id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12030v1 | SPA-VL: A Comprehensive Safety Preference Alignment Dataset for Vision Language Model | 2024-06-17T18:57:37 | 2024-06-17T18:57:37 | Yongting Zhang, Lu Chen, Guodong Zheng, Yifeng Gao, Rui Zheng, Jinlan Fu, Zhenfei Yin, Senjie Jin, Yu Qiao, Xuanjing Huang, Feng Zhao, Tao Gui, Jing Shao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The emergence of Vision Language Models (VLMs) has brought unprecedented
advances in understanding multimodal information. The combination of textual
and visual semantics in VLMs is highly complex and diverse, making the safety
alignment of these models challenging. Furthermore, due to the limited study on
the safety alignment of VLMs, there is a lack of large-scale, high-quality
datasets. To address these limitations, we propose a Safety Preference
Alignment dataset for Vision Language Models named SPA-VL. In terms of breadth,
SPA-VL covers 6 harmfulness domains, 13 categories, and 53 subcategories, and
contains 100,788 samples of the quadruple (question, image, chosen response,
rejected response). In terms of depth, the responses are collected from 12
open- (e.g., QwenVL) and closed-source (e.g., Gemini) VLMs to ensure diversity.
The experimental results indicate that models trained with alignment techniques
on the SPA-VL dataset exhibit substantial improvements in harmlessness and
helpfulness while maintaining core capabilities. SPA-VL, as a large-scale,
high-quality, and diverse dataset, represents a significant milestone in
ensuring that VLMs achieve both harmlessness and helpfulness. We have made our
code https://github.com/EchoseChen/SPA-VL-RLHF and SPA-VL dataset url
https://huggingface.co/datasets/sqrti/SPA-VL publicly available. | [
0.0324646011,
0.0545562841,
-0.0001010124,
0.040948078,
-0.0342247933,
0.0334776975,
-0.0204135887,
-0.0143269617,
0.0095598316,
-0.0275699608,
-0.0366508104,
-0.0364633128,
-0.0055596884,
0.0467267819,
0.0088441027,
-0.0612788312,
0.0575319491,
-0.0201906767,
0.0109545449,
0.0132974219,
0.0703387409,
0.0086844135,
0.0127388341,
0.0414987504,
-0.0238612667,
-0.0406002961,
0.0262991432,
0.0390826724,
0.0562885478,
-0.0464032367,
0.017952621,
0.0497729369,
0.025733836,
0.0113938944,
0.0000019611,
-0.045487836,
0.0013421648,
0.0007961902,
0.0236443263,
-0.0409559086,
0.0595095158,
-0.0455310084,
0.006825041,
0.0137820486,
-0.0289663747,
-0.0263617337,
0.1085373834,
0.0583597384,
0.053065598,
0.040757589,
-0.0109898765,
0.0133926105,
0.0323089845,
0.0145713091,
0.0011067984,
-0.0148919383,
0.060287945,
-0.0074297092,
-0.048846852,
0.0192897208,
-0.0314584002,
0.0332436077,
-0.0105333123,
0.0059345821,
-0.0107402643,
-0.0076659936,
-0.0259606484,
-0.0751482919,
-0.0093962578,
0.1030359939,
-0.0304482747,
-0.0082846619,
-0.0269111171,
-0.0112429261,
-0.0000535735,
0.0158410873,
-0.0162481014,
0.0190260839,
-0.0024969499,
0.0077398065,
-0.0396338701,
0.0205861609,
0.0232466832,
0.0019519911,
0.063362442,
0.0311772041,
0.0210036989,
0.0088439686,
0.0190756619,
-0.0257446114,
-0.0150033878,
-0.0291029252,
-0.0279178731,
-0.0440847762,
-0.0090562776,
0.019700408,
-0.0775707141,
-0.0063828612,
0.049445577,
-0.0636202246,
0.0617271364,
0.0014253135,
-0.0528384298,
0.0294037033,
0.0187132824,
0.0321733244,
-0.023678638,
0.0659837872,
-0.0411079749,
0.0097334767,
0.023961829,
0.0050978372,
0.0144600943,
-0.0180984791,
-0.0244844016,
0.0121633373,
-0.0677945614,
0.0136353988,
-0.0537201054,
0.0186186302,
-0.006259684,
0.0182434339,
-0.0247548111,
-0.0041118241,
-0.0404527672,
0.0266458653,
0.0308238249,
0.0191152748,
-0.0106464708,
-0.049695868,
0.022423422,
0.029839687,
0.0009301231,
-0.0530201681,
-0.017629467,
0.1054833382,
0.0199023653,
-0.011487917,
-0.0407989211,
-0.0261195544,
-0.0495792478,
-0.0139371622,
0.0152490148,
-0.0584671795,
0.02274861,
-0.0255659558,
-0.0064236387,
-0.0508853644,
0.0163191892,
0.0258011855,
-0.0429562591,
0.0863114595,
-0.047812283,
-0.0308500212,
-0.0401825607,
0.019534139,
0.0087110689,
0.0657225475,
0.0131842932,
0.0352760553,
0.0583173893,
-0.0280533116,
-0.0082207592,
0.0338041373,
-0.0026604601,
0.021384066,
-0.0861550942,
0.0289455932,
0.0195855126,
-0.0070521217,
-0.0032175686,
0.0520465374,
-0.0056082606,
-0.0915473476,
0.0957937911,
0.009700086,
-0.0091852201,
-0.0135696447,
-0.0116281351,
-0.0010512029,
-0.0157381985,
-0.0050272285,
-0.0711255148,
0.0277996901,
-0.0567999855,
-0.003680568,
-0.0318675078,
0.0470009036,
-0.031317424,
-0.0174332932,
-0.041460447,
-0.0270274412,
0.045306731,
0.0032820145,
0.0061886925,
-0.0101480046,
-0.0328025296,
-0.0242879875,
0.036229074,
-0.0312549993,
-0.0199105348,
-0.015863819,
0.0269437656,
0.0530298911,
0.036361061,
-0.0099486122,
-0.0689249411,
-0.0456047915,
0.007184749,
0.0038794507,
0.0055288007,
-0.0009710742,
0.0398856811,
-0.0600413457,
-0.076112479,
0.0193532892,
-0.0224296376,
-0.0177482236,
0.0219886173,
-0.0170778707,
-0.0234324615,
0.00179773,
-0.0283428673,
0.0364026986,
0.0377249829,
-0.0020810738,
-0.0331603922,
0.0222854987,
0.0466659814,
-0.0309040863,
-0.0153373908,
-0.0195561182,
0.0324616507,
0.0012576623,
0.0233544167,
-0.0003475156,
-0.0411848165,
-0.0006755079,
0.054486908,
-0.070288159,
-0.0359964035,
0.0791299045,
-0.0484813377,
0.0122913718,
-0.0295178089,
-0.0279140044,
-0.0369327962,
-0.0114777749,
0.0027717929,
0.0000281954,
-0.0014441955,
-0.0437174365,
0.0536935255,
-0.0342714414,
-0.0147099867,
-0.0283306446,
-0.0439116359,
0.0108303633,
-0.0185324363,
-0.0465237759,
-0.0127138942,
-0.0367041565,
0.0542401671,
0.0184050519,
0.006321969,
-0.0470889807,
0.034750253,
-0.0441918783,
-0.022843333,
-0.0115306573,
-0.0194285382,
0.0034340939,
-0.0174769722,
-0.0056869565,
-0.0244814474,
-0.0193464756,
0.0597906001,
-0.0112052094,
0.0393960774,
0.0233827829,
-0.0184364356,
-0.0044440497,
-0.0325262547,
-0.0259717368,
-0.0216554627,
0.0485900417,
-0.0104004154,
-0.0327438377,
-0.006846719,
0.033529833,
-0.0507176481,
0.0470542647,
-0.009985392,
-0.0503000319,
-0.0120260976,
0.0226516593,
-0.0043505277,
0.0528230965,
0.0316264331,
0.0130468737,
0.0470921025,
0.0299340561,
-0.0458984338,
-0.0102403788,
-0.0384845585,
-0.0338751264,
-0.0055457167,
-0.0390194505,
-0.0178468935,
0.0449837632,
0.0016373327,
-0.0086590312,
-0.0500458255,
0.0305768866,
0.0067566228,
-0.0551417284,
-0.0293550212,
-0.0264435932,
-0.0095208641,
0.0395757183,
-0.0347474813,
-0.0893841386,
0.0567672141,
0.0165644959,
0.0310012903,
-0.003233755,
-0.0067854393,
0.0114731472,
0.0455388911,
0.0286154728,
0.0492742807,
0.034766268,
0.0187442712,
-0.0696840063,
-0.0371355116,
0.0254144222,
-0.0143387206,
0.0791099221,
-0.0514848121,
-0.0108133284,
-0.0199815314,
-0.0504956543,
-0.0557963587,
-0.046271611,
0.0087666456,
-0.0251535624,
-0.0584267899,
0.0097500086,
-0.0433805995,
0.0075553218,
0.0144668808,
-0.014777787,
-0.0078592431,
0.0067394776,
-0.0032307783,
0.0040145656,
0.1122570112,
-0.0213097222,
0.0169746503,
-0.0035998293,
-0.0091078458,
0.0971907899,
0.0028234655,
0.0194495488,
-0.039587114,
0.0252568275,
0.0418842323,
0.0464364104,
-0.0043682712,
0.0395341814,
0.0453635044,
-0.0118453177,
0.030303169,
0.0359541513,
-0.006563263,
-0.045981016,
0.0017307621,
0.0029876649,
0.0169916451,
0.0237470847,
-0.0346962363,
-0.0545067154,
-0.0303861666,
-0.0243460741,
0.0032137011,
-0.0138042774,
-0.0140759218,
0.0184343457,
-0.0500065945,
0.0496234335,
0.0264000874,
-0.0367814116,
-0.0517615005,
0.0234308839,
0.0150214955,
-0.0459282957,
0.026563393,
-0.0077574071,
-0.0226734169,
-0.0305065941,
0.0011612228,
0.0115919644,
-0.0451302491,
0.0300736018,
-0.0409530662,
0.0252478272,
0.0680038854,
0.0025410464,
-0.0153940041,
-0.0599280447,
0.013432093,
-0.0039802482,
-0.0311055426,
0.0022632605,
0.0717966706,
-0.0412727483,
-0.0118931858,
-0.0292700101,
0.0417953841,
-0.0067319022,
-0.0313478969,
-0.0177863799,
0.0453024954,
0.0010879795,
-0.0020671585,
-0.0896823257,
0.0326770246,
-0.0043093991,
0.0397558026,
-0.0083675981,
-0.0471795462,
0.0139865102,
-0.0206872057,
0.0015118191,
-0.0033376475,
-0.0331640765,
0.0383172855,
0.0040171868,
-0.0466697626,
-0.0773442313,
-0.0127436891,
-0.0024669874,
0.0219552815,
0.0072603086,
-0.0359977111,
-0.0119314361,
0.0130752409,
-0.0854090229,
0.0893019736,
0.0161224734,
0.0134368809,
-0.0367084965,
0.0515034422,
-0.0141478805,
-0.0149082309,
-0.0202751886,
0.0208058096,
-0.0538567752,
-0.0439908952,
0.0092487019,
0.0944836959,
0.0159560088,
0.0140040806,
0.0197839867,
-0.0355897471,
0.0478329994,
0.0618588999,
0.0061648116,
-0.0187289678,
0.0136622516,
-0.0404973663,
0.0077250507,
0.0151149137,
-0.0343383215,
-0.0248201117,
0.057277713,
-0.0010008262,
-0.0262885224,
-0.0206909943,
0.0342161246,
0.0106451372,
0.0756633207,
-0.0096186558,
0.0101232994,
-0.015319691,
0.0039518145,
0.0035553179,
-0.0318433233,
-0.0370341204,
0.0121705392,
0.045453161,
-0.0079496214,
-0.0151567934,
-0.0147480071,
-0.0344035253,
0.0194072071,
-0.026333496,
0.0140538141,
0.0370271988,
0.0016071682,
0.0180409215,
0.035171628,
-0.0413623676,
0.0112057282,
-0.0280570704,
0.0150932018,
0.0173410121,
0.0540215485,
-0.0003287536,
0.0230882503,
-0.0015580959,
0.0660592541,
0.0084270947,
-0.0240520705,
-0.0582522303,
-0.0132383863,
0.0059716627,
-0.0152485808,
0.037134897,
-0.0042744861,
-0.0160634741,
-0.0660687983,
0.0485220477,
-0.0234597176,
-0.0428809486,
0.0959621221,
0.025432786,
-0.0207804013,
-0.0330647379,
0.0725654513,
0.014343081,
0.0112869553,
0.0049797199,
-0.0212199073,
-0.0291498974,
-0.0198387578,
0.0810077116,
0.017378388,
-0.0354317538,
-0.004194513,
-0.0543460213,
-0.0802877173,
0.0116796466,
0.0194542725,
0.0131785702,
0.0182550997,
0.0456385277,
0.0357452594,
0.0203725211,
-0.038185399,
-0.0033036883,
-0.0410405509,
-0.001813931,
-0.0019185385,
-0.0277924743,
-5.740672864e-33,
0.003587675,
-0.0051579778,
0.0071738479,
-0.0188368019,
-0.0002152115,
0.002234441,
0.0503876172,
0.0120460391,
-0.0311465207,
0.0123095335,
0.0519486256,
-0.0090725617,
-0.0041964389,
0.0257257707,
-0.0071824007,
-0.0441176072,
-0.0201084092,
-0.0158869494,
-0.0254946612,
-0.0099557005,
0.0223661698,
0.0000648507,
0.0542791001,
-0.1114524901,
0.0064957356,
0.045806624,
-0.0268454105,
-0.0077270237,
-0.0280808304,
0.1189907566,
0.0041042636,
0.0613009855,
0.0184181537,
0.0241125487,
-0.0134161906,
0.0369948484,
-0.0099210469,
0.0009317123,
0.0455716401,
0.0205857921,
-0.0893103406,
-0.0152802272,
0.0443851389,
-0.0298249833,
-0.015364253,
-0.0574314557,
0.0393613763,
-0.0312048402,
-0.025548121,
0.0067197909,
-0.0424750261,
0.0044650864,
0.0109853521,
-0.0315074027,
0.0191380084,
0.0841216892,
0.0295534506,
0.0490914211,
-0.039334394,
0.0291197728,
-0.0294906627,
-0.0138247935,
0.0865368471,
0.0188102145,
0.0057724337,
0.0829192325,
0.0044957534,
-0.0389507301,
0.020408364,
-0.0298940502,
0.0052584345,
0.0872139335,
0.0345099978,
0.0807289109,
-0.0043378803,
0.0071005612,
-0.0669593513,
0.028414771,
-0.0694767013,
0.070538938,
0.0235147364,
0.0102174468,
-0.0350378193,
0.0072370823,
-0.0329387821,
0.0089717889,
-0.0508793183,
-0.0130613809,
0.0690662637,
-0.0020852995,
-0.0131332148,
0.0282360073,
0.0154187744,
-0.0370940343,
0.0055927834,
0.0114466297,
0.0032663515,
0.0202094335,
0.0122128334,
0.0370807499,
-0.0343954712,
0.0119531313,
0.0292355102,
-0.0576951802,
0.0156128807,
0.0191808455,
0.0812940598,
0.0198971163,
-0.0556205809,
0.0040011969,
-0.0271058548,
0.0109526841,
0.0078243613,
0.0448952243,
0.0540895984,
0.0048400401,
-0.0169502981,
0.0284968093,
0.0353219062,
-0.0155725433,
-0.0507278703,
-0.0390851051,
-0.0272809397,
0.0304259509,
0.024137374,
-0.0218042843,
-0.0379943736,
-0.0436354838,
0.014455745,
-0.0411753282,
0.0137163717,
0.0073960843,
2.54e-7,
0.0329765789,
0.0336542949,
0.0216110405,
0.0366320685,
-0.0044152606,
0.0852034464,
-0.0094185462,
0.0735034272,
0.0154353455,
-0.0134044876,
0.0091177858,
-0.0083871922,
0.0393362641,
0.0180903673,
0.0164920669,
0.0273050163,
-0.0233000163,
-0.0083014918,
-0.0263876077,
0.017958669,
0.0802025497,
0.094625935,
-0.0024338241,
-0.024313312,
0.0407925136,
-0.0271670688,
0.0560356304,
-0.079116039,
-0.0126784369,
-0.022424832,
-0.006818431,
0.014045937,
0.0003583993,
0.0405823812,
-0.0007544301,
-0.0456412174,
0.0000433412,
0.0645853058,
-0.0414800942,
-0.0555717833,
-0.0121615157,
0.0147271734,
-0.0329127684,
-0.0709581897,
0.0518042333,
-0.0368621014,
-0.027253516,
-0.0027841276,
-0.0317075737,
0.0192466639,
0.0441184938,
-0.0294092074,
-0.0284870937,
-0.0151554029,
0.0494562723,
0.0013912596,
-0.049245514,
-0.0581182055,
-0.010945145,
0.0008790042,
-0.0161089059,
-0.0534601174,
-0.0299833696,
0.043457672,
-0.0017348415,
-0.0527750738,
-0.0326595157,
2.405685005e-34,
0.0156108364,
-0.0272631459,
0.0200551096,
-0.0392395258,
0.0072838166,
-0.0086624017,
-0.0154500259,
0.0280367155,
-0.0204461869,
-0.0244815126,
-0.0028472838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12023v1 | LiLiuM: eBay's Large Language Models for e-commerce | 2024-06-17T18:45:41 | 2024-06-17T18:45:41 | Christian Herold, Michael Kozielski, Leonid Ekimov, Pavel Petrushkov, Pierre-Yves Vandenbussche, Shahram Khadivi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce the LiLiuM series of large language models (LLMs): 1B, 7B, and
13B parameter models developed 100% in-house to fit eBay's specific needs in
the e-commerce domain. This gives eBay full control over all aspects of the
models including license, data, vocabulary, and architecture. We expect these
models to be used as a foundation for fine-tuning and instruction-tuning,
eliminating dependencies to external models.
The LiLiuM LLMs have been trained on 3 trillion tokens of multilingual text
from general and e-commerce domain. They perform similar to the popular LLaMA-2
models on English natural language understanding (NLU) benchmarks. At the same
time, we outperform LLaMA-2 on non-English NLU tasks, machine translation and
on e-commerce specific downstream tasks.
As part of our data mixture, we utilize the newly released RedPajama-V2
dataset for training and share our insights regarding data filtering and
deduplication. We also discuss in detail how to serialize structured data for
use in autoregressive language modeling. We provide insights on the effects of
including code and parallel machine translation data in pre-training.
Furthermore, we develop our own tokenizer and model vocabulary, customized
towards e-commerce. This way, we can achieve up to 34% speed-up in text
generation on eBay-specific downstream tasks compared to LLaMA-2.
Finally, in relation to LLM pretraining, we show that checkpoint averaging
can further improve over the best individual model checkpoint. | [
0.060521733,
0.0644943491,
-0.0278745461,
0.0283637717,
-0.0142300529,
0.040712703,
0.0529629178,
-0.0062520946,
-0.0164934434,
-0.0847624168,
-0.0402476899,
-0.072153762,
-0.0040880255,
0.0643614158,
0.0115665514,
-0.0136558106,
0.0263314489,
-0.0346331112,
0.0013658975,
-0.0106791053,
0.0303278379,
0.0422534347,
0.0032612246,
0.0254069474,
0.0273420699,
-0.0211819746,
-0.0082436549,
0.0005538883,
-0.0117096193,
-0.0227143001,
0.0538920574,
0.0347497277,
0.0308565367,
0.0315603428,
0.0000021143,
-0.0609886348,
-0.0416177213,
-0.0329624787,
-0.0426307097,
0.0590373427,
0.0571679398,
-0.0110119255,
0.0227197874,
0.0404651687,
-0.0349004194,
-0.0092160357,
0.0540411696,
0.0636230484,
0.0387824029,
0.063454926,
-0.0175017584,
-0.0270482395,
0.0121479603,
-0.0525411293,
-0.0309646856,
-0.0404160917,
0.026640512,
0.0181786083,
-0.0025838413,
0.0059134765,
0.0005994302,
0.0107141891,
0.0052201743,
0.005783116,
-0.0176810659,
0.041223567,
0.0052471496,
-0.0224107932,
-0.0222069379,
0.0759298503,
-0.0148770362,
-0.020608196,
0.0295031108,
0.017917987,
-0.0356941745,
-0.0536030009,
-0.0302202459,
0.0626368895,
0.0286328625,
0.016865341,
0.0288089011,
-0.0202850867,
0.0424028262,
0.0431670435,
-0.0328088477,
0.018089937,
0.0328392498,
0.0008522099,
-0.0363056771,
-0.0162718855,
-0.0285588782,
-0.0581710897,
0.0319895968,
0.0306714289,
-0.051502075,
0.015418103,
-0.0405152254,
0.0158515647,
0.0017877901,
-0.060987819,
0.016437741,
0.0412188284,
-0.0046774452,
0.0388181657,
-0.0251968522,
0.048299063,
-0.0154514611,
-0.0087673236,
-0.0641278401,
0.0167389419,
-0.0137283243,
-0.0264433157,
-0.0494701117,
0.0398380235,
-0.0421722345,
-0.044658307,
-0.0438122079,
0.002599369,
0.0166013259,
-0.0191895161,
0.0201850533,
-0.0131843481,
-0.0387053937,
-0.0290510859,
-0.0023219448,
0.0112958075,
-0.0302333124,
0.0193250682,
0.0151750054,
-0.0613532774,
0.0185873322,
0.0187452398,
-0.0145342592,
-0.0295740683,
0.0138137322,
0.050575912,
-0.0048614168,
-0.0141856018,
-0.0893423334,
-0.0389709845,
-0.0099398643,
-0.0648007914,
-0.0135911312,
-0.0642711371,
0.055452548,
0.0200450066,
-0.0009291281,
-0.0182432421,
0.0150024248,
0.0108134672,
-0.0101188533,
0.06580396,
-0.0175073408,
-0.0150339212,
0.0179096479,
-0.0255686957,
0.0541152619,
0.0632801354,
0.0202567317,
0.0340312943,
0.0420651212,
-0.0029639415,
0.0015457427,
0.0598990656,
-0.0259880591,
-0.0198313817,
-0.0328483917,
0.0173308551,
0.0063801473,
0.0095232138,
0.0703910962,
0.0508994125,
-0.0384921283,
0.0279918052,
0.0739230737,
0.0114265904,
-0.0064900774,
0.0412045345,
0.0685074702,
0.0147503735,
-0.005158891,
-0.0343440473,
0.0026639833,
-0.0088530108,
0.0197868627,
0.0048789415,
0.0177928228,
0.0212474838,
-0.0371161029,
-0.0362268314,
0.0021001957,
-0.0337448418,
0.0037770821,
0.0072384868,
0.0292051602,
0.0046909959,
-0.0499525741,
0.0787863284,
0.0125112236,
-0.0363964178,
0.016111305,
-0.0314284302,
0.0229686946,
0.1204789802,
0.0467474759,
0.0192160681,
-0.0344992243,
-0.0498768315,
-0.001010516,
0.0665469766,
0.0513397455,
-0.0285022762,
-0.0000044285,
-0.0936354622,
-0.0149485497,
-0.0319908746,
-0.0009446314,
0.0426305942,
0.00705462,
-0.014256509,
0.0505447909,
-0.0154073592,
-0.0104056196,
0.031319689,
-0.0490777977,
-0.0357457735,
-0.0030770497,
-0.005496067,
0.0198644008,
-0.0030428413,
-0.0201029144,
0.0001564719,
0.0255732313,
-0.0333604626,
-0.0307280309,
0.0299848504,
-0.0007001426,
-0.0165100321,
0.0686684772,
0.0050519537,
0.0224951468,
0.0239395108,
-0.035183616,
-0.0565740317,
-0.0014332631,
-0.0389475003,
0.0493452214,
-0.0446497686,
0.0314754955,
0.0039170156,
0.0466132276,
-0.0149896238,
0.0356876031,
0.0240134355,
0.0177995469,
0.0173030421,
-0.0227256231,
0.0259738248,
-0.0268920399,
-0.0323990807,
0.0210593659,
-0.027111372,
0.034872476,
0.0344884768,
0.0287623052,
-0.0310308971,
-0.0090294098,
-0.0869823694,
0.0207879413,
-0.0191452,
0.037501689,
0.0240139943,
0.0100050494,
-0.0082695764,
0.0019135037,
-0.0198717322,
-0.0001433505,
-0.0018309815,
0.0240622479,
0.0406688936,
-0.0108826989,
-0.0504304208,
-0.0177706648,
-0.0113159548,
0.0104102669,
0.0369612537,
0.007619652,
-0.0428177789,
-0.0573655367,
0.0197680332,
-0.0357518271,
-0.0007385583,
-0.0000579349,
-0.0375542082,
-0.0382057577,
-0.0205187052,
0.0755411237,
0.0148509983,
0.0127229551,
-0.0266749505,
0.0045233876,
-0.0520409681,
-0.0449186526,
-0.0023199397,
0.0007349219,
-0.027194405,
-0.01223116,
-0.02865302,
0.0095447777,
0.0796904415,
-0.0252385736,
-0.0269006416,
-0.0411890633,
-0.0260178,
-0.0221112669,
-0.0142528946,
-0.0285994578,
0.0143197021,
-0.0317928046,
0.028070448,
-0.0324975736,
-0.05821665,
0.0154180136,
-0.0310103465,
0.0018459955,
-0.0505906232,
0.0054995143,
-0.041362904,
0.0031725478,
-0.0051541636,
0.0387706645,
-0.0347788185,
-0.0522671677,
-0.0164343566,
0.068989642,
-0.0019796116,
-0.0263707787,
0.0461446978,
-0.0400254689,
0.037364848,
-0.0247254185,
-0.0320111029,
-0.048278641,
-0.0213951673,
-0.0299175102,
0.0055052522,
0.0636859164,
0.0082504777,
-0.0579774119,
0.0300661959,
0.0092223193,
0.0459421985,
-0.0060946811,
-0.0124688158,
-0.0131146945,
0.0145582398,
0.0513661504,
-0.0015518893,
0.015794158,
-0.0612304062,
-0.0008080541,
0.0002786396,
0.011845015,
-0.0345612355,
-0.0264784973,
0.0033247012,
0.0471412204,
-0.05813054,
-0.0183279589,
0.0468412302,
-0.0069203628,
-0.043898955,
-0.0233743396,
0.1109330803,
0.0153587237,
-0.0220165327,
0.0038705873,
0.0132193258,
0.0168515462,
0.0322056301,
0.0299854018,
-0.0640268996,
-0.0208270457,
0.0017633978,
-0.0010766165,
0.0452325679,
-0.0003161478,
-0.0393104069,
-0.1191670895,
0.0105047654,
-0.0039767027,
-0.0354397967,
-0.0170450192,
-0.0116352886,
-0.0471376143,
-0.0108304061,
0.0796755776,
0.0351751894,
-0.0279970299,
0.0084434832,
0.0418096855,
0.0036382151,
-0.0497625433,
0.004257136,
-0.0423844941,
0.0584335886,
0.0290731359,
0.0238032956,
-0.0107769109,
0.011348391,
0.0298502874,
-0.0380292907,
-0.0198024362,
-0.0035074938,
0.0369769372,
0.0167239979,
-0.0202625133,
0.0205396675,
0.0062777582,
-0.0554064065,
0.0007454842,
0.0098532764,
0.0219700392,
0.0148798171,
-0.0068723327,
0.0282338597,
-0.0128580984,
-0.0468322523,
0.0679174662,
0.0000828279,
-0.0612902306,
-0.0471650697,
-0.0351215228,
-0.0278159473,
-0.072287336,
0.0179637428,
0.0145427911,
-0.0143721392,
-0.0249179322,
-0.1017066389,
-0.0479526334,
0.0040175202,
0.0541720837,
0.0445124991,
0.0303650368,
-0.0127317673,
-0.0119836936,
-0.0479748063,
0.0083093951,
-0.0648592785,
0.0293828398,
-0.0753578469,
0.0501166992,
0.0143194459,
-0.0716089383,
-0.030495137,
0.0345848985,
-0.087258637,
-0.0776416436,
0.0105863418,
0.0498658307,
0.0201399159,
0.0306501687,
-0.0021933927,
-0.0607157238,
0.0125310337,
0.0241661426,
-0.0365739912,
-0.0092825796,
0.0218977313,
0.0535248183,
-0.0212624539,
0.0416674986,
-0.0458771475,
0.0148173766,
0.0000682724,
0.0716061518,
0.0281794965,
-0.0077360156,
0.0315623246,
0.0395434238,
-0.0203391463,
-0.0399267115,
0.0058488962,
-0.0504136086,
0.0516194925,
0.0092751458,
-0.0167200137,
-0.0499426648,
0.0065028602,
0.0407274552,
-0.0036939336,
-0.0052351654,
0.0367134213,
0.0074712057,
-0.0123725124,
0.0197971743,
-0.0075720595,
-0.0525983572,
0.0274949148,
0.0229060818,
-0.0242647398,
0.0008181615,
0.0202872436,
0.0153203271,
0.0157625638,
-0.0448624976,
0.0616289601,
0.0101171331,
-0.0031062311,
-0.0379096456,
0.039209947,
0.0082563823,
-0.0256691631,
-0.0311767627,
0.0119347181,
0.0753623843,
-0.0169913732,
0.0812018663,
-0.0386034362,
-0.0159681104,
-0.0270655565,
0.0507087782,
-0.004771594,
-0.0150332572,
0.0294614527,
0.0038614299,
-0.0554481782,
0.0165010188,
0.1095757931,
0.0024974882,
0.0401653722,
0.0009646812,
0.0009604621,
-0.0561588965,
-0.0117523381,
0.0230586212,
-0.0145311225,
-0.0435052551,
-0.0271492247,
0.0026145822,
-0.0399941243,
-0.0141714327,
-0.0014321391,
0.0097892862,
-0.0101976898,
0.0437183529,
0.0889214352,
0.0102300281,
0.0284613241,
-0.0445615463,
0.0157872308,
-0.0109944399,
-0.0001368698,
-0.0337331817,
-6.938333365e-33,
0.0116543667,
-0.0203531086,
0.034733437,
0.0008309731,
-0.0197412279,
0.0322933532,
-0.0309799667,
-0.0195157174,
0.0321535245,
-0.0013857748,
0.0048828772,
0.0069248718,
0.0281996131,
0.0268602557,
0.0131457997,
-0.0119683146,
0.0620785169,
0.0248589534,
-0.0156206265,
0.0500369594,
0.0191276167,
0.0699569955,
0.0739656463,
-0.0024886839,
0.0079832906,
-0.0325463712,
-0.025714105,
0.0253392141,
0.0251339767,
0.0728144646,
-0.0523000695,
0.0253826398,
0.0244394392,
-0.051091779,
-0.0297935791,
-0.0180385876,
-0.0743724778,
0.0233890396,
0.0369914845,
0.0378002338,
0.0042915177,
-0.0388414264,
0.0432494171,
-0.0343643613,
0.0109801395,
0.0426969528,
0.0176106691,
-0.0394467264,
-0.0234246664,
-0.0578756444,
-0.0787020698,
0.009668869,
-0.0207013432,
-0.0016393153,
0.0578348637,
0.0803131685,
-0.030205112,
0.0180918053,
-0.0333414972,
0.037361607,
-0.0037721407,
0.0279141366,
0.0762641355,
0.0138262678,
0.0003337424,
0.0330336429,
0.0001103642,
-0.0058539817,
0.032808125,
0.0132653778,
0.019215839,
0.0468816534,
0.013845792,
0.0350346826,
0.0236671939,
0.0160098337,
-0.0571864694,
0.035439238,
0.0233951043,
0.0206769072,
0.0215330366,
-0.001511754,
-0.0244573392,
-0.0276592094,
-0.021879863,
-0.0059146751,
-0.0373524949,
-0.0247690752,
0.0551236086,
0.0306071155,
-0.0419006124,
-0.0205802638,
0.0489566624,
-0.0433370396,
-0.0945315063,
0.005302168,
-0.0079976842,
-0.0038333538,
0.0074969768,
0.0239727274,
-0.0523770601,
-0.0775241852,
0.0057713976,
-0.0346187204,
-0.0158369504,
-0.0074408166,
0.031885609,
0.0237399545,
-0.0790354908,
0.0332204923,
-0.0173593964,
0.0193654168,
0.0042400039,
0.0396441221,
0.0404477976,
-0.0121508231,
-0.0092241727,
0.0406292006,
0.0331795774,
-0.024170123,
-0.0191304181,
-0.0080109127,
0.0161577091,
0.0576366819,
-0.0281455163,
0.0100931199,
-0.0360963233,
0.0453919135,
0.0254343487,
-0.0762574598,
-0.0407178365,
0.0198865067,
2.915e-7,
0.0403668694,
0.076025106,
-0.0022301641,
0.0246851724,
0.0050723031,
0.0332465321,
-0.0208057873,
0.0378195643,
-0.0105736265,
0.0257998742,
0.0111671444,
0.0162853729,
0.0659037754,
0.0000037298,
-0.0654714778,
-0.0137616359,
-0.0426485837,
0.0250904225,
-0.065625906,
-0.0214171875,
0.0122797396,
0.1147834882,
-0.0086527653,
-0.0282225106,
0.0053017451,
-0.0563275181,
0.0603337474,
-0.040251229,
-0.0009991444,
0.0404218696,
0.0150593976,
0.0613348782,
-0.0469815135,
-0.0106682787,
-0.0298009105,
0.0303762108,
0.0182107612,
0.0766823962,
0.0320856385,
0.0270110741,
0.0230396893,
-0.0377049334,
-0.018572107,
-0.0812918693,
0.0516594797,
-0.0480405204,
-0.02066979,
-0.0385978073,
-0.005657325,
-0.0248904433,
-0.0069457041,
-0.0473965704,
-0.0086632622,
0.0345659778,
0.0128896143,
-0.0321525745,
-0.0337955169,
-0.0317556113,
-0.0120421071,
-0.0190980751,
-0.043469537,
0.0076171602,
-0.0327152722,
0.017610712,
0.0116039813,
-0.0272014141,
0.0452891216,
2.770319449e-34,
0.0529687628,
-0.0397007093,
0.0025128454,
0.0412064418,
0.033647608,
-0.0309132542,
-0.0162565261,
0.0034164756,
-0.0166854393,
-0.0821279883,
-0.0200017393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12018v1 | CItruS: Chunked Instruction-aware State Eviction for Long Sequence Modeling | 2024-06-17T18:34:58 | 2024-06-17T18:34:58 | Yu Bai, Xiyuan Zou, Heyan Huang, Sanxing Chen, Marc-Antoine Rondeau, Yang Gao, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long sequence modeling has gained broad interest as large language models
(LLMs) continue to advance. Recent research has identified that a large portion
of hidden states within the key-value caches of Transformer models can be
discarded (also termed evicted) without affecting the perplexity performance in
generating long sequences. However, we show that these methods, despite
preserving perplexity performance, often drop information that is important for
solving downstream tasks, a problem which we call information neglect. To
address this issue, we introduce Chunked Instruction-aware State Eviction
(CItruS), a novel modeling technique that integrates the attention preferences
useful for a downstream task into the eviction process of hidden states. In
addition, we design a method for chunked sequence processing to further improve
efficiency. Our training-free method exhibits superior performance on long
sequence comprehension and retrieval tasks over several strong baselines under
the same memory budget, while preserving language modeling perplexity. | [
0.0250963885,
0.0580831654,
-0.0153487744,
0.0225389004,
-0.0379401818,
0.0127690462,
-0.0010440742,
-0.010021246,
-0.0040280852,
-0.0370953083,
-0.0133904042,
-0.0612177029,
0.007025985,
-0.005233096,
-0.0094076758,
-0.0424121171,
0.0633593723,
-0.027950896,
-0.0216453765,
0.0157110244,
-0.0321264006,
-0.0210839324,
0.0218624771,
0.0291857943,
0.0436887145,
-0.0271089263,
-0.0582920164,
-0.0278804749,
-0.0023971389,
-0.0438862666,
-0.0152005926,
0.0561240949,
-0.0098233726,
0.010069225,
0.0000021176,
-0.0028815658,
-0.0013794341,
-0.0012537648,
-0.0247641206,
0.0504137352,
0.0018937351,
0.0280397516,
-0.0101837544,
0.0076712985,
-0.0240541082,
-0.0106782345,
0.0490800925,
0.0184769146,
0.0705827251,
0.0493561327,
0.0056016729,
-0.015209402,
0.0205736458,
-0.0457010381,
0.0575630292,
-0.0247291643,
0.0316313691,
-0.037895795,
0.0086630415,
-0.0071468875,
-0.0521497168,
0.0470749773,
0.0507621355,
0.0298063792,
-0.0183356851,
0.0358584151,
0.0101171453,
-0.0202365853,
-0.0226237085,
0.0255301148,
-0.0508827381,
0.0002723009,
0.0323495045,
0.0033606736,
0.0059217145,
-0.0212806277,
-0.0380735435,
0.0238208957,
-0.0140381688,
0.0094078071,
0.0115709994,
-0.0223127324,
0.0244356617,
-0.0230112467,
-0.0559512898,
0.0282764249,
0.0371502377,
-0.0405516922,
-0.0751320794,
-0.0442950241,
-0.0186485462,
-0.0788159147,
0.0276008993,
0.0674934685,
0.0012283748,
0.0153668774,
-0.0301893223,
-0.0424720347,
0.0109368032,
-0.017899327,
0.0248373542,
0.0665647686,
-0.0184305944,
0.0383351818,
-0.0301501658,
0.0541894287,
-0.0230741668,
-0.0103211598,
-0.0304108299,
0.0447504036,
-0.0400584303,
-0.008457982,
-0.0146426018,
0.0455049165,
-0.03836729,
-0.0227527339,
-0.0091138734,
0.0125140296,
0.0115860868,
-0.0267202426,
0.0140827885,
0.0385205671,
-0.0331857577,
0.0127187166,
-0.0294325128,
0.0552731864,
0.0017340005,
-0.0370438956,
0.0370373353,
-0.0360424072,
-0.059615545,
0.0042173006,
-0.0025139889,
-0.0375200473,
-0.0153948348,
0.0490443781,
-0.0055294349,
-0.0568134151,
-0.0278119333,
-0.0069503179,
0.00179043,
-0.0585311763,
0.0518533699,
-0.0378139131,
0.0195971504,
-0.0118355379,
-0.0089366622,
-0.0370828137,
0.0301755108,
0.0749378055,
-0.0105743231,
0.036385797,
0.0056604319,
-0.0302018803,
-0.0215855055,
0.0364887267,
0.0418047868,
0.0271318592,
0.0182829164,
0.0383040681,
-0.0109196827,
-0.0321546048,
0.0182081182,
0.0207302179,
0.0226534605,
-0.0145403715,
-0.0103193782,
0.0059613003,
0.00653286,
-0.0122146448,
0.0313215293,
0.0655385479,
-0.0181906894,
-0.0178582817,
0.0254260357,
0.0405276343,
-0.0001285594,
0.0282808449,
0.0186339039,
0.0112074399,
-0.0439959131,
0.0383955799,
-0.0391981564,
0.0614559427,
0.0102164811,
0.040147692,
0.0562076867,
0.0518036969,
-0.0264775343,
-0.0297238193,
-0.0074076974,
-0.0149821928,
0.0286208,
0.0277944691,
0.0367692634,
0.0169511084,
-0.0804821104,
0.0944750383,
0.0049971784,
-0.0583338626,
-0.0168554373,
-0.0658088475,
-0.0004894187,
0.0796496868,
0.0498436242,
-0.0112581877,
-0.0390115045,
0.0121422112,
-0.0068813716,
0.0289513469,
-0.0098311007,
0.032003291,
0.0101196794,
-0.06189375,
-0.0291731097,
0.0153713292,
0.0030758842,
0.0142000495,
0.0481130071,
-0.015493487,
0.0587367751,
-0.0152885672,
-0.0102310497,
0.0186243951,
-0.0482840054,
-0.0460404716,
-0.0087943655,
0.0045820824,
0.0199452005,
-0.0147833461,
0.0038957673,
0.0352057517,
0.0723141804,
-0.0229988638,
0.0163560789,
-0.0265024137,
-0.0987903252,
-0.0544193462,
0.0314736515,
0.0167704523,
0.0184509084,
0.0530000553,
-0.0146191018,
-0.0584129766,
0.0215491205,
-0.0807347819,
0.0669415221,
-0.0231017582,
0.0677086264,
0.0349833108,
0.0592994355,
-0.0331454463,
0.0531092361,
-0.0745154694,
0.0166184194,
0.0147530911,
0.002544164,
-0.0151219778,
-0.0288034007,
-0.0313824303,
0.016665535,
-0.0203535035,
-0.0282593071,
-0.0061283712,
-0.0248007346,
-0.045358967,
-0.0132370936,
-0.0552336052,
0.0273444336,
-0.0181576293,
0.0514340512,
-0.0026799403,
0.0432992913,
0.0178343188,
0.0071149673,
-0.006617215,
-0.0206741579,
-0.0001377911,
0.018642351,
-0.0122345798,
-0.0002962916,
-0.0673733056,
-0.0222994816,
-0.0413632989,
-0.0063449582,
0.0441469215,
-0.0680932105,
-0.0329421535,
-0.0490709469,
0.0268222503,
-0.0146966157,
0.0346857421,
-0.041203741,
-0.0165532157,
-0.0106505984,
-0.0257060099,
0.0689629614,
0.051387582,
0.0196491834,
0.0192398801,
0.0430180915,
-0.0422009453,
-0.0029717912,
0.0407076702,
-0.0243458655,
0.0257623941,
-0.0080560418,
-0.0104326308,
-0.0043474934,
0.0953187421,
-0.0298034269,
0.0183219388,
-0.0498740152,
-0.035680715,
0.0073559997,
-0.0118020801,
0.0320755057,
-0.0107644768,
-0.0516166463,
0.0015582636,
-0.0644482449,
-0.0386843085,
0.0625473037,
-0.0495976098,
-0.0077421134,
-0.0460477993,
0.0398515426,
-0.0275245309,
0.0788378492,
0.0173517428,
-0.0077163046,
-0.0048767696,
-0.0212870371,
0.0041663898,
0.0229451433,
-0.0622322634,
-0.0469787046,
0.0502184294,
-0.0172517821,
-0.0061585684,
-0.0110695995,
-0.0200249739,
-0.0414457098,
0.0013261741,
0.0067593255,
0.0086206337,
0.0841190666,
-0.0283374451,
-0.0364124551,
0.0472577773,
0.0406553783,
0.0569413714,
-0.0006364544,
0.0266813319,
-0.0294025689,
0.0162555054,
0.0557444841,
-0.0059322114,
0.0131557407,
-0.041356314,
0.038066335,
0.0675797239,
0.0663420409,
-0.0155466702,
0.0216019414,
-0.0015509917,
0.0434236117,
-0.0436927304,
-0.0237040706,
0.0572806112,
0.0271367244,
-0.0888835266,
-0.0626592413,
0.0984300449,
0.0424778052,
-0.0669920146,
0.0132202683,
-0.0064349431,
0.0390220918,
0.024015177,
0.024639776,
-0.0778879672,
-0.0360688195,
0.0097199157,
-0.0108469222,
0.0045384332,
-0.0148908943,
-0.0138407322,
-0.1169780791,
0.0023108637,
0.0016921032,
-0.028026145,
-0.0227927007,
-0.0489229523,
-0.0063445885,
0.0605415367,
-0.0017638075,
0.0384061299,
-0.0234359521,
-0.006603708,
0.0303533617,
-0.0037675782,
-0.0265292153,
0.0206891336,
0.0036864118,
0.0002057157,
0.0759315714,
-0.0062960838,
0.026055146,
-0.0660991371,
0.0239754859,
0.0007876777,
0.035851948,
-0.0111954464,
0.0030736334,
-0.0038521409,
-0.018761849,
-0.0335337855,
0.0024263267,
-0.0316245146,
-0.0491841249,
-0.0097428979,
0.0660323501,
-0.0367894806,
-0.0183560811,
-0.0091395723,
-0.0230409168,
-0.001184093,
0.0643421784,
0.0573652424,
-0.0376934111,
-0.0510371514,
-0.0110172266,
-0.0204423442,
-0.0480286404,
0.0063048941,
0.0096673882,
0.0329060704,
-0.0572645664,
-0.0337735265,
-0.0366386287,
0.0108120805,
0.0321117416,
0.0055125654,
0.0149013447,
0.038696453,
-0.0042048111,
-0.0709660053,
0.0171689373,
-0.02624809,
0.003041168,
-0.0506257713,
-0.0159229096,
-0.0039460631,
-0.0011441142,
-0.014190956,
0.0188987348,
-0.105349429,
-0.0513779558,
0.0331417173,
0.0688680559,
0.0180643238,
0.0259308629,
0.0111690694,
-0.0225516763,
0.0040803202,
0.0594413057,
-0.0101276161,
0.0375260562,
-0.0011873954,
-0.0340857469,
0.0041086474,
0.0077995779,
-0.0073286532,
0.0040023969,
0.0286152624,
0.0563828498,
-0.0104420576,
0.0180469081,
-0.0027505092,
-0.0035523311,
0.049207747,
0.008934183,
0.0163320471,
0.0301658176,
0.0577854067,
-0.0159937628,
0.0032901792,
-0.0312026534,
-0.0105148032,
0.0054006381,
0.0058831316,
0.013493225,
0.0176263079,
0.0221394263,
-0.0400627665,
-0.0286813676,
0.0165866725,
-0.0247337781,
-0.0333510228,
0.0264689848,
-0.0099243522,
-0.0254173912,
-0.0029515058,
0.0107454285,
0.039806392,
-0.0303761195,
0.0700544938,
0.0079737436,
0.027880162,
-0.0475165807,
0.0517840832,
-0.0442065746,
-0.0182948578,
-0.0370066203,
-0.0202546585,
0.0547734648,
-0.0348415673,
0.0292026475,
0.0117047466,
0.0107964007,
-0.0205553137,
0.0089184092,
0.0053491499,
-0.0611509271,
0.0021670407,
0.0457990915,
0.0013385226,
-0.0213102624,
0.0821797177,
0.0135505497,
0.0499767624,
0.0039646998,
-0.0160658881,
-0.0205129627,
-0.0516528375,
-0.0170201678,
0.0276027136,
-0.0181843452,
-0.0339592919,
-0.034674149,
-0.0781996474,
-0.0030420395,
0.0106035834,
0.0312544294,
-0.0221009701,
0.0460111611,
0.0368915573,
-0.0151478117,
-0.0657449216,
-0.0238947868,
0.0104341777,
-0.0049195583,
-0.0334445834,
-0.0084732221,
-6.322756361e-33,
-0.0256468523,
-0.0122372685,
0.0370262153,
0.0018031599,
-0.0400380306,
-0.0079661086,
-0.0781661645,
-0.0110024996,
0.0181829482,
-0.0264883973,
-0.0313888565,
0.0171708446,
0.0143452492,
0.035972435,
0.0030655279,
-0.0175145734,
0.0602883212,
0.0350333042,
-0.0220169704,
0.0417701192,
0.011978481,
0.0499174595,
0.0469566658,
0.0063478602,
-0.031303551,
-0.0058530034,
0.059662044,
-0.0265396219,
-0.0195041448,
0.0463619828,
-0.0495075993,
0.0141110644,
0.0264237877,
-0.1057422981,
-0.0409924984,
0.015369284,
-0.04405424,
0.0194889158,
0.0221640542,
-0.0119778542,
-0.005910859,
-0.0675893575,
0.0338036418,
0.0475746244,
0.0028389606,
0.0045467932,
0.0154040707,
-0.0167174824,
-0.0652791932,
0.0141431121,
-0.036297027,
0.0225163829,
0.0201278403,
-0.0405679494,
0.0271385089,
0.0193927754,
-0.0185459051,
0.010836958,
-0.0325951278,
-0.0071449191,
0.0556839891,
0.1002333015,
0.0774232596,
0.0619669706,
0.0521274842,
0.0432019085,
0.0382528268,
0.0134316338,
-0.0449630581,
0.0087923901,
0.0345073454,
0.0304379482,
-0.0019390598,
-0.0713007525,
0.0648599863,
-0.0123579884,
-0.0374141783,
-0.0066998648,
-0.0202451106,
0.0712339804,
0.051853653,
0.0201605298,
-0.0196497124,
-0.0342473984,
-0.0113673005,
0.0399754196,
-0.0358084254,
-0.0070409994,
0.0504949354,
0.0316932015,
-0.0167221446,
0.0257807355,
0.0633282661,
-0.0111298729,
0.0053998204,
0.0191127993,
0.0093601737,
0.0183295868,
-0.0166677795,
-0.002070613,
-0.050501693,
-0.0330440514,
0.009198091,
-0.002468735,
0.0061646728,
-0.0136096021,
-0.0251953751,
0.0185233299,
-0.0738855377,
-0.0168864448,
-0.0729988515,
0.0229200758,
0.0098415473,
0.0309089925,
0.0472549535,
0.0175401755,
-0.0024749083,
0.0703009069,
-0.0138962399,
-0.0323989764,
-0.0411181189,
0.0040390883,
0.0264268313,
0.0156142423,
-0.0027281763,
-0.0001410277,
-0.0605267845,
0.0385766029,
-0.0278028678,
-0.0704488233,
-0.0218530875,
0.0743204802,
2.832e-7,
-0.0086289914,
0.0254411958,
0.0481604859,
0.0043903249,
0.0209063925,
-0.0023333032,
0.0114211682,
-0.0038875581,
0.0101759592,
-0.0018799934,
-0.0003069855,
0.0316839702,
0.0306154042,
0.0005313587,
-0.0902976766,
-0.0108969044,
-0.0605235025,
0.0067617455,
-0.0642144606,
-0.0290102437,
0.0184869841,
0.081613414,
-0.0118906591,
0.0044516176,
0.0367806368,
0.006273624,
0.0333965681,
0.0164529644,
0.0209442209,
-0.0029816707,
0.0075077815,
0.0183122959,
-0.0085694948,
-0.0111300843,
-0.0208903439,
0.0030719584,
-0.0253983196,
0.0783590451,
0.0104973651,
-0.0570521802,
0.0241190083,
0.0187494624,
-0.0289500896,
-0.0123418514,
0.0675101876,
-0.0390440933,
-0.0122492909,
-0.0154286372,
-0.0439442247,
0.0019271838,
-0.0380558558,
0.0220194608,
0.0060733831,
0.0394408517,
0.005447662,
-0.0260089878,
-0.0136966715,
-0.0773464218,
-0.0274432525,
-0.0266726371,
-0.0861774981,
-0.0127897011,
-0.0920256227,
-0.010284517,
0.0021531875,
-0.0295977667,
-0.0386585295,
3.086737503e-34,
0.0103385886,
-0.04484386,
0.0179104339,
0.047969982,
0.0363433696,
-0.0185749903,
0.0130428607,
0.0418362096,
0.0065626283,
-0.106348224,
-0.054849349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12009v1 | FinTruthQA: A Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating the Quality of Financial Information Disclosure | 2024-06-17T18:25:02 | 2024-06-17T18:25:02 | Ziyue Xu, Peilin Zhou, Xinyu Shi, Jiageng Wu, Yikang Jiang, Bin Ke, Jie Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Accurate and transparent financial information disclosure is crucial in the
fields of accounting and finance, ensuring market efficiency and investor
confidence. Among many information disclosure platforms, the Chinese stock
exchanges' investor interactive platform provides a novel and interactive way
for listed firms to disclose information of interest to investors through an
online question-and-answer (Q&A) format. However, it is common for listed firms
to respond to questions with limited or no substantive information, and
automatically evaluating the quality of financial information disclosure on
large amounts of Q&A pairs is challenging. This paper builds a benchmark
FinTruthQA, that can evaluate advanced natural language processing (NLP)
techniques for the automatic quality assessment of information disclosure in
financial Q&A data. FinTruthQA comprises 6,000 real-world financial Q&A entries
and each Q&A was manually annotated based on four conceptual dimensions of
accounting. We benchmarked various NLP techniques on FinTruthQA, including
statistical machine learning models, pre-trained language model and their
fine-tuned versions, as well as the large language model GPT-4. Experiments
showed that existing NLP models have strong predictive ability for real
question identification and question relevance tasks, but are suboptimal for
answer relevance and answer readability tasks. By establishing this benchmark,
we provide a robust foundation for the automatic evaluation of information
disclosure, significantly enhancing the transparency and quality of financial
reporting. FinTruthQA can be used by auditors, regulators, and financial
analysts for real-time monitoring and data-driven decision-making, as well as
by researchers for advanced studies in accounting and finance, ultimately
fostering greater trust and efficiency in the financial markets. | [
0.0412603877,
0.0519357063,
-0.0037908221,
0.0425996892,
-0.0101753483,
0.0022231077,
0.010721718,
0.0306151286,
0.022652233,
-0.0581647642,
-0.0081906412,
-0.0125124874,
-0.0109281419,
0.0409656949,
0.0387043767,
-0.0162881017,
0.0275152046,
0.0299009588,
0.0360683985,
0.0290487632,
0.0532219298,
0.0207861066,
0.0136158234,
0.0224929508,
0.0104838703,
-0.0237764884,
0.0100020459,
-0.0050816182,
0.0037934261,
-0.0182685256,
0.0053594811,
0.0560008362,
-0.0110826399,
0.0306308195,
0.0000015367,
-0.0638804063,
-0.042569343,
0.0119352527,
-0.0487987846,
0.0312623382,
0.0315979421,
-0.038574703,
0.0813042149,
0.0243927203,
-0.0687232837,
-0.0133978669,
0.0568617694,
0.0863792151,
0.0900357515,
0.0551558882,
-0.0168387741,
-0.0614932887,
0.0040555764,
-0.0185786728,
0.0030079507,
-0.1192728803,
0.0102861989,
0.026370516,
-0.0124863358,
-0.005111699,
0.0052690203,
0.0287798289,
-0.008777678,
-0.0025291787,
0.0325714089,
-0.0165391713,
-0.0409874916,
-0.0028780664,
-0.0499064475,
0.0884455144,
0.0430881754,
0.0169773884,
-0.0002313171,
-0.0434175134,
0.0266403966,
0.0138775036,
-0.0063817729,
0.0152349947,
-0.0566379018,
-0.0125223361,
0.0132992929,
-0.0052207676,
-0.0009001326,
0.0219690129,
0.0110758767,
0.0136742704,
-0.0228071772,
-0.0385069437,
0.0428314209,
0.020343855,
-0.0194130447,
-0.0393837355,
0.0352438837,
0.0337021947,
0.0124831023,
0.0231121369,
-0.0157050639,
-0.0456108004,
0.0064191865,
-0.0685742199,
-0.0006502788,
0.0182328559,
-0.0092593944,
0.0559265465,
-0.0204872377,
0.0635075942,
0.03368425,
-0.0017377428,
-0.0140337273,
-0.0012486904,
-0.0109841144,
-0.0158424675,
-0.0229541566,
0.0933493823,
-0.0866644084,
-0.0270939134,
-0.0428972431,
-0.0026879236,
0.003460296,
0.0308384933,
0.0086373119,
-0.005286945,
0.0024297603,
-0.002363391,
-0.0581442527,
-0.0092145642,
-0.0578723885,
0.0208130125,
-0.0041778586,
-0.0465021245,
0.022667218,
0.0190169793,
0.0139791975,
-0.0179398805,
-0.0144852186,
0.061775852,
0.036034584,
-0.0284493156,
-0.0223359764,
-0.0465801284,
0.0066737859,
-0.0146240378,
-0.0446131229,
0.0160155743,
0.0357985832,
-0.0018317921,
-0.040404968,
-0.0107205436,
0.0023150123,
0.0244056582,
0.0081930542,
0.0851815268,
-0.0142197646,
-0.0085202418,
0.0217863806,
-0.0158527102,
0.0291999634,
0.0334164798,
0.0054619405,
-0.0296106935,
0.063548483,
-0.0043908013,
0.0314318538,
0.0139196068,
0.0045990231,
-0.0606408156,
0.0440990776,
0.0923439562,
-0.0283000544,
0.0153546957,
0.0106511516,
0.0544228964,
-0.0110765956,
-0.0377277583,
0.0489480384,
0.0309755635,
0.0333395936,
0.0182730798,
-0.0094283745,
0.0580318198,
0.0459498428,
0.0002938916,
0.0150246732,
0.0102606965,
-0.0173329376,
0.0255429298,
0.0324544013,
-0.0239372663,
-0.028417103,
-0.0688142926,
-0.0332480334,
0.0187444184,
-0.017828688,
0.0159146991,
-0.0136907641,
-0.006149054,
-0.0812967196,
0.0403567292,
0.0067787743,
-0.0329764076,
-0.0016434425,
-0.0284391809,
0.0603765063,
0.0608141422,
0.0211190656,
-0.0513610505,
0.0298812725,
-0.0283653215,
-0.0263442937,
0.0547799356,
0.0436747633,
-0.0064356807,
-0.0208744574,
-0.030147491,
-0.0184119493,
0.0187581088,
0.0080934409,
-0.0123731429,
-0.0086208396,
0.0046856119,
0.0101228273,
-0.0356745869,
-0.0309063625,
0.0688529536,
0.0364837572,
-0.0660350919,
0.0362140201,
-0.0042973184,
0.003828584,
0.0465003885,
0.0143214297,
0.0159526356,
-0.0011102391,
0.0238172207,
-0.0110769682,
-0.0316134244,
-0.0328855105,
-0.015899362,
-0.0013566,
-0.0215040743,
-0.0004350018,
0.0438716039,
-0.0699310005,
-0.0079106688,
-0.0289274659,
-0.0357124135,
-0.0137109682,
-0.0722555146,
-0.0472737662,
0.0003879933,
0.025322536,
-0.0369991548,
0.0782164633,
-0.0050037634,
0.0534176454,
-0.0622357577,
-0.0183329806,
0.0086906087,
-0.061607033,
0.0361078158,
-0.0127765816,
-0.0498029329,
0.0681196153,
0.0575496443,
0.0197794512,
-0.024108585,
0.0138547942,
-0.0806598812,
-0.0255563892,
-0.0198202003,
0.0224517267,
0.0166222099,
0.0072761644,
-0.015025801,
-0.0174786244,
-0.0346078165,
-0.0601332486,
-0.0179944914,
0.0049623023,
0.0862988234,
0.0326883048,
0.0170908049,
-0.0552232899,
-0.0300458819,
0.0001708255,
0.0169644654,
0.0844664425,
-0.043709822,
-0.0450710617,
-0.0134354904,
-0.0168199055,
-0.0137809478,
0.0205394011,
0.0403195508,
-0.0086412681,
0.0286899023,
-0.0311561879,
0.0490114726,
0.0167348031,
0.0559732914,
-0.0607523471,
0.0482011624,
-0.0376534835,
0.0324891061,
-0.0379178375,
0.0076058619,
-0.0098942798,
-0.0226644464,
0.0545342453,
0.0037503447,
-0.003716158,
-0.0014572707,
-0.0626710951,
0.0457214639,
-0.0325319879,
-0.0010030743,
-0.0731698573,
-0.0163777899,
-0.0065381154,
0.0659482405,
-0.0012574921,
-0.0448752418,
0.0530782342,
-0.0021570898,
-0.0270336755,
-0.0453774258,
-0.0116476752,
-0.0721066445,
0.0315598063,
-0.0206089672,
0.0224417485,
0.0234221965,
-0.063812159,
0.0023554454,
-0.0472331084,
0.0405524559,
-0.043904826,
0.033743225,
-0.011500204,
0.0411167927,
0.0056851828,
-0.0236541256,
-0.0311435182,
-0.0895437747,
-0.0123556713,
0.0049495078,
0.0212657377,
-0.0192077011,
-0.0425973348,
0.0193322394,
0.0031814275,
0.0041147768,
-0.0195405576,
-0.0335961245,
0.0071343705,
0.0478896722,
0.0468715876,
0.0295562893,
0.07920935,
-0.0273966715,
0.0367389396,
0.0148014706,
0.0302625336,
0.0265968814,
0.0349406116,
-0.0205998961,
-0.0278567653,
-0.0452434942,
0.0264781415,
0.0146040488,
0.0231578741,
-0.0530503467,
-0.00484731,
0.086490944,
0.0224932302,
0.0518407114,
-0.0104392376,
0.0450239182,
-0.0136431744,
-0.0083201202,
0.0593288168,
-0.0998374745,
-0.0242463518,
-0.0341618769,
0.03988019,
0.0019081343,
-0.0674466118,
-0.0097030066,
-0.1182336286,
0.0325308852,
-0.0319842286,
-0.025883548,
-0.0561399087,
-0.0663804784,
-0.0249694232,
-0.0660787001,
0.0402361825,
-0.0066281329,
-0.0092959609,
0.0106252301,
0.0041839089,
-0.0976423174,
0.0070710434,
-0.0094055794,
-0.0220368337,
-0.0316331387,
0.0556043349,
0.0289589204,
-0.037817128,
-0.0131797204,
-0.0420773514,
-0.0468645431,
-0.0319907516,
-0.0019930361,
0.0677631423,
-0.031719815,
-0.014226946,
-0.0119577982,
0.0397922024,
-0.0350410007,
0.0693639368,
0.0066155065,
-0.0003712965,
0.0060316743,
-0.0280781742,
0.0136921378,
0.0335664563,
0.0075426255,
0.1002726704,
0.0065017752,
-0.008185491,
-0.0305968951,
-0.0412581973,
0.0198282357,
-0.0806622431,
0.0163734779,
-0.0017064892,
0.027980525,
0.0252119526,
-0.1080887243,
-0.0908671841,
0.0243151747,
-0.0157975443,
-0.0064720968,
0.0226003192,
0.0186357852,
0.0091070235,
-0.0276908074,
0.006221782,
-0.0291621834,
0.0268575735,
-0.0372931324,
0.0239102878,
-0.0127561884,
0.0140421968,
-0.0712110028,
0.0549687967,
-0.0354081281,
-0.0109049175,
-0.0247291774,
-0.021315502,
0.0185269322,
-0.0179575887,
-0.0531772599,
0.0078188451,
0.0065126098,
0.0314847827,
-0.0864538699,
-0.0288911499,
0.0203190874,
0.0175265372,
-0.0050767241,
0.0253065526,
-0.0517339706,
-0.0199723411,
0.000386235,
0.039917063,
-0.0165450126,
-0.0257066786,
0.0155010093,
0.0217115562,
-0.0012241731,
0.0569647737,
-0.0285253171,
-0.0346565954,
-0.0255399905,
0.0074481098,
0.0016061058,
-0.0404483154,
0.004676776,
0.0374707989,
0.011120528,
-0.0190238561,
0.0443123989,
-0.050952021,
0.0001409955,
-0.0592480563,
0.0103940498,
0.0221060682,
0.0000586933,
-0.0382222086,
-0.0205956548,
-0.0179303773,
-0.0047962284,
0.0649453849,
0.0209253542,
0.0269949529,
-0.0026348955,
0.0153796235,
0.0231022369,
0.0299238078,
-0.0116953086,
-0.0252435505,
-0.0263868403,
-0.0190935209,
0.0418980755,
-0.0126445955,
-0.0135524664,
-0.0391126908,
-0.02601601,
0.0093953134,
-0.0208120011,
0.0389616117,
0.0469996482,
-0.0431000851,
0.0509040728,
0.0031872473,
-0.0488354079,
-0.0159047712,
0.0705059394,
0.0267085861,
0.0090906769,
-0.0311964136,
-0.0296522472,
-0.0496728607,
-0.0184842311,
0.0250170194,
0.0254220832,
0.004284319,
0.0208048895,
-0.0634059235,
-0.0482947901,
0.0275999457,
-0.0151359597,
-0.0219753925,
-0.0132352505,
0.0222107563,
0.0638265088,
0.041979976,
-0.004967269,
-0.053442806,
-0.0000226022,
-0.0367398784,
-0.0147566209,
-0.0672563389,
-5.44547207e-33,
-0.0048566265,
-0.0407576971,
-0.0019793462,
-0.0078978296,
0.0551263392,
0.034849491,
-0.0287394114,
-0.0275585391,
-0.0500915535,
0.0166334026,
0.0094575267,
0.0422997773,
0.0183379762,
0.0115183797,
-0.0445409939,
-0.0402061157,
0.0253788419,
-0.0257120766,
-0.0206427798,
-0.0114958761,
-0.0005920709,
0.0431835204,
0.0312830321,
-0.0375242643,
0.079945311,
-0.0210915301,
-0.0419925489,
0.0213597603,
0.0385897569,
0.0612456538,
-0.0063173342,
0.0415097028,
0.0328511856,
-0.0622086599,
0.0010966868,
0.0356965773,
-0.0449542254,
-0.0395722352,
0.0311710481,
0.0165997427,
-0.0189631619,
0.0421858542,
0.0582270361,
-0.0200082362,
0.0032215756,
-0.0205039494,
0.0484655425,
0.0047843657,
0.007238395,
-0.0454079323,
-0.0607009716,
0.0325587094,
-0.0213976055,
0.0478861965,
0.0238453876,
0.1099085808,
-0.0113619994,
0.0033403549,
-0.0283856187,
-0.0338196568,
0.0456472896,
0.0034531606,
0.0020964325,
0.0059227487,
-0.0059099454,
0.020691514,
0.0063656792,
0.0018372579,
-0.0002295859,
0.0426403545,
0.011793714,
0.0263570752,
0.0754560903,
0.0288957004,
0.0079510259,
-0.0022410341,
-0.0727081224,
0.0341136456,
-0.0189454593,
0.0251006484,
0.0206981786,
-0.0131118167,
-0.0642621294,
-0.0179036893,
-0.0408175103,
0.0373597704,
-0.0483297966,
0.0239008218,
0.02627155,
-0.0024244213,
-0.0392059833,
0.0405069925,
0.0040281476,
-0.0404268093,
-0.0645152032,
-0.0082313195,
0.0300761405,
0.0056142793,
0.0368870087,
0.0088462504,
-0.0318254642,
0.0254003536,
-0.0128553165,
0.0069898958,
-0.0107370242,
-0.0377232991,
0.0388234891,
-0.021430172,
-0.0391048715,
0.0087945089,
0.0324344784,
0.0281781927,
-0.0094014043,
0.0258280765,
-0.005636422,
0.0348299891,
-0.0185064152,
0.0199130047,
-0.0084586935,
0.0163423978,
-0.0339463092,
-0.0337761268,
0.010673332,
0.0364395492,
-0.0106038256,
-0.0125605166,
0.008900254,
0.0557254814,
0.0220533032,
-0.0069928551,
-0.0212292876,
0.0276255608,
2.239e-7,
0.0643975139,
0.0104153287,
0.0114208041,
0.0079536941,
-0.0040693604,
0.0294479132,
0.0338496603,
0.03710787,
-0.0228986312,
-0.0376354791,
0.024826413,
-0.002690644,
0.0735957325,
-0.0043662004,
-0.0574869625,
-0.0545701385,
-0.0436323024,
0.0227432754,
-0.0496538877,
0.0580875799,
0.032479763,
0.0590815842,
-0.0163137503,
-0.0122892568,
-0.0270450916,
-0.0809147134,
0.0314052068,
-0.0269127246,
-0.0050811544,
0.0300931763,
0.0702061132,
0.0273538809,
0.0273376908,
-0.0023628108,
-0.0053854482,
0.0030172162,
0.0624030828,
0.0312946178,
0.0249371789,
-0.0051729367,
-0.0240625702,
-0.0159026347,
0.0021319254,
-0.0411710963,
0.0615491793,
-0.0286092479,
-0.0255072713,
-0.0036632249,
-0.0323484614,
-0.0233955085,
0.0382333845,
-0.0006861259,
-0.0306963418,
0.0164933559,
0.0258908439,
-0.0194683056,
0.0271551479,
-0.0233729593,
-0.001931628,
0.0166620705,
-0.0018001788,
0.0340048559,
-0.0245613754,
-0.0137513205,
0.0137945451,
-0.0402894691,
0.0304715689,
1.833137982e-34,
0.0438341238,
-0.0264551714,
-0.0239649378,
0.0411173552,
0.0939398929,
0.0201204196,
-0.0198976249,
0.019142257,
-0.0106271598,
-0.0836454928,
0.0138993254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11978v1 | Dialogue Action Tokens: Steering Language Models in Goal-Directed Dialogue with a Multi-Turn Planner | 2024-06-17T18:01:32 | 2024-06-17T18:01:32 | Kenneth Li, Yiming Wang, Fernanda Viégas, Martin Wattenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present an approach called Dialogue Action Tokens (DAT) that adapts
language model agents to plan goal-directed dialogues. The core idea is to
treat each utterance as an action, thereby converting dialogues into games
where existing approaches such as reinforcement learning can be applied.
Specifically, we freeze a pretrained language model and train a small planner
model that predicts a continuous action vector, used for controlled generation
in each round. This design avoids the problem of language degradation under
reward optimization. When evaluated on the Sotopia platform for social
simulations, the DAT-steered LLaMA model surpasses GPT-4's performance. We also
apply DAT to steer an attacker language model in a novel multi-turn red-teaming
setting, revealing a potential new attack surface. | [
0.0460250229,
0.0342455395,
-0.0153282825,
0.0377139971,
-0.0407110862,
-0.0209697243,
0.0063614314,
-0.0270922631,
-0.0075067272,
-0.035077773,
-0.0319290832,
-0.0019534684,
-0.0493410267,
0.0637819543,
0.0443104245,
-0.0496183448,
0.0582614616,
-0.0817078426,
0.032075271,
-0.0080009401,
0.0001093019,
-0.0199905951,
-0.038445048,
0.0681676641,
-0.0272239987,
0.0021744156,
-0.0688743442,
0.0064979298,
0.0268028062,
-0.0121059697,
0.0081536593,
0.0063733119,
0.0380248576,
0.0382344313,
0.000002102,
-0.0465450175,
-0.0087646889,
-0.0450330637,
-0.0032820918,
-0.0123822773,
0.015014722,
-0.0030597192,
-0.021859739,
0.034264788,
-0.0409237444,
0.0046165902,
0.0337664671,
0.0739836469,
0.0853748694,
0.1062035486,
0.0127860932,
-0.0391780213,
0.0009097473,
-0.0290632602,
-0.0328792743,
-0.0694969967,
-0.0144818267,
-0.0023190274,
0.0212880988,
0.0177967306,
-0.0148509592,
-0.0065926076,
0.0071358471,
-0.0233474188,
-0.0632470697,
0.0498154648,
-0.0293457266,
0.0242346004,
-0.0303925239,
0.0415415801,
-0.0482751839,
-0.0134891942,
0.0246600229,
-0.0042958762,
0.0043113129,
-0.036492493,
0.0042811618,
0.0009191436,
0.0232752617,
0.0020409529,
0.0252001286,
-0.0007389082,
0.0106028756,
-0.0190897789,
-0.018578615,
0.0910360292,
-0.0104572345,
-0.0200980976,
-0.0183899682,
-0.0388756432,
0.0178263541,
-0.0768036544,
-0.0219421461,
0.0387221202,
-0.070701234,
0.0224307999,
-0.0558087826,
0.0263884589,
0.0119744306,
-0.0149484659,
0.0112659633,
0.0258971136,
0.0102760745,
0.0194475763,
0.0033584849,
0.0551532581,
0.0103067728,
0.0721938014,
-0.0172182638,
0.0123295663,
-0.0189535841,
-0.0083120791,
-0.0771889389,
0.0333620235,
-0.0522411168,
-0.0431938469,
-0.0269833095,
0.0518746078,
-0.0222070068,
0.0448378734,
-0.0146774873,
-0.0160195567,
-0.0206939671,
0.0198239665,
-0.0436406061,
-0.0384677052,
-0.0422665291,
0.0021137486,
0.0050858133,
-0.0643798113,
-0.0193966944,
-0.005995526,
-0.0380551107,
-0.0214032792,
0.0013252099,
0.1420494467,
-0.0323651992,
-0.0425232463,
0.0174705647,
-0.0390179567,
0.0001963317,
-0.0662722439,
-0.0022265036,
-0.0581547581,
0.0492991731,
-0.0097075952,
-0.0146798268,
-0.016438758,
0.018986905,
-0.0084280251,
-0.0186510049,
0.0894366801,
0.0487618707,
0.0175068025,
0.0148555934,
0.005836085,
-0.0118290428,
0.0863111839,
0.0502456762,
0.0306652375,
0.0323685855,
0.0272353534,
0.049771931,
0.0842583627,
0.0126477787,
0.0250709318,
0.0440287665,
0.0087020304,
0.0402537957,
0.043825049,
0.0162007753,
0.0441462919,
-0.0472491495,
-0.0529612489,
0.0681003481,
0.060359478,
-0.0158541538,
0.0093439259,
0.0449219421,
0.0247448217,
-0.0207095519,
-0.0204397719,
-0.0305879153,
0.0379490294,
-0.0209180526,
-0.0055025006,
0.0145302573,
0.0136088766,
-0.0227231402,
-0.0212992374,
0.0351844653,
-0.013358959,
0.0358261839,
0.0057078786,
0.0086214133,
0.0056184246,
-0.0916297436,
0.0038019638,
-0.0027989638,
-0.0388313308,
-0.0331236683,
-0.0774920955,
-0.0053510657,
0.0427090451,
0.0554241128,
-0.0169940479,
-0.0776998699,
-0.0205906369,
-0.0365372784,
0.0477611348,
0.0244452115,
-0.0123223355,
0.0186148621,
-0.0171652827,
-0.0086487783,
-0.0200733598,
-0.0007385515,
0.0420984887,
-0.0071245129,
0.0008052681,
-0.0308528785,
0.0384664014,
-0.0075206328,
0.0266765431,
0.0604189895,
-0.033639092,
0.0025228437,
-0.0013419032,
0.0950647891,
-0.0059800344,
-0.0266626533,
0.0131743876,
0.0381398536,
0.0047120936,
0.012399097,
0.0464048386,
0.0050879582,
-0.0137737356,
0.019476248,
0.0145979235,
0.0183445606,
0.034492027,
-0.0374142416,
-0.026100738,
0.0496989861,
-0.0302355401,
0.0301917996,
0.0043122028,
0.0005719621,
0.0307508577,
0.0158708021,
-0.0088251885,
0.0102965767,
0.0068709869,
-0.0401446372,
-0.0080514066,
0.0125860721,
0.0071554799,
-0.0937833488,
-0.0035436391,
0.0515414476,
0.0182851721,
-0.0022155838,
0.0341899134,
0.0272331256,
-0.017277671,
-0.0526155978,
-0.0644650385,
-0.007243013,
-0.0396803021,
-0.0070501138,
0.0145245595,
-0.0130715566,
-0.027675163,
-0.0115250396,
-0.0203016829,
-0.0017199772,
0.0221139006,
-0.0142381275,
0.0038856061,
0.0267777368,
-0.0752460957,
-0.0249778777,
0.020615194,
0.0032082566,
-0.0003376496,
-0.0162088796,
-0.0228153802,
-0.0349347703,
-0.0143635646,
-0.0453562699,
0.0473883301,
-0.0378633589,
-0.0789853632,
0.0525849313,
-0.0085786507,
0.0290426705,
0.0498369485,
0.0170655753,
0.0410380363,
0.0542659238,
-0.0463230945,
-0.0723184422,
0.0432926379,
-0.0304490309,
-0.0260083936,
-0.08510039,
-0.0067824177,
0.0566377193,
0.0637557134,
0.0051080571,
0.0275906101,
-0.0471016616,
-0.0372274332,
0.0366891287,
-0.0498366542,
0.0173193607,
-0.0157426018,
-0.0329029113,
0.0087671094,
-0.0311582237,
-0.0293740965,
0.0853178576,
-0.0286174193,
-0.0263095759,
-0.0424431823,
-0.0048147477,
0.0081202406,
0.0449895523,
0.0073778578,
0.013181271,
-0.0142037831,
-0.0055470024,
-0.0158980824,
-0.0700410232,
-0.0061770561,
-0.0111313481,
0.0519310646,
-0.0466473661,
0.0195913184,
0.016032612,
0.0037549092,
-0.0224974863,
-0.0233052671,
-0.0437224209,
0.021168977,
0.0129992329,
-0.055540815,
-0.036999166,
-0.0006516348,
0.0485734493,
0.0461127572,
-0.0013712781,
0.0048894407,
-0.0297324955,
-0.0353588089,
0.0569208972,
-0.0224152431,
-0.0181028917,
-0.0381612778,
0.0493797809,
0.0494353063,
0.0578824431,
-0.0497917682,
-0.0235579684,
-0.0262571648,
0.0287234671,
-0.013585547,
-0.0111181401,
0.0299370531,
0.0598788932,
-0.0229883473,
-0.0273195095,
0.0795097798,
0.0231853053,
0.0119366962,
0.0135409944,
-0.0171610843,
0.0463160612,
-0.0088727772,
0.0536254719,
-0.0683604404,
-0.0212291293,
0.0023656571,
0.0244491827,
-0.021510886,
-0.0241898336,
-0.0211025067,
-0.1005754247,
0.0213693473,
0.0034620631,
-0.0661532208,
0.0102016665,
-0.0135705164,
0.0045198514,
0.0133388462,
0.0350502655,
0.000590372,
0.0468817465,
-0.0188506301,
-0.01279891,
-0.0295070596,
0.0402688682,
0.0116361482,
-0.0238333717,
0.0961016193,
0.0645415634,
0.0427510105,
-0.0046330737,
-0.0104603954,
0.0246994849,
0.0341979638,
0.0030433794,
-0.0066639776,
0.0036157316,
-0.0255979132,
-0.012296794,
0.0626415238,
0.028963102,
0.0306327064,
-0.0338537879,
0.0365334302,
0.0306019299,
-0.0580333807,
-0.0078032487,
-0.0144005287,
0.0301974192,
0.0411107801,
0.0452357419,
-0.0201299042,
-0.0331258141,
-0.0426881164,
-0.0327102728,
-0.0296171214,
-0.077196613,
-0.0624370426,
-0.0647818595,
0.0185573548,
-0.0159979276,
-0.0491183847,
-0.0659192577,
0.0208665505,
0.0219953246,
-0.0106742792,
-0.0192071367,
-0.0135220978,
0.0263192989,
0.0058219791,
-0.0449924245,
-0.0435523465,
0.0403637774,
-0.0655794814,
-0.0309790857,
0.0094635533,
-0.0655040219,
-0.0074507403,
0.0600356385,
-0.0442342684,
-0.0661664382,
0.0125517333,
0.0710392073,
0.0152429054,
0.0376524851,
-0.0200539958,
-0.0263688676,
0.0380002223,
0.008453778,
-0.0211656708,
0.0351124667,
0.052660957,
0.0597693995,
0.0257151574,
0.0330931209,
-0.0245032869,
0.0172138289,
0.0377815627,
0.0161151309,
-0.076808922,
-0.0199254043,
0.0031039161,
-0.0067446334,
0.0434878021,
-0.0174332447,
0.0169992484,
0.0110025117,
0.0197531171,
-0.0635484383,
-0.0105818436,
-0.0279201418,
0.004393186,
-0.0213203821,
0.0047858083,
0.0124005694,
-0.032774061,
-0.0473432466,
-0.0207345132,
0.0126368972,
0.0206252914,
0.0740611628,
0.0080231866,
0.0085110096,
-0.0078622689,
0.0209384821,
0.0092279287,
0.0000979596,
0.0026888952,
0.0311704632,
0.0528992452,
0.0266690552,
-0.04274657,
0.0036135996,
0.031834878,
-0.0828761235,
-0.0639661402,
0.0542106591,
0.056367971,
0.0466990322,
0.0377686135,
0.0224072486,
-0.0552074388,
0.0303218123,
0.0139434077,
0.0109161204,
-0.0049795215,
-0.0741523206,
0.0696041808,
0.0278935991,
-0.0095070256,
0.0322514847,
0.0448876619,
0.0048609339,
0.0789524093,
0.0187923945,
0.0097174002,
-0.0533159077,
-0.038176734,
0.0164693743,
0.0319787301,
-0.0087461974,
-0.0283598397,
-0.0476815701,
-0.0256472491,
0.0006207144,
0.0491332151,
0.0150521873,
-0.0068394532,
0.0450270958,
0.0252402313,
0.0070778499,
-0.0034147273,
-0.0585249998,
-0.0064659924,
0.015806932,
-0.0410870239,
0.0018823326,
-6.228959993e-33,
-0.0135240387,
-0.028332023,
0.050241787,
0.0038439147,
-0.0441676788,
-0.0196676403,
-0.0538166836,
-0.0089605805,
-0.0362889431,
0.0061491304,
-0.0218110662,
0.0288619082,
0.016322758,
0.0057044011,
-0.0277285241,
-0.033077471,
0.0185106657,
-0.0319008902,
-0.0407220982,
0.0353454687,
0.060978204,
-0.0314889327,
0.0205443222,
-0.0567989424,
0.0014546419,
-0.0091932984,
-0.0633659139,
0.0344953276,
-0.0288224295,
0.0248499122,
0.0161087289,
-0.0074189682,
-0.0198921878,
-0.0394748524,
0.0042769406,
0.0240197238,
0.0125986999,
-0.0264991242,
0.0108837876,
-0.0027914559,
-0.0313768163,
-0.0534108877,
0.0017765397,
-0.00362372,
-0.0380362533,
0.0245955978,
0.0006327947,
0.0002299155,
-0.0093534468,
0.0206685681,
-0.0558531545,
-0.0010287915,
-0.0199040249,
-0.0427267738,
0.0036868176,
-0.0038062353,
0.0153331244,
-0.0716210902,
-0.0301112812,
0.0670924187,
-0.0283185504,
0.0047169081,
0.0383912995,
0.0486443602,
0.0217922553,
0.0477154851,
0.0041745217,
0.0049504149,
-0.0343339629,
0.022460185,
0.0125596961,
0.0424959883,
0.0348892622,
0.0141749326,
-0.0390021503,
-0.0354359522,
-0.0486389361,
-0.012370199,
0.0632471964,
0.0582945161,
0.0266074874,
0.0117645804,
-0.0559188314,
0.0033446981,
-0.0220860653,
-0.0077856244,
0.0098056765,
-0.0446366183,
0.0260476377,
0.0306701828,
-0.0007416969,
-0.0388995595,
0.0523170978,
0.0020994877,
0.0119005376,
0.0447166637,
-0.0275578238,
0.0080906237,
-0.0445682071,
-0.0242038984,
-0.0478540324,
-0.0249160118,
0.0422196873,
-0.0319524184,
0.022215426,
0.0056368476,
-0.0089257481,
0.0524530821,
-0.049684383,
-0.0003910196,
-0.0382387564,
0.0676814988,
0.0116561083,
-0.0160359312,
0.0285789482,
-0.0263834409,
-0.0216876008,
0.0007210623,
-0.0007819273,
-0.1052016094,
-0.0158101432,
0.0378140435,
-0.0341911428,
0.0320167206,
-0.0487292297,
0.0507407933,
-0.0265364647,
0.047875829,
-0.0014287917,
-0.0397296175,
-0.0186197944,
-0.0285434518,
2.906e-7,
-0.04831798,
0.0327640288,
0.0319139697,
0.0721020848,
0.001069824,
0.0618860424,
-0.0110114859,
0.0791782737,
0.0234007034,
0.0076347883,
0.0119178863,
0.0588871092,
0.0111358538,
0.0170914829,
-0.0697806776,
0.0020572026,
-0.0460699499,
-0.0220273677,
-0.057406567,
-0.0341196619,
0.0410689525,
0.0779567361,
0.0439993031,
0.0101758521,
-0.0208897069,
-0.014927567,
0.0211640801,
-0.0239812918,
-0.0112479106,
0.0169206038,
-0.0108793136,
-0.0062062708,
-0.0372508503,
0.0235651881,
-0.0162024125,
0.0205861237,
-0.0243592225,
0.05215488,
0.010260581,
-0.0633306652,
-0.0253703818,
-0.0198696796,
-0.0177392606,
-0.0310837459,
0.0431029797,
-0.009540773,
0.0112862391,
0.0206520725,
0.0098817479,
0.0166850798,
-0.0114498939,
-0.0372416563,
-0.0260338783,
0.0202771518,
0.0037942678,
0.0211460013,
0.0544320308,
-0.0486869179,
-0.0065291766,
-0.0408249497,
-0.0260899961,
-0.0292072389,
-0.002715047,
0.044530496,
-0.011526675,
-0.0079879537,
-0.0290821027,
2.549651839e-34,
0.0085423896,
-0.0293771364,
-0.013653256,
0.0188351572,
0.0503060706,
0.013596545,
0.0220703464,
0.022519974,
0.0655448362,
-0.0192841832,
-0.0387169831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11977v1 | Reframing linguistic bootstrapping as joint inference using visually-grounded grammar induction models | 2024-06-17T18:01:06 | 2024-06-17T18:01:06 | Eva Portelance, Siva Reddy, Timothy J. O'Donnell | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.10; I.2.6; F.4.2 | Semantic and syntactic bootstrapping posit that children use their prior
knowledge of one linguistic domain, say syntactic relations, to help later
acquire another, such as the meanings of new words. Empirical results
supporting both theories may tempt us to believe that these are different
learning strategies, where one may precede the other. Here, we argue that they
are instead both contingent on a more general learning strategy for language
acquisition: joint learning. Using a series of neural visually-grounded grammar
induction models, we demonstrate that both syntactic and semantic bootstrapping
effects are strongest when syntax and semantics are learnt simultaneously.
Joint learning results in better grammar induction, realistic lexical category
learning, and better interpretations of novel sentence and verb meanings. Joint
learning makes language acquisition easier for learners by mutually
constraining the hypotheses spaces for both syntax and semantics. Studying the
dynamics of joint inference over many input sources and modalities represents
an important new direction for language modeling and learning research in both
cognitive sciences and AI, as it may help us explain how language can be
acquired in more constrained learning settings. | [
0.0194770321,
0.0375490263,
-0.0306610279,
0.0163283795,
-0.0389424041,
0.0266865157,
-0.053774327,
-0.0012619137,
-0.0304248463,
-0.0799048766,
-0.032219436,
-0.0381692015,
0.0266220476,
-0.0003354783,
0.0399086475,
-0.0349073038,
0.0562336259,
-0.030907739,
-0.0376822427,
0.0045974497,
-0.0039994437,
-0.0004952007,
-0.0283251647,
0.0131414225,
-0.0783214867,
0.011186312,
0.0157197192,
-0.0363483801,
-0.0620618723,
-0.0135169309,
-0.0119227981,
0.0310923904,
0.054355111,
0.0299886391,
0.0000016502,
-0.0619477071,
0.0134615358,
-0.0401859544,
-0.0224049482,
-0.0141677605,
0.027948007,
-0.0479564965,
0.0091292821,
-0.024337342,
-0.0737796128,
-0.0584869199,
0.0558533818,
0.0096942745,
0.0130939968,
-0.0114075635,
-0.0231084321,
-0.0000139934,
0.0349152982,
-0.0095043583,
0.0006666382,
0.0204537679,
0.0067003374,
0.0470712706,
-0.0341875218,
-0.0249007698,
-0.0510833971,
-0.004189319,
0.0376412459,
0.0046545514,
-0.0051574344,
0.0654053167,
-0.003264436,
-0.0515240617,
-0.0232277606,
0.0362804681,
-0.0121252481,
-0.035527721,
-0.0270878337,
0.0219072755,
0.0133815557,
0.0772733837,
-0.0533399582,
0.0844893977,
-0.0179695711,
0.0760705993,
0.0531670563,
-0.0437603779,
0.0075511909,
0.0173747502,
0.0138903148,
0.0781594142,
-0.0173365101,
-0.0270537604,
0.0582886264,
0.0722687021,
-0.0255926978,
-0.0398963764,
-0.0450902358,
-0.0115420287,
0.0198820923,
0.0362940766,
-0.0237346143,
0.0181179028,
-0.0073455088,
-0.0158379395,
0.038449347,
0.0071426448,
-0.0352023616,
0.0474703051,
-0.0486328602,
-0.0176072754,
-0.0055076885,
0.0312431082,
-0.0270789843,
0.032936912,
-0.0296002515,
-0.0500922464,
-0.0222250298,
0.0219871644,
-0.0397211537,
-0.0106820799,
-0.0086280992,
0.0056130541,
-0.003537857,
-0.0250589289,
-0.0272953026,
-0.0161643848,
-0.0774930865,
-0.0019064246,
-0.0550311692,
-0.0287141986,
-0.014013445,
0.0733560547,
-0.0095282961,
-0.0585194826,
-0.0419259369,
0.0207541492,
0.0138952183,
0.013638434,
-0.0259399414,
0.0660368428,
-0.0215441287,
-0.0293831807,
-0.0322461277,
-0.031341657,
-0.0152622741,
-0.0111820344,
0.0510401279,
-0.0551126935,
-0.0411382206,
0.0100593176,
-0.0007695865,
-0.0611909814,
0.002627251,
0.0110786417,
-0.0110131521,
0.03686212,
-0.0013469215,
-0.0172557812,
-0.0232998691,
-0.0163303502,
0.0088171912,
0.0638945028,
-0.0016434697,
-0.0128270248,
-0.0184909366,
0.0081548775,
-0.0039415117,
0.0112462463,
0.0077287965,
0.0245376043,
-0.0772496834,
-0.0442294106,
0.0233286973,
0.0184238516,
-0.0101484712,
0.0153125748,
-0.0293376744,
0.0307593141,
0.0324448943,
0.0498076603,
0.0034138232,
0.0090310713,
0.0848214179,
-0.0427967682,
-0.0059500518,
0.048861254,
-0.059964899,
0.0057721711,
-0.0161287021,
0.0028297121,
-0.0683994368,
0.0026099719,
-0.0047937878,
-0.0345455743,
-0.0042627202,
-0.0176433846,
-0.0064271884,
0.0001301275,
0.0509919077,
0.096696578,
-0.0144357001,
0.0184502043,
0.095908232,
-0.0521794185,
0.0032606865,
-0.0150445979,
-0.0060282433,
-0.0292344131,
-0.0118793054,
-0.0132315699,
-0.0350635797,
-0.0025211682,
0.0167952534,
0.0613255501,
-0.0126979025,
0.0144781973,
0.0047998857,
-0.012066395,
-0.0012865273,
-0.0144295515,
0.0265257116,
-0.0096168099,
-0.0164930951,
-0.0255312324,
-0.0203560963,
-0.0335355736,
0.0086774677,
0.0776158273,
-0.0160272792,
-0.0284995437,
-0.036444407,
0.047332406,
0.0015710176,
-0.0600905977,
-0.0004207364,
0.008194006,
0.0187038463,
-0.0313092321,
0.0156595148,
0.0452275015,
-0.0764819086,
-0.0522875972,
0.0105327386,
-0.0023579709,
-0.0144475512,
-0.0126461657,
0.0213404968,
0.0000445386,
0.0443411544,
-0.0356179141,
0.064844653,
-0.0302222054,
-0.0027467532,
-0.0255472269,
0.0206091274,
-0.0349461325,
0.0863824561,
0.005285054,
-0.0134073654,
-0.0296911839,
0.0048190886,
0.0108930031,
-0.0008702615,
0.0234160013,
-0.0210359227,
-0.0007716882,
-0.0180627592,
-0.0093368581,
0.0012587273,
-0.0824000314,
-0.0006333686,
-0.0478158332,
-0.0162690226,
0.0088066179,
0.0118897362,
0.029510593,
-0.0513945185,
0.0005798003,
-0.0342866555,
0.0072899619,
0.0476530083,
-0.0386701636,
0.0256605223,
0.0477221869,
0.0013872709,
-0.0185108352,
-0.0362036154,
-0.0200086441,
-0.052167315,
0.0748294443,
0.0527474396,
-0.0105160624,
-0.0368060246,
0.0025466869,
-0.014396769,
0.0398937948,
0.0240301434,
-0.0139928628,
0.0500366651,
-0.0391569659,
0.0410892367,
0.0796477199,
-0.0197337158,
0.0815156028,
0.0501773767,
-0.011106099,
-0.0512750931,
-0.0278156251,
-0.0503652096,
-0.0192305986,
-0.0151827084,
0.0020145937,
-0.0264580082,
0.1083563268,
0.0001679772,
-0.0114212744,
-0.0363730155,
0.0464960225,
-0.0337786935,
0.0016930274,
-0.0402777605,
-0.0445233174,
-0.0365925692,
0.055635117,
-0.048052296,
-0.0649067238,
0.0677065477,
-0.0005819547,
-0.0007842085,
-0.0365863591,
0.0047054524,
0.0030403922,
0.0630736127,
0.0526922718,
0.0168318208,
0.0378797911,
-0.0072548101,
-0.0860795528,
0.0071866745,
0.0689031258,
0.0190782361,
0.0425505228,
-0.0684626997,
0.0077197878,
0.019221982,
0.0024194303,
-0.0501883961,
-0.0493093133,
-0.025366528,
-0.0096321665,
-0.0859598443,
0.0208312031,
0.0565326996,
-0.0055204965,
0.0089285756,
-0.0010000801,
0.0139030525,
-0.022580361,
-0.0277718939,
0.0098590907,
0.0152350087,
-0.0211036466,
-0.0118957134,
-0.0233453028,
0.0102009848,
0.0381058194,
0.0445845686,
0.0683104545,
-0.0453773364,
0.0697230101,
0.0291838255,
0.0344235189,
-0.0529476516,
0.0069126613,
0.0120530985,
-0.0078318967,
-0.0070102257,
0.0501159877,
0.0388678983,
0.0048242733,
0.0375153422,
0.0235541277,
0.0478451885,
0.0372580029,
0.0049805609,
-0.057056006,
-0.0234222095,
0.0119149173,
-0.0325844698,
0.0081740841,
-0.0401998349,
-0.0077697081,
-0.0934758708,
0.0044009895,
-0.0070020859,
-0.0456319116,
0.0278204139,
-0.0279164631,
0.0146333463,
0.0525070839,
-0.0174169652,
-0.0045950371,
-0.0316392779,
0.0351014324,
0.0250183661,
0.0660371631,
-0.0178597923,
-0.0107120601,
-0.0421604291,
0.0324490108,
0.0035403094,
-0.0111943781,
-0.0333087742,
-0.0302834399,
0.0848439112,
-0.0304119587,
0.0084527908,
-0.0160978865,
0.0225717779,
0.0298401862,
-0.0182024054,
-0.012524344,
0.038285289,
-0.0106522366,
-0.0391901359,
-0.0315944254,
0.0848492756,
0.0197224524,
-0.0111657055,
0.0416230857,
0.0356514454,
-0.0196170956,
0.0194488503,
0.0679706186,
-0.0467100777,
0.0103379488,
-0.0549103171,
0.0169521011,
0.0003571141,
-0.071047686,
0.0647032633,
-0.0274629984,
-0.0502967574,
-0.0969699323,
-0.0163258389,
0.0251230802,
0.0285108984,
0.0431585126,
0.0037141449,
0.0126215266,
-0.0354051441,
0.0032956479,
0.069386892,
-0.0159323625,
-0.0269757006,
-0.0122052934,
-0.0177866872,
0.0240911189,
-0.041626785,
-0.0298128854,
-0.053900227,
0.004602687,
-0.0581092536,
0.0066558179,
0.0286088698,
0.0173685178,
0.0270440076,
0.0189740099,
-0.0098150866,
0.011439031,
0.0520666316,
0.0010456927,
0.0311048739,
-0.0021631082,
-0.0393551104,
0.0235246867,
0.0256786868,
-0.0212622434,
0.0305859931,
0.0211017504,
-0.0035892101,
-0.0159563459,
0.035928119,
0.0857795477,
-0.0024732149,
0.1027351767,
-0.0215766579,
0.0004533819,
-0.0417717956,
-0.0360892713,
0.0072769551,
-0.0030247881,
-0.0172795579,
-0.0036287704,
0.0264664125,
0.0491839051,
0.0249875952,
0.0036737029,
0.0024650546,
0.0740154833,
-0.0015499715,
-0.0309852846,
0.0415463857,
0.0258248746,
0.0004586456,
0.058650896,
0.00546963,
0.0024051315,
-0.052428782,
0.0282484591,
-0.0190487988,
0.0256309919,
0.038344074,
-0.0266568158,
-0.0229709391,
-0.0099568125,
-0.0250106342,
0.0154115418,
0.011385628,
0.0027055244,
0.0593586452,
-0.0734410957,
0.0163214393,
-0.0592556968,
0.0297833104,
0.0229995903,
0.0106953643,
-0.0003891276,
-0.068772763,
0.0667354092,
0.0143445907,
-0.0028780859,
-0.0053527341,
0.0570963398,
0.0035811451,
0.0700190887,
-0.0112376139,
0.0244662818,
-0.0117549635,
-0.0194617715,
0.0102756117,
0.0012957947,
0.0134714199,
0.0829792768,
-0.0370797552,
-0.0626673922,
-0.0759077743,
0.0302213114,
0.007782293,
-0.0143535072,
0.0507220067,
0.0410445295,
-0.0086923521,
0.0049361619,
-0.0225341339,
0.0463686362,
0.0159474611,
0.0179803204,
-0.0096384706,
-5.83184641e-33,
-0.01874559,
-0.0256645586,
-0.0026721968,
0.0852917582,
0.0030058392,
0.0016790516,
-0.0067718388,
0.0372655503,
-0.031431593,
0.0387115702,
0.0280158464,
0.0094880797,
-0.0027792056,
0.0092632538,
0.0070250235,
0.0125194676,
-0.0278050173,
-0.0325156115,
-0.0090903873,
-0.0453286171,
-0.00533253,
-0.0064671016,
0.0707014948,
-0.0564673841,
-0.0076394319,
0.0372424535,
0.0141179739,
0.0359616987,
-0.0356708989,
0.0412666202,
0.0003636719,
0.0586887412,
0.0301080123,
-0.0109559949,
0.0014010443,
0.0435093604,
-0.0527109727,
-0.0586962551,
0.0532206595,
0.0275755394,
-0.1002163067,
-0.000980402,
0.0342268385,
-0.0224336088,
-0.0090027824,
0.0071513066,
0.0281520132,
-0.0102674626,
-0.0039675888,
0.0297440309,
-0.0688319877,
-0.0307156108,
0.0303967204,
-0.0411790796,
0.040150661,
0.0218335334,
0.0128497966,
-0.0275630765,
0.0044182139,
0.0330523886,
-0.0120027857,
0.0595068075,
0.0566962846,
0.0251785479,
0.0136861736,
0.0666160062,
-0.0031789066,
-0.023275312,
-0.0147953732,
0.006020328,
0.0400387794,
0.0215928089,
-0.0060005346,
0.0472069345,
0.0309207346,
0.0017184317,
-0.0667059943,
-0.0144261615,
0.0440053903,
0.0366462246,
-0.022337418,
-0.0164573919,
0.014691473,
-0.0206476804,
-0.0543709174,
0.0155509934,
-0.0307169631,
-0.0088032205,
0.0243348535,
0.0093109086,
-0.0107212747,
0.0155574987,
-0.0296493731,
-0.0078193909,
-0.0241471045,
-0.0259539988,
-0.0168011282,
0.0202527717,
-0.0026159668,
0.0264901631,
-0.000757304,
-0.0622857586,
0.0256461836,
0.0050702989,
0.048981823,
0.0610873848,
0.0788302943,
-0.0108305356,
-0.007171256,
-0.0083675859,
-0.0367639288,
-0.0379197933,
0.0577376746,
-0.0513080135,
0.0554900467,
0.0349907167,
-0.0459340848,
-0.0053856107,
0.0471954681,
0.0137745561,
-0.0349155255,
-0.0275318455,
-0.0594314411,
0.0493228771,
-0.0303878803,
-0.0410003439,
-0.033254914,
-0.0096033104,
0.0406099446,
-0.0561813936,
-0.0296864267,
-0.0021674542,
2.516e-7,
0.0400424674,
0.0707319155,
0.0096409703,
-0.0112000424,
0.0222998038,
0.036001686,
-0.0124797272,
-0.0178896505,
0.0042163474,
-0.0700156689,
-0.0876509547,
0.0220847558,
0.0035971452,
0.0012239737,
-0.0188691448,
-0.0130985947,
0.0097936159,
0.0519235134,
-0.0223878305,
0.0141864792,
0.0740080327,
0.047389742,
-0.007121033,
-0.0333946869,
-0.0130234482,
-0.0459017009,
0.063402757,
-0.0230352953,
0.0048852907,
-0.0221865028,
-0.0371469446,
-0.0051101604,
-0.0092996769,
0.0579298474,
-0.0025787337,
-0.0017491196,
-0.004921875,
-0.0373132713,
-0.018193135,
0.0422415324,
-0.0061223307,
0.0043922598,
-0.028608175,
-0.0384259969,
0.0465946607,
-0.0816659629,
-0.0208979398,
0.0128731178,
-0.0119776465,
0.0051488904,
-0.0017541097,
0.0128813516,
-0.0381723978,
-0.0164466575,
0.0253882743,
-0.0031300066,
-0.014405095,
-0.0276746005,
-0.0371129923,
0.0659256279,
-0.0102620991,
-0.0039714207,
-0.007054029,
-0.0386542529,
0.0346969813,
-0.0404467359,
-0.0228880625,
1.880696026e-34,
-0.0264209844,
-0.0163074061,
0.1089275777,
0.003891614,
0.000890774,
-0.0280343983,
-0.0115034757,
0.0371949263,
0.0359262265,
-0.0432662517,
-0.0022414231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11839v1 | mDPO: Conditional Preference Optimization for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:59:58 | 2024-06-17T17:59:58 | Fei Wang, Wenxuan Zhou, James Y. Huang, Nan Xu, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Direct preference optimization (DPO) has shown to be an effective method for
large language model (LLM) alignment. Recent works have attempted to apply DPO
to multimodal scenarios but have found it challenging to achieve consistent
improvement. Through a comparative experiment, we identify the unconditional
preference problem in multimodal preference optimization, where the model
overlooks the image condition. To address this problem, we propose mDPO, a
multimodal DPO objective that prevents the over-prioritization of language-only
preferences by also optimizing image preference. Moreover, we introduce a
reward anchor that forces the reward to be positive for chosen responses,
thereby avoiding the decrease in their likelihood -- an intrinsic problem of
relative preference optimization. Experiments on two multimodal LLMs of
different sizes and three widely used benchmarks demonstrate that mDPO
effectively addresses the unconditional preference problem in multimodal
preference optimization and significantly improves model performance,
particularly in reducing hallucination. | [
0.016530538,
0.0725470185,
0.0123729911,
0.0386307202,
-0.0335765518,
0.0126529401,
0.007362044,
-0.0214799065,
-0.01896891,
-0.0386503749,
-0.0700138509,
-0.063383311,
0.000704702,
-0.0330196768,
0.0325407162,
-0.0734978244,
0.0347432382,
-0.0545106195,
-0.0257295053,
-0.0310418028,
0.0406114496,
0.0099819489,
-0.0136595378,
0.0242304932,
0.0036353997,
-0.0371482335,
0.01651836,
0.0063916668,
0.03362244,
-0.0173770394,
-0.0055028726,
0.0549318679,
0.0143826762,
0.0036188769,
0.0000020988,
-0.0523985922,
-0.028284058,
-0.0222535692,
0.0220403187,
-0.00647187,
0.0587904193,
0.0155070499,
0.0055990485,
-0.0106482944,
-0.0109830219,
0.0057707969,
0.0921618193,
0.0419624187,
0.0290178619,
0.0332234427,
-0.000125685,
-0.0538485236,
-0.0059554917,
-0.0162208974,
0.0308527891,
-0.0041147484,
0.0267709754,
0.0137959961,
-0.0306024067,
-0.0110000316,
-0.0457158908,
0.029624451,
-0.0192593746,
0.0261825193,
0.0447170362,
0.0282390434,
-0.0089719873,
-0.0464113094,
-0.0168331191,
0.0838767216,
-0.0146106444,
-0.0075115496,
-0.0260706469,
-0.0221291184,
0.0004857498,
0.0132514955,
-0.0328141563,
0.0133724352,
0.025060799,
0.0294311084,
0.009338174,
0.0114540439,
0.0156258661,
0.0164834838,
-0.0349592716,
0.0689427406,
0.0448054709,
-0.022704171,
0.0184188299,
0.0045798016,
-0.0651878044,
-0.0587352477,
0.0132851917,
-0.0185989607,
-0.0393542573,
0.0165609177,
-0.0305328853,
0.0045286268,
0.0137120057,
-0.0540309288,
0.0421489626,
0.0406795591,
-0.0316626355,
0.0460801199,
0.0091592483,
0.0475720465,
-0.0577997267,
0.0420223996,
-0.0475784466,
0.0048329723,
0.0158011205,
-0.0044135149,
0.0223128852,
-0.0057589812,
-0.0081181573,
-0.0514850803,
-0.0471427776,
0.0211432856,
-0.0177967511,
0.0284536928,
-0.0099476827,
0.028304249,
-0.0285311583,
-0.0212298986,
-0.0371186361,
0.0925777107,
-0.0073811682,
0.0019855374,
0.0029660386,
0.0202338211,
0.0341330357,
0.0523030646,
-0.0183724612,
-0.0581054688,
-0.0160318967,
0.0785562769,
-0.0034530119,
0.0113995522,
0.0249062739,
0.0031446095,
-0.0507452451,
-0.0673318729,
0.0225142296,
-0.0556250811,
0.0321245305,
0.0177664012,
0.015004307,
-0.025738325,
0.0036999627,
-0.0144909173,
-0.0094921449,
0.0770023093,
0.0498145185,
0.0025748287,
-0.0037590151,
-0.0054167695,
-0.0163306426,
0.0865927339,
0.014599219,
0.065724358,
0.0371143892,
-0.0309016798,
-0.0214203801,
0.0782633871,
-0.0196872819,
0.0161044355,
-0.0605953671,
0.0268000588,
0.0609958321,
0.0522800945,
0.0615312569,
0.0167318042,
-0.0203730464,
-0.0237653535,
0.1004166082,
0.0065081026,
0.0140962731,
-0.0511114709,
-0.048370067,
0.0013322431,
-0.0373315625,
0.0396232642,
-0.065360859,
0.0780277997,
-0.0267836824,
0.0304404348,
0.0733511299,
0.0608651377,
-0.0033878956,
0.0054320744,
-0.0104059894,
-0.0000828554,
-0.019576434,
0.0758228898,
0.0221259166,
-0.0458231941,
-0.0575709306,
0.0251527056,
0.0437389798,
-0.0290555991,
0.0073224776,
-0.0130069694,
0.0367379226,
0.0572634265,
0.0340772048,
-0.0039459099,
-0.0269997641,
-0.005033243,
-0.0003986715,
0.0838150308,
0.0290550217,
-0.0042883684,
0.0076520252,
-0.0566283241,
-0.0514855422,
0.024092542,
-0.0090560289,
-0.0023318005,
-0.0032550388,
-0.0116574811,
-0.0404372588,
0.0204411224,
0.0078787506,
0.0084406687,
0.0478958972,
0.0088100806,
-0.0383407623,
0.0214941297,
0.0549906716,
-0.0209288243,
-0.0042402046,
-0.0080485083,
-0.0139307184,
-0.0114803379,
0.0115750516,
-0.0029882288,
-0.062470641,
-0.0313613899,
0.0498796105,
-0.0437876172,
-0.0486849323,
0.0296508577,
-0.0216437988,
0.0001323792,
-0.0144845108,
0.0063584102,
0.0416019261,
-0.0131134642,
0.042784065,
-0.015454107,
0.0083877826,
-0.0858851671,
0.0535340346,
-0.0151565922,
0.0164442658,
0.022412641,
-0.0098818783,
-0.0079761464,
-0.0394258499,
-0.0344978273,
0.0577482432,
0.0243740045,
0.0218572542,
0.015396866,
-0.0005963647,
-0.0548324436,
-0.0321694091,
-0.0692598969,
0.0173231084,
-0.002048119,
-0.0082159601,
0.0225947537,
0.0052612186,
0.0027621109,
-0.0100612799,
-0.0461901277,
0.0332075581,
-0.0117661767,
0.0363021865,
-0.0015512442,
-0.015198946,
0.0055461898,
-0.0435554571,
-0.0126570351,
0.0073407651,
0.0270732138,
-0.0312986299,
0.0144116729,
-0.041980654,
0.035080906,
-0.0727658346,
0.0096055986,
0.00223819,
-0.0216528904,
0.005111333,
-0.0148381386,
0.0608322211,
0.0764084682,
0.0172101818,
-0.0345151424,
0.082468316,
-0.0099210395,
-0.0688776076,
-0.0327576622,
-0.0194628518,
-0.0040420508,
-0.0110902181,
-0.0382221341,
-0.0334291607,
0.0568837263,
0.020728739,
0.0020722349,
-0.0545209423,
0.0130653372,
-0.0156591479,
-0.0164610222,
-0.0414751209,
0.0177293513,
-0.031588804,
0.0493040718,
-0.0409754328,
-0.0509580225,
0.0760703459,
-0.0260986127,
-0.0113534024,
-0.0342668407,
0.0442324504,
-0.0125054531,
0.0013678321,
0.0258056633,
0.0460855179,
-0.0144091155,
0.0175255518,
-0.0947759002,
-0.0339786448,
0.0335199088,
-0.0263554305,
0.0696122795,
-0.0088935466,
-0.0062570274,
-0.0315360688,
-0.0558707751,
-0.0300605539,
-0.0467915758,
-0.0086195925,
-0.0483440422,
-0.0206786618,
0.0050039985,
-0.0340710208,
0.0193387698,
0.0498364083,
-0.0156826284,
-0.0166103002,
-0.0049343677,
-0.0289925318,
0.033343982,
0.1205836684,
0.0186948441,
-0.0025098857,
-0.0484482832,
-0.0283270776,
0.0411231741,
0.0461238772,
0.0119546736,
-0.0276552849,
0.0327043012,
0.074498117,
0.0084277978,
-0.0073708268,
0.0159049053,
0.0606591254,
-0.003616242,
0.0629044995,
0.0780214071,
0.0166269708,
-0.0888924673,
-0.0239080209,
-0.0206316747,
0.0761067942,
0.0034414493,
0.0185254905,
-0.0556987897,
-0.0466310419,
-0.0081954235,
-0.0166873224,
0.023224663,
0.0315219387,
0.0139686679,
-0.1082108468,
0.0097134849,
0.0348464996,
-0.0172358863,
0.0127449017,
-0.0277096163,
0.0269444976,
-0.0305982064,
0.0339579359,
0.0100914538,
-0.0057208277,
-0.0228657424,
-0.0096685486,
0.0318065621,
-0.0156355388,
0.0137387849,
-0.0596798435,
0.0401641205,
0.0849801302,
0.0211498607,
0.0072501902,
-0.0535147712,
0.0232413914,
0.0419178568,
-0.0408951938,
-0.0074471561,
-0.0101577751,
-0.0077415099,
-0.0063671959,
-0.0351038463,
0.0232938807,
0.0148053728,
-0.0175076909,
-0.0057439157,
0.0672421455,
0.0042736749,
0.0080329981,
-0.0261286646,
0.0187320076,
-0.006542312,
0.0453018211,
0.007863421,
-0.0785402656,
-0.0091519626,
-0.0293930937,
-0.0070838071,
-0.0357760713,
-0.0258737896,
0.0076607061,
0.00158542,
0.0126073565,
-0.0599452369,
-0.0073865801,
-0.0076813782,
0.0143939974,
0.0245760772,
0.0136853792,
-0.0264695063,
-0.0293590948,
-0.0053391182,
0.0689846352,
-0.0371748246,
0.0139152687,
-0.0482998639,
-0.0030386297,
0.0192831904,
-0.0371218845,
0.0000262996,
0.0203581993,
-0.0450708754,
-0.0723742619,
-0.0244245641,
0.0456507355,
0.0139181018,
0.0477318689,
0.038425412,
-0.0789891258,
0.0179851651,
0.005025845,
0.0299874973,
0.0155423479,
-0.0087646348,
0.0126660466,
-0.009499047,
0.0313343816,
-0.0284087192,
-0.0186247434,
0.0275420919,
0.0328053162,
0.0137025109,
-0.0114570642,
0.0219065696,
-0.0056314101,
0.0200514141,
-0.0465579182,
-0.0076095313,
-0.0447470918,
-0.0078851283,
-0.0137684243,
-0.0387984402,
-0.0148377595,
-0.0372962989,
0.0536291748,
-0.0074376781,
0.0219473671,
-0.0236627217,
-0.0182113163,
-0.0076242737,
-0.0401725993,
0.0266049001,
0.0146916127,
-0.0277685989,
0.0381669216,
0.0418767743,
-0.0121501144,
0.0254806355,
0.0004645002,
0.0334536321,
-0.0002860904,
0.0809246451,
0.0177576523,
-0.0329763442,
-0.01593359,
0.037559472,
0.0257157329,
-0.0319521837,
-0.033837527,
-0.0135416603,
0.0723078027,
-0.0185880158,
0.0798918381,
0.0066041844,
-0.0170804802,
-0.0185484532,
0.042103529,
-0.0133835515,
-0.0349997878,
0.0430987068,
0.012391679,
-0.0082082665,
0.0299193282,
0.0500824228,
-0.0103330165,
0.0026195596,
-0.0319193602,
0.0096634561,
-0.0176215116,
-0.0244007856,
0.0234852061,
0.0164834764,
-0.0592063628,
-0.0039429702,
-0.0426620767,
-0.0583063029,
-0.0326559246,
0.0101032304,
-0.0388577916,
0.0100945411,
0.0485250838,
0.0319280587,
-0.0356551707,
-0.0286727585,
-0.0335262604,
-0.024084026,
-0.0089539764,
-0.0165748782,
-0.0088368012,
-6.696079408e-33,
-0.0206658151,
-0.0049192212,
0.021974422,
-0.062684387,
-0.0392250195,
-0.0365076959,
0.0003124989,
0.0367075205,
0.0085783107,
-0.0412166305,
0.008104274,
-0.0459048785,
0.0127867432,
0.0234064981,
0.0166277271,
0.0158994049,
0.0121453637,
0.0011545763,
-0.0546658412,
-0.012461192,
0.0239254907,
-0.0218934137,
0.0348400772,
-0.0453721993,
0.0209964812,
0.0248572212,
-0.0303261746,
-0.006119418,
-0.0240448397,
0.072184138,
-0.0528785065,
0.0273024775,
-0.0092893895,
-0.0218468159,
-0.0360550061,
0.0244399514,
0.0042638099,
0.0069156792,
0.0472170301,
0.0440157056,
-0.0219831243,
-0.0373084918,
0.0407622531,
0.000164961,
-0.0366851129,
-0.0180924069,
0.0420319587,
-0.0207441319,
-0.038356144,
0.0736562908,
-0.0716435164,
0.0029615331,
-0.0160123799,
0.0027243383,
0.039374359,
0.0613333993,
0.0078229606,
0.0674167126,
-0.0518527217,
0.0603749305,
-0.0144992461,
0.0163388774,
0.0983141437,
0.0484542213,
0.0247308407,
0.0601652376,
0.0556987189,
-0.0532625392,
0.0502598397,
-0.0467886962,
0.0167841669,
0.019046668,
0.0221339986,
0.0550880469,
0.0315332077,
0.0234253928,
-0.0132130235,
0.0127870189,
-0.0339786522,
-0.0114582172,
0.0738808438,
0.070795767,
-0.0109634381,
-0.007973955,
-0.0350651518,
-0.0042636273,
-0.0572576113,
-0.0368986204,
0.0386476852,
-0.001495035,
-0.0163097009,
0.0087790834,
0.0967028365,
-0.0438394099,
-0.047002174,
-0.0012308031,
-0.0332130492,
0.064261958,
0.0045857038,
0.0065466729,
-0.0442404449,
-0.0061278762,
0.0028413851,
-0.0406100973,
-0.0097601982,
0.0445264913,
-0.0040843245,
-0.0148230409,
-0.0426527336,
0.0164941661,
-0.0337484293,
-0.0553422347,
0.0164274666,
0.0096730841,
0.0584470741,
-0.0283111036,
-0.0203900933,
0.031310413,
0.0293826386,
-0.0120987231,
-0.0329981782,
-0.0559038594,
-0.0345960334,
0.0250530597,
-0.018116951,
0.0238573272,
-0.0304554328,
-0.0293336082,
0.002835802,
-0.0332689025,
-0.0371700488,
0.006028519,
2.684e-7,
0.0293696895,
0.0450423174,
-0.0338184349,
0.0179674849,
-0.0019313747,
0.0525986589,
-0.0118399262,
0.0058095553,
0.0399495587,
-0.0170454979,
-0.0254799277,
0.009708724,
0.0400133915,
-0.0051094065,
-0.0495851003,
0.005822029,
-0.0026503124,
0.0326212384,
-0.0481760018,
-0.0031343605,
0.0164512321,
0.1004729643,
-0.0149575388,
-0.0150485495,
0.0156163108,
0.0204605199,
0.0808363259,
-0.050703004,
-0.0303908996,
0.0119046113,
-0.0218819547,
-0.0254235603,
-0.0257792212,
-0.0117340591,
0.0189094562,
-0.0175639391,
0.0281568747,
0.047348056,
-0.0093256859,
-0.08540719,
-0.0403294563,
0.0454804339,
-0.0337759666,
-0.0897100642,
0.0680381432,
-0.048268538,
-0.0520066768,
-0.0141571499,
-0.01685239,
-0.0237597749,
0.0584339537,
-0.0360899419,
-0.018999951,
0.008481238,
0.0281911232,
0.0081807943,
-0.0680591017,
-0.0475764908,
-0.0338037945,
0.0150382528,
-0.0501239449,
-0.043132484,
-0.0167210922,
0.0248560067,
0.0048081735,
-0.0579624958,
-0.0259061847,
2.409056056e-34,
0.0234427955,
-0.0095817698,
0.0514286533,
-0.0185026005,
0.0141235907,
-0.0193503387,
-0.0099151414,
0.0230608676,
0.0118108075,
-0.0791126937,
-0.0171102546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11830v1 | Language Modeling with Editable External Knowledge | 2024-06-17T17:59:35 | 2024-06-17T17:59:35 | Belinda Z. Li, Emmy Liu, Alexis Ross, Abbas Zeitoun, Graham Neubig, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When the world changes, so does the text that humans write about it. How do
we build language models that can be easily updated to reflect these changes?
One popular approach is retrieval-augmented generation, in which new documents
are inserted into a knowledge base and retrieved during prediction for
downstream tasks. Most prior work on these systems have focused on improving
behavior during prediction through better retrieval or reasoning. This paper
introduces ERASE, which instead improves model behavior when new documents are
acquired, by incrementally deleting or rewriting other entries in the knowledge
base each time a document is added. In two new benchmark datasets evaluating
models' ability to answer questions about a stream of news articles or
conversations, ERASE improves accuracy relative to conventional
retrieval-augmented generation by 7-13% (Mixtral-8x7B) and 6-10% (Llama-3-8B)
absolute. Code and data are available at https://github.com/belindal/ERASE | [
0.0712061152,
0.0627193972,
-0.0282985847,
0.0335764848,
-0.0410654917,
-0.0195177197,
-0.035960488,
0.000763308,
0.0189502165,
-0.0513335727,
0.0145600317,
-0.0274878554,
-0.0502744876,
0.0567166954,
-0.015695747,
-0.0306361541,
0.0613866784,
-0.0167916641,
0.0348007306,
-0.0143043017,
0.0384729244,
-0.0017231912,
0.023944689,
0.009527443,
0.017990509,
-0.008602188,
-0.0436136685,
-0.0227027424,
-0.030895777,
0.0142236063,
0.0310715083,
0.0752066225,
0.0152855897,
0.0462609492,
0.0000021061,
-0.0584814139,
-0.0151108196,
-0.0182297081,
-0.0332197584,
-0.0078550298,
0.020758763,
-0.0185998771,
-0.0197925735,
0.0089598084,
-0.0411534235,
0.0093829427,
0.0161940362,
0.0370256379,
0.0835782662,
0.0905549824,
-0.0097965645,
0.0191818215,
0.031222254,
-0.0102381734,
0.0577851422,
-0.0086856047,
0.0339829251,
0.0152189238,
0.0025032079,
0.0225286148,
0.0052567055,
0.065188475,
0.0280787051,
-0.0435929224,
0.0256031808,
0.0200731624,
-0.0076490291,
-0.0193689503,
-0.0023768353,
0.0262427926,
0.0091550555,
-0.0741136,
0.0095250942,
-0.0059097758,
0.0022725889,
0.0009225513,
-0.0619311295,
0.0045334306,
-0.0162285306,
-0.0033654671,
-0.0105524231,
-0.0543929748,
0.0181762166,
0.0338838287,
0.0265656263,
0.0684349984,
0.0205396116,
-0.0264653731,
-0.035680782,
-0.008769148,
0.034035366,
-0.0876282528,
0.012329394,
0.0735515431,
-0.0299822632,
0.0285813119,
-0.058248613,
-0.0285830162,
0.0273528807,
-0.066592671,
0.0330773853,
0.0411677063,
0.0130887926,
0.061453905,
0.0001847921,
0.037468683,
0.0055455868,
-0.029870579,
-0.0343207903,
-0.0033430746,
-0.0511626638,
-0.0279240273,
-0.0391716771,
0.0457376838,
-0.0284702592,
-0.0020389804,
0.000126525,
0.0428031161,
-0.0074098138,
-0.0041116537,
-0.0053435871,
0.0114327325,
-0.0478104204,
-0.0191682503,
-0.043511048,
0.0089096576,
-0.0155830132,
0.0214192923,
0.0053513166,
-0.0391718633,
0.0067079226,
-0.0175755266,
0.0050734114,
-0.0038029843,
-0.0146306278,
0.0551760457,
-0.0285381563,
-0.0221029781,
-0.0503036752,
-0.0592184365,
0.0144203473,
-0.0631731451,
0.0003925806,
-0.0652913377,
0.0343293138,
0.0062126773,
-0.0565112829,
-0.0847168118,
-0.004199374,
0.0494289212,
-0.0275833011,
0.0394460931,
-0.0393915549,
0.0222531185,
0.0568690337,
0.0126976585,
0.0048691351,
0.1000007913,
0.0211782269,
0.0173405018,
0.0445134863,
0.0108894492,
0.0134525634,
0.0417338014,
0.0139894383,
-0.0082545886,
-0.0157768037,
0.0393083952,
-0.0191504993,
0.008213765,
0.0189779233,
0.0395911373,
-0.0273642987,
-0.0018485424,
0.0547206998,
-0.0243837237,
0.008415495,
0.0196087733,
0.0353215374,
0.0232695062,
-0.0010176806,
0.0041681961,
-0.0372889414,
0.0413633808,
-0.0251407772,
0.0096443361,
-0.0097547853,
0.002110457,
-0.0329389237,
-0.0590138808,
-0.0102197072,
0.0029219086,
0.02886484,
0.0011716698,
0.0480743907,
0.0349802859,
-0.0133291362,
0.0671399534,
0.0171819199,
-0.0749099553,
-0.0104046911,
-0.0415535867,
0.0490689576,
0.0668045953,
0.0727607831,
-0.0021770173,
-0.0520407371,
0.017028911,
-0.0010247485,
0.0021920989,
0.0481660403,
-0.0364750028,
-0.0235165805,
-0.05006589,
-0.0337783694,
-0.0106314104,
0.0218327567,
0.0164411776,
0.0680443645,
0.0000464391,
0.0320356004,
-0.0313878842,
-0.0226805359,
0.0248727743,
-0.0715131536,
-0.0155173428,
-0.0364138782,
-0.0180560276,
-0.0107111456,
0.0086376145,
0.0139727928,
0.0137064261,
0.0635357276,
-0.009396337,
-0.0502864718,
-0.0022389686,
-0.0098716738,
0.0039113606,
0.0455854535,
0.0254172608,
0.0208957773,
0.0311755091,
-0.0270947274,
-0.0586468317,
0.0152256368,
-0.0491623618,
0.0620276891,
-0.0734357536,
-0.009011318,
-0.0198034979,
-0.0230870731,
0.0033541427,
0.059364967,
-0.0093500772,
0.0145260366,
0.0225074124,
-0.0202011671,
0.0204963498,
-0.0494999103,
-0.0394461378,
0.004276704,
-0.0125207696,
0.0388368033,
0.0589328408,
-0.0063663493,
-0.0574544109,
-0.0268953778,
-0.0811071098,
0.0213623289,
-0.020680787,
0.0055199605,
0.0308251046,
0.0286751781,
-0.0068876971,
-0.0413205996,
-0.0066600749,
0.015016621,
0.0445472486,
0.0451076068,
0.0080443034,
0.0376647301,
0.009185167,
-0.0313658305,
0.0035977312,
0.0232072789,
0.0203702971,
-0.0018353433,
-0.0311737526,
-0.054266911,
0.0162909217,
-0.0873837546,
0.0413538143,
-0.0202391446,
-0.0081160674,
-0.0181451309,
-0.0247453228,
0.0267961007,
0.0211468413,
0.001194492,
0.0194559637,
0.0498323962,
-0.0125055183,
-0.0553628094,
0.0286228117,
-0.002334629,
-0.0201826468,
-0.0154710133,
0.0023091098,
-0.0133374864,
0.0642829165,
-0.0175119471,
-0.0331096463,
-0.0259505138,
0.0521812476,
-0.0186889265,
-0.0307351779,
-0.039730899,
-0.04839129,
-0.031226702,
0.0458682142,
-0.0372888148,
-0.0453844592,
0.0712908953,
-0.0039862893,
0.0258582551,
-0.0644254982,
0.0004508656,
-0.0265285615,
0.0641665235,
0.0095042037,
0.0048958855,
-0.004396738,
0.0144480523,
-0.0690951347,
-0.0227286573,
0.0212097671,
-0.0512716696,
0.0468511134,
-0.0679369569,
0.0403642356,
0.0215113275,
-0.0296456832,
-0.0602663904,
-0.0190928951,
-0.0292968545,
0.0056013134,
-0.0048426241,
0.0077863657,
-0.0454956368,
-0.008384618,
0.063045457,
0.0541871451,
-0.0113283545,
0.0115064271,
-0.0063263327,
0.0171448588,
0.0803659931,
-0.0093564,
-0.0377324708,
-0.0167998392,
0.0261724442,
0.0818889439,
0.0536378957,
-0.0271716155,
-0.0145898294,
-0.0150919911,
0.0017001235,
-0.0401396751,
-0.0344425328,
-0.0060259732,
0.0231426917,
-0.0765436813,
-0.0362124927,
0.1126641035,
0.0495456755,
-0.0266967826,
-0.0187787637,
-0.0277294107,
0.023169823,
0.034013886,
0.0629650578,
-0.057945963,
-0.0175079443,
0.0440093018,
0.0242300462,
0.016137775,
-0.0335964262,
-0.0345820338,
-0.1022243127,
0.0099799028,
-0.021633774,
-0.0179929212,
0.017540535,
-0.0565056354,
0.0072830729,
0.0093581164,
-0.026495263,
0.0374952815,
0.0246277247,
0.0330575109,
-0.0049249893,
-0.0287638493,
-0.0352139175,
-0.0004225986,
0.0020909074,
0.0235560033,
0.0559321977,
0.0520764925,
0.0143862832,
-0.0061904117,
0.0282204524,
-0.010066174,
0.0066311345,
-0.004253916,
0.047648713,
0.0228898246,
0.019459201,
-0.0252556577,
0.0151456119,
0.0087555079,
-0.0378956124,
0.0149762658,
0.0759669766,
-0.0199478604,
-0.0182957631,
-0.0375329927,
-0.0155484891,
0.0362771936,
0.0802675039,
0.0190729722,
-0.0288960226,
-0.0138056837,
-0.0371937901,
-0.0116233462,
-0.0143090561,
-0.014533476,
-0.0104963602,
-0.0322278365,
0.0131752044,
-0.090913035,
-0.0732089728,
0.0065813581,
-0.003102551,
0.0248186737,
0.0262895059,
0.0353749506,
-0.0365221649,
-0.056480702,
-0.0078090313,
-0.0314889848,
-0.0089504011,
-0.0014743248,
-0.0108905965,
0.0140413856,
-0.0339639783,
-0.0257576648,
0.0374427997,
-0.070617035,
-0.0653572381,
0.0164007377,
0.0398537666,
0.0360804796,
0.0651822239,
-0.0058558933,
-0.063233912,
0.03563454,
0.0168150626,
-0.0431150608,
0.0318700224,
-0.0172320437,
-0.0200527664,
-0.0085045388,
0.052899383,
-0.0737167448,
0.0164629128,
-0.0162550956,
0.0302136391,
-0.0075062905,
-0.0172855183,
0.0055530793,
0.0203958135,
0.0140104638,
0.0336528979,
-0.0231669396,
-0.0285659488,
0.0293738637,
-0.0315215699,
-0.0337242447,
-0.019582551,
0.0287010595,
-0.014591719,
0.0138800824,
-0.0141412588,
0.0332353003,
-0.0220052581,
0.0326645896,
-0.0136484988,
-0.0480037294,
0.0318117179,
0.0175628513,
0.0511530116,
0.0031195164,
-0.0234388448,
0.0368946865,
-0.0006671906,
0.0250374153,
-0.0287390184,
0.0249625668,
0.0285442416,
-0.0078966105,
-0.0019089449,
-0.0067138574,
-0.1016702056,
-0.0693843588,
-0.0289353672,
0.0292799324,
0.0170068126,
-0.0113383634,
0.0597869866,
-0.0353442729,
-0.0239020959,
-0.0406922661,
0.0253004339,
0.0337544419,
-0.0792093948,
0.0162030365,
0.020454688,
-0.0237938892,
0.0301267654,
0.0826908723,
-0.0175283663,
0.0982604325,
-0.0160426386,
-0.0239954758,
-0.0636352748,
-0.0052613174,
-0.000257606,
0.0294666979,
-0.0244129226,
-0.0067072739,
-0.0442915559,
-0.0605974682,
0.0314686075,
0.0260062087,
-0.0148209026,
-0.0186068937,
0.0374205187,
0.0808594301,
0.0094088586,
-0.0112071848,
-0.0319978967,
0.0146394745,
-0.0989455357,
-0.0329908468,
-0.0227263365,
-6.100823028e-33,
-0.0182887781,
0.004943267,
0.0637405962,
-0.0247719772,
-0.01093842,
0.0077006952,
-0.0696589574,
-0.0201221481,
-0.0154970353,
0.0078721372,
-0.0307432469,
0.0278890058,
-0.0016079266,
0.0175517835,
0.0071628569,
0.0122717824,
0.0529904291,
-0.0293986965,
-0.0168678034,
0.0343628712,
0.0659831762,
0.0567177646,
0.0573974177,
-0.0238739811,
0.0426828191,
-0.0190813132,
-0.0135715231,
0.0462349914,
-0.0138202468,
0.0718920901,
-0.0335346162,
0.0430784672,
0.0162389316,
-0.0047744019,
-0.049830012,
0.0065357885,
-0.0411177352,
-0.0380228609,
0.0114556532,
0.0082240943,
-0.0308470335,
-0.0129064787,
0.0315435976,
-0.0261235889,
-0.0009055698,
0.0268601645,
0.0424056537,
-0.0295085218,
-0.0209411066,
0.0177850742,
-0.0447523072,
0.0059031066,
0.0102586839,
-0.0337260701,
-0.0173567981,
0.0318266787,
0.0250659026,
-0.0356311277,
-0.0769026726,
0.0273391306,
0.022982128,
0.0630449876,
0.0559436344,
-0.0224473085,
-0.0056351181,
0.0423328802,
0.0045061032,
0.0055325059,
0.0012572875,
-0.0104652662,
0.0471983626,
0.0276213903,
0.0346068293,
0.0606501661,
0.0403021872,
0.0046541323,
-0.0302132629,
0.0349192359,
-0.0013032421,
0.0810402334,
0.0041623274,
0.0324558243,
-0.0184995923,
-0.023401428,
-0.0658152699,
0.0133445701,
-0.0371132381,
-0.0562203638,
0.0371316671,
0.0258120764,
-0.0170922112,
-0.0295622498,
0.0144952126,
-0.0403470397,
-0.0338386036,
0.0659319684,
-0.0507610328,
0.0004324579,
0.0125198048,
0.0440863967,
-0.0489936806,
0.0128813088,
0.0109122247,
0.0070988466,
-0.0329872742,
0.022208944,
0.0275341347,
0.038797114,
-0.064852044,
0.0191850029,
-0.0518550836,
0.0532145202,
-0.0000487406,
-0.0009266534,
0.0104597183,
0.0196122564,
-0.0039022693,
0.0506695025,
0.0549921282,
0.0082261749,
-0.045549944,
-0.0319066383,
0.0226523969,
0.0144666359,
-0.0192791503,
-0.0006140004,
-0.0350880697,
0.0430795997,
0.0053632096,
-0.0408190116,
0.0159872528,
0.0344970077,
2.819e-7,
0.0379268602,
0.0323881507,
0.017223604,
0.0331513509,
0.0233034398,
0.0230171625,
-0.0400219709,
0.0221248996,
0.0210800283,
-0.0029901408,
-0.0285302885,
0.0173807777,
0.025494311,
0.0328888781,
-0.1146142408,
-0.005526898,
-0.073448576,
-0.0097792177,
-0.0520180762,
-0.0314656682,
0.0135423969,
0.0548560359,
0.0222292468,
-0.0099968566,
-0.0357121564,
-0.0456238911,
0.0613931119,
-0.0191869885,
-0.0292654335,
0.0126528824,
0.0683141425,
0.044431407,
0.0030760684,
-0.0035218592,
-0.0537593737,
-0.00305624,
-0.0152292084,
0.029099144,
-0.0033422336,
-0.0018181499,
0.0109612411,
0.0061627515,
-0.0054562297,
-0.0530459359,
0.0975925922,
-0.0124748256,
0.0164067727,
-0.0311230645,
-0.0361628681,
-0.0126532065,
-0.0229078885,
-0.0174431894,
-0.0230793152,
0.0122750718,
0.0043140738,
0.0229811706,
-0.0075801904,
-0.0539636016,
-0.0392742679,
-0.0269550085,
-0.037327189,
-0.038645532,
-0.0735997409,
0.0000288204,
0.0006507451,
-0.0907452628,
0.0356840789,
2.401737686e-34,
0.0242394693,
0.0212394223,
-0.0013112344,
0.0042616511,
0.034074232,
-0.0066121873,
0.0233172402,
0.0249730423,
0.0193796065,
-0.0717642531,
-0.0367770419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11827v1 | WPO: Enhancing RLHF with Weighted Preference Optimization | 2024-06-17T17:59:13 | 2024-06-17T17:59:13 | Wenxuan Zhou, Ravi Agrawal, Shujian Zhang, Sathish Reddy Indurthi, Sanqiang Zhao, Kaiqiang Song, Silei Xu, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a promising solution to
align large language models (LLMs) more closely with human values. Off-policy
preference optimization, where the preference data is obtained from other
models, is widely adopted due to its cost efficiency and scalability. However,
off-policy preference optimization often suffers from a distributional gap
between the policy used for data collection and the target policy, leading to
suboptimal optimization. In this paper, we propose a novel strategy to mitigate
this problem by simulating on-policy learning with off-policy preference data.
Our Weighted Preference Optimization (WPO) method adapts off-policy data to
resemble on-policy data more closely by reweighting preference pairs according
to their probability under the current policy. This method not only addresses
the distributional gap problem but also enhances the optimization process
without incurring additional costs. We validate our method on instruction
following benchmarks including Alpaca Eval 2 and MT-bench. WPO not only
outperforms Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) by up to 5.6% on Alpaca Eval 2
but also establishes a remarkable length-controlled winning rate against
GPT-4-turbo of 48.6% based on Llama-3-8B-Instruct, making it the strongest 8B
model on the leaderboard. We will release the code and models at
https://github.com/wzhouad/WPO. | [
0.0228509866,
0.0839348286,
-0.0106624477,
0.0221990943,
-0.0172530711,
-0.0142353754,
-0.0616198778,
-0.0007997139,
-0.0311843567,
-0.0153459357,
-0.0466997549,
-0.0638906807,
0.006034499,
-0.0054804012,
0.0034604263,
-0.0602580234,
0.0095951753,
-0.0575578809,
0.0170191675,
-0.0141896643,
0.0015104441,
0.0046676616,
-0.0119437268,
0.0469350927,
0.0426772721,
0.0126828626,
-0.0217298735,
0.0175867919,
0.0345517881,
-0.0451481305,
0.0311824493,
0.0395034961,
0.0327333994,
0.0198046342,
0.0000023381,
-0.0353000909,
-0.0424306691,
-0.01402847,
0.004861027,
0.0176902581,
0.0546447784,
0.041811727,
-0.0692359582,
0.0467563793,
-0.0146022588,
0.0314161703,
0.0594085269,
-0.0116742384,
0.0420368947,
0.0745214373,
0.0284502916,
-0.0248731393,
0.0149550624,
-0.0328863002,
0.0281604547,
-0.0419873632,
0.0142537793,
-0.0188658834,
0.0289364699,
-0.0179213379,
-0.0425364636,
-0.0232246537,
0.0164735112,
0.0092589092,
-0.0334511623,
0.0283158887,
-0.0233722664,
0.01188266,
-0.0086330483,
0.0910502076,
-0.0577977709,
-0.0398946665,
0.0221678633,
-0.0239085611,
-0.0102989683,
-0.0340993665,
-0.0112830456,
0.0430219024,
-0.000790105,
0.0570170172,
0.03370497,
0.0100932326,
0.025139831,
0.011156735,
-0.0251605157,
0.0973544717,
0.0111193387,
-0.0413512029,
-0.0004681263,
0.0010129358,
-0.0151531436,
-0.0551042669,
-0.0070196646,
0.0129744085,
-0.0745246336,
0.0415474288,
-0.0396064781,
0.015708046,
0.0139665715,
-0.0531089194,
0.0666572973,
0.0626337901,
0.006550476,
0.0066835871,
-0.0116681829,
0.0633381531,
-0.0320811942,
0.0102044819,
-0.0430259407,
0.0597611666,
-0.0344796702,
0.0035815809,
-0.005519209,
0.0357247852,
-0.031237226,
-0.0169848613,
-0.0666060001,
0.002639987,
-0.02055889,
0.0400068983,
0.0300934147,
0.0108177941,
-0.0496890508,
0.0196701642,
-0.0730002001,
0.0555785112,
-0.0195477586,
-0.0193249881,
0.010399404,
-0.0208075158,
0.0272965226,
-0.0031682199,
-0.0521812849,
-0.039742969,
0.0260470081,
0.0802578256,
-0.0108242622,
-0.0161958076,
0.0111802863,
-0.003604339,
-0.0022139174,
-0.0741450936,
0.0033297893,
-0.0674012303,
0.00061046,
-0.038471017,
-0.0052639865,
-0.0142336292,
0.0276865736,
0.0305324104,
-0.0047823437,
0.0592886582,
0.0299913511,
-0.007926167,
-0.0245155841,
-0.0241707787,
-0.0054954044,
0.0850527585,
0.0371975079,
0.0519072711,
-0.0021659911,
-0.0004561673,
-0.0007045553,
0.0352598242,
0.036531806,
0.0103531545,
-0.0358203575,
-0.0085501764,
-0.0010658761,
0.0437075533,
0.0793238431,
0.0394539163,
-0.026033178,
-0.0128467362,
0.0546537004,
0.0170302931,
0.0092595248,
-0.0215324201,
0.0065624882,
0.0365521125,
-0.0126936641,
0.0094263237,
-0.0511364974,
0.0421780869,
-0.0189744327,
0.043004889,
0.0261095129,
0.0504695922,
0.0057859803,
-0.0563519113,
0.0111881038,
-0.0096212495,
-0.0104966182,
0.0421887524,
0.0547714531,
-0.0335198194,
-0.0770718977,
0.004999374,
0.064802967,
-0.0203816127,
-0.017175246,
-0.0771803632,
0.0288581289,
0.0789397508,
0.042769134,
-0.0190895367,
-0.0241877344,
-0.0123640979,
-0.0567595996,
0.0358388312,
0.0293834899,
-0.0082437396,
-0.0241616387,
-0.0448063873,
-0.0446106754,
0.0326205641,
0.0102356998,
0.0639393404,
0.0185848698,
-0.0080077928,
-0.0152730253,
0.0031439178,
-0.027817145,
0.0191784017,
0.0349354707,
-0.0475008339,
0.0077976356,
0.0068894094,
0.0537668541,
0.0001024498,
-0.0192580707,
-0.001235133,
0.013240166,
0.0136814415,
-0.0221434217,
-0.0483998619,
-0.069663547,
-0.0141122816,
0.0621224158,
-0.0079285437,
0.0234164484,
0.0445568226,
-0.0319096856,
-0.0205921289,
0.0171365365,
-0.0069608535,
0.062665686,
-0.004849894,
0.0371708721,
-0.0186337922,
-0.0012495583,
-0.0803699866,
0.0573055111,
-0.0115274787,
0.0108217727,
0.0128907757,
0.0100352457,
-0.0032616004,
-0.0662816763,
-0.0094358949,
0.0622630566,
0.0075479643,
0.0314377695,
0.0238460656,
0.0549819022,
-0.0251707528,
-0.0255566332,
-0.0324037522,
0.0214036964,
-0.0340831727,
0.0157961342,
0.0252026282,
-0.0113942241,
-0.023960555,
-0.0246621557,
-0.0060394071,
-0.0329786092,
-0.0099897273,
-0.0011634144,
0.0042364928,
0.015314782,
-0.0412131734,
-0.0599327199,
-0.0353492685,
-0.0101113748,
-0.0120342625,
-0.0403549373,
0.0439174622,
-0.0334480554,
0.0176468734,
-0.0227205902,
0.0493301377,
-0.0108170165,
-0.0559921935,
0.0250631142,
-0.0315869674,
0.0351254381,
0.0838416368,
-0.001724534,
0.0019814416,
0.0916034207,
0.0066624656,
-0.0992948636,
0.0354976356,
-0.0229902193,
-0.0490517393,
-0.045429904,
0.0051823757,
0.0043532988,
0.0780929849,
-0.0111614019,
-0.0013189978,
-0.0673483685,
-0.0311023444,
-0.0042086551,
-0.0153908534,
-0.0159232914,
0.0068179448,
-0.0671514645,
0.0198478587,
-0.0202475376,
-0.0628626868,
0.0920436606,
-0.0341781639,
0.0150681166,
-0.0965862796,
0.001822207,
-0.0195133239,
0.0059099086,
0.0309614614,
0.0233119037,
-0.0291021951,
-0.0154078761,
-0.0394111536,
-0.0333203897,
0.0181200113,
-0.0472067297,
0.0305256378,
-0.0237766001,
0.0173534192,
-0.0174317472,
-0.0492865629,
-0.0334283561,
0.0183660369,
-0.0272754282,
-0.0320939682,
0.043699652,
-0.0589879714,
0.0260388702,
-0.0016257288,
0.0274616797,
0.0378963538,
-0.0296519883,
-0.0078395028,
-0.0198239964,
0.0047777784,
0.0807640254,
-0.0356917605,
0.0002179873,
-0.0239563584,
0.0165008251,
0.0185360741,
0.1055241972,
-0.0158130452,
-0.0271782819,
0.0153444028,
0.0475758761,
-0.0473795421,
-0.0082584787,
0.075980857,
0.050515309,
-0.0474135615,
0.0193445869,
0.0896940455,
0.0307517126,
-0.03546286,
0.0179646742,
-0.0025028666,
0.09883973,
0.0052718627,
0.0749766678,
-0.057995446,
-0.008732398,
0.0155561594,
0.0532273762,
-0.0112374667,
-0.0167526472,
0.0140237929,
-0.1549217701,
-0.0013832202,
-0.0010857638,
-0.0315603279,
-0.0046775416,
-0.0404554978,
0.0044993656,
-0.0384839885,
0.0349986851,
0.0181988962,
0.0012001797,
0.0092385393,
0.0191973764,
0.0126035307,
-0.0086393524,
0.0193540771,
-0.0205264278,
0.0536794215,
0.1056684181,
0.0052089579,
0.0060858927,
-0.0418287627,
0.0062489673,
0.0164806601,
-0.0317653827,
-0.0172695722,
0.0073391465,
-0.0099761421,
-0.0173144806,
-0.0196612012,
0.0362090655,
0.0048502116,
0.0079691643,
0.0075896461,
0.065792881,
0.0109868441,
-0.0092329644,
-0.0073885354,
-0.0185229369,
0.0307090692,
0.0425296612,
-0.0039334134,
-0.0732870623,
-0.0341360271,
-0.0480659232,
-0.04136163,
-0.0840318277,
-0.0394706987,
-0.0194397625,
0.0116398875,
0.0075579253,
-0.0583652705,
-0.0285451971,
-0.0180791244,
0.0384005234,
-0.0044035311,
0.0332129635,
0.019043522,
0.018178124,
-0.0034068786,
-0.0036537941,
-0.0404295102,
0.0523087122,
-0.0787727982,
-0.0342979357,
0.0177133139,
-0.0151837552,
-0.0135699799,
-0.0044326601,
-0.0081098517,
-0.0735028759,
-0.0015905515,
0.0625016987,
0.0175286513,
0.0388650894,
-0.005065307,
-0.0458656475,
0.0560390428,
0.0062290323,
-0.0241532326,
0.0061271237,
0.0240290444,
-0.0266866125,
0.0014288793,
0.0179055929,
-0.0150006227,
-0.0020653459,
0.0307126157,
0.0620967112,
-0.0056341831,
-0.0148798767,
0.0297724213,
-0.0045645521,
0.0168249719,
-0.0358142629,
-0.0111755943,
0.0008583152,
0.0196562316,
-0.0146461818,
0.0029616444,
-0.0149355326,
0.0005513163,
0.0244564619,
-0.0240599867,
0.0272960216,
-0.0396843888,
0.0147219906,
0.017847551,
0.0163333472,
0.0423360877,
0.0315657333,
0.0573500656,
0.0571502633,
0.0095054926,
0.0293676257,
0.0000080727,
0.0302730408,
0.0652837008,
0.0196207389,
0.0320009962,
0.0192683507,
-0.0388499945,
0.0015155801,
0.0150621627,
-0.0225899164,
-0.0215763822,
-0.0516337007,
0.0176801663,
0.0776572451,
-0.0041230046,
0.0208723769,
-0.0274381395,
0.0038461797,
-0.0016446505,
-0.0233911555,
-0.0529002696,
-0.0094685601,
0.0329156443,
0.0402723216,
-0.0048477831,
0.0073437491,
0.0548071191,
0.0622521639,
0.0587991364,
-0.0043626656,
0.0345336683,
-0.0337216184,
-0.0415174365,
0.0096780546,
0.0506792963,
-0.0540592149,
-0.0298366044,
-0.04262916,
-0.0554982685,
-0.0355441682,
0.0716607794,
0.0034072092,
-0.0001046776,
0.0393147282,
0.0185116976,
-0.0439282916,
0.0037850323,
-0.0731359795,
-0.0332427733,
-0.0157911386,
-0.018636385,
-0.0049739382,
-6.480833168e-33,
-0.0332175158,
-0.0045473049,
0.0365676582,
-0.0265846159,
-0.0357441269,
-0.0327585563,
-0.0090435864,
0.0145254228,
0.002302262,
-0.031660635,
-0.0428777598,
-0.0254664309,
0.0217013303,
0.0356337801,
0.023249805,
0.0151801798,
0.0500212573,
-0.0143629462,
-0.0729657784,
0.0298507903,
0.0028903603,
0.0102228839,
0.0227170456,
-0.0220616031,
-0.0196775366,
0.0265465677,
-0.0179686137,
0.0173060801,
-0.0425626263,
0.0812560916,
0.0028169903,
0.0248847548,
-0.0205426626,
-0.0775464028,
-0.0282097422,
-0.0023407915,
-0.0309963487,
-0.0301508177,
-0.0052172858,
0.0160227809,
0.0237738937,
-0.0321572348,
0.0312886126,
0.0292616785,
-0.0271141306,
0.0089653162,
0.0112044048,
-0.0291452687,
-0.0257360451,
0.0330893882,
-0.0473969989,
0.0120663224,
0.0216615256,
0.0126012946,
0.0173609257,
-0.013699932,
-0.0012497671,
0.0158530157,
-0.0373294838,
0.0366959386,
0.0302636772,
0.0527965948,
0.0946244523,
0.056956321,
0.0139261642,
0.0159594584,
0.0006996326,
-0.0384960175,
0.0144366222,
-0.0304821879,
0.0420801342,
0.0148824835,
-0.0149490619,
0.039531637,
0.0598301403,
-0.0193144493,
-0.0275179204,
0.0323534124,
0.0561124794,
0.0248111244,
0.0215195436,
0.0354814418,
-0.0880872533,
-0.0044597755,
-0.0474186726,
0.0008711902,
-0.0163572039,
-0.0802771151,
0.0322555639,
0.028608162,
-0.0245606452,
-0.0146426819,
0.0196898412,
-0.0242273062,
-0.0426869728,
0.016550472,
-0.0285639539,
0.0263324734,
-0.020376781,
0.0025239093,
-0.0645656511,
-0.0351825021,
-0.0051530818,
-0.028770091,
-0.0180366542,
0.0051476425,
-0.0059776935,
0.0204858799,
-0.0608632043,
0.0225211252,
-0.0362557136,
-0.0097167846,
0.0164989177,
0.0535256825,
0.0278730541,
-0.0413220078,
0.0009631186,
0.0413229279,
-0.0142004723,
-0.0364711545,
-0.0273264032,
-0.0121807158,
-0.0164563004,
0.0122605367,
-0.0330954939,
0.0168846194,
-0.0560633764,
0.055259537,
-0.0223565828,
-0.0358949117,
-0.0217198674,
-0.0089461002,
3.024e-7,
0.0058097993,
0.0401599295,
0.0175301842,
0.0073037744,
-0.0429508165,
0.0484621152,
-0.0360192321,
0.0026706122,
0.0099345502,
-0.0092307013,
0.0255442914,
0.025304364,
0.0123303169,
0.012132803,
-0.0654188916,
-0.0203128606,
-0.0359940231,
0.0039747651,
-0.056538824,
-0.0466144979,
0.0279305987,
0.1159327328,
0.0318828747,
-0.0293376967,
0.0351400226,
0.0682558939,
0.0128919082,
-0.0229999814,
-0.0088552106,
-0.0094062239,
-0.0300527811,
-0.0118261678,
-0.052485764,
-0.0188753586,
-0.014130448,
0.027054105,
-0.0328087211,
0.0629396886,
0.0159490667,
-0.0618674159,
0.0041526989,
0.0170788821,
0.004077855,
-0.0574914664,
0.0524196103,
-0.0097754616,
0.0117996251,
0.0021995839,
-0.0077044913,
-0.0196150783,
-0.0187717862,
-0.0397588871,
-0.015341741,
0.021946447,
-0.0137213888,
0.0043748431,
0.0051261061,
-0.0437621176,
-0.0035193753,
0.0143118463,
-0.0198814683,
-0.0464340895,
-0.072458975,
0.0357649028,
-0.0232059658,
-0.0314381532,
0.0102702547,
3.030596169e-34,
0.0034193224,
-0.044298742,
0.0334002413,
-0.0347924493,
0.0148137482,
0.0388529748,
-0.0116592422,
0.0266749859,
0.0550098121,
-0.0572477654,
-0.0361201689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11823v1 | On Efficient Language and Vision Assistants for Visually-Situated Natural Language Understanding: What Matters in Reading and Reasoning | 2024-06-17T17:57:30 | 2024-06-17T17:57:30 | Geewook Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in language and vision assistants have showcased
impressive capabilities but suffer from a lack of transparency, limiting
broader research and reproducibility. While open-source models handle general
image tasks effectively, they face challenges with the high computational
demands of complex visually-situated text understanding. Such tasks often
require increased token inputs and large vision modules to harness
high-resolution information. Striking a balance between model size and data
importance remains an open question. This study aims to redefine the design of
vision-language models by identifying key components and creating efficient
models with constrained inference costs. By strategically formulating datasets,
optimizing vision modules, and enhancing supervision techniques, we achieve
significant improvements in inference throughput while maintaining high
performance. Extensive experiments across models ranging from 160M to 13B
parameters offer insights into model optimization. We will fully open-source
our codebase, models, and datasets at https://github.com/naver-ai/elva . | [
0.0524284877,
0.0464974009,
0.0081060752,
0.074945353,
-0.0225930996,
0.0051254788,
0.0206260812,
-0.0406669639,
0.0369050317,
-0.070213072,
-0.021429833,
-0.00905996,
0.0320266634,
0.0523902401,
0.0044399058,
-0.0681315213,
-0.0032151258,
-0.071535252,
0.0135770533,
0.0205568708,
0.016922649,
0.0025227906,
-0.0035407846,
0.0239443071,
-0.0007940283,
-0.0187880918,
-0.0078356192,
0.0081535606,
0.0170639493,
-0.0137251308,
-0.0246258955,
0.0159809235,
0.0532931723,
0.0110966004,
0.0000018029,
-0.0087527772,
0.0263504162,
0.0079764938,
-0.0200054534,
0.002942902,
0.0209561996,
-0.0810920224,
0.0176485516,
-0.0078703845,
-0.0077788807,
-0.0258555897,
0.0651178882,
0.0232736096,
0.0615288951,
0.0398758464,
-0.0152543224,
-0.0099485703,
0.0083435019,
-0.0259532668,
0.0135071911,
-0.0470228083,
0.0118836639,
0.0194446351,
0.0053366767,
0.010806676,
-0.0530462489,
0.0523642376,
0.0454194359,
-0.025409149,
-0.0036193118,
0.0476642847,
-0.0489815697,
-0.0493686683,
-0.0122829145,
0.0844482854,
-0.0211551636,
-0.009639862,
-0.0159482844,
-0.002652324,
-0.0249003414,
-0.0396988951,
-0.0434396714,
0.0503439568,
-0.0319930799,
0.0197282247,
-0.0127503872,
-0.0123141631,
0.017382998,
0.0266142078,
0.0033487207,
0.0226855949,
0.0001310795,
0.0300466958,
-0.0293947626,
0.0215003155,
-0.0791650563,
-0.0411191545,
-0.0079325112,
0.0328001603,
-0.0056392527,
0.0219212919,
-0.0335633159,
-0.030431075,
-0.0119795147,
-0.0238303393,
0.0427795686,
0.04771173,
-0.0650702938,
0.1097570434,
-0.0222567935,
0.0721810535,
-0.0279233232,
0.0213577449,
-0.007714347,
-0.0495506786,
0.0178311374,
0.0034228878,
-0.0427814685,
-0.020321982,
-0.0608661361,
-0.0573291853,
0.0033919243,
0.0222718064,
-0.0005864506,
0.0151006402,
0.0145251192,
0.0258661751,
-0.0417569838,
-0.0408656485,
-0.0004430142,
0.0125739789,
-0.0207005832,
0.0369171537,
-0.0544635504,
-0.0625626892,
-0.016824225,
0.0615307987,
0.0339473113,
-0.018452704,
-0.025193641,
0.0680140629,
-0.0107702194,
-0.0665064976,
-0.0165065173,
0.01592605,
-0.0089899916,
-0.0596582517,
0.0082981782,
-0.050079491,
0.0342219137,
-0.0033589585,
-0.0026930773,
-0.0295878313,
0.0035832259,
0.0279443245,
-0.0385810509,
0.1054657772,
-0.0141888075,
-0.008543686,
0.0041261949,
0.0143655026,
-0.0097452411,
0.0681717694,
0.0196740013,
0.0575445406,
0.0345978662,
0.0257521067,
0.0148874139,
0.023755759,
-0.0144613888,
0.0124990288,
-0.0319920406,
0.0219464786,
-0.0336889066,
0.0255004354,
0.035995923,
0.0432962067,
-0.0265435949,
-0.0407512821,
0.0724934489,
0.0575851053,
0.0140164196,
-0.0148623856,
0.0256853979,
0.0115478877,
0.0320348404,
-0.0438333228,
-0.0791272447,
0.0312175378,
0.0221530832,
-0.0069744117,
-0.0134795364,
0.0145297619,
-0.0423583947,
-0.0411548764,
-0.0258527286,
-0.0052036601,
-0.0092805456,
0.0331915207,
0.0403759368,
0.0030228647,
-0.0275894143,
0.0061423159,
0.0151414592,
-0.0462760925,
-0.0219711699,
-0.0204586517,
0.0500237308,
0.0840693265,
0.0319796652,
-0.0145019656,
0.0177594237,
0.0158409141,
0.0515467301,
0.0476467013,
-0.0028875186,
0.0108159957,
0.0542394966,
-0.0610744394,
-0.0498836935,
-0.0201785378,
0.0106706815,
0.0139344865,
0.0321545899,
-0.0042776344,
0.0264385808,
-0.0564375892,
-0.0098008532,
0.035315074,
0.0227672122,
-0.0069649606,
-0.0297289398,
0.0167811755,
-0.0039893356,
-0.0080045471,
0.0058552059,
-0.0165667795,
-0.0026597241,
-0.0400545336,
0.0472977273,
0.0206454489,
-0.0266449153,
-0.0465458445,
0.0340938419,
-0.0537565984,
-0.0182016902,
0.0225090515,
-0.0583845638,
-0.0060881572,
0.0205070376,
-0.0492246598,
-0.0072352416,
-0.0325396024,
-0.0120243011,
0.0344912037,
0.0530236624,
-0.0088815559,
0.0345587656,
-0.0214628763,
-0.0249465015,
0.0366783962,
0.0175565854,
0.0244623721,
-0.0186734945,
0.0099967187,
-0.0410072319,
0.019045366,
0.0126985339,
-0.0083106961,
0.0098218499,
-0.0348850936,
-0.0194897763,
-0.0851102695,
-0.0394373387,
-0.0519728735,
-0.0224145055,
0.0112601565,
0.0022784199,
0.0012035785,
-0.0470440052,
-0.0016544497,
0.0201529078,
-0.0224556495,
-0.0051912512,
0.0222344529,
0.0035949117,
-0.0084450236,
-0.0416159704,
0.0024247211,
0.0205815397,
0.0568850413,
0.0540075153,
-0.04004151,
-0.0529846624,
0.0040721511,
0.0082922,
0.0555579178,
-0.0335835218,
-0.0202314556,
-0.0020668637,
-0.0277203191,
0.0389934555,
0.0891727209,
-0.0347213373,
0.0494876467,
0.0075846678,
-0.0088154329,
-0.0378873982,
0.0099614514,
0.0133932633,
0.0059178253,
-0.0084821032,
-0.0189587101,
-0.0630021691,
0.0496535562,
-0.0349874049,
0.0001320887,
-0.0524762645,
0.025206279,
0.0107619446,
-0.0427237637,
-0.0418828502,
-0.0059472295,
0.0184062403,
0.0407931581,
-0.0665520355,
-0.0744978487,
0.0317438208,
-0.0609517545,
-0.0081586605,
0.0037972042,
-0.0086050211,
-0.0734640807,
0.0896361992,
0.0434078798,
-0.0084071551,
-0.0397290289,
-0.0116993627,
-0.058309719,
-0.0105318548,
0.0028308691,
0.0170771107,
0.0578533895,
-0.0793743208,
0.047493875,
-0.0442601144,
-0.0117261708,
-0.0355239846,
-0.003973559,
-0.0671425611,
-0.0005597212,
-0.0337795205,
-0.014452721,
-0.0364495367,
0.0489854515,
0.0235910267,
0.0561921187,
0.0126534719,
0.0021410417,
-0.0313076414,
0.0289393719,
0.0729421601,
0.025365917,
-0.0146393906,
-0.0290694758,
0.0017623154,
0.066919215,
0.0038221604,
-0.0001885423,
-0.0555569157,
0.0443413407,
0.0307524391,
0.0390806682,
0.0114675974,
-0.001881915,
0.0406075902,
-0.0816396102,
-0.0150465332,
0.0665460601,
0.007210548,
-0.0408897623,
-0.021329917,
0.0102120433,
0.0245296415,
0.0393219441,
0.0172658656,
-0.0598755255,
-0.0584227219,
0.0049638972,
-0.0080043804,
0.0344198532,
-0.000424067,
-0.0557016358,
-0.0686682016,
0.0468102284,
-0.0242135637,
-0.0155231413,
-0.0706734061,
0.0223245565,
0.0196409654,
-0.0361908004,
-0.0006868939,
-0.0023232594,
0.0080200415,
0.0044115242,
-0.0184426699,
0.0205400437,
0.0262113065,
0.0319431499,
-0.0425864756,
-0.0164100397,
-0.0026535206,
0.0060243048,
0.0366769023,
-0.0483296514,
0.0437573604,
-0.0247818958,
0.0095586739,
-0.0022968692,
0.0604975522,
-0.0335670076,
-0.0560677424,
0.0081530269,
0.0555626899,
-0.0443097614,
-0.0290800128,
-0.0328249596,
0.0254173633,
0.005276666,
-0.0043846425,
-0.0346251614,
-0.0045956071,
-0.0014128974,
0.04441664,
0.033013016,
-0.0187246464,
-0.0575180203,
-0.0030570633,
-0.0084964111,
-0.0522362553,
-0.0178619623,
-0.0001425663,
0.0323121808,
-0.0177004449,
-0.026974963,
-0.0276879445,
0.0397600196,
0.0531342328,
-0.0097186221,
-0.0060252161,
0.0088091921,
0.0186410099,
-0.0462614708,
0.0945255235,
-0.0320729911,
0.0286953859,
-0.0213594195,
0.0019464471,
0.0187963862,
-0.0362639502,
-0.0181204099,
0.0267008152,
-0.1060297117,
-0.024215674,
-0.016900979,
0.0596610159,
0.0214007199,
0.0667697042,
-0.0051775216,
-0.0644036457,
-0.0043201121,
0.0118339183,
-0.0099926069,
0.0185220316,
-0.0121964347,
-0.0095045799,
0.0138218738,
0.0339175873,
-0.0222230498,
0.0177226812,
0.0175111163,
0.013853997,
-0.027461201,
-0.0163509808,
-0.015656719,
-0.0047907392,
0.0311618038,
-0.0009972682,
0.0332069546,
-0.0396355204,
0.0382737853,
-0.0002201506,
-0.0100206584,
-0.0872487128,
0.015306999,
0.0117667802,
-0.0061374032,
-0.0075149578,
-0.0011489167,
0.015479818,
0.0146514904,
-0.0073898179,
0.0241708737,
0.01613071,
-0.0077741928,
0.0078287302,
-0.0004554311,
-0.020302901,
0.0468494594,
-0.0569909178,
0.040798977,
0.0069324714,
0.0343091488,
0.0272993203,
-0.0453970432,
-0.0391121991,
0.0180458054,
-0.0251399912,
-0.0429522842,
-0.0086660534,
0.0744269639,
0.0307088252,
-0.0083900373,
0.0103405938,
-0.0175765138,
-0.0232293513,
-0.0115629015,
0.0542285629,
0.0150447842,
-0.0401863344,
0.069518961,
0.0403198078,
0.0235654693,
-0.00682254,
0.0613307543,
0.0597421266,
0.0287370291,
-0.0003589071,
0.0000060313,
-0.0301888157,
-0.0268241968,
0.011030308,
-0.0158806406,
-0.0130330808,
0.0856768563,
-0.0184538923,
-0.0601276085,
-0.0135381827,
0.0016439459,
-0.0157677196,
0.0303455275,
0.0374780186,
0.0507562272,
0.0293132737,
-0.0105186664,
-0.0217321236,
-0.0083507942,
-0.0053232983,
-0.0145226624,
0.0258859005,
-5.955742413e-33,
-0.0109184124,
-0.0518608689,
0.0442471728,
0.0107761994,
-0.0021115725,
0.0398735553,
-0.0308163818,
-0.0067597185,
-0.0363827422,
0.0068653938,
0.0203410964,
0.0443175845,
0.0117766736,
0.0552116707,
-0.0427799895,
-0.0061797881,
0.0134264296,
0.0078328848,
0.003383788,
-0.0108996155,
0.0022007385,
0.0144220274,
0.0229423158,
-0.0365325361,
-0.0100348499,
0.017218601,
0.0064625083,
0.0410769358,
-0.0007185357,
0.0551220588,
-0.0486934185,
0.0151822744,
0.0241844244,
0.012323238,
-0.0223418418,
0.0541981012,
-0.0907420143,
-0.0060320538,
0.0143600106,
0.0726265907,
-0.118032895,
0.0120726731,
0.031582661,
-0.009097565,
0.0462149754,
-0.0476980805,
0.0410752892,
-0.0262074396,
-0.0319299176,
0.0497191139,
-0.0311499238,
0.0356951766,
-0.0060520265,
-0.024831729,
0.0707410872,
0.0261739343,
0.0427789316,
0.0463837869,
-0.0316013955,
-0.0267164651,
-0.0113919275,
0.0176952332,
0.0702886656,
0.0339660011,
-0.0065169963,
0.0413004272,
0.0045101964,
-0.0480670519,
-0.0538566299,
-0.0203344133,
0.0018056754,
0.0600704066,
0.0480382368,
0.0419430025,
-0.0197783373,
0.0483868234,
-0.0688339323,
-0.0337766223,
-0.0248900522,
0.0933957994,
0.0086980294,
-0.0041852789,
-0.0113710817,
-0.0024490296,
-0.0494434722,
-0.0392601341,
-0.0665315762,
0.0364371799,
0.0579287969,
0.0459656827,
-0.0401651524,
0.0222033374,
0.0484461859,
-0.0514944047,
-0.0091454675,
0.0375650562,
-0.0011443389,
0.0330247656,
0.0161316227,
0.0612742975,
-0.0575493947,
-0.0034674641,
0.0267163105,
0.0174852852,
-0.0001017934,
-0.0231176112,
0.0374260731,
0.0182955731,
-0.0404914096,
-0.0089193359,
-0.0609047003,
0.0247328822,
-0.0146739446,
0.0483310968,
0.026322769,
-0.0062502362,
-0.0473669991,
0.0400826149,
-0.0018196391,
0.0089900587,
0.0002545622,
-0.0086538764,
-0.0033627942,
0.0318378322,
-0.020971885,
-0.0143015683,
-0.0222888105,
-0.0194665175,
0.0228215139,
-0.0703574345,
-0.0111032203,
0.0447647125,
2.42e-7,
0.0467707776,
0.0172838196,
0.0355684757,
0.0062198015,
0.0252376683,
0.0425201468,
-0.0106741134,
0.0204924699,
-0.0256768353,
-0.0172428563,
-0.0073616258,
0.075771749,
0.0276486836,
-0.0191728044,
-0.0371134169,
0.0537894592,
-0.0171410013,
0.0169528276,
-0.0483609624,
-0.0182054844,
0.0509490967,
0.0932179391,
-0.0467225239,
-0.0257571675,
0.0306255035,
-0.0991403908,
0.0665084273,
-0.0298261847,
0.0196806528,
-0.0091165137,
0.0171757247,
0.060402561,
-0.0215816684,
-0.0121658128,
0.020614313,
-0.0204816107,
0.0477610901,
0.0467706919,
-0.0023781464,
-0.0048607555,
-0.0038229858,
-0.0004854182,
-0.0245728604,
-0.0761033148,
0.0852926821,
-0.0553892478,
-0.0203288496,
-0.0277957469,
-0.0199570935,
-0.0100930119,
0.0043114871,
0.011878225,
-0.0079740947,
0.0133980317,
0.0448917672,
-0.0732539743,
-0.0379960984,
-0.1012121886,
-0.0441292524,
-0.054036174,
-0.0195558462,
0.0006337608,
-0.0669890344,
0.006020728,
0.0581602566,
-0.0285914186,
-0.0529269911,
1.703625825e-34,
0.033064004,
-0.0366700552,
-0.0044777398,
0.0263925828,
0.0005501133,
-0.0283230022,
-0.0116876699,
-0.0152792782,
0.006767916,
-0.0785416439,
-0.0112944767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11817v1 | Iterative Length-Regularized Direct Preference Optimization: A Case Study on Improving 7B Language Models to GPT-4 Level | 2024-06-17T17:55:38 | 2024-06-17T17:55:38 | Jie Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Jiaheng Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Chao Yang, Han-Sen Zhong, Wanli Ouyang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a standard method for aligning language
models with human preferences, is traditionally applied to offline preferences.
Recent studies show that DPO benefits from iterative training with online
preferences labeled by a trained reward model. In this work, we identify a
pitfall of vanilla iterative DPO - improved response quality can lead to
increased verbosity. To address this, we introduce iterative length-regularized
DPO (iLR-DPO) to penalize response length. Our empirical results show that
iLR-DPO can enhance a 7B model to perform on par with GPT-4 without increasing
verbosity. Specifically, our 7B model achieves a $50.5\%$ length-controlled win
rate against $\texttt{GPT-4 Preview}$ on AlpacaEval 2.0, and excels across
standard benchmarks including MT-Bench, Arena-Hard and OpenLLM Leaderboard.
These results demonstrate the effectiveness of iterative DPO in aligning
language models with human feedback. | [
0.0347474217,
0.062639147,
-0.0108771194,
0.0497755148,
-0.014692693,
-0.0144969262,
-0.0379075073,
0.0165787507,
-0.0283400398,
0.0014902848,
-0.0350030363,
-0.0562804043,
0.001973032,
0.025114553,
0.0055641555,
-0.087456204,
0.0003394423,
-0.0233615283,
0.009557589,
-0.0352930054,
0.0146107581,
-0.0099857496,
0.0000559763,
0.0300379172,
0.0433212928,
0.0042479336,
-0.0392163917,
0.0072350809,
-0.0159677323,
-0.0642276406,
0.0110137202,
0.0437941737,
0.018736152,
-0.0053677135,
0.0000022876,
-0.0470037423,
-0.0190983936,
-0.0282115154,
0.0071206903,
0.04155045,
0.0254511386,
0.0138927288,
0.0132141216,
0.0205909163,
-0.0246710591,
-0.0004664201,
0.0490474254,
0.014781462,
0.0472194478,
0.0686543435,
0.0048778206,
-0.0318724737,
-0.001072931,
-0.0568165295,
-0.0114828954,
-0.0362683311,
0.0042119506,
-0.0407408662,
0.0057470873,
0.0112017533,
-0.0358109921,
-0.018657716,
-0.0059756325,
0.0480789915,
-0.0112330625,
0.0111305378,
0.0205435921,
0.0038480144,
0.0072519439,
0.0583204292,
-0.0153058115,
-0.0141439186,
-0.0043886686,
-0.0214521438,
0.0102002593,
-0.0615641139,
-0.0121164089,
-0.0235070232,
0.0237083901,
0.019268116,
-0.0019569362,
0.0153168431,
-0.0024383944,
-0.0132302232,
-0.0295446943,
0.1035430655,
0.0122128585,
-0.0707711205,
-0.0231747068,
-0.0151371239,
-0.0247262977,
-0.0525689125,
-0.0019457688,
0.0050977441,
-0.042863071,
0.0222952403,
-0.0170039404,
0.0157010686,
0.0118287755,
-0.0472299792,
0.0831285864,
0.0480384752,
-0.0091649164,
-0.008561979,
-0.0230057295,
0.0671024248,
0.0203941595,
0.0183700453,
-0.0548461229,
0.0364921615,
-0.0095657185,
-0.0030343791,
-0.0090728411,
0.0162021257,
-0.0356320888,
-0.0062883408,
-0.0653817803,
-0.0007858998,
0.0233182907,
0.0192648116,
0.0151217449,
0.0251311082,
-0.0297602527,
-0.01610687,
-0.0867491961,
0.0268677566,
-0.0457520857,
-0.0132301813,
0.0137028024,
-0.0256622564,
0.0124529833,
-0.0167538896,
-0.0206144452,
-0.0530410856,
0.0255560353,
0.1121406183,
-0.001123537,
-0.0227720421,
0.0423167534,
0.0059463638,
-0.0474880449,
-0.0733146593,
-0.0286654569,
-0.0442430638,
0.0253667627,
-0.0282587148,
-0.0142278764,
-0.0369390287,
0.0048864456,
0.0004098663,
-0.0267144796,
0.0467263497,
-0.0015775698,
0.0138504934,
-0.0374541804,
-0.0214095097,
0.0058405371,
0.0689144284,
0.0389120281,
0.0696458295,
0.0332737714,
-0.0357105993,
-0.0211106967,
0.0408326201,
0.0295734294,
0.0260316227,
-0.0657301918,
0.0292824972,
0.0186182354,
0.0520823896,
0.063368015,
0.0539624766,
-0.0152841955,
-0.0318858325,
0.112442553,
0.0181860868,
0.061561849,
0.0032208047,
0.0119523201,
0.0282485951,
-0.0052925483,
0.0195921976,
-0.0354281329,
0.0147626633,
-0.0081540234,
0.0409128256,
0.0485378541,
0.0459739901,
0.004857847,
-0.0684244484,
-0.014165082,
0.0035526964,
0.0158757251,
0.0473025627,
0.0593152232,
-0.0473338105,
-0.073482886,
-0.0109684467,
0.0316667892,
-0.0432249866,
-0.0155050261,
-0.0484357141,
0.044252459,
0.0629245713,
0.0253075771,
-0.0025549149,
-0.0098024243,
-0.0417337045,
-0.0590476021,
0.0701185912,
0.0622822419,
-0.0035240932,
-0.0016325047,
-0.0321284197,
-0.0424648933,
0.019964844,
0.0101096556,
0.0496667139,
-0.005953474,
-0.0081124399,
0.0022517326,
0.0215598941,
-0.0373105891,
0.0217221398,
0.030704055,
-0.0769518912,
0.0235660933,
0.0025373369,
0.073375158,
0.0240105521,
0.0144171678,
-0.0191986375,
0.0184386745,
0.0013388859,
-0.0248242207,
-0.0214166343,
-0.0551333502,
0.0065720268,
0.0962974578,
0.0268089063,
0.0501376167,
0.0747586787,
-0.0204334632,
-0.0194719229,
0.0033128366,
0.0025691539,
0.0738886371,
0.0015355827,
0.0199743174,
-0.0229633749,
-0.001810084,
-0.0731662065,
0.0266203322,
0.001422157,
0.0121841095,
-0.0190240089,
-0.0585621484,
0.0391154885,
-0.0709997192,
-0.0162624344,
0.088420786,
0.0100640915,
0.0248326957,
0.059483584,
0.0476595797,
-0.0314631015,
-0.0178349596,
-0.0698709935,
0.0113190692,
-0.0150469244,
0.0043360242,
0.025546968,
0.0015118136,
-0.0307614896,
-0.0082230428,
-0.042532593,
-0.0332453847,
0.000116363,
0.0187374037,
0.0113446256,
0.0333651379,
-0.0246301368,
-0.0544739366,
-0.0280893892,
0.003573434,
-0.0104114469,
-0.0591133274,
0.0150623852,
-0.0315160342,
0.0390615016,
-0.0792652965,
0.0236727931,
-0.0147707127,
-0.0595126413,
0.0154052265,
-0.0262052454,
0.0267041624,
0.0591814406,
0.0302703604,
0.0011533991,
0.0753176734,
-0.0018914727,
-0.0659493357,
0.0146344993,
-0.0504037365,
-0.0658955872,
-0.0466629788,
-0.0122211296,
0.029053567,
0.095041424,
0.0022616121,
-0.0048981709,
-0.0662187263,
-0.0109960474,
-0.0237605292,
0.0062924419,
-0.0064705983,
0.0198961757,
-0.0454993695,
0.0353712142,
-0.0082928129,
-0.046672754,
0.0700804815,
-0.018334616,
0.0109685585,
-0.082155779,
-0.0118235601,
-0.0144099519,
0.033851359,
0.0301519595,
0.0319677554,
-0.0174380355,
-0.0140753053,
-0.0446586385,
-0.0441476516,
0.0437965803,
-0.0419672877,
0.0556455441,
-0.0093779722,
0.0012109167,
-0.022065999,
-0.0730961412,
-0.0098620467,
-0.0097600985,
-0.0215936117,
-0.0340507887,
0.0325829983,
-0.0321363732,
0.016822027,
0.014467679,
0.0366609916,
0.0295064766,
-0.0236292146,
-0.000761363,
-0.0001549707,
0.008051347,
0.0909913108,
0.0097225942,
0.0040105172,
-0.0307198949,
-0.0030661304,
0.0121313129,
0.0649518296,
-0.0288302097,
0.0158771053,
0.0014703325,
0.0473740175,
-0.0527837276,
-0.0450768135,
0.0588900708,
0.0315110609,
-0.0572378486,
0.0441269949,
0.0887938589,
0.0196776129,
-0.0406057686,
0.0267668962,
-0.001737028,
0.0876000971,
-0.009025122,
0.0481154732,
-0.0680232048,
-0.0196357332,
0.0024615186,
0.0460485853,
-0.0016133464,
-0.010165914,
-0.0201829039,
-0.124140963,
-0.0336585082,
0.0099337725,
-0.0473098382,
-0.0016702904,
-0.0050060055,
0.0023337449,
-0.0394111909,
0.024203226,
0.0382375382,
-0.0032973224,
0.0199801382,
0.0133108916,
-0.0126593225,
-0.0148078054,
0.0042632758,
-0.0166294221,
0.0484644808,
0.0848341584,
0.0345305949,
-0.0019123052,
-0.0221435409,
0.03738866,
0.0235610623,
-0.0113970274,
-0.0222835857,
0.0273312349,
-0.010894306,
0.0060209366,
-0.0000034274,
0.0093162376,
0.0193958953,
0.0354084112,
0.0390383303,
0.0449364223,
0.0522697903,
-0.0370013416,
0.0249813888,
-0.0159593206,
0.0111284209,
0.048324611,
0.010115223,
-0.0834828168,
-0.0410201326,
-0.0622608624,
-0.0151887471,
-0.0728292167,
-0.0339727253,
-0.0551790521,
0.0280137826,
0.0146470666,
-0.0495403707,
-0.0485081896,
-0.0163927283,
0.0473236293,
0.0111322217,
0.0339774974,
-0.0557284392,
0.0097169103,
-0.0056433878,
0.0149782449,
-0.0130889202,
-0.00408067,
-0.0990960598,
-0.0365717337,
0.020403171,
-0.036773704,
-0.0091839554,
0.0221161209,
0.0051750941,
-0.0559234247,
-0.005694076,
0.0683806315,
0.0234448686,
0.0523288995,
0.0254148673,
-0.0500538722,
0.033107318,
-0.0169222411,
-0.0250825919,
0.006068585,
0.0292648021,
0.0094766701,
0.010249842,
0.022668574,
-0.0205757953,
0.0021902707,
0.0306290518,
0.0631141588,
0.0246283207,
-0.0371906199,
0.0438805185,
0.0281197168,
0.0259268824,
-0.0307881795,
-0.053603299,
0.0003851277,
0.0203726441,
-0.0629324839,
0.0068293945,
-0.0333208963,
-0.0062148795,
0.0134839667,
0.0101495599,
0.0066784481,
-0.0443851948,
-0.0437419042,
-0.0090650776,
-0.0306408945,
0.0247049984,
0.0211206358,
0.0074800323,
0.0626946092,
0.0322192051,
0.0016368721,
0.0121790506,
0.0378554277,
0.0451717004,
0.0010999545,
0.0066547347,
0.0314484052,
-0.0152441533,
0.0127762351,
0.0404914133,
0.0183057748,
-0.0065685851,
-0.0424844995,
-0.0282659903,
0.0607453138,
-0.0023529551,
0.050926175,
-0.0047268141,
-0.0053506773,
-0.0049252557,
-0.0055119414,
-0.0470640734,
-0.03529891,
-0.019811457,
0.0288999882,
-0.03529834,
0.001995879,
0.0709503293,
0.0522601791,
0.0290836375,
-0.01077173,
0.0051211156,
-0.0459496938,
0.0107591106,
0.0117420331,
0.0769608021,
-0.0517269485,
-0.0339896306,
-0.0494573154,
-0.0539069176,
-0.0153824706,
0.0381799899,
0.0132459141,
-0.0059083751,
0.0395029299,
0.0383167826,
-0.0486576632,
-0.0242139418,
-0.0667411163,
-0.0375403427,
-0.0132451896,
-0.0189240985,
-0.0127169862,
-6.63450481e-33,
-0.0272421073,
0.0055105495,
0.0295739286,
-0.0076440633,
-0.0535023324,
-0.0282698814,
-0.0000481984,
0.0301881861,
0.000083665,
-0.0251480862,
-0.0453299992,
-0.0369536206,
-0.0009142965,
0.0133857019,
0.022793252,
-0.0023182405,
0.0445486009,
-0.0259214099,
-0.0681515634,
0.0154465334,
0.0198568404,
0.0150287086,
0.0370093696,
-0.0429667123,
0.0189936515,
0.0613633655,
-0.0208011661,
0.0025236178,
-0.0112008657,
0.0592063367,
-0.010469825,
0.0184880421,
-0.0019969344,
-0.0393357836,
-0.011474791,
-0.0320812836,
-0.0400023833,
-0.0072367731,
-0.0025647746,
0.0059784674,
0.0157469492,
-0.0157360323,
0.0302315298,
0.0143462792,
-0.0422784165,
-0.0291890576,
0.025535576,
-0.0328334235,
-0.0419984981,
0.0108726192,
-0.0413409024,
0.0107471403,
0.0043617147,
0.0049574557,
0.0471114814,
0.052576866,
-0.0068888459,
0.0402591676,
-0.0302662253,
0.0554412343,
0.0380567275,
0.0383579843,
0.047711309,
0.0405367054,
0.0405732319,
0.005937492,
0.0436651073,
-0.0182634816,
0.0149375768,
-0.0074891835,
0.0428763963,
-0.0026991707,
0.0415778793,
0.0099887634,
0.0669160262,
-0.0241743755,
-0.0325648896,
0.0231153034,
0.0240116138,
-0.0140427779,
0.0182330813,
0.0532555431,
-0.0594312958,
-0.0238413364,
-0.0201122817,
-0.0292396359,
-0.0227690134,
-0.1081863642,
0.026097225,
0.0091133583,
0.00305461,
-0.0176673904,
0.0466193594,
0.0097174663,
-0.0435865931,
0.0095604686,
-0.0523639172,
0.0416488983,
-0.0014157564,
-0.0071935398,
-0.056601759,
-0.0000233067,
-0.0219462235,
-0.0062726117,
-0.0227448177,
0.0017704251,
-0.0025169824,
0.0273558479,
-0.057156682,
0.0205147956,
-0.0081458129,
-0.0102317128,
0.0297679733,
0.031233646,
0.0318042226,
-0.0483104326,
0.0128368251,
0.0749383718,
-0.0070051588,
-0.0608145148,
-0.0410413072,
-0.0217411686,
0.0158031322,
0.0084744059,
-0.0110383406,
0.0021919331,
-0.0156788696,
0.0318391621,
-0.0031606951,
-0.0058432058,
-0.0294831935,
-0.0341771506,
3.07e-7,
-0.0027890105,
0.0738106519,
-0.0189152416,
-0.0099339457,
-0.0562905483,
0.0542641133,
0.0016765962,
0.0030427643,
0.0334109962,
0.0341241919,
0.0258655827,
-0.0015998216,
0.0248105042,
0.0113610318,
-0.0886117294,
-0.0264496803,
-0.0422363952,
0.0141930617,
-0.0520334207,
-0.0061365068,
0.0405919515,
0.0802802369,
0.0438630879,
0.0075044674,
0.0077276565,
0.0148287276,
0.0267425757,
-0.0335857868,
-0.0293161292,
0.0072888006,
0.0263169874,
-0.0416499414,
-0.0513293818,
-0.0225114543,
-0.0077752443,
0.0223221518,
0.014293869,
0.0517441556,
-0.0053576352,
-0.0436853468,
0.0103087779,
0.0254943334,
-0.0159754511,
-0.0633882061,
0.0596674941,
-0.0116514424,
-0.01658375,
0.008212314,
-0.0328334309,
-0.0592891462,
0.0176469274,
-0.058822073,
-0.0361494198,
0.0105067901,
-0.0069482061,
0.026232373,
0.0115171475,
-0.0489714444,
-0.0049990895,
0.0306165107,
-0.0297443923,
-0.0323504545,
-0.042074576,
0.0509456247,
-0.0198145397,
-0.0454732887,
0.013565002,
3.097555036e-34,
0.0035703396,
-0.0077774236,
0.0202189274,
-0.0563680492,
0.0308773462,
-0.0048875869,
0.0517452545,
0.0262542423,
0.0628541782,
-0.0653707162,
-0.0255757794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11813v1 | How Do Large Language Models Acquire Factual Knowledge During Pretraining? | 2024-06-17T17:54:40 | 2024-06-17T17:54:40 | Hoyeon Chang, Jinho Park, Seonghyeon Ye, Sohee Yang, Youngkyung Seo, Du-Seong Chang, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Despite the recent observation that large language models (LLMs) can store
substantial factual knowledge, there is a limited understanding of the
mechanisms of how they acquire factual knowledge through pretraining. This work
addresses this gap by studying how LLMs acquire factual knowledge during
pretraining. The findings reveal several important insights into the dynamics
of factual knowledge acquisition during pretraining. First, counterintuitively,
we observe that pretraining on more data shows no significant improvement in
the model's capability to acquire and maintain factual knowledge. Next, there
is a power-law relationship between training steps and forgetting of
memorization and generalization of factual knowledge, and LLMs trained with
duplicated training data exhibit faster forgetting. Third, training LLMs with
larger batch sizes can enhance the models' robustness to forgetting. Overall,
our observations suggest that factual knowledge acquisition in LLM pretraining
occurs by progressively increasing the probability of factual knowledge
presented in the pretraining data at each step. However, this increase is
diluted by subsequent forgetting. Based on this interpretation, we demonstrate
that we can provide plausible explanations for recently observed behaviors of
LLMs, such as the poor performance of LLMs on long-tail knowledge and the
benefits of deduplicating the pretraining corpus. | [
0.019137267,
0.0304788873,
-0.0130104786,
0.0177193377,
-0.0219381638,
0.032374993,
-0.0100946287,
-0.0046353769,
-0.0281224325,
-0.041010201,
-0.0087712109,
-0.0548948534,
0.0077690887,
-0.0187086836,
0.0257437862,
-0.0055779302,
0.0723822638,
-0.0492121615,
-0.0131028835,
-0.0471839085,
-0.0102578746,
-0.0201295894,
-0.0096816104,
-0.0337223709,
-0.0458692722,
-0.0143811917,
-0.0272225961,
-0.0501557812,
-0.0133499121,
-0.0409571566,
-0.009542428,
0.0302448664,
0.0377680138,
0.0502662435,
0.0000018545,
-0.0680861026,
0.0060786461,
-0.0213077515,
-0.0891524553,
0.0656172633,
-0.0096131461,
0.0162421893,
-0.0086964434,
-0.0003195563,
-0.0289413165,
-0.0444474258,
0.0264591482,
0.0369905904,
0.0189705864,
0.069032535,
0.0223835427,
-0.0220368337,
0.0267313737,
-0.0149747608,
0.0038296136,
-0.0167566519,
0.0390871763,
0.0489004441,
-0.04429847,
-0.0199324526,
-0.0285387598,
0.0088792574,
0.0171315894,
0.0622934513,
0.0002720809,
0.0996097103,
0.0192906838,
-0.030477386,
0.0015141924,
0.0154264448,
0.0021437511,
-0.0360492542,
-0.0045655393,
0.0090464456,
0.000437878,
0.0042332001,
-0.0364936814,
0.0458232872,
-0.0332577601,
0.0284379013,
-0.0013521675,
-0.0389583856,
0.0655733049,
0.0085406741,
-0.0459154174,
0.0379401632,
-0.0028888488,
-0.0637663528,
0.0152200079,
0.0187891796,
-0.0032903478,
-0.0665412396,
-0.0084155314,
0.0311763305,
0.0226192549,
0.0608955324,
-0.0256826635,
0.0078896908,
0.0399279408,
-0.067286551,
0.0212405417,
0.0093823774,
-0.0378572121,
0.0413712971,
-0.04512842,
0.0370038524,
-0.0051837959,
0.0183174089,
-0.026105931,
0.0105130021,
-0.0592149235,
-0.0169591885,
-0.0274147037,
0.0314221159,
0.0640089735,
0.0373315215,
-0.0239742231,
0.0061690491,
0.0094750514,
0.0214361083,
-0.0219405591,
-0.0274741258,
-0.0428127535,
0.0083968202,
-0.0665290803,
0.0397761948,
-0.026575299,
0.0395224355,
0.0055774455,
-0.0523147024,
-0.0450142175,
-0.0343691409,
0.0069419681,
0.0020191281,
0.0213649869,
-0.0237796232,
-0.0294746999,
-0.0573986918,
-0.1152176857,
-0.015551826,
0.0034907826,
-0.1165823415,
0.0064012087,
-0.0408100449,
0.032303758,
0.0186696593,
0.0010524529,
-0.030499151,
0.0117011834,
0.0168574322,
-0.0260147806,
0.0588732846,
0.0069349841,
0.0200636573,
0.0329252519,
0.0011842218,
-0.0009036873,
0.0654413104,
-0.0029391025,
0.0062143947,
0.0196948349,
-0.0093375808,
-0.0019124903,
0.0181609876,
0.0426356047,
0.0017599233,
0.0095341476,
-0.011039515,
0.0338988006,
0.0270939674,
0.0541197248,
0.0247767307,
-0.0356136598,
0.0008509073,
0.0783181712,
0.0294958446,
-0.0045392415,
0.0351237431,
0.0349878184,
-0.035386011,
0.0570824891,
0.061031729,
-0.0620894916,
-0.0074360124,
-0.0083594406,
0.0377513021,
-0.0256686732,
0.052197706,
-0.050953798,
-0.0244661439,
-0.0056641381,
-0.0175286699,
-0.0126897087,
0.0027755669,
0.0606640317,
0.0079106474,
-0.0185014065,
0.0894797444,
0.057503406,
-0.02276708,
0.0287242681,
-0.0232784972,
0.0368375368,
0.0294521246,
0.0101990122,
-0.0219418816,
-0.0261327438,
0.0181920677,
0.007639199,
-0.03136665,
0.0793173835,
-0.0038122991,
0.0225496609,
-0.042593807,
-0.0050477874,
-0.0075125233,
0.0324496888,
0.0256647207,
0.0196851008,
0.0133716017,
0.0024590348,
-0.0326718688,
-0.0305087324,
0.0467418022,
-0.0733080208,
-0.0477460138,
-0.0413801521,
-0.0051108273,
0.0285367649,
-0.0071163164,
-0.0279186685,
0.0042214449,
0.0429957062,
0.0062129321,
-0.0055418527,
0.0192362946,
-0.0753681585,
-0.0150614893,
0.0350680426,
0.0498078726,
-0.0106225517,
-0.0067121056,
-0.0184059069,
-0.0355200581,
0.0076389136,
-0.0026269928,
0.0811168253,
-0.0398400947,
0.0475235917,
0.0087958835,
0.0135675054,
0.0103891231,
0.0863679126,
-0.0315870009,
-0.0235352721,
-0.030989578,
-0.0111511238,
0.0122090103,
-0.0376804546,
-0.0039265594,
0.0296221375,
0.0013872327,
0.0250310302,
-0.0142564094,
-0.0590749346,
-0.0610647686,
0.0158036612,
-0.0636499748,
-0.020382531,
-0.0064875861,
0.0030145876,
-0.0007011446,
-0.0281888209,
-0.0207806583,
-0.0078926431,
-0.0208554342,
0.0039976821,
-0.0162586924,
0.0483044945,
0.0067890198,
-0.0034150586,
0.0192761756,
-0.0185319073,
0.0083869733,
-0.0045953002,
0.0321133509,
-0.0003376703,
-0.0139857735,
-0.0692102909,
0.0764508843,
-0.0469030142,
0.0268875137,
-0.0156745613,
-0.0229360722,
0.0117949359,
-0.0080652935,
0.0434134528,
0.0949499607,
0.014913979,
0.0348943137,
0.1060490161,
-0.0098692654,
-0.0401021577,
0.0143203298,
-0.0450514629,
-0.0477521755,
-0.0507163927,
-0.0089878617,
-0.0150872972,
0.0488362983,
0.0228934512,
0.0114616742,
-0.0009054351,
-0.0179478303,
-0.0529172681,
-0.0315074064,
-0.023358088,
-0.0021806576,
-0.0391648524,
0.0337480493,
0.0074811988,
-0.0456694402,
0.0443581566,
-0.0262452457,
0.0044844081,
-0.0415974371,
-0.0014357601,
0.0274821315,
0.0512411222,
0.0355423726,
0.0143967606,
0.0327797383,
0.0057160663,
-0.0572829358,
-0.0220290367,
0.0509989299,
-0.0314208455,
0.0490389764,
-0.0335159004,
0.0026311895,
0.0107709588,
-0.0420026667,
-0.0758803785,
-0.030285513,
-0.0221964233,
-0.0207068231,
-0.0489094593,
-0.0056604454,
-0.0127218375,
-0.0358980559,
0.0694665611,
0.0282406788,
0.028652925,
-0.0196021274,
-0.000786524,
0.0024991385,
0.0024770321,
0.0113698021,
0.0271229297,
-0.056750305,
-0.0032109534,
0.0603563488,
0.0656416565,
-0.0054731905,
-0.0230209902,
-0.0137404855,
0.0013709437,
-0.0450192578,
-0.0216410421,
0.0298476778,
0.0212394912,
-0.0445114598,
-0.0139017198,
0.0981748253,
0.0097634792,
-0.004065807,
0.0162953455,
0.0159349386,
0.0276672244,
0.0330679677,
-0.0112748621,
-0.076136671,
0.0103478506,
0.0194617715,
0.0003874966,
-0.0068268692,
-0.0109009044,
-0.0432888381,
-0.1259922683,
-0.0309022553,
0.0137634939,
-0.0031506089,
-0.0136010926,
-0.0208716579,
-0.02426726,
-0.0164047442,
0.0511819422,
0.0313815773,
-0.0337581709,
0.0170104187,
0.0463766605,
-0.0126823001,
-0.0628471226,
0.0400627591,
-0.0564654693,
0.0643814206,
0.0193613954,
0.0113819456,
-0.0245179199,
-0.0228882618,
0.0183481406,
0.0010889149,
0.0205417816,
0.0170607567,
0.0383263379,
0.0025619653,
-0.0115096448,
0.0080748824,
0.0211894456,
0.0145786228,
-0.0226850566,
0.0151372114,
0.0361505039,
-0.0020066549,
-0.0596331879,
0.0370742269,
-0.0003535041,
-0.0376482122,
0.0960536227,
0.023230793,
0.0115312142,
0.0099536758,
-0.0066375979,
0.0281952284,
0.0115553904,
-0.0267785788,
0.0577278808,
-0.0321355797,
-0.0005846052,
-0.0613646731,
-0.0395830981,
0.0154486541,
0.0533323064,
0.0042495481,
0.0139136659,
0.0618607514,
-0.0097779846,
-0.0270826891,
0.0366395004,
-0.0394170769,
-0.0271875318,
-0.0464509316,
-0.0559590273,
0.0176572725,
-0.0153964413,
-0.0210901909,
-0.0490762889,
-0.0873487592,
-0.0574305616,
0.0723576322,
0.0311366133,
0.0293850079,
0.0742123947,
0.0147961369,
-0.0301936381,
0.0602416173,
0.0055269361,
-0.0361988433,
0.0474194735,
0.0430832133,
-0.0140596293,
0.0044266321,
0.0211372282,
-0.0071050161,
0.0039513297,
0.0266901162,
0.007197821,
-0.0358233899,
0.0211075768,
0.0369416364,
0.0265921131,
0.0449690931,
-0.0139377499,
0.0056709438,
-0.0427769609,
0.0348159261,
0.0180910062,
0.0024540212,
0.0071967798,
-0.0189823657,
0.0307361446,
0.0437119566,
-0.0104331914,
-0.026215177,
0.0239580795,
0.0369807519,
0.0061709187,
-0.063865833,
0.0130707566,
0.0059986403,
0.0594833121,
0.0111369183,
-0.0416204929,
0.0473814867,
-0.0391251855,
0.0266370475,
-0.0127819935,
0.0494776964,
0.0049512619,
-0.0063297586,
-0.0488073975,
-0.0179872978,
-0.0775615498,
-0.0229699649,
-0.0015261325,
0.0144374277,
0.0665834248,
-0.0680034235,
0.0135675576,
-0.0768304095,
0.0107765207,
-0.0217704773,
-0.0185649171,
-0.0200747792,
-0.0022467421,
0.0147722512,
0.0054443497,
-0.0321736261,
0.0218958799,
0.1028168127,
0.0023462947,
0.1053435281,
-0.0183790196,
0.0106387166,
-0.0125460466,
-0.0520081744,
-0.0031599873,
-0.0163184702,
-0.0370134003,
0.0012271079,
-0.0764082223,
-0.0688882172,
-0.0061529833,
-0.0241868868,
0.0118053043,
-0.0407663733,
0.0151173929,
0.0554976761,
-0.0360883586,
0.0027708057,
-0.0052057295,
0.0333436355,
0.041408997,
0.0277385842,
-0.0023996101,
-6.298695461e-33,
-0.0060100006,
0.0216290802,
0.045573283,
0.0212101452,
-0.003896466,
0.0191148724,
-0.0086829746,
-0.0046271668,
-0.0395184048,
0.0111546861,
-0.0214952324,
0.0054115131,
0.0278600566,
0.0186945945,
0.0004735665,
-0.0240047518,
0.0578308478,
-0.0268314295,
-0.0178853218,
0.0147837345,
0.0641028658,
0.0485325791,
0.0773366839,
-0.0195822772,
0.0116785327,
-0.0023510121,
0.0083287135,
0.0210945904,
-0.0553265549,
0.0521993749,
-0.0409985073,
0.0462777801,
0.0300895646,
-0.0446796864,
-0.0391535349,
-0.0205619764,
-0.0933343917,
-0.0347794779,
0.0372343473,
0.0138325328,
0.0254108664,
0.0088555841,
0.0204906706,
-0.0322380699,
-0.0118103027,
-0.0019600673,
-0.002874641,
-0.0110513857,
-0.0687398538,
-0.0251263287,
-0.0275006276,
0.0011755965,
0.0402828716,
-0.0051407283,
0.003923283,
-0.0698540732,
0.0048699658,
-0.0393417738,
-0.0764513835,
-0.0008098545,
0.0282213222,
0.0471230112,
0.0079937158,
0.009492442,
0.030404672,
0.0847273469,
0.0486300774,
0.0254295114,
-0.020302292,
0.0163802374,
0.0584550686,
-0.0114957225,
-0.0054664188,
0.0174213368,
0.0467387848,
-0.0239590537,
-0.0521352962,
-0.0363537185,
0.0278207622,
0.0590281971,
0.0177660976,
0.0000463604,
-0.0214284156,
-0.0410640016,
-0.0628992692,
0.0225956142,
-0.0204252042,
0.0192799754,
0.0017047464,
0.0375345424,
0.0183435604,
-0.0271407291,
0.0047112377,
0.0015233381,
-0.034554746,
0.0038126109,
0.0107552046,
-0.0104915882,
-0.024223391,
0.0194959044,
-0.1037353575,
-0.0240821484,
-0.0277305264,
0.0159708969,
-0.0122215524,
0.0335556492,
0.0553414598,
0.0330661945,
-0.0388589427,
0.0014863712,
-0.0327333026,
-0.0114514427,
0.0517361462,
-0.0199455842,
0.0587380715,
0.0417601652,
-0.0039596767,
0.006095761,
0.0578883477,
-0.0195236988,
-0.0485777967,
0.0044411402,
0.0110151563,
0.0497853123,
-0.0153590152,
-0.0129389176,
-0.0418065041,
-0.0126697421,
0.0712902695,
-0.0419755764,
0.0129246674,
-0.0017708038,
2.554e-7,
-0.007587688,
0.02873151,
-0.0026704967,
0.0033221035,
0.0116581507,
0.0465501286,
-0.0638479814,
0.0081992438,
0.0187435262,
-0.0273420811,
-0.0141310701,
0.0530558564,
0.0246892702,
0.0132113351,
-0.0545639023,
-0.0260776114,
-0.0620911494,
-0.0003464884,
-0.0488800704,
0.0024521709,
-0.0203023907,
0.0803252459,
0.0508689396,
-0.0275984574,
0.0275572482,
-0.0808755159,
0.075492017,
-0.0055380659,
0.0023930697,
-0.0014938914,
0.0495036952,
0.0302797873,
0.0080576492,
0.0403476246,
-0.0196915306,
-0.0002319089,
-0.0345211066,
0.0361470468,
0.0254226532,
0.0039098044,
-0.0325506181,
-0.0067310017,
-0.0323261656,
-0.0411924571,
0.0677113235,
-0.0612002201,
-0.0237901546,
-0.0278582964,
0.0170933995,
-0.0036211743,
-0.0022987367,
0.0277366303,
-0.0218674131,
0.0344941989,
-0.016891405,
0.0303890239,
-0.01873192,
-0.0917395577,
-0.0207991805,
0.0239249542,
-0.0342761502,
-0.0933319703,
-0.0165863559,
-0.0348002389,
0.0481300242,
-0.0438009575,
0.0099682296,
2.021768779e-34,
0.0299041793,
-0.0203896463,
0.0133621814,
0.0221092291,
0.0210801214,
-0.0354723521,
0.013662437,
0.0260425042,
-0.0057080626,
-0.0624024197,
0.0052383803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11811v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11811v1 | RepLiQA: A Question-Answering Dataset for Benchmarking LLMs on Unseen Reference Content | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | Joao Monteiro, Pierre-Andre Noel, Etienne Marcotte, Sai Rajeswar, Valentina Zantedeschi, David Vazquez, Nicolas Chapados, Christopher Pal, Perouz Taslakian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on vast amounts of data, most of
which is automatically scraped from the internet. This data includes
encyclopedic documents that harbor a vast amount of general knowledge (e.g.,
Wikipedia) but also potentially overlap with benchmark datasets used for
evaluating LLMs. Consequently, evaluating models on test splits that might have
leaked into the training set is prone to misleading conclusions. To foster
sound evaluation of language models, we introduce a new test dataset named
RepLiQA, suited for question-answering and topic retrieval tasks. RepLiQA is a
collection of five splits of test sets, four of which have not been released to
the internet or exposed to LLM APIs prior to this publication. Each sample in
RepLiQA comprises (1) a reference document crafted by a human annotator and
depicting an imaginary scenario (e.g., a news article) absent from the
internet; (2) a question about the document's topic; (3) a ground-truth answer
derived directly from the information in the document; and (4) the paragraph
extracted from the reference document containing the answer. As such, accurate
answers can only be generated if a model can find relevant content within the
provided document. We run a large-scale benchmark comprising several
state-of-the-art LLMs to uncover differences in performance across models of
various types and sizes in a context-conditional language modeling setting.
Released splits of RepLiQA can be found here:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ServiceNow/repliqa. | [
0.0673538521,
0.036640536,
0.0176114962,
0.0579485781,
-0.0276054107,
0.0146540692,
-0.0269392859,
0.0265033729,
0.0009210711,
-0.0742869526,
-0.0446352325,
-0.0028460021,
-0.0460993461,
-0.0213385765,
0.0232158992,
0.0162838735,
0.0430493243,
-0.0020314967,
0.0079428786,
0.0051748333,
0.0182653032,
0.0340802856,
0.0116272615,
0.0186425373,
-0.0128928572,
-0.0145177124,
0.0142902201,
0.0148153678,
-0.0019680841,
-0.0095118741,
0.065577358,
0.0460026637,
0.0419629961,
0.0102296043,
0.0000014828,
-0.036364574,
0.0169679634,
-0.0100660073,
-0.0396792069,
0.00857314,
0.0118016582,
-0.0115335537,
0.0496350452,
0.0219502263,
-0.0525906123,
0.0180413276,
-0.0131273717,
0.0414592549,
0.0772443265,
0.0897170827,
0.016559016,
-0.0089273574,
0.035068959,
-0.0036691944,
0.0519835614,
-0.0442497768,
0.0333695263,
0.0265638828,
0.0027073077,
0.0201596655,
0.0190271325,
0.024407424,
0.0306603163,
-0.0033633965,
0.0086858887,
0.0121594621,
-0.0624655634,
0.0075642788,
0.0054885121,
0.0942715183,
0.0259694047,
-0.0279903319,
0.010801984,
0.0027771152,
-0.0110956393,
0.0233512055,
-0.0485724993,
0.017899977,
-0.0123684406,
-0.0039679417,
0.0164950229,
-0.0200476665,
0.0212381836,
0.0303581692,
0.0108558899,
0.0900406316,
0.0114264023,
-0.035292916,
0.0099133868,
0.0059239748,
-0.0146827511,
-0.0456864759,
-0.0180886127,
0.0757962391,
-0.0061605945,
0.0249716584,
-0.0307254214,
-0.006996165,
0.0671200007,
-0.0566626303,
-0.0001092293,
0.0123174861,
-0.0163000934,
0.0767051354,
-0.0308714174,
0.0243011899,
-0.0242721159,
0.0172511041,
-0.0443790331,
-0.0434968919,
-0.0112813869,
-0.0271765683,
-0.0179268308,
0.0362943634,
-0.0298912004,
-0.0187828913,
0.0102855228,
0.0313185863,
0.0098676067,
0.0129506793,
0.0080359913,
0.0064944285,
-0.0247877296,
0.0022630126,
-0.0575766377,
0.0073353914,
-0.0395901129,
0.0433201678,
-0.0013077861,
-0.0893418938,
-0.0173268728,
0.0067838617,
0.0066652102,
-0.0313636921,
0.0398921557,
0.057804808,
0.011440048,
-0.0449137762,
-0.0334523469,
-0.0371460803,
0.0182255004,
-0.052200906,
0.0113441553,
-0.0687952414,
0.0382778496,
0.0141499611,
-0.0418450423,
-0.0243850369,
0.0135570858,
0.0746524334,
-0.009237783,
0.0420221239,
-0.0113104675,
0.0057728891,
0.0564705916,
0.029104244,
-0.0049298028,
0.0958757401,
0.0188891087,
-0.006633271,
0.0630896315,
0.0399532951,
0.013365441,
0.0257518031,
0.0439791568,
0.0482720807,
0.0205544084,
0.0839580223,
-0.004065475,
0.0258165244,
0.0319484286,
0.0280398279,
-0.0172810107,
-0.0593004525,
0.0416466817,
0.0502291583,
-0.0208891537,
0.003400984,
0.0191494413,
0.0108727664,
0.0324017517,
0.0056075198,
-0.0279269274,
0.0276071969,
-0.0268480815,
0.0046947757,
0.0484203957,
-0.0132615147,
-0.0459348783,
-0.0246289466,
-0.0210682787,
-0.0068855952,
-0.0157066863,
0.0181124117,
0.0361223668,
0.0263643414,
-0.0286104418,
0.0877331942,
0.0241535231,
-0.0379915945,
0.003109253,
-0.0436204597,
0.0817639828,
0.0113338009,
0.0555364899,
-0.0539654195,
-0.0401122198,
-0.0074509475,
0.0537516773,
0.0389693566,
0.0288533978,
-0.0195151363,
0.0189554803,
-0.0160373878,
-0.0077850623,
-0.0542856455,
0.0139093548,
-0.0217845589,
0.0704006031,
0.0046653957,
0.0325698666,
-0.0760255083,
0.0036548334,
0.0441509299,
-0.0419003181,
-0.010388975,
-0.0019155714,
-0.0276042521,
-0.0068441317,
0.0119271772,
-0.0066418517,
0.0255627967,
0.0618871823,
-0.0263656452,
-0.02305343,
-0.0416515321,
-0.0157961063,
-0.0251125898,
0.0490775071,
-0.0521483682,
-0.0148432311,
0.0578880943,
-0.0616974644,
-0.020812735,
-0.0114162797,
-0.0260365382,
0.0155668547,
-0.0444918312,
-0.0420776606,
0.0168139171,
0.0152062941,
-0.0266421214,
0.0483557954,
-0.0289310999,
0.06496948,
0.0255445186,
0.0125480872,
0.0159343965,
-0.0400263518,
-0.0083265854,
-0.0183704644,
-0.0036068505,
0.0142730437,
0.0243621059,
0.0267293807,
-0.0686893314,
-0.0270505436,
-0.0771328062,
0.0193109363,
-0.0429283008,
0.0321372524,
0.0456737652,
-0.0047706477,
-0.0046048793,
-0.0328556076,
-0.0548528954,
-0.0153872175,
0.0341224931,
0.0256711431,
0.056552384,
0.0083574019,
0.0447653756,
-0.0703951195,
-0.02327751,
0.0029499573,
0.0402397178,
-0.0053361622,
0.0193222556,
-0.0363708623,
0.0129505135,
-0.0594246946,
0.0057207104,
-0.0289949607,
-0.0175791532,
-0.0034801571,
-0.0343007334,
-0.0025606554,
0.0490729176,
0.0112917032,
-0.011972066,
0.0251968205,
0.0254369434,
-0.0780771449,
0.0085713705,
-0.0092329811,
-0.0155721987,
-0.0422591716,
-0.0516941473,
-0.0045817066,
0.0325974934,
-0.0018592831,
0.0065188576,
-0.0289269313,
0.0381863266,
0.0167446677,
-0.0072975317,
-0.0441032052,
-0.000966284,
-0.0055156732,
0.0567623936,
-0.0427781865,
-0.0231466461,
0.056658715,
-0.0340903066,
-0.0003950602,
-0.0156654101,
-0.0050546541,
-0.0800528154,
0.0338498093,
-0.0196047742,
-0.0087398216,
-0.0287375394,
0.0238339864,
-0.0355485827,
-0.0029500583,
0.0057476517,
-0.0662996322,
0.0645745099,
-0.0144508993,
0.0416184366,
-0.03459711,
-0.0348459557,
-0.0573663861,
-0.0590543188,
-0.0271248948,
0.0060803709,
-0.0327362604,
-0.0042921598,
-0.0108379638,
-0.0278728977,
0.0355381817,
0.0256226808,
-0.0225190166,
-0.0139687676,
-0.0086496752,
0.0784110129,
0.0887865722,
0.0465509892,
0.0326203965,
-0.0088632042,
0.0078661311,
0.0509745069,
0.03201285,
0.032014858,
-0.0140289236,
-0.0189854968,
0.0071903151,
-0.0294886325,
0.0126429358,
-0.0095454864,
0.0332129523,
-0.0510420538,
-0.0323652737,
0.1018574089,
0.0285870954,
-0.0332884751,
-0.0229348652,
-0.0317315198,
0.0158865042,
0.0319826901,
0.0221796613,
-0.1018407792,
-0.0216031969,
-0.0285716653,
0.0278737377,
0.002619026,
-0.0200137533,
-0.0156408176,
-0.1064585447,
0.0094477246,
-0.0386636071,
-0.0183608755,
-0.0250673275,
-0.0763908103,
0.0216549281,
-0.0096759154,
-0.0020669138,
0.0131593877,
-0.0255144965,
0.0101424782,
0.0017592188,
-0.011410729,
-0.0291504748,
0.0375153646,
-0.0195377562,
0.022177184,
0.0313229635,
0.0259386674,
-0.0075580254,
-0.0167276375,
0.0339445323,
-0.0593822114,
-0.0238630623,
-0.010906375,
0.0663938075,
-0.0365137383,
0.0054747239,
-0.0124575235,
0.0257951207,
-0.056212049,
0.0075752009,
0.0272586197,
0.0418920554,
-0.0138161201,
-0.0032479961,
-0.0432729684,
0.00817947,
0.0093857227,
0.1195963547,
0.0537324958,
-0.0034146204,
-0.0296349823,
-0.0134498673,
-0.0034172183,
-0.0320360176,
-0.0385501795,
0.00898863,
0.0205499455,
0.0474614389,
-0.0824473798,
-0.0604218319,
0.0006563569,
-0.0057305386,
-0.0324142687,
0.0243585464,
-0.0151393581,
-0.0167778991,
-0.0512009002,
0.0318142958,
-0.0459812209,
0.002641204,
-0.0336003639,
0.0000091168,
0.0521984585,
-0.0237375963,
-0.0325240195,
-0.0021014977,
-0.1046329811,
-0.0433527939,
-0.0243885666,
0.031475734,
0.0193433072,
0.0469913818,
-0.0347936563,
-0.0445020124,
0.04521209,
0.0304143894,
-0.0641392842,
0.0159660317,
0.0143737132,
0.023780359,
0.0044487449,
0.0608790629,
-0.0955905765,
-0.0031127827,
0.0028934504,
0.0324788503,
-0.0346292034,
-0.0419750586,
0.0128575116,
0.0039965273,
0.0097903712,
0.0351521,
0.0101621877,
-0.0216327477,
0.0262048319,
-0.0094997017,
-0.0187518001,
-0.0415440947,
0.0102867233,
0.0016584572,
-0.0424198173,
-0.0214641504,
0.018471187,
-0.0272461344,
0.0694993287,
-0.0492566228,
0.0022999595,
0.0582559295,
0.0052121659,
-0.0120914867,
-0.0258043129,
-0.0511752293,
0.001814489,
-0.024887912,
0.0472001471,
-0.0111395288,
0.0408914723,
0.0268641878,
-0.0269414522,
0.0290891435,
-0.0000679485,
-0.0900196806,
-0.0383758955,
-0.0232382584,
0.0282022189,
0.0315358639,
-0.0061574355,
0.0459491052,
-0.0080180634,
-0.0296517052,
-0.0194988418,
-0.0079200687,
-0.008489944,
-0.0010818697,
0.0669588521,
0.0298428256,
-0.0122657502,
0.0532633401,
0.0871342272,
0.0268388987,
0.0500544459,
0.0119301705,
0.0006242533,
-0.0165996104,
-0.0205506179,
-0.0191052593,
0.0143897263,
-0.0005479042,
0.0060288063,
-0.0315902717,
-0.0626348034,
0.0115760323,
0.0206670575,
-0.0311035309,
0.0023791105,
0.0167435482,
0.0597357266,
0.0334891267,
-0.020101374,
-0.0647838637,
0.0324627198,
-0.0390693508,
-0.0351607427,
-0.0423320383,
-6.136903725e-33,
-0.0182996523,
-0.0174942333,
0.0239430051,
0.0051726899,
-0.0083334576,
0.026077399,
-0.0411478244,
-0.0218285844,
-0.0627015457,
-0.0149771553,
-0.0222257841,
0.0549708977,
-0.00457606,
0.035834834,
-0.028658554,
-0.0527388118,
0.0026895921,
-0.029658597,
-0.0363295339,
0.0251642391,
0.0158784911,
0.021971697,
0.0402807742,
-0.0349887013,
0.0336335711,
-0.0717384145,
0.00258789,
0.0416258015,
-0.0226488449,
0.0818198174,
-0.0293977503,
0.0451651886,
0.0475858562,
-0.0198332481,
-0.0048291334,
0.0395536907,
-0.0943799391,
-0.0483287014,
0.0047137984,
-0.0321276747,
-0.0609245338,
-0.0078146048,
0.0538933277,
0.0012985859,
0.0288827624,
-0.0089095468,
0.0465819277,
-0.0077289031,
-0.0089941248,
-0.0228849128,
-0.0125195039,
0.0169546809,
0.0056207418,
0.0003139041,
-0.0240512602,
0.0670021772,
0.0027393745,
0.0518875495,
-0.0660200492,
0.0042914706,
-0.0157153383,
0.0327169858,
0.0418241657,
-0.0173601806,
-0.0030720311,
0.0488531031,
0.0043301522,
0.0002928406,
-0.003694152,
-0.046401117,
0.0027659379,
0.0197087657,
0.0354338475,
0.063335821,
0.0197618101,
0.0087907249,
-0.0762531832,
0.0513598807,
0.0183303226,
0.029850876,
0.0144596491,
-0.0207835864,
-0.0016626543,
0.007934262,
-0.0634418428,
0.0201556329,
-0.0430733375,
-0.0142351305,
0.0436058342,
0.0155740567,
-0.0011035819,
-0.0111557441,
0.0200667866,
-0.0363542587,
0.0006968559,
0.0728464574,
-0.0271178819,
-0.0009382132,
0.0247872304,
0.0428216383,
-0.0529344939,
0.0254665539,
0.0157852303,
-0.0062619736,
0.000308488,
0.0059009367,
0.0268453211,
-0.0057402747,
-0.0442315489,
-0.0090792356,
-0.0392476358,
0.0166616011,
-0.0359394886,
-0.0056597362,
0.0122506125,
0.021527905,
-0.0052114218,
0.0387868062,
0.0126180947,
0.01521709,
-0.0292314086,
-0.0594784431,
0.0036733993,
0.0143740326,
-0.0329368263,
0.0211939197,
-0.0302336104,
0.0564903393,
-0.0189627297,
-0.0447193794,
0.0103313159,
0.0592187755,
2.215e-7,
0.0749435052,
0.0044622719,
0.0217410047,
0.0467544608,
0.018274188,
-0.0033281664,
-0.020870015,
0.0465761572,
0.025138732,
-0.0458038636,
-0.0058808918,
0.0472729094,
0.0473298207,
0.0173371192,
-0.0802206472,
0.003332373,
-0.0955168232,
-0.0197142418,
-0.0381154753,
-0.0322966836,
0.0154517973,
0.0790641457,
-0.0047231554,
-0.019372439,
-0.0397317857,
-0.0356976166,
0.0746198967,
-0.0424686372,
-0.0257858243,
0.0081845159,
0.052880995,
0.0522605292,
0.0373671204,
-0.0051071602,
-0.0225855839,
0.0172399301,
0.0131259812,
0.05613067,
0.0337458514,
-0.0766540766,
-0.019211933,
-0.0374228917,
0.0338218026,
-0.0409418568,
0.1020480916,
-0.0219197646,
0.0046967822,
-0.0399584286,
-0.0384158753,
-0.0238288101,
0.0247208867,
-0.0259902943,
-0.017691683,
0.0215411615,
0.0028669764,
-0.0138335293,
0.0093664648,
-0.0684246793,
-0.0178004485,
0.011262414,
-0.0598238185,
-0.0406879149,
-0.0344803743,
0.00763172,
-0.0260211769,
-0.0622618347,
0.0102307489,
1.918525708e-34,
0.0173881222,
-0.016596375,
-0.0118818413,
0.0369491763,
0.0199487563,
0.0064177308,
-0.0239800997,
-0.0335639231,
0.001222152,
-0.0852902159,
0.0143021652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11944v1 | Transcoders Find Interpretable LLM Feature Circuits | 2024-06-17T17:49:00 | 2024-06-17T17:49:00 | Jacob Dunefsky, Philippe Chlenski, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | A key goal in mechanistic interpretability is circuit analysis: finding
sparse subgraphs of models corresponding to specific behaviors or capabilities.
However, MLP sublayers make fine-grained circuit analysis on transformer-based
language models difficult. In particular, interpretable features -- such as
those found by sparse autoencoders (SAEs) -- are typically linear combinations
of extremely many neurons, each with its own nonlinearity to account for.
Circuit analysis in this setting thus either yields intractably large circuits
or fails to disentangle local and global behavior. To address this we explore
transcoders, which seek to faithfully approximate a densely activating MLP
layer with a wider, sparsely-activating MLP layer. We successfully train
transcoders on language models with 120M, 410M, and 1.4B parameters, and find
them to perform at least on par with SAEs in terms of sparsity, faithfulness,
and human-interpretability. We then introduce a novel method for using
transcoders to perform weights-based circuit analysis through MLP sublayers.
The resulting circuits neatly factorize into input-dependent and
input-invariant terms. Finally, we apply transcoders to reverse-engineer
unknown circuits in the model, and we obtain novel insights regarding the
greater-than circuit in GPT2-small. Our results suggest that transcoders can
prove effective in decomposing model computations involving MLPs into
interpretable circuits. Code is available at
https://github.com/jacobdunefsky/transcoder_circuits. | [
-0.0330975205,
0.0696484521,
-0.0204844866,
0.0836519226,
0.0126906773,
0.0029352363,
0.0336062908,
0.0103666289,
-0.0182232726,
-0.0153384851,
-0.0366981253,
0.006507528,
0.0019813515,
0.0780028328,
0.0552915633,
0.008199201,
0.0163279641,
-0.027622221,
-0.0886308327,
-0.0501030087,
-0.0053813844,
-0.0047323937,
-0.008210158,
0.0726722479,
0.0463984162,
0.0300446991,
-0.0162838697,
-0.0126672694,
0.0251278169,
0.0631069168,
-0.0604705811,
0.0293656047,
0.0464115515,
0.0344930366,
0.0000020121,
0.0234268419,
0.0045470754,
-0.0153972032,
-0.0799391419,
0.0072833775,
-0.0298384801,
-0.0420377813,
-0.0207484048,
-0.0254779384,
0.0106554674,
-0.0592759438,
0.0777175128,
0.034719035,
0.0222163219,
0.0584144332,
0.0021525489,
-0.0652889907,
0.0714597479,
0.0001075461,
0.0551392026,
-0.0191535056,
0.0056541008,
-0.0457451083,
0.0018204806,
-0.0461575128,
-0.0516018383,
0.0113629662,
0.0440226756,
-0.0064549427,
0.0164305158,
0.0133147035,
-0.0016326213,
-0.0437675491,
-0.0186836664,
0.0361014493,
-0.0182458758,
-0.0318294764,
-0.0337240621,
-0.0031943333,
-0.0495776832,
-0.0155560821,
-0.0161305517,
0.0032230611,
0.0347829238,
0.0370866954,
-0.0288304146,
-0.0320877768,
0.0609467551,
-0.0405467972,
-0.0531655513,
0.0759036615,
0.0149172973,
0.012759557,
-0.0240110755,
0.0003437617,
-0.0050113802,
0.0150603205,
0.0495774373,
0.0121436045,
0.0329292975,
-0.003060576,
0.0047652107,
0.0141637903,
-0.05352211,
0.0027840475,
0.0722818226,
0.0390040465,
-0.0025780811,
-0.0247961283,
-0.0471884795,
0.0682851747,
-0.0606138594,
0.0377876945,
-0.0203217976,
0.0142737525,
-0.0469412915,
-0.0520870052,
0.0278496891,
0.0482123792,
0.0092520518,
-0.0290212501,
-0.0168786664,
0.0145785287,
-0.0475125685,
-0.019707622,
-0.0299519096,
0.0120456805,
-0.0144114494,
-0.0097354818,
-0.0032341457,
0.0591727309,
0.0233063009,
0.0073002181,
-0.0151930777,
-0.03760539,
-0.0253963806,
0.0242744647,
0.0340344533,
-0.01872278,
0.0083170095,
0.0911813453,
0.0087007517,
-0.0300100483,
-0.0726587623,
-0.0066388049,
-0.0195434205,
0.0063947542,
0.0065154489,
-0.0629439577,
0.0358202383,
0.0022887813,
0.0255865119,
-0.0532161482,
0.0107386447,
-0.0027945505,
-0.0363727212,
0.089393504,
0.0169846714,
-0.014988957,
-0.0190130472,
-0.0099679958,
-0.0072305915,
0.0346220694,
0.045575615,
0.0423509069,
-0.0217438061,
-0.0138366902,
0.0056820647,
0.0410919115,
0.0289590675,
-0.01118806,
-0.0689953342,
-0.071944356,
-0.0302121267,
-0.0212801863,
0.0490254499,
0.0224365331,
-0.0253121983,
-0.0269617252,
0.0315729789,
0.0526026376,
0.0441977344,
0.049513258,
0.0691933259,
-0.0120261973,
-0.0266789645,
0.0358031839,
-0.0474288501,
0.04039336,
-0.0601119734,
-0.0020767364,
-0.0132132182,
0.0106870914,
-0.0193560403,
-0.0284881648,
-0.0162468888,
-0.0086147888,
0.0014159717,
-0.0010620054,
0.0403762311,
-0.0065192571,
-0.0493273176,
0.0941969976,
0.0217379835,
-0.0285703,
0.0056169839,
-0.0712765083,
-0.0003111369,
0.0442313403,
0.0103193456,
-0.01420986,
0.0265117716,
-0.0213555284,
-0.045306161,
0.0157230198,
-0.0401681289,
-0.0095229,
0.0550580136,
-0.0142956115,
-0.032181263,
-0.0215286557,
0.0375548378,
0.0559286177,
-0.0665223822,
-0.0407965593,
0.024017211,
-0.0270775966,
-0.0134988064,
-0.008507736,
-0.0298193023,
-0.0097988406,
0.0401122309,
0.0415699072,
0.0181622617,
0.029530054,
-0.0007478257,
0.0058871326,
0.0327770226,
-0.0849544555,
0.0119205862,
-0.0044248542,
-0.02643371,
-0.0306318197,
0.0169619843,
-0.050494682,
-0.0114330091,
0.0501564704,
0.0113578346,
-0.0589397922,
0.0211522412,
-0.0733263567,
0.0368333794,
-0.0240733586,
-0.0149430148,
-0.0002343379,
0.0097277444,
-0.0040234644,
0.033674825,
0.0133892745,
0.0082630236,
0.0168565009,
-0.015018072,
0.0297258981,
-0.0291217621,
-0.0363176502,
0.0225935671,
0.0037104688,
-0.0302304942,
0.02596635,
-0.0290168878,
0.0295141805,
-0.0280311592,
-0.0177221969,
-0.047315076,
-0.0165180154,
0.0098964293,
0.0149240848,
0.0279104803,
0.0418205559,
0.0450090431,
-0.0088524176,
0.0265350062,
-0.0227723885,
0.0333029069,
0.0386873782,
-0.0044783344,
-0.0357763357,
-0.009288365,
-0.0643047467,
-0.0331703722,
0.0909417048,
-0.0279128812,
-0.0051263114,
-0.042965699,
0.0235530827,
0.0552187748,
0.0186074749,
-0.0039702998,
-0.0748063922,
0.0325402431,
-0.0285463277,
0.0058296639,
0.052091226,
-0.0180398002,
0.0706781894,
0.065892987,
-0.00709158,
0.0025529598,
-0.0108324643,
-0.0321054235,
0.0085666487,
-0.0684920922,
-0.0379502922,
-0.0434775203,
0.0877176374,
0.017086599,
-0.0000340046,
-0.0738232285,
-0.012224474,
0.023462737,
-0.0402937792,
-0.0084363669,
-0.0137238018,
-0.0276953634,
0.0705083609,
-0.0109705832,
-0.0092296768,
0.047691375,
-0.0084553072,
-0.0141603379,
0.0202208795,
-0.0132308304,
-0.0403432213,
0.0702763572,
0.0564296395,
0.0342179015,
-0.0001172832,
-0.0097437492,
-0.0191149171,
0.0306373369,
0.0050028884,
0.0077459589,
0.0449877419,
-0.0121669769,
0.0031235463,
0.0036917315,
-0.0303689074,
-0.0098950025,
0.0246425848,
0.0036222313,
0.0291825179,
0.0343436934,
-0.0396685265,
-0.0607333444,
0.0262935981,
0.0249486417,
0.0148202544,
-0.0009061049,
-0.0029189487,
-0.0327789932,
0.0073937932,
0.0055782679,
0.0274468102,
0.0505536199,
-0.0417215787,
0.0068929428,
0.0232911985,
0.00731949,
0.0050792578,
-0.0473992415,
0.0645357743,
0.0321921706,
0.0325991213,
0.0070239259,
-0.020337658,
0.0531613044,
-0.0377401002,
-0.0233852845,
0.0991572812,
0.0069819605,
-0.0708522424,
0.0356083475,
-0.0045712446,
0.0086650522,
0.0445338823,
0.0346866623,
-0.0681149289,
-0.0176554509,
0.0004595169,
0.0165841356,
-0.0060609826,
0.0139343999,
0.0053761345,
-0.0650769547,
0.0207489207,
0.0349455625,
-0.0085969036,
-0.0702205524,
-0.0327806436,
-0.0236242935,
-0.0609527044,
0.0046118712,
0.009892419,
-0.00102,
0.0022259217,
-0.0124855815,
-0.021475058,
-0.0406582244,
0.0364561379,
0.0288558993,
0.0335404389,
0.057484746,
-0.0045278077,
-0.0311079957,
-0.025234364,
0.0295012742,
-0.0031371228,
0.0291803349,
-0.0212319326,
0.0232356228,
0.0627647787,
-0.0397288762,
0.0105735362,
0.0280132666,
-0.0597733296,
-0.0371875316,
-0.0581280291,
0.0694027767,
-0.0482230671,
-0.0466247573,
0.0116844587,
-0.0207933243,
-0.0336657949,
0.0372511707,
0.0558331944,
-0.014949997,
-0.0441758335,
-0.0520743914,
-0.0207607877,
-0.0578505844,
-0.0960050672,
0.0041354927,
0.0607856885,
-0.0561624393,
0.0303078536,
0.0049492661,
0.009530046,
0.026684206,
0.0130039006,
-0.0671511516,
0.0344345532,
-0.0444722548,
-0.0458370596,
0.0149392113,
0.0053621889,
0.0026587753,
-0.0562323853,
-0.0505740568,
0.0161502101,
-0.0583333634,
-0.0317900628,
-0.01914143,
-0.0840163678,
-0.0653230175,
0.0050820471,
0.0311963074,
0.0201920625,
0.0180194862,
0.0053917537,
-0.0149759082,
0.0407752581,
0.0343357883,
-0.0460925624,
0.0380624719,
0.0454475954,
-0.029365303,
-0.0024553849,
0.040649347,
-0.0005998172,
0.0340996794,
0.0473511443,
0.0153312599,
-0.0320733041,
-0.0161286965,
0.0427544191,
-0.0124444868,
0.0314478017,
0.0379851125,
0.0228691828,
-0.0541467778,
0.019068934,
0.0196474493,
0.0310231447,
-0.0756006986,
-0.0247331522,
0.0484495424,
-0.0047002551,
-0.0001532245,
-0.0681616664,
0.016674174,
-0.0069508422,
-0.054387819,
0.0712088794,
0.0146834133,
-0.0317094512,
0.0149192521,
0.0164003521,
-0.0274302624,
0.0521232523,
0.0035302991,
0.0380706228,
0.0226102471,
-0.0116691953,
0.0210768338,
0.0251042992,
-0.0632503182,
0.0214001443,
-0.0679972172,
-0.0558315627,
-0.0152950818,
0.0074684671,
0.030911576,
-0.0143706575,
0.0386879891,
-0.0145634245,
0.0020063899,
-0.0158726033,
0.0224876907,
-0.002947202,
-0.0093080085,
0.0327080972,
0.0323305763,
0.0164762046,
-0.0462878644,
0.0540553108,
0.0326856226,
0.0305281933,
0.0027194344,
0.0292111877,
-0.03214252,
-0.0342578255,
0.0041934387,
0.02285349,
-0.0390183032,
0.0309290737,
0.0076335063,
-0.0713859499,
0.0097241057,
-0.0399952978,
0.0210735463,
-0.0250390042,
-0.0027940255,
0.0200586542,
0.0026406569,
0.0105961999,
0.0045926017,
-0.00125995,
0.048064135,
-0.0176239461,
0.0034940713,
-6.382959304e-33,
-0.0362283736,
-0.0399067365,
-0.0050221989,
0.0600140691,
0.0083315065,
0.0142646842,
-0.0912886411,
0.0028149267,
-0.0098584425,
0.013679482,
0.0168216731,
-0.0124643305,
-0.0012147069,
0.0244914368,
0.0154388128,
-0.0251898523,
0.0508020632,
0.0257225428,
0.0312681384,
0.0058947117,
0.0394351445,
0.0514770187,
0.0835396275,
-0.0580316484,
0.0035183704,
0.0448040329,
-0.0174219981,
0.0055656759,
-0.0293285064,
0.0362291075,
-0.0283410046,
0.0569810905,
0.0048003485,
-0.0252539311,
-0.0164701529,
-0.0291227717,
-0.0450007319,
-0.0040456145,
-0.0051389574,
0.0309758056,
0.0178876705,
-0.0526164062,
0.0681203902,
-0.0233248118,
-0.0311028436,
-0.065999791,
0.0257053766,
-0.0320366696,
0.0128884995,
-0.0136876991,
-0.0637849644,
0.0056326538,
-0.0154482024,
-0.0129615758,
0.0544221699,
0.0119267786,
-0.0353720821,
0.02183301,
-0.0628769472,
0.0105947079,
0.0267539676,
0.0606503524,
0.0476194993,
0.0124142719,
0.0328713879,
0.019520577,
0.0429560244,
-0.0195242781,
-0.0280117746,
0.0049684793,
0.0307978187,
0.069733046,
0.0287995357,
-0.0166924465,
0.0529820807,
-0.0088540437,
-0.03511592,
-0.0074894154,
-0.0100655947,
0.06043569,
0.0343015678,
0.0616634227,
0.000244787,
-0.0319674201,
0.0147077767,
-0.017866591,
-0.0497755259,
-0.0145662921,
-0.0155958571,
-0.0264705587,
-0.0429521054,
0.0063124672,
0.0330065191,
-0.0683129802,
0.0078716744,
0.0129834563,
0.0309718736,
0.0133377109,
0.0093939807,
0.0062204101,
-0.0198599268,
-0.0364063531,
-0.014251546,
-0.0184428282,
0.0175344963,
0.014236073,
-0.0065089623,
0.0923264623,
-0.0056265914,
-0.071681127,
-0.0693479702,
-0.0286216475,
0.0129515426,
0.0966547877,
0.0165593866,
0.002731272,
-0.0238938127,
0.0199491531,
-0.0303518549,
0.0034116914,
0.0075211199,
0.0307871699,
0.0111279292,
0.0566231385,
-0.0574734509,
-0.0675315484,
-0.0550474189,
0.0378445871,
0.0341886953,
-0.0314501785,
-0.0205827914,
0.0076241964,
2.821e-7,
0.0587628931,
-0.0123637561,
0.0303188413,
0.0039170482,
0.0397711471,
0.0166279841,
-0.0012347089,
0.0119715659,
-0.0225328784,
-0.060063459,
0.0327183306,
0.0406427495,
0.052288603,
-0.0008000632,
-0.0404090919,
0.0527151227,
-0.0130064273,
-0.0082674921,
-0.0107978154,
0.0017798364,
0.0141565176,
0.0792379752,
-0.0108552724,
-0.0209434181,
0.0645863563,
0.0076321843,
0.0254577193,
-0.0290238839,
0.033759702,
-0.0247600731,
-0.0267733075,
-0.0407863967,
0.000016114,
0.0180378966,
0.0053756824,
0.0400831364,
-0.0188633855,
0.0329229198,
-0.0345182158,
-0.0415876284,
-0.0012729357,
-0.032635916,
-0.0031915766,
-0.0310583077,
0.0359280221,
-0.0305388104,
-0.0698005557,
-0.027443504,
0.0213261545,
-0.041681163,
0.0087417476,
-0.0231859442,
0.0408200212,
-0.0215370543,
-0.0024635068,
-0.0385450907,
-0.0100183785,
-0.025386706,
0.0255693365,
0.0023145899,
-0.064404279,
0.0072494475,
-0.061833743,
-0.0028067653,
0.0423512831,
0.0154938167,
-0.0553937778,
2.799613595e-34,
0.0063753664,
0.007524027,
0.0112480344,
0.0494036153,
0.0598638952,
-0.0196875259,
-0.0064852019,
-0.0194109622,
-0.0150294127,
-0.0831434131,
-0.0604156032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11801v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11801v1 | Safety Arithmetic: A Framework for Test-time Safety Alignment of Language Models by Steering Parameters and Activations | 2024-06-17T17:48:13 | 2024-06-17T17:48:13 | Rima Hazra, Sayan Layek, Somnath Banerjee, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ensuring the safe alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human values
is critical as they become integral to applications like translation and
question answering. Current alignment methods struggle with dynamic user
intentions and complex objectives, making models vulnerable to generating
harmful content. We propose Safety Arithmetic, a training-free framework
enhancing LLM safety across different scenarios: Base models, Supervised
fine-tuned models (SFT), and Edited models. Safety Arithmetic involves Harm
Direction Removal to avoid harmful content and Safety Alignment to promote safe
responses. Additionally, we present NoIntentEdit, a dataset highlighting edit
instances that could compromise model safety if used unintentionally. Our
experiments show that Safety Arithmetic significantly improves safety measures,
reduces over-safety, and maintains model utility, outperforming existing
methods in ensuring safe content generation. | [
0.0217704847,
0.0649566725,
-0.0029397269,
0.0389035866,
-0.0066667804,
0.0148837259,
-0.0300066844,
-0.0164857693,
-0.014679742,
-0.0168796945,
-0.049258817,
-0.0369759984,
-0.0270288326,
0.0149580082,
0.027021993,
-0.0197098888,
0.0903093815,
-0.0252886266,
-0.0031502354,
0.014885311,
0.0426952206,
0.0191978272,
0.0032776897,
0.0458458327,
-0.0140819028,
-0.0277137887,
-0.0134065542,
0.0425842069,
0.0606688336,
0.0028456363,
0.04638483,
0.0713845491,
0.0020433969,
0.0725505501,
0.0000015912,
-0.0341978669,
-0.0273692776,
0.0070734117,
-0.0344841965,
-0.0121850083,
0.0322201811,
-0.0321708508,
-0.0381456614,
0.0381357595,
-0.0362220556,
0.0257456228,
0.0696496889,
0.041277431,
0.1044071764,
0.0798582435,
-0.0005681173,
0.0247487556,
0.0313605182,
-0.004571157,
-0.0003813044,
-0.0500369556,
0.0384723656,
0.0004952169,
-0.0505588539,
0.024616437,
-0.0032979371,
0.0266137142,
-0.0019123792,
-0.0423101969,
-0.016891541,
-0.0157593302,
-0.0346242078,
-0.0449546352,
-0.0098206662,
0.083297275,
-0.0345504507,
-0.0293222759,
-0.0150120761,
-0.0187238753,
0.0079711685,
-0.0171465259,
-0.0130917234,
0.0099333832,
0.0134675428,
0.0027830775,
0.0170050617,
-0.0261256415,
0.0442042314,
0.0363573171,
0.0666129515,
0.0521872081,
0.0314054415,
-0.0278674979,
-0.0009327988,
-0.0048275078,
-0.0280892812,
-0.0502742529,
0.0041279453,
0.0083556864,
-0.0369899273,
0.0430381335,
-0.0828787908,
-0.0347868428,
0.0535983108,
-0.0782605261,
0.0144147174,
0.0394612551,
0.0190944746,
0.0332158618,
0.015157395,
0.0137586463,
-0.0202843081,
0.0508945994,
-0.0290103145,
0.0184703376,
0.0279995147,
-0.0319982618,
-0.0193964038,
0.0010502153,
-0.0276776813,
0.0350210518,
-0.0493301041,
0.0404668227,
-0.0384146571,
0.0074231713,
0.0165077671,
0.0154435355,
-0.0426062159,
-0.0138363913,
0.0038917272,
0.0116245868,
-0.0228650235,
0.0191270653,
0.0089781517,
-0.0425806046,
-0.0232290477,
0.0192536786,
-0.0202134158,
-0.0404881835,
-0.0129492022,
0.0960737318,
-0.0065652411,
-0.0043140315,
-0.0254793894,
-0.0514052063,
-0.0249644592,
-0.0346182473,
-0.007797719,
-0.0554470979,
0.034649536,
-0.0176244117,
-0.0441533886,
-0.0989965573,
0.0242208093,
0.0488840118,
-0.0513077565,
0.0515566766,
-0.0296746977,
-0.0029460213,
0.0032623829,
0.0163302869,
-0.0276838653,
0.0675835982,
0.0420166291,
0.0173331387,
0.0404004306,
-0.0120141879,
0.0092586745,
0.0681494623,
0.021929305,
0.0442246459,
-0.0388724655,
0.0219116826,
0.0205171779,
0.0182409454,
-0.0044154865,
0.0632437244,
-0.013477481,
-0.023629941,
0.0753673166,
0.0102294246,
-0.0342197008,
0.0327455588,
0.0142077748,
-0.0164957698,
-0.0246522576,
-0.0030657125,
-0.0819626972,
0.0095008304,
-0.0792935789,
-0.0073469304,
0.0116886478,
0.0308363512,
-0.0135673154,
-0.0090395911,
-0.0259116292,
-0.0037538665,
0.0652145222,
-0.0101666534,
0.0021936535,
0.0094477003,
-0.0283670593,
0.040625535,
0.0396000892,
-0.0405646451,
0.0133371474,
-0.0095672067,
0.0010146548,
0.0768729076,
0.0473648421,
-0.0074832728,
-0.0959033519,
-0.0457016416,
0.0234531295,
0.0158631746,
0.0340664126,
-0.0150410216,
0.0272770971,
-0.0326541252,
-0.0547370501,
0.0137444912,
0.0103376303,
-0.0405164212,
0.0639977306,
-0.0070723561,
0.0106448364,
-0.0213631149,
-0.0724084899,
0.0373295993,
-0.0321379825,
-0.046486564,
-0.0329640023,
0.0112148291,
0.0011434194,
-0.0096516078,
-0.0148758311,
-0.0121848276,
0.0252182316,
0.0213037897,
-0.0000821901,
-0.0076019657,
-0.0448788591,
0.0022676461,
0.0630003214,
-0.0238724574,
-0.0614859946,
0.0596622229,
-0.0480682813,
0.000042138,
-0.0249767601,
-0.0231077485,
-0.0279722791,
-0.0275281556,
0.0232221037,
-0.0016795362,
-0.0285586976,
-0.0315996371,
0.0595220923,
-0.0045928238,
0.0034127717,
-0.0004953972,
-0.0468987189,
-0.0057993424,
-0.0083247051,
-0.0358284563,
-0.0121781388,
-0.0295190793,
0.0557205379,
0.0361265913,
0.0334550291,
-0.0504693761,
-0.0138563262,
-0.0459110662,
0.0185171794,
-0.031920407,
0.035826236,
0.0480684824,
0.0190762598,
-0.0167886969,
-0.0067809932,
-0.0378080755,
-0.0147176785,
0.0013020209,
0.0308210794,
0.0170192644,
-0.0212608483,
-0.0068483735,
-0.0544136055,
0.0022213492,
-0.0368901342,
0.0144060208,
-0.0088103786,
-0.0164885633,
-0.0479326658,
0.0183232799,
-0.0427032411,
0.037361823,
0.0167921856,
-0.0661001429,
-0.0111121722,
0.031201452,
0.008687404,
0.0634237155,
0.0349681489,
0.0090256641,
0.0483245291,
0.0311898254,
-0.0598303303,
0.0229864977,
-0.0130547825,
-0.0499659553,
-0.0165986642,
-0.0285543595,
-0.0089927968,
0.0482008755,
-0.003251276,
-0.0070044678,
-0.0674967542,
0.0271455534,
-0.0258898735,
-0.0260988325,
-0.0034733487,
-0.0425322168,
-0.0468735285,
0.0220446978,
-0.0408322848,
-0.0554278232,
0.0799339563,
0.0093905255,
0.0321797468,
-0.0218875464,
-0.0035701627,
0.0131575884,
0.0193693992,
-0.0198520385,
0.0617803819,
0.0088529466,
-0.0165468156,
-0.07665544,
-0.0171591286,
0.0425912999,
-0.0450629815,
0.0606277175,
-0.0516966209,
0.0022393924,
-0.0211726576,
-0.0593469888,
-0.0695367754,
-0.0958475918,
0.0056936615,
-0.005574327,
-0.0061591403,
-0.0159030445,
-0.0188393705,
-0.0173566863,
0.0316330157,
0.0106190601,
-0.0410399139,
0.0158868488,
-0.0182863306,
0.0110707711,
0.1163080707,
-0.0357560776,
0.0178126618,
-0.0452017635,
0.0348549336,
0.0805925876,
0.0040188241,
-0.000925819,
-0.0141707407,
-0.0191357695,
0.0350259766,
-0.0155190052,
0.0112007912,
0.0277054422,
0.0617627762,
-0.0142149087,
-0.0162116531,
0.0670449585,
0.0202136189,
-0.0087991795,
0.0090271123,
-0.0286670178,
0.043874789,
0.0099846506,
0.0086838817,
-0.0545541979,
-0.0254913848,
0.0204016063,
0.0315490626,
0.0248725954,
-0.0188648347,
0.0217585918,
-0.0756989494,
0.0057254359,
0.0338065885,
-0.0600214303,
-0.0282663237,
0.0107719405,
0.0248247217,
-0.0112072323,
0.0674206093,
0.0202886574,
-0.0099050933,
-0.0403561853,
0.0187057033,
0.0288749784,
-0.050211899,
0.0027428148,
-0.0563903004,
0.0588411428,
0.0812781304,
-0.0038795869,
-0.0061765905,
-0.0389532559,
0.038113948,
0.0246536043,
-0.0100965649,
0.0181676801,
0.0331572071,
-0.0249102917,
0.0025752184,
-0.0015922682,
0.0343755633,
-0.0024238434,
-0.0246958248,
-0.0059644738,
0.0733230487,
-0.0020226983,
0.014072164,
-0.0317931995,
0.0147100734,
0.036625158,
0.0660633445,
0.0157336965,
-0.0530225895,
0.0144070443,
-0.0382392332,
-0.0072420547,
-0.0192247201,
-0.0520468093,
0.008289515,
-0.0158532243,
-0.030807104,
-0.0710893944,
-0.0351206474,
0.0180841032,
0.019852547,
0.039464213,
-0.016566528,
-0.013224354,
-0.0056324941,
-0.0125720631,
0.0422481783,
-0.0395107791,
0.022288667,
-0.0365015715,
0.0471527949,
-0.0080868853,
0.0041787326,
-0.0042503569,
0.0315502509,
-0.0695402995,
-0.1080040932,
0.0265168268,
0.0834403038,
0.0213931054,
0.0323663205,
-0.0301954933,
-0.0519996211,
0.0208097063,
0.0353054777,
-0.0427184664,
-0.0104348725,
0.019251531,
-0.0295793209,
0.004997578,
0.0347904153,
-0.0583370924,
-0.0502997898,
0.0395232923,
0.0471984483,
-0.0496274233,
-0.0531202145,
0.0161500107,
0.0044069244,
0.0352715291,
-0.0130437762,
0.0077449563,
-0.0163852647,
0.0161837526,
-0.0159052368,
-0.0490810461,
0.0048179636,
0.0346724577,
0.0322310291,
-0.0221861675,
-0.0044564269,
-0.0043039275,
-0.0288992114,
0.0445695817,
-0.0327789932,
-0.0155784031,
-0.0003351519,
0.0278359558,
0.0380033664,
0.0280889533,
-0.0402940996,
0.0363422744,
0.001842499,
0.0222069621,
-0.0118734613,
0.0386557616,
0.0182794146,
0.0282519963,
-0.006710012,
0.0433907583,
-0.0183528606,
-0.0550928898,
-0.0685821921,
-0.0139526138,
0.0243034028,
-0.0096699363,
0.0571407489,
-0.0163841564,
-0.0356930941,
-0.0290518794,
0.007542544,
-0.0066141193,
-0.0531855933,
0.028772587,
0.0220571812,
-0.0112279439,
-0.0077832188,
0.0663987771,
-0.0131838908,
0.0525302552,
0.0020234117,
-0.0273793079,
-0.0225805715,
-0.0066002402,
0.0425716452,
0.0038096549,
-0.0469262451,
-0.0215215012,
-0.040373642,
-0.0917270854,
-0.0097892871,
0.025147086,
-0.0229533017,
0.0165249128,
0.0374387503,
0.0434565395,
-0.0131150158,
0.0027093652,
-0.0195023548,
-0.0150022348,
0.0000477934,
-0.0177571829,
-0.0540156364,
-5.922612207e-33,
0.0077285753,
-0.0066519068,
0.0008759103,
-0.0120639978,
-0.0158420503,
-0.016616175,
0.001513919,
0.0291692484,
-0.0211875308,
0.0064495909,
-0.0138193276,
0.0301073939,
-0.0037237271,
0.0132146263,
-0.0111090383,
-0.0534614511,
0.0212288778,
-0.0074012494,
-0.0324556231,
0.010416151,
0.018588908,
0.0021153269,
0.0726356432,
-0.0913679153,
0.0412523821,
0.0102242408,
-0.0296612494,
0.0301724263,
-0.043027401,
0.0783423111,
0.0169123001,
0.0326988995,
-0.0066959294,
-0.0214231797,
-0.0050055371,
0.0179428905,
-0.0158773102,
-0.0154073201,
0.0302723087,
-0.0059559052,
-0.0587940738,
-0.0725378543,
0.0688556656,
-0.0340478905,
-0.0176270176,
-0.0203747023,
0.0096674357,
-0.0101590566,
-0.0104639968,
-0.0192289352,
-0.0732104629,
0.0120527791,
-0.0005107902,
-0.0518955253,
-0.0099730175,
0.03773579,
0.035032589,
-0.0207315814,
-0.0411056951,
-0.0269225352,
0.0216636322,
0.0234382208,
0.0864587352,
0.006429879,
-0.018479282,
0.0736618936,
-0.0397335663,
0.0045748977,
0.013462306,
-0.0146038644,
0.0054661655,
0.0243796296,
0.0378043279,
0.0753694251,
0.0059063551,
-0.0046728295,
-0.0739674717,
0.0473181233,
-0.0609502047,
0.0629359186,
0.0158129595,
-0.0004736625,
-0.0476375669,
0.0139544178,
-0.0430567898,
0.0148050506,
-0.0392605253,
-0.0357861519,
0.0192075092,
-0.0026368299,
-0.0444448441,
-0.0258773305,
0.0002271767,
-0.0262809638,
0.0322240852,
0.0542206205,
0.0090364218,
-0.0270880442,
-0.0022839736,
0.049231194,
0.0019363253,
0.0030861879,
-0.0009560584,
-0.0485572144,
0.0224582665,
0.0227761697,
0.0682014003,
0.0437666215,
-0.0706775039,
0.0257327929,
-0.0390305333,
0.0567162186,
-0.0041973051,
0.002432591,
0.0578386784,
0.0024462498,
0.0113358703,
0.0288060531,
0.0708795488,
0.0272177774,
-0.038391497,
0.0043520355,
-0.0106818788,
0.0097312415,
-0.0021685057,
0.0024224967,
0.0176467225,
0.0191469304,
0.0281523988,
-0.0802288726,
0.0049386951,
0.0285848565,
2.397e-7,
0.0615694858,
0.0447075814,
0.0372034088,
0.0367844738,
0.0001784382,
0.0639620274,
-0.016054431,
0.0533516519,
0.0199382603,
0.0146678025,
0.0299754851,
-0.0025916831,
0.062179327,
0.0561385825,
-0.0556033701,
0.0027330774,
-0.0839746296,
0.0407048576,
-0.0349572822,
-0.0211473312,
0.0601495616,
0.0993188247,
-0.0055174241,
-0.0071690953,
-0.0166507419,
-0.0375512354,
0.0549224243,
-0.0382636823,
-0.0015766022,
0.0050075692,
0.0267880224,
0.0232052207,
0.0094223022,
-0.0078673819,
-0.0256416854,
-0.0063430038,
-0.0077445656,
0.0901156962,
-0.0394994318,
-0.025919972,
-0.0186064318,
-0.058731623,
0.0236033276,
-0.048460938,
0.0485748686,
-0.0368686616,
0.0147869624,
-0.0182580166,
-0.0286784768,
0.00682852,
0.0341667831,
-0.0443464704,
-0.0273955576,
0.0143713783,
0.027958842,
0.0322421566,
-0.0350889489,
-0.0416925848,
-0.0434329882,
0.0047026342,
-0.0057009179,
-0.0608728491,
-0.0124023482,
0.0275456551,
-0.0213195328,
-0.0849662349,
0.021881735,
2.110440084e-34,
-0.0054771411,
-0.0556656569,
0.0294648297,
-0.0027737126,
0.0462160744,
0.0112585053,
0.0119964154,
-0.0037429121,
0.0058202106,
-0.0370941348,
-0.0289770719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11794v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11794v3 | DataComp-LM: In search of the next generation of training sets for language models | 2024-06-17T17:42:57 | 2024-06-20T17:43:05 | Jeffrey Li, Alex Fang, Georgios Smyrnis, Maor Ivgi, Matt Jordan, Samir Gadre, Hritik Bansal, Etash Guha, Sedrick Keh, Kushal Arora, Saurabh Garg, Rui Xin, Niklas Muennighoff, Reinhard Heckel, Jean Mercat, Mayee Chen, Suchin Gururangan, Mitchell Wortsman, Alon Albalak, Yonatan Bitton, Marianna Nezhurina, Amro Abbas, Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Dhruba Ghosh, Josh Gardner, Maciej Kilian, Hanlin Zhang, Rulin Shao, Sarah Pratt, Sunny Sanyal, Gabriel Ilharco, Giannis Daras, Kalyani Marathe, Aaron Gokaslan, Jieyu Zhang, Khyathi Chandu, Thao Nguyen, Igor Vasiljevic, Sham Kakade, Shuran Song, Sujay Sanghavi, Fartash Faghri, Sewoong Oh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Kyle Lo, Alaaeldin El-Nouby, Hadi Pouransari, Alexander Toshev, Stephanie Wang, Dirk Groeneveld, Luca Soldaini, Pang Wei Koh, Jenia Jitsev, Thomas Kollar, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Yair Carmon, Achal Dave, Ludwig Schmidt, Vaishaal Shankar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We introduce DataComp for Language Models (DCLM), a testbed for controlled
dataset experiments with the goal of improving language models. As part of
DCLM, we provide a standardized corpus of 240T tokens extracted from Common
Crawl, effective pretraining recipes based on the OpenLM framework, and a broad
suite of 53 downstream evaluations. Participants in the DCLM benchmark can
experiment with data curation strategies such as deduplication, filtering, and
data mixing at model scales ranging from 412M to 7B parameters. As a baseline
for DCLM, we conduct extensive experiments and find that model-based filtering
is key to assembling a high-quality training set. The resulting dataset,
DCLM-Baseline enables training a 7B parameter language model from scratch to
64% 5-shot accuracy on MMLU with 2.6T training tokens. Compared to MAP-Neo, the
previous state-of-the-art in open-data language models, DCLM-Baseline
represents a 6.6 percentage point improvement on MMLU while being trained with
40% less compute. Our baseline model is also comparable to Mistral-7B-v0.3 and
Llama 3 8B on MMLU (63% & 66%), and performs similarly on an average of 53
natural language understanding tasks while being trained with 6.6x less compute
than Llama 3 8B. Our results highlight the importance of dataset design for
training language models and offer a starting point for further research on
data curation. | [
0.024711879,
0.0859969035,
0.0054054414,
0.0189138632,
-0.0105617922,
0.0075518093,
0.0123937801,
-0.0020535872,
0.0044269185,
-0.0512852333,
-0.0217358898,
-0.0138303703,
-0.0181418322,
0.0458173305,
0.0169950053,
-0.0282226261,
0.0414237455,
-0.0265195202,
-0.0142611153,
-0.0041462765,
-0.006279056,
0.0369004458,
0.0162545852,
0.0324665718,
0.0302664433,
-0.0152619565,
-0.0030024278,
0.0345972329,
-0.0224122163,
-0.030476395,
0.0078752916,
0.0390238278,
0.0498887748,
0.0670709088,
0.0000020677,
-0.053875532,
-0.0237095077,
-0.0084230192,
-0.0458763354,
-0.0193143096,
0.0525529198,
-0.0068885502,
0.0421725288,
0.0559419878,
-0.0254131146,
-0.0521787703,
0.0203535967,
0.0302400365,
0.0644369721,
0.0755071193,
-0.00631188,
-0.0434276462,
0.0266440269,
-0.0310062729,
-0.0435965508,
-0.0020831181,
0.0331088938,
0.024231676,
0.0258100126,
0.0093179857,
-0.0046561779,
0.0284697339,
0.0007340992,
-0.0060165199,
-0.0145190135,
0.0517436527,
-0.0453473479,
-0.0612584054,
0.008532553,
0.1066388041,
-0.0528068505,
-0.0524141267,
-0.0035334823,
-0.0079492591,
-0.0257130619,
-0.0077908821,
-0.0471687131,
0.0209484547,
0.0223759878,
0.0500876829,
0.0098400302,
-0.0309555884,
0.0626146048,
0.0256187674,
-0.0353513993,
0.0394392237,
0.0252021495,
-0.0288048591,
0.0166139714,
-0.006537552,
0.0019514832,
-0.0622918084,
-0.0107096788,
0.0125789465,
-0.0178066529,
0.0127822841,
-0.0433316976,
-0.029327536,
0.0383928306,
-0.0192642454,
0.0583429746,
0.0398854986,
-0.048439566,
0.073910147,
-0.0238408297,
0.0260335729,
0.0009694105,
0.0455378518,
-0.0444495529,
-0.0321702212,
-0.0294168759,
0.0068518906,
-0.0319869444,
0.0345293544,
-0.0486010984,
-0.0024854743,
0.0038052539,
0.0014618114,
0.0036365942,
-0.0092171188,
0.0313071012,
-0.0234167408,
-0.0224640705,
0.0069221235,
-0.0026896875,
-0.0044406978,
-0.0184020922,
0.0478749238,
0.0082267839,
-0.1087356061,
-0.0426714011,
-0.009242529,
0.0213087369,
-0.0528215989,
0.0376955867,
0.0452977233,
0.0189478416,
-0.0566225648,
-0.0291161258,
0.007405146,
0.0247153305,
-0.050116051,
-0.0150393099,
-0.0706564933,
0.048220478,
-0.0239758473,
0.0358721875,
-0.0429409742,
-0.0059863734,
0.0352763981,
-0.0406263173,
0.0914846286,
-0.0550025068,
0.0118102953,
-0.0151118105,
-0.0218159761,
-0.0003136931,
0.0988821536,
0.0034293921,
0.0139214164,
0.0546391085,
0.0012002683,
-0.0161849521,
0.0060489881,
0.0357087925,
0.0140292933,
-0.017431261,
0.0292928685,
-0.0019880682,
0.0355142131,
0.0598075725,
0.0337681286,
-0.0541404672,
-0.0251644496,
0.0574611351,
0.0281980764,
0.050793115,
-0.0064369063,
0.0084369173,
0.0294542871,
0.0147720883,
-0.0343148448,
-0.0487441421,
-0.0132516241,
0.0022960906,
0.0104220621,
0.0165432114,
0.0387975574,
-0.0452478714,
-0.0169799235,
-0.049098067,
-0.0019572491,
0.0220306907,
0.0237300601,
0.0418363363,
0.0237798151,
-0.0282629486,
0.0343789756,
0.0577136725,
-0.0470692292,
-0.0054780869,
-0.0442383438,
0.030655548,
0.031953007,
0.0636922196,
-0.0252990797,
-0.0419389717,
-0.0236482993,
0.046517279,
0.0376108885,
0.0402508415,
-0.0216480047,
0.0621253885,
-0.0735213906,
-0.0235822313,
-0.0336047076,
-0.0043033152,
0.0096365875,
0.0150194438,
-0.0090391105,
0.0000132905,
-0.0456012189,
-0.0368803181,
0.0606288351,
-0.0223277565,
-0.0287546273,
-0.0069667064,
-0.0153050693,
0.0411462486,
0.0129323173,
-0.0076272902,
-0.0053921659,
0.057547085,
-0.0190215204,
0.0108317742,
-0.0078809438,
-0.0329461694,
-0.0492431968,
0.0768192187,
-0.0131014315,
0.0034384469,
0.0937391445,
-0.0566803254,
-0.0447759666,
0.0003448373,
-0.0115513466,
0.0587902814,
-0.0667146742,
0.0166320987,
-0.0063863224,
0.0405048057,
-0.025396103,
0.0331226438,
-0.0151788509,
0.0194674954,
0.0079156151,
0.0094822124,
0.021048367,
-0.0439617001,
-0.0359830856,
0.0349816158,
-0.0014208442,
0.0110075418,
-0.0010467513,
0.0248734728,
-0.042265933,
-0.0096625192,
-0.0720138848,
0.0071533583,
-0.0351228267,
0.0033929299,
0.030565666,
0.0184640456,
-0.021535309,
-0.0236659758,
-0.0085399123,
-0.045346871,
0.0165416878,
0.0110481596,
0.0173984468,
0.0078740381,
-0.0147804096,
-0.051089637,
-0.0449192561,
-0.0048197871,
0.0578679144,
-0.0426125862,
-0.0125875203,
0.0001206844,
0.0133072287,
-0.0423217639,
0.0290211421,
-0.0155081963,
-0.022312101,
0.0051512145,
-0.0371687263,
0.0001961658,
0.0226173885,
-0.0174905416,
0.0219418108,
0.0641478151,
-0.0198059157,
-0.0646446943,
0.003467798,
-0.0289900396,
-0.0067695887,
-0.0201494694,
0.0140154511,
-0.0023592559,
0.0595865697,
-0.0373346508,
-0.0136066843,
-0.0427156016,
0.003350836,
-0.020377107,
-0.0367735848,
-0.0444532521,
0.0218520202,
-0.0262681749,
0.0173432827,
-0.0673767105,
-0.0504845902,
0.0512229875,
-0.0484525077,
-0.0161962584,
-0.0471604615,
-0.0140896831,
-0.0405733883,
0.0378776155,
0.0039732317,
0.0138697177,
-0.0086130826,
-0.0214394424,
-0.0268323217,
0.0238350183,
0.0087913759,
-0.0496898033,
0.045705542,
-0.0302102249,
0.0269683283,
-0.0057749744,
-0.0198181737,
-0.0451740026,
-0.0254298672,
-0.0142760864,
0.0300692506,
-0.0131628839,
0.0018989685,
-0.033766333,
-0.0022626857,
-0.0246625915,
0.0700819641,
0.0028754899,
0.0064397384,
-0.0224690456,
0.0205891393,
0.0446750261,
0.0149366986,
0.0302978121,
-0.0053207329,
0.0299567785,
0.0296759699,
0.0671249032,
-0.0256168451,
-0.0263383035,
0.0414303765,
0.063472122,
-0.0216036178,
0.0092796898,
-0.0102725029,
0.0365980193,
-0.0402977951,
-0.0228423811,
0.1100877821,
0.0233473666,
-0.0423738584,
-0.0137272319,
-0.0149575025,
0.0446785502,
0.0303438175,
-0.0013181693,
-0.0737035051,
-0.0396387279,
0.0264577772,
0.0384396352,
0.0197236557,
-0.0318433046,
-0.038159769,
-0.1049343199,
0.0075654299,
-0.0109943561,
-0.0470741987,
-0.0249862745,
-0.0825690851,
-0.0088468762,
-0.0480767228,
0.0455595478,
0.0219351351,
-0.0243811533,
-0.0094189439,
0.0257467572,
0.0093425633,
-0.0816846713,
0.0369070582,
-0.0426624566,
0.0636691377,
0.0170656648,
0.0480865762,
0.0084142536,
-0.009526711,
0.053259559,
-0.0287261624,
-0.0227441434,
-0.0182572734,
0.0509011522,
-0.0429836921,
-0.0100368112,
0.0078178924,
0.0285276454,
-0.0548249222,
-0.0199377891,
-0.0278017428,
0.060466107,
-0.0048479815,
-0.0026068583,
-0.0116346944,
-0.0291918796,
-0.0162819587,
0.0852334052,
0.0349471234,
0.0073604295,
-0.018351227,
0.0066247149,
-0.0201044939,
-0.0036338484,
0.0174592678,
0.0327611193,
-0.0352004804,
-0.0000129208,
-0.0358127393,
-0.0559160821,
0.0550859123,
0.0394180492,
0.0108474446,
0.0238295849,
-0.0112886662,
-0.003786674,
-0.0475554764,
0.0843936056,
-0.044756718,
0.0126031907,
-0.0621753894,
-0.0248528495,
-0.0032816313,
0.0009544311,
-0.0299943946,
0.0422143377,
-0.1165205464,
-0.0670462623,
0.0174559951,
0.0339370146,
0.0332936309,
0.0510903709,
-0.0311918929,
-0.0476673953,
0.0194804259,
-0.0038552538,
-0.0433298685,
-0.0041242596,
0.0351191871,
-0.0542074926,
0.028709311,
0.0351459831,
-0.0652240813,
0.0081296796,
0.0064532724,
0.0333065726,
-0.0097616632,
0.0112558845,
0.034237951,
0.0343737863,
0.0560204349,
-0.0165507961,
0.0081909643,
-0.0783806071,
0.0258200672,
-0.0262942556,
0.0085508917,
-0.0421399437,
0.0431466103,
0.0379983149,
0.0013437557,
-0.0217488278,
0.0014200989,
-0.0420161895,
0.0550891049,
-0.0449717753,
0.0126423966,
0.0045485846,
0.0021335636,
0.0241401605,
-0.0081035877,
-0.0214726608,
0.0156812668,
-0.0268155131,
0.015669113,
-0.0265022889,
-0.0049312636,
0.0095432103,
0.0140848616,
-0.0180376191,
0.0534809232,
-0.0639761835,
-0.0376999266,
-0.0406016745,
-0.003476752,
0.0512182154,
-0.0194039438,
0.0671932548,
-0.012660468,
-0.0020522771,
-0.0163333155,
0.0141889052,
-0.0045259777,
-0.0171900559,
0.0382659025,
0.02868196,
-0.0397996418,
-0.0045207273,
0.1053499877,
0.0251122974,
0.0563934408,
0.0029532448,
0.035817448,
-0.0195428245,
0.0021684901,
0.0271023139,
0.062812224,
-0.02455757,
-0.0125832437,
-0.0271938294,
-0.0558935255,
0.0039873547,
-0.0066173398,
-0.0059526516,
0.0113027077,
0.0491345376,
0.0457942039,
0.0188914575,
-0.0122299343,
-0.0363601297,
-0.0285197515,
0.037828669,
-0.0134730758,
0.0144287571,
-6.86947658e-33,
-0.002653941,
0.0388455316,
0.0068905917,
-0.0278148428,
-0.0221134592,
0.0186063368,
-0.0164924562,
-0.0445936397,
-0.0588164963,
-0.0152738485,
-0.0114892917,
0.0487517305,
0.0198886041,
0.0223839227,
-0.0312240887,
0.0002993256,
0.0683092773,
-0.012122212,
-0.0085647777,
-0.002388221,
0.0272428636,
0.0559376143,
0.059777692,
-0.0144552262,
-0.0077646133,
-0.0042751604,
0.0066852379,
0.0207345467,
0.0182854924,
0.0403688811,
-0.0243153796,
0.0318219364,
0.0280315429,
-0.0236318596,
-0.0470927134,
-0.0170825664,
-0.1046865508,
-0.0281385817,
0.029992016,
0.0194152296,
-0.0080169421,
-0.0016847146,
0.0290440824,
-0.0099967141,
0.01613071,
0.000842768,
0.0069316202,
-0.0088771647,
-0.0554967336,
0.0146892862,
-0.0034015756,
0.041765064,
0.0038937738,
-0.0097183222,
0.0471894667,
0.0428255312,
-0.0063854759,
0.0604481064,
-0.0588550791,
0.0246489421,
0.0136604253,
0.0157574564,
0.0559888966,
0.0148168309,
0.0570025817,
0.0693603083,
0.010169127,
-0.0152609199,
-0.0141572608,
0.0266062003,
0.0417036302,
0.0642635226,
0.0080283303,
0.0312525406,
0.0500964448,
-0.0355476774,
-0.0666980073,
0.0186425429,
0.0086508691,
0.046877142,
-0.0028713718,
0.0369944833,
-0.019848749,
-0.0074370592,
-0.0463507287,
-0.0244001634,
-0.0323768668,
-0.0169655625,
0.0479752272,
0.0380933061,
-0.0198015496,
-0.0296295937,
0.0250829998,
-0.045862034,
-0.0274665169,
0.0129768597,
0.0010620636,
-0.0378660746,
0.0039229346,
0.0431367718,
-0.078528665,
-0.0417400822,
0.0472451523,
-0.0093385139,
0.0027532161,
-0.0031890916,
0.0166859869,
0.0306952633,
-0.0565547422,
0.008589088,
-0.053865511,
0.0139096649,
-0.0026397954,
0.0380189121,
0.051656846,
0.01753469,
0.0141357603,
0.0264476277,
0.0406459272,
0.0086658048,
-0.0333649777,
-0.0119444467,
0.0048168851,
0.0203859638,
-0.0179337878,
-0.0294112768,
-0.0467653535,
0.0036793933,
0.053180173,
-0.0626621097,
-0.0146119464,
0.0333388448,
2.831e-7,
0.0323929936,
0.0360082351,
0.0253230855,
0.0342326574,
-0.0090727257,
-0.0101440698,
-0.0378179289,
0.0325321369,
-0.0033132231,
-0.0098120216,
-0.0236095544,
0.0113498485,
0.0470554829,
0.0455192886,
-0.0940685123,
-0.008037352,
-0.071144931,
-0.0214522593,
-0.0517341383,
-0.0527089424,
0.0200696997,
0.147961095,
0.0227446537,
-0.0226547047,
0.0014068132,
-0.0440302938,
0.0377733968,
-0.035191834,
-0.0273997206,
-0.0140995681,
0.0685322657,
0.03882505,
0.0107862251,
-0.0064753438,
-0.0233809091,
0.0265110712,
0.0268900059,
0.037108466,
-0.0137930363,
-0.0302393697,
0.0269979332,
-0.0391787142,
-0.0322774798,
-0.0885810778,
0.090646252,
0.0025336319,
-0.0178157929,
-0.0362959318,
-0.0447975211,
-0.0050102235,
0.0291917473,
-0.0257933829,
-0.0193591788,
0.0392054617,
0.0210351124,
-0.0267372876,
-0.019648239,
-0.093913883,
-0.0348632224,
-0.0110991448,
-0.0253018439,
-0.0541178212,
-0.03574083,
-0.030580949,
0.0328047872,
-0.0464655347,
-0.004735467,
2.793569442e-34,
0.0372033678,
-0.0029447614,
0.020136144,
0.0071756341,
-0.0061487239,
-0.0378189422,
0.0014946959,
-0.0010521483,
-0.0211170018,
-0.090305917,
0.002542679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11785v1 | CELL your Model: Contrastive Explanation Methods for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:39:10 | 2024-06-17T17:39:10 | Ronny Luss, Erik Miehling, Amit Dhurandhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The advent of black-box deep neural network classification models has sparked
the need to explain their decisions. However, in the case of generative AI such
as large language models (LLMs), there is no class prediction to explain.
Rather, one can ask why an LLM output a particular response to a given prompt.
In this paper, we answer this question by proposing, to the best of our
knowledge, the first contrastive explanation methods requiring simply
black-box/query access. Our explanations suggest that an LLM outputs a reply to
a given prompt because if the prompt was slightly modified, the LLM would have
given a different response that is either less preferable or contradicts the
original response. The key insight is that contrastive explanations simply
require a distance function that has meaning to the user and not necessarily a
real valued representation of a specific response (viz. class label). We offer
two algorithms for finding contrastive explanations: i) A myopic algorithm,
which although effective in creating contrasts, requires many model calls and
ii) A budgeted algorithm, our main algorithmic contribution, which
intelligently creates contrasts adhering to a query budget, necessary for
longer contexts. We show the efficacy of these methods on diverse natural
language tasks such as open-text generation, automated red teaming, and
explaining conversational degradation. | [
0.022955047,
0.0671441481,
-0.015947666,
0.0316062905,
-0.049096033,
0.0269037355,
0.0364826024,
-0.0053705848,
-0.0392984226,
-0.0435397215,
0.0240552332,
-0.0455360971,
0.0045712045,
0.0388935581,
0.0030617644,
-0.0731686652,
0.0247626659,
-0.0208674073,
-0.005985063,
-0.0072290031,
-0.0193456765,
0.0287971981,
-0.0040475498,
0.0532806143,
0.0245979298,
-0.0211414117,
-0.067425102,
0.019671062,
0.007852897,
0.0104854982,
0.0229905751,
0.0504634343,
0.0203428622,
0.0299382787,
0.0000021294,
-0.0253643915,
-0.0307744052,
-0.0058797668,
-0.0602492914,
0.0138584627,
0.0062640761,
0.0077323532,
0.0191542394,
0.0414627716,
-0.0307025388,
-0.0150586097,
0.0774620026,
0.0517630912,
0.0437647142,
0.0744518042,
0.0185962692,
-0.0365144648,
-0.0171135198,
-0.0230287835,
0.0138125634,
-0.0382066034,
-0.0037931434,
-0.0183672495,
0.0072354996,
0.0092454581,
-0.0096519822,
0.0107688894,
0.0753279254,
-0.0477148816,
0.001864466,
0.0191877689,
-0.0130691379,
-0.0141282938,
0.006593076,
0.0715788603,
-0.0076808291,
-0.0064278715,
0.0007620795,
-0.0208672155,
2.205e-7,
-0.027909277,
-0.0297829695,
0.0002744641,
0.0129398936,
0.0168778952,
0.0146629503,
0.0177040733,
0.0431429036,
0.0594902225,
-0.0411215127,
0.0370303653,
-0.0194954108,
-0.0074357213,
-0.0358010195,
-0.0008238112,
-0.0064312448,
-0.0809180737,
0.0294171106,
0.0786933675,
-0.0489461459,
0.0074490309,
-0.0094618406,
-0.0354085714,
0.0064079515,
-0.0013566241,
0.0396551974,
0.0321622752,
-0.0486041568,
0.0335514285,
-0.0195563193,
0.0458537005,
-0.0352513529,
0.0051865894,
-0.0169278979,
-0.0262272302,
-0.0560596026,
-0.0277044605,
-0.0254346319,
-0.0009220249,
-0.0556303822,
0.0082142502,
-0.0295562893,
0.0183553044,
-0.0207103994,
0.0083511183,
0.0121553326,
0.0402895026,
-0.0293265209,
-0.0509085804,
-0.0333599225,
-0.0033364177,
-0.0512131192,
-0.0267838612,
0.036869362,
-0.0864949375,
-0.0349828154,
0.0266003925,
-0.0040048119,
-0.0225394573,
-0.005376183,
0.074770771,
-0.0236395672,
0.0076574846,
-0.0372239649,
-0.0480304211,
-0.0459434688,
-0.0439491831,
-0.0209813602,
-0.0383589268,
-0.0095152846,
0.0067667207,
-0.0380928703,
-0.0234634485,
0.0147895999,
-0.0105912676,
-0.0059982194,
0.0599282049,
-0.0332769975,
0.0011521588,
0.0236950964,
0.0213762019,
-0.0049222815,
0.0442779362,
0.0023205518,
-0.0086669941,
0.0042514028,
-0.0576231889,
0.0268967059,
-0.0176231116,
0.0099471305,
-0.0223148782,
-0.0442885198,
-0.0057203909,
-0.0222213846,
0.0500213616,
0.0257838424,
0.0283634514,
-0.0295754261,
-0.0262678973,
0.0406010188,
0.0201651454,
0.0309784133,
0.0275682062,
0.0468084589,
0.0060035693,
-0.0347139388,
0.0726267174,
-0.0118772397,
0.0369842164,
0.0015266367,
-0.0072210403,
0.0474296063,
0.0197551977,
-0.0208640974,
-0.1073293462,
0.0068352851,
0.0095991017,
-0.0060018231,
0.0318529382,
0.0399479829,
0.0189497396,
-0.0336619355,
0.0355466232,
0.0521302186,
-0.0239248276,
-0.0038202067,
-0.09563604,
0.0395977311,
0.0979323164,
0.0356537253,
-0.047010988,
-0.0095733013,
-0.0098551093,
-0.0100342492,
0.0647783428,
0.0490575247,
0.000681119,
0.0211784374,
-0.0781892687,
-0.011591441,
-0.0308074635,
0.0341581143,
0.0522970818,
0.0039935582,
-0.0314643718,
0.044747442,
-0.0138548268,
-0.05324037,
0.0305577591,
0.0101741981,
-0.0660343841,
0.0671526715,
0.0097192163,
0.0258752573,
0.0256370641,
0.0132735269,
0.0137971342,
-0.0265043844,
-0.0241431575,
-0.0363012478,
0.0046947324,
-0.0619499646,
-0.0254565347,
-0.0063870866,
-0.0099623371,
0.0046904893,
0.0543786511,
-0.0438975468,
-0.0573692024,
0.031869106,
-0.0465476699,
0.0541249439,
-0.0354487896,
0.0210519657,
0.0054055168,
0.0221925024,
-0.0310528353,
0.0609393679,
0.0008305164,
0.001432886,
0.026794754,
0.016269993,
0.0032669127,
-0.0563627928,
0.0162106119,
0.0128296874,
-0.0306828264,
0.0141314287,
0.0027629728,
0.0088466443,
-0.0416317917,
0.0086004157,
-0.0352423787,
-0.0055262204,
-0.0388990268,
-0.0011003155,
0.0369752236,
0.0001503084,
0.0253905989,
-0.0152578959,
-0.0394429676,
0.0254861414,
0.0026835697,
0.0200023446,
0.0676558539,
0.0260473788,
-0.0392601639,
-0.0525263846,
-0.000799331,
-0.0006664594,
0.0781068504,
0.0116902059,
0.0128378291,
-0.0617536195,
0.0238139257,
-0.0100136343,
0.0193851925,
-0.0127448123,
-0.0642146841,
0.0390389822,
-0.022496758,
-0.0003891888,
0.0666523501,
0.0384425372,
0.0665583163,
0.0524787083,
0.0246606097,
-0.0675700381,
0.0125084324,
-0.0466216356,
-0.022452876,
-0.0144779244,
-0.067870304,
0.0019637553,
0.1025213525,
-0.0154680349,
-0.0127156796,
-0.0546121225,
-0.0010823128,
0.0372599475,
-0.033697933,
-0.0108325249,
-0.0119941588,
-0.003530079,
0.0505475365,
-0.0064806477,
-0.0522150099,
0.0838934928,
-0.0229223408,
0.0074418699,
-0.0071193571,
-0.0536594763,
-0.0363620333,
0.0741691515,
-0.0150754787,
0.0064381883,
0.0299872495,
-0.0152526619,
-0.02333677,
-0.0355296582,
0.0185889043,
-0.003592747,
0.0248957407,
-0.0534675159,
-0.024239732,
0.0151631776,
-0.0398721844,
-0.0537937023,
-0.049507238,
-0.0490384363,
0.0245343242,
0.0252765324,
-0.0356842242,
-0.0244571939,
0.0053419871,
0.0064742719,
0.0437544994,
-0.0159397293,
0.0036829151,
-0.0377514474,
0.0118613057,
0.0246706121,
0.0298420507,
0.0522543862,
-0.0479602069,
0.0443906486,
0.0381927863,
0.0000802869,
0.0254953317,
-0.051734224,
-0.0307623819,
0.0009449265,
-0.020644268,
-0.0409459844,
0.0140256537,
0.0251319222,
-0.101339221,
-0.0113065634,
0.1178846583,
0.0216060169,
-0.0493683107,
0.0138138784,
-0.0413391069,
0.0456441715,
-0.0143011352,
0.0264872592,
-0.0375431217,
-0.0518912338,
0.0082917269,
0.0346384645,
-0.0291324109,
-0.0053694714,
-0.0143288868,
-0.1218651161,
0.021696968,
0.0055525163,
-0.0312033352,
-0.0262669027,
-0.0119405435,
-0.0239183754,
0.0057629365,
0.0080302553,
0.0033074676,
0.0572449379,
0.010640203,
0.0420765691,
-0.023336133,
-0.037661396,
0.0051031746,
-0.0029957655,
0.0294366907,
0.0437715799,
0.0232532155,
0.0007024302,
-0.0137062604,
0.0357432812,
-0.0377876498,
0.0367200263,
-0.0125846928,
0.0806942061,
0.0237169359,
-0.0271346457,
-0.0179338232,
0.0371532403,
-0.023251256,
-0.0049917432,
-0.0106339473,
0.02698786,
-0.024751883,
-0.0256927591,
0.0073441141,
0.0201190151,
0.059288539,
0.0778951794,
0.0535561703,
-0.0472959317,
-0.0549109913,
-0.0338163078,
0.0084583694,
-0.0957389921,
0.0047634109,
-0.0090100951,
0.0297689401,
-0.0215848964,
-0.0272569433,
-0.024579769,
0.0099185342,
0.0306699034,
-0.0222888868,
-0.0411783531,
-0.0591780879,
-0.0182580967,
-0.0108491424,
0.0378326364,
0.0056691053,
0.0066486876,
-0.0395292044,
-0.0421541519,
0.0157273188,
-0.0688420013,
-0.0235207062,
-0.014345726,
-0.0282041505,
-0.0548101775,
0.0017382799,
0.029108556,
0.0273661688,
0.0537247434,
0.0004012718,
-0.115953058,
0.0077990228,
0.0525191054,
0.0057823379,
-0.0154295415,
0.0574758872,
0.0175175387,
-0.0038383419,
0.0528894588,
-0.0241683424,
0.0157049764,
0.0119522521,
0.0031304155,
-0.0642840117,
-0.0253290497,
0.0304204635,
-0.0185096841,
0.0415654071,
-0.0034434861,
-0.0463607684,
-0.0182712581,
0.0299478974,
-0.00830663,
-0.0366658308,
-0.0500368513,
0.0312044844,
0.001413285,
-0.0165163185,
0.0193031207,
-0.0321202539,
-0.0210102554,
0.0054287198,
-0.0224624798,
0.0165184382,
0.0439120308,
-0.0034948764,
0.0132288132,
0.0075179795,
-0.0166426692,
0.0280688908,
0.0104562566,
0.0610420704,
0.0264066495,
0.0830544978,
0.032011617,
0.013030665,
-0.0025976489,
0.0039038749,
-0.082502611,
-0.0592684634,
0.0423356444,
0.0313084684,
0.0364712104,
-0.0037080343,
0.0311077479,
-0.008115516,
-0.0269297976,
-0.0205414314,
0.0851146802,
0.0362991057,
-0.0274953246,
0.0158631075,
0.0364652909,
-0.0299474914,
0.0028541062,
0.0635524467,
0.0133730639,
0.0384680778,
0.0152772134,
0.0008004389,
-0.0078328662,
-0.012207007,
0.0139199505,
0.0375984386,
0.019840518,
0.0114610773,
-0.051097244,
-0.0602337718,
-0.0073466073,
0.0222091991,
-0.0047036647,
-0.0221119076,
0.0255048349,
0.068243593,
0.0048471293,
-0.0144830337,
-0.0376049504,
0.0506154038,
-0.0493865609,
0.0041210642,
-0.0211500879,
-6.911868579e-33,
-0.0225944258,
-0.0908591747,
-0.0147553366,
-0.0411179028,
0.007415677,
0.0332483202,
-0.0389283076,
-0.0137734227,
-0.0257462785,
0.0546129197,
0.007201036,
0.03025629,
0.0046414458,
0.0297987442,
-0.0182192512,
-0.0496499985,
0.0441402867,
0.0282869563,
-0.0362891294,
0.0368351638,
0.0434357189,
0.0206555314,
0.0077808863,
-0.0504596829,
0.0229040142,
0.0003405107,
-0.0200978778,
0.0444147028,
-0.0455775559,
0.0547592826,
-0.0064622676,
0.0422816947,
0.0189752653,
-0.029754838,
-0.0160499904,
0.0590977445,
-0.0232344791,
0.0088643609,
0.0160161089,
0.0027158353,
-0.0931925252,
-0.0574667603,
0.0382644013,
0.0173613504,
0.0135203879,
-0.0508663952,
0.0269529112,
-0.0282809008,
-0.0037642915,
0.0135732088,
-0.0122550102,
0.0449389108,
-0.0478390977,
-0.069901213,
0.0051813428,
0.0614958517,
-0.0010474561,
0.0011133795,
0.0097467043,
-0.0124468822,
0.0636635497,
0.0235087536,
0.0617158599,
0.0485342965,
-0.0254509095,
0.0395580344,
0.0390793309,
0.0145296566,
-0.0589118116,
-0.0302451681,
-0.047202602,
0.036188554,
0.0881012976,
0.038880676,
0.0279595945,
0.0247574057,
-0.0495648906,
-0.0016684013,
-0.0090185963,
0.0043133539,
0.0438837223,
0.0065127853,
-0.0380376056,
-0.0256191827,
-0.035834264,
-0.0634519383,
-0.0374485739,
0.0016286061,
0.0204311535,
0.0038876147,
-0.057524018,
-0.0347965099,
-0.0065004905,
-0.0298796073,
0.0340960473,
0.0201681536,
-0.0294724014,
-0.001388158,
0.0082326205,
0.0119436095,
-0.0126887579,
-0.0190349258,
0.0099146031,
0.0107832579,
0.0230895206,
0.0169530995,
0.0424535386,
0.0131891472,
-0.0318679698,
0.001376141,
-0.0479732193,
0.0256678388,
-0.048943229,
0.0074531259,
0.008885392,
-0.0136392154,
-0.0385259427,
0.0846922621,
0.0198897943,
0.0056258729,
-0.0227289461,
-0.018008016,
-0.0231269617,
0.0059166378,
-0.0337830968,
0.0004663675,
0.0052626566,
-0.0070381546,
0.0608845763,
-0.0240776557,
-0.0254777558,
-0.0076387287,
2.715e-7,
0.0328457206,
0.0076257973,
0.0362459123,
0.0361107886,
0.0208891407,
0.0706842467,
0.041645091,
-0.0116456887,
-0.0070936969,
-0.0120068565,
0.0088968351,
0.046109762,
0.0810116976,
0.0002357192,
-0.019696584,
-0.0102498811,
-0.0888632536,
-0.0195718836,
-0.039346654,
-0.028422229,
0.0842333883,
0.0463049337,
0.0113018267,
-0.0178342871,
0.0319768749,
-0.0192255601,
0.0364300646,
-0.0281861331,
0.0239006411,
0.009814335,
0.040222194,
0.009752607,
-0.0044151559,
0.0033043888,
0.0029693239,
-0.0087825637,
-0.0305886939,
0.0750981122,
-0.00323481,
-0.0547790192,
-0.0179736763,
-0.0079986304,
0.0154024735,
-0.0691024587,
0.0831957906,
-0.0058056945,
-0.0135561842,
-0.0345734395,
0.0014739037,
-0.0367111713,
-0.0016584026,
-0.030470904,
-0.0123757515,
0.0234634113,
-0.0206233989,
-0.0344231203,
-0.0101993848,
-0.0900278464,
-0.0504325964,
-0.0147774005,
-0.0368640125,
-0.0057736151,
-0.0348618999,
0.0094313221,
0.0606431477,
-0.0293324329,
0.0048039998,
2.538479591e-34,
0.0410141163,
0.0274415202,
0.0143984249,
0.0338937826,
0.0498993322,
0.0260848626,
-0.0194459856,
-0.0141275199,
0.0898395777,
-0.0596675389,
-0.0273465868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11784v1 | MDCR: A Dataset for Multi-Document Conditional Reasoning | 2024-06-17T17:38:43 | 2024-06-17T17:38:43 | Peter Baile Chen, Yi Zhang, Chunwei Liu, Sejal Gupta, Yoon Kim, Michael Cafarella | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The same real-life questions posed to different individuals may lead to
different answers based on their unique situations. For instance, whether a
student is eligible for a scholarship depends on eligibility conditions, such
as major or degree required. ConditionalQA was proposed to evaluate models'
capability of reading a document and answering eligibility questions,
considering unmentioned conditions. However, it is limited to questions on
single documents, neglecting harder cases that may require cross-document
reasoning and optimization, for example, "What is the maximum number of
scholarships attainable?" Such questions over multiple documents are not only
more challenging due to more context having to understand, but also because the
model has to (1) explore all possible combinations of unmentioned conditions
and (2) understand the relationship between conditions across documents, to
reason about the optimal outcome. To evaluate models' capability of answering
such questions, we propose a new dataset MDCR, which can reflect real-world
challenges and serve as a new test bed for complex conditional reasoning that
requires optimization. We evaluate this dataset using the most recent LLMs and
demonstrate their limitations in solving this task. We believe this dataset
will facilitate future research in answering optimization questions with
unknown conditions. | [
0.0251831822,
0.0580341369,
0.0108853932,
0.0353076719,
-0.0454703644,
0.0420537293,
0.0254775286,
0.0202829745,
0.0217949059,
-0.0026788283,
-0.000938599,
-0.0030546444,
-0.0439083725,
-0.0164794326,
-0.0069335713,
-0.0118767126,
0.0259334873,
-0.0154429823,
0.0037295679,
-0.0281061325,
-0.0065746959,
0.0362888575,
-0.0305310469,
-0.0144218588,
-0.0165332723,
-0.0440172441,
-0.0260663237,
0.0167358052,
0.0348932967,
-0.013253957,
0.0083098691,
0.0413162485,
0.0305415764,
-0.0497135185,
0.0000019523,
-0.0579302981,
-0.0472593047,
-0.0204535797,
-0.0441547409,
-0.0506512113,
0.0209823102,
0.0067230468,
0.0540586375,
0.0094186291,
-0.0487108715,
0.028417591,
0.001403295,
0.0698946938,
0.036045894,
0.081695579,
0.001651098,
-0.0724887922,
0.0062438464,
-0.0029508071,
0.0570884049,
-0.0809660777,
0.0180376731,
0.0252271947,
0.0183491763,
-0.0493661202,
0.0184784215,
0.0212842207,
0.0406658202,
-0.0013597191,
-0.015952386,
0.0198592134,
-0.0292664673,
-0.0003290294,
-0.000919331,
0.0788503289,
0.034216851,
0.0173590295,
0.0270204283,
-0.0386492684,
0.0274695363,
0.0412616767,
-0.0087765306,
-0.0026134914,
-0.06439998,
-0.0155555839,
0.0105303805,
0.0162658151,
0.0264592227,
0.022860609,
-0.0528898351,
0.1051298827,
-0.0306043327,
-0.040821407,
0.0541115329,
0.0039967629,
-0.0326875262,
-0.0306628402,
0.0161522422,
0.0406612679,
-0.0417354777,
0.0321428329,
-0.009100371,
-0.0129766492,
0.0302522164,
-0.0212364886,
0.0546224527,
0.0271908864,
0.023601288,
0.0712195858,
-0.0196095239,
0.0069733053,
-0.0580657981,
-0.0023876843,
-0.0307546053,
-0.0111291548,
-0.0538795516,
-0.0124885794,
-0.0127334008,
0.0528755672,
-0.0197006911,
0.0108929072,
-0.0242740475,
0.0273646824,
-0.0246420857,
0.0461680219,
0.0281049628,
0.0197518729,
-0.0196377896,
-0.0338903479,
-0.0835819766,
-0.0396461673,
-0.0390138775,
0.0620861389,
-0.0088934768,
0.02602938,
0.0108944904,
-0.0079809213,
0.0135682933,
-0.0635857731,
0.0263146088,
0.0931567103,
0.0265652183,
0.0066582025,
-0.0689030588,
-0.0725262389,
0.022230003,
-0.0775707513,
0.029029591,
-0.0475861803,
0.0498745106,
0.0091034407,
-0.0361526683,
-0.0154734561,
-0.0107230498,
0.0131923566,
0.0312569253,
0.0883911327,
0.0773823336,
-0.0235283431,
0.0497505255,
0.0094532706,
-0.0290447995,
0.0834818259,
0.0347556211,
0.0308349412,
0.0260836966,
0.0061552133,
-0.0201300252,
0.0252814107,
0.0023169324,
0.023726372,
0.0159336012,
0.0724310726,
-0.001332122,
0.0473024622,
-0.0414566919,
-0.0283656977,
-0.0392237902,
-0.0516453795,
-0.0038521702,
0.0475819856,
0.051758334,
-0.0281193946,
0.001477537,
0.0320103504,
0.014749242,
0.0300540868,
-0.003051477,
0.0456182994,
-0.0226112194,
-0.0014374388,
-0.0235827137,
0.0070208488,
-0.0165605377,
-0.0741605759,
-0.0268475953,
-0.0028389392,
-0.0382314399,
0.0335597321,
0.0500373505,
-0.0193043649,
-0.0284797847,
0.0237181783,
0.0119414032,
-0.0376585498,
-0.0393665582,
-0.0247387625,
0.0386734158,
0.0140817687,
0.0617340617,
-0.095812723,
-0.0407380499,
0.0012910301,
-0.0055005155,
-0.0139439153,
0.0607193932,
-0.0163123626,
0.0336680859,
-0.0461594723,
-0.0211790353,
-0.0281744469,
-0.0017822939,
0.025671687,
0.0251990594,
-0.0027358078,
-0.0208871644,
-0.0106979059,
0.0379359163,
0.0380360559,
-0.07254906,
-0.0051052063,
0.0230683815,
0.0131074898,
0.0462221988,
-0.0065131309,
0.0099061802,
0.0012283085,
0.0185082629,
-0.0020712346,
-0.0265040025,
-0.0308419708,
-0.032122869,
-0.0077942302,
0.0172773078,
-0.0616040528,
-0.0379020311,
0.0374197923,
-0.0586851276,
-0.0359582379,
-0.0195740853,
0.0082139913,
-0.0050490103,
-0.0373269618,
-0.0164366178,
0.0120643377,
-0.020945251,
0.0025656982,
0.0731522515,
-0.0031671512,
0.0174637176,
0.011872286,
-0.0142389899,
0.0367223136,
-0.0444434397,
0.0532394089,
-0.0341180116,
0.0039187754,
-0.0066641094,
0.0127253085,
0.0279529709,
-0.0635028034,
-0.0375876166,
-0.0206674617,
0.0396942571,
-0.003142376,
0.0177814718,
-0.0007055581,
-0.016942028,
-0.0059482818,
0.0123744877,
-0.0548576228,
0.0181845315,
-0.0044986741,
-0.024261687,
0.0659138635,
-0.0171259362,
0.058391545,
-0.0190973245,
-0.0130117042,
-0.036773175,
0.0298991036,
0.047230158,
0.0062361606,
-0.0084991325,
0.0464555435,
-0.0086617824,
0.02407079,
-0.0230504535,
0.0437882133,
-0.0105068181,
-0.0272553898,
0.0015895943,
0.0766036958,
-0.0548196211,
0.0026854612,
0.0632855445,
-0.0009404378,
-0.0634039789,
0.0385133885,
-0.0008634492,
0.0553867146,
-0.0633996055,
-0.0456141084,
-0.0140030477,
0.0032815915,
-0.0027563502,
-0.0242807083,
-0.0322781168,
0.0438696072,
-0.002559047,
-0.0339211486,
-0.0521568209,
0.0207686052,
0.030594103,
0.0833420828,
0.0190542843,
0.0061332858,
0.1069657281,
0.0176045764,
0.0029129407,
-0.0414225385,
0.0197640415,
-0.0953140035,
0.0459744297,
-0.0158217251,
-0.0146082761,
-0.0147229983,
0.0068382975,
-0.0459128022,
-0.014023128,
0.0395755209,
-0.0194375571,
0.0628068745,
-0.0535751395,
0.0049142828,
-0.0443758033,
-0.0373508483,
-0.0098774573,
-0.0451513119,
0.0162413511,
-0.0019130399,
-0.0084578404,
-0.0290254839,
-0.069625102,
-0.0420934558,
0.0089578629,
0.0427906252,
-0.0424376987,
-0.023480624,
-0.0269507114,
0.0470061228,
0.0363486968,
0.0004890206,
0.0067112548,
-0.0488766953,
0.0200238582,
0.0338318124,
0.0129072862,
-0.0129889892,
0.0305134505,
0.0397036038,
0.0203614105,
-0.0422178358,
0.0612858273,
-0.0123669785,
0.0179485735,
-0.0895586535,
0.0144793913,
0.0766574591,
0.0414052904,
-0.0432420261,
-0.0074542719,
-0.0849401057,
0.0046009338,
0.0133257639,
0.0515798964,
-0.1017221659,
-0.0324302092,
-0.0141865602,
0.0130181173,
-0.0247820318,
-0.0315056778,
-0.0141264163,
-0.0401067324,
0.0355118178,
-0.0137417922,
0.0291682109,
0.0214910451,
-0.0159962382,
-0.0401739329,
-0.0477630012,
-0.0202095378,
-0.0238858629,
0.0092090601,
-0.0202471204,
-0.0232268237,
0.0157119799,
-0.0095999064,
0.0474876277,
0.0151078086,
-0.0119873621,
0.0044961581,
0.0485664159,
-0.0141681787,
-0.0599424802,
0.0121866148,
0.0060056881,
-0.0426653177,
0.0039554457,
0.0138403894,
0.0034136341,
0.0172458999,
-0.0240351707,
0.0349657908,
-0.0279761478,
-0.0182714649,
0.0784871951,
0.0482140146,
-0.0411958992,
-0.0239993334,
-0.026863236,
-0.0035766757,
-0.0392761379,
0.0685417727,
0.0094493637,
-0.0323433727,
-0.0458521768,
-0.0261542536,
-0.035383977,
-0.0667886809,
0.0391500331,
0.0008257899,
-0.0227292608,
0.0544452369,
-0.0158272814,
-0.0321437493,
0.0465263464,
0.0107823424,
-0.0337946974,
-0.0217224471,
0.0457090512,
-0.0202308279,
-0.0471134,
0.0433999561,
-0.0209949315,
0.0178080611,
-0.0145047978,
0.0069476888,
0.0157112814,
-0.0256307553,
-0.0461729653,
0.0024516592,
-0.0646954775,
-0.0369201824,
-0.0430982113,
-0.0086452682,
0.0267089643,
0.0378084071,
-0.0280132629,
-0.0369961634,
-0.0185365807,
-0.0271527339,
-0.012952528,
-0.0212965664,
0.049567949,
0.0011918831,
-0.0121604521,
0.023575021,
-0.0258684941,
0.024977928,
0.0017719208,
-0.0064500198,
-0.0347324163,
0.0086477231,
0.0192222167,
0.0255455431,
-0.0285537727,
0.0342905149,
-0.0222023539,
-0.0484747998,
0.0755310282,
-0.0196636971,
-0.0299542416,
-0.0034441194,
-0.0194859933,
0.0465346351,
-0.0373919159,
-0.0183568019,
-0.0543259643,
-0.0263549164,
0.0074866037,
-0.0210925862,
0.0533453152,
0.0676083714,
0.0123905055,
0.0362500772,
-0.0694702417,
-0.0255752634,
0.010065604,
-0.020061342,
0.0590256266,
-0.009944276,
0.0534149781,
0.0525345728,
0.0066677895,
-0.0006418777,
-0.0310044158,
-0.049676165,
-0.0268567745,
0.0232503451,
0.0159976464,
0.0152433431,
0.0178892016,
-0.0055801533,
-0.0199621525,
-0.0072818678,
0.027662456,
0.0040552653,
0.0043763844,
-0.0182056502,
0.0515675619,
0.0451314971,
0.0014881248,
-0.0007652715,
0.0396763273,
0.0079052215,
0.0414189883,
-0.0553598851,
-0.011355944,
-0.055527214,
-0.0403026007,
0.0188374501,
0.026432693,
-0.0105212005,
0.0360883735,
-0.0903802067,
-0.0453517772,
0.0406646878,
0.0404964052,
-0.0061605475,
0.0301498361,
-0.0099798059,
0.0321118832,
0.0093591008,
-0.0344946347,
-0.0257369429,
0.0144872675,
-0.0699347407,
-0.0363712572,
-0.016082719,
-5.819406007e-33,
-0.0135042854,
-0.0302798543,
0.0665413961,
-0.0197162498,
0.0253897253,
0.0010831914,
-0.0089898333,
-0.0600416251,
-0.030249102,
-0.0023374604,
-0.0236791093,
0.0215343516,
0.0132620325,
0.0235737748,
0.0085757906,
-0.0121616758,
-0.0146599794,
0.0087892776,
-0.035035301,
0.004747319,
0.0144701134,
-0.0174573995,
0.027482301,
-0.0127642984,
0.0414274633,
-0.0224667899,
-0.0131154023,
0.0351187922,
-0.1006720513,
0.0524589196,
-0.0160118081,
-0.0155973881,
0.0418713763,
-0.0146356113,
0.0364691019,
0.0275516789,
-0.0802471563,
-0.0396494009,
0.0220339969,
-0.0046102912,
-0.0547853708,
-0.0273109004,
-0.0141252708,
0.042468071,
0.0197711028,
-0.0514023677,
0.0505782478,
-0.0299922246,
0.0097080134,
-0.0449909419,
-0.0164393727,
0.0447296202,
-0.043119859,
0.0417180546,
-0.0071612196,
0.0867556259,
-0.0160048548,
0.0472694375,
-0.0300476085,
0.0023876135,
-0.0052428101,
-0.0025834821,
0.0516739823,
-0.0294556282,
-0.0156443361,
0.0392127149,
0.0155651784,
-0.0028448976,
-0.012868179,
-0.0385266021,
-0.0154899638,
0.0518152714,
0.0298190992,
0.0446266644,
0.0264018606,
0.017983323,
-0.096170418,
0.0286958888,
-0.0020735753,
0.050541386,
0.0352224894,
-0.0211427603,
-0.0004495955,
0.0024845013,
-0.0655388162,
0.0341658071,
-0.0388498828,
0.0356512032,
0.0296848062,
-0.0365100466,
0.0033333539,
0.0183916576,
0.0142618008,
-0.0373660438,
-0.0074606175,
0.0498337112,
0.0231868438,
0.0271909181,
-0.0060792868,
0.0813150555,
-0.0335796699,
-0.0153368702,
0.0058587827,
-0.0422361828,
0.0433093011,
0.0226401892,
0.0674515441,
-0.0169382915,
-0.0270586964,
-0.0387031585,
-0.047021877,
0.0209085513,
0.0054961033,
0.0426407084,
0.0186091289,
0.0370056294,
-0.0062414142,
0.0220420342,
0.0042958544,
0.0018745037,
-0.0461741276,
-0.0352860913,
-0.0070073227,
0.0445957705,
-0.0009973288,
0.0183271188,
-0.0134541942,
0.0040746089,
0.0289566871,
-0.0165731162,
0.010308926,
0.0812920034,
2.595e-7,
0.0582503676,
0.0373688489,
-0.0182877555,
0.0351620354,
-0.0185310002,
0.0212932117,
-0.0726625919,
0.0049319896,
0.0141541185,
0.0058863382,
0.0266151354,
0.0346763805,
0.0374740101,
0.0445410311,
-0.086201638,
-0.0105375201,
-0.0275897533,
-0.0391227603,
-0.0502214804,
0.019682724,
0.0708943084,
0.031247627,
0.0321980529,
-0.0353842452,
-0.0181940366,
-0.0126833124,
0.027900992,
-0.0400463976,
-0.0092284987,
0.0127546424,
0.0543870218,
-0.0380322598,
0.0233710706,
0.0395981707,
-0.0102369236,
0.0464146398,
-0.0090581402,
0.0897646844,
0.0123514729,
-0.0433100238,
0.0025871084,
-0.0416387059,
0.0100547932,
-0.0159424506,
0.0954665616,
-0.0114006214,
-0.0416814834,
-0.0211519748,
-0.010106449,
-0.0212542005,
0.0071047419,
0.0173731707,
0.0370050259,
0.0046117683,
-0.0066287681,
-0.0383066088,
0.0215231776,
-0.0577426516,
0.0057605882,
0.0353205539,
-0.0144892763,
-0.0317650214,
-0.0047442033,
0.024141632,
0.0452573448,
-0.0903738439,
-0.0297659785,
2.185037368e-34,
0.0392520428,
0.0126758385,
-0.0089366557,
0.0223789234,
0.054828275,
-0.0102716647,
-0.045009125,
0.0215900093,
-0.0086420719,
-0.0899911895,
0.0037019288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11780v1 | Split, Unlearn, Merge: Leveraging Data Attributes for More Effective Unlearning in LLMs | 2024-06-17T17:35:52 | 2024-06-17T17:35:52 | Swanand Ravindra Kadhe, Farhan Ahmed, Dennis Wei, Nathalie Baracaldo, Inkit Padhi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown to pose social and ethical risks such
as generating toxic language or facilitating malicious use of hazardous
knowledge. Machine unlearning is a promising approach to improve LLM safety by
directly removing harmful behaviors and knowledge. In this paper, we propose
"SPlit, UNlearn, MerGE" (SPUNGE), a framework that can be used with any
unlearning method to amplify its effectiveness. SPUNGE leverages data
attributes during unlearning by splitting unlearning data into subsets based on
specific attribute values, unlearning each subset separately, and merging the
unlearned models. We empirically demonstrate that SPUNGE significantly improves
the performance of two recent unlearning methods on state-of-the-art LLMs while
maintaining their general capabilities on standard academic benchmarks. | [
-0.022184791,
0.0887220576,
-0.0155829843,
0.0535844788,
-0.0338533148,
0.0334420241,
0.0169807691,
0.0159432162,
0.0257976018,
-0.0308450162,
-0.0239001121,
0.0339847915,
-0.0071147331,
0.0323395766,
0.0095138419,
-0.0060943011,
0.0595371425,
-0.0323419124,
0.025143005,
-0.0144170532,
0.0070766369,
0.0112560522,
0.0179740023,
0.0012984601,
0.0111311842,
-0.0339943729,
0.0056901583,
-0.0152403424,
0.0144247022,
0.0322433524,
0.0204619188,
0.0369045362,
0.0114178658,
0.0676326528,
0.0000021176,
-0.0369918235,
-0.0362207554,
0.0203219783,
-0.0275577269,
0.0351366512,
0.0371940583,
0.0088442601,
-0.0134115303,
0.0383003131,
-0.0303256009,
-0.016599454,
0.03952967,
-0.0034320119,
0.0670094416,
0.0656002611,
-0.0039603747,
-0.0187119804,
0.0201836228,
-0.0013774466,
-0.0154417651,
-0.0061438764,
0.0843617767,
-0.0270250421,
-0.0619487166,
-0.0432068445,
0.0031924802,
0.0399436653,
0.0015370583,
0.0114930291,
-0.0214127153,
-0.004916369,
-0.0466535017,
-0.0085528521,
-0.0205210317,
0.0634650812,
-0.0401390456,
-0.0228071492,
0.0554938503,
-0.0083306571,
0.0052633067,
-0.0084011499,
-0.0313326083,
0.0169304702,
-0.025702158,
0.0371683761,
-0.0365663879,
-0.0306101181,
0.0821285322,
0.0199368261,
-0.0001840774,
0.0757248625,
0.0068071345,
-0.0066484935,
0.0056300079,
-0.0306533314,
0.0168364514,
-0.0336389951,
-0.0091420356,
0.0327087939,
-0.0161448363,
0.0382805876,
-0.0259028431,
-0.0072184154,
0.0469887108,
-0.0288071465,
0.0399966799,
-0.0164244529,
0.0117903957,
0.0613833703,
0.0093376869,
0.0031309279,
0.0178724229,
0.0456447676,
-0.0344769843,
0.0175160114,
-0.022533346,
-0.0300012659,
0.0336693488,
0.0506780408,
0.0131534953,
0.050984893,
-0.0247766934,
0.0090198312,
-0.0575898774,
0.0069362125,
0.0084945709,
-0.0231289212,
-0.0052140504,
-0.0022081067,
-0.023949828,
0.0147628374,
0.0050489465,
0.0113737816,
0.0129476935,
-0.0575689077,
-0.0047344747,
-0.0129592763,
-0.0108275926,
0.014000155,
0.0312965363,
0.0940082669,
0.0062589664,
-0.0056697829,
-0.0615107752,
-0.0407052301,
-0.008420296,
-0.0544754267,
0.0145898359,
-0.0678092018,
0.036988806,
-0.0399027914,
-0.0301316418,
-0.087568976,
-0.002508068,
0.0064002629,
-0.0910804048,
0.0444656387,
-0.0549703836,
0.0119104441,
0.0175449867,
0.0178417973,
-0.0275063589,
0.0575720258,
-0.0193667039,
0.0340774544,
0.0434540175,
-0.0350730754,
0.0440339483,
0.0445613563,
0.0404931083,
0.0132606803,
-0.0470701903,
-0.028876368,
0.016879458,
-0.04834738,
-0.0205220561,
0.0538261384,
-0.0034425692,
-0.019083349,
0.040654704,
-0.0046916748,
-0.03488997,
0.0408961959,
0.0003335754,
0.013446779,
0.0052581308,
0.0212507509,
-0.0627401695,
-0.0298806801,
-0.0728959814,
0.0033420138,
-0.0029671746,
0.0844875053,
-0.0388735123,
-0.0621528551,
-0.0180836432,
-0.0495296083,
0.0589608662,
0.038585037,
0.0491618514,
0.0443786457,
-0.0290149581,
0.0549523905,
0.1053894684,
-0.0764124021,
0.0078587905,
-0.0433805026,
0.0267734062,
0.0685230121,
0.0644866973,
-0.0704691857,
-0.0335928462,
-0.0189003963,
0.0042313044,
-0.0376416631,
0.0008237127,
-0.0128145535,
0.0483301766,
-0.0475892127,
-0.0446401164,
0.0425075106,
0.0239134189,
-0.0153794158,
0.0382083841,
-0.0438676812,
0.0035190613,
-0.0405400805,
-0.0560394339,
0.0484259948,
-0.0501007661,
-0.0103328871,
-0.0039477721,
0.0061149355,
0.0313274749,
-0.0171892084,
-0.012940974,
-0.0220343489,
0.0575712845,
-0.006348738,
-0.0300356373,
-0.0342893079,
-0.0330885239,
-0.0111347735,
0.0583290569,
-0.0120914849,
-0.0242657084,
0.04905558,
-0.053383287,
0.0108399102,
-0.0068904557,
-0.0133777186,
0.0171968006,
-0.0237049833,
0.0523249768,
-0.0505005829,
-0.0010723253,
-0.0133549878,
0.0743492022,
-0.0507406965,
-0.0385204032,
-0.0213073697,
-0.0590387508,
-0.0146697713,
0.006225762,
-0.0486851148,
-0.0155437281,
-0.0307309423,
0.0405053087,
0.0014957651,
-0.015983656,
-0.0315662362,
-0.0383045897,
-0.0388933346,
-0.020387264,
-0.0043693497,
0.0106077623,
0.0100832935,
-0.0042752465,
-0.0080745555,
-0.0048134192,
-0.0019561024,
0.0119609628,
-0.0006021706,
0.0195934996,
0.0102168899,
-0.0266999975,
-0.0477062874,
-0.0051607145,
-0.0161129553,
-0.0156825911,
0.0522235036,
-0.0237771198,
-0.0200270079,
-0.0090414407,
0.063374579,
-0.0679811165,
0.0249960385,
-0.0036186937,
-0.0289623048,
-0.0141945863,
0.0001869358,
-0.0207069777,
0.0488030203,
-0.0043535819,
0.044905901,
0.0773959458,
-0.0079827234,
-0.0378321633,
-0.0008556434,
-0.0248385835,
-0.02293537,
-0.0039349711,
-0.0174387358,
0.0056579849,
0.0394868329,
0.0205249004,
-0.0178863239,
-0.0182534102,
0.0382944681,
-0.0126189496,
-0.0767347664,
-0.0421152413,
-0.0495589077,
-0.0237692147,
0.0036724946,
-0.0255735442,
-0.0905374885,
0.0562113859,
-0.0052394089,
0.0504926071,
-0.0122472038,
-0.0203338601,
-0.0091553032,
0.0337332003,
-0.0038981631,
0.0508775748,
0.0273802914,
-0.0319250077,
-0.023354793,
-0.0274947863,
0.0311383326,
-0.0569386221,
0.0452875979,
-0.0711359754,
0.0048545501,
0.0312855877,
-0.0309530422,
-0.039347928,
-0.0308099631,
0.0161589682,
0.0057166736,
0.0026512952,
-0.0073843393,
-0.0241872165,
-0.050752297,
0.0351419225,
-0.0306264181,
0.0319562256,
0.0218701735,
0.0001479994,
-0.0077539375,
0.0314413272,
-0.0557732135,
0.0063347346,
-0.0167387072,
0.0392390303,
0.098257862,
0.0286949724,
-0.0094687594,
-0.00178705,
0.0039502531,
0.006911675,
-0.0172173958,
0.0027710022,
0.0145010706,
0.0108463448,
-0.0390501469,
0.0028691939,
0.0991529375,
0.0132945944,
-0.0329012722,
0.0005659207,
0.0267744698,
0.0317376256,
0.0121614682,
0.0125094587,
-0.0849856511,
-0.0103557259,
0.0030095454,
0.0196797233,
0.0011248431,
-0.0519503206,
0.0143726701,
-0.0979837179,
0.0126828132,
0.0592083521,
-0.0488770381,
-0.0305772275,
-0.0382940285,
-0.0054773847,
-0.0460658297,
0.0321021304,
0.0018138882,
-0.0286180004,
-0.0284394044,
0.0045501646,
-0.0595540218,
-0.0522254072,
0.0179244727,
-0.0304692797,
0.0404836945,
0.034348961,
0.0107180066,
-0.0456155911,
-0.0301816668,
0.0218050666,
0.0159732793,
-0.0058788205,
-0.0229973905,
0.0672489926,
0.0042312797,
-0.0090293698,
-0.0132644819,
0.0528458245,
-0.0070948196,
-0.0355914459,
0.0251464639,
0.1040560976,
0.0325704962,
-0.0294793285,
-0.0185460243,
-0.0341120996,
-0.0068873633,
0.0905386657,
0.0085302442,
-0.0289066788,
-0.002946995,
-0.0191903394,
-0.0239201356,
0.0511482842,
-0.0081070354,
0.0122775482,
-0.0513741001,
-0.0245577358,
-0.0776095018,
-0.0030719952,
0.0331155434,
-0.0201398097,
0.0374524593,
0.0228187386,
0.0349945277,
0.0312252082,
-0.0519612692,
-0.0297086015,
-0.027242044,
-0.0197477322,
-0.0263224058,
0.0014016024,
-0.0045922399,
0.0259639472,
-0.0072933645,
0.03398633,
-0.0597409084,
-0.1068053395,
0.0440525524,
0.0465947874,
0.024040712,
0.0363748744,
0.0009272411,
-0.0416124538,
0.0834759101,
0.0500873029,
-0.0392173715,
0.0300487764,
0.0254175831,
-0.0180303976,
0.0267655235,
0.0328553729,
-0.0489492826,
0.006481613,
0.0484130308,
-0.0278383642,
-0.1014352515,
-0.0026635753,
-0.0002227834,
0.0662143752,
0.0350596644,
0.0021684158,
-0.0034756768,
-0.0180863589,
0.0120788282,
0.011603714,
-0.0409953333,
-0.014915389,
0.0310883056,
0.0267924313,
-0.0028283715,
0.0022161081,
0.0255051665,
0.0149890082,
0.011428426,
-0.0091163637,
-0.0107069351,
0.0089499587,
0.0251219105,
0.037264023,
0.0040642461,
0.0042029233,
0.0285966136,
0.0043380572,
0.017089529,
-0.0143891759,
0.0284923632,
-0.0104333172,
0.0454669483,
-0.0251959562,
0.017467659,
0.0068565775,
-0.0624761954,
-0.0347352177,
0.0206466224,
-0.0040154597,
0.0124122221,
0.0381648019,
0.0184270851,
-0.0273619983,
-0.0344724394,
0.0034513033,
-0.0184874423,
-0.0211824961,
0.002336524,
0.0239866227,
-0.0622913279,
0.0056738863,
0.0955206528,
0.0005541531,
0.0552648194,
-0.0025369916,
-0.0027402071,
-0.0455961078,
-0.0452267826,
0.0457058772,
-0.030158259,
-0.0070174267,
-0.0363756754,
-0.0408693403,
-0.0740031451,
-0.0064983615,
0.007048083,
0.0218150187,
-0.0007316208,
0.0050316877,
0.0745791197,
-0.0052608144,
0.0080012921,
-0.0541142859,
-0.0078006177,
0.0316828489,
-0.0459530689,
0.028032342,
-6.01519708e-33,
0.0077547967,
-0.011384137,
-0.0137696061,
0.0486323349,
0.0059382864,
-0.0110065937,
0.0231336895,
-0.0089139538,
-0.0327055715,
0.0226524267,
-0.008468885,
0.012322397,
0.0034671971,
0.0017840324,
-0.0057098223,
-0.0243267529,
0.0369163454,
-0.0227780174,
-0.0152312955,
0.0327031203,
0.049503807,
0.0417661332,
0.0292818174,
-0.1133792326,
-0.0137835927,
-0.0143275,
-0.0333865546,
0.0483379997,
-0.0197477285,
0.0261622071,
-0.0044053942,
0.0339368023,
0.0115171298,
-0.0145099768,
-0.036361631,
0.0206835903,
-0.0546947643,
0.0190697405,
0.0130315591,
-0.0163089726,
-0.0076108226,
-0.053263355,
0.0784001797,
-0.015636934,
0.0031284639,
-0.0481433719,
0.0200133063,
-0.0317946039,
-0.0369165279,
-0.0161318686,
-0.0335257538,
0.0123590091,
-0.0180615149,
-0.0180174652,
0.0407287292,
-0.0130633414,
0.0099109439,
0.0146072665,
-0.0814158618,
0.0245726518,
0.0545594841,
0.0213962384,
0.0968144909,
0.0041480935,
0.0007383139,
0.1094538122,
0.0254392419,
0.01799253,
0.0023160169,
-0.0001357755,
0.024649702,
0.096154578,
0.0300225299,
0.0380365364,
0.0145701449,
-0.0660757571,
-0.079014644,
0.0379688777,
0.0087337885,
0.0267896019,
-0.0161521994,
0.0327945836,
-0.0205605403,
-0.0347854197,
-0.0260575339,
0.0068602259,
-0.0318294615,
-0.0172460694,
0.0149912853,
-0.0043418622,
-0.0581062511,
-0.0209697317,
-0.0131373806,
-0.0563653819,
0.0050708507,
0.0509261079,
0.0296761952,
-0.0114504956,
-0.0133016547,
-0.0258895848,
-0.0783397779,
-0.0301443785,
-0.0033183454,
-0.013770896,
0.0342759155,
-0.0140216732,
0.068848975,
0.0502218306,
-0.0433171727,
0.0169530883,
-0.0302287303,
0.0286332127,
0.0477711596,
0.0051857405,
0.0146518322,
0.0080254674,
0.0133828763,
-0.0242904238,
0.0741383731,
0.0153500699,
-0.0517009385,
0.0185721405,
-0.0095248455,
-0.0023157762,
-0.0034302701,
-0.0275056232,
0.006134423,
0.0000496899,
0.0787742659,
-0.0380715095,
0.0098338444,
0.0050897407,
2.69e-7,
0.0231988076,
0.0169258621,
0.0197189059,
-0.0252425857,
0.0180022418,
0.0533498861,
-0.0249211174,
0.0269476101,
0.0025180259,
-0.0324167721,
0.0171292648,
0.028852351,
0.0651769415,
0.0453791469,
-0.0517225936,
0.0079784775,
-0.0644469485,
-0.0373141021,
-0.0429487228,
-0.0323165804,
-0.000829018,
0.0770976841,
0.0471659377,
-0.0608800054,
-0.002198138,
-0.0298272725,
0.0242455099,
-0.0638401359,
-0.0283370782,
0.0464457422,
0.0189784467,
0.0232403893,
0.0059957686,
-0.0128523139,
-0.0233423281,
-0.0028343534,
-0.0076322006,
0.091729477,
0.0181737598,
-0.0170265865,
0.0007423613,
-0.0227718782,
0.0037543955,
-0.0099409521,
0.0734304041,
-0.0062613855,
-0.0170371942,
-0.0198640395,
-0.0241392739,
-0.0274545141,
0.018302286,
0.0011439233,
-0.0035037324,
0.0599046648,
-0.0144625409,
-0.0092563555,
-0.0239045564,
-0.0540535823,
-0.0335291736,
-0.0200844295,
-0.0655796081,
-0.0648891404,
0.0304641388,
0.0101233497,
-0.0294503216,
-0.0840198249,
0.0643060952,
2.486452946e-34,
-0.0140712922,
-0.0555585958,
0.0105643189,
0.0386491455,
0.0183559954,
0.0062616104,
-0.0350468419,
0.0258099418,
-0.0240498986,
-0.0324317217,
0.036004588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11776v1 | Improving Multi-Agent Debate with Sparse Communication Topology | 2024-06-17T17:33:09 | 2024-06-17T17:33:09 | Yunxuan Li, Yibing Du, Jiageng Zhang, Le Hou, Peter Grabowski, Yeqing Li, Eugene Ie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-agent debate has proven effective in improving large language models
quality for reasoning and factuality tasks. While various role-playing
strategies in multi-agent debates have been explored, in terms of the
communication among agents, existing approaches adopt a brute force algorithm
-- each agent can communicate with all other agents. In this paper, we
systematically investigate the effect of communication connectivity in
multi-agent systems. Our experiments on GPT and Mistral models reveal that
multi-agent debates leveraging sparse communication topology can achieve
comparable or superior performance while significantly reducing computational
costs. Furthermore, we extend the multi-agent debate framework to multimodal
reasoning and alignment labeling tasks, showcasing its broad applicability and
effectiveness. Our findings underscore the importance of communication
connectivity on enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the "society of
minds" approach. | [
0.0326106288,
0.0387477651,
-0.0145692108,
0.0498450696,
-0.078656882,
-0.0192842856,
0.037735898,
-0.0295998659,
-0.0003906077,
-0.0341992937,
-0.013235894,
-0.0570955388,
0.0116246855,
0.0026463298,
0.0166933425,
-0.0297772214,
0.0570310578,
-0.0315221027,
0.021554146,
-0.0369576551,
0.0231330991,
-0.0328018703,
-0.0325762518,
0.0040171794,
-0.0567721054,
-0.0161841176,
-0.0405382924,
-0.0166995954,
0.0389768817,
-0.0008898186,
-0.0402239449,
0.0478450358,
0.0351722501,
0.0853592828,
0.0000018969,
-0.0152891856,
0.001403925,
-0.0019851078,
-0.0451475233,
-0.0062787249,
0.047149457,
0.02452356,
0.012136397,
-0.0145793604,
-0.0374500044,
-0.0048843594,
0.0881619453,
0.0544219129,
0.1001340672,
0.0590396598,
-0.0024474589,
-0.0208542999,
-0.0012766861,
-0.0041428828,
0.0006816037,
-0.0681789964,
0.0087125907,
0.0353890657,
0.025932068,
-0.0110525042,
-0.01943532,
0.0510651171,
0.0167183168,
-0.0416655727,
-0.0108014606,
0.0178703461,
-0.0441452861,
-0.0413961224,
0.0011873307,
0.0783309639,
0.0641089082,
0.0028765996,
-0.0122474758,
0.0278617144,
-0.0178424381,
0.0276385434,
-0.0319253393,
0.029337734,
-0.0122458367,
-0.0006577185,
0.0213402528,
-0.0027145317,
0.019196,
0.0013765185,
-0.0317832902,
0.0870381147,
-0.0129153859,
-0.0194657352,
-0.018499298,
-0.0128402878,
-0.0531947389,
-0.084007062,
-0.0098272106,
-0.0109682102,
-0.0647425428,
0.0196127892,
-0.0311605893,
-0.0143786808,
-0.0033789419,
-0.0110643329,
0.0227001905,
0.0200573802,
0.0297597889,
0.0757925734,
0.013609401,
0.03065289,
-0.0163843408,
0.0427204892,
0.0191338416,
-0.0389023647,
-0.05278828,
-0.023877481,
-0.0332277641,
0.0473464504,
-0.0281964093,
-0.0241088718,
0.0212754104,
0.0123348692,
-0.0499737933,
0.0319285356,
0.0004925593,
0.0066925352,
-0.0178086124,
-0.0428939536,
-0.0472953878,
0.0320119187,
-0.0336783789,
0.0119118867,
0.023734102,
-0.0366167836,
-0.0277201552,
0.0167518519,
-0.0002739307,
-0.0412613191,
-0.035602048,
0.0479763448,
-0.0423018485,
0.0083134156,
0.0288772359,
-0.0121813929,
-0.0090932976,
-0.1182196513,
-0.0216020755,
-0.041786734,
0.0281172097,
-0.01686332,
-0.0189033467,
-0.037483152,
0.0043779002,
-0.0028620551,
-0.0262074415,
0.1138999462,
-0.0273471139,
0.0126165133,
0.0461748354,
0.0183645897,
-0.0480554923,
0.0501916595,
0.048148904,
0.0010412727,
0.0256167091,
0.0234998465,
-0.0032928293,
0.0323417559,
0.0195358396,
0.0276490077,
0.0472958311,
-0.004354503,
0.0087630143,
0.0740878731,
-0.0225684233,
0.0748442188,
-0.0614331886,
-0.0818097889,
0.0683018267,
0.0362923332,
-0.0256335326,
-0.0438511632,
-0.0093497336,
0.0208943635,
0.0024884252,
0.0420431606,
-0.0369614996,
0.0541519374,
0.0022622268,
-0.0030308194,
0.0314907618,
0.0102072898,
-0.0177981853,
-0.0339132994,
-0.0118077099,
0.028705731,
0.0402912013,
0.0220611487,
0.0213135034,
-0.0301424786,
-0.0602655895,
0.034200646,
0.03031593,
-0.0434432626,
-0.0419265777,
-0.0348901153,
0.0272537638,
0.0004404635,
0.0522011593,
-0.018427657,
-0.0822079927,
-0.0092118355,
0.0245541334,
0.0746143088,
0.0184801798,
-0.0317824706,
-0.0301965177,
-0.075170733,
-0.0328298584,
0.0012563679,
0.0034840198,
0.0269496106,
-0.0157431047,
-0.0365978703,
-0.0255762804,
0.0025460224,
0.0081266733,
-0.0054085506,
0.043842148,
0.0458395071,
-0.0391695201,
0.0484242924,
0.0653169379,
0.0106194941,
-0.0400375091,
-0.0048868591,
-0.0035008751,
-0.0221146513,
-0.0125698438,
0.005140915,
-0.0305956695,
-0.0620424971,
0.030739544,
-0.0325447284,
-0.0449178852,
0.009716318,
-0.0252517108,
-0.0363909192,
0.0190139227,
-0.0632964075,
-0.0302064866,
-0.0373181999,
-0.024396617,
0.0019504984,
-0.0410430208,
-0.050858479,
0.0695496053,
0.012507258,
-0.0370229967,
0.018424388,
0.052184552,
0.0494005196,
-0.0800279155,
0.0007803296,
0.0561623648,
0.0400734469,
0.021211341,
0.0516160503,
-0.0376051515,
-0.0069031636,
-0.0417567678,
-0.1090766788,
-0.0230281055,
0.0027563961,
-0.0035676234,
-0.009736876,
-0.0274154898,
0.0482179523,
0.0278201383,
-0.0612924695,
0.0356563367,
0.0304707736,
0.0247752313,
0.0396714509,
0.035297472,
-0.0370950103,
-0.023069188,
0.0060864724,
-0.0222718138,
0.0266390294,
0.0319927596,
-0.03623119,
-0.011433458,
-0.0019926035,
-0.0748767853,
0.0226080157,
-0.0202014148,
-0.0055722483,
0.0380068049,
0.0161679499,
0.0189874507,
0.0535464138,
-0.0216496475,
0.0464930348,
0.0096339155,
-0.0327670909,
-0.0360984467,
0.0238799062,
0.0040666335,
0.0160968844,
-0.0479502827,
-0.0296109207,
-0.0122046247,
0.0685281754,
-0.0142844655,
-0.0189350639,
-0.0472330898,
0.0665166676,
0.0249876883,
-0.0228950139,
-0.0353772677,
-0.00164363,
-0.0040002721,
0.0512562804,
-0.0802582949,
0.0104900729,
0.0959351063,
-0.0176223218,
0.0095448606,
-0.0341543183,
0.0130133452,
-0.016129842,
0.0547683798,
0.023346059,
0.0376660377,
-0.0023744293,
-0.0182728209,
-0.078029722,
-0.0308623668,
0.0923203304,
0.0051497789,
0.0492767245,
-0.0512157045,
0.0672887266,
-0.0294507127,
-0.0470006727,
0.0063952943,
-0.0145607386,
-0.0219606999,
0.025990909,
0.0152597995,
0.0119736781,
-0.0828083828,
0.0349213295,
0.0249171201,
-0.0183755569,
0.0188112576,
0.0093429973,
-0.0422407389,
0.0232734531,
0.0148574188,
0.0596214049,
0.0097044222,
-0.0435754061,
-0.0014034774,
0.0588424318,
0.0243619662,
-0.0432976782,
0.0009836876,
-0.0214661211,
-0.0068544536,
0.0120766917,
0.0074719959,
-0.0322429091,
0.0638059676,
-0.0376715511,
0.0136623075,
0.0614587031,
0.0333682783,
-0.0035902935,
-0.0323851965,
-0.0033082541,
0.0526880398,
0.0031279295,
-0.012008274,
-0.0712359473,
-0.0294358842,
0.0035116416,
-0.0325984769,
-0.0158822834,
-0.0691721067,
-0.0132958544,
-0.0579858348,
0.0415333845,
0.0090111811,
0.0078999223,
-0.0059838579,
-0.0259811394,
0.0134852864,
-0.0559391715,
-0.0061173253,
0.0016505499,
0.0704658851,
-0.0062252372,
-0.0266527105,
0.0506658293,
-0.0106697017,
0.0154035315,
-0.0289565362,
0.0631418899,
0.0349827409,
0.036039751,
0.0045684678,
-0.0867194012,
0.0028992856,
0.060907308,
-0.0321183167,
-0.0092553357,
0.0046264245,
0.0007989242,
-0.0257839095,
0.0105489641,
-0.0041390499,
0.0463477932,
-0.01121403,
-0.0112200398,
0.0527604073,
-0.0192805398,
-0.0003366602,
0.0165577736,
0.0043847007,
0.0205042381,
0.065213263,
0.0019493814,
0.0000078201,
-0.0703648329,
-0.0280264951,
-0.0322152562,
-0.0302743409,
-0.0272595733,
-0.0245810971,
-0.0033874826,
-0.0043212171,
-0.0337366574,
-0.0360240005,
0.0239980854,
0.0426524915,
-0.022602044,
-0.003935915,
0.0637147874,
0.0164066758,
0.0245866366,
0.0005312939,
-0.0627990514,
0.0119906915,
0.0062441519,
-0.0120258266,
0.0055487198,
-0.0188843887,
-0.017945122,
0.0273290612,
-0.0602479503,
-0.0762955025,
-0.0147587173,
0.0377130359,
0.0232409872,
0.0286212042,
0.002730706,
-0.0334171876,
-0.0103949886,
0.0134141361,
0.0248749554,
0.0354473926,
-0.0074960147,
-0.0155000603,
-0.0110706855,
0.0520069785,
0.0108940257,
0.0016489505,
0.0002743172,
0.0549518056,
-0.0859114677,
0.0104497969,
0.0167692844,
0.0177919175,
0.0069110533,
0.0291193221,
0.01394621,
-0.035242781,
-0.0120093822,
-0.0459727757,
-0.0323308967,
-0.0397224054,
0.0000700123,
-0.0168792848,
-0.032717485,
0.0586121604,
-0.0058091492,
0.0229460336,
0.0277145337,
0.0391728543,
0.0023753701,
0.03356025,
-0.0419181474,
0.0191771351,
0.0109796356,
0.0066354666,
0.0249863509,
0.0018552562,
0.0495048501,
0.0161281675,
0.0579214059,
0.0670401976,
-0.0486516915,
0.0203666538,
0.0200063661,
-0.0464286171,
-0.0507829562,
0.0418457538,
0.0565695763,
0.0575670525,
0.061038319,
-0.0034464251,
-0.0406669192,
-0.0221081264,
0.0057222126,
0.0166903883,
0.065596357,
-0.0262548085,
0.0439161658,
0.0440775193,
0.0044823647,
0.0285531804,
0.0531048365,
0.015811896,
0.0331159495,
-0.0029316896,
-0.0210643616,
-0.0430283844,
-0.0337483883,
-0.0376325548,
0.0505871065,
-0.0033813112,
0.0517981313,
-0.0572583266,
-0.0319892354,
0.0057085766,
0.0515782647,
0.0238079038,
-0.0050247312,
0.0573173314,
0.051018022,
-0.0010286939,
-0.0264239386,
-0.0281560086,
-0.0101858042,
-0.0178769026,
-0.0088570379,
-0.0152007686,
-6.544238599e-33,
-0.0522683263,
-0.0664559752,
0.0654187799,
-0.0234093554,
-0.0303533375,
-0.0127869872,
-0.0502464473,
0.0241871383,
-0.0479096957,
0.0541658998,
0.0304832365,
0.0072061708,
0.0119336313,
0.010768705,
-0.0324820094,
-0.0248013586,
0.0220817085,
0.0037870398,
-0.0242181793,
-0.0045370627,
0.0179224312,
-0.0501878709,
0.0112701636,
-0.0576333627,
0.0068966756,
0.0272117835,
-0.0184292886,
0.0599069744,
-0.0399787799,
0.0374432169,
-0.0183130242,
0.0271920189,
-0.002050353,
-0.0423662551,
-0.0011180468,
-0.0181636252,
-0.0228843279,
-0.0197990239,
0.0572193041,
-0.020177789,
-0.0482470989,
-0.0369678475,
-0.0085411966,
0.0017580058,
-0.008254501,
-0.0213756505,
0.0129449833,
0.0066311657,
-0.0179084539,
0.0424340181,
-0.0438713431,
0.0366237611,
-0.0145069622,
-0.0221048091,
0.0375118889,
-0.0437588245,
0.0097461976,
0.0077840937,
-0.1007934064,
0.0131738903,
-0.0173355043,
0.0019896235,
0.0485469326,
0.0245455522,
0.0110038556,
0.0433590263,
0.0153953647,
0.0342118889,
-0.0580918565,
-0.0021746517,
-0.0201912653,
0.0494920537,
0.0459229238,
0.0822852924,
-0.0089617558,
0.026446484,
-0.0354717337,
-0.0267573483,
0.0082526356,
0.043402005,
0.0238932949,
0.0465050675,
-0.0216201413,
-0.0264695007,
-0.0400514342,
0.0020734186,
-0.0334299803,
-0.0057344669,
-0.0212845355,
-0.0025060328,
-0.0031582494,
0.0249028634,
0.0534779243,
-0.0436838791,
-0.0081828395,
-0.0386395045,
0.0194809288,
0.0472706966,
-0.0068179509,
-0.0053542149,
-0.0279129334,
0.0082095591,
-0.0144387921,
0.0508256629,
0.0076413578,
0.0216675717,
0.0008546127,
-0.0179557111,
0.0042269784,
0.0004922908,
-0.0131909959,
0.0029902905,
-0.0309406687,
-0.0178674366,
0.0357176699,
-0.0094962856,
-0.0071467743,
0.0248476621,
0.0086914916,
-0.0080760177,
0.0078389067,
-0.0196587872,
-0.0499958545,
0.0034574792,
-0.0096541252,
0.0366660468,
-0.053953588,
-0.0243566558,
0.0080301408,
-0.0138189672,
-0.021519104,
-0.0050824978,
2.709e-7,
-0.0067340164,
0.0425547734,
0.0315860435,
0.020994382,
0.0214337744,
0.0704541728,
0.0015208805,
-0.0124651827,
-0.0031982493,
-0.1169847175,
-0.0038252827,
0.0665337145,
0.0250380989,
0.0356687345,
-0.042622555,
-0.0217935629,
-0.037062645,
-0.0485279001,
-0.0447689556,
0.0141204083,
0.0618813708,
0.048509486,
0.0134081757,
0.019934848,
0.0003887443,
0.0003100096,
0.055506248,
0.0239592474,
-0.0388300978,
0.0444903374,
0.047422301,
-0.0850635394,
-0.0022824698,
0.0494225509,
0.0422461294,
-0.0007472733,
-0.000332526,
0.0230885036,
-0.0304813664,
-0.0185454991,
-0.0383600332,
-0.0162109565,
-0.0289485529,
-0.0304147433,
0.0520676076,
-0.0658413172,
-0.0726083666,
0.004300958,
0.0006160773,
0.0000620773,
0.0340551995,
0.0010735799,
-0.0512078442,
0.0057098726,
-0.0039068907,
-0.0111188432,
0.0262911227,
-0.0489491671,
0.0050159101,
0.0315583274,
-0.0473576039,
-0.0558468923,
0.0345521308,
-0.0179490205,
0.051940158,
-0.0333325341,
-0.0273371115,
2.245671755e-34,
0.0693685487,
-0.0047514271,
0.0193108413,
0.0202648025,
0.0598104708,
-0.0096826302,
-0.0473540202,
-0.0244891699,
0.0180667918,
-0.0761513636,
-0.0007335437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11768v1 | GAMA: A Large Audio-Language Model with Advanced Audio Understanding and Complex Reasoning Abilities | 2024-06-17T17:31:01 | 2024-06-17T17:31:01 | Sreyan Ghosh, Sonal Kumar, Ashish Seth, Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Utkarsh Tyagi, S Sakshi, Oriol Nieto, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | Perceiving and understanding non-speech sounds and non-verbal speech is
essential to making decisions that help us interact with our surroundings. In
this paper, we propose GAMA, a novel General-purpose Large Audio-Language Model
(LALM) with Advanced Audio Understanding and Complex Reasoning Abilities. We
build GAMA by integrating an LLM with multiple types of audio representations,
including features from a custom Audio Q-Former, a multi-layer aggregator that
aggregates features from multiple layers of an audio encoder. We fine-tune GAMA
on a large-scale audio-language dataset, which augments it with audio
understanding capabilities. Next, we propose CompA-R (Instruction-Tuning for
Complex Audio Reasoning), a synthetically generated instruction-tuning (IT)
dataset with instructions that require the model to perform complex reasoning
on the input audio. We instruction-tune GAMA with CompA-R to endow it with
complex reasoning abilities, where we further add a soft prompt as input with
high-level semantic evidence by leveraging event tags of the input audio.
Finally, we also propose CompA-R-test, a human-labeled evaluation dataset for
evaluating the capabilities of LALMs on open-ended audio question-answering
that requires complex reasoning. Through automated and expert human
evaluations, we show that GAMA outperforms all other LALMs in literature on
diverse audio understanding tasks by margins of 1%-84%. Further, GAMA IT-ed on
CompA-R proves to be superior in its complex reasoning and instruction
following capabilities. | [
-0.006116393,
0.0181710105,
-0.0048793484,
0.0423393808,
0.0145500712,
0.0109842308,
0.0255359877,
-0.0348786861,
-0.0096877813,
-0.0134457173,
-0.0589157641,
0.0051972093,
-0.0118502686,
0.0415876918,
0.0268023517,
-0.048499614,
0.0378873795,
-0.0637720153,
0.038671229,
-0.0114828711,
0.0014895584,
0.0172578581,
-0.0516909994,
0.049889572,
0.0028906411,
-0.0040893224,
-0.0197830144,
0.0395355821,
0.020346716,
-0.0215198565,
-0.0137970885,
0.007684825,
0.0632996708,
-0.0091109248,
0.0000016664,
-0.0362275466,
0.0302268937,
-0.0117228068,
-0.0546111278,
-0.0166328978,
-0.0665308684,
0.0372566767,
-0.0358524956,
0.0391606353,
-0.0298345275,
0.0004447614,
0.014602256,
0.0189041346,
0.0505741686,
0.0842542276,
-0.0064152703,
-0.0762243494,
0.0134080462,
-0.0231994577,
0.0285730157,
-0.0624083951,
-0.0065531223,
0.0072184722,
0.0474646576,
0.0114400871,
-0.0144008175,
0.0373037569,
0.0423641615,
-0.0027520705,
-0.0052707777,
0.0315276757,
-0.0344289467,
-0.0079806149,
-0.0284817014,
0.0877810866,
0.0253133588,
0.009543811,
0.0190791525,
0.0370152071,
-0.0064409371,
-0.0353617631,
-0.0601983406,
0.0261073727,
0.0075438078,
0.0293360185,
-0.0208878219,
0.0217069034,
0.0364635848,
-0.0163763892,
0.0053033289,
0.0879970938,
-0.0090402961,
-0.0279686507,
0.0318630151,
-0.0239870884,
-0.044871252,
-0.0348441191,
0.0309327524,
0.063544482,
-0.0555609837,
0.0001837183,
-0.0119257495,
0.0514907576,
0.0020015312,
-0.0244782902,
0.0227543768,
0.0446170419,
-0.0329511091,
0.1039096639,
-0.0215532705,
0.0264723208,
-0.0153526738,
0.0053624623,
-0.0059563974,
-0.0204711612,
-0.0422042124,
-0.0352086537,
-0.0075847353,
0.026218405,
-0.0241144132,
-0.0275132228,
-0.0161665156,
0.0125385523,
-0.0574145205,
0.0368824974,
-0.0042410819,
0.0099493861,
0.00968087,
-0.0102538737,
-0.0207553878,
0.0038611111,
-0.0734777227,
0.0904283896,
0.0009388553,
-0.0381027237,
-0.0160239246,
0.0012078681,
0.0224306379,
-0.0047449288,
0.0411858968,
0.0607464276,
-0.0342113115,
0.0031199052,
-0.0261777434,
-0.0350674875,
0.0214238111,
-0.0667351112,
-0.0282174274,
-0.0473057777,
0.0456548668,
-0.0161147006,
-0.0297016632,
-0.0155162644,
-0.0178847574,
0.0358830579,
0.0199222844,
0.0701201335,
0.0222770907,
0.0586321317,
0.0635606498,
0.0334484652,
-0.0185818672,
0.0441049375,
0.0673275515,
-0.0274378117,
0.0261179246,
-0.0298747234,
0.0086276745,
0.0422242656,
-0.0021694773,
-0.0406105481,
-0.0097910324,
0.0325561576,
-0.0603831373,
0.0474640988,
0.0193185266,
0.0524418019,
-0.0301969964,
-0.048805695,
0.0285084266,
0.0533548109,
-0.0117806038,
-0.0204476491,
0.0291890725,
0.0026414192,
0.0200742073,
0.0122328028,
-0.0344440639,
0.0793196559,
-0.0309394225,
0.020522289,
0.0323945656,
0.006991894,
-0.0333095565,
-0.015781099,
-0.0145458197,
0.0157312248,
0.0366074033,
0.0365295671,
0.0020653491,
-0.0074310484,
-0.0354253612,
0.0192558188,
-0.0201991219,
-0.0286682732,
-0.013638217,
-0.057740014,
0.0681525767,
0.086927779,
0.035211809,
-0.0581501201,
-0.0147611005,
-0.0103773354,
0.0287535079,
0.0532444678,
0.0118415374,
-0.0206232164,
0.0286915246,
-0.0491585322,
-0.0365655124,
-0.0385671407,
-0.0150338737,
0.0370446816,
0.0119791385,
0.0165552013,
0.006471491,
-0.0019871679,
0.0448913723,
-0.0109743485,
-0.0074256859,
-0.0370551459,
-0.0143604083,
0.0061404351,
0.0343609117,
0.0295069888,
-0.0103034871,
0.0190644674,
0.0363497324,
-0.0191818364,
-0.0108655784,
-0.0044256025,
-0.0827627555,
-0.0188320857,
0.0422783196,
-0.0536989085,
-0.0170619376,
0.0368247144,
-0.0241995286,
-0.0602242798,
0.0366679206,
-0.0291546285,
0.0202623084,
-0.0477370434,
-0.0059265867,
0.0328673013,
0.02738823,
0.0089315595,
0.0180129241,
0.0325614959,
-0.0173227265,
0.0352417789,
0.0374077372,
0.0089159878,
-0.0463630036,
-0.0280335266,
0.0375593863,
-0.0015478309,
0.0037018682,
-0.033708021,
-0.0235323906,
-0.0666576773,
-0.0138954092,
-0.0835876316,
0.0319371969,
-0.0115828291,
0.0123096863,
0.0055385558,
-0.0321155041,
-0.0030639011,
-0.0481458977,
-0.0671327412,
-0.0131737106,
0.0200754795,
0.0091661662,
-0.0432840101,
-0.003606502,
-0.0353448838,
-0.0176094901,
-0.0057736463,
0.0049379589,
-0.0013162721,
-0.0103209689,
0.0339306965,
-0.0230607446,
-0.0355379246,
-0.0411335118,
0.0294748154,
-0.0119431131,
-0.0263192579,
0.011573622,
0.0040856032,
0.0152235078,
0.0624174029,
-0.0018700071,
0.0050281649,
0.0412685238,
-0.015757516,
-0.0459983423,
0.0484389663,
0.0104818344,
-0.0098639121,
-0.0360218696,
0.018339647,
-0.0284194853,
0.0528658219,
0.025672704,
0.0224839747,
-0.0401963331,
-0.0185999516,
-0.0060833734,
-0.0243016947,
-0.0472089648,
-0.0666415766,
-0.0398609564,
0.0610099994,
-0.0383207127,
-0.0082564401,
0.1030189991,
-0.0453326292,
-0.0528198518,
-0.0494478345,
-0.0608718134,
-0.0416894108,
0.0423466936,
-0.0536627397,
-0.0056064986,
-0.0019129504,
-0.0267814547,
-0.0442492329,
-0.0004882499,
0.0251222588,
-0.0711235479,
0.019963935,
-0.0322083682,
0.0012910378,
0.0100193089,
-0.0303896647,
-0.0369004719,
-0.0061132507,
-0.0242324192,
0.0232856646,
-0.0184581485,
-0.0090924772,
-0.0325618871,
0.0231706724,
0.0353087634,
0.0433540978,
0.0001650185,
0.0027342383,
-0.0194868483,
0.0324006192,
0.0479204096,
0.0665100068,
-0.0356261693,
-0.0105283614,
0.0518878214,
0.0239585415,
0.0387286656,
-0.038525708,
-0.0190968122,
0.0564586148,
0.0301892292,
0.0095516928,
-0.0231109001,
0.0549617968,
0.0465535708,
-0.0797538757,
0.0146650318,
0.1210236698,
0.0369977467,
-0.0250479802,
-0.0127250906,
0.0114976764,
0.0261003654,
0.0259485338,
0.0295939222,
-0.0585467033,
-0.0501538143,
0.039415326,
0.0382764339,
0.0148356892,
0.0297129583,
0.0060302517,
-0.0872253105,
0.0440313332,
0.0001227477,
-0.0346147679,
-0.0319244452,
-0.0175611079,
0.00511669,
0.0053895987,
0.0194052979,
0.0044893045,
-0.0100364434,
-0.014978799,
0.0221454594,
-0.023159612,
-0.0600281619,
0.089653641,
-0.027745029,
0.0679938942,
0.073147051,
0.0174798779,
-0.0139763467,
-0.048335731,
0.029308401,
-0.0179366674,
0.005228959,
0.0238355193,
0.0272726733,
0.0193115454,
-0.0257270075,
0.002534444,
0.0498355553,
-0.027412679,
-0.0389635563,
0.0164844859,
0.089567326,
-0.0178055353,
0.0134841427,
-0.0256295167,
0.043321155,
-0.0292117875,
0.0789424255,
0.0285243075,
-0.0128816674,
-0.0106169423,
-0.0158577729,
-0.0495981574,
-0.0727272183,
-0.0203262065,
0.0229328088,
0.0274515841,
-0.017987892,
-0.0330495052,
-0.0028917305,
0.020573603,
0.0328425653,
0.008645176,
-0.0067570778,
0.0092546158,
0.0182513762,
-0.062939316,
0.0449475013,
0.0009619145,
0.062423531,
-0.0426422022,
-0.02633694,
0.0379952006,
-0.0265083499,
-0.0256028231,
0.0271316972,
-0.0324912444,
-0.0611153319,
-0.0109818354,
0.0193364415,
0.0298503451,
0.0375997424,
-0.0197415184,
-0.0515110679,
0.0180319902,
-0.003939752,
-0.0660964102,
0.0398864634,
0.0361199528,
-0.0016199263,
-0.0012390915,
0.0380619727,
-0.0733605549,
0.0291237365,
-0.0176160876,
0.0442356393,
-0.0340680443,
-0.0161302872,
0.0065262555,
-0.0335063897,
0.0167020429,
0.0128027489,
0.029518526,
-0.0323897712,
0.0465438291,
0.0042426451,
0.0200361554,
-0.0403839834,
-0.012242456,
0.0131359361,
-0.0216709469,
-0.0272328127,
0.0006892227,
-0.0038351887,
-0.0063359998,
-0.0278659835,
0.043202471,
0.0263916776,
-0.0486420095,
0.0065647112,
-0.0155996839,
0.0058381651,
0.0035207453,
0.0031685461,
0.0373578854,
0.0456155688,
0.0669773519,
0.0013393842,
-0.0069321357,
-0.0076348092,
0.0227869861,
-0.0654269755,
-0.0279347599,
0.0230389498,
0.0354823805,
0.0442237705,
0.0040706312,
-0.0065560839,
0.0308468491,
0.004004552,
0.0015622559,
0.0044306531,
-0.0162717346,
-0.0241403263,
0.0464791059,
0.0527042337,
-0.0218930617,
-0.0098664491,
0.0471503213,
-0.0345960073,
0.0253647529,
-0.0658120513,
0.0466034263,
-0.0255469885,
-0.0365292318,
-0.0286304466,
0.0415244959,
0.0034808244,
0.0073702503,
-0.0170540046,
-0.0777019039,
-0.0407158807,
0.0103703924,
0.0086697945,
-0.0159879643,
0.0369371921,
0.0375968069,
0.0027904687,
-0.0146113774,
0.0333145261,
-0.0465971231,
-0.0516057685,
-0.0148043577,
0.0056711058,
-5.988078793e-33,
-0.0400350392,
-0.0227150898,
0.0212629344,
-0.0234070756,
-0.0034119352,
-0.0065693348,
-0.0635405034,
-0.0077757756,
-0.0099425809,
-0.0026192644,
-0.0032564541,
0.012625576,
0.0266343821,
0.0208257083,
0.0126084033,
-0.0422325023,
0.0398513637,
-0.014650167,
-0.0250538979,
0.0107176453,
0.0457498282,
0.0099293254,
0.0007795308,
-0.0562630035,
-0.0333043225,
0.0027068143,
-0.0287520289,
0.0117544048,
-0.0426031388,
0.0980368629,
0.0115019204,
0.0036081616,
0.0105466638,
-0.0665697455,
-0.005446176,
0.0434599854,
-0.1016904935,
-0.0105548203,
0.0307109058,
0.0331314169,
-0.0131268296,
-0.0270738117,
0.0276266541,
0.0108665954,
-0.0060673854,
-0.0334140025,
0.0217410531,
-0.0189134125,
0.014151915,
-0.0444105901,
-0.007423698,
0.0060293381,
-0.0542117134,
-0.0553946793,
0.0189547855,
0.0406197235,
-0.0208124947,
0.0198428929,
-0.0433306247,
0.0223533399,
-0.0219014119,
0.0011904553,
0.0656631887,
0.0295086503,
-0.0248097032,
0.0421816707,
0.0372377299,
-0.0455585532,
-0.0628462508,
-0.0069826473,
-0.0116081396,
0.0479791984,
0.0182297453,
-0.0093575697,
0.0368667133,
0.0130856037,
-0.018494321,
0.0171868484,
-0.0139572406,
0.033754535,
0.0224821772,
0.0577327162,
-0.042826388,
-0.0047240104,
-0.0544224828,
0.04990777,
-0.0596434325,
-0.0233214963,
0.0733377784,
0.0022026522,
0.0166080054,
-0.0061070076,
0.0248188302,
-0.0268108584,
0.0343769193,
0.005502095,
-0.0239658784,
0.0117056882,
0.0133131063,
0.0177034959,
-0.0045845779,
0.0054268008,
0.107453011,
-0.0257996153,
0.0354055129,
-0.0102150897,
0.0047728764,
0.0809741765,
-0.0595087409,
-0.0032243175,
-0.0192138944,
0.012430666,
-0.0059782304,
0.0158150941,
0.0065377546,
0.0294783097,
-0.0455961227,
0.0300486702,
-0.0571408123,
0.0207626596,
-0.0375145152,
-0.039293047,
-0.0485969558,
0.0412586555,
-0.0358214602,
0.0287014581,
-0.0214788076,
-0.0547612235,
-0.0267760083,
-0.0476591736,
-0.011800197,
0.0446837321,
2.646e-7,
-0.0260080658,
-0.0128717469,
0.0023208095,
0.0419144519,
0.0323493034,
0.0229253974,
-0.0577617697,
-0.0100717787,
0.0296866037,
-0.0262022521,
0.0072461306,
0.0637553632,
0.0770026147,
0.011981938,
-0.1076656953,
-0.0182013605,
-0.0523453243,
-0.0002190753,
-0.0544529669,
-0.0002979637,
0.0900483951,
0.1040669158,
0.023056386,
-0.0157560837,
0.0360999443,
-0.0389479958,
0.0198229346,
-0.0023327225,
0.0144354729,
-0.053894747,
0.0233555567,
0.0015607155,
-0.0135171162,
0.0311072525,
-0.0490177833,
0.023994159,
0.018007962,
0.0907504186,
0.027384175,
-0.089868769,
-0.0136861252,
0.0107364561,
-0.0017112937,
-0.0191134382,
0.0997703448,
-0.0163158868,
-0.0488477498,
0.0025282383,
-0.0454053506,
-0.0461176485,
-0.0128644779,
-0.0104587069,
0.0145798903,
-0.0417742245,
0.0037893574,
-0.0172290727,
-0.0005201265,
-0.0915131196,
-0.0005345101,
0.0528505594,
-0.0669003949,
-0.0088705542,
-0.0363082476,
-0.0178496018,
0.0334164761,
-0.0346780047,
-0.0257792957,
2.002087514e-34,
0.032738056,
-0.038865298,
0.0279772766,
0.0299437549,
0.0285040904,
0.0086720688,
-0.0275343228,
-0.0077878023,
0.0390450768,
-0.0576824918,
-0.0080658449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11939v1 | From Crowdsourced Data to High-Quality Benchmarks: Arena-Hard and BenchBuilder Pipeline | 2024-06-17T17:26:10 | 2024-06-17T17:26:10 | Tianle Li, Wei-Lin Chiang, Evan Frick, Lisa Dunlap, Tianhao Wu, Banghua Zhu, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid evolution of language models has necessitated the development of
more challenging benchmarks. Current static benchmarks often struggle to
consistently distinguish between the capabilities of different models and fail
to align with real-world user preferences. On the other hand, live
crowd-sourced platforms like the Chatbot Arena collect a wide range of natural
prompts and user feedback. However, these prompts vary in sophistication and
the feedback cannot be applied offline to new models. In order to ensure that
benchmarks keep up with the pace of LLM development, we address how one can
evaluate benchmarks on their ability to confidently separate models and their
alignment with human preference. Under these principles, we developed
BenchBuilder, a living benchmark that filters high-quality prompts from live
data sources to enable offline evaluation on fresh, challenging prompts.
BenchBuilder identifies seven indicators of a high-quality prompt, such as the
requirement for domain knowledge, and utilizes an LLM annotator to select a
high-quality subset of prompts from various topic clusters. The LLM evaluation
process employs an LLM judge to ensure a fully automated, high-quality, and
constantly updating benchmark. We apply BenchBuilder on prompts from the
Chatbot Arena to create Arena-Hard-Auto v0.1: 500 challenging user prompts from
a wide range of tasks. Arena-Hard-Auto v0.1 offers 3x tighter confidence
intervals than MT-Bench and achieves a state-of-the-art 89.1% agreement with
human preference rankings, all at a cost of only $25 and without human
labelers. The BenchBuilder pipeline enhances evaluation benchmarks and provides
a valuable tool for developers, enabling them to extract high-quality
benchmarks from extensive data with minimal effort. | [
0.0508490503,
0.0357269198,
-0.0164627377,
0.0502987653,
-0.0398958996,
-0.0010742338,
-0.0169535074,
0.0092725987,
0.0193093047,
-0.0315004624,
-0.0636581928,
-0.0267152879,
-0.0067681824,
0.034678068,
0.0128819244,
-0.0409515947,
0.0218378529,
-0.0366337858,
0.0016401459,
0.0184540767,
0.0139294248,
0.017438652,
-0.044428505,
0.0853489563,
-0.0013420149,
-0.0032565312,
0.0039349394,
0.0149025247,
-0.0175469555,
-0.0563551262,
0.025918046,
0.0646137372,
-0.0192929748,
-0.001459343,
0.0000022053,
-0.0669129267,
0.0079903714,
-0.019654911,
-0.0445930958,
-0.0193401128,
0.038208317,
0.0537594967,
-0.014634138,
0.0123533485,
-0.047721073,
0.0211703256,
0.0248733461,
-0.0145178372,
0.054178264,
0.0619010217,
0.011900574,
0.0470746644,
0.0021824483,
-0.0184453521,
0.0076961126,
-0.0709409565,
-0.0240505412,
-0.009978015,
0.0663145036,
0.0106772985,
0.0190632045,
0.009050834,
0.0168936998,
-0.0218099039,
0.0354542509,
0.0110973623,
-0.0740681067,
-0.0389576554,
-0.0255568251,
0.1044514328,
0.0121001108,
-0.0160227809,
0.0106468135,
-0.0188222472,
0.0243942402,
0.0206762496,
-0.0486112684,
0.0011205298,
0.0032898656,
-0.0038145769,
-0.026923025,
0.0023110278,
0.0095407553,
0.0076404638,
0.0339363292,
0.0824406818,
0.0133871362,
-0.0030563592,
0.0204632338,
0.0156051265,
0.013822915,
-0.086500518,
0.0171773508,
0.0037538703,
-0.0735869706,
0.0114846053,
-0.0222448334,
-0.0072518755,
0.0329320431,
-0.0318903662,
0.0328112133,
0.0461069569,
-0.0397534296,
0.057379555,
0.0149022928,
0.0575408377,
0.0307642501,
0.0111362375,
-0.0223056637,
0.005683783,
-0.0258303247,
0.0115099726,
-0.0223021004,
0.0217225291,
-0.0145774065,
0.0019553376,
-0.0312792771,
0.0357330963,
-0.0248954017,
0.0324185863,
0.0139212664,
-0.0011850331,
-0.0210881662,
-0.0082385847,
-0.0534368977,
-0.0128079196,
-0.0726795867,
0.0094905896,
0.0506170727,
-0.1096345633,
0.0207808819,
0.0254647564,
-0.02400079,
-0.0168111417,
0.0018528214,
0.0798404366,
0.0069072517,
-0.0156913977,
-0.0192757677,
-0.0159177631,
-0.0036271384,
-0.056254711,
-0.0040401681,
-0.0788383707,
0.0241049696,
0.0108252373,
-0.0121368608,
-0.049142316,
0.0010576916,
0.0336377025,
0.0076067853,
0.0490641557,
-0.0257036854,
0.000280904,
0.0451934524,
0.0283999704,
-0.0636783764,
0.0719534382,
0.0152135435,
0.0478846356,
0.0551446378,
-0.0001065146,
0.0266048145,
0.0560019799,
-0.0224227197,
0.0046973913,
-0.0139448261,
0.0251753405,
-0.0170544125,
0.0558144599,
0.01081484,
0.0494582057,
-0.0202779714,
-0.0041707349,
0.0714562535,
0.0742923841,
-0.0199999232,
-0.0303194877,
0.031969782,
0.0265015252,
0.041741468,
0.0039059815,
-0.051631514,
0.0316915251,
-0.0325715281,
-0.0101851169,
0.0252031181,
0.0042367545,
-0.0059481198,
-0.0412827022,
-0.0100754965,
-0.0024302751,
-0.0031431075,
-0.0049204445,
0.0458003543,
0.0140753109,
-0.0292128064,
0.0495710783,
0.0099383052,
-0.0524812452,
-0.0226046797,
-0.0366705135,
0.0205985848,
0.054635454,
0.0572322048,
-0.0273778532,
-0.0608709529,
0.0051248665,
0.0032145816,
0.0704723522,
0.0612318404,
-0.0146522969,
-0.0229338575,
-0.0356477872,
-0.0253868811,
0.0030922405,
0.0009283983,
-0.0033896507,
0.0405704416,
0.0021054989,
-0.0107579017,
-0.0679878816,
-0.0373942927,
0.0337761752,
-0.0308796037,
-0.0058983183,
-0.0253480319,
-0.0168825891,
0.0325921886,
0.0254534781,
0.0051043523,
0.0087489365,
0.0386487469,
-0.0110244406,
0.0006880959,
0.0158036128,
-0.0436335243,
0.0010043592,
0.0484197251,
-0.0310303029,
-0.0581741668,
0.0534965843,
-0.0142805316,
-0.000207293,
-0.0280518308,
-0.0187341161,
0.0244446788,
-0.0266268719,
0.041424375,
-0.0249122307,
-0.0197386723,
-0.0336748287,
0.0396363027,
-0.0126950471,
0.0128006572,
0.0267081652,
0.0081374943,
-0.0070495578,
-0.038037274,
-0.026480414,
0.0439367555,
-0.018048821,
0.0240103714,
0.0308764707,
0.0332551114,
-0.0965722054,
-0.0106142228,
-0.1015435681,
0.0148867294,
-0.0213308781,
-0.0015888847,
0.0113955652,
-0.00151271,
-0.0177634452,
-0.0228593312,
-0.0457216389,
-0.028448401,
-0.0014874403,
0.0397450477,
0.046248015,
-0.0124575589,
-0.0004854733,
-0.0555890277,
0.0197366867,
0.0028941368,
0.0155846588,
0.0047458378,
0.0066179377,
-0.0243104305,
0.0400537178,
-0.0275623444,
0.0015946706,
-0.0131798368,
-0.0311304796,
0.0505077951,
0.0021949224,
0.0392375365,
0.044269748,
0.040759109,
0.0125143733,
0.0420922339,
0.0059615644,
-0.0784487128,
-0.0165348724,
0.0199802686,
-0.0237697866,
-0.0207271501,
-0.0298397802,
0.0450601876,
0.0524202771,
-0.0090575749,
0.0316718668,
-0.0539859124,
0.0156201106,
-0.0283805802,
-0.0335673243,
-0.0551668331,
0.0090120025,
-0.0539882965,
0.0590340942,
-0.0260718074,
-0.0548136719,
0.0789014325,
-0.0540833287,
-0.005202041,
-0.0149571793,
-0.0272047333,
-0.0378650241,
0.0318039358,
-0.0157965869,
0.0107410979,
-0.0014018052,
-0.0063054054,
-0.0366218351,
0.0078461561,
0.0342607014,
-0.0676162988,
0.0269792862,
-0.0608872175,
0.0112937316,
0.0091600772,
-0.0468396321,
-0.0514012948,
-0.0337862596,
-0.0661359876,
-0.012140369,
0.0401439518,
-0.0289474037,
0.0014229324,
-0.0115919095,
-0.0092211682,
0.0516207814,
0.0075236945,
-0.0183126442,
0.0032840311,
0.0139857931,
0.027519824,
0.0574325249,
-0.0178694148,
-0.0193301309,
0.0075791222,
0.0486350618,
0.0537046343,
-0.0225504022,
-0.0403131843,
0.0081864884,
0.0537902974,
-0.0460110009,
-0.0164068118,
0.0396912098,
0.0615564026,
-0.0428176895,
0.007820297,
0.1118132696,
0.0143021289,
-0.0423761606,
0.009041423,
-0.0364291035,
0.0449269898,
0.0404777303,
0.0209874604,
-0.1135885641,
-0.0413361751,
0.0286455359,
0.0559641793,
0.0001616185,
-0.0427739546,
-0.0095225824,
-0.1449060291,
0.0288837627,
-0.0227664635,
-0.0408415608,
0.0282917488,
-0.0477965996,
0.0138613209,
-0.0225069821,
0.0204818081,
0.0196687318,
0.0020015268,
0.0095726438,
0.0119295623,
-0.0687048137,
-0.050534144,
0.0605132729,
-0.055872824,
0.0989845246,
0.0561335869,
0.0410188325,
0.0134034315,
-0.0385585539,
0.0618956126,
0.0387958921,
0.0140783237,
-0.0151337981,
0.051980678,
-0.0089572603,
-0.0052249897,
-0.0189554673,
0.0047699162,
-0.0252185557,
-0.0096139601,
0.0255106594,
0.0421249792,
-0.0081259757,
0.010835276,
-0.0188285578,
0.0145931281,
0.0083985357,
0.079283841,
0.0494816415,
-0.0489482582,
-0.0163519587,
-0.0478912294,
-0.0153526887,
-0.0260175765,
-0.0709755197,
-0.0083456216,
-0.0174334981,
-0.0020510333,
-0.0850515515,
-0.0352281183,
0.0320684537,
0.024849534,
0.0044780644,
0.016258195,
-0.0091949711,
-0.0079019787,
-0.0169037823,
0.0660332292,
-0.0297391284,
0.0217361897,
-0.1071939766,
-0.0023835383,
0.0338942967,
-0.0366660729,
-0.0116984276,
0.0424126722,
-0.0636690035,
-0.0567981862,
0.0039003203,
0.0325757153,
0.0241014734,
0.0191971995,
-0.0208056066,
-0.0713596046,
-0.0100711221,
0.0256293286,
-0.0476220846,
0.0081191333,
0.0055710454,
0.026596779,
-0.0122952033,
0.0096188486,
-0.0690607131,
0.0059539275,
-0.0039415648,
0.0349390469,
-0.0056662001,
-0.0805951878,
0.0226100013,
0.0643909574,
0.0407972559,
-0.0149709722,
-0.0419098139,
-0.0116580091,
-0.001090916,
0.0067114932,
-0.0326911844,
-0.0475650951,
-0.0081436187,
-0.0015034579,
-0.0209498219,
0.0199280307,
0.0573104806,
-0.0369651802,
0.0483106896,
-0.0378871001,
0.0141698252,
0.03595737,
0.0389219448,
0.0140123907,
0.005641202,
-0.0146200052,
0.0063428101,
-0.0157322381,
0.0856607929,
-0.0029654859,
0.0312648304,
0.0046985745,
-0.0149065303,
0.0583932698,
0.0517834723,
-0.0416255705,
-0.0625013933,
-0.0080285249,
0.0534321778,
0.0587501675,
0.0167798903,
0.0379253849,
-0.0011875074,
0.0033727081,
-0.0262182932,
-0.0019465868,
-0.0105334753,
-0.0133914426,
-0.0035813903,
0.0260383151,
-0.0228377581,
0.0263984948,
0.0602875017,
0.0071912333,
0.0183432661,
-0.0030584743,
0.0176227987,
-0.0518849939,
0.0065646069,
0.0093115894,
0.0082700206,
-0.0079387734,
-0.042531535,
-0.0686357021,
-0.0485749692,
0.0106631583,
0.0299944449,
-0.0137563301,
0.0012249496,
0.0614055991,
0.0545415133,
-0.0282377284,
0.0013230526,
-0.0461606868,
-0.0156714823,
-0.0315107144,
-0.0062998631,
-0.0363281071,
-6.382153356e-33,
-0.0285799168,
-0.0626581758,
0.0237296559,
-0.0192917157,
-0.0180653483,
-0.009640323,
-0.0325468034,
0.0237643458,
-0.0087366505,
-0.0078542773,
-0.0360971317,
-0.0014512721,
0.0157781001,
-0.0212114286,
0.0143252127,
-0.0324355438,
0.0387426391,
-0.0172643773,
-0.0654981956,
0.008056527,
-0.0057312972,
0.0133837098,
0.0214230753,
-0.0779646933,
0.0544496737,
0.0041924291,
-0.0216476098,
0.0135509372,
0.0216130204,
0.0580474734,
0.014634354,
0.0433480814,
0.014261364,
-0.041508235,
-0.0209245421,
-0.0096737333,
-0.0331213623,
-0.0420710109,
0.0200934913,
0.0095664831,
-0.0339085571,
-0.0210250523,
0.0348927528,
-0.0064809462,
-0.0446290001,
0.0402201265,
0.0363267325,
-0.0323832184,
-0.0049336455,
0.009042657,
-0.0371278487,
0.0254529491,
-0.0212085322,
-0.0329212062,
-0.00402926,
0.0532568134,
-0.0207801405,
0.0376756452,
-0.0525171012,
0.0450708121,
-0.032209266,
0.0131993797,
0.1191199273,
0.0053006406,
-0.0150864376,
0.0924287289,
0.0224113483,
0.0354812481,
0.0208923928,
-0.0302354898,
0.0306312982,
0.0938294977,
0.0466561876,
0.0681644231,
0.008459758,
0.0005395927,
0.0084222602,
0.0872564167,
0.0442854315,
-0.009987927,
-0.0084530627,
0.0342342928,
-0.0621140786,
-0.0056282543,
-0.0402695984,
0.0190963466,
-0.0381879434,
-0.0239355154,
0.0551925711,
-0.0207309425,
-0.0141364643,
-0.0364324488,
-0.0015988821,
-0.0203836262,
-0.0091088815,
-0.0004645897,
-0.0251477119,
0.0287533272,
0.0101543125,
0.0222008694,
-0.0290748533,
0.004517396,
0.0035133273,
0.0359028801,
0.0540162176,
0.0064756558,
-0.0175330639,
0.0034149545,
-0.0442335084,
0.0083585316,
-0.0266391858,
0.0080740061,
-0.0210893154,
0.0079506552,
0.0304753259,
-0.0335120223,
-0.0368611477,
0.07725209,
-0.0001360462,
-0.0038561928,
-0.0533844009,
0.0157142635,
-0.0015833856,
-0.0181757342,
-0.0215268843,
-0.0104613025,
-0.0252230316,
0.0248720907,
0.0403490588,
-0.0119244475,
-0.0172875095,
-0.0258250628,
2.767e-7,
0.0208987519,
0.058439929,
0.0181418695,
0.0267614517,
-0.0332140774,
0.0477945022,
-0.0348152556,
0.0079421541,
0.0266195443,
-0.0155150285,
-0.0247595478,
0.0266463067,
0.0724852681,
0.0400993675,
-0.0956709757,
-0.0197906755,
-0.0629657432,
0.0092775095,
-0.0413577482,
-0.0081134513,
0.0277762823,
0.0220015105,
-0.0071446993,
-0.015475749,
-0.0106695658,
-0.0413846709,
0.0204110406,
-0.0639622286,
-0.0220229682,
0.0393804908,
0.0411825702,
0.025212286,
0.0043174545,
-0.004133781,
-0.0215296112,
-0.0264618043,
0.033469893,
0.0588774048,
0.0257379021,
-0.041186966,
-0.0008745433,
-0.0129109472,
0.0034381787,
-0.0336982086,
0.04635638,
-0.0179556347,
-0.0103745125,
-0.0605507568,
-0.0238057394,
-0.0309740771,
0.0242393985,
-0.0386685431,
-0.0156906322,
-0.000601562,
0.0122057796,
-0.0067972336,
-0.0496137254,
-0.0269623194,
-0.029416956,
0.0000012888,
-0.0420567952,
-0.0845698565,
-0.052799236,
0.0012456056,
-0.0364792086,
-0.0435118228,
0.0118703982,
2.487783413e-34,
0.0157478936,
0.0114194015,
0.0382469818,
0.0521891862,
0.0358150341,
0.0301800612,
0.0007652641,
0.0108999796,
0.0023334306,
-0.034239281,
0.0161694791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11757v1 | STAR: SocioTechnical Approach to Red Teaming Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:16:45 | 2024-06-17T17:16:45 | Laura Weidinger, John Mellor, Bernat Guillen Pegueroles, Nahema Marchal, Ravin Kumar, Kristian Lum, Canfer Akbulut, Mark Diaz, Stevie Bergman, Mikel Rodriguez, Verena Rieser, William Isaac | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | This research introduces STAR, a sociotechnical framework that improves on
current best practices for red teaming safety of large language models. STAR
makes two key contributions: it enhances steerability by generating
parameterised instructions for human red teamers, leading to improved coverage
of the risk surface. Parameterised instructions also provide more detailed
insights into model failures at no increased cost. Second, STAR improves signal
quality by matching demographics to assess harms for specific groups, resulting
in more sensitive annotations. STAR further employs a novel step of arbitration
to leverage diverse viewpoints and improve label reliability, treating
disagreement not as noise but as a valuable contribution to signal quality. | [
0.0166199654,
0.0358656794,
-0.0075876848,
-0.0021683597,
-0.0209776424,
0.0011850897,
0.0210866574,
-0.0170326866,
-0.0082740821,
-0.0682184994,
-0.0093004135,
0.0010969285,
0.0032440422,
0.0039620418,
0.0248810388,
-0.0486875214,
0.0636289045,
-0.0541340113,
0.0223462693,
0.0008921367,
0.0392968655,
0.0222183168,
0.0089071142,
0.0701140836,
-0.0268516727,
-0.0150803691,
0.008603923,
0.0074758925,
0.0464512371,
-0.0094873523,
0.0336712785,
0.0714814141,
-0.0094219046,
0.0506398529,
0.0000020231,
-0.0208757184,
-0.0304436628,
0.037189994,
0.0093411002,
0.0162895471,
0.0280794036,
0.0038701908,
-0.0401055142,
0.0513356775,
-0.0161516257,
0.0030331856,
0.0849629641,
-0.0037168192,
0.0784586743,
0.0317951664,
-0.0147545282,
0.0401444845,
0.0091486657,
-0.0074951816,
-0.0306728631,
-0.0273354929,
0.0427496396,
0.0273376908,
0.0232346412,
-0.0026108325,
0.0069768964,
0.0537391081,
0.0257701911,
-0.0417301469,
-0.0557590686,
-0.0021729306,
-0.0376599319,
-0.0343486443,
-0.019512618,
0.0333624743,
0.0031240119,
-0.0157471187,
-0.0160082523,
0.0062251911,
-0.0076972316,
0.0026415242,
-0.0112550668,
0.0308036674,
-0.0256883986,
0.0026168223,
0.0213330928,
0.0201518405,
0.018771328,
-0.0193610676,
0.0200895071,
0.0893469676,
-0.0085290819,
-0.010145288,
-0.0168518759,
0.0234559942,
-0.0087153995,
-0.02727402,
0.0211331509,
-0.0217076968,
-0.0373137891,
0.0220847614,
-0.0259123296,
-0.0437497832,
0.0667682961,
-0.0835609958,
0.022883445,
0.0125381127,
0.0243929662,
0.028857993,
0.0419831797,
-0.0400908776,
0.0204016976,
0.0127416132,
0.0008980696,
0.0132245133,
-0.0181239955,
-0.0075098248,
-0.0524084754,
-0.021240877,
-0.0015850501,
0.0279353335,
-0.0200143028,
0.020437805,
-0.0336330384,
-0.0031004923,
0.0117109399,
-0.0378591418,
-0.0401139334,
0.0014245642,
0.0277381986,
-0.0050908634,
-0.0247997325,
0.0220414307,
-0.0012665085,
-0.0871561244,
0.0175567325,
0.0028444561,
-0.0773313493,
-0.0300818961,
-0.0425036475,
0.0778799951,
0.0249963701,
0.0158462692,
-0.0085457293,
-0.0644691586,
-0.0414852649,
-0.0347739793,
-0.0156737287,
-0.073924616,
-0.0185419712,
0.0080623673,
-0.0134579735,
-0.0601933226,
0.006716935,
-0.010558228,
-0.0348840915,
0.0446545109,
-0.0476976857,
0.0021898011,
-0.0083273249,
0.0417439453,
-0.0130204987,
0.090162605,
0.0435251668,
-0.0327968858,
0.0223660432,
-0.026782345,
0.0266297124,
0.0670109913,
-0.0053398125,
0.0477675684,
-0.0301073864,
-0.0243555065,
0.0356138572,
-0.0218072534,
0.0027104334,
0.0796679556,
-0.0257825088,
-0.0276779123,
0.0465149358,
0.0057858871,
0.0119345766,
0.0233551655,
0.0130768586,
0.0341979414,
-0.0304537117,
-0.0234491304,
-0.0348877981,
0.0102772312,
-0.0501912683,
-0.0388124622,
0.0046750647,
0.0376035422,
-0.0116407415,
-0.0160381142,
-0.0301199425,
0.0052489634,
0.055402603,
-0.0004015573,
0.0167665277,
-0.0111556305,
-0.0146207213,
0.0367700383,
0.0410788581,
-0.0501820445,
-0.0204586312,
-0.0436095484,
-0.0181340184,
0.0381169394,
0.0376652926,
-0.0388362557,
-0.0251228046,
-0.0273166951,
-0.0040085563,
0.006840392,
0.0499060974,
0.0112187052,
0.0032970004,
-0.0514894165,
-0.0324714594,
0.0712043047,
0.0079177935,
0.0189482421,
0.0231860187,
-0.0072614066,
-0.0377192385,
0.0081150634,
-0.1010792181,
0.0250866991,
0.0056939623,
-0.00894826,
-0.0400722362,
0.0046608518,
0.0201653484,
0.0018777348,
-0.0417267978,
0.0276885256,
0.0163163394,
0.0223373435,
-0.003622313,
0.0296286251,
0.0035946546,
0.0114901047,
0.0275265258,
-0.0392752998,
-0.0349723659,
0.0348828956,
-0.0123467771,
0.0108401086,
0.0309149344,
-0.0717089772,
0.0128999176,
0.0178344697,
0.0024515854,
-0.0110435048,
0.0161642954,
-0.0268588625,
-0.0042793113,
-0.013429773,
-0.0395153649,
-0.0503431447,
-0.0552816652,
0.0258721597,
-0.0765842274,
-0.0369968265,
0.0173548162,
-0.001218599,
0.0599858277,
0.0298234019,
0.0267596077,
-0.0103654526,
-0.0035004599,
-0.0432517566,
-0.0256171618,
-0.0218150839,
0.0232105199,
0.0039156172,
-0.020929141,
-0.0226512533,
-0.0128995087,
0.0220311414,
-0.0036044961,
-0.0259451717,
0.0251932424,
0.0028138608,
-0.0149624115,
-0.0700558499,
-0.0141201559,
-0.0317796692,
-0.0463660732,
0.0509736761,
0.0497866347,
-0.0643909201,
-0.0937261805,
0.0197144449,
-0.0288060829,
0.0169281214,
0.0198533144,
-0.0679141134,
0.0303747654,
0.0268402714,
0.0313056558,
0.0139000956,
-0.0409077518,
0.0367641039,
0.0692697093,
-0.0162666291,
-0.0335902721,
-0.0123932622,
-0.0111476649,
-0.0327664204,
0.0090178624,
-0.0664646924,
-0.009683283,
0.0795820206,
0.0014656316,
-0.031083053,
-0.0566652007,
-0.03231382,
-0.0534064025,
-0.0467612408,
-0.002930576,
-0.0823343843,
-0.0138924187,
0.0300338492,
-0.0159648247,
-0.0503677502,
0.0803217217,
-0.0111029176,
0.0119151995,
-0.08305154,
-0.0417182483,
-0.0140102459,
0.0128907636,
-0.0371941924,
0.0215691384,
0.0558431558,
-0.0018586501,
-0.0001376416,
-0.018454494,
0.0360152163,
-0.0188999586,
0.040890485,
-0.0901509598,
0.0168565437,
0.0002514024,
-0.0111001572,
-0.0039735287,
-0.0180423968,
-0.0480376408,
0.0190677214,
0.0439920612,
0.0072052157,
-0.03549942,
0.0500829965,
0.0342209339,
-0.0083157551,
0.0030024978,
-0.0090903705,
0.0065378984,
-0.0433417074,
0.0008397469,
-0.0548951104,
0.0632154346,
-0.0486756265,
0.020274505,
0.0916678905,
0.0361904167,
-0.0028399222,
-0.0326932631,
-0.0300866421,
0.0473203957,
0.0263862666,
-0.0405402556,
0.0309077259,
0.0695582777,
-0.0728690103,
-0.0012612208,
0.0436656959,
0.0184606146,
-0.0358171426,
0.0235212222,
-0.0350735225,
0.0629687905,
-0.0094978632,
0.0229543783,
-0.0628950968,
0.0076074502,
0.0171186198,
0.0200400539,
-0.0215536542,
-0.0187341757,
-0.0032221533,
-0.0586940423,
0.0535028651,
0.0364301875,
-0.0950525105,
-0.007313008,
-0.0348923318,
-0.0014471347,
-0.0209138375,
0.0742141008,
0.0098619964,
0.0104386276,
-0.020197304,
0.0510093644,
-0.0992281288,
-0.0369516015,
0.0203876924,
-0.056238763,
0.1077944189,
0.0421570949,
-0.0097083524,
-0.030839676,
-0.0097168712,
0.0376587808,
0.0192068573,
-0.0056883488,
-0.0111227054,
0.0485536829,
0.0031401543,
-0.0142145259,
-0.0327989571,
0.0139957322,
-0.024859935,
-0.0245950464,
-0.008872712,
0.0670688972,
-0.024450615,
-0.0245442148,
-0.0366078205,
0.0557768904,
0.0473324731,
0.0591860823,
0.016767079,
-0.0396108627,
-0.0323114432,
-0.0561460257,
0.0193415266,
-0.0398917347,
-0.0688143149,
0.0103213703,
-0.0454846099,
-0.0936892629,
-0.0292917509,
-0.041866336,
0.045409523,
0.0259173978,
0.0231650546,
-0.007596836,
0.0219718143,
-0.0045307404,
0.0052597164,
0.0519913062,
-0.0161551572,
0.0513236783,
-0.0667423457,
0.0277526639,
-0.0289133899,
0.0344368555,
-0.0124662435,
0.0565086231,
-0.0250541531,
-0.0925518498,
0.0563672259,
0.0602916218,
0.035483405,
-0.0223204661,
-0.0328136012,
-0.1020932794,
-0.0017312869,
0.0235036518,
-0.0001631903,
0.0124930246,
0.0488520488,
-0.0397094712,
0.0122046936,
0.0116862664,
-0.0283220876,
0.0187470466,
-0.0048773452,
0.0095391441,
-0.0828270167,
-0.013952977,
-0.0075051272,
0.0144164721,
0.0296086464,
-0.0400651544,
-0.0072159199,
-0.006577475,
-0.0126912175,
-0.0411852561,
-0.009559894,
-0.0142700728,
0.0305976793,
-0.0176383741,
-0.0234705079,
0.0076544522,
0.0236352943,
-0.04067472,
0.0114544434,
-0.0069878572,
0.0656845197,
0.016119495,
0.0361952782,
0.0409781411,
0.0170669686,
-0.0012675184,
0.0126709426,
-0.014828302,
0.0284795277,
0.0330899209,
0.0243519936,
0.0143837007,
-0.0182478148,
0.0360569097,
0.025213385,
-0.0068234676,
-0.0770738423,
-0.0044962717,
0.0216522925,
0.0176440217,
0.0524595603,
0.0703315437,
-0.0432650112,
-0.0071217804,
-0.0518432409,
0.0251411553,
-0.0078466879,
-0.0042114328,
0.0379193015,
0.021851534,
-0.0175927747,
-0.0056239152,
0.052445475,
0.0411902517,
0.0454491787,
-0.043015264,
-0.0346457176,
-0.015199868,
-0.0197068248,
0.0105419112,
-0.0051495554,
-0.0532619692,
-0.0333926268,
-0.1084965169,
-0.0708600283,
-0.0084837954,
0.0495002605,
0.012449611,
0.0032539391,
-0.0024257316,
0.0273025353,
-0.003377344,
-0.0096363071,
-0.0270445868,
0.0054464033,
-0.0326901898,
-0.0106598642,
0.0031216091,
-6.536212176e-33,
-0.0217992011,
-0.0479978919,
0.016325729,
0.0118629131,
-0.0104754809,
0.0250855815,
-0.0251940917,
0.0424389429,
0.0005786648,
0.0489851125,
0.0445214137,
0.0015410435,
0.020308217,
-0.026302008,
0.0210016128,
-0.0150672067,
0.0018720101,
0.0161118004,
-0.0024665927,
-0.0153661491,
0.0159879159,
-0.0131908208,
0.0501116104,
-0.1280539334,
0.0598615445,
0.0204506889,
-0.0368395187,
0.0222500321,
-0.0381716378,
0.0629789531,
0.0284997635,
0.0388705656,
-0.010951208,
-0.0341144204,
-0.0201181099,
0.041070316,
-0.0365983732,
-0.0030949756,
0.0253885351,
0.0051606083,
-0.0550990179,
-0.0231264532,
0.0425222255,
0.0207179338,
-0.0450331494,
-0.0092682745,
0.0204208698,
-0.0118408902,
-0.0160762109,
0.0299039874,
-0.0319750868,
0.042502638,
-0.0128055094,
-0.021660028,
0.0197850671,
0.0423435569,
0.00081983,
-0.0146362837,
-0.0532431453,
0.0210417286,
-0.0135394353,
-0.0091355955,
0.072302483,
0.0107781803,
-0.0166783221,
0.0516472608,
-0.0160606969,
0.0156983696,
-0.0142719578,
-0.0525104292,
0.0270166509,
0.0405712463,
0.037752375,
0.0449464694,
-0.0449752547,
-0.0048178816,
-0.0622489341,
0.0283638965,
0.0357816517,
0.0247898716,
-0.0024010646,
0.0425250269,
-0.1160893962,
-0.042950701,
-0.0161132868,
-0.0171609037,
-0.0047230963,
-0.0250873957,
0.0150120864,
-0.0397075228,
-0.0562173165,
0.0353273414,
0.0193016417,
-0.0065191234,
0.0070170639,
0.0014511265,
0.0130771324,
0.0075557381,
-0.0295475237,
0.0331038907,
-0.0408140793,
0.0244362745,
0.0239295661,
-0.0020399068,
0.0505599305,
-0.0048826342,
0.0413732268,
0.041660212,
-0.0528364927,
0.0071821068,
-0.0184987355,
0.0563671291,
0.0366959013,
-0.0230031963,
0.0374364406,
0.0014770725,
0.0261371136,
0.0532527938,
0.0534167625,
0.0051370491,
0.0023900014,
0.0603489131,
-0.0512116812,
-0.0101529956,
-0.0179778226,
0.0046257847,
0.0104882931,
-0.011855552,
0.0862039775,
-0.0362731256,
-0.0313393213,
-0.041600965,
2.702e-7,
0.0783907026,
0.0779633746,
0.0548865087,
-0.0058926577,
0.0245597363,
0.0651312023,
0.0005419943,
0.0474845544,
0.0589384697,
0.0380255505,
-0.0127672628,
0.0198566262,
0.0487943776,
0.0876354054,
-0.002115401,
-0.0262217857,
-0.0651488379,
0.0165154338,
-0.0352499895,
-0.0291367956,
0.0569196008,
0.0308171213,
0.0368822552,
-0.0136837363,
-0.0270641167,
-0.0217950772,
0.0039600949,
-0.043379195,
-0.018714197,
0.0341544859,
0.008651494,
0.0047621406,
0.0195327103,
0.0596227311,
0.0013470175,
-0.0427013859,
0.0050303461,
0.0623815395,
-0.0294106174,
-0.0078851534,
0.0133471349,
-0.0484791137,
-0.0071970522,
-0.0312424339,
0.0360562764,
-0.0137226768,
-0.0272564162,
-0.0192535035,
-0.0094207069,
-0.0203545503,
0.0337889567,
-0.0140843187,
-0.0077375378,
0.0272500888,
0.0004026963,
0.0131082917,
-0.0204121284,
-0.0222556535,
-0.0368587039,
0.0167578645,
-0.0159872603,
-0.0748549253,
0.0309957955,
0.0248403642,
-0.0406937934,
-0.0601644963,
0.0277293455,
2.663617394e-34,
0.0318708904,
-0.0216005743,
0.0002606983,
-0.0063347509,
0.0484857894,
0.0014075154,
-0.0320510976,
0.007881728,
0.029966969,
-0.0018451046,
-0.02210759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11753v1 | A Semantic-based Layer Freezing Approach to Efficient Fine-Tuning of Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:13:08 | 2024-06-17T17:13:08 | Jian Gu, Aldeida Aleti, Chunyang Chen, Hongyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Finetuning language models (LMs) is crucial for adapting the models to
downstream data and tasks. However, full finetuning is usually costly. Existing
work, such as parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT), often focuses on
\textit{how to finetune} but neglects the issue of \textit{where to finetune}.
As a pioneering work on answering where to finetune (at the layer level), we
conduct a semantic analysis of the LM inference process. We first propose a
virtual transition of the latent representation and then trace its factual
transition. Based on the deviation in transitions, we estimate the gain of
finetuning each model layer, and further, narrow down the scope for finetuning.
We perform extensive experiments across well-known LMs and datasets. The
results show that our approach is effective and efficient, and outperforms the
existing baselines. Our approach is orthogonal to existing efficient
techniques, such as PEFT methods, offering practical values on LM finetuning. | [
0.0080555277,
0.0624978729,
-0.0396507569,
0.0680976659,
-0.0395424105,
0.0206915513,
-0.0172637478,
-0.035572961,
-0.0637261644,
-0.0381294861,
-0.0039064633,
-0.0099099474,
0.0307611451,
-0.0049921949,
0.0296832379,
-0.0632008389,
0.0273981579,
-0.0487149023,
-0.0187707655,
-0.0007174309,
0.0067366529,
0.0121080568,
0.0303904396,
0.0443002619,
0.0507383905,
0.0014044259,
0.0071295928,
0.0216623228,
0.028283067,
0.0111633353,
-0.0005257744,
0.0556481443,
0.0089724036,
0.0264820438,
0.0000022033,
-0.0339868441,
-0.0184653737,
-0.0170143414,
-0.0000249256,
0.0481467284,
0.0682405978,
-0.04177057,
-0.0148163494,
0.0000127489,
-0.0128093576,
-0.0079427399,
0.0667234808,
0.0189930927,
0.0175623298,
0.0321964137,
-0.006748959,
-0.0002852051,
-0.0192663707,
-0.0305356607,
-0.0563467145,
-0.0713035092,
0.0393546671,
-0.0180493519,
-0.0329932049,
-0.036833819,
-0.0507906638,
0.0671160221,
-0.0123934988,
0.0209858268,
-0.055909954,
0.0394695587,
-0.0179160163,
-0.0214172136,
0.0275302753,
0.0612950474,
-0.0690288171,
-0.0358953737,
0.0381182469,
-0.0350436866,
-0.0097062876,
0.0249587521,
-0.0407374017,
-0.003691812,
0.0176276732,
0.0179521982,
0.0752832517,
-0.0208463892,
0.0650920197,
0.0392338634,
-0.0302387588,
0.0667572394,
0.0180488061,
-0.0004071338,
-0.0219723172,
-0.0244982969,
-0.0323400609,
-0.0323980525,
-0.0365190394,
-0.0151557149,
-0.0094311517,
0.0026359144,
-0.0483359545,
0.0042947922,
-0.0047674146,
-0.0024694835,
0.0827226266,
0.0349479914,
-0.0014689025,
0.0380846076,
-0.0090714116,
0.0061700391,
-0.0103384117,
0.0242879763,
-0.0575995818,
-0.0043980028,
0.0229918044,
0.0108038504,
-0.0536133945,
-0.0219040439,
-0.0228287056,
0.0044392385,
-0.021331396,
0.0081861643,
0.0015932849,
-0.0201063603,
-0.0238383133,
-0.0232718345,
-0.0421228409,
0.000215731,
0.0017410165,
0.0244178977,
-0.0370258912,
0.0458803698,
-0.0210773591,
-0.0631710663,
-0.0230637714,
0.0210295878,
0.0136788534,
-0.0093895206,
-0.0091341976,
0.0450215489,
0.0154826846,
-0.013316175,
-0.0477065407,
-0.0113473479,
-0.0144069819,
-0.0698324367,
0.0252947286,
-0.068065539,
0.0082825022,
0.0049515534,
0.0232251771,
-0.0673922747,
-0.0483457111,
-0.018311603,
-0.065984644,
0.0868134797,
-0.033305537,
0.0129897464,
-0.0001710811,
-0.0053753424,
0.0100523913,
0.0959852114,
0.0540977344,
0.0176517963,
0.043945346,
-0.0436323695,
-0.0126850903,
0.0584030449,
0.0251996964,
0.0312492624,
-0.0590580478,
-0.0177754462,
-0.0036875193,
0.0017581854,
0.0311354008,
0.0208358746,
-0.0232341047,
-0.0221401937,
0.0437976159,
0.0440714061,
0.0090491734,
0.0011684798,
0.0516873896,
0.0051582917,
-0.0443554111,
0.0427138954,
-0.0656706467,
0.0436553285,
-0.0086959833,
0.0036706864,
0.0298930481,
0.040150214,
-0.0216584746,
-0.0156753454,
-0.0097283116,
0.0059786839,
0.0099578621,
-0.0158700161,
0.0099344067,
0.016522022,
-0.0080338968,
0.0650216043,
0.053888388,
-0.007430579,
0.0157338008,
-0.0606396645,
-0.0038676921,
0.0555198975,
0.0154957399,
-0.0073825107,
-0.0310818646,
0.0153425541,
0.0581115447,
0.0073947809,
0.0486080758,
-0.0105370255,
0.028481612,
-0.0625973716,
-0.0122762052,
-0.0236992668,
0.0547825322,
-0.0151612964,
-0.0041540544,
0.000325739,
0.0347397327,
-0.077195093,
-0.0041660559,
0.0345893838,
-0.0430945046,
0.0155193638,
-0.0059421505,
-0.0108686741,
0.0212392844,
-0.0420375988,
-0.0126004955,
0.0117956996,
0.0073007201,
-0.0234746914,
-0.0034124157,
0.0094717182,
0.0112451715,
-0.0197798442,
0.0038502901,
-0.0251296032,
0.0324152708,
0.0238183718,
-0.083140932,
-0.0448318049,
0.0546836108,
0.0066536632,
0.0229397491,
-0.0287833437,
0.0275863297,
-0.0376942754,
0.0328477472,
-0.0358319543,
0.0206611343,
-0.0244562905,
0.0527632907,
0.0235114656,
0.0148062436,
0.0077140345,
-0.0250489712,
-0.027881518,
0.0350727439,
-0.004411072,
0.0235353075,
0.0108092958,
0.0048147589,
-0.0130457059,
-0.0276528839,
-0.0337889604,
0.0131712165,
-0.0432345308,
0.0256868992,
0.038360104,
0.0255879518,
-0.0056774965,
0.0139080519,
0.0161151756,
0.0280161593,
-0.0071913917,
0.0351975895,
0.0030100299,
-0.006244489,
-0.0506251715,
-0.0652025416,
-0.0290821884,
0.003303515,
0.0369948968,
-0.051373031,
-0.0192335639,
-0.0585920475,
-0.0261135716,
-0.0549833104,
0.0262943152,
-0.0349289738,
-0.0365138128,
-0.0114571517,
-0.0174672995,
0.0130363926,
0.0612794347,
0.0027671771,
0.0522657596,
0.0778571963,
-0.0190668665,
-0.0284634754,
-0.0101260366,
-0.041869428,
0.0048448197,
-0.0559204891,
-0.0198074337,
-0.0141415559,
0.081393227,
-0.0081754504,
0.0075199232,
-0.0702386647,
0.0529203899,
-0.0589528307,
0.0018047994,
0.0310580246,
0.0473345369,
-0.0128465481,
0.0460242182,
-0.0241738949,
-0.0449184328,
0.0725203305,
-0.0430755951,
0.030939931,
-0.0062197931,
-0.0215280596,
-0.0203251932,
0.0482721105,
0.0044714836,
0.012894704,
0.0072934707,
0.0120032076,
-0.0696293265,
-0.0032454752,
0.0554386154,
-0.0131258778,
0.0433561504,
-0.048365958,
0.0138158584,
-0.0203407966,
-0.0232727211,
0.0136021106,
-0.0596601367,
-0.0565558709,
0.0303876158,
0.0211740211,
-0.0134307547,
-0.0250653774,
0.0046360246,
-0.0375754163,
0.0508975163,
-0.0237216931,
0.0209100991,
-0.0473232605,
-0.0039873971,
0.0819748789,
0.0339287221,
0.0244744457,
-0.0212246701,
0.0381443948,
-0.0002042207,
-0.0002215908,
0.0459337942,
-0.0348146185,
0.0009252951,
0.0678191334,
0.0014218541,
-0.0350307226,
0.0290433615,
0.040595457,
-0.056793347,
-0.0259313211,
0.1004348621,
0.0034195045,
0.0112234391,
0.0432819091,
0.0153131178,
0.0557030551,
0.0132070007,
0.0098040197,
-0.0439139009,
-0.0471656062,
0.0271906704,
0.0442431644,
-0.0053981189,
-0.0140841296,
-0.0006751433,
-0.0613695905,
0.0535734333,
0.0083890278,
-0.0440476201,
-0.0021084065,
-0.0556240641,
0.0298286695,
-0.0186517686,
0.0125266537,
-0.0050872643,
-0.026919147,
0.0044516516,
0.0014017853,
-0.0176455155,
-0.0898957476,
0.0338857286,
-0.0341809057,
0.0727223158,
0.0613379516,
0.0421353206,
-0.0211688094,
-0.0366838761,
0.0694916993,
-0.0731169358,
-0.0276537109,
-0.0396170914,
0.0479400903,
0.025549572,
-0.0162144247,
0.0266073924,
0.0247627497,
0.010700156,
-0.0019500778,
-0.0308295339,
0.0511635132,
-0.0296205226,
-0.062254224,
0.0095487963,
0.0175968949,
-0.0278745629,
0.0684315637,
0.0497491881,
-0.0306688938,
-0.0288430694,
-0.03023085,
-0.0102637727,
-0.0216254238,
-0.0243630409,
0.0153067205,
-0.0135310227,
-0.0214159768,
-0.0255934782,
0.0033354657,
0.0229656566,
0.0166362673,
0.0000015517,
0.035282217,
0.0202780291,
-0.0083590262,
-0.0533936545,
0.0364536829,
-0.0462380536,
0.0378463492,
-0.0092258481,
0.0056139873,
0.0711412504,
-0.0074849199,
-0.0127097843,
0.017822342,
-0.0745814592,
-0.0864805728,
0.0155434133,
0.0102472436,
0.0208449904,
0.044258412,
-0.0208831113,
-0.1099338159,
0.0394289047,
0.0296048038,
-0.0329501107,
0.0465298072,
0.0248237364,
-0.0398375839,
-0.0175821204,
0.0707505196,
-0.0452978574,
0.0231885016,
0.0304792654,
0.0340573564,
-0.0193491131,
-0.0674325824,
-0.0048424979,
-0.0003011972,
0.0570505001,
-0.019620249,
-0.0335483551,
-0.0450964011,
-0.0021413213,
0.0200910866,
-0.0328611843,
-0.0520023033,
-0.0250739828,
0.012970943,
0.0388139561,
-0.016140623,
0.0145452917,
0.0043918062,
0.0378781855,
-0.0494495146,
0.0143533703,
0.0206917878,
0.0136376312,
0.0365482904,
0.0178669523,
-0.0126459254,
0.0576860085,
-0.0323615894,
0.0248396285,
-0.0423331968,
0.0176636688,
0.058127936,
0.0491700321,
-0.0576290824,
0.0352141298,
-0.0476665497,
-0.0583354235,
-0.0312885679,
-0.005266204,
0.0529777855,
-0.0208427049,
0.0886804312,
-0.0070487959,
-0.0190673862,
-0.025805397,
0.04789472,
0.0247205254,
-0.0533375517,
0.0545264743,
0.0301659517,
-0.033862669,
0.0093247779,
0.0545048453,
0.0395738333,
0.0430556089,
-0.0182150286,
-0.0045692562,
0.000096915,
-0.0245393775,
-0.0258403141,
0.0226446874,
-0.0153724682,
-0.0039041843,
-0.0577947609,
-0.1018694714,
-0.0336816683,
0.0057661003,
-0.0130981179,
-0.0358374827,
-0.010701647,
0.0861235783,
0.0162164997,
-0.0150237223,
-0.0534247495,
-0.0403594337,
0.0337814055,
-0.0320306085,
-0.0280642994,
-7.223089525e-33,
-0.0247963481,
0.010595616,
-0.0001044437,
0.0573312566,
-0.0181856789,
-0.0063819676,
-0.0375627391,
0.0093176812,
-0.0185131673,
0.0090831676,
0.0110994568,
-0.0051160348,
0.0181797352,
0.0047485395,
-0.0253166314,
-0.0230330732,
0.0771121457,
0.0041456372,
-0.0289196745,
0.009416909,
0.0045835185,
-0.0020068323,
0.0407143012,
-0.026914008,
0.0161777213,
-0.0103872959,
-0.0191771649,
0.0211290233,
-0.0202217568,
0.0277668573,
-0.0111695854,
0.0234074816,
0.0302496366,
-0.0406388007,
-0.0235832855,
-0.0257119462,
-0.0941071808,
-0.0250059012,
0.0556643568,
-0.0079410756,
-0.0489619263,
-0.0279207975,
0.0467668138,
0.0026301283,
-0.0238500424,
-0.0091635073,
0.0193344932,
-0.0119841415,
-0.0297707412,
-0.0403500795,
-0.0789965093,
0.0441561043,
0.001724557,
-0.0314382091,
0.0585251488,
-0.0151537601,
0.0092936978,
0.0214789845,
-0.058574494,
-0.0108830184,
0.0117269447,
0.0626659468,
0.0620369874,
0.0516482815,
-0.0171803962,
0.0264623221,
-0.028291909,
0.0165907666,
0.0114683723,
0.0045798644,
0.1096266285,
0.0367789343,
0.017876476,
0.007371447,
0.0240616892,
-0.0347782969,
-0.0449756272,
0.0022610598,
0.000129682,
0.0187845938,
0.0342573971,
0.0207185205,
0.0043137679,
-0.0641222969,
-0.1173306182,
-0.0181739498,
-0.0279939566,
0.0284633953,
0.0276247673,
0.0146881221,
-0.0392179266,
-0.0147279324,
0.0240394287,
-0.0442820936,
-0.0191199519,
-0.0221655928,
-0.0284179654,
0.0081449877,
0.0113363098,
0.040962588,
-0.0303359907,
-0.0582683012,
-0.0024169558,
-0.0275599789,
0.0378973037,
-0.0043732193,
0.0360814296,
0.0261091013,
-0.0450374335,
0.0000955509,
-0.032756824,
-0.0068719755,
-0.009639062,
0.0135247847,
0.019211065,
0.0030326478,
0.0017270322,
0.0036122377,
0.0496719368,
0.011712837,
-0.0141456909,
0.0256620403,
0.0128391469,
0.0344360657,
-0.0367993154,
-0.0194826573,
-0.0371447876,
-0.0091806296,
0.0629387945,
-0.0435749218,
-0.035579592,
0.0245824363,
2.912e-7,
0.0412848033,
0.0285892729,
-0.0191071015,
0.0249553882,
0.0139306234,
0.0285724662,
-0.0110279974,
0.0066625974,
0.0455073602,
-0.0195795409,
-0.0115358094,
0.0185815804,
0.0573685169,
0.0293335449,
-0.0628767386,
0.0103582321,
-0.0502072461,
0.0255345963,
-0.0263715517,
-0.0229435563,
-0.0042480575,
0.105676949,
0.0269146245,
0.0151070049,
-0.0164255425,
-0.0181449056,
0.0462640151,
-0.0463531688,
0.0145158181,
0.0471274741,
0.039556127,
0.019203743,
-0.0048195869,
0.0125253657,
-0.0086536072,
0.0383897088,
0.0035925186,
0.06954813,
0.0062478599,
0.0131333983,
-0.0146227786,
-0.0402770638,
-0.0035137073,
-0.0812567547,
0.0916943476,
-0.0919243619,
-0.0431300215,
-0.0469870083,
0.0182358269,
0.0328297429,
0.019474702,
-0.0086065261,
-0.00510001,
0.0407146178,
0.0379400812,
0.0031142449,
-0.0315498412,
-0.0698727816,
-0.0301440991,
0.01934525,
-0.0219225585,
-0.0475465469,
-0.0184390526,
-0.027333254,
0.0286604036,
-0.0459607914,
0.0337162912,
2.921397565e-34,
0.0523232892,
-0.028350139,
0.0134840086,
-0.0250361077,
0.0263520274,
-0.0101775695,
0.0214925911,
0.028401522,
0.0002967378,
-0.0979242176,
-0.0053184615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11745v1 | Multi-Layer Ranking with Large Language Models for News Source Recommendation | 2024-06-17T17:02:34 | 2024-06-17T17:02:34 | Wenjia Zhang, Lin Gui, Rob Procter, Yulan He | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | To seek reliable information sources for news events, we introduce a novel
task of expert recommendation, which aims to identify trustworthy sources based
on their previously quoted statements. To achieve this, we built a novel
dataset, called NewsQuote, consisting of 23,571 quote-speaker pairs sourced
from a collection of news articles. We formulate the recommendation task as the
retrieval of experts based on their likelihood of being associated with a given
query. We also propose a multi-layer ranking framework employing Large Language
Models to improve the recommendation performance. Our results show that
employing an in-context learning based LLM ranker and a multi-layer
ranking-based filter significantly improve both the predictive quality and
behavioural quality of the recommender system. | [
0.033353094,
0.0351973288,
0.013672106,
0.0380451381,
0.0144151766,
-0.0573263764,
0.0228624474,
0.0117058894,
0.0937671587,
-0.0220844131,
-0.057273522,
0.0079675242,
-0.0341218077,
0.0009991848,
-0.0071076979,
-0.003216269,
0.0073697199,
-0.0340635963,
0.0396467783,
-0.0154397348,
-0.0081346678,
0.0507023185,
0.0301140696,
0.0202378128,
0.0442478172,
-0.0088411644,
0.0182867441,
0.009187378,
0.0455049463,
-0.0021255368,
-0.0070956405,
-0.0194001812,
0.010703681,
-0.0211139508,
0.0000016539,
-0.0314920731,
-0.0310929623,
-0.0470732525,
-0.0044330158,
-0.0140747828,
-0.0137857702,
0.0183100309,
0.0051034489,
0.0280363336,
-0.0423063934,
0.0557462163,
-0.0192522854,
0.039033819,
0.0653797984,
0.0562622696,
-0.0257989056,
0.0140499137,
0.034638118,
-0.0123447319,
0.0343538858,
-0.0446381234,
0.0477808677,
-0.019617632,
-0.0044430345,
0.0632539392,
0.0348751992,
-0.0032580253,
-0.0177711342,
-0.0495118871,
0.0625453293,
0.0070165815,
-0.0098328609,
0.0153295845,
0.0004622849,
0.0737432986,
-0.0181879047,
0.0038233302,
-0.0052644433,
0.0279567037,
0.0163564142,
0.0762383565,
-0.0463180244,
-0.005331371,
-0.029601546,
0.0020153853,
0.0082960166,
-0.0166357365,
0.0360483043,
0.0440495834,
0.0117619662,
0.1051484793,
0.0034020052,
-0.0266523845,
0.0280275829,
-0.0083379783,
0.0222449936,
-0.0558299609,
0.0405097827,
-0.0190091264,
-0.0604393557,
0.0128807714,
0.008260292,
0.0808858052,
-0.013395031,
-0.0980602726,
-0.0474120341,
0.0089586247,
0.0132757127,
0.0725426152,
-0.0168103594,
-0.024233656,
-0.0195459258,
-0.0083085885,
-0.0117204273,
-0.0285523348,
-0.026581578,
0.0087843472,
0.0181325097,
0.0540062934,
-0.0253880396,
-0.0236950815,
-0.0672440007,
0.0369673558,
-0.0141565902,
0.0334065817,
0.0198335666,
0.0201626346,
0.012898122,
-0.0077776341,
-0.072618857,
0.0083029205,
0.0068370989,
0.0311179403,
-0.0234094132,
0.0156309213,
0.0223783739,
0.0226476155,
-0.0194370188,
-0.0371802375,
0.0093946094,
0.0177426711,
-0.0092770401,
-0.0282080825,
-0.0252489801,
-0.009832073,
-0.0040243454,
-0.0380751602,
-0.0278525334,
-0.0498681776,
-0.0042522643,
0.019347176,
0.0280959122,
-0.0598357469,
0.0208721776,
-0.0019638045,
-0.0374164358,
0.0385043733,
0.0357715338,
-0.0069218357,
0.0284124892,
0.0219449122,
-0.0015103722,
0.0086355386,
-0.0081498623,
0.0423381329,
0.0559014417,
0.0411004238,
-0.0176587999,
0.0195598174,
-0.0042165397,
0.0512134843,
-0.0275920313,
0.0273049083,
-0.0572515614,
0.02325828,
0.0436539315,
0.015468156,
-0.0517309308,
-0.0105542177,
0.052537553,
0.0052119144,
0.0254299548,
0.0233153868,
0.0187030174,
0.0200279672,
0.0049573509,
-0.0206604581,
0.0047339438,
0.0638161302,
-0.001554416,
-0.0429491811,
0.0620510317,
0.0384649709,
-0.0264926385,
-0.0167744253,
0.0110968864,
-0.015979046,
-0.0285869837,
0.0592521913,
0.0050299959,
-0.0541575365,
-0.0362802893,
0.0566403419,
0.0097828731,
-0.0158584509,
-0.0216023307,
-0.0140291518,
0.0381767899,
0.0960478559,
0.0088608218,
-0.0034874715,
0.0311967228,
-0.0276161022,
-0.0031185807,
-0.049188707,
-0.0219454728,
-0.0119335037,
0.028777644,
-0.0161410868,
-0.0495519079,
0.0343931317,
0.0026882109,
0.0335418656,
0.0223066639,
0.0594512373,
0.0089509105,
-0.0054266243,
-0.0215006322,
-0.0175575595,
-0.026716603,
0.0120697431,
0.0403662771,
-0.0103920829,
0.0320455767,
0.0396051407,
0.0108353924,
-0.0266200881,
0.030367896,
-0.0161904935,
-0.0370038003,
-0.0082659507,
-0.0168153457,
0.0050331042,
0.0429989658,
-0.0580101125,
0.019184079,
0.0292236414,
0.0143529065,
-0.0278677568,
-0.0201954506,
0.0149758793,
0.0153150335,
-0.0272717979,
-0.0109944306,
-0.0098951263,
0.0011133302,
-0.0479576625,
0.0778215304,
-0.0157708097,
0.0128014768,
0.0466143116,
0.0358489044,
-0.0193285216,
-0.0292476639,
-0.0258844905,
0.0027069685,
0.0599895306,
0.0272753835,
0.011088497,
-0.0167586152,
-0.0442465506,
-0.0290890224,
-0.0673656985,
0.0195950493,
0.0165727064,
-0.031509649,
-0.0260108653,
0.007778144,
0.0243737623,
0.0004794956,
-0.0527883917,
-0.0233014897,
-0.0123685095,
-0.0227526482,
-0.0043250029,
0.0153647838,
-0.031032715,
-0.0229251739,
-0.006362882,
-0.0076781954,
0.0622812398,
0.0093287574,
-0.0151893059,
-0.0550756939,
0.0087663215,
-0.0662745088,
-0.0351462848,
-0.0286526624,
0.0224106517,
-0.0265365578,
-0.0056469883,
-0.0058890018,
0.0400080308,
0.0108420076,
0.0156649295,
0.051029399,
0.0067623369,
-0.076494284,
-0.0054148212,
0.0053435327,
0.0196696259,
-0.0434743427,
0.0085461652,
-0.0171978492,
-0.0552829206,
0.0040689693,
-0.0037652971,
-0.019560948,
0.0497566089,
0.045812279,
0.0237838738,
-0.0132973408,
-0.050253205,
0.0094763674,
0.0641149953,
0.0048567071,
-0.0072171809,
0.0526426509,
0.0086959144,
0.0269173812,
-0.0064504603,
-0.0740755871,
-0.0735128745,
-0.0352999531,
-0.0327883773,
0.0261122324,
-0.0779632479,
0.0077732503,
-0.0335359238,
0.0093755554,
0.046117276,
-0.0413189791,
0.0469238237,
0.0028568401,
0.0230325367,
0.0501533337,
-0.049821943,
-0.0305446424,
-0.0323012061,
-0.0334624834,
-0.0192454197,
0.0110222418,
-0.0178007651,
-0.047159154,
-0.0302793123,
0.0372732244,
-0.0036536222,
-0.0160725135,
-0.0380364358,
0.0322536379,
0.0372404195,
0.0137530789,
-0.0378749371,
-0.0063567013,
0.0001261107,
0.0482995547,
0.0103050135,
-0.0067239767,
-0.0158565734,
-0.0262971539,
-0.0149506964,
0.0706940144,
-0.0082877353,
-0.0285651758,
0.0193547569,
-0.0139953587,
0.0246340465,
0.021373529,
0.0861438215,
0.0401541032,
-0.0947754979,
-0.0177876428,
-0.0333174206,
0.0070327143,
0.0362752043,
0.0395839475,
-0.0808888003,
0.0124156792,
0.0035463716,
0.0052007982,
0.0339893587,
-0.0346098654,
-0.0153064132,
-0.0923298076,
0.0581304356,
-0.0027316685,
0.0202323683,
-0.0134968041,
-0.0897974223,
-0.003764248,
-0.0426958986,
-0.0184720904,
0.0218153708,
-0.012179764,
-0.0011703832,
0.0015668882,
0.0008201162,
-0.0377808064,
0.030466862,
-0.0359865129,
0.0042059408,
0.0396428965,
0.045867078,
-0.0261599813,
-0.0190829448,
-0.0256009586,
-0.0001575232,
-0.0203589182,
-0.009814187,
0.0392873734,
-0.0508974157,
0.020500984,
-0.046783179,
0.0092619583,
0.0251396038,
0.0200672131,
0.0017002214,
0.0343498811,
-0.0356329679,
0.0324819908,
0.0063351304,
0.0121867172,
0.0107326843,
0.0695348084,
-0.01045023,
-0.046983771,
0.032443881,
-0.044026725,
-0.0137488022,
0.0331816003,
-0.055338271,
0.0513418801,
-0.020573562,
0.0036435064,
-0.0504347831,
0.018762432,
-0.0046020024,
0.0103404205,
-0.0020710046,
0.0901773646,
0.0152618615,
-0.0260063466,
0.0177089479,
0.0139880059,
0.0151722468,
0.0104777087,
-0.0205468815,
0.0330584981,
0.0915766507,
-0.0579165183,
-0.0048594987,
-0.0142594269,
-0.0162097011,
-0.0426770933,
-0.0567613058,
0.0461270548,
0.0234381035,
0.0602521338,
-0.0166764855,
-0.0498981737,
0.066239655,
0.0417634211,
-0.0281502679,
-0.0132183079,
0.0012459393,
0.035770122,
0.0140522635,
0.0374286994,
-0.0785261542,
0.0008313328,
-0.0292616021,
-0.0432364605,
-0.0628437176,
-0.0552552044,
0.0258357357,
0.013504562,
0.0217686053,
0.0020149674,
0.0321135484,
-0.0264665727,
0.038002152,
-0.0384024903,
-0.0353126079,
-0.0302653629,
0.0453916192,
0.0683276653,
-0.0279942472,
-0.0056212055,
-0.0345936604,
0.0049618683,
0.04654897,
-0.0473018661,
0.016618425,
-0.0100081218,
-0.0575763546,
0.0140671991,
0.0026166451,
-0.0108012678,
-0.0040849769,
0.0393283442,
0.0108460207,
-0.0074799364,
-0.0179056488,
0.0092579741,
-0.0149441408,
0.0071126153,
0.0123243378,
-0.1032438949,
-0.094917722,
-0.024180416,
0.0045768456,
0.0551469214,
-0.0221776869,
0.060353294,
-0.0071665575,
-0.0053022476,
-0.013124139,
-0.0044494146,
0.0035256343,
0.0109202815,
0.0329748131,
0.0367788635,
-0.0102828508,
0.0684439465,
0.0763257295,
0.0125984447,
-0.0284311343,
-0.0033873229,
-0.080819279,
-0.0390582457,
-0.0226074848,
-0.0144928228,
0.0563254803,
-0.0271075685,
-0.0241002347,
0.0153900646,
-0.0138423042,
0.0293544475,
-0.0465042107,
-0.0080056544,
-0.044824753,
0.0227397699,
0.0736124143,
0.0246525872,
0.0382972173,
-0.0656137094,
-0.0738386884,
-0.010929171,
-0.0540165529,
-0.0079997983,
-5.587371136e-33,
0.020159876,
-0.0443967506,
0.0013464069,
0.0074760006,
0.0064243842,
0.0057771346,
0.0236663111,
-0.0168019552,
-0.0132971322,
0.0039743539,
-0.0051359781,
0.023959605,
0.0104567129,
-0.0095804138,
0.0179825276,
-0.0104564121,
0.0437319092,
0.0291135684,
0.0083365738,
0.0249690097,
0.0363519602,
0.0493903607,
0.019453641,
-0.1057957336,
0.0394314565,
-0.0019596559,
-0.0270634126,
-0.0188150331,
0.0170044675,
0.0786167756,
0.0293713938,
0.0450145118,
0.0114702201,
-0.0745554492,
0.0418639667,
0.0015890383,
-0.032169465,
0.0152363814,
0.0342206731,
-0.0358841307,
-0.0052956473,
-0.0073328456,
0.0245606303,
0.0080523323,
0.0034584769,
-0.0261200797,
0.0574872643,
-0.0273870118,
-0.0480707102,
-0.0595478229,
0.0372125693,
0.018698426,
-0.0386214405,
0.0247608013,
-0.0054855035,
0.0617846623,
-0.0403973535,
0.0645995587,
-0.0649045035,
0.0321609825,
-0.0649752021,
0.0334155522,
-0.014655876,
-0.0200154055,
-0.064910315,
0.0410254709,
0.0098914178,
-0.0345802493,
0.0184266809,
-0.0522578135,
-0.0385751091,
0.0534298196,
-0.0044418355,
0.0803609639,
-0.0144869918,
-0.0313418545,
-0.1100686342,
0.0422361121,
0.061345946,
-0.012705517,
0.0154857244,
0.0283373222,
0.0058119874,
-0.018282719,
-0.0039220764,
-0.0088502131,
-0.0456906669,
-0.0372309685,
-0.0106733115,
0.0306326095,
0.030751951,
0.0177028887,
0.0128657185,
-0.059702158,
-0.0434770323,
0.0416165181,
-0.0721867308,
-0.0148146776,
0.0323866419,
0.038921129,
-0.0567955673,
0.0065180296,
-0.0366536751,
-0.0267799944,
-0.0133306915,
0.0110057583,
0.0233353693,
-0.0073627345,
-0.0380727984,
0.0061726016,
0.020542372,
-0.0350025967,
-0.0355064794,
0.0482342504,
-0.0177581385,
0.0267098062,
-0.006196151,
0.0564633533,
0.0256130677,
0.0402442999,
0.0114231808,
-0.0779380277,
0.0203275997,
-0.0124882068,
-0.0396104343,
-0.0304143913,
0.0144027499,
0.0113605671,
0.025209127,
-0.0647877231,
-0.0360733941,
-0.0490490384,
2.53e-7,
-0.0028715499,
0.0453907177,
-0.0672460049,
0.0170111675,
0.0115911691,
-0.0088013234,
0.0136261862,
0.0516858771,
0.0349132791,
-0.0052207205,
0.0194110908,
-0.0079013016,
0.0108261025,
0.0260725897,
-0.1118016914,
-0.0494976193,
-0.0994133726,
-0.0384128578,
-0.0686356425,
-0.0277698617,
0.0148545979,
0.0811122805,
0.0229518041,
0.0066003622,
-0.0178291369,
-0.0345732905,
0.0838095099,
-0.0473758876,
-0.0436297953,
-0.0150362616,
0.0936524123,
0.0066505098,
-0.0248678178,
0.0382948183,
-0.0154480273,
0.0415363722,
0.0251657758,
0.0532677285,
-0.0105319023,
-0.0118615655,
0.0105529604,
0.0153904678,
0.0223434623,
-0.0387349054,
0.0564635135,
0.0152441356,
0.0066923364,
0.0005626476,
-0.0717939511,
-0.0300776083,
0.070090577,
-0.0212613326,
-0.0100209517,
0.0051335674,
0.0030101226,
-0.013714348,
0.0196365863,
-0.0203222763,
0.0050081951,
-0.0037908785,
-0.0238837432,
-0.0669327602,
0.0148993824,
-0.0290889014,
0.011226479,
-0.0521989278,
0.0620563552,
1.873711478e-34,
0.0211112108,
0.0632642433,
-0.0015298423,
0.038560383,
0.0288728494,
0.0050244094,
-0.0709790736,
0.0107033132,
0.0451078154,
-0.0256095845,
0.011871974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11736v1 | Interactive Evolution: A Neural-Symbolic Self-Training Framework For Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T16:52:56 | 2024-06-17T16:52:56 | Fangzhi Xu, Qiushi Sun, Kanzhi Cheng, Jun Liu, Yu Qiao, Zhiyong Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the primary driving forces contributing to the superior performance of
Large Language Models (LLMs) is the extensive availability of human-annotated
natural language data, which is used for alignment fine-tuning. This inspired
researchers to investigate self-training methods to mitigate the extensive
reliance on human annotations. However, the current success of self-training
has been primarily observed in natural language scenarios, rather than in the
increasingly important neural-symbolic scenarios. To this end, we propose an
environment-guided neural-symbolic self-training framework named ENVISIONS. It
aims to overcome two main challenges: (1) the scarcity of symbolic data, and
(2) the limited proficiency of LLMs in processing symbolic language. Extensive
evaluations conducted on three distinct domains demonstrate the effectiveness
of our approach. Additionally, we have conducted a comprehensive analysis to
uncover the factors contributing to ENVISIONS's success, thereby offering
valuable insights for future research in this area. Code will be available at
\url{https://github.com/xufangzhi/ENVISIONS}. | [
0.0158356,
0.0640264228,
-0.0390543677,
0.045561213,
-0.0364110917,
0.0291953739,
-0.0031635154,
-0.0192101337,
0.012825083,
-0.0014965819,
-0.0315390639,
0.0218263194,
-0.0252982061,
0.0344700254,
0.0578454174,
-0.0065272939,
0.0752717331,
-0.011594384,
-0.0103329131,
-0.0060436409,
-0.0139852818,
-0.0005981703,
0.0131052509,
0.0077095511,
-0.0265273806,
-0.0385446697,
-0.0263027865,
0.0168267582,
0.0126881292,
-0.0285837054,
-0.0067592533,
0.0432324335,
0.0476210862,
0.0922610983,
0.0000018873,
-0.0637371913,
0.00000714,
-0.013478525,
-0.032740932,
0.0161972586,
0.0384387933,
-0.0161428321,
-0.0187889133,
-0.0142741762,
-0.0469939299,
-0.0137771824,
0.0538590848,
-0.0112668658,
0.0785818398,
0.0653018579,
0.0018738011,
-0.0271017849,
0.0040847203,
-0.0210940614,
-0.0109391296,
0.0230904873,
0.0242696702,
-0.0132313464,
-0.0288502742,
-0.0249013435,
-0.0084417667,
0.0532911718,
0.040890146,
-0.0001430375,
0.0007439081,
0.0331856906,
-0.0427851751,
-0.0216036774,
-0.028951278,
0.0626373291,
-0.0369779915,
-0.0433860198,
-0.0167213939,
-0.018005101,
0.0355589539,
-0.0218803901,
-0.0235825349,
0.0022230691,
0.003497459,
0.0469189361,
0.0434247851,
-0.0030081416,
0.0432957262,
0.0043160827,
-0.0215958245,
0.0628463402,
0.0158586912,
-0.0208325218,
-0.0180303659,
-0.0292267185,
-0.0413344763,
-0.0338564627,
0.0160951819,
0.0303933155,
0.0155263692,
0.0268247202,
-0.0830032602,
-0.0302492622,
0.0133179091,
-0.0649956986,
0.0504291654,
0.049256511,
0.0120192496,
0.0490925424,
-0.0252860337,
0.0632601976,
-0.0101997042,
0.0255473666,
-0.0345552787,
0.0135508925,
-0.0395041779,
-0.0059747784,
-0.0525708273,
0.0223161168,
-0.0207243171,
-0.0141048813,
-0.0184234623,
0.0316900574,
0.0253739879,
0.0048964079,
-0.0079098362,
-0.0035218436,
-0.046506308,
0.0046052029,
-0.0270312913,
-0.0034697989,
-0.0285068359,
-0.033826869,
-0.0025464541,
-0.0236896202,
-0.0067799171,
-0.0024534864,
-0.0090950588,
-0.0217198133,
-0.0136077041,
0.1118442789,
0.0129422592,
-0.0381558351,
-0.0200248621,
0.0191452503,
-0.0259239133,
-0.0370946564,
0.0192156527,
-0.0408714525,
0.0471752845,
-0.0229707099,
-0.0248399954,
-0.0511855222,
0.0227952972,
-0.0188185312,
0.0350861214,
0.0608767904,
-0.0540833138,
0.0158150233,
0.0463480763,
-0.0294894204,
0.0317299627,
0.0696173161,
0.068398416,
-0.0063316151,
0.003979465,
0.0038386933,
-0.0251665674,
0.0771798044,
0.0014024136,
0.0080275601,
-0.0309676882,
0.002821418,
0.0075055934,
0.1040746793,
0.023018701,
0.04249366,
-0.0234414265,
-0.0505598299,
0.0490026399,
0.0534832515,
0.0654670298,
0.0278951451,
0.0381456688,
0.0049073389,
0.0197762251,
-0.0232345387,
-0.0672441795,
0.0410234518,
-0.0034508442,
0.0171067696,
-0.0278707687,
0.0467243269,
-0.0063349418,
-0.0475518219,
-0.0221003126,
0.0070183948,
0.002600091,
-0.025575215,
0.0415221788,
0.0195165984,
-0.0136777759,
0.016446067,
0.0602454282,
-0.0321046822,
0.012080159,
-0.0242576245,
0.0513264947,
0.0597853065,
0.0524967164,
-0.0333983265,
-0.0552842878,
-0.001188282,
-0.0252027977,
0.0768492445,
0.0359832793,
-0.0180182829,
-0.0066117039,
-0.0275069028,
-0.0145088593,
-0.0315876454,
-0.0007651931,
0.0286048166,
0.0092326682,
-0.0240251608,
0.0017853446,
-0.0150089068,
-0.0388854854,
0.0846407041,
-0.0545130931,
-0.0307111088,
-0.0004607113,
0.0037051195,
0.0456702039,
0.0061099627,
-0.0372929201,
0.006125852,
0.0197626799,
-0.0402028188,
-0.0093981838,
0.0215046909,
-0.0592051446,
-0.0606205389,
0.0846710354,
0.0039168973,
-0.0309520867,
0.0107605653,
-0.0408783592,
-0.0456481092,
0.0334167853,
-0.065044038,
0.035793703,
-0.0448824018,
0.0475003272,
-0.0154927485,
0.001615635,
-0.0396085829,
0.0512362383,
0.0189698618,
-0.0224123504,
0.0064819269,
0.0246849731,
0.020081725,
-0.0405762643,
-0.0131329903,
-0.0149717415,
-0.0029729658,
0.0024169856,
-0.0126521606,
0.0146902651,
-0.0518536717,
-0.0111498972,
-0.0796130151,
0.0231232177,
-0.0155268917,
0.0350462981,
0.0531042852,
-0.0160374418,
-0.0298387222,
-0.0214255024,
-0.0262093078,
0.0268434789,
-0.0288652442,
-0.0116855409,
0.0685111359,
-0.0110117113,
-0.0197475515,
-0.0585820302,
-0.0199663192,
-0.0651116446,
0.027991144,
0.0344785117,
-0.015233011,
-0.0760068297,
-0.0228908546,
-0.0460609943,
0.0472474508,
-0.0007979106,
-0.0404238105,
-0.006175804,
-0.0023890645,
0.0286635663,
0.0450587645,
0.0078716753,
-0.0195058789,
0.0563460439,
0.010524055,
-0.0682343915,
0.0077971527,
-0.0196707901,
0.0394963175,
-0.0178836156,
0.0013752914,
0.0008208337,
0.0839662701,
-0.020355748,
-0.015881585,
-0.0531291366,
0.0549905114,
-0.0012208011,
-0.0280068293,
-0.0165500976,
-0.0003023508,
-0.0328687951,
0.003065458,
-0.0602496229,
-0.0519601218,
0.1008269042,
-0.0261513945,
-0.0069342107,
-0.0329323225,
-0.0110830823,
-0.0508129001,
0.0767806694,
0.0253561642,
0.0166720822,
0.0504304543,
-0.0293698702,
-0.0559817888,
0.0098808613,
-0.0022234267,
-0.0061884169,
0.0277407002,
-0.053436555,
0.0171794128,
0.0054201651,
-0.0634535253,
-0.0196603108,
-0.0484860614,
-0.0090980232,
-0.0009553734,
-0.0113940509,
-0.0191192925,
0.0166509729,
0.0053351955,
-0.0281431098,
0.0699231029,
-0.0091505572,
-0.0088540688,
-0.0428603068,
0.0065649007,
0.0487785004,
0.0452831648,
0.0392998345,
-0.0185245145,
0.022406118,
0.0182983801,
0.0173668079,
-0.0016821971,
-0.0578089394,
0.0130689219,
0.0011268446,
-0.0710139349,
-0.0047436492,
-0.0037225662,
0.0143490294,
-0.077564612,
-0.0114442008,
0.0943860263,
0.0333044715,
-0.009664109,
0.027009042,
-0.0276510883,
0.0258180331,
0.0610730648,
0.0525972247,
-0.0843677744,
-0.031282898,
0.0042613777,
-0.0053275544,
0.0238195639,
-0.0372550935,
0.0083691273,
-0.0950251222,
0.0125001892,
0.0422570631,
-0.055494424,
0.027768258,
-0.01307071,
-0.0005014582,
-0.0341974571,
0.0080740247,
0.045659177,
-0.0087623261,
-0.0129861301,
0.0024672777,
-0.0136689413,
-0.0412211306,
0.0099526728,
-0.0921443552,
0.0581502616,
0.0565748028,
0.0326425061,
0.007693009,
-0.0168872923,
0.067139864,
-0.0086362232,
0.0245026723,
-0.0095343478,
0.0464259125,
-0.0039992169,
-0.0286943931,
-0.0039395923,
0.0449930131,
-0.0428920835,
0.0098283952,
0.0000630971,
0.0692933574,
0.0081145158,
0.0200473592,
-0.0250586569,
-0.035610795,
-0.0134809241,
0.0310873669,
0.0375631377,
-0.0507339425,
-0.0404054075,
-0.0166772269,
0.014474025,
-0.0051391618,
-0.0477008447,
0.0019856782,
0.004176083,
-0.0353635736,
-0.0966552123,
-0.0386723764,
0.034258347,
0.0567297712,
0.025684949,
-0.0163792931,
0.001413269,
-0.0300171152,
-0.0477288552,
0.0449978858,
-0.0526573695,
-0.0053311144,
0.0085503235,
0.0039989697,
0.0201440789,
-0.0221068207,
0.0149523821,
-0.0001921,
-0.0818802118,
-0.0958599821,
-0.0050787698,
0.0807562694,
0.0197002869,
0.0767401978,
-0.0442685001,
-0.0485610701,
0.0500112139,
0.0466982722,
0.0062886965,
-0.0154413925,
0.0024155232,
0.0184788145,
0.0001056144,
0.0404897332,
-0.0059157596,
-0.0047585783,
-0.0048821601,
0.0548962913,
-0.0102388393,
0.005601068,
0.038912978,
0.0034667242,
0.0270352568,
-0.0509633981,
-0.0341996513,
-0.0497284643,
-0.0005096293,
-0.0371717401,
-0.0398057811,
-0.0280332621,
0.0082156695,
0.002354956,
0.0166717302,
0.0045847474,
-0.0163068753,
0.0155390631,
0.0150595205,
-0.028260991,
-0.0115629137,
0.0323384479,
0.0149120502,
0.0163917243,
0.0226786658,
0.0103486041,
0.0432166234,
-0.0148851713,
0.0237699691,
-0.0376797952,
0.0422659516,
0.0198159907,
0.013724139,
-0.0409783125,
0.0210194755,
-0.010991211,
-0.0058795684,
-0.0395579301,
0.0296630971,
0.0835140646,
-0.0015647684,
0.0458223112,
-0.0044234158,
-0.0312402919,
-0.000924214,
0.0075619887,
-0.0560302176,
-0.0210601818,
0.0333697051,
0.0192621332,
-0.0377614982,
-0.0104894144,
0.0336666778,
-0.0108594457,
0.059770111,
0.0112016117,
0.0407340974,
-0.0442739166,
-0.01027436,
-0.0061218138,
-0.0272835083,
-0.0410351083,
-0.0294456966,
-0.0343531929,
-0.0792345777,
0.0154078631,
0.0908154547,
-0.0225041509,
0.0072376882,
0.0321662016,
0.0454376228,
-0.0332153849,
-0.0276482832,
-0.0135630565,
-0.0033000803,
-0.0062024756,
-0.0458720289,
-0.0214027725,
-5.774591019e-33,
-0.0341515057,
0.0151165277,
0.0377893634,
-0.0066649029,
-0.0352227837,
-0.0253678113,
-0.0399550237,
0.0147115104,
-0.000503942,
-0.0040798192,
-0.0105125336,
-0.0008540267,
0.0006564014,
-0.0176303629,
0.0196507424,
-0.0165313147,
0.0326777846,
-0.0461689495,
-0.0250437055,
-0.0149279172,
0.005036925,
0.0300385561,
0.0399518684,
-0.0508333705,
-0.0257470049,
0.0443530567,
0.0174083617,
0.043740876,
-0.0383621901,
0.0481917374,
-0.0131794279,
-0.0024324281,
0.0035226066,
0.0167614873,
-0.0292957593,
-0.0145718204,
-0.0717897862,
-0.0336462073,
-0.0083791735,
-0.002627373,
-0.0465855561,
-0.0483998172,
0.0834595039,
-0.0118896682,
-0.02852582,
0.0361888967,
0.0355390199,
-0.0180011708,
-0.0147780972,
-0.0426233783,
-0.0646104962,
0.0246872939,
-0.0161176194,
0.0031221951,
0.0227595419,
0.0036564413,
0.0205495395,
-0.0076055932,
-0.0507224202,
-0.0026199862,
0.0187597275,
0.0201536361,
0.0706388131,
-0.0045893532,
0.0496118888,
0.0433692709,
0.0565662384,
-0.0246877261,
-0.0035860823,
0.0188228954,
0.0687689781,
0.0196598545,
0.05903624,
0.0306248385,
0.0285936091,
0.0146009345,
-0.0460108556,
-0.0061562797,
0.0272627771,
0.0112573653,
-0.0083361184,
0.0597657375,
-0.0162637029,
0.0125019867,
-0.0477507748,
-0.048036851,
-0.0297486205,
-0.0387995578,
0.0072066123,
-0.0085221594,
-0.0330486186,
-0.0040752389,
0.0033185552,
-0.0470145084,
-0.0290256701,
-0.0093417717,
-0.0117692165,
0.0305117164,
0.0032950644,
0.0569589399,
-0.0329893343,
-0.035651844,
-0.0077248998,
0.0289062709,
0.0597389564,
-0.0072354572,
0.0350612439,
0.0447222628,
-0.0488129333,
0.0149458274,
-0.0323611945,
-0.0085013323,
0.0177513063,
-0.0256465804,
0.0457294546,
0.0001237778,
0.0109150261,
0.0155538768,
0.0649964139,
-0.0114690531,
-0.0416064113,
0.050362017,
0.0043512699,
0.0270537417,
0.0139177684,
0.0026527969,
-0.0235933363,
0.0283114854,
0.0268659256,
-0.0676501095,
-0.0011299824,
0.0289573632,
2.512e-7,
0.038659744,
0.0622433051,
0.0606184117,
-0.0126125412,
0.0638138205,
0.0274146944,
-0.0235582869,
0.0108603565,
0.0144570814,
-0.0101585407,
0.0109563302,
0.0267610997,
0.0366078131,
0.009553575,
-0.095295094,
0.0233923215,
-0.0777722523,
0.0344908088,
-0.0737094954,
0.0030795292,
0.0051234649,
0.1247843578,
0.0432662703,
-0.0061417636,
-0.0202703439,
-0.0381145068,
0.0535222962,
-0.024061013,
0.0008541187,
0.0326358825,
-0.0392930135,
0.0109270727,
-0.0271258783,
-0.0178947411,
0.0034426057,
0.0694109425,
-0.0136814788,
0.0536088645,
0.0062923897,
0.012360313,
0.0142430868,
0.0109026153,
-0.0001317721,
-0.0345350094,
0.0742311031,
-0.115584597,
-0.0394528918,
-0.0265000034,
-0.0176365152,
0.0042798114,
0.0075923651,
-0.025857104,
-0.0085681248,
0.0550345406,
0.0272512976,
-0.0203208979,
-0.0331871398,
-0.0708396286,
-0.0455744192,
0.0044768737,
-0.0638315901,
0.0145429457,
-0.0525124371,
0.0280647874,
0.0177075081,
-0.0503217056,
-0.0075550335,
2.154476122e-34,
0.0011465399,
-0.0220669247,
0.0305666309,
0.0276681483,
0.029088717,
-0.0184373576,
-0.0161864664,
0.0104979314,
0.0265337024,
-0.055317156,
-0.0242076963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11727v2 | 1000 African Voices: Advancing inclusive multi-speaker multi-accent speech synthesis | 2024-06-17T16:46:10 | 2024-06-27T08:52:54 | Sewade Ogun, Abraham T. Owodunni, Tobi Olatunji, Eniola Alese, Babatunde Oladimeji, Tejumade Afonja, Kayode Olaleye, Naome A. Etori, Tosin Adewumi | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Recent advances in speech synthesis have enabled many useful applications
like audio directions in Google Maps, screen readers, and automated content
generation on platforms like TikTok. However, these systems are mostly
dominated by voices sourced from data-rich geographies with personas
representative of their source data. Although 3000 of the world's languages are
domiciled in Africa, African voices and personas are under-represented in these
systems. As speech synthesis becomes increasingly democratized, it is desirable
to increase the representation of African English accents. We present Afro-TTS,
the first pan-African accented English speech synthesis system able to generate
speech in 86 African accents, with 1000 personas representing the rich
phonological diversity across the continent for downstream application in
Education, Public Health, and Automated Content Creation. Speaker interpolation
retains naturalness and accentedness, enabling the creation of new voices. | [
0.0204446688,
0.0526483916,
-0.0102817332,
-0.0352354869,
0.0334349647,
-0.036328651,
0.0544158556,
-0.0309982877,
-0.039710287,
0.0305693783,
-0.0343905017,
-0.0926537812,
0.0528578497,
0.0081666028,
0.0382563807,
-0.1187246144,
-0.0148417363,
-0.0309992004,
-0.0413739197,
-0.0319360904,
0.0032647119,
0.0622964837,
-0.0158397797,
0.0610147715,
-0.0204171836,
0.0268253908,
-0.0315830484,
-0.0084247841,
0.0043572392,
0.053005442,
-0.0281199962,
-0.0025901813,
-0.0162503067,
0.0112746786,
0.0000019619,
-0.0267842524,
-0.0241872184,
0.0015932558,
-0.0530928075,
0.0381833203,
0.0526709259,
0.0695491806,
-0.0582079142,
0.0422724672,
-0.0301704574,
0.0082419105,
0.0689907372,
-0.0428168774,
0.0620920733,
0.0300978869,
-0.0056419927,
-0.0282652806,
-0.0133097703,
-0.0062395292,
-0.009316003,
0.0129901515,
-0.0242649596,
-0.0625036135,
0.0240129698,
-0.0103833973,
0.0179288518,
0.0194354039,
0.0071910839,
-0.0053049857,
-0.007323477,
-0.0287237819,
-0.0153726125,
-0.0845539272,
-0.0154717239,
0.0507412143,
0.0008652562,
0.0154809095,
0.0139578711,
0.0546903238,
-0.0023625616,
-0.0450104252,
-0.0207733363,
0.0094344914,
-0.0121210525,
0.0032654228,
-0.0304017626,
0.0521409251,
0.0156375989,
-0.0315272734,
-0.0382409729,
0.0068302481,
0.0205276199,
-0.0108409422,
-0.0076755038,
0.0189069677,
-0.0040288866,
0.0107183689,
0.0498540439,
0.0097307302,
-0.015303188,
-0.0129868919,
0.0159943644,
-0.0240526386,
-0.0192275308,
0.023260247,
0.0642175004,
0.0207514241,
-0.0158954747,
-0.0578648522,
0.0187768806,
-0.0039108996,
-0.0163468141,
-0.0278968439,
-0.0123325083,
-0.0231603868,
0.0126794251,
-0.0380714312,
-0.0168189704,
-0.0121979313,
-0.0607077032,
0.0445087738,
-0.0375216119,
0.0018548837,
-0.0473710485,
0.0076185944,
0.0283657983,
0.0207689311,
-0.0279980153,
-0.0668384284,
0.0454394035,
0.0101592559,
-0.0131390207,
0.0526295751,
-0.0301177651,
-0.0991871133,
0.0306838788,
-0.0343528464,
0.0228689592,
0.0667012855,
0.0114161698,
0.0118171219,
0.0049114865,
0.0069948183,
-0.0447175801,
-0.0610792004,
-0.0236080736,
0.0029842688,
-0.0441477671,
-0.0574418418,
-0.0151886353,
-0.0241326205,
0.0068790205,
-0.0162646715,
-0.0191446878,
0.0077606654,
0.0636923462,
-0.0053161113,
-0.0100170802,
0.0457296409,
0.0771687105,
0.0034495865,
0.029918531,
0.0242771674,
0.0431002267,
-0.0276249591,
-0.0137487287,
-0.0092765559,
-0.0247489065,
0.0622429401,
0.0493831784,
0.0092974221,
-0.0102155171,
-0.0509459376,
-0.0167021751,
0.0270275082,
0.0399800315,
0.047605671,
-0.0096197464,
-0.0126958154,
0.0450652689,
0.0175607167,
0.0210403111,
0.0141164111,
0.0938872546,
-0.0061519328,
0.0056040413,
-0.0294411201,
0.0108925011,
-0.011617207,
0.0290159527,
-0.0140535589,
0.0542443991,
0.1076362804,
-0.0437716171,
0.0082726628,
0.0523417741,
-0.0165255908,
-0.0032437935,
-0.0170309842,
-0.0137548726,
0.0307746809,
-0.0172932856,
0.0165153015,
0.0052325828,
-0.0975242108,
0.0307796877,
-0.0287813991,
-0.0165875759,
0.0478805602,
-0.0369652361,
0.0422273427,
0.0405863039,
-0.0545298904,
-0.0036624265,
0.0393549465,
-0.0051120715,
-0.0374693125,
0.0513896421,
-0.0728985667,
0.0265590437,
0.0316930823,
-0.0237804055,
0.0420246385,
-0.0148018729,
0.0788269937,
0.0129470369,
-0.0242898837,
0.038581308,
-0.0335917138,
-0.0641678721,
0.0123111075,
0.0271420144,
0.0156781115,
0.0363635495,
0.0721398517,
-0.0327383913,
0.0177898798,
-0.0300203394,
-0.0575844385,
0.0004505466,
0.0526861586,
-0.0587901212,
0.0121567026,
0.0315215364,
-0.0645747185,
0.0265757721,
0.0045055845,
0.0617820732,
-0.0809904113,
0.0946038887,
0.0008192883,
0.0292525124,
-0.0048041306,
0.0153212734,
0.0278791357,
0.0238471832,
0.0297595281,
-0.0420778133,
0.0497024395,
-0.032223057,
0.0489269271,
0.0666621551,
-0.0110823186,
-0.0178904869,
0.032829091,
0.0251807272,
-0.0097142728,
0.0118104937,
-0.0436137319,
-0.030077314,
-0.0259068869,
-0.0211433284,
-0.0796416849,
0.01129709,
0.0019491112,
-0.0082078958,
-0.0296605956,
0.0680325776,
-0.0041707722,
0.0028454266,
-0.0483772531,
-0.0654845461,
0.0135182422,
-0.0458076745,
-0.0502301715,
-0.0506128147,
-0.0205608271,
-0.0183891468,
0.0030703822,
0.0342817232,
0.011558488,
-0.0148063544,
0.0144896647,
-0.0062798695,
-0.0941459164,
0.0275393371,
0.0130171767,
0.0304739121,
-0.0342030525,
-0.016265491,
0.0055269385,
0.0349814892,
-0.0105068432,
-0.0025084638,
-0.0347661041,
-0.0020659848,
-0.0439670794,
-0.0225728676,
-0.0065610302,
0.0190153886,
0.0590524487,
-0.0074619702,
-0.0257802587,
-0.0010479447,
0.0158037655,
0.0714087263,
0.0171423629,
-0.065519169,
0.0248604827,
0.0040573678,
-0.0409286581,
0.0422286652,
-0.0262632705,
-0.0230796877,
-0.0136315422,
-0.0514992438,
-0.0071845511,
0.0320510752,
-0.0265285335,
-0.0560969971,
-0.0001035823,
0.0062836036,
-0.0119955018,
-0.0134647926,
-0.0463167168,
0.0360205546,
-0.0047382507,
0.0004100967,
0.0073627024,
0.0745159239,
0.0167553201,
-0.0589710064,
0.0074156364,
-0.0190829895,
-0.033099208,
-0.0130597278,
-0.0449649878,
0.026392024,
-0.0067586568,
-0.0482446775,
0.0056848563,
0.0584336184,
-0.028308006,
0.0395797193,
0.0345867872,
0.0553090088,
0.0470095575,
0.0187426358,
0.0209944025,
0.005092816,
-0.0325802825,
-0.0156492423,
0.047291249,
-0.0290022399,
-0.0411491655,
0.0452157818,
-0.0274277441,
0.0257712826,
0.0247473177,
-0.0201587901,
0.0130982241,
0.0386014506,
0.0097480668,
-0.036149215,
0.0057439404,
0.0553282574,
0.0159650743,
0.0427769721,
0.0663206056,
-0.0251780841,
0.00987266,
0.0260686018,
-0.0235389024,
0.0596518628,
-0.0132560246,
-0.0229524169,
-0.0692555755,
-0.0127286995,
0.0465924628,
0.0326801613,
-0.0497693941,
0.0217176508,
-0.0267062709,
-0.0870615914,
0.0555566549,
0.060742043,
0.0103845699,
-0.0102308448,
-0.0045967069,
-0.051864218,
0.0283933654,
-0.013503531,
0.0320546627,
0.019279018,
-0.0256475918,
0.0630277991,
-0.0879493356,
-0.0492939539,
-0.0100248568,
-0.0471409224,
0.0977870673,
0.038578961,
0.004453165,
0.0156669188,
-0.0554194376,
-0.077215828,
-0.0303021148,
0.0020951815,
-0.0177151114,
-0.0068656844,
0.070751965,
-0.0275916625,
0.0055174152,
0.0626725033,
-0.0319612883,
0.0205379706,
-0.0045917202,
0.0241216645,
-0.0121448459,
0.0205613412,
-0.024705166,
0.0379654393,
0.0155459419,
0.029149821,
0.0262082126,
-0.0880561396,
0.0010927803,
-0.018596407,
0.0223581214,
-0.077893436,
-0.0301090404,
0.0651953891,
0.0204628166,
-0.0483083874,
-0.0319834761,
-0.0083307009,
-0.0074701449,
0.0391061492,
0.0269019045,
-0.0468787812,
0.0106842639,
-0.0152200637,
0.0008678178,
-0.0416526347,
-0.0074480823,
0.0684077144,
-0.0122832479,
-0.0097593553,
0.0071317079,
-0.0428831764,
0.0309016313,
0.0110868048,
-0.0222160872,
-0.065465726,
0.070824638,
0.0160913803,
0.0242303871,
0.0389138348,
0.0244917925,
-0.0547550172,
0.0654973015,
-0.0172330011,
0.0539772399,
0.0396785587,
0.0710178316,
0.0141949989,
0.0012776776,
0.0190489739,
0.0025688212,
0.0512720197,
-0.0192785971,
-0.0182637405,
-0.0118476218,
-0.0516204312,
-0.0268215276,
-0.0150320483,
-0.0241471324,
-0.0350425169,
0.0291406401,
-0.0305766948,
0.0056258924,
-0.0097756693,
0.0438268334,
-0.0414959751,
-0.0187438093,
0.0524418205,
0.0293722227,
0.0079509048,
-0.0143805491,
-0.0045390604,
-0.0219586045,
0.0240597408,
0.0490082428,
0.0125026554,
0.0122771347,
0.0322817378,
0.0234151054,
-0.029180862,
0.0434880406,
-0.0106211836,
0.0156308785,
-0.0106329601,
-0.0282090213,
-0.0035072428,
-0.0096802283,
-0.0228182916,
0.0170197524,
-0.0025875776,
0.0321202949,
-0.0317652822,
0.0006502976,
0.0626956001,
0.0538099259,
0.0988679901,
0.0128353341,
0.031052608,
0.0156272594,
-0.0063195415,
-0.0465600565,
-0.0118524414,
-0.0245752484,
-0.0368655361,
-0.0157096609,
0.0171598196,
0.0231402125,
-0.0479367487,
0.0248533096,
-0.0233173966,
0.0294934511,
-0.003706539,
-0.0237287488,
-0.0358988494,
-0.0390978083,
-0.0231233872,
-0.0039232736,
-0.0222474299,
-0.0189762879,
0.0666343197,
0.0001648419,
-0.0047561708,
-0.0295206476,
0.0277455002,
-0.0474159345,
-0.0389114507,
0.0242394693,
0.001197145,
-0.0507730134,
-0.0416750088,
-0.0242356099,
0.0582927465,
-6.03826432e-33,
-0.0049992362,
0.0577107556,
-0.013775602,
0.0040647313,
-0.0697897375,
-0.0331626385,
-0.0251736958,
0.0061630309,
-0.0261882804,
-0.0088825915,
-0.0336143188,
-0.0257475488,
0.012278609,
0.047823064,
0.0076926318,
0.053754624,
0.0627915859,
0.0094730062,
0.0041065412,
0.0377719551,
0.0275721382,
0.0418276638,
-0.0022022813,
-0.0121355318,
-0.0144212479,
-0.0162837971,
-0.0470138788,
-0.0301906355,
-0.0014541977,
0.0291514099,
0.0075022979,
0.0590759665,
-0.024168577,
-0.0161258616,
-0.0337816253,
0.0091035208,
-0.0342130065,
-0.0237941016,
-0.019557938,
0.0433685519,
-0.0328316391,
-0.0417153537,
0.0324663445,
0.0028273666,
-0.0573528036,
0.0307558738,
-0.0180056486,
-0.0521928743,
0.0046676588,
-0.0212032348,
-0.0246259067,
0.0251844954,
-0.0016427074,
0.0059641236,
0.0035155113,
0.053639181,
-0.0537173226,
-0.0812134892,
-0.0424286537,
0.0319826044,
0.0362631939,
0.0285568163,
0.0162619054,
0.0509680398,
-0.0135980668,
0.0058182068,
0.056265898,
-0.0969548672,
-0.0117313713,
0.0041776788,
0.0418692306,
-0.0013469466,
0.0282069854,
0.0697667599,
0.0022721877,
-0.0372716971,
0.0114615355,
0.0154112875,
0.0608003363,
-0.0276666284,
-0.0217301548,
0.0264297724,
0.0144631611,
-0.0095278788,
-0.0490484312,
-0.0320422463,
0.0084320856,
-0.0315829143,
0.0386352576,
-0.0347410664,
0.0077444958,
0.0458409749,
0.0412623584,
0.0264074653,
-0.0230863094,
-0.0493133962,
-0.056358356,
0.0219389498,
0.0139318882,
-0.0047508124,
-0.0295477603,
-0.0036072384,
0.0261387825,
0.0416455306,
0.0032227982,
0.008399507,
-0.0349256694,
0.0485268347,
-0.0676504299,
0.0201273095,
0.0020025633,
0.063157104,
0.0110427076,
-0.0114598749,
0.0209691282,
-0.0345435105,
0.0103896949,
0.0078529883,
0.0140251629,
0.0004418464,
0.0507617965,
-0.0199042037,
-0.0041469834,
0.019308053,
-0.0745811015,
0.0214970522,
0.001738425,
-0.0239030458,
0.0115608852,
-0.0359267853,
-0.0193314273,
-0.0246933512,
2.665e-7,
-0.0638774782,
-0.0281085353,
0.0576966852,
-0.0433068052,
0.0323493667,
0.0086494219,
0.0206100941,
0.0050985287,
-0.0015875982,
0.0460950583,
-0.0136366691,
-0.0281915106,
0.1158039644,
0.0305138603,
-0.0882268474,
-0.0046230787,
-0.0620094016,
0.0128226131,
-0.0351919457,
0.0077600502,
-0.0101938853,
0.0795506462,
-0.0118129039,
-0.0648756772,
-0.0138586536,
-0.0019318914,
0.018061148,
-0.0087730745,
0.0142292175,
-0.0255974121,
0.0579175092,
-0.0379501805,
0.0044606146,
-0.0115869706,
-0.0451381952,
0.0386381522,
0.0179099776,
0.0351825617,
-0.0172462463,
0.0268607549,
0.0159410033,
-0.0037531308,
-0.0694940761,
0.0125367735,
0.027281018,
0.0609432943,
-0.0140954955,
-0.0403463095,
-0.0379766636,
-0.0083703892,
-0.0148629723,
-0.0471379235,
0.0099925045,
-0.0012861879,
0.0049564908,
-0.0138618043,
0.0059984955,
-0.0225059856,
-0.0199930165,
0.0127741965,
-0.036945574,
-0.0063696131,
-0.0079699764,
0.0404136032,
-0.0080560045,
-0.0128244096,
0.0296137501,
2.193897657e-34,
-0.0040573585,
-0.0241221022,
0.0719407573,
-0.0005721482,
-0.0252649877,
-0.0211935658,
0.0487008207,
0.0294294301,
0.0202938784,
0.0131948162,
-0.0543783754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11721v1 | Zero-Shot Generalization during Instruction Tuning: Insights from Similarity and Granularity | 2024-06-17T16:40:21 | 2024-06-17T16:40:21 | Bingxiang He, Ning Ding, Cheng Qian, Jia Deng, Ganqu Cui, Lifan Yuan, Huan-ang Gao, Huimin Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Understanding alignment techniques begins with comprehending zero-shot
generalization brought by instruction tuning, but little of the mechanism has
been understood. Existing work has largely been confined to the task level,
without considering that tasks are artificially defined and, to LLMs, merely
consist of tokens and representations. This line of research has been limited
to examining transfer between tasks from a task-pair perspective, with few
studies focusing on understanding zero-shot generalization from the perspective
of the data itself. To bridge this gap, we first demonstrate through multiple
metrics that zero-shot generalization during instruction tuning happens very
early. Next, we investigate the facilitation of zero-shot generalization from
both data similarity and granularity perspectives, confirming that encountering
highly similar and fine-grained training data earlier during instruction
tuning, without the constraints of defined "tasks", enables better
generalization. Finally, we propose a more grounded training data arrangement
method, Test-centric Multi-turn Arrangement, and show its effectiveness in
promoting continual learning and further loss reduction. For the first time, we
show that zero-shot generalization during instruction tuning is a form of
similarity-based generalization between training and test data at the instance
level. We hope our analysis will advance the understanding of zero-shot
generalization during instruction tuning and contribute to the development of
more aligned LLMs. Our code is released at
https://github.com/HBX-hbx/dynamics_of_zero-shot_generalization. | [
-0.0222773794,
-0.0073490315,
-0.0121674323,
0.0500334017,
-0.0005326166,
0.0342178605,
0.0122103821,
0.0102172028,
-0.0804253444,
-0.0002713328,
-0.0486381501,
-0.0098592313,
0.0046452135,
-0.0517908968,
0.0353549942,
-0.0438769087,
0.0872653946,
0.0031310308,
-0.046631556,
-0.0058432682,
0.0132776788,
-0.0277318247,
-0.0201187767,
0.0105557907,
0.0026393102,
-0.0256974269,
-0.044279255,
0.056749668,
0.0321758687,
-0.0161028281,
-0.0100287367,
-0.0035977652,
0.0259890221,
0.0449037477,
0.000001707,
-0.0360231586,
0.0064789746,
0.000105934,
-0.0272564609,
-0.0040287273,
-0.0218093023,
-0.0064657386,
-0.0047731986,
-0.0144907022,
-0.0000662729,
-0.0356177464,
0.0757427365,
0.0050078603,
0.0621563271,
0.1085512787,
0.0010097207,
-0.035743583,
-0.0185973123,
0.0124908993,
0.0834845379,
-0.0242192782,
-0.0134218708,
-0.007577735,
-0.0401362702,
-0.0094169024,
-0.0427289046,
-0.0126614859,
0.0132485814,
0.047297433,
0.0125631606,
0.0432850569,
-0.0644633397,
-0.0100831026,
-0.0089903744,
0.0297345109,
-0.0554466993,
-0.0239439607,
0.0019948424,
-0.0058432515,
0.0134744132,
-0.0195048358,
-0.0500638895,
0.0320705399,
0.0061209584,
0.0358337983,
-0.0255161952,
-0.0267118942,
0.0211925264,
-0.0534198433,
-0.0215360448,
0.0618545152,
0.0005468382,
-0.0411520414,
-0.0214019082,
0.0097218687,
-0.0035273936,
-0.0315240994,
-0.0516273938,
0.0604182668,
-0.0255333669,
0.0122892363,
-0.0746603087,
-0.0008847151,
0.0006519663,
0.0038089245,
0.1018197238,
0.0638582334,
-0.0153464181,
0.0086775534,
-0.0749326423,
0.0743546635,
-0.0258842744,
0.0656255111,
-0.0618674681,
0.0321259163,
-0.094907172,
0.0169837195,
0.0007276231,
0.0516614988,
0.0097169299,
0.0144190658,
-0.0305042248,
0.0647672638,
-0.0070560318,
0.036333207,
-0.0232453477,
-0.008055456,
-0.0703058019,
0.0396455005,
-0.0077037923,
0.035383746,
-0.0540359579,
0.012700526,
-0.0068390393,
-0.0052728062,
-0.0438169464,
0.0133122541,
-0.0224044845,
-0.0256143361,
0.0244347174,
0.069997184,
-0.0287940577,
-0.0037987044,
-0.0286803599,
0.0000056975,
0.0194137227,
-0.0440010168,
0.0402614884,
-0.025695961,
0.0451716334,
0.0186855961,
-0.0083395746,
0.0066184755,
-0.0079301829,
-0.0121837538,
-0.0249826536,
0.0543066561,
0.0311647356,
0.0003131338,
-0.0079889204,
-0.0004988447,
-0.0071698143,
0.0714754462,
0.0212087985,
-0.0129017793,
0.0046479483,
-0.022997912,
-0.0085366815,
0.0198161751,
0.0204076283,
0.0152939875,
0.0144555867,
-0.0114266127,
0.0411725976,
0.047112003,
0.077542834,
-0.0210457724,
-0.0365715548,
-0.015854314,
0.0159674939,
0.0584363714,
0.0427693687,
0.0030884237,
0.044495184,
-0.0243987255,
-0.009635021,
0.0746259764,
-0.0695803314,
0.0419063605,
-0.0163562763,
0.0244662054,
-0.0036292672,
0.0308247805,
-0.0596862584,
-0.022804549,
-0.0172682218,
0.0192751028,
-0.0337355882,
-0.0376329385,
0.0171624608,
-0.0093362248,
-0.0434633307,
0.0513770804,
0.0250340085,
-0.0457945801,
-0.022023391,
-0.0389456972,
-0.0164859369,
0.0109298769,
0.0169024356,
-0.0418621451,
-0.1061962619,
0.018796904,
0.0337649211,
-0.0128300702,
0.0184285883,
-0.011934272,
0.0477558225,
-0.0342962481,
-0.0505649485,
-0.0257973,
-0.0143376598,
0.0113124317,
0.0117541961,
-0.0390047804,
0.0001592282,
-0.024954468,
-0.0294292811,
0.0486592799,
0.00825099,
-0.0425887853,
-0.0080490001,
0.028483171,
-0.0017020758,
-0.015192911,
-0.0324566923,
-0.0174055006,
0.0509144329,
0.0082112802,
0.052988179,
-0.0008691254,
-0.0697971135,
-0.0238467846,
0.0266397633,
-0.0340402238,
-0.0018870196,
-0.0132879429,
-0.0764755309,
-0.0656755865,
0.0081167463,
0.0045080339,
0.0263880286,
0.0444248617,
0.0541142523,
-0.0137972552,
-0.0156770907,
-0.0420839936,
0.0358346924,
0.0085026221,
0.0006753012,
-0.0100655695,
0.0249333028,
0.0117713241,
-0.058478754,
-0.0120009221,
0.0089409333,
0.0063221306,
0.0276695695,
-0.0077732047,
-0.0092442418,
-0.0593742877,
-0.0122973714,
-0.0658859834,
0.0405418649,
0.0104213431,
0.0655041859,
0.0535303541,
-0.0232004598,
-0.0011875919,
-0.0184584837,
-0.0194350127,
0.0336949751,
-0.0262748562,
-0.002980293,
0.0578157566,
0.0108668311,
-0.0317700692,
-0.0151401609,
-0.0078777848,
-0.0244433824,
0.0131441876,
-0.0512291081,
0.0313590989,
-0.0881180987,
0.0469040275,
-0.0250872895,
0.0163511839,
0.0031409818,
-0.0002064979,
0.0328081548,
0.0223134253,
-0.0194130205,
0.1063578874,
-0.0577180944,
0.026092872,
0.0331127271,
0.0212794319,
-0.0545932241,
-0.0023742404,
-0.0184546113,
-0.0666833147,
-0.0406301804,
-0.0109640649,
-0.0147681311,
0.092434749,
-0.0160943884,
0.0039638509,
-0.0553981289,
0.0032807158,
0.0158643909,
0.0007044993,
-0.0005000007,
0.0095536876,
-0.0346798748,
-0.0390542224,
-0.0673340634,
-0.0822212398,
0.0521281511,
0.0103579899,
-0.0080935238,
-0.0191030912,
-0.0024592956,
-0.0163247604,
0.0267058816,
0.0248252917,
0.0068329978,
-0.004108056,
-0.0163712576,
-0.0969986767,
0.019176295,
0.0218185019,
0.0112946127,
0.0715128109,
-0.0298787914,
-0.0278861206,
-0.0525045283,
-0.0163914394,
-0.0294944495,
0.0439085625,
0.056431897,
0.013789692,
-0.0093263518,
-0.025088245,
-0.0409544967,
-0.0425016023,
0.0287414603,
0.0348916613,
-0.025747342,
-0.0191355515,
-0.0606425665,
-0.0060808905,
-0.0008232623,
-0.0170653835,
-0.0378853716,
-0.0418614149,
-0.0063117589,
0.0231214073,
0.0669945106,
-0.0063629295,
-0.0463009961,
0.0051354864,
0.0081922328,
-0.0606962182,
-0.0379208289,
0.0402623527,
0.0933397859,
-0.0392133817,
-0.0276333038,
0.0468492582,
0.0166087709,
-0.0363173373,
0.01012001,
-0.0011426971,
0.0186810791,
0.0629251078,
0.0405519418,
-0.0627453402,
-0.028232703,
-0.0053086197,
0.015120076,
0.0090311114,
0.0052973526,
0.0078260526,
-0.0943872035,
-0.0201486386,
0.0465343632,
-0.0942673907,
-0.0238002315,
0.0239250567,
0.017455237,
-0.0113252476,
0.0470297448,
0.001253386,
-0.0289924387,
0.0161204506,
0.0575952679,
0.0536599904,
-0.021946691,
-0.0123932594,
-0.0551486574,
0.06296774,
0.0659383237,
-0.025911428,
0.0131374765,
-0.0350208208,
0.0323233232,
0.0228038635,
0.0601485297,
0.005028097,
0.0515420847,
-0.0082568238,
0.0062307296,
0.0308056343,
0.0122615583,
0.0167164672,
0.0142013235,
0.0142735047,
0.0686506182,
-0.015363602,
-0.0093583716,
-0.0158693809,
-0.059226308,
-0.0217232257,
0.0230122823,
0.0255966634,
-0.0020161706,
-0.0280369278,
-0.029836487,
-0.0097224452,
-0.0359671861,
-0.003632969,
0.0361095406,
-0.0505166724,
-0.0162800346,
-0.036084976,
-0.0206428282,
0.0196126457,
0.0452019274,
0.0206351522,
-0.0562568419,
-0.0393579602,
-0.0279543456,
-0.0474988185,
0.0282923039,
-0.0034582443,
0.0074291201,
-0.0716461837,
-0.0505247042,
-0.0043001999,
0.0035618395,
0.0111510353,
-0.0432211347,
-0.0793120041,
-0.0638307333,
-0.0034016226,
0.0765731931,
0.0158200394,
0.0941540226,
0.0345859453,
-0.0179571416,
0.0547903255,
0.0383252129,
0.0067511108,
0.0461829379,
0.0540690757,
-0.0236516856,
0.0189425573,
0.0101871742,
-0.0337490588,
0.0167936124,
0.0734935552,
-0.0153918201,
-0.0236391835,
0.0410640612,
0.0103000347,
-0.0099713933,
0.0601757877,
0.0203338508,
0.0127902869,
0.0101798819,
0.0313339904,
0.0102175046,
0.0096653476,
-0.0152700329,
-0.044990994,
0.0019890973,
0.0200197175,
0.0504298173,
0.0228978377,
0.0056409459,
0.0425889567,
-0.0562599748,
0.0083615612,
-0.0028311834,
0.0164338164,
0.0121415481,
0.0552688986,
0.0017826004,
0.0395794772,
0.0111612855,
0.0491572954,
0.0035582061,
0.036605794,
0.058515083,
0.0824240372,
-0.0560843013,
0.0301894136,
-0.0596131831,
-0.0205805283,
-0.0400192738,
-0.0174631458,
0.0485879593,
-0.0331324339,
0.0268416442,
0.0328021049,
0.004795196,
0.0213150717,
0.0063492619,
-0.0424899235,
0.0005513762,
-0.0099552535,
0.0473183095,
0.0297572967,
-0.0240759775,
0.0823628828,
-0.0360635705,
0.0536809005,
-0.0478759259,
0.0271160454,
-0.0272985846,
0.0066663139,
0.0741644204,
0.0002901056,
0.0029545366,
-0.0427220166,
-0.0098399846,
-0.0328670219,
-0.0203307364,
0.0048152274,
0.0340656154,
-0.0279710218,
0.0405016616,
0.0150381215,
-0.0299103297,
-0.0338492654,
0.025699446,
-0.0248124078,
0.0407703333,
-0.0161201954,
-0.027100049,
-5.381841826e-33,
-0.0452304967,
0.0111617884,
0.0275526792,
-0.0005757261,
-0.029512044,
0.009190239,
-0.0066615543,
-0.0103778159,
-0.0261803493,
-0.0119800968,
-0.0029189389,
-0.0099505996,
0.0085797999,
-0.0183702558,
0.0562211126,
-0.0370695218,
0.0238066949,
-0.0301529039,
-0.0537180342,
0.010769669,
0.0243294816,
0.0246096458,
0.0853163376,
-0.0088220602,
0.0050183097,
-0.0034539236,
0.010955302,
0.0141793508,
-0.006570695,
0.0244124215,
0.016203871,
0.0025933108,
0.0102964016,
-0.0442493781,
-0.047036089,
-0.016817119,
-0.0417582393,
-0.0645834878,
-0.0072781001,
0.0147584248,
-0.0524524078,
-0.0469644554,
0.0739497095,
-0.0054669795,
-0.0573544353,
-0.0359593518,
0.0349206626,
-0.0095744021,
-0.0310376193,
-0.0105126807,
-0.0815183222,
-0.0203624349,
-0.0085429586,
-0.0399005152,
0.0244570188,
0.0140981926,
0.0100896657,
0.0085997563,
-0.0537231304,
0.0203932021,
-0.0155939385,
0.0500701033,
0.0819089413,
0.0701626614,
0.0238237083,
0.0264451802,
0.0592482425,
0.0092439661,
-0.0047832276,
0.0031058029,
0.0110507747,
0.0193207413,
-0.0196676385,
-0.0303753428,
0.0800312683,
0.0100894906,
-0.038445726,
0.0191019755,
-0.0121711455,
0.0570249371,
-0.0340029411,
0.050428886,
-0.0465835035,
-0.0166393034,
0.0040671928,
-0.0145774139,
-0.0201589726,
-0.026295362,
0.018220704,
-0.0088524781,
0.002608109,
0.0291821249,
0.0201707631,
-0.0200393908,
0.0226952024,
-0.0222113132,
-0.0324529484,
0.0247519854,
0.0019454552,
-0.0170418303,
-0.0704266876,
-0.1008744091,
0.0130111557,
-0.0077739079,
0.0758390054,
0.0161010325,
0.0759992227,
0.0128419073,
-0.0398829468,
-0.0132242329,
-0.0491906703,
-0.032305751,
0.0137316901,
-0.0087955454,
0.023599172,
0.0278546773,
-0.0041268333,
0.0574904121,
0.0334984325,
-0.0455658026,
-0.0488123447,
-0.0098314928,
-0.0212057848,
0.0262495223,
-0.0008165439,
0.029096676,
-0.0245450754,
-0.0177427977,
0.0031979172,
-0.0620847046,
-0.0413649715,
0.0137747144,
2.479e-7,
0.0226880033,
0.0269970223,
0.0276770461,
0.0174099226,
0.003867456,
0.0277221948,
-0.0333651863,
0.0481820442,
-0.001277686,
-0.0180024002,
0.0274830684,
0.0399377979,
0.0050041694,
0.0000277808,
-0.0349109322,
0.0237172563,
-0.0093022361,
0.0454559997,
-0.0398620255,
0.0465465337,
-0.0060834642,
0.0543313399,
0.0256658327,
0.0064595193,
0.0348196328,
0.0185303502,
0.02328372,
0.0077663129,
0.0410799496,
0.024431793,
-0.0257425699,
-0.0123054311,
-0.036953833,
0.0386591628,
-0.0039103283,
0.0406650081,
-0.0246244334,
0.0194602087,
-0.0418363288,
-0.0102098864,
-0.0145447338,
-0.0200216938,
-0.0038919298,
-0.0164168961,
0.060948886,
-0.0729282349,
0.0000653005,
-0.0052021276,
-0.0017885066,
0.0311917961,
0.0003585025,
0.0308314506,
0.0187905263,
0.0314897262,
0.0217360966,
0.0034226887,
-0.0595206954,
-0.0509971343,
-0.0299227294,
0.0581793077,
-0.0265579876,
-0.0514599346,
-0.0213161036,
-0.0127907842,
0.0063249571,
-0.0438844487,
-0.0553924739,
2.308979013e-34,
-0.0283193327,
-0.0180661995,
0.0858866274,
0.0305132028,
-0.0146564553,
-0.0471711755,
-0.0496472232,
0.0255997423,
0.0244736262,
-0.013826835,
-0.014244468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11717v1 | Refusal in Language Models Is Mediated by a Single Direction | 2024-06-17T16:36:12 | 2024-06-17T16:36:12 | Andy Arditi, Oscar Obeso, Aaquib Syed, Daniel Paleka, Nina Rimsky, Wes Gurnee, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Conversational large language models are fine-tuned for both
instruction-following and safety, resulting in models that obey benign requests
but refuse harmful ones. While this refusal behavior is widespread across chat
models, its underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. In this work, we
show that refusal is mediated by a one-dimensional subspace, across 13 popular
open-source chat models up to 72B parameters in size. Specifically, for each
model, we find a single direction such that erasing this direction from the
model's residual stream activations prevents it from refusing harmful
instructions, while adding this direction elicits refusal on even harmless
instructions. Leveraging this insight, we propose a novel white-box jailbreak
method that surgically disables refusal with minimal effect on other
capabilities. Finally, we mechanistically analyze how adversarial suffixes
suppress propagation of the refusal-mediating direction. Our findings
underscore the brittleness of current safety fine-tuning methods. More broadly,
our work showcases how an understanding of model internals can be leveraged to
develop practical methods for controlling model behavior. | [
0.0541894622,
0.0923715308,
-0.0254071336,
0.0296244025,
-0.0267549325,
0.0149841104,
-0.0011410464,
0.0092010414,
0.050409805,
-0.021281017,
-0.0421381444,
-0.0724660158,
-0.0072081843,
0.0488428436,
0.0301216226,
-0.0159254204,
0.0676938668,
-0.0161900036,
0.0033829717,
-0.0190240964,
0.0227670278,
-0.0160790775,
0.0126256021,
0.0561890341,
0.0322402157,
-0.0028455162,
-0.0239359699,
-0.0000275401,
-0.0529425219,
-0.0099939257,
0.026780542,
0.0769551843,
-0.0087203151,
0.0824660957,
0.0000022406,
-0.0180942304,
-0.0104030631,
-0.0196812581,
-0.0304220729,
0.0292463005,
0.0079186885,
-0.067217201,
-0.0402383618,
0.0083987061,
-0.0298754647,
0.0062485314,
0.0554133318,
0.0690576881,
0.0663316548,
0.0692803934,
0.0083194952,
0.0111773238,
0.0404052995,
-0.0463230386,
0.011390415,
-0.0915144831,
0.0220411196,
-0.0223698299,
-0.0053884778,
0.0256316531,
-0.0472968854,
0.0224024523,
0.0373675264,
-0.0286765043,
-0.0437083133,
-0.0102910465,
-0.0193163883,
-0.0638536662,
-0.0042709075,
0.0817515478,
-0.017130699,
-0.0013202127,
0.0095869247,
0.0034734874,
0.009819014,
-0.0194171816,
-0.0730377212,
0.0087734889,
0.0321624205,
-0.026359614,
-0.0356002524,
-0.0181668475,
0.0515358895,
0.0093655195,
0.0255701579,
0.0047547966,
0.0217588656,
-0.020099612,
-0.0233487692,
-0.0077398475,
-0.0040853033,
-0.0674427748,
0.013361156,
-0.0134039363,
-0.0574297383,
0.004109174,
-0.0561429076,
0.0142660365,
0.0439239107,
-0.0364014469,
0.0360457189,
0.0189235602,
0.0131661892,
0.03937364,
0.0139546711,
-0.0171901435,
-0.0569552891,
0.0437120199,
0.0009202916,
0.0284130722,
-0.0097139291,
-0.0272611976,
-0.0146937575,
-0.0037547322,
-0.0527476147,
-0.0167639237,
-0.019134691,
0.0319333933,
-0.0154285375,
0.0033796444,
-0.0463758893,
0.0165003259,
-0.0110775819,
0.0054158135,
0.0256625395,
-0.0171669219,
-0.0266313087,
-0.0062796376,
0.0230793431,
-0.0705276504,
-0.0453647189,
-0.0021058994,
-0.0440743193,
-0.0284320116,
-0.0241610035,
0.0927171931,
0.0155872228,
-0.0114640873,
-0.0163585581,
-0.0409368351,
-0.0450571552,
-0.0506775677,
0.0289793275,
-0.0161730517,
-0.0008034795,
-0.0048346063,
-0.0379887111,
-0.0770594552,
0.0002623382,
-0.0071759648,
-0.05296994,
0.0746818334,
0.054836113,
-0.0369351842,
-0.0129801724,
0.0736586303,
0.0041338406,
0.0455138832,
0.00414884,
0.029468555,
0.051372584,
-0.0051730336,
0.0560970753,
0.0415777788,
0.0580674931,
0.0343949236,
-0.0614036396,
0.0063977335,
0.0346461199,
0.0103297895,
-0.01687981,
0.055607684,
-0.0381919332,
-0.0751897767,
0.0877426714,
0.0098532559,
-0.0594026037,
0.0450985916,
-0.0069429926,
0.0092375726,
-0.0260813162,
0.0354428925,
-0.0798231289,
0.0267012175,
-0.0683300495,
-0.0226203538,
0.0321655273,
0.0381207876,
-0.0334406048,
-0.0208734982,
0.0323354267,
-0.0033863329,
0.0468548052,
-0.0019995878,
0.0144560626,
0.0276974086,
-0.0274419896,
0.0099767782,
0.0344727896,
-0.0354855508,
-0.0378257744,
-0.0794063359,
0.013723691,
0.0384811983,
0.079380624,
-0.0060247956,
0.0101951389,
-0.0105021587,
0.0242834166,
0.0192302708,
0.057998199,
-0.0059762765,
0.0483607501,
-0.0456674993,
-0.0263579693,
0.0140588935,
0.0350793079,
0.0113716545,
0.0084057469,
-0.0215621665,
-0.0224181637,
0.00771371,
-0.027978573,
0.0209826771,
-0.0192287397,
-0.053466551,
-0.0039965278,
-0.0015912169,
0.0259589758,
-0.0125378203,
-0.000089988,
0.0149038676,
0.0317188054,
0.0076962654,
-0.0170151293,
0.0094007449,
-0.083643958,
-0.0317367651,
0.0189755429,
0.0053311391,
-0.0377700664,
0.0681542307,
-0.0229997486,
-0.0149701973,
0.0832368582,
-0.0219812319,
0.0512363352,
-0.0038097785,
0.0069703199,
-0.0121094026,
0.0410984568,
-0.0223306138,
-0.0003136162,
-0.0272897519,
-0.0009699155,
0.0305941012,
0.0080550425,
-0.0026727109,
-0.0135400919,
-0.0441857576,
0.0440842509,
-0.0201879721,
0.0473586582,
0.012942438,
-0.007364579,
-0.0280518401,
-0.0252058934,
-0.0207074396,
-0.0152641479,
-0.0077065635,
-0.0059624906,
0.0163589641,
0.0144354841,
-0.0097674746,
-0.022157101,
0.014441303,
-0.0100899702,
-0.0038727494,
0.0436208919,
-0.0050181882,
-0.0067370948,
-0.0511796325,
-0.0650533661,
-0.0296329334,
0.0248337593,
0.0439846553,
-0.0271636788,
0.0124234036,
0.0097341137,
-0.0104186134,
-0.016238803,
0.051801376,
-0.0340004824,
-0.0685672536,
0.0263670702,
-0.0012407628,
-0.0166534688,
0.0899654627,
0.0160553269,
0.0762118101,
0.0507523902,
0.0050732982,
-0.0457533486,
0.0018615205,
-0.0033693665,
-0.0260425694,
-0.0173826162,
0.0003945746,
-0.0247597359,
0.0751380548,
0.0196063071,
-0.0035787127,
-0.0547935478,
0.0517350659,
0.0018747927,
-0.0667779297,
-0.0060315751,
-0.0036636565,
-0.047856044,
0.0224090591,
-0.0218372717,
-0.0550535768,
0.0823138803,
-0.0319008939,
-0.0093783801,
0.0039214119,
-0.024867082,
0.0189537294,
0.0831691027,
-0.0101350984,
0.0032986307,
0.0860496163,
-0.0060694688,
-0.0484174713,
-0.02493551,
0.0324676782,
-0.0206379164,
0.0004968882,
-0.0352469794,
-0.0059853131,
0.0083210804,
-0.0274424087,
-0.0375403799,
-0.0817530602,
0.0068200855,
-0.0019719016,
0.047744479,
-0.0268730242,
-0.0270494409,
0.0101821152,
0.0063620559,
0.0145257413,
-0.0336590335,
0.0134303207,
-0.0556219891,
-0.0028497013,
0.0672885329,
-0.0154195307,
0.0325941592,
-0.0423922166,
0.0459889323,
0.0754174739,
-0.0230785441,
0.0417559855,
0.0146374917,
0.0223878901,
0.01769186,
0.0481469408,
-0.0316317528,
0.0122761661,
0.0786239132,
-0.043121621,
-0.0423599407,
0.0538420305,
0.0241613016,
-0.025689587,
0.0320952982,
-0.0005454203,
0.0727065653,
0.0023757496,
0.0093860924,
-0.0458984524,
-0.0383882113,
0.0197313447,
0.0348937176,
-0.0079959445,
-0.0303407442,
-0.0029645269,
-0.0830559954,
0.0115545727,
0.0172555689,
-0.0189186446,
-0.0313804224,
-0.0192247666,
-0.0129066119,
-0.0059448951,
0.0758940727,
-0.0221864805,
0.0164402518,
-0.006206831,
0.0000144811,
0.0226114225,
-0.0282336306,
0.053418912,
-0.04690101,
0.092279613,
0.0701240003,
0.022169387,
-0.001172456,
0.0059970547,
0.0506852642,
0.0079938965,
-0.0169663243,
0.0076458957,
0.0332615338,
0.0177603438,
0.0045566862,
-0.0287831146,
0.034561187,
0.0060173124,
-0.0193108805,
0.0041043297,
0.0451337062,
-0.0109466854,
-0.0290505514,
-0.0187648498,
0.0362511463,
0.0476658717,
0.0792556852,
0.0500440001,
-0.0600226484,
-0.043574594,
-0.0690826848,
-0.0237713177,
-0.0242419634,
-0.0526143163,
-0.0153977247,
0.0234091971,
-0.0247255974,
-0.0576628037,
-0.0251093283,
-0.0014834715,
0.0022059372,
0.0109534422,
-0.0220245272,
-0.0124597754,
-0.0103403116,
0.03498042,
0.0075040194,
-0.0150872786,
0.0205103196,
-0.0503029302,
0.0072847223,
0.0034499306,
-0.0232341327,
-0.007742526,
0.026183201,
-0.0465534516,
-0.1023557633,
0.0153113622,
0.0439120755,
0.0246422347,
0.0272547752,
-0.0325341485,
-0.0589282215,
-0.0062736189,
0.0602530427,
-0.0194228124,
0.0273649972,
0.0942280516,
-0.0211613495,
0.0021005596,
0.0502788238,
-0.0155636948,
0.0040930738,
0.0607356541,
0.0112726837,
-0.0415317081,
-0.0012357507,
0.0189938117,
-0.00150398,
-0.0028712726,
0.0176259149,
-0.0404055566,
-0.0008252033,
0.0153779984,
-0.0012142122,
-0.0079831341,
-0.0496687628,
-0.0009061623,
0.0262228753,
-0.0200678315,
0.0014978348,
-0.0085716052,
0.0197221674,
0.0047155651,
-0.0549804866,
0.0161556154,
0.0130657712,
0.0046348721,
0.0333236828,
0.0141992765,
-0.0144572239,
0.0693244711,
-0.0092516514,
0.0086364755,
-0.0123271998,
0.0534644797,
0.0233998001,
-0.0054733139,
-0.0137275606,
0.0524548441,
-0.0994761363,
-0.0494055189,
0.010167066,
0.0710250363,
0.0100743873,
-0.0143726738,
0.0185171645,
0.0045997244,
-0.0074905502,
-0.0319199115,
0.0367987491,
0.0031612334,
-0.0607675649,
0.0242231134,
0.0144894002,
-0.004146399,
0.0170377064,
0.0532844365,
0.0256368537,
0.0875376612,
0.0200097766,
0.0144590447,
-0.0275130384,
-0.0473280922,
0.0753933489,
0.0061114221,
-0.0323623791,
0.0165020917,
-0.0658223853,
-0.0848203376,
-0.079992868,
0.0176976956,
0.0189797692,
-0.0420935266,
-0.0150892772,
0.0444412418,
0.0232044179,
-0.0100632161,
-0.0324394479,
-0.0142335501,
0.0161770564,
-0.0322908685,
-0.0152573092,
-7.239356163e-33,
-0.0044359984,
-0.0126629006,
-0.0186567102,
-0.0346642956,
0.0124602346,
-0.0321901478,
-0.041549813,
-0.007801028,
-0.0342343412,
-0.0171182659,
-0.0346105732,
0.0338247381,
-0.0032823966,
0.0207576398,
0.0024364076,
-0.0322587229,
0.0403515846,
-0.0144228954,
-0.0373026393,
0.0462626852,
0.0317260921,
-0.0010572851,
-0.008575703,
-0.0471584275,
0.0470380522,
-0.0262746401,
-0.0354309231,
0.0160902906,
-0.049331475,
0.0570635609,
-0.0186764635,
-0.0144037018,
-0.0148724252,
-0.0421731435,
-0.0224583019,
0.0426667444,
-0.0136901038,
0.0008780781,
0.0190816708,
-0.0259048641,
-0.0203928016,
-0.0094382567,
0.0466670655,
-0.0157153104,
-0.0212546028,
-0.0192747526,
-0.0256895721,
0.0061988374,
-0.0183370579,
0.0326870047,
-0.0651983693,
0.0100705698,
-0.0293498971,
-0.084539108,
0.0066847918,
0.0038319791,
0.0143169668,
-0.0164753795,
-0.0204790924,
0.0170503017,
0.0170173738,
0.0295513123,
0.0324652568,
-0.015836766,
-0.0041938936,
0.0420199335,
-0.001372912,
0.0143082682,
-0.0070920666,
-0.0486711599,
0.0255609136,
0.0557315312,
0.039306324,
0.0273437761,
0.0340463221,
-0.055522304,
-0.0370019637,
-0.0152377086,
0.0321961306,
0.030069083,
0.0355450585,
0.0146877533,
-0.0188549496,
-0.0328085013,
-0.0221921913,
-0.059695892,
-0.0270766821,
-0.0161120333,
0.0320422091,
0.0344404392,
-0.0055930489,
-0.0383718163,
0.0230669752,
-0.0704137012,
-0.0267971717,
0.0358022563,
0.0149935381,
-0.0195401087,
0.0168938506,
0.010933131,
-0.0534530543,
-0.0143045941,
0.0286545847,
-0.0412034951,
0.0032031916,
0.013281838,
0.0671391115,
0.0336868539,
-0.0431911275,
-0.0081977723,
-0.0300227478,
0.0623148642,
0.0025530017,
0.0127323261,
0.0341017134,
-0.0184783563,
-0.0178524945,
0.0155092776,
0.0096696103,
0.023498565,
-0.0859366208,
0.0103173573,
-0.0159707349,
0.0269196723,
-0.0343280695,
-0.0248849746,
-0.041681435,
-0.0189774577,
0.0740048215,
-0.0860253647,
-0.0162656419,
-0.0473839007,
3.009e-7,
-0.0291363243,
0.0411788076,
0.0207632724,
0.0213681944,
0.0389389358,
0.0886141062,
-0.0248759761,
0.0697818398,
-0.0184467714,
-0.0103765363,
-0.0021643911,
0.0027225371,
0.0546804965,
0.019024983,
-0.0443056524,
0.0255221296,
-0.0984665677,
-0.0067852288,
-0.012491202,
-0.0313653797,
0.0242367424,
0.118598789,
0.008262842,
-0.0021438687,
0.0289769657,
-0.02260991,
0.0466969758,
-0.0389114395,
0.020643197,
-0.0017797992,
0.0206876602,
-0.0156199168,
0.0281372517,
-0.0097158356,
-0.0140859,
-0.00261764,
-0.0325146616,
0.1012187004,
0.0001582982,
-0.0276881363,
-0.0305582862,
-0.0159010403,
-0.0325898677,
-0.0465428196,
0.0534770563,
-0.0147690224,
-0.0386096165,
-0.0405053198,
0.053636726,
-0.0071700206,
0.0232233703,
0.0068224547,
-0.0173971932,
-0.0049171355,
0.0055758175,
0.0108420216,
0.0399238989,
-0.0598776527,
-0.0124697266,
-0.0327447802,
-0.0245310739,
-0.0504768379,
-0.0172824636,
-0.0054874872,
0.012852638,
-0.0299770962,
-0.0059922333,
2.878896097e-34,
0.0420034565,
-0.0202073343,
0.0388514064,
0.0018908835,
0.0429954641,
0.00218091,
0.0586223416,
0.0113724424,
0.0457866192,
-0.0281797033,
-0.0358530954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11715v1 | Measuring memorization in RLHF for code completion | 2024-06-17T16:33:35 | 2024-06-17T16:33:35 | Aneesh Pappu, Billy Porter, Ilia Shumailov, Jamie Hayes | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) has become the dominant
method to align large models to user preferences. Unlike fine-tuning, for which
there are many studies regarding training data memorization, it is not clear
how memorization is affected by or introduced in the RLHF alignment process.
Understanding this relationship is important as real user data may be collected
and used to align large models; if user data is memorized during RLHF and later
regurgitated, this could raise privacy concerns. In this work, we analyze how
training data memorization can surface and propagate through each phase of
RLHF. We focus our study on code completion models, as code completion is one
of the most popular use cases for large language models. We find that RLHF
significantly decreases the chance that data used for reward modeling and
reinforcement learning is memorized, in comparison to aligning via directly
fine-tuning on this data, but that examples already memorized during the
fine-tuning stage of RLHF, will, in the majority of cases, remain memorized
after RLHF. | [
0.0255298316,
0.0813183412,
-0.0344811492,
-0.005877133,
-0.0181301143,
0.0088915676,
-0.0445573889,
-0.0184538271,
-0.0081994031,
0.0483376011,
-0.0448043942,
0.0111413393,
0.0317340344,
-0.0178700518,
-0.0007784155,
-0.0291944258,
0.0335746668,
-0.050990548,
-0.0262794234,
-0.01954275,
-0.0060762935,
-0.0078870626,
0.0166918524,
0.0405218825,
0.0260274746,
-0.0244701728,
-0.0216375049,
-0.0040003653,
-0.0018643917,
-0.0318236426,
0.0276740044,
0.076014474,
0.0207829084,
0.0252424777,
0.0000021795,
-0.031661883,
-0.0341356397,
-0.0109266462,
-0.0376910158,
0.0316937007,
0.0061418763,
0.034012001,
0.0005239049,
0.0049645239,
-0.0255961046,
0.0096004633,
0.0810077637,
0.0074016927,
0.0350042321,
0.0229074266,
0.0222669113,
0.0109654563,
0.0026631451,
-0.0059104883,
0.0593767948,
-0.027350286,
0.0180058163,
0.0351075083,
0.0082409084,
-0.0360874943,
-0.0266900323,
0.0164184179,
0.0352905095,
0.0449749045,
0.0256163981,
0.032796517,
0.000096595,
-0.0024797306,
0.0048828591,
0.034694735,
-0.0048035663,
-0.046121262,
0.0241966583,
0.0154968444,
-0.0045818994,
0.0045607202,
-0.0317828916,
0.0046108644,
-0.0528585799,
0.0024605878,
-0.0107653495,
-0.0530722253,
0.0307333898,
0.0019949207,
-0.0038011125,
0.0471487753,
-0.0080547193,
-0.0314540192,
-0.0291473027,
-0.0086825117,
0.0456863046,
-0.0739882737,
-0.007092318,
0.0230624322,
-0.0212691408,
0.0319360495,
-0.0447712429,
-0.0085657407,
0.0249357186,
-0.0250170231,
0.0265851915,
0.0433512442,
0.0127524538,
0.0121745924,
-0.0377544984,
0.0663721859,
-0.0320032202,
0.0038437815,
-0.0204051416,
0.0370337293,
-0.0544463992,
-0.00487416,
-0.0262986906,
0.0614590608,
0.0457549542,
0.009897585,
-0.0512395203,
0.0563615225,
-0.0031032292,
0.0885668769,
-0.0448695533,
-0.0095039969,
-0.0550197437,
0.0283339024,
-0.033927694,
-0.0265878867,
-0.0536979139,
-0.0277483892,
0.012358183,
0.0021081439,
0.0044837245,
-0.0544906035,
-0.030918302,
-0.0224492457,
0.008580802,
0.0448950045,
0.0262450408,
0.0312726274,
-0.0297835562,
-0.0567244589,
0.0325626172,
-0.0430197045,
-0.0210154653,
-0.0849056244,
-0.0318565816,
0.0168987792,
-0.0065465719,
-0.047763247,
-0.016931938,
0.025137648,
-0.0298511703,
0.0748305544,
-0.0080755791,
0.0026050748,
0.0047984389,
-0.0010359305,
-0.0271332767,
0.0461515486,
0.0281977076,
0.0630167052,
0.0172632355,
-0.0651726648,
0.0447391011,
0.0074362271,
0.0291708075,
0.0039176219,
-0.0120882904,
0.0122490665,
0.0455275066,
-0.0173752941,
0.0440170616,
0.0012752053,
-0.0321932286,
0.0171060469,
0.0447012521,
0.0600865856,
0.0319523588,
-0.0001032835,
-0.0173890982,
0.0027478463,
0.0147181852,
0.0454796553,
-0.0785272419,
0.0452356897,
-0.0252922457,
0.0334872901,
0.007033031,
0.0088101216,
-0.0226317421,
-0.0511027463,
0.0076174848,
-0.0217387099,
0.027862601,
0.0588847362,
0.0367378071,
0.0156426746,
-0.022950232,
0.010297765,
0.0360251702,
-0.0482612029,
-0.0062961089,
-0.0337767936,
0.0765656829,
0.087858744,
0.0366546735,
-0.0415240638,
0.010898808,
-0.0215374865,
-0.0126472572,
-0.0571349673,
0.0502823628,
-0.0010710876,
0.0084580826,
-0.0266905371,
-0.0635722727,
-0.0124645559,
-0.0089830616,
0.0500872768,
0.0370701514,
-0.044083856,
-0.0230153017,
0.0187327899,
-0.0813066587,
0.0215591583,
-0.0078757703,
-0.0151272612,
-0.0138726421,
0.0217433404,
0.0374304689,
-0.0176138394,
-0.0045904955,
0.0054335403,
0.0117110349,
0.0491318218,
0.0146052614,
-0.0325013362,
-0.0349165723,
0.0154716941,
-0.0000727112,
-0.0155432476,
-0.0006780776,
0.0424886793,
0.0079249348,
-0.0130727114,
0.0226120371,
0.0069158645,
0.0856265649,
0.0197113454,
0.042181693,
-0.0257875808,
-0.041005116,
-0.0427033305,
0.0339591056,
-0.0075167455,
0.0336800627,
-0.0311879274,
0.0063438853,
0.0102995271,
-0.0388017036,
-0.0328409076,
0.0447699428,
-0.0297629889,
0.048936896,
0.042493023,
-0.0083667701,
-0.0542420819,
-0.0055423011,
-0.038243264,
0.0067524388,
-0.0077330223,
0.0168861412,
0.0091204736,
0.0276954379,
-0.0045441417,
-0.0464002937,
-0.0337821767,
-0.0322027542,
-0.0386802442,
0.047354646,
0.020326741,
0.0089358818,
-0.0327838063,
-0.0519037582,
-0.0354355164,
-0.0104132164,
0.0267246645,
-0.0026354664,
0.0239309967,
-0.04945454,
0.0305884052,
-0.0152854631,
0.0129658422,
-0.0141526246,
-0.0502136946,
0.0357877351,
-0.0027787604,
0.0377479941,
0.0959811285,
-0.0170514155,
0.0093893996,
0.0585624203,
0.0261305738,
-0.0831261948,
0.0084087467,
-0.0297570229,
-0.1119454503,
-0.0390239246,
-0.0132611692,
0.0399312116,
0.0655703768,
-0.0115917651,
0.0116136819,
-0.056062609,
0.0019236393,
-0.0048028706,
-0.0257027168,
-0.0260736365,
-0.0081002349,
-0.0331041925,
0.0621109009,
-0.0341467299,
-0.1255235523,
0.0848435089,
-0.0063152905,
0.0122021837,
-0.0091035906,
-0.0204838477,
0.0037811529,
0.032373365,
0.0203693174,
0.0498442315,
0.0164325405,
-0.0586845316,
-0.0361256301,
-0.0487333871,
0.0392624773,
-0.0480858162,
0.0376719497,
-0.0178249106,
-0.028233489,
0.0132693257,
-0.0373641364,
-0.0578054376,
-0.0048495154,
-0.0147252847,
-0.046043992,
0.0170757845,
-0.0381156653,
0.0323766619,
-0.0322775617,
0.0727056786,
0.006939684,
0.0111520458,
-0.0338901356,
-0.0141892498,
-0.0593743548,
0.0214873869,
-0.0625816211,
-0.013896687,
-0.0523658395,
-0.0211974941,
0.0211762488,
0.1064528152,
0.0451775156,
-0.0248936228,
0.0122760814,
0.0423776358,
-0.0255934149,
-0.0104060955,
0.0833457187,
0.0375398323,
-0.0283620916,
0.0228427257,
0.0527419224,
0.0309430156,
-0.0802999139,
0.0134595288,
-0.0166614186,
0.0771102682,
0.0399232171,
0.0324490815,
-0.0519332401,
0.0228961855,
0.0155361062,
0.0643745288,
-0.0236032344,
-0.0236573406,
-0.0020770666,
-0.0880429819,
-0.0136106228,
0.0189554263,
-0.0592654236,
-0.0302370396,
-0.0183504242,
0.0046330309,
-0.0074766511,
-0.0187983215,
0.0206064247,
-0.0065591447,
0.0256077554,
0.0318705812,
-0.0219838116,
0.0119941328,
0.0124780228,
-0.0644827187,
0.0431035832,
0.1037789062,
-0.0161275379,
-0.0008295158,
-0.0294663757,
-0.036569126,
0.0434443355,
0.0090187564,
-0.002091093,
0.0601220503,
-0.0082630729,
-0.0119680008,
-0.0090625081,
0.0518082194,
0.0006915961,
-0.0161504988,
0.0379471593,
0.0377668552,
0.0042094057,
0.0128728952,
0.0159844588,
-0.0270234831,
-0.0145998737,
0.0429632068,
0.0283058267,
-0.0405873284,
-0.0043297186,
-0.0488503352,
0.0199811868,
-0.0412056595,
0.0086750323,
0.0053462633,
-0.0249509886,
-0.0026288435,
-0.0499719083,
-0.0327970795,
0.0068789129,
0.0491635017,
0.0258437451,
0.0152871702,
0.0309858862,
-0.0058171195,
-0.0475880392,
0.0355131179,
-0.0410850756,
0.023842914,
-0.0700297654,
-0.0468379855,
-0.0233264472,
-0.0546652861,
0.0009369683,
-0.0305682588,
-0.0556910336,
-0.0292626005,
-0.0005748905,
0.0714244843,
0.0265720151,
0.0733776391,
0.002138284,
-0.0544917099,
-0.004047194,
-0.0184816737,
-0.0669029132,
0.0247464534,
0.0408576094,
-0.000419695,
-0.0008490725,
-0.0071697398,
-0.0603203252,
-0.0489848368,
0.0592595562,
-0.0211237874,
0.0001554728,
0.0208009072,
0.0461584255,
0.0169041175,
0.031662073,
0.0040962668,
-0.019744128,
0.0072994255,
-0.0005944095,
0.0414873771,
-0.0282347873,
-0.0140832113,
-0.0262419265,
0.0501021743,
0.0128240827,
0.0372541621,
-0.0582989976,
0.0266977549,
0.0430543125,
-0.0265914928,
0.0064995093,
0.0203150436,
0.0510743074,
0.0764304101,
0.0369985625,
-0.037169233,
0.0288800038,
0.0046703774,
0.0379806533,
0.0204318725,
0.0584390797,
0.0148908831,
0.0257133879,
-0.0047719344,
0.0051459591,
-0.0612227172,
-0.0818784758,
-0.0089721624,
-0.0459940061,
0.0280107595,
-0.0000490355,
0.0051146289,
-0.0185541436,
0.0161317419,
-0.0233650208,
0.0014129936,
-0.0264045708,
-0.0061367527,
-0.0226470549,
0.0305314586,
-0.0253045782,
-0.0232565459,
0.0891764462,
-0.0069708889,
0.0453127027,
-0.0753742233,
-0.0245211422,
-0.0185787175,
0.0009741501,
0.0885152593,
0.0265784487,
-0.0405538268,
-0.0532725342,
-0.0286964867,
-0.0737496614,
-0.018217219,
0.0290487353,
-0.0107003693,
-0.0212787036,
0.0407937951,
0.0529674329,
-0.0407306291,
-0.0173525326,
-0.0518064648,
-0.0130362809,
0.0090316841,
-0.0258086771,
-0.0329583436,
-5.748128437e-33,
-0.0199645013,
-0.0066634556,
0.0117394459,
0.0250574034,
-0.0031077117,
-0.0019803371,
-0.0287191216,
0.0140141789,
0.0012135837,
-0.0635562241,
-0.0142142391,
-0.0138454922,
0.0006865316,
-0.000485596,
0.0574478619,
-0.0161528569,
0.0509930663,
0.0204821974,
-0.0698716566,
0.0325796083,
-0.011400586,
0.0332196467,
0.0239893328,
-0.057262145,
0.0245035123,
0.0181201939,
0.0052395291,
-0.0125518367,
-0.046401944,
0.0760058016,
-0.0057135015,
0.0035413441,
-0.0257622488,
-0.0597763062,
-0.0394928418,
0.010570012,
-0.0729374513,
-0.0427114777,
0.0320037305,
0.0078075547,
-0.0220935903,
-0.0430904329,
0.0815933347,
-0.0347549878,
-0.0176857077,
0.0022653525,
0.0303644855,
-0.0045892457,
-0.0552692376,
-0.0047040354,
-0.0302920118,
0.0048715761,
-0.015845241,
-0.0063195508,
0.0403243564,
0.0248548836,
-0.0102952197,
0.0349921621,
-0.0355833769,
0.0317331366,
0.0205185991,
0.0085255168,
0.0832823664,
0.0654611364,
0.0570161231,
0.0331542715,
0.0514060147,
0.0286747105,
-0.0004537011,
0.0051491666,
0.0286737606,
0.0265783817,
-0.0173752606,
0.0067784092,
0.0352836289,
-0.0117725562,
0.0424508452,
0.0051744548,
-0.0337745026,
0.0467053428,
0.0343838111,
0.0427572243,
-0.0931987241,
-0.030436188,
-0.084780708,
0.0154631352,
-0.0229524858,
-0.0543632209,
0.0263559408,
0.0034861583,
-0.0344888456,
-0.0388897806,
-0.0011294166,
-0.0413419455,
-0.0129219117,
0.0291972086,
-0.0115421554,
0.0192170665,
-0.0217358824,
0.000966113,
-0.0571340919,
0.0223209783,
-0.0290847272,
-0.0393017866,
0.036667347,
0.0447367914,
0.0301734377,
0.0214303974,
-0.0632353798,
0.0070616025,
-0.0387676097,
-0.0253931098,
0.0425699502,
-0.0039974265,
0.0701763481,
-0.0002604013,
0.0053942036,
0.0443001501,
-0.0099897282,
-0.0384284779,
-0.0793216676,
-0.0088552861,
-0.0281134378,
-0.0052239411,
0.0115525993,
-0.0430814847,
-0.048681628,
0.0507920496,
0.0668769479,
-0.0058802348,
-0.0104827434,
0.0038299391,
2.888e-7,
-0.0525079034,
-0.0020409005,
0.0177538525,
0.008414316,
-0.0187501404,
0.0583451651,
-0.0216534398,
0.0206308998,
0.0286461506,
0.0041423636,
0.0036444105,
0.0033911671,
0.0432140455,
0.0268445387,
-0.0421256833,
-0.0452275686,
-0.0383137502,
0.0218253564,
-0.0440585613,
0.0037626969,
-0.0036933082,
0.0563335679,
0.0572454073,
0.0188702121,
0.0425659791,
0.0015460704,
0.0197842177,
-0.0623375848,
0.0042266892,
0.0094493348,
-0.034113612,
0.0389681347,
-0.0098535689,
-0.0136059877,
-0.0038039847,
-0.0193575863,
0.0005305875,
0.0453738049,
0.0106886523,
0.0196822826,
-0.0338166282,
-0.0102602122,
-0.0037560223,
-0.0680330545,
0.0265668314,
-0.0326276198,
0.0056711887,
-0.0024902527,
0.0387958549,
-0.0577165782,
0.0074864631,
0.0085884985,
0.0498325154,
-0.0008564206,
-0.008489199,
0.0225106999,
-0.0306449365,
-0.0554527231,
-0.0284699649,
0.0369986705,
-0.0211828072,
-0.0360446535,
-0.0559359044,
0.0224385131,
-0.0254239216,
-0.0746881515,
0.0332530178,
2.456686077e-34,
0.0043079634,
-0.0512097105,
0.0316789076,
-0.0005141572,
0.0533290468,
-0.013340801,
0.0202094857,
0.034558069,
0.0647560582,
-0.0389872976,
-0.0122034615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11709v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11709v2 | Instruct, Not Assist: LLM-based Multi-Turn Planning and Hierarchical Questioning for Socratic Code Debugging | 2024-06-17T16:28:21 | 2024-06-25T21:17:41 | Priyanka Kargupta, Ishika Agarwal, Dilek Hakkani-Tur, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MA | Socratic questioning is an effective teaching strategy, encouraging critical
thinking and problem-solving. The conversational capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) show great potential for providing scalable, real-time student
guidance. However, current LLMs often give away solutions directly, making them
ineffective instructors. We tackle this issue in the code debugging domain with
TreeInstruct, an Instructor agent guided by a novel state space-based planning
algorithm. TreeInstruct asks probing questions to help students independently
identify and resolve errors. It estimates a student's conceptual and
syntactical knowledge to dynamically construct a question tree based on their
responses and current knowledge state, effectively addressing both independent
and dependent mistakes concurrently in a multi-turn interaction setting. In
addition to using an existing single-bug debugging benchmark, we construct a
more challenging multi-bug dataset of 150 coding problems, incorrect solutions,
and bug fixes -- all carefully constructed and annotated by experts. Extensive
evaluation shows TreeInstruct's state-of-the-art performance on both datasets,
proving it to be a more effective instructor than baselines. Furthermore, a
real-world case study with five students of varying skill levels further
demonstrates TreeInstruct's ability to guide students to debug their code
efficiently with minimal turns and highly Socratic questioning. | [
0.0349416696,
-0.0082234601,
-0.0445396453,
0.0243114568,
-0.0257252585,
0.0186705198,
-0.0324836783,
-0.0224556103,
0.0045232479,
-0.0261641964,
0.0420969613,
0.0086284783,
-0.0291738175,
-0.0237318259,
0.0097784819,
-0.0654559731,
0.0383518264,
-0.066101931,
0.0162741132,
0.0180947743,
0.0146471933,
0.0030772702,
-0.077905722,
0.0513163917,
-0.0096501326,
-0.0561820865,
-0.0737924874,
0.0212182421,
-0.0003687083,
-0.038508065,
-0.0104853492,
0.0232683662,
0.0088840239,
0.0057431408,
0.0000023465,
-0.0255625062,
-0.0213001408,
-0.0099925883,
-0.0347737409,
0.0048220037,
-0.0583303981,
0.0511543117,
-0.0066861212,
0.0456100106,
-0.0654797703,
-0.0037421549,
0.0150990477,
-0.0093504516,
0.108380273,
0.0512811653,
0.0366822779,
0.0006651806,
0.0093850074,
0.0375136845,
0.047503259,
-0.067232497,
0.0078828093,
0.0857770965,
0.0352302268,
0.0290202107,
-0.0425048135,
0.0089209573,
0.0364896208,
-0.0638367906,
-0.0025425348,
-0.0004877925,
-0.0102865547,
-0.0068842666,
0.0043438156,
0.0468500145,
-0.0207236968,
-0.0015440081,
0.009823584,
-0.015540652,
0.0149994809,
0.0264806282,
-0.0395779014,
0.0163863506,
-0.0368764997,
-0.0312631354,
0.0039704544,
-0.0762788355,
-0.0151548162,
-0.0031256848,
-0.0052297185,
0.0482977517,
-0.0515677817,
-0.0368944257,
-0.0188321937,
0.0215142556,
0.0242900327,
-0.0361369289,
-0.0109731508,
0.0847834349,
-0.0589767024,
0.0572966412,
0.0087209372,
0.0187098142,
0.0154248141,
0.0039335657,
-0.024179358,
0.0272464361,
0.0350908078,
0.0017964483,
0.0143288299,
0.0574141964,
0.0254135747,
0.0228955038,
-0.020601457,
0.024880968,
-0.0817959011,
-0.0054542837,
-0.0551035404,
0.0347219557,
0.0151358778,
0.0376220047,
-0.0082888976,
0.0569017418,
0.0080796378,
0.0686964914,
-0.0348971225,
-0.015196979,
-0.0107079493,
0.0236281846,
-0.0041928864,
0.0096470555,
-0.0087379608,
-0.019420458,
0.001475279,
-0.05007888,
-0.021575911,
0.008921315,
-0.0261862855,
0.0079937987,
-0.021972293,
0.0337682217,
-0.0156907309,
0.0145504186,
-0.0057568797,
-0.0536865592,
-0.0057215993,
0.0096512893,
-0.0145335309,
-0.0757085308,
-0.0413501859,
0.0099407174,
-0.0016294742,
-0.0201353561,
0.0340715759,
0.0124857752,
0.0236255955,
0.0395697802,
-0.0243044272,
0.0362191945,
0.0584176555,
0.036739096,
-0.0062557892,
0.0426209942,
0.044158265,
-0.0212992057,
0.0153774759,
-0.0305723045,
0.0777187422,
0.0197568126,
-0.0101626767,
0.0267276894,
0.039150998,
0.0056682709,
0.0028021592,
0.033790525,
-0.0198815372,
0.0028176173,
-0.0131086409,
0.0369019434,
-0.012549676,
0.0342298821,
-0.0378815643,
0.0186652187,
0.0355362631,
0.0269713234,
0.0090102004,
-0.0199563,
-0.0257768854,
0.036213357,
-0.0096679535,
-0.0093608443,
-0.0150658907,
-0.0115258992,
0.0219278485,
-0.0647486523,
-0.0036745518,
0.0513630845,
-0.0192046128,
0.0269541014,
0.033996705,
0.0076756566,
-0.0360522494,
0.0385415927,
0.005852981,
-0.0553864986,
-0.0295259692,
-0.0486133993,
0.0359289236,
0.0472573526,
0.0631742999,
-0.073375836,
-0.1023396924,
-0.002600102,
0.0135799851,
-0.010491441,
0.0574237965,
-0.0447560549,
-0.023093963,
-0.0302859489,
-0.0275016911,
-0.0190218482,
0.0001751342,
0.0170484278,
0.0314922705,
-0.0372571796,
0.0022473587,
-0.0097806351,
-0.0363523029,
0.037690375,
0.0030209785,
-0.0192829408,
-0.0295022652,
-0.0129149677,
-0.0020986481,
0.0063352031,
-0.0202654544,
0.00625906,
0.0473507866,
0.0199403502,
-0.0097798929,
-0.0162070394,
-0.0556469932,
-0.0746246353,
0.0498491153,
-0.0542789921,
-0.0491126701,
0.018834386,
-0.0552912317,
-0.0199419875,
0.0447223894,
-0.0260770898,
0.0104221776,
0.0106542241,
0.025230987,
-0.0348057523,
-0.0610518344,
-0.0412532203,
0.0170622822,
0.0240463689,
0.0049782707,
-0.028718058,
0.0650775358,
0.0047721965,
-0.0301133487,
0.0094270129,
0.0276193731,
-0.0034033654,
0.0139880041,
-0.0068202452,
0.0307889655,
-0.0473435782,
-0.0210288763,
-0.0770244896,
-0.0129930563,
-0.008621634,
0.0219752919,
0.0068924506,
0.0014421705,
-0.0155793726,
-0.0260401815,
-0.0264583696,
0.0011712356,
0.0037215869,
-0.0297650937,
0.0293336418,
0.0189896971,
-0.0417213812,
-0.0653371438,
0.0029360629,
-0.062933147,
-0.0163963847,
0.0286324956,
-0.0299880411,
-0.066417329,
0.0727491751,
-0.0159678329,
0.030074453,
-0.0115506789,
-0.035386011,
0.0265447125,
-0.041357547,
0.0408306718,
0.0568504333,
-0.0392649621,
0.0351561643,
0.0526134856,
-0.0240123775,
-0.0812613219,
0.0561474934,
0.0504553467,
-0.0315081701,
-0.043699339,
-0.0354280025,
0.0135979755,
0.0772295147,
0.0035497742,
-0.0113408407,
-0.0202212222,
0.0172079001,
-0.0049072513,
0.0143994205,
0.002976089,
-0.0444372669,
-0.0041925535,
0.0030145103,
-0.0205166917,
-0.0601009801,
0.087555483,
-0.0141514186,
-0.0507857725,
-0.0259373803,
-0.0398357175,
-0.0361291394,
0.0710408315,
-0.0072987806,
0.0091446023,
-0.0079206582,
-0.0256137867,
-0.0152375819,
0.0171736162,
0.0394748338,
-0.0320111625,
0.0519588552,
-0.1159486473,
-0.0201520678,
0.0181956813,
-0.0296613649,
-0.036325369,
0.0014033909,
-0.0283143427,
-0.0288455132,
0.0464468747,
-0.0117545184,
0.0006471091,
-0.0189086217,
0.0470364727,
0.0414251201,
-0.0092985379,
-0.0498982817,
-0.001588403,
-0.0274542812,
-0.0291059092,
-0.0016806648,
0.0115113612,
-0.0533268526,
0.0803884864,
0.0577197634,
0.0756203383,
0.0186345167,
0.0001886258,
-0.0207369067,
0.0226703752,
-0.0116256867,
-0.0166792218,
0.0327196941,
0.0713298991,
-0.0622606352,
-0.0709545985,
0.0895354748,
0.0690609962,
-0.0684410408,
0.0133275213,
-0.0344360024,
0.0324391276,
0.0636816472,
0.0584132299,
-0.0706557184,
-0.034313634,
-0.0125920558,
0.0239788704,
-0.0182720385,
-0.0404909998,
-0.0058793537,
-0.1025036424,
-0.0038359738,
0.0092342542,
0.0237460025,
0.0025476341,
-0.0188630559,
-0.0071352622,
0.0256065018,
-0.0251766145,
0.0386067964,
0.0136157852,
0.029993156,
0.0626996979,
-0.0778044909,
0.0096634924,
0.0342500545,
0.0196045544,
0.0345838405,
0.0621547773,
-0.0065311394,
0.009133569,
0.0264915749,
0.0193278994,
0.0101152342,
0.0261427835,
-0.0396474339,
0.0184574891,
-0.0251583997,
0.0066718375,
0.0089576486,
0.0258363746,
-0.0448991098,
-0.0063354634,
0.0982622877,
0.0616014414,
-0.0430337675,
0.0214570202,
-0.0341618583,
-0.0047888164,
0.0075841821,
-0.0112164021,
0.0388304852,
-0.018885823,
-0.01157826,
-0.0881742537,
-0.0157403369,
-0.0190159157,
-0.010460455,
0.0088090282,
0.0154311871,
0.0660257563,
-0.0240572654,
-0.0322503224,
0.0812307373,
0.0500650816,
-0.0145993391,
-0.0709521845,
-0.0031002341,
0.037643373,
0.0003829901,
-0.00663519,
-0.0029469628,
0.0136598554,
-0.0212224517,
-0.0107627884,
-0.0062998543,
0.0153179737,
0.0000685511,
0.0095136072,
-0.0476178452,
-0.0674802288,
-0.0144494828,
0.0532911234,
0.020571636,
0.0286389943,
-0.0219027624,
-0.0377955884,
-0.0586869307,
-0.0287004653,
-0.0209155604,
-0.0046906881,
-0.0041517578,
0.034903992,
0.0258698277,
0.0028398412,
-0.0442970023,
-0.0056255669,
-0.0126870554,
0.013217004,
-0.0982835516,
-0.028555382,
0.0148009295,
0.0195583347,
0.0290201213,
0.0480799489,
-0.011505371,
0.0090439636,
0.0482097715,
-0.018683698,
-0.0387220979,
-0.0403818265,
0.0514935665,
0.0026446481,
-0.0780378729,
0.0508168787,
0.007694162,
-0.020471802,
0.0185655728,
0.0031223299,
0.0571515188,
0.0505685359,
-0.022692116,
0.0489127673,
0.005657352,
-0.0088850614,
-0.0108287027,
0.0508075282,
0.0404721685,
0.0618776157,
0.0978522897,
0.0168098435,
0.0140049206,
0.0242499374,
-0.0373897068,
-0.0546047427,
-0.1067770198,
0.0391235985,
0.0396809541,
0.0396021791,
0.0709643736,
-0.0069822497,
-0.0096766222,
0.0387000665,
0.0463707559,
0.0246128254,
-0.0171027575,
-0.0642025173,
0.0450520851,
0.0525867343,
0.0387914404,
-0.0210386198,
0.0492103472,
0.0145885888,
0.0261028372,
-0.0183913875,
-0.0192681272,
-0.0460906141,
0.0073246639,
0.0389440581,
-0.0073950887,
0.0218610987,
0.0156122986,
-0.0632727072,
-0.052567374,
-0.0404165871,
0.0538072065,
0.0244823694,
-0.0340834446,
0.0214710645,
0.0462527163,
-0.0130204381,
-0.0393378548,
-0.0225387905,
0.0060210484,
-0.0381792337,
-0.0257746708,
-0.0364723429,
-5.416718744e-33,
-0.0685496628,
-0.0829348862,
0.0342302509,
0.0049507306,
-0.005343094,
-0.033022806,
-0.0439881384,
0.0490368083,
-0.0129387304,
0.0176247638,
-0.0002045415,
0.0701676905,
-0.013517756,
-0.0377829671,
0.0461165309,
0.0104315365,
0.0211050939,
0.0550762489,
-0.0320831835,
0.0532534383,
-0.0145200295,
0.0186019,
0.0073400489,
-0.035008803,
0.0194411259,
-0.0388888232,
0.0207125284,
0.065150775,
-0.0336479284,
-0.0023425885,
0.0255753193,
-0.0145895137,
-0.0176583827,
0.0067799827,
-0.0181923322,
-0.0091250828,
0.0097103836,
-0.0575145967,
0.0048986832,
-0.0057191988,
-0.0114560621,
-0.0152332233,
0.0280396231,
0.0294761099,
0.0131631037,
0.0027679445,
0.0348332748,
0.024926953,
0.001585253,
0.0070337532,
-0.0209868457,
0.0214825403,
-0.0975315347,
-0.0478789061,
-0.0402029045,
0.0828358084,
0.0068406556,
-0.0456443466,
0.0401444174,
0.0338675119,
0.034229096,
-0.0076614865,
0.0245321076,
0.0085860565,
-0.028433146,
0.0254378989,
0.0389718376,
0.0291245505,
-0.0046693194,
-0.0254079401,
0.0026880768,
0.0246321298,
0.0461720414,
0.0325696878,
-0.0068847118,
0.0282593109,
-0.0535055175,
0.0260823388,
0.0405734591,
0.0262333658,
-0.0337523147,
0.0016676553,
-0.0517029651,
-0.0137206931,
-0.0744058639,
0.0204986446,
0.0225061253,
-0.0247032605,
0.0191593505,
-0.0219562016,
-0.0039847353,
-0.0069671469,
-0.0090246312,
0.0047587594,
-0.0051066172,
-0.0070872842,
-0.0283914283,
0.0487774462,
-0.0539772324,
0.0273814108,
-0.02681702,
-0.0093703084,
-0.0158529151,
-0.0038167471,
0.0590943843,
0.002442908,
-0.0217440948,
0.0204931889,
-0.0463167764,
-0.0212191604,
-0.0581944399,
-0.0057715615,
-0.0274597295,
0.021923162,
0.0039845305,
-0.0002815175,
-0.0283422954,
0.0417930596,
0.0054838425,
-0.0545165055,
-0.0444569811,
-0.020340817,
-0.0202859882,
-0.0260154568,
-0.0417476408,
-0.0630807132,
-0.0200015791,
0.0211142953,
0.0120086353,
-0.0839833096,
-0.0037968731,
0.0405878723,
3.02e-7,
0.0000818539,
0.0802848935,
0.0060139536,
0.0010821179,
0.0113804741,
0.0181298405,
-0.0165583603,
-0.0250509884,
0.0634717122,
-0.0119366786,
-0.0072479304,
0.0287555177,
0.0267432034,
0.0444952212,
-0.088754274,
-0.0322600007,
-0.0119639067,
-0.0038398427,
-0.0533217154,
0.0331305973,
0.0472496897,
0.0072719771,
0.0270173009,
0.0223353058,
0.0193524845,
-0.0105863316,
-0.0124677941,
0.0036150818,
0.0155066466,
0.0534101538,
-0.0325066447,
-0.0170291904,
0.0054364023,
0.0383453406,
0.02674843,
-0.0300048813,
-0.0469453074,
0.0525288545,
-0.0013086599,
0.0141885914,
-0.0049194018,
0.0134896059,
0.0042716656,
-0.0414798222,
-0.0050247204,
-0.017364895,
0.0151325362,
0.0455829166,
0.020717904,
-0.0342332758,
-0.0415281169,
0.023831008,
0.0297947861,
0.0202285666,
-0.0420312881,
-0.0472934321,
0.0254881419,
-0.019185517,
-0.0192809943,
-0.0012904477,
-0.0130159454,
-0.0381550454,
-0.0089498907,
-0.0209577549,
-0.0295240618,
-0.0054950342,
0.0233047921,
2.762432387e-34,
0.0038389363,
-0.0208073203,
0.0427068956,
0.0421429425,
0.0411182754,
0.0153755648,
0.0133452071,
0.0430745222,
0.0549927689,
-0.0202352069,
-0.0391291156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11706v1 | Prompts as Auto-Optimized Training Hyperparameters: Training Best-in-Class IR Models from Scratch with 10 Gold Labels | 2024-06-17T16:25:55 | 2024-06-17T16:25:55 | Jasper Xian, Saron Samuel, Faraz Khoubsirat, Ronak Pradeep, Md Arafat Sultan, Radu Florian, Salim Roukos, Avirup Sil, Christopher Potts, Omar Khattab | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | We develop a method for training small-scale (under 100M parameter) neural
information retrieval models with as few as 10 gold relevance labels. The
method depends on generating synthetic queries for documents using a language
model (LM), and the key step is that we automatically optimize the LM prompt
that is used to generate these queries based on training quality. In
experiments with the BIRCO benchmark, we find that models trained with our
method outperform RankZephyr and are competitive with RankLLama, both of which
are 7B parameter models trained on over 100K labels. These findings point to
the power of automatic prompt optimization for synthetic dataset generation. | [
0.0622544177,
0.0279539283,
0.0128088295,
0.0059214816,
0.0149751967,
0.0046572136,
0.0328757465,
0.0164725073,
0.0406526178,
-0.0399389789,
-0.0613252632,
-0.0045717927,
-0.0628246292,
-0.0092365863,
0.0007967952,
-0.0127931526,
0.059128698,
-0.0037020885,
0.0375680849,
-0.0097298333,
-0.0334234945,
0.0192147177,
0.0291177481,
0.0149389962,
0.0081616556,
-0.0076654116,
-0.0031282541,
0.0520670637,
-0.0188910887,
-0.0346217528,
0.0169546772,
0.0469679944,
0.0111271162,
0.0317232721,
0.0000018738,
-0.0472458303,
-0.0144847836,
-0.0013235204,
-0.053744901,
0.0250189062,
0.0527214669,
0.018558979,
0.051615268,
0.0214187931,
-0.0262107905,
-0.0097827092,
-0.0045420369,
0.0328268819,
0.0381200872,
0.06761498,
0.0080601592,
0.0097439392,
0.0071970359,
-0.0447978824,
0.0442869216,
-0.0406956263,
0.0130070951,
-0.0496895537,
0.0173255634,
0.087769419,
0.0257802326,
0.0268261712,
0.0113481702,
-0.0326749831,
0.0523220897,
0.0170401372,
-0.0590692312,
-0.0070703407,
0.0149372499,
0.0445019193,
-0.0604170524,
-0.0279134754,
-0.0153069077,
0.0028512378,
0.0197863653,
-0.0129042547,
-0.024827227,
0.0064313607,
-0.0137520479,
-0.0060350117,
-0.0031354332,
0.0125053702,
0.0174556635,
-0.0024587864,
-0.0022355316,
0.0321953744,
0.0064610369,
-0.0374945961,
0.0271138307,
-0.0310245249,
-0.0322007202,
0.0138844987,
-0.0069114622,
0.0212287474,
-0.0382432565,
-0.0116162617,
-0.0178584568,
-0.0116698071,
0.0523952506,
-0.0550666004,
0.0307238027,
0.0219668187,
-0.0104172723,
0.0796457902,
-0.0127134472,
0.0293067377,
0.0029365243,
0.0241349116,
-0.0520058163,
-0.0220648237,
-0.0087448359,
-0.0127247125,
-0.0602762103,
0.0158502329,
-0.041320052,
-0.0181158315,
-0.0052389689,
0.0253610797,
0.0330468006,
-0.0181717351,
0.0309896357,
0.0216708463,
-0.0776192546,
0.0007911833,
-0.0695183128,
-0.0130097959,
-0.0145316999,
-0.0070183449,
-0.0044170585,
-0.0610355586,
-0.0068034283,
-0.0006218857,
-0.0067449682,
-0.0384082384,
0.0444757715,
0.0070563825,
-0.0275215041,
-0.0301473066,
-0.0437692553,
-0.0362290479,
0.0382305123,
-0.022149507,
0.0118560279,
-0.0181151554,
0.0480312183,
-0.0267725885,
0.0019236237,
-0.0228228103,
-0.0096358703,
0.035772454,
-0.0128283184,
0.0605895929,
-0.0054436806,
0.0062101651,
0.0443132259,
-0.0165846925,
0.0074244738,
0.0495000146,
-0.0154357469,
0.0538950525,
0.0495982654,
-0.0002598811,
0.0092153279,
-0.0052676462,
0.0222079307,
0.0066097211,
-0.0018490768,
0.0368809737,
0.0265402142,
0.0443305075,
0.0239334516,
0.0404189825,
-0.0259051491,
-0.0338411629,
0.0335697457,
0.0308142006,
0.0629887953,
-0.0144650498,
0.0457336456,
0.0109487223,
-0.012092975,
-0.0380755216,
-0.0232678857,
0.0286034644,
-0.0038506915,
0.0055526788,
0.0668469146,
-0.0077850344,
-0.0569280721,
-0.0480197743,
0.0068399603,
0.0423769765,
-0.0913469344,
0.0289564207,
0.010598856,
0.0179919414,
-0.0253516678,
0.0146969175,
0.0122821312,
-0.0188969504,
0.0104893902,
-0.0582226291,
0.0240864456,
0.0519000925,
0.0677047223,
-0.0685156807,
0.0513428822,
-0.013856641,
0.009030926,
0.0301717687,
0.0640384182,
-0.0237981752,
0.0184481088,
-0.0438691713,
-0.0245073158,
-0.0002999439,
0.0072479448,
0.0182065256,
-0.0238932017,
0.0198638812,
0.032607995,
-0.0518220924,
-0.0806239843,
0.044956509,
-0.0161459055,
-0.1058492437,
0.0457359329,
0.0001503883,
0.0038805506,
-0.0133065525,
-0.0170187633,
0.0225272402,
0.0450852253,
0.0007671817,
0.0201789755,
-0.0876468867,
-0.0137482425,
-0.0147743952,
-0.0011394601,
-0.0240542572,
0.0608665831,
0.0316302814,
-0.0207456965,
-0.0155794984,
-0.0436495058,
0.0081138276,
0.0148810446,
-0.0529440865,
0.0136967963,
0.00784011,
0.0349627696,
-0.0558760166,
0.0430335775,
0.0396906286,
0.061239142,
0.0168920346,
0.0197432432,
0.0250567086,
-0.0883051977,
-0.0115054678,
0.0064750621,
-0.0057602488,
0.026586486,
0.0103953592,
0.0339953378,
-0.0132909156,
-0.0272410884,
-0.0778944269,
-0.0032936034,
-0.0206566025,
-0.0368788876,
0.0072783269,
0.008323337,
-0.0020911149,
-0.0374206118,
-0.0124871582,
-0.042606473,
-0.0127224894,
0.0343516245,
0.019606594,
0.0213470552,
0.0080175372,
-0.0438949652,
-0.0458308868,
0.0057743383,
0.0632174909,
0.0308824554,
0.0122873746,
-0.0065118107,
0.0225462839,
-0.0124744596,
0.0447566174,
-0.0139267612,
-0.0110940896,
0.0166863613,
-0.0822223052,
-0.0073839976,
0.0828008801,
0.0442937538,
-0.0278367754,
0.0314600877,
0.0241134893,
-0.1124087945,
0.0277384892,
-0.0570197701,
-0.0311087035,
0.0311744381,
-0.046357315,
0.0673574284,
0.0139699448,
-0.0169122443,
0.0031728034,
-0.0512243584,
0.027978953,
0.0387915075,
-0.0050325878,
-0.0981807113,
0.0187359825,
0.0145375319,
0.0577655025,
-0.0123351086,
-0.04036396,
0.0424579866,
-0.0367146879,
0.0045634131,
-0.0372944213,
-0.0093329502,
-0.0426405892,
0.0295900349,
-0.0017593625,
0.0241701007,
-0.0031725063,
0.0228775796,
-0.0133569073,
0.0351799242,
0.0399592519,
-0.0231473465,
-0.0011548818,
0.0125153428,
0.0479320586,
-0.0068162163,
-0.0541957095,
-0.0573058315,
-0.0769844726,
0.0431610718,
0.0076807197,
0.0168664474,
0.0225029867,
-0.026051417,
0.0320808925,
0.0125993323,
0.0718859956,
-0.0346902199,
-0.0450297371,
0.0168963857,
0.0153490193,
0.0378257148,
-0.0542736351,
-0.0178941656,
0.0155332675,
0.0484070107,
-0.0270938259,
0.0510825403,
-0.004397314,
-0.0004902709,
0.0015093707,
0.0580238625,
-0.0209282786,
-0.0095393015,
-0.0028231528,
-0.0272341557,
-0.0061755832,
-0.0346948728,
0.077582553,
0.0258820318,
-0.0881318524,
-0.0253167953,
-0.0454064794,
0.0363311507,
0.0399068967,
0.0697452351,
-0.031840045,
0.0076010926,
0.0121066757,
0.0769960284,
-0.0145257199,
-0.0177220479,
-0.0277102999,
-0.1139400974,
0.0606027879,
-0.0269629695,
-0.0046229707,
-0.0220428817,
-0.0266979095,
-0.0244983863,
-0.0075010723,
0.0002163176,
0.0630904138,
-0.0380594693,
-0.0075114183,
0.0058068293,
0.0387405828,
-0.052653268,
-0.0104753235,
-0.0211077482,
0.0204754006,
0.0105220638,
0.0143293105,
0.025537461,
-0.0682250783,
0.0118579622,
-0.0337829813,
0.0176712815,
-0.0435038731,
0.0714630559,
-0.0170543361,
-0.0245559718,
0.0123281414,
-0.0059882565,
-0.0088595534,
0.0377235338,
-0.0073098042,
0.0290384088,
-0.0495725758,
0.0088340826,
-0.0315377787,
-0.035039112,
0.0071698688,
0.0709806234,
0.0178497043,
0.0024932914,
0.0039685522,
-0.0158934947,
0.0222189035,
-0.0425994694,
-0.0274761841,
0.039611645,
-0.034059111,
-0.0083969263,
-0.0248501413,
-0.0395877957,
0.0037636838,
0.0500919297,
0.0001779925,
0.0060626203,
-0.0787721649,
0.0043305932,
-0.0186550729,
0.0811109245,
-0.0292763934,
-0.0442887545,
-0.078932479,
0.0025176303,
0.0564670116,
-0.0550349578,
-0.0449739359,
-0.0175860394,
0.0172175802,
-0.040047247,
-0.0093213143,
0.0496284291,
0.0192038435,
0.0389203988,
-0.046417471,
-0.0878983364,
0.0374912918,
0.0662059262,
-0.0565357246,
-0.0217868462,
0.0095504457,
-0.0343299098,
-0.0354199484,
0.0112625761,
-0.0777104571,
0.0750273168,
0.0116241165,
0.024497699,
-0.012118821,
-0.0633147657,
0.0650207624,
0.0537799522,
0.0561417453,
-0.004410387,
0.0000631059,
-0.0491474606,
0.0192799978,
0.0055292356,
-0.0144525161,
-0.0284560826,
0.0294354577,
0.0371914469,
-0.0160233546,
-0.0049605453,
0.0152721889,
-0.0189807266,
0.0465977639,
-0.042917762,
-0.0629662648,
-0.0181552749,
0.0290043112,
0.0308221634,
-0.0211283155,
-0.0592849553,
0.0536404252,
0.0035716887,
0.0411630683,
-0.0187806636,
0.0067059938,
0.0382519104,
0.019604655,
-0.0268065128,
0.0049412949,
-0.0776223391,
-0.0968062133,
-0.0542704053,
0.0052635679,
0.046170447,
0.0300754569,
-0.032347966,
-0.0115053169,
-0.0197725017,
-0.0132752955,
-0.0185519997,
0.0678318515,
-0.0091524338,
0.0295947399,
0.0520123765,
-0.0040937182,
0.0201634727,
0.0659013763,
0.0180287585,
0.0215983912,
-0.0429879799,
-0.0322179385,
-0.0469569676,
0.008460559,
0.0309149288,
0.036840681,
-0.003528296,
-0.0167402755,
-0.016778212,
-0.0181627255,
0.0097327633,
0.0102120601,
-0.0298308935,
-0.0030456756,
0.0582150742,
0.0751622394,
-0.019523656,
0.0117825735,
-0.0359221734,
-0.0028170897,
-0.0266047344,
-0.0131068118,
-0.0240459032,
-6.439356584e-33,
0.0029398212,
0.0189393088,
0.0184725858,
-0.0081905155,
0.007553014,
0.0022094729,
-0.003592537,
-0.055263903,
-0.0451876931,
-0.0024975056,
-0.067238614,
-0.0027944176,
0.015687421,
0.0000642645,
-0.0082921293,
0.0037309076,
0.0695596337,
-0.0194243286,
-0.0324212536,
0.0151385544,
0.0126564587,
0.0344090909,
-0.0100817727,
-0.0479844734,
-0.01582966,
-0.0148075931,
-0.0178163312,
0.0569647588,
0.0062395302,
0.0496982373,
-0.0312364381,
0.0572964512,
0.0185083859,
-0.0719949007,
0.0289431307,
0.0279691983,
-0.0712503046,
-0.055419106,
-0.0195884742,
-0.0163856894,
-0.0389126912,
-0.0195341967,
0.0310934167,
-0.0118252765,
-0.0292830374,
0.031113293,
0.0511178114,
0.0064163171,
-0.0505590886,
-0.0663040951,
-0.0055201221,
-0.004250986,
0.0397362523,
0.0092261843,
0.0079175737,
0.0780757591,
0.004444309,
0.0734668449,
-0.0339783728,
0.0191155821,
-0.005784099,
0.0606543161,
0.0113249077,
0.0211668536,
0.0049680057,
0.0330300182,
0.0213809162,
0.0322850011,
0.0391904749,
-0.0141826021,
0.0319967195,
0.0158339441,
0.0485749319,
0.0703185201,
0.0315875523,
-0.0204197243,
-0.050997559,
0.0394804887,
0.0066168415,
-0.0066117975,
0.0246978328,
0.0031310881,
-0.0425070934,
-0.0334938653,
-0.0516629405,
-0.0311347768,
-0.0598869585,
0.0084986789,
0.06053349,
0.0614049584,
-0.0176219828,
-0.0412985869,
0.0424455293,
0.015116618,
-0.0134779112,
0.0281899367,
0.0156239616,
-0.0047772233,
0.0007969255,
-0.0114725688,
0.0024834936,
-0.0225104187,
0.0413402729,
-0.006252171,
-0.003635084,
0.0113274148,
0.0044276193,
0.011040478,
-0.0495014898,
-0.0046395804,
-0.000614209,
0.0307197478,
0.0074640168,
0.0120188668,
0.0000184734,
-0.0010517035,
0.0009729535,
0.0595412143,
0.0097210128,
0.0205175038,
0.0154220341,
-0.0443145819,
0.0126831429,
0.0168572329,
-0.0108965524,
0.017785605,
-0.0400140509,
0.034015622,
0.0351680741,
-0.0506262518,
-0.0141410893,
0.0626309663,
2.692e-7,
0.017384151,
0.014791525,
-0.030675482,
0.0124858776,
-0.0118453791,
0.0210458804,
0.0193853844,
0.0103034424,
0.0446578972,
-0.0183414724,
0.0235984195,
-0.0042973682,
0.0242865123,
-0.0030637423,
-0.1031788662,
-0.0647639781,
-0.0619041957,
0.0116098532,
-0.0619205609,
-0.0498090498,
0.023262741,
0.1018951237,
-0.010343981,
-0.0243868101,
0.0127737718,
-0.0851405337,
0.0238247495,
-0.017597951,
-0.0116132889,
0.0311042778,
0.0867163613,
0.0104882084,
-0.0276907329,
0.011363429,
-0.0104834186,
0.0124797896,
0.0035077089,
0.0388908423,
-0.0096770572,
-0.0322167985,
0.0335545838,
-0.0087047368,
0.004372987,
-0.0815172791,
0.0721542984,
-0.0197244249,
0.0419266447,
0.0332570188,
-0.014376929,
-0.0213408116,
0.0279662237,
-0.0725375339,
-0.0242362395,
-0.0118464455,
0.0038320322,
0.0097469771,
-0.0099642929,
-0.0757131651,
0.017130645,
-0.0254451502,
-0.0258388482,
-0.0306967571,
-0.0320368595,
0.0152951619,
0.0013750759,
-0.0158701744,
0.0175633915,
2.392793367e-34,
0.0381319225,
-0.0127108684,
0.033831235,
-0.0099955471,
-0.003363084,
0.0125979483,
-0.0283551216,
0.0181830674,
0.0450840108,
-0.1087005064,
-0.0288577564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11704v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11704v1 | Nemotron-4 340B Technical Report | 2024-06-17T16:25:04 | 2024-06-17T16:25:04 | Nvidia, :, Bo Adler, Niket Agarwal, Ashwath Aithal, Dong H. Anh, Pallab Bhattacharya, Annika Brundyn, Jared Casper, Bryan Catanzaro, Sharon Clay, Jonathan Cohen, Sirshak Das, Ayush Dattagupta, Olivier Delalleau, Leon Derczynski, Yi Dong, Daniel Egert, Ellie Evans, Aleksander Ficek, Denys Fridman, Shaona Ghosh, Boris Ginsburg, Igor Gitman, Tomasz Grzegorzek, Robert Hero, Jining Huang, Vibhu Jawa, Joseph Jennings, Aastha Jhunjhunwala, John Kamalu, Sadaf Khan, Oleksii Kuchaiev, Patrick LeGresley, Hui Li, Jiwei Liu, Zihan Liu, Eileen Long, Ameya Sunil Mahabaleshwarkar, Somshubra Majumdar, James Maki, Miguel Martinez, Maer Rodrigues de Melo, Ivan Moshkov, Deepak Narayanan, Sean Narenthiran, Jesus Navarro, Phong Nguyen, Osvald Nitski, Vahid Noroozi, Guruprasad Nutheti, Christopher Parisien, Jupinder Parmar, Mostofa Patwary, Krzysztof Pawelec, Wei Ping, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Rajarshi Roy, Trisha Saar, Vasanth Rao Naik Sabavat, Sanjeev Satheesh, Jane Polak Scowcroft, Jason Sewall, Pavel Shamis, Gerald Shen, Mohammad Shoeybi, Dave Sizer, Misha Smelyanskiy, Felipe Soares, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Dan Su, Sandeep Subramanian, Shengyang Sun, Shubham Toshniwal, Hao Wang, Zhilin Wang, Jiaxuan You, Jiaqi Zeng, Jimmy Zhang, Jing Zhang, Vivienne Zhang, Yian Zhang, Chen Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We release the Nemotron-4 340B model family, including Nemotron-4-340B-Base,
Nemotron-4-340B-Instruct, and Nemotron-4-340B-Reward. Our models are open
access under the NVIDIA Open Model License Agreement, a permissive model
license that allows distribution, modification, and use of the models and its
outputs. These models perform competitively to open access models on a wide
range of evaluation benchmarks, and were sized to fit on a single DGX H100 with
8 GPUs when deployed in FP8 precision. We believe that the community can
benefit from these models in various research studies and commercial
applications, especially for generating synthetic data to train smaller
language models. Notably, over 98% of data used in our model alignment process
is synthetically generated, showcasing the effectiveness of these models in
generating synthetic data. To further support open research and facilitate
model development, we are also open-sourcing the synthetic data generation
pipeline used in our model alignment process. | [
-0.0236168038,
0.0554264747,
-0.0173665807,
0.0508040711,
-0.0296024345,
-0.005940814,
0.0031849565,
-0.0385799445,
-0.0848551169,
-0.0222937167,
-0.0358969085,
-0.0621226542,
0.0297067873,
0.0575322658,
0.0703065395,
-0.0273865554,
0.0663062409,
-0.0328445025,
-0.0056677428,
0.0069388435,
0.0030537455,
0.0168876834,
-0.0101655275,
0.0312576443,
-0.0107047977,
-0.0118144033,
-0.0217353646,
0.0155304167,
-0.00044846,
-0.020905586,
0.0195715949,
0.0643705353,
0.020954363,
0.0774324313,
0.0000021763,
-0.0617749095,
-0.0019112632,
-0.0032390496,
-0.0133911967,
0.0086124241,
0.0772538707,
-0.0500967763,
-0.0500650741,
0.0012318747,
-0.0072583128,
-0.0358844362,
0.0674348101,
-0.0237281006,
0.0431144387,
0.0926683396,
-0.0226385836,
-0.0373746194,
0.0243686736,
-0.0270570219,
-0.0052507441,
0.0168550275,
0.0153758489,
-0.0176207293,
-0.0199529994,
-0.0142026991,
-0.0124462536,
0.0114187878,
0.0008060889,
-0.0055926759,
0.0265130904,
0.0420269445,
-0.0186185893,
-0.0152012287,
0.0020929715,
0.0350268446,
-0.0321499854,
-0.0212489553,
0.0048088501,
0.0103456117,
-0.0302198511,
-0.0502738059,
-0.035830766,
0.0153832249,
0.0083440486,
0.0016172077,
0.0314471088,
-0.0178375449,
0.0356428623,
-0.0281310063,
-0.0148702906,
0.0213421732,
0.0542264022,
-0.0198329929,
-0.0368376337,
0.0080558546,
0.0016684189,
-0.0224914588,
0.0246087983,
0.0118253641,
0.0002350204,
0.0236154869,
-0.0735499039,
-0.016165331,
0.0211634915,
-0.041834943,
0.060531985,
0.0461077727,
0.0314104892,
0.0141623057,
-0.0609044954,
0.0204508584,
-0.0155821033,
-0.0049107526,
-0.0363539234,
0.0180407297,
-0.0072791968,
0.0051594884,
-0.0099666603,
0.0059471135,
-0.0828272626,
-0.0451979078,
-0.0373946689,
0.029587822,
0.0239061564,
-0.0116408067,
0.0415865369,
-0.0012323153,
-0.0322795101,
0.0320175961,
-0.0297335498,
0.0430969149,
0.0080582937,
-0.0107117984,
-0.0119854994,
-0.0956076384,
0.01031176,
-0.0186230801,
-0.0134567367,
-0.0325926319,
0.022147039,
0.0779252872,
-0.0078514563,
-0.0135114416,
-0.0181734357,
0.0250522345,
0.0090271449,
-0.0733698756,
-0.0062207971,
-0.0711343139,
0.055464264,
0.0099882763,
-0.0085438928,
-0.0178368036,
0.0135926092,
0.0016528431,
0.0218203645,
0.0470095538,
-0.0523673035,
0.0032156175,
0.033886604,
-0.0340803675,
0.0341469608,
0.0611473732,
0.0351747461,
0.0030366292,
0.02889538,
-0.0199207682,
-0.0073487367,
0.0573625639,
0.0200382993,
0.0007153795,
-0.0388459079,
-0.0217476077,
0.0098061413,
0.0678037405,
0.0672310889,
0.0628605261,
-0.0262702424,
-0.034757331,
0.1022206768,
0.024355948,
0.005644538,
-0.0002957208,
0.017236853,
-0.0343554653,
0.0165893529,
-0.0573962703,
-0.0291167982,
0.0033625704,
-0.0139365885,
0.0572688207,
0.0203314219,
0.0826590657,
-0.009041979,
-0.0300386976,
-0.010379469,
0.0016490205,
-0.0047921194,
-0.022175692,
0.066262655,
-0.0416873842,
-0.0633353069,
0.0633872226,
0.0084386999,
-0.0645310655,
-0.0040768795,
-0.0407179929,
0.0620033033,
0.0684076995,
0.0433782823,
0.0113435304,
-0.1003406346,
-0.0120223658,
-0.0915416554,
0.0874747187,
0.0299045928,
-0.004336467,
0.021597771,
-0.077701807,
0.0084181046,
-0.0076371073,
0.0285114311,
0.0259590615,
0.0158444103,
-0.0071333074,
-0.0036874674,
0.0112370988,
-0.0488644578,
0.0503843725,
-0.0395919867,
-0.0010306607,
-0.0343562104,
-0.0231305528,
0.0343760923,
0.006809148,
0.000774609,
0.0160010681,
0.048763752,
-0.0255321395,
0.0344934613,
-0.0221644081,
-0.0693869889,
-0.04574164,
0.0831844583,
-0.0144395418,
0.0471600965,
0.0333639905,
-0.0199683663,
-0.0653703958,
0.0357936174,
-0.0379885435,
-0.003560053,
-0.0501589552,
0.0447643921,
-0.0065412056,
0.031769488,
-0.0045693,
0.0456509143,
-0.0082763033,
0.0086296843,
0.031559743,
-0.0066816756,
0.0189345386,
-0.0540096089,
-0.0462842137,
0.0006686068,
-0.0140345152,
0.0224730931,
-0.0027005565,
-0.0248711463,
-0.0229467042,
-0.0069627934,
-0.0648372546,
0.0297948737,
-0.0140262321,
0.0450292192,
0.0576312542,
-0.013141687,
-0.021265896,
-0.0028134102,
-0.0193616543,
-0.0148489783,
0.0134793175,
0.0041736914,
0.0229528695,
-0.0021364251,
-0.0422566459,
-0.0500455387,
-0.0403288007,
-0.0261072665,
0.0546344742,
-0.0230300836,
-0.0453578047,
-0.0367134847,
-0.0026659654,
-0.0345137753,
0.0483606718,
-0.0036952777,
-0.0327983722,
0.0315984488,
-0.0101253996,
0.0340573713,
0.0432779938,
0.0018614499,
0.0078532156,
0.0244006328,
-0.0040208912,
-0.0200153422,
-0.0062239622,
-0.0292600133,
0.0082214717,
-0.0550210476,
-0.0756853148,
-0.0306939743,
0.1117445976,
-0.0095981825,
-0.0117096798,
-0.0633947253,
-0.0189010669,
-0.0066700927,
-0.0013091607,
-0.0015189048,
-0.0017888229,
-0.0250872858,
0.0249976311,
-0.0484763421,
-0.0709569976,
0.0279527009,
-0.0659374297,
-0.0129799088,
-0.0484434478,
-0.0099037336,
-0.0251023397,
0.0329805948,
0.0354872607,
0.009337361,
0.0061249649,
-0.0163562205,
0.0087313224,
0.0084844017,
0.0116128689,
-0.0376668945,
0.0546290651,
-0.0283630565,
0.0106309801,
-0.0369679779,
-0.0106393015,
-0.0046364963,
0.0196215119,
-0.0012640256,
0.0186521672,
0.0430347137,
-0.0218110569,
-0.0352252685,
0.0345924832,
-0.0113566294,
0.0799184367,
-0.0357378349,
0.0145908492,
-0.0325900391,
0.0277354289,
0.0637600422,
-0.0099398708,
-0.010147715,
-0.0388528295,
-0.0032178017,
0.0216809325,
0.001953329,
0.0239791404,
-0.1047163308,
-0.0147285424,
0.0498753898,
-0.0020458521,
-0.0191611238,
0.0119205834,
0.0174304917,
-0.0457440875,
0.0375343822,
0.0925631896,
-0.0148477601,
-0.0389920771,
-0.0016228555,
0.0050317617,
0.0691033602,
0.0429120138,
0.0202082973,
-0.0664894879,
-0.00120174,
0.0335870087,
0.0033815585,
0.0147459982,
-0.0033565178,
-0.0050056325,
-0.1164806783,
0.0282696579,
0.0159293003,
-0.085964635,
-0.0116399536,
-0.042868603,
0.0111850565,
-0.0364078172,
-0.0034453198,
0.0432840735,
0.0096311765,
-0.008195553,
0.0254712719,
-0.0124576353,
-0.0598495081,
-0.0060656019,
-0.0275993142,
0.0572053008,
0.0299963448,
0.0159571692,
0.0079400949,
-0.0474152416,
0.0147835156,
0.0052369293,
0.0036762895,
-0.0127794556,
0.0673536062,
-0.0128815956,
0.0050333585,
-0.0154580204,
0.0255864095,
-0.0197922196,
0.0056581371,
-0.0435872525,
0.063537918,
0.0048489925,
-0.0107072685,
-0.0205138754,
-0.0072550918,
0.0052520819,
0.0446356013,
0.0127608906,
-0.0030757764,
-0.0388974547,
-0.0007968568,
0.0113711786,
-0.0297368281,
-0.0139286956,
-0.0241139755,
0.0087521328,
-0.0432789288,
-0.0343429074,
-0.022677226,
0.0163236838,
0.0677062199,
0.0241208579,
0.0092171188,
-0.024125034,
-0.0235741418,
-0.0561376661,
0.0702890977,
-0.0025195996,
0.0493084826,
-0.0887372121,
-0.0221121963,
0.005918134,
-0.0166041367,
-0.0155601902,
0.0259644408,
-0.0396769904,
-0.0785864964,
-0.0127718411,
0.060595803,
0.0267521832,
0.0534489006,
0.0046830727,
-0.0150088575,
0.0174422655,
0.0411340371,
-0.059777882,
0.0253938511,
0.028998727,
-0.0460363589,
-0.0287107639,
0.0013854194,
0.0093126548,
0.0131999282,
-0.0070536495,
0.0479974076,
0.0252820887,
-0.0492319651,
0.0298665706,
-0.021460006,
0.0494236313,
-0.0361700356,
-0.0080795586,
-0.0541854501,
0.0046058409,
-0.0106744617,
0.0438921712,
-0.0175028965,
-0.0143997259,
0.0632070899,
0.0164170805,
0.0216124151,
-0.0305741075,
0.0052823992,
0.0274790525,
-0.0308726355,
-0.0090199979,
0.0362210944,
0.0122220274,
-0.0045056459,
0.0081018405,
-0.0177078135,
-0.010410849,
-0.0427059457,
0.0462837331,
-0.0438555703,
0.0358169824,
-0.0047398643,
0.0020783604,
-0.018740572,
0.0395116396,
-0.0052206609,
0.0254891459,
-0.0751820728,
-0.0130774369,
0.0724159181,
0.0232106168,
0.0966724604,
-0.0042411699,
-0.0082515376,
-0.0409276709,
0.0175460055,
-0.0323424302,
-0.0087963343,
0.0267602205,
0.0158906672,
-0.0097763184,
-0.0363779217,
0.0339283571,
0.0188852903,
0.0524921194,
0.0078181997,
0.0040042433,
-0.0210452005,
-0.0149235362,
0.0410501659,
-0.0190600958,
-0.059909422,
-0.0510085672,
-0.0193132032,
-0.0455390327,
0.0076913256,
0.0542788543,
-0.0197804291,
-0.0059056734,
0.0309795178,
0.0420251302,
-0.0208005328,
-0.0372607894,
-0.0195217542,
0.0179883018,
-0.0318377465,
0.0114949103,
0.0029814586,
-6.612271069e-33,
-0.0236514583,
0.0399670042,
0.038817361,
-0.0287952423,
-0.0508727022,
-0.0108653009,
-0.0303725712,
-0.00990343,
0.0012081534,
-0.0215453338,
-0.0070804274,
-0.0307961609,
0.0319014527,
0.0242641345,
0.0029294165,
0.0283741876,
0.0632884949,
-0.0164396614,
-0.0247952268,
0.0095652547,
0.0286492258,
0.0574815832,
0.0956729203,
-0.0194607601,
0.0059195412,
-0.036794208,
-0.0137791559,
0.0086043105,
-0.0145953856,
0.0582809485,
-0.0531517528,
0.0235215686,
0.0263260379,
-0.0640512332,
-0.0194022693,
-0.0018865648,
-0.0477245413,
0.0022097642,
0.0577065945,
0.027117528,
-0.0613381006,
-0.0375260226,
0.0042763855,
-0.0029805922,
-0.0327540487,
-0.0195864644,
0.0104987351,
-0.0410753749,
-0.0413614139,
0.0132502923,
-0.0746052638,
0.0248600859,
0.0150914676,
0.0137663307,
0.0283055119,
0.010072384,
-0.006573501,
-0.0215777848,
-0.0337692127,
0.0359350741,
0.0112546775,
0.0935391039,
0.1047983244,
0.0746300295,
0.036784064,
0.0531526804,
0.0559704192,
-0.0234413631,
0.0192289688,
0.0290223192,
0.0654774159,
0.0097483369,
0.0431101322,
0.0472132303,
0.0494272932,
-0.0160646848,
-0.0011721021,
0.0190998428,
0.0211034287,
0.0156818423,
0.0226667542,
0.0216363948,
-0.0215287711,
-0.0047394037,
-0.0289705489,
-0.0560210012,
-0.0254451521,
-0.0356629491,
0.0416564047,
0.0122311115,
-0.0125562688,
-0.0023179683,
0.0548304319,
-0.0101673119,
0.0218733773,
0.029318843,
0.0063380147,
0.03795176,
-0.0280526839,
0.0193935465,
-0.0255876239,
-0.0451630093,
0.0312542617,
0.0032907492,
0.010975318,
-0.0179450456,
-0.0050367983,
0.0771617368,
-0.0464629531,
0.0271202233,
-0.0481184646,
0.0143104941,
-0.0173177887,
0.0596180521,
0.0221129712,
-0.0155935073,
-0.0135384714,
0.0064820782,
-0.0053655813,
0.0026545059,
-0.0191975664,
0.0057472452,
0.0179691203,
0.0427475609,
-0.0105616832,
0.0226636585,
-0.0632500648,
0.0598412715,
0.0266943313,
-0.0502109192,
-0.0178176668,
0.03167722,
2.796e-7,
0.0240428019,
0.0225545242,
0.0257132091,
-0.0027929486,
0.0156617071,
-0.0170217492,
-0.0437897481,
0.0049075317,
0.0372095406,
-0.0165932123,
0.0091586569,
-0.0136523861,
0.0505373329,
0.0049735247,
-0.0721259415,
-0.010394332,
-0.0611860044,
0.0308097918,
-0.0535424948,
0.0160439741,
-0.0264690556,
0.1382987648,
-0.0161144063,
-0.0293761324,
0.004520895,
0.0023742565,
0.0244884789,
-0.0232053306,
-0.0034499422,
0.0441263355,
0.0344535634,
-0.0129531324,
-0.0296374783,
0.0092562707,
-0.0039931005,
0.0210683923,
-0.029234482,
0.0781069249,
-0.0359195173,
-0.0035025508,
0.0427625366,
-0.0124524925,
-0.0415004678,
-0.083812885,
0.0042875707,
0.0384002291,
0.0036615967,
-0.0462827943,
-0.0563396439,
0.0012471331,
-0.0056550219,
-0.0562351011,
0.0246470235,
0.0031086169,
0.025979476,
-0.0352876224,
-0.0370319262,
-0.0187670086,
-0.0397752188,
-0.003259233,
-0.0545397326,
-0.0444576666,
-0.0415631793,
0.0075402251,
0.0368836001,
-0.0331087671,
-0.0029759305,
2.774035573e-34,
0.0259505548,
0.0094226468,
-0.0015311952,
0.0389468968,
0.0060324892,
-0.0443289429,
-0.0133336382,
0.0249967333,
-0.0231025722,
-0.0669784695,
-0.0447270349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11698v1 | Meta Reasoning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T16:14:11 | 2024-06-17T16:14:11 | Peizhong Gao, Ao Xie, Shaoguang Mao, Wenshan Wu, Yan Xia, Haipeng Mi, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Meta-Reasoning Prompting (MRP), a novel and efficient system
prompting method for large language models (LLMs) inspired by human
meta-reasoning. Traditional in-context learning-based reasoning techniques,
such as Tree-of-Thoughts, show promise but lack consistent state-of-the-art
performance across diverse tasks due to their specialized nature. MRP addresses
this limitation by guiding LLMs to dynamically select and apply different
reasoning methods based on the specific requirements of each task, optimizing
both performance and computational efficiency. With MRP, LLM reasoning operates
in two phases. Initially, the LLM identifies the most appropriate reasoning
method using task input cues and objective descriptions of available methods.
Subsequently, it applies the chosen method to complete the task. This dynamic
strategy mirrors human meta-reasoning, allowing the model to excel in a wide
range of problem domains. We evaluate the effectiveness of MRP through
comprehensive benchmarks. The results demonstrate that MRP achieves or
approaches state-of-the-art performance across diverse tasks. MRP represents a
significant advancement in enabling LLMs to identify cognitive challenges
across problems and leverage benefits across different reasoning approaches,
enhancing their ability to handle diverse and complex problem domains
efficiently. Every LLM deserves a Meta-Reasoning Prompting to unlock its full
potential and ensure adaptability in an ever-evolving landscape of challenges
and applications. | [
0.0702011809,
-0.0093215574,
-0.0105515067,
0.0311070159,
-0.06758333,
0.0410113037,
-0.0107189966,
-0.024876656,
-0.0265003983,
-0.045373641,
-0.0019037367,
0.0029533794,
0.0094499877,
0.0097405259,
-0.0095963506,
-0.0552255251,
0.0464099012,
-0.0906336978,
0.022115251,
-0.0255593304,
-0.0133219259,
0.0196491722,
-0.0207852889,
0.0350084752,
0.0083237113,
-0.0409092046,
-0.0266526788,
0.0172742847,
0.0061576432,
-0.0349915475,
-0.0194301866,
0.036409054,
0.0298806075,
0.0394892879,
0.0000025415,
-0.0533857644,
-0.0320428722,
-0.0196211692,
-0.0574634783,
-0.0385467,
0.0271616485,
0.0436529443,
-0.0074513867,
0.0450989902,
-0.0364294387,
0.0057662991,
0.0344781242,
0.0229370706,
0.051697623,
0.0427792445,
-0.0026516197,
-0.0038137701,
-0.0249268822,
0.002268777,
0.0259499531,
-0.0325216055,
0.0221942794,
-0.0057179984,
0.0412121341,
0.0037832903,
0.0134517476,
0.0305255931,
0.0314626582,
-0.002230084,
-0.0309561584,
0.036942821,
-0.0073786411,
-0.0084157502,
-0.0294208732,
0.0624545999,
-0.0037995176,
-0.0159947407,
-0.0064483737,
0.0048143426,
0.0036859862,
0.0325860828,
-0.0470379181,
0.0476589203,
-0.0405768603,
-0.0054641813,
-0.0022573639,
0.0092359744,
0.0265625957,
0.0306450706,
-0.0613176748,
0.0849281549,
0.0109567018,
-0.0371058397,
0.0360045172,
-0.0320736021,
-0.032293126,
-0.0631530285,
0.0013361261,
0.040674746,
-0.0602836497,
0.0380281731,
-0.0029271205,
-0.0167699791,
0.0024466382,
-0.0096652629,
0.0515695624,
0.0679249391,
0.0060437219,
0.0655815601,
-0.0240423623,
0.0267800204,
-0.0162959397,
0.0122520104,
-0.0316492245,
-0.0122104995,
-0.0921865106,
-0.0206718035,
-0.0332271494,
0.0500624254,
-0.0207736343,
-0.0046760594,
-0.0168149006,
0.0502662472,
0.006117336,
0.0189579129,
0.0267251916,
0.0009155007,
0.0195242073,
-0.0538696498,
-0.0490273125,
0.0104033286,
-0.0540430322,
0.0073945732,
0.0342802331,
-0.0166877955,
-0.0013451758,
-0.0026673058,
-0.0308718719,
-0.0327680372,
0.0217616297,
0.0521892123,
0.0156443492,
-0.0117179323,
-0.0594433583,
-0.0172205921,
-0.0257827044,
-0.0917965248,
0.0217990614,
-0.0765778571,
-0.001685498,
0.0257524773,
-0.0182420705,
0.017657822,
0.0165770799,
0.0225174408,
-0.0133738499,
0.0759348124,
-0.0323198102,
0.0305359308,
0.024615081,
0.0167574249,
-0.0533050522,
0.0783347338,
0.0353593938,
0.0318480134,
-0.013047521,
0.0405705795,
0.0025205533,
-0.0033783561,
0.0023485329,
-0.0249453485,
-0.016258819,
0.0041103079,
-0.0086953519,
0.017557336,
-0.0332793184,
0.0498970523,
-0.0067449058,
0.0225554463,
0.0454927385,
0.0638566986,
-0.0280754529,
-0.0039755106,
0.0411102735,
0.0007114377,
-0.00331297,
-0.0290472414,
-0.0705334693,
0.0635764003,
-0.0634718686,
-0.0057253093,
-0.0151930554,
0.0454662852,
-0.0252127852,
-0.042523399,
-0.0280327089,
0.0148571609,
-0.0343144909,
0.0555966683,
0.0362202749,
0.0060130861,
-0.0102255233,
0.0191767197,
0.0121874874,
-0.0142060602,
-0.0466445573,
-0.075672552,
0.0350387581,
0.0897905529,
0.051512707,
-0.0386062041,
-0.0453090481,
-0.0125609459,
0.0348404869,
0.0395697691,
0.0036314772,
-0.0171976183,
-0.01926638,
-0.0504967868,
-0.0211792029,
0.013787725,
-0.0089829108,
0.0064773606,
0.007814575,
-0.0307994131,
0.0035337287,
-0.0432874486,
-0.0113288248,
0.0171813592,
-0.028538892,
0.0093464553,
-0.0218608864,
0.0355818234,
-0.0066661621,
-0.0092260474,
0.0110872798,
0.0270316433,
0.0122230379,
-0.0380975269,
-0.0236317459,
0.0332470238,
-0.0718992278,
-0.0493281558,
0.0379142575,
0.0095611978,
-0.0377548672,
-0.018021455,
-0.0303539578,
-0.0417772047,
-0.0096720699,
-0.0071371864,
0.0526382178,
-0.0415424556,
0.0324819274,
-0.0020046118,
-0.0456581749,
-0.0327596739,
0.0864699185,
-0.0127247674,
-0.0120200235,
0.082709752,
-0.0245236736,
0.0099698417,
-0.0156803634,
-0.0213773511,
0.0473687425,
-0.020718066,
-0.0161047801,
-0.0100786658,
0.0088535314,
-0.0667246729,
-0.0099777039,
-0.080870524,
0.0002705026,
-0.0156280603,
0.0043789926,
-0.0014613497,
0.0101944124,
-0.0084602963,
-0.0088846404,
-0.0145555148,
0.0003638512,
0.0127199739,
0.0450985767,
0.0086917337,
-0.0069558104,
0.0104051279,
-0.0074240896,
-0.0067121293,
-0.0276974328,
0.0610199422,
-0.0069212611,
-0.0037526672,
-0.0264796596,
0.0042213732,
-0.0393484458,
0.0048649027,
-0.009412935,
-0.000439827,
0.0072632642,
-0.0526361093,
0.0651510879,
0.0678463727,
-0.0037849785,
-0.0104266834,
0.0699834526,
0.0010044316,
-0.0713491216,
0.0307624806,
0.0161995143,
0.0093363645,
-0.0022650643,
-0.0099021476,
-0.0268164687,
0.045471251,
-0.0164040085,
0.0005823592,
-0.0550863743,
0.051927235,
-0.0050570052,
-0.024939822,
-0.0724104568,
-0.0106435223,
0.0060558156,
0.0693788379,
-0.0463768169,
-0.0288037714,
0.0964126736,
0.0083620204,
-0.0017301167,
-0.0459436662,
0.0173266996,
-0.0181724392,
0.0693841204,
-0.0384758338,
0.0234951004,
0.0200410467,
-0.0078828922,
-0.0679995939,
-0.0282586943,
0.0249525309,
-0.0263119433,
0.0392934419,
-0.0722037628,
0.0172752142,
0.008651644,
-0.0612752549,
-0.0695830435,
0.0240978207,
-0.0584432743,
0.0067242826,
-0.0393496305,
-0.006066415,
-0.0145324115,
-0.0069918046,
0.0326621234,
0.017331617,
-0.0127763804,
-0.0344608426,
-0.0115326745,
0.0050847982,
0.032802213,
0.0167801827,
0.024360111,
-0.0081573343,
0.0869619623,
0.0326641314,
0.0513531715,
-0.0026696401,
-0.0348087698,
0.0312811993,
0.0247670319,
-0.0059709162,
-0.0062839105,
0.0431316644,
0.0093971742,
-0.0840456411,
-0.006512641,
0.1274382919,
0.0748367608,
-0.054966379,
-0.0272265524,
-0.0591964945,
0.0454300642,
0.047600206,
0.0459331721,
-0.0401833393,
-0.0641364306,
0.0465012603,
-0.0043774582,
-0.0058572222,
-0.0309389904,
-0.0153963408,
-0.0873927251,
0.0423175432,
-0.0220452417,
-0.0038720414,
-0.0153716654,
-0.0288589168,
0.0082494104,
0.0358685218,
-0.0336875021,
0.0367028676,
-0.0147064421,
-0.0008930246,
0.0237997714,
0.0004291662,
-0.0560462475,
0.0497707874,
-0.009279564,
0.0468620025,
0.0762767419,
0.0143752377,
0.0486179851,
-0.0543550663,
0.0639926568,
0.0303303599,
0.0251249988,
-0.0444770455,
0.0377630107,
0.0111573394,
0.0211139582,
-0.0343621112,
0.0215014182,
-0.034955889,
-0.0421022139,
0.0142942136,
0.1310058534,
-0.0238944925,
0.0090740081,
-0.0111115836,
0.0061970195,
0.0006150306,
0.0831577778,
0.026977649,
-0.0411842056,
-0.0373653062,
-0.0358345732,
-0.0705259964,
-0.0251383204,
0.0058727842,
0.0417983793,
0.0421059839,
-0.0013082532,
-0.0573508851,
0.0097315116,
0.0642214715,
0.0454191603,
0.0197750479,
0.0072080968,
0.0006096521,
0.034599971,
-0.0466291867,
-0.0021845319,
-0.057789173,
0.0191682931,
-0.0478536487,
0.0131312748,
0.047695864,
-0.0503182076,
-0.0191745907,
-0.0057334853,
-0.0576492287,
-0.0636503249,
-0.0313219205,
0.0483805351,
0.0279034954,
0.036243856,
-0.0098022725,
-0.055444926,
0.0405311696,
0.0024692432,
-0.0115789706,
-0.0284853578,
0.0501673818,
0.0158808958,
0.0004582052,
0.0521577597,
-0.035509713,
0.0265334416,
0.0216001552,
0.03214458,
-0.0159290135,
0.0176854841,
0.0493591055,
0.0246195085,
0.0075252508,
-0.0140227498,
-0.0394166969,
-0.0395519882,
0.0243277103,
0.004408868,
-0.061263524,
-0.023763746,
0.0504963994,
-0.0014706922,
-0.0175286252,
0.0200413521,
-0.023037333,
0.0006266347,
-0.0119800605,
0.0389511697,
0.0081719616,
-0.0019110284,
0.0633269846,
0.0471487381,
0.0000130592,
-0.000327784,
0.0104200942,
0.014918793,
0.0235870536,
-0.0532989129,
0.1107000411,
0.0389399268,
-0.031301368,
-0.063997224,
0.018486809,
-0.0770274177,
-0.0884421468,
0.0522893518,
0.0425640047,
0.0492042862,
0.0305861402,
-0.0177581552,
-0.0415032394,
-0.0027077349,
0.0038797469,
0.024536211,
0.0400123298,
-0.0215299092,
0.0118836034,
0.0443080813,
-0.0131313074,
-0.0089292722,
0.0284839235,
-0.0547860973,
0.0120997392,
0.0139581123,
-0.0139677795,
-0.0285085738,
-0.0244245995,
-0.055059664,
0.0321992338,
-0.0160572212,
0.044102259,
-0.0955920666,
-0.0483641364,
0.0196790285,
0.0211765189,
-0.0050956691,
0.0060671624,
0.0496438406,
0.0591088198,
0.0059767845,
-0.0459710248,
-0.0164442267,
-0.0070812004,
-0.0249534827,
-0.0104703708,
-0.0404719748,
-6.850253574e-33,
-0.0022870961,
-0.0371769071,
0.0642894432,
-0.0252617933,
0.0050908392,
-0.0424481519,
-0.0456930585,
0.0101412032,
-0.028981084,
0.0078896098,
-0.0440182239,
0.0162164029,
0.0089913337,
0.0235261079,
0.0190388113,
-0.0181077216,
0.027194608,
0.0068397783,
-0.0352631174,
0.0132494569,
0.0543830879,
0.0120454747,
0.0022170278,
-0.0239294041,
-0.0071811061,
0.0416513458,
0.010449525,
0.0465599373,
-0.0658659637,
0.0315261483,
-0.0089630382,
0.0222340543,
0.0344518125,
-0.026347518,
-0.0056882561,
0.0257504769,
-0.0624843761,
-0.030316785,
0.0494362004,
-0.0418371558,
-0.0365769193,
-0.0357332081,
-0.0172391906,
0.0075865933,
0.0197419412,
-0.0123852687,
0.0282589179,
-0.0430074148,
-0.0223742258,
0.0134717301,
-0.0452830791,
0.0137348138,
-0.0165919624,
-0.0193547029,
0.036457099,
0.0676879361,
-0.0247208867,
0.0332709588,
-0.0085690012,
0.0506263524,
-0.0021464124,
0.0075727981,
0.0763173997,
0.0301538389,
-0.0133698434,
0.0463770851,
-0.0010595309,
0.0113912374,
-0.002555151,
-0.0003912872,
0.0024539945,
0.0610712655,
0.0319957212,
0.0357052758,
0.0381449014,
0.0048978571,
-0.0455372855,
-0.0090273898,
0.0151551953,
0.0341009125,
0.0556758009,
0.0063150199,
-0.0410456806,
-0.0348828807,
-0.0581725128,
0.0198922399,
-0.0708381534,
-0.0087133069,
0.0546105318,
-0.003903413,
-0.0284429602,
-0.026692709,
0.0310598202,
-0.0204460323,
0.0123623079,
0.0246823113,
-0.0034237853,
0.0105543714,
-0.0119625665,
0.0426354036,
-0.043533612,
-0.020938389,
0.014741444,
0.002292532,
0.000066164,
0.0105153313,
0.0334411338,
0.0088885641,
-0.0419870205,
-0.0061047417,
-0.0747862533,
0.0309951194,
-0.0041702231,
-0.0124292197,
0.0124586532,
0.0270334054,
-0.0038041938,
0.0194230359,
0.0000090796,
-0.0432481244,
-0.0413425006,
0.0140195992,
-0.0354437269,
0.0075954404,
-0.0141362343,
0.0047217715,
-0.0550485291,
-0.00204544,
0.0285747033,
-0.0461752377,
-0.006991467,
0.0379381031,
3.145e-7,
0.0034735457,
0.0602659397,
-0.0067591849,
0.0027467357,
0.0184177421,
0.022946449,
-0.0249236915,
-0.0544306189,
0.0515234657,
-0.03910283,
0.0107938712,
0.065705359,
0.0511046089,
0.0395613872,
-0.0741365999,
0.0072098156,
-0.0353127532,
-0.0204452053,
-0.0440434255,
0.0064859297,
0.0554252751,
0.0476604663,
0.0104238102,
-0.0182406735,
0.0153886368,
-0.0302104689,
0.0448190309,
-0.0369269922,
0.0303418301,
-0.0062706321,
-0.0186719056,
0.0072009149,
0.0007856595,
0.0407566018,
0.0210381802,
-0.0003034706,
-0.0214592088,
0.0465375185,
-0.0032557903,
-0.0230940282,
-0.0232503507,
-0.0055818595,
0.0131568294,
-0.0320268422,
0.0827125385,
-0.0591325797,
-0.0072236806,
-0.0248480234,
0.0423229598,
-0.004640331,
-0.0236946624,
-0.0204477124,
-0.028072793,
0.0109951803,
-0.0129170744,
-0.0232879687,
-0.0071960702,
-0.087215282,
-0.0114003429,
0.0044238856,
-0.0251597017,
-0.0404382907,
-0.0501352809,
-0.0167014804,
0.0550955795,
-0.0719516054,
-0.007025599,
3.195158261e-34,
0.0279909763,
-0.0069963289,
0.0070447773,
0.0392329395,
0.0128473807,
0.0108952643,
-0.0630864203,
0.0020128386,
0.0349093676,
-0.092154637,
-0.037411239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11695v1 | Optimizing Instructions and Demonstrations for Multi-Stage Language Model Programs | 2024-06-17T16:12:03 | 2024-06-17T16:12:03 | Krista Opsahl-Ong, Michael J Ryan, Josh Purtell, David Broman, Christopher Potts, Matei Zaharia, Omar Khattab | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language Model Programs, i.e. sophisticated pipelines of modular language
model (LM) calls, are increasingly advancing NLP tasks, but they require
crafting prompts that are jointly effective for all modules. We study prompt
optimization for LM programs, i.e. how to update these prompts to maximize a
downstream metric without access to module-level labels or gradients. To make
this tractable, we factorize our problem into optimizing the free-form
instructions and few-shot demonstrations of every module and introduce several
strategies to craft task-grounded instructions and navigate credit assignment
across modules. Our strategies include (i) program- and data-aware techniques
for proposing effective instructions, (ii) a stochastic mini-batch evaluation
function for learning a surrogate model of our objective, and (iii) a
meta-optimization procedure in which we refine how LMs construct proposals over
time. Using these insights we develop MIPRO, a novel optimizer that outperforms
baselines on five of six diverse LM programs using a best-in-class open-source
model (Llama-3-8B), by as high as 12.9% accuracy. We will release our new
optimizers and benchmark in DSPy at https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy | [
0.0373185165,
0.0391003489,
-0.01657735,
0.0185632501,
-0.03594248,
-0.0000626721,
0.023765238,
-0.0186368991,
0.0162031353,
-0.0309592243,
-0.0389105789,
-0.0079158656,
0.0343467519,
0.0027603139,
0.050002303,
-0.073420845,
0.0392459594,
-0.0701303482,
-0.0166966114,
0.0076063792,
-0.0034678574,
-0.0017027006,
-0.0364280269,
0.0616203174,
-0.0131301358,
-0.0195772368,
-0.0117211463,
0.0108451089,
0.0007449051,
-0.0564973801,
0.0224709846,
0.072363168,
-0.0013094223,
0.0076463073,
0.0000022709,
-0.0283305049,
0.0003624171,
-0.0039834888,
-0.0425790325,
0.0281979255,
0.0664850026,
0.0088444147,
-0.0002940428,
0.0423286185,
-0.016000839,
-0.0011949833,
0.0459802076,
0.0014085789,
0.0547440797,
0.0650962219,
0.017682841,
0.0133328615,
-0.0157786123,
-0.0226914231,
0.0056785666,
-0.0141638312,
0.0137123102,
-0.0039705154,
0.0499958396,
0.0036624051,
-0.0104597835,
0.0364915244,
0.0231061541,
-0.0177171864,
0.022399025,
0.0439906269,
0.015235112,
-0.0274402425,
-0.0479383804,
0.0695582777,
-0.0207771696,
-0.0425913259,
-0.0032332921,
-0.0358661599,
-0.0152900005,
-0.0171826743,
-0.0590536818,
0.0371087082,
0.0252840277,
-0.0095326649,
0.0393464975,
-0.0246278979,
0.0434132554,
-0.003830089,
0.0122440122,
0.0864827782,
0.0289616697,
-0.029467836,
0.0146563426,
0.0112526817,
-0.0019092215,
-0.0795070976,
0.0010869412,
0.0468058065,
-0.0442999862,
0.0393831693,
-0.0226962641,
-0.0306358282,
0.0154300714,
-0.0142236054,
0.099379532,
0.0340006612,
0.0067145652,
0.0374351554,
-0.0090017673,
0.0710206404,
0.0192110687,
0.0260082837,
-0.0323533453,
0.0225147214,
-0.0637051314,
0.009574187,
-0.0457713418,
0.0232401453,
-0.029525701,
0.00457248,
0.0009545243,
0.0397910252,
-0.016443843,
0.0205395613,
0.0270355213,
-0.0211671498,
-0.0545506291,
0.023270864,
-0.022232186,
0.030105589,
-0.0535730496,
-0.0168527588,
0.0101419874,
-0.0178182516,
-0.063113533,
0.031591475,
-0.0275638606,
-0.0204444937,
0.0325809307,
0.067996718,
-0.0149692558,
-0.0500789694,
-0.0041229916,
-0.0227961764,
0.0001706895,
-0.0714441165,
0.0155554786,
-0.0736564323,
0.0327114724,
0.0170509834,
0.0121826101,
-0.0117410924,
-0.0021595247,
0.0166341923,
-0.0112852082,
0.0668988302,
0.0343304388,
0.0213230811,
-0.0063524856,
0.0027688292,
-0.032859657,
0.0820920393,
0.0260931049,
0.0436231159,
0.036356125,
0.0087816101,
0.0331214517,
0.0621895827,
0.021448927,
0.0416061915,
0.0092533743,
-0.0052171205,
0.0441220738,
0.009116183,
0.0225130189,
0.0185389165,
-0.0119736195,
0.0516747013,
0.0251806956,
0.031401936,
0.0072528995,
-0.0706109479,
0.0819410011,
0.0073026801,
0.0204760991,
-0.0089089191,
-0.0600866303,
0.0331415534,
-0.0312753282,
-0.0009980144,
0.0189578328,
0.0272676833,
-0.0240748618,
-0.0128482552,
-0.0361025929,
-0.0070561054,
0.0113858264,
0.0286741797,
0.0095045306,
0.0269634463,
-0.0684687495,
0.0430517755,
0.0477082469,
-0.0196313895,
0.0126221757,
-0.0503567941,
0.0181870162,
0.0699387342,
0.0452679545,
-0.0288419016,
-0.0172330271,
-0.0081899632,
0.0151367662,
0.0494523644,
0.0350907929,
-0.047875464,
0.0382523611,
-0.0250823759,
-0.0216706917,
-0.034036018,
0.0282024723,
0.0287304688,
0.0665235445,
-0.0398005992,
-0.0027423969,
-0.0353325717,
-0.0068470309,
0.0609069318,
-0.0646202788,
-0.0294036921,
0.0061576017,
0.0011749162,
0.0307284873,
0.0066367923,
0.0124392165,
-0.0036551633,
0.0317986757,
-0.0086933002,
0.0099963993,
-0.026479302,
-0.0347622596,
-0.0799994692,
0.0300535653,
0.0071756197,
-0.0160929039,
0.0136541026,
-0.0331109129,
-0.0395273454,
0.0343062989,
-0.030340679,
0.0094243512,
-0.0169117954,
0.0389024541,
0.0080720941,
0.0011536494,
-0.0346944109,
0.0334326886,
-0.0040714997,
0.0384490825,
0.0726329237,
0.0244634375,
0.0094545064,
-0.0303657018,
-0.0059293844,
0.0219180807,
-0.008601795,
0.0118452702,
0.0217837933,
0.0615945905,
-0.0191845521,
-0.0442077741,
-0.0889051855,
0.0321629681,
-0.0377388895,
0.0193721522,
0.0274034068,
0.0015289984,
-0.0066538169,
-0.0010898927,
0.0073195565,
-0.0187083501,
-0.0317223445,
0.019023668,
0.0223872419,
0.0272715427,
-0.0581387952,
-0.0272724759,
-0.0096643586,
-0.0098022046,
0.0444596969,
-0.0173453987,
0.0242219176,
-0.0537776202,
-0.0246049166,
0.0052762562,
0.0124901924,
-0.0040796837,
-0.0020051422,
0.0222172141,
-0.0009000373,
0.0622680634,
0.0438285917,
-0.0459871888,
0.0405141711,
0.064630948,
-0.0034555073,
-0.077409409,
0.0237312187,
-0.0201400407,
0.0009295991,
-0.0184786171,
-0.0633672625,
0.0157194119,
0.111681506,
0.0006214357,
0.0056836656,
-0.0597987808,
-0.0119719254,
-0.0264417119,
-0.0450465493,
0.0211800896,
-0.0019509937,
-0.0220157895,
0.0056668539,
-0.0172498841,
-0.0608800836,
0.0841592401,
-0.0615565218,
-0.0360427164,
-0.0464962833,
-0.0083914921,
-0.0350181758,
0.056655962,
-0.0008763324,
-0.0096550463,
-0.0043922858,
-0.0514970608,
-0.0293742325,
0.0265732761,
0.0262574721,
-0.0134212347,
0.0337232836,
-0.072292462,
0.0068727727,
-0.0188936498,
-0.0265566651,
-0.0375962667,
0.013601223,
0.0032320498,
0.0433260351,
0.0039800601,
-0.0049146344,
-0.0201658029,
0.0003654232,
0.0393847004,
0.0425296687,
-0.0257152673,
0.0137339411,
-0.0385725498,
-0.0307033546,
0.0129931392,
-0.0053399573,
-0.0026947302,
-0.0585366599,
0.0202644318,
-0.0149334269,
0.0714988708,
0.0184140019,
-0.0195076969,
0.0052135913,
0.0493772849,
-0.0527521111,
-0.0088462308,
0.0599283949,
0.0634643957,
-0.0679475591,
-0.0300985053,
0.0951316357,
0.0630754605,
-0.0526268259,
0.0256194528,
0.0132833682,
0.0413125679,
0.0329368003,
0.0482086129,
-0.0681976825,
-0.0347499251,
0.017771462,
0.046932511,
-0.0058342176,
-0.0081517287,
-0.0357855931,
-0.1292761713,
0.0214882754,
-0.0060061994,
-0.042459026,
-0.0145303952,
-0.0762131587,
-0.0046617333,
-0.0009119897,
0.0437735207,
0.0138736861,
-0.0351611041,
0.0240741577,
0.0088042794,
-0.016170349,
-0.0354471728,
0.0132169919,
-0.0026538672,
0.0707780942,
0.0517981052,
-0.0181959029,
0.0047639636,
0.0102241281,
0.0541299544,
-0.0363904983,
-0.015213782,
-0.05660142,
0.0155550409,
0.0020024902,
-0.0020350011,
0.0270110182,
0.018461477,
-0.039950192,
-0.0294578504,
-0.0051046722,
0.0641164929,
-0.0187595319,
-0.0017670499,
-0.013170206,
0.0198398158,
0.0474932157,
0.0847760439,
0.0394352712,
-0.0496382788,
-0.0216494761,
-0.0390070826,
-0.044837255,
-0.0622732379,
-0.0095361685,
0.0034206351,
-0.0186634511,
0.0225992724,
-0.0613361262,
-0.0407788306,
0.0776884928,
0.0292731486,
0.0190381017,
-0.0084013268,
-0.0439522155,
-0.0242054444,
-0.0369320586,
0.0327428244,
-0.044752188,
0.0325080045,
-0.0852955356,
-0.0556728914,
0.015878519,
-0.0330931544,
-0.0114377281,
0.0473557226,
-0.1180887148,
-0.0751744062,
-0.0257687978,
0.0778108686,
0.0175792407,
0.0454888493,
-0.044097241,
-0.0478903055,
0.0310140979,
0.0350285023,
-0.0069683488,
0.0060264976,
0.024074439,
0.0049550273,
-0.010179529,
0.016069416,
-0.0295217689,
0.0129407756,
0.0316932909,
0.0740296692,
0.0188467689,
-0.0231551062,
0.0227930173,
0.0282020662,
0.0231493022,
-0.0277455412,
-0.0640611872,
-0.0542408861,
0.0061351466,
-0.0151505787,
-0.0213949531,
-0.0410302095,
0.0123099172,
-0.0039990204,
-0.0167972464,
0.0184864737,
-0.0028890108,
-0.0335812084,
0.059793368,
-0.0261199102,
0.0353949331,
-0.0193721354,
-0.0096073942,
0.0065574558,
0.0109695047,
-0.0171191115,
0.0085367765,
0.0068324883,
0.0176358949,
-0.0325846486,
0.0468867235,
0.0078543723,
-0.00250281,
-0.0186898988,
0.0327268317,
-0.0312603414,
-0.0365403183,
-0.0359319709,
0.0512278154,
0.0562466308,
0.0049799006,
0.0637241304,
-0.0490314141,
0.0018165782,
-0.0083571794,
0.0222267397,
0.0020245793,
-0.0588924922,
0.038593173,
0.0419848114,
0.0075685885,
-0.0179974828,
0.0638355389,
0.0125153223,
0.037455719,
0.0170943514,
0.0366971381,
-0.0538856983,
-0.0604804195,
0.0308439806,
0.0004483692,
-0.037952289,
0.0074669127,
-0.0560660698,
-0.0390037857,
-0.0339678898,
0.0108386716,
-0.0361128747,
-0.0151028438,
0.0439492762,
0.033147756,
-0.0128256492,
-0.0125981234,
-0.0447592996,
-0.0196546409,
0.0354324989,
-0.0508244708,
-0.0077104042,
-6.763865024e-33,
-0.0635377318,
-0.0272346344,
0.0333711095,
0.013146095,
-0.0110577475,
-0.0009217758,
-0.0615962222,
0.0290028583,
-0.0011603798,
-0.0206782799,
-0.0260558613,
-0.0167404786,
0.017339116,
-0.0067337765,
-0.0035227959,
-0.0003704302,
0.0331594609,
-0.0036963834,
-0.0749903172,
0.0247448143,
-0.0118031986,
0.0071004224,
0.0538135208,
-0.0073694442,
0.0353485756,
0.0198117495,
-0.0428443588,
-0.0073832506,
-0.0128238872,
0.0564859137,
-0.0192224886,
0.0298203211,
0.0164648239,
-0.091574721,
-0.023399245,
-0.0024023154,
-0.036130745,
-0.0469843112,
0.0309870727,
0.0057018567,
-0.0671335906,
-0.050706666,
0.0208431575,
-0.0173969474,
-0.037457902,
0.0184841622,
0.0270831212,
0.0034924641,
-0.027162049,
0.0173061211,
-0.0661896095,
-0.0042165807,
0.0131063722,
-0.032060504,
0.020847192,
0.0297529567,
0.0087699471,
-0.0013104418,
-0.0009019389,
0.0272268467,
0.0188714582,
0.0590273552,
0.0745595992,
0.0283623338,
0.0047981776,
0.0190578662,
0.0136177512,
0.0224742368,
0.0393976793,
-0.0025336696,
0.0484322459,
0.0085048936,
0.0460064486,
-0.0136400228,
0.012164237,
0.0251429901,
-0.016420573,
0.0213783383,
0.0654238835,
0.0033730543,
0.0200870354,
0.0043643317,
-0.0227225069,
-0.0172335524,
-0.0810263976,
-0.0070429128,
-0.0285241567,
-0.0270385668,
0.0319963321,
0.0406919718,
-0.0504106618,
-0.0037778958,
0.0323384441,
-0.022403324,
-0.0310053639,
-0.0167674795,
-0.0092676505,
0.0475734472,
0.0118184658,
0.03571954,
-0.0629215315,
-0.047552038,
0.0424686559,
-0.0358988866,
0.0268936753,
0.0205858704,
0.0059116618,
0.0366576724,
-0.0651386231,
0.0107072899,
-0.0555966161,
0.0433835238,
-0.0051748627,
0.0457103401,
0.0271769017,
0.0000997818,
-0.0155358016,
0.0243742503,
0.0295640286,
-0.04388915,
-0.0277062356,
0.0193824712,
-0.0125993602,
0.0228798594,
-0.0404615141,
0.02141295,
-0.0494840257,
-0.03126904,
0.0235170685,
-0.0346268639,
-0.0331907123,
0.0170714241,
2.902e-7,
0.0264056325,
0.0686482862,
0.0058021303,
0.0783459544,
0.0033682105,
0.0170063693,
-0.0536088571,
0.0045668576,
0.001916268,
-0.0369590968,
-0.0242407527,
0.0193755031,
0.0384322666,
0.020208165,
-0.0966748521,
0.0246332083,
0.019052038,
0.0262535065,
-0.0743211806,
-0.0280903131,
-0.0225370266,
0.0789766163,
0.0109748058,
0.0053438833,
-0.0287880767,
-0.0194607712,
0.037833564,
-0.0099721039,
-0.0132820439,
0.0449885167,
0.0115098571,
0.0288535506,
0.0024594849,
0.0161639247,
-0.035716258,
-0.0183590297,
-0.0151753966,
0.0897548497,
0.0182059072,
-0.0735514089,
0.0239527114,
-0.0174781661,
0.0120587219,
-0.045260217,
0.046222914,
-0.0175240207,
0.0050970512,
-0.0329826064,
0.0057253423,
-0.0042439243,
-0.0051035285,
-0.0289967861,
-0.0175203513,
0.0507769585,
0.0095163779,
0.0025667252,
-0.0351079777,
-0.0480720997,
-0.0452243648,
-0.028379323,
-0.027093837,
-0.0498625189,
-0.0214230288,
0.0049230312,
-0.0397980735,
-0.1145429015,
-0.0239645019,
3.596381344e-34,
0.0457465611,
-0.0345055275,
0.0275103301,
0.028251674,
0.0214668363,
-0.0036657858,
-0.0333983861,
0.0090523716,
0.0193085074,
-0.0758900568,
-0.0392270125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11687v1 | Tokenization Falling Short: The Curse of Tokenization | 2024-06-17T16:05:32 | 2024-06-17T16:05:32 | Yekun Chai, Yewei Fang, Qiwei Peng, Xuhong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models typically tokenize raw text into sequences of subword
identifiers from a predefined vocabulary, a process inherently sensitive to
typographical errors, length variations, and largely oblivious to the internal
structure of tokens-issues we term the curse of tokenization. In this study, we
delve into these drawbacks and demonstrate that large language models (LLMs)
remain susceptible to these problems. This study systematically investigates
these challenges and their impact on LLMs through three critical research
questions: (1) complex problem solving, (2) token structure probing, and (3)
resilience to typographical variation. Our findings reveal that scaling model
parameters can mitigate the issue of tokenization; however, LLMs still suffer
from biases induced by typos and other text format variations. Our experiments
show that subword regularization such as BPE-dropout can mitigate this issue.
We will release our code and data to facilitate further research. | [
0.0479512587,
0.0592849962,
-0.0381114744,
0.0461973548,
-0.0620726719,
0.0004419893,
0.0072395033,
0.0347651504,
-0.0232214909,
-0.0399049409,
0.007456569,
-0.0547516495,
-0.0074749533,
0.0698556527,
0.0419391543,
-0.0632068589,
0.0562358573,
-0.053982988,
0.0353786983,
0.0184533745,
0.0273009595,
-0.0015143069,
0.0206801165,
0.054515481,
-0.0400101095,
-0.0093258573,
-0.0003775756,
0.0323066227,
-0.0216100644,
-0.0123374276,
-0.0076855398,
0.0361550488,
-0.0064823343,
0.0722199455,
0.0000019828,
-0.0479801148,
-0.0377536602,
-0.0091180904,
-0.0031772794,
0.0428959802,
0.060458038,
-0.03459692,
-0.0206718575,
0.0443951488,
0.016603725,
-0.020822674,
0.0419449285,
0.0413477197,
0.0191882141,
0.0445320718,
-0.0178570319,
0.0267125946,
0.0071247811,
-0.0171488039,
-0.0246430673,
-0.0397288203,
0.031733688,
-0.0126592638,
0.0347592495,
-0.0230218936,
-0.0143957874,
0.0053557679,
-0.0088387504,
-0.0044189142,
-0.0053885868,
0.0298803449,
-0.0237882584,
-0.0357071236,
-0.0172557514,
0.0423845313,
-0.0361994505,
-0.0142159434,
0.0161628891,
-0.0309606101,
-0.010752731,
-0.0249811877,
-0.0492745526,
0.0279414132,
-0.0010649514,
0.0066560134,
0.004294191,
-0.0212324653,
0.0457563102,
-0.0077543091,
-0.0425559655,
0.0806862041,
0.0277939364,
-0.030380886,
-0.0541469194,
-0.0223625321,
-0.0335931852,
-0.0997996777,
0.0528862476,
0.0064097797,
-0.0570852198,
0.0187344253,
-0.0441363379,
-0.0469770581,
0.0198590457,
-0.011635243,
0.0136459358,
0.0154065946,
0.0077910898,
0.014124291,
0.0078576505,
0.0648190603,
-0.0129095893,
0.0113859829,
-0.04733558,
-0.0085815731,
-0.0270737931,
-0.0440792739,
-0.059972994,
0.0584208332,
-0.0170238297,
-0.0335834138,
0.0058036521,
0.0282460749,
0.0245904811,
-0.0086112879,
-0.0144933378,
-0.0249224659,
-0.0192434806,
-0.0186487325,
-0.0012775747,
0.025847191,
-0.0419099778,
0.002495005,
-0.0001019999,
-0.0327332243,
-0.0065080673,
0.0093209026,
0.0181226712,
-0.0475027412,
-0.0195635278,
0.081626609,
-0.0079396935,
-0.0262483843,
-0.0240717269,
-0.0200266689,
-0.0241466891,
-0.0442834049,
-0.0613950528,
-0.0794497281,
0.0048620822,
0.0271216948,
-0.0132467682,
-0.0590328388,
-0.002466453,
0.0022244942,
-0.0465990901,
0.0709491298,
-0.0072626113,
0.0137615353,
0.0314763598,
-0.0051933234,
0.0208108611,
0.0730357915,
0.0581848361,
0.0366151184,
0.0592231527,
-0.0106901089,
0.0058065499,
0.0766273215,
-0.0161079653,
-0.0083183665,
-0.0431789197,
-0.0303353779,
0.0221237354,
0.0460526012,
0.0271340758,
0.1127360761,
-0.0115258433,
0.0355400331,
0.0350352153,
0.0979420617,
-0.0112317577,
0.0244578049,
0.0237614084,
0.0028684102,
-0.0218483247,
0.0128079699,
-0.0316096582,
-0.0245312657,
0.0162731353,
0.0065365536,
0.0304204766,
0.0421227515,
-0.012493995,
-0.0434614718,
-0.0623223707,
0.0077042631,
0.011706139,
-0.0485169142,
0.0455099903,
-0.0092468439,
-0.0523020737,
0.068434976,
0.005954897,
-0.0422986783,
0.020441521,
-0.0510144792,
0.020498028,
0.0739575997,
0.0843219832,
-0.0371203981,
-0.0124428039,
0.0073582768,
0.0278062038,
0.0384469591,
0.0384195559,
-0.0232011788,
-0.0102212178,
-0.032052841,
-0.0079691745,
0.0125725493,
0.0133695528,
0.0039628563,
-0.0134518687,
-0.0078416914,
0.003293633,
-0.0712873936,
-0.030843908,
0.0404319428,
-0.041131068,
-0.0138497707,
-0.0169028156,
-0.0049966001,
0.0137573052,
0.0030875797,
-0.024261333,
0.0490278341,
0.0122656748,
-0.0439995117,
-0.01836868,
-0.0082407491,
-0.0146573372,
0.0142153343,
0.0672228634,
0.0089530759,
0.0124876099,
-0.0045531131,
-0.0019136484,
-0.0488466173,
0.0470909663,
-0.0332751945,
0.0834799483,
-0.0008515383,
0.064054206,
-0.0251459125,
-0.0193005726,
-0.0608582757,
0.0279531088,
-0.0016255195,
0.0178520046,
-0.0207103007,
-0.0228381716,
0.0281441472,
-0.0266379528,
-0.0273311753,
0.0355255678,
-0.0167831723,
-0.0044987476,
0.0342749096,
0.0053011244,
-0.0232575238,
-0.0417052768,
-0.0773397237,
0.0076532615,
-0.0061126151,
0.0246408377,
-0.0026213906,
0.0521529987,
-0.0318109691,
0.0115712974,
0.0109076267,
-0.0454946831,
-0.0159661137,
0.032529857,
0.0558801666,
0.0107140783,
-0.0330339782,
-0.0688804463,
-0.0299933385,
-0.0359103903,
0.0383224525,
-0.0061353035,
-0.0179053415,
-0.0587289184,
0.0195238553,
-0.0303346738,
0.0219458602,
0.0118463561,
-0.0355746634,
0.0115695717,
-0.009104237,
0.0905019939,
0.0339455679,
-0.0121746436,
0.0324885696,
0.0344817974,
-0.032444872,
-0.0520429052,
-0.0095281899,
0.0316773094,
0.0060513602,
-0.0080978367,
-0.0637253076,
-0.0070610833,
0.0931273922,
-0.008160051,
0.0078981295,
-0.0440885238,
0.037296243,
-0.0454187989,
-0.0154688163,
0.0023011151,
-0.0338646397,
-0.027238518,
0.0351148099,
-0.029232014,
-0.0612259917,
0.0640770197,
-0.0500613265,
0.0217519589,
-0.038082242,
0.0227357484,
-0.0425021201,
0.0523656048,
0.0027863083,
0.0118630761,
0.0020820296,
-0.0618257746,
-0.0352580324,
0.0023540244,
-0.0123799983,
-0.0060738535,
0.0443174988,
-0.0478032008,
0.0201750882,
0.0017954177,
-0.0471031256,
-0.0178735815,
-0.0258631986,
-0.0524423867,
0.0220444892,
0.0823814943,
-0.0110752806,
-0.0292387716,
0.0444644839,
0.0170477293,
0.0349470228,
-0.0109679447,
0.0165401492,
-0.0262784883,
0.0351572968,
0.03974168,
-0.0357766598,
0.0442069769,
-0.0438617319,
0.0044635097,
0.0368944108,
0.0744429156,
-0.0174652152,
-0.0107082613,
-0.0289391205,
0.0370531753,
-0.0585971922,
-0.0467920527,
0.0007696216,
0.0614314191,
-0.0314588994,
-0.0413888656,
0.1320404559,
0.0557107888,
-0.0378612205,
0.0358602703,
-0.0521161892,
0.0835784301,
0.0170123763,
0.0188683122,
-0.0399630889,
-0.0214179587,
0.0490095168,
-0.0084135039,
0.0033438366,
-0.0342231244,
0.0051219291,
-0.0982405543,
0.012920971,
0.0249423198,
-0.0298871361,
0.0012081459,
-0.0382127278,
0.0048197196,
-0.0036681695,
0.05829335,
0.0451003648,
-0.0388450772,
0.0009284898,
0.0387817174,
-0.0590791926,
-0.0087591559,
0.0033755498,
-0.0606942028,
0.0325645879,
0.0614114888,
0.0051557184,
-0.0147425514,
0.004494546,
0.0924333632,
0.0316300169,
0.0165852141,
-0.0392262712,
-0.0062868712,
-0.0043506105,
-0.0041395961,
0.0093024988,
0.0076090144,
-0.03629601,
-0.0354643241,
0.0132023459,
0.0562734008,
0.0159076732,
-0.0134554775,
-0.0282563046,
-0.0515459292,
0.0003627882,
0.0677918792,
0.0494737625,
-0.040507745,
-0.0710941181,
-0.0420062952,
0.0097746179,
-0.0362489969,
0.0027438635,
-0.0396328345,
0.006073223,
-0.0055203382,
-0.0555848926,
-0.0179344937,
0.0460892059,
0.0359526575,
0.0043931138,
0.0024228597,
-0.0237646792,
-0.0065166154,
-0.0347215608,
0.0053285621,
-0.0153556541,
0.033953134,
-0.1010118872,
0.0177739672,
-0.0153465448,
-0.0096940883,
-0.0181614459,
0.0018459258,
-0.1150738671,
-0.0688662827,
0.0041535879,
0.0399894081,
0.0225882698,
0.0245098937,
-0.0178351253,
-0.1008721218,
0.0181985628,
0.0252687614,
-0.0258057509,
0.0058515691,
-0.0072294595,
-0.0062308121,
0.0089948783,
0.031004414,
-0.0396222956,
-0.0103091598,
0.0037446071,
0.0835035071,
0.0048434432,
-0.0059363656,
-0.0005099354,
0.0431166366,
0.0258254725,
-0.0274404865,
-0.0250893645,
-0.0259825829,
-0.004851324,
-0.0490614437,
-0.0065052132,
-0.0424431637,
0.0187132955,
-0.0043715043,
0.0082197264,
-0.0139675224,
-0.0325946249,
-0.059117049,
0.0446938798,
0.0096818246,
0.0221876707,
-0.0055561294,
0.0034016948,
0.0604727753,
-0.0163961295,
0.0081492839,
0.0215383731,
-0.0190813821,
0.0069968877,
-0.0327797718,
-0.0092472993,
-0.0010757945,
0.0191772562,
-0.05530826,
0.0277120881,
-0.0152868563,
-0.0266080219,
-0.0185455624,
0.0349344425,
0.0183663499,
-0.0163722299,
0.0326189436,
-0.0136502497,
-0.0117482943,
-0.0233647358,
-0.0116851255,
0.0071690949,
-0.0273463354,
0.0243103355,
0.0413609259,
-0.046602767,
-0.0107683744,
0.1061048359,
0.048456274,
0.0224139523,
-0.0030535001,
-0.0222188588,
-0.0355666354,
0.0285627786,
0.0256045461,
0.0457474776,
-0.047662016,
-0.0099717453,
-0.0881535113,
-0.073407568,
0.0261274707,
0.0238847416,
0.0033991223,
-0.0011912398,
-0.003000105,
0.0716732144,
0.0061913477,
-0.0127220238,
-0.0157224573,
-0.0064533912,
0.0372363403,
-0.04913304,
0.0267378874,
-6.292377179e-33,
-0.0172209479,
-0.0255662873,
-0.0026918217,
-0.0082542663,
-0.0070701498,
0.0074005057,
-0.0479222722,
0.0301940627,
0.0401519798,
-0.022391662,
-0.0372825898,
0.0021749143,
0.0134722013,
0.0178880021,
0.0572722703,
0.0088142483,
0.0620852783,
-0.0121484557,
-0.0293170791,
-0.0072479583,
0.01300136,
0.0375451855,
0.0316690169,
-0.0152603192,
0.0173905436,
-0.0069121942,
-0.016106857,
0.0484529361,
0.0417122729,
0.0707223415,
-0.0226453431,
0.0198199302,
0.0199891422,
0.0055337232,
-0.0510728657,
0.0019800826,
-0.0477416664,
-0.0267035645,
0.0313722827,
0.002475318,
0.0004485655,
-0.0645081773,
0.0528255962,
-0.0051500024,
-0.0275837649,
0.0285776984,
0.0222779475,
0.0144981332,
-0.0287956297,
0.024649119,
-0.0751619563,
0.0233649835,
-0.0085487152,
0.0036226667,
0.0363340229,
-0.0272764079,
0.0034633582,
0.0284715015,
-0.0074797003,
0.0238665175,
0.0333028287,
0.0582653247,
0.0788220093,
0.0357884243,
-0.0107617816,
0.0405823626,
0.0339672081,
0.0199451316,
-0.0119859921,
-0.0029471335,
0.0567301735,
0.0256098695,
0.0366124399,
0.0169754829,
0.0299872141,
-0.017234195,
-0.0325797684,
-0.001776928,
0.0131376218,
0.0353961959,
0.0201226734,
0.0734483898,
-0.0423489846,
-0.0339593887,
-0.0146432603,
-0.0405670479,
-0.0377909057,
-0.0282285493,
0.0329249762,
-0.0043139444,
-0.0109704118,
-0.0086748088,
0.0356346965,
-0.0236905664,
-0.0553709865,
-0.0146599626,
0.0020542373,
0.0323211811,
-0.0155462157,
0.0346784368,
-0.0661977381,
-0.0360418521,
-0.0083037997,
0.0131945275,
0.0162284058,
0.0088171698,
-0.0099242143,
0.0106906798,
-0.0682958663,
-0.0113754198,
-0.0245638229,
0.0018375095,
0.0060631167,
0.013275994,
0.0316733085,
-0.0217821971,
0.0110023282,
0.0122426748,
0.0369947925,
-0.0504076965,
-0.0139777204,
0.0355167799,
-0.0093702972,
0.0119647412,
-0.0195860043,
-0.0239286572,
-0.0396081656,
0.0249065422,
0.0503772087,
-0.0296201352,
-0.0248277485,
0.0007981178,
2.66e-7,
0.040335983,
0.0886841565,
0.0658555999,
-0.0274947826,
0.0240260083,
0.0201970413,
-0.0226240009,
0.0115849609,
-0.016251009,
0.0302080512,
0.0280301347,
0.0099122208,
0.038794633,
0.030657202,
-0.0865087509,
0.0307338964,
-0.0721034482,
0.039995417,
-0.0717606843,
-0.0238670837,
-0.0029184737,
0.0893511698,
0.0081856344,
0.0116408905,
-0.0509241819,
-0.0718502924,
0.0079120332,
-0.0287031028,
0.0089786816,
0.0537544228,
0.0183285642,
0.0080002993,
0.035967689,
0.0131558375,
-0.0106923506,
0.00328294,
0.0685276687,
0.0452517606,
-0.0193352588,
0.0172382556,
-0.0001104404,
-0.0301757306,
0.0015121906,
-0.0831155181,
0.0530303381,
-0.0056876619,
0.0048258831,
-0.0469629504,
0.0020752824,
-0.0126570603,
-0.0076631447,
-0.0181776788,
-0.0190505199,
0.0716127232,
0.0213213004,
0.004180734,
-0.0174125489,
-0.0473124199,
-0.0370302498,
-0.0096321115,
-0.0481523015,
-0.0178387631,
-0.0493840799,
0.0286197234,
0.0124302264,
-0.0294293091,
-0.0156942923,
2.917942484e-34,
0.0554632284,
-0.0278898943,
-0.0027313868,
0.0476256534,
0.0411383212,
-0.016397519,
-0.0062250476,
0.0336877108,
-0.0123376977,
-0.0703089982,
-0.0127235185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11683v1 | HoLLMwood: Unleashing the Creativity of Large Language Models in Screenwriting via Role Playing | 2024-06-17T16:01:33 | 2024-06-17T16:01:33 | Jing Chen, Xinyu Zhu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Yadong Xi, Yuxiang Zhang, Junjie Wang, Jiashu Pu, Rongsheng Zhang, Yujiu Yang, Tian Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative AI has demonstrated unprecedented creativity in the field of
computer vision, yet such phenomena have not been observed in natural language
processing. In particular, large language models (LLMs) can hardly produce
written works at the level of human experts due to the extremely high
complexity of literature writing. In this paper, we present HoLLMwood, an
automated framework for unleashing the creativity of LLMs and exploring their
potential in screenwriting, which is a highly demanding task. Mimicking the
human creative process, we assign LLMs to different roles involved in the
real-world scenario. In addition to the common practice of treating LLMs as
${Writer}$, we also apply LLMs as ${Editor}$, who is responsible for providing
feedback and revision advice to ${Writer}$. Besides, to enrich the characters
and deepen the plots, we introduce a role-playing mechanism and adopt LLMs as
${Actors}$ that can communicate and interact with each other. Evaluations on
automatically generated screenplays show that HoLLMwood substantially
outperforms strong baselines in terms of coherence, relevance, interestingness
and overall quality. | [
0.0677195191,
0.005055171,
-0.0016674947,
0.0157269444,
-0.0525207072,
-0.0200079624,
0.0008942954,
0.010257666,
0.0283603687,
-0.0518201888,
-0.0040618242,
-0.0431662947,
-0.0058826422,
0.0781632066,
-0.0101255514,
-0.0664671361,
-0.0436230004,
-0.0381929502,
0.0659640282,
0.00913723,
-0.008734758,
0.0439344943,
0.015320573,
0.0498616993,
-0.0219445806,
-0.0274679922,
0.0094586685,
0.0219735987,
0.038118314,
0.0040414366,
-0.0241916254,
0.0304928459,
0.0424439646,
0.0393164419,
0.0000017923,
-0.0785575062,
0.0328264311,
-0.0235128943,
0.0448209159,
-0.000877336,
0.0425225906,
0.002534807,
-0.0156472344,
-0.0201105382,
-0.0264704004,
0.0262118112,
0.0477906279,
0.0276090279,
0.0777038112,
0.0795146823,
-0.0290668346,
-0.0462711193,
-0.0168046728,
-0.0025833675,
0.0310000367,
0.0047070985,
-0.0070787678,
0.0177716631,
0.0616743043,
-0.0210554339,
-0.0320985168,
0.0089222323,
0.0038078532,
-0.0965588838,
0.0137242703,
0.0664491579,
-0.0248343032,
0.0018283513,
0.0084667793,
0.033056207,
-0.0183735024,
-0.0140645988,
-0.0179752391,
-0.0236852262,
0.0065237037,
0.0185398571,
-0.0541730933,
0.052639816,
-0.0159695316,
0.0130339973,
0.0242397506,
0.0022671435,
0.0071933079,
0.0002816647,
0.0588257648,
-0.0029825196,
0.0337351337,
-0.0048031625,
-0.0503489375,
0.0034993009,
-0.0119271446,
-0.085473299,
0.0173998233,
0.0357987173,
0.0008929172,
0.0080245212,
-0.0622742586,
-0.0075426837,
-0.0298100505,
-0.0537646934,
0.0790446773,
0.0186841786,
0.012670083,
0.053291142,
0.0067631835,
0.0418811366,
0.0221086554,
0.0062835608,
0.0133608701,
0.0237907004,
-0.0436070934,
-0.0221393313,
-0.052303765,
0.0066248151,
-0.036852207,
-0.0254890304,
-0.0073549519,
0.0294676218,
-0.0123248445,
0.0338922143,
0.0192181505,
0.0486221761,
-0.0245991368,
-0.0322893523,
-0.0490900762,
0.013928663,
0.0138686141,
-0.0200107284,
0.003865923,
0.0108520007,
-0.0010386943,
0.0070150951,
0.0161525086,
-0.0147153633,
0.0305706449,
0.0649049282,
-0.0255853552,
-0.0026527757,
-0.0337872356,
-0.0073515405,
-0.0053676851,
-0.0510703065,
-0.05378801,
-0.056234546,
0.053990528,
-0.0216734391,
-0.0031318762,
-0.0554110743,
0.0153478058,
0.0069249286,
-0.0078261914,
0.0525005944,
-0.0133092841,
0.0185777936,
0.0455742888,
0.0139768785,
-0.0142742023,
0.0123007111,
0.095652923,
0.0702724084,
0.0201200172,
0.0053154812,
0.0737103,
0.0318924189,
-0.0728520378,
0.0103276419,
-0.0289874282,
-0.0271929037,
-0.0288302545,
0.0647054687,
0.0116660753,
0.065238066,
-0.0008818368,
0.0244228207,
0.0944432765,
0.051955577,
0.0300630443,
0.0398768596,
0.1123985946,
0.0142016169,
0.0098598227,
0.0147501044,
-0.0006239846,
0.0537869856,
0.0416578762,
0.002371686,
-0.030645581,
0.0088794651,
-0.0003943213,
-0.0170373488,
0.0093540149,
0.0048462725,
-0.0317439027,
-0.0408383347,
-0.0020794591,
0.0190541856,
-0.0717957765,
-0.0421162322,
0.0154709499,
-0.0695471168,
0.0797698051,
-0.0153040374,
0.0397554785,
0.1370723844,
0.0657700673,
-0.0296567678,
-0.0100685162,
-0.0265223254,
-0.0163734984,
0.0323294774,
-0.0009888021,
-0.0483516045,
0.0064219167,
-0.0256163981,
0.0310186353,
-0.0244573429,
0.0131419795,
0.046971526,
-0.05790646,
-0.0034440302,
-0.0211955104,
0.0143397041,
-0.0618556999,
0.0318521075,
-0.0434698947,
-0.035632655,
-0.0112691643,
-0.0072809206,
-0.0038852657,
-0.0088542886,
-0.0765027255,
-0.0076105758,
0.0221621916,
-0.0391020067,
-0.0494313128,
0.0546967275,
-0.0244202539,
-0.0026789901,
0.0044784304,
-0.0573259071,
-0.0021157626,
0.0152680445,
-0.0074880412,
-0.0455320328,
0.008958987,
-0.04162376,
-0.0119525744,
-0.0483711883,
0.0304687656,
-0.0047978614,
-0.0014866876,
-0.035675019,
0.0463871732,
0.010481691,
-0.004940466,
0.0228969753,
0.0244232081,
-0.0042928024,
-0.0234405957,
0.0249748994,
0.0216264911,
0.0489400104,
0.0191833135,
0.0423203409,
0.0041810879,
-0.0068313736,
-0.0697625875,
-0.0491151214,
-0.0200371873,
0.0016079361,
-0.0206677765,
0.0380779505,
-0.0083175981,
-0.041175317,
0.008098769,
-0.0182416718,
-0.0315473936,
0.0292717647,
-0.0499453694,
0.0384462513,
0.0062586172,
0.0061420458,
-0.0092762867,
0.0194207672,
-0.015303202,
0.0484372303,
0.0793553218,
0.0010152146,
-0.031413395,
0.0219663624,
0.0159679987,
-0.000924352,
-0.0155674042,
-0.0126901362,
-0.0073019383,
-0.0111951344,
0.0242113415,
0.0578529313,
0.0277946051,
0.0151207754,
0.0897083804,
-0.0257974025,
0.0021437816,
0.0119773829,
0.0249301977,
0.0123981321,
-0.0450238474,
-0.0386257544,
0.0286258832,
0.0309388731,
0.0372208171,
0.0238566138,
-0.057616815,
0.0723967478,
0.0147535568,
-0.0344651192,
0.0291879848,
-0.049668178,
-0.0336244665,
0.0513658151,
-0.0264032688,
-0.0293724872,
0.0553738475,
-0.0497401506,
-0.0249571428,
-0.0038105231,
0.0053933049,
-0.0478233173,
0.0878060609,
0.0262154676,
0.0466347747,
-0.0181393698,
0.0050794911,
-0.0553930178,
0.0029744587,
0.0707028583,
-0.0103511885,
0.0072267549,
-0.0338692963,
0.0034354159,
-0.0155829703,
-0.0032147001,
-0.0362629965,
-0.0194926485,
-0.0265579801,
0.0041899728,
0.055716835,
-0.0440986603,
-0.0120871998,
0.0354141667,
0.0071908804,
0.0561398007,
0.0118603567,
-0.0355734341,
-0.0198140964,
0.0295832995,
0.0563725233,
-0.0305564888,
-0.0626193583,
-0.0109987389,
0.0852596909,
-0.0005389821,
-0.0711659119,
0.0091955382,
-0.032387767,
0.0358292684,
0.015707707,
-0.0246111564,
0.0123934979,
-0.0152340839,
0.0317642167,
-0.0722571537,
-0.0157374498,
0.1263832897,
0.0294620991,
-0.0421847999,
0.000310983,
-0.0236719921,
0.0029829789,
0.0322906561,
0.0361527056,
-0.0418595523,
0.0101423599,
-0.0002059126,
-0.0006575552,
-0.0019320593,
-0.0386197157,
-0.0362627916,
-0.0967737585,
0.1137517393,
0.0095094657,
0.0099063003,
-0.002154704,
-0.0080635557,
-0.0066665011,
-0.0072250003,
-0.0542998798,
0.0042897565,
-0.0062874486,
-0.007800654,
-0.0460123643,
-0.0059463144,
-0.0142582534,
0.0224157572,
-0.0533047728,
0.0530784465,
0.0730338022,
0.0808695629,
-0.0182470717,
0.0114139058,
-0.0471957847,
0.0080801025,
0.0104448693,
-0.0069960267,
0.0339650102,
-0.0296953414,
-0.0173016414,
-0.0179800559,
0.0444855131,
0.0365626179,
-0.0512175635,
0.0096068894,
0.056258712,
-0.0387777723,
-0.0505785085,
-0.0157583952,
0.0357322097,
0.0076307273,
0.0449259244,
0.0241617579,
-0.0838523954,
-0.0294310879,
-0.0215515457,
-0.0035322327,
-0.0709828958,
-0.0605740137,
-0.0233602803,
-0.023049619,
0.0056636161,
-0.0658466071,
-0.0187154151,
0.0293542948,
0.0590441823,
0.0365727171,
-0.0054552965,
-0.0365980007,
-0.0190021899,
-0.0382845327,
-0.0323682688,
-0.0073595745,
0.0009039671,
-0.0123889353,
-0.0326947309,
0.00636,
-0.0671302527,
-0.0101469625,
0.0015176235,
-0.042102512,
-0.0767505616,
-0.0080067432,
0.0447255261,
0.0201601721,
0.0267145429,
0.0163190048,
-0.0707349032,
0.0479819067,
0.0025353506,
0.0024927638,
0.0433760025,
-0.0321043245,
0.0304840766,
-0.0324214473,
0.0321222246,
-0.032931447,
0.0183786247,
0.0051501333,
0.0352942348,
-0.003056278,
-0.0415507816,
0.0181786958,
0.0191213246,
-0.0454291478,
-0.0668258891,
0.0267154612,
-0.0790519267,
-0.0365607552,
-0.0385727398,
-0.03471696,
-0.0526329838,
0.014535469,
0.0286219921,
-0.0191500485,
-0.0207144767,
0.0312025957,
-0.062270768,
-0.0105416179,
-0.0264780205,
-0.0064261407,
0.0352285169,
-0.0009133267,
0.0434484109,
0.0162251908,
-0.0044796267,
0.0368036777,
-0.0554156229,
0.0336031988,
0.0146061238,
0.024478782,
0.0166419595,
-0.0222523119,
0.0036617487,
0.0343958959,
-0.032143347,
-0.042601455,
-0.0110362824,
0.0515064187,
0.0907968581,
-0.0268507339,
0.0342340767,
-0.0662018806,
0.0184010696,
-0.0179222506,
0.0251528472,
0.031623628,
-0.0577898882,
-0.0208295472,
0.0252175238,
-0.0175375845,
0.0258204304,
0.0699735582,
0.0010604716,
0.0311319437,
0.0331771895,
-0.0414870456,
-0.0234753527,
-0.0199350491,
0.0100259176,
-0.0054756831,
0.0059658024,
0.0255766883,
-0.0605104528,
-0.0272701364,
0.0496551394,
-0.0061473711,
0.0314147994,
-0.0316816978,
0.0102372803,
0.0251020566,
0.0069672312,
0.0446571037,
-0.0466313846,
0.0033930168,
-0.0294371508,
-0.0138107622,
-0.0460045226,
-5.0645208e-33,
-0.0418298766,
-0.0424452089,
0.0016047382,
0.0192194805,
-0.0476799682,
-0.0088856863,
-0.0241817553,
-0.0052402024,
0.052078668,
0.0443700142,
0.0049703736,
-0.0087446189,
-0.0099476893,
-0.0031665945,
0.0122973602,
-0.0021388372,
0.0630827919,
0.0265956447,
-0.0649794117,
0.0090490021,
0.02327732,
0.0256868266,
0.0088677611,
-0.0232148338,
-0.028338246,
-0.068269074,
-0.048541978,
0.0078778537,
0.0162901338,
0.0193082578,
0.0100900671,
0.0383088402,
0.0252288133,
-0.0108823795,
-0.0055627595,
0.0154642127,
-0.0042204596,
-0.0093520619,
0.0175991151,
-0.0022275818,
-0.0010110468,
-0.0395235047,
0.0088587906,
-0.0294726659,
0.0048778234,
-0.024380384,
0.0569344871,
-0.0186431017,
0.0255578179,
-0.0127001423,
-0.112962082,
-0.0074784206,
-0.0416212343,
-0.0613503382,
0.0050689862,
0.0027727985,
0.0238869432,
-0.0202914309,
-0.0590541549,
0.0246697273,
-0.0213528089,
0.0463363715,
0.0374152139,
0.0276113022,
-0.0085544651,
0.0758643597,
-0.0063205869,
0.0164203085,
-0.0676182285,
0.0125323934,
-0.0285219736,
0.0392971598,
0.0109639913,
0.0641038045,
0.0019252864,
-0.0086052539,
-0.0284537543,
0.0425748117,
-0.0437193699,
0.0317248181,
0.0423834845,
0.0381876938,
0.0206144638,
-0.0338916481,
-0.0331434235,
-0.0284121856,
-0.0127302222,
-0.0414788313,
-0.002002426,
-0.0124014411,
-0.001229512,
-0.0089731775,
0.015046725,
-0.0329582691,
0.0429008156,
0.0043415488,
-0.0789248124,
0.0765526369,
-0.0043384056,
0.0187168475,
0.0302561186,
-0.006133717,
0.0405065343,
0.0328119956,
0.0461451113,
0.0338185318,
0.0049194163,
0.0596439317,
-0.0306426324,
-0.0108319558,
-0.02981125,
0.025043115,
0.0038833697,
0.0194007065,
-0.0152857853,
-0.0137890568,
-0.0289818048,
-0.0115705384,
0.0054311585,
-0.014823555,
0.0023497038,
0.0157658663,
-0.0330287814,
-0.000704871,
-0.0540353209,
0.0563766286,
-0.0142741818,
-0.0186653808,
0.0464897975,
-0.0393326581,
-0.0112054842,
-0.0330261812,
2.507e-7,
-0.0009305024,
0.0220329594,
0.0232541058,
0.021902265,
0.0187470969,
0.0416229293,
-0.0341356993,
0.0359090827,
0.017313337,
-0.0146805579,
0.0390331522,
0.0195831042,
0.015768962,
0.0170125905,
-0.0907647088,
0.0227740761,
-0.0773471743,
-0.0332843103,
-0.0671092421,
-0.0237276424,
0.0422195084,
-0.0055399295,
0.0430058651,
-0.0434146337,
0.0018617598,
-0.0845282599,
0.0696441457,
-0.0101051712,
-0.0258610807,
0.0348254368,
0.0279469714,
-0.0115422793,
-0.0209756903,
0.0030281586,
-0.0141115319,
-0.0031370039,
0.0106060077,
0.0386415236,
-0.0533614829,
0.0362581536,
0.0230167173,
0.0081297355,
-0.0106170531,
-0.0208100006,
0.0400086939,
-0.0102645112,
-0.0315675065,
-0.0564371943,
0.0017755496,
0.0045222337,
-0.0025146836,
-0.053556893,
-0.018580677,
0.0162624735,
0.0227112249,
0.0203929376,
-0.0011669961,
-0.0393818431,
-0.0277997572,
-0.008302927,
-0.0280372649,
0.0050098202,
-0.0111742038,
-0.009708738,
0.0194017496,
-0.0640428811,
0.0275312103,
2.221912993e-34,
0.0307737887,
0.0170301273,
-0.0130420756,
0.009130328,
0.048929397,
0.0318675786,
0.0229735896,
0.0205700751,
0.0122186635,
-0.0274268892,
-0.0385637209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11682v1 | Knowledge-to-Jailbreak: One Knowledge Point Worth One Attack | 2024-06-17T15:59:59 | 2024-06-17T15:59:59 | Shangqing Tu, Zhuoran Pan, Wenxuan Wang, Zhexin Zhang, Yuliang Sun, Jifan Yu, Hongning Wang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly applied to various
domains, which triggers increasing concerns about LLMs' safety on specialized
domains, e.g. medicine. However, testing the domain-specific safety of LLMs is
challenging due to the lack of domain knowledge-driven attacks in existing
benchmarks. To bridge this gap, we propose a new task, knowledge-to-jailbreak,
which aims to generate jailbreaks from domain knowledge to evaluate the safety
of LLMs when applied to those domains. We collect a large-scale dataset with
12,974 knowledge-jailbreak pairs and fine-tune a large language model as
jailbreak-generator, to produce domain knowledge-specific jailbreaks.
Experiments on 13 domains and 8 target LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of
jailbreak-generator in generating jailbreaks that are both relevant to the
given knowledge and harmful to the target LLMs. We also apply our method to an
out-of-domain knowledge base, showing that jailbreak-generator can generate
jailbreaks that are comparable in harmfulness to those crafted by human
experts. Data and code: https://github.com/THU-KEG/Knowledge-to-Jailbreak/. | [
0.0303198602,
0.083071433,
-0.0198343322,
0.0486605316,
-0.0370102637,
-0.023297213,
0.0281888451,
0.01137463,
0.0500799455,
-0.0092555908,
-0.0017038984,
0.0023054723,
0.0180771109,
0.0268593449,
0.0562619306,
0.0127242627,
0.0493614748,
-0.0513634942,
-0.0144713363,
0.0120850299,
0.0087309098,
-0.000578525,
0.0169265233,
0.0276341345,
0.0127996402,
-0.0208903141,
-0.0012311984,
0.0005644257,
0.0323699489,
-0.0377093144,
0.0057108304,
0.0315766148,
-0.0237647779,
0.0329310261,
0.0000021653,
-0.0089555485,
-0.0190543849,
0.0494239628,
-0.023636803,
0.0385933109,
-0.0082352329,
-0.0746169761,
-0.0139328679,
-0.0092905406,
-0.027623767,
0.0036861422,
0.0179088246,
0.0172226056,
0.0704089925,
0.0757112131,
0.0119820246,
0.0128430547,
0.0379616283,
-0.0114665302,
0.0286569726,
-0.0527005531,
0.0120393392,
-0.0046338867,
-0.0001985972,
0.0145859886,
0.0170230083,
-0.0032527412,
-0.0002405825,
-0.0012632466,
-0.0529505126,
-0.0218338855,
-0.0321987532,
-0.0051750038,
0.0055757025,
0.035450384,
-0.0327698439,
-0.0277466774,
0.0333545767,
0.01980903,
0.0089551657,
0.029288169,
0.0209670719,
0.0280629303,
-0.0153381517,
-0.0338323563,
0.0300151594,
-0.0109994495,
0.0825344026,
-0.0137046939,
-0.0089137089,
0.0533708893,
-0.0031823821,
-0.0245089922,
0.0152334217,
-0.071818158,
-0.0257352311,
-0.0487098321,
-0.0214772113,
-0.0111915246,
0.0185814444,
0.0160755515,
-0.0617845692,
-0.0237291157,
0.0723118559,
-0.0463605002,
-0.0357730649,
0.0026755859,
0.0071104048,
0.0154352617,
0.0070643974,
-0.0004241646,
-0.0092903832,
0.0055904877,
-0.0129897492,
0.0037219818,
-0.0269235391,
-0.013641132,
0.0150979245,
0.0347151197,
0.0011991254,
0.034614902,
-0.0418837517,
0.0057334746,
-0.0543188117,
0.0479947366,
-0.0272083543,
-0.0017723987,
0.0011177174,
0.0061824378,
0.050219059,
-0.0232781116,
-0.0206633788,
0.0021623562,
0.0124308234,
-0.0429470688,
-0.0127263917,
-0.00622604,
-0.0935839489,
-0.0103756329,
-0.0054887924,
0.1383209229,
0.0423792303,
0.0055457302,
-0.0894684419,
-0.1157452911,
-0.0332312062,
-0.0301215015,
0.0085228384,
-0.1069521531,
-0.0243676528,
-0.0092154369,
0.0118916044,
-0.1082053408,
0.0032381981,
-0.0303713288,
-0.0700551644,
0.0470649339,
-0.0301973969,
-0.0133930743,
0.0129393814,
0.0753768906,
0.0046780892,
0.0591643304,
-0.0133192139,
0.0343032815,
0.0341543928,
-0.0158148706,
0.0199424736,
0.0398285948,
0.0148454504,
0.0277368184,
0.001856965,
0.0050226455,
0.0640428737,
0.0045278501,
-0.0300596282,
0.0211757906,
-0.013161472,
-0.0222346634,
0.0566342659,
0.0371457636,
-0.0068379105,
0.0438041985,
0.009655782,
-0.0391420275,
0.0258896518,
-0.0293828081,
-0.0562052876,
-0.0159807578,
-0.0842913464,
-0.0176528245,
-0.0395921208,
0.027470706,
-0.0007984923,
0.0220591091,
0.0105032949,
-0.0175769422,
-0.036640767,
-0.0066252318,
0.0130330361,
0.0279972833,
0.000863804,
0.0855970457,
0.0418215916,
-0.0314517766,
-0.0452803075,
-0.0493835509,
-0.0266859066,
0.0449933074,
0.0598878227,
-0.027345771,
-0.027623428,
0.0030757221,
-0.0088348268,
0.0133460956,
-0.0045059579,
-0.0143322293,
0.0224370975,
0.0076655066,
0.0092416098,
-0.038463477,
0.0478204787,
0.0156852826,
0.0207700506,
0.0255523007,
0.0089404918,
-0.0765049532,
-0.0275437441,
0.0073816855,
-0.0494678579,
0.0205879305,
0.0290040541,
0.0122139985,
0.0018437434,
0.0122206444,
-0.0418185927,
0.0234379936,
0.0649673268,
-0.0256571732,
0.0358006395,
0.0019700709,
0.0017437738,
-0.0103350114,
0.0283688903,
-0.0689333975,
0.0069314996,
0.0447645523,
-0.0382911786,
0.0061610905,
0.0666795596,
-0.0062882402,
0.03973414,
0.0375168882,
0.0346385501,
0.0001046782,
-0.0053847115,
-0.020690389,
0.0086524738,
-0.0268004611,
0.0059607667,
-0.0287173223,
0.0018802192,
0.0065610665,
0.0423959754,
-0.0542092621,
-0.0135755073,
-0.0533165894,
0.0375914276,
-0.0037452581,
0.0002836514,
-0.0102833994,
-0.0303495377,
-0.0497903079,
-0.0203492548,
-0.0111003462,
0.0374487713,
0.0387628637,
0.0356793106,
-0.0064237183,
-0.0174046401,
0.0063881618,
-0.0114681078,
-0.0165578313,
0.0086279381,
-0.0149544133,
0.0165824667,
-0.0381032489,
-0.0161697473,
0.0009941243,
-0.0108554401,
0.0693830699,
-0.0345225073,
0.0193325542,
-0.0176218376,
0.0260586012,
-0.0149447164,
0.0049027521,
-0.0322233588,
-0.0380185023,
0.0177954845,
-0.0013891151,
-0.0154076358,
0.0277410168,
-0.0114316829,
0.0296290684,
0.0748100281,
-0.0100579476,
-0.0125299348,
-0.0367971621,
0.0528491363,
-0.0393835306,
-0.0254479293,
-0.082638815,
0.0364334956,
0.0783334002,
0.0279111564,
-0.0052938513,
-0.0151657164,
0.0203176215,
-0.0276382789,
-0.0296332575,
0.0015383578,
-0.0104386378,
-0.0105016334,
0.0126264505,
-0.0107751526,
-0.0579073392,
0.0535719432,
-0.0444723666,
0.0597026646,
-0.0302776452,
-0.0382004417,
-0.0151515426,
0.0313015059,
-0.032852035,
0.029610889,
0.0791426972,
0.007180647,
-0.0208498109,
-0.0117038768,
0.0169572476,
-0.0098012956,
0.0723582208,
-0.0765960068,
-0.0012587666,
0.0039030819,
-0.0401928872,
-0.0349921137,
-0.0178804342,
-0.0133903865,
-0.0218370147,
0.068089895,
-0.0428013615,
0.0075865779,
-0.0238554757,
0.0306086447,
0.0019074237,
0.0307448208,
-0.0237777773,
0.0071563865,
0.0117605533,
0.005107807,
-0.089950718,
-0.0031021833,
-0.0011900011,
0.0377674922,
0.0845626295,
0.0551089682,
0.0240525547,
-0.0233800337,
0.0143168932,
-0.010417725,
-0.0129491752,
-0.0200236104,
0.0280756615,
0.0265740473,
-0.0501516685,
-0.0278613381,
0.0533418991,
0.0216589887,
-0.0020313205,
0.043896731,
0.0165847652,
-0.0034850403,
0.0171937514,
0.0466418341,
-0.1037147269,
-0.0286981203,
-0.0025240865,
0.061543826,
-0.0214356519,
-0.0511554964,
-0.0178196523,
-0.0798287466,
-0.0041066371,
0.0388923436,
-0.010674878,
-0.0218757018,
-0.0521182977,
-0.0432982631,
0.0148491561,
-0.0152138313,
-0.0077772918,
-0.0044339914,
-0.0147124985,
-0.0121344645,
-0.068459928,
-0.0430561714,
0.0447361469,
-0.0158450846,
0.0627704337,
0.0907736644,
-0.0151045518,
-0.0439959466,
0.0430933312,
0.0136046689,
0.0093699805,
-0.0074636107,
-0.0044798316,
0.0319893733,
0.0477073118,
-0.0098339329,
0.0297320802,
0.0425116494,
-0.047404144,
-0.0466039591,
0.0566329062,
0.0525781736,
-0.0010666428,
-0.0435770154,
-0.0257726144,
-0.0130392928,
0.0156280901,
0.039316006,
0.0216721389,
-0.0118635893,
-0.0369389802,
-0.0657249689,
-0.0291355662,
-0.0449245982,
-0.0359206237,
0.0307323933,
0.0199306179,
-0.0121996114,
-0.0508321747,
0.0295112114,
-0.0035324404,
0.0308045186,
0.053795401,
0.008409678,
-0.028911382,
0.0174725167,
-0.0539604798,
-0.0078823054,
0.0161258001,
0.0440834127,
-0.0543497242,
0.0098965941,
0.0087790042,
0.0053767655,
-0.0056472518,
0.0355820805,
-0.0546183437,
-0.0858923569,
0.0153830191,
0.0681719556,
0.0217755307,
0.0023216854,
-0.0410337523,
-0.0393584743,
0.0753656849,
0.0917425901,
-0.0807356089,
0.0047421134,
0.0461541377,
-0.0419770479,
0.0176944118,
0.0185705032,
-0.0477626882,
-0.0164127592,
0.0695615411,
-0.0129637579,
-0.048184894,
0.0285369121,
0.0134374108,
0.0362088457,
0.0055079097,
-0.0002980757,
0.0179034602,
0.0448054448,
0.0156288017,
0.0102730282,
-0.0429131947,
0.0066011171,
-0.0049563083,
0.0185116306,
-0.0274760835,
0.0482671261,
0.0452481434,
0.0221811552,
-0.0135659054,
-0.0013602076,
0.0288244579,
0.0480763912,
0.0747969374,
0.0997471958,
0.0030549658,
0.00416773,
0.019100396,
-0.0477788225,
0.0543723293,
-0.0277364962,
0.0309899822,
-0.0178292003,
0.0039205649,
0.0021736687,
0.0357681848,
-0.0359527282,
-0.0599256121,
0.000927972,
0.0640127659,
-0.0074059721,
0.0235175528,
0.0163353607,
-0.0345912464,
0.0221896097,
-0.0559046455,
-0.0138229271,
-0.0356623419,
-0.0228574574,
0.0195059236,
0.007438038,
-0.0116244564,
0.0071080071,
0.1258763373,
0.0391914286,
0.0825932175,
0.027840782,
-0.0370916687,
-0.0521916933,
-0.0104548568,
0.0624117479,
0.0031773602,
-0.0643727034,
-0.042252887,
-0.0841047242,
-0.0825358033,
-0.0154345501,
-0.0113716247,
0.0290125012,
0.0406037122,
-0.0377147049,
0.0657710582,
0.0245348476,
0.0231740829,
-0.0664678663,
0.0454338193,
-0.0203787256,
-0.0767924786,
0.0461366512,
-5.988609602e-33,
0.0429649279,
-0.0233994387,
-0.0562098511,
-0.0330185033,
0.0149833411,
0.0077744373,
-0.0438448973,
0.019435063,
-0.0147057585,
-0.0072837304,
0.0016211105,
-0.0081615495,
-0.0097064683,
-0.0076650991,
-0.0087698698,
-0.0057506287,
-0.0024149946,
0.0361655541,
-0.0204992574,
0.0549044721,
0.0406545699,
0.0355075225,
0.0266343374,
-0.0425209701,
0.0399602689,
-0.0254979301,
-0.0045750127,
0.0166516621,
-0.0290491637,
0.0463990867,
0.0231609847,
0.0275986344,
-0.0068180352,
-0.0437071435,
-0.002368141,
-0.0332806781,
-0.0087044276,
0.017441351,
0.0129842833,
-0.0250924062,
0.0098272217,
-0.0754445195,
0.0301854461,
0.0228096507,
0.0181237869,
-0.0308221895,
-0.0070181228,
-0.0238170605,
-0.0044384534,
-0.0416179858,
-0.0053106165,
0.0123204626,
-0.0516461097,
0.0021580036,
-0.0273707379,
-0.0350754261,
0.007490532,
-0.0129834721,
-0.0220858045,
0.0499492101,
0.0614961311,
0.0191403143,
0.054121051,
-0.0341756679,
-0.0191318914,
0.0498602353,
-0.0474579148,
-0.0020719136,
0.0509573705,
0.0297899004,
-0.0086124977,
0.0959641561,
0.0433520228,
0.0814814717,
0.0499694385,
-0.0349216834,
-0.0900887251,
0.0062093227,
-0.0323003344,
0.0167132597,
0.0086886268,
-0.0163642522,
-0.0349419899,
-0.0156334117,
-0.0027546964,
0.0132303257,
-0.0154323615,
-0.0541774146,
0.0035013151,
-0.0149848731,
-0.0322368294,
-0.0181430504,
-0.0124637885,
-0.0798247755,
0.0272578094,
0.0210567843,
-0.0153965699,
-0.00886444,
-0.0212746747,
0.0133170476,
-0.0310103409,
0.0078525236,
-0.0083969673,
-0.0323238373,
0.0591258779,
0.0033915008,
0.0384754576,
-0.0035803847,
-0.0544079877,
-0.0151726836,
-0.0221470445,
0.0316372812,
0.0173838921,
0.010880339,
0.0050285575,
-0.0052113086,
0.0058682053,
-0.0408317931,
0.0430010855,
-0.0146753769,
-0.0376857705,
0.0396934822,
-0.0237563811,
0.0184098352,
-0.0166160762,
-0.0306146815,
-0.002825768,
0.0010210352,
0.0492655449,
-0.0410245284,
-0.0201596245,
-0.0084411232,
2.915e-7,
-0.0009805127,
-0.0111540705,
-0.0043077287,
-0.0046626236,
0.0101235844,
0.0641395524,
-0.0362849571,
0.0576063544,
-0.0277120713,
-0.059799321,
-0.054132767,
-0.0241474696,
0.0685443357,
0.0527491868,
-0.0565352328,
0.0316028707,
-0.0176034756,
-0.0301280394,
-0.0637931898,
-0.0335192233,
-0.0148131363,
0.0413591191,
-0.0067128576,
-0.0500739105,
0.0041551651,
-0.0315897167,
-0.01528004,
-0.0026807711,
0.0096437205,
0.0354873165,
0.0017402775,
0.0374695323,
0.0001159365,
0.0479063615,
-0.0531412773,
-0.0492347963,
-0.0481546596,
0.0381949432,
0.0323504359,
0.0317090675,
-0.0232986994,
-0.0531207621,
0.0053210501,
-0.0407911986,
0.0591957346,
0.0018972858,
-0.0263921078,
-0.0002641705,
0.0123455608,
-0.0357842892,
-0.0137150018,
-0.0275264103,
0.0163320284,
-0.0079691373,
0.015572587,
0.0294477455,
0.0200629905,
-0.0363144316,
-0.0184522569,
0.0506823808,
-0.023719212,
-0.0439648293,
0.0050212741,
0.017228391,
0.0225728825,
-0.0612835027,
0.0362523086,
2.84591843e-34,
-0.012859269,
-0.0228308775,
-0.005618725,
-0.0032911366,
0.0390798636,
-0.0210423041,
0.001092682,
0.0094789369,
-0.0306427255,
-0.0234348457,
-0.0053575537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11681v1 | R-Eval: A Unified Toolkit for Evaluating Domain Knowledge of Retrieval Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T15:59:49 | 2024-06-17T15:59:49 | Shangqing Tu, Yuanchun Wang, Jifan Yu, Yuyang Xie, Yaran Shi, Xiaozhi Wang, Jing Zhang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have achieved remarkable success on general NLP tasks,
but they may fall short for domain-specific problems. Recently, various
Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RALLMs) are proposed to address this
shortcoming. However, existing evaluation tools only provide a few baselines
and evaluate them on various domains without mining the depth of domain
knowledge. In this paper, we address the challenges of evaluating RALLMs by
introducing the R-Eval toolkit, a Python toolkit designed to streamline the
evaluation of different RAG workflows in conjunction with LLMs. Our toolkit,
which supports popular built-in RAG workflows and allows for the incorporation
of customized testing data on the specific domain, is designed to be
user-friendly, modular, and extensible. We conduct an evaluation of 21 RALLMs
across three task levels and two representative domains, revealing significant
variations in the effectiveness of RALLMs across different tasks and domains.
Our analysis emphasizes the importance of considering both task and domain
requirements when choosing a RAG workflow and LLM combination. We are committed
to continuously maintaining our platform at https://github.com/THU-KEG/R-Eval
to facilitate both the industry and the researchers. | [
0.0491215624,
0.0083862348,
0.0013005189,
0.0300740134,
-0.0360102914,
0.0019987943,
-0.0014429919,
0.0139085595,
0.0185200479,
-0.0542525426,
-0.0514325052,
-0.012706588,
-0.0238723755,
0.0435277224,
-0.0075776852,
0.0166956373,
0.0369200818,
-0.0097634373,
-0.0206724405,
0.0470236018,
0.005529284,
0.0148833739,
0.0172085091,
0.0435386673,
0.0208057817,
-0.0267596748,
0.0212626085,
0.0194373596,
0.0192181226,
-0.0190779716,
0.0419961736,
0.0402894877,
0.033422213,
0.038469065,
0.0000017676,
-0.0654033422,
-0.0333814174,
0.030436093,
-0.0082162097,
0.0206510164,
0.0822504237,
0.022507675,
0.0415903628,
0.0283656865,
-0.0224608164,
-0.0428330302,
0.0002174816,
0.0473783277,
0.0334017016,
0.0628510788,
0.00339794,
-0.0103871096,
0.0077607627,
-0.0465644933,
0.0138974227,
-0.0650193468,
0.0499589406,
0.0267590303,
0.0329787135,
0.0269134436,
0.0101556461,
0.0542610362,
-0.0170754883,
0.0026054031,
0.0261501856,
-0.0047240914,
-0.0339193605,
-0.0256086066,
-0.0065056719,
0.0411923304,
0.035213206,
-0.0195561424,
0.0080049252,
0.0357059799,
-0.0035084567,
0.0568449125,
-0.0451581553,
0.0266819187,
-0.0022183601,
0.0028091457,
-0.0347941853,
0.007691246,
0.0271351226,
0.0447084643,
0.003807486,
0.0762615427,
0.034091875,
-0.0355151258,
0.0022508358,
-0.0032108466,
0.0009630668,
-0.0148102986,
0.0067769582,
-0.0026160451,
-0.0313135087,
0.010832075,
0.0310781486,
-0.0337868109,
0.0730571598,
-0.0053522368,
0.0252066702,
-0.0195630901,
-0.0272145979,
0.0577377938,
-0.0265732892,
0.0570904687,
-0.0186374336,
-0.0307832249,
-0.0197202917,
-0.0281522851,
-0.0434840471,
-0.0365025625,
-0.0088271983,
0.0009914177,
-0.0515810326,
-0.0355553962,
-0.0304279607,
0.0089051742,
-0.0165640432,
-0.0112746432,
0.0261348914,
0.0127610546,
-0.0366510227,
0.0063758232,
-0.0463433117,
0.0428127497,
-0.0078695714,
-0.0020085215,
0.0053522051,
-0.0307143591,
-0.0039917212,
0.00525301,
0.0052678329,
-0.0459420793,
0.039876014,
0.0368730165,
0.0370462574,
-0.0452514142,
0.0058976277,
-0.0311238114,
-0.0110123279,
-0.0754981712,
0.0046215244,
-0.0787766203,
-0.0128969969,
0.0298125409,
0.0169596858,
-0.043472562,
0.0072258539,
0.0502807796,
-0.0263985135,
0.0460649766,
0.0269640312,
0.0230901446,
0.0245349966,
0.0176404882,
0.0255619697,
0.0538493581,
-0.0388972312,
0.0439715497,
0.0546216294,
-0.0088484921,
0.0190200526,
0.0213175286,
0.0007990549,
0.0087139513,
-0.0093986532,
0.0519195609,
-0.0058523999,
0.015953552,
0.0291460026,
0.0434345864,
-0.0212948266,
0.0045589334,
0.0061911489,
0.0535629168,
0.0440356843,
-0.0162060354,
0.0239273198,
0.042978067,
0.0110376738,
-0.0617389791,
-0.0138218766,
0.0179011989,
-0.0464194641,
0.0256704111,
0.0340085849,
0.0502319932,
-0.0066791144,
-0.0187698305,
-0.0522155501,
0.0203858651,
-0.0019862861,
0.0203811936,
0.0719218105,
0.0010489207,
-0.032847181,
0.0288998969,
0.021425344,
-0.0468911678,
0.0084151402,
-0.0493735783,
0.0267307032,
0.035076607,
0.0910244435,
-0.0600060299,
0.0017970314,
-0.0015507182,
0.0071993526,
0.0424827375,
0.0212059226,
-0.0052702017,
-0.0136070531,
-0.0314876549,
-0.0360840857,
0.0002257793,
0.0139746396,
0.0016613856,
0.0675800443,
-0.0237457361,
0.03015057,
-0.0451291129,
-0.0314621516,
0.0327292718,
-0.0233098492,
-0.0287001971,
-0.0076843677,
-0.0128011247,
0.0068421466,
-0.0021541517,
-0.0248605609,
0.0343952551,
0.0507021174,
-0.0165903084,
-0.0208535399,
-0.0529177897,
0.0206180215,
-0.015116876,
0.0245737731,
0.0048813568,
0.0156742632,
0.0568310246,
-0.0155308349,
0.0069264392,
-0.0081398506,
0.0058465819,
0.0046553025,
-0.0646333247,
0.0271986313,
-0.0078636007,
0.0075831073,
-0.0964524075,
0.0544481091,
0.0398130938,
0.0425893478,
0.0064258925,
0.0051559983,
-0.012259772,
-0.0236749258,
-0.0563144833,
-0.0206753798,
-0.0358286835,
0.0416581221,
0.060433466,
0.0183527973,
-0.0727135241,
-0.0111109652,
-0.0807829201,
0.0493374132,
-0.0121641979,
0.0019067653,
-0.0078221625,
0.0190087296,
-0.0236948021,
-0.0053748637,
-0.0065125362,
-0.0393782556,
0.0369907729,
0.0296269171,
0.0093113128,
-0.0047544972,
0.0003690013,
-0.0244720411,
-0.0336659513,
0.0255967621,
0.0746480301,
-0.0086588655,
0.0120008355,
-0.0354916789,
0.0578682311,
-0.035307195,
-0.0119206933,
-0.0063260701,
0.0086707855,
-0.0195759051,
-0.0252196062,
0.0419607498,
0.0125204446,
-0.0229093283,
0.0083400253,
0.0244214442,
-0.0442660972,
-0.0809811503,
0.0053160945,
-0.0067236358,
-0.0585542545,
-0.0005789955,
-0.0199211612,
0.0176545717,
0.0193771031,
-0.0084288381,
-0.010591411,
-0.0203453172,
0.0025677537,
-0.034604758,
-0.0153211141,
-0.0574713871,
0.0037057931,
-0.0103810057,
0.0378461815,
-0.0313056782,
-0.0586195812,
0.055586379,
-0.0342193097,
-0.0379398353,
-0.0689800978,
-0.0132345129,
-0.0742132887,
0.0720564649,
-0.0323375985,
-0.0044165957,
-0.0414851084,
-0.0155970082,
0.0007140666,
-0.0039559784,
-0.0169033073,
-0.0805016607,
0.0903506204,
0.0027663647,
0.0316403061,
-0.0024082146,
-0.0190880913,
-0.0404965505,
-0.0276278388,
-0.0186751094,
0.0100048399,
-0.024477642,
-0.0160968341,
-0.0492683016,
0.0144092273,
0.0531483516,
-0.0184702855,
-0.0212399028,
-0.0185718536,
0.0046991487,
0.0313802585,
0.078558892,
-0.0165423062,
-0.0059717661,
0.008488954,
0.0149048483,
0.0348189548,
0.0231484864,
0.0085273562,
-0.0254286844,
-0.011973653,
0.0516194627,
-0.0349743515,
0.0379903987,
0.0159275122,
0.0166442059,
-0.0613571405,
-0.0261351876,
0.0699932724,
0.0298981387,
-0.0479652286,
-0.0456872247,
-0.049476631,
0.0456613377,
0.0445784442,
0.0490428619,
-0.0369859785,
-0.0339890644,
0.0202363301,
0.0219321903,
0.0182308201,
0.0023060166,
0.027831018,
-0.1272967607,
0.0479182489,
-0.0204146188,
0.0135221565,
-0.0437200256,
-0.0493095517,
0.0279212203,
0.0063868607,
0.0308344085,
0.0533825345,
-0.0713657141,
-0.0164069273,
0.0167249646,
-0.000698609,
-0.0565652288,
0.0567057431,
-0.0663842559,
0.012977683,
0.0943628773,
0.0009546771,
-0.0030810372,
-0.0198583491,
0.019314466,
0.0043811216,
-0.0025910113,
-0.0268455986,
0.0391548686,
0.0112996111,
-0.0053207679,
-0.0451506525,
-0.0168637391,
-0.0359900631,
-0.0124697201,
0.0149107901,
0.0615406819,
-0.0219520256,
0.0045540589,
-0.0396855883,
-0.0244746897,
-0.016364092,
0.1029961854,
0.0199774113,
0.0003372942,
-0.0268297978,
0.0120506315,
-0.0039082235,
-0.0072658304,
-0.0777788237,
0.0101736374,
-0.0174411833,
0.0134803439,
-0.0568294786,
-0.0253731944,
0.0463636965,
-0.0119394464,
-0.0012909368,
0.0419659652,
-0.0631468073,
0.0203558598,
-0.0793475881,
0.0679002702,
-0.0561181419,
0.0388688892,
-0.0577946976,
0.0287046935,
0.0813337713,
-0.0362015627,
-0.0289498232,
0.0322381705,
-0.0809368715,
-0.03770395,
-0.0136741521,
0.0002688548,
0.020685751,
-0.0077419188,
-0.0267242324,
-0.0531654842,
0.0605247058,
0.0108114211,
-0.0620073341,
0.0005984289,
-0.0162356962,
-0.0188176502,
-0.0409060158,
0.0213027596,
-0.0767819583,
0.0074534183,
-0.0007519177,
0.1000403091,
0.0307031963,
-0.0476729721,
0.0189716481,
0.007941368,
0.0851831436,
0.0131687988,
-0.0533440374,
-0.0376559496,
-0.0318248011,
-0.0432702936,
-0.0204176139,
-0.0160100814,
0.0228432138,
0.0142894927,
-0.0131233018,
-0.0017207511,
0.0360437594,
-0.0195135437,
0.0719458908,
-0.0356449708,
0.0207710601,
-0.0054365573,
-0.0169651099,
0.0279901493,
0.0150303524,
-0.0317152515,
0.0035335806,
-0.0171302315,
0.0330402441,
-0.0071402369,
0.0364672616,
-0.0090319384,
-0.0280426592,
-0.0186563581,
0.0154411402,
-0.0391185805,
-0.0321142189,
0.0215745494,
0.0226742905,
0.0455448143,
-0.0147546902,
0.0602003299,
-0.0221662112,
-0.0238792915,
-0.0502532348,
-0.0031883873,
-0.0198286697,
-0.0012490193,
0.0307880472,
0.0401759632,
-0.0381347127,
0.0120678032,
0.0340558216,
0.0240922291,
0.0045080744,
-0.0088232495,
-0.0678109303,
-0.013698875,
-0.0493822582,
0.0384083949,
-0.0038182875,
-0.0410122387,
-0.0190871581,
-0.0691156387,
-0.0659372509,
0.021476632,
-0.0154521558,
-0.0408154503,
-0.0267437343,
0.0231211483,
0.0941568315,
0.0251594596,
-0.0044942056,
-0.0687125549,
0.0287598241,
-0.0541655421,
-0.0278780609,
-0.0189733915,
-6.230862825e-33,
-0.0007857445,
-0.0422401056,
0.0249509402,
-0.0679420307,
-0.0027061065,
0.0421683118,
0.0000987997,
0.0042717727,
-0.0111392625,
-0.0048256852,
-0.0147401188,
-0.0009484561,
0.0123690693,
0.0006949942,
0.0156878438,
0.0044556265,
0.0221506078,
0.0223718286,
-0.0215158947,
0.0037416366,
0.0276893117,
0.0636963248,
0.021477608,
-0.0398234129,
0.0301903486,
-0.0180189461,
0.0071887439,
0.0171857812,
-0.0204641428,
0.0976262391,
-0.0288917888,
0.0477551073,
0.0327568129,
-0.0584220923,
0.0058453586,
0.0367164649,
-0.0753885508,
0.009345145,
0.0216919314,
-0.0289698187,
-0.0280950163,
0.004411574,
0.0313892886,
-0.0072854026,
-0.0083520561,
-0.0065534916,
0.0519164205,
-0.024315061,
-0.033902403,
-0.0425568409,
-0.0327140354,
0.027519729,
0.0406581089,
-0.0340121686,
0.0355988368,
0.0319918692,
0.0090643922,
0.0712991431,
-0.0598647334,
0.0023475471,
-0.0396096632,
0.0509662032,
0.0630331412,
0.0256958548,
-0.0045622266,
0.0534291118,
-0.0274122786,
-0.0141044809,
0.0090205632,
-0.0508608855,
0.0289099533,
0.0692026168,
0.0057105199,
0.0427261144,
0.0019015612,
0.0110814376,
-0.0371684805,
0.0411217809,
-0.014500211,
0.0851560161,
0.0467850938,
0.0054176594,
-0.0498818792,
0.0023195804,
-0.0393774472,
0.0579672121,
-0.0795215666,
-0.028679138,
0.0527829528,
0.0351190567,
-0.0259507988,
0.0372441709,
0.0559630916,
-0.0220007095,
-0.0205607433,
0.0503437705,
0.003599674,
0.0113870651,
-0.0293171387,
0.0505722873,
0.0010443198,
0.0145529779,
0.001752653,
-0.0380616151,
-0.022094056,
-0.0265659448,
-0.015429398,
-0.0140968496,
-0.0725606754,
-0.0137509527,
-0.0030721377,
0.0106897708,
-0.0436129458,
0.055265367,
-0.0042110663,
0.0368223004,
0.0095124496,
0.0490177497,
0.0476532355,
-0.0200174283,
-0.0374160409,
-0.0098701324,
0.0272263102,
-0.0421370119,
-0.0062635923,
0.034422446,
-0.0381959416,
0.0275476053,
0.0319812447,
0.0272734165,
0.0091956193,
0.0112292245,
2.596e-7,
0.0428365208,
0.0388766192,
0.0096430993,
0.0411636867,
-0.0287623703,
0.0104195587,
-0.0269574374,
0.0071773636,
0.0651235059,
0.0089963879,
-0.0298950411,
0.0137696238,
0.0834112838,
0.0098655252,
-0.0738429725,
-0.0191370249,
-0.0377833657,
-0.0170700829,
-0.0579635166,
-0.0241694357,
0.0125846751,
0.0847703442,
0.026685277,
-0.0165118817,
-0.041837655,
-0.0588570386,
0.0500394627,
-0.0329872407,
-0.0284953788,
0.0446114205,
0.0172554348,
0.0076206424,
0.0385865569,
-0.0270243715,
0.0160203986,
0.0051284032,
0.0354465395,
0.0697911829,
0.0059128702,
-0.035390798,
-0.0107875224,
0.0039708233,
0.0073827221,
-0.0539276414,
0.0480123609,
-0.0314785428,
-0.0026627062,
-0.0279238001,
-0.0110379625,
-0.0148835201,
0.0103468001,
-0.0405693464,
-0.0255615674,
0.0040015997,
0.0012159526,
0.0074119098,
-0.049458608,
-0.0739026889,
-0.0163665824,
-0.0003476836,
-0.0617789663,
-0.0513849035,
-0.0409883484,
-0.0039948877,
-0.0245817285,
-0.0686633363,
0.01382084,
2.832661746e-34,
0.0374280103,
0.0191799123,
-0.0157718081,
0.0367657878,
0.0540938079,
-0.005021465,
-0.050362993,
0.0445819199,
-0.0264852066,
-0.1271402091,
0.019212313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11678v1 | TourRank: Utilizing Large Language Models for Documents Ranking with a Tournament-Inspired Strategy | 2024-06-17T15:58:22 | 2024-06-17T15:58:22 | Yiqun Chen, Qi Liu, Yi Zhang, Weiwei Sun, Daiting Shi, Jiaxin Mao, Dawei Yin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly employed in zero-shot documents
ranking, yielding commendable results. However, several significant challenges
still persist in LLMs for ranking: (1) LLMs are constrained by limited input
length, precluding them from processing a large number of documents
simultaneously; (2) The output document sequence is influenced by the input
order of documents, resulting in inconsistent ranking outcomes; (3) Achieving a
balance between cost and ranking performance is quite challenging. To tackle
these issues, we introduce a novel documents ranking method called TourRank,
which is inspired by the tournament mechanism. This approach alleviates the
impact of LLM's limited input length through intelligent grouping, while the
tournament-like points system ensures robust ranking, mitigating the influence
of the document input sequence. We test TourRank with different LLMs on the
TREC DL datasets and the BEIR benchmark. Experimental results show that
TourRank achieves state-of-the-art performance at a reasonable cost. | [
0.0315359719,
0.0321491323,
-0.0028629329,
0.0464963391,
-0.0196573995,
-0.0130596533,
0.0261169225,
0.0007099605,
0.0439317934,
-0.0631402507,
-0.0255173948,
-0.0070356964,
-0.0115764141,
0.0032039878,
0.0078315437,
-0.0438241176,
-0.0012152743,
-0.0425713509,
0.0090180235,
-0.0314819217,
-0.0158271678,
0.0017470076,
0.0210784413,
-0.0209994223,
0.0931367055,
0.021989679,
-0.0275083277,
0.0052844766,
0.0079103205,
-0.0192990061,
-0.0500940196,
0.011952877,
0.0217670482,
0.0747819245,
0.0000017388,
-0.0677929819,
-0.067037344,
-0.0058147218,
-0.0031493953,
0.024123216,
0.011364066,
0.0296463519,
0.0274301432,
-0.0016935086,
-0.0281240251,
0.0025729004,
-0.0231321342,
0.007677014,
0.0554774776,
0.0540898927,
-0.0076348432,
-0.0352377072,
0.0158311408,
-0.0460916609,
-0.0004365096,
-0.0588594675,
0.0148367081,
-0.0266661327,
0.0520267561,
0.0459697172,
-0.013105344,
-0.0045068939,
-0.029249426,
-0.0267005339,
0.0416201837,
0.0324128531,
-0.0813077763,
0.0130621595,
0.0024487507,
0.0687188208,
-0.0453075916,
-0.0085395817,
0.0371376537,
0.0044743125,
-0.0040599951,
0.0255841967,
-0.0606487319,
0.0266954545,
0.0214742497,
0.0014694203,
0.0084369462,
0.0491817817,
0.0212394744,
0.0378270857,
-0.029512208,
0.0397371277,
0.0108540803,
-0.0335450955,
-0.0245774277,
0.000173861,
-0.014775971,
-0.0414273217,
0.0035229747,
0.0097945193,
-0.0254542436,
-0.0023065656,
0.002434205,
0.0330346152,
0.017212119,
-0.0772533789,
-0.0176258758,
-0.0300615076,
0.0354617722,
0.129136458,
-0.0063409805,
0.0420131423,
0.0037290759,
-0.0236217324,
-0.0326128937,
0.0053490717,
-0.0190730616,
-0.0103318635,
0.0413251817,
0.0199396275,
-0.0239406973,
-0.0316978469,
-0.0307407528,
0.0031165876,
0.0024316253,
0.0347651765,
0.0614397824,
0.0021630309,
-0.0041346634,
-0.0189167652,
0.0189769175,
-0.0037313958,
-0.0082537029,
-0.0048376042,
-0.0412704088,
0.0187437721,
0.0128404507,
0.011095101,
-0.0078633931,
-0.0096486509,
0.026492022,
0.0467726216,
0.0094390996,
-0.0110117607,
0.021864878,
-0.0304076523,
0.0250615478,
-0.0445234105,
-0.0030709179,
-0.058594726,
0.0522679277,
0.0157271139,
0.0346885696,
0.0287779868,
-0.0072857016,
-0.0037619413,
-0.0763394982,
0.0441652685,
0.0205133948,
-0.0013845703,
0.0428508669,
0.010558608,
0.0082747117,
0.0117628789,
-0.0091541335,
0.0252065193,
0.0645156577,
0.0018063027,
-0.0155342994,
0.0469531305,
0.0009061443,
0.0076333708,
-0.0104383761,
0.0225044508,
-0.0084680365,
0.0275760144,
-0.0199139751,
-0.0037684902,
-0.0422461666,
-0.0231883097,
0.0516252108,
0.0472691618,
0.0661604255,
0.0072498284,
-0.0480920114,
-0.0111535601,
-0.0224431362,
-0.0326699018,
0.0135938488,
-0.0127879558,
-0.0169936754,
-0.0094107026,
0.0718531534,
0.0146828694,
-0.0324082561,
0.0060187429,
-0.0195710342,
0.0530635081,
-0.0122136297,
0.01188445,
0.0350073315,
-0.0457115769,
0.0105788447,
0.0417694002,
-0.0005380017,
-0.0442767926,
0.0166469384,
-0.0167920049,
-0.019928202,
0.0872778147,
0.0733703822,
-0.0560559966,
0.0227894317,
0.0033586011,
0.0414672233,
-0.00809089,
0.0398306847,
-0.0165940393,
-0.0116023188,
-0.0385533869,
-0.031103557,
0.0684336051,
-0.0133477403,
0.0182189252,
-0.0208207928,
0.0438260138,
0.0146667808,
-0.0408740155,
-0.0205753166,
0.0045732027,
-0.0053653931,
-0.0234340169,
0.0212021433,
-0.0372389778,
0.0249969307,
0.0196032897,
-0.0091949385,
-0.0109272432,
0.0638531595,
-0.0170374904,
0.0129563743,
-0.0496982262,
0.0251932107,
-0.0242531653,
0.036578577,
-0.0093120458,
0.0122292824,
0.0445163287,
-0.0573504418,
-0.0286954157,
-0.0161424186,
0.0194412824,
0.0083921636,
0.002875095,
0.04756549,
-0.0120238885,
-0.0276853405,
-0.0530441515,
0.0850303993,
0.0003776501,
0.067155607,
0.0323102511,
-0.0130286589,
-0.0137970457,
-0.0335984342,
-0.0471053869,
0.0837364867,
0.0341028869,
-0.0017250649,
0.0405120254,
-0.0044803829,
-0.0159386713,
-0.0247610565,
-0.0886128023,
0.0148896733,
0.0297167171,
0.0022831282,
-0.0049903854,
-0.0206345525,
0.0020798403,
-0.0070104003,
-0.0486984216,
-0.0220128,
0.0133761158,
-0.0072470997,
0.0039839852,
-0.0197722726,
-0.023615934,
-0.0332139507,
-0.0797244981,
0.0058325012,
0.0788512081,
0.002387706,
-0.0116731962,
-0.0499586798,
0.0164252799,
-0.0629117116,
0.0065830899,
-0.0340670869,
0.0132208662,
-0.0407148451,
-0.043241296,
-0.0341059752,
0.0454929322,
0.0311990175,
-0.028567126,
0.0476378985,
-0.015904557,
-0.0772550628,
-0.0121771656,
0.0055941958,
0.0468869992,
-0.0043816534,
-0.001055503,
-0.0152212819,
-0.0108434157,
-0.0409534872,
-0.0060230563,
-0.0067524598,
0.0158989672,
-0.0243975688,
0.0164450053,
-0.0866760388,
-0.0187640376,
0.0177067667,
-0.0073006423,
0.0033483324,
-0.0139745716,
0.0265910197,
-0.0264721029,
0.0208683368,
-0.0551507771,
0.0159620643,
-0.0674406514,
0.0272527654,
0.0518165566,
0.0122913085,
-0.1074609533,
0.0242225118,
-0.0025051117,
0.0237422623,
0.0264871046,
-0.0645612776,
-0.0098021841,
0.0196240991,
0.0220023077,
-0.0165414792,
-0.0518007725,
0.0021521803,
-0.0318692662,
0.0059704627,
-0.0007510665,
0.0170547292,
-0.0177150406,
-0.061649397,
0.0351682678,
0.0346469246,
0.0573574007,
-0.0217285808,
-0.0096739838,
0.0212734193,
0.0958394185,
0.0319960713,
-0.0243197959,
0.0178756732,
-0.032538496,
0.0375058465,
0.0508717895,
0.0615473911,
-0.0091155935,
0.0199704543,
0.0098351603,
0.050507728,
-0.0588771701,
-0.041179806,
-0.009167904,
-0.0345769413,
-0.0029964875,
0.0051965364,
0.1046634167,
0.0583675988,
-0.0822557956,
-0.0019883984,
-0.0023356616,
0.0497091636,
0.0075238957,
0.037281584,
-0.0571155176,
0.0202060044,
0.0129233245,
0.0428189524,
0.0050918832,
-0.0373719037,
-0.0136365322,
-0.1096625701,
0.0405981392,
0.0168880764,
0.0268305577,
0.0499768741,
-0.0634852201,
-0.0030146339,
-0.0297022462,
-0.0552968569,
0.0384730957,
-0.0146728028,
-0.0022480772,
-0.0114304358,
-0.019746827,
-0.0031979873,
0.01965902,
-0.0209312942,
0.0147213135,
-0.0020817125,
0.0424259603,
-0.0193277225,
-0.0175448973,
0.0346050747,
0.0073307813,
-0.0231146552,
-0.0303043704,
0.027706651,
-0.021546308,
0.0344806239,
-0.0037617036,
-0.0168172624,
0.0167421438,
0.047962416,
0.0148233538,
0.06384442,
0.0143559761,
0.0060043768,
-0.025601849,
-0.0373431928,
-0.0489666834,
0.0460249856,
-0.0371056795,
-0.0360815451,
-0.0061765201,
-0.0490194894,
0.0422529168,
0.0354549326,
-0.0512194075,
-0.0015703704,
-0.0202379692,
-0.0602103472,
-0.0520646386,
-0.0149210924,
-0.0076274709,
0.0213980358,
-0.0207083132,
0.046708066,
-0.038560681,
-0.0168086588,
-0.0503682382,
-0.0116797201,
0.0361105427,
-0.0039112605,
-0.0560479909,
0.045922406,
0.0761546344,
-0.0293598287,
-0.04831459,
-0.005108926,
-0.0262494441,
-0.0534256175,
0.0014166074,
0.0532711782,
0.0224274304,
0.0183808934,
-0.0072076549,
-0.0841428712,
0.0506394282,
0.0459720641,
-0.0078080297,
-0.0045863427,
-0.0043829056,
-0.0400925279,
-0.0343452767,
0.017798489,
-0.0785848573,
0.0343976393,
-0.0108119734,
0.024318343,
-0.0368082337,
-0.0298380964,
-0.0005539355,
0.0581793673,
0.05562675,
0.0109722931,
-0.0042976425,
-0.0033431456,
0.0651490241,
-0.0579244941,
-0.0576163568,
0.0067016413,
0.0129322521,
0.046109207,
-0.0043594618,
-0.0288606975,
0.0230771508,
0.0241818689,
-0.0061141164,
-0.0858887136,
0.0189358704,
0.0278842598,
-0.0349665135,
-0.0054193707,
-0.0042946944,
-0.0133590251,
0.0037870803,
-0.0019980168,
0.0301841833,
-0.0497240126,
-0.0341636911,
0.0271853022,
0.0089519396,
-0.0371775404,
0.0687726662,
-0.0830180496,
-0.0083147744,
-0.0141219366,
0.026595559,
0.0763767585,
0.0030160868,
0.0382063761,
-0.0004027855,
-0.0204698518,
-0.0051553166,
-0.0715568662,
0.0219583046,
-0.0150516191,
-0.0444113202,
0.0683280677,
0.0164934322,
0.0799120516,
0.0890328512,
0.0498867296,
-0.0384503417,
0.0205496754,
-0.0495951846,
-0.025745267,
0.034171313,
0.0041277446,
0.045958519,
-0.0015243813,
-0.0112043032,
-0.0096874414,
0.0127783585,
0.0282079484,
-0.0068072295,
0.0182775278,
-0.0300445743,
0.0354311988,
0.0734818652,
0.0035859509,
0.0032294744,
-0.0488463938,
0.0198703129,
-0.010342747,
-0.0549106523,
-0.0101150218,
-5.898568939e-33,
0.0242358539,
-0.0453367978,
-0.0135887368,
-0.0135152098,
-0.0004389161,
0.0021689823,
0.0274917502,
-0.0361490585,
0.0150940781,
-0.0185641609,
-0.0498205274,
0.0196505077,
0.0121521829,
0.0209555887,
0.0497200266,
0.0253313743,
0.0258855578,
0.0038666774,
-0.0360669158,
0.0025660701,
0.0197735149,
0.0244559851,
-0.019984968,
-0.0442818962,
0.0101571735,
-0.0385321975,
-0.0012226764,
-0.0179832522,
0.0302752107,
0.0541682653,
0.0204472262,
-0.0046688104,
0.0356466509,
-0.0809021741,
0.0217081234,
-0.0167204775,
-0.0174097829,
-0.0125435367,
-0.0087065082,
-0.0084795933,
0.0267614983,
0.0158708654,
0.0121362284,
0.0247151423,
-0.0150632951,
-0.0229152106,
0.0376929827,
0.0030222037,
-0.0617875122,
-0.0498405471,
0.0366758108,
0.036556419,
-0.0244734325,
0.0274488349,
0.0552129336,
0.0148699861,
-0.0330409482,
0.0843493342,
-0.0499902479,
0.0538178831,
-0.024153363,
0.0793019012,
0.0254056621,
-0.0168781746,
-0.0168489441,
0.0598497428,
0.0005345473,
0.0006735526,
0.0251426231,
-0.04090764,
-0.0328934789,
-0.0172864441,
0.0525767691,
0.0096122241,
0.030346401,
0.0265454967,
-0.0780757219,
0.0380528532,
0.0296593178,
-0.0150562618,
0.0067555802,
0.0311641693,
-0.0520214401,
-0.0201186817,
0.0181985479,
0.0025181193,
-0.0318583548,
-0.004986573,
0.0065136193,
0.0170502756,
-0.0443007275,
-0.002980035,
0.0351635925,
-0.0199969374,
-0.0889544487,
0.0690849498,
0.0105017889,
0.0387300029,
-0.0163688399,
0.0308403168,
-0.0542710014,
-0.0172555223,
-0.0083709257,
-0.0191651154,
-0.0283555202,
-0.031155467,
-0.0117458776,
-0.0140709206,
-0.0167840812,
0.0119749056,
0.0458069555,
-0.0347858481,
-0.0461635403,
0.036367435,
0.0098489169,
0.0052755359,
0.0168927573,
0.0402570628,
0.0365743823,
-0.0009641332,
0.0064932718,
-0.0175748579,
-0.0205583703,
-0.027870832,
0.0081127509,
0.0156422742,
-0.0071582757,
0.0478456207,
0.0118819326,
-0.051812686,
-0.0213715658,
-0.0041729049,
2.626e-7,
0.0262569282,
0.0969588161,
-0.0379525721,
0.0088619506,
0.0147627471,
-0.0272453707,
-0.0234305412,
0.0877135321,
0.0320822299,
0.0538869053,
0.0079115871,
-0.0052702986,
0.0232396554,
0.0382940546,
-0.073194541,
-0.0239214581,
-0.1111903042,
-0.0010092999,
-0.0683288723,
-0.0749390796,
0.0252596121,
0.0978816971,
-0.0127855632,
0.0218766481,
-0.0296715945,
-0.0686535686,
0.024390446,
-0.0162561182,
-0.0273383409,
-0.0283350609,
0.0835278332,
-0.0253168102,
-0.0569572337,
-0.0141872382,
-0.0221111197,
0.0685531273,
0.0489598438,
0.0179333948,
-0.0503818765,
-0.0042856201,
0.0111392522,
-0.0329334624,
-0.0039012232,
-0.0410792902,
0.0729116425,
0.0024013403,
0.0031245782,
0.0161477495,
-0.0616992526,
-0.0432788618,
0.0288384482,
-0.0018188704,
-0.0335793719,
0.0456694551,
-0.0150574539,
-0.0340356641,
0.0225543883,
-0.0312348884,
-0.0162498299,
-0.0180244613,
-0.036900077,
-0.0210774746,
-0.006814722,
0.0086936066,
-0.0183407292,
-0.0348519608,
0.0150753176,
2.348797507e-34,
0.0701837614,
0.0117165456,
-0.0132936062,
-0.0277018361,
0.0046701441,
-0.0127020003,
-0.032832168,
0.0314046293,
0.033549495,
-0.1108853444,
-0.0027707631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11675v2 | BLoB: Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation by Backpropagation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T15:55:38 | 2024-06-18T15:15:04 | Yibin Wang, Haizhou Shi, Ligong Han, Dimitris Metaxas, Hao Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Large Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from overconfidence during
inference, particularly when adapted to downstream domain-specific tasks with
limited data. Previous work addresses this issue by employing approximate
Bayesian estimation after the LLMs are trained, enabling them to quantify
uncertainty. However, such post-training approaches' performance is severely
limited by the parameters learned during training. In this paper, we go beyond
post-training Bayesianization and propose Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation by
Backpropagation (BLoB), an algorithm that continuously and jointly adjusts both
the mean and covariance of LLM parameters throughout the whole fine-tuning
process. Our empirical results verify the effectiveness of BLoB in terms of
generalization and uncertainty estimation, when evaluated on both
in-distribution and out-of-distribution data. | [
0.0094113955,
0.090016529,
0.0030784323,
0.0221753437,
0.0309143178,
0.0332628712,
-0.0198252518,
-0.0128225628,
-0.0391875952,
-0.0368598737,
-0.0572234057,
-0.0576561876,
0.0253399834,
-0.0065727094,
0.0556718521,
-0.0137666063,
0.0214013942,
-0.0549825281,
0.0225313511,
-0.0325554311,
-0.0319937244,
0.0182935316,
-0.0236375071,
0.006260416,
0.0445591584,
0.0150104677,
0.0143606961,
0.0243338365,
0.0357688591,
0.0161577333,
0.0135020912,
0.0527999923,
0.0192001034,
0.0354920812,
0.0000017159,
-0.0414748602,
-0.0081807598,
-0.0269397497,
-0.0110334791,
0.0252896976,
0.0356773213,
0.0193609018,
-0.031574659,
0.0222898554,
-0.00065227,
-0.0153400423,
0.0560787246,
0.0126231704,
0.0209575333,
0.077369146,
0.0007449934,
-0.0046481211,
-0.0060395198,
-0.0591642857,
-0.0094908345,
-0.0891851634,
0.0337596163,
-0.0086582527,
-0.010024488,
0.0066437824,
-0.0454079732,
0.0379366539,
-0.0385109633,
0.0284423996,
-0.0122843627,
0.0276878122,
0.0082269274,
0.0267292168,
-0.0118703768,
0.0479647294,
-0.0511640906,
-0.0218666252,
0.003125156,
-0.0223035477,
0.0159778595,
0.0037965751,
-0.0465696044,
0.0314309895,
0.0458724722,
0.0119717,
0.0064175692,
-0.0548101328,
0.0678068027,
0.0088172713,
-0.0420925617,
0.0649857149,
0.0384193286,
-0.0121479416,
-0.0094695259,
-0.0081471521,
-0.0447892137,
0.0026666264,
-0.0243713968,
0.0254781134,
-0.0293812435,
0.0279167015,
-0.0427578725,
-0.0568466559,
-0.0056932666,
-0.0549627952,
0.0300563835,
0.0367368162,
-0.0062634284,
0.0535359792,
-0.0194750149,
0.0242825449,
-0.0163862426,
-0.003741086,
-0.0401512086,
-0.0144220693,
-0.0144862849,
0.0298257582,
-0.019410396,
-0.0136871804,
-0.0223170798,
0.0070273699,
-0.0283259805,
0.0191226881,
0.0241130479,
-0.00458042,
0.0326281972,
0.001462534,
-0.0492649376,
-0.0442320965,
0.0026045302,
0.0573516972,
0.0045255078,
0.0188956819,
-0.0054259421,
-0.0160776768,
0.0013513379,
-0.0198588222,
0.0484503061,
-0.0329789408,
0.0294360369,
0.0396507792,
-0.0258621667,
-0.0343318284,
-0.0382907614,
0.081757918,
-0.0573438331,
-0.0699228495,
0.0147398226,
-0.0433237627,
-0.002344843,
0.0010486548,
0.0279819388,
-0.0759861767,
-0.0036306637,
-0.0159633476,
-0.0877046213,
0.0656558275,
0.0117092626,
0.0062143165,
0.0533013828,
-0.0121571319,
-0.0179521348,
0.0786151588,
0.0449879654,
-0.0006674761,
0.0153033435,
0.003052098,
-0.0245587174,
0.0453567915,
0.0009828315,
0.0497314744,
-0.050678879,
-0.0206224453,
0.0273181237,
0.0291424729,
0.0323258527,
0.012714358,
0.0018695523,
-0.0144774206,
0.0772347152,
0.0192769095,
0.0334641449,
0.0147310169,
0.0077411244,
-0.0248610228,
0.0022496199,
-0.0269167498,
-0.0393064618,
0.0102337692,
-0.0268107224,
-0.0026872754,
0.0307056773,
0.0458179638,
-0.0180119723,
-0.0295377038,
-0.0294857547,
0.018000938,
-0.025709182,
0.0282695778,
0.1032984555,
0.0025227203,
0.0001159153,
0.0084306626,
0.0379805453,
-0.0171532966,
0.0142085869,
-0.049852971,
0.0239078235,
0.017137656,
0.0165795311,
-0.0466237664,
-0.0178496372,
-0.0171167385,
0.0017428308,
-0.0021127567,
0.0132681821,
0.0197886899,
0.024831621,
-0.0472690351,
0.0010128344,
-0.0029093248,
0.052947361,
0.0438258611,
-0.0298439469,
0.010506561,
0.0304136444,
-0.0467162989,
-0.0352012292,
0.0315246321,
-0.0310480651,
-0.0357291847,
0.0423026718,
-0.0311494339,
0.0373739004,
-0.0252697617,
-0.0123179844,
0.002574882,
0.0201582052,
-0.0029557219,
0.0015623779,
-0.0292986576,
0.0295773856,
-0.0156926736,
0.0608386844,
-0.0010309574,
0.0187700428,
0.0298228469,
-0.0439004675,
-0.0650295317,
0.0665251389,
-0.0203686263,
0.002729984,
-0.0157331154,
0.0539312139,
-0.019183185,
0.059735287,
-0.0332091898,
0.0230679587,
0.0000866047,
-0.0059934286,
0.0306331906,
0.041769091,
-0.0187928453,
-0.0256538019,
-0.0504765213,
0.0343713686,
-0.0076356279,
0.0256916098,
0.0082092257,
0.0180159938,
-0.0087749129,
0.0054959315,
-0.0859672427,
0.0398897342,
-0.0549769513,
0.0189583637,
0.0405183807,
0.0255550966,
-0.0204643086,
-0.0287569873,
-0.0071495115,
0.0158475041,
-0.0102620693,
-0.0034274142,
0.0061510438,
0.0292662513,
0.0034102427,
-0.0526690483,
-0.0242218766,
0.014832899,
0.0392626077,
-0.0319139436,
-0.0059860134,
-0.086391516,
0.0443064123,
-0.0277772415,
0.0550170913,
-0.0286916606,
-0.0443771034,
-0.041825369,
-0.0588841923,
0.0603192337,
0.0613262765,
-0.0006086209,
-0.0243625827,
0.1151590422,
0.0113319596,
-0.0230323486,
0.0107881315,
-0.034979675,
-0.0516140312,
-0.0403847061,
-0.022594735,
-0.0075320862,
0.0554615632,
-0.0343625471,
-0.0367375501,
-0.0544580743,
0.0219769944,
-0.0148145454,
0.003524842,
-0.0756793544,
0.0412303023,
-0.0310098454,
0.0189722665,
0.0097488528,
-0.0400666669,
0.0363506339,
-0.0312211681,
-0.0014144692,
-0.0415963233,
-0.0370609947,
-0.0027305547,
0.0268403478,
-0.0125689814,
0.0023680953,
-0.0327367038,
-0.0065345005,
-0.0828759447,
0.0261279792,
0.0249384642,
-0.0211275239,
0.0196592156,
-0.053018976,
0.0071886056,
-0.0208257586,
-0.0133333299,
-0.0204010494,
-0.042449709,
-0.0423593968,
0.0021686866,
0.0213109311,
-0.070946604,
-0.0138917705,
-0.0051747444,
0.0080693364,
0.0630009919,
-0.0250803307,
0.0010547581,
-0.0185655039,
0.0076673725,
0.0707655102,
0.0254644956,
0.0717845336,
-0.022326408,
-0.0206768978,
-0.0149255861,
0.0620167889,
-0.0210634675,
-0.0225464962,
0.0027546224,
0.0434885882,
0.0103792036,
-0.0100662531,
0.052797161,
0.0183170047,
-0.0251798294,
-0.0404824056,
0.0901122913,
-0.0060124332,
-0.0748755038,
-0.0067534726,
-0.0160008054,
0.0374777056,
0.0166219845,
0.0617113188,
-0.0109634427,
-0.0219776426,
0.0121544544,
0.0195397269,
0.0278378595,
-0.0051606609,
-0.0129148923,
-0.1016216129,
0.0165254846,
0.0232200399,
-0.0223907717,
-0.0219997726,
-0.0387415476,
0.0323511809,
-0.0171271563,
0.0381968059,
0.0236831643,
-0.0203084107,
-0.0219364502,
0.0376059003,
-0.0134237241,
-0.1018540338,
-0.021181481,
-0.0301911421,
0.0772675648,
0.0271519739,
0.0266809314,
-0.0320012197,
-0.0191714745,
0.0290965941,
-0.0335754305,
-0.0452995934,
-0.0098374542,
0.0323298424,
0.0030114572,
0.0021271345,
0.0671221763,
0.0285475347,
-0.0264778789,
0.0158568975,
0.0075041889,
0.0612082109,
-0.0153776184,
-0.0180997252,
0.0144747375,
-0.0208224058,
-0.0216595288,
0.0139696728,
0.0119088264,
-0.0340653099,
0.007188783,
-0.0163859688,
-0.0226292741,
0.0105380453,
0.0149500491,
0.0286576487,
-0.0352708921,
-0.0198511034,
-0.0604943447,
0.0341561697,
0.0265741963,
0.0224723034,
-0.00026493,
0.0161974113,
-0.0149295228,
0.0174268875,
-0.0382087864,
0.0394225121,
-0.0246833265,
0.011899326,
-0.020877881,
0.0110628214,
0.0412168913,
-0.0232526343,
-0.0145383533,
0.0087967031,
-0.0839862153,
-0.0831997693,
-0.0079247756,
0.0548753887,
0.0227617901,
0.0177816749,
-0.022792099,
-0.0989133641,
0.0294687171,
-0.0119050937,
0.0216191933,
0.0311489534,
0.0378511734,
0.0016994725,
-0.0183127429,
0.035506662,
-0.083045572,
-0.0032015117,
0.0519991815,
0.0258941371,
0.0034845998,
-0.0519970357,
-0.0303107612,
0.0087359715,
0.0527415834,
-0.0360779688,
-0.0506628565,
-0.0554910526,
0.0156183578,
-0.0242275707,
-0.0006992152,
-0.0274509136,
-0.0023678038,
0.0397893712,
-0.0007019429,
-0.0143649383,
0.0015855427,
0.025755208,
0.0125788469,
-0.0527533926,
-0.0252492987,
0.0120554678,
0.0000418938,
0.0621415712,
0.0034346527,
-0.0083876755,
-0.0082996171,
0.0673189908,
0.0293260068,
-0.0013194029,
0.0174475182,
0.0254921112,
-0.0481156558,
-0.0799960345,
0.000628998,
-0.0997468382,
-0.0791313797,
-0.0441937894,
0.0439386107,
0.0792735517,
0.0145557504,
0.0835363939,
-0.0099242758,
-0.0237219185,
-0.020282317,
-0.0056784195,
0.0043008137,
0.0406407937,
0.0518311784,
0.0027674031,
-0.0143659515,
0.0524275899,
0.0651087612,
0.0747080371,
0.0462216176,
-0.0420361236,
-0.0064603291,
-0.0161471199,
-0.0149846524,
-0.0114283739,
0.0455452241,
-0.0350855291,
-0.0004372104,
-0.0032874222,
-0.0812566504,
-0.034660168,
-0.0048120408,
0.0019087009,
-0.0392068066,
-0.0127047924,
0.035264425,
-0.0217037071,
0.0172729716,
-0.0359551124,
-0.0313919,
0.0073510385,
0.0044909222,
-0.0150404572,
-6.521411233e-33,
-0.031395983,
0.0019442006,
-0.0110348724,
-0.0318293422,
-0.012210588,
-0.02125182,
-0.0058858586,
0.023245329,
0.0043729418,
0.0226870049,
-0.0245671961,
0.0300177038,
0.0179604478,
0.0232364312,
0.0229781102,
0.0078873169,
0.0630626678,
-0.0025125367,
-0.00992228,
0.0122784385,
0.0394312553,
0.0623218678,
0.0768956169,
-0.0070752925,
0.0105951289,
0.001704777,
-0.055627577,
0.0285154786,
-0.0018965527,
0.0173440725,
-0.0188197512,
0.0434423089,
0.0096376622,
-0.0011935506,
-0.0382900201,
0.0244482402,
-0.0475955531,
0.0036798934,
0.0022659702,
-0.0021927576,
-0.0005700244,
0.0031577772,
0.0065385965,
0.0421140045,
-0.0129375206,
-0.0210887268,
0.0295587853,
-0.0605089478,
-0.0187363233,
-0.0232924055,
-0.0141531685,
0.0252100471,
0.00771055,
0.0117244534,
0.0209575165,
0.0365547389,
-0.0233583879,
0.0041479184,
-0.0222866312,
-0.0114950463,
0.0259985831,
0.0670809746,
0.0649988577,
0.0694199279,
-0.0138805555,
0.009394452,
-0.0012065551,
0.0031018839,
0.020173803,
-0.0211917274,
0.0612750985,
0.0136265932,
0.0331376381,
0.0299901683,
0.0224481374,
-0.0081554083,
-0.0838488117,
-0.0059546577,
0.0166603457,
0.0142820273,
0.0225267038,
0.0437057093,
-0.016957799,
-0.0166244786,
-0.0635168999,
-0.0139174461,
-0.0234747808,
0.0141862882,
0.0081975646,
0.0210855529,
-0.0331370011,
-0.0161636248,
0.0263989437,
-0.0485366285,
-0.000752287,
-0.0045839814,
-0.0157980081,
0.0049092523,
0.010042673,
0.0578605533,
-0.0337393656,
-0.0616890602,
0.0022349576,
0.0057474165,
-0.0096488735,
-0.0107268859,
0.0248882156,
0.0130221406,
-0.0662911236,
-0.0030703279,
-0.0148073416,
0.0154421963,
0.0065047918,
0.0788905621,
-0.005814435,
-0.0253577475,
0.0075164367,
0.0664833486,
0.0559164844,
0.0147532308,
0.043614585,
-0.0140432836,
0.0173958782,
-0.0039219111,
-0.0610808916,
-0.0146541605,
0.0115366178,
0.0110995201,
0.0648137182,
-0.0590905063,
-0.0249927305,
0.017065404,
2.59e-7,
0.0496171042,
0.0575820692,
-0.0538523532,
-0.0204693265,
0.0298626851,
0.0261360854,
-0.0316612758,
0.0042839712,
0.0450155288,
-0.0016374475,
0.0519595742,
-0.0064842002,
0.0786513016,
0.0082229357,
-0.0600155331,
-0.0749513209,
-0.0707151145,
0.0297475159,
-0.0288175847,
-0.0326298662,
-0.0140972668,
0.120324716,
0.0104111172,
-0.0111010429,
-0.0049919854,
-0.0306770205,
0.0711910054,
-0.0389814489,
-0.0087090842,
0.0138926283,
0.0474159755,
0.0232888907,
-0.021406889,
0.0001589563,
-0.0302171204,
0.0886812806,
-0.0298617072,
0.0694304854,
-0.0070723924,
0.0169213656,
0.0220877174,
0.0435126498,
0.0196944419,
-0.0556601956,
0.0527296849,
-0.0806478858,
-0.0161131807,
-0.0599795729,
-0.0061205411,
-0.0303504597,
0.0442567356,
-0.0565814674,
-0.0188956037,
-0.0174642131,
0.0238319542,
-0.0097303381,
-0.0253794994,
-0.1069660112,
0.0063917101,
0.0516826212,
-0.0636367723,
-0.0550260134,
-0.0043014912,
-0.041416537,
0.0351160765,
-0.0680031627,
0.0367645696,
2.141718335e-34,
0.0687765926,
-0.0232829861,
-0.0282723773,
0.023947347,
0.0236914419,
-0.0308655854,
-0.001574979,
0.0081420746,
0.0402931534,
-0.1003689915,
-0.0154144801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11674v1 | Endor: Hardware-Friendly Sparse Format for Offloaded LLM Inference | 2024-06-17T15:55:08 | 2024-06-17T15:55:08 | Donghyeon Joo, Ramyad Hadidi, Soheil Feizi, Bahar Asgari | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of large language models (LLMs) challenges their usage on
resource-constrained platforms. For example, memory on modern GPUs is
insufficient to hold LLMs that are hundreds of Gigabytes in size. Offloading is
a popular method to escape this constraint by storing weights of an LLM model
to host CPU memory and SSD, then loading each weight to GPU before every use.
In our case study of offloaded inference, we found that due to the low
bandwidth between storage devices and GPU, the latency of transferring large
model weights from its offloaded location to GPU memory becomes the critical
bottleneck with actual compute taking nearly 0% of runtime. To effectively
reduce the weight transfer latency, we propose a novel sparse format that
compresses the unstructured sparse pattern of pruned LLM weights to non-zero
values with high compression ratio and low decompression overhead. Endor
achieves this by expressing the positions of non-zero elements with a bitmap.
Compared to offloaded inference using the popular Huggingface Accelerate,
applying Endor accelerates OPT-66B by 1.70x and Llama2-70B by 1.78x. When
direct weight transfer from SSD to GPU is leveraged, Endor achieves 2.25x
speedup on OPT-66B and 2.37x speedup on Llama2-70B. | [
-0.0011388974,
0.024989184,
-0.0143834688,
0.0661450922,
-0.0333965905,
-0.0014766477,
0.0215108693,
0.0433426425,
0.0022879262,
-0.0144991614,
0.0241580307,
-0.0192146003,
0.0185164697,
-0.0353841297,
0.002764059,
-0.0239781439,
0.0331197791,
-0.0321392901,
-0.0185553655,
-0.0307801813,
0.0294186976,
0.0316739082,
-0.0002947937,
-0.0124627342,
0.004773654,
-0.0178412851,
-0.0562329255,
0.0195870791,
0.0103037311,
-0.0110037792,
-0.03411505,
0.0164077356,
0.036188487,
0.0256454051,
0.0000024029,
-0.0154553009,
-0.0208276659,
0.0062349061,
-0.0393272005,
0.0455869585,
0.0965978205,
-0.0172767211,
-0.0417932756,
-0.0117925461,
0.0028122233,
-0.0179804824,
0.0637004822,
-0.0165045876,
0.0059615802,
0.032391116,
-0.0136001064,
0.0044730962,
0.0137430653,
-0.0159174688,
-0.0026450332,
-0.0084367516,
-0.0010164618,
-0.0191245582,
0.0025922945,
-0.0068853595,
-0.0209267568,
-0.0092444709,
0.015470379,
0.0157195739,
-0.0215568002,
0.0331906825,
-0.0408604965,
-0.0205758624,
-0.0018699756,
0.0284965523,
-0.052704528,
-0.0481220409,
0.0136654545,
-0.0229053814,
-0.0170765184,
0.0022256996,
-0.0397685021,
0.0816965029,
-0.0132082319,
0.0306991152,
0.0602043532,
-0.0187245198,
0.0152769554,
-0.0005400506,
-0.0422231816,
0.0612132363,
0.0439168625,
0.0142499441,
-0.0490109213,
-0.0058950139,
-0.0574459508,
-0.0528593399,
0.0202812292,
0.0257326569,
0.0079471618,
0.0109024756,
-0.0870801285,
-0.0512480438,
0.017923696,
-0.0518688746,
0.1066924483,
0.0758355483,
-0.009466297,
0.0072405231,
-0.0433006845,
0.0063434965,
-0.0213287696,
-0.0389900208,
-0.0269772857,
0.0222309139,
0.0372557044,
0.0142823895,
-0.0398063399,
0.0607864559,
-0.0662299544,
-0.0223305617,
-0.0279538091,
0.0110949315,
-0.0188345145,
-0.0438539386,
0.0028246855,
0.017671017,
-0.0072898618,
0.0247184914,
0.0029188066,
0.0272302944,
-0.0019522565,
0.0190389492,
-0.0208651088,
-0.0952734351,
-0.0166681092,
0.0471921675,
0.0352292992,
-0.0355315767,
0.0402224958,
0.0257617049,
0.0085320724,
-0.0565103218,
-0.0320188738,
-0.0142106889,
0.0501516052,
-0.0581737719,
0.0151340608,
-0.0984276608,
0.0303088855,
0.0203824639,
0.0037139435,
-0.0110146664,
0.0233487971,
0.049905505,
-0.0290689822,
0.0342145078,
-0.0424915217,
-0.0195242409,
-0.0115706688,
-0.0149372593,
0.0102274232,
0.0737300143,
0.0158004165,
0.0425959006,
0.0132486969,
-0.0004281978,
-0.0522211492,
0.0382462703,
0.0376069844,
0.0335459821,
-0.074843891,
-0.0003472554,
0.0042941915,
0.0185196698,
0.0743462071,
0.0508238226,
-0.0284125395,
-0.0291446038,
0.0264131837,
0.0761997923,
-0.0353874192,
0.0368372761,
-0.0163613092,
0.0251650978,
-0.0057267677,
-0.004654028,
-0.0116576143,
0.0319644772,
-0.022914296,
0.0055912235,
0.0793935508,
0.0668495074,
0.017044127,
0.0113010695,
-0.032789968,
-0.0111895287,
0.0121731916,
0.0233878605,
0.0183944795,
-0.0169790424,
-0.0333601907,
0.0854355469,
0.070957996,
-0.0933507308,
-0.0970877334,
-0.0326438695,
0.0383302569,
0.0157338958,
0.007220306,
0.0170233324,
-0.0700343922,
0.0507536307,
-0.0028646917,
0.0240253955,
-0.0206613708,
0.0257741418,
0.0216785558,
-0.0652601495,
0.0159687568,
0.0370565876,
0.0145610049,
0.0335723422,
0.0418778844,
0.0322422981,
-0.0019015626,
-0.039330747,
-0.0290472135,
0.0089738704,
0.0067229145,
0.0142969834,
-0.0017513011,
-0.015414496,
0.0051954244,
-0.0262945723,
0.0065512322,
-0.0277260672,
0.0743712634,
-0.0458451323,
0.0352533758,
-0.0496512763,
-0.0353563726,
0.0178940855,
0.0498938225,
0.0047081555,
0.0255099908,
0.0474860594,
-0.0344919227,
-0.0409494191,
0.0193395223,
-0.0077135121,
0.0381708667,
-0.0540739745,
0.0070406185,
0.0078828838,
0.055838529,
0.0051516891,
0.0605130829,
-0.0386230424,
0.0588002428,
0.0380612053,
0.0073301261,
0.0282251686,
-0.030040754,
-0.0241658892,
0.0059213447,
-0.0053462973,
-0.0158980247,
-0.0213419572,
-0.0082879821,
0.0262455475,
0.0271530431,
-0.1202307045,
0.0334343389,
-0.0247312747,
0.0384763367,
0.0378439911,
0.045774065,
0.0040911809,
-0.0140925692,
-0.0008480994,
0.0546091497,
0.0171497967,
0.0158194955,
-0.0106756976,
-0.0250312202,
-0.0176729802,
0.0112797963,
-0.0280546676,
-0.0078383228,
0.0338652097,
-0.0198858641,
-0.0291380715,
-0.0366175286,
0.0576482899,
-0.022126792,
0.0638745576,
-0.0042589391,
-0.0050111129,
0.0172374714,
-0.0477599949,
0.0186035428,
0.0558680296,
-0.0235752687,
0.0070950594,
0.0624256842,
0.0036214744,
-0.0384009331,
0.0174310077,
0.0046703322,
0.0115338787,
-0.0062143723,
-0.0342238918,
-0.0746468231,
0.0700793564,
-0.0206878893,
-0.0385822803,
-0.0046396502,
-0.0531110205,
0.0076514329,
0.0011531564,
-0.0207978413,
0.0241413265,
-0.0243149586,
0.0229965411,
-0.0160849206,
-0.0714634135,
0.0138485264,
-0.0634489879,
-0.000614399,
0.034188278,
-0.0479831509,
-0.0484269969,
0.058304105,
0.0212227516,
0.0090164943,
-0.0340197012,
0.0230597835,
0.0318203159,
0.0358114503,
-0.0006639318,
-0.0404052734,
0.0011046064,
-0.0378633626,
0.0322592333,
-0.0552965999,
0.0004034184,
0.0253605247,
0.037244603,
-0.0437079519,
-0.0059976759,
-0.0060053812,
-0.0551596731,
-0.0031968409,
0.0226705726,
-0.0175055936,
0.0412051976,
-0.0280157365,
0.0191124771,
-0.0137907136,
-0.014521502,
0.0496527851,
0.0509653017,
-0.008259139,
-0.0063127438,
-0.0643544719,
0.0590644814,
0.0213294458,
-0.0012203885,
-0.0960858539,
0.0033294631,
0.0910989195,
0.0155831585,
-0.0439519063,
0.0539920554,
0.0244226046,
-0.0573198833,
0.0036924244,
0.060121052,
0.0125939129,
-0.0360005796,
-0.0019583451,
0.0004165464,
0.0682377294,
0.0385422669,
0.0487253554,
-0.0956137627,
-0.044724144,
0.0107715912,
-0.0030804144,
0.0044369902,
-0.0179656446,
-0.0020459287,
-0.1093672588,
0.0673591271,
0.000840169,
-0.0025969397,
0.0235185809,
-0.0686932057,
-0.0180611406,
0.0300895832,
-0.0278115161,
-0.0041937977,
-0.007430282,
0.0147130853,
0.0125913462,
0.0034386516,
0.0428829901,
-0.0131545374,
0.0083198017,
0.0061720097,
0.0042389249,
0.0139243565,
-0.0158626698,
-0.0844099671,
0.0418494195,
0.0115632145,
-0.0174619481,
-0.0498198494,
-0.0130206021,
0.0148149831,
0.0147292772,
-0.0356545486,
-0.0063633774,
-0.0122652426,
-0.0201499667,
-0.0469122566,
0.117252022,
-0.0209404659,
0.0048591755,
-0.0078783017,
-0.0467152074,
-0.0145501019,
0.015082526,
0.0009440971,
0.0223581865,
-0.0357206017,
-0.0498974435,
-0.0298460275,
0.0133781731,
-0.0236227233,
-0.0052340147,
-0.0189296547,
-0.0287293531,
0.031077059,
0.0492386222,
0.0120142605,
0.0386464521,
-0.0063621588,
0.0163044203,
0.0016496669,
-0.0337911136,
-0.1077190712,
0.0138573041,
-0.0284631364,
0.0457587913,
-0.0350206345,
-0.0011177768,
0.0050920467,
-0.0048181922,
0.0105840471,
0.0247810073,
-0.0975005776,
-0.0609451011,
-0.0103641022,
0.0282949954,
0.0200664178,
0.0303696357,
0.0071899835,
-0.0485920422,
0.0211960431,
0.0490802638,
-0.0336853564,
0.0705470368,
-0.0188314617,
-0.0689694583,
0.0217049122,
0.0156700723,
0.0085976608,
0.0076385983,
0.0021200143,
0.0264746286,
0.0059495205,
-0.0417376794,
-0.0165466983,
0.0436941013,
0.0245999992,
-0.0151572274,
-0.0528272353,
0.0100747095,
0.0541638695,
0.0047987523,
0.0154612223,
-0.022941485,
0.0065485206,
0.0049434765,
0.0116798803,
0.0017358679,
-0.0032591885,
0.0481791385,
0.0153935719,
-0.0287839938,
0.0329308957,
-0.0023125596,
-0.0354721099,
0.0283180363,
-0.0083726887,
0.0074326205,
-0.0211994369,
0.0028948362,
0.0714291856,
-0.0444627367,
-0.0000289403,
0.0117198052,
0.0209643003,
-0.033181183,
0.0097418437,
-0.0041552875,
-0.0485483296,
-0.02201524,
-0.0040728571,
0.0314567313,
0.0001971715,
0.0274141058,
-0.0039218795,
0.0135209067,
-0.0250097606,
0.0541253835,
-0.0369395241,
-0.0402935781,
0.0525073744,
0.0274985973,
0.0000634308,
0.0303683616,
0.0246252455,
0.0258973017,
0.0361644402,
0.0255333949,
-0.0023926948,
-0.0201773029,
-0.0485392138,
-0.0090957396,
0.0154377921,
-0.0030717198,
-0.0064116153,
-0.0038373475,
-0.0413296483,
0.0280270949,
0.0160634182,
-0.0067129154,
-0.0594584458,
0.0158876423,
0.0343994088,
0.0162603687,
-0.0229886509,
-0.0135605028,
0.0204346981,
-0.0089376615,
-0.0182080846,
-0.0083902869,
-7.074288103e-33,
-0.0038201853,
-0.022721421,
0.0390020423,
-0.0155741842,
-0.0235044323,
0.0039733411,
-0.024352232,
-0.0019431496,
0.0102409525,
-0.00734916,
-0.0302302092,
0.0012734106,
0.0130813755,
0.0087994011,
-0.027233135,
0.034202151,
0.0003211805,
0.0205283072,
-0.0290822107,
0.0074932114,
0.0371595733,
0.032852497,
0.0311272852,
-0.016259972,
-0.032498952,
-0.0390803441,
0.0546790957,
-0.0150963925,
-0.0202216003,
0.0207968708,
-0.0446274392,
0.0168651491,
0.0058194757,
-0.0285572764,
0.0138825085,
-0.0098171839,
-0.0699772835,
-0.0312705263,
0.0624958314,
0.032482557,
-0.0229876488,
-0.0541843772,
-0.0218242817,
0.0564839914,
-0.0186843444,
-0.0108423382,
-0.0232567545,
-0.0171975382,
-0.0637362897,
-0.0000938806,
-0.0459980331,
0.0305822417,
0.0597368553,
0.0532568246,
0.0584797673,
-0.0523383543,
-0.0385892428,
-0.0019973873,
-0.036750827,
-0.0146979252,
0.0314421728,
0.0793517381,
0.0670316815,
0.0001217825,
0.0254153479,
0.0251148213,
-0.0033927534,
-0.0370765887,
-0.0370632075,
0.0522233658,
0.054515738,
0.0287050847,
-0.0299299788,
-0.0171519686,
0.1041828543,
-0.0040341704,
-0.0543915257,
-0.0087358085,
0.0488938838,
0.0035816077,
0.0384731293,
0.03039838,
0.0067730984,
-0.0623958111,
0.0098701138,
-0.0004042588,
-0.0404985398,
-0.0217580758,
0.0010623472,
0.0253749713,
-0.0363209397,
-0.0134135177,
0.0193279702,
-0.0153036043,
-0.008016414,
-0.0404860564,
0.0175161753,
0.0160492342,
0.0341861993,
0.0288963299,
-0.0227099638,
-0.0492955036,
-0.0022037446,
-0.0544244498,
0.056070365,
-0.0107398648,
0.0351506025,
0.0408053249,
-0.0586450621,
-0.0049083633,
-0.0517546833,
-0.0049417792,
0.0115921032,
0.0705811977,
0.0319937281,
0.0042124721,
0.0317981318,
0.0238572247,
-0.0237812828,
0.0157995336,
-0.0536323786,
-0.0337185971,
-0.012375216,
0.0114312852,
-0.0652986988,
-0.0107750446,
-0.058166869,
0.0250793193,
-0.003993758,
-0.0713668317,
-0.0456368737,
0.0655626878,
3.162e-7,
0.0121496171,
0.0085702389,
0.0145382592,
0.0389620066,
-0.0190232079,
-0.0090603353,
0.0167267099,
0.0162504315,
0.0215783436,
-0.0362767056,
-0.0280209891,
0.0332156457,
0.030345127,
0.0038715808,
-0.0460138917,
0.0116810631,
0.0063327788,
-0.024311753,
-0.0098738838,
-0.0108199809,
-0.0289615355,
0.1048856825,
-0.0172460992,
-0.0246764403,
0.0466298833,
0.0286525618,
0.008893095,
-0.0051962482,
0.0362170599,
-0.0621455126,
0.0174010154,
-0.0021788257,
-0.0625491664,
0.0007046991,
0.0241195187,
-0.0135921547,
-0.0658257753,
0.0670266524,
-0.0283433553,
0.0216980353,
0.0352666527,
-0.0394238271,
-0.0340054743,
-0.0153214196,
0.0522266477,
0.0551031157,
-0.0018020117,
-0.0789510831,
-0.01018239,
0.0047421316,
-0.0353062823,
0.0145726195,
0.0781557038,
0.0295158643,
0.0330984071,
-0.0653583258,
-0.0360215865,
-0.0268879533,
-0.0595870726,
0.011366237,
-0.0324932858,
-0.0615241937,
-0.0773137882,
0.0132880807,
0.0120120533,
-0.0458133891,
-0.016731821,
3.377583275e-34,
0.0198312234,
0.0270086657,
-0.0108808903,
0.0919092074,
0.0093300808,
-0.0509762652,
-0.0123977056,
0.0459432974,
-0.0383651182,
-0.091779381,
-0.041815117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11670v1 | Benchmarking of LLM Detection: Comparing Two Competing Approaches | 2024-06-17T15:51:46 | 2024-06-17T15:51:46 | Thorsten Pröhl, Erik Putzier, Rüdiger Zarnekow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This article gives an overview of the field of LLM text recognition.
Different approaches and implemented detectors for the recognition of
LLM-generated text are presented. In addition to discussing the
implementations, the article focuses on benchmarking the detectors. Although
there are numerous software products for the recognition of LLM-generated text,
with a focus on ChatGPT-like LLMs, the quality of the recognition (recognition
rate) is not clear. Furthermore, while it can be seen that scientific
contributions presenting their novel approaches strive for some kind of
comparison with other approaches, the construction and independence of the
evaluation dataset is often not comprehensible. As a result, discrepancies in
the performance evaluation of LLM detectors are often visible due to the
different benchmarking datasets. This article describes the creation of an
evaluation dataset and uses this dataset to investigate the different
detectors. The selected detectors are benchmarked against each other. | [
-0.0126169063,
-0.0517888404,
0.0343074389,
0.125404492,
-0.0669769123,
0.027618112,
-0.0088739293,
0.1105253398,
0.0407631211,
-0.0252272431,
-0.0254305005,
0.0193335637,
-0.00323644,
-0.0122582968,
-0.0069104205,
0.0293407515,
-0.0113960383,
-0.0393704623,
-0.0068494454,
0.0179538373,
-0.0087335538,
-0.0222014226,
-0.0135466419,
-0.0031626613,
-0.0107448604,
0.0002056656,
-0.0098024271,
0.044731833,
0.0677497685,
-0.0500479527,
-0.044131048,
-0.0158054177,
-0.0013791168,
0.0402934961,
0.0000016775,
-0.0710855424,
-0.0349421464,
0.0075679994,
-0.0010031724,
-0.0273596812,
0.0813404396,
0.0138940169,
-0.057478115,
0.0026195638,
-0.0018033166,
0.0593894422,
0.0200502202,
0.0722603872,
-0.0246282909,
0.0916003436,
-0.0292370617,
-0.0283819381,
0.0602722876,
0.0145043237,
0.0090448996,
-0.0096332617,
0.030565301,
0.0145661328,
0.020825021,
0.0146873286,
0.0235471074,
0.0076090842,
-0.0006480113,
-0.0263923481,
-0.0082669528,
0.0261252001,
-0.0219691508,
0.0109995939,
-0.0804898292,
0.0174076073,
-0.038403172,
-0.0051739337,
0.0422539823,
-0.0302533135,
-0.0170098469,
0.0043452359,
-0.0047231717,
0.0363373607,
-0.0503011942,
0.0385904163,
-0.0093472544,
0.0159936436,
-0.0089173764,
-0.0122772083,
-0.0214061569,
0.0621339642,
0.0220276341,
-0.0429439135,
0.0083427243,
-0.0080144675,
0.016417563,
-0.0076927198,
0.0522054918,
0.0365483724,
0.0885021538,
-0.0043408368,
-0.0429705419,
-0.0526627898,
0.0272179767,
-0.0515107736,
0.025213087,
0.0201390292,
-0.0344387554,
0.0464137197,
-0.1143640131,
0.0777689517,
-0.0370701812,
0.0818719938,
-0.0022515613,
0.0354258046,
-0.0004135217,
0.0185438748,
0.0085142236,
0.0130255884,
0.0189031549,
-0.0028258855,
-0.0361979641,
0.0189329684,
0.0646742359,
0.0149120186,
0.0096433852,
-0.0824626535,
-0.0047133891,
-0.0162062608,
0.006976869,
-0.0443989709,
0.0241858233,
-0.0120566087,
-0.0234151985,
-0.0707231686,
0.0179216247,
0.0905546099,
0.0391160846,
0.0028017249,
0.0360702276,
0.084707737,
-0.0335944742,
-0.0769813433,
-0.0488534495,
0.0159677807,
-0.0286103711,
-0.0008116876,
0.0410764478,
-0.043207556,
-0.018110916,
-0.02268029,
0.0122277709,
0.0160330981,
0.0140732275,
0.0022920449,
0.0336442739,
0.0509356968,
-0.052254796,
-0.03330753,
0.0474645831,
0.0129406154,
-0.0096323043,
0.0480558537,
0.0341057628,
0.0720042959,
0.030814318,
0.0022424066,
0.011922325,
0.0881945565,
-0.044390142,
0.0043726512,
0.0052583376,
-0.0393047035,
0.0025682375,
0.007399281,
0.0460715629,
0.0423126854,
0.0012398628,
-0.013975325,
0.0565379411,
0.1027813926,
0.0424684174,
-0.0122282244,
-0.0501410253,
0.0230869427,
0.016412776,
0.0212347303,
0.0168385021,
-0.0111341225,
-0.0478520617,
0.0084912488,
0.0072921421,
0.0362205543,
0.0127627216,
-0.0236311816,
-0.0432685688,
-0.0056929281,
-0.022873098,
-0.0588187762,
0.0903898478,
-0.0334148891,
-0.0806439221,
0.0144921942,
-0.0181430709,
-0.03678298,
-0.0456202887,
-0.0887541026,
0.0341189206,
0.0314109437,
0.0702169463,
-0.0646424517,
0.0188044198,
0.0164309666,
-0.0292522013,
0.0477918275,
-0.0352341421,
0.0657268763,
-0.0016637474,
-0.0632704422,
-0.0488615409,
0.0209389664,
-0.0323896855,
0.0516662374,
0.0087446989,
0.0575547107,
-0.0080703581,
-0.0065333415,
-0.0142113091,
0.0470965356,
0.0252903029,
-0.0288544055,
-0.0301306713,
0.0001950059,
0.0290719438,
0.0176730547,
-0.0310442932,
-0.0112095717,
0.0445750467,
-0.0517529957,
0.0064298925,
0.0050437483,
0.009436965,
-0.0324056447,
0.0697769821,
-0.0498682596,
-0.0037500381,
-0.0054126554,
-0.0178231616,
-0.0089330524,
-0.0458158925,
0.0041463682,
0.017660927,
-0.0693225563,
0.0282694865,
-0.0047523882,
0.0166847613,
-0.0497408845,
0.0535650626,
-0.0371144339,
-0.0022613425,
0.0267262757,
-0.0006729295,
0.0344140939,
-0.0375790708,
-0.004401641,
0.0297517218,
-0.0221343711,
0.0216261875,
-0.0206335727,
0.0593948551,
-0.0222165175,
-0.0726914555,
-0.0191686787,
-0.0010903483,
-0.0310473889,
0.0365186185,
0.0308961403,
-0.0535391867,
-0.0175680593,
-0.0183871537,
-0.0278234687,
0.0217599813,
0.0004433774,
-0.05922883,
0.0557269156,
-0.0318606012,
-0.01949214,
0.0223473404,
0.0301183593,
0.019786194,
-0.0152237406,
0.0158123672,
-0.1023481339,
-0.083298251,
0.0682940111,
0.0303356275,
-0.0262838602,
-0.0209283736,
-0.0239595734,
0.0098575894,
-0.0329196379,
0.0061639016,
0.04914454,
0.0214420035,
-0.0300472043,
-0.0011099064,
0.0252418611,
-0.0254468936,
-0.0127475774,
0.0270360876,
0.0226004496,
0.0044380599,
-0.0471681543,
0.0271915756,
0.0132416543,
-0.0289202463,
0.0700284392,
0.0114859734,
-0.0450636223,
-0.0334708728,
-0.0348350629,
-0.0168062449,
0.0241437983,
-0.0595062226,
0.0166668966,
-0.003522079,
-0.0650064275,
-0.0334800296,
-0.0828526616,
-0.0234556124,
0.0083502335,
-0.0223419573,
-0.0533711314,
-0.0064869267,
-0.0019236936,
-0.0018211245,
-0.0197018236,
-0.0548415408,
0.0052305227,
0.0011821924,
0.0311169531,
-0.042282261,
0.0419250913,
0.0019102771,
0.0566196628,
-0.068278484,
0.0219500475,
-0.01108074,
0.007766597,
-0.0096666627,
-0.0334822424,
0.0055599413,
-0.0224992484,
-0.0029399372,
0.054455936,
-0.0161712393,
0.0463990644,
0.002239408,
0.0157876033,
-0.0372709706,
0.0833062604,
-0.0398564935,
-0.0216138382,
0.0187272672,
-0.0165858977,
-0.0076199402,
0.0387367308,
-0.0112398658,
-0.0211997498,
-0.0317602195,
0.0075645447,
0.0303077269,
-0.0018579101,
0.0216067005,
-0.0057616513,
0.038720917,
-0.0081537571,
0.0353437178,
0.0496749766,
-0.0044291476,
-0.0548664816,
-0.0692074373,
-0.0257181656,
-0.0164125413,
-0.0243922267,
-0.0409297086,
-0.069417417,
-0.0100079216,
0.0357480831,
0.0154332276,
-0.0211435948,
0.0242977459,
-0.0195280164,
-0.0304542203,
0.0299069416,
0.0259190761,
0.0200752933,
-0.0088180974,
0.0262881424,
0.0125558721,
0.0281296652,
-0.0183467865,
0.0031695561,
-0.0084593715,
-0.0276388861,
-0.0034863797,
-0.0495727696,
0.0176837053,
-0.0452438295,
-0.0061018798,
-0.0192495771,
0.0438407958,
0.0490590334,
-0.0193570722,
-0.0391911827,
0.0419384204,
-0.009919459,
0.0132317627,
-0.0384211466,
0.0129462685,
0.0029491992,
-0.0108525185,
-0.0288315378,
0.0201432034,
0.0226932932,
0.0028411364,
0.0234306604,
-0.0075603183,
-0.0382226072,
0.0014299392,
-0.0097835427,
-0.0010916005,
-0.0172562283,
0.0293822624,
0.011185579,
0.0108023519,
-0.0617543608,
-0.0339367203,
0.0252110884,
-0.0292172134,
-0.0373411737,
-0.0000031477,
-0.0223303679,
-0.0142846275,
-0.0440318584,
0.0251426436,
-0.0413958691,
0.0113797784,
-0.0027941945,
0.0365480371,
-0.0279555824,
0.034165021,
-0.0474646464,
-0.0450846478,
-0.0343706533,
0.0050748792,
-0.1048014536,
0.0539882705,
-0.0045650396,
-0.0502862185,
-0.0157385934,
0.0000131233,
-0.0676944479,
-0.0387766287,
0.0014556732,
0.0052698087,
0.0204336401,
-0.0223691445,
-0.0327237211,
-0.0237359647,
0.0604088455,
0.0462022536,
0.0374496281,
0.0087812226,
0.0152531294,
0.0355026238,
-0.0455839932,
0.004315645,
-0.0323545001,
0.0134694362,
0.0199514348,
-0.0505453385,
-0.0297550391,
-0.0426429957,
-0.0246026162,
0.0448405072,
-0.0058587696,
-0.0295715462,
0.0061860043,
-0.0055546323,
0.0313933231,
-0.0002621269,
0.0245214272,
-0.0241925865,
0.0293496177,
0.006476426,
-0.0412976444,
-0.0116456738,
-0.0118368277,
-0.0222653672,
0.0077355374,
-0.0243200324,
0.0999977589,
-0.0027998318,
0.020280065,
0.0017737509,
-0.0122256018,
0.0144633725,
0.0339349806,
0.0105614522,
0.0205166731,
0.0284393355,
0.035199713,
-0.0032450627,
-0.0073004048,
0.038608782,
0.0554992817,
-0.0292889327,
0.0079351831,
-0.0310858618,
0.0693103895,
0.1044679731,
0.0506641418,
0.0495162234,
-0.0534955189,
-0.0026393167,
-0.026485052,
0.0067822067,
0.0237641186,
0.0330789648,
-0.0062486646,
-0.0157172177,
-0.0044587096,
-0.0026481147,
0.0274530295,
0.0131751858,
-0.0146844434,
0.0160913561,
-0.0142235281,
-0.0684026927,
-0.0043774643,
0.0138720619,
-0.0398975909,
0.0074716313,
0.0046760528,
-0.0097425785,
0.0263880901,
0.0753638521,
0.0127524231,
0.0160964169,
-0.0175767913,
-0.0051855156,
-0.0043353038,
0.0082082069,
0.0071459468,
0.0225350186,
-0.0072044036,
0.0045570531,
-0.0103628058,
0.0017691964,
-5.139959986e-33,
-0.0068872739,
-0.0856269747,
-0.0193943568,
0.0151410578,
-0.0222491175,
0.0220242683,
0.0200875569,
-0.0324953273,
0.0401080549,
-0.0419999659,
-0.0372486673,
-0.010517478,
0.0554033406,
-0.016306093,
-0.0531627275,
-0.0252933688,
0.0050861668,
-0.0346690267,
-0.0232982542,
-0.047754012,
0.016491022,
0.0322047882,
0.072623305,
-0.0586627722,
0.0068377005,
-0.0244569704,
-0.0250404347,
-0.0439350344,
0.0027233833,
0.0350490697,
-0.0114003923,
0.0094081033,
0.0403010845,
0.0104309907,
0.0025823794,
0.0484267473,
-0.014547932,
0.020934293,
-0.0421086587,
0.0803184956,
0.0180594604,
-0.0599491,
0.0254435446,
-0.032582581,
-0.063881442,
-0.0027192731,
0.0034454549,
-0.0524214692,
-0.0218644552,
-0.040163964,
-0.0231431089,
0.0723143667,
0.045230072,
0.0078786425,
0.0988343582,
-0.0426431224,
0.0153790824,
0.0192079544,
-0.0487327576,
-0.0029701905,
0.0462878272,
0.0241775569,
0.0418900959,
0.0366149433,
-0.0234378651,
0.0405056886,
0.0068038837,
-0.0059450967,
0.0241023749,
-0.0521260388,
0.0112464204,
0.0318608545,
0.0580095984,
0.0336217023,
0.0438924022,
0.0034594028,
-0.0186392386,
0.0408865362,
0.0318900347,
-0.0029052999,
0.022526104,
0.0350142531,
-0.0339852087,
0.0135968048,
0.0316444226,
-0.0226710849,
-0.0201539285,
-0.0183131304,
0.0494636707,
0.0144780688,
0.0017380085,
-0.0251113791,
0.0271977689,
-0.0081114201,
0.0109756738,
-0.0463089123,
0.0127496608,
0.0357951894,
-0.0057146819,
-0.0256354827,
-0.03794083,
-0.0459361523,
0.0349946395,
0.0077490923,
0.0053761834,
-0.0424591899,
-0.0076817316,
-0.0103765465,
-0.0789805725,
0.0205697641,
0.0036702736,
-0.0016254029,
0.0461299047,
0.0215175562,
0.0221899617,
-0.0950850621,
0.0332679562,
0.0202078745,
0.017387744,
-0.0076384256,
-0.0050222399,
-0.0039450554,
-0.0199893229,
0.0407887846,
-0.0378433801,
0.0663577318,
-0.0021093914,
0.0205567218,
-0.011076035,
-0.0021586865,
0.0061578425,
0.0063540367,
2.24e-7,
0.041369997,
0.0229111053,
0.0790217221,
0.0119087473,
0.0036094,
-0.0020221488,
-0.0515098013,
0.0053608045,
-0.0311912782,
-0.0085325362,
0.0091642011,
-0.0142109143,
0.0939591154,
-0.0295768268,
-0.0430689566,
0.0292086639,
-0.0190214012,
0.0117931738,
-0.04789472,
0.0473325737,
0.0914177299,
0.0057934779,
-0.0366842337,
-0.0227561761,
0.0230877958,
-0.0689105168,
0.0215451922,
-0.0540007837,
0.0472570322,
-0.0201162845,
0.0654592812,
0.027585173,
-0.0151095185,
0.0122972,
0.0165295657,
-0.0315977782,
0.0252601504,
0.0284109805,
-0.0058908486,
0.0133780623,
0.0086012166,
-0.0025907836,
0.007265117,
-0.0163266398,
0.0458358824,
0.0549341664,
0.0189269111,
-0.0188178588,
-0.0138425818,
-0.0699966699,
0.0129771112,
-0.0229857806,
-0.0022732676,
0.0314428881,
0.0257618185,
-0.029986497,
-0.0482493937,
-0.0268812086,
-0.0137220398,
-0.0475355461,
-0.0127853239,
-0.0428232029,
-0.0664559677,
0.0636224523,
0.0214389153,
-0.0396318138,
-0.0538886227,
2.112678344e-34,
-0.0200784151,
-0.0496609956,
-0.0186129492,
0.0601787232,
-0.0114258835,
0.0156772472,
0.0045001912,
-0.0152331432,
-0.0573041439,
-0.0304226205,
0.0338936709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11668v1 | "Not Aligned" is Not "Malicious": Being Careful about Hallucinations of Large Language Models' Jailbreak | 2024-06-17T15:51:01 | 2024-06-17T15:51:01 | Lingrui Mei, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Baolong Bi, Jiayi Mao, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | "Jailbreak" is a major safety concern of Large Language Models (LLMs), which
occurs when malicious prompts lead LLMs to produce harmful outputs, raising
issues about the reliability and safety of LLMs. Therefore, an effective
evaluation of jailbreaks is very crucial to develop its mitigation strategies.
However, our research reveals that many jailbreaks identified by current
evaluations may actually be hallucinations-erroneous outputs that are mistaken
for genuine safety breaches. This finding suggests that some perceived
vulnerabilities might not represent actual threats, indicating a need for more
precise red teaming benchmarks. To address this problem, we propose the
$\textbf{B}$enchmark for reli$\textbf{AB}$ilit$\textbf{Y}$ and
jail$\textbf{B}$reak ha$\textbf{L}$l$\textbf{U}$cination $\textbf{E}$valuation
(BabyBLUE). BabyBLUE introduces a specialized validation framework including
various evaluators to enhance existing jailbreak benchmarks, ensuring outputs
are useful malicious instructions. Additionally, BabyBLUE presents a new
dataset as an augmentation to the existing red teaming benchmarks, specifically
addressing hallucinations in jailbreaks, aiming to evaluate the true potential
of jailbroken LLM outputs to cause harm to human society. | [
-0.0058277659,
0.0391954556,
-0.012123825,
0.0238456,
-0.0507983938,
-0.0249391403,
0.0098128654,
-0.0110312384,
0.0413286462,
-0.0141316336,
-0.02140457,
-0.0302934535,
0.0284086298,
0.021559041,
0.0250836518,
0.016732404,
0.0728551596,
-0.0430279449,
-0.0126339514,
0.0250150394,
0.0088204267,
-0.0125171393,
0.0157702621,
0.0443294309,
0.0002396025,
-0.0184968095,
-0.0109326169,
0.0334202684,
0.0353268944,
-0.0408757664,
-0.0174918883,
0.030125441,
-0.0587549694,
0.0470094532,
0.0000022888,
-0.03903988,
-0.0304524489,
0.0311640278,
-0.0034101533,
0.0479774512,
-0.0046738395,
-0.0236830711,
-0.0385608636,
0.0372362807,
-0.0101773972,
0.0061890311,
0.041071251,
0.0229742676,
0.0576229468,
0.0621469468,
0.0154274181,
0.03245667,
0.0529177822,
0.0119798305,
0.0341589153,
-0.0216521118,
-0.005398016,
0.0054368665,
-0.0056852135,
0.0225586258,
0.0181271378,
-0.0469282083,
0.0420968235,
-0.014343515,
-0.0661650524,
0.0048099249,
-0.0609744228,
-0.0196389742,
-0.0037971672,
0.0345569663,
-0.0465811379,
-0.0270413309,
0.0115309069,
0.0024870732,
-0.0144925173,
-0.018122578,
0.0396791175,
0.0389158837,
-0.0254183002,
-0.0064075789,
0.0540765114,
0.0253674611,
0.0742891207,
-0.0200521462,
-0.0120983683,
0.0778074339,
0.0031943968,
-0.0205519255,
0.0177135337,
-0.0465699323,
0.0071643461,
-0.05542472,
-0.0377960801,
-0.0285073277,
-0.0044804439,
0.018975459,
-0.0623561591,
-0.0299555268,
0.0623372756,
-0.0782367736,
-0.0443468764,
0.0245780256,
-0.0153742544,
0.0121978456,
-0.008753553,
0.0049559786,
-0.0047567296,
0.0452558324,
0.0128053557,
0.0464697741,
0.0150950514,
0.0027721738,
-0.0087434519,
0.0174321141,
0.0266973674,
0.0358688943,
-0.0432310775,
0.0231530555,
-0.0594355017,
0.0494716018,
-0.0467007831,
-0.0144403148,
0.0231992472,
0.0227373205,
0.0496505424,
-0.0514422581,
-0.0291459691,
-0.0389941111,
0.0035511651,
-0.0949905589,
0.003486318,
-0.01315975,
-0.107664071,
-0.0396814942,
-0.017551519,
0.1140638664,
0.059999045,
0.006792374,
-0.0550946407,
-0.0775569975,
-0.0518465117,
-0.0260297433,
-0.0102238851,
-0.0784439147,
-0.0731280446,
-0.0151957786,
-0.0020161506,
-0.0531801581,
0.0131885745,
-0.0306794848,
-0.0447811075,
0.0366525613,
-0.0179713964,
-0.0223677494,
-0.0352697372,
0.0681928247,
0.0162397213,
0.074345313,
0.0115505792,
0.0560326502,
0.0424180217,
-0.0478926934,
0.0461167693,
0.0509240516,
-0.0272586439,
0.053310737,
-0.0337182954,
-0.0115930093,
0.0736818612,
-0.0381134301,
-0.0352751911,
0.0422972701,
-0.0036861356,
-0.0126628382,
0.051720053,
0.0010894032,
-0.0316179246,
0.0311282109,
-0.0329160169,
-0.0310304035,
-0.0064629754,
-0.0121253375,
-0.067740649,
0.0196995474,
-0.0931111798,
-0.0128028989,
-0.0029411179,
0.0336770788,
-0.0038532668,
0.0066003883,
-0.0140823517,
-0.0054094885,
-0.009900365,
-0.0150603624,
0.0082533099,
-0.0032680612,
-0.0189744588,
0.0456540473,
0.0367076695,
-0.0416076034,
-0.0425055474,
-0.0844820663,
-0.0095602376,
0.065042451,
0.0386677086,
-0.0169197675,
-0.0110342223,
-0.0020783525,
-0.0351746231,
-0.0130467871,
0.0085076448,
0.0247982256,
0.0205447786,
-0.0116019193,
0.0135257188,
-0.0216307938,
0.043561779,
0.024085125,
-0.0209612194,
0.0146268336,
-0.0118482187,
-0.028729273,
-0.0750557929,
0.0164759178,
0.027104469,
0.0245562214,
0.0007466726,
0.0314488225,
0.0040398738,
-0.0057894741,
-0.0525985993,
0.0309714694,
0.0398509614,
0.0213872064,
0.0277077369,
0.0313228965,
-0.0229525901,
0.0182918478,
0.031777855,
-0.0339621082,
0.0263699181,
0.0763440058,
-0.0205282439,
-0.0064499145,
0.0778638348,
-0.0285787079,
0.0047001895,
0.0305242874,
0.0537026636,
-0.0293306541,
0.022906838,
-0.0126063265,
-0.0037093516,
-0.026031075,
0.0286978874,
-0.0574566573,
0.0192865282,
0.0151484478,
0.0267271344,
-0.078254953,
0.018951837,
-0.0388197862,
0.0414479412,
0.0092186611,
0.0351604596,
-0.0296865087,
-0.0334204696,
-0.0541397706,
-0.0094282143,
-0.0359516814,
0.0371941067,
0.0599522069,
0.0200738087,
-0.0163132288,
-0.0093258722,
0.0172660928,
-0.0157399122,
0.0227063727,
0.0377715454,
-0.0032328113,
-0.0330634266,
-0.071998179,
-0.0127915433,
-0.0054855151,
-0.0138947796,
0.0635702014,
-0.0164915863,
0.0047410848,
-0.0252571683,
0.0242129117,
-0.001619107,
-0.0161752794,
-0.0223597046,
-0.0696234331,
0.0374008715,
0.0061067152,
-0.0019470829,
0.0352304317,
-0.0010007613,
0.0488433056,
0.0825362727,
0.0080560818,
-0.0464408286,
-0.0416044071,
0.0594494976,
-0.0497436672,
-0.0134113608,
-0.1016451865,
0.0161905084,
0.0617874116,
0.0000441939,
-0.0145001346,
-0.0280358437,
-0.0123854475,
-0.0180697255,
-0.0369145498,
0.018409593,
-0.0483327433,
-0.0336182006,
0.0109353792,
-0.0331692845,
-0.097711876,
0.0339743197,
-0.0578685477,
0.0226701554,
-0.0175283086,
-0.023833774,
-0.0199654605,
0.0361562371,
-0.0437671542,
0.0122710029,
0.033606343,
-0.0205035433,
-0.0022908298,
-0.0059931935,
0.0019836049,
-0.0273979362,
0.0399436206,
-0.0390224978,
-0.004083836,
-0.0103803119,
-0.0043133828,
-0.0288522076,
-0.038734775,
-0.0030533446,
-0.0366849154,
0.0372968353,
-0.0159196649,
0.0097450465,
-0.0039924383,
0.0173127241,
-0.016835114,
0.0154273622,
-0.0199433863,
-0.0056808065,
-0.0305111986,
0.0032489023,
-0.1034439802,
0.0565429479,
-0.0057634446,
0.044527337,
0.0729450062,
0.0488666333,
0.0282028075,
-0.0633756593,
-0.003882722,
0.0175426193,
-0.0025213244,
-0.0182670746,
0.0575068742,
0.0532235913,
-0.0181545019,
-0.0372996666,
0.0414312854,
0.0220112782,
-0.0028265798,
0.055134166,
-0.0169791337,
0.0695402771,
0.029671587,
0.0196987484,
-0.070789583,
-0.0029045516,
0.0156125817,
0.0433722697,
-0.0359607786,
-0.0393619239,
0.0046718116,
-0.0923404992,
0.003356382,
0.0442010239,
-0.0375878923,
0.0183606129,
-0.0477119349,
-0.0264972672,
0.0143252406,
0.0238993224,
0.0037152821,
0.0061415513,
0.0025245352,
0.0081852274,
-0.0849530101,
0.0021093467,
0.04627119,
-0.0292209983,
0.057083834,
0.0732527375,
-0.0376038626,
-0.0547091216,
0.0126940282,
0.0481201708,
-0.0029158304,
-0.0138290329,
0.0257921685,
0.0343053415,
0.0500890128,
-0.0208803415,
0.015392188,
0.0044616214,
-0.0264576245,
-0.0275152083,
0.0380613953,
0.0322131962,
-0.0203243326,
-0.0381471179,
-0.0052177329,
-0.0082206596,
0.0416901484,
0.0257476531,
0.0173697919,
-0.0362094752,
-0.0437430851,
-0.0490875468,
-0.0097479261,
-0.0517006479,
-0.0221540593,
0.0288948566,
0.0106356945,
-0.038883768,
-0.0394383222,
-0.0029022736,
-0.0441745371,
0.0559226386,
0.0479064733,
-0.0289900228,
-0.0410833023,
0.0261263885,
-0.0097839879,
0.0107273068,
0.0216803327,
0.0726700351,
-0.0635366663,
0.0543299019,
-0.035838075,
0.0080075292,
-0.0074127656,
0.0390506499,
-0.0729309991,
-0.0877001956,
0.029697001,
0.0832007378,
0.0315260217,
-0.0440322049,
-0.0516288206,
-0.0391750708,
0.0214816593,
0.0454097092,
-0.0426789112,
0.0166122615,
0.0600731261,
-0.0414449535,
0.0149979135,
-0.0045150346,
-0.0215280261,
-0.0218507182,
0.0689026564,
-0.0040736455,
-0.0487428457,
0.0237637516,
0.0053951284,
0.0528268628,
0.015381895,
-0.0286567062,
0.025716316,
0.0446839072,
0.0189023074,
-0.0093590682,
-0.019306995,
0.0097061479,
0.0091590313,
0.0355234817,
-0.0427777804,
0.0174370911,
0.0269823577,
0.011882483,
-0.0076702288,
0.0136136692,
0.040353395,
0.0265406519,
0.0884143487,
0.0819928423,
0.022863593,
-0.0224537458,
0.0358626582,
-0.0082633039,
0.0513949767,
0.007844693,
0.0219390783,
-0.0229435209,
-0.0066426662,
0.0127203492,
0.0638313964,
-0.0431482755,
-0.0594024435,
0.0118445624,
0.0633570254,
-0.0047698906,
0.0528053083,
0.0322610289,
-0.0037205385,
0.0188193545,
-0.0723217279,
-0.0078081754,
-0.0288061723,
-0.0792260394,
-0.0029643974,
-0.0162423383,
-0.0190653447,
0.0108705191,
0.0616895631,
-0.0025294272,
0.0478612855,
0.0237954017,
0.0006408708,
-0.0223050676,
-0.0056534545,
0.0291718263,
0.0127098123,
-0.0538053438,
-0.0669922829,
-0.0892439708,
-0.0749834627,
0.0025808713,
0.001504316,
0.0601869859,
0.0337665677,
-0.0347842164,
0.0417259559,
-0.0065724007,
0.0426370502,
-0.0576202944,
-0.0302792806,
-0.0229180399,
-0.0275032502,
0.0139406417,
-6.113659059e-33,
0.0328514241,
-0.0319767036,
-0.0405588262,
-0.0388405025,
-0.0102179116,
0.0119016403,
-0.0401280895,
0.0409612693,
-0.0222972259,
-0.0387403667,
0.0092420829,
-0.0188071188,
0.0102803623,
-0.0207022969,
-0.0008121947,
-0.011959712,
-0.01032364,
0.0346996002,
-0.0521808751,
0.0217787232,
0.0483261161,
-0.0075127124,
0.0172987152,
-0.0587993599,
0.0358112045,
-0.0309925172,
-0.0338488519,
0.0234026406,
-0.0362459905,
0.0360773914,
0.0394565687,
0.0004575563,
-0.00297653,
-0.0307560787,
-0.0007178954,
0.0203573797,
0.0242787544,
-0.0091166906,
0.0096049765,
-0.0042496785,
-0.0210188963,
-0.0419252776,
0.016197918,
0.0310090259,
0.0080208629,
-0.0284958724,
-0.015527471,
-0.0161769632,
-0.0223210976,
0.0187075399,
0.0044601657,
0.0038343752,
-0.0498787202,
0.0310043674,
-0.0158775356,
-0.0039666416,
-0.008760483,
-0.0196415279,
-0.0305379797,
0.0235281121,
0.0350651704,
-0.0107853496,
0.0598147772,
-0.0000179562,
-0.0146769779,
0.0634528697,
-0.0076681133,
0.0028391145,
0.0181607753,
-0.0009613243,
0.0339109041,
0.081365481,
0.0314021073,
0.061415486,
0.0490000471,
-0.0211256761,
-0.0718203336,
0.0215555131,
0.0200946536,
0.023311073,
0.0143645499,
-0.0182323679,
-0.0724186227,
-0.0083872592,
-0.0161582716,
-0.001641222,
-0.0179501772,
-0.0607161745,
0.0097864326,
-0.0274949148,
-0.0375851579,
-0.0290627144,
0.0087991133,
-0.039278429,
0.0019353619,
0.0316098034,
-0.0098696006,
0.0110834679,
-0.035775125,
0.0240236428,
0.0196144655,
-0.0091775954,
-0.0047501745,
-0.0272203013,
0.067062825,
-0.0044434746,
0.0507061034,
0.0051864842,
-0.0680776387,
0.0112820212,
-0.0258990563,
0.0438550711,
0.0050965031,
0.0156260971,
0.0184479784,
-0.0361283943,
-0.0076476745,
-0.0111250784,
0.0404734984,
0.0152540049,
-0.0441618189,
0.0579352863,
-0.0201488379,
0.0239296649,
0.0149907349,
-0.0008573438,
-0.0032041001,
-0.0065509346,
0.0554426871,
-0.051444076,
-0.0221588984,
0.001590143,
3.116e-7,
-0.0310366713,
0.0011474518,
0.0385815427,
0.0071134041,
0.007665277,
0.0831804574,
-0.0340172313,
0.0670153648,
-0.0000095968,
-0.0346722603,
-0.043495506,
-0.0172709078,
0.0688371956,
0.0655456409,
0.0076644123,
0.0245243143,
-0.0751039386,
0.005654518,
-0.0565737337,
-0.023129357,
0.0248942748,
0.0315450765,
0.0087684421,
-0.0433678143,
0.0091974707,
-0.0477485843,
-0.0233888123,
-0.0101083349,
0.0002161229,
0.0201909188,
-0.0042231795,
0.0369337015,
0.0121858688,
0.039036952,
-0.0230939314,
-0.0467058159,
-0.0375417285,
0.0187584907,
0.0083034132,
0.0017931428,
-0.0407514721,
-0.0439466648,
-0.0061086612,
-0.0434219092,
0.0563020632,
0.0501316637,
-0.009336534,
-0.026363736,
-0.0144486735,
-0.025108112,
0.0330548882,
-0.0046936763,
0.0157160424,
0.011479497,
0.010806608,
0.0160559546,
0.0126239983,
-0.0190525558,
-0.0316214524,
0.0156540107,
-0.001942926,
-0.0487447679,
0.0029843035,
0.0921011716,
0.007587804,
-0.0304919854,
0.0307061076,
3.247379368e-34,
-0.0005275086,
-0.0597691461,
0.0334864557,
-0.0106676295,
0.0402838103,
0.0135492915,
-0.0086521134,
0.0190746766,
-0.0238368083,
-0.0040379791,
-0.0020775695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11665v1 | See It from My Perspective: Diagnosing the Western Cultural Bias of Large Vision-Language Models in Image Understanding | 2024-06-17T15:49:51 | 2024-06-17T15:49:51 | Amith Ananthram, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Carl Vondrick, Mohit Bansal, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Vision-language models (VLMs) can respond to queries about images in many
languages. However, beyond language, culture affects how we see things. For
example, individuals from Western cultures focus more on the central figure in
an image while individuals from Eastern cultures attend more to scene context.
In this work, we present a novel investigation that demonstrates and localizes
VLMs' Western bias in image understanding. We evaluate large VLMs across
subjective and objective visual tasks with culturally diverse images and
annotations. We find that VLMs perform better on the Western subset than the
Eastern subset of each task. Controlled experimentation tracing the source of
this bias highlights the importance of a diverse language mix in text-only
pre-training for building equitable VLMs, even when inference is performed in
English. Moreover, while prompting in the language of a target culture can lead
to reductions in bias, it is not a substitute for building AI more
representative of the world's languages. | [
-0.0089257583,
0.0609462783,
-0.0225225445,
0.0519082807,
-0.0126365479,
0.0635314509,
0.0543295331,
-0.0237505287,
0.0267713722,
-0.0655096322,
-0.0705531389,
-0.0674178675,
0.0030567145,
-0.0005194478,
0.00161236,
-0.0911916345,
-0.0007736821,
-0.0268828385,
0.0033402143,
-0.0328496285,
-0.0176948402,
-0.0018190289,
0.0328828357,
0.010232646,
-0.0172654502,
-0.0085733468,
0.0349983349,
-0.0134492312,
0.028036112,
0.001267886,
-0.0274522454,
0.0176132843,
0.0094221206,
-0.0220961552,
0.0000020513,
-0.0518915839,
0.0466259271,
-0.018931549,
0.0636596009,
0.0346397422,
0.0284701996,
-0.0251901001,
-0.0110717509,
-0.0413606241,
-0.0376074314,
-0.0445851125,
0.0687160417,
0.0667650029,
0.012876817,
0.0184761025,
-0.0006881329,
-0.0541810207,
-0.078379482,
-0.0187159944,
0.0034336664,
-0.0275128689,
0.049344264,
0.026145041,
-0.0356365032,
-0.0165085066,
-0.0879490152,
0.0220014956,
0.0399932005,
0.0228643697,
-0.035985373,
0.0451794863,
-0.041356355,
-0.0430716611,
0.0150205093,
0.0474357866,
0.0077796401,
-0.0193067584,
-0.0112268524,
-0.0105235847,
-0.0136744045,
-0.0320734531,
-0.0307587665,
0.0995382145,
-0.0139249889,
0.021650387,
-0.0135517875,
0.0141910966,
0.0190076139,
0.0067330971,
-0.0169680621,
0.0390882343,
0.0049281986,
0.010385029,
0.0020525996,
0.0487033203,
-0.0229844339,
-0.044695545,
0.0170624945,
-0.0154388566,
0.0043978682,
-0.0038642441,
-0.0214040559,
0.0086454032,
-0.0199061129,
-0.0444671661,
0.0131396754,
0.034889929,
-0.0711268932,
0.0441823043,
-0.0074455575,
0.0795078725,
-0.0269013233,
0.0156968851,
-0.0539928935,
-0.0446344092,
0.0137524446,
0.0221918002,
0.0542429797,
-0.0607117675,
-0.021942772,
-0.0013987848,
-0.0721448734,
-0.0105091855,
-0.0392012782,
0.0033726927,
0.0060636098,
-0.0194447655,
-0.0159366783,
0.0065429262,
-0.0285293106,
0.0627366304,
-0.0235113297,
-0.0152520444,
-0.0789735019,
-0.072561346,
0.0248002149,
0.0453074202,
-0.0301260687,
-0.0371469408,
-0.0060294657,
0.0306057446,
-0.0038069163,
0.0002957898,
-0.0522598363,
0.0189763941,
0.0088764522,
-0.0395251662,
0.0654259846,
-0.0315148868,
0.0010768108,
0.0064352849,
0.0328262374,
-0.0198082048,
-0.0074863979,
0.0055250521,
-0.0495360345,
0.0438668728,
0.0262402203,
0.0252471585,
0.0293475818,
0.0087732356,
-0.0103099877,
0.0956653655,
-0.0282545015,
0.0441710725,
0.0391163975,
-0.008801695,
-0.006954778,
0.0487325266,
-0.0348084755,
-0.018479757,
-0.0520955957,
0.006272811,
0.0105164945,
-0.0147247994,
0.0575442277,
0.0143725062,
-0.0089829387,
-0.0258114133,
0.0522190034,
0.0634200051,
-0.0223664362,
0.0018958534,
0.0316421762,
-0.0298467036,
-0.0118858442,
0.0252922345,
-0.0744496882,
0.0553139187,
0.0156478453,
-0.0090639684,
-0.0334240161,
0.0741452575,
-0.0582296774,
-0.022643609,
-0.0031202068,
-0.0189656001,
0.0114291888,
0.0357341208,
0.0477110483,
-0.0096615963,
0.0465339795,
-0.0141525166,
0.0451399721,
-0.0309021678,
-0.0024145518,
-0.0265366398,
0.0319611654,
0.0033351579,
-0.048539456,
0.0070711095,
0.0299563911,
0.0110799689,
0.0569120273,
0.0458244719,
0.0462988056,
0.0324164219,
0.0327090696,
-0.0362761393,
-0.0481349342,
-0.0233243871,
0.0040533491,
0.0500079542,
0.0068575405,
0.0201299321,
0.0099199731,
-0.0143695381,
-0.0385605395,
0.0097713824,
-0.008973782,
-0.0051669511,
-0.0228960849,
0.0351863354,
0.00278041,
0.0072069648,
-0.0474429801,
-0.0014011671,
-0.0266175717,
-0.0294300709,
0.0377362743,
0.0738688856,
-0.0574252158,
0.0261203889,
0.0389733389,
-0.1051145718,
-0.0394346826,
-0.0195188466,
-0.002989983,
0.0012467951,
0.0573135465,
0.0143213188,
-0.0033843091,
-0.0361458771,
-0.0289460644,
-0.0274619181,
0.0099661574,
-0.0127008958,
0.0412793271,
-0.0210643522,
0.0055535897,
0.0047530564,
-0.0154582784,
0.0390783176,
-0.0038636143,
-0.0462216362,
0.0325884335,
0.0276168678,
-0.0081492802,
0.0394879319,
0.0227853525,
-0.0236581843,
0.0435361713,
-0.087744996,
-0.0254922509,
-0.0391743518,
-0.0287064631,
-0.0171117168,
-0.0062994608,
-0.0411234535,
-0.0572819188,
-0.0661304146,
0.01048622,
-0.0070602074,
0.0535620935,
0.0027481269,
-0.0232711006,
0.0431145653,
0.0039051857,
-0.0108295223,
0.0215839539,
0.0593484603,
0.0394550376,
-0.0161872581,
-0.0482118987,
0.0258680508,
-0.0287058745,
0.0415924378,
-0.0358774923,
-0.0354318805,
0.0094571151,
0.0012862325,
0.0355008245,
0.1212670505,
-0.0253073052,
-0.0014783321,
0.0819014385,
0.0047238902,
-0.0153740151,
-0.0285190176,
0.0572572127,
-0.028023582,
0.0156185254,
-0.0771012232,
-0.0166929979,
0.052120693,
-0.0216612518,
-0.0093290517,
-0.0503808223,
0.0391813479,
-0.0702387542,
-0.0788765177,
-0.0386063457,
-0.0091814725,
0.0269583929,
0.0889965892,
-0.0367857926,
-0.0476949699,
0.0597695261,
-0.002728834,
-0.0262077209,
0.0038969736,
0.0235921089,
-0.0384380668,
0.0389047191,
0.0231428128,
0.0584100671,
0.0112563558,
0.0046079331,
-0.0587785468,
-0.0141117191,
0.0330931433,
0.0023660029,
0.0351715274,
-0.0319593698,
-0.0424043275,
-0.0531488433,
-0.0201651771,
-0.040542461,
0.0194653124,
-0.0297345109,
-0.0044701826,
-0.0145052988,
0.0126505401,
-0.0071461704,
0.0119809285,
0.0647845939,
-0.0067090788,
-0.0119812628,
0.0389759056,
0.0331803747,
-0.0446891263,
0.043614015,
-0.0011533211,
0.0210074112,
-0.0510161035,
-0.0047356975,
0.0321223289,
0.0441091992,
-0.0256749205,
-0.0381216221,
0.0491735153,
0.0324266404,
0.0225011632,
-0.0262453277,
0.0021535645,
0.0785288364,
-0.0179583821,
0.0416992903,
0.0790245682,
-0.0024490345,
-0.071604006,
-0.017521387,
-0.015638303,
-0.0303063728,
0.055607222,
0.03301806,
-0.0981897712,
0.0184659734,
-0.0220390372,
-0.0280502755,
0.0009795624,
-0.0158791989,
-0.015429819,
-0.1063965112,
0.0341960341,
0.0316417105,
-0.0275688414,
-0.0300828721,
0.0147046959,
-0.0120674577,
-0.0357964486,
0.0120480871,
-0.0250446405,
-0.0071682693,
-0.0024981995,
-0.006987338,
0.0226651058,
-0.0276431106,
0.014464343,
-0.0726183131,
-0.0151817175,
0.0441825576,
-0.0030169981,
0.0016260032,
-0.0578754432,
0.0192801636,
0.0096884705,
0.0219848566,
-0.0211078711,
0.0035091864,
-0.0033240551,
-0.0707270429,
0.0084629674,
-0.0017942926,
0.0055244137,
-0.0166397691,
0.0110875526,
0.0288018491,
0.0126233231,
-0.0229048971,
-0.0266563315,
0.0165984854,
-0.0214530434,
0.0289964303,
0.0202358682,
-0.0454265662,
-0.0133326845,
-0.0317449942,
-0.0226094816,
0.0203969702,
-0.0670052469,
0.0510852188,
-0.0443778336,
-0.0439374745,
-0.0326220617,
-0.0646068305,
0.0042852173,
0.00554652,
0.0241925567,
-0.0813257396,
0.004609603,
0.0004797489,
-0.0467244871,
0.0976967439,
-0.0227196477,
0.0167318769,
0.0248918664,
-0.0048007099,
0.0220488757,
-0.0622533672,
0.0102161868,
-0.0111950915,
-0.0225233715,
-0.0382019803,
-0.0002450488,
0.0820575282,
0.0037565029,
0.0203815289,
0.0417276062,
-0.0455840938,
-0.004303921,
0.0013253746,
0.0588212498,
0.029428862,
-0.0058860322,
-0.0077693928,
0.0135316094,
0.0192267094,
-0.0320122615,
0.0573199801,
0.0812425464,
-0.0210795812,
-0.0182216298,
0.0127505763,
-0.0042443019,
0.0161219779,
0.0524996072,
-0.0325478204,
0.0310675129,
-0.0302321129,
-0.0126225846,
-0.0280569047,
-0.0337228887,
-0.0117390081,
-0.0407217965,
-0.00434343,
0.0143224923,
0.0094393203,
0.0222961921,
0.0057480959,
-0.0195919499,
-0.0502902083,
0.031571079,
0.0456637666,
-0.0032205947,
-0.0280140955,
0.0442188978,
-0.0115585597,
0.040639203,
0.0062415246,
0.0498339273,
0.0234733243,
0.0777197853,
0.0087238783,
0.0000025476,
-0.0184234716,
0.003655833,
-0.0190382022,
-0.0677749515,
0.0466996804,
0.0317482427,
0.1103222296,
-0.1025308445,
0.0265326388,
0.0066907317,
0.0064225439,
-0.01748785,
0.0057114842,
0.0406288765,
-0.0240436364,
0.0398743823,
-0.0116793998,
0.0059248442,
-0.0336721614,
0.0621328242,
-0.0260406733,
0.007647675,
0.0202739798,
-0.015329048,
-0.0178492442,
-0.034266796,
0.0662745684,
-0.0291156061,
-0.0380878523,
0.0449327677,
-0.0468659066,
-0.067078419,
-0.0417150632,
0.0332127102,
-0.0078296531,
0.029821489,
0.0290810931,
0.0610199273,
0.0047089071,
-0.0400417745,
-0.019635722,
-0.0100002959,
-0.0306895841,
-0.0075024739,
0.0370980017,
-6.316666566e-33,
-0.0203534141,
0.0113966838,
0.0172338299,
-0.0161496717,
0.003687192,
-0.0055781826,
-0.0060187792,
0.019515913,
-0.0445213467,
0.0336761102,
0.0034832605,
-0.0102936933,
0.0050293971,
0.0088545186,
0.0229276959,
0.0153329019,
0.0222659539,
0.0216770936,
-0.0096639218,
-0.0283803195,
0.0123709543,
0.0050934716,
0.0734153911,
-0.0807428509,
0.0042963382,
0.0281486921,
0.0213807281,
0.0141202826,
0.0360405967,
0.0467193946,
-0.0366168395,
0.0325961746,
0.0434778407,
0.0001984261,
-0.0345314294,
-0.0005540308,
-0.0399118289,
-0.0371992998,
0.0355598256,
0.07568378,
-0.0010938987,
-0.0181867015,
0.0302675553,
-0.0345259979,
-0.029484313,
-0.0051173219,
0.0385053195,
-0.0433533862,
0.0167956892,
0.0358922891,
-0.0244121291,
-0.0040629231,
-0.0064326026,
0.0289404057,
0.0607871264,
0.0244823098,
-0.0036809477,
0.0401597843,
-0.0142859658,
0.0506898239,
0.0185661633,
-0.0037931446,
0.0940075293,
0.0443738699,
0.0317119248,
0.0494213402,
0.0816558525,
-0.0018325481,
-0.0121043157,
-0.089020513,
0.0331467241,
-0.0137035372,
-0.0077223587,
0.0969808474,
0.0146969557,
0.0258827917,
-0.0676402599,
-0.0160866603,
-0.0165227167,
0.0562096462,
0.0098740794,
0.006274255,
0.0018088623,
-0.023890337,
-0.0264298748,
-0.0527913794,
-0.0357622392,
-0.0069706948,
0.033184737,
-0.0076874471,
0.0097682606,
0.0242618937,
0.055043593,
-0.0592834763,
0.0221237242,
-0.0132426675,
0.0203767717,
-0.0019492758,
0.0133077661,
-0.0053618322,
-0.056766592,
-0.0042098016,
-0.0001843383,
0.0088837026,
-0.008415699,
0.0252125524,
0.0189926475,
-0.0162017643,
-0.0244319495,
-0.0206653439,
-0.046373751,
-0.0438262746,
0.0217273422,
0.0432013795,
0.0456296355,
0.0177771058,
-0.0354816318,
-0.0006918784,
0.0258669648,
-0.0321497731,
-0.0267410465,
-0.0620003082,
-0.0060667787,
0.0440918617,
-0.0427152738,
-0.0170531422,
-0.0246739257,
0.0249284171,
0.0367596038,
-0.0659859404,
-0.0243620574,
0.0004009522,
2.667e-7,
0.0366538204,
0.0284833331,
-0.0125301797,
0.0423842408,
0.0309377257,
0.0285782497,
-0.0425812528,
0.0101663675,
0.032039497,
-0.0215083249,
-0.0289299861,
0.0475995429,
0.0224861801,
0.0011193474,
-0.0385704599,
0.015396175,
-0.0319250487,
0.0126743894,
-0.0470521003,
0.0164197776,
-0.0010602473,
0.0622525588,
-0.0366298929,
0.0056842705,
0.0175552294,
-0.0339351855,
0.0877474025,
-0.0800248384,
0.002411505,
-0.0313714258,
-0.0182036664,
-0.0150117883,
0.0008641517,
0.0447486378,
0.0125485584,
-0.0020713471,
0.0400329083,
0.019404415,
-0.0102704093,
0.035175588,
-0.0088414606,
0.0640726984,
-0.0281027611,
-0.0870176032,
0.0607309006,
-0.0310894623,
-0.0347119272,
-0.040312767,
0.0008151896,
-0.0116865858,
0.0763463303,
0.003017023,
-0.0008625756,
0.009071066,
0.0287428759,
0.0004033344,
-0.0173313785,
-0.0356382802,
-0.0257801898,
-0.0374621004,
-0.0008991605,
-0.0180355795,
-0.0218219869,
-0.0197461322,
0.0297770221,
0.0353440195,
-0.0255835652,
1.728308681e-34,
0.0245658383,
-0.007037905,
0.0219176393,
-0.0059929495,
0.0070934198,
-0.0225634463,
-0.0106302071,
-0.0046622637,
-0.0070526223,
-0.0020179802,
0.0040272828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11661v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11661v2 | Cultural Conditioning or Placebo? On the Effectiveness of Socio-Demographic Prompting | 2024-06-17T15:43:45 | 2024-06-20T08:25:08 | Sagnik Mukherjee, Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Sunayana Sitaram, Kalika Bali, Alham Fikri Aji, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL | Socio-demographic prompting is a commonly employed approach to study cultural
biases in LLMs as well as for aligning models to certain cultures. In this
paper, we systematically probe four LLMs (Llama 3, Mistral v0.2, GPT-3.5 Turbo
and GPT-4) with prompts that are conditioned on culturally sensitive and
non-sensitive cues, on datasets that are supposed to be culturally sensitive
(EtiCor and CALI) or neutral (MMLU and ETHICS). We observe that all models
except GPT-4 show significant variations in their responses on both kinds of
datasets for both kinds of prompts, casting doubt on the robustness of the
culturally-conditioned prompting as a method for eliciting cultural bias in
models or as an alignment strategy. The work also calls rethinking the control
experiment design to tease apart the cultural conditioning of responses from
"placebo effect", i.e., random perturbations of model responses due to
arbitrary tokens in the prompt. | [
-0.0062066647,
0.0588099696,
-0.0417875685,
0.0009897903,
-0.0177776236,
0.0408629924,
0.0639244914,
-0.0076181018,
0.0574820936,
0.0244240295,
-0.0212035552,
-0.02705184,
0.0221625194,
-0.0073939594,
0.0395857692,
0.0046413713,
0.0379552804,
0.0176066179,
0.0238280073,
-0.0111534223,
-0.0108543653,
0.0122328112,
0.0496996343,
0.0100859283,
0.0212666541,
-0.0077729383,
0.0204360448,
0.01293106,
0.0366795473,
-0.0687822178,
0.0440270267,
0.0243954062,
0.0211955234,
-0.0115776621,
0.0000020417,
-0.0924832523,
-0.0231824238,
-0.0105100144,
-0.0277640298,
0.0348791406,
0.0517559089,
0.006948336,
-0.0031485339,
0.0017591314,
-0.0499187708,
0.0336176269,
0.0104560563,
-0.0048287688,
-0.0411184579,
0.0150471358,
0.0116109671,
0.0089653106,
-0.0748740882,
-0.0092550786,
-0.0023495494,
0.0260828398,
0.0262945741,
-0.0206058621,
-0.0407200232,
-0.0027410572,
-0.0265747365,
-0.0103071937,
-0.0080201877,
0.0304274932,
-0.020993812,
-0.0233627874,
0.0052457051,
-0.024186017,
0.002865806,
0.0294933412,
0.1044028625,
0.0341311283,
0.0085470947,
0.0022276284,
0.0495828837,
0.023012137,
-0.0058547491,
-0.0058354833,
0.0101286722,
0.0125573967,
0.0512451865,
-0.0030254689,
-0.0009066647,
0.0077895354,
0.0296468325,
0.1037331671,
-0.0048586074,
-0.0308813881,
-0.0372320786,
-0.0084273964,
0.0457390174,
-0.061668735,
-0.0310577564,
0.0176584031,
-0.0032716531,
0.0014590295,
0.0183464158,
0.0662288889,
0.0342071205,
-0.0111454232,
0.0050789276,
0.0923489258,
-0.0495016128,
-0.025977606,
0.0137994345,
0.067337133,
-0.0266585313,
0.0030534999,
0.0023676064,
0.0297524296,
0.0257315505,
0.0142632397,
0.0834632739,
-0.0377233922,
0.0003856246,
0.0464768149,
-0.0930881351,
0.0099959886,
-0.0254633781,
0.0418171585,
-0.0413111784,
-0.0361884274,
-0.0001268464,
0.0016532663,
-0.055465024,
0.048592329,
-0.0378441364,
0.0244359579,
-0.0139918504,
-0.0677617863,
0.0099058365,
0.0118422396,
-0.0039930739,
-0.0278363042,
0.0181570593,
0.0390328653,
0.0076628961,
0.0166428033,
-0.0724946782,
0.0109647643,
0.0099922922,
-0.0450003259,
0.0449850149,
-0.0379759334,
0.0227511525,
0.0255350545,
0.002058473,
-0.0450574011,
0.0038035905,
0.0237186644,
-0.0171182714,
0.0518386401,
0.035720557,
0.0264962688,
0.0238659084,
0.0295608081,
-0.0423557311,
0.0637189224,
0.0024391911,
-0.0090887826,
0.0388630778,
-0.0274809599,
0.002429137,
0.0473936275,
-0.0148436911,
0.0632612258,
-0.0240373388,
0.0283553097,
0.0122837508,
-0.028900547,
0.0837291628,
-0.0151464818,
0.0163089298,
0.0338409804,
0.0250509251,
0.0688921958,
-0.0070202597,
0.018335579,
-0.0007332771,
-0.0263855737,
-0.0558600873,
0.0472246408,
-0.1008407474,
0.0082157142,
-0.0426883623,
0.0241495334,
-0.0344244875,
0.054567378,
-0.0330092423,
-0.0020540883,
-0.0340932645,
0.0152270766,
0.0188928246,
0.0423086211,
-0.0115856035,
-0.0608553477,
0.0330148451,
0.0177958254,
0.0138737131,
-0.0149478773,
-0.041586142,
-0.0309838559,
0.0761067793,
0.0275758374,
-0.0395893008,
0.0040176692,
0.025623152,
-0.0245212559,
0.0244172197,
0.0320895277,
0.0458701365,
0.0366010927,
-0.0379163623,
-0.0249338038,
-0.0454644412,
-0.0077890619,
-0.0279270709,
0.0396599881,
0.0158326309,
0.0405153893,
-0.016379023,
0.0267849825,
0.0168135744,
0.0152496696,
-0.0304587167,
-0.0253852364,
-0.063390784,
0.004239392,
0.069601588,
0.0042799367,
0.0146556674,
-0.0183495507,
-0.0320385695,
-0.0021370957,
0.0515088327,
0.0203144252,
-0.0296324492,
0.0215155929,
0.0135719068,
0.002248781,
-0.0386965051,
-0.0138283111,
-0.0104885967,
0.0326559618,
0.0085557373,
0.0561429448,
0.043813806,
0.0058764801,
-0.0024235232,
-0.0035913598,
0.0079996819,
-0.0245091785,
0.0137352664,
-0.0537984185,
-0.0028202075,
0.0146912616,
-0.0023395766,
0.0126200346,
-0.0372572988,
-0.010711045,
0.0335857943,
-0.0161696896,
-0.034572944,
-0.0032183581,
0.0190471206,
-0.0467245914,
-0.0087649692,
-0.0601884089,
0.0176178645,
0.019367395,
0.0076521407,
-0.0085945344,
-0.0148061533,
-0.0718277693,
0.0192527696,
-0.0955042019,
-0.0285948105,
0.0752258673,
0.077440232,
0.0251073986,
-0.0462194085,
-0.0178242475,
-0.008917301,
-0.0142917531,
-0.0302923862,
0.0128793763,
-0.0112542659,
-0.0347281396,
-0.0417975895,
-0.024929069,
-0.0620157458,
-0.0161929615,
-0.0225862451,
-0.035781417,
-0.0080012893,
0.0715716705,
0.0883618295,
0.0370950028,
-0.0149666872,
0.0035480643,
0.030950604,
0.0013204309,
-0.0541090183,
-0.0232412238,
0.013652496,
-0.0084781293,
0.0175624583,
-0.1248432621,
-0.0477119274,
0.0430193432,
0.0143493954,
0.0183100179,
0.0064447368,
0.060568057,
-0.0418503061,
-0.0258831605,
0.006390064,
-0.0249471627,
-0.0202688295,
0.0876833647,
-0.0332254209,
-0.0782110319,
-0.0047310139,
0.036716111,
-0.0156279504,
0.0179085508,
-0.0128636761,
-0.0344440192,
-0.0163884908,
-0.037240427,
-0.0080172829,
0.0263305362,
0.0004960556,
-0.0482095219,
-0.0455500707,
0.008040145,
-0.0343010016,
0.0437565483,
0.0024993026,
-0.0220413283,
-0.04335263,
-0.0273928549,
-0.034680292,
0.0113311335,
-0.0069445618,
0.0148143321,
-0.0030088348,
0.0162073784,
0.0170262717,
-0.0233080983,
0.0530117154,
-0.0320126079,
-0.0133426702,
0.0183558557,
-0.0066339131,
-0.0451348238,
0.0146511327,
0.0402916968,
0.0273644645,
-0.0648742989,
0.022220334,
-0.0338330194,
-0.0004949743,
-0.0419547148,
0.0053126412,
0.0518759601,
0.0644083172,
0.0325430781,
0.0098017417,
0.0395877101,
0.0732140467,
0.0034522119,
0.0688015074,
0.0504689105,
-0.0292486176,
-0.006840704,
-0.022460755,
-0.0707498714,
0.0269245822,
0.0161143914,
0.0040571797,
-0.0744697452,
0.0581218451,
0.0307806805,
0.0115080401,
-0.0596082285,
0.002407968,
-0.0326704197,
-0.0550737642,
0.0371169709,
0.019581141,
-0.0133010056,
-0.0100660492,
0.0297914091,
0.0239919964,
-0.0192683823,
0.0476559959,
-0.0005606887,
-0.0105178617,
-0.0186276753,
-0.0044136401,
-0.0553798974,
-0.0324034542,
-0.0149657819,
-0.0492672026,
0.0442518219,
0.0465545617,
-0.0044187591,
0.0087983096,
-0.0930082947,
0.0271363016,
0.0193374138,
-0.0187501945,
0.0008830585,
-0.03644187,
-0.015784191,
0.0086460747,
-0.0349326916,
0.0132371215,
0.0121128885,
-0.0078128213,
0.0236509647,
-0.0021511072,
0.0072476855,
-0.0152559811,
0.0077296323,
0.0186113399,
-0.0282012783,
0.0515390858,
-0.0074961586,
-0.0352785997,
0.0451278389,
-0.0597772002,
-0.0581124686,
0.0642692223,
-0.0346700959,
0.0147902919,
-0.0704128966,
0.0058121732,
0.0197268147,
-0.0780853108,
-0.0099404734,
-0.0127412174,
0.0232253782,
-0.0361077078,
0.003259639,
-0.0287333541,
0.0152172716,
0.0589043349,
-0.0429391526,
0.0070511363,
0.0094393436,
-0.0149237039,
-0.0103920624,
-0.0380952284,
0.0220191162,
-0.0273559,
-0.0307477713,
-0.027970897,
0.0453286953,
0.0431431271,
0.0285402536,
0.0302349906,
0.0635510385,
0.0651189983,
0.0005377646,
0.0137591027,
0.037540134,
0.0463577062,
-0.0118982019,
0.1086627916,
-0.0086871283,
-0.009810891,
-0.0069020879,
0.0174015313,
0.0695918798,
-0.0043049678,
-0.0476628058,
-0.017237924,
0.0247206427,
0.0156929698,
0.0425323434,
-0.0571623705,
-0.00876523,
-0.0330710784,
-0.0285338871,
-0.0175403841,
0.0001376119,
0.0184993725,
-0.0755179226,
0.0250445213,
0.0027597211,
0.0161677804,
-0.0216504801,
-0.0535843149,
-0.0043816664,
-0.0939725861,
0.0841678903,
-0.0134933684,
0.0290733036,
-0.0154163493,
0.0277412739,
-0.0175919607,
0.0692527592,
-0.010340197,
0.0150304176,
0.0321304426,
0.1240414381,
0.0102248015,
0.0104231471,
0.0170338415,
0.019251544,
-0.0056462884,
-0.0102707567,
0.0009505691,
0.0135889156,
0.0032595028,
-0.076683186,
-0.0014068236,
0.027803069,
-0.0030837343,
-0.02360842,
-0.002479227,
0.0123967705,
-0.0113242185,
0.0561376363,
-0.0197908245,
-0.0547076091,
-0.0219784658,
-0.0123406006,
-0.0201645028,
0.0057393028,
-0.0477065891,
-0.0233271476,
-0.0225423798,
-0.0340297632,
0.0993327945,
-0.0625745058,
-0.0413972065,
-0.0216791891,
-0.0929181725,
-0.0346523784,
-0.0275692418,
-0.0159080606,
-0.0164239816,
-0.0374431238,
-0.0233400092,
0.0402568504,
-0.0421852507,
-0.0386827029,
0.0190727338,
-0.021379916,
-0.027531242,
-0.0282234456,
-0.0259919427,
-6.319966766e-33,
-0.0474603474,
-0.0227713585,
0.020778235,
-0.0118763391,
-0.0038124768,
-0.0336496383,
-0.0060748793,
0.0169307869,
-0.0142879393,
-0.0353139974,
-0.0251040272,
-0.0196076743,
0.0195705928,
-0.0526566021,
0.0311529003,
-0.0367200263,
-0.0181404389,
0.0032816324,
-0.0265291128,
-0.0616497733,
-0.0415477864,
0.0036719732,
0.0427770689,
-0.060163267,
0.0839923248,
-0.0139172198,
0.008700069,
-0.0355581716,
-0.0023831003,
0.0207709502,
-0.0417051502,
-0.0091862809,
0.0349992104,
-0.015690973,
-0.000895132,
0.0659615919,
0.004780056,
-0.041963581,
0.0587628335,
-0.0041367267,
0.0441859104,
-0.081189692,
-0.0114890495,
0.0131292595,
-0.0795955509,
0.0315593891,
0.0251285173,
-0.0274906531,
0.0294191539,
0.0018342139,
-0.0241107848,
-0.0046589398,
0.0047940616,
0.044452969,
-0.0277237669,
0.1063895822,
-0.0138601121,
0.0516019538,
-0.0239089001,
0.0118197603,
0.0347085819,
-0.0255378261,
0.0683913156,
0.0329682492,
0.0151431095,
0.0169021823,
-0.0007142473,
0.0439330339,
-0.0464087687,
-0.0613824427,
0.0187346935,
-0.0348732509,
0.01457405,
0.066682674,
-0.0177036207,
-0.0217908658,
-0.0119888959,
0.012702547,
0.0680043101,
-0.0247753989,
0.003397743,
0.0381784216,
-0.0241594315,
-0.0133188954,
0.0136021813,
-0.0322557762,
-0.0062058559,
-0.0436475351,
0.0471639968,
-0.0131148901,
0.0303605758,
-0.0454350822,
0.0622230954,
-0.0029654102,
-0.0159331914,
-0.0524654277,
0.0045147724,
-0.0367206223,
0.035815157,
-0.0147613883,
-0.0313206799,
0.0106731122,
-0.0403426886,
0.0193056222,
0.0282741953,
0.0415449925,
-0.0071651456,
-0.0165188611,
-0.0773693323,
0.0109217875,
-0.0106197065,
0.0049102874,
0.0301426053,
-0.0660723969,
0.05905338,
-0.0105274003,
0.0450588092,
-0.0253067128,
0.0497892275,
-0.0105518214,
-0.0337991491,
-0.0160668865,
-0.0461564884,
0.0539021157,
-0.0292199496,
0.0129933581,
0.0277154446,
0.070472464,
0.0074680545,
0.0099421348,
-0.0099613648,
-0.043745853,
2.673e-7,
-0.0407110266,
0.037220493,
-0.0158458874,
0.0343944356,
0.0075003868,
0.0061905007,
-0.0653142333,
0.04021658,
0.0644707978,
-0.0401932821,
0.0287829824,
-0.026277164,
0.0267794915,
-0.0088396119,
-0.0561951399,
-0.0085302889,
-0.0163210575,
0.0092166234,
-0.0226916131,
0.0389003009,
-0.0136362882,
0.0069672959,
-0.023442803,
0.0151622016,
-0.0531659573,
0.0288863201,
0.0311390124,
-0.1064756364,
-0.0329126529,
-0.0177341513,
0.0315901302,
-0.0320532285,
-0.0054582222,
0.0277204756,
0.0210189708,
0.0017210355,
-0.0094787069,
0.0717173964,
0.024684066,
0.0069109593,
-0.0048350655,
-0.0202553272,
-0.011496882,
-0.0776704773,
0.0309003312,
0.0205563903,
-0.0280928444,
-0.0140251154,
-0.0111043854,
-0.0319189467,
0.0676792637,
-0.0024210331,
0.0097436914,
0.0101039242,
0.0325627066,
0.0145049542,
0.0132768145,
0.0088668661,
-0.000614667,
0.0012106437,
-0.0038715568,
-0.0812102929,
-0.0241292752,
0.0601283647,
-0.0172452107,
-0.009704113,
-0.0319957323,
2.473042438e-34,
0.0092936745,
-0.0114508169,
0.0085229082,
-0.0052062487,
0.0259834006,
0.0104462076,
0.0017359793,
0.0322831459,
0.0231674667,
-0.0350864977,
0.018307941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11657v1 | Can LLM be a Personalized Judge? | 2024-06-17T15:41:30 | 2024-06-17T15:41:30 | Yijiang River Dong, Tiancheng Hu, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Ensuring that large language models (LLMs) reflect diverse user values and
preferences is crucial as their user bases expand globally. It is therefore
encouraging to see the growing interest in LLM personalization within the
research community. However, current works often rely on the LLM-as-a-Judge
approach for evaluation without thoroughly examining its validity. In this
paper, we investigate the reliability of LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge, asking
LLMs to judge user preferences based on personas. Our findings suggest that
directly applying LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge is less reliable than previously
assumed, showing low and inconsistent agreement with human ground truth. The
personas typically used are often overly simplistic, resulting in low
predictive power. To address these issues, we introduce verbal uncertainty
estimation into the LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge pipeline, allowing the model to
express low confidence on uncertain judgments. This adjustment leads to much
higher agreement (above 80%) on high-certainty samples for binary tasks.
Through human evaluation, we find that the LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge achieves
comparable performance to third-party humans evaluation and even surpasses
human performance on high-certainty samples. Our work indicates that
certainty-enhanced LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge offers a promising direction for
developing more reliable and scalable methods for evaluating LLM
personalization. | [
0.0653530806,
0.0840457007,
-0.0230491497,
0.0125668403,
-0.0260013863,
-0.0162323806,
0.0006821806,
-0.0495567843,
0.0022737174,
-0.040689528,
-0.070273824,
-0.0703746229,
0.0127487471,
0.0216698218,
0.013302017,
-0.0782264546,
0.0284271389,
-0.0198598094,
0.0366781913,
-0.0122531541,
0.0236735363,
0.0160892308,
0.0034998911,
0.0468428098,
0.0039137737,
-0.0026386117,
0.0247691385,
-0.0016991879,
0.0216924474,
-0.0215237681,
0.0312351175,
0.0721376389,
0.00366546,
-0.0351769067,
0.0000023129,
-0.0481454991,
0.0242877845,
-0.0438307188,
-0.0025670708,
0.0325350985,
0.0317509361,
0.1036247015,
-0.01588572,
0.017000068,
-0.0332082696,
0.0178780314,
0.0139318798,
0.0081681674,
0.0168176629,
0.0130705563,
-0.0049819457,
0.024214169,
-0.0219461024,
-0.001111659,
0.0281731635,
-0.0264184754,
-0.0063438909,
-0.0403263457,
-0.0037044112,
0.0141792307,
0.0162655059,
0.0115232253,
-0.002657573,
0.0136114843,
0.0158918574,
-0.0000966646,
-0.0092403507,
-0.0417376757,
-0.0014662039,
0.0470722653,
0.0487607978,
0.0004644078,
-0.0269775279,
-0.01778147,
0.0246854629,
0.0143122692,
-0.0058016093,
0.0133604696,
-0.0182548948,
0.0069108061,
-0.0437522307,
0.0330745578,
0.0206208508,
0.0349286981,
-0.0126889823,
0.1305293739,
0.004689184,
-0.0074089863,
0.036178913,
0.033460699,
0.0026994578,
-0.0362806581,
0.0302949343,
-0.0053076525,
-0.0749834031,
0.0273214038,
-0.0375943817,
0.0253196191,
0.0242751241,
-0.0509911329,
0.0316293724,
0.0602656342,
-0.0031311389,
0.0141888969,
0.0105084497,
0.0407135338,
0.0177871659,
-0.0000555802,
-0.0247321874,
0.0117447246,
-0.0150870197,
0.0031396945,
0.0275544114,
0.0083833346,
0.0065187751,
0.0058120703,
-0.0882482678,
0.0294398479,
-0.0305542927,
0.0197553448,
-0.0067724371,
0.0405421443,
-0.0017154537,
-0.0069609568,
-0.0903971344,
0.0217419043,
-0.048313681,
0.0477289893,
0.0115717407,
-0.038332466,
0.0580960065,
0.0146153802,
-0.0142450389,
-0.0086893989,
0.0041670809,
0.0461340733,
-0.0277586076,
-0.014399196,
-0.0161689799,
-0.0216117669,
-0.0329685099,
-0.0663969964,
-0.0490954556,
-0.0825626254,
-0.0055713989,
0.0412083529,
0.0141085479,
-0.0358640812,
0.0067802169,
0.0327975042,
-0.0209552627,
0.067941159,
0.0154268742,
0.0215829238,
0.0094685778,
0.0210234337,
-0.0358798914,
0.0439493284,
0.0227018259,
0.0687073842,
0.0385778397,
0.003837009,
0.0085946824,
0.0318666548,
-0.0588846467,
-0.0034204673,
-0.0169413555,
-0.0045522307,
-0.0263813622,
-0.0004785055,
0.0576274246,
0.0870094597,
-0.0130063063,
0.0070096627,
0.1208465919,
0.0425488129,
-0.0207943413,
0.0086173937,
0.0361838304,
0.0297838561,
0.0368240327,
-0.0002840045,
-0.0548991263,
0.0151477102,
-0.0307839606,
-0.0059802784,
0.0293468125,
0.0328912586,
-0.0023861835,
-0.0673443079,
-0.015901722,
-0.0077166869,
0.040652208,
0.0280503351,
0.0265488774,
-0.0289841574,
-0.0068435525,
0.0309895072,
0.0197825246,
-0.0478987545,
0.010523241,
-0.0418899283,
0.0381898955,
0.1140703559,
0.0251490194,
0.0224869382,
0.0087968213,
-0.0073640868,
-0.0338041671,
0.0249618907,
0.0549565926,
-0.0013054176,
-0.0038439941,
-0.0487428717,
-0.0258918218,
0.0101981619,
-0.0072812955,
0.0329214893,
0.0449963696,
0.0016435215,
0.0117260981,
-0.0137364585,
-0.0327668115,
-0.0104185799,
-0.0153085683,
-0.0121219521,
0.0276198313,
0.0069116843,
0.0322957411,
0.0228425432,
0.0346189402,
0.0197146665,
-0.0049046087,
0.0250681546,
-0.024349574,
0.0031450919,
-0.0314332992,
0.0471462719,
0.0422584973,
0.0094018811,
-0.0219492,
0.0032745083,
0.0015824813,
-0.0093117496,
0.0095408186,
-0.0170433763,
0.0000207726,
-0.031536404,
0.0342943519,
-0.0113534089,
-0.0172224753,
-0.0471797958,
0.0337593816,
-0.0220235512,
-0.0066751107,
0.0098880762,
-0.0053605735,
0.0108021498,
-0.0394404754,
-0.0881150365,
-0.0225446746,
0.0057649352,
0.0298139062,
0.0503962748,
-0.0017634459,
-0.0601303503,
-0.0137896799,
-0.100039497,
-0.0166243128,
-0.0027510021,
0.0029988023,
-0.0136791775,
0.0023796491,
-0.002400083,
-0.0136148501,
-0.0444091819,
-0.0308657773,
-0.022580415,
0.0266076699,
0.0091667017,
0.001658004,
0.0060183583,
-0.055531688,
0.0073094,
-0.010770414,
-0.0089452555,
-0.0028147369,
0.0010347678,
-0.0437432267,
0.0298112724,
-0.0499584116,
0.0083883004,
-0.0130834496,
-0.0130759366,
0.0338760689,
0.0035115862,
0.0591814667,
0.0336167999,
0.0132308844,
-0.0037380557,
0.0658443496,
-0.0117308106,
-0.0650794059,
-0.000282816,
-0.014233321,
-0.0375860929,
-0.0150706526,
-0.0739104003,
0.0219897926,
0.0292088371,
0.0290078986,
0.0148638058,
-0.055388134,
0.0184900165,
-0.0326393619,
-0.0216709431,
-0.0224264059,
-0.0080070505,
-0.0282603763,
0.0730877668,
0.0134833409,
-0.0527166948,
0.1067749485,
-0.0089775193,
0.0214992501,
0.0027186107,
-0.0198044889,
-0.0087134372,
0.0121363811,
-0.0087685883,
0.0071216458,
-0.0209342316,
0.0017446697,
-0.0556155443,
-0.0490168221,
0.0214082431,
-0.0654679462,
0.0563225038,
-0.0823160708,
-0.0159417652,
0.0284263715,
-0.0664298162,
-0.0363092646,
-0.0308360029,
-0.0490450561,
-0.0339238346,
0.0712609068,
-0.023263108,
-0.0308495294,
-0.0205131378,
0.023795275,
-0.0222478844,
-0.0335853063,
-0.0240739509,
0.0063859909,
-0.0282825734,
0.042454876,
0.0216060039,
0.0251776129,
-0.0233060382,
-0.0329618827,
0.0433080532,
0.0214683097,
-0.0225864016,
-0.017214179,
-0.0076154796,
0.0725582018,
0.0003708281,
-0.0371677317,
0.0710672215,
0.0800836161,
-0.0192928649,
0.016025085,
0.1217069849,
0.0195362698,
-0.0676265433,
-0.0071349135,
-0.0342393517,
0.0305816252,
0.0213100445,
0.0304286741,
-0.0497637168,
-0.0221183524,
0.0061626616,
0.0445060804,
-0.0382534787,
-0.0024719161,
-0.0110662542,
-0.102163367,
0.0138948187,
0.0027001735,
-0.0127986027,
0.0233239438,
-0.0348767787,
0.0183658078,
-0.0308791455,
0.0559915714,
-0.0081551773,
0.0014828901,
0.0231446624,
0.0189872105,
-0.0642604455,
-0.0611214712,
0.0312367827,
-0.0476563536,
0.0628785193,
0.0457015112,
0.0130029405,
0.0011070712,
-0.060904935,
-0.0173690543,
0.0270394646,
0.0124936206,
-0.0207879469,
0.0358085036,
-0.0134353321,
0.0091631543,
-0.0672852844,
-0.0055010263,
0.0012565264,
-0.023741018,
0.0081656985,
0.0298597217,
-0.0301524233,
-0.0020305638,
-0.0259335823,
0.002675097,
0.0153286671,
0.0676535442,
0.0077957101,
-0.1042834148,
-0.0101858722,
-0.0550688878,
-0.0161196515,
-0.0357648246,
-0.0535306409,
0.0002074988,
-0.0034199385,
-0.0293181799,
-0.047291249,
-0.0311275497,
0.007473947,
0.0094244648,
0.0020038022,
-0.0010053219,
0.0261951908,
-0.003532954,
-0.0123043545,
0.0437348858,
-0.0077031632,
0.0733556226,
-0.0950208977,
0.0003523608,
0.0454587601,
-0.029117614,
0.0201808494,
0.0232594348,
-0.0494311973,
-0.0699416026,
-0.014391602,
0.0806759521,
0.0246747117,
0.0093867881,
-0.0104089882,
-0.1155286431,
0.0318670273,
0.014847165,
-0.0360254832,
0.0064163734,
0.0163583513,
0.0758720189,
-0.022062514,
0.0278650932,
-0.0253576934,
-0.0008876725,
0.0183211435,
0.0078997733,
-0.0126886582,
-0.0896552652,
0.0174143501,
0.0184416268,
0.0496710911,
-0.0332966633,
0.0350767039,
0.0004661508,
-0.019077722,
-0.0167578254,
-0.0340200178,
-0.0201482922,
-0.043177329,
0.0284776147,
-0.0091407774,
-0.0319099985,
-0.0338393115,
-0.0392140448,
0.0165896975,
-0.0261931717,
-0.0053646485,
0.000373794,
0.0029096184,
0.0378106572,
0.0020574857,
-0.03542725,
-0.0000640548,
0.0005427885,
0.0503194258,
0.031334471,
0.0467983857,
-0.0167441629,
-0.0296506137,
-0.0164109915,
0.0109909391,
-0.0160265248,
-0.0723482445,
-0.0096912393,
0.0051784897,
0.0059341486,
-0.000730033,
0.0303725656,
-0.0380215757,
0.0115894191,
-0.0407985188,
-0.0106800422,
-0.001294486,
0.0049223136,
0.0336926579,
0.0093606319,
-0.0306712184,
-0.0107946852,
0.0608508065,
-0.0024400179,
-0.0182555094,
-0.0656642765,
-0.0822606757,
-0.0503718443,
-0.0188331306,
-0.0171778444,
0.0421925671,
-0.0597690791,
-0.0395278037,
-0.0800446495,
-0.0606191345,
0.0117093176,
0.0258492902,
0.0093030278,
-0.0463838875,
0.0078577157,
0.0556251667,
-0.0142368758,
-0.0146990186,
-0.0581758134,
-0.0191317573,
-0.0021441542,
0.0256342087,
-0.0589565523,
-6.924214943e-33,
-0.0165718105,
-0.0368089899,
0.0006402969,
-0.0229450539,
0.0194472987,
-0.0370513834,
-0.0034293914,
0.0737545341,
0.0141392052,
-0.0051394631,
-0.0237938184,
-0.0329541862,
0.020089699,
-0.0000961008,
0.0670499951,
0.0095581813,
0.0524756461,
0.029424075,
-0.0517304465,
-0.0159582272,
0.0354640521,
-0.0109025137,
0.0388756655,
-0.0947560966,
0.0711718574,
0.0392673761,
-0.0334511735,
-0.0069289757,
-0.0156589933,
0.0613265894,
0.0108936625,
0.046564281,
0.0032091041,
-0.0133453105,
-0.0312002674,
0.0048773387,
-0.0424108133,
-0.0335915945,
0.0551642105,
0.0533437133,
-0.0114365127,
-0.0185527112,
0.0307044331,
-0.0119029107,
-0.0696607903,
0.0468402468,
0.0380373299,
-0.0084465994,
0.0074959812,
-0.0240106583,
-0.0117608765,
0.0017312797,
0.0183601696,
0.0086395796,
-0.0114867231,
0.0441111922,
-0.060867846,
0.0044407384,
-0.0704702884,
0.061767336,
-0.0273401309,
-0.005496474,
0.0745123625,
0.0289169811,
-0.017685065,
0.0586363822,
0.0195625089,
0.0200719777,
-0.0282019749,
-0.0402193628,
0.0301813558,
0.0429646075,
0.0177657399,
0.0541580617,
0.0038129259,
-0.0167917069,
0.011744122,
0.061602518,
0.0523914658,
0.0243226457,
0.0764360949,
0.0534599498,
-0.0698842257,
-0.058962699,
-0.0239195991,
-0.0220416244,
-0.0502868295,
-0.0485362709,
0.0178327318,
-0.0083006369,
-0.0251587126,
-0.021436628,
0.0165105294,
-0.0203375872,
-0.0420765504,
-0.0145413848,
-0.0365387462,
0.0422436669,
0.0135799218,
0.0010950444,
-0.0529671051,
0.0279575493,
0.004662646,
-0.0069410652,
-0.0077105272,
0.0191932227,
-0.0074063251,
0.0215868875,
-0.0644723251,
-0.006262661,
-0.0112768952,
0.002755298,
0.0064918459,
0.0206176341,
0.0543736145,
0.0067239106,
-0.0455107391,
0.0571909063,
-0.0339946933,
0.0056516454,
-0.0266743805,
-0.03519205,
0.0183132291,
-0.0034967312,
-0.036157649,
-0.033024922,
-0.0207776427,
-0.0197502673,
0.0060768924,
-0.0122072957,
-0.0127892541,
0.0060215276,
2.993e-7,
0.0293584075,
0.0500130355,
-0.0490938053,
0.0338429026,
-0.0003784839,
0.0640149415,
0.0066189375,
-0.004489528,
0.0495261773,
-0.014732209,
0.0034475061,
0.0212148968,
0.0531985685,
0.043043606,
-0.0570306815,
-0.0108502237,
0.0069446475,
0.0355215073,
-0.0164340492,
0.0323694311,
0.0678754002,
0.03794007,
0.0335292108,
0.0045077903,
0.0114582116,
0.010941078,
0.0523344949,
-0.0612715743,
-0.0408379659,
0.0160720125,
0.0712784007,
0.0025979285,
-0.0025023974,
0.0369513892,
-0.009845661,
-0.0067852805,
-0.0067669214,
0.0764756128,
0.0037193371,
-0.0123877311,
-0.0226174612,
0.0017374974,
0.0253481008,
-0.0430524498,
0.0435583107,
-0.0315150842,
-0.0395608358,
-0.0099022575,
-0.0093416348,
-0.0148083922,
0.0528743528,
-0.0306880902,
-0.0443004668,
0.0157158654,
0.0145678921,
0.0083242571,
-0.0505054221,
-0.0543709658,
-0.0111498712,
0.0036533149,
-0.0360484719,
-0.0603763722,
-0.0348998569,
0.0210162885,
-0.001538793,
-0.0661527589,
0.0450716689,
2.558654013e-34,
0.0436278731,
0.0439711735,
0.0269147828,
-0.0252662823,
0.0539099388,
0.0453287326,
0.0076622097,
0.0390597358,
0.0606700517,
-0.0423205942,
-0.0146302814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11654v1 | Ruby Teaming: Improving Quality Diversity Search with Memory for Automated Red Teaming | 2024-06-17T15:36:14 | 2024-06-17T15:36:14 | Vernon Toh Yan Han, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Ruby Teaming, a method that improves on Rainbow Teaming by
including a memory cache as its third dimension. The memory dimension provides
cues to the mutator to yield better-quality prompts, both in terms of attack
success rate (ASR) and quality diversity. The prompt archive generated by Ruby
Teaming has an ASR of 74%, which is 20% higher than the baseline. In terms of
quality diversity, Ruby Teaming outperforms Rainbow Teaming by 6% and 3% on
Shannon's Evenness Index (SEI) and Simpson's Diversity Index (SDI),
respectively. | [
-0.008289515,
-0.0223394297,
0.0072427788,
-0.0008285153,
-0.056025032,
-0.0375370383,
0.0519315191,
-0.0329021439,
-0.0466540419,
-0.0054900036,
0.0113068083,
-0.002718912,
-0.012530203,
0.0275111552,
0.0153247342,
0.0145259611,
0.0644685775,
-0.0367990062,
-0.0506368354,
0.00888272,
-0.013320406,
-0.0273589399,
-0.0122535974,
0.0266693626,
-0.0082945963,
-0.0183463562,
-0.0557725802,
0.0491017848,
0.0456429198,
-0.0233890917,
-0.0049651694,
0.0153993834,
-0.0408944748,
-0.0052060355,
0.0000020024,
-0.0231049508,
-0.0365686528,
0.0183170699,
-0.0279606842,
0.0387702063,
-0.0343622863,
-0.0015657694,
-0.0084454883,
0.0474318787,
-0.0025837289,
0.020798929,
0.0108305039,
0.0414288267,
0.0607567839,
0.0439942963,
0.0281204879,
0.0567726456,
0.0083688339,
-0.0297265854,
0.0196312554,
-0.0086755659,
-0.0210458916,
-0.0337982811,
0.0279498212,
0.0440538898,
0.0005644863,
-0.0752939135,
-0.009673073,
-0.0112236217,
-0.0716911703,
0.0285241026,
-0.0034601775,
0.0162712652,
-0.0274278801,
-0.0254346523,
-0.0726121143,
0.0340411365,
-0.0109397899,
0.0201672763,
-0.0149766579,
0.0051533263,
0.0386449732,
0.0368765891,
-0.0459948406,
-0.0486801267,
-0.065199554,
0.012849831,
0.0026417235,
-0.0493004173,
0.0126304217,
0.0583684705,
0.0233324841,
-0.0484685376,
-0.0179870985,
-0.0446277894,
0.0414781384,
-0.0059746723,
-0.0331632867,
-0.0272866189,
-0.0331284441,
-0.0192553028,
-0.0524966717,
-0.0492395759,
0.0453568138,
0.0262529831,
0.0175457876,
0.0181791913,
-0.022020163,
-0.0024153448,
-0.0065058703,
-0.0233207643,
-0.0095050205,
-0.0097402595,
-0.0021861608,
0.0078802602,
-0.032954827,
0.0281609129,
0.0190544147,
0.0042486032,
0.0388463214,
-0.0152623346,
-0.0317317173,
0.0347288065,
-0.0349998586,
0.0086469511,
-0.0008646568,
-0.0008956837,
-0.0203505512,
0.0564000458,
0.0051172907,
-0.0564031899,
-0.0503361113,
-0.0375685804,
-0.0240440033,
-0.0647842288,
-0.0206523482,
-0.0072394568,
-0.0414494574,
-0.0682137758,
-0.0245987903,
0.0493054874,
0.0159236398,
-0.0263469536,
0.0014561219,
-0.0193222277,
0.0476974919,
0.0128180431,
-0.0083067883,
-0.0171765387,
-0.0093271052,
-0.0144578144,
-0.0137181366,
0.030556934,
-0.0183471534,
-0.0187220145,
-0.0158576854,
0.038325157,
0.0280357618,
-0.0038907595,
-0.0089058168,
0.0020952155,
-0.0770687163,
0.0426390879,
-0.0437480845,
0.0417867377,
-0.0015827463,
-0.0187867247,
0.0184601899,
-0.0197372194,
-0.0499442369,
-0.0057652257,
0.036207702,
0.0383684598,
0.0844977424,
-0.0082201622,
0.019466402,
0.0272483043,
-0.0208800044,
-0.0779714808,
0.0252256505,
-0.0113908872,
0.0841949657,
0.0536733493,
0.0150152138,
0.0510631949,
-0.0524089858,
-0.0075452114,
-0.0047398945,
0.0546147414,
-0.0855192095,
-0.0089465138,
0.0303326901,
0.088610284,
-0.0315965638,
0.0360144936,
-0.0489427485,
-0.0092212167,
-0.0377403386,
-0.0621476099,
0.0132240336,
0.0116370935,
-0.0277169552,
0.0229803994,
0.0283610709,
-0.022731971,
-0.0376774482,
-0.0669539347,
-0.012729235,
0.0151081206,
0.0302971341,
-0.0175677333,
-0.0360260457,
-0.0009518226,
-0.0476442687,
-0.0247836579,
0.0091828853,
0.0698439777,
0.0197259802,
-0.0640547499,
-0.0471044816,
0.0093282377,
0.0016585357,
0.0456860662,
-0.002068752,
0.0044734483,
-0.0217796545,
0.0599682629,
0.0120756663,
-0.0030444181,
0.054790698,
-0.008448693,
0.0438724086,
0.0231863391,
0.0504449978,
0.0056003081,
-0.0303850733,
0.0418834724,
0.015150087,
0.0384446979,
0.0048935297,
-0.0090662483,
0.075082764,
0.036220368,
-0.022747986,
-0.0158756878,
0.0399379693,
0.0466290452,
-0.0277737416,
-0.0027813916,
0.0658739954,
-0.0460131578,
-0.0515383668,
0.0220317189,
-0.0015597099,
-0.0012768535,
0.0362727866,
-0.0096011478,
0.0335480571,
0.019656999,
-0.0265115462,
-0.0869970769,
0.0022369137,
0.0200903751,
-0.0831109583,
0.0004602363,
0.0169326589,
-0.0076027149,
0.0273541752,
0.030667441,
0.0325409845,
-0.0136355888,
-0.066442363,
0.0174030513,
0.0387858637,
0.0014817173,
0.0284492932,
-0.0116138225,
-0.0024552378,
-0.0133750886,
0.0007054126,
0.0338698253,
-0.0325161554,
-0.0443688519,
0.012620653,
-0.0386380628,
0.0220935531,
-0.0919113085,
0.0287604406,
-0.0266571939,
0.0094412705,
0.0532211214,
0.0225441735,
-0.0226320792,
-0.0589237884,
-0.0072556944,
-0.0104731014,
-0.0439932607,
0.0185272377,
-0.0247689858,
0.0367357172,
-0.0418152623,
-0.019697886,
0.0097352425,
0.0341243036,
0.0080325473,
0.079275839,
0.0224526208,
-0.0564100929,
-0.0011918022,
-0.0011981393,
-0.019257836,
0.0249028858,
-0.0133147091,
0.0336377844,
0.0089239869,
0.0291764941,
-0.0217439458,
-0.0100586312,
-0.0463226959,
0.0608344302,
-0.0008181945,
-0.0375585482,
-0.0512110442,
-0.0036381462,
-0.0086047594,
-0.0300623011,
-0.0336317234,
0.0452630334,
-0.0050897729,
0.0287326425,
-0.0982267261,
-0.0026828677,
-0.0390044227,
-0.0140897017,
-0.0643257871,
0.0007107162,
-0.0161494836,
-0.019143464,
0.0206894968,
-0.0872031897,
0.0382235982,
-0.0308375917,
-0.04822395,
-0.0123566026,
-0.0011038053,
0.0076829139,
0.0305533037,
-0.0607908592,
0.0069064074,
0.0287589543,
-0.0346026979,
-0.0135071687,
0.0048809433,
-0.0438255966,
0.0094191888,
0.0763147995,
-0.0103235031,
-0.014308922,
-0.0319548361,
0.0382944196,
0.0000036602,
-0.0162225589,
-0.0427184515,
0.0414723009,
-0.0084203621,
0.0454332083,
0.0445522144,
0.081553027,
-0.0112375533,
-0.0238368548,
0.0065292143,
0.0220369548,
-0.0316881947,
0.0067116041,
0.0293495972,
-0.008525799,
0.0166061763,
0.0172806624,
0.013007585,
0.0241078343,
-0.0472442359,
0.004827376,
-0.0443317443,
0.0025572272,
-0.0040216707,
0.0518542118,
-0.0471507981,
0.0109904157,
0.0028938612,
0.0379268602,
-0.0257233791,
-0.0436696298,
-0.0225429703,
-0.0849312022,
-0.0257302392,
0.0034885525,
-0.0499382243,
-0.0222454499,
-0.0271614008,
0.0098916758,
0.017198218,
0.0923650637,
0.0153822806,
0.0157959666,
0.0106813638,
0.0081865136,
0.0013314866,
-0.0511010587,
-0.0356757678,
-0.0527429841,
0.008234228,
0.0646715462,
-0.0293506086,
0.0035880231,
0.0091348616,
0.0296697542,
0.0325367041,
0.0387272723,
-0.0176546648,
0.0380284488,
0.0162501894,
-0.0008454947,
-0.0100973789,
-0.0204381403,
0.0400475189,
-0.0249850731,
0.0427540541,
-0.0369910225,
-0.0503178276,
0.0041545643,
-0.0182125233,
-0.0083753904,
0.0548377,
0.0620261058,
0.0159167796,
-0.0149837835,
0.0257873703,
-0.019392956,
0.0162613168,
-0.0724062398,
-0.0356122218,
0.0263344962,
0.01044962,
0.0034966413,
-0.0144808851,
-0.0230025053,
0.0306312237,
0.0481456518,
0.0160344448,
-0.0257185344,
-0.0817373246,
0.0468138792,
-0.0130900284,
-0.0311669651,
0.016407948,
0.003676442,
-0.0481685363,
-0.0130486162,
-0.0581251122,
-0.033888299,
-0.0063806255,
-0.0018555265,
-0.0404696539,
-0.0141754281,
0.0672006086,
0.0588449948,
0.0342632644,
-0.028984597,
0.0083116051,
-0.0225858465,
0.0256049912,
0.0355673544,
-0.019072758,
0.0247187428,
0.0217123162,
-0.0359557308,
-0.0032737665,
-0.026262138,
-0.0378395207,
0.0308077149,
0.0452083908,
0.016629234,
-0.0233440306,
0.0007303761,
-0.0071369647,
0.0127738239,
0.0048362911,
-0.0031595272,
0.0141992439,
0.0404137522,
0.0642424077,
-0.0642007217,
0.0247269832,
0.0232344512,
0.0146894362,
-0.0356822722,
-0.0215952545,
0.040550001,
0.0749793127,
0.020713266,
-0.0176765304,
0.0098101525,
0.0240541305,
0.0485407002,
0.0233267341,
0.0418151692,
0.0089568114,
-0.0116674881,
0.012533633,
0.0298533887,
0.0205794685,
0.0239037145,
-0.0029280493,
0.0154890819,
-0.0158476923,
0.0222666245,
0.0240375791,
-0.0715227798,
-0.0827857926,
0.1043126434,
0.030674288,
0.0426065996,
0.0387030318,
-0.0187845379,
-0.0095335757,
0.0254520401,
-0.0239096172,
0.0004560805,
-0.0034821348,
0.0480511673,
-0.0045437347,
0.0077853091,
0.0086734248,
0.0460941121,
0.0093015721,
-0.0773406401,
0.046755854,
-0.0239292644,
-0.0028685511,
-0.0421392284,
0.0356305353,
-0.0171307903,
0.0738161653,
-0.0079280119,
-0.0665847212,
-0.0541988723,
0.0411741212,
0.0209044665,
0.0262711421,
0.0637886748,
0.0438281074,
-0.0039158422,
0.0320299044,
-0.006844942,
0.0427945778,
-0.0259563159,
0.0160296187,
-0.0349503756,
-0.0318344049,
0.0340262055,
-5.900539361e-33,
0.0404936038,
-0.0106942253,
-0.0268317927,
-0.0725419968,
0.0024799274,
0.0593352355,
-0.0222035255,
-0.0091753602,
-0.0086820889,
-0.0306753796,
-0.0176039059,
-0.0152040021,
0.0340921357,
-0.0111099305,
-0.0004161954,
0.0211801864,
0.0052250912,
0.0340848565,
-0.0208096895,
0.0011164923,
0.088584587,
0.0163959824,
-0.055550836,
-0.0186101347,
-0.0338229649,
-0.0043989038,
-0.0206236187,
0.0061380933,
-0.0409654006,
-0.0021287974,
0.0350359529,
-0.0063207629,
-0.0473184101,
-0.0448264703,
-0.0008102898,
0.0042697145,
0.0163430702,
-0.0389487781,
-0.0420744196,
-0.0550414808,
-0.0066731377,
-0.0250754375,
-0.0418048799,
0.0404867567,
-0.0335205123,
-0.007169819,
0.0163154379,
0.0143087264,
-0.038727127,
-0.0130438646,
0.0576136112,
0.0322912484,
-0.0208959859,
-0.0002821497,
-0.0399180539,
-0.0618961304,
0.0139445094,
-0.0192370061,
-0.0416911282,
0.0644178987,
-0.0351387039,
0.0178663116,
0.0083886357,
0.0186322983,
-0.0300793014,
0.0362631008,
0.0098978672,
0.0354984999,
0.061513789,
0.0189848095,
-0.0285454188,
0.0138874138,
0.0619015247,
0.0058545563,
0.0306629036,
-0.0179542452,
-0.0035565742,
0.0353260972,
0.1469251215,
0.0148862842,
0.0246123672,
0.0030108904,
-0.0933373049,
0.0192884691,
0.0373433866,
0.0158372279,
-0.0166229494,
-0.0751214921,
0.0204640683,
0.0116738565,
-0.0618831553,
0.0505065098,
0.0331351459,
0.0570568368,
0.0564102679,
0.0715267882,
-0.0088456273,
-0.016143119,
-0.0612249002,
-0.0427965336,
0.0524927527,
-0.0185858794,
0.0483221784,
-0.0503391586,
0.0419082046,
-0.0316717513,
0.0079552075,
0.0247020777,
-0.0650899336,
-0.0049337693,
-0.0211006012,
0.0830447674,
0.01195776,
-0.0622461885,
0.0058463844,
-0.0115883211,
0.0019008956,
0.0169569589,
0.0227169283,
-0.0846235231,
-0.0191494655,
0.0284659863,
-0.0010831632,
0.0373722948,
0.0075824773,
0.0554686822,
-0.0175657999,
-0.0274613798,
0.0006979997,
-0.0117569938,
-0.0304690674,
-0.0473081693,
2.876e-7,
-0.0007976472,
0.0109138694,
0.0774031878,
0.0113665517,
-0.0471271388,
0.0364235267,
-0.0201625917,
0.0779370889,
-0.0034564734,
-0.002205692,
-0.0518328436,
0.0298094153,
-0.0010207692,
0.0225939211,
0.0087282797,
-0.0331456549,
-0.0382277742,
0.0656261295,
-0.0729092509,
-0.0040595885,
0.0597153828,
0.0241049919,
0.0384983942,
-0.0228385627,
-0.0207252651,
-0.0492109396,
0.0057193139,
0.0465162657,
-0.0239666551,
0.0110592619,
0.0330552161,
-0.0778906047,
-0.0641028732,
0.0727569833,
-0.010865733,
-0.0507834032,
-0.0489875935,
-0.0101955449,
0.0517087318,
-0.0547790527,
0.0239433777,
0.0323902927,
-0.0115509862,
0.038621828,
0.0513210595,
0.080587104,
-0.0137683237,
-0.0159069691,
-0.0077810804,
-0.0332353152,
0.0344952792,
-0.004506629,
0.0139660593,
0.0359017029,
-0.0209967885,
-0.0058257012,
0.0597848706,
-0.0515035279,
-0.0081969248,
-0.0303971339,
-0.0377057716,
-0.0450795591,
0.0411255434,
0.0761452466,
0.0527518615,
0.0167490076,
-0.0335078575,
2.760181959e-34,
0.0051821726,
-0.0127411187,
0.0153026078,
-0.0038879195,
0.0276601464,
0.0121795814,
-0.0584398955,
-0.0109498426,
0.0193340182,
0.0129714161,
-0.0320654139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11651v1 | A Two-dimensional Zero-shot Dialogue State Tracking Evaluation Method using GPT-4 | 2024-06-17T15:32:17 | 2024-06-17T15:32:17 | Ming Gu, Yan Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue state tracking (DST) is evaluated by exact matching methods, which
rely on large amounts of labeled data and ignore semantic consistency, leading
to over-evaluation. Currently, leveraging large language models (LLM) in
evaluating natural language processing tasks has achieved promising results.
However, using LLM for DST evaluation is still under explored. In this paper,
we propose a two-dimensional zero-shot evaluation method for DST using GPT-4,
which divides the evaluation into two dimensions: accuracy and completeness.
Furthermore, we also design two manual reasoning paths in prompting to further
improve the accuracy of evaluation. Experimental results show that our method
achieves better performance compared to the baselines, and is consistent with
traditional exact matching based methods. | [
0.0058939462,
0.0538855642,
0.0137542253,
0.0720324218,
-0.0505837388,
0.0032201381,
0.0018870798,
0.0271958895,
0.0262723342,
-0.0770539045,
-0.0390814953,
-0.077292867,
0.0058474364,
0.0254834387,
-0.0254119355,
-0.0600244962,
0.0392262675,
-0.0301730223,
-0.0141342012,
0.0200600103,
0.0221033785,
0.0111570209,
-0.0533738732,
0.0465324223,
-0.008492711,
-0.0317778587,
-0.0093529988,
-0.014614664,
0.0420089923,
-0.0539618246,
-0.0456179455,
0.0241282266,
0.0369536802,
0.0251168683,
0.0000018956,
-0.0504058339,
0.0040358943,
0.0041618031,
-0.039113842,
0.0121377334,
-0.0030513776,
0.0052496255,
0.0006845036,
0.013092353,
-0.0215520263,
-0.0196117628,
0.0311424136,
0.0567997396,
0.0916122049,
0.0560133308,
-0.0117449537,
-0.044470761,
0.026130259,
0.0020179385,
0.0326831341,
-0.0943304077,
0.0220002942,
0.0158341266,
0.0468139872,
0.0193455033,
-0.0137084145,
0.0379671156,
-0.0127702784,
-0.0147454999,
-0.0346907601,
0.0204878505,
-0.0598011129,
0.023903586,
-0.0382647812,
0.1013664603,
0.0495365821,
0.0530041158,
0.0180590674,
-0.0240554232,
-0.0330670476,
-0.0223585367,
-0.0662907958,
-0.0413942933,
-0.0030600894,
-0.0003593262,
-0.0292388853,
0.0283020437,
-0.0149462782,
-0.0096314987,
-0.0107632689,
0.08671657,
0.0239174366,
-0.0516758673,
-0.0477044843,
0.0028536245,
0.0105503062,
-0.0673996508,
0.0101525979,
0.0193655174,
-0.0252854228,
0.0263928548,
-0.045581799,
0.0049700672,
-0.0207582396,
-0.0232471377,
0.0069229193,
0.0676645562,
-0.0206611976,
0.0819829702,
0.0162647814,
0.1141909584,
-0.0170101095,
-0.0191759989,
-0.032809075,
-0.0045334669,
-0.090277575,
0.0083790692,
-0.0516275316,
0.0077138338,
-0.0088961497,
-0.0812934637,
-0.0232980866,
0.0112657202,
-0.0080347247,
0.0287505127,
-0.0206912141,
-0.0039572567,
0.0160263311,
-0.024391612,
-0.0228091367,
0.0642819181,
-0.0186817311,
0.0060552079,
-0.0186050367,
-0.0214576926,
-0.0071416991,
0.02233156,
0.0508580245,
0.0025161142,
0.0026711021,
0.0523595028,
0.0083226319,
-0.0492486432,
0.0012793267,
0.0053856289,
-0.0505001694,
-0.0636400506,
-0.0424711704,
-0.0307853743,
0.0306085125,
0.0040293122,
0.0036403525,
0.0022594596,
0.0021260616,
0.0185477212,
-0.0236177482,
0.0761854872,
0.0234853253,
0.013781379,
0.0046686186,
0.0137682995,
0.0051857289,
0.0256304983,
0.0404991619,
-0.0006578365,
0.0235829633,
-0.0134951258,
0.0537617765,
0.0528475866,
-0.0152114993,
0.011637426,
-0.052979026,
0.0426054671,
-0.0048648901,
0.0229587462,
-0.0000143218,
0.043261826,
-0.0599760264,
0.0103761777,
0.0567877963,
0.0831715465,
-0.0239847358,
-0.0298976041,
0.0358960181,
0.0540036559,
-0.0040387111,
0.0069048004,
-0.0010259143,
0.0078979805,
-0.0189735834,
0.0012507,
0.061745327,
-0.0220276974,
-0.0389186814,
-0.0038624872,
-0.0107487496,
0.0079847565,
0.0199620966,
-0.0029274574,
0.0405808352,
-0.0198585298,
-0.085304074,
0.0347541198,
-0.0359969698,
-0.0313517042,
-0.0379659235,
-0.0318810195,
0.0200012736,
0.0793844536,
0.0578774959,
-0.0058572786,
-0.0698012784,
-0.0451120324,
0.0103244092,
0.0326402858,
0.0009863679,
-0.007409072,
0.0126913777,
-0.0751969814,
-0.0197701938,
0.0134438211,
0.0032744452,
0.0002412874,
0.0023565535,
0.0051284949,
0.028172031,
0.0116912676,
0.0278748348,
0.0070114341,
0.0391975567,
-0.0534231849,
0.0154847698,
-0.0089177657,
0.064883545,
0.0387429185,
-0.0041452595,
-0.0143305054,
0.0094763981,
0.0118096005,
-0.0090813329,
0.0206521284,
-0.064647913,
-0.0506531745,
0.0183534212,
0.0249713324,
-0.0292392075,
0.0166733004,
-0.0316256806,
-0.0792479813,
-0.0182611514,
-0.0189522058,
-0.0078793904,
-0.0386939831,
0.0400933772,
0.0366066992,
-0.0141562941,
-0.040075019,
0.0348833501,
0.0159126185,
0.014633432,
0.0223737806,
0.0225206912,
0.0335335843,
-0.0517623723,
-0.0276645534,
0.0437094122,
-0.0045778621,
0.0111644166,
0.0029305499,
-0.0127792424,
-0.0601725169,
-0.0011995101,
-0.0974306464,
0.0164204128,
-0.00730995,
0.0258382615,
0.0198259819,
-0.0083026327,
-0.0342298597,
-0.0169427004,
-0.0376787931,
-0.0124398237,
0.0569389611,
-0.0286795702,
0.0033709041,
0.0190312937,
-0.0319544673,
-0.0344346724,
0.0345721282,
-0.010323884,
0.0067659724,
-0.013196297,
-0.0092506753,
-0.0540070459,
0.0186578333,
-0.0044391113,
0.0360198058,
-0.0068313293,
-0.0311553162,
0.0353261083,
0.0191890076,
-0.0133878672,
0.0288328994,
-0.0188292135,
-0.0144405058,
0.0092190793,
-0.0497430749,
-0.0421761461,
0.031906642,
0.0003072402,
0.0151673025,
-0.0133058969,
0.0236630589,
-0.0080005229,
0.0250042472,
0.0373363681,
0.0599147081,
-0.062983714,
-0.0072265565,
-0.0222295206,
0.0241681412,
-0.0257088859,
-0.0224315058,
-0.0568651333,
0.0230804924,
-0.0024285107,
-0.0188213214,
0.035225369,
-0.1054287031,
-0.0466871299,
-0.0306542665,
0.0183580425,
-0.009053654,
0.0738729164,
-0.0040704212,
0.0044899508,
-0.0057305684,
-0.0272436105,
0.0118482597,
-0.0558915995,
0.019092517,
-0.0306549035,
0.0505716018,
-0.0436110236,
0.0620783158,
0.0008473493,
-0.0200538021,
-0.0450126119,
-0.0532251336,
-0.0572218485,
0.0012715835,
-0.0364312381,
-0.0383043587,
0.010921767,
0.0629288778,
0.018554436,
0.0535293892,
-0.0103946477,
0.003006835,
-0.0367237292,
0.0457779504,
0.0405817591,
-0.02286667,
-0.0634757951,
0.0103206011,
0.072219722,
0.0240962412,
0.0341358855,
0.0670808405,
-0.0337426253,
-0.0128712393,
0.0107324887,
-0.0015654702,
-0.0145566082,
0.0162763093,
0.062734805,
-0.0645639971,
0.0103665618,
0.1301438212,
0.0355118699,
-0.0272927452,
-0.0404598936,
-0.0103731705,
-0.0395981781,
0.0218975823,
0.0075254319,
-0.0750461221,
-0.0680291802,
-0.0004201929,
0.0194229353,
-0.0095171258,
-0.0268683136,
-0.0056085917,
-0.1239426881,
0.0352208503,
-0.0061080488,
-0.0453503691,
-0.0310642701,
-0.0097706215,
0.0522361919,
0.0000243854,
0.0017300403,
0.0021045245,
0.0077443202,
-0.0253903978,
0.0120804608,
-0.0213477127,
-0.0326675922,
0.0668106228,
-0.0192571115,
0.0911738425,
0.084547624,
0.0644246638,
0.0027396122,
-0.0279141981,
0.0196504109,
-0.0143365609,
-0.007435692,
0.0109054595,
0.0275945421,
-0.0203817841,
-0.0161223579,
-0.0204533748,
0.0092738112,
0.023066951,
-0.0078584198,
0.009294617,
0.0478160866,
-0.0544252545,
0.0408795103,
0.0008548828,
0.0275611561,
0.0130337374,
0.0876613185,
0.024272915,
-0.0152510339,
-0.0101995496,
0.0157317817,
-0.0282477103,
-0.02209194,
-0.0091131395,
-0.0151490951,
0.0033292423,
0.0363167785,
-0.0808308423,
-0.0172736868,
0.0619351715,
0.0360379741,
-0.0373140611,
0.0211433433,
-0.0090873567,
0.0119257495,
0.0342063867,
0.0092542553,
-0.0337995701,
0.024171412,
-0.0620939359,
0.0171351936,
0.0528495051,
0.0154130608,
-0.0224252604,
0.0504669063,
-0.044063732,
-0.0419720449,
-0.0428065993,
0.0175678432,
0.0146693131,
0.0465248749,
-0.0118960021,
-0.0039545982,
-0.0304771215,
0.0005883368,
0.009297071,
-0.0150774345,
0.031418547,
0.0561240315,
-0.0420427918,
0.0125543186,
0.0181182865,
0.0373254009,
-0.0184416007,
0.0420521498,
-0.0685455576,
-0.0858371332,
0.0047318875,
0.0278374478,
0.0734958723,
0.0124616642,
-0.0029314556,
0.0032824529,
0.0208810847,
-0.0391528755,
-0.02175612,
-0.0613214374,
-0.0169331059,
0.0094457939,
-0.0518646874,
-0.0242335126,
-0.0150800357,
-0.0556527674,
-0.0042063948,
-0.02771849,
-0.0223079398,
-0.0002742235,
-0.0295009762,
0.000147364,
-0.0157633442,
-0.0112539856,
0.0126525508,
0.0316080824,
0.0283097122,
0.0054891165,
0.132932052,
-0.0011744912,
-0.0128323399,
0.0078263097,
0.0447702892,
-0.0436590724,
-0.0574789979,
-0.023943983,
0.0523305126,
0.0633438975,
-0.018087931,
0.044587817,
-0.0117263757,
0.0068210498,
-0.0242393706,
0.0465165563,
0.0189804137,
-0.0283061191,
0.0254190024,
0.0387040563,
-0.0075832321,
0.0085818321,
0.0513516292,
0.01306233,
0.0331147835,
0.0149645759,
-0.0115114572,
-0.0363764986,
0.002567465,
0.023150688,
0.0178348795,
-0.0102405176,
0.012934071,
-0.0402702689,
-0.0387873128,
0.0092118159,
0.0005934802,
-0.0118586682,
-0.0091199586,
0.0502652489,
0.0160675347,
-0.0226993691,
0.0129452776,
-0.0375134088,
-0.0533660911,
0.0092197889,
-0.0050365133,
-0.0473819338,
-5.867031528e-33,
-0.0426403694,
-0.0399271846,
0.0392696075,
-0.0174839105,
-0.0382304229,
-0.0038059475,
-0.026925128,
0.0058836141,
0.0214496143,
-0.0205761176,
-0.0088054305,
0.0164697748,
0.0140803428,
0.0026038643,
-0.0245227385,
-0.0569630973,
0.0437410958,
0.0094273491,
-0.0407476388,
0.0119510107,
0.0433818437,
0.0007740205,
0.0435279571,
-0.0789045319,
0.0238748845,
-0.006836216,
-0.0380263664,
-0.0055041006,
-0.0026188486,
0.0290044956,
-0.0350735448,
0.0136627536,
0.022781739,
-0.0756834522,
-0.0102178156,
0.0376498289,
0.0108983023,
-0.0244641323,
0.0298814904,
-0.0012129614,
0.0122042745,
0.0301665794,
-0.0130106648,
0.001628808,
-0.0225647427,
0.0154754398,
-0.0039377147,
-0.003530208,
0.0102755288,
0.0170366708,
-0.0614481829,
0.0509985164,
-0.0110734422,
-0.0766049922,
0.040879149,
0.076209493,
0.0178190637,
-0.009517096,
-0.055117406,
-0.0121331336,
0.0000900622,
-0.0004841526,
0.0543006212,
0.0117546571,
0.0166021734,
0.0783426017,
-0.010895228,
-0.0314574577,
-0.0416287892,
-0.0600589961,
-0.0162211061,
0.0279342569,
0.0610721782,
0.0128129916,
0.0298248269,
0.0179520212,
-0.0177486464,
0.0209082384,
-0.0044914861,
0.0576123223,
0.0090692472,
0.0313614532,
-0.0621832982,
-0.0011431878,
-0.0317105204,
0.009254491,
-0.0316722766,
-0.0166097768,
0.0415067188,
0.0082500689,
-0.01176407,
0.0009206278,
0.0753106922,
-0.0251218285,
0.0029865922,
0.000361556,
-0.0382132195,
0.0393393077,
-0.0146400956,
0.0179548636,
-0.0256629772,
-0.0264464654,
0.0339080691,
0.0253388807,
0.0243184213,
-0.0116495891,
-0.0038128323,
0.0039796946,
-0.0532185398,
0.0031841558,
-0.0132311052,
0.0037329092,
-0.0715535283,
0.0308563933,
0.0290083345,
0.0189031456,
-0.0116227707,
0.0901333243,
-0.0088669304,
-0.0332633555,
-0.0030239492,
-0.0440043397,
-0.0032417648,
-0.009884052,
-0.025454659,
0.0240963288,
0.006329508,
-0.0349169485,
0.0042454596,
-0.0176164247,
0.0101480177,
0.0190778673,
2.693e-7,
-0.0029365644,
0.0489013381,
0.0089989491,
0.0037433789,
0.0063468455,
0.0619042516,
-0.0424262211,
0.0158120357,
0.0168471243,
-0.0103312228,
0.0450834259,
0.0034676921,
0.0667698383,
0.0075547677,
-0.1088984609,
-0.0229939036,
-0.0556898601,
-0.010335261,
-0.0672709197,
0.0493272319,
0.0893362612,
0.0313394964,
0.0121513903,
0.0372335911,
0.0250969864,
-0.036236845,
0.0502143688,
0.0087208627,
0.0062868227,
0.0056148572,
0.0362999476,
-0.0088456692,
-0.0101198955,
0.0213421676,
0.0122329341,
0.0282180887,
0.0229614563,
0.0999121889,
-0.0265528969,
-0.0137550114,
-0.053982757,
0.0118772034,
-0.0074213501,
-0.0416234173,
0.0705709234,
-0.0274044052,
-0.0090335207,
-0.0329598039,
-0.0335286781,
-0.0135945249,
0.0398095064,
0.0478357896,
-0.0119424257,
0.0059676063,
0.0269639436,
-0.0177785493,
-0.0254954994,
-0.0879857019,
0.0010337102,
-0.0367789641,
-0.0399422757,
-0.0099766562,
-0.0216117911,
-0.0258651339,
0.0030507834,
-0.0401490927,
-0.0280750468,
2.223385116e-34,
0.0105341971,
-0.0022901264,
0.0201115366,
-0.0022829422,
0.0244194865,
0.0214651972,
-0.0131525593,
0.0177443195,
0.0110878609,
-0.098984547,
0.0154216234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00066v1 | Compress then Serve: Serving Thousands of LoRA Adapters with Little Overhead | 2024-06-17T15:21:35 | 2024-06-17T15:21:35 | Rickard Brüel-Gabrielsson, Jiacheng Zhu, Onkar Bhardwaj, Leshem Choshen, Kristjan Greenewald, Mikhail Yurochkin, Justin Solomon | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) with low-rank adapters (LoRAs) has
become common practice, often yielding numerous copies of the same LLM
differing only in their LoRA updates. This paradigm presents challenges for
systems that serve real-time responses to queries that each involve a different
LoRA. Prior works optimize the design of such systems but still require
continuous loading and offloading of LoRAs, as it is infeasible to store
thousands of LoRAs in GPU memory. To mitigate this issue, we investigate the
efficacy of compression when serving LoRA adapters. We consider compressing
adapters individually via SVD and propose a method for joint compression of
LoRAs into a shared basis paired with LoRA-specific scaling matrices. Our
experiments with up to 500 LoRAs demonstrate that compressed LoRAs preserve
performance while offering major throughput gains in realistic serving
scenarios with over a thousand LoRAs, maintaining 75% of the throughput of
serving a single LoRA. | [
-0.0034817848,
0.0503936261,
-0.0345189236,
0.0488943979,
0.0033592363,
0.0216578711,
0.0404878668,
0.050876718,
0.0159630198,
-0.0106552765,
0.0133759575,
-0.0370342992,
0.0149761159,
0.038792666,
-0.0061388128,
-0.0352401026,
0.0153081212,
-0.0319877453,
-0.0451546758,
-0.0216307845,
-0.0170470178,
0.0245372746,
0.051792305,
0.0282006301,
0.0452736095,
-0.0255824123,
-0.028408153,
-0.0190449655,
-0.0068878434,
0.0321323015,
-0.0125126289,
0.0158632919,
0.064980045,
0.0407922082,
0.0000023011,
-0.0036425744,
-0.0221713278,
0.0088984622,
-0.0380406529,
0.0607118309,
0.0504520014,
-0.0529340953,
-0.018265795,
0.0437609889,
-0.0333866179,
-0.0559033938,
0.0426890813,
-0.0246048048,
0.0362681746,
-0.0095902421,
-0.017109612,
-0.0403393023,
-0.0038412681,
-0.0240727942,
-0.0497523025,
-0.0315771811,
-0.0102341315,
-0.0031274499,
-0.0056183371,
-0.0117984712,
-0.0296040997,
0.0257738177,
0.0016674545,
-0.0302055236,
-0.0082267113,
0.0020914557,
-0.0509737097,
0.0070904084,
-0.0117658898,
0.0109285787,
-0.0366155691,
-0.0346330591,
0.0193684157,
0.013578319,
-0.0532326587,
-0.0354581214,
-0.0111666564,
0.0232649092,
0.0017929273,
0.0271885954,
-0.0253595877,
-0.0396365225,
-0.0059683993,
-0.030577071,
-0.0787593573,
0.024234999,
0.0519273952,
0.0156363621,
-0.0459008999,
-0.0167661551,
0.0042697424,
-0.0576232933,
0.0300642438,
0.0254265293,
-0.040029075,
-0.0028260665,
-0.0911381021,
-0.068336308,
0.0419452004,
-0.0372292809,
0.118861109,
0.0594926439,
0.0146680241,
0.0272504184,
-0.0368600599,
0.0501380302,
-0.0418560095,
-0.0423578247,
-0.0534306169,
-0.0277181901,
0.0235259533,
-0.0037378029,
-0.0297524892,
0.0499142781,
-0.0940935463,
-0.0260100104,
-0.0027630383,
0.0550323091,
0.0364068113,
0.0120194079,
-0.0456183739,
0.0097462628,
-0.0018828495,
0.0101622408,
0.0171673279,
0.0647339672,
0.0196500178,
-0.0276922677,
-0.0478716642,
-0.0607718751,
-0.0003968024,
0.0108034667,
0.0393445902,
0.0042052157,
0.0146457311,
0.0265498646,
-0.0067689689,
-0.0264008362,
0.0086771604,
-0.0303824954,
0.0491766892,
-0.0408037789,
-0.0261179432,
-0.0210274365,
0.0405563973,
0.0256564505,
0.0261829495,
0.0108598853,
-0.0190117471,
0.0296476316,
-0.0418642424,
0.0527654923,
0.0133871138,
0.028545659,
0.0193999093,
-0.0211961325,
0.0863215849,
0.0613170043,
0.0372683667,
0.0129322922,
-0.0016094551,
-0.0331244357,
-0.037597578,
0.0433460288,
-0.0048247017,
0.0358844846,
-0.0661967024,
0.0390994623,
0.0492448285,
0.007330602,
0.0446644463,
0.0552893691,
-0.0296404194,
-0.0385977551,
0.0442884378,
0.0665257648,
0.0073182741,
0.0470658094,
0.0330776051,
0.0051211552,
-0.0003814825,
-0.0184886102,
0.0012348341,
0.0503854565,
0.0029140858,
-0.007003597,
0.0425435007,
0.0765513033,
-0.0212304611,
0.0004750899,
-0.0473983549,
-0.007793129,
-0.0410146415,
0.0025122981,
0.02098093,
-0.0220796727,
-0.051043354,
0.0521462969,
0.0347800292,
-0.086587064,
-0.0052036839,
-0.0485612787,
-0.0027271314,
0.0641229749,
0.0492356606,
0.023959687,
-0.0560243167,
-0.0012494549,
-0.0017411213,
0.0401509106,
0.0336092785,
0.0060744509,
-0.0209824611,
-0.0463306718,
-0.0097574471,
0.0574940518,
0.0135343382,
0.0171924792,
-0.0037388529,
0.0381219685,
-0.027458543,
-0.0081297467,
-0.0346639119,
0.0116908913,
-0.0112013146,
0.0111726755,
0.0436371751,
-0.0121476371,
0.0226746984,
-0.0355800427,
-0.0015656431,
-0.0437388457,
0.0645703301,
-0.0507115573,
0.0264281165,
-0.0202954486,
-0.0136848185,
0.012913662,
0.0171993785,
0.0203268006,
0.0452553853,
0.0566987954,
-0.0369278602,
-0.0351985283,
0.0210139975,
-0.0285856444,
0.0284071043,
-0.0010835757,
0.0143129639,
-0.0159600899,
0.0465294793,
-0.0077479081,
-0.0007778617,
-0.0192117281,
0.0437069051,
0.0408858582,
0.0034106788,
0.0519863144,
-0.0256797094,
-0.0351484902,
0.0005828776,
-0.0072071259,
0.0292657204,
-0.0025427537,
0.0021103905,
0.02667813,
-0.0198966563,
-0.0594948418,
-0.0204344783,
-0.0207468085,
0.0392002463,
0.0400474332,
0.0356628448,
0.0391059034,
-0.04016928,
-0.0114135807,
0.0656506419,
-0.0004703831,
0.0352442935,
-0.0100309998,
-0.0090947747,
-0.0561440848,
-0.025401568,
-0.02142803,
0.0097723864,
0.0544568077,
-0.0241281241,
-0.0199087765,
-0.0583547577,
-0.013704719,
-0.0064149201,
0.0577744991,
-0.0096828258,
-0.0577574596,
0.0144090466,
-0.0092121279,
0.0343655869,
0.0606430173,
0.0146341408,
-0.0290964991,
0.0776642635,
0.02053589,
-0.0578811988,
0.0127695743,
-0.0316241793,
-0.0505505614,
-0.0663701594,
-0.0043143001,
-0.0204187855,
0.0391861424,
-0.0222420823,
-0.0045099789,
-0.0373665541,
-0.0428175814,
-0.0082604857,
-0.0242524426,
-0.0378385819,
-0.003153892,
-0.0083178412,
0.0208719354,
-0.0011180695,
-0.0684967935,
0.0078185713,
-0.0344114602,
-0.0247394051,
0.0085487608,
-0.040675886,
-0.0592433065,
0.0476544052,
0.0388449393,
0.0439061932,
-0.0872592926,
-0.0141157433,
0.0163962971,
0.0343152322,
-0.033483278,
-0.0521812476,
0.0433607548,
-0.029222494,
0.0086404309,
-0.0473886579,
-0.0694657862,
-0.0085003721,
0.0105718877,
-0.0097353952,
-0.0070447368,
-0.000966806,
-0.053030517,
-0.0351355113,
0.0577711537,
-0.003590788,
0.0690685436,
-0.0038761143,
-0.0055442089,
-0.0208294392,
0.0136088422,
0.0513537526,
0.0768671557,
-0.00167676,
0.0270704627,
0.0087206922,
0.0369127579,
0.0885320827,
-0.0206311215,
-0.038735535,
0.022057062,
0.0991178825,
0.0144231999,
-0.0208094101,
0.0229974706,
-0.027493855,
-0.0284015033,
-0.0387027897,
0.0628368929,
0.0230345577,
-0.0669006258,
-0.0079388088,
-0.0085826665,
0.0766752511,
0.0409550928,
0.0610753261,
-0.0790324584,
0.0104953144,
0.0044660829,
0.0003152561,
0.0234763566,
0.0077178637,
-0.0247408785,
-0.1095062345,
0.0397756584,
0.0073781512,
-0.0029135197,
-0.0205435194,
-0.0552078858,
0.0062433905,
0.0072737075,
0.0441285819,
0.0288879722,
-0.0130260428,
0.0038405315,
0.006176074,
-0.0143131111,
0.0015102084,
-0.0109802801,
0.0023473012,
0.0452131666,
0.0362027586,
0.01746439,
0.0412342399,
-0.0389082842,
-0.0392934941,
0.0230757073,
-0.0206406359,
-0.0380917005,
-0.0094444314,
0.0346069671,
-0.0392450467,
-0.0088626668,
-0.0128604705,
-0.0344030708,
0.0112592578,
-0.0452911817,
0.0847227499,
-0.0074196411,
-0.0067365235,
-0.0098026702,
-0.0521419048,
-0.0189516228,
0.0289611612,
0.0042024939,
-0.0203348584,
-0.0086030951,
0.00144563,
-0.0467651933,
0.0241795536,
-0.0728805512,
0.0148968669,
-0.0191594679,
-0.0044541084,
0.0120351361,
0.0393592492,
0.0285062287,
0.0240165833,
-0.009560287,
0.00706062,
0.0141217606,
0.0042267451,
-0.0274382047,
-0.0284993388,
-0.068020992,
-0.0209052376,
-0.0459988229,
-0.0070808176,
0.0173688103,
0.006484692,
-0.0279102996,
0.0013825047,
-0.0605891459,
-0.0426781625,
0.0335036702,
0.0529412702,
0.0312236529,
0.0152615421,
0.0112336706,
-0.0724350438,
0.0243961178,
0.0543707162,
-0.0400529467,
0.0905604661,
-0.025205262,
-0.0552261211,
0.0044670468,
0.0471293144,
-0.0391493589,
-0.0068484289,
-0.005395222,
-0.0186379105,
0.0046800775,
-0.0497634038,
-0.009862693,
0.063238658,
-0.0202835072,
0.0159916263,
-0.0520565026,
0.0369132906,
0.0868178084,
-0.0351689607,
0.0164924599,
-0.033723034,
-0.0234655775,
-0.0121996319,
-0.0128264064,
-0.0261826999,
0.0048868014,
0.0526785515,
-0.0167959519,
-0.0315574631,
-0.0109881302,
0.0207538698,
-0.0505445935,
0.0803584158,
0.0211072899,
0.0026069046,
-0.0150884017,
0.0156475864,
0.0473928265,
-0.0673923641,
-0.063951984,
-0.0071058716,
0.0043012649,
-0.0128864609,
0.0512870699,
-0.0081863357,
-0.112897113,
-0.0235827919,
-0.0080305394,
0.0244955085,
0.0221698526,
0.0825323462,
0.0146998428,
0.0203311816,
-0.0140558546,
-0.0140229827,
0.0093544293,
0.0216766391,
0.023146674,
0.0026199108,
-0.0211198088,
0.0356915109,
0.0316121392,
-0.0000394413,
0.0425966121,
0.004171107,
-0.0129974457,
-0.0152276,
0.009189018,
-0.0438969433,
0.0188931879,
-0.0033915685,
-0.0666998178,
-0.0233346429,
-0.0454697832,
0.0015776595,
0.026630301,
-0.0140399942,
-0.0284762941,
-0.0141138881,
0.0431656539,
0.0335071646,
0.0279684979,
-0.0103876684,
0.0203921273,
-0.0312832631,
-0.0213092752,
0.0447369814,
-7.084938817e-33,
-0.0161518492,
-0.0135162324,
0.0377446972,
-0.0279996321,
0.0132316416,
0.0216818489,
-0.0198769048,
-0.0455428213,
0.0123453271,
-0.0258663669,
-0.0365911387,
0.0095575936,
0.0248718038,
0.0058653462,
0.0185906589,
0.0088224346,
0.0473514237,
0.0063822446,
-0.0213021841,
0.0238109492,
0.0432108007,
0.0047738282,
-0.0012263001,
-0.0320687406,
-0.0606054962,
-0.0205559488,
0.0261320081,
0.0055063148,
0.000474429,
0.0571384132,
-0.0683894604,
0.0556888543,
-0.0085936477,
-0.0379847437,
-0.0071544694,
0.013546953,
-0.070961304,
-0.009870749,
0.0294624809,
0.015717322,
-0.0023265064,
0.0093400665,
0.0175025649,
0.039025452,
-0.0192556344,
0.0063775526,
-0.010605922,
0.0271152779,
-0.0472149141,
0.017550258,
-0.0376426578,
-0.0054480811,
0.0255612414,
0.0481479429,
0.0798408687,
-0.0299046524,
-0.005690882,
0.0410078354,
-0.0674832612,
0.0151651064,
-0.0003062333,
0.0656057447,
0.0556595325,
-0.0149967931,
-0.0007957604,
0.0473357588,
0.0030994439,
-0.0288110971,
0.0284720603,
0.0285824593,
0.0163410567,
0.004869944,
0.0121219829,
0.0149686225,
0.0290992185,
-0.0320492424,
-0.0620257035,
-0.0205224697,
0.0377269089,
-0.0034069563,
0.0348343886,
0.003767096,
0.0057619014,
-0.0255147796,
-0.0326998532,
-0.0074408539,
-0.0423541442,
-0.0190252662,
0.0214592833,
0.0439793281,
-0.0245579313,
0.0054279692,
0.0355015211,
-0.016655894,
-0.0233181771,
-0.0118113291,
0.0129843215,
0.0085391626,
0.0267598201,
0.0489170328,
-0.0118682347,
-0.0339541286,
-0.0032416764,
-0.0655348226,
-0.0051491461,
-0.0069609582,
0.0145396041,
0.0473847538,
-0.1115020588,
0.0213521235,
-0.0352632627,
0.0078561278,
0.0286237244,
0.0350947417,
0.0421458408,
0.0071445801,
0.0215700623,
0.0372054763,
-0.0053360332,
0.0066014798,
0.0094483988,
-0.0524229258,
0.0054775425,
0.0064813755,
-0.0255406499,
0.0155535284,
-0.0608873107,
0.0502877273,
0.054381147,
-0.0349398218,
-0.0122590382,
0.0209344029,
3.062e-7,
-0.0131467069,
0.0485481583,
-0.0082041351,
-0.0458863527,
0.0182758383,
0.0128513984,
0.0383934602,
0.0548790731,
0.0272393283,
0.0010414385,
-0.0607139878,
-0.0021917815,
0.0144617707,
0.0208479781,
-0.0680882037,
0.0209153816,
-0.0602024607,
-0.0092255259,
-0.0265499707,
-0.0480155423,
-0.0110673653,
0.1201229542,
-0.0171310883,
-0.0507357828,
0.009262505,
-0.009260009,
0.0070098219,
0.0040062414,
-0.0122959567,
-0.0117567945,
0.0302465651,
-0.004449687,
-0.0474754199,
0.005632346,
-0.0068389801,
0.0213408116,
-0.0921581313,
0.0396771729,
-0.0398487113,
0.0302930083,
0.0455433503,
-0.0609528571,
-0.0433765687,
-0.0233058445,
0.0615910627,
0.0202452261,
-0.0075015547,
-0.0114818448,
0.033493422,
-0.0217955448,
-0.0103132725,
-0.0115871429,
0.0404292606,
0.0416803397,
-0.0017245244,
-0.0425001085,
0.0127670094,
-0.0763823017,
-0.0026636547,
0.0106666619,
-0.0234866925,
-0.0228536446,
-0.0621876195,
-0.0020649056,
0.0319101661,
-0.0233463999,
-0.0100558596,
3.27081923e-34,
0.0075396504,
0.0519158356,
0.0283249114,
0.0991665348,
-0.0047121742,
-0.0376231372,
-0.020216018,
0.0104506975,
-0.0189337935,
-0.1473460048,
-0.0375905037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11634v1 | The Base-Rate Effect on LLM Benchmark Performance: Disambiguating Test-Taking Strategies from Benchmark Performance | 2024-06-17T15:14:10 | 2024-06-17T15:14:10 | Kyle Moore, Jesse Roberts, Thao Pham, Oseremhen Ewaleifoh, Doug Fisher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Cloze testing is a common method for measuring the behavior of large language
models on a number of benchmark tasks. Using the MMLU dataset, we show that the
base-rate probability (BRP) differences across answer tokens are significant
and affect task performance ie. guess A if uncertain. We find that
counterfactual prompting does sufficiently mitigate the BRP effect. The BRP
effect is found to have a similar effect to test taking strategies employed by
humans leading to the conflation of task performance and test-taking ability.
We propose the Nvr-X-MMLU task, a variation of MMLU, which helps to
disambiguate test-taking ability from task performance and reports the latter. | [
0.0255176667,
0.0301484428,
-0.01549323,
0.042124562,
-0.0658054277,
0.0035247551,
-0.0013192907,
0.0341807827,
0.0057907547,
-0.0499457344,
-0.031601537,
-0.0834287927,
-0.0117925964,
0.0274983142,
0.0627233982,
0.0334306844,
0.048270639,
-0.0637251586,
0.0555111021,
-0.0469077975,
-0.0240589362,
-0.0391786657,
-0.0177000184,
0.0255361851,
0.0267413221,
0.0063155214,
0.0108387303,
-0.001349026,
-0.0451517105,
-0.033524476,
-0.0010765471,
0.0654369295,
-0.002817435,
0.0130008208,
0.0000019401,
-0.0765260756,
0.0459179915,
-0.0212489944,
-0.0569660477,
0.0076710014,
-0.0123596275,
0.0458583981,
0.0166157838,
0.046875421,
-0.0193375535,
0.0132806189,
0.0027963964,
0.0213901922,
-0.0160244871,
0.088259615,
0.0168716814,
0.0475421026,
0.0101716509,
-0.0335199125,
0.0445923992,
-0.0318109281,
0.0055598393,
0.0237727351,
0.0411715284,
-0.0241822507,
-0.0216197148,
0.0018236749,
0.026942227,
0.0299412403,
-0.0233513787,
0.0533052236,
0.0221549515,
-0.0055332836,
-0.0431696177,
0.0323944949,
-0.0075202724,
-0.0195440035,
0.0010002187,
-0.0169771109,
0.0093286475,
0.0234560072,
-0.0436259061,
0.0446963832,
-0.0080265068,
-0.0105523812,
0.0225890335,
-0.0109724961,
0.046263013,
-0.0193936862,
0.0035646562,
0.1074485108,
0.0122544393,
-0.0580173768,
0.0306238234,
0.0319007039,
-0.0254824273,
-0.0901671275,
-0.0043055261,
0.0254725423,
-0.0518280491,
-0.0018385357,
-0.0167062841,
-0.0005992248,
0.0682807863,
-0.0185650829,
0.0572538003,
0.0613584518,
-0.0246367473,
0.0016018219,
-0.0396832749,
0.1061707437,
0.0147808408,
0.0389081575,
-0.0117246537,
0.0081019495,
-0.0326061286,
-0.0113436105,
0.0284314957,
0.0297818184,
-0.0249394327,
-0.0000906039,
-0.0443361625,
0.0187441967,
-0.0088105928,
0.006251811,
-0.0068725613,
-0.0060736528,
-0.020339543,
0.0425304137,
-0.0812818483,
-0.0093824556,
-0.0474157408,
0.0313808918,
0.0113040172,
-0.0850798339,
-0.0345337018,
-0.0186444055,
-0.0098795323,
-0.0349367484,
0.0372156836,
0.0899777487,
-0.0243845005,
-0.0242154095,
0.0277563818,
-0.0383439586,
-0.0092925234,
-0.0580359846,
0.0209926926,
-0.0694304332,
0.0230632499,
0.0282731447,
-0.0134929661,
-0.0005252117,
0.0042930399,
0.0222123377,
-0.0029130599,
0.0263524819,
0.0607106462,
0.0088885343,
-0.011888898,
0.0025814711,
-0.0463603884,
0.0906730369,
0.0146232704,
0.0015566949,
0.0324847549,
-0.0173324738,
0.0226594377,
0.0658100992,
0.0210207794,
0.0053928592,
0.0035774568,
0.0098560806,
0.0115387794,
0.0362848043,
0.0954589397,
0.0208498724,
-0.0158248749,
-0.038837634,
0.0587853603,
0.0730960667,
-0.01827945,
-0.0529442057,
0.0002674158,
-0.006307832,
0.0115969777,
0.0484684817,
-0.0735005438,
0.0142271183,
-0.0202013291,
0.0481596664,
0.0086471485,
0.0158660859,
-0.0240560938,
-0.0146089392,
-0.0469714999,
0.013844071,
-0.0150656737,
0.0450954922,
0.0411888435,
-0.0189395659,
-0.0414397679,
0.0817993954,
0.0173409749,
-0.0231512785,
0.0093705356,
-0.0895403326,
0.0369409285,
0.0108703002,
0.0267294385,
0.0110485777,
-0.0353524424,
0.0098676421,
-0.0128489379,
0.0611190647,
0.0350273289,
0.0001199726,
0.0373295136,
0.0049107629,
0.0124375019,
-0.0196398292,
-0.0014721935,
0.0083602834,
-0.0001089045,
-0.0195269939,
0.0002504323,
-0.0483414903,
-0.0190775488,
0.0380991884,
-0.0153971929,
-0.0065775733,
-0.0101457471,
-0.0273533687,
0.0267078504,
-0.0125275049,
-0.0089174667,
0.0214216989,
0.0361650027,
-0.0198901705,
-0.0072195483,
-0.0016147876,
-0.0464042276,
-0.0616363548,
0.0475760438,
0.0120161762,
-0.0351091363,
0.039945025,
-0.0119535495,
-0.0455659106,
-0.0099818334,
-0.0284950882,
0.0725691691,
-0.026002707,
0.0314023942,
-0.0162570085,
0.0030532875,
-0.0307597723,
0.0592155084,
-0.0306626838,
0.0549272113,
0.0170565378,
0.01474794,
-0.0183727462,
-0.0829672515,
-0.0139455004,
0.0142179336,
-0.0262160636,
-0.0031197048,
-0.0027294138,
0.0171802435,
-0.0716779381,
-0.015931949,
-0.0724578574,
0.0054365858,
-0.0177868493,
0.050841935,
0.0168824624,
-0.0038060576,
-0.0341237187,
-0.0241991207,
-0.033982981,
-0.0331893004,
0.0426918939,
0.057808999,
0.0017184124,
-0.0019487272,
-0.0044091977,
-0.0433787517,
-0.011005925,
-0.0337688439,
0.0105677955,
-0.0092897508,
0.0173361562,
-0.0318079852,
0.0371037051,
-0.0150538171,
-0.0016743342,
-0.0151995383,
-0.0156428125,
0.0411364958,
0.0036151698,
0.0415235609,
0.0695030838,
-0.0207253397,
0.0080603557,
0.0474893637,
-0.0222906806,
-0.0669878423,
0.0146510014,
-0.0148356762,
-0.0223890245,
-0.0311925281,
-0.0758637413,
-0.0050394232,
0.0648984686,
0.0185025316,
0.0174187906,
-0.0153713254,
0.0257100109,
-0.0130189573,
-0.0468509607,
-0.0284765158,
0.015689496,
-0.0385650173,
0.0516040102,
-0.0319039524,
-0.0607386231,
0.0561840907,
-0.0425866805,
-0.0177187044,
-0.0254238732,
0.0133545017,
-0.0366550237,
0.0253887419,
0.0171572492,
-0.0367860012,
-0.009692735,
-0.0472203605,
-0.0251503624,
0.0055549862,
-0.0308556706,
-0.0347535834,
0.0386868566,
-0.0642928332,
0.0082737282,
-0.0114207454,
-0.0488138534,
-0.0482487008,
-0.0027385061,
-0.0301250946,
0.0152339237,
-0.0058644642,
-0.0254031196,
0.0211961903,
-0.0053597856,
-0.0043663993,
-0.0012174295,
-0.0580220409,
0.005847903,
-0.0230330825,
0.0467899442,
0.0559483394,
0.0903199911,
0.0532076955,
-0.0369813554,
-0.012363038,
0.0445063226,
0.0798726454,
0.0358854681,
-0.0088717816,
0.0278688408,
0.018437786,
-0.0307925791,
-0.0181074794,
0.0567956381,
0.0428466015,
-0.0332493857,
-0.0368156843,
0.1155063435,
0.0230612718,
-0.0005843107,
0.0163636003,
-0.0269317385,
0.0547078326,
0.0289699566,
0.0223813877,
-0.0560692921,
-0.0430921838,
0.0172048323,
0.0310976971,
-0.0493706279,
-0.0117329024,
-0.0048443726,
-0.115971908,
0.0095192846,
-0.0349741876,
-0.0393022299,
0.0171331409,
-0.0523395203,
0.0218073409,
-0.0021523046,
0.0636515021,
0.0236696899,
-0.0154458731,
0.0094524426,
0.0276876874,
-0.038718164,
-0.0766891316,
0.0563786402,
-0.0366093628,
0.0658278912,
0.0315621905,
0.0040532984,
-0.0448031835,
-0.0232676584,
0.038474381,
-0.0197302252,
0.0288345404,
-0.0403247811,
0.0143182091,
0.0206461959,
0.0093779899,
-0.0176233351,
-0.0062951758,
-0.027008336,
0.009008483,
0.0164407529,
0.0545293987,
-0.0244638417,
-0.0263092369,
-0.0154310884,
0.0008764657,
0.0067580943,
0.1059892401,
0.0388698988,
-0.0480094329,
-0.0364226624,
-0.0121866344,
-0.0268626567,
-0.0423146039,
-0.0257072411,
-0.0103924191,
-0.0065898201,
0.0392231494,
-0.0539198257,
-0.0542950816,
0.0301274881,
0.0305541977,
-0.003940532,
0.0084664188,
-0.0320812017,
0.0008941262,
-0.0115738716,
0.0447718985,
-0.000829735,
0.0258830208,
-0.0788612738,
0.0023458772,
0.0048107384,
-0.0065800068,
-0.0309962165,
0.0406814925,
-0.1259654313,
-0.0591553375,
-0.0046536392,
0.0317972898,
0.0327246264,
0.0093233185,
0.0157918539,
-0.0552241057,
0.0231557246,
-0.0385005437,
-0.0384657755,
0.0859310776,
0.0156018985,
-0.0159685742,
-0.0059301364,
0.0244932119,
-0.0483375527,
-0.0205352418,
0.0224406458,
0.0534255505,
-0.0036339138,
-0.0131894238,
0.0088797342,
0.0288599785,
0.0310984701,
0.0049210852,
0.0046943892,
-0.0129905455,
0.0314936489,
-0.0104855448,
0.0225852672,
0.0002829228,
-0.0348416641,
-0.009223518,
-0.0025322284,
-0.0043524862,
-0.0323549621,
-0.0610214882,
0.0352652743,
-0.0320317298,
-0.001075903,
0.0335431509,
0.0012589903,
0.0173880327,
0.0014232412,
-0.0122725619,
-0.0203977879,
0.0184260048,
0.0731152147,
0.0112281023,
0.0437130257,
-0.01697677,
-0.0368006937,
0.0140888849,
-0.0185946152,
-0.0688209683,
-0.0615169667,
0.0142702786,
0.0167931803,
0.0099865114,
-0.0134088043,
0.0421256386,
-0.0405687392,
0.0343832523,
-0.036338672,
-0.0306701735,
-0.0054103509,
0.0021332577,
0.0672108978,
0.0069359974,
-0.0149186784,
0.0076321792,
0.0703078359,
0.0609567687,
0.0276605785,
-0.018742742,
0.0254096091,
-0.0293370355,
-0.0339700654,
0.0207780823,
0.0295043848,
0.0010240629,
-0.0268586762,
-0.0781319365,
-0.0444292016,
0.0600036122,
0.0287714433,
0.0207496919,
-0.022638863,
0.0043039722,
0.0589550324,
-0.0010528697,
-0.0560177937,
-0.0305024963,
0.0174165331,
-0.0005756156,
-0.0040213917,
-0.0477512628,
-6.775996126e-33,
-0.0309044123,
-0.0535199977,
0.0319370925,
-0.0319694206,
0.0241619293,
0.0261200033,
-0.0288718306,
0.0251744259,
-0.0153916534,
-0.0334871747,
-0.0490327403,
0.0052376804,
0.0313586183,
0.0172440913,
0.0181245338,
-0.0177506097,
0.0223089438,
-0.0131996442,
-0.0412011035,
-0.0186422169,
0.0213711988,
0.0193080138,
0.0635987744,
-0.0156654045,
0.042633716,
-0.0123567441,
0.0289133862,
0.0035327957,
-0.0506665148,
0.0620707497,
-0.0197695773,
0.0527615994,
0.0395307504,
-0.0293811988,
-0.0242207423,
0.0008215823,
-0.0355937965,
-0.0530864783,
0.0613690317,
0.0122375712,
-0.0098347468,
0.0066413097,
0.0380501524,
0.0017203304,
-0.0570463352,
-0.0068031782,
0.0055948435,
-0.0103877615,
-0.0362579599,
0.0069166808,
-0.0289769154,
0.0006054478,
0.017427709,
0.0036774024,
0.0017848895,
0.0290025342,
-0.027302349,
-0.0156444758,
-0.0294088721,
0.0241926964,
0.0210189186,
0.0522236228,
0.0837743804,
0.0353659242,
-0.0136119658,
0.0575595908,
0.0413426794,
0.0087092621,
0.0460255407,
-0.0125995362,
0.0594959892,
0.0135730505,
0.041957356,
0.0442113504,
0.0850862786,
0.0063053267,
-0.0539500229,
0.0336456001,
0.1036813185,
0.0080432678,
0.0257655047,
-0.00075077,
-0.0493306555,
-0.0348557383,
-0.0299316868,
0.0192118157,
-0.0361803919,
-0.0239284448,
0.0532714166,
-0.0241172146,
0.0299152955,
-0.0151982047,
0.048198279,
0.0077893962,
-0.0185527187,
-0.0353773013,
-0.0142283738,
0.0348392129,
0.0030909567,
0.0095683448,
-0.0733139962,
-0.0053192368,
0.0062397304,
-0.0001769537,
0.0205330849,
0.0041410583,
-0.0133360969,
-0.0011118987,
-0.0443477482,
-0.0086359391,
-0.0463139862,
0.0277660247,
0.0254610088,
-0.0136786904,
0.0617303625,
-0.0161280222,
0.0001082196,
0.0117462035,
-0.0097057726,
-0.0678212568,
-0.0473548621,
0.0196851753,
-0.0053371498,
0.0401002094,
-0.0322489813,
0.0027933684,
-0.0141216107,
0.0426920652,
-0.0249370467,
-0.0442854315,
-0.0026384268,
0.0286399275,
2.688e-7,
0.0390608273,
0.0501577184,
-0.0000372908,
0.0354837924,
0.0043550413,
0.0100362105,
-0.066527456,
0.0107309716,
0.0495813563,
-0.0275601298,
-0.0257030465,
-0.0061220038,
0.046268668,
0.0147255687,
-0.0610269159,
-0.0034311814,
-0.0634446442,
0.0183589961,
-0.0164776668,
-0.0052629923,
0.0030784928,
0.039012365,
-0.0292526223,
-0.0410995297,
-0.0147936912,
-0.0412914455,
0.047635369,
-0.0430637151,
-0.0346244983,
0.0073058894,
0.0231803227,
0.0187260062,
0.0263980199,
0.0820988119,
0.0056275479,
-0.0008772089,
-0.0165679902,
0.0325464495,
0.0140436729,
-0.0740373656,
-0.0221015066,
-0.0241233557,
0.0225556027,
-0.0170432534,
0.0539502688,
0.0173679441,
-0.0226478614,
-0.0335411392,
0.0217197705,
-0.0220758114,
0.009841267,
-0.0179472324,
-0.0058198189,
0.015686458,
0.0149204507,
-0.0102049857,
-0.0272970926,
-0.0505846366,
-0.0274245869,
0.0199361034,
-0.0500412621,
-0.0992737338,
-0.0494259857,
-0.0054056356,
-0.0100659803,
-0.0814147815,
-0.0463257767,
2.881532465e-34,
0.01917121,
0.0243336167,
0.0383793451,
0.0737659782,
0.0178253204,
0.0030981328,
-0.0299528018,
0.021555949,
-0.0114078801,
-0.0469744727,
-0.0284646582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11632v1 | Unveiling the Power of Source: Source-based Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Neural Machine Translation | 2024-06-17T15:13:52 | 2024-06-17T15:13:52 | Boxuan Lyu, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Kotaro Funakoshi, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Maximum a posteriori decoding, a commonly used method for neural machine
translation (NMT), aims to maximize the estimated posterior probability.
However, high estimated probability does not always lead to high translation
quality. Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding offers an alternative by seeking
hypotheses with the highest expected utility.
In this work, we show that Quality Estimation (QE) reranking, which uses a QE
model as a reranker, can be viewed as a variant of MBR. Inspired by this, we
propose source-based MBR (sMBR) decoding, a novel approach that utilizes
synthetic sources generated by backward translation as ``support hypotheses''
and a reference-free quality estimation metric as the utility function, marking
the first work to solely use sources in MBR decoding. Experiments show that
sMBR significantly outperforms QE reranking and is competitive with standard
MBR decoding. Furthermore, sMBR calls the utility function fewer times compared
to MBR. Our findings suggest that sMBR is a promising approach for high-quality
NMT decoding. | [
-0.0119436709,
0.058479961,
0.0400987491,
0.003541009,
0.0198006742,
-0.0014751144,
-0.0177483186,
0.021929672,
-0.0495679453,
0.0084303971,
-0.0227781069,
-0.0109790536,
0.0205539949,
-0.0116999,
0.0330192149,
-0.0053225034,
0.0037139973,
0.0050750487,
0.0000065428,
0.0202589054,
-0.0585913397,
-0.0087548736,
0.0034832777,
0.060559269,
0.0004047,
0.0039105038,
0.0110425623,
0.0404446386,
0.0692894608,
-0.0247454308,
-0.0344589688,
0.0214808602,
-0.0065182336,
0.016512949,
0.0000020078,
0.0061236555,
-0.0573590025,
0.0259967148,
-0.0038803485,
-0.0148075856,
-0.0069386517,
-0.0276794918,
-0.050394021,
0.0201490037,
-0.0148042282,
-0.0198396295,
0.0744212866,
0.0126693342,
0.0621103495,
0.1009262353,
0.000191769,
-0.0151608316,
0.0132446494,
-0.0694802031,
0.0104398075,
-0.0504856333,
-0.0210499708,
0.0145710818,
-0.0697425157,
0.0047537992,
-0.0157273002,
0.0543363206,
0.047097452,
0.0044389088,
0.0132794669,
0.0169935673,
0.0404310636,
-0.0029661818,
-0.0048271981,
0.0542214178,
-0.0539163649,
0.0016016803,
-0.0378771573,
-0.0313037671,
0.0003510492,
-0.0161742549,
-0.0111097125,
0.0595676899,
-0.0003205371,
0.0464951769,
0.0271076374,
0.0661157891,
0.0517255217,
-0.015448492,
-0.0366288126,
0.0292358771,
0.0001870997,
-0.0244083088,
-0.042079147,
0.0281272978,
0.0086910566,
0.0283739343,
0.0495174341,
-0.0430852734,
0.0346494354,
0.0270267501,
-0.0231345166,
-0.0408958234,
-0.0313849188,
-0.0545026436,
-0.0039197933,
0.0659353808,
0.0054032858,
0.0207184833,
0.0125650363,
0.0358892344,
-0.0233346075,
0.0139303701,
-0.036162518,
0.0249562785,
0.0210181903,
0.0276252441,
-0.0042273607,
-0.0145284412,
-0.0404431932,
-0.024983177,
-0.0131524168,
-0.0181322377,
0.0068508899,
-0.0273003653,
0.0594722666,
0.0053021261,
-0.0880869105,
-0.0193686653,
0.0003399552,
0.0429315604,
0.0258669108,
-0.0168792587,
0.0188615434,
-0.0442721061,
-0.0472375862,
0.0007239703,
-0.0206973813,
-0.025633119,
-0.0216623619,
0.0693529919,
-0.0244766474,
-0.0004686377,
-0.0168514811,
0.0008194565,
-0.0271579903,
0.0090434523,
0.0404898264,
-0.0327258334,
0.0483365692,
-0.0252567474,
0.0242244489,
-0.0434951074,
0.0010099582,
-0.0170335732,
-0.0149497939,
0.0344570465,
-0.0129073849,
-0.0248570293,
0.0312849432,
0.0221859347,
-0.0087423678,
0.0785402507,
0.0521759503,
0.0329867415,
-0.0013439244,
0.0137607139,
-0.017973613,
0.0297864769,
0.0082581248,
0.0302577969,
-0.0215117633,
-0.0354012959,
-0.023397021,
0.0177975297,
0.0598868728,
0.0325584449,
-0.0838219374,
0.0029267748,
0.0692625269,
-0.0046925219,
0.0435644388,
0.0237264521,
0.0278910939,
0.0089308703,
-0.0264721699,
0.0107641993,
-0.013231636,
0.0537099317,
0.0286697894,
0.0049604643,
0.0832713991,
0.0461882986,
0.0262507088,
-0.0628015324,
0.0177719519,
-0.0432388075,
-0.0316496231,
-0.0302975569,
0.03972321,
0.0359358266,
-0.0432434455,
0.0257013105,
-0.0267238244,
-0.0405462794,
0.008938035,
-0.029643178,
-0.0155269522,
0.0387792177,
0.0549488999,
0.0053842654,
-0.031842798,
-0.0157210901,
-0.0678421035,
0.0343460999,
0.0037777124,
0.0380664356,
0.0734611303,
-0.0546939932,
-0.0305679049,
0.0035403315,
0.0349770524,
0.0477325283,
-0.0356857516,
-0.0007224462,
0.0317199044,
0.0023130898,
-0.0447485745,
0.0242235158,
0.0390329547,
-0.0263877995,
0.0572106093,
0.0109734116,
0.0525583103,
-0.0023221106,
-0.0357908942,
0.0417194329,
0.0019798996,
-0.0339184627,
-0.0381115936,
0.0209621452,
-0.0622953326,
-0.0670554489,
0.0110565601,
-0.0620297156,
0.0073717525,
0.0230917353,
-0.0320509896,
-0.0407344997,
0.0095053129,
-0.0553277731,
-0.0218922719,
-0.0357748009,
0.0277749784,
0.0165252257,
-0.0079426421,
-0.0226996187,
0.0333136879,
-0.0465435348,
-0.0272255111,
0.0208703969,
-0.0504185595,
0.0144765852,
-0.0635406971,
0.0063365283,
0.0387781858,
0.00573189,
0.0316518173,
0.0403324217,
0.0479715914,
-0.0050036614,
-0.0162341371,
0.0088767968,
0.0072216084,
-0.0185922328,
0.0320589356,
0.0400944538,
0.0343029201,
0.0088826148,
-0.0250121318,
-0.0058888346,
-0.0359646268,
-0.0340691134,
-0.0027953736,
0.0111137182,
0.0237609409,
0.0652968585,
-0.0118176183,
-0.0376953743,
0.0134557206,
0.074390322,
-0.0265504457,
-0.0037943751,
-0.1095787808,
0.0462795235,
-0.0251098145,
-0.0086045302,
0.0045834887,
-0.0540558472,
0.0287084058,
-0.0178501401,
0.0368536189,
0.0511848107,
-0.0119441971,
-0.0102450196,
0.0542398244,
0.0240418408,
-0.0698356479,
0.0079515371,
-0.0275105946,
0.0027018127,
-0.0080707707,
-0.0885988846,
0.0332826078,
0.0220274739,
0.0328905955,
0.0090550967,
-0.1080029756,
0.0531535111,
0.0078805564,
-0.054437615,
-0.0119084744,
0.0096505089,
0.0145482002,
0.0192665122,
-0.0082527017,
-0.0495471582,
0.0697368085,
-0.0370704047,
0.0221872497,
-0.0605890304,
0.0131867444,
-0.0114978487,
-0.0388976075,
-0.0508490205,
0.0342057757,
-0.0296447743,
-0.0465224832,
-0.0241927169,
0.026344616,
0.0252694469,
-0.0147465505,
-0.0065881102,
-0.0439879335,
-0.0437013805,
-0.0303956177,
-0.0074463258,
0.0079543432,
0.0147254504,
0.0273443423,
-0.0286465269,
0.0103193698,
-0.0110838227,
0.0139729148,
0.0151256863,
0.0128942067,
0.0580085926,
-0.0203439016,
0.0048047211,
-0.0055399579,
0.0390512645,
-0.0046794168,
-0.0265827756,
0.0585968159,
-0.024634799,
0.012512357,
0.0332966782,
0.0255430844,
-0.0036722543,
-0.0480570272,
-0.0179380197,
0.0256791618,
0.0534753315,
-0.0176718179,
0.0080955448,
0.0224958565,
-0.054233361,
-0.002960518,
0.0801972076,
-0.0033635781,
-0.0461779051,
-0.0100826342,
-0.008483449,
0.024213776,
-0.0183408726,
0.0155619234,
-0.0434516706,
-0.0076835342,
-0.0072710952,
0.0532382801,
0.0170867871,
-0.0002540869,
-0.0304690022,
-0.0749794394,
0.0416726992,
0.069357045,
-0.0222817603,
-0.0453917794,
-0.0129224863,
-0.0613921098,
-0.0630669445,
0.0061317929,
0.0194517802,
0.0580454171,
0.0052092648,
0.0131584294,
0.0014290812,
-0.0819767192,
-0.0709182173,
-0.0413637422,
0.0161409061,
0.0843239874,
0.0074759503,
0.0111506106,
-0.0131011764,
-0.0341157988,
-0.057517238,
0.0147028798,
0.0052062897,
0.0318612903,
-0.0130313858,
-0.0160366166,
0.0404126272,
-0.0389574207,
0.0065925252,
0.020165205,
-0.0215707552,
0.0435148291,
-0.0438080281,
0.0019716963,
-0.0025292973,
-0.0144120296,
0.0257997774,
0.0219756421,
0.0412955545,
-0.0318366587,
0.0111131631,
-0.0559015796,
0.029167356,
-0.052125603,
0.011425049,
0.0169716403,
0.0039019608,
-0.1070368662,
-0.1153461635,
-0.0379851088,
-0.0321393311,
0.027747497,
-0.0355459861,
-0.0135110635,
0.0204582941,
-0.0084517496,
-0.0066017839,
0.0275539756,
0.0060228985,
-0.0354664922,
-0.0137130143,
0.0472788475,
0.0090213371,
-0.0233851112,
0.0010580494,
0.0172078647,
-0.0306992903,
-0.0655789599,
-0.0519756824,
0.0838976204,
0.0187166017,
0.0041023381,
-0.0495986529,
-0.0456614047,
-0.0115741091,
-0.0064673969,
-0.022165902,
0.010480036,
0.0404680334,
-0.0214458853,
-0.0210331064,
0.0191517398,
-0.0388411023,
-0.0114826309,
-0.0303143505,
0.0548378825,
-0.0098183611,
0.0138277151,
0.0384257734,
-0.0107711647,
0.0397189856,
-0.0653581992,
-0.0295369755,
-0.041097749,
0.0156032406,
-0.0412160903,
-0.0006192661,
-0.0602349676,
0.0362970829,
0.0637489706,
0.009919974,
-0.0032524085,
-0.0002765063,
-0.0022900952,
-0.0232602023,
-0.0040758564,
0.006672611,
0.0056545124,
0.0005659866,
0.0106387613,
0.0071034292,
-0.0125448303,
0.0065857461,
0.0073359949,
-0.0070947832,
-0.0310933534,
0.0140862549,
0.0060742474,
-0.0178130902,
0.0235660374,
0.0634908229,
-0.0696331784,
-0.0349929221,
-0.0578097627,
-0.0005553889,
0.070555985,
0.0561902113,
0.1534069628,
0.0223696046,
-0.0007250811,
-0.0273447223,
0.0384552106,
0.0349118747,
-0.0322775543,
0.0023959517,
-0.0028270171,
0.0027817918,
0.0293870177,
0.0677531585,
-0.003080704,
-0.0105771441,
-0.057370916,
-0.0041149254,
-0.0201672856,
-0.0165979713,
-0.029238617,
-0.0117002483,
-0.0091217496,
-0.0312818438,
-0.0222325418,
-0.0351619907,
0.0086882068,
0.020408364,
0.01767537,
-0.0100870281,
0.0011376458,
0.0368739478,
-0.0686867461,
0.0034465683,
-0.0338732973,
-0.0435492881,
-0.0283558443,
-0.0163269974,
-0.020538019,
-6.373614859e-33,
-0.0133744273,
-0.0092475293,
-0.0056843939,
-0.1061577126,
-0.0183675978,
0.0059788087,
-0.0473680384,
-0.0372059047,
0.0226349905,
0.0088944826,
0.0178915113,
0.0398284979,
0.0273324084,
-0.0013111966,
-0.0087443171,
0.0238196366,
0.0533454083,
-0.0001381272,
-0.054133907,
0.0055040591,
0.0365606733,
0.01227412,
0.0842064768,
-0.0398737453,
0.0092937136,
0.0294449814,
-0.0421335064,
-0.0062306365,
0.0114787798,
0.0480759852,
0.0209885165,
0.0152348839,
0.0165222175,
-0.0700609982,
-0.0259026848,
-0.0530102849,
-0.0349479131,
0.0055149822,
-0.0346659273,
0.0087006483,
-0.0204372741,
-0.0453038663,
0.0374447182,
0.003706034,
-0.0283975173,
-0.0301615484,
-0.0219637435,
-0.0649831295,
-0.0368585512,
-0.0696074143,
0.0154361315,
0.0554514118,
-0.0132103898,
0.0130079472,
0.0299596023,
0.0561775081,
-0.0382798314,
-0.0235871878,
-0.0442278199,
0.0421009511,
0.0147420997,
0.0276030619,
0.0738317743,
0.0066426443,
-0.0168038998,
-0.0074508442,
0.0344465524,
-0.0464948751,
0.0362270959,
-0.0085691856,
0.0077523855,
0.0224548448,
0.0728161857,
0.0402448624,
0.0319724455,
0.0157129373,
-0.0738255456,
0.0626107529,
-0.0137427673,
-0.0035899491,
0.0006441762,
0.0519437455,
-0.0290322881,
-0.0175694935,
-0.0583311655,
-0.0763662159,
-0.0069598327,
-0.016813824,
0.0173789877,
0.0246332306,
-0.0387669764,
-0.0209734477,
0.0870910659,
-0.0127704907,
0.0801613852,
0.0242404453,
-0.0128172683,
0.0148958554,
-0.0078915553,
0.0230398923,
0.0061260401,
0.0446876213,
0.0625477955,
0.0105938576,
0.0002163245,
-0.0247435849,
0.0191848446,
0.0299341269,
-0.0116698295,
0.0078151375,
-0.0227855369,
-0.0055794944,
0.031074781,
0.0347388759,
0.0374095514,
-0.0532472022,
-0.0090151811,
0.0485415645,
0.0168418009,
0.0586728416,
-0.0013638184,
0.03374248,
0.0423713923,
0.0202702787,
-0.0260639116,
0.022203071,
0.0090039466,
0.0351694115,
0.0802525878,
-0.0587988161,
-0.0648678392,
0.0515537336,
2.702e-7,
0.0539641418,
0.034057267,
0.0203926861,
-0.0081455037,
0.0198491272,
0.0400634333,
-0.0233195946,
0.0195105039,
0.0084382314,
0.049459476,
0.0297083929,
-0.0124637065,
0.0765420571,
0.0326292701,
-0.0777332708,
-0.052964367,
-0.0559559576,
0.0087367948,
-0.0203967001,
-0.0391126014,
0.0070040929,
0.074325189,
-0.0565341637,
0.0118139647,
0.0172663238,
-0.0029147794,
0.0527171604,
-0.0178488325,
-0.007743706,
-0.0137846256,
0.0454170816,
0.006079461,
-0.0171102658,
-0.059189748,
-0.0296874512,
0.0001858935,
0.0384002402,
0.0703743994,
-0.0012738411,
-0.0534231775,
0.039192602,
0.0516074561,
-0.0035526091,
-0.0068859356,
0.0065894234,
-0.053741172,
-0.0278189573,
0.0167601667,
-0.0528371036,
0.0110053737,
0.0221357457,
-0.0413078144,
-0.0192162283,
-0.0090805693,
0.0150819104,
0.0219296552,
-0.0065451595,
-0.0425822437,
-0.0336927213,
-0.0272164866,
-0.0065701297,
-0.0505833253,
0.0003738228,
-0.0173140839,
0.0541320555,
-0.0383402631,
-0.0165494345,
2.273199445e-34,
0.0489890762,
-0.0338801332,
0.0455642715,
0.0194595773,
0.0457109027,
-0.0191840399,
-0.0136664445,
-0.0011906011,
0.0052541853,
-0.0313160159,
-0.0643000305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11629v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11629v3 | Can Many-Shot In-Context Learning Help Long-Context LLM Judges? See More, Judge Better! | 2024-06-17T15:11:58 | 2024-06-30T13:31:24 | Mingyang Song, Mao Zheng, Xuan Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) as judges for judging the performance
of LLMs has recently garnered attention. However, this type of approach is
affected by the potential biases in LLMs, raising concerns about the
reliability of the evaluation results. To mitigate this issue, we propose and
study two versions of many-shot in-context prompts, which rely on two existing
settings of many-shot ICL for helping GPT-4o-as-a-Judge in single answer
grading to mitigate the potential biases in LLMs, Reinforced ICL and
Unsupervised ICL. Concretely, the former utilizes in-context examples with
model-generated rationales, and the latter without. Based on the designed
prompts, we investigate the impact of scaling the number of in-context examples
on the consistency and quality of the judgment results. Furthermore, we reveal
the symbol bias hidden in the pairwise comparison of GPT-4o-as-a-Judge and
propose a simple yet effective approach to mitigate it. Experimental results
show that advanced long-context LLMs, such as GPT-4o, perform better in the
many-shot regime than in the zero-shot regime. Meanwhile, the experimental
results further verify the effectiveness of the symbol bias mitigation
approach. | [
0.0047363457,
0.0342090391,
0.0020920064,
0.0451429524,
-0.033476945,
0.0257613584,
0.0488238409,
0.0228109527,
-0.0134814698,
-0.0628922731,
-0.0506315157,
-0.0385063849,
-0.0316539705,
-0.0366250239,
0.0044630477,
-0.0352346897,
0.0319614299,
-0.0342525691,
0.059311308,
-0.0195786767,
-0.0027396732,
-0.0048062643,
0.0125384042,
0.0178573579,
0.0144597888,
-0.0697888657,
0.0199312046,
-0.0093074441,
0.0071548228,
-0.0411698334,
-0.0061703897,
0.0891675726,
0.0014788705,
0.0263272021,
0.0000021696,
-0.0602917485,
0.0073626232,
0.005078184,
-0.0302389432,
0.0451571047,
-0.014948315,
0.030482294,
0.0063850135,
0.0082174586,
-0.0443306491,
-0.0027425915,
0.0019274013,
0.0219982415,
0.0521825925,
0.0543717183,
0.0308466423,
-0.0432819203,
0.0131595777,
0.0014475834,
0.0291476678,
-0.0344268344,
0.024661256,
0.0475712307,
0.013103296,
0.0275429636,
-0.0367587097,
0.0108236894,
0.0510747209,
-0.0191682614,
0.002046555,
0.0269152019,
0.0038307989,
0.0292865932,
0.0082605351,
0.0631587654,
0.007615854,
-0.0234378669,
-0.0563103557,
-0.0316279829,
0.058955621,
0.0083417566,
-0.0753073394,
0.0318453759,
0.0059930952,
0.0117269214,
0.0327687226,
0.0191359967,
0.0264330916,
0.0279972125,
-0.0172077976,
0.0501615703,
0.0250840895,
-0.0504145809,
0.0074555222,
0.0371172875,
-0.0304426886,
-0.0407238454,
-0.0326926894,
0.0502074324,
-0.0442481115,
0.0367522426,
-0.0004674727,
0.0372247249,
0.0257510655,
-0.0227409787,
0.0278400499,
0.0205822419,
-0.0109544881,
0.0361756273,
-0.0407413393,
0.041251,
0.0219946541,
0.0294285137,
-0.023397563,
0.0020639903,
-0.0484924279,
-0.0139618907,
0.0131358802,
0.0424290784,
-0.0070167114,
0.0337451398,
-0.0730981529,
0.0249837432,
-0.0682205781,
0.0046428223,
0.0140561331,
-0.0120206568,
0.0313138254,
0.0060591986,
-0.0451107323,
0.0380163714,
-0.0307515748,
0.0220932364,
0.000596442,
-0.0625432357,
-0.0119344499,
0.0096640568,
-0.0015434438,
-0.0224200916,
0.0141634708,
0.0713245794,
0.0075531187,
-0.0448208936,
-0.0075155403,
-0.0485324338,
-0.0367815681,
-0.0747949556,
-0.0354168229,
-0.0875545591,
-0.0210965518,
-0.0015225084,
0.0147527726,
-0.0318130665,
-0.0029030535,
0.0316278078,
0.0093535669,
0.0524353385,
0.0114232637,
-0.0053403755,
-0.0170544796,
0.0284081418,
-0.0183644611,
0.0609829314,
0.016848715,
-0.036563985,
0.0185368992,
-0.0452883355,
0.0586311035,
0.0254006553,
0.0200002808,
0.0351542272,
-0.0054550902,
0.0342081338,
0.0088178953,
0.0209074467,
0.0087878499,
0.0260918122,
-0.0270056985,
0.0145238647,
0.0589738227,
0.0376801454,
0.0384220034,
-0.0018193744,
0.0196692161,
-0.0432487093,
0.0128091648,
0.0341470428,
-0.0737231821,
0.0152797503,
-0.0480724275,
0.021380499,
0.0096710576,
0.0201064553,
-0.0277544912,
-0.0562279373,
0.0035672484,
0.0324979648,
-0.0470382422,
0.0546820797,
0.030255083,
-0.0020777786,
-0.0274083447,
0.0096456967,
0.026699543,
-0.0354476273,
0.0118588218,
-0.0705317035,
0.0595789514,
0.0302559026,
0.065075852,
-0.0063674231,
-0.0407546908,
-0.0202083439,
-0.0044761887,
0.0262447428,
0.0305786934,
-0.0283354204,
-0.0231381021,
-0.0239125844,
-0.0395420976,
-0.0099894106,
0.001143817,
0.0025857759,
0.0182302855,
0.0412923582,
-0.0063806698,
-0.0549986027,
-0.0060973745,
0.0195476525,
0.0187603645,
-0.0676736608,
0.0001126722,
-0.0157514159,
0.0287979618,
0.0493322536,
-0.0037131188,
0.0193697698,
0.017889509,
-0.0056290696,
-0.0210650936,
-0.0286857747,
-0.0966855437,
-0.0577472486,
0.0443154052,
-0.0224378109,
-0.0188644323,
-0.0557452962,
-0.0384235121,
-0.0310448054,
-0.0236590952,
0.0057083457,
0.0372142754,
-0.0207000896,
0.0188218616,
-0.0423389971,
-0.018604368,
-0.0824385211,
0.0581190363,
0.0329829119,
0.0126832686,
0.0300612208,
0.0395948626,
0.0115997223,
-0.0129310014,
-0.0264084041,
0.0131947082,
0.0146110598,
0.0065270923,
0.0143438568,
0.0302704014,
-0.0593702942,
-0.0208305288,
-0.0726010799,
-0.0076529332,
-0.0327645279,
-0.0024823386,
0.011207832,
-0.0244195908,
-0.0016054724,
0.0113839041,
-0.0571544394,
-0.0287365317,
0.0326243863,
0.0451243222,
0.0047849296,
0.0103336014,
-0.0238050614,
-0.0040316391,
-0.023846386,
-0.0402619988,
0.0348870791,
0.0256839804,
0.0251519475,
-0.0639055744,
0.048766315,
-0.0089527871,
-0.0357334316,
0.0247621965,
0.0047632162,
0.0386781655,
0.0079139527,
0.0180321652,
0.0418301076,
0.0046051354,
-0.0041423771,
0.0711290464,
-0.0145764193,
-0.1000515893,
-0.0075272461,
0.0198196862,
-0.0238501281,
-0.0256294459,
0.0149748214,
-0.0086010275,
0.0307922773,
0.0221215207,
-0.0241764151,
-0.0423803553,
0.0507086813,
-0.0283506177,
-0.0336979181,
-0.0453031436,
-0.0409085974,
-0.0145821236,
0.0221858397,
0.0239141528,
-0.0606641322,
0.0841257051,
-0.0081358906,
0.0128365653,
-0.019471867,
0.0189516637,
-0.0729498193,
0.0285528153,
-0.0271346327,
-0.0272849724,
-0.0289326794,
0.0027638827,
-0.022521019,
-0.0305597614,
0.0058786594,
-0.0255568698,
0.0729378238,
-0.0419683494,
-0.0208876524,
-0.0267720167,
-0.0411343612,
-0.0432871506,
-0.0156571772,
-0.02862183,
0.0105701778,
-0.0317712761,
0.0283093154,
0.0240412913,
-0.0045780917,
0.010835289,
-0.0151955802,
-0.0452545956,
-0.0197272282,
-0.000415409,
0.044494614,
0.0177454408,
-0.0204855278,
0.0390970707,
-0.0426289439,
0.0813793987,
0.0460523069,
0.0502767041,
-0.0268302839,
-0.0160056371,
0.0073176846,
0.0560009219,
-0.0447787195,
-0.0068838764,
0.0496495068,
0.0640824884,
-0.0634559244,
0.0079514347,
0.1285452098,
-0.000417846,
-0.0879419222,
-0.0052469978,
-0.0254858844,
0.0099422978,
0.0181819163,
0.0184760205,
-0.1141790673,
-0.0432453342,
-0.0055993125,
0.0070531731,
-0.0302466862,
-0.0092220791,
0.0011727141,
-0.1525115222,
0.044867672,
0.0201451071,
-0.0280568898,
-0.0135574201,
-0.0417339429,
0.0128663946,
-0.011028992,
0.0293200128,
0.0510545298,
-0.0208818633,
0.0073066959,
0.0304318368,
0.0070162346,
-0.0063730925,
0.0735163912,
-0.0375292413,
0.0413302407,
0.0256510526,
0.0155261988,
-0.017817989,
-0.0546611883,
0.0435477532,
-0.0632593259,
0.016493842,
-0.0299341474,
0.0094143897,
-0.020255914,
0.0226524826,
-0.0385489054,
0.0383771285,
0.0026767214,
-0.0385493487,
0.0519840941,
0.1048090905,
-0.0237024371,
-0.0225525834,
-0.0505288765,
-0.0106830215,
-0.0229386892,
0.0870548189,
0.0472476929,
-0.0671769157,
-0.0376351774,
-0.0227725841,
-0.0364656337,
-0.0195813999,
-0.0325242504,
-0.0007624575,
-0.0197428372,
0.0332144201,
-0.0167505387,
-0.0389875807,
0.0242155902,
0.0433332175,
-0.0101002064,
0.0319934636,
-0.0648728162,
0.0348767005,
0.050851766,
0.024761565,
-0.0547164381,
0.0324490964,
-0.0531120114,
0.0491574034,
0.0153244482,
-0.0266484208,
0.0043086233,
0.0039541177,
-0.0265745725,
-0.0482967123,
-0.0066146306,
0.0228243694,
0.0190502368,
0.0344096608,
0.0200022012,
-0.0271860436,
0.107370317,
0.0036161251,
0.0274693631,
0.0105871828,
0.0269938447,
0.0264432859,
0.0182776302,
0.0029568512,
-0.0289425459,
0.0281222425,
0.065655835,
0.0387007743,
-0.0256291069,
-0.0243378747,
0.0404362977,
0.0138076721,
0.033709012,
-0.015308246,
-0.0111284312,
0.0041549248,
0.0333657898,
-0.0397709645,
-0.015786387,
0.0061832401,
-0.0125432136,
0.014056759,
-0.0600741729,
-0.0189242028,
-0.0029169496,
-0.0196673796,
0.0456785709,
-0.0200730488,
0.0553636216,
0.0529660024,
-0.0395284258,
-0.0175103489,
-0.0120485844,
-0.0368182845,
-0.0136699639,
-0.0102757923,
0.0342143737,
0.0045561395,
0.0922802463,
-0.0035837851,
0.0039542327,
-0.0048903399,
0.0064947708,
-0.0828202814,
0.0050660362,
-0.0266310014,
0.0260502454,
0.0509677231,
0.0137587739,
0.0350638181,
0.0077094496,
0.001361663,
-0.0235384777,
-0.007451335,
0.0094246361,
-0.004051364,
0.0564634278,
0.0451816134,
0.0014916323,
0.0023325384,
0.0437837355,
-0.0266274959,
0.0434070751,
-0.0136380438,
0.0027038814,
-0.0099943243,
-0.0265418775,
0.0085906014,
0.0089666042,
0.013830266,
-0.0485406965,
-0.0897935852,
-0.0379032455,
-0.0140395528,
0.0389499851,
0.001618954,
-0.0138259334,
0.0010028458,
0.0552041978,
0.0014732149,
-0.0436253659,
-0.0261785407,
-0.0012012798,
0.0101361535,
-0.0119038196,
-0.0409083702,
-5.937925225e-33,
-0.0262204036,
-0.0473445281,
0.0337306224,
0.0009317556,
-0.0037756991,
-0.0022267699,
0.0072606108,
0.0151511943,
-0.0170619916,
0.0262429602,
-0.0358218737,
0.0007830244,
0.0033300042,
-0.004214847,
0.0563738309,
-0.0313192792,
0.0266793948,
0.0209129937,
-0.009676531,
0.0202329867,
-0.0249776114,
-0.0247901231,
0.0475541875,
-0.037360128,
0.0732001513,
0.014199473,
0.0003591078,
-0.0086013377,
-0.0899813771,
0.0666553155,
-0.0031328215,
0.0602546036,
0.0364183187,
-0.0410221517,
-0.0252445638,
0.0256663747,
-0.0452086143,
-0.013930968,
0.0357160829,
-0.0185491629,
-0.0109006315,
-0.0781535655,
0.0301909819,
0.0101053966,
-0.0848504081,
-0.0294100344,
0.0126799084,
-0.0467364006,
-0.0118569667,
-0.0344103761,
-0.0423860587,
0.0260926932,
-0.0175093673,
0.0250252541,
-0.0143238986,
0.031732481,
-0.0088530378,
0.0656755641,
-0.0284219384,
0.0308108591,
0.0234821457,
0.011342831,
0.0709212944,
0.0079193944,
-0.0130486824,
0.0510763191,
0.012692349,
0.0013618639,
0.0049778763,
-0.0752009302,
0.0064721974,
0.0226329844,
0.0902099684,
0.1095641553,
0.0704636797,
0.0180475153,
-0.0808235407,
0.0096199587,
0.0276875459,
0.0146640288,
0.0403391607,
-0.0120478272,
-0.0537936464,
-0.0228807572,
-0.0531290807,
-0.0213483013,
-0.0437627472,
-0.0303518698,
0.0401118658,
-0.0299570262,
0.0191694777,
-0.0132089695,
0.0380579121,
-0.0497483164,
-0.0257894136,
0.0252538938,
-0.0128102861,
0.0265109949,
0.0060209893,
-0.0027601873,
-0.0309885591,
0.010803896,
-0.0115259644,
-0.0104052927,
0.0132800927,
0.0016230937,
0.0497884415,
-0.0021967127,
-0.0612011515,
-0.0307303183,
-0.0218290221,
-0.0370347053,
0.0205141846,
-0.0342022032,
0.024541162,
0.0143461116,
0.0085752876,
0.0387986898,
0.0134734856,
-0.0059785829,
-0.0089427894,
-0.0302453469,
-0.0187718086,
0.0035727508,
-0.0131733222,
-0.0162948687,
0.0079208957,
0.0055089588,
0.0110350205,
-0.0404640138,
-0.0098366756,
0.026500579,
2.692e-7,
0.0486564599,
0.0480825454,
-0.009370584,
-0.0021736294,
0.0269185547,
0.0247836877,
-0.0102798436,
-0.0025846723,
0.0559337661,
0.0124688251,
0.029012695,
0.0213612653,
0.0309197009,
0.0449032299,
-0.0543161668,
0.0122034345,
-0.0601063892,
-0.0079479627,
-0.043559093,
0.0151989432,
0.0778942332,
0.0578814335,
0.0179036371,
-0.0150082782,
-0.0170134641,
-0.0267540365,
0.0554066375,
-0.0322735608,
-0.0170864426,
0.0205493066,
0.0322503783,
-0.0525148548,
0.0547660217,
0.0405169278,
0.0231565982,
0.010910566,
-0.0177305546,
0.0612859167,
0.0116869528,
-0.0249165278,
-0.0072850552,
-0.0228713844,
0.0140607283,
-0.0562298745,
0.0766085312,
-0.0357938893,
-0.0262323469,
-0.0465939865,
-0.0476701669,
-0.0630926043,
0.0321861207,
-0.0025888099,
-0.0063284254,
0.0211226046,
-0.0088364948,
0.0024730086,
-0.020539945,
-0.0504971147,
-0.0375546962,
0.0245973915,
-0.015414183,
-0.0593824461,
-0.0090126181,
-0.0252399649,
0.0243250933,
-0.0905226469,
-0.0158571005,
2.628995641e-34,
0.0353008769,
-0.0339083821,
0.0553313419,
0.0437120721,
0.0008420156,
0.0326714851,
-0.010182362,
0.0011481497,
0.0472383313,
-0.0867425278,
-0.0118052559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11624v1 | Words in Motion: Representation Engineering for Motion Forecasting | 2024-06-17T15:07:55 | 2024-06-17T15:07:55 | Omer Sahin Tas, Royden Wagner | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Motion forecasting transforms sequences of past movements and environment
context into future motion. Recent methods rely on learned representations,
resulting in hidden states that are difficult to interpret. In this work, we
use natural language to quantize motion features in a human-interpretable way,
and measure the degree to which they are embedded in hidden states. Our
experiments reveal that hidden states of motion sequences are arranged with
respect to our discrete sets of motion features. Following these insights, we
fit control vectors to motion features, which allow for controlling motion
forecasts at inference. Consequently, our method enables controlling
transformer-based motion forecasting models with textual inputs, providing a
unique interface to interact with and understand these models. Our
implementation is available at https://github.com/kit-mrt/future-motion | [
-0.0018338178,
0.0815861225,
0.0021165756,
0.0367858522,
0.004034657,
-0.0206753574,
0.0104370043,
0.0351796709,
-0.0002677528,
-0.0386577919,
0.0077504311,
-0.0086617963,
0.0029507391,
0.0268564541,
-0.0073762904,
-0.1115476117,
0.0419252738,
-0.0279512405,
-0.0300030913,
0.0148911821,
-0.0009593267,
-0.0153700737,
-0.0082181701,
0.0575460233,
-0.0329144858,
-0.0114505403,
-0.0223450307,
-0.032310918,
0.0338866413,
-0.0363616087,
-0.0155225117,
0.0459324047,
0.1110528111,
0.023840636,
0.0000019875,
-0.0202041753,
0.0217824727,
-0.0138687771,
0.0232912935,
-0.0486341938,
0.0136573035,
-0.046136301,
0.0308886077,
-0.0096388496,
-0.0489607081,
0.0062891645,
0.0511167012,
-0.0082240887,
0.0550489537,
0.0413091816,
-0.016437009,
-0.0549983904,
-0.0100420965,
0.0013739306,
0.0396157987,
0.0153720975,
0.0083131799,
-0.03119733,
0.0391528979,
0.029088961,
-0.081917204,
0.0171024762,
0.0065739681,
0.0195548218,
0.0149835106,
0.052684404,
0.020680327,
-0.027976308,
-0.0607433915,
0.0321465731,
-0.0006011163,
-0.0304101817,
0.011501818,
-0.002920609,
-0.0035855381,
0.0470262766,
-0.0521866977,
0.0081202313,
0.0311331283,
-0.0083419578,
-0.0587959439,
0.0612209439,
0.0058156494,
-0.0053605558,
0.0145171909,
0.0750757381,
0.0315302424,
0.0099219978,
-0.0648232102,
-0.0156476013,
0.0586021021,
-0.053740751,
0.0295515526,
0.0267152991,
0.0128461616,
0.0074114823,
-0.0142672928,
0.0005234775,
-0.0526532754,
-0.0316365063,
0.0394006073,
0.0524259061,
0.0269357264,
0.0197419114,
-0.0007353543,
0.0648262501,
-0.031665612,
-0.0253794827,
-0.0136535447,
0.0281666704,
-0.0512145832,
-0.0186426565,
-0.0423575975,
-0.0271021426,
-0.03622251,
-0.0413015373,
-0.0158219486,
0.0102464436,
-0.0338063277,
-0.0136109143,
-0.0028512902,
0.0751535594,
-0.0136222085,
-0.0379531197,
-0.056837894,
0.0209224783,
-0.0138879288,
0.0113795958,
-0.0217683129,
-0.0266544446,
-0.0065051783,
-0.0010879104,
-0.003776368,
0.0088425884,
-0.0226098914,
0.0913390666,
0.0216925107,
-0.0016275493,
0.0017191654,
-0.0607276633,
-0.013042178,
-0.0188861769,
0.0320522524,
-0.0520196892,
0.0028008765,
0.0226210058,
0.0184055492,
-0.0357959494,
0.013928812,
0.0036030123,
-0.0146619976,
0.0723249391,
-0.0024981089,
-0.0070285494,
-0.0174923055,
0.0166123547,
0.0343581699,
0.0525509194,
0.0499026068,
0.0563235469,
0.0069244425,
0.0134802992,
0.0300367959,
0.0157066006,
-0.024636725,
-0.0306187961,
-0.042437505,
-0.0272968207,
-0.0112752086,
0.0333631933,
0.0169622451,
0.0047078291,
-0.0085252095,
-0.0135321375,
0.038795948,
0.0750498101,
-0.0170162972,
0.0481125936,
0.0667754114,
0.0063246782,
-0.0419642963,
-0.0235753339,
-0.0046691103,
0.0923292264,
-0.0053879581,
-0.0172103997,
-0.015720835,
0.0428624451,
-0.027311679,
-0.0384019949,
0.0066107768,
-0.0210606288,
0.0583697855,
-0.0427727401,
0.018633144,
0.0077847233,
-0.0367305577,
0.059695933,
-0.0112600792,
-0.0327165127,
0.0185680278,
0.0137420362,
0.002354295,
0.0878119916,
-0.0024877042,
-0.0094975512,
0.0006110837,
0.000731712,
0.0144834118,
0.0175249968,
-0.0193884429,
0.0079668313,
-0.0160036739,
-0.0413508676,
-0.034921091,
0.0362817422,
0.0239298865,
0.0097023603,
-0.0321135782,
0.0424702875,
0.0315547697,
-0.0127520999,
-0.0417596027,
0.0253861379,
-0.0026821832,
-0.0139179435,
-0.0273211636,
-0.0036358288,
0.0240910649,
-0.0119587937,
0.0238148905,
0.0280597135,
0.0519971214,
-0.0172782205,
-0.0226689558,
0.0815401152,
-0.0411899723,
0.0109400507,
0.013272725,
-0.064937748,
0.0235031042,
0.0205461029,
-0.0270759873,
-0.0278828051,
0.0404858664,
-0.048186861,
0.0231517032,
0.0225538127,
-0.0231834035,
0.0342493281,
-0.0010828186,
0.0113381445,
0.0243641417,
0.0221262574,
0.0074620191,
0.0047238162,
-0.0170933343,
0.0100740939,
0.0016736425,
-0.0141314249,
0.0217402317,
0.0056681326,
-0.0003123425,
0.0326364003,
-0.0369492806,
-0.0227651969,
0.0196039323,
-0.058010567,
-0.0452794731,
-0.0118035935,
-0.0099102873,
0.0009279764,
-0.0167380553,
-0.0026487382,
-0.0188659653,
0.0011010248,
0.0279400572,
0.0064868219,
-0.0317934491,
0.0170120373,
-0.0261909962,
-0.0447653644,
-0.0105141681,
0.0060377899,
-0.0441624336,
0.0532740541,
0.0444222912,
-0.0122285699,
-0.0428480394,
-0.0319900662,
-0.021407973,
0.0179782268,
-0.0069421912,
-0.0395642072,
0.0332108028,
-0.0165369101,
0.0052954736,
-0.014682617,
0.0162695497,
0.0340879895,
0.0551790111,
-0.0518020615,
-0.0114191566,
0.0004715331,
-0.0586318076,
0.0045785126,
-0.0538171604,
-0.0071536442,
0.0091461744,
0.0750521868,
0.0246913545,
0.0160156153,
-0.0879527479,
-0.0098289158,
-0.0327516757,
-0.0012498556,
-0.0185461994,
0.0198135097,
-0.0256364513,
0.0577428266,
0.0148757789,
-0.0638317242,
0.0634914562,
-0.0011650117,
-0.0270238947,
-0.0056971209,
0.0264397729,
-0.0128309056,
0.0672230646,
0.017213773,
0.0097852461,
0.0207717903,
0.033075247,
-0.0320918933,
-0.0064027109,
-0.0041071014,
0.0109495427,
-0.0069396854,
-0.0674865544,
0.0017061982,
0.052503366,
0.0154722705,
-0.0285925884,
-0.0318217427,
-0.0530971549,
-0.0257142,
-0.0360556655,
-0.0527920276,
-0.0026753559,
0.0113750221,
-0.0197011847,
0.0185340047,
-0.0029117856,
-0.028630631,
-0.0088449223,
0.0115156872,
0.063805759,
0.0533509143,
-0.0345951952,
-0.0057198983,
0.000184649,
0.0470019057,
0.0176527202,
-0.0095206108,
-0.0806701928,
0.0642690882,
0.0317828134,
-0.0112058586,
-0.0042458442,
0.072178416,
0.039466314,
-0.0484754965,
-0.0325057246,
0.0853398666,
0.0500989519,
-0.0099384347,
0.0368423127,
-0.0086338539,
0.0373412222,
0.0240291171,
0.0156493392,
-0.0429089107,
-0.0429406464,
-0.0357135311,
-0.0053562764,
0.0338531658,
-0.0405218378,
-0.0073860101,
-0.0682146698,
0.0492481776,
0.0329951495,
0.0224606376,
-0.0528338589,
-0.0312417112,
-0.0095294975,
-0.0179577954,
-0.0591355041,
-0.0302484408,
0.0024035946,
0.0295584276,
0.0068042283,
-0.1091030985,
-0.0234495681,
0.0250491519,
-0.0032839461,
-0.0084519368,
0.0410326533,
0.0486276112,
-0.0323606506,
-0.07120689,
-0.0657735914,
-0.0360961594,
0.0541219786,
-0.0149140293,
0.0337147415,
-0.0193413999,
-0.0133687146,
-0.0273840632,
0.0557733513,
-0.0368692912,
-0.0752650648,
-0.0142786866,
0.1169237867,
-0.0513523258,
-0.0442070961,
-0.0460285768,
0.0040776618,
0.0233458374,
0.0456851944,
-0.0158814117,
-0.0217179991,
-0.008764145,
-0.0478673317,
0.0322162472,
0.0222883597,
-0.0848401114,
-0.0529317521,
0.0186370667,
-0.0303557683,
-0.0681706071,
-0.0193002559,
0.0282329936,
0.0251186788,
0.0082612298,
-0.0286226831,
0.0516875461,
-0.0107532144,
-0.0810258016,
0.0370898433,
0.0131459599,
0.0120468326,
0.0148913097,
-0.0270726625,
0.0258549824,
0.0385191739,
-0.027679706,
0.019362526,
-0.0904025286,
-0.0536509231,
0.0174876358,
0.0505480506,
0.0289234631,
0.0141351111,
0.0098003894,
-0.0064597623,
0.0786231309,
0.0281720236,
-0.0264923405,
0.0239883885,
0.0016605991,
0.0129530756,
-0.0063190144,
0.0186866689,
-0.0163237862,
0.0065185656,
-0.055159457,
-0.0018926105,
-0.0908223316,
-0.0247039907,
0.0154463015,
-0.0386828817,
0.0899118781,
-0.0285598226,
-0.0005609604,
0.0090796323,
-0.0524425395,
-0.02021439,
0.0023713692,
-0.0573877357,
-0.0025074645,
0.0313341208,
0.0082973531,
-0.0296685677,
0.0314203165,
-0.0115792388,
-0.0856505483,
0.0118080564,
0.0239659008,
0.0646508113,
-0.0122281369,
-0.0013725845,
0.010993097,
0.041943416,
-0.0211258531,
-0.0607129782,
0.0319165774,
0.0080073988,
0.0213790331,
0.0241029672,
0.0497291349,
-0.0478099883,
-0.010207342,
-0.0682233796,
-0.0592825189,
-0.0135476599,
0.0584109426,
0.0201045256,
-0.0516245291,
-0.0059818602,
-0.0756160542,
0.0267022215,
0.020435784,
0.0410095826,
-0.0095860027,
-0.0217405837,
0.0678276122,
-0.0017745262,
-0.035566926,
-0.0210091397,
0.0565523207,
-0.0262301713,
0.052839864,
0.0169071984,
-0.0344909467,
-0.0368581787,
-0.0045396853,
-0.0032776084,
-0.0165253673,
0.0273021962,
0.012474807,
-0.0530195646,
-0.0519965142,
0.0462921932,
-0.0141123217,
0.0068268278,
-0.0607260987,
0.070123747,
-0.0057299961,
-0.0213818122,
0.0052789948,
-0.0056962804,
-0.0251871664,
-0.0384974219,
-0.0315293074,
-0.093427062,
-5.773854866e-33,
-0.0507563092,
-0.0437573977,
0.0192971043,
-0.0030926655,
-0.0043465439,
-0.0121900151,
-0.0566602387,
-0.0045364052,
0.0241089668,
0.0504738837,
0.0154068479,
0.0034917919,
0.0123585211,
-0.0010628235,
0.0503886491,
-0.0293170046,
0.0239725988,
-0.0350160785,
-0.01121841,
-0.0335334726,
0.080022648,
0.0250722114,
0.0443948582,
-0.0494870245,
0.0027872087,
0.0069131358,
-0.0274611041,
-0.019818224,
0.0433241054,
0.0032370861,
-0.0320758037,
0.0118090529,
0.0214754269,
-0.0157584269,
-0.0488912202,
0.0488846116,
0.0088316705,
-0.0614336468,
-0.0050586159,
0.0377974585,
-0.0312622786,
0.0075715412,
0.0445542783,
-0.0208826326,
-0.051453691,
0.0079277018,
0.0597027093,
-0.0113124549,
0.0172496196,
-0.0169472042,
-0.0384953618,
-0.0015097579,
-0.0508536734,
-0.0287331305,
0.0673519,
0.045031365,
0.018124368,
-0.0209297687,
-0.0436094478,
0.0291780792,
-0.0515561737,
0.05077466,
0.0781624541,
0.0038380784,
0.0349760018,
0.0756273642,
0.0067765582,
-0.0849829614,
-0.0533535741,
0.0687424019,
0.0211195853,
0.0638082251,
0.0296708569,
0.0189806242,
0.0581105463,
-0.0211020727,
0.0130585721,
0.0248598307,
-0.0497483909,
0.0807071626,
0.0142273307,
0.0332545005,
-0.0088150222,
-0.0381473638,
-0.0058902954,
-0.0112058409,
0.0155320298,
-0.0182740092,
0.0059371549,
-0.0212590676,
0.0216381811,
0.0171538629,
0.030932527,
-0.0281967763,
-0.0001291191,
0.047676608,
-0.0105249565,
0.0233949814,
0.0344011597,
0.0230217613,
-0.0328706168,
-0.0018613591,
0.0222890321,
0.0313920826,
0.0379525684,
0.0030879425,
-0.0417125374,
0.0681820214,
-0.0411476381,
-0.0314479657,
-0.007570087,
-0.0493881591,
0.0191396475,
-0.0410884283,
0.0732752904,
0.0157047454,
-0.0542242154,
0.0183962062,
-0.044212833,
-0.0023960425,
0.001581346,
0.0429095887,
-0.0027778987,
0.0417955443,
-0.0326493308,
-0.0163751394,
-0.0420669615,
-0.0050333017,
0.0497168042,
-0.0537657887,
-0.0367902629,
0.0377080105,
2.771e-7,
0.0198006742,
0.0429999568,
0.0194805358,
0.0135599934,
0.0316337645,
0.0350896493,
-0.0059762308,
0.0227556154,
0.0146432854,
-0.022548873,
0.0286805928,
0.0295940861,
0.0344270132,
0.0164198596,
-0.0339502729,
-0.0180973932,
-0.031222662,
0.0238038003,
-0.03083116,
-0.0189749114,
0.0998661891,
0.0845062211,
0.03374153,
0.0541926175,
0.0265337229,
-0.0144831538,
0.059233699,
-0.033062309,
0.0262839086,
-0.029589504,
-0.0105864508,
-0.0034214172,
-0.0317778625,
-0.0422190838,
-0.0335442536,
-0.0046824561,
-0.0114223901,
0.0237180162,
-0.0399629809,
-0.0130306985,
-0.0293646511,
0.0101777278,
-0.0166723207,
0.003084979,
0.0267577153,
-0.0494383201,
-0.0070201177,
-0.0289092697,
-0.0357045308,
0.0282352157,
-0.0122088324,
0.0386680029,
-0.0273490604,
-0.011549239,
0.0127841458,
-0.0156853218,
-0.0033813445,
-0.08223553,
-0.0208742302,
-0.0089292722,
-0.0622286908,
0.0148547757,
-0.057192985,
-0.0247160215,
0.0335229561,
-0.0157306846,
-0.0373606347,
2.292719539e-34,
0.0219744109,
0.0216689389,
-0.0117081739,
0.0000454331,
0.0168101173,
-0.0144126024,
0.0467846245,
0.0463168547,
0.056662444,
-0.0319218524,
-0.050785318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11622v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11622v1 | Building Knowledge-Guided Lexica to Model Cultural Variation | 2024-06-17T15:05:43 | 2024-06-17T15:05:43 | Shreya Havaldar, Salvatore Giorgi, Sunny Rai, Thomas Talhelm, Sharath Chandra Guntuku, Lyle Ungar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cultural variation exists between nations (e.g., the United States vs.
China), but also within regions (e.g., California vs. Texas, Los Angeles vs.
San Francisco). Measuring this regional cultural variation can illuminate how
and why people think and behave differently. Historically, it has been
difficult to computationally model cultural variation due to a lack of training
data and scalability constraints. In this work, we introduce a new research
problem for the NLP community: How do we measure variation in cultural
constructs across regions using language? We then provide a scalable solution:
building knowledge-guided lexica to model cultural variation, encouraging
future work at the intersection of NLP and cultural understanding. We also
highlight modern LLMs' failure to measure cultural variation or generate
culturally varied language. | [
0.0486975051,
0.0878460109,
-0.0575025864,
0.0407264531,
-0.0252702255,
0.0019480608,
0.0065310523,
-0.0019624198,
-0.0012883809,
-0.0301610753,
-0.0000329321,
-0.0439045355,
0.0180420596,
0.0122327097,
0.005894152,
-0.0668275356,
0.03593117,
0.0325842649,
-0.0091010863,
-0.0186859164,
0.0128727481,
0.0255756304,
0.0024993692,
0.010394535,
-0.0276987087,
0.0097183445,
0.0188047271,
-0.0213414431,
0.018163994,
-0.0100626834,
0.0392528921,
0.0206039473,
-0.0035510154,
-0.0128439246,
0.000001939,
-0.0343231,
-0.0136791682,
-0.0456105061,
0.045587562,
0.0394084007,
0.072228007,
0.0267342869,
-0.0113313869,
-0.0212963279,
-0.0478710718,
-0.0177693497,
0.0335435309,
0.0002210387,
-0.0016804207,
0.0403814465,
0.0062015872,
-0.0278362781,
-0.1034594178,
-0.0068730353,
-0.0373497345,
0.0265438613,
0.0095332498,
0.0527883619,
0.0014906824,
-0.0091466149,
-0.0800900012,
0.0161744896,
-0.0035882748,
0.0167628042,
-0.0220082048,
-0.0091007082,
-0.0607914403,
0.0122903753,
0.0047516054,
0.0363561325,
0.0815707818,
-0.0033087891,
0.0429424122,
0.0006417442,
-0.0275778435,
0.0447266027,
-0.0058677206,
-0.0001470169,
0.0038959826,
0.0134607907,
0.0135216787,
0.0042401645,
0.0005073507,
0.0442417227,
0.0032973958,
0.0907837972,
0.0190229453,
-0.0054836087,
-0.0909447372,
-0.0048076515,
-0.0182583183,
-0.0497032367,
0.0298157744,
0.0299408287,
0.0000622412,
0.0307382904,
0.0254618861,
0.0076802196,
0.0291809589,
-0.0274462607,
0.0086846901,
0.0150066549,
-0.0538014397,
-0.0023661428,
0.0397949405,
0.039034009,
0.0070707668,
-0.0017848116,
-0.0308640357,
-0.0279052742,
-0.0737980902,
0.0171104576,
0.0522067063,
-0.0432403982,
-0.0076653911,
0.038924139,
-0.0583217964,
-0.001058538,
-0.0596320033,
0.0198555179,
-0.0122001916,
-0.001814582,
0.0229016244,
0.0070205233,
-0.0406454541,
0.0451050624,
-0.081808731,
0.0023565963,
-0.0443767756,
-0.0099905059,
0.0528952107,
0.0039135194,
-0.0305826496,
0.0072415206,
0.0049013714,
-0.0057644891,
0.0314744301,
0.0162718091,
-0.0270261653,
0.0174687915,
-0.0351455621,
-0.015902942,
0.0208056699,
-0.0879250914,
0.0444312505,
-0.0031514852,
0.0480188914,
-0.0754423141,
-0.0122368811,
-0.0151422611,
-0.0135693429,
0.0220789779,
-0.0026066371,
0.0307368934,
0.0596951954,
0.0038130924,
0.0148668587,
0.0971160308,
0.0107194018,
-0.0241435189,
0.1263332516,
-0.0111843776,
-0.0643970072,
0.0113102132,
-0.0057633715,
0.0301161334,
-0.0388517492,
-0.0082545429,
0.0259166695,
-0.0146141332,
0.0356195644,
0.057878267,
-0.0233009551,
-0.0113700023,
0.0174262971,
0.1132746488,
-0.0027466188,
0.0170424655,
0.0489786342,
0.0438780524,
-0.0320072025,
-0.0132349394,
-0.0060416525,
-0.0332739986,
-0.0183219872,
-0.0276414007,
-0.0246513635,
0.0704000741,
-0.0602338128,
-0.036905013,
-0.0538679846,
0.0289477967,
0.0480597392,
-0.0110541144,
0.0218158085,
-0.0117469523,
0.0961098596,
0.0459425822,
0.0663757622,
-0.0576252677,
0.0027546233,
-0.0143197095,
0.0291697308,
0.0494828857,
0.0028197386,
-0.0033385775,
0.0340613462,
0.0533475429,
0.0231403597,
0.0506533422,
0.0527475029,
-0.0185023881,
-0.0005092272,
-0.0406703688,
0.0053740651,
-0.002554473,
0.0109752445,
-0.0172752924,
0.0864654481,
0.0211506858,
0.0088940235,
-0.0358705148,
0.0074792947,
-0.003830801,
-0.0416293219,
0.012743148,
0.0011937746,
-0.0021926775,
0.0402887464,
0.0430307239,
-0.0022768166,
-0.0156347398,
-0.0412024036,
-0.0205257349,
-0.0114599513,
0.0457279794,
0.0107402718,
-0.0149552543,
0.0367787704,
-0.0637272969,
-0.0084541971,
-0.0267355777,
-0.0093750963,
-0.0203627218,
0.0095362803,
-0.0001253888,
0.0580795072,
-0.0360429697,
0.0135980062,
-0.0273546763,
-0.0091729546,
-0.0564946868,
0.0595798083,
-0.0457454026,
0.0412087962,
-0.0365911834,
0.0023218356,
0.033795733,
0.0033144476,
-0.046279788,
-0.0186880454,
0.0102705602,
-0.0145085268,
0.0160234999,
0.0176059883,
-0.0350484103,
-0.0065416712,
-0.090427652,
-0.0025676093,
-0.025824707,
0.001931401,
0.0189790111,
0.0072741825,
-0.0315950215,
0.0240893792,
-0.0564279892,
0.0081439847,
0.0219821166,
0.0511073284,
0.0334716588,
-0.0507222749,
0.0014522516,
0.0008668891,
-0.021089768,
-0.0044164415,
0.0255601332,
-0.0763556138,
-0.0083861174,
-0.0192530099,
0.0076203444,
-0.1010460332,
0.0011796568,
-0.0177257676,
-0.0314725563,
0.0247571822,
0.0374045596,
0.0602523796,
0.0173209775,
0.0139625836,
-0.020380646,
0.0384172723,
-0.0297119655,
-0.0348205455,
-0.0187577829,
-0.0140831368,
0.0371849872,
-0.005100749,
-0.1122981608,
-0.001015169,
0.0819598883,
0.0143110659,
-0.0247204285,
-0.0074070771,
0.0305539854,
-0.0732985437,
-0.0289273895,
0.0071914364,
0.0322044864,
-0.0127445459,
0.0730844215,
-0.0192971937,
-0.0220448896,
0.0295285471,
0.0236342736,
0.0333250985,
-0.0067816866,
-0.0137431594,
-0.0603011847,
0.0550966226,
-0.0337437019,
0.0137630384,
-0.0097571583,
-0.0033765477,
-0.0048620752,
-0.0252484214,
0.046633862,
-0.0405778475,
0.0787654519,
-0.0670989603,
-0.014678753,
0.0054446571,
-0.0441312455,
-0.0318455957,
0.0503737256,
0.0033093605,
0.0230804402,
0.0812431052,
-0.0203354396,
0.0478931852,
0.0149662718,
0.0300450847,
-0.0168978106,
0.0070932787,
0.0250577591,
0.0178885125,
0.0164489727,
0.0360970944,
0.0455226637,
0.0079190107,
0.0203805864,
-0.048508998,
0.0242601112,
0.0383125693,
-0.0218470823,
0.0458590165,
0.0337351114,
0.0355594791,
-0.0592491403,
-0.0189377647,
0.0302246343,
0.0652344152,
-0.0006983777,
-0.0145587847,
0.0529919267,
0.0602096952,
-0.0372829251,
0.0135268597,
-0.0563356765,
0.0296919495,
0.0493550263,
0.0515535846,
-0.0927530453,
0.0366996489,
-0.0362243578,
-0.0322157517,
-0.0437898226,
-0.0398372561,
-0.0202565435,
-0.0790389851,
-0.0070047579,
0.0231329724,
-0.0172743089,
-0.0440042391,
0.0012948264,
0.0041657202,
0.0024154426,
-0.008910452,
-0.0297474042,
-0.0065430123,
-0.0116402274,
0.0179424677,
-0.0584747456,
-0.0353891514,
0.0286454316,
-0.0325680859,
0.0429417305,
0.0064138123,
0.0348469876,
-0.0016679364,
-0.0633391812,
-0.0616261326,
0.015248782,
0.0062228888,
-0.0210062228,
-0.0181833524,
0.0139752571,
-0.033588931,
-0.0169312116,
-0.0322890021,
-0.0031358665,
-0.0079406034,
0.0325722806,
0.0204754174,
0.011743376,
0.0140674179,
-0.0252639074,
0.0164468065,
0.0285353437,
0.0505034961,
0.0133706238,
-0.0588775426,
0.0330843031,
-0.030580692,
-0.0384656154,
-0.0051938668,
-0.0821977258,
0.016176708,
-0.0430522673,
-0.0165014081,
-0.0359679721,
-0.0484154113,
0.003462458,
0.0359429941,
0.0359209403,
-0.0388971567,
0.0436156541,
-0.0059275674,
-0.0685593858,
0.0167110842,
-0.0596717149,
-0.0034459678,
0.0445127189,
-0.0690157339,
0.0275645517,
0.0048903567,
0.006301824,
0.0283005983,
-0.0747765154,
-0.0368895717,
0.0586108565,
0.0235436112,
0.0086700581,
-0.0062442296,
0.0097898059,
-0.0253761616,
0.0404035673,
-0.0074644079,
0.0272103101,
0.0180358365,
-0.0042683939,
0.0400199406,
0.0186843928,
0.0173292607,
-0.011557064,
0.0454234444,
0.0482703149,
0.0690611452,
-0.0849903077,
-0.0200937688,
-0.0113583393,
-0.0119929863,
-0.0079316786,
-0.0459853336,
-0.0162126143,
-0.019750772,
-0.0479559749,
-0.0335050374,
-0.0381513759,
-0.0014777093,
-0.0607526712,
0.0005793952,
-0.0222640298,
-0.0475615002,
0.0228951238,
-0.0154012591,
0.0416107997,
-0.0313214287,
0.0201850776,
0.0264099296,
0.0222593136,
-0.0354560688,
0.0292504635,
-0.0135470834,
0.047471609,
-0.0258462541,
0.0521209352,
-0.0011391884,
0.0857966617,
-0.0019578463,
0.0025788338,
-0.0395183228,
-0.0006739362,
-0.0234830081,
-0.0130753033,
0.0339651145,
0.001980569,
0.0589470714,
-0.0669354647,
0.0253156051,
0.0240199137,
-0.0143632479,
-0.0015414899,
0.0278119761,
0.0253926553,
-0.0673014224,
0.0116510568,
0.0079444712,
-0.0000210004,
-0.0168448947,
0.0458652824,
-0.0508233756,
-0.0223383587,
0.016275527,
-0.0630854517,
-0.0052140406,
-0.0218549352,
0.0618714131,
0.0205107462,
-0.0099530611,
-0.002877272,
-0.0983144641,
-0.0619605333,
-0.0026264288,
-0.0175509155,
0.0430047549,
0.0061893328,
0.0301312711,
0.0815401226,
-0.002913442,
-0.0370019749,
-0.0542067215,
-0.0034401293,
-0.0340304673,
-0.0131401811,
0.0074996152,
-6.221502216e-33,
-0.0355661921,
-0.0503589213,
0.005340782,
-0.026922565,
-0.028244691,
0.0002844672,
0.0093328394,
0.0265990831,
-0.0410991721,
0.0202098992,
-0.0478770174,
0.0156567637,
0.0147335175,
0.0018808962,
0.0740286186,
0.0354629271,
-0.0121369874,
0.0352114476,
0.0069668517,
-0.0284562372,
0.0598097928,
-0.0318819769,
0.0851359293,
-0.0447220951,
0.0542729832,
0.0494477153,
0.0031664006,
0.0078996038,
0.0426526703,
0.0115578799,
-0.0270312,
0.0645616725,
0.0387686752,
-0.0189447794,
-0.0160380919,
-0.0518567078,
-0.0356171653,
-0.0862220451,
0.0645979717,
-0.0025091569,
0.0126834372,
-0.0416201502,
0.0159540903,
-0.0061889221,
-0.0229944643,
0.0250048973,
0.045639284,
0.0140343755,
-0.0024278297,
-0.0240610875,
-0.0349051915,
0.0273490865,
0.0062662293,
0.0517361313,
-0.0111074597,
-0.016281385,
-0.0197295994,
-0.0068712388,
-0.0364352018,
0.0409139656,
0.0280185845,
0.0454728343,
0.0429094993,
0.0046853973,
0.0069156033,
0.0402953587,
0.0139551936,
0.0486449115,
-0.009121838,
-0.0105006741,
0.0515852757,
0.0052664476,
-0.0103363702,
0.109250769,
0.007057427,
-0.0423944704,
-0.0230741668,
-0.0101744691,
0.0546621494,
-0.0197062958,
0.0021649455,
0.0135243144,
-0.0460026115,
-0.024949016,
-0.0144736841,
-0.0295052063,
0.0035140589,
-0.0403630733,
0.012485235,
-0.0052942038,
-0.0102270311,
0.0056924513,
0.0280217584,
-0.0532191955,
-0.0101513313,
-0.0016334996,
0.0003285848,
-0.0209711622,
0.0074373833,
-0.0221299045,
-0.0701037645,
-0.0326086245,
-0.0501923263,
0.029984463,
-0.0111318193,
0.0009488001,
-0.0122629264,
-0.0040598931,
-0.0552962571,
-0.0180249941,
-0.0014385392,
-0.0257891268,
-0.0660658851,
-0.0213513896,
0.0270957109,
0.0272362847,
-0.0143995732,
-0.0274403077,
0.0762932822,
-0.0317522585,
-0.0008049694,
-0.068823114,
-0.0352365747,
0.0396988951,
-0.0277072545,
-0.0089646494,
-0.0429262593,
0.0323001593,
0.0157904904,
-0.0027501299,
0.0132205794,
-0.0397269912,
2.603e-7,
0.0326448977,
0.0573580265,
-0.0309962686,
0.0822882578,
0.026089089,
-0.0372399166,
0.0304318462,
-0.0172913037,
-0.0073778625,
-0.0422090739,
0.0209016092,
0.028064914,
0.039112322,
0.0556524023,
-0.0949083269,
0.0015266537,
-0.0015725659,
0.016692901,
-0.0132086063,
-0.0087200431,
0.0233719628,
0.0226686168,
0.0469256975,
-0.0090603633,
-0.04721516,
0.0211940221,
0.0295700151,
-0.0524000563,
-0.0188218709,
0.0504763834,
0.0390683115,
-0.0552249141,
0.0253042243,
0.0128027424,
-0.0081885578,
0.0152783012,
0.0140990866,
0.0625882819,
-0.0048957765,
0.0031421063,
-0.021272514,
-0.0206470452,
-0.0098937973,
-0.0811988637,
0.0296487324,
0.0214855429,
-0.0087625403,
-0.028247647,
0.0013846601,
0.0036359616,
0.0357666537,
-0.0242762994,
-0.0271381829,
0.0045339749,
0.0182074718,
-0.0065130834,
-0.014481524,
-0.0729362816,
-0.0384224206,
-0.0114727253,
0.0198467467,
-0.0696081519,
0.0093717389,
-0.0152336145,
-0.0124845216,
0.0091752131,
0.0073368708,
2.136813861e-34,
0.0126551203,
0.031849172,
0.0046776459,
0.0079882201,
0.0724865943,
-0.0039941072,
-0.0233893842,
-0.0055998373,
0.0096128033,
-0.0113442196,
0.0099382671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11617v1 | DELLA-Merging: Reducing Interference in Model Merging through Magnitude-Based Sampling | 2024-06-17T15:02:45 | 2024-06-17T15:02:45 | Pala Tej Deep, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the proliferation of domain-specific models, model merging has emerged
as a set of techniques that combine the capabilities of multiple models into
one that can multitask without the cost of additional training. In this paper,
we propose a new model merging technique, Drop and rEscaLe via sampLing with
mAgnitude (DELLA-Merging), that employs a novel pruning technique, MAGPRUNE,
which shows significant advantages over DARE and TIES. MAGPRUNE first ranks the
parameters in order of their magnitude and assigns higher dropout probabilities
(p) to parameters with lower ranks corresponding to lower magnitudes. To
approximate the original embeddings, MAGPRUNE employs a rescaling operation on
the parameters that survive the random dropping by 1/(1 - p). On three
different expert models considered for merging (LM, Math, Code) and
corresponding benchmark datasets (AlpacaEval, GSM8K, MBPP), DELLA shows an
average improvement of 2.4 points over baseline methods employing delta
parameter pruning (an improvement of 3.6 points over TIES, 1.2 points over
DARE), and 11.1 points over the no-pruning baseline (TA). We release the source
code at: https://github.com/declare-lab/della. | [
-0.062691167,
0.065813303,
-0.0271573812,
0.0077599064,
-0.0053297738,
0.0216771774,
0.0263852086,
-0.0035550192,
-0.0165740177,
-0.0004470847,
0.0006254281,
0.0230111741,
0.0292191338,
0.0538973063,
0.0224479232,
-0.0356031656,
0.0371585302,
-0.0263297614,
-0.0189674199,
-0.0094528412,
-0.031670589,
-0.0000312622,
0.0343880653,
0.0380025543,
0.0638942644,
-0.0042155357,
-0.010312533,
0.009391102,
0.0438087918,
0.0238758791,
0.0098070381,
0.065000467,
0.0230668578,
0.0500017144,
0.0000023299,
-0.025627844,
-0.0258820746,
0.050253991,
-0.0206082538,
0.0448307879,
0.0102011692,
0.0186416656,
0.0186133031,
0.0209791996,
-0.0199629366,
-0.0291114748,
0.0176432468,
0.0526229255,
0.0535042398,
0.0286220498,
0.0225989483,
-0.0457206219,
0.0222016424,
-0.0288845319,
-0.0468131118,
0.0015029086,
0.0612534508,
0.059089765,
-0.0273243655,
-0.0065119001,
0.0188190881,
0.006331786,
0.0201867446,
0.0201676562,
0.0397467427,
0.0296430439,
0.0564505011,
-0.0099276174,
0.0082677631,
0.0473273881,
-0.0481825359,
-0.0272309557,
0.00946745,
-0.0267904475,
0.0166190974,
0.0505987294,
-0.0704716817,
-0.0613603555,
0.0091073727,
0.027263606,
0.0052596722,
0.0019076616,
0.0209649503,
-0.0408056565,
-0.0313049629,
-0.0023284305,
0.0312332977,
-0.0095209293,
-0.0158409998,
-0.0441599824,
-0.0508175045,
-0.0393830873,
-0.0037277045,
-0.0268134009,
0.0158295855,
-0.0438806191,
-0.0549462251,
-0.0444348603,
0.0156316366,
0.0021503947,
0.0787807629,
0.009572641,
0.0266190562,
0.0141444961,
-0.0211176686,
0.0393703356,
-0.005997505,
0.0107934587,
-0.0491381735,
0.0477014706,
-0.0627628565,
0.0051288251,
0.0374746621,
0.0443400368,
-0.0308077391,
0.0077223117,
-0.0584144183,
0.0056521557,
-0.0362042189,
-0.0150080277,
0.0301074367,
0.0149379829,
-0.0022585555,
0.0126178423,
-0.0119469408,
0.0263871215,
-0.0162728541,
0.0131672975,
0.0069002411,
0.0024894834,
-0.0078573208,
-0.0374094881,
-0.0275947452,
-0.0134263802,
0.0047400231,
0.0517666824,
-0.0021188171,
0.0162472744,
-0.0413747504,
-0.0479858555,
0.033166647,
-0.0404240116,
0.0185430814,
-0.0775287673,
0.0596838742,
-0.0431797504,
0.0046297563,
-0.0809625313,
-0.0236025639,
-0.0003831291,
-0.0101872003,
0.0682368279,
-0.0024767485,
0.0095124915,
0.0508436076,
0.0127667682,
-0.0708571598,
0.0690117702,
-0.0039464151,
-0.0086016562,
-0.0250511747,
-0.0586072169,
0.0100358743,
0.0169241894,
0.0226765051,
0.0054389257,
-0.0419129767,
-0.0248072483,
0.0209165905,
-0.019170491,
0.0494033322,
-0.0222407132,
-0.0644110292,
-0.0299093146,
0.0141791357,
-0.0111939609,
0.071101822,
0.0495508276,
0.042283278,
0.0255669579,
0.0210151728,
0.0071790935,
-0.0568972155,
-0.0005243263,
-0.0328762904,
0.0339606702,
0.015397165,
0.1098255739,
-0.0284082964,
-0.0846289322,
-0.005481822,
0.0031501716,
-0.05632177,
0.009780149,
0.0549306311,
-0.0110644959,
-0.01685757,
0.0092157545,
0.0230058003,
-0.0361327119,
-0.0420828573,
-0.041961465,
-0.0404145643,
-0.0239813048,
0.0213844664,
-0.0396973863,
-0.0232405271,
0.0113384984,
-0.0172000695,
-0.0576068014,
0.0366284326,
-0.0007879348,
0.0139071755,
-0.0652514473,
-0.063510038,
-0.0090176985,
0.0135812014,
0.0358120985,
0.0125248926,
-0.0181884058,
0.032181967,
-0.0682699382,
-0.0379903428,
0.0250032973,
-0.0662001595,
-0.0250850953,
0.0151296994,
-0.0180215761,
0.0368294157,
0.0140946545,
-0.0147030922,
0.007282279,
0.0480235852,
0.0104293711,
-0.0556251667,
-0.0277214423,
-0.0121992091,
-0.0055352272,
0.056156259,
-0.0321841538,
0.0133107044,
0.0429050922,
-0.0509162322,
-0.048987966,
0.001446208,
0.0110028572,
0.0519750863,
0.0010307922,
0.0761136413,
-0.026577197,
0.0215476118,
-0.0051982598,
0.0624879934,
-0.0194179453,
-0.007158224,
0.0110488981,
0.0239530299,
0.0178469624,
0.0251706131,
-0.0109419497,
-0.015033585,
-0.0283256397,
0.0309075527,
-0.0157898702,
-0.0331983194,
-0.011604337,
-0.0223629717,
-0.0514203273,
0.0092417421,
0.0505821779,
0.0261240471,
0.0034462058,
0.0052011264,
-0.0116650602,
0.0154492455,
0.046082668,
-0.0403932929,
-0.0462119915,
0.0152009251,
-0.029384857,
-0.0336027518,
-0.0488432236,
-0.0136269098,
-0.0409737006,
-0.0461686999,
0.0986178666,
-0.0199358668,
-0.0130963279,
-0.0421927124,
0.0812964886,
-0.0598107874,
-0.0079187844,
-0.0166524965,
-0.0402302109,
-0.032738816,
-0.0088888248,
0.0468639024,
0.0707517862,
-0.0536115132,
0.0010504186,
0.0767512769,
-0.014155468,
-0.0492068641,
0.007303799,
0.0017906869,
0.0267587062,
0.0202086065,
-0.0425566696,
-0.0191571936,
0.0459631011,
-0.0125138871,
-0.0272590872,
-0.0193915945,
0.01381958,
-0.0049143173,
-0.0081821615,
0.0318446308,
0.0017043033,
-0.0163077638,
0.0364570953,
-0.0098322844,
-0.0731054172,
0.0622388199,
-0.0284534115,
0.022854181,
-0.03924492,
-0.0388625637,
-0.0389433056,
-0.0284194369,
-0.0151847182,
-0.005283766,
0.0076448391,
0.0015525706,
-0.0265378617,
0.0186943784,
0.032731723,
-0.0330582634,
0.0210335944,
-0.0320462771,
0.0108011495,
0.0077932281,
-0.0210812017,
-0.0084580155,
0.0055991323,
-0.0134796984,
0.0339945816,
0.0069443765,
-0.0558286309,
-0.0275622644,
0.0066923192,
-0.0157172605,
0.0076174345,
-0.0184693541,
-0.0247179233,
-0.0027034129,
0.0229337085,
0.0174726285,
-0.001115336,
0.0100107277,
-0.0287450217,
0.0701735094,
-0.0090539707,
0.0629320592,
0.0072153662,
-0.1005093679,
-0.0173540879,
0.003436699,
-0.0312063973,
-0.0188631564,
0.0171214342,
-0.0052165459,
-0.0165046565,
0.0601283759,
0.0786378756,
0.0136579471,
-0.017744353,
-0.0200865678,
-0.0437277444,
0.097859554,
0.026892174,
0.0303562693,
-0.0217718259,
-0.0030820151,
0.0281870365,
-0.0078404415,
0.011126087,
-0.0057542324,
0.0114185177,
-0.1188935786,
0.020436611,
0.0625709519,
0.013720613,
-0.0145927425,
-0.048808746,
0.0189847331,
-0.0524917431,
-0.0230070278,
-0.0130531872,
-0.0357052721,
0.0044733034,
0.0293127187,
-0.0143967895,
-0.0637244061,
-0.0151258809,
-0.0386587121,
0.0230760761,
0.0102802375,
0.0180523042,
0.0007461586,
-0.0234765708,
0.0603420399,
0.0234818459,
-0.003171728,
-0.0170974713,
0.068785578,
0.0298628155,
0.0325541869,
0.0115773324,
0.0528278276,
0.0000110787,
-0.0140231466,
0.0112323146,
0.1069663092,
-0.0084294779,
-0.0326429605,
-0.0617580973,
-0.0071430472,
-0.052861575,
0.0376284011,
0.0297106337,
-0.0087062931,
0.0029475547,
-0.0071156556,
-0.0184147581,
0.0608634092,
0.0072648567,
0.0112927109,
-0.0158688538,
-0.0533874668,
-0.0038588212,
0.0142175918,
0.0354101323,
0.0549243987,
0.0219543185,
0.0129391504,
-0.0312167462,
0.0032912486,
-0.0557645261,
0.0191521533,
-0.0104038613,
0.0083547737,
-0.0257968474,
0.0318963453,
0.0244002864,
-0.0028865666,
-0.0710593387,
-0.0178726409,
-0.1077472046,
-0.0760754719,
-0.0263456162,
0.050819546,
0.0267719217,
0.0435848311,
-0.0150544159,
-0.0497117117,
0.0496044792,
0.0138013959,
0.010420315,
0.0225866903,
0.0354021788,
-0.0547081195,
0.0092744911,
-0.0151547855,
-0.0249615349,
0.0107733821,
0.0118750781,
-0.0523857549,
-0.0521028973,
-0.0222677458,
-0.0123967901,
0.0267460514,
0.0371785834,
0.0206465032,
-0.0388358384,
-0.0380018204,
0.0125145558,
-0.0095634423,
0.002812597,
-0.043482136,
0.0292045511,
0.0078555457,
0.0508602485,
0.0420549922,
0.0209217984,
0.0511967801,
-0.0317986831,
0.0061505567,
-0.0086869774,
0.0039169593,
0.0296282917,
0.0154237822,
-0.0195792262,
0.0043673739,
-0.0345671177,
0.01493413,
0.0105862711,
-0.0280183293,
0.0377792642,
0.0020612704,
0.0646042675,
-0.0263026264,
0.0204094835,
-0.0506586991,
-0.1035027131,
-0.046865847,
-0.0227106512,
0.0315844715,
0.0179575775,
0.0543077886,
0.0096376007,
0.0016376192,
-0.0334848724,
0.0385900252,
-0.0106917145,
0.04558561,
0.0339617282,
0.0074714469,
-0.01256801,
0.0114746671,
0.060800653,
0.0343386531,
0.0282168146,
-0.0432821326,
0.0035877666,
-0.029113235,
-0.0151776737,
0.0420438461,
0.0243166424,
0.0006756168,
-0.0815483481,
-0.0772187337,
-0.0598131754,
0.0245362669,
-0.0053559542,
-0.025935268,
0.0131846191,
0.014326226,
0.0364619084,
-0.0349420272,
0.0150376419,
0.020263629,
-0.0624465235,
0.0008717894,
-0.0493723378,
0.0108403843,
-6.176820941e-33,
-0.0079368604,
-0.0007174811,
-0.0067653758,
-0.0497744009,
-0.0438861586,
0.0160082094,
0.0357335433,
-0.003818824,
-0.0044234395,
-0.021531621,
-0.020357769,
0.0077206092,
0.0126146898,
-0.0348300152,
0.0342800207,
0.0236955285,
0.0631523579,
0.0020940732,
0.004406882,
0.0261850301,
-0.0587124713,
0.0409739874,
-0.0088068601,
-0.0603628755,
-0.031148484,
0.0317332111,
-0.0006426673,
-0.0165071599,
-0.0073686894,
0.0450707749,
-0.0067946324,
-0.005669584,
-0.0045241518,
-0.0358096957,
-0.0774678588,
-0.0287533142,
-0.027318079,
-0.052630838,
0.0205553249,
-0.0288034361,
0.020758586,
-0.037262287,
0.056739971,
0.0419077873,
-0.0103631308,
-0.1113408431,
0.0696054846,
0.0074630342,
-0.0538931899,
0.0071289917,
-0.0316662565,
0.0259553064,
-0.0007220075,
0.0007124346,
0.0460025519,
0.0275029745,
0.0258222725,
0.024054816,
-0.0109844925,
0.0241044182,
0.0908477232,
0.0431651734,
0.0693906099,
0.0200222712,
0.0049165511,
0.0462307744,
0.0164338257,
-0.0409325585,
0.013814155,
-0.0302016009,
0.0238902085,
0.1078378856,
0.0323923342,
0.0483113341,
0.0449553207,
0.0127328159,
-0.0530995913,
0.0648965761,
-0.0002335467,
-0.0191051234,
-0.0146826236,
0.0402271114,
-0.0369531438,
-0.0067488584,
-0.0255663656,
-0.016144678,
-0.029894162,
-0.0376299657,
0.0124513172,
-0.0184073541,
-0.0512174629,
0.0208956879,
0.0065512653,
-0.063738808,
-0.0074014096,
0.0038862345,
-0.0179065391,
0.0413902849,
0.0048509054,
-0.013890245,
0.0044002137,
-0.0417087935,
0.0068528811,
0.0046750861,
0.0630950108,
-0.0336264446,
-0.0082345372,
-0.0055324794,
-0.0385388918,
-0.0051593301,
-0.0300347805,
-0.0481519029,
0.0424139164,
0.0646006614,
0.0554108955,
0.0164287817,
0.0106564388,
-0.0292622223,
0.0308980234,
0.0217970591,
-0.0532027036,
0.0695858151,
0.0158441588,
0.0384358838,
0.0158225503,
-0.0156131228,
-0.0237668846,
-0.0274031088,
0.0577047206,
-0.0197177511,
-0.073934488,
0.0307198353,
2.951e-7,
-0.0006986686,
0.0035834427,
-0.0073297536,
-0.0293807164,
-0.0212052576,
0.0599228777,
-0.026714677,
-0.0025705134,
0.0436777547,
0.0266267117,
0.0273404978,
0.0077362843,
0.0598095544,
0.014567907,
-0.067409344,
-0.0491402522,
-0.0061202482,
0.0069731539,
-0.0686610341,
-0.042873051,
0.0135062123,
0.0875289366,
0.0566192903,
0.005820815,
-0.0098715173,
-0.0043984847,
0.0251504518,
-0.0241671931,
-0.0012444303,
0.0472031273,
-0.0251229722,
-0.0170061085,
-0.0059990594,
0.0196034014,
-0.0110378684,
0.0263803303,
0.0386624224,
0.0639427975,
0.0126384385,
0.0429541655,
0.0504426919,
0.0132183759,
-0.0113072451,
-0.0518979505,
0.059148185,
-0.0434118286,
-0.0317351632,
-0.039893657,
-0.0587482825,
-0.0471121855,
0.0423863269,
-0.0081078894,
0.038428016,
0.0384300724,
-0.0238702167,
-0.0135407159,
-0.0059185391,
-0.0127397422,
-0.0204865299,
0.028644789,
-0.0825091004,
-0.0577151068,
-0.0124160275,
-0.0033220341,
0.0645005628,
-0.0516863652,
-0.0028903377,
3.435074821e-34,
0.0394276157,
-0.0246687327,
0.0616020225,
0.0821356699,
-0.0123856151,
-0.0196669083,
-0.0086812163,
0.0283420254,
-0.0098331543,
-0.0460200086,
-0.0028900146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11614v1 | Intrinsic Evaluation of Unlearning Using Parametric Knowledge Traces | 2024-06-17T15:00:35 | 2024-06-17T15:00:35 | Yihuai Hong, Lei Yu, Shauli Ravfogel, Haiqin Yang, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The task of "unlearning" certain concepts in large language models (LLMs) has
attracted immense attention recently, due to its importance for mitigating
undesirable model behaviours, such as the generation of harmful, private, or
incorrect information. Current protocols to evaluate unlearning methods largely
rely on behavioral tests, without monitoring the presence of unlearned
knowledge within the model's parameters. This residual knowledge can be
adversarially exploited to recover the erased information post-unlearning. We
argue that unlearning should also be evaluated internally, by considering
changes in the parametric knowledge traces of the unlearned concepts. To this
end, we propose a general methodology for eliciting directions in the parameter
space (termed "concept vectors") that encode concrete concepts, and construct
ConceptVectors, a benchmark dataset containing hundreds of common concepts and
their parametric knowledge traces within two open-source LLMs. Evaluation on
ConceptVectors shows that existing unlearning methods minimally impact concept
vectors, while directly ablating these vectors demonstrably removes the
associated knowledge from the LLMs and significantly reduces their
susceptibility to adversarial manipulation. Our results highlight limitations
in behavioral-based unlearning evaluations and call for future work to include
parametric-based evaluations. To support this, we release our code and
benchmark at https://github.com/yihuaihong/ConceptVectors. | [
0.0112826461,
0.0949029028,
-0.0314647406,
0.082579203,
-0.0475184247,
0.0150711611,
-0.0207372811,
0.02365526,
-0.0495235175,
-0.0200448185,
-0.0361175612,
-0.0101284562,
0.0266230013,
0.01828002,
0.0512310006,
-0.009280744,
0.0340781175,
-0.0398402996,
-0.0030007679,
0.0005102378,
-0.0037343416,
-0.0112857819,
0.0068491814,
0.0201716628,
0.0169103052,
-0.0624844544,
-0.0164566245,
-0.0305253416,
-0.0125001082,
0.0035504622,
0.0257188827,
0.0367323309,
0.0038516519,
0.0842475817,
0.0000021509,
-0.0287146214,
-0.0480397604,
0.0016536358,
-0.0181621946,
0.0845946372,
0.010877667,
-0.0129824514,
0.003334593,
0.0128791258,
-0.0271365512,
-0.0042968201,
0.0229774639,
0.020199148,
0.049385082,
0.0576263852,
0.0055383453,
-0.0019583199,
0.0136045525,
-0.0294524841,
0.0008077304,
0.0023613342,
0.0490952246,
-0.0532131754,
-0.0964272171,
-0.0242889132,
-0.0195841417,
0.024342183,
0.0205646101,
0.0283691362,
-0.0031154258,
0.0217560045,
-0.0033775358,
0.0000440444,
0.0084330654,
0.0626736283,
-0.0227774139,
-0.0230611637,
0.0265222657,
-0.0025814271,
0.008964899,
0.0040819407,
-0.0422054119,
-0.0132228611,
-0.0046672765,
-0.0121534104,
-0.0311657432,
-0.0266907439,
0.0661688671,
0.0175099056,
0.0114742555,
0.0500629954,
0.0282454491,
-0.0164368153,
-0.0256416742,
-0.0304854698,
-0.0214413311,
-0.0343013816,
-0.0057143257,
0.00396227,
0.0262557119,
0.0474523567,
-0.0287873577,
-0.0352592841,
0.0476387367,
-0.035844855,
0.0760788396,
-0.0014432613,
-0.0097106369,
0.0404567085,
-0.0406208597,
0.0697196275,
-0.0134196766,
0.0518504344,
-0.0112724751,
0.0345985666,
-0.0316982903,
-0.0111490535,
0.0154871698,
0.0444742851,
0.0551273301,
0.0343990438,
0.0039135804,
0.0122133782,
-0.0427986756,
0.0419312939,
-0.0539747365,
-0.0158503596,
0.0079777688,
0.0097037889,
-0.025164254,
0.0028706321,
-0.0179810077,
-0.0079047009,
0.0041572414,
-0.0564392507,
-0.0422074795,
-0.0053530345,
-0.0216638818,
-0.0239810366,
0.0110383891,
0.064526692,
0.0035361112,
-0.0317691788,
-0.0629261881,
-0.0472327098,
-0.0087761758,
-0.0650509447,
0.0200617611,
-0.066681765,
-0.0073676193,
-0.0140678277,
-0.0228951517,
-0.0878082365,
-0.0137409754,
0.0135317091,
-0.0545455068,
0.0550045483,
0.0394604579,
-0.0134421093,
0.0103000514,
0.0419382788,
-0.0150977932,
0.0601489916,
-0.0035873554,
0.0393331125,
0.045412153,
-0.0296237804,
0.0317054763,
0.0389670394,
0.0819798112,
0.0272667855,
-0.0424072221,
0.004561238,
0.046400737,
-0.0084143449,
0.017736759,
0.0399879888,
-0.03345621,
-0.0396625288,
0.071024023,
0.0020275323,
-0.0324876457,
0.0447522476,
0.0217891578,
-0.0298031885,
0.0329904892,
0.0459975302,
-0.0544508919,
-0.02375881,
-0.0739845634,
-0.0167634301,
0.0119956238,
0.0087445173,
-0.0353637226,
-0.0407956615,
0.015940519,
-0.0238302983,
0.062009763,
-0.0043414268,
0.0671743527,
0.0546876192,
-0.0062394184,
0.0451995656,
0.0392067395,
-0.0565026738,
0.0186721217,
-0.0509960242,
0.0344910398,
0.0260862987,
0.1054033041,
-0.0480645597,
-0.0119406162,
0.018993279,
-0.0363756716,
-0.0250819121,
0.024749497,
-0.0217408184,
0.0433283895,
-0.0292098094,
-0.0318197496,
-0.0293098018,
0.0379155874,
0.0073178769,
0.0477236472,
-0.0146133583,
0.0155793242,
-0.0908412188,
-0.034727674,
0.0422717705,
-0.023544861,
-0.0294774808,
0.0004546636,
0.0084629515,
0.0120456843,
0.0069004465,
-0.0053580897,
0.0095493495,
0.0550945774,
0.0029345779,
-0.0200156961,
-0.0348779075,
-0.0236898679,
-0.0224820599,
0.0300797839,
-0.0002579024,
0.0024198745,
0.0595294014,
-0.0340056829,
-0.0083626378,
0.0537974164,
-0.0098471064,
0.0587540418,
-0.0262260213,
0.0402507037,
-0.0504709519,
0.028360337,
0.0050824159,
0.0590876117,
-0.0333606377,
0.0125804981,
-0.0160868689,
-0.0076731211,
-0.0201035924,
0.0015167226,
-0.0441196263,
0.0089576924,
-0.0272232965,
0.0283094849,
0.0160279777,
-0.0384248756,
-0.0540175028,
-0.0063101426,
-0.0445138142,
-0.0074805776,
-0.0144922296,
0.0268440284,
0.0301733427,
-0.0136689702,
0.0147412717,
-0.0096953735,
-0.0104217306,
0.0030470584,
-0.0423657857,
0.0319639333,
-0.0066033565,
0.0080954004,
-0.0301718209,
-0.024021294,
0.0024487444,
0.0091189099,
0.0727283806,
-0.03279626,
0.0225221273,
-0.0086193727,
0.0574203469,
-0.0471519865,
0.0407608263,
-0.0264732577,
-0.0464323238,
0.0023741941,
-0.0027527658,
-0.0198985506,
0.0377080664,
0.002242014,
0.0507787094,
0.0871167928,
0.0152218547,
-0.0437678173,
-0.014477618,
-0.0221443214,
-0.0370291322,
-0.0203008913,
0.0304563232,
-0.0112450253,
0.0593850389,
0.0184800848,
-0.0286314934,
-0.0390946977,
0.0366350263,
-0.036864046,
-0.0391993448,
-0.0673645735,
-0.0130446702,
-0.0149266915,
0.001943514,
-0.0375022329,
-0.0843849182,
0.0718925148,
-0.0385920256,
0.0141419098,
-0.00524374,
-0.0043152836,
0.0053753331,
0.0753586963,
0.0006000639,
0.0102130361,
0.0671555176,
-0.0012310568,
-0.0604413971,
-0.0134957805,
0.0329838246,
-0.0421757326,
0.0387223363,
-0.0613092259,
-0.0121222259,
0.037007235,
-0.012196973,
-0.0633527488,
-0.0233395044,
0.0414046608,
0.006125784,
0.0101763858,
-0.0259458665,
0.0102748517,
-0.0531334057,
0.0489382111,
0.023033563,
0.0207806267,
0.0011553935,
-0.0209580604,
0.0172219202,
0.0454250015,
-0.0547135882,
0.0060300855,
-0.0403810441,
0.0123158982,
0.0976643413,
0.0182558931,
-0.0031221344,
-0.0010868869,
-0.0060150144,
-0.0029476739,
-0.0094327359,
-0.0073672072,
0.0222325176,
-0.0014043842,
-0.0501200035,
-0.0319550335,
0.0929740667,
0.0091076307,
-0.0422186293,
0.0219827499,
0.0113075757,
0.032813251,
0.0028283529,
-0.0227710567,
-0.0713123083,
0.0124361962,
0.0090624643,
0.0332679339,
-0.0116480729,
-0.0454458334,
-0.0013256025,
-0.1035295501,
-0.0141191399,
0.0257797204,
-0.0268617347,
-0.0438312963,
-0.0461841784,
-0.0079318061,
-0.0236351285,
0.0194355883,
0.0055020959,
0.007306654,
0.0138789807,
-0.0159900356,
-0.0678486973,
-0.0511537567,
0.0543488711,
-0.0271102507,
0.0145918643,
0.0361121707,
0.0290599633,
-0.0121486951,
-0.0402804017,
-0.021691883,
-0.0527274758,
-0.0095381541,
0.0142544499,
0.0720886439,
0.002386231,
-0.001191676,
0.0286967419,
0.0624250099,
-0.0387795232,
-0.0275325775,
0.0272841919,
0.0609565601,
-0.0008753282,
-0.0390154831,
0.0120322499,
-0.0658553168,
0.0170866307,
0.0938910022,
0.0362965167,
-0.0298869535,
-0.0148812355,
-0.0212870426,
0.0197133645,
0.0149080316,
-0.0396729149,
0.0146866841,
0.0257455297,
-0.0272302441,
-0.0813379958,
-0.019115068,
0.0032386475,
0.0053421459,
0.0123898732,
0.0323593095,
-0.0054379595,
-0.0113059906,
-0.0633936152,
-0.0075992676,
-0.0305278432,
0.0132100331,
-0.0195716713,
-0.0311165694,
-0.0255243368,
-0.0055854004,
-0.0216910113,
0.019647859,
-0.0930885151,
-0.0889977515,
0.0146549502,
0.0349683352,
0.0186819956,
0.0718352273,
-0.038403891,
-0.0337262303,
0.1006497815,
0.0074112928,
-0.0263801664,
0.0230667274,
0.0417143479,
-0.0158086419,
0.0059875729,
0.0552509092,
-0.040968556,
-0.0291780252,
0.0696020126,
-0.0116274683,
-0.0391061828,
0.0251757763,
0.0212448891,
0.0382782966,
0.1103449985,
-0.000948876,
-0.0082960101,
-0.0064865705,
-0.0072919838,
0.0117884418,
-0.0348782912,
-0.0253866408,
-0.0085836835,
0.0494877659,
0.0255801678,
0.0055892821,
-0.0139202774,
0.0296279099,
0.0078946464,
-0.0046847104,
-0.0281034485,
0.0381102301,
0.0345298648,
0.0581186451,
0.0153395301,
0.001830763,
0.0304396823,
-0.043600481,
0.0177916754,
-0.0179862864,
0.045696184,
0.0157905277,
0.0152090918,
-0.0098912362,
0.0142813446,
-0.0321086422,
-0.0428219587,
-0.0459952429,
0.0257717408,
0.0168457106,
0.0121462699,
0.0111303609,
-0.0330165997,
-0.0052797822,
-0.0337961651,
0.0060642269,
-0.034981139,
-0.0324744992,
0.0125597073,
0.0202017445,
-0.0233741384,
0.0287191961,
0.0942439288,
-0.0174608789,
0.1068727374,
-0.0169092119,
0.0014711019,
-0.0342756957,
-0.0104609113,
0.0308144279,
-0.0120873945,
-0.0300512351,
0.0078801587,
-0.0338272564,
-0.085529834,
-0.0117105814,
0.0147739295,
0.0076331799,
-0.0046180319,
0.0223112404,
0.0743644014,
-0.0247244611,
0.0181862004,
-0.06557291,
0.0014645919,
-0.002480248,
-0.0330514014,
-0.0232251212,
-6.716852597e-33,
0.0121807437,
-0.0084341262,
-0.0150806643,
0.034022592,
0.0137832696,
0.0166883655,
-0.0174227804,
-0.0044021276,
-0.0256283805,
0.0003656549,
0.0013891266,
0.0233629812,
-0.0235311426,
0.0038373296,
-0.0153929377,
-0.038888447,
0.0569597259,
-0.0163032282,
-0.0486203581,
0.0365313366,
0.0782888383,
0.0300060064,
0.0625949055,
-0.0684044808,
0.0283870194,
-0.0105738575,
-0.0389174297,
0.030795943,
-0.0379585139,
0.0546813086,
-0.019089628,
0.0228255931,
-0.008788703,
-0.0208934527,
-0.0277401153,
-0.0291881282,
-0.0491911396,
-0.0186863262,
0.0077012274,
0.013985225,
-0.0409504995,
-0.0406616777,
0.0503843874,
-0.0188881885,
-0.0020074781,
-0.0100458786,
0.0030823718,
0.0021991828,
-0.0164673533,
0.0160116777,
-0.018499082,
0.0068866475,
-0.0275970381,
-0.0377889201,
0.0351363011,
-0.0048898575,
0.0200882964,
-0.0233392064,
-0.1102477759,
0.0094558401,
0.0149471527,
0.0318829641,
0.0707014799,
0.0157636609,
0.0210448876,
0.0827771798,
0.0248586815,
0.0235353932,
-0.0015624516,
-0.0027037517,
0.0674303025,
0.0345573053,
0.0414374955,
0.0357375778,
0.0475391224,
-0.0381730907,
-0.0347728282,
0.0177610647,
-0.0019630131,
0.0474314392,
0.0024485569,
0.038349133,
-0.0160480216,
-0.0222881194,
-0.0588401295,
-0.0411974341,
-0.0550637804,
-0.0167577211,
0.0219831187,
0.0135392426,
-0.040166758,
-0.0492341705,
-0.0148435589,
-0.0467732027,
0.0008667739,
0.0733359307,
-0.0263200458,
0.0177761,
0.0120884394,
-0.0099239442,
-0.0629505143,
-0.0273827631,
0.0121688815,
-0.0205658041,
0.032088425,
0.0041516027,
0.0783568695,
0.0589099638,
-0.0351233035,
-0.0014747524,
-0.0496699363,
0.0148043251,
0.0397964083,
-0.0303487517,
0.0163932182,
0.0106388722,
-0.0226294566,
-0.0257741045,
0.0571828224,
0.0308937561,
-0.0515676811,
0.0071865874,
-0.0044947607,
0.0044852579,
-0.0113745965,
-0.0588511378,
0.0107112788,
-0.0081172371,
0.1005728617,
-0.0231024157,
0.0159476288,
-0.0085601918,
2.89e-7,
0.0036190965,
0.0209671762,
-0.0018223134,
0.0053907153,
0.047236342,
0.0716120824,
-0.0501806624,
0.0417852737,
-0.0211329814,
-0.0511517636,
0.0016989544,
0.017443506,
0.0591457374,
0.0322433673,
-0.0708848983,
0.0154844327,
-0.0608138032,
-0.0297114234,
-0.0198209863,
-0.0252462514,
-0.0060123857,
0.0815141946,
0.0580893867,
-0.0013591229,
0.0019553779,
-0.0359516516,
0.0378317796,
-0.0331227593,
-0.0059927469,
0.0012544885,
0.0358717442,
0.0317466706,
0.0280374046,
0.0112103336,
-0.0270240661,
0.0003934279,
0.0083430521,
0.0554699413,
0.0264822226,
-0.0174837839,
-0.0563410521,
0.00329012,
-0.0132890865,
-0.049120456,
0.075403519,
0.0010397189,
-0.0269453265,
-0.0183927752,
0.0024989005,
-0.0224152319,
0.0366959274,
0.0281482693,
-0.0431571715,
0.0204377305,
-0.0144087616,
0.0061986637,
-0.01068985,
-0.0521023534,
-0.0441168733,
0.0006983849,
-0.0336751975,
-0.0506122522,
-0.0179696213,
-0.027812358,
-0.0231386609,
-0.0748042762,
0.0324691013,
2.587770916e-34,
-0.0117482701,
-0.0403712317,
0.0003065266,
-0.0149195008,
0.0393129624,
-0.0432381555,
0.00509449,
0.0155542251,
-0.0057550697,
-0.052626498,
0.0105698807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11598v1 | Understanding "Democratization" in NLP and ML Research | 2024-06-17T14:47:06 | 2024-06-17T14:47:06 | Arjun Subramonian, Vagrant Gautam, Dietrich Klakow, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Recent improvements in natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning
(ML) and increased mainstream adoption have led to researchers frequently
discussing the "democratization" of artificial intelligence. In this paper, we
seek to clarify how democratization is understood in NLP and ML publications,
through large-scale mixed-methods analyses of papers using the keyword
"democra*" published in NLP and adjacent venues. We find that democratization
is most frequently used to convey (ease of) access to or use of technologies,
without meaningfully engaging with theories of democratization, while research
using other invocations of "democra*" tends to be grounded in theories of
deliberation and debate. Based on our findings, we call for researchers to
enrich their use of the term democratization with appropriate theory, towards
democratic technologies beyond superficial access. | [
0.025962498,
0.094420895,
-0.0324220136,
-0.0392956808,
-0.0494617373,
-0.0013150384,
0.028354777,
-0.0281736664,
0.0111156134,
-0.0519478396,
0.0350212529,
0.0596547201,
0.0336925797,
0.0337347686,
-0.0321517102,
-0.0554631576,
-0.0061280509,
0.03608156,
0.0001531064,
0.0038927065,
-0.0110418545,
-0.0129294032,
0.0094250301,
0.0559382588,
0.0254771281,
-0.0152849127,
0.0035745599,
-0.023710411,
-0.0173778068,
-0.0043419292,
-0.0004716092,
0.0212033093,
0.0044945912,
0.0156820938,
0.0000018989,
-0.0322224312,
0.0000016097,
0.0430740044,
-0.0263808873,
0.0082434351,
0.0565540232,
0.0088167926,
0.002901583,
-0.0033463549,
-0.0486671478,
-0.0095757367,
0.0350787491,
-0.0363259017,
-0.0100302519,
0.0221033171,
0.0145714711,
-0.0297162961,
0.0195614807,
0.018160928,
-0.0477163494,
0.0322046913,
-0.0005563405,
-0.0019482143,
0.0172051452,
0.0113402149,
0.0030335605,
0.0245950092,
0.0310360827,
0.0354035459,
0.0157176349,
0.0017781263,
0.0431514457,
-0.0447852127,
0.0177991427,
0.0437192954,
0.0866335332,
0.0162133481,
0.0286168195,
0.014109171,
0.0215393603,
0.0310345385,
-0.0426066592,
0.0387869775,
-0.0135259088,
-0.0189606193,
0.0053635584,
-0.0160104427,
0.0327952653,
0.0449934602,
-0.0113557493,
0.0949627832,
-0.0336386487,
-0.0089676706,
0.038748879,
-0.0059635835,
0.0575063042,
-0.0023064273,
0.0076261088,
-0.0038562894,
0.0351875052,
0.0090501159,
-0.0254649017,
-0.0382404849,
0.031097291,
-0.0129662063,
0.0196281169,
-0.0334920511,
0.0262734313,
0.0149408933,
0.073906675,
-0.0469813496,
-0.0528446585,
0.0752077326,
-0.0109442221,
0.0333422422,
-0.0448481664,
0.0099423165,
0.0107286442,
0.001437966,
-0.0357437618,
0.0098126158,
0.023340812,
0.0109231286,
-0.0323350765,
-0.0201327056,
-0.0749934241,
0.0397740752,
0.0143958265,
0.0224314407,
-0.0625324175,
-0.0019990185,
-0.0356721617,
0.0397597626,
-0.0136868414,
-0.0265435129,
0.0479795262,
0.0123738032,
0.0074459421,
-0.0196708683,
-0.0007331318,
0.04674403,
0.0167352967,
-0.029123066,
-0.0123505993,
-0.0326363333,
0.0160627272,
-0.0357937366,
0.0194121245,
-0.0444472618,
-0.017795518,
0.0430199765,
0.001534144,
-0.0681547076,
-0.009927284,
0.0239696521,
-0.0274329949,
0.0627829805,
-0.0757609829,
-0.0181491431,
0.0770045742,
0.0336375535,
-0.0272205267,
0.0412011482,
0.0154428966,
-0.0060503674,
0.0413750708,
0.0233142506,
0.0663050041,
0.0007958339,
-0.0445000008,
0.0004817852,
-0.0091689527,
0.0243050288,
-0.0555584505,
-0.0308901165,
0.0117511004,
0.0566889867,
-0.028862901,
0.0500714779,
0.0479553007,
0.0602006875,
-0.0235544071,
-0.0258504134,
-0.0163178779,
0.0201152004,
0.0083718617,
0.0089818304,
-0.0224281456,
-0.0231559612,
0.002348731,
-0.043503087,
-0.0092229974,
0.0381097943,
-0.0054060635,
-0.0704388693,
0.0193107016,
-0.0356316008,
0.0958530828,
-0.008497552,
0.021637395,
-0.0030392532,
0.0418333039,
0.0032677245,
-0.0066414783,
0.0233885739,
-0.0166638866,
-0.0791802853,
-0.0210127886,
0.0082362974,
0.0311753172,
-0.0069065941,
0.051720202,
-0.0524553917,
0.0176812913,
0.0282141771,
-0.0057992633,
-0.0114175081,
-0.0664237067,
0.0135188708,
-0.0242550522,
-0.0212646984,
0.01090327,
0.0115750432,
-0.0151598109,
0.0296540037,
-0.0476414636,
-0.0362582356,
-0.0469546244,
0.0255286526,
0.0421197675,
-0.0229119137,
-0.0242345799,
0.0459355265,
0.0208635703,
0.0411390327,
-0.0160288792,
0.0130199026,
0.0318606906,
-0.0121339448,
-0.0405560061,
-0.0007595317,
0.0503946356,
0.0623293854,
0.012968109,
-0.0356837288,
-0.0048629423,
0.0439511575,
0.0177649111,
0.0018684461,
0.0631500408,
-0.0202942751,
0.0068926057,
0.0081150169,
0.0007346313,
-0.0320421159,
-0.0046679666,
-0.0727642253,
0.0171360709,
-0.0373969823,
-0.0131193679,
0.0098623578,
-0.0096620917,
0.0358817168,
0.0774653628,
-0.0081898766,
0.0861263946,
-0.0038439876,
0.0500697605,
0.0432852991,
-0.0532489792,
-0.0101021128,
0.0100627868,
0.0295250881,
-0.0440975912,
-0.025529094,
0.0085235098,
0.0053268922,
-0.0199301988,
0.0114095239,
0.0057182065,
-0.0037714287,
-0.0095858648,
-0.0320760086,
0.0197537709,
0.0486081503,
0.0296291746,
-0.0306575652,
-0.0037041723,
-0.0128505034,
0.02159792,
0.0158678293,
-0.0006081421,
-0.0225639958,
-0.0018662756,
-0.063473098,
-0.0078965006,
-0.0279153734,
-0.0236739032,
0.0273928717,
0.0378841795,
0.0621729679,
-0.0422436334,
0.0390276685,
-0.0083506471,
0.0691512004,
0.0551206693,
0.0627522841,
-0.0398049727,
-0.0280857719,
0.0135473525,
-0.0052000098,
0.0047892141,
-0.0239892621,
0.0601491295,
-0.0037031125,
-0.0025384061,
0.0101138391,
0.0044677244,
0.0795284435,
-0.0801671445,
-0.0600310005,
-0.0318978019,
-0.054729823,
-0.0233319234,
0.0493764207,
-0.0027454628,
-0.043877434,
0.0220779497,
0.0044010109,
0.0202158038,
-0.0587433539,
-0.0600398965,
-0.0076776454,
0.0577548109,
-0.0005268702,
0.0343161896,
0.0509586297,
-0.0346503109,
-0.0162285063,
-0.0177032594,
0.0489141643,
-0.0788213313,
0.0778825581,
-0.0371302962,
-0.0005379919,
-0.0057840594,
-0.0353863128,
0.000907293,
-0.0181914866,
0.0018547199,
0.0273368191,
0.0607847124,
-0.0201106258,
-0.0789658353,
-0.0234111995,
0.0459687822,
0.0040519992,
0.054048758,
-0.0240136087,
-0.0108917588,
-0.0019003181,
0.0052058357,
-0.0022595276,
0.0471623242,
0.0383931026,
-0.017625222,
0.067441918,
0.0547787659,
0.0116788931,
-0.010018643,
-0.0346782431,
0.0046654814,
-0.0613134578,
0.0081597036,
-0.0149684921,
0.024787927,
-0.0180559568,
0.0391566381,
-0.0011305129,
-0.0109757446,
-0.0696419552,
-0.0123995207,
0.0085500525,
-0.0133804977,
0.0375011005,
-0.0139757451,
-0.1001346931,
0.042016279,
0.0255416017,
0.061936345,
-0.0582722314,
-0.0285307076,
-0.0171060972,
-0.0872881785,
0.0145205306,
-0.0207692217,
-0.0086784335,
-0.0047300234,
-0.0495779999,
0.0215449389,
-0.0282946415,
0.0725582242,
-0.0275527425,
0.0067670112,
0.0266689751,
0.0264947005,
-0.0812024921,
-0.057798516,
-0.0283866562,
-0.0342139304,
0.0372959152,
0.0541156307,
0.027801754,
-0.0395483151,
0.0247747228,
0.0245159902,
0.0116392998,
-0.0098849395,
0.0161686894,
0.0259197764,
-0.0361499973,
0.0222102813,
-0.000712525,
0.0012255567,
-0.0014126274,
-0.0212891232,
0.0214141496,
0.0145265702,
0.003698119,
-0.0367992222,
-0.0456074104,
-0.0712796673,
0.0274648983,
0.0093388222,
0.0086592445,
-0.0351864211,
-0.0079448968,
-0.0339109711,
-0.0038034292,
0.0898426324,
-0.0802543163,
0.0111897448,
-0.0024941536,
-0.01859219,
-0.0239383895,
-0.072822623,
0.0101758502,
0.0496993139,
0.0405270383,
0.0293326993,
0.0310098436,
-0.0311151631,
-0.0492489561,
0.0069890567,
0.0147325611,
-0.0131895561,
-0.0020500717,
-0.0717624649,
-0.0466828197,
0.0561034605,
-0.0091453101,
-0.0152271762,
0.0591637306,
-0.037757013,
0.0129685774,
0.0144959893,
0.0338522233,
-0.0306238905,
-0.0028241703,
-0.0405682996,
0.0370996892,
0.0850115269,
0.0081550628,
0.0179158449,
0.0280432347,
-0.0063900743,
-0.0115715051,
-0.0050316062,
0.0197399221,
-0.0340525135,
0.0051828125,
-0.0399010293,
-0.0290484037,
-0.0031066006,
0.0153504414,
-0.0012998536,
0.0484145135,
-0.028744759,
-0.0057122307,
-0.003278841,
-0.068168737,
0.0316798761,
-0.0227260645,
-0.011476906,
-0.0368408896,
0.01663596,
0.0111113871,
-0.0328799225,
0.0438158289,
-0.0085801128,
0.0230085161,
-0.0396674164,
0.0521499254,
0.0160659999,
0.0322520733,
0.0159586128,
-0.00669281,
-0.0134097068,
0.0245671347,
-0.029126063,
0.0359476879,
0.0192793757,
-0.0059059719,
0.006127602,
0.0145289376,
0.0226451643,
0.0214799009,
-0.0472160988,
-0.0983446538,
0.0376348309,
0.0494862758,
-0.0219923202,
-0.0046726717,
0.0060533751,
0.0413660593,
-0.0094880713,
-0.0115179634,
-0.0420535617,
0.0275643207,
0.0108161978,
0.0195013154,
0.0060712085,
-0.0462249331,
0.0101621002,
0.0122984909,
-0.0063556614,
0.0394544601,
-0.0282743834,
0.0131595908,
-0.0103581045,
-0.0843142867,
-0.0047038053,
0.0246245898,
-0.0117840143,
-0.0633403063,
-0.0513252169,
-0.0261120014,
-0.0170432441,
-0.0100630326,
0.0077490383,
-0.0404425003,
-0.0229283795,
0.0588113554,
0.0282405913,
-0.0405755267,
-0.035916131,
0.0316028707,
-0.1001404971,
-0.0201285481,
0.0477063805,
-5.757445332e-33,
0.0228736885,
-0.062250711,
0.0175400078,
-0.0577436388,
-0.0142157618,
0.0203196518,
0.044543054,
0.0439276323,
-0.0474131294,
0.0179328136,
-0.0281878915,
-0.0113054952,
0.0033880065,
-0.0214524865,
0.0269429889,
0.0030084767,
0.006586384,
-0.0347970054,
-0.0183259696,
-0.005679871,
-0.0138630774,
-0.0099490872,
-0.028498942,
-0.0796669647,
0.0826994777,
0.0385892726,
-0.0208759606,
-0.0403180458,
0.0102743423,
0.0329331718,
-0.0064345901,
0.0422786102,
0.009333971,
-0.0464164689,
-0.0183101669,
0.0951717049,
-0.0424029492,
0.0475448444,
0.0132718496,
0.0232297909,
0.0015536847,
-0.0008501213,
0.049799595,
-0.0186353195,
-0.0276523251,
0.0398129858,
0.0463937148,
-0.057816457,
-0.0382686071,
-0.0428089499,
-0.0325676873,
-0.0036509305,
-0.0413182266,
0.0490775444,
-0.0053103054,
0.0458957776,
-0.0012120677,
-0.0192312114,
-0.0967575833,
0.0085731409,
-0.0116750514,
-0.0160160027,
0.0476435311,
-0.0075207357,
0.0287280455,
0.0620620251,
0.0567366891,
0.0305885747,
-0.0626215786,
-0.0361830033,
0.0307956338,
0.0467421152,
-0.010751727,
0.0395880714,
0.0229606349,
-0.0362850316,
-0.0342920087,
-0.0048724758,
-0.0017454667,
-0.0274360888,
0.0354264304,
-0.0208148081,
-0.0878073946,
-0.0431063697,
-0.0410735682,
-0.0217806026,
-0.0080676479,
-0.0248906165,
-0.0181223843,
0.0166942365,
-0.0536493324,
-0.0072652386,
-0.0017802001,
-0.0702330545,
-0.0611344613,
0.0130745256,
-0.0042467071,
0.0092366347,
0.0057902718,
-0.034469679,
-0.0626556128,
-0.0273890123,
-0.0774429664,
0.0631812513,
0.0359473377,
0.0033806679,
-0.0136302682,
-0.0076502096,
-0.0490873642,
-0.0319296159,
0.0000129907,
0.0249941349,
0.0238884538,
0.0116104269,
0.0711430907,
0.0035025307,
0.0381169394,
-0.0033528388,
0.0274984688,
0.033692129,
-0.015237649,
0.0317155607,
-0.0790464953,
-0.0191121027,
-0.0132859116,
-0.0044625117,
-0.0465998761,
0.0532414429,
0.0649598166,
-0.0165239461,
0.0006211686,
-0.0694726035,
2.536e-7,
0.0343637429,
0.0315891914,
-0.0358967073,
-0.014939527,
0.000566136,
0.0342525467,
0.0414917506,
0.0189836398,
-0.0438825265,
-0.0819369704,
-0.006253663,
0.0305278264,
-0.0057632634,
0.0184282362,
-0.0450705104,
-0.0379030369,
-0.006252062,
0.0603112988,
-0.0645850375,
0.0350171253,
-0.0040545235,
-0.0167845357,
-0.015197196,
-0.0003549782,
-0.0639295876,
-0.0445342138,
0.001556645,
-0.0494811498,
0.0242253989,
0.0090010623,
0.072250925,
0.0360785984,
0.028855931,
-0.0005576311,
0.0323866159,
-0.0052388152,
-0.0137026506,
0.0527583733,
0.0386759862,
0.0067510982,
0.0083934702,
-0.0641326383,
0.0052977805,
0.0237099957,
0.0875689536,
-0.0202079955,
-0.0506790727,
-0.0851173475,
-0.0179631077,
-0.0329829529,
0.0920235589,
-0.0021245342,
-0.0141145363,
0.0013546594,
-0.0196149722,
-0.0182016212,
0.0139710559,
-0.0646180287,
0.0165118314,
-0.0170939565,
0.0263084751,
-0.0307613108,
0.0138656665,
0.029221328,
0.0338162817,
0.0361512825,
0.0235339832,
1.940007867e-34,
0.0214265622,
-0.0181491151,
0.0278263856,
0.0082864389,
0.0371414088,
0.0136308288,
0.0703749508,
-0.0591675602,
-0.0100533823,
-0.0379616283,
0.0276396777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11581v1 | Style Transfer with Multi-iteration Preference Optimization | 2024-06-17T14:20:53 | 2024-06-17T14:20:53 | Shuai Liu, Jonathan May | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous recent techniques for text style transfer characterize their
approaches as variants of reinforcement learning and preference optimization.
In this work, we consider the relationship between these approaches and a class
of optimization approaches developed primarily for (non-neural) statistical
machine translation, formerly known as 'tuning'. Inspired by these techniques
from the past, we improve upon established preference optimization approaches,
incorporating multiple iterations of exploration and optimization, and choosing
contrastive examples by following a 'hope' vs 'fear' sampling strategy.
Cognizant of the difference between machine translation and style transfer,
however, we further tailor our framework with a new pseudo-parallel generation
method and a dynamic weighted reward aggregation method to tackle the lack of
parallel data and the need for a multi-objective reward. We evaluate our model
on two commonly used text style transfer datasets. Through automatic and human
evaluation results we show the effectiveness and the superiority of our model
compared to state-of-the-art baselines. | [
0.0393171199,
0.0743969008,
-0.0081856726,
-0.0088114021,
-0.025948463,
0.0211200677,
-0.0173489209,
0.013679143,
-0.0630847067,
-0.0041922918,
-0.0635217875,
-0.0384274758,
0.016209811,
-0.0479343459,
0.0302248802,
-0.0977185518,
-0.0268857721,
-0.010548125,
0.0158789884,
-0.0160049405,
0.0639071092,
0.0367891006,
0.0023938755,
-0.0030845418,
0.0162696671,
0.0063244323,
0.0149005791,
0.0582370535,
0.0679680035,
0.0023785864,
0.0097559728,
0.0166350864,
0.0015169122,
0.008130556,
0.0000019598,
-0.0275831744,
-0.0313860774,
-0.016616622,
0.0964099169,
-0.0249338225,
0.1097545847,
-0.031560123,
-0.0245822631,
-0.002602601,
0.000868441,
0.000293355,
0.0800218284,
0.0317942463,
0.0563911647,
0.0858324319,
-0.0336188339,
-0.046051275,
-0.0287808795,
-0.0573209636,
0.0023843171,
-0.0069305403,
0.0143402424,
-0.040495418,
-0.020397678,
0.0055471803,
-0.0018030335,
0.0278866161,
-0.0187361315,
-0.0262986496,
-0.0087559056,
-0.0113007938,
-0.0083605601,
0.0263287351,
-0.0223095585,
0.0699610859,
-0.0421796627,
0.0146013293,
0.0198819172,
-0.0277585313,
0.0017530727,
0.0159125403,
-0.0715992302,
0.0054363338,
-0.011801756,
0.0330529734,
0.0038714153,
0.0379662327,
-0.0103998892,
-0.0297365244,
-0.0259097088,
-0.0264913067,
0.0073160105,
-0.0298312213,
0.0300860591,
0.0306417607,
-0.0359964482,
-0.036399398,
0.0629304871,
-0.0290460438,
-0.0290834662,
0.0180309117,
-0.0737834498,
-0.0658934042,
-0.0077660806,
-0.0186974797,
0.1031856686,
0.0247659478,
0.0241714735,
0.0160338972,
-0.0156556536,
0.0354624689,
-0.0302380677,
0.0016661369,
-0.0660352036,
0.0212354716,
-0.045750685,
0.0221425649,
-0.01337591,
-0.0102170873,
0.0102370465,
-0.0274157207,
-0.0152089354,
-0.0104375891,
-0.0128641697,
-0.0029007767,
0.0155824795,
0.0022333593,
-0.0710263029,
-0.0066059567,
0.0161109529,
0.0123743182,
0.0120807011,
0.0109551959,
0.0120886052,
0.0285973791,
-0.0311112404,
0.0264554713,
0.0224087965,
-0.0329911821,
-0.0277364012,
0.0533233471,
-0.07445997,
0.0225357879,
-0.0074324263,
-0.0033385162,
-0.0257845633,
-0.0088985302,
0.0092420597,
-0.0612934828,
0.001244131,
-0.0304808579,
0.0143687958,
-0.0280976221,
-0.0095514106,
0.0081097446,
-0.0449073538,
0.0398283526,
0.0575647987,
-0.0110471109,
0.0076517635,
-0.0162119307,
-0.0061040069,
0.0499599613,
0.0434402712,
0.1040944159,
0.0000438197,
0.0047476469,
-0.0327118784,
0.0590295121,
0.0406910442,
0.063005887,
-0.0539472215,
-0.0577613898,
0.0172777418,
0.0518494584,
0.055707071,
0.0523762852,
-0.0227168985,
-0.0013547082,
0.0878947452,
-0.0034424462,
0.0552360862,
-0.0010209257,
0.037511196,
0.0181079786,
-0.0142719084,
0.040318504,
0.0205534399,
0.0408425033,
-0.0006972882,
0.0275175907,
0.0413255915,
0.0487230755,
-0.0118006757,
-0.0072485805,
0.0230712462,
0.0120785711,
-0.0048330626,
-0.0138230035,
0.0185750909,
0.0642171726,
-0.0751301348,
-0.0793490857,
0.0024227772,
-0.038570378,
0.015209537,
-0.0090530943,
0.0146553246,
0.1162313893,
0.0450277142,
0.0120020397,
0.012588894,
-0.0066508674,
-0.0035422118,
0.0351996496,
0.0415415205,
-0.0257962681,
0.022803979,
-0.0624026805,
-0.0143676884,
0.0002090259,
-0.0171758458,
0.0513897724,
-0.0287995655,
0.0433023386,
-0.0139415078,
0.0281638335,
-0.0551383831,
0.0320602804,
0.0020269989,
-0.0306430385,
0.0563836806,
0.0079000136,
0.001454481,
-0.0224980805,
-0.0501261503,
-0.013467011,
-0.0457941703,
-0.0457777865,
-0.0177948158,
0.0282561816,
-0.0389126092,
-0.0651065335,
-0.0289497152,
-0.0652355701,
0.020297695,
0.0213139076,
-0.0537821874,
-0.056018386,
-0.0129607031,
-0.018328039,
0.0335611328,
-0.0022336836,
0.0239637978,
0.0301113427,
0.01582711,
-0.0738377944,
0.0142275458,
0.0016227515,
-0.0323662683,
0.001864239,
-0.0111163128,
-0.0164611358,
-0.0471192636,
0.0198691729,
-0.0066187633,
0.0253437608,
0.010678187,
0.0251175128,
0.0429912731,
-0.044562079,
-0.0681742951,
-0.0290021785,
0.0244132057,
-0.0091193235,
0.03636178,
0.0253240187,
0.0233346839,
-0.0124566685,
-0.0029230781,
-0.0473621003,
0.0267176013,
-0.0363302417,
0.0207228214,
0.0352356099,
0.008731259,
0.017190598,
-0.0367967188,
-0.0287639778,
0.0261367466,
0.029736191,
0.026834989,
0.0334142856,
-0.0601714812,
0.0344529822,
-0.0251380391,
-0.0391507223,
0.0234153606,
-0.032223817,
-0.0088397861,
-0.0445252545,
0.0474210382,
0.076616697,
0.052381698,
-0.014569818,
-0.0053472412,
-0.0103072142,
-0.0402773954,
0.0003229186,
-0.0372555554,
0.0049484586,
0.0147861047,
-0.0458669215,
0.0443528444,
0.039724309,
0.0375969,
-0.0034435298,
-0.0627193078,
0.0232134555,
0.0426281802,
-0.0406370088,
0.0147573631,
0.0379088037,
0.0145584596,
0.0120227328,
-0.0263297036,
-0.0308764223,
0.0803668499,
0.0007522864,
0.0074503208,
-0.0232955292,
0.003984408,
-0.0202297866,
0.0051259715,
-0.0099908328,
0.02519246,
0.0104604894,
-0.0095553501,
-0.0481764041,
-0.0245871376,
0.0584439784,
0.0008569317,
0.021923447,
-0.0391624756,
-0.0084624728,
-0.0292749237,
-0.0271594115,
-0.0166162048,
-0.0187652688,
0.0125067243,
-0.0384590738,
0.0728755221,
-0.0465130694,
-0.0036822751,
0.0029683262,
0.0028215833,
0.076825358,
-0.0327352434,
-0.0413450226,
-0.0031012534,
0.0453748181,
0.0314749889,
-0.0300758537,
-0.013976275,
-0.0540897623,
-0.0242675189,
0.0138118397,
0.0316621289,
0.0095705343,
-0.021634778,
0.0034755776,
0.0377025045,
-0.0197383761,
-0.0210375134,
-0.0156335887,
0.031992618,
-0.0262770988,
-0.0090637701,
0.0781644806,
0.02767835,
-0.0545440614,
-0.0332370289,
0.0074974406,
0.0724618435,
-0.0236507934,
0.05107693,
-0.0519839451,
-0.0150058558,
-0.0203097258,
0.0493476801,
0.0192855317,
-0.0029720187,
-0.0267514512,
-0.0286881514,
0.0127653824,
0.034179125,
-0.0748925731,
0.0274184067,
-0.0168933645,
0.017145833,
-0.0350041464,
-0.0298465639,
-0.0069206329,
0.0076258932,
0.0108213034,
0.0119993323,
0.0358578525,
-0.0249259751,
-0.0102288593,
0.0017291825,
-0.0013452031,
0.1163250059,
0.0386341885,
-0.0015831726,
-0.0635797158,
-0.0243005436,
-0.0088853147,
-0.0090067293,
-0.0408195294,
0.0279648174,
0.0186225511,
-0.002422543,
-0.0105204973,
0.034450952,
0.0089144129,
0.0225578696,
0.0507507473,
-0.0170665029,
-0.0017191347,
-0.0386985987,
-0.0174531098,
-0.013405663,
0.0436585434,
0.0128240045,
0.0293565188,
-0.086005114,
-0.0043330183,
-0.0676061958,
-0.0213245656,
-0.1396705955,
-0.0090983203,
-0.0370738767,
-0.0350366458,
0.0069807395,
-0.1444117725,
0.0170250311,
-0.0204609875,
0.0682645738,
0.0229061171,
-0.032325875,
-0.0152115654,
-0.028271284,
-0.0271624792,
-0.0397457406,
-0.0067307134,
0.0133525645,
-0.0087909847,
-0.0118170734,
0.0202828664,
-0.074337922,
-0.0051278146,
-0.0107926829,
-0.0663159117,
-0.0455362238,
-0.0273875911,
0.0929574817,
0.0060032937,
0.0249977279,
-0.0138238212,
-0.0661855787,
0.0678135082,
0.0601559803,
0.0470031686,
-0.0093021896,
0.0361962058,
0.0118481219,
0.0018161961,
0.0293934979,
0.0038403142,
0.0265340135,
0.0297647584,
0.0278197825,
0.028487429,
-0.027670864,
0.0079726884,
-0.0078769038,
-0.0195965655,
-0.022062026,
-0.0144762015,
-0.0178987011,
0.0122642564,
0.0001969197,
-0.0129199019,
-0.0602800176,
-0.0358280428,
0.0409891084,
0.024075143,
-0.0235873871,
-0.0023388546,
0.0419753343,
-0.0044397218,
-0.058959879,
-0.0012831866,
0.0138632655,
0.0695860833,
0.008303728,
0.0452189222,
0.01753157,
0.0227169972,
0.0191180035,
0.0483012199,
-0.0176022723,
0.0332934111,
0.054729417,
0.0111093801,
0.0093720248,
0.0317048058,
-0.0531465597,
-0.0028429653,
-0.0412409678,
-0.0572532378,
0.033662241,
-0.0204545557,
0.1129020378,
0.0141030597,
0.0000089864,
0.0056572706,
0.0277072769,
-0.0188611727,
-0.0013767631,
-0.0281360261,
0.0081814537,
0.0400698222,
0.0100220293,
0.075335525,
-0.0430285372,
-0.0113372384,
-0.005192948,
-0.0113810534,
-0.0305022318,
0.0007824081,
0.0230392125,
0.0026909627,
0.0409272946,
-0.0454316512,
-0.0007464795,
-0.030959174,
0.0315099172,
-0.0066265725,
0.0300366152,
0.0069654756,
0.0458758026,
0.0434230044,
-0.0508606285,
0.0385229327,
-0.0456946902,
-0.0101792132,
-0.0046490473,
-0.0262891445,
-0.0177328307,
-5.722335152e-33,
-0.0355122276,
-0.0193105061,
-0.0106210308,
-0.0109564066,
-0.0376187153,
-0.0428467244,
-0.0310529303,
-0.0655807108,
0.0272361897,
0.015289519,
-0.0260189753,
-0.042534098,
0.0143126883,
0.0364193954,
0.0371508636,
0.0538233072,
0.0496260896,
0.0136964517,
-0.0724513009,
0.0251755789,
0.043456886,
0.0154444957,
0.0707116723,
-0.056426812,
-0.0077517927,
0.0369890742,
-0.0425974801,
-0.0181400906,
0.0261778962,
0.0233086199,
0.0414826833,
-0.0077047003,
-0.0152482809,
-0.0751480982,
-0.0456322655,
-0.0198763814,
-0.0382680148,
-0.0512900576,
0.0154457968,
0.0036565249,
-0.0224225,
-0.0390335582,
0.0431248471,
-0.0281490367,
0.0237355083,
-0.0080695786,
0.050671827,
-0.0497277789,
-0.0210569203,
-0.0264970604,
-0.0403846763,
-0.0001244446,
-0.0253580231,
-0.025266679,
0.037403401,
0.0104834307,
-0.0047921017,
0.0278632697,
-0.0410801917,
0.0444497764,
-0.0038734023,
0.0227126349,
0.0375670157,
0.057645876,
0.0180564299,
0.0094633298,
0.000097808,
0.0311285201,
0.0011906667,
0.0025600011,
0.0319507606,
0.0065659243,
0.0093057426,
0.0516745113,
0.0181490742,
-0.012452241,
-0.0141041484,
0.0707371011,
0.0190278124,
-0.0206613466,
0.0236821584,
0.0683383793,
0.001576751,
0.0065709818,
-0.0451956503,
-0.0622021556,
-0.0177552886,
-0.0255823173,
-0.0115684485,
0.0329195857,
-0.0428741574,
-0.0011580709,
0.0316980369,
0.0195878018,
-0.0188044533,
-0.0243957173,
-0.0675090775,
0.0458275229,
-0.0400844738,
-0.0476992391,
-0.0339112617,
-0.0160815585,
0.0580831617,
0.0273497347,
-0.008117754,
-0.0036596144,
0.063169688,
0.0435291566,
-0.0590412915,
-0.0072835074,
-0.0119148158,
0.0216607433,
0.007822738,
-0.0154266777,
0.0045625912,
-0.0267857332,
-0.0242828019,
0.0209697336,
0.0642905608,
-0.0403173827,
-0.0223374423,
-0.0232203584,
-0.0034956806,
0.0119839488,
-0.0616061278,
0.0098185735,
-0.006160764,
-0.0284755472,
-0.0067784879,
-0.0515123382,
-0.0526200198,
-0.0034604296,
2.599e-7,
0.0032174923,
0.024956746,
0.0074813692,
0.0165840201,
0.0150818601,
0.0254362375,
-0.0005311057,
0.04966316,
0.0206633676,
0.0453996845,
0.0264859051,
0.0190623887,
0.0651700944,
-0.008146856,
-0.0751574188,
-0.0246994123,
-0.01806641,
0.0481747948,
-0.0178861022,
-0.0568448603,
0.038267076,
0.0333993174,
0.0491775498,
-0.0134693626,
0.0354679227,
0.0427603163,
0.0737790987,
-0.0155999605,
0.0213739648,
-0.0000831964,
0.0028756242,
-0.0353979245,
-0.0808813125,
0.0093925698,
-0.011733342,
-0.0024176829,
0.0405402742,
0.0579796247,
0.0291791689,
0.0119693354,
0.0122668752,
0.0220917612,
0.0310991947,
-0.0314213037,
0.0338072516,
-0.0240284633,
-0.013914736,
-0.0273904353,
-0.0324785039,
-0.0088189347,
0.0256075785,
-0.0268236566,
-0.0234242547,
0.0187264383,
0.0221898407,
0.0736794546,
-0.0301099084,
-0.049648013,
-0.0187078267,
0.0002366676,
0.0047390573,
-0.0158124194,
-0.0246041957,
0.0656995773,
-0.0434096083,
-0.0391775295,
0.0041566761,
2.171483138e-34,
0.0186787099,
-0.0468733534,
0.0043867701,
-0.0236422922,
0.0225680135,
0.0199926868,
-0.0331562012,
0.0018064751,
0.031477239,
-0.0744516775,
-0.0373074561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11580v1 | Error Span Annotation: A Balanced Approach for Human Evaluation of Machine Translation | 2024-06-17T14:20:47 | 2024-06-17T14:20:47 | Tom Kocmi, Vilém Zouhar, Eleftherios Avramidis, Roman Grundkiewicz, Marzena Karpinska, Maja Popović, Mrinmaya Sachan, Mariya Shmatova | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-quality Machine Translation (MT) evaluation relies heavily on human
judgments. Comprehensive error classification methods, such as Multidimensional
Quality Metrics (MQM), are expensive as they are time-consuming and can only be
done by experts, whose availability may be limited especially for low-resource
languages. On the other hand, just assigning overall scores, like Direct
Assessment (DA), is simpler and faster and can be done by translators of any
level, but are less reliable. In this paper, we introduce Error Span Annotation
(ESA), a human evaluation protocol which combines the continuous rating of DA
with the high-level error severity span marking of MQM. We validate ESA by
comparing it to MQM and DA for 12 MT systems and one human reference
translation (English to German) from WMT23. The results show that ESA offers
faster and cheaper annotations than MQM at the same quality level, without the
requirement of expensive MQM experts. | [
0.0126879606,
-0.0234116986,
0.0068397322,
0.0399599411,
0.0067792251,
0.0318883061,
0.0229159966,
-0.0069186892,
-0.0072979014,
-0.0165062714,
-0.0182187706,
-0.0306537561,
0.0538582727,
-0.0273151137,
0.0368848033,
-0.0793115571,
0.0210741498,
0.0071940925,
0.0065075075,
0.0170370601,
0.0215935912,
-0.0081211179,
-0.0136763686,
0.0371243246,
-0.0145022189,
0.0234509502,
0.024320351,
0.0310770348,
0.0803242475,
-0.062296778,
-0.0059987004,
0.0530624129,
-0.0192115214,
0.0677562058,
0.0000019695,
-0.0489739068,
-0.031406004,
0.0417830274,
0.0113293324,
0.0420065597,
0.027673224,
-0.0277473405,
-0.0295251869,
-0.0058514629,
-0.0125975935,
-0.0092634866,
0.0509070009,
0.0021324414,
0.1083640084,
0.0262816865,
-0.0188444518,
0.0004920035,
-0.011773183,
-0.0196085852,
-0.0214507524,
-0.0737427846,
-0.0413803421,
0.0398647822,
-0.0209264383,
0.0012459687,
0.0080263102,
0.0317037813,
0.0235962234,
-0.0147296693,
-0.0018138164,
-0.0220306516,
-0.0323483013,
-0.0344010927,
0.0112749478,
0.0562012047,
0.0085470714,
0.0197316501,
-0.0370194614,
-0.0135848522,
0.0083208149,
-0.0321796872,
0.0015595643,
0.0051284661,
-0.0024007368,
-0.0059882589,
-0.0184115916,
0.0669882819,
0.0125029944,
-0.0119796284,
-0.0245112441,
0.0028446023,
-0.005595257,
-0.0355930477,
0.0030714921,
0.0499325916,
-0.0195925273,
-0.0027646136,
0.0523146242,
-0.0322450586,
-0.0285535436,
-0.0115856044,
-0.0311350059,
-0.0723850876,
0.0341929682,
-0.0593487024,
0.0285496581,
0.0325803198,
-0.0227107089,
0.0266020242,
-0.0180382747,
0.0759143382,
0.0093787098,
0.0036830772,
-0.0444814265,
-0.0031277228,
-0.0051555918,
0.0505190492,
-0.0278324671,
-0.0268322527,
-0.0386248082,
0.0317944437,
-0.088764593,
0.0069053345,
-0.0210460611,
0.0381119475,
0.0050575985,
-0.032721322,
-0.015224807,
0.004528787,
0.0024254411,
0.0261479821,
-0.0350245461,
-0.01141054,
-0.0045975479,
-0.0408345014,
0.0044107004,
0.0438283756,
-0.0155022144,
-0.0031487579,
-0.0038430069,
0.0710899234,
0.0115170125,
-0.0306657627,
0.0308577083,
-0.0116158649,
-0.0229513291,
-0.0262370743,
-0.021043634,
-0.0498702079,
0.0364662409,
0.0078263171,
0.025196882,
0.0088281799,
0.0089511788,
-0.0123344986,
0.0149693238,
0.0429867506,
-0.0390040465,
-0.0188941639,
0.0074141803,
-0.002426564,
-0.0285540055,
0.0233467836,
0.0663420558,
0.0212833975,
0.0287600644,
0.0201609656,
0.01005466,
0.0322682858,
-0.0193916988,
0.0017493378,
-0.0138258161,
-0.0129221501,
-0.0256237704,
0.0296823103,
0.0285296757,
0.0680865943,
-0.0346837603,
0.0496473648,
0.0297534913,
0.0322588496,
0.0075893877,
0.0181829594,
0.0299769696,
0.0002124518,
0.0094522843,
-0.007179338,
-0.0155954761,
0.0187101271,
-0.0029956417,
-0.0117089674,
0.0709327459,
0.0069354628,
0.0216615573,
-0.0740064904,
-0.022689065,
-0.0167684797,
0.0226796698,
-0.0456398055,
0.0270867627,
-0.0179849677,
-0.0304985419,
0.0420655645,
-0.0401330963,
-0.0791082829,
0.0145716509,
-0.0135494862,
-0.036078535,
0.0930846259,
0.0319119543,
0.0071216063,
0.0090501551,
-0.0000898283,
0.0142371515,
0.0284927376,
0.0669530481,
0.0065993429,
-0.0111866174,
-0.038089443,
-0.0316053666,
0.0527756885,
0.0060042432,
0.0272080284,
-0.0136426575,
0.0124613736,
0.0035300602,
-0.0536759682,
-0.1215995923,
0.0102352481,
0.0700965151,
-0.0015289274,
0.0129212039,
0.0121296933,
0.0437242649,
0.0702147111,
-0.0326261446,
-0.0025458892,
0.0084276423,
-0.0160548892,
-0.0459501259,
0.0293623414,
-0.0059281085,
0.0013508353,
0.0118323779,
-0.07800401,
-0.0507649183,
0.0092289383,
-0.0437114276,
-0.028186135,
-0.0620269291,
-0.0772536546,
-0.0391540565,
-0.040816348,
0.0293040294,
-0.0154939797,
-0.0206089355,
-0.0578889251,
0.0183183774,
-0.0036849249,
0.025973253,
-0.013293053,
-0.0143518196,
0.0329117924,
-0.0193152688,
-0.0747638717,
0.0319701917,
0.0158402845,
0.0607024245,
0.0340517201,
0.0337038338,
-0.0382400639,
-0.0196526367,
-0.0537502393,
-0.0143557023,
-0.0113849351,
0.0446616262,
0.0268420484,
-0.0166289117,
0.0206457041,
-0.015133529,
0.0076365792,
-0.0160842389,
0.0242715236,
-0.0094112251,
0.0435187854,
-0.0009332633,
0.0266243052,
-0.0250051264,
0.0129098548,
0.0223208927,
0.0215642191,
0.0690596253,
-0.016643418,
-0.0891819447,
0.0195470192,
-0.0303835217,
-0.0268897116,
0.0645965561,
-0.073902227,
0.0173775163,
0.0218601767,
-0.0373884588,
0.0107965963,
-0.0003248877,
0.0049991277,
0.0231579691,
0.0162948966,
-0.0234849826,
-0.0064840275,
0.0037631975,
-0.0250488073,
0.0020352784,
-0.0508792959,
0.0205321833,
-0.0176389292,
0.0024512422,
0.0194789805,
-0.062158104,
-0.0276354253,
-0.0400289111,
-0.0233830232,
-0.0027829239,
-0.0032491363,
-0.0043586218,
0.0604582727,
0.015433332,
-0.0448420681,
0.0652379915,
-0.0433600545,
-0.0208892245,
-0.0457153246,
0.0428056084,
-0.0073943036,
0.0157175343,
-0.0441831648,
0.0195149872,
-0.0676338077,
-0.0177282859,
0.0202428922,
0.0213816874,
0.0635739416,
-0.0397711657,
0.0052121379,
-0.0836643875,
-0.0134291854,
-0.0147969164,
0.0074147382,
-0.0030589339,
0.0236578099,
-0.0366863608,
-0.0156604201,
0.0014930587,
-0.0197706576,
-0.0163694806,
0.0350354463,
0.0481730998,
0.0509447902,
0.0057417639,
-0.0142069003,
0.005268144,
-0.0031768784,
-0.0691107437,
0.0328231789,
0.0330400467,
-0.0411698148,
0.0237478297,
0.0452999435,
-0.0225819517,
0.0296821054,
-0.0088337259,
-0.0170493294,
0.0499417074,
0.0068493686,
-0.0367563181,
0.0055595771,
0.0405541509,
-0.0662479699,
0.0106461383,
0.1006975025,
0.0243932065,
-0.0407067463,
-0.0170304272,
-0.0182194132,
0.007726321,
0.0182128288,
0.0049014711,
-0.0822513252,
-0.0016639694,
0.0056611397,
0.0810361207,
0.0236039795,
0.0112652658,
0.0158080421,
-0.0675665885,
0.0296732839,
0.0486995354,
-0.0786171854,
-0.042529013,
-0.0168303289,
-0.0210976563,
-0.0214950051,
0.0315007642,
-0.0074442592,
0.0557847619,
0.0013576032,
0.0373512767,
-0.0294169765,
-0.0904365107,
0.0103580337,
-0.0439951085,
0.0516182408,
0.0771163255,
0.0368084051,
-0.0168191195,
-0.0537414141,
0.0126676066,
-0.0295050144,
-0.008062345,
-0.0140510676,
0.0486214161,
0.016903881,
-0.0159307271,
-0.0012926526,
-0.0281313919,
0.0061477618,
-0.0018756147,
-0.0124476068,
0.0577809848,
-0.0014477562,
0.0475709513,
0.0370546132,
-0.0204655938,
-0.0114634819,
0.018214494,
0.018559806,
-0.05143876,
-0.0116639268,
-0.0248350222,
-0.0057304301,
-0.0917798281,
-0.0076094707,
0.0417351648,
-0.0722938254,
-0.0737775043,
-0.0837784484,
-0.0494867004,
0.0014839778,
0.0514973477,
-0.0086506363,
-0.0283534378,
0.0002592888,
0.0284931976,
-0.0105444631,
0.0114026535,
0.0123089878,
0.0271899235,
-0.0373621844,
0.0357027911,
-0.0300771613,
0.0231287032,
-0.0075718504,
0.026302252,
0.0117740184,
-0.0412193462,
-0.007005393,
0.057514783,
0.0181063954,
-0.0050739185,
-0.0499924682,
-0.061221052,
0.0046954546,
0.0013038251,
-0.0010903637,
-0.0016747782,
0.0409359746,
0.0159770921,
-0.0287704021,
0.0077313553,
-0.0347290561,
-0.0046375399,
-0.0323324278,
0.0340492353,
-0.0000924449,
-0.0571200103,
-0.0020608294,
0.0436970741,
0.0243131295,
-0.0768953934,
-0.0573803112,
-0.0011574426,
-0.0069898642,
-0.0118338363,
-0.0389023982,
-0.0340484791,
0.0061828517,
0.0136087881,
-0.0467851199,
-0.006288765,
0.0194950812,
-0.0275576208,
-0.0324425027,
0.0019820065,
0.0298771318,
0.002432361,
0.0435135439,
-0.0223946404,
0.0294854473,
-0.0320038721,
-0.0396804512,
0.0131216114,
0.0097088283,
-0.0202233605,
0.0227695666,
0.005517412,
0.0160402898,
0.067833975,
0.0558116734,
-0.0027985536,
0.0340966396,
-0.044753965,
0.0135451378,
0.0899475962,
0.0508916192,
0.1550020278,
0.0024813705,
-0.0081965607,
-0.0221594274,
0.0472721346,
-0.0040118829,
-0.0068775164,
-0.0284510553,
-0.0048255352,
0.0104396325,
0.0084960507,
0.0030771026,
-0.0479351059,
-0.0240731332,
-0.0694622472,
-0.047925543,
-0.0394102596,
0.0015999372,
-0.0507317856,
-0.0474344119,
-0.0207632948,
-0.0446522981,
-0.0576250218,
-0.0404089354,
0.0139145935,
0.0705201626,
0.0346516743,
-0.006195616,
0.0058616549,
0.0682534352,
-0.0281034298,
0.0157071389,
-0.0234084688,
-0.0384010263,
0.0092536416,
-0.0092953155,
-0.0386907272,
-5.744221755e-33,
-0.0384001173,
-0.0812296942,
-0.0364610031,
-0.0591336265,
-0.0159633532,
0.0044235149,
-0.0209853426,
0.0168671831,
0.0530102961,
0.0323321633,
0.0342270508,
-0.0362494253,
0.0304173157,
-0.0396487713,
0.0389540419,
0.0162903424,
0.0315121375,
0.0101507334,
-0.0596893057,
-0.0019157344,
0.0290684532,
-0.0274729878,
0.0796683729,
-0.0744178072,
0.0939360037,
-0.0166598763,
-0.0642869249,
0.0097343009,
0.0456079282,
0.0397905223,
0.0313872471,
0.0237662233,
0.0279396493,
-0.0164935999,
-0.0121388016,
-0.0253698248,
-0.0617457405,
0.0049124681,
0.0074676825,
0.0622846968,
-0.0380638726,
-0.0000473945,
0.0279913507,
-0.0514770038,
-0.0542575531,
0.0168344248,
0.0258634109,
-0.0535044149,
-0.0015051462,
-0.0346312188,
-0.019106593,
0.0530529246,
-0.0196154397,
-0.0045036133,
0.0135510126,
0.074663192,
-0.0305669084,
-0.0246374477,
-0.0778993964,
0.008216016,
-0.0213222075,
-0.0280041024,
0.0580183342,
-0.0334267467,
-0.0442053713,
-0.0036233079,
0.0083492184,
-0.0213664882,
0.0578580052,
-0.0090191718,
0.026697563,
-0.024135191,
0.0986507609,
0.0692869648,
0.0074468418,
-0.0003786963,
-0.0355137438,
0.0817732364,
-0.0438625626,
0.0163358469,
-0.0025322705,
-0.0013124553,
-0.0476180688,
-0.0069253785,
-0.052116394,
-0.0328507908,
-0.0318942741,
-0.0359071642,
0.0053333589,
-0.008908961,
-0.0252823345,
-0.0083513493,
0.0645355135,
0.016036056,
0.0100917201,
-0.0338599533,
-0.0113326125,
0.0455465801,
-0.0184679255,
0.0105468528,
0.0340907015,
0.0004327037,
0.0042006918,
0.0467233434,
0.039125219,
-0.0503075346,
0.0581138134,
0.0193788037,
-0.0484530218,
0.045110248,
-0.0056860391,
-0.020532025,
-0.024507463,
0.0039311652,
0.0129717784,
-0.0448498689,
-0.0143618966,
0.0343783759,
-0.0141865984,
0.0368628502,
-0.051086124,
0.0123820528,
0.0165624786,
0.0147418734,
-0.0462043136,
0.0308694597,
0.0231242888,
0.0056253979,
0.0191813577,
-0.0111203874,
-0.0235221684,
-0.0270203855,
2.616e-7,
0.0540059768,
0.0728961825,
0.0194917358,
-0.0049724504,
0.0018901548,
0.0195657779,
-0.0195354726,
0.0113438964,
-0.0119305793,
0.0669828355,
0.0334672444,
-0.0293784793,
0.0804672539,
0.0795793533,
-0.0250299647,
-0.0633010045,
-0.0335444361,
0.0302436296,
-0.0063377935,
0.0190699622,
0.1122173667,
0.0383982472,
-0.005076481,
0.0121962968,
-0.0101221157,
-0.0301977675,
0.0490367226,
0.0127119273,
-0.0049131103,
-0.0129372217,
0.0787138864,
0.0223145224,
-0.0178930033,
0.0200846717,
-0.0151550323,
-0.0252760686,
0.0533978492,
0.0617396384,
0.0020526461,
-0.0245139804,
0.0188592374,
-0.005651969,
0.0084571335,
-0.0167688075,
0.0036273799,
-0.0168786738,
-0.0163818151,
0.0470570624,
-0.0125660142,
-0.0064536659,
0.0715268701,
-0.010746222,
-0.0298034754,
0.0258343555,
0.0385964811,
0.0081284055,
-0.0266703963,
-0.0289493296,
-0.0310235862,
0.0105902087,
0.0128109409,
-0.0727388039,
0.0182767455,
-0.0014848405,
-0.0055222157,
-0.0184677187,
-0.0010033321,
2.101279493e-34,
0.0626056492,
-0.0476527885,
0.0195949245,
-0.0288147405,
0.040933717,
0.0309209339,
-0.0264920462,
-0.0208966769,
0.0126808453,
-0.0030800197,
-0.0055735088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11577v1 | Mathematical Entities: Corpora and Benchmarks | 2024-06-17T14:11:00 | 2024-06-17T14:11:00 | Jacob Collard, Valeria de Paiva, Eswaran Subrahmanian | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.HO | Mathematics is a highly specialized domain with its own unique set of
challenges. Despite this, there has been relatively little research on natural
language processing for mathematical texts, and there are few mathematical
language resources aimed at NLP. In this paper, we aim to provide annotated
corpora that can be used to study the language of mathematics in different
contexts, ranging from fundamental concepts found in textbooks to advanced
research mathematics. We preprocess the corpora with a neural parsing model and
some manual intervention to provide part-of-speech tags, lemmas, and dependency
trees. In total, we provide 182397 sentences across three corpora. We then aim
to test and evaluate several noteworthy natural language processing models
using these corpora, to show how well they can adapt to the domain of
mathematics and provide useful tools for exploring mathematical language. We
evaluate several neural and symbolic models against benchmarks that we extract
from the corpus metadata to show that terminology extraction and definition
extraction do not easily generalize to mathematics, and that additional work is
needed to achieve good performance on these metrics. Finally, we provide a
learning assistant that grants access to the content of these corpora in a
context-sensitive manner, utilizing text search and entity linking. Though our
corpora and benchmarks provide useful metrics for evaluating mathematical
language processing, further work is necessary to adapt models to mathematics
in order to provide more effective learning assistants and apply NLP methods to
different mathematical domains. | [
-0.0516245402,
0.0790956765,
-0.0111315129,
0.0792892128,
-0.0154766813,
0.0120888986,
-0.0134730916,
-0.0141890766,
-0.0641542822,
-0.0525188446,
0.0015422719,
0.0237931423,
-0.0102621671,
0.0313428082,
0.0455649644,
-0.0804189071,
0.00953406,
-0.0096075581,
0.0133231925,
0.0175827965,
-0.0178871881,
-0.0144541273,
-0.020851342,
0.0063286591,
-0.0633318201,
-0.0437367409,
0.0235919971,
-0.0499161892,
0.0197263379,
-0.0419303663,
-0.018529471,
0.0299381763,
-0.0198243782,
0.0193567034,
0.0000019968,
-0.0593122318,
-0.0356572121,
0.0050537298,
-0.0385985263,
0.0082490742,
-0.0049815048,
-0.0479000919,
0.0148875555,
-0.0492473766,
-0.0786245912,
0.0320091732,
0.00386731,
-0.0058758743,
0.049663417,
0.0644795075,
-0.017890621,
-0.0970586911,
0.0348776244,
-0.0145214526,
0.0236944091,
-0.0666071773,
0.0066072061,
-0.017967755,
0.0333973132,
0.0414193869,
-0.0318500251,
0.0511394739,
0.065072,
0.0116932793,
0.0545736589,
0.0020792007,
-0.0258650519,
0.0137250228,
-0.0031785381,
0.0613639392,
0.0029480609,
0.0021112782,
0.0471337698,
0.0160059333,
-0.0145047931,
0.0392786413,
-0.0426469557,
0.0144686271,
-0.0243345927,
-0.0080342516,
-0.0094797788,
0.0145091824,
0.0272459183,
0.0037021614,
-0.0407772176,
0.0667929277,
0.0089743994,
-0.054711774,
-0.0180320945,
0.0132631334,
-0.0832344517,
-0.0369236134,
0.0478379987,
0.0147950118,
0.089806661,
0.0322058275,
-0.0544317514,
-0.0884425268,
-0.0404118523,
-0.0565056168,
-0.0234994199,
0.0438113622,
0.009826988,
0.0156914815,
-0.0057169609,
0.0125470096,
-0.0114203515,
0.0023943435,
-0.0101040844,
0.0307078045,
-0.0400621295,
0.0051667825,
-0.0194572154,
0.0596192889,
0.0072479793,
0.0108295707,
-0.0663631111,
0.004890806,
-0.0354007259,
0.0209175367,
-0.0165304989,
-0.0523336232,
0.0000555942,
-0.0124257905,
-0.0501454249,
-0.0578618348,
-0.0514889434,
-0.0312798023,
-0.0244960822,
-0.0324629284,
-0.0246456265,
0.016926799,
-0.0214287471,
-0.045313973,
0.0006406754,
0.0839843974,
0.0863931328,
-0.0219534039,
0.0190393236,
-0.0331422798,
0.048572436,
-0.0123723792,
0.001156843,
-0.0750900432,
0.0496440306,
0.0145703526,
-0.0195918921,
-0.0441849753,
-0.0009313127,
0.0404897556,
0.002909831,
0.0819636956,
-0.0326303802,
-0.0205551907,
0.060230311,
-0.0143189486,
-0.0168994255,
-0.0074857529,
0.0652761832,
-0.0468856022,
0.0499783047,
0.0046888413,
0.013092489,
0.0415831357,
0.0316828005,
-0.0573494993,
0.0102178063,
0.0199064761,
-0.0152519513,
0.050834734,
-0.0088609587,
0.0444099866,
-0.0441498272,
-0.0569397211,
-0.0572221428,
0.0833413824,
-0.0230146889,
0.01122142,
0.0307509732,
0.0047746343,
0.0545390844,
-0.012295424,
-0.0551910214,
-0.0080610728,
-0.0016443449,
0.0198625922,
0.0017359752,
-0.0092679029,
0.0244679023,
-0.0652699843,
-0.0310260914,
-0.0251351949,
-0.0199442841,
-0.0380670056,
0.0712625906,
-0.008939852,
0.0178638045,
0.0659274161,
0.0105313426,
-0.025067335,
0.0035243088,
0.0195631292,
0.0003457298,
-0.0081078392,
0.0322268568,
-0.0562815554,
-0.0103303771,
-0.0230171587,
-0.0014200838,
0.0553006269,
-0.0185957197,
-0.0128737343,
-0.0155396396,
-0.0277223699,
0.0197133161,
-0.0060412767,
0.0219906475,
-0.0096435808,
-0.0030730981,
0.018625753,
0.0374815129,
-0.0190157332,
0.0128645329,
0.0585617125,
-0.0253978185,
-0.0706944764,
-0.0031230778,
-0.0079937382,
0.0150215328,
0.0090749525,
0.0086860135,
0.0422524102,
-0.0090927491,
-0.0584974065,
0.0190839637,
-0.0081811612,
-0.025001511,
-0.0422966518,
0.0454394668,
-0.0634815767,
-0.0077532246,
-0.0017696272,
-0.0456152894,
0.0007476383,
0.048202537,
-0.0243421178,
0.0033893434,
0.0137003716,
-0.0103568835,
0.041385714,
-0.0072923126,
-0.010188153,
0.0822027177,
0.0185900331,
0.0467323922,
0.004320635,
-0.0104064588,
0.0185735989,
-0.002024261,
-0.0119411638,
-0.0416755676,
0.0058224211,
-0.0038978844,
-0.0126463026,
-0.0182008017,
0.0027740051,
0.0269527417,
0.0243444424,
0.0191582441,
-0.0134895742,
0.0891001821,
0.0228654388,
-0.0350562856,
-0.0100496328,
-0.0173482317,
0.0188587196,
-0.0147654004,
-0.0421838015,
-0.0499912277,
0.0531576052,
0.0237826705,
-0.0152199455,
-0.0715852901,
-0.0251689237,
-0.0593707822,
0.0521421731,
0.0433861725,
-0.0137086753,
0.0151547231,
0.0259402618,
-0.0210384484,
0.0083773304,
-0.0155677926,
0.0628459081,
0.010465038,
-0.0197287742,
0.0228942838,
0.0471518897,
-0.0193040315,
0.0554285347,
-0.0285573676,
-0.0256014373,
-0.0522330105,
0.0036907902,
-0.0091282418,
0.0702327192,
-0.0302645434,
-0.0030499732,
0.0655299053,
0.0841820315,
-0.03460728,
-0.0200950541,
-0.0125293145,
0.0454373062,
-0.0531841591,
0.0323437862,
-0.0171227101,
0.017927343,
-0.0213531069,
0.0254030656,
0.0145449694,
-0.0337567255,
0.0341953598,
0.018759653,
-0.0190567505,
-0.0745001286,
-0.0011183706,
-0.0768591687,
0.0000257374,
0.0380915515,
-0.0358763002,
0.0171644557,
-0.0292929355,
0.0286937263,
0.045801919,
0.0161780268,
-0.0023667449,
0.011461081,
-0.0285100397,
0.0512276553,
-0.0334123373,
-0.0033042568,
-0.0117743872,
0.0265560634,
-0.0048658317,
0.0230185315,
0.0016810463,
-0.0284783691,
-0.0110599939,
-0.0235917568,
0.0090976292,
0.0144765023,
-0.0098261097,
-0.0188127495,
-0.0293698404,
-0.0053400421,
0.0261497665,
0.007495455,
0.0203348864,
-0.0435847081,
-0.0180847887,
0.0000555369,
0.0275949668,
0.0101947831,
-0.0237717666,
-0.0267983731,
-0.0284854081,
-0.0873598903,
-0.0495984331,
0.0190966744,
-0.0596211925,
-0.047845874,
0.0032220718,
0.0888811201,
0.0343344584,
0.0042731822,
0.0002171073,
-0.0502684414,
0.0013966903,
-0.0044299536,
0.0040358356,
-0.1182750091,
0.000725087,
-0.0015125133,
-0.0022173699,
0.0432133004,
-0.0386500247,
0.0374947377,
-0.0844716802,
-0.0167517178,
-0.0182638019,
-0.0193555243,
0.0016908976,
-0.0275337361,
0.0046992591,
-0.0141573818,
-0.0304710846,
-0.0132321939,
-0.0257047005,
0.0616542585,
0.0213048905,
-0.0235443022,
-0.076011382,
-0.032880716,
-0.0557840914,
-0.0456263907,
-0.0174971893,
0.0393655375,
-0.0480986312,
-0.0316608734,
-0.0169362128,
0.0401827544,
-0.0313753635,
0.0032806462,
0.0114069255,
-0.0393879786,
-0.0183563791,
-0.002282284,
0.0539656579,
-0.078953959,
-0.0166329462,
0.0371201709,
0.0625184998,
0.0085595697,
0.0506751463,
-0.0427593254,
-0.0186150856,
-0.0414738022,
0.0563921444,
0.0155471722,
0.0130637372,
-0.0384494998,
-0.0244279504,
0.0228712838,
-0.0452009551,
-0.0325185545,
-0.0266797561,
0.0249889512,
-0.0019991649,
-0.0533388183,
-0.0520455465,
0.018006688,
0.0155103169,
0.0142265307,
-0.0298490133,
0.045962058,
-0.0079860669,
-0.0308540091,
0.0669652149,
-0.0160689931,
0.0248494763,
-0.0211399421,
0.0242007878,
-0.0057616234,
0.0528790094,
-0.0601570532,
0.0230442993,
-0.0678702295,
-0.0436052717,
0.0033321499,
0.0340584666,
0.0096166646,
-0.0114396252,
-0.0282966234,
-0.0081647802,
-0.0153481439,
0.0669085681,
-0.0763588175,
0.0204674937,
0.0357087851,
0.0340149663,
0.0107672466,
0.018316308,
0.0152969668,
0.0086946404,
-0.0367685333,
0.0340329632,
-0.0707449615,
-0.0293693133,
0.0096687088,
0.0200454723,
0.0023555611,
0.018078221,
0.01438489,
0.0287167672,
-0.0073266672,
-0.0268546082,
0.0223043747,
-0.026310781,
0.0056041041,
-0.0039492785,
0.0297713447,
-0.0179647375,
-0.0026903101,
0.0400134698,
0.0266059246,
0.0258202031,
0.0726370662,
-0.0076986784,
0.0186406206,
0.001004613,
-0.0061203903,
0.061757274,
-0.0348361842,
-0.032572154,
0.0392524712,
-0.0164211448,
-0.0214098394,
0.035707742,
0.0257549267,
-0.0084821358,
0.006615371,
-0.0280998275,
-0.0364440456,
0.017810978,
0.0260770731,
0.0255064666,
0.0251693279,
0.0125114638,
-0.031358134,
0.0095194839,
0.0070137721,
0.0251843911,
0.0016718417,
0.0165035073,
0.0391736142,
0.0368817337,
0.013557435,
-0.075013876,
0.0505546555,
-0.0318039134,
0.0178425964,
0.0241996627,
0.0325733013,
-0.031843666,
0.0137727996,
-0.020428475,
-0.010508527,
0.003715382,
0.0120436084,
-0.0634002164,
-0.0541233122,
0.0803754479,
-0.0100526959,
-0.0152435126,
0.0219492503,
0.0791254342,
0.0441099666,
-0.0175237767,
0.019146774,
0.012063521,
0.044459559,
-0.0500805117,
-0.0698498338,
-0.0455171615,
-5.373732752e-33,
-0.0485076271,
-0.0172175393,
0.0165281799,
0.052525498,
0.0311250314,
-0.0089638503,
-0.022878902,
0.0147557613,
0.0018575224,
-0.0099757751,
0.0178690385,
0.0283136033,
-0.0065441118,
0.0034539001,
-0.0013946024,
-0.0144688264,
0.0112230927,
-0.0283635538,
0.0025079842,
-0.0586841963,
0.0256189629,
0.0508164987,
0.1160742268,
-0.0656730533,
0.0425354019,
0.0032588039,
0.0415211767,
-0.0081038913,
0.0251772329,
0.073128514,
-0.0368504897,
0.0080360947,
0.0069311145,
-0.0292114895,
-0.0162069295,
0.0327635966,
-0.0357761905,
-0.0451777354,
-0.0222558603,
0.0378174633,
-0.0421005152,
-0.0461934432,
0.0556046441,
0.0042522238,
-0.0486086309,
0.0213731993,
0.0684232265,
0.0120695801,
-0.0131735932,
-0.019977266,
-0.0684772506,
0.073577486,
-0.0278020669,
0.0220162831,
0.0603765845,
-0.0142441522,
-0.0149714602,
0.022869112,
-0.0196440332,
-0.0255142003,
-0.0026889208,
0.0203697328,
-0.0263707079,
-0.0705500916,
0.032962665,
0.038166333,
0.0114593096,
-0.0388375744,
-0.0085010119,
0.0291597359,
0.0606112331,
0.0577997677,
0.0503892675,
0.0132005904,
0.0695894584,
0.0499409474,
-0.0377153084,
0.0120257605,
-0.0139523586,
0.0259111747,
-0.0385474451,
-0.0041952413,
-0.0517877936,
0.0348491296,
-0.0170197673,
-0.0018089748,
-0.0174779054,
-0.0199844334,
-0.0067733335,
-0.0433792062,
0.0041251821,
0.0671380311,
0.0068259318,
-0.0232706945,
-0.0362296067,
-0.0201032199,
0.0213872585,
0.0140630687,
0.017931981,
0.0109103406,
-0.0814157203,
-0.0056994832,
-0.0369233005,
-0.0017011004,
0.0535250902,
-0.0255905967,
-0.0047623306,
0.0073392713,
-0.005656912,
-0.0147488695,
-0.0016018219,
-0.0256720353,
0.0038486763,
0.0812340826,
0.0376939289,
0.0695667416,
0.0089627262,
0.0367511287,
0.0137923202,
-0.0030650517,
-0.0296270512,
0.0618992187,
0.0127450936,
0.029010063,
-0.0043117907,
-0.0461335704,
-0.0047118743,
0.0153592424,
0.039720118,
-0.0782291219,
0.0137813995,
0.0047300425,
2.725e-7,
0.0544334687,
0.0525474325,
0.0357343033,
0.0183220692,
0.0031122051,
-0.003285069,
0.0090360977,
0.0213205405,
-0.0199211612,
-0.0358163044,
-0.0287637673,
0.0236658696,
-0.0036695532,
0.0267875623,
-0.1002574563,
0.0177387223,
-0.0389715284,
-0.0125128729,
-0.0439181328,
0.0194089822,
0.049675256,
0.0649114847,
0.0435682759,
0.0299036261,
-0.022976283,
-0.0350001864,
0.0372773595,
0.0120085105,
-0.003587849,
0.0210965779,
-0.0006857972,
0.0214481726,
0.016200779,
-0.0090140197,
-0.0013778701,
0.0825771838,
0.0525305122,
0.0389856584,
0.0333636738,
0.0326362103,
-0.0227403045,
-0.0360070951,
-0.0142013878,
0.0152466036,
0.0129371043,
-0.0494317114,
-0.0416180976,
-0.0183060709,
-0.0376654007,
0.0172958411,
0.0382482708,
0.0125347124,
0.0095476033,
-0.0053113857,
0.0457187295,
-0.0408896022,
-0.0012485642,
-0.0449426584,
0.0190064646,
0.0373211093,
-0.0549035817,
0.0267298054,
-0.0661802217,
0.0055370661,
0.0114540001,
0.022599807,
-0.0351619981,
2.332563287e-34,
0.0204700921,
-0.0163247269,
0.0247703996,
0.0784291551,
0.0061328709,
-0.01077131,
-0.0777277946,
0.0273981187,
0.001876532,
-0.0452677086,
0.0268156808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11568v1 | Towards an End-to-End Framework for Invasive Brain Signal Decoding with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T14:04:18 | 2024-06-17T14:04:18 | Sheng Feng, Heyang Liu, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, q-bio.NC | In this paper, we introduce a groundbreaking end-to-end (E2E) framework for
decoding invasive brain signals, marking a significant advancement in the field
of speech neuroprosthesis. Our methodology leverages the comprehensive
reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs) to facilitate direct
decoding. By fully integrating LLMs, we achieve results comparable to the
state-of-the-art cascade models. Our findings underscore the immense potential
of E2E frameworks in speech neuroprosthesis, particularly as the technology
behind brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) and the availability of relevant
datasets continue to evolve. This work not only showcases the efficacy of
combining LLMs with E2E decoding for enhancing speech neuroprosthesis but also
sets a new direction for future research in BCI applications, underscoring the
impact of LLMs in decoding complex neural signals for communication
restoration. Code will be made available at
https://github.com/FsFrancis15/BrainLLM. | [
-0.0233428627,
0.1013709977,
-0.0035263074,
0.0472812168,
-0.0093076946,
0.0127013214,
0.0080745332,
0.0377478525,
-0.0233069807,
-0.0057880851,
-0.013732871,
-0.0415793285,
0.0715611801,
0.0882981494,
0.0632191077,
-0.0103458781,
0.0548343882,
-0.0530748554,
0.0028761935,
-0.0402974896,
-0.0071271299,
-0.0064374618,
-0.0832024142,
0.0540824942,
0.0309687443,
0.016926229,
-0.0124565586,
-0.0200589933,
-0.0223752838,
-0.020905612,
-0.0604413301,
0.0298069809,
0.0297320988,
0.0122145368,
0.0000018923,
-0.0075328331,
0.0245030764,
-0.0109584751,
-0.0788766146,
-0.0183981247,
0.005292106,
-0.0030031514,
0.0088082906,
0.0172521472,
-0.0026963912,
-0.0160997268,
0.052993279,
0.030848952,
0.0467850417,
0.0347994529,
-0.0150969271,
-0.0359984264,
0.0927741006,
-0.0171535965,
-0.0070320428,
-0.018852029,
0.0331160463,
-0.0588587448,
0.0039045648,
-0.0166959595,
-0.0388643965,
0.0460082404,
0.0209511928,
0.0179335251,
0.0388559923,
0.0250441823,
0.0236739982,
-0.0460394584,
-0.0571872517,
0.025805125,
0.0150743332,
0.0090500405,
-0.0061710095,
0.0341079719,
-0.0185393207,
-0.0256652925,
-0.0310408399,
0.0100074224,
0.0192159973,
0.0423448645,
0.0105853975,
-0.0756230429,
0.045927532,
0.0009272053,
-0.0685272962,
0.0631578863,
0.0188078117,
0.0090195173,
0.0417857468,
0.0059931022,
-0.0266054589,
-0.028579453,
0.0526521094,
0.0427384451,
-0.0701519549,
-0.0070057302,
-0.0226273276,
-0.0378022417,
-0.0397843048,
0.0000049455,
-0.0112529909,
0.0376589783,
0.0020236636,
0.0087534627,
-0.0137179419,
0.0185247008,
-0.0647677705,
0.007136527,
0.0058203023,
-0.0377302319,
-0.0116555048,
-0.0263893679,
0.0248896591,
0.0239523556,
-0.0581387393,
-0.0471098162,
-0.0254306607,
0.0143295964,
-0.0079929279,
-0.0241954848,
-0.0029210495,
0.0134589113,
-0.0063506081,
-0.0368646868,
0.0007075877,
0.0710899606,
0.0368686765,
0.057632219,
0.0084630419,
-0.0531635173,
-0.0474342071,
0.0272518136,
0.0125896065,
-0.0186679065,
-0.0269221701,
0.0651699454,
0.0195795912,
-0.0000649629,
-0.034394972,
0.0120199192,
-0.0304496083,
0.0201196335,
0.0342728496,
-0.054804828,
0.0185578335,
0.0097840037,
0.0069219046,
-0.0772641152,
0.0165608283,
-0.037851546,
-0.0247251969,
0.0386786088,
-0.0633832365,
0.0073341425,
0.0519523285,
0.00588765,
-0.0157259684,
0.0122657679,
0.0427041911,
-0.0272883866,
-0.0239870604,
-0.0502472818,
-0.0056793448,
0.0561739691,
0.039023798,
-0.0155201629,
-0.1067821234,
-0.0535604209,
0.0184332505,
0.0294125844,
0.0311713088,
0.0592986532,
-0.0231777895,
-0.0185535941,
0.0682437569,
0.0713648573,
0.0047556944,
0.0298411977,
0.0075409748,
-0.0072394097,
-0.0129633183,
-0.0380026996,
-0.0226909257,
0.0243085604,
-0.0206406917,
-0.0090874014,
0.0050658165,
-0.0024555824,
-0.0085017914,
-0.0158042032,
0.0201636106,
-0.0408839844,
0.0030493797,
0.0576881766,
0.0866732448,
-0.0199441053,
-0.0099614263,
0.0387834981,
0.0149479005,
-0.0292378776,
0.0579554997,
-0.0654350743,
-0.0072281449,
0.0289799031,
0.0196990576,
-0.0120629389,
0.0014968998,
-0.0229344815,
-0.0207808334,
0.0734060779,
-0.073823832,
0.0310785361,
0.0578985661,
-0.0430864729,
-0.0326562524,
0.069728829,
-0.0102044512,
-0.0121074459,
-0.019744603,
0.0054133544,
-0.0404429361,
0.0330534354,
0.0041366951,
0.0160244741,
-0.044017937,
0.0072331545,
0.0085680783,
-0.0023839804,
0.019237332,
0.0077860905,
-0.0282962546,
0.0251782555,
0.0116620949,
-0.0870399997,
-0.0531514063,
-0.0224411432,
-0.0373388156,
-0.035067793,
0.0284325704,
0.0253501292,
-0.0050308653,
0.0385122709,
0.0078947572,
-0.0551946051,
0.0254101232,
-0.0562820919,
0.0702289343,
-0.0518767759,
-0.0062369485,
0.0041870782,
0.0084466357,
-0.0235504508,
-0.0083758254,
-0.0217666496,
-0.0276209451,
0.0228611398,
-0.0342466608,
-0.0093851052,
-0.0608754493,
-0.067897141,
0.0568535849,
-0.0516289994,
0.0010702021,
-0.010146617,
-0.0182063356,
-0.0211862903,
-0.0236785058,
-0.0788780004,
-0.0317827389,
0.0177415516,
0.0293663293,
0.0033449868,
0.0264673941,
0.0115317283,
0.0177418832,
-0.0164882187,
-0.0171149131,
0.0181252845,
-0.0037116827,
-0.0189936385,
0.0251184572,
-0.0335885435,
-0.0017495988,
-0.025220599,
-0.0268842969,
0.0691548884,
-0.0478871875,
-0.0375045761,
-0.0681535751,
0.0401807204,
0.0251964871,
0.0302386917,
-0.0030328163,
0.0048922161,
0.0252968501,
-0.0386785865,
0.0087424275,
0.0634910837,
0.0182555132,
-0.0166387949,
0.0468054563,
-0.0287748687,
0.0021423299,
-0.0098472489,
-0.0104171215,
0.000468743,
-0.0647132769,
0.0030101696,
0.0141214952,
0.0489324406,
0.0471977852,
-0.0095325112,
-0.0456657223,
-0.0044274861,
-0.036937099,
-0.0278566685,
-0.0472668037,
-0.0275412332,
-0.0357385315,
0.0605506524,
-0.0230028462,
-0.0222466998,
0.0507198647,
-0.0499681756,
0.0082425885,
0.0000957846,
-0.0161391515,
-0.0012767781,
0.0267425571,
-0.0182250887,
0.00660278,
-0.0518596135,
-0.0452979431,
-0.0148356594,
0.0134271393,
-0.0579752326,
-0.0326125398,
0.0182567667,
-0.0393431596,
-0.0149478614,
0.013701464,
-0.0068944534,
-0.0446204171,
0.0072013028,
-0.018578779,
-0.0037270053,
0.0247713402,
-0.0012086105,
-0.0183285289,
-0.0162854735,
0.0387608744,
0.040137656,
-0.0238256846,
0.0004128528,
-0.0372320041,
0.0682078451,
0.0156635754,
0.0520986579,
0.009316083,
-0.0320264064,
-0.0021010695,
0.0459595472,
0.0280225463,
0.0658883676,
-0.0770512521,
0.0108269574,
0.0309418198,
0.0280158333,
0.0267959032,
0.0397683457,
-0.0004789566,
-0.0235584415,
0.0105412314,
0.1183729619,
0.0006411636,
-0.1171110943,
-0.0076334276,
-0.0125516821,
0.006886974,
-0.0035048374,
-0.0092106154,
-0.0440849736,
-0.0185341854,
0.0133751333,
0.0179385711,
0.0116925547,
0.0269112624,
-0.0270721894,
-0.0510533936,
0.0216665957,
0.0179108381,
0.0034135871,
-0.0257283915,
-0.0526857153,
0.0122778285,
0.0153084667,
0.0440719128,
0.0322926193,
-0.0039481181,
0.0005733841,
0.0099399947,
-0.0109039238,
-0.0726538524,
0.0176017098,
-0.0093228593,
0.1166324466,
0.0760408863,
-0.0045547439,
-0.0479029156,
0.0193409957,
0.0364801139,
0.0043547614,
-0.0369496271,
-0.0049190572,
0.0140329413,
0.0387374721,
-0.0251881331,
-0.0026568405,
0.0638369247,
-0.054945033,
-0.0472575612,
-0.0197596718,
0.0746828243,
-0.0585248061,
-0.0017320091,
0.0040880945,
0.0021162697,
0.0186499003,
0.0473605841,
0.0493934453,
-0.0922071561,
0.0178126357,
0.0036081367,
0.0017689181,
0.0337107964,
-0.0581805483,
0.0160707589,
0.0420152098,
-0.0406752788,
-0.013046586,
0.0289231651,
0.0281394441,
0.0210939627,
0.0440190956,
0.0646842942,
0.0875959694,
-0.0046818848,
-0.0063696629,
0.0280301515,
-0.0048783883,
0.0165636577,
-0.0567129105,
0.0422747284,
0.0008397318,
-0.0323457383,
-0.0320036709,
0.0346200205,
-0.0414204523,
-0.0509852581,
0.0401018858,
-0.0245084409,
0.026383318,
0.012014064,
-0.0266750716,
-0.0649606586,
0.0361823328,
0.0352626331,
-0.025616888,
0.070696339,
0.0233116597,
0.0298121516,
0.019477943,
0.0345671996,
-0.0334782898,
0.0127107939,
-0.0274606347,
0.0468482003,
0.0046166535,
0.0035822538,
0.0185149889,
0.0337462351,
0.0618115216,
0.0060116695,
0.0493829958,
-0.0141507555,
0.027328603,
0.0085656513,
0.0818083808,
-0.030888088,
-0.0071020653,
0.0560208559,
-0.0057786191,
0.0123913996,
-0.0469461605,
0.0155468583,
-0.022606492,
0.0037916475,
0.0206775405,
-0.0356714241,
0.0051897829,
0.0128795141,
0.016435042,
0.0015867397,
0.0287408512,
-0.0190211218,
0.00533592,
-0.043633908,
0.0601876788,
0.035509374,
-0.0420388393,
-0.0405730605,
0.0301189385,
-0.0122561343,
-0.0746222064,
0.0718721449,
0.0111769764,
0.0075689415,
0.0582627989,
0.0148394024,
0.0024969412,
0.0172895715,
-0.0305069853,
0.052304294,
-0.033766076,
0.0326631404,
0.0403028429,
0.0171936229,
0.0050709411,
-0.0201419219,
-0.0027242976,
-0.0071944571,
-0.0066665919,
-0.0107074194,
0.0398426093,
0.0009306041,
-0.0618077554,
-0.0326018669,
-0.0189054087,
-0.068738617,
0.0164456423,
-0.0053796275,
-0.0587040037,
0.0052050729,
-0.0029960799,
0.0129459752,
-0.0551714003,
-0.0094171539,
-0.0041306,
-0.01574523,
-0.0059842044,
0.037563283,
-0.0101009877,
0.0033231159,
-0.0833772942,
-0.0135325417,
-6.207186165e-33,
-0.0129815927,
-0.0106344754,
0.0207321066,
0.0028772794,
-0.0406731404,
0.0080364347,
-0.0483057238,
0.0365614444,
0.0195590686,
-0.0232204925,
-0.0311820731,
0.011279867,
0.0141654555,
0.0665649474,
0.0102522671,
0.0259751044,
-0.0070392806,
-0.0192446895,
0.022283107,
0.0079869889,
0.0442274213,
0.0392844155,
0.0473204404,
-0.0458166152,
0.0020843905,
0.0292087011,
0.0020823223,
0.0151849193,
-0.0194452424,
0.0123748658,
-0.0724441037,
0.051727429,
0.0382421799,
-0.0067812903,
0.0083473288,
0.022189118,
-0.037921913,
0.0371347927,
0.0237057675,
-0.0395747088,
-0.0640476122,
-0.0343579873,
0.0766927674,
0.0086658448,
-0.0063802665,
-0.0022823422,
0.0065084621,
-0.0495897792,
0.0026331877,
0.0168668348,
-0.0039529749,
-0.0162656959,
-0.0174600277,
0.014020022,
0.042277012,
0.0105315614,
-0.066272825,
0.0303124376,
-0.0509245843,
0.0162942745,
0.0163627099,
0.0436054878,
0.0244568791,
-0.0206868034,
0.0222256389,
0.0533922054,
0.0795604214,
-0.0210767407,
-0.0367368199,
-0.0358772799,
0.0779969245,
0.0594059937,
0.05374562,
0.0022264661,
0.0200823788,
-0.0448989086,
-0.060776893,
-0.0198681951,
0.0031030416,
0.03960751,
0.0400056653,
0.0084336735,
-0.0051277382,
-0.0103533668,
-0.0608248562,
-0.01139862,
-0.0288126655,
0.0177497938,
0.0345585383,
-0.0370135903,
-0.0177333429,
-0.0410064496,
0.0583033226,
-0.0308612846,
0.0373424254,
-0.0078317458,
0.0084120203,
0.0162222311,
0.0190463681,
0.0262907892,
-0.0126232887,
-0.0087385699,
0.0151980752,
-0.0172881577,
0.0341417603,
-0.0322631858,
-0.0753565654,
0.0423235595,
-0.0156725366,
-0.0323753059,
-0.0336283594,
-0.0077023106,
0.0226532519,
0.0062176781,
0.043852821,
-0.0112219304,
0.0067403214,
-0.0136391884,
-0.071116209,
0.0301388353,
-0.016432358,
0.0019225341,
0.0272949226,
0.0423042066,
-0.0171543341,
0.0054880185,
-0.0049879691,
0.0206519645,
0.0494290255,
-0.0433626771,
-0.0269289128,
0.0108538847,
2.746e-7,
0.0099331932,
0.0282057133,
0.0298498459,
0.0371498689,
0.056451939,
0.000432438,
-0.0298966896,
0.0003987366,
0.0194543358,
-0.053667739,
-0.0439145416,
0.0735939369,
0.0607583188,
-0.0343901254,
-0.0230191946,
-0.0411207564,
-0.0386951789,
-0.0054348684,
-0.045050282,
-0.0028075015,
0.048829671,
0.0274957418,
-0.0203451458,
-0.0475233272,
0.0563285537,
0.020117199,
0.0522393323,
-0.0331159756,
0.0152088497,
-0.0184814725,
-0.0212441329,
-0.0463983454,
0.0367078148,
0.051144246,
0.0271146297,
0.0342669338,
-0.0280365292,
0.0489616469,
-0.0565881319,
-0.0416546799,
0.0094134351,
0.0414978601,
-0.0247698352,
-0.0175823234,
0.0317417383,
-0.0529924594,
-0.0544524305,
-0.0525581241,
-0.0236951038,
-0.0084034847,
0.0279954374,
-0.0327149406,
0.0082261274,
-0.0576186664,
-0.0337882787,
-0.0146822995,
0.0152177066,
-0.0238104332,
0.006108948,
0.0553452969,
-0.0991966799,
-0.0161124878,
-0.0244195592,
-0.0015430392,
0.0157868862,
-0.0496164821,
0.0141906068,
2.203353728e-34,
-0.017844703,
0.0025896584,
0.042042762,
0.0474912785,
0.0105584869,
-0.032130558,
0.012839119,
0.0118920803,
-0.0337147154,
-0.0980196893,
-0.0542417429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11566v1 | MEMLA: Enhancing Multilingual Knowledge Editing with Neuron-Masked Low-Rank Adaptation | 2024-06-17T14:03:50 | 2024-06-17T14:03:50 | Jiakuan Xie, Pengfei Cao, Yuheng Chen, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge editing aims to adjust the knowledge within large language models
(LLMs) to prevent their responses from becoming obsolete or inaccurate.
However, existing works on knowledge editing are primarily conducted in a
single language, which is inadequate for multilingual language models. In this
paper, we focus on multilingual knowledge editing (MKE), which requires
propagating updates across multiple languages. This necessity poses a
significant challenge for the task. Furthermore, the limited availability of a
comprehensive dataset for MKE exacerbates this challenge, hindering progress in
this area. Hence, we introduce the Multilingual Knowledge Editing Benchmark
(MKEB), a novel dataset comprising 12 languages and providing a complete
evaluation framework. Additionally, we propose a method that enhances
Multilingual knowledge Editing with neuron-Masked Low-Rank Adaptation (MEMLA).
Specifically, we identify two categories of knowledge neurons to improve
editing precision. Moreover, we perform LoRA-based editing with neuron masks to
efficiently modify parameters and facilitate the propagation of updates across
multiple languages. Experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms
existing baselines and significantly enhances the multi-hop reasoning
capability of the edited model, with minimal impact on its downstream task
performance. The dataset and code will be made publicly available. | [
0.0402902626,
0.0338654332,
-0.0261600204,
0.0625290051,
-0.0208137315,
-0.0042062113,
0.0238259267,
-0.0359666012,
-0.0062187053,
-0.039893385,
-0.0721483827,
-0.0358757637,
0.0221996922,
0.0131004518,
0.0466017611,
-0.0284861252,
0.0704333112,
-0.0450707786,
-0.0291987453,
-0.0156748928,
-0.0237627905,
-0.0009745953,
0.0209348164,
-0.0065815183,
0.0257870499,
-0.0359333269,
-0.0093851471,
-0.0042387983,
0.0300066005,
0.0308784507,
0.0046397797,
0.0602273643,
-0.0195785835,
0.0689249262,
0.0000021511,
-0.0446643345,
-0.0281315502,
-0.0015145204,
0.003257192,
0.0114657097,
0.0015485989,
-0.0442097746,
-0.0499481075,
-0.0396067686,
-0.0069887689,
0.0372425541,
0.0723699704,
0.0132636717,
0.0711304843,
0.0978882164,
0.0048547443,
-0.0050721592,
0.0176373981,
-0.0533417277,
-0.0039057166,
-0.0071296534,
0.0424954742,
0.0132483141,
-0.0751793087,
-0.0127004031,
-0.0363017358,
0.0513085835,
0.0045383,
-0.0396813154,
-0.0131414551,
-0.0137847988,
-0.0303084552,
0.0069645452,
0.0107289748,
0.0448435359,
-0.0521337874,
-0.0105792545,
-0.0256482232,
0.0020935028,
0.0259864237,
-0.0539762303,
-0.0321230255,
-0.0115673319,
0.0448011495,
0.0068056015,
0.006608516,
-0.0970919356,
0.0616635829,
0.0056600231,
-0.0084382081,
0.0763952285,
0.052122876,
-0.0257613808,
-0.0291111153,
-0.0244979709,
-0.0095094861,
-0.0572054908,
0.0005957385,
0.0292671397,
-0.0371264257,
0.0181703903,
-0.0376509055,
-0.0491472892,
0.0018776839,
-0.0624737218,
0.0609896183,
0.0435564891,
0.0098304199,
0.0570619293,
-0.0442661457,
0.0237765964,
0.0044947872,
0.0211288817,
-0.0047970908,
-0.0101788482,
-0.0325797051,
-0.0060812184,
-0.0146869803,
0.0303110108,
-0.0656968504,
0.0380577222,
-0.0385457724,
0.0111883357,
-0.026194185,
0.0200422704,
-0.0171003006,
-0.0221318863,
-0.0161542203,
-0.0356668606,
-0.0195187181,
0.0587226599,
0.0032654323,
0.020588493,
-0.0108968392,
-0.0126463585,
-0.0168496352,
-0.0142611051,
0.0117328502,
-0.0582531318,
0.0352612026,
0.0569500513,
-0.0548442043,
-0.0105833998,
-0.0507429652,
-0.0249487963,
0.0021032523,
-0.0511747748,
0.0129119819,
-0.0640686378,
0.0719813481,
-0.0307157729,
-0.0198436975,
-0.0679524988,
0.000649719,
-0.011601327,
-0.0349508412,
0.0740385577,
-0.0300404336,
-0.0062277489,
0.0508479364,
0.0172393732,
-0.0705532432,
0.0565985255,
0.035585057,
-0.0235779732,
0.0669245571,
-0.0098200459,
-0.0416805223,
0.0595040098,
0.0143865012,
0.0220561605,
0.0137556354,
-0.0043202983,
0.0123479804,
0.036133036,
0.0529961027,
0.0189567544,
-0.0320319571,
-0.0071619195,
0.0904068872,
-0.0090065598,
0.034039367,
0.0357154123,
0.0066466499,
-0.0669750646,
-0.0033519987,
-0.0376655757,
-0.0238600653,
0.0437527597,
-0.029778149,
0.0073092384,
0.0084641837,
0.0398698673,
-0.0110357599,
-0.0338065326,
0.0150730638,
0.0260843337,
0.0268039573,
-0.0147225726,
0.0375368223,
0.0083987154,
-0.0141352816,
0.040931385,
0.0273730922,
-0.0269632861,
0.0243622176,
-0.0311670154,
-0.0053152521,
0.0407520272,
0.0307718571,
-0.0383844562,
-0.0752012804,
-0.0260242913,
-0.0278422646,
0.0354877636,
0.0398445353,
-0.0218308996,
0.0333316997,
-0.0320978835,
0.0002206316,
-0.0666786581,
0.0143209007,
0.0380932204,
0.0193595774,
0.0061918972,
0.013297433,
-0.0165981986,
-0.0134193599,
0.0041882903,
-0.0604727641,
0.0059267958,
0.0208494645,
0.0154095981,
0.0044860495,
-0.0145925218,
-0.0062901247,
-0.0155906249,
-0.0364447124,
-0.0406892672,
-0.0056486959,
-0.0152115328,
-0.0085493801,
-0.0590214916,
0.0883795395,
-0.0030798314,
-0.0344128683,
0.0587267578,
-0.0414939746,
-0.0282092728,
0.0180473533,
-0.004475032,
0.0290339608,
-0.0434497148,
0.0157391857,
0.0142956888,
-0.0055446988,
0.0068294536,
0.0278018285,
-0.0010393487,
0.0191175248,
0.0309949126,
0.0107047139,
0.0146126673,
-0.0310978424,
-0.0492568649,
0.0432967879,
0.006590765,
-0.0055690724,
-0.0131203411,
0.0226102639,
-0.0252509154,
-0.0158034582,
-0.0650489181,
-0.0147218108,
-0.0140880402,
0.005450042,
0.0366241299,
0.0085773692,
-0.0014525122,
-0.0124613047,
-0.0387993827,
0.0079039251,
-0.007727779,
0.0503764302,
0.0370383933,
0.0256986935,
0.008641935,
-0.0547881275,
-0.0091965953,
0.0147138378,
0.0525400229,
-0.0195447318,
-0.0389163308,
-0.052576758,
0.0226985198,
-0.0935765505,
0.0213960204,
-0.0107439077,
-0.0248873401,
-0.0432255752,
0.0094924513,
0.0840542614,
0.0345571786,
-0.0469473712,
-0.0250548851,
0.086577177,
-0.0312719159,
-0.0006677818,
0.0220028162,
0.0135359392,
0.0200637896,
-0.0363119654,
-0.0199456923,
0.0038537616,
0.0546749979,
-0.0080633275,
-0.0751757026,
-0.0360953398,
0.019911781,
-0.0038729103,
-0.0389797278,
-0.0749762207,
0.0053334613,
0.0028269009,
0.0190224331,
-0.0678438917,
0.0006133237,
0.067725122,
-0.0082741613,
0.0022928587,
-0.0386792272,
-0.0028288157,
-0.0249134991,
0.0403762199,
-0.0205332898,
0.064849183,
-0.0709988028,
0.0059856786,
-0.0872051492,
-0.0056851543,
0.020500971,
-0.001448515,
0.0410493277,
-0.0706577152,
0.0003967909,
-0.0306808744,
-0.0389026403,
0.0166877154,
0.0243494902,
0.0090165818,
0.05513677,
0.0482707471,
-0.0264302902,
-0.016633071,
-0.0133779068,
0.0565515719,
0.1080757603,
-0.0093452632,
-0.0055957795,
-0.0244321767,
0.0022753128,
0.038105581,
0.0406586491,
0.0331883729,
-0.0121676456,
0.0458488986,
0.0340935253,
0.0161993243,
-0.0699155256,
0.0072088833,
0.0433174334,
0.0004745781,
-0.0603154898,
-0.0127848666,
-0.0410260037,
0.0498448722,
-0.0432942696,
-0.000075196,
0.0762002468,
0.0291529745,
-0.0449123681,
0.017815236,
-0.0964718238,
0.0004200908,
0.0497484952,
0.0667155907,
-0.0805552751,
-0.0031805688,
0.0330169685,
-0.0097346622,
0.0161896944,
-0.0527939759,
-0.0076881694,
-0.0990698189,
0.0051275818,
0.0222012177,
-0.0639659911,
-0.0544212647,
-0.0255204588,
0.0025348603,
0.0187131967,
0.0160611868,
0.0263980832,
0.0319903903,
-0.0404578783,
-0.0441058762,
0.0236370079,
-0.0334997512,
0.0291402005,
-0.0104133943,
0.0559656993,
0.0070208353,
0.0352593921,
-0.0172067992,
-0.0248173364,
0.0271421019,
0.021006722,
0.0046866094,
-0.019438006,
0.0099970018,
0.0307684261,
-0.0173265729,
0.0309862942,
-0.0048080985,
0.0139983986,
-0.034597937,
0.0200655889,
0.0908833221,
-0.0035583342,
0.0182056017,
0.0387942307,
-0.0402531438,
-0.0263074376,
0.0301196743,
0.0132548315,
-0.0101631386,
0.0194981694,
-0.0407731608,
-0.039899867,
-0.0408629216,
0.0024525323,
-0.0049259705,
-0.0615181662,
0.0328805633,
-0.0552753992,
-0.0578575358,
0.0461610965,
-0.0246623661,
0.0538768545,
0.0108257132,
0.0048325458,
-0.0295673981,
-0.015654793,
0.0114095584,
-0.0427214168,
0.0076515931,
-0.0474320799,
0.0033707167,
-0.0030030063,
-0.0497687869,
-0.015841281,
-0.0079879994,
-0.0285862014,
-0.0547603853,
-0.0038400267,
0.0716056079,
0.0081032617,
0.0487783365,
0.0145268636,
-0.047336407,
0.0296156481,
-0.0087975375,
0.0040501659,
0.052811645,
0.0201433804,
0.0093867332,
-0.0198583454,
0.0556900278,
-0.0564331524,
0.0011196106,
0.0516033322,
0.0625494346,
-0.0207936168,
0.0019264404,
-0.0038938494,
0.0299856476,
-0.0121244891,
0.0330665112,
-0.0165850278,
-0.0732794106,
0.0759434626,
-0.0512657724,
-0.0217874181,
-0.0094678821,
0.0039283717,
0.0004581452,
-0.0198647454,
-0.0179000031,
0.0230532829,
0.0385352969,
-0.0137394778,
-0.016343439,
-0.0427053571,
0.0161209963,
0.0081001855,
0.0347547606,
0.0313012637,
-0.0322317593,
0.0240167119,
0.0081771724,
0.0157095194,
-0.0364184603,
-0.0073122978,
0.0138236908,
-0.0449744985,
-0.0602820478,
0.04026917,
-0.0311424434,
-0.0334155299,
-0.0108721741,
-0.0129474476,
0.0776837841,
0.0403205939,
0.0575005859,
-0.0167691801,
-0.0594452024,
-0.0028393611,
0.0144526418,
0.0447847545,
-0.0152530344,
0.01857052,
-0.0098652514,
0.0240311176,
0.0276991092,
0.0578138977,
-0.0107153365,
0.0963403657,
-0.0228658784,
-0.0062316228,
-0.0459827408,
-0.0203765463,
-0.0038817707,
0.0171621144,
-0.0382561237,
-0.0373297185,
-0.0168270096,
-0.0819057524,
0.0046375492,
0.0222205129,
-0.037475992,
0.0401139073,
-0.0222002156,
0.0629846528,
0.0172441993,
-0.0121250059,
-0.0185154527,
-0.0017679315,
0.0088946875,
-0.0076613966,
0.0175646674,
-6.146602655e-33,
-0.0207472164,
0.0205765925,
0.053376969,
0.010886509,
-0.0155184269,
-0.0214291643,
-0.0275121704,
-0.0038619435,
0.0010008332,
0.0166134499,
-0.0190115459,
0.0017417171,
-0.0183713045,
0.0038756044,
0.0116160521,
0.0345812067,
0.061990153,
0.0352884941,
-0.0094751883,
-0.0032767195,
0.033903487,
0.0423213504,
0.0904599801,
-0.0013196274,
0.0667218938,
0.0435698889,
-0.0061998181,
0.0362372547,
-0.0674292967,
0.0288822167,
-0.0291649401,
0.0347509235,
0.0249509383,
-0.0274967458,
-0.0343728289,
-0.0452734903,
-0.04566627,
-0.0256476216,
0.0312156472,
0.0410353653,
-0.0033497096,
-0.0725637674,
0.0384182334,
0.0165022556,
-0.0012822945,
-0.0194438882,
0.0108401524,
-0.059231814,
0.0091564702,
-0.003552801,
-0.0716726333,
0.0117818415,
0.0195656884,
-0.0040883659,
-0.0016704547,
0.0297672059,
0.0052050138,
-0.0183043964,
-0.1441615522,
0.0040729679,
0.0056091934,
0.0676758066,
0.0660729185,
-0.0099181589,
-0.021167567,
0.0296344347,
0.0148148639,
0.0240228344,
0.0304854438,
0.0105771925,
0.0137185585,
0.0132991318,
0.0498877913,
0.0604833998,
0.0059256847,
-0.0132085802,
-0.0856592804,
-0.0105761774,
-0.0514724627,
0.0299669877,
-0.0205238126,
0.0287934858,
0.0315561965,
-0.0012860609,
-0.056176573,
-0.0061718104,
-0.0613891408,
-0.0211848915,
0.0125560351,
0.0009092788,
0.0010690801,
0.0137912044,
0.0149261765,
-0.0118942894,
0.0058683096,
-0.0059180562,
0.0002767594,
0.0397632346,
0.0149634434,
0.0023947638,
-0.0241130833,
0.0116138011,
0.0042355959,
-0.0243594497,
0.0136283953,
-0.0063435193,
0.0716335624,
0.037601728,
-0.0589947924,
0.0256516486,
-0.020799147,
0.0325807855,
0.0077563273,
0.0252478626,
-0.0252939612,
-0.0333403572,
-0.0012656398,
0.0079658823,
0.0804326013,
0.0118944375,
0.0221449807,
0.028685458,
0.0040357541,
0.0439591222,
-0.0130713321,
0.0190007351,
-0.0253089666,
0.0288278665,
0.0154517051,
-0.0465617925,
-0.0160226692,
-0.0045945798,
2.902e-7,
0.0453309231,
0.0535671487,
-0.0135446228,
0.0038734765,
0.0274512451,
0.0208586212,
-0.0456002504,
0.0107860323,
0.0089060375,
0.0216713678,
-0.0054627643,
0.0124779446,
0.0037082224,
0.0454907604,
-0.0357293226,
-0.0132613201,
-0.0248880126,
0.007140222,
-0.0450614654,
-0.0437309593,
0.0062022698,
0.0497355163,
0.0115512982,
-0.0215579253,
-0.0144190649,
-0.0356976651,
0.0927161276,
-0.0205548815,
-0.0258787815,
0.0000167094,
0.0579241849,
0.0127563579,
0.0134156765,
0.0241554938,
-0.032949239,
0.0176748987,
-0.0217343997,
0.0546738505,
-0.0391022265,
0.0197588857,
0.0151678389,
0.0195068773,
-0.0277102031,
-0.0715618879,
0.0659271404,
-0.0258227829,
0.0102738682,
0.015910672,
-0.0182544477,
0.0143446922,
0.0409745947,
-0.0711587816,
-0.0122636231,
-0.0104720732,
0.0274009723,
0.0447571576,
-0.0257566404,
-0.0456687883,
-0.0508486107,
0.0071086292,
0.0125709726,
-0.0549153984,
-0.035006579,
-0.0650930479,
0.0289130192,
-0.0767730922,
0.0149022508,
2.410090124e-34,
0.0001922837,
0.0165837128,
0.0249079242,
0.0268703103,
0.047212664,
-0.0306974296,
-0.0175986234,
-0.0110002337,
-0.0155658731,
-0.0680396706,
-0.0460618213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11565v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11565v2 | Extrinsic Evaluation of Cultural Competence in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T14:03:27 | 2024-06-19T05:18:56 | Shaily Bhatt, Fernando Diaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Productive interactions between diverse users and language technologies
require outputs from the latter to be culturally relevant and sensitive. Prior
works have evaluated models' knowledge of cultural norms, values, and
artifacts, without considering how this knowledge manifests in downstream
applications. In this work, we focus on extrinsic evaluation of cultural
competence in two text generation tasks, open-ended question answering and
story generation. We quantitatively and qualitatively evaluate model outputs
when an explicit cue of culture, specifically nationality, is perturbed in the
prompts. Although we find that model outputs do vary when varying nationalities
and feature culturally relevant words, we also find weak correlations between
text similarity of outputs for different countries and the cultural values of
these countries. Finally, we discuss important considerations in designing
comprehensive evaluation of cultural competence in user-facing tasks. | [
0.0252096821,
0.0090083191,
-0.0394770205,
0.0094553549,
-0.0305959508,
0.0208314694,
0.0597488135,
-0.0324897878,
-0.0066278172,
-0.0128698312,
-0.046811264,
-0.0708518699,
0.0113166589,
0.046010267,
0.0058204406,
-0.0238108281,
0.0096894549,
-0.0083576953,
0.0216879547,
-0.0110970633,
0.0187734924,
0.0487849079,
0.0195589662,
0.0785308331,
-0.0141512724,
-0.0074926754,
0.0269838888,
-0.0145979179,
0.0536094606,
-0.0036862395,
0.0159307718,
0.0223210771,
-0.0197814293,
0.0181762595,
0.0000020405,
-0.0596230216,
0.0022317972,
-0.0297630467,
0.0186150763,
0.0125916973,
0.0666890144,
0.0443466417,
-0.0165265929,
0.0165838283,
-0.0369568169,
0.0226384345,
0.0434185788,
-0.0020993839,
0.0124097271,
0.012466806,
0.00544438,
0.0601624995,
-0.0496445186,
-0.002902129,
-0.0232324302,
0.0241360888,
-0.0286350455,
0.0406852178,
0.0230710469,
-0.004015326,
0.0025643122,
0.0504414923,
0.0336959325,
-0.0050049135,
-0.0257140156,
0.0169915315,
-0.0038290415,
-0.0110615268,
0.0286660064,
0.0400451608,
0.0644219816,
0.0112940297,
-0.0010108368,
-0.003024397,
0.0040773619,
0.0171142258,
-0.0227761883,
0.0500959158,
-0.0024048989,
-0.0155202886,
0.0390188731,
-0.0016361591,
0.0103568071,
0.0364959985,
0.0424596891,
0.0680214912,
0.015255522,
0.0107710194,
-0.0725157931,
-0.0054220459,
-0.006243777,
-0.0842006654,
0.0436149426,
0.0284803566,
-0.051909633,
0.0095803896,
-0.020605484,
0.016610384,
0.0118176294,
-0.029566234,
0.0218276829,
0.0553723238,
-0.0235092137,
0.0027434635,
-0.0112833092,
0.0625537559,
-0.0152838873,
-0.0209296476,
-0.0381125472,
-0.0285228323,
-0.0125023965,
-0.0347202681,
0.0275485441,
-0.0185197107,
-0.0171429832,
0.0023673966,
-0.0448421948,
0.0361388735,
-0.0060690022,
0.0168496408,
-0.0221570842,
-0.0067341211,
-0.0421911106,
-0.0031681713,
-0.0254200939,
0.0558761247,
-0.083987318,
-0.0280015171,
0.0093498603,
-0.0594164468,
0.0374890119,
-0.0030197559,
-0.0175911803,
-0.0239884388,
-0.0142779881,
0.0075677456,
0.002039833,
0.0164644271,
-0.0242896061,
-0.0348465033,
-0.0023609025,
-0.056542296,
-0.0099709611,
-0.089805752,
0.0142498659,
0.0398257375,
0.0013239175,
-0.0582633428,
0.0177891068,
0.0439129733,
-0.0013578758,
-0.0060664024,
0.023803914,
0.0320309848,
0.0873443484,
0.0119284401,
-0.0230727419,
0.0541918874,
0.0408063121,
0.0179825407,
0.0585676841,
-0.0145344408,
-0.0142383762,
0.0499167107,
-0.0349867903,
-0.0248621665,
-0.0447161347,
0.0268874876,
0.0294098891,
-0.0018225049,
0.0212713145,
0.053563457,
-0.0121667683,
0.0356318802,
0.0495249778,
0.0688350648,
-0.032930214,
0.003325212,
0.1018412337,
-0.0282170177,
-0.0358958282,
0.0624122359,
-0.0264646783,
0.0312757082,
-0.0068219965,
0.0100501943,
0.0128995795,
0.0887670368,
-0.04766839,
-0.0456635281,
-0.0022592312,
0.0115500651,
0.032304015,
0.0180301238,
0.011326042,
0.0070444979,
0.0190296471,
-0.0018624839,
0.0169242118,
-0.0886210576,
0.0228098501,
-0.0221400596,
0.0617363453,
0.084927544,
0.042032592,
0.0123583386,
0.0113331862,
-0.0093462616,
0.0118421651,
0.0437745377,
0.0623045564,
-0.0234482456,
0.0032601519,
-0.0378826074,
-0.0046927365,
-0.0066151735,
-0.0245535728,
0.0280085746,
0.0333813131,
0.0498570427,
0.0376123041,
-0.0192694869,
-0.0406386368,
-0.0106521118,
-0.1024263352,
-0.0089344708,
-0.0134009309,
0.0104538184,
-0.0276513547,
0.0402832106,
-0.032102488,
0.0051608253,
-0.0300047435,
-0.0247700009,
-0.0133075593,
0.0412974022,
-0.0758356676,
0.0004387714,
0.0123875104,
-0.046140641,
-0.0029348622,
0.0164650157,
0.0461874157,
-0.0292091072,
0.0373007096,
-0.0158195142,
-0.0280411579,
-0.0522669107,
-0.0091652153,
-0.021945782,
0.0012590868,
-0.027702447,
0.034714058,
-0.0214272682,
0.0386896357,
0.0003009844,
-0.0127532668,
0.0154477526,
-0.0203227419,
-0.0511256866,
0.0544675142,
-0.0005579719,
-0.0041821115,
0.0621752813,
0.014474283,
-0.0305359848,
-0.0062170592,
-0.103620775,
0.0072540636,
-0.0276138168,
0.0131421657,
0.0502157211,
0.0424571037,
-0.0238400623,
-0.0019749834,
-0.0924916565,
-0.032650508,
0.0828551054,
0.050687246,
0.0319793895,
-0.0140829077,
-0.0058469502,
0.008522558,
-0.0134907467,
0.0162043534,
0.0355467014,
0.0044873264,
0.0222570114,
-0.0491822027,
-0.020576667,
-0.0814136937,
-0.0339504033,
-0.0073874849,
-0.0466701649,
0.0215947926,
0.0354175605,
0.0891309679,
0.0208031628,
0.0190024655,
-0.0142890075,
0.0390006192,
-0.0240667053,
-0.0188547485,
-0.0259245187,
0.0047823596,
0.0325178728,
0.0289016329,
-0.1077271104,
0.0095559731,
0.0573189221,
0.011774065,
-0.003859112,
-0.0186302196,
0.0366207957,
-0.0792231858,
-0.0490686633,
-0.0108510768,
-0.0278094877,
0.0017431474,
0.0630333871,
-0.0286886562,
-0.0427369401,
0.0655134171,
-0.0305102877,
-0.0081282062,
-0.0179491267,
-0.0156168891,
-0.0415835306,
0.053805057,
-0.0265519489,
0.0728739277,
0.0074227909,
-0.0239444766,
-0.0552874245,
-0.0029717472,
0.0354754031,
-0.038234245,
0.0167914983,
-0.047033038,
-0.0518803932,
-0.0041620778,
-0.0243681781,
-0.041042719,
0.0133872461,
0.0250040255,
0.0335228108,
0.0318458863,
-0.0058989027,
0.0379251838,
0.0049350373,
0.0906587318,
0.006616469,
-0.0470974073,
0.0178314894,
0.0032894381,
0.0424978249,
0.0607509278,
0.0178192109,
0.0346636437,
-0.0493071489,
0.0341058262,
-0.0032771453,
0.044323951,
-0.044301223,
0.0399953872,
0.0056026815,
0.0396156013,
-0.0128077706,
-0.0546413623,
0.0347137563,
0.1054766476,
-0.0399137512,
-0.0016724722,
0.0812642351,
0.0317357183,
-0.0054326449,
0.0059909699,
-0.054608278,
0.0210093316,
0.038868092,
0.0460110344,
-0.0731312409,
0.0312633961,
0.012858307,
-0.0020792442,
-0.0593587644,
-0.039902743,
-0.0330564119,
-0.1000029072,
0.0279276259,
-0.00586741,
-0.0613423586,
-0.0239530001,
0.0164005179,
-0.0215990208,
0.0393608026,
0.0357437916,
-0.0102102384,
-0.0094209751,
0.0034605006,
-0.0040464355,
-0.0323838666,
-0.0490329489,
0.0216202233,
-0.0381122679,
0.0303726941,
0.0727784932,
0.0294368956,
0.0148717202,
-0.0548889935,
-0.0226009972,
-0.0202562474,
0.0257368628,
0.0039814478,
-0.022283081,
0.0283859987,
-0.0245620962,
-0.0317297652,
0.0006534538,
0.0007844269,
-0.0209255964,
0.0107384128,
0.0457163304,
-0.003763611,
-0.0199744999,
-0.0098209325,
0.0171426423,
0.013031045,
0.0587752797,
0.0443035848,
-0.0803397819,
-0.0297939163,
-0.028830735,
-0.0347457565,
-0.0402564295,
-0.0300639793,
0.0133081842,
-0.0037989691,
-0.035158284,
-0.087789081,
-0.0854843855,
0.0162494797,
-0.0065633231,
0.0126424413,
-0.0357205458,
-0.0276744198,
-0.0020893377,
-0.0022839638,
0.0227583218,
-0.0478014685,
0.0479939394,
-0.0181470904,
0.0158132687,
-0.0256458409,
-0.0827827379,
0.0055704224,
0.0193037614,
-0.0167703163,
-0.0341523066,
0.021246545,
0.0343242288,
0.0122669498,
-0.0087598497,
0.0194583237,
-0.0441150889,
0.0046869232,
-0.0193471052,
-0.0382520445,
-0.000552559,
-0.0106953122,
0.0260780584,
-0.0139423124,
0.0202940889,
-0.010011551,
0.0432322845,
0.0135663152,
0.0471418165,
-0.0026262398,
-0.0233871564,
0.0011040512,
0.0293145757,
-0.0337336585,
-0.0343147889,
-0.0299171228,
-0.0455878153,
-0.039084103,
-0.0323147029,
-0.0362389833,
-0.0321009941,
-0.0240649618,
0.0044411421,
0.0066994997,
0.0262944531,
-0.0012260068,
-0.0019090915,
0.0100687938,
-0.0417067967,
0.0257989354,
0.0008512855,
0.0668131337,
-0.0036532159,
0.0180341844,
-0.0551587455,
0.0117898453,
-0.029281294,
0.0402605273,
-0.0196784716,
0.1161435023,
-0.020678699,
-0.00150168,
0.0483966842,
0.0301720928,
-0.0401465259,
-0.0196441505,
0.0282784384,
0.0176024009,
0.0536126979,
-0.0403327271,
0.0483843461,
0.0116133867,
0.0152015286,
-0.0337583981,
0.0184668191,
0.054543037,
-0.0642474517,
-0.0184540022,
0.0037313688,
-0.0220392048,
-0.0359827988,
0.0749669373,
-0.0520988666,
0.0032526141,
-0.02159,
-0.0536766686,
-0.0153790321,
-0.0364817008,
0.0257718917,
-0.0154512022,
-0.0266113225,
0.0229890514,
-0.0690388009,
-0.0518231392,
-0.0372541584,
0.0328695513,
0.0121471966,
-0.033464212,
0.015194308,
0.0793316066,
-0.0221144054,
-0.0053918618,
-0.0644007847,
-0.007746248,
-0.0634364411,
0.0134387845,
-0.0142196873,
-6.267212784e-33,
-0.0278224479,
-0.0580891296,
0.0183894597,
-0.0114293955,
-0.0037004077,
-0.0154482489,
-0.0437612645,
0.0135611109,
0.0006569345,
-0.0000466186,
-0.0238935929,
-0.0251115523,
0.0011017243,
0.0052339919,
0.0064726043,
0.0142685389,
0.0360469744,
0.0244910438,
-0.0523765385,
0.0374982171,
0.0530627109,
-0.0102593685,
0.0424513742,
-0.0308142565,
0.0536610819,
-0.0315493979,
0.0183871053,
-0.0031793227,
0.0380307995,
0.0463754199,
-0.0363547057,
0.0388357602,
0.0479679033,
-0.0561217777,
-0.0259242281,
0.0159906391,
-0.0231578872,
-0.0285459906,
0.0247479957,
0.0002513915,
0.0009731634,
-0.0643138289,
0.0008831593,
-0.040478766,
-0.037156105,
0.0196066462,
0.0350672044,
-0.0093360431,
0.0504479669,
-0.0137101579,
-0.0586870834,
0.038000796,
-0.0084209135,
-0.0096359039,
-0.0492929332,
0.1133584976,
-0.0180437677,
-0.0444975011,
-0.0060760477,
0.0202830452,
0.0055375989,
0.0261636544,
0.1079505384,
0.0167075805,
-0.0121141691,
0.0451257192,
-0.0116914418,
0.0340607986,
-0.0178443715,
-0.0233102776,
0.0181533974,
-0.0097802486,
0.0281861573,
0.0803570449,
-0.0185702909,
-0.0142843062,
-0.0135873165,
0.0319151767,
0.0450294353,
-0.0324163027,
0.0320626982,
-0.0426784791,
-0.0125134233,
-0.0191640239,
-0.0234237239,
0.0191272981,
-0.0245036092,
-0.0669141039,
0.0521504991,
-0.0139973238,
0.0056151659,
-0.0257414989,
0.0361655466,
-0.0125945713,
-0.0075944276,
0.0109370416,
-0.0216862299,
-0.0046456191,
0.0325802155,
0.0258340184,
-0.0268585924,
0.0177151095,
-0.0242207665,
0.0076077376,
-0.0014671802,
0.0380879454,
-0.0116344132,
0.0343028642,
-0.0625664964,
0.01244424,
-0.0372480489,
0.0661824271,
-0.0127838971,
-0.0122678988,
0.0376576781,
-0.0194826759,
-0.0396132767,
-0.0087804254,
0.0289989114,
-0.0129841547,
-0.0291581582,
-0.0714025274,
-0.0072539994,
0.0378262959,
-0.0632478371,
0.0000633409,
-0.0429396629,
0.0675283149,
0.0063686837,
0.0212609619,
-0.0278945994,
-0.0251852088,
2.755e-7,
0.0020477774,
-0.0136757493,
-0.0101172095,
0.0553742312,
0.0129003851,
0.0028131921,
-0.0050273286,
0.0102765039,
0.0421821885,
-0.0029874803,
0.0036418114,
0.0109499525,
0.0634314269,
0.0709744468,
-0.0807485208,
-0.0076988786,
-0.0491284281,
0.046609398,
-0.0444480032,
0.0088836011,
0.0204474833,
-0.018297838,
-0.0268332232,
-0.0048932168,
-0.0469878241,
-0.036297366,
0.0413837619,
-0.0434302129,
-0.0022332792,
-0.0046243649,
0.0010115484,
-0.0384594835,
0.0286456235,
0.0002611044,
0.0076241116,
0.0164340232,
0.0556581989,
0.0513220318,
0.0324148312,
0.014122854,
0.0332821161,
0.0016078092,
0.002924057,
-0.1163296625,
0.0614962652,
0.0304604284,
-0.0182244685,
-0.0401990041,
0.0235406701,
-0.0260466654,
0.0363389999,
-0.0377306975,
-0.0205171295,
0.0272891447,
0.0167032015,
0.0022512826,
0.0178654529,
0.0032670775,
-0.0255258065,
-0.0098544825,
-0.0056951134,
-0.0789358765,
-0.0468727872,
-0.0128736654,
-0.0539301597,
-0.0184341893,
0.0209948905,
2.413055951e-34,
-0.0018731949,
0.022401765,
0.0190887731,
0.0002882646,
0.0720460191,
0.0044960668,
0.01109045,
-0.0008637531,
0.0273631047,
-0.0214462876,
-0.0362830013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11555v1 | Input Conditioned Graph Generation for Language Agents | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 | Lukas Vierling, Jie Fu, Kai Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent progress in Large Language Models (LLMs) and language agents has
demonstrated significant promise for various future applications across
multiple disciplines. While traditional approaches to language agents often
rely on fixed, handcrafted designs, our research aims to develop both learnable
and dynamic agents. Our method uses an existing framework that abstracts
language agents as graphs. Within this graph framework, we aim to learn a model
that can generate edges for every given input to the language agent. This
allows us to generate edges that represent the flow of communication within the
graph based on the given input, thereby adjusting the internal communication of
a language agent. We learn to generate these edges using a pretrained LLM that
is fine-tuned with reinforcement learning. This LLM can be fine-tuned on
several datasets simultaneously, and we hypothesize that the model learns to
adapt to these different domains during training, achieving good overall
performance when encountering data from different domains during deployment. We
demonstrate that our approach surpasses the previous static approach by nearly
6% accuracy on a combined dataset of MMLU and CMMLU, and by more than 10% when
trained with a sparsity-inducing loss. It also performs superior in additional
experiments conducted with the MMLU and Mini Crossword Puzzles datasets. The
code is available at https://github.com/lukasVierling/DynamicGPTSwarm. | [
0.0358860865,
0.0281693526,
-0.0350985341,
0.0306702647,
-0.0249587391,
-0.0138014834,
0.0077897375,
-0.0042199409,
0.0347165912,
-0.0009743206,
-0.0151091805,
-0.013655494,
-0.0241817851,
0.0641462728,
0.0326731391,
-0.0339313745,
0.0384935029,
-0.0528245829,
-0.0107056061,
-0.0210747216,
-0.0042403946,
0.0311202034,
0.0141233709,
0.0318502225,
-0.0345237888,
0.0025056219,
-0.0663337857,
0.0056739831,
-0.0046104393,
-0.0411949754,
-0.0210621245,
0.0153585766,
0.0278785136,
0.0611759648,
0.0000022012,
-0.0063012289,
-0.008040458,
-0.0424775891,
-0.0246578641,
-0.0460596681,
0.0588269494,
-0.0427044481,
-0.0127473036,
0.0155049516,
-0.0566235185,
-0.0476049334,
0.06061415,
0.0256499685,
0.0914072394,
0.1092155799,
-0.0039868969,
-0.0146271335,
-0.0009418248,
-0.0328770876,
-0.0120792864,
-0.0455251299,
0.0128246676,
-0.0026534658,
0.0097292773,
-0.0363010913,
-0.0753453523,
0.0043795761,
0.0320572257,
-0.0144853108,
0.014342933,
0.0448162593,
0.0147957876,
-0.0441379845,
-0.021337945,
0.1286142617,
-0.0395501591,
-0.0105051147,
0.0227464773,
-0.0249657333,
0.0028417073,
0.0230953861,
-0.0290406421,
-0.0044409288,
0.019340612,
0.0162701067,
-0.0279084835,
-0.0526404418,
0.0379273184,
-0.0139228962,
-0.0473909229,
0.0779944509,
-0.0025009657,
-0.0142372437,
0.002912428,
-0.0177909248,
0.0152423959,
-0.0598574504,
-0.006144837,
0.0528098568,
-0.0684972927,
0.042542059,
-0.0691581145,
-0.0146704772,
-0.0056721289,
0.0004140389,
0.0484728739,
-0.0172564983,
0.0396537222,
0.0183097497,
-0.0235347804,
0.0500213876,
-0.026558768,
0.0794762075,
-0.0394505188,
0.0041920766,
-0.0421467423,
0.0094126593,
-0.0417127162,
0.0553000644,
0.0161197931,
-0.0455473252,
-0.0411424898,
0.0732857957,
-0.0119539145,
0.0426230505,
0.0133308973,
0.0003246868,
-0.0350314751,
-0.0237483103,
-0.0074602119,
0.0070468788,
-0.0224866234,
0.0207337234,
0.0032411909,
-0.0173639003,
-0.0117159691,
0.0062084766,
0.0279461741,
-0.0346894786,
0.0147752762,
0.137881577,
-0.0034314306,
-0.0464763157,
-0.0167082883,
-0.016982751,
-0.0161596481,
-0.0535704903,
0.021487236,
-0.0670303106,
0.0348345861,
-0.0156723615,
0.0054505719,
-0.0896136314,
0.0237269979,
-0.0174403358,
-0.0364161767,
0.0775780901,
-0.0120606478,
0.0320422351,
0.0027227895,
-0.0358462632,
0.0088304197,
0.0519411452,
0.0760673806,
0.0381949544,
0.0282467585,
-0.0011785651,
0.0098028574,
0.0762553886,
0.0367535017,
0.0402783453,
0.0034708192,
-0.0225307886,
0.0005048385,
0.0439195186,
0.0435070507,
0.0449754857,
-0.0363014825,
-0.0177154858,
0.0518602021,
0.0440800637,
0.0310596097,
0.0124780945,
0.0624296404,
0.0397757627,
-0.041421853,
0.0108363684,
-0.0362254754,
0.0192257352,
0.0264246725,
0.0179102961,
-0.0235410128,
-0.0019983505,
-0.0282453652,
-0.0209449865,
0.0477070622,
-0.0219326857,
0.0823962614,
-0.0052455589,
0.0780214965,
0.053624209,
-0.0536522083,
0.0010950179,
0.0284825992,
-0.0438004881,
0.0055739274,
-0.0507469289,
0.0080329943,
0.0717189983,
0.0535052493,
0.0157421585,
-0.0303287506,
-0.0050225309,
0.0003537986,
0.0817899778,
0.0378359333,
-0.0311758313,
0.0105492342,
-0.0453751683,
-0.0234915614,
-0.0115637891,
-0.0161730889,
0.0560610443,
0.0088896407,
0.0134976665,
-0.0049382066,
-0.0478194058,
-0.0504301004,
0.0371409617,
-0.0265821721,
-0.0194126181,
0.030050233,
-0.0047183465,
0.0314156748,
-0.0021022698,
-0.0247621257,
-0.0012284049,
0.0175801609,
-0.0008379466,
-0.0060869399,
-0.0011419109,
-0.0441537797,
-0.0209028851,
0.0648600608,
-0.0244627241,
-0.0301888697,
0.013085329,
-0.059216287,
-0.0598390698,
0.0582970418,
-0.0479593799,
0.0384898707,
-0.0038551365,
0.0072765048,
0.0015203825,
-0.0128779076,
-0.0065339063,
0.0218783263,
0.0180608537,
-0.021196615,
-0.0006160553,
0.0462461896,
-0.0167556591,
-0.0509511456,
0.0132437581,
0.0158075634,
0.0281041376,
0.0192791447,
0.032690797,
0.0372815244,
-0.0336100943,
-0.0315659754,
-0.0491524115,
-0.0149537968,
-0.0127575854,
-0.0261845849,
0.0030294047,
0.0119310813,
-0.0203536507,
-0.0342564061,
-0.0414405242,
0.0414758548,
0.0279781427,
0.0099937823,
0.0369053818,
0.0154440962,
-0.0407042652,
-0.049415648,
-0.0264329799,
-0.0090959296,
0.0352804177,
0.0159682222,
-0.0157510433,
-0.0288373828,
0.0618628375,
-0.0338760801,
0.0663625076,
-0.0162045248,
-0.0633200482,
0.0148884244,
-0.0353499949,
-0.0014528773,
0.0561421849,
0.0005107743,
0.0413143933,
0.0721242055,
-0.0476820692,
-0.0510513186,
0.0293235071,
-0.0639945194,
-0.0139106838,
-0.0703053027,
-0.022394482,
0.0024027147,
0.0524405874,
0.0112398155,
0.0002057452,
-0.080156222,
-0.0034983237,
0.036464043,
-0.0471312553,
-0.0096493019,
-0.0122317728,
-0.0377886668,
0.0311492495,
-0.0408090129,
-0.0510356799,
0.0681917667,
-0.0269205645,
-0.0052447515,
-0.0056271409,
-0.0312155411,
-0.041145023,
0.0571155809,
0.0469438657,
0.0225811135,
-0.0107784355,
-0.0218354557,
-0.07285133,
0.0078876019,
0.0483934544,
-0.0224146899,
0.0173929464,
-0.0497222506,
0.0159294065,
0.0178032201,
-0.0298434552,
-0.0317157805,
0.0460365042,
-0.0119184973,
-0.0042626872,
-0.0167372487,
-0.0603080317,
-0.0014804688,
-0.0131033743,
0.0095282998,
0.0238317121,
-0.0179605875,
0.0107589252,
-0.0497017242,
0.0156336091,
0.0848432779,
0.0231018718,
-0.0328232683,
-0.067382589,
0.0192554053,
0.0233699828,
0.0570644103,
-0.019802805,
-0.0397535637,
0.0154212043,
0.0063528619,
-0.0000368475,
0.011820958,
0.0121981576,
0.0290536117,
-0.0468805991,
-0.0088868001,
0.0953779146,
0.0141335009,
-0.0701203644,
-0.0095040184,
0.0235954169,
0.0423336998,
0.0291100945,
0.0299506746,
-0.0788899437,
-0.0194821786,
0.0027822161,
0.0143397488,
0.0043975273,
-0.0362446308,
-0.01785581,
-0.1452248245,
0.0140837403,
0.0476354882,
0.0015412726,
-0.0163112935,
-0.0436020978,
-0.0128198639,
0.0084359311,
0.0029332964,
-0.0165662654,
0.0016069814,
-0.0176229328,
0.0077935108,
-0.0068801516,
-0.0280469581,
0.0074749035,
-0.025714647,
0.0551310293,
0.0641111284,
0.0348178893,
-0.0258120336,
-0.0131203197,
0.0713928491,
0.0440754704,
-0.0174842943,
-0.0038656208,
0.041369155,
0.0109805055,
-0.0185356252,
-0.0088343825,
0.00641248,
-0.0174254943,
0.0025923774,
0.0200896226,
0.0992445871,
-0.0332540236,
-0.0326396115,
-0.0028695099,
-0.0238262322,
0.0018103794,
0.0123695433,
0.0224380791,
-0.0384163521,
-0.0703130662,
-0.0400504246,
0.0020931787,
-0.0537965931,
-0.070414111,
0.0131063433,
-0.035020642,
-0.0126768388,
-0.0559742562,
-0.0554511957,
0.0487345904,
0.0198702998,
0.0316458084,
-0.0159721244,
0.0385195315,
-0.0093961461,
-0.0499219,
-0.0079011461,
-0.0453489535,
0.0366219729,
-0.0542690158,
-0.0469360128,
-0.0021965678,
-0.0545802489,
0.0067401296,
0.0112201208,
-0.0474845469,
-0.0915363133,
-0.0204117075,
0.031652011,
0.0196452234,
0.0943051428,
-0.0160458256,
0.0023961808,
0.0616874062,
0.0029359297,
-0.0471988469,
-0.0045591965,
0.0335392356,
-0.0250472408,
0.0005972066,
0.0303257629,
-0.0647763014,
0.0198520049,
0.0273081642,
0.0346694328,
-0.0456504822,
-0.018087998,
0.0200817306,
0.0147418948,
0.012083157,
-0.0053786198,
0.015400731,
-0.0601782091,
0.0059741172,
-0.0074878964,
-0.0138138486,
-0.0427027866,
-0.0147556821,
0.0311118085,
0.010964998,
0.0417254753,
-0.0397489406,
0.000614037,
0.0394826829,
-0.0104086818,
0.0194087643,
0.0032347068,
0.0096604163,
0.0643216521,
0.0225410368,
0.0148224579,
0.0601952262,
0.0093069263,
0.0308771599,
0.026606366,
0.0272434056,
0.0365105756,
-0.0207848903,
-0.0232796595,
0.004557299,
-0.0639263615,
-0.0428711809,
-0.0175732113,
0.0323550738,
0.0536412001,
0.0450676195,
0.0480425507,
-0.0433586538,
0.023093842,
-0.0004735881,
0.0297530033,
-0.0026604279,
-0.061063502,
0.0356242098,
0.0248799808,
-0.0001622855,
-0.0147787025,
0.0696572289,
0.0395356007,
0.0509979837,
-0.0150911845,
0.0005283022,
-0.0439820029,
-0.0175238494,
-0.0115972934,
0.0137980226,
-0.0117403707,
0.0242266022,
-0.041355174,
-0.1003909558,
-0.0185750742,
0.0314710774,
0.0209486149,
-0.0069259992,
0.0563339293,
0.0305425078,
0.0004501986,
0.0198189318,
-0.0498095043,
0.004145945,
0.004891648,
-0.0391230546,
-0.0011050422,
-6.199705612e-33,
-0.0285955332,
-0.0451900661,
0.0422181413,
0.0396234021,
-0.0525627993,
-0.0105765872,
-0.0709803477,
-0.0152139878,
-0.0228963792,
0.0134812491,
-0.0206675008,
0.0370953269,
0.0085269045,
0.0215116385,
0.0042596678,
-0.0023947519,
0.047048077,
-0.0132318074,
-0.0128593855,
0.0483791269,
0.0202927571,
0.0090744309,
0.0203279667,
-0.0379040763,
0.0128743248,
0.0084673017,
-0.0079190806,
0.0410181023,
-0.0030887695,
0.0384360999,
-0.012649117,
0.0301235169,
0.0058091432,
0.0256819762,
-0.0258104801,
0.0020639743,
-0.0780009031,
-0.033537358,
-0.0179031324,
0.0287834201,
-0.0574352108,
-0.0413379781,
0.0221862476,
-0.0173954535,
-0.0040817554,
-0.0058389939,
0.0510779396,
-0.0172589626,
-0.0289052725,
0.004075998,
-0.0274939612,
0.0194518063,
0.0000472942,
-0.0159057397,
0.0340482481,
-0.0159594174,
0.0224454887,
-0.0379689448,
-0.0403673425,
0.067238532,
0.0013535299,
-0.0024118815,
0.044460278,
0.0296336617,
0.016528843,
0.0519511029,
0.031076191,
0.0040896288,
0.0124048535,
0.0240607727,
0.0310054347,
0.0365950391,
0.0169172008,
0.0301438067,
-0.0345475972,
-0.0418153629,
-0.0302754622,
-0.0215566568,
0.0315094031,
0.0522313975,
0.0014318875,
0.0012366187,
-0.0068967063,
-0.0248503964,
-0.0313798711,
0.0089672757,
-0.0208304357,
-0.0595444553,
0.0273786765,
0.0397309326,
0.0129218763,
-0.057698261,
0.0052926131,
-0.0296432227,
-0.0238275435,
0.0207191128,
-0.0291370451,
0.0255710613,
-0.0015902091,
0.0025520364,
-0.0045428686,
-0.0540863872,
0.0032891287,
-0.0231087338,
0.0163507313,
0.0309576225,
0.0081619676,
0.0573293231,
-0.0408237055,
-0.006762261,
-0.0533163957,
0.0111613804,
0.000825415,
-0.0147083448,
0.0237706471,
0.0020779567,
-0.0255548526,
0.0089391451,
0.0214651357,
-0.0191557556,
-0.0122912005,
0.0143550262,
-0.0194974206,
0.0478292853,
-0.0763176754,
-0.0244025327,
-0.0724786445,
0.0615527183,
0.0471898355,
-0.0665807799,
-0.0105693275,
-0.0124813411,
2.963e-7,
0.0227657426,
0.0330601968,
0.0274244081,
0.0881277397,
0.0184361711,
0.0281844735,
-0.0680846199,
0.0250534229,
-0.0119756013,
-0.0036345937,
0.0207131207,
0.0566881411,
0.020189736,
0.0228070226,
-0.0939609557,
0.0435522422,
-0.0327870585,
-0.0186395869,
-0.0459189527,
0.0002492456,
0.0253453888,
0.0648467541,
0.0389599428,
-0.0098446347,
-0.0073029278,
-0.0491681173,
0.0321697257,
-0.0213423576,
0.0160142239,
0.0089411279,
-0.0548874214,
-0.0091584669,
-0.0334018357,
0.0288165025,
-0.0019858181,
0.0411931761,
-0.0216915365,
0.0173981618,
-0.0122122569,
-0.0160004646,
0.0349287428,
-0.01496688,
-0.001994733,
-0.0171234217,
0.0487713777,
-0.038985908,
-0.0159350447,
-0.015605526,
0.0022166166,
-0.017450016,
-0.0113174841,
-0.0377253443,
-0.0402037911,
0.021313889,
0.0185237136,
0.0040324633,
0.0345804654,
-0.0591038167,
0.007461058,
0.0047250846,
-0.0396721177,
-0.0473080985,
-0.0500869751,
0.0315120146,
0.008821005,
0.0007129257,
0.0130856084,
2.608300742e-34,
0.0343494192,
0.004120457,
-0.0153660029,
0.0307854973,
0.0248843729,
-0.032268554,
-0.0166955125,
0.0211089645,
0.0570606552,
-0.0713413358,
-0.0556969307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11547v1 | GECOBench: A Gender-Controlled Text Dataset and Benchmark for Quantifying Biases in Explanations | 2024-06-17T13:44:37 | 2024-06-17T13:44:37 | Rick Wilming, Artur Dox, Hjalmar Schulz, Marta Oliveira, Benedict Clark, Stefan Haufe | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large pre-trained language models have become popular for many applications
and form an important backbone of many downstream tasks in natural language
processing (NLP). Applying 'explainable artificial intelligence' (XAI)
techniques to enrich such models' outputs is considered crucial for assuring
their quality and shedding light on their inner workings. However, large
language models are trained on a plethora of data containing a variety of
biases, such as gender biases, affecting model weights and, potentially,
behavior. Currently, it is unclear to what extent such biases also impact model
explanations in possibly unfavorable ways. We create a gender-controlled text
dataset, GECO, in which otherwise identical sentences appear in male and female
forms. This gives rise to ground-truth 'world explanations' for gender
classification tasks, enabling the objective evaluation of the correctness of
XAI methods. We also provide GECOBench, a rigorous quantitative evaluation
framework benchmarking popular XAI methods, applying them to pre-trained
language models fine-tuned to different degrees. This allows us to investigate
how pre-training induces undesirable bias in model explanations and to what
extent fine-tuning can mitigate such explanation bias. We show a clear
dependency between explanation performance and the number of fine-tuned layers,
where XAI methods are observed to particularly benefit from fine-tuning or
complete retraining of embedding layers. Remarkably, this relationship holds
for models achieving similar classification performance on the same task. With
that, we highlight the utility of the proposed gender-controlled dataset and
novel benchmarking approach for research and development of novel XAI methods.
All code including dataset generation, model training, evaluation and
visualization is available at: https://github.com/braindatalab/gecobench | [
0.0249939188,
0.0728238523,
-0.0338728912,
0.0146100614,
0.017317716,
0.0361627787,
0.0425824709,
-0.0352560319,
-0.0235210154,
-0.0152142774,
-0.0002662192,
-0.0425221287,
0.0404551923,
0.0207083561,
0.0196568258,
-0.0265389215,
-0.005402552,
0.0009061096,
0.0053547863,
-0.0042576264,
0.0081098787,
0.0364811607,
0.0193045102,
0.0649231672,
0.0188276637,
-0.0252179205,
-0.0149714025,
0.0074237837,
-0.0174320638,
0.0141068259,
0.0268746633,
0.0169498231,
0.0132271424,
0.018301148,
0.0000020976,
-0.0515191108,
0.014437967,
0.0406083576,
-0.0756276771,
0.0399662405,
-0.0182500314,
-0.0200976916,
0.0088722203,
0.0140651306,
0.0054660188,
-0.0120469267,
0.0453381576,
0.0702046975,
0.0469094329,
0.0383084416,
-0.0075397375,
-0.0161084775,
-0.0380021334,
-0.0332749709,
-0.0045960839,
-0.0075875618,
-0.0024554585,
-0.0295101404,
-0.0342339985,
0.0093887746,
-0.0242951494,
-0.0132086519,
0.0201972798,
-0.0339962691,
-0.0043265093,
0.0188274849,
-0.017506402,
-0.0515887961,
-0.0017309543,
0.0671115294,
-0.0184039623,
-0.0082456786,
-0.0065006134,
-0.0224909279,
-0.0065108994,
0.006087204,
-0.0332461856,
-0.0044972301,
0.0250770263,
0.0183495451,
-0.0015640625,
-0.0304295905,
0.0805988386,
0.0631070212,
-0.0239544977,
0.0918589234,
-0.0139237205,
-0.0117232688,
0.0118695395,
-0.0008969749,
-0.0096158981,
-0.0433692299,
-0.0066192951,
0.010317022,
-0.0062841433,
-0.0022946375,
0.0129777091,
-0.0060109883,
0.0159471761,
-0.0393283553,
0.050313171,
0.0349415094,
-0.0028200587,
0.027533967,
-0.0481116362,
0.0653304085,
0.0009674973,
0.0185489282,
-0.0064106937,
-0.0590244494,
-0.056543,
-0.0334921665,
-0.0067930617,
-0.0189882815,
-0.049410671,
0.0228291787,
-0.0423358679,
-0.0058970451,
-0.0382249765,
0.0005598229,
0.0379168503,
0.0269641932,
-0.0176802035,
-0.0172306374,
-0.01564987,
-0.0099783633,
-0.0819801092,
0.0480515398,
-0.0114089707,
-0.0833766907,
-0.0421335809,
0.0283512734,
0.0056732614,
-0.028167434,
0.0086243264,
0.0204210784,
0.0250662565,
-0.0411549024,
-0.0163016226,
-0.0156813432,
-0.0360356756,
-0.0766058713,
-0.0060419263,
-0.0210019946,
0.0155283697,
0.0201951619,
-0.0076326113,
-0.0334633105,
0.0008571894,
-0.0188775733,
-0.0397243947,
0.0872423872,
0.0317382477,
0.0093784388,
0.0187395848,
0.0089327041,
-0.0134909116,
0.0766456425,
0.0670485198,
-0.0128843021,
0.0244076215,
-0.0193330869,
0.0296370275,
0.0119138081,
0.0636598766,
0.0302490443,
-0.0021540062,
0.0293728169,
-0.0492997132,
0.060889028,
0.0556072295,
-0.0496016257,
0.0258088596,
-0.0043440983,
0.0433024578,
0.0483211502,
0.0381200872,
0.0539591871,
0.0469833016,
-0.0133638717,
-0.0119182495,
0.0239826478,
-0.0665661916,
0.0105657317,
0.004733915,
-0.0301592574,
-0.0116838682,
0.0005430524,
-0.0379322618,
-0.0801052973,
-0.0138952369,
-0.0173985679,
0.0118694538,
0.019193029,
0.041260194,
0.0239239335,
-0.0170668717,
0.0578674339,
0.0526272841,
-0.0712765679,
-0.0206531193,
-0.0820975751,
0.0344832465,
0.0500168391,
-0.0011588942,
-0.0483611859,
0.0136097958,
-0.0167507958,
0.0099567128,
0.0172289945,
0.0563980527,
0.0273273513,
0.0730137378,
-0.0408202447,
-0.0296659563,
-0.0389741659,
0.0464131311,
0.0154448524,
0.0472504571,
0.0146924825,
0.0369001329,
-0.0777537972,
-0.0722735822,
0.0606980696,
-0.0108445389,
-0.0510642529,
0.0613588654,
0.002095215,
0.0210804585,
0.0234820507,
-0.0142292306,
-0.0042011221,
-0.0034730746,
-0.0082168877,
-0.0118345376,
0.0221156422,
-0.0069328519,
-0.0235692654,
0.0016098155,
-0.0638872385,
-0.0473222136,
0.0499143526,
-0.0395112857,
-0.0331404023,
0.035212148,
-0.013414355,
0.015857324,
-0.0406930447,
-0.0015210373,
-0.0115706278,
0.0620717369,
-0.0000023691,
0.0176928062,
-0.0046910155,
-0.0348911844,
-0.0098084044,
-0.0097614434,
0.0112838168,
-0.0391893201,
-0.0035675408,
0.002527592,
0.0072484151,
-0.0101941153,
-0.0029458953,
-0.0340952314,
0.0001624649,
-0.0138776144,
-0.0552797727,
-0.0078102848,
-0.0303105637,
-0.0208921377,
-0.0095344102,
0.0013943024,
-0.0072701257,
-0.0174509976,
-0.0166945327,
-0.0040989686,
-0.0000666996,
0.0093406262,
0.0546867587,
-0.0217306968,
-0.0008074804,
-0.0591755919,
-0.0158711448,
-0.0335781761,
0.1028212681,
0.0218243431,
0.0071401177,
-0.0524800271,
-0.0081455335,
-0.0073209903,
-0.0175201222,
-0.0289530475,
-0.0609526597,
0.0061148112,
0.0355350114,
-0.0167147275,
0.0759171247,
0.0024470598,
0.0736173466,
0.040393576,
0.0590584427,
-0.0449618287,
-0.0110015878,
-0.005814224,
0.0136491293,
-0.0098902844,
-0.0477294363,
-0.0168135967,
0.0636565462,
-0.0071499492,
-0.0265078489,
-0.0561050922,
0.028720336,
-0.0117873205,
-0.0449703597,
-0.0343965217,
-0.0516366549,
0.0208790712,
0.0482234582,
-0.0478802249,
-0.0580273978,
0.0363659598,
-0.0482800081,
0.0009153214,
0.0009658338,
-0.0468832478,
-0.0686285347,
0.0642289594,
-0.0214065239,
0.0125540867,
0.026237959,
0.0141929416,
-0.0471638851,
-0.0583813861,
0.0246293489,
0.0123285605,
-0.0120545384,
-0.0369913951,
0.0106990431,
0.0270065647,
-0.0174673442,
-0.0313952938,
-0.0482972264,
-0.0106441155,
-0.0040064957,
0.0275319684,
-0.020917438,
-0.0021544965,
0.0360128582,
-0.0004250318,
0.0151829533,
-0.0228799526,
0.006794895,
-0.0124336872,
0.0005498901,
0.0117591498,
0.0347047485,
0.053981822,
-0.042472519,
0.0011178637,
0.0073349727,
-0.0240304377,
0.0221106987,
-0.0427431241,
0.0320259184,
0.0059442949,
-0.0414592922,
-0.0175768305,
-0.0208245087,
0.0635897294,
-0.0962752253,
-0.0075029563,
0.1048899963,
0.0337318256,
-0.0453986265,
0.0234661438,
0.0182458721,
-0.0022459775,
0.0139830392,
0.0066162478,
-0.0261681341,
-0.0181831345,
0.0366509557,
0.0066358987,
-0.0066394759,
-0.0039541498,
-0.0137926163,
-0.1106992811,
0.027684737,
-0.0040772427,
-0.0472551063,
-0.0303553008,
-0.0699815303,
-0.0177321229,
-0.0304399971,
0.0096363658,
-0.0150659531,
0.0428112,
0.0175186656,
0.0123132886,
-0.0395875797,
-0.0435534976,
0.053363435,
-0.057743609,
0.0502277017,
0.0482164696,
0.0763070509,
-0.0106718475,
-0.0121331885,
0.0326125585,
-0.0070954873,
0.0279531907,
-0.0047885734,
0.0744518563,
0.0004756669,
-0.0339014493,
-0.0458777361,
0.0635104477,
0.0062605892,
-0.0040951236,
-0.029531749,
0.0215321481,
0.0109091448,
-0.0170475207,
-0.0198126677,
-0.0343841463,
0.0077912072,
0.0912017971,
0.0412812009,
-0.0355853662,
-0.0855875164,
-0.0495114326,
-0.0156344976,
-0.015094622,
-0.0388323888,
0.011837136,
0.0724299699,
-0.0239642374,
0.0158800911,
-0.0570397563,
0.0064062099,
0.0012812339,
0.0040845992,
-0.0550837368,
-0.0068416432,
0.0047277943,
-0.0399941169,
0.0668632612,
0.0099582635,
0.0142609216,
0.0153623875,
-0.0280915871,
-0.0178699456,
-0.0495151393,
-0.0226946305,
0.0015773219,
-0.0203787535,
-0.0353720002,
0.0114874449,
0.0402042754,
0.0247795619,
0.0715000406,
-0.0154204266,
-0.0774903744,
0.0344499312,
0.0171344224,
-0.0337143093,
-0.0074070254,
0.0623852275,
-0.0093515217,
0.0261730216,
0.0715748966,
-0.0214245431,
0.0131177325,
0.0139254443,
-0.0139737446,
-0.0186179336,
-0.0206987895,
0.0051353606,
-0.0080512008,
0.0129375681,
-0.0402404666,
-0.0228030067,
-0.0376081839,
0.0078123128,
-0.0073252209,
-0.0202464238,
-0.0213343184,
-0.0195730347,
0.0325122029,
-0.0118414983,
-0.0088860849,
-0.0182692446,
-0.0272270329,
0.0006322442,
-0.0331023484,
0.0259430949,
0.0158216041,
0.0222835932,
-0.0218175109,
0.0355790034,
0.0007719955,
0.0037019572,
-0.0483124778,
0.0310241003,
0.0343299061,
0.030210929,
-0.0050347736,
0.0348864272,
-0.0338543616,
-0.0076382491,
-0.0748519525,
-0.0210115816,
-0.0086897667,
-0.0025974,
0.0166655239,
-0.0684285164,
0.0679180399,
0.0286945961,
-0.0295465551,
0.0283165351,
0.0690931827,
0.0106733283,
0.0114571285,
-0.0086715315,
0.0102031697,
-0.0421244577,
-0.0287145004,
0.0604940206,
0.0703142062,
0.0486853905,
-0.0030754472,
-0.0217945576,
-0.0092389863,
-0.0189557001,
0.0129025215,
0.001631003,
-0.0153743224,
0.0174650867,
-0.0573218539,
-0.0525120199,
-0.0148908999,
-0.0321693458,
0.0024876962,
0.0064549507,
-0.0006715013,
0.0490750074,
-0.0191080961,
-0.0354883634,
-0.045625966,
-0.0241859891,
0.0038467385,
0.0244300161,
-0.0227127224,
-6.171615706e-33,
-0.0010881299,
-0.0389290415,
-0.0247201007,
-0.0412340648,
0.0096344352,
0.0279460344,
-0.0464696884,
-0.0207735822,
-0.0273114853,
0.0658790171,
0.0073445472,
0.0741526484,
0.0126232589,
0.0274952296,
-0.0180733725,
-0.0257964544,
0.0552131832,
0.0307219457,
-0.0289763808,
-0.0098933801,
-0.0007336212,
0.0602865703,
0.0494380482,
-0.0722284913,
0.1076809987,
0.0091613783,
-0.014878762,
0.0094176084,
-0.034754429,
0.0329357535,
-0.0254334267,
0.0644786507,
0.0087710684,
-0.0476149693,
0.0293035507,
0.0424768068,
-0.0737097859,
-0.023905769,
0.0087701101,
0.0405687131,
0.0053463387,
-0.012558979,
0.0386297926,
0.0225250069,
-0.0145024993,
-0.0538297482,
0.0633921623,
0.0114213098,
0.0392122678,
0.0434898436,
-0.030724898,
0.0406972766,
-0.0601781607,
-0.0332420357,
0.0284876227,
0.0211975649,
-0.0194806103,
0.0292354058,
-0.0749988779,
-0.0052148211,
0.0199589282,
-0.0071259164,
0.0171793886,
-0.0083580008,
0.027310729,
0.0377579369,
0.0651250109,
0.0304746665,
-0.0875293761,
-0.0273044948,
0.0064871581,
0.0077433595,
0.0845907852,
0.029895477,
0.0348195545,
0.0093143424,
-0.1065463573,
-0.0359107815,
-0.0267501008,
0.0134372814,
0.0167380888,
-0.0147999078,
-0.0820311159,
-0.0328428596,
-0.0415303335,
-0.0686245859,
-0.0205814056,
0.0086084092,
0.0064741955,
-0.0273720212,
-0.0784945637,
-0.0134960227,
-0.040388193,
-0.0719275326,
-0.0179857668,
0.0057697878,
0.0001682271,
-0.0495946333,
0.0552538708,
-0.0044998857,
-0.0152002163,
0.0036273259,
-0.0119739678,
0.0173978675,
0.0576745123,
0.0053031831,
0.0387250036,
0.028620448,
-0.0472212806,
-0.0063172602,
-0.057324823,
-0.0313142538,
-0.0159434453,
0.0561927147,
0.0166077968,
0.0666732341,
-0.0458235703,
0.0117293829,
0.0464360863,
0.038559489,
0.0043880362,
-0.0350299329,
-0.0095182387,
0.0353125557,
-0.0016851018,
-0.0310199838,
-0.0110502793,
-0.0011982376,
0.0556565858,
-0.0728736296,
-0.0024420691,
-0.0035403327,
2.546e-7,
0.0366401151,
0.0414492823,
0.0475335307,
0.0225917231,
0.0200085398,
0.0379872508,
0.0086375484,
-0.0022425873,
-0.0016246766,
-0.0038278485,
-0.0050467174,
0.0635806993,
0.049004361,
0.0051294058,
-0.0212772675,
0.0073181568,
-0.0704950243,
-0.0129014356,
-0.0161086991,
0.0283006001,
0.0141808866,
0.0918005556,
0.050540138,
0.003276885,
0.0139589161,
-0.0170192663,
0.0554687828,
-0.0276615974,
0.0370714404,
0.0166467726,
0.0101342052,
0.0240044445,
0.0197700094,
-0.0008151667,
-0.0135262785,
0.01772964,
-0.0026159433,
0.0310517009,
-0.0366683677,
0.0051117167,
-0.0188872758,
-0.0124685355,
0.0006907254,
-0.0741497055,
0.0982552767,
-0.0004584828,
-0.0598722175,
-0.0347458571,
-0.0034483422,
-0.0072820559,
0.0717185959,
-0.0020150165,
0.0412592068,
0.0364851281,
-0.0039352374,
-0.0219567977,
0.0064865812,
-0.0847050026,
-0.0733996183,
-0.0074424292,
-0.00386332,
0.0200550091,
-0.0267006755,
0.0181665849,
0.0850985795,
-0.0627587512,
0.0188042838,
2.249765322e-34,
0.0014424836,
0.0276125986,
0.0106338859,
0.006577434,
0.0267534312,
0.0111818761,
0.0100052496,
-0.0167469755,
0.0669321045,
0.0097560873,
-0.0009928293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11546v1 | GigaSpeech 2: An Evolving, Large-Scale and Multi-domain ASR Corpus for Low-Resource Languages with Automated Crawling, Transcription and Refinement | 2024-06-17T13:44:20 | 2024-06-17T13:44:20 | Yifan Yang, Zheshu Song, Jianheng Zhuo, Mingyu Cui, Jinpeng Li, Bo Yang, Yexing Du, Ziyang Ma, Xunying Liu, Ziyuan Wang, Ke Li, Shuai Fan, Kai Yu, Wei-Qiang Zhang, Guoguo Chen, Xie Chen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | The evolution of speech technology has been spurred by the rapid increase in
dataset sizes. Traditional speech models generally depend on a large amount of
labeled training data, which is scarce for low-resource languages. This paper
presents GigaSpeech 2, a large-scale, multi-domain, multilingual speech
recognition corpus. It is designed for low-resource languages and does not rely
on paired speech and text data. GigaSpeech 2 comprises about 30,000 hours of
automatically transcribed speech, including Thai, Indonesian, and Vietnamese,
gathered from unlabeled YouTube videos. We also introduce an automated pipeline
for data crawling, transcription, and label refinement. Specifically, this
pipeline uses Whisper for initial transcription and TorchAudio for forced
alignment, combined with multi-dimensional filtering for data quality
assurance. A modified Noisy Student Training is developed to further refine
flawed pseudo labels iteratively, thus enhancing model performance.
Experimental results on our manually transcribed evaluation set and two public
test sets from Common Voice and FLEURS confirm our corpus's high quality and
broad applicability. Notably, ASR models trained on GigaSpeech 2 can reduce the
word error rate for Thai, Indonesian, and Vietnamese on our challenging and
realistic YouTube test set by 25% to 40% compared to the Whisper large-v3
model, with merely 10% model parameters. Furthermore, our ASR models trained on
Gigaspeech 2 yield superior performance compared to commercial services. We
believe that our newly introduced corpus and pipeline will open a new avenue
for low-resource speech recognition and significantly facilitate research in
this area. | [
-0.0069763274,
0.0567634106,
0.0224932414,
-0.0037707146,
-0.0063041947,
-0.002349694,
0.0543526597,
-0.0095139146,
-0.008402979,
-0.0068392991,
-0.0717958733,
-0.0503512211,
0.0335910134,
0.0133873438,
0.0313397534,
-0.0420034416,
0.0237718225,
-0.065885067,
0.039753139,
-0.0198606532,
0.0233294237,
-0.0088438671,
-0.0470735878,
0.0356423706,
-0.0239373595,
0.0111024994,
-0.0089121768,
0.0141938441,
0.0228438787,
-0.037185967,
0.0026512037,
0.0112804146,
0.0254876651,
0.0610751733,
0.0000019849,
-0.0272823945,
-0.0294684637,
0.0249204636,
-0.0656043515,
0.0269983467,
0.0384286307,
0.0190090798,
-0.0296478011,
0.0712883547,
-0.0233723987,
-0.0663193539,
0.0593278334,
-0.0014421616,
0.0126412343,
0.0475249775,
-0.0257950649,
-0.063097477,
-0.0025967672,
-0.0339230709,
-0.0287487339,
-0.0550558381,
-0.01490031,
-0.0141706513,
0.0156665202,
0.0029119763,
-0.0078988615,
0.0556631908,
-0.0082265092,
-0.0476824716,
0.0229639523,
-0.0224746559,
-0.0590452924,
-0.0992046893,
0.0126119927,
0.0427327752,
-0.0093194917,
-0.0187479071,
0.031829197,
0.0092814192,
-0.0227603968,
-0.0326337591,
0.0034198614,
0.0172227174,
0.0218329336,
-0.0093686087,
-0.0056347675,
0.0389275365,
0.036249321,
-0.0408906788,
0.0431745462,
-0.0191260427,
0.0076366193,
-0.0376082435,
-0.0103052864,
-0.0307776686,
0.0341075771,
0.0000521589,
0.045141913,
-0.016118601,
0.0082661025,
-0.0017872404,
-0.0194637906,
-0.0343255363,
0.0049274741,
-0.0238734372,
0.0350836366,
0.0577558167,
-0.0826834142,
0.0195158459,
-0.0070456588,
0.0728158802,
0.011913904,
0.0240401234,
-0.0177091677,
-0.0067588487,
0.0162088964,
0.0220583081,
-0.0394947901,
0.0052885427,
-0.0293836482,
-0.0301711019,
-0.0452593267,
0.0131742209,
-0.0036692908,
0.0104898792,
0.0362342,
-0.0453057289,
-0.0371677838,
-0.0049094516,
0.039480608,
0.0447444469,
0.0336923674,
0.0553564206,
0.0115549071,
-0.0844649449,
-0.0172295384,
0.0282880645,
0.0525474474,
0.003451749,
0.0268353578,
0.0383907743,
-0.0160580147,
-0.0245740507,
-0.044328317,
0.0361873507,
-0.0380643867,
-0.0340248197,
-0.0232986398,
-0.045197688,
0.0613306165,
0.0163194202,
0.0062063378,
-0.0345302671,
0.0030756451,
-0.0290823933,
0.0274823364,
0.0634687692,
-0.0122288372,
0.050873369,
0.0163997728,
-0.0001658386,
-0.0068634087,
0.0375281461,
0.0547564924,
-0.0194551554,
0.0425818786,
-0.0411304012,
-0.0012861044,
0.0619699173,
-0.0100662811,
0.024693666,
0.013546586,
-0.0253310408,
0.056551639,
0.0268221591,
0.0192129482,
0.064788878,
-0.0022182905,
-0.0055714143,
0.0447671674,
0.0155100515,
0.0029416915,
0.0268092416,
0.0396600291,
0.0377362333,
0.0152228121,
-0.0307330955,
0.0140004959,
-0.0034682872,
0.0228154399,
0.0198113695,
0.083540298,
0.0516988076,
-0.034799438,
-0.0002815774,
-0.0295308381,
-0.0089237969,
-0.0247647204,
0.0504890904,
0.0543550029,
0.0069193733,
-0.053474877,
0.022787042,
0.0142142484,
-0.0589558221,
0.0059457449,
-0.0372414365,
-0.0207123663,
0.0266313925,
0.0073875049,
-0.0376432911,
-0.0243415534,
-0.0387605019,
0.0061667501,
0.0458482765,
-0.0102735702,
-0.0065792832,
0.0489863046,
-0.0942109898,
-0.0086742016,
0.0761361644,
-0.0000617184,
0.0530844741,
0.0128093464,
0.0089073582,
0.0197946038,
-0.0483141541,
-0.030880088,
-0.0245013479,
-0.0265392214,
-0.0006621407,
0.0155629227,
0.0405971259,
0.0903900638,
0.0333481058,
-0.0313251726,
-0.0204816684,
0.0258665811,
-0.021195231,
0.0339499936,
0.0160353985,
-0.0179440193,
-0.0062176557,
0.0860108212,
-0.0240304377,
0.0073930835,
0.0663252696,
0.0192615483,
-0.0739612132,
0.034323018,
-0.0020544978,
0.020569114,
-0.0461354293,
0.0730691329,
0.004123155,
0.0297616906,
0.0234541409,
-0.0384828225,
0.0298980288,
0.0079736011,
-0.0021380943,
-0.0029809854,
0.021494057,
-0.0751936808,
-0.0412060432,
0.0217489079,
-0.0451742336,
0.0268340781,
-0.0067765568,
-0.0110601094,
-0.0019266927,
-0.0055568963,
-0.0604808144,
-0.0128956642,
-0.017160356,
0.0273304656,
-0.0470934212,
0.0309102442,
-0.0121578621,
-0.0429079086,
0.0025874025,
-0.0266023576,
0.001735381,
-0.001157932,
-0.0489323325,
-0.0162462164,
-0.0071810796,
-0.0134631107,
-0.0114512332,
0.0241394956,
-0.0179953948,
-0.0049693901,
-0.0525073372,
-0.026468141,
0.0341046862,
0.0220841449,
0.0064367768,
-0.0076861759,
-0.0522913747,
-0.0222650822,
0.0272217579,
0.0034914329,
0.0015852987,
-0.0405745618,
-0.0269880071,
0.0034444076,
0.0071715354,
-0.047370825,
-0.0143890958,
0.0371389985,
-0.031167727,
-0.0124784969,
0.0198696386,
-0.0539524481,
0.025613077,
0.0134084309,
0.03801075,
-0.0388211831,
-0.0534729064,
-0.0338280573,
-0.0066462043,
0.019442372,
-0.0096420292,
-0.030164782,
-0.0052150511,
-0.0067761182,
-0.0163444337,
0.0292488225,
-0.0688486472,
-0.0663744733,
-0.0424730889,
-0.0664496273,
-0.0112165296,
-0.0098236213,
-0.0286064409,
0.0175414961,
0.0116735604,
-0.0552789196,
-0.002954002,
0.0453944691,
0.0244708043,
-0.051960554,
0.0225488171,
-0.010959452,
0.0346177854,
-0.0301223192,
-0.064476192,
-0.0172123406,
-0.0299257189,
-0.0195843317,
0.0152925337,
0.005308121,
-0.046418082,
-0.0468600392,
0.0617602281,
0.0230456237,
0.0577383861,
0.0109089203,
0.0408556201,
-0.0188720189,
0.0473052002,
0.0337494649,
-0.0167003125,
-0.0051119328,
-0.0121964607,
0.0605838336,
0.0007098127,
0.0716471076,
-0.0202669352,
-0.0316884071,
-0.0142726935,
0.0465707146,
0.0236773249,
0.0138802147,
-0.00389456,
0.0301863179,
-0.0132109514,
0.026199894,
0.0940940529,
-0.0215621125,
-0.024459295,
-0.0209068768,
0.0062406724,
0.0284563992,
0.0179658644,
-0.0103070922,
-0.0755568594,
-0.0131781418,
0.0864093825,
0.0490050875,
0.0228638034,
0.0201600697,
-0.0174172465,
-0.1197081134,
0.0376077034,
0.0374506861,
-0.0435083769,
-0.0278242603,
-0.053707581,
-0.020309329,
-0.0367112048,
0.0574348755,
0.0287084635,
-0.0051864092,
-0.0323810354,
0.0621839762,
-0.041546043,
-0.0775875598,
0.0296719167,
-0.0434040911,
0.1000885591,
0.0138399098,
0.0040426869,
-0.0095666898,
-0.0295515191,
0.0470262654,
0.0097367996,
-0.0130007556,
0.0026497554,
-0.001677942,
0.0041167624,
-0.0183986872,
0.0358227193,
0.0252092592,
-0.0221159309,
0.0204136241,
0.0105501143,
0.0754849762,
-0.0096095689,
0.008418736,
0.0484485701,
-0.00715562,
0.0104320748,
0.0467145145,
-0.0014651943,
-0.0354449153,
0.0261516217,
0.0365462303,
0.0140242232,
-0.0038783273,
-0.0152451145,
0.0289088618,
-0.0269629676,
-0.0570675209,
0.0120150289,
0.0018715564,
0.0092868265,
0.0271850936,
0.033459533,
-0.032207109,
0.0071217339,
0.0302642323,
-0.0472189747,
0.0001321397,
-0.0126217175,
0.0108124781,
-0.0761577934,
-0.0323223695,
0.0265402123,
-0.0447957478,
-0.0149115548,
0.0119057521,
-0.0590871722,
-0.0678099617,
0.0304060131,
0.0045764721,
0.0216611344,
0.0337663516,
-0.0405510589,
-0.0230136421,
0.0269967467,
0.0235865731,
-0.0552449115,
0.0059127901,
0.0397397205,
-0.0159340855,
-0.0112730209,
0.0315113403,
-0.0559812374,
0.0215063561,
-0.0400460102,
0.018706955,
-0.0308968052,
-0.0624590926,
-0.0222699605,
0.0387037508,
0.0601666868,
-0.0233612098,
-0.0212505907,
-0.0560896248,
0.0138130318,
0.0084284637,
0.0447644293,
-0.0399142317,
0.0012434674,
0.0396969467,
0.0300021153,
-0.0064098509,
0.0193466917,
-0.0106729157,
-0.0575776137,
-0.0090769222,
0.0505331866,
-0.0159761328,
0.0141747473,
0.0356622152,
0.006370673,
0.0133087328,
0.0512806065,
0.0534630306,
0.0019992231,
0.0203150641,
-0.0003720813,
0.0026406203,
0.0334822088,
0.0379967317,
0.0225685481,
-0.0159696937,
-0.0286411233,
-0.0086313952,
0.0042961352,
0.0564342029,
0.0076474906,
0.0773832947,
0.0092432629,
0.0120451907,
-0.0491407588,
0.036651168,
-0.0209909063,
-0.0361692458,
0.0040762485,
0.0010311876,
-0.0343758352,
0.0866949558,
0.0594508275,
0.0224389117,
0.0136868544,
-0.0113234119,
0.0574039444,
-0.0261072628,
-0.0364276357,
-0.0351536535,
0.0131494328,
-0.0546792857,
-0.0431626774,
-0.0054824497,
-0.0844005644,
-0.0077224723,
-0.0253977608,
-0.0197642986,
-0.0284599327,
-0.0043638879,
-0.0062163984,
-0.033133395,
0.0289402492,
0.0021060624,
-0.0810701773,
-0.0241875481,
-0.0242173132,
0.0527740642,
-6.534733992e-33,
0.0093734581,
0.0273580812,
-0.0141409328,
0.004686716,
-0.0405313112,
0.0298240185,
-0.0233963095,
0.0168229435,
-0.0159647856,
-0.0215524789,
-0.0304307565,
0.0199863967,
0.0532865562,
0.0009711381,
0.0187701732,
-0.0179958157,
0.0889173299,
-0.0058685066,
-0.0015851187,
-0.0095253056,
0.0180464312,
0.0507299788,
0.031126732,
-0.0959891379,
-0.0310051925,
0.0168207493,
-0.0260258187,
-0.0238556396,
0.0269541703,
0.0471677072,
0.0075374427,
0.0522606596,
-0.0390974581,
-0.0241135154,
-0.013981943,
-0.0088392571,
-0.0950813964,
0.0489310622,
-0.0186505914,
0.0928716958,
0.0247941464,
-0.0210507829,
0.014143019,
0.0017696713,
-0.0592460558,
-0.0110738194,
0.0180823915,
-0.0351304747,
-0.0155713651,
-0.0496952794,
0.0111508481,
0.0440678857,
-0.0033774856,
-0.0422539972,
0.0804828778,
0.0636744574,
-0.0114794997,
-0.0301103462,
-0.1043789983,
0.0463163257,
-0.0196113009,
0.0504127517,
0.0422242805,
0.0168036148,
-0.0043331999,
0.0008327652,
0.056678161,
-0.0907246992,
0.0625908747,
-0.0622051395,
0.0219603311,
0.0105969757,
-0.0244835597,
0.0056306385,
0.0229148716,
-0.0700695887,
-0.0238588899,
-0.032078553,
0.0207302496,
0.0137431445,
0.0268843509,
0.0337547101,
-0.0662629977,
-0.0007759328,
-0.0393452458,
-0.0499694198,
-0.0375579633,
-0.0187937673,
0.0419852287,
0.0203056224,
0.0206231512,
0.0174915846,
0.064811267,
-0.0295868013,
0.0249245875,
-0.0054845866,
-0.0054850671,
0.0070016063,
-0.0227500889,
0.0304142516,
-0.0513324104,
-0.0399497673,
0.0165103134,
0.0440798365,
0.0025710212,
-0.0415743887,
-0.0050461339,
0.0748532191,
-0.0762757584,
-0.0030902959,
0.003557388,
0.0273172334,
0.0036309371,
0.036304716,
0.0481395088,
-0.0034479555,
0.0050064437,
0.0584623925,
0.010874005,
0.055009976,
-0.0002831786,
0.0118629131,
-0.0072311303,
-0.0196514595,
-0.0540579334,
0.0323359855,
-0.0143929264,
-0.012015136,
0.002263196,
-0.0221061539,
-0.0106574558,
0.0015195925,
2.941e-7,
-0.0608094819,
0.0262518954,
0.0456174277,
-0.0482279025,
0.0005628595,
0.0275550112,
-0.0031170461,
-0.0375223234,
-0.0309204776,
0.011255295,
0.0078160558,
-0.0040806984,
0.1314193755,
0.0182921477,
-0.1208194345,
-0.0438767038,
-0.0565530509,
0.0086155944,
-0.0028187467,
0.0074043106,
-0.0266125519,
0.1169707328,
-0.0105020059,
-0.0362452976,
0.0137735913,
-0.0178005435,
0.0156054487,
0.0468787141,
-0.020464031,
-0.0030964613,
0.0029808679,
0.0157928187,
-0.0148673672,
-0.019349413,
-0.0480593927,
0.0250899754,
0.0207282659,
0.068318516,
-0.0153360199,
-0.0287128258,
-0.0025635422,
0.0549065098,
-0.0440316647,
-0.0373191349,
0.0357166529,
0.0498849526,
-0.032726083,
-0.0208813846,
-0.0417828262,
-0.0075746588,
-0.0105352979,
-0.0143800015,
0.0024483264,
0.0164158978,
0.0288937371,
-0.0380534716,
-0.0442722887,
-0.0183631573,
-0.0002943133,
-0.0154970745,
-0.0347103775,
-0.0059716199,
-0.0040927078,
0.0311294403,
0.0254883263,
0.0061319629,
0.0201347843,
2.218683369e-34,
0.053520266,
-0.0374173671,
0.0250879228,
-0.0237918496,
-0.0039704833,
-0.0373317562,
0.0021116131,
0.0114473142,
-0.0201097466,
-0.0149274757,
-0.0364370272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11514v1 | Counterfactual Debating with Preset Stances for Hallucination Elimination of LLMs | 2024-06-17T13:21:23 | 2024-06-17T13:21:23 | Yi Fang, Moxin Li, Wenjie Wang, Hui Lin, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in various natural language processing
tasks but struggle with hallucination issues. Existing solutions have
considered utilizing LLMs' inherent reasoning abilities to alleviate
hallucination, such as self-correction and diverse sampling methods. However,
these methods often overtrust LLMs' initial answers due to inherent biases. The
key to alleviating this issue lies in overriding LLMs' inherent biases for
answer inspection. To this end, we propose a CounterFactual Multi-Agent Debate
(CFMAD) framework. CFMAD presets the stances of LLMs to override their inherent
biases by compelling LLMs to generate justifications for a predetermined
answer's correctness. The LLMs with different predetermined stances are engaged
with a skeptical critic for counterfactual debate on the rationality of
generated justifications. Finally, the debate process is evaluated by a
third-party judge to determine the final answer. Extensive experiments on four
datasets of three tasks demonstrate the superiority of CFMAD over existing
methods. | [
0.046444755,
0.0751262456,
-0.0239057243,
0.0319785886,
-0.0827974677,
0.0060273916,
0.0144719258,
-0.0229399279,
0.0147407018,
-0.0568941385,
-0.0135438731,
-0.0272712074,
-0.014031345,
-0.0345565006,
0.0215370767,
-0.0139821861,
0.0634735152,
-0.0471458696,
0.0515212901,
-0.0548772104,
0.0082392804,
-0.0092855887,
-0.0192477778,
0.0091459546,
-0.0065703322,
-0.0301910602,
-0.0025372833,
-0.0337188654,
0.0009646103,
-0.0136236874,
-0.0000630222,
0.0632926971,
-0.0043150801,
0.0602443777,
0.0000020358,
-0.0622715019,
-0.0305702966,
-0.0198400933,
-0.0451771952,
-0.0152199538,
0.0222564675,
0.0497040749,
0.0004641985,
0.0045337658,
-0.054067824,
0.0432483219,
0.0177105926,
0.0722572878,
0.0738577247,
0.0593259744,
0.0260705911,
-0.0446381979,
-0.0003109727,
0.0190980323,
-0.0136505896,
-0.002487696,
0.019890273,
0.0296929348,
-0.0325423069,
-0.0123228552,
-0.0061126589,
0.0199653711,
0.0035000697,
0.0036319003,
-0.0154191656,
-0.0219046492,
-0.0784357637,
-0.0300766118,
-0.0158696659,
0.0494431034,
0.0345167443,
-0.0570005476,
0.0088250516,
-0.0214339402,
0.0209177658,
0.0538676754,
-0.0442545377,
0.0411536284,
-0.0182392467,
0.0188421607,
0.0247491151,
0.006814546,
0.0281501114,
0.0243241284,
-0.0346472375,
0.1006661803,
-0.0118441032,
-0.0349284336,
0.0449423902,
0.0225046519,
0.0170899797,
-0.0467284508,
0.009822228,
0.0053533041,
-0.0737382025,
0.0299750715,
0.0254120994,
-0.0128465956,
0.0411880799,
-0.0761687979,
-0.0194854792,
-0.0102302013,
-0.0072856694,
0.0653623343,
-0.0289568547,
-0.0010343468,
-0.0422108695,
0.0795159563,
0.0054128645,
-0.0113389855,
-0.0247722156,
-0.0310714468,
-0.0318680331,
0.0471051075,
-0.0191836674,
0.0213182922,
0.0227513816,
-0.0029128608,
-0.0849585161,
0.0151463188,
-0.0016240161,
0.0601238459,
0.0215618424,
-0.035596434,
-0.081208311,
0.0443351045,
-0.032512255,
0.0200528819,
0.0273144972,
-0.0610251166,
-0.0261886101,
0.0169142019,
-0.0117601193,
-0.0123623004,
0.015585606,
0.0635849908,
-0.0080661345,
0.0119273122,
-0.0148846097,
-0.0516179018,
-0.0211429261,
-0.098635681,
-0.0013184315,
-0.0575551279,
0.0026295104,
-0.0258247908,
-0.0111711361,
-0.0483003668,
0.0203194357,
0.0098183323,
0.0053384928,
0.1141947284,
0.0095166573,
-0.0051436373,
0.0554313436,
0.0236087181,
-0.0517889597,
0.0769953579,
0.0092214104,
-0.0095942961,
0.0362279341,
0.0122021819,
0.0445822105,
-0.003417728,
0.0338213146,
-0.0149368988,
-0.0096440632,
0.0123457229,
-0.0445536301,
0.0301510468,
-0.0146101797,
0.068184562,
-0.0280209351,
-0.0543544441,
0.0643892959,
0.0428629257,
-0.0224518366,
-0.0145816766,
-0.0096354242,
-0.0125784511,
0.0002826388,
0.0459843203,
-0.0340145677,
0.0332208835,
-0.0202371813,
-0.0307831857,
0.0394806974,
-0.0008627091,
-0.015945375,
-0.0521937646,
0.0102481227,
0.0069839074,
0.0538032725,
0.0515365042,
0.0248300936,
0.0276770294,
-0.0269897394,
0.0154882111,
-0.0123406723,
-0.0395780541,
-0.0111094546,
-0.0699857473,
0.0250947084,
0.0379551351,
0.0592753477,
-0.0230000634,
-0.0053428253,
-0.0323612802,
0.0344390757,
0.0610940903,
0.0628331304,
-0.0157724656,
-0.0297515355,
-0.0413937643,
-0.0342466161,
-0.0124582537,
0.0223173518,
0.0130223632,
-0.0114955474,
-0.0213986132,
-0.0013576503,
0.0183634367,
-0.0026692599,
0.0376062281,
0.0173271913,
-0.0077627478,
-0.030166287,
0.0022557029,
0.0549989268,
0.0251240786,
-0.0072061392,
0.0384788662,
0.0382667258,
-0.0054964302,
-0.0367173292,
0.0292271487,
-0.023483837,
-0.0451383106,
0.035868194,
-0.0500596426,
-0.0181126092,
-0.0019072617,
-0.0066043972,
-0.0293952711,
0.0360574611,
-0.0159819499,
0.0152066061,
-0.0453741997,
0.0248657539,
-0.0148868402,
-0.0064325617,
-0.0415290333,
0.0566888824,
0.0041024527,
-0.0107777491,
0.0288618021,
0.0204796903,
-0.0051684608,
-0.0496099703,
-0.0149898045,
0.0262394026,
0.0380425192,
0.0024181656,
0.0427727848,
-0.0670545474,
-0.0540816933,
-0.0167229418,
-0.0720358118,
-0.0142032588,
-0.0179669615,
0.0008783631,
-0.0066201175,
-0.0560406372,
0.009908963,
-0.0051861596,
-0.040850509,
-0.0152053023,
0.0349523574,
0.037633881,
0.0174067095,
-0.0053004306,
0.0055263522,
-0.0023990548,
0.0242980644,
-0.0244365092,
0.0404480845,
0.0209368952,
-0.0365214907,
-0.0694990978,
-0.0161812454,
-0.0655496493,
0.0132233799,
-0.0018601487,
-0.0069730598,
0.0597545281,
0.0382591076,
-0.0052388851,
0.0778337717,
0.0305073131,
0.0068320716,
0.0618465319,
-0.0032672384,
-0.0789003894,
-0.0084757442,
0.004462298,
0.0463245325,
-0.0086883353,
-0.0408211909,
-0.0002465948,
0.062892206,
0.0193801243,
-0.0088257277,
-0.0496328846,
0.0960858464,
-0.0046181357,
-0.053147357,
0.028451873,
-0.0767531544,
-0.0548205264,
0.0612675697,
-0.0295722857,
-0.0298264883,
0.0954376534,
-0.0158150736,
0.0037706243,
-0.031360466,
0.0222930405,
-0.0268301796,
0.0376502834,
-0.0116489865,
-0.0084718876,
0.0052980902,
0.030802073,
-0.0482196994,
-0.047289703,
0.0428225249,
-0.0526793413,
0.0320185199,
-0.061280217,
0.0076547367,
0.0067187855,
0.0020853803,
-0.0499699786,
-0.0425509773,
-0.0352548212,
-0.0156338755,
-0.0147410249,
0.0519376136,
-0.0228261668,
0.0197749175,
0.0030282107,
0.003498381,
0.0145708648,
0.0000507674,
-0.0024763986,
-0.0240924172,
0.0186522976,
0.0480874851,
0.0739002228,
-0.0058783651,
0.0527544655,
0.0849467665,
0.0387683548,
-0.0046827947,
0.0038101138,
-0.0275981948,
0.0013435089,
-0.0145697044,
0.0135477381,
-0.0092556635,
0.0478148125,
-0.0416215248,
0.0193390492,
0.0691497922,
0.0477456339,
-0.0211005211,
-0.0137479417,
-0.0291941985,
0.0179145709,
0.0124381408,
-0.0255220402,
-0.0886000693,
-0.0105131455,
-0.0000525721,
0.0010629373,
-0.064162612,
-0.0471566729,
-0.0265891887,
-0.1154238433,
0.0233652908,
0.029280439,
0.0219511967,
0.0405613892,
-0.0191653632,
0.0179367904,
-0.0266065095,
0.0087444782,
0.0097095249,
0.0454316884,
-0.0084141167,
0.0221961699,
-0.0075347773,
0.0162149575,
0.0179060735,
-0.0293443576,
0.0883982852,
0.0417563133,
0.026758112,
0.0313833319,
-0.0546985082,
0.0462035798,
-0.037233524,
-0.0083365496,
-0.0137546733,
0.0167592019,
-0.010503483,
0.0090351598,
-0.0230638739,
0.0302482136,
0.0082821753,
-0.0578122996,
0.0158534609,
0.0638721734,
-0.0463152751,
-0.0304702222,
-0.0093654664,
0.0484713875,
-0.0043275608,
0.086965166,
0.0323971212,
-0.0209339522,
-0.0641858876,
-0.0445861742,
-0.0087260017,
-0.04612647,
-0.0486242436,
0.0096340673,
0.0531732813,
0.0203291159,
-0.065440841,
-0.0620692149,
0.0050501223,
0.0246600192,
-0.0188383404,
0.0324314721,
0.0006240128,
0.0174620748,
0.0122634079,
0.0127154337,
-0.0452184863,
0.0146513665,
0.003516179,
-0.0262743682,
-0.0089225136,
-0.0179109592,
-0.0018069431,
0.0271911062,
-0.0403670333,
-0.0876763687,
0.0126733361,
0.0431038849,
0.0322868079,
0.0541840345,
-0.000655604,
-0.0330027044,
0.0233262926,
0.0121342978,
-0.0021630423,
0.0133002233,
0.043960128,
0.0050953217,
-0.0021000151,
0.0327783152,
0.021087829,
-0.0007764836,
0.0261504278,
0.0576058924,
-0.0470420457,
-0.0136930561,
0.0462628715,
-0.0082834242,
0.0364637077,
-0.0019858163,
0.0258182716,
-0.0283733178,
0.0158224311,
-0.0402680822,
-0.0426297709,
-0.0005882441,
-0.0030458516,
-0.0101864496,
-0.0577273965,
0.0127671901,
-0.0131107103,
-0.0582907647,
0.0197982136,
0.032643456,
0.0461310372,
0.0272825677,
0.0060133073,
-0.0260475986,
-0.011099861,
-0.0052649509,
0.0346397683,
0.0013377179,
0.0527788103,
0.0270595327,
0.0716626793,
0.0179942474,
-0.0302463602,
-0.0108129466,
0.0015591137,
-0.072776027,
-0.0421934575,
0.0160553884,
0.0258752406,
-0.0069366079,
0.0145165892,
0.0196416955,
-0.0017982391,
0.0097685382,
0.0198004805,
-0.0109916348,
0.0512554981,
-0.0084183104,
0.011101569,
0.0273393672,
-0.0331683792,
-0.0185784698,
0.0537523031,
-0.0383212902,
0.0350747891,
-0.0206611156,
-0.0170341656,
-0.0415859818,
-0.109424755,
-0.0603271089,
-0.013678561,
-0.026213279,
-0.0314809047,
-0.0716509447,
-0.0376805067,
-0.035518121,
0.0356949568,
0.0091300635,
-0.0230742935,
0.0061041513,
0.0532911681,
-0.0118545201,
-0.0229154825,
-0.0316782594,
0.0201738514,
0.03673096,
0.0234968085,
-0.0205933638,
-6.241496641e-33,
-0.0214927439,
-0.0630700216,
0.0278565492,
-0.0577481948,
0.0044264635,
-0.0485061258,
-0.0023399966,
0.0110812522,
-0.020011209,
0.0161670558,
-0.0072496934,
0.026324125,
0.0320288911,
-0.0178473778,
-0.0053367717,
-0.0402696244,
0.0296515096,
-0.0072634555,
-0.0539638251,
-0.0127134258,
-0.0050569936,
-0.0256356951,
0.0249738768,
-0.065705359,
0.0714897066,
0.0093104616,
-0.0119888019,
0.0423387662,
-0.0690642595,
0.0413369648,
0.0004421194,
0.0329780616,
0.0229565632,
-0.0546678454,
-0.0224681124,
0.017930897,
-0.0147535624,
-0.013997172,
0.0643951893,
0.0179334953,
0.0125467069,
-0.0227086209,
0.0286931302,
-0.0068142721,
-0.033436086,
0.0297779255,
-0.008107191,
-0.0486712605,
0.0154055124,
0.048036661,
-0.0365118757,
0.012551791,
-0.0119631924,
0.0027780454,
0.0073251957,
0.034801852,
-0.0078456504,
-0.0057512964,
-0.086433202,
0.0504808202,
0.0274021775,
-0.0572121963,
0.0573630929,
0.000422236,
0.0281633157,
0.0721345395,
0.0521765314,
0.0436243638,
-0.0777103901,
-0.0764599144,
-0.0122434152,
0.0309441518,
0.088127546,
0.0755416676,
0.0375939272,
-0.0104592033,
-0.0367310829,
-0.0175184011,
0.003313882,
0.0165977795,
0.0506546013,
0.017649686,
-0.023936471,
-0.0250079464,
-0.0549065322,
-0.0248852465,
-0.0279142372,
-0.0235928502,
0.0056956364,
0.009708832,
-0.0496197045,
0.0022598959,
0.0327645876,
-0.0590572357,
-0.0065136789,
0.0187898166,
0.0301959421,
-0.0175760314,
-0.0078275036,
-0.0098217884,
-0.0254491456,
0.029844854,
0.014141283,
0.0311953984,
0.0383529924,
-0.0113770394,
-0.0159769598,
-0.0315881185,
-0.0467067473,
0.0138107985,
-0.0391867645,
0.0205313601,
0.0076338132,
-0.0113689322,
0.0557824709,
0.0285530444,
-0.0183819756,
0.0060592121,
0.0044698035,
-0.0259528235,
-0.0350459144,
0.0407152325,
-0.0277973153,
0.0159120094,
-0.0257169288,
0.0068572857,
-0.0136056999,
0.0127561018,
0.0013813999,
-0.0383279175,
-0.0046208403,
0.0043436764,
2.736e-7,
0.0136237899,
0.0446821377,
0.0160303786,
0.0004012904,
0.0340934508,
0.0188134257,
-0.0121541321,
-0.0141388196,
0.020440191,
-0.071938023,
0.0096503422,
0.0459424257,
0.0370349959,
0.0619385727,
-0.0486071557,
-0.0336587206,
-0.0491339788,
-0.0076661231,
-0.0398908779,
-0.0098945387,
0.0542335324,
0.037726447,
-0.000413959,
0.0066804569,
-0.0295711271,
-0.0221427921,
0.0651744157,
-0.0155487657,
0.0104358122,
0.0253574438,
0.0283285379,
-0.0529359281,
0.0179428607,
0.0624666773,
0.028837692,
-0.0183903091,
-0.0251042321,
0.030191483,
-0.0003054485,
-0.0923414081,
-0.0497042835,
-0.0068914448,
0.0161014143,
-0.0392145365,
0.0660360903,
-0.0365362428,
-0.0280357748,
-0.022634415,
-0.0313480608,
-0.0567349307,
0.0502959304,
-0.0015335317,
-0.0363852903,
0.0150228096,
0.0055704466,
0.0309890509,
0.0112756127,
-0.0778357461,
-0.0374424271,
-0.0061749173,
-0.0402021669,
-0.0359086581,
0.0112669822,
-0.0060041295,
0.0094626602,
-0.0713693053,
0.0086024832,
2.247451297e-34,
0.0299487468,
0.0236980189,
0.0214181263,
0.0307591688,
0.0437664427,
0.0323065072,
0.0171657614,
0.0013451905,
0.0494644679,
-0.0349462591,
-0.0169900097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11930v1 | A Critical Study of What Code-LLMs (Do Not) Learn | 2024-06-17T13:11:17 | 2024-06-17T13:11:17 | Abhinav Anand, Shweta Verma, Krishna Narasimhan, Mira Mezini | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models trained on code corpora (code-LLMs) have demonstrated
impressive performance in various coding assistance tasks. However, despite
their increased size and training dataset, code-LLMs still have limitations
such as suggesting codes with syntactic errors, variable misuse etc. Some
studies argue that code-LLMs perform well on coding tasks because they use
self-attention and hidden representations to encode relations among input
tokens. However, previous works have not studied what code properties are not
encoded by code-LLMs. In this paper, we conduct a fine-grained analysis of
attention maps and hidden representations of code-LLMs. Our study indicates
that code-LLMs only encode relations among specific subsets of input tokens.
Specifically, by categorizing input tokens into syntactic tokens and
identifiers, we found that models encode relations among syntactic tokens and
among identifiers, but they fail to encode relations between syntactic tokens
and identifiers. We also found that fine-tuned models encode these relations
poorly compared to their pre-trained counterparts. Additionally, larger models
with billions of parameters encode significantly less information about code
than models with only a few hundred million parameters. | [
0.0221157651,
0.0417586789,
-0.0292745698,
0.0495857894,
0.0032927208,
0.0428413339,
-0.0526573174,
0.0228555966,
0.0019125027,
-0.0394653752,
-0.0561244003,
0.0290709231,
0.0033105423,
0.0255714227,
0.063179642,
-0.0059493599,
0.0563399009,
-0.0309451278,
-0.0261468478,
0.023347903,
-0.0045078914,
0.0010532909,
0.0265335813,
0.0521376543,
-0.0087710265,
-0.0246275123,
0.00687224,
0.005440216,
-0.0290259924,
-0.0241086744,
0.0204069447,
0.0518136211,
0.003586778,
0.0172382481,
0.0000018368,
-0.0382753573,
0.0051042815,
-0.054653462,
-0.0356490426,
0.0305839572,
-0.0183920059,
-0.0441392548,
-0.0049130507,
0.009991033,
-0.0313178785,
-0.0335639268,
0.0935849026,
-0.0260952003,
0.0384013653,
0.0671741888,
0.0120592369,
0.0036282858,
0.0262112413,
-0.0346358977,
0.0460896268,
-0.0185907278,
0.0199767333,
0.0049798293,
-0.0041592149,
0.0363062099,
-0.0230279285,
0.0251817498,
0.0167928711,
-0.0029130182,
0.0571765862,
0.0496063977,
-0.0501650125,
-0.0193841215,
0.0008102346,
0.0456384383,
-0.0562982634,
-0.0489129759,
-0.0086449087,
-0.0068673114,
0.0136314416,
-0.0616181716,
-0.0250495858,
0.0265906658,
-0.0213486664,
0.0381861292,
0.0334387608,
-0.0142203318,
0.0337043256,
-0.0063185329,
-0.0210569073,
0.040998619,
-0.0199233945,
-0.0051710568,
-0.0154509107,
-0.0098348632,
0.0109276194,
-0.0809459686,
0.010022128,
0.0465662368,
0.033598382,
0.0074348003,
-0.0388499051,
-0.016456956,
0.030676648,
-0.0633485392,
0.029687304,
0.0294528808,
-0.0595980994,
0.0407957025,
-0.0875088722,
0.0704729035,
-0.0153915482,
0.0554049984,
-0.026101768,
-0.0059142462,
-0.04430658,
-0.0188297164,
-0.0581882298,
0.0843725204,
0.0203966573,
0.0085789869,
-0.0021976628,
0.0488698147,
0.0090321423,
0.0437414944,
-0.0368485525,
-0.0174382962,
-0.0195298493,
0.0055146301,
-0.0098265223,
-0.0204891395,
-0.0260565095,
-0.0288833715,
-0.0235274564,
-0.061088413,
-0.020705983,
0.0273881368,
-0.0174345449,
-0.0384361669,
0.0177826304,
0.0872692019,
0.0259029884,
-0.0100101838,
-0.0562556535,
-0.0039707716,
0.0010125623,
-0.0099031376,
-0.0015548145,
-0.0775789618,
-0.0428948589,
0.0553842783,
0.0064741955,
-0.1033103764,
0.0157716386,
-0.0028865244,
-0.0423384383,
0.0794431567,
-0.0342516899,
-0.0029971928,
-0.0029547415,
0.0153705375,
-0.0407238603,
0.0364091285,
0.0165436324,
0.0102509214,
0.0132226609,
-0.0603004843,
0.0395289175,
-0.0128264353,
-0.0052872212,
0.0024538545,
-0.0270868018,
0.0268908832,
0.0505501889,
-0.0027061636,
0.0804410651,
0.0150919631,
0.0061057806,
-0.0486486927,
0.0176976714,
0.0489908271,
0.0453775227,
0.0663721338,
0.0532576256,
-0.0115053561,
0.0102283796,
0.008144442,
-0.088900432,
0.0523692518,
-0.0128570935,
0.010282876,
0.0334126987,
-0.0150725665,
-0.0188464653,
-0.0621309876,
-0.0254602004,
-0.018390758,
0.0126927719,
-0.0110944724,
0.0217313897,
-0.0130916918,
-0.0237153675,
0.0410899185,
0.0249256101,
-0.0323646031,
0.0097090136,
-0.0431521833,
0.0233022217,
0.0500725135,
0.0214858931,
-0.049693279,
-0.0250897147,
-0.0083632767,
-0.0031634611,
-0.0146849221,
0.0185115524,
0.0158931594,
0.0343168862,
-0.0263304207,
-0.0089750895,
-0.0441767536,
0.0050965608,
0.0436828546,
-0.003856519,
-0.0254193004,
0.01644901,
-0.0001557847,
-0.0441842526,
0.043361783,
0.0280936528,
-0.0144837778,
-0.00057209,
0.0038145042,
0.0311617609,
-0.0141404485,
-0.0018430183,
0.0399625264,
0.0228762049,
-0.0249599628,
0.0137989372,
-0.0361336246,
-0.0374989696,
-0.0331247225,
0.0191310663,
-0.0196978115,
-0.0176990703,
0.0379917435,
0.0193158779,
-0.0131914252,
0.0559749827,
-0.0620335601,
0.070796594,
-0.0047272178,
0.036912661,
0.0209311508,
0.0108488547,
-0.0100115864,
0.0530713573,
-0.0061428258,
0.050886564,
-0.0116298562,
0.0694721937,
0.0161771644,
0.0035574634,
0.0233925059,
0.0029846367,
-0.0301482361,
0.0133696767,
-0.0103023322,
0.0076002399,
-0.0307408534,
-0.0217692237,
-0.0517906249,
0.0005951501,
-0.0129902977,
0.0148193184,
0.0079145832,
-0.0090056323,
-0.0032401392,
-0.0376367904,
-0.0235404428,
0.0056873756,
-0.0593051538,
0.002475027,
0.0555956736,
0.0014272601,
-0.0358680747,
-0.0570665486,
-0.0092378063,
-0.0414734036,
0.0326874331,
-0.0139432373,
-0.0451521166,
-0.0666858777,
0.0564792417,
0.002549876,
0.020638641,
-0.0040374948,
-0.0946490169,
0.0169423334,
-0.023489682,
0.0152474539,
0.0660439953,
-0.0186338183,
0.0132957911,
0.0602697693,
-0.0110225175,
-0.0634795576,
0.0196009614,
0.0219506864,
-0.032000035,
-0.0306721088,
-0.0061662323,
0.0306805708,
0.1032054499,
0.0048582912,
-0.000965773,
-0.0678539649,
0.0042476836,
0.0295048337,
0.018293066,
0.0010372299,
-0.0291022323,
-0.0145123526,
0.0504616499,
-0.0348475538,
-0.1068756208,
0.073632203,
-0.0471319109,
-0.0443417057,
-0.0148657616,
-0.0140214395,
-0.0490370914,
0.0503120981,
0.0082648657,
0.0326344408,
0.0497970134,
-0.0884936824,
-0.0257371739,
0.0224137884,
-0.0301750619,
-0.0063275266,
0.0382390842,
-0.0253354143,
0.0098230941,
0.012924144,
-0.0249712467,
-0.0455203094,
-0.0294031482,
-0.0144370552,
-0.0088308919,
0.0391769744,
-0.0049245111,
0.0296666175,
0.0068656486,
0.0130211934,
0.0420158841,
0.0247007404,
-0.0283571389,
-0.0235015228,
-0.0438507721,
-0.026838351,
-0.0194713268,
0.0044848225,
0.000354901,
-0.0321472362,
0.0092394045,
0.0170096699,
0.0386677235,
-0.0294590071,
0.0487386584,
0.0464270301,
-0.03186737,
-0.0460767634,
0.0245982409,
0.0376467034,
-0.0424725153,
-0.0144118816,
0.101019159,
0.0501499176,
-0.0849896893,
0.0289993156,
-0.0343468599,
-0.0052414737,
0.0655117035,
0.0114133973,
-0.0553610362,
-0.0293211099,
-0.0006356046,
0.0132130003,
-0.0035696183,
-0.0241378993,
-0.0081300857,
-0.0895572901,
0.0040921606,
0.0273422841,
-0.039899718,
-0.0930821598,
-0.0211506579,
0.0103504304,
-0.0000214448,
-0.028194787,
0.0168665629,
-0.0349311754,
-0.0082436735,
0.0128437243,
-0.0333595015,
0.0030523404,
0.0093946019,
-0.0475837886,
0.0614967532,
0.1004235521,
-0.0031870299,
-0.0049887132,
0.0039630705,
0.0234419387,
-0.0112743229,
0.0304164477,
-0.0312303659,
0.0470622741,
-0.0338409916,
-0.0239509679,
0.0326864608,
0.037735302,
-0.0613995492,
-0.0098995287,
0.019996725,
0.0526460744,
-0.0169421565,
-0.0143314991,
0.0008751356,
-0.0099891899,
-0.0323877148,
0.052695442,
0.0933509395,
-0.0095862625,
-0.0236470923,
-0.0596768633,
0.0230573881,
-0.0164391529,
0.0061619123,
0.0118554765,
0.0112585379,
-0.0316133872,
-0.0704693422,
-0.0532213897,
0.0421726704,
0.0043085809,
0.0014633685,
0.0054026549,
-0.0152012557,
-0.0064768083,
-0.0414424688,
0.0348031819,
-0.0350948535,
-0.0084809642,
-0.0681846812,
-0.0344422236,
0.0152528426,
-0.0238915123,
-0.0002585415,
-0.0280889776,
-0.0892569721,
-0.0262661818,
-0.0135331163,
0.0619368367,
0.0172159988,
0.0415440463,
-0.0584468134,
-0.0678675175,
-0.0562768877,
0.0054477877,
-0.0864304528,
0.0163060464,
0.0493923016,
0.0044686883,
0.0209109802,
0.0427052937,
-0.0422296859,
-0.0040616328,
0.0269436911,
-0.0030939977,
-0.0482442491,
-0.0133545902,
0.0400483124,
-0.0210738853,
0.04882247,
0.024494905,
0.0084034763,
0.0007105113,
0.0173445567,
0.0188300628,
-0.0085151521,
-0.0306075197,
0.0004971999,
0.0406495892,
-0.0236406103,
0.0304578915,
-0.0235712416,
-0.0296700615,
0.0310812723,
-0.0023254594,
0.0812515244,
0.0155756436,
0.037263792,
0.041525878,
0.0052400641,
-0.0271043926,
0.0153701259,
-0.0021914137,
0.0190655626,
-0.021050591,
0.0142585728,
-0.002393994,
0.0054381341,
0.0076591596,
0.0121276891,
-0.0332333148,
-0.0547566377,
-0.0019209774,
0.0031559879,
0.0543195829,
0.0070723649,
-0.0027000983,
-0.0211462751,
0.0203335267,
-0.0260930117,
0.0342889056,
-0.0308689065,
-0.0146305664,
0.0280970633,
0.0404625349,
-0.024903249,
-0.0376318097,
0.10523884,
0.0105185611,
0.0265097469,
-0.0154823428,
-0.0176911503,
-0.0367250293,
0.0366739221,
0.0441211797,
0.0227483008,
-0.0210775677,
0.031711299,
-0.0204598308,
-0.0693207681,
0.0084855333,
-0.0132303294,
0.005753106,
-0.023627419,
0.0214716233,
0.0737532303,
0.0155361965,
-0.0143758999,
-0.0308468305,
0.0232554749,
0.027593147,
-0.0326483287,
-0.0329462253,
-6.055931633e-33,
-0.0377694368,
-0.0469044894,
-0.0275946539,
0.0132571403,
0.009100752,
0.0169597846,
-0.0593351759,
-0.0051289313,
-0.0364546403,
-0.0398771316,
0.006335095,
0.046275612,
-0.0149598476,
-0.0224857628,
0.0875301808,
-0.0245301072,
0.022306418,
0.018076472,
-0.0407886915,
0.0112175131,
-0.0124109276,
0.022695791,
0.062801674,
-0.034517996,
0.0126480218,
-0.0068641421,
0.024744885,
0.0168365631,
0.0350480191,
0.0783820674,
-0.0093903895,
0.0211293921,
0.0218420755,
-0.0078549329,
-0.0418753847,
0.0037170851,
-0.0599772371,
-0.0456387699,
0.0380391628,
0.0049174298,
0.0231003501,
-0.1120047122,
0.0921126902,
-0.0016879839,
0.0209409911,
-0.0099116582,
0.0283159669,
-0.0104916273,
-0.0177934468,
-0.0026644296,
-0.0374445543,
0.0377351865,
-0.0489243902,
-0.0149449939,
0.0311717354,
0.0017359309,
-0.0015297001,
0.0550370701,
-0.008971842,
-0.0099159647,
0.0151625108,
0.0862288475,
0.0418757796,
0.0061748298,
-0.0002247567,
0.0314059369,
0.0283761676,
-0.0053194058,
-0.0211111847,
0.0274448059,
0.0433578677,
0.0491239056,
0.0336907059,
-0.0081229676,
0.0213795677,
0.0249483939,
-0.0222286545,
-0.0169049706,
-0.0249221809,
0.0657634959,
-0.0010075052,
0.0468412973,
-0.0574508868,
-0.0191105213,
-0.0103361644,
-0.0338898748,
-0.0431680121,
-0.064352721,
0.0304708518,
-0.0297738053,
-0.0022102864,
0.0318050385,
0.0199149027,
-0.0319307223,
-0.0075668748,
0.0176429469,
0.0071392581,
0.0511520803,
0.0157957301,
0.0146361925,
-0.0726716295,
-0.015354584,
0.0238456503,
-0.0190468691,
0.069984518,
0.0307202097,
0.0410991348,
0.0230089966,
-0.0535071865,
-0.045871947,
-0.0412523001,
-0.0323214233,
-0.0289711487,
0.0081691649,
0.0373396389,
0.0113837849,
-0.0012072162,
0.0302108154,
-0.0256112646,
-0.0069678514,
-0.0545576699,
0.0056631127,
-0.0192676187,
0.0394473188,
-0.0417254306,
-0.0580997244,
-0.0595972687,
0.0584718809,
0.0552640855,
-0.0078379391,
-0.030488234,
0.0238911584,
2.646e-7,
0.0565524958,
0.0467280634,
0.0309211873,
0.0262278691,
-0.0014629704,
0.0408642814,
-0.0334653519,
0.0275543462,
0.0065627117,
-0.0220359545,
-0.0128148636,
0.015895335,
0.0321454331,
0.0183304865,
-0.0573277771,
0.0203703102,
-0.0180909242,
0.0029908125,
-0.0276774038,
-0.0085043609,
0.0455395579,
0.1113119423,
0.00543465,
0.0231329966,
0.0133702569,
-0.0480759069,
0.009014369,
-0.0382658988,
0.0367140137,
0.0043856781,
-0.0530063957,
0.0342894383,
-0.0197483711,
0.0038457292,
-0.0009687185,
0.0054906583,
0.0020523332,
0.0609478988,
-0.0446360856,
-0.0076697897,
-0.0092558758,
-0.0098398197,
0.0055836262,
-0.0898287594,
0.0464920662,
-0.0389371365,
0.0053821076,
0.0206509531,
0.0248365141,
0.0287037287,
-0.015601648,
-0.0045582689,
-0.0127820233,
0.0209027026,
-0.0024284171,
-0.0448357575,
-0.0125001958,
-0.0786091238,
-0.052612558,
0.0203147084,
-0.0052831625,
-0.0294598285,
-0.0665914044,
0.0025694694,
0.0575606562,
-0.0371555462,
0.0033312987,
2.34014821e-34,
0.0011619686,
-0.0552586354,
0.0223918036,
0.06144014,
0.0414839499,
-0.0235986002,
-0.035515368,
0.0556160733,
0.0319958329,
-0.0229386762,
-0.0038760568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11503v1 | GeoGPT4V: Towards Geometric Multi-modal Large Language Models with Geometric Image Generation | 2024-06-17T13:04:27 | 2024-06-17T13:04:27 | Shihao Cai, Keqin Bao, Hangyu Guo, Jizhi Zhang, Jun Song, Bo Zheng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large language models have seen widespread adoption in math problem-solving.
However, in geometry problems that usually require visual aids for better
understanding, even the most advanced multi-modal models currently still face
challenges in effectively using image information. High-quality data is crucial
for enhancing the geometric capabilities of multi-modal models, yet existing
open-source datasets and related efforts are either too challenging for direct
model learning or suffer from misalignment between text and images. To overcome
this issue, we introduce a novel pipeline that leverages GPT-4 and GPT-4V to
generate relatively basic geometry problems with aligned text and images,
facilitating model learning. We have produced a dataset of 4.9K geometry
problems and combined it with 19K open-source data to form our GeoGPT4V
dataset. Experimental results demonstrate that the GeoGPT4V dataset
significantly improves the geometry performance of various models on the
MathVista and MathVision benchmarks. The code is available at
https://github.com/Lanyu0303/GeoGPT4V_Project | [
-0.0492013134,
0.1123985723,
-0.0111151664,
0.0836902857,
-0.0503309034,
0.0103464853,
0.0291563943,
0.0088102659,
-0.0154658984,
-0.023949476,
0.0017028518,
-0.0149237337,
0.0022865427,
0.0299980044,
0.04572317,
-0.0890379176,
-0.045393616,
-0.0866685584,
-0.0135744335,
-0.0299937166,
-0.0077286968,
0.0323419198,
-0.0246972796,
0.0159693789,
-0.0738858879,
-0.0615432449,
-0.0282518156,
0.0034474873,
0.0262029525,
-0.0294245183,
-0.0125326067,
0.0748746917,
0.0466961712,
0.0720157549,
0.0000021535,
-0.0001383816,
-0.0149305407,
0.0541512482,
0.0307892766,
0.0264065377,
0.0293714255,
-0.0741838291,
-0.0249604974,
-0.0479340814,
-0.0446217321,
0.0001220787,
0.0308165718,
0.0286637619,
0.0701356828,
0.0451911613,
-0.0274883229,
-0.0404856056,
0.0305784103,
-0.0331112593,
0.0211238693,
-0.0410379469,
0.0181380119,
0.0491254292,
-0.0127903922,
0.0534647405,
-0.0325691476,
0.0358095504,
0.0319196656,
0.0122379484,
-0.0579646789,
0.0216963626,
-0.0070395707,
0.0143364491,
-0.0274164472,
0.082916446,
-0.0136294467,
-0.0134368073,
-0.0084021725,
-0.0096976664,
-0.0123545919,
0.0491843447,
-0.0958918706,
0.0213262457,
-0.0118224528,
-0.0123265833,
-0.0600189492,
-0.042504549,
-0.0244579222,
-0.0268689469,
-0.0003206926,
-0.0093807299,
0.0614358895,
0.0040196292,
-0.0699889958,
0.0199904945,
-0.0725516304,
-0.0444391295,
0.0177447125,
0.0172651708,
0.0290376768,
0.0119939325,
-0.0564150363,
-0.0481534079,
-0.00521809,
-0.0119677391,
0.0776012093,
0.0255543832,
-0.0021314495,
0.0299567934,
-0.0617339164,
0.0388211012,
-0.0359012224,
0.0461059026,
-0.0217555761,
0.0138208205,
-0.0076540671,
0.0046878816,
-0.0611912683,
-0.0336865038,
-0.0114919459,
0.0150909731,
-0.0090668304,
0.0185219124,
0.0041673156,
0.0230224282,
0.0292493198,
-0.0021451544,
-0.071709998,
-0.0601275824,
0.0096452916,
0.0106762704,
-0.0130263446,
0.0152752232,
-0.0269079376,
-0.0375405774,
-0.0090039233,
0.0109145604,
0.040191602,
-0.0247878991,
0.0099136475,
0.0646945313,
-0.0159015115,
-0.0290412512,
-0.0019119151,
-0.0238994434,
-0.0141532524,
-0.0873248652,
0.0197665561,
-0.0577466786,
0.006237437,
0.0115859136,
-0.0087133441,
-0.0107769668,
0.0060500451,
0.0075591807,
0.0156472828,
0.0708824396,
0.0312079955,
-0.0160584394,
0.0159722473,
-0.0068187048,
-0.0076027699,
0.073725678,
0.0551404804,
0.022020841,
0.0140124755,
-0.0239758324,
0.0029711102,
0.0589161739,
0.0387974493,
0.0644693822,
-0.0356950611,
0.0035530399,
0.0385295488,
0.0489951372,
0.0091530858,
0.0539585426,
-0.0363750383,
0.0068976767,
0.0478569679,
0.0371926762,
0.0137259495,
0.0342538878,
0.036472261,
0.0253224354,
0.0081752427,
-0.0199383255,
-0.0497989804,
0.0210335758,
-0.0120498175,
0.0364587866,
-0.0207218882,
0.070854947,
0.0071711871,
-0.0199761465,
0.00513244,
-0.010177712,
-0.0240596086,
-0.0072337841,
0.0987398326,
-0.0006076366,
-0.0138770491,
0.0414386503,
0.0124188839,
-0.0532913692,
-0.0325191021,
0.0044069877,
0.0261763372,
-0.050928656,
0.0336458646,
-0.0154717127,
-0.0493601523,
0.0007794848,
0.0390361808,
0.0384220146,
0.0448116362,
0.0337616354,
-0.0026303388,
-0.0298685618,
-0.0305102542,
-0.0032196685,
0.024208799,
0.0061588623,
0.0307138953,
0.0081232823,
0.0269721188,
-0.0477454029,
0.0119837336,
0.0244361013,
-0.0037116839,
-0.0174248107,
-0.0501784831,
0.0100442944,
-0.0162108913,
-0.0163322333,
0.0187839288,
0.0022974615,
0.0576823875,
-0.038720116,
0.0385179892,
0.0020749439,
-0.0509021096,
-0.0358397812,
0.0695642307,
-0.0661676675,
-0.0319927521,
-0.0043654977,
-0.0411589257,
-0.0266815871,
0.0362218283,
-0.0136153223,
0.0234928187,
-0.0151294796,
-0.0126858894,
-0.0049571698,
-0.0183073748,
-0.0218235757,
0.0550232306,
0.0170993432,
0.0373250619,
0.0033971933,
0.0350484811,
-0.0037902924,
0.0334547982,
0.0058630728,
-0.0081639038,
0.0143151274,
0.0312859677,
-0.0464499928,
0.0406959951,
-0.0163966641,
-0.0335789919,
-0.0685179904,
0.0038327489,
-0.0091340672,
0.0275166407,
0.0282094013,
-0.0230350103,
-0.0311826691,
-0.0248041004,
-0.0393873304,
0.0241130237,
0.0056091421,
-0.023530867,
-0.0088302055,
-0.0053499057,
-0.0118943546,
-0.0080098473,
-0.0144843068,
-0.0341591239,
0.0335953496,
0.0433625355,
0.0260470975,
-0.0331627056,
0.0113713779,
-0.0032033587,
0.0235024784,
-0.0134948231,
-0.0048226789,
0.0119689014,
-0.0495539941,
0.077476941,
0.0287318304,
-0.0060902345,
0.0078002168,
0.0094732959,
-0.0524288304,
-0.0472264439,
0.0143415947,
-0.0476807803,
-0.0310654286,
-0.015754424,
-0.0173732694,
-0.029373914,
0.0525243133,
-0.0315148085,
-0.0173528418,
-0.0334049724,
0.0543449596,
-0.0059152613,
0.0368604213,
-0.0337353274,
0.0365775041,
-0.0060227141,
0.0321152471,
0.014704911,
-0.0564898252,
0.0193027724,
-0.0711513162,
-0.0264914464,
-0.0212615132,
0.0142658874,
-0.0650395006,
0.0559301302,
0.0317128636,
0.0169861168,
0.0025110657,
0.0125354202,
-0.0548221879,
0.0409251451,
0.0375072919,
-0.0077157752,
0.0510710664,
-0.0506719798,
0.0322708078,
-0.0529935844,
-0.054258801,
0.0010359487,
0.0215860959,
-0.0104590133,
-0.0209701844,
-0.0091472669,
-0.0694993362,
0.0172400214,
0.020831462,
0.0075764363,
0.0217080861,
-0.0613523349,
-0.0128640048,
-0.041137971,
0.0521536283,
0.0630946308,
0.0311652794,
-0.0404005721,
-0.0572525971,
-0.0262952521,
0.0443591252,
0.0187921561,
0.0032170904,
-0.0286806859,
0.0309245195,
0.0391894579,
0.0516501442,
-0.0045781275,
-0.0001668806,
0.0478133596,
-0.024831051,
-0.0209631026,
0.0489213467,
0.0130316643,
-0.0479463898,
-0.0437802598,
-0.0348017104,
0.0725234076,
0.0144731048,
-0.0083801225,
-0.073903054,
-0.0237401668,
0.0270352904,
-0.0345608369,
0.0606552809,
-0.0096277045,
-0.0112841241,
-0.0797529295,
0.069413878,
0.0275912955,
-0.0344320983,
-0.0251647253,
0.0035395226,
0.0217605885,
-0.0120764682,
-0.0272879228,
-0.0277912896,
-0.0288524274,
0.0363680534,
0.0130762216,
0.034136083,
-0.0220937449,
-0.0047662407,
-0.0231420361,
-0.0492708869,
-0.0221689716,
0.0389182046,
-0.0051100901,
-0.1072317436,
0.0514410473,
0.0670247823,
-0.0371190533,
0.0024881728,
0.017867269,
0.0290664043,
-0.0192132872,
-0.0016137977,
0.0625455827,
-0.069220908,
-0.0343343727,
0.0076829884,
0.0828851163,
0.0157932974,
0.0297269728,
-0.0201260839,
-0.0217807628,
-0.0111672524,
0.0157159548,
0.0075302743,
-0.0121722566,
-0.0590607449,
-0.0463456176,
0.0541508719,
-0.0291161835,
-0.0327112935,
-0.0003822449,
0.0539982766,
-0.0142552163,
-0.007663988,
0.0201516878,
0.0532267764,
0.0609717816,
0.0085810553,
-0.0285698436,
0.0061771176,
-0.0194023959,
-0.0411068946,
0.0523418188,
-0.0544380955,
0.0468812399,
-0.0492725596,
0.0097217485,
0.0165663101,
-0.0140392222,
-0.0299893264,
0.0541765615,
-0.124388285,
-0.0200774949,
-0.0351803191,
0.0465908051,
0.0142991291,
0.0368862562,
-0.0107625872,
0.014429789,
-0.0125323255,
-0.0021017024,
-0.0278175436,
-0.0068268836,
-0.0136397341,
-0.0050979909,
-0.0014044034,
0.0068454691,
0.0312268399,
-0.004749761,
-0.0094545176,
0.0012048373,
0.0048575848,
-0.0303063132,
0.0379651524,
0.0235752147,
0.034153156,
0.0053949989,
0.0231830031,
-0.0531480201,
-0.0131910723,
-0.0392409116,
-0.0161987059,
-0.0503835902,
0.0320008807,
0.0048641525,
-0.0490124449,
0.0148320971,
-0.0262086429,
0.0200581364,
0.042378366,
-0.0360756256,
0.0377219692,
0.012131053,
-0.0207328442,
0.0918513983,
-0.0072658295,
0.0473796576,
0.0023160647,
-0.041824434,
0.0336664729,
-0.0251897629,
0.0269764513,
0.0020873682,
-0.033075586,
0.0022304887,
0.0209952351,
-0.025169095,
-0.0915824696,
-0.0779298469,
0.0136815282,
0.061275918,
0.0301357824,
0.0361571386,
-0.078460373,
-0.0302035753,
-0.0015895523,
0.0474980436,
0.028211873,
-0.0146465087,
0.0705364868,
0.0083071468,
-0.0086255874,
-0.0461773537,
0.0780967548,
-0.0086434241,
0.0263354201,
0.0273086652,
0.0098223137,
-0.0550878979,
-0.0171555541,
0.021162523,
0.0007385571,
0.0129406815,
0.0157188475,
-0.0418599844,
-0.0671839565,
-0.0254185237,
0.0260377508,
-0.0461962037,
0.0247242339,
0.0555475354,
0.0573388748,
-0.0397906341,
-0.0216803662,
-0.0012045378,
0.0376693681,
-0.0214259699,
-0.0271782968,
0.0127524873,
-5.22757105e-33,
-0.0158979855,
-0.0186820365,
0.0250184666,
-0.0130049773,
-0.0016324013,
-0.0213151164,
-0.0090254359,
0.0380232297,
0.0253127646,
-0.0006613466,
0.0275749154,
-0.0112139834,
0.008603612,
0.0455932394,
0.0015556194,
0.0230310541,
0.0156930014,
-0.0154031245,
-0.0134264398,
0.0392294489,
-0.013728369,
0.0150515633,
0.0646548271,
-0.0582089163,
-0.0239746328,
0.0137966527,
-0.0298540201,
0.0016836805,
-0.0383052193,
0.0629424378,
-0.0359170064,
0.0379279815,
0.0141969994,
-0.0014465546,
-0.0237115342,
0.0105316294,
-0.0266761146,
-0.0116666351,
-0.0254010875,
0.0434158966,
-0.102847673,
-0.0296189375,
-0.0074060778,
-0.0278955158,
-0.0239172336,
-0.0427950472,
0.0339586213,
-0.019382257,
-0.0222268701,
0.019523168,
-0.0484405383,
0.0369110182,
-0.0258135386,
-0.0349320956,
0.0293980297,
0.0258972608,
0.0520554967,
0.0372021385,
0.0053067058,
0.0329615436,
0.0387491137,
0.027370479,
0.0612722002,
-0.0042227441,
-0.0024277973,
0.0228491649,
0.0189221855,
-0.0868367851,
-0.0078234654,
0.0079778004,
0.0462859459,
0.0644770116,
0.0513324365,
0.0374730341,
-0.0152084213,
0.0092991358,
-0.0096939085,
0.0172637794,
-0.0706213787,
0.0023102383,
0.004198405,
0.0116039496,
0.0007216957,
-0.0009399983,
-0.0497583859,
-0.0307850763,
-0.03447989,
0.0217074063,
0.0129132252,
0.002708216,
0.0022626028,
0.0386321731,
0.0110861007,
-0.014710648,
-0.0562741496,
0.0203002691,
-0.0478273816,
0.0361262485,
-0.0124369571,
0.0520436876,
-0.0135483127,
-0.0135538336,
0.0111139873,
0.0114002032,
-0.0016069795,
-0.0140299955,
0.0151480557,
0.0200856309,
-0.0485155135,
0.0157529507,
-0.064263247,
-0.0094531262,
0.0458214283,
0.0336930119,
0.0466714464,
-0.0010894984,
-0.0144651709,
0.0446908325,
0.0233370326,
0.0045249262,
-0.0299184676,
-0.0015214096,
-0.0478967801,
0.008423131,
0.0001095581,
-0.0169485062,
-0.0255784653,
-0.037234582,
0.0930358618,
-0.0521587208,
-0.0146333026,
0.0067522274,
2.641e-7,
0.0595994405,
0.0638260245,
0.0396442339,
-0.0061775642,
0.0197034962,
0.0582567528,
-0.0546263084,
0.0015441397,
-0.0041136728,
0.0169454422,
-0.0042398572,
0.0148199927,
0.0706677884,
0.0539723411,
-0.027250858,
0.0807552338,
-0.0143611459,
-0.0202423725,
-0.0826902539,
0.0233048648,
0.078765139,
0.0660365894,
-0.0203273594,
-0.0228800979,
0.0140432091,
-0.0255953744,
0.0664172396,
-0.0314831845,
-0.0208269302,
0.0143252052,
-0.0325135328,
-0.0293663982,
-0.0184122697,
-0.0118793566,
0.0014387025,
-0.0123951929,
0.026813576,
0.042515263,
0.0213744398,
0.052728042,
0.0016420519,
-0.0101663535,
-0.0234517362,
-0.0675291047,
0.0382433832,
-0.0297740139,
-0.0083613032,
-0.0516971275,
-0.0023243311,
-0.0081768949,
0.0349787064,
-0.0272476561,
-0.0158101469,
0.0161903948,
0.0385680012,
-0.0247122087,
0.0003208969,
-0.045164533,
-0.0199637227,
0.0219507571,
-0.0549685247,
-0.009993393,
-0.0645731539,
0.0162889753,
0.0300057493,
-0.0384538919,
-0.0090060374,
2.754403669e-34,
0.0074256933,
-0.0112160733,
0.0496215336,
0.0321707614,
0.0029095241,
-0.0177052263,
0.0396612361,
0.0003709372,
-0.0463524573,
-0.0653051138,
-0.0254587624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11497v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11497v2 | CrAM: Credibility-Aware Attention Modification in LLMs for Combating Misinformation in RAG | 2024-06-17T13:01:12 | 2024-06-27T10:18:53 | Boyi Deng, Wenjie Wang, Fengbin Zhu, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) can alleviate hallucinations of Large
Language Models (LLMs) by referencing external documents. However, the
misinformation in external documents may mislead LLMs' generation. To address
this issue, we explore the task of "credibility-aware RAG", in which LLMs
automatically adjust the influence of retrieved documents based on their
credibility scores to counteract misinformation. To this end, we introduce a
plug-and-play method named $\textbf{Cr}$edibility-aware $\textbf{A}$ttention
$\textbf{M}$odification (CrAM). CrAM identifies influential attention heads in
LLMs and adjusts their attention weights based on the credibility of the
documents, thereby reducing the impact of low-credibility documents.
Experiments on Natual Questions and TriviaQA using Llama2-13B, Llama3-8B, and
Qwen-7B show that CrAM improves the RAG performance of LLMs against
misinformation pollution by over 20%, even surpassing supervised fine-tuning
methods. | [
0.0500598066,
0.0180766191,
-0.0142724039,
0.0439612642,
-0.0187807269,
-0.0231826659,
-0.0402463637,
0.0000359554,
-0.0169855226,
-0.0617381185,
-0.0300916899,
-0.0189814027,
-0.0105865858,
-0.0344552584,
0.0455643311,
0.0083507821,
0.0857649595,
0.0007099044,
0.0197985582,
-0.0040474394,
0.012538515,
0.0182449911,
0.015471397,
0.0189626608,
0.0090627996,
-0.026388824,
0.0402060598,
0.0168104991,
0.0042606909,
-0.0135215251,
0.0157053676,
0.0586355776,
0.0010485349,
0.0518129617,
0.000002066,
-0.0498343185,
-0.0175733399,
-0.0213938989,
-0.0455783233,
0.0482508168,
0.0273800343,
0.0362970494,
0.0040137675,
0.0308643486,
-0.0175221786,
0.0327227078,
0.0272297151,
0.0555349179,
0.0801813304,
0.0728017166,
0.0211775117,
0.0074980352,
0.0376467668,
-0.0269390214,
0.0806433484,
-0.0196601469,
0.0242249593,
0.0280858502,
-0.033522889,
0.0471274666,
0.0032126354,
0.0417443924,
0.0022106373,
-0.0140765356,
0.0336679853,
0.0062535335,
-0.0576662123,
-0.0084458934,
0.0171972103,
0.0676336959,
0.0133780651,
-0.0740679055,
-0.009939786,
0.0082749436,
0.0375348739,
0.0447946377,
-0.0246520955,
0.0219500754,
-0.027196167,
0.0153827686,
0.0424984433,
-0.0268046651,
0.0411827937,
0.0365852937,
0.0138204712,
0.063790381,
0.0032824753,
-0.0297176689,
0.0213704556,
-0.0021188043,
-0.0024770421,
-0.0662316233,
0.0057643205,
0.0136567187,
-0.0124192145,
0.0237086397,
-0.0207623504,
-0.0328410417,
0.057114657,
-0.0590183474,
-0.029044548,
0.0225278828,
-0.0467351116,
0.0339727774,
-0.0204187818,
0.0240668785,
-0.0343050398,
0.0464441776,
-0.0054154494,
0.0078876326,
0.0018381858,
-0.0016049553,
-0.0156317726,
0.0190580655,
-0.0179811567,
0.0272974037,
-0.0422387756,
-0.0090564135,
-0.0284257568,
0.0035273987,
-0.0107116876,
0.013646883,
-0.0597928651,
-0.0186434425,
-0.0569849424,
0.051766295,
-0.0083342874,
0.0173434317,
0.0133769931,
-0.0684136823,
-0.0318690874,
0.0348819084,
-0.0225515217,
-0.008317031,
-0.0065778331,
0.0086889574,
-0.0112729017,
-0.028092606,
-0.0440999791,
-0.0478197969,
-0.0073834909,
-0.0534607805,
0.022504257,
-0.0542708598,
-0.0072093122,
-0.0234802123,
-0.004334989,
-0.0321081057,
0.0162207298,
0.0450504273,
-0.0429562703,
0.0293894913,
0.0096349269,
-0.0042948918,
0.0542864166,
0.0346690454,
0.0047915867,
0.0466622338,
0.0025243803,
0.0409503169,
0.0471422002,
0.0165041201,
0.0178583004,
-0.0001723599,
0.0613070503,
0.0082072252,
0.001353971,
0.016039975,
0.0024297596,
0.0062210183,
0.0262849741,
0.0416387431,
-0.0294681452,
-0.0344745144,
0.0720452592,
-0.0562175289,
-0.0042085792,
0.0071754819,
0.0135366526,
-0.0021721236,
0.0092247101,
0.0625326931,
-0.0718999803,
0.0605592802,
-0.0649218112,
-0.0005079565,
0.0744180307,
0.0443923622,
-0.0130724059,
-0.0553660132,
-0.0048554642,
0.0051703257,
-0.0453156792,
0.0137480656,
0.0023471208,
0.0208688378,
-0.0365206935,
0.0753674507,
0.0416584387,
-0.0260372944,
0.0262932796,
-0.0403822511,
0.0513500161,
0.0217669215,
0.0619694032,
-0.0135181826,
-0.0325268731,
-0.0298577063,
0.0159032177,
0.0713431686,
0.0349687971,
0.0024929638,
-0.0337341614,
-0.030117929,
-0.0000151858,
-0.0415321477,
0.029926246,
0.0074876291,
0.0430117808,
-0.0025244958,
0.0251412597,
-0.0356660523,
-0.0621963516,
0.0290624667,
-0.0039463341,
-0.0462163649,
-0.0291794837,
0.0041881003,
0.0351545475,
-0.000523702,
-0.001100104,
0.0239740517,
0.0527874455,
-0.0154412128,
0.0076220217,
-0.0225875601,
-0.0096547818,
0.0083334101,
0.0428635031,
0.0005063974,
-0.0291300882,
0.0138350949,
-0.0257680081,
-0.013707919,
0.0158111732,
-0.0639863536,
0.0284931585,
-0.0512510724,
0.0038327838,
0.0017545823,
0.0388457477,
-0.0248608217,
0.0692709312,
-0.0402223393,
0.0119977137,
0.0378879867,
0.004478693,
-0.0022380932,
-0.0099046268,
0.0207894444,
-0.0222271271,
0.0049440381,
0.0089357505,
0.0471372828,
-0.0378682502,
-0.0471709408,
-0.0251432229,
-0.013827607,
-0.0003804258,
-0.0300400965,
0.0035670078,
0.0339770168,
-0.018841885,
0.0080633704,
0.0031099981,
-0.038935326,
-0.0051196599,
0.0152236158,
0.0207741279,
0.0062801735,
0.0042117322,
0.022208618,
-0.0337093845,
0.0126904538,
-0.0050053773,
0.0202217791,
0.0218003895,
-0.0461783782,
-0.0876732618,
-0.003949428,
-0.0783605054,
-0.0036584919,
-0.0125911068,
-0.0275031216,
-0.012507475,
0.017533496,
0.0376207158,
0.0405843109,
0.0317193642,
-0.0357851274,
0.0848623589,
0.010359141,
-0.0635984614,
-0.0045028417,
-0.0100082131,
-0.037528757,
-0.0089338971,
-0.0811727419,
0.0468577072,
0.0208220556,
0.012587795,
-0.0031849823,
-0.0132885389,
0.0282702651,
0.0175774843,
-0.0332395397,
0.0371201262,
-0.0344796404,
-0.0395581461,
0.0349492729,
-0.0468611233,
-0.0682670027,
0.0884639025,
-0.0525364466,
0.0166535433,
-0.0520898327,
0.0518430397,
-0.0045319926,
-0.0421221666,
-0.0196412597,
0.0280616675,
0.0179296061,
-0.0045041982,
-0.0322773531,
-0.0309014525,
0.035233248,
-0.0555364788,
0.0484212339,
-0.0179067161,
0.0050443225,
0.0233812444,
0.0032084591,
-0.0682266578,
-0.0468786545,
0.0203910358,
-0.0332194827,
-0.0391953811,
0.0076108542,
-0.0765727684,
-0.0549307987,
0.0686616078,
0.0010068215,
-0.0369123705,
-0.0098149562,
0.0061984891,
0.0361892097,
0.0549263209,
0.0363174714,
0.0757942945,
-0.0162699204,
-0.0360928811,
0.0587788522,
-0.0058575715,
-0.0304573961,
0.0324604623,
-0.0541271269,
0.0269563347,
-0.0393870398,
-0.0071366439,
0.0115986448,
0.0176415797,
-0.0660920441,
-0.0287120622,
0.0791845247,
0.0342519768,
-0.0351767577,
-0.029074423,
-0.0461176485,
0.0141430534,
0.0350066274,
0.0346135832,
-0.0530621707,
-0.0115931164,
-0.0033618871,
0.0380919725,
-0.0112934513,
-0.0000445278,
-0.0090546282,
-0.1263898909,
0.0566217564,
0.0192076527,
0.007017782,
-0.0111670997,
-0.0503917299,
0.0066688838,
0.0326433145,
0.0347829126,
0.0424679853,
0.0145548349,
-0.0003591651,
-0.0024353457,
0.0305609535,
-0.022313416,
-0.0071227271,
-0.0038010322,
0.0430689529,
0.0473960899,
0.0185834728,
-0.0097761396,
-0.1264247447,
0.0248169154,
-0.0109280385,
-0.019353224,
-0.0272548757,
0.0572555736,
-0.0086806556,
0.006448559,
-0.0156137012,
0.0052005397,
0.028142551,
0.004826467,
-0.0139092626,
0.0722811818,
-0.0168510433,
-0.0118749635,
-0.0288233161,
0.0211491361,
0.0231652483,
0.0663944483,
0.0290967152,
0.0102714719,
0.0177625511,
-0.0379625112,
0.0266675763,
0.0075297127,
-0.0399611518,
0.0550178401,
-0.0161052663,
-0.0627414957,
-0.0969483927,
-0.0304159876,
-0.0337227434,
0.0120056355,
-0.0005641302,
0.0206480324,
0.0004270886,
-0.0200258717,
-0.0205503963,
0.0306051616,
-0.0836643726,
-0.0004832598,
-0.0376061834,
0.0205757711,
0.0266226865,
-0.0233579818,
0.0099441232,
0.0520692095,
-0.0084545249,
-0.0578014851,
0.0097371219,
0.0594754852,
0.0239386652,
0.0431071296,
-0.0243994519,
-0.0505529046,
0.017725138,
0.003675642,
-0.0484245084,
0.0493354872,
0.0049356613,
-0.0153239816,
0.0027900189,
0.0450857431,
-0.0511292554,
0.0295619201,
0.004340081,
0.0179705955,
-0.0226665046,
-0.0254237615,
0.0378473699,
0.0346500613,
0.0641618073,
0.0106703145,
0.0323353633,
-0.0202765949,
0.0285027456,
-0.0201903917,
-0.0325248539,
0.0168698076,
0.0329083055,
0.0159175843,
-0.0340444408,
0.0303212609,
0.0188845005,
-0.0648632497,
0.0464779139,
-0.0216823891,
-0.0039266464,
-0.0307143573,
0.0581301786,
-0.0047306567,
-0.0153893866,
-0.03900107,
0.0048164288,
0.0084221205,
0.0747420564,
-0.0093547422,
0.0261306632,
0.0019058591,
-0.0407251306,
0.0029546265,
-0.0117922118,
-0.0348738916,
-0.0103863636,
-0.0350811034,
0.0107102729,
0.0208884869,
0.0161664113,
0.0677424073,
0.0093560144,
-0.0102058183,
-0.0095454892,
-0.0269384533,
0.019409012,
-0.023907505,
0.0358816981,
-0.008570483,
-0.015916707,
0.0209905487,
0.0417265072,
-0.0314273201,
0.0111653339,
-0.0011495512,
-0.0528358594,
-0.0393206328,
-0.0699870065,
-0.0649587363,
0.0396775417,
-0.0280569177,
-0.0002863663,
-0.0680810958,
-0.0622471496,
0.045067858,
0.030419359,
-0.0206371527,
-0.0317352191,
-0.0130468104,
0.0723797977,
0.0005059426,
-0.018111676,
-0.0451968759,
0.0213963315,
-0.0519626178,
-0.0062586307,
0.0142890019,
-6.839981222e-33,
-0.025132563,
-0.0611642972,
-0.0032263838,
-0.0412333608,
-0.0132144941,
0.0239525288,
-0.0444715247,
-0.0048944862,
-0.0472919084,
0.0100477263,
-0.0026548845,
0.0367162526,
0.0026590456,
-0.0198045317,
-0.0242129937,
0.0133907776,
0.0569700263,
0.0028485879,
-0.0551144071,
0.045311626,
0.057835646,
-0.013617808,
0.0617116205,
-0.0725674406,
0.0730799139,
-0.0117304642,
-0.0123122539,
0.0216122866,
-0.0615429915,
0.0618069023,
-0.0148188835,
0.0508853123,
0.0132341646,
-0.0447495356,
0.0017198693,
0.0012434901,
-0.0624748245,
-0.0354379267,
0.0657712668,
-0.0376275219,
-0.0235770307,
-0.043904148,
0.0634730607,
-0.0000382992,
0.0120943692,
0.0178656243,
0.0177856125,
-0.042046465,
-0.0266644508,
0.004858484,
-0.0477002598,
0.0087721944,
0.0322104804,
0.0064342981,
-0.0351164155,
0.053454157,
0.014085195,
0.0621981174,
-0.0880593285,
-0.0041237748,
-0.0355701745,
0.0526574403,
0.0583895743,
-0.0309684183,
-0.0128885172,
0.0406018682,
-0.0287852548,
0.0117155537,
-0.0190181993,
-0.0470108725,
0.0092361923,
0.013766408,
0.0768392384,
0.1003676578,
0.0236202776,
-0.0368356332,
-0.1015074328,
0.0452522375,
0.0111152548,
0.0584335104,
0.020487722,
-0.019461263,
-0.0342323072,
0.0196448732,
-0.0250006914,
0.0037631337,
-0.0520224459,
-0.0079570748,
0.0184827149,
0.0419087969,
-0.0418617763,
0.0305832382,
0.0101207495,
0.0081991227,
-0.0092127938,
0.0214995872,
-0.0169552956,
-0.0213480014,
0.0026850426,
0.0212652981,
-0.0511568934,
0.044324711,
0.0097812433,
-0.010977339,
-0.0105334474,
0.0395317413,
0.0459092669,
-0.0301072132,
-0.0497841127,
0.0347511992,
-0.0357295796,
0.0510089844,
-0.0145714087,
-0.0341214761,
0.0460370108,
-0.0059896982,
-0.003196954,
0.0079246489,
0.0236991663,
0.0126203476,
-0.0317744501,
-0.0107228002,
0.0050331699,
0.0454563089,
-0.0561474413,
-0.0002118596,
-0.0001621092,
0.0572449788,
0.0025128541,
-0.0544302538,
-0.0173727274,
-0.0144897345,
2.858e-7,
0.0148302307,
0.0626051649,
0.0048120804,
0.0074856742,
0.0039633294,
0.0135046048,
-0.0059962976,
0.0138051212,
0.0382138751,
-0.0863798261,
-0.0430646725,
-0.0013883231,
0.0156207597,
0.0313294269,
-0.0759375393,
-0.0086057857,
-0.0315904468,
0.0094329221,
-0.0218991209,
-0.0517613441,
0.0196083542,
0.0766886175,
0.0087996852,
-0.0145942159,
-0.0310237091,
-0.0495275334,
0.0608614907,
0.0040057623,
-0.0373483486,
0.0213820115,
0.10576763,
0.0055734459,
-0.0064947517,
-0.0189753976,
-0.0347449891,
0.0257793274,
-0.022666797,
0.0292636752,
-0.0056617553,
-0.0731156617,
-0.0294077098,
-0.0291505121,
0.0322761238,
-0.0622410923,
0.0405524857,
-0.0165717751,
-0.0032414587,
-0.0074273576,
-0.0683625489,
0.0141449003,
0.0275858101,
-0.0148818111,
-0.0290746167,
0.0071976082,
-0.0203965399,
0.0235558059,
-0.0040499596,
-0.0539521538,
-0.0497196168,
-0.0085214293,
-0.0247880183,
-0.0596130788,
-0.0197751559,
-0.0467002764,
-0.0194958989,
-0.0715213418,
0.0308771003,
2.742001515e-34,
0.0578416511,
-0.0111363977,
0.0419055298,
0.0025010321,
0.0373442322,
0.0033542665,
-0.0164340399,
-0.0020012066,
0.0220745504,
-0.0675824434,
-0.0071057547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11486v1 | Analysing zero-shot temporal relation extraction on clinical notes using temporal consistency | 2024-06-17T12:53:21 | 2024-06-17T12:53:21 | Vasiliki Kougia, Anastasiia Sedova, Andreas Stephan, Klim Zaporojets, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents the first study for temporal relation extraction in a
zero-shot setting focusing on biomedical text. We employ two types of prompts
and five LLMs (GPT-3.5, Mixtral, Llama 2, Gemma, and PMC-LLaMA) to obtain
responses about the temporal relations between two events. Our experiments
demonstrate that LLMs struggle in the zero-shot setting performing worse than
fine-tuned specialized models in terms of F1 score, showing that this is a
challenging task for LLMs. We further contribute a novel comprehensive temporal
analysis by calculating consistency scores for each LLM. Our findings reveal
that LLMs face challenges in providing responses consistent to the temporal
properties of uniqueness and transitivity. Moreover, we study the relation
between the temporal consistency of an LLM and its accuracy and whether the
latter can be improved by solving temporal inconsistencies. Our analysis shows
that even when temporal consistency is achieved, the predictions can remain
inaccurate. | [
0.0332082361,
0.0317316353,
0.0195361767,
0.0262329485,
-0.0569628514,
-0.0015814983,
0.0130726816,
0.0563115589,
-0.0177916419,
-0.0208132081,
-0.0053972537,
-0.0747540444,
0.0314199068,
0.0170815699,
-0.055777669,
-0.0595727302,
0.0638007894,
0.0351952091,
0.0142193818,
0.0406672582,
-0.0207981784,
-0.0276301969,
-0.0725253671,
0.0202067513,
-0.0072487211,
-0.0252184551,
0.0090321498,
-0.0356425345,
0.0619311295,
-0.1071576029,
-0.0417375937,
0.0360513218,
-0.0309461039,
0.0301718526,
0.0000019816,
-0.0372386649,
-0.0093989,
-0.0021579014,
-0.0591026321,
-0.0314416215,
-0.0118811037,
-0.0330003686,
-0.0083978819,
-0.0336932912,
-0.0573515892,
-0.0451381467,
0.0051575233,
0.024043655,
0.0129775647,
0.0856469795,
-0.0401522741,
0.023779653,
0.0606994368,
-0.0152254924,
0.0507485345,
-0.0436369963,
0.0196169578,
-0.0177586414,
0.0573305339,
-0.0127665959,
0.0212161224,
0.03049374,
0.0117779905,
0.031251058,
0.0295368284,
0.0704544634,
-0.0356788039,
0.0111653134,
-0.0238928068,
0.0705163106,
0.0384516977,
0.0041290335,
0.0314195827,
0.0049155736,
-0.0487813801,
-0.0031951691,
-0.0483134203,
-0.0102806902,
-0.0308592133,
0.0001616224,
0.0031351722,
0.0393620469,
0.0189221613,
-0.0133709097,
-0.0047893706,
0.0491933152,
0.0134076485,
-0.0267064404,
-0.0329725146,
0.0273616649,
0.0459140576,
-0.044135768,
0.0110972757,
0.0844032988,
-0.0073715756,
-0.0062071937,
-0.0278060846,
-0.0056047617,
0.0376799032,
-0.0445124619,
0.0157034136,
0.0123381,
-0.0360453799,
0.0499784239,
-0.0353382938,
0.0493453741,
-0.036171902,
0.0133459596,
-0.001567419,
0.046608638,
-0.0560697727,
0.0137039535,
0.0376111902,
0.0310414732,
-0.017665254,
0.0054481016,
-0.0581553392,
0.0049997517,
0.0083869556,
0.0318318121,
-0.0292372592,
-0.0030418793,
-0.0292518176,
-0.0078429412,
-0.0255653448,
0.0206019916,
0.0046163583,
-0.0065060393,
-0.0504133478,
-0.0479980782,
-0.0260831285,
0.0126138357,
0.0379661918,
-0.0369972028,
-0.0132108079,
0.0797556043,
-0.0293130428,
-0.0308875162,
-0.0389133766,
-0.0472105816,
-0.0220893137,
-0.0452825651,
0.0044905869,
-0.0272647943,
0.0379421115,
0.0170506202,
-0.0158473421,
-0.0027366837,
0.0194028635,
0.0055562686,
-0.0340977609,
0.0719844997,
-0.0252879262,
-0.0003640832,
-0.0067233881,
0.027930297,
0.0302573815,
0.0066830586,
0.0430459455,
-0.0492641665,
0.0126242917,
0.0319083519,
0.0013285138,
0.018865684,
-0.0020715625,
-0.0522394292,
-0.0548567027,
-0.0070295143,
0.037279252,
0.0268756617,
0.0089222332,
0.0311054327,
-0.014527279,
-0.041397281,
0.03949821,
0.0382525735,
0.034257859,
-0.0373209193,
0.0598004311,
-0.0816270486,
0.0304065868,
0.0279440228,
-0.0288248621,
0.0036583743,
0.0006704216,
0.03988114,
-0.0757395849,
-0.0150178624,
-0.0095791835,
-0.0054518543,
-0.0421107672,
-0.0275178496,
-0.060105022,
-0.0515602008,
0.0686701313,
-0.0318861268,
-0.0348014124,
0.0647821724,
0.0257439408,
-0.0065599359,
-0.0249405857,
-0.0080271652,
0.0153529113,
0.092578873,
0.0641207024,
-0.0539199188,
-0.0682659,
-0.0111989379,
-0.0096885664,
0.0344519317,
0.0224759094,
-0.0301564373,
0.0331209935,
-0.0274782162,
-0.0150331873,
0.0350766666,
0.0063975975,
-0.02865104,
0.0269519668,
0.0599413961,
-0.0044801771,
0.0269835573,
0.04680942,
0.0372885428,
-0.051612813,
-0.0484763794,
-0.0356097706,
-0.0021861726,
0.0283851177,
0.0354045443,
-0.0274988618,
0.0133099472,
0.0568864904,
-0.0527942106,
0.0275854133,
0.0385898799,
-0.0662374943,
-0.0632292181,
0.0256864652,
0.0310943015,
-0.0218020882,
-0.0349401683,
-0.0228208397,
-0.0264346208,
-0.0394657217,
0.045148503,
0.0203813184,
-0.0093422951,
0.0425897837,
0.0629257858,
-0.0079783173,
-0.0422946773,
0.039080102,
-0.0257823523,
-0.0095355092,
0.0039063683,
-0.0355542414,
0.010179163,
-0.0519328639,
-0.0095732966,
0.0661508739,
0.0092592333,
-0.0541067682,
-0.0433606841,
-0.0077034403,
-0.0474373698,
-0.031916108,
-0.0912941471,
0.0062594297,
0.014979885,
0.0418613851,
0.0198333077,
0.0108383037,
-0.0132401856,
-0.010832007,
-0.0119978273,
-0.0079669571,
0.0086993175,
0.0211258419,
0.0782164261,
0.0653257146,
-0.0002162781,
-0.0469199605,
0.002856551,
-0.065082401,
0.0429789387,
0.0087246597,
-0.0577648543,
0.0184350014,
-0.0159772225,
-0.0438726768,
-0.0022961898,
-0.0072983075,
0.0257436931,
0.0345288105,
-0.0154699972,
0.0046306197,
0.0333408453,
-0.0116457744,
0.0604587197,
0.0198798925,
-0.030756982,
-0.0014182242,
0.012254375,
-0.0284314249,
0.0230582617,
0.0193123333,
-0.0167879835,
-0.0309329815,
0.0890913159,
-0.0045676441,
0.0453894585,
-0.0152823273,
-0.0055863671,
-0.0213581938,
0.0315247364,
-0.0029681094,
0.0284893662,
-0.0511130095,
0.0072142789,
-0.0397152975,
-0.0192302559,
0.0497374609,
-0.0153520443,
0.0076450272,
0.0226668194,
-0.00959587,
-0.0495375693,
0.0605850182,
-0.0002122078,
-0.0113394912,
0.0159141254,
-0.0200329591,
-0.0242248122,
-0.0267879907,
0.0181215331,
-0.0358609408,
0.0553023331,
-0.0239724945,
0.0495283417,
-0.0400214382,
0.0087671317,
-0.0394891091,
-0.0644709393,
-0.0301453918,
0.013776022,
-0.0936835781,
0.0287083071,
-0.0367216952,
0.0352348462,
-0.034515325,
0.0635682344,
-0.0192515533,
-0.0174230486,
-0.0347623713,
0.0821410567,
0.032520894,
-0.0322819538,
-0.0212537684,
-0.0210938174,
0.0356198214,
0.0346533358,
0.0194300413,
0.0439573638,
-0.021058768,
-0.0026528314,
-0.0514744408,
-0.0604803599,
-0.020558171,
0.0152724925,
-0.0070311436,
-0.0822915435,
0.0047334405,
0.1010600179,
0.0308884513,
-0.0360351391,
0.0005309311,
-0.0053313966,
-0.0566513501,
-0.019643642,
-0.0228090137,
-0.0884239748,
-0.0166631378,
-0.0072283261,
-0.0089026531,
-0.0319175348,
-0.0570125952,
-0.0061388351,
-0.0571602471,
0.0040214346,
-0.0023523681,
-0.0373793356,
0.0167404115,
-0.0177809913,
0.0152016208,
-0.0119512463,
0.0174976606,
0.0238990411,
-0.0285454951,
-0.0027388199,
-0.0053260201,
-0.0320544206,
-0.0644794554,
0.0391384475,
0.0216195136,
0.0460695811,
0.0409937426,
0.0272237845,
-0.0106458599,
-0.0243008137,
0.0169863533,
0.0030388669,
0.0124872848,
-0.033397004,
0.0728475302,
-0.0028541463,
-0.0006099073,
-0.0257655457,
-0.0101710949,
0.0286364406,
-0.0410760008,
-0.0197631773,
0.0799464136,
-0.0374104641,
-0.0219792183,
-0.0300578568,
0.0061949417,
-0.0043501812,
0.0417568795,
-0.008337331,
0.0269535556,
-0.0610318407,
0.0439937077,
0.0216326825,
-0.0459167324,
-0.0202996992,
0.0017885552,
-0.0484494939,
-0.0037658946,
-0.0593122058,
-0.0538235642,
-0.0189867578,
0.0147642726,
-0.0191125311,
0.0298177879,
0.0050587179,
0.0067843804,
-0.0563555472,
0.0280890688,
0.0143097267,
-0.0054413234,
-0.0577337295,
0.0298256576,
0.0316423215,
0.01671944,
-0.0042023514,
-0.0027439084,
-0.0437611043,
-0.0057918672,
-0.0072818412,
0.0091078682,
0.0238758326,
0.0370232575,
0.0284122881,
0.027181128,
0.0434666239,
0.0575016811,
0.0051531401,
0.0229402669,
0.0051931329,
0.0103354035,
-0.0250805058,
0.0032572569,
0.0075229346,
0.0165642705,
0.0006066293,
0.0198775586,
-0.0143142436,
-0.010752053,
-0.009816519,
0.0106629385,
0.0778881907,
0.0277863983,
0.002196769,
-0.000168953,
0.0227159001,
-0.0575565137,
0.0509531721,
-0.0055221985,
-0.0045879409,
-0.0071179834,
0.0067437915,
-0.0265510585,
-0.027716741,
-0.0696393475,
-0.0069167325,
-0.0377245359,
0.0173510611,
0.0159497932,
-0.0038147774,
0.0181118865,
-0.0075090858,
-0.0154669126,
0.0400125906,
-0.0052647172,
0.0107647981,
-0.0090361871,
0.0432570353,
0.0011834538,
0.0385155939,
-0.0100358268,
0.0178607982,
-0.066605702,
0.0648613945,
-0.021619495,
0.0122226682,
0.0711696669,
-0.0192924719,
0.0544439554,
-0.0020095981,
0.0092050936,
-0.0072502992,
0.0430516005,
0.0090223933,
0.0488222837,
0.0198961012,
0.025121484,
0.0000113192,
0.0309364237,
0.0881699696,
-0.0183106642,
0.0561144464,
0.0314161032,
-0.0293668974,
-0.0333197154,
-0.0280091651,
-0.0073473924,
-0.0493130758,
-0.0361252651,
-0.0259935334,
-0.0968784317,
-0.0015234004,
0.1316350549,
-0.0113162016,
-0.0333320871,
-0.0056569488,
-0.0072800936,
0.0098627601,
0.0452087186,
-0.0306411106,
0.005496881,
0.0634184554,
0.0213231705,
-0.0322994292,
-0.0176012646,
-6.248778828e-33,
-0.0336542279,
-0.0575116985,
0.0212338865,
0.0179173462,
-0.050842084,
0.0682864562,
-0.0632486492,
-0.0059745484,
-0.0004671816,
0.016317727,
-0.0288839955,
-0.0020032655,
0.0326104201,
-0.0238573886,
0.0157260485,
-0.0384558178,
0.0113911191,
-0.0051561054,
0.0025744746,
0.0080117816,
0.0417901874,
0.0556648821,
0.0516818613,
-0.0677773282,
0.0413641483,
-0.0113115795,
0.0236793403,
-0.0004787252,
0.0117433416,
0.0633192137,
-0.0424529575,
-0.0035631417,
0.0672473386,
-0.0178613514,
-0.0067321388,
-0.0156797506,
-0.1096767262,
-0.0335082337,
-0.0003427135,
-0.0167664103,
-0.0092276037,
-0.0422269069,
0.0065348563,
-0.0232735742,
-0.0266052857,
-0.045635052,
0.0155326165,
-0.0323903896,
-0.0317176506,
-0.0592198968,
-0.0545319878,
0.0558483414,
0.0187617932,
0.0050408402,
0.0605515689,
0.0097735841,
0.0190035831,
0.014518912,
-0.0396040492,
-0.0293868855,
-0.0028588932,
0.0180352535,
-0.0046471939,
-0.0113670016,
-0.0199699476,
0.0728886947,
-0.0105658062,
-0.0073037222,
-0.0394275486,
0.0247511454,
-0.0291379262,
0.031985417,
0.0335488133,
0.0136032747,
0.0279081017,
0.0151159409,
-0.1022509709,
0.0222301614,
-0.0001180194,
0.0325393565,
-0.0176600721,
-0.0150812306,
-0.0307626817,
0.0310692824,
0.0321285836,
-0.0083730351,
-0.003065936,
-0.0297636054,
0.0254194196,
-0.0005203592,
0.0537531376,
0.0449946448,
0.0381144136,
0.0061387043,
-0.0095652463,
-0.0228645168,
-0.0095652724,
0.0434138775,
-0.0092749195,
-0.0186085384,
-0.0586295314,
-0.0194458775,
0.0172018409,
0.0124030588,
0.0492581278,
0.0048224521,
0.0333656184,
-0.0150768962,
-0.027379524,
-0.0357567593,
0.0187609736,
-0.0139036803,
0.00626182,
-0.0071055084,
0.0443127863,
-0.0063020959,
-0.0019128615,
0.0933716521,
-0.0058293361,
0.0378110111,
-0.0090945726,
0.0203570146,
0.0192082543,
0.0273983926,
-0.0215812419,
0.0010678641,
-0.0040970487,
0.0626263618,
-0.0032721928,
-0.0127533022,
0.0056643779,
-0.0038758167,
2.634e-7,
0.0592477955,
0.0208602194,
0.057785742,
0.0074754246,
0.0260741469,
-0.0190326814,
-0.0280670337,
0.0105985729,
-0.0383754224,
0.0103019038,
0.0545986183,
0.0106268385,
0.0508450568,
0.0344459079,
-0.0234388001,
-0.0256769359,
-0.0890638605,
-0.0523435995,
-0.0500925295,
-0.0179577209,
0.0831754729,
0.0138473641,
-0.0077267946,
-0.0043197125,
-0.0035268834,
-0.0194249675,
0.0661744103,
-0.0084426329,
-0.0129968012,
0.0297968145,
0.0411463901,
-0.0337933153,
-0.0033371581,
0.0313178413,
-0.0154316342,
-0.0260992404,
-0.0204076245,
0.0957817212,
-0.078780666,
-0.0134887416,
0.0206775423,
-0.0157356337,
0.0101902364,
-0.0022960317,
0.0932686254,
-0.0300943349,
-0.0177997109,
-0.0124184974,
-0.0282543544,
0.0277639069,
0.0559183545,
0.0343027711,
0.0028317801,
0.046113193,
0.0209675673,
0.0166039057,
-0.0712763369,
-0.0654296353,
-0.036997214,
0.0643073395,
0.0004668635,
-0.0141792558,
0.0229202677,
-0.0433493294,
-0.0034810274,
-0.0774601698,
-0.0348418877,
2.357256474e-34,
0.0185322203,
0.0200501103,
-0.0049964166,
0.0470223315,
-0.0162387546,
-0.0145589532,
-0.0141004063,
0.0327512659,
0.0055877795,
-0.0583133474,
0.0148075325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11477v1 | Vocabulary Expansion for Low-resource Cross-lingual Transfer | 2024-06-17T12:42:34 | 2024-06-17T12:42:34 | Atsuki Yamaguchi, Aline Villavicencio, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in many
languages beyond English. Yet, LLMs require more inference steps when
generating non-English text due to their reliance on English-centric
tokenizers, vocabulary, and pre-training data, resulting in higher usage costs
to non-English speakers. Vocabulary expansion with target language tokens is a
widely used cross-lingual vocabulary adaptation approach to remedy this issue.
Despite its effectiveness in inference speedup, the majority of previous work
has focused on high-resource settings assuming access to a substantial amount
of target language data to effectively initialize the embeddings of the new
tokens and adapt the LLM to the target language. However, vocabulary expansion
for LLMs in low-resource settings (i.e. languages and compute) has yet to be
explored. In this paper, we investigate sample-efficient adaptation strategies
from different angles, including target vocabulary size and initialization
methods, and the amount of target data available for adaptation. Extensive
experiments across typologically diverse languages, tasks and models show that
simpler heuristic-based embedding initialization is more efficient and robust
to changes in target vocabulary size and adaptation data in low-resource
settings, outperforming a popular random initialization and a more
sophisticated state-of-the-art approach that relies on external data and model. | [
0.006853546,
0.0542118289,
-0.0040613855,
0.024636114,
-0.033762604,
0.0143472748,
0.0044944477,
-0.0039944188,
-0.0298294779,
-0.0353516042,
-0.0351324081,
-0.0468073674,
-0.0140818218,
-0.0205507725,
0.0414321907,
-0.0371231176,
0.0623027198,
-0.0638155192,
-0.0514860973,
-0.0320019871,
-0.024274027,
0.0084354542,
0.0235721096,
0.010236321,
0.0001346264,
0.0101854736,
0.008733985,
0.0113537814,
-0.0025697742,
-0.0114079276,
-0.0438432619,
0.0362159349,
0.0145458374,
0.0415926762,
0.0000019509,
-0.0553586595,
-0.0231207684,
-0.0043108645,
0.0044837445,
0.0342695899,
0.0987946019,
-0.0330437012,
-0.0005651105,
0.0337887555,
-0.0102486154,
-0.0488151833,
0.0692424551,
-0.0069894413,
-0.0005284238,
0.0698790178,
-0.0156922489,
-0.0129603986,
0.0001871119,
-0.030847948,
-0.0105891386,
-0.0422774516,
0.0352266394,
0.006997277,
-0.0067979624,
-0.0026802355,
-0.0530515201,
0.0259764884,
-0.0015103985,
0.014563906,
0.0179077052,
0.022456117,
-0.0167241041,
-0.0121718254,
-0.0235296544,
0.0565611534,
-0.0199486706,
-0.0270898994,
-0.0092057697,
0.0075439312,
-0.0083015049,
0.0155908372,
-0.0504717268,
0.0209155288,
0.0379918367,
0.0240033474,
0.0723518506,
-0.0318263173,
0.0454712026,
0.0078608533,
-0.078953743,
0.0210301783,
0.0649631247,
-0.0178687926,
0.0242516175,
0.0126645137,
-0.0119959293,
-0.0556227677,
0.0101513742,
0.0027359105,
0.0002756917,
0.0311656483,
-0.0670650229,
-0.0757555664,
-0.0018697381,
-0.001256876,
0.0414588824,
0.0367795303,
0.0082502272,
0.0465678461,
-0.0683441386,
0.0102639515,
-0.0221716687,
0.0128740622,
-0.0799037144,
-0.0443778224,
-0.0221685097,
0.0050362838,
-0.0389644429,
0.0094978204,
-0.0409505889,
-0.0120871067,
-0.035742484,
0.0411367677,
0.0280758683,
-0.0271555725,
0.0197547041,
-0.0560684055,
-0.0427461341,
0.0101471487,
-0.0072541474,
0.0331745781,
-0.0276640225,
0.0041867108,
-0.0154834976,
-0.0514170267,
-0.0239614025,
0.0146353804,
0.0258229412,
-0.0464570113,
0.0155285671,
0.0789054483,
-0.0212956797,
-0.0418417305,
-0.0436617658,
0.0414827168,
0.0038243667,
-0.0250724424,
0.0289833564,
-0.0653158873,
0.0324313231,
0.0168459062,
0.0264419727,
-0.0213865098,
-0.003702248,
0.0112079931,
-0.0626320317,
0.0549653322,
-0.0326613523,
0.0265608765,
-0.0009761122,
-0.0429032184,
0.0126352422,
0.0969953164,
0.0017028642,
-0.0110254725,
0.0522601418,
-0.0179857779,
-0.0555779561,
0.072268948,
0.0424370579,
0.0504472181,
-0.0410397016,
-0.0255349018,
0.0548693351,
0.0245021321,
0.0590438992,
0.0414983146,
-0.027969962,
0.0462680757,
0.0195203181,
0.0798132122,
-0.0022355795,
0.0357266366,
0.0705707595,
0.0029257578,
-0.0636809766,
-0.0188498516,
-0.0225178767,
-0.0101565076,
-0.0098444391,
-0.0050846096,
0.0570120774,
0.0671818554,
-0.036743138,
-0.0058370698,
-0.0077432222,
-0.0245260783,
0.0342994817,
-0.0177473053,
0.0657958388,
0.0303247012,
-0.0025080428,
0.0773665383,
0.077221252,
-0.032757327,
0.0329165868,
-0.0249916483,
0.0206890237,
0.0366669148,
0.0087240711,
0.0115760667,
-0.0038081452,
0.0138365123,
0.0523907207,
0.0288930703,
0.0635855943,
-0.0069652279,
0.0100611039,
-0.0721056759,
0.0061740945,
0.0105773807,
-0.0032022218,
0.0635194033,
0.0232612193,
0.051599972,
0.0360778756,
-0.0648301244,
-0.0358802341,
0.0233028661,
-0.084218882,
-0.0269558858,
0.0425135233,
0.0047647152,
0.0277718492,
0.0283702221,
-0.0022051476,
-0.0099374428,
-0.0031988858,
-0.0456021987,
0.0056212684,
0.0121549917,
-0.0591728836,
-0.0348161533,
0.0325879343,
-0.0129679274,
0.0260820147,
-0.00485203,
-0.0310206246,
-0.0411228128,
0.0377402492,
-0.0133016109,
0.0515176579,
-0.0520043559,
0.0328573026,
-0.0124905976,
0.0431970246,
-0.0132038705,
0.029733086,
0.0226925109,
0.0113516636,
0.0168588143,
0.0117138922,
0.0072585428,
-0.0199356731,
-0.0338997394,
0.0398289971,
-0.0022500325,
-0.0043824189,
0.0177582707,
0.0086934781,
-0.0232781973,
-0.0081172604,
-0.1100708395,
0.0008950834,
-0.0098510385,
0.019268889,
0.0184328519,
0.038620621,
-0.0093160011,
-0.0075441445,
-0.0442648381,
0.0195019208,
0.0092594279,
0.0646136552,
-0.0104355784,
-0.0038655666,
0.002567129,
0.0013311065,
-0.0116962949,
0.0328487977,
0.0610018186,
-0.0265261214,
-0.0192701668,
-0.0529801697,
0.0245937891,
-0.0393422022,
0.0083616162,
0.0010969266,
-0.0220013279,
-0.0355233476,
-0.0149066811,
0.0702849478,
0.0146784568,
-0.011418459,
-0.0364231132,
0.0426211096,
-0.0357757434,
-0.053017132,
-0.0040807724,
0.0029135763,
-0.0483311489,
-0.0528501384,
-0.0543605909,
-0.0021541796,
0.0719334856,
-0.048057463,
-0.0350715257,
-0.0679859743,
-0.0162027441,
-0.0577332228,
-0.03476144,
-0.0127155809,
0.0280028582,
-0.0163404793,
0.0043346984,
-0.0045867255,
-0.0203340705,
0.0538906157,
-0.0512031876,
0.0055416245,
-0.0711876526,
-0.0118976096,
-0.0336029008,
0.0183283072,
0.0170121398,
0.030934846,
-0.0361464582,
-0.0047578677,
-0.0349964239,
0.014892281,
0.0095150732,
-0.0145710595,
0.0445486344,
-0.0373596698,
-0.0112643531,
-0.0194619745,
-0.0243885294,
-0.0219563115,
-0.0341223851,
-0.0172122195,
0.0031817639,
0.0497149117,
0.0034223832,
-0.0255260188,
0.0197041463,
0.0348439552,
0.0547504053,
-0.0033600046,
0.0373120233,
-0.0162959769,
0.006038853,
0.0376822576,
0.0188634228,
0.0026515441,
-0.0468678437,
0.0269448254,
-0.0060421317,
0.0539012328,
-0.0412963033,
-0.0183471087,
0.0061284299,
0.0438999906,
-0.0143615762,
-0.0294375625,
0.0064409655,
0.0538745672,
0.0158771239,
-0.0204248168,
0.0779303461,
-0.003833245,
-0.0511165373,
0.01599098,
-0.0491446853,
0.0463224128,
0.017717462,
0.04227769,
-0.0731630251,
-0.0130554382,
0.0317037255,
0.0012309678,
0.0211996697,
-0.0299578309,
-0.0272769369,
-0.1533249617,
0.0076075317,
0.0347131677,
-0.0768385306,
-0.0098009659,
-0.0614620708,
-0.0027735422,
-0.0066439859,
0.0358395353,
-0.0197585914,
-0.020836072,
0.000730381,
0.0166233536,
0.0060846047,
-0.0657592043,
-0.0204651337,
-0.0325104706,
0.0576890297,
0.0095107825,
-0.0009405252,
-0.0304186549,
-0.0043430924,
0.0517207049,
-0.0044311075,
-0.0250644758,
-0.0333814099,
0.012142173,
0.0010675628,
-0.0013408992,
0.0532185063,
0.0053446572,
-0.0123579046,
-0.0121838413,
0.0327149034,
0.0853258669,
0.053484071,
-0.0041285641,
0.0150796212,
-0.0266236905,
0.0219028201,
0.0646548867,
0.0425259769,
-0.0734365359,
0.0045655421,
0.0136160916,
-0.0399801843,
-0.0286655482,
0.0032008621,
0.018908402,
-0.0556886904,
-0.0445171967,
-0.0620815828,
-0.0262997709,
0.0177177191,
0.0507763065,
0.0510168299,
0.0503011495,
-0.0231404845,
-0.0091325128,
-0.0155175505,
0.0291147809,
-0.0622923858,
-0.0017030132,
-0.0515682176,
-0.0088166771,
0.0022863632,
-0.0348034278,
-0.0050458242,
-0.0093322182,
-0.0124494452,
-0.0582229011,
-0.0136888111,
0.0251196139,
0.0051211701,
0.0581571758,
0.0031738468,
-0.0411297567,
0.091373235,
-0.0053770705,
-0.0061653792,
0.0311890263,
0.0264819618,
0.00740916,
0.0075393287,
0.0532025322,
-0.0468866117,
0.021439543,
0.0278121512,
0.0536249541,
-0.0003417182,
-0.0126212547,
-0.0269267857,
0.0554253682,
0.0134174451,
-0.0363734663,
-0.005960532,
-0.0290350318,
0.0275991,
-0.0357744694,
0.0009342258,
-0.0299988352,
-0.0137453107,
0.0426433533,
0.0096105421,
0.0044749603,
-0.0225421749,
0.0147995651,
0.0281929933,
0.0058122124,
0.0226454139,
-0.0202327333,
0.0388081186,
0.047768455,
0.0380536355,
-0.0187683124,
-0.0393721722,
0.0094816377,
0.0287222099,
-0.0861289352,
0.0174656659,
0.0016812987,
-0.0171153042,
-0.0197434071,
0.016128853,
-0.0069648293,
-0.0186634809,
-0.0116949128,
0.0185037535,
0.057085257,
-0.0453585945,
0.0838505328,
-0.0152824791,
-0.0200699344,
-0.0314277075,
0.0068135788,
-0.0219591074,
-0.0287786964,
0.0268379506,
-0.0122803543,
-0.0269309971,
0.0153018599,
0.061405912,
0.0388366394,
0.0044716429,
-0.0161952097,
0.0236529093,
-0.024355771,
-0.0113626979,
0.0383333787,
0.0000956194,
-0.028032016,
0.0154096382,
-0.016340645,
-0.0904668942,
-0.0077253948,
-0.0357660204,
-0.0461732335,
0.0186652988,
0.0251461547,
0.0771186873,
-0.0226781387,
0.0108606005,
-0.0413690619,
0.0195781328,
0.0008747691,
-0.044466015,
0.0385925174,
-6.117671535e-33,
-0.0266910158,
0.0343781337,
0.0251794718,
-0.0344038643,
-0.0185806081,
0.0127574448,
-0.0227916893,
-0.0129131088,
0.0016425813,
-0.0075197713,
-0.04177697,
-0.0219368059,
0.0274889935,
0.0476722308,
-0.0107770413,
0.0312666483,
0.0321618766,
-0.0023944108,
-0.0008560416,
0.0287560951,
0.0237853825,
0.0512304157,
0.0734722838,
-0.0297154728,
-0.0171346366,
0.0363590978,
0.0555579364,
0.0035746049,
0.0483866818,
0.0200244598,
-0.0188723672,
0.0437274314,
0.0049354895,
-0.0356967486,
-0.0262647159,
0.0261399057,
-0.0759070888,
-0.0427716486,
0.0528026447,
0.0156613216,
-0.0110549303,
-0.0593740344,
-0.0018626048,
-0.0072950614,
-0.0168825537,
0.0197988953,
-0.0019157317,
-0.0299842134,
-0.0386224277,
0.017576566,
-0.0701623708,
0.037760172,
0.0361059494,
0.039124839,
0.061137259,
0.0274383891,
-0.0009952319,
-0.0186863095,
-0.0239712354,
0.0320428833,
0.0033998624,
0.0352485664,
0.0833904073,
0.0312911235,
0.0021208921,
0.0369119607,
0.0249269139,
-0.0190911721,
0.0326846018,
-0.0045000361,
0.0374052674,
-0.0169064123,
-0.0036194799,
0.063872464,
0.020561859,
-0.0442474,
-0.0752656981,
-0.0007797684,
0.0011607409,
0.0073207854,
0.0583342128,
0.0062845652,
-0.0222595371,
-0.0266010221,
-0.0643749312,
0.004403478,
-0.0350715593,
-0.0514730178,
0.0423749797,
0.0012150174,
-0.0293962248,
-0.0248702895,
0.0646193177,
-0.0374203324,
-0.0465523377,
0.0137045542,
0.0061100195,
-0.0201680623,
-0.0285070743,
0.0355540141,
-0.06297528,
-0.0740381852,
0.0032495284,
-0.0319328159,
0.0100097526,
-0.0032070645,
0.019714212,
0.0023264284,
-0.0714745894,
-0.0064018006,
-0.0316277929,
-0.0079392577,
-0.0014391497,
0.0367803052,
0.0447180569,
0.0204968899,
0.0082210833,
0.0178258829,
0.0631438792,
-0.0315723866,
0.0101865977,
-0.0595273376,
0.0093496889,
0.0322223417,
-0.038419418,
0.011456891,
-0.0147693865,
0.0169043969,
0.048430074,
-0.0575151332,
-0.0192227717,
0.0117530003,
2.775e-7,
0.0333173014,
0.0471037664,
-0.0134703116,
-0.0443700105,
-0.0082891574,
-0.0123359123,
-0.0194520801,
0.0372767895,
0.0087615149,
0.0178417414,
0.0072100251,
0.0396238454,
0.0550142899,
0.0268579032,
-0.099357225,
-0.0038344567,
-0.0417355336,
0.0583141148,
-0.0413728878,
0.0175754763,
-0.0129334889,
0.1020177528,
-0.0099539934,
-0.0164993461,
-0.0166425351,
-0.0838885307,
0.0541502796,
-0.0708650127,
-0.0330367796,
0.0112024378,
0.0082863262,
0.0418603197,
-0.0058991085,
0.024715811,
-0.0390835591,
0.0605332032,
0.0311600119,
0.0255701859,
-0.0021633578,
0.0132815978,
0.0004862694,
-0.0152178435,
-0.026616428,
-0.056457784,
0.0510548428,
-0.0471832268,
-0.0286998414,
-0.0164561067,
-0.0177644249,
0.0094835656,
0.0028939836,
-0.010955763,
-0.0155062946,
0.0205365717,
0.0713806897,
0.0270693097,
-0.0598306842,
-0.0543302074,
0.0235189013,
0.0266283918,
-0.0352538526,
-0.0603210479,
-0.0467737764,
0.0100972876,
0.0177448392,
-0.0058437721,
0.0468021892,
2.727579898e-34,
0.0334364958,
-0.0315483287,
0.017536588,
0.0022909208,
0.0294225682,
-0.0459507853,
0.0391133092,
0.0224394687,
-0.0123527702,
-0.1158014387,
-0.0150410375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11474v1 | How Far Can In-Context Alignment Go? Exploring the State of In-Context Alignment | 2024-06-17T12:38:48 | 2024-06-17T12:38:48 | Heyan Huang, Yinghao Li, Huashan Sun, Yu Bai, Yang Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent studies have demonstrated that In-Context Learning (ICL), through the
use of specific demonstrations, can align Large Language Models (LLMs) with
human preferences known as In-Context Alignment (ICA), indicating that models
can comprehend human instructions without requiring parameter adjustments.
However, the exploration of the mechanism and applicability of ICA remains
limited. In this paper, we begin by dividing the context text used in ICA into
three categories: format, system prompt, and example. Through ablation
experiments, we investigate the effectiveness of each part in enabling ICA to
function effectively. We then examine how variants in these parts impact the
model's alignment performance. Our findings indicate that the example part is
crucial for enhancing the model's alignment capabilities, with changes in
examples significantly affecting alignment performance. We also conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of ICA's zero-shot capabilities in various alignment
tasks. The results indicate that compared to parameter fine-tuning methods, ICA
demonstrates superior performance in knowledge-based tasks and tool-use tasks.
However, it still exhibits certain limitations in areas such as multi-turn
dialogues and instruction following. | [
0.0188997947,
0.0023426532,
-0.0173693094,
0.0192903802,
-0.0632380992,
0.0125784166,
0.0001862762,
-0.0383635424,
-0.0506537184,
-0.0110344617,
-0.0607256889,
-0.0291893389,
0.0311675537,
-0.0086856429,
0.0236389767,
-0.0461932942,
0.0799897239,
-0.0069450019,
-0.0123973051,
0.0298522301,
0.0271094702,
0.0038615603,
-0.0398871936,
0.0385619812,
-0.0044726953,
-0.04093365,
-0.0614377037,
0.0323229842,
0.0236452688,
-0.0164721645,
-0.0037185024,
0.0467388406,
0.0355853513,
0.0430361181,
0.0000017577,
-0.0598536469,
0.0161705296,
-0.0165823251,
-0.0719480067,
0.0165607072,
0.0250704922,
-0.0149484444,
-0.0198968872,
0.0136322295,
-0.0550036319,
0.0129836407,
0.0634465665,
0.0136312433,
0.0215672124,
0.0671288669,
-0.0072738705,
0.0007667907,
-0.0050770948,
-0.0075920974,
-0.008302873,
-0.0420381241,
-0.0004120694,
-0.0264473278,
0.034200374,
-0.0071747536,
-0.0179182868,
0.0458206572,
0.0177201834,
-0.0014812545,
-0.0110450545,
0.0272729471,
-0.0527036525,
-0.0213328637,
-0.038745869,
0.0776077509,
0.0023543467,
-0.0418675058,
-0.0169192627,
-0.0186070055,
0.0335772522,
-0.024282638,
-0.0423434786,
-0.0206333734,
0.006152824,
0.0302086025,
-0.003042531,
-0.0104835164,
0.0295955483,
-0.0059811245,
0.0201605726,
0.0554827973,
0.0070998063,
-0.0539044328,
-0.0102463579,
-0.0061811772,
-0.0162646901,
-0.0575066172,
-0.0213756282,
0.0416628085,
-0.0677934214,
0.060806077,
-0.0992770195,
0.0064456803,
0.0178308412,
-0.036461331,
0.015798036,
0.098019816,
0.0125766983,
0.0490638092,
0.0095717162,
0.0990651175,
-0.0113061378,
0.0420447178,
-0.0330533087,
0.0260413475,
-0.0217111427,
-0.0161770936,
-0.0177641194,
-0.0173584409,
-0.0288152117,
-0.0451461673,
-0.0281223375,
0.0805857256,
0.0088403495,
0.0637342408,
-0.0272043031,
-0.0169174057,
-0.0492141694,
-0.0127812689,
-0.0058651543,
0.0357026905,
-0.0163245928,
0.0154511053,
0.0288049597,
-0.0396589302,
-0.0302973241,
0.0126200477,
-0.0148875043,
-0.035674423,
-0.0317795053,
0.0554245226,
-0.0468387641,
-0.0435217097,
0.0020313507,
0.0102082044,
-0.0237371866,
-0.0589061677,
-0.0261067804,
-0.052105315,
0.0414452702,
0.0424059145,
-0.0235314518,
-0.0288967863,
0.002870637,
0.0302691571,
-0.0033464329,
0.050143566,
0.0020094758,
0.0444942303,
0.0316578075,
-0.0190941356,
-0.0012935596,
0.0686854124,
0.0314461812,
-0.0054831808,
-0.0011779544,
-0.0066345301,
-0.0010622336,
0.0637033135,
0.014969036,
0.005780356,
-0.0324744582,
0.0254634041,
0.0378464498,
0.064223282,
0.0449471548,
0.022995133,
-0.0120156771,
0.0137143154,
0.0768035576,
0.0347831398,
0.0051731453,
-0.0238589589,
0.0074258614,
0.0165931676,
0.0058314633,
0.0286802482,
-0.0935456157,
0.0153018441,
-0.0370050445,
0.0765288919,
0.0065734899,
0.0227643568,
-0.0244230274,
-0.0178751592,
-0.0334432833,
0.0172361396,
0.0130631607,
0.0075164507,
0.0260235481,
0.005013118,
-0.0745364204,
0.0131800221,
0.0196039826,
-0.0119303474,
-0.0233517345,
-0.0189644508,
0.0302046984,
0.0627985075,
0.0368021242,
-0.0273942128,
-0.0537764989,
0.0129469978,
0.0271286182,
0.0533308536,
0.0545681864,
-0.0107393116,
-0.0076091085,
-0.0433595181,
-0.0225502495,
-0.0236129221,
-0.013849074,
-0.0038217087,
0.0364686288,
-0.0139512001,
-0.0127938176,
-0.020958785,
-0.0066076727,
0.0450978354,
-0.0402430259,
-0.039184127,
-0.070339568,
0.0435458422,
0.0177448839,
-0.0131820925,
-0.0019742954,
-0.0110072484,
0.0280349944,
0.017119009,
0.0631865859,
0.0429789685,
-0.093600221,
-0.0400065295,
0.034624476,
0.0066848127,
-0.0507211052,
-0.0018313153,
-0.0121069159,
-0.0378373303,
-0.0328655913,
-0.0087929685,
0.0567390136,
-0.0036021338,
0.0548144728,
-0.0084572863,
-0.0395150259,
-0.055182226,
0.048949331,
0.0089349458,
-0.0007521729,
0.0427103192,
0.0027688236,
-0.0093208775,
-0.0432598256,
-0.0072303093,
-0.0011713563,
-0.0168166012,
-0.0054107793,
-0.0088560879,
0.0068421238,
-0.0579580553,
-0.0021981548,
-0.1020144597,
0.0263896305,
-0.0313834511,
0.0201760978,
0.0561159439,
0.0082508875,
-0.0252755005,
-0.0182242487,
-0.0323667042,
-0.0196032915,
-0.0165107977,
0.0030912794,
0.0430160463,
0.0272091255,
-0.0362010561,
-0.0682689399,
0.0142251467,
-0.0272575933,
0.0157150477,
-0.0203242972,
0.0037172216,
-0.0550193824,
0.0468053967,
0.0223450381,
0.014413246,
-0.0196638983,
-0.0126978317,
0.029662719,
0.042196881,
0.0702619106,
0.0891139284,
-0.0031477837,
0.0260583349,
0.037815176,
0.0239457991,
-0.0691858307,
0.0171921793,
-0.0153792379,
-0.0220045857,
-0.0507284924,
-0.0049054157,
-0.0166390501,
0.06119949,
0.0158932917,
0.0430011526,
-0.077102758,
0.0099932542,
0.0211739894,
-0.0451335981,
-0.0354056209,
-0.0345881842,
-0.0628654659,
0.0041642278,
-0.0602507032,
-0.0640697926,
0.0665151924,
-0.0349305384,
-0.0214827824,
-0.0233506579,
-0.0020255947,
-0.0089911511,
0.0239123534,
-0.0223396942,
0.010829147,
-0.0044419058,
-0.0415196754,
-0.0684034079,
0.0153065473,
0.0044453684,
-0.0117708584,
0.0606984943,
-0.0610411912,
0.0043652542,
-0.0106415711,
-0.0466629229,
-0.0625970662,
-0.0393620096,
-0.0039359373,
0.0070858407,
0.0067163692,
0.0031721457,
-0.0455198064,
0.0060764737,
0.0587198474,
0.0505847521,
-0.0087353671,
0.0113832373,
-0.0445478447,
-0.0018231116,
0.0552458689,
0.0160541367,
-0.0292990226,
-0.0294592772,
0.0336936563,
0.0097933467,
0.0668041334,
-0.0187574942,
-0.0362419374,
-0.0268179439,
0.0305161215,
-0.040258646,
-0.0027005842,
0.0453014895,
0.0785064772,
-0.0304790344,
-0.0253831111,
0.111352779,
0.0400156267,
-0.0369386934,
0.013994745,
-0.0189263187,
0.0169236027,
0.0307026003,
0.0238614269,
-0.081003733,
-0.0236379858,
0.0258366,
0.0076283226,
0.0250286534,
0.0288901906,
-0.0087402994,
-0.1266117841,
-0.0017057345,
0.0276683662,
-0.0820596814,
-0.0441890843,
-0.0005025464,
0.0487591811,
-0.0059694392,
0.0792134553,
0.039240092,
-0.0164028592,
-0.0102735208,
0.0148952706,
0.0182807352,
-0.0694011077,
0.0041972147,
-0.0365318954,
0.0543695241,
0.0730976835,
0.0002076954,
0.0349670164,
-0.0212741438,
0.0371894985,
0.0026704315,
0.0393736549,
0.0084027518,
0.0162659101,
-0.0205373503,
-0.0009347288,
-0.002837433,
0.0514819138,
-0.0065546152,
-0.027559774,
-0.0025726552,
0.0560248047,
-0.022531148,
0.0413539223,
0.0039250534,
-0.0272167828,
0.0346077532,
0.0684165955,
0.0371394753,
-0.0515200943,
-0.0191516522,
-0.0050298763,
-0.0133978352,
-0.0069697429,
0.0089425296,
0.0016337691,
-0.0278784633,
0.0167763922,
-0.0450074412,
-0.0334513783,
0.0300110653,
0.0742029697,
0.0409456454,
-0.0168073494,
-0.0036308367,
-0.0232500862,
-0.0017342337,
0.0241407603,
-0.0125561887,
0.0322061963,
-0.0712120906,
-0.0136135714,
-0.0154562937,
-0.0507879853,
0.0004016578,
0.0152222477,
-0.0547450334,
-0.1032527313,
0.0117475558,
0.0157586262,
0.0265206657,
0.1032074615,
-0.004319767,
-0.0168176163,
0.0241001584,
0.0202254597,
0.0001142798,
0.0297766626,
0.0044680191,
0.0203981679,
-0.0077206325,
0.0248945486,
-0.0331082195,
-0.0319861881,
0.0154813733,
0.0422038399,
-0.0574092716,
-0.0287703797,
0.0434544571,
-0.0190883111,
0.042014841,
-0.0081506409,
-0.0166965872,
-0.015433304,
0.0280997604,
-0.0221176185,
-0.0191567875,
0.0044274391,
-0.0654093251,
0.0064257598,
0.0031548801,
0.0306559056,
-0.0171769653,
-0.0168914236,
0.0399058573,
-0.0375566892,
-0.0190893207,
0.0045126574,
0.0245395526,
0.0262106378,
0.047524754,
-0.0297142733,
0.0427160971,
-0.0021854704,
0.043074701,
-0.0048656226,
0.0940301493,
0.0429470912,
0.0063802097,
-0.0159433484,
0.0308924671,
-0.0380364731,
0.0168300234,
-0.0211296584,
-0.000972958,
0.0435354412,
-0.0409097038,
0.0265383199,
-0.0262015667,
-0.0048141601,
-0.009239885,
0.0341204628,
-0.0284688547,
-0.0232691634,
0.025424799,
0.0339849629,
-0.0150008136,
0.0009205701,
0.0459396429,
-0.0129066426,
0.0245788731,
-0.0171586256,
0.0308278408,
-0.0409376621,
-0.0018285376,
0.0617189519,
0.0140317231,
-0.043484658,
-0.0264779609,
-0.0414440706,
-0.0247101989,
-0.0001263138,
0.0431725122,
-0.0318133384,
-0.0205913931,
0.045776017,
0.0569036081,
-0.0421543084,
-0.0391804948,
0.0060133445,
-0.0068197139,
-0.0058528716,
-0.021377461,
-0.0681184381,
-5.722017769e-33,
-0.050240621,
-0.008982406,
0.0468411669,
-0.0023460258,
-0.0304514207,
-0.0229292847,
-0.0309606735,
0.022318732,
-0.0030433312,
-0.0148329409,
-0.021481026,
-0.0206689835,
0.0178226512,
-0.0021830099,
-0.0002826804,
-0.024992099,
0.0334765352,
-0.0036183007,
-0.0539793186,
-0.014576179,
0.0126636242,
0.013779196,
0.0478525646,
-0.0525150336,
0.0251984689,
-0.0061140726,
-0.0141790146,
-0.0032966838,
-0.045001179,
0.0619075373,
0.00695174,
0.0125110783,
0.0007472691,
-0.007466258,
-0.018673135,
0.0595619567,
-0.038952928,
-0.0036597822,
0.063597776,
0.038794037,
-0.0163619872,
-0.0421233624,
0.0482339785,
-0.0366148911,
-0.0429917686,
0.0194018651,
0.0374406986,
-0.0117018037,
-0.0271394625,
0.0104139186,
-0.1003329605,
-0.0127818305,
-0.0339911804,
-0.0441218838,
-0.0033003353,
0.0429508463,
0.0039758007,
0.0006754557,
-0.0688155964,
0.0344492905,
0.0067122648,
0.0217631347,
0.1200778484,
0.0382172801,
0.016046308,
0.0417877026,
-0.0151404794,
-0.0031414751,
0.0351371318,
-0.0353608727,
0.0454103462,
0.0165998135,
0.0010422671,
0.0500907749,
0.0033062114,
0.022660356,
-0.0079902029,
0.0099205729,
-0.0054583824,
0.0251628552,
0.0197965764,
0.046502579,
-0.0867683366,
0.0002303979,
-0.0353683569,
0.0047609555,
-0.0235050227,
-0.0455129594,
0.0430289395,
0.006911851,
0.0209444165,
0.0032356996,
0.0339072235,
-0.0016727063,
-0.0023955444,
0.0089381188,
-0.0275921896,
0.0291376449,
-0.0306124929,
0.0070053921,
-0.0928260088,
-0.0562943965,
0.0085733207,
0.0331376903,
0.0345948339,
0.0169517547,
0.0312406942,
0.028226329,
-0.0615388975,
0.0155454427,
-0.0233263746,
0.0148662366,
-0.0003688993,
-0.0586109422,
0.0690232441,
0.013556717,
-0.0275270771,
0.0467980951,
0.0020128544,
-0.063513726,
-0.0399572477,
-0.0418964922,
-0.0353046507,
-0.0079263104,
-0.0317142978,
0.0131976716,
-0.0045147925,
0.0142184347,
0.0102900118,
-0.0206053127,
-0.0031543551,
0.0369887203,
2.502e-7,
0.0339962244,
0.0371611677,
0.0548562557,
0.0072077513,
0.0054222564,
0.0209337641,
-0.0392607488,
0.0206602886,
0.0175265111,
-0.0089617996,
0.039810814,
0.0078591108,
0.045060277,
-0.0197800025,
-0.083458893,
0.025361903,
-0.0547471903,
0.0408085659,
-0.0504138321,
0.0528573133,
0.0069444091,
0.0808520466,
-0.0029275906,
0.037672881,
-0.0086219553,
-0.020356115,
0.0392489098,
-0.0467333905,
-0.0047724098,
0.0154572129,
-0.0356192663,
-0.0087754214,
-0.0156699307,
0.0250681862,
0.002386489,
0.0464468077,
-0.0233735219,
0.0709930584,
-0.0269270986,
-0.028975673,
-0.0160991997,
0.0157763567,
-0.0101570478,
-0.075605318,
0.0434790328,
-0.0654179752,
-0.0016203008,
-0.0123832254,
-0.0107414443,
-0.0065259063,
-0.0153363477,
0.017017737,
0.0147905489,
0.0180360153,
0.0295427069,
0.0003327787,
-0.044049859,
-0.0422050767,
-0.0480850488,
0.0348686688,
-0.0417773835,
-0.0293297656,
-0.030417433,
0.0000820554,
0.0219718348,
-0.0426894687,
-0.0168515854,
2.180427226e-34,
-0.0129575348,
-0.0164599977,
0.0626918003,
0.0583921969,
-0.0133361658,
-0.0098639149,
-0.0059323241,
0.0409511514,
0.0595267564,
-0.0713918284,
-0.0046251649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11473v1 | Promises, Outlooks and Challenges of Diffusion Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T12:38:38 | 2024-06-17T12:38:38 | Justin Deschenaux, Caglar Gulcehre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The modern autoregressive Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved
outstanding performance on NLP benchmarks, and they are deployed in the real
world. However, they still suffer from limitations of the autoregressive
training paradigm. For example, autoregressive token generation is notably slow
and can be prone to \textit{exposure bias}. The diffusion-based language models
were proposed as an alternative to autoregressive generation to address some of
these limitations. We evaluate the recently proposed Score Entropy Discrete
Diffusion (SEDD) approach and show it is a promising alternative to
autoregressive generation but it has some short-comings too. We empirically
demonstrate the advantages and challenges of SEDD, and observe that SEDD
generally matches autoregressive models in perplexity and on benchmarks such as
HellaSwag, Arc or WinoGrande. Additionally, we show that in terms of inference
latency, SEDD can be up to 4.5$\times$ more efficient than GPT-2. While SEDD
allows conditioning on tokens at abitrary positions, SEDD appears slightly
weaker than GPT-2 for conditional generation given short prompts. Finally, we
reproduced the main results from the original SEDD paper. | [
0.0274010897,
0.0610131696,
0.001120905,
-0.0086962739,
-0.0389671251,
-0.0109985229,
0.007652286,
0.0139974654,
0.0009048912,
-0.0323105715,
0.0006124322,
-0.0631083995,
0.0061939508,
0.0287274253,
0.0511241481,
-0.0199960414,
0.0449292846,
-0.0380999781,
-0.0391937569,
-0.0216119662,
0.00049927,
-0.0007764471,
-0.0024947983,
0.0399952009,
-0.0378421284,
-0.0158536937,
-0.018442288,
0.0094756065,
0.0136700217,
-0.0297358651,
-0.0027129487,
0.078362897,
0.0247870889,
0.015158833,
0.000002131,
-0.0377369411,
0.0055375998,
0.010025261,
0.0076907757,
0.0196541362,
0.0298181307,
0.0229137372,
0.008040552,
0.0421506241,
-0.0136139272,
-0.0304691605,
0.0444532558,
0.04617396,
0.0425196886,
0.0674083382,
-0.0104088541,
-0.0784351155,
0.0492143147,
-0.0548661575,
0.0254551582,
-0.0253013205,
0.0306040067,
0.0057526221,
-0.0063491901,
-0.0059083723,
-0.0424566679,
0.0429008193,
0.0242400225,
-0.0054456014,
0.0613726042,
0.0808580294,
0.0354919732,
-0.0222112518,
-0.0349631794,
0.0751048848,
-0.0146179805,
-0.0253801923,
0.0438342765,
-0.0056742802,
-0.0314149223,
0.0001982508,
-0.0279878005,
-0.0131047228,
0.0200225357,
0.0379708298,
0.0372994617,
-0.0272070821,
0.0412285812,
0.0096152928,
-0.0146901542,
0.0454009064,
0.0409146212,
-0.0309494212,
-0.0022543236,
-0.0195802543,
-0.0408984497,
-0.0631529838,
-0.0095687686,
0.0168165248,
-0.033764489,
0.0191914588,
-0.0242943987,
-0.0269933026,
0.0426846519,
0.0036225233,
0.0269092489,
0.0023266743,
0.0431466326,
0.0143807996,
-0.0469763838,
0.0393081009,
0.0022201119,
-0.0196322743,
-0.0365458988,
0.0160440188,
-0.0212452263,
-0.0078663109,
-0.0503377728,
0.0607754029,
0.0078993514,
-0.0352699719,
-0.0508477241,
0.0047634258,
0.0040478194,
-0.0446556546,
0.0601411499,
-0.0034994029,
-0.0337097086,
0.0029832099,
-0.0035588592,
0.0173404794,
-0.0431170575,
-0.0120448908,
0.023089502,
0.0039400263,
-0.0312681943,
0.0198283866,
0.0139225842,
-0.0060558468,
-0.0080973841,
0.0316104665,
-0.0040283431,
-0.0241994392,
-0.0052792472,
-0.019346565,
-0.0507984497,
-0.0608519465,
-0.0120170675,
-0.0994805917,
0.010638332,
0.029318843,
-0.0001154755,
-0.010073158,
0.0108064581,
0.0249447413,
-0.0327762216,
0.0245120246,
0.0009330763,
0.0374222025,
0.0180417746,
-0.0205208939,
0.0303353295,
0.078159906,
0.0197816323,
0.0255006421,
-0.0105428919,
0.0007190224,
-0.0212146696,
0.0261006169,
0.0609046221,
0.0361734293,
0.0128499065,
-0.0164194517,
0.0243684314,
0.0245601628,
0.0741525292,
0.0796554312,
-0.0494434461,
-0.0116024492,
0.0555486865,
0.0487838425,
0.0005190578,
-0.0429438353,
0.0750568435,
0.0146830529,
-0.0449974611,
0.0149657046,
0.0026909332,
-0.0150860734,
0.0366951413,
0.0079394467,
0.0940978006,
0.0061878548,
-0.0436299257,
-0.0289094336,
0.0079978267,
-0.0109453984,
0.0355372019,
-0.007834346,
0.0364746563,
0.0213978961,
-0.0488414131,
0.0743617862,
0.0178874284,
-0.0469955653,
0.0072007058,
-0.0740769878,
0.0254646577,
0.0616785698,
0.0667393655,
0.0184713062,
0.0396822803,
-0.0310041029,
0.029785376,
0.0333564021,
0.0394343249,
0.0200756062,
0.0083302148,
-0.0486627482,
0.0227629896,
0.0195976254,
0.0354692377,
0.0440215766,
-0.0095389793,
0.0246292334,
0.0283595342,
-0.035023056,
-0.019135816,
0.0246358365,
-0.0259101558,
-0.029625522,
0.0453497842,
-0.0178953744,
0.0151164029,
0.0042868927,
-0.0255499892,
0.023941014,
-0.0054490366,
-0.039994549,
-0.0440656655,
-0.0107189212,
-0.0879740715,
-0.050910376,
0.0222641081,
-0.0057716356,
0.000039777,
0.0039815628,
-0.0277804229,
-0.040787708,
0.0386251658,
-0.0454847477,
0.0426081978,
-0.0549470112,
0.0176515784,
0.0360187776,
0.037637867,
-0.0290745348,
0.0605299957,
-0.0287803765,
0.0335267894,
-0.0370136984,
0.0320678651,
0.0244588275,
-0.023639448,
-0.0014409118,
-0.0411131345,
-0.0162732247,
0.006922103,
0.0095091835,
0.0112968693,
-0.0291931387,
-0.017585434,
-0.0974367857,
0.0167011917,
-0.0462506041,
-0.0084620733,
0.0125465142,
0.0348807946,
0.0030568421,
0.018360883,
-0.0417872183,
0.0045638885,
0.0127504477,
0.0115447566,
0.0194337144,
-0.0074480698,
-0.0165551547,
-0.0354439244,
-0.0196977854,
-0.0244312547,
0.0391369015,
-0.0274210069,
-0.0039358274,
-0.0382611491,
0.0763790905,
-0.0022652496,
0.0080491034,
-0.0101790521,
-0.0489690788,
0.0002138657,
-0.0145988893,
0.1109463051,
0.0124264723,
0.035433881,
0.0171875712,
-0.0158254858,
-0.0268876236,
-0.0303397104,
0.0098597277,
-0.0611781739,
0.0260540508,
-0.0222416893,
-0.0601479933,
-0.0030218668,
0.0474050045,
0.0402730331,
-0.0276606046,
-0.0745972395,
-0.0236426387,
-0.0378225856,
-0.0434105881,
-0.0142316334,
-0.0051836884,
-0.0284991693,
-0.0301855728,
-0.0437581725,
-0.0520322025,
0.0581968129,
-0.0473271348,
0.0126025053,
-0.06428992,
-0.0046817642,
-0.0323560648,
0.0128714591,
0.0358058736,
0.0171762574,
-0.0015505445,
-0.04092291,
-0.0187679585,
0.0042058481,
-0.0036516117,
-0.0189709589,
0.0380056091,
-0.0001043568,
0.0431770235,
0.012151354,
-0.0136886248,
-0.0191368908,
-0.1049939618,
0.0321963094,
0.0209456291,
0.0073725767,
-0.0103443908,
0.0195838232,
0.0476191565,
-0.005936028,
0.0161865223,
-0.0161828157,
0.0027514624,
-0.0132735968,
0.0334475823,
0.1055264696,
-0.0178031176,
-0.0046347668,
-0.0294796247,
0.039295163,
0.0414747074,
0.0714874342,
0.0234350357,
-0.0317984521,
-0.0038097254,
-0.0207389258,
-0.0382149294,
-0.0120563619,
0.0148446243,
0.0733029321,
-0.0247631874,
-0.018887369,
0.1039861441,
0.0098029198,
-0.0342579186,
0.01339084,
0.0185257085,
0.1081993505,
-0.0120499479,
-0.0147563862,
-0.0622065626,
-0.0368516482,
0.0177003331,
-0.0006956584,
-0.0195799321,
-0.0387447476,
-0.0034458553,
-0.1206310466,
0.0502034388,
0.0054003624,
-0.0161900148,
-0.0138753168,
-0.0761296675,
-0.0280904304,
0.0279328004,
0.0006123891,
-0.0016537707,
-0.0150220031,
0.017268464,
0.0502686575,
-0.0235104412,
-0.0446022712,
0.0034507227,
-0.0480422415,
0.0310357679,
0.0875357017,
0.0237788931,
0.0091557018,
-0.0565480925,
0.0654918328,
-0.0328125656,
-0.0140722524,
-0.0233165324,
0.0349894762,
-0.0085036438,
-0.009712371,
-0.0055514546,
0.0293588545,
-0.0254633818,
0.0132969534,
-0.0197063945,
0.0792455673,
0.0071792249,
-0.0558198094,
-0.0220909957,
0.0005318686,
0.0415669568,
0.100282535,
0.0361422673,
-0.0546841808,
-0.0770170689,
-0.0121868504,
0.0599217713,
-0.0034041649,
-0.0273129325,
-0.0037106208,
0.0121434676,
-0.1032765955,
-0.0808361471,
-0.0372374021,
0.0005095268,
0.0692692623,
-0.0091946246,
0.071404919,
-0.0434526727,
-0.0304810386,
-0.0378782451,
-0.0091264537,
-0.0090584746,
0.0167372171,
-0.0780379847,
-0.0141556403,
0.0313907079,
0.0016498014,
-0.0403932445,
0.0088950042,
-0.1084392965,
-0.0877765641,
-0.0179134365,
0.0292559713,
0.0164780933,
0.0192088522,
-0.0311679523,
-0.0500296317,
0.0820478573,
0.033548899,
0.0124307042,
0.0252079107,
-0.0069165477,
-0.0344396569,
0.0148489904,
0.0327052064,
-0.0226975642,
0.0214391872,
0.0087468876,
0.0888339579,
0.0065072565,
0.0407116599,
-0.0062938873,
0.0137488581,
0.0234435033,
-0.0268134195,
0.0274107046,
-0.0428603813,
0.0145477057,
-0.0253659058,
0.0138156954,
-0.0403339304,
0.0070553008,
0.0412466638,
0.0164727885,
-0.0332573391,
-0.0220616534,
0.0031061606,
0.0294355005,
0.0218090918,
0.0045835888,
-0.0150972093,
0.0231350455,
0.0367328562,
-0.022887338,
-0.0125122368,
-0.0253969599,
0.0125169,
0.0055527831,
-0.0183694027,
0.0300891958,
0.0150313322,
-0.0216687396,
-0.0026612876,
0.0250041485,
-0.0476306304,
-0.0220343918,
-0.0248793736,
0.0204690155,
0.0604198612,
0.0327491537,
0.0692411214,
-0.0291055236,
0.0228993762,
-0.0267362893,
0.02766167,
0.0080883969,
-0.0081427302,
0.0355594121,
0.0208119247,
-0.0239345338,
0.0271427575,
0.0808933452,
0.0191409383,
0.022705527,
0.005177456,
-0.0169278812,
-0.0083564753,
-0.0082561783,
-0.0329911485,
-0.0094909118,
-0.0008817422,
0.0351107344,
-0.0352974162,
-0.09053877,
-0.0369272493,
0.0010992715,
0.0172085688,
0.003376038,
0.0507783256,
0.0673960894,
-0.00212909,
-0.0225068647,
-0.0813812912,
0.015673602,
-0.0129850246,
-0.0441193655,
-0.0188282542,
-7.245272573e-33,
-0.0052331919,
-0.0277541671,
0.0153722269,
-0.0292963181,
-0.0538494252,
-0.0148793571,
-0.052760452,
-0.0061845267,
-0.0049761245,
0.0246165078,
-0.0227699671,
0.0108463466,
0.0046517495,
0.0276959613,
-0.0184774455,
0.000852659,
0.061325904,
-0.0141493008,
-0.0000857974,
0.0377734117,
0.0159373339,
0.0316977724,
0.0067612999,
0.0142685799,
-0.0213060156,
0.0058969851,
0.0030655372,
-0.0330852047,
0.0105195036,
0.0174068939,
-0.0445591398,
0.0536389574,
0.034600202,
-0.0134114902,
-0.0119510097,
0.0332658105,
-0.0780817345,
-0.0341663323,
0.0162436869,
-0.024950454,
-0.0119360853,
-0.0167411584,
0.0548555776,
0.0057236124,
-0.0368094258,
0.0273693297,
0.0243505351,
0.0283161905,
-0.0117401853,
-0.0174422096,
-0.0304755606,
0.0427436978,
0.0112404395,
-0.0049049226,
-0.0210871566,
-0.0021069266,
-0.0174870249,
0.0341067575,
-0.0610797033,
0.0090350416,
0.0112612834,
0.0676871315,
0.0231217444,
0.0095093613,
0.0353800282,
0.039901372,
0.0422450304,
0.0115242228,
0.0120826289,
-0.0098080607,
0.0255283285,
-0.0020185164,
-0.0046610716,
-0.034191031,
0.0443015397,
-0.0355161354,
-0.0871169418,
0.0082475645,
-0.0086852321,
0.0421902537,
0.0525651723,
-0.0108170277,
-0.0591398105,
-0.0128002921,
-0.0445976406,
-0.0157416109,
-0.0000776209,
-0.0504407883,
0.0531492569,
0.0280049164,
0.0087498873,
-0.0431508012,
0.0545214042,
-0.0077562514,
-0.0753694698,
0.011479334,
-0.0081143426,
0.0165289976,
-0.0124077182,
0.0386776961,
-0.0697463974,
-0.0304976609,
-0.0088292509,
0.0455973707,
-0.0210885238,
-0.0132152075,
-0.0125304237,
-0.0128408233,
-0.0675624087,
0.0034303297,
-0.0312501378,
0.031211352,
-0.0284527894,
0.0120991385,
0.0284200422,
0.0055733034,
0.0019527002,
0.0504493825,
0.0072972532,
-0.0143604688,
0.0071292189,
0.0140548395,
0.0108773317,
0.0401016288,
-0.014311308,
0.0129774194,
-0.0130520612,
0.0560479127,
0.0406387709,
-0.054449942,
-0.0265332926,
0.0330496281,
2.952e-7,
0.0175179224,
0.0236674268,
-0.0094915498,
0.0277679972,
0.0183433648,
0.0295305718,
-0.0057420437,
0.0236594137,
0.0093357833,
-0.0095849847,
-0.0154198594,
0.0119613092,
0.0372349694,
-0.0315746851,
-0.120305486,
0.0129530933,
-0.0493454486,
0.0307400711,
-0.0417706743,
-0.0134080835,
0.0040747221,
0.0915119275,
-0.0137011074,
0.0049059703,
0.0111400951,
-0.019669421,
0.0632025301,
0.0064586722,
-0.0294247288,
0.0356045887,
0.0172868334,
-0.0393629186,
0.0130687952,
0.016312344,
-0.0379666574,
0.026550699,
0.0119366813,
0.0209754892,
-0.0233106259,
-0.0796224922,
0.0242603626,
-0.007602111,
0.0079181055,
-0.0662135482,
0.0648680404,
-0.0091170631,
-0.0259065423,
-0.0088757593,
-0.0725226402,
0.0076657003,
0.034820091,
-0.0182559472,
-0.0652353317,
0.0176599417,
0.0168595947,
-0.0139866956,
-0.0208828915,
-0.0766041279,
0.0125963408,
-0.0296110269,
-0.0492422357,
-0.059914846,
-0.0450324528,
0.0286397971,
-0.0000104795,
-0.0098485043,
-0.0222661495,
2.879399126e-34,
0.0763912648,
-0.0452956557,
0.0221944526,
0.025546167,
0.0288239233,
-0.0141838836,
-0.0162439942,
0.0200552773,
0.0225498471,
-0.0917421281,
-0.039953094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11464v1 | Automating Easy Read Text Segmentation | 2024-06-17T12:25:25 | 2024-06-17T12:25:25 | Jesús Calleja, Thierry Etchegoyhen, David Ponce | cs.CL | cs.CL | Easy Read text is one of the main forms of access to information for people
with reading difficulties. One of the key characteristics of this type of text
is the requirement to split sentences into smaller grammatical segments, to
facilitate reading. Automated segmentation methods could foster the creation of
Easy Read content, but their viability has yet to be addressed. In this work,
we study novel methods for the task, leveraging masked and generative language
models, along with constituent parsing. We conduct comprehensive automatic and
human evaluations in three languages, analysing the strengths and weaknesses of
the proposed alternatives, under scarce resource limitations. Our results
highlight the viability of automated ER segmentation and remaining deficiencies
compared to expert-driven human segmentation. | [
0.0076722829,
-0.0003062692,
-0.016945878,
0.0389864109,
-0.0587670133,
0.0022376433,
0.0474259332,
0.0053709387,
0.0077849673,
-0.0488478281,
0.0235092286,
-0.0177046694,
0.0171888489,
0.015474014,
0.0023870494,
-0.1190843508,
0.0217549186,
-0.0497447588,
-0.0050435094,
0.0237746052,
0.0508302562,
-0.0007762385,
0.0221849494,
0.0079886969,
0.0310006849,
-0.0039951191,
0.0124931168,
0.0040863766,
0.023079535,
-0.0079865744,
0.0011107902,
0.0342024267,
-0.0328578018,
0.0200462062,
0.0000018503,
-0.0378044471,
-0.0820074603,
0.0077812481,
0.0068840478,
0.0284005236,
0.0729981363,
-0.0678533539,
-0.027665494,
-0.0033718115,
0.0192407686,
0.0127588185,
0.0023831339,
0.0406164341,
0.0553622879,
0.0774293393,
-0.0246612988,
-0.0286280531,
0.0179154668,
0.0095523596,
-0.0105025601,
-0.0028666717,
0.0275561512,
-0.0352597572,
-0.0246107187,
-0.007495054,
0.0118881185,
0.0358351469,
0.004590645,
-0.0090623647,
0.0139272017,
0.0370623842,
0.007565577,
-0.024982648,
-0.0066596372,
0.0194526166,
-0.037381541,
-0.0149623668,
0.04720366,
-0.0154398773,
-0.0242625698,
0.0255276896,
-0.0277005248,
0.0197025482,
-0.0146630472,
0.0287150722,
0.0338153765,
0.0317608379,
-0.0024578522,
-0.011199899,
-0.040909756,
0.0326581299,
0.0331904814,
-0.059681695,
0.0110388575,
0.0181978084,
-0.0096298847,
-0.0338373296,
0.0493306629,
-0.001061443,
0.0481858626,
0.0178216882,
-0.0688992143,
-0.1063783094,
-0.0112398732,
0.0306900349,
-0.0119447112,
0.0152871413,
0.0047283266,
0.0286002159,
-0.0323524326,
0.0055450015,
0.0298684426,
0.0144473081,
-0.0265065972,
0.023848433,
0.0138238845,
-0.0120853484,
-0.0656810105,
-0.0014026337,
-0.0573867857,
-0.0324719436,
-0.0273137782,
-0.0135266008,
0.0135619882,
0.0044213459,
0.0388374589,
-0.0391754285,
-0.0124147348,
-0.005176689,
0.0462714173,
-0.0526660085,
-0.0704985186,
-0.0239437222,
0.0064414348,
-0.0218222011,
0.0175152421,
0.0329042785,
0.0103325704,
-0.0242503844,
-0.0311125629,
0.0044169421,
-0.0446228869,
-0.0482956134,
-0.0474340729,
-0.024110524,
-0.0127821099,
-0.0253535546,
-0.0013819436,
-0.0715319663,
-0.011201812,
0.0013214211,
0.0428717025,
-0.0173266698,
-0.0056808256,
0.0047927001,
-0.0122671304,
0.0702634081,
-0.0117871072,
0.0128711229,
0.0788469613,
0.0182603598,
0.0500318557,
0.0519200191,
0.0384750366,
-0.0012387256,
0.0820900053,
0.0104751186,
0.0313482657,
0.0828068852,
-0.0362407528,
-0.0247480646,
0.0191461761,
-0.0550225601,
-0.0449299477,
-0.0242400132,
0.0191616286,
0.0833193883,
-0.0109223472,
-0.0073983255,
0.0209079944,
0.0509802252,
0.0086209942,
0.0411200896,
0.0362715274,
0.0280253515,
0.0144833382,
0.0711248219,
0.0350991376,
-0.0599422455,
0.0030625083,
0.0385811813,
0.0017012907,
0.042792093,
0.0160487778,
-0.0223088041,
0.0150334258,
0.0026342203,
0.0370720886,
-0.0449898019,
0.0881823003,
0.0233134497,
-0.0796418935,
-0.0104589304,
-0.0000687802,
-0.0824556872,
0.0262949392,
-0.0418546125,
0.0107498029,
0.0201977883,
0.0538099036,
-0.0388283171,
0.0430275612,
0.0393318869,
0.0150842872,
0.0244814623,
-0.0130300457,
0.0032218434,
-0.0185528472,
-0.0655885935,
0.0306702256,
0.0272410065,
0.0200497471,
-0.0024689331,
0.0077713034,
0.0088231955,
0.0309908893,
-0.0379516669,
-0.0079289228,
0.06503319,
-0.0294431094,
0.0205494631,
-0.0298888423,
0.0237236489,
-0.0412220098,
0.0211494677,
-0.0200846139,
0.0042500892,
-0.008924529,
-0.0505861044,
0.0543969423,
0.0141379246,
-0.0251757428,
-0.037604887,
-0.0352607183,
-0.0799351037,
-0.0011259986,
0.0116689894,
0.002391682,
-0.0302636083,
-0.0200602021,
-0.0302848481,
0.0071104923,
-0.0384608805,
0.0485366657,
0.0157143474,
-0.0395828746,
-0.0573164187,
0.057897646,
-0.0101081952,
0.015090487,
-0.010212549,
-0.0308152493,
0.0050727585,
-0.0590791181,
-0.0127909379,
-0.016967034,
-0.0016226481,
-0.0268202033,
-0.0110005243,
0.0031373242,
-0.0140409255,
-0.0293619353,
-0.0847462863,
-0.0469724163,
-0.0416584201,
0.0122741451,
0.0288548358,
-0.0071603335,
-0.0259924605,
0.0065137376,
-0.000727957,
-0.0048818584,
0.0176471546,
-0.0113952644,
0.0532380454,
-0.0254526921,
-0.0187930912,
-0.0463185422,
-0.0247882642,
-0.0078548929,
0.0341523699,
0.0658916458,
-0.0620436594,
-0.0755126923,
0.0152755249,
0.0541893281,
0.009181357,
0.0172687806,
-0.0322055593,
-0.0292289648,
-0.022013288,
0.0834238976,
0.0811867118,
0.0175298974,
0.0423342772,
0.0032467989,
-0.0177972429,
0.0130109536,
-0.0087924413,
-0.0246969573,
0.057615418,
-0.0083109578,
-0.0981908664,
0.0590787902,
0.0888029858,
0.0148436092,
0.0005924705,
-0.028870808,
-0.0241536312,
-0.0826996937,
-0.0461582802,
-0.0398799144,
-0.0088451672,
-0.0399287753,
0.0338170528,
-0.0154214967,
-0.0252521988,
0.0641002804,
-0.0599120297,
-0.007936934,
-0.060506735,
-0.0304286238,
-0.0423151068,
0.0065725436,
0.0371932462,
0.0197924059,
0.0107638948,
-0.0471824668,
-0.0409086682,
0.0557064638,
0.0316031091,
0.022864366,
0.034236826,
-0.0650089979,
-0.0128939012,
-0.0029794623,
-0.0117532434,
-0.0043955608,
-0.0208772011,
0.0078178234,
-0.0166767575,
0.081550926,
-0.0028407096,
-0.0182660129,
0.054425098,
0.0008282983,
0.086132206,
0.0045133159,
-0.0027590578,
-0.0180591494,
0.0862067044,
0.0246990509,
-0.0462346002,
-0.0074275038,
-0.0813023597,
0.0304534361,
0.0348632708,
0.0337324664,
-0.0140315592,
0.0367538258,
0.0023509283,
0.0148296906,
-0.0723824352,
0.0107990699,
-0.0185062177,
0.0465488359,
-0.0627093613,
-0.0257451944,
0.1013792753,
0.0420594811,
-0.0324002653,
-0.0279884823,
-0.0343693942,
0.0241867304,
-0.0491438061,
-0.0086890254,
-0.0495830663,
0.0016716167,
0.0234847274,
0.07143756,
-0.0218678061,
-0.0123690767,
0.0381975733,
-0.0698956922,
0.036177963,
0.0158420485,
-0.0055083488,
-0.0107121076,
-0.006335631,
-0.0152722429,
0.0052430606,
-0.0256931558,
0.0103972284,
-0.0320620462,
-0.0044970592,
0.0201951116,
-0.080720365,
-0.0035144791,
-0.0332616828,
-0.0219502021,
-0.0120071666,
0.0488019325,
-0.0001740082,
-0.0040864991,
-0.0033814076,
0.0674228445,
-0.070145689,
-0.0106920786,
-0.0063734595,
0.0333942883,
-0.0107257292,
-0.003881129,
-0.022517737,
0.0684946477,
0.0376275331,
-0.0161299612,
0.0261842925,
-0.0032326917,
0.02106544,
-0.0294657722,
-0.0161373671,
-0.0014649844,
0.0142613202,
0.0643704534,
0.0292956401,
-0.0277783386,
-0.0641538128,
-0.0468857251,
0.0624223687,
-0.0771283582,
-0.0324142613,
0.0330767557,
-0.0425506122,
-0.0675017908,
-0.0994973779,
-0.0533806235,
0.0689553693,
0.0247304067,
0.0275498573,
-0.0275997594,
0.0286347847,
0.0073234099,
-0.0087335408,
-0.0145271048,
0.0008105055,
-0.0024594665,
-0.1084556207,
-0.036542505,
-0.0337667502,
-0.0186460838,
-0.0358211026,
-0.0101176109,
-0.0537191331,
-0.0319815129,
0.051958371,
0.0350431576,
0.022345392,
0.0053082532,
-0.0241617672,
-0.0552985147,
0.0320533402,
0.013260127,
-0.0278272983,
0.0154897282,
0.0024480815,
0.0168437492,
-0.0268019922,
-0.0049016951,
0.0075358325,
0.029284507,
-0.0051871282,
0.0141045731,
-0.0702638552,
0.0006254254,
-0.0206132587,
0.0228069238,
0.0449167341,
-0.0416192524,
0.0309499595,
-0.0680448264,
-0.0083454559,
-0.0483694226,
0.0118089151,
-0.0386844911,
0.0124224955,
0.0314823724,
0.0214949884,
-0.0317133926,
0.0644804463,
-0.00586484,
0.002192396,
-0.0671226084,
0.0467669591,
0.0115681672,
0.0418199226,
0.013817125,
-0.0063505,
0.0049344739,
0.0200337321,
-0.0536512807,
0.0289835185,
0.0170876309,
0.0755446032,
0.0284544956,
-0.046084296,
0.0044378685,
0.0459690988,
0.0065063797,
0.0488300212,
-0.0561933629,
0.0080269799,
0.0137301432,
-0.0043146447,
0.0628361031,
-0.0199340936,
-0.0282813162,
-0.0115696695,
0.0234779399,
0.0513114184,
-0.0149612688,
-0.0243121162,
-0.0003908418,
0.0002419996,
-0.0431558564,
0.0690195411,
0.0264307242,
-0.0164513215,
0.0389465801,
-0.0148347057,
-0.0410560109,
0.0113517866,
-0.0033283911,
-0.0086597558,
-0.0156552438,
-0.0145518761,
-0.0621412694,
-0.0003858927,
-0.0119129037,
0.0320816822,
0.0167067926,
0.0135427341,
0.0005269497,
0.0430050008,
-0.0254424401,
-0.0115721002,
-0.0458001047,
0.0123324385,
-0.0148867853,
-0.0359525904,
0.0237513799,
-5.880748812e-33,
-0.0187501479,
-0.0338601544,
-0.021239141,
-0.0178207923,
-0.002575217,
0.0158420019,
-0.0469382294,
0.005282538,
0.057775002,
0.0079644499,
-0.0026846835,
-0.0314752497,
0.0502308831,
0.0494718552,
-0.0274512079,
0.0216744877,
0.0552428253,
-0.0203212686,
-0.0292269308,
0.0007622516,
0.0051660626,
0.0391430445,
-0.0008443626,
-0.0204324275,
0.0447119959,
-0.0455337428,
-0.0260980055,
0.0211459901,
0.0592236184,
0.0221806355,
-0.0123957768,
-0.0186308734,
0.0318401381,
-0.0128117129,
-0.0018574656,
0.0757964551,
-0.1045655608,
0.0091791553,
0.0139591824,
0.0073737167,
-0.066448845,
-0.0184061136,
0.0258755237,
-0.0178986955,
0.0442185514,
0.0240889266,
0.050777372,
-0.0093473727,
0.0141926352,
-0.0161036178,
-0.070511654,
0.0660618842,
-0.014246136,
0.0166504513,
0.0730312169,
0.0279032346,
0.0127976425,
0.0040096371,
-0.0717828572,
0.0106673595,
0.057479687,
0.0071689044,
0.0441019684,
0.0098386016,
-0.0129547156,
0.0256487131,
-0.0009127763,
-0.0086481487,
-0.0283744819,
0.0331747383,
0.0402092077,
0.0005865689,
0.0375677198,
-0.0143513298,
0.0136427684,
-0.0049841795,
-0.0318404511,
0.0442735888,
-0.0019109345,
-0.0132702766,
0.0278879963,
0.014258896,
-0.0711940154,
-0.0017594314,
0.0179135203,
-0.0242890641,
-0.0048501953,
0.0138348136,
0.0090014003,
0.0164933763,
-0.0838813335,
-0.0059935651,
0.0186955743,
0.0198568329,
0.0106249778,
-0.036167644,
0.0006592915,
0.0577955544,
-0.0466476642,
0.0121350372,
-0.0397524163,
-0.0104254065,
0.0152632352,
0.0285025463,
-0.0051627941,
-0.0080155339,
-0.0202101097,
-0.0425510928,
-0.0514793731,
0.016584428,
-0.0028999532,
0.0396580324,
-0.0130147468,
0.0859534964,
0.0218621697,
-0.0103821093,
-0.014064108,
0.0305266101,
0.0362562947,
-0.0253498014,
-0.0339138322,
0.0513157919,
0.0012276979,
0.0443971939,
-0.0269493144,
0.0092372,
0.0197019633,
-0.0094762538,
0.0598097071,
0.0054030037,
0.0243568104,
0.0073778555,
2.301e-7,
0.0482426919,
0.0340292305,
0.0597519912,
0.0027601996,
-0.0120357703,
0.020293735,
0.017283855,
0.0053021465,
-0.0003920717,
0.0064738644,
0.0224031452,
-0.0110278772,
0.0557833537,
0.0091708871,
-0.0806880966,
-0.0165324621,
0.0051232479,
0.0079504177,
-0.0386306643,
0.0033620324,
0.0433894694,
0.0230262168,
-0.0032929108,
0.0268892702,
-0.0104834735,
-0.0505161062,
-0.0034533984,
-0.0210816152,
0.0070882426,
0.0492635593,
0.0719131678,
0.0180206131,
-0.0324594788,
0.0099431938,
-0.0137215862,
-0.0067957575,
0.0755823851,
0.0675534829,
0.0206189994,
0.0340964533,
0.0385699309,
-0.0070117204,
-0.0250733532,
-0.0585794002,
0.046434138,
-0.0372011662,
0.0446636043,
0.0426106267,
-0.030737238,
-0.0052740034,
-0.0422956198,
-0.0192154404,
-0.0415811017,
0.0627398416,
0.0304882918,
-0.0301692169,
0.0073667034,
-0.0589813925,
-0.030311225,
0.0026046962,
-0.0260879118,
-0.0255635306,
-0.0303631034,
0.0273550246,
-0.0237869173,
-0.072956048,
-0.0049614632,
2.341352403e-34,
0.0101378746,
0.0010099263,
-0.0480634347,
0.052020777,
0.0298092868,
-0.0175789911,
-0.0102627277,
0.0063497294,
-0.0339668654,
-0.0721950158,
0.0000570518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11460v1 | TRACE the Evidence: Constructing Knowledge-Grounded Reasoning Chains for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-17T12:23:32 | 2024-06-17T12:23:32 | Jinyuan Fang, Zaiqiao Meng, Craig Macdonald | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) offers an effective approach for
addressing question answering (QA) tasks. However, the imperfections of the
retrievers in RAG models often result in the retrieval of irrelevant
information, which could introduce noises and degrade the performance,
especially when handling multi-hop questions that require multiple steps of
reasoning. To enhance the multi-hop reasoning ability of RAG models, we propose
TRACE. TRACE constructs knowledge-grounded reasoning chains, which are a series
of logically connected knowledge triples, to identify and integrate supporting
evidence from the retrieved documents for answering questions. Specifically,
TRACE employs a KG Generator to create a knowledge graph (KG) from the
retrieved documents, and then uses an Autoregressive Reasoning Chain
Constructor to build reasoning chains. Experimental results on three multi-hop
QA datasets show that TRACE achieves an average performance improvement of up
to 14.03% compared to using all the retrieved documents. Moreover, the results
indicate that using reasoning chains as context, rather than the entire
documents, is often sufficient to correctly answer questions. | [
0.0364989154,
-0.0086543737,
0.0021348381,
0.0027866615,
-0.0394724123,
0.0011485794,
-0.0196210127,
-0.0214169193,
0.0167250056,
-0.0344874188,
0.0252444483,
0.0307156127,
-0.0430529043,
0.0136033949,
0.0107854009,
-0.0129431756,
0.0568187647,
0.0009551456,
0.0001575234,
-0.0038309526,
0.0021586646,
0.021704942,
-0.0444405153,
0.0109149171,
-0.0338489898,
-0.034457162,
-0.0218976531,
-0.0126018468,
0.0184920672,
-0.0305240881,
-0.000250851,
0.0265676957,
0.0337092169,
-0.0034475869,
0.0000019918,
-0.0375137739,
-0.0102269016,
-0.0063981144,
-0.0701700598,
-0.044964999,
-0.0708200037,
0.0759275034,
0.0237949602,
0.0377530903,
-0.0595856234,
0.0101486463,
0.0039965599,
0.0546699427,
0.0550612733,
0.0423249677,
0.0053945058,
-0.0361642875,
0.0243996046,
0.0032424836,
0.0698255301,
-0.0189108811,
0.0026865571,
0.0965308994,
0.0353134833,
0.0372403041,
-0.0038979971,
0.0429544672,
0.0265999474,
-0.0180994589,
0.019865334,
0.0190506354,
-0.0199564788,
-0.0018527107,
0.0154459951,
0.0894191712,
0.0715267956,
-0.0254908502,
-0.0040383358,
0.0165147595,
0.0282125939,
0.0489289425,
-0.0452805385,
0.0123780379,
-0.0746750161,
-0.0242707469,
-0.0050490657,
0.0081640314,
0.0244065896,
0.0078012445,
-0.0051481444,
0.1004833281,
-0.0155480318,
-0.0333536491,
0.0059617055,
0.0260351021,
0.0057907705,
-0.0083794445,
0.0098108985,
0.0422842801,
-0.0089255357,
0.0425773673,
0.0170351751,
-0.0016342642,
0.0273083989,
0.0186838862,
-0.0026707891,
0.0258864053,
-0.0062648994,
0.0451486632,
-0.0669737011,
0.0117069343,
-0.0430010892,
-0.0330392718,
-0.0407659598,
-0.0051913066,
-0.0621007942,
-0.0391475074,
-0.0483683646,
0.0564893968,
-0.0519401021,
-0.0121900691,
-0.0008933712,
0.0533722825,
-0.0020622325,
-0.0170338433,
0.0014719816,
0.0522476807,
-0.0022070426,
-0.0027716281,
-0.0657214001,
0.0273897275,
-0.0869303346,
0.0501925536,
0.0688250214,
-0.0150644472,
-0.0070736073,
0.0119230244,
0.0366704203,
-0.0207561515,
0.0095810555,
0.0079237744,
-0.0185750686,
0.0085803661,
-0.0609077848,
-0.0950969383,
0.0107419295,
-0.0447779261,
0.0246675592,
-0.0551762357,
0.0380584076,
0.0209235959,
-0.0374803655,
0.0107328473,
0.0003663772,
0.0492729023,
-0.0276576858,
0.0326333568,
-0.0214334484,
-0.0129095456,
0.0280622914,
0.029471036,
-0.0105200009,
0.0316540264,
0.0155696226,
0.0275083985,
0.0381315909,
0.0185612496,
-0.0162135847,
-0.0553445593,
0.0481934398,
-0.0039257999,
0.0253077485,
0.0431643166,
-0.0453683548,
0.0117553826,
-0.0056746113,
0.0130907642,
-0.0503995232,
0.0108617907,
-0.001613335,
0.0142607549,
0.0431904085,
0.0151338736,
0.05457123,
-0.0195089336,
0.0145329405,
0.0231690109,
-0.0010514463,
0.0429463722,
-0.0697725862,
0.0391299687,
-0.0058035939,
0.0368916877,
-0.0485903397,
-0.0403213985,
-0.0128759798,
0.027510846,
0.0157064535,
0.0202116631,
0.0240224507,
0.0324591585,
-0.0458616465,
0.0058238925,
-0.0145574994,
-0.0620588548,
-0.006103605,
-0.0347851887,
0.0721091703,
0.0373020507,
0.0795684233,
-0.0070905462,
-0.05132908,
-0.0023402071,
0.0098049194,
-0.0096790604,
-0.0055549801,
-0.032894671,
-0.0210475065,
-0.0495093502,
-0.0405180976,
-0.0124383783,
-0.0245880131,
0.0170299485,
0.0419323854,
0.011655665,
0.0279073361,
-0.0606960915,
0.0392558388,
0.0065987092,
-0.0408207662,
-0.0230268463,
-0.0066517089,
0.0137332343,
0.0032164657,
0.0493747257,
0.0175256077,
0.0434934385,
0.0328648947,
-0.0158050843,
-0.0484177805,
0.0341722742,
-0.0469955429,
-0.0485040396,
-0.0086813653,
-0.0058880835,
0.0224779285,
-0.0255252905,
-0.0253153257,
-0.0844944119,
0.005632103,
-0.0425999276,
0.0103829186,
-0.0453987755,
-0.0498563536,
0.0631192848,
-0.0249120463,
-0.0226296932,
0.1017977372,
0.0049075317,
0.0040294062,
-0.0065315436,
0.0464185886,
0.0296559837,
-0.0300322883,
0.0437837318,
-0.0142634707,
-0.0102727544,
0.0212498903,
0.0557602681,
-0.0177515242,
-0.0803395063,
0.0259429608,
-0.0394599847,
0.0379516706,
0.0077783996,
0.0333182737,
0.0014626619,
0.0095694223,
-0.0005359563,
-0.0241004024,
-0.0694731027,
0.0332324244,
0.0407859385,
0.0207947213,
0.0070456169,
0.0286783949,
0.0241579525,
-0.0043605589,
-0.0069008772,
-0.0098681394,
0.0194550548,
0.0221751016,
-0.0016998801,
-0.0355486348,
0.0074518323,
-0.0767409876,
0.0206911284,
-0.0057102372,
0.0054898928,
0.020991005,
-0.0199171007,
0.0328177474,
0.0588582978,
-0.0165568963,
-0.0005690673,
0.0090197837,
-0.0357788503,
-0.0568995886,
0.0516640879,
-0.0494000912,
0.038859766,
0.0255860277,
-0.0112055941,
0.0072440961,
0.0287825502,
0.0222826898,
-0.020635508,
-0.0404651724,
-0.001589213,
0.0384948142,
-0.0046599563,
-0.0473191217,
-0.0361994058,
0.0190520845,
0.0589669347,
-0.030588204,
-0.006258674,
0.0749459416,
0.0036829791,
0.0167315844,
-0.0581314936,
0.0237239078,
-0.0278474577,
0.0457975678,
-0.0192716196,
0.0092415921,
-0.0262974035,
0.0002383993,
-0.0060679261,
-0.0229064375,
0.054211963,
-0.0534374751,
0.0027766766,
-0.0503401496,
0.0322508402,
0.029296143,
-0.0234194789,
-0.063090615,
0.0175956134,
0.0003544398,
-0.0081772646,
-0.0569182262,
-0.0069003622,
-0.0225445777,
-0.0085187862,
0.06900388,
0.0108029079,
-0.0198794995,
-0.0136254905,
-0.0130156372,
0.0691399202,
0.0505624488,
-0.0235265549,
0.0444014072,
0.0163821951,
0.0455405153,
0.0678773597,
0.0334148221,
-0.0136522613,
0.019583961,
-0.006725267,
-0.0190450046,
-0.0080025671,
-0.0245315973,
0.0053986227,
0.0218434781,
-0.0586420782,
-0.044072289,
0.0576723479,
0.051838778,
0.0108794877,
-0.0326032527,
-0.0358353555,
0.0494730882,
0.020522492,
0.0477027856,
-0.0908682793,
-0.0265836846,
0.0036835393,
0.0353412554,
-0.0285368357,
-0.0505889282,
0.0080687553,
-0.1121656373,
0.0286905672,
-0.0056216666,
-0.0048964391,
-0.0396801494,
-0.0547760949,
-0.0084089302,
0.0433795825,
-0.0410352834,
0.0332093909,
0.0006571694,
0.0277805477,
0.0345728174,
0.01173326,
-0.0212791376,
0.0241093338,
0.0050366498,
0.008504075,
0.0708803609,
0.0175492223,
0.0136358058,
-0.0760837942,
-0.0249608587,
-0.0190320984,
0.0426916257,
-0.0185940769,
0.0112137701,
0.0122999279,
0.0297562443,
-0.0580275171,
0.0293366779,
-0.0571104735,
-0.0274096616,
0.0323050953,
0.1026142463,
-0.0517019816,
-0.0129645448,
-0.0356502719,
0.0151435062,
-0.0006333237,
0.0575491264,
0.0204747673,
0.0066042719,
-0.0131481523,
-0.0133769205,
0.0123444777,
-0.0710582584,
0.0105035556,
0.0386355966,
-0.0059942733,
0.0510629676,
-0.0941690654,
-0.0513629243,
0.0213325527,
0.0612824969,
-0.0415824801,
0.020568965,
-0.0024212939,
-0.0053754235,
-0.0610516258,
0.0215754248,
-0.029037565,
-0.0043046474,
-0.0071340259,
0.0259219967,
0.0128430892,
-0.0339326039,
-0.0183571707,
0.0167954452,
-0.0197861157,
-0.0359433554,
-0.0155278789,
0.0435008258,
0.0246042758,
0.0229210015,
-0.0061627985,
-0.0086884024,
-0.0058905371,
0.0019184216,
-0.030947635,
-0.0137101403,
0.0119374562,
-0.03913486,
-0.0210515261,
0.0089979675,
-0.0647498816,
0.0263930093,
-0.038397003,
0.0645648092,
-0.0268230941,
-0.0308290254,
0.035616193,
0.0119759412,
0.0086245416,
0.0268087853,
0.0019875602,
-0.0266050417,
0.0089456076,
-0.0197345242,
-0.015159905,
-0.0119128302,
0.0473931581,
-0.0162302516,
-0.0597709529,
0.0234696846,
-0.0133733703,
-0.0066599282,
0.0600225292,
-0.0130381593,
-0.0214708876,
0.0078538796,
0.0222304761,
0.0088158185,
-0.0261966512,
-0.038445171,
-0.0020670567,
0.0253700241,
0.0693160668,
-0.0106292153,
0.080188565,
0.0313178748,
-0.0235550962,
-0.0128286313,
-0.0069609745,
-0.0979957879,
-0.0118926382,
-0.0127697093,
-0.0113947997,
-0.0018528474,
0.0274926256,
0.0169178117,
-0.0147358952,
-0.0157852843,
0.0214374345,
0.0142567633,
0.0380413495,
-0.0242743343,
0.0479617268,
0.0372614153,
-0.0110236071,
-0.0098122815,
0.0537057482,
-0.0420155153,
0.0444536097,
-0.0438162647,
-0.0498420596,
-0.0357324071,
-0.0393120721,
-0.0486306921,
0.0297391526,
-0.0026782218,
0.0300129373,
-0.0539899543,
-0.0446157977,
-0.0379978083,
0.0235780776,
0.0030534177,
-0.0086798714,
0.0380739719,
0.0640500039,
0.0323816985,
-0.0583895296,
-0.0261233822,
0.0411937572,
-0.1156797409,
-0.0000287816,
0.0084657902,
-6.088587601e-33,
-0.0219130721,
-0.0391685888,
0.0601790659,
-0.037632186,
-0.0202350412,
0.0026520446,
-0.0288555119,
-0.0069324099,
-0.048948165,
0.019371476,
-0.0138231805,
0.0061283521,
0.00351839,
0.0171851292,
-0.0149363615,
0.0318420716,
0.0023866734,
0.0177683849,
-0.0193069689,
0.0583661385,
0.0847844481,
0.0017793678,
0.0225776993,
-0.0360775404,
0.0086357426,
-0.0460874699,
0.0021451821,
0.0408677571,
-0.0399999544,
0.0735546872,
0.0040094857,
0.0056698648,
0.0332560465,
-0.0329535753,
0.0153721888,
0.0453777425,
-0.1331616193,
-0.056933105,
0.0245826114,
-0.031870801,
-0.0885758549,
-0.0161548518,
-0.0150942188,
-0.0098594148,
0.0553089119,
-0.016524246,
0.0185119845,
-0.0144992275,
-0.031764064,
-0.0526908226,
-0.0388075151,
0.0070129293,
-0.0122131873,
-0.0187797006,
-0.0549468584,
0.1016677469,
0.0007478046,
-0.0193698164,
-0.0538106002,
-0.0084571019,
-0.0295759477,
0.0139223998,
0.0509872995,
0.0250413958,
-0.0118931876,
0.0251691863,
-0.0115346154,
-0.028647529,
-0.069908835,
0.0031774372,
-0.0312139317,
0.0507015139,
0.0461056456,
0.0330073759,
0.0100546647,
-0.0030588994,
-0.0788924769,
0.0454249084,
0.0262381546,
0.0565021001,
0.004302389,
-0.020808693,
-0.0491755493,
-0.0155835738,
-0.0523011908,
0.0151676424,
-0.0233693309,
-0.0421168022,
0.0425144024,
0.0152681107,
-0.0286499187,
-0.0040544951,
0.024963025,
-0.0002843833,
0.0309546571,
0.0681134164,
-0.0166728981,
0.0199165456,
-0.0320021436,
0.0445620678,
-0.0325822607,
0.0106550623,
0.0316497348,
-0.0030520535,
-0.0066129407,
0.0299734585,
0.038604077,
-0.0153494636,
-0.0358867124,
-0.0015978583,
-0.0541707389,
0.0584788285,
-0.003911959,
-0.0457496531,
0.0226795301,
0.0682763755,
-0.0139281582,
0.059891656,
0.0164875649,
0.0093243066,
-0.0153710479,
-0.04185801,
-0.0115126241,
0.0097301416,
-0.0187014155,
0.0227929335,
-0.0270440299,
0.0448808894,
0.0039878506,
-0.0559066907,
-0.004515674,
0.0692849606,
2.731e-7,
0.0301859695,
-0.0059317835,
0.0583761781,
0.0091787046,
-0.0051014354,
0.0160186011,
0.0307131037,
-0.0158472247,
0.043537721,
-0.0490911677,
-0.0091521954,
0.0353342108,
0.0061429245,
0.0586106181,
-0.046309825,
-0.0350830369,
-0.0372078568,
-0.0581738092,
-0.026439948,
-0.0209276676,
0.066001378,
0.0075253495,
-0.0019390417,
-0.0335897654,
0.0007370549,
-0.0335546471,
0.0475634933,
0.0459330641,
-0.0038833753,
-0.0081232199,
0.0738362893,
-0.0172901526,
0.019572258,
0.057231836,
-0.0016910138,
0.0234939381,
-0.0373382494,
0.000840332,
-0.0030092073,
-0.0477953255,
-0.003230006,
-0.0414617024,
0.0383003503,
-0.0324152559,
0.0813675597,
-0.0215484351,
0.0011279873,
0.007624873,
-0.0426148623,
-0.0086046914,
-0.0227239486,
-0.0067148069,
0.0030847914,
-0.0099122133,
0.0055304165,
0.0022477848,
0.0176223665,
-0.0797637478,
0.0113973962,
0.0236465186,
-0.0263756383,
-0.0290767327,
-0.0055542458,
-0.0237492491,
0.009494788,
-0.0539392866,
-0.0196770988,
2.360713162e-34,
0.0112544242,
0.0222187024,
0.0289179422,
0.0099270437,
0.0537249707,
-0.0096164411,
-0.0246983171,
-0.0051905871,
0.0317170657,
-0.1018146724,
-0.0317081623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11455v1 | Adaptive Reinforcement Learning Planning: Harnessing Large Language Models for Complex Information Extraction | 2024-06-17T12:11:01 | 2024-06-17T12:11:01 | Zepeng Ding, Ruiyang Ke, Wenhao Huang, Guochao Jiang, Yanda Li, Deqing Yang, Yanghua Xiao, Jiaqing Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing research on large language models (LLMs) shows that they can solve
information extraction tasks through multi-step planning. However, their
extraction behavior on complex sentences and tasks is unstable, emerging issues
such as false positives and missing elements. We observe that decomposing
complex extraction tasks and extracting them step by step can effectively
improve LLMs' performance, and the extraction orders of entities significantly
affect the final results of LLMs. This paper proposes a two-stage multi-step
method for LLM-based information extraction and adopts the RL framework to
execute the multi-step planning. We regard sequential extraction as a Markov
decision process, build an LLM-based extraction environment, design a decision
module to adaptively provide the optimal order for sequential entity extraction
on different sentences, and utilize the DDQN algorithm to train the decision
model. We also design the rewards and evaluation metrics suitable for the
extraction results of LLMs. We conduct extensive experiments on multiple public
datasets to demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving the
information extraction capabilities of LLMs. | [
0.0684747547,
0.0379706472,
0.0009474553,
0.0046730577,
-0.0592786521,
0.0484129004,
-0.028551558,
0.0018487721,
0.0155146746,
-0.0423461273,
0.0010296435,
0.0114191035,
-0.0286035445,
-0.0215276834,
-0.0361493342,
-0.0423452146,
0.0302170478,
-0.0356073976,
0.0454910807,
0.0447892398,
0.0102003142,
-0.0018653814,
-0.0165194403,
-0.018301066,
0.0215141289,
0.0137528926,
-0.0023512498,
-0.0387831517,
0.0576103814,
-0.0618115962,
-0.0053341533,
-0.009068979,
-0.0107417293,
0.0258232933,
0.0000016848,
-0.0541105345,
-0.0481478535,
0.0072953501,
-0.027503496,
-0.0433998331,
0.0081478097,
-0.0216847863,
-0.0156189688,
0.0057277665,
-0.0282690059,
-0.039028395,
0.0023185078,
0.0657590106,
0.0388088264,
0.0915373787,
-0.0065027932,
-0.036421515,
0.0055414964,
-0.0224474948,
-0.0050439984,
-0.0573017262,
0.0950827673,
0.0248676632,
0.0594309904,
-0.004035553,
0.0254087914,
0.0245753359,
0.0020772829,
0.014130611,
-0.0544728488,
0.039939709,
0.046134755,
-0.022892639,
-0.0250052046,
0.0790635049,
-0.0106843878,
0.0515142679,
0.0812529996,
-0.0175674129,
-0.0047651576,
0.0035224764,
-0.0364533551,
0.0433130115,
-0.0339144655,
0.0179871041,
0.029985873,
-0.0138721438,
0.0214102454,
0.0187311321,
-0.0805391669,
0.0783330575,
-0.0223743971,
-0.0796802863,
0.0443083085,
0.0141237238,
0.0238044243,
-0.0267335363,
0.0330896676,
0.0369593427,
-0.0487561636,
0.0606137551,
-0.002728523,
-0.0381887481,
-0.0025900821,
-0.0357002914,
0.0127159869,
-0.0005892453,
0.0224782191,
0.0698288754,
-0.033088237,
0.0516117103,
-0.0076625454,
0.0090402123,
-0.0011841862,
0.0008648286,
-0.0599710941,
0.0182762574,
-0.0091114799,
0.0708938092,
-0.0272400398,
-0.0250708349,
-0.0148400059,
0.0423531383,
-0.0101776402,
0.0497602038,
0.0342119373,
-0.0367922857,
-0.023767462,
-0.0157127418,
-0.055090297,
-0.0145118469,
-0.030385999,
0.0006062045,
0.0088046836,
-0.0035223975,
-0.0058961916,
-0.0265199896,
0.0370073095,
-0.0586854219,
0.0109228967,
0.079458043,
0.0063783973,
-0.0272607747,
-0.0364682972,
-0.0132064437,
0.0096087949,
-0.0556524955,
0.0174081791,
-0.029993169,
0.0412997007,
-0.0058198101,
-0.0162140019,
-0.0102554038,
0.0249963906,
0.0060989312,
-0.0661453232,
0.0387981124,
0.0020943675,
0.0118413717,
-0.0127542242,
-0.0314875878,
0.0056184437,
0.0686978027,
0.0613312721,
0.0327462517,
0.0462130979,
0.0339209661,
0.010089946,
0.0590646602,
-0.0196277555,
-0.0230636746,
0.0044097183,
0.0186061282,
-0.0284371302,
0.0214649774,
0.0370898061,
0.0222714897,
-0.0204477664,
0.0564855188,
0.0132176317,
0.0224554185,
0.0267118551,
-0.0336661339,
0.0341598727,
0.0279413257,
0.0043505402,
0.0019784304,
-0.0187303834,
-0.0095690871,
-0.0183812156,
0.0332636908,
-0.0397047773,
0.0600856058,
0.0288903769,
-0.0351313166,
0.0058046319,
-0.0151350088,
0.0396836028,
0.0434947424,
0.0753970221,
0.004724015,
-0.0653894171,
-0.0087292865,
0.0348811895,
0.0019150948,
-0.0127850613,
-0.0321191065,
0.0369360633,
0.0509515852,
0.0357468165,
-0.0867048651,
-0.0083257612,
-0.0042450735,
-0.0297555067,
0.0278554335,
0.0032858297,
-0.0386387073,
0.008152537,
-0.0201414619,
-0.0669471174,
0.0519357249,
0.0007935919,
0.020167226,
0.0664245337,
0.0129593732,
-0.0199809391,
0.0372492373,
-0.0355934091,
0.0526437908,
-0.0518031046,
-0.0568319932,
0.0182464253,
0.0055854637,
0.0461360514,
0.0016284138,
-0.0407567807,
-0.0093014622,
0.0367716998,
-0.0090375496,
-0.0180854443,
-0.0316142999,
-0.0173350219,
-0.0340392217,
0.0224647895,
0.0420386344,
-0.0207375102,
-0.0186580773,
-0.0407442003,
-0.0096727489,
-0.0486662872,
0.0226033628,
0.0202366859,
-0.0117559694,
0.002918968,
0.0462134704,
-0.0105608432,
-0.0765062943,
0.0744642988,
-0.0033468127,
-0.0013309233,
0.0201782342,
-0.0255328733,
-0.0567444824,
-0.0385076255,
0.0000769386,
0.0291612688,
0.0073812166,
0.0041627893,
0.044406727,
0.0292038918,
-0.0399919599,
-0.0544724017,
-0.0309082251,
0.0294164717,
-0.0271080565,
0.0321008265,
0.0030786977,
0.0224404167,
-0.028835468,
-0.0198451355,
-0.0037881285,
0.0004318519,
-0.0002531757,
-0.0201258622,
0.0424888059,
0.0630896986,
-0.0073042838,
-0.036017891,
0.0041391361,
-0.0038661431,
0.0149673056,
0.0053546312,
-0.0213833787,
-0.0530776605,
0.0061581978,
0.0022218816,
0.0313108414,
-0.0037456735,
-0.0034280377,
-0.0438521914,
-0.0390215181,
0.0400160551,
0.0701263696,
-0.0045370944,
0.0585331358,
0.0079333428,
-0.0310899634,
-0.0515097678,
0.0433168001,
-0.0610476919,
0.0208915547,
-0.0602366254,
-0.0244593844,
0.0633414686,
0.0593409166,
-0.0247899275,
0.044527825,
-0.0225516073,
-0.0100463564,
0.00468949,
-0.0458711721,
0.014893719,
0.0461002663,
-0.0280019455,
0.0262176655,
-0.0381008536,
0.0115836561,
0.0679767206,
0.0088619785,
0.0008932696,
-0.0349498689,
-0.0321905091,
-0.0482590869,
0.039453689,
0.0120999916,
0.0196977034,
0.0086408174,
-0.0312650949,
-0.0147098824,
-0.0276576225,
0.0099664796,
-0.0197272431,
0.0586725324,
-0.0359933153,
0.0049328245,
-0.0029468054,
-0.0363935232,
-0.0548005141,
-0.0071729091,
-0.0177553687,
-0.0006693254,
-0.0082423138,
-0.0142449476,
-0.046309039,
0.0049909586,
0.0505766459,
0.0318442658,
-0.0158382803,
-0.0040050396,
-0.0310352985,
0.0330167599,
0.0551221073,
0.0189528782,
0.0241115969,
-0.0216176547,
0.0491906814,
0.0169649515,
0.0321926884,
-0.0205851439,
0.0223049466,
-0.0075521986,
0.0294915121,
-0.0872343034,
0.0281720459,
0.0410234258,
0.0003915345,
-0.0574955717,
-0.0168410093,
0.078857474,
0.0155936247,
-0.0089223972,
-0.0252346415,
0.0096456911,
0.0009997603,
-0.0099434927,
0.0632014051,
-0.0487607606,
-0.0045887069,
0.021740362,
0.0058934167,
-0.0010921282,
-0.0684440359,
0.0024655224,
-0.1237190515,
0.0221256074,
-0.019484017,
-0.05237877,
-0.0327555537,
-0.0357044153,
0.0171554908,
-0.0294435248,
0.0184487607,
0.0484459512,
-0.0591175109,
0.0058125295,
0.0219579358,
-0.0369753726,
-0.0346527994,
-0.0086912578,
-0.0098132398,
0.0135396142,
0.0998402461,
0.0225992091,
-0.0179720242,
0.0274520367,
-0.0155579615,
-0.035074994,
-0.04753948,
-0.0204178281,
0.0178429931,
-0.0300157554,
-0.0023013547,
-0.0296996534,
0.0074751968,
0.0214091036,
-0.01935816,
0.0492780209,
0.081922628,
-0.0068676341,
-0.0314676464,
0.0081723025,
-0.031461753,
0.0092625162,
0.0731883794,
-0.0266408976,
-0.0516343638,
-0.0506851114,
0.0185489357,
-0.0554295368,
-0.0814649537,
0.0160968881,
0.008654058,
-0.0809582323,
0.039810773,
-0.0797816515,
-0.0636004657,
0.05580163,
0.0219487268,
0.0203259718,
0.0184772033,
0.0519739352,
0.0450611338,
-0.0273324158,
-0.0148001881,
-0.0230157115,
-0.0002774869,
-0.0647380203,
0.0040696808,
0.0038955188,
-0.0223804787,
-0.0526062734,
-0.0086499592,
-0.0423437357,
-0.0335281938,
0.0093761487,
0.0244260374,
0.0082868617,
0.0551825166,
0.0071366983,
-0.0130032087,
0.0389590226,
-0.0121823819,
-0.0382663012,
-0.0231073797,
0.0252415333,
0.0448263325,
-0.004767817,
0.0291910693,
-0.0666296184,
0.0205074847,
-0.0170428064,
0.0485029407,
-0.0772993341,
-0.0214589052,
0.0073224897,
0.0321499109,
0.0418152586,
-0.0129250428,
-0.0445957296,
-0.0631963611,
0.0046593691,
-0.022482397,
-0.0445546657,
-0.0399739631,
0.0393875614,
0.0316902697,
-0.0039706412,
0.0039114845,
0.0129020726,
0.0430748537,
-0.0158147141,
-0.0377861485,
0.0058677797,
0.0126750153,
0.0015354952,
0.0406386591,
-0.0300587025,
0.0206229687,
0.016283514,
0.0431826524,
0.0436663069,
-0.0352152102,
0.0372808836,
0.0434171855,
-0.0202511549,
-0.012313568,
-0.024636915,
-0.0205834359,
0.0021855498,
0.0045006839,
0.0482746437,
0.0667445213,
0.0070303739,
0.0618895143,
-0.0285403337,
-0.0140782055,
-0.0014255338,
-0.0103405891,
-0.0123891737,
0.0342263617,
0.0243095439,
0.0349776335,
-0.0336534977,
0.0032056498,
0.0389635861,
0.0117113059,
0.0354018956,
-0.0040141512,
-0.0159969013,
-0.0623468682,
-0.0336793326,
-0.0023319337,
0.008993485,
-0.0475188792,
-0.0249900427,
-0.044903066,
-0.0154217714,
-0.0022339821,
0.016744189,
-0.0306612905,
-0.0171703678,
0.0342002735,
0.0258385278,
0.00871618,
-0.0213954672,
-0.0978796706,
-0.0220309608,
-0.0085334675,
-0.0491684936,
0.0371031202,
-5.742692878e-33,
-0.0417152904,
-0.0239174217,
0.0647003055,
-0.0116434386,
-0.0266177878,
0.003346713,
-0.0097546065,
-0.0394600034,
0.0214892756,
0.015714908,
-0.0172019079,
-0.0379594229,
0.0339080729,
0.0087217754,
0.0017710136,
0.0027921223,
0.0230954122,
-0.0077212504,
-0.0026532689,
-0.0019902985,
0.0435794368,
0.0674747825,
0.0291880742,
-0.060845606,
0.0235287622,
0.0162687432,
-0.0054634996,
0.0344844982,
0.0376866274,
0.0747849345,
0.0085271681,
-0.0197852049,
0.0050097248,
-0.042598933,
0.0045587518,
0.0369578414,
-0.1427169144,
-0.0055442732,
-0.0079971747,
0.0087097343,
-0.033685755,
-0.0176527221,
0.0054333573,
-0.0133819534,
0.018037077,
0.0103479177,
0.0461636968,
-0.0305967871,
-0.0055707078,
-0.0192197189,
-0.0446060896,
0.0423763096,
0.028127037,
0.0454257317,
0.0891780555,
0.0066499328,
0.0118424827,
0.0235940218,
-0.012019434,
-0.022809254,
-0.0112781748,
0.0207636319,
0.0205813628,
0.0785921291,
0.0252899863,
0.0543313064,
0.013829845,
-0.028868245,
0.0286003128,
0.0001832704,
-0.0046746233,
0.0643447116,
-0.0603590831,
0.02933079,
0.006528982,
0.0246131439,
-0.0908169895,
0.0137395049,
0.0536381267,
0.0564254187,
0.0141733149,
-0.0184697416,
-0.0564345531,
0.0348557681,
-0.002256247,
0.0363652371,
0.0057602096,
-0.0256177429,
0.0511022992,
0.0572030358,
-0.012306706,
0.0093810475,
0.0345594846,
-0.0205450878,
-0.038647864,
-0.0018098797,
-0.0271424707,
-0.0080924677,
-0.025561275,
-0.0150490487,
-0.0776720792,
-0.0494545959,
-0.0187136419,
-0.0351929031,
-0.0137296459,
0.0234429911,
0.0006830542,
-0.0161004625,
-0.060195677,
0.0172987003,
-0.0200603455,
0.045129396,
-0.0035812522,
0.0466756225,
0.0226811431,
0.0032604425,
-0.011523963,
-0.0060460456,
0.0624290779,
-0.0461383462,
-0.0044263266,
0.0166442208,
0.0079595493,
-0.0100661162,
-0.0079272911,
0.0031998164,
-0.0358436927,
0.0242147353,
-0.0134424539,
-0.0458063409,
0.0258580782,
0.0564907901,
2.498e-7,
-0.0060411971,
0.0725108534,
0.0369506702,
0.0204027239,
-0.0018837266,
0.010122369,
-0.0310069975,
-0.0057201479,
-0.0105768843,
0.0396801271,
0.0491107143,
0.0072789737,
0.005577263,
0.0207570642,
-0.1025059298,
-0.0547958799,
-0.040524479,
-0.0282057729,
-0.071684137,
-0.0228339862,
-0.0003648096,
0.0574287362,
0.0297987983,
0.011076129,
-0.0311728697,
-0.057175763,
0.0194440223,
-0.0199405141,
0.0037247818,
0.0350427926,
0.0372321978,
0.0140700974,
-0.0236018207,
-0.013119773,
0.0125170927,
0.0591947027,
0.003387264,
0.1035343185,
0.0230198633,
-0.0086955279,
-0.0049941605,
-0.0433964096,
0.0274618566,
-0.0085672503,
0.0589554496,
-0.0563192219,
0.0049754535,
-0.0148338182,
-0.0200027898,
-0.0334499888,
-0.060459666,
-0.0000242158,
-0.0082938382,
0.0367838964,
0.0134375971,
0.0138036497,
-0.0409688689,
-0.0865302011,
0.0156617928,
0.0553672425,
-0.0111995153,
-0.036701262,
-0.0134164952,
0.0166324023,
-0.0162988901,
-0.083716996,
-0.005730005,
2.417512039e-34,
-0.0349381417,
0.0087612206,
-0.0470319875,
0.0431813411,
0.017729396,
0.015752485,
-0.054964833,
0.0487616882,
-0.010683028,
-0.0868120864,
-0.0010087283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11431v1 | Super(ficial)-alignment: Strong Models May Deceive Weak Models in Weak-to-Strong Generalization | 2024-06-17T11:36:39 | 2024-06-17T11:36:39 | Wenkai Yang, Shiqi Shen, Guangyao Shen, Zhi Gong, Yankai Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Superalignment, where humans are weak supervisors of superhuman models, has
become an important and widely discussed issue in the current era of rapid
development of Large Language Models (LLMs). The recent work preliminarily
studies this problem by using weak models to supervise strong models. It
discovers that weakly supervised strong students can consistently outperform
weak teachers towards the alignment target, leading to a weak-to-strong
generalization phenomenon. However, we are concerned that behind such a
promising phenomenon, whether there exists an issue of weak-to-strong
deception, where strong models may deceive weak models by exhibiting
well-aligned in areas known to weak models but producing misaligned behaviors
in cases weak models do not know. We then take an initial step towards
exploring this security issue in a specific but realistic multi-objective
alignment case, where there may be some alignment targets conflicting with each
other (e.g., helpfulness v.s. harmlessness). Such a conflict is likely to cause
strong models to deceive weak models in one alignment dimension to gain high
reward in other alignment dimension. Our experiments on both the reward
modeling task and the preference optimization scenario indicate: (1) the
weak-to-strong deception exists; (2) the deception phenomenon may intensify as
the capability gap between weak and strong models increases. We also discuss
potential solutions and find bootstrapping with an intermediate model can
mitigate the deception to some extent. Our work highlights the urgent need to
pay more attention to the true reliability of superalignment. | [
0.0431374386,
0.0697860718,
-0.0344367698,
0.0297584292,
-0.0273548365,
0.02258146,
-0.013812826,
-0.020370964,
-0.0343751833,
0.0169992726,
-0.078640826,
-0.0372562073,
0.0261556003,
-0.0124652628,
0.0617642738,
-0.0443929657,
0.0621545687,
-0.0506119803,
0.0338076241,
-0.0120106107,
-0.0048932233,
-0.0387592092,
0.0076183882,
0.0139756138,
-0.00005374,
-0.0239460599,
-0.0142861074,
-0.007107676,
0.0328307934,
-0.0024728375,
0.0022478458,
0.0434068777,
0.0261812415,
0.0722744763,
0.0000019381,
-0.0393302888,
-0.002720817,
-0.0199503284,
-0.0386475548,
0.0127954874,
-0.0133830691,
-0.055680491,
-0.0120758191,
-0.0187528953,
-0.0516187362,
-0.0000523955,
0.0447290093,
0.0454312228,
0.0531406179,
0.0640617087,
0.0306587182,
-0.0186301377,
0.0318087712,
-0.0424593687,
0.0059682853,
-0.0906270519,
0.0221730974,
-0.007746879,
-0.0387802757,
0.004084988,
-0.0288328007,
-0.0062881629,
-0.017594032,
0.0062649678,
0.0089833764,
0.0037435435,
-0.0181038026,
-0.023952527,
-0.0088972393,
0.0298799369,
-0.0338073745,
-0.0010266212,
-0.0049153725,
-0.0069920123,
0.0452007204,
0.0258530304,
-0.0071646012,
0.025745539,
0.0128848804,
0.0083027491,
0.0238549113,
-0.0028323072,
0.0460562557,
0.0021219822,
0.029220609,
0.0451262221,
0.0053916862,
-0.0566223785,
-0.0069460608,
0.016632814,
-0.0975862965,
-0.0768203661,
-0.0425439216,
0.0224130973,
-0.0691526756,
0.0200011507,
-0.0570664108,
-0.0037212076,
0.0014027889,
-0.0179939792,
0.0339946896,
0.017251756,
0.0210674126,
0.0284302253,
0.0092781819,
0.1208484173,
-0.0605992265,
0.0454016738,
-0.0265186112,
0.0493352376,
-0.0030868638,
-0.0426486284,
0.033892706,
0.0167252012,
-0.0050736316,
-0.0141328666,
-0.055853527,
0.0137942815,
-0.0444971547,
0.0430923626,
-0.0423139594,
0.0151531212,
-0.0504958071,
-0.0222247262,
-0.0344866104,
0.0079013761,
-0.0213848911,
0.0297914948,
0.0119934585,
-0.0120135052,
-0.0260886438,
0.0034030064,
-0.0561838187,
-0.0362354815,
-0.0213765241,
0.0957235917,
-0.0218441579,
-0.0011762403,
-0.0202658959,
-0.0107225636,
-0.0422379524,
-0.0739733949,
0.001900187,
-0.0401866809,
0.0015527782,
-0.0114266863,
-0.028813472,
-0.0596982799,
-0.0078095915,
-0.0332753174,
-0.0323996916,
0.0240543168,
0.0294914935,
0.033683829,
-0.001476025,
-0.0009920107,
-0.0630217344,
0.064839527,
0.007097587,
0.0286070108,
0.011790392,
-0.0003447953,
0.0191554222,
0.0378302969,
0.0169669185,
0.0260498133,
-0.0033787445,
-0.0159201548,
0.0574017912,
0.0651931837,
0.0270481948,
0.0370387062,
-0.0082941595,
0.0028569158,
0.0984010696,
0.0252453499,
0.0028350949,
0.0032517039,
-0.0237274654,
-0.0137711121,
-0.0119799869,
0.0720536858,
-0.0990669429,
0.0095770704,
-0.0467284471,
0.00294056,
-0.0463555865,
0.0355901457,
-0.0187713858,
-0.0121184848,
-0.0196084492,
-0.0238633417,
-0.0184371285,
0.0290907267,
0.0399828181,
-0.001222202,
-0.0245734472,
-0.0119683035,
0.0276129264,
-0.0260324534,
0.0105939591,
-0.0691938251,
0.0269564111,
0.0134169394,
0.0211302079,
-0.0028211391,
-0.0030392527,
0.0000431234,
0.0013888053,
0.0466266721,
0.0396390259,
-0.0127138849,
0.0090042641,
-0.0138502633,
-0.0237722099,
-0.0313610733,
0.0260018539,
-0.0023032264,
-0.0220893379,
-0.0441176519,
-0.0167734642,
-0.0115663344,
-0.0115783159,
0.0607310347,
-0.0233668257,
-0.0100845136,
-0.0760922804,
0.0283658206,
0.017943278,
0.0068593179,
-0.0258872248,
0.0171008985,
0.025445126,
-0.0006396587,
0.0186515674,
-0.0209977068,
-0.0498965867,
0.0291557983,
0.0363177396,
-0.0530123562,
-0.0262964591,
0.0463358089,
0.0073958379,
-0.0327727757,
0.0261777863,
-0.015743982,
0.024525838,
0.0187401343,
0.0777034611,
-0.0498463064,
0.0112835513,
-0.0485121869,
0.0747461691,
0.0131650809,
0.0256984718,
0.0186129157,
-0.0092097828,
-0.0064603584,
-0.0528478995,
-0.0107766446,
0.0136108296,
0.0053238459,
0.027585905,
0.0349921957,
0.0000889611,
-0.0286439862,
-0.0653840676,
-0.0275918283,
0.0027767872,
-0.0085483259,
0.0052561192,
0.0316746011,
-0.0450165831,
-0.0084493943,
0.0303311646,
-0.0486332364,
-0.0235809181,
-0.009139522,
0.0010300254,
0.0216099247,
0.0032355618,
-0.0100092096,
-0.0330231525,
-0.0123062646,
-0.0135763008,
0.0203056913,
0.0216536131,
0.0185382422,
-0.0677581206,
0.0431932881,
-0.0166100394,
0.040991284,
-0.0181093123,
-0.0419190414,
0.0330381878,
0.0349398367,
0.0409447663,
0.1260756999,
0.0008537228,
0.0158921201,
0.0551351979,
0.0292913821,
-0.0510485955,
-0.010321998,
0.0209978111,
-0.0620545112,
-0.073265478,
-0.0236990117,
-0.0283666439,
0.080012247,
0.0272395462,
0.0003532547,
-0.0500536337,
0.0256381091,
-0.0091465525,
-0.0757962093,
0.0070708361,
-0.0244154055,
-0.0399251059,
0.0223365929,
-0.0523043461,
-0.052083306,
0.0899923816,
-0.0211775489,
0.0005807643,
0.0308096297,
0.0154175339,
0.0059060412,
0.0415958799,
-0.0060365251,
0.0223542489,
0.0012312478,
-0.0138514088,
-0.1043614671,
-0.0290888716,
0.0433463305,
-0.0266987961,
0.0200030152,
-0.0175862145,
-0.0274445098,
-0.0354555994,
-0.0623020381,
-0.0558150746,
-0.0325234644,
-0.0055068126,
-0.005854704,
0.0120626995,
-0.0236573815,
-0.0543196425,
-0.0317727737,
0.0320385881,
-0.018436579,
-0.0294974148,
0.0120064924,
-0.0362906009,
-0.0343513787,
0.0666928887,
0.0012653806,
0.0162923019,
-0.1020642743,
-0.0102875745,
0.0256266147,
0.0401900485,
0.0286039039,
0.0054412885,
-0.0030873159,
0.0483827814,
0.0249284822,
-0.0032736931,
0.0164793376,
0.0632966533,
0.0008189291,
0.0108439317,
0.0716684088,
0.0172419809,
0.0027912236,
0.0372252539,
-0.003703648,
0.0415920317,
0.0193295944,
-0.003101255,
-0.0234661251,
-0.0099105891,
0.0097972667,
0.0473968387,
-0.0028284367,
-0.0288564153,
0.0094823875,
-0.100417681,
-0.0240508113,
0.0545019396,
-0.0240470245,
-0.0268160347,
0.0174404178,
0.0032919843,
-0.0317556597,
0.048212111,
0.0244359318,
0.0317133442,
-0.0038317703,
0.01350547,
0.0655137077,
-0.0295086857,
-0.0117340209,
-0.0452878065,
0.0672602728,
0.0815152675,
0.0099717947,
-0.025565166,
-0.0514058061,
0.0217886381,
0.0320763998,
0.0041568307,
0.0495759584,
0.0051825349,
-0.0255116448,
-0.0227458607,
-0.0166264083,
0.0443931818,
0.0252409391,
-0.0056067901,
0.0079001123,
0.0833943039,
0.0129885552,
-0.0260694828,
-0.000096803,
-0.0372024998,
0.0030257625,
0.0622110367,
-0.001211261,
-0.0616155602,
-0.0006662621,
-0.0050372127,
0.0004719934,
0.0261515584,
-0.0504878238,
0.0746969506,
0.0335820168,
-0.0151044307,
-0.0604957119,
-0.0148172732,
-0.0226662252,
0.0513693951,
0.0467230827,
-0.014132902,
-0.0083255954,
-0.0260190424,
0.0183170158,
0.0184017122,
-0.0251368154,
0.0383503623,
-0.0658650473,
-0.0184839852,
-0.0063469494,
-0.0637447387,
0.0137798805,
-0.0139322858,
-0.0469186455,
-0.1078546196,
0.0208793245,
0.0288436785,
0.0354248844,
0.0502757989,
0.015786279,
-0.030353602,
0.026518045,
0.0300681833,
-0.0302056465,
0.0525002331,
0.038600035,
-0.0339907333,
0.0010763302,
0.033344496,
-0.0471562669,
-0.0051990305,
0.082312271,
0.0173951071,
0.0024401026,
0.0070492313,
0.0602606535,
0.0020038644,
0.0717394203,
-0.0365261845,
0.0144462753,
-0.0092891585,
-0.007824257,
-0.001220272,
-0.0277742539,
-0.013166368,
-0.0373814367,
0.0624242797,
0.0487416312,
0.0612048283,
-0.0196324289,
0.0199756362,
0.0361257307,
-0.0492230169,
0.0080700275,
-0.0132248746,
0.0197838172,
0.0192664359,
0.0503727645,
-0.0101767797,
0.0548389927,
-0.0419178419,
0.029218547,
0.0548802428,
0.0618032962,
0.0375445262,
0.0128650749,
-0.0210934114,
0.012107606,
-0.0742675439,
-0.0407023653,
-0.0057459865,
-0.0103391437,
0.0391729549,
-0.011779543,
0.0243656449,
-0.0108488118,
0.0051300982,
-0.0056971805,
0.0171741191,
-0.0361548141,
-0.031365294,
0.0360317975,
0.0237222761,
-0.0066022705,
0.0060158568,
0.0461823978,
-0.0219894536,
0.0441785604,
-0.0740313232,
-0.002301266,
-0.0036365211,
-0.0450916849,
0.0447336771,
0.0068998877,
-0.021040909,
-0.0175512843,
-0.0501867756,
-0.0710384473,
-0.0302059166,
0.0342765376,
0.0259222556,
-0.0185908638,
0.014784364,
0.051233016,
-0.0564757027,
0.0031390407,
-0.023112705,
-0.0371394679,
0.0584818311,
0.0216556787,
-0.0254027676,
-6.213483876e-33,
-0.0060792649,
-0.0080356644,
-0.0259651653,
-0.0215169583,
-0.0148729431,
-0.0050455476,
0.0034872328,
0.0271536168,
-0.0597069003,
-0.0260961894,
-0.0033358559,
-0.0148863653,
0.0048591467,
0.0025811638,
0.0025272081,
0.0137470858,
0.0170499291,
-0.0129010445,
-0.0536181778,
-0.0241551474,
0.0143911252,
0.014607409,
0.0599474944,
-0.0805741921,
0.057805907,
-0.0414706618,
-0.0580116175,
0.020767821,
-0.0419923738,
0.0517839678,
-0.0098119043,
-0.006091536,
-0.0082785189,
-0.0237935055,
-0.01560059,
0.0193687379,
0.0188074894,
-0.0139376093,
0.0500014313,
-0.0078583928,
-0.0271210689,
-0.048423253,
0.0353298932,
-0.0166716315,
-0.0599810295,
-0.0103301667,
0.0081958231,
-0.0238034036,
-0.018263489,
0.0281542074,
-0.0785904303,
-0.0118980203,
-0.0228061676,
0.000170424,
-0.004732423,
-0.0017963583,
0.0001682417,
-0.0351435319,
-0.0037953835,
0.0511991493,
0.0404143929,
0.0223071016,
0.0956194028,
0.0685259029,
0.0099279489,
0.0717602596,
0.0188836027,
0.0139993699,
0.0325562917,
-0.0361944661,
0.0019483975,
0.0398773998,
0.0747004151,
0.0593588054,
0.0298975483,
-0.0081574852,
0.0016500881,
-0.0404608361,
0.0206485447,
-0.0105996616,
0.0191941764,
0.0544606075,
-0.0651305914,
-0.0181848146,
-0.0327316225,
-0.0300791971,
-0.0261251368,
-0.0292252582,
0.018286651,
0.0185411312,
0.0091765039,
-0.0024055638,
0.0240198597,
-0.0427494422,
0.0035423189,
0.0003738305,
-0.0191118009,
0.0076510212,
-0.0299055278,
0.0000315881,
-0.062658526,
-0.0553367324,
0.0187127069,
0.0370160192,
0.0495258979,
0.057008069,
0.0536996461,
-0.0005624157,
-0.0261328351,
0.0045922063,
-0.0239197277,
-0.0195151903,
0.0443272926,
-0.0837085843,
0.087434791,
-0.0608129837,
-0.0321749151,
0.0298326854,
0.0208317079,
-0.0225265101,
-0.062509805,
0.0365600251,
-0.02464775,
0.006787675,
-0.0011865866,
-0.0132040381,
0.0054772114,
0.0232517291,
0.0233018044,
-0.0508792661,
-0.0135518061,
-0.0202319585,
2.791e-7,
-0.0150383711,
0.0101716202,
-0.0008149866,
-0.0078481985,
-0.0080223456,
0.0772013664,
-0.0567213595,
0.0437764227,
0.0073011648,
-0.0272462424,
0.0087932833,
0.0129064601,
0.0223293956,
-0.0019993365,
-0.0319109187,
0.0347627997,
-0.0693073347,
0.016879214,
-0.0319111384,
0.0184387285,
0.0470800586,
0.083648093,
0.0204019304,
-0.0035190242,
-0.0259059221,
-0.0659699216,
0.0326896794,
-0.0075763944,
-0.0008734487,
0.0039342311,
0.0143373199,
-0.0126279108,
-0.0383021422,
0.0264292508,
0.0169523191,
0.0422161855,
-0.0063926661,
0.0285709593,
-0.035635259,
0.0112726679,
-0.0315582566,
0.0241920352,
-0.0104103228,
-0.0256952476,
0.0450950414,
-0.0543403327,
-0.055205185,
-0.0270375665,
0.0114823962,
-0.0021761453,
-0.0108798649,
-0.0113024982,
0.0475258306,
0.0303001013,
-0.0060253739,
0.0526399016,
-0.0191051867,
-0.0444684587,
-0.0409741923,
0.0325086787,
-0.0311595555,
-0.0713199452,
0.0121419271,
0.0723124966,
0.007306362,
-0.0662479252,
0.0036605841,
2.416874242e-34,
-0.0100936079,
-0.0225049611,
0.0502899624,
-0.0154412873,
0.0413100906,
-0.0285533778,
-0.0179120339,
0.0357287675,
0.0493197851,
-0.0060784356,
-0.0286130253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11430v1 | A Simple and Effective $L_2$ Norm-Based Strategy for KV Cache Compression | 2024-06-17T11:35:16 | 2024-06-17T11:35:16 | Alessio Devoto, Yu Zhao, Simone Scardapane, Pasquale Minervini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) is often hindered by the
extensive memory requirements of the Key-Value (KV) cache, especially as
context lengths increase. Existing approaches to reduce the KV cache size
involve either fine-tuning the model to learn a compression strategy or
leveraging attention scores to reduce the sequence length. We analyse the
attention distributions in decoder-only Transformers-based models and observe
that attention allocation patterns stay consistent across most layers.
Surprisingly, we find a clear correlation between the $L_2$ and the attention
scores over cached KV pairs, where a low $L_2$ of a key embedding usually leads
to a high attention score during decoding. This finding indicates that the
influence of a KV pair is potentially determined by the key embedding itself
before being queried. Based on this observation, we compress the KV cache based
on the $L_2$ of key embeddings. Our experimental results show that this simple
strategy can reduce the KV cache size by 50% on language modelling and
needle-in-a-haystack tasks and 90% on passkey retrieval tasks without losing
accuracy. | [
0.0215566717,
0.0406738222,
-0.0043377466,
0.0252873376,
-0.0280342624,
0.0201189499,
-0.0174029134,
0.014166072,
-0.0070133931,
-0.0198600683,
-0.004721168,
-0.0735244527,
0.0007611864,
0.0062684566,
0.0116472393,
-0.0065824995,
0.0510341972,
-0.0327365622,
-0.0003494908,
0.0047427886,
-0.0417708978,
-0.0036356281,
0.0441650413,
0.0352031849,
0.0292110723,
0.0157529414,
-0.0304448716,
-0.0007299916,
-0.0041796346,
-0.0105564808,
-0.0165764857,
0.0697485432,
0.018967703,
-0.0032261778,
0.0000021694,
-0.0020607836,
0.0023298846,
-0.0008622051,
-0.0673585609,
0.0796368048,
0.0663096756,
-0.0043522022,
-0.0241096206,
0.0147236111,
0.0032512429,
-0.0336517766,
0.0658652037,
0.0042692805,
0.0345616825,
0.0218435377,
0.0067848037,
-0.0430241898,
0.0069808247,
-0.0356426351,
0.0191987474,
-0.079074204,
0.013486715,
-0.0308333244,
-0.0309957862,
0.0278165452,
-0.0298938546,
0.0690398961,
0.0325682089,
0.033004608,
0.0508777499,
0.0484132543,
-0.0233185701,
-0.0097219655,
-0.0114166867,
0.0225039553,
-0.061250452,
-0.0444698632,
-0.0005746143,
0.0041199056,
-0.0104096662,
-0.0205559824,
-0.0391670801,
0.0138765005,
-0.0063094874,
-0.0163122285,
0.0122581897,
-0.0143032381,
0.0322278887,
-0.0308317114,
-0.0479048789,
-0.0326838046,
0.0390603133,
-0.0337698013,
-0.0382715017,
-0.0210221317,
0.0024834822,
-0.0418380164,
0.0047335345,
0.0334310271,
0.0278661717,
0.0259217527,
-0.0358721986,
-0.0161113869,
0.0077729612,
-0.0843918473,
0.0560509264,
0.0572143868,
0.0022340023,
0.0155720254,
-0.042531196,
0.0832910016,
-0.0203270335,
0.0127349244,
-0.0364172868,
-0.0136483386,
-0.0360385701,
-0.0274178181,
-0.0293655675,
0.0133754155,
0.0126119563,
-0.0150479721,
-0.011228242,
0.0362468734,
0.0691097304,
-0.0003661521,
0.0086177541,
0.0176894516,
-0.0126041705,
0.0206743404,
0.0341396853,
0.0464644954,
0.0003070326,
-0.0416210853,
-0.0028402731,
-0.0480809547,
-0.0395430401,
-0.0086883297,
0.0101981424,
-0.0330425799,
0.0041886698,
0.047746107,
0.001596023,
-0.0431695469,
-0.0110577494,
-0.0018123799,
0.004946054,
-0.0124246022,
0.0281382799,
-0.0414465815,
0.0061612143,
0.0128105925,
-0.0250661671,
-0.0310602505,
-0.0007313815,
0.0450993143,
-0.0584162809,
0.0332820565,
0.0702329725,
0.0053904518,
0.0122814449,
0.0113442214,
0.0310314484,
0.039948225,
0.0286242347,
0.017231198,
0.001507166,
-0.0595470257,
-0.0060518719,
0.0240042843,
0.054735899,
0.0102292616,
-0.011733124,
0.0141269099,
0.0367892422,
-0.0078270854,
0.0332297236,
0.0613438003,
-0.0294628739,
-0.04219063,
0.0385320708,
0.0684845448,
0.03980349,
0.0232165512,
-0.015493542,
0.0286985822,
-0.0165447108,
-0.0142216142,
-0.0519700646,
0.073090069,
-0.0009217722,
0.0151559953,
0.0440976061,
0.0164136235,
-0.0274443831,
-0.0139118088,
-0.029157592,
-0.0098353913,
0.0280369297,
0.009341646,
0.0231743362,
-0.0212086532,
-0.0568925664,
0.0864537284,
0.0005736069,
-0.0667999238,
-0.0108722402,
-0.0354222544,
-0.0321899801,
0.0581951514,
0.0484112315,
0.0695445314,
-0.0056289579,
0.0193883236,
-0.0172096509,
-0.0112237167,
0.0347630195,
0.0152831972,
0.003548695,
-0.0722990185,
-0.0106763719,
-0.0015814458,
-0.0055424334,
-0.0073117041,
0.027789304,
0.00445484,
0.0420775004,
-0.022590844,
0.0107736327,
-0.0066934032,
-0.0352092758,
-0.0429152586,
-0.0151062179,
0.0163934473,
0.0025012465,
-0.0030548107,
-0.0145968851,
0.0378512926,
0.0491327792,
-0.0415395387,
0.0296337306,
-0.0269898623,
-0.0691953599,
-0.0003698615,
0.0261074863,
0.0178167727,
0.0395743661,
0.0574049801,
0.0063949204,
-0.0224418752,
0.0334223546,
-0.0601424128,
0.0855545923,
-0.0080804294,
0.0033306009,
-0.0165353827,
0.0319983922,
-0.0414176024,
0.0389014594,
-0.0558504574,
0.0010465205,
-0.0114748655,
0.0137820747,
-0.0025688405,
0.0116426153,
-0.0210975446,
0.0283109657,
-0.0258312225,
0.0303827524,
0.0128691867,
-0.0289817434,
-0.0034692755,
-0.0146696018,
-0.0500896834,
-0.0117711667,
-0.0247870442,
0.0473933667,
0.0088392785,
0.0196095966,
0.0118205855,
-0.0134083303,
-0.0283273663,
-0.0292269997,
-0.0205970351,
0.0327462032,
-0.0342770778,
-0.0235055331,
-0.0156920012,
-0.027686039,
-0.0606653877,
0.0013659018,
0.0558333769,
-0.0516817868,
-0.0308684148,
-0.0246033389,
0.0719311163,
0.0043959706,
-0.0112861805,
-0.0076426356,
-0.0747383684,
-0.0012199121,
-0.0256208591,
0.0480457246,
0.0711070076,
0.0157418214,
0.0026815259,
0.0678934678,
-0.0369758233,
-0.0248101093,
0.0043549971,
-0.0175557323,
-0.0540708676,
-0.0410225131,
-0.0235632658,
0.0016097411,
0.1108792275,
-0.0273615792,
0.0052876491,
-0.0853727013,
-0.0567092784,
-0.0046065394,
-0.0101801371,
-0.0280818753,
0.0084614819,
-0.0325755998,
0.0365521871,
-0.0186490063,
-0.035915371,
0.0518439189,
-0.031432502,
-0.0156621672,
-0.0381014906,
0.0109741753,
-0.0032955057,
0.0537216291,
-0.0106854811,
0.0266513862,
-0.0316762514,
-0.0332224555,
-0.0382427722,
0.005031528,
-0.0177561566,
-0.0627528876,
0.048743289,
-0.0075156149,
-0.0122657157,
-0.0351038985,
-0.0100906091,
-0.0416328162,
0.010285846,
-0.0240830984,
-0.0025808432,
0.0575788058,
-0.0232348405,
0.007275431,
0.0438591205,
0.0275557898,
0.0426801704,
0.017436387,
0.0133858575,
0.0031493728,
-0.0005569161,
0.0297117867,
0.0231842175,
0.0143356035,
-0.0219581481,
0.0147385942,
0.0681072176,
0.0656367838,
0.015972117,
0.0050766477,
0.0047190678,
0.0573425815,
0.0087445686,
-0.0254038945,
0.0506424569,
0.0175661258,
-0.0851283222,
-0.0291769393,
0.0765638649,
0.0377972759,
-0.0948699787,
-0.0040821112,
-0.0351008922,
0.0274573006,
0.0182847325,
0.0364136957,
-0.0619767271,
-0.024162367,
0.0309712812,
0.0376745909,
0.0194335971,
0.0077235647,
-0.0048980797,
-0.1282916665,
0.0093550039,
0.030765919,
-0.0147542004,
-0.0522883423,
-0.0595021546,
-0.0285632107,
0.0049987156,
0.0174532309,
0.0298373718,
0.0014045399,
-0.0141271194,
0.019462496,
0.0113187013,
-0.0756543204,
0.0560880415,
0.0002169159,
0.0433461331,
0.068433091,
-0.0098977285,
0.0291621014,
-0.0458996184,
-0.0052147037,
0.0010840965,
0.0089527788,
0.0063784556,
-0.0048665488,
-0.0143596269,
-0.0179430749,
-0.0353945345,
-0.011918067,
-0.0229584482,
0.0095185386,
-0.0202838797,
0.0710363314,
0.0024504086,
-0.0309111234,
-0.0171431564,
-0.0425083414,
-0.0332558043,
0.0660022497,
0.0710011348,
-0.0113376454,
-0.0286194161,
-0.0305862203,
0.0146307722,
-0.0494863316,
-0.0795597807,
0.0478472747,
0.0097687338,
-0.052855663,
-0.0312426649,
-0.0223471597,
-0.0081239324,
-0.0034054806,
-0.0186631605,
0.0063618501,
0.0321407616,
-0.0080603193,
-0.1100067943,
0.0092913136,
-0.041034054,
0.0044501033,
-0.0677528381,
-0.0021405469,
-0.0198897086,
-0.0148549909,
-0.0146039883,
-0.0104472851,
-0.1038692519,
-0.0509877205,
0.0273014642,
0.0675831512,
0.0134010799,
0.0446591079,
-0.0059751044,
-0.0764357373,
0.0355649926,
0.0026961686,
-0.0795547441,
0.050797686,
0.0085385554,
-0.0483194217,
0.010263579,
0.0209524818,
-0.0579900965,
0.00459173,
0.0005769165,
0.0375781655,
-0.0059913537,
-0.0298297629,
0.0018112772,
-0.006638092,
0.0165064652,
0.024442073,
0.0065466333,
0.0412517302,
0.0568090901,
0.005259004,
0.0202752091,
-0.0050465777,
-0.0174865946,
-0.0070243566,
-0.0030472565,
0.0210894048,
0.0145322969,
0.0370594002,
0.0212451741,
-0.0076220399,
0.0288652852,
-0.0101139918,
0.0031487958,
0.0671459362,
0.0142675415,
-0.0505829901,
-0.0226581451,
-0.0025674242,
0.0316211358,
-0.0363069512,
-0.0120529151,
0.0025143716,
0.0156393591,
-0.0166898705,
0.0489522144,
-0.0654544532,
-0.0341385119,
0.0282596201,
-0.0614985265,
0.0453999527,
-0.029210506,
0.0248384755,
-0.028696375,
0.008489321,
-0.0488601141,
0.00652176,
-0.0095522571,
-0.0116989883,
0.0156401154,
0.026681982,
0.0049460344,
-0.0067184493,
0.0611687973,
0.0172324665,
0.0478743613,
-0.0366539396,
-0.0056512225,
-0.0181753933,
0.0029224313,
0.0000153053,
0.0327803753,
-0.0275044125,
-0.0150012067,
-0.0586599521,
-0.0857846215,
0.0035968176,
-0.0278190989,
-0.0040338594,
-0.0335841104,
0.0171882473,
0.0422336794,
0.0017329904,
-0.0234052204,
-0.009422916,
0.0168644544,
-0.0532564297,
-0.0280561019,
0.0213874765,
-6.678577032e-33,
-0.0175445471,
0.0188258309,
0.0157409944,
-0.0394330285,
-0.0350213051,
0.0267754085,
-0.0523385294,
-0.0075964541,
-0.0514362305,
-0.0364922136,
-0.0408667624,
0.0094372947,
0.0166888367,
0.0115578463,
0.0275849011,
-0.0133098764,
0.0504900478,
0.0139767705,
-0.0100693172,
0.0585873909,
0.0298825447,
0.0366268419,
0.0677291751,
-0.0115556465,
-0.0287365653,
0.0012527835,
0.0743115917,
-0.0241060015,
-0.0051750815,
0.0579378158,
-0.0300170854,
0.0274412539,
0.0097309984,
-0.0711957067,
-0.0317772068,
0.0084307734,
-0.0523239933,
0.0168711711,
0.0069340877,
0.0082161911,
0.0346283279,
-0.0724628717,
0.0177631881,
0.0251411814,
0.0129332915,
-0.0320946313,
-0.0039448314,
-0.0026192989,
-0.0969138667,
-0.0105096558,
-0.015319597,
0.0224858318,
0.0139172291,
-0.011444659,
0.0589240864,
0.0266040731,
-0.0180660505,
0.039680507,
-0.0698062181,
0.0090796594,
0.0198820811,
0.1089087948,
0.074039869,
0.0405194387,
0.0077776611,
0.0256625563,
0.0190454163,
-0.0102662854,
-0.0692925826,
0.0287480298,
0.0524135567,
0.0029482055,
0.0228881426,
-0.009081061,
0.0506312028,
-0.0496389456,
-0.032208208,
-0.0428201109,
0.0091424892,
0.0737181753,
0.0656689107,
0.0182687081,
-0.0533040911,
-0.0350989737,
-0.0552669205,
0.0387897231,
-0.0526554994,
-0.0321009867,
0.0367529839,
0.0188260842,
-0.025104899,
-0.017881019,
0.083820574,
-0.0251624025,
0.0330760553,
0.0383448564,
0.0133877425,
0.047313977,
-0.0119262012,
0.0349872522,
-0.0560864583,
0.0159987994,
0.0142326728,
-0.0400492884,
0.0019059317,
0.0148683246,
-0.0406257249,
0.0375638418,
-0.0374806561,
-0.0274535865,
-0.0533256456,
-0.0261647142,
0.0186384041,
0.0597751252,
0.0557974018,
0.0150742354,
0.0183793455,
0.0562207848,
-0.026969634,
0.0125977434,
0.010368404,
-0.0168811753,
0.0162796471,
0.0301219486,
-0.0104759997,
0.0126463976,
-0.1010600701,
0.0434678309,
0.029758282,
-0.0147961266,
-0.0186704211,
0.0398926139,
2.867e-7,
0.0172560606,
0.0498927385,
0.0275647249,
0.0258453339,
-0.0146132382,
0.0217271186,
0.0104121175,
0.0262340065,
-0.015247019,
-0.0122684436,
-0.02701943,
0.0432574712,
0.0521024466,
0.0073762578,
-0.0766403601,
-0.0257213172,
-0.0583968051,
0.0236582775,
-0.0189718362,
-0.0018937496,
0.0317006148,
0.1216347739,
-0.0226890445,
0.002050221,
0.0391652472,
0.0293174218,
0.0362280197,
-0.0128176631,
-0.008624211,
-0.0221312176,
0.0157287568,
0.0316673182,
-0.027479142,
0.0059307879,
-0.0223967917,
-0.0080640316,
-0.0221326388,
0.0633592531,
-0.0015658807,
-0.0747044384,
0.0192988012,
-0.0217758454,
-0.044844389,
-0.0440436266,
0.0683870763,
-0.0270128287,
-0.0203408953,
-0.045843821,
-0.004883647,
0.0095533542,
-0.0374263935,
-0.0039371708,
0.0185319856,
0.0139726894,
0.0086370222,
-0.0171008185,
0.0267559979,
-0.0956268534,
-0.0304020178,
-0.0075115236,
-0.003339337,
-0.0112570599,
-0.0880772546,
-0.0208444167,
0.0482445247,
0.004947864,
-0.0021845731,
2.850826348e-34,
0.03106457,
-0.0270832442,
0.0256646965,
0.0454760417,
0.0080802552,
-0.0295799654,
0.0092848567,
0.0471705832,
0.0144852716,
-0.0990502238,
-0.0462285168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11429v1 | Fusion Makes Perfection: An Efficient Multi-Grained Matching Approach for Zero-Shot Relation Extraction | 2024-06-17T11:31:48 | 2024-06-17T11:31:48 | Shilong Li, Ge Bai, Zhang Zhang, Ying Liu, Chenji Lu, Daichi Guo, Ruifang Liu, Yong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Predicting unseen relations that cannot be observed during the training phase
is a challenging task in relation extraction. Previous works have made progress
by matching the semantics between input instances and label descriptions.
However, fine-grained matching often requires laborious manual annotation, and
rich interactions between instances and label descriptions come with
significant computational overhead. In this work, we propose an efficient
multi-grained matching approach that uses virtual entity matching to reduce
manual annotation cost, and fuses coarse-grained recall and fine-grained
classification for rich interactions with guaranteed inference speed.
Experimental results show that our approach outperforms the previous State Of
The Art (SOTA) methods, and achieves a balance between inference efficiency and
prediction accuracy in zero-shot relation extraction tasks. Our code is
available at https://github.com/longls777/EMMA. | [
0.0258643366,
0.0257938877,
0.0230669919,
0.0952998102,
0.016940318,
0.0284373183,
-0.0288329516,
0.0131634912,
0.0170036852,
-0.0638942868,
-0.0376658775,
0.0089484984,
-0.0056354473,
-0.0071505001,
-0.0046396945,
-0.0280042887,
0.0390490703,
0.0563329011,
-0.0060365037,
0.0432950109,
0.0137144877,
0.044002004,
-0.0349566676,
0.0038799455,
-0.0417474955,
0.0017614326,
0.0190767515,
0.0144367442,
0.0531375445,
-0.0507671237,
-0.0143345138,
0.0309516024,
0.0107466159,
0.0130807711,
0.0000018377,
-0.0396094732,
-0.0066201342,
0.0135314316,
-0.0320107974,
-0.0217482578,
-0.0152503699,
-0.0451092571,
0.0448636375,
-0.0120719038,
-0.0421559364,
-0.0680443123,
0.0393943638,
0.065855585,
-0.0091661541,
0.0256191008,
-0.0599500276,
-0.0626058802,
0.0160520729,
-0.0329500996,
0.0323508307,
-0.0448094197,
0.0229496174,
-0.0265521705,
0.008214226,
0.000764002,
0.0103019327,
0.0097723538,
0.0057434924,
-0.0005861751,
0.0373759568,
0.0661633462,
-0.0660861284,
-0.0022773566,
0.0058987369,
0.127422452,
0.0440415069,
0.0168582238,
0.0255744793,
0.000155728,
-0.0133092571,
-0.0191271603,
0.0086882506,
-0.0308722481,
-0.0295143798,
0.00615633,
-0.0301802121,
0.0167462137,
0.0139653543,
0.0130519234,
0.0022867129,
0.0089435726,
0.0003597673,
-0.0240411758,
0.0085969819,
0.0348703898,
0.0121361678,
-0.0429441221,
-0.0283838287,
0.0360197574,
-0.0199519377,
0.0073344409,
-0.0495244302,
0.009249323,
-0.0020449155,
-0.0085241748,
0.0090569565,
0.0184808616,
0.0017968727,
0.0788507089,
-0.0447330289,
-0.0136473365,
-0.0060361186,
-0.0218653847,
-0.0107387081,
-0.0000629279,
-0.0802720338,
0.0441688485,
-0.041478388,
0.0883619338,
-0.0246047862,
-0.026559297,
-0.0263587851,
-0.0108622927,
-0.0217399187,
0.0473960191,
-0.0247832611,
0.0155789312,
-0.0057568369,
0.0028900132,
-0.0138697568,
0.0509059653,
-0.0714161396,
0.0000761096,
-0.0323929451,
-0.0296683293,
-0.0289926324,
-0.0157170482,
0.0421652831,
-0.0513517968,
0.0166494604,
0.0818231925,
0.0033476513,
-0.0604398064,
-0.0220162757,
-0.0411685519,
0.0139040574,
-0.0501496494,
0.0022740343,
-0.0089153852,
0.0849746317,
0.0152848763,
-0.0106091565,
0.007421297,
0.040260084,
-0.0065294947,
-0.0892470479,
0.0908771902,
-0.0024504247,
-0.0165946539,
-0.0256870706,
0.0223971643,
0.0323601775,
0.0720096529,
0.0009713754,
0.0027136598,
0.006453176,
0.0187705718,
0.0031961873,
0.0371939205,
0.0230485164,
-0.0060661966,
-0.0144315064,
0.0049402686,
0.0249041468,
0.0146349007,
0.0443520881,
0.0070538535,
-0.0515967868,
-0.0353682265,
0.0211707279,
0.0289265141,
-0.025138421,
0.0050819647,
0.0390009917,
0.0166464355,
0.0094090104,
0.0207863823,
-0.0824176967,
0.0602180064,
-0.0450723805,
-0.0011543335,
-0.0054489709,
0.0204916913,
-0.0366312638,
0.0212472808,
0.0105156777,
-0.0181191023,
-0.0155124972,
0.0163375549,
0.0403838865,
0.0164589491,
-0.034038119,
0.0594547279,
0.075024806,
0.006233193,
-0.0401024967,
0.0061504375,
-0.0134288222,
0.047774706,
0.0489066243,
-0.0314924456,
-0.0722470656,
0.0010530765,
-0.017441703,
0.0414453596,
0.041443903,
-0.0417398289,
0.0437070131,
-0.0288925264,
-0.043413721,
0.0160884652,
-0.004534137,
0.0028958281,
0.0482214093,
0.0154980607,
0.0182990767,
0.0026934315,
0.0240352415,
0.0373173729,
-0.0158069413,
-0.0432854332,
0.0139166564,
0.0407492444,
-0.0007086489,
0.0306667034,
-0.0144446641,
-0.0189359691,
0.0324722305,
-0.0251385216,
0.0197662134,
0.0215097293,
-0.0024214112,
-0.0403896756,
0.0312343724,
0.0087652216,
-0.0388321914,
-0.0603553988,
-0.0565395281,
-0.0084393676,
-0.0103078438,
0.0364559814,
0.0522687435,
0.0066454499,
-0.0212587733,
0.0371531621,
0.0062955706,
-0.0238371417,
0.0666217953,
0.0083413301,
-0.010904233,
0.0023404728,
-0.0491249636,
0.0045745773,
-0.0000976028,
-0.0106538767,
0.0056749964,
-0.0168556422,
-0.0145210549,
-0.0092077935,
-0.0177272819,
-0.0701973662,
-0.0064002546,
-0.075453423,
0.0252828393,
0.0396173373,
0.0216210466,
-0.0056325658,
0.0148903169,
-0.0007216194,
-0.0290696826,
-0.0074451268,
0.0581344888,
-0.0339623205,
-0.008327852,
0.0368982255,
0.040189907,
0.0042522606,
-0.0311799813,
0.007144216,
-0.0480448604,
0.0529001728,
-0.0029102175,
-0.0188035052,
0.0052049668,
0.0181820672,
-0.0587130003,
0.0513652638,
0.014404594,
-0.0018497582,
-0.0225524604,
0.0099770827,
-0.0360113755,
0.0394539833,
-0.0183719918,
0.0287652053,
-0.0114796255,
-0.0075335023,
-0.0388051346,
0.038007088,
-0.0025350342,
0.0143853473,
0.0010135337,
0.0259689447,
-0.0410765223,
0.0418807603,
-0.0317719467,
0.0340460204,
-0.0361047462,
0.0244763196,
0.0532599911,
0.0030916973,
-0.0112238489,
0.0564242564,
0.0329777636,
-0.0208090451,
-0.0819822401,
0.0353110135,
0.0666195452,
-0.0206591096,
-0.0158036277,
0.0204347819,
0.0247119032,
-0.0191537086,
0.0808730721,
0.000040085,
0.0143378628,
0.0483653247,
-0.0012798628,
-0.0188858639,
-0.029122822,
0.0415543616,
0.0044211834,
0.0244550705,
-0.0183703881,
0.0525875054,
-0.0409441628,
-0.0152289607,
-0.0375913419,
-0.030910356,
-0.0522897802,
0.0180865843,
-0.0785543919,
-0.0168961398,
-0.0291289091,
0.0139661226,
-0.0006890696,
0.0200890005,
-0.0092474837,
-0.0246667415,
-0.0209241323,
0.0660917908,
0.0902152061,
-0.0170027222,
-0.0354589485,
0.0281222295,
0.0203373283,
0.0557550862,
0.0064882827,
0.0165916998,
-0.0012983179,
-0.0185975861,
-0.0013913865,
-0.021159865,
0.0183303747,
-0.0023241721,
0.0135791693,
-0.0575128347,
0.0083465204,
0.1013828442,
0.019717887,
-0.0273708198,
-0.0126175769,
0.0398716293,
0.0216745809,
0.0512731448,
0.0305936802,
-0.1182231903,
-0.0649246499,
-0.0168193579,
-0.0166366547,
0.0206250604,
-0.0892942026,
-0.0140615711,
-0.1319941282,
0.0000927347,
-0.0059249075,
-0.0439282097,
-0.019834552,
-0.0460610539,
0.0272491686,
-0.0269155726,
-0.0347546004,
-0.0341729969,
-0.0321779251,
-0.0052587697,
-0.0325292014,
0.0547524206,
-0.0485491678,
0.0604170263,
-0.0462983735,
0.0335181542,
0.0345117711,
0.0454945378,
0.0089629674,
-0.0189731028,
-0.0133572016,
-0.0182171091,
-0.029897796,
-0.0340670757,
0.1023956686,
-0.0697829351,
-0.0239973534,
0.0156314671,
0.0097015752,
-0.0154399993,
-0.0091692852,
-0.0132215992,
0.0464981273,
0.007056741,
0.0065644789,
0.0004202632,
-0.0145106995,
0.0127119925,
0.0713996068,
0.0137178553,
0.0091217523,
-0.0216062404,
0.022028869,
0.0006320496,
-0.0382789709,
-0.0105279088,
-0.0073800194,
-0.0589025356,
-0.0257448051,
-0.0541568547,
-0.0562371463,
0.0696434453,
0.0510200262,
0.0027252629,
0.0040145046,
0.0165183581,
0.0207377188,
-0.0716580749,
0.0224785823,
-0.0544504561,
0.0142463446,
0.0233866051,
0.0144258244,
0.0365856998,
-0.0091266371,
-0.0171069987,
-0.0174327083,
-0.0561897121,
-0.0386498272,
-0.0546626411,
0.0332954191,
0.0132832909,
0.0683414862,
-0.0024662297,
0.0045768931,
-0.0176512673,
0.0918806717,
-0.0426677875,
-0.005476302,
0.001738857,
-0.0254803021,
-0.0071729105,
0.0446926802,
-0.0274154171,
0.0301987808,
0.0117926793,
0.0326984487,
-0.0532798879,
-0.0492139682,
0.0036631259,
0.0019061641,
0.0560340993,
0.006185316,
0.025005294,
-0.0118693775,
0.0136720426,
-0.0301265083,
-0.021417493,
-0.0404107571,
-0.016124865,
-0.0221765433,
0.0075639207,
0.0108848494,
-0.0180832576,
-0.0286140367,
0.0754572526,
-0.0273404047,
-0.0515010171,
0.0059965393,
-0.0244051702,
0.0163885597,
-0.0214043465,
-0.0184108671,
0.0267881025,
0.0209474415,
0.0358335525,
-0.0546652898,
0.0527571626,
0.0202394575,
-0.0019494612,
-0.035961818,
0.003203921,
-0.0003350209,
0.0314705335,
-0.038128864,
0.0408745594,
0.0652732104,
-0.0631439313,
0.0124672158,
0.0001357239,
-0.0091914563,
0.0182309244,
0.0307645295,
-0.0479504429,
-0.0204103403,
0.0200425219,
0.0377302319,
-0.0098540802,
0.0252570827,
0.0883527175,
-0.0522744432,
0.0796983019,
0.0367408097,
-0.002124622,
-0.0398636013,
-0.0092469007,
0.011507283,
0.0237029474,
0.000595738,
0.0069876742,
-0.0704243109,
-0.0521002933,
-0.0014600107,
-0.0551640801,
-0.0451965891,
0.0221862849,
0.0229262765,
-0.010380554,
0.0571961664,
-0.0210886262,
-0.0130718863,
-0.0139605748,
-0.0194335766,
-0.0074168104,
-0.0276029594,
-6.238953899e-33,
-0.0594619699,
-0.0278092977,
0.0241424572,
0.0031245933,
-0.0603686497,
0.0329299122,
-0.0223370884,
-0.0277468786,
-0.0531983636,
0.0155258151,
-0.0102071185,
-0.0087921582,
0.0027531704,
-0.0130590983,
-0.017857112,
-0.0347730182,
0.0116122961,
0.0059955148,
0.0037105551,
0.0202837773,
0.0037044743,
0.0288362373,
0.051352486,
-0.0808262825,
0.0033209417,
0.0076629776,
-0.0086841462,
0.0306330062,
0.0509464145,
0.0229498018,
-0.0350812376,
0.0033243836,
0.0253326837,
-0.0103779761,
0.0412368365,
-0.0232544318,
-0.1372959316,
-0.0011669748,
-0.0193520039,
-0.0200033057,
-0.0010542115,
0.0128233004,
0.018656956,
0.0006171018,
0.0624878481,
-0.0569024049,
0.0099649271,
-0.0504965931,
-0.007446371,
-0.0541196838,
-0.0933497697,
0.0100717712,
0.0196897499,
-0.0316015556,
0.0587506406,
-0.003128838,
0.0481057614,
0.0199247152,
-0.0544078425,
-0.0400594436,
-0.027129041,
0.0091989413,
0.0156386811,
0.0178144276,
0.0104961721,
0.0657392889,
0.0086536091,
-0.0015389202,
-0.0404469557,
-0.0007957845,
0.0127380183,
0.048900865,
-0.0367521942,
0.0410875902,
0.0648171306,
-0.0022004214,
-0.0758024976,
0.008907401,
0.0142302141,
0.0537795424,
-0.0609387159,
0.0041864319,
-0.018376451,
0.0041200803,
0.001999863,
-0.0032643818,
-0.0354673602,
-0.0173984263,
-0.0119821317,
0.004245773,
-0.0326866992,
0.058086995,
-0.000623515,
-0.0406926051,
-0.0245240182,
0.0215089265,
-0.0066725677,
0.0142821753,
-0.0011186603,
-0.0188714135,
-0.0495952368,
-0.0715709031,
0.0163740274,
-0.0073467558,
0.0359065533,
0.0470949076,
0.0786458254,
-0.0449028835,
-0.0467226505,
-0.0195308905,
-0.0385912769,
-0.002640977,
-0.0309965461,
-0.0038410039,
0.0235010944,
0.0444033891,
0.0058400827,
0.0357996225,
0.0505791083,
-0.0008414747,
-0.0076449839,
0.0493475683,
0.031883385,
0.0189555362,
0.0327066369,
0.008686332,
-0.0027693983,
-0.0309429541,
0.0088550868,
-0.0320179947,
-0.012532223,
-0.0042185849,
2.584e-7,
0.0106952311,
0.0101488829,
0.0399788506,
0.0241334997,
-0.0125663271,
0.0738177449,
0.0266216882,
0.0611346178,
-0.0111874491,
-0.0292812642,
0.0229357742,
0.0202888716,
0.0175911691,
0.0386715755,
-0.0608854294,
-0.0040048631,
-0.0585157983,
-0.0701553598,
-0.0546895117,
-0.0214712974,
0.0653988719,
0.0353616215,
0.0496781096,
0.0128439525,
-0.004548355,
-0.0055383719,
0.0595473498,
0.0011731037,
0.0168647524,
0.0205945186,
-0.0369470716,
0.0325244367,
-0.0329843536,
0.0692683384,
-0.0234858133,
0.0236891992,
-0.0070423912,
0.027970301,
-0.0620455481,
-0.006812525,
-0.020512199,
-0.026844047,
0.0086974101,
0.0103771584,
0.0892219171,
-0.0726958439,
-0.007957668,
-0.0251939353,
-0.0257028807,
0.0464582294,
-0.0252447817,
0.0429385751,
-0.0018904669,
0.0300223678,
0.0317416713,
-0.0016418163,
-0.0530082621,
-0.0871533826,
0.0035795916,
0.066140756,
0.0197483953,
-3.277e-7,
0.0206188262,
-0.0467048027,
0.006804937,
-0.0498706661,
-0.0228256043,
2.168041832e-34,
-0.0360509232,
0.0174781326,
0.0173257682,
0.0487391241,
0.0237755477,
-0.0321114585,
-0.0665531754,
-0.0003711871,
-0.0018260197,
-0.0470440462,
0.0368866511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11427v1 | DiTTo-TTS: Efficient and Scalable Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech with Diffusion Transformer | 2024-06-17T11:25:57 | 2024-06-17T11:25:57 | Keon Lee, Dong Won Kim, Jaehyeon Kim, Jaewoong Cho | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Large-scale diffusion models have shown outstanding generative abilities
across multiple modalities including images, videos, and audio. However,
text-to-speech (TTS) systems typically involve domain-specific modeling factors
(e.g., phonemes and phoneme-level durations) to ensure precise temporal
alignments between text and speech, which hinders the efficiency and
scalability of diffusion models for TTS. In this work, we present an efficient
and scalable Diffusion Transformer (DiT) that utilizes off-the-shelf
pre-trained text and speech encoders. Our approach addresses the challenge of
text-speech alignment via cross-attention mechanisms with the prediction of the
total length of speech representations. To achieve this, we enhance the DiT
architecture to suit TTS and improve the alignment by incorporating semantic
guidance into the latent space of speech. We scale the training dataset and the
model size to 82K hours and 790M parameters, respectively. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate that the large-scale diffusion model for TTS without
domain-specific modeling not only simplifies the training pipeline but also
yields superior or comparable zero-shot performance to state-of-the-art TTS
models in terms of naturalness, intelligibility, and speaker similarity. Our
speech samples are available at https://ditto-tts.github.io. | [
-0.0524517633,
0.0460695773,
0.0320427455,
0.008236276,
0.014800705,
-0.0421352424,
0.0476656072,
-0.0031044628,
-0.06364692,
0.0186996255,
-0.0753744394,
-0.0345062912,
0.022112811,
0.0071544903,
0.0328641161,
-0.0771490857,
0.0045152805,
-0.0025411989,
-0.0270371139,
-0.0010031578,
0.0642843321,
0.0038802729,
-0.0298480615,
0.0121391816,
-0.029500138,
-0.0404942408,
-0.0247653797,
0.0336765796,
0.0594823398,
-0.0313285515,
-0.0259187669,
0.0188818015,
0.0603276715,
0.0425859056,
0.0000019376,
0.0084972009,
-0.0110147493,
0.0170221739,
-0.0243988745,
-0.0059216497,
0.0263424274,
-0.0226839166,
-0.0201098453,
0.0292362999,
0.0249260254,
-0.0088767121,
0.0625074878,
0.0344679989,
0.0442597419,
0.0906315744,
-0.0249880049,
-0.074597232,
0.0463749915,
-0.0367127433,
0.0340479165,
-0.0068352306,
-0.0287715457,
-0.0190314408,
-0.0051783053,
-0.0215781145,
-0.0570706092,
0.0446098037,
0.0038471799,
0.0079169087,
0.0302728694,
0.0441045873,
0.0132772429,
-0.0394268632,
-0.0009502906,
0.1185993776,
-0.018468231,
-0.0043301042,
0.0302488804,
-0.0032034928,
-0.0331353769,
-0.014867004,
-0.0210761391,
-0.0134114325,
0.040187642,
0.0017781075,
-0.0510580279,
0.0518113412,
0.0154837137,
-0.056650158,
-0.017368516,
-0.0070815692,
0.035475947,
-0.0384443738,
-0.0352381654,
-0.0149726048,
0.0072865328,
-0.0442670174,
0.048836261,
0.0150812836,
0.0040978319,
-0.0114435293,
-0.0573388785,
-0.0353542082,
-0.0332254097,
0.0125978785,
0.031911619,
0.0570096411,
-0.0372898094,
0.0029186516,
-0.0183996614,
0.0587834492,
-0.0539295785,
-0.0131336916,
-0.0232658237,
-0.0258876551,
-0.0191700403,
0.036625389,
-0.0340754017,
-0.0105710924,
-0.0191967394,
-0.0341062099,
-0.0354009047,
-0.0016188725,
-0.0144052701,
0.0110263955,
0.0555873439,
0.022187328,
-0.0609831437,
-0.0498996787,
-0.0019697563,
0.0782453567,
-0.010900219,
0.0178108364,
0.026766317,
-0.0023521008,
-0.0508923382,
0.0435449891,
0.0623396151,
-0.0213478673,
0.0083209071,
0.0369680338,
-0.0295483563,
-0.0257117841,
-0.0164368637,
0.0114326039,
-0.0433866158,
-0.0643157437,
-0.0075343465,
-0.0649651214,
0.0534278676,
-0.0244410392,
-0.0024908076,
-0.0313233063,
-0.0108344015,
0.0122531224,
0.0098761935,
0.0695615411,
0.0128593817,
0.0229031723,
0.0366385803,
-0.0112217357,
0.0111804642,
0.0246557016,
0.0573757626,
-0.0052809757,
-0.0250219144,
0.000099873,
0.0126089603,
0.0603760332,
0.0601129755,
0.0380375423,
-0.0120882522,
0.0065698782,
-0.0216275547,
0.0625993758,
0.0984545648,
0.0347481482,
-0.0273071397,
-0.0212945659,
0.0866990164,
0.0647245869,
0.0323194899,
-0.0158181228,
0.0747357979,
0.0676571876,
-0.0534494221,
-0.0379472151,
0.0004165595,
0.0558555871,
0.0287253,
0.0323455818,
0.0749987438,
0.0187184364,
-0.0712111443,
0.0085726026,
0.009628077,
-0.0389635339,
-0.0073457998,
-0.0040584421,
0.0053635221,
0.0162540507,
-0.0808035806,
0.077513732,
-0.0179087147,
-0.0630529895,
-0.0078025819,
0.0088554937,
0.0226983111,
0.05065009,
-0.0048210854,
0.0024057366,
-0.0112536829,
-0.0240035579,
0.010050551,
0.065894872,
-0.0365242101,
0.0230410956,
0.0390920155,
-0.0822015107,
0.0085056648,
0.033391308,
-0.0124235572,
0.0042085368,
-0.0049908771,
0.0828605741,
0.0236012302,
-0.0200641267,
0.0345428549,
0.0047621778,
-0.0510861985,
-0.0221659113,
-0.0121153146,
0.0341586508,
0.0336094163,
-0.0093167508,
-0.0480975024,
-0.0172445979,
-0.0029323262,
-0.0160237737,
0.0010326662,
0.0211081076,
-0.056936197,
-0.0356184244,
0.0254530124,
-0.0565548688,
0.006324701,
0.047444962,
0.0099574402,
-0.0536810793,
0.0433265194,
-0.0134351673,
0.0155646773,
-0.0129738618,
0.032447841,
0.0444787666,
0.0320277661,
0.0331950597,
-0.001381942,
0.0110499375,
-0.014731532,
0.0011750497,
0.0359217823,
0.0068531274,
-0.0340289436,
0.0096951155,
-0.0190062337,
-0.0016690562,
0.0396976359,
-0.0272254441,
-0.0179420635,
-0.0328680165,
-0.0222372804,
-0.068477571,
0.0613129362,
0.0023275609,
0.0216374695,
0.0136194732,
0.0183974281,
-0.0036753537,
0.0084584365,
-0.0527605824,
0.0019987272,
0.0021851386,
-0.0394736379,
0.0129975984,
-0.0401921645,
-0.017322138,
-0.0498420298,
0.0129822241,
0.0177935753,
-0.0019266972,
-0.0675190166,
0.0067134821,
0.0123937195,
0.0453293398,
0.0176246632,
0.0070772106,
0.0109429574,
-0.0395710319,
-0.0139523176,
0.0391545594,
0.0739076957,
0.0219931826,
0.0082739592,
-0.0270881094,
-0.0336636268,
-0.0266279615,
-0.0467143171,
0.0081277294,
-0.0015551863,
0.035370674,
-0.0345519595,
0.0015615068,
-0.0492052138,
0.0665791705,
-0.0163494851,
0.023220975,
-0.0906519219,
-0.0228792857,
0.0228344072,
0.0009126269,
0.039903421,
0.0122568589,
-0.0295247436,
-0.014488739,
-0.0509024747,
-0.0386055335,
0.0349085741,
-0.0848544911,
-0.0697338581,
-0.0308043603,
-0.0163051914,
0.002836589,
-0.0082745515,
-0.0026534379,
0.0175532997,
0.0035417641,
-0.0160841905,
-0.0462473147,
0.0024666979,
0.0074832202,
-0.0296945535,
0.034533225,
0.0360746123,
0.0091123097,
-0.0395929664,
-0.0047841417,
-0.0163612198,
-0.051628314,
-0.0235560294,
-0.0099637378,
-0.0534965284,
-0.0504542775,
-0.0479544699,
-0.0116084693,
0.0294216014,
0.0372943021,
0.0112542007,
0.0061647468,
-0.0343742296,
0.069367528,
0.0304288696,
-0.0088558579,
-0.0412825197,
-0.0334926732,
0.0334292166,
0.0315328464,
0.0261544827,
0.0214890633,
-0.0437779278,
-0.0412337668,
0.0075914385,
0.0139319673,
0.0131455176,
0.0053707617,
0.1002966836,
-0.0221321546,
0.006212546,
0.0902021378,
-0.0175722875,
-0.0193923395,
0.0062758005,
0.0163133033,
0.0683241189,
-0.0088889636,
-0.0215861313,
-0.0719938949,
-0.0685056448,
0.0256596971,
0.0139296828,
0.0288742166,
0.0189218745,
-0.0231637843,
-0.0941997096,
0.0023240109,
0.0299973544,
0.0158871394,
-0.0091653429,
0.0087630292,
-0.0239714142,
-0.0033063984,
0.0344393551,
0.0054113041,
0.0103425235,
-0.0001818794,
0.0223502144,
-0.0240986031,
-0.0433852598,
0.0117519367,
-0.0475088991,
0.0635808259,
0.0411226451,
0.0258072019,
0.0216721278,
-0.0784369111,
0.0093464321,
0.0073412922,
-0.0338713154,
0.0477461442,
0.0470094904,
-0.0407599956,
-0.0122717237,
-0.0011059034,
0.0590123609,
-0.0202240814,
0.0003078488,
-0.0029420347,
0.0715028495,
0.0308754295,
0.0087996973,
-0.0100640515,
0.0373797677,
0.0080654901,
0.0622690096,
0.0059975432,
-0.0333059654,
-0.028532777,
0.0173986442,
0.0245301612,
-0.0412374623,
-0.0888389051,
0.0161846727,
-0.0020639526,
-0.076634638,
-0.0346904136,
-0.0092461109,
-0.0264273752,
0.0450436771,
-0.0116005186,
-0.0502653345,
-0.0072598485,
0.0008332205,
-0.0482047163,
0.0338688344,
-0.0209522024,
0.0398924798,
-0.0711693913,
0.021959085,
0.0272236951,
-0.0103385784,
-0.001723724,
0.0233742204,
-0.122219786,
-0.0573045425,
-0.0510402806,
-0.0238071065,
0.0094938697,
0.0765639022,
-0.0287394207,
0.0013215038,
0.127885446,
-0.01260796,
-0.0180891901,
0.0234371033,
0.0588511676,
-0.033228036,
0.0137430783,
0.0150754172,
-0.0311998893,
0.0306730662,
-0.0093875732,
-0.0117718913,
-0.0373243988,
0.0119585311,
-0.012697326,
-0.0130567458,
0.036864832,
0.00410478,
0.078914851,
-0.017200375,
0.009174224,
-0.0056126211,
0.0441203974,
-0.0491378866,
-0.0380720645,
0.0501180552,
0.0088209547,
0.0044495389,
0.0007726159,
-0.0281879567,
-0.0318120234,
-0.0084664458,
0.0207292996,
0.004940216,
0.0206276122,
0.0047640218,
-0.0085826637,
0.0114478813,
-0.0057533029,
-0.0208305828,
0.0332146622,
-0.0097471913,
0.0232363977,
0.0065985722,
0.0186358858,
-0.0074414397,
0.0182483848,
0.0065529183,
-0.0000611126,
-0.0276178699,
-0.0140074678,
0.0315224156,
0.0121859331,
0.0720514804,
0.0374124721,
0.0253223535,
-0.0028610565,
0.0271528848,
-0.0643362924,
0.0121359071,
0.0067261299,
-0.0058962232,
-0.0008236506,
0.008510951,
0.034371268,
-0.0082341572,
-0.0071207993,
-0.0302441642,
0.0321675427,
-0.0046889842,
-0.0288006999,
-0.0638461113,
-0.0166927967,
0.0090519162,
-0.0131959775,
-0.0213761274,
-0.0649970621,
0.0117324656,
-0.0032650321,
-0.021262845,
-0.0174437314,
0.0323547274,
-0.0339768864,
-0.0152880857,
0.0040150126,
0.0196904074,
-0.0365270786,
0.0089823185,
-0.0201917309,
-0.0024746424,
-5.967661191e-33,
-0.0246357638,
0.0458314195,
0.0277865529,
-0.0280688163,
-0.1022774875,
-0.0033937348,
-0.0390327871,
-0.0066325152,
-0.0086510628,
0.0082590757,
-0.02510776,
0.0391122848,
0.0143850921,
0.0532816239,
-0.0396600775,
0.0046141623,
0.0705927983,
-0.0319733322,
-0.0231937803,
0.0210851841,
0.0324890763,
0.0170703735,
0.0228122175,
-0.0329268873,
-0.0425605737,
-0.0154567715,
-0.0008213872,
-0.0270140786,
0.0687345341,
0.0149241854,
0.0014108954,
0.0116560319,
-0.0335626565,
-0.0460567921,
-0.0319326706,
0.0415920764,
-0.0583960116,
0.0284820143,
-0.0252562258,
0.0337250195,
-0.0346654803,
-0.0319951586,
0.0516293608,
0.0029848728,
0.0038544757,
-0.0460348763,
0.0224272944,
-0.0196195375,
0.0320331641,
-0.0117555419,
-0.0611898936,
0.0314287208,
-0.0494542308,
-0.0485795848,
0.0510907248,
0.0474088453,
0.0170831699,
0.0326384939,
-0.0979925394,
0.0130179962,
-0.0238116719,
0.0547147579,
0.0566702634,
0.0027600594,
0.0143130785,
0.0335044116,
0.0439860784,
-0.0388651788,
0.0209570006,
-0.0100377342,
0.0193653926,
0.0321686715,
0.011020367,
0.0194130838,
0.0491580628,
-0.0261385925,
-0.0431174003,
0.0112622809,
-0.0429371819,
-0.0112829832,
0.0052860421,
0.0362620912,
0.0047244937,
0.0127645107,
-0.0178426988,
-0.0283389743,
-0.0096283965,
-0.0310221855,
0.0372814834,
0.0162295364,
0.0394522958,
-0.0064428914,
0.0949023813,
-0.0054419385,
0.0197544582,
-0.0088020684,
-0.0409891456,
0.0150854327,
0.0071980795,
0.0363272987,
-0.0522223897,
-0.0183630716,
0.0493795872,
0.0638010278,
0.0155606205,
0.0158532057,
0.0063113528,
0.011917633,
-0.0634918064,
-0.0113071483,
-0.021966191,
0.0193859991,
-0.0434771776,
0.0210702326,
0.0273131263,
0.0015502447,
-0.0049848235,
0.0543848611,
-0.0313396491,
-0.012644344,
0.0209597163,
0.0163823366,
0.0140207857,
0.0214960985,
-0.0517179146,
0.0324144401,
-0.0142847085,
0.005003965,
0.0559723973,
-0.0429414436,
-0.0160980485,
0.0277650114,
2.665e-7,
-0.0358291678,
-0.0302077644,
0.0345418826,
-0.0092177223,
0.0264448281,
0.0447416045,
-0.0055384259,
0.0541200005,
-0.0283534396,
-0.0455323569,
0.0230929628,
0.0192438886,
0.0863131583,
-0.0051973895,
-0.0774672404,
-0.05309733,
-0.0503179878,
0.024176022,
-0.01223177,
-0.0025856374,
-0.0052593271,
0.0870961398,
0.0052190623,
0.0039347433,
0.0535398573,
0.0067321607,
0.0428625904,
0.0278629307,
0.0130614648,
-0.0074783652,
-0.0369685926,
-0.0553930849,
-0.0418501943,
-0.0156157073,
-0.0341053605,
0.0457792096,
0.0064966008,
0.0695611387,
-0.0342059657,
-0.0773834139,
-0.0282346364,
0.0330670662,
-0.0647051856,
0.0098458203,
0.0586193725,
-0.0397205763,
-0.0215231031,
0.0165323466,
-0.0842424035,
0.0273345988,
0.0148864929,
0.007102571,
-0.0307559595,
0.0106807332,
0.0415991545,
-0.0033670103,
-0.0212594755,
-0.0527030341,
-0.0198720023,
0.004468827,
-0.0498771071,
-0.0381048732,
-0.0471538007,
-0.0332059599,
0.0467598401,
-0.0055141943,
-0.0262718219,
2.041730832e-34,
0.0163621102,
-0.0146511123,
0.0437025912,
-0.0071425629,
-0.0088017322,
-0.0370484479,
0.0015689234,
-0.0339711122,
0.0277054682,
-0.0436034575,
-0.0292634591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11424v1 | Evaluating the Efficacy of Open-Source LLMs in Enterprise-Specific RAG Systems: A Comparative Study of Performance and Scalability | 2024-06-17T11:22:25 | 2024-06-17T11:22:25 | Gautam B, Anupam Purwar | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | This paper presents an analysis of open-source large language models (LLMs)
and their application in Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) tasks, specific
for enterprise-specific data sets scraped from their websites. With the
increasing reliance on LLMs in natural language processing, it is crucial to
evaluate their performance, accessibility, and integration within specific
organizational contexts. This study examines various open-source LLMs, explores
their integration into RAG frameworks using enterprise-specific data, and
assesses the performance of different open-source embeddings in enhancing the
retrieval and generation process. Our findings indicate that open-source LLMs,
combined with effective embedding techniques, can significantly improve the
accuracy and efficiency of RAG systems, offering a viable alternative to
proprietary solutions for enterprises. | [
0.0598532073,
0.0512821302,
-0.0040368554,
0.0313164704,
-0.043764554,
-0.0135920113,
0.0049143676,
0.0004579553,
0.0443956293,
-0.0776102245,
-0.0181225874,
-0.0244145449,
-0.0217467416,
0.0118202139,
0.0152841369,
0.0443706438,
0.0281601287,
-0.0016927095,
-0.0380843841,
0.0058204122,
0.0039656274,
0.045255851,
0.0207693428,
0.0448549539,
0.0343730301,
0.0290877633,
0.0178124253,
0.0190291721,
-0.0235267524,
-0.003608092,
-0.0120473364,
0.0216206778,
0.0464966148,
0.0637321472,
0.0000014891,
-0.1052361503,
-0.0367389359,
0.013015761,
-0.0057024462,
0.0448613912,
0.0935762301,
0.0190151203,
-0.0207928307,
0.0401472636,
-0.0214449186,
-0.0086111929,
0.0296632294,
0.0202958174,
0.0466357842,
0.0533412807,
-0.0039219405,
-0.0576614141,
-0.0017966448,
-0.0118087605,
-0.0081257122,
-0.0130175827,
0.0318685472,
0.0083235614,
0.0275194477,
-0.0066552474,
0.0391130075,
0.017768696,
-0.0269396026,
-0.0047796676,
0.0293330494,
0.017452389,
-0.0712536648,
-0.0149213141,
-0.0067939409,
0.0651189312,
0.0506255217,
-0.0045465915,
-0.0001746188,
0.0089815212,
0.0189345032,
0.0363269001,
-0.040542163,
0.0601919889,
0.0146040823,
0.0422286578,
-0.0205648281,
0.0008597988,
-0.0116870226,
0.0426673405,
-0.0403961539,
0.0513439402,
0.0321897268,
-0.036840491,
0.0256922413,
-0.0067376844,
-0.007697314,
0.009970108,
0.0300692506,
0.0082826549,
0.0039069452,
0.052597031,
-0.0423819311,
-0.0131540354,
0.0549612306,
-0.0176406316,
0.0209134128,
0.0118084718,
-0.0100814877,
0.0195110776,
-0.0531791374,
0.0226839129,
-0.0260031093,
-0.0293247662,
-0.0430020206,
-0.0129873864,
-0.0646667853,
-0.0234221201,
-0.0438644253,
0.0261015184,
-0.0537346341,
-0.0470338129,
-0.0587238073,
0.0368743092,
0.0109452493,
0.0232508406,
0.0200950354,
0.0275606737,
0.0011238026,
-0.0016376699,
-0.0305408668,
-0.0037342377,
0.0233623832,
-0.0026252728,
0.010348659,
-0.0848832354,
0.0241951421,
0.0229380634,
0.0212782826,
-0.018547032,
0.0088912249,
0.0267360024,
0.0356570035,
-0.0345313214,
-0.0801839978,
-0.0543614328,
-0.0181643665,
-0.026427526,
-0.0286196601,
-0.0671847761,
0.0301789735,
0.0230069309,
-0.0295173731,
-0.0433662161,
0.0383436866,
0.0341372453,
-0.0671252757,
0.0318254121,
-0.0439337008,
0.0332986787,
0.0133797694,
-0.0169626251,
0.0789069682,
0.0572444536,
0.0146872792,
0.0279619601,
0.0627382025,
-0.0210384186,
-0.0157503411,
0.0545004457,
-0.0175546519,
-0.010020812,
-0.0347717963,
0.0365255624,
-0.0293204654,
0.0397073068,
0.0347653367,
0.0679235458,
-0.0095607387,
0.0431762189,
0.0442120992,
0.0574412569,
0.0443805307,
0.0161122363,
0.054803621,
0.0552429259,
-0.0187233854,
-0.0487784483,
0.003953482,
-0.0332041979,
-0.0251822509,
0.0505068302,
0.0341048613,
0.0430191718,
-0.011059612,
-0.007192607,
-0.0449505597,
-0.0021782112,
-0.0347122028,
-0.0149647575,
0.0805482417,
0.001456784,
-0.0493230335,
0.0379205495,
0.0248530302,
-0.0656747743,
0.0264190901,
-0.0254886113,
0.0001468745,
0.1205622628,
0.0943383351,
-0.0226471964,
0.0229131505,
-0.0231155623,
-0.0087286336,
0.0531432293,
0.0421560034,
0.0065842601,
-0.0530693606,
-0.0807824433,
-0.03735644,
-0.0013356652,
-0.0092587145,
0.0118286405,
0.0239680298,
-0.0039822413,
0.0686686411,
-0.0295196399,
-0.0374546647,
0.0346823111,
-0.0372179747,
-0.0026059272,
-0.005781475,
-0.002116177,
0.0061747977,
0.0623000376,
-0.030993849,
0.0380863138,
0.0273500569,
-0.028808834,
-0.0324136354,
-0.0116002429,
0.0184708759,
0.0121360496,
0.0154586127,
0.008476981,
0.0267710146,
0.0107754488,
-0.0223995056,
-0.0248103943,
0.0012586628,
-0.0412920564,
0.0293318722,
-0.0669492558,
-0.0095173297,
-0.0027099212,
0.0294486899,
-0.0690527707,
0.0439818949,
-0.0015855384,
0.0566648245,
0.0478208922,
-0.0105483774,
0.014570402,
-0.0535118878,
-0.0409880206,
0.0031956888,
-0.018772332,
0.0387094207,
0.0146025904,
0.0056274696,
-0.0563183688,
-0.0265470371,
-0.0605072826,
0.0199056957,
-0.002227172,
0.0248568822,
0.0182249453,
0.0259790476,
-0.0309194792,
0.0082407193,
-0.0108284168,
-0.0306488611,
0.0494891666,
0.0422414057,
0.0269144345,
-0.0051897489,
-0.0412270948,
-0.0122520123,
0.0007572268,
0.0307770129,
0.0439460725,
0.0065212832,
-0.0096397353,
-0.1004699022,
0.0570206717,
-0.059314426,
-0.014080002,
0.0289871003,
-0.0099929506,
-0.0098038819,
-0.0332006849,
0.056216836,
-0.0217867345,
0.0138323512,
-0.0029004416,
0.031992536,
-0.0381755345,
-0.054654263,
-0.0441665463,
-0.0357297808,
-0.0583673641,
-0.0158831272,
-0.0406220853,
0.0229129884,
-0.0117010083,
0.0258054435,
-0.0155632216,
-0.0216495153,
-0.0010019307,
-0.0302468073,
-0.0154212192,
-0.0310341865,
-0.0064129229,
-0.0188615732,
0.0274849962,
0.0375149697,
-0.045126047,
0.0360040143,
-0.0464810804,
0.0047100792,
-0.020482488,
-0.026002584,
-0.0518984459,
0.0313324928,
-0.0432902016,
0.0126150465,
-0.0076536541,
-0.0485411212,
-0.0070429821,
0.0381653123,
0.0027762626,
-0.0654934421,
0.0366354622,
-0.0196392126,
0.0197678953,
-0.0119011439,
0.0339164063,
-0.035651803,
-0.0332565568,
-0.0161711778,
0.016235074,
0.0303368904,
0.0329059623,
-0.041244965,
0.0552809276,
0.0130792735,
-0.0086576007,
0.0097931512,
-0.017821854,
-0.007076175,
0.0034533695,
0.0409167781,
0.0097755436,
0.034324877,
0.0331503935,
-0.005657203,
0.0094189802,
0.0492181256,
-0.0418656506,
-0.0347568169,
-0.0335167721,
0.0225710087,
-0.0659831315,
0.012299587,
0.0114555014,
-0.0058012181,
-0.0185984429,
-0.0133957267,
0.0819557831,
0.0390657932,
0.0077427817,
-0.0069457032,
-0.0168534275,
0.035816811,
0.0471505076,
0.0364205651,
-0.0623029508,
-0.0105501572,
-0.0090627717,
0.0489528775,
0.0114237601,
-0.0191849284,
-0.0154675152,
-0.1597853303,
0.083484076,
0.0078722555,
-0.0078491475,
-0.0372893587,
-0.0342013463,
-0.0211428963,
-0.010605786,
0.004098577,
0.047543738,
-0.0519983061,
0.0025211433,
0.0208313577,
-0.0389545672,
-0.0756746233,
-0.0232864618,
-0.0417330526,
0.0101291789,
0.0565789044,
0.0025074922,
0.0110062985,
-0.0154772867,
0.0030924422,
-0.0584313348,
0.0234263092,
-0.0093546342,
0.0367903672,
0.0072597107,
-0.0021161276,
-0.0299157724,
0.0064312583,
-0.0350654423,
0.0177032091,
-0.0044578193,
0.0576701164,
-0.0149149308,
0.0552531928,
-0.02391099,
0.0014420915,
0.0041720024,
0.0889407471,
0.0011752412,
-0.0269411914,
-0.025412159,
0.0025739088,
0.0044098725,
-0.0061938255,
-0.0242714249,
0.0483257659,
-0.0624105185,
-0.0344472192,
-0.0757690519,
-0.0589616448,
0.0375827961,
0.0145420451,
0.0006019479,
0.0374187864,
-0.0161652043,
-0.0033258055,
-0.0484921299,
-0.0004790434,
-0.0660479516,
0.0282205623,
-0.0395837836,
-0.0055947779,
0.0320327878,
-0.0321618319,
-0.0032124042,
-0.0043227156,
-0.0452266857,
-0.0719354972,
-0.0108785359,
-0.0032768964,
0.0254227985,
0.0086221052,
0.0180612877,
-0.0616438501,
0.0708993822,
0.034536805,
-0.0550595671,
0.0080754831,
-0.0125714317,
0.0335219689,
-0.0289273635,
0.0328145809,
-0.0746830478,
-0.0041426793,
-0.0298703313,
0.0763582066,
0.0509842485,
-0.0429215543,
0.0390985608,
0.0526966304,
0.0022039514,
-0.0334903635,
0.0280595142,
-0.0593426488,
0.006563663,
-0.0325133614,
-0.0201949794,
-0.0365386717,
0.0244285762,
0.0375397317,
-0.0371360555,
0.0286468063,
0.0142793227,
-0.0533233285,
0.0682501942,
-0.0395226739,
0.0233185776,
-0.0012343611,
-0.0045767208,
0.0313182622,
-0.0074906331,
-0.0502466075,
0.0035488019,
-0.0370552205,
0.0068047787,
-0.0297796261,
0.0476974733,
-0.0171958506,
-0.0072817784,
0.0006930768,
0.0308688544,
-0.0228491053,
-0.0229473747,
-0.0119727897,
-0.0180398747,
0.0527054071,
0.0180582125,
0.0660390183,
-0.0318792611,
0.0011655734,
-0.0246354379,
0.0293113645,
0.0154078184,
-0.0346409045,
0.0334617831,
0.008122487,
-0.0546518378,
0.0257986169,
0.0644948035,
0.0331438668,
0.0231019538,
-0.0620209426,
-0.0494142361,
-0.061203409,
-0.0608693771,
0.0246813409,
0.011580742,
-0.0583790466,
-0.0431765243,
-0.073276937,
-0.0347448736,
-0.0125132604,
0.0090814689,
-0.0293696616,
0.0030621183,
0.0327606387,
0.0780699998,
0.0188912265,
0.0114567271,
-0.0504986756,
0.0104781147,
-0.0820022002,
-0.0128928795,
-0.007681279,
-5.685338304e-33,
-0.019826483,
-0.0286768675,
0.0437615067,
-0.0539378338,
-0.0277099051,
0.0115550747,
0.016296545,
-0.0000277096,
0.00277626,
-0.0475883894,
0.0045373323,
-0.0229949653,
0.0302782934,
0.0210454892,
0.0124176387,
0.0127096334,
0.0248661004,
0.0033018305,
-0.0032944416,
0.0120916367,
0.0593364649,
0.0461428016,
0.0553844348,
-0.0222658738,
0.021379821,
-0.022376243,
-0.0007162602,
0.0008015963,
0.0351766422,
0.0553128682,
-0.0220914017,
0.053893812,
0.0048964494,
-0.0217470042,
-0.0041680569,
0.0226667505,
-0.0298627261,
0.0125484485,
0.0238693785,
-0.0141943386,
0.0296195969,
0.0145481154,
0.0582104512,
-0.0449952856,
-0.0064031328,
0.0527147464,
0.0350176543,
-0.048562061,
-0.0337086022,
-0.0367869176,
-0.050024163,
0.0280233398,
0.0117707541,
0.0348758474,
0.0249278042,
0.0460941941,
-0.0059748725,
0.0412572958,
-0.0261468366,
0.0316980816,
-0.0201333761,
0.0083533628,
0.0948468745,
0.0228678118,
0.0109293647,
0.0459313728,
-0.0043026609,
-0.0158961155,
-0.0014857277,
-0.0237531848,
0.015235018,
0.0767121837,
-0.0079602068,
0.06099426,
-0.0179478936,
-0.0246743243,
-0.0228349846,
0.0287349597,
0.0014835816,
0.0140744997,
0.054356318,
0.0164819025,
-0.0378944576,
-0.006031713,
-0.0127632823,
0.0392644703,
-0.043088682,
-0.0482200943,
0.0614508055,
0.0365710929,
-0.0558180697,
0.0282453112,
0.0445705242,
-0.0190010834,
-0.0375667065,
0.0185465384,
-0.0149693806,
0.0016837411,
-0.0422669649,
-0.0208827965,
-0.0691162273,
-0.0335225165,
0.0117867487,
-0.0308441166,
-0.0230134819,
-0.0031701685,
-0.0088602686,
-0.0071150591,
-0.0587056242,
0.0330744199,
-0.02713296,
0.0188496169,
-0.0528506562,
-0.0557023995,
0.0337610394,
-0.0005921547,
0.0008033471,
0.0441173315,
0.0487971418,
0.0041204263,
-0.0163582452,
-0.0359492935,
0.0546323806,
0.0125272973,
-0.016062798,
0.0497429147,
0.010030929,
0.0399959348,
0.0449927896,
0.0056523248,
-0.0083555998,
0.0077572907,
2.378e-7,
0.0612872243,
0.0446329303,
0.025948856,
0.0143544003,
-0.0196539145,
-0.0126650389,
0.0207431652,
0.0148735484,
-0.0029690636,
0.0112601956,
0.0046751713,
-0.0218138713,
0.0436115339,
0.0153121734,
-0.0669833943,
-0.013387423,
-0.0582997352,
-0.0123475371,
-0.0815892592,
-0.0026501804,
0.080830507,
0.0442598574,
0.0133870663,
-0.0183235481,
-0.049924884,
-0.0728983879,
0.0540361442,
-0.0373011939,
-0.0349637829,
0.0423488766,
0.0320909061,
0.0577546917,
-0.0135751311,
-0.021084439,
-0.0041170996,
0.022891419,
0.0219457671,
0.0120923789,
0.0132366726,
0.0065296339,
0.0028273836,
-0.0784240216,
-0.0147975907,
-0.0444088094,
0.0468338877,
-0.0447470434,
-0.0234877821,
-0.0046594278,
-0.038623143,
-0.0222452432,
-0.0269758366,
-0.0406836048,
-0.0069915047,
0.003746307,
-0.0046737618,
-0.0158216543,
-0.0223932266,
-0.068091765,
0.0199158974,
0.0000179153,
-0.04776958,
-0.0466815382,
-0.019971028,
0.0088655073,
0.0157087408,
-0.0048325751,
0.0178488493,
2.285674378e-34,
0.0301615689,
0.0046229665,
-0.0018904739,
0.0320660546,
0.0525039881,
-0.0042916373,
0.0095016705,
0.0402382165,
-0.043241255,
-0.0943225026,
-0.0092433468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11423v1 | Dredge Word, Social Media, and Webgraph Networks for Unreliable Website Classification and Identification | 2024-06-17T11:22:04 | 2024-06-17T11:22:04 | Evan M. Williams, Peter Carragher, Kathleen M. Carley | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | In an attempt to mimic the complex paths through which unreliable content
spreads between search engines and social media, we explore the impact of
incorporating both webgraph and large-scale social media contexts into website
credibility classification and discovery systems. We further explore the usage
of what we define as \textit{dredge words} on social media -- terms or phrases
for which unreliable domains rank highly. Through comprehensive graph neural
network ablations, we demonstrate that curriculum-based heterogeneous graph
models that leverage context from both webgraphs and social media data
outperform homogeneous and single-mode approaches. We further demonstrate that
the incorporation of dredge words into our model strongly associates unreliable
websites with social media and online commerce platforms. Finally, we show our
heterogeneous model greatly outperforms competing systems in the top-k
identification of unlabeled unreliable websites. We demonstrate the strong
unreliability signals present in the diverse paths that users follow to uncover
unreliable content, and we release a novel dataset of dredge words. | [
0.0620948374,
0.0278388914,
-0.0130126588,
0.0147612644,
-0.0188352149,
0.0041835615,
0.0247465055,
0.0034444181,
0.0247192103,
-0.048787348,
-0.0012423629,
-0.0126980739,
0.0118716462,
0.0736689344,
0.0250029471,
0.0485053323,
0.0240876898,
0.0213881005,
0.0353908166,
-0.033473324,
-0.0048090331,
0.0198087674,
-0.0097056152,
0.0321732908,
-0.0059890212,
-0.0143257147,
0.0348095968,
0.0330990143,
-0.008614392,
-0.0540536419,
0.0396955535,
0.0324109755,
-0.0334799737,
0.0794101059,
0.0000019096,
-0.0263899267,
0.0050462689,
-0.0405470282,
-0.0316391028,
-0.0130936271,
0.019839434,
0.0306153428,
0.0132161491,
0.0168117844,
-0.0100887679,
-0.013205478,
0.0492420122,
0.0245727301,
0.0476490781,
0.0575661436,
-0.0040670554,
0.0330329463,
0.0026815173,
-0.0020285242,
-0.0214045048,
-0.0163551457,
0.0558546558,
0.0179934483,
-0.0307388119,
-0.0419034287,
-0.0176779795,
-0.0081597352,
-0.0076231509,
-0.0240121298,
0.0437562875,
-0.0206987467,
-0.0116716279,
-0.0117272995,
0.0279415045,
0.0818468481,
-0.0013401471,
-0.027175026,
0.0226532128,
-0.0060403175,
0.013026502,
0.0591824651,
-0.0409523547,
0.0575733855,
-0.0190482493,
0.00231863,
-0.0428521372,
-0.0049956422,
0.0743484795,
0.0484064296,
-0.0080938442,
0.0563859418,
-0.0202405155,
-0.0005831972,
0.0487385541,
0.0286068842,
-0.0052883457,
-0.0211768709,
0.0178351104,
-0.020807324,
-0.0566527955,
0.0109257391,
-0.0237795301,
0.0161720812,
0.0248966757,
-0.0448045172,
-0.0134703526,
-0.0134172784,
-0.022252474,
0.038299486,
0.0033544512,
-0.0119526535,
0.0027790109,
0.0364682972,
0.0400391929,
0.0321668945,
-0.0312322155,
0.0223915875,
0.0189166386,
0.0170032382,
0.0547309518,
-0.0223309938,
-0.0668601617,
0.0311339479,
-0.0960839689,
0.0318433419,
0.0120857563,
0.0550687052,
-0.0074665756,
-0.0015743581,
-0.0384588204,
-0.0036201582,
0.0254424848,
0.0358456969,
0.0005841486,
-0.0110872611,
0.0085630445,
0.0239305496,
0.0180243831,
-0.013650924,
-0.0005068128,
0.0313285775,
0.0537359864,
-0.0435117222,
-0.0947990417,
-0.0671876147,
-0.0572888032,
-0.0012217732,
0.0085072899,
-0.0688935518,
-0.0266204514,
0.0144356117,
-0.0039997054,
-0.050450854,
0.0044759065,
-0.0088037858,
-0.0946527719,
-0.0003558766,
-0.0473779477,
0.0083483588,
0.0080785211,
0.0073269471,
-0.0277809966,
0.0082887439,
-0.0070958813,
0.0883959085,
0.0669592395,
0.0216919594,
-0.0007524377,
0.0150242755,
0.0452271737,
0.0065197847,
0.0008992994,
-0.0438639075,
-0.0081017548,
-0.027462706,
-0.0045027933,
0.051224485,
-0.0199744422,
-0.0155183431,
0.083421804,
-0.0315246396,
-0.0290291961,
0.0027724321,
0.0424821116,
0.004674301,
-0.0204807464,
0.0058070272,
-0.0884019807,
-0.0251878332,
-0.0394982472,
-0.0294536334,
0.048913192,
0.050837718,
-0.0134387128,
-0.0408528186,
-0.0256168209,
-0.0256869178,
0.0294266008,
-0.0224024449,
0.0613052957,
-0.0144725358,
-0.0334927328,
-0.0134342769,
0.0320414975,
0.0244121514,
-0.0095062135,
-0.0148183564,
0.0110493461,
0.0670297369,
0.0204219781,
0.0012773291,
0.0217676591,
-0.0310628805,
0.0071230452,
-0.0016023146,
0.0107829133,
-0.0227891561,
-0.0579823442,
0.0025536655,
-0.0584674738,
-0.0112577789,
0.0329215713,
0.0022566079,
0.0325020365,
0.0249036457,
0.0012385332,
-0.0919288993,
-0.0564756133,
-0.0213145446,
-0.0020864659,
0.0347607322,
-0.0303875133,
0.0228907112,
0.0045637134,
0.0370474011,
0.0071883807,
-0.0265824907,
0.0207649991,
0.0473170504,
-0.0782652572,
-0.0435016304,
0.0293994471,
0.048575595,
0.0685247555,
-0.066598624,
-0.0136134224,
0.040950153,
-0.0072619445,
-0.0184129514,
0.0605334342,
-0.062429823,
0.0264392383,
0.0203287918,
0.0088784266,
-0.0065092864,
0.0212696884,
-0.0096164653,
0.0795481354,
-0.0253424514,
0.0475311577,
-0.0022439372,
-0.0333250612,
-0.0163931306,
-0.0098787956,
-0.002361529,
-0.0126452884,
-0.069728151,
0.0321525075,
0.0398161784,
-0.0667594597,
-0.0550826304,
0.0168956947,
-0.0312273595,
-0.0631209388,
-0.0077023874,
-0.0306653269,
-0.0170534756,
-0.0338467658,
0.0012591265,
0.0172192212,
0.0081858318,
0.0342646129,
0.0371405855,
0.0177370925,
0.0079707718,
-0.0208694134,
-0.0173119884,
0.0034835553,
-0.0452153496,
-0.0224172007,
0.0587059632,
0.0320122726,
-0.0811001807,
-0.0515898988,
0.0033377537,
-0.0574367419,
-0.0483466089,
-0.0295993835,
0.0015834189,
-0.0182256103,
0.0342101902,
-0.0557688102,
-0.00659806,
0.0083521446,
0.0274263527,
0.047854133,
0.009814824,
-0.0287024807,
-0.0600447804,
-0.0428492017,
-0.0111278463,
0.0097723268,
-0.0032794334,
0.0094030676,
-0.0152855841,
0.0605350398,
-0.000364323,
0.0052800812,
0.0438732989,
-0.0150411269,
0.0340500511,
0.0087938067,
-0.0543386675,
0.0059046024,
0.0282042269,
-0.0131635126,
-0.0212367047,
0.0563597046,
0.0261407308,
0.0887220949,
0.0572989918,
-0.0533579029,
0.0445154756,
-0.0631673038,
0.0234648809,
0.0314967521,
0.0589738972,
-0.0130288955,
0.0031378267,
0.0003380862,
0.0768574774,
-0.0495323986,
-0.013503287,
0.026757706,
0.0236037858,
0.0292169638,
-0.027588414,
-0.0447828658,
-0.0348284543,
-0.0154106049,
-0.0190384854,
0.020867208,
-0.0326732881,
-0.0358926244,
-0.0466863886,
-0.030480681,
-0.0367660448,
-0.0427607447,
-0.0361151099,
0.000817696,
0.061599806,
0.0057492889,
-0.0151270917,
0.0761907175,
-0.0049744477,
-0.0519685298,
0.02167904,
0.0135551738,
-0.0327368006,
-0.0198398065,
-0.0250710603,
0.0000960799,
-0.0103773577,
0.0162731633,
-0.0043051718,
-0.0162053891,
-0.0079319105,
0.0155277811,
0.0574203506,
0.0128268059,
-0.0242374279,
-0.0044287527,
0.0324056186,
-0.0144550931,
0.0301268995,
-0.0306013338,
-0.0792216137,
0.0044643767,
-0.0131616555,
0.0482911952,
0.0222715605,
-0.0404489562,
0.0299752988,
-0.0717650577,
0.0358259641,
0.0222325251,
0.0405403078,
0.004544192,
-0.0443175063,
-0.0112808803,
-0.0231058672,
0.0266524609,
-0.0126188407,
-0.0072754277,
-0.0126850735,
0.0146449218,
-0.0070224707,
-0.0515603088,
0.0226042829,
-0.0241281129,
0.0581456572,
-0.0235125516,
-0.0249323361,
-0.0459569134,
-0.0245712139,
0.0485904254,
0.0148063414,
-0.0363095514,
-0.0056368136,
0.099308677,
-0.0205959715,
0.0122159161,
-0.0017071038,
0.0375498459,
-0.0503952615,
0.0019561935,
-0.0603880025,
0.0502439104,
0.0087385168,
-0.047629226,
-0.0108112171,
-0.0385213047,
0.0169678126,
0.0294811726,
0.0207575299,
-0.0057087136,
-0.04340446,
-0.0434004441,
-0.0044999756,
-0.0004234183,
-0.0178804044,
0.0440993868,
-0.0213631857,
-0.0365153663,
-0.0576529875,
0.0191534739,
-0.0122553799,
-0.01676636,
-0.0003303788,
-0.041764807,
0.0526584871,
-0.0138065713,
-0.0897917449,
0.0175805893,
-0.020483302,
0.0353561901,
-0.0584957935,
0.029721247,
0.0243097935,
-0.035276264,
-0.0056054629,
0.0232895687,
-0.03263551,
-0.078477107,
0.0265424829,
-0.0113518815,
0.0197415706,
0.0131866131,
-0.0502540469,
-0.0203554183,
0.0386058688,
0.0429722071,
-0.0324721262,
-0.0196319614,
0.0474647582,
0.0051723458,
-0.0125206662,
0.0178216957,
-0.0521232001,
0.0163676701,
0.0113298902,
-0.0051890109,
-0.0182980206,
0.011206137,
0.0336860307,
0.0296224896,
0.0930224136,
-0.0145184603,
-0.0180474296,
-0.0426683947,
-0.0488050692,
0.0397202335,
-0.0325510614,
0.0298974141,
0.0466704071,
0.030934697,
-0.0089717889,
-0.0089220386,
-0.0444930382,
-0.0154331904,
-0.0039392719,
-0.0660467669,
-0.073592253,
0.0074501247,
0.0004895361,
0.0091135427,
-0.0021861901,
0.0103802653,
0.0096656578,
0.0322453119,
0.0282780901,
-0.0151783591,
0.0025109649,
0.0152137494,
-0.0200821981,
0.0098409159,
-0.0162480436,
-0.0193829536,
-0.0118119679,
-0.0471976362,
-0.0219584648,
0.0716866031,
-0.0105096688,
-0.0150239849,
-0.0041606892,
-0.0021462301,
-0.0096353134,
-0.0050360961,
0.0288165659,
-0.0217086822,
0.0144487536,
0.0086848559,
-0.0408721417,
0.0709908232,
0.0171793327,
0.0357873142,
0.0069028656,
-0.0043921866,
-0.0690630227,
-0.0073574153,
-0.0343896337,
-0.0177093185,
0.1083895415,
-0.0185724683,
-0.0369163491,
-0.0443975329,
-0.0711068586,
0.0329760052,
0.026071623,
0.0390849337,
0.0372224748,
-0.0450333096,
0.0775971562,
0.0265459977,
0.0685983598,
-0.0274527073,
0.0011884735,
0.0055474802,
-0.0175047386,
-0.007048449,
-6.615879836e-33,
0.0763491094,
-0.0941468105,
-0.0442058034,
-0.0051706028,
-0.0055455812,
0.030007368,
-0.0095902532,
0.0348294377,
-0.0300510861,
0.0293098632,
0.0241198372,
0.0346606709,
-0.0006001576,
0.0142360236,
-0.0053199721,
-0.0252141915,
0.000863751,
0.0339946859,
-0.0218811166,
0.0457869433,
0.0906447545,
-0.0135492748,
0.0147834979,
-0.1029866561,
0.0537607484,
-0.0364155434,
-0.0046378667,
0.0115311788,
0.0339693613,
0.0517570004,
-0.0207311176,
0.0803419948,
0.013972356,
-0.0143436287,
0.0541519262,
-0.0314426236,
-0.071368508,
-0.0008987202,
-0.0157327745,
-0.0023355668,
0.0142250303,
0.0198132619,
0.0609324649,
-0.0122174229,
-0.0138399545,
-0.000011366,
0.0553200133,
0.0126232468,
-0.0468573086,
-0.0396879278,
-0.0317241251,
0.0146995718,
-0.022526592,
0.0167125966,
-0.0205056053,
0.0261017587,
0.02845948,
0.0306912158,
-0.0895631462,
0.006529666,
-0.0850995928,
-0.0420739092,
0.0203196239,
-0.0404375084,
-0.0771176964,
0.0803442821,
-0.0326929949,
0.0171578526,
0.0344424993,
-0.0238900688,
-0.0008854672,
0.0585434251,
0.0340128317,
0.0728792176,
0.0184503496,
-0.0706857219,
-0.0525062159,
0.0073036291,
0.0578105934,
-0.020528812,
0.0193765704,
-0.0333220288,
-0.0216741897,
-0.0206519701,
0.0009184862,
-0.0324289314,
-0.0656127334,
0.0109462989,
-0.0204062946,
0.0110230325,
-0.044878602,
0.0411702171,
-0.0173139125,
-0.0837450027,
-0.054421369,
0.0743758827,
-0.0021610695,
0.0321652777,
0.0140368892,
0.0046407892,
0.0034969533,
0.0013328997,
-0.0350234881,
0.0141078476,
0.014081507,
-0.0102014327,
0.0324229673,
-0.0020936504,
-0.0098960837,
0.029193297,
-0.0150687145,
-0.0018559627,
-0.0225029681,
-0.0692360699,
0.0377602465,
0.0216892455,
-0.0166978315,
0.0175391827,
0.0841840655,
0.0701742992,
0.0022161293,
0.019814996,
-0.0456062704,
0.0129738525,
-0.0395780578,
-0.0390036851,
-0.0010746928,
0.0494526289,
0.003318487,
-0.0741141587,
0.0165844541,
-0.0141519895,
2.777e-7,
0.0162788648,
0.0702900589,
-0.0160446502,
-0.0168437008,
0.0381254405,
0.0061579254,
0.0256825928,
0.0028988549,
-0.0127621097,
-0.0746064186,
-0.0025471351,
-0.0083173709,
-0.0038272489,
0.0126120457,
-0.0050067566,
0.0241278782,
-0.0318445377,
0.0047545633,
-0.0394853726,
0.0258074477,
0.0024495781,
0.0406079032,
0.0714073479,
-0.0405392013,
-0.0285788551,
-0.0276015792,
0.0227072518,
0.0263563804,
0.0092270868,
-0.0071818912,
0.0428817533,
0.0032232527,
-0.0093479846,
-0.0083425222,
-0.0208321474,
0.0227524582,
0.0019450315,
-0.018714685,
0.0378935821,
0.01525182,
-0.0288413931,
-0.0495636128,
0.0693978295,
-0.0390302539,
0.0508614816,
-0.0135560483,
-0.0185476765,
-0.0238445643,
-0.036344815,
0.0001817569,
0.0629137754,
0.0085698217,
-0.0147444978,
0.0257692728,
-0.0113423523,
0.0386881493,
0.0101501131,
-0.0818705931,
0.0486892127,
0.0033146555,
-0.0093625169,
-0.0336717293,
0.0519587435,
-0.0174692087,
0.0703444406,
-0.0435342453,
0.032907255,
2.284002513e-34,
0.0626871362,
-0.0283340886,
0.003603976,
-0.0474926084,
0.0202871561,
0.001454892,
-0.0308239013,
-0.0025015147,
0.0123773534,
-0.0102702426,
0.0365842208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11418v1 | BAMBINO-LM: (Bilingual-)Human-Inspired Continual Pretraining of BabyLM | 2024-06-17T11:08:08 | 2024-06-17T11:08:08 | Zhewen Shen, Aditya Joshi, Ruey-Cheng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Children from bilingual backgrounds benefit from interactions with parents
and teachers to re-acquire their heritage language. In this paper, we
investigate how this insight from behavioral study can be incorporated into the
learning of small-scale language models. We introduce BAMBINO-LM, a continual
pretraining strategy for BabyLM that uses a novel combination of alternation
and PPO-based perplexity reward induced from a parent Italian model. Upon
evaluation on zero-shot classification tasks for English and Italian,
BAMBINO-LM improves the Italian language capability of a BabyLM baseline. Our
ablation analysis demonstrates that employing both the alternation strategy and
PPO-based modeling is key to this effectiveness gain. We also show that, as a
side effect, the proposed method leads to similar degradation in L1
effectiveness as human children would have had in an equivalent learning
scenario. | [
-0.0186419897,
0.0654698163,
-0.0466774777,
0.0161051061,
-0.038001541,
0.0407161266,
0.0305239689,
-0.0056865825,
-0.0347905718,
0.0211830717,
-0.0421338603,
-0.0222612843,
-0.0024817628,
-0.0224052351,
-0.019041108,
-0.0675256029,
0.0531607196,
-0.0103812004,
-0.0162858553,
-0.0285793319,
-0.0132246036,
-0.0148928883,
-0.0283929911,
0.0271437597,
0.0091152154,
0.0160827655,
-0.0093044769,
-0.0210786387,
-0.0027653645,
-0.0371565036,
-0.0184420627,
0.0805736408,
0.0431644246,
0.0090550957,
0.0000020087,
-0.0604981668,
0.017896045,
-0.0344896875,
0.0040285657,
-0.0274893381,
0.0226188432,
0.0344726741,
-0.0155892223,
-0.0150562273,
-0.0167480074,
0.0274202786,
0.0592680424,
0.0308206212,
-0.0200785864,
0.0177764762,
0.0020298557,
-0.0121887261,
0.0346788354,
0.0015321937,
0.0815711692,
0.0089727025,
-0.018396765,
-0.0148706883,
0.0100327088,
-0.0383500457,
-0.0347965211,
0.0386591144,
0.0707305595,
0.0059245671,
-0.0399417803,
0.0325222239,
0.0566595085,
-0.0500006676,
-0.0067484602,
-0.0083560236,
-0.033311218,
-0.0259779319,
-0.0072047799,
0.0286064819,
0.0193733014,
-0.0162453745,
-0.0469332896,
0.0097792419,
0.0128647219,
0.0487185121,
0.041039966,
-0.0272311792,
0.0467083342,
-0.0147929378,
0.0077502057,
0.0622896329,
0.0136165963,
-0.0513822995,
0.0222538672,
0.0411605574,
0.0408378392,
-0.0299016293,
-0.010247184,
-0.0056000641,
0.0012842448,
0.0401051827,
-0.0198318921,
0.0178077221,
0.0026160271,
-0.0303798076,
0.0401791893,
0.0213534292,
-0.068454951,
0.0088723982,
0.0137824211,
0.0308348704,
0.0220105443,
0.0002294277,
-0.0176894926,
0.0386684984,
-0.067269817,
-0.0366011634,
-0.0268626008,
0.0229639076,
-0.0162901878,
0.0279264394,
-0.0317875482,
0.0181025378,
-0.0191448797,
-0.0271295179,
-0.0108152414,
-0.0321219824,
-0.0149228079,
-0.0076518501,
-0.0328489877,
0.043196056,
-0.0041434146,
-0.0099006435,
-0.0048580682,
-0.0503723882,
-0.0086156856,
-0.0046720533,
-0.0326689854,
-0.012585761,
0.0078029153,
0.0190824121,
-0.0440661535,
-0.0560367331,
-0.0284853857,
0.0324504264,
0.0038664241,
-0.0777276754,
0.0267955009,
-0.0548879951,
0.0092197238,
-0.0355574638,
0.0022142064,
-0.064921163,
-0.0130154993,
-0.0199391842,
0.0216541402,
0.0167245287,
0.0132321091,
-0.0061501549,
0.003877566,
0.0065752431,
0.0257602874,
0.1078506783,
0.0255458672,
-0.0850766599,
0.0055887783,
-0.0262674578,
-0.0370840877,
0.0388552174,
0.0631312728,
0.034595836,
-0.0155289657,
-0.0361139849,
0.0353725292,
0.0072592222,
0.0361905731,
-0.0338305719,
-0.0489126891,
0.0425300635,
0.0768776238,
0.0444102921,
-0.0235089548,
0.0364549942,
0.0275703184,
0.0037122376,
0.0239415541,
0.0317332186,
-0.0366112627,
0.0225235373,
-0.0464346558,
-0.0135208787,
-0.016379578,
0.0487575829,
-0.058825992,
-0.0393812619,
0.017738374,
-0.0212997012,
0.0487487428,
0.0298927333,
0.0619717166,
0.0222331136,
-0.0220723208,
0.0236172378,
0.0679576546,
-0.0259988904,
0.0517926924,
-0.0761778653,
-0.0195364077,
0.0447060727,
-0.0281395111,
-0.0158256907,
-0.0016051352,
0.0075122616,
-0.0055998932,
0.0485702679,
-0.0004726702,
0.0220529083,
0.0426978543,
-0.0090899654,
-0.0003025015,
0.0320116878,
0.010395702,
0.0117532536,
0.0062117931,
-0.0031667168,
-0.0333883949,
0.023166215,
-0.0018679167,
0.0303014256,
-0.0832325816,
-0.0038981931,
0.0175380465,
-0.0048907041,
0.0009013026,
0.0128347985,
0.0020795476,
-0.0268959254,
0.0379466377,
-0.005282972,
0.0352030955,
0.0657195896,
-0.051166255,
-0.0535155162,
0.0212985184,
0.0255037509,
-0.0135502052,
-0.0238737594,
0.0050628963,
0.0107842339,
0.0626672432,
-0.0090734204,
0.0689449236,
-0.0165152606,
0.0400597863,
-0.0787313506,
-0.0198981967,
-0.0522890389,
0.0288389139,
-0.0189519506,
0.0019814358,
-0.0151839368,
-0.0307595972,
0.0265270006,
-0.0753479525,
-0.0298495572,
0.0120876152,
-0.015281029,
0.0183937997,
-0.0033691584,
0.0544823594,
-0.0670004115,
-0.0211389903,
-0.0651980191,
-0.0025346046,
0.0005354445,
0.0169561431,
-0.0105671063,
-0.0275199637,
-0.0014257069,
-0.0221755244,
-0.0280845556,
0.0166646019,
-0.0213988889,
0.02308161,
-0.0033166676,
-0.0175312255,
-0.0537458062,
0.0028223437,
-0.0358022712,
0.0248760395,
0.002447868,
-0.0191683806,
0.0405520238,
-0.0352222957,
-0.0127498712,
-0.0276501365,
0.0089852512,
-0.0236758776,
-0.0100865867,
0.0598946325,
0.0390607789,
0.0559650026,
0.096212022,
-0.0217561815,
0.0061532692,
0.0414978005,
-0.0167660005,
-0.0454151221,
-0.0133737326,
-0.017442055,
-0.0508942902,
-0.0704611912,
-0.0082016988,
-0.0227800477,
0.0765108019,
-0.0032020633,
0.0097260578,
-0.0683565661,
0.0001286529,
-0.0180189926,
-0.0690591857,
-0.0334692374,
-0.0192686617,
-0.0262924209,
0.0311368033,
-0.0231831633,
-0.0590450615,
0.0538480803,
0.0176294968,
-0.0132349283,
-0.0679494813,
0.016955832,
0.0335594155,
0.0251931902,
-0.0040067756,
0.0196577497,
-0.0511920527,
-0.0014802899,
-0.0577328242,
-0.0143603906,
-0.0094254287,
-0.0154049015,
0.027929958,
-0.0437158942,
-0.021311041,
0.0345234759,
-0.0498053208,
-0.0422063731,
0.054212749,
-0.0127648897,
-0.0004477033,
-0.0327453054,
-0.000577887,
-0.0313087553,
-0.0381586701,
0.065618962,
0.0065842303,
-0.0155361118,
0.023514038,
-0.0039780783,
-0.081620954,
0.0018710864,
-0.0091119995,
0.0219077244,
-0.048841808,
0.0111224344,
0.0082296198,
0.0193256009,
-0.0313157961,
0.0031853155,
0.0605270825,
0.0160832778,
0.0314466543,
-0.0585456491,
0.0404814035,
0.0179678649,
-0.0354145281,
-0.0268190671,
0.0460068323,
0.0197246224,
-0.0521801151,
-0.0093495483,
-0.0427924357,
0.0636118799,
0.0003367328,
0.0286229588,
-0.0573610961,
0.0268750321,
0.0087974491,
0.0138069522,
0.014717021,
0.0209599938,
-0.0062164972,
-0.0496314764,
0.0049520209,
0.0279895719,
-0.0600084774,
0.0099790199,
-0.0372558348,
-0.0271606054,
0.0360260308,
0.0344975814,
0.0267228577,
0.0059460867,
-0.023766214,
0.0160260368,
0.0333059914,
-0.071474351,
0.0152277388,
-0.0108467154,
0.0139157986,
0.0519643463,
-0.0160891339,
-0.0199025162,
-0.0567060374,
0.0469108745,
0.0244457927,
-0.0326591842,
-0.0276367273,
0.0025350368,
0.0334444717,
0.010515986,
-0.0204440299,
0.0252469778,
0.0026323767,
-0.0456857048,
0.004092806,
0.0669488385,
0.0049464484,
0.0096740481,
0.0450444594,
0.0050383597,
0.0145734828,
0.0354300104,
0.0433499329,
-0.0989016593,
0.0244580265,
0.0051584761,
-0.0258894507,
-0.0500530563,
-0.0330738463,
0.0315796807,
-0.046655301,
-0.0345457979,
-0.0482950062,
0.0050272383,
-0.0033871501,
0.0637908056,
0.0199217331,
0.0028546972,
-0.0122292507,
-0.0278632492,
0.0159184709,
0.0555665791,
0.0048350217,
-0.0082142213,
-0.0859842896,
-0.0633638874,
-0.0066646272,
-0.0724050477,
0.0008860622,
-0.0535604097,
-0.0558183193,
-0.0447721332,
0.0434044152,
0.0551628508,
0.0272079278,
0.0535937101,
0.0389730409,
-0.070572719,
0.0147998491,
0.0393600613,
0.0631782338,
0.0199559852,
0.0205760095,
-0.0040343618,
0.0378792994,
0.0136332149,
-0.002481608,
0.014044472,
0.0182427019,
0.0084150294,
-0.0082297325,
0.0356802717,
0.0207633208,
-0.0235149376,
0.055200845,
-0.0505218394,
-0.0016568875,
-0.0613493212,
0.0232874844,
-0.0271139462,
0.028023148,
-0.0091591179,
-0.0631127656,
0.0312974304,
0.0203973483,
0.0365766622,
-0.0592455156,
-0.0247587617,
0.0036497358,
0.0011980926,
0.0053431499,
-0.0253222603,
0.0238899607,
0.002370253,
0.0937373266,
0.0103162173,
0.0463153645,
-0.0069861589,
0.0604527518,
-0.0205243304,
0.0461934283,
0.0205003265,
-0.0070551601,
-0.0494512916,
0.010815843,
0.0089919604,
-0.0097848112,
0.0105087012,
-0.0073211235,
0.080498606,
-0.001120856,
0.0744055957,
-0.0084080715,
-0.0015644822,
-0.0138429934,
-0.0114918472,
-0.0382285193,
-0.0305779241,
0.0021817619,
-0.022324698,
0.0174837876,
0.0009729723,
0.0038959836,
-0.034563411,
0.0171269681,
-0.0395568497,
0.0866360813,
-0.0119760074,
0.0129639944,
0.0659625232,
0.0260511599,
-0.0537913479,
0.0064185639,
-0.0316875763,
-0.0389559567,
-0.0559863932,
0.0272164661,
-0.0050401366,
-0.0095649129,
0.0360827409,
0.0340323523,
-0.0581975952,
-0.0307922382,
-0.0160135906,
0.0110788858,
0.0624108873,
-0.0217189323,
0.0007010343,
-6.171227058e-33,
-0.0242504012,
0.001431735,
0.0505556092,
0.017845571,
0.0108405147,
-0.0123303924,
-0.0163399782,
0.0507236868,
-0.0009709947,
-0.0147170313,
0.0113401143,
-0.0569051728,
0.0060671442,
-0.0034806691,
0.0318793133,
0.0091601377,
0.0013657279,
-0.0255774967,
0.0056118849,
0.0037494039,
-0.0019093122,
-0.0117188133,
0.0601193197,
-0.0531988777,
0.0293771308,
-0.0021328093,
-0.004762792,
0.0266084354,
-0.0288619511,
0.0671451017,
0.0090360492,
0.0050382754,
0.0114023015,
0.0364445597,
-0.0334428288,
-0.0032007569,
-0.0624865554,
-0.0382904522,
0.0349604636,
0.0158032291,
-0.0549442358,
-0.0303641148,
0.0297528915,
0.0039061701,
-0.0436461009,
0.0107880579,
-0.0057777949,
-0.0199969932,
-0.021789385,
0.0549182929,
-0.0715302154,
-0.0161837675,
0.0045207338,
-0.003980604,
0.0545172915,
0.023982672,
-0.081495598,
-0.017634809,
-0.0319881812,
0.0214243289,
0.0586130656,
0.0249815769,
0.0927404463,
0.0509692915,
0.0798205733,
0.0045324904,
0.1045070589,
0.0446802936,
0.0459535792,
0.0145299146,
0.1315296888,
-0.0427899398,
0.0280862227,
0.0138086835,
0.0362470672,
0.0056724674,
-0.0577169433,
-0.0302357394,
0.0564328916,
0.0090355296,
0.0235780217,
0.008235123,
0.0171455704,
-0.0217792895,
-0.0696594566,
-0.0448136292,
0.0065856958,
-0.079117842,
0.0200940035,
0.0091445977,
0.0175148137,
-0.0461161248,
0.0490987785,
-0.0007890573,
-0.0142293703,
-0.0354326814,
-0.016957989,
0.0135780182,
0.0221025441,
0.0195541028,
-0.0798311979,
-0.0571612045,
-0.0076257293,
-0.0112512028,
0.0150306709,
0.0507626459,
0.0596305355,
0.0232151635,
-0.026391441,
0.042418085,
-0.0372182466,
-0.0007523643,
0.1080754772,
0.0196811445,
-0.0080168108,
0.0119465468,
-0.00350643,
0.0375583172,
0.0914163291,
-0.0729780644,
-0.0677609071,
0.0419254266,
-0.0271809734,
0.0592074469,
-0.0051513836,
0.0007096569,
-0.0320125595,
0.0312987566,
0.0166022014,
-0.0693354011,
-0.0230960976,
0.0025589974,
2.761e-7,
0.0017908349,
0.0599775426,
-0.0181836244,
-0.0088711046,
0.0551020317,
-0.0044358652,
-0.0611556321,
-0.0139458412,
0.0340805128,
0.0330929607,
-0.0033947749,
0.036755342,
0.0427446701,
-0.0085300514,
-0.0502428114,
-0.0184080638,
-0.0186027475,
0.0358950645,
-0.0455834679,
0.0293264445,
0.0021113537,
0.023825014,
0.0321101695,
-0.0275222864,
-0.0047887145,
0.0250337683,
0.0449701287,
-0.0278764684,
-0.0145396991,
-0.0181423295,
-0.0319625437,
0.0144028636,
0.0240296181,
-0.0093099643,
-0.0221117325,
0.044198595,
-0.0617925934,
0.0248823781,
-0.0454636216,
-0.0393232144,
0.0294674709,
0.0139968274,
-0.0626574457,
-0.0830961242,
0.0246977396,
-0.0162823349,
0.0106157018,
0.0310361981,
-0.0215938687,
-0.0441892743,
0.0460323691,
-0.0393778235,
-0.0544155836,
0.0270488653,
0.0025493049,
0.0206072032,
-0.0019447876,
0.0200855546,
-0.0074452935,
0.0367289968,
-0.0537156612,
-0.0522536524,
-0.0140963132,
0.0304019954,
-0.0606343821,
0.0436577052,
0.0231228434,
2.061294777e-34,
-0.0101386141,
-0.0288178585,
0.0555891916,
0.0178857278,
0.0113211721,
-0.0203281045,
-0.0540561639,
0.0231724661,
0.021373421,
-0.0180662908,
0.0148153156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15486v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15486v2 | SampleAttention: Near-Lossless Acceleration of Long Context LLM Inference with Adaptive Structured Sparse Attention | 2024-06-17T11:05:15 | 2024-06-28T08:55:17 | Qianchao Zhu, Jiangfei Duan, Chang Chen, Siran Liu, Xiuhong Li, Guanyu Feng, Xin Lv, Huanqi Cao, Xiao Chuanfu, Xingcheng Zhang, Dahua Lin, Chao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) now support extremely long context windows, but
the quadratic complexity of vanilla attention results in significantly long
Time-to-First-Token (TTFT) latency. Existing approaches to address this
complexity require additional pretraining or finetuning, and often sacrifice
model accuracy. In this paper, we first provide both theoretical and empirical
foundations for near-lossless sparse attention. We find dynamically capturing
head-specific sparse patterns at runtime with low overhead is crucial. To
address this, we propose SampleAttention, an adaptive structured and
near-lossless sparse attention. Leveraging observed significant sparse
patterns, SampleAttention attends to a fixed percentage of adjacent tokens to
capture local window patterns, and employs a two-stage query-guided key-value
filtering approach, which adaptively select a minimum set of key-values with
low overhead, to capture column stripe patterns. Comprehensive evaluations show
that SampleAttention can seamlessly replace vanilla attention in off-the-shelf
LLMs with nearly no accuracy loss, and reduces TTFT by up to $2.42\times$
compared with FlashAttention. | [
0.0066213869,
0.0724202171,
0.008979802,
0.0628724843,
-0.0188529529,
0.0014174286,
-0.0069924328,
0.010560235,
-0.0345590413,
-0.0492083989,
-0.0294742752,
-0.0535407923,
-0.0030897276,
0.0359380171,
0.045669172,
-0.0127592972,
0.0387241989,
-0.0496204421,
-0.00690905,
0.0197030753,
0.0060496964,
0.0139045883,
-0.0086629167,
0.021168936,
0.0135206757,
-0.0161964893,
-0.0370373242,
0.0037525501,
0.0072198221,
-0.0296450928,
-0.0097515751,
0.0412908085,
0.0003660613,
0.0307138134,
0.0000021066,
-0.0272417981,
0.0274457913,
-0.003569047,
-0.0222201645,
0.0494663492,
0.0331176519,
0.0287743825,
-0.0002433302,
-0.0098679801,
0.0080969715,
-0.0139368335,
0.0582450107,
0.0189724695,
0.009845254,
0.0427990928,
-0.005876991,
0.0184254535,
0.0050470452,
-0.0623304173,
0.034091711,
-0.0666371435,
0.0129155694,
-0.0908120126,
0.0069273165,
-0.0019669686,
-0.0157655273,
0.0478052683,
0.0297198612,
0.002521283,
-0.0027294019,
0.0416532047,
-0.0640754476,
0.0043863393,
-0.0081462935,
0.0640176758,
-0.0304159373,
-0.0269445814,
0.0002689393,
-0.0137891863,
0.0002936335,
-0.0583441481,
-0.0507654399,
0.0297520775,
0.0054046414,
0.0086272471,
0.0811194703,
0.0096874824,
0.0380496308,
0.0168720391,
-0.0600361563,
0.045554094,
0.0261661764,
-0.0175048411,
-0.0139576746,
0.0028352519,
-0.0368555337,
-0.0513147153,
-0.0172082447,
0.0264650192,
-0.0187399816,
-0.001315812,
-0.0561698452,
-0.0322588719,
0.004735101,
-0.0120720277,
0.034889169,
0.0845642611,
-0.0552752391,
0.0510274805,
-0.0472580232,
-0.0095051844,
-0.0352172256,
0.0169423819,
-0.0256832,
0.006467713,
0.0432668515,
0.0222476553,
-0.027839968,
0.0262980107,
-0.0626227409,
-0.0044326135,
0.0072801001,
0.0294408109,
0.0019604207,
-0.0301564578,
-0.0341702737,
0.0084759807,
-0.0384947099,
0.0113797104,
0.0274394639,
0.0341186151,
-0.0368572064,
0.0020102169,
0.0131420596,
-0.0719376206,
-0.0698001161,
0.0452426635,
0.0125816949,
-0.0486676395,
0.009382912,
0.072837323,
-0.0036147968,
-0.0576718077,
-0.0621574298,
0.0069502019,
-0.0152378585,
-0.0410149433,
0.008398057,
-0.0683125183,
0.0151884034,
0.0076962844,
-0.0107551524,
0.0035262913,
0.0051120631,
0.0365017578,
-0.038589552,
0.0298139751,
0.0072169653,
-0.0096330838,
-0.0531976819,
-0.0025834974,
0.0243338421,
0.0877868161,
0.0013123308,
0.028912425,
-0.003473684,
0.0007511879,
-0.0446773879,
0.0508888438,
0.0635998473,
0.0336315371,
-0.0782302395,
0.0205567367,
0.0178906359,
0.0095288483,
0.0970032439,
0.0257386751,
-0.034382429,
-0.0297981184,
0.0313247703,
0.0884776264,
-0.0136172418,
0.0086910343,
0.0464395061,
-0.0144495796,
-0.0313726664,
0.0065248101,
-0.0775203183,
0.0462248102,
0.025004765,
0.0276335292,
0.0771880075,
0.0343333706,
-0.0356938392,
0.0004900031,
-0.01008844,
0.0306853857,
-0.0263371188,
0.0602850281,
0.0330372378,
-0.0197544582,
-0.0400381573,
0.0789958909,
0.0419986658,
-0.033832904,
-0.0477097295,
-0.058497183,
0.0344001241,
0.0568595715,
0.034198124,
-0.0262297336,
-0.0399941728,
-0.0074204463,
0.021306755,
0.0180912856,
0.0160498042,
0.0146318814,
0.0659010783,
-0.0222397652,
0.0051556192,
0.0018944237,
0.0278866794,
0.0121840332,
0.0282306392,
0.0242494997,
0.0202080496,
-0.0341550335,
-0.0026675267,
0.0283150189,
0.0191368964,
-0.03835636,
-0.015195773,
0.0038928459,
0.0592829138,
-0.001123767,
0.0054561244,
0.0064571784,
0.0458664969,
-0.0507884584,
0.0734091252,
-0.0215967242,
-0.0826980844,
-0.049819205,
0.0135993743,
0.0180933625,
-0.0185252447,
0.0207824428,
-0.0320085064,
-0.0325521827,
0.0171756018,
-0.015339043,
0.0514521599,
-0.0334437378,
0.0151446396,
0.0246088747,
0.0310596768,
-0.0332069062,
0.0515206009,
-0.0432511978,
0.0207666289,
0.0234822072,
-0.0014907172,
-0.0218509715,
-0.0493475236,
-0.0295151882,
-0.0047464096,
-0.0244745798,
-0.0273022484,
-0.0207063407,
-0.0081750918,
-0.0108949412,
0.0068805604,
-0.0427268296,
0.0201449171,
-0.0431503803,
0.0463574156,
0.0113491612,
0.0635497794,
0.0009972978,
-0.0202552453,
-0.0203272291,
-0.0200830158,
-0.0069136089,
0.03640927,
-0.0121343574,
0.0134622138,
-0.0336736888,
-0.0515397824,
-0.0358834118,
-0.0027986406,
0.0323444419,
-0.0407443419,
-0.0662228242,
-0.0411502756,
0.0366275422,
0.0291987918,
0.0420745388,
-0.0298315454,
-0.0060903421,
-0.0101626264,
-0.0631555766,
0.0202008784,
0.0874407068,
-0.0131144673,
0.0007539155,
0.0311462246,
-0.0220992547,
-0.0297423527,
0.0477413386,
0.0176513568,
0.0186457187,
-0.0208933838,
0.0014792577,
0.0152810784,
0.116122365,
-0.0377984941,
-0.0135905016,
-0.0332291648,
-0.0385240242,
0.032432273,
-0.01584775,
-0.031031847,
0.0392488837,
-0.0272047818,
0.0142775653,
-0.0497365743,
-0.0411181748,
0.0529791974,
-0.0504207984,
-0.0194654223,
0.0124334591,
0.0091181323,
-0.0246861205,
0.0482195839,
0.0179849807,
-0.0145452823,
-0.0222220831,
-0.0524702705,
-0.0371281877,
0.0027026914,
-0.0353235491,
-0.008955502,
0.1133041233,
-0.0158627592,
0.0225464758,
-0.0565209277,
-0.0028500371,
-0.0340524167,
-0.0251485463,
-0.0511439592,
0.0019084639,
0.0276845396,
-0.0082670562,
-0.0350078307,
0.0228410438,
0.0090609565,
0.1018164828,
-0.0082454467,
0.0213417765,
-0.0204828549,
0.0154732065,
0.0505286753,
0.0354141667,
0.0008193938,
-0.0341852903,
-0.0164339505,
0.0761781931,
0.0617417991,
0.0047783148,
-0.0016539171,
-0.0052656019,
0.0505140014,
-0.0020705492,
-0.0046396796,
0.0504831448,
0.0430925526,
-0.1115259677,
-0.009368646,
0.0750575587,
0.0030456968,
-0.0587667115,
0.0015634876,
-0.0162959788,
0.0692724884,
0.0352977738,
0.032008972,
-0.0838459879,
-0.053755492,
0.0248238239,
0.0231499765,
0.0192883089,
-0.0305013787,
0.0041292408,
-0.0796334818,
0.0214646384,
-0.0025133726,
-0.0738279894,
-0.0132713318,
-0.0196477417,
0.0310152117,
0.0157877412,
0.0069685425,
0.0544687174,
-0.0215105992,
-0.008284634,
0.008130189,
0.0258787889,
-0.0156612061,
0.0441316068,
-0.0127592403,
0.0398749039,
0.0563003682,
-0.0123471245,
0.0077812844,
-0.0437932424,
0.025403006,
-0.0477635786,
-0.0149773126,
-0.0205062162,
0.0179263037,
-0.0249208435,
-0.0222911313,
0.0078367991,
0.0353416614,
-0.0207667202,
0.0092268037,
-0.0087931985,
0.0779577494,
-0.0001864639,
0.0196033902,
-0.0067665684,
-0.0318189673,
-0.0154769104,
0.0612875037,
0.0773326531,
-0.0027437636,
-0.052136749,
-0.0165961329,
-0.0285243057,
-0.0739237443,
-0.018044427,
0.0079675699,
0.0079451799,
-0.0255876109,
-0.0116059557,
-0.011242074,
0.0492353626,
0.0425797254,
-0.0392516963,
0.0353403874,
-0.0311794151,
-0.029848963,
-0.0597594827,
0.0532290749,
-0.0559445769,
0.0177905541,
-0.0629190728,
-0.011554555,
-0.0269081499,
-0.0249819476,
0.0075082746,
0.0413593054,
-0.1293724775,
-0.0421142876,
0.0085791396,
-0.003674486,
0.0077031008,
0.0510279909,
-0.026086349,
-0.0323855653,
0.0019083157,
0.0030234018,
-0.0168091655,
0.0504807942,
0.008114187,
-0.006384145,
0.0168355741,
0.0539423935,
-0.0456795692,
-0.0039731176,
0.0311196446,
0.0408930704,
-0.0149546647,
-0.006941122,
-0.0231735315,
-0.0000696392,
0.0388862342,
-0.0142231695,
0.0188396517,
0.0040314733,
0.0579402968,
0.0190973803,
0.0075839809,
-0.037722148,
-0.0078395689,
-0.0234447774,
-0.0101034772,
0.0088321418,
-0.0031245814,
-0.0005645451,
0.0134467417,
-0.04948432,
0.0511869676,
-0.0149983186,
-0.0261186808,
0.0355883092,
0.0039733211,
-0.0295250434,
-0.0359229259,
0.0011620927,
0.0562760308,
-0.0457782149,
0.0252979863,
0.0208611898,
-0.0122594712,
-0.0180804841,
0.0007498562,
-0.0567997806,
-0.0060452982,
-0.0127550168,
0.0083869128,
0.035611853,
-0.0640075207,
0.0311363097,
0.0264251325,
-0.0068572671,
-0.0280618723,
0.0251927376,
-0.0035965405,
-0.0176296383,
0.0229368154,
0.0428049527,
0.0140062999,
0.0096932584,
0.0682363734,
0.0703167841,
0.028240636,
0.0283775032,
-0.0077360077,
-0.0152524887,
-0.0312614366,
0.001555632,
0.0293495804,
-0.0158145167,
0.0151821757,
-0.0254234131,
-0.0643725693,
0.0197601486,
-0.0306083262,
-0.0257251542,
-0.044771079,
0.0070426012,
0.0365339629,
0.0201123804,
-0.0340420939,
-0.0067185471,
0.0257571805,
0.041072011,
-0.0450559855,
-0.0154043799,
-7.121586322e-33,
-0.0232741423,
0.0023412993,
0.0000199662,
-0.0290209278,
-0.0639414564,
0.0214204751,
-0.0589995719,
-0.0308581032,
-0.0184009373,
-0.0062444787,
-0.0194959752,
0.0102693541,
0.0109256022,
0.0371350124,
-0.0026675879,
-0.0283573419,
0.029594915,
0.0140231196,
0.0022106499,
0.0266768839,
0.0131096495,
0.0281816777,
0.0657657161,
0.0058259699,
-0.0051155761,
-0.0174300298,
0.0446347073,
-0.0018592378,
-0.0092205899,
0.0349827707,
-0.0182781797,
0.0156775359,
0.0257405471,
-0.0439676531,
-0.030710429,
-0.0097230002,
-0.0912529901,
-0.0138396872,
0.0343383029,
-0.0040527661,
-0.0089150295,
-0.0411541052,
0.0251488499,
0.0406192169,
0.0510106869,
-0.0301458184,
-0.021343641,
-0.0252281483,
-0.0716707706,
-0.0101775592,
-0.0411500372,
0.0345686786,
0.0018476775,
0.0091805141,
0.0428536981,
-0.0053741559,
-0.0126688229,
0.0320708454,
-0.0247782543,
-0.0198770836,
0.0345562436,
0.0888670385,
0.0492594652,
0.0570274964,
0.0073255152,
0.0202473141,
0.0227909535,
-0.0141380122,
-0.0155735854,
0.0139964111,
0.0533618666,
0.0213854183,
-0.0117486445,
-0.0055885119,
0.0767880455,
0.0213623047,
-0.0697717071,
-0.0257029776,
0.0179441441,
0.0663226992,
0.0445167609,
0.0150906742,
-0.0339819938,
-0.0353171155,
-0.0027192193,
0.007397688,
-0.063959226,
0.0298832543,
0.0447506644,
0.0307080429,
-0.0092214094,
0.0067605665,
0.075682193,
-0.0048967525,
0.0185726825,
-0.0097114732,
0.005445112,
0.0176797435,
0.0001789918,
0.02611476,
-0.0649833307,
-0.0044285068,
0.0133033684,
-0.0166402757,
0.0089992937,
-0.0218036845,
0.0504652821,
0.0044180383,
-0.0661202893,
-0.0399334617,
-0.0369737707,
0.0223675258,
-0.0155510725,
0.0317930989,
0.0600462332,
-0.0125006875,
0.0209280271,
0.0921671763,
-0.0082116975,
-0.0301080421,
-0.0087745264,
-0.0105482852,
0.0134563036,
0.0245442856,
-0.0484612547,
0.0017476386,
-0.0395608991,
0.0169462115,
0.0014057984,
-0.0628471747,
-0.0273640677,
0.037606895,
2.826e-7,
0.019584462,
-0.023235105,
0.0170705076,
0.0106811691,
0.0150666879,
0.0041993298,
0.0321177281,
0.0150204096,
-0.0119070811,
-0.0213734359,
-0.0196052045,
0.0214588139,
0.0474010855,
0.0012445379,
-0.0897774622,
-0.0041716765,
-0.0481261872,
0.0193315018,
-0.0358559601,
-0.0454217568,
-0.0055052144,
0.1092550457,
-0.0366055593,
-0.010505138,
0.0605365969,
-0.0013959965,
0.0193239115,
0.0091887023,
0.0062985672,
-0.0113226213,
0.0042988556,
0.0066755419,
-0.0088385539,
-0.0014346982,
-0.0095534651,
0.0359625369,
-0.0252523143,
0.0819447041,
-0.015144838,
-0.0395379476,
0.0069583142,
-0.0177026801,
0.0115778334,
-0.0262814816,
0.0787067935,
-0.0311781317,
-0.0102500645,
-0.0365459286,
-0.0048470679,
0.0146494433,
-0.0690966919,
0.023130592,
0.01639078,
0.0121816974,
0.0283048209,
-0.0758038834,
-0.0345491394,
-0.0966691077,
-0.0374476202,
-0.0303567387,
-0.042077329,
-0.0430938117,
-0.0868853703,
-0.0233096797,
0.0252791829,
-0.022204766,
-0.0200627111,
3.0898544e-34,
0.0362699591,
-0.0225432087,
0.0012686277,
0.0777075887,
0.0105160605,
-0.0322499871,
-0.0042338176,
0.0090367673,
0.0217199009,
-0.0829514861,
-0.0426722877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15485v2 | SegHist: A General Segmentation-based Framework for Chinese Historical Document Text Line Detection | 2024-06-17T11:00:04 | 2024-06-25T07:37:22 | Xingjian Hu, Baole Wei, Liangcai Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Text line detection is a key task in historical document analysis facing many
challenges of arbitrary-shaped text lines, dense texts, and text lines with
high aspect ratios, etc. In this paper, we propose a general framework for
historical document text detection (SegHist), enabling existing
segmentation-based text detection methods to effectively address the
challenges, especially text lines with high aspect ratios. Integrating the
SegHist framework with the commonly used method DB++, we develop DB-SegHist.
This approach achieves SOTA on the CHDAC, MTHv2, and competitive results on
HDRC datasets, with a significant improvement of 1.19% on the most challenging
CHDAC dataset which features more text lines with high aspect ratios. Moreover,
our method attains SOTA on rotated MTHv2 and rotated HDRC, demonstrating its
rotational robustness. The code is available at
https://github.com/LumionHXJ/SegHist. | [
0.0071166079,
0.0404187962,
-0.002067961,
0.0556538142,
-0.0504178815,
0.0060070753,
0.0232795235,
0.0732580498,
0.0054962179,
0.0136624798,
0.028969178,
-0.0377455838,
0.0373975821,
0.0181006566,
-0.0581807196,
-0.0529978536,
-0.0207890421,
-0.0034625484,
0.0075988458,
0.0571735166,
0.0052638561,
-0.0384565182,
-0.0209242068,
-0.0611251518,
-0.0613813251,
-0.0029867897,
-0.0494874641,
0.0261726175,
0.0641031861,
-0.0273113921,
0.016012786,
0.0057063065,
0.0249926802,
0.0545223542,
0.0000019709,
-0.0493912771,
-0.0522734076,
-0.0017911713,
-0.0053830105,
0.0034371931,
0.091516614,
-0.0231754165,
-0.0700040609,
-0.0562115796,
0.0134231988,
0.0032176801,
0.0055406643,
0.1262719631,
-0.0043753618,
0.109146513,
-0.0295686498,
-0.0524252728,
0.0408126712,
-0.0167686082,
0.0067116325,
0.0241551958,
0.0255711488,
0.0423778072,
-0.041627869,
0.0303367823,
-0.0016123704,
0.0239668582,
0.0149778137,
-0.0383384451,
-0.0385195278,
0.0244189557,
-0.0309958979,
0.0598647781,
-0.0220706742,
0.0413752981,
-0.0320780613,
0.0122733666,
0.0422346704,
-0.0089259483,
-0.0461888835,
-0.0236252062,
-0.0242687892,
0.0157025196,
-0.0655027777,
0.0068065133,
-0.0466664657,
0.0168639626,
-0.0368081145,
-0.0193895716,
-0.0166812949,
0.0358850658,
-0.0123527832,
-0.0688080117,
-0.002935841,
-0.0189461056,
0.0186427664,
0.004841181,
0.0738085732,
0.02545649,
0.058768589,
-0.0336329974,
0.009301234,
-0.0577070042,
0.0010581192,
-0.0159968548,
-0.016745884,
0.0079682022,
0.0134469466,
0.0536007062,
-0.0533211902,
0.0525473878,
-0.0271688793,
0.0008512671,
-0.0240058675,
0.0447967947,
0.0066100061,
0.0033097577,
-0.0376640819,
-0.0577015728,
-0.0384551585,
-0.0345241688,
0.0299449749,
-0.010830977,
0.0614585094,
-0.0036056982,
-0.0115069663,
-0.0487503968,
-0.0298956539,
-0.0220509637,
0.0319179781,
0.0009192007,
-0.0097519448,
-0.0072014206,
-0.0286693219,
0.0080709616,
0.0183418822,
0.0193077028,
0.0721600056,
-0.0046985871,
0.020136239,
-0.023045022,
-0.0528330505,
-0.0410869159,
-0.0471293144,
-0.0086097037,
-0.0526418239,
-0.0398749448,
0.0313533731,
-0.0168388039,
-0.0155319041,
-0.0560522377,
0.0273855943,
0.0719770715,
0.0049329447,
-0.0088534113,
0.0049283709,
0.0264615379,
0.0013682627,
-0.0021420699,
0.0251338314,
0.0281801596,
0.0093986737,
0.04958269,
0.0124853104,
0.0874494612,
0.0797012076,
0.0407645889,
0.0112533392,
0.0227664188,
-0.0342121795,
-0.0134525849,
-0.0249643438,
-0.0014684675,
-0.0177440066,
-0.0019827206,
0.007880453,
0.0130048683,
-0.0093995351,
0.0000733606,
0.0414776988,
0.0305365678,
0.0212510973,
0.0058629666,
-0.0170995779,
0.0279918853,
-0.0034669996,
0.0536822602,
0.0116785485,
-0.0241766032,
-0.0000848081,
0.0190205798,
-0.0390198492,
0.0186775178,
0.0074135098,
-0.0210403223,
0.0040208488,
0.0204840153,
-0.0183039717,
-0.0557316765,
0.0819586962,
-0.0225271862,
-0.02916345,
-0.0431037545,
-0.0016333673,
-0.0765550286,
-0.0340857618,
-0.002267149,
0.0476792306,
0.0417290814,
0.0763862431,
-0.078131035,
0.0345609523,
0.0195689816,
0.0360330828,
0.0194406584,
0.0313012153,
-0.0092663011,
0.0044352929,
-0.0422757939,
-0.0445877276,
0.0503034256,
0.004842266,
-0.0044075958,
0.0220813695,
0.0613626093,
-0.0151071241,
-0.0141443685,
0.0048111933,
0.0471983589,
0.0199329667,
0.0158190988,
-0.026728224,
0.0505421571,
-0.0182886049,
0.0345045589,
-0.0453860313,
-0.029314287,
0.060516227,
-0.0226094276,
0.0059564454,
-0.0367885046,
-0.022556711,
-0.0420227088,
0.0158206206,
-0.0336438715,
-0.0187519826,
-0.0336640403,
-0.0321560465,
-0.0201619025,
-0.0167539287,
0.0158270374,
-0.0245374944,
-0.0191130079,
0.0434315763,
-0.0438809805,
0.0223469958,
-0.0342241302,
0.0692409053,
-0.015148988,
-0.0011618948,
-0.006722027,
-0.0330937281,
0.0223898273,
-0.0163669046,
-0.0238133222,
-0.0120192347,
-0.0106081385,
0.0204374008,
0.0162672363,
0.0360618867,
-0.0187130682,
-0.0483998396,
-0.0469080433,
0.0049399189,
-0.0567907207,
0.0084430417,
0.0217323359,
-0.0186642073,
-0.0122595578,
-0.0408272333,
-0.012692946,
-0.0254347846,
-0.0407952406,
-0.0377288163,
0.0485593677,
-0.0329036564,
-0.0031751092,
0.0101024723,
-0.0060951961,
-0.0018270899,
-0.0270528737,
0.0305712707,
-0.0452147871,
-0.0222398303,
-0.0410468988,
0.0529322289,
0.0203730315,
-0.0316593759,
0.0012279708,
-0.036124438,
-0.0208705105,
0.0315208994,
0.1358100772,
0.0240966324,
-0.0282928012,
-0.0236716866,
0.0218305476,
0.0333123952,
0.0397395827,
-0.021567082,
0.0797588676,
0.003681069,
-0.0432842895,
0.041401688,
0.0116891973,
-0.0038456982,
0.0436604582,
0.0419678278,
-0.089032039,
-0.0270964298,
0.0398593806,
-0.0082520256,
-0.0110219456,
-0.05001086,
0.0078352345,
-0.0206792876,
-0.0023052134,
-0.0090548573,
-0.0460315496,
-0.0580935106,
-0.0491512716,
0.0031756498,
-0.0474942774,
0.0292810053,
0.0389703214,
-0.0028628292,
0.0088952128,
-0.0400843918,
0.0104675675,
0.0340834744,
0.0159924012,
-0.0105881561,
0.0087469444,
0.0075812885,
-0.0012437535,
-0.0362550505,
0.0060713231,
-0.0116430307,
0.0007770958,
0.0051114531,
-0.0333937481,
0.0447612591,
-0.0517975725,
-0.0025005494,
0.0769849569,
-0.0146238506,
0.0878515318,
-0.0063956962,
0.0018140728,
-0.0472042263,
0.0804036111,
0.0155527182,
-0.0694324896,
-0.0079784179,
-0.016446868,
0.0129770711,
0.0608591363,
-0.0056729084,
-0.0212630872,
0.0294544231,
0.001393993,
-0.0081236707,
-0.0064448402,
0.0251901466,
-0.048893258,
0.0344090946,
-0.0640498549,
-0.0052611995,
0.0645345077,
0.0275727399,
-0.0492675379,
-0.0607716851,
-0.0210161284,
-0.0080835493,
-0.0314178951,
-0.0599847771,
-0.045795396,
0.0071097566,
0.0142242936,
-0.0226416308,
0.0095895445,
0.0090068821,
0.0213301852,
0.0208277497,
0.0402416848,
0.0069785691,
-0.0157965999,
-0.0121470625,
-0.027265748,
0.0409266241,
-0.0216399319,
-0.0367577523,
0.0162999351,
-0.0302026998,
-0.0454540774,
-0.0352296457,
-0.0354546346,
0.0595181659,
-0.0033914249,
-0.0095229978,
-0.0927769914,
0.0359837115,
0.0695897788,
0.0366711691,
-0.0081181023,
0.0724111125,
-0.0207519587,
0.0125408145,
-0.0082436306,
0.098499693,
0.0218810551,
0.0315822922,
-0.0071704909,
0.0284756478,
0.0101066334,
0.0314294398,
0.0455989875,
-0.0091777612,
0.0302130096,
-0.0216533467,
-0.0103003979,
-0.0108540161,
-0.0139262062,
0.0056227311,
-0.0065911766,
-0.0110182203,
-0.0616275519,
-0.022366235,
0.0355372801,
-0.0546740927,
-0.0017788114,
-0.0237198919,
-0.06066994,
-0.0482884832,
-0.0513023064,
0.0105250087,
-0.0291327871,
0.0388854109,
0.0316127278,
-0.0171829388,
0.0198528059,
-0.0019362052,
-0.0450481474,
-0.0523669943,
-0.0475707427,
-0.0038054171,
-0.082546629,
0.0435762107,
-0.0224155951,
-0.0393634215,
0.0087557053,
-0.026426265,
-0.0927640274,
-0.0003132555,
0.0261892676,
-0.048857253,
-0.0015049676,
0.0097185858,
-0.0366718024,
0.0264161825,
0.0456959121,
-0.0100832218,
0.0048329099,
-0.0651422963,
-0.030737089,
-0.0269040298,
-0.039382074,
0.0190553106,
0.0256647337,
0.0010460896,
0.0195765328,
-0.0756321996,
-0.034203086,
-0.0170342624,
-0.0404075943,
0.0100504812,
0.0543822423,
0.0297546368,
0.0012958688,
-0.0062922407,
0.0281252712,
-0.0130276447,
-0.0110151526,
0.0200958084,
0.0222786702,
-0.0140693774,
0.0067140111,
-0.0143052172,
0.059326604,
0.0355839133,
0.0246890113,
-0.0375693068,
0.0169731639,
0.037973173,
0.0551412068,
0.0218593646,
-0.0156644471,
0.0690967441,
0.0207690205,
-0.0133306468,
0.0532965511,
0.0029483773,
0.1022128612,
0.0090806959,
-0.0333035849,
0.0101537993,
-0.0045626229,
-0.0713725612,
0.0484766811,
-0.0624498315,
0.00789678,
0.0751049519,
-0.0283295531,
0.056200549,
-0.0352947637,
-0.0180807151,
-0.0228411704,
0.0029714848,
0.0695830509,
-0.0129814399,
-0.04492075,
0.0136907483,
-0.0197424237,
0.0320229344,
0.0102219265,
-0.0165798273,
-0.0053593325,
0.0635934845,
-0.078393355,
-0.0351079218,
0.0202341545,
0.0542372502,
-0.0276304372,
-0.0330520123,
0.0222464092,
0.0147135211,
0.0564625114,
0.0376158021,
0.000187476,
-0.0048641707,
0.0601490848,
-0.0255907774,
0.0030485799,
-0.0136779873,
-0.0133736916,
-0.0177716091,
0.0336571895,
0.0134041663,
-0.0116529223,
-0.0002266775,
-5.842815977e-33,
0.0282113403,
-0.0256310478,
-0.0232136231,
-0.0436574854,
-0.0478025302,
0.0139673119,
-0.0070386892,
-0.0192815233,
-0.0049159219,
-0.0056936406,
-0.0205039382,
0.0071888561,
0.0403842703,
0.0090970742,
-0.044092495,
0.0140526304,
0.0461376384,
-0.0188478623,
-0.0393762849,
0.0203920789,
0.0316202827,
0.0187934171,
0.0526000299,
-0.025895806,
0.0027378311,
-0.002218741,
0.0027247367,
0.011436888,
0.0008627351,
-0.0041198223,
0.0005212605,
-0.0558253713,
0.0422460921,
0.0193589628,
-0.0002433031,
0.020360373,
-0.0985929817,
0.0325088203,
-0.0620850697,
0.1073186398,
0.050965488,
0.0040002987,
-0.0165433083,
-0.0462219343,
0.0246280972,
-0.025097454,
0.0386251137,
-0.0526891723,
-0.0184286237,
-0.0272670146,
-0.0182238482,
0.0608198792,
-0.0141110588,
-0.0078315204,
0.0389359519,
-0.0115476707,
0.0342415385,
0.0092447177,
-0.0468196757,
0.0109785842,
0.0229045469,
0.0250170007,
-0.0309324581,
0.0189272948,
-0.0027453103,
0.0059051616,
0.0221647583,
-0.0258708373,
0.0053653084,
0.007244051,
-0.0080710026,
-0.0322421454,
-0.0246918984,
0.0063059274,
0.0547984317,
-0.0223306064,
-0.005241714,
0.0323320813,
0.0178175252,
0.0180380121,
0.0260910671,
0.0453250445,
-0.0869371369,
0.038256079,
0.0551372916,
-0.0393533483,
-0.0111835953,
0.006966833,
-0.0062171686,
0.0759364292,
-0.0148738967,
0.0073485696,
0.0200513136,
0.006651408,
0.0230668522,
-0.0039576227,
-0.0486115664,
0.0327377133,
-0.0169612523,
-0.065852575,
-0.0229662322,
-0.0213652421,
0.0481557734,
0.027062336,
-0.0228888784,
-0.031704586,
0.0638256595,
0.0055343658,
-0.0465823561,
0.0094737187,
0.0257571731,
-0.0150821507,
0.0775294453,
0.0910605863,
-0.0268145036,
-0.0512179844,
0.0166157503,
0.0854787901,
0.0411307588,
0.0012062335,
-0.0382729471,
0.0078889942,
-0.0175491832,
0.0048191412,
-0.0230699033,
0.033191599,
0.0159018729,
-0.0264991429,
-0.0032097681,
-0.0448730104,
0.0010258965,
-0.0151840411,
2.421e-7,
0.01956187,
-0.0126651796,
0.0701067597,
-0.0040427269,
0.0354313105,
0.0060508014,
-0.0573526993,
-0.0235079527,
-0.0538885891,
0.068723239,
0.0371469036,
-0.0263579134,
0.0710435286,
-0.0177191719,
-0.0360845849,
0.006799839,
-0.0018848919,
-0.0485156365,
-0.0645757243,
0.0009610354,
0.0250345096,
0.0315346457,
-0.0349712446,
-0.0069296071,
0.0135816699,
-0.049458921,
-0.020539308,
0.0104904901,
0.0192769151,
0.0430837497,
0.0136454646,
-0.0138065191,
-0.0677455962,
-0.0001361856,
0.013658125,
0.0396527126,
0.0296828318,
0.0739959478,
0.0200855918,
0.0563085563,
0.0239413213,
-0.0019476494,
-0.00074518,
-0.0243655164,
0.0575276054,
0.0931337401,
0.0289772004,
-0.0108297961,
-0.0010521491,
0.0135695925,
0.0113720838,
0.0127561213,
0.0050059087,
0.0449488498,
0.0188181791,
0.0028733294,
0.0184595212,
-0.0331547931,
-0.0098825628,
-0.0284399856,
-0.0041602701,
-0.0233826451,
-0.0022365656,
0.033264935,
-0.0255935621,
-0.0087621063,
-0.0202526655,
2.451020975e-34,
0.0165174436,
-0.0048611131,
-0.0530056134,
0.0071847057,
0.0465658009,
-0.0196280219,
0.0459104031,
-0.0723926201,
-0.0610033385,
-0.0268022101,
0.0091010034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11410v2 | HARE: HumAn pRiors, a key to small language model Efficiency | 2024-06-17T10:56:03 | 2024-06-18T11:59:03 | Lingyun Zhang, Bin jin, Gaojian Ge, Lunhui Liu, Xuewen Shen, Mingyong Wu, Houqian Zhang, Yongneng Jiang, Shiqi Chen, Shi Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Human priors play a crucial role in efficiently utilizing data in deep
learning. However, with the development of large language models (LLMs), there
is an increasing emphasis on scaling both model size and data volume, which
often diminishes the importance of human priors in data construction.
Influenced by these trends, existing Small Language Models (SLMs) mainly rely
on web-scraped large-scale training data, neglecting the proper incorporation
of human priors. This oversight limits the training efficiency of language
models in resource-constrained settings. In this paper, we propose a principle
to leverage human priors for data construction. This principle emphasizes
achieving high-performance SLMs by training on a concise dataset that
accommodates both semantic diversity and data quality consistency, while
avoiding benchmark data leakage. Following this principle, we train an SLM
named HARE-1.1B. Extensive experiments on large-scale benchmark datasets
demonstrate that HARE-1.1B performs favorably against state-of-the-art SLMs,
validating the effectiveness of the proposed principle. Additionally, this
provides new insights into efficient language model training in
resource-constrained environments from the view of human priors. | [
0.0326021388,
0.1252130419,
-0.0003040343,
0.0612471662,
-0.0064956159,
0.0031678861,
0.0073549976,
-0.0015182246,
-0.0403278843,
-0.0469696112,
-0.0633771718,
-0.0648246855,
0.0180145744,
-0.0066948445,
0.0237848181,
-0.0466739163,
0.0136743961,
-0.0405747443,
-0.0213045757,
-0.0369632766,
-0.0150566511,
0.0138899144,
0.0261991508,
0.033535827,
-0.0171442889,
-0.002729008,
0.0022920144,
0.0292698964,
-0.0059458562,
-0.0248709023,
0.0085110888,
0.0610036142,
0.0215662289,
0.0284089558,
0.0000020103,
-0.0296623297,
0.0027163427,
0.0103608603,
-0.0216449201,
0.0236312039,
0.0700726062,
-0.0259000082,
-0.0164961778,
0.0102596181,
-0.002736866,
-0.0395025313,
0.071348235,
0.0326612853,
0.0479953215,
0.0827662349,
-0.0065299352,
-0.0108612962,
0.0185656361,
-0.0566168316,
-0.0096463608,
-0.044115603,
0.028995771,
-0.0153678181,
-0.0208338294,
0.0237337127,
-0.0075234435,
0.0062990212,
0.0069907978,
0.0326187275,
-0.0282099079,
0.0443969741,
-0.0007508922,
-0.0274203308,
0.0216842424,
0.0876859576,
-0.0281017236,
-0.0137566971,
-0.0063657206,
-0.0226432383,
-0.0036291759,
0.0084275883,
-0.0367868058,
0.0560230091,
0.0262511596,
0.0429667942,
0.0000449261,
-0.0191591736,
0.0633637011,
0.0507625267,
-0.0109110549,
0.0462962128,
0.0153271155,
-0.0001607642,
0.0034690222,
0.0023513366,
-0.0068450333,
-0.0346531309,
-0.021928329,
0.0197185017,
0.0018046764,
0.0327967852,
-0.0648002923,
-0.0452499017,
0.0492557697,
-0.0527407862,
0.037770126,
0.0103364196,
-0.0359566361,
0.0355738625,
-0.0221335497,
-0.0020753557,
-0.0111825876,
0.0222329088,
-0.0416634306,
-0.0281998646,
-0.0070911688,
0.0264301375,
-0.0110641969,
0.0100388164,
-0.0423695855,
-0.003267321,
-0.0084964121,
0.0193455555,
-0.0222928133,
-0.0071562841,
0.0213187635,
0.0224962924,
-0.045065362,
-0.0225987043,
-0.0174722336,
0.0065311179,
-0.0257800017,
0.0462995991,
-0.0079825222,
-0.0917019993,
-0.021751117,
0.0069865398,
0.0164486319,
-0.0261580907,
0.0331193283,
0.0745716691,
-0.0030547515,
-0.0159767177,
-0.0556672029,
0.0053682383,
-0.0190719217,
-0.0551825501,
-0.0173014104,
-0.0843326449,
0.0345356762,
0.0006318257,
0.0101416167,
-0.0833867043,
0.0228786469,
0.0388927385,
-0.0666966513,
0.0543047599,
-0.0581169985,
0.0097723836,
0.0111706164,
-0.0040231124,
0.0145680811,
0.1111954823,
0.0472990163,
0.0387716405,
0.0191284399,
-0.0105423564,
-0.048275236,
0.02636135,
0.039493259,
0.0219640415,
-0.0265883263,
-0.0004669995,
-0.0029163559,
0.0233666953,
0.0540635325,
0.0851890445,
-0.0196055081,
-0.0328866355,
0.0786650777,
0.0565725602,
-0.0241855159,
0.0372853018,
0.0082535688,
0.028036274,
0.0011873448,
-0.0412915722,
-0.054150667,
-0.0145698879,
0.0111843143,
-0.0117261037,
0.0217472687,
0.0359814391,
-0.0171015114,
-0.0281234849,
-0.0358190984,
-0.0089534484,
-0.0027108165,
0.0228221975,
0.0455577746,
0.0188755933,
0.0251574647,
0.0937554762,
0.0871317014,
-0.0122859096,
0.0168466568,
-0.0253536925,
0.0034077903,
0.0322872326,
0.0000168103,
-0.0075465036,
-0.0070951823,
-0.0175897926,
0.047743272,
0.027299352,
0.0618718788,
-0.008631452,
0.0387761444,
-0.0465332456,
-0.0132140052,
0.0036592132,
0.019010473,
0.0314719863,
0.0169096068,
-0.001676104,
0.0360730886,
-0.0542079546,
-0.0531438626,
0.0572195277,
-0.0281272195,
-0.0211760085,
0.0442450196,
-0.003555252,
0.0371390395,
-0.008594214,
-0.0185870137,
0.00263518,
0.0329415984,
-0.014087406,
0.0014580853,
-0.0394242331,
-0.0334191099,
0.0002255212,
0.0483160131,
-0.0123566296,
0.0121181784,
0.0553341545,
-0.0454955213,
-0.0298934765,
0.0181431826,
-0.0235194582,
0.0134662809,
-0.0482648313,
0.0054701963,
-0.0002905541,
0.061257869,
-0.0244399197,
0.0668890476,
-0.0255823005,
0.0065206159,
0.0217266288,
0.0250579957,
0.0124904159,
-0.049828425,
-0.014364724,
0.0151261436,
-0.0273559168,
0.046002727,
0.0054716738,
0.0337478742,
-0.02457661,
0.0197949093,
-0.0750427991,
-0.0102809537,
-0.039429456,
0.0092911497,
-0.0039012588,
-0.0035040898,
-0.0016258036,
-0.0240780339,
-0.0365221687,
-0.0184256844,
-0.0351561718,
0.0369435921,
0.0237379,
0.0286996663,
0.0006637515,
-0.034879826,
-0.0258801393,
0.0264174342,
0.0357158706,
-0.0172824711,
0.0300264563,
-0.0466161296,
0.0189283043,
-0.0276972912,
0.0152209252,
-0.0055577867,
-0.0257285908,
-0.0185467489,
-0.029843796,
0.0162093639,
0.0062001674,
0.0076235873,
0.0063558966,
0.0766941383,
0.0394886099,
-0.0583726317,
0.0031194536,
-0.009566878,
-0.010322284,
-0.0526279099,
-0.048376441,
-0.0324127674,
0.0376636349,
-0.024454806,
-0.0010649135,
-0.0376966633,
0.0243079141,
-0.0000905073,
-0.0411507227,
-0.0540570281,
0.0223816279,
-0.0318934619,
0.0236156713,
-0.0367344581,
-0.0511488356,
0.0407020487,
-0.0279230438,
0.0029381148,
-0.0068562655,
-0.0260684099,
-0.0305566546,
0.0497650579,
0.0202665627,
0.0306190662,
-0.0183538739,
-0.0015346501,
-0.0655319244,
0.0251010545,
0.0242462438,
-0.0138054369,
0.0527793355,
-0.0475182459,
0.0233307444,
-0.0376963392,
-0.0462086909,
-0.0602177866,
-0.0621308163,
-0.0395716727,
0.0129511794,
0.0298702177,
-0.018903153,
-0.01086812,
-0.0082781231,
-0.0039672866,
0.0409500599,
0.0043184925,
0.0187650267,
0.013825302,
0.0020791565,
0.0666333586,
-0.0015685501,
0.0497057736,
-0.0367069654,
-0.011856894,
0.0569632351,
0.073095426,
-0.0145203313,
-0.0240602419,
-0.0055134832,
0.0313148052,
0.0199522357,
-0.0118156699,
0.0454245433,
0.0301806964,
-0.0435809679,
-0.0160695463,
0.0908714533,
-0.0286508575,
-0.0702302307,
0.0225696769,
0.0167329609,
0.0633612648,
0.0078285784,
0.0023111631,
-0.0481082946,
-0.0518037528,
0.0195499994,
0.0261580292,
0.0213506725,
-0.0382031314,
-0.0285723414,
-0.0988739356,
0.0153438505,
0.0043182336,
-0.047052905,
0.0265539233,
-0.0700558648,
0.014222418,
-0.0642324761,
0.0309218932,
-0.0097645083,
-0.028468553,
-0.0237750839,
0.0388044305,
-0.0133677302,
-0.1055996865,
0.0036105504,
-0.0432219952,
0.0532588102,
-0.0009267275,
0.004220644,
-0.0323112942,
-0.0301955715,
0.0424614064,
-0.0114582004,
-0.0244695731,
-0.0031799835,
0.0584567487,
-0.0324648172,
-0.0144060263,
0.0537247099,
0.0420033559,
-0.0631565526,
-0.0072041024,
-0.0114856604,
0.0534151942,
0.0043969508,
-0.0124072172,
0.004345479,
-0.043879129,
0.0162672456,
0.0887262449,
0.0127577139,
-0.040170148,
0.0081644552,
-0.0106189437,
-0.015104088,
-0.0194794573,
-0.0309694074,
0.0187813286,
-0.0114063835,
-0.0656712875,
-0.0517245643,
-0.0417286716,
0.0079942141,
0.0259303953,
0.0012687721,
0.0006256612,
-0.0131485201,
0.0241678134,
-0.0534154251,
0.0683205202,
-0.0567789525,
0.0034626375,
-0.0654654652,
-0.0335596539,
0.0209190585,
-0.0210965667,
-0.0237208754,
0.0050560851,
-0.1617484242,
-0.0562950224,
0.0225435682,
0.0282799192,
0.0168106314,
0.042334266,
0.016708428,
-0.0807350203,
0.0502704196,
0.0413019769,
-0.0450122803,
-0.0228764452,
0.0496287905,
-0.039092008,
-0.0013639372,
0.060988389,
-0.0617932715,
0.0481199175,
0.0390699804,
0.0290127918,
-0.0274247918,
-0.0041608727,
0.0147543764,
0.0059328671,
0.0423054732,
-0.0485919453,
-0.0248721112,
-0.0385285169,
0.0060054623,
-0.0091403695,
-0.0201799627,
-0.0455743372,
-0.0019777766,
0.0199719369,
0.0061029047,
-0.0170260742,
-0.0034091263,
0.0259560626,
0.017353639,
-0.0051218942,
-0.0005153581,
0.0390097089,
0.0210208464,
0.0528014936,
0.0153541015,
-0.0272238888,
0.0328581259,
-0.0166968405,
0.0384084284,
-0.0211867206,
-0.0251231547,
0.0205508247,
-0.0061927773,
-0.0277587138,
0.0010911694,
-0.055826176,
-0.0785821229,
-0.0523935035,
-0.0127869667,
0.0559770353,
-0.0161255002,
0.0377665684,
-0.0363562405,
-0.0123943612,
-0.043588385,
0.0010024401,
-0.0130333202,
-0.0289548505,
0.0209901389,
0.0184027236,
-0.0359726027,
0.0335848182,
0.1034489125,
0.0446254164,
0.033324413,
-0.0244788695,
0.012967323,
-0.0338410288,
-0.0288173687,
-0.010409154,
0.0364858657,
-0.015171825,
0.0037400899,
-0.036904294,
-0.0916384682,
-0.03790861,
-0.0339391977,
0.0077087563,
0.000340153,
0.0490547754,
0.053076718,
-0.0119161978,
0.0202312004,
-0.0373028405,
-0.0032994372,
0.0152936019,
-0.0093043623,
-0.0323141478,
-6.812725916e-33,
0.0253622457,
0.0072398172,
-0.0088421544,
-0.0484594889,
0.0263167676,
0.0061492813,
-0.0016911356,
0.0098994952,
-0.0633829162,
0.0289696474,
-0.0172553733,
0.008461671,
0.0193934906,
0.0614853762,
-0.0023753417,
-0.00828001,
0.0670637339,
-0.0130141042,
-0.0073386747,
0.0159933046,
0.0280691478,
0.0329027809,
0.050443165,
-0.0200298708,
-0.005214544,
-0.0082231276,
-0.0224611759,
0.0315834507,
0.0349524803,
0.0465577208,
-0.0255780146,
0.0650104061,
0.0276166555,
-0.0098629706,
-0.0309867971,
-0.0205727648,
-0.0825068876,
-0.0160403959,
-0.0086229406,
0.0111860447,
-0.0282167979,
-0.007589052,
0.0589371361,
-0.0032447532,
0.0171791222,
-0.0196012855,
0.026688613,
-0.0430121943,
-0.0555300862,
0.0289477929,
-0.0251102578,
0.0374226086,
0.0124007454,
0.009852197,
0.0299894921,
0.0088792844,
-0.0173768643,
-0.0145131154,
-0.0365536101,
0.0070962026,
0.0220460966,
0.024392426,
0.0532197133,
0.056859646,
-0.0022108827,
0.0819827542,
0.0494127274,
0.0340860896,
0.0068811621,
-0.0179243889,
0.0473128222,
0.0456535332,
0.0185794961,
0.0617193021,
0.0320766047,
-0.0208398644,
-0.0808763057,
0.0026218044,
0.0100634182,
0.0256300569,
0.0227661561,
0.0087982304,
-0.0328585505,
-0.0398992337,
-0.0421492867,
-0.0131387571,
-0.0270042531,
-0.005394828,
0.0134639293,
0.0299029015,
-0.0290624686,
0.0056630415,
0.0322528481,
-0.0490393899,
-0.0280665252,
0.0438565761,
0.0155977774,
-0.0249601901,
0.0219305102,
0.0055377721,
-0.0789728463,
-0.0224597827,
0.0072173276,
-0.0073519512,
0.0084994528,
0.0023989216,
0.0558221042,
0.0119970283,
-0.060636837,
-0.0157556497,
-0.0472155549,
0.0112081775,
0.0125796311,
0.0383029506,
0.0507827662,
-0.0209947992,
-0.0022381349,
0.0824735612,
0.026291687,
0.0033428404,
-0.0158263389,
-0.0250865035,
0.0022786094,
0.0024727096,
-0.0204949398,
-0.0053965077,
-0.0196969435,
-0.0212265085,
0.0811373964,
-0.0495373905,
-0.0192891713,
-0.0118829701,
2.627e-7,
0.0299245361,
0.0181391984,
-0.0169806294,
0.0159546193,
0.0103720259,
0.0352406725,
-0.019621538,
0.0282636397,
-0.034161374,
-0.0035673338,
0.0088883927,
0.0396779813,
0.0770558938,
0.042118419,
-0.0707593709,
-0.0282330904,
-0.0858246833,
0.0121503165,
-0.0066093653,
-0.0084608262,
0.0052827816,
0.1447629184,
0.0207189918,
-0.0592224635,
0.0198799074,
-0.0231175628,
0.064892441,
-0.0675789937,
0.0058497228,
0.0293619595,
0.0213505719,
0.0567242168,
0.0016184649,
-0.0022158327,
-0.0287939869,
0.0112493085,
-0.0064034066,
0.0540620685,
-0.0039258171,
0.0123696858,
-0.0175782498,
-0.0256867167,
-0.0061620022,
-0.0331492685,
0.0611913502,
-0.0185406953,
-0.0253912695,
-0.0365279168,
-0.0193021502,
-0.0068873689,
-0.0105814785,
-0.0232251901,
-0.02780178,
0.0167550948,
0.0185692217,
-0.0130506009,
-0.034466695,
-0.0763119161,
-0.0185118541,
0.005674317,
-0.0555793792,
-0.0409829691,
-0.0166004226,
-0.0454499014,
0.0588877723,
-0.0487197116,
0.0252043214,
2.327435422e-34,
0.0499780029,
-0.0147760715,
-0.0272900034,
0.0112745538,
0.0147701912,
-0.0069595496,
0.0381574295,
-0.0068096216,
-0.002206146,
-0.0582783669,
-0.0247883648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11409v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11409v2 | CodeGemma: Open Code Models Based on Gemma | 2024-06-17T10:54:35 | 2024-06-19T02:37:50 | CodeGemma Team, Heri Zhao, Jeffrey Hui, Joshua Howland, Nam Nguyen, Siqi Zuo, Andrea Hu, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jingyue Shen, Joe Kelley, Kshitij Bansal, Luke Vilnis, Mateo Wirth, Paul Michel, Peter Choy, Pratik Joshi, Ravin Kumar, Sarmad Hashmi, Shubham Agrawal, Zhitao Gong, Jane Fine, Tris Warkentin, Ale Jakse Hartman, Bin Ni, Kathy Korevec, Kelly Schaefer, Scott Huffman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces CodeGemma, a collection of specialized open code models
built on top of Gemma, capable of a variety of code and natural language
generation tasks. We release three model variants. CodeGemma 7B pretrained (PT)
and instruction-tuned (IT) variants have remarkably resilient natural language
understanding, excel in mathematical reasoning, and match code capabilities of
other open models. CodeGemma 2B is a state-of-the-art code completion model
designed for fast code infilling and open-ended generation in latency-sensitive
settings. | [
0.005740134,
0.1073596403,
-0.0037790418,
0.006271719,
-0.0142814983,
0.0018447068,
-0.041490864,
-0.0247806385,
0.0026060028,
0.006548143,
-0.0096430881,
0.0220612194,
-0.0271238629,
0.1192241088,
0.0206066128,
0.0043888367,
0.0344533212,
-0.0347998627,
-0.0431867391,
0.0053814785,
-0.0055282083,
0.0305182636,
0.008547239,
0.0600980818,
0.0182523578,
-0.0433673821,
-0.0385923982,
0.010596728,
-0.0191332176,
-0.0189251024,
0.037977729,
0.0515457354,
0.0071562626,
-0.0153539935,
0.0000020628,
-0.0214267392,
-0.0085116504,
0.0056998222,
-0.0100634638,
0.0195508637,
0.0031386816,
-0.0203860439,
0.0008071592,
0.0337627977,
-0.0647933707,
0.005261742,
0.0625839382,
-0.0384513438,
0.0656391531,
0.0655921325,
0.0003622693,
-0.0403134786,
0.040364027,
-0.0280095171,
0.023586385,
-0.0437147655,
-0.006782426,
0.03403043,
0.0460372418,
-0.0096730441,
0.0064837257,
0.0191325229,
0.0412298217,
-0.0177475382,
0.0164232515,
0.0425472669,
0.0098389946,
0.0005493489,
-0.0248074736,
0.0451627709,
-0.0205685943,
-0.0241383556,
0.0148877045,
-0.0157675296,
-0.0189383589,
-0.0782517865,
-0.0389596671,
0.0605642684,
-0.0140759377,
0.0175473243,
0.0110443886,
-0.0076756091,
0.0035525996,
0.0056098765,
-0.0174875539,
0.0603810959,
0.0349955708,
0.0038053249,
-0.0643987507,
-0.0052011129,
-0.053514272,
-0.0715341568,
0.0104707154,
0.0784392282,
-0.0157910157,
-0.0028769849,
-0.0879952163,
-0.0149302958,
0.0069967541,
-0.0374170132,
0.0504244417,
0.0753537416,
-0.0194968898,
0.0017072151,
-0.0389857255,
0.01806584,
-0.0267665014,
0.0051671127,
-0.0192354247,
0.0215631779,
-0.0508736596,
-0.0047552641,
-0.0584899299,
0.0444210321,
-0.0535704009,
-0.0073574404,
-0.023708187,
0.08284159,
0.0211538952,
0.014316882,
0.0339122303,
0.0462294742,
-0.0343001559,
-0.0054714326,
0.0090723,
-0.0400050953,
-0.0119373426,
-0.0503495298,
0.0261005331,
-0.080288589,
-0.0106523205,
0.0230962019,
-0.0120515963,
-0.0132979136,
0.0241505038,
0.0571057014,
0.0004994283,
-0.0101251034,
-0.04892819,
-0.0510209315,
0.0079128994,
-0.0802736729,
-0.0051371362,
-0.0731297806,
-0.0373469256,
0.0311912689,
-0.0179471858,
-0.0860919505,
0.0240903124,
0.0403274968,
0.0112314606,
0.0146847609,
-0.0756686106,
-0.0247861203,
0.0045859609,
-0.0185872391,
0.0111589003,
0.0194651,
0.0276702326,
-0.0191830713,
-0.0307892002,
-0.0149831912,
0.0092790667,
0.011428169,
0.0111208195,
-0.0231571253,
0.0095985597,
0.027253693,
0.0518171526,
0.022563491,
0.0534778833,
0.0514359251,
-0.0135440528,
-0.0030059067,
0.0167435613,
-0.0117242401,
0.0141484179,
0.0610570349,
0.0888924375,
0.0035503388,
0.0011744265,
-0.0066539417,
-0.0336659625,
0.0652591139,
-0.0160552263,
0.0398883596,
0.0115990043,
0.0293319765,
-0.014912528,
-0.0716267377,
0.009824967,
-0.0274032708,
0.0327982418,
-0.0430979468,
0.0169368554,
0.0095844418,
-0.0706517771,
-0.0008554857,
0.0057869726,
-0.0567675233,
-0.030459499,
-0.0489638671,
0.0199179109,
0.0366992839,
0.0493752584,
-0.020881502,
-0.0390320048,
-0.0183783416,
-0.0114804544,
0.0214088261,
0.006924781,
0.0235877726,
-0.0179731045,
-0.0472548977,
0.0102391085,
-0.0451264828,
0.0022616906,
0.0387738831,
0.0367877036,
-0.0227867961,
0.0294966046,
0.0579448901,
-0.0760912076,
0.045297686,
0.0028452033,
-0.0183978602,
0.0016641737,
-0.0288505349,
0.0469401591,
-0.0422046594,
-0.0354970209,
0.0450960882,
0.0152213853,
-0.0171863008,
-0.0182423871,
-0.0145661039,
-0.0499378368,
-0.0305180326,
0.0167159233,
-0.0251612011,
-0.0058818134,
0.0444214568,
-0.0098495288,
-0.0307453834,
0.0601786114,
-0.0464629568,
0.033045128,
-0.0707389712,
0.0101828137,
0.039135661,
-0.0150427287,
0.0004675623,
0.0503293052,
-0.023371283,
-0.0028996684,
0.0274302717,
0.0427719355,
0.0134524871,
-0.0036173295,
-0.0108013321,
0.010206555,
-0.035415452,
0.0369265676,
-0.0201232303,
0.0512756407,
-0.0056220549,
-0.0473303422,
-0.0924027711,
0.0455996916,
-0.0284163151,
-0.0001737294,
0.0178727489,
0.0239073429,
-0.0076106084,
0.0047638039,
-0.040446762,
0.0162788834,
0.0315948166,
-0.0131925615,
0.014272023,
0.0137683321,
-0.0500446036,
-0.0284749847,
0.011381682,
-0.0109752053,
0.0457695648,
0.0215304643,
0.0210177172,
-0.0515869968,
0.0520383343,
-0.0379657112,
0.0421909764,
0.0071765152,
-0.0417353213,
0.027600307,
-0.036123611,
0.0416064858,
0.0024240911,
-0.0070155049,
-0.0101516061,
0.0234045666,
-0.0107068662,
-0.0226910058,
0.0368760973,
-0.0068263537,
-0.0781099424,
-0.0015571336,
-0.0035698689,
0.0317144953,
0.1063125059,
0.0025844921,
-0.0383403935,
-0.0726285353,
0.0024321661,
0.0207953062,
0.009693197,
0.0104457717,
-0.0286179632,
-0.0211431235,
0.0399985835,
-0.0347484052,
-0.0870203525,
0.0416861363,
-0.0346450582,
-0.0041280664,
-0.0347711071,
-0.0226662569,
-0.0499424338,
0.0231738277,
0.004161512,
0.0404731333,
0.0367515385,
-0.0380741619,
-0.0225434005,
0.0405525677,
-0.0262984168,
-0.0068236748,
0.002470091,
-0.0239488557,
0.0333561599,
0.018245101,
-0.0312936604,
-0.038547527,
-0.0057889507,
-0.0210948605,
0.0146417292,
0.0725467131,
-0.027264066,
0.0238125324,
0.0012280372,
-0.0390756801,
0.0517195649,
-0.0112892073,
-0.037593618,
-0.0315986685,
-0.0259912964,
0.006108026,
-0.0169429556,
-0.0162126757,
-0.0209626369,
-0.0439382941,
0.0296057649,
0.0034684262,
0.0515176319,
-0.0784641132,
0.0439210609,
0.0108602792,
-0.0142946551,
-0.0588956401,
0.0731509849,
0.0260041989,
-0.0412960947,
-0.0503828973,
0.0920613483,
0.0217159372,
-0.0402633697,
0.009351748,
-0.0376215614,
0.0666335449,
0.0540061854,
0.0297845341,
-0.0915111154,
-0.0173886679,
-0.0028751704,
0.0277285594,
-0.0049679372,
-0.0208231658,
-0.037473578,
-0.0664611161,
0.0403693728,
0.0168559011,
-0.0556448735,
-0.0376808532,
0.0261995401,
-0.0316426679,
0.0251040496,
-0.0468818471,
0.0593338013,
-0.0256940126,
0.0409429818,
0.0110623566,
-0.0108461743,
0.0055927439,
0.0205309372,
-0.0296062678,
0.0516673997,
0.0849311948,
-0.0065397224,
0.0441970751,
-0.021510303,
0.0407481901,
0.0048745172,
0.0528827347,
-0.0332812667,
0.0072070509,
0.0105675859,
-0.0332829468,
-0.0031776275,
0.0373567753,
-0.064523682,
-0.0066193575,
-0.0139931487,
0.0519996583,
-0.0086526806,
0.0246220455,
-0.0290350448,
0.0083218217,
0.0136014894,
0.0069629797,
0.042233441,
-0.0232325941,
-0.0613579303,
-0.0422527343,
0.0299701523,
-0.0684353784,
0.0002301438,
0.004172062,
0.0319224894,
-0.0426191203,
-0.0480967872,
-0.0066907038,
0.0146799684,
0.0518782027,
-0.0058213528,
-0.0467704199,
0.0030103931,
-0.0336232148,
-0.0833904669,
0.0018746015,
-0.044155892,
-0.000326402,
-0.0657715127,
-0.0310204979,
-0.0097646005,
-0.0275718495,
-0.0270028841,
0.0508845039,
-0.0951104611,
-0.0520943105,
-0.0173862427,
0.0885086581,
0.027442649,
0.0268074814,
-0.0319303349,
-0.0316512659,
-0.0552906655,
-0.0070113437,
-0.0526222214,
0.0429746211,
0.0557361394,
0.0083540203,
0.019750325,
0.0116237905,
-0.0167809892,
-0.0138968239,
0.0087070977,
0.0336090922,
0.0177987088,
-0.0116765574,
0.0574182011,
0.0079917554,
-0.0152992876,
0.0110937124,
-0.0056882817,
-0.0163694359,
0.00755574,
0.0124309054,
0.0031636998,
-0.0752917826,
0.0117460238,
0.0098788114,
-0.0228064489,
0.0292668641,
-0.0135269929,
-0.0255869906,
0.0793817788,
0.0082319444,
0.0134710018,
0.0267927144,
0.0594734587,
0.065545328,
-0.0146912206,
-0.0245660767,
0.0186814796,
-0.0200128965,
0.0133845154,
-0.0149371577,
0.0446334332,
0.0028311971,
0.0586044416,
0.0161327496,
-0.0006202203,
-0.04452895,
-0.0674790367,
-0.0538733974,
-0.0133654047,
0.0482910424,
0.0845226049,
0.0156842377,
-0.0262875985,
0.0188548993,
-0.0215667412,
0.0810837969,
-0.0120386444,
-0.0540630333,
0.0022871122,
0.00275178,
-0.0059087779,
-0.0681370199,
0.0950666443,
0.0068338248,
0.0711323693,
-0.0260432735,
0.0249763653,
-0.0484263301,
-0.0000674592,
0.0326613635,
0.0213038363,
0.015549873,
0.0031894343,
0.0105593232,
-0.051658053,
0.0324066281,
0.0449157953,
0.0115727494,
0.0082243839,
0.0548535474,
0.0576492846,
-0.0084546208,
-0.0428485125,
-0.0136807635,
-0.0029131144,
0.0203297008,
-0.0502365232,
-0.0138298701,
-6.323712185e-33,
-0.0412187241,
-0.0231580604,
0.0412100367,
0.0129932165,
-0.0195260849,
-0.0123734837,
-0.0585207306,
0.0246732086,
0.0275317058,
-0.0277474895,
0.0422761105,
0.0462529734,
-0.00773919,
0.0179170631,
0.024961926,
0.0034404702,
0.0429080687,
-0.0011566724,
-0.0175597537,
0.033242099,
-0.0152224591,
0.0566706359,
0.0084125819,
-0.0111720702,
0.0088484362,
-0.0206643622,
-0.0194661431,
-0.0252769496,
0.002276385,
0.0515034385,
-0.0256161317,
0.0141064059,
-0.0053836708,
0.0137436548,
-0.0355073847,
-0.0058476399,
-0.0133108217,
-0.0240288004,
0.01961568,
-0.0033226099,
-0.0139927529,
-0.0850391164,
0.0353103206,
-0.0225929189,
-0.0362734161,
0.0042646951,
0.0123685366,
-0.0066788318,
0.0018338618,
-0.0103455652,
-0.0658646747,
0.0136328042,
-0.0348421149,
-0.0224281251,
-0.0430103615,
0.001482323,
-0.0319062658,
-0.0045975405,
0.0329607986,
0.003027115,
0.0340106636,
0.0516222604,
0.0219084304,
-0.0243477412,
0.0249898415,
0.0073841373,
0.0400609784,
-0.019412268,
-0.0718399212,
0.055713322,
0.0240269117,
0.0685620531,
0.0281624142,
-0.0069055296,
-0.0096590724,
0.0208223779,
-0.0632317364,
0.0093595888,
-0.0595739782,
0.0335520022,
0.001679969,
0.0340568945,
-0.0200574882,
-0.0020415969,
-0.0284315143,
-0.0526404157,
-0.0314652584,
-0.0578865036,
0.0572811998,
0.0062110717,
-0.0454607978,
-0.00279594,
0.025042003,
-0.0297843479,
0.0139151085,
0.0295720119,
-0.0220965277,
0.0234438814,
-0.027578298,
0.0470029227,
-0.0128185069,
-0.013556269,
0.0487385876,
-0.0388901941,
0.0554836653,
0.0253254119,
-0.004738926,
0.0686316788,
-0.053984046,
0.0037740222,
-0.0630687922,
0.0325994045,
0.0156423468,
0.0214899089,
0.0316362567,
-0.0189871565,
-0.0035687999,
0.0622214042,
-0.0266836453,
0.0094280383,
-0.0669168234,
-0.0125586521,
0.0302357487,
0.0542107187,
-0.0236314368,
-0.0085047157,
-0.0369964428,
0.0283474978,
0.0088159116,
-0.0252455361,
-0.0421766229,
0.0579001606,
2.775e-7,
0.0583252944,
0.0113413418,
0.0316937938,
0.073264502,
-0.0045628576,
-0.0063217562,
-0.0087940283,
0.0091787092,
0.0104684597,
-0.0213152058,
-0.0250168871,
0.0357155092,
0.0303488318,
0.0066687479,
-0.0185736753,
0.0501756631,
-0.0085285362,
0.0088012302,
-0.066137448,
-0.0180957802,
0.0525356866,
0.0530683957,
-0.0198445786,
0.0085447039,
0.035730198,
-0.0149370916,
0.0450161621,
0.0155558493,
0.0006081359,
0.0056823245,
-0.0406502075,
0.0622431003,
-0.0304770544,
-0.03824028,
0.0150049869,
-0.014660907,
0.0080935908,
0.0613832735,
-0.0005622501,
0.0304540284,
0.0510958061,
-0.010638155,
-0.0168469679,
-0.0506852306,
0.0570498295,
-0.0441327691,
-0.0040413756,
-0.0037203124,
-0.0212102216,
-0.015713606,
0.0048846328,
-0.0400235467,
0.02285132,
0.0014278662,
0.0219726618,
-0.0207125694,
-0.0175429173,
-0.0438269824,
-0.0409624018,
-0.0022197957,
-0.0439526178,
-0.0157314017,
-0.062444035,
0.0352358744,
0.0587475225,
-0.0039182999,
0.0008691514,
2.613509651e-34,
0.0301624537,
-0.0271248259,
0.0187281072,
0.0630661547,
0.0405610166,
-0.0080920253,
0.0069297319,
0.0135266874,
-0.0057403375,
-0.0768588856,
-0.0655491576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11403v1 | Multimodal Structured Generation: CVPR's 2nd MMFM Challenge Technical Report | 2024-06-17T10:45:47 | 2024-06-17T10:45:47 | Franz Louis Cesista | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal Foundation Models (MMFMs) have shown remarkable performance on
various computer vision and natural language processing tasks. However, their
performance on particular tasks such as document understanding is still
limited. They also require more compute, time, and engineering resources to
finetune and deploy compared to traditional, unimodal models. In this report,
we present Multimodal Structured Generation, a general framework which
constrains the output logits of frozen MMFMs to force them to reason before
responding with structured outputs that downstream APIs can parse and use. We
provide a detailed account of our approach, including the technical details,
theoretical discussions, and final evaluation results in the 2nd Multimodal
Foundation Models Challenge hosted by the Computer Vision and Pattern
Recognition (CVPR) conference. Our approach achieved the second highest score
in the hidden test set for Phase 2 and third highest overall. This shows the
method's ability to generalize to unseen tasks. And that simple engineering can
beat expensive & complicated modelling steps as we first discussed in our
paper, Retrieval Augmented Structured Generation: Business Document Information
Extraction as Tool Use. All of our scripts, deployment steps, and evaluation
results can be accessed in https://github.com/leloykun/MMFM-Challenge | [
0.037566416,
0.0793098286,
0.0183381233,
0.044719696,
-0.0325167291,
0.000877144,
-0.0006642287,
0.018514052,
-0.0189917702,
-0.0903375521,
-0.0272890516,
-0.0297398679,
-0.0156888235,
0.0631399304,
0.0186836421,
-0.0859791189,
0.0077045276,
-0.0215736311,
-0.0199458674,
0.0317549966,
0.02517391,
0.0321379192,
-0.0160694811,
0.0132252844,
-0.0479097664,
-0.0250173844,
-0.0282399971,
0.0388650298,
-0.0234522894,
-0.0398441367,
-0.0109264227,
0.0126438113,
0.0589900166,
0.0310910102,
0.0000022741,
-0.0593169741,
-0.0373581052,
0.0238085631,
0.0063629569,
-0.051056169,
0.0496208407,
-0.0450699814,
-0.0004065942,
-0.0300146677,
-0.0205035005,
-0.0332281478,
0.0310137253,
0.0522466563,
0.0602060258,
0.0579891503,
-0.03595718,
-0.0600312166,
0.0310903974,
0.0070466995,
-0.0196789298,
-0.0261203032,
-0.0280787144,
0.0251747463,
0.0062728799,
0.0015419298,
0.0070199813,
0.0222359188,
0.0017487779,
-0.0058458135,
0.0219984446,
0.0466613434,
-0.0321575478,
-0.0573823489,
-0.0385562517,
0.0767032057,
0.020356182,
0.0316104852,
0.0466558076,
-0.020324355,
-0.0260906052,
0.0170907024,
-0.0655505061,
0.0588571467,
-0.056383349,
-0.014889583,
-0.0056806826,
0.0139960134,
0.010649954,
0.0274946261,
0.0122998031,
0.0160398073,
0.0010499777,
-0.0115294522,
-0.0101290178,
0.0199373476,
-0.0036925024,
-0.0294817202,
-0.0097099515,
0.0263079964,
0.0122496383,
0.0006038278,
-0.0578251891,
-0.0558728762,
-0.0043227221,
-0.0370372348,
0.0410670005,
-0.0027586671,
-0.039214436,
0.0598827824,
-0.0454615057,
0.0111203659,
-0.0515741669,
0.0122950654,
-0.0239679255,
0.0178633723,
-0.0544898808,
-0.0176958051,
-0.0153133404,
0.0097795129,
-0.0732191056,
-0.0553604923,
0.0148196742,
0.0362550728,
-0.0126329353,
0.0332346559,
-0.0159051213,
0.009654901,
-0.0485038571,
-0.0105524892,
-0.012710806,
0.0140042733,
-0.002047128,
-0.0104328319,
0.0321099758,
-0.0542794652,
0.0290259644,
0.0669312701,
0.0179977566,
0.0000658498,
0.0016922761,
0.0949325264,
-0.0322595052,
-0.0185101312,
-0.0560935587,
-0.0859869346,
0.0155315856,
-0.0726336017,
0.0697494447,
-0.0392127074,
0.0529767983,
-0.0082745515,
-0.0096920161,
0.0033686452,
0.0134230526,
-0.0103796646,
-0.0116761848,
0.0703215003,
-0.0176644213,
-0.0019698185,
0.0522225648,
0.0040373136,
0.0021444126,
0.0720311552,
0.0179862808,
0.0548268147,
0.0619730055,
-0.0246523302,
0.0016329607,
0.0309097506,
-0.0099251391,
-0.0344918445,
-0.0084102089,
0.0145431617,
-0.0236029923,
0.0083025303,
0.0312030036,
0.0171925705,
-0.0233370084,
0.0318804421,
0.0305323191,
0.0013929289,
0.0174786523,
0.0032149842,
0.0700715408,
-0.0247712936,
-0.0043071499,
0.0264182072,
-0.0189077463,
0.020589726,
-0.0383224562,
0.0398557968,
-0.0147194583,
0.0180186592,
-0.0114066452,
-0.0103127975,
0.0072505702,
-0.0027863316,
-0.0211139414,
-0.0290616713,
0.0821635723,
0.0299109519,
-0.0661967322,
0.0232235491,
-0.0345568992,
-0.0692174584,
0.0204106178,
-0.0171369612,
-0.0059742192,
0.0670256391,
0.0963397026,
-0.0109238001,
-0.0144273937,
0.0175231006,
-0.0185372904,
0.0458375327,
0.0384061262,
-0.0322768129,
0.0205093157,
-0.0735408291,
-0.0434331857,
-0.0225244351,
-0.0087276278,
0.0046341205,
-0.0051787198,
-0.018090656,
0.0410419144,
-0.0326644666,
0.0209037792,
0.0436862707,
0.008739071,
-0.0153510794,
-0.0098866839,
0.0181033332,
0.0293574557,
0.0233058147,
-0.0393956862,
0.0256922729,
0.0293391496,
-0.0409187116,
0.0296536256,
0.0295410417,
-0.0183776375,
-0.0079534547,
-0.0254927296,
-0.0182864647,
0.0039820285,
-0.0053346124,
-0.0586481616,
-0.0489868224,
0.0113557652,
-0.0094210366,
-0.0000197296,
-0.0464006215,
-0.004585484,
0.0743134394,
0.0028589081,
-0.0264197346,
0.0611972585,
-0.0192032419,
-0.021392785,
0.01063783,
-0.0194521714,
0.014028267,
-0.056426689,
0.0339810066,
0.0514727123,
-0.0032129679,
0.0033206271,
0.0242113434,
0.0113461167,
-0.0405292213,
-0.0255070683,
-0.0800947621,
-0.0280495323,
0.0113219824,
0.0146575645,
0.0179996956,
0.032720644,
0.0080827055,
-0.0282892101,
-0.0277094208,
0.0345346779,
0.0554551072,
0.0029041439,
0.0312666558,
0.0370260477,
-0.0054738922,
-0.0181120224,
-0.0194436181,
0.0031917198,
0.0396305099,
0.0313447192,
-0.042671483,
-0.0586410314,
-0.0123902373,
-0.0281513352,
0.0265121143,
-0.0182205066,
0.0333833024,
0.0331364758,
-0.0843160152,
0.0099063423,
0.0646232143,
0.0123431133,
0.0600838661,
-0.0210374724,
-0.0477187708,
-0.0301851463,
0.0235724133,
-0.0216954295,
0.0527547747,
0.0077575399,
-0.0372256748,
0.0350245237,
0.0334838293,
0.0134184957,
0.051690001,
-0.0268423054,
0.0263068732,
0.0279849041,
-0.0496877581,
-0.0308129713,
0.0088327173,
0.0143652754,
0.0512780212,
-0.0119348709,
-0.0514805838,
0.0321643502,
-0.071892485,
-0.0102649163,
0.0105297407,
0.032983914,
-0.0363612957,
0.1172391623,
0.02154053,
0.0284424778,
0.0116607249,
-0.0186849795,
-0.0341111682,
-0.0258131064,
0.0519927554,
-0.0120582655,
0.0048029847,
-0.0664230809,
0.0185275432,
-0.0389262661,
-0.0074521173,
-0.028505927,
-0.0267322492,
-0.0061551197,
-0.0087253628,
0.0106360344,
0.0094033973,
-0.0541251972,
0.0296289492,
0.0020069445,
0.0464864224,
0.0128961317,
-0.0209238864,
-0.0375371091,
0.0829378143,
0.0250593107,
0.0248904712,
-0.028723428,
-0.0716188997,
-0.0158166178,
0.0592325963,
0.0403563119,
-0.0072872951,
-0.0421391055,
0.0134972902,
0.014996537,
0.0160017647,
-0.0203311294,
-0.0043205889,
0.0417603999,
-0.0834056139,
-0.0039835414,
0.0409354344,
0.013490025,
0.0154687865,
-0.0149846142,
0.0387674235,
0.0411587693,
0.0019353268,
0.0311946906,
-0.0695605725,
-0.0379703902,
0.0230331458,
0.054584749,
0.0071443771,
-0.0246098302,
-0.0249677841,
-0.0825176686,
0.0920057371,
0.0063995314,
-0.0142296953,
-0.0086195432,
-0.0223851837,
-0.0221834816,
0.0280793086,
-0.0648082271,
0.0330110565,
-0.0106622633,
-0.0044372138,
0.0089468593,
-0.0276643634,
-0.037484955,
-0.0238054283,
0.0068957945,
-0.0193353072,
0.0627352148,
-0.0058024018,
0.0181197599,
-0.0407288969,
0.0348694026,
-0.0011374712,
0.0266292021,
-0.0451145619,
0.0291230939,
-0.0144857047,
-0.0085298158,
0.000234835,
0.0179687776,
-0.0091036065,
-0.012985466,
-0.0140071735,
0.0280867778,
-0.0412120782,
0.0076813032,
-0.0648043826,
0.0121701462,
0.0028015401,
0.0463786684,
-0.013195863,
-0.0052353977,
-0.0580440983,
-0.0193434414,
0.0322512239,
-0.0685790107,
0.0232773945,
0.0117751285,
-0.0311105046,
-0.0188361313,
-0.0684483647,
-0.030922085,
0.0019594135,
0.068032138,
-0.0381408259,
-0.048593618,
-0.0073722941,
0.0315371193,
-0.061438363,
0.0388510115,
0.0109723043,
0.0042476086,
-0.0651575401,
-0.0139528578,
0.0041701393,
-0.0608383529,
-0.021858979,
0.0600680858,
-0.0531645939,
-0.0228412058,
-0.0374838822,
0.0693168491,
0.0202031173,
0.0322514623,
0.0291180704,
0.0090522552,
0.0018477632,
0.0375303663,
-0.0335913338,
-0.0096014086,
0.0281130672,
-0.0236178301,
-0.0195451919,
-0.0105686784,
-0.0617627427,
0.0321021937,
-0.0181808695,
0.0711454749,
0.0352073871,
-0.0192903019,
0.0077183037,
0.0428375825,
-0.0030404932,
-0.0382021889,
0.0342448764,
-0.0449056216,
-0.0161759257,
-0.0078193704,
-0.0592230074,
-0.0854354277,
0.0223004706,
-0.0092710769,
-0.0001391092,
0.0439238027,
0.029146798,
-0.0080766119,
0.0716760084,
0.0182377715,
0.0110079814,
0.0438142121,
0.0083976155,
-0.007641315,
-0.032479208,
-0.0200047363,
0.0416032523,
-0.0330195762,
0.041834712,
-0.0403619409,
0.1070456728,
0.0127754286,
0.0021509768,
-0.0399779864,
0.029373575,
-0.0169386659,
-0.0075108106,
-0.0578952543,
0.0021721823,
0.034324117,
0.0069817929,
0.0584467351,
-0.061486695,
0.0006513585,
-0.0230402257,
0.0657803565,
0.065437071,
-0.0473649614,
0.022000296,
0.0103916386,
0.0010707673,
-0.0202213991,
0.0722677708,
0.0171979778,
0.0175167769,
-0.028457284,
-0.0274120737,
-0.0884195864,
-0.0433554687,
0.0547244251,
0.0167104825,
-0.001278504,
0.0081849676,
-0.0453099087,
-0.00440046,
0.0261798482,
0.0383080654,
-0.0030099638,
0.020329887,
0.0351336114,
0.0860413611,
0.027111169,
-0.0302897114,
-0.0672961101,
0.0247210506,
-0.0131753897,
-0.0088401781,
0.0129252588,
-6.552233429e-33,
-0.03432706,
-0.0396039337,
0.0366961174,
-0.0173661951,
-0.025008874,
0.0156083265,
-0.0475202501,
-0.0066817426,
0.0326217785,
-0.0369117148,
0.0156471319,
-0.0489700213,
0.0249626357,
0.0377336442,
-0.0053401096,
0.0259537566,
0.0227766316,
-0.0167664159,
-0.0293196458,
0.010679015,
0.0578773804,
0.0275872424,
0.0353635512,
-0.0986675397,
0.0143509973,
0.0031552319,
-0.0503202938,
-0.0005820029,
0.0180814229,
0.0473394543,
-0.0196079314,
-0.0051836865,
0.0332959369,
-0.0116139585,
-0.0217087101,
0.0221005417,
-0.0858183578,
0.0393415615,
-0.0172593463,
0.0362244248,
-0.0993111506,
0.002981456,
0.0464933291,
-0.0503455885,
0.0346835516,
-0.004992527,
0.0322835855,
-0.0303479936,
0.0066883359,
-0.0535231493,
-0.0546661951,
0.0444245152,
0.0099225016,
-0.0108635556,
0.0486084856,
0.05541851,
0.0268244185,
0.001707411,
-0.052969534,
0.036840342,
-0.0282536615,
0.003848546,
0.0921497494,
0.0462406501,
0.0086510973,
0.0442538522,
0.007447267,
-0.0242044292,
-0.0045407848,
0.0058858013,
0.0049215341,
0.1051460803,
-0.0194897316,
0.0510229953,
-0.0039004199,
0.0271401498,
-0.0214985795,
0.0494451299,
-0.0046769073,
0.0329998955,
0.0095186019,
-0.0046527488,
-0.0119079286,
0.0204640273,
0.0058530173,
-0.0443389714,
-0.0190308951,
0.0043804524,
0.0395585671,
0.0496298075,
-0.0360547416,
-0.0044057406,
0.0723574013,
-0.0127534671,
-0.012316972,
-0.0196964256,
-0.017241234,
0.0577730536,
-0.0203818828,
-0.0296669342,
-0.031148959,
-0.0655957088,
0.0450529084,
0.0035642954,
0.0008643821,
0.0142032392,
0.0068998397,
0.0301075242,
-0.0204262547,
0.0061930157,
-0.0304797534,
0.0357807912,
-0.0135775208,
0.0462181829,
0.0364584252,
-0.039037548,
-0.045073919,
0.01342599,
-0.0061621633,
0.0259956643,
-0.0189127382,
-0.0262310766,
0.0264006555,
0.066202417,
-0.017766986,
0.0352690555,
-0.0383796953,
-0.0553352237,
0.046902027,
-0.0206122454,
0.0020322178,
0.0387193337,
2.9e-7,
0.0334635526,
0.0052682469,
0.0248256028,
0.002048702,
0.0402784012,
0.0536455102,
-0.0119269928,
0.0122992797,
-0.0623791069,
-0.0559463501,
-0.0003254315,
-0.0113939596,
0.0600208156,
0.0128715634,
-0.0223305468,
0.004518922,
-0.0248065386,
-0.0098488862,
-0.0518316887,
0.0055126818,
0.038388107,
0.0202511381,
-0.0499400906,
-0.0431509539,
0.0166264437,
-0.0445898138,
0.0727116689,
0.0236481577,
-0.00531044,
-0.0054508084,
0.0356305987,
0.0117800888,
-0.0255572982,
-0.0240136255,
-0.0138344998,
-0.0343460664,
0.0509535894,
0.060221903,
-0.001922725,
-0.0116968099,
0.0154445972,
-0.0062048826,
-0.0139558855,
-0.0255747307,
0.0478799753,
0.0043880814,
-0.0228859633,
-0.0126738511,
-0.0715292841,
0.020579299,
-0.0640022382,
0.0047954824,
-0.044006899,
0.048978854,
0.0269120224,
-0.0379171409,
-0.0300318915,
-0.0417658128,
0.0071863313,
-0.0357621536,
-0.0432493649,
-0.01187135,
-0.0322769992,
-0.0079294657,
0.0111365849,
-0.0313878581,
-0.083327502,
2.863600895e-34,
0.024930831,
0.0107392119,
-0.0160406157,
-0.0028980626,
0.0347118117,
-0.007468354,
-0.0390289873,
0.0049426593,
-0.0208743121,
-0.0540214404,
-0.0193957053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11402v1 | Evaluating Open Language Models Across Task Types, Application Domains, and Reasoning Types: An In-Depth Experimental Analysis | 2024-06-17T10:45:36 | 2024-06-17T10:45:36 | Neelabh Sinha, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The rapid rise of Language Models (LMs) has expanded their use in several
applications. Yet, due to constraints of model size, associated cost, or
proprietary restrictions, utilizing state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs is not always
feasible. With open, smaller LMs emerging, more applications can leverage their
capabilities, but selecting the right LM can be challenging. This work conducts
an in-depth experimental analysis of the semantic correctness of outputs of 10
smaller, open LMs across three aspects: task types, application domains and
reasoning types, using diverse prompt styles. We demonstrate that most
effective models and prompt styles vary depending on the specific requirements.
Our analysis provides a comparative assessment of LMs and prompt styles using a
proposed three-tier schema of aspects for their strategic selection based on
use-case and other constraints. We also show that if utilized appropriately,
these LMs can compete with, and sometimes outperform, SOTA LLMs like
DeepSeek-v2, GPT-3.5-Turbo, and GPT-4o. | [
0.0448389649,
0.0038729259,
-0.0210723411,
0.0493906885,
-0.0888922513,
-0.0362883508,
0.0024985028,
0.0043795719,
0.0212470312,
-0.0594314858,
-0.0189502444,
-0.036189653,
-0.0205079932,
0.0686699525,
-0.0028651794,
-0.0416058861,
0.0671392381,
-0.0502898358,
-0.0050743376,
0.0142377,
-0.0123899551,
0.0405758247,
-0.0014494092,
0.0617448315,
0.0238852128,
-0.0245514046,
-0.02704807,
0.0149010876,
-0.0192452092,
-0.0089588696,
-0.0095990645,
0.0412350148,
0.0077106762,
0.0468434356,
0.0000023829,
-0.0894691423,
-0.0150696337,
-0.0029715747,
-0.0473161861,
0.0215438269,
0.0425661579,
0.0194344744,
-0.035590928,
0.0145049347,
-0.0248604305,
-0.0222466215,
0.0358851813,
-0.0062407996,
0.0388773754,
0.0410635993,
0.0023189478,
-0.0109587982,
0.044729609,
-0.0102212103,
-0.0143183637,
-0.0250110142,
0.0035855304,
-0.0158214588,
0.0464207307,
0.0214990228,
0.0238675401,
0.0215696041,
0.0254551023,
-0.00307948,
-0.0272314418,
0.0304729193,
-0.0106312875,
-0.0256406255,
-0.0396422036,
0.0506951138,
0.0128472187,
0.0063249581,
-0.0202416796,
-0.0449536145,
-0.0171016809,
-0.0185211003,
-0.0225263704,
0.0658142716,
-0.0068656253,
0.0158941969,
0.0273571331,
0.0235843565,
0.026112752,
0.0267488454,
-0.0101208938,
0.1274498403,
0.0298509374,
-0.0229932237,
0.017101096,
-0.0376576558,
-0.0236804187,
-0.0845291093,
-0.0124248443,
0.0206100959,
-0.0419659838,
0.0523662046,
-0.0466414802,
0.0071573402,
0.0459481813,
-0.0109898197,
0.0751562119,
0.0577767268,
-0.0293590706,
0.0438451916,
0.0031472032,
0.0557054766,
-0.0058553815,
0.0427085608,
-0.0172361061,
-0.0151042268,
-0.0379843004,
-0.0165059473,
-0.0402784497,
0.0347385928,
-0.0643909052,
-0.0055076275,
-0.0076281535,
0.0577126853,
-0.0022136003,
0.0184618011,
0.0391974822,
-0.0311754681,
-0.032216005,
-0.0340107456,
-0.0889509991,
-0.0014137013,
-0.0070386692,
0.0277709197,
0.0126776882,
-0.1071628854,
0.0153639968,
0.0184651949,
-0.0450694971,
-0.0226681437,
-0.00757998,
0.0556028336,
0.0295122918,
-0.0119245509,
-0.0686893612,
-0.0551369451,
-0.0107248332,
-0.0538285375,
-0.0422830917,
-0.0957990736,
-0.0188514236,
0.0229684468,
-0.0172018465,
-0.0515354387,
0.0018084215,
0.0385391898,
-0.0233112853,
0.0584788248,
-0.0403794572,
0.0087658446,
0.0174761526,
0.0122920079,
0.0038751662,
0.0752357617,
0.0047440808,
0.033798974,
0.0422890149,
0.0010476062,
-0.0168703329,
0.0487249829,
-0.0338996463,
-0.0137330983,
0.0011277478,
0.0534160435,
0.0268300008,
0.0478375927,
-0.0037119067,
0.0605736114,
0.0320434682,
0.0150668202,
0.0554563776,
0.0490797088,
0.0287709925,
-0.029657105,
0.073909618,
0.0156583153,
-0.0183517002,
-0.0289582331,
-0.0508981347,
-0.0086996956,
-0.0387408696,
0.0458427742,
-0.0029045534,
0.0245195441,
-0.020169856,
-0.0495462492,
-0.0377957076,
-0.013590496,
-0.0020276057,
-0.0088459169,
0.0418086722,
0.0081796879,
-0.0609065555,
0.0734040886,
0.0254963469,
-0.0248173866,
-0.0329102986,
-0.0846360698,
0.0576017238,
0.0501003303,
0.0479503348,
-0.0249709953,
-0.0222465415,
-0.0092211217,
0.0015421973,
0.0548929088,
0.0953002274,
0.0198983084,
-0.0230021365,
-0.0485418774,
-0.0080657247,
-0.0204576459,
0.0240725745,
0.0186765827,
0.0050673196,
0.0011064864,
0.0178555995,
-0.0415507965,
0.0026626682,
0.010584184,
-0.0137951067,
-0.0025820131,
-0.026346093,
-0.0022660163,
0.0074839354,
0.0332727097,
0.0232862476,
0.0337016173,
0.0283009484,
-0.0044453014,
-0.0087219439,
-0.019496087,
-0.045083303,
0.0505702607,
0.0300625693,
0.0222110003,
-0.0033398611,
0.034956418,
-0.027413832,
-0.0394107662,
0.0201610699,
0.0059416341,
0.0115188472,
-0.0711360946,
0.0287470687,
-0.0091565466,
-0.0398296379,
-0.047622662,
0.0621336997,
0.0121818585,
0.0063249478,
0.0382297039,
-0.0035847814,
0.0226515587,
-0.0369264334,
-0.0357621051,
0.0310501717,
-0.020538887,
0.0256282203,
-0.0054102642,
0.0233721193,
-0.0609470531,
-0.0327865705,
-0.0837331638,
0.0554878488,
-0.0365042835,
0.0253160931,
0.0220423117,
0.0328427739,
-0.0222889446,
0.0179229546,
-0.0087098656,
-0.0009124147,
0.0296129342,
0.0172279552,
0.022055544,
0.0028462363,
-0.033341486,
-0.0159464981,
-0.0103897825,
-0.0308456291,
0.0126447519,
-0.0255081896,
0.0367471166,
-0.0422349311,
0.045198746,
-0.0373110808,
0.0078746453,
0.0050950637,
0.0233513676,
0.0241919681,
-0.0167904142,
0.0464192405,
0.0127048884,
-0.0088537652,
0.0203504264,
0.0350623876,
-0.0117083089,
-0.0398863293,
-0.001760197,
0.0070490432,
-0.0611571185,
-0.0227332916,
-0.0257226545,
0.0181177221,
0.0471542031,
0.0147031089,
0.017145237,
-0.0615155473,
0.0058753733,
-0.0377651751,
-0.0017377132,
-0.0350842439,
-0.0189555101,
-0.0318404548,
0.0693459585,
0.00250259,
-0.0434491113,
0.0662349239,
-0.033059828,
0.0256441291,
-0.0391130485,
-0.016095344,
-0.0600585938,
0.0813134536,
-0.0585842095,
-0.0151305674,
0.0669261366,
-0.0356591567,
-0.0388734378,
-0.0055830847,
0.0108077154,
-0.0335149281,
0.0891329572,
-0.0790125057,
-0.0035840066,
-0.0258928612,
-0.0022241434,
-0.0290628839,
-0.0572471693,
-0.0673869923,
0.0611484274,
0.0038916373,
0.0474434234,
-0.0022109586,
0.0305319522,
-0.0134188421,
0.0268264059,
-0.0053841881,
-0.0045408653,
-0.0601644441,
-0.0233065989,
0.0266220346,
0.01946388,
-0.013275722,
-0.0081454841,
0.04412416,
0.0191973858,
0.0168858394,
-0.0266424492,
-0.026463598,
-0.0099602491,
0.0406219289,
-0.0571540073,
-0.0628830791,
0.0623497181,
0.0484271571,
-0.0744783655,
-0.0024232389,
0.1272009909,
0.040579848,
-0.0042534815,
0.004966469,
-0.0490138568,
0.039214626,
0.0256815087,
0.020370042,
-0.1021765321,
-0.0477989465,
-0.0089845341,
0.0085739065,
0.0068830699,
-0.009258789,
-0.0182018466,
-0.1332738549,
0.0383866206,
-0.0129067423,
-0.0273024924,
-0.0024235512,
-0.0243252888,
0.0119063472,
-0.002026458,
0.0281862002,
0.0366952419,
-0.0123495292,
-0.0192804616,
0.008927864,
-0.0115733109,
-0.0312332921,
0.0565902367,
-0.0343673266,
0.0490312614,
0.0645136982,
-0.0247621648,
-0.0116504831,
-0.0743266046,
0.0460272878,
0.0051598181,
0.0114381779,
-0.0262204595,
-0.0103250714,
0.0008692585,
0.0103680687,
-0.0224384777,
-0.001428291,
-0.0352897495,
-0.0196879804,
0.0067624766,
0.0967997238,
-0.0352604985,
-0.0008614893,
-0.0215175897,
-0.0204611924,
0.0071299719,
0.0857158974,
0.0002275992,
-0.0274432171,
-0.0508125536,
-0.0235914644,
-0.0273728222,
-0.0076326542,
-0.0324076489,
0.0136173805,
0.0100472718,
-0.0258199349,
0.0011655383,
-0.0422711931,
0.0343916863,
-0.0034695952,
0.0114933318,
0.0094284145,
-0.0072907205,
0.0004535555,
-0.0170931425,
0.0242034215,
-0.0545627661,
0.0737095103,
-0.0755095258,
0.0287178513,
0.0256074797,
-0.043109823,
-0.0051897801,
-0.0031362565,
-0.0476123579,
-0.0464375876,
-0.0135426568,
0.0417501964,
0.0305697918,
-0.0152772665,
-0.0286018364,
-0.0434079953,
-0.0126627563,
-0.0022794604,
-0.0232706089,
0.0121069793,
0.0289181136,
0.000037798,
0.0108167287,
0.0523129851,
-0.0390429534,
-0.004840211,
-0.0192384701,
0.0339496359,
0.0236211289,
-0.069510825,
0.0352301784,
0.0375859439,
0.0547697283,
-0.0148656843,
-0.0143089229,
-0.0230839718,
0.0185904596,
-0.043661382,
-0.0289836228,
-0.0203540009,
0.0270896573,
-0.0014246119,
-0.011051489,
0.0209764782,
-0.0140469875,
-0.0562967658,
0.0502216071,
-0.0434393287,
0.0111726718,
0.0130539434,
0.0476983674,
0.0095934831,
0.0058652801,
-0.0495552681,
0.0190278664,
-0.0509179644,
0.0356129929,
-0.0272544175,
0.084583886,
-0.0043353406,
0.0111782597,
0.0022302419,
0.0492542014,
-0.0311460793,
-0.0519678853,
0.0360341892,
0.0471598692,
0.0389749259,
0.015814418,
0.0225892756,
-0.038362287,
0.0054265964,
-0.0310226418,
0.0282435957,
0.0621520057,
-0.0502030067,
0.0626769811,
0.0239042267,
-0.0269981641,
-0.0275827758,
0.0477715135,
-0.030681435,
0.0175601095,
-0.0035039755,
-0.0105560347,
-0.0417066328,
0.0034720749,
0.0152502498,
0.0372861698,
-0.0342123024,
-0.0285291057,
-0.1166109815,
-0.0320278592,
0.0006204658,
0.0423203111,
-0.0009392056,
-0.0066737635,
0.0465455204,
0.0811998993,
0.0499483682,
-0.0394243784,
-0.0384366252,
-0.0156531669,
-0.0321610719,
-0.0120599773,
-0.0238066502,
-6.471073626e-33,
-0.0244384874,
0.015668612,
0.026667824,
-0.0182032771,
-0.012644982,
-0.0117992433,
-0.0167053025,
0.0138795935,
-0.0430508815,
-0.0254880767,
-0.0084371064,
-0.0022899765,
0.0226680338,
0.0103408266,
0.0137289017,
-0.0155142462,
0.0224835481,
-0.0009261065,
-0.0269399621,
-0.0094593577,
0.0291712321,
-0.0281758886,
0.0348785929,
-0.0382619537,
0.0714032724,
-0.0025012342,
-0.0057336036,
0.0065872674,
-0.0392187014,
0.0568687879,
-0.0022929024,
0.0583168752,
0.0042868168,
-0.0746164247,
-0.020223001,
0.0268210787,
-0.0208194219,
-0.0240577571,
0.0746446103,
-0.0192367304,
-0.0497255288,
-0.0511584766,
-0.0181333274,
0.0070936829,
-0.0285871997,
0.0058942446,
0.0059256507,
-0.0145036206,
-0.0008209816,
0.0404801369,
-0.0302691944,
0.02668746,
0.0202176161,
-0.0292396266,
-0.0059851985,
0.0142443283,
-0.0131501341,
0.009396825,
-0.0079065999,
0.031822335,
0.033112321,
0.002844888,
0.108817026,
0.0177828968,
-0.0297142062,
0.024089396,
-0.0346430726,
0.0147776231,
-0.0317394957,
0.0082551185,
0.0087039089,
0.0784206614,
0.0373327881,
0.0164366849,
-0.0186539106,
-0.0056362581,
-0.0433574654,
0.0117064714,
0.0209606607,
0.0064171958,
0.0287530366,
0.0220280625,
-0.0508859977,
-0.0157293193,
-0.0466339067,
0.0248479154,
-0.040563304,
-0.0487911329,
0.0559868328,
-0.0464033782,
-0.0030166972,
-0.0145818181,
0.0176649168,
-0.0339506492,
0.0127472356,
-0.0108731315,
-0.0220462773,
0.0199205149,
-0.0234902203,
0.0419995785,
-0.0513402969,
0.0037933057,
0.0028951187,
0.0052895937,
-0.0100386692,
0.0299875643,
-0.0348326415,
0.0187391508,
-0.0404168032,
0.0197225902,
-0.0449341983,
0.0291509125,
-0.0154509451,
-0.0149359899,
0.030202033,
-0.0103351036,
0.0045162602,
0.0725403279,
0.0091377161,
-0.0621873252,
-0.0543472618,
-0.02136546,
0.0121821184,
0.0008458602,
0.004517524,
0.0159058124,
-0.0182649214,
0.0211240575,
0.0135321114,
0.0292858593,
-0.007372533,
0.0270149391,
3.03e-7,
0.0400616266,
0.0013721691,
0.0151749207,
0.0837677941,
-0.020231409,
0.0440024212,
0.010986181,
0.0404867716,
0.0054651983,
-0.0329284109,
-0.0179218054,
0.0108706094,
0.0436163992,
0.0044560749,
-0.0544617362,
0.0161936022,
-0.0366920792,
0.0214197244,
-0.0783460885,
0.0251922943,
0.0953861922,
0.067301698,
0.0071885469,
0.0015805868,
-0.0432672761,
-0.0045811543,
0.0118742529,
-0.0476542749,
-0.018367758,
0.0303436872,
0.0441083163,
0.0027420751,
0.0234393962,
0.0472830869,
0.0271452703,
0.0113092465,
0.0004831548,
0.0599720366,
0.0018212261,
-0.0506118387,
-0.016396204,
-0.064058952,
-0.0033269422,
-0.0806581751,
0.0722752735,
0.0006084611,
-0.0263937656,
-0.0100701358,
-0.0100145731,
0.0025802467,
-0.0044974224,
-0.0277105682,
-0.0180487074,
-0.0059893886,
0.001040732,
-0.016191747,
-0.0162832364,
-0.0276687834,
-0.0355008505,
-0.0028161618,
-0.014947406,
-0.0593298487,
-0.0352410078,
0.0184644628,
0.0313792415,
-0.0578124486,
-0.012655478,
2.969033326e-34,
0.0234248843,
0.0097028371,
0.0218064338,
0.0093256263,
0.0243749935,
0.0375585705,
0.0143620297,
0.0192540139,
0.0100386925,
-0.0820512995,
-0.0317969136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11400v1 | Large Language Models and Knowledge Graphs for Astronomical Entity Disambiguation | 2024-06-17T10:38:03 | 2024-06-17T10:38:03 | Golnaz Shapurian | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.IM | This paper presents an experiment conducted during a hackathon, focusing on
using large language models (LLMs) and knowledge graph clustering to extract
entities and relationships from astronomical text. The study demonstrates an
approach to disambiguate entities that can appear in various contexts within
the astronomical domain. By collecting excerpts around specific entities and
leveraging the GPT-4 language model, relevant entities and relationships are
extracted. The extracted information is then used to construct a knowledge
graph, which is clustered using the Leiden algorithm. The resulting Leiden
communities are utilized to identify the percentage of association of unknown
excerpts to each community, thereby enabling disambiguation. The experiment
showcases the potential of combining LLMs and knowledge graph clustering
techniques for information extraction in astronomical research. The results
highlight the effectiveness of the approach in identifying and disambiguating
entities, as well as grouping them into meaningful clusters based on their
relationships. | [
0.0527617112,
-0.013650368,
-0.0041365162,
0.0470426194,
-0.0378441103,
0.0203164034,
0.0036595846,
0.0373682939,
0.0826404616,
-0.0410291515,
0.0064178831,
-0.0029960484,
-0.0036849582,
-0.03892456,
0.0033266393,
-0.0468910784,
0.051697731,
-0.032421276,
0.0383152291,
-0.0189680383,
-0.0333643407,
0.0022170192,
-0.0072438573,
-0.0510290377,
-0.0113070542,
-0.0213452876,
0.0244510695,
-0.0144791072,
0.0533769056,
-0.0243086293,
-0.0429590791,
0.037877623,
-0.0159122683,
0.093975611,
0.0000014823,
-0.0669018924,
-0.0480090417,
0.0365020894,
-0.0151588339,
0.0478456356,
0.0335420668,
0.0011847159,
0.0204495098,
-0.0459136963,
0.0065581473,
-0.0220653675,
0.0369341411,
-0.0190821942,
0.0208200105,
-0.0005565666,
-0.0118659595,
-0.0620615669,
-0.0204994101,
-0.0007072854,
-0.0023739692,
0.0078706313,
0.0700411573,
0.0666473657,
0.0193864815,
0.0398892462,
-0.0243827701,
0.0715218708,
-0.0358310342,
0.0072130733,
0.0349466987,
0.0195731334,
-0.0714104474,
0.0004721243,
0.0492122583,
0.0264899842,
0.0745012239,
-0.0451467596,
0.0692918375,
0.0190816578,
-0.0429428406,
0.1171699464,
-0.0399898589,
0.0178931449,
-0.0164378192,
0.0055768536,
0.0059996024,
-0.0488914438,
0.039643988,
0.0192013085,
-0.039388191,
0.0844888762,
0.0341994315,
-0.0328090042,
-0.0049845474,
0.0143052042,
-0.0010983874,
-0.0417978391,
0.0449286662,
0.0262603555,
0.0374341905,
0.0459021814,
0.0065437495,
0.0242193118,
0.0285227522,
-0.0436972938,
-0.0554672815,
-0.0132276928,
0.0245465282,
0.0887102857,
-0.0071660979,
-0.0054434501,
0.0051796492,
-0.0395766534,
0.0255856887,
-0.0385529511,
-0.074011907,
-0.0122222565,
-0.0221882202,
0.0227816142,
0.0016830981,
0.0224222094,
-0.0202677585,
-0.008016713,
0.0189804845,
0.0324037224,
0.009545275,
-0.0298139136,
-0.0278295185,
-0.0304296985,
-0.0418761224,
0.0233921614,
0.0085660592,
0.0083729625,
-0.037500035,
-0.0379081033,
0.0123136751,
0.0537921898,
0.0133482497,
-0.0344897322,
-0.0024277736,
0.0808449984,
0.0538126752,
-0.0492648445,
-0.0321664177,
-0.0460296497,
0.000788752,
-0.0382406227,
0.0121807167,
-0.0627234876,
0.0209851917,
0.0463300906,
0.0074736727,
-0.0339680761,
0.0112097338,
-0.0146392714,
-0.0605514683,
0.0340442359,
-0.0830293894,
0.0059605725,
0.062936306,
0.027456753,
0.008170886,
0.0096470062,
0.0659308732,
0.0030350541,
0.0753790811,
-0.0107075647,
0.0063421414,
0.0186834149,
-0.0003366397,
-0.0182783902,
0.017110901,
0.0075073009,
-0.0519029535,
-0.019414952,
-0.0149887176,
0.0676935315,
-0.0226249751,
0.020389732,
-0.0230038054,
0.0316399559,
-0.0100095477,
0.0582680069,
-0.02077589,
0.0104548726,
0.0271384604,
-0.0477923378,
-0.0042389282,
0.0140462453,
-0.0246898308,
0.0100592319,
0.0107562663,
0.047554329,
0.0168199148,
0.0186375771,
-0.0012792055,
0.0021289983,
0.0031098488,
-0.0281220935,
0.0791892037,
-0.0310235489,
-0.0157149825,
0.0585009716,
0.0610230938,
-0.0168702547,
0.0460682511,
0.0113106184,
0.016172478,
0.0221040919,
0.022213608,
-0.0496986322,
-0.0207548793,
0.0389626175,
-0.0325806066,
0.0573942214,
-0.0158282574,
-0.0473311543,
-0.040233437,
-0.0355801545,
-0.0362359509,
0.0295497384,
-0.0040813936,
0.017890105,
0.0319963917,
0.0118039018,
0.0165371709,
-0.0859332755,
0.0007793035,
0.0119161541,
-0.0476242267,
-0.016789956,
-0.0511688069,
-0.010906755,
-0.0079577724,
0.0238379911,
-0.0144906072,
-0.0048435489,
0.0267194528,
-0.0044442415,
0.0130302925,
-0.0091836331,
0.0600098111,
0.013116546,
0.0460725836,
-0.0620984137,
-0.0245978255,
-0.0198990721,
0.0028234918,
-0.0496306121,
0.0184259545,
-0.030160632,
0.0430832617,
0.0138038881,
0.0088699674,
-0.0217261966,
-0.0375698023,
-0.0538874865,
0.0588859059,
0.006847146,
0.0520891249,
0.0081815561,
-0.0083729737,
0.0288075637,
-0.0105327833,
-0.0179036949,
-0.006039741,
0.0434986241,
-0.0147784688,
0.0479565375,
-0.0450024046,
-0.0345040746,
-0.045741532,
-0.0683891773,
-0.0027683787,
0.0025194976,
0.0120249409,
0.0233151764,
-0.0007020801,
-0.026650317,
0.009296936,
0.0417054594,
0.0236291271,
-0.0128614362,
-0.0308127329,
0.0548123829,
0.0008746348,
-0.0244974531,
-0.0323276818,
-0.0168786626,
-0.0279911589,
0.0567347519,
0.060591206,
-0.0759292245,
-0.0630017966,
0.0739607066,
-0.0678282678,
-0.034471225,
-0.0137338545,
-0.0122884177,
-0.0133890845,
-0.01558802,
0.0273616202,
0.0145177543,
-0.0207358841,
-0.0184525922,
0.0451257825,
-0.0540019944,
0.0209123697,
-0.028148137,
-0.048555892,
0.0359756723,
-0.0232189707,
-0.0066022449,
0.022549741,
-0.0084323138,
0.0043280441,
-0.027046809,
0.0225370359,
-0.0046696528,
-0.0484711751,
0.0376824625,
0.0302664656,
0.0151385702,
-0.027035648,
-0.0113750473,
0.024352489,
-0.0232482273,
0.0348024257,
-0.0368172452,
0.0297435708,
-0.0350522101,
-0.0175227746,
-0.0122017469,
-0.0064030113,
-0.0067864368,
0.026880227,
-0.0051421192,
-0.0194252692,
-0.017086193,
0.033068005,
0.0045659593,
-0.0160255134,
0.0526193008,
-0.0570330247,
0.0177020691,
0.010083409,
0.0527678058,
-0.0179366115,
0.0392603874,
-0.0204799864,
0.0335609354,
0.0562971719,
-0.0461339243,
-0.0064883563,
0.0198511072,
0.0585695356,
-0.0485037789,
0.0089164358,
-0.0006704711,
-0.0316045359,
0.058063522,
0.0564189665,
-0.0364453867,
0.0461732484,
-0.0230531003,
-0.0336471461,
0.0342692211,
0.0089740669,
-0.0477416702,
0.0207071416,
-0.0615404546,
0.013756969,
-0.0754658878,
-0.0188857485,
-0.0223554,
0.0313178524,
-0.0022342564,
0.0080423746,
0.101424627,
0.0311044548,
-0.0581990778,
-0.0080938982,
0.0369652286,
-0.0129391607,
0.0349214748,
-0.0189405438,
-0.0727050155,
0.0417261906,
-0.0346550979,
-0.0100526614,
0.0392551757,
-0.0586112477,
-0.0070798248,
-0.0561155751,
0.0152109265,
0.0209881272,
-0.0645869598,
-0.0478714295,
-0.0846930966,
0.0050538345,
-0.0175154097,
-0.0680288821,
-0.0024347377,
-0.0134581672,
0.003596952,
0.0120737692,
-0.0344698094,
-0.0627987087,
-0.018668808,
-0.0479711406,
0.0425963216,
-0.0183435511,
0.0503044389,
-0.0327036902,
0.0456797294,
-0.0219629928,
-0.0439670421,
-0.0293547306,
-0.0095688151,
-0.0020664372,
0.0394553915,
0.0060138274,
-0.0243586432,
0.0197658036,
-0.0442656204,
-0.0099736722,
0.0273981038,
0.0746173114,
-0.0068060723,
-0.0202437192,
-0.0096822632,
-0.0196003672,
0.012444838,
0.0649550408,
-0.048636917,
0.0283055957,
-0.0199570395,
-0.0072597647,
0.0174320266,
0.0342655666,
0.0091148745,
-0.0094048083,
-0.0151311429,
0.0186458714,
-0.01535857,
-0.0020141844,
0.0110780792,
0.0150361573,
0.0230378732,
0.0413286984,
0.0647288784,
-0.0027544843,
-0.0441312902,
0.0178172328,
-0.0711883083,
-0.0198395941,
-0.0270548258,
-0.0489855334,
0.0439069718,
0.0244380459,
-0.031409584,
-0.0022427717,
-0.0853044167,
-0.0410565473,
0.0107448399,
-0.0331271254,
0.0279125776,
0.0374423899,
-0.0155916335,
-0.0416459031,
0.0131024318,
0.0031663859,
-0.0132653555,
0.0264347605,
-0.0849188045,
0.0254260544,
-0.0103171086,
-0.0142279053,
-0.0306153949,
0.0098373052,
0.0069128452,
0.0056365174,
-0.1144465208,
-0.0509053804,
-0.0107023641,
0.0693867132,
0.0128375702,
-0.0685479492,
0.0097139031,
-0.0010952761,
-0.0217278879,
-0.0260967128,
0.0232702307,
0.0442659892,
0.0208957326,
0.0055268081,
0.0040658079,
0.0272255074,
0.0270675067,
0.0351441354,
0.0027686041,
-0.0269419607,
0.0115190791,
0.0293250829,
-0.0008377514,
0.0317452177,
-0.0123103838,
0.0188883394,
-0.02950974,
-0.0116212443,
0.0061099781,
-0.0343159735,
0.0263735522,
0.0386530198,
-0.0196586009,
-0.0158031657,
0.0129832169,
-0.0723595172,
-0.0024818198,
-0.0101572052,
0.0324554108,
0.0537362285,
0.0349121764,
0.0383313783,
-0.0828311965,
-0.0352931693,
0.0100416755,
0.0385691635,
0.0087679671,
0.0392961353,
0.0312136747,
0.021067366,
-0.0326336697,
0.0472175926,
0.057968881,
0.0086356653,
0.0174139496,
0.0300429426,
-0.0105126388,
-0.0408721827,
-0.0267091934,
-0.0424751788,
-0.0227996018,
-0.0279694758,
-0.0000134143,
-0.059567567,
-0.0202781726,
0.0095914993,
0.0083011976,
0.0093515674,
-0.0284813084,
0.0566623099,
0.0311991237,
-0.0038713387,
-0.0210394617,
-0.0267242733,
0.016080318,
-0.0472418368,
-0.026438918,
0.0035378113,
-5.79954456e-33,
-0.0347864032,
-0.0403655171,
0.0082048625,
-0.0049080481,
-0.0412047431,
-0.0116351694,
-0.0352339149,
-0.0318050943,
-0.0069572139,
0.0303325262,
0.0418585129,
0.0195009634,
0.0025759521,
-0.0203983895,
0.0020909647,
0.0160581563,
0.0309972614,
0.0426184684,
-0.0132618789,
0.0598390587,
0.0771982968,
0.0177872721,
0.0241052024,
-0.0955953971,
0.0448785461,
0.0089076338,
0.0212415513,
0.0119585963,
0.0153600061,
0.0601438321,
-0.0472686552,
0.0354333445,
-0.0003585282,
0.0115591744,
0.0297814365,
-0.026910983,
-0.0640898272,
0.0019162215,
0.0269560907,
0.014019697,
0.0517058484,
-0.0370926782,
0.0010976051,
-0.0006790737,
-0.0053566899,
-0.0026325197,
0.0636482611,
-0.0048097717,
-0.0691950694,
-0.0433925651,
-0.0021901163,
0.0358811319,
-0.0220249891,
0.0598645434,
0.0609679073,
-0.0618085638,
-0.0157913845,
0.0968872011,
-0.0444359891,
0.0488161556,
-0.0004260479,
0.0179150533,
-0.0140037974,
0.0071062073,
0.0262865275,
0.0513298064,
-0.0455127992,
-0.0307121649,
0.0326091945,
0.0358076245,
0.0001535616,
0.0435308628,
-0.0080626942,
0.0328737982,
-0.0303912498,
-0.0274677332,
-0.0741092116,
-0.0159821175,
-0.0216788426,
-0.0427729413,
-0.0115708848,
0.0147885187,
-0.0021305648,
-0.0069459667,
0.0275695585,
-0.0310887787,
0.0225215815,
-0.0350663215,
-0.0720739961,
-0.045493409,
-0.0506820381,
0.036956694,
-0.0151572032,
-0.0612772778,
-0.0514731109,
0.0388369896,
-0.0015563524,
0.0367307141,
-0.0205884594,
0.0176973324,
-0.0721681267,
-0.0378477462,
0.0085741142,
0.0065747672,
-0.0077857743,
0.0030846323,
-0.049769938,
-0.0008416879,
-0.0318102539,
0.019158978,
0.0462252237,
-0.0611493625,
-0.003106233,
-0.0200219676,
0.0025590132,
0.0218783263,
0.0654121116,
0.0324922055,
0.0758629218,
0.0432503894,
0.0547143854,
0.0427051857,
-0.0350971855,
-0.0056501236,
0.0167836789,
0.0054208995,
-0.0079884697,
0.0192197431,
0.0095831482,
-0.0194161776,
0.0043374053,
0.009546089,
2.453e-7,
0.0634659603,
0.074223347,
0.0379793793,
-0.0036242781,
0.0103449579,
-0.0346656926,
0.0001280119,
-0.0059891227,
0.0109207332,
-0.0052199201,
-0.0306103528,
-0.0403640419,
-0.0059107421,
0.0627477989,
-0.0449592769,
-0.0132462811,
-0.0058759288,
-0.071354799,
-0.058559563,
0.0202905517,
0.0030303746,
0.0365319252,
0.0220979881,
0.0043598479,
-0.0399332903,
-0.0398859419,
0.0252292082,
-0.0217080098,
-0.0092290035,
0.0821727216,
-0.0072638704,
-0.003205342,
0.0007195795,
0.0624814108,
-0.0056099393,
0.0003227399,
0.0093462812,
-0.0009091651,
0.0227905586,
0.0417876504,
0.017437093,
-0.0412848704,
0.0467065834,
-0.0368139967,
0.0216874834,
-0.0073537021,
-0.0189754013,
0.0704702586,
-0.0331733376,
-0.0376364253,
-0.040664386,
-0.010317307,
-0.0009736161,
-0.0034459655,
-0.0394717269,
0.023937922,
-0.0013660121,
-0.0557605438,
0.03590196,
0.0827351287,
-0.0446205959,
-0.0587248355,
0.0560669526,
-0.0785692483,
0.0077466196,
0.0049681994,
0.0172603484,
2.00897885e-34,
0.0252457932,
0.0195269808,
-0.0473062173,
0.0156009169,
0.0129771819,
-0.0395243615,
-0.0444096029,
0.0332571827,
-0.0144115472,
-0.0642265677,
0.0398673825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11385v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11385v2 | MetaGPT: Merging Large Language Models Using Model Exclusive Task Arithmetic | 2024-06-17T10:12:45 | 2024-06-27T16:01:28 | Yuyan Zhou, Liang Song, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 has catalyzed the
exploration of multi-task learning (MTL), in which a single model demonstrates
proficiency across diverse tasks. Task arithmetic has emerged as a
cost-effective approach for MTL. It enables performance enhancement across
multiple tasks by adding their corresponding task vectors to a pre-trained
model. However, the current lack of a method that can simultaneously achieve
optimal performance, computational efficiency, and data privacy limits their
application to LLMs. In this paper, we propose \textbf{M}odel
\textbf{E}xclusive \textbf{T}ask \textbf{A}rithmetic for merging
\textbf{GPT}-scale models, which formalizes the objective of model merging into
a multi-task learning framework, aiming to minimize the average loss difference
between the merged model and each individual task model. Since data privacy
limits the use of multi-task training data, we leverage LLMs' local linearity
and task vectors' orthogonality to separate the data term and scaling
coefficients term and derive a model-exclusive task arithmetic method. Our
proposed MetaGPT is data-agnostic and bypasses the heavy search process, making
it cost-effective and easy to implement for LLMs.Extensive experiments
demonstrate that MetaGPT leads to improvements in task arithmetic and achieves
state-of-the-art performance on multiple tasks. | [
-0.0240124483,
0.0810272843,
0.001196213,
0.0520308204,
-0.0396901071,
0.032594163,
0.0520428307,
-0.0419957303,
-0.0058518318,
0.0038729988,
-0.0778817832,
-0.045724228,
0.0053205481,
0.0025309559,
0.0420068018,
0.0091185393,
0.0176220722,
-0.0296978448,
-0.0207609162,
-0.0090587698,
-0.028556861,
0.0252719391,
0.0316723026,
0.0311053135,
0.0403916799,
-0.0155280177,
-0.0143071497,
-0.0022562291,
0.0598781034,
0.0188029036,
0.0233839117,
0.0593935698,
0.0511225015,
0.0892487839,
0.0000021268,
-0.0307136215,
-0.0565984808,
0.0255215596,
-0.0154406643,
0.0129944971,
0.0206097402,
0.0097151874,
0.0106259771,
0.0203371439,
-0.0376265608,
-0.0375413001,
0.0660663843,
0.0689145327,
0.0724306852,
0.0737907887,
-0.0039683026,
-0.0143203987,
0.0245361459,
-0.0716028139,
0.0024894834,
-0.0695400983,
0.0622191727,
0.0017349019,
-0.0354846492,
0.0284985714,
0.0159468912,
0.0256942902,
0.0014798787,
0.0243373923,
-0.0137077207,
0.0268889796,
0.0256851334,
-0.0092399744,
-0.0222885776,
0.0291899256,
-0.0349682383,
-0.0158296395,
0.0310738403,
0.0082267681,
0.0068653468,
0.0049802577,
-0.0715296045,
0.0042112651,
0.0027058609,
0.0286047384,
-0.005080949,
-0.0341239795,
0.0404922888,
0.0144880526,
0.0019416901,
0.0426582806,
0.0349017307,
-0.0180439223,
-0.0154934181,
-0.0094959661,
-0.0722915977,
-0.0370569192,
0.0094068097,
0.006746511,
-0.0108969826,
0.005896003,
-0.0531374104,
-0.0829341784,
0.0032566686,
-0.029619595,
0.0911295563,
0.0062630624,
0.0101637449,
0.0634663925,
-0.0047355285,
0.0728238299,
-0.0433777086,
0.0291007143,
-0.0551344827,
0.0151366647,
-0.0627853945,
-0.0043464862,
-0.0082858438,
0.0479812101,
-0.0674825311,
0.0336545706,
-0.0240679495,
0.0507769696,
-0.0321980491,
-0.0147911264,
0.0637114123,
-0.0290526655,
-0.0438338667,
-0.0292457994,
0.0200108588,
-0.0025120617,
0.0268068872,
0.0442414209,
-0.0061340956,
-0.0107961399,
-0.0467936583,
-0.0216032267,
0.0084165717,
-0.050247103,
-0.0001874289,
0.0520259812,
-0.0095533514,
-0.0272213928,
-0.0053654769,
-0.04416335,
0.0068385797,
-0.0937853903,
-0.0043754862,
-0.0488250852,
0.0560540855,
-0.0486165024,
0.0014709779,
-0.0259259008,
-0.0238661226,
0.0182811096,
-0.0364039987,
0.0848301873,
0.0144558819,
0.0084548797,
0.0237948615,
0.0255620684,
-0.0250535514,
0.0649667978,
0.0025112724,
0.0174891055,
0.0184342042,
0.0052873213,
-0.0013260911,
0.0127459699,
0.0447307862,
0.0530671291,
0.0224815514,
-0.0077385665,
0.0739529878,
-0.0564458519,
-0.0080186417,
0.0589428619,
-0.0295036938,
-0.0006096851,
0.0761847869,
0.0278720334,
-0.0101710455,
0.0083621219,
-0.0031996993,
0.0330708697,
-0.021474408,
0.0181786213,
-0.0822259635,
-0.0074953442,
-0.0583248436,
-0.0239755027,
0.0330385119,
0.0679292381,
-0.0356371216,
-0.0152447065,
-0.0029367711,
-0.0490778983,
0.0118683828,
0.0327803232,
0.0482845269,
-0.036964234,
-0.0537965372,
0.0153014511,
0.0457933024,
-0.0760207176,
0.0109039443,
-0.0622981675,
0.0042879749,
-0.0054055895,
0.0107627418,
-0.0208053142,
-0.0354020223,
-0.0267857946,
0.0135085955,
-0.0088574532,
-0.0070395675,
0.0021914137,
0.051089216,
-0.0524654873,
-0.0737845525,
0.0005742395,
0.0279658996,
0.017461881,
-0.0059111123,
-0.0251969099,
0.0298998412,
-0.0483573265,
0.0014220863,
0.0296868328,
-0.0430850759,
-0.0344008319,
0.0128763653,
0.0048641814,
0.0377536751,
0.0129430825,
-0.007303216,
0.008779576,
0.0270560607,
0.0059560426,
-0.0235385653,
0.0093851388,
-0.0222245529,
-0.0147364223,
0.015358327,
0.0096132709,
0.01998307,
0.0817417428,
-0.0388218723,
-0.066006504,
-0.0453194007,
0.000067014,
0.0271670371,
-0.0332190618,
0.0216865521,
-0.0118402923,
0.004933137,
-0.0304240398,
0.0476310439,
-0.0264180191,
-0.0256105494,
-0.0118831815,
-0.0322584845,
-0.0086736949,
-0.0328383446,
-0.0377852991,
0.014775835,
0.003599304,
0.0370635986,
0.0014192691,
0.0074921385,
0.0054917135,
-0.0392938368,
-0.0978337452,
0.0261938814,
-0.0262147188,
0.0492632277,
0.0258781947,
-0.0026698958,
-0.0045591202,
0.0057379939,
-0.0192388948,
-0.0223525967,
-0.018308362,
0.0229467694,
-0.0049548307,
0.0172290523,
-0.0297976062,
-0.002459595,
-0.0518360324,
-0.0134043302,
0.017602101,
-0.0352990367,
-0.0113976514,
-0.0368174762,
0.0368135832,
-0.0218918622,
0.0403190553,
-0.029365994,
0.0003462359,
-0.0179929025,
-0.0347485654,
0.0519121848,
0.0402679965,
-0.0292298403,
-0.0116455844,
0.0822422802,
-0.0257220455,
-0.0062108566,
0.0313263535,
-0.0147427013,
-0.0253323838,
-0.0280013699,
-0.0078107989,
0.0101496838,
0.0528147332,
-0.0178946387,
-0.0714629814,
-0.054191228,
0.0040678792,
-0.0097651891,
-0.0284428969,
-0.0212278776,
-0.0070953392,
-0.0272099879,
0.0094780335,
-0.0277705286,
-0.0647033229,
0.048744861,
-0.0236226004,
-0.0129240314,
-0.0495472439,
-0.0177759435,
-0.0216494538,
0.0518752895,
-0.0058767605,
0.0296543147,
0.0459006429,
-0.0516467988,
-0.0574420616,
-0.0027029486,
0.0573247112,
-0.0470321923,
0.0787013546,
-0.0524709336,
0.0196290389,
-0.0229586381,
-0.0404314622,
-0.0146517502,
-0.0227758661,
0.0165313166,
0.0146055417,
-0.0151622947,
-0.0413486883,
-0.0433769301,
-0.0225649271,
0.0232368615,
0.0267055836,
-0.0187353138,
0.0219708979,
-0.0183704812,
0.0280171074,
0.0484221429,
0.0222471096,
-0.0204802789,
-0.0403312556,
0.0059270831,
0.0467047915,
0.1064864844,
-0.0158027615,
0.0116052674,
-0.0353981815,
0.04983766,
0.0023281849,
-0.0173727851,
0.0129535226,
0.0387578234,
-0.0256484672,
0.0231020134,
0.0970820785,
-0.0030327865,
-0.0605367608,
-0.0540823638,
0.0329564027,
0.0285705719,
-0.0049190414,
-0.0016719559,
-0.0498318523,
-0.0044565536,
0.0343988873,
-0.0015221247,
0.0220792275,
-0.0253368597,
-0.0472400151,
-0.0945521221,
-0.0030239085,
0.036326509,
0.006129093,
-0.0074132914,
-0.0490680374,
0.013462604,
-0.0461754911,
0.0159559455,
-0.0156755652,
-0.0182127357,
-0.0310434327,
-0.0053526014,
0.0309462119,
-0.0380989127,
0.0058635743,
-0.0234205425,
0.0304637644,
0.0492393337,
0.0291917622,
-0.0111125531,
-0.048630666,
0.0517886467,
0.0463331342,
-0.0627759844,
0.0024470328,
0.0230471902,
-0.0082336953,
0.0083607631,
0.0012290406,
0.0554555207,
-0.0092751486,
-0.0044710981,
-0.0021371653,
0.0852698013,
0.0139310434,
0.0166084226,
0.0169280078,
-0.0520474464,
0.0144793242,
0.0712489933,
-0.0297841337,
-0.0253068786,
0.0080613717,
0.03199986,
-0.0224013515,
0.0096486723,
0.0114376796,
0.016360281,
-0.0226254594,
-0.0170912165,
-0.0339089632,
0.0045876,
0.015646657,
0.036683701,
0.0141267832,
0.0340517052,
0.0179254133,
-0.0043533156,
-0.0694372505,
0.0204532631,
-0.0621032305,
0.0261080377,
-0.0450153798,
0.0265277717,
0.0353908055,
-0.0045482866,
-0.0281009469,
0.032410413,
-0.1563287526,
-0.1003339514,
-0.0311368518,
0.0129826684,
0.0150302006,
0.0138355279,
-0.0096514989,
-0.0322751962,
0.0411261283,
-0.0002181723,
-0.024387449,
0.0381228589,
0.0763844624,
-0.0409097187,
-0.0109741483,
0.0327320658,
-0.0341174863,
-0.0121022314,
0.0363088734,
-0.0160244871,
-0.0346054584,
-0.0079695815,
0.0050335722,
0.0238806307,
0.0749546736,
-0.0090353163,
0.0159628429,
-0.061752636,
0.024769105,
-0.0257029068,
0.0130007183,
-0.0444331318,
0.0060828771,
0.0416484773,
0.003247974,
0.0366372354,
0.0487454385,
0.0531817302,
-0.0132959802,
-0.0681231767,
-0.0142273111,
-0.0611171611,
-0.0430009328,
0.0375886299,
0.0150111429,
-0.0160504077,
0.0057539698,
0.0399277583,
0.0029572579,
-0.0135112619,
0.0343815796,
-0.0021250653,
0.0214838572,
0.0054114065,
0.0747604445,
-0.06077547,
-0.0552105941,
-0.0354178697,
0.0075551881,
0.0557176471,
0.0142404083,
0.0767925754,
-0.0267167948,
-0.0167431142,
-0.0587013997,
0.012827401,
-0.0116349282,
0.020094119,
0.0275705531,
0.0053875423,
0.0125265243,
-0.0064355033,
0.099996686,
0.0176924057,
0.0099384328,
-0.007287378,
-0.0043851165,
-0.034691859,
-0.0650761798,
0.0222023893,
-0.0066104922,
-0.0476398356,
-0.0278176442,
-0.0116953515,
-0.079327397,
-0.0081835221,
-0.0148254465,
-0.0353727862,
0.0053293607,
0.0255308077,
0.0254805759,
-0.0482203327,
-0.0178832319,
-0.0235984474,
-0.0601987876,
0.0191119183,
-0.0126662124,
0.0282183494,
-6.301754685e-33,
-0.0092888474,
0.0098929629,
0.0012591728,
-0.0162327364,
-0.0215044972,
0.0338092521,
0.0303703658,
-0.0057123736,
-0.0029949495,
-0.0312183909,
-0.0122550866,
0.0141737768,
0.009512064,
0.0286122765,
-0.0135218492,
-0.0071637738,
0.0652874708,
-0.0057802354,
0.0072207106,
0.0448455773,
0.0103070596,
0.0126914149,
0.0503615513,
-0.0591197833,
0.0650799647,
-0.0042069242,
-0.0500995442,
0.0315688215,
-0.035666775,
0.0448987447,
-0.0203245506,
-0.000271304,
0.0284983683,
-0.0386473536,
-0.0536203571,
0.0270167906,
-0.0456128344,
-0.00020811,
0.0221380424,
-0.0413875468,
-0.042712763,
-0.0256361533,
0.0160104353,
0.0144622326,
-0.0020136004,
-0.053980343,
0.0034685922,
0.0036967522,
-0.0009376591,
0.0183717497,
-0.0088238753,
0.0046577523,
0.0193677917,
-0.0195478089,
0.0989030302,
0.0025078093,
0.0273940992,
-0.035101641,
-0.0299043581,
0.0262846835,
-0.0012993123,
0.0086068921,
0.072426632,
0.0425038636,
0.0051242411,
0.0247726068,
0.0094759809,
0.020573888,
-0.0042661205,
-0.0243981127,
-0.0031943149,
0.0564969741,
0.0230330471,
0.0135760177,
-0.0051731924,
0.0101471795,
-0.0528812744,
0.0402030833,
0.0181484707,
0.0113806212,
0.0134805944,
0.03722433,
-0.0224465467,
0.0065855025,
-0.041813489,
0.0194478128,
-0.0446069315,
0.0147716207,
0.0003227486,
0.0283003058,
-0.0059279087,
0.0187429283,
0.0418363139,
-0.0490261465,
-0.009907675,
0.0423026606,
0.017207237,
-0.0133014517,
-0.0135206468,
0.027554445,
-0.0396068431,
-0.0212421659,
0.0139512178,
0.0073414827,
-0.0149149755,
-0.0098530101,
0.033397641,
0.0251276493,
-0.0681469738,
-0.0000573182,
-0.0321356431,
0.0130415233,
0.031625282,
0.0534098968,
0.081798397,
-0.0155496774,
0.0175237544,
0.0274823997,
0.0404263958,
-0.0204646587,
-0.0478113554,
0.0311388597,
-0.0206326079,
-0.0012579311,
0.0349664614,
0.0031477143,
0.0184086934,
-0.0116113275,
0.0996586755,
-0.0091293156,
-0.0138961868,
-0.009053221,
2.856e-7,
-0.0296356194,
-0.0058448319,
-0.0125962263,
-0.0086616334,
-0.0089470828,
0.0661828816,
-0.0507548898,
0.0672661364,
0.0062567019,
-0.0017280444,
-0.0015508686,
0.0134577639,
0.067759119,
0.0091374358,
-0.0504193045,
-0.0148545681,
-0.017107036,
0.0231077,
-0.0468819737,
0.0006348627,
0.032365676,
0.0846447796,
0.0529283583,
-0.0176054928,
-0.0319786631,
-0.0186233427,
0.0787793323,
-0.0543266647,
-0.0394515879,
0.0193395298,
0.006023061,
0.0303453207,
-0.0179329235,
0.0166619159,
-0.034626551,
0.0337805562,
0.0110513745,
0.1246082634,
0.0059337434,
0.0092824688,
0.0050419872,
0.0114535065,
-0.0380493365,
-0.012470562,
0.0681056827,
-0.0241581891,
-0.0259523913,
-0.0205981042,
0.0310287382,
-0.0270757955,
0.04380624,
-0.0012787255,
0.0124804294,
0.0213588607,
-0.003330633,
-0.0065999352,
0.0059200861,
-0.0856063887,
-0.0166720971,
0.012355255,
-0.075206548,
-0.0537629947,
0.0024186205,
-0.018786991,
0.0286222566,
-0.0709491968,
0.0338164642,
2.839149924e-34,
0.0009278464,
-0.0346237235,
0.0454509556,
0.0304965656,
-0.0127649773,
-0.0229496565,
-0.0470643118,
0.0101664374,
0.0114419861,
-0.0784827694,
-0.027793169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11380v1 | A Realistic Evaluation of LLMs for Quotation Attribution in Literary Texts: A Case Study of LLaMa3 | 2024-06-17T09:56:46 | 2024-06-17T09:56:46 | Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) zero-shot and few-shot performance are subject
to memorization and data contamination, complicating the assessment of their
validity. In literary tasks, the performance of LLMs is often correlated to the
degree of book memorization. In this work, we carry out a realistic evaluation
of LLMs for quotation attribution in novels, taking the instruction fined-tuned
version of Llama3 as an example. We design a task-specific memorization measure
and use it to show that Llama3's ability to perform quotation attribution is
positively correlated to the novel degree of memorization. However, Llama3
still performs impressively well on books it has not memorized nor seen. Data
and code will be made publicly available. | [
0.047376737,
0.0109493807,
-0.0336753502,
0.072883971,
-0.0373744108,
0.0238424223,
0.0237946752,
-0.0078565339,
0.0213171747,
-0.0652141571,
-0.0450015441,
-0.0016506544,
0.0383084938,
-0.0629720613,
0.047528021,
0.0130647989,
0.0291162226,
-0.0543658473,
0.0316124223,
0.0005238802,
0.006201521,
-0.006799012,
0.0264351089,
0.0152959079,
0.0228825435,
-0.0278822929,
0.0366277061,
0.0050271968,
0.0280161779,
-0.0201729592,
-0.0099615781,
-0.0215522293,
-0.0337226801,
0.0192842055,
0.0000018197,
-0.0617928058,
0.0086428504,
-0.0348176286,
-0.0221247282,
0.0679124668,
0.0588128977,
0.0264835469,
0.0030040478,
-0.0073889759,
-0.0069179735,
0.0353962891,
0.0248610564,
0.0275149718,
0.0524431989,
0.0586026087,
-0.0127937561,
-0.0328965038,
0.0204530172,
-0.0065565198,
0.0224563628,
-0.0223415475,
0.0355095491,
0.0432415381,
-0.0155219184,
0.0500775911,
-0.0339510478,
0.0680355579,
-0.0120782079,
0.0212048888,
0.0318571515,
0.0175921172,
-0.0130473934,
0.0513495542,
-0.0299375188,
0.0583569258,
0.0433896594,
-0.0402976684,
0.0010489278,
-0.0134650609,
-0.0109260883,
-0.0051448257,
-0.083167769,
0.0258185361,
-0.0208594762,
0.0348658562,
0.0220162347,
-0.0064589889,
0.0317839831,
0.0069839898,
0.0130785424,
0.0303302277,
0.0075792531,
-0.01647567,
0.0155770825,
-0.0144669954,
-0.0353170261,
-0.046435941,
0.0123427045,
0.0294333156,
0.0444963053,
0.0206553489,
-0.0324240066,
-0.023867419,
0.0287546664,
-0.0384684838,
0.1011795104,
0.032652203,
-0.0173693504,
0.0418930613,
-0.0423535481,
0.0760224089,
-0.0438807756,
0.0517238863,
-0.0160600003,
0.0103305858,
-0.0571516491,
-0.0225414895,
-0.0221123416,
0.0291657224,
0.0366435088,
-0.0348403491,
-0.0607327446,
0.0071497178,
0.0303945355,
-0.0107286423,
-0.0219746009,
0.0075734179,
-0.007926574,
0.0254424959,
-0.0131042814,
-0.0112518528,
-0.0318568572,
0.0361479446,
-0.0195524246,
-0.0497492813,
-0.0485987253,
0.0271731559,
-0.0025177447,
-0.0361235365,
0.0202479791,
0.0896560475,
-0.0131762987,
-0.0370548628,
-0.0527017228,
-0.0312761255,
-0.0243394636,
-0.0502348468,
-0.016238844,
-0.045165021,
0.0315536372,
0.0027143757,
0.0208971072,
-0.0433446728,
0.0219607968,
0.0466122031,
-0.0737379566,
0.0274052117,
0.0360130966,
0.0204777662,
-0.0034311698,
-0.0102076279,
-0.0149544869,
0.0304773785,
0.1021692678,
0.0398037136,
0.0349264704,
0.0430282354,
0.0116064334,
0.0486424118,
0.0091995196,
0.0327435769,
-0.0305608492,
-0.0273194928,
0.0047888188,
0.0133504244,
0.0603760593,
0.0834648758,
-0.0294121094,
-0.0079864552,
0.1153473035,
0.0675075054,
-0.0049995757,
0.0098909186,
0.03115784,
-0.0134858107,
0.0760636851,
-0.0048088455,
-0.041047249,
0.0379907452,
0.0196009707,
0.0335706249,
0.0013887668,
0.0216656905,
0.0038771429,
0.0092066964,
-0.0159841329,
-0.0025732068,
-0.0458152071,
0.0001770625,
-0.0065316418,
-0.0080182478,
-0.0504458621,
0.0362968966,
-0.020874802,
-0.0454287827,
-0.0189884696,
-0.0464274697,
0.027806256,
0.0722814798,
0.0595754236,
0.0003326848,
0.0062023867,
-0.0265299622,
-0.0041618659,
-0.0113557102,
-0.0087362844,
-0.0190377422,
0.0339534692,
-0.0626268685,
-0.0063800411,
-0.0381276719,
0.0030973472,
0.0465047657,
-0.0321728587,
0.011874808,
0.0192616321,
-0.0183890965,
-0.0278210212,
0.0496266074,
-0.0219116714,
-0.05369078,
-0.0355448164,
-0.0095899003,
0.0195018221,
0.015577578,
-0.0125408918,
-0.0111543927,
0.0162669662,
-0.0516315773,
0.0206869449,
0.0428826287,
-0.0407931842,
-0.0056422385,
0.0570413098,
-0.0159544349,
0.0325253345,
0.0224132221,
-0.0101363044,
-0.0531503595,
-0.0229747705,
-0.0326126702,
0.0350650102,
-0.0155477766,
0.0404949039,
-0.0141906179,
0.0321218632,
-0.0439673364,
0.047351215,
-0.0028096219,
0.0105633438,
0.0258750729,
-0.0190337375,
0.0281990804,
-0.0014672583,
-0.0483134054,
-0.0215813946,
0.0557782799,
0.0091632726,
-0.0110775586,
-0.0290845558,
-0.0355682187,
-0.0430065729,
-0.0420863405,
0.043842569,
-0.0023318485,
0.0245576892,
0.0046439581,
-0.0098268101,
-0.032568194,
-0.0031717352,
-0.0230206829,
-0.0175055638,
-0.0238527693,
0.0007253599,
0.039744325,
0.0132471565,
-0.0121608591,
-0.0526114106,
0.0084560942,
-0.0305200163,
0.0354892313,
0.0263536647,
-0.0107158246,
-0.0431094915,
0.0468723886,
-0.0211773012,
-0.038015347,
-0.0260655005,
-0.0321066938,
-0.0124672232,
0.0097928122,
0.0397301987,
0.1022596732,
-0.0489993989,
-0.0280435681,
0.0500845388,
-0.0306259636,
-0.0473067202,
-0.0034549665,
0.0210111495,
-0.0394652598,
-0.0583479665,
-0.0440522842,
0.0023550468,
0.0429758281,
0.0387770943,
-7.57e-7,
-0.0075940457,
0.0288949274,
0.0076971594,
-0.0401888527,
0.0176755954,
-0.0021956507,
-0.0478419811,
0.0225648843,
-0.0247542914,
-0.0431007855,
0.0080208648,
-0.0611383133,
-0.0165136345,
0.003034059,
0.0228223056,
-0.0550670959,
0.036332313,
-0.0084377201,
0.0088016195,
-0.0004135158,
-0.0411755852,
-0.0201124027,
-0.0346377194,
0.0604588836,
-0.0268978626,
0.0552067161,
-0.0192248337,
-0.0088896006,
0.0048303464,
0.0041183485,
-0.0113494797,
-0.0152980257,
-0.0650934279,
-0.000160811,
0.0011832786,
0.0127310324,
-0.0221163407,
-0.0455428697,
0.0467168763,
0.0067450171,
-0.0245508198,
-0.0169528332,
-0.0263197031,
0.010836239,
0.0352673754,
-0.0193822198,
0.0233059898,
-0.0582719147,
0.0061878203,
0.001423264,
0.005607517,
0.0428191982,
-0.0422727615,
0.017203575,
0.0203818642,
-0.0342141837,
-0.0160733815,
0.0163564924,
0.0577329621,
-0.0574172325,
-0.0002655958,
0.0764230564,
-0.0069323517,
-0.0574941114,
-0.0288464874,
-0.0113525828,
0.0090271533,
0.0154018961,
-0.0216200501,
-0.0973719433,
-0.0242101587,
0.0058032959,
0.0450045988,
0.0114650503,
-0.0333133265,
-0.012657267,
-0.1141858473,
0.0252367463,
0.0026326103,
-0.0040964815,
0.0101527208,
-0.003841463,
0.0029332615,
-0.0176033322,
-0.0088364184,
-0.0007720984,
-0.0467115454,
0.0149911642,
0.0004575163,
0.026914157,
-0.0025503389,
0.0301922429,
-0.0242112,
0.0770054385,
0.032414794,
0.0610177852,
-0.0056524756,
-0.0139158508,
-0.0375593826,
-0.0295822397,
-0.0133530796,
-0.0072435122,
0.0409229025,
-0.0102433311,
-0.0004268959,
-0.0248452667,
0.0319805406,
0.0038792915,
-0.0140765999,
0.0389389284,
0.0279130023,
0.0196634047,
0.019243354,
-0.0077854996,
0.0182856675,
-0.018851243,
0.0778028443,
0.0321883224,
0.001250072,
-0.0446834676,
-0.0213332549,
-0.0170935914,
-0.0902641788,
-0.0317365862,
0.0206713285,
-0.0576416738,
-0.0005457771,
-0.1009527892,
-0.0024566411,
-0.0028669878,
0.018297134,
0.082263954,
0.0490546376,
0.0239912812,
-0.0273891333,
-0.023738414,
-0.0453345999,
-0.0820667595,
0.0069569536,
-0.0268622246,
0.0134107666,
0.0739050135,
-0.0307787973,
0.0252157394,
0.013741876,
-0.1244219244,
-0.0532453954,
0.0199775845,
0.0775249377,
0.0281694755,
0.0331655852,
0.0085647246,
-0.0381808318,
0.0572028533,
0.0057630464,
-0.009774589,
0.0855004415,
0.0186618473,
0.0365683325,
-0.0291075148,
0.0307355728,
-0.0167975426,
0.0179735478,
0.0414182283,
0.0018897344,
-0.0176472906,
-0.0125209969,
-0.0106915152,
0.0172121711,
0.003736261,
-0.0323047414,
-0.0108171357,
-0.0110438336,
0.0384280607,
-0.020951679,
0.0144600682,
-0.0288634188,
0.0164703242,
0.0412379988,
-0.0136308046,
-0.0295227431,
-0.052927535,
0.0087790629,
0.0394353308,
-0.0271438025,
0.0195625406,
0.0038648923,
0.008047387,
-0.0374539569,
0.0201019235,
-0.0073778694,
0.0173069015,
-0.0097478069,
0.0608134903,
0.0203642584,
0.0519729443,
0.0043250644,
-0.0359029844,
-0.0413638763,
0.0312437136,
-0.0963789448,
0.0174130667,
0.0208234377,
-0.0017988277,
0.0582557432,
-0.0468213893,
0.0952401683,
-0.0193229653,
0.0139697101,
-0.0012957859,
0.0351719484,
-0.0099246856,
0.0297932718,
-0.0350383036,
0.0046929126,
-0.0008310376,
0.0624971315,
0.050611414,
0.014256902,
0.020909505,
0.0152216461,
-0.0422759466,
-0.0274703521,
-0.0370021313,
0.0294266194,
-0.0179066435,
0.0316488743,
-0.040235851,
-0.0643937141,
-0.0646352544,
0.0745682195,
0.0153517155,
0.0367012769,
-0.0419181027,
0.0210443195,
0.0374280475,
-0.0077363714,
-0.0117885806,
-0.0630529672,
0.0255170651,
-0.0113269137,
-0.0208134837,
-0.0404082611,
-5.435759181e-33,
-0.0533679537,
0.0174716692,
0.0034941516,
0.0589248836,
-0.0664133579,
-0.0009204993,
-0.0416404344,
-0.0466195792,
0.0061160442,
-0.0111629702,
-0.0336900242,
-0.000203073,
0.0160510335,
-0.0316243693,
0.0303382948,
-0.0182824582,
0.0293420032,
-0.0098866988,
-0.0603956096,
0.0020324143,
0.0673960969,
0.0286647044,
0.0400930494,
-0.0480017401,
0.0390362479,
-0.0605718046,
-0.0275220033,
-0.0414073579,
0.0047775605,
0.0678000525,
-0.0053589302,
0.029348094,
0.0126394639,
-0.0345005915,
-0.0128821116,
0.012596908,
-0.0975117534,
-0.0308208782,
0.059501294,
0.0023832347,
0.0621203296,
-0.0833996087,
0.0490414053,
-0.0190354828,
-0.0041501005,
0.0037295318,
0.0573926158,
-0.0295065809,
-0.0390271284,
-0.0466613695,
-0.0577331968,
-0.0276478771,
-0.0359618068,
-0.0003138764,
0.0391214527,
-0.0350334942,
0.0039881486,
0.0361870863,
-0.042410206,
0.00134303,
0.0067177443,
0.0121248011,
-0.0009763427,
0.0534054451,
0.0370460749,
0.0630003437,
0.0199260674,
-0.0081195915,
0.0075684581,
0.0067168828,
0.0424383581,
-0.0029101041,
0.009982218,
0.0842765793,
0.0231737159,
0.0105176624,
-0.0424442776,
-0.0193601903,
0.03808612,
0.0250722002,
0.0242723003,
-0.0017814394,
-0.0410211347,
-0.0200956855,
-0.0301373396,
-0.0057421806,
-0.008739939,
-0.0306756347,
0.0289059654,
-0.0275147967,
-0.0342213362,
-0.0081803314,
0.0477817543,
-0.0397211388,
-0.0114325387,
-0.015725987,
-0.0322849602,
0.0781267732,
-0.0241233893,
0.0031929826,
-0.0448758602,
-0.0067581511,
-0.0014196443,
0.0074834484,
0.0667537004,
0.0144272884,
0.047911346,
0.0194168184,
-0.0849544033,
-0.007402489,
-0.0176439006,
-0.021840632,
-0.0110458927,
0.0147453109,
0.0014710636,
0.0121175321,
0.0089200335,
0.0246453751,
0.0071195015,
-0.0216343626,
-0.0351764522,
-0.0258164778,
-0.0160365682,
0.0000628378,
-0.0651790574,
0.0121156275,
0.000663834,
0.0335002802,
-0.0185350962,
-0.0530527197,
-0.0024376062,
0.0016839154,
2.472e-7,
0.023326477,
0.0390729196,
0.0196716916,
-0.0024604837,
-0.0216765869,
0.0130696297,
-0.0307676513,
0.0349442177,
0.0053929333,
-0.0215939786,
0.0250583012,
0.0504958443,
0.0239447467,
0.0080888839,
-0.1120005995,
0.0268470552,
-0.0301717557,
-0.0120919561,
-0.0428488888,
-0.0341591612,
0.0219690334,
0.0508657694,
0.0586508885,
-0.0043695676,
-0.0288821254,
-0.0758113191,
0.0656002313,
-0.0327519365,
-0.0349353626,
0.0421312042,
0.0862754285,
0.0317844115,
-0.0298817698,
0.0200572778,
0.0146662844,
0.0112912338,
0.0281621609,
0.0612281412,
0.0224542785,
-0.0275500603,
-0.0421578176,
-0.0546787754,
-0.0004348904,
-0.0146687701,
0.0293295216,
0.0420081317,
0.0076685986,
-0.0149964392,
-0.019276632,
-0.0104679586,
0.0391432419,
-0.0209539663,
-0.0031230827,
0.0158250723,
-0.0110851135,
0.0092365425,
-0.0072198459,
-0.0732985958,
-0.018841099,
-0.0264942627,
0.0018355893,
-0.0628383458,
-0.0066204676,
-0.0454566777,
0.0170800686,
-0.1175065637,
0.0280161276,
1.974144498e-34,
0.0274356455,
-0.0510819964,
0.0348345377,
0.0601310432,
0.0196377225,
-0.0015769957,
0.0236929543,
0.0341219343,
-0.0007823753,
-0.0695650876,
0.0014058463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11375v1 | Boosting Scientific Concepts Understanding: Can Analogy from Teacher Models Empower Student Models? | 2024-06-17T09:51:38 | 2024-06-17T09:51:38 | Siyu Yuan, Cheng Jiayang, Lin Qiu, Deqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Analogical reasoning plays a critical role in human cognition, enabling us to
understand new concepts by associating them with familiar ones. Previous
research in the AI community has mainly focused on identifying and generating
analogies and then examining their quality under human evaluation, which
overlooks the practical application of these analogies in real-world settings.
Inspired by the human education process, in this paper, we propose to
investigate how analogies created by teacher language models (LMs) can assist
student LMs in understanding scientific concepts, thereby aligning more closely
with practical scenarios. Our results suggest that free-form analogies can
indeed aid LMs in understanding concepts. Additionally, analogies generated by
student LMs can improve their own performance on scientific question answering,
demonstrating their capability to use analogies for self-learning new
knowledge. Resources are available at https://github.com/siyuyuan/SCUA. | [
0.0313348025,
0.0119774258,
-0.0196852535,
0.0341096893,
-0.0047522648,
-0.0052885851,
0.0018509299,
-0.0215614941,
-0.0222999305,
-0.0495851971,
-0.0547895767,
0.0133152949,
-0.0217864737,
-0.039081309,
0.0073172026,
-0.1126027629,
0.0207305234,
-0.0297909658,
-0.0055165547,
-0.0037585679,
-0.0151554113,
0.0060689575,
-0.0536461361,
0.0109009407,
0.0396446325,
-0.0379595719,
0.0245107468,
-0.0228676591,
0.0618429296,
-0.0307300147,
-0.0227318648,
0.0155578982,
0.0425748155,
-0.0234277956,
0.0000018957,
-0.0696948692,
0.0247658491,
-0.0000898718,
-0.0228959564,
0.0495955087,
0.0267772693,
0.0252037738,
0.0196790025,
-0.0129428385,
-0.0479317009,
0.0008604035,
0.0412414856,
-0.0001704399,
0.0285100136,
-0.0221458618,
0.0168302227,
-0.0554466471,
-0.0055851089,
0.0261787809,
0.0467209145,
-0.0005470397,
0.022757059,
0.0641327053,
0.0345486961,
0.0206324439,
-0.0192781556,
0.0291615017,
0.0261553265,
-0.0101932706,
0.0341643691,
0.0353497006,
0.0033334652,
0.0405931361,
0.0425826348,
0.06772919,
0.0113565037,
-0.069620572,
-0.0121207554,
-0.0016185907,
0.0077163521,
0.0950283632,
-0.1101640761,
0.0205988344,
-0.0067102774,
0.0355443805,
0.0232022218,
0.0383022055,
0.0075092264,
0.065041855,
0.0248828493,
0.0345452018,
-0.0076697846,
-0.003014839,
-0.0042300676,
-0.0124606527,
-0.009021013,
-0.0110043865,
-0.0002986211,
0.0780335516,
0.0436395407,
0.0456496738,
-0.0367553271,
-0.0278450903,
0.009939013,
-0.0529544391,
0.0705136955,
0.0642471537,
0.0299769659,
0.0446671136,
-0.0622056052,
0.0558193102,
0.0027305933,
0.0784664378,
-0.0283542778,
0.0134714833,
-0.0981732383,
-0.0281581227,
-0.0477151945,
0.0398018882,
0.0740264282,
-0.0044966545,
-0.0010346189,
-0.0041803857,
-0.0427011773,
-0.0362332538,
-0.0406316631,
0.0329637453,
-0.002617562,
-0.013151058,
-0.0844875276,
0.0081487922,
-0.060571909,
0.0380221047,
-0.027613217,
-0.0569099188,
-0.0189725012,
0.0008192472,
-0.0222984608,
-0.0076136044,
-0.0043009012,
0.0345354825,
-0.0002343269,
0.0177513603,
-0.0412688516,
-0.0207166728,
0.0623647347,
-0.0129561098,
0.0119546736,
-0.0650927424,
0.0255123433,
0.014768553,
0.0102162063,
-0.0592355728,
0.0138937645,
0.0259518065,
-0.0248084422,
0.064352341,
-0.0186333079,
0.0113327485,
0.0354888365,
0.0522354692,
-0.03137476,
0.0159979407,
0.0463381186,
-0.0600848608,
-0.0075293169,
-0.0318316296,
-0.004975134,
-0.0470838547,
0.020830987,
0.0083835581,
-0.0346420296,
0.0064649712,
-0.0282338243,
0.0779215917,
0.034929838,
0.0346985385,
-0.0076213269,
-0.0063955863,
0.0110103013,
0.062782824,
-0.0019488776,
0.0403251201,
0.0565057583,
-0.0224838872,
0.0456015579,
0.0414303318,
-0.012895992,
0.0475654267,
0.004203367,
0.0095788613,
-0.0074334946,
0.0358076692,
-0.0272096191,
-0.0400304534,
-0.024165934,
0.0138972281,
-0.0207074434,
-0.0291325897,
0.0172476415,
0.0183086712,
0.0600143708,
0.0232576076,
0.0299650449,
-0.0228829458,
0.0577593893,
-0.0609977469,
-0.0013764278,
0.0533308983,
0.0341018625,
-0.0486946627,
-0.0508746132,
0.0236517098,
0.0176812168,
0.0231850874,
0.0740262121,
-0.0330649428,
-0.0586968958,
-0.0250307787,
-0.0077908188,
-0.0419265255,
0.0084961792,
-0.011991147,
0.014116806,
0.0396822765,
0.0249700285,
-0.077252157,
-0.0374049097,
0.0422734357,
-0.0641397163,
-0.0347839631,
-0.034409754,
-0.0219879244,
0.003687423,
0.0019928166,
0.0114413826,
0.0351004414,
0.0212515648,
-0.0503379107,
-0.0280309636,
0.0559589528,
-0.0451571308,
0.0036708734,
0.0376279131,
-0.0880042389,
0.0142022269,
0.0069517763,
-0.0283645988,
-0.0364945084,
0.0622929558,
-0.0042148205,
0.066913113,
0.0132963024,
-0.0041583977,
-0.0108300466,
-0.0003483124,
-0.0055897115,
0.0256032646,
0.0297822431,
0.0341903567,
0.0442211255,
0.0446738824,
0.0075297542,
0.0046553328,
0.0155450413,
-0.0597360656,
0.0251061376,
-0.0294072535,
-0.0129223261,
-0.0617887452,
-0.0598370247,
0.0562258586,
0.0011194897,
-0.0339065827,
0.0377466604,
0.0111203305,
0.0306161381,
-0.030795427,
-0.0044983206,
-0.0109335296,
0.0031734533,
-0.0056136772,
-0.0384795032,
-0.0208403654,
0.0601371415,
-0.0027004464,
-0.0085376957,
-0.0467398651,
0.0236320067,
-0.0820625499,
0.0474864542,
0.0513712019,
0.0541467406,
-0.0486346297,
0.0178333037,
-0.0204709172,
0.0159939118,
-0.0012666871,
-0.0221016388,
0.0281303469,
-0.002481401,
0.0129323434,
0.0885403976,
0.0420074165,
0.0215640999,
0.0855472013,
0.0241993926,
-0.0881181806,
-0.0036634379,
0.0112942774,
-0.0030544472,
0.0063729705,
-0.0273513701,
-0.0008934988,
0.0227559879,
-0.0059041725,
-0.0062649217,
-0.035344284,
0.0995484963,
-0.0027739205,
0.0062526017,
-0.013207186,
-0.0203766935,
0.0022733181,
0.0087315841,
0.026951585,
-0.0144294202,
0.0953712463,
-0.0043778168,
0.0328284018,
-0.0238668416,
0.0198284164,
-0.0330480263,
0.0323219411,
-0.0223708767,
0.0055905036,
0.0251738932,
0.0637986958,
-0.036217019,
0.0027481725,
0.0053429301,
-0.0090411836,
0.0129787279,
-0.0902385339,
0.0106477523,
-0.0072918562,
0.018857209,
-0.0451493002,
0.0269669965,
-0.036717996,
0.028716905,
-0.0477166139,
-0.0198171642,
-0.0501045324,
0.0027404807,
0.0477491245,
-0.0146505209,
0.001499371,
-0.0227691643,
-0.0005433392,
0.0181952566,
0.080313012,
-0.000698065,
-0.0101044672,
-0.0201802049,
0.0695510507,
0.0328606889,
0.0321829915,
-0.0016563154,
-0.037342906,
-0.0177288651,
0.0093813613,
-0.026783295,
0.0245311521,
0.0215760525,
-0.0034994048,
-0.042191308,
-0.0286275353,
0.0739920512,
0.0303870216,
-0.0105090346,
0.0170835536,
-0.0344893299,
0.035075143,
0.0153690865,
0.0224441718,
-0.0746312588,
-0.0272027366,
-0.0301368367,
-0.0083606988,
0.0018673552,
-0.0296438187,
-0.0126891481,
-0.0827297494,
-0.0013295618,
0.0243166108,
-0.0784041658,
-0.0430136621,
-0.0513374805,
0.0176584404,
-0.0002157947,
-0.0392839015,
-0.0103670545,
-0.0260641836,
0.0385937095,
0.0451449752,
0.0015520786,
-0.0523447506,
0.0070814826,
-0.0187407862,
0.0573435687,
0.0139779598,
0.0055453391,
-0.0259063281,
-0.0640986636,
-0.0530367307,
-0.0179873742,
0.0054170121,
0.0040704142,
-0.0085621001,
0.0055010575,
0.0058203992,
-0.0026039563,
0.0680004805,
-0.058907453,
-0.0442090742,
0.0255752783,
0.1020252705,
-0.0206947625,
-0.0393341668,
-0.0956609175,
0.012378104,
-0.0333869755,
0.1071566045,
0.0576738603,
-0.0230857227,
0.0073482115,
-0.0145526519,
0.0097260661,
-0.0212530289,
-0.0641876161,
0.0191298369,
-0.0230246056,
0.0421563871,
-0.0389466435,
-0.014571853,
0.0308529995,
0.0072291349,
0.0191693734,
-0.0176960584,
-0.0035911344,
-0.0084666386,
0.0038187886,
0.0231942236,
-0.0484107919,
0.0078081288,
-0.0079509364,
-0.0500934906,
0.072321102,
-0.020527415,
-0.0385864452,
0.0070549306,
-0.0259437375,
-0.0368921496,
-0.0134921158,
0.0537060164,
0.0251962487,
-0.0156648066,
0.0452906527,
-0.0216345098,
0.0191667732,
0.0195245221,
0.0333107375,
-0.0083984546,
-0.0331851952,
0.0072125448,
0.0335501954,
-0.0114096534,
-0.015848387,
0.0266609322,
0.0058459807,
0.0312044211,
-0.0451506376,
-0.0385814421,
0.0485012121,
0.0126898382,
0.0210313462,
0.0084216706,
-0.0360978693,
-0.006212465,
0.0050593638,
0.015354746,
-0.0007852516,
0.002918113,
0.0169050526,
0.0127790449,
0.0292999297,
0.0081840577,
-0.0763427913,
-0.0453870595,
0.0225850753,
0.0289862528,
0.0236284658,
0.0234653875,
0.003559733,
-0.0036127472,
-0.0210353546,
-0.0194908176,
-0.0186833236,
-0.0216181707,
0.0494294316,
0.0021531947,
0.0312920325,
0.0565016605,
0.0262015387,
-0.0107554141,
0.0039008101,
-0.0717107803,
-0.0679682493,
-0.042141147,
0.0155169303,
0.0031822445,
-0.0065660947,
-0.0204339456,
-0.05384776,
0.0144700846,
0.0199624915,
-0.0221165642,
-0.0077564926,
-0.0054555698,
0.0852995366,
0.0434980616,
0.0434773937,
0.016539922,
0.0464841351,
-0.0661359802,
0.0836231709,
-0.0207305253,
0.0036048437,
0.0131682586,
0.0050245798,
-0.0077958275,
0.0034797913,
0.0163252652,
-0.0124877337,
-0.045067694,
-0.0425857827,
-0.0007517648,
0.0407351367,
-0.0146120731,
-0.0274338387,
0.0780920535,
0.0125582824,
-0.0340257883,
-0.0112084672,
0.0222995691,
0.0494726487,
-0.0661969334,
-0.0369514413,
-0.0662126765,
-5.977429549e-33,
-0.0362121575,
-0.0080082845,
0.0189382117,
0.0342464,
0.0051033073,
-0.0205705855,
-0.0527110696,
-0.0073444457,
-0.0758311152,
0.0250687115,
0.0178661682,
-0.0270347651,
-0.022515038,
-0.0192695316,
0.0370588452,
-0.0024884825,
0.0001667324,
0.0092398534,
-0.0194347799,
0.0041944627,
0.0023128048,
-0.0327060707,
0.0137624731,
-0.048304148,
0.0061799604,
-0.0231163837,
0.0264787655,
0.0025866951,
-0.0348927081,
0.0618524551,
-0.0170141477,
0.0398095027,
0.0226888023,
-0.0049405843,
-0.0014279231,
-0.002015732,
-0.0416183732,
-0.0510837436,
0.0305243339,
-0.0262804981,
-0.0138082337,
-0.0379727706,
0.0685560703,
0.0127532817,
-0.0131582813,
0.001500639,
0.0746964961,
-0.0361659527,
0.024642447,
0.0080041252,
-0.0584531575,
-0.0139187267,
-0.0411964878,
-0.0156897008,
-0.0403635539,
0.0461585037,
-0.0211109314,
0.0637437105,
-0.034543246,
0.0762956068,
0.0552033745,
0.000360616,
0.0478391238,
0.0000313518,
0.0158843212,
0.0571690239,
0.0224068202,
-0.0506657511,
-0.0409657173,
-0.0325042941,
0.0275119655,
-0.0011501244,
0.06630712,
0.0445199572,
0.0709067583,
0.0389008112,
-0.0505976975,
0.0221459884,
0.023611879,
0.0352352075,
0.0005262903,
0.0057786894,
-0.0103123235,
0.0129147833,
-0.0579763539,
-0.0161801148,
-0.023377344,
-0.0502093546,
-0.005457588,
-0.0590707175,
-0.0382205844,
-0.0007119962,
-0.0088952398,
-0.0194175262,
-0.0012033165,
-0.021940086,
0.0190088805,
0.0129700005,
-0.0243083928,
-0.0061851246,
-0.0603234395,
-0.0336324014,
0.002203414,
0.005424527,
0.0481929109,
0.027641844,
0.0122027835,
-0.0170995351,
-0.0122822877,
-0.0353084207,
-0.0381623283,
-0.0867225975,
0.0211489741,
-0.1057034433,
-0.0221163742,
0.0487614572,
-0.0020975936,
0.029122021,
0.0089001488,
-0.0359817185,
-0.0213237666,
-0.0019966329,
-0.0442826599,
0.0042120987,
-0.0212081335,
-0.0153337549,
-0.0262560695,
0.0024955317,
-0.0025869999,
-0.0866296813,
-0.0190390106,
0.0181352179,
2.626e-7,
0.0473715849,
0.0067531224,
0.0112140616,
-0.0382927954,
-0.0072033703,
0.0176513251,
-0.0176343713,
-0.0146517577,
0.0242258981,
-0.0118684685,
0.0049434355,
0.0722078905,
-0.0220450163,
0.032281246,
-0.0601610541,
0.0074765817,
-0.0769313127,
-0.0378086343,
-0.0073444908,
-0.0140815238,
0.0668722466,
-0.0236547031,
0.0497582257,
-0.0080810394,
-0.012783614,
-0.0421480909,
0.0260324664,
-0.0301207975,
0.0564003922,
0.0409545153,
0.0094897561,
0.0097277621,
0.0070733083,
0.0442563556,
0.0235038139,
-0.0145052839,
0.0048855273,
-0.018091321,
0.0102654202,
-0.0221268274,
-0.0170668606,
-0.0266832747,
0.0161053576,
-0.0802177638,
0.0230218563,
-0.078883484,
0.0214026477,
0.009103992,
-0.0122282598,
0.0327078216,
-0.017923424,
-0.0166546181,
-0.0339577273,
-0.0090585351,
-0.0101863006,
0.010541602,
-0.0170631949,
-0.038618803,
-0.0211725049,
0.0178601798,
-0.0422694422,
0.0009485224,
-0.0270165075,
-0.0252501704,
0.0149928667,
0.0048212581,
-0.0068724458,
1.455905773e-34,
0.0144582111,
0.0123128872,
0.0335460193,
0.0399750397,
0.0262973383,
0.0048968676,
0.0147439782,
0.0230560806,
0.0499626547,
-0.043892324,
-0.0257698316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11370v1 | Fairer Preferences Elicit Improved Human-Aligned Large Language Model Judgments | 2024-06-17T09:48:53 | 2024-06-17T09:48:53 | Han Zhou, Xingchen Wan, Yinhong Liu, Nigel Collier, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising abilities as cost-effective
and reference-free evaluators for assessing language generation quality. In
particular, pairwise LLM evaluators, which compare two generated texts and
determine the preferred one, have been employed in a wide range of
applications. However, LLMs exhibit preference biases and worrying sensitivity
to prompt designs. In this work, we first reveal that the predictive preference
of LLMs can be highly brittle and skewed, even with semantically equivalent
instructions. We find that fairer predictive preferences from LLMs consistently
lead to judgments that are better aligned with humans. Motivated by this
phenomenon, we propose an automatic Zero-shot Evaluation-oriented Prompt
Optimization framework, ZEPO, which aims to produce fairer preference decisions
and improve the alignment of LLM evaluators with human judgments. To this end,
we propose a zero-shot learning objective based on the preference decision
fairness. ZEPO demonstrates substantial performance improvements over
state-of-the-art LLM evaluators, without requiring labeled data, on
representative meta-evaluation benchmarks. Our findings underscore the critical
correlation between preference fairness and human alignment, positioning ZEPO
as an efficient prompt optimizer for bridging the gap between LLM evaluators
and human judgments. | [
0.0286346115,
0.0807445273,
0.006315642,
0.0321109369,
-0.0277111083,
0.0088219661,
0.0467680506,
-0.0226301122,
-0.0239021406,
-0.0469292998,
-0.0422153994,
-0.0526877195,
0.0141183548,
0.0128226997,
0.0137072885,
-0.04090124,
0.022319518,
-0.0254267529,
0.0223368295,
-0.0285565853,
-0.0034855369,
-0.0008671452,
0.0157289691,
0.0491072647,
0.0182017125,
-0.0070167519,
0.0161718018,
0.0148729449,
0.0251101144,
-0.0262908582,
0.0053430656,
0.0974930748,
-0.0322242863,
0.0493351743,
0.0000021352,
-0.0616392903,
-0.0124131711,
0.0004248831,
-0.019558752,
0.0456119552,
0.0587879121,
0.0155878682,
-0.0329600386,
0.0174420998,
-0.00081128,
-0.016309239,
0.0385134853,
-0.0130605008,
0.0433076844,
0.0364110135,
0.0095386272,
0.0151446592,
-0.0350161158,
-0.0443866961,
0.0167390741,
-0.0104817972,
0.010404855,
-0.0524506606,
-0.0141130015,
0.0086880689,
0.0043223361,
0.0001749775,
0.0125011234,
-0.0166335832,
0.0283137579,
0.029331645,
-0.0316226743,
-0.0456210822,
-0.0259199888,
0.0885345936,
0.0078966292,
-0.0148192318,
-0.0100696385,
-0.0503771454,
0.0259234086,
0.0064190687,
-0.0102457888,
0.0689071342,
-0.0071132239,
0.0228081942,
0.005038966,
0.0137695279,
0.0206902046,
0.0366194136,
-0.0212189015,
0.0875025466,
0.0215651225,
-0.0280257259,
0.0238757562,
0.0461050943,
-0.0446648896,
-0.0680613369,
0.0017798711,
-0.0067350972,
-0.0851473585,
0.0035864979,
-0.0421379767,
-0.0174848884,
0.0389954299,
-0.0133148134,
0.0600448027,
0.0341763943,
-0.0100490879,
-0.0013791285,
-0.0071149487,
0.0754250884,
0.0249064304,
0.0019680308,
-0.0721771345,
0.0299677774,
0.0182173923,
0.0046308851,
0.0041364436,
0.0164410491,
-0.0648729131,
0.0108412346,
-0.0583162233,
0.0124593833,
-0.0262016114,
0.0282365531,
0.0207258184,
0.0281799007,
-0.0356680341,
0.0118315564,
-0.0404593162,
0.0145464726,
-0.0438669287,
0.0163402688,
0.0385701433,
-0.0298334155,
-0.0004824902,
0.0312398486,
-0.0219110753,
-0.0179039612,
0.0043979236,
0.0560538918,
-0.0131411813,
-0.0174651649,
0.0005399465,
-0.0458616801,
-0.0444759317,
-0.0614679977,
-0.0284083188,
-0.071891129,
0.0054932199,
0.0117972856,
-0.0130514912,
-0.0321583897,
-0.0074958275,
0.0263763033,
-0.0228099376,
0.0213660765,
0.0163949709,
-0.0005961622,
-0.0068972013,
0.0037688713,
-0.0159521513,
0.0635798052,
0.0319606587,
0.0640048087,
0.0112288967,
0.0074352794,
-0.0307701975,
0.0254599433,
0.0205974355,
0.0244696662,
-0.0346748158,
-0.0052133999,
0.0266068019,
0.0501091182,
0.0532514043,
0.0773887038,
-0.0301659983,
-0.0023120327,
0.0634131506,
-0.0009089463,
-0.0030779247,
-0.0185625143,
0.073943302,
0.0201800447,
-0.0522699319,
0.040147908,
-0.0417490266,
0.0144783584,
-0.0310954787,
0.0204085298,
0.0623579435,
0.0467036031,
-0.0090194847,
-0.0437776968,
0.0023468828,
0.0001212495,
-0.0134904124,
0.0201181378,
-0.0004655916,
0.0000826225,
-0.0644680336,
-0.0099450601,
0.0370973274,
-0.0599971153,
0.0192976799,
-0.0586326793,
0.0796855688,
0.0890976787,
0.05064198,
0.0288201924,
-0.0038553141,
0.0014867802,
-0.0315663628,
0.067599088,
0.0739659443,
-0.0326675363,
-0.0040988573,
-0.058376655,
-0.0439962894,
0.010515525,
0.0093430271,
0.0449267551,
-0.0066595217,
0.0048181359,
0.0402645804,
-0.0094559342,
-0.0440299064,
0.036060147,
-0.0114406664,
-0.0323088579,
0.0369368307,
0.009687609,
0.0363235883,
-0.0090265768,
-0.0252321456,
0.0138641503,
-0.0051744068,
-0.0083105639,
-0.0072280527,
-0.0052784132,
-0.0810074583,
-0.0444930233,
0.0028281047,
-0.0261629112,
-0.0038158169,
-0.0028803265,
-0.0314156748,
-0.0147923417,
-0.0170713421,
0.0061782994,
-0.0129945222,
-0.0538047478,
0.0518727154,
-0.0070796874,
-0.0070450143,
-0.0938006565,
0.0557639934,
0.0013769026,
0.0122722369,
0.0695970207,
0.0023440067,
-0.0000273635,
-0.0253645163,
-0.0349819139,
0.0352243409,
-0.000308309,
0.0179584082,
0.0537126064,
0.0541178398,
-0.040639434,
-0.0450006574,
-0.0810229853,
0.0387896076,
-0.0192336142,
0.0044901422,
0.0130599625,
0.0007490179,
-0.00519817,
0.0343925282,
-0.0378391109,
-0.0181248225,
0.0209517758,
0.0301377866,
0.0189548619,
0.0147223445,
0.0049077449,
-0.0306598693,
-0.0057181842,
0.0096836304,
0.0409456901,
0.0422443599,
0.0739691257,
-0.0475355908,
0.0548359156,
-0.0512719937,
-0.0284984969,
0.035045471,
-0.0188949816,
0.0087111071,
0.0042392989,
0.0446111076,
0.0600512549,
0.0271457192,
0.0044626505,
0.077548407,
0.0109318886,
-0.0708736107,
-0.0215331819,
-0.0124581633,
-0.0247364379,
0.0188309606,
-0.0391695313,
0.0185631979,
0.073690854,
0.0207217,
-0.0124244764,
-0.0634347573,
0.0480342917,
-0.0333776958,
-0.0492506996,
-0.0242870133,
-0.0297515094,
-0.0130568743,
0.0537262075,
-0.0295149386,
-0.0733983517,
0.1016284078,
-0.0348302796,
0.0218019579,
-0.0464407019,
0.0425911397,
-0.0373147018,
-0.0043269,
-0.0090191467,
0.0304398667,
0.0134729613,
0.0063452185,
-0.0734845176,
0.0017471717,
0.0657687709,
-0.0279041678,
0.015643267,
-0.0641934425,
-0.0017413094,
-0.0312433448,
-0.0689133629,
-0.0609641671,
-0.0666760281,
0.0014183394,
0.0107076187,
0.052617237,
0.0055044759,
0.0161124729,
-0.0021079378,
0.0009477307,
0.0340911821,
-0.0235954709,
-0.0087392703,
-0.0123479562,
0.00764122,
0.054599259,
-0.0080533056,
0.0382180773,
-0.0293263644,
0.0247000288,
0.0220930874,
0.0180418212,
0.0494449548,
0.0026844274,
0.0229860526,
0.0453040004,
-0.0161656439,
-0.0239592809,
0.0509333313,
0.0433334075,
-0.0293665119,
-0.0072780782,
0.1197748482,
0.0417408682,
-0.0472318567,
0.0137529457,
-0.0127597991,
0.0809331238,
0.0052390629,
0.0136579638,
-0.0574479774,
-0.0340901799,
0.0170459282,
0.0588101372,
-0.0514879897,
-0.0256395061,
-0.009173153,
-0.1398200393,
0.0405270196,
0.0233068988,
-0.0239299759,
0.0057154298,
-0.0288735256,
-0.0068409638,
-0.0212217029,
0.050784979,
0.0435968079,
-0.0143845063,
0.03030218,
0.0189011432,
0.02929678,
-0.0527922362,
0.0195050761,
-0.0313604735,
0.056765493,
0.0913123265,
0.0054215295,
0.0264973734,
-0.035775274,
0.0233312119,
-0.0272943247,
-0.0114766518,
-0.0282964353,
0.0066019464,
0.0102785155,
0.0023988399,
-0.0458265021,
0.0300041493,
0.0037305674,
0.0002395388,
-0.0016263538,
0.0409202613,
0.0081008496,
-0.0293830708,
-0.0182799213,
0.0191603526,
0.0155484639,
0.0770847425,
0.0346419476,
-0.0689200014,
-0.035969466,
-0.0286259595,
-0.0365481079,
-0.0822006091,
-0.0292692017,
0.0346287005,
0.0050441013,
-0.0271517802,
-0.0985269621,
-0.0334179923,
-0.0035653436,
0.0246257819,
0.0068653901,
-0.0416165441,
-0.0383655988,
-0.0219014324,
-0.0131871654,
0.0232697446,
-0.0262194779,
0.0094686095,
-0.0888092071,
0.0028525109,
0.010235549,
-0.0474123396,
-0.0191080477,
0.0344733447,
-0.0288020223,
-0.0715134069,
-0.0253226366,
0.050933037,
0.0183176622,
0.0368950106,
0.0022718934,
-0.0520267785,
0.0622972809,
0.090815179,
-0.0098981792,
0.0270663965,
0.0102896094,
0.0003203408,
-0.0064865812,
0.0175954662,
-0.0279655047,
0.0175677575,
0.0343013257,
0.0333136469,
0.0539149418,
-0.0452879071,
0.0392542966,
0.0528225265,
0.0248923469,
-0.0880364627,
0.0025768962,
-0.0403966382,
-0.0085386652,
-0.0255093798,
-0.0357514694,
-0.0308145024,
-0.011647597,
0.018313041,
-0.0126666566,
-0.0021585012,
-0.0011128305,
-0.0232628975,
0.048730962,
-0.0400068276,
0.0151709188,
-0.0316183865,
0.0311722774,
0.0396078117,
0.0046384018,
-0.0180523377,
0.0045362897,
-0.0073414161,
0.055208046,
-0.0077981418,
0.0535153635,
0.0238720886,
0.0250532571,
-0.0004536919,
0.0394836068,
-0.0261570998,
-0.0300497971,
-0.0374498554,
-0.0009716817,
0.0323504992,
-0.0035211269,
0.0547228828,
-0.0133379549,
0.0059259436,
-0.0413224101,
0.017192401,
0.012147407,
-0.051158879,
0.0084337723,
0.0090093855,
-0.0266993903,
-0.0118492357,
0.0645553768,
0.0080822175,
0.014309546,
-0.0426326208,
0.0073576686,
-0.044913508,
-0.0472592972,
-0.0066982773,
-0.0268836804,
-0.0357559845,
-0.0188908651,
-0.0834107772,
-0.048858244,
-0.0221931543,
0.0357319117,
0.0320071913,
-0.0137549276,
0.0371563248,
0.0482636467,
-0.0560903624,
0.0033678587,
-0.0504658967,
-0.0070167314,
-0.0275239702,
-0.0160698779,
-0.0323059037,
-6.62046206e-33,
-0.0463990346,
-0.018313285,
0.0077849394,
-0.0566928498,
-0.0117407944,
-0.0062003033,
-0.0229033343,
0.0208582729,
0.0138374129,
-0.0105168233,
-0.0018206174,
-0.0504544526,
0.0095766708,
0.018260451,
0.0226789061,
-0.0139843309,
0.0661604553,
0.0081470087,
-0.099188976,
0.0153000709,
0.0177577734,
-0.0246060658,
-0.0186403207,
-0.0007746299,
0.0236117542,
0.008873459,
-0.0188653115,
-0.0035166715,
-0.0310214143,
0.0539305843,
0.0006478908,
0.0503871925,
0.0111533143,
-0.0209925901,
-0.0282510631,
0.009681615,
-0.0205137581,
-0.0149385957,
0.0071469434,
-0.0175902508,
-0.0123934923,
-0.0529866703,
0.0230255183,
0.008225386,
-0.0717360526,
0.0026094876,
0.0075541153,
-0.0211551953,
-0.0331872813,
0.0016745433,
-0.0437929928,
0.0083492091,
-0.0354938842,
-0.0327352881,
0.0089508258,
0.060396269,
-0.0144146038,
0.0616800897,
-0.0075011346,
0.0482095852,
0.016950557,
0.0327574573,
0.0814520344,
0.0132098114,
-0.0116810743,
0.0488554686,
0.0252963882,
0.0109515656,
0.0101502333,
-0.02521066,
0.0266465377,
0.0068602487,
0.0183100142,
0.0845167562,
0.0221477635,
-0.0285469387,
-0.0558243096,
0.0647778586,
0.0122913113,
-0.022016177,
0.0396098495,
-0.0104811955,
-0.0225628298,
-0.0405019261,
-0.0712857619,
-0.0502087139,
-0.0601772293,
0.0012639,
0.0455184542,
0.021282427,
-0.0473428182,
-0.057477247,
0.0489329509,
-0.0146427089,
-0.0025683455,
0.0261367802,
-0.0664379001,
-0.0016548022,
-0.00785264,
0.0157741848,
-0.0573111139,
-0.0184253585,
0.043524906,
0.0198584106,
0.0020193767,
0.0271424353,
0.001917481,
-0.0024691871,
-0.052341558,
0.0382598639,
-0.0548227653,
0.0349909738,
0.0084497947,
-0.0181033071,
0.0174098834,
-0.0191741958,
-0.0128571037,
0.0347800292,
0.0091725774,
-0.0266433209,
-0.0375606194,
-0.0196834691,
-0.0144089842,
0.0145061724,
-0.032410223,
0.0195663031,
0.0086774258,
0.0055218074,
0.0332713202,
-0.0233889688,
-0.034950722,
-0.0145720076,
2.757e-7,
-0.0050706617,
0.0564097315,
-0.0078140553,
0.0281713922,
-0.0147185,
0.0617506877,
0.0147862593,
0.0343829058,
0.0316517502,
0.0151529275,
0.0205751881,
-0.001360523,
0.0322964825,
0.0187708009,
-0.0592251569,
0.0382911935,
-0.0790857449,
0.0196233634,
-0.0503836647,
-0.036293231,
0.0605178624,
0.0349171646,
-0.0254069641,
-0.0190138239,
0.038782496,
0.0068774954,
0.0496244244,
-0.0320161022,
-0.0020121818,
0.0232763346,
0.0121437144,
-0.0394916646,
0.0023650201,
0.0214329865,
0.0103134774,
-0.0044398722,
-0.0004561677,
0.0707894638,
0.0397323966,
-0.0176051389,
0.0065747062,
-0.0106513314,
0.0156856235,
-0.0668664202,
0.0733027831,
-0.0117950384,
-0.0196878258,
-0.0211427454,
-0.0198339354,
-0.0213055406,
0.0295555387,
-0.0607180335,
-0.0111853387,
0.0240948871,
0.0045508021,
0.0466949195,
-0.0133590223,
-0.0206356272,
-0.0410998277,
-0.0193613842,
-0.0292345583,
-0.0659755617,
-0.0390682258,
0.0303075798,
-0.0081776371,
-0.0578846857,
0.0157459471,
2.661692522e-34,
0.0385487005,
-0.0205029882,
0.0362486504,
-0.0448774248,
0.0267696995,
0.0240356512,
-0.0067477226,
0.0052352026,
0.029654786,
-0.0576244779,
-0.0166648123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11368v1 | Improving Quotation Attribution with Fictional Character Embeddings | 2024-06-17T09:46:35 | 2024-06-17T09:46:35 | Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans naturally attribute utterances of direct speech to their speaker in
literary works. When attributing quotes, we process contextual information but
also access mental representations of characters that we build and revise
throughout the narrative. Recent methods to automatically attribute such
utterances have explored simulating human logic with deterministic rules or
learning new implicit rules with neural networks when processing contextual
information. However, these systems inherently lack \textit{character}
representations, which often leads to errors on more challenging examples of
attribution: anaphoric and implicit quotes. In this work, we propose to augment
a popular quotation attribution system, BookNLP, with character embeddings that
encode global information of characters. To build these embeddings, we create
DramaCV, a corpus of English drama plays from the 15th to 20th century focused
on Character Verification (CV), a task similar to Authorship Verification (AV),
that aims at analyzing fictional characters. We train a model similar to the
recently proposed AV model, Universal Authorship Representation (UAR), on this
dataset, showing that it outperforms concurrent methods of characters
embeddings on the CV task and generalizes better to literary novels. Then,
through an extensive evaluation on 22 novels, we show that combining BookNLP's
contextual information with our proposed global character embeddings improves
the identification of speakers for anaphoric and implicit quotes, reaching
state-of-the-art performance. Code and data will be made publicly available. | [
0.0369090773,
0.0610664003,
-0.0337688103,
0.0586351231,
-0.0315464512,
-0.0102547267,
0.0229522977,
0.0144419037,
0.0409236513,
-0.0204721894,
0.0228558592,
-0.0136895236,
0.0281978175,
0.0006067203,
0.0485530607,
0.0124526238,
-0.0013893805,
-0.0043988763,
0.064694427,
0.0018227343,
0.0019377682,
0.0396399572,
0.0155245503,
0.0605161227,
-0.0184406452,
-0.0468927957,
0.0314104557,
0.012371256,
0.0667834729,
0.0148083642,
0.0090438658,
0.0047833687,
0.0103502022,
0.0324395411,
0.0000015192,
-0.0221720189,
0.0566712543,
-0.0375298485,
-0.0153683573,
0.0022830428,
0.0371276997,
0.0580978096,
-0.0016739037,
0.0020431681,
-0.0021667301,
0.0007490648,
0.0181982405,
0.0583557039,
0.0397651084,
0.0616055243,
-0.0278181359,
-0.0660631582,
-0.0014982217,
0.004083904,
-0.0008007485,
-0.0027705254,
0.0263385549,
-0.0148016252,
-0.014114853,
0.0326544195,
-0.0185588896,
0.0421944819,
-0.0033392801,
0.0027326643,
0.0024622357,
0.0221639145,
-0.0090075312,
0.0611579828,
0.001630615,
0.0680602491,
0.0380447656,
-0.0348835848,
-0.0072431071,
0.0077958857,
0.0169568658,
0.0105690146,
0.0035639615,
0.0198256373,
-0.0207666829,
-0.0087168906,
0.0195934437,
0.0103155421,
0.0403619446,
0.0284129512,
0.0263275001,
-0.024011299,
0.006102866,
-0.0032848078,
0.0007379886,
-0.0372120515,
-0.0485104769,
-0.0481999815,
0.030317314,
0.0105482079,
0.0389048867,
-0.0077907867,
-0.023981262,
-0.0026586747,
-0.0204325877,
-0.0301807206,
0.0503249317,
0.0211280007,
-0.0253738053,
0.0293706302,
-0.0302175563,
0.0559251197,
-0.0378313921,
0.0438770577,
0.0028181595,
-0.0222881138,
-0.0607132092,
-0.0291693434,
-0.0488736778,
-0.0004413955,
0.0159938857,
-0.0139181213,
-0.0359144881,
-0.0167984087,
-0.0196322724,
0.017664561,
-0.0375428163,
0.0480111837,
0.0037214579,
0.0128440121,
-0.0308781583,
0.013292782,
-0.0412767194,
0.0009608766,
-0.0345232673,
0.0039358982,
-0.0438631475,
0.0056728222,
0.0198852867,
-0.0292089768,
0.0538073964,
0.0665565282,
0.0075425715,
-0.0287737213,
0.0036438198,
-0.023552658,
-0.0427457057,
-0.0502696857,
-0.0380816832,
-0.0079810219,
0.0404413119,
-0.0359659642,
0.0078835171,
-0.0609993748,
-0.0041814968,
0.0375644714,
-0.0494587086,
0.059839882,
0.0525790453,
-0.0026642529,
0.0145118451,
-0.0119010527,
-0.0019418903,
-0.0166782681,
0.108384259,
0.0243351478,
0.0069557438,
0.0275116246,
0.0228017811,
0.0280913748,
0.0094943754,
-0.0015622268,
-0.0302611012,
-0.0212118998,
0.0055190339,
0.0570903271,
0.012976951,
0.0513973311,
-0.041262731,
-0.0568595044,
0.0849078819,
0.0452813506,
0.0083439248,
0.0205435473,
0.0881831944,
0.0129743265,
0.0393636562,
-0.0387298353,
-0.0408520103,
0.015623576,
0.0520248078,
-0.0020025056,
-0.0621670894,
0.0069233598,
0.0018631252,
0.0225134399,
-0.0022730255,
0.0009438535,
-0.0115435198,
0.0005492474,
-0.0259010848,
-0.0027483674,
-0.0471421741,
0.015919691,
0.0027632797,
-0.075778529,
-0.0066644563,
-0.0193281863,
0.011442191,
0.0704330951,
0.0788883716,
-0.0298236106,
0.0051642349,
-0.0642523542,
-0.0270495191,
0.0166643802,
-0.0009214623,
-0.0444474854,
0.0673070326,
-0.035405647,
0.0356234722,
0.0039205248,
0.0009040748,
0.059492629,
-0.0284029394,
0.0019682697,
-0.0033410122,
-0.0230645612,
-0.0249761753,
0.0491204895,
-0.0513857529,
-0.0442353934,
-0.0121525889,
0.0446255356,
0.0181953833,
0.0440669619,
-0.0271748286,
-0.0409062989,
0.0203402359,
-0.0649380162,
-0.0361464731,
0.0610112324,
-0.0638486296,
-0.0251170322,
0.0587689541,
-0.0713610575,
-0.0060502938,
0.0319124945,
-0.0060833469,
-0.0410424694,
0.0101102302,
-0.0306776408,
0.0134852892,
-0.0437769517,
-0.0138130495,
-0.0230978988,
0.0253449865,
-0.0338862799,
0.0404852144,
0.0360694714,
0.0165685844,
0.0351159014,
0.0027577004,
0.0325440243,
-0.0184718128,
-0.0337032937,
-0.0456429273,
0.0381465107,
0.0178041477,
0.0069944859,
-0.0512668788,
-0.0051794979,
-0.0386623479,
-0.0696195364,
0.0146013955,
0.0172147453,
-0.0212810449,
-0.0054415548,
-0.0015608796,
-0.0058762715,
0.0033792115,
-0.0440606959,
-0.0409417748,
-0.0310049281,
-0.0362103693,
0.0459955484,
0.0115648964,
-0.0290305596,
-0.0159569327,
0.017672861,
-0.0705475733,
0.0469325744,
0.0161359701,
0.0330088064,
-0.0210916195,
-0.0060674744,
0.0227709468,
-0.0002800765,
-0.0197892897,
-0.0247539449,
-0.0094549526,
0.0068690563,
-0.0163118728,
0.0593691729,
-0.0318820998,
-0.016590761,
0.0172566175,
-0.0544836149,
-0.048194766,
0.0283212047,
0.0309057087,
0.0041768923,
-0.0567509867,
-0.0327351838,
-0.0249551181,
0.0409437045,
0.0169848409,
-0.0161494687,
-0.0457261465,
0.0478869714,
0.0414228365,
-0.0362266749,
0.0390026197,
-0.0505910031,
-0.0342033915,
-0.0116231721,
-0.0206021797,
0.0350501053,
0.0615016222,
-0.0517094843,
-0.0164399613,
-0.0012956207,
0.012012952,
-0.0423727445,
0.0495932736,
0.004618417,
0.0325726084,
0.0313138887,
-0.0487192012,
-0.0318057053,
-0.0052675875,
0.0594083816,
-0.0242398735,
0.0331900939,
0.028669145,
-0.0082008308,
0.0154020507,
0.0009300698,
-0.0356115028,
-0.0630904585,
-0.0465299487,
-0.0029597487,
-0.0283593852,
-0.0483105816,
-0.0199061055,
-0.0439550467,
0.0037921469,
0.0066622621,
0.0076488922,
-0.0150803197,
-0.0347224735,
0.0049747238,
-0.0099918647,
0.0342125446,
-0.0203743502,
-0.0022060082,
0.0354428925,
-0.0201603901,
-0.0319117308,
0.0347077772,
-0.0550231896,
0.0091219051,
0.0032119555,
-0.0273519512,
0.0148191778,
-0.0225513559,
0.0399517827,
-0.055229675,
0.0029102629,
0.1016284302,
-0.012146363,
-0.0313770175,
-0.0174055658,
0.0027337337,
-0.0053160568,
0.0266652107,
0.0069152857,
-0.0687311292,
-0.0378666259,
0.0200885553,
0.0146458987,
0.0021344917,
-0.0694544017,
-0.022905048,
-0.0887536928,
0.0322992988,
-0.0039625643,
-0.0125247324,
-0.0029516916,
0.0162049998,
-0.0130323321,
-0.034547098,
0.0046074335,
-0.0150699178,
-0.0127816154,
0.0011496621,
-0.040653795,
0.0177291054,
0.0137858614,
0.044956632,
-0.0638933182,
0.0542292036,
-0.0072066798,
0.0963669419,
-0.0255195741,
0.0109449178,
-0.0678083301,
-0.0245392714,
-0.028514374,
0.0170682613,
0.1003144234,
-0.049842339,
-0.013370798,
-0.028219834,
0.0227067079,
0.0028601019,
-0.0543791689,
0.023161212,
0.0629436746,
0.0172409136,
0.0143721541,
-0.0055739875,
0.0503223799,
0.0013838352,
0.0769404098,
-0.0006814752,
-0.0209854506,
-0.0490628742,
-0.0086349305,
0.0189244747,
-0.0590996742,
-0.0603343695,
0.0309402123,
-0.0111011835,
-0.0379557051,
-0.0640546083,
-0.0220071133,
-0.0284879301,
0.0242630988,
0.0912193209,
0.0126382019,
0.0094216336,
-0.001518568,
-0.0498205237,
-0.0103649916,
-0.0600734018,
0.023637047,
0.040018253,
0.035785187,
0.0449189954,
-0.0385042466,
0.0176620819,
0.0636804998,
-0.0482391529,
-0.0508795008,
0.030651655,
-0.0141215743,
0.0152770681,
0.0583740026,
-0.0462959521,
-0.0400469154,
0.0798033401,
0.0134043954,
-0.0202009417,
0.0479326583,
0.0164524131,
0.000663506,
-0.0500426963,
0.0280664749,
-0.0058927485,
0.0211518463,
-0.0029008437,
-0.0151174273,
-0.0282402057,
-0.0142709529,
-0.0012785497,
0.0069066146,
-0.0169632155,
-0.036198318,
0.0245442055,
-0.0365086719,
-0.0051674712,
-0.0249163806,
0.0053090611,
-0.0003384228,
0.0153629873,
0.0424071103,
-0.0243196581,
-0.0192508921,
-0.0541149192,
0.0044235331,
0.0441496745,
0.0015659268,
-0.0099048223,
0.0563029274,
0.0357755572,
-0.0475058556,
0.0366551839,
-0.0040137335,
0.0103875306,
-0.0322765671,
0.0634967312,
0.0027949933,
0.0100442134,
0.0375970565,
-0.0190133359,
-0.0449023843,
0.0064117368,
-0.1013418213,
-0.0001725003,
0.0191255528,
-0.0380534902,
0.0472215638,
-0.0442728437,
0.0458583795,
-0.0311986245,
0.0297792405,
0.024342211,
0.0162832476,
-0.0123468861,
0.0238542389,
-0.0406347327,
0.0276238769,
-0.0195407998,
0.047119651,
0.0022073542,
0.0061803097,
0.0367115289,
-0.0010034039,
-0.057404045,
-0.0476864576,
-0.0505426191,
0.0184664652,
0.0167664383,
0.0177261997,
0.013010907,
-0.0664457083,
-0.064276807,
0.0839968175,
-0.0122453291,
0.0415058956,
-0.0273019131,
-0.0074874931,
0.0159533899,
0.0265702903,
-0.014638003,
-0.0425321199,
0.0608308874,
0.0061287684,
-0.0312812179,
-0.0408658609,
-4.509442449e-33,
-0.0499793179,
0.0268357601,
-0.0253559314,
0.0543165281,
-0.0766540915,
0.0044868314,
-0.0216007996,
-0.0550344922,
0.0115628317,
0.0483943708,
-0.0325854905,
0.0343689732,
0.0019377264,
-0.025076814,
0.0210122783,
-0.0413622707,
0.0611896478,
0.0212179963,
-0.0291022193,
-0.0143518038,
0.1024113521,
0.029031517,
0.0520926565,
-0.1043957174,
0.0250278823,
-0.0552322641,
-0.045458369,
-0.0067620929,
0.0211481713,
0.0432330668,
-0.0188968033,
0.0312152673,
-0.006617574,
-0.0096290046,
0.0048692417,
0.038260445,
-0.1076573581,
-0.0219955184,
0.0202390421,
0.0332259424,
0.0280467626,
-0.0761176422,
0.0158544257,
-0.026941061,
0.0055775288,
-0.0267154351,
0.0744979158,
-0.0190617684,
0.0500232391,
-0.0200996622,
-0.0609666072,
-0.0214391258,
-0.0417555608,
0.000773778,
0.0367780775,
0.0007367325,
0.0164753553,
-0.0091797607,
-0.0778151751,
-0.0103797987,
-0.0594656803,
-0.0186809637,
-0.0502567105,
0.0430225059,
-0.0109793684,
0.0773746967,
0.0435213856,
-0.0228365641,
-0.0167823825,
0.0216457956,
0.0348763801,
0.0074066874,
0.0368429944,
0.1171891168,
0.0139251985,
0.0029274507,
-0.0459984839,
-0.0254646186,
0.0422620438,
0.0244379397,
0.022989396,
-0.0294499621,
-0.0327629894,
-0.0265518874,
-0.0420758165,
-0.0455224216,
-0.0021516543,
-0.0158268455,
0.0032187675,
-0.040875975,
-0.0109495884,
-0.0104590664,
0.0377642661,
-0.0861769021,
0.0074853553,
-0.0020378772,
-0.015095233,
0.0516852215,
0.0151965907,
0.0339712948,
0.015236794,
0.0028375811,
0.0258858521,
0.0138930241,
0.0639952198,
0.0107879424,
0.0620367154,
0.0407022946,
-0.0486818366,
-0.0258858353,
0.0021259724,
-0.0141937342,
-0.0444197319,
0.0327835307,
-0.0062628626,
0.0623922423,
0.0070280824,
0.0031807784,
0.0103452886,
0.017130509,
-0.0167709012,
0.0039893566,
0.0247827135,
-0.0004981194,
-0.0372287221,
-0.0218647588,
0.0235204566,
-0.0038980336,
-0.015071041,
-0.0709135085,
0.0119831534,
-0.0402795151,
2.27e-7,
0.0198282022,
-0.0102769928,
0.06997253,
0.0156411193,
-0.004920898,
0.0522592589,
0.0126636298,
0.0206784327,
-0.0113855731,
-0.0361127034,
0.0472965129,
0.0360255986,
0.0301444754,
0.0228698384,
-0.1076642573,
0.0051106964,
-0.0175105948,
-0.0244900063,
-0.0148387384,
0.0100649558,
0.050155472,
0.0394026339,
0.0899373218,
-0.0359935239,
-0.0150347082,
-0.0679211989,
0.051050581,
-0.0134168724,
-0.0277071409,
0.0270737167,
0.0386191197,
-0.0232886244,
0.0041826661,
0.0414122082,
0.012234875,
0.0415700078,
0.0053075673,
0.0296926368,
-0.0241797529,
-0.0072909705,
-0.0693714246,
-0.0345875286,
0.0005928896,
-0.0058434932,
0.0152999917,
0.0297858734,
-0.00580701,
-0.0165082533,
-0.023087386,
0.007687293,
0.0435460061,
0.0306254122,
-0.0329814218,
0.0088200606,
0.0158959217,
0.010403879,
0.0172109827,
-0.0974095389,
-0.0185468048,
0.009540977,
-0.0550807379,
-0.0044603697,
0.0322264694,
-0.0272122808,
0.0559940338,
-0.0996903554,
0.0241646301,
2.134582947e-34,
0.0224743001,
0.0075208973,
0.0257950723,
0.0518220477,
0.024670437,
0.0030911819,
0.0217621438,
0.0232117213,
0.0276037399,
-0.0158757195,
-0.0157128945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16937v1 | A Complete Survey on LLM-based AI Chatbots | 2024-06-17T09:39:34 | 2024-06-17T09:39:34 | Sumit Kumar Dam, Choong Seon Hong, Yu Qiao, Chaoning Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The past few decades have witnessed an upsurge in data, forming the
foundation for data-hungry, learning-based AI technology. Conversational
agents, often referred to as AI chatbots, rely heavily on such data to train
large language models (LLMs) and generate new content (knowledge) in response
to user prompts. With the advent of OpenAI's ChatGPT, LLM-based chatbots have
set new standards in the AI community. This paper presents a complete survey of
the evolution and deployment of LLM-based chatbots in various sectors. We first
summarize the development of foundational chatbots, followed by the evolution
of LLMs, and then provide an overview of LLM-based chatbots currently in use
and those in the development phase. Recognizing AI chatbots as tools for
generating new knowledge, we explore their diverse applications across various
industries. We then discuss the open challenges, considering how the data used
to train the LLMs and the misuse of the generated knowledge can cause several
issues. Finally, we explore the future outlook to augment their efficiency and
reliability in numerous applications. By addressing key milestones and the
present-day context of LLM-based chatbots, our survey invites readers to delve
deeper into this realm, reflecting on how their next generation will reshape
conversational AI. | [
0.0660525337,
0.0229222346,
-0.0374099612,
0.0183453206,
-0.0442006402,
-0.0021248548,
-0.009551011,
0.0146655738,
0.0738360062,
-0.0559429675,
-0.0383613557,
-0.0071368371,
-0.0223879833,
0.0422911085,
0.0089169843,
-0.0145152388,
0.0277680624,
-0.0369245671,
0.0200197212,
-0.0016488507,
-0.0061587789,
0.0188491773,
-0.0401381552,
0.0712038949,
-0.0558720529,
-0.0093506789,
-0.0484414771,
-0.0046638115,
-0.0073607978,
-0.0056806789,
0.0011938267,
0.0049442924,
0.0275242217,
0.0406632982,
0.0000019515,
-0.0327518173,
0.0085512158,
-0.0109874969,
-0.0548175834,
-0.0435108393,
0.041601941,
0.0061374949,
-0.0296053104,
0.0485730693,
-0.0700242221,
0.0211241823,
0.019303618,
0.0307771545,
0.0537302941,
0.0862239003,
0.0018288711,
0.0126565471,
0.0514309444,
-0.0035288883,
0.01127721,
-0.0430461653,
0.003555167,
0.0214230791,
0.01373275,
0.0148923527,
-0.0123948706,
0.0214330796,
0.03079696,
-0.0352131389,
-0.0124265468,
0.0401233919,
-0.0333485492,
-0.0391565375,
-0.0507500917,
0.096124351,
0.0314282142,
-0.0132972226,
0.0079365745,
0.008045516,
0.0213597212,
-0.0151284626,
-0.0409729518,
0.0463836119,
0.0128448624,
0.023146363,
-0.0117877685,
-0.0322096162,
0.0046888837,
0.0228907298,
-0.0175715573,
0.0407908931,
-0.0059446511,
-0.0255543813,
0.0115553793,
-0.0078676362,
0.0010776952,
-0.0823750198,
-0.0129677383,
0.0681769028,
-0.0267630871,
0.0481884629,
-0.0498166718,
-0.0075796773,
0.006015609,
-0.0420212634,
-0.0125605874,
0.048551172,
-0.0213759337,
0.0433389395,
-0.020225931,
0.0712327212,
-0.0013601171,
0.0307819955,
-0.011730466,
-0.0421977639,
-0.0456985012,
-0.0201703627,
-0.0152563518,
0.047018785,
-0.0047195605,
-0.0490297936,
-0.0272366088,
0.0884170979,
-0.0018348615,
0.0553573407,
0.010078636,
0.0007544166,
-0.0086167594,
-0.0078179408,
-0.059065152,
-0.0029442706,
-0.0075948555,
0.0309480913,
0.0327790007,
-0.0827211216,
-0.0039277324,
0.0482069515,
-0.0103406673,
0.0146457329,
0.0045855492,
0.0848676711,
-0.0014299067,
-0.049807284,
-0.0207974743,
-0.0200686827,
-0.0206698887,
-0.0642749295,
0.0133605879,
-0.0344489552,
0.0472265035,
-0.005671137,
-0.0134630492,
-0.0398407653,
0.0336571671,
0.0240099896,
-0.0366892554,
0.0369744375,
-0.0461948067,
0.0384487733,
0.0398403928,
0.0002756386,
-0.0267432313,
0.0627887323,
0.056993708,
0.0298783854,
0.0461484157,
0.0088134082,
0.0234332196,
0.0426134765,
0.0040258043,
-0.0154773295,
0.0048815934,
0.0156220105,
-0.0122505212,
0.0364279933,
0.0027392788,
0.045711983,
-0.0349404253,
0.0013713469,
0.0742607042,
0.0656028837,
-0.0223867986,
0.0122297518,
0.0264651496,
0.0331328474,
0.0372689627,
-0.0232466627,
-0.0371077321,
0.0204236694,
-0.0410806686,
-0.0096229101,
0.002484035,
-0.0015464324,
-0.0402538739,
-0.0512292199,
0.0067473762,
-0.036999777,
0.029912319,
0.0178824514,
0.0357161053,
0.0186677221,
-0.0359946601,
0.031200815,
0.031008387,
-0.063880913,
-0.0627536774,
-0.0832019523,
0.0388398319,
0.0733722597,
0.0625869036,
-0.0135174757,
-0.0488438644,
-0.0017480643,
-0.0097763659,
0.0754357725,
0.038047865,
0.0047036055,
-0.0042778472,
-0.0486870632,
0.0089975707,
-0.0218443945,
-0.00886996,
-0.0028048556,
0.0335851535,
0.0094815083,
-0.0234473199,
-0.0008069669,
-0.0041642394,
0.0373074114,
-0.0363807492,
0.014456803,
-0.0140618375,
-0.0099650873,
0.0497777723,
0.0207521748,
0.0027644732,
-0.0229313895,
0.0527527183,
0.0020219956,
-0.0272132456,
0.0401302278,
-0.0152093098,
-0.0345205478,
0.0401445553,
0.0120638153,
-0.0143584451,
0.0194971133,
-0.0209046695,
-0.0266663861,
0.0160209369,
-0.0425114073,
0.052613534,
-0.0496761911,
0.0117858266,
-0.0039890986,
0.0277788043,
-0.0056668255,
0.0393213555,
-0.0039117588,
-0.0545363724,
0.0379739143,
0.0417639576,
-0.0074029141,
-0.0488915369,
-0.0090571661,
0.0199810509,
0.0197527036,
0.0016724957,
0.0148798525,
0.0219328124,
-0.0489632562,
-0.0390295647,
-0.1244617254,
-0.006964542,
0.0015350654,
-0.0303137153,
-0.0137709016,
-0.0090201674,
-0.0205740724,
-0.0151920915,
-0.0458893515,
0.0543890186,
0.0493340567,
-0.0034741713,
0.0467539318,
0.0041500232,
-0.0486639068,
-0.0478952974,
0.0555183366,
0.0216813963,
0.009365771,
0.0092528043,
-0.014643061,
-0.0626563653,
0.063465938,
-0.0542727225,
0.0512102023,
-0.0372358896,
-0.0565894172,
0.0398047902,
-0.0277408715,
-0.005148578,
0.0490105413,
0.0264976174,
0.0388921723,
0.0400785394,
-0.0161967073,
-0.092081733,
0.0456524566,
-0.0136748841,
-0.0245796666,
-0.0336021706,
-0.0154659804,
0.0067216516,
0.0278399959,
-0.0028451642,
0.0293474421,
-0.0599157065,
0.0172509942,
0.0463847555,
-0.0692483932,
-0.0029671651,
0.0050287084,
-0.0458474047,
0.0337936878,
0.0030049344,
-0.0530538484,
0.0549068451,
-0.0341833159,
0.001972432,
-0.0122717833,
-0.046585869,
-0.0323267542,
0.0592145287,
-0.0251007117,
0.006566504,
-0.0143645229,
-0.0033881497,
-0.0391306393,
0.0037788798,
-0.0339560136,
-0.0591194928,
0.0131505998,
-0.0442865379,
0.0171949286,
0.0319592841,
-0.0379538722,
-0.071718812,
-0.0182519387,
-0.0266356468,
-0.0063466658,
0.0209147297,
-0.0412882641,
-0.0224523768,
-0.016205702,
0.0183326937,
0.0261192545,
0.004348442,
-0.0056314468,
-0.0349798687,
-0.0123126945,
0.0432251915,
0.0428513736,
0.0018507492,
0.0080531435,
0.0576871634,
0.062388096,
0.0264855754,
0.0117130568,
-0.0319785066,
-0.0323302336,
0.0170931462,
0.0143854041,
0.0015281209,
0.0073049953,
0.0231597796,
-0.035246212,
-0.0184689667,
0.1132727116,
0.018931238,
-0.047900293,
0.0017224977,
-0.0159137845,
0.004547528,
-0.0083118863,
0.0392518528,
-0.1071306542,
-0.039116852,
0.0153193111,
0.0197662935,
-0.0402748473,
-0.0322126113,
-0.0236929152,
-0.1130736619,
0.03396843,
-0.0192335509,
-0.0269944333,
-0.0487492271,
-0.0190764051,
-0.0017991458,
0.0088076713,
0.0516030528,
0.0008538126,
0.0015104354,
-0.0348485038,
-0.0027497301,
-0.0482979566,
-0.03396089,
0.0141464612,
-0.0219104327,
0.0919326693,
0.0642343238,
0.0521323904,
0.0235951226,
0.0081972554,
0.0097309127,
0.040073473,
0.0285733547,
0.0074991351,
0.042977225,
-0.0285580065,
-0.0134516973,
-0.0172748975,
0.0232586563,
-0.0244736336,
0.0115633886,
0.0178053621,
0.0447575636,
-0.066366151,
0.0112505825,
0.0004313964,
0.0310600586,
0.0115113799,
0.0797102526,
0.0229886957,
-0.058567632,
-0.0303562805,
-0.0289216079,
-0.0080612237,
0.0097505506,
-0.027480796,
-0.0051247138,
-0.0106055802,
0.0123022962,
-0.0861837864,
-0.0618440397,
0.0419318937,
-0.0272631589,
0.0187609661,
-0.0140444618,
0.0054442524,
0.0109711485,
0.0161913913,
-0.0126759447,
-0.0630576164,
-0.0058108154,
-0.0583960786,
-0.031466879,
0.0438912921,
-0.0757900104,
0.0091207055,
0.0221077502,
-0.0796093419,
-0.0527524687,
-0.0086246962,
0.0539951324,
0.0251502693,
0.0383575335,
0.0000762235,
-0.0186131895,
0.027813077,
0.0479360968,
-0.0460923202,
0.023246672,
0.0174868293,
0.066814281,
0.0078745419,
0.0439447388,
-0.0733780265,
-0.0085368827,
-0.0081356959,
0.0257621873,
-0.0460301004,
-0.0639623255,
0.0290672015,
0.0304620881,
-0.0123844035,
0.0223980602,
-0.0174141005,
-0.013712056,
0.0387723595,
-0.0321581252,
-0.0016299901,
-0.0739930943,
0.0093086744,
-0.0158962943,
-0.0037660999,
0.0254777744,
0.001164064,
-0.0366146453,
0.0401409604,
-0.0073672193,
-0.0232416689,
0.0071967198,
0.0096538402,
0.0034492873,
-0.0019191143,
-0.0196300615,
0.0427942351,
-0.003024936,
0.0194217712,
0.0125711681,
0.080902122,
0.0055060349,
-0.0595421083,
0.0010989814,
0.0499152914,
-0.0829941928,
-0.0943771601,
0.0336470194,
0.0932055712,
0.0635484979,
0.0541273169,
0.0397445448,
-0.0804837868,
0.0179213304,
-0.0009487353,
0.0425783955,
-0.01220538,
-0.0252752434,
0.012156439,
-0.0003564459,
-0.030419223,
0.0158572458,
0.0637757182,
-0.0046025347,
0.0522126295,
-0.0244567692,
0.0019837348,
-0.0435503125,
-0.0265358035,
0.04730222,
0.0031123671,
-0.0042529656,
0.0162388626,
-0.0206745081,
-0.0444708392,
-0.0272355154,
-0.0005228498,
-0.0250275787,
-0.0340460017,
0.0463192463,
0.0498704687,
-0.0007475194,
-0.0026330762,
-0.0557213426,
-0.0191914197,
-0.0369216837,
-0.0121070845,
-0.0116551351,
-5.938636766e-33,
-0.0269901436,
-0.0297934227,
0.0428834073,
0.0481738113,
-0.0394515358,
-0.0116566624,
-0.0265769046,
-0.0054320544,
-0.0371203646,
-0.0071715782,
-0.0414853133,
0.0421066731,
0.003136775,
0.009071785,
-0.0021913375,
-0.0267447215,
0.0249428693,
-0.0336777382,
-0.0029306391,
0.0323749557,
0.0442664959,
0.0069360416,
0.020425722,
-0.063407816,
0.0169970989,
-0.0065796673,
-0.0163144395,
0.0241598692,
-0.0093969749,
0.0427406952,
-0.0113928774,
0.0428837873,
0.0141016915,
0.0084181707,
-0.0159167945,
0.0155254491,
-0.0133303776,
-0.0135627193,
0.0010924833,
0.0158530567,
-0.0341729112,
-0.0303137042,
0.0278070699,
-0.0281105898,
-0.0177541934,
0.0477950647,
0.0138892094,
-0.0374005809,
0.0038468142,
0.0254551936,
-0.0303691179,
-0.0069796671,
-0.0057460209,
-0.0618260056,
-0.0066307327,
0.0425214432,
0.004918993,
0.0171522293,
-0.0462896973,
0.0633643642,
0.0069019911,
-0.0414376333,
0.0708156899,
0.0030107955,
0.0297420081,
0.0662473515,
0.0527226329,
0.0210925061,
-0.0285197608,
-0.0345717818,
0.0116332304,
0.0582297482,
0.0110348808,
0.0218051281,
-0.0475162081,
-0.0115503054,
-0.0276661888,
0.0095118461,
0.0807652175,
0.0293812733,
0.0265796464,
-0.0026038464,
-0.0546377078,
0.0032004653,
-0.024488939,
0.0297939219,
-0.0143702244,
-0.0339969583,
0.031109402,
0.0389018469,
0.0190742426,
-0.0595016144,
0.0229654647,
-0.0551045202,
0.0173721798,
0.021182524,
-0.0405011289,
0.0222696736,
-0.0033503857,
0.000464074,
-0.0616048239,
-0.0292803049,
0.0358139984,
-0.0360447951,
0.0174108837,
0.0289652161,
-0.0231058765,
0.0474312305,
-0.018800104,
0.0049072099,
-0.0268566478,
0.045665253,
-0.0072778179,
-0.0246057287,
0.0082085431,
0.0218029823,
-0.0207600612,
0.0481896885,
-0.0050284564,
0.0349355191,
-0.0212633722,
-0.0380858183,
-0.0031739993,
-0.0081300465,
-0.058645796,
0.0034882785,
-0.0315262005,
0.0051523102,
-0.0065898518,
-0.0643771589,
0.000413347,
-0.0037955688,
2.648e-7,
-0.003856621,
0.0373449251,
0.0010035456,
0.0495967716,
0.0159132741,
0.0388280787,
-0.0226419643,
0.0099666556,
0.0003107461,
-0.0025565184,
0.017739011,
0.0690312535,
0.0603027716,
-0.0011453932,
-0.1042976603,
-0.0389867611,
-0.0533723421,
-0.0473668724,
-0.0464311205,
-0.0036388594,
0.0490538329,
0.0799509138,
0.0033686396,
-0.0205322616,
-0.0005748961,
-0.0275049694,
0.0644042343,
-0.0636116713,
-0.0209827572,
0.0349213108,
0.03601446,
0.0468106307,
-0.0119024552,
0.0156916156,
0.0377707034,
0.0379774719,
-0.0124926483,
0.0546824522,
0.0231885407,
-0.0562914722,
0.0095172171,
0.0158528294,
-0.012284725,
-0.0382843316,
0.0633108169,
-0.0426115729,
-0.0339083932,
-0.0319111086,
0.0333674625,
-0.0181759093,
-0.0023658748,
-0.040328078,
-0.0024350733,
0.0148032438,
-0.0090160752,
0.0039214804,
0.0015560918,
-0.0628300682,
0.0213981699,
-0.0393391587,
-0.0657225773,
-0.0707732439,
-0.0311366897,
-0.0133310203,
0.0075134886,
-0.0398061089,
0.0246021822,
2.15824574e-34,
0.0062593552,
-0.0004753214,
-0.0133121777,
0.0868672356,
0.0202928744,
0.0117409052,
0.0271726027,
0.0072229165,
0.0109414971,
-0.0686396882,
-0.0173356142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11357v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11357v2 | Refiner: Restructure Retrieval Content Efficiently to Advance Question-Answering Capabilities | 2024-06-17T09:25:10 | 2024-06-18T02:44:27 | Zhonghao Li, Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Kening Zheng, Sirui Huang, Hui Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are limited by their parametric knowledge,
leading to hallucinations in knowledge-extensive tasks. To address this,
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) incorporates external document chunks to
expand LLM knowledge. Furthermore, compressing information from document chunks
through extraction or summarization can improve LLM performance. Nonetheless,
LLMs still struggle to notice and utilize scattered key information, a problem
known as the "lost-in-the-middle" syndrome. Therefore, we typically need to
restructure the content for LLM to recognize the key information. We propose
$\textit{Refiner}$, an end-to-end extract-and-restructure paradigm that
operates in the post-retrieval process of RAG. $\textit{Refiner}$ leverages a
single decoder-only LLM to adaptively extract query-relevant contents verbatim
along with the necessary context, and section them based on their
interconnectedness, thereby highlights information distinction, and aligns
downstream LLMs with the original context effectively. Experiments show that a
trained $\textit{Refiner}$ (with 7B parameters) exhibits significant gain to
downstream LLM in improving answer accuracy, and outperforms other
state-of-the-art advanced RAG and concurrent compressing approaches in various
single-hop and multi-hop QA tasks. Notably, $\textit{Refiner}$ achieves a 80.5%
tokens reduction and a 1.6-7.0% improvement margin in multi-hop tasks compared
to the next best solution. $\textit{Refiner}$ is a plug-and-play solution that
can be seamlessly integrated with RAG systems, facilitating its application
across diverse open-source frameworks. | [
0.0387765244,
0.0498148203,
0.0052656964,
0.0109833553,
-0.0141091784,
-0.0075238198,
-0.0528398454,
-0.0009787104,
-0.0370136425,
-0.0542895533,
-0.0252512246,
0.0110678822,
-0.0373722501,
-0.007328019,
0.0245438963,
-0.0070485314,
0.0529798344,
-0.0134227797,
-0.0008281846,
0.017562734,
0.0122470092,
0.0312315561,
0.0243918318,
0.0218045469,
0.0013919576,
-0.0238466021,
-0.02116777,
0.0176051352,
0.0005555039,
0.0078702951,
0.0282508507,
0.0354034789,
0.0335632302,
0.0051844772,
0.0000019012,
-0.0368488804,
-0.0472355373,
0.0133469878,
-0.027211342,
0.0115961032,
0.0382223688,
0.006704831,
0.0268229637,
0.0388269238,
-0.0417566448,
-0.009419092,
0.0046626218,
0.060369391,
0.0760630593,
0.060353037,
0.0071908543,
-0.0271016527,
0.0482268445,
-0.0172855202,
0.0374259837,
-0.0118602347,
0.007867394,
0.0162205528,
0.0266024824,
0.0252690073,
-0.016548356,
0.0463564396,
0.0456803516,
-0.0226169638,
0.0002541626,
0.010530618,
-0.0720168501,
0.0143631417,
-0.0073701106,
0.0653903857,
-0.0024177691,
-0.0168692693,
0.0089171445,
0.0303591285,
0.0309996698,
0.0023889001,
-0.0785469338,
0.0130848018,
-0.0173493139,
0.0202221349,
-0.0016640994,
-0.0117238825,
-0.0020823351,
0.0177787077,
-0.0368335471,
0.0202058479,
0.0113246264,
-0.0204767119,
-0.0166872591,
0.0281814728,
-0.0233466141,
-0.0225087963,
-0.0018030872,
0.0706674531,
-0.0069398512,
0.0198997464,
-0.0480076857,
-0.0518352538,
0.0481527038,
0.0165046453,
-0.0082817823,
0.0412912443,
-0.0247599632,
0.0444425568,
-0.0454833917,
0.0426133312,
-0.0216922499,
0.0133476797,
-0.0758521184,
-0.0272867884,
-0.0445316285,
-0.0535032265,
-0.0550997481,
0.0606276132,
-0.0661290884,
-0.0128890555,
-0.0144967651,
0.0547201112,
0.0178572182,
-0.0257034861,
0.0077015022,
0.0278033558,
-0.008276362,
0.0055790646,
-0.0101163238,
0.0538387299,
-0.0284212809,
-0.0017200029,
0.0572647043,
-0.061676193,
-0.0397033058,
0.0244120918,
0.0208025258,
-0.0157300811,
-0.0042451932,
0.0080926744,
-0.0553608388,
-0.0282593034,
-0.0325263217,
-0.0676393658,
0.0009832717,
-0.0378761925,
0.010383822,
-0.0668744519,
0.0597440153,
0.0113481097,
-0.0369875506,
-0.0111020468,
0.0102369068,
0.0569947623,
-0.0298829284,
0.0210876781,
-0.0041552018,
0.0002492094,
0.0476926826,
0.0262716636,
0.0469554216,
0.0512536913,
0.0006122326,
0.0250922628,
0.0457039401,
-0.0011549819,
0.007735766,
0.00909233,
0.0473950729,
0.0017182924,
0.0021656298,
0.0400550812,
0.0090294657,
-0.0205775537,
0.0610304587,
0.054129824,
-0.0542804152,
-0.0183499027,
0.0197290275,
0.0034648837,
0.0165888965,
0.0211474523,
0.0285672657,
0.0372734144,
0.014012563,
0.0433762148,
-0.0263572391,
0.0364658497,
-0.0352191366,
0.0258230139,
0.0854306892,
0.0469592921,
-0.0434766933,
-0.0307329558,
-0.0141323712,
0.0021503284,
-0.0092740953,
0.0286501907,
0.0229979008,
0.0466677919,
-0.0436237492,
0.0650943071,
0.0026096811,
-0.054666847,
0.0302983951,
-0.0379583873,
0.0305937082,
0.036088232,
0.0807100311,
-0.044486884,
-0.0237115473,
0.0028951201,
-0.0009732606,
0.0070614158,
0.0334839486,
-0.0155767808,
-0.009317833,
-0.057620395,
-0.0174512137,
-0.0528264903,
-0.0015552295,
-0.0034239755,
0.0522180945,
-0.0175999794,
0.0430112705,
-0.0240598619,
0.0115990993,
0.0318729207,
-0.005422974,
-0.0427156202,
0.0045299549,
-0.0279298685,
-0.0079744328,
0.007902788,
-0.0041127852,
0.0292051528,
0.0577676594,
-0.040082369,
-0.0222316347,
-0.0142896352,
-0.0311393421,
-0.0568279661,
0.0209352523,
0.0166004766,
0.012774081,
0.0377314389,
-0.05610485,
-0.0450663641,
0.0059113898,
-0.0459853113,
0.0185715873,
-0.0644789413,
-0.007602632,
0.0528838821,
0.0456862748,
-0.0537853912,
0.0517995693,
-0.0091483127,
0.0045801224,
0.0277296435,
-0.0261670463,
0.0106607787,
-0.0404435433,
0.0028287037,
-0.0177113954,
-0.0435123444,
0.0121151628,
0.028282186,
-0.000243985,
-0.0454889983,
-0.0355389379,
-0.0791183189,
0.030006988,
-0.0270258617,
0.0303907394,
0.0353090242,
0.0409404635,
-0.0013539725,
-0.0190592464,
-0.0581643432,
-0.005865322,
0.0516999476,
0.0340186246,
0.0180827938,
0.0318609625,
0.0121401763,
-0.0241703819,
-0.027497964,
0.0141515303,
0.0481424294,
-0.009172881,
0.0202517081,
-0.055548232,
0.004427928,
-0.0441641808,
0.0047960849,
-0.0110821342,
-0.0182308797,
-0.0250342507,
-0.0369379595,
0.0553746559,
0.0426637381,
0.0166361947,
0.0161473341,
0.0359633565,
-0.0076544574,
-0.0582610369,
0.0308637563,
-0.0343581922,
-0.0393639393,
0.0022949832,
-0.0300718993,
0.0415126272,
0.0370528437,
0.0092425076,
-0.0034099745,
-0.0230759699,
0.0115837445,
0.0147203505,
-0.041150894,
-0.0510040112,
-0.0248971507,
0.0071499469,
0.0128381383,
-0.0266993064,
-0.0166115165,
0.0708414912,
-0.021539893,
-0.0058922949,
-0.0344937555,
0.0119859045,
-0.0827565342,
0.0361057967,
-0.0142901242,
-0.0021258274,
-0.0270436779,
-0.0205141157,
-0.0458419658,
-0.0075285635,
-0.0374266021,
-0.0789980143,
0.0339243673,
-0.0440201834,
0.0146059198,
-0.0290099122,
-0.0591092966,
-0.044595167,
-0.0426852517,
0.0344381481,
0.0166250039,
0.0091066435,
0.0026951495,
-0.0298361201,
0.0053729797,
0.0557258427,
0.0318041518,
-0.043340385,
-0.0101973321,
-0.010498439,
0.0855292901,
0.0931248665,
0.0361958072,
0.0420192443,
-0.0203389041,
0.0099519622,
0.089661777,
0.0634811595,
-0.0297859181,
0.0184024274,
-0.0162289292,
0.0232255235,
-0.0298875179,
0.0061708181,
-0.0188809074,
0.0619084835,
-0.0589664467,
-0.0376267247,
0.0817367882,
0.0397020169,
-0.0270569101,
-0.0265211817,
-0.0459024943,
0.0573269166,
0.0131143173,
0.0825964734,
-0.0957204923,
-0.0337094702,
-0.0156950764,
0.0500977859,
0.0087126317,
-0.0126614133,
-0.0114934202,
-0.1064183041,
0.0476529486,
-0.0125268213,
-0.0580698848,
-0.011729612,
-0.0224470515,
-0.0135000208,
0.0355191045,
0.0150420079,
0.0551563837,
-0.0400787853,
0.010464997,
0.0140907075,
0.0132144494,
0.0111661963,
-0.0205993038,
0.0061085327,
-0.026010951,
0.0437261611,
-0.0101223057,
0.0371286124,
-0.0023333104,
0.0225790031,
-0.0782723725,
0.0153866187,
-0.0058737085,
0.0513368994,
-0.0092341499,
0.0154192867,
-0.0160156563,
0.0239215735,
-0.0301117469,
-0.013463283,
0.0019215132,
0.0606915429,
-0.0018134748,
0.0141027831,
-0.0478095263,
-0.001031387,
-0.0178217608,
0.0770767033,
0.0360636972,
0.0033447188,
-0.0509335212,
-0.0014256744,
0.0079096993,
-0.0509933233,
-0.0005879424,
0.0286269803,
-0.0122017609,
0.0069940398,
-0.0854915604,
-0.0453470312,
0.0236252621,
0.0236687232,
-0.0352598466,
0.0175561085,
-0.0333803557,
-0.0101968562,
-0.0824419856,
0.0237577148,
-0.0537789389,
-0.0325067565,
-0.0300698038,
0.0110785542,
0.0115544135,
-0.0556866787,
-0.002508827,
0.0345119163,
-0.0801794305,
-0.0380545519,
-0.0126222959,
0.0343636461,
0.0197290126,
0.0629167557,
-0.0010902772,
-0.0516797006,
0.0274700578,
0.0201606099,
-0.0802925378,
0.0486604311,
-0.0158775877,
-0.0082493322,
-0.0194659866,
0.0282788016,
-0.0937214121,
0.0081029152,
-0.0225430802,
0.0522809401,
0.0062805242,
-0.0116650648,
0.0419705212,
0.0330077857,
-0.0070498022,
0.0276721418,
0.0464687534,
0.0038933596,
0.0294918735,
-0.0214640256,
-0.0151764248,
-0.0314135589,
0.0382867232,
0.0067784376,
-0.0363620855,
0.0167819988,
0.0307956915,
0.0124056563,
0.0689071566,
-0.0331413075,
-0.0425009988,
-0.0164387375,
-0.0238250773,
0.0085847937,
-0.0131300213,
-0.0330877006,
-0.005604683,
0.0046267794,
0.0570129678,
-0.0347453915,
0.0620482303,
0.01518887,
-0.0133869387,
-0.0071958969,
0.0290137287,
-0.0901473388,
-0.0298127662,
-0.0241657235,
-0.008520497,
-0.0094359675,
0.011321676,
0.0537652075,
0.0069275242,
-0.0248144064,
-0.0243486669,
-0.004960685,
0.0014542035,
-0.0145060048,
0.0285260659,
0.040105775,
-0.0087284902,
0.0044147312,
0.0688210502,
-0.0160052422,
0.0290294793,
-0.0404496901,
-0.0179111566,
-0.0364522748,
-0.0404801145,
-0.014639196,
0.0252418797,
-0.0091370866,
-0.0165558401,
-0.0296209194,
-0.0257261433,
0.0005597618,
0.0137923295,
-0.0183099397,
-0.0125457747,
0.0285706297,
0.0668514296,
0.0004615785,
-0.064502351,
-0.0461233929,
0.0443699732,
-0.0519522019,
-0.0250192694,
0.0311382171,
-6.61606865e-33,
-0.0319293849,
-0.0035326791,
0.0512461066,
-0.0300010554,
-0.0357935578,
0.0052167829,
-0.0384101607,
-0.0339699201,
-0.0200952031,
-0.0313549004,
-0.0173425619,
0.0024205605,
0.0012467854,
0.044578664,
-0.0136428056,
0.0018348605,
0.0511695892,
0.0046120794,
-0.0394342653,
0.0427988768,
0.0426063351,
0.0221835598,
0.0274284501,
-0.0060135773,
-0.0225458406,
-0.0227192175,
0.0118015911,
0.0335235558,
0.0089699356,
0.0642229393,
-0.0143196629,
0.0139172189,
0.0345363617,
-0.0377485827,
-0.0196372513,
0.0229523145,
-0.1319240481,
-0.0218461119,
0.0089759044,
-0.0196428429,
-0.0719798431,
-0.0465481058,
0.0516594201,
-0.0313838087,
0.0389426649,
-0.0191647299,
0.0083244536,
-0.0184082277,
-0.01582052,
-0.0205281582,
-0.024200961,
0.0122545613,
0.0012324121,
-0.0154524231,
-0.0235018618,
0.0913784653,
0.0093068583,
0.0463729016,
-0.0504342839,
0.0024337713,
-0.0081119575,
0.0648809299,
0.0554719046,
0.0143875768,
-0.0053674122,
0.0315278508,
0.0100972597,
-0.022432344,
-0.0301608965,
-0.0198776536,
-0.0070606354,
0.0240506828,
0.0204841979,
0.0413072817,
0.0375132151,
0.017468188,
-0.0573792607,
0.0544089116,
0.0048066587,
0.051885467,
0.0051606274,
0.0113381576,
-0.0091726938,
-0.0025486893,
-0.0278189443,
0.0504789315,
-0.0371311046,
-0.0183446631,
0.0546996333,
0.0633237064,
-0.0304417331,
-0.0000739681,
0.0563616566,
-0.0209858529,
0.026070876,
0.0538596213,
-0.0294713732,
0.0287637711,
-0.0211608186,
0.0111499848,
-0.0262776613,
0.0145281581,
0.0645376444,
-0.0452666059,
-0.0307142325,
0.0240171757,
0.028225664,
0.0075478712,
-0.0479621887,
0.0221115351,
-0.0261288714,
0.0563738123,
-0.0295816977,
-0.0294397529,
0.0264082067,
0.0508586913,
-0.0043000705,
0.0408484042,
0.0271693673,
0.013974688,
-0.0295101386,
-0.0435033552,
0.0427587256,
0.006084763,
-0.0045383247,
0.0297480188,
-0.0065077599,
0.0275597647,
-0.0279154778,
-0.0560252853,
0.0032762371,
0.0566962361,
2.708e-7,
0.0701828226,
0.01293144,
0.0702662244,
-0.0089950189,
-0.004501462,
-0.0136366747,
0.0072246897,
0.0184007902,
0.0395049863,
0.0011478896,
-0.0201480892,
0.0345251672,
0.0488551371,
0.0135587575,
-0.0993303955,
-0.0001141265,
-0.062063098,
-0.054362651,
-0.0412545353,
-0.0496820621,
0.0685790032,
0.0850985572,
-0.0295232218,
-0.0184257198,
-0.0446891263,
-0.0276974235,
0.0650184676,
0.0237804502,
-0.0499383509,
0.0256906152,
0.0371283703,
0.0023632357,
0.0066904533,
-0.0295421425,
-0.0182224084,
0.038616024,
-0.0010561773,
0.0539477654,
0.0215915721,
-0.0711623803,
0.0103102177,
-0.0135822091,
0.0159910955,
-0.0490630493,
0.0716278628,
-0.0386527441,
0.0098094083,
-0.0046247831,
-0.0592725426,
-0.010921441,
-0.003294454,
-0.015024879,
-0.0081139123,
0.049603533,
-0.0037319863,
0.0088867657,
-0.01809581,
-0.0930436105,
-0.0270114802,
0.0118372245,
-0.0402287655,
-0.008335596,
-0.0505182408,
-0.003501693,
-0.0156193739,
-0.0779279694,
-0.0079399757,
2.822033624e-34,
0.0312437546,
-0.0009081486,
-0.0021709402,
0.0435277484,
0.0370504782,
-0.0170491952,
-0.0365524665,
0.0350485258,
0.0010259955,
-0.1279463619,
-0.0147092557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12937v1 | Self-Train Before You Transcribe | 2024-06-17T09:21:00 | 2024-06-17T09:21:00 | Robert Flynn, Anton Ragni | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | When there is a mismatch between the training and test domains, current
speech recognition systems show significant performance degradation.
Self-training methods, such as noisy student teacher training, can help address
this and enable the adaptation of models under such domain shifts. However,
self-training typically requires a collection of unlabelled target domain data.
For settings where this is not practical, we investigate the benefit of
performing noisy student teacher training on recordings in the test set as a
test-time adaptation approach. Similarly to the dynamic evaluation approach in
language modelling, this enables the transfer of information across utterance
boundaries and functions as a method of domain adaptation. A range of in-domain
and out-of-domain datasets are used for experiments demonstrating large
relative gains of up to 32.2%. Interestingly, our method showed larger gains
than the typical self-training setup that utilises separate adaptation data. | [
0.0009306612,
0.0186704751,
-0.0174990352,
0.0117155295,
-0.0198820196,
-0.0008558032,
0.0642413124,
-0.0306089167,
-0.0224114992,
-0.0414845385,
-0.0829056054,
-0.0305150989,
0.0143531663,
0.0122366333,
0.0097993333,
-0.069091484,
0.0309570953,
-0.075305678,
-0.0463045351,
0.0047542285,
-0.0219613072,
-0.0207163505,
-0.0699041635,
0.0072045503,
-0.0008683905,
0.0055845459,
0.0011422058,
0.0244419072,
0.0073744054,
-0.0097392136,
0.0097136432,
0.0542092212,
0.0277581755,
0.0016817817,
0.0000019058,
-0.0324933156,
-0.0288500581,
-0.0079619279,
-0.0244989935,
0.0060838978,
0.0389513709,
0.0010183813,
-0.018945802,
0.0423050709,
-0.0375295207,
-0.0343834795,
0.0444046184,
0.0021526227,
0.0252288766,
0.0706836879,
-0.0131958192,
-0.0205505937,
-0.0279378388,
-0.0128143542,
-0.0465844423,
-0.0576719306,
0.0170703661,
-0.0159486011,
-0.0134958886,
-0.0469732545,
-0.0298523884,
0.0321005136,
-0.0123051507,
-0.0461936854,
0.0146595677,
0.0049087852,
-0.0120405918,
-0.0061911801,
-0.0256305244,
0.0228518229,
0.0482538901,
-0.0089417435,
0.0203920957,
0.0084260814,
-0.004379658,
0.0184793416,
0.00213982,
-0.0311215073,
0.0287047159,
-0.0005023269,
-0.0290927794,
0.0415697768,
0.0098219644,
-0.005953921,
-0.0202666335,
-0.0019649265,
-0.0222187489,
-0.0560768992,
0.0132148508,
0.0433300845,
0.0256525688,
-0.0010894602,
0.0492770188,
0.0195234846,
0.022147635,
0.0017103207,
-0.0801460817,
-0.0639744624,
-0.0297456775,
0.0044519142,
0.0188869368,
0.0579662696,
-0.048386842,
-0.0102258846,
-0.0140319746,
0.0470996797,
0.025818117,
0.0171218999,
-0.0400156789,
0.0224285349,
-0.0721050724,
0.0158903003,
-0.0653438643,
0.030100489,
0.003558198,
0.0109541416,
-0.059725631,
0.0103054978,
-0.0146959843,
-0.0503870584,
-0.009062741,
-0.0425976627,
-0.0930499062,
0.0075547374,
0.0054611932,
0.0433408357,
0.0299980547,
0.0614561103,
0.0284569133,
-0.055312451,
-0.0234829616,
-0.0159455538,
0.0277856085,
-0.0057719601,
-0.0103256516,
0.1008804739,
-0.0241563208,
-0.0330626853,
-0.0442771614,
0.022820605,
-0.0430916101,
-0.0352988653,
0.0289603472,
-0.0422515459,
-0.0014043212,
0.0082301386,
0.011216728,
-0.0547700338,
-0.0245965216,
-0.0380690843,
0.0284619555,
0.0584624372,
0.0032498052,
0.0154610593,
0.0742980838,
0.0043177134,
-0.0021856441,
0.0686134845,
0.0415867604,
-0.0478644371,
-0.014932231,
-0.035508927,
0.0122730779,
0.0647898093,
0.0442506336,
0.0230756328,
-0.0159172993,
0.0081996433,
0.0412248038,
0.0299266111,
0.0454498492,
-0.0039794636,
-0.0160343591,
0.0056036436,
0.0780196413,
0.0321136713,
0.0390746146,
-0.0084437802,
-0.0021065928,
-0.0154218795,
0.0165682249,
0.0273156296,
-0.0399622247,
-0.0551088899,
0.0071111987,
0.0156835448,
0.0094875311,
0.0186025295,
-0.0127451057,
-0.0320998989,
-0.0057115927,
-0.0172726028,
0.0056721014,
0.0123122847,
0.0731121302,
0.0511004589,
-0.0167272352,
0.0513007827,
0.0247085001,
-0.0338851437,
0.0469027534,
-0.0422425754,
-0.0466438197,
0.0356095396,
0.0091020027,
-0.0892524421,
-0.0370604917,
-0.0155305797,
0.0291962121,
0.0623429641,
0.0377953835,
0.0229763724,
0.0273795594,
-0.0606820695,
-0.0083999978,
0.0326729938,
-0.0049029598,
0.040826384,
-0.0055099269,
0.0428558253,
-0.0072968518,
-0.0486232154,
-0.0367341042,
0.0162138641,
-0.0467355214,
-0.0386551917,
0.0364310481,
0.0074928352,
0.0422696546,
0.0155914184,
-0.045367647,
-0.0227969885,
0.0056132246,
-0.0179090388,
0.0050643561,
0.012134728,
-0.0898862854,
-0.0099605536,
0.0501651131,
-0.0294109564,
0.0057253358,
0.0281165857,
0.0061450014,
-0.0635730475,
0.0278768875,
-0.0304270927,
0.0081055043,
-0.0210672263,
0.038689293,
0.0118562514,
0.0108474968,
-0.0094898818,
-0.0302860625,
0.0575571284,
-0.0648363382,
-0.0134420032,
0.0230391175,
0.0129985362,
-0.0436805412,
-0.0028143791,
0.0144616337,
-0.049623318,
0.0557920896,
-0.0390044898,
-0.0072704633,
-0.0434159487,
-0.0193948857,
-0.0350106619,
-0.0110433744,
-0.0074302931,
0.0609603263,
0.0128220916,
0.0188174173,
-0.0271146353,
-0.0490301028,
-0.02110257,
-0.0323236883,
-0.0270992387,
0.0027724695,
-0.0108362185,
0.0088448552,
0.0299239457,
-0.0055674305,
0.0140640019,
-0.0090051871,
-0.0004628415,
-0.0231317785,
-0.0285184458,
-0.0586907938,
0.0762015879,
0.0371232033,
0.027017504,
0.028637534,
-0.0205471274,
-0.0201177094,
0.0334365629,
0.0475014225,
0.0191152059,
-0.0206607301,
-0.0120120617,
0.0436609648,
-0.0153113808,
-0.0374064632,
0.0176935624,
0.0203453973,
0.0102480929,
-0.0346521176,
-0.0001025251,
-0.0446151234,
0.0093524409,
0.0253594127,
0.0207266156,
-0.0530293025,
-0.0107944598,
-0.0560102277,
-0.0502565503,
-0.0246614628,
-0.0272761583,
-0.0211540964,
-0.0030900117,
0.0004634373,
0.002926948,
0.0322529823,
-0.0635295659,
-0.0028023776,
-0.0705464706,
-0.0432450734,
0.0118296882,
0.0028849877,
-0.043820288,
-0.0258130953,
0.052471716,
-0.05071868,
-0.0127139855,
-0.0245583579,
0.0487795696,
-0.0360449366,
0.0374456085,
-0.0587015375,
0.0263157748,
-0.0199941173,
-0.0554086789,
-0.021611467,
0.0086511821,
0.0002452175,
-0.002720695,
-0.0450001992,
-0.0169992894,
-0.0229969677,
0.0239461549,
-0.0114732282,
0.106253624,
-0.028810164,
0.0065880059,
-0.0050107162,
0.0599669106,
-0.0084022637,
0.0753759965,
-0.0382376164,
-0.0275828801,
0.0143925874,
-0.0131627591,
0.0837329701,
-0.0082519585,
-0.0465656891,
-0.0146600883,
0.0170247033,
-0.0056547178,
0.0098570297,
0.0179120097,
0.0735570639,
-0.0521443076,
-0.0359355584,
0.0638344288,
-0.0123871481,
-0.0197131895,
-0.0254491754,
-0.0099033872,
0.0237012133,
-0.0003713189,
0.022278877,
-0.0359054841,
-0.0246580523,
0.039217677,
0.080523327,
0.0085997237,
0.0186345298,
0.018800728,
-0.0930529907,
0.036740344,
0.0262351353,
-0.0558717661,
-0.0345599093,
-0.0420372747,
0.0083312299,
-0.0263139326,
0.0645999834,
-0.0398327932,
-0.0232573152,
-0.0138335051,
0.0917833075,
-0.0494959205,
-0.0785693228,
-0.0223598331,
-0.0086059356,
0.0938871577,
0.08518181,
-0.0139975566,
-0.0139048537,
-0.0055645891,
0.0583648756,
0.0187302604,
0.0420148745,
-0.0153480889,
0.0741937906,
0.0189246368,
-0.0125238048,
0.0514265075,
0.0118727898,
-0.0334876664,
-0.0001873163,
0.0532685444,
0.0639219657,
-0.0093562678,
0.0240634084,
-0.0019337528,
0.0372910164,
0.0472683907,
0.0460557751,
0.0071147671,
-0.0513912365,
-0.0029357497,
0.0082977004,
0.0211320948,
-0.0383400097,
-0.0333345495,
0.0185240675,
-0.0417473167,
-0.0428328328,
-0.0303220265,
-0.0428460836,
-0.0103994021,
0.0617273524,
0.0482670031,
-0.005244541,
0.0180915687,
0.0462673418,
-0.0199292414,
0.0110812914,
-0.0178533066,
0.0113070915,
-0.0591229536,
-0.0304247886,
0.0278431419,
-0.0449558236,
0.0013843653,
-0.0057364632,
-0.053790044,
-0.054988414,
0.0533890389,
-0.0010723557,
0.0184380841,
0.068933934,
-0.0142548522,
-0.0234766174,
0.071996741,
0.0427125618,
-0.061922878,
0.0351690389,
0.0905447602,
-0.0459580682,
-0.0244987439,
0.0074697621,
-0.0233058948,
0.0355576351,
0.0181335863,
-0.0286372192,
-0.0027557043,
-0.0276993793,
-0.010898442,
-0.0080531426,
0.0874074996,
0.0267383438,
-0.0181716289,
-0.0324381329,
0.0489465185,
0.004924424,
0.0382529348,
-0.0219608676,
-0.0163501166,
0.0428216122,
0.0363466144,
0.0031557754,
0.0097342571,
-0.0258735269,
-0.021603452,
-0.0300215371,
0.0453233272,
0.0113829812,
0.0588474944,
0.0029491917,
0.0225020796,
-0.0062460387,
0.0214064065,
0.0384137221,
0.0269623604,
-0.0051337993,
0.0137000112,
0.0259801932,
0.0232154541,
0.0596926324,
-0.0120143713,
-0.0459199399,
0.0111412304,
-0.0612283945,
-0.0145108933,
-0.0059018969,
-0.0030933858,
0.0547419563,
-0.0041171373,
0.012523395,
-0.0069177286,
-0.0028171022,
-0.0217403881,
0.0666183531,
-0.0006915,
-0.0219836067,
0.0211806502,
0.0234501753,
0.0404846855,
0.0060833916,
0.0494460501,
0.0042781471,
0.0518454462,
-0.0393237285,
-0.037523482,
-0.0034475687,
-0.0141935814,
-0.0158737525,
-0.0069511812,
0.0219212603,
-0.0522270314,
0.0377075411,
-0.0223131664,
0.0174037851,
-0.0487841889,
0.0287085939,
0.0082975179,
-0.0365498997,
0.0156844798,
0.0129759153,
-0.011735999,
0.0467728339,
-0.0125046596,
0.010760081,
-6.093646635e-33,
-0.0557042062,
0.0167950038,
0.0314859971,
0.0244677495,
-0.019361563,
-0.0053191353,
-0.0164102484,
0.0146377087,
0.0225087125,
0.0103494897,
-0.0306007117,
0.0217282865,
0.0694273263,
0.0122427046,
-0.0070736082,
-0.0168564301,
0.1032983586,
-0.0638566241,
-0.0012786106,
-0.0096987179,
0.0032073921,
0.058345098,
0.0391587354,
-0.1212981939,
-0.0177117549,
0.0237611365,
0.0049116267,
-0.0240255911,
0.01597373,
0.0222865045,
0.0037661714,
0.0367769711,
-0.0087399799,
-0.0702685192,
-0.0339709632,
0.0217624251,
-0.0961165354,
-0.0006565444,
-0.0370784625,
0.060483899,
0.0111714117,
-0.0258828513,
0.0326355733,
0.0227526166,
-0.0383621678,
-0.0537936538,
0.031714052,
-0.0552050844,
-0.0020980714,
-0.0210504346,
-0.0412319079,
0.0406856053,
-0.0076385089,
-0.0370281078,
0.0577586405,
0.0727507547,
-0.0303271543,
-0.0884858444,
-0.0745032951,
0.0444094203,
0.0391502939,
0.0751834884,
0.0264502279,
0.026731424,
-0.0588783659,
0.0073140929,
0.0481694415,
-0.0161991585,
0.0744102299,
-0.0559967346,
0.0495887548,
-0.017978292,
0.0123391459,
0.0332898572,
0.0254552085,
-0.0406669676,
-0.0441916101,
0.0190852899,
-0.0061356034,
-0.0799813643,
0.0172754861,
0.0028332598,
-0.0283770412,
0.0071199532,
-0.0162382908,
0.0034058695,
-0.0057968441,
-0.0056007304,
0.0551034547,
-0.0043523903,
-0.0182338208,
-0.0075309854,
0.046115838,
-0.0352823623,
0.0136762504,
-0.0424809381,
-0.015170807,
-0.0136494366,
-0.0437759086,
-0.0040744506,
-0.0494741462,
-0.0706387237,
0.0359916016,
0.0821203738,
0.0163393002,
-0.0269530658,
0.0383978784,
0.0524537042,
-0.0649200454,
-0.0142388726,
0.0046066693,
0.048503492,
0.0227598026,
0.0216763038,
0.009117662,
-0.0103133814,
0.0091040814,
0.0318884999,
0.0146480249,
-0.0395243652,
-0.0417847969,
0.0666453391,
0.0008691698,
0.0403317921,
-0.0258282684,
-0.0120593812,
0.0089707086,
-0.0083104251,
0.0170525108,
-0.0479250439,
-0.0141648296,
-0.0024845169,
2.695e-7,
0.0061711795,
0.0397851877,
0.0274292473,
-0.0409264304,
0.0267382134,
0.0333093964,
-0.0547598749,
0.0430385284,
0.0511336327,
0.0527310781,
0.0233934969,
0.0021060323,
0.0863883495,
0.0373785608,
-0.064852342,
-0.0602955818,
-0.0350379124,
0.0477772579,
-0.0020462158,
0.0317061171,
-0.0197244827,
0.0419231132,
-0.0132618425,
-0.0406344607,
-0.007429156,
-0.0388761014,
0.0262442306,
0.0008629414,
0.0332156606,
0.0132394303,
0.0007663932,
0.0048704823,
-0.0134713585,
0.0569046214,
-0.0538396165,
0.0401983112,
-0.0005053871,
0.0126920361,
-0.0101799909,
-0.0227550734,
0.0044956771,
0.0563262627,
-0.0086685587,
0.0230032243,
0.0183870289,
-0.072552219,
0.0005556743,
0.002469063,
-0.0358538777,
-0.0276571829,
0.0001559138,
0.0097367177,
0.0224468093,
0.0152885243,
0.0258839093,
0.0316765606,
-0.0539122932,
-0.0219973624,
0.0113913044,
0.0057366085,
-0.0458975136,
-0.0062808958,
-0.0500903577,
0.0047415975,
0.0053726011,
-0.0519532636,
0.0126894452,
2.063354188e-34,
0.0114136804,
-0.0153220035,
0.0225044712,
-0.0020124549,
-0.0304261055,
-0.0168677792,
0.0209000744,
0.0129072107,
0.0075272154,
-0.0250821952,
-0.0255184043
] |
Subsets and Splits