id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12950v1 | MolecularGPT: Open Large Language Model (LLM) for Few-Shot Molecular Property Prediction | 2024-06-18T12:54:47 | 2024-06-18T12:54:47 | Yuyan Liu, Sirui Ding, Sheng Zhou, Wenqi Fan, Qiaoyu Tan | q-bio.QM | q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Molecular property prediction (MPP) is a fundamental and crucial task in drug
discovery. However, prior methods are limited by the requirement for a large
number of labeled molecules and their restricted ability to generalize for
unseen and new tasks, both of which are essential for real-world applications.
To address these challenges, we present MolecularGPT for few-shot MPP. From a
perspective on instruction tuning, we fine-tune large language models (LLMs)
based on curated molecular instructions spanning over 1000 property prediction
tasks. This enables building a versatile and specialized LLM that can be
adapted to novel MPP tasks without any fine-tuning through zero- and few-shot
in-context learning (ICL). MolecularGPT exhibits competitive in-context
reasoning capabilities across 10 downstream evaluation datasets, setting new
benchmarks for few-shot molecular prediction tasks. More importantly, with just
two-shot examples, MolecularGPT can outperform standard supervised graph neural
network methods on 4 out of 7 datasets. It also excels state-of-the-art LLM
baselines by up to 16.6% increase on classification accuracy and decrease of
199.17 on regression metrics (e.g., RMSE) under zero-shot. This study
demonstrates the potential of LLMs as effective few-shot molecular property
predictors. The code is available at https://github.com/NYUSHCS/MolecularGPT. | [
0.0004663382,
0.0773982406,
0.022000473,
0.0021083502,
-0.0073080286,
-0.0031557642,
0.0254919752,
-0.0047045266,
0.0366819464,
-0.020869391,
-0.0166091081,
-0.0099213114,
-0.0150893349,
0.0389466994,
0.030694427,
0.0331300534,
0.0163362306,
-0.0045547104,
-0.0174128748,
-0.041715879,
0.0005822152,
0.0286169816,
0.0386001468,
0.0187572669,
0.0306660533,
-0.0319021158,
-0.0016641866,
0.0068713394,
-0.0126470197,
-0.0551226176,
0.0060430947,
0.0450241677,
0.024798695,
0.035812594,
0.0000019393,
-0.03051644,
-0.0139547056,
0.0398132876,
-0.0163857751,
0.0007452266,
0.0338154323,
-0.016171487,
0.0212451853,
-0.0120029533,
-0.0127823623,
-0.0434247777,
0.0769622847,
0.0227367636,
-0.0194936544,
0.0612753071,
0.0083260722,
-0.0343206562,
0.0357224755,
-0.0287413225,
0.1043369547,
-0.0604314804,
0.0436343476,
0.0131718572,
0.0082753301,
-0.0040314025,
-0.0231842175,
0.0053736521,
-0.0089926617,
-0.0007372097,
0.0194799136,
0.0315668359,
-0.0189198777,
-0.0222431701,
0.0011245166,
0.1184570268,
-0.0373410732,
-0.0304654967,
-0.0620077625,
-0.0065340828,
-0.0320437215,
-0.0083622243,
-0.0536324196,
0.0035579382,
0.0158921499,
0.0318158455,
0.0027763236,
0.0121910973,
0.0753399357,
0.0012739009,
0.0128225172,
0.0661761314,
0.0020708912,
0.0138561316,
0.0118289515,
-0.0115277115,
-0.0734528229,
0.0061156815,
-0.0610685237,
0.0032782799,
-0.0136478003,
0.0196376368,
0.0542603806,
0.0058072302,
0.0320980214,
-0.0408789292,
0.0631083697,
0.0130430413,
0.0168213025,
0.0496036597,
-0.049464792,
0.0201422293,
-0.028088348,
0.0365832113,
-0.0123759946,
-0.0006426873,
-0.0941292718,
0.0291944854,
0.0043976824,
0.0363556184,
0.0084055504,
-0.0169950239,
-0.0722578913,
0.0216427594,
0.0077360077,
0.0053731701,
0.0260768123,
0.0523227975,
-0.0189461652,
0.0149798123,
-0.017368177,
0.0177574325,
0.0058883955,
-0.008776674,
-0.0304460991,
-0.0504732952,
-0.0396344215,
-0.0024997108,
0.0079440586,
-0.0410852917,
0.0525311381,
0.0755628273,
0.0161044337,
-0.0531579852,
0.0043128869,
-0.0520278849,
-0.0120805167,
-0.0873223767,
0.0267063379,
-0.0631707981,
0.0249778461,
0.0354888178,
-0.0013591544,
-0.0651294589,
0.0111863306,
-0.0010315017,
-0.0535864644,
0.1041488051,
0.016132962,
-0.0513618402,
0.0039944309,
0.000791806,
-0.008751926,
0.0236055832,
-0.0021719106,
0.019283792,
-0.0131597547,
0.0017557581,
-0.0068254191,
0.0074263862,
0.0385139249,
-0.0484915562,
0.0053264098,
0.0143733593,
0.0394876413,
0.0159883089,
-0.0382953361,
-0.0041738227,
-0.007233005,
-0.0219475701,
0.03635199,
0.024574006,
0.016378697,
0.0176158175,
0.0085620321,
0.0283691548,
-0.041245956,
-0.0660802647,
-0.0701441541,
0.0455049686,
-0.027054267,
0.0270893164,
0.044796519,
0.0022170506,
-0.0170018803,
0.0076940525,
-0.0180549622,
-0.0189322736,
0.0083265658,
-0.0406618454,
0.0560376234,
-0.0384139344,
-0.1126198992,
0.0228445549,
0.0630264729,
-0.0129136713,
-0.0473986082,
-0.0002023084,
0.0304535348,
0.0368986949,
0.033828076,
-0.0387385152,
-0.0322896875,
0.0104280477,
-0.0168132763,
-0.0363346972,
-0.0080335597,
-0.0132465642,
0.0403147936,
-0.0172256976,
-0.0023957642,
-0.0536764041,
0.0127768079,
0.0056242547,
0.0141786076,
-0.0065911934,
0.0049931146,
-0.0577318147,
0.0006059897,
0.0044942698,
0.0083733713,
-0.056057442,
0.0459658056,
-0.0071122791,
0.0348052271,
-0.0118315201,
0.0024738589,
0.0249885786,
0.0310653653,
-0.0394662991,
-0.0108546037,
-0.0595863797,
0.0016921797,
-0.0662405491,
0.0392695665,
0.0053444132,
0.0349567048,
-0.0147907585,
-0.0773569271,
-0.0226488169,
0.0725049227,
-0.004446778,
0.0170758925,
-0.0403325781,
-0.0130171496,
0.0012893851,
0.0717155486,
-0.0230235327,
0.0215150714,
0.0063870056,
-0.0004033438,
0.0197794661,
0.0165838096,
0.0255665537,
-0.0018654612,
0.0146293985,
-0.0005658009,
0.0246564522,
0.0149154328,
0.0048339777,
0.0049934057,
-0.0148577224,
0.0087004164,
-0.0358321145,
0.0059872488,
-0.0120573789,
0.0119004063,
-0.0106227165,
0.0022348654,
0.0171334427,
-0.0124490373,
-0.020910833,
0.0116310017,
-0.0454540811,
0.0005503829,
0.02616781,
0.0227656141,
-0.0624365807,
-0.0340176448,
-0.0559084602,
-0.0382613391,
0.0967729613,
-0.0270274002,
-0.0259935036,
0.0412568003,
0.0080142384,
-0.0043256888,
0.0077200043,
-0.009412311,
0.014358948,
-0.007432682,
-0.0358203351,
-0.0127097759,
0.0202295426,
-0.0590384714,
-0.000897163,
0.0530095845,
0.0082548475,
-0.015096643,
0.0140413186,
-0.0579903573,
-0.0438365005,
0.0446958058,
0.019762272,
-0.0485214889,
0.0544747598,
-0.0154053504,
-0.0071661365,
-0.0578103513,
0.0227739513,
0.0182343926,
-0.0199995227,
-0.0440144762,
0.0310507827,
0.0152599113,
-0.0154575985,
0.0223053414,
-0.0763914809,
0.0725581199,
-0.0159597043,
0.0083946669,
-0.0230149161,
0.0112439413,
-0.041438546,
0.0228205211,
0.0298911948,
0.0084360316,
0.0083904881,
0.0060521332,
-0.0173736326,
-0.0313584358,
0.0121553,
-0.0098541919,
0.0133151487,
-0.0082025789,
0.0036095099,
0.0272528641,
-0.0305777285,
0.0236814339,
0.0089958068,
-0.0295016486,
0.0655417144,
0.0151694557,
-0.0387113914,
0.0001386323,
-0.0080709169,
-0.0258340389,
0.0124790445,
-0.03096224,
0.0035350996,
-0.0258039068,
-0.0155759836,
0.0374428295,
-0.1126678288,
-0.0060294778,
-0.0388675854,
0.0593204424,
0.0214703977,
-0.0118419221,
0.0031647258,
-0.0272952225,
0.0334886648,
-0.0140870064,
0.0201515052,
-0.0479689799,
0.0400138833,
0.0058140755,
-0.0429376177,
-0.0235511232,
0.1024140045,
0.0272936039,
-0.0448279642,
0.0096759871,
0.0043715681,
-0.0015375308,
0.0011101858,
0.0602005236,
-0.0981111825,
-0.0631358996,
-0.0640622601,
0.0242519043,
0.0202349331,
-0.026659904,
-0.0107705025,
-0.0589979626,
0.0399628021,
0.0201835372,
-0.0449272506,
-0.0251124594,
-0.0721176788,
-0.0438451618,
-0.0567113608,
-0.0081764599,
0.0090698227,
0.016914105,
0.0022656454,
-0.0095367506,
-0.0252730232,
-0.0420843326,
0.089268446,
0.0076909671,
-0.0177225936,
0.0572041236,
-0.00524113,
0.0264011733,
0.0120598609,
0.0288507063,
0.0162424874,
0.0275083631,
-0.0328535698,
0.0783404782,
0.0157540608,
-0.0017666628,
-0.0201381855,
0.0341131799,
-0.0357235521,
-0.0433268547,
-0.0481537543,
0.116483286,
-0.0067680348,
-0.0509380437,
-0.0211552214,
-0.0036196935,
-0.0071679037,
0.0476115867,
-0.0076281424,
-0.0130842393,
-0.0799539313,
-0.0109648192,
-0.0117347781,
-0.0332694389,
0.0145981805,
0.0012515201,
-0.0083688283,
-0.0111287357,
-0.0202760044,
0.0177114792,
0.0426853709,
-0.0370908901,
-0.0262933206,
0.0211071577,
0.0284257252,
-0.0249016453,
-0.0738215894,
0.0131807672,
0.022704944,
0.018108936,
-0.0253207255,
-0.0235217493,
0.0651590526,
-0.0144908763,
-0.0060840128,
0.0445369184,
-0.1071162298,
-0.0725572482,
-0.0451297872,
0.02642617,
0.009436151,
0.0380341709,
-0.0008582871,
-0.0533543751,
0.0634339973,
0.0460231788,
0.0265878178,
-0.0320996121,
0.0053767231,
-0.0304110032,
-0.0166986287,
0.0218396727,
-0.0113192853,
0.0308861714,
0.039295353,
-0.0151386168,
0.0137352729,
0.0241379347,
0.0350636207,
0.0175258964,
0.0703665763,
0.0068286718,
0.010383103,
-0.0122266151,
-0.0055657034,
0.042271696,
0.0129717262,
-0.0145771215,
-0.0263213199,
0.0481874309,
-0.0260725208,
-0.0343121625,
-0.0245932657,
-0.0072592101,
0.0130751617,
-0.031033162,
0.0027082977,
-0.0211611278,
-0.0174996555,
0.0985040069,
-0.0070836735,
-0.0070861708,
0.0099385148,
-0.043818891,
0.0344779864,
-0.0262805037,
0.0437963083,
0.0104904659,
0.0613005869,
-0.0460133366,
0.0071685221,
0.0106188767,
-0.0019135097,
-0.0768021122,
0.0407733805,
0.0373719074,
0.0021445116,
0.024323795,
-0.0163609181,
-0.0139877712,
-0.0497679561,
0.0418403931,
-0.0006910212,
-0.0291179791,
0.0510140024,
0.0365900509,
-0.0430176184,
-0.0120445564,
0.0683714002,
0.056519255,
0.0389078073,
0.0264327284,
-0.0259767994,
-0.0335431807,
-0.0002389074,
-0.017654404,
0.0268267877,
-0.0100039383,
0.0568920188,
-0.0407624021,
-0.0366238877,
0.0300150961,
-0.0128122987,
-0.0090622343,
0.0301235449,
-0.006255846,
0.033837188,
0.0157747269,
-0.0760528743,
-0.0161589142,
-0.0100691803,
0.0090551404,
-0.0300370976,
-0.0050155893,
-5.986532283e-33,
0.0161074363,
-0.0306789316,
-0.0090674609,
0.0128227137,
0.0366800055,
-0.0005059129,
-0.0912417173,
-0.010365136,
-0.010805456,
0.0711825117,
0.0086585963,
-0.0052543068,
-0.0074907616,
-0.0035664425,
0.0224720445,
-0.0247764774,
0.0031689233,
0.0239316672,
0.0253925063,
0.0476859547,
0.0449834131,
0.0466484353,
0.0673349872,
-0.006562504,
-0.0303087141,
0.0163754709,
-0.005609279,
-0.0153419329,
-0.0509060882,
0.0382175855,
-0.0071991868,
0.054844968,
-0.024269646,
-0.0514895692,
-0.0246745571,
-0.0206500143,
-0.0357499085,
0.0028983462,
0.0112167262,
-0.0036588341,
0.0079145692,
-0.0075266906,
-0.0236292034,
0.0078466479,
-0.0164761823,
-0.0582375303,
0.014607762,
-0.000652025,
-0.0303057488,
-0.0167956762,
-0.0417550988,
0.0467038937,
0.0153092435,
0.0010396806,
0.0080922078,
-0.0255298894,
0.0201748312,
0.0399677828,
-0.0344124809,
0.0217017084,
-0.032605093,
0.0311733056,
0.0653390884,
0.0061325203,
0.0278245732,
0.059103407,
-0.0149891665,
0.0112990774,
-0.0177874546,
0.0005562451,
0.0010026527,
0.0927387848,
0.0112121589,
0.0082961572,
0.040109314,
0.0329034403,
-0.1355352104,
-0.0120550841,
-0.0020162098,
0.027755864,
0.0151648913,
0.0205805991,
-0.0011637325,
-0.0432334132,
-0.0212220494,
0.0073798131,
-0.0173383635,
-0.0266086012,
-0.0141736865,
-0.0377780572,
-0.0390843414,
0.0194267631,
0.033439029,
-0.0639845431,
-0.0282998234,
0.0600243472,
-0.025376739,
-0.0096605644,
-0.0135994125,
0.0038367193,
-0.0655805096,
-0.0146607691,
0.0230633058,
-0.0410703346,
0.026550727,
0.0008441313,
0.0669126809,
0.0316089578,
-0.0411913767,
-0.0473123528,
-0.0810301304,
0.0075608175,
0.0160587952,
0.0321856402,
0.0022990364,
0.0431416295,
-0.0158830844,
0.0946824327,
0.0417511314,
0.0027100765,
0.0200976301,
0.0185723919,
0.0433212593,
-0.0032148128,
-0.0867272243,
0.0082776612,
-0.0207324196,
-0.0162764341,
0.0151843913,
-0.0410105698,
-0.0445507839,
0.0134926941,
2.797e-7,
0.078332305,
0.0505090393,
0.0164986085,
0.0225267671,
0.0041303588,
0.0461743362,
0.0073155374,
0.0285785049,
-0.0540189818,
-0.045189634,
0.0582310371,
-0.0121856602,
0.0222192854,
-0.009287416,
-0.0533105917,
0.0536223464,
-0.0411025099,
-0.0248791538,
-0.0625830144,
-0.005081784,
-0.0167310107,
0.1323898137,
0.0356310047,
-0.0078003961,
0.0679707006,
-0.026776785,
0.0440054536,
-0.015605079,
-0.0175723061,
0.0357895531,
-0.0500607938,
-0.0531882569,
-0.0074030114,
0.0449771434,
-0.0258298814,
0.0042919731,
-0.0185767915,
0.0456210747,
-0.0278873518,
-0.0261210185,
0.0275896657,
-0.0130575579,
0.0139932092,
-0.0395248532,
0.0636371374,
-0.0492746495,
-0.0751687363,
-0.0102479709,
-0.0212581642,
-0.0021691667,
0.0658252314,
0.0330816135,
0.0469928123,
0.029655423,
-0.0097122071,
-0.016479576,
-0.006600827,
-0.0555631146,
-0.0484375507,
0.0271578245,
-0.0087442109,
-0.0030384059,
-0.0395653024,
-0.007251645,
0.036586944,
-0.0259196665,
0.0004694719,
2.657716963e-34,
0.0661366954,
-0.0179983713,
0.0206847619,
-0.0039138487,
0.0570332147,
-0.0122995013,
-0.0171773117,
0.0151677839,
0.0122717572,
-0.0844206288,
-0.0158131272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12566v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12566v2 | RichRAG: Crafting Rich Responses for Multi-faceted Queries in Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T12:52:51 | 2024-06-21T18:12:15 | Shuting Wang, Xin Yu, Mang Wang, Weipeng Chen, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) effectively addresses issues of static
knowledge and hallucination in large language models. Existing studies mostly
focus on question scenarios with clear user intents and concise answers.
However, it is prevalent that users issue broad, open-ended queries with
diverse sub-intents, for which they desire rich and long-form answers covering
multiple relevant aspects. To tackle this important yet underexplored problem,
we propose a novel RAG framework, namely RichRAG. It includes a sub-aspect
explorer to identify potential sub-aspects of input questions, a multi-faceted
retriever to build a candidate pool of diverse external documents related to
these sub-aspects, and a generative list-wise ranker, which is a key module to
provide the top-k most valuable documents for the final generator. These ranked
documents sufficiently cover various query aspects and are aware of the
generator's preferences, hence incentivizing it to produce rich and
comprehensive responses for users. The training of our ranker involves a
supervised fine-tuning stage to ensure the basic coverage of documents, and a
reinforcement learning stage to align downstream LLM's preferences to the
ranking of documents. Experimental results on two publicly available datasets
prove that our framework effectively and efficiently provides comprehensive and
satisfying responses to users. | [
0.0600785278,
0.0170545876,
-0.004641287,
0.0057123345,
0.0072776792,
-0.0071778172,
-0.0418475531,
0.0099610919,
0.0090785325,
-0.0446620099,
-0.0081836274,
-0.0116189327,
-0.050849475,
0.0032207677,
0.0200950503,
-0.0567977913,
0.0411033668,
-0.0250964388,
-0.009092628,
0.0029573848,
0.0096291527,
0.0450514294,
0.0174909253,
0.0330228135,
0.012334411,
-0.0051250849,
-0.0470326617,
0.0200377721,
0.0013978021,
-0.0179463774,
0.02450669,
0.0336284004,
0.0195591208,
0.0305731483,
0.0000019564,
-0.057631202,
-0.0407359898,
0.0052870018,
0.0061264001,
-0.032980185,
0.0369845815,
0.0554579422,
0.0371747501,
0.0131527949,
-0.0541509315,
0.0035581111,
0.0046394384,
0.0606752448,
0.0590554401,
0.0604710095,
0.0056774043,
-0.0124410549,
0.0328248627,
-0.0372117013,
0.0819253772,
-0.0449532978,
-0.0180661138,
-0.0078026433,
0.0555084944,
0.0514705293,
0.0090026427,
0.0077322689,
0.013928296,
-0.037667729,
0.0421286635,
0.0173673481,
-0.0668412969,
0.0034902056,
0.0210995637,
0.0826183408,
0.0178046543,
-0.0035330716,
0.0191034693,
-0.0207321681,
0.0215432141,
0.0312417634,
-0.0432188287,
0.0096304929,
-0.0445378013,
-0.021274941,
0.0241283346,
0.0036549091,
-0.002083241,
0.0241571702,
-0.027976172,
0.0395268984,
0.0200738907,
-0.036929775,
-0.0018082208,
0.0113855377,
0.0081793787,
-0.0579240061,
-0.0067477091,
0.040646363,
-0.0697195828,
0.0134071829,
0.0007826577,
-0.0126759773,
0.058062695,
-0.0161278881,
-0.0008241556,
0.0148288012,
-0.027215872,
0.0360825248,
0.0028295871,
0.0064887353,
-0.0316123515,
-0.0147999097,
-0.0587805286,
-0.0141915688,
-0.0471090339,
-0.0420141853,
-0.0321422108,
0.0560141839,
-0.0365006588,
-0.0053616622,
-0.033071626,
0.047446195,
0.0065033869,
0.0072479411,
0.0328778923,
0.0557932891,
-0.0730256662,
-0.0128183234,
-0.0663996562,
0.0222062189,
-0.044864174,
-0.0004587257,
0.0595750175,
-0.0290209167,
0.0080345022,
0.0208409578,
0.0198879689,
-0.0340431109,
-0.0074358578,
0.018903736,
-0.011506048,
-0.0075955535,
-0.0415834598,
-0.0742026791,
0.0170267075,
-0.0371921025,
0.0036353741,
-0.0684849396,
0.0208754428,
0.0156493802,
-0.0325298682,
-0.0038756817,
0.01406781,
0.0552891865,
0.006268526,
0.0098117255,
0.0148199396,
-0.0171174817,
0.046061188,
0.0218177587,
0.016623795,
0.0537934974,
-0.0228085611,
0.0555713959,
0.0436177813,
0.0147248171,
0.0154193668,
-0.0062946198,
0.0080211554,
-0.0001789008,
0.012105803,
0.053457655,
-0.027961025,
0.0174387936,
0.0042744307,
0.0411248654,
-0.0328075439,
0.0201316867,
-0.0016874975,
-0.0073140957,
0.0541864373,
0.0329128951,
0.0541566052,
0.0393154398,
-0.0145799899,
0.047062885,
0.0068727001,
0.0635722652,
-0.0245897919,
0.0165766291,
0.0626876578,
0.0290478878,
-0.0385344587,
-0.0441138707,
0.0108958073,
0.0167007092,
-0.043197833,
0.0358723626,
0.0344851725,
0.0533260629,
-0.0482451022,
0.0328123979,
0.0119407037,
-0.0568761975,
0.0404513441,
-0.0365845598,
0.0553659089,
0.0674367845,
0.0782400444,
-0.0558319539,
-0.0217758138,
-0.0081018843,
-0.0080122892,
0.0150017962,
0.0507136881,
-0.0354679264,
-0.005155026,
-0.0581625141,
-0.0447037183,
-0.0320693962,
-0.0037036622,
0.0295956302,
0.0196576584,
0.0118591283,
0.0439376943,
-0.0606331453,
-0.0011294532,
0.0206371471,
-0.0232210271,
-0.0372782089,
0.0335183255,
-0.0081546009,
-0.0031091,
0.0239255968,
0.0059701386,
0.0291975606,
0.0302695297,
-0.0232076682,
-0.0316766724,
-0.0242308266,
-0.0230985172,
-0.0064512021,
-0.0010884387,
-0.017989248,
-0.0036615913,
-0.0187009424,
-0.041924417,
-0.0357864909,
-0.0286403876,
-0.0365126245,
0.0346280076,
-0.0751087442,
-0.0082970401,
0.042940557,
-0.0002342248,
-0.0644985884,
0.1037297547,
0.0092087472,
0.0088043744,
0.0482800305,
-0.0107115367,
0.0192231201,
-0.0688930228,
-0.0044894791,
0.0177386608,
-0.0380801745,
0.0219118893,
0.0546786413,
0.0162471272,
-0.0774517804,
-0.0311302505,
-0.0777605772,
-0.0010068098,
-0.0198223572,
0.0094360411,
0.0118605467,
0.0564465784,
0.0104127461,
-0.0163945518,
-0.0630159229,
0.0087919608,
0.0423122086,
0.0166124161,
0.0241740383,
0.0354993343,
0.0469268188,
-0.0269273054,
-0.0137602314,
-0.0000263703,
0.0130879544,
0.0110324482,
0.0417942479,
-0.038664788,
0.0141743235,
-0.0526120327,
-0.0025031129,
-0.0121747982,
0.0215935856,
0.0129424632,
-0.0660157725,
0.0227157697,
0.0359662361,
0.0435739458,
0.0074907504,
0.0236879792,
-0.0080672931,
-0.0890214518,
0.0306532886,
-0.0389101654,
-0.0166910496,
0.0040641245,
-0.0159965623,
0.0385471024,
0.0125485361,
0.0003070142,
-0.0024376155,
-0.0494110994,
0.0306615662,
0.0219927579,
-0.0341812521,
-0.032096941,
-0.0013384453,
0.009805942,
0.0459682047,
-0.0039054623,
-0.022996081,
0.085580796,
0.0046165357,
0.0046436032,
-0.0516368188,
0.0256169848,
-0.0643334165,
0.0430176556,
-0.019416146,
0.0253554303,
-0.0182187296,
-0.0072223805,
-0.0612648651,
0.0122810919,
0.0218586288,
-0.056576252,
0.0284321383,
-0.0329996943,
0.0026108506,
-0.0117370943,
-0.048178032,
-0.0509273782,
-0.0452957302,
0.0456438027,
-0.0067347884,
-0.0181947164,
0.0000032854,
-0.0011515983,
-0.0424336977,
0.0364512503,
0.0084467689,
-0.0338034332,
-0.042986773,
0.0041271332,
0.077443853,
0.111488089,
0.0063882601,
0.0028105909,
-0.0122748818,
0.0099056242,
0.0547881313,
0.0359160341,
-0.0290841088,
0.0473159589,
-0.003824828,
0.0612784587,
-0.0456288233,
-0.0234215762,
0.0233270843,
0.0224052072,
-0.0451031178,
-0.0408502519,
0.060235627,
0.0598342493,
-0.0464877263,
-0.0097761014,
-0.0614712872,
0.076715745,
0.022879187,
0.0934195071,
-0.0780851021,
0.0226547346,
-0.0187962707,
0.0609766804,
-0.0099235112,
-0.0059978119,
-0.0127993878,
-0.1414198279,
0.0530757345,
-0.023947034,
-0.0065069618,
0.0402876176,
-0.0000443991,
-0.0149695724,
0.0288681686,
-0.0197775923,
0.0386407971,
-0.0225238521,
0.0032144494,
0.0095558232,
0.0454843082,
-0.0290299617,
-0.0028416016,
-0.0088662477,
-0.0319706611,
0.0717751905,
0.0261290316,
0.0295985639,
-0.0484252833,
-0.0058305264,
-0.0277966075,
0.0220848098,
-0.0159261767,
0.0256070588,
-0.0000498077,
0.0193697792,
-0.0253501777,
0.027217105,
0.0065998309,
-0.009419078,
0.0131079964,
0.0518283136,
-0.0391154364,
0.0178974457,
-0.0470198579,
-0.0173809472,
0.0189255085,
0.049853567,
0.0039243368,
-0.0183229949,
-0.0267603397,
-0.0363681354,
0.0312009752,
-0.0666881129,
-0.0174256805,
0.0183534306,
-0.0046434836,
0.0340084583,
-0.0730923861,
-0.0337458402,
0.0127522284,
0.0400310047,
-0.0196288619,
0.0071815732,
-0.0340503827,
-0.0149586471,
-0.0306850318,
0.0184119549,
0.0002963545,
-0.0233598575,
-0.0171242431,
-0.0451973043,
0.0517274328,
-0.0862664208,
-0.0101079317,
0.0048937672,
-0.0087311948,
-0.0480543189,
-0.0146149546,
0.0619804002,
0.0208074078,
0.0468055941,
-0.0254915729,
-0.0574386865,
0.0446274392,
0.0533118099,
-0.0367140658,
-0.0258713886,
-0.0116713364,
0.0048722215,
-0.0202788543,
0.0308554452,
-0.1067315787,
-0.0033695053,
-0.0361427143,
0.0512119681,
0.0135923484,
-0.0403365754,
0.0381503962,
0.0153751597,
-0.0064661582,
-0.0127526801,
0.0193918832,
-0.0363996476,
0.0296542887,
-0.0327191092,
-0.0448729284,
-0.0246470515,
0.0230724011,
0.0136533938,
-0.040862266,
0.011789429,
0.0315984488,
-0.0232334863,
0.0883662924,
-0.0767527744,
-0.0135751115,
0.004410163,
-0.0202293582,
0.0177703314,
-0.0020378302,
-0.0236444063,
-0.007231073,
0.0117113357,
0.076352112,
-0.0334364772,
0.0671071261,
-0.0056737042,
-0.0022384431,
0.0156985819,
0.0129519571,
-0.0704204664,
-0.0767576024,
-0.0437537953,
-0.0061827111,
-0.0026914421,
-0.0005506411,
0.0278667491,
-0.0004971684,
-0.0224884097,
-0.0071797585,
0.0079221195,
0.0292497352,
-0.0554262735,
0.0074383663,
0.048567377,
-0.0206722543,
0.0006859066,
0.0543435365,
-0.036546655,
0.0005646453,
-0.0203585085,
-0.0087680537,
-0.0486333035,
-0.052889023,
-0.0024515782,
0.0578872226,
-0.0112671033,
-0.0011014803,
-0.0658323541,
-0.0346905179,
-0.0141255017,
0.0074905716,
-0.0154493954,
-0.005250141,
0.063759163,
0.0751589164,
-0.0008658102,
-0.0232228823,
-0.0692178905,
0.0115593364,
-0.0968779847,
-0.0274102744,
-0.0006514753,
-6.350935899e-33,
-0.040524669,
-0.0258143451,
0.0375624374,
-0.0457658544,
-0.016074378,
-0.0094497874,
-0.0300379992,
-0.0074351062,
-0.011752489,
-0.0297111999,
-0.0297796931,
-0.0033074317,
0.0037799922,
0.0351902843,
0.0052600005,
-0.0025344316,
0.0404179394,
0.0055058608,
-0.0383351371,
0.0704398453,
0.0552673973,
0.0111786965,
0.0088775791,
-0.0521741249,
0.0039513828,
-0.0139334314,
-0.0072819511,
0.0281969402,
-0.0245274827,
0.0860860422,
-0.0023631281,
0.0368648395,
0.0193315763,
-0.0339754112,
0.0019647218,
-0.0054043261,
-0.074604176,
-0.0323047787,
0.0025646898,
-0.0351181664,
-0.0511937551,
-0.0423964188,
0.0160239656,
-0.0246967301,
0.0355340764,
-0.0049928245,
0.0382401235,
0.0064357095,
-0.0248483419,
-0.0749049708,
-0.0385976695,
0.0066721723,
-0.003874378,
0.0056564962,
-0.029241221,
0.1036132202,
0.0240356326,
0.0599005185,
-0.0033702701,
0.0341129713,
-0.0136232097,
0.0633852258,
0.0637562126,
-0.0032770245,
-0.0102060018,
0.0403909311,
0.0086307824,
0.0123352148,
-0.0041727028,
-0.0237565786,
-0.02521093,
0.0693240687,
-0.0072321622,
0.0636256486,
0.0182644054,
0.0112848682,
-0.0277832784,
0.0849168301,
-0.0164348129,
0.027347533,
0.0121516306,
-0.0004825076,
-0.0169330053,
-0.0177947544,
-0.0200378727,
0.0230961964,
-0.0510260575,
-0.0305758473,
0.0463000052,
0.0401524939,
-0.0255372841,
-0.0117307445,
0.0290145781,
-0.0116238967,
-0.0024030898,
0.043989215,
-0.0513277613,
-0.0055519668,
-0.0025558267,
0.0252722986,
-0.0142803621,
-0.0066018975,
0.0426841266,
-0.0270321313,
-0.0301712062,
0.0364611931,
0.0148283113,
0.0071412264,
-0.0426901616,
0.0230382867,
-0.0378760248,
0.0444126502,
-0.0363497287,
0.0091730803,
0.0159991663,
0.0207805745,
-0.0276914686,
0.0443935208,
0.019392781,
0.0160169844,
-0.0402715169,
-0.0468054451,
0.0153939016,
0.0106225777,
0.0018387246,
0.036100015,
-0.0122652529,
0.0250930674,
0.0319248475,
-0.0331834517,
-0.0270683337,
0.0378237218,
2.707e-7,
0.0205509141,
0.0114041567,
0.0219770614,
0.0390355885,
-0.0094851404,
0.0167083777,
0.0250162985,
0.0424530953,
0.0432974696,
0.0066689034,
0.006400316,
0.0018922923,
0.0327750817,
0.0389198139,
-0.1041471064,
0.0049161511,
-0.040080823,
-0.0271226037,
-0.063368544,
-0.0432597063,
0.0751001984,
0.0468515754,
-0.0379272886,
-0.0118426466,
-0.0022654918,
-0.0151084578,
0.0692864284,
0.0215474907,
-0.0300528351,
0.0320905223,
0.0464604758,
0.0136040235,
0.0086154221,
-0.0375453308,
-0.0384842865,
0.0164742786,
0.0037553818,
0.0159669928,
0.0182408299,
-0.1005359367,
0.0125293164,
-0.0052176621,
0.0340864398,
-0.0647176355,
0.0657243282,
-0.0115573639,
0.0101410374,
-0.0020494803,
-0.0413158871,
-0.0128863715,
-0.0142937144,
-0.047966443,
-0.0098514073,
0.0180105921,
-0.0068516708,
0.0118914656,
-0.0057643703,
-0.0513962917,
-0.0326199047,
0.0055138459,
-0.0371824391,
-0.0530217327,
-0.0385148562,
0.0399314612,
-0.0418721177,
-0.0451263152,
-0.0008141957,
2.597314232e-34,
0.0390181579,
0.0260668863,
-0.0097639076,
0.0134645822,
0.0394267067,
0.0130324746,
-0.0240648072,
0.0272910874,
0.039113678,
-0.0886317044,
-0.0411609747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12564v1 | Low-Resource Machine Translation through the Lens of Personalized Federated Learning | 2024-06-18T12:50:00 | 2024-06-18T12:50:00 | Viktor Moskvoretskii, Nazarii Tupitsa, Chris Biemann, Samuel Horváth, Eduard Gorbunov, Irina Nikishina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We present a new approach based on the Personalized Federated Learning
algorithm MeritFed that can be applied to Natural Language Tasks with
heterogeneous data. We evaluate it on the Low-Resource Machine Translation
task, using the dataset from the Large-Scale Multilingual Machine Translation
Shared Task (Small Track #2) and the subset of Sami languages from the
multilingual benchmark for Finno-Ugric languages. In addition to its
effectiveness, MeritFed is also highly interpretable, as it can be applied to
track the impact of each language used for training. Our analysis reveals that
target dataset size affects weight distribution across auxiliary languages,
that unrelated languages do not interfere with the training, and auxiliary
optimizer parameters have minimal impact. Our approach is easy to apply with a
few lines of code, and we provide scripts for reproducing the experiments at
https://github.com/VityaVitalich/MeritFed | [
0.0329551734,
0.0623644292,
-0.0160425045,
0.0330826081,
-0.0273905098,
0.0269569475,
0.0503877699,
-0.0149328932,
-0.0062599001,
-0.0117074791,
-0.0463619791,
-0.0520026982,
0.0582443736,
-0.0131734712,
0.0125889163,
-0.0446367674,
0.0480429009,
-0.0227510352,
-0.0094334846,
-0.0323233642,
-0.0301499292,
0.0390451662,
-0.0127411727,
0.0362683199,
-0.0362096578,
-0.024695741,
-0.00572757,
0.0167778544,
0.0368835591,
0.0080609545,
0.0036253533,
0.0520017482,
-0.0064321253,
0.117776148,
0.0000021201,
-0.035755977,
-0.0146218389,
0.0016172274,
0.025906926,
0.0385101363,
0.0577254184,
-0.0010372002,
-0.0158077125,
0.0123513062,
-0.033385504,
-0.0374329835,
0.0699605718,
-0.0162402634,
0.0342745855,
0.0961107016,
-0.0070665143,
-0.0484644845,
-0.0344331972,
-0.0407226682,
-0.092410028,
0.0090448288,
-0.0176317375,
0.0138958218,
-0.0486601032,
-0.038246803,
-0.0329749212,
0.0318834074,
0.0152213518,
0.0324251726,
0.0264413245,
-0.0063005225,
-0.057157021,
-0.0257892441,
-0.0318840407,
0.0790620148,
-0.0182784759,
0.0046918956,
-0.0241316278,
-0.0275678225,
-0.0087348819,
-0.0011593298,
-0.0065736175,
0.001728464,
-0.0140095782,
0.0193589646,
0.0685415789,
0.0538617149,
0.0167378634,
0.002197207,
-0.0247500278,
0.0416927338,
-0.0181480721,
0.0167034399,
-0.01020901,
0.0139370197,
-0.0104317712,
-0.0213017296,
0.0486722849,
-0.001750025,
-0.0398360975,
-0.0132165095,
-0.0533155762,
-0.1215954348,
0.0224596467,
-0.034085054,
0.0220561214,
0.0448822416,
0.0062883967,
0.0347042494,
0.0046980134,
-0.0261695515,
-0.0334338881,
0.0187808126,
-0.0644608662,
-0.0119201178,
-0.0661143064,
0.0204060264,
-0.0332524702,
0.0204747785,
-0.0264682453,
0.0100011695,
-0.0217385031,
-0.01312178,
-0.0317931473,
0.0142838722,
0.0460869037,
-0.0187426992,
-0.089231059,
-0.0026899569,
0.0147406729,
0.0531868637,
-0.0499478243,
0.0041372557,
-0.0202493351,
-0.0220578872,
-0.0132666342,
0.0254525337,
0.0012246299,
-0.034387175,
0.0031795774,
0.0563280545,
-0.0103783766,
-0.0248122904,
0.0072200196,
-0.0227120109,
0.0269880891,
-0.0655075386,
-0.0380607806,
-0.0819868147,
0.0529851206,
0.0025728608,
0.0221935418,
-0.0177527666,
-0.0235648472,
-0.0233602431,
-0.0341549926,
0.0389632508,
0.0065400782,
-0.0206704214,
0.0105807204,
-0.0145972185,
-0.0293508954,
0.119964458,
0.0304739904,
0.044241,
0.0535516292,
0.0001569401,
-0.0851171091,
0.0296690837,
0.0003508218,
0.0620661713,
0.0020082113,
0.015777139,
-0.0596963875,
0.0219131391,
0.0360789411,
-0.0068358481,
-0.0076777264,
0.01787032,
0.0529619083,
0.0773358122,
0.0467056073,
0.0267236121,
0.0066040871,
0.0308624115,
0.0428373106,
0.0407007597,
-0.0070687039,
0.0153925456,
0.006408209,
-0.0450442843,
0.0212557856,
0.1098902598,
-0.017135974,
-0.0448514782,
0.0243454166,
-0.0491453372,
-0.0325185098,
0.0028753453,
0.0527787544,
0.001414553,
-0.0214331318,
-0.000105264,
0.0339846276,
-0.0167293344,
0.0190904327,
0.0179156214,
-0.0303708445,
0.0374103822,
0.0372127965,
-0.0392655768,
-0.0167629365,
-0.0462609194,
-0.0013881897,
0.0097581847,
0.0440637246,
0.0037887867,
0.0457619727,
-0.0532880574,
-0.040787071,
0.0374529064,
0.0143244294,
0.0187740047,
-0.0380610637,
0.050291732,
-0.0102856811,
0.0244184453,
-0.0472840033,
0.0308722928,
0.0150086554,
0.000540094,
0.0741941631,
0.0146837402,
0.0471674763,
0.0349682085,
0.0057802415,
-0.0139547568,
-0.0070924377,
-0.0346865281,
-0.0494701155,
0.0184922293,
0.0076438352,
-0.0459492654,
-0.0002892391,
-0.0263895076,
-0.0191106107,
0.0290090498,
-0.0640470013,
-0.0416530743,
0.0230575632,
-0.035916537,
0.0009792849,
-0.011025086,
0.0166822206,
0.0030582272,
0.0239133742,
-0.0433684252,
0.020210335,
-0.0161255579,
-0.0480766222,
0.0040394221,
-0.070676744,
0.049183473,
-0.0660880134,
0.0504835695,
0.0263026711,
0.0358496942,
0.0251621548,
0.0210392363,
0.0141607486,
0.0055283513,
-0.0037664066,
-0.0358844958,
0.0377454236,
-0.033973828,
0.0496397503,
0.0251591485,
0.0594307184,
0.0039371215,
-0.0292717461,
-0.0139983455,
0.0139082121,
-0.0184101388,
-0.0005797875,
-0.0241619907,
-0.0042524002,
0.0144083397,
-0.0073387083,
-0.0372135341,
0.0209013186,
0.0618899129,
0.0144560859,
-0.0340823159,
-0.0709339678,
-0.0196822379,
-0.0722385943,
0.0113762282,
0.0305779073,
-0.0355877765,
-0.019538844,
0.0048906654,
0.0210968498,
0.0292498879,
-0.0405435637,
-0.0132232215,
0.0334788822,
0.0204995405,
-0.0658431277,
0.0144813182,
-0.0389635563,
0.0572790951,
-0.0161415804,
0.0069106021,
0.0297530796,
0.0288651213,
0.018010417,
-0.022493856,
-0.0605598167,
0.0546185821,
-0.0223807488,
-0.0120055536,
-0.0340601876,
0.0632549003,
0.0338331088,
0.0372954831,
0.0007484423,
-0.0702123493,
0.0961006433,
0.0165347811,
0.0117832003,
-0.0547491759,
-0.0331400298,
-0.0693563446,
0.0320721716,
-0.0382703729,
0.0416178219,
-0.0243574865,
-0.0185099803,
-0.019937586,
0.0474065579,
0.0182711016,
-0.0257678274,
0.0064404518,
-0.0115248319,
-0.004755001,
-0.0216509588,
-0.0161290541,
0.0057652574,
-0.0404377617,
-0.0116838682,
-0.0231730901,
-0.0237077512,
-0.0148541676,
-0.0221293326,
-0.016842274,
-0.0075211106,
0.033852309,
-0.0258771181,
0.0207014885,
-0.0167067684,
0.0382282548,
-0.0165959932,
-0.044348482,
0.0114445277,
-0.0200296771,
0.0012832559,
0.0293626264,
0.0305494815,
-0.0374797471,
0.0139896814,
-0.0331132337,
0.0535860285,
-0.0267644804,
-0.0283827148,
-0.040992979,
0.0599582754,
-0.0495543256,
0.0482564345,
0.0649199113,
0.0063581415,
-0.0424022079,
0.0273185894,
-0.0263601132,
0.0597721487,
0.0092369672,
0.0214071032,
-0.0709221512,
-0.0218411721,
0.007404271,
0.0436343849,
0.0268809274,
-0.0109364456,
-0.016014982,
-0.0587891415,
-0.0014718769,
0.0544184931,
-0.0599373952,
-0.0321188457,
-0.0229608845,
-0.0434627458,
-0.0529479235,
-0.0179816894,
-0.0422149301,
0.0422713421,
0.0280109737,
0.0131227477,
-0.0086874478,
-0.0853208825,
-0.029683413,
-0.0255145859,
0.0513902791,
0.0084421877,
0.0094197579,
-0.0151106268,
-0.0841485709,
-0.0211879574,
0.0346732773,
-0.0419991091,
-0.0557229184,
0.0268979445,
-0.0056850254,
-0.0348572135,
0.0063524074,
0.0054586525,
-0.0062795989,
0.0328913778,
0.0523220114,
0.0693891346,
-0.0137088606,
0.0224965028,
0.0147121651,
-0.0466365553,
0.0670247376,
0.0214441158,
-0.0038071494,
-0.0329466835,
-0.0111958813,
-0.0048142369,
-0.0371474251,
-0.0601081811,
-0.0182946362,
0.0564140081,
-0.0147443339,
-0.022411,
-0.0653402731,
-0.0294852834,
0.0386661254,
0.0474781916,
-0.0011877218,
0.0443904549,
-0.0091314139,
-0.0056261709,
-0.036508698,
0.094962813,
-0.0307858624,
0.0504062213,
-0.0756059512,
-0.0598940551,
-0.0124168349,
-0.0295653567,
0.0080443257,
0.0395108052,
-0.0579974353,
-0.0517158285,
-0.0343421921,
0.0620949082,
0.0139055047,
0.0435910635,
-0.0138023654,
-0.0458550677,
0.0275130421,
-0.0172606464,
-0.0501031987,
0.0000886476,
0.0644686073,
-0.0643015876,
-0.0017625026,
0.0604966506,
0.0201264434,
0.0180861317,
-0.0018941802,
0.0290677659,
0.051228635,
-0.0553160459,
-0.0348240398,
0.0257979929,
0.0392296091,
-0.0567337126,
-0.0432288647,
-0.0309141818,
0.0244390182,
-0.0077818842,
-0.0014857689,
-0.0473874807,
-0.0191343781,
0.0121992761,
0.0079177553,
0.0011475118,
-0.0063748662,
-0.0016519161,
-0.0319256857,
-0.0059350636,
0.029839417,
-0.0350647345,
0.0149257332,
0.0361910276,
0.0260031652,
0.0023471082,
0.0118897082,
0.0042274413,
0.0318502523,
-0.0260525346,
0.0293031149,
-0.0224616583,
0.0272992272,
-0.029307805,
0.0432741381,
-0.0260178912,
-0.0543164313,
0.0237436797,
-0.0330906548,
0.0534111708,
-0.0034382674,
0.0824361071,
0.0194378216,
-0.0045501459,
-0.0173558965,
0.0472271852,
-0.0278128441,
-0.011471292,
-0.0162017271,
-0.0277506802,
-0.013604911,
0.0747423768,
0.0913868919,
-0.0187886655,
0.0049527986,
-0.0244214926,
-0.0045307982,
-0.034232866,
-0.0340984166,
0.0416726246,
0.0469221286,
-0.0468157642,
-0.007099865,
-0.0560462587,
-0.0463835001,
-0.0087492876,
-0.0227549877,
-0.0153737403,
-0.0126736378,
0.0396123938,
0.0103467694,
-0.0451858342,
0.0323846452,
-0.0696126968,
0.0172796659,
-0.0081036333,
-0.0095392801,
0.0064053391,
-6.195564934e-33,
-0.0105554797,
-0.0008584234,
-0.0077644694,
0.0205256697,
0.0208735336,
0.0267997496,
0.0130028669,
-0.0147539629,
0.0282218214,
0.0079581011,
-0.0027658802,
-0.0349634476,
0.0203107744,
0.0128445374,
0.0063309558,
0.0394790582,
0.0338367075,
-0.0079259444,
-0.0237354822,
0.0335335061,
0.0503044352,
0.0244436581,
0.0954007134,
-0.0614049621,
0.0385802388,
0.0047554285,
0.0024313766,
0.0229270253,
-0.0125869168,
0.0219280049,
-0.0141114341,
0.0324209034,
0.0015217804,
-0.0294719357,
-0.0251688249,
-0.0327965617,
-0.0745585263,
-0.0158487726,
-0.0038772011,
0.0665503219,
-0.0500835739,
-0.0363480709,
0.0278077535,
-0.0139059993,
-0.0195711982,
-0.013751125,
0.0316796377,
-0.0103106694,
-0.0231105257,
-0.0186744798,
-0.0527570024,
0.0313334763,
-0.0144050326,
0.0156921837,
0.0247098729,
0.0691331327,
0.0009234192,
-0.0173194241,
-0.0421187878,
-0.0049687098,
-0.0591944978,
0.023917865,
0.0532009713,
0.0209884532,
-0.0291174054,
0.0038185162,
0.0605278388,
-0.0098742517,
0.0090984004,
0.0445277244,
0.0239566229,
-0.0247358996,
0.0392239727,
0.0424582399,
0.0200054757,
-0.027075354,
-0.0711671337,
0.0527155884,
0.0547631569,
-0.0507350191,
0.0009294348,
-0.0000929565,
-0.0140957506,
0.0046693445,
-0.0224067643,
-0.0181110371,
-0.0097137708,
-0.0028752908,
-0.028660059,
0.0026385142,
-0.0523872487,
-0.0056196037,
0.0412302017,
-0.0166066159,
0.0069016176,
-0.005948652,
0.0103349434,
0.0215182565,
-0.0035933652,
0.0292326733,
-0.0262882188,
-0.034002617,
-0.0033249764,
-0.0040213973,
0.0443641767,
-0.0044446103,
0.0778192878,
0.031328924,
-0.0184894875,
0.0123037938,
-0.0328356475,
0.0067760358,
-0.0169138573,
0.0779567212,
0.0352203995,
-0.0084341569,
-0.0232844725,
0.0212058015,
0.0472723246,
-0.0078528086,
-0.0266856998,
-0.022475278,
0.0291878991,
0.0346818678,
-0.0259702075,
-0.0060451687,
-0.0411797985,
0.003544268,
0.04821245,
-0.0314161107,
-0.0171222482,
-0.035260208,
2.797e-7,
0.0424930379,
0.0413472839,
-0.0318111628,
-0.0503670014,
0.0214917511,
0.0303598586,
-0.0431758054,
0.0424454063,
-0.0179282278,
0.0459854342,
0.0294985697,
0.0397816673,
0.0483562425,
0.0133737922,
-0.0642556101,
-0.0444090143,
-0.0068519916,
0.0713523701,
-0.0692568123,
-0.0201946646,
-0.0309264548,
0.0775698796,
0.0646259636,
-0.0284900796,
-0.0142831802,
0.031001335,
0.0542852618,
0.022218585,
-0.0381990671,
-0.0166305918,
0.0309413355,
0.0519269817,
-0.0575423241,
-0.0171186775,
-0.0236643888,
0.0253117085,
0.0156744178,
0.0797074884,
-0.023196578,
0.0262219477,
0.0049268925,
0.0134318443,
-0.0333331116,
0.0231032595,
0.0347762555,
-0.014959217,
-0.0633163005,
0.0023647314,
0.0419496857,
0.0532090478,
0.0556536689,
-0.00204183,
-0.0383386239,
0.0501168929,
0.042365253,
-0.0263722483,
-0.0525228046,
-0.0365074724,
-0.0273812767,
-0.0286445394,
-0.0116824927,
-0.0379241519,
-0.0114574935,
0.0462507196,
-0.006310401,
-0.0331682153,
-0.0232049413,
2.561557163e-34,
0.0568351299,
0.0049695754,
0.0144203827,
-0.0421068743,
0.0059660831,
-0.0478041731,
-0.0147602549,
0.0063615129,
0.0282206517,
0.0153508903,
-0.0243114922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12549v1 | MultiSocial: Multilingual Benchmark of Machine-Generated Text Detection of Social-Media Texts | 2024-06-18T12:26:09 | 2024-06-18T12:26:09 | Dominik Macko, Jakub Kopal, Robert Moro, Ivan Srba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent LLMs are able to generate high-quality multilingual texts,
indistinguishable for humans from authentic human-written ones. Research in
machine-generated text detection is however mostly focused on the English
language and longer texts, such as news articles, scientific papers or student
essays. Social-media texts are usually much shorter and often feature informal
language, grammatical errors, or distinct linguistic items (e.g., emoticons,
hashtags). There is a gap in studying the ability of existing methods in
detection of such texts, reflected also in the lack of existing multilingual
benchmark datasets. To fill this gap we propose the first multilingual (22
languages) and multi-platform (5 social media platforms) dataset for
benchmarking machine-generated text detection in the social-media domain,
called MultiSocial. It contains 472,097 texts, of which about 58k are
human-written and approximately the same amount is generated by each of 7
multilingual LLMs. We use this benchmark to compare existing detection methods
in zero-shot as well as fine-tuned form. Our results indicate that the
fine-tuned detectors have no problem to be trained on social-media texts and
that the platform selection for training matters. | [
0.0517812558,
0.0416139811,
0.0210984815,
0.096069105,
-0.0268808808,
0.0398823954,
0.0044946214,
0.0479927212,
0.0209237467,
-0.0296828505,
-0.0244253855,
-0.0449122787,
-0.0224174429,
0.0073719635,
0.0041572619,
0.0058788508,
0.0303136129,
0.0264865961,
0.0059602619,
0.0106100896,
0.0402661413,
0.0456299856,
0.0154502466,
0.0017025498,
-0.0383153409,
0.0156111522,
0.0265961885,
0.0518594943,
0.0363807492,
-0.0398065783,
0.0328363217,
0.056851238,
-0.0057593621,
0.1229308173,
0.0000015987,
-0.0168041848,
0.0038641361,
-0.0236879624,
0.0129232854,
-0.0346966051,
0.1006567255,
-0.0823612586,
-0.0413909815,
0.0249504503,
-0.038976863,
0.030522177,
0.0411367156,
0.0209906101,
0.0029073113,
0.0880909711,
-0.0476091243,
0.0047665671,
0.0174061824,
-0.0068616546,
-0.0108361226,
-0.0082483096,
-0.0095450217,
-0.0485617593,
-0.0319903605,
0.0214306898,
0.0132868141,
0.025464572,
0.0178646892,
-0.0191708896,
-0.0359805934,
-0.0040312558,
-0.0294756778,
-0.0412094444,
-0.0212631822,
0.0635729432,
-0.0491989702,
-0.0309203658,
0.0259069782,
-0.0278344098,
-0.0039753048,
-0.0110242637,
0.0153688658,
0.0369480141,
-0.0385948978,
0.0423406959,
0.0026298321,
0.0068001733,
0.0253924783,
0.0815230608,
0.0363088809,
0.0273067914,
0.0074525219,
-0.0228147935,
0.0010803896,
0.0530271344,
0.001493006,
-0.0041089761,
0.0782492608,
0.0135828592,
-0.0002227672,
-0.0186606925,
-0.0637649596,
-0.0898271501,
0.0422350392,
-0.0762199163,
0.0190712195,
-0.0236634929,
0.0016354123,
0.0369582772,
-0.0503912196,
0.0119033894,
-0.0424323082,
0.0284488797,
-0.003504043,
0.0104512665,
0.0140757849,
0.0260229278,
-0.0045495983,
-0.0290308073,
-0.0417529494,
0.0015676859,
-0.0504282303,
0.0207434501,
0.0293123815,
-0.00613093,
-0.0521389879,
-0.0373154692,
-0.03935422,
-0.0050144303,
0.0499023534,
0.0192027744,
-0.0265769307,
0.0120794522,
0.0009353497,
-0.0595314763,
0.0023140779,
0.0676964521,
0.0701602548,
-0.0122920601,
0.0204377752,
0.0281492509,
-0.0409070626,
-0.073409684,
-0.0525272861,
-0.0344169401,
-0.031102499,
-0.0639694706,
0.0152282575,
-0.0903188363,
0.0298089851,
-0.0119395833,
-0.0091158925,
0.0241484903,
0.0150325261,
0.0410043783,
-0.0261176061,
0.03189639,
-0.040727295,
-0.0069391928,
0.0253897328,
0.0100681866,
0.0270556118,
0.0873854384,
0.0179011412,
0.0812663287,
0.0778263137,
0.0210687686,
0.0130192153,
0.0762690082,
-0.0160019025,
0.0427706167,
0.0008573306,
-0.0509056598,
-0.0378789678,
0.0022123568,
0.0233753156,
0.0366725326,
-0.012178571,
0.0010086116,
0.0600249246,
0.0423706099,
0.0103355199,
-0.0129967285,
0.0441270061,
0.0378762223,
-0.0051689125,
0.0338051133,
-0.0150688253,
-0.013407724,
-0.0395442136,
-0.0301115215,
0.0178506169,
0.0228222311,
-0.0256997105,
-0.0089410255,
-0.0009451965,
-0.0478474386,
0.0309100244,
-0.0477033854,
0.0622997805,
-0.0038794524,
-0.0375130251,
0.0008215707,
0.021960061,
-0.0548165478,
0.0151205882,
-0.0223627575,
0.0434865206,
0.0557111055,
0.0113165788,
-0.0062912158,
0.029974157,
-0.0026188972,
0.0498666242,
0.1221998483,
0.0115544824,
0.0214376766,
0.0288241282,
-0.0378085636,
-0.0062293909,
0.0124587417,
-0.0030490637,
0.0008404417,
0.0314558558,
0.0583737716,
0.0241549332,
0.0211334582,
-0.0418570898,
0.0327810235,
-0.0202606115,
0.0253715515,
0.0073840767,
0.0024771779,
-0.0036779279,
0.0386810787,
-0.008939378,
-0.0327692367,
0.018375013,
-0.0561569929,
-0.0312312692,
-0.0082623791,
-0.0293306727,
-0.0381327905,
0.0083088176,
-0.0552432351,
-0.0293952785,
0.0347984768,
-0.053615611,
-0.0243067481,
0.0217159204,
-0.0115956469,
-0.0019928822,
-0.0419921055,
-0.0236443914,
-0.0438135825,
0.0499154702,
0.0416195579,
0.035910055,
-0.0343442336,
0.0035964472,
-0.0149167525,
-0.0390511565,
0.0407085977,
-0.0024920721,
-0.0099566886,
0.0247353427,
-0.0279041976,
0.0249455906,
0.0364460908,
0.048036173,
-0.0475357361,
-0.03979614,
-0.0927604362,
0.0133503368,
-0.0625042096,
0.0212715771,
0.027314879,
0.000875248,
-0.0138340695,
-0.0456698574,
-0.0266714357,
0.0344863273,
0.0568541922,
0.0189042576,
0.0569195971,
-0.0287761446,
0.0527987368,
-0.0325965472,
-0.0134970602,
0.0116118249,
0.0073552257,
0.0491978601,
-0.0793850943,
-0.018447103,
0.024217166,
0.001281822,
-0.0083333058,
0.0176026095,
-0.0563060716,
0.0109073445,
0.0170632675,
0.0118092066,
0.0616027452,
0.0257577822,
0.012534393,
-0.0364439264,
0.0448816158,
-0.0137013262,
-0.0029867301,
0.0004714165,
-0.0010999672,
-0.0276316348,
-0.0595731027,
0.0151467817,
0.0361385345,
-0.034974616,
0.0282948315,
-0.0048416187,
-0.0061462787,
-0.0292002615,
-0.0366454273,
0.0008773169,
0.0025482769,
-0.0153076993,
0.0200552382,
-0.0426186174,
-0.0594924763,
0.0235903617,
-0.0146280527,
-0.0033035863,
-0.0110110678,
-0.0493895002,
-0.0280803982,
0.0121894749,
0.0143179996,
0.0542561971,
-0.0523107313,
-0.010261273,
-0.0104234451,
0.0168030914,
0.0422633812,
-0.0125302579,
0.0031105073,
0.0187746473,
0.0016627586,
-0.0248129107,
-0.0314544253,
-0.0284719206,
-0.0501330793,
-0.0336312465,
-0.0389820039,
-0.0178503543,
-0.0355218612,
-0.0068283719,
-0.0400281511,
-0.0085089384,
0.0478284508,
-0.0105807995,
-0.0112167755,
-0.0144303236,
0.0561366715,
0.0147210872,
-0.0286775231,
0.0214934219,
-0.065172188,
0.0051279617,
0.0808909535,
0.0139839239,
-0.0023047172,
0.0064876089,
-0.0204518139,
0.0097173583,
0.0391669646,
-0.0134068662,
-0.0248253588,
0.0796794519,
-0.019460706,
0.0269783903,
0.0844756514,
0.0029090038,
-0.0494268462,
-0.0081682913,
-0.0104650995,
-0.0036015641,
0.0264296066,
-0.0099350838,
-0.1248520538,
-0.0399012826,
-0.0096396767,
-0.0012558177,
-0.0101995142,
-0.0003121571,
-0.004404577,
-0.0809867531,
-0.0049851122,
0.0296658371,
-0.0236170217,
-0.0031810724,
-0.007348205,
-0.0174009223,
-0.01118764,
-0.0003519999,
-0.0301856007,
-0.002991321,
-0.0261183158,
-0.0100033581,
-0.0245862957,
-0.0647777766,
-0.0230572559,
-0.0557898507,
-0.0214172378,
0.0120667191,
0.0531047471,
-0.02665109,
-0.0395123698,
0.0428113043,
0.008156986,
-0.0101913875,
-0.0350756608,
0.0512192659,
-0.004271274,
-0.0226974636,
-0.0278922804,
0.0273222011,
-0.052912768,
0.0017336288,
0.0047059939,
0.0198323913,
0.0434129313,
-0.0563646294,
-0.0186724663,
0.0102160526,
0.0261531584,
0.0479564853,
0.0166585054,
-0.0608375855,
-0.0569704995,
-0.0114749204,
-0.0077370899,
-0.0934744775,
-0.0173496995,
-0.0099604484,
-0.0377359539,
-0.0427503251,
-0.0657271445,
-0.0422244072,
-0.0247090124,
0.0236714929,
-0.0340524428,
-0.0273679998,
-0.0156677682,
-0.0416300148,
-0.0335888453,
-0.0010670351,
-0.0180222373,
0.0341451168,
-0.045267731,
0.0268812589,
-0.0291986968,
-0.022138644,
0.0181509554,
0.0144248782,
-0.0874022767,
-0.0588807762,
-0.0212662574,
0.0007054896,
0.011056846,
-0.0049763341,
-0.0371009335,
-0.052562993,
0.0355884731,
0.0631989986,
-0.0233444367,
0.0157743189,
0.0259623881,
0.0074344203,
-0.0247561261,
0.0435856171,
-0.0123056779,
0.0314042345,
0.0406801552,
-0.0316571854,
-0.0360191874,
-0.0075362152,
-0.0308501944,
0.0120346025,
0.0330332592,
-0.039518144,
-0.036068704,
-0.0506570563,
-0.0397553258,
0.0007209022,
-0.0134875346,
-0.0554432534,
0.0112296948,
0.0200220589,
0.0051279985,
-0.0161888804,
0.0009284278,
-0.0043334933,
0.0432054326,
-0.0436771996,
0.0451466702,
0.0198897347,
0.0581759959,
0.0188579056,
0.01718341,
0.0020269058,
0.0716514364,
0.0086180689,
0.0307618845,
-0.0177273043,
0.0453425609,
-0.0070326566,
-0.0196484514,
0.0305713806,
0.0320402533,
0.0083059911,
0.030496072,
-0.0538654886,
0.0396953598,
0.0965956971,
-0.0230273977,
0.0860155001,
-0.0131457113,
-0.0044265301,
-0.0288712587,
0.0159206912,
-0.0221676603,
-0.0545885153,
-0.0272897668,
-0.0299577527,
-0.0306198932,
0.0299690682,
0.0757978857,
-0.0133874156,
0.0132106328,
0.0489076599,
-0.0073551624,
-0.0277871229,
0.0225197766,
0.0279918555,
0.0086454749,
-0.0115687083,
0.0268270206,
-0.0274244081,
-0.0423175916,
0.0306009017,
-0.0323177837,
0.0038290648,
0.0320408791,
-0.0180309266,
0.0737086087,
0.0109263407,
0.0569032431,
-0.0380618609,
-0.0163382683,
-0.0020029163,
-0.0312140398,
0.0138583574,
-5.894474913e-33,
0.0280318595,
-0.074132815,
-0.0473519601,
-0.0187407341,
0.0030104381,
0.0288531985,
-0.0211482868,
0.0114527429,
0.005787177,
0.017617546,
-0.0089707039,
0.0262377616,
0.0196786728,
0.0249746479,
-0.0083608814,
-0.0195850451,
0.0291792043,
-0.021226624,
-0.033518333,
0.0070416932,
0.0457375459,
0.0266245231,
0.0652634874,
-0.0469097756,
0.0241400674,
-0.0473600067,
-0.0395109691,
0.0163993537,
0.0349019095,
0.0491880439,
-0.0229074098,
0.0560738929,
0.0564915203,
0.0352654643,
-0.0165361557,
0.0659148768,
-0.0254065972,
-0.0128866462,
-0.0320849307,
0.0352320895,
-0.0724461302,
-0.0520358086,
0.0347020291,
-0.0390227214,
-0.0246708877,
0.019857157,
0.0239954777,
-0.0309807584,
0.0233837105,
-0.0306639988,
-0.0847837552,
0.0626548454,
0.02408503,
0.0099734478,
0.031668704,
0.0704724863,
0.008445641,
0.0366002731,
-0.057433527,
0.0150314244,
-0.0534570515,
-0.0051707467,
0.0271128044,
-0.0053913649,
-0.047289744,
0.0294338726,
0.0260253735,
0.0517931581,
0.0144612845,
-0.0088449437,
0.0020974684,
0.0053646043,
0.0768562257,
0.1038106307,
0.0392627716,
-0.049598936,
-0.0743745491,
0.0216810573,
0.0518548265,
-0.0347928479,
0.0113423299,
-0.0002602391,
-0.0205184445,
0.0122005977,
0.0131745311,
-0.0488107167,
-0.0399855524,
-0.0172293689,
-0.0007145757,
0.044346422,
-0.0267668553,
0.0114405341,
0.0322700776,
-0.0292026382,
-0.0226172842,
-0.0018926295,
-0.0227623656,
0.0320026129,
0.0072298734,
0.0328894258,
-0.0311894584,
-0.0467054322,
0.0100253774,
0.0161555838,
-0.0023864633,
-0.009912801,
0.0874369442,
0.0042997859,
-0.0557258762,
0.0166007914,
-0.0274192467,
0.0298614707,
-0.0005953847,
0.0230633803,
0.0168981627,
-0.0528917685,
-0.0220118891,
0.0394706242,
0.0299282409,
0.0237711407,
-0.0203598216,
-0.0219055973,
-0.0273959991,
0.0243266877,
-0.0176112764,
0.0166387521,
-0.0333191827,
-0.0084271049,
0.0223863423,
-0.0561809726,
0.0124858562,
-0.0290367883,
2.317e-7,
0.0220252834,
0.033829771,
0.014702565,
-0.019994352,
0.0398899205,
0.0432097539,
-0.01147018,
0.0320807956,
-0.0622311085,
0.0196267441,
-0.0320259109,
0.0334033072,
0.0855625123,
0.0135164717,
-0.0645999759,
0.0200614389,
-0.0767792538,
0.0123193841,
-0.0445639454,
-0.0200807173,
0.0258859619,
0.0525507592,
0.0116141587,
-0.0344099887,
-0.0089387447,
-0.0792037398,
0.0684855506,
-0.01503208,
-0.0091503272,
-0.0126713701,
0.0339569598,
0.0149205662,
-0.0022078503,
-0.0199716147,
-0.0244394578,
-0.0285098255,
0.0429252088,
0.0571053885,
0.0273890644,
0.0313792564,
0.0509832948,
-0.0166828632,
-0.0157402232,
-0.0072437539,
0.048741363,
-0.0086864224,
-0.0344308019,
-0.0306185,
0.023981927,
-0.0318199508,
0.0541331433,
-0.0344062112,
-0.0530729257,
0.0505458638,
0.050390806,
-0.0104668792,
-0.0278314799,
-0.0296618268,
-0.0085313888,
-0.0124711432,
-0.0191933047,
0.0121274404,
-0.0705616698,
0.0293746591,
0.046127364,
-0.0252317488,
0.0366002545,
1.618426592e-34,
0.0303472187,
-0.0298180357,
0.0042281426,
-0.0119289225,
-0.0055376152,
0.0202252474,
-0.0410341546,
-0.010232782,
-0.0063633253,
0.0034852112,
0.0514092892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12548v1 | P-Tailor: Customizing Personality Traits for Language Models via Mixture of Specialized LoRA Experts | 2024-06-18T12:25:13 | 2024-06-18T12:25:13 | Yuhao Dan, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Junfeng Tian, Liang He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personalized large language models (LLMs) have attracted great attention in
many applications, such as intelligent education and emotional support. Most
work focuses on controlling the character settings based on the profile (e.g.,
age, skill, experience, and so on). Conversely, the psychological theory-based
personality traits with implicit expression and behavior are not well modeled,
limiting their potential application in more specialized fields such as the
psychological counseling agents. In this paper, we propose a mixture of experts
(MoE)-based personalized LLMs, named P-tailor, to model the Big Five
Personality Traits. Particularly, we learn specialized LoRA experts to
represent various traits, such as openness, conscientiousness, extraversion,
agreeableness and neuroticism. Then, we integrate P-Tailor with a personality
specialization loss, promoting experts to specialize in distinct personality
traits, thereby enhancing the efficiency of model parameter utilization. Due to
the lack of datasets, we also curate a high-quality personality crafting
dataset (PCD) to learn and develop the ability to exhibit different personality
traits across various topics. We conduct extensive experiments to verify the
great performance and effectiveness of P-Tailor in manipulation of the
fine-grained personality traits of LLMs. | [
0.0714927688,
0.0428879373,
-0.0474421717,
0.0186639931,
-0.0145653086,
-0.007083578,
0.039768137,
-0.0413791686,
0.0046471716,
0.0257075187,
-0.0547281094,
0.0273231473,
-0.0298600625,
0.029690804,
0.0212968197,
-0.0706354678,
0.0393278599,
-0.0078625167,
0.0629869998,
-0.0368030705,
0.0014033836,
0.0548186116,
0.0029097577,
0.0429938398,
0.0118013527,
-0.0143627357,
0.0071465797,
-0.0182452854,
0.037720874,
0.0105465287,
0.0401402526,
0.0646283031,
-0.0000567506,
-0.0359322913,
0.0000019981,
-0.0287690088,
-0.0381735265,
-0.015210811,
0.0149166817,
-0.0344412103,
0.0930004343,
0.0470370091,
0.0038208314,
0.0463545173,
-0.0575926974,
-0.0144811319,
0.0114285974,
0.0538564995,
0.0823324472,
0.0648077354,
-0.0050366153,
-0.0205164123,
-0.0011845072,
-0.0039048211,
0.0239486564,
-0.022259783,
0.0152758537,
-0.0325032286,
-0.0239687935,
0.0162032526,
-0.0148251001,
-0.0135342712,
-0.0149240615,
0.0043830615,
0.0012457287,
-0.046103444,
-0.0208169017,
-0.0178795699,
0.0065259933,
0.0515869595,
0.0189475194,
-0.0013522794,
-0.0118696596,
-0.0247437656,
0.0342447236,
0.0101028373,
0.0121417008,
0.0135086607,
-0.0081176041,
-0.0101012792,
0.0441211239,
0.0080157854,
-0.0346291065,
-0.0008847457,
-0.0267267823,
0.0516213402,
-0.0101629039,
0.0084257368,
0.0024785805,
-0.019457357,
0.0163566731,
-0.0334234349,
0.0272075105,
0.008970594,
-0.0155819627,
0.0215623807,
-0.0572762899,
0.0155153805,
0.0114407288,
0.0009296589,
0.028589461,
0.0239148997,
-0.0015105979,
-0.0124245575,
0.0253419876,
0.0125346854,
0.0366093554,
0.0225343071,
-0.0321054831,
-0.0229086708,
-0.0938242227,
-0.0011035047,
-0.0029141523,
0.007654164,
0.0104515133,
0.0180955902,
-0.0781863779,
0.0295827817,
-0.0382052213,
0.0044778092,
0.011963659,
0.0034785317,
-0.0137755666,
0.0048130904,
-0.0813662782,
0.018042447,
-0.0435554571,
-0.0019276105,
-0.0164702851,
-0.0202875491,
0.0495285206,
0.0049511031,
0.0037275765,
-0.0288863555,
0.0552693605,
0.0520451553,
0.0088132862,
-0.0399993509,
-0.0382557362,
-0.0270535331,
-0.0085754916,
-0.0639603063,
0.0150456131,
-0.0278553702,
0.0401563011,
-0.034320835,
0.0026463941,
-0.0931494758,
-0.0315141343,
0.0010351411,
-0.0093507897,
0.0407560654,
-0.0043603815,
0.0142975226,
0.0151048163,
-0.0050665173,
-0.0061692246,
0.0388835929,
0.0157213211,
0.0159336179,
0.0066197026,
-0.0543699451,
0.0279254001,
0.0296981875,
-0.0240026787,
0.014286573,
-0.0453909896,
-0.0151032396,
-0.0059368564,
-0.01040754,
0.0691395327,
0.00895504,
-0.0090548834,
-0.0009718818,
0.0757826939,
0.0588323101,
0.0753836483,
0.0697291568,
0.0185907446,
0.0514742509,
0.047849711,
-0.0321302526,
-0.0215310864,
0.0296445917,
-0.0357960276,
0.0101040937,
-0.0514789857,
0.0423998907,
-0.0235445667,
-0.0599747449,
0.0110476604,
-0.0159954391,
0.0196072552,
0.0475826152,
-0.0090980595,
-0.0150687983,
0.0023598415,
0.0074733063,
0.0575049967,
-0.0554534942,
-0.0398762263,
-0.0628234148,
0.0002630243,
0.1210019961,
-0.0015913701,
-0.0349151976,
-0.0450322479,
-0.0115003577,
-0.0668357313,
0.0238888096,
0.0489890128,
-0.0120851956,
-0.0073481519,
-0.0624086335,
-0.0035607452,
-0.0121341487,
0.0008629524,
0.0166233405,
0.003621347,
0.0174939949,
-0.0087049501,
0.0312347338,
0.004207626,
0.0104545597,
-0.0990861133,
-0.0084770303,
0.0156035637,
0.0337166153,
0.0333938152,
0.0271978229,
0.0150733674,
-0.0226025302,
0.0076966304,
0.0096093779,
-0.0148361428,
0.0300916173,
0.0136718554,
0.0100907199,
0.0203476865,
-0.0259937067,
-0.0175803266,
-0.0137762967,
-0.0027633298,
-0.0160972681,
-0.0011486117,
-0.034565974,
0.0508428104,
-0.0154649587,
0.031579949,
-0.0458390526,
0.0625423938,
-0.0114612868,
0.0303377863,
-0.0097574536,
-0.0205337312,
0.0110136624,
0.0156742539,
-0.0279207341,
-0.0681869835,
-0.019390827,
-0.045947928,
0.0362992473,
0.0500974916,
0.0092907008,
0.0330747291,
-0.0547627397,
-0.1055581346,
-0.0342461318,
0.0085932529,
0.0459788293,
-0.0100680636,
0.0041967141,
-0.0133537585,
-0.049519714,
0.0021263361,
-0.0499882065,
0.0002417926,
-0.0083066104,
0.0068221544,
0.0208822712,
0.0018909308,
-0.0263405684,
-0.0565209016,
-0.0164722782,
-0.0332742147,
0.0010780322,
-0.0335947834,
0.066074349,
-0.0252436604,
0.0201868024,
-0.0689983144,
0.0146804433,
-0.011067085,
-0.0725062117,
0.0100620445,
-0.0182308443,
0.0221139621,
0.0652467236,
0.0062470315,
0.0240513347,
0.0239394158,
0.0038996083,
-0.0384652056,
0.0300911739,
-0.0103788907,
-0.0006040608,
-0.0399073847,
-0.0300718397,
-0.0387427583,
0.0126502141,
0.0122798169,
-0.0024202766,
-0.0684206039,
0.0502356961,
0.0589738488,
-0.0637333468,
0.0828202143,
0.0593756437,
0.0123966159,
0.0428893641,
0.0174044818,
0.0081413947,
0.0623608045,
0.0212453306,
0.0091007994,
-0.0208322536,
-0.0697344914,
-0.0471516475,
0.0341770165,
-0.0273150261,
0.000380975,
0.024184322,
-0.0084403194,
-0.0393182337,
-0.0476373583,
0.0206860509,
-0.0447058007,
0.0167501569,
-0.0034504894,
-0.0540815108,
0.0493374616,
-0.0158377867,
-0.0259794313,
-0.0508189052,
-0.0381505154,
-0.0209975075,
0.0344936587,
-0.0262054801,
-0.0609392747,
-0.0404677242,
0.0122651421,
-0.0074442127,
-0.0310977865,
-0.00412144,
-0.012140546,
-0.0624029487,
0.0543944724,
0.0353868902,
-0.0002991508,
-0.0695857853,
-0.0177068096,
-0.0171929467,
-0.0575447306,
-0.023432333,
-0.0027670085,
0.0426730663,
0.0135930432,
-0.0188760757,
0.0023019407,
0.014990082,
0.0316222198,
-0.0220071226,
0.0218067076,
0.1207656786,
0.0232122671,
-0.0243188702,
0.0137875425,
-0.0021402305,
0.022788981,
0.0450213216,
0.0705197155,
-0.0023991358,
-0.0095911454,
-0.035356421,
0.0214889981,
-0.0333160684,
-0.0261495579,
-0.0297281519,
-0.0923639387,
0.0353285,
0.0251006857,
-0.030934168,
-0.0002752622,
-0.0117334332,
-0.0091007398,
-0.0516112372,
0.0065939482,
-0.05336041,
-0.0071002198,
-0.0118913446,
-0.0101635167,
-0.0478887372,
-0.0479164347,
0.084688589,
-0.0097787036,
0.0677977651,
-0.0058642281,
0.0165280774,
-0.0232616048,
-0.0321908519,
-0.0922241956,
0.0659879819,
0.0082788533,
0.0257277768,
0.0606359653,
-0.0222051423,
-0.0016056498,
-0.0750422105,
0.0270076357,
-0.014441641,
0.0379707627,
0.0242494773,
0.0378775746,
0.0173441097,
-0.0300233234,
-0.0244342238,
0.0060433899,
0.0255558137,
0.0382189229,
-0.0296087004,
-0.1183706671,
0.0150058251,
-0.0009528258,
-0.0454189219,
0.0041228333,
-0.0714922473,
0.0352216251,
-0.0116871791,
-0.0234269891,
-0.0210570265,
-0.0633127391,
0.0424890406,
0.0480565093,
-0.0016677356,
-0.0317511149,
-0.0278276373,
0.0282557663,
-0.0133844726,
0.0357523002,
-0.0261209328,
-0.0043927119,
-0.0588628985,
-0.0490072258,
0.0711596683,
-0.0698649064,
-0.0030825129,
0.0243621599,
-0.0469244123,
-0.0588587262,
0.0337316692,
0.0588517338,
0.0210686848,
0.044368092,
0.0096793994,
-0.0775912851,
0.0341859311,
0.0116465483,
-0.0290807132,
0.0271549374,
0.0157059617,
0.0255465433,
0.0020893277,
0.0207258593,
-0.0289668329,
0.0577773936,
0.0120864669,
-0.0241003446,
-0.0163746495,
-0.0783681795,
0.0113520706,
0.041113738,
-0.0494996607,
-0.0102837142,
-0.0234121513,
-0.0239029024,
0.0014700288,
-0.0417855233,
-0.01814791,
-0.0166422855,
-0.0589063503,
0.0084024779,
-0.0164617747,
0.0073230616,
-0.0704654157,
-0.0238177814,
-0.0071690013,
-0.0421587005,
0.0237398837,
0.0187060069,
0.0359322876,
-0.0204628631,
0.0302061159,
-0.0142742563,
-0.0169635862,
-0.0012236066,
0.0399215892,
-0.0035335571,
0.0496353656,
-0.0427426398,
0.0142622711,
-0.0537833646,
0.0422720239,
-0.0114982296,
-0.0463170111,
0.0028761111,
0.0193422958,
0.0162018668,
0.008371491,
0.0459249876,
-0.0167562198,
0.0072747683,
-0.0055354796,
0.0511634424,
0.001000652,
-0.0076632779,
0.0023027319,
0.0086458335,
-0.0015016552,
-0.0454242304,
0.0197560452,
0.0487089008,
0.0341790095,
-0.0346078724,
-0.0055887555,
-0.0765596703,
0.031875968,
0.0280217379,
0.0218292642,
-0.0034566009,
0.0005632634,
-0.0742071196,
-0.087085858,
0.0587589815,
-0.0022080161,
-0.0254657827,
-0.0133537939,
0.012642704,
0.0172362514,
-0.036762625,
-0.0175442584,
-0.0497805662,
-0.0111667663,
0.0256410353,
0.0007266527,
0.0137279797,
-5.540156303e-33,
-0.0264519434,
0.0044036517,
0.0321212336,
0.0046450137,
0.0162254944,
-0.0487114489,
-0.0035762035,
0.0279801134,
-0.0249526761,
-0.0095077576,
-0.0406962745,
-0.0013648702,
0.0043906989,
-0.0211877506,
0.0259473305,
0.0420049764,
0.0546227507,
0.0205642004,
0.0121212499,
-0.0043063825,
0.0087117748,
0.0133792618,
0.0755425543,
-0.0714631975,
-0.0019471465,
-0.031592492,
-0.0235870238,
0.0004990093,
0.0139837405,
0.0908520892,
0.0183839723,
0.0497996397,
0.0077506034,
-0.0013151428,
-0.0289876629,
-0.0307922084,
-0.0431305915,
-0.058925245,
0.0045681023,
0.0052590184,
0.0242615622,
-0.070867829,
0.0049790279,
-0.0109423492,
-0.0009221723,
-0.0361821651,
0.062163841,
-0.0165058747,
0.0328859054,
0.0642036796,
-0.0386416465,
-0.002870512,
-0.0339267701,
0.0169960875,
0.000066997,
-0.0192391742,
-0.0262526032,
0.0003712561,
-0.037763983,
0.0477875732,
0.0186757054,
-0.0238321535,
-0.0009789946,
0.0095873326,
-0.0095141912,
0.0221767332,
0.0647656992,
0.0731858835,
0.0535617769,
-0.0113804908,
0.055452399,
0.0734790787,
-0.0041954606,
0.0769841596,
-0.0219353754,
-0.0512147918,
0.0014501853,
0.00843737,
0.0971218199,
-0.0351285636,
0.0467350893,
0.0181350801,
-0.0384710468,
-0.0152480863,
-0.0210412219,
0.0119166085,
-0.015090391,
-0.0376955345,
0.0098321578,
-0.0164362919,
-0.0163183957,
-0.0326882154,
0.0122455638,
-0.0408096574,
0.0218548402,
0.007536551,
-0.0767800212,
0.0288897213,
-0.0124728922,
0.0034265073,
-0.0523562282,
-0.0490523912,
0.0009728324,
-0.0239646286,
0.0463003553,
0.0341206715,
0.0213168729,
0.0608134829,
-0.0685451403,
-0.0031070791,
0.0273898728,
0.0273853485,
0.0013543546,
0.0234554969,
-0.0107236654,
0.0124495933,
-0.0159736648,
0.0209682789,
-0.0078897551,
0.0059754108,
-0.0210458897,
-0.0099742161,
0.0626565516,
0.0040723281,
-0.0097722895,
-0.0026341935,
-0.0486751124,
-0.026919486,
0.0507478006,
-0.0144231869,
0.0140287858,
0.0040892968,
2.696e-7,
-0.0401634835,
0.0552935079,
-0.048964262,
0.0381972753,
0.0072327857,
0.0433882885,
0.007221946,
-0.0007991189,
0.0367777534,
-0.0013739094,
0.021219993,
0.0436550491,
0.0302880146,
0.0067359866,
-0.0571097024,
0.0087548345,
0.0315719508,
0.0168178622,
-0.0195044726,
0.0102930991,
0.0432637073,
0.079144232,
0.0630738437,
-0.0071053323,
0.0011803198,
0.034130089,
0.0320016742,
0.01083213,
-0.033396285,
0.0527983457,
-0.0197070055,
0.0168602262,
0.0089461207,
0.0499643348,
0.0107680578,
0.0293195304,
-0.0257912967,
0.1017300412,
-0.0575194247,
-0.0284971315,
0.0338896886,
0.0246380512,
-0.0421274863,
0.010737069,
0.0377347991,
0.0010972095,
-0.0766641423,
-0.035458494,
-0.0216905288,
-0.0202036537,
0.0151304901,
-0.0221545715,
0.0016250269,
0.0330492035,
0.0094114328,
-0.0388539061,
-0.0067975358,
-0.0637515336,
0.0340914838,
0.0130626261,
-0.0441418998,
-0.0488398783,
0.0185383037,
0.012881482,
0.0473478921,
-0.0408491716,
0.0557829514,
2.16685394e-34,
-0.0057752822,
0.0687250495,
0.0202474818,
-0.0176294036,
0.0704855919,
0.0240640324,
0.012905472,
0.0240335185,
0.044541683,
-0.069233641,
-0.0287771076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12546v1 | Liar, Liar, Logical Mire: A Benchmark for Suppositional Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T12:24:22 | 2024-06-18T12:24:22 | Philipp Mondorf, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knights and knaves problems represent a classic genre of logical puzzles
where characters either tell the truth or lie. The objective is to logically
deduce each character's identity based on their statements. The challenge
arises from the truth-telling or lying behavior, which influences the logical
implications of each statement. Solving these puzzles requires not only direct
deductions from individual statements, but the ability to assess the
truthfulness of statements by reasoning through various hypothetical scenarios.
As such, knights and knaves puzzles serve as compelling examples of
suppositional reasoning. In this paper, we introduce $\textit{TruthQuest}$, a
benchmark for suppositional reasoning based on the principles of knights and
knaves puzzles. Our benchmark presents problems of varying complexity,
considering both the number of characters and the types of logical statements
involved. Evaluations on $\textit{TruthQuest}$ show that large language models
like Llama 3 and Mixtral-8x7B exhibit significant difficulties solving these
tasks. A detailed error analysis of the models' output reveals that
lower-performing models exhibit a diverse range of reasoning errors, frequently
failing to grasp the concept of truth and lies. In comparison, more proficient
models primarily struggle with accurately inferring the logical implications of
potentially false statements. | [
0.0867247358,
0.0438881442,
-0.034620259,
0.0684406012,
-0.1151972935,
0.0027782386,
0.0155607518,
-0.0010260388,
0.0134077827,
-0.0336981565,
0.0444486849,
0.0058044232,
0.0193974487,
-0.0242631938,
0.0273017585,
-0.0089368867,
0.0826816186,
-0.0467793941,
0.0330067053,
-0.025606744,
-0.0022906794,
0.0089029074,
-0.0381507501,
-0.012446885,
-0.044245176,
-0.0290005244,
-0.0183951911,
-0.0111954473,
0.0091812043,
0.0167112816,
-0.0263703167,
0.0135915009,
0.0023039908,
0.0412150547,
0.0000023238,
-0.0414138511,
-0.0057163807,
-0.0203458257,
-0.0776998773,
0.0341589972,
0.0013825301,
0.0124679189,
0.0125110736,
0.0137130283,
-0.0140842861,
-0.0027940555,
0.0459184162,
0.0688396841,
0.0558976345,
0.0667208731,
0.0244522747,
-0.0315650813,
-0.0132837705,
-0.0127337174,
0.0163881183,
-0.0599476807,
0.0101958299,
0.0124858227,
0.0288402252,
-0.0008961,
0.019423835,
0.0182451475,
0.0167571586,
-0.0017192217,
-0.073839128,
0.0076357471,
-0.0274283439,
0.0109366309,
0.0016701511,
0.0243768319,
-0.0105059184,
-0.0123190284,
-0.0051185014,
0.0098664174,
0.017384775,
0.0404498391,
0.0304109678,
0.0662278756,
-0.0536922254,
-0.0363983028,
0.0151165891,
0.0265566781,
0.0263883844,
-0.0254658181,
-0.0429567285,
0.1012278348,
-0.024894448,
-0.0106642125,
0.0146371545,
-0.0461098962,
-0.032184273,
-0.0764893591,
-0.0220184289,
0.0407956317,
-0.024247501,
0.0245887414,
-0.0140090892,
0.0063771894,
0.0470819287,
-0.0609118715,
0.0560422055,
0.0272996817,
0.0003017006,
0.0490582772,
-0.0078816786,
0.0661838353,
-0.0089038741,
0.0050032632,
-0.0256730635,
0.011570205,
0.0038364446,
-0.0174198318,
-0.0376101136,
0.0480992869,
-0.026554469,
0.0233403314,
0.0111982115,
-0.0287668481,
-0.0034223187,
0.0594999939,
-0.0273826141,
-0.0142138917,
-0.0012119024,
-0.0340745561,
-0.0524344631,
0.0183975734,
-0.05871794,
0.0236532073,
-0.0075843674,
-0.0520183593,
-0.0099355942,
-0.0283580087,
-0.0073542949,
-0.0310522877,
0.04076593,
0.0602088533,
0.0159161296,
0.0201571919,
-0.0362274684,
-0.0415100008,
-0.0338993594,
-0.1070835292,
-0.0319372676,
-0.0690230355,
0.0336677358,
0.0037898796,
-0.0092719942,
-0.0305748917,
0.0243430082,
0.0051361849,
-0.0179781336,
0.0693066493,
0.030262636,
0.0258482695,
-0.0127246706,
0.0145847248,
-0.0318326689,
0.0526791401,
0.0099534029,
0.0435707942,
0.0051642307,
0.010847901,
0.0001798661,
0.0169605128,
0.0199300665,
-0.0536279865,
0.0090458859,
0.0402068608,
0.0678662211,
0.0345425308,
-0.0306203347,
0.0524942018,
-0.0125984447,
-0.0644547343,
0.0435095355,
-0.028306568,
0.0115347011,
-0.0177088622,
0.020136971,
-0.0306079984,
0.0558786578,
0.0173639264,
-0.0564220883,
0.0283012446,
-0.0356910229,
0.0109882364,
-0.0191350989,
0.0523762926,
0.006615418,
-0.032448858,
-0.0163089037,
0.0048471428,
-0.0442710295,
0.0274754409,
0.0160719194,
-0.0154415965,
-0.0348234512,
0.0266884156,
0.0284063779,
-0.0588577278,
-0.0303854216,
-0.050566379,
0.0329365805,
0.0178456921,
0.0416782759,
-0.0281409398,
-0.0310171451,
0.0024109141,
0.0110781165,
-0.0019591083,
0.0264222845,
-0.0032120815,
0.0292275418,
-0.0052548666,
0.0134644583,
-0.0317361653,
0.0183320194,
0.0175879132,
-0.008934156,
-0.0089490144,
-0.024275817,
-0.0964320824,
0.0444683097,
0.0357386991,
-0.0025524846,
0.0276766345,
-0.0581770502,
0.0280237384,
0.0137648564,
-0.0003848523,
-0.0308726933,
0.0161740631,
0.0146797523,
-0.0346185975,
0.0108242407,
-0.0216802228,
-0.0295180567,
-0.0614308491,
0.0469145812,
-0.0514803529,
-0.0275148228,
0.0563835651,
-0.0246277004,
-0.01701474,
0.0044473619,
-0.0485791452,
0.0068588145,
0.0022385032,
0.0228459518,
-0.030327376,
-0.0403406955,
-0.0282195285,
0.1035276577,
-0.0120738149,
0.020965077,
-0.0740073472,
-0.0344783515,
0.031355191,
-0.0607921854,
-0.0075925123,
-0.0127728935,
0.0010533321,
0.0065410682,
0.005105752,
-0.0074045612,
-0.0005042465,
-0.0674975887,
-0.0610519424,
-0.002203681,
0.0145320781,
-0.0020628057,
-0.015802756,
-0.0101340637,
-0.0214402881,
0.0047343834,
-0.0312971361,
-0.0114127789,
0.0171421506,
-0.0110731414,
0.0053313184,
0.0177426692,
-0.0048263893,
-0.0027505448,
0.0175780393,
-0.0229302589,
0.0223993417,
-0.0060009165,
0.0036379783,
-0.0038356374,
0.0665427446,
-0.0917234123,
0.0297283847,
-0.0199525729,
-0.0204602275,
0.0084032239,
-0.0048712404,
-0.0143153667,
0.0908383653,
0.0014979509,
0.013636807,
0.0337369554,
-0.0384304598,
-0.0230905656,
0.0188328456,
-0.000345709,
0.0129264407,
-0.0020893249,
-0.0806714743,
-0.0073018698,
0.0500621684,
0.0225522052,
-0.0078394981,
-0.0176871121,
0.0160204414,
0.0036029143,
-0.0133868949,
0.0107247187,
-0.0302256048,
0.0389813371,
0.0529711843,
-0.0274202134,
0.0102289449,
0.1007976457,
-0.0290696081,
0.0319469012,
0.0101936664,
0.0292699933,
-0.0193729233,
0.0717320219,
0.0040855724,
0.0486962311,
0.0356774591,
0.0007421891,
-0.0259294044,
-0.0475274809,
0.0591986775,
-0.0404488333,
0.0029706913,
-0.0568231568,
0.0171776228,
-0.00988732,
-0.0690523833,
-0.0487541705,
-0.0315029621,
-0.0686632469,
-0.0451320596,
-0.064297542,
-0.0228662957,
-0.0494047552,
-0.0027752446,
0.0016080012,
-0.0233307835,
0.0090890015,
0.0097826105,
-0.0284954179,
-0.028654946,
0.0084812958,
0.02653425,
0.0627970472,
-0.0183045343,
0.0086140297,
0.0452425741,
0.0094703818,
0.0508356132,
-0.0300725941,
-0.0004126721,
-0.008669965,
-0.0065038223,
-0.0090907011,
0.0072417175,
0.0080066789,
-0.0474651903,
0.008114391,
0.0883104056,
0.0468196347,
0.0752172172,
0.010060044,
-0.021862261,
0.0090609984,
0.0051181442,
0.026018735,
-0.1080503017,
-0.0247700624,
0.0350525789,
-0.0315882228,
-0.0464390703,
-0.067000553,
0.0014294257,
-0.1323006302,
0.0622931831,
0.0085946117,
-0.0328002833,
-0.0583677702,
-0.0099479659,
0.0048546842,
0.009152689,
0.0009101943,
0.0414363667,
0.0172103848,
-0.0085217273,
-0.0053531216,
0.007849508,
0.0149388406,
0.0380318761,
-0.0056527397,
0.0644113868,
0.0167083479,
0.0281002689,
-0.0073362547,
-0.0527566448,
-0.0023721457,
0.0613396876,
-0.0262378901,
-0.016992256,
0.0207954757,
0.0024801388,
-0.0316462107,
-0.0435001105,
-0.0055587208,
0.0165995471,
-0.0194394123,
0.0196927488,
0.0498718992,
-0.013638474,
-0.0551634468,
-0.0010643917,
0.019611096,
-0.01887279,
0.0749611855,
0.0251518413,
0.0240609013,
-0.0413085818,
-0.0258746631,
-0.0254471637,
-0.0084867636,
-0.0241360608,
0.0481977761,
0.0664472952,
0.0838598385,
-0.0363272391,
0.0141454898,
0.0286483709,
0.0155718084,
0.0080584353,
-0.017187655,
0.0211354829,
0.0178706553,
-0.0746371597,
-0.017764315,
-0.0500725172,
0.0411289446,
-0.0312573612,
0.0547552519,
0.0045149345,
-0.0487275682,
-0.0107382145,
-0.0329648331,
-0.0269912034,
-0.0382514223,
0.0304857455,
0.065702714,
0.0297304597,
0.000794216,
-0.0282369293,
-0.0097266594,
-0.0115220705,
0.0290334411,
-0.0318243504,
0.0429923981,
0.0155964168,
-0.0321673676,
0.0113153234,
0.0232128333,
0.00068369,
0.0356569551,
0.0249241218,
-0.0155400233,
-0.0194752198,
-0.0421389081,
0.0462776795,
0.0376576744,
-0.0255100075,
0.0520819277,
0.0259716697,
-0.0058838194,
0.0067007495,
-0.0430234596,
-0.0219308045,
-0.0146370009,
0.007308681,
0.0014938014,
0.0491154231,
0.0338255279,
-0.0002538037,
0.0114214979,
0.000833915,
0.0142198708,
-0.0078448933,
0.023707252,
0.0234063379,
0.0126034273,
-0.0153970765,
-0.0283720568,
0.0147046484,
-0.0193414968,
0.0819027945,
0.0090795811,
0.0279221553,
0.0460211076,
-0.0310951173,
-0.0481649712,
-0.0010180795,
-0.0698997751,
-0.0247960314,
0.0623948723,
-0.0124535095,
0.0107613569,
-0.0174193121,
-0.0221944172,
-0.0202497095,
0.0112284198,
0.0123599507,
-0.0012513009,
0.0551772304,
-0.014300066,
0.0525514372,
0.0336603038,
0.0113855936,
0.0135462256,
0.0263028909,
-0.0155646708,
0.0889195874,
0.0321453847,
-0.0031410118,
-0.0493793599,
-0.0335564502,
-0.0260005053,
0.0160847865,
-0.0021846322,
0.0139115583,
-0.1074485183,
-0.0579718091,
0.0424250737,
0.0437110513,
0.0265063383,
-0.0076287454,
0.0021126645,
0.0599959791,
0.0658898205,
-0.0423970222,
-0.0290202219,
0.0291810278,
-0.011055843,
0.0077337702,
0.0234551989,
-6.927866323e-33,
-0.0495953262,
-0.0308638271,
0.005297638,
-0.001370815,
-0.0214082133,
-0.0143543845,
-0.0077330517,
0.0055613131,
-0.0985296965,
0.0076573207,
0.0074126949,
0.0397331826,
0.007672207,
-0.0134384725,
-0.0539889075,
0.0130828312,
0.0034964953,
0.0207610615,
-0.0540078059,
-0.0436230376,
0.0314949192,
-0.0558597594,
0.030402638,
-0.0816741511,
0.0100426637,
0.0071219639,
-0.0392215736,
0.0498657003,
-0.0909913406,
0.0203889273,
-0.0109525863,
-0.0009947912,
0.0062441975,
0.0038406118,
0.0584989488,
0.0039617624,
-0.038272284,
-0.0173128806,
0.0794398859,
0.0029641364,
-0.0070758024,
-0.0331800617,
-0.0000578843,
-0.0041230302,
-0.0090408456,
-0.030797746,
0.0029729577,
-0.0259156656,
0.0380327292,
0.0568040311,
-0.0435710996,
0.0024849456,
-0.0308472067,
-0.0545747541,
0.0032385951,
0.027221499,
0.0044982568,
-0.0453455299,
-0.0551265441,
0.0252154395,
0.0255331304,
-0.0228361357,
0.0151463188,
-0.0162135027,
-0.0156474691,
0.0663546026,
0.0142359594,
-0.007889864,
-0.0406513475,
0.065860413,
0.0159841068,
0.0831695721,
0.1023076028,
0.079031989,
-0.002027174,
-0.0049429177,
-0.0910938084,
-0.0146549111,
0.0405635387,
-0.0136925541,
0.037953753,
-0.0363209918,
-0.0591572337,
-0.0246943254,
-0.0613668747,
-0.0217088573,
-0.0418116525,
0.0044020414,
0.0088020759,
-0.0099904025,
-0.0155589143,
-0.0271822363,
0.0201762486,
-0.0462738648,
0.0060062618,
-0.0459238701,
0.0307665952,
0.0231965668,
0.0012303443,
0.0641908422,
-0.0154310223,
0.0079542873,
0.0259559192,
0.0290581416,
0.0274343342,
0.0075598932,
0.0203151349,
0.023786135,
-0.0406076685,
0.0068664863,
-0.0373435058,
0.0238019247,
-0.0114994477,
-0.0327946097,
0.0643731877,
-0.0028213686,
-0.0199398156,
-0.0462957621,
-0.014108208,
-0.0375735797,
-0.0632746965,
0.0579514615,
-0.0275507011,
0.0220007058,
0.0055370941,
-0.0051108985,
-0.0582441613,
0.0048784795,
-0.0308535546,
-0.0049392106,
-0.0132523924,
-0.0044658328,
3.112e-7,
0.0098813232,
0.0127755851,
0.0391078219,
0.0705081746,
-0.0051734275,
0.0576905496,
-0.0065835826,
-0.0037447594,
0.0204666723,
-0.0943051204,
-0.0262668449,
0.0353130847,
0.0226155967,
0.0423144996,
-0.0210482031,
0.0417542122,
-0.0078468081,
-0.057001356,
-0.0433660969,
0.0336637683,
0.0575870611,
0.0560727082,
0.0413485877,
-0.010900083,
0.000387907,
-0.0326972082,
0.0189626459,
0.0220314935,
-0.008716315,
0.0129116271,
0.0009817478,
-0.0062907408,
0.0029709549,
0.0645879507,
0.0612812415,
-0.0003274287,
-0.0008359757,
0.0212534312,
-0.0237047747,
-0.0067951707,
-0.0299846381,
-0.0246972516,
-0.0285566449,
-0.0805674493,
0.0990503356,
0.0014260828,
-0.0458826348,
-0.0418390296,
0.0056665679,
0.0088099716,
0.0084874118,
0.0227450319,
-0.0200009253,
0.0275359806,
0.0080343587,
-0.0181574933,
0.0045347409,
-0.0614182614,
-0.0327359848,
-0.0051799831,
0.0104388371,
-0.0432610922,
0.0280049555,
0.0022473526,
0.0255513862,
-0.0490879118,
-0.00424624,
2.770798142e-34,
0.0175181311,
0.0082374709,
0.0082981372,
-0.0145629868,
0.0768177435,
-0.0029879257,
-0.0600457415,
0.0061959531,
0.0229816828,
-0.0376794524,
-0.0022741053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12534v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12534v3 | Unified Active Retrieval for Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T12:09:02 | 2024-06-27T15:37:15 | Qinyuan Cheng, Xiaonan Li, Shimin Li, Qin Zhu, Zhangyue Yin, Yunfan Shao, Linyang Li, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), retrieval is not always helpful and
applying it to every instruction is sub-optimal. Therefore, determining whether
to retrieve is crucial for RAG, which is usually referred to as Active
Retrieval. However, existing active retrieval methods face two challenges: 1.
They usually rely on a single criterion, which struggles with handling various
types of instructions. 2. They depend on specialized and highly differentiated
procedures, and thus combining them makes the RAG system more complicated and
leads to higher response latency. To address these challenges, we propose
Unified Active Retrieval (UAR). UAR contains four orthogonal criteria and casts
them into plug-and-play classification tasks, which achieves multifaceted
retrieval timing judgements with negligible extra inference cost. We further
introduce the Unified Active Retrieval Criteria (UAR-Criteria), designed to
process diverse active retrieval scenarios through a standardized procedure.
Experiments on four representative types of user instructions show that UAR
significantly outperforms existing work on the retrieval timing judgement and
the performance of downstream tasks, which shows the effectiveness of UAR and
its helpfulness to downstream tasks. | [
0.0311694983,
0.0249346253,
-0.0151624046,
-0.0222313944,
-0.0077183195,
0.0113154612,
-0.0035176026,
0.0142810578,
-0.0053543281,
-0.0436404198,
0.0000753191,
-0.0537325367,
-0.0095195118,
-0.0087126084,
-0.0074469764,
-0.0208806135,
0.065694049,
0.0247412622,
-0.0011906328,
0.0390591919,
-0.0150363268,
0.004703966,
-0.0208484307,
0.0629342645,
-0.0231169034,
0.0147671523,
-0.0076217554,
0.0564504229,
0.034444876,
-0.0159912184,
0.0237314533,
0.034938667,
0.0067057,
0.0216755215,
0.0000020378,
-0.0312534384,
-0.0393128507,
-0.0079899542,
-0.0228877049,
0.0101571316,
0.0076877354,
0.0905330107,
-0.0286463387,
0.0347367488,
-0.034701746,
-0.0108831301,
0.0474248268,
-0.0065748277,
0.0279081967,
0.0572360903,
-0.0056265327,
0.0294054747,
-0.0148902349,
-0.0203983244,
0.0605968162,
-0.0135829216,
-0.0177009813,
-0.008742719,
0.0423769504,
0.0284905378,
0.0398208313,
0.0530695505,
0.0366320945,
0.0040021897,
-0.0045695012,
0.0006286205,
-0.0392958596,
0.0004290771,
-0.0094244843,
0.0155758215,
0.050438825,
0.0059404015,
0.0232638195,
-0.0152362837,
0.0037469014,
0.0019788106,
-0.0255787428,
-0.0120715089,
-0.0654295534,
-0.0084911101,
-0.0348619223,
0.0176628884,
0.002399443,
-0.0267401561,
-0.0044948542,
0.0343531854,
0.0100851031,
-0.0386671573,
-0.0194525495,
0.0161830094,
-0.0160099436,
0.0052224398,
0.0277767964,
0.0424161628,
-0.0316582173,
-0.0044246581,
-0.0274564847,
-0.0284950715,
0.034645047,
-0.0055342559,
0.0860607922,
0.0564273112,
-0.0385343544,
-0.0052064746,
-0.0326447375,
0.0524181351,
-0.0106118843,
-0.0193340499,
-0.037819583,
0.0457341596,
-0.063170597,
-0.0389025435,
-0.0464783162,
0.0635650381,
-0.0391434282,
-0.014630788,
-0.0588726997,
0.0236043148,
-0.02960895,
-0.0202302895,
0.0127189495,
0.0347209238,
-0.0748089403,
0.0424068235,
-0.0328904949,
0.0218889378,
-0.0299833957,
0.0016212467,
0.020501798,
-0.0771731138,
-0.0117374165,
0.0203096289,
-0.002623057,
-0.0005005985,
0.005667754,
0.0208283123,
-0.0377612747,
-0.0400967486,
-0.0465981364,
-0.0810715333,
0.0195423719,
-0.0270828251,
0.0217031129,
-0.0470388085,
-0.0004566656,
-0.0007815054,
-0.0289696269,
0.0160544645,
0.0001724603,
0.0468796678,
0.0228239074,
-0.0016109428,
0.0336097255,
0.0002594547,
0.0163045917,
0.0350395814,
-0.0039358307,
0.0250555295,
-0.0115733892,
0.04643251,
0.0138224429,
0.0110199908,
0.0027484589,
0.0008629553,
0.0164165068,
-0.0251672287,
0.0005235877,
-0.0155541506,
-0.0498256981,
-0.0225074738,
-0.0003933059,
0.0139065338,
-0.0332032219,
0.0263056885,
-0.0069927932,
0.0103926854,
0.0216020606,
-0.0530706719,
0.0784712359,
0.0223416574,
-0.0347423926,
0.042925816,
-0.0095763458,
0.0477986522,
-0.0299109109,
0.0059620128,
0.0248212684,
0.0476115271,
-0.0034303465,
-0.047185801,
-0.0016651088,
0.0008363915,
-0.0017510544,
0.0157179032,
0.0041919276,
0.0247239005,
-0.071378693,
0.0494264588,
0.0012345244,
-0.0894970298,
-0.0348332785,
-0.0875449702,
0.0022550786,
0.0758153871,
0.0720531866,
-0.0138985701,
-0.0431415215,
0.0678761676,
0.0045217322,
-0.0310487952,
0.0165848099,
-0.0158865452,
-0.0001059725,
-0.0552065298,
-0.0518494658,
0.0089608114,
0.0063431216,
0.0642703846,
0.0534136519,
-0.0113249552,
0.0476921946,
0.01538218,
0.0009167977,
0.0159254596,
0.0268351026,
-0.0550831743,
0.0047001876,
0.0221311729,
0.0184612647,
-0.0050545866,
-0.0173352342,
0.0173250306,
0.0474638566,
-0.0078239739,
0.0111269215,
0.0014269016,
-0.0651762486,
-0.0088891285,
-0.0205134563,
0.0486468077,
0.0102625675,
0.0252762642,
0.0011098618,
-0.0357036069,
-0.0138607435,
-0.0417993069,
0.0104128337,
-0.0342897996,
0.0485279784,
0.0174573343,
-0.0221935362,
-0.0347427316,
0.0676003993,
-0.0288144015,
-0.0088043297,
0.0772985443,
0.0008893551,
0.0353854299,
-0.0638038218,
0.0033792569,
0.0055239461,
-0.0476884879,
-0.0109294252,
0.0639010146,
-0.0082278624,
-0.0230252314,
-0.0149091594,
-0.0655672476,
0.0116696609,
-0.0277480483,
0.0335928164,
-0.0156319141,
0.0398647003,
0.0122665791,
-0.0218750592,
0.0057575204,
0.0484588258,
0.0159655269,
0.0248326045,
-0.0247082431,
0.0219342951,
-0.0279659592,
-0.0167413447,
-0.0226276722,
0.008483029,
0.0068692002,
0.0060566054,
-0.0195741337,
-0.0500489436,
0.0262786914,
-0.0411287807,
0.0173328854,
0.0032803167,
-0.000950455,
0.0572696999,
-0.0388642736,
0.0078591742,
0.0553662628,
0.0024203488,
0.0254652835,
0.0181140359,
-0.0416503772,
-0.0869695693,
0.0481670797,
-0.0173159502,
-0.0540076047,
0.0324886404,
-0.0120707685,
0.0155569594,
0.035068281,
0.0134433676,
0.0027185746,
-0.0433308333,
-0.0192757826,
-0.0155677758,
-0.0195280667,
-0.0138567174,
-0.0346676931,
-0.0363784134,
0.0030412865,
-0.0437897556,
-0.0838142931,
0.0488022342,
-0.0336380824,
-0.0115279909,
-0.034981519,
0.0116330264,
0.0107798502,
0.0666704178,
0.0083695874,
0.0184318442,
-0.0270813145,
-0.0376534499,
-0.0479577668,
0.0126474611,
0.0114859054,
-0.0741910487,
-0.0030540749,
-0.0380858704,
0.0015388493,
-0.0191741455,
-0.036827676,
-0.0551820174,
0.0407076441,
0.0702688247,
0.0026939111,
0.0199104641,
-0.0434465781,
-0.0344780646,
-0.010321591,
0.0379659012,
0.0432567447,
-0.0108035514,
-0.0300607923,
-0.0267679896,
0.0133818351,
0.0428929515,
-0.0295596365,
-0.0534615256,
0.0110940263,
-0.0423803516,
0.0487999767,
0.0535111353,
-0.0332583375,
-0.0292480141,
-0.0024747627,
0.0564563982,
0.0052289888,
-0.026816383,
0.0852808654,
0.0401507095,
-0.0598753951,
-0.03278137,
0.0413820706,
0.0382735468,
-0.0142446449,
-0.0297081284,
-0.0027569763,
0.0243450403,
0.018394528,
0.0461625122,
-0.0564425178,
-0.0278110188,
0.0020814496,
0.0828015506,
-0.0094812643,
0.0219997391,
0.0019274382,
-0.0745793805,
0.0454582572,
0.0133334445,
-0.0055158772,
-0.0247035846,
-0.0096139377,
-0.022771081,
0.0553505234,
-0.0135985911,
0.0403729491,
-0.005094049,
0.0210522842,
0.0332344361,
0.0178923681,
-0.0127751715,
0.0217549894,
0.0077417637,
0.0037395658,
0.1076846495,
0.0147491004,
0.0620669313,
-0.08546336,
0.0149083724,
-0.0309817083,
0.0594248809,
-0.0252739191,
0.0277304873,
0.0162902642,
0.0254871566,
-0.0499188751,
-0.0119786495,
0.0268313345,
-0.0272596143,
-0.0370003767,
0.0471257269,
-0.0545713305,
0.0124147693,
-0.0654488951,
-0.0073637213,
0.0513015091,
-0.0009268602,
-0.0042882613,
0.0105198761,
-0.0396976806,
0.0213069059,
0.0367442705,
-0.1237469092,
-0.0054901936,
0.0075511485,
-0.0298832804,
-0.0299306624,
-0.0799363106,
-0.024676729,
-0.0418305881,
0.0673138723,
-0.0231579877,
0.0046103988,
-0.0287338607,
0.0121227074,
-0.0905789211,
0.0234168544,
0.0208256356,
-0.0059714247,
-0.0427752063,
-0.0700914264,
-0.0027220147,
-0.002558795,
-0.0118857082,
0.0533313528,
-0.0084440047,
-0.0533518158,
0.0046546073,
0.0526457205,
0.0272564292,
0.006956914,
0.0126809916,
-0.0170311183,
0.0349149033,
0.051406838,
-0.0062155463,
0.023387488,
0.0233286303,
-0.031454958,
-0.0421099141,
-0.0128697185,
-0.0887415782,
0.0478051268,
-0.0141471671,
0.0537357107,
-0.0025836984,
-0.0257918034,
0.0014244693,
0.0272486545,
0.0447288826,
-0.0108023025,
-0.017494332,
-0.0014154098,
0.0434366278,
0.0059387982,
-0.0058412431,
-0.026393069,
0.0410664566,
-0.0124025587,
-0.0135099096,
0.027699504,
-0.0145505136,
0.0147942463,
0.0638681874,
-0.0121941837,
-0.006136057,
-0.0189583711,
0.0147078857,
0.0023888033,
-0.0000474063,
-0.0234072693,
0.0360217281,
0.0131087238,
0.0545111187,
-0.0391255058,
0.0787547156,
-0.0046106675,
0.0458096415,
-0.0281365737,
0.0370630436,
-0.0287337508,
0.0067954478,
-0.0255004857,
-0.0214517973,
0.0271642506,
0.0063668964,
0.054169111,
-0.0013141871,
0.0117423702,
-0.0271349102,
0.030752033,
0.0164462999,
-0.0597842522,
-0.0371314101,
0.0360046625,
0.0141845308,
-0.0146618625,
0.0352250338,
-0.0927466899,
0.0152130239,
-0.0783973783,
-0.031790778,
-0.0278398842,
-0.0675189793,
0.0331128202,
-0.0029416326,
-0.0160690732,
-0.0284351986,
-0.028937567,
-0.0029237459,
-0.0091467313,
0.0316693448,
-0.0041275499,
-0.0152573958,
0.049416095,
0.0751630291,
0.0055546914,
-0.0721685812,
-0.0174307972,
-0.0121499468,
-0.0803689435,
0.0241573043,
-0.0360026471,
-6.260058431e-33,
-0.0614464656,
-0.0224920921,
0.0337608196,
-0.0524970703,
-0.0074522039,
0.0221424848,
-0.031672921,
-0.004245935,
0.0349929556,
-0.0580405779,
0.0041930424,
-0.007178952,
0.0263151266,
0.0057620988,
0.0131954225,
0.0345565267,
0.0470083877,
0.0127105769,
-0.0824288651,
0.0579796918,
0.1122478396,
0.0103189247,
0.006662902,
-0.0522187427,
-0.018947389,
0.0116502298,
0.038971711,
-0.0090869488,
-0.0277451165,
0.0774466023,
0.0234128814,
-0.0012224806,
0.0006607155,
-0.0240806453,
-0.0100942217,
0.0235551652,
-0.054953739,
-0.0359903015,
-0.0126819536,
0.0036083169,
-0.0513054915,
-0.027140867,
0.013249265,
-0.0105709042,
-0.0405934304,
0.0023816512,
0.0086951656,
0.020936789,
-0.028345447,
-0.0542424954,
-0.0689098909,
0.0021986973,
0.0199284106,
0.0020061254,
0.0028940239,
0.0658624172,
0.0240631606,
-0.050355617,
-0.060977485,
0.0157276597,
-0.0161222778,
0.0988826454,
0.0470902175,
0.0385490879,
0.0107670864,
0.0252477974,
0.0121655054,
-0.0018451968,
-0.0260060746,
0.0096788313,
0.0131973559,
0.0456472374,
-0.0222217962,
-0.004182016,
0.0912243053,
-0.0330551043,
-0.0019319346,
0.0723151714,
0.0228680633,
0.0721058846,
0.0280246921,
0.0226733591,
-0.0765447617,
0.0169532355,
0.0121971155,
0.0706867501,
-0.0379572995,
-0.0757223815,
0.0647300184,
0.0700723305,
-0.0389268063,
0.0049473126,
0.0754818693,
0.0406302735,
0.0290010776,
0.0178158339,
-0.0310417544,
0.0034115976,
-0.0394236222,
0.0089269103,
0.0023512982,
-0.0656660125,
0.0993226618,
-0.0255068,
0.0217593927,
-0.000258929,
0.001915097,
0.0593517348,
-0.0504749194,
0.0207048021,
-0.025707094,
0.0207234956,
-0.0181038696,
-0.0416886732,
0.0297008678,
0.0207177494,
-0.0168975722,
0.0346575826,
-0.0128706573,
-0.0224024002,
-0.0679206029,
-0.0592782423,
0.006484292,
-0.0013377637,
-0.0211522318,
0.0666496679,
-0.0246237051,
0.0459212139,
-0.0293857045,
-0.0156347211,
-0.0200448427,
0.0297991242,
2.878e-7,
0.0090539996,
-0.0120611973,
0.044672478,
0.0164323617,
-0.0278071407,
-0.009361024,
0.0254600123,
0.0064293095,
0.0181562044,
0.0408262163,
0.0033918014,
0.0082537206,
0.0300971419,
0.0095287515,
-0.0396055914,
-0.0412572287,
-0.0223143529,
0.0385520644,
-0.0383984335,
-0.0236302204,
0.089278236,
-0.0005395833,
-0.0465519018,
-0.0175668895,
0.0397002958,
-0.0509471968,
0.0278417822,
0.0259473566,
0.0351944081,
-0.018697964,
0.0466832295,
0.0146195199,
-0.0162117891,
-0.0330642983,
-0.0176443923,
-0.0011731425,
-0.0066871177,
0.0285053067,
-0.0156730283,
-0.0874798,
0.0171985868,
0.0046980311,
0.0000951118,
0.0348423645,
0.0429999456,
-0.0038547378,
0.0190695301,
0.0254610162,
-0.0264758989,
-0.0030919414,
-0.0385118239,
0.0265710652,
0.0215682611,
0.0114045842,
-0.0120706744,
0.0100890147,
-0.0319618732,
-0.090263851,
0.0030413654,
0.0143210022,
-0.0261122659,
-0.062263675,
-0.0644480437,
0.0489612408,
-0.0225818586,
-0.0496484227,
-0.014463908,
2.929389549e-34,
-0.0111218784,
-0.0065731113,
0.0180401821,
0.0152910892,
0.0348577425,
-0.0037844463,
-0.0261733569,
0.0501717068,
0.0198825877,
-0.0503280908,
-0.0479534417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12527v1 | FuseGen: PLM Fusion for Data-generation based Zero-shot Learning | 2024-06-18T11:55:05 | 2024-06-18T11:55:05 | Tianyuan Zou, Yang Liu, Peng Li, Jianqing Zhang, Jingjing Liu, Ya-Qin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data generation-based zero-shot learning, although effective in training
Small Task-specific Models (STMs) via synthetic datasets generated by
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), is often limited by the low quality of such
synthetic datasets. Previous solutions have primarily focused on single PLM
settings, where synthetic datasets are typically restricted to specific
sub-spaces and often deviate from real-world distributions, leading to severe
distribution bias. To mitigate such bias, we propose FuseGen, a novel data
generation-based zero-shot learning framework that introduces a new criteria
for subset selection from synthetic datasets via utilizing multiple PLMs and
trained STMs. The chosen subset provides in-context feedback to each PLM,
enhancing dataset quality through iterative data generation. Trained STMs are
then used for sample re-weighting as well, further improving data quality.
Extensive experiments across diverse tasks demonstrate that FuseGen
substantially outperforms existing methods, highly effective in boosting STM
performance in a PLM-agnostic way. Code is provided in
https://github.com/LindaLydia/FuseGen. | [
-0.0161037575,
0.0376470499,
0.0160682835,
0.0478710309,
-0.0067719594,
0.0017098306,
0.0430871621,
0.0090444284,
-0.0485747717,
-0.0459408611,
-0.0689668804,
-0.0317983292,
-0.002361991,
0.0068827877,
0.0661373511,
0.0051112343,
0.0198510811,
0.0224445481,
-0.0276647657,
0.0106593147,
-0.004924207,
0.0320319757,
-0.0157206822,
0.0268771276,
0.016865585,
-0.0035182794,
0.0108164186,
0.045712661,
0.0166467652,
-0.0322017111,
0.0015832217,
0.053834375,
0.0487579219,
0.0545501485,
0.0000019323,
-0.0299645029,
0.0040430008,
-0.0256179664,
-0.0473261513,
-0.0461561866,
0.0577130467,
-0.00978861,
-0.0149220498,
0.0142010339,
-0.0208200272,
-0.0669223592,
0.0445156358,
0.0108722905,
0.0188699104,
0.1033591107,
-0.0263720267,
-0.0063855373,
-0.0383330435,
-0.0380873494,
0.0466946699,
0.021899106,
0.0186737664,
-0.0207319204,
0.0080010239,
0.0086670257,
-0.0013061067,
-0.0148343788,
-0.0062161265,
-0.0147201614,
0.0220569875,
0.0530468374,
-0.0911436677,
-0.0428471789,
0.0188821517,
0.0944959968,
-0.060581319,
-0.046575468,
-0.0084419735,
-0.0304413103,
-0.035989549,
-0.0180641599,
-0.0739502236,
0.0299311336,
0.0205935054,
0.0761804581,
-0.0324114859,
-0.0088066757,
0.0275728181,
-0.004297772,
-0.0265593063,
0.0083394088,
0.0079510882,
-0.0008446384,
-0.0307698343,
0.0043080305,
-0.0042113764,
-0.0443342589,
-0.0488703996,
0.0248376355,
-0.0077210236,
0.0097498707,
-0.0829626098,
-0.0492674187,
0.0178175587,
-0.0142748365,
0.0964119807,
0.0353134573,
-0.0096205575,
0.03053982,
-0.0420976691,
0.0077138063,
0.0311515331,
0.0384407528,
-0.0507141575,
-0.0131619843,
-0.051655516,
0.0256425627,
0.0050221542,
0.0440349914,
-0.0255990736,
-0.0093860142,
-0.0294767823,
0.0219137799,
-0.0024734654,
0.0054220445,
0.021327395,
0.0030647716,
-0.0501735695,
-0.0003953808,
0.0320982412,
0.0537435897,
0.0073442124,
0.0483951233,
-0.0319305956,
-0.0603995658,
-0.0403721966,
0.0485725813,
0.0195517652,
-0.0237930194,
0.0198722482,
0.0468287058,
-0.0214434434,
-0.0468578823,
-0.0617725588,
-0.0089180609,
0.0088931993,
-0.0634097308,
0.0047393981,
-0.0683853105,
0.0264058355,
-0.016974099,
-0.0107979402,
-0.0185002126,
0.0081336098,
0.0200265106,
-0.0291192718,
0.0809844434,
-0.0411840864,
0.0111603383,
-0.0226960443,
-0.012326668,
0.0039343974,
0.1057747304,
0.0197720844,
0.0033623623,
0.0221802928,
0.0316191167,
0.0176330134,
0.0462073274,
0.0394288823,
0.0281807147,
-0.0394786634,
-0.0225235429,
0.0123845013,
-0.0050222334,
0.0503630377,
-0.023100337,
-0.0485286266,
0.0252295453,
0.0577327386,
0.0262651201,
0.0527931936,
-0.0214532502,
0.0556847304,
0.0085058641,
-0.0104396222,
-0.0154426862,
-0.0094185313,
-0.00263873,
-0.0295415446,
0.0033969528,
-0.0084087625,
0.0148817161,
-0.0620830357,
0.0024455772,
-0.0043294174,
-0.0256383717,
-0.0249521378,
0.0150152072,
0.085959807,
0.0276815183,
-0.0563243553,
0.042399209,
0.021498302,
-0.0644952655,
0.0167051498,
-0.0172205865,
0.0385656245,
0.0638964623,
0.04432166,
-0.0420181677,
-0.0403835922,
-0.0034226447,
0.0464575216,
0.0358566903,
-0.022475075,
-0.020612685,
0.0478828698,
-0.0646546632,
-0.0494564474,
-0.0273620654,
0.0078596799,
-0.0006133273,
-0.014285841,
0.0118628312,
0.0291275457,
-0.0220883545,
-0.0085293232,
0.0420561917,
-0.0425257087,
-0.0309511553,
0.0510784648,
-0.0212195516,
0.0007309449,
0.0073481952,
-0.0417241044,
0.0005859355,
0.0365461446,
-0.0417987593,
0.013129347,
0.0028590113,
-0.0212922469,
-0.0700994805,
0.0293240473,
-0.0173747204,
0.0257444009,
-0.0039686789,
-0.0831956193,
-0.0475669429,
0.0096619297,
0.0402208976,
0.0063041984,
-0.0615128204,
0.0200627055,
-0.0004380181,
0.0273815971,
-0.0319050215,
0.0311899129,
0.020996742,
-0.0048581054,
0.017012313,
0.0443681851,
0.0330647416,
-0.0389792398,
-0.0004061321,
-0.0073825703,
-0.0197902564,
0.0179768,
-0.0028201535,
0.028237354,
-0.0313271768,
0.0112310741,
-0.0854930803,
0.0285816323,
-0.0201840959,
0.0086916424,
0.0119116073,
-0.0090150442,
-0.0222079623,
-0.0219372585,
-0.0067850119,
-0.0005570376,
0.0175977554,
-0.0105594527,
0.0191806573,
-0.0182487685,
0.021710502,
-0.0341046378,
-0.0096346987,
-0.0007625797,
0.0586189441,
-0.0278999675,
-0.000792772,
-0.0193881895,
0.056616798,
-0.0167734921,
0.0303254351,
-0.0059166225,
-0.0044848034,
0.0054874094,
-0.0295668729,
-0.0032512171,
0.0171643533,
-0.0352446027,
-0.0185111146,
0.0310577787,
-0.012906841,
-0.0361847319,
-0.0099582076,
-0.0121654579,
0.003515563,
-0.013450196,
0.0140586877,
-0.0235740449,
0.0454291292,
-0.0170060247,
-0.0164016485,
-0.0468752086,
0.0373252816,
0.0154148508,
-0.0147717455,
-0.0059927823,
0.0200745352,
-0.0219488181,
0.0160361212,
-0.0622283034,
-0.0450983047,
0.0048308675,
-0.0573749244,
-0.0154194171,
-0.0328458659,
0.0035525546,
-0.021510249,
0.0146122864,
0.0111377891,
-0.011723835,
0.0394129753,
0.0090848347,
-0.0459213145,
-0.006577861,
0.0086631821,
-0.0066654063,
0.0425512418,
-0.0324969143,
0.0325238779,
-0.0487405285,
-0.0025724547,
-0.0506387055,
-0.0507080965,
-0.0059301741,
0.020641936,
-0.0654499158,
-0.001763302,
-0.0320903622,
-0.0248498581,
-0.0069295159,
0.0929986686,
-0.0151217235,
-0.0046984684,
-0.0276655778,
0.02616404,
0.0375426151,
-0.0142157348,
-0.0468265601,
-0.0092107523,
-0.0148483803,
0.0223391559,
0.0425030813,
0.0340929516,
-0.0348454714,
0.0141425654,
0.039881181,
0.0199673604,
-0.0104681626,
0.0048689791,
0.0299790632,
-0.0370023288,
0.0060380767,
0.1023682132,
0.0224322677,
-0.057852149,
-0.0157412868,
-0.004596475,
0.0279314592,
0.0369550176,
0.0238162763,
-0.1162232161,
-0.0504280515,
-0.008732371,
0.0128651364,
-0.0141965654,
-0.0170100722,
-0.0311554447,
-0.1497634053,
0.0436280221,
0.0276969541,
-0.0483031161,
0.0085209515,
-0.0449266434,
0.0120736696,
-0.0298232827,
0.0040316624,
0.0002043175,
-0.0121711213,
-0.006811202,
0.032376755,
0.0061326977,
-0.1296804249,
0.0108494805,
-0.0300523732,
0.0452585146,
0.0523298047,
0.0194473807,
0.0102295447,
-0.0022504006,
0.0071968166,
0.0112005938,
-0.0192283783,
-0.0291163344,
0.0658451021,
-0.027112674,
-0.0022716182,
0.0460883826,
0.0423261188,
-0.0431656912,
-0.0231569186,
-0.0212477539,
0.0595941804,
-0.020547308,
0.017894499,
-0.0240909532,
-0.031391371,
0.0329405181,
0.0624023415,
0.0403785557,
-0.0059448928,
-0.0121722529,
0.0027020203,
-0.0465567596,
-0.0851963088,
0.012563495,
0.0150407506,
-0.0306335445,
-0.0434953868,
-0.0312060285,
-0.0175664201,
0.0804355666,
0.0584229454,
-0.0144722164,
0.0097853448,
-0.0505810007,
-0.0101375254,
-0.0685663894,
0.0012118515,
-0.0561600439,
0.039258454,
-0.0303270463,
-0.0220057946,
0.0337504297,
-0.023045091,
0.0061633247,
0.0091522047,
-0.0881487727,
-0.0579408668,
-0.0337840989,
0.0743826851,
0.0146051813,
0.0337094329,
0.000005366,
-0.0389145203,
0.0955204815,
0.0622485019,
-0.0138450852,
0.0046028462,
0.0605717935,
-0.0594285876,
0.0080796052,
0.0334266722,
-0.0322673805,
0.0431945473,
0.0515363589,
0.0121649969,
-0.0211872756,
0.0206861924,
-0.0192616954,
-0.0245493352,
0.062732242,
-0.0246324316,
0.0081106592,
-0.0379442573,
0.0095095057,
-0.0403064303,
0.0084022852,
-0.0656095371,
-0.009729214,
0.0146872886,
-0.023741208,
0.0071908631,
0.0140382694,
-0.0917374119,
0.0691573918,
-0.0490265302,
0.0216767956,
0.024477914,
0.0088849114,
0.024880033,
0.0077601899,
0.0023774246,
0.0093982127,
0.002183022,
-0.0056004515,
-0.0183263049,
0.0219353363,
0.0175960958,
0.044190567,
-0.048850432,
0.0352376141,
-0.0213173144,
0.0064551756,
-0.0551576726,
0.0180892423,
0.0871434659,
-0.0279686842,
0.0587157719,
0.0130254002,
-0.0092945276,
-0.0335249789,
0.042978406,
-0.0261970107,
-0.0247591846,
0.0064476454,
0.0089275464,
-0.0209027827,
0.0116937077,
0.1322923899,
0.0256009586,
0.0287347604,
-0.0206739567,
0.0243874118,
-0.0329522155,
0.0080004716,
0.0463424213,
0.0166300759,
-0.0029940871,
0.0033573604,
-0.0437474772,
-0.0678370893,
0.0203589648,
-0.0304537546,
-0.0126230381,
0.0222504959,
0.036103107,
0.0318884328,
-0.0147453761,
0.0435547456,
-0.0282858405,
-0.0280696079,
0.0304397885,
-0.0198695008,
-0.0024139341,
-6.076354011e-33,
-0.0187904108,
-0.01199813,
0.0247622579,
-0.0148862284,
-0.0189778339,
0.0226333048,
-0.0474678092,
-0.0038546163,
0.0001315524,
-0.0205289926,
-0.0264807995,
-0.0083229141,
0.0270595923,
0.0437681824,
-0.0027774489,
0.0086106481,
0.061950691,
-0.027513789,
-0.0155703044,
0.0166643653,
0.0384072363,
0.0502137206,
0.068911925,
0.0057072593,
-0.0080140214,
-0.0089503964,
-0.0053495965,
0.0193465315,
0.0451978296,
0.0577075891,
0.0214300379,
0.0603898913,
0.0272236001,
-0.0495318063,
-0.0523731038,
0.0019545243,
-0.0366139896,
-0.047735963,
0.0082882382,
0.0008371585,
-0.0167361964,
-0.0037608468,
0.029848747,
-0.0115625663,
0.007455653,
-0.0215126183,
0.0323817283,
-0.0357458293,
-0.0321345627,
-0.0106202578,
-0.0569788665,
0.0128699737,
0.0260095578,
-0.0360637456,
0.0521013401,
0.0343819857,
0.0031710125,
0.0351521187,
-0.0568243749,
0.0208968557,
0.0030111268,
0.046203807,
0.0682378411,
0.0742474422,
0.0323244743,
0.0546799302,
0.0092044063,
0.0071320152,
-0.0343126431,
-0.0050562322,
0.0638555139,
0.039475631,
0.0112184472,
0.0761361718,
0.046424862,
0.0184162464,
-0.0806871355,
0.0411584899,
0.0231139455,
0.0049707745,
0.0054157483,
0.0268685259,
0.0418573543,
-0.0287467279,
-0.0161502063,
-0.0425096713,
-0.0322608054,
-0.0185683388,
0.013110159,
0.0332180336,
-0.0247356687,
0.0134253372,
0.0796089768,
-0.0441979468,
-0.0202626232,
0.0333580635,
-0.0335419774,
0.0084631676,
0.0212204121,
-0.0242448971,
-0.0715928078,
-0.0447356552,
0.0637214035,
0.0251191873,
0.0132666053,
0.0135908015,
0.0628080294,
0.041858241,
-0.0087516718,
-0.0100172888,
-0.0342288651,
0.0034600559,
0.0091448557,
0.1004184633,
0.0041878335,
0.0271817613,
-0.0108315684,
0.038836617,
0.0041624228,
-0.0392979831,
0.0152429258,
0.0192851052,
-0.0027360655,
0.024195224,
-0.0286230873,
0.00912508,
-0.0415582135,
-0.000357264,
0.0536052473,
-0.0459088497,
-0.0142720407,
-0.00370637,
2.547e-7,
0.029752763,
-0.0031167183,
-0.0157207083,
-0.0019841781,
-0.0002880605,
0.0275355875,
-0.0354965329,
0.034821488,
-0.0092138229,
-0.0040113861,
0.0179421213,
0.0285777487,
0.0548074432,
0.0126985144,
-0.0975466892,
0.0360950045,
-0.0318307579,
0.0321664661,
-0.0435821414,
-0.0179264974,
0.0215094518,
0.1000885293,
0.0316384993,
-0.0341418535,
0.0443185829,
0.0050645019,
0.0597184077,
0.0033888002,
-0.0003709141,
0.0224474426,
-0.0015355129,
0.0287058558,
-0.024025932,
0.0179337524,
-0.0466588847,
0.0071586324,
-0.0143878134,
0.0385130569,
-0.0411968753,
-0.0526984297,
0.0073118149,
-0.0003471238,
-0.008347244,
-0.0358200073,
0.0805502012,
-0.0720489472,
-0.0190374535,
-0.0155507466,
-0.024321625,
0.0317989103,
0.0169568677,
-0.02535519,
-0.0338259116,
0.0168022271,
0.0540734567,
-0.0094008958,
-0.0636809692,
-0.0639319718,
-0.0259731784,
-0.0085868025,
-0.0416595303,
-0.0139785334,
-0.0000376578,
-0.0538541041,
0.0103067122,
-0.044885993,
0.0158795081,
2.575346033e-34,
0.0122103021,
-0.0064896941,
0.006073168,
-0.0142679289,
-0.030546993,
-0.0079966215,
-0.0441641584,
0.0078870477,
-0.0053745736,
-0.0399110168,
-0.0139329601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12502v1 | Code-Optimise: Self-Generated Preference Data for Correctness and Efficiency | 2024-06-18T11:05:37 | 2024-06-18T11:05:37 | Leonidas Gee, Milan Gritta, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code Language Models have been trained to generate accurate solutions,
typically with no regard for runtime. On the other hand, previous works that
explored execution optimisation have observed corresponding drops in functional
correctness. To that end, we introduce Code-Optimise, a framework that
incorporates both correctness (passed, failed) and runtime (quick, slow) as
learning signals via self-generated preference data. Our framework is both
lightweight and robust as it dynamically selects solutions to reduce
overfitting while avoiding a reliance on larger models for learning signals.
Code-Optimise achieves significant improvements in pass@k while decreasing the
competitive baseline runtimes by an additional 6% for in-domain data and up to
3% for out-of-domain data. As a byproduct, the average length of the generated
solutions is reduced by up to 48% on MBPP and 23% on HumanEval, resulting in
faster and cheaper inference. The generated data and codebase will be
open-sourced at www.open-source.link. | [
-0.0169261955,
0.0968105197,
-0.0141376574,
-0.0004381622,
-0.0312378854,
0.0060268501,
-0.0371943749,
0.0109874718,
0.0245266072,
-0.0164731964,
0.0133723924,
0.0486129411,
-0.0218011346,
0.0525024422,
0.0108226491,
-0.00813423,
0.0463032499,
-0.0347029269,
-0.0308374371,
-0.0068077259,
-0.0216761325,
0.0098486887,
-0.0049652602,
0.0190323107,
0.0027064129,
-0.0484787114,
0.0027426949,
0.0298943873,
-0.0256862193,
-0.0176196098,
0.0481465757,
0.0408370532,
-0.0163741354,
0.0032442394,
0.0000025112,
0.0032023003,
-0.0170489475,
0.0135080554,
-0.0088081947,
0.0730716437,
0.0342331827,
0.0155608421,
-0.001723991,
0.0437187329,
-0.0363526419,
-0.0054194368,
0.0484469496,
-0.0599935763,
0.0286871158,
0.0555807278,
0.0281827208,
0.0332453325,
-0.0142025305,
-0.0113795344,
-0.0138385985,
-0.0508008301,
-0.0089435382,
-0.0258068405,
0.0037314403,
-0.0210315399,
0.0067050126,
0.0108304415,
0.0100916624,
0.0062882164,
0.008538045,
0.0054078293,
-0.0156715065,
0.0036655478,
-0.0020015032,
0.0123936394,
-0.0986308977,
-0.0661544874,
0.0169565231,
-0.0495948941,
-0.0522104762,
-0.0415688232,
0.0183027554,
-0.0187078137,
-0.0427349322,
-0.0112835774,
0.0211609229,
0.0155820828,
0.0035926506,
0.0049306299,
-0.0267972089,
0.0934651196,
0.0046816226,
0.0179268885,
0.0025421029,
-0.0065951655,
-0.0149689848,
-0.0525476709,
-0.005477448,
0.0083129155,
0.0014913509,
0.0042757811,
-0.038090948,
-0.0007905485,
0.0215043798,
-0.0670082718,
0.0285033174,
0.044351209,
-0.0118593834,
-0.0309530459,
-0.0660427585,
0.0310241058,
-0.020157041,
-0.0290242974,
-0.0112883076,
0.0458928533,
0.0049117892,
0.0277263392,
-0.0190930124,
0.0456955731,
-0.0190831739,
0.0487881489,
-0.0555309728,
0.0396532565,
-0.0046124556,
0.0386894196,
-0.0256670918,
0.0119945556,
-0.0260662735,
0.0281971227,
-0.0031804149,
0.0002502929,
-0.0469188653,
-0.0451087169,
-0.0378458053,
-0.0503263026,
0.0180236455,
-0.0049049039,
-0.0447469689,
-0.0345313773,
0.0425499082,
0.0628942475,
0.0142100463,
0.0169335175,
-0.0406047702,
-0.0321010351,
0.012329556,
-0.0142838815,
0.0016899658,
-0.1082436293,
-0.0461673476,
0.0069809752,
-0.0090169003,
-0.0597116277,
-0.0126462663,
0.0045676487,
0.0112040229,
0.0506782793,
-0.0158731025,
-0.0022087088,
-0.0177346319,
0.0026853159,
0.0051384941,
0.0977640599,
0.0142561449,
0.0200058036,
0.0145985251,
-0.0619143695,
-0.00183282,
0.0211939923,
0.0334546082,
-0.0153443487,
0.0023079861,
0.0362633318,
0.0424860716,
-0.0235484634,
0.0343664289,
-0.0084681846,
-0.0029320179,
-0.0311166849,
-0.0383941345,
0.0012535575,
0.0414660983,
0.0033101987,
0.0511206351,
0.0388356857,
-0.0097507341,
-0.0234652963,
-0.0594717748,
0.0451167598,
-0.00608795,
0.0133428434,
-0.0264481883,
0.0482257903,
0.0024096631,
-0.0599799193,
-0.0037985048,
-0.0132608516,
-0.020906793,
0.0337009616,
0.0360607319,
0.0104500521,
-0.0588763952,
-0.0112241078,
0.0413832478,
-0.0177152324,
-0.0796535611,
-0.0532220379,
0.0172428656,
0.0252640303,
0.0210499,
-0.0494731665,
-0.0172179267,
0.018074939,
-0.007492627,
-0.0431866907,
0.0517164804,
-0.0325198844,
0.0354330465,
-0.0354561806,
-0.0119074294,
0.0071699894,
0.0154937906,
0.088497147,
0.0419089571,
-0.0283871852,
0.0361633487,
-0.0137238633,
-0.0424344093,
0.0169502441,
0.0078604277,
-0.0228384864,
0.0667849332,
0.0163650233,
0.0428900644,
-0.0554952398,
-0.0155000482,
0.0068391622,
0.0380219631,
0.0126077319,
0.0070223762,
-0.0414919965,
-0.0646144673,
-0.0248987805,
0.0169301834,
-0.0360717475,
-0.0196827706,
0.0483171865,
-0.0547105335,
-0.0004932889,
0.0610042736,
-0.0237980802,
0.035678234,
0.0247144923,
0.0062857871,
-0.0087607084,
-0.0290786475,
-0.0270948876,
0.0469981804,
0.0423674136,
0.0236473773,
-0.0129922135,
0.0654817,
0.0262842514,
0.0347744487,
0.0107309511,
0.0054454603,
-0.0424610078,
0.0330957398,
0.0142940721,
0.0101770721,
0.0027686225,
0.0043593915,
-0.0730548427,
0.0294041876,
-0.000857636,
0.0188803449,
0.0000010145,
0.0182802975,
0.0196958464,
-0.0326984189,
-0.0014999107,
0.0081637716,
-0.0090754442,
0.0160359256,
0.0065292255,
-0.0182683449,
-0.041368477,
-0.0357233882,
-0.0255150832,
-0.0589425452,
0.0125288554,
-0.0583012253,
0.029957708,
-0.0424631611,
0.0765099972,
-0.007102665,
0.0433467478,
-0.0413624533,
-0.0500830188,
-0.0005737094,
-0.0412057675,
0.0090105105,
0.0742797405,
0.0024977692,
-0.037110433,
0.0282400455,
0.0146415271,
-0.1193374693,
0.0264694579,
0.0115415305,
-0.0306167509,
0.0181851368,
-0.0034534435,
0.024754459,
0.085675925,
-0.0009416557,
-0.0454805791,
-0.0539443679,
-0.012079834,
0.0408937335,
-0.0038351931,
0.0220808554,
-0.0027180533,
0.0063926466,
0.0566392727,
-0.0072764074,
-0.0888848752,
0.0848640949,
-0.0086817425,
-0.0002825837,
-0.049808383,
-0.0316442661,
-0.0301452782,
-0.0012949463,
0.0164783821,
-0.0024165437,
-0.0045447475,
-0.0133505454,
-0.0155199952,
-0.0203854423,
0.0153671736,
-0.0615982935,
0.0650896132,
-0.0136619145,
0.0011410058,
0.0048006978,
-0.0517767929,
-0.0611938275,
-0.0139641101,
-0.0061129914,
-0.0277069397,
0.0075131464,
0.0043026153,
0.0490198098,
0.0073180459,
-0.042907387,
0.0621375479,
0.0222928412,
-0.0352584384,
-0.0059891581,
-0.0669562519,
-0.0179830659,
-0.0787911639,
-0.009274127,
0.0173172001,
-0.0115140239,
0.0317895971,
0.084982954,
0.0452370234,
-0.0817396045,
0.0169546176,
0.0378289223,
-0.0292762928,
-0.0434733778,
0.0755752996,
0.0316092484,
-0.066112712,
-0.038801685,
0.0481524393,
0.0431821384,
-0.0359416157,
0.0096659362,
0.0047754482,
0.0732768551,
0.0718529373,
0.0671595931,
-0.0678541064,
-0.0284850001,
0.0033121512,
0.0875117108,
-0.0223593023,
-0.0153712053,
0.008108696,
-0.1194795966,
0.0018624656,
0.0183673892,
-0.0123054022,
-0.0304755811,
-0.0584715866,
-0.0209717248,
-0.0238391664,
-0.0555749163,
0.0383567661,
-0.0026341914,
0.0218473561,
0.0231277067,
-0.0280043799,
0.0214869846,
0.0603982359,
-0.0262697469,
0.0273778122,
0.1027509719,
-0.0115852691,
0.0242650248,
0.0001663887,
0.0137955574,
-0.0419696942,
-0.0018036732,
-0.0471494123,
0.0370698906,
-0.0059329206,
-0.0050485171,
0.0400858372,
0.0199665017,
-0.0352100506,
0.0029722059,
0.0554852225,
0.0596582741,
-0.0028514715,
-0.01746279,
-0.0394191965,
0.0044340622,
0.0122120595,
-0.0047090962,
0.0036819887,
-0.026219992,
-0.0369837619,
-0.0916049182,
-0.0143386526,
-0.0873347744,
-0.0173452757,
-0.0271458942,
-0.0208964311,
-0.0189116914,
-0.0165043101,
0.0258869212,
0.0359087139,
0.0729813054,
0.0078504141,
-0.0428704023,
-0.0099885762,
-0.031060392,
-0.1004284248,
0.0064872582,
-0.0169150475,
0.0217437521,
-0.0487895682,
-0.0142000932,
0.0356310159,
-0.0066649588,
-0.009841756,
0.0181545261,
-0.073782295,
-0.0520153642,
-0.0104803573,
0.1250636578,
0.0211532731,
0.0477526896,
-0.055257041,
-0.0021477384,
0.0040296186,
0.0344163179,
-0.0469798744,
-0.0196468439,
0.0481347963,
-0.0275499858,
0.0134118004,
-0.0229988117,
-0.0458300523,
0.0178304091,
0.0312899984,
-0.0163429324,
0.0007927563,
-0.0012806115,
0.0235305559,
0.0019735289,
0.0220280904,
0.0243797358,
-0.0718601122,
0.0215527713,
0.0039084204,
0.0313957334,
-0.0298592187,
-0.0361593105,
0.0618297532,
-0.0137232943,
0.0046943012,
0.0125570288,
-0.0387210436,
-0.0198226552,
0.0164002087,
0.00023522,
0.0268912632,
0.046594318,
0.0530373268,
0.0948617607,
0.0059343684,
-0.0114779603,
0.0181780439,
0.0440507717,
0.0668120384,
-0.0256223381,
0.0244737342,
0.0140750399,
0.0724213347,
0.0014091079,
-0.0331754088,
-0.0259153955,
-0.0529383384,
-0.0445822291,
-0.0278013032,
0.0122774802,
-0.0074048005,
0.0196320675,
-0.0346599557,
0.018303832,
-0.0338059887,
0.051572945,
-0.0434296392,
-0.0053390041,
0.0142795099,
0.0348951966,
-0.0114822993,
-0.0458286852,
0.075748913,
0.0123672932,
0.0358998291,
-0.0310305674,
-0.0038536803,
-0.0423771068,
-0.0009914758,
0.0363586098,
0.0282937717,
-0.0107401665,
-0.0348880887,
-0.0106149213,
-0.0649321452,
-0.0039197588,
0.0234317072,
0.0430226885,
-0.008431471,
0.0420890525,
0.0838390216,
0.030870216,
-0.003687442,
-0.0453058779,
0.017182773,
0.0304268431,
-0.0418897532,
-0.0262369346,
-6.217244723e-33,
-0.0248861816,
-0.011319587,
-0.01677089,
-0.0080369338,
0.0245294552,
-0.016041385,
-0.0065558478,
-0.0044233766,
0.0124516366,
-0.0417878442,
0.0146220215,
0.0168723464,
0.0055765482,
-0.0323029235,
0.0556295104,
0.0313104503,
0.0171108507,
-0.0070629632,
-0.0675013289,
0.0109075019,
-0.0202403795,
0.024025226,
-0.0000332169,
-0.0391290784,
-0.0542596094,
0.0369221196,
0.0463136472,
-0.0193302464,
-0.0283232555,
0.0555626489,
0.0310258195,
-0.0077393018,
-0.0331808291,
-0.0154877407,
-0.0343058929,
-0.0515343398,
-0.0314147584,
-0.0261761509,
0.0304474849,
0.0326514691,
0.0133424224,
-0.0551750474,
0.0589136556,
0.0145224622,
-0.0189063195,
0.0041723484,
0.0057127834,
0.0163443517,
-0.0132693956,
-0.0238133054,
-0.0442137718,
0.0318242908,
-0.032605622,
-0.0095349569,
0.0085660387,
0.0364601947,
-0.0135004548,
0.023614293,
0.0227692109,
0.021205252,
0.012952243,
0.0597489811,
0.0552013516,
0.0076974127,
0.0142987054,
-0.0231418405,
0.0694936663,
0.0108579025,
0.0070566535,
0.0092023397,
0.0599010848,
0.0476440862,
0.0385842882,
0.0140218576,
0.0604892224,
-0.0438977443,
-0.0350972973,
0.0318437852,
0.0346910805,
-0.0215246677,
-0.0003712766,
0.0077927746,
-0.0536047518,
-0.0141820265,
-0.0335783735,
-0.0164114553,
-0.0388015397,
-0.0522761196,
0.035712216,
0.0024254445,
-0.0582638718,
0.0158119053,
0.035772562,
-0.0186499078,
-0.0025449498,
-0.0004808576,
-0.0414869152,
0.0156973936,
-0.0040297755,
0.047437571,
-0.0144904191,
-0.0181946885,
-0.0044143628,
-0.0427387059,
0.0845239833,
-0.0118759181,
-0.0083940625,
0.0160915479,
-0.0817596987,
-0.0011029262,
-0.0613663048,
-0.0182947833,
0.0068217297,
0.0248508453,
0.0304120556,
0.0134808552,
0.0267253052,
0.044252295,
-0.0230496991,
-0.0412452966,
-0.0803414956,
-0.0086455327,
0.0414991155,
0.0446531065,
-0.016858831,
-0.0495087169,
-0.0298667476,
0.0073972037,
-0.0216377527,
-0.0129461195,
-0.0374620818,
0.0517566763,
3.136e-7,
0.0110283429,
0.0125256414,
0.0068613752,
0.0651720688,
-0.0228201002,
0.0483296439,
0.0027422432,
-0.0083200438,
0.0418614671,
0.027276,
-0.0259146802,
-0.0075677908,
0.0487689413,
0.0385530628,
-0.0118493512,
-0.0019932494,
0.0490259118,
0.0221676156,
-0.0366117246,
-0.0376816466,
-0.0380906984,
0.0635547638,
0.0074399109,
0.003630548,
0.0492447875,
0.043224182,
-0.0109585142,
0.0016990576,
0.013224218,
0.0189269874,
-0.0909708589,
-0.0027051969,
-0.0144733666,
0.0053439778,
-0.0118444925,
-0.0130272722,
-0.0051352112,
0.0793281347,
0.0225376301,
-0.010167663,
0.0378653966,
-0.0259935837,
0.0189811327,
-0.0424155369,
0.0694359541,
0.0006946373,
0.0040812804,
-0.0290952809,
-0.0130119007,
-0.0297975969,
-0.0130520165,
-0.0025885305,
0.0198773649,
0.0170658417,
0.014095027,
-0.0099124545,
-0.0436365046,
-0.0249836836,
-0.0487525165,
0.0356003195,
-0.0239688288,
-0.0338173397,
-0.0624685287,
0.0714728311,
0.0259146765,
-0.0173705909,
0.0151230777,
3.209527302e-34,
0.0407027155,
-0.0329474658,
0.0120486738,
0.0400471091,
0.0385779664,
-0.0158437863,
-0.0105468724,
0.0152367568,
0.0499329008,
0.0200171992,
-0.0518484339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12494v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12494v1 | LightPAL: Lightweight Passage Retrieval for Open Domain Multi-Document Summarization | 2024-06-18T10:57:27 | 2024-06-18T10:57:27 | Masafumi Enomoto, Kunihiro Takeoka, Kosuke Akimoto, Kiril Gashteovski, Masafumi Oyamada | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-Domain Multi-Document Summarization (ODMDS) is crucial for addressing
diverse information needs, which aims to generate a summary as answer to user's
query, synthesizing relevant content from multiple documents in a large
collection. Existing approaches that first find relevant passages and then
generate a summary using a language model are inadequate for ODMDS. This is
because open-ended queries often require additional context for the retrieved
passages to cover the topic comprehensively, making it challenging to retrieve
all relevant passages initially. While iterative retrieval methods have been
explored for multi-hop question answering (MQA), they are impractical for ODMDS
due to high latency from repeated large language model (LLM) inference for
reasoning. To address this issue, we propose LightPAL, a lightweight passage
retrieval method for ODMDS that constructs a graph representing passage
relationships using an LLM during indexing and employs random walk instead of
iterative reasoning and retrieval at inference time. Experiments on ODMDS
benchmarks show that LightPAL outperforms baseline retrievers in summary
quality while being significantly more efficient than an iterative MQA
approach. | [
0.016698448,
0.004900441,
0.0205167942,
-0.0005651208,
-0.0461525023,
-0.0057350541,
-0.0286537781,
-0.0081517845,
0.0378689095,
-0.0289599542,
0.0269880705,
-0.0147402147,
-0.0104245525,
-0.0096646287,
-0.0258550923,
-0.0621788055,
0.0313434936,
-0.0270877611,
-0.0020864091,
-0.0241951216,
0.0090709999,
0.0216859337,
0.0073195547,
0.0128555121,
0.0237916131,
-0.0313741043,
-0.0314194486,
-0.0006602545,
0.0249269009,
-0.0412513912,
0.002334211,
-0.0029339227,
0.034947902,
-0.0240780395,
0.0000018011,
-0.0613910481,
-0.0703962445,
0.0115067335,
0.0195605867,
0.0011256938,
0.032118991,
0.0245532319,
0.0696211159,
0.0335791335,
0.0014101827,
0.0128257852,
-0.0061492706,
0.0773896202,
0.053823635,
0.0373539403,
0.000491938,
-0.0516174622,
-0.015083639,
0.0129774772,
0.0013306125,
-0.076903291,
0.0041604615,
0.0571990125,
0.0465990417,
0.0054476946,
-0.0006176893,
0.016314853,
-0.016757708,
0.0156389829,
-0.0201828387,
0.0191660188,
0.0006612825,
0.0169590618,
0.0187022742,
0.1056256369,
0.0334080867,
0.0144727984,
0.021597812,
0.0303465296,
-0.0009191927,
0.0506313629,
-0.1047504544,
0.0491852239,
-0.0506505743,
0.006736639,
-0.0262592193,
0.0125832139,
0.0089092106,
0.0333351716,
-0.030279329,
0.0511913411,
0.0312749594,
0.0061279293,
-0.0150128389,
-0.0084966095,
-0.0028122335,
-0.0361113995,
0.0247586239,
0.0965774804,
-0.0128316656,
0.0115700187,
-0.0186990723,
-0.0284974612,
0.0450043194,
-0.0329031274,
0.0156544056,
0.0153109636,
0.0119798146,
0.0658992305,
-0.0396166071,
-0.0138476091,
-0.0205414966,
-0.0101520093,
-0.0695247203,
-0.0494843349,
-0.0059043313,
0.001549114,
-0.0466437973,
0.0885111243,
-0.0551826991,
-0.0356401056,
-0.008208896,
0.0510074757,
0.0523371287,
-0.0445847996,
-0.0135562392,
0.0284147747,
0.0125888065,
-0.0030159636,
-0.0227942895,
0.0595031418,
-0.0506608635,
-0.0212254822,
0.0174473412,
0.0171956588,
-0.0185774937,
0.0161296222,
0.0425883904,
0.0139278984,
0.0116549218,
0.0697942823,
-0.0144732194,
-0.0335099399,
-0.0394353308,
-0.0461725928,
-0.0011069988,
-0.0453022942,
0.0086376807,
-0.0856443048,
0.0132009741,
0.0409012698,
-0.0251501594,
-0.0000178654,
0.0298794284,
0.0483308844,
-0.0568623729,
0.0086350637,
-0.0170726087,
-0.0081545198,
0.0257035568,
0.0265379325,
0.02247959,
0.0735678971,
0.0130750798,
0.0290063545,
0.0705002025,
0.0551624335,
-0.0153843304,
-0.0013259363,
-0.0021365017,
0.0181117468,
0.0569460541,
0.0137749035,
-0.00357439,
-0.0109776165,
0.0142179197,
0.050862629,
-0.0484523438,
0.0189663172,
0.0092465263,
0.0725370124,
0.0354021676,
-0.0113457283,
-0.010055135,
0.035655167,
0.0356745422,
0.0327621512,
0.0172567461,
0.055474665,
-0.0259125214,
0.0462636016,
0.0887515396,
0.041936934,
-0.0178816281,
-0.0179035608,
-0.0138420127,
0.0102158906,
0.0085646426,
0.0258838031,
0.0384869799,
0.0003782992,
-0.0408475325,
0.0877302811,
0.0388444252,
-0.0460930206,
-0.0055278353,
-0.016749382,
0.0043122005,
0.0224210341,
0.0561082475,
-0.0318395197,
-0.0149701973,
-0.008264347,
0.0101505546,
0.0115977945,
0.0362748951,
-0.0195734799,
-0.0182357021,
-0.0595254339,
-0.0358932652,
-0.0152494311,
-0.0166061167,
0.0176697671,
0.0238285884,
-0.0127457017,
0.048772864,
-0.0634912103,
-0.0214882698,
0.0135644013,
-0.0167728309,
-0.0047235889,
0.0004628726,
-0.0247912724,
-0.0133044049,
0.052416306,
0.0018967399,
0.0353099331,
0.0424056947,
-0.0265721586,
-0.0507133454,
-0.0038298282,
-0.0287369806,
-0.0067259911,
0.0507096797,
-0.0400632583,
0.0060369172,
0.0156212701,
-0.0022224751,
-0.062986061,
0.0098091895,
-0.0589968562,
0.0107517261,
-0.0257518403,
-0.0251903832,
0.029158188,
-0.0100461114,
-0.0543621294,
0.082496278,
0.0217357613,
0.0494303815,
0.0449225307,
0.0296320822,
0.0203785934,
-0.0109729348,
0.0056093596,
0.0072611482,
-0.0067007504,
0.0138376057,
0.0458067693,
0.0078791091,
-0.0383679718,
0.0038815222,
-0.1059733406,
0.0001654514,
-0.0038642827,
0.0164248906,
0.0328886174,
0.0413450859,
0.0000736534,
-0.0273907278,
-0.0355066955,
-0.0003920831,
0.0315361507,
0.0241042227,
0.017279502,
0.0118270507,
0.0094711492,
-0.0204023998,
-0.0062556043,
-0.0152568482,
0.0602251515,
0.0048586908,
-0.0197162647,
-0.0231610835,
-0.0085582789,
-0.0591045059,
-0.0032296672,
0.0016780824,
0.0333997235,
0.0045497254,
-0.0485670455,
0.0613847002,
0.0164977778,
0.0257002879,
-0.0279749706,
0.0443948284,
-0.0338413008,
-0.0422370248,
0.0172863752,
-0.0339884087,
0.0213334523,
0.0195646286,
-0.0191336162,
0.0101550845,
0.0167527199,
0.0075213541,
-0.0165819656,
0.0055067707,
-0.0282424968,
0.0002056854,
0.0507124476,
-0.0600853153,
0.003237565,
-0.0163835846,
0.0262730513,
-0.0084443474,
0.0015086945,
0.0436217412,
-0.0121451477,
0.0253186543,
-0.0739265457,
0.0038933081,
-0.0892984569,
0.0875128806,
-0.0405619107,
0.0513462201,
-0.0302096326,
-0.0327834785,
-0.0219552927,
-0.0200298857,
0.0340525396,
-0.0606628507,
0.075815618,
-0.0382272117,
0.0191795882,
-0.0279203597,
-0.0211566966,
-0.0095307566,
-0.0142356157,
-0.028132502,
0.022705337,
-0.0125469984,
-0.0063107084,
-0.0235721264,
0.0111823054,
0.0344383717,
0.0255754031,
-0.0588337705,
-0.0138485618,
0.0040325546,
0.0711555034,
0.0883922726,
0.0014446673,
0.0412493907,
-0.0528504774,
0.0331543349,
0.0753649548,
0.0273177959,
-0.030500276,
0.0458918363,
-0.0240815878,
0.0071158279,
-0.0677814335,
0.009116808,
-0.0072603412,
0.0509100854,
-0.0427866317,
-0.0208546948,
0.082175687,
0.0280621797,
-0.0571860969,
-0.0348793156,
-0.0374051258,
0.0147695774,
0.0204583853,
0.029110318,
-0.0871489272,
-0.034679696,
0.0044796038,
0.0509761013,
0.0331291817,
-0.0463206246,
-0.0091215754,
-0.0624438003,
-0.008971015,
-0.0037909367,
-0.0653265044,
-0.0312974229,
-0.0751739517,
-0.0014890305,
0.0373439007,
-0.0142218964,
0.0572117642,
-0.0330635458,
-0.009130206,
-0.0064898957,
-0.0101867234,
0.0527845919,
0.0117906621,
-0.0257209297,
-0.0418705307,
0.0243844371,
0.0268203784,
0.0034031798,
0.0194921512,
0.0510703996,
-0.0586905442,
-0.0101860287,
-0.0000328781,
0.0164781939,
-0.0047407402,
0.0144172776,
-0.0627666488,
0.0253451429,
-0.016892653,
-0.0137105864,
-0.0080469009,
0.0418601222,
0.0123432223,
-0.0023878394,
-0.0559227653,
0.0394809805,
-0.0464756489,
0.0666642264,
-0.003475483,
-0.0026796402,
-0.0686696842,
-0.0369092561,
-0.0141002322,
-0.0440893583,
-0.0232630093,
0.0216610879,
-0.0346785448,
0.0285137836,
-0.0558164716,
-0.040251106,
0.0239045545,
0.032870423,
-0.0318278633,
0.0241171103,
-0.0025834476,
0.0171098504,
-0.0487958118,
0.0048427978,
-0.0257447883,
-0.0101414379,
-0.0145562803,
0.0240921844,
0.0642364845,
-0.0406274386,
-0.0107262069,
0.0264370162,
-0.0835102126,
-0.0447088517,
-0.0113673583,
-0.0035176806,
0.0140386261,
0.0308532212,
-0.0032221647,
0.0176694542,
0.0667092055,
0.0004884438,
-0.0038515627,
0.0075130933,
-0.010621489,
0.0500317439,
-0.0242861211,
0.0081495922,
-0.1188085079,
0.0204737019,
-0.0620547049,
0.08081799,
-0.0112751983,
-0.1068145409,
0.022171,
0.0539901815,
-0.0154777076,
0.0294019394,
0.0028803195,
-0.0073803677,
-0.0044458462,
-0.020169666,
-0.044153966,
-0.0009630554,
0.0540432073,
-0.0248160344,
-0.046487201,
0.0235135462,
0.0494133905,
0.0250910148,
0.0450021848,
-0.0390493013,
-0.0107306056,
-0.0286852084,
-0.0430401266,
-0.0364136361,
-0.029892588,
-0.0383300334,
-0.0418190062,
-0.0429407991,
0.0298626292,
-0.0048912605,
0.0336942486,
0.0218236074,
-0.0166633856,
-0.0408888459,
0.0051370035,
-0.1243724078,
-0.0098214,
-0.0248991698,
0.0040847836,
0.046264302,
0.0039999126,
0.0531254672,
-0.0043158964,
-0.0205202196,
-0.007249142,
0.0173037313,
0.0156783424,
0.016134534,
0.0002930053,
0.0355654508,
0.0088404128,
0.0317272469,
0.075429365,
-0.04964789,
0.0120347282,
0.0106287478,
-0.0412460417,
-0.0265128296,
-0.0477769934,
-0.03226972,
0.041450154,
-0.004457219,
-0.0500987768,
-0.0406244509,
-0.0149777578,
0.028757086,
0.0054991716,
0.0124451173,
-0.0122215347,
0.0408321582,
0.0622369312,
0.0517352559,
-0.0470541455,
-0.0529593751,
0.0334106684,
-0.0180712231,
0.0079106167,
0.0094551835,
-6.0737918e-33,
-0.0289621912,
-0.0460168011,
0.0061009759,
-0.0121695092,
-0.0495693274,
0.0047928826,
-0.0303437319,
-0.009703137,
-0.0171883162,
0.0034378737,
0.0011001865,
0.0075162128,
-0.0001899174,
0.0300174896,
-0.0236035883,
0.015716901,
0.010109162,
0.0008297572,
-0.0194125306,
0.0240836889,
0.0755562112,
0.0348703973,
-0.0120044183,
-0.0025053467,
0.0146764154,
-0.0386213921,
-0.0052512884,
0.0002595166,
0.0350665338,
0.0254689585,
0.0136231678,
0.0059269099,
0.031000413,
-0.0092625162,
-0.0250710249,
0.0266881064,
-0.1129615679,
-0.0329041556,
0.0061573326,
-0.0412905142,
-0.0355873369,
-0.0213424303,
0.0299892873,
-0.01725615,
0.0622505024,
-0.0475399159,
0.0365443677,
-0.00860452,
-0.04674647,
-0.0813363045,
0.0217062049,
0.0288519952,
-0.0225496776,
-0.015333917,
-0.0400346033,
0.0658658445,
-0.0011340602,
0.0132098915,
-0.0111428108,
0.0362900421,
-0.0140944701,
0.0039045054,
-0.0068630646,
0.0247021466,
0.0244113132,
0.0598271266,
-0.0255877804,
-0.0331957787,
-0.0317130387,
-0.0032305573,
-0.0229563918,
-0.0019520544,
-0.0037766099,
0.0095011536,
0.0112981992,
0.0526786037,
-0.0942710489,
0.0708750039,
0.0015040969,
0.0319835357,
0.0163265597,
0.0079492666,
0.0034037833,
-0.0197628029,
-0.0184407793,
0.049114421,
-0.0206788685,
-0.0377734415,
-0.0125078838,
0.0094993403,
-0.0463053025,
-0.0395549089,
0.0197001603,
-0.0391135104,
-0.0007318112,
0.0383189507,
-0.0084639993,
0.0132234832,
-0.0154629443,
0.0195303466,
-0.0172218848,
0.0121167945,
-0.0035295729,
-0.029367039,
-0.0302156806,
0.0099315988,
-0.00164965,
-0.0109782927,
-0.0593850613,
0.0032887447,
-0.0099934414,
-0.0062050018,
-0.0272279475,
0.0157390535,
0.028836647,
-0.0042874413,
0.0110017862,
0.0902552754,
0.0083928248,
0.0343767405,
-0.0252303667,
-0.0273998063,
0.0117856422,
0.0155281518,
0.0066709612,
0.0449912585,
-0.021665968,
0.0527765863,
-0.0168838948,
-0.0589657538,
-0.0179517251,
0.0527702086,
2.612e-7,
0.0487593561,
0.0178708099,
0.0465418361,
0.0675679594,
-0.018674884,
-0.0016361526,
0.015443367,
0.0331209749,
0.0170268323,
-0.0060131806,
0.0083354069,
0.0393152237,
0.0024556078,
0.0551293939,
-0.1046784222,
-0.033182811,
-0.0290868748,
-0.0732370391,
-0.0253801551,
-0.028023161,
0.0415101685,
0.0290532392,
-0.0215238277,
0.0069409306,
-0.0276178122,
-0.0496777259,
0.0496422537,
0.0374835804,
-0.062790826,
0.0106813265,
0.0462872013,
-0.0243643261,
0.0019527542,
-0.0296361744,
0.0143518401,
0.0237898845,
0.0452002771,
0.0146259665,
0.0182337947,
-0.0724343657,
0.0072636348,
-0.0555888675,
0.0406277403,
0.0239548739,
0.0798248872,
-0.0030074804,
-0.0003704739,
-0.0130231176,
-0.0374330953,
-0.0055921786,
-0.0202695355,
0.0182060767,
-0.02545847,
0.0571354777,
-0.026382871,
-0.0250239633,
0.0252255723,
-0.0863790363,
-0.0258614868,
0.0440464914,
-0.0130656324,
-0.0297726952,
0.0057630055,
-0.027581647,
0.0109170293,
-0.0681692213,
-0.0097889323,
2.371570643e-34,
0.0733254477,
-0.0095438734,
-0.0462776683,
0.0079222061,
0.0361852422,
-0.0440085605,
-0.0158524346,
0.0004225203,
0.0313908532,
-0.1060271114,
-0.0137358923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12480v1 | The Power of LLM-Generated Synthetic Data for Stance Detection in Online Political Discussions | 2024-06-18T10:36:21 | 2024-06-18T10:36:21 | Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Maike Behrendt, Marc Ziegele, Stefan Harmeling | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Stance detection holds great potential for enhancing the quality of online
political discussions, as it has shown to be useful for summarizing
discussions, detecting misinformation, and evaluating opinion distributions.
Usually, transformer-based models are used directly for stance detection, which
require large amounts of data. However, the broad range of debate questions in
online political discussion creates a variety of possible scenarios that the
model is faced with and thus makes data acquisition for model training
difficult. In this work, we show how to leverage LLM-generated synthetic data
to train and improve stance detection agents for online political
discussions:(i) We generate synthetic data for specific debate questions by
prompting a Mistral-7B model and show that fine-tuning with the generated
synthetic data can substantially improve the performance of stance detection.
(ii) We examine the impact of combining synthetic data with the most
informative samples from an unlabelled dataset. First, we use the synthetic
data to select the most informative samples, second, we combine both these
samples and the synthetic data for fine-tuning. This approach reduces labelling
effort and consistently surpasses the performance of the baseline model that is
trained with fully labeled data. Overall, we show in comprehensive experiments
that LLM-generated data greatly improves stance detection performance for
online political discussions. | [
0.0158364791,
0.0570939593,
0.0261279736,
0.0619023852,
0.0071949344,
0.0210628174,
-0.0086881593,
-0.0150057049,
0.0236395299,
-0.0552544221,
-0.0032390689,
-0.0294488054,
-0.0469234996,
0.02880002,
-0.0125005236,
-0.0200915765,
0.0397753082,
0.0236312151,
0.0292048492,
0.0061965566,
0.0427862741,
0.0318693146,
-0.0353192948,
-0.0086209374,
-0.021900652,
-0.0066988794,
-0.0064644273,
-0.0004248287,
0.0686249658,
-0.0071728253,
0.0210478809,
0.0445086621,
0.0294180736,
0.0316640399,
0.0000016266,
-0.0076245782,
-0.0420115665,
-0.0427185148,
-0.0274519306,
-0.0395243987,
0.0381112546,
-0.0276551433,
-0.0004776816,
0.0379102565,
-0.0804576427,
0.0404658318,
0.0189160258,
0.0618247278,
0.084449403,
0.0869012848,
-0.0010671747,
-0.0295916665,
0.0031879321,
-0.0148755852,
-0.0147579806,
-0.0339604653,
0.020521123,
-0.0103814658,
-0.0739490911,
0.0776305422,
-0.0197789669,
0.0017135682,
0.0325427391,
-0.0240341742,
-0.0400877967,
-0.0031212454,
-0.0141809396,
-0.0227268301,
-0.0110878255,
0.081032902,
0.0236718915,
-0.0376827158,
0.023396112,
-0.0253546089,
0.0246833507,
0.0310125798,
-0.0213530734,
0.0216209199,
-0.0426972173,
0.0507486202,
0.027545305,
-0.0002809196,
-0.0061961138,
0.0227353144,
0.0005358534,
0.030750256,
-0.0597108454,
-0.0213020742,
-0.0006187875,
0.0181609523,
-0.0018010739,
-0.024729263,
0.0233725719,
0.0260730553,
-0.0068488256,
0.0357345305,
-0.035199713,
0.0083707795,
0.0345479809,
-0.0700596571,
-0.0079664011,
0.0075928792,
-0.0100886086,
0.0898351222,
-0.0201802924,
0.0105177574,
-0.0362058058,
0.0033814802,
-0.01559358,
0.0016229312,
-0.0328494981,
-0.0008275169,
-0.0108617563,
0.0308511965,
-0.0862972587,
-0.0022016268,
-0.0085521089,
0.0096733142,
-0.0021585417,
-0.0000201267,
0.0301054772,
-0.0069794585,
-0.0038343573,
0.0080153402,
-0.0439206585,
0.056617856,
-0.0116803786,
0.034295287,
0.0114174215,
-0.0591082089,
-0.0127368765,
0.047322493,
0.007329491,
0.0021335038,
0.0151109202,
0.0188872851,
0.0062361737,
0.0038347708,
0.0075050192,
-0.0148394601,
-0.0026884221,
-0.0551875755,
0.0254632644,
-0.0803234875,
0.0570554696,
-0.0031583365,
-0.0042646327,
-0.012711009,
0.0204522144,
0.0343069434,
0.0325387605,
0.0954532698,
-0.0127067221,
-0.0223439764,
0.0232143961,
0.0167534575,
0.0045950413,
0.0947670788,
-0.0239243265,
0.0342317633,
0.0351699442,
-0.0027598173,
0.0096318834,
0.0044430275,
0.0258959234,
0.0072486312,
0.0351789631,
0.0525796786,
-0.0731682852,
-0.0229118429,
0.0031701087,
0.0510688946,
0.0030219632,
-0.0466239639,
0.0744007826,
0.0131165469,
0.0132509246,
0.0154217612,
-0.0019398468,
0.0395839736,
0.0211142655,
0.0040250593,
0.0040342496,
0.0526707694,
-0.0125239026,
-0.0186679065,
-0.0256269109,
0.0324376747,
-0.0249462947,
-0.0824218094,
-0.0117055923,
0.0085958643,
-0.006966826,
0.0242993403,
0.0012589998,
0.0212996677,
-0.0539742,
0.0908602104,
0.0313388593,
-0.0645565391,
-0.0184344761,
-0.0368888378,
0.038641762,
-0.0021056735,
-0.0256417394,
-0.0380351879,
-0.0683127642,
-0.0468385592,
0.0387320556,
0.0881153718,
0.0532755889,
-0.043689914,
-0.0282305945,
-0.034284845,
-0.0085967565,
-0.0173423849,
0.0107945092,
0.0400573723,
0.001052246,
0.0023341882,
0.0008114683,
0.0079733711,
0.0422795005,
0.0206189882,
0.004503319,
-0.0132478606,
0.0061692442,
0.0062541566,
0.0356122702,
0.030581113,
-0.0002227894,
-0.0236443151,
0.0612455122,
-0.0125556858,
-0.0526921004,
-0.0258383788,
-0.0323039666,
-0.0769662559,
0.0264440794,
-0.0302518532,
-0.05543584,
0.0322083682,
-0.0535400659,
0.0116862832,
0.004368803,
-0.0280961823,
-0.0589338019,
-0.0577783883,
-0.0564251356,
-0.0146274893,
0.0116272597,
-0.0520989895,
0.0757356063,
-0.0221764985,
-0.0144155612,
0.0227835272,
-0.0188841727,
0.0248543303,
-0.03120704,
0.002857645,
-0.0073410757,
0.0134399598,
0.0345221981,
0.0199673045,
-0.016038835,
-0.0236331448,
-0.0555179827,
-0.0898868069,
-0.0123755718,
-0.0367320888,
0.0444866642,
0.0516413413,
-0.0397262536,
0.0003621925,
0.0119608296,
-0.0676465034,
-0.0436010025,
0.0013154729,
0.0028852136,
0.0464851074,
0.0051440648,
0.0018516819,
-0.0294656642,
0.0216309652,
-0.0107910307,
0.0068994015,
0.019064635,
-0.0581756085,
-0.0343571752,
-0.0057999864,
-0.0336332545,
-0.007026596,
-0.0468866043,
-0.034858875,
0.0363152176,
-0.0097263511,
0.0218208507,
0.0431000702,
0.0453346074,
0.0669684708,
-0.0162218791,
0.038714841,
-0.0461332574,
-0.0037469196,
-0.0584059246,
0.0518634506,
-0.0493302159,
-0.0003783841,
0.04884376,
0.0811756551,
-0.0126846442,
-0.0021168906,
-0.0256628264,
0.072673358,
-0.0083878711,
-0.0143556036,
-0.001400908,
0.0125962878,
-0.0291117225,
0.0124484822,
-0.0219200607,
-0.0223631691,
0.0583120994,
0.0160649307,
0.0202965941,
-0.0327832773,
-0.0586753041,
-0.0650798231,
-0.0087202527,
0.0163148642,
-0.0098369177,
-0.0225049593,
0.0177592281,
-0.0074950149,
-0.029601207,
0.0456677526,
-0.0544799231,
0.0276019722,
-0.0033912496,
0.0392432958,
0.003403879,
-0.0420416817,
-0.0298655014,
-0.072322011,
-0.0239180159,
-0.0134864524,
-0.0076599275,
0.0016863842,
0.030541379,
-0.0058480049,
-0.014176988,
0.010110911,
-0.0159429871,
-0.0054420689,
0.0051231403,
0.0447171293,
0.0117152352,
-0.0004994964,
0.0468579791,
-0.0333711356,
0.0345974676,
0.0822470412,
-0.0333471335,
0.0276229531,
-0.0121118072,
-0.0400271229,
0.0153237525,
-0.0130476682,
0.0255887881,
-0.0520574413,
0.0711607486,
-0.0344683044,
0.0156560559,
0.0855932161,
0.0348364599,
0.0079697147,
-0.0272271242,
0.0192964692,
-0.0321682431,
0.0139319692,
-0.0088964105,
-0.0679972991,
-0.0074291802,
-0.0368470177,
0.009261176,
-0.0339223333,
-0.0107341362,
-0.0006510027,
-0.0758902282,
-0.0021572434,
-0.0451549068,
-0.0398659222,
-0.01753713,
-0.066375263,
0.019831242,
-0.0523996428,
0.0171286743,
0.0049754293,
0.0159386769,
-0.0248072129,
0.0250367373,
-0.0307807568,
-0.0198124945,
-0.0157789681,
-0.007338556,
0.0112150786,
-0.0057654795,
0.0479139872,
-0.0040216888,
-0.0458875,
0.0740647763,
-0.0173846893,
-0.0022879485,
-0.0185558572,
0.0561755262,
-0.0358607806,
-0.0252171308,
-0.0206971671,
0.035376519,
-0.0214685909,
-0.0107829347,
-0.0417172387,
0.0220779758,
-0.0025176571,
-0.0068767173,
-0.0111668073,
0.0515977256,
0.042977199,
0.056311056,
0.0322379097,
-0.0251131542,
-0.0255804453,
-0.0539575927,
-0.0366183557,
-0.060129229,
-0.0398917831,
-0.0231381506,
-0.004039994,
0.0466753766,
-0.0619241819,
-0.0187587198,
-0.0068326015,
0.0202732049,
-0.0562230758,
-0.0141886808,
0.016630087,
0.0232133456,
-0.0442895368,
0.0369943008,
-0.0193453636,
0.013340855,
-0.0059520733,
-0.0523207076,
0.0581648163,
-0.0020894175,
-0.0325835049,
-0.0016263592,
-0.0894926414,
-0.0396881849,
-0.0272776838,
0.0537322387,
0.0193923321,
0.01539414,
0.0120262783,
0.016295284,
0.0250329226,
0.0901705846,
0.0048850318,
-0.0050608595,
0.0370584391,
0.0608166046,
0.0014937251,
0.0071589896,
0.0209122729,
0.0291796755,
0.051426895,
-0.0094942935,
-0.0949760526,
-0.0091820695,
0.0159611814,
-0.0021745474,
0.0310391225,
0.050816305,
-0.0373826362,
-0.0379344635,
0.0034954511,
-0.0087081166,
-0.0279059745,
-0.0198127218,
0.0198449176,
-0.0022957092,
-0.0531173386,
-0.0309150983,
0.0577537045,
-0.0363839269,
0.0871027187,
-0.0606970787,
0.0579419173,
0.0314176232,
-0.02679649,
-0.0033691472,
-0.0076427869,
-0.0407172963,
-0.0016468236,
0.0563509241,
0.0116415173,
0.0417295881,
0.0322084725,
0.0074951607,
0.0016396103,
0.0502239056,
-0.0056944694,
-0.021354463,
-0.0331386216,
-0.0638483167,
0.0538080297,
-0.0024049606,
0.0033216372,
0.0165847689,
-0.0031282215,
-0.0448842123,
-0.0045220987,
0.0149933081,
-0.013073232,
-0.0175885949,
0.0554529615,
0.0373064019,
-0.0220745169,
-0.0062531335,
0.0296798032,
-0.0252865292,
0.031009797,
0.0302763823,
-0.0097058518,
-0.056346491,
-0.0055234777,
-0.0312876143,
-0.0287786089,
0.0185215268,
0.0172504727,
-0.0464708991,
-0.0356522985,
0.0355322845,
0.0332455635,
0.0138406772,
0.028619891,
0.0014392869,
0.0489877425,
0.0205651503,
0.0448075458,
-0.0577332824,
0.0163471568,
-0.0176819041,
-0.022672642,
-0.0088305585,
-5.742173089e-33,
-0.0238134712,
-0.0629919395,
-0.0072002742,
0.0041179694,
0.0018639574,
0.0039362488,
-0.0106843198,
0.0145332366,
-0.0156373028,
0.0419363901,
0.0261641834,
0.0538517274,
0.0121084368,
0.0229567736,
-0.0680885613,
-0.0484939404,
0.0216470044,
-0.012083007,
-0.0413469225,
0.000889064,
0.0397263728,
-0.0096468478,
0.0462007113,
-0.0540275238,
0.024532387,
-0.0104400786,
-0.0228470564,
0.0449671969,
-0.0200385284,
0.0801929161,
-0.0091145327,
0.0350498147,
0.0700447634,
-0.0592619143,
-0.0083294678,
0.0699114278,
-0.0503774062,
-0.0067355856,
0.0002315964,
0.007458325,
-0.0033165086,
0.007027809,
0.020704696,
0.0064969868,
-0.0133962957,
-0.0083446931,
0.0209360272,
-0.0253788047,
0.0426679254,
-0.0914045572,
-0.024082914,
0.0260576606,
0.0124286078,
-0.0268517397,
-0.0294163506,
0.0499526076,
0.0346568041,
0.0545697734,
-0.0489997417,
0.01447846,
-0.0284561124,
0.0234257318,
0.0119293137,
-0.0127820838,
-0.0035796522,
0.0577188469,
-0.0006806629,
0.0419666916,
-0.0787193179,
0.0156761743,
-0.0182744414,
0.0106688999,
0.099282749,
0.0707608312,
0.0325437412,
-0.0161033534,
-0.0743835121,
0.0113587184,
0.0401345938,
-0.0175066572,
0.0080575868,
0.0114309099,
0.0162998103,
0.0072787874,
-0.0290108789,
-0.0309233833,
-0.0252940804,
0.009790278,
-0.0243872497,
0.0402706563,
-0.0557421222,
0.0169018824,
0.0249870811,
-0.0583676361,
-0.0082820868,
0.0295501426,
-0.0016032594,
0.0033180683,
0.015611168,
-0.0081808111,
-0.0335058421,
0.0040060193,
0.0142558739,
-0.01050922,
-0.000840771,
-0.0157212988,
0.0552428737,
-0.0307380483,
-0.0683868825,
-0.0060326969,
-0.0282326713,
0.0429909192,
-0.0324863419,
0.0935018286,
0.0245427303,
-0.0106366808,
-0.008572788,
0.0644910559,
-0.026982354,
0.0144531354,
-0.0111758066,
0.0410902649,
-0.0537459329,
0.045986861,
-0.0341727249,
-0.0368291326,
-0.0002654539,
0.0479922593,
-0.0294858888,
-0.0914250463,
0.0098019782,
0.0223680064,
2.286e-7,
0.0376719423,
0.0480111912,
0.0234618541,
-0.0104013616,
0.0465246029,
0.0270687621,
0.0099684894,
0.0141857499,
0.0037366832,
-0.0996761099,
-0.0239600558,
0.0693653673,
0.0310572349,
0.0376214832,
-0.1220439076,
-0.0433300473,
-0.0234210305,
-0.0093916962,
-0.0102834124,
0.0117734466,
0.0110586248,
0.0725084469,
-0.0067084227,
-0.0091699446,
-0.0057058167,
0.0420302339,
0.0438201614,
-0.0003554388,
-0.0343817808,
0.0178266093,
0.0439347811,
-0.0641663149,
-0.0015646745,
0.0133181028,
-0.0091901869,
0.0087259766,
-0.0090583051,
0.0735390559,
0.0592395887,
-0.0664755926,
-0.003464621,
-0.0118004587,
0.0217700936,
0.0060627433,
0.0545121543,
-0.08433339,
-0.0238019954,
-0.0359126367,
-0.0671803653,
-0.0047731623,
0.025733579,
-0.0172158852,
-0.0132527836,
0.0350834504,
0.0034731915,
-0.0161501598,
0.0197316203,
-0.0512851514,
-0.0120781418,
-0.0193944834,
-0.0654604882,
-0.0716767535,
0.0450118706,
-0.0307093561,
0.0323379822,
-0.018531505,
-0.0030626401,
1.720849343e-34,
0.0428878143,
-0.0038741394,
-0.0155041609,
0.0213561114,
0.0324941091,
0.0195111968,
-0.020457251,
-0.0194774028,
0.0298184194,
-0.0384462811,
0.0060703014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12474v1 | Exploring Intra and Inter-language Consistency in Embeddings with ICA | 2024-06-18T10:24:50 | 2024-06-18T10:24:50 | Rongzhi Li, Takeru Matsuda, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ME | Word embeddings represent words as multidimensional real vectors,
facilitating data analysis and processing, but are often challenging to
interpret. Independent Component Analysis (ICA) creates clearer semantic axes
by identifying independent key features. Previous research has shown ICA's
potential to reveal universal semantic axes across languages. However, it
lacked verification of the consistency of independent components within and
across languages. We investigated the consistency of semantic axes in two ways:
both within a single language and across multiple languages. We first probed
into intra-language consistency, focusing on the reproducibility of axes by
performing ICA multiple times and clustering the outcomes. Then, we
statistically examined inter-language consistency by verifying those axes'
correspondences using statistical tests. We newly applied statistical methods
to establish a robust framework that ensures the reliability and universality
of semantic axes. | [
-0.0061671096,
0.0516856834,
-0.0191882513,
0.0652831644,
-0.0170830544,
0.027357908,
0.0394690558,
-0.007067367,
-0.0095670959,
-0.0005599877,
-0.0280096512,
-0.0440526605,
0.0669199303,
-0.0189772956,
0.0162445121,
-0.0271447022,
0.0597403161,
0.0218814947,
-0.0090767378,
0.0030771154,
0.0110854581,
-0.0078174556,
-0.0050918036,
0.0237258673,
-0.0609450638,
-0.0118023939,
0.0551424995,
-0.0756084397,
0.0186054483,
-0.025708396,
-0.0554955155,
0.0396552607,
0.0186865106,
0.0175994691,
0.0000017682,
-0.0305269957,
-0.0131823849,
0.0009685831,
0.0361224487,
0.0152166188,
-0.0029067856,
-0.0527287759,
0.0121008158,
-0.0536635481,
-0.0271594469,
-0.0504684299,
0.0786970407,
0.0456144735,
-0.019010704,
0.0176647753,
-0.0275622346,
-0.035903208,
-0.0269664247,
-0.039386902,
-0.0116678253,
0.0410996936,
0.0061199637,
-0.0080859903,
-0.0815996453,
0.0347676277,
-0.0613529719,
0.0127021056,
-0.0011427299,
0.0330706872,
0.0144110797,
0.0728491321,
-0.006805656,
-0.0336513594,
0.0391254425,
0.0913725421,
0.0338926427,
0.0294990968,
-0.0139819514,
-0.027797319,
-0.0123581877,
0.0672177076,
-0.065785788,
0.0051753703,
0.0407251008,
0.0238211639,
0.0216715224,
0.0272160303,
0.0067557781,
-0.0392924733,
-0.0425420329,
0.0769508332,
0.0411277935,
-0.0497180335,
0.014162248,
0.0038728842,
-0.0176011585,
0.0277916044,
-0.0156351775,
-0.0442454219,
0.0328090414,
0.0294112135,
0.0253533609,
-0.0080100242,
0.0413113944,
-0.0275874399,
0.0384404361,
0.0085366424,
-0.0167667847,
0.0082489643,
0.0108952653,
0.0553630553,
0.000399667,
0.0641411021,
-0.0106589766,
0.0420120023,
-0.0204083603,
-0.0169746596,
0.0474144258,
-0.0099054398,
0.0043613156,
-0.039757695,
-0.0316939503,
0.0299143232,
-0.0465995595,
-0.0072783232,
-0.0097803334,
0.009891361,
0.0035451064,
0.0480500087,
-0.0075752554,
0.026532352,
-0.0638052374,
0.0187676474,
-0.0757640228,
-0.0211236123,
0.0019810991,
0.0461216383,
0.0054574548,
-0.0188241433,
-0.0407193564,
0.0355389789,
0.0055029965,
-0.0140391327,
0.0585949942,
-0.004112937,
-0.0481209792,
-0.0413569026,
0.0284296237,
-0.0855516121,
0.0601948313,
0.0110662449,
0.0242794976,
-0.0800403059,
0.0074299029,
-0.0111464029,
-0.0529019795,
0.0520542078,
-0.011257112,
0.0078846887,
-0.0216112603,
0.0142675433,
0.0522815585,
0.0394318961,
-0.006923052,
-0.0556637384,
0.0864675865,
-0.055770494,
0.0001421302,
0.0166221093,
-0.0287394859,
0.0051802099,
-0.0558378734,
-0.0102230618,
0.0587697253,
0.0011090974,
0.0047066407,
0.027384812,
-0.0270693172,
-0.0164575912,
0.0017845774,
0.0915200636,
-0.0105395308,
-0.0261898041,
0.0176497847,
0.0059435638,
0.017108772,
0.0295076985,
-0.0258100424,
-0.0007496451,
0.0866492093,
0.0030828263,
0.0278305467,
-0.0048755491,
-0.0114761218,
-0.0139743974,
-0.0519659482,
-0.0100905122,
0.0006900338,
-0.0636445656,
0.0295672882,
-0.0234555397,
0.0486845523,
-0.014761229,
0.0335936658,
-0.062729165,
-0.0125362705,
0.0382352881,
0.0404635146,
0.0204041321,
0.004836292,
-0.0057550133,
0.0102171777,
0.0330397673,
0.0174775664,
0.0313804187,
-0.0176443588,
-0.0339300148,
0.0278140269,
-0.0313314088,
-0.0322423354,
0.0245290771,
0.0265686214,
0.0282246135,
-0.0167471841,
0.033260148,
-0.0102342386,
-0.0148367472,
-0.0026855513,
0.0529851131,
-0.018190898,
0.0118288044,
0.0181779768,
0.015406427,
0.0131501211,
0.0043012165,
-0.0397953391,
0.0136182792,
0.0510228276,
-0.0284576919,
-0.0020678425,
0.0380975679,
0.0021401988,
0.0022515096,
0.0337144919,
-0.0859752446,
-0.0132812401,
0.0006877285,
0.0165102687,
-0.016395729,
0.0417859033,
-0.0228005014,
-0.0289016087,
-0.0156470519,
-0.0112705389,
-0.0423242711,
0.0573782921,
-0.031794738,
0.0381423086,
-0.0130984709,
0.0672131106,
-0.0051441705,
-0.0214570723,
0.0513729155,
-0.0143269729,
0.0036926575,
0.0654806793,
0.0028792378,
-0.006311269,
-0.0012644142,
0.0014676006,
-0.031965211,
0.0006937586,
-0.0719540194,
-0.0193819255,
0.0055689374,
0.0335611105,
0.0209184662,
-0.0230370145,
-0.0081729349,
0.0069878655,
-0.0232289173,
0.0096985139,
-0.0235338006,
0.0564838164,
0.0487786829,
-0.0507344231,
-0.0068256836,
-0.0487282798,
-0.013942576,
-0.0345920324,
0.0717464089,
0.0226100869,
-0.0182753652,
0.0020230454,
-0.0276312772,
-0.0709929764,
-0.0244327448,
-0.0112942494,
-0.0146462973,
0.0573602505,
0.0190230608,
0.0336859114,
-0.005624881,
-0.0175666753,
0.0025969832,
0.0785580054,
-0.0485976823,
-0.0455045812,
-0.0292282142,
-0.0302697588,
0.0900461152,
0.010484037,
-0.0516857728,
-0.0030483615,
0.0809922591,
0.0583801605,
0.0012545746,
-0.0318667591,
0.0159644596,
-0.065193072,
-0.0090010306,
-0.0618936308,
-0.0134495301,
-0.032395754,
0.0233990047,
0.0001904768,
-0.0498850867,
0.0346460044,
-0.036560446,
-0.002310669,
-0.0403659269,
0.0195624363,
-0.043368917,
0.0364328623,
-0.0534481481,
-0.0198708065,
-0.0294104498,
-0.0059551192,
-0.0084668873,
0.0442023501,
0.0206435211,
-0.0191898793,
0.0477519557,
-0.013195727,
-0.0194902234,
-0.00454567,
-0.0033168388,
-0.0134654744,
-0.0521126315,
0.0109587237,
-0.028961869,
0.0339177176,
-0.0222925525,
-0.0043104859,
0.0240854081,
0.0487332791,
-0.0268006716,
-0.0219028778,
0.0129619865,
-0.0198673531,
0.0298057441,
0.0300770681,
-0.0062737954,
0.010015808,
-0.0049023163,
-0.0015690741,
0.0236696135,
-0.0191408917,
0.0162369218,
-0.0016560034,
0.0131762326,
-0.0131599847,
0.035036169,
-0.0297895242,
-0.0386089534,
0.0151033318,
0.0277684927,
0.0015576696,
0.0681414008,
0.0241526328,
-0.0798354372,
0.0281847026,
-0.0116547048,
0.0054272227,
0.0382829048,
-0.0213345811,
-0.0451377258,
-0.0069041359,
-0.0290624797,
0.0055369153,
0.0097399084,
-0.0195368044,
-0.0098431967,
-0.0840482786,
0.0452416316,
0.0020680977,
-0.0482742377,
-0.0481891669,
-0.0942310989,
0.0369021334,
0.012347932,
0.0230311844,
-0.036473643,
-0.0209564827,
0.007479602,
-0.0156791769,
-0.0847250819,
-0.0523825623,
-0.0333097652,
-0.0272228997,
0.0008931076,
-0.0127448598,
0.0550737232,
-0.0428081602,
-0.0445932299,
0.0270943623,
-0.060103368,
-0.0382512286,
-0.0233519915,
0.0517231412,
0.0214210842,
-0.0425347276,
-0.0305643734,
-0.0245464575,
-0.0097581139,
-0.0011381423,
-0.0202957727,
0.0947897136,
-0.0078194356,
-0.041003935,
-0.0297439657,
-0.0036504455,
-0.0011713139,
0.0559863411,
0.0322993062,
-0.0171450451,
0.0017560979,
0.0200150963,
0.0271325186,
0.0487566739,
-0.0271259435,
0.0041662017,
-0.0222399272,
-0.0317583978,
-0.081949465,
-0.0601765811,
0.0433459245,
0.0207118504,
0.0190785956,
0.0108645,
-0.054276403,
-0.0441731885,
-0.0357575417,
0.040960528,
-0.0040723528,
0.0054419693,
0.0359446146,
0.0304950774,
-0.0102247205,
0.012546652,
-0.0221182797,
0.0086620795,
0.0185106322,
-0.0587470904,
0.0140119297,
-0.0400060751,
0.0025248562,
0.0318554305,
-0.0102315648,
-0.0167006068,
0.0333583429,
0.0121307606,
-0.0134743275,
0.0184967928,
-0.0031501902,
-0.0549494736,
0.020942606,
0.0148588996,
-0.0101442253,
0.0227520298,
0.0114546092,
0.0529596247,
0.0198248271,
-0.0150198154,
-0.0111571355,
0.0305174664,
0.059388224,
-0.0053258045,
0.0207398459,
-0.0740140527,
-0.0433481894,
-0.0434935167,
-0.0226050746,
0.0207848977,
-0.0135229789,
0.0429591574,
0.004583457,
-0.0475573465,
0.0463048145,
-0.0329117551,
-0.0106819319,
-0.0187479295,
0.0265240185,
0.01030898,
0.0159183554,
-0.0470944643,
0.0442264751,
-0.0131931938,
0.0072991555,
-0.0574317686,
-0.0086383447,
-0.0190903731,
-0.0125746466,
-0.0164027158,
-0.0338531211,
-0.0515102893,
0.0193794779,
-0.0092305234,
0.0493976325,
0.0184137002,
-0.0382232405,
0.0104850512,
-0.0101761315,
0.076638639,
-0.004866885,
0.0144607928,
-0.0114377057,
-0.0137940869,
-0.0288833063,
0.0262398943,
0.0520498902,
-0.0010550275,
-0.046505779,
0.0076719858,
0.0634719282,
-0.0286369827,
-0.0121651841,
-0.0915324613,
-0.0188733935,
-0.0212382656,
0.0350639597,
0.0394482464,
0.02877138,
-0.0630497336,
-0.0224670935,
-0.06195556,
-0.0283335689,
0.0182944816,
-0.0021639797,
-0.0192495007,
0.0622837245,
-0.0163814463,
0.0681104511,
0.0155570554,
0.0247070249,
-0.0039592977,
-0.0054996838,
-0.0504436158,
-0.0604977533,
-0.0175130758,
-6.131164006e-33,
-0.0052892854,
0.0005132807,
-0.0302830115,
0.0071783913,
-0.0419919938,
0.0475422293,
-0.0203707498,
0.045543354,
0.005490581,
0.077083312,
0.0123591302,
-0.001574248,
0.0132447416,
-0.0208897535,
0.0788998976,
0.0143751027,
-0.0343927741,
0.0045786342,
-0.0537165329,
-0.005070786,
0.0733414218,
-0.0085505908,
0.1206211671,
-0.0792265534,
0.066715546,
0.0317242183,
0.0398826003,
-0.0054314854,
0.0298732929,
0.0597346611,
-0.0692573413,
0.0598701052,
0.0610037073,
-0.0154721066,
-0.014154152,
0.0341343805,
-0.0437504724,
-0.0750289634,
0.0536735244,
-0.0002010359,
-0.0738338828,
-0.039852377,
0.0418653898,
-0.0465923436,
-0.0311894305,
0.0113131432,
0.0489417389,
0.0219908375,
-0.0072010085,
0.039694719,
-0.0551720299,
0.0027768193,
-0.0203654524,
0.0627717897,
0.034763176,
-0.0023190496,
0.0072298688,
0.007952353,
-0.0362647437,
0.0481359325,
-0.0684663653,
0.0046409923,
0.0338406302,
-0.0045509511,
0.0238270722,
0.1185159683,
0.0563839749,
-0.0371451974,
0.0103141712,
-0.0355645046,
0.0871012956,
0.0118360789,
0.0570696145,
0.0553113818,
-0.0062776934,
-0.004388385,
-0.0566908494,
0.0023109983,
-0.0167212281,
-0.0038424481,
0.0235931817,
-0.0299035199,
-0.0669071749,
-0.027386466,
-0.019663848,
-0.0239223074,
-0.0187827572,
-0.0286095254,
0.0294440649,
-0.0181700364,
-0.0076265754,
0.0380188897,
0.0404331908,
-0.0232142881,
-0.0169440955,
0.025553681,
-0.030478755,
0.049374532,
0.023759244,
-0.0348304175,
-0.0137757985,
-0.0090590306,
-0.0071019023,
0.006134755,
0.0516877994,
-0.0199642405,
0.0342088081,
-0.0180099513,
-0.0650608167,
-0.0289870556,
-0.0045529264,
-0.0838638693,
-0.0141887916,
-0.0240872391,
0.0316813439,
0.0165680032,
-0.029053662,
0.0052870535,
0.0596840046,
0.0436914563,
-0.0301854219,
-0.0342003517,
-0.0177504495,
0.0111539848,
0.0082928129,
-0.01330972,
-0.0267810728,
-0.0106559247,
0.0430121943,
-0.043114949,
0.0037378764,
0.0049574776,
2.475e-7,
0.0392251238,
0.0742018372,
0.0016980183,
-0.0176564306,
0.0463643633,
-0.0221476257,
-0.0470153019,
0.0180504955,
-0.0308011621,
0.0051380009,
0.0057519469,
0.0226075556,
0.0103037916,
0.0496740416,
-0.0045668157,
0.0328697637,
-0.0441683233,
0.0014731333,
-0.0328554213,
-0.0139764743,
0.0137039255,
0.094651565,
-0.0011755504,
0.0078318175,
-0.0607233644,
-0.0124586718,
0.0376994684,
-0.0241441987,
0.0212163478,
0.0061481497,
-0.0287720989,
0.0063938522,
0.0759723112,
0.0216625854,
0.0321504772,
0.0380610749,
0.0494159423,
0.0042338078,
-0.0155938379,
0.0590835735,
0.0232356004,
0.0049288133,
0.0132313929,
-0.0509388261,
0.072225593,
-0.0419401564,
-0.0417099446,
-0.0456953906,
-0.0079844594,
0.0429591909,
0.0900022164,
0.0133169619,
0.0026465396,
0.0384087488,
0.0137344645,
0.0117368791,
-0.0309656672,
-0.010298715,
-0.0248504691,
0.0143839773,
-0.0284487344,
-0.0283132382,
0.0019947141,
-0.0202771332,
0.0240590516,
-0.0205683075,
-0.0028111693,
2.145802489e-34,
-0.0078556072,
0.0232329685,
0.0184887052,
0.005118398,
0.0059843408,
-0.0714596733,
0.0316785723,
0.0147964153,
-0.0394151881,
-0.069183372,
0.017465936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12471v1 | Fighting Randomness with Randomness: Mitigating Optimisation Instability of Fine-Tuning using Delayed Ensemble and Noisy Interpolation | 2024-06-18T10:20:36 | 2024-06-18T10:20:36 | Branislav Pecher, Jan Cegin, Robert Belanec, Jakub Simko, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova | cs.CL | cs.CL | While fine-tuning of pre-trained language models generally helps to overcome
the lack of labelled training samples, it also displays model performance
instability. This instability mainly originates from randomness in
initialisation or data shuffling. To address this, researchers either modify
the training process or augment the available samples, which typically results
in increased computational costs. We propose a new mitigation strategy, called
Delayed Ensemble with Noisy Interpolation (DENI), that leverages the strengths
of ensembling, noise regularisation and model interpolation, while retaining
computational efficiency. We compare DENI with 9 representative mitigation
strategies across 3 models, 4 tuning strategies and 7 text classification
datasets. We show that: 1) DENI outperforms the best performing mitigation
strategy (Ensemble), while using only a fraction of its cost; 2) the mitigation
strategies are beneficial for parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods,
outperforming full fine-tuning in specific cases; and 3) combining DENI with
data augmentation often leads to even more effective instability mitigation. | [
0.0415850691,
0.10567642,
-0.0065557193,
0.0286336336,
0.0195554011,
0.0171104018,
-0.0181017034,
-0.0009753556,
-0.0408267528,
-0.0643706694,
-0.0205298662,
-0.0513121821,
0.0290084016,
-0.0252902973,
0.0300336648,
-0.0514111444,
0.053269282,
-0.0259874146,
0.0196650308,
-0.024997633,
0.0037143985,
-0.0076261349,
0.0149404779,
0.0333228372,
0.0217772014,
0.0100049116,
-0.0044422955,
0.0241741166,
0.0040722173,
0.0150724174,
0.0464242324,
0.1025011018,
0.0105597721,
0.063870348,
0.0000021701,
-0.044631198,
-0.0342003442,
0.0127320075,
-0.0329186767,
0.019949032,
0.0493799634,
0.0125418287,
-0.0061102188,
0.0174383763,
-0.0129780667,
-0.0381716862,
0.0511772633,
0.0295846574,
0.0294959769,
0.0643884316,
-0.0018570643,
-0.0137119647,
0.0036859126,
-0.0378722586,
-0.0257616844,
-0.0585931726,
0.0255195778,
-0.0270997509,
-0.0141929686,
-0.0160235576,
-0.0252800472,
-0.0079035712,
-0.0200986508,
0.0229521226,
0.0087067056,
0.0136548793,
-0.0487153493,
-0.0437203161,
-0.0261328351,
0.0792383701,
-0.0718658939,
-0.0174365845,
-0.010187489,
-0.0229925681,
0.0151918856,
0.0037471328,
-0.0015971503,
0.0115653593,
0.0122483158,
0.0337056294,
0.0348983631,
0.0113988062,
0.0696882457,
0.0265779179,
-0.0096939057,
0.046669554,
0.0154317394,
-0.0296564158,
-0.0073472629,
0.0168367792,
-0.0513173789,
-0.0415650234,
-0.0365845896,
-0.0047831945,
-0.02458179,
0.0098092901,
-0.0967988819,
-0.0815992802,
0.0066558435,
-0.0007377881,
0.0292681549,
0.0194061454,
0.0180295464,
0.020850854,
0.0038079196,
-0.0150634283,
0.0275126267,
0.0530135259,
-0.0290462021,
0.0184741858,
-0.0195622332,
0.0147608211,
-0.0434393845,
0.0116187064,
-0.0328401886,
-0.0058061932,
-0.0315719321,
0.0068364823,
0.0285859667,
-0.0210707132,
-0.0142292045,
-0.0088644791,
-0.0264906418,
0.0130934501,
0.0322937742,
0.0207988936,
-0.0019952853,
0.0309526045,
0.0049093147,
-0.0542313196,
-0.0355631299,
-0.0152767012,
0.0178021081,
-0.021949999,
0.0341736786,
0.0201306529,
0.0021545161,
-0.0553313531,
-0.0246663243,
-0.0171488542,
-0.0297867786,
-0.0511121973,
-0.0182285104,
-0.0395168737,
0.016926039,
0.0015167703,
0.0277178362,
-0.0766488388,
-0.0047192392,
-0.0305256303,
-0.0628767684,
0.0744241849,
-0.0961928666,
0.0188708548,
0.0127064958,
0.0026375134,
0.0611743703,
0.0812807679,
0.0367517844,
-0.0286676455,
0.0436060205,
-0.0173036642,
0.0065521118,
0.034585163,
0.0337956436,
0.01281079,
-0.0311659724,
-0.0191103984,
0.048943229,
-0.0031058255,
-0.0034794935,
0.013483298,
-0.0439772233,
0.0084374538,
0.0495476574,
-0.0046970029,
-0.0243261531,
-0.0005484714,
-0.045952864,
-0.0122477636,
0.009070416,
0.0034122048,
-0.0522845276,
0.0021651958,
-0.0457126126,
-0.0229494814,
0.0518547557,
0.0449380465,
-0.017316537,
-0.0389316157,
-0.0227155462,
-0.0011376492,
0.0136352722,
0.0283257272,
0.0316975676,
0.0021971194,
-0.0091975518,
0.0572008938,
0.0576880872,
-0.0354691632,
-0.0139792403,
-0.0496901721,
-0.003595798,
0.1105859578,
0.0369729809,
-0.0175353549,
-0.0380643755,
-0.0326824561,
0.0420114696,
-0.0109458137,
0.0328655876,
-0.0054203295,
0.058680512,
-0.0515037552,
-0.0526233278,
0.031965185,
0.0175311919,
-0.0045990101,
0.0273061804,
0.0108826431,
0.0087294793,
-0.0264023468,
-0.0468977466,
0.038221471,
-0.0266521927,
-0.0289986115,
0.0248745847,
0.0036180154,
0.0298301075,
-0.0161069352,
-0.0465292707,
-0.0194985867,
0.0237545054,
-0.0032493272,
0.0107952235,
-0.0282684546,
-0.0275558848,
-0.0370036066,
0.0532154068,
0.0524419807,
-0.0091114799,
-0.000090456,
-0.0584338568,
-0.065211542,
0.0212366842,
0.0199486818,
0.0032526101,
-0.0342042223,
0.0376246534,
-0.0678881258,
0.0754279196,
-0.0656932816,
0.0152602121,
0.0032863333,
0.0383470505,
-0.0371005647,
0.014608888,
0.0162714329,
-0.0038410716,
-0.046069596,
0.0316353738,
-0.0185104925,
0.0254944228,
0.0011128951,
-0.0112772724,
-0.0170832146,
-0.0395688415,
-0.0726554617,
-0.0250935908,
-0.0418030098,
-0.0025707246,
-0.0008534102,
0.0387311205,
-0.0311134346,
-0.0237685777,
0.0185222644,
-0.0149903605,
0.0061500976,
0.0168611929,
-0.0137100425,
0.0097547248,
-0.0386483073,
-0.0312898308,
-0.0298453532,
0.0341424681,
0.0519732907,
-0.0178093538,
-0.0308052674,
-0.0928561017,
-0.016564874,
-0.0140452329,
0.0280833878,
-0.0067471168,
-0.0451525412,
-0.0336651541,
-0.0208696481,
0.0055896835,
0.0290336888,
-0.0048554111,
0.0031622457,
0.047493536,
0.0248104464,
-0.0250055138,
-0.007025871,
-0.0068522058,
-0.0197217539,
-0.0482932255,
0.0126037505,
-0.0346601903,
0.0663609356,
-0.0326702632,
-0.0331138931,
-0.0447461009,
0.0384324715,
-0.0230146572,
-0.0279913414,
-0.0397717319,
-0.0288958102,
-0.0215721577,
0.0319048762,
-0.0357904322,
-0.0489050597,
0.0771958455,
-0.0156387687,
0.0055702501,
-0.0606978796,
-0.0233657788,
0.0063229455,
0.0163148921,
-0.0012923334,
0.0068898671,
0.0472668931,
0.0006868339,
-0.0458769277,
-0.04536568,
0.0247666426,
-0.0289722141,
0.0268493947,
0.0077298745,
0.0356350094,
-0.0245804191,
-0.0468181223,
-0.0202750936,
-0.115206793,
-0.0267356951,
-0.0009426866,
0.0634112284,
-0.0355086438,
-0.0069112685,
-0.0024430868,
-0.0318065472,
0.033504121,
-0.0457280688,
0.0016155259,
-0.0109673105,
0.026295973,
0.0399603359,
0.011989695,
0.0398516767,
-0.0403032005,
0.0065529514,
0.000633817,
0.0388930999,
0.0348197594,
-0.0438669585,
-0.0028758834,
0.0428164266,
-0.0049775047,
-0.0338307098,
0.0168547239,
0.0379189476,
-0.0378711447,
-0.0394783728,
0.1252605021,
0.003430218,
-0.0425399356,
0.0092854286,
0.0194461346,
0.0968925282,
0.0246810336,
0.0285214651,
-0.0082877045,
-0.0524499267,
0.0386793427,
0.0447900966,
0.0035695967,
-0.005734378,
0.0176479891,
-0.0734541863,
0.0264847316,
0.0420360416,
-0.044345431,
0.0056456281,
-0.0414287709,
-0.0004363673,
-0.00116468,
0.0519739464,
0.0130917821,
0.0124701597,
0.030497944,
0.0530600064,
-0.0214646813,
-0.1243094951,
-0.0028630886,
-0.0285803396,
0.0603390299,
0.0562352501,
-0.0184475146,
-0.0062765921,
0.0076466165,
0.0695237815,
0.015559826,
-0.0127042048,
-0.003329206,
0.0762882605,
0.0095187062,
-0.0217701979,
0.0297237523,
0.0017441707,
-0.0250376351,
0.0011160453,
-0.0385632999,
0.0290440246,
-0.0289808121,
-0.0007363965,
0.0267041977,
-0.0430297777,
0.0427548662,
0.054050263,
0.0255998448,
-0.0433214568,
-0.0163724907,
-0.0286712255,
0.0185515806,
-0.0593631975,
0.0144549068,
0.0343357138,
0.0095256241,
-0.0233965423,
-0.0172736738,
-0.0504052937,
0.0087694395,
0.0113741606,
0.018281525,
0.0443253592,
-0.0305200368,
0.027923774,
-0.0488928296,
0.0066550393,
-0.0052328114,
0.0377713144,
-0.0268089101,
-0.007755531,
0.0175679494,
0.0127477394,
-0.009408094,
0.0207795091,
-0.0890381113,
-0.0896421447,
0.0383757204,
0.044052165,
0.0117968265,
0.0571563207,
-0.0082577178,
-0.1068695486,
0.0754710957,
0.0606429949,
0.0216074716,
0.0394400693,
0.0268608704,
-0.0918388516,
-0.0101052988,
0.0306996386,
-0.0431518517,
0.0164102558,
0.0521027073,
-0.0019406441,
-0.0168330111,
-0.0478240214,
-0.0316721238,
0.0133051099,
0.0628549829,
-0.0530923232,
-0.0250337012,
-0.0216436759,
0.0329603516,
0.0299767833,
-0.0226956978,
-0.0305609927,
0.0018847381,
0.0400828868,
-0.0062533771,
-0.032588169,
0.0445388108,
0.0302107967,
0.0299460758,
-0.0035337615,
0.0187381227,
-0.0373647958,
0.006095395,
0.0575132929,
0.0265253615,
-0.004250288,
0.05418979,
0.0080478312,
0.0004252852,
-0.0296457168,
-0.0264975633,
0.0380722843,
0.0308666024,
-0.0581091717,
0.0315246135,
-0.0535780676,
-0.032035172,
-0.0413635187,
0.0062493482,
0.0539314561,
-0.0082277097,
0.0508888327,
0.0215835534,
-0.0208069384,
-0.025732711,
-0.0049448549,
0.0089520533,
0.0070424243,
0.019434398,
-0.0031933656,
-0.0342626423,
0.0255031269,
0.0945814624,
0.0170373116,
0.0528672859,
0.0127929151,
0.0104658278,
-0.0317831896,
0.0019774162,
-0.0272204503,
0.0236025304,
-0.0086714588,
0.0225670207,
0.0216364712,
-0.0405494943,
0.0155827487,
-0.0123387445,
0.0178886577,
0.0040332167,
0.0160184391,
0.0428516306,
-0.0170540158,
0.0308178626,
-0.0317318998,
-0.0554762632,
0.0141155338,
-0.020292975,
-0.0060540289,
-7.286649974e-33,
-0.0048952713,
0.0212856364,
-0.0440065116,
-0.0330599733,
-0.0112103904,
-0.0288274009,
0.0024325529,
0.0255522057,
-0.0120088831,
0.0043586669,
-0.031793002,
0.0228143129,
0.0197179057,
0.0225944966,
0.0070944857,
-0.0118753742,
0.0642162189,
-0.0161207207,
-0.0324746035,
0.0114081288,
0.0408713073,
0.0619751513,
0.0649813265,
-0.0541597977,
-0.0143468212,
0.0137449242,
-0.017587265,
-0.0224902276,
-0.0223940797,
0.0265365131,
0.0124812191,
0.0507461056,
0.000990541,
-0.0087605054,
-0.0459115729,
0.0062722806,
-0.0642218813,
-0.0202918462,
-0.0120942919,
0.0382098109,
0.0063250586,
-0.0334594585,
0.0649581179,
-0.0047004474,
-0.0167977791,
-0.0135186734,
0.02089197,
-0.0469657704,
-0.0470935777,
-0.0405817926,
-0.0223818254,
0.0317884162,
0.0142327538,
0.000729089,
0.0278720893,
0.0013473913,
0.0008194964,
0.0224298108,
-0.0509111509,
-0.0196501892,
0.0622125939,
0.0826053768,
-0.0032849037,
0.0717220455,
-0.0053962325,
0.045222532,
0.0104293991,
0.0301791243,
0.0188868828,
0.0020012958,
0.0649053901,
0.0163674466,
0.0325406455,
0.0263203904,
0.0558198914,
-0.0307529494,
-0.0677803382,
0.0173976067,
-0.0067054429,
-0.0429810472,
0.0531146154,
0.0242001712,
-0.032156691,
-0.0530030131,
-0.0598314628,
-0.0337924771,
-0.0248367451,
0.0130561572,
-0.0005314258,
0.0446503721,
-0.0353203975,
0.0075788596,
0.0446502641,
-0.049913764,
-0.0425523296,
0.012451048,
-0.0156961363,
-0.0113838287,
0.0069476124,
0.0014412047,
-0.0165214352,
-0.0587510355,
0.0319928788,
0.0106703816,
0.0133301308,
-0.0410044193,
0.0822076723,
0.0293675102,
-0.061698664,
0.0007730576,
0.025242094,
0.0570618436,
0.0348058194,
0.0324679278,
0.0375006795,
0.0059414338,
0.0248120818,
0.0250412039,
0.0452736206,
0.0222876016,
-0.0025964202,
-0.0269018561,
0.0128517821,
0.0185621604,
0.0138510233,
0.014530398,
-0.0262176655,
-0.0315972492,
0.0336326845,
-0.0643375516,
-0.0034378311,
0.0054404964,
2.852e-7,
0.0334406495,
0.0537937582,
-0.0100905979,
-0.0402556956,
0.0336636752,
0.0191151146,
-0.0183253158,
-0.0088658994,
-0.0118291993,
-0.0058240145,
0.012598142,
0.0197088886,
0.0614441559,
0.0052392967,
-0.0705716833,
-0.0247687139,
-0.0685667694,
0.0887134001,
-0.0231761374,
-0.0315161757,
0.0095862309,
0.1344900429,
0.0300293509,
-0.0355103649,
-0.0076301508,
-0.0320633054,
0.0547816269,
-0.0252769776,
0.0092017278,
0.0541831478,
0.0190260485,
0.0403423347,
0.0121450545,
0.0093714697,
-0.0522714555,
0.022078108,
-0.0291424114,
0.0139363008,
-0.0412237532,
-0.0008962678,
-0.016106233,
0.0149664525,
0.0097125601,
-0.0391675606,
0.0827933252,
-0.064402014,
-0.0298277829,
-0.0355250165,
-0.0161219295,
-0.0400518775,
0.0545547493,
-0.0175741296,
-0.0015477471,
0.0353465937,
0.0217904374,
0.0065277568,
-0.0324065499,
-0.1084493473,
-0.0107177431,
0.030857496,
-0.0223381631,
-0.0440979116,
-0.0041039586,
-0.0504935086,
0.0342042707,
-0.0375628471,
0.0032775423,
2.985747386e-34,
0.0506070405,
-0.0270197261,
0.0342064388,
-0.0077852909,
0.0088481093,
-0.0346853361,
0.0232840497,
0.0067771263,
-0.0094311675,
-0.0567112416,
-0.007892129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12468v1 | Adaptive Token Biaser: Knowledge Editing via Biasing Key Entities | 2024-06-18T10:18:06 | 2024-06-18T10:18:06 | Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Hongcheng Gao, Yilong Xu, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The parametric knowledge memorized by large language models (LLMs) becomes
outdated quickly. In-context editing (ICE) is currently the most effective
method for updating the knowledge of LLMs. Recent advancements involve
enhancing ICE by modifying the decoding strategy, obviating the need for
altering internal model structures or adjusting external prompts. However, this
enhancement operates across the entire sequence generation, encompassing a
plethora of non-critical tokens. In this work, we introduce $\textbf{A}$daptive
$\textbf{T}$oken $\textbf{Bias}$er ($\textbf{ATBias}$), a new decoding
technique designed to enhance ICE. It focuses on the tokens that are mostly
related to knowledge during decoding, biasing their logits by matching key
entities related to new and parametric knowledge. Experimental results show
that ATBias significantly enhances ICE performance, achieving up to a 32.3%
improvement over state-of-the-art ICE methods while incurring only half the
latency. ATBias not only improves the knowledge editing capabilities of ICE but
can also be widely applied to LLMs with negligible cost. | [
0.0438549332,
0.0335428342,
-0.0086433245,
0.0135771763,
-0.0457305126,
0.0034532328,
-0.0180394873,
-0.0191356931,
-0.0193714183,
-0.0645237043,
-0.0243767202,
-0.0284197889,
0.0201282743,
0.0214359816,
0.025398124,
-0.0479614213,
0.0695358068,
-0.0459528752,
0.0425939038,
0.0074849832,
-0.0067086103,
-0.0037138283,
-0.0016245146,
0.0447328389,
0.0119251739,
-0.0173794515,
-0.0269088447,
0.0148890791,
0.0026156695,
-0.0416821912,
-0.0064362502,
0.0658869371,
-0.0219599772,
0.0219074097,
0.0000023821,
-0.0466758423,
-0.0621034727,
-0.0051761232,
-0.0531933159,
0.0522375852,
0.0371061563,
0.0138964085,
-0.0466313325,
0.0194149762,
-0.0286885034,
-0.0131599968,
0.0713972598,
0.0088379411,
0.0691061541,
0.0628568083,
-0.0064582294,
0.0180823095,
0.0300627574,
-0.0063976469,
0.0051009012,
-0.0409437902,
0.0457179584,
-0.0342827775,
-0.0442698225,
0.0000433912,
-0.0282035992,
0.0428220406,
0.0174616352,
-0.0079480447,
0.0318873525,
0.0307140704,
-0.0276053883,
0.0020092223,
-0.0358367115,
0.0314755291,
-0.0136118131,
-0.0306773577,
-0.0065992502,
0.003865584,
0.0302212331,
-0.018155247,
-0.0454718731,
-0.0069307471,
-0.0037106453,
-0.0024550844,
0.0401520208,
-0.0431859493,
0.0250108019,
0.0007097243,
-0.0564069822,
0.0471560806,
0.0522255637,
-0.0254953224,
-0.0399411134,
-0.0224959683,
-0.0287534259,
-0.1011918187,
0.0149784125,
0.0418932587,
-0.0272427052,
0.0285177156,
-0.065326415,
-0.0337215625,
-0.0112247234,
-0.0348856486,
0.0235464498,
0.0800878257,
-0.0190753974,
0.0304900017,
-0.0449495614,
0.0533285253,
0.0247231778,
-0.0114480471,
-0.0211372152,
0.0064484864,
-0.0402832702,
-0.037695609,
-0.0677190423,
0.0498429276,
-0.030811796,
-0.0113468692,
-0.0288333669,
0.0504929498,
0.0346947797,
0.0139269037,
0.0275125429,
-0.0111003537,
-0.0086345486,
-0.0010435116,
-0.0069022048,
0.0361042693,
-0.0156181026,
-0.0152554931,
-0.0027788342,
-0.0626998395,
-0.0184932891,
-0.009360685,
0.0242299289,
-0.031346079,
-0.0230126213,
0.0681650639,
-0.0229485352,
-0.0296986736,
-0.048991289,
-0.0467529818,
-0.0165079366,
-0.0265025925,
-0.0312636644,
-0.0618359447,
0.0293169655,
0.0245603323,
-0.029288156,
-0.049301967,
0.0058982358,
0.01729808,
-0.0362485871,
0.0373456702,
-0.0118384268,
0.0132458946,
0.0216941293,
0.0008463199,
0.0040306528,
0.0745612904,
0.0264819283,
0.0060471366,
0.0485922135,
-0.0048305453,
-0.0231820233,
0.065794453,
0.04343329,
-0.0052888878,
-0.0277447794,
0.0085217441,
0.0411829613,
0.0170532539,
0.0411025733,
0.0312341694,
-0.0486915819,
0.0115543883,
0.0784523785,
0.0086880066,
-0.0001040751,
0.0301798899,
0.0210299287,
-0.0230930671,
0.0031479257,
0.0023503497,
-0.0328273065,
0.0361679569,
0.0066859475,
0.0332121812,
0.0443557911,
0.0403272137,
-0.0092286412,
-0.018047573,
0.0100555485,
0.0148797426,
-0.0324791148,
-0.0095773097,
0.0186451767,
0.0202239435,
-0.0763749853,
0.0965006649,
0.0102616344,
-0.0293084867,
-0.0007664285,
-0.0381549001,
-0.0136158802,
0.1045336723,
0.0658145696,
0.0012662678,
-0.0548174307,
0.0140386801,
-0.0099321678,
0.0078813853,
0.0304055624,
-0.0178539027,
-0.0148708532,
-0.0679759309,
-0.0422943942,
0.0118888915,
0.0129559068,
0.0466424525,
0.0534022823,
0.0247517321,
0.0245114304,
-0.0436276831,
-0.0030099554,
0.0062588071,
-0.032556925,
-0.0186456572,
0.0030768646,
0.0028423562,
0.0125287632,
0.0217156596,
-0.0098773837,
0.0188032668,
0.0263960939,
-0.0292508975,
0.0115581797,
0.0499683805,
-0.0848219097,
-0.051789742,
0.0527934618,
0.0322210044,
-0.0153057659,
-0.0386299491,
-0.0030383673,
-0.0495522767,
0.0116456635,
-0.0212267917,
0.1244502589,
-0.0385199673,
0.0613987558,
0.0131186359,
-0.0126050506,
-0.0240033753,
0.0405213982,
-0.0310490262,
-0.0358700603,
0.044914145,
-0.017966073,
-0.0281632934,
-0.0295693148,
0.0094661824,
0.029691821,
0.0074703437,
-0.0314386413,
-0.0018977138,
-0.0013808634,
-0.0267621968,
-0.0374002345,
-0.0870907679,
-0.0041782963,
-0.0322869979,
0.0141915362,
0.0295889918,
0.0452196784,
-0.0180237293,
0.0020899794,
-0.0093647987,
-0.0132606113,
-0.0328264646,
0.0306451395,
-0.0016167936,
0.0349893831,
-0.0393819138,
-0.0103791077,
0.0158884022,
-0.012394188,
0.0387067087,
-0.0174379647,
-0.0427207984,
-0.0720812082,
0.0185542479,
-0.0123905502,
0.0008924906,
0.0046908073,
-0.0120078614,
-0.0186685957,
-0.0102350023,
0.1036793143,
0.0257990267,
0.0001462937,
0.0046005468,
0.030539548,
-0.0561368428,
-0.0573235191,
0.0013994958,
0.0069099758,
-0.0204627384,
-0.0319515318,
-0.0218573976,
0.027295528,
0.0492221974,
0.0258512739,
-0.0008467239,
-0.0671870336,
0.0136117702,
-0.0007289417,
-0.0364685133,
-0.0297807064,
-0.0304943863,
-0.0298311822,
-0.0000497923,
-0.0386441164,
-0.0213919114,
0.0572205819,
-0.0420466885,
0.0063717547,
-0.0307764653,
0.0393683948,
-0.015094135,
0.0351504646,
-0.0124068391,
0.0305055548,
-0.0144088771,
-0.0443072319,
-0.0502032228,
0.0051622144,
-0.024069149,
-0.0304299854,
0.0088763563,
-0.0636735931,
-0.0084796827,
0.0047403001,
-0.0109058637,
-0.0336587615,
0.0270336065,
-0.0151693057,
0.0101487637,
0.0406055078,
-0.0327948257,
-0.0195885133,
0.0118400119,
0.0192134846,
0.0763555393,
-0.0226557776,
0.0052193701,
-0.0110094445,
0.0138342287,
0.0515917465,
-0.0099145472,
-0.0024695543,
-0.0138945235,
0.0433137938,
0.0723409355,
0.0636885613,
-0.0536483862,
-0.00725498,
0.0022521145,
0.0333728008,
-0.065627791,
-0.0046193949,
0.0295407884,
0.0294620544,
-0.0649840757,
-0.0146365194,
0.1339019388,
0.0293710697,
-0.0655748174,
0.0174503792,
-0.0220806077,
0.0325900428,
0.0190105215,
0.0112979794,
-0.0908793062,
-0.0446379408,
0.0451138765,
0.0312223062,
-0.0076579056,
-0.0395538434,
-0.0297358166,
-0.1195184663,
0.007496634,
0.0084586916,
-0.0543192066,
-0.023385575,
-0.0255971085,
-0.0146534275,
0.0125745805,
0.0464411601,
0.062491186,
0.0165664963,
0.020539714,
0.0042246529,
-0.0245687813,
-0.0512137078,
-0.0098324874,
-0.0088960212,
0.0733615309,
0.0672600716,
0.0144911278,
0.0434782505,
0.0032484359,
0.0526704006,
-0.0067234356,
0.0248863399,
-0.0453721546,
-0.0057941135,
-0.0322298892,
0.0041664075,
0.0029669632,
0.0409235992,
-0.0018786751,
-0.0287324972,
0.027157411,
0.0843638778,
-0.0004872894,
0.0335260257,
0.0035508587,
-0.0600656867,
0.0056212824,
0.0752203465,
0.032168515,
-0.0308038127,
-0.0031467504,
-0.0529552028,
0.009264241,
-0.0537999906,
0.0127941268,
-0.0141835557,
-0.0127337789,
-0.015036297,
-0.0831737295,
-0.0025941969,
0.0587114505,
0.0504865944,
0.0340056531,
0.0413189307,
0.0053591277,
-0.0229318589,
-0.0703921467,
-0.0265832674,
-0.0427918471,
-0.0143812057,
-0.0776621625,
-0.0224002507,
-0.0140146576,
-0.0461804941,
-0.0066346442,
0.0394326709,
-0.0295724068,
-0.0780489966,
0.0389772914,
0.0463119447,
0.0216802079,
0.0954270288,
-0.0007819507,
-0.0443059765,
0.0556692854,
0.043566592,
-0.0411217064,
0.0400424525,
-0.003165219,
0.0434185602,
-0.0213246793,
0.0350922197,
-0.0547218099,
-0.0581754632,
0.0327755064,
0.0755157098,
-0.0012164155,
-0.0164131653,
0.0225520786,
0.0386177376,
-0.0058517866,
-0.0255180523,
-0.0143595161,
-0.0000456612,
0.0827714577,
-0.0254138652,
-0.000643388,
-0.0113479448,
0.0258592274,
0.0119292066,
-0.0085022049,
0.0009902809,
-0.012147937,
-0.0021782315,
-0.0076710931,
0.0041139023,
-0.0013364169,
-0.0387665704,
0.0490828119,
0.073158145,
-0.0218944307,
-0.0184001159,
0.0188479275,
0.0039272169,
0.0036873822,
-0.0645920262,
0.0352094397,
0.0316738971,
-0.0181230474,
-0.0438884757,
0.0366320349,
-0.0527383201,
-0.0109714745,
-0.0315018222,
0.0385490172,
0.0570518598,
-0.0002752488,
0.0458613113,
-0.0543514602,
-0.011707088,
-0.0218109116,
0.0217426661,
0.0343644433,
-0.0420922525,
-0.0164488815,
0.0138167758,
-0.0076964707,
0.0161503311,
0.0691468269,
-0.0093868934,
0.1061413363,
-0.0304911733,
-0.0179331396,
-0.0395319201,
-0.031050209,
0.0079725198,
-0.0046844217,
-0.0523086749,
-0.0192397591,
-0.0353669189,
-0.0400520898,
-0.0052810004,
-0.0120617794,
-0.0132983038,
-0.0121904034,
0.0129338484,
0.0495057888,
-0.025222417,
-0.0363375619,
-0.0091007352,
0.0184810869,
-0.0066530597,
-0.0422971621,
-0.0053407224,
-6.638081986e-33,
-0.0280725211,
-0.0003829614,
0.0139202261,
-0.0134275733,
-0.0259848237,
-0.0040745819,
-0.056565661,
-0.018032331,
0.0401989371,
-0.0386351943,
-0.0254013892,
-0.0087209055,
0.0220202357,
0.0090316487,
0.0010940245,
0.0231031366,
0.0744345486,
0.0017018225,
-0.0374319218,
0.0302314535,
0.0503209531,
0.0501536764,
0.0694426894,
-0.0129900677,
0.0351808183,
0.0200209469,
0.0220862459,
0.008510178,
-0.0010317095,
0.0439582206,
-0.009815231,
0.011675694,
0.0035138784,
-0.0435930975,
-0.0443017371,
-0.0306017622,
-0.0780720189,
-0.0000768341,
0.0501556993,
0.0494459383,
0.0238792636,
-0.0943575501,
0.010081769,
0.0031552762,
-0.0362098962,
0.025518503,
-0.0041323667,
-0.0269269478,
-0.0323959216,
-0.0214566924,
-0.0394981354,
0.0374476165,
-0.0195581559,
0.0259853806,
0.0103615485,
-0.0210038871,
0.0098549696,
-0.0118021667,
-0.0604096428,
0.0289359819,
0.0363025777,
0.0712259412,
0.0628199428,
0.0133987926,
0.0279629976,
0.0448443294,
0.0273133423,
-0.004511686,
0.0008136716,
0.0102755008,
0.0328653641,
0.0011466146,
-0.0033187089,
0.024781717,
0.031149298,
-0.0263156425,
-0.0268526543,
0.0031366951,
-0.0001628912,
0.0574950688,
0.0342487022,
0.0295539852,
-0.0186519567,
-0.00804717,
-0.0583843179,
-0.0074985926,
-0.0546298288,
-0.0291912835,
0.065378204,
0.0280133747,
-0.0323999114,
-0.0432444997,
0.0554184318,
0.0074719354,
-0.0168392584,
0.0286642238,
0.0035224948,
0.0347381793,
-0.0276341103,
0.0165939461,
-0.0503506139,
-0.0064850068,
0.0525537506,
-0.0005634411,
0.0052625034,
0.0049731131,
0.0063766502,
0.038515415,
-0.0752592757,
0.0101073682,
-0.0251164604,
0.0292227045,
0.0039857826,
-0.0443661585,
0.0436988883,
-0.0096002743,
0.0027207343,
0.0232941117,
0.0208230205,
-0.0208074488,
-0.027973542,
0.0057365494,
0.0285461023,
0.0254014209,
-0.0242617782,
0.0244174562,
-0.0044197915,
-0.0193913672,
0.0025668165,
-0.0234980378,
-0.0205467679,
0.0264721476,
3.036e-7,
0.0226902682,
0.0651535615,
0.0559438914,
-0.0079828287,
0.0222749561,
0.0029205247,
-0.0172686633,
-0.0050184685,
0.0107027674,
0.0229023825,
0.006198952,
0.0222690627,
0.0158750918,
-0.0013017992,
-0.0975482911,
0.0041716937,
-0.0342312679,
0.0304916929,
-0.0671798512,
0.0068236291,
0.0106452461,
0.0590976886,
-0.0188124441,
0.0068450784,
0.0029231203,
-0.0435896665,
0.0247455407,
-0.0228018966,
0.0064130756,
0.0068531325,
0.0118362699,
0.0108981663,
0.0100026345,
0.0275816917,
-0.0347722657,
-0.01852859,
-0.0127986651,
0.0617907941,
-0.0073722466,
-0.0230015367,
0.0130438115,
0.0070104529,
-0.0186182689,
-0.066494301,
0.067971006,
-0.0038592515,
0.0052450541,
-0.0360181853,
-0.0260325074,
0.0055041867,
-0.0509088449,
-0.011957353,
-0.0047697788,
0.0428432897,
0.0196733065,
0.0463670157,
-0.0118547874,
-0.0562635176,
-0.0449237898,
-0.029576445,
-0.0197400488,
-0.0695146397,
-0.0699032843,
0.010171067,
0.0280381665,
-0.074921377,
0.0031734752,
3.382460199e-34,
0.0203151274,
0.0022174916,
0.0298664682,
0.0772963315,
0.04736742,
-0.0314277932,
0.0002215932,
0.0426757485,
0.0183965284,
-0.0922143608,
-0.0669975206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12442v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12442v1 | Abstraction-of-Thought Makes Language Models Better Reasoners | 2024-06-18T09:46:44 | 2024-06-18T09:46:44 | Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Abstract reasoning, the ability to reason from the abstract essence of a
problem, serves as a key to generalization in human reasoning. However,
eliciting language models to perform reasoning with abstraction remains
unexplored. This paper seeks to bridge this gap by introducing a novel
structured reasoning format called Abstraction-of-Thought (AoT). The uniqueness
of AoT lies in its explicit requirement for varying levels of abstraction
within the reasoning process. This approach could elicit language models to
first contemplate on the abstract level before incorporating concrete details,
which is overlooked by the prevailing step-by-step Chain-of-Thought (CoT)
method. To align models with the AoT format, we present AoT Collection, a
generic finetuning dataset consisting of 348k high-quality samples with AoT
reasoning processes, collected via an automated and scalable pipeline. We
finetune a wide range of language models with AoT Collection and conduct
extensive evaluations on 23 unseen tasks from the challenging benchmark
Big-Bench Hard. Experimental results indicate that models aligned to AoT
reasoning format substantially outperform those aligned to CoT in many
reasoning tasks. | [
0.0200377591,
0.0402204171,
-0.0192732457,
0.0368134603,
-0.0311515108,
0.0537599064,
0.0136404345,
-0.0286476519,
-0.0247699581,
-0.0171835143,
0.0289925002,
-0.0062335157,
-0.0038626522,
0.0347301178,
0.0414159447,
-0.0925318748,
0.0191912614,
-0.0555107519,
0.0420537703,
0.0066635963,
0.000249073,
0.0301479362,
-0.0173562337,
0.021027742,
0.0292759649,
-0.0449670404,
-0.0476806201,
-0.0125855105,
0.0299139302,
-0.0203828309,
-0.0205322672,
0.0130626662,
0.0276699644,
0.0023163664,
0.0000025309,
-0.043774195,
-0.0128682228,
0.008606297,
-0.0169620309,
0.0035427168,
-0.0505937859,
0.008214009,
0.0119071202,
0.0242765844,
-0.0082076686,
0.0067838188,
0.016176505,
0.0615001358,
0.0683224797,
0.0412117578,
-0.00542237,
-0.0357747115,
0.0045161238,
0.0081736911,
-0.0078674387,
-0.019701045,
-0.0188408885,
0.0495498367,
0.0198699459,
0.0329922512,
-0.0019000423,
0.0303896498,
0.0549423024,
0.0152679551,
-0.0135160256,
0.0412658826,
-0.0503555462,
-0.0338820592,
0.0146486768,
0.0525820367,
-0.0423105359,
-0.0449061804,
0.0075938087,
-0.027755795,
-0.0055921739,
-0.0297425613,
-0.0410955772,
0.0559363551,
-0.0210851319,
0.0130517976,
0.0266501829,
-0.0085204691,
0.0237893146,
0.0318252482,
-0.0718899444,
0.0675056055,
-0.0328830555,
-0.0239874274,
0.0339683369,
-0.0244294163,
-0.0403881446,
-0.0782053843,
-0.0179305933,
0.0296298023,
-0.0414193086,
0.0008604605,
0.0087279575,
-0.0181189626,
-0.0273663308,
0.025028564,
0.0497717038,
0.060746491,
0.0149554973,
0.0396782234,
-0.0412793495,
0.0221820138,
-0.0246252641,
0.0383984149,
-0.0430724211,
0.0112608587,
-0.0542589538,
-0.0164398886,
-0.0412669964,
0.0576542467,
-0.0216080602,
0.0116904499,
0.0228274129,
0.0116295172,
-0.0400337987,
0.0076499749,
-0.010156678,
0.0106309783,
0.0240878612,
-0.0409446023,
-0.0393696167,
-0.0110953227,
-0.0724031255,
0.0256035756,
0.0615908578,
-0.019108532,
-0.010496608,
-0.014405976,
-0.0201597959,
-0.025387153,
0.0108548831,
0.0465619899,
-0.0021696051,
0.0350270011,
-0.0412148461,
-0.055204317,
0.0454966687,
-0.0599770509,
0.0133134667,
-0.0811266825,
0.0293284412,
0.0287072305,
-0.0096150888,
-0.0088962764,
0.006615472,
0.0015300134,
-0.029420102,
0.0793622881,
-0.0339778624,
0.0179956704,
-0.0019968434,
0.0230993275,
-0.0299174432,
0.0418775082,
0.0325280093,
0.024811944,
-0.0115446914,
0.0124584949,
0.0008428558,
0.0142680919,
0.010365908,
-0.045293387,
-0.0048425766,
0.0230198149,
-0.0887089521,
0.0358365141,
0.0122094173,
0.0594588816,
-0.0228984598,
0.0406824909,
0.0091275061,
0.0435735583,
-0.0284176245,
0.0272003952,
0.0686812326,
-0.0008862989,
0.002849278,
-0.0152351568,
-0.0574217103,
0.0650335774,
0.0096568251,
0.0242984369,
-0.0079262983,
-0.0112300385,
-0.0378537811,
-0.0509402566,
-0.0162573531,
0.0345824622,
0.0027737943,
0.0248517059,
0.0202595741,
0.0245845579,
-0.0092185577,
0.049586948,
0.0140037183,
-0.0238443799,
-0.0383090638,
-0.0549859442,
0.0384586565,
0.02167923,
0.0325878412,
-0.0001519799,
-0.0290591177,
-0.039487008,
0.033172138,
0.01286845,
0.0489176102,
-0.0210627951,
-0.0246980414,
-0.051909335,
-0.0059690648,
-0.0217739251,
-0.0042142579,
-0.0154693807,
0.0075710327,
-0.0384721607,
0.0162826981,
-0.0381325819,
-0.0534223579,
0.021514127,
-0.0273387246,
-0.0161360353,
-0.0332805887,
0.0409504585,
0.0031127688,
-0.0028490354,
-0.0085230414,
0.0440570153,
-0.0272429604,
-0.0236457586,
-0.0238145757,
0.0209802333,
-0.029164277,
-0.0016934236,
0.0166362431,
-0.0481604114,
-0.0527463369,
0.0195976645,
-0.0535208248,
-0.0188860986,
0.0284982417,
-0.0098662777,
0.0207167566,
-0.0259909071,
0.0253786761,
-0.0124587584,
-0.0541338548,
-0.0110976193,
0.0907192081,
-0.015833145,
-0.0119263493,
0.0332461037,
0.0098040905,
0.035873618,
-0.0184822716,
-0.0095381364,
0.0175104905,
-0.0195947252,
-0.0138437077,
0.0097372076,
0.0470224097,
-0.0907377154,
0.0119359754,
-0.0318835005,
-0.0084342696,
-0.006422196,
0.0121072223,
0.0350081995,
0.0067002689,
0.0222337376,
0.0160784367,
-0.0205767918,
0.0041305199,
-0.0151549028,
0.0211917814,
0.037329562,
-0.0213233363,
-0.0098076221,
-0.0125418482,
-0.019196583,
-0.0657090321,
0.0238832776,
-0.0296276808,
0.0058662798,
-0.0388063006,
0.058234673,
-0.058136221,
0.0036500485,
-0.0084863082,
-0.0211833138,
0.0483116396,
-0.0377285294,
0.0109334439,
0.0843852088,
-0.0186887886,
0.0028920658,
0.0520231575,
-0.0063904533,
-0.0487131216,
0.0425488986,
0.0125465784,
0.0159014836,
0.0243740324,
-0.0153587479,
-0.0156444497,
0.0777950734,
-0.0138446419,
-0.0002469388,
-0.0898290351,
0.0566233918,
-0.0220742393,
0.0069156759,
-0.0533558764,
-0.0332937129,
-0.0094130952,
0.0771201327,
-0.0446416065,
-0.0145005994,
0.0929531679,
0.0111621795,
0.0053554359,
-0.0496467464,
0.0185309015,
-0.0109853102,
0.0830234289,
-0.0271598771,
0.0057299691,
0.020682402,
-0.0054509398,
-0.0639788434,
-0.0159060042,
0.0199620239,
-0.0167056024,
0.0418429039,
-0.0495728254,
-0.0232606009,
-0.0045046918,
-0.0406563617,
-0.0412601046,
0.0270797573,
-0.0736109689,
0.0294906348,
-0.0038885716,
-0.0039426484,
-0.0135642709,
-0.0089799576,
0.0317302532,
0.0196769405,
-0.0008790037,
-0.0255760588,
-0.0346234404,
0.0015531256,
0.0387794636,
-0.012487906,
0.0699491352,
-0.0225668401,
0.0783709064,
0.0333423838,
0.0496431738,
-0.0009058686,
-0.0536846668,
0.016223643,
-0.0160880964,
-0.0073438887,
-0.0193665493,
0.0136240581,
0.0700328946,
-0.0739935264,
-0.0404353216,
0.1146301106,
0.0352159888,
-0.0001136844,
0.0159368273,
-0.0538715646,
0.0774151683,
0.050798662,
0.0308034979,
-0.0546638109,
-0.0400617495,
0.0552799553,
-0.0032512054,
-0.0051051346,
-0.0604614429,
0.0043810252,
-0.0936927125,
0.0478089191,
0.0037307534,
-0.0358644873,
-0.0233195741,
-0.0039706663,
-0.0000018948,
0.0301346947,
-0.0276365988,
0.0469334871,
0.016196426,
0.0256033428,
0.0267420858,
-0.0155041935,
-0.0051416922,
0.0591884963,
-0.0362499803,
0.0231028628,
0.0144291585,
0.0312991254,
0.0234392062,
-0.0563945025,
0.0821044296,
-0.0251509994,
0.0216766614,
-0.0185374822,
0.0122333672,
0.020938972,
-0.0179234818,
-0.0296952147,
0.0633923337,
-0.0176762454,
-0.0418350771,
-0.0008321451,
0.1208641008,
-0.0273509752,
-0.0384446941,
-0.0096883178,
-0.0084181326,
-0.039610628,
0.0482616201,
0.0571888909,
-0.0124956928,
-0.0556866191,
-0.0476182178,
-0.0425984636,
-0.0451776385,
-0.0217430945,
0.0003739993,
0.0306494329,
0.0171881337,
-0.0343175158,
-0.0340924785,
0.0546369627,
0.0110272216,
0.0004021116,
-0.0462736636,
0.0339017175,
-0.0139801819,
-0.0407802165,
0.0466659777,
-0.0143949315,
0.0412075669,
0.0230429713,
-0.0019289994,
-0.0079499343,
-0.0231686234,
-0.0258885566,
0.0513423607,
-0.0566589497,
-0.0577183664,
-0.0232878458,
0.0302898008,
0.0268223025,
0.0301803704,
-0.0167886745,
-0.0583260059,
0.0214859899,
-0.0368475281,
-0.0206403937,
-0.0103559475,
0.0237525497,
0.0069730063,
0.0358122922,
0.0660357624,
-0.0220114551,
0.0169242322,
0.0276439004,
0.0331165865,
0.0030248195,
0.0488447435,
0.0376953743,
0.0366178565,
-0.0055677919,
0.0047931969,
-0.0110706901,
-0.044599507,
0.0194134507,
-0.0178601164,
-0.052059561,
-0.0456731692,
0.0254492071,
0.0030506605,
-0.0082268454,
-0.0109181041,
-0.0188499074,
0.0291895363,
0.029563006,
0.0318891518,
0.0145075694,
0.0063264607,
0.0340528935,
0.0436541513,
-0.0209013317,
-0.019672174,
-0.0054182354,
-0.0357623175,
0.0680577531,
-0.0311888382,
0.064451918,
0.0645362139,
0.0202517584,
-0.0552583002,
-0.0000496297,
-0.0629109219,
-0.1098167375,
0.0431125052,
-0.0509986654,
-0.0011739286,
-0.0204948224,
0.0352335833,
-0.0349751674,
-0.0145538393,
0.0407901555,
0.0451869629,
-0.0053835949,
-0.026326878,
0.0047791549,
0.0443002768,
0.0043059229,
-0.0422950387,
0.0275721047,
-0.0804464072,
0.0138791585,
0.005957182,
-0.0036763996,
-0.0308043286,
0.0142074609,
-0.0570430607,
0.051812198,
0.0092268493,
0.014740197,
-0.0461129397,
-0.0885577425,
-0.0541539975,
0.0425195806,
0.0004039643,
0.0141771957,
0.0355594978,
0.0498905443,
0.0000463251,
-0.0433679074,
0.0121041881,
-0.0044323918,
-0.023857018,
-0.0317373127,
-0.0664765835,
-6.932668217e-33,
-0.0009042552,
0.0089585371,
0.0424580537,
0.0140585965,
-0.0452952757,
-0.0081818113,
-0.0707614943,
0.0248016976,
-0.0316033922,
0.0523916781,
-0.0287318006,
0.0203166753,
-0.0058715334,
0.0160282124,
0.0294680092,
0.0052615674,
0.0171750672,
-0.0089204004,
-0.0444895811,
0.0176115967,
0.0396426134,
-0.0256136451,
0.0144305341,
-0.0609813333,
0.000391889,
0.0233116169,
-0.0155397458,
0.0368907936,
-0.0518674292,
0.0209768359,
0.0101984954,
-0.0101033291,
0.0333476216,
-0.0061863787,
-0.0091034481,
0.0002920477,
-0.0699076578,
-0.0357777216,
0.0562171154,
-0.006432489,
-0.0865675136,
-0.0472223721,
0.0014739445,
0.0019703642,
0.0169629715,
-0.0532020181,
0.0054714554,
-0.0248082578,
0.0416868292,
-0.006878091,
-0.0332242809,
0.002617751,
-0.0594482236,
-0.0139400242,
0.0452736579,
0.0303604584,
-0.0307680108,
-0.0041162167,
-0.035048604,
0.0059427726,
0.0324008018,
-0.005044295,
0.084930636,
-0.0100661246,
-0.0054892791,
0.0412178077,
0.018263083,
-0.000625629,
-0.0333874598,
0.0554990284,
0.0064030839,
0.0769803673,
0.0174990743,
-0.0382470936,
0.0048030452,
0.007759355,
-0.0531414486,
-0.0020981834,
-0.0440331772,
0.0594505928,
0.0536997057,
0.0170637071,
-0.0213770699,
-0.0253714453,
-0.0670329258,
-0.0353042819,
-0.0402525701,
-0.0008809088,
0.0280055478,
-0.0199424103,
-0.0392829627,
-0.0362074636,
0.0042371056,
-0.0395700485,
0.0216493569,
0.025048146,
-0.0421897955,
0.0268506948,
-0.0038892485,
0.0212414525,
-0.0401479006,
-0.006638689,
-0.0119255446,
0.0341489799,
0.0375042036,
0.0137819853,
0.0676924214,
0.0026531906,
-0.0339504778,
-0.005088394,
-0.0995342582,
0.0218002386,
-0.0356209278,
0.0491571426,
-0.0050236001,
0.0552444234,
-0.0075741606,
0.0035698966,
0.0042951144,
-0.0358298905,
-0.0276561882,
0.0795188248,
0.005567085,
0.016201742,
-0.0151340365,
-0.0206305664,
-0.0546763279,
0.0028909426,
0.0823893994,
-0.0436152332,
-0.0326626264,
0.0584441647,
3.109e-7,
-0.0001561825,
0.0442483686,
0.0284317899,
0.0602206998,
0.0119385729,
0.048726473,
0.0158135109,
-0.0365342535,
0.0558603927,
-0.0555561706,
-0.0239526201,
0.0679462627,
0.0384585783,
0.0293129217,
-0.0515347049,
0.0110938298,
-0.0387341641,
-0.0371741466,
-0.0441860482,
-0.0113406451,
0.0656835958,
0.0440332219,
0.0315299667,
-0.0204165056,
0.0265903864,
0.0275700763,
0.0139372395,
-0.0091000181,
0.0378320664,
0.018633293,
-0.017730413,
0.0284615904,
0.0166664328,
0.0287424624,
0.014910317,
-0.0097340941,
-0.0192447267,
0.0236448552,
-0.0011296989,
-0.0011310203,
-0.0173666887,
-0.0374721922,
0.0197453257,
-0.0891673565,
0.0845676512,
-0.0494545661,
-0.0397076234,
0.003206613,
0.0089301532,
0.0086095426,
-0.0259185117,
0.0097515406,
0.0128101772,
0.0165470541,
-0.0057706395,
-0.0081844926,
-0.0122334631,
-0.0741810352,
-0.0542902499,
0.0242586676,
-0.0047245962,
-0.0281197838,
-0.025712546,
0.0112929679,
0.0109658949,
-0.0801024958,
-0.0179203227,
2.998129566e-34,
0.0060601444,
0.0108463969,
0.0452963524,
0.0295119751,
0.0667560995,
-0.0115743987,
-0.0185026936,
0.0071515553,
0.0145941814,
-0.0612571649,
-0.0360095799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12430v1 | PlanRAG: A Plan-then-Retrieval Augmented Generation for Generative Large Language Models as Decision Makers | 2024-06-18T09:25:35 | 2024-06-18T09:25:35 | Myeonghwa Lee, Seonho An, Min-Soo Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | In this paper, we conduct a study to utilize LLMs as a solution for decision
making that requires complex data analysis. We define Decision QA as the task
of answering the best decision, $d_{best}$, for a decision-making question $Q$,
business rules $R$ and a database $D$. Since there is no benchmark that can
examine Decision QA, we propose Decision QA benchmark, DQA. It has two
scenarios, Locating and Building, constructed from two video games (Europa
Universalis IV and Victoria 3) that have almost the same goal as Decision QA.
To address Decision QA effectively, we also propose a new RAG technique called
the iterative plan-then-retrieval augmented generation (PlanRAG). Our
PlanRAG-based LM generates the plan for decision making as the first step, and
the retriever generates the queries for data analysis as the second step. The
proposed method outperforms the state-of-the-art iterative RAG method by 15.8%
in the Locating scenario and by 7.4% in the Building scenario, respectively. We
release our code and benchmark at https://github.com/myeon9h/PlanRAG. | [
0.0309034828,
0.067848593,
-0.0225629359,
0.0336766206,
-0.0256953109,
-0.0070285345,
-0.0457592793,
-0.0171527844,
0.0010848223,
-0.0256939195,
-0.0106128287,
-0.0341912843,
-0.0326957218,
0.0315163955,
0.0236571394,
-0.0038996739,
0.0067579653,
-0.048520375,
0.011162092,
-0.0151994452,
-0.026328085,
0.0003931263,
-0.0079495087,
0.0343231261,
0.0149621665,
0.0031419406,
-0.0479039885,
0.0103694918,
0.021064885,
-0.0607775226,
-0.0079800822,
0.0174110215,
0.0423110649,
0.0179413725,
0.0000020327,
-0.0586977415,
-0.0376049429,
-0.010293344,
-0.0137435272,
-0.0040812152,
0.0014267982,
0.0368034467,
-0.0206065159,
0.0349500738,
-0.0724003464,
-0.0126869315,
0.0409680642,
0.0285019986,
0.0343952253,
0.0755433813,
0.000641958,
-0.0805272907,
0.0091714421,
-0.0418992043,
0.005358201,
-0.0703742579,
-0.012577991,
0.0420889631,
0.041529566,
-0.0084585892,
0.013148373,
0.0206636433,
0.0106627904,
-0.0129087353,
-0.0489678457,
0.0355329104,
-0.0099206381,
0.0085292868,
-0.0231040101,
0.0575479195,
0.0097818775,
0.0060919048,
0.0514907204,
0.0195997078,
0.003885851,
-0.0107147824,
-0.030291535,
0.020407455,
-0.0183680188,
0.0306751635,
-0.02276434,
-0.0115859918,
0.0323674046,
-0.0086529311,
-0.0609089211,
0.0797919035,
-0.0028847337,
-0.0367847271,
-0.0066615418,
-0.0100099146,
-0.0028235412,
-0.0675866231,
-0.0250382181,
0.0507604666,
-0.0915027112,
0.015964454,
0.0122618796,
0.0242996868,
0.0046816366,
-0.009273733,
0.0580179282,
0.0272639785,
0.0327212699,
0.019440705,
-0.0076151444,
0.038925793,
-0.0126127647,
-0.0204983559,
-0.0602692626,
0.0178343449,
-0.0289260596,
-0.0117507484,
-0.0487271622,
0.0550469756,
-0.0946868658,
-0.0279674307,
-0.028823832,
0.035232529,
-0.0280534346,
0.053211011,
0.00654996,
0.0334891938,
0.0027379962,
0.0013566297,
-0.0822180361,
-0.020458499,
-0.0361792669,
0.0229045134,
0.0212555043,
-0.0330812894,
0.0273657758,
0.0045960988,
0.0019653179,
0.0110709192,
0.0222505368,
0.0879476368,
-0.0310221259,
0.0012479972,
-0.0663784072,
-0.0710791051,
-0.0043913806,
-0.1093697771,
-0.0051842602,
-0.0763203651,
0.018216962,
-0.0086490847,
-0.0342263021,
-0.0136751672,
0.0033355714,
0.0078170933,
0.0211795941,
0.0473591052,
0.0234357882,
0.048185721,
0.014545639,
0.0178786311,
0.0313178785,
0.0944324955,
0.0370705947,
0.0732446015,
-0.0086080292,
0.0042696018,
0.0338633694,
0.0462948903,
0.0008374606,
0.0049091638,
-0.0521276072,
0.0329729095,
-0.0335883349,
0.0391045511,
-0.0028108601,
0.0407806598,
-0.0575425737,
0.0405962095,
0.019068459,
-0.0117270881,
0.072385475,
0.0283844806,
0.0416794792,
0.033626277,
-0.0229905993,
-0.0038805935,
0.0231109392,
0.0393331274,
-0.0302920733,
0.0184946358,
-0.007870717,
0.0309538711,
-0.0047127116,
-0.054975953,
0.0271714851,
0.0113361552,
-0.0074127875,
0.0398368165,
0.0249865185,
0.0221352987,
-0.0772202015,
0.0254251007,
-0.0063293865,
-0.0260766372,
-0.0203926694,
-0.0545814447,
0.0728352666,
0.0818549693,
0.0674185604,
-0.0383833125,
-0.027670566,
0.006581116,
-0.0414292924,
0.0078226831,
0.0390501879,
-0.0318229534,
-0.0238969307,
-0.0651863515,
-0.0606188588,
-0.014994747,
0.0140768355,
0.0500629172,
0.0240623429,
-0.0093194693,
0.0211762246,
-0.0098813772,
0.00268166,
-0.0028389585,
-0.0164322127,
-0.0370292328,
0.0284261256,
-0.0062026009,
0.0504550301,
0.0103972424,
-0.0375763737,
0.0327852406,
0.0403957814,
-0.0131569393,
-0.026890602,
-0.0052620806,
0.0071789208,
-0.0208102595,
0.0277998131,
-0.0223577246,
-0.0025947085,
-0.0112129394,
-0.0470121726,
-0.0481387414,
-0.015850028,
-0.0407576524,
0.0200898387,
-0.0516764857,
0.0247310232,
0.0146292634,
-0.027186431,
-0.0567540601,
0.0779626966,
-0.0108215781,
-0.022216741,
0.0405836627,
0.0161655657,
0.0140721668,
-0.0793498307,
0.0262770429,
0.0709012672,
0.005782532,
0.0150303245,
0.0338903479,
0.0186841991,
-0.049412407,
-0.047641933,
-0.0833923295,
0.0184608605,
-0.0043275817,
0.0308990236,
-0.0103448704,
0.0045891968,
-0.014361782,
-0.0061835162,
-0.0557593778,
0.0285788849,
0.0163840652,
0.0053206868,
0.0129969902,
0.0317708366,
-0.0208341498,
-0.0312838331,
-0.0060755778,
-0.0008124918,
-0.0006978512,
0.0023214277,
0.0291331466,
-0.0630623102,
0.0342047289,
-0.0456965007,
0.0305534117,
-0.014909924,
-0.0152925849,
0.0381447747,
-0.0418101996,
0.0552497245,
-0.0051943003,
0.0162663683,
-0.0023640217,
0.0740463808,
-0.0425922312,
-0.0817968324,
0.0521677136,
-0.0217609387,
-0.044962611,
-0.047281269,
-0.0321816504,
0.0357654877,
0.015826514,
-0.0160804093,
-0.0066997134,
-0.0480079316,
0.0251425039,
0.0343972147,
-0.0420772545,
-0.0307432562,
-0.0033872095,
0.0107470248,
0.074529022,
0.0134053621,
-0.0131550841,
0.0516527444,
-0.0263280701,
0.0070747435,
-0.0241348054,
-0.0033276444,
-0.0603273921,
0.0643531978,
-0.0019367702,
0.0163783934,
-0.0757080093,
-0.0144312195,
-0.0385458916,
-0.0426049829,
0.0036313587,
-0.0540006086,
0.0489099175,
-0.06954436,
-0.0068380279,
0.0137555972,
-0.0504633076,
-0.0539122298,
-0.0076832385,
-0.0366802365,
-0.022079302,
0.0288147572,
-0.0227324981,
-0.0488411412,
-0.0221633296,
0.0389675982,
0.0236108582,
-0.0123510221,
-0.0204914492,
-0.0177401844,
0.012488774,
0.0996698514,
0.0580396764,
0.0205485355,
0.0231847763,
0.0414436422,
0.0372143239,
0.0031613316,
-0.009022682,
-0.0245811418,
0.0132532697,
0.042416919,
-0.0040759873,
-0.0089689502,
0.0525502376,
-0.006758274,
-0.0389812328,
-0.0059836451,
0.0756700635,
0.0223931782,
0.0107019851,
0.0029430087,
-0.0264790803,
0.0538550131,
0.024908131,
0.0724341497,
-0.0826392695,
-0.01922049,
-0.0019359152,
0.0235072821,
-0.0247574057,
-0.0375334807,
-0.0186366122,
-0.1449866444,
0.079736948,
-0.0062203915,
-0.004695117,
0.0065024947,
-0.0141542256,
-0.0203358922,
-0.0004688435,
-0.0028484978,
0.0363832861,
0.0018035676,
0.012940268,
-0.0039766966,
0.0190803204,
0.0014472167,
0.0132737067,
-0.0065207137,
0.0164302588,
0.099079363,
0.0476413928,
0.0218292177,
-0.0175508931,
0.0265408196,
0.0433373116,
0.0117879752,
0.0037244614,
0.0056939637,
0.0404732637,
-0.0012231019,
-0.0053847469,
0.0133586358,
0.0025301804,
-0.0256513413,
0.0416083001,
0.0592825934,
-0.0251697656,
-0.0223022997,
-0.0104581006,
0.0070985993,
0.0363456309,
0.0411888994,
-0.0166953579,
0.0013291708,
-0.0534340069,
-0.0117104119,
-0.0025445593,
-0.0753127038,
-0.0221781582,
-0.0046457779,
0.0149725964,
0.0180127677,
-0.0631587505,
-0.0365033299,
0.0141403312,
0.0581240095,
0.0057612481,
0.001696761,
0.0072946474,
0.0007111982,
-0.0284870621,
-0.0315979272,
-0.0302681252,
0.0059144455,
-0.0432716347,
-0.0057124305,
0.0382772647,
-0.0654124767,
0.0020545144,
0.0406234898,
-0.0268944167,
-0.0629415438,
-0.0092571843,
0.0556864217,
0.0261103194,
0.0162680801,
0.019156592,
-0.0428551324,
0.0739179701,
0.05981813,
-0.0056463876,
0.0028604625,
-0.0015785355,
0.0324680433,
-0.0088169295,
0.013280862,
-0.0500686951,
0.0120350812,
-0.0154102603,
0.0708979368,
-0.0364625268,
0.0068193446,
0.0164490547,
0.0628144518,
0.0001739057,
-0.0546042509,
-0.035882581,
-0.0100391032,
0.0563714951,
-0.0422519706,
-0.0123617286,
-0.0524760932,
0.0041292422,
0.0248868763,
-0.0391231701,
0.0597810224,
-0.0194916278,
-0.0005047568,
-0.0087133739,
0.0066229519,
-0.0019674203,
0.0470168479,
-0.0114340717,
0.0862674713,
-0.0146106239,
0.024312187,
0.0257988721,
0.027883878,
0.0635870844,
0.0119370474,
0.0413474701,
0.021771783,
-0.0253284797,
-0.0323899649,
0.0058518914,
-0.0128930211,
-0.0872553214,
0.0219610259,
0.0411982797,
0.0460272022,
0.0260302126,
0.0262694973,
-0.0286496244,
0.0107936775,
-0.0116882334,
-0.0163365044,
0.0000229312,
-0.0644171089,
0.0234391056,
0.0431952551,
-0.0376642793,
-0.0175493099,
0.0533449203,
0.0102621922,
0.043415647,
-0.0559070371,
-0.0284601878,
-0.0568685792,
-0.0782969296,
-0.0139582483,
0.0217426419,
-0.0322989821,
-0.0173593834,
-0.0678129271,
-0.0228138734,
-0.0389841869,
0.0652517974,
-0.0052333642,
-0.0169877559,
0.0329276919,
0.045349516,
0.0020354996,
-0.0059499019,
-0.0767870173,
0.0150459073,
-0.0688456818,
-0.0276984517,
-0.0260849111,
-5.907949017e-33,
-0.0153213367,
-0.0424892269,
0.107573159,
-0.0832683966,
-0.0268086735,
-0.0328776538,
-0.0364859998,
-0.0155800628,
0.0155216083,
0.0002367651,
-0.0239032079,
-0.0033654671,
0.0144131752,
0.0327106006,
-0.0030893951,
-0.0358271971,
0.0426959693,
0.0318973698,
-0.0447428375,
0.0024322988,
0.026072856,
0.0023873835,
0.0051842695,
-0.0419159047,
-0.0516166501,
0.0132895438,
-0.0361045897,
0.0500125475,
-0.0356304832,
0.0590275638,
0.0075496668,
0.0111164898,
0.0036401965,
-0.0345314629,
-0.0144693451,
0.0147008402,
-0.0383664258,
-0.0163327157,
0.0201918259,
-0.0183959194,
-0.0147416145,
-0.0438180678,
0.0234553311,
0.0122362049,
-0.0304455347,
0.0112468572,
0.0050391685,
-0.0181479547,
-0.0084894365,
-0.0201887693,
-0.0589291416,
0.0034577975,
-0.0091207139,
-0.0095224502,
0.0478183255,
0.0530534945,
0.0131045887,
0.0133655099,
-0.0330363102,
0.0493880771,
0.0244510993,
0.0121809198,
0.0692314878,
0.0155097265,
0.0180059914,
0.0180775709,
0.0386276506,
-0.0190440137,
-0.0483689457,
-0.0026769226,
-0.0219625458,
0.108912982,
-0.0335172117,
0.0439944007,
-0.0050494764,
0.0062020598,
-0.0719957799,
0.0588721521,
-0.0106522767,
0.0635030344,
0.0354385301,
0.0018174514,
-0.0311968345,
-0.0113002192,
-0.0481218249,
0.0156161441,
-0.0132268947,
-0.0148548149,
0.034772139,
0.0271943118,
0.0000389812,
-0.0112246834,
0.0282059889,
-0.0481831059,
-0.0237762555,
0.0252229273,
-0.0620636158,
0.0008061866,
-0.0232291035,
0.0437639318,
-0.0199042335,
-0.0309854783,
0.0477036163,
-0.0019232829,
-0.0102992635,
0.0248967111,
-0.0260160193,
0.0427772254,
-0.0358904079,
0.0192371849,
-0.0425477847,
0.0497410186,
-0.0148242461,
-0.0515668318,
0.0124656651,
-0.0200834461,
-0.0152574405,
-0.0175775308,
0.0233049151,
-0.0109355832,
0.0017281155,
-0.04033079,
0.0020219958,
0.0195905957,
0.0007575021,
0.0400306769,
-0.0133521175,
0.0172632895,
0.052402243,
-0.0094856909,
-0.0194629673,
0.038540028,
2.835e-7,
-0.0139379604,
0.0316925235,
0.0091381436,
0.0496622734,
-0.0247284248,
0.0386468284,
-0.0078998003,
-0.0033078138,
0.0339998752,
0.0144332638,
0.0555887818,
0.0203665104,
0.0231683385,
0.0250649285,
-0.0883104131,
0.0185570866,
-0.0478022881,
-0.0206533466,
-0.0559258573,
-0.0203529336,
0.054187201,
0.0597848035,
-0.0052947928,
-0.0209431089,
0.0292843003,
-0.0022719556,
0.0331513472,
-0.0229545292,
-0.0114696342,
0.0483483486,
0.0624056309,
-0.0161115602,
-0.0119191958,
-0.0264174286,
-0.0114253871,
0.0268542338,
-0.020634871,
0.0439668559,
0.0311543066,
-0.0474175774,
-0.0065995166,
-0.0553131811,
0.0056915032,
-0.0201980732,
0.0672474578,
-0.0141751459,
-0.0366252214,
-0.0120278643,
-0.0084572071,
-0.0330680646,
-0.0334133133,
-0.0196605232,
0.0085819084,
-0.0050361119,
-0.0071078753,
-0.0088303816,
0.0194401257,
-0.05025585,
0.0167528316,
0.0450050943,
-0.0547802038,
-0.0313316435,
-0.0375468209,
0.051342193,
-0.0158081241,
-0.0543553457,
-0.0006214271,
2.362559056e-34,
0.0030112383,
0.0270943902,
-0.0233205762,
0.0115966406,
0.0633054897,
0.0246647131,
-0.0092334086,
0.0304737594,
0.0152458576,
-0.0744247586,
-0.0240697023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12428v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12428v1 | PSLM: Parallel Generation of Text and Speech with LLMs for Low-Latency Spoken Dialogue Systems | 2024-06-18T09:23:54 | 2024-06-18T09:23:54 | Kentaro Mitsui, Koh Mitsuda, Toshiaki Wakatsuki, Yukiya Hono, Kei Sawada | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Multimodal language models that process both text and speech have a potential
for applications in spoken dialogue systems. However, current models face two
major challenges in response generation latency: (1) generating a spoken
response requires the prior generation of a written response, and (2) speech
sequences are significantly longer than text sequences. This study addresses
these issues by extending the input and output sequences of the language model
to support the parallel generation of text and speech. Our experiments on
spoken question answering tasks demonstrate that our approach improves latency
while maintaining the quality of response content. Additionally, we show that
latency can be further reduced by generating speech in multiple sequences. Demo
samples are available at https://rinnakk.github.io/research/publications/PSLM. | [
0.0150962491,
0.0334079973,
-0.0064008264,
0.0202592555,
-0.0447302312,
-0.0182446074,
0.0270013381,
0.0170368012,
-0.019101182,
-0.0408332534,
-0.0136074768,
-0.0658737794,
0.0241463427,
0.0202840287,
0.0389974453,
-0.064218916,
0.0413312837,
-0.0521864668,
-0.0145177627,
-0.0282484014,
0.0041000382,
0.006702058,
-0.0474600457,
0.0189928077,
-0.001135792,
-0.0256065708,
-0.0518474989,
0.0164613146,
0.0068110954,
-0.023207726,
-0.0167060867,
0.0123314979,
-0.0029878935,
0.0141293807,
0.0000016463,
-0.0301928427,
0.0456178784,
-0.0070794853,
0.0068716728,
0.0052721375,
0.0070315469,
0.0406711027,
-0.003168463,
0.0459881648,
-0.0186090171,
-0.0064630914,
0.0340586938,
0.0170309469,
0.0580013618,
0.0569057912,
-0.0069672456,
0.0020141469,
0.0327830315,
-0.0140258279,
0.0112810908,
-0.0132058468,
-0.0374341495,
-0.0087944716,
0.0433909185,
0.0250749011,
-0.005546147,
0.0705295801,
0.0248543005,
-0.0201752465,
-0.0325929597,
0.0373285376,
0.02734253,
-0.021338094,
-0.0471787862,
0.0843890235,
0.0016430685,
0.0008318449,
0.012121778,
-0.0039143292,
0.0004118481,
-0.0259719342,
-0.0434473678,
0.0464464799,
-0.0267533492,
0.015297561,
-0.0479672998,
-0.0181064978,
-0.0137365116,
-0.0131090833,
0.0356713049,
0.0375758596,
0.0281731803,
-0.021641897,
-0.0357644707,
-0.0214773286,
0.0057557411,
-0.0649790019,
0.0034030159,
0.0736702755,
-0.0741467401,
0.0104449056,
-0.0534776896,
-0.0273625217,
0.0138861286,
-0.0350893065,
0.0463532582,
0.0427821726,
-0.0192208849,
0.0047514434,
-0.0321700945,
0.06479875,
-0.0036035124,
-0.0050505647,
-0.0227805525,
-0.0118530188,
-0.0108054532,
-0.0157077722,
-0.0336162001,
0.0305150636,
-0.0941113308,
-0.0587657392,
0.0058178059,
0.0618904084,
0.0221075751,
-0.0204896405,
0.0224814266,
0.0167976022,
0.0013861662,
-0.0099422606,
-0.0362458266,
0.0484455898,
0.0014173042,
0.0376141965,
0.0235571079,
-0.0513240434,
-0.016902294,
0.0385529101,
0.0134459408,
-0.0044599436,
-0.0289322119,
0.0866789818,
-0.0487008579,
-0.0154156312,
-0.0360286795,
-0.029619325,
-0.019436188,
-0.0581764467,
0.0183281377,
-0.0593224876,
0.0106295366,
0.0070240865,
-0.0290843546,
0.0296570193,
0.0162678231,
0.037630368,
0.018672267,
0.0417206436,
-0.0358183347,
0.0403119549,
0.0676810816,
0.0199488848,
0.0318185538,
0.0300924908,
0.0516741127,
-0.0132997846,
0.0207936931,
-0.0326219983,
-0.0100819981,
0.0586629361,
0.0098289307,
-0.0185630433,
-0.0104875639,
0.0054265694,
-0.0093875015,
0.0321938433,
0.0416069366,
0.0655690506,
-0.0415776446,
-0.0227295328,
0.0781359822,
0.0628584176,
-0.0024966956,
-0.0318941809,
0.0537872165,
0.0295367073,
0.0134737799,
-0.0013811535,
-0.0096552866,
0.064161703,
0.0147715844,
0.0433401614,
0.0756100118,
0.0428081043,
-0.0355553441,
-0.0150986677,
0.0012914276,
-0.0263776518,
-0.0142319258,
0.0179458689,
0.0245093554,
0.0356361754,
-0.083332561,
0.0383388437,
-0.0226154644,
-0.0666732937,
-0.0130371144,
-0.0359592885,
0.0097673712,
0.0849514008,
0.01510855,
0.0323999748,
-0.0256940667,
-0.0065844879,
0.0016694943,
0.08894182,
0.0037281308,
-0.0052492702,
0.0268047135,
-0.0285767615,
-0.0077201473,
0.0330060497,
-0.0335084386,
0.0510877073,
0.0144439014,
0.0026887089,
0.0105713559,
0.0256723519,
0.0624936335,
0.0084958756,
-0.035207428,
0.0091085481,
0.0013038245,
-0.0269343145,
0.0565905795,
0.0084712701,
-0.0193531215,
0.0179425068,
0.0437609553,
-0.0205112826,
-0.0091159325,
0.019992264,
-0.0462097935,
-0.0636826083,
0.0386842415,
-0.0017671257,
0.0278720111,
0.0782908201,
0.0072885356,
-0.0777918547,
0.0110742291,
-0.080614306,
0.0017179843,
-0.0625024289,
0.0042279498,
0.0727767944,
0.0042250594,
-0.0412733071,
0.0004978049,
-0.029380098,
0.0325614512,
0.0568812378,
0.0669845864,
0.0076430799,
-0.0898359343,
-0.0101880599,
0.0371741168,
-0.0183506031,
0.0171122365,
0.0049635721,
0.0073401364,
-0.019477956,
-0.0100981127,
-0.0885544345,
0.00334946,
0.0019857823,
-0.010036733,
0.0130126402,
0.016481325,
-0.0036969541,
-0.0305003598,
-0.0608528629,
0.0463151,
0.1004466787,
0.0054810778,
0.0121871727,
0.0081279213,
-0.0276402775,
-0.0356779359,
0.0066538989,
0.0410369374,
0.0411794856,
-0.0356379226,
-0.0117469374,
-0.0606473722,
-0.0246736743,
-0.0424022377,
0.0536196567,
-0.0036813843,
-0.0605380684,
0.0175263882,
-0.0085114008,
0.061245326,
0.000468308,
0.048763942,
-0.0042421892,
0.0080901058,
-0.0210289638,
-0.0346564539,
0.0429202802,
-0.0221707914,
0.0190104693,
-0.0194716901,
-0.0130300932,
-0.0139692398,
0.0611145459,
0.0272100605,
0.0143571049,
-0.0180522539,
-0.0010739418,
0.0500023663,
-0.0435858108,
-0.0118394168,
-0.006583258,
-0.0726302341,
0.0326987021,
-0.0243181679,
-0.0677257478,
0.0061181746,
-0.0789262205,
-0.0179309174,
-0.005288112,
-0.0286002327,
-0.0090795662,
0.0559655353,
0.0245426893,
-0.0032946561,
-0.069668524,
-0.0159087665,
-0.0303114206,
0.0295088962,
-0.0155589683,
-0.0464388058,
0.0349462591,
-0.0266632494,
0.0138835907,
-0.0318931751,
-0.0303974971,
-0.0337283835,
-0.0134015838,
-0.0080343913,
0.0117679499,
0.0037203042,
-0.0221517961,
0.0011866945,
0.0322617292,
0.0069298977,
0.0333610214,
-0.0202379897,
0.0073999031,
-0.040200118,
0.0644411892,
0.0545925051,
0.0527619161,
-0.0104794437,
-0.0033783263,
0.0310849603,
0.0323483497,
0.0548792556,
-0.0060276282,
-0.0398501605,
-0.001529573,
0.029870471,
0.0097059608,
-0.0358272679,
0.0556425117,
0.0358222201,
-0.0488835312,
-0.0150448615,
0.0909538642,
0.0056212838,
0.0095199905,
-0.0111251138,
-0.0141605614,
0.041155383,
0.0196572971,
0.0126616061,
-0.0532862172,
-0.0240161587,
0.006373954,
0.0132851806,
0.0159613751,
0.0156405214,
-0.0388336405,
-0.0988427401,
0.0212765839,
-0.000387791,
-0.0432447642,
-0.0073273852,
-0.0212747399,
-0.0405373275,
0.0642037913,
0.0281159058,
0.0537306592,
0.002671585,
-0.0079567051,
0.0292505119,
-0.0131482985,
-0.0097176591,
0.0078353863,
0.0051431265,
0.0560136624,
0.0470585041,
0.0094979601,
0.0130841536,
-0.0730301514,
0.0457146391,
-0.0063645579,
-0.006922117,
-0.001326538,
0.0001099449,
0.0075050178,
-0.0307413284,
-0.0268896278,
0.0251683202,
-0.0080537759,
-0.0067675216,
0.0033617043,
0.0231442861,
-0.050204657,
-0.0079999827,
-0.0302414931,
0.0601551235,
0.0110620316,
0.0432301909,
0.0065689925,
-0.0662498027,
-0.0582317077,
0.0142195858,
-0.019877281,
-0.0642340705,
-0.0034833523,
-0.0072601889,
0.0253002197,
0.0252464954,
-0.0711235628,
-0.0334654115,
-0.0065836022,
0.0479874574,
-0.0293677244,
0.0293868985,
-0.0185688846,
0.0168940797,
-0.0348178819,
-0.005220111,
0.0059929541,
0.0101163229,
-0.0745547712,
-0.0132736741,
0.0249997918,
-0.0644026771,
-0.022260556,
0.0273371283,
-0.1210484356,
-0.0623548515,
-0.0330657363,
0.0395542197,
0.0176485721,
0.0352097191,
0.0202869233,
-0.041350916,
0.0133189727,
0.0338189006,
-0.0375277922,
0.0461095609,
-0.0023440195,
0.0301270057,
-0.0250535943,
0.0088582588,
-0.0474457219,
0.0239911843,
-0.0134416306,
0.0329130925,
-0.0064725433,
-0.0961555317,
-0.0337037258,
0.0449265018,
0.0417265482,
-0.0116864024,
-0.0069468124,
0.0087848697,
0.0497218147,
-0.0095465407,
0.0334903672,
-0.0720667019,
-0.006334452,
-0.0200307388,
-0.0114058377,
0.0166265164,
-0.035693381,
-0.012981033,
0.0356270596,
0.0006486273,
-0.0055490495,
0.0167064462,
-0.0272054616,
0.0143448636,
0.0039820606,
-0.0106014684,
0.0080407253,
0.0002803224,
-0.0002521857,
-0.0032390568,
0.0648900568,
0.0034953274,
-0.0105040446,
0.036717616,
0.0096698692,
-0.0695380718,
-0.0390590169,
-0.0077504981,
0.0363206342,
0.0442670919,
0.0479674749,
0.0471949317,
0.0081797885,
0.0231132004,
-0.0672579482,
0.0703585595,
-0.0108847171,
-0.0281462669,
0.0624294281,
0.0156690776,
-0.0178712718,
0.0003988676,
0.0688830912,
0.029600516,
0.0107203107,
0.0188098438,
0.0318149216,
-0.0446688496,
-0.0622892007,
-0.0166282672,
0.0274261199,
0.0009451467,
-0.0087216459,
0.0055290344,
-0.0478599034,
0.0368735157,
0.0510827079,
0.0060815457,
-0.0240728315,
0.0437423065,
0.0346228182,
0.0216433536,
-0.0267315134,
-0.0406175815,
-0.011823561,
-0.0218231119,
-0.0264949203,
0.0071262242,
-5.401845434e-33,
-0.0768874511,
-0.0630579218,
0.0857438892,
0.0209813118,
-0.0509893745,
-0.0057407925,
-0.02120848,
0.0231389049,
0.0037728343,
-0.0223769005,
-0.0089951083,
0.0044494062,
-0.0040014945,
0.0608976707,
-0.0397138149,
0.0082080569,
0.0516323932,
-0.0446521193,
0.0173844025,
0.0106845582,
0.0320223421,
0.0255430285,
-0.010149383,
0.0224631149,
-0.0170186982,
-0.0147415819,
0.0132624144,
-0.0057218685,
-0.0090780314,
0.0568605922,
-0.0369537808,
0.0669402033,
0.0112949964,
-0.0330167077,
-0.0453704633,
0.0724129304,
-0.0509647019,
-0.0102432063,
0.0369261205,
0.011006915,
-0.0549462251,
0.0016306455,
0.0193136744,
-0.0095134918,
-0.0064747315,
-0.0170060601,
0.0089962743,
0.0016949307,
-0.0544288792,
-0.0171994511,
-0.0154149523,
0.0016123482,
-0.0053426088,
-0.0213379879,
0.007626507,
0.075191237,
-0.0149389673,
-0.0085571744,
-0.0183887463,
0.0197764244,
-0.0137257902,
0.0344831347,
0.0610110089,
0.0421753898,
0.0125902416,
0.0437155589,
0.0170690659,
-0.0422712304,
-0.0160972569,
0.0102557614,
0.0246933959,
0.0171831977,
0.0474194996,
0.0355161466,
-0.0284892004,
-0.0172014032,
-0.0458879545,
0.0294288881,
-0.0014043009,
-0.0082875118,
0.0345020033,
0.0005094802,
0.022128243,
0.0007442549,
-0.0588868596,
0.0418926887,
-0.0090643996,
-0.0107083507,
0.076443933,
0.0324764885,
0.0320040435,
-0.0405567624,
0.101922296,
-0.0098623456,
-0.0106523233,
-0.0124897771,
-0.0357710719,
0.0360128134,
-0.0193735175,
0.017440863,
-0.0323803425,
0.0052871425,
0.0602121092,
0.0177785847,
-0.0088471072,
0.0052221832,
-0.0367016569,
-0.0008273375,
-0.0797373354,
0.0159520563,
-0.0232925657,
0.0701316446,
0.0103556365,
0.0327170119,
0.0359762833,
-0.0625124127,
-0.0275828317,
0.0677813515,
-0.0723046064,
-0.0647015497,
-0.0055211834,
-0.0575916171,
-0.0075542764,
0.0174249914,
-0.0491804257,
0.0720058829,
-0.0333302058,
0.0197903942,
-0.0033692354,
-0.0404338539,
-0.0064356099,
0.0369797386,
2.283e-7,
-0.0112590464,
-0.0004721233,
0.0324681699,
0.0595481358,
0.0565800928,
-0.0156228673,
0.0077072643,
0.0343003683,
0.0032162725,
-0.0031322353,
-0.0322977789,
-0.0020452931,
0.0491394177,
-0.0003536969,
-0.0810451508,
-0.034995269,
-0.0875469446,
0.0239915457,
-0.0044101654,
0.0063613583,
0.0325840227,
0.0158741623,
-0.0424099043,
-0.0218279734,
0.0081081688,
-0.018221816,
0.0610591322,
-0.020066591,
-0.0225514546,
-0.0255601965,
0.046397984,
-0.0193237141,
0.0023952331,
0.0161001645,
-0.015080451,
-0.0138918459,
0.0181754027,
0.0479833744,
0.0193757303,
-0.1150744185,
0.0099155521,
0.0125518786,
-0.015661912,
-0.0024103331,
0.0632711649,
-0.00121324,
-0.0085464641,
-0.0406278297,
-0.0259450469,
-0.0295976903,
-0.0132708186,
-0.0342539623,
-0.0072232941,
-0.0004098538,
0.0144821005,
-0.0186904036,
0.0335238054,
-0.0678907856,
-0.012805636,
0.0141951973,
-0.0885253027,
-0.0574082732,
-0.0712666661,
0.0002705075,
0.0346010923,
-0.0337750614,
-0.0568614639,
1.606414509e-34,
0.0060105477,
-0.0313764401,
0.0131542003,
0.0495204367,
-0.0259836204,
-0.0358403362,
0.0019774537,
0.004869068,
0.0172246732,
-0.0827022567,
-0.0531222634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12422v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12422v1 | Open-Source Web Service with Morphological Dictionary-Supplemented Deep Learning for Morphosyntactic Analysis of Czech | 2024-06-18T09:14:58 | 2024-06-18T09:14:58 | Milan Straka, Jana Straková | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present an open-source web service for Czech morphosyntactic analysis. The
system combines a deep learning model with rescoring by a high-precision
morphological dictionary at inference time. We show that our hybrid method
surpasses two competitive baselines: While the deep learning model ensures
generalization for out-of-vocabulary words and better disambiguation, an
improvement over an existing morphological analyser MorphoDiTa, at the same
time, the deep learning model benefits from inference-time guidance of a
manually curated morphological dictionary. We achieve 50% error reduction in
lemmatization and 58% error reduction in POS tagging over MorphoDiTa, while
also offering dependency parsing. The model is trained on one of the currently
largest Czech morphosyntactic corpora, the PDT-C 1.0, with the trained models
available at https://hdl.handle.net/11234/1-5293. We provide the tool as a web
service deployed at https://lindat.mff.cuni.cz/services/udpipe/. The source
code is available at GitHub (https://github.com/ufal/udpipe/tree/udpipe-2),
along with a Python client for a simple use. The documentation for the models
can be found at https://ufal.mff.cuni.cz/udpipe/2/models#czech_pdtc1.0_model. | [
-0.0040430343,
0.088388592,
0.0099536274,
0.039643947,
-0.027138548,
0.0142243961,
-0.0345816128,
-0.0335067213,
-0.0625756234,
0.0010100051,
0.0189933013,
-0.0235665757,
0.0207950529,
0.0121502299,
0.0308223609,
-0.0165218282,
0.0391422361,
-0.0364003032,
-0.0400577597,
-0.0191746522,
0.022110451,
0.0266718138,
-0.0435634367,
0.0127793392,
-0.0350826718,
-0.0304770693,
-0.017929649,
0.0316815712,
-0.0026961467,
-0.0347379856,
0.0156321581,
0.0202176515,
-0.0087421276,
0.0678686053,
0.0000020581,
-0.0761525407,
-0.0268338881,
-0.0114553748,
-0.0350718498,
-0.0038652169,
0.0595866889,
-0.0876304209,
-0.0538876541,
-0.0116118919,
0.007638562,
-0.0298870187,
0.0694743469,
-0.0467272922,
-0.000627654,
0.0506487936,
-0.0177495498,
-0.0961847827,
0.0663030148,
0.0173939969,
-0.0899018869,
0.016147526,
0.0124063604,
-0.0264309626,
-0.0376083255,
-0.0256244615,
-0.0046959287,
0.0442782007,
-0.0005897394,
-0.0325121544,
-0.0268617198,
-0.002672012,
-0.0171633624,
-0.0508012287,
0.0265149102,
0.0416093208,
-0.0339763686,
-0.021373786,
0.0210440811,
0.0054613757,
-0.0071442476,
-0.0088418927,
-0.0348507203,
0.0393422917,
0.0016070638,
0.0285243094,
0.064276509,
-0.0168249514,
0.0014951798,
0.0064681224,
-0.0185122099,
0.0399805307,
0.0449297428,
-0.0008375935,
0.0276420601,
0.0034299821,
0.0394708849,
-0.0186626147,
0.0329466164,
0.0182471238,
-0.0374479294,
0.0223785434,
0.0065241181,
-0.0677458346,
0.0488895997,
-0.0240177605,
0.0100936927,
-0.0101105422,
-0.047644373,
0.0164002515,
-0.0358110815,
-0.0088473875,
0.0109032048,
0.0045826002,
-0.0221147109,
-0.0390552618,
-0.0125782341,
0.0005752699,
-0.0540726259,
0.0038674311,
-0.0010126815,
0.0402374156,
-0.042577453,
0.0019821369,
0.0354721472,
0.0208329838,
0.0024197791,
0.026905369,
-0.0546076447,
0.0242550652,
-0.025645759,
0.0783441141,
-0.0314450711,
-0.0096532907,
-0.0539325774,
-0.0603926815,
0.0049270932,
0.0187640376,
0.0091805095,
-0.0356564038,
0.0297236666,
0.05084344,
-0.0078328857,
-0.0162887424,
0.0076445355,
-0.0251795631,
-0.0288646687,
-0.0271664895,
0.0078647649,
-0.0763158426,
-0.0176499821,
0.0014248496,
-0.0009124776,
-0.0150533114,
-0.0101202801,
0.0079811458,
-0.0318496823,
0.0733683929,
-0.0390013792,
-0.0243211295,
0.0123937391,
-0.0391519777,
0.0620864071,
0.0386326872,
0.0053526047,
0.0062824804,
0.0174838416,
0.0079298085,
-0.0135568278,
0.0373708159,
-0.0282129906,
-0.0493535735,
-0.0271169785,
-0.0000610078,
-0.0381786861,
0.0334518142,
0.0689748898,
0.0861029923,
0.0115726236,
-0.0229872596,
0.0179638509,
0.0532572903,
0.0386397876,
0.0168770012,
0.0275159366,
0.0440940149,
0.0064828312,
-0.0186036229,
-0.0043844837,
-0.0418265052,
0.0123661421,
0.0383906178,
-0.0967395455,
0.0610904694,
0.0165693741,
-0.0180099364,
-0.0198154133,
-0.0466806777,
-0.0036756727,
-0.0326909572,
0.0851053819,
-0.0113110328,
-0.0274510104,
0.0312040541,
0.0518903658,
-0.0131322797,
0.0000457251,
-0.0124581484,
0.0031570422,
0.0437886938,
0.0232066326,
-0.0525166728,
-0.0496399961,
0.0003793639,
-0.0294239037,
0.0237428024,
0.0069403001,
-0.0315984488,
0.0050881593,
-0.0619373508,
0.029125886,
0.0269065574,
0.0254813544,
0.017107144,
-0.0444430597,
0.0446127392,
0.0099065509,
0.0196936149,
0.0095699988,
0.0239173304,
0.0024977792,
0.0055321157,
-0.0473755859,
0.017096892,
-0.0144666135,
0.0377209336,
-0.0129721602,
0.0355266295,
0.0324072503,
-0.0219618212,
0.0501603633,
0.0107990429,
-0.0363476761,
-0.0323596559,
0.0737929493,
-0.0323783718,
-0.009080817,
-0.0189275667,
0.0064546047,
-0.0393381044,
0.065724194,
-0.0542585291,
0.0134262592,
-0.0459095836,
0.0279321987,
0.0181767214,
0.0695349947,
-0.0198044069,
0.0398314856,
0.0242721904,
0.0110034272,
0.0318967514,
-0.0050395918,
0.0042049303,
0.0030859825,
-0.0190710966,
0.0254581012,
-0.0335288979,
-0.044702407,
-0.0309170391,
0.0015772538,
-0.0199551694,
0.0135964574,
-0.0936902761,
0.0090844333,
-0.0214067567,
0.0649762526,
-0.0000987001,
0.0372475646,
0.0115929674,
-0.0261415076,
-0.0099362377,
0.0029497999,
-0.0000996901,
-0.0118429363,
0.0345526598,
-0.0139706377,
-0.0050573396,
-0.041349709,
-0.0110182641,
-0.0203247499,
0.0032303804,
-0.0159088317,
-0.0557817295,
-0.0122799072,
0.0009627174,
-0.0344220996,
0.0590596534,
0.0126230828,
-0.0835420415,
0.0208207015,
-0.0194314811,
0.0974901095,
0.017614264,
-0.0393864512,
-0.0097014718,
0.0255706348,
-0.0494988151,
-0.0271498933,
-0.0257544834,
-0.0105730668,
0.0112187332,
-0.0470391512,
-0.0023309155,
-0.0281694308,
0.0830624774,
-0.0542779714,
-0.0181532074,
0.0186673291,
-0.0143751763,
-0.0491441153,
0.0210917871,
0.0314706154,
0.0106676668,
-0.0376452357,
0.0196938124,
0.0133395363,
0.0073278267,
0.0795063972,
-0.0296293795,
-0.0386579521,
-0.040831428,
-0.0311374869,
-0.0317126401,
0.0647954643,
0.0142671047,
-0.0151973516,
0.0443651713,
-0.0876937136,
-0.041584637,
0.0084563503,
0.0380221866,
-0.0285106022,
0.0444204621,
-0.0979855657,
0.0221726447,
-0.0431832038,
-0.0176147018,
-0.0060679186,
-0.0395375825,
-0.0150665147,
0.0420237742,
0.0328220949,
-0.0419443958,
0.0778768659,
0.008654872,
-0.019682372,
0.0581667162,
0.0056632417,
0.0387685858,
-0.0215516295,
0.022533888,
0.011889888,
0.0240301974,
0.0128582772,
0.0211107489,
0.0226305798,
0.0170076732,
-0.0126015395,
-0.0068346635,
-0.0099765379,
-0.0176024493,
0.0212271437,
-0.0122909769,
-0.0747111365,
-0.0586337522,
0.0025892803,
-0.0389799811,
-0.0255026948,
0.0851500183,
0.0242820568,
-0.0306519885,
-0.0062300093,
-0.0104875565,
0.0273350347,
0.0006237125,
0.0096493354,
-0.0887757465,
-0.0175258424,
0.0341008678,
0.0284764804,
-0.0061576194,
-0.0109778764,
0.0228216406,
-0.1050476953,
-0.0106507428,
-0.0113886651,
0.0021116955,
0.0338684358,
-0.025197858,
-0.019104762,
-0.0360719971,
-0.0239099786,
0.0170027371,
-0.0258679278,
0.011279719,
0.0368449613,
-0.0438494645,
-0.0355367772,
-0.027646834,
-0.0470445044,
0.0105372733,
0.0170449726,
0.0388001502,
-0.042578496,
-0.0192580596,
0.0794645548,
-0.0405548029,
-0.0332184583,
-0.0050663659,
0.0183369126,
0.0484631658,
-0.0449843146,
-0.0132118715,
0.0017746191,
-0.028016353,
-0.0168507826,
-0.0598795861,
0.0316242799,
0.0170374382,
0.0249508489,
0.000065468,
-0.0197113343,
-0.0165689252,
0.0022336238,
0.0060345433,
0.0293096192,
-0.0598161146,
-0.0051539107,
-0.0035752845,
-0.0010058987,
-0.0153909139,
0.030587744,
-0.0304810964,
-0.0800143033,
-0.0877903327,
-0.0500494428,
0.0524751991,
0.0061437604,
-0.0079267593,
0.0077366834,
-0.0163992345,
-0.0005274932,
-0.0818505585,
0.0567423403,
0.0134443492,
0.0378147326,
-0.0661622882,
-0.0332814716,
0.1026994064,
0.0321904011,
-0.0229378156,
0.032619115,
-0.0188879669,
-0.0424582437,
0.0430170521,
0.0150830206,
0.0177482404,
0.0052278684,
-0.0663420334,
-0.0498531163,
0.0149807585,
0.0234090686,
-0.0217383374,
-0.0026142511,
0.0400302261,
-0.0168528073,
0.01456019,
0.0136776343,
0.0213811323,
0.0160453282,
-0.0615674034,
-0.0028196324,
-0.020623317,
-0.0408000983,
0.0028338004,
0.0011016933,
0.0340238772,
-0.0024717366,
0.0317802764,
-0.0121940076,
0.0162562206,
0.0048880167,
-0.0127625614,
0.0153190885,
0.0200097151,
0.0249851644,
-0.014217779,
-0.0397306681,
0.0370882004,
-0.010717894,
-0.0312263276,
0.0188859403,
0.0119609265,
0.0906518251,
0.0212564189,
0.0071852864,
0.0094360085,
-0.0084188776,
0.0352619998,
-0.0147667136,
0.0345687419,
-0.0609570555,
-0.0431237146,
-0.0511807054,
-0.0275874808,
-0.0277640428,
0.0231086928,
0.0283928234,
0.0306261554,
-0.0222592466,
0.0189399943,
0.0774425119,
-0.0132789984,
0.0960292816,
-0.0042627216,
0.0147996694,
-0.0042607603,
0.0241788439,
-0.03343907,
-0.0107281031,
0.0207944326,
0.0092624715,
-0.0293715652,
-0.0263617132,
0.0213354751,
0.0423336662,
0.0325791053,
-0.0108580859,
0.0028947981,
-0.0209459532,
-0.0060934173,
-0.0317649432,
0.0141822509,
-0.0320227221,
-0.0211809501,
-0.0368137844,
-0.0812650993,
-0.0164649636,
0.0455419943,
0.0019093193,
0.0093137948,
0.0425240807,
0.0062195682,
0.0028470596,
-0.0206097551,
-0.0311392713,
0.0470831357,
0.0382150114,
-0.0347043313,
0.0024442545,
-5.871937012e-33,
-0.0063531892,
0.0152791711,
-0.0297404621,
-0.0615096651,
-0.0177971199,
-0.0274852645,
-0.0158379041,
-0.0021145246,
-0.0213976223,
0.0269973632,
-0.0040878397,
0.0148548521,
0.0447283164,
0.0098380717,
0.0195737518,
0.0035175628,
0.024819646,
-0.0175009593,
0.0418887697,
-0.0126549182,
0.0333574787,
0.0529372133,
0.1484920233,
-0.015634438,
-0.0016918827,
-0.0039883042,
-0.0104021989,
0.0181919113,
0.0132888919,
0.0413171612,
-0.0191700719,
0.0250687655,
-0.0014126801,
-0.0015991738,
-0.0039487616,
-0.0085684611,
-0.1069704965,
-0.0096433023,
0.0141334701,
0.060419824,
-0.0419034623,
-0.0076048439,
0.0629190281,
0.0124854427,
0.0308991559,
0.0605868213,
0.0393934138,
-0.0278965645,
0.0078625856,
-0.0099161752,
-0.0758991688,
0.0295255836,
0.0019754185,
-0.0142033827,
0.078456223,
-0.0347969048,
0.0325846188,
-0.046365045,
0.0141257774,
-0.0135954721,
0.0440464206,
0.0738304332,
0.0444886759,
-0.0000856803,
-0.038136974,
0.0246916171,
0.0359557271,
-0.0896036476,
0.0594910309,
0.044762779,
0.0620669238,
0.0423220582,
0.0110202422,
0.031470485,
0.0285520889,
-0.0255816542,
-0.0880915821,
-0.014525325,
0.0675143898,
0.0470960476,
-0.0644799992,
-0.0045583993,
-0.0118537042,
-0.0222569034,
0.0096516442,
-0.027397519,
-0.0125643201,
0.0026289269,
0.0042241304,
-0.033785291,
-0.0349862538,
0.0639202297,
0.0162461493,
-0.0140209887,
-0.050792437,
-0.0428016484,
0.0063605164,
0.05954016,
-0.042783346,
0.0485884771,
-0.0127839437,
-0.0327295288,
-0.006026844,
0.0403614864,
0.0379736461,
0.022318013,
-0.0064973491,
0.0120632956,
-0.0388618149,
0.0232385006,
-0.0356975868,
0.0064327423,
-0.0099924579,
0.1065018922,
0.0273279585,
-0.0059735826,
-0.0039885412,
0.006949394,
0.069932662,
0.0078950264,
-0.0381998569,
-0.0280244611,
0.0175202414,
0.0237961952,
-0.035921853,
0.0312529355,
0.009775606,
0.0414445885,
0.0069759907,
0.0111287246,
0.0208494104,
0.0119207669,
2.87e-7,
0.0549000911,
0.0687411353,
0.0327771865,
0.0052294233,
0.0339218602,
-0.0287654158,
-0.0174779687,
-0.0067994907,
-0.059033107,
-0.0118401013,
-0.0035772463,
-0.0261824969,
0.0260217004,
0.0545197353,
-0.1075261757,
-0.0278846752,
-0.0335074551,
0.0127961412,
-0.0529248677,
0.0269831941,
0.0377964713,
0.1163066998,
0.0003327165,
-0.0436278358,
-0.0226309393,
0.0093922494,
0.0078586219,
0.0361401476,
-0.00446006,
0.0278498884,
0.0309874192,
0.0122348564,
-0.0041064676,
0.0196805596,
0.0051177847,
0.0207506716,
0.0068617188,
0.0170280263,
-0.0417684689,
-0.0176528376,
0.0472913459,
-0.0533840209,
0.0026965898,
-0.0261240974,
0.0723531395,
0.0078602089,
0.0098635321,
-0.0335500836,
-0.0231983513,
0.0251938887,
0.005902953,
-0.0078314068,
-0.0235597286,
0.0412859507,
0.0220786538,
-0.0466382913,
-0.0610226914,
-0.0952036753,
-0.0164793655,
0.0211465638,
0.0016523984,
-0.0288265739,
0.0098671038,
-0.0142807253,
-0.0149549553,
-0.0084170848,
-0.023966454,
2.571926768e-34,
-0.0089864172,
0.0026885748,
0.013636698,
0.0338597149,
-0.0259188525,
0.0017610129,
0.0439667553,
0.0459920466,
-0.023855418,
-0.0221128929,
-0.0231682658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12420v1 | MMUTF: Multimodal Multimedia Event Argument Extraction with Unified Template Filling | 2024-06-18T09:14:17 | 2024-06-18T09:14:17 | Philipp Seeberger, Dominik Wagner, Korbinian Riedhammer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the advancement of multimedia technologies, news documents and
user-generated content are often represented as multiple modalities, making
Multimedia Event Extraction (MEE) an increasingly important challenge. However,
recent MEE methods employ weak alignment strategies and data augmentation with
simple classification models, which ignore the capabilities of natural
language-formulated event templates for the challenging Event Argument
Extraction (EAE) task. In this work, we focus on EAE and address this issue by
introducing a unified template filling model that connects the textual and
visual modalities via textual prompts. This approach enables the exploitation
of cross-ontology transfer and the incorporation of event-specific semantics.
Experiments on the M2E2 benchmark demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach. Our system surpasses the current SOTA on textual EAE by +7% F1, and
performs generally better than the second-best systems for multimedia EAE. | [
0.0084403343,
0.0263678879,
0.0422964506,
0.0550747663,
-0.0184291136,
0.0196380764,
-0.016895486,
0.0252554957,
-0.0104215741,
-0.1112702638,
0.0023128155,
0.0041298438,
-0.0676676854,
0.0457012504,
-0.0070800893,
-0.0903669447,
0.0404068492,
-0.0088648014,
-0.0051527796,
0.0461376086,
0.0165631622,
0.044322852,
-0.0365402773,
0.0154687176,
-0.0641002804,
-0.0073003918,
-0.0145626804,
0.0248438437,
0.0447157733,
-0.0229323488,
-0.0517706089,
-0.0005702674,
0.0707634017,
-0.0124313431,
0.0000018516,
-0.0637560859,
-0.021320859,
0.0049730013,
-0.0058280993,
-0.005870658,
0.0272208396,
-0.0203988627,
-0.0107010193,
-0.0304314792,
0.0036372757,
-0.0244280268,
0.0380276479,
0.0757889748,
0.0290055498,
0.0699054152,
-0.0616925806,
-0.0157882068,
0.0387885273,
-0.0042640097,
0.0063243606,
-0.0207489114,
-0.00626403,
-0.0062466711,
0.033739198,
0.0121179847,
-0.0004008604,
0.0338061638,
-0.0125695979,
0.0214918554,
-0.0396502279,
0.0290362351,
-0.0181707852,
0.0094309663,
-0.0520449355,
0.041389849,
0.0233937949,
0.0311253089,
0.0230924208,
-0.0140350973,
-0.0106252572,
0.0791541338,
-0.0476375408,
0.0309644882,
-0.0439098999,
0.0281025097,
0.0522416085,
0.0301019847,
-0.012803779,
-0.001254837,
0.0227305349,
0.0249305405,
0.0453523248,
0.0238300487,
-0.0289837122,
0.0057924786,
-0.0128553305,
-0.0611597672,
0.0228955932,
0.0068896217,
0.0170982517,
0.0163340848,
-0.0446181893,
-0.0014789198,
-0.0215887688,
-0.0330235511,
0.0047208667,
0.023378687,
-0.0520163998,
0.1058304459,
-0.0139785549,
-0.0203383137,
-0.0325797424,
-0.0004365534,
0.0010015479,
-0.0269107688,
-0.0618757792,
0.0290357322,
-0.0211342368,
0.0238697194,
-0.0414845943,
-0.0423958302,
0.0173973441,
0.0229562763,
0.005196468,
0.0070177075,
-0.0097630164,
-0.0242290497,
-0.0350374132,
-0.0078695593,
-0.0361393765,
0.028426785,
-0.0289179701,
0.0102617536,
0.0068577826,
-0.0410708226,
-0.0028787397,
0.0389869064,
0.0405974351,
-0.0434955247,
-0.0124386661,
0.0530288368,
-0.0644906238,
-0.0150964642,
-0.0509003103,
-0.0536662266,
-0.0315919295,
0.0149785075,
0.0151486006,
-0.0749227181,
0.0562765524,
0.000093857,
0.003837591,
0.0026267003,
0.0028326288,
-0.0160733256,
-0.0598990247,
0.0700582936,
0.0107516935,
-0.0132156145,
0.0361647271,
0.007025335,
-0.0162402149,
0.0658705458,
0.0173503626,
0.0578637607,
0.0872475132,
0.0368007459,
-0.0033509394,
0.0274964683,
-0.0245880857,
-0.0004501496,
-0.0132820215,
-0.0122423545,
0.0056900303,
0.0105598206,
0.0617579855,
-0.0111335162,
-0.0467350781,
-0.0192522313,
0.0373908281,
-0.0031537674,
-0.0287106596,
-0.0345475823,
0.057878878,
-0.0146550415,
-0.0164544247,
0.026318118,
-0.0128142312,
0.0299564581,
0.0190471616,
-0.0013595941,
0.0366346724,
0.0053196698,
-0.0391625278,
0.0029091334,
0.0099395495,
-0.0502679534,
-0.0125065129,
-0.0175537895,
0.0252413042,
-0.0161010362,
-0.0375821963,
0.069000259,
0.0174171869,
-0.0165725816,
0.0299476553,
0.0070753405,
0.0204932876,
0.0189779736,
0.0147135863,
-0.0349412337,
-0.056926433,
-0.0004553289,
0.0417648628,
0.0164777283,
0.0113839135,
-0.0167302061,
0.0347593129,
-0.0447449237,
-0.0137401717,
-0.0573585033,
0.0049238526,
0.0241287109,
-0.0236174334,
0.0314310454,
0.0090293065,
0.0155181792,
0.0195679627,
0.0217277911,
0.0606920347,
-0.0487460345,
-0.0430302955,
0.0337979533,
0.0306031462,
0.0117975259,
-0.005645073,
-0.0275162738,
0.0002050648,
-0.0284622554,
-0.0094511742,
0.051347997,
-0.0526711717,
-0.037692558,
0.0131723061,
-0.051651299,
-0.0234861132,
0.0076104817,
-0.0374657251,
-0.0442967229,
-0.0214514565,
0.0186263118,
0.0137563711,
-0.0467775799,
0.0141920699,
0.0705564022,
0.00153957,
0.0053711091,
0.0562657304,
0.040014971,
-0.0382949896,
-0.0116102677,
0.0040552458,
0.0356811509,
-0.0404377952,
-0.0152638173,
0.0321210288,
-0.0127805853,
-0.007574047,
0.037228141,
-0.0428239256,
-0.0625464171,
0.0108929127,
-0.1285298765,
0.0058676763,
0.0005465873,
0.0452666879,
0.0189051162,
0.0219913069,
-0.0128879678,
-0.0091292774,
-0.0450208373,
-0.0839024633,
-0.0290666185,
0.0289003812,
0.0443215705,
0.0378942043,
0.0376370735,
-0.0199752487,
-0.0001836417,
-0.038927149,
0.071493879,
0.0000958755,
-0.0436758138,
-0.0083401632,
-0.0314434692,
-0.0161474161,
0.0478747785,
-0.0048067383,
0.0041872794,
0.0132551445,
-0.0034337924,
0.0268903747,
0.0506834164,
0.0038500228,
0.043363452,
-0.0325070955,
-0.0393667072,
-0.0555965416,
0.0285712816,
-0.0183098316,
0.0127462689,
0.0109784566,
-0.0002982885,
0.0150439925,
0.0247335583,
-0.0066301012,
0.0527572967,
-0.0535377264,
-0.0123002278,
0.046868939,
0.0143477498,
-0.0251335725,
-0.0212299936,
-0.000372414,
0.0131321903,
-0.0336197317,
0.0077750245,
0.0441009998,
-0.0307982732,
-0.0132224718,
0.0008354,
0.0385916904,
-0.0494141392,
0.0724107549,
-0.0082558161,
0.0281923451,
0.0157097578,
-0.0483382605,
-0.0078247366,
-0.0545505024,
0.0758420378,
0.0048528505,
-0.001495241,
-0.0294351969,
0.0128436955,
-0.0251657572,
-0.0147812292,
-0.014862556,
-0.0242366474,
-0.0074250577,
-0.0074610733,
-0.0573182181,
0.0133739682,
-0.019018203,
0.0144266998,
0.001494846,
0.0185224228,
-0.0058993376,
-0.0010702484,
-0.0152615719,
0.1222869381,
0.047487434,
-0.0011295223,
-0.0659016445,
0.0120329708,
0.0029286104,
0.0718474463,
-0.0027711284,
-0.0000514729,
-0.0342150815,
0.0481315143,
0.0020799735,
-0.0217854958,
-0.0254427921,
-0.0043922644,
0.0732835084,
-0.0640154332,
0.0489996299,
0.062109109,
0.0332298614,
0.0078676948,
-0.0319550969,
0.0401626937,
-0.0302708037,
0.0203486476,
0.0147169009,
-0.0630572811,
-0.0589767694,
-0.0250106342,
0.0013842623,
-0.0119103622,
0.0081715602,
0.0052598286,
-0.0545174517,
0.055482734,
-0.0141572701,
0.0259684026,
0.0040302617,
-0.0582643561,
0.0316384695,
-0.0285151694,
-0.033054173,
-0.0265859533,
0.0047847638,
-0.0124477847,
-0.0083514089,
-0.0029024594,
-0.0538564473,
0.0157236513,
-0.0559886843,
0.0046283365,
-0.029717043,
0.0415991731,
-0.0142304879,
-0.0323115662,
-0.0074565592,
-0.0271803439,
0.0042690123,
-0.0083930828,
0.0458013527,
-0.0599339046,
-0.0170929302,
0.011103374,
0.0398063958,
0.0363966487,
-0.059055429,
-0.0242722165,
0.1019929796,
0.0014181407,
0.0367444977,
-0.0095227305,
-0.0277259834,
0.0358280055,
0.049312897,
-0.0143943867,
0.0058608898,
-0.0058214818,
0.0181452595,
-0.0128138708,
-0.0332999937,
0.0195845086,
0.0090360194,
-0.050728064,
-0.0752514601,
-0.082197465,
-0.0322892703,
0.0109156687,
0.0492537729,
-0.0502110869,
-0.006824397,
-0.0004542075,
0.0044175638,
-0.0595409758,
0.0907175019,
-0.0126652699,
-0.0072719436,
-0.0123061724,
0.0115649896,
0.0148496581,
-0.0033155626,
-0.0246961024,
0.0595376715,
-0.0134007204,
-0.0243380386,
-0.0577863269,
0.002320844,
0.0034114996,
0.0602926575,
0.0349819176,
0.0057401285,
0.0232706517,
0.0252245311,
-0.0029295643,
-0.0383338071,
0.0349489972,
-0.0062212069,
-0.0308431555,
-0.0127562443,
-0.0155799482,
0.0249904301,
-0.0212210435,
0.0412174948,
-0.0326510668,
-0.0039623929,
0.0105680507,
-0.0080160582,
0.0591510162,
-0.0232616663,
-0.0413419157,
-0.0297115911,
-0.0054405597,
-0.029558789,
-0.0115701659,
-0.0441819876,
0.0469466783,
-0.038012974,
0.0207399968,
-0.0172877535,
0.0050725746,
-0.0217615645,
0.01681206,
-0.0450511165,
-0.0165821984,
0.009078078,
0.0100853108,
-0.0517318696,
-0.0011774169,
-0.0065312823,
0.0229401793,
0.0171980318,
-0.0022354305,
-0.0713227317,
0.0855696425,
0.0277306139,
0.0056638066,
0.0004020694,
0.0393229686,
-0.011825569,
0.0391333774,
-0.035790924,
0.0071302694,
0.0643150955,
-0.0697557554,
0.0151501354,
-0.0164392777,
-0.0285667386,
0.0307316612,
0.0364287011,
0.0192873161,
-0.0018099766,
0.0612267777,
0.0157802086,
-0.0003420977,
0.0480516255,
0.0183422733,
-0.0703316107,
0.0371784419,
0.0224984977,
-0.0294278115,
-0.0393166617,
-0.0078214034,
0.0837639421,
0.0099719707,
-0.0226194598,
-0.0321449675,
-0.0159329493,
0.0075605097,
0.0479695052,
0.0041615847,
-0.0359685011,
0.0494068712,
0.0430818088,
0.0512097105,
0.0487873033,
-0.0015983887,
-0.0155794481,
-0.0223305114,
0.0066230269,
-0.0042937691,
-0.0120936735,
-6.355099353e-33,
-0.0230766553,
0.0122330952,
0.0061401874,
0.0691920146,
-0.0058572819,
0.0206064023,
-0.0139426505,
-0.0181831755,
0.0369763523,
-0.0041582086,
0.0248674266,
-0.0543545857,
0.0188970994,
-0.0105636539,
-0.0063536749,
-0.0058211461,
0.0108268289,
-0.0046921507,
-0.0470278338,
-0.0024560811,
0.0674782693,
0.0049674315,
0.0476337187,
-0.1188553199,
-0.0055766194,
0.0642938018,
-0.0284671858,
-0.0212687608,
0.0911152959,
0.0763115659,
-0.012276968,
0.0138989501,
0.0131997773,
-0.0553471111,
0.0187359061,
0.02271544,
-0.0824797153,
-0.0255700629,
0.0526877977,
-0.0053640483,
-0.0498065911,
-0.0420131981,
-0.0111970911,
-0.0096929586,
0.0462517962,
-0.0306673329,
0.0269995369,
0.0089179203,
0.0175891928,
-0.0606484078,
-0.0827437937,
0.0448011868,
-0.015326011,
-0.0296039209,
0.0211466923,
-0.0220490936,
0.0643355176,
0.0263191927,
-0.0376681462,
0.0065004365,
-0.0715494826,
-0.0070058038,
0.0500601679,
-0.0219680779,
-0.0469170175,
0.0426364541,
-0.0412125699,
-0.0400681682,
-0.0204471964,
0.0399791673,
-0.0125764236,
0.0942874253,
-0.0055891466,
0.0459723808,
0.021003399,
0.0346886106,
-0.0423225798,
0.0426960923,
0.0005486562,
0.0399103127,
-0.0301337559,
0.0334329568,
-0.0243986621,
0.0275494754,
-0.0182150956,
0.0019173926,
-0.0293684267,
-0.0304050446,
0.0058762366,
0.0111503517,
-0.0041104066,
0.0914262682,
0.0674311742,
0.0315026827,
-0.0081621185,
-0.0232251883,
-0.0113610821,
0.0607657954,
-0.0227674711,
0.0069555286,
-0.0101944795,
-0.0428421423,
0.0700489432,
-0.0182954911,
0.0400672927,
0.0017393051,
0.0277980138,
0.0336838178,
-0.041145809,
0.0078756381,
0.0022743656,
-0.0248666182,
-0.0494231135,
0.003690283,
0.0403467901,
-0.0094489604,
-0.0447948575,
0.020104371,
0.0141203078,
0.0043860078,
-0.0213537514,
-0.0849577188,
-0.0128562003,
0.0264591277,
0.0097191008,
0.0349033028,
0.0036072386,
-0.0351825692,
-0.0079465928,
-0.0169365052,
-0.0114158513,
0.0396982394,
2.66e-7,
0.0312250443,
0.0220612101,
0.0413849652,
0.0144259194,
0.0010141502,
0.0349049866,
-0.0014218175,
0.0551448278,
0.0106866034,
-0.0245578792,
0.0103337793,
0.0196638275,
0.0220768321,
0.0230230484,
-0.0321167037,
-0.0117013818,
-0.0184625033,
-0.0155508686,
-0.0776946917,
0.0174672492,
0.1138035432,
0.0523977429,
0.0195618086,
-0.002401324,
0.0104317619,
-0.0295472387,
0.0722363964,
-0.0144326827,
-0.072702229,
0.0067173783,
0.0209130272,
0.0104739303,
-0.0397531204,
0.0382556021,
-0.0135247689,
-0.0103267655,
0.0318106376,
0.0352169387,
-0.0199777484,
-0.0135900714,
-0.0512371249,
0.0009536631,
-0.00627437,
-0.0481084213,
0.0747200251,
-0.0251634028,
-0.0160856638,
-0.0487507284,
-0.0859981924,
0.0552116595,
-0.0369182602,
-0.0018152188,
-0.0497463495,
0.0424393937,
0.0418018959,
0.0054667103,
-0.0495683253,
-0.1204749569,
0.0170627665,
0.018962834,
-0.0005771714,
-0.0136590041,
-0.010075218,
-0.0564533211,
0.0373035595,
-0.072632134,
-0.0637817979,
2.257690266e-34,
-0.0091522029,
0.0314858444,
-0.0086320899,
-0.0049905437,
0.043347612,
0.013588638,
-0.0401881188,
0.0050542168,
-0.0225697123,
-0.0174582209,
-0.010566324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12419v1 | AI-Assisted Human Evaluation of Machine Translation | 2024-06-18T09:12:11 | 2024-06-18T09:12:11 | Vilém Zouhar, Tom Kocmi, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annually, research teams spend large amounts of money to evaluate the quality
of machine translation systems (WMT, inter alia). This is expensive because it
requires detailed human labor. The recently proposed annotation protocol, Error
Span Annotation (ESA), has annotators marking erroneous parts of the
translation. In our work, we help the annotators by pre-filling the span
annotations with automatic quality estimation. With AI assistance, we obtain
more detailed annotations while cutting down the time per span annotation by
half (71s/error span $\rightarrow$ 31s/error span). The biggest advantage of
ESA$^\mathrm{AI}$ protocol is an accurate priming of annotators (pre-filled
error spans) before they assign the final score as opposed to starting from
scratch. In addition, the annotation budget can be reduced by up to 24% with
filtering of examples that the AI deems to be very likely to be correct. | [
0.0299345572,
-0.0078570805,
-0.009787295,
0.0362739637,
-0.0059410171,
0.0193325318,
0.0119864019,
-0.0090653831,
-0.0235318299,
-0.026520893,
0.001586199,
-0.0079198601,
0.0376801863,
-0.0140861366,
0.0429478399,
-0.0632465929,
0.0246456116,
-0.0013623316,
0.0136912465,
0.021010574,
0.0191274062,
-0.0061629727,
-0.0239173174,
0.0488884002,
-0.031324774,
0.0115971239,
0.0044331714,
0.017771082,
0.0601508878,
-0.0556751788,
-0.0120753134,
0.0620659851,
-0.0356701091,
0.0732721835,
0.0000018775,
-0.0492063016,
-0.0336089469,
0.049086228,
-0.0020760477,
0.0416241251,
0.0117643317,
-0.0218632463,
-0.0352304578,
-0.0023684422,
-0.0283566937,
-0.0004332738,
0.0671952069,
-0.0156088108,
0.1059287637,
0.034628205,
-0.0230424423,
0.0223821793,
-0.0073467125,
-0.0146030951,
0.002636912,
-0.0747859851,
-0.024044428,
0.0067395167,
-0.0097579146,
0.0034024578,
0.0065708375,
0.0382768251,
0.0180080477,
-0.0392197669,
0.005234377,
-0.0207381099,
-0.0718370453,
-0.049255304,
-0.0117197689,
0.0488062724,
0.013142067,
-0.0063768723,
-0.0237758048,
-0.0106566865,
-0.0037093575,
-0.0353847332,
-0.0099352952,
0.0140932081,
0.000989828,
-0.0101536009,
0.0104128756,
0.0500726588,
0.0073490897,
-0.0010153531,
-0.0279167034,
0.030681273,
0.0029374096,
-0.0376448147,
-0.013071632,
0.0596237034,
-0.0157012064,
-0.0305461176,
0.0651812851,
-0.0118216462,
0.0021255058,
-0.009964074,
-0.0475094765,
-0.078028366,
0.0275072064,
-0.040238142,
0.0082781566,
0.041913271,
-0.0342154913,
0.0336279385,
-0.0141965505,
0.0601110607,
0.0161527302,
0.0005261637,
-0.0410707369,
0.0014391034,
-0.0048923823,
0.0404905789,
-0.0486338586,
-0.0238448791,
-0.0254360586,
0.0349566527,
-0.0677390099,
-0.0038799555,
-0.025848968,
0.0618086271,
-0.0039245696,
-0.0357872695,
-0.0313358605,
-0.0089095738,
-0.0083248513,
0.0171638802,
-0.0289869457,
-0.0084799612,
0.0131771695,
-0.0687891096,
-0.0197275765,
0.0294750594,
0.002526256,
-0.0144070089,
0.0037082853,
0.0469751433,
0.0197960045,
-0.0278525446,
0.0074919621,
-0.0232287161,
-0.016274808,
-0.027298728,
-0.0225208346,
-0.0627000332,
0.0346867628,
0.0031612725,
0.009846299,
-0.0029582267,
0.0234088525,
0.0041940976,
0.0108389482,
0.0644448102,
-0.0425611809,
-0.0208405964,
0.0185032487,
-0.0099236136,
-0.0247776378,
0.0335490666,
0.0727963746,
0.025643941,
0.0447523966,
0.0276777577,
0.0215527359,
0.0564316623,
-0.0014064834,
0.0013028793,
0.0168678891,
-0.0211299602,
-0.026653368,
0.0237832684,
0.0186440535,
0.068636097,
-0.0220867526,
0.0363406539,
0.028679831,
0.0541838929,
-0.0226641968,
0.0556391813,
0.0586856231,
-0.0006966679,
0.0421046391,
0.000185251,
-0.0279065277,
0.0220264979,
-0.0179273356,
-0.0156195424,
0.0573519878,
0.0083614821,
0.0142721618,
-0.0832072571,
-0.0230847783,
-0.0180297531,
0.0171367563,
-0.0445572548,
0.0396858826,
0.0194748882,
-0.0277459137,
0.0051872996,
-0.0091843065,
-0.0611733757,
0.0050228415,
-0.0208503287,
-0.0192027912,
0.0900479108,
0.0585770793,
-0.0296246801,
-0.0043885158,
-0.0131118884,
0.0021436946,
0.0387854353,
0.0851630867,
-0.0076745721,
-0.0330850817,
-0.0380437449,
-0.0120798564,
0.0528883152,
0.0108249905,
0.0136433002,
-0.0060575972,
0.0108791776,
0.0103630582,
-0.0300121922,
-0.1279696822,
0.0309879947,
0.0400518067,
-0.0181799475,
0.0083795413,
0.0132360766,
0.0577896312,
0.071145162,
-0.0323544815,
0.0081872074,
0.0099446215,
-0.0202315561,
-0.0332592651,
0.0320034064,
-0.000296475,
-0.0101552336,
0.0334068052,
-0.0827597231,
-0.0419989713,
0.0048711319,
-0.0399300642,
-0.0340203904,
-0.0558441393,
-0.071528852,
-0.0286657605,
-0.0414728783,
0.0476032421,
-0.0013232321,
-0.015793886,
-0.0472515821,
0.0079674516,
-0.0012044378,
0.0164065603,
-0.010073334,
-0.0138521269,
0.0405038297,
-0.0314987339,
-0.0716963187,
0.0166749433,
0.0327711813,
0.027940467,
0.0338989384,
0.0059750951,
-0.0275931656,
0.0020261018,
-0.0687538609,
-0.0120963184,
-0.0116069671,
0.0447219238,
0.0193329807,
-0.0183579661,
0.0060660308,
-0.0031934595,
0.006171687,
-0.0094434777,
0.0022061514,
-0.0101672355,
0.0559140854,
0.0131621724,
0.023204688,
-0.0535517,
0.0095374268,
-0.0212683436,
0.0204646271,
0.089170821,
-0.0403557085,
-0.0988822654,
0.0201104414,
-0.0262504052,
0.0059681376,
0.0475870147,
-0.0738777518,
0.0122382501,
0.0064862254,
-0.045886863,
0.0333248712,
-0.0095113385,
0.0223914962,
0.045825135,
0.0267636012,
-0.0168391708,
0.0081616146,
0.0070022396,
-0.0077727935,
0.01610405,
-0.0438088849,
0.0190571435,
0.0164808985,
-0.0093240151,
0.0051219305,
-0.0424794219,
-0.0117279598,
-0.0474903658,
-0.0227275714,
0.0171320755,
-0.0185239781,
-0.0063992478,
0.072488524,
-0.0072329524,
-0.0476099998,
0.0822477043,
-0.0516336076,
-0.0224473998,
-0.0578093939,
0.0559115745,
0.00393546,
0.0191571917,
-0.026832927,
0.0165082179,
-0.0439583026,
0.0036083558,
-0.0007643775,
0.0380801857,
0.0553324036,
-0.0447164811,
0.0061803567,
-0.0832237229,
-0.0005951439,
-0.0181299429,
-0.0036302123,
-0.0253778435,
0.009319623,
-0.0378354415,
-0.0225386247,
0.0133809112,
-0.0312664695,
-0.0182369929,
0.0083583286,
0.0353896022,
0.0635605156,
-0.0034040704,
-0.0034769569,
-0.0023581656,
-0.0049290331,
-0.0476699434,
0.0163935255,
0.0468118042,
-0.0403474085,
0.022628922,
0.0287606865,
-0.0189069938,
0.0254638921,
-0.0185530372,
-0.0188055355,
0.0450461283,
-0.0140028577,
-0.0382147655,
0.0026263071,
0.0484417416,
-0.0645450801,
-0.0066953567,
0.1159306467,
0.0433662795,
-0.0507108048,
-0.0145542305,
-0.0137398224,
-0.0018309884,
0.0138072418,
0.0240101945,
-0.0980404168,
0.0088134278,
0.0167804733,
0.0656318292,
0.0054127448,
-0.0002014933,
-0.0008301114,
-0.0918118283,
0.0556821153,
0.0469124801,
-0.0574564449,
-0.0290370788,
-0.0031913968,
-0.0169870816,
-0.0360113829,
0.0093569243,
-0.0104789445,
0.0529766455,
0.0084393257,
0.0392076597,
-0.0358478948,
-0.0739730969,
-0.0202750769,
-0.0583902374,
0.0651147142,
0.1006033346,
0.0493206792,
-0.0113868965,
-0.0328971148,
0.0159318186,
-0.0127901332,
-0.0166661888,
-0.0045189396,
0.0647411644,
0.0189128276,
-0.0240060799,
0.018164726,
-0.0101880934,
-0.0107570756,
0.0047284858,
0.0090503767,
0.0572729632,
-0.0120637799,
0.049681142,
0.0201182049,
-0.0117338859,
-0.0039021845,
0.0382587798,
0.0231194142,
-0.0409110375,
-0.0131501714,
-0.0497993417,
-0.0162975099,
-0.1055056974,
-0.0212268755,
0.0217421781,
-0.0616390072,
-0.067138806,
-0.1091984138,
-0.0792746469,
0.0250744708,
0.0466507934,
0.0162495393,
-0.0229822546,
0.0145841641,
0.0165171232,
-0.0087104216,
-0.0075791241,
-0.0098384237,
0.0213257857,
-0.0129125658,
0.0074517448,
-0.0234515071,
0.0052211713,
-0.0063304049,
0.0458578989,
-0.0368376225,
-0.0464074574,
0.0067065391,
0.0712989718,
0.0256500691,
0.0085430117,
-0.0640555546,
-0.0453992747,
-0.0066676317,
0.0149325859,
0.0045966455,
-0.0021166089,
0.0254233442,
0.0138139213,
-0.0249813758,
0.0020546217,
-0.0100146225,
-0.0033026892,
-0.0233897287,
0.0265310686,
-0.0228663627,
-0.0472241826,
0.0236297045,
0.0479762331,
0.0344913341,
-0.0640548393,
-0.0362670608,
-0.0129851894,
-0.0030769568,
-0.0176537782,
-0.0419730619,
-0.0480107851,
0.0143337743,
0.0061904909,
-0.0426812209,
-0.0004435314,
0.0340454802,
-0.0525129624,
-0.0227078516,
-0.0207331758,
0.0208390485,
0.0081587136,
0.0650831684,
-0.0166949537,
0.0283241495,
-0.002895006,
-0.0166251883,
0.0159979202,
0.022597013,
-0.0200666096,
0.0046174144,
0.0098460447,
0.0144693935,
0.0534689799,
0.0458895899,
-0.02118087,
0.0319339372,
-0.0482165292,
0.0317551158,
0.0858047977,
0.0152180288,
0.1324177533,
-0.0087386072,
-0.0141255371,
-0.0181831568,
0.0384471714,
0.0092153931,
0.0031106314,
-0.038717594,
-0.00240908,
0.0179822557,
-0.0009622157,
0.0139897782,
-0.0427628569,
0.0134022823,
-0.0424400121,
-0.046072118,
-0.0409851149,
-0.0084095858,
-0.0522612222,
-0.0426542386,
-0.0211814735,
-0.0350925624,
-0.0388180241,
-0.0397678353,
0.0086657796,
0.0530981869,
0.0314429328,
0.0009384634,
0.015097796,
0.0654145032,
-0.0375977084,
0.0211970229,
-0.0276564062,
-0.0375922285,
0.0076404531,
-0.0205590278,
-0.0407254957,
-5.594065944e-33,
-0.038384188,
-0.0766931921,
-0.0258670803,
-0.0188219585,
-0.012953382,
-0.013196785,
-0.0360377841,
0.0025010898,
0.0328688361,
0.0319774263,
0.0035044618,
-0.0140088489,
0.0337036774,
-0.047694359,
0.0334352702,
0.0232904665,
0.0550760329,
0.0108631849,
-0.0547765791,
-0.0180366263,
0.0044445349,
-0.0164600778,
0.063310802,
-0.0858927146,
0.0955407619,
-0.0227503665,
-0.0695091784,
0.0050987015,
0.0286329873,
0.038726829,
0.0295531116,
0.0154213365,
0.0198333524,
0.0052045882,
-0.0259425882,
-0.0371387824,
-0.0764929652,
-0.0067576668,
0.0025458566,
0.0658348203,
-0.0343845151,
-0.0206117891,
0.0426185019,
-0.0572419725,
-0.046852015,
0.0357872695,
0.0380704813,
-0.0686190128,
0.006074944,
-0.0091902902,
-0.0405005738,
0.034556713,
-0.0253769066,
-0.0192019958,
0.0291427076,
0.053737592,
-0.0072881118,
-0.0186981801,
-0.0643827543,
0.0104046334,
-0.0073569147,
0.0019519733,
0.0656087995,
-0.049524799,
-0.0420479625,
0.0097570736,
0.0077195698,
-0.0100778677,
0.0373858847,
0.0056480626,
0.0215478893,
-0.0225198492,
0.1023817435,
0.0518860444,
0.0057395371,
-0.0049291942,
-0.0393823124,
0.0954981446,
-0.0407960601,
0.014013676,
-0.0102372896,
0.0043675322,
-0.0633827671,
0.0061783446,
-0.0483411849,
-0.0665497631,
-0.0212765206,
-0.0214161258,
-0.0084019881,
0.0011613681,
-0.0483501963,
0.0252951775,
0.0492885821,
-0.00901228,
0.0258109327,
-0.0417734571,
-0.0170224141,
0.0349953882,
-0.0136993863,
-0.0011443296,
0.0179161113,
-0.0037312428,
0.0121118892,
0.041900795,
0.0375125147,
-0.0323023796,
0.0697858855,
0.0398187414,
-0.0438582264,
0.0381189212,
-0.023350846,
-0.0054568537,
-0.000121316,
-0.0183177553,
0.0121795218,
-0.0253880378,
-0.0156474151,
0.0342468582,
0.0135385152,
0.0510122702,
-0.0442740172,
0.0197727513,
0.0098347301,
0.0070425016,
-0.0590537377,
0.0204808619,
0.0165495109,
0.0130839553,
0.0115336347,
-0.0329326056,
-0.0208759643,
-0.0381292701,
2.475e-7,
0.0588919707,
0.0707826093,
0.0506679676,
-0.0042680809,
0.0108984523,
0.0012887719,
-0.0264144987,
0.009680856,
-0.0106564127,
0.0483263992,
0.0594869703,
-0.0101139341,
0.0854137391,
0.0581188463,
-0.0341964327,
-0.0520796627,
-0.023811806,
-0.0069823121,
-0.0196752269,
-0.0098219188,
0.0915328711,
0.0488829128,
0.0061693857,
0.005959894,
-0.0078972671,
-0.0372938886,
0.0477141812,
0.0235187002,
-0.0097165108,
0.0085548228,
0.0679562315,
0.0325426608,
-0.0258865897,
0.014850148,
-0.0378444977,
0.0019435904,
0.0619069003,
0.0480316319,
-0.0085103214,
0.0132893212,
0.0137180164,
-0.0013166749,
0.027551854,
-0.0086051915,
0.0147685437,
-0.0043364684,
-0.0080502341,
0.0199126583,
-0.0203793291,
0.0012294921,
0.0572582968,
-0.0090598874,
-0.0120538566,
0.0234959833,
0.0280372873,
0.0100616273,
-0.0243911874,
-0.0309877824,
-0.0321226567,
-0.001639858,
0.0115402341,
-0.05428195,
0.0105206249,
-0.0086633814,
-0.0080814641,
-0.0322361365,
0.0029340098,
2.016674205e-34,
0.0586954281,
-0.0470489301,
0.0264124367,
0.0038849402,
0.0476250127,
0.0225699674,
-0.0330538712,
-0.001036345,
0.0144634601,
-0.008785367,
-0.0157050677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12416v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12416v2 | Beyond Under-Alignment: Atomic Preference Enhanced Factuality Tuning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T09:07:30 | 2024-06-27T12:07:55 | Hongbang Yuan, Yubo Chen, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success but still tend
to generate factually erroneous responses, a phenomenon known as hallucination.
A recent trend is to use preference learning to fine-tune models to align with
factuality. However, existing work primarily evaluates fine-tuned models on
in-domain (ID) datasets and the factuality on out-of-domain (OOD) datasets
remains underexplored. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
the factuality of different models tuned by various preference learning
algorithms and demonstrate that their performance on OOD datasets either
increases minimally or decreases. Subsequently, we reveal that the main cause
of model's failure to uphold factuality under a distribution shift is
\textbf{under-alignment}, rather than \textbf{over-alignment}, by analyzing the
token distribution shift of the models before and after tuning. Finally, we
propose \textbf{APEFT} (\textbf{A}tomic \textbf{P}reference \textbf{E}nhanced
\textbf{F}actuality \textbf{T}uning), a framework that enhances model's
awareness of factuality at the granularity of individual facts. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that APEFT improves model performance by an average of
$\boldsymbol{3.45\%}$ on both ID and OOD datasets, which is highly effective. | [
0.0427362062,
0.0712805167,
0.0030159818,
0.0409595668,
-0.0574467219,
0.012402284,
-0.0121317254,
-0.0357727297,
-0.0434777923,
-0.0437773168,
-0.0286460947,
-0.0634027049,
0.007062322,
-0.0114242034,
-0.0025058426,
-0.0043306025,
0.0588257201,
-0.0238968786,
0.0209141616,
-0.0220510457,
0.0177368391,
0.0086768111,
-0.0286087785,
0.0178217925,
-0.0018071681,
-0.0067368192,
0.0124165947,
0.0090408176,
0.0294950306,
0.0164693259,
-0.0092448024,
0.0531414412,
0.0030228004,
0.0385436118,
0.0000020942,
-0.0578642078,
-0.0202858187,
-0.0156508312,
-0.0289709363,
0.0307701267,
0.0547855869,
0.0091114501,
-0.0364494994,
0.0108300541,
-0.029673133,
0.0192441065,
0.0883743316,
0.0429551713,
0.01209452,
0.1035632044,
0.0000630463,
-0.0343416147,
0.0171748362,
-0.0216610711,
-0.0097087463,
0.0152920354,
0.0318341367,
-0.0085981609,
-0.0374688543,
0.0059620556,
-0.0062797558,
0.0159264412,
-0.0082865823,
0.034552265,
0.0242380146,
0.0384167992,
-0.0608783923,
-0.022452144,
0.0124018732,
0.0898965746,
0.0067847203,
-0.044963181,
-0.015428517,
-0.0298811626,
-0.0228905138,
0.0219587013,
-0.0085176211,
0.0036811745,
-0.0097311353,
0.0654223785,
0.0663343295,
-0.0030091305,
0.0293464195,
0.0247892551,
-0.0593904369,
0.0996209979,
-0.0002388814,
-0.0377568603,
-0.0007567553,
-0.0089970119,
-0.0619803667,
-0.0346851647,
0.0066882102,
-0.0201603491,
-0.026523849,
0.0377254151,
-0.0460357331,
0.0353538059,
0.0394571461,
-0.0846055448,
0.0468242876,
0.0462974422,
-0.0391631052,
0.0299332179,
0.0056320103,
0.0566666797,
-0.0144630363,
0.0484631024,
-0.0502551757,
0.0199864581,
-0.0185704213,
0.0230996069,
0.0130047491,
0.0284456518,
-0.0188513137,
-0.0065223374,
-0.0327293351,
-0.0117978062,
-0.0087315161,
0.0379611552,
-0.0182358809,
0.0137683321,
-0.0615069568,
-0.0281287283,
-0.0678565949,
0.0852937028,
-0.011167746,
-0.0018498345,
0.0017072038,
-0.043323148,
-0.0012250062,
-0.006887076,
-0.0300115701,
-0.0337699614,
-0.0045950045,
0.0290233698,
-0.0028504748,
-0.0181023236,
-0.0034319244,
0.0174376983,
-0.0511023849,
-0.0934438035,
0.0097895917,
-0.0752137154,
0.0235385336,
0.0199442841,
0.0043482026,
-0.0725228339,
0.0069015594,
0.0006322166,
-0.0481670536,
0.0618575178,
0.024049297,
-0.0119025819,
-0.0276962668,
-0.0284874775,
0.0278656222,
0.0589376502,
0.037877623,
0.0152229024,
0.0382939689,
-0.0009034856,
-0.0223959517,
0.0028970288,
0.0091456408,
0.0246235505,
-0.0337471478,
0.0134591125,
0.0165727288,
0.0370176509,
0.0485701151,
0.0218465254,
0.0068276343,
-0.0413011424,
0.0961412266,
-0.032928016,
0.0144313667,
-0.001035924,
-0.0218061581,
0.0161435269,
0.0168662146,
0.0615896657,
-0.0816360563,
0.0538787283,
-0.026663607,
0.0429390743,
0.0212969612,
0.046908129,
-0.0052930359,
-0.0609007254,
-0.0097558936,
-0.0034920711,
-0.0297459308,
0.0118585257,
0.0454515181,
-0.0223229099,
-0.041830603,
0.0343588889,
0.0737032741,
-0.0304269381,
-0.0142748049,
-0.0331278481,
0.0384697989,
0.0761271343,
0.0373687893,
-0.0527544729,
-0.0559829362,
-0.0044675041,
-0.024239799,
0.0773183182,
0.046965789,
0.0046872939,
-0.0023957905,
-0.0587808602,
-0.0159728043,
-0.0156511012,
0.0247704498,
0.0220595095,
-0.0089478428,
-0.0103887208,
0.0000977396,
-0.0278221127,
-0.0207923502,
0.0279885866,
0.0022625988,
0.0016199579,
0.0037566843,
0.0217689835,
0.0360434577,
-0.0091983657,
-0.0241768546,
0.0140405009,
0.0195486378,
0.0033260807,
0.0011409216,
-0.023571549,
-0.0654160157,
-0.0144381216,
0.0669756457,
0.0039740084,
0.0198298506,
0.0111942515,
-0.053427536,
-0.0303929988,
-0.0115338247,
-0.0086266184,
0.031465508,
-0.02530564,
0.0372895375,
-0.0002496645,
0.0156623591,
-0.0641135126,
0.0645366833,
-0.0279238205,
0.0175097305,
0.0007341007,
0.0011040773,
-0.0038454647,
-0.0308385771,
0.0089312159,
0.0296628196,
0.0101834442,
0.0248842742,
0.0451055989,
-0.0220162757,
-0.0203564633,
-0.0188673306,
-0.0672676936,
0.0317784287,
-0.0303120948,
-0.0062387008,
0.0338851325,
-0.0067305733,
0.0013984781,
0.0000103008,
-0.0291839,
-0.0136074442,
-0.0300731305,
-0.0051550381,
0.0420333073,
0.0027747722,
-0.0086714644,
-0.0554612279,
-0.0054265787,
-0.0285597127,
-0.0062848511,
-0.0379165635,
0.0104007619,
-0.0615373701,
0.0395719223,
-0.0811577141,
0.0157194864,
-0.0212370623,
-0.0396382883,
-0.0157375466,
0.0162012205,
0.0441740192,
0.0792382509,
0.0216008816,
0.0074894526,
0.0953295678,
0.0301758647,
-0.0502352528,
-0.0058298297,
-0.0380108021,
0.0230509285,
-0.0281911418,
-0.0202196352,
-0.0049810507,
0.0613037758,
0.0122803636,
-0.0024588637,
-0.0500911996,
0.020083895,
-0.0256676488,
-0.0311258901,
0.015511062,
0.0249121971,
-0.0175388604,
0.043593958,
-0.0275621433,
-0.0365168713,
0.1110917255,
-0.0291049387,
0.0300401337,
-0.0824582279,
-0.0107581886,
-0.0218856409,
-0.0216005389,
0.0352756567,
0.0226704143,
0.0295802634,
0.0168617852,
-0.0671027973,
-0.052478727,
0.033731211,
-0.0347211547,
0.0866133422,
-0.0458936766,
0.009089428,
0.0076119467,
-0.0595516413,
-0.0332973525,
-0.0792244747,
0.0034078518,
0.0014959408,
-0.0184937436,
-0.0414645299,
-0.0641893446,
-0.0104088504,
0.016113542,
0.0447264686,
-0.0228408501,
-0.0010591561,
-0.0182002541,
0.0170862097,
0.0814877599,
0.0166300591,
0.0641647503,
0.0000667764,
-0.0106353555,
0.0445968509,
0.0469453186,
-0.013051576,
-0.0260361619,
-0.0092181005,
0.0300361384,
-0.0289460607,
-0.0307508614,
0.0066300989,
0.037203081,
-0.018131135,
-0.0115210125,
0.1161021143,
0.0435694717,
0.0048865709,
0.0217899848,
0.0055710142,
0.0374475196,
0.0077115302,
0.0074068764,
-0.0658130124,
-0.0233778581,
0.0085559627,
0.0058358666,
-0.0195421837,
-0.0122420397,
0.002145163,
-0.1194635779,
0.020444015,
0.0381950438,
-0.020915255,
-0.0353744589,
-0.0519913137,
0.0246870052,
-0.0549584813,
0.0444680303,
0.0126931826,
-0.0065913899,
-0.0090110367,
0.0337825269,
0.0097717224,
-0.0535139032,
0.0295557175,
-0.0203117095,
0.0730600283,
0.0787326023,
0.0402625799,
-0.0258292295,
-0.0206061471,
-0.0032049862,
0.0006284234,
-0.0201052036,
-0.0182740055,
0.019247245,
-0.0072820922,
-0.0076279724,
-0.0288823582,
0.0298777036,
0.0117080137,
-0.0205386207,
-0.0390850455,
0.0512239896,
-0.0205076654,
-0.0015884265,
-0.0151068578,
0.0124677988,
0.0049768374,
0.068444401,
-0.0043204515,
-0.041684974,
-0.0149794668,
-0.0555342101,
-0.0153119741,
-0.037873935,
0.0215100218,
0.0093987705,
-0.0106982552,
-0.0215714928,
-0.079216063,
-0.0019562868,
-0.0267390367,
0.0285512004,
0.0080223568,
-0.0217091702,
0.0294925123,
-0.0152456155,
-0.0049392255,
0.0304285921,
-0.0577782467,
0.0271214526,
-0.0487188213,
-0.0096854921,
0.061340481,
-0.0340415612,
-0.018294394,
0.0067954767,
-0.0162901636,
-0.0822845548,
0.0321544111,
0.0521425791,
0.0268466529,
0.0661906004,
-0.0082958145,
-0.0413958579,
0.0396115892,
0.0488034002,
-0.0372570939,
0.0110974386,
0.0416056514,
-0.0152016627,
0.0021341615,
0.0341618359,
-0.0041996818,
0.0022089819,
0.027249882,
0.0485130511,
-0.0124419918,
-0.0571839251,
0.0644336566,
0.0115847904,
0.0434055962,
-0.0037793152,
-0.0211500786,
-0.0382067077,
0.0371796265,
-0.0061970991,
-0.011902649,
-0.0212488547,
-0.029246591,
0.0406135581,
0.003466069,
-0.0184351243,
-0.0328386799,
-0.0281823426,
0.0279058032,
-0.0035467399,
0.0045371163,
0.0186384786,
0.0229774117,
0.0382911526,
0.0103092566,
-0.0540359877,
0.0273939166,
0.0308405068,
0.0713231266,
0.0009997041,
0.0668947846,
0.0327019729,
-0.0088671222,
-0.0300209876,
0.0157378353,
-0.0568840094,
0.0270265378,
-0.0511106141,
0.0013750512,
0.0410040505,
-0.0371560752,
0.0486252829,
-0.033409711,
-0.0076832999,
-0.0311167184,
0.0609079078,
0.0123733561,
0.0058853971,
0.0263602342,
0.0166232511,
-0.0267648436,
0.040978618,
0.0650808588,
0.0148683069,
0.0304834805,
0.0053881477,
0.0007194714,
-0.037302684,
-0.0293751005,
-0.0632124841,
0.0313249715,
-0.0437716991,
-0.011868367,
-0.0746532828,
-0.0647325069,
-0.0016128812,
0.0142839123,
0.0058162818,
-0.0624052584,
0.0152117899,
0.0694695339,
-0.025112072,
-0.0175859947,
-0.0550221018,
-0.0147557044,
-0.0026895478,
0.0197876971,
-0.051687438,
-6.6477541e-33,
-0.0476645529,
0.0107792551,
-0.0168035254,
-0.0148993842,
-0.0156212486,
-0.0210768878,
-0.005670106,
-0.0020770074,
-0.0456824116,
0.0042055333,
-0.0017107022,
0.0028193672,
0.0280778445,
0.0045577749,
-0.0232707858,
-0.0316905081,
0.0533824861,
0.0188909434,
-0.0565322228,
-0.0203049891,
0.0541234128,
-0.0165773183,
0.0723271444,
-0.0479956493,
0.0177172702,
0.0211758129,
-0.0144875627,
0.0263538603,
-0.059368562,
0.0759888589,
0.0066740606,
0.0617667139,
0.0017452487,
-0.0325935856,
-0.0012099015,
-0.0095134191,
-0.0551224165,
-0.0274627581,
0.0768389702,
0.0046552923,
0.0659424067,
-0.0281021856,
0.0171681233,
0.0103662722,
-0.0339301303,
-0.0344874747,
0.0336406603,
-0.0427205116,
-0.0492766201,
0.0467827469,
-0.08160308,
0.0056123771,
0.0047589401,
-0.0124926139,
-0.0062442939,
0.0280530024,
0.0127489734,
0.0117789088,
-0.0779359639,
0.0245833155,
0.0214469079,
0.0429806001,
0.0523890369,
0.0171904918,
-0.0113782436,
0.0489367098,
0.0184583645,
-0.0024965808,
0.01151942,
-0.0340072401,
0.0300658252,
0.0296564121,
0.0303369071,
0.0485397018,
0.0205524135,
-0.0117049003,
-0.0649555549,
0.003380765,
0.045140408,
0.0028846893,
0.0347434841,
0.0301485546,
-0.0755191967,
-0.0129789934,
-0.030834049,
0.0204505641,
-0.037016321,
-0.0295063555,
-0.0007658842,
-0.0114979995,
-0.0440685079,
0.0230688453,
0.0307260957,
-0.0539345182,
-0.0361775793,
0.0260911696,
-0.04652391,
0.0409506187,
-0.0128268301,
0.0022615138,
-0.0826154277,
-0.0181835443,
-0.0077392012,
-0.0067522349,
-0.0183044206,
0.0198033918,
0.0486129187,
0.0174033307,
-0.0530372523,
0.0130772972,
-0.0410518795,
-0.0272543598,
0.0194554105,
0.0158168972,
0.0216871034,
0.0200829413,
-0.0247484706,
0.0311849099,
0.0052630189,
0.0019635127,
-0.0325306989,
-0.0183285382,
-0.0042453869,
0.0474190302,
-0.0224327687,
-0.0069059189,
-0.0259207189,
-0.0160382371,
-0.0111765089,
-0.0250791442,
-0.0379676819,
-0.0011351897,
2.766e-7,
0.0229651555,
0.051435668,
0.0030892151,
0.0091025624,
-0.0304673426,
0.0691690817,
-0.0420561172,
0.0028653161,
0.0415804945,
-0.0217977762,
0.0182905942,
0.0211328641,
0.0383765399,
0.0062993378,
-0.0833966658,
0.0174878519,
-0.0241600871,
-0.0044111386,
-0.0388793498,
-0.0040162536,
-0.013561666,
0.1191827133,
0.0498689264,
-0.0040422175,
0.0137105957,
0.0159311518,
0.058267653,
-0.0374884941,
-0.0435818546,
0.0288354326,
0.0014169504,
-0.0036684512,
-0.0171332024,
0.0252938159,
-0.0077993926,
0.0268866289,
-0.0155432224,
0.0647326484,
-0.0037303374,
-0.0386780649,
-0.0354422256,
-0.0298415571,
0.0115549797,
-0.0860174298,
0.0677265376,
-0.0311073009,
-0.0433198363,
-0.0257268045,
-0.0423723198,
0.0321742445,
0.0168673787,
-0.0116319275,
-0.037713021,
0.0089103961,
0.0194887146,
0.0244296864,
-0.0335866511,
-0.0205461979,
-0.0454860553,
0.0485873036,
-0.0105066197,
-0.068416059,
0.0164947733,
0.0184924174,
0.0241076928,
-0.0746752545,
0.0065081883,
2.923389936e-34,
0.0509282686,
0.0226638895,
0.0197369941,
-0.0005333581,
0.0184142441,
-0.0005488504,
-0.0123899551,
0.0145514039,
0.0320793204,
-0.0560836531,
-0.0024609999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12403v1 | PDSS: A Privacy-Preserving Framework for Step-by-Step Distillation of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:48:14 | 2024-06-18T08:48:14 | Tao Fan, Yan Kang, Weijing Chen, Hanlin Gu, Yuanfeng Song, Lixin Fan, Kai Chen, Qiang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the context of real-world applications, leveraging large language models
(LLMs) for domain-specific tasks often faces two major challenges:
domain-specific knowledge privacy and constrained resources. To address these
issues, we propose PDSS, a privacy-preserving framework for step-by-step
distillation of LLMs. PDSS works on a server-client architecture, wherein
client transmits perturbed prompts to the server's LLM for rationale
generation. The generated rationales are then decoded by the client and used to
enrich the training of task-specific small language model(SLM) within a
multi-task learning paradigm. PDSS introduces two privacy protection
strategies: the Exponential Mechanism Strategy and the Encoder-Decoder
Strategy, balancing prompt privacy and rationale usability. Experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of PDSS in various text generation tasks,
enabling the training of task-specific SLM with enhanced performance while
prioritizing data privacy protection. | [
0.0204563569,
0.0912831202,
-0.0073370659,
0.0400521643,
-0.038813334,
0.0015227102,
0.0837366953,
-0.0418599881,
-0.0191955864,
-0.0208513234,
-0.0019714974,
-0.0341563858,
-0.0044360403,
0.0360409953,
0.0313048586,
-0.0073918537,
0.0038056085,
-0.033260636,
0.017595375,
-0.0190594345,
-0.040423274,
0.0172662307,
0.0158179738,
0.0463207699,
0.0666091517,
-0.0538857654,
-0.0475114584,
0.0088609932,
0.0081880586,
0.0105470326,
-0.019007517,
0.0318269357,
0.0717659295,
0.0287365913,
0.0000022029,
-0.0674772859,
-0.0614573173,
0.0233484954,
-0.0728182942,
0.0082419943,
0.0103644384,
0.0014241289,
0.0123152304,
0.0176047869,
-0.0204930324,
0.0302747469,
0.0394643806,
0.0268133916,
0.0752638876,
0.0766811073,
-0.0037168683,
-0.027647756,
-0.0210745502,
-0.0404855348,
-0.0300554447,
-0.0255368724,
-0.0000394307,
-0.0448761545,
-0.0380030833,
0.0306248404,
0.0148367388,
-0.0091429101,
0.0239509456,
-0.0026165142,
-0.0205959268,
0.0290228128,
0.0567919165,
-0.0601426065,
-0.0235792957,
0.0500532761,
0.0215914883,
-0.014583691,
0.0496164374,
0.0241494216,
0.0017395522,
0.0166056436,
-0.041419711,
0.0781506002,
0.0022476886,
0.0303834286,
0.0411266387,
-0.0111500407,
0.0055308943,
0.0213294439,
-0.0004585736,
0.0174974874,
0.0135892229,
0.012918463,
-0.0599926524,
-0.0147640826,
-0.0069537084,
-0.082556963,
0.0510704741,
0.048326917,
-0.0090339333,
0.009035727,
-0.0509947836,
-0.0230110846,
0.0177074093,
0.0282166023,
0.0187939163,
-0.0170482043,
0.0641962215,
0.0080493856,
-0.0140236504,
0.0677061304,
0.0177755691,
0.0450915024,
0.0025023583,
0.0167851709,
-0.0331470259,
-0.0047401763,
-0.0177182388,
0.0874942318,
-0.1194469929,
-0.0047727693,
-0.0303184316,
0.0364797898,
-0.0227639098,
0.0340266041,
0.032402955,
0.0230423845,
-0.025646694,
-0.040874742,
-0.0002500518,
0.0030531893,
-0.0257640053,
0.0084776478,
0.0467394665,
-0.0443606824,
-0.0305376146,
-0.0057414342,
0.0122969812,
0.0036449016,
-0.0503113754,
0.0502186865,
-0.0185793079,
-0.0097666299,
-0.0205195863,
-0.1275815219,
0.0125464145,
-0.0639592931,
-0.0083702607,
-0.0297105759,
0.0249651335,
-0.0151577704,
-0.0147106461,
-0.0750698522,
0.000159794,
0.0386731848,
0.0029346079,
0.0643064529,
-0.0072573344,
-0.0134539874,
-0.0119407596,
0.0519419946,
-0.0067449496,
0.0367489867,
0.0332476906,
0.0437740088,
0.0285684746,
-0.004832732,
-0.0052169426,
-0.0463239625,
0.0349206775,
0.0061961366,
-0.0314171985,
0.0244125873,
-0.0165606719,
-0.019110648,
0.0152284494,
0.0718821138,
-0.0109634409,
0.010137381,
0.0769285262,
0.0509188771,
0.027095532,
0.0063938946,
-0.0122386403,
0.0461559743,
-0.0555263087,
0.0187234171,
-0.0408540368,
0.0122868149,
-0.0186011419,
-0.0011289681,
-0.0190729741,
0.0439356863,
-0.0036413837,
-0.0085089207,
0.0511173159,
-0.0887636766,
0.0143592125,
0.0384861194,
0.0130604608,
0.0303521343,
-0.0243280437,
0.042492792,
-0.0080117406,
-0.0832938179,
0.0240568947,
-0.0617297776,
0.0371196605,
0.0827771202,
0.0341500305,
0.0255724806,
0.0027577288,
-0.0543265976,
0.003239631,
0.0270753372,
-0.0161634311,
-0.0084731001,
0.0589127652,
-0.0691953823,
-0.0601180345,
-0.0231516585,
0.0161663871,
-0.0063162041,
-0.0049189706,
-0.0122309299,
0.0449419841,
-0.0237247348,
0.0249300096,
0.0188142061,
-0.0330090113,
-0.0463082679,
0.0172420256,
0.0165228918,
0.0298842471,
0.0330474488,
0.0193057451,
0.0293061566,
0.0283275452,
-0.0334749743,
0.0076644323,
0.0066649839,
-0.0370106287,
-0.0449477695,
-0.0216450412,
0.0086090239,
0.0397704169,
0.0454413779,
-0.0191875156,
-0.0430599116,
-0.0053789988,
-0.0059258197,
0.0034014899,
-0.0467439815,
0.0158353802,
0.0149758253,
0.0062815063,
-0.0338809825,
0.0267716367,
-0.0161696617,
-0.0341719538,
-0.0106900102,
0.0092872623,
-0.0267719384,
-0.0362015441,
0.041619461,
0.0153843127,
-0.0275561139,
0.0060304063,
0.009466188,
0.0106535163,
0.0078913281,
-0.0104436465,
-0.0234393198,
0.0310872849,
-0.0139657045,
0.0386888012,
0.0263883881,
0.0304400455,
0.0269600824,
-0.0251134858,
-0.0576247871,
0.002232674,
-0.0201457199,
0.0190074556,
0.029223524,
-0.0067479229,
-0.0430090763,
0.0251308586,
-0.0057397005,
0.015258613,
0.055280216,
-0.0389399938,
0.033040449,
-0.0577814542,
0.0643154681,
-0.0157781914,
-0.0081438981,
0.0163969062,
-0.0007590961,
-0.0051910165,
0.023344595,
-0.0004716536,
0.0418980867,
0.0362829007,
0.0252015069,
0.0403768718,
-0.003562059,
-0.0543609001,
-0.009964034,
-0.0285071079,
-0.0060328334,
-0.039347291,
-0.0210537091,
0.0533024631,
0.0414359011,
0.0133343302,
-0.042074386,
-0.0376922525,
0.0509778112,
-0.0041058548,
-0.0434486903,
-0.0346070156,
-0.0583174489,
-0.0296235438,
0.0256575104,
-0.0086545292,
-0.0551932007,
0.0902642161,
-0.0319847688,
0.0133276219,
-0.0314040296,
-0.0254200418,
-0.0200188532,
0.0742721036,
-0.0280385576,
0.0601535626,
0.0333867818,
-0.0505056418,
-0.0361260027,
0.0034169673,
0.0392265096,
-0.042041,
0.033831276,
-0.0460804924,
-0.0390964523,
-0.0234411489,
-0.0598208904,
-0.0329877585,
-0.0830384716,
0.0106280642,
0.011138211,
0.0032195118,
-0.0081077581,
0.0083956737,
-0.0162476506,
0.0356156863,
0.0270937085,
0.0001503968,
0.0139200455,
-0.0497655943,
0.0162567813,
0.0356473885,
0.0237840507,
0.0044182609,
-0.0440765284,
0.0563407317,
0.0706419945,
0.0467062928,
-0.0225145258,
0.0252216402,
-0.0210920107,
0.0126127154,
-0.0157106277,
-0.0053650299,
0.0342062525,
0.0917260349,
-0.0344792046,
-0.0091130259,
0.0998151973,
0.0098674204,
-0.0354514234,
-0.0003746276,
0.0447800271,
0.0564283431,
-0.0062638051,
-0.0111303572,
-0.087244913,
-0.0080623496,
0.032665059,
0.0675177723,
-0.0203341637,
-0.0310014412,
-0.0488316528,
-0.103546083,
0.0230150931,
0.0041218977,
0.0340204835,
-0.0034132903,
-0.0390665382,
-0.0328439288,
0.0271907672,
0.0121023487,
-0.0032538485,
0.0036283813,
-0.0248950236,
0.0209195446,
0.0047269696,
-0.0645004809,
-0.0400392339,
-0.0296401512,
0.0267541036,
0.0421324112,
0.0330314562,
0.0426299721,
-0.0433490016,
-0.010124865,
0.0106621832,
0.0051928815,
0.0153453071,
0.0076201861,
0.0202348344,
0.0216337424,
-0.016827533,
0.072974436,
-0.0384166092,
-0.028614115,
0.0173452646,
0.0432007201,
-0.0414193012,
-0.0158719402,
0.0192771461,
-0.0333776176,
0.0316052884,
0.0894617662,
0.0241530892,
-0.0425911099,
-0.025673667,
-0.0228378177,
0.0074850954,
-0.0554832853,
0.051872544,
-0.0130494591,
-0.0015356166,
-0.0196316782,
-0.0688048601,
0.0218864419,
-0.0117532304,
0.0401310138,
0.0213294365,
0.0107119437,
0.0458019935,
-0.0077328901,
-0.0500980429,
-0.0175761878,
-0.0682546124,
0.0072134347,
-0.0035864944,
0.0119831413,
0.0242407713,
-0.0402389839,
-0.0201728605,
-0.00645361,
-0.0552436821,
-0.0697755888,
-0.021608619,
0.0267084911,
0.0214563441,
0.0460766777,
-0.0213932227,
-0.048266083,
0.0502683856,
0.020111274,
-0.0507692844,
0.0019804216,
0.0336541235,
-0.0251636282,
-0.0028628048,
0.0360771306,
-0.0177898109,
-0.0205685887,
0.0095144231,
0.0079591293,
-0.0077343527,
-0.0437293127,
0.0093908301,
0.0525452383,
0.0170841999,
-0.0059613734,
0.015566187,
-0.0709208772,
0.0342341699,
-0.0464145802,
0.0252385382,
-0.0538589582,
-0.0197853539,
0.0270624943,
-0.0116406437,
0.0530969836,
-0.0069250995,
0.0394759104,
-0.0001215798,
-0.0541943051,
0.0551835522,
-0.0374220237,
0.00786989,
0.043756716,
0.001786705,
-0.0316217206,
0.0411398783,
0.0153551381,
0.0174263306,
-0.0269854814,
0.0646514371,
0.0324791819,
0.0222994518,
-0.0025111826,
0.0451141186,
-0.0395197868,
-0.065735653,
-0.0045538619,
-0.0184422228,
-0.0013193851,
0.0638931021,
0.0429343916,
-0.0291671064,
0.0116904993,
-0.0155252609,
0.0609163158,
0.0155599006,
-0.0385633819,
-0.0125545729,
0.0106913531,
-0.0215935744,
0.0206433609,
0.1084265336,
0.0120231379,
-0.0023969891,
-0.0328339748,
-0.0199293308,
-0.0612173826,
-0.0457257666,
-0.0454813354,
0.0498896129,
-0.017837422,
-0.0293133054,
-0.0307251457,
-0.0645159185,
-0.0361744054,
-0.0189610962,
0.0055083353,
-0.0344587825,
0.0423785895,
0.0121576982,
-0.0214506462,
-0.0525802225,
-0.077646561,
0.0072017754,
-0.0150986211,
-0.0048315134,
-0.0032505367,
-6.326055827e-33,
-0.0073258937,
-0.0167015549,
0.0017734813,
-0.0037294482,
-0.0155624887,
0.0137176709,
-0.0476376042,
-0.0258341599,
0.0156864524,
-0.0122846048,
-0.0189045444,
-0.0072981636,
0.0252422113,
0.0623199753,
-0.0302903876,
-0.0059002773,
0.0983989462,
-0.0123909358,
-0.0088981902,
0.0716341361,
0.0598338582,
0.0172629748,
-0.0002212407,
-0.0702627078,
0.0288612619,
0.0082902908,
-0.0369462967,
0.0145653579,
-0.0321570225,
0.0387900583,
-0.0097697685,
0.009715816,
0.0027865698,
-0.0412208773,
-0.0205193479,
0.0658902675,
-0.0646403432,
-0.0089909127,
-0.0004240094,
-0.0456881821,
-0.0243544932,
-0.0868056566,
0.03611302,
-0.0193121098,
-0.0011381451,
0.0082906587,
-0.0237713214,
-0.0072550983,
-0.0054373345,
-0.0207341537,
-0.0134730823,
-0.0222403742,
-0.0220625233,
-0.0216387492,
0.0428533405,
0.0115014678,
-0.0080381641,
-0.0346369669,
-0.0131063163,
0.0348847769,
0.0407129042,
-0.0150296288,
0.0648082644,
0.0279229358,
0.0114830993,
0.0573452413,
0.0300513636,
0.0255973581,
-0.0472091995,
0.0039757416,
-0.0208490286,
0.0596018359,
0.0131620923,
0.0098672472,
-0.0247767139,
-0.0148151182,
-0.0657553673,
0.0087082041,
-0.0096708732,
-0.0095536504,
0.0780143663,
-0.0004945957,
-0.0111141456,
-0.0208199229,
-0.050614588,
0.0342784412,
-0.0222071912,
0.0104425345,
0.0304735769,
0.0335396416,
-0.0620798171,
-0.0215843841,
0.0459878929,
-0.0557268634,
-0.0104328413,
0.0486180298,
0.0500838868,
-0.0475252904,
0.0107182665,
-0.0363603346,
-0.0499028601,
-0.0065549673,
0.0137915863,
-0.0311989412,
0.0043360777,
0.0233539678,
0.024631124,
0.0023317498,
-0.0377171449,
-0.0002139421,
-0.0667656884,
0.0613040142,
0.015702052,
0.0397180058,
0.054520715,
-0.0198330767,
-0.0256571919,
0.0163143054,
0.001121444,
-0.0185677335,
-0.0201998111,
0.05087585,
0.0137620345,
0.0239910912,
-0.0028200645,
-0.0166857988,
0.008330619,
0.0052260407,
0.093332313,
-0.0024383531,
0.0020784354,
-0.0169207491,
2.914e-7,
-0.0349855833,
0.0167412423,
-0.0107107405,
-0.0062754364,
0.0317363404,
0.0453797914,
0.0397136211,
0.0365875773,
-0.0120966733,
-0.0028017699,
-0.0205667242,
0.0114899362,
0.0703155026,
0.0268635396,
-0.0795027465,
-0.015352834,
-0.0036473523,
0.0018310772,
-0.044914104,
0.013651127,
0.0506975465,
0.0254295915,
0.018703226,
-0.0292345956,
0.018061623,
-0.0136586642,
0.023456499,
-0.0477784239,
-0.0099719865,
-0.0160942469,
0.0326798148,
0.0244719367,
0.0142465103,
0.0108895767,
-0.0355125964,
0.0146171283,
-0.087409474,
0.110797599,
0.0226126742,
-0.0318870842,
0.0067305989,
-0.0445788726,
-0.0085057672,
-0.0360022411,
0.0578293353,
-0.0264263265,
-0.0553995408,
0.0061019268,
0.0154219912,
-0.0851130933,
-0.037267115,
-0.0117848832,
0.0124154603,
-0.0067232559,
-0.0205689948,
-0.0180708803,
0.0148949288,
-0.0529404394,
-0.020050237,
-0.0227127243,
-0.0413183495,
-0.0447859094,
-0.0122791231,
-0.0023133704,
0.0120950341,
-0.0457684174,
0.0361584835,
3.06849553e-34,
-0.0205609053,
-0.0106252283,
0.0053674108,
0.031220004,
0.0480938964,
0.0099379066,
-0.019576218,
0.0047476231,
0.046263773,
-0.0630542189,
-0.0327802487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12402v1 | Flee the Flaw: Annotating the Underlying Logic of Fallacious Arguments Through Templates and Slot-filling | 2024-06-18T08:44:45 | 2024-06-18T08:44:45 | Irfan Robbani, Paul Reisert, Naoya Inoue, Surawat Pothong, Camélia Guerraoui, Wenzhi Wang, Shoichi Naito, Jungmin Choi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior research in computational argumentation has mainly focused on scoring
the quality of arguments, with less attention on explicating logical errors. In
this work, we introduce four sets of explainable templates for common informal
logical fallacies designed to explicate a fallacy's implicit logic. Using our
templates, we conduct an annotation study on top of 400 fallacious arguments
taken from LOGIC dataset and achieve a high agreement score (Krippendorf's
alpha of 0.54) and reasonable coverage (0.83). Finally, we conduct an
experiment for detecting the structure of fallacies and discover that
state-of-the-art language models struggle with detecting fallacy templates
(0.47 accuracy). To facilitate research on fallacies, we make our dataset and
guidelines publicly available. | [
0.0348818749,
0.0350771286,
0.0045265746,
0.0299800634,
-0.015243358,
0.0427510664,
0.0284468904,
0.0131382598,
0.0031227602,
-0.0676376,
0.0344528034,
0.0217340495,
0.0290160868,
0.0224359073,
0.0188216828,
-0.0650842637,
0.0288383719,
-0.0022517857,
0.0739499032,
-0.0228125658,
0.0157724749,
0.0109922048,
-0.0505674742,
0.0453137904,
-0.0125307664,
-0.0621406697,
0.0234784372,
0.0259086676,
0.0082602203,
-0.0128249452,
0.031596005,
0.0505058989,
-0.0107317157,
0.0464202762,
0.0000022325,
-0.009313521,
0.0334285088,
0.0166493915,
-0.0504077785,
0.0426516272,
0.0417716168,
-0.0038177248,
-0.009398099,
0.0126132593,
0.0221555308,
-0.0427697413,
0.0531948395,
0.1088902429,
0.0724373385,
0.0807295963,
0.0090242904,
-0.0199789181,
-0.0034145799,
-0.0205940623,
-0.0490716733,
-0.0101028383,
0.017420087,
0.0612693876,
-0.0473762974,
0.0016372795,
0.0208791383,
-0.0130205201,
0.0491120629,
-0.0300442744,
-0.0018726623,
0.0256051086,
-0.0468908735,
-0.0226557478,
-0.0133785661,
0.0237024147,
0.0140777072,
-0.0775611028,
0.0086013256,
-0.0358921736,
-0.0118072452,
0.0249124449,
-0.0085769994,
0.0320319347,
-0.0184700415,
-0.016602695,
0.101122357,
0.0082851835,
0.0363200419,
0.0353207439,
0.0667832121,
0.0306713898,
0.0006335358,
-0.0273824874,
-0.0074105784,
-0.004472957,
0.0222507901,
-0.0762261823,
-0.0017133013,
-0.0088868681,
-0.0047633215,
0.0258177351,
-0.0296446774,
-0.0060360986,
0.0602066442,
-0.0450459085,
0.04136068,
0.0000868377,
0.0041289437,
0.0364857949,
-0.0232231934,
-0.0031451492,
-0.0293197688,
0.0014470561,
0.0182677209,
0.0003426917,
-0.0435118936,
-0.0458728001,
0.004839045,
0.0138653908,
-0.0066645616,
0.0157554541,
-0.0066405432,
-0.0475548171,
-0.0693084672,
0.0074747368,
-0.0081194574,
0.0402158201,
-0.0128341038,
-0.0444733538,
-0.056540478,
0.0542682856,
-0.0355432183,
0.0345621035,
0.0007482245,
-0.0603283271,
-0.0161436535,
0.0433832631,
-0.0312312637,
-0.0057582348,
-0.019755803,
-0.0058876588,
0.0173136219,
0.056944795,
-0.0165438857,
-0.019856371,
-0.0394454524,
-0.0267058164,
-0.0175729059,
-0.0995718092,
-0.012916239,
-0.0306123979,
0.0117519116,
-0.0597199835,
-0.0067947842,
0.0515850745,
-0.0242286287,
0.0142907575,
-0.0453601405,
-0.0299526025,
0.0602458231,
0.0113069685,
-0.0177889671,
0.0550887547,
0.0002919433,
0.0248190351,
0.0207111128,
-0.0061830785,
0.0240227804,
-0.0307993535,
0.0109830331,
0.0126837138,
0.0203214195,
0.0159033295,
-0.0315736607,
0.0098182503,
0.034219034,
0.0227922704,
-0.0386124998,
-0.0292932671,
0.0148877352,
0.0296064746,
0.0355898589,
0.0294009484,
0.0543489382,
-0.0329973511,
0.009851194,
-0.0214812793,
-0.0361332931,
-0.0124740796,
-0.0184004158,
-0.0612819903,
0.0041730548,
0.0185341798,
0.0238641649,
-0.065228641,
-0.035055846,
-0.0001495244,
-0.0029167626,
-0.0051835706,
0.0128257629,
0.0527840741,
-0.0141346036,
0.0502044633,
0.0321569927,
-0.0220573694,
-0.0515342876,
0.0023486149,
0.0388384573,
0.0004315179,
0.0046398388,
-0.0018578662,
-0.0190793369,
-0.029069243,
0.027038224,
0.0509136505,
0.0891596451,
-0.0333568268,
-0.0198982004,
-0.0269680209,
-0.0180831961,
-0.0249811634,
0.0778547153,
0.0089308582,
0.0248084348,
-0.0276650619,
0.0412332676,
-0.0074170707,
-0.0544169657,
0.0370317809,
0.0150237195,
0.0146677289,
-0.0136143956,
-0.012478563,
0.0525943674,
0.0129237557,
0.0040427153,
0.0062556257,
0.0202059243,
-0.0164467953,
-0.0243492909,
-0.0113896336,
-0.0233308598,
-0.0049793036,
0.0311840679,
-0.0574852079,
-0.0279602502,
-0.02120471,
-0.0511726327,
0.0166459773,
0.0169331096,
-0.0464832261,
0.0081798928,
-0.0149209173,
-0.0205242112,
0.0059308033,
-0.0170620903,
0.0161499847,
0.1047665998,
0.0118357241,
0.0497538,
-0.0258366019,
-0.0007470336,
0.0126239853,
-0.0508220755,
0.0044586873,
-0.0210385434,
0.0131689161,
-0.0077870875,
0.0301458314,
-0.0207627341,
-0.050640814,
0.0182360802,
-0.0903829858,
0.0027239795,
-0.0168903451,
0.0092661735,
0.0284215733,
-0.0546441749,
0.007376906,
-0.0121938158,
-0.0017136047,
-0.0804232284,
-0.0337627269,
-0.0021519449,
0.0603999868,
-0.0245902557,
0.0088893836,
-0.0043066167,
0.0090243071,
-0.0293735899,
0.019998759,
0.0034791843,
0.0323430933,
-0.0159985386,
-0.0004079267,
-0.0136511633,
-0.0278474297,
-0.0044834265,
-0.0170458537,
0.0194292311,
0.030021457,
-0.0425086617,
0.0639913455,
0.013968219,
0.0717478767,
0.0298063233,
0.0040231771,
-0.0376967527,
-0.0106966179,
0.0226482395,
0.0706537887,
-0.0012793728,
-0.0673697442,
-0.0003962201,
0.0706237331,
0.0057368609,
0.0344822481,
-0.0599365011,
0.0694436133,
-0.0530858785,
-0.0247052591,
0.0312631167,
-0.0371510796,
-0.0263509341,
0.0177122541,
-0.0411478579,
-0.0017652923,
0.0402766094,
-0.0221923254,
0.0481910519,
-0.002585052,
-0.0032749875,
-0.0217008386,
0.0072701424,
-0.0032166559,
-0.0097798705,
0.0546630248,
-0.0066224616,
-0.0056410944,
-0.0362280533,
0.0684011355,
-0.0220899209,
0.0238616373,
-0.064169392,
-0.0204988513,
0.023226833,
-0.0378689431,
-0.0326305032,
-0.0433918573,
-0.0639992431,
-0.030896293,
-0.0520894267,
-0.0012014398,
-0.0099119321,
-0.0642778799,
0.0085269241,
0.01898757,
0.021193156,
0.013727379,
0.0336146913,
0.0226854403,
0.0063828416,
0.0451209024,
0.0311152916,
0.0216829441,
0.0029853203,
0.0935346708,
-0.0242640097,
0.0596920662,
-0.0603553019,
-0.0012290498,
-0.031515006,
-0.0203315206,
-0.0310806744,
-0.0162781384,
0.0360150486,
-0.0647405908,
0.0203114785,
0.0801414251,
0.0182391871,
0.0193807352,
-0.0002390856,
-0.0235012546,
0.0227710269,
0.0236561019,
-0.0382496417,
-0.0914321542,
-0.0355357789,
0.018360449,
0.0356711447,
-0.05452355,
-0.0079487795,
0.028620258,
-0.1224412173,
0.0362512842,
0.0130000124,
0.0272271801,
0.0227120742,
-0.0525622889,
0.0271261502,
-0.0093220752,
-0.0126590375,
0.0032434175,
0.0091418894,
0.0034858729,
0.0464788191,
-0.0532822125,
-0.0189865213,
0.0249462873,
0.0116506061,
0.0881387219,
0.0036607957,
0.0701857507,
-0.0283909142,
0.016674025,
0.0083860578,
-0.0606731959,
-0.0367673337,
-0.0366420597,
0.0251071677,
0.0128247207,
0.0001128788,
-0.0236524288,
0.056177672,
-0.0197392795,
-0.0635836124,
0.0065404503,
0.0629600137,
0.0194906779,
-0.0272912625,
-0.0045789718,
0.0121440971,
-0.0027423748,
0.0739068091,
0.0276169796,
0.0443174243,
-0.0206802282,
-0.058423508,
-0.0194203462,
-0.072087951,
-0.0383251645,
0.0498496331,
0.0283382833,
-0.0479909405,
-0.0560876019,
-0.0544131063,
0.004695931,
-0.0039349608,
0.0188392177,
-0.0400654823,
-0.0146246981,
-0.0097439988,
-0.014775143,
0.028362019,
-0.0159851909,
0.000848045,
-0.0016635738,
-0.0078902887,
-0.0564998202,
0.015136471,
-0.0369945168,
0.0824386105,
-0.0401169248,
-0.0340345465,
0.0085653253,
0.0383386537,
0.0169821512,
0.050093513,
-0.0337344594,
-0.0210455246,
0.0281567685,
0.0095653208,
-0.0235670991,
-0.0121216988,
0.0471037254,
-0.0751040056,
0.0370873287,
0.0041835601,
-0.0096711861,
0.0210596491,
0.0160503127,
0.0473931544,
-0.0635817274,
0.0672260746,
0.0458049849,
0.0083717061,
0.0223400909,
0.0065862723,
-0.0191001017,
-0.0213649385,
0.0058056731,
-0.0517032966,
-0.0642725155,
0.0162980724,
0.0659968406,
-0.0011082477,
-0.007478069,
-0.0243693627,
-0.0522499271,
-0.0427751057,
0.0251188688,
0.0169452932,
0.0215504505,
0.0474844202,
0.0283299778,
0.0006452057,
-0.0109331487,
-0.0578603335,
0.0019790442,
-0.0032708338,
0.036866717,
0.0059823697,
0.0526606776,
0.0410531908,
0.007095376,
0.0433323011,
-0.034403909,
0.0083187763,
-0.0400371887,
0.0194816329,
-0.0031598252,
-0.0021827784,
-0.0564657673,
0.0523880683,
-0.0062895897,
-0.0310942791,
-0.0084450468,
0.0133937141,
0.0281952824,
-0.0510848053,
0.0443642214,
0.0334102176,
-0.0366172753,
-0.0113596311,
0.0218090694,
-0.0338145234,
0.038443584,
0.0439227559,
-0.0242554657,
-0.0309880208,
-0.0308171399,
-0.0402495451,
0.0455367267,
0.0000065453,
-0.0273898821,
-0.0852825791,
-0.0686405301,
0.001277828,
0.0297251511,
0.0302640721,
0.0237666834,
-0.0414562076,
0.0694256574,
0.0120833991,
0.0189991929,
-0.0549734272,
0.0281515606,
-0.0181752406,
0.00167716,
-0.019714376,
-6.628907987e-33,
-0.0088131605,
-0.059450414,
-0.0460928716,
-0.0045652925,
0.0168592744,
0.0291039813,
-0.0400950946,
-0.0164056662,
0.0011069144,
0.1071093529,
0.0317298248,
0.0398927145,
0.0181724653,
0.0009899901,
-0.0056539457,
-0.0027241602,
0.0194646977,
0.0280324798,
-0.0378641225,
-0.0181049109,
0.020095991,
-0.0364442281,
0.0137201194,
-0.0482652187,
0.059784051,
0.0025231598,
-0.0467789359,
0.006990429,
-0.031921979,
0.0590082183,
-0.0066143121,
0.0326888375,
0.025159847,
-0.0193879567,
0.0383344032,
0.0161909163,
-0.0815195069,
-0.0207597259,
0.0841541737,
-0.0101185562,
-0.0021390836,
-0.0553839207,
0.0210256111,
0.0202615112,
-0.0076267882,
-0.03925547,
0.0325152501,
-0.0532815531,
0.0072066463,
-0.0095579438,
-0.0573348142,
0.0288951602,
-0.0550528206,
-0.006362136,
-0.0569687895,
0.044457268,
0.0071524316,
0.0362206511,
-0.0806913376,
0.0101601789,
-0.0167700034,
-0.0050555235,
0.0076870988,
-0.0773608908,
0.0019327982,
0.0577607006,
-0.0145012895,
0.0030307311,
-0.0510207489,
0.0393641442,
-0.0453428999,
0.0145142404,
0.0688453242,
0.0321027897,
0.0796536729,
0.0129937641,
-0.0600515977,
-0.0450453199,
0.017911775,
0.0522545092,
0.0138262687,
-0.0368870944,
-0.0653954893,
0.0037865359,
-0.0581321642,
-0.0851830766,
-0.0092980005,
-0.0374604538,
0.0029489158,
0.0201194361,
-0.0273706764,
0.0272761192,
-0.0547957681,
-0.0226284824,
0.0311614592,
0.0043321121,
0.0146651734,
-0.0320867635,
0.0093532205,
0.0241759121,
-0.0184457079,
-0.0011641147,
-0.0033542851,
0.0205596276,
0.0553059019,
-0.0164049156,
0.0654361099,
-0.0295046084,
-0.0624022521,
-0.0153756524,
-0.0380465314,
-0.0102139702,
-0.0348257944,
0.0379520766,
0.0625233799,
0.0439736098,
-0.0157675277,
-0.0053043845,
0.0136979008,
-0.0042089624,
-0.0497238599,
0.0108611202,
-0.0087215248,
0.015318051,
-0.0108373016,
-0.0399974175,
0.0003353589,
-0.0087427767,
0.0331221409,
-0.0571776032,
0.0099160057,
-0.0155200288,
2.745e-7,
0.0566372275,
0.0691376179,
0.0077784406,
-0.0113743227,
0.0266891494,
0.0576820485,
0.0009217258,
0.0047869021,
-0.0049667819,
-0.045110587,
-0.0306399725,
0.0140398312,
0.0472669937,
0.0211690348,
-0.0598134883,
0.0208094306,
-0.0758949742,
-0.0306148436,
-0.0385068282,
-0.0044819401,
0.0385242812,
0.0678640231,
0.0650217459,
-0.0072332988,
-0.0090250205,
0.0102692107,
0.0398055352,
-0.000708497,
-0.0190033708,
0.0005914964,
0.0435462184,
-0.0271058455,
0.0075801848,
0.0334934965,
-0.0305252057,
-0.0091568809,
0.0072410582,
0.0571109392,
-0.0100954566,
-0.0108281588,
-0.0844708458,
-0.0326053873,
0.0350196511,
-0.0720578581,
0.0402974263,
-0.0427678004,
-0.0305813551,
-0.0135295857,
-0.0701688752,
0.011709298,
0.0106417825,
0.0242363904,
-0.0269227661,
-0.0110342596,
-0.0061708242,
0.0012106675,
-0.0062105074,
-0.0430411436,
-0.0303593632,
0.0354244076,
-0.0377744809,
-0.0098817069,
0.0062198164,
-0.0269411933,
0.0363453925,
-0.0220972244,
0.0233343225,
2.265703831e-34,
0.0139410896,
-0.0031374833,
0.0186401252,
0.0157704335,
0.0717296675,
0.0272116028,
0.0080429064,
-0.016839968,
0.0305538662,
-0.0128621757,
-0.0007199535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12399v1 | QueerBench: Quantifying Discrimination in Language Models Toward Queer Identities | 2024-06-18T08:40:29 | 2024-06-18T08:40:29 | Mae Sosto, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | With the increasing role of Natural Language Processing (NLP) in various
applications, challenges concerning bias and stereotype perpetuation are
accentuated, which often leads to hate speech and harm. Despite existing
studies on sexism and misogyny, issues like homophobia and transphobia remain
underexplored and often adopt binary perspectives, putting the safety of
LGBTQIA+ individuals at high risk in online spaces. In this paper, we assess
the potential harm caused by sentence completions generated by English large
language models (LLMs) concerning LGBTQIA+ individuals. This is achieved using
QueerBench, our new assessment framework, which employs a template-based
approach and a Masked Language Modeling (MLM) task. The analysis indicates that
large language models tend to exhibit discriminatory behaviour more frequently
towards individuals within the LGBTQIA+ community, reaching a difference gap of
7.2% in the QueerBench score of harmfulness. | [
0.0413238294,
0.0627954528,
-0.0428333059,
0.0022205533,
-0.0072478419,
0.0416755341,
0.0519914329,
-0.0026861397,
0.0567695871,
-0.0747384429,
0.0159064904,
-0.0439972728,
-0.0010577234,
0.0074028755,
0.0442952663,
-0.0163584482,
0.0187122617,
0.0348135941,
0.0067086034,
-0.0343255475,
0.031363003,
0.0348299555,
0.0239792224,
0.0787125751,
0.018105017,
-0.0470539294,
0.0621101037,
-0.0042706658,
0.0023716453,
0.0155254994,
0.0344037376,
0.0434920564,
-0.0344800912,
0.0323162898,
0.0000017016,
-0.0660533831,
0.0273207482,
0.0253122598,
0.0057058441,
-0.0138047459,
0.0087148659,
-0.0114084352,
-0.0007602118,
0.0706306845,
-0.0063072625,
0.0174136367,
0.0598842613,
0.0109651843,
0.0485124029,
0.0117747681,
-0.0087629734,
-0.0155393826,
-0.0130563295,
-0.0052280845,
0.0173920766,
0.0149798943,
0.0551505946,
-0.0463727452,
-0.033335112,
-0.0364070237,
-0.0210551005,
0.0253613852,
0.0061340122,
0.025412282,
0.0224591643,
-0.0243636258,
-0.0192272216,
-0.0545160174,
0.0461985134,
0.0429721586,
-0.0023510952,
0.0085042864,
0.0237459186,
0.0093329502,
-0.0055454881,
0.0229570568,
-0.0327283703,
0.0484754071,
-0.0224985108,
-0.0184796639,
-0.0235878788,
-0.0512659028,
0.062219929,
0.0635080263,
0.0334127881,
0.0714482591,
0.0357917137,
-0.0240376946,
-0.0004579276,
-0.0257233325,
-0.0165934078,
-0.0309871454,
0.0452250242,
-0.0000959526,
-0.0255662035,
0.0477848686,
-0.0186372306,
-0.044100143,
0.0403731093,
-0.0324816629,
0.0523355044,
0.074949868,
-0.0030774528,
-0.0223960727,
-0.0213760268,
0.0654371232,
-0.007218543,
0.0071375733,
0.0123788984,
0.0023943158,
0.0292157587,
-0.0392994881,
0.007652936,
-0.0174646135,
-0.0111923199,
0.0512535125,
-0.0196521766,
-0.0238962956,
-0.0787404925,
0.0127559435,
-0.0186361354,
0.0136364531,
-0.0277284626,
0.0201407466,
0.0036963159,
-0.0206203256,
-0.0310991742,
0.0292685963,
-0.0540480874,
-0.062429022,
0.0329110399,
0.0123798754,
0.0017862564,
-0.0604118034,
0.0161517244,
0.0511775352,
0.0308888033,
-0.0552561916,
0.0243490934,
-0.0108485082,
-0.0451792777,
-0.0402139761,
-0.0124052027,
-0.0628555268,
-0.0060033672,
0.0164726749,
-0.0128015028,
-0.0566273183,
0.0069865305,
0.0181509089,
-0.0290644877,
0.0656023398,
0.0278257001,
-0.0015960361,
0.0629664958,
0.0292376578,
0.000127664,
0.0646023378,
0.0211777221,
0.0218405984,
0.0182615165,
-0.0258359797,
0.0044861822,
0.0203214269,
0.0027734879,
0.0193813276,
-0.0282911118,
0.0254851319,
-0.0142063582,
0.0105788531,
0.0030428334,
0.0489358418,
0.013347595,
-0.0114193261,
0.0395568125,
0.0645147711,
0.0191819444,
0.0401200615,
0.0383181125,
0.0251049995,
-0.0062826085,
0.0029599601,
-0.0874992535,
-0.0407024138,
-0.0269108284,
-0.0264898539,
-0.0082488498,
0.0421179272,
-0.017797783,
-0.0363926627,
-0.0437209718,
0.012854524,
0.0726001784,
-0.0054205474,
-0.0055994201,
0.0061420589,
-0.0104445452,
0.0333843976,
0.0155592896,
-0.021760758,
0.0466085337,
-0.0134377573,
-0.0143727474,
0.0402504019,
0.0159461815,
-0.0383817665,
-0.0062782075,
-0.0707845464,
-0.0596152544,
0.0481569208,
0.0253477562,
0.0077399421,
-0.0065778405,
-0.0119293202,
-0.0264703259,
0.0476363972,
0.0029150962,
-0.0178433564,
0.0646183491,
0.0265313387,
0.0134652425,
-0.0086849974,
-0.047839608,
0.0343339965,
-0.0104751484,
-0.0677258521,
-0.0056138765,
0.0101320622,
0.034955658,
0.006413247,
-0.0349646024,
-0.0124845877,
-0.0336322784,
0.0063709212,
-0.0761660114,
-0.0101684602,
-0.0273138601,
0.0198415983,
0.0397598296,
-0.0615350753,
-0.03142092,
0.1101433784,
0.0074377786,
0.0148147084,
0.0626082793,
-0.0476188436,
0.0043816338,
-0.0183460154,
-0.0207473226,
-0.0545911677,
0.0210990924,
-0.0440937206,
0.0410792567,
-0.0266773794,
0.06268695,
-0.0251852665,
-0.0534281284,
-0.0050020972,
0.0081212716,
-0.0684078634,
-0.0133164367,
-0.0286312774,
0.026290061,
0.0265517756,
-0.0106695741,
-0.0239745751,
-0.0198076013,
-0.0931008607,
-0.0213530492,
0.0095590586,
-0.0135157919,
-0.0227836128,
-0.0184248388,
-0.0424582213,
0.0244453475,
-0.0060825814,
-0.0766007304,
0.0152993482,
0.0457487032,
-0.0028132848,
-0.0374310985,
-0.0194157772,
-0.024338983,
-0.0380645767,
-0.0413803235,
0.045307979,
0.0054936316,
-0.0430490784,
-0.0008488973,
-0.0117432727,
-0.0350155346,
-0.0184249673,
0.0235459264,
-0.0397298932,
0.0514363684,
0.0515332557,
0.069040373,
0.0323913693,
0.0721293762,
0.022248935,
0.0546904765,
0.0304654445,
-0.0069016716,
-0.000165745,
-0.0010280822,
0.0056522004,
-0.0140841976,
-0.089046821,
-0.0185708907,
0.0098512731,
0.079284519,
-0.0443578623,
-0.0625699759,
0.0560843013,
-0.0920332074,
-0.0558883622,
-0.0419874415,
-0.0591929071,
-0.0447615311,
-0.0074735805,
-0.0495938323,
-0.0516328253,
0.0468846373,
0.0082537942,
-0.011438339,
-0.0275450256,
0.0034429249,
0.003879667,
0.0516708381,
0.0058628842,
0.0661641285,
-0.0184852425,
-0.0560352951,
-0.0195421316,
-0.0529201925,
0.004542382,
-0.0449779592,
0.0290152524,
-0.0222653709,
0.0099868057,
0.0177010819,
-0.0200171378,
-0.056148421,
-0.0511914529,
-0.0351130404,
-0.0113809183,
-0.0059847729,
0.0097552929,
0.0215342529,
0.0047582793,
0.0122354655,
-0.0104786092,
-0.0268928148,
-0.0082116509,
0.0063631004,
-0.0132623902,
0.0053590592,
-0.0372283421,
0.0696756616,
0.0075750826,
-0.0158179495,
0.0226256028,
-0.004186044,
0.0701482743,
0.0159821287,
0.0145010725,
0.0275525525,
-0.0405996591,
-0.0287899412,
-0.0171718132,
0.0468343981,
-0.0146963932,
0.0178472977,
0.0684121922,
0.0227443296,
0.0147941895,
0.0323643386,
-0.0203881506,
0.0041682776,
0.0174436904,
-0.0148233706,
-0.1012453362,
0.0165532939,
0.011825541,
0.0271181576,
-0.0753927007,
-0.0452400409,
0.0092025846,
-0.0519103184,
0.0242992137,
-0.011347604,
-0.0187070053,
-0.044859793,
-0.0257597044,
0.0532366261,
0.013738865,
0.0183081515,
-0.0138020702,
-0.004749109,
0.0231356788,
0.0161449332,
-0.0670346171,
-0.0063743507,
0.0077646524,
-0.0359565951,
0.0264234692,
0.0080876388,
0.0634059086,
-0.0498288237,
0.0039914246,
0.0300049782,
-0.0278420132,
-0.0237466656,
-0.0312749706,
0.0059988191,
0.0189946964,
-0.030436594,
-0.0275813881,
0.02645755,
0.0139041543,
0.0030164011,
0.008826538,
0.0398779884,
0.0104127331,
-0.0275769681,
-0.0285634287,
0.0211183522,
-0.0216247048,
0.0942241848,
0.0463125482,
-0.0346073322,
0.0103439316,
-0.1084168106,
0.0284372028,
0.0206188112,
-0.093789421,
-0.0210416876,
0.0362158492,
-0.0207919851,
-0.0268024951,
-0.0447683074,
0.0411104709,
-0.0190501101,
0.0334532559,
-0.0165664833,
-0.0243226774,
-0.0043175439,
-0.0574016832,
0.0328566246,
-0.0033618731,
0.0481901839,
0.0069761388,
0.0085262591,
-0.0372007303,
-0.007343458,
-0.0377451926,
0.0367281064,
-0.0191634987,
-0.0443540104,
0.0698514879,
0.0227001514,
0.0238192864,
-0.0150680766,
-0.0151904738,
-0.0822850317,
0.0393470041,
0.0320576839,
-0.0199310947,
0.0289412756,
0.0376943685,
-0.0132999215,
0.0004024929,
0.034704037,
0.0095212609,
-0.0045921556,
0.0160508566,
0.0181543697,
-0.009656162,
-0.0441652164,
-0.0075244568,
0.0220801271,
-0.0098288152,
-0.0386180133,
-0.0031193274,
-0.0190248117,
-0.0461696312,
-0.0009857861,
-0.0500717461,
0.0161309261,
-0.0412954278,
0.0231773555,
0.0356365442,
-0.0443502218,
0.0052435193,
-0.0589556545,
0.0195071176,
-0.0427232385,
0.0325473659,
-0.0083249044,
0.0281558819,
0.0118661886,
0.0034450176,
-0.014456355,
-0.0143069606,
-0.0454251803,
0.0092166951,
0.019991776,
0.0116199758,
0.0092428355,
0.0305136759,
0.0082454365,
-0.0296415109,
-0.0021056221,
-0.0575061701,
-0.0159335844,
-0.0530962721,
-0.0205092262,
-0.0141945882,
0.0060667223,
0.0134797152,
-0.0269306172,
-0.0291095898,
-0.0164493714,
0.0061509847,
-0.0185000543,
0.0542234294,
0.0108314622,
-0.0138981137,
-0.0301342849,
0.0267171618,
0.0338145606,
0.0472962335,
0.0217218697,
-0.0199483261,
-0.0114084929,
-0.0282357112,
-0.0131565165,
0.0315609947,
0.0040455386,
0.0063238773,
-0.0864949897,
-0.0659716129,
0.014755398,
-0.0385604352,
0.0312180854,
-0.0423159637,
-0.0064321277,
0.0468535908,
0.0048820679,
-0.0343217999,
-0.02301443,
0.0237662122,
0.0453727171,
-0.0161957443,
-0.0137654729,
-5.33340852e-33,
-0.0299256779,
-0.0644235611,
-0.0344683342,
-0.009045653,
-0.0103976531,
-0.0077295233,
0.0255034659,
0.0010966064,
0.0007441607,
-0.0137786064,
0.0155459885,
0.0518870652,
0.0131577654,
0.0093785385,
-0.0092735421,
-0.0276227016,
0.0456787758,
0.0137942685,
-0.0175531395,
-0.0074025202,
-0.0233486556,
0.0238483157,
0.0152173284,
-0.081869185,
0.0916151404,
0.0168220457,
-0.0283576977,
-0.0312845185,
-0.023147814,
0.0226768181,
-0.0391094461,
0.0893410295,
0.0127396369,
0.0111044142,
0.0391096473,
0.1109346375,
-0.0381122641,
-0.0090636415,
0.057216391,
0.0081790723,
0.0580642149,
-0.0267257858,
0.0373603404,
0.0036352552,
-0.0416889042,
-0.0354153812,
0.0436679572,
-0.0386092179,
0.0361167528,
-0.0086055538,
-0.0357063226,
0.0177992154,
-0.0152840493,
0.0383308157,
-0.0283835623,
0.0580818467,
0.0238167159,
0.0153355235,
-0.0544837564,
-0.0073063807,
-0.0167927071,
0.0025652396,
0.0342910513,
0.0053122141,
0.0499938354,
0.0545575581,
0.0282245409,
-0.0057122973,
-0.0455687381,
-0.0129408501,
0.0578238554,
-0.0107967146,
0.052885253,
0.0332807973,
0.0064291144,
-0.045802962,
-0.0018388848,
0.0028836655,
0.0256094858,
0.0118644601,
0.0271885805,
-0.028724771,
-0.0290222224,
-0.0632597879,
-0.071581319,
-0.0701923072,
-0.0205757599,
-0.0089005427,
0.0241536126,
-0.047672864,
-0.0590358898,
0.0084230145,
-0.0400045514,
-0.0154329678,
-0.0454479717,
0.0218518656,
-0.0172518548,
-0.0239020884,
0.0358568393,
0.0395308398,
-0.02053288,
0.0191090796,
0.0089508016,
-0.0021654738,
0.0564746335,
-0.0060649845,
-0.0144304512,
0.0409193188,
-0.0864531025,
0.0001007148,
-0.0026974131,
0.0387883112,
0.0198210217,
0.060902968,
0.0397880115,
0.0509931557,
-0.0002133085,
0.0318408497,
0.0773331821,
0.025062805,
-0.0537187792,
-0.0037466255,
-0.0450332724,
0.0484188348,
-0.0252439622,
-0.0501035638,
-0.024611989,
0.0688517541,
0.0950661004,
-0.0605290867,
-0.0012319181,
-0.05237763,
2.336e-7,
0.0307163764,
0.0312448256,
-0.0192790125,
0.0397317,
0.0107072089,
0.0329406485,
0.0494541377,
0.0365166217,
0.0700479001,
0.0275199618,
-0.0529487394,
0.031608589,
0.013799428,
0.0381036289,
-0.0106593957,
-0.0238644928,
-0.0312425941,
0.0444522239,
-0.0528102368,
0.0295304637,
-0.0150522981,
0.0764814392,
0.0892597064,
-0.0282678362,
-0.0411799476,
-0.0334613249,
-0.0017004247,
-0.0360572711,
0.0107986005,
-0.0096444311,
0.0655815452,
0.0193261206,
0.0728430375,
-0.0014602896,
0.0209170729,
-0.0027120237,
0.0384328105,
0.0091236131,
-0.0012751125,
0.0470914282,
-0.013353006,
-0.0268475097,
-0.0363884717,
-0.0562201291,
0.0657576099,
-0.005040721,
0.0056105237,
-0.0322198831,
-0.0791062415,
-0.0284156054,
0.0422414131,
-0.0332147554,
-0.0613334104,
0.0102492422,
0.0300466735,
-0.0226146374,
0.0430583768,
-0.0728487223,
-0.0249779541,
-0.0225209463,
-0.0104595479,
-0.028830478,
-0.0116659086,
0.0038768267,
-0.0263618734,
-0.0373754054,
0.0281538069,
2.044659466e-34,
0.0215585046,
0.0351068489,
-0.0065289838,
-0.023068333,
0.0361835249,
0.0126164155,
0.0115222391,
0.0074434387,
0.0085180905,
-0.0276744161,
-0.002391878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12397v1 | Unveiling the Flaws: Exploring Imperfections in Synthetic Data and Mitigation Strategies for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:38:59 | 2024-06-18T08:38:59 | Jie Chen, Yupeng Zhang, Bingning Wang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen, Weipeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Synthetic data has been proposed as a solution to address the issue of
high-quality data scarcity in the training of large language models (LLMs).
Studies have shown that synthetic data can effectively improve the performance
of LLMs on downstream benchmarks. However, despite its potential benefits, our
analysis suggests that there may be inherent flaws in synthetic data. The
uniform format of synthetic data can lead to pattern overfitting and cause
significant shifts in the output distribution, thereby reducing the model's
instruction-following capabilities. Our work delves into these specific flaws
associated with question-answer (Q-A) pairs, a prevalent type of synthetic
data, and presents a method based on unlearning techniques to mitigate these
flaws. The empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach,
which can reverse the instruction-following issues caused by pattern
overfitting without compromising performance on benchmarks at relatively low
cost. Our work has yielded key insights into the effective use of synthetic
data, aiming to promote more robust and efficient LLM training. | [
0.0522944368,
0.0929353237,
-0.0097321514,
0.0735364035,
0.0073353322,
0.0135366758,
-0.007778015,
0.0046862718,
-0.014247302,
-0.0715736002,
-0.0169696864,
-0.0657604188,
-0.0061778929,
0.0373631865,
0.0419615619,
-0.0137428744,
0.0673499927,
-0.0462839864,
-0.0351364315,
0.0019695123,
0.0071896701,
0.0183691587,
0.0171846654,
0.0043103737,
-0.0025403067,
-0.020401109,
-0.0182295758,
0.0112974197,
-0.0179078765,
0.0126178088,
0.0225048997,
0.0638890266,
0.0017530053,
0.0446317494,
0.0000018622,
-0.0332046002,
-0.0112968329,
-0.0001010177,
-0.0478896648,
0.0497974493,
0.0060670641,
0.0114642493,
-0.0051329168,
0.0570816249,
-0.0358272158,
-0.0335932188,
0.0347085483,
0.0249871202,
0.0576137304,
0.1114100292,
0.0017300583,
-0.0476655923,
0.0483749732,
-0.0162544493,
0.0310652684,
0.0069005019,
0.0357060768,
-0.0124027496,
-0.0006875631,
0.0120820291,
-0.0214021411,
0.010414524,
0.0264737625,
0.0063424259,
-0.003529497,
0.0345406421,
-0.0454794317,
-0.0157995224,
-0.0058766929,
0.1030975506,
-0.0333059877,
-0.0112660425,
0.0009962022,
-0.013937409,
0.0266136173,
0.0023455913,
-0.0226956885,
0.0286361966,
0.0030787124,
0.0383862741,
0.0247819256,
-0.0385964811,
0.0311812069,
-0.0264830068,
-0.0542860217,
0.0172483176,
0.0204303171,
-0.039885845,
-0.017958682,
0.0102410298,
-0.046260003,
-0.0325714983,
-0.0275178514,
0.0192884803,
-0.0242459234,
0.0407439955,
-0.0642055944,
-0.0226625912,
0.01206234,
-0.0578234941,
0.0569673926,
0.0368642844,
-0.0052673994,
0.012706439,
-0.0224241782,
0.0371440277,
-0.0100435754,
0.0594551042,
-0.059950266,
0.0189120322,
-0.029804131,
-0.0063374666,
-0.02156673,
0.0612771697,
-0.0675399005,
-0.0107591627,
0.0005256762,
0.0288713798,
0.0133427056,
0.0062268297,
0.0178159699,
0.0123172589,
-0.0138246296,
0.026763415,
-0.0405158475,
0.0011163687,
-0.0166601446,
0.0203463603,
-0.0176436044,
-0.0994020551,
-0.0044393186,
0.0163240898,
0.0127084777,
-0.0285636578,
0.0158570632,
0.0697229952,
-0.016933335,
-0.0221436955,
-0.0416049175,
-0.0132247657,
-0.0021184704,
-0.0605647862,
0.0081800018,
-0.0824934989,
0.0565174408,
0.0109218005,
-0.0076852976,
-0.0028572194,
0.0295953881,
0.0396579504,
-0.049807135,
0.038969852,
-0.0282197502,
0.0364916287,
-0.0162890889,
-0.0118393013,
0.0578273982,
0.0754903108,
0.0408514403,
-0.0288571529,
0.0311922692,
-0.033655405,
0.0177409928,
0.0436118506,
0.0534509867,
0.0086226407,
-0.0274698008,
0.0466466285,
0.0475937761,
0.0239742715,
0.0459193848,
0.0521877669,
-0.0277561154,
-0.0417978019,
0.0658160076,
0.0009899593,
-0.0078237932,
0.0269895028,
0.0480439253,
0.0057073091,
0.0222618748,
0.019363502,
-0.0422239713,
-0.0104761226,
0.0051027983,
0.023001926,
0.0276274439,
0.0099967923,
-0.0497107133,
-0.0604559667,
-0.0080996696,
0.0002824556,
-0.0330290422,
0.0388569534,
0.0223311894,
0.0332946032,
-0.0646325052,
0.0323375911,
0.0249925628,
-0.035367433,
-0.0036964449,
-0.0434621572,
0.0340152457,
0.0569212809,
0.0343151502,
-0.0071675237,
-0.0436353385,
-0.0163171235,
-0.0110559063,
0.0479126945,
0.0541447066,
-0.0289111324,
0.0393438302,
-0.043711137,
-0.0160890631,
-0.0139290439,
-0.0061717723,
0.0099733192,
0.0222402439,
-0.0042682644,
0.0039563491,
-0.0353882499,
-0.0647482947,
0.0529337898,
-0.0513281524,
-0.0547624007,
0.0247472432,
-0.0175829791,
0.0103598936,
0.0101561546,
-0.016577458,
0.0329947174,
0.0500179902,
-0.009475504,
-0.0133571895,
-0.0163886175,
-0.0789388567,
-0.0663587078,
0.0308648981,
-0.0167981982,
-0.0265855305,
0.0547582693,
-0.05443196,
-0.0472033285,
-0.0138391759,
-0.0454870872,
0.0220527202,
-0.0340282917,
0.0348643027,
0.0163398813,
0.0344181769,
-0.0385289602,
0.0361660458,
-0.0114296917,
0.0463177413,
-0.0046961377,
0.0234677158,
0.0125755016,
-0.0369794257,
-0.0224192031,
0.0234065894,
-0.0201847628,
0.0309527162,
-0.022311613,
0.0002759516,
-0.0515290238,
-0.0100109288,
-0.0596056059,
0.0165599491,
-0.023316646,
0.0190967843,
0.0388038941,
0.0001062556,
-0.0313718133,
-0.0333393253,
-0.0633750856,
-0.0416695513,
0.0146885654,
0.0228331573,
0.0462227836,
0.0348926596,
-0.0171393082,
-0.0363369472,
-0.0224198345,
-0.03688021,
0.0521088652,
-0.0283140671,
0.0236110296,
-0.0726561919,
0.0333237462,
-0.0126853539,
0.066630438,
-0.0062733395,
-0.0385709777,
0.0085798642,
-0.0344659165,
0.0442948565,
0.0444516689,
0.0074786679,
-0.0203128606,
0.0436573662,
0.015357147,
-0.0631916523,
0.0152250594,
-0.0374886431,
-0.0226403475,
-0.0491343662,
-0.0510680899,
0.0008942732,
0.0655970424,
0.0064700115,
-0.0131546753,
-0.041843459,
0.0174183603,
0.0165686179,
-0.0302649159,
-0.0473430306,
0.0075219716,
-0.0240395125,
0.0269224215,
-0.0335766971,
-0.0402864218,
0.0523199812,
-0.0266561918,
-0.0166817792,
-0.0620784611,
0.0012703622,
-0.0493989959,
0.0093626315,
0.0144642247,
-0.0028909219,
-0.0162341744,
-0.0222072788,
-0.0678990036,
-0.0125478003,
-0.0046692584,
-0.0404199511,
0.0419446416,
-0.0223972872,
-0.002443841,
-0.0286135804,
-0.0340941064,
-0.0715534315,
-0.058955878,
0.0173391234,
-0.0166371334,
0.0111546768,
-0.023663871,
0.02314738,
-0.0328046083,
-0.0177848749,
0.0602966584,
-0.0304763503,
0.0021281675,
-0.0259065218,
0.0775302351,
0.0635574982,
-0.0106517486,
0.0084892167,
-0.0521055721,
0.0459082909,
0.0578188188,
0.047032766,
0.0307603236,
-0.0065173362,
0.0047472077,
0.0366259776,
-0.0062608835,
-0.0130378613,
0.04726189,
0.03006001,
-0.0408127904,
-0.0384458564,
0.0988819301,
0.0396548882,
-0.0196925346,
0.0098281428,
0.0157686342,
0.0595995001,
0.0449558236,
0.0470612757,
-0.0907316953,
-0.0164149664,
-0.0169157367,
0.0216896553,
-0.0084604947,
-0.0186708644,
-0.0089126006,
-0.1750640273,
0.0175910126,
-0.005553971,
-0.078833729,
-0.0356308818,
-0.0452818349,
-0.0186614357,
0.0021300407,
0.025015166,
0.0161009431,
-0.0408605561,
0.0064979875,
0.0573061332,
-0.0197687559,
-0.0579118095,
0.0228663366,
-0.0289492141,
0.0685256496,
0.051669009,
0.0247001834,
-0.0019082023,
-0.0048791198,
0.0323060192,
-0.0196460448,
-0.0030815741,
-0.002006894,
0.09126959,
-0.0203124285,
-0.0142931649,
0.0121325096,
0.0186534245,
-0.0369853936,
0.0199390892,
0.0089197122,
0.0774931908,
0.0048003802,
-0.0311821606,
-0.0316696838,
-0.0247163642,
0.0075500021,
0.0769157857,
0.0496540144,
-0.0502719022,
-0.0539858118,
-0.0199586116,
-0.0319379158,
-0.0756467506,
-0.0276464447,
0.0475128479,
0.0087737842,
0.0058939084,
-0.0812554434,
-0.0805933625,
0.0351257399,
0.0047833081,
-0.0107308747,
0.0145724053,
-0.0283705126,
-0.0119232452,
-0.0471955277,
0.0404201932,
-0.0331420898,
0.0163969509,
-0.0626229271,
-0.0172647014,
0.012413892,
-0.0099786557,
-0.0081738606,
-0.011508734,
-0.089993313,
-0.0744631588,
-0.0007543662,
0.0528502055,
0.0153329987,
0.0665675476,
0.0113991126,
-0.0260174107,
0.024466427,
0.0478738993,
-0.0310271233,
-0.0172269214,
0.0476596467,
-0.0223554149,
0.0000904348,
0.0131452689,
-0.0043120976,
0.0113455476,
0.041083239,
0.0341956913,
-0.0415283628,
-0.0064914082,
0.0455662981,
0.0231237914,
0.0243114494,
0.0202255063,
-0.0010876441,
-0.0245541502,
0.0498638526,
-0.0356321111,
-0.0115650957,
-0.0511143468,
0.0192991309,
0.020029109,
0.0168923624,
-0.0079613561,
-0.0005924327,
-0.0260553006,
0.0353877209,
-0.0193282962,
-0.003315828,
0.0282555632,
0.0140047949,
0.0362049416,
0.0050303885,
-0.0173827801,
0.0099323932,
0.0337926224,
0.0584542006,
0.0065852604,
0.0420859009,
0.0077405106,
0.0054391827,
0.006191222,
-0.0061258161,
-0.0658166185,
-0.0499539636,
-0.0597167388,
0.0219336618,
0.0191447884,
-0.0182665102,
0.0302262548,
0.0134307854,
0.0004472261,
-0.0160625558,
0.0110033462,
-0.0221195463,
-0.0073828637,
0.0408690497,
0.0311225727,
-0.0262927208,
-0.009547499,
0.0885099024,
0.0325100645,
0.0644458085,
-0.0129601778,
0.0265800003,
-0.0391069986,
-0.0137311211,
0.030039655,
-0.021964062,
-0.0242752302,
-0.0131015098,
-0.0254370347,
-0.0822702125,
-0.0315206572,
0.0211571977,
0.015628159,
-0.0004441237,
0.0262863096,
0.0456327759,
0.0018940112,
0.0061553265,
-0.0640500262,
0.0118051609,
-0.0241523348,
-0.0340469144,
-0.0160782319,
-6.223566678e-33,
-0.002831406,
-0.0117587438,
0.0237849988,
-0.029692959,
-0.0176444612,
-0.0007241098,
-0.0199123602,
-0.0045684623,
-0.0414722078,
-0.0183818415,
-0.0311821885,
0.0311940052,
0.0150530161,
0.029183045,
-0.0001559094,
-0.0256751236,
0.0508234017,
-0.0249339137,
-0.0021591212,
0.0221447069,
0.026197644,
0.0146409348,
0.0590998083,
-0.0362726711,
0.0009110677,
-0.0406128466,
0.0159542598,
0.0302350391,
-0.05293037,
0.0685170144,
-0.0325809531,
0.0593678951,
0.0248473343,
-0.0144584505,
-0.0393910035,
0.0383707881,
-0.0533025824,
-0.030357495,
0.0281094406,
0.0160948224,
-0.0250894371,
-0.0224360768,
0.0191709679,
-0.015113188,
0.0124997394,
-0.0115748728,
0.0205279775,
-0.0183269177,
-0.0170754194,
0.0009973998,
-0.0450298414,
0.0188321564,
0.0039896923,
0.0045327065,
-0.0085297208,
0.0872479007,
0.0210648738,
-0.0092665693,
-0.0441534035,
0.0287976116,
0.0501957387,
0.0659868047,
0.0371172503,
0.0455863364,
-0.0076543917,
0.0319402069,
0.05187352,
0.0230738427,
0.0278267395,
0.0125422152,
0.0345734321,
0.0220986623,
0.0585640818,
0.0733231828,
0.0712114275,
0.0004393886,
-0.0711410195,
0.0176993869,
-0.0017603835,
-0.0164924022,
0.0073549277,
-0.0200678855,
-0.0436337031,
-0.0287146606,
-0.043446973,
0.0154285543,
-0.033837229,
-0.0116290366,
0.0506864153,
0.0128936144,
-0.0153245116,
0.0149728283,
0.0379393212,
-0.0494828559,
-0.0176281985,
-0.0027291572,
-0.0350999273,
0.0339021683,
0.0004650785,
0.0162533168,
-0.0652730465,
-0.0505801141,
0.0293152872,
-0.027024379,
0.0150885861,
0.0164685678,
0.0405051969,
0.0151173417,
-0.0787201673,
-0.0062499265,
-0.0276569501,
0.0340714641,
-0.0052611833,
0.003262769,
0.0235133879,
0.0062566861,
-0.0101074697,
0.0562442616,
0.0036912248,
0.0071361489,
-0.048952125,
-0.0139495833,
0.0040946295,
0.0417592078,
-0.0031228552,
-0.0101237046,
-0.0521464646,
0.0227694642,
0.0300967507,
-0.0735885948,
-0.0137701752,
0.0236535948,
2.423e-7,
0.0420340374,
0.0128836269,
0.0516863577,
0.0210589077,
0.0027259893,
0.0162680317,
-0.004457836,
0.0224332977,
0.03756449,
0.0054973583,
0.0073540546,
0.013464191,
0.0506923348,
0.023523327,
-0.1079632863,
-0.0213852581,
-0.075972341,
-0.0108298166,
-0.0738561526,
-0.0173765011,
0.0270797648,
0.1222472116,
-0.0180919115,
-0.0197873674,
0.002702707,
0.0099311965,
0.0410987884,
-0.0123720495,
-0.0219663586,
0.0418981463,
-0.0038711084,
-0.0011832578,
0.008979449,
0.0074853702,
-0.0271506179,
0.0280454308,
-0.0159962326,
0.0555934645,
0.0072159995,
-0.0446907245,
0.0044303862,
-0.0140737975,
-0.0079527991,
-0.0568919666,
0.0691097081,
-0.0448423512,
-0.0143821333,
-0.0280685704,
-0.0188128203,
-0.0040121423,
0.0197120011,
-0.0378965996,
0.0090019396,
0.017662257,
0.0287648533,
-0.0258654412,
0.007101099,
-0.0573139712,
-0.0252113789,
0.0143376943,
-0.0264786873,
-0.0532675162,
-0.0300080683,
-0.0062895278,
0.0121438289,
-0.0395667963,
0.0018954639,
2.450880237e-34,
0.02580663,
0.0013889222,
0.0442700014,
0.0309347436,
0.015215829,
-0.0298178382,
-0.0077453665,
0.0242902692,
0.0266938824,
-0.0676409453,
-0.0444298983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12946v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12946v1 | Instruction Data Generation and Unsupervised Adaptation for Speech Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:27:00 | 2024-06-18T08:27:00 | Vahid Noroozi, Zhehuai Chen, Somshubra Majumdar, Steve Huang, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose three methods for generating synthetic samples to
train and evaluate multimodal large language models capable of processing both
text and speech inputs. Addressing the scarcity of samples containing both
modalities, synthetic data generation emerges as a crucial strategy to enhance
the performance of such systems and facilitate the modeling of cross-modal
relationships between the speech and text domains. Our process employs large
language models to generate textual components and text-to-speech systems to
generate speech components. The proposed methods offer a practical and
effective means to expand the training dataset for these models. Experimental
results show progress in achieving an integrated understanding of text and
speech. We also highlight the potential of using unlabeled speech data to
generate synthetic samples comparable in quality to those with available
transcriptions, enabling the expansion of these models to more languages. | [
0.0179555193,
0.0681667626,
-0.0145568987,
0.0322830528,
-0.0279245768,
-0.0058123693,
0.045647718,
-0.0188067686,
-0.0264941342,
-0.0934974104,
-0.0687451586,
-0.0501748063,
0.0004961482,
0.0299609508,
0.0635799095,
-0.0771179795,
0.0288026966,
-0.0874251351,
-0.0667146295,
0.0039748107,
0.0228551216,
0.0513555743,
-0.0359578021,
0.0207971763,
-0.048725415,
0.0010224663,
-0.020388104,
-0.0075281099,
-0.0188570749,
-0.0106736859,
-0.0278801434,
0.0191592388,
0.0579973944,
0.0215784758,
0.0000017148,
-0.0405283831,
0.0061398912,
0.0129214767,
-0.0200736634,
0.0121892309,
0.0923234895,
-0.0107182711,
-0.0196364094,
0.0359870829,
-0.0053381459,
-0.0384662524,
0.0524200648,
0.034029033,
0.0601720624,
0.0873223394,
-0.0197268054,
-0.0214963891,
0.0113192117,
0.0027533353,
0.0139445905,
0.019512238,
0.012027164,
0.0006923005,
0.0296698958,
0.0095604872,
-0.0331959203,
0.0303310379,
0.0072392127,
-0.0222944357,
-0.001580586,
0.0252023432,
0.0048299185,
-0.0459507816,
-0.0399750732,
0.0886534899,
0.0021220886,
-0.0239343215,
0.0051305387,
0.0075438861,
-0.0209667385,
0.0163197741,
-0.0234352536,
0.0395938419,
0.0236479435,
0.0203761123,
0.0102952747,
-0.0290189292,
0.0150870373,
-0.0190348495,
-0.0117602134,
-0.0037564684,
0.0407806672,
-0.0276813898,
0.0046204119,
-0.0213484541,
-0.0025093425,
-0.0287000835,
0.0038477117,
0.0261245891,
-0.0165161267,
0.0167848356,
-0.0776358545,
-0.0581835359,
-0.0244755875,
-0.0198646337,
0.0684841052,
0.0043567084,
-0.0503466539,
0.0140609993,
-0.0262059961,
0.0159360524,
-0.0194097087,
0.013618933,
-0.0404167883,
-0.011401129,
-0.0367093347,
0.0144473696,
-0.0454072505,
0.0079238713,
-0.0883565098,
-0.0286417287,
-0.0010155967,
0.0192846339,
0.0107037071,
-0.0259399321,
0.0550486371,
-0.0091021191,
-0.0772322863,
-0.0117668835,
-0.010526238,
0.0103712101,
-0.0030174856,
0.0543204024,
-0.0052040657,
-0.061457064,
0.022550378,
0.0460261367,
0.0198447015,
-0.0128864106,
0.0283255819,
0.095490396,
-0.0468625464,
-0.0135912383,
-0.0649452657,
-0.0150705492,
-0.0314569063,
-0.0657088086,
0.0248171836,
-0.0693933591,
0.0411123745,
-0.0147121269,
-0.0017675495,
-0.0065979827,
0.0171047002,
-0.0099981241,
0.001536791,
0.0738356784,
-0.0075593186,
0.0381460451,
0.0295614284,
-0.0416422337,
0.0599513762,
0.0718851015,
0.0718255267,
-0.0157220308,
0.0217195116,
-0.0296615884,
-0.0104493406,
0.0802346319,
-0.000290783,
0.0121622831,
-0.0241781175,
-0.017763637,
0.0300945845,
0.019438928,
0.0353257023,
0.0614100136,
-0.020474948,
0.0064372825,
0.059358377,
0.0144739877,
0.0365189202,
0.0255251843,
0.1080397069,
0.0130099552,
0.002497955,
-0.0117262937,
-0.0099958936,
-0.0075653438,
0.0048242137,
0.0247574951,
0.0171658192,
0.0487295911,
-0.042006541,
-0.0294944383,
-0.0000548782,
-0.0103259757,
-0.006189554,
0.0037881613,
0.0746804252,
0.0603411645,
-0.0565461107,
0.0090654148,
0.0398352444,
-0.0461869501,
0.0509200171,
0.0016499609,
0.0072990614,
0.0669482723,
0.0061886609,
-0.0111542689,
0.0188656151,
-0.012503664,
0.0054236529,
0.0639785305,
0.0326307081,
-0.026473837,
0.0201633312,
-0.0692283884,
-0.0086187832,
0.0145155778,
0.0010569898,
0.0515234694,
-0.0220942833,
-0.0052025947,
-0.0003965415,
-0.0336586423,
-0.0071874838,
0.043467056,
-0.0373220183,
-0.0368226208,
0.0151617387,
-0.0132980281,
0.0533595532,
0.0273481049,
-0.0416844971,
0.0090205111,
0.0271544214,
-0.0348514616,
0.0287589766,
0.0100345118,
-0.0684621409,
-0.0286833234,
0.0169155523,
-0.0415485352,
0.0125691006,
0.0249208417,
0.0158992931,
-0.0623274744,
0.0287474133,
-0.0680089518,
0.0289669149,
-0.0581416488,
0.0135155125,
0.0313000344,
0.0132799568,
0.0029124888,
0.004145565,
0.0249361191,
-0.015084384,
0.0358473845,
0.0511518531,
-0.017230114,
-0.0479797013,
-0.0112009123,
0.0208781455,
-0.0143020181,
0.0359470434,
-0.0247243997,
0.0081059486,
-0.0254764855,
-0.0250996593,
-0.1014703214,
0.0081484085,
-0.0081668682,
0.0123608587,
0.0284612197,
0.0075031798,
-0.0064826384,
0.0038235453,
-0.0253263004,
-0.0111334259,
0.0387325622,
0.004222176,
-0.0194881801,
0.0087979157,
-0.0279715247,
-0.0249705557,
-0.002268885,
-0.0056301965,
0.0638869703,
-0.0118774706,
-0.0056040213,
-0.0651200488,
0.0243642312,
0.0108194174,
0.0734964311,
0.0054057059,
-0.0628410578,
0.0140127083,
-0.0244296286,
0.0879350975,
0.0231005196,
0.0208948608,
0.0202202909,
0.0375366397,
-0.0356349461,
-0.0506174192,
0.0178310424,
-0.0207672361,
0.0040228921,
-0.051094491,
-0.026237024,
-0.0218911543,
0.0707416907,
0.0254446417,
0.012174895,
-0.0488633476,
-0.0091999983,
-0.0038699538,
-0.065149188,
-0.0085395928,
-0.0024135704,
-0.04748464,
-0.0042832838,
-0.0184529144,
-0.0317960493,
0.0133408969,
-0.0885684118,
-0.0346701965,
-0.0453143828,
-0.0283811241,
0.0002881281,
0.0356730446,
0.0105036153,
0.0214533135,
-0.0039893719,
-0.0044939546,
-0.0410129689,
0.0241869967,
0.0229526423,
-0.0298665389,
0.0039154477,
-0.0501156375,
0.0088425074,
0.0083785523,
-0.0021743523,
-0.0433209985,
-0.0261568855,
0.0021789914,
0.0036910251,
0.0085643316,
-0.0117218085,
-0.012431412,
0.0209680852,
0.0328915417,
0.0460577831,
0.0078504048,
0.0184151493,
-0.0428776965,
0.035153985,
0.0540245324,
0.0226162691,
-0.0525762588,
-0.0516060814,
0.0302749369,
-0.0137836225,
0.0486798733,
0.0160712264,
-0.047643356,
0.0345272459,
0.0003617684,
0.028831115,
-0.00778346,
0.0417300686,
0.0304415394,
-0.0435141772,
0.0010638915,
0.0722875744,
-0.0022287709,
-0.0225202944,
-0.0039544888,
0.0359496698,
0.0113563668,
0.0157485846,
0.0193127077,
-0.045679152,
-0.0315314084,
0.0154959168,
0.0130611053,
-0.0080296025,
0.015390872,
-0.0262207948,
-0.1461726576,
0.040915966,
0.0170188062,
-0.0725806653,
-0.0448489748,
-0.0295372512,
-0.0072025498,
0.0183680393,
0.0186801143,
0.0107814372,
-0.0304434355,
-0.0221810173,
0.053642828,
-0.0017401638,
-0.0764180869,
-0.0074101123,
-0.0230507404,
0.0841483846,
0.0426462181,
0.015132579,
0.0018115147,
-0.0254373085,
0.0339933969,
-0.0137780644,
-0.0073044021,
-0.008950131,
0.0395908915,
-0.0096902587,
-0.0304591805,
0.0044940286,
0.0790631697,
0.0005858457,
0.001602459,
-0.0069383299,
0.0696381554,
-0.002372504,
-0.0102338884,
-0.0064391308,
0.019533705,
0.0261929035,
0.0445777103,
0.0136557175,
-0.0961293653,
-0.0066539259,
0.0058293631,
-0.0193465669,
-0.0533098765,
-0.0451621935,
0.0378607288,
-0.0696910769,
-0.0063047535,
-0.0681222305,
-0.0101270983,
0.0363057293,
0.0653752312,
0.0311015323,
-0.016399309,
0.0164850019,
-0.0069519226,
-0.0361575484,
0.0421620645,
-0.0399718508,
0.0310039259,
-0.0413973518,
-0.067095764,
0.0228583962,
-0.0766539797,
0.0008347835,
0.0082393615,
-0.0449906886,
-0.0618371032,
0.0023599272,
0.0292020086,
0.0161476657,
0.0715391189,
0.0026452281,
-0.0388699174,
0.0497746691,
0.035950359,
-0.0560388416,
0.0089570098,
0.0296510458,
-0.0184513647,
-0.008337046,
-0.0050003477,
-0.0431672074,
0.0481896177,
0.020934049,
0.0306690931,
-0.0096497564,
-0.0182099603,
0.0173092708,
0.0247967094,
0.0207392387,
-0.0185345672,
0.0100991605,
-0.0747091547,
0.0066803684,
-0.0088722315,
0.0092309183,
-0.0715850145,
0.0112434793,
0.0292499755,
0.0414724126,
-0.0012403585,
-0.0150662828,
0.0030766863,
0.0151475593,
0.0030961393,
0.0344521217,
0.0348932147,
0.0468501747,
0.0066002328,
0.0153266257,
0.002898003,
0.0219282228,
-0.0222058818,
0.012046109,
-0.0020838922,
0.0510059223,
-0.0174378958,
-0.0294331368,
-0.0127898278,
-0.0087715108,
-0.0203590132,
0.0211101864,
-0.0832812339,
0.0481707714,
0.0439977646,
-0.0169887003,
0.0534534305,
-0.0303795263,
0.0043634577,
-0.0186783224,
0.0577972494,
-0.014673247,
-0.0090913968,
0.023700932,
0.0040728259,
-0.0114653101,
-0.0080633489,
0.0634407327,
0.0511245988,
0.0704505742,
-0.0250075236,
0.0418863893,
-0.0568095855,
-0.0313755162,
0.0131787658,
-0.0014806417,
-0.0243658572,
0.0087781288,
-0.0024003822,
-0.0732246637,
-0.0214684121,
0.0440110192,
0.0017575186,
-0.0065488676,
0.0624625385,
-0.0008817447,
-0.0404399335,
0.0228184033,
-0.0259320829,
0.0049842438,
0.0130143045,
-0.0216112267,
0.0010207325,
-5.687979493e-33,
-0.0365416668,
0.0144678624,
0.0351092182,
-0.0005610997,
-0.0450467654,
-0.0120118652,
-0.0063841478,
0.0111312224,
0.0257727131,
-0.003855818,
0.0141428774,
-0.0116379093,
0.0131366113,
0.0538241267,
-0.014233212,
0.0209911261,
0.0658394024,
-0.0635271668,
0.0144085083,
0.0387555286,
0.0450887233,
0.0122598931,
0.0547018014,
-0.0612380169,
-0.0090127019,
-0.0084935501,
-0.0120716626,
-0.00042611,
0.0127607351,
0.0835361108,
-0.0362266824,
0.0580386929,
-0.0046375529,
-0.0347619578,
-0.0397625081,
0.0556351095,
-0.0587387271,
0.0173987038,
0.0555560589,
0.0270969998,
-0.0543734543,
-0.027064966,
0.0165941678,
-0.0192859527,
-0.0153252119,
0.0035975964,
0.0320687816,
-0.0408915244,
0.0254921708,
-0.0287351683,
-0.0627280548,
0.0090755057,
-0.0113464557,
-0.0326857641,
0.0317027308,
0.0731102675,
-0.0026180628,
-0.0215136223,
-0.0005999254,
0.0557369106,
0.0012972904,
0.0395140573,
0.0653878599,
0.0453787819,
0.0196492597,
0.0502835922,
0.0348677821,
-0.0428721569,
0.0101201599,
-0.0133427596,
0.0458286293,
0.0501378216,
0.0136556067,
0.1033475026,
-0.0049674744,
-0.0010448071,
-0.0311890952,
0.0009248233,
0.0008415454,
-0.0234462302,
0.032924328,
-0.0048951129,
0.0179830808,
0.0154954381,
-0.0757557377,
-0.0190113056,
-0.0207715333,
0.0002534091,
0.0634778589,
0.0314183198,
-0.0318188444,
-0.0075832643,
0.0856757611,
-0.0334335789,
-0.0121637974,
-0.0387496501,
-0.022757899,
0.0218074694,
-0.017666677,
0.0126098283,
-0.053266231,
-0.0781273916,
0.0832275748,
0.0000417211,
0.0114633739,
-0.0035136051,
-0.0265388172,
0.0331566222,
-0.0501755364,
0.00674984,
-0.0242068265,
0.0444611982,
-0.0044605024,
0.0187134389,
0.0418738462,
0.0014392772,
-0.0386568755,
0.0306975991,
-0.013398543,
-0.0184162073,
-0.0153797893,
-0.0479786359,
-0.0079117715,
0.0642068312,
-0.0480703898,
0.0293454994,
-0.0486311987,
-0.0523151681,
0.0427835248,
-0.0432345457,
0.0007848499,
0.0445934311,
2.538e-7,
-0.00118489,
0.0138999354,
0.004876669,
-0.0045199413,
0.0467897542,
0.0161280613,
-0.0232399441,
0.0310257357,
0.0171850547,
-0.0322122276,
-0.0242461413,
0.0008848577,
0.0680388957,
0.0143190362,
-0.0591341965,
-0.021273721,
-0.0301548298,
0.0296741091,
-0.0648972467,
0.0059514581,
0.0121272085,
0.0970029682,
-0.0498373546,
-0.0361944139,
-0.0015326564,
-0.0083860625,
0.0542120375,
-0.0421131216,
-0.0335594863,
-0.0051564309,
-0.013780416,
0.007889878,
-0.0126029532,
0.0167869236,
-0.0281253587,
0.0170352459,
0.0285609663,
0.05438127,
0.0104782544,
-0.0195845459,
0.0324734934,
0.0145446407,
-0.0650464594,
-0.000073158,
0.0373436064,
-0.0254039783,
0.0083276778,
-0.0375209451,
-0.011362562,
0.0087849991,
-0.0481078699,
-0.060803175,
-0.0048651244,
0.0327403136,
0.0409311689,
-0.0118396403,
-0.0126509862,
-0.026448423,
-0.0106558185,
0.0200381726,
-0.075489454,
-0.0495792702,
-0.0374082886,
-0.0168997962,
0.033582665,
-0.0538522303,
-0.0163997822,
2.068828961e-34,
0.0098208841,
-0.0124845086,
0.020007195,
-0.0323664509,
0.0005229286,
-0.0300064497,
0.0047487668,
0.0166422836,
0.0089817578,
-0.0937793925,
-0.0445828512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12389v1 | EMO-KNOW: A Large Scale Dataset on Emotion and Emotion-cause | 2024-06-18T08:26:33 | 2024-06-18T08:26:33 | Mia Huong Nguyen, Yasith Samaradivakara, Prasanth Sasikumar, Chitralekha Gupta, Suranga Nanayakkara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion-Cause analysis has attracted the attention of researchers in recent
years. However, most existing datasets are limited in size and number of
emotion categories. They often focus on extracting parts of the document that
contain the emotion cause and fail to provide more abstractive, generalizable
root cause. To bridge this gap, we introduce a large-scale dataset of emotion
causes, derived from 9.8 million cleaned tweets over 15 years. We describe our
curation process, which includes a comprehensive pipeline for data gathering,
cleaning, labeling, and validation, ensuring the dataset's reliability and
richness. We extract emotion labels and provide abstractive summarization of
the events causing emotions. The final dataset comprises over 700,000 tweets
with corresponding emotion-cause pairs spanning 48 emotion classes, validated
by human evaluators. The novelty of our dataset stems from its broad spectrum
of emotion classes and the abstractive emotion cause that facilitates the
development of an emotion-cause knowledge graph for nuanced reasoning. Our
dataset will enable the design of emotion-aware systems that account for the
diverse emotional responses of different people for the same event. | [
0.0295601208,
0.0671598464,
-0.0004464653,
-0.0177375227,
0.0390267037,
0.0431576818,
-0.0085170278,
0.0084980996,
0.0507046357,
-0.0031768004,
0.009426767,
0.0334345214,
-0.0610079058,
0.042996347,
-0.0024310024,
-0.0819037557,
-0.0089499885,
0.0865357444,
0.0702307299,
-0.0134448968,
0.0530213676,
0.0631422102,
-0.0001730915,
0.0277207885,
-0.0472272933,
-0.0218960606,
-0.0118931187,
0.0331383459,
0.0364653841,
-0.0330411643,
0.0440967754,
0.0261905137,
0.0072943396,
0.0115268659,
0.00000229,
0.0021117867,
-0.0294749308,
-0.0449790247,
0.0166856032,
-0.0435812213,
0.0740822926,
-0.0388456769,
0.0011352999,
0.0194326136,
-0.0089528849,
-0.0200176053,
0.0396309793,
0.0677169114,
0.0894076377,
0.0782874152,
-0.0501187071,
0.0104335351,
-0.0399918742,
-0.0061832862,
0.007295195,
0.0344476923,
0.0272281338,
-0.0210142322,
0.0051489328,
-0.0762038231,
-0.0006718076,
-0.0012755799,
-0.007249176,
0.0093797492,
0.0168186165,
-0.0020539449,
-0.017391257,
-0.0387152061,
0.0106509812,
0.0833200365,
-0.0024178773,
-0.0089879222,
0.0548030175,
-0.0206035357,
0.0044386713,
-0.0029850218,
-0.020332193,
-0.0013099835,
-0.0300857313,
0.0428159945,
-0.0252405182,
0.0134973591,
0.038499549,
0.0491622463,
0.0166343208,
0.0234594066,
-0.0267703589,
-0.0263125319,
0.0177718159,
-0.0064246645,
-0.0114883976,
-0.0359347947,
-0.0040188818,
-0.0146888094,
-0.0348241888,
0.0210564211,
-0.0373722613,
-0.040759135,
-0.0137187159,
-0.0362870768,
-0.0430357642,
0.0052400706,
0.0280684233,
0.006427818,
0.0787605494,
-0.0470842533,
-0.0056457166,
-0.0012598663,
-0.0196336973,
-0.0232650507,
-0.0482657254,
0.0203166362,
-0.0094953701,
-0.0119880997,
-0.0108183064,
-0.0020347992,
-0.0777340829,
-0.0075601847,
-0.0542560034,
0.0156556293,
-0.027607061,
0.0233361367,
0.0029729498,
-0.0081746019,
0.0061384803,
0.0029385781,
-0.0491099246,
0.0442096181,
0.0094887139,
-0.0221515037,
0.0291920304,
-0.0293679275,
0.0439538844,
0.001115018,
0.0153853074,
-0.0032805868,
0.0328784436,
0.0014313027,
-0.0356736258,
-0.0551045313,
0.0080321273,
-0.0049490551,
-0.010141843,
-0.0380246192,
0.0469698682,
0.0120867584,
0.0277061351,
-0.0507768318,
0.0182697568,
-0.0172688309,
-0.055576358,
0.0495928302,
-0.080969736,
0.0103175193,
-0.0133671435,
0.0284315888,
0.0012278558,
0.047997348,
0.0515457951,
0.0761320814,
0.093140699,
-0.0299528167,
0.0240435563,
-0.0100380545,
0.026697753,
-0.036238607,
0.0146093834,
-0.0406511836,
-0.0772854835,
0.0439410061,
-0.0138445366,
0.0004919085,
-0.00901262,
0.0004497764,
0.0279804952,
0.0425118767,
-0.0196692999,
0.06434609,
-0.0434436873,
0.0297861323,
0.0161591209,
-0.0729321912,
-0.0023011123,
0.0315450989,
-0.0146665452,
-0.0028804359,
0.0046979398,
0.0106246164,
-0.0483914763,
-0.0340190642,
-0.0401895791,
-0.0017086099,
-0.0327347517,
-0.000206354,
0.0161707569,
-0.0210483577,
-0.0471398383,
0.0153232617,
0.0327063315,
-0.1137270108,
-0.0179107282,
-0.0123282028,
0.0226633325,
0.0626816824,
0.0197941307,
-0.0581697896,
-0.0202039573,
-0.0227606129,
0.0129016377,
0.0200099591,
-0.0012097721,
-0.0165328421,
0.0070067053,
-0.0556991026,
0.0032286809,
0.0203049611,
-0.007402638,
0.0034259812,
-0.0182717498,
0.0272367392,
-0.0336834043,
0.0025954116,
-0.0164704621,
0.0016948819,
-0.0400532223,
-0.0161816422,
0.0066536926,
0.030618595,
0.0342678428,
0.0392785408,
0.0017126226,
-0.0286651887,
0.0240742508,
-0.0091339136,
-0.0433308706,
0.0454909727,
0.0056328746,
-0.0092616575,
0.0394518971,
-0.0507473536,
-0.0418059044,
0.0598209016,
-0.0756965503,
-0.032581795,
0.0439429507,
0.0103134476,
0.0192694869,
-0.001933926,
-0.0294731837,
-0.0178071801,
0.0174614657,
0.0414287187,
0.0553417243,
0.0106292609,
-0.0146751218,
-0.0272511709,
-0.0358221829,
-0.0007284381,
0.0034170877,
-0.0423307791,
-0.0067261131,
0.0013486408,
0.0078677125,
0.018249156,
-0.0458061583,
-0.1120753363,
-0.0387152992,
-0.0914284959,
0.0148891564,
-0.0029423982,
-0.0220835935,
0.018686194,
0.0040815938,
-0.0227346886,
0.0034860994,
-0.0108135454,
0.0484814048,
0.0151653849,
0.0162155274,
0.0277798939,
-0.0324045308,
0.0336615555,
-0.0665875524,
-0.0002720267,
-0.04949411,
0.0204229001,
0.0185089912,
0.0125623774,
0.0249642134,
0.0426726937,
-0.0588376075,
0.0077787144,
0.0100860214,
-0.0419678837,
-0.0078976462,
-0.024852192,
0.0103681302,
0.0211057179,
0.0018481454,
0.0960072428,
-0.0082441261,
-0.0122498795,
-0.0351896659,
0.0285034664,
-0.0324281305,
0.0234780069,
-0.0191708561,
-0.0460539199,
-0.0487153716,
0.0651764125,
0.0019478797,
-0.0007640327,
-0.0535022244,
0.0171637423,
0.0010609841,
-0.0159445573,
-0.0383955054,
-0.0265979227,
0.0035094109,
0.0219958015,
-0.0278392844,
-0.0487374328,
0.008631018,
0.0663787723,
0.0051048305,
-0.0125276344,
-0.0083328467,
-0.0078555727,
0.0727603659,
-0.0422952659,
0.0013245642,
0.0207910314,
0.0226440486,
0.0251539536,
-0.0660026073,
-0.0133992815,
-0.0463208519,
0.00828207,
-0.0409125499,
-0.0076816599,
0.0341776311,
-0.0536562018,
-0.01995969,
-0.0709010139,
-0.057441473,
-0.029896155,
-0.016139552,
-0.0255269129,
-0.0227567609,
-0.0660055801,
0.0260570664,
-0.0248098634,
0.0277475733,
-0.0394894369,
0.0200518742,
0.0183345787,
0.0487725921,
-0.0252143238,
0.0294880886,
-0.0117303086,
0.0400807485,
0.059808448,
0.0607892573,
-0.0381147414,
-0.0180843268,
0.0409317836,
-0.0253195148,
0.012119527,
0.028370209,
-0.0635661706,
0.0387146436,
-0.0209666677,
0.0397873148,
0.1046546549,
0.020370217,
-0.0199078526,
0.0303389952,
0.0130292745,
0.0104480311,
0.0168923195,
0.021392433,
-0.0408166349,
-0.0244571902,
-0.010744717,
0.0474471971,
-0.000040541,
-0.059940964,
0.007030264,
-0.061519742,
0.0391119979,
-0.0024973084,
0.0121818632,
-0.0345419757,
-0.0140878763,
0.0173243247,
-0.0405820943,
-0.0389307514,
-0.0491853543,
0.0131517844,
-0.0022701628,
0.031987451,
-0.0129560838,
-0.0347248316,
0.0419990644,
-0.0136666568,
0.0468518026,
-0.0435470194,
0.1121630371,
0.0072087413,
-0.023907043,
-0.001011668,
0.0118087176,
-0.0334380046,
0.0034287982,
0.078718029,
0.0169808585,
-0.0216228664,
-0.0559395552,
0.0878234059,
-0.0865843296,
-0.0061255307,
-0.0351805873,
0.0736338273,
-0.0102606462,
-0.0136301201,
-0.0361559317,
0.0089216074,
0.0252671745,
0.0215313304,
0.0362863354,
-0.0363225676,
0.0013693323,
-0.0172498878,
0.0308588147,
-0.0425118431,
-0.0309993438,
-0.016830476,
-0.041966375,
-0.0640366897,
-0.0479365177,
-0.0596747994,
0.0354851559,
-0.0014721638,
-0.0280784518,
-0.079731591,
0.0182155427,
-0.0271037277,
-0.04523056,
0.0657911599,
0.0283037387,
0.0278638452,
0.020061031,
-0.0220966283,
-0.002045963,
0.0286111906,
-0.0116346963,
-0.001601923,
-0.0187753476,
-0.038484633,
0.0487802811,
-0.0048941621,
0.0145004671,
0.0097142095,
0.019991722,
-0.0414629057,
0.0385347269,
0.0593477525,
-0.0160329882,
-0.0345501415,
0.0465263315,
0.0180597734,
0.0129259303,
0.0348128006,
-0.0400452912,
0.0473336726,
0.0047373422,
-0.0297149532,
-0.0338447317,
0.0273064412,
-0.016391661,
0.0164742302,
0.0586927161,
0.0033403547,
-0.0719245523,
-0.047415778,
-0.0309225209,
-0.0223098826,
-0.0059006982,
-0.0309279207,
-0.0000012929,
-0.0067769927,
0.0067951852,
-0.0782310739,
-0.0405452214,
-0.0050241593,
-0.0075255781,
-0.0287900437,
0.0486788377,
-0.0061775357,
0.0160291996,
-0.0093504665,
0.0170820151,
0.0241758227,
0.016825432,
-0.0026851702,
0.0044736168,
-0.0063171419,
0.0106926793,
0.0146586774,
0.0116398884,
0.0131299663,
0.0249075405,
-0.0107814902,
-0.0335403942,
0.0064804247,
-0.0190876629,
0.0269811302,
-0.0585928559,
0.0683438927,
-0.0320910215,
0.0039856532,
0.003508687,
0.0163469482,
-0.0355083495,
-0.030091675,
0.0121744638,
0.0080040395,
-0.0210813936,
0.0017578554,
0.0322870128,
-0.085380584,
0.0807731152,
0.0305333603,
-0.0297368523,
-0.0132570639,
0.0393439122,
0.0578651652,
-0.0126029691,
-0.002826486,
0.0320006013,
-0.0742130652,
-0.0481104143,
0.0257999077,
-0.0419559404,
-0.0232864972,
-0.0002133708,
0.0299693495,
0.0437620692,
-0.0162235573,
0.0486702807,
-0.0394849665,
0.0217016935,
-0.0928606465,
-0.0363482013,
0.0139654325,
-6.596462139e-33,
0.0594692864,
-0.0149866538,
-0.0408731028,
-0.0101029603,
-0.0350796953,
0.0447334237,
-0.0269735549,
-0.0062452084,
0.0233121403,
0.0814395696,
-0.0513767563,
0.0798056871,
0.0013042858,
0.0246184673,
0.0228835251,
-0.0060724234,
0.0197199099,
-0.0125129502,
0.0042381515,
0.0713040903,
0.0718566403,
0.0558325388,
0.039886225,
-0.107823953,
0.0174342785,
0.014295348,
-0.0143920463,
-0.0004935845,
0.0621548519,
0.0296420343,
0.0046635759,
0.0809751824,
0.0040775631,
-0.0049572457,
-0.0027127974,
0.034126658,
-0.0333899595,
-0.0326968841,
-0.0227547418,
-0.0235090628,
-0.0479208529,
-0.0268472861,
0.0052804165,
0.0354513377,
0.0052801301,
-0.0460879095,
0.0443325117,
0.0045799888,
0.0452785231,
-0.0582271293,
0.0253091566,
0.0324974842,
-0.0553634949,
-0.0282776281,
0.0292884912,
0.0412731357,
0.0015194761,
0.0401976742,
-0.0446493924,
0.0223932303,
-0.0456333123,
-0.0315253064,
-0.0041283192,
-0.0559748672,
0.0139967697,
0.0809495226,
-0.0065261112,
0.036898233,
-0.0271581337,
0.0629367903,
-0.0442887843,
0.081257008,
0.0210675355,
0.0452529676,
0.0196406003,
-0.0492208116,
-0.032546673,
0.0598697886,
0.0046801288,
0.0211157836,
0.0104315821,
0.0044529103,
-0.0024149152,
0.0112893991,
0.0165547393,
-0.0213766173,
-0.0073223747,
0.0059036538,
-0.0371891931,
-0.0476501472,
-0.0006771168,
0.0040277429,
-0.0318338349,
-0.0203369837,
-0.0094382679,
0.0223916918,
0.002590785,
0.0414024033,
0.0235708468,
0.0041332939,
-0.0167472474,
0.0099146664,
0.0180109721,
0.02421166,
0.0692784116,
0.002706469,
0.0025009788,
0.0355449878,
-0.0327933691,
0.0110171819,
-0.024955174,
0.0186401699,
-0.037041232,
-0.0131391622,
-0.0425849706,
0.0551664978,
0.0126430811,
-0.0135294748,
0.0462229326,
0.0816203281,
0.019472016,
-0.0178057868,
-0.0382537358,
0.0211915076,
-0.0030437722,
-0.0336602926,
-0.0511996225,
-0.0351720862,
0.0503790304,
-0.0206330419,
-0.0177301392,
-0.0351955853,
2.988e-7,
-0.0044527594,
0.0472211353,
0.0364040472,
-0.0039898222,
0.0179906804,
0.0718085766,
0.0008842816,
0.0407968909,
-0.0105514247,
-0.0398163833,
0.0516419224,
-0.013567036,
0.0589020327,
0.0407588221,
-0.067362085,
-0.0260051191,
-0.0246366337,
-0.0053790542,
-0.0409244038,
0.0039238781,
0.0779428855,
0.059529867,
0.0873695239,
-0.0278618615,
0.0321984924,
0.03425074,
0.0172290988,
-0.0530391224,
0.0326017626,
0.0221974738,
0.0298121721,
-0.0583321974,
-0.0064146151,
-0.0167698413,
-0.0137172565,
-0.0417790078,
0.0191617515,
0.0189207532,
0.010823125,
0.0006466198,
0.0280814022,
0.000981222,
-0.0024248981,
-0.0324683748,
0.0127588613,
-0.0441432148,
-0.051554922,
-0.0103786746,
-0.024492519,
0.0000793673,
0.0257880315,
-0.0151650133,
-0.0457912125,
0.0116791055,
-0.008642083,
-0.0071427003,
-0.0180791542,
-0.0940267816,
0.0235640947,
0.0154032577,
-0.0259059612,
-0.012516682,
0.0025270812,
0.0113152368,
0.0474040546,
-0.0357932821,
0.0176792704,
2.239730457e-34,
-0.0096549885,
0.0116941622,
-0.0451479144,
-0.0121443849,
0.0323136151,
-0.0266807601,
-0.0236270335,
-0.0277552009,
0.0304503106,
-0.0593821928,
0.0209611412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12387v1 | Performant ASR Models for Medical Entities in Accented Speech | 2024-06-18T08:19:48 | 2024-06-18T08:19:48 | Tejumade Afonja, Tobi Olatunji, Sewade Ogun, Naome A. Etori, Abraham Owodunni, Moshood Yekini | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recent strides in automatic speech recognition (ASR) have accelerated their
application in the medical domain where their performance on accented medical
named entities (NE) such as drug names, diagnoses, and lab results, is largely
unknown. We rigorously evaluate multiple ASR models on a clinical English
dataset of 93 African accents. Our analysis reveals that despite some models
achieving low overall word error rates (WER), errors in clinical entities are
higher, potentially posing substantial risks to patient safety. To empirically
demonstrate this, we extract clinical entities from transcripts, develop a
novel algorithm to align ASR predictions with these entities, and compute
medical NE Recall, medical WER, and character error rate. Our results show that
fine-tuning on accented clinical speech improves medical WER by a wide margin
(25-34 % relative), improving their practical applicability in healthcare
environments. | [
0.0259871967,
0.0865032598,
0.0137403784,
-0.0287643969,
0.0335432254,
0.0085619176,
0.0282881651,
-0.0268445946,
0.0023685098,
0.0122408839,
-0.0167368744,
-0.0887520462,
0.0601905696,
0.0124229155,
0.0294992849,
-0.0260777064,
0.0135417888,
-0.0258303545,
0.0296413619,
-0.0315188132,
-0.0116778035,
0.0274987668,
-0.0366131291,
0.071241051,
0.0165882353,
0.0556695089,
0.0225341357,
-0.0161303487,
0.034042947,
-0.0499832034,
-0.0446609296,
0.0104584983,
-0.0826145634,
-0.0123543106,
0.0000018707,
-0.0418549329,
-0.0079494631,
0.0393780358,
-0.088614054,
-0.0223955382,
0.0365836732,
-0.0215644445,
-0.0412733629,
0.0179982129,
-0.0094960053,
-0.0210468732,
0.0642772913,
0.0068935328,
-0.0089214351,
0.0467502475,
0.0082433885,
0.0113192443,
0.0188420005,
-0.0277322605,
0.0049587651,
-0.0485664345,
0.0376253836,
-0.0385247916,
-0.002356292,
-0.0316253752,
0.0049856235,
0.0169068761,
-0.040443901,
0.0121132582,
-0.0023041896,
0.033307001,
-0.0379183479,
-0.0365090854,
0.0070578735,
0.0534690693,
-0.0187614094,
-0.001843123,
0.0114517082,
0.0181892738,
-0.0314970799,
-0.0163988657,
0.0053418959,
-0.0046561477,
-0.0564931072,
0.0000985866,
0.037832614,
0.0189659763,
0.0482988209,
-0.0054188501,
-0.0474353693,
-0.0115956087,
0.0117504625,
-0.0203267839,
0.031865336,
-0.0018700765,
-0.0131997885,
-0.0007820441,
0.0388340503,
-0.0000205783,
-0.0412398167,
0.0132029168,
0.0135961147,
-0.0113846604,
0.0595257469,
-0.0376637913,
0.0138806561,
0.0005410297,
-0.0229460523,
0.0146246543,
-0.0303476769,
0.043007575,
-0.001107069,
0.0053876592,
-0.0094930632,
0.0111862784,
-0.0119987419,
0.0011134874,
-0.0039162547,
0.0132786809,
0.0016094488,
0.0234442316,
-0.0976124108,
-0.0555758514,
-0.0294678248,
0.0443324484,
0.0750268549,
0.0198374856,
-0.0219659675,
-0.0357421674,
0.0440187901,
-0.0052219937,
0.0338331871,
0.0055434313,
-0.0459047221,
-0.0816075876,
0.0303324647,
-0.0333728045,
0.0225562453,
0.0337108113,
0.0641409978,
0.0473634079,
0.0426016003,
-0.0466151312,
-0.0006194662,
-0.0046441494,
-0.05646649,
0.0149288485,
-0.0298554748,
-0.0415307954,
0.0366057307,
0.0105536953,
0.0218716934,
-0.0694502145,
0.0179905333,
-0.0124716414,
0.0023143524,
0.0605846494,
-0.0160308089,
-0.0003159212,
0.0287759099,
0.0150485188,
0.0236826055,
-0.0200091433,
0.0125616267,
-0.0704259872,
-0.0282200128,
-0.0137289641,
-0.0106138252,
0.0380060747,
0.022200115,
-0.0822884664,
0.0001190954,
-0.0073295161,
-0.0031185683,
0.0515466556,
-0.000303317,
0.0809485167,
0.02995429,
-0.03950404,
-0.0114125805,
0.0430918038,
0.0026433661,
-0.0124038067,
-0.0024037245,
-0.0440226421,
-0.0087423036,
-0.0384369195,
-0.0057684667,
-0.0339637883,
0.0299356598,
-0.0117679276,
0.0026850961,
0.0379706249,
-0.0245265439,
-0.0047976919,
-0.0204350203,
-0.045903489,
-0.0644106194,
0.0303225759,
0.0103896512,
-0.0301412009,
-0.0716303363,
0.0299921259,
0.0450880602,
-0.0286418572,
-0.0004410891,
-0.0552236326,
-0.0156395826,
0.0596641377,
0.0159875937,
0.0025134447,
-0.0368060209,
-0.0355097838,
-0.055514168,
-0.0220152549,
-0.0409795791,
-0.005431735,
0.052714631,
-0.0591797121,
0.0316895843,
0.0906132162,
0.0064730244,
0.0140117491,
0.010037805,
0.0581263602,
0.0048027621,
-0.0337791406,
-0.0159775782,
0.0090350155,
-0.0647145063,
-0.0160698537,
0.0358331874,
-0.0063372487,
0.0396231152,
0.0335490629,
-0.0248090997,
0.0291955378,
-0.0149209844,
-0.0477615409,
-0.0030780069,
0.0393195264,
-0.0625679567,
-0.0224570055,
0.0193339884,
-0.0113305151,
0.0391655341,
-0.0283922087,
0.0217621271,
-0.0393830948,
-0.0217999294,
-0.0550852828,
0.0484818146,
-0.0029030729,
0.0429342203,
0.0436200537,
0.0228364915,
-0.0063744131,
-0.0314577445,
-0.0177395642,
0.0170706231,
0.0192648564,
-0.0156166553,
-0.0185470767,
-0.0244668052,
-0.0146846985,
0.0384220108,
-0.0027306268,
0.0055745188,
-0.032614693,
-0.0176740699,
0.0069624176,
-0.0122360354,
-0.0994801894,
-0.0251539014,
0.0262592584,
0.0119659351,
0.0103721824,
0.0414927974,
0.014755534,
-0.008819635,
-0.0146172065,
-0.0622254349,
6.82e-8,
-0.0205776058,
-0.0323000289,
-0.0010186156,
-0.0307634231,
-0.0182269979,
0.0159191042,
-0.0168204512,
0.006359708,
-0.0116642257,
-0.0373574607,
-0.0115152569,
-0.0135107823,
0.0154262222,
-0.0050957897,
-0.0013114805,
-0.0092257718,
-0.0090418709,
-0.0026593255,
-0.0042380095,
0.0401192829,
-0.0294481888,
0.003472528,
0.0021160368,
0.0024301328,
0.0014658211,
-0.0077032177,
-0.0074512069,
0.013288659,
0.0369458012,
-0.0765732974,
-0.0329210274,
0.0883508101,
0.0336464196,
0.028781265,
-0.025457304,
-0.0273731332,
-0.018580718,
-0.0011288074,
-0.0360204503,
-0.0189236738,
-0.0478646383,
0.0103538092,
-0.0140896579,
-0.024953289,
0.081276156,
-0.0605913065,
0.0004790847,
-0.0325483568,
-0.0027348537,
-0.0267660171,
-0.0510016643,
-0.0213652384,
0.0030577849,
0.016278144,
-0.0634609014,
0.0646070689,
0.0508640409,
0.0097402744,
-0.0898840874,
0.0561176129,
0.001588578,
-0.0146269221,
0.0156787876,
-0.0577915385,
-0.0095539736,
-0.0059511675,
-0.0551614873,
0.0155964913,
0.0241923016,
-0.0219377019,
-0.019048946,
0.0391202495,
-0.0172790624,
0.0764153004,
0.0239859354,
0.0158303007,
0.0235860385,
-0.0205701571,
0.0014189493,
0.013057353,
-0.0226773173,
-0.0296895057,
0.0440368094,
0.0296336357,
-0.0077190492,
0.0213885847,
0.0074501927,
-0.0149641633,
0.018657608,
0.0019805364,
-0.0215508174,
0.0250875205,
0.0391461626,
-0.0242800247,
-0.0002720596,
0.1067496613,
0.0289799813,
0.0005253984,
0.020160092,
-0.0068399352,
0.0030738197,
-0.0372365452,
-0.0199444555,
-0.04609254,
-0.0445220768,
0.0489975214,
0.0684575811,
-0.0138331139,
-0.0318413265,
0.0297495145,
-0.0509076118,
0.0243141539,
0.031520173,
-0.0595827289,
-0.0132482629,
-0.049501013,
-0.0215171818,
-0.0570857972,
0.0134862205,
0.00451768,
0.0250288676,
-0.0239783525,
0.0418727249,
-0.1101536825,
-0.0984600261,
0.0290224738,
-0.0166686047,
0.0712703764,
0.0678106844,
-0.0177744571,
-0.0068316059,
-0.0265877675,
-0.0544743799,
-0.028115442,
0.0017564128,
-0.010424816,
0.0580107756,
0.0337462574,
-0.0235547181,
-0.0281740557,
0.0428429283,
-0.0520264655,
-0.0071312399,
-0.0320977159,
0.0327711515,
-0.0475261733,
-0.0174592305,
-0.0069909678,
0.0267155878,
0.0251346845,
0.0381277353,
-0.011225394,
-0.0012783197,
-0.0320066288,
0.0353200398,
0.0878007263,
-0.0243261401,
-0.0150479116,
0.0360731222,
0.0166257862,
-0.0475927889,
-0.0341176167,
-0.0217170641,
0.0429581329,
-0.0272357929,
0.0226907097,
0.0043660966,
-0.0050010881,
0.0282829013,
-0.021664694,
0.0286636967,
0.0276854932,
0.0426870324,
-0.0631827563,
0.0184965115,
0.0733038783,
-0.0014304629,
-0.0220218152,
-0.0036929394,
-0.0041128546,
-0.0231077131,
0.0741490051,
0.0178907178,
0.0147692477,
-0.0038097815,
0.0010404852,
-0.0218824036,
0.0329638161,
0.0042947228,
-0.0066078552,
-0.0286408979,
0.0050700251,
0.0027950595,
-0.0105169825,
0.0063451231,
0.0151320845,
0.0655514821,
-0.0145139592,
0.0090792151,
-0.0630373359,
-0.063812159,
0.0056438018,
0.0318108015,
0.0510145612,
-0.0292737223,
-0.0326204859,
-0.0305597279,
0.0370777212,
0.0538360588,
0.0884012356,
0.0145521322,
-0.029760167,
0.033416409,
-0.0063403104,
-0.0366934538,
0.0200026538,
-0.0535481609,
-0.0917012766,
-0.0084744757,
0.0818711892,
0.0282103457,
0.0412058271,
0.0834185183,
-0.0010522477,
-0.0119066844,
0.0548660047,
0.0583839752,
0.0451247655,
-0.0068389941,
-0.0003822907,
-0.0337323844,
0.0190638974,
0.0131026562,
0.0316326879,
-0.0069039385,
0.0405090936,
-0.0435976237,
0.0503088795,
0.0487436727,
0.007080738,
0.0352566913,
0.0109917838,
0.0338745415,
-0.0443828665,
0.0129072648,
-0.0555837862,
0.0496725962,
0.059855368,
0.0025882623,
-0.0107547864,
0.0242909659,
0.0710573643,
-0.004825288,
0.0489862673,
-0.0160639733,
-0.0160036683,
-0.0387075469,
-0.0210044887,
-0.0091316793,
-0.0407492295,
-0.0956919417,
-0.0050314465,
-0.0447747,
-0.0550892688,
0.0588533953,
-0.018896902,
0.0134153124,
0.0022638682,
0.0144986166,
0.0023771245,
-0.0135253267,
0.0142115317,
0.0110558299,
-0.0013195248,
-0.0368772075,
0.004659568,
0.0460008048,
-5.438189515e-33,
0.0052326955,
-0.0035626076,
-0.0040930272,
0.0037562449,
0.0109177921,
0.0607509613,
-0.0212975536,
0.0399787277,
-0.0241114516,
0.0105026411,
-0.034800496,
-0.0202177763,
0.0261871926,
0.0347941965,
0.0204547979,
-0.0355228148,
0.0281841196,
0.040125113,
-0.0244793594,
-0.0147522399,
0.0033407207,
0.0809244886,
0.0580061674,
-0.0490850806,
-0.0151484888,
0.0091317585,
0.0174314324,
-0.0373095162,
0.0152402716,
0.0343499705,
-0.021709159,
0.0323635861,
0.0085107535,
-0.0142051643,
-0.0070400452,
-0.0304398704,
-0.0881663933,
0.0320322365,
-0.0097266994,
0.0176148042,
-0.0023347831,
-0.0466230661,
0.0718126446,
-0.0027318071,
-0.0850634873,
0.0271367189,
-0.0118445354,
-0.0528284907,
-0.0149831939,
-0.0362714715,
0.0082383733,
0.0753232986,
-0.0000585365,
0.0230201371,
0.0405467227,
-0.010735047,
-0.0326793231,
-0.0026989048,
-0.0260451268,
-0.0289224219,
0.0364844203,
0.0440509096,
0.0093857348,
-0.0306386165,
-0.080354847,
0.0317293964,
0.0760761872,
-0.0588551983,
-0.0367500372,
-0.0096856141,
-0.0299562216,
0.0232159495,
0.0207493082,
0.0301863216,
0.028982101,
-0.0431600921,
-0.0424089991,
0.0422821604,
-0.0530540384,
0.0587096363,
0.0069755777,
-0.029192673,
-0.0853520483,
-0.0076051839,
-0.0290417466,
0.0167141706,
-0.0044922959,
0.0044929287,
0.0509376526,
-0.0270212628,
0.0206140056,
0.0645166859,
0.0206800979,
0.0192975774,
0.0180055462,
-0.0352780595,
0.0606314316,
0.0309783313,
-0.0500227027,
0.0108415373,
-0.0671922043,
0.0076134647,
0.0215812474,
0.0037533897,
0.0395624824,
-0.0063933954,
0.0213455167,
-0.0006244966,
-0.0914105624,
-0.0019644329,
0.0176881198,
0.02483215,
-0.0016186174,
0.0269821044,
0.0512911156,
-0.008887928,
0.0286967736,
0.0271297954,
-0.008671077,
0.0086610466,
-0.0121836467,
-0.0209423844,
0.0388405211,
0.0192448255,
-0.0632938445,
-0.0046119429,
0.0085347332,
0.0167386495,
-0.0062782057,
-0.0410590582,
0.0000219892,
0.0019600424,
2.648e-7,
0.0304733049,
0.0358534977,
0.0238533001,
-0.051672712,
0.0101348106,
0.0013933048,
-0.0045574014,
-0.0104074273,
-0.0179933887,
0.0149960369,
0.0271989834,
-0.0407780334,
0.0837577283,
0.0402296074,
-0.0837452933,
-0.0393313766,
-0.0954317153,
-0.0061026728,
0.0073156753,
-0.029532304,
-0.0225589201,
0.0969664976,
-0.0540728308,
-0.0741638765,
-0.0001479845,
-0.0227068439,
0.0385771319,
-0.0331037305,
0.0088627022,
0.0327222571,
0.0186727569,
0.0009899694,
0.0194037464,
0.0683059916,
-0.0402689017,
0.0254236069,
-0.0017925649,
0.0675347894,
-0.0802397877,
-0.0072726463,
0.0289527681,
0.0206968524,
-0.0235006828,
-0.0217617154,
0.0446695648,
0.0470797867,
-0.0462495387,
-0.0459014624,
-0.0390195101,
-0.0006113817,
0.0593123697,
-0.0145258075,
0.0025379693,
0.0261317007,
0.0194361191,
-0.001516876,
-0.0517582037,
-0.0266672838,
0.0033958247,
0.053171929,
-0.0204653833,
0.0102937454,
0.062984854,
0.0036002761,
-0.0512670688,
-0.0766132027,
0.0155604267,
2.265395035e-34,
0.0272549093,
-0.0206139889,
0.0298286229,
0.0619152002,
0.0046002241,
-0.0354462378,
0.0326455534,
0.0148949996,
-0.0063278833,
-0.0233283695,
-0.0421891212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12386v1 | IPEval: A Bilingual Intellectual Property Agency Consultation Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:18:18 | 2024-06-18T08:18:18 | Qiyao Wang, Jianguo Huang, Shule Lu, Yuan Lin, Kan Xu, Liang Yang, Hongfei Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) in vertical domains,
including intellectual property (IP), lacks a specific evaluation benchmark for
assessing their understanding, application, and reasoning abilities. To fill
this gap, we introduce IPEval, the first evaluation benchmark tailored for IP
agency and consulting tasks. IPEval comprises 2657 multiple-choice questions
across four major dimensions: creation, application, protection, and management
of IP. These questions span patent rights (inventions, utility models,
designs), trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, and other related laws.
Evaluation methods include zero-shot, 5-few-shot, and Chain of Thought (CoT)
for seven LLM types, predominantly in English or Chinese. Results show superior
English performance by models like GPT series and Qwen series, while
Chinese-centric LLMs excel in Chinese tests, albeit specialized IP LLMs lag
behind general-purpose ones. Regional and temporal aspects of IP underscore the
need for LLMs to grasp legal nuances and evolving laws. IPEval aims to
accurately gauge LLM capabilities in IP and spur development of specialized
models. Website: \url{https://ipeval.github.io/} | [
0.0283457078,
0.0581412427,
-0.0266210549,
0.031231612,
-0.0994562954,
-0.009097117,
0.0924728513,
0.0230404045,
0.0268755611,
-0.0358270444,
-0.0222675744,
-0.0352209099,
0.0012824694,
-0.0234577842,
0.0082034748,
-0.0075827944,
0.0019498317,
-0.0075163799,
0.025994787,
-0.0434408188,
0.0313756913,
0.0024961617,
-0.0089551173,
0.0473571755,
0.0225474592,
-0.0300075989,
0.0462116711,
-0.027156245,
-0.0008895716,
-0.0478697233,
-0.0048105968,
0.0860617831,
0.0055745635,
0.0298082102,
0.0000022172,
-0.1085911989,
-0.017398499,
0.0082433298,
0.0616158061,
0.0903891101,
0.040119689,
0.032180585,
-0.0161456931,
0.0103080105,
-0.0423936434,
0.0467548147,
-0.0153251989,
0.0261568371,
0.0239471328,
0.025603665,
-0.005021954,
-0.0137448264,
0.0180714801,
-0.0428985655,
-0.0272992104,
-0.1036984995,
0.0059232535,
0.0508658811,
0.0570122227,
-0.0394752882,
0.0133899124,
0.041154325,
0.0306771044,
-0.0443994664,
-0.0424724892,
-0.0117812632,
-0.0427128784,
0.0156424195,
0.0128245531,
0.0382822677,
0.0809293389,
0.0184414294,
-0.0087691033,
-0.0005620566,
0.0608035214,
-0.0067718243,
-0.0151927741,
0.0377807878,
0.0036035187,
0.0108561125,
0.0337010585,
0.0148970243,
-0.0013088,
0.0274484009,
-0.0044337143,
0.0681523383,
-0.0068277484,
-0.0235401634,
0.0031162628,
-0.0169237945,
0.0499278679,
-0.0445360877,
0.0210460331,
0.0069416626,
-0.0098517518,
0.0209264345,
0.0110971853,
-0.0070019858,
0.0190833993,
-0.0483762734,
0.0109974304,
0.0180728622,
-0.0254220832,
0.0423656628,
-0.0477166921,
0.0761298686,
-0.038124498,
0.0229693577,
-0.0038446051,
-0.0355530344,
-0.0678296462,
-0.0101753706,
-0.0168484133,
0.054713171,
-0.0403112732,
0.0049201725,
-0.0557233728,
-0.0218133386,
-0.0536304265,
0.0266398676,
-0.0151605243,
-0.0120125944,
0.0408922136,
-0.0682535619,
-0.0607840419,
0.0377871804,
-0.0360651799,
0.0371252969,
-0.0210690107,
-0.0276802778,
0.0415606014,
0.0095581645,
-0.0374010541,
-0.024478294,
0.0107831396,
0.102220118,
-0.0085067935,
0.0286698267,
-0.021598544,
-0.0424001329,
0.0007450933,
-0.07163091,
-0.0217949096,
-0.0864702314,
-0.0079573821,
-0.0275247991,
-0.0189298727,
-0.0892529935,
0.0003622766,
-0.0066374135,
-0.0156281739,
0.0039281086,
-0.007572473,
0.0078142183,
-0.032004714,
0.037563514,
-0.004733894,
0.0188862868,
-0.0088235205,
0.013735082,
0.0359333679,
-0.0359879769,
0.0048557515,
0.0356182978,
-0.0368330441,
0.0276428945,
0.0015731071,
0.0050550671,
0.0146395871,
0.0010459156,
-0.022373775,
0.0482379496,
-0.0048792711,
0.0503198169,
0.0701187402,
0.0619440265,
-0.0040054191,
0.0281003751,
-0.0066799042,
0.0016413319,
0.0036998838,
-0.0424830988,
-0.0126085263,
0.0081716264,
-0.0128242355,
-0.0153880231,
-0.026646778,
0.0309018977,
-0.0098151071,
-0.0483039357,
0.0050665438,
0.0574203543,
0.0329497568,
0.006876627,
0.0221212264,
-0.0191249885,
-0.0062627415,
0.0584615692,
-0.0459733345,
-0.0195681937,
-0.0458957441,
0.0020537653,
0.0042255884,
0.0496331975,
-0.0051303641,
0.0306617022,
0.0134506449,
-0.0174643062,
-0.0257744938,
0.0841334984,
0.0434699133,
0.0123692378,
-0.0249889176,
-0.0107325409,
-0.0142753096,
-0.0071262866,
0.0047515598,
0.0315843932,
-0.0327156857,
0.0481605865,
0.0289195478,
-0.0547621362,
0.0087820077,
-0.0291061196,
-0.0397816747,
-0.020769855,
-0.0030998022,
0.0116067138,
0.0176610779,
0.0578298755,
-0.037381608,
0.0274826083,
0.0166815817,
-0.032024242,
-0.0162895042,
0.044563558,
0.063251242,
0.0575175211,
0.0510668866,
-0.0325731412,
0.0148131549,
-0.0494901203,
-0.012261034,
-0.0102822576,
0.014449358,
0.0123015167,
-0.0122913895,
-0.0358979665,
0.003516143,
-0.0656884015,
0.0223932434,
-0.0018379245,
0.0095151793,
-0.0128836446,
0.0202496033,
0.0483582914,
-0.0253438056,
0.0794375017,
-0.0237232614,
-0.0459762253,
0.0317768306,
-0.0272588823,
0.0060724486,
0.0540663339,
0.0384362638,
-0.0115441242,
0.0134813469,
-0.0738483593,
-0.0165994316,
-0.0103850663,
0.0223558303,
0.0139379427,
-0.0439373851,
-0.0181567352,
0.0351164378,
-0.0451535769,
-0.0613200068,
-0.0245116465,
0.0078752311,
0.0088549005,
-0.0378379524,
-0.0660424307,
0.018272873,
-0.0066865562,
-0.0122304037,
-0.0187838823,
0.0219436511,
-0.017507242,
-0.0192575641,
-0.00823591,
-0.0597309358,
-0.0109681888,
0.0029086731,
-0.0291319806,
0.0014736047,
0.0133982394,
-0.0234843325,
-0.0235729497,
-0.0069279601,
-0.0039618127,
0.0336063839,
-0.0413901918,
-0.0398898683,
0.0025126955,
0.0582748614,
0.0022325828,
-0.0099884551,
-0.013597291,
0.0048042298,
0.0363137573,
0.0010411419,
0.0025418538,
-0.0193544067,
-0.0114374077,
-0.0544166602,
-0.0244519897,
-0.0228410605,
-0.0082209921,
-0.0104450025,
0.1023821011,
-0.0119178686,
-0.0279630814,
0.0407859646,
-0.0547437258,
0.0337131955,
-0.0624261722,
-0.0040368163,
-0.0327454545,
0.0807279274,
-0.0604552254,
-0.0006988989,
-0.0133214276,
-0.0139016882,
-0.0152094644,
0.0174706168,
0.0663547739,
-0.0277189892,
0.0150251929,
-0.027432913,
0.0199900847,
-0.0021820115,
0.0069390363,
-0.0005151629,
0.0266353376,
0.0024125087,
0.0622448623,
0.0570432879,
0.0148932803,
0.0142551437,
0.0046993345,
0.0352507979,
0.0134404777,
0.0196364895,
0.0229198691,
-0.0087388633,
0.0039775847,
-0.0177085977,
-0.0182233658,
0.0041156821,
-0.0030986448,
0.0307865124,
-0.0122507904,
-0.0124390256,
0.0126989959,
0.0245631766,
0.0288932715,
0.0161667988,
-0.0030437156,
-0.0311942771,
0.0312725976,
0.0345312916,
-0.0458974279,
0.0242702942,
0.0724350512,
-0.0025709691,
0.0194885097,
0.0044023795,
-0.005594329,
-0.0482347794,
0.0361712798,
0.0195175894,
-0.1350954175,
0.048059281,
-0.0314886346,
-0.0252900086,
-0.0618126132,
-0.0451092497,
-0.0189026874,
-0.1025652289,
0.0709987655,
0.0144859953,
-0.0106512289,
-0.0098551745,
0.0367160477,
-0.0240543149,
0.0175111014,
0.0156420469,
-0.0223954618,
0.0268832128,
-0.0210614223,
0.0260593314,
-0.0712256581,
0.0153570129,
0.0678646117,
-0.0210749358,
-0.0150985904,
0.0536726117,
-0.0060217031,
-0.0108642494,
-0.050067313,
0.0123452833,
-0.0078577762,
-0.0195658486,
0.0346055478,
-0.026490273,
0.0554068796,
0.0153279956,
-0.0177147929,
-0.0032922986,
-0.020338038,
-0.0227131192,
0.0499457531,
0.0844991654,
-0.0247482751,
0.0015510406,
0.000068428,
-0.0121824807,
-0.0318128839,
0.0404655635,
0.0192590617,
-0.0481565595,
-0.024711933,
-0.043862056,
-0.06340231,
-0.0862917379,
-0.0196578391,
0.0027873334,
-0.0130390162,
-0.0296170339,
-0.0685592294,
-0.0315681621,
-0.0174009483,
0.0270139873,
0.0266836453,
0.0378722586,
0.0434558615,
-0.0104285274,
-0.0097823804,
-0.0236890204,
-0.0086521944,
0.039611917,
-0.0191806704,
0.0426243581,
0.0003094898,
0.0006964762,
-0.0198984854,
0.0169181768,
-0.0428231396,
-0.0497481078,
-0.0330894031,
-0.0142221758,
0.0205452479,
-0.0654420778,
-0.0461533144,
-0.0327283554,
0.0617940575,
0.0204282477,
0.0168759357,
-0.0154621871,
0.0357658267,
-0.0123948595,
-0.0230015982,
-0.0028483279,
-0.0196098313,
0.0049737711,
0.0397957712,
0.054202307,
0.0160493162,
-0.0102743264,
0.0676581338,
0.0924838036,
-0.0110611701,
-0.0118463198,
0.0221999846,
-0.0038320143,
-0.007089464,
0.0004085518,
-0.0450394489,
-0.034869656,
-0.0477652103,
0.0543636866,
-0.0531282015,
-0.0084999492,
0.0815660655,
0.0262795873,
-0.0169935953,
-0.0177683663,
0.058753632,
-0.022879608,
0.0432730205,
0.0058232779,
-0.0127832815,
0.001663364,
0.0221691281,
-0.0421213061,
0.0465165079,
-0.0037223618,
0.0882418156,
-0.0160405431,
0.026493635,
0.0028995441,
0.0343502648,
0.0149337463,
-0.1036696732,
0.0171295088,
0.0815527961,
0.0785181224,
0.0127322925,
0.0058253189,
-0.0409797654,
0.0099640666,
-0.0186223108,
0.0197768118,
-0.0274025518,
-0.0609655976,
0.0199265964,
0.0042783315,
-0.0052831089,
-0.0078251418,
0.0562992357,
-0.0054242304,
-0.0131248962,
-0.0406279266,
0.0006972714,
-0.0013373794,
-0.0388138704,
0.0079063103,
0.0141891968,
-0.014546697,
0.0098637724,
-0.1185452417,
-0.0347065441,
-0.0590267889,
-0.0107399793,
-0.0143746436,
0.0226039477,
-0.0277104005,
0.0881528035,
0.025336381,
-0.0402178876,
-0.0516756848,
0.0029930943,
-0.0113807078,
-0.0360635594,
-0.0086515993,
-6.273842572e-33,
0.0133200232,
-0.0408545099,
0.0385899059,
-0.0041730516,
0.0003554416,
-0.0218486674,
-0.0366980918,
0.0218335465,
-0.0332122408,
0.0258596539,
-0.0216893256,
-0.0439818315,
0.0014815331,
-0.0078880396,
0.0294319969,
-0.0018669396,
-0.0266365744,
0.039558094,
-0.0153579051,
-0.0248184744,
-0.0100962631,
-0.0013505027,
0.0696442798,
-0.0832973197,
0.0530117825,
0.0250668731,
-0.0113994498,
-0.0079376986,
-0.0660834014,
0.0440816619,
0.0096131461,
0.0323070325,
0.0292048454,
-0.1274576187,
0.0045182551,
-0.0395427644,
-0.0144791771,
0.0013113592,
0.0424162485,
-0.0134312287,
0.0483440943,
-0.0392465703,
0.0182069186,
0.0085184239,
-0.0689358264,
-0.0147133172,
0.0147574134,
-0.0237601381,
-0.0081544742,
-0.0168856569,
-0.0587825179,
0.017389223,
-0.0322809964,
0.0525236949,
0.0279237609,
0.0124323945,
-0.0412553549,
0.035522677,
-0.1042993963,
0.0270662569,
-0.0208257791,
-0.0067854198,
0.0761053041,
-0.0570475422,
0.0070113889,
0.0400135703,
0.0029383528,
0.0339213088,
0.0124101276,
-0.0249472931,
0.0312987082,
0.0832961127,
0.0270997062,
0.041573938,
-0.0095945783,
0.0021875002,
-0.0162963681,
0.008439959,
0.0443098471,
0.0278498996,
-0.0065630279,
0.0176749025,
-0.0011498961,
-0.0383432284,
-0.0377792828,
-0.0600207783,
-0.0036214152,
-0.0131991254,
0.0574271083,
-0.0343931764,
0.0195906498,
0.0022250691,
0.0643693805,
-0.0390797593,
-0.0358050354,
-0.0198774543,
-0.011055734,
0.0486980192,
0.0126775187,
0.0250598118,
-0.0940020382,
0.0116227791,
-0.0280186217,
-0.0018505915,
0.021391904,
-0.0176471304,
-0.0084895054,
-0.0287958048,
-0.0109766852,
-0.0119677726,
-0.0300762281,
0.0114655457,
0.0403018147,
0.0409872942,
-0.0193680711,
0.0235322304,
0.0010811057,
0.008665571,
0.0204294324,
-0.0487953983,
-0.0332982689,
-0.0284847673,
-0.0258804094,
-0.0085841184,
-0.0128608327,
0.0134554086,
-0.0047418685,
0.0411620066,
0.0535316393,
-0.0003734432,
-0.0247400627,
0.0197580885,
2.934e-7,
0.0475710332,
0.0114183594,
-0.0090527292,
0.0284013208,
-0.0020317086,
0.0507764257,
-0.033451464,
0.0535326414,
0.0065500122,
-0.0380524732,
0.0081201866,
-0.028461447,
0.0648103207,
0.0340616517,
-0.0571146309,
-0.038838055,
-0.03021436,
-0.0102734268,
-0.0482710227,
0.0235251244,
0.0440112874,
0.0071488,
0.0315840058,
-0.0255450979,
-0.0004443558,
-0.0299148336,
0.030033445,
-0.0237903725,
-0.0033016277,
0.0333158113,
0.0650091022,
-0.0346415155,
0.0182180069,
0.0532797351,
0.0220804401,
0.0481482111,
0.0012614683,
0.0434096754,
0.0361075215,
0.0262856707,
-0.0355078727,
-0.0608583614,
0.014614773,
-0.0704065859,
0.0044343006,
0.0556226857,
-0.0362881906,
0.0334616452,
-0.0241478179,
-0.0218389723,
0.0228113327,
0.0202748813,
0.0062355283,
0.0052762893,
0.0129382722,
-0.0030743154,
-0.0159753151,
-0.0236524791,
0.0030614287,
0.0021454655,
-0.0174907222,
0.0157692321,
-0.0311146528,
0.0019717743,
0.0265889652,
-0.048768606,
0.0522963367,
2.60520887e-34,
-0.0001074285,
-0.0608074367,
0.012416387,
0.0470664389,
0.0614335649,
0.0575972088,
0.0097529031,
-0.0021973897,
-0.0517054349,
-0.0575987995,
0.0192464218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12382v1 | From Instance Training to Instruction Learning: Task Adapters Generation from Instructions | 2024-06-18T08:14:28 | 2024-06-18T08:14:28 | Huanxuan Liao, Yao Xu, Shizhu He, Yuanzhe Zhang, Yanchao Hao, Shengping Liu, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have acquired the ability to solve general tasks
by utilizing instruction finetuning (IFT). However, IFT still relies heavily on
instance training of extensive task data, which greatly limits the adaptability
of LLMs to real-world scenarios where labeled task instances are scarce and
broader task generalization becomes paramount. Contrary to LLMs, humans acquire
skills and complete tasks not merely through repeated practice but also by
understanding and following instructional guidelines. This paper is dedicated
to simulating human learning to address the shortcomings of instance training,
focusing on instruction learning to enhance cross-task generalization. Within
this context, we introduce Task Adapters Generation from Instructions (TAGI),
which automatically constructs the task-specific model in a parameter
generation manner based on the given task instructions without retraining for
unseen tasks. Specifically, we utilize knowledge distillation to enhance the
consistency between TAGI developed through Learning with Instruction and
task-specific models developed through Training with Instance, by aligning the
labels, output logits, and adapter parameters between them. TAGI is endowed
with cross-task generalization capabilities through a two-stage training
process that includes hypernetwork pretraining and finetuning. We evaluate TAGI
on the Super-Natural Instructions and P3 datasets. The experimental results
demonstrate that TAGI can match or even outperform traditional meta-trained
models and other hypernetwork models, while significantly reducing
computational requirements. | [
0.0041905129,
-0.0146493986,
-0.0140342079,
0.0067914966,
-0.0053699249,
0.0307588633,
-0.0006616779,
-0.0425871871,
-0.018643003,
-0.0144698462,
-0.0527810529,
0.0212018862,
-0.033040788,
-0.0158970822,
0.038910117,
-0.0319176577,
0.0587959811,
-0.0322604924,
-0.0371648483,
0.0090795122,
0.0016525518,
0.0074788402,
-0.0260973275,
0.0421811938,
0.0128520867,
0.000420116,
-0.0332043581,
0.0039814361,
0.0144613171,
-0.0294292457,
0.0389224999,
0.0186413843,
0.0879845396,
-0.0015791836,
0.0000020478,
-0.0142262662,
0.0127636883,
-0.022362778,
-0.0369259156,
-0.0245167762,
0.0065405713,
0.0087848026,
0.0025992342,
0.0186252389,
-0.0339237116,
-0.024013523,
0.0345085151,
0.0573667325,
0.0579751246,
0.0639301538,
-0.0026064138,
-0.0092491833,
0.0032483593,
-0.0117936349,
0.043859221,
-0.0248060599,
0.017005235,
0.0252091531,
0.0163685586,
-0.0030481075,
-0.0185313951,
-0.0047079925,
0.0339768864,
0.0312346313,
-0.0182737969,
0.0354088061,
-0.0268285554,
0.0134877181,
-0.0440087467,
0.0473319218,
-0.0352647826,
-0.0251724124,
-0.0129822027,
0.0101133734,
0.0157972798,
0.0254951809,
-0.0247972962,
-0.0086243814,
0.0039620125,
0.0220686402,
0.0098346323,
-0.007968721,
0.0017923146,
-0.0073648142,
0.011939114,
0.0748142749,
-0.004242565,
-0.0280523784,
0.0274286252,
-0.0029579352,
-0.0273562856,
-0.0239660125,
0.0131160161,
0.0364795104,
-0.0229276679,
0.0079168379,
-0.0597077198,
-0.0302165411,
-0.0264012963,
-0.0135333445,
0.1155068427,
0.0441274755,
-0.0185218826,
0.0024692055,
-0.070037961,
0.0681153834,
-0.0176765658,
0.0238492787,
-0.0605320781,
0.038742695,
-0.120131366,
0.0085921688,
-0.080417335,
0.0434446521,
-0.0339849889,
0.0175924562,
-0.0151380505,
0.034046609,
-0.033255972,
-0.0240952689,
0.0241122805,
0.0045742332,
-0.084532015,
-0.0053450279,
-0.0390096642,
0.0164200496,
-0.0355211571,
0.0506388731,
0.0020036227,
-0.0221194141,
-0.0119660236,
0.0048476588,
-0.0164069291,
-0.0206084419,
0.0381042659,
0.0704434738,
-0.0544096716,
-0.0169208534,
-0.0489858873,
-0.0000767903,
0.0081497235,
-0.0661289394,
0.0332886502,
-0.0493295938,
0.0475915708,
-0.0399989672,
-0.0207360014,
-0.021951383,
0.006541858,
-0.0080330865,
0.0038803066,
0.0625757203,
0.0070287432,
0.0196003262,
0.009705117,
-0.0222973097,
-0.0436583273,
0.054490298,
0.0294998586,
0.00858845,
-0.0241977293,
-0.0060674292,
0.0136249997,
0.0386329927,
0.0264251493,
0.005595753,
0.0053160056,
-0.0077713192,
0.0307501517,
0.0166860335,
0.0531573296,
-0.0012090711,
-0.0298588686,
0.0207831133,
0.0597462021,
0.0064277845,
-0.0050278585,
-0.0066259983,
0.1131231636,
0.0187594984,
-0.0204505082,
0.0344652645,
-0.0898281559,
0.0394786596,
0.0049388888,
0.0171263311,
-0.0175711196,
0.0249442011,
-0.0730423108,
-0.039283175,
0.0445606224,
-0.0022676492,
-0.0001885268,
0.0020959096,
0.0425124578,
0.0376844667,
-0.0752735659,
0.0186109841,
0.0402907096,
-0.0191446505,
0.0197798423,
-0.0568544269,
0.0023559125,
0.0586270355,
0.0027730076,
-0.0392333157,
-0.0628208295,
-0.0066827587,
0.0389336571,
-0.0007825018,
0.017164547,
-0.0382087715,
0.004872032,
-0.0529898219,
-0.0282433853,
-0.0022220826,
-0.0135456529,
0.0299215764,
0.0023247544,
-0.0566949323,
0.0180827472,
-0.0554842688,
-0.0582617186,
0.0472284108,
-0.0598603003,
-0.0452160202,
-0.0190286934,
0.0045969081,
0.0182355549,
-0.0066734157,
-0.0123646539,
-0.0024838697,
0.0366471447,
-0.0262883082,
0.0074014971,
-0.0035273728,
-0.059947513,
-0.0365699306,
0.0037727174,
-0.0520994738,
0.0034916296,
0.0331898853,
-0.0398082212,
-0.0620874837,
-0.0281688422,
0.0080665182,
0.0434969142,
-0.0030926671,
0.0090336874,
0.0192643572,
-0.0104634967,
-0.0175387617,
0.0212037731,
0.0117412126,
-0.0180367492,
-0.0130722001,
-0.0292524062,
-0.0209357422,
-0.0399288051,
-0.0146689992,
-0.0067944443,
-0.0229451805,
0.0276535973,
-0.0005420755,
0.0423702113,
-0.0434468761,
-0.0319064558,
-0.0848015025,
0.0215519052,
-0.0174688902,
0.0372531973,
0.0483841673,
-0.0105796736,
-0.0126024215,
-0.0321431309,
-0.0347979888,
0.0293560531,
-0.0236326735,
0.0022252684,
-0.0068723061,
0.0358504392,
-0.0132947927,
-0.0445621312,
-0.0162948947,
-0.0126795759,
-0.0105037829,
-0.0353115872,
0.025433166,
-0.0617227741,
0.0711640939,
-0.0038668935,
0.058183983,
-0.0104614599,
-0.0346774012,
0.0332564972,
-0.0210027434,
0.0523007736,
0.0698792338,
-0.0312974304,
-0.0040402375,
0.0443490222,
0.0086216489,
-0.0699208528,
0.0341021642,
-0.0710468143,
-0.0466724262,
-0.0591216199,
-0.0042116544,
-0.0146661038,
0.0941378102,
-0.0045864037,
-0.0083494494,
-0.0711197481,
-0.0154982498,
-0.0105396081,
-0.0471711233,
-0.0064085755,
0.0111026689,
-0.0127019165,
-0.0320256986,
-0.0488980711,
-0.0505319387,
0.0513748936,
0.0065224972,
0.0067783012,
-0.0316144899,
-0.018775221,
0.0182068627,
0.035610199,
0.0275914278,
0.0077561866,
0.0283605829,
-0.0139511349,
-0.0814991146,
0.0023163185,
0.024231283,
0.0087086335,
0.0357524417,
-0.063011609,
-0.0120376199,
0.0006540692,
-0.0317670591,
-0.0387840904,
0.0264255162,
0.0331412703,
0.0299405009,
-0.0208917409,
0.0057772039,
-0.0315404236,
-0.0048343302,
0.0311684236,
0.0617847219,
-0.0333246812,
-0.0223060008,
-0.056885045,
-0.0002966161,
0.0194788259,
0.0043238844,
-0.0441168286,
-0.0396113917,
-0.0040592682,
0.0152897183,
0.0812923834,
-0.0116360122,
-0.0338893682,
0.029505806,
0.007068811,
-0.0302355196,
0.0138837053,
0.0620036535,
0.0825144649,
-0.0683992207,
-0.0221594609,
0.086532712,
0.0178622454,
-0.013508183,
0.018682925,
0.0283371732,
-0.0073394412,
0.0426600203,
0.0538347475,
-0.0195171498,
-0.0168243386,
-0.0111815892,
0.0289929137,
0.0217052642,
-0.0341571122,
0.0157721695,
-0.1025202051,
0.0070710974,
0.025409257,
-0.0328730345,
-0.0328492671,
-0.0155181857,
0.0067632464,
-0.0103570344,
-0.002630098,
0.0027737773,
-0.0068443003,
0.0131052313,
0.0527867787,
0.0128780054,
-0.0614568889,
0.0412840992,
-0.0428434871,
0.07837262,
0.052563522,
-0.0173309725,
-0.0161589403,
-0.010377517,
0.0028864192,
0.031299416,
0.0262684058,
-0.0055374657,
0.0485717654,
-0.0223743673,
-0.0056926855,
0.0101328352,
0.0516709462,
-0.0243396834,
-0.0029008873,
0.0321124122,
0.0850016549,
-0.0164532308,
-0.0127951801,
0.007289967,
-0.029807223,
0.0460853502,
0.0422182791,
0.0081558414,
-0.0542999171,
-0.004928695,
-0.0086980714,
-0.0452250913,
-0.073391445,
0.0030812735,
0.0643681437,
-0.0422894731,
0.0095614009,
-0.0446832553,
-0.0271364991,
0.0702034608,
0.0376900621,
0.0475803614,
-0.045921959,
0.0595827512,
-0.0178869721,
-0.0495336652,
0.0014975653,
-0.0270650424,
0.013771194,
-0.0362865888,
-0.0603070483,
0.0589664616,
-0.0241029412,
0.0002204666,
0.0040380871,
-0.0312959738,
-0.0375345387,
-0.0064254152,
0.0942265019,
0.0115725324,
0.0831426606,
0.0109347561,
-0.0023668956,
0.0156046133,
0.0106269466,
-0.0479850061,
0.0055670082,
0.0500180908,
-0.0098722745,
0.0141841546,
0.0052099978,
-0.0475972369,
0.0741563365,
0.0539953336,
0.0140531901,
-0.0109650483,
0.0137526225,
0.0503025055,
-0.0220371205,
0.0300819594,
-0.0136473048,
0.0291522536,
-0.0408807285,
-0.0204967204,
0.0100718942,
0.0148134241,
-0.0542947687,
0.0233484581,
0.0285061728,
0.0257923137,
0.0670140162,
0.0174516421,
0.0095935939,
0.0432093143,
-0.044494696,
0.0111252861,
-0.0151193049,
0.0470258333,
0.026794089,
0.0474737547,
-0.012284332,
-0.0117664635,
0.0287245065,
0.0351653434,
-0.0157447141,
0.0594447404,
0.0143422997,
0.0314060971,
-0.0392937809,
0.0415842384,
-0.0507975779,
-0.0154064251,
-0.0676983595,
-0.0153912986,
0.036535833,
-0.0220425893,
-0.0017279353,
-0.0204569157,
0.0248555113,
-0.0141403722,
0.0293900929,
-0.0340418853,
0.0186694916,
0.0269256048,
0.0475734696,
0.0147545431,
0.0133022889,
0.0730598792,
-0.0037837594,
0.0736501217,
0.009527809,
0.0315620489,
-0.0631016418,
-0.0252203569,
0.0394996181,
0.0162301622,
-0.0223581903,
-0.00196355,
0.0061234646,
-0.0577217713,
-0.0335043408,
0.043605268,
0.0014389189,
-0.0208266173,
0.0656107366,
0.0183289293,
-0.0466998816,
-0.0451337025,
-0.0140773347,
-0.0212432668,
0.0223591458,
0.0043595475,
-0.0157741122,
-5.540159977e-33,
-0.0432427414,
0.0131801097,
0.0522326902,
-0.0098301545,
-0.0235336572,
-0.0149190947,
-0.0284069609,
-0.0071286159,
-0.010843154,
0.0113424622,
0.0116460547,
-0.0083517237,
0.0176307503,
0.0111206761,
0.0435359851,
0.0102535058,
0.0585788302,
-0.0485889167,
-0.0088993087,
0.0558461547,
0.0352900289,
0.0087064737,
0.0789982677,
-0.0525881983,
0.0060921437,
0.0004169385,
-0.0104442779,
0.0258393846,
0.0069457144,
0.0369841196,
0.008550562,
0.0411690027,
0.0163207836,
-0.0658379644,
-0.0519068055,
0.0195168667,
-0.0841268376,
-0.0374690257,
0.0105087459,
-0.0233226307,
-0.0566979051,
-0.0269296505,
0.0342806503,
0.0020300657,
-0.0369245037,
0.0045668273,
0.0392033421,
-0.0167230777,
-0.0067201569,
-0.0211779345,
-0.0834032148,
-0.0307617988,
-0.0084586265,
-0.0663875416,
0.0177218299,
0.0421198867,
-0.0215342455,
-0.0675983727,
-0.0641986206,
0.0282864925,
-0.0012129403,
0.0484829843,
0.0427533351,
0.0435638614,
0.0222847275,
0.0195293091,
0.0458207428,
0.02546666,
0.0283473711,
0.0295391269,
0.0510256812,
0.0738033354,
-0.0039352672,
0.0029787014,
0.0153718842,
-0.0241195261,
-0.021738166,
0.0197675116,
-0.0082104532,
0.0411252566,
0.0101087056,
0.0088152345,
-0.0297695044,
-0.0039478755,
-0.0316136368,
0.006958032,
0.0190233421,
-0.0386328697,
0.0627292693,
0.0073416661,
0.0004277209,
-0.0079937819,
0.0496790558,
-0.0489040501,
0.0264564995,
-0.0240501184,
-0.0235615522,
0.023281049,
-0.0010998007,
0.0003867317,
-0.0703910962,
-0.0881380439,
0.023647517,
0.0169940908,
0.0287955776,
0.0242506992,
0.05814014,
0.0388598219,
-0.042321682,
-0.0059654224,
-0.05495378,
0.0048468905,
0.0684718862,
0.0315995663,
0.0170220695,
0.018645579,
-0.0270411689,
0.0254859533,
-0.0190914143,
-0.1101898402,
-0.0034616624,
0.0235353913,
-0.0002823309,
0.0445922352,
-0.0112234037,
0.0196317006,
-0.0817702562,
-0.0221891589,
0.009638397,
-0.0315674953,
-0.0130631197,
0.0523540452,
2.745e-7,
-0.0135229966,
0.0138519537,
0.0339052603,
-0.0013381094,
0.0193106383,
0.0372139141,
-0.009493107,
0.0386880115,
0.0034662904,
-0.0457829833,
0.0302239954,
0.0668250024,
0.0090098903,
0.0027617808,
-0.074443154,
-0.006554509,
0.0160684884,
0.0019867376,
-0.0263483804,
0.0302843545,
0.0327534117,
0.0468208492,
0.0066788755,
0.0211627223,
0.002690315,
-0.0228642002,
0.0186247882,
-0.0105286827,
-0.0014890088,
0.0222222432,
-0.0564085543,
0.0332683958,
-0.0428356342,
0.0604250953,
-0.0204371251,
0.0128777409,
-0.0096388198,
0.0574892461,
-0.0305455681,
0.0007682999,
-0.007393349,
-0.0018710422,
-0.0087390989,
-0.0184134878,
0.0347315669,
-0.120113112,
-0.0041225026,
-0.0023027479,
0.0084764231,
0.0224984121,
-0.0579150915,
-0.0062607415,
0.0201350842,
0.0054222085,
0.0279265456,
0.007016012,
-0.0372016616,
-0.0524924025,
0.0160494074,
0.0775921494,
-0.0441407599,
-0.0587457865,
-0.0260318723,
-0.0260351636,
0.0072944774,
-0.0453054868,
-0.0042081149,
2.152571454e-34,
-0.0161380135,
0.0021988489,
0.0520185605,
0.0041983575,
-0.0132966852,
-0.0176893622,
-0.1068187058,
0.0109675219,
0.0263447259,
-0.0698247254,
-0.0521230623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12381v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12381v2 | QOG:Question and Options Generation based on Language Model | 2024-06-18T08:09:58 | 2024-07-02T09:21:03 | Jincheng Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Question-Options Generation (QOG) is a task that involves generating a set of
question-options pairs given context. This task has various applications,
including fine-tuning large models, information retrieval, and automated
multiple-choice question generation for education. In this paper, we develop
QOG models using three different methods based on fine-tuning
sequence-to-sequence language models (LMs). Experiments demonstrate that the
end-to-end QOG model is computationally efficient and stable during both
training and inference, outperforming other methods. Furthermore, our analysis
indicates that our QOG models are competitive on the QOG task compared to the
large language model Llama 3-8B. | [
0.0497165546,
0.0213046838,
-0.006125981,
0.0261746254,
-0.0414654762,
0.0141029228,
0.0033600584,
-0.0110471537,
0.0015209139,
-0.0546145551,
0.0057717026,
-0.0693939105,
-0.0588135757,
0.0131212333,
0.0477357544,
-0.0390659831,
0.0267740786,
-0.0252591632,
-0.0284985248,
-0.0132557927,
-0.0131070819,
0.0118948463,
-0.002026188,
0.0267104488,
0.0436374657,
-0.0272854529,
-0.0616964288,
0.011954586,
0.012260383,
-0.045470573,
0.0069831531,
0.0434051491,
-0.0100207506,
-0.0122589963,
0.0000019469,
-0.0570023507,
-0.0369228274,
-0.0208249744,
-0.0372016951,
-0.0053276466,
0.0080909925,
0.0549673513,
0.0326016285,
0.0557667501,
-0.031898994,
0.0034065107,
0.0333390348,
0.0164577477,
0.0706912205,
0.0771641433,
0.0117255859,
-0.0215844456,
0.0202071555,
-0.0531113371,
0.0312963203,
-0.0142122526,
0.0129610933,
0.0045195804,
0.0571134351,
0.0491320863,
0.0064444435,
0.0274762176,
0.0203505997,
-0.0121094491,
-0.0045191813,
0.0100405989,
-0.0128688011,
-0.0215000398,
-0.0030581874,
0.1065195352,
-0.0112203276,
-0.0035717655,
0.0231460072,
-0.0132002356,
0.0224537384,
0.0275053587,
-0.0426056795,
0.0433612913,
-0.007087986,
-0.0247532278,
0.0454710089,
-0.021170469,
-0.0078790234,
0.0262834635,
-0.0250964742,
0.0341081321,
0.028753737,
-0.0219668522,
-0.0267404821,
-0.0098686954,
-0.0388221629,
-0.0933815241,
0.0149330432,
0.0574849769,
-0.0379198641,
0.0236391686,
-0.0510143153,
-0.0071598203,
0.0233789552,
-0.002137572,
0.0178086087,
0.0397058576,
0.0203609578,
0.014768241,
-0.0128388312,
0.042888578,
0.012416142,
0.0282227658,
-0.0930987746,
0.0143224755,
-0.0078860242,
-0.0041906792,
-0.0534481965,
0.0410965569,
-0.0866939127,
-0.0405794792,
-0.0427319705,
0.0263868384,
0.0544702448,
0.0101227593,
0.0092099132,
0.0202433895,
-0.0401725098,
0.0063783014,
-0.0527744405,
-0.00806926,
-0.0282213688,
-0.0097931279,
0.0741140693,
-0.0151846064,
0.0050710058,
0.011380326,
0.0241159033,
-0.0191908386,
0.0072245798,
0.0753113627,
-0.0212738588,
-0.0248852242,
0.0058286288,
-0.0318817198,
-0.0140358014,
-0.0457809754,
0.0003791829,
-0.0633683875,
0.0199386273,
0.0083000744,
-0.0196740106,
0.0031931149,
0.0375241898,
0.0500534549,
0.0058184378,
0.0388991684,
0.0085725673,
0.0090394616,
0.0373640507,
0.0050872522,
0.0289454442,
0.0514436848,
0.0347247161,
0.025978677,
0.0248895716,
-0.0050815446,
-0.0029186911,
0.0396231189,
-0.0006065027,
-0.0100501189,
-0.0244502574,
0.0339404158,
0.0128478818,
0.0492484011,
-0.0419173092,
0.0622587167,
-0.0212308131,
-0.0147363693,
0.0341380239,
0.0325885825,
0.0426396839,
-0.0010937778,
0.0547146425,
0.0275699496,
0.0027862976,
-0.0081296321,
-0.0232254993,
0.0367628299,
0.0131342979,
0.0353364013,
0.0428549051,
0.0406714194,
-0.0193650592,
-0.062855795,
0.0004841937,
0.0188559443,
-0.0191319399,
0.0349624865,
0.0139447944,
0.0161845889,
-0.0697796866,
0.0217489172,
-0.0005254316,
-0.0412686244,
0.0013206817,
-0.0507257693,
0.0820030123,
0.0377580971,
0.0551035851,
0.0108502265,
-0.0615205094,
-0.0093300482,
-0.0219766907,
0.055018682,
0.0470655151,
-0.0175883286,
-0.0230381005,
-0.0684522614,
-0.0126953414,
0.0083637675,
0.002639812,
0.0054912474,
0.0093069151,
0.0067645865,
0.0464481413,
-0.0174111575,
-0.0347642861,
0.0295788068,
-0.038397409,
-0.0415033586,
0.0241197739,
-0.0000278484,
0.0037721689,
-0.0027189674,
0.0181342624,
0.0337380059,
0.0374097154,
-0.0434199497,
-0.0144867999,
-0.0255971737,
-0.0665222183,
-0.085615404,
0.0277998466,
0.0031008136,
0.0365299843,
0.0027818575,
-0.0378128402,
-0.0531318039,
-0.0326088071,
-0.016735198,
-0.0094963862,
-0.0591784641,
0.0173992384,
0.0396049768,
-0.0170767047,
-0.0751740932,
0.0683184564,
0.0034209976,
0.0112232706,
0.0105302017,
0.0626794249,
0.0065457663,
-0.0665555,
-0.0117081301,
0.0261243396,
-0.0440053195,
0.0278647989,
0.0138945663,
0.0563337356,
-0.0538634062,
-0.037945956,
-0.0742021203,
0.0436556526,
-0.0133506814,
0.0053375526,
0.0124977538,
0.0217373464,
-0.02196436,
-0.0192013178,
-0.0718772709,
0.016226504,
0.0410258099,
-0.0013424626,
0.0429288186,
0.0218071733,
-0.0057045734,
-0.0540499911,
-0.0124591673,
0.0100243594,
0.027392447,
-0.0052516349,
0.044671122,
-0.0500700511,
0.0211478509,
-0.0468594022,
-0.0024228788,
0.0158640537,
-0.0297748893,
0.0107483575,
-0.036845509,
0.0578435212,
0.0546210892,
0.0429954305,
0.0011648183,
0.0322953612,
0.0205804911,
-0.051955279,
0.0372650214,
-0.0417762883,
-0.0306118559,
0.0133272614,
-0.0480933115,
0.0048017944,
0.0673049912,
0.0116398791,
-0.015685562,
-0.0373376347,
0.0684113055,
0.012587185,
0.0054091299,
-0.0524544716,
0.0110378191,
-0.0212487262,
0.0778844506,
-0.0079136128,
-0.0273561962,
0.0522605702,
-0.0399637297,
0.013032617,
-0.0750064626,
-0.0116666723,
-0.0330554172,
0.0397949815,
0.0145241255,
0.0363115929,
0.0472452082,
-0.0026471152,
-0.1053679734,
0.0049031312,
0.0105080325,
-0.0624869168,
0.0594798103,
-0.044565767,
-0.0231285393,
-0.0075779003,
-0.0338726975,
-0.0614128113,
-0.0125116073,
-0.0075541795,
-0.0081685018,
0.0046683499,
-0.0060520908,
0.0015585796,
0.0131437397,
-0.0014913789,
0.0354529917,
-0.049485188,
0.0046733185,
-0.0211624261,
0.0841455832,
0.1026384458,
0.038589038,
0.0244414024,
-0.0132110994,
0.0688438639,
0.0288893767,
0.020586174,
0.0374053903,
0.0274311621,
-0.0016422743,
0.0078309681,
-0.0169354882,
-0.0140158478,
0.0455926396,
0.063324593,
-0.0427798219,
-0.0542650707,
0.0995882004,
0.0346449092,
-0.0032012223,
-0.0166613609,
-0.0178109705,
0.0412771627,
0.0176957212,
0.0596649051,
-0.0644486248,
-0.0356075019,
-0.013187889,
0.0313244089,
-0.0150096146,
-0.0133021493,
0.0004180184,
-0.1140031591,
0.0330603272,
-0.0039148265,
-0.0169082154,
0.0156737827,
-0.0057918285,
-0.0271705948,
0.0184007939,
-0.0028293077,
0.0353745073,
-0.0233473573,
0.0175215192,
0.0431633741,
0.027684316,
-0.0076184561,
0.013668919,
-0.0189793892,
0.0155907003,
0.065063335,
-0.0000874507,
0.0050959657,
-0.012669893,
0.0134560503,
-0.0381930694,
-0.027103534,
0.0041083,
-0.0187198762,
-0.0055021956,
-0.0322419181,
-0.0187428538,
0.0545067154,
-0.0015271853,
0.028910948,
0.0558031239,
0.0324203894,
-0.0133094545,
-0.0192058496,
-0.0313177556,
0.0221524462,
-0.0022401013,
0.0789498389,
0.0462930277,
-0.0745384097,
-0.0175378919,
-0.0476379208,
0.0038704432,
-0.1038868204,
-0.0088486057,
-0.0127645032,
-0.0038024192,
0.0219435599,
-0.1046409756,
-0.0308500808,
0.040179532,
0.0255759042,
0.0073701958,
0.0083724633,
0.032849595,
-0.0125787798,
-0.0229482111,
0.0060479711,
-0.009068816,
-0.0104799271,
-0.0587458536,
-0.0019778854,
0.0274104681,
-0.0494942814,
-0.0305202827,
0.0222437344,
-0.062277995,
-0.0643202439,
-0.0265886541,
0.0634015426,
0.0144723738,
0.0011787078,
-0.010986032,
0.0163468085,
0.0048843417,
0.0249509849,
0.0389543995,
-0.0061843153,
-0.0290944353,
0.0157850645,
-0.0282077473,
0.0240653343,
-0.0447318219,
0.0260184463,
-0.0085065588,
0.0746913552,
-0.0441489778,
-0.0522734858,
0.0450610109,
0.0209333226,
-0.0056527941,
-0.0270536933,
-0.0258501489,
-0.0161289833,
0.0284265745,
-0.0105700847,
-0.0190169271,
-0.0534670725,
0.0078396583,
0.0262484867,
-0.0245250054,
0.0290278383,
-0.0719450787,
-0.016162781,
0.0722125545,
0.0081543587,
0.0182667673,
-0.0102635911,
0.0353300758,
0.0532603711,
-0.0206734296,
-0.0341496989,
0.0032354053,
-0.007005868,
0.0657378584,
-0.0086401058,
0.1035373956,
0.0054772445,
-0.0230363347,
0.0125345523,
0.0277323201,
-0.0144360652,
-0.0583873987,
-0.0406351015,
0.0061880667,
0.0147126783,
0.015164718,
-0.0292356256,
0.0000207672,
-0.0058586206,
-0.0203021392,
0.0553382225,
0.0015441665,
-0.0186338909,
0.0585590862,
0.0140177691,
-0.0049374579,
-0.0274914131,
0.0405061543,
0.0303373262,
0.016588401,
0.0180023368,
0.0274964944,
-0.0557575747,
-0.0116113517,
-0.0134656979,
0.0357946418,
-0.0115660932,
0.0107355826,
-0.0319367647,
-0.0496898703,
0.000634517,
0.0329494029,
0.0113519812,
-0.0008972719,
0.0382920355,
0.0642803609,
-0.0112293512,
0.0080847396,
-0.0444612056,
0.035125006,
-0.0716473609,
-0.0467615239,
0.0174154453,
-6.3225962e-33,
-0.0466627441,
-0.0505606979,
0.0341945961,
-0.0550291538,
-0.0165037811,
-0.0333106592,
-0.0394996516,
0.0190941971,
-0.0354559869,
-0.0238453709,
-0.0039382451,
-0.0264755972,
-0.0093690027,
0.0426451899,
0.0059147542,
-0.0247564018,
0.0210741442,
-0.0217470694,
-0.0078214183,
0.0316026583,
0.0259420089,
0.0160892643,
0.0037952997,
0.0251198113,
-0.0058703343,
-0.0577361397,
-0.0020098547,
0.0210773982,
-0.0562644415,
0.0795497298,
-0.0317941979,
0.0041266424,
0.0117667224,
-0.0285055675,
0.0045019272,
0.0564539805,
-0.0503869429,
-0.0417189002,
0.0017863606,
-0.0556572713,
-0.0324599482,
-0.062094301,
0.0078147557,
-0.015498532,
0.0350139178,
0.008841428,
0.0198718756,
-0.0131780999,
-0.0278556235,
0.0005501255,
-0.0211352371,
-0.0029360654,
0.00405504,
-0.0445985347,
-0.0469772071,
0.092351675,
-0.0080611603,
0.0122627439,
0.0181111824,
0.0089333784,
0.0625241101,
0.0418284535,
0.049215965,
0.0410802998,
-0.0292447619,
0.0307444539,
-0.0288811065,
-0.0495109968,
-0.0115448153,
0.0199772641,
-0.0082813399,
0.0470866896,
0.0409286954,
0.0611140616,
0.026626084,
0.0134659857,
-0.0641090646,
0.0446261726,
0.0113498829,
0.000826815,
0.0119532496,
-0.0405079536,
-0.0024893754,
-0.0076750419,
-0.0711514875,
-0.011753045,
-0.0406336114,
-0.0349401161,
0.0750552863,
0.0022605441,
-0.0508736968,
-0.0331327207,
0.033887133,
0.0014311461,
-0.0019344083,
-0.0142149134,
-0.0378631316,
0.0134809157,
-0.0246843975,
0.0390950367,
-0.0546109192,
-0.0021009864,
0.0273389835,
-0.0171989333,
-0.0355214737,
0.041202765,
-0.0056261988,
-0.028385371,
-0.0516162328,
0.0165759753,
-0.0321095102,
0.04614456,
-0.027578624,
0.0117929718,
-0.0077059423,
0.0036491351,
-0.0090716034,
0.0561034903,
-0.0147497403,
-0.0440064259,
-0.045344647,
-0.0636742264,
0.0202688072,
0.0416982956,
-0.0197591465,
0.0384743065,
-0.0268493593,
0.0260786396,
0.0226780698,
-0.0177849308,
0.0007815453,
0.0371548049,
2.618e-7,
0.0520836078,
0.0332214832,
0.0072560003,
0.0326686651,
-0.0285652932,
0.0366495326,
0.029398581,
0.012055303,
0.038012784,
-0.0079878466,
-0.0086222738,
0.0034664874,
0.0318905152,
-0.0054290053,
-0.113877058,
-0.0134356841,
-0.0392244868,
-0.0001273599,
-0.0633798763,
-0.0210464336,
0.0924016535,
0.0961551517,
-0.0245513543,
-0.004626648,
-0.0257906709,
-0.0257499907,
0.0327575691,
-0.0197309367,
-0.0283451658,
0.0443063714,
0.0037573806,
0.0281801298,
0.0093180425,
-0.0081086718,
-0.0172900297,
0.0038529851,
0.0105809355,
0.0758138821,
0.0407989249,
-0.039159704,
0.0279916544,
0.0055797542,
0.0198473204,
-0.087188445,
0.0652023628,
-0.0553471632,
0.0338353664,
-0.016005015,
-0.0306765214,
-0.0081849666,
0.0034405433,
-0.0566863939,
0.0056878794,
-0.0079505034,
0.0101342965,
-0.0201861244,
0.0423438959,
-0.0419910774,
-0.0091322334,
0.0107964585,
-0.0081971409,
-0.033235725,
-0.0720000267,
-0.0325538591,
-0.0209997371,
-0.0280409735,
-0.0199308656,
2.326612576e-34,
0.0132824434,
-0.0186456982,
-0.0008171916,
0.0328107066,
0.0177882966,
-0.0182469226,
0.0043424773,
0.0091831852,
0.0099522388,
-0.1047847867,
-0.0203329753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12373v2 | WebCanvas: Benchmarking Web Agents in Online Environments | 2024-06-18T07:58:33 | 2024-06-27T16:56:13 | Yichen Pan, Dehan Kong, Sida Zhou, Cheng Cui, Yifei Leng, Bing Jiang, Hangyu Liu, Yanyi Shang, Shuyan Zhou, Tongshuang Wu, Zhengyang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | For web agents to be practically useful, they must adapt to the continuously
evolving web environment characterized by frequent updates to user interfaces
and content. However, most existing benchmarks only capture the static aspects
of the web. To bridge this gap, we introduce WebCanvas, an innovative online
evaluation framework for web agents that effectively addresses the dynamic
nature of web interactions. WebCanvas contains three main components to
facilitate realistic assessments: (1) A novel evaluation metric which reliably
capture critical intermediate actions or states necessary for task completions
while disregarding noise caused by insignificant events or changed
web-elements. (2) A benchmark dataset called Mind2Web-Live, a refined version
of original Mind2Web static dataset containing 542 tasks with 2439 intermediate
evaluation states; (3) Lightweight and generalizable annotation tools and
testing pipelines that enables the community to collect and maintain the
high-quality, up-to-date dataset. Building on WebCanvas, we open-source an
agent framework with extensible modules for reasoning, providing a foundation
for the community to conduct online inference and evaluations. Our
best-performing agent achieves a task success rate of 23.1% and a task
completion rate of 48.8% on the Mind2Web-Live test set. Additionally, we
analyze the performance discrepancies across various websites, domains, and
experimental environments. We encourage the community to contribute further
insights on online agent evaluation, thereby advancing this field of research. | [
0.0223862622,
0.0029158003,
-0.0311267469,
-0.0358434208,
-0.018999679,
0.0267760474,
0.0337948166,
0.0211037751,
0.0751027092,
-0.0402007736,
-0.0520320833,
-0.0253158137,
-0.0009014731,
0.0600346848,
-0.0106717525,
-0.0547016189,
-0.0059333993,
-0.0113274045,
0.0103028761,
0.0281727761,
0.0103804916,
-0.0215923768,
-0.0489082523,
0.0706941932,
-0.0063155536,
-0.0371390171,
-0.0326501057,
-0.0103307376,
0.0323942229,
-0.0378467478,
-0.005955582,
0.0168339331,
0.0071412604,
0.0080304882,
0.0000022436,
-0.0586582795,
0.032822296,
-0.0259023365,
-0.0423925593,
-0.0299077071,
0.0189429466,
0.056621816,
-0.0081923595,
0.046772629,
-0.0282025915,
0.0289976485,
0.0195781942,
0.0183166508,
0.0151602617,
0.0195522271,
-0.0194449387,
0.0831903964,
0.0163237061,
0.0157124884,
0.0297523662,
-0.0764685795,
0.003067808,
-0.0138637666,
0.0178975984,
-0.0606511012,
0.0132857859,
-0.0212193634,
0.0118235284,
-0.0128290784,
-0.0033792106,
0.0281709768,
-0.0535067469,
-0.0455366448,
-0.0195220802,
0.0846848637,
0.0311213471,
0.0449294485,
0.0271581542,
0.0158422962,
-0.0046647321,
0.0292631779,
-0.0485229902,
0.000256985,
-0.0277897473,
-0.034459237,
-0.0286844708,
0.0279879551,
0.0073950491,
0.0169313401,
-0.0129736839,
0.0766866505,
-0.011224648,
-0.019397879,
0.0078557143,
0.0065079001,
0.0384277925,
-0.0701049119,
0.0169215389,
0.0389473736,
-0.0789003968,
-0.009278981,
0.0075437101,
0.0269099865,
0.0187297035,
-0.0377866477,
0.0659344569,
0.0406538509,
-0.0092305336,
0.0726471245,
0.004341335,
0.0722059086,
0.0166651253,
-0.0203920435,
-0.0039995858,
0.0206619259,
-0.0954826102,
0.045859281,
0.0292208102,
0.0398310162,
0.0060852286,
-0.0395930558,
0.0032835833,
0.0551569685,
-0.0448472761,
0.0412464291,
-0.0366051234,
0.0092675714,
-0.0295530017,
0.0348225124,
-0.0755626485,
-0.012317826,
-0.0745263696,
0.0225034207,
0.0223129168,
-0.0889047682,
0.0073201242,
0.0033399765,
0.0272618365,
-0.0217913464,
-0.0106172068,
0.0808420256,
0.0173382256,
-0.0381811075,
-0.0160538759,
-0.0611972325,
0.0347802714,
-0.0475959331,
-0.060316693,
-0.0234603658,
0.063269861,
0.0129623339,
-0.0579301529,
0.0157387629,
-0.0013724673,
0.0145164728,
0.0154335033,
0.0368883014,
-0.0020831989,
-0.0173564963,
-0.0053754076,
0.0303063057,
-0.0903624818,
0.0223837607,
0.0024250643,
0.1022023335,
0.0491182022,
0.037185356,
0.0478485674,
0.0064347968,
-0.0333175622,
0.0235911403,
0.0813993365,
0.0379106104,
0.0185335744,
0.0290481392,
-0.0046693995,
0.0092807477,
-0.044065211,
0.0282926951,
0.0899324045,
0.0402272716,
-0.0307764467,
-0.0381571315,
0.0036680063,
0.0266653467,
0.0210940856,
-0.0190302115,
-0.0545945168,
0.056855198,
-0.0278756581,
-0.0432406478,
-0.0240698494,
0.0316038057,
-0.0393641219,
-0.0586002767,
0.0125934146,
-0.0228811018,
0.0698757842,
0.005389059,
0.0395799279,
-0.0090132039,
-0.0279329624,
-0.0241290946,
-0.0053563691,
-0.0328974612,
-0.0078346934,
-0.0944497287,
0.0162140094,
0.0975837931,
0.0936177447,
-0.039948348,
-0.0964878276,
-0.0047308351,
0.0287643056,
-0.001097503,
0.0382874236,
-0.0280018505,
-0.010226598,
-0.008554766,
-0.0911208168,
-0.023271434,
-0.0070113186,
0.0169105772,
0.0194269493,
0.0361885354,
-0.0093932441,
-0.0441180915,
0.0179644767,
0.0150706926,
0.013509444,
-0.0013340586,
-0.0342647657,
0.0259308852,
0.056799069,
0.0021540388,
0.0412198491,
-0.0154751083,
0.01107678,
0.0246319752,
-0.0414279476,
0.0083705727,
0.059056662,
0.020920055,
0.0503356904,
-0.0381592177,
0.0110290293,
0.0633390769,
-0.0072118891,
-0.0191439334,
0.0096081654,
-0.014936287,
0.0165577717,
0.0132430764,
0.0083385669,
-0.0104634054,
-0.0023844568,
0.0162408929,
0.0443125702,
0.0210787635,
-0.0205792412,
0.028448863,
0.0096797403,
-0.0053795599,
-0.010549725,
0.0235289894,
-0.021052381,
-0.0208264254,
0.0111589143,
0.0325179659,
-0.0099837389,
-0.0811648965,
0.011603388,
-0.0969961733,
0.0078738462,
-0.0124986134,
0.0101846252,
0.0262333527,
0.006301892,
0.0166022182,
-0.0240794402,
-0.0085005732,
0.039406091,
-0.0192761794,
0.0470466278,
0.0374858491,
0.0331875682,
-0.0596114099,
-0.0551040173,
0.0122949854,
-0.0062448182,
-0.0169059969,
0.02821064,
0.0179306492,
-0.01674827,
-0.0017935237,
-0.0498358719,
0.0063339612,
-0.0353683382,
-0.0495705083,
0.0387563854,
-0.0264924634,
-0.0228101425,
0.0841850713,
0.0250472873,
0.0509708859,
0.0341999568,
-0.0225296598,
-0.0480260514,
0.0088609904,
0.001529177,
0.0216373205,
-0.0739830136,
-0.0031032981,
-0.0010831024,
0.0409438387,
-0.0052319048,
0.0239144843,
-0.0405522585,
0.0065508415,
-0.0096007427,
-0.0370521694,
-0.0242389664,
0.005377572,
-0.0274192933,
0.0490996763,
-0.0237866919,
-0.0204870459,
0.0554882362,
-0.000610785,
0.0043504261,
-0.0142794652,
-0.0023086313,
-0.0011313874,
0.0471396893,
0.0011775962,
-0.001141295,
-0.0319397189,
-0.0197401885,
-0.039449688,
-0.0036819233,
0.0636011064,
-0.0439157225,
-0.0250004586,
-0.0128420936,
-0.0104292827,
-0.0119142337,
-0.0446435772,
-0.0354271084,
-0.0055632838,
-0.0198166072,
-0.0115165291,
-0.0058051636,
-0.0316004343,
-0.0648579001,
-0.0074331495,
0.0213665292,
0.0515618622,
-0.0134524908,
-0.0511841476,
-0.0157245602,
-0.0229265224,
0.0332685411,
0.0541309454,
0.0069470243,
-0.0093245395,
0.0244248621,
0.0695443302,
0.0422017723,
-0.043763198,
-0.0137785301,
-0.0114627033,
0.0174368583,
-0.0596688613,
-0.0072589843,
0.052416794,
0.0075267213,
-0.063472949,
0.0024227151,
0.100127019,
0.0463915318,
-0.0330326706,
-0.0110704601,
-0.0343274586,
-0.0185827091,
0.0311455298,
0.0094709527,
-0.0385483503,
-0.0313151479,
0.0423210599,
0.0423629098,
0.0048561427,
-0.0416953117,
0.0652527809,
-0.0577717163,
0.0293377656,
-0.0433585197,
0.0465849005,
0.0393588506,
-0.0545163788,
0.0532812104,
-0.0092916396,
-0.0053180517,
0.0339634158,
-0.0000479234,
-0.0255833957,
0.0126749752,
-0.042824164,
-0.0546018109,
0.0636325777,
-0.043592412,
0.0466517545,
0.0679036155,
0.0552914105,
0.0143987518,
-0.0714887008,
0.0038858033,
0.0066901972,
0.0149907265,
-0.0020102169,
0.0905677006,
-0.0100128399,
0.0207149331,
-0.0424568467,
0.0007025294,
-0.0353414901,
0.0058092158,
0.0289433114,
0.0609328859,
-0.0371876769,
0.0023895786,
-0.0391577892,
-0.0310969558,
0.0235715117,
0.0554567203,
0.0106199533,
-0.0374724045,
-0.0657995418,
-0.0177078824,
-0.0179894976,
-0.0261232089,
0.0133528868,
-0.0149874063,
-0.010228754,
-0.0135761239,
-0.1015166268,
-0.0861253589,
0.0522749722,
0.0303435791,
0.0079003545,
-0.0467121825,
0.0149890408,
0.0373774953,
-0.0308941919,
0.009720318,
-0.0168753173,
0.0437972173,
0.0020596816,
-0.0126170982,
0.0264559351,
-0.0384839214,
-0.0056535648,
-0.0094042914,
-0.0424137972,
0.0058108717,
-0.0092388662,
0.0324980058,
0.0265769232,
0.0021319936,
-0.0541207306,
-0.016320359,
-0.0063347723,
-0.0322516747,
-0.0597085357,
-0.0568551868,
0.0547815822,
0.0263566952,
-0.0067297085,
-0.0074307462,
-0.0838135108,
-0.0226124693,
-0.0384839438,
0.020736374,
-0.0089693507,
0.0156214144,
0.0057549365,
0.0177841373,
0.0176881533,
0.0188959185,
-0.0215211976,
0.0054089548,
0.0229374785,
0.0245451201,
-0.0002343184,
-0.0389270633,
0.0026888628,
-0.0069098477,
0.0284616947,
0.0336626209,
0.0639953464,
-0.0102436189,
-0.0454353616,
-0.0328952447,
-0.0105809197,
0.0163181312,
0.0239046477,
-0.0038647463,
-0.0109543595,
-0.0281108283,
-0.0141129876,
0.0357236266,
0.0485471748,
-0.0184406377,
0.0319180973,
0.0171923861,
-0.0006985636,
-0.0024817113,
0.0611186847,
-0.0664125606,
-0.0296952855,
0.0053511276,
0.011513846,
0.0144524947,
0.0364459381,
0.0512386523,
-0.0041934531,
0.0164840482,
-0.011537605,
-0.011720214,
0.0005741326,
-0.0165302418,
-0.039574638,
0.048499655,
0.005545882,
0.0103177698,
0.0453306027,
-0.0778055936,
0.0269054137,
-0.0436710343,
-0.0477845818,
-0.0336140953,
-0.0076003424,
-0.0311851464,
0.0644801259,
-0.0083696181,
-0.0791966245,
-0.0227531828,
-0.0443222262,
0.0125363711,
0.0259932801,
-0.0159222055,
0.0077612153,
0.0538286343,
0.0453633107,
0.0389192812,
-0.0096137235,
-0.0360319242,
-0.0491660908,
-0.0090634339,
0.0345132351,
-0.0352380686,
-6.071632931e-33,
0.008499776,
-0.0135300308,
0.0187135935,
0.028681118,
-0.0209573004,
-0.0250707995,
-0.0522790626,
-0.0016677394,
0.0232053734,
0.0016467364,
-0.0119886575,
0.0137819434,
0.0249465778,
-0.0299654976,
0.019810956,
-0.0497232527,
0.0431864746,
0.0019011635,
-0.0568747371,
0.0416130051,
0.0145015568,
0.0070965234,
-0.0161843523,
-0.0500731878,
0.0195707977,
-0.0113523295,
-0.0413806774,
-0.0092662647,
0.0103431689,
0.0604545847,
-0.0245521702,
0.0306217298,
0.0409281366,
0.012919886,
0.019856425,
-0.0081136003,
-0.063448891,
-0.0388776846,
-0.0245023649,
0.0243460126,
-0.0407079272,
0.0068791346,
0.001978657,
0.011424832,
-0.0493152663,
0.0192540344,
0.0463565253,
-0.0389596075,
0.0114195459,
-0.000941324,
-0.0686631277,
-0.0122561343,
-0.0156693514,
-0.0352100059,
-0.0077090715,
0.0878326297,
0.001051503,
-0.0375216901,
-0.068155095,
0.0165440086,
-0.04043369,
-0.0117288744,
0.0561212488,
0.0032529065,
-0.014015683,
0.0550749749,
0.0321889631,
0.0500999391,
-0.010175487,
0.0123539614,
0.0482811518,
0.049643442,
0.0005435955,
0.0253751073,
-0.010635172,
-0.0109358458,
-0.013899656,
0.0941981375,
0.1059078649,
0.0449193306,
0.0242642649,
0.0044669709,
-0.0561084561,
0.0132139996,
-0.0186883919,
0.034744963,
-0.0630360097,
-0.0401830189,
0.0761432275,
0.0457128733,
-0.0242579989,
-0.0538868941,
-0.0050461092,
-0.0168711301,
-0.0093351472,
-0.0013426002,
-0.0181730259,
0.0304322839,
0.0228283014,
-0.0619832985,
0.0020395552,
-0.0430870801,
-0.0034122688,
0.0240769219,
0.0475872308,
-0.0262898337,
-0.0136812329,
0.035270296,
-0.0178810433,
-0.0139391534,
-0.0492137894,
0.0123132654,
0.0107618496,
-0.0195350032,
0.0327497385,
-0.0201312024,
-0.0183379687,
0.040047586,
-0.0044833818,
0.017970968,
-0.0559773408,
-0.0053479667,
0.0161357205,
-0.040302977,
-0.0426166728,
-0.0454150811,
-0.0620307662,
0.0334479585,
-0.0283461567,
-0.0553456023,
-0.026001187,
-0.0109906681,
2.884e-7,
-0.0336732455,
0.0581381544,
-0.0170347858,
0.0258633848,
0.0414614901,
0.0319350734,
-0.0393888354,
-0.0117770452,
-0.004995876,
-0.0185067207,
0.0253824648,
0.0250084028,
0.031456545,
0.0627918318,
-0.0241518766,
-0.0475089327,
0.0181998834,
0.0129879788,
-0.041354347,
0.0150457211,
0.0255600307,
0.0074370615,
0.0145785389,
-0.0022111316,
0.0593114607,
-0.0249767639,
0.005704069,
-0.009140091,
0.0121379588,
-0.0163139738,
0.0149058132,
0.0302391555,
-0.0009287113,
0.0146447141,
-0.017161373,
-0.0136816343,
-0.0289656129,
0.0471464992,
0.0214175358,
-0.0298265498,
-0.0026194626,
-0.0398159176,
0.0611226968,
-0.0201467089,
0.0881440043,
-0.0121312905,
-0.0268866401,
0.0025572714,
-0.0444077924,
-0.0353663675,
-0.0254334062,
-0.0008703684,
-0.0252429489,
-0.014023833,
-0.0172738712,
0.0076272651,
-0.0207509827,
-0.0606661662,
0.0273567419,
0.0083148368,
-0.0352895446,
-0.0771194473,
-0.0365715474,
-0.0006508016,
0.0244440455,
-0.0323754959,
-0.0175396334,
2.416046345e-34,
-0.0047418405,
0.0327887274,
0.0343608595,
0.0207063071,
0.0316727646,
0.0435687378,
-0.0279788282,
-0.0093796328,
0.0521619171,
-0.0469025113,
-0.0056825993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12369v1 | A Comparative Study of Continuous Sign Language Recognition Techniques | 2024-06-18T07:51:44 | 2024-06-18T07:51:44 | Sarah Alyami, Hamzah Luqman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Continuous Sign Language Recognition (CSLR) focuses on the interpretation of
a sequence of sign language gestures performed continually without pauses. In
this study, we conduct an empirical evaluation of recent deep learning CSLR
techniques and assess their performance across various datasets and sign
languages. The models selected for analysis implement a range of approaches for
extracting meaningful features and employ distinct training strategies. To
determine their efficacy in modeling different sign languages, these models
were evaluated using multiple datasets, specifically RWTH-PHOENIX-Weather-2014,
ArabSign, and GrSL, each representing a unique sign language. The performance
of the models was further tested with unseen signers and sentences. The
conducted experiments establish new benchmarks on the selected datasets and
provide valuable insights into the robustness and generalization of the
evaluated techniques under challenging scenarios. | [
-0.0360482447,
0.0598847717,
-0.0034790637,
0.0419859402,
-0.0317401737,
0.0567554533,
0.0543422401,
-0.0179224927,
0.0532503612,
-0.0239557829,
-0.0292096976,
-0.0315470025,
0.0290395934,
0.0315427445,
-0.0164583921,
-0.0534928814,
0.0359590948,
-0.0366658941,
-0.0268081855,
0.003754535,
0.013544267,
-0.0164285135,
-0.0410539731,
0.0602725931,
-0.0853483081,
-0.0054674069,
-0.0119184125,
-0.0198621657,
0.0449499674,
-0.0201939121,
-0.0645748377,
0.0128360027,
0.0406539589,
0.0412911922,
0.0000020832,
-0.0095721427,
0.0150327738,
-0.0149389775,
-0.0198459346,
-0.0055605583,
0.026932776,
-0.0791595504,
-0.0162790325,
0.0147135388,
-0.0351119451,
-0.0662328601,
0.024179101,
0.0646664202,
0.0079820585,
0.0083706453,
0.0062221484,
0.0014276451,
0.0596368872,
-0.0326738544,
-0.016539555,
0.0053289798,
0.0110192765,
-0.0210360643,
-0.0029267762,
-0.0620062761,
-0.0191195607,
0.0736887828,
0.0484026782,
-0.0370077938,
-0.0577466153,
0.0128501402,
-0.0499806218,
0.0048455046,
0.0066968282,
0.0611152835,
-0.0492553189,
0.0198642276,
0.0084956707,
-0.0642111376,
-0.0119146612,
-0.0157088451,
-0.0159835964,
0.025957318,
0.0128695592,
0.0128406016,
-0.0229153968,
0.034506239,
0.0607039817,
-0.0204711817,
-0.0125380568,
0.0258764569,
-0.0213152952,
-0.0029117805,
0.0106796511,
-0.0266665146,
0.0182427317,
-0.0105493367,
0.026313806,
-0.0124691166,
0.0078344624,
-0.0202661213,
-0.0186595805,
0.0034510074,
-0.0068739555,
-0.026954677,
-0.0315447636,
0.0361933485,
-0.0244201478,
0.0273148138,
0.0038421892,
0.0155262575,
-0.0046221982,
0.0459141769,
0.0101822019,
0.0315492898,
-0.0205700416,
0.004732728,
0.0067658927,
-0.0189061239,
0.0106713092,
-0.0463548824,
-0.0291439686,
0.0070450474,
0.0233822986,
-0.0242975745,
0.0195416175,
0.0276228506,
0.0271271914,
0.0282521248,
0.0398413427,
0.0403770767,
0.0141064739,
0.0259113982,
-0.015321712,
-0.0901695341,
0.0163114425,
0.020769693,
0.0145488,
0.0074629425,
0.0033279497,
0.0367360748,
-0.0065969462,
-0.0413497947,
0.0055114911,
0.0225300044,
0.0157101452,
-0.0422216132,
-0.0067499885,
-0.032644432,
0.0284484942,
-0.0243702587,
-0.0053437897,
-0.0765240565,
-0.0017406791,
-0.055728741,
0.0471754521,
0.0420032777,
-0.0038509588,
-0.0043738261,
0.05115382,
-0.0084340777,
-0.0143954121,
0.020390464,
0.04576708,
0.0172063857,
-0.0079434197,
-0.0251328442,
0.0135829998,
0.066134192,
-0.045245219,
-0.0093430793,
0.0100355223,
-0.038404271,
0.0126624536,
0.0526115112,
-0.0006463872,
-0.0118854921,
-0.0172328465,
-0.039039474,
0.0190043561,
0.0755754933,
0.0252395291,
-0.0235477965,
0.0406709723,
0.0193281434,
0.0540296398,
-0.045610033,
-0.0207780283,
-0.006399428,
0.0685068741,
-0.0514964312,
-0.0673251152,
-0.0009584901,
-0.0472150631,
-0.0272018481,
-0.0104796207,
-0.0617428273,
0.0205910895,
0.0588993616,
0.0760122091,
-0.0576850437,
-0.0313055664,
-0.0533543937,
0.0031126894,
0.011275759,
0.01049753,
-0.0137084583,
-0.0137347197,
0.0185074992,
-0.0371016748,
-0.0239337068,
-0.0208681133,
-0.0250225421,
0.0028483665,
0.002279704,
0.0094945095,
0.0390655771,
0.0848343074,
-0.0335148461,
-0.0548684187,
0.0427608751,
0.0170384794,
0.0400796942,
-0.07505849,
0.0681257322,
0.0194419306,
0.0053023817,
0.0190614592,
0.0562496223,
-0.0129315555,
-0.0244651306,
0.0526661575,
0.0156576522,
0.0247650836,
0.0408766754,
-0.0223206375,
-0.038832847,
0.0450980999,
-0.0490148216,
-0.0036833265,
0.0648530498,
-0.0917949975,
-0.0334166363,
0.0121344877,
-0.0297739245,
-0.0314303376,
0.0373012312,
-0.0126840901,
-0.0469303168,
0.0352337062,
0.0102559729,
0.0091260653,
-0.0246205237,
0.0094786454,
-0.0137832109,
0.0223472621,
-0.0048217261,
0.0104101393,
-0.0193671882,
-0.0521171503,
-0.0172347818,
-0.0426595509,
0.0507643111,
-0.0808963254,
0.009272106,
0.0369380526,
-0.0379545726,
0.0094994493,
0.0255502835,
0.0443098284,
-0.0178935286,
0.0457344502,
-0.06927827,
-0.0123899886,
-0.0270901024,
0.0161767155,
-0.0388987511,
-0.0007281969,
-0.004637599,
-0.0174399372,
-0.0256932508,
-0.0263177734,
0.0164631382,
-0.0689440221,
-0.0033382857,
0.0065079802,
-0.0484554656,
-0.0365395248,
-0.0341539197,
0.0006431728,
0.0521240048,
0.0125480648,
-0.0456379615,
0.0013134957,
-0.053352166,
0.0322100855,
0.0393808968,
-0.0158973914,
0.0175940767,
0.0378305651,
0.0031453848,
-0.0832462758,
0.0041861637,
-0.0073534511,
0.0369888879,
0.0052751135,
-0.0011250519,
-0.0231935158,
0.0040181978,
-0.0076590786,
0.0599732809,
-0.053484045,
-0.0171992052,
0.0024294008,
0.0563791767,
0.0202914532,
0.0402697138,
-0.0256100502,
-0.0572609156,
-0.0006352101,
-0.0548618585,
-0.0238681827,
0.028092999,
-0.0248630717,
-0.0241950881,
-0.0004677221,
-0.0562535077,
-0.0006698555,
-0.0342300087,
-0.0289584175,
0.0319432504,
-0.0336175561,
-0.0453295708,
0.0426874906,
0.0039521526,
0.0010859444,
-0.0441804267,
-0.050513424,
0.0257852711,
0.0304780081,
-0.0035159697,
0.0063818726,
-0.0074522905,
-0.0065223039,
0.0041425703,
-0.032047864,
0.0188498255,
-0.0401492119,
0.0016742556,
-0.0334940962,
0.0113449059,
0.027618371,
-0.0145091936,
-0.0191038605,
-0.0153796924,
-0.000104029,
0.0592273921,
0.0250251312,
0.0177394748,
-0.0291057806,
-0.0084293839,
0.027235195,
0.0210580174,
0.0050239041,
-0.0201748386,
0.0106471507,
-0.0043298863,
-0.0327091329,
0.0516072288,
-0.0852616355,
0.006740273,
0.0047237733,
0.0145299565,
-0.018302219,
0.0230206512,
0.0300771929,
-0.055159159,
0.0459517054,
0.0548399426,
0.0116141587,
-0.044367604,
0.0274721328,
0.0351805836,
-0.0199879594,
-0.0417151935,
-0.0470504686,
-0.0718426928,
-0.066250667,
0.0092428355,
0.032959912,
0.027181562,
-0.0185427591,
-0.0075428411,
0.0006457138,
0.0115063637,
-0.005280247,
-0.0774034709,
0.0034648504,
-0.0098796478,
0.0270164106,
-0.0017264541,
0.0361433104,
-0.0105440989,
-0.0001872504,
-0.0252543017,
0.0253179222,
-0.0668049529,
-0.0836632624,
0.0389101543,
-0.0093082972,
0.0031019431,
0.0088574849,
-0.0224466436,
0.0201639626,
-0.0661192983,
0.0324038863,
0.005927389,
0.0208797194,
-0.0272500347,
-0.0081465254,
-0.0014560325,
-0.035541527,
0.022695221,
0.0566035733,
-0.1081874222,
0.0244911592,
0.0465769619,
0.0462809429,
-0.0462646373,
-0.0299764704,
-0.0147702545,
-0.0764951333,
0.0092908461,
0.0161812939,
0.0017255673,
-0.0489124097,
-0.0543954484,
0.0111406641,
0.0033451079,
0.0417916365,
-0.0144070936,
-0.0043275319,
-0.0002156487,
-0.0701815858,
0.0043069702,
-0.0617753007,
0.033891961,
0.0048865099,
0.0022193012,
0.0167331863,
0.0460739583,
0.0079140663,
-0.0413616896,
0.0574118011,
0.0098619042,
0.0866058394,
-0.0612003021,
0.0059274714,
-0.0280587636,
-0.0103618307,
0.0159023013,
-0.01248438,
-0.0959222689,
-0.0098389518,
0.026791526,
-0.0098031722,
0.0067728981,
0.0117694093,
0.0008176469,
-0.0442949459,
-0.0310976747,
0.0479323305,
0.0330293886,
0.0101330448,
0.0443428531,
-0.0646795034,
-0.0298386123,
-0.0010111405,
0.0214873906,
0.0301028527,
-0.0066326433,
-0.0201093927,
-0.1186020598,
0.0263610464,
-0.0395761542,
-0.0142257502,
0.002732222,
-0.0011165426,
-0.0428650007,
-0.0347536206,
0.0210031178,
0.012484245,
0.0483799316,
-0.0720067024,
-0.008863043,
0.0188560262,
0.0439290144,
0.0127061363,
0.0128342193,
0.0125399735,
0.0127716307,
-0.0085632643,
0.1179330051,
0.0561196394,
0.0552244931,
-0.0150918756,
0.0125465523,
-0.0299592912,
0.0665207952,
-0.0164960604,
-0.0113954758,
-0.0011640337,
-0.023633277,
0.0154388612,
0.0212585256,
0.031816218,
0.0296931155,
0.0384765416,
-0.0676811337,
-0.0128366323,
0.0240269043,
0.0313468277,
0.0414303988,
0.0308612343,
-0.0015271958,
0.0247695092,
-0.0506885238,
0.0332535952,
-0.0039067739,
-0.0262302607,
0.0132974479,
-0.0100828558,
-0.0376525298,
0.0166433118,
0.0133253159,
-0.0545676202,
-0.0247885678,
-0.0103211021,
0.0235780086,
-0.0682462007,
0.0146731166,
0.0403442048,
-0.0229539443,
-0.0226847753,
0.0321180448,
0.0036296656,
-0.0100931935,
0.0285971407,
-0.0208556224,
0.0197665561,
0.0335608311,
0.0101598324,
-0.0134409973,
-0.0032573231,
0.0189981256,
-0.0131787313,
-0.0312077831,
-0.0088169556,
-0.0299783703,
-0.0444782637,
-5.493480729e-33,
0.0335826091,
-0.0149184335,
-0.0129136061,
-0.0105623668,
-0.0331542715,
0.0314839818,
-0.0399760827,
0.0408439115,
-0.0034001032,
-0.0071656634,
-0.0025864637,
-0.030433733,
0.0088688387,
-0.0066653229,
0.009604862,
-0.0488684885,
0.0296445414,
-0.025046993,
-0.0082553793,
0.0322627239,
0.0205548219,
0.0263308343,
0.0780970678,
-0.1189684942,
0.0169974454,
-0.0187132284,
-0.0233469196,
-0.0367789194,
0.0071904007,
0.01286506,
-0.0460869558,
0.0186834894,
0.0102785286,
-0.0019535641,
-0.0112470686,
0.0183365159,
-0.038855955,
0.0046180785,
-0.059001971,
0.1000010818,
-0.0562245436,
0.0274038911,
0.0085406145,
0.0288057048,
-0.0436226986,
0.0120292976,
0.039395202,
-0.0126118958,
-0.0162992999,
-0.0617883317,
-0.0086758416,
0.0695688874,
-0.0477969162,
-0.0161032975,
0.0278031193,
0.0304158498,
-0.0531217493,
-0.0280776508,
-0.0422366485,
-0.0025202374,
0.048991397,
-0.0074304678,
0.0709018186,
-0.0214831904,
0.0416141562,
0.0572021753,
0.029888019,
-0.0576265827,
0.0419977941,
0.0101994788,
0.104794018,
0.0363395624,
0.0141863599,
0.0635901541,
0.0667740926,
-0.0337173566,
-0.0481238477,
-0.0131464386,
0.1044107825,
0.0465135798,
-0.023271041,
0.0106169078,
-0.0097750807,
0.0184063558,
-0.0379462764,
0.0132769858,
0.0256639421,
-0.0059464411,
0.052486334,
0.0295417719,
-0.011987255,
0.0519169122,
0.0758238211,
-0.0042601335,
-0.0242105648,
0.0509550944,
0.0014632692,
0.034293022,
0.047217302,
-0.0063345633,
-0.0548608154,
-0.0407585762,
0.0294999201,
-0.0270865429,
0.0623779669,
-0.0364916623,
0.0054164156,
0.0822203904,
-0.0013967499,
-0.0037242246,
0.0060877656,
0.0505055264,
0.0138211064,
0.0281625111,
0.0500959046,
-0.0650322884,
-0.0141842114,
0.0636350214,
-0.0272451937,
0.0022676515,
-0.0127886524,
0.0393655933,
0.0182714537,
0.0435149036,
-0.0329421312,
-0.0087090675,
0.0128029045,
-0.0625845268,
0.0502971597,
-0.0819071829,
0.0145920357,
0.0190370586,
2.535e-7,
-0.0047500557,
0.0132839559,
0.0330127403,
0.0045404215,
0.0363370031,
0.0384219401,
-0.0128374333,
0.0029486364,
0.0068085175,
0.0574080423,
0.0096215243,
-0.0198913962,
0.0534102768,
0.0127504207,
-0.0462168679,
0.0399425589,
-0.0100360662,
0.0278108194,
-0.0397012234,
0.0398006588,
0.0334037542,
0.0836509392,
-0.0093829967,
-0.0299445689,
0.0433403626,
-0.0511268601,
0.0453707054,
-0.0517461412,
0.0563005731,
-0.0194760617,
0.057170447,
-0.0365873836,
0.015439407,
-0.0305461865,
4.522e-7,
0.0190290008,
0.0035030094,
0.0002534498,
-0.0358114764,
-0.0251403395,
0.0329100005,
0.0249077491,
-0.0213787835,
0.0053738793,
0.0816092044,
-0.0618624799,
-0.0001170936,
-0.037698973,
-0.0224412456,
-0.0163800623,
0.0415174849,
0.0245479755,
0.0582596958,
0.0420090184,
0.0169010628,
-0.1010552943,
-0.0149062378,
-0.0326501615,
-0.0030115899,
-0.0310841985,
-0.056445878,
0.0313828103,
-0.0313070826,
0.0184544157,
-0.0022433167,
0.0154836271,
-0.0354750827,
1.556584224e-34,
0.0180166606,
0.0121891638,
0.0072511756,
0.0242726598,
-0.0432025976,
-0.024217952,
0.0474749915,
0.040651001,
-0.0037593346,
-0.01332522,
-0.0081216209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12364v1 | Does Context Help Mitigate Gender Bias in Neural Machine Translation? | 2024-06-18T07:44:13 | 2024-06-18T07:44:13 | Harritxu Gete, Thierry Etchegoyhen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural Machine Translation models tend to perpetuate gender bias present in
their training data distribution. Context-aware models have been previously
suggested as a means to mitigate this type of bias. In this work, we examine
this claim by analysing in detail the translation of stereotypical professions
in English to German, and translation with non-informative context in Basque to
Spanish. Our results show that, although context-aware models can significantly
enhance translation accuracy for feminine terms, they can still maintain or
even amplify gender bias. These results highlight the need for more
fine-grained approaches to bias mitigation in Neural Machine Translation. | [
-0.0001638297,
0.0677663237,
-0.0240281858,
0.0357968919,
0.0227500573,
0.0014709666,
0.0794816017,
-0.021732118,
-0.063564755,
-0.0215119068,
-0.0395077579,
-0.0409259573,
0.0492147319,
-0.0237688217,
0.0338330269,
-0.0091432575,
0.0086093955,
0.0334498324,
-0.0064221276,
-0.0380348489,
-0.0214396454,
0.0117753875,
0.0170888882,
0.0525636338,
0.0198789574,
-0.031641338,
0.0476882122,
0.0589359589,
0.0175966937,
0.0315199569,
0.0583189838,
0.0310840476,
0.0027403431,
0.052291546,
0.0000016007,
-0.0365199409,
0.0033039358,
0.0326643623,
-0.0065201526,
-0.0217514075,
0.0296396408,
-0.0741852969,
-0.034472838,
0.0102415401,
-0.0171174295,
0.0082603628,
0.0270554572,
0.0112711666,
0.0239362568,
0.0354498178,
-0.0132909818,
-0.004207145,
-0.0589080229,
-0.0774373934,
-0.0028589533,
-0.0257269889,
-0.0086362809,
-0.0466860794,
-0.0861141607,
0.0328785479,
-0.0364985391,
0.0314159356,
0.0125808986,
0.0093081724,
-0.0421397015,
0.0438206196,
-0.0070376201,
-0.0282027945,
0.0152517781,
0.0358085148,
-0.0111278258,
0.0151720094,
-0.0128460256,
-0.0150921168,
0.0322200134,
-0.0123115405,
-0.0415337272,
0.0311056171,
0.0054811877,
-0.0186653361,
0.0237069484,
0.0230175741,
0.037833143,
0.0293023214,
-0.0266923904,
0.0603817664,
0.0150408074,
-0.0336848274,
0.0193809438,
0.0201681443,
0.0178562142,
-0.0396517515,
0.0403396823,
-0.0138733834,
0.0228950437,
0.0032881349,
-0.0156050008,
-0.0368873216,
0.0304033682,
-0.0799687356,
-0.0300348457,
0.0637860596,
0.0027876629,
0.0174598843,
0.0080940947,
0.0376164354,
-0.0129078776,
-0.0005883611,
-0.0533478409,
-0.0384984501,
-0.0179492868,
-0.0022954289,
-0.0332673602,
-0.0597891808,
-0.0725474879,
0.0307524018,
-0.0294443108,
0.0111002596,
-0.0462578088,
0.0007583871,
0.0299707763,
0.0330586582,
-0.0750283375,
0.0245338436,
0.0096159177,
0.0344628915,
-0.0424221829,
0.0161336996,
-0.0164998267,
-0.0693715364,
-0.0038250575,
-0.0101540564,
-0.024066411,
-0.0393689163,
0.0014026854,
0.0353208072,
0.01186998,
-0.0143679157,
0.0097385077,
-0.0222146399,
-0.0360062495,
-0.058943551,
0.0332874171,
-0.0454869308,
0.0506617762,
0.0311029144,
0.0248909257,
-0.0353584997,
-0.0256039482,
0.0289559402,
-0.0300999209,
0.0660637766,
0.0562138744,
-0.007731867,
0.0736069083,
0.0221497323,
-0.0482859612,
0.0798779726,
0.0498597957,
0.008432799,
0.0113840513,
0.023501439,
-0.0288706329,
0.0472928844,
0.0368206315,
0.0257150084,
-0.0365307257,
0.0170802604,
-0.0073182876,
0.0664185733,
0.112902157,
-0.0364158228,
-0.0023687177,
0.0042834552,
0.068002373,
0.0646240488,
0.0663637891,
0.0613814518,
0.037640281,
-0.0477260351,
-0.0265353899,
0.015780339,
-0.0814394131,
-0.0073288847,
-0.0193320494,
-0.02485447,
-0.0522539429,
0.0344012268,
-0.0222638492,
-0.0400670059,
0.0253671035,
0.0235810373,
0.0071181948,
-0.0068760188,
0.0079698991,
0.0330486074,
0.0109283552,
0.0420890264,
-0.0085921232,
-0.0460725576,
0.0051722229,
-0.0163735412,
-0.0308205299,
0.0364320055,
0.0008053705,
-0.0177881308,
-0.0358436219,
-0.016924968,
-0.0088903904,
0.0444316454,
0.0561499298,
0.0308185201,
0.0513465032,
-0.023364557,
-0.0245361812,
0.008182223,
0.039301008,
0.0170668513,
0.0137614142,
0.0726254955,
0.0508271456,
-0.0442168228,
-0.0837954506,
0.0227509812,
-0.0263192412,
-0.0376760587,
0.0485822633,
0.0102546616,
-0.0018594306,
0.0337039009,
-0.0285610687,
-0.0116201798,
0.0125546269,
-0.0386532098,
0.0052940906,
0.0586350337,
-0.0635055527,
-0.0348525196,
-0.017726656,
-0.0462761372,
-0.0669540614,
-0.0181366988,
-0.0320268758,
0.0002795127,
0.0278808866,
-0.0053060497,
-0.0065536839,
-0.0334242322,
0.0079117659,
0.0050985613,
0.0409369431,
-0.0381485894,
0.0196591523,
-0.0258471239,
-0.0307601839,
0.0221702885,
-0.0232384726,
0.0030991572,
-0.0862466395,
-0.0325212292,
0.0331020132,
0.0319409482,
0.0296936464,
0.025342321,
0.0084146587,
0.0051274528,
-0.0170969982,
-0.0684255958,
0.0195007138,
-0.02336457,
0.0025277473,
0.021268703,
0.0326055922,
-0.0125053236,
-0.009639333,
-0.0439817905,
0.0042621559,
-0.0048640328,
0.0296877325,
0.0239077844,
0.0132294511,
0.0296723321,
-0.0337626524,
-0.0373899192,
-0.0357305482,
0.051188603,
0.052461002,
-0.0035440144,
-0.0732837394,
0.0169997495,
-0.0123273497,
0.0030836617,
-0.0213920753,
-0.0342413299,
0.0018641161,
0.0230401345,
0.0086083412,
0.1067026779,
-0.0127464244,
0.0053358758,
0.0390302502,
0.0246430617,
-0.0497296825,
0.0037333404,
0.0162466951,
0.0067837932,
-0.0057810354,
-0.066708155,
0.0160912983,
0.0126941111,
0.0034473829,
-0.0347801,
-0.0121753551,
0.0341401435,
-0.0275368113,
-0.027233392,
-0.0356989391,
0.0250810366,
0.0268848669,
0.0580579117,
-0.0254223812,
-0.0357056931,
0.0170989446,
-0.0180909615,
0.0092374086,
-0.015374179,
-0.0385853611,
-0.0643339977,
0.0405414253,
-0.0373382457,
0.0295906067,
0.0002031639,
-0.0027305041,
-0.0790094882,
-0.0268073734,
0.0119826188,
-0.0134501932,
0.0286066979,
-0.0344552808,
-0.0143695697,
-0.0213581752,
-0.0315528139,
-0.0326552875,
-0.0029098154,
0.0138845332,
0.0174349118,
-0.0078174025,
-0.0060154679,
-0.0160413664,
-0.0046164086,
-0.0241610724,
0.0933738202,
-0.0113075515,
-0.0088072987,
-0.0277350564,
-0.003514356,
-0.0014608121,
0.0120820962,
0.0164225232,
-0.0720099807,
-0.0280454308,
-0.0007976231,
-0.0341333076,
0.0083552087,
-0.0458718874,
-0.0040977797,
0.0471461192,
-0.0427199006,
-0.0349762067,
-0.0216360856,
0.0117374854,
-0.0757998303,
-0.0022775789,
0.0944640189,
-0.0132974638,
-0.0859591961,
-0.0047048754,
-0.0115988571,
0.0111670019,
0.0290630665,
0.0356588587,
-0.038718313,
0.0074134306,
0.0347785093,
0.012131664,
0.0161930826,
0.0011927841,
-0.0401595272,
-0.0938746929,
0.0022590596,
0.0197253786,
-0.0954393744,
-0.0470356159,
0.0164756365,
-0.0198088717,
-0.0519586578,
0.0627909228,
-0.0166687686,
0.0192786641,
0.0035948835,
-0.0134288408,
0.0201594401,
-0.0550422557,
0.0081386873,
-0.1102586463,
0.0407359637,
0.0569916517,
0.0467029437,
-0.0320002772,
0.0000543409,
0.0283786003,
0.0003206977,
0.0252774619,
-0.0015901945,
0.0100180488,
-0.0340389423,
-0.0133138057,
0.008817452,
0.0083691245,
0.0049468637,
0.0283292066,
0.0058947094,
0.0118289515,
-0.0071986807,
0.0144080287,
-0.0550118089,
-0.0245756581,
0.0148947528,
0.0644313321,
0.0102031613,
-0.0587689131,
-0.0172948502,
-0.0338702574,
-0.0072119413,
0.0226984769,
-0.0090022376,
-0.0001392696,
-0.0198507123,
-0.0742375478,
-0.0448996797,
-0.0537935421,
0.0098035969,
0.0340045542,
0.0247273874,
-0.0433295257,
0.0144796725,
-0.003080271,
-0.0636397675,
0.0627788007,
-0.0137531105,
0.0330050811,
0.0058469283,
0.0143270092,
-0.0132155642,
-0.0480339378,
-0.0260594916,
0.0262133982,
-0.0532113053,
-0.0563013516,
-0.0028633184,
0.0493376032,
0.0269706734,
0.0842315108,
-0.0163057409,
-0.0454766825,
0.0343785919,
0.0659241676,
-0.0244507995,
0.0295205768,
0.0465184189,
0.0230270624,
0.014981308,
0.0332732834,
-0.0379863903,
0.0000112236,
0.0041948515,
0.0335040763,
-0.0001668357,
-0.0596309304,
0.003952628,
-0.0259294007,
0.0094228713,
-0.055266656,
-0.000219662,
-0.0393449217,
0.0114939511,
-0.0220932253,
-0.0209862106,
-0.0161049943,
-0.0592694618,
0.0558127388,
0.0176579151,
0.0296980143,
-0.001900863,
-0.0068738712,
0.0011712891,
-0.0299846474,
-0.0251170471,
-0.0115353102,
0.0311679803,
-0.0169514902,
0.039188534,
0.0159030724,
0.0010548997,
-0.0209628716,
0.0377016589,
0.0034663952,
0.0318342969,
0.016996365,
0.0431121551,
-0.0363195203,
0.0262631737,
-0.0579249747,
-0.0121623995,
-0.0191779286,
0.0144207953,
0.0570497215,
-0.0325856544,
0.0573176257,
0.0118761947,
-0.0186634958,
0.0192038193,
-0.0007997615,
0.0333482325,
0.0333709456,
0.0291439109,
-0.013233345,
0.0386596434,
-0.0160928015,
0.0499238372,
0.0346688256,
0.0509855412,
-0.034804143,
-0.0453415588,
0.0017631004,
-0.001785435,
0.023799032,
-0.047007218,
-0.0343974419,
-0.0270364657,
-0.0742354915,
-0.058489576,
0.0077624917,
-0.0082279239,
0.0176127609,
-0.0153505085,
0.0077786618,
0.0740571842,
-0.0438553728,
-0.0384648368,
-0.0321914777,
0.0017334708,
0.0121645276,
-0.0161864683,
-0.0628827289,
-5.320091271e-33,
-0.0346536115,
-0.0344371237,
0.0314238742,
-0.0277768187,
0.0017597788,
0.0306205954,
-0.0001497796,
-0.0265495293,
0.0065749758,
0.0180289708,
-0.0133986063,
0.0556491725,
0.017080972,
-0.0092664417,
0.0049776854,
0.0216183774,
0.0794718117,
0.0455951057,
-0.0099820402,
-0.0513982475,
-0.0332639553,
0.0238402411,
0.0616724566,
-0.0809550658,
0.1081386283,
-0.0054756296,
-0.0021934672,
0.0165038388,
-0.0129636107,
0.0155845731,
0.0098123932,
0.0307402089,
0.0177801922,
-0.0321524702,
0.011660194,
0.025793165,
-0.0968845859,
-0.0224057324,
0.0169839617,
0.0508773103,
0.0207140129,
-0.0542501882,
0.0870724767,
0.0011109461,
-0.0504036471,
-0.0177305825,
0.0399317443,
-0.0169547554,
0.004184165,
0.0284214932,
-0.0541365482,
-0.0077805356,
-0.0170716308,
0.0221750047,
0.0286902599,
0.0204247013,
-0.0106053473,
-0.0088721998,
-0.1009541452,
0.0154320803,
-0.017891027,
-0.001871051,
0.0494426973,
0.0140527273,
0.0120698279,
-0.0010191813,
0.0897172689,
0.0440305695,
-0.0133451484,
-0.0598446243,
0.0263593029,
-0.0352090374,
0.0436121784,
0.045013357,
0.062858209,
0.017654093,
-0.0907464176,
-0.0236741863,
-0.017982088,
-0.0086276336,
0.0261403695,
-0.0106933862,
-0.0514992587,
-0.028414404,
-0.0448483303,
-0.0907984301,
-0.0139810164,
-0.0005731257,
0.0022862959,
0.030465737,
-0.0000566827,
0.0185092092,
-0.0050130272,
-0.0786752328,
0.0297512859,
0.0020282394,
-0.016527446,
-0.0549738035,
0.0378575064,
0.0176957604,
-0.0229996908,
-0.0063420385,
-0.028008502,
0.0486193113,
0.0463411398,
0.0256036259,
0.0505034588,
0.0146926707,
-0.0236045551,
-0.0177084003,
-0.0668660849,
-0.0074642897,
-0.0017708872,
0.0471465997,
0.0281815827,
0.0043966891,
-0.0018167394,
0.0054975906,
0.0756988153,
0.0281610787,
-0.011745478,
0.0107188048,
0.0318178982,
0.0461645201,
-0.0540946387,
-0.0284069683,
0.0381032564,
0.0306299198,
0.0714458078,
-0.0575087965,
-0.0352914818,
-0.0261527058,
2.261e-7,
0.0348284878,
0.0574015565,
-0.0027406358,
0.0546023734,
0.0371641666,
0.0197447613,
-0.006742591,
0.0598802529,
0.0306282155,
0.0532425605,
-0.0090092486,
0.0248195827,
0.0108437948,
0.0194927342,
-0.0638206601,
-0.0424740352,
-0.0473147035,
0.0513268672,
-0.0160792321,
0.018390283,
-0.0014263424,
0.0720184892,
0.0146096107,
-0.0129094897,
0.0023421701,
-0.0385528058,
0.075843446,
-0.008891522,
0.0337504447,
0.0115027735,
0.0073331366,
0.0507842042,
0.0000865715,
0.0075787092,
0.0138479592,
0.008526098,
0.0330207497,
0.0577325746,
-0.0307210051,
0.0412984006,
0.0074614775,
-0.0296898838,
-0.0216481946,
-0.0491928793,
0.036724098,
-0.0340216644,
-0.0220816508,
-0.012039247,
-0.0059849983,
0.0257249177,
0.0768096,
0.0000873002,
-0.0216988176,
-0.0162483491,
0.0491651632,
0.0083205057,
-0.0326070115,
-0.0360233374,
-0.0472350158,
-0.0010640909,
-0.0138995014,
-0.0424213447,
-0.0102285799,
0.0257159378,
0.0207822863,
-0.0446325131,
0.0139007084,
1.709957079e-34,
0.0093200067,
0.0351935513,
0.0020870958,
-0.0064105955,
0.0020673573,
-0.0065144743,
-0.0082453089,
-0.0245765299,
0.0394351631,
0.0337474048,
-0.0327453613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12354v1 | Cross-Lingual Unlearning of Selective Knowledge in Multilingual Language Models | 2024-06-18T07:40:18 | 2024-06-18T07:40:18 | Minseok Choi, Kyunghyun Min, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models memorize vast amounts of information, including
private and copyrighted data, raising significant safety concerns. Retraining
these models after excluding sensitive data is prohibitively expensive, making
machine unlearning a viable, cost-effective alternative. Previous research has
focused on machine unlearning for monolingual models, but we find that
unlearning in one language does not necessarily transfer to others. This
vulnerability makes models susceptible to low-resource language attacks, where
sensitive information remains accessible in less dominant languages. This paper
presents a pioneering approach to machine unlearning for multilingual language
models, selectively erasing information across different languages while
maintaining overall performance. Specifically, our method employs an adaptive
unlearning scheme that assigns language-dependent weights to address different
language performances of multilingual language models. Empirical results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework compared to existing unlearning
baselines, setting a new standard for secure and adaptable multilingual
language models. | [
-0.0003862758,
0.1014594138,
-0.011766606,
0.081178762,
-0.0475793891,
0.0091811353,
0.0578261502,
0.0123721249,
0.0082242573,
0.0017996685,
-0.0405754,
-0.017222615,
-0.0180143006,
-0.0021299741,
0.0268392768,
0.019569857,
0.0400752723,
-0.05594505,
0.0030223918,
-0.0538568459,
0.0135625545,
0.0107290288,
0.0287911426,
-0.0162086505,
0.0147463176,
-0.0331617333,
-0.0349204428,
-0.0262867082,
-0.0039698179,
0.0074908501,
0.02463286,
0.0367417894,
0.0036667488,
0.0677602962,
0.000002224,
-0.018884426,
-0.0590991937,
0.0298160724,
-0.0273273084,
0.0571559891,
0.0131765315,
-0.036939498,
-0.0141895739,
-0.0025230644,
-0.0230842941,
-0.0046026772,
0.0348734446,
0.025482107,
0.0580332056,
0.0697552711,
-0.0127468342,
-0.0211300887,
-0.0265762862,
-0.0341830626,
-0.0093065463,
-0.0655010343,
0.0217703562,
-0.020939948,
-0.0674339384,
-0.0142641254,
0.0030360939,
0.0373761766,
0.0085487142,
0.0365891382,
-0.0696886852,
0.0139714368,
-0.0274848565,
0.0127113611,
-0.0159117915,
0.0285496265,
-0.0611894093,
-0.0472925231,
0.0107716145,
-0.0040716361,
0.0116048446,
0.0169813465,
0.0026332468,
0.0331054665,
-0.0186939929,
-0.0064061536,
0.0055837152,
-0.0221434254,
0.0676705986,
0.014184745,
-0.0085096313,
0.0556799509,
0.0174848232,
-0.0173667837,
0.0083324332,
-0.0503373668,
0.0408393033,
-0.0442576632,
0.0315633714,
-0.0098975608,
0.0265017264,
0.0348292775,
-0.0574204586,
-0.0418498181,
0.0374773853,
-0.0742111951,
0.0331724621,
0.002067259,
-0.0146949077,
0.0541565046,
-0.0098578418,
0.0396142416,
0.0012432104,
0.0247009825,
0.0060788929,
-0.0198551193,
-0.0164867528,
-0.0206642561,
0.0170703102,
0.0572375953,
0.0180834532,
0.0408441238,
-0.0300042853,
0.0126147987,
-0.0324147902,
0.0250639785,
-0.0154229198,
-0.0400444344,
-0.0328305066,
-0.0223300196,
0.0134928199,
0.0111990217,
-0.0074758921,
-0.0106478082,
-0.0260799509,
-0.0744827092,
-0.0174064785,
-0.0227385089,
-0.0197272152,
-0.0168068204,
-0.0000267627,
0.102756992,
0.0020528047,
-0.0085288743,
-0.0627010465,
-0.0675226897,
0.0020958323,
-0.0402844362,
0.0310070086,
-0.0615155809,
0.0088432739,
-0.0155631555,
-0.0038872284,
-0.0909610689,
-0.0112417582,
-0.0053912918,
-0.0749739259,
0.0548566133,
-0.0149075724,
-0.0223617163,
-0.0110932998,
-0.0019964557,
-0.0117389597,
0.0619038641,
-0.0237196852,
0.0313918479,
0.0693609267,
-0.0331916474,
0.0505783372,
0.053845223,
0.0344073586,
0.0047460627,
-0.0185863506,
0.0110791223,
0.0627936646,
-0.0840902925,
-0.0024660055,
0.0295193195,
-0.0054627676,
-0.0529099815,
0.079685986,
0.0149803469,
-0.0291923881,
0.0537129715,
-0.0080692461,
-0.0057591326,
-0.0053387759,
0.0251693297,
-0.0528763905,
-0.0060339072,
-0.0656307191,
-0.0134751061,
-0.0266610421,
0.046504423,
-0.0273914076,
-0.0027353121,
0.0217847992,
-0.0603686087,
0.0517487265,
0.0535028279,
0.041119881,
0.0592958517,
0.0126142697,
0.0798631981,
0.0525112301,
-0.0929777324,
0.0024774072,
-0.0245208479,
-0.0239430461,
0.0583908148,
0.0195513517,
-0.0352870673,
0.0131498873,
-0.0183290262,
0.0201151613,
-0.0037578768,
0.0334451795,
0.0067008352,
0.0992326587,
-0.0578554235,
-0.0218112823,
-0.0062673376,
0.0329595171,
0.0467395857,
-0.010109771,
-0.0012738375,
0.0192825552,
-0.0402755514,
-0.0467203632,
0.0138508053,
-0.0631064177,
-0.026224358,
0.0379554667,
0.0063652224,
0.0129182879,
0.0257910471,
-0.0251119435,
0.0141092716,
0.0433662646,
0.0203240737,
0.0110554276,
-0.0242360644,
-0.0178310368,
0.0290012676,
0.0234298967,
0.0033413228,
0.043173369,
0.0315754861,
-0.028199438,
-0.0048642471,
0.048511181,
0.0149957752,
0.0285328403,
-0.023678327,
0.0240704417,
-0.0483194999,
0.0254470557,
0.0035882059,
0.0344431065,
-0.014555363,
-0.0028547749,
-0.0338819958,
-0.0383302346,
0.0277098194,
-0.0325976051,
-0.0656210184,
0.0113311373,
-0.023729505,
0.0490052402,
0.0187283102,
-0.0003223066,
0.0046862923,
-0.019814508,
-0.0253723878,
-0.0283238124,
-0.0366360992,
0.0249336343,
0.0122243557,
0.0167906918,
-0.0209997669,
-0.051696375,
-0.0249213129,
-0.0148548372,
-0.045754727,
0.0393123664,
-0.005752739,
-0.0172401331,
-0.0000250743,
0.0136384042,
-0.0209347829,
0.0375283062,
0.0646691173,
-0.0324421227,
-0.0091958288,
-0.0046987687,
0.0425216705,
-0.0528660901,
0.0414933451,
-0.017256666,
-0.0310514495,
-0.0038419818,
0.0078036631,
-0.0367555134,
0.0461160764,
-0.0151193095,
0.0071969512,
0.067552112,
-0.0235256031,
-0.0180590153,
0.0011017307,
-0.0019989118,
-0.0359729044,
-0.0389373936,
-0.0078646317,
0.0140740955,
0.0201483592,
0.0158134922,
-0.01180143,
-0.0324269831,
0.0193377957,
-0.0041333348,
-0.042282328,
-0.0426053591,
-0.0080126291,
-0.0023232596,
0.0203812346,
-0.0055942978,
-0.0547337383,
0.0418166444,
-0.0245623887,
0.0361940414,
-0.0354948863,
-0.0234446116,
0.0093595972,
0.0324248411,
-0.018300727,
0.0667390302,
0.0410404988,
-0.0169237219,
-0.0449863039,
-0.0359569788,
0.0599386282,
-0.0505499244,
-0.0198565815,
-0.0339344367,
-0.0197306238,
0.0247903261,
-0.0395058058,
-0.0247903448,
-0.0170234516,
-0.0026399975,
-0.0052872896,
-0.0194346905,
-0.0359433219,
-0.0044997437,
-0.0435665101,
0.0855620801,
0.0140315713,
0.0106034148,
0.0327812992,
-0.0138479732,
-0.0147292893,
0.0064715571,
-0.0732014924,
-0.0295681227,
-0.0391209461,
0.0087611107,
0.0687926486,
0.0450519659,
-0.0197763313,
0.0156163815,
0.0106185731,
0.0282700844,
-0.0197475255,
-0.0276991408,
0.0366666988,
0.0106120668,
-0.0326965414,
0.0058643986,
0.0627999678,
-0.0008725623,
-0.0421899594,
-0.0165436585,
0.0095575862,
0.0024462384,
-0.0017195825,
0.0084433295,
-0.0790929943,
0.0009896418,
0.0147857992,
0.0386564247,
-0.0034070704,
-0.0302823372,
-0.0174521636,
-0.0919656083,
-0.038236253,
0.0407617763,
-0.0659428239,
-0.0345722549,
-0.0445603989,
-0.047561828,
-0.0155950524,
0.0141076408,
-0.0292922296,
0.0136381537,
-0.0096400995,
0.0053988704,
-0.0560368523,
-0.04223096,
0.0186871011,
-0.030739978,
0.0075965147,
0.0378686413,
0.0163405146,
-0.0507070571,
-0.0323467366,
0.0248761661,
-0.0052064923,
-0.0102049205,
-0.0054103928,
0.0341470242,
0.0166400541,
-0.0319153592,
0.0393195525,
0.0464388952,
0.0202548988,
-0.0406523384,
0.0305951592,
0.0434338301,
0.0051710387,
0.0073949508,
0.0195868481,
-0.0447185114,
0.028865261,
0.0429499932,
-0.0123278592,
-0.0418442748,
-0.0213895831,
-0.0500220172,
0.0129835941,
-0.016469799,
0.0051443805,
0.0313557312,
-0.0244372915,
-0.0661598369,
-0.0237861332,
-0.0114973783,
-0.0464514792,
0.0036419132,
0.0513764732,
0.0286004469,
0.0489196964,
-0.0103795705,
-0.0522190407,
-0.0377217345,
-0.0717924833,
0.0139600057,
-0.0193329584,
0.0109318737,
-0.0139088919,
-0.0166380107,
-0.0111815929,
0.0036561864,
-0.0443011671,
-0.0970909446,
0.0262772013,
0.0694946349,
0.0177549962,
0.0276488476,
-0.0274808295,
-0.0674886033,
0.1032044888,
0.0202760939,
-0.0341995656,
-0.0032312828,
0.0831343681,
-0.0541684143,
-0.0040068589,
0.0530767627,
-0.054259181,
-0.0147681329,
0.0918766037,
-0.0271350387,
-0.0393006168,
-0.0107647367,
-0.0048175319,
0.0582589284,
0.0187942535,
0.0090784207,
0.0155807966,
-0.0135307843,
0.0340904929,
-0.0150223766,
-0.0363160223,
0.0083892979,
0.0230138488,
0.0446819812,
0.0072461879,
0.044862628,
0.0027382888,
0.0366818309,
-0.0138585176,
-0.0070791999,
-0.0150253968,
0.050849963,
0.0516737439,
0.032659512,
-0.00378525,
-0.0135436747,
0.0458530411,
0.0105277672,
0.0255577248,
-0.0260881577,
0.0471871532,
-0.0138972681,
0.0130554074,
-0.0397729911,
0.0132333348,
-0.0336115211,
-0.0552864671,
-0.0203642678,
0.012043234,
0.040910352,
-0.0035686956,
0.0120690977,
-0.0132302344,
0.0033355823,
-0.0493090078,
0.0131249363,
0.0210927743,
-0.0475357398,
-0.0060904375,
-0.0058291103,
-0.0333481841,
0.0657616779,
0.1091397479,
-0.0144198453,
0.0555739477,
-0.0140756955,
-0.0182992853,
-0.0351498127,
-0.0228348859,
0.0351541713,
0.0182614997,
-0.0522123352,
-0.0325107574,
-0.0329346918,
-0.0819548517,
0.0164170805,
-0.0117560904,
0.0397752747,
0.0079789739,
-0.0042139008,
0.0835695565,
-0.0025686186,
0.0438563339,
-0.0966036469,
0.0115432153,
0.0240290854,
-0.0144286705,
0.0228066463,
-6.234348166e-33,
0.0512101911,
0.0137053048,
-0.029773375,
0.0294463281,
0.0614735335,
0.0316652805,
0.0012272461,
-0.0030152714,
-0.0457892977,
-0.0135676134,
-0.0296831075,
-0.012690966,
0.0109070083,
0.0211244803,
-0.0230797976,
-0.0018302572,
0.0195708834,
-0.0049624713,
-0.0225448087,
0.0445001833,
0.0920990705,
0.0544384085,
0.0894595757,
-0.0926861987,
0.048162017,
-0.0123296697,
-0.0469743572,
0.0029791989,
-0.0128610646,
0.038398128,
-0.0354886465,
0.014020904,
-0.0034040373,
-0.0223551877,
-0.0144934161,
0.0092303352,
-0.0169739276,
-0.0105970865,
-0.0069728787,
0.0068455492,
0.0570231415,
-0.0635060668,
0.0139211519,
-0.0323474444,
0.002260685,
0.0080679851,
0.0002233874,
-0.0103395563,
-0.036949642,
-0.0162810236,
-0.0078021884,
0.006649327,
-0.0377277471,
0.0049653682,
0.0634064078,
0.0163259767,
0.0038718886,
-0.0350144617,
-0.0727325827,
0.0521934219,
0.0152369067,
0.0321006067,
0.0721297115,
0.0196077358,
0.0118378149,
0.0669045299,
0.0463781357,
0.0140486043,
0.0584115088,
0.02061655,
0.0202142801,
0.0316162296,
0.0350107364,
0.0692922696,
0.0470608734,
-0.0513994657,
-0.0630411729,
-0.0071522994,
-0.0147110326,
0.0334064513,
0.0385544077,
0.0162094552,
-0.018611934,
-0.0219637845,
-0.0516123809,
-0.0360159278,
-0.0432063416,
-0.0130704371,
0.0041972487,
-0.0062476117,
-0.0502721295,
0.016203098,
0.028003186,
-0.0279692635,
-0.0297942311,
0.0642467812,
0.0161083024,
-0.0271771252,
-0.0083572995,
0.0253385156,
-0.030634068,
-0.0251590796,
-0.0246430375,
-0.0510190576,
0.0253110472,
0.0029350133,
0.0618582107,
0.0483896434,
-0.053493809,
-0.0038841336,
-0.0263458844,
0.0105812699,
0.0565818772,
0.0675451234,
0.0292846281,
0.0097717484,
0.0052376762,
-0.0110172238,
0.0611181743,
-0.0149123119,
-0.0494465306,
0.001577047,
-0.0062505095,
0.0254702624,
0.0035121876,
-0.0215796828,
0.0139043601,
0.0343199596,
0.0574829467,
0.0002612638,
0.0112123583,
0.0082879253,
2.966e-7,
0.0035538359,
-0.0175693892,
0.0028198841,
-0.0182119384,
0.0091460198,
0.0680101812,
-0.0437969156,
0.066405721,
-0.0435560197,
-0.0093023889,
-0.0418190658,
0.0151241245,
0.06533961,
0.0509194918,
-0.0706151202,
-0.0167958196,
-0.0599553548,
-0.0167269688,
-0.0583926551,
-0.012182083,
-0.0212749392,
0.0858329758,
0.017626524,
-0.0266166199,
-0.0364525653,
-0.0597711951,
0.0156978443,
-0.0400440656,
-0.037181627,
-0.0197714772,
0.0288039353,
0.0773339048,
0.0025820686,
0.0104901241,
-0.0475615524,
0.0002930595,
-0.0152494237,
0.0683614686,
0.0550740436,
-0.0194592644,
-0.0028679259,
-0.0205386952,
-0.030631721,
-0.0026102643,
0.0522174314,
0.0415990651,
-0.0292470921,
-0.0058078575,
-0.0103075067,
-0.0153675778,
0.0641268939,
-0.029654745,
-0.0157188755,
0.0469621606,
0.0258969199,
0.011076577,
-0.0161065906,
-0.047058586,
-0.032504946,
-0.0284924172,
-0.0152306855,
-0.0031008879,
0.0151810618,
-0.0115347132,
-0.0100077167,
-0.0600101911,
0.0801873878,
2.360911068e-34,
-0.0047561675,
-0.0649750382,
-0.0065270257,
0.0119015146,
0.0248646289,
-0.0282229073,
-0.0019505135,
0.0341267623,
-0.0259507746,
-0.018156575,
-0.0042177509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12347v1 | Interpreting Bias in Large Language Models: A Feature-Based Approach | 2024-06-18T07:28:15 | 2024-06-18T07:28:15 | Nirmalendu Prakash, Lee Ka Wei Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as Mistral and LLaMA have showcased
remarkable performance across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
Despite their success, these models inherit social biases from the diverse
datasets on which they are trained. This paper investigates the propagation of
biases within LLMs through a novel feature-based analytical approach. Drawing
inspiration from causal mediation analysis, we hypothesize the evolution of
bias-related features and validate them using interpretability techniques like
activation and attribution patching. Our contributions are threefold: (1) We
introduce and empirically validate a feature-based method for bias analysis in
LLMs, applied to LLaMA-2-7B, LLaMA-3-8B, and Mistral-7B-v0.3 with templates
from a professions dataset. (2) We extend our method to another form of gender
bias, demonstrating its generalizability. (3) We differentiate the roles of
MLPs and attention heads in bias propagation and implement targeted debiasing
using a counterfactual dataset. Our findings reveal the complex nature of bias
in LLMs and emphasize the necessity for tailored debiasing strategies, offering
a deeper understanding of bias mechanisms and pathways for effective
mitigation. | [
0.0408669747,
0.0492234267,
-0.0423021242,
0.0477227606,
0.0041945018,
0.0169408824,
0.0396262668,
-0.0241107568,
0.0555674657,
-0.0591172352,
-0.0309635438,
-0.0007975146,
0.0254704114,
0.007942806,
0.0428581499,
-0.0439350419,
0.0200711694,
0.011520151,
0.0566066764,
-0.023596203,
0.0183358938,
0.0113011096,
0.0268948413,
0.0541814305,
0.0198318902,
-0.032686621,
0.0688084885,
-0.0045820451,
0.0057011754,
0.0014553638,
0.0276979096,
0.0470140502,
-0.0090471562,
0.023142172,
0.00000197,
-0.0716660991,
0.0170675404,
0.0095459679,
-0.0253438838,
-0.0072751516,
0.0571565814,
-0.0133115761,
0.002988067,
0.0271143541,
-0.0164788179,
0.004395016,
0.0322060511,
0.0438874774,
0.0300737917,
0.0473927371,
-0.0058761938,
-0.0413633212,
-0.0286221765,
-0.0277462173,
0.0193081219,
-0.029618971,
0.0439974628,
-0.0469168201,
-0.0669257864,
-0.0221002959,
-0.0425750948,
0.0195669588,
-0.0098362351,
-0.0079140048,
0.03654911,
0.0152802113,
0.003753504,
-0.048646275,
-0.0092422394,
0.0546845384,
0.0064693214,
-0.0387744159,
0.0069771069,
-0.0294306856,
0.040367756,
0.0357611589,
-0.0450101122,
0.0143394358,
0.0100933742,
0.0018733644,
0.0508948304,
0.0077326009,
0.0371365771,
0.0298051145,
0.0033190073,
0.0450006761,
0.0014211573,
-0.0310425386,
0.0290689506,
0.0352789797,
0.0465925708,
-0.0670890361,
0.0216446202,
-0.0162304118,
-0.009297207,
0.0223408509,
-0.0103719905,
-0.0087220883,
0.038510181,
-0.0731269419,
-0.0158260297,
0.0192324668,
-0.0352682956,
0.0310671497,
-0.0292071365,
-0.0033257448,
-0.0400287099,
0.0069706012,
0.0067226859,
-0.015367507,
-0.0227232687,
-0.0271607488,
0.0236630067,
-0.0376024991,
-0.0086472379,
0.0317979716,
-0.0150973434,
-0.0043795113,
-0.0540480278,
-0.0171809215,
0.0285745598,
0.0367527716,
-0.0195745677,
0.0089319451,
-0.0452697687,
0.0421306528,
-0.0327384286,
0.0583703853,
-0.0317418687,
-0.0802086815,
-0.0250948463,
0.0219611265,
0.0129326135,
-0.0475734882,
-0.0061230431,
0.0556548014,
0.0214111377,
-0.0348835997,
-0.0316168815,
-0.0372346044,
-0.0112353684,
-0.0680754185,
-0.0065306081,
-0.0226170942,
0.0245326925,
0.0396796092,
0.0150706396,
-0.0280238111,
-0.0025771137,
0.0270362981,
-0.0829889774,
0.0468277968,
0.0272439811,
0.0220408868,
0.0395710804,
0.0094767297,
-0.0151046095,
0.0944973603,
0.0229807105,
0.0232520625,
0.0071670385,
0.0020060092,
0.0192584526,
0.0303974636,
0.0359445401,
-0.0125813298,
-0.0255246554,
0.0045125247,
-0.035961464,
0.0110899713,
0.094043754,
0.0037769289,
-0.0288921427,
-0.0081454283,
0.0721649677,
0.0173865017,
0.0097077228,
0.0242940057,
0.0200730301,
-0.0100382734,
0.0028095203,
0.009823055,
-0.0801564679,
0.0177981351,
0.0012926742,
-0.0439634956,
-0.031936083,
0.0256073829,
-0.0042319428,
-0.0343392342,
-0.0049841343,
0.0396224335,
-0.016094191,
0.0178972688,
0.0288656,
0.0243636407,
-0.0129594486,
0.0695855394,
0.0346969441,
-0.0027877998,
0.0015254301,
-0.0394955054,
0.0059685619,
0.0583844669,
0.0140871489,
-0.0239505209,
-0.001321425,
-0.0400322042,
-0.0217232648,
0.0363275297,
0.0543519445,
-0.0098983217,
-0.005914839,
-0.0351561978,
-0.0191512797,
0.0024040176,
0.0535252765,
0.0228414685,
0.0193227064,
0.0153808668,
0.0094033293,
-0.0390582308,
-0.0628681183,
0.0401497446,
0.0123523818,
-0.0437116697,
-0.0261812862,
0.0137684727,
0.034585271,
0.0237500034,
-0.0173712652,
-0.0037907779,
0.0003316802,
-0.0122608272,
0.0141204521,
0.0436339006,
-0.0274650119,
-0.0071989498,
0.001728147,
-0.0485150479,
-0.0671134517,
0.0237595588,
-0.021639498,
-0.0059246635,
0.0555559732,
-0.0191907398,
0.038394887,
0.0001093096,
-0.0053611761,
-0.030229101,
0.0394249782,
-0.0451114327,
0.0715763494,
-0.0141204409,
-0.0426670983,
0.0238571577,
-0.0466460474,
0.0103285499,
-0.0460790098,
-0.0064234729,
-0.0047012237,
0.0312253851,
-0.0248069521,
0.0168851614,
-0.0509931371,
-0.0378895514,
-0.0336628295,
-0.0827279985,
-0.0118199559,
-0.0294173583,
0.0046373354,
0.0189899597,
-0.007791887,
-0.0178384501,
-0.0215935037,
-0.0100171398,
-0.0244671516,
0.0027283148,
0.0421256237,
0.0116631631,
-0.0272351913,
-0.0165252201,
-0.0569341891,
-0.0078380583,
-0.0554863773,
0.0590198115,
0.0440609157,
-0.0487719513,
-0.0685886964,
-0.0097392611,
-0.0067844186,
0.0014507977,
-0.0127419513,
-0.0128873959,
0.0086104535,
0.0444763191,
0.020571908,
0.0989611074,
-0.0143848974,
0.0415192284,
0.0723503232,
0.0161102973,
-0.0650590509,
-0.0281099658,
0.000512572,
0.0219818447,
-0.0423867032,
-0.0583666004,
-0.0194348525,
0.0751970932,
0.0274416767,
-0.0170935262,
-0.0258634351,
0.0378130339,
-0.0121100256,
-0.065628849,
0.0053558764,
-0.0337708369,
-0.0141154015,
0.0361287706,
-0.0468105525,
-0.0798325911,
0.0246019382,
0.0003399461,
0.0156541113,
-0.0277222525,
0.0156938676,
-0.0619151704,
0.0363874212,
0.013135246,
0.0169635806,
0.007321931,
-0.0453456566,
-0.0578586236,
-0.0142630236,
0.0299475361,
-0.0113301808,
-0.0038499837,
-0.041546721,
-0.0034340515,
0.0166929327,
-0.0075057968,
-0.0374306627,
-0.0543355346,
-0.05154052,
-0.0082959021,
0.0071857828,
0.0106710475,
-0.0332015678,
-0.0285585951,
0.0088235596,
0.0118995728,
-0.0095884176,
-0.0007150398,
-0.0136156045,
0.0027544838,
0.0347823761,
0.026344277,
0.0588450171,
-0.0059695914,
-0.007503551,
0.0168986451,
0.0042753397,
0.0170889515,
-0.0256599542,
-0.0065253745,
0.0320685878,
-0.0573721565,
0.0039937627,
-0.004391674,
0.0548151173,
-0.0752989054,
0.0183673687,
0.0907108113,
0.0011727342,
-0.0669202134,
0.0173568353,
-0.0060290033,
0.0073968447,
0.0595791563,
-0.000692041,
-0.0741766766,
-0.0150732109,
0.0190926977,
0.0034120115,
-0.0271353815,
-0.0253011528,
-0.007814073,
-0.1182606965,
0.0383817926,
-0.0359722935,
0.0035071003,
-0.0121490909,
-0.050553713,
0.0064415815,
-0.049788408,
0.0376852453,
-0.0138919409,
-0.0045116311,
0.0032031978,
0.0182166826,
-0.0042352388,
-0.07039202,
0.0217317268,
-0.0446779542,
0.1001931429,
0.0723292828,
0.0382455289,
-0.0281663649,
0.0006490177,
0.0466900431,
0.0117055401,
0.0207039863,
-0.0243744627,
0.0685226992,
-0.0330491662,
-0.0200367589,
-0.0138861882,
0.0491846167,
0.0043351613,
0.0196692627,
-0.0181119274,
0.0538209602,
0.02913622,
-0.0442865007,
-0.0272204317,
-0.0183297042,
0.0012565684,
0.0780855566,
0.0281713065,
-0.0121473996,
-0.0355365053,
-0.0220060814,
-0.0305243693,
0.0708534122,
-0.0848965719,
0.0124767795,
0.0179494433,
-0.037913058,
-0.0197512526,
-0.0520879664,
0.0360148996,
-0.0109502748,
0.0161652993,
-0.0068719112,
0.0092411544,
-0.0254036915,
-0.0212412011,
0.0659105107,
-0.0268879142,
0.029590996,
0.0260165576,
-0.0197377671,
-0.018935781,
-0.0439913422,
-0.0302777961,
0.017008815,
-0.0792790577,
-0.0473062955,
0.0410208069,
0.0463713109,
0.0271367803,
0.0663223043,
-0.030214604,
-0.1062219441,
0.0421252958,
0.0286844987,
-0.0315377712,
0.0327276438,
0.0133216269,
-0.0078507317,
0.0200604759,
0.0244785547,
-0.0327509679,
0.0005933422,
0.0284950417,
0.0068942094,
0.0028389522,
-0.0043052733,
0.000427295,
-0.007757016,
0.0503697731,
-0.0336278565,
0.0412923209,
-0.0637306124,
-0.010769289,
-0.0110787759,
-0.0321056359,
-0.0077774599,
-0.0202007648,
0.0420166589,
0.010671299,
-0.0208371896,
-0.0450355336,
-0.0644711033,
0.0024950132,
-0.0383493491,
0.0551978983,
-0.0036109493,
0.0010033607,
-0.0000386518,
0.016830733,
-0.0076190257,
0.0327591263,
-0.0204099212,
0.0421332419,
0.0567019805,
0.0269792806,
0.007715059,
0.0006137381,
-0.032808736,
-0.0082327332,
-0.0597479157,
-0.0354010127,
0.009697563,
0.0471782573,
0.0355792083,
-0.0740689486,
0.0771560296,
0.0055052969,
0.0065979119,
0.0300045963,
-0.0241700951,
0.0034209227,
0.0118923988,
0.0375927463,
-0.0040027974,
-0.022205539,
0.0155177377,
0.0794265866,
0.0331676118,
0.0715110675,
-0.0432677306,
-0.0550427698,
-0.0015748164,
-0.0481665544,
0.0461182781,
0.0014283966,
-0.0408669002,
-0.0198862143,
-0.0936574414,
-0.0532107987,
-0.0073395018,
-0.0381066203,
0.0202199928,
-0.0449451171,
-0.010060641,
0.0589200333,
-0.016427394,
-0.0443707928,
-0.0155784506,
-0.0212915633,
-0.008537461,
0.0003430683,
-0.0140027478,
-6.581769929e-33,
-0.0181842856,
-0.039983917,
-0.0122745866,
-0.0177543256,
-0.0113412561,
0.0068208897,
-0.0226747729,
-0.0194851775,
-0.0271207634,
0.0343431085,
-0.0016613471,
0.0489617512,
0.0228215568,
-0.0251626242,
0.0348202512,
-0.0327719115,
0.0686304495,
0.0138748307,
-0.0061036651,
-0.0148453023,
-0.0221438333,
0.0111640263,
0.0696692318,
-0.1049527079,
0.1014146656,
0.0142898252,
-0.0083933687,
0.0081978338,
-0.0430018641,
0.0372279771,
-0.0358636007,
0.0668973401,
0.0337638408,
-0.0692236796,
-0.0016952929,
0.0239878278,
-0.0495105051,
-0.0337754637,
0.0612852424,
0.0435286053,
0.0179235395,
-0.0316366851,
0.0662031919,
0.0210578647,
-0.0295688808,
-0.0068149483,
0.0668117851,
-0.0053658094,
0.0375758857,
0.0242501963,
-0.0608409345,
0.0251012519,
-0.0233906992,
0.0242363103,
-0.0032919259,
-0.0098717762,
-0.0083819591,
0.0577096455,
-0.0720735267,
-0.0095918151,
0.0264504347,
-0.0130197527,
0.0470974371,
0.0023164013,
0.0179838575,
0.0680896938,
0.0790908635,
0.0569281168,
-0.0208161399,
-0.0559828319,
0.0108242705,
-0.0042325077,
0.0023964127,
0.0476943143,
0.0461347029,
0.0224233959,
-0.0719346404,
-0.0442058593,
0.0158998817,
0.048511751,
0.0345147774,
-0.0090306625,
-0.0496339239,
-0.03647824,
-0.0601020381,
-0.0754097328,
-0.0261252671,
-0.0003815517,
0.0197426192,
0.0246585943,
-0.0021064635,
0.0194203611,
-0.0034206163,
-0.0563068651,
-0.0042894334,
0.0095747784,
-0.0125842001,
-0.0083962521,
0.0304402392,
-0.0023589861,
-0.0956079736,
0.0195878223,
-0.0119990995,
0.0371156968,
0.0439900942,
0.0184577499,
0.0063206595,
-0.0079248324,
-0.0421667434,
0.0063428846,
-0.0423428267,
-0.026558198,
0.0039877212,
0.0420986712,
0.059746474,
0.0033241317,
-0.0180539768,
-0.0036372459,
0.0681396574,
0.0421332717,
-0.0075880424,
0.0048249802,
-0.0111374734,
0.0151088415,
-0.0457711928,
-0.0229060706,
0.0081662145,
-0.0009953036,
0.0211880729,
-0.0519637801,
-0.0155528765,
-0.0543726273,
2.683e-7,
0.0292056948,
0.0911427364,
-0.0073551331,
0.0372530632,
0.0466862731,
0.022363374,
0.025322279,
0.056053333,
0.0451051742,
-0.0217499174,
-0.0190428142,
0.0324555747,
-0.0081734341,
0.0198109765,
-0.0645889342,
-0.0042632762,
-0.0495611876,
0.0086581958,
-0.0159221627,
-0.0270078033,
0.0139062656,
0.0707242936,
0.0238412451,
0.0054667559,
-0.0101726204,
0.0096210865,
0.0545139126,
-0.0092341099,
0.0063614282,
0.0198683422,
0.0416464731,
-0.0007574392,
-0.0002025219,
0.0351445861,
0.0059548924,
0.0493238568,
-0.0264481176,
0.0556751862,
-0.0292879809,
0.0113019999,
-0.0224619955,
-0.0255741831,
-0.0083235148,
-0.0771406218,
0.0596759841,
-0.0178213976,
-0.0621824451,
-0.0583769456,
-0.0128974793,
-0.0162191093,
0.0530073419,
0.0139039364,
0.0110535463,
-0.0047217011,
0.0016610513,
-0.0097789736,
-0.0456816591,
-0.0733200759,
-0.0546915978,
-0.0250096526,
-0.0221607815,
-0.0642240345,
-0.0005795461,
0.0184685942,
0.0304483008,
-0.0495477468,
0.0292261895,
2.175610914e-34,
0.0211748928,
0.0368274115,
0.0279570054,
0.0063966513,
0.0256480295,
0.0043201805,
-0.029149672,
0.0088380529,
0.0466788597,
-0.0561927631,
0.0031704949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12336v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12336v1 | A Compass for Navigating the World of Sentence Embeddings for the Telecom Domain | 2024-06-18T07:03:34 | 2024-06-18T07:03:34 | Sujoy Roychowdhury, Sumit Soman, H. G. Ranjani, Vansh Chhabra, Neeraj Gunda, Subhadip Bandyopadhyay, Sai Krishna Bala | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | A plethora of sentence embedding models makes it challenging to choose one,
especially for domains such as telecom, rich with specialized vocabulary. We
evaluate multiple embeddings obtained from publicly available models and their
domain-adapted variants, on both point retrieval accuracies as well as their
(95\%) confidence intervals. We establish a systematic method to obtain
thresholds for similarity scores for different embeddings. We observe that
fine-tuning improves mean bootstrapped accuracies as well as tightens
confidence intervals. The pre-training combined with fine-tuning makes
confidence intervals even tighter. To understand these variations, we analyse
and report significant correlations between the distributional overlap between
top-$K$, correct and random sentence similarities with retrieval accuracies and
similarity thresholds. Following current literature, we analyze if retrieval
accuracy variations can be attributed to isotropy of embeddings. Our
conclusions are that isotropy of embeddings (as measured by two independent
state-of-the-art isotropy metric definitions) cannot be attributed to better
retrieval performance. However, domain adaptation which improves retrieval
accuracies also improves isotropy. We establish that domain adaptation moves
domain specific embeddings further away from general domain embeddings. | [
0.0307162367,
0.0122914333,
-0.0188644398,
0.0039970735,
-0.0379010998,
0.0083505968,
0.0168794487,
-0.0337606892,
-0.0258985367,
-0.0727637559,
-0.0448617674,
-0.0387223698,
-0.0188349616,
-0.0212839618,
0.0277660377,
-0.0095271971,
0.0278421715,
0.0639805645,
-0.0041448036,
0.0184966419,
-0.0030069016,
0.0116893435,
0.0034901262,
0.0516748168,
0.0093501769,
0.0004104142,
0.0436823182,
-0.0023677892,
0.0410944484,
-0.0344748013,
0.0596821643,
0.0115083624,
0.0526985526,
0.0148971854,
0.0000017372,
-0.0476216413,
-0.0314989351,
-0.020280635,
-0.00412068,
0.0050724144,
0.0254674572,
-0.000737057,
0.0310103036,
0.0303285886,
-0.018993983,
-0.0278591439,
0.0226356424,
0.0408546142,
0.0126347365,
0.0682147443,
-0.0195772089,
0.0059465854,
0.0065932977,
-0.0145682851,
-0.0469999351,
-0.0396301039,
0.0029269257,
0.0229589846,
-0.0166999381,
0.029918978,
0.031447541,
0.0335111618,
0.0047066882,
0.0321029201,
0.0262032636,
0.0385353267,
-0.0151245855,
0.0287169646,
-0.0046299179,
0.0349706262,
0.0373188779,
-0.0375800356,
-0.0212848522,
0.038185779,
0.0033079074,
0.0135264015,
-0.0643273219,
-0.0009925085,
0.0311872475,
0.0402132981,
-0.0393611342,
0.0432702862,
0.0258059148,
-0.006993311,
-0.0326007381,
0.0325787365,
0.0325099267,
-0.0966920108,
0.0119275842,
0.0543393902,
-0.0333202705,
0.0364188403,
0.0472909287,
-0.0417212658,
0.0091187926,
0.0142193707,
-0.0123679191,
-0.0132160913,
0.0269171502,
-0.0396176949,
0.0756899491,
0.0257708002,
-0.0080610337,
0.0166494623,
-0.0307788886,
0.0160096753,
-0.0113118002,
0.0342328809,
-0.0473880358,
0.0005175215,
-0.0889012218,
-0.0234413259,
-0.0228680186,
0.0438663587,
0.0130328247,
-0.0218074601,
-0.0656905696,
0.0292958505,
0.0239827018,
-0.02573785,
-0.0191961657,
0.0108957691,
-0.0408327654,
0.0137189105,
-0.0064294282,
-0.0034935491,
-0.048821874,
0.0604056381,
-0.0011150106,
-0.0415650792,
-0.0083431331,
0.0027302713,
0.0067632305,
-0.0372529514,
-0.0311817378,
-0.0034888303,
-0.0066608456,
-0.0557411872,
0.0060231676,
-0.0039608376,
-0.0317465998,
-0.0298770238,
0.0196992215,
-0.0368683822,
0.0119929332,
0.0146517595,
-0.0028761406,
-0.0280107558,
-0.0128305685,
0.0400322936,
-0.0348105766,
0.0410850234,
0.0599525645,
0.0153407445,
-0.0005771051,
-0.0012960616,
0.0492712967,
0.0532541797,
-0.0052452013,
-0.0107543776,
0.0616150089,
0.0168571956,
-0.0251893271,
-0.0038519239,
-0.0019373634,
0.002192229,
0.0187718645,
0.0251792204,
0.0051556397,
0.0259230509,
0.0070246528,
0.0064003374,
-0.0457495004,
0.0183591563,
0.0431327187,
0.0634779111,
0.0542691238,
-0.0300030764,
0.0297423955,
0.0295096245,
-0.0536423773,
0.0111273481,
-0.0333927646,
-0.0434257425,
-0.0056808391,
0.0200343858,
0.0361141637,
0.0043519186,
-0.0384836048,
-0.0169158597,
0.0058253924,
-0.0144629497,
-0.0351757742,
-0.0318819322,
0.0349612199,
0.0031682097,
-0.0210523251,
0.0769635215,
0.0233734399,
-0.0670045465,
-0.050190676,
0.0274491459,
-0.0370858312,
0.0151533848,
0.0345852561,
-0.0166407023,
0.0092570931,
0.0010227049,
0.0366516337,
0.0262295231,
0.0513751917,
0.0052810903,
0.0113859819,
-0.0712525845,
-0.0351045653,
-0.0001049822,
0.0408345126,
-0.0097067906,
0.0299221873,
0.0245364942,
0.0541591384,
-0.0993926302,
0.0206657387,
0.0321246162,
-0.0154554518,
0.0112589132,
-0.0051906789,
0.0380802639,
-0.0062911767,
0.0290785022,
-0.0237995964,
0.0224202052,
0.0160644371,
-0.0564503707,
-0.0412253812,
-0.0230462346,
-0.0818430409,
-0.0340267532,
0.0091786105,
-0.0571439639,
-0.0008812256,
0.0662246048,
-0.0203449335,
-0.0006788567,
0.007775581,
-0.0279082302,
0.056673903,
-0.0735992938,
0.022548588,
-0.0145310815,
0.0404086858,
-0.0403009579,
0.0538413525,
0.0107248984,
0.0180986803,
-0.0351934955,
-0.0192240439,
0.0552260429,
-0.0301555302,
-0.024288699,
-0.0373682827,
-0.0344406478,
0.0414054729,
0.0199956559,
-0.0129020978,
-0.0145301614,
-0.0006017282,
-0.0547119714,
0.0201190747,
-0.0165900737,
0.0335010625,
0.0214130878,
0.0150118303,
-0.0070321006,
-0.0345929079,
0.0128052672,
-0.0137093663,
0.0096135587,
0.049030222,
0.0557528138,
-0.0049701119,
-0.0444310568,
-0.0538860932,
-0.0245740451,
-0.0323473737,
0.0912769437,
-0.0494066887,
-0.0357036106,
-0.0449881963,
0.0669748485,
-0.0344326682,
-0.0044705668,
0.0006412431,
-0.0360890105,
0.0061181481,
0.0364975929,
0.0191667173,
0.0316264033,
0.0193381477,
-0.0007613627,
0.0252557546,
0.0346136689,
-0.0768659115,
0.004140133,
-0.0482735112,
-0.0369297229,
-0.0370474719,
-0.0150969261,
0.0628593192,
0.0594704263,
0.0148315318,
0.0033663791,
-0.0388253219,
-0.0258912481,
-0.009186672,
-0.0122515718,
-0.0340146124,
0.0228872541,
-0.0184458867,
0.0552426688,
-0.0123996167,
-0.0334390178,
0.0703401044,
0.0091761341,
0.0183501076,
-0.0708516389,
-0.0528353266,
-0.0079727136,
0.0552754626,
-0.0095250616,
0.0192859825,
0.062654011,
-0.0272333585,
-0.0399033912,
0.0050571579,
0.0245219544,
-0.0225481205,
0.0308849197,
0.0348253809,
0.0236887168,
0.0166206956,
-0.0832846314,
-0.0423262119,
-0.0542592742,
-0.0305110477,
-0.0028919459,
-0.0020728374,
0.0176234152,
-0.070080936,
0.014871168,
-0.0201762393,
-0.0486928038,
0.0033448886,
-0.0144146122,
-0.0261126291,
0.049424801,
0.0591690615,
0.0108425273,
-0.0394134708,
0.0047592288,
0.0273935329,
0.0056403475,
-0.0024244941,
0.0320493877,
-0.0100283558,
-0.0238021519,
0.0154141448,
-0.0461953767,
-0.0310884155,
0.0117787244,
0.0730619952,
0.0294962917,
-0.0368295275,
0.0994603187,
0.0369815081,
0.0006512489,
-0.0129779065,
0.0108284438,
0.0508562736,
0.0347864218,
0.0385179073,
-0.0564440154,
-0.0211432241,
0.0116798934,
0.0184625424,
0.0175241716,
0.0133254053,
-0.0078092734,
-0.1355116516,
0.0082692401,
0.0023524242,
0.0062816762,
-0.0498582572,
-0.0517317094,
0.0053054858,
0.0398651436,
0.0390159525,
-0.0246430095,
-0.0129834311,
0.0019571993,
0.0358377509,
-0.0644300953,
-0.075230062,
0.007185719,
-0.0562689677,
0.0093450136,
0.0420234539,
0.013397838,
0.0111613246,
-0.0168908536,
0.0143194506,
-0.0311507173,
-0.0168545265,
0.0285726544,
0.0540950708,
-0.0185346473,
-0.0023277544,
-0.0367392115,
-0.0316028856,
-0.0236837175,
-0.014511833,
0.0014671404,
0.0771671608,
-0.0074129645,
-0.0014259001,
-0.031485308,
0.0459235907,
-0.0165466461,
0.0768254548,
0.0472584292,
-0.0089094378,
-0.0359820947,
-0.000253747,
0.0221758969,
-0.0447793007,
-0.0228224918,
0.0511195809,
0.0015569798,
-0.0007269742,
-0.0675026253,
-0.0446967855,
-0.0050475588,
0.0296578538,
-0.0069237426,
0.0108853215,
-0.0258848555,
-0.0202563889,
-0.051108107,
-0.0088510616,
-0.0290834606,
0.0260476246,
-0.0338854566,
0.0500464886,
0.0256426055,
0.0130617497,
-0.0515787713,
-0.0714218691,
-0.0675258785,
-0.0726684779,
-0.0422289036,
-0.025313152,
0.0054115974,
0.0209172517,
-0.0169839282,
-0.0042945147,
0.0546162091,
0.046598196,
-0.047951825,
0.014418059,
0.0422750749,
-0.0422596782,
0.0127790347,
0.0622667521,
-0.071015276,
0.0440041907,
-0.007521288,
0.0774238482,
-0.0085565569,
-0.0437226556,
0.0411446691,
-0.0211516153,
0.0808505788,
0.0240571257,
-0.0422628,
-0.0295195375,
-0.0015669883,
0.001053042,
0.0066491445,
-0.0034261984,
-0.024749212,
0.0235155784,
0.0168535989,
-0.0086208181,
0.0318905376,
-0.0148943467,
0.0689544305,
-0.0437552072,
0.0038671347,
-0.012038257,
0.0035012707,
-0.0225559026,
0.0097849397,
-0.0603618287,
0.0005325254,
-0.0057747825,
0.0213695224,
-0.0242506042,
-0.0034420684,
-0.005558311,
0.0112762116,
-0.042190101,
0.025498651,
-0.0676260218,
0.0395846851,
-0.0086996118,
-0.0211739466,
0.03985966,
-0.0470350645,
0.0230137073,
-0.0165783055,
0.0000281452,
-0.0183065534,
0.0153399035,
-0.0343627147,
0.0240480285,
0.0572962947,
-0.0071957824,
-0.052405104,
0.014360006,
0.0699503869,
0.0080034724,
0.0607297122,
-0.0452451296,
-0.0810482875,
-0.0379884206,
-0.0219991077,
0.0387713611,
0.030041365,
-0.0108639151,
-0.0030805224,
-0.030224653,
-0.058524847,
0.0014580472,
-0.0195708685,
-0.0258845408,
0.0030237401,
0.0162450206,
0.0612878613,
-0.0094056781,
0.0155055737,
-0.0193484165,
-0.0224018507,
0.0040394263,
-0.0222807992,
-0.0487755835,
-6.087236517e-33,
-0.0091235973,
0.0485811308,
-0.0200497936,
-0.0269412603,
-0.0182155147,
0.004390324,
0.0060377587,
0.005833277,
-0.0533564687,
0.0215470809,
0.0038256142,
-0.0018580313,
0.0250456408,
0.0174868964,
-0.0281321127,
-0.0106693227,
0.0495873988,
0.0163179133,
-0.0074492143,
-0.0258949362,
0.0227061417,
0.0837940276,
0.0663351044,
-0.0716695637,
-0.0040717069,
-0.008668975,
0.0370559432,
0.0111116702,
0.0756911784,
0.0769105405,
-0.0236788224,
0.0598400757,
0.0319486149,
-0.0309000798,
-0.0031281959,
0.0546138361,
-0.0816849247,
-0.0316468067,
0.0088163754,
0.0068646003,
0.0174808782,
-0.0010826915,
0.0299463104,
-0.0182414781,
-0.015375426,
-0.0214963313,
0.0422054008,
-0.0077138548,
-0.0380936339,
0.0122936107,
-0.0528559834,
0.001469551,
0.0182370525,
-0.0295481849,
-0.011217799,
0.0499721318,
0.0135030402,
0.0357703604,
0.0021457497,
0.0349531621,
-0.0319213457,
0.0386718251,
0.009639346,
-0.0053063221,
-0.0101444591,
0.0743357092,
-0.0092539927,
-0.0189400166,
0.004420728,
-0.056915585,
0.0159305558,
0.0143558988,
-0.0418679155,
0.0649867058,
-0.000146229,
-0.0266546309,
-0.0884342417,
0.0081479251,
0.0078473929,
-0.0217016265,
0.0734776855,
0.035078641,
-0.0851336494,
-0.0349572264,
-0.0052207788,
0.0231211726,
-0.0149642117,
-0.0464606993,
0.0765881687,
-0.0031688956,
0.0134503059,
0.0134243956,
0.009379168,
-0.0518882945,
-0.0259056427,
-0.0350512303,
-0.0118054496,
-0.0062022889,
-0.0110374382,
0.0057951529,
-0.0167612545,
-0.0235660132,
-0.0323411971,
0.0312060416,
-0.0072537903,
-0.0293262992,
0.0892932862,
-0.0391557813,
-0.0682663098,
-0.0172026772,
-0.0084029306,
-0.0765845254,
-0.0227170289,
0.0195922609,
0.0093843089,
0.0455173589,
-0.0039877384,
0.0774696991,
0.017542256,
-0.0274890307,
-0.0116232857,
-0.0323375724,
0.0241156295,
0.0363177881,
-0.0166818593,
-0.0012121949,
-0.0612797774,
0.0640685037,
0.0142053096,
-0.0268602949,
-0.0331536978,
0.0157620925,
2.545e-7,
0.0675316751,
0.0106223812,
0.0081764599,
-0.0057141758,
-0.007064736,
0.0358514786,
0.0003598271,
0.0412654653,
-0.0068624122,
-0.0008404294,
0.023852367,
-0.0020461509,
0.0539006405,
0.0041523436,
-0.0975439847,
-0.0052236607,
-0.0711970255,
-0.0256982297,
-0.0701283813,
-0.0056139836,
0.0711772665,
0.0939419195,
0.0258816872,
0.0139355855,
-0.027560927,
-0.0526113212,
0.0580601171,
-0.0531638674,
-0.0137399519,
0.0093874279,
-0.0058842041,
0.0513389371,
0.018570438,
0.0128718829,
-0.0085369302,
0.0454572178,
0.0457623526,
0.0001890421,
0.028528491,
-0.0185730495,
-0.0275542289,
-0.0178230777,
-0.0064945919,
-0.0307934005,
0.0321526974,
-0.0942124203,
-0.0382465236,
-0.0282482691,
-0.0179798715,
0.0096808765,
0.0306023937,
0.0399407409,
-0.0275148042,
-0.011206938,
0.0391937234,
0.0404537544,
-0.0247904155,
-0.0736379921,
0.0361064598,
0.0716834292,
-0.0250172727,
-0.0211717542,
-0.0426502116,
-0.0065977755,
0.0557257943,
-0.0217070915,
0.0408981889,
2.187127544e-34,
0.0319446921,
0.0422962457,
0.0464013107,
-0.0028977701,
0.0381995738,
-0.025106702,
0.0401383378,
-0.0123929223,
0.0421233363,
-0.0709423497,
0.0349302851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12335v1 | Attention Score is not All You Need for Token Importance Indicator in KV Cache Reduction: Value Also Matters | 2024-06-18T07:01:11 | 2024-06-18T07:01:11 | Zhiyu Guo, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Scaling the context size of large language models (LLMs) enables them to
perform various new tasks, e.g., book summarization. However, the memory cost
of the Key and Value (KV) cache in attention significantly limits the practical
applications of LLMs. Recent works have explored token pruning for KV cache
reduction in LLMs, relying solely on attention scores as a token importance
indicator. However, our investigation into value vector norms revealed a
notably non-uniform pattern questioning their reliance only on attention
scores. Inspired by this, we propose a new method: Value-Aware Token Pruning
(VATP) which uses both attention scores and the $ \ell_{1} $ norm of value
vectors to evaluate token importance. Extensive experiments on LLaMA2-7B-chat
and Vicuna-v1.5-7B across 16 LongBench tasks demonstrate VATP's superior
performance. | [
0.0264543518,
-0.0072908285,
-0.0183903072,
0.0435028188,
-0.0270780046,
-0.0020899191,
-0.0073768576,
0.0208404437,
-0.0035122714,
-0.0277455412,
-0.0366969705,
-0.0456854999,
0.0192479528,
0.0206398461,
0.0201316196,
-0.0457411893,
0.0883157328,
-0.0237461086,
0.0466943383,
-0.0127823204,
-0.0145386793,
-0.0298143644,
0.0500500612,
0.0519605018,
0.000009079,
-0.0104932105,
0.0248551238,
-0.0103156138,
0.0200447012,
0.0073504457,
-0.0077215354,
0.0383652225,
-0.0355421528,
-0.0213948786,
0.0000020564,
-0.0428664722,
-0.0083379159,
-0.0182335041,
-0.0153728491,
0.0682300925,
0.0766176805,
0.0321975574,
-0.0208411105,
0.0109124752,
0.0248531066,
-0.0107058678,
0.0432720557,
0.0073926398,
0.066872403,
0.0481050313,
0.0078158826,
-0.0054597706,
-0.0057741487,
-0.0178785548,
0.032679271,
-0.0811515078,
0.0071535711,
-0.0091699418,
-0.04454289,
0.0031190305,
-0.0232760869,
0.0512052402,
0.0215204358,
0.0065735751,
0.0429089479,
0.0508539788,
-0.0674162209,
0.0134522319,
0.0225581378,
0.0360792801,
-0.0421549939,
-0.0430451035,
0.0132872453,
0.0180676263,
0.0059763929,
-0.0622565895,
-0.0559197403,
-0.0003245961,
-0.003868608,
0.0001612826,
0.0365244187,
-0.0165973958,
0.0151461251,
-0.0177110657,
-0.0282985326,
0.0041960441,
0.0377244167,
0.0016183996,
-0.0610164329,
-0.0390516371,
-0.0465813056,
-0.0768378749,
0.0170698948,
0.0480262935,
-0.0085583832,
0.0078224707,
-0.0431282595,
-0.027495712,
0.0098387515,
-0.0596202128,
0.0067168023,
0.0560375787,
-0.0132767372,
0.0397428311,
-0.0362038203,
0.0859093443,
0.0260362029,
0.0174093377,
-0.0488660187,
0.0000912524,
-0.0030168695,
-0.0068671708,
-0.0226012431,
0.0415735692,
-0.0145664886,
0.0029067781,
-0.0328662507,
0.0202032998,
0.0264575407,
-0.0228197966,
-0.0036179144,
0.0149984369,
0.0009237701,
0.0348347053,
-0.0020302122,
0.0375197269,
-0.0386331305,
-0.0540056415,
-0.0283319019,
-0.0646670461,
-0.0322044343,
0.0140069593,
-0.0081878547,
-0.0361778587,
-0.0015177643,
0.0948706046,
0.0013891195,
-0.054960873,
-0.0036676861,
-0.0230899211,
0.0101399552,
-0.0625720397,
0.0109864958,
-0.0547154844,
-0.018593546,
0.0053318008,
0.0003294007,
0.0209611505,
-0.0216494258,
0.0540804081,
-0.0308563653,
0.0002461084,
0.0646049157,
0.0077202534,
0.0087719988,
-0.0058947075,
0.00859496,
0.0498891138,
0.0310016293,
0.0519663654,
0.0124124037,
-0.0332647115,
-0.0375220217,
0.0119661652,
0.0352151804,
0.0042036143,
-0.0308548249,
-0.0003037306,
0.0179495141,
-0.0204919726,
0.0564669073,
0.0817981809,
-0.051580511,
-0.0066904053,
0.0669495314,
0.0616366155,
0.0177338235,
0.0181283671,
-0.0155509645,
-0.015021841,
0.0115655893,
0.0194722824,
-0.0644457117,
0.0763900429,
0.0055398927,
0.006310585,
0.0694259554,
0.0173563231,
-0.036907427,
-0.0368528441,
-0.0091348169,
-0.0002292017,
-0.0124036139,
-0.0038403138,
0.0244272295,
-0.0162971579,
-0.0435052365,
0.0725652426,
0.016365137,
-0.0404595248,
-0.0077101155,
-0.055808384,
0.0105645545,
0.0641804338,
0.053751722,
-0.0044997884,
-0.0204305127,
0.0479026027,
0.0021142596,
-0.0314284451,
0.0441027619,
0.0073108273,
-0.0040719174,
-0.0519250296,
0.0150083657,
-0.0426908992,
-0.0027088532,
-0.0139891366,
0.0231431443,
0.0210910402,
0.0098130787,
-0.0447619222,
-0.0346053652,
0.0066200751,
0.0296940319,
-0.0078344494,
0.0089785429,
0.0121711371,
0.0152133116,
-0.0123997265,
-0.0003286576,
0.037793126,
0.0354382247,
-0.0389126018,
0.033383213,
0.0126328347,
-0.069502607,
-0.0378808714,
0.056939438,
-0.0017940454,
0.0342023894,
0.0408022813,
-0.0320089087,
-0.0343822613,
0.0584784038,
-0.0470494181,
0.0628500134,
-0.0007926252,
0.0269342791,
-0.0284269769,
0.0491225757,
-0.0261234716,
0.0510522313,
-0.0309119709,
0.0335613377,
-0.0014625799,
0.0222623702,
-0.0118671088,
-0.0053490545,
-0.0361327454,
0.0069756722,
-0.0119285695,
0.01939198,
0.0081981337,
0.0088288225,
-0.0222486611,
-0.012323034,
-0.1084060222,
-0.0027214864,
-0.0251497105,
0.0613788627,
0.0232324712,
0.0320401564,
0.0107536642,
-0.0031334271,
-0.0048828786,
-0.0149546452,
-0.0047213868,
0.0435439087,
0.0206714571,
-0.0310358834,
-0.0115952482,
-0.0387791991,
-0.0407860093,
0.0128265945,
0.0545428321,
-0.0368091501,
-0.0363619924,
-0.0179695208,
0.0392840281,
-0.0198689215,
0.0013382882,
-0.0109086623,
-0.035361927,
-0.004662768,
0.025799606,
0.0756500438,
0.0787924752,
0.0213283785,
0.0111238463,
0.045021493,
-0.0297181103,
-0.0459971279,
0.0057403031,
0.024882555,
-0.0047158902,
-0.0114301713,
-0.0212739911,
0.0220623352,
0.0565530583,
-0.0272715352,
-0.0246049166,
-0.0479860529,
-0.0088402629,
-0.0093430653,
-0.0237557758,
-0.011206639,
0.0029244975,
-0.0570262335,
0.0044525629,
-0.0328074992,
-0.055950813,
0.0392386541,
-0.0365095697,
-0.009385325,
-0.0501643494,
0.0314959362,
-0.0437412634,
0.0317263156,
0.0025886574,
0.028898323,
-0.0544658117,
-0.0472344235,
-0.0112787466,
-0.0039800219,
-0.0505860262,
-0.0529662743,
0.0646306351,
-0.0169363152,
0.0095695285,
-0.0209485833,
-0.0027972262,
-0.0191346016,
0.024077611,
-0.0201683007,
0.0125646591,
0.0551030226,
-0.0083894227,
-0.0083655119,
0.0444497317,
0.0269780923,
0.0332723968,
-0.0218636785,
0.0071574058,
-0.0019674252,
0.021560682,
0.0360801928,
0.0059026214,
0.0495205894,
-0.0271082614,
0.0113865882,
0.0982099622,
0.0729431733,
-0.0130259534,
0.0048147608,
-0.0085367057,
0.034426719,
-0.0485692956,
-0.0143430149,
-0.0032168478,
0.0453892723,
-0.0532140136,
-0.0307795946,
0.0811925381,
0.0231683534,
-0.0635193959,
0.0267711692,
-0.0321044587,
0.0256292559,
0.0360472202,
0.0397672057,
-0.0892176479,
-0.0261982121,
0.034961734,
0.0256900731,
0.0040837778,
-0.02588333,
-0.0315036178,
-0.0903299227,
-0.0019008648,
0.0010129448,
-0.0782346055,
0.0031534641,
-0.0602865927,
-0.0009477721,
0.0007586008,
0.038266547,
0.0184804536,
-0.0176079292,
-0.0024479246,
0.0026774951,
0.0211872645,
-0.0183944311,
0.0585279055,
-0.0094809765,
0.0402052775,
0.0663565695,
0.0268132202,
0.0296408739,
-0.0174553264,
0.0625484735,
0.0133799519,
0.0165523142,
-0.0340573117,
0.0103437332,
-0.0131200468,
-0.0255977511,
-0.0226822682,
-0.0219663344,
0.0129580284,
0.0100914668,
-0.0136704976,
0.0441473909,
0.0077743945,
-0.0575878881,
-0.0094437134,
-0.0298434012,
-0.0387122221,
0.0637118071,
0.07870996,
-0.0093208579,
-0.0621847138,
-0.0198134612,
-0.0059667276,
-0.0446229838,
-0.0381633379,
-0.0264554359,
-0.0106148357,
-0.0716894865,
-0.0649385303,
-0.0151955597,
0.0063107237,
0.0282996669,
-0.034633439,
-0.0020941624,
-0.0088798003,
-0.0071240966,
-0.0420883372,
0.0266299713,
-0.0645142123,
0.0069768107,
-0.0844233632,
0.0358515903,
0.0092811733,
-0.0177460723,
-0.0330087729,
-0.0041475799,
-0.0981873348,
-0.0591230467,
-0.0018253247,
0.079874523,
0.020650791,
0.0260332525,
-0.0019929763,
-0.0614609458,
0.0354613326,
0.0263183601,
-0.080668211,
0.0764648765,
-0.005744372,
-0.0197711736,
-0.0017144841,
0.0356032066,
-0.0391599759,
0.0103289839,
0.0112721873,
0.0443920717,
0.0424764156,
-0.007096109,
-0.0374032743,
0.0503997505,
0.000229952,
0.0327325724,
-0.0149526363,
0.0108771762,
0.055246044,
0.0116567621,
0.0028636211,
-0.0197196566,
0.0093247574,
-0.0436071754,
0.0207980126,
-0.0082378341,
0.0004038352,
0.0280871186,
-0.0047965087,
0.0040930738,
0.0027805869,
-0.0236139111,
0.0318668336,
0.0305064116,
0.0017393599,
-0.0373042226,
-0.0268999301,
-0.0020970928,
0.0308934879,
-0.0573116615,
-0.0345949233,
-0.0027972045,
0.0095876697,
-0.0424912311,
0.0597798079,
-0.0638824031,
-0.0333861895,
0.0115921209,
0.0009637426,
0.0356302038,
-0.0244402625,
0.0677019283,
-0.0000010584,
0.0009511862,
-0.0488693118,
-0.0119197303,
0.0156661719,
-0.0379801095,
-0.0163776129,
0.0159089267,
0.0062307771,
0.0006334626,
0.0835903436,
-0.0213749018,
0.0396199264,
-0.0021550755,
-0.017326409,
-0.0183634553,
-0.0122906882,
-0.0351182707,
0.0300009158,
-0.0026325539,
-0.0435344689,
-0.0761939511,
-0.068783693,
0.0219513606,
-0.0224902388,
0.0021155674,
-0.0152092306,
0.0216303635,
0.0484494939,
0.0392321236,
-0.0310242251,
-0.0088062985,
0.0011858019,
-0.0164934937,
-0.0132896183,
0.0220018458,
-6.691577999e-33,
-0.0300975535,
-0.0163672008,
-0.0013850975,
-0.0280890334,
-0.0303096082,
0.0497440249,
-0.0705526173,
-0.0447038971,
-0.0156726316,
-0.0448387675,
-0.0445549265,
0.0076179695,
0.0212078635,
-0.0110841487,
-0.0102681099,
0.0030399696,
0.0506417118,
0.0222956631,
-0.0444941744,
0.0735814422,
0.0521433391,
0.024210399,
0.0819005221,
0.0020277163,
-0.0198582802,
0.0259550102,
0.0690640658,
-0.0015932142,
-0.0148049137,
0.0234319717,
-0.037354283,
0.0358767882,
0.033810921,
-0.0714587197,
-0.0375813134,
-0.0147515666,
-0.0590931661,
-0.0466151647,
0.0694866478,
0.0045918743,
0.0151240453,
-0.0737630427,
0.041357249,
0.0510063171,
-0.0082681132,
-0.0123253325,
0.0084091369,
0.0007046913,
-0.0618970059,
-0.0087296087,
-0.0301585887,
0.0222014841,
-0.0111693768,
0.0089503899,
0.0295501333,
-0.0001812158,
0.0099651618,
0.0332926847,
-0.0509462431,
0.0289225578,
-0.0042495234,
0.0934220552,
0.0944451243,
0.0362923369,
0.0180587322,
0.0632818565,
0.0510921702,
0.0236719269,
-0.0150793698,
0.0255535021,
0.0625024065,
0.0053254394,
0.005104288,
-0.0314089395,
0.0328886621,
-0.0490673035,
-0.0521123447,
-0.0075830519,
0.0189084113,
0.0765624419,
0.0438026078,
0.0113097094,
-0.0276242476,
-0.0341695808,
-0.020159686,
0.0197321437,
-0.0603497922,
-0.0269210506,
0.0101680309,
-0.0030458502,
-0.0455765128,
-0.0234621298,
0.0512979291,
-0.0107659763,
-0.0047882828,
0.0517102033,
0.0192461945,
0.0414036214,
-0.0086960988,
0.029025957,
-0.0603106059,
0.0081499023,
0.0188404135,
-0.0272298232,
0.0181218404,
-0.0054862262,
-0.0134645607,
0.0060581514,
-0.0471939221,
-0.0105393436,
-0.0501561053,
-0.004232449,
0.0079544745,
0.0510155074,
0.0279230978,
0.0022852905,
0.0235934053,
0.091896899,
0.011184847,
-0.0138921924,
-0.0405080318,
0.0003277991,
0.0265253223,
0.0282167196,
-0.0372263975,
0.0098377485,
-0.0719545484,
0.0747092664,
-0.0047919727,
-0.0385365039,
-0.0422391184,
0.0264080334,
2.853e-7,
0.0146823246,
0.0436294414,
0.0394698121,
0.001820636,
-0.0049060057,
0.0252305996,
0.0123106418,
0.0197916552,
0.0256877877,
0.0459423065,
-0.0110752536,
0.0378367715,
0.0166229792,
0.0194054507,
-0.0868322849,
0.0194847994,
-0.088292107,
-0.0264330041,
-0.0265393853,
-0.0250029936,
-0.0120342197,
0.0776167884,
0.006359302,
-0.0136291897,
0.0076040137,
0.0012042843,
0.0122014163,
-0.0023859246,
-0.0254932214,
0.032351356,
0.044293426,
-0.0011332559,
-0.0142337484,
-0.0325081833,
0.0136193037,
-0.0204912629,
0.0025765765,
0.0567055494,
0.0034733026,
-0.0583033971,
0.0301824957,
0.0038111247,
-0.025829671,
-0.0383465365,
0.0992393866,
-0.0095402561,
-0.0096292645,
-0.0618392937,
0.0070711132,
-0.0041050282,
-0.0131286252,
0.0092966305,
-0.0237623435,
0.0705991983,
-0.0132427141,
-0.0193921532,
-0.0183802005,
-0.0811549649,
-0.0583553053,
-0.0258144364,
-0.0498785116,
-0.050929144,
-0.0688966587,
0.026055662,
-0.0055495962,
-0.0502405316,
-0.0130342375,
2.837650939e-34,
0.0368289314,
-0.0222035013,
0.0165035427,
0.0404902846,
0.0307865329,
-0.0147071453,
0.0002034588,
0.0284929909,
-0.0081556374,
-0.0646153986,
-0.0572181307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12331v1 | Retrieval Meets Reasoning: Dynamic In-Context Editing for Long-Text Understanding | 2024-06-18T06:54:28 | 2024-06-18T06:54:28 | Weizhi Fei, Xueyan Niu, Guoqing Xie, Yanhua Zhang, Bo Bai, Lei Deng, Wei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current Large Language Models (LLMs) face inherent limitations due to their
pre-defined context lengths, which impede their capacity for multi-hop
reasoning within extensive textual contexts. While existing techniques like
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) have attempted to bridge this gap by
sourcing external information, they fall short when direct answers are not
readily available. We introduce a novel approach that re-imagines information
retrieval through dynamic in-context editing, inspired by recent breakthroughs
in knowledge editing. By treating lengthy contexts as malleable external
knowledge, our method interactively gathers and integrates relevant
information, thereby enabling LLMs to perform sophisticated reasoning steps.
Experimental results demonstrate that our method effectively empowers
context-limited LLMs, such as Llama2, to engage in multi-hop reasoning with
improved performance, which outperforms state-of-the-art context window
extrapolation methods and even compares favorably to more advanced commercial
long-context models. Our interactive method not only enhances reasoning
capabilities but also mitigates the associated training and computational
costs, making it a pragmatic solution for enhancing LLMs' reasoning within
expansive contexts. | [
0.0478259549,
0.0379182845,
-0.0230002813,
0.0430646278,
-0.0300385058,
-0.0046037845,
-0.0005950651,
-0.0240678955,
-0.0075213471,
-0.0500474647,
-0.0247303974,
-0.0380414613,
-0.0120511604,
0.0144455917,
0.0206545871,
-0.0262550265,
0.0561570488,
-0.0321184956,
-0.0022221778,
0.0148039255,
0.0054293568,
0.0005236832,
0.0177683365,
0.0043748454,
0.0027293295,
-0.0292907283,
-0.0366082452,
0.0016988203,
0.0153690167,
-0.0146779353,
0.0040346198,
0.0206239428,
0.060115438,
0.0240613073,
0.0000021933,
-0.0591503568,
-0.0536790937,
-0.0059174309,
-0.0348221585,
0.0101417312,
0.019844573,
0.0194425117,
-0.0023486868,
0.0003819801,
-0.0329614729,
0.0375289619,
0.0143290032,
0.0241157245,
0.0727232471,
0.060447149,
0.0036523372,
-0.0194798149,
0.0056139929,
-0.0451493859,
0.0610321499,
-0.0417775959,
0.0208009295,
0.008164377,
0.0303552523,
0.0327175818,
0.0074078217,
0.05010565,
0.0389719307,
-0.0389260575,
0.0071777534,
0.0310267266,
-0.0090237251,
0.0008907084,
0.0123065002,
0.0546915941,
0.0197595358,
-0.0088471379,
-0.0073317294,
0.0271101296,
0.0017578921,
0.0139515726,
-0.0591662414,
0.0234040339,
-0.0219851807,
0.0092167268,
0.0049486253,
-0.0297806542,
0.0476354733,
0.0198512617,
-0.0472710878,
0.0887593031,
0.0147662396,
-0.0278383866,
-0.026458893,
-0.0204450972,
-0.0258313697,
-0.0447774827,
0.009997136,
0.0839950889,
-0.032335896,
0.0445770398,
-0.0170466229,
-0.0035396202,
0.0285744146,
-0.0236517303,
-0.0056420784,
0.0585369579,
-0.0177286845,
0.0569560118,
-0.0460400842,
0.0139723718,
-0.0285270195,
0.0038621896,
-0.0409762748,
-0.0151630733,
-0.0370759144,
-0.0472151823,
-0.0547945499,
0.0180069525,
-0.0768255368,
-0.0020919377,
-0.0260877833,
0.0559176877,
-0.0161071867,
0.0099168932,
-0.0275718663,
0.0149819395,
-0.0387362465,
-0.0249142572,
-0.0490624085,
0.017077351,
-0.0313969478,
0.023182312,
0.0366147831,
-0.0222825408,
-0.0231352672,
-0.0087251971,
0.0006087104,
-0.0335888155,
0.004234218,
0.0737343132,
-0.0401285477,
-0.0301869381,
-0.0460133329,
-0.0715152547,
-0.032136783,
-0.0702729598,
0.0143290907,
-0.0581356101,
0.0234473068,
0.0043708296,
-0.0483029,
-0.0391419232,
0.0249629579,
0.0392834172,
-0.0206938516,
0.0742349103,
0.0046870573,
0.0068914825,
0.0494980812,
0.0459623113,
0.0122097852,
0.0643509105,
0.0179426018,
0.0104996525,
0.0360781774,
0.0502340533,
0.0004947746,
0.0240388159,
0.0366081931,
0.0062669539,
-0.0459452011,
0.0332763866,
0.020351002,
0.0168671794,
0.01103797,
0.0148673831,
-0.0475476235,
0.0214172006,
0.0380803831,
0.0218445174,
0.0349460877,
-0.0120451218,
0.0571736991,
-0.0271719564,
-0.0150731336,
-0.0010927097,
-0.0480819456,
0.0602552854,
-0.0376312882,
0.0210750569,
0.0367060155,
0.0235682633,
-0.0022083186,
-0.0480748154,
-0.0151249105,
0.0329345539,
0.0055215801,
0.0338595547,
0.0336246602,
0.0327381007,
-0.009950161,
0.0434590615,
0.0124570038,
-0.0366591215,
0.0026455037,
-0.0528188124,
0.0403943621,
0.0986861736,
0.0757031143,
-0.0349527374,
-0.0406340174,
0.0000326483,
0.0124271531,
0.0310967471,
0.0128074838,
-0.0302614998,
-0.023271272,
-0.0298658367,
-0.033209756,
-0.0527977645,
0.0138105731,
-0.0081627248,
0.0523480102,
-0.0088602258,
0.0576741584,
-0.047810588,
0.036644008,
0.0140051255,
-0.0477796532,
-0.0214458629,
-0.0313787535,
0.0131718535,
-0.0174249653,
-0.0013039111,
-0.0154065443,
0.0288211517,
0.017680794,
-0.0368199646,
-0.0246282537,
0.0079930862,
-0.0539452583,
-0.0371504053,
0.0327334478,
0.0247007851,
-0.0012618667,
-0.0535619147,
-0.0301675498,
-0.0363096222,
0.0051740403,
-0.0198145732,
0.0602610521,
-0.0747319758,
0.0077308062,
0.010969908,
-0.0145683428,
-0.0414734297,
0.0885028392,
0.0050718817,
-0.0254230238,
0.0603354461,
0.0451333858,
-0.0058214758,
-0.0357857272,
0.0021870728,
0.0155318016,
0.0124308504,
-0.0364118516,
-0.0280040801,
-0.0083203921,
-0.0557998307,
-0.0214564931,
-0.0696561709,
0.0174940489,
-0.0148424059,
-0.0048649074,
0.0355122387,
0.0327562764,
-0.0052240752,
0.0052816668,
-0.0185206942,
0.0037892731,
0.0280123875,
0.0397396274,
0.0332793482,
0.0456450023,
-0.0181678478,
-0.0314148404,
0.0103099057,
-0.0080405204,
0.0351913236,
0.0122761838,
-0.0242890939,
-0.0504091941,
0.0237778816,
-0.0614470579,
0.0136116259,
-0.0320370123,
0.0024901961,
-0.0010129877,
-0.0394387841,
0.0593033098,
0.0548579283,
-0.008324015,
0.0023706234,
0.0602878109,
-0.0408485606,
-0.0354070403,
0.0406041779,
-0.0015618936,
-0.0196823981,
-0.0005290302,
0.0100570945,
-0.0189611744,
0.0483329818,
-0.0203929245,
-0.027461363,
-0.015958434,
0.025469413,
0.0079130912,
-0.0024527228,
-0.0717175007,
-0.0449899957,
0.0017646648,
0.0717809796,
-0.0579724163,
-0.049373731,
0.0885500759,
-0.0337138735,
0.0154253328,
-0.0301381331,
0.0074130655,
-0.0495400168,
0.0773276761,
-0.0308742877,
0.0208891332,
-0.0402403846,
0.0162112564,
-0.0515976921,
-0.0061711557,
0.0076073473,
-0.0418733135,
0.0769327655,
-0.0500738658,
0.0300670173,
0.0024386356,
-0.0282905307,
-0.0550901778,
0.0011117312,
-0.0053850156,
0.0026787587,
0.0024333966,
-0.0061978539,
0.0015417011,
-0.0114975926,
0.0574565344,
0.0692139864,
-0.0182486717,
-0.0206797458,
-0.01311401,
0.0223136861,
0.0502282232,
0.0102299629,
0.0054625748,
-0.0416988879,
0.0444800258,
0.0563885793,
0.027915813,
-0.0784131661,
0.029255148,
-0.0008977733,
-0.016733313,
-0.0166453607,
-0.0064542261,
0.0138155026,
0.045553498,
-0.0861514732,
-0.062268842,
0.0920159966,
0.0594508126,
-0.0477042794,
0.0009971999,
-0.0679519325,
0.0232961625,
0.045679681,
0.070509851,
-0.0796671212,
-0.0430371575,
0.0456750132,
0.0091252765,
-0.0036821272,
-0.0339635275,
-0.0284614917,
-0.1039116457,
0.0379453935,
-0.0121202534,
-0.0194548853,
-0.0042877677,
-0.0440813564,
0.0185783133,
0.0600986741,
-0.0102055995,
0.0702518597,
0.0016697871,
0.0164949,
-0.0401343815,
0.0522784181,
-0.0078273891,
0.0353181064,
0.021307366,
0.0013929113,
0.0453716964,
0.0129538625,
0.050747294,
-0.0246837344,
0.056406498,
-0.019679606,
0.0499786139,
-0.012383732,
0.0116196889,
0.0082677212,
0.0120704453,
-0.0181319192,
0.0421858989,
-0.0003346896,
-0.0556479171,
0.0045599779,
0.0855347887,
-0.0267533865,
0.050838396,
-0.0170166604,
-0.0110114301,
0.0038410223,
0.0701746196,
0.0305690281,
-0.0102875978,
-0.0225406643,
-0.0478921868,
-0.0386673398,
-0.0237414036,
-0.0060016331,
0.0102735013,
-0.0111268666,
0.0269625541,
-0.0688930526,
-0.0232614018,
0.0255962554,
0.0483628437,
0.0145685766,
0.0210649576,
-0.0189340152,
-0.019057462,
-0.0760663524,
0.0161771737,
-0.0426265672,
0.0146261072,
0.0078426385,
0.0211611036,
0.0209108926,
-0.0653461218,
-0.0149153825,
0.0374812819,
-0.0482575446,
-0.0675811991,
-0.0214988533,
0.0066156262,
0.0284848344,
0.0696223825,
-0.0169290733,
-0.0167161804,
0.0537102334,
0.0227900408,
-0.0285311472,
0.0256686211,
-0.0124280611,
0.0630540997,
0.0154195251,
0.0459619612,
-0.0761129633,
-0.0025784443,
0.011166269,
0.0384048857,
-0.010000566,
-0.0095154494,
0.0259508565,
0.0004359917,
-0.0136731239,
0.0143428622,
-0.0006807212,
-0.0464958288,
0.0585681386,
-0.0460661836,
-0.0373379886,
-0.014133729,
0.0288656,
-0.019050248,
-0.0316811241,
0.0253279861,
0.02495577,
0.0232290197,
0.0421141386,
-0.0067723631,
-0.0027767294,
-0.0024557579,
-0.0053987727,
0.0294474661,
-0.0055856137,
0.0014075796,
0.0199233945,
-0.0300710909,
0.0529011078,
-0.0517615639,
0.0758055672,
0.0233117994,
-0.0285276528,
-0.0647091866,
-0.0041150185,
-0.1000168473,
-0.0346541218,
0.0064336173,
0.0314386748,
0.0261217747,
0.0121820178,
0.0234532785,
-0.0158598851,
-0.0299354643,
0.0254863948,
0.0168406293,
0.0238853768,
-0.0740129426,
0.0084182518,
0.0337441154,
0.0018096269,
0.0162376668,
0.0535462759,
-0.0562025309,
0.0818211213,
-0.0388166122,
-0.0184629671,
-0.0312123727,
-0.0521860197,
-0.0179150216,
0.0272271335,
-0.0127291363,
-0.0182495546,
-0.044102259,
-0.0760386512,
-0.0012501804,
0.0142692709,
-0.0440763161,
-0.0049280114,
0.0036049981,
0.0709885135,
0.0121098831,
-0.0474223755,
-0.0124762291,
0.0300129894,
-0.036932867,
0.0027419787,
-0.0052976073,
-6.42854571e-33,
-0.0385452062,
-0.0428505428,
0.0647036135,
-0.0650106966,
-0.0397571325,
-0.0086095156,
-0.0698335394,
-0.0192693435,
-0.0052653169,
-0.0060266224,
-0.0354264155,
0.0291228183,
-0.0097165536,
0.0134980232,
-0.0016299869,
0.0096845953,
0.0221987404,
0.039771989,
-0.022964552,
0.0398193337,
0.0829209313,
0.0333182216,
0.0053578205,
-0.0106935371,
0.0328514539,
0.0136772534,
-0.004812832,
0.0758963227,
-0.0511142053,
0.0539799742,
-0.0201987289,
0.0001325535,
0.0269132797,
-0.0268791001,
-0.0025023576,
0.0310340747,
-0.0786180124,
-0.0015893821,
0.0170972906,
-0.0401653759,
-0.0258944053,
-0.0658456534,
0.0386164002,
-0.0015501818,
0.0230948552,
-0.0078367749,
0.0201017093,
-0.0449008457,
0.0038807101,
-0.0261743981,
-0.0641622916,
0.0078110183,
-0.0159410741,
0.0000327032,
-0.0269902479,
0.0287250448,
0.0236927215,
0.036105752,
-0.0582032055,
0.013719283,
-0.0075081689,
0.0315315612,
0.0595619865,
0.0123228459,
0.0180828031,
0.0286590364,
-0.0195351373,
0.0028777476,
-0.056983225,
-0.0283775534,
-0.0099236723,
0.0227772798,
-0.0016968249,
0.0607830808,
0.028224593,
-0.0057163625,
-0.0718189105,
0.00813461,
-0.0202539079,
0.0454077236,
0.0239595231,
0.0351792946,
-0.0003402301,
-0.0109894024,
-0.0518942289,
0.042235598,
-0.0521882772,
-0.0202687178,
0.0442601927,
0.0353695638,
-0.0238489583,
-0.0174243711,
0.0117762899,
-0.0105594629,
0.0072614616,
0.0550637282,
-0.0307972562,
0.0105599444,
-0.0106078135,
0.0175332706,
-0.0140360305,
-0.0028997571,
0.0357002169,
0.012493277,
-0.0192099717,
-0.0092889722,
0.0456618182,
0.0150471851,
-0.0517026596,
0.0104749715,
-0.07058613,
0.0481947586,
-0.000895423,
-0.0232778192,
0.0263545513,
0.022503702,
-0.0176856145,
0.0418706201,
0.0301499721,
0.0102160797,
-0.0113088842,
-0.0120472182,
-0.0055412017,
0.011165102,
-0.0168941766,
0.0249603968,
-0.0091731912,
0.0218846556,
0.0078267809,
-0.0828043148,
-0.0102348356,
0.0521703549,
2.913e-7,
0.0426498353,
0.0318526961,
0.0261023734,
0.0155666973,
0.0384252444,
-0.00459002,
-0.0168258194,
-0.0137491245,
0.0111721717,
-0.0371798314,
-0.0094534829,
0.0689562634,
0.011331724,
0.033827845,
-0.0456525758,
-0.0029068463,
-0.0170640443,
-0.0248014107,
-0.0518235862,
-0.0183048155,
0.0643488914,
0.0482176878,
-0.0107864365,
-0.0218498334,
-0.0023543146,
-0.0856973529,
0.0657824576,
-0.0084924689,
0.0065791272,
0.0133038508,
0.0164584573,
0.0343098156,
0.0082967235,
-0.0189882386,
-0.0103574581,
0.0354124829,
-0.0394717231,
0.0610093549,
0.0186890755,
-0.0319333598,
-0.0066189305,
-0.0265573971,
-0.009369636,
-0.0634525418,
0.10578987,
-0.0504201278,
0.0024322907,
-0.0081147207,
-0.0016272644,
-0.0180751979,
-0.0412696339,
-0.0045208731,
0.0113295959,
0.0209292211,
-0.018804064,
0.0058573429,
-0.0047669797,
-0.1131862849,
-0.0461295024,
0.0061387187,
-0.060280405,
-0.0195880588,
-0.0660221726,
-0.0186383035,
0.0317112319,
-0.0682628229,
0.0064479713,
2.959602738e-34,
0.0158009157,
-0.0069909082,
-0.0071677673,
0.0200582836,
0.0540673658,
-0.0140103186,
-0.0154481707,
0.0047952882,
0.0289435759,
-0.0998815373,
-0.0375380218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12329v1 | SNAP: Unlearning Selective Knowledge in Large Language Models with Negative Instructions | 2024-06-18T06:54:05 | 2024-06-18T06:54:05 | Minseok Choi, Daniel Rim, Dohyun Lee, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-following large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have
become increasingly popular with the general audience, many of whom are
incorporating them into their daily routines. However, these LLMs inadvertently
disclose personal or copyrighted information, which calls for a machine
unlearning method to remove selective knowledge. Previous attempts sought to
forget the link between the target information and its associated entities, but
it rather led to generating undesirable responses about the target,
compromising the end-user experience. In this work, we propose SNAP, an
innovative framework designed to selectively unlearn information by 1) training
an LLM with negative instructions to generate obliterated responses, 2)
augmenting hard positives to retain the original LLM performance, and 3)
applying the novel Wasserstein regularization to ensure adequate deviation from
the initial weights of the LLM. We evaluate our framework on various NLP
benchmarks and demonstrate that our approach retains the original LLM
capabilities, while successfully unlearning the specified information. | [
0.0513117798,
0.0779238492,
-0.0358090475,
0.0417947397,
-0.0513366573,
-0.0125841498,
-0.0227260254,
0.0291002262,
0.0395962857,
-0.0271308422,
-0.0670808628,
-0.0038790356,
-0.0371713527,
-0.0041212109,
0.0001939396,
-0.0065430156,
0.0485891774,
0.0076193898,
-0.0011323442,
-0.0233196095,
0.0338207595,
0.0050832732,
0.0175234005,
0.0293236841,
-0.0019754614,
-0.054797031,
0.0086102337,
0.0085131386,
0.010557198,
-0.0144287162,
0.0417392366,
0.0677918419,
0.000101625,
0.0504779145,
0.0000019472,
-0.0270267278,
-0.0189343169,
-0.0147522641,
-0.0284216739,
0.0116485218,
0.0446954519,
-0.0205902606,
0.0036346987,
0.0099303387,
-0.0458667278,
0.0157374553,
0.0371917449,
0.0670053288,
0.0776140541,
0.0752204731,
-0.00421543,
-0.0015605043,
0.0235160943,
-0.0348366089,
0.0241937507,
-0.0520933382,
0.0335233249,
-0.0346223786,
-0.0062562642,
-0.0040545543,
0.0061354293,
0.0502216183,
0.0190072842,
0.0223782957,
0.0081900964,
0.0276303403,
-0.0699412376,
0.0016030308,
-0.0217147339,
0.09095788,
-0.0009361683,
-0.0080344761,
-0.0067480165,
0.0024172042,
-0.0066923802,
-0.0099868812,
-0.0478540547,
0.0002584519,
0.0013680632,
0.0294044055,
-0.045291014,
-0.0205526892,
0.0410016701,
0.0276306719,
0.0339986458,
0.0560488403,
0.0264910683,
-0.0336520299,
0.0294824988,
-0.0046122801,
-0.0231993813,
-0.0391379744,
0.0308226366,
0.007233636,
-0.009737879,
0.0272643548,
-0.0263230391,
-0.0151625657,
0.0220822189,
-0.0295028035,
0.0239797737,
0.0126049072,
0.0255567878,
0.0411016941,
-0.035658326,
0.0340059921,
0.007343886,
0.0316024311,
-0.0267795958,
0.010521695,
-0.0358046591,
-0.0327315591,
-0.0124679292,
0.0804210454,
-0.0156366453,
0.0123671098,
-0.0339774899,
0.0269811451,
-0.0465093479,
0.0168327801,
0.0033514937,
0.0289992224,
-0.0366923362,
-0.0276580676,
-0.0432007536,
0.047913976,
-0.0378644131,
0.0095517142,
-0.0038720807,
-0.0399744809,
-0.0150538739,
-0.0048627071,
-0.0026170935,
-0.0112005658,
0.0000905268,
0.0738411024,
0.0047434447,
-0.0314067416,
-0.050647866,
-0.0243532006,
-0.013577926,
-0.0670149177,
-0.0123927183,
-0.0148948748,
0.0191530865,
-0.0080892034,
-0.013556106,
-0.0824214369,
0.0164785869,
0.0425060727,
-0.0663844347,
0.0696219057,
-0.020875711,
-0.02937649,
-0.0101313684,
0.0364910141,
0.0042758072,
0.0742325112,
-0.0269110668,
0.0412844941,
0.0257194508,
0.0024566676,
0.0405986793,
0.0471861102,
0.0632645115,
0.0151230507,
-0.0339710712,
-0.0067965975,
-0.0083953375,
-0.0183287282,
0.0368810706,
0.0875954702,
-0.0286338143,
-0.040632084,
0.0738288239,
0.0450176187,
-0.0383973271,
0.0371538326,
-0.0016855014,
0.0265863482,
-0.009340384,
0.0403973237,
-0.063453652,
0.0116598187,
-0.0788253546,
-0.0135157537,
-0.0189430099,
-0.0038629435,
-0.0297777262,
-0.0233538691,
0.0093542216,
-0.0398087762,
0.0391709283,
0.0146874338,
0.0177240539,
0.0310741104,
-0.0539410636,
0.0871922895,
0.0489530303,
-0.0531442165,
0.0247406345,
-0.037657667,
0.0185135249,
0.0689028278,
0.0884059444,
-0.0470313467,
-0.0205135513,
-0.0136238579,
-0.0406516045,
0.0372225493,
0.017008476,
-0.0037379293,
0.0245786533,
-0.0516688488,
-0.0186811537,
0.0158894062,
0.020054657,
0.0151382433,
0.0443727151,
-0.0193032399,
0.0158857331,
-0.0166327879,
-0.0113701113,
0.0200179946,
-0.0334830433,
-0.0761846825,
0.0131767709,
0.0147046726,
0.0073767607,
0.0163753778,
0.0114208059,
0.0022280226,
0.0527870618,
-0.0123702483,
-0.0487454347,
-0.0323898681,
-0.045504041,
-0.0667812228,
0.0167957693,
-0.0259725917,
0.0045452258,
0.0633738711,
-0.0304334164,
-0.0109956982,
0.0154104941,
0.0042949202,
0.0505704172,
-0.0423630737,
0.0148856295,
0.0150120668,
0.0055968794,
-0.0456007831,
0.0481296219,
-0.0399568453,
0.0149636138,
0.0077048163,
-0.0593124144,
-0.0175970588,
-0.0353748687,
-0.0272090808,
0.0172255114,
0.0000389975,
0.0166358072,
0.0311824158,
-0.0140970321,
-0.0288956109,
-0.0233445894,
-0.0947813317,
0.0076529109,
-0.0010627914,
0.0085266624,
0.0231720526,
0.0156126367,
0.0150403669,
-0.0325889774,
-0.0277327318,
-0.012169227,
-0.0095351823,
0.0283072535,
0.0132647157,
0.0040968726,
-0.0162258353,
-0.0150047773,
-0.0076365173,
-0.0020736139,
0.0125326756,
-0.045808021,
0.0099639352,
-0.0081776725,
0.0408992618,
-0.0614485107,
0.0587880611,
-0.0065793423,
-0.0419517569,
-0.0034841073,
-0.0106957108,
0.0080629932,
0.0226377975,
-0.0034615486,
0.0491977446,
0.0128423218,
0.0144609576,
-0.0389466546,
0.0273360033,
-0.0456773266,
-0.0264268797,
-0.0226934794,
-0.0096603232,
0.0076971129,
0.045100525,
0.0254514478,
-0.005009234,
-0.0853061974,
0.0080284998,
-0.0391825326,
-0.0605425574,
-0.0396991111,
0.002130497,
-0.0319775678,
-0.0226174779,
-0.0493921712,
-0.072698541,
0.0699445605,
0.0218248349,
0.0193143226,
-0.0169177111,
0.0018534102,
0.0029603709,
0.0696576461,
0.0018989474,
0.02941202,
0.0160528347,
-0.0386892371,
-0.0525915399,
-0.0228818171,
0.0128609063,
-0.0380456448,
0.0087701473,
-0.0488902852,
-0.0059068049,
0.0181667227,
-0.0461759605,
-0.0792968795,
-0.0907774195,
0.004277024,
-0.0079288166,
0.0403487831,
0.0071020387,
-0.0314302519,
-0.0385503955,
0.0132093383,
0.0053583905,
-0.0071655205,
0.0188101362,
-0.0265599862,
0.022567397,
0.0760438219,
-0.0404413827,
-0.0244975574,
-0.0013332387,
0.0009438928,
0.0826740414,
0.0460201725,
-0.0235431008,
0.0370350257,
-0.0272920579,
0.0228880141,
-0.0352938548,
-0.020620238,
0.0129815107,
0.0674928725,
-0.0421246216,
-0.0149550531,
0.1268617362,
0.0245212521,
-0.0624316894,
0.0074526388,
0.0311307237,
0.045228038,
0.0070749228,
0.0042736437,
-0.0855837092,
-0.0429196656,
-0.0072446587,
0.0070269625,
-0.0079482105,
-0.0386675261,
-0.0218458995,
-0.1350542754,
-0.0351998545,
0.01896042,
-0.0476955324,
0.0045158924,
-0.0041133719,
0.0032464296,
0.0023853339,
0.0236554891,
0.0014149356,
-0.030405784,
0.0185019616,
-0.0002176707,
-0.0362925567,
-0.0292565636,
0.0187522713,
-0.0385189541,
0.064441964,
0.0554193296,
0.0402884781,
0.0007604881,
-0.0554636344,
0.0362422727,
0.0038090535,
0.0077339942,
-0.0277894121,
0.0790713802,
-0.0383947119,
0.0102814492,
-0.0463762805,
0.0517944098,
-0.0074233483,
-0.0239514988,
-0.0058816946,
0.0712411925,
-0.0011472998,
-0.0092616836,
0.0075201732,
-0.00638222,
0.0333627984,
0.1163936034,
-0.006800876,
-0.0543347374,
-0.0245954171,
-0.0327248871,
0.0122371018,
0.0068647717,
-0.0215436313,
0.0121169006,
0.000977141,
-0.0083266497,
-0.0719552413,
-0.056593705,
0.025122555,
0.0021603722,
0.0287022498,
0.0118594486,
0.0024019377,
0.0155659718,
-0.0076924465,
-0.0060013593,
-0.0487489812,
0.0098095424,
-0.0427387096,
0.0072756372,
0.0045468961,
-0.001237764,
-0.0011847123,
0.019171318,
-0.0943188593,
-0.0754605979,
-0.0095892316,
0.0461694598,
0.0300482288,
0.0500291176,
-0.030842036,
-0.0418706946,
0.0432800502,
0.1031164303,
-0.0448213331,
0.0019775811,
0.0532786734,
0.0083584813,
0.0011662483,
0.0671026632,
-0.0271607917,
0.011969666,
0.0437154658,
0.0412951782,
-0.0448814631,
-0.0075323679,
0.0193046499,
0.0490195937,
0.0409856886,
-0.0163501687,
-0.030029688,
-0.0217552036,
-0.0026010452,
-0.0358266011,
-0.0186834633,
-0.0150144706,
-0.0137683153,
0.0457028523,
-0.0051946351,
-0.0283112172,
-0.0099852728,
-0.0304882843,
0.0526274741,
-0.04070298,
-0.0560252964,
0.0421449505,
-0.0093738483,
0.0079922369,
0.017143935,
-0.0184718054,
0.0439998992,
0.0281141084,
0.0196318179,
-0.0289609935,
0.0639357641,
0.0058129751,
-0.0139751863,
-0.0348672979,
0.0040318496,
-0.0229005311,
0.000325008,
-0.0189014338,
0.0722280368,
0.0241738092,
0.0049917744,
0.0315797813,
0.0076566809,
-0.0301999282,
-0.0134738674,
0.0259379186,
-0.0130722262,
-0.0273375902,
0.0321010686,
0.0072413171,
-0.0339790545,
0.0089800917,
0.0875127539,
-0.0238769073,
0.0754977986,
-0.0523365587,
-0.013821681,
-0.058887843,
-0.038520053,
0.022538431,
0.0314614624,
0.0013957492,
0.0578920916,
-0.0722932741,
-0.0693024769,
-0.0175714046,
-0.0038717235,
0.0122939823,
-0.0404130891,
0.0357613713,
0.0294141546,
-0.0162805915,
-0.0676422119,
-0.0626043379,
0.0005822239,
-0.0047884127,
-0.0299363527,
-0.027272189,
-6.440009718e-33,
-0.0091109863,
0.0010420246,
0.0069713295,
0.0206862781,
-0.0149981827,
-0.0097038494,
0.0170057919,
-0.0147410175,
-0.0104591958,
0.0074954918,
-0.0310434699,
0.0022701463,
-0.0068973,
0.009591761,
-0.0367686078,
-0.0218581334,
0.0777373239,
-0.0089124106,
-0.0087863551,
0.0427276641,
0.0466860831,
0.0595804714,
0.0584036112,
-0.0534881875,
0.0300599281,
-0.0314222164,
-0.0467453226,
0.0327873304,
0.0244669374,
0.0181875117,
-0.0538146682,
0.021512473,
0.0218804386,
-0.0321556441,
0.014541747,
0.002217399,
-0.0590240285,
-0.0235726628,
0.0394626334,
0.0022892701,
-0.0410384461,
-0.0391821973,
0.0503213964,
-0.0303721335,
-0.021207476,
0.0018846714,
0.0146613512,
0.0154625028,
-0.0290949941,
-0.0034695389,
-0.0498441011,
0.009682104,
0.0173155349,
-0.0219925437,
-0.0050366628,
0.0235576816,
-0.0190536026,
-0.006246211,
-0.0546911173,
-0.0100123249,
0.0197002869,
0.023274079,
0.0506008565,
0.0088346917,
0.0205670595,
0.0949905813,
0.0226944108,
0.0052687093,
0.001768481,
-0.0206425264,
0.0435039327,
0.0232048631,
0.0151943797,
0.0421148054,
0.0278632063,
-0.0523240194,
-0.039356336,
0.0099023506,
0.0343954638,
0.047793258,
0.0004524761,
0.0508057587,
-0.0435238853,
-0.0137679502,
-0.0267320853,
-0.0049888552,
-0.0244621076,
-0.0314280204,
0.0316997096,
0.0102441581,
-0.0646250397,
0.0180139765,
-0.0040488923,
-0.0518492796,
-0.0329299383,
0.0374646224,
-0.0039321119,
-0.0142792417,
0.0212606397,
0.0061632041,
-0.0752272084,
0.0129231848,
0.0192067511,
-0.0219733883,
0.006374768,
0.0186027326,
0.085294798,
0.0206290446,
-0.0690987185,
-0.0052322107,
-0.0445238948,
0.0542952381,
0.0345204622,
-0.0104769142,
0.0212646648,
0.0374182388,
-0.0225764792,
0.0418088995,
0.0402728803,
0.0275542308,
-0.0578771308,
-0.0028550369,
0.0381223001,
-0.0078796046,
-0.0250312705,
-0.0084631238,
0.0195065774,
-0.0050198166,
0.017982889,
-0.0627087578,
-0.0143767064,
-0.0237069614,
2.682e-7,
-0.0058027417,
0.0199789107,
0.0096403975,
0.0256818216,
0.0195757989,
0.0383992642,
-0.0056223311,
0.0363320597,
0.0095771337,
-0.0062748827,
0.0177261643,
0.0299896467,
0.0395607017,
0.0374432504,
-0.0902059823,
-0.0016498275,
-0.019564515,
-0.0383467376,
-0.0460120253,
0.0087943375,
0.0422451757,
0.108719185,
0.0640313849,
-0.0009757061,
0.0112609705,
-0.0459949076,
0.0785369053,
-0.021497624,
-0.0416844375,
-0.0050304946,
0.0498850457,
0.0066536209,
0.0184040256,
0.0014311871,
-0.0300607141,
-0.0329103321,
0.0043652635,
0.0982255712,
-0.0133265648,
-0.04759207,
-0.0238104872,
-0.0185442939,
-0.0039858539,
0.0030681619,
0.0835022703,
-0.0189468823,
-0.0120559279,
-0.0149587113,
-0.03036022,
-0.0366917998,
0.0224629808,
-0.0159242079,
-0.0248065796,
0.019535698,
0.0018349071,
0.0188951455,
-0.0485436693,
-0.0679776371,
-0.0012568135,
-0.0007113838,
-0.0475126989,
-0.0520658866,
-0.0010443372,
-0.0037790188,
-0.0305739082,
-0.0884569511,
0.0303233974,
2.472127068e-34,
0.0264794193,
-0.0136597566,
-0.0013671373,
0.0179170165,
0.0230394527,
0.0101240594,
0.0137894647,
0.0222448632,
0.0377189182,
-0.0586264171,
-0.0066318247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12321v1 | Automatic benchmarking of large multimodal models via iterative experiment programming | 2024-06-18T06:43:46 | 2024-06-18T06:43:46 | Alessandro Conti, Enrico Fini, Paolo Rota, Yiming Wang, Massimiliano Mancini, Elisa Ricci | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Assessing the capabilities of large multimodal models (LMMs) often requires
the creation of ad-hoc evaluations. Currently, building new benchmarks requires
tremendous amounts of manual work for each specific analysis. This makes the
evaluation process tedious and costly. In this paper, we present APEx,
Automatic Programming of Experiments, the first framework for automatic
benchmarking of LMMs. Given a research question expressed in natural language,
APEx leverages a large language model (LLM) and a library of pre-specified
tools to generate a set of experiments for the model at hand, and progressively
compile a scientific report. The report drives the testing procedure: based on
the current status of the investigation, APEx chooses which experiments to
perform and whether the results are sufficient to draw conclusions. Finally,
the LLM refines the report, presenting the results to the user in natural
language. Thanks to its modularity, our framework is flexible and extensible as
new tools become available. Empirically, APEx reproduces the findings of
existing studies while allowing for arbitrary analyses and hypothesis testing. | [
0.0060273539,
0.0675992742,
-0.0343660526,
0.0734327957,
-0.0666019544,
-0.0046845195,
0.0180031583,
0.0096018743,
-0.0051605981,
-0.0976406783,
-0.0487729385,
-0.0304699074,
0.0145006701,
0.0602217354,
0.0611646585,
-0.0700686276,
0.0435857289,
-0.0222289097,
-0.0351667367,
0.0312536769,
0.0142699433,
-0.0041074553,
-0.0401414372,
0.0525398701,
-0.008622624,
-0.0051667681,
-0.0409344472,
0.0083779925,
-0.0179759841,
-0.0502915233,
-0.0225963853,
0.0401899554,
0.0471152514,
0.0121417502,
0.0000023224,
-0.0584002472,
0.0016537912,
0.0183523968,
0.0444134735,
0.0119502172,
0.1176332906,
0.0081675155,
0.0224875025,
-0.0149637191,
-0.0058857445,
-0.0205115564,
0.0573678538,
-0.0285742711,
0.0375376903,
0.0093814405,
-0.007690792,
-0.0010023213,
-0.0108785694,
0.0287671871,
0.0026941041,
-0.0046298518,
-0.0021259165,
0.0358643048,
0.0655737594,
-0.0088925548,
-0.0282067154,
0.0236424562,
0.0151567338,
0.009942038,
-0.0140937362,
0.0146090267,
0.0089551397,
-0.0451865755,
-0.0209244359,
0.0722700208,
0.0062924279,
0.004303331,
0.0051238816,
0.0009043296,
-0.0230082776,
0.0448009446,
-0.0644263998,
0.0383304432,
0.0116684278,
-0.0351783931,
-0.0376551412,
0.007513959,
0.0147576518,
0.00684446,
0.0042895456,
0.0421995297,
0.0422452092,
-0.0031699797,
-0.0007302957,
-0.0192877427,
0.0101647256,
-0.0659933388,
-0.0141192405,
0.0165647529,
-0.0266727749,
0.0069362572,
-0.0111250533,
-0.0418523066,
0.0498491563,
-0.0447375961,
0.0947919115,
0.0366787165,
-0.0109600695,
0.0309603531,
0.0040067956,
0.0393917821,
-0.0293354727,
0.0163650308,
-0.0192655213,
0.0369255506,
-0.0768826455,
-0.0195551384,
0.0123049254,
-0.0128585799,
-0.0339451879,
-0.0545170084,
-0.0099561075,
0.0207420122,
0.0117601268,
0.0005489586,
-0.054819487,
-0.0150621179,
-0.034038648,
0.0241317675,
-0.0295172743,
0.0493363924,
-0.0413342677,
0.0154769691,
0.0096109062,
-0.0577811152,
0.0468825623,
0.0423833691,
-0.0174355358,
-0.0235392656,
-0.0075632124,
0.1116201878,
-0.0070506469,
-0.0156136602,
-0.0178329051,
-0.050379999,
-0.0055132769,
-0.0527754724,
0.0366558842,
-0.0990461707,
0.0493512265,
0.0289611779,
0.0035842645,
0.0036169549,
0.0032225011,
0.0006169649,
0.019177964,
0.103503339,
0.0194033552,
0.0051146755,
0.0350207798,
0.0055058659,
-0.0083517237,
0.0863946974,
0.0173392985,
0.014544202,
0.036148034,
-0.0324475653,
-0.0042594727,
0.0569011867,
-0.0259168632,
0.006297023,
-0.041978959,
0.0094579598,
0.0471652299,
0.0807399303,
-0.0210294314,
0.0517273284,
-0.0297115874,
-0.0015293666,
0.0870151743,
0.0645863935,
-0.0191835202,
-0.0102221575,
0.0397183001,
-0.0149553716,
0.0209299065,
0.0133496383,
-0.0290801506,
0.053197138,
-0.0150463395,
-0.0008851326,
0.022508882,
0.0270034671,
-0.00741885,
-0.0278206263,
-0.0435058326,
0.0058927475,
0.0360440314,
-0.0269483756,
0.0492903031,
0.0011289456,
-0.0390169173,
-0.0186668672,
0.0076763635,
-0.0648957565,
-0.0102675231,
-0.0443341322,
0.0136782965,
0.0432798155,
0.0606621467,
-0.0267118849,
-0.0034621896,
0.0115679819,
0.0245659593,
0.0506353267,
0.0526428558,
-0.0038091952,
0.0174546149,
-0.0239010658,
-0.0293178763,
-0.0596565418,
0.0026037325,
0.0350728408,
-0.0011415938,
-0.0203018729,
-0.0118764136,
-0.0597475469,
0.0059135389,
0.0337382294,
-0.0346264206,
-0.0026175701,
-0.039110817,
-0.0191196837,
0.0234108008,
-0.0260839388,
-0.0301877111,
0.0264721494,
0.0203372706,
-0.02332462,
-0.0093867434,
0.0412754901,
0.0298388191,
0.0103542646,
0.0287661925,
-0.0810049921,
-0.0191532169,
0.0492705144,
-0.0111315455,
-0.0064654462,
0.0392649025,
-0.0390163586,
0.0291215125,
-0.0189051051,
0.0049778931,
-0.0257982109,
-0.0190291926,
-0.0254818369,
0.0334698334,
-0.0016502206,
0.034335684,
-0.0058913548,
-0.0084914258,
0.0133418804,
-0.0108606452,
-0.0305302553,
0.0316727236,
-0.0082544181,
0.0141777322,
0.0161392987,
-0.0275229998,
-0.0462737456,
-0.0227380916,
-0.1198442951,
0.0038266561,
0.0082495445,
0.0092832725,
0.0270522535,
-0.0090653617,
-0.0020361778,
0.0212740656,
0.0114599792,
0.002368489,
0.0126793562,
0.0606609136,
0.0299988575,
-0.0042767702,
-0.0131977769,
-0.0652885959,
-0.0210740529,
-0.0516476892,
0.0773369297,
0.0177421924,
0.0212378539,
-0.0086001344,
-0.0182367973,
-0.0384308472,
-0.0002118016,
-0.0088315317,
-0.0423668697,
0.083711803,
-0.0288858935,
0.0621767677,
0.0574763454,
0.010260527,
0.0221558847,
0.0762278736,
-0.0461302511,
-0.0503799133,
-0.017530648,
0.0035340542,
0.0010700513,
-0.0003352874,
-0.0854903534,
0.0098555302,
0.0473168083,
0.0187995899,
0.0435663015,
-0.0201680548,
0.040409483,
-0.0355213806,
-0.0551435985,
-0.0649825558,
0.0043454128,
-0.0240505859,
0.0217766706,
-0.0142086595,
-0.0444521718,
0.0500885583,
-0.0378276631,
-0.0046469532,
-0.0084924707,
0.0469122529,
-0.0372952744,
0.1082127839,
0.0321414694,
0.0227311105,
-0.0106154587,
0.0150107658,
-0.0146590685,
0.0024022711,
0.0330254249,
-0.0283847805,
0.0130842803,
-0.0803612471,
0.0021561952,
-0.0023764654,
-0.0185955688,
-0.0135363108,
-0.0223669019,
-0.0322484486,
-0.0205370206,
0.0108062699,
-0.0081686424,
-0.0172602367,
0.0293299668,
0.0521611832,
0.0008387193,
-0.0095294369,
-0.0239168294,
-0.0388856009,
-0.0019217827,
0.0105692614,
0.0153568611,
-0.0362544432,
-0.0436731651,
-0.0056289835,
0.0464268215,
0.000758889,
0.015033477,
-0.1022769734,
0.0216697138,
-0.0080633853,
0.0056726271,
0.0084867245,
0.0389163569,
0.0458074622,
-0.0463838466,
0.0398767591,
0.0628536046,
0.0304242745,
-0.0363901444,
0.0070372852,
-0.0228778254,
0.0268769227,
0.0390495323,
0.0153483041,
-0.0873712823,
-0.0346802585,
0.0089510307,
-0.0069107749,
0.0161142237,
-0.0080150627,
0.016030455,
-0.1233534515,
0.0168639775,
-0.007727907,
-0.037997324,
0.0021908111,
-0.0606062263,
0.0208562277,
-0.0151734417,
-0.0233034585,
0.0431145392,
-0.0200703032,
0.0115505271,
-0.0036756126,
-0.0121784797,
-0.0770606101,
0.0062190429,
-0.0499446876,
0.0240931045,
0.0573149957,
0.0326802582,
-0.0209527463,
-0.0274989344,
0.0294215251,
0.0241429657,
0.0290899947,
-0.0190847479,
0.0209297743,
0.0279828366,
-0.012350182,
-0.0417608023,
0.0074739107,
0.0014022577,
-0.0245586056,
0.0018082602,
0.03064676,
-0.0145221381,
-0.004679752,
-0.0661570579,
0.0084374072,
0.0104735559,
0.0495023541,
0.0381551683,
-0.0404384285,
-0.0290008131,
-0.0349498019,
-0.0093138376,
-0.0277570933,
-0.0614865646,
-0.0115229553,
0.0065206736,
0.0587902777,
-0.0660707727,
-0.0142570436,
0.0217643753,
0.0176495314,
0.0098222233,
-0.0289526172,
-0.0117299836,
0.0021557442,
-0.0459116325,
0.0436042212,
0.013293488,
0.0562228709,
-0.0352561213,
0.0058653448,
0.0132495603,
-0.0076194387,
0.0039573708,
0.0512424372,
-0.0677111596,
-0.068525508,
-0.0171357002,
0.0812718719,
0.0138234356,
-0.0187326856,
0.0203683414,
-0.0785275698,
-0.0504363552,
0.0196327697,
-0.0158247948,
0.0195663814,
-0.0169900097,
-0.0013567333,
0.0028583149,
-0.023966454,
-0.0117701078,
0.0012875125,
-0.027286455,
0.0438283607,
0.0099969413,
-0.0316539109,
0.0284631699,
0.0204852764,
0.0240307841,
-0.035275016,
-0.0279368777,
-0.0022351574,
-0.044817932,
-0.0521457531,
-0.0315068811,
-0.0344299115,
0.0204556696,
-0.0161314011,
0.0158097558,
0.0232781637,
0.0190568417,
-0.025379559,
0.0366834961,
-0.0258961227,
0.0633235797,
0.0355327688,
-0.0135962097,
-0.0068581505,
0.0358767025,
-0.0251763649,
0.0146709187,
-0.0580003969,
0.0476646833,
-0.0270838812,
0.0593375079,
0.0118928989,
-0.0184650533,
-0.0284171849,
0.039995458,
0.0077054207,
-0.0199380722,
-0.0166077204,
0.0237447545,
0.0456958041,
0.0137933493,
0.0280142985,
-0.0620982572,
-0.0064311968,
-0.0446603894,
0.0308671817,
-0.0169067644,
0.0044425693,
0.0434942171,
0.027721066,
0.0076613147,
-0.0349972211,
0.049262248,
0.0093127452,
0.0044648563,
0.018073028,
0.0027767729,
-0.0482982434,
-0.0071840412,
0.0588770807,
0.0192167927,
-0.0228183996,
-0.0400797576,
-0.0305599701,
-0.0653233975,
-0.0065645673,
0.0592548586,
0.0109996237,
0.0066385604,
0.0521073155,
0.0626556277,
0.0150363101,
-0.0176377911,
-0.0114901476,
0.0349426307,
-0.032144513,
-0.0219040103,
-0.0016966761,
-6.708270019e-33,
0.0052528926,
-0.0313471518,
0.0407881886,
-0.0475115776,
0.011969734,
0.005343101,
-0.048849456,
0.0393603779,
0.0242705382,
-0.0044658757,
0.038408339,
-0.0451894067,
0.0003457012,
-0.0211093761,
0.0146404831,
0.0154248457,
0.0205936618,
-0.0032577217,
-0.0563824996,
-0.039273873,
0.0155765824,
-0.0084165083,
0.032720048,
-0.0574534908,
0.0084958449,
0.0108110029,
-0.0371021107,
-0.0036707891,
-0.0254478734,
0.0631884634,
-0.0474449173,
0.0358680114,
0.0239047371,
-0.0115556531,
-0.0265876818,
0.0498968661,
-0.0222408008,
-0.0063400958,
0.0295762755,
0.0188175682,
-0.0865071565,
0.0142498827,
0.0416994728,
-0.0267074686,
-0.0352857262,
0.012795127,
0.0339103974,
-0.0063055335,
0.0119950688,
0.0238202643,
-0.0880640075,
0.0362809226,
-0.0107806725,
-0.0289300587,
0.0104801971,
0.0624083467,
-0.0102609722,
-0.0024860261,
-0.0147671374,
0.0460976735,
-0.0128471842,
0.0099870246,
0.096658662,
0.0350407623,
0.025664445,
0.0558245331,
0.0043991362,
0.0017753736,
-0.0060821953,
0.0268780719,
0.0656249002,
0.0461585857,
0.0505672507,
0.098184593,
0.0096386652,
0.0339875631,
-0.0052015376,
0.0362626277,
0.0163456462,
0.0189518556,
0.0217372328,
0.0517278947,
-0.0088991858,
0.0048633493,
-0.0715562552,
0.0180206262,
-0.0616676584,
-0.0406432562,
0.0598752834,
-0.0184821356,
-0.0192294512,
0.0014810046,
0.0680684522,
-0.0261966456,
-0.0456775799,
-0.0232702438,
-0.0257527549,
0.0749922767,
0.0104204519,
0.018464148,
-0.0143027734,
-0.0108802123,
0.018774854,
0.0107978955,
0.0647039711,
-0.0074198749,
-0.039334245,
0.0368423089,
-0.0296367984,
0.0057692574,
-0.0201436263,
-0.0451330766,
0.0147879301,
-0.0150041496,
0.0406663492,
-0.0160872545,
-0.0447341017,
0.0249172337,
0.0035884071,
-0.0111109577,
-0.0889136717,
-0.055505801,
-0.0288308132,
0.0171903148,
-0.0178733878,
0.0077793445,
-0.081334196,
-0.0362156853,
0.0202482902,
-0.032996349,
-0.028647691,
0.0259619877,
2.91e-7,
0.0586376004,
0.0672449321,
-0.0132290255,
0.010796763,
0.0296864863,
0.0262408592,
-0.0452151373,
0.0325938128,
0.0162627399,
-0.0512572415,
-0.0326976664,
0.0278077777,
0.0500160158,
0.0575430021,
-0.01362749,
-0.0257775746,
-0.0241101962,
-0.0010184264,
-0.0693911165,
0.0147653474,
0.0297431722,
0.0290879589,
-0.0064459774,
0.0075088008,
-0.0090760477,
-0.0469004624,
0.0612897575,
-0.0332356617,
-0.0390664004,
0.0170688052,
-0.0218590088,
0.0026907574,
0.0181548223,
0.0044350675,
-0.0005848424,
-0.0591272265,
0.015439136,
0.0238389987,
-0.0073020738,
-0.0080160815,
0.022031866,
-0.0020029831,
-0.0218864214,
-0.0573599264,
0.0588260107,
-0.0508964211,
-0.0161861759,
-0.0422811247,
-0.0137751773,
-0.0095005063,
0.0433214866,
-0.0448351279,
-0.0331020206,
0.0304004177,
0.0057236864,
-0.00008352,
-0.0498000458,
-0.0240184162,
-0.0447564274,
0.0192013308,
-0.0792636052,
-0.0328836739,
-0.049785845,
-0.0266719069,
-0.0037711982,
-0.0901413634,
-0.0331629962,
2.635892257e-34,
0.0353640765,
0.0086379461,
0.0446799435,
-0.0147460978,
0.0556619875,
0.0010125479,
-0.052821897,
0.0176025964,
0.0082985079,
-0.0716506243,
-0.0118009439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12319v1 | PRePair: Pointwise Reasoning Enhance Pairwise Evaluating for Robust Instruction-Following Assessments | 2024-06-18T06:43:04 | 2024-06-18T06:43:04 | Hawon Jeong, ChaeHun Park, Jimin Hong, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pairwise evaluation using large language models (LLMs) is widely used for
evaluating natural language generation (NLG) tasks. However, the reliability of
LLMs is often compromised by biases, such as favoring verbosity and
authoritative tone. In the study, we focus on the comparison of two LLM-based
evaluation approaches, pointwise and pairwise. Our findings demonstrate that
pointwise evaluators exhibit more robustness against undesirable preferences.
Further analysis reveals that pairwise evaluators can accurately identify the
shortcomings of low-quality outputs even when their judgment is incorrect.
These results indicate that LLMs are more severely influenced by their bias in
a pairwise evaluation setup. To mitigate this, we propose a hybrid method that
integrates pointwise reasoning into pairwise evaluation. Experimental results
show that our method enhances the robustness of pairwise evaluators against
adversarial samples while preserving accuracy on normal samples. | [
0.0022768232,
0.0463206023,
0.0007530524,
0.0248616897,
-0.0443999693,
0.0201393943,
0.0630684197,
-0.0463004559,
-0.0084161907,
-0.0823259205,
-0.0143090477,
-0.0372029319,
0.0052746399,
-0.0029753831,
0.054793898,
-0.0529421233,
0.0244433191,
-0.034566991,
0.0091467071,
-0.0112755243,
0.0179638732,
0.020572843,
-0.0250915885,
0.0397141166,
0.0542764738,
-0.0472717434,
0.0180593338,
-0.0033972296,
0.0251299329,
-0.0363986753,
0.0054457542,
0.0579094738,
-0.0133507084,
-0.0007534871,
0.0000021065,
-0.0459048115,
-0.0188063569,
0.0067571164,
0.0160811469,
0.066353552,
0.0133643756,
0.0411726199,
-0.0038082255,
0.0075750519,
-0.0345089398,
-0.0098963082,
-0.0028455055,
0.0283033643,
0.0780769885,
0.0465066805,
0.0175751112,
-0.0191170741,
0.012412007,
-0.0077514942,
-0.011825352,
-0.0373582765,
-0.0044256691,
-0.0093283961,
0.0260211267,
0.0312169287,
0.0076658158,
0.0230707061,
0.0189513527,
-0.0219938252,
-0.0069844644,
0.0267167464,
-0.0105587598,
-0.0212829541,
0.0012058016,
0.0732675865,
-0.0050064642,
0.0260382537,
-0.0018054415,
-0.0279992856,
0.0060305498,
0.0065091532,
-0.0335220285,
0.0352650806,
-0.0354823172,
0.0034623381,
0.0239334609,
-0.0140972594,
-0.0062435782,
0.0247166809,
-0.0128646912,
0.0486519523,
0.006760973,
-0.0285427868,
0.0037762625,
0.0335686244,
-0.1004896685,
-0.0500499308,
0.0133760078,
0.0330118239,
-0.0564353876,
0.0271774027,
-0.0503226034,
-0.0078193294,
0.027383266,
-0.0480150543,
0.0614519753,
0.0246951263,
-0.0287146606,
-0.0096071195,
-0.04191643,
0.0635056347,
0.0315460414,
0.034586329,
-0.0306583811,
0.0611970685,
-0.0293342825,
0.0003876018,
-0.0193031728,
0.0667504519,
-0.0144176111,
0.0083866352,
-0.0589176528,
-0.0132188471,
-0.0480381772,
0.0179225188,
0.0090635922,
0.0216319282,
-0.0132982656,
0.0190237574,
-0.0160193108,
0.0349371135,
-0.0394280963,
0.0330286734,
0.0170096532,
-0.0390370712,
0.0171944555,
0.0543323606,
-0.0041091801,
-0.0172037128,
0.0128010008,
0.0566943027,
-0.0171783175,
-0.02519821,
-0.0365462638,
-0.0601157695,
-0.0407178849,
-0.0543485172,
-0.0177162979,
-0.075925909,
-0.0003019335,
-0.0005164812,
-0.023240231,
-0.0250977222,
0.0141248275,
0.0439045541,
-0.0165121593,
0.0237268228,
0.0614074096,
0.0052858619,
-0.0019114523,
0.0285014641,
-0.0082237339,
0.0280115288,
0.0475067608,
0.0079571353,
0.0029115409,
-0.0260119736,
-0.0078872247,
0.0163542721,
0.0182829369,
0.0063478537,
-0.0249132086,
-0.0223478507,
-0.0078402199,
0.024063386,
0.0281705335,
0.0812341273,
-0.0216338001,
0.0273175035,
0.0634001866,
-0.0295674019,
0.0297116432,
-0.0184758678,
0.1171875075,
-0.0028439243,
-0.0189722851,
0.0801656768,
-0.0368943512,
0.0274882447,
-0.0548229553,
0.0094520207,
0.0476863012,
0.0428392217,
-0.0077864067,
-0.0698308423,
0.0161213242,
0.0288089979,
0.0000870048,
-0.0072934348,
0.0316412747,
0.0289249606,
-0.0789678022,
-0.0427717641,
0.0025089653,
-0.0526523814,
0.0430394709,
-0.0541064814,
0.0411308482,
0.0655974746,
0.0544674769,
0.0350841843,
-0.0183692668,
-0.0085574677,
-0.0014450864,
0.0284998659,
0.0321606621,
-0.0187295154,
0.0065691103,
-0.0547140278,
-0.029271163,
-0.0225273389,
0.0074279034,
0.0315058604,
-0.0129018314,
0.0143775707,
0.0185214803,
0.0031466077,
-0.0812241361,
0.0354968049,
-0.0018093756,
-0.057226155,
0.0020327468,
0.0115521848,
0.0276675317,
0.0147684757,
-0.0161570013,
0.0402758941,
0.0019210352,
-0.0158681031,
0.0057907989,
0.0022149938,
-0.0632656664,
-0.0659859553,
-0.006460763,
-0.0366944559,
-0.0216349103,
0.0007833518,
-0.0271807499,
-0.0083795488,
-0.0048414059,
-0.0205251072,
-0.0473793596,
-0.005546099,
0.0366861038,
0.0077414187,
-0.0054512182,
-0.0625683963,
0.0509459972,
0.008468369,
0.019516496,
0.0184999947,
0.0297382046,
-0.0102807246,
-0.0358882546,
-0.0503475778,
0.0237625297,
-0.011990319,
0.0077299662,
0.0371928141,
0.0457805917,
-0.0565489866,
-0.0472650789,
-0.062192671,
0.0172535013,
-0.0194988046,
0.0438670106,
0.0473906696,
-0.0540917665,
0.0089404676,
0.0425695553,
-0.0419087,
-0.0250321478,
0.0186689533,
0.0311077144,
0.0212329142,
0.0264679361,
-0.013765729,
-0.0276929662,
-0.0046033487,
-0.0371356197,
0.0261095073,
0.0479116067,
0.0243513584,
-0.0602073669,
0.102597326,
-0.0354073197,
-0.0265191793,
0.0355576612,
-0.0463034138,
0.0512619875,
0.0248020664,
0.0340952799,
0.0834829435,
0.0114890058,
0.0177837908,
0.0651725084,
-0.0193864387,
-0.0592182949,
-0.0072379075,
-0.0137776481,
-0.018892495,
-0.0111323316,
-0.0466650762,
-0.002131938,
0.0466576368,
0.0590663292,
-0.0043858471,
-0.03320482,
0.0606800355,
-0.07017041,
-0.0255965367,
-0.0178413782,
-0.0453464948,
0.0008556704,
-0.0102754729,
-0.0289062653,
-0.0503379852,
0.1039972231,
-0.0452350378,
-0.0021838096,
-0.0372088514,
0.0214894097,
-0.0199835673,
0.0236257743,
-0.0021767255,
0.0258010998,
-0.0224071126,
-0.0250417981,
-0.0762068629,
-0.0016039755,
0.0355352052,
-0.0307124183,
0.0265412088,
-0.0870062485,
-0.0397638381,
0.0076595168,
-0.0078337034,
-0.0411690772,
-0.0117825996,
0.0349019654,
0.0003171467,
0.0157480333,
0.0036885762,
0.0015525919,
-0.0044626612,
0.0333723724,
-0.0120571032,
-0.0604282953,
-0.0102582835,
-0.0095891971,
0.032450404,
0.0294451937,
-0.0210125204,
0.0145357382,
-0.0403432474,
0.0472968221,
0.0483598709,
0.0021988635,
0.0543134585,
-0.0168773923,
0.0154242767,
0.0212380942,
-0.0164037757,
-0.0481220745,
0.0514896475,
0.0778254867,
-0.0669820905,
-0.0207743049,
0.0936657414,
0.0174674708,
0.0082947109,
0.0014912796,
0.01125261,
0.0255588889,
-0.0077159833,
0.0147455633,
-0.0322551765,
-0.0108736595,
-0.0218266696,
0.0545975156,
-0.0594279543,
-0.0283609983,
-0.0057397499,
-0.1410894841,
0.0442433022,
0.0283612218,
-0.0437967516,
-0.0193592794,
-0.0187577959,
-0.0184292421,
0.0040994575,
0.0487309843,
0.0390129872,
-0.0081904745,
0.0299487226,
0.0713873506,
-0.0217036288,
-0.047451891,
0.0350995176,
-0.0430268496,
0.0496739894,
0.0775934532,
0.0415516421,
0.0060581667,
-0.041812595,
0.0117531652,
-0.0668916702,
0.0134131545,
-0.0182380714,
0.0071923807,
-0.0028624376,
-0.0003363799,
-0.0164830461,
0.0512296967,
0.0070973095,
0.0208655819,
0.0048568891,
0.0485323556,
-0.015229811,
-0.025250813,
-0.0235504881,
0.0692311376,
0.0117788687,
0.0714011043,
0.0457708538,
-0.0560831167,
-0.036573384,
-0.0242734384,
-0.055053968,
-0.0907548666,
-0.052779559,
0.0668689907,
-0.0026303113,
0.021233473,
-0.0961644053,
-0.0524533503,
0.0297192894,
0.0301555693,
-0.0182217099,
0.0142670255,
-0.0471652597,
0.0071446719,
0.0235426426,
0.0085334964,
0.0264391825,
0.0242734104,
-0.057461191,
-0.0259904806,
0.0130663682,
0.0048419894,
-0.0225969329,
0.0537908375,
-0.041457653,
-0.0766196921,
-0.0144353323,
0.0677271038,
0.0164185334,
0.0178332031,
0.0151190963,
-0.0355349667,
0.0220765956,
0.0373332277,
-0.0117083145,
0.0345793925,
0.0403017625,
0.0265706051,
0.0025277955,
-0.0023719273,
-0.0000450613,
0.026460547,
0.0255223177,
0.0444587134,
0.0083097573,
-0.0218231212,
0.021573374,
0.0701243132,
0.0435791314,
-0.0534478314,
-0.0036049599,
-0.0379135236,
-0.0121319573,
-0.042468112,
-0.0253969934,
-0.0407025926,
0.0103613436,
0.0054884693,
-0.0178204887,
-0.0126727438,
-0.0088385111,
-0.0048243315,
0.0234381706,
-0.0073770131,
0.0646619424,
-0.0118338307,
-0.006927493,
0.0240089502,
0.009007684,
-0.0404297896,
-0.0037188393,
-0.0095559247,
0.0498592742,
0.0003582762,
0.0789036378,
-0.0022795706,
0.0192217529,
0.0223168656,
0.0225209519,
-0.0096175922,
-0.0234687813,
-0.04217574,
-0.006543221,
0.0045428914,
0.0110575594,
0.0693383962,
-0.0251094159,
0.0391501188,
-0.0364899486,
0.0531206578,
0.0078437692,
-0.0428913943,
0.0504313074,
0.0050534867,
0.0169628821,
-0.036525216,
0.0518541299,
-0.0261080749,
0.0225153062,
-0.0195010304,
0.0130740125,
-0.0375123136,
-0.0665093139,
0.0140177812,
-0.0327170007,
-0.0113076149,
-0.0032005997,
-0.0504585207,
-0.0357844234,
-0.0330596045,
0.0633201897,
0.057084579,
-0.0365796201,
0.0203936491,
0.0660538822,
-0.0585194454,
0.0143861528,
-0.0554229431,
-0.0070971041,
0.0016355503,
-0.0147800623,
-0.0327980854,
-6.406531639e-33,
-0.059034247,
-0.0696440041,
0.0470117144,
-0.0463426076,
-0.0092890179,
-0.0115726599,
-0.0453116484,
0.019858636,
0.0066373111,
-0.0016648949,
0.0385386199,
-0.0225926302,
-0.0073337844,
0.0023554428,
0.0186764468,
-0.0204330832,
0.0476096794,
0.0098374914,
-0.0364428647,
0.0341975875,
0.0334802419,
-0.0323163792,
0.0338560641,
-0.0474635102,
0.056391336,
0.0084191551,
-0.043430984,
-0.0093814954,
-0.069644168,
0.0755494162,
0.015812872,
0.0133834928,
0.0227269176,
-0.0384049304,
-0.0136379125,
0.0028286013,
-0.0150898648,
-0.0214082114,
0.0283327922,
-0.0096315844,
-0.0553755239,
-0.0503934212,
0.0441665649,
0.0035333377,
-0.04302416,
-0.0164303705,
0.0304313097,
-0.0066213585,
0.0021065737,
-0.0120512722,
-0.0540049411,
0.0245978273,
-0.0282757524,
-0.0318317972,
-0.0214323718,
0.0758651718,
-0.0318634361,
-0.0104791233,
-0.0223873463,
0.0341968387,
0.030753959,
0.0293378253,
0.0756026432,
-0.0190753881,
-0.0224960744,
0.0591093786,
0.0142433504,
0.0023020729,
0.0133621795,
0.0069257473,
0.0309359822,
0.0258615296,
0.0766665414,
0.0519084223,
0.0214450024,
0.0039456147,
-0.0804540589,
0.0521866046,
0.0020344341,
0.0097684255,
0.0193431862,
-0.0317365229,
-0.0448347107,
-0.0348786414,
-0.0578611046,
-0.0533878468,
-0.0338086262,
-0.0413138047,
0.0405613221,
-0.0129506597,
-0.0616305694,
-0.019021159,
0.0429376476,
0.0099234618,
-0.0198615268,
0.0073915669,
-0.0797769651,
0.041009631,
-0.0294058379,
0.0052014082,
-0.04176227,
-0.0116420444,
0.0069493568,
-0.0084553864,
0.0397796296,
0.0135475919,
0.049207218,
0.0041919807,
-0.0560264885,
0.0098308986,
-0.045878645,
0.0339476019,
0.0196695402,
-0.0103743272,
0.0354580134,
-0.0181347933,
-0.0266085826,
0.0594116487,
-0.0281843469,
-0.0228224546,
-0.0461883508,
-0.0106840534,
-0.0146941105,
0.0215585902,
-0.0365098566,
-0.0075589316,
0.012250552,
-0.0070812479,
0.018452242,
-0.0449607074,
-0.0194561481,
-0.0079361582,
2.794e-7,
0.0146195767,
0.0468480997,
-0.0014070682,
0.0121503687,
0.0071975319,
0.0308386609,
-0.0020372844,
0.0032936151,
0.0223603956,
-0.0242917221,
0.0007907698,
0.0165692121,
0.0349407382,
0.046363987,
-0.0231094677,
0.015497935,
-0.0647613555,
0.0214467458,
-0.0443744734,
-0.0093864715,
0.0990555659,
0.0025978424,
-0.0214383453,
0.0205322355,
0.0141592417,
-0.0236975513,
0.0533997938,
0.0103873154,
-0.0095235407,
0.0189646427,
0.0546716154,
-0.0445328392,
0.02449934,
0.0341861099,
-0.0024088935,
-0.0404772535,
0.0078682052,
0.0740550458,
0.0499740466,
-0.0067420928,
0.005627302,
-0.0104094939,
0.000950033,
-0.0457728095,
0.0599337667,
-0.0739020631,
-0.0463332087,
0.0028388891,
-0.016802635,
-0.0256286021,
0.0102766817,
-0.0216020364,
0.0031539244,
0.0252330229,
-0.0105109848,
-0.0284982882,
0.0023799893,
-0.0237687286,
-0.019325275,
0.0187306907,
0.0019870051,
-0.0669189468,
-0.0276240837,
0.0173882153,
-0.0319639817,
-0.0560006574,
-0.0318272747,
2.502725048e-34,
0.0229343753,
-0.0244758856,
0.0527117886,
-0.0466540791,
0.0366227962,
0.0183552634,
-0.0264111944,
0.00388058,
0.0195403248,
-0.0528806262,
-0.0361091234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12317v1 | Finding Task-specific Subnetworks in Multi-task Spoken Language Understanding Model | 2024-06-18T06:39:41 | 2024-06-18T06:39:41 | Hayato Futami, Siddhant Arora, Yosuke Kashiwagi, Emiru Tsunoo, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Recently, multi-task spoken language understanding (SLU) models have emerged,
designed to address various speech processing tasks. However, these models
often rely on a large number of parameters. Also, they often encounter
difficulties in adapting to new data for a specific task without experiencing
catastrophic forgetting of previously trained tasks. In this study, we propose
finding task-specific subnetworks within a multi-task SLU model via neural
network pruning. In addition to model compression, we expect that the
forgetting of previously trained tasks can be mitigated by updating only a
task-specific subnetwork. We conduct experiments on top of the state-of-the-art
multi-task SLU model ``UniverSLU'', trained for several tasks such as emotion
recognition (ER), intent classification (IC), and automatic speech recognition
(ASR). We show that pruned models were successful in adapting to additional ASR
or IC data with minimal performance degradation on previously trained tasks. | [
-0.010324656,
0.0303465109,
-0.0022730643,
0.06128392,
-0.0074918037,
0.0165726412,
0.0584505349,
-0.0449184068,
-0.0050325682,
-0.000053911,
-0.0805690661,
-0.0831015408,
-0.0004524341,
-0.0095283221,
0.0069752163,
-0.0025155842,
0.0673727542,
-0.0475145504,
0.0286997911,
0.0086004231,
-0.0020464084,
0.0247036982,
-0.0142129911,
0.0376563482,
0.0342308693,
-0.018250905,
-0.0361438915,
0.0367300883,
0.0059769163,
0.0195568241,
0.0138575509,
0.0364369787,
0.0555416942,
0.0003857859,
0.0000020439,
-0.0158870425,
-0.036711283,
-0.0320466831,
-0.1131176278,
-0.0105023151,
0.0453838296,
0.035977006,
-0.0016743422,
0.0141216274,
-0.0009119837,
-0.0205279402,
0.0200020466,
0.0623900853,
0.0430494212,
0.0761620924,
0.0133145899,
-0.0093819983,
-0.0321488008,
-0.0416212082,
-0.0242242757,
-0.0759288222,
0.0110196164,
0.0111539308,
-0.0287579019,
-0.0411419645,
-0.0068302737,
0.0102238879,
0.001577319,
0.0238775574,
-0.0275377855,
-0.0094804307,
-0.0022413847,
-0.059150096,
-0.0119879479,
0.0593631044,
-0.057064604,
-0.0092213387,
-0.0008811931,
-0.0037526297,
-0.0126247825,
-0.0431829132,
-0.042206116,
-0.0427785292,
-0.0116805984,
-0.0034695838,
-0.0192837156,
-0.0018244241,
0.0370443277,
0.0097489115,
-0.0235240199,
0.0611547343,
-0.0349439606,
0.0060633942,
0.0052970406,
-0.0554845445,
-0.0341226272,
-0.032896731,
0.0370198265,
0.0173385218,
-0.0326508656,
0.0326024257,
-0.0201208442,
-0.0627866909,
-0.0494870692,
-0.0288100652,
0.0003138788,
0.0678643882,
-0.0167831536,
0.0318790413,
0.0051123179,
0.0558558926,
0.0111557059,
-0.0287374891,
-0.065847978,
-0.0102465888,
-0.0607599579,
-0.0058007441,
-0.0639005303,
0.0303942263,
-0.0365140587,
-0.0041523632,
-0.0201890953,
0.0096289851,
-0.0377800725,
-0.004822406,
0.0468797497,
0.0039706742,
-0.0473434143,
0.0102905678,
0.0254595298,
0.0489488542,
0.0049326038,
0.0539298095,
-0.0176273081,
-0.0493656844,
-0.0482840315,
0.0159296766,
0.0306608249,
-0.023069242,
-0.000944675,
0.0290252771,
0.00095149,
-0.0447002836,
-0.0833010674,
-0.022822883,
-0.0184719414,
-0.0589840412,
0.0261472948,
-0.0231852233,
0.0384004004,
-0.0499737598,
0.0143786846,
-0.0543313287,
-0.0089447368,
-0.0289361011,
-0.0422632657,
0.0777752995,
0.0243193246,
-0.0007743498,
0.0075336802,
-0.0028962672,
0.0004611335,
0.0636286661,
0.0049141184,
0.0139042512,
0.0182403792,
-0.026891008,
-0.0437303148,
0.0164244045,
0.025255654,
-0.0422341861,
0.0108442344,
-0.0024796743,
-0.0097539891,
0.0084648039,
0.0359896198,
0.0092119323,
-0.0555373393,
-0.017198123,
0.0352362506,
0.038878426,
0.009432856,
0.0457569472,
0.0057797981,
0.0426390544,
-0.0060427836,
0.0263427272,
-0.0391659923,
0.0149342455,
-0.012595281,
-0.0115636177,
-0.0257118866,
0.0041726176,
-0.0596925281,
-0.0550773665,
-0.0233278144,
-0.0194216929,
0.0085514216,
0.0427087545,
0.0512982756,
-0.0046200096,
-0.0480877571,
0.0575833619,
-0.0064129713,
-0.0658684969,
0.047000505,
-0.05096009,
0.0243662093,
0.0652326792,
-0.0010382419,
-0.0430075154,
-0.0419599637,
-0.0176299904,
0.0246619303,
-0.0274005048,
0.0161125939,
-0.0276269838,
0.0700113922,
-0.078740254,
0.0100645637,
-0.0127820615,
0.0099271638,
0.0218394566,
-0.0652017295,
-0.0498206988,
0.0125087453,
-0.053943146,
-0.0150673324,
-0.003620201,
-0.0367503911,
0.0186735522,
0.0137949428,
0.0076360726,
0.0418564305,
0.0349900089,
-0.0242798124,
-0.0184503067,
0.0340202451,
-0.0112782456,
0.0367330313,
0.0194447841,
-0.0227721017,
-0.0516465679,
0.017100567,
0.0177960452,
0.0187841207,
0.0811379403,
-0.0366101749,
-0.080789201,
0.0225294549,
-0.0029352827,
0.0369386971,
-0.0455453508,
0.0183932353,
-0.0016735642,
0.0259492565,
-0.006062401,
0.0076832292,
0.0090193935,
-0.0300253313,
0.0463219769,
-0.0473251007,
0.0229088832,
-0.0752593279,
-0.0504301265,
0.0249789692,
-0.0390651226,
-0.0217782781,
-0.0409681424,
-0.0089283576,
-0.023129018,
-0.0107939159,
-0.0674537644,
-0.0141051067,
-0.0445262715,
0.020645408,
0.0066107842,
0.0224025454,
0.0056526284,
-0.0400866345,
0.0269716214,
0.0169333275,
-0.0145247588,
-0.02359147,
-0.0322537534,
-0.005192983,
-0.0288610067,
-0.054047782,
-0.0157202873,
0.0185886342,
0.046230942,
-0.0209527668,
-0.0531500578,
-0.0489198864,
0.0619830377,
-0.0113522988,
0.0408059061,
-0.0219459925,
-0.0182640571,
-0.05183715,
0.017686937,
-0.0217743684,
0.0652553812,
-0.028300127,
0.0521596484,
0.0418500826,
-0.0297158938,
-0.0246988107,
0.059790466,
-0.0145746311,
0.0101586403,
-0.0139114708,
0.0141752698,
-0.0140939653,
0.0796982795,
0.0315425023,
-0.0112261316,
-0.0366567746,
-0.0521514267,
-0.0111140413,
-0.0344768316,
-0.0422950499,
-0.0388186052,
-0.0193517786,
0.0144084785,
-0.0043543745,
-0.0103689795,
0.0143678505,
-0.0461131185,
-0.0149620855,
-0.089557305,
-0.0308446251,
0.0007351479,
0.0525185093,
-0.0111249704,
0.0277301893,
0.0389811248,
-0.0290272962,
-0.0414424948,
0.0016579472,
-0.0337584764,
-0.0256454963,
0.0654579177,
-0.0495646149,
0.0094802184,
-0.0130830724,
-0.0154994577,
-0.0449538976,
-0.0081967674,
-0.0362040177,
0.038127739,
0.034104649,
0.0004739111,
-0.0056758104,
0.035433773,
0.0146190235,
0.0303716715,
0.0146849472,
0.0216679126,
-0.0100990888,
0.0391138382,
0.0170321278,
0.0491937324,
0.003959443,
-0.0069177798,
0.0393333472,
-0.0055399379,
0.0938518345,
0.00501417,
-0.0455010049,
0.0183419827,
0.0268769991,
-0.0007610414,
-0.0241966043,
0.0055591776,
0.0620073527,
-0.044686228,
0.0141724283,
0.1167492419,
0.0182548035,
-0.0465891585,
-0.0013128314,
-0.0287257843,
-0.0106164776,
0.0230861101,
0.026938865,
-0.0224818457,
-0.0488154292,
0.0346152075,
-0.0025565783,
0.0422095954,
-0.0036213868,
-0.0274909828,
-0.0478985198,
0.0367817581,
0.0159949046,
-0.0232805368,
0.0202916842,
-0.0175919328,
0.0269448534,
-0.0326146036,
0.0520273782,
-0.0098920092,
0.0233841036,
-0.039092131,
0.0595777668,
-0.0292507578,
-0.068991214,
0.0355140306,
0.0300236549,
0.0774448514,
-0.014528757,
0.050181672,
-0.010820698,
-0.0021365304,
0.0564221814,
0.0020716346,
0.0278736316,
-0.0283679739,
0.0446090959,
0.0186732672,
-0.0161736645,
0.0432458669,
0.0127520198,
-0.0409847498,
-0.0205805171,
-0.0153394351,
0.0406247377,
-0.0469262712,
0.007090332,
0.0217722356,
-0.016973801,
0.0133223552,
0.0780654326,
0.0406515747,
-0.0139911463,
-0.0022424161,
0.0165265296,
0.0123918131,
-0.0490893312,
0.0102624334,
0.0280240159,
0.0028107483,
-0.0277192723,
0.024901215,
-0.0051458706,
0.0323142372,
0.019459838,
0.0164523609,
0.0033781952,
0.0642617643,
0.0344808586,
-0.0534305274,
0.0374337099,
0.0118333921,
0.0340968072,
-0.0319422372,
-0.012814722,
0.0328246728,
-0.0693793073,
-0.0377363451,
0.0282772258,
-0.1222688258,
-0.0354012884,
0.0062455619,
-0.0077092489,
0.0300991088,
0.0695980936,
-0.0225259475,
-0.0243614111,
-0.0303607676,
-0.0611233376,
-0.0251368713,
0.0293946769,
0.0490168445,
-0.0052105915,
-0.0351400524,
0.0506548509,
-0.0250008814,
0.0442718267,
0.013630393,
0.0031357966,
-0.017178081,
-0.0327545218,
-0.0146477465,
0.0259026345,
0.0668505728,
0.026276337,
-0.0182400271,
-0.0746320635,
0.0483184978,
0.059649013,
0.0353028513,
-0.0439278893,
-0.0127121666,
0.0116900206,
-0.0146539751,
-0.0105860494,
0.0062676244,
0.0160664227,
-0.0056246407,
0.003232721,
0.0100407377,
0.0236740131,
-0.0102536511,
0.0095154587,
0.0019857029,
-0.0337797254,
0.0162835047,
0.0264560375,
0.0086212968,
0.0143247135,
0.0483563878,
-0.0215514712,
-0.0064173853,
-0.0456513613,
0.0533893295,
-0.0395071693,
-0.0746684298,
-0.0211498048,
0.0207453333,
0.0091750054,
-0.0429103076,
0.014098851,
0.0230940916,
0.0476152375,
-0.0538241602,
0.0403635353,
0.0038810179,
0.0029119267,
0.0610275418,
-0.0053113839,
-0.0207141936,
0.008058778,
0.0678528026,
-0.0026123773,
0.0667429566,
-0.0324535295,
0.0216261838,
-0.0619891472,
-0.0548013113,
0.0030259085,
0.0166970473,
-0.0466633327,
0.0026026883,
-0.0198313035,
-0.050319884,
0.0103262933,
-0.0277271252,
0.0334517919,
-0.0206293575,
0.0415272638,
0.0535613187,
-0.0342562199,
0.0252833571,
0.0153900273,
-0.0716286674,
-0.013157405,
0.0079544326,
0.0139275892,
-6.279707554e-33,
-0.0359576643,
0.0272855647,
0.0073882458,
0.0099232849,
-0.0037414921,
0.0383152626,
-0.0403247625,
-0.0134553257,
-0.0368581973,
-0.0563705452,
-0.0029661171,
0.0285560042,
0.0365249068,
0.0034747012,
-0.0339745544,
-0.0398848616,
0.1096040606,
-0.0254220031,
0.0133489938,
0.0138722081,
0.0564731546,
0.0460945368,
0.0776123703,
-0.0311058573,
0.0054354682,
0.0239903778,
-0.0031940208,
0.042020984,
0.0025729276,
0.0461398587,
-0.0088288886,
0.0549786277,
0.0236558635,
-0.0532801785,
-0.0245945342,
0.0471490733,
-0.0763884261,
-0.0190260503,
0.0403222442,
0.0341322422,
-0.0493534692,
-0.0067797336,
0.0275233258,
0.048209507,
0.0229399838,
-0.0238082092,
0.0272199661,
-0.0024773558,
-0.016332332,
0.002601061,
-0.0000368155,
0.0091648391,
-0.0313598849,
-0.0554276071,
0.0716947094,
0.0839081407,
-0.0312500298,
-0.0259571746,
-0.0804987848,
-0.0101784216,
-0.040824376,
0.0260503776,
0.0781622827,
0.0320835486,
-0.0314548872,
0.0510401726,
0.032119628,
0.0172174163,
0.0063431929,
-0.0250340011,
0.018915724,
0.0572618358,
-0.0142783057,
-0.0085480269,
-0.0072817332,
-0.0365198739,
-0.0589187294,
-0.0185064524,
0.0690037385,
0.0519001894,
0.0385973379,
0.0363349132,
0.0027859099,
-0.0062653157,
-0.0424699001,
-0.0173133314,
-0.0323217027,
0.0020210459,
0.043591179,
0.0048500104,
-0.0062900856,
0.0065706866,
0.0581960864,
-0.0398115106,
0.0516801067,
0.0475245118,
0.0087982621,
-0.0081153875,
0.0212548822,
0.0500491746,
-0.0421038605,
-0.0315277427,
-0.0018867593,
0.0295424033,
0.0188909695,
-0.017594697,
0.0249663237,
0.061862994,
0.0117915152,
-0.0327378251,
-0.045793131,
0.0100569641,
-0.0178789794,
0.0971373245,
0.0552272312,
0.0358932614,
-0.018074207,
0.0291176587,
-0.0045763715,
-0.0162893739,
-0.0058339592,
0.0113608222,
0.0102876639,
0.0381568708,
-0.0376815163,
-0.0365735628,
0.0125718331,
-0.0164389927,
0.0066055828,
-0.0366529003,
-0.0108486349,
0.0510681793,
2.914e-7,
-0.0210449062,
-0.0065795095,
0.0000869548,
-0.0212757513,
0.0347061455,
0.0312924087,
-0.0465543121,
-0.0116835395,
-0.0114689423,
-0.0213662442,
0.0221932717,
0.027188234,
0.0616529062,
-0.0021042195,
-0.0938332528,
-0.0222370028,
0.0050517623,
0.0270900019,
-0.008700598,
0.0108408947,
0.0412319712,
0.0876059607,
0.0027741205,
-0.0089174882,
0.0123072946,
-0.0041673877,
0.004336664,
-0.0422258116,
0.0086033,
0.0033457505,
0.0049988898,
0.0112278573,
-0.0191405155,
0.0529415645,
0.0063707992,
0.0253682286,
0.0276509877,
0.0679120719,
-0.0137503594,
-0.0108004091,
-0.0018265267,
0.0413195938,
-0.01847977,
-0.0030064664,
0.0663277656,
-0.0118672308,
-0.023729967,
-0.0036395492,
0.0121575519,
0.0140877739,
-0.0226760022,
0.0408333167,
0.0466514416,
0.0164571386,
-0.0218881667,
-0.0513791442,
-0.0268849619,
-0.072913222,
0.0244028419,
0.0107173864,
-0.1026081592,
-0.0171144754,
-0.0292706024,
-0.0343585536,
0.0717844814,
-0.0682875589,
-0.0023830882,
1.895448366e-34,
0.0204857998,
-0.0134390416,
-0.0148734925,
0.0459585376,
0.004715147,
-0.0460295491,
-0.0866720229,
-0.0063087097,
-0.0015737575,
-0.0634236932,
-0.0286353137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12307v1 | Can Tool-augmented Large Language Models be Aware of Incomplete Conditions? | 2024-06-18T06:28:06 | 2024-06-18T06:28:06 | Seungbin Yang, ChaeHun Park, Taehee Kim, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in integrating large language models (LLMs) with tools
have allowed the models to interact with real-world environments. However,
these tool-augmented LLMs often encounter incomplete scenarios when users
provide partial information or the necessary tools are unavailable. Recognizing
and managing such scenarios is crucial for LLMs to ensure their reliability,
but this exploration remains understudied. This study examines whether LLMs can
identify incomplete conditions and appropriately determine when to refrain from
using tools. To this end, we address a dataset by manipulating instances from
two datasets by removing necessary tools or essential information for tool
invocation. We confirm that most LLMs are challenged to identify the additional
information required to utilize specific tools and the absence of appropriate
tools. Our research can contribute to advancing reliable LLMs by addressing
scenarios that commonly arise during interactions between humans and LLMs. | [
0.0475783236,
0.0276782345,
-0.0362125374,
0.0373126082,
-0.0280276518,
0.0166499559,
-0.0093565816,
0.0150259398,
0.0057259924,
-0.0324932374,
0.008027073,
-0.0200363025,
0.0090295067,
-0.0291575622,
0.0173028838,
-0.0568849035,
0.0400999263,
-0.0391919054,
-0.063514784,
0.0081350226,
-0.0041287923,
0.0177227929,
-0.0021831214,
0.0453619137,
-0.0191891976,
0.0035146626,
-0.0144864842,
0.0076823696,
0.0062428447,
0.0253080297,
-0.0179595761,
0.0646641627,
0.0201957673,
0.0245425496,
0.0000018992,
-0.0526183136,
0.0298577007,
-0.0218456089,
-0.0474564619,
-0.0264956001,
0.0476654395,
-0.030573627,
0.0060862764,
0.0302602723,
-0.0492481999,
-0.0317018069,
0.0432718061,
0.0125249121,
0.0387859233,
0.0298998263,
-0.0056018247,
0.0555478297,
-0.0130475722,
0.010836524,
0.0115161361,
-0.0154783502,
0.0420424752,
0.001245208,
0.0708166808,
-0.0274092089,
0.0293330643,
0.0475971363,
0.0334473737,
-0.0197965987,
-0.0288455021,
0.0285473447,
-0.027649736,
-0.0478924736,
0.0142428894,
0.0546835028,
0.0205997527,
-0.0254455656,
0.0081737479,
-0.019148143,
0.0220792256,
0.08226832,
-0.0534685776,
-0.0181803778,
-0.0131261339,
0.0071031232,
-0.0124028744,
-0.0201747976,
0.0370627828,
0.0193988495,
-0.0216267221,
0.0846574903,
-0.0073096603,
-0.0166434534,
-0.0639172792,
-0.0123347845,
-0.0272152573,
-0.0840931758,
0.0062627755,
0.0518400818,
-0.0641126931,
0.0353802554,
-0.0834146738,
0.0166762006,
0.0235152412,
-0.0607588887,
0.0285705123,
0.0174840111,
-0.0288536269,
0.0511019342,
0.0140820658,
-0.0116783967,
0.0046482123,
-0.0081226574,
-0.0326218829,
0.002270112,
-0.0119328629,
-0.0085310852,
-0.0154817114,
-0.0220151134,
-0.0384154543,
-0.0153348614,
0.0155727193,
0.0519545935,
0.0102513768,
0.044011727,
-0.029296238,
-0.0188526977,
-0.012361588,
-0.0353162624,
-0.0252171829,
-0.0221271981,
-0.0066028014,
0.0449079163,
-0.0143060535,
-0.0572562777,
0.0007554694,
0.0236891638,
0.0108000077,
-0.0336534008,
-0.0259369425,
0.0908570215,
0.027547108,
0.0161928311,
-0.0794892684,
-0.0583317801,
0.0102605149,
-0.067790471,
-0.0255826358,
-0.0706372932,
0.0383673385,
0.0461398885,
-0.033572007,
-0.0495867096,
0.0000152017,
0.0056271595,
-0.0413841344,
0.0708481818,
-0.0235489942,
0.0418639295,
0.017801661,
0.0239019264,
0.0052662105,
0.0690256134,
-0.0040719095,
-0.0013226004,
0.0179488026,
-0.0166630726,
0.0340560712,
0.0826194808,
-0.0223508701,
0.0463392958,
-0.0527711362,
-0.0012922899,
0.0064924206,
0.0167554691,
-0.0034586727,
0.0374964364,
-0.0350930877,
-0.0002137469,
0.0751291215,
0.0385476239,
0.0157530103,
0.018832488,
0.0587728322,
0.0195884947,
-0.0061361277,
0.0712405145,
-0.067397587,
-0.0252203196,
-0.0663899034,
-0.0010952558,
-0.0110682454,
0.026828289,
-0.006206098,
-0.0404732637,
-0.0464634113,
-0.0262616668,
0.0000019345,
0.0166943073,
0.0553475693,
-0.010738397,
-0.0000414796,
0.0191966873,
0.0086108129,
-0.0379046351,
0.0055652373,
-0.0327748731,
-0.0042780666,
0.0967236757,
0.0584960468,
-0.0253472254,
-0.0344306938,
0.0209322721,
0.0109157721,
0.004044069,
0.0529448986,
-0.0122106476,
0.0127132069,
-0.0445051976,
-0.0276211202,
0.0562152416,
0.01097426,
-0.0281318221,
0.0373283401,
-0.0220822394,
0.0156962108,
-0.0408640467,
-0.0140937474,
0.0274099391,
-0.0232320074,
-0.0038518892,
-0.0413779877,
0.001090929,
-0.0011766874,
-0.0029586127,
0.0015847308,
-0.0009475427,
0.0306739602,
0.003980597,
-0.0434975736,
0.0447021648,
-0.0461760275,
-0.0083269756,
0.0393786244,
0.0513679795,
-0.0346823148,
-0.0030156167,
0.0106502464,
-0.0449499935,
-0.0068135089,
-0.0084226467,
0.0823989287,
-0.0184437837,
0.0453045331,
-0.010220754,
0.0148109887,
-0.0381587148,
0.0434507653,
-0.0130193001,
0.0258919727,
0.0281144753,
-0.0249679834,
-0.0317237973,
-0.0367546901,
-0.0308023114,
0.0162197798,
0.0228961483,
0.0276839156,
-0.0001756563,
0.0032393329,
-0.0247519426,
-0.0155319776,
-0.0921199322,
-0.0144241014,
0.0005442173,
0.0153891239,
0.0249163993,
0.0158196706,
-0.0445985757,
0.0021561664,
0.0175355878,
0.0018466173,
0.0132175004,
0.0267034937,
0.0122494791,
0.0092586046,
-0.0424774177,
-0.0197640397,
-0.014595815,
-0.0199511405,
0.048290953,
0.0111415386,
-0.0713219419,
-0.0573834702,
0.0868823677,
-0.0263067484,
0.041097194,
0.0023088194,
0.0139082782,
0.0006312808,
-0.0159784183,
0.0283767451,
0.0251624342,
-0.0691492185,
0.0454958826,
0.0825794265,
-0.0343731157,
-0.0850014463,
-0.0288642291,
0.0177222826,
-0.0226242132,
-0.0465611741,
-0.0329033546,
-0.0073444233,
0.0307378471,
0.0254786331,
0.0118478611,
0.0087625962,
0.0213646516,
-0.0292260945,
-0.055617407,
0.0078511294,
-0.0478742495,
-0.0462872833,
0.0890862346,
-0.0001811087,
-0.0611856133,
0.0800075158,
-0.0436031744,
-0.0078024981,
0.0169514101,
-0.0333252512,
-0.0003395473,
0.0307932831,
0.0070325756,
-0.005995193,
0.0048658135,
-0.0356469154,
-0.0275414828,
-0.0200582761,
0.0146660963,
-0.0227326378,
0.0448470674,
-0.0782765299,
0.029400697,
-0.0192350913,
-0.0135021713,
-0.0335868038,
-0.0411027856,
-0.0080952691,
-0.0049284925,
0.0120040076,
-0.0464885011,
-0.0142213665,
0.0139648868,
0.0300980527,
0.0508477949,
0.0082696499,
-0.0089548938,
-0.0268281195,
0.0191422496,
0.0348586403,
0.02420206,
-0.0020078945,
-0.0321738459,
0.0203932524,
0.0342683643,
0.0549277291,
-0.0331386104,
-0.0253852904,
-0.0066503575,
0.0574661791,
0.0061903805,
-0.0322802961,
0.0594299696,
0.0120709799,
-0.0709738582,
0.0176926572,
0.1089873761,
0.045338802,
-0.0451524258,
-0.0083913291,
-0.0510228723,
-0.0041362229,
0.0115450351,
0.0255699847,
-0.1059634089,
-0.0058568432,
0.040392071,
0.0077040629,
-0.0087517845,
-0.0395220071,
-0.0067155804,
-0.0927421972,
0.0610950403,
0.0201911367,
-0.0185620449,
0.0202204548,
-0.0154741285,
0.0446118861,
0.0006552092,
0.0465800725,
-0.0057597142,
-0.0200935602,
-0.0294282623,
0.0078509767,
-0.0358727016,
-0.0906108916,
-0.0119879637,
-0.0235538222,
0.0575420856,
0.0474352576,
-0.0138248345,
-0.0008042136,
0.0144766085,
0.0880791247,
0.0530016981,
0.0224373601,
-0.0384483896,
0.0047422769,
0.0207078047,
0.0018086691,
-0.0168562084,
0.0234028995,
-0.0254305992,
-0.0204700269,
0.0263754632,
0.1064628363,
-0.0578237697,
-0.002732201,
-0.0003885535,
-0.0339863412,
0.0130308112,
0.0677318797,
0.0611268654,
-0.0353604257,
-0.0087504238,
-0.0081213359,
-0.0605526716,
0.0076134023,
-0.016146414,
-0.0100095151,
0.0022046198,
0.0012289282,
-0.0454798043,
-0.0785341263,
0.0892256498,
0.0229157284,
0.0194383021,
0.0265991334,
0.0015008834,
-0.0118492115,
-0.0099864686,
0.0189768579,
-0.0413991287,
0.0254963059,
-0.0088218367,
0.0337624103,
0.0005744159,
-0.0266522821,
0.0207183063,
0.0173377953,
-0.0281467475,
-0.1019607857,
0.0131715108,
-0.0008383035,
0.0434396751,
0.0443704501,
-0.0213553458,
-0.0902937576,
-0.023244435,
0.0479942523,
-0.0265346169,
0.0213230383,
0.008305259,
-0.0096810339,
0.0083848154,
0.0414263867,
0.0003675268,
-0.0139850574,
-0.012371337,
0.030466862,
-0.0735585019,
-0.054182101,
0.0307807568,
0.0162331816,
0.002625915,
-0.0004160695,
-0.0150181325,
-0.0394562446,
0.0126886489,
0.0079631498,
-0.029658379,
-0.0475026444,
0.0056616599,
-0.0175987594,
0.023670854,
0.01920381,
-0.0047016023,
-0.0392765701,
0.0464113876,
-0.0470516458,
0.022117801,
0.0101060085,
-0.0245122276,
0.0650590584,
0.0132145165,
-0.0040666764,
0.0380003117,
0.0017070719,
0.0206093658,
0.0056259236,
0.0599358268,
-0.0008469276,
0.0026004829,
-0.0231497381,
-0.0081119863,
-0.0155164152,
-0.0770380124,
-0.0032917445,
0.0522410758,
0.0400187857,
-0.0311704203,
0.0762579665,
-0.028792141,
-0.0048522134,
-0.0334543847,
0.0230435114,
0.01012858,
-0.0233817566,
0.0250937287,
0.0436628796,
-0.0494251922,
0.0270562991,
0.0576972216,
-0.0117414501,
0.048141934,
-0.033054661,
-0.0347331427,
-0.0109252306,
-0.0498766974,
0.0390647613,
-0.0159827918,
-0.0523263142,
-0.0134416642,
-0.0698756352,
-0.086910069,
-0.0459316075,
0.021791216,
-0.0304703191,
-0.0422619618,
-0.0187118407,
0.0616430454,
0.0137383919,
0.0216627792,
-0.0231425222,
-0.0013823721,
-0.0012913137,
-0.0098894369,
-0.0371756814,
-6.100943516e-33,
-0.0583066866,
-0.0802733451,
0.0460266024,
-0.0279413871,
0.0176997483,
-0.0088709434,
-0.0330558345,
0.0304497145,
-0.0070850113,
-0.011360663,
-0.0138121825,
0.0007695255,
0.0249189287,
-0.0323305354,
0.0272130296,
0.0013666038,
0.0254656374,
0.0364958271,
-0.0233999994,
-0.0094269421,
0.055243168,
-0.0062387618,
0.0459695719,
-0.0744809434,
0.060134083,
-0.0307696294,
-0.003492794,
0.0263459459,
-0.0515163429,
0.0610127412,
-0.0177029166,
0.0562428311,
0.0268991534,
-0.0065307496,
-0.053289149,
0.0319054127,
-0.043285232,
-0.0128466459,
0.0687233806,
0.0280750897,
0.0013543251,
-0.0097671207,
0.0454411395,
-0.002182038,
-0.0107246526,
0.0358312801,
0.0240996238,
-0.0250867419,
-0.0122599769,
0.0066687958,
-0.0449830592,
0.0344647318,
0.0207679942,
-0.0405793376,
0.0115103303,
0.025989756,
0.0044536069,
-0.0451838933,
-0.0327028669,
0.0236796904,
0.0455922112,
0.0248018689,
0.0977007076,
0.0057086479,
-0.0135731697,
0.0440352857,
0.0076192487,
-0.021123752,
0.0063423845,
-0.0363914445,
0.0434701182,
0.0400087163,
-0.0075375941,
0.0356868692,
-0.0419077799,
0.007272535,
0.0060410756,
0.0184893347,
-0.0098586613,
0.0621125847,
0.0379554592,
0.0283446051,
-0.0429578274,
-0.0503897704,
-0.0322405659,
0.0063548619,
-0.042808339,
-0.0200646315,
0.0337949656,
-0.0012661691,
0.00420711,
0.0133114839,
0.0317503102,
-0.0210229494,
-0.0344752781,
-0.0020412898,
0.0094154282,
0.0241480563,
-0.0057919598,
0.01192501,
-0.0166977439,
-0.0123603456,
-0.0090169478,
-0.0165212099,
0.0222256053,
0.0004613143,
-0.0002879769,
0.0458233096,
-0.0511856228,
-0.0026459387,
-0.0546242334,
0.0250688586,
0.0008893682,
-0.0217316784,
0.0829717368,
-0.0238038599,
-0.0180196315,
0.0224501118,
0.0075721671,
-0.0525768958,
-0.0558879152,
0.0087255966,
-0.0292428974,
-0.0153278215,
-0.0300027486,
-0.0019992825,
-0.0120111611,
-0.002701608,
0.0788236782,
0.0115933912,
-0.0001030123,
-0.0069688177,
2.647e-7,
0.0372303203,
0.0222574212,
0.0160944294,
0.017271081,
-0.009053125,
0.0331422761,
-0.0449507684,
-0.0090762489,
0.0231003407,
0.0023226219,
0.0432947204,
0.0134664858,
0.0465766415,
0.0416281074,
-0.0470161475,
0.0005622535,
-0.024266813,
-0.024265239,
-0.062404491,
-0.0170545038,
0.0379976481,
0.0290205572,
0.0242240336,
-0.0057047042,
-0.0260889828,
-0.1010705829,
0.0193244945,
-0.0772601515,
-0.0327707566,
0.0008299174,
0.0280302316,
0.0180176087,
0.032375399,
0.0428933613,
0.01465471,
0.0218929425,
-0.0072706267,
0.0951135084,
0.0024808208,
0.0197066851,
0.0012752321,
-0.0404628888,
-0.0194316376,
-0.0385959595,
0.067273967,
-0.0643053427,
-0.0121818054,
-0.0047281571,
0.0232103374,
-0.0497060642,
-0.0186478607,
-0.0007628341,
0.0031433818,
0.0220876262,
0.0167231876,
-0.0010649284,
-0.0291898288,
-0.0369353779,
-0.0502002947,
0.0732769445,
-0.0502259955,
-0.0875281468,
-0.0076264292,
-0.0041501084,
-0.0263450481,
-0.0544484071,
-0.0147588374,
2.552330221e-34,
0.0239983462,
0.0386331044,
0.0253914893,
0.0632991418,
0.0283407178,
0.0088354601,
0.0060326005,
0.0540916771,
0.0162709821,
-0.0675951913,
-0.0209993888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12304v1 | COT: A Generative Approach for Hate Speech Counter-Narratives via Contrastive Optimal Transport | 2024-06-18T06:24:26 | 2024-06-18T06:24:26 | Linhao Zhang, Li Jin, Guangluan Xu, Xiaoyu Li, Xian Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68U15, I.2.7 | Counter-narratives, which are direct responses consisting of non-aggressive
fact-based arguments, have emerged as a highly effective approach to combat the
proliferation of hate speech. Previous methodologies have primarily focused on
fine-tuning and post-editing techniques to ensure the fluency of generated
contents, while overlooking the critical aspects of individualization and
relevance concerning the specific hatred targets, such as LGBT groups,
immigrants, etc. This research paper introduces a novel framework based on
contrastive optimal transport, which effectively addresses the challenges of
maintaining target interaction and promoting diversification in generating
counter-narratives. Firstly, an Optimal Transport Kernel (OTK) module is
leveraged to incorporate hatred target information in the token
representations, in which the comparison pairs are extracted between original
and transported features. Secondly, a self-contrastive learning module is
employed to address the issue of model degeneration. This module achieves this
by generating an anisotropic distribution of token representations. Finally, a
target-oriented search method is integrated as an improved decoding strategy to
explicitly promote domain relevance and diversification in the inference
process. This strategy modifies the model's confidence score by considering
both token similarity and target relevance. Quantitative and qualitative
experiments have been evaluated on two benchmark datasets, which demonstrate
that our proposed model significantly outperforms current methods evaluated by
metrics from multiple aspects. | [
0.0389925092,
0.0572188236,
-0.0291470289,
0.0460634008,
-0.0544700399,
-0.000670979,
0.0222389903,
-0.0115760602,
-0.0369495898,
-0.0369180925,
0.0289718676,
-0.0324081555,
-0.0345011726,
0.0454886965,
-0.0010167558,
-0.0697364211,
0.0225053895,
0.0546756126,
0.030920038,
-0.0370819531,
0.0003087477,
0.0120970672,
-0.026303092,
0.0361369886,
-0.0714285299,
0.0047101523,
0.0409015939,
0.0143716047,
0.076834172,
-0.0105936946,
0.0422695242,
0.0275224727,
0.0285718124,
0.0372017734,
0.0000020556,
-0.0458164103,
-0.038831763,
0.0018397027,
-0.0014269334,
-0.0792795792,
0.0913363993,
-0.0204980783,
-0.0082337093,
0.0148805156,
-0.0052174092,
0.0165342521,
0.0636050627,
0.0941587463,
0.0792810246,
0.0744045824,
-0.0099244798,
-0.065892823,
-0.0023279518,
0.0108140642,
-0.0172719955,
0.026019251,
0.01521366,
-0.0236163903,
-0.0731269866,
-0.0014028528,
-0.043571502,
0.0289276689,
0.0215330347,
0.0429611169,
0.0592946671,
-0.0087918509,
-0.0258719251,
-0.005309199,
0.0002927609,
0.0576772913,
-0.014917965,
0.0114413602,
0.0177846178,
-0.0084763961,
-0.0120210927,
-0.027490681,
-0.017780263,
-0.0144094024,
-0.0220188648,
0.0372062922,
0.0089558521,
0.023856163,
0.0272461493,
0.0247830413,
0.0001573688,
-0.0195799209,
-0.0078091808,
-0.0135495272,
-0.0124667324,
-0.0188915748,
-0.0131606786,
-0.0021938782,
0.0302695334,
-0.0000738232,
0.0017950649,
0.004135279,
-0.0288297404,
-0.0636888146,
-0.0207008738,
-0.0709075928,
0.0323538817,
0.0577287823,
-0.0378001779,
-0.02214236,
0.0031719841,
0.0258929841,
-0.0140000368,
0.0014222079,
-0.0072048171,
-0.0155923916,
-0.0486013554,
-0.0001636856,
-0.0167642292,
0.0212989468,
-0.0287985224,
0.0423495658,
-0.0267484337,
-0.0121760126,
-0.0496712103,
-0.0372955985,
-0.0372440331,
0.0388973653,
-0.0011973436,
0.0010391237,
-0.0203009602,
0.0361783504,
-0.0552860163,
-0.0059597972,
-0.0413994379,
-0.0331914015,
0.0032915566,
0.0379702486,
-0.0011157626,
-0.0493606776,
0.000358064,
0.0904603451,
-0.0028340698,
-0.0074816849,
-0.0250596907,
-0.0235445686,
-0.0372888446,
-0.0632613823,
0.026186578,
-0.0688244849,
0.0148746623,
-0.0073842169,
-0.0340316482,
-0.0860742554,
-0.0153956618,
-0.0060838363,
-0.0527593531,
0.0560224503,
0.0706696883,
-0.0149101987,
0.0654726028,
0.0325632542,
0.015651226,
0.0415405519,
0.006872009,
0.0500667393,
0.0234301798,
-0.0064694062,
-0.0128236292,
-0.0057673198,
0.067473121,
0.019596111,
-0.0608662851,
0.0254623871,
-0.0378427841,
0.0097618019,
0.0624467321,
0.0564295016,
-0.0441396646,
-0.090267919,
0.0219176412,
0.0762844607,
-0.0206318107,
0.0132260406,
0.0585211739,
0.0399022996,
-0.0542332567,
0.0198236909,
-0.0244533494,
0.0022497734,
0.0006718164,
-0.0521474145,
0.0495359935,
0.0666501969,
-0.0209941417,
-0.0247207843,
-0.0059931991,
0.0026740467,
0.032248266,
-0.0439686663,
0.026752172,
0.0316469707,
-0.0211127754,
0.015151144,
0.0446160622,
-0.0165536013,
0.001714728,
-0.0602575131,
-0.0061678453,
0.0333180949,
0.0179113969,
0.0236764587,
-0.0106787635,
-0.0552567393,
-0.0321514942,
0.0524048693,
0.0149585567,
-0.0093501164,
0.0037126788,
-0.0294721499,
-0.0189467203,
0.0131093105,
0.0245168768,
0.0341547579,
0.0134163294,
0.018064836,
0.0218275841,
0.0024106214,
-0.0148743903,
0.029426109,
0.0501422174,
-0.0326939449,
0.018068064,
0.0318687707,
0.0606660433,
0.0343802534,
-0.0148394005,
-0.0487275347,
0.0005698948,
-0.0102470033,
-0.0355715416,
0.0282068346,
-0.0488087758,
-0.0274881776,
-0.0021861678,
-0.0936386138,
-0.0225325357,
0.0581126474,
-0.0058186003,
0.0256383121,
0.0986424088,
-0.0032520669,
0.0146350674,
-0.0271978863,
-0.0341029055,
-0.021001054,
0.024458956,
-0.020386057,
0.0866492018,
0.0064033363,
-0.0110374866,
0.0096432064,
-0.0357482359,
0.0424258523,
0.0220827255,
0.0004714821,
-0.0169944819,
-0.0229722634,
0.0228693169,
-0.012205827,
-0.0285803266,
-0.0064978972,
0.0072118035,
-0.0509366505,
-0.0011874881,
-0.0189971905,
-0.026237011,
0.0056680548,
-0.0295359865,
-0.0035440247,
0.0250283889,
-0.0005679719,
-0.0588114075,
0.0373774245,
0.0000850693,
0.0014950273,
-0.0302715134,
-0.0037311818,
-0.0298825409,
-0.0138700539,
-0.0271951649,
0.0458783843,
-0.025035765,
-0.012871136,
0.0333108082,
-0.038196981,
-0.0411276296,
0.0058054137,
-0.0079412507,
-0.0436926298,
0.0140246954,
0.0448456518,
0.0408697985,
-0.0075611826,
0.0722540542,
0.0663119406,
0.0228465889,
-0.0232014284,
-0.0412263051,
0.0073735383,
-0.0487530194,
0.0424643122,
-0.0332037061,
-0.072229512,
-0.0109611712,
0.0737782493,
0.0796943903,
-0.0155621096,
-0.104222618,
0.0253501553,
-0.0608308762,
-0.034072157,
-0.0193092395,
-0.0467759967,
-0.0069637457,
-0.0235928167,
-0.0393504649,
-0.025056472,
0.0978969783,
0.0128505286,
0.0435604528,
-0.0216314867,
-0.0142597146,
0.009072436,
0.0622814745,
0.0006047901,
0.0545290783,
0.0144651132,
0.0042227288,
0.006408928,
-0.0375078842,
0.0090747504,
-0.0123380544,
-0.0092054484,
-0.0181899387,
0.0042777928,
0.0228347462,
-0.0392978638,
-0.0628446266,
-0.0802942216,
-0.0113360407,
-0.0418524817,
0.0070953043,
-0.0147820897,
-0.055766739,
0.0224197228,
0.0279635582,
0.0073916996,
0.0012787273,
-0.0095609846,
0.0340507403,
-0.0069988398,
-0.0050451495,
-0.0111217061,
0.0464490429,
0.0105569009,
-0.0159242824,
0.0556141548,
-0.01354683,
-0.0087800212,
0.0022328608,
0.0144559909,
-0.0069636013,
0.0233570989,
0.0103827808,
-0.0402490012,
0.0438418277,
-0.0099402228,
-0.0138378339,
0.0712544024,
0.0035097746,
0.0281769466,
0.0121273771,
-0.0073508793,
0.01439262,
-0.0086544855,
0.0093975505,
-0.0753166825,
0.0061522224,
-0.0286951568,
0.0416226946,
-0.0891730115,
-0.0463130027,
-0.0079135979,
-0.0549353436,
0.0550650582,
0.0074768215,
-0.0227412023,
-0.0479219705,
-0.0301135741,
0.0169480201,
-0.0036738308,
-0.0000958282,
-0.0255161021,
0.0338208377,
0.000899077,
0.0210868288,
-0.0390518196,
-0.0103500597,
0.0054424903,
-0.0125119807,
0.028710572,
0.0357702523,
0.0634242222,
0.0026930608,
0.003959585,
-0.0202364866,
-0.0319171809,
-0.0160295554,
-0.0549785681,
0.0593978241,
-0.0176385697,
-0.0345815495,
-0.0252574608,
0.0589030609,
0.0137732979,
-0.0418894961,
0.0002655324,
0.0650315881,
-0.0009139507,
-0.0158648677,
-0.0754538253,
0.0222818777,
0.0108899977,
0.1086982265,
0.0231668595,
-0.0200626627,
0.0386786126,
-0.0840403065,
0.0167101528,
-0.0625262186,
-0.0939917266,
-0.0254816748,
-0.0160924867,
-0.0196082816,
-0.0434572697,
-0.047576718,
-0.0144489277,
0.0527645759,
-0.0171131995,
-0.0206920058,
-0.0566606224,
-0.0454710312,
-0.0792820528,
0.0032453407,
-0.0037467433,
0.0284656826,
0.0296029374,
0.014134597,
-0.0113742603,
-0.0438660719,
-0.0557546988,
0.0321049616,
-0.0300671849,
-0.0667432472,
0.0500217453,
0.0391851515,
0.0207749214,
0.0277817938,
0.0001870495,
-0.0421094894,
0.076263018,
0.0527803116,
-0.0070147808,
0.0131208496,
0.0351356342,
-0.0333912037,
0.0054343133,
0.0080336463,
0.0137789799,
0.0687952563,
0.0449178703,
0.0085386066,
-0.0384946056,
0.0150628565,
-0.0030458267,
-0.0558497235,
0.0536148958,
0.0040817722,
-0.0472639315,
-0.0440432802,
-0.0044734455,
-0.0219969172,
-0.0400731079,
-0.0151926875,
0.0018546055,
0.0138772558,
0.0231934618,
-0.0431634076,
-0.04890953,
-0.0390827395,
0.0356083624,
-0.0340212546,
0.0322295316,
0.0317266881,
0.0268354956,
0.0043746005,
0.0137745542,
-0.0226096697,
-0.0075027938,
0.0006223449,
0.0036736333,
-0.0130415102,
-0.0021357369,
0.0480065532,
0.0123726651,
0.0435410216,
-0.0458579212,
-0.0253936797,
0.004303013,
-0.0513315797,
-0.0412782617,
-0.0155602451,
-0.0129948119,
0.0160633251,
0.0061601251,
-0.018346075,
0.0011956887,
0.004886372,
-0.012847784,
-0.0167056695,
0.0168133583,
0.0353317373,
-0.0097014895,
-0.0019712469,
0.0135981115,
-0.0426279269,
0.0747864917,
0.0120626334,
-0.0402783379,
-0.0412544422,
-0.0189218838,
0.0139856078,
0.0294744223,
0.0388788134,
0.000711175,
-0.0712529048,
-0.045684807,
0.0441266075,
-0.0253190715,
0.0174903814,
-0.0097451797,
0.0235056486,
0.065313004,
0.0032496615,
-0.0141540579,
-0.0064615849,
0.0142117143,
0.010572914,
-0.0249242391,
0.0299339108,
-6.524790779e-33,
-0.0115246512,
-0.035730999,
-0.0073147067,
-0.032568641,
-0.0230940245,
-0.0053005787,
0.0115806591,
-0.0105077857,
-0.0157587808,
0.0302212127,
0.0300514642,
0.022375932,
0.0170293916,
0.0234260429,
-0.0490872078,
0.0286753681,
0.0588047355,
0.0114500048,
-0.0149506172,
0.0113460124,
0.0524020232,
0.0198058337,
0.0310760122,
-0.0675930977,
0.0322653204,
-0.0207337514,
-0.0021283652,
0.0023478828,
0.0443943962,
0.0535082743,
-0.0245797429,
0.0642689839,
0.0338921957,
-0.0202155672,
0.0109235626,
0.0129244942,
-0.0456454679,
-0.030485943,
0.0369952433,
-0.0360173285,
0.0052179275,
-0.035408657,
0.0248444416,
0.0024417366,
-0.0428655334,
-0.0152324131,
0.0383802876,
-0.0212327819,
0.0238334015,
0.0085529787,
-0.0889638737,
0.0436405018,
-0.0493381172,
0.0208713785,
-0.0011796096,
0.0628597587,
0.0478057191,
-0.0076574818,
-0.0692682341,
0.0281573515,
-0.035545554,
-0.0276878588,
0.016537359,
0.000124977,
0.0127064278,
0.0695290565,
0.0243690703,
0.0021023795,
-0.027215831,
0.0142062465,
0.0303225853,
0.0274465606,
0.0306904763,
0.0937507749,
0.0187657438,
-0.0772367641,
-0.0528426543,
-0.0028154019,
-0.0048864963,
-0.0152634671,
0.0381302498,
0.0086726267,
-0.0467479192,
-0.024600653,
-0.0497139618,
-0.0732918531,
-0.007682696,
-0.052745536,
0.0191884413,
0.0083357608,
-0.0493667908,
0.0108083216,
0.0442896225,
0.0261452217,
0.0235778932,
0.0285604764,
-0.0269677863,
0.0056773676,
0.0255637001,
0.0486734584,
-0.0456488132,
0.0132592563,
0.0214197692,
-0.0125757745,
0.0395439081,
-0.003711615,
0.059684068,
0.0136586223,
-0.0644410253,
0.0205288585,
-0.0120552396,
0.0190322939,
-0.0536605567,
-0.0060435184,
0.0121067828,
0.0770648867,
-0.006498225,
-0.0173766837,
0.053671971,
-0.0400224663,
-0.029534122,
0.0190219097,
-0.0214780997,
0.0286085978,
-0.0162758417,
-0.0088903029,
0.0185260382,
0.0358426496,
0.0500075556,
-0.1154123172,
-0.0120342616,
-0.0168581922,
2.748e-7,
-0.0041279108,
0.0120501053,
0.0142770233,
-0.0152529683,
-0.0153490994,
0.0436231382,
0.059768647,
0.0152165014,
0.0193776172,
-0.0286818258,
-0.0225729737,
0.0980193466,
0.009203746,
0.0566876531,
0.0038745643,
0.0344455466,
-0.0301757734,
-0.0316970199,
-0.0428391248,
0.0275147595,
0.037914373,
0.0745712668,
0.0688944757,
-0.0247914195,
-0.0119047696,
0.0377537943,
0.0281953085,
-0.0243174806,
-0.0146200974,
-0.0210195687,
0.0092960596,
-0.0146009289,
0.0140468823,
0.0035503707,
-0.0039341049,
0.0224075988,
-0.0005781843,
0.0189062729,
0.0214383025,
-0.0595477298,
0.0041794479,
0.0033834551,
-0.0253577102,
-0.0332220383,
0.0190315749,
-0.0194933843,
-0.0195603259,
-0.0456531718,
-0.0524373576,
0.0410138145,
0.0140788704,
-0.0053760204,
-0.036731936,
-0.0087417578,
0.035212595,
0.0241286289,
0.0176244229,
-0.0898577124,
0.0037659302,
0.0274050981,
-0.0385928489,
-0.0181147102,
-0.0156249218,
-0.0142582227,
0.0541381128,
0.0288822092,
0.0347543471,
2.388421768e-34,
0.0453644097,
0.0047698123,
-0.0286504161,
-0.0685383826,
0.0415302962,
0.018275097,
-0.0169384144,
0.0009983707,
0.0559862517,
-0.0239292104,
-0.0309192222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12295v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12295v1 | Fast and Slow Generating: An Empirical Study on Large and Small Language Models Collaborative Decoding | 2024-06-18T05:59:28 | 2024-06-18T05:59:28 | Kaiyan Zhang, Jianyu Wang, Ning Ding, Biqing Qi, Ermo Hua, Xingtai Lv, Bowen Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive performance in diverse
applications, yet they face significant drawbacks, including high inference
latency, expensive training cost, and generation of hallucination.
Collaborative decoding between large and small language models (SLMs) offers a
novel approach to address these challenges. Inspired by dual-process cognitive
theory, we integrate these methods into a unified framework termed Fast and
Slow Generating (FS-GEN). This paper explores several techniques within the
FS-GEN framework, including speculative decoding, contrastive decoding, and
emulator or proxy fine-tuning. We provide a comprehensive analysis of these
methodologies, offering insights into their similarities and differences under
this framework. Our study delves into the differential knowledge capabilities
of LLMs versus SLMs through the FS-GEN lens, revealing that fewer than 20% of
collaborative interactions are required across various methods. These
interactions adhere to a scaling law relative to the parameter ratios, thereby
facilitating predictable collaboration. Furthermore, we investigate the
specific positions where collaboration is most effective from an uncertainty
perspective, yielding novel insights that could refine FS-GEN methods. Our
findings reveal that the essential difference between models of different sizes
lies in the uncertainty of the next token prediction, where interventions by
larger models are most needed to assist the smaller ones. Code for
Reproduction: https://github.com/TsinghuaC3I/FS-GEN | [
0.0212850366,
0.0911658332,
-0.0174939316,
0.0174037311,
-0.0399264731,
0.0253752712,
0.0296520498,
-0.0097387433,
-0.0411165841,
-0.0206111092,
-0.0368017629,
-0.1022438779,
0.0284105074,
0.0205756724,
0.0117027881,
-0.0464245006,
0.0314659849,
-0.0665685087,
0.0178615823,
-0.0240449775,
-0.0460874885,
0.014315485,
0.0105925296,
0.0736686215,
0.0239005834,
-0.004867685,
-0.0026992522,
0.0191594865,
0.0006696514,
-0.0180161707,
-0.0072070109,
0.0738360509,
0.0095391842,
0.0982443988,
0.0000019291,
-0.0404984616,
0.009250436,
0.0047304262,
-0.0013024755,
0.0245924741,
0.0442759916,
-0.0162221361,
-0.0139238583,
0.0142089417,
-0.0111873066,
-0.0787024796,
0.0689641312,
0.0221453588,
0.009994396,
0.0465753451,
0.0067147114,
-0.0498478971,
0.0161429718,
-0.0215906184,
-0.0316666737,
-0.0220972802,
0.0341198146,
-0.0009496345,
-0.0436214954,
-0.0174599085,
-0.0149595235,
0.0259433575,
0.0180197842,
0.011296751,
-0.024324853,
0.0457180031,
-0.0134608345,
-0.0643861964,
-0.0024904178,
0.0394450985,
-0.0289269015,
-0.0242702458,
-0.0068613202,
0.0054817707,
-0.0071264496,
-0.0000102729,
-0.0300312825,
0.0259449668,
-0.0311738886,
0.0576613024,
0.0443052202,
0.0071456837,
0.0385146625,
-0.0132552302,
-0.0462764949,
0.0271978471,
0.02023701,
-0.0110623594,
-0.0106515149,
0.0255855657,
-0.0416296609,
-0.0382519141,
0.0051224655,
0.0050757974,
-0.0412564315,
-0.0121233957,
-0.0243250653,
-0.0680004358,
0.0010052439,
-0.0338381231,
0.0512766466,
0.0447498783,
0.0205345452,
0.0068139653,
-0.0459639318,
0.0077579189,
0.0035890795,
0.0158199351,
-0.036675103,
-0.0116248,
-0.0469012484,
0.0007539867,
-0.0476139672,
0.0256183408,
-0.0340974107,
-0.0275108721,
-0.0503368601,
-0.0032782613,
-0.0072904471,
0.0162297152,
0.0309706461,
0.0070735733,
-0.0297114998,
-0.0125542171,
0.0254947208,
0.0535767637,
-0.0161845349,
0.0216554739,
0.0133110592,
-0.0519070253,
-0.0141889425,
0.0085768569,
-0.0046020988,
-0.0074611916,
-0.0224617571,
0.0677915439,
-0.0212497357,
-0.0014074839,
-0.0214660056,
-0.0118709756,
0.0004612305,
-0.0739409328,
0.0009902401,
-0.0642392784,
-0.0042564543,
0.0318116508,
0.0115288403,
-0.0600574911,
0.0208753422,
-0.0198464226,
-0.0259023942,
0.0733708367,
-0.0169449355,
0.0138779366,
0.02555204,
0.0252137929,
-0.0250451751,
0.1140852049,
0.0266220383,
0.0357145183,
0.0014640641,
0.004532156,
-0.0061928546,
0.0467485227,
0.0159149356,
-0.0068155406,
-0.0245332159,
-0.047240369,
0.0353530794,
0.0172995627,
0.057346411,
0.0753351226,
-0.0547508262,
0.0076096314,
0.0814394206,
0.0375944786,
0.0386299044,
0.0670440495,
0.0665383637,
0.0277494229,
-0.0036261226,
0.0240463018,
-0.0248277579,
0.0172060244,
-0.0139077501,
0.0218777321,
0.0335475504,
0.0753778592,
-0.0320892148,
-0.0142735252,
-0.0109790768,
-0.0219673943,
0.0093575371,
-0.0121766115,
0.0765886977,
0.0117920628,
-0.0634786859,
0.04455534,
0.009325359,
-0.022351779,
-0.0065283347,
-0.0631207451,
0.0284730215,
0.0561195761,
0.0345473625,
0.0154937105,
0.0129906284,
0.018329937,
-0.029002592,
0.0259196069,
0.034167707,
-0.0133329518,
0.0242492128,
-0.064669311,
-0.009098581,
0.0244020261,
0.0214849971,
0.018383069,
0.0129444161,
-0.0018366651,
0.0127513809,
0.0292823538,
-0.0386879221,
0.0180712901,
-0.0017862521,
0.0047457302,
0.0025858521,
-0.0106028598,
0.0276211184,
-0.0112855481,
-0.0171854608,
0.030846836,
0.0061363946,
-0.041704759,
-0.0062065236,
0.0503049009,
-0.0520123243,
-0.0558052845,
0.0005214717,
0.0256845634,
0.0367155932,
-0.0118743908,
-0.017550936,
-0.0444203541,
0.0718796775,
-0.0299661215,
0.0526095703,
-0.0407284796,
0.024955729,
-0.0013570313,
0.0175150707,
-0.0249885842,
0.0567306913,
-0.0184496995,
0.0069978251,
0.0375165083,
0.0082254289,
-0.0061963093,
-0.0224312786,
-0.0014352393,
0.0344794989,
-0.0033011707,
-0.015495006,
-0.0052189869,
-0.0032322989,
-0.0269843321,
-0.053131979,
-0.0847078636,
-0.0385098048,
-0.036233332,
0.0063561383,
0.0062264991,
0.0055884221,
-0.0104388753,
0.0125066955,
-0.003180291,
0.0394393206,
0.0151284207,
0.0293840338,
-0.0260617398,
0.0219271984,
-0.0350962393,
-0.0235973503,
-0.0100440038,
0.0195233505,
0.0603204072,
-0.0069127711,
-0.0300601367,
-0.1005050763,
0.0406205207,
-0.0011346951,
0.017814802,
0.0041412925,
-0.045926258,
0.0228692759,
-0.0180075262,
0.0575804301,
0.0263081249,
-0.0157235172,
0.0198374875,
0.0549704581,
-0.0311926045,
-0.0333942473,
-0.0087082917,
-0.022934489,
-0.0239174273,
-0.0512192734,
-0.0518008992,
-0.0495107137,
0.0955291241,
0.0330609828,
-0.0099565322,
-0.0952529982,
0.022920629,
-0.0166674182,
-0.0631697327,
-0.0021105718,
-0.0297657698,
-0.0115454998,
0.0357317999,
-0.0287995525,
-0.0618305542,
0.0800853819,
-0.0388438217,
-0.0208417606,
-0.0236411467,
0.0044271685,
-0.0134242522,
0.0621598214,
-0.00128263,
0.0201624017,
0.0010357302,
-0.0446998589,
-0.0507869311,
0.044464983,
0.0129185719,
-0.0310521498,
0.0005261891,
-0.0597118512,
-0.0047258851,
-0.0268861707,
-0.0312709399,
-0.0330882221,
-0.0206295978,
-0.0229232479,
0.0386361964,
0.0522836335,
-0.0442598127,
-0.0228573252,
0.0364285037,
-0.0274067353,
0.0324651822,
-0.0147381397,
-0.0180472992,
-0.0062260432,
0.0229585655,
0.0365311988,
0.0045326529,
0.0392744727,
-0.0677175224,
0.0429186486,
0.0539151393,
0.0702650845,
0.0125234853,
-0.0357690714,
-0.0106223002,
0.0550038218,
0.0152796851,
-0.0147098731,
0.0362490341,
0.090978615,
-0.0416050255,
-0.0339086987,
0.1269532591,
0.0017551132,
-0.0806683525,
0.0216164328,
-0.0338190757,
0.0525709651,
0.0150305741,
0.0032348505,
-0.0331180058,
-0.0198845249,
0.0282609407,
0.0206635538,
-0.0194837395,
-0.0302564949,
-0.0061558513,
-0.0930854753,
0.0556608811,
0.0435123593,
-0.0143829463,
-0.0117880534,
-0.0280343723,
-0.0134339249,
0.0128850611,
-0.0072559221,
0.0177268591,
-0.0028620944,
-0.0000609664,
0.0317458808,
-0.0112624858,
-0.0636596009,
-0.012452689,
-0.0305508468,
0.0817498788,
0.0479223803,
-0.0164642241,
0.038188003,
-0.0204157457,
0.0045210533,
-0.0467037894,
0.0167743377,
-0.03116793,
0.0267061498,
0.0108344695,
0.0217358693,
0.0030083058,
0.0362700336,
-0.0236632824,
-0.0288740825,
-0.0222270731,
0.0354178399,
-0.0331452936,
-0.0569942258,
0.024092976,
0.0178744961,
0.0418144092,
0.0853931829,
0.0520685241,
-0.0297702588,
-0.0285705663,
-0.0284415931,
0.0271042157,
-0.053668227,
-0.027529452,
0.0024221661,
0.0531625077,
-0.0194256548,
-0.0409338251,
-0.0082424451,
0.0391410477,
0.039362181,
0.006425912,
0.0511780865,
-0.0107098361,
-0.0021849854,
-0.0330839641,
0.0058097895,
-0.0036785344,
-0.0013214968,
-0.0376219898,
-0.0271344557,
-0.0007843158,
-0.0241660904,
-0.0113663096,
0.0348253772,
-0.1277671456,
-0.0805484056,
0.0036966617,
0.0417266414,
0.0305093285,
0.026887089,
-0.0107604684,
-0.0870662257,
0.0523331687,
0.0316328965,
-0.0323135071,
0.0050674365,
0.0191655234,
-0.0081435442,
0.0007706318,
0.0524752997,
-0.0026941672,
-0.0027118227,
0.0206965953,
0.0487897396,
-0.0264987499,
-0.0206182078,
-0.0003206625,
-0.0097640222,
0.0127915237,
-0.076462768,
0.007720686,
-0.0373982042,
0.017119918,
-0.0177037846,
0.0146905091,
-0.045750834,
-0.0190628357,
0.0394419432,
-0.0233865399,
0.0078973388,
-0.0125982612,
0.0405258909,
0.0179660264,
-0.0192228742,
0.0059334701,
-0.0023263714,
0.0397668742,
0.0568570644,
-0.0035681932,
-0.0199714191,
0.0050500403,
-0.0146773215,
0.032653261,
-0.031329155,
0.0441133007,
0.022303164,
0.0027095836,
-0.045540262,
0.0112803839,
-0.052750241,
-0.0777287334,
-0.0466942675,
0.0373169445,
0.0736167058,
0.015887456,
0.055062294,
-0.0525372475,
0.0033163656,
-0.0337953456,
0.0157498866,
-0.0124412626,
-0.0233309604,
-0.0038541327,
-0.0013953662,
-0.0324363559,
-0.0170191471,
0.1080224589,
0.0069515109,
0.0312125813,
-0.0144882472,
-0.0135152005,
-0.0234122481,
-0.0550815985,
-0.0302055553,
0.0448056497,
-0.0310288519,
0.0252388772,
-0.0750630349,
-0.0628396794,
-0.0187125858,
-0.0158322342,
-0.0058252704,
-0.0252517685,
0.0203496926,
0.0530689247,
-0.0229640156,
-0.0288148895,
-0.0065275291,
0.0020841884,
0.0354249515,
-0.0208744835,
-0.0368926153,
-6.566877885e-33,
-0.0167571846,
-0.0241778474,
0.0108520268,
-0.0371549651,
-0.0246215221,
-0.0032360589,
-0.0423500985,
0.0027427746,
0.0220985673,
0.004636256,
-0.015073332,
-0.0104789473,
0.0272190645,
0.0299682152,
0.0202493705,
0.0237765331,
0.0859831795,
-0.0478754304,
-0.0243686959,
0.0162442029,
0.0472319014,
0.0375535935,
0.0284647103,
-0.0221982356,
-0.0012551706,
0.0098013394,
-0.0025715223,
0.0095687341,
-0.014827475,
0.0429605842,
-0.0227748267,
0.0365387499,
0.0245918203,
-0.0243051872,
-0.0513800569,
-0.0111258365,
-0.077787675,
-0.0025264819,
0.0327268876,
0.0071718497,
-0.0362612344,
-0.0283673648,
0.0128297498,
0.0093665505,
-0.0188573059,
-0.018965207,
-0.0042545344,
-0.0419944376,
-0.0220215432,
-0.0157419275,
-0.059000425,
0.0083535844,
0.0012028363,
0.0181964636,
0.0739588737,
0.0182293989,
-0.0176514741,
0.0069631222,
-0.0890916139,
0.0140751004,
-0.0165687576,
0.0646601915,
0.0856660008,
0.049313318,
0.0125218425,
0.047920607,
0.0207711756,
-0.0078789098,
-0.0550614372,
-0.0301767569,
0.0430542827,
0.0651925355,
0.0184803978,
0.0169632267,
0.0266528893,
-0.0332808904,
-0.0494285487,
0.0108442707,
0.0140936989,
0.0350525863,
0.0827688351,
0.0310228914,
-0.0266277306,
-0.0451437943,
-0.051838886,
-0.0522614829,
-0.0286909733,
-0.0228600856,
0.0101262964,
0.0491083823,
-0.0261259247,
-0.0396558307,
0.0747014806,
-0.0269920006,
-0.0070907362,
-0.0048994888,
-0.0060187308,
0.0210048445,
-0.0132833356,
0.0152347069,
-0.0604168065,
-0.0338955224,
0.0371172726,
0.0276232958,
0.0027560794,
0.0038748148,
0.0060125627,
0.0045530763,
-0.0584415533,
0.010838666,
-0.0487361215,
0.0481777824,
0.0084593212,
-0.0094469022,
0.0552933663,
-0.007235433,
-0.0227836836,
-0.0364972726,
-0.0045645679,
0.0374338627,
0.0099657308,
0.0104706921,
0.0071539478,
0.0377388671,
-0.013768605,
0.0101299854,
-0.0407798961,
-0.0278924573,
0.0555622019,
-0.0011735191,
-0.0391343795,
0.0421584696,
2.651e-7,
0.0229308885,
0.0375082158,
0.0216851961,
0.0178184938,
0.0644135177,
0.0250813216,
0.0048365067,
0.0147432294,
0.0371000357,
-0.0045488994,
0.0012182363,
0.0484004579,
0.0771143362,
0.0326569527,
-0.0639747083,
-0.0176773425,
-0.0477344543,
0.0367576629,
-0.0395090245,
-0.0240918547,
0.0275924783,
0.0792778954,
-0.0005640562,
-0.0116686365,
0.0346580334,
-0.0012799003,
0.0568218119,
-0.0321324281,
0.0090153376,
0.0331273191,
0.0050182017,
-0.0157959182,
0.014700802,
0.038437739,
0.0118553825,
-0.0206102859,
-0.0192276333,
0.0321875587,
0.0092395106,
-0.0249392185,
0.0119555574,
0.0213824827,
-0.0110141942,
-0.0763512626,
0.0428838842,
-0.0911895856,
-0.0465804599,
0.0165053718,
0.0111311115,
-0.0234024953,
-0.0024913771,
-0.0218240041,
-0.0005399846,
0.0423154607,
-0.002878485,
0.0191673134,
-0.0119360071,
-0.0533220619,
-0.0114035495,
-0.016018929,
-0.0620584674,
-0.0817360207,
-0.053977102,
-0.0108061898,
0.02004111,
-0.0399850234,
0.0187973287,
2.760111475e-34,
0.0422894619,
-0.0120309945,
0.0040433705,
0.050815694,
0.014671132,
-0.0414306112,
-0.0030864871,
0.0459282584,
-0.0026350606,
-0.090426214,
-0.0316401757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12277v1 | What Matters in Learning Facts in Language Models? Multifaceted Knowledge Probing with Diverse Multi-Prompt Datasets | 2024-06-18T05:11:35 | 2024-06-18T05:11:35 | Xin Zhao, Naoki Yoshinaga, Daisuke Oba | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) face issues in handling factual knowledge,
making it vital to evaluate their true ability to understand facts. In this
study, we introduce knowledge probing frameworks, BELIEF(-ICL), to evaluate the
knowledge understanding ability of not only encoder-based PLMs but also
decoder-based PLMs from diverse perspectives. BELIEFs utilize a multi-prompt
dataset to evaluate PLM's accuracy, consistency, and reliability in factual
knowledge understanding. To provide a more reliable evaluation with BELIEFs, we
semi-automatically create MyriadLAMA, which has more diverse prompts than
existing datasets. We validate the effectiveness of BELIEFs in correctly and
comprehensively evaluating PLM's factual understanding ability through
extensive evaluations. We further investigate key factors in learning facts in
LLMs, and reveal the limitation of the prompt-based knowledge probing. The
dataset is anonymously publicized. | [
0.0121467793,
0.0333953872,
-0.0193394367,
0.0757289305,
-0.0350706503,
0.0068232249,
0.0069693881,
-0.052566424,
-0.0258467048,
-0.0152620096,
-0.00508954,
-0.0382212959,
0.0202209353,
0.0437737405,
0.0163081158,
-0.0080038495,
0.0617580079,
-0.0348953381,
0.0365001,
-0.0115572456,
-0.0092137186,
0.0067717964,
-0.0302271638,
0.0168373119,
-0.0318293646,
-0.0226716176,
-0.0335571542,
-0.0091882441,
0.0156153021,
-0.0373103991,
-0.0447482541,
0.035434559,
0.0575812533,
0.0413052179,
0.000001934,
-0.0525652915,
-0.0169264302,
-0.0274550896,
-0.0820405856,
0.0168887433,
0.0013134689,
-0.0101976674,
0.0243293997,
-0.004356686,
-0.0357426144,
-0.0297907162,
0.0107073439,
0.0283893701,
0.0601114929,
0.053735733,
0.0090563698,
-0.0039382316,
0.0055148876,
-0.0205911621,
0.0067986483,
-0.0016821243,
0.0422557816,
-0.0082653202,
-0.012944092,
0.025968628,
-0.0403582491,
0.0532330982,
0.0315961316,
0.0039940276,
-0.022442976,
0.0417542197,
0.031368278,
-0.0859886706,
0.0034106409,
0.0439120419,
0.0315827914,
0.0118705584,
-0.0349657163,
-0.0104704499,
0.0092684217,
0.0345322751,
-0.019793475,
0.0392403975,
-0.0359079614,
0.0355552807,
0.0186600722,
-0.0012934051,
0.0194200799,
-0.0296656247,
-0.0259959903,
0.0691219792,
0.0131319324,
-0.0335165821,
-0.0044186139,
0.0144199068,
-0.0020388796,
-0.0289318152,
-0.0154626379,
0.0141668441,
0.0006700553,
0.0584962331,
-0.021678742,
0.0270576142,
0.0220865216,
-0.0186488405,
0.0040035606,
0.0382332094,
-0.0642597079,
0.044570297,
-0.0037187682,
0.0440605767,
0.0400834121,
0.040320456,
-0.0133536486,
-0.0229611546,
-0.0337941721,
0.0030320776,
0.010656354,
0.0238662865,
0.0136504229,
0.0105493721,
-0.0171544049,
0.0176600516,
0.0044997376,
0.0655693337,
-0.002229885,
-0.0403888412,
-0.0089006452,
-0.0148327611,
-0.0663531274,
0.0892221332,
-0.0212162323,
0.0291435532,
-0.007620099,
-0.0782748237,
-0.0314110741,
0.0036033052,
-0.0025531291,
-0.0018904129,
-0.011993425,
0.0002750936,
-0.0116736498,
-0.0432470962,
-0.0406218059,
-0.0246820897,
0.0064196102,
-0.0732064843,
-0.0362412222,
-0.0703131855,
0.046399828,
0.014906276,
0.0042123948,
-0.0371356271,
0.0058323122,
0.0071726111,
0.0037814337,
0.0815838128,
-0.0121438997,
0.0186219066,
0.0071374639,
0.0234930441,
-0.0095997602,
0.0841820017,
-0.0110412808,
0.0165178739,
0.0295092445,
0.0039350903,
0.0221396089,
0.0304933805,
0.0292397384,
-0.0149985589,
0.0209720023,
0.0171164516,
0.0553273186,
0.0198155995,
0.0127640953,
0.0346328653,
-0.0269126538,
-0.0056814332,
0.0783834532,
0.0106452908,
-0.0139230387,
-0.0087681338,
0.0422311127,
-0.0084464317,
0.0677420422,
0.0270678997,
-0.0255357139,
0.010261979,
-0.027335953,
0.011041631,
-0.0009479756,
0.0562261194,
-0.0268123094,
-0.0455652513,
-0.0227796361,
-0.0060325339,
-0.0520999953,
0.0309411269,
0.0632846504,
-0.0256138183,
-0.0376433432,
0.0593467243,
0.0212092437,
-0.0394158065,
0.0253706817,
-0.0339834318,
0.0565421656,
0.0630368814,
0.0268242806,
-0.0259089079,
-0.0385812074,
-0.0019574256,
0.005857103,
0.0414147228,
0.0376529098,
-0.0379483551,
0.0100889476,
-0.051332131,
-0.0191829149,
-0.0076310444,
0.0196907837,
0.0342665389,
-0.0126976538,
0.0044033779,
-0.0247288812,
-0.0311836675,
0.036118567,
0.0375842452,
-0.0282783154,
0.0086448472,
-0.0370013006,
0.0046082912,
0.0134604126,
0.0352936238,
0.0044430397,
-0.0054891696,
0.0441388562,
-0.029740233,
0.017579142,
0.0105722463,
-0.0268337913,
-0.0889128521,
0.0422198214,
-0.0381876752,
-0.0370374434,
-0.0110919187,
-0.0365960374,
-0.0436061807,
-0.0198116638,
-0.0220100321,
0.026672842,
-0.053216394,
0.0057512824,
-0.0201332401,
0.0301422309,
0.0092789605,
0.0870393515,
-0.0355112888,
-0.0046238322,
0.0498689711,
0.0011612213,
0.0169070289,
-0.0525018573,
-0.0479187518,
0.0066270651,
-0.0140707996,
-0.0094211036,
0.0057603479,
-0.0092211915,
-0.0432843603,
-0.0040750667,
-0.0776983798,
-0.0076645976,
-0.0095295403,
-0.0002971893,
0.0218618736,
-0.024976138,
-0.0246890374,
-0.0234772656,
-0.038503807,
-0.0136765828,
0.0081590479,
0.029505318,
0.0384850353,
-0.0002454176,
-0.0322520435,
-0.0045300364,
0.0080302274,
0.00005197,
0.0402751751,
0.0188998934,
0.0046318187,
-0.0533607341,
0.0006106462,
-0.0468134098,
-0.014008644,
-0.0228993762,
0.0029208299,
0.0345336832,
-0.025055591,
0.0228500515,
0.0385760441,
0.0029386487,
0.0508313999,
0.0833263695,
-0.0072857626,
-0.0573977418,
0.0021617892,
-0.0243069474,
-0.0247488506,
-0.0354626738,
-0.0158610716,
-0.0279361103,
0.0478794686,
0.0516517349,
-0.0052096676,
-0.0475767031,
0.0080588395,
-0.0140590379,
-0.0349338278,
-0.0613726899,
-0.0142971333,
-0.005758815,
0.0730441362,
-0.0167637095,
-0.0495331325,
0.1147903502,
-0.0543087013,
-0.0087797912,
-0.0221248362,
0.0066434061,
-0.0097667594,
0.0382671729,
-0.0074850726,
-0.0076806452,
0.0215462632,
-0.0137658212,
-0.0458014384,
0.0303219855,
0.0163591877,
-0.0526104346,
0.0655614883,
-0.0773098916,
-0.0006673153,
0.0107990177,
-0.0096693179,
-0.094735764,
-0.0406076238,
-0.013902802,
-0.0105636613,
-0.0235441867,
0.0119922757,
-0.0269736424,
-0.014937561,
0.0402232632,
-0.0036412629,
0.0131607605,
-0.0110528739,
-0.0314874835,
-0.0007379598,
0.0274202581,
0.0526497327,
0.0380572714,
-0.0436255746,
0.0389448702,
0.0296440739,
-0.0310730375,
-0.0191591941,
0.0218013916,
0.0320577696,
0.0241662133,
0.0005973674,
0.0231834799,
0.0258012097,
0.0456628203,
-0.0391389355,
-0.0343408473,
0.1371104717,
0.0370034762,
-0.0518580526,
-0.0077668047,
-0.0251617003,
0.0122865187,
0.0249086618,
0.0003191202,
-0.0983007476,
-0.014525312,
-0.0063843937,
0.0252840463,
0.0021144808,
-0.0188448764,
-0.0455127582,
-0.1259762645,
-0.0079713473,
-0.0183336213,
-0.0002992582,
-0.077586472,
-0.0702263415,
-0.0016452862,
-0.0154945729,
0.0435719602,
0.0276205745,
0.0250744801,
0.0082640396,
0.0170190893,
-0.000080026,
-0.1166008115,
0.0442299619,
-0.0380678177,
0.0739924312,
0.0138336737,
-0.0017752498,
-0.0064847427,
-0.0645485073,
-0.0526913516,
0.0093468595,
-0.026394695,
0.014410289,
0.0266857203,
-0.0335853174,
-0.0012359786,
0.0217118002,
0.0127810445,
-0.0478197113,
-0.0078015546,
0.0174261648,
0.1021411419,
-0.0241900627,
-0.0238410216,
0.0132236229,
-0.0130565334,
0.0041081393,
0.1269415617,
0.0565253757,
0.0142822182,
0.0397791304,
-0.0590874329,
-0.0005664839,
0.008277203,
-0.0208880268,
0.0615410954,
0.0152391559,
-0.009315256,
-0.0339934975,
-0.0173205603,
0.0447866395,
0.0568354204,
0.0123264361,
-0.0071040927,
0.0350218415,
-0.0042616944,
-0.0310679954,
0.0057709087,
-0.0345609784,
-0.0036465349,
-0.0289391801,
-0.0217652842,
0.033844877,
-0.0354919955,
0.0040373122,
-0.0053701773,
-0.0894554257,
-0.0552548468,
0.0086054746,
0.0314170457,
0.0324066281,
0.0678294748,
-0.0372548997,
-0.007500377,
0.0634200349,
-0.0026217524,
-0.0385879539,
0.0091963764,
0.0145428944,
0.0043413551,
0.0008648604,
0.0304460786,
-0.0171304662,
-0.0166394077,
-0.0232616011,
0.02948872,
-0.022537902,
-0.0707089007,
0.0402859561,
0.0333999991,
0.0586653985,
-0.0141891511,
-0.0368344001,
-0.0608455576,
0.0097583542,
-0.038224563,
-0.0034927679,
-0.0288673844,
-0.0173038468,
0.0301524643,
-0.0068386546,
0.0097787278,
-0.0151162632,
-0.009306767,
0.0187860485,
-0.006055681,
0.0080961837,
0.0265606381,
0.0037665532,
0.0125825992,
-0.0221860129,
-0.0207032915,
0.0206819996,
-0.014403631,
0.024557095,
-0.0002431495,
0.0602854639,
0.0136710554,
0.0001648211,
0.0172663797,
0.0018737628,
-0.0383694284,
-0.0425748937,
-0.0008704305,
0.044600822,
0.0436325967,
0.0209144261,
0.0209786687,
-0.0457150042,
0.0263732206,
-0.001946486,
0.0282563549,
0.0156425592,
-0.0390988849,
0.0757174715,
0.0159051847,
-0.0327368602,
-0.0093066515,
0.0842686892,
-0.0344308764,
0.0517795794,
-0.0396003202,
0.0002079917,
-0.0468456149,
-0.018461436,
-0.0198586062,
0.0141282193,
-0.0525236242,
0.018386839,
-0.0895832628,
-0.0677852407,
-0.0054812622,
0.0269419067,
0.0037406455,
-0.0105894636,
0.0208726022,
0.066198878,
-0.0056988266,
-0.0000970723,
-0.0089641754,
0.0255591534,
0.009849282,
-0.0002797746,
-0.0062701078,
-6.740131793e-33,
-0.0714046061,
-0.0186156463,
0.0353104845,
-0.0383117124,
0.0035598474,
0.0242596958,
-0.0482901447,
0.0156153413,
-0.0498204976,
0.0016752676,
0.0173998978,
0.0107463077,
0.0046283994,
0.0219401997,
0.0156579167,
-0.0457434393,
0.0536311045,
-0.0027294771,
-0.0406277664,
-0.0051844209,
0.0497377068,
0.0150966346,
0.0684111267,
0.0087832157,
0.0765592754,
0.0031243612,
-0.0050445916,
0.0582323559,
-0.0597728081,
0.0532391742,
-0.0387856066,
0.0577041656,
0.0168504063,
-0.0773197114,
-0.0367836505,
0.002067327,
-0.0642226934,
-0.0529053658,
0.0571564212,
0.0307770371,
-0.00846845,
-0.0065297694,
-0.0059483419,
-0.0078592729,
0.0038693605,
0.0163217243,
0.0301196873,
-0.014268294,
-0.000088053,
0.0055688415,
-0.0000529763,
-0.0047701118,
-0.0149507215,
-0.0131330229,
0.0347246639,
-0.0030551478,
0.0181836579,
-0.0076347524,
-0.0869320184,
0.0376060791,
0.0309569389,
0.007348096,
0.1027574837,
0.0010097611,
0.0055394256,
0.0755720288,
-0.0163813252,
-0.0244018771,
-0.0779782161,
0.0379987806,
0.0475946069,
0.0181921162,
0.0255489387,
0.0826780796,
-0.0064175413,
0.0195813142,
-0.0540290028,
0.0309935827,
0.0587594919,
0.0071543725,
0.0323309973,
-0.0069650081,
-0.0270662121,
-0.0297138523,
-0.0541699156,
0.0157535169,
-0.0279195793,
0.0016482844,
0.0130555686,
-0.0005531589,
-0.0099563487,
-0.0336587131,
0.0427999198,
-0.0385118574,
-0.0115969507,
0.0486600623,
0.0005419618,
0.0088329474,
0.0116060013,
0.0362976603,
-0.0702081695,
0.012573068,
0.032113675,
-0.0214361288,
-0.0060349321,
0.0187187493,
-0.0054915142,
0.0092598032,
-0.0286591481,
0.0014145667,
-0.0461607352,
-0.0059218993,
-0.0054858946,
-0.0011662769,
0.0356939435,
0.0283492804,
-0.0496332385,
-0.0076833046,
0.0014251306,
0.0005099442,
-0.0427177846,
0.020985594,
-0.0181444231,
0.0221395269,
-0.0192415603,
-0.0166614875,
-0.0482142642,
-0.0541168265,
0.0223955531,
-0.0287458804,
0.0162029918,
0.0320953764,
2.611e-7,
0.0300723482,
0.032467939,
0.0166312922,
0.0223452467,
0.0300144274,
0.0431545936,
-0.0597125106,
0.0094293086,
0.016670499,
-0.1123308092,
0.0109907761,
0.0485219397,
0.0350172967,
0.0618794747,
-0.096675843,
-0.0072267577,
0.0053457706,
0.0003314716,
-0.054552611,
0.0149200028,
0.0854730681,
0.0821016058,
0.0238008257,
0.0125133898,
0.0077690887,
0.0357445925,
0.037579488,
0.0023109461,
-0.0235635694,
0.0031371242,
0.0633529797,
0.0004837667,
0.0240892544,
0.0595199056,
0.0094823372,
-0.0034135613,
-0.0131766619,
0.043855004,
0.0493765771,
-0.0628425106,
-0.0378365479,
-0.0001539049,
-0.0190009195,
-0.0695425868,
0.0737454295,
-0.0274148881,
-0.0376943201,
-0.004867489,
0.0007920612,
-0.0010015727,
0.0082671707,
0.0142333843,
-0.038367942,
0.0100283008,
0.0029443651,
-0.0075295623,
-0.0162611138,
-0.0371821709,
0.0024086875,
-0.0117395306,
-0.0576469749,
-0.0845905393,
0.0002034795,
-0.0454467349,
0.0281302631,
-0.0591308139,
0.0358795561,
2.195018509e-34,
0.024599975,
-0.0122060152,
0.0033471517,
0.0165766254,
0.0253456458,
-0.042319335,
-0.041901689,
0.0032278872,
0.0037257234,
-0.0769404918,
-0.001853905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12276v1 | CodeNav: Beyond tool-use to using real-world codebases with LLM agents | 2024-06-18T05:10:38 | 2024-06-18T05:10:38 | Tanmay Gupta, Luca Weihs, Aniruddha Kembhavi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | We present CodeNav, an LLM agent that navigates and leverages previously
unseen code repositories to solve user queries. In contrast to tool-use LLM
agents that require ``registration'' of all relevant tools via manual
descriptions within the LLM context, CodeNav automatically indexes and searches
over code blocks in the target codebase, finds relevant code snippets, imports
them, and uses them to iteratively generate a solution with execution feedback.
To highlight the core-capabilities of CodeNav, we first showcase three case
studies where we use CodeNav for solving complex user queries using three
diverse codebases. Next, on three benchmarks, we quantitatively compare the
effectiveness of code-use (which only has access to the target codebase) to
tool-use (which has privileged access to all tool names and descriptions).
Finally, we study the effect of varying kinds of tool and library descriptions
on code-use performance, as well as investigate the advantage of the agent
seeing source code as opposed to natural descriptions of code. All code will be
made open source under a permissive license. | [
0.0103836171,
0.0459651537,
-0.0310451277,
0.0259926356,
-0.0514660962,
0.02412026,
-0.0173228309,
0.0339353085,
0.0382812917,
-0.004770379,
-0.0164580084,
0.0927152708,
-0.0237017069,
-0.0240002871,
0.0085401367,
-0.0139230276,
0.0101071363,
-0.0054087308,
-0.0516310334,
0.0328779742,
-0.0105210841,
0.013757932,
-0.0282207932,
0.0463430807,
0.0180018265,
0.0003674063,
-0.0470648929,
0.0568465218,
0.0052912459,
-0.0161840357,
0.0104649207,
0.0484923385,
-0.0027647358,
-0.0112479441,
0.0000023224,
-0.017996328,
-0.0147601003,
0.0220830534,
-0.0630357713,
0.0199034773,
0.0338571668,
0.0498050638,
0.0320136547,
0.002226159,
-0.0400187187,
0.0434295423,
0.0195538439,
-0.0531776436,
0.0376972184,
0.0399296395,
0.0243969467,
0.0280030444,
-0.0489600711,
0.0413455069,
0.0634090975,
-0.0719768405,
-0.0090289032,
0.0372529142,
0.114637129,
-0.0039562183,
0.0354488753,
0.0328539126,
0.0167613849,
-0.0163187478,
0.0356267691,
0.0137243569,
-0.053587798,
-0.0221640542,
-0.0188035164,
0.0672045276,
0.005668913,
-0.0130682308,
0.0661601126,
-0.0047259852,
-0.0189357083,
0.0237778388,
-0.0100213466,
-0.0181631502,
-0.0125763183,
-0.0215261634,
-0.0416418724,
-0.0310029704,
0.0060698302,
-0.0079611558,
-0.025435064,
0.0455299728,
-0.0123369331,
0.005579263,
0.0599721819,
-0.0300643742,
0.0601357035,
-0.047595229,
0.012186843,
0.0708285868,
-0.031379573,
0.0129689947,
0.014542032,
0.0008829614,
0.0406082459,
-0.0240811743,
0.0092530381,
0.0327368416,
-0.0609993003,
0.024596205,
-0.0140491668,
0.0382273607,
-0.0339061283,
0.0107545191,
-0.0126326913,
-0.0060483776,
-0.0488191471,
0.0226981863,
-0.0440852568,
0.0457543172,
-0.0491745844,
0.0404084176,
0.0029336531,
0.0588024966,
0.0171149187,
0.058924105,
-0.0319590233,
0.0036216942,
0.0222963393,
0.0056236,
-0.0348818749,
-0.0812677816,
-0.0415349491,
-0.028386347,
-0.0084902067,
-0.0862052143,
-0.0078528263,
0.0005570472,
-0.0332946964,
-0.0206830911,
0.0387661606,
0.0478878468,
0.0347997732,
0.0154706333,
-0.0703848749,
-0.0491218492,
0.0533435494,
-0.0271768477,
-0.0578399971,
-0.0894783735,
0.0030292089,
0.0139665809,
-0.0591469966,
-0.0784214884,
-0.0124896485,
0.0193313863,
0.0128418887,
0.0450168103,
-0.05597068,
0.0238221884,
0.020686429,
0.0345914923,
-0.0370123535,
0.0066100536,
-0.0249452144,
0.0269540586,
0.0073483661,
-0.0065569538,
0.0649095774,
0.0149350362,
-0.0194924213,
0.0070851338,
0.0048380052,
0.0671778098,
0.0061368039,
0.0001107771,
-0.0215158872,
-0.0201278869,
0.003481169,
0.003587675,
-0.0255525634,
0.0883089527,
0.0550292879,
-0.0219382383,
0.017179152,
0.0374785401,
0.0104509136,
-0.0317830369,
-0.0517617278,
0.063349776,
-0.0157350078,
-0.0315423124,
-0.0534439944,
-0.0056980625,
-0.0047059283,
-0.0473451987,
-0.0071167331,
0.0115210908,
-0.032263685,
0.022267364,
0.0156590473,
-0.0022786113,
0.004456012,
0.0536341742,
0.0123414164,
-0.0586229749,
-0.0864991248,
-0.0386785455,
0.0189757254,
0.0802079886,
0.0487159155,
-0.0711225942,
-0.0443285666,
0.0490317121,
0.0130772181,
-0.0144965146,
0.0385959744,
0.0005575088,
-0.0085195629,
-0.0239773691,
-0.0365541503,
-0.0326632001,
-0.0109922504,
0.0846498013,
0.0252617896,
-0.0238964558,
0.0056641591,
-0.0563404858,
-0.032144215,
0.0371112563,
-0.0210525598,
-0.0242498051,
0.0189342033,
0.0200590566,
-0.0162866749,
0.020544298,
-0.0008317219,
-0.002623609,
0.0714022443,
0.0090409294,
-0.0441175178,
-0.0288929027,
0.0425352193,
0.0320782401,
0.010141436,
-0.0483813249,
-0.0008764637,
-0.0151065355,
-0.03276252,
0.0143231107,
-0.0049675992,
0.0039272537,
0.0019300928,
0.0147715639,
-0.0042423271,
-0.0345858969,
-0.0394810401,
-0.029208282,
0.0531516969,
0.0415160991,
0.0021252227,
0.0560106002,
0.0479298532,
0.027559014,
-0.0065170648,
0.0115123754,
0.0154623929,
0.010272854,
0.0118373875,
-0.0362225734,
0.036327716,
-0.0081199743,
-0.0010038712,
-0.0780921802,
0.0331781693,
-0.0060942383,
0.0153915649,
-0.0041047945,
0.0477317236,
-0.0076920977,
-0.0354801901,
-0.0429060087,
-0.0103314025,
-0.0280584544,
-0.0325465016,
0.030100463,
0.0216921978,
-0.055166617,
-0.0328203104,
0.0104962625,
-0.0143782785,
-0.008050764,
-0.003439026,
-0.0392650515,
-0.0492921956,
0.0672591701,
0.0204724204,
-0.013820447,
-0.0158397965,
0.0239525363,
-0.0040012146,
-0.0215925593,
-0.0416550711,
0.0299810916,
-0.0606935583,
0.0272659231,
0.0693864971,
-0.0002908322,
-0.0729965493,
0.0156468377,
0.0657971129,
-0.0398450419,
-0.0045423559,
-0.0328277983,
0.0659646019,
-0.0158878639,
-0.0095850136,
0.0292001516,
0.0105189141,
-0.0254476555,
0.0343436338,
-0.0299900956,
0.0121336309,
-0.0096175428,
-0.027640434,
0.0741569325,
0.0234132204,
-0.0739416182,
0.0457490459,
-0.0377911776,
-0.0326799229,
0.0180769023,
-0.0960136056,
-0.0817378908,
0.0619735755,
-0.0102051999,
-0.0072245235,
-0.0431850962,
-0.0381780453,
0.0049493662,
-0.0112167615,
0.0134350061,
-0.0422915444,
0.0942572653,
-0.0369874239,
0.0210055076,
-0.0086068995,
-0.0090117119,
-0.0325143822,
-0.0024437907,
-0.0263200328,
-0.0353454798,
0.0348795466,
-0.0052185841,
0.0282716472,
-0.0044919928,
0.0293594357,
0.0233698636,
0.0341343991,
-0.0379399844,
-0.001936465,
-0.0573528968,
-0.065205358,
-0.0035082346,
-0.0088639632,
0.0259271041,
-0.0124493567,
0.0419154875,
0.0633535087,
-0.0118783591,
-0.0344868898,
0.0126096988,
0.0220920257,
-0.0457001701,
-0.0053061899,
0.0478992201,
0.003786132,
-0.0464484543,
0.0228467565,
0.0389258824,
0.0618485995,
-0.067589201,
0.0037695919,
-0.0186762139,
-0.0004539914,
0.0798938647,
0.1015443504,
-0.1239518151,
-0.0286417343,
-0.0112112174,
0.0795615166,
-0.0038696297,
-0.0258073267,
-0.03157942,
-0.0477037914,
0.0282628406,
-0.006717009,
0.0322539099,
0.0208578967,
-0.0044359211,
0.0026780805,
-0.0089639723,
-0.0526292548,
0.0530265607,
-0.0183418114,
0.0106673995,
0.0055950251,
-0.0191131402,
0.043998912,
0.0171632431,
0.0039237561,
-0.0026634533,
0.0850391164,
0.0154400934,
0.0279868059,
-0.0250006206,
0.0257132147,
-0.0145194139,
0.0419459864,
-0.0595390797,
0.0491049439,
0.0085910903,
-0.0067224577,
0.0136704994,
0.0093522454,
-0.0544939265,
-0.0056544086,
0.0594032928,
0.0222905297,
-0.0529086553,
0.0189391486,
-0.0308064725,
-0.0221440699,
-0.0131579367,
0.0219990928,
0.0374942198,
0.0309720114,
-0.016959263,
-0.0429485552,
-0.0351726636,
-0.0008081252,
-0.0181563683,
0.0002743029,
-0.0442522243,
0.0537991934,
-0.0206728596,
0.0128602777,
0.0586731657,
0.036966417,
0.0276079383,
-0.0270565301,
-0.028012339,
0.0194566287,
-0.025424324,
0.0018570574,
-0.0239962563,
0.0373221599,
-0.0118053881,
-0.010775201,
0.0233246367,
0.0049114865,
-0.0083891544,
0.0170664564,
-0.0277957972,
-0.0366988853,
-0.0376289487,
0.0222652759,
0.0222965796,
0.0096200202,
-0.0289510731,
-0.0246122051,
-0.0237673298,
0.0501183979,
-0.0585565306,
0.0147657404,
-0.0111769326,
0.0229274072,
-0.0055529829,
-0.0064298613,
-0.1054373905,
-0.0476162173,
-0.0134567488,
-0.0175060276,
-0.0442038067,
-0.0423902571,
0.029680552,
0.0373697802,
-0.0411379039,
0.0495520718,
-0.0152373444,
0.0162925478,
0.0482655205,
0.0483198203,
-0.0309164543,
-0.031689994,
0.005912025,
-0.0512054376,
-0.0650230572,
0.0655577853,
0.0353374109,
-0.0539877526,
0.054127682,
-0.0124969967,
0.0610612817,
-0.0063242018,
0.0095306691,
0.0442632213,
0.0124360453,
-0.0119254468,
0.0490147807,
0.010751578,
0.0720970929,
-0.00873545,
0.004343844,
-0.0187025368,
0.0380024463,
0.0026018787,
-0.0121822245,
-0.0411711261,
-0.1081969887,
0.053171955,
-0.0089612016,
0.0116847362,
0.0302176941,
0.000485872,
-0.0164379235,
0.0018348347,
-0.0110971406,
0.0020760067,
-0.0169604253,
0.0112764155,
0.0018730743,
0.0230083931,
-0.0043298583,
-0.0815101266,
0.0544360541,
-0.0306281745,
0.0147159938,
-0.044138249,
-0.0296171252,
-0.0416149907,
-0.0268911794,
0.0621674061,
-0.0295253471,
-0.0125559131,
-0.0702759922,
-0.0622935891,
-0.0136927785,
-0.0040569198,
0.0030358925,
-0.0218496751,
-0.0129761798,
0.057273902,
0.0655337423,
0.0529537387,
-0.0373850726,
-0.01589261,
-0.0008470963,
-0.0576532558,
-0.0360657461,
-0.0033450983,
-5.61254398e-33,
-0.0449792817,
-0.0854403451,
0.0359722115,
0.0632921308,
0.0481014363,
-0.0452773459,
-0.0263387784,
0.0167800151,
-0.0111405104,
-0.031044947,
-0.0044806539,
0.0232593138,
0.0158500001,
-0.087149784,
0.0406510755,
-0.0005007838,
0.0169336963,
0.0488405861,
-0.022847008,
0.0023714239,
-0.0321422219,
0.0412206762,
-0.0056394301,
-0.0659074783,
0.0041986485,
-0.0028384496,
0.054699745,
0.0150663769,
-0.0025876821,
0.0274608806,
0.0368243307,
0.000355256,
-0.0339674912,
0.0168894269,
0.0030615181,
-0.034994781,
-0.0112221474,
-0.0155330459,
0.0274249595,
-0.0066243624,
0.0224777535,
-0.044174742,
0.0649163947,
0.008753974,
-0.0218003653,
0.0448410325,
0.0404992923,
0.0045276419,
-0.0131773511,
-0.041190397,
0.0094863074,
0.0296578128,
-0.0318066142,
0.0254733507,
-0.0219745543,
0.0368193053,
-0.0095494492,
0.0100752134,
0.0050280225,
-0.0168593992,
0.0084821945,
0.0116291335,
0.0552745089,
-0.0064605125,
-0.0001865682,
-0.0217060652,
0.0197488274,
-0.0318302438,
0.0054909871,
0.0035470577,
-0.0056171427,
0.1073896587,
0.014830254,
0.0052389042,
-0.0358255766,
0.0104889059,
0.0115436856,
0.0503801443,
-0.0027311721,
0.0297686551,
-0.006845776,
0.0260620713,
-0.0318020321,
0.0009678695,
0.0053875493,
0.0285654739,
-0.0423749574,
-0.0576797165,
0.0268807355,
-0.0233147964,
0.0137442462,
-0.0340838768,
-0.0332499817,
0.000190906,
-0.0101808095,
-0.0012615388,
-0.0167933051,
-0.0204360019,
-0.0019946294,
0.0198687408,
-0.0118096583,
0.0162996687,
-0.032893315,
-0.0073482706,
0.0862526447,
-0.0042350874,
0.00296101,
0.0084272027,
-0.0700094476,
-0.0007283777,
-0.0442784876,
0.0021769824,
-0.0254505314,
-0.0180908609,
0.0009301404,
-0.0141401794,
0.017428264,
0.0237733983,
-0.0338790268,
-0.0492358319,
-0.0503862612,
-0.0091761034,
0.0160705,
0.0098681962,
-0.0546854101,
-0.0037091172,
-0.0065154331,
0.0623272657,
0.0725504458,
-0.0125608845,
-0.0155506488,
0.036990054,
3.016e-7,
0.0174906999,
0.0215216912,
-0.010658239,
0.0507527888,
-0.0280587394,
0.0120690344,
-0.0497592203,
0.0014108839,
-0.0175689626,
-0.0286745206,
0.0035161444,
-0.0002401825,
0.0506007969,
0.0502937324,
-0.0392688513,
-0.0025642491,
0.0718741938,
-0.0110913394,
-0.0740312114,
0.0002846619,
0.0344825871,
-0.0091793565,
0.017085202,
-0.0058476599,
0.0220171399,
-0.0566542856,
-0.0160724856,
-0.0443961546,
0.0254411548,
0.0081019253,
-0.007701444,
0.0514253452,
-0.0163754728,
-0.0109548429,
-0.0070332163,
-0.0123073841,
-0.0196450967,
0.0605778061,
0.0180720575,
-0.0339844674,
0.010384134,
-0.0863445848,
-0.0176211633,
-0.007734227,
0.0197923556,
0.0246536918,
0.0054321773,
0.0323184878,
-0.0009152573,
-0.06962993,
-0.0617210791,
-0.0036767726,
0.0421225987,
-0.0179495756,
-0.0017486264,
-0.061009679,
-0.0461056791,
-0.0511571392,
0.0094670253,
0.0394043103,
-0.0142631894,
-0.042200204,
-0.0329386778,
0.039242588,
-0.0048559546,
0.0202071052,
0.0205458961,
2.791586254e-34,
-0.0110628977,
0.0146994693,
-0.0003851979,
0.0860693827,
0.0341288671,
0.0463428162,
-0.0061235554,
0.019440569,
0.0021859591,
-0.0404118374,
-0.0118226996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12274v1 | SafeInfer: Context Adaptive Decoding Time Safety Alignment for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T05:03:23 | 2024-06-18T05:03:23 | Somnath Banerjee, Soham Tripathy, Sayan Layek, Shanu Kumar, Animesh Mukherjee, Rima Hazra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Safety-aligned language models often exhibit fragile and imbalanced safety
mechanisms, increasing the likelihood of generating unsafe content. In
addition, incorporating new knowledge through editing techniques to language
models can further compromise safety. To address these issues, we propose
SafeInfer, a context-adaptive, decoding-time safety alignment strategy for
generating safe responses to user queries. SafeInfer comprises two phases: the
safety amplification phase, which employs safe demonstration examples to adjust
the model's hidden states and increase the likelihood of safer outputs, and the
safety-guided decoding phase, which influences token selection based on
safety-optimized distributions, ensuring the generated content complies with
ethical guidelines. Further, we present HarmEval, a novel benchmark for
extensive safety evaluations, designed to address potential misuse scenarios in
accordance with the policies of leading AI tech giants. | [
0.0166577399,
0.0761397034,
-0.0074112429,
0.0324776247,
-0.02137734,
0.0013091979,
-0.0249005407,
0.0087143555,
0.0010749383,
-0.0240685325,
-0.0010083236,
-0.0336670615,
-0.0139812725,
0.0627740771,
0.0228598136,
-0.0056440234,
0.0757417753,
-0.0409125388,
0.0185218863,
0.0162499528,
0.0150476433,
0.0087948469,
0.000909087,
0.0693525001,
-0.0122047411,
-0.0183647629,
-0.0038770894,
0.0375528932,
0.0282178596,
-0.0278305933,
0.013453681,
0.0404820889,
-0.012117004,
0.0588229932,
0.0000019432,
-0.0386441052,
-0.0171297155,
0.0375371799,
-0.0346467309,
-0.0243803933,
0.0313368961,
-0.0163248256,
-0.0373054259,
0.0416783057,
-0.0316269845,
0.0126214176,
0.0944589376,
0.0088764541,
0.0712401941,
0.0704661757,
-0.0146153485,
0.0365887359,
0.0579774529,
0.0226912703,
-0.0109904855,
-0.0504749455,
0.0311108772,
-0.0299568344,
0.0040703225,
0.017856745,
-0.0059807347,
0.0352773331,
0.0253161993,
-0.0497377776,
-0.0211170856,
-0.0140607301,
-0.0525742024,
-0.0539337844,
-0.0221048612,
0.0504770987,
-0.0217853487,
-0.0282715652,
0.0147433141,
-0.0034277192,
-0.0044098836,
-0.0334798433,
-0.0023014706,
0.0111086508,
-0.0095190033,
0.0037456506,
0.0419296511,
0.0305134468,
0.0482578166,
0.0231163427,
0.0417572483,
0.0915970653,
0.0214976016,
-0.0257147774,
-0.0194560513,
-0.0263439212,
0.0019932911,
-0.0473004542,
0.0265792105,
0.0183449537,
-0.0453863852,
0.0246260986,
-0.0696972087,
-0.0542907193,
0.0484802499,
-0.0706900731,
0.005469521,
0.0594085939,
0.0165040307,
0.0251988415,
0.0134684537,
0.0143483272,
-0.0107648494,
0.0419489034,
-0.0219693705,
0.0095826359,
0.0303909425,
-0.0220170561,
-0.0229905173,
0.0181781631,
-0.0213352926,
0.0377559736,
-0.037975423,
0.0508031808,
-0.0372854248,
0.0324949361,
0.0106728338,
0.0093107214,
-0.0437131822,
0.0044913115,
0.018793257,
-0.0261276141,
-0.0203647353,
-0.0112478444,
0.009889273,
-0.0673624724,
-0.0098287743,
0.0135219684,
-0.0252472721,
-0.0351521559,
-0.0235279649,
0.1236004308,
-0.0049113021,
0.0136102755,
-0.028094437,
-0.0676832423,
-0.0112912115,
-0.0014388518,
0.0018887245,
-0.0476582423,
0.0173272677,
-0.0001341558,
-0.0433216505,
-0.1069270074,
0.014639643,
0.03331789,
-0.0527546145,
0.0384593159,
-0.0460364781,
-0.0111495843,
-0.0126117878,
0.0285388567,
-0.0336902738,
0.0681934655,
0.049033612,
0.0405604951,
0.0378141664,
0.0057766526,
0.0140965376,
0.0522289909,
0.0210374892,
0.03384839,
-0.0627834648,
0.0207709428,
0.0203191452,
0.0146966213,
-0.0117797116,
0.0817402974,
-0.0068744752,
-0.0327158161,
0.0580428354,
0.0378914624,
-0.0368525311,
0.0294260047,
0.0259912629,
-0.0191728957,
-0.0267244074,
-0.0250736773,
-0.0781246796,
0.0033807845,
-0.0589371026,
-0.0250487328,
0.0066471803,
0.0307376012,
-0.008597495,
-0.0225024391,
-0.022924317,
-0.0099783372,
0.0704202801,
0.0025418974,
-0.0006444509,
0.0096872216,
-0.0492073707,
0.0166588034,
0.0345645398,
-0.0290866252,
0.0034328394,
-0.0537498966,
-0.0091658104,
0.1145476252,
0.070607014,
-0.0113924043,
-0.0530641079,
-0.021649234,
-0.0090414435,
0.0089162039,
0.0011102533,
0.0023229055,
0.0418020599,
-0.0235147309,
-0.0533385389,
0.0458042733,
0.0179410502,
-0.0267730225,
0.031136537,
0.0316952169,
-0.000578745,
-0.0444089584,
-0.0540597774,
0.0359036997,
-0.0266967043,
-0.0315513723,
-0.0261441115,
0.0018432833,
0.0169729497,
-0.0068563507,
-0.0098232413,
0.0201079305,
0.0209492948,
0.0008325478,
0.0008251062,
0.0035868327,
-0.0718755201,
0.021040611,
0.048028972,
-0.0299577396,
-0.0277928207,
0.056189809,
-0.0188958906,
0.0012150125,
0.010217011,
-0.032400243,
0.0101916753,
-0.0202755202,
0.0224351995,
-0.0226146579,
-0.0287690796,
-0.0339437909,
0.0489375517,
-0.0223705713,
-0.0222145822,
-0.0464814417,
-0.0196355805,
-0.0246612635,
-0.0093910014,
-0.0409591645,
0.0162964985,
-0.0478610881,
0.0630079955,
0.0246911496,
0.0427397341,
-0.023678584,
-0.0100071393,
-0.0623123497,
-0.0027619698,
-0.0279303119,
0.0212529134,
0.0103880204,
0.0149048315,
-0.0096188365,
-0.0080628879,
-0.0181171279,
-0.0127528422,
-0.0122132488,
0.0369707607,
0.0115642324,
0.0011534414,
-0.0231951065,
-0.0304205865,
-0.0162390657,
-0.0300439801,
0.0431467444,
-0.0095649697,
-0.010444751,
-0.0354294106,
0.0296814106,
-0.008030992,
0.029728746,
0.0153990686,
-0.0431076959,
0.0083005028,
0.0128908847,
-0.0087766051,
0.0485198237,
0.0332037695,
0.026986368,
0.0486559011,
0.0312348958,
-0.0527375601,
0.0174699984,
0.007826264,
-0.0277847163,
-0.0170183573,
-0.0329571925,
0.0175826959,
0.0241745356,
-0.018894285,
-0.0005740872,
-0.0855098739,
0.0259691793,
-0.0425317548,
-0.0755654722,
-0.0030213664,
-0.0725193769,
-0.0275514349,
0.0469801091,
-0.0090548312,
-0.0498003326,
0.078954123,
0.0033442921,
0.0326199308,
-0.0177303702,
-0.0075884,
0.0179471951,
0.0248668399,
-0.0355314761,
0.0654108971,
0.0005263152,
-0.0397436284,
-0.045913849,
-0.0217674784,
0.0254233293,
-0.0543013439,
0.024039967,
-0.0257396176,
-0.0062258355,
-0.0048193764,
-0.0642769188,
-0.064372912,
-0.0690691173,
0.0008902168,
-0.0014110832,
0.0180545952,
-0.0316995792,
-0.012372368,
0.0021026658,
0.0061946712,
0.0174431019,
-0.0310755689,
-0.0007388514,
-0.0125427926,
-0.0296925008,
0.0761138722,
-0.052736152,
0.0218252875,
-0.0133346515,
0.039996177,
0.1090674549,
0.0560863055,
-0.0156965479,
-0.0171669926,
0.0073680193,
0.0476197079,
-0.0036778834,
0.0079609249,
0.0708610043,
0.0355955996,
-0.0321507379,
-0.0249996614,
0.0454479158,
0.0213297941,
-0.0455971509,
0.0353841297,
-0.0331472121,
0.0308092777,
-0.0009230353,
0.0156430472,
-0.0481263697,
-0.001993095,
0.0340229496,
0.0637719408,
-0.0171157829,
-0.0429325737,
0.019976791,
-0.0571949556,
0.0256535932,
0.0297074709,
-0.0539887585,
-0.0325166136,
-0.020555865,
-0.0034269548,
0.0072695646,
0.081996344,
0.029359255,
-0.0056963237,
-0.0400512926,
0.0301967468,
0.0152955409,
-0.0663840771,
0.0033265399,
-0.0524654277,
0.089024514,
0.0951875597,
-0.0139408298,
-0.0120047322,
-0.0301728491,
-0.0108288089,
0.0304688029,
-0.0163597837,
-0.0149877835,
0.0024677769,
-0.0088435747,
-0.0095363241,
-0.028695723,
0.0092825433,
-0.0122978678,
-0.0401501842,
-0.0045327959,
0.0584221296,
-0.0254877247,
-0.001257283,
-0.0521923602,
-0.0079374183,
0.0449854843,
0.0694280118,
0.0135112898,
-0.0479539484,
-0.0234650932,
-0.0517822802,
0.0067135333,
-0.0679171085,
-0.0328989998,
0.0141613092,
0.006009215,
-0.0702050701,
-0.061687164,
-0.005903759,
-0.02766384,
0.0205694735,
0.0340711027,
-0.0184503719,
0.0240944717,
0.0039732293,
-0.0483611263,
0.0092642205,
-0.0225035492,
0.0163747072,
-0.0465589017,
0.0641053915,
-0.0250302106,
-0.0024031047,
-0.0201691929,
0.0635629445,
-0.0160003062,
-0.0865300372,
0.0571056679,
0.0831220597,
0.0276758615,
-0.0126393745,
-0.0454495288,
-0.0542890392,
0.0530000106,
0.0639503226,
-0.0420382284,
-0.0223895665,
0.0335571021,
-0.0462653674,
0.020491017,
0.0167297609,
-0.0739263594,
-0.0515445583,
0.0283766314,
0.0408063717,
-0.0323800743,
-0.0175203718,
0.0198531281,
0.041328337,
-0.0131248012,
-0.0211885646,
0.0170004219,
0.0206366982,
0.0134051749,
-0.0340449847,
-0.03263814,
-0.0135748871,
0.0485478118,
0.0146685829,
-0.0216569826,
0.007601636,
0.008932638,
-0.016476348,
0.0353606381,
-0.0207684357,
0.0165770371,
-0.0221066047,
0.0561588332,
0.0471473113,
0.0170195121,
-0.028418107,
0.0392079502,
0.001068892,
0.0235149544,
-0.0317002423,
-0.0057937428,
0.0223906934,
0.0221764594,
-0.0208384804,
0.0692123398,
-0.0478921123,
-0.0546793528,
-0.0421535298,
0.006083102,
0.0050107962,
0.0279322602,
0.0485151671,
-0.0251193028,
-0.0022817808,
-0.0338071808,
0.0037371381,
0.0187003091,
-0.0605778471,
-0.0026405591,
0.0132414438,
-0.010998196,
-0.0244084615,
0.0691242144,
0.0083511006,
0.0454721823,
0.008321193,
-0.0139514497,
-0.0134124793,
-0.0193881281,
0.0354776867,
0.0259872284,
-0.0513042472,
-0.0340507627,
-0.0558606908,
-0.0935747549,
-0.0088739721,
0.0082819508,
0.0012595789,
0.0307892617,
0.0222806334,
0.0378858075,
0.0142542003,
-0.0211629141,
-0.0268086717,
-0.0168509856,
0.0154621955,
-0.0332171656,
-0.0276625659,
-6.277850273e-33,
0.0199672636,
-0.0190519746,
-0.014895685,
-0.0378367752,
0.0003636623,
-0.0170257837,
-0.0283518322,
-0.0015721361,
-0.0102435676,
-0.0030209534,
-0.0291988105,
0.0153322797,
0.0116379531,
0.0201655161,
0.0104070082,
-0.0542342849,
0.0128806727,
0.0014552022,
-0.0181829333,
0.0315329246,
0.0349383131,
-0.0166799966,
0.0310844965,
-0.1010861322,
0.032570906,
0.0071716039,
-0.0408504307,
0.034496136,
-0.0134681119,
0.0668088645,
0.0117436964,
0.0397860818,
-0.0049911211,
-0.0129549336,
-0.0005657045,
0.0099087805,
-0.031725388,
-0.0121398028,
0.0128478045,
-0.0087289708,
-0.0552530289,
-0.0817464292,
0.058415886,
-0.0162137598,
-0.0362058803,
-0.0156741515,
-0.009709944,
0.0096054217,
-0.0096438266,
-0.0636077821,
-0.0458803102,
0.0096008386,
-0.025505513,
-0.0200806148,
0.022140963,
0.0424747095,
0.0366999805,
-0.0139811793,
-0.0334213413,
-0.017383365,
-0.0036324798,
-0.0145814829,
0.0825749859,
0.0085531184,
-0.0240321308,
0.0596670061,
-0.0297322329,
0.0228403751,
-0.0044680811,
-0.0147180958,
0.0184051935,
0.0419602133,
0.0243905932,
0.0556402355,
0.0118753863,
-0.0397560559,
-0.0546335317,
0.0509767085,
-0.0375566706,
0.0608237162,
0.0394291505,
0.0030151817,
-0.094323203,
-0.0056002513,
-0.0358981267,
0.0199906994,
-0.0418661088,
-0.0278831832,
0.0284258388,
-0.0204775166,
-0.0609009303,
-0.0282940362,
0.0038813991,
-0.0451937877,
0.0311372522,
0.0319787152,
0.0249516945,
-0.0218466483,
-0.0027943677,
0.0730263218,
0.0364550725,
-0.0205712393,
0.0267963223,
-0.0477233976,
0.0309217926,
0.0027635254,
0.0117950467,
0.0544698611,
-0.0600013658,
0.0103040775,
-0.0196732581,
0.0643562227,
0.034307804,
-0.0231573023,
0.0528066605,
0.0009718371,
0.006127242,
-0.0094478028,
0.0648917779,
0.0422534607,
-0.0330683701,
0.003699065,
-0.0210227929,
0.020228263,
0.0011007647,
-0.0056482763,
-0.0076961699,
0.0304610617,
0.0483605191,
-0.0720260888,
-0.0171122756,
0.0212973673,
2.738e-7,
0.0422903039,
0.0571846105,
0.0345742926,
0.0249661021,
0.0142138507,
0.0587311499,
-0.0002642103,
0.0756675377,
-0.0039235316,
0.0115199471,
0.0128675001,
0.0053059421,
0.0599536225,
0.0766660422,
-0.0438666977,
-0.0270980839,
-0.094058387,
0.0194326043,
-0.0464457758,
-0.0063807936,
0.0516153723,
0.0701571256,
-0.005425449,
-0.0301750731,
0.0058083693,
-0.058405567,
0.0038216275,
-0.0355861485,
0.0178486146,
0.0042818598,
0.0031309274,
0.0533911847,
0.051173944,
0.0039432272,
-0.0205527935,
-0.0244477168,
-0.0070556267,
0.0789000615,
-0.0384104289,
-0.0267446265,
-0.0109368786,
-0.0499791242,
0.0183288194,
-0.0666725039,
0.0335943326,
0.0140711637,
-0.0015294426,
-0.0250329357,
-0.0249101762,
-0.0138585735,
0.0165810287,
-0.0315147042,
-0.0257826559,
0.0303243548,
0.0182552803,
0.033634048,
0.0059434026,
-0.0296249986,
-0.0438441411,
-0.0214125644,
-0.0054865079,
-0.0673765913,
-0.0256749503,
0.0533663221,
0.0038836815,
-0.0669262633,
0.0365897119,
2.773918023e-34,
0.003785765,
-0.0411092974,
0.0158593692,
0.0224280078,
0.0448931605,
0.0279625915,
0.0076935403,
0.0197566021,
0.0101902848,
-0.0140099768,
-0.0437117741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12269v1 | Unveiling Implicit Table Knowledge with Question-Then-Pinpoint Reasoner for Insightful Table Summarization | 2024-06-18T04:55:09 | 2024-06-18T04:55:09 | Kwangwook Seo, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Implicit knowledge hidden within the explicit table cells, such as data
insights, is the key to generating a high-quality table summary. However,
unveiling such implicit knowledge is a non-trivial task. Due to the complex
nature of structured tables, it is challenging even for large language models
(LLMs) to mine the implicit knowledge in an insightful and faithful manner. To
address this challenge, we propose a novel table reasoning framework
Question-then-Pinpoint. Our work focuses on building a plug-and-play table
reasoner that can self-question the insightful knowledge and answer it by
faithfully pinpointing evidence on the table to provide explainable guidance
for the summarizer. To train a reliable reasoner, we collect table knowledge by
guiding a teacher LLM to follow the coarse-to-fine reasoning paths and refine
it through two quality enhancement strategies to selectively distill the
high-quality knowledge to the reasoner. Extensive experiments on two table
summarization datasets, including our newly proposed InsTaSumm, validate the
general effectiveness of our framework. | [
0.030034991,
0.0591079369,
0.0065106517,
0.0125032356,
-0.000610272,
0.0459034517,
-0.0285538789,
0.0006868296,
-0.03716195,
-0.0025482681,
0.0075145774,
0.0404134393,
-0.0061507002,
0.0043743509,
0.0239695124,
-0.0082144821,
0.030916959,
-0.0053042718,
-0.0158930197,
0.0349890515,
0.0294045489,
0.0044540837,
-0.0257482287,
0.0290378612,
-0.0123861684,
-0.0044286018,
-0.0370973758,
-0.0111235548,
-0.0185851268,
0.008290614,
0.0028229591,
0.0468755066,
0.0136526572,
0.0157066509,
0.0000019431,
-0.0009471551,
-0.0768719241,
-0.0028844776,
-0.0431598537,
0.0070903115,
-0.0353582427,
-0.037103802,
0.0111886282,
-0.0033408364,
-0.0361191519,
0.0131176142,
-0.0159436986,
0.0788795575,
0.0671664849,
0.0368850194,
0.0131091624,
-0.0126252277,
-0.0084228478,
0.0038932886,
0.0519407243,
-0.0336620957,
-0.0315488353,
0.0559652559,
-0.0324446261,
-0.0181966256,
0.0205648504,
0.038958922,
0.0319622867,
-0.0696317554,
0.0085846754,
0.0287009068,
-0.0192320943,
0.0357627422,
0.0160826202,
0.0721528232,
0.0153647456,
-0.0245823041,
0.0342990234,
-0.0102814799,
0.040145319,
0.0025766233,
-0.0544513613,
0.0054229493,
-0.0131730828,
0.0012528222,
0.0341292135,
-0.0070272009,
-0.0074923746,
0.0138120912,
-0.0297538657,
0.0560426675,
-0.0525447875,
-0.0149544021,
-0.0041541052,
-0.0057921358,
0.0055654664,
-0.0481471978,
0.0026892335,
0.0920560136,
-0.0406261906,
0.0039072316,
0.0347974896,
-0.0013446865,
0.0167020988,
-0.0188727528,
-0.0086865881,
0.0332578979,
0.0124342516,
0.0357798375,
-0.0412235968,
-0.0114470748,
0.0071611744,
0.0541213974,
-0.0245525409,
-0.0381662697,
-0.0383881293,
0.0023958907,
-0.0408923477,
0.0112443361,
-0.0488541387,
0.019743057,
0.014118243,
0.0075660632,
-0.0273480266,
0.0676236898,
-0.0140373502,
0.0281593055,
-0.0003948767,
-0.0291979797,
-0.0423005298,
0.0067076888,
-0.0559852272,
-0.0287508387,
0.0168898087,
-0.0320100933,
-0.0310814809,
-0.0213363022,
0.0250918642,
0.0170097817,
0.0336878523,
0.0331765525,
-0.0707770362,
0.0016723032,
-0.0713798478,
-0.0703265071,
-0.0177546795,
-0.0460878126,
-0.0216150414,
-0.0382985994,
-0.0089176409,
0.0124455085,
-0.0040668626,
-0.0506811962,
0.0124421334,
0.0225973837,
-0.0001147418,
0.0515963025,
-0.0084959427,
0.0248860475,
-0.0087276073,
-0.0016410975,
-0.0298994314,
0.062260285,
0.0380812511,
0.0165427271,
-0.0043436335,
-0.0267795678,
-0.0179186296,
-0.0059451344,
0.0497883298,
-0.0081686452,
0.0026721128,
0.0512797609,
-0.0328653194,
0.0072484864,
-0.0073991641,
-0.0077524409,
-0.0049386807,
0.0873743668,
0.0324372873,
0.036269322,
0.0148700541,
0.0794827864,
-0.001731357,
-0.0057535381,
0.0262438413,
0.0444969721,
-0.012101748,
0.0624868497,
0.012570763,
0.0267509725,
0.0668916181,
-0.0070406301,
-0.0056759836,
-0.107007131,
0.0246320684,
0.0297759771,
-0.0239681844,
0.0352897123,
0.0330954269,
0.0290864669,
-0.0425527133,
-0.0021040079,
-0.0069617918,
-0.068719551,
-0.0166919399,
-0.0278950296,
0.0784378946,
0.0547132194,
0.0454606377,
-0.0745817274,
-0.0136411004,
-0.0196494795,
0.0277207755,
0.0097449468,
0.0305437595,
-0.0632258132,
-0.012600923,
0.0035203872,
-0.0415792353,
0.0193431675,
0.0390023999,
-0.0539373234,
0.021255454,
-0.0372059904,
0.0234904233,
-0.0607687794,
-0.0480274223,
0.0264825355,
0.0487437323,
0.0031518573,
-0.0087449057,
0.0060342792,
-0.0144826882,
0.0483039729,
0.0068655973,
0.0288036913,
0.0273947511,
-0.0198846199,
0.0112611903,
-0.0145122213,
-0.0226568729,
0.0122108785,
0.0429343916,
-0.0008930105,
-0.0838325322,
-0.0535783805,
-0.0476927944,
-0.0578894578,
-0.0024101753,
-0.0121375974,
-0.0345474184,
-0.0381520987,
-0.0102654472,
0.0069387993,
-0.0057025305,
0.0099506285,
0.0821174458,
0.0121131605,
-0.0057081939,
0.0141526647,
-0.0950012207,
0.0219486784,
-0.011033535,
0.0484502614,
-0.0296767708,
-0.0277725626,
0.0370314196,
0.0376329832,
0.0165415481,
-0.0654805079,
0.0052869245,
-0.0612950735,
0.012215158,
-0.0313760266,
-0.00999605,
0.033376731,
-0.0023487525,
-0.0064603803,
-0.0200402103,
-0.0507882349,
-0.0063146157,
0.0098496713,
-0.021391334,
0.0883654654,
-0.0058930353,
0.0188717209,
-0.0451887324,
-0.0107303234,
-0.0265514869,
0.0115055442,
0.0163699947,
0.0012958391,
-0.002810522,
-0.0182818864,
-0.0018650934,
-0.0059409537,
0.0363159776,
-0.0014001391,
0.0029434457,
-0.0289915428,
0.0010211924,
0.0596276522,
-0.0163304172,
0.022720715,
0.0149428174,
-0.0172066968,
-0.0427393913,
0.0195136238,
-0.0055215345,
0.0455098301,
0.0368761495,
-0.0370354019,
0.0331761055,
0.040999528,
-0.0316106826,
-0.0186428428,
-0.0311491303,
0.0435143262,
0.0171364695,
0.0239396188,
-0.0942568928,
0.0464879796,
0.0403438322,
0.0471262634,
-0.0380494073,
0.0047668493,
0.0404981598,
-0.0409096666,
0.0367994234,
0.0070692562,
-0.0148226069,
-0.0525474213,
0.060067039,
-0.0196007285,
-0.0038802139,
-0.0118606938,
0.0009426036,
-0.0393502899,
-0.0372839421,
0.0599146038,
-0.0279950257,
0.1562176049,
-0.0755614787,
-0.0035851202,
-0.0000571084,
-0.0141277388,
-0.0239527021,
-0.0389512591,
-0.0412644781,
0.0102510964,
0.0169556364,
-0.0102312528,
-0.0313990042,
-0.0317122303,
0.0528669246,
0.0659652129,
-0.0098816529,
-0.0507099815,
-0.0100066774,
0.0163736958,
0.0349313356,
0.0346738808,
-0.0037275448,
-0.0189474542,
0.0689871535,
0.0576393455,
-0.0061342292,
-0.0599209554,
-0.0048446502,
0.0248890389,
-0.0158736166,
-0.0331218056,
0.0407242253,
0.0325228088,
0.0088340696,
-0.0716887861,
-0.0158257298,
0.0806803182,
0.0265023727,
0.0221051127,
-0.0109421164,
-0.0083707999,
0.0250894465,
0.0119661558,
0.0349737965,
-0.0722489655,
-0.0371055454,
-0.001568772,
0.0045319577,
0.0148754586,
-0.0480697192,
-0.0161326807,
-0.0934197977,
0.0176141728,
-0.0252026394,
-0.0511720739,
-0.0711923093,
-0.0268631633,
-0.0033718699,
-0.0284568649,
0.030174749,
0.0627255589,
-0.0039335489,
0.0214503594,
0.0328701101,
-0.0649653003,
-0.0006398091,
-0.0277131442,
-0.0429561511,
0.0190069135,
0.0310871899,
0.0405742861,
0.0102989273,
0.023937026,
-0.0017041042,
-0.0178662892,
0.0266088545,
0.0116851013,
0.0873388723,
0.0114883184,
0.0204849262,
-0.0097391428,
0.030520821,
-0.0242830049,
0.0044810697,
0.0345746279,
0.0505330488,
-0.0160529781,
0.0110623287,
0.0190135129,
-0.0034118651,
-0.0412600823,
0.063483946,
0.0519858189,
0.0265674274,
-0.0297949295,
-0.0509205721,
-0.0590230301,
-0.0786872283,
0.0264615342,
0.0392497778,
-0.0225484334,
-0.0052177049,
-0.0450268947,
-0.0308405869,
0.0708482042,
0.0208815672,
0.0000094155,
0.0342489108,
-0.0410143919,
-0.0009855104,
-0.0532797836,
-0.0085332301,
-0.0459851585,
0.0017889902,
0.0104553085,
-0.0309033003,
-0.017498387,
-0.0358965546,
-0.0004695095,
0.0293615721,
-0.0162511114,
-0.0100369006,
-0.0248790439,
0.0052908123,
0.021512758,
0.0486238524,
-0.0043379101,
0.0010338594,
0.0113057438,
-0.0115096364,
-0.0499671176,
-0.0761349499,
0.0295408424,
-0.0298569947,
0.0200565942,
0.050690677,
-0.0393534936,
-0.0065419669,
-0.0030776754,
0.023635529,
-0.0202196296,
0.0238826293,
0.0607256778,
0.013912865,
0.0085974019,
0.0314457603,
-0.0536539294,
-0.0335719101,
0.0155688105,
-0.0445877276,
-0.0611472204,
0.0040979641,
0.0382413752,
-0.0066540041,
-0.017019188,
-0.0088911112,
0.0089910105,
0.0248308145,
0.0304818489,
-0.0269078314,
0.0014924892,
0.0126513578,
-0.0356312506,
-0.0351388045,
-0.0278384369,
-0.0069177994,
-0.012380627,
0.0208208915,
0.0182445757,
0.0049141282,
0.0210710298,
0.0431268513,
-0.0181568656,
-0.0273965299,
0.0261766296,
-0.0762087852,
-0.0112785986,
-0.0118818348,
-0.0212340821,
0.0258480422,
-0.0203875601,
0.0304437652,
-0.0058199489,
-0.0149925752,
0.0529921614,
0.0606730841,
0.0551835522,
0.0055224169,
-0.0179660115,
0.004620831,
-0.0013011635,
-0.0322999246,
0.085210368,
-0.0296774209,
0.0125189852,
-0.001430331,
-0.0337590724,
-0.062628597,
-0.0082305744,
-0.0298977327,
-0.0035184138,
-0.0109851025,
-0.0249225684,
-0.0252859835,
-0.0371750556,
0.0088398326,
0.0562209524,
-0.0295717884,
0.0052405926,
-0.0116051715,
0.0447414108,
0.0562812947,
-0.0213878192,
-0.0496848896,
0.0120358234,
-0.0107799256,
-0.0091862492,
-0.004431867,
-6.088783027e-33,
-0.0457500182,
-0.0369317494,
0.0096051032,
-0.0376256816,
0.0188700669,
-0.0026550323,
-0.0794185624,
-0.0312689692,
-0.0026552798,
0.0505007952,
-0.0527298376,
0.0679467395,
0.007967378,
-0.0181213897,
0.0316952318,
-0.0586513281,
0.0322117023,
0.0189437997,
-0.0236596465,
0.0213775244,
0.0247382447,
-0.0007987727,
-0.0029635322,
-0.0023462065,
0.0687837005,
0.0200152826,
-0.0256749112,
0.0108271092,
-0.0094613479,
0.0281918477,
-0.0115596773,
0.0149105145,
0.0262530297,
-0.0588957705,
-0.0509579107,
-0.0220073145,
-0.1621442288,
-0.0304579679,
-0.0029343409,
-0.0111663193,
-0.0178301577,
-0.0317599289,
0.0245169997,
-0.0094280764,
0.0091859875,
-0.033973597,
0.0389919952,
-0.0495507084,
0.0061322358,
-0.0264666304,
0.0130210873,
0.0307227671,
-0.061559055,
-0.0053466195,
0.075792484,
0.0163859408,
0.0491870493,
-0.0571601205,
-0.0277361795,
0.0465591699,
0.0321633182,
0.019818699,
0.0585297197,
-0.027072724,
-0.0064627333,
0.0251247045,
-0.0011238989,
0.0017608656,
-0.0458917506,
0.0167286415,
-0.0622581057,
0.0508141965,
0.0769967809,
0.0109442044,
0.0452364907,
0.020114515,
-0.0554366,
0.0933596045,
-0.0185160059,
-0.0007680898,
-0.0299407206,
-0.0266130809,
-0.0165355504,
-0.0122639211,
-0.0181574989,
0.0085683707,
-0.0134595679,
0.0017406784,
-0.0050128186,
-0.0059633739,
-0.0131908739,
0.000083986,
-0.0307398904,
0.0009643096,
-0.006926307,
0.0342875905,
0.0058431909,
-0.0202625729,
0.0123096677,
-0.0252441987,
-0.0104572298,
-0.0020064556,
0.0160412304,
-0.0149348807,
0.0343715996,
0.0602415092,
0.0866472647,
0.0082328375,
-0.0385877639,
-0.0002110402,
-0.0323458873,
0.0550703034,
-0.0261824019,
-0.0134076616,
-0.0197078455,
0.0153747182,
-0.02070296,
0.0457466617,
0.0230310373,
0.0256966911,
0.0062183761,
0.0475448295,
-0.0008207057,
-0.0113003897,
0.0346152186,
-0.0091556096,
-0.0174506214,
-0.0302446652,
0.0317468569,
-0.0350054093,
0.0007320775,
0.0118543478,
2.347e-7,
0.0581117608,
0.0086941849,
0.0758156478,
0.0208770651,
-0.0297150388,
0.0250958037,
-0.0135361282,
-0.0555727929,
-0.0316166244,
-0.0377854146,
0.0529136211,
0.0231662598,
0.0675977767,
0.0434194729,
0.0052436953,
-0.0677788928,
-0.0402572863,
-0.035940621,
-0.0328793563,
0.0080593321,
0.0322245546,
0.0458290987,
-0.0545138642,
-0.0092230067,
-0.0034071531,
-0.0310831629,
-0.0061356565,
-0.0545632057,
0.0437884778,
0.031618502,
0.0991627574,
-0.0351355039,
0.0005635897,
0.0557833761,
-0.0435734317,
-0.0149806384,
-0.0129468553,
0.0224923231,
0.0009797367,
0.0339003056,
-0.0263192467,
-0.0702738836,
0.0698814541,
-0.0522049591,
0.1014584973,
-0.0480224565,
-0.0057807183,
0.0916013792,
-0.0153677678,
0.0052264053,
-0.0341130644,
0.0352009609,
-0.0240396317,
0.0243296511,
-0.0017704356,
0.0047417907,
0.0267417002,
-0.0590504743,
-0.0504087359,
0.0243006907,
0.025264591,
-0.0044243829,
0.0070101433,
-0.0451118238,
-0.0181230381,
-0.05894408,
-0.0278156623,
2.028577693e-34,
0.0507946424,
0.013123625,
0.0133751007,
0.0077671148,
0.0993974581,
-0.0245368276,
-0.0141304098,
-0.027755538,
0.0404867679,
-0.0591185167,
-0.0217093006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12266v2 | Towards a Client-Centered Assessment of LLM Therapists by Client Simulation | 2024-06-18T04:46:55 | 2024-06-20T22:06:47 | Jiashuo Wang, Yang Xiao, Yanran Li, Changhe Song, Chunpu Xu, Chenhao Tan, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although there is a growing belief that LLMs can be used as therapists,
exploring LLMs' capabilities and inefficacy, particularly from the client's
perspective, is limited. This work focuses on a client-centered assessment of
LLM therapists with the involvement of simulated clients, a standard approach
in clinical medical education. However, there are two challenges when applying
the approach to assess LLM therapists at scale. Ethically, asking humans to
frequently mimic clients and exposing them to potentially harmful LLM outputs
can be risky and unsafe. Technically, it can be difficult to consistently
compare the performances of different LLM therapists interacting with the same
client. To this end, we adopt LLMs to simulate clients and propose ClientCAST,
a client-centered approach to assessing LLM therapists by client simulation.
Specifically, the simulated client is utilized to interact with LLM therapists
and complete questionnaires related to the interaction. Based on the
questionnaire results, we assess LLM therapists from three client-centered
aspects: session outcome, therapeutic alliance, and self-reported feelings. We
conduct experiments to examine the reliability of ClientCAST and use it to
evaluate LLMs therapists implemented by Claude-3, GPT-3.5, LLaMA3-70B, and
Mixtral 8*7B. Codes are released at https://github.com/wangjs9/ClientCAST. | [
0.0447487421,
-0.0333705284,
-0.0249950457,
-0.008953481,
-0.0315247141,
0.0240826439,
0.0287996214,
0.02188728,
0.0358789936,
0.0428781249,
-0.0599174052,
-0.0027824908,
-0.0380144902,
-0.0394363366,
0.0262156464,
-0.0621997975,
0.0060479413,
0.0505893752,
-0.0153629864,
0.0341702476,
-0.0126786903,
-0.008558115,
-0.0543560609,
0.0226341039,
0.0684617534,
0.0122802407,
-0.0019403702,
0.0513327569,
0.0617391169,
-0.0509416908,
-0.009235248,
-0.0209565554,
0.0384792127,
-0.0109502077,
0.0000023341,
-0.0050583789,
-0.0170624442,
-0.0017469246,
-0.0151251312,
-0.0303925034,
0.0534944721,
0.0227458924,
0.0059081926,
0.0364421345,
-0.0015719278,
0.0503624044,
0.0044079009,
-0.0059283595,
0.0617165081,
0.0306450669,
0.0103679821,
0.049112577,
-0.0373037346,
0.0131276222,
0.0181268975,
0.0219069887,
-0.0111261439,
0.0053330506,
0.0573288873,
-0.03812306,
-0.008308392,
-0.0115943523,
0.0043657799,
0.031748604,
0.0516467579,
0.0323488191,
0.0017857166,
-0.045141317,
-0.0311364196,
0.035876736,
0.0756726637,
0.0393722132,
0.0218463298,
-0.0055240714,
0.0348972753,
-0.020146016,
-0.037798252,
-0.0193061549,
0.0328330398,
0.0287578106,
-0.0371542685,
0.0116720712,
0.0200884566,
-0.0217644069,
0.0820183158,
-0.0336092748,
0.0128058251,
-0.0082585588,
0.0142739536,
0.0197008178,
0.0090608168,
-0.0275010839,
0.023370713,
0.0650702342,
-0.0358239524,
-0.0201221053,
0.0006731831,
0.0203590691,
0.0388279334,
0.042679105,
0.0600078851,
0.0341018103,
-0.0127098905,
-0.0067983055,
0.003461082,
0.0042239008,
0.0100944815,
0.0479072705,
-0.0078234812,
0.0891417563,
-0.0253850594,
0.0347773843,
0.0221073125,
-0.0171569102,
0.0279053394,
0.0076260278,
-0.0605622791,
-0.0226973444,
-0.0331336409,
0.0339615643,
-0.0372108594,
0.0151259927,
0.0303837117,
0.0547954887,
-0.0340102576,
-0.0015594339,
-0.0030212498,
0.0125967721,
0.012554951,
-0.0603814125,
0.0336044952,
0.0089538917,
-0.0528952442,
0.0108917626,
0.0435923189,
0.0610204376,
-0.0113309305,
-0.0287571382,
-0.0162416399,
-0.0106941732,
0.0182548165,
-0.0191047564,
0.0858719051,
-0.0557618961,
0.0162007008,
-0.0249231067,
0.0147645213,
-0.022285955,
0.0361393839,
-0.0133596128,
-0.0150244879,
0.0761097893,
-0.0401889794,
0.0174870417,
0.0300703552,
0.0921700597,
0.002847865,
-0.0043334332,
0.0156300999,
-0.0207363032,
0.0114046009,
-0.060290277,
0.0230265334,
-0.0060502924,
0.0092342738,
0.0192658007,
-0.0108558964,
-0.0351283401,
-0.0179488193,
0.0977449194,
-0.0380099341,
-0.0057257246,
-0.0564196445,
0.0472467504,
0.0457082726,
0.0339034349,
0.089963913,
-0.0131645603,
-0.0160746034,
-0.0149637014,
0.0229112059,
-0.0094278352,
-0.0633964241,
0.0587813966,
0.0280681513,
0.0020684686,
-0.0138443131,
0.0055396608,
-0.0228151381,
-0.0122248111,
-0.0371511728,
-0.0331569463,
-0.0383611806,
0.0149221839,
-0.0399106294,
-0.0279692952,
-0.008095596,
0.0447545275,
0.0180300102,
-0.0345944092,
-0.0077901874,
-0.0739784315,
-0.0183728002,
0.1006312743,
0.0241228156,
-0.0093478486,
-0.0246936921,
-0.0459745377,
-0.0063534062,
0.0272284579,
0.013705329,
0.0232481081,
-0.0063840197,
0.0055181007,
-0.0365060866,
0.011324767,
-0.0148976995,
0.029258579,
-0.0178041738,
0.0110168159,
-0.0432123877,
-0.019507762,
0.0174271706,
0.0535788611,
-0.096615009,
-0.0456043184,
-0.029296115,
-0.0404519066,
0.0571281873,
0.0149280755,
0.0040186574,
-0.000448928,
0.0462087803,
0.0266744066,
0.0044285767,
0.0120538445,
-0.0237759687,
0.0305651631,
-0.0158435944,
-0.0228431076,
0.0129145542,
0.0011870486,
-0.0041447403,
0.0284420047,
-0.0102019729,
-0.0207780078,
0.0978643224,
-0.0138358306,
0.0092509286,
0.0042163348,
0.0043535768,
-0.0353151523,
-0.0334683806,
-0.0225465484,
0.0416308306,
0.0049181269,
-0.0361880958,
-0.0448528305,
-0.030921733,
-0.0095396237,
0.0058741365,
-0.0352602154,
0.0019238052,
-0.0638250187,
0.0510767736,
-0.08321511,
-0.0107800672,
-0.0847776383,
0.004492728,
0.0021313061,
-0.0199245922,
0.0117692668,
-0.0666681975,
-0.0468744338,
0.0148882037,
-0.0254470147,
0.0209578034,
0.0378579125,
-0.0042642406,
-0.0080297487,
-0.0022420322,
-0.0288645774,
-0.0277644396,
0.0193885323,
-0.0199638624,
0.0022108178,
-0.0167434607,
0.0589880832,
0.0018880073,
-0.0025218597,
-0.0169364661,
-0.0522378869,
-0.0136210723,
-0.0603857078,
0.0602035522,
0.0475325361,
0.0117885936,
-0.014141758,
0.0182854347,
0.026766615,
0.0290083829,
0.0301850792,
-0.0285971835,
-0.0186296403,
0.0024972195,
-0.1060611382,
-0.0346908383,
-0.103380233,
-0.0170910992,
0.0397481024,
0.0036047816,
0.0456760749,
0.0185953546,
-0.0070137735,
0.0302258115,
0.0158290714,
0.0240367372,
0.0115818419,
-0.0353118777,
-0.0294497944,
0.0095264567,
-0.0106443763,
0.0301249512,
-0.0134186801,
-0.0050756754,
0.0188268498,
-0.0140349614,
0.0025411267,
-0.0093579283,
-0.0504071526,
-0.0232681967,
-0.0318699665,
-0.0149712367,
0.016859306,
-0.055083707,
-0.0200864635,
-0.041599568,
0.0050287386,
-0.0615999028,
-0.0226737633,
-0.0157774296,
0.0331277773,
-0.0545460135,
0.0170261543,
-0.0131549183,
-0.0282635819,
-0.0244094972,
0.0416270718,
-0.0368189141,
-0.0797611475,
0.0436486602,
0.0002335445,
0.026279429,
-0.0142191648,
0.0162158143,
-0.0307301302,
-0.0199814439,
0.0230484176,
0.0505046919,
-0.0421989672,
0.0178037249,
0.0631825253,
0.0030212905,
0.0079022497,
-0.0276320782,
-0.0040537328,
-0.0078772325,
0.0082727904,
0.0329747014,
0.0386642218,
0.0353943035,
0.0314695649,
-0.0073366882,
0.0677377358,
0.0029862195,
-0.0478745699,
0.02944782,
-0.0330416784,
-0.022331981,
-0.0031552843,
-0.0398764834,
-0.0620772094,
-0.0097708562,
-0.0229019132,
0.0962266549,
-0.0503899865,
-0.011933066,
0.0355058685,
-0.0153139504,
0.0451398455,
0.00194223,
0.0448542908,
-0.0098293703,
-0.0038862429,
0.0320490003,
0.0054410789,
0.0351193845,
0.0068042991,
0.005085255,
-0.0028627298,
0.0221874099,
-0.035562098,
-0.0273146294,
0.0532429665,
0.0043799109,
0.104689315,
0.0039286609,
0.016640842,
-0.0200252794,
-0.0741855055,
-0.031689629,
0.0230187867,
0.035272155,
0.0194443539,
-0.0019372938,
0.0071299938,
0.0593241677,
-0.0182249099,
0.050349243,
-0.0272404663,
-0.0111902831,
0.0133997705,
0.0247343145,
-0.0564107113,
-0.019676825,
-0.000077152,
0.0757433623,
0.0308263022,
0.0077595459,
0.0200117566,
-0.0011296589,
0.0343562812,
0.0231713746,
0.0210272186,
0.0741264746,
-0.035665635,
-0.0209229011,
-0.0319007821,
0.0449190773,
-0.0228351783,
-0.0097146668,
0.0179238282,
-0.0018593799,
-0.0425132662,
-0.0237401891,
-0.0739092529,
-0.005852106,
-0.0132071208,
0.0354446992,
0.0294086281,
0.0369568132,
-0.0424891114,
0.0022378657,
0.0147646358,
-0.0465324447,
0.0104560712,
0.0052520055,
-0.0099076005,
-0.0013427512,
0.0357140489,
0.0542999282,
0.0322158709,
0.0028387432,
0.039013274,
0.0608683005,
-0.0133054079,
0.0713243932,
-0.0461424887,
0.0385086574,
-0.0223678723,
0.0535793118,
-0.0084020272,
-0.0397108421,
0.0173022356,
0.0101848105,
0.014921586,
-0.0075948141,
-0.0064348532,
-0.0430935584,
-0.0098387776,
0.0455135219,
0.028151989,
-0.0398760885,
0.0405536629,
0.0096789096,
-0.0005744806,
-0.0477714427,
0.0526503362,
-0.0036620207,
-0.077884458,
0.010256852,
0.0143896723,
0.0116950553,
-0.0663913637,
-0.078307122,
-0.041148264,
-0.040065024,
0.0398070961,
-0.0071123522,
-0.0580330528,
-0.0220448952,
0.0024250918,
-0.0121630365,
-0.005752312,
-0.0028517593,
0.0215753485,
0.0179600008,
0.0674676746,
-0.0005464964,
0.0152091188,
0.0243171267,
0.0461827815,
0.0069175782,
-0.0754582435,
-0.0359275863,
0.0695109218,
-0.0031030984,
0.0668349862,
-0.0247384347,
-0.0617242493,
0.0381620564,
-0.006472196,
0.009423364,
-0.0748845339,
0.0043942407,
-0.0110643636,
0.0021491437,
0.0062485454,
-0.0339010432,
-0.0194611922,
-0.0184632223,
0.0208760742,
-0.0555287302,
0.003093427,
-0.0386329778,
0.0078686513,
0.0279954039,
-0.0221272595,
-0.0198772084,
-0.0271975584,
-0.0372591987,
-0.0241950024,
0.022407962,
-0.0029360389,
-0.0286547262,
-0.0870428309,
0.0351877138,
-0.0221886523,
-0.0083033675,
-0.0139621785,
-0.0087910295,
0.0355286822,
0.0450538993,
-0.0026766027,
0.0051739574,
-5.776561809e-33,
-0.0051225722,
-0.0329850353,
0.0560322106,
0.0232853275,
-0.0831815451,
-0.0298732147,
-0.0443270057,
0.0109039834,
0.0236807559,
-0.026797941,
0.0321045555,
0.0061556511,
0.0022536935,
-0.0177077707,
0.0260621738,
-0.049249135,
-0.0146503644,
-0.0230029486,
-0.0104587832,
-0.0413705967,
-0.1014051363,
0.0333537869,
0.0245668311,
-0.0774351507,
0.0291362647,
-0.0068707676,
-0.0218148604,
-0.0310028419,
-0.0525315739,
-0.0130122062,
0.0077641848,
0.0124499137,
0.0170630552,
-0.0146810198,
0.0264802892,
-0.0299109966,
-0.0280278176,
-0.0041714404,
-0.004558837,
-0.044313658,
-0.110574685,
0.0144547513,
0.051728949,
-0.0186217297,
-0.0394703522,
-0.0218402501,
0.0131656369,
-0.0201783385,
0.0118038366,
0.026295742,
0.0147333844,
-0.0251209028,
0.0014337953,
-0.0457549021,
-0.0400994383,
0.0164162498,
-0.0789114982,
0.0149282329,
-0.0667969584,
-0.0008719799,
0.0255478285,
-0.0497692265,
0.0266973544,
-0.0503944121,
0.0275398903,
0.0081748478,
-0.0260455068,
-0.0191930234,
-0.044479318,
-0.0254327226,
0.014012266,
0.0436765328,
0.0518257879,
0.0382231846,
-0.0726618096,
-0.0238102637,
0.0019204179,
0.0258296635,
0.0198349319,
-0.0064137694,
-0.0052353675,
0.0420505628,
0.0095241508,
-0.0049687992,
-0.0083886925,
-0.0392050855,
0.0171347577,
-0.0614850335,
0.0233426522,
-0.0034003372,
-0.0057261507,
-0.0580803901,
-0.0065719225,
0.0182484388,
0.0545854978,
-0.0851743594,
0.022200726,
0.0563937463,
-0.0022619329,
-0.0397603177,
-0.0579485968,
0.0131493071,
-0.0088983253,
-0.0415322147,
0.0889005959,
-0.025867926,
-0.0020884466,
-0.0145226987,
-0.0308260079,
0.0119171673,
-0.0010109789,
0.0717955083,
0.0796543062,
-0.03497006,
-0.0348428041,
-0.0336142816,
-0.0123655489,
0.0082037561,
-0.0037035104,
-0.0181635935,
-0.0460797027,
0.0042135697,
-0.0728684142,
0.0147733651,
-0.0133394683,
0.0315718986,
-0.0259592608,
0.0192379002,
0.0452431589,
-0.0004349013,
0.0086268857,
-0.0619986244,
2.98e-7,
-0.034178298,
0.0275134016,
0.029719973,
0.0002341421,
0.0194646791,
0.0307090674,
-0.0277886577,
0.0901483223,
0.0505266972,
-0.1056295261,
0.0413980037,
0.0198114477,
0.0375974886,
0.0284206066,
0.009130029,
-0.0065064896,
-0.0164549015,
-0.0039063664,
0.0100466646,
-0.0257765967,
0.013738378,
-0.0466796756,
0.0106182918,
-0.0282600578,
0.0128442599,
0.0229665022,
0.0177039914,
-0.0750235319,
-0.010201863,
-0.0003716976,
0.0463421941,
-0.01344065,
0.0120944073,
0.0383690782,
-0.0215444434,
-0.0611417033,
-0.0043354067,
0.0944744572,
-0.03917896,
-0.0338518322,
0.0110893864,
0.0048664734,
0.0250645746,
0.0099429982,
-0.0094270743,
-0.057020437,
0.0015271477,
0.0414002687,
-0.0761615261,
-0.0390378051,
0.0871071219,
-0.0458084978,
-0.010327708,
0.0655347034,
-0.0111165522,
0.0322883613,
-0.0038966325,
0.0025991455,
0.0111588817,
0.0052346247,
-0.0452727079,
-0.0403207056,
0.0328112431,
0.0048718862,
-0.0767374784,
-0.0751036555,
-0.0456227399,
2.213885194e-34,
-0.0408011563,
0.0468007661,
0.0438289829,
0.0311955307,
0.0155445123,
0.0349901877,
-0.012115987,
0.0645765811,
0.0113704186,
0.0336201936,
-0.0012894927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12263v1 | Defending Against Social Engineering Attacks in the Age of LLMs | 2024-06-18T04:39:40 | 2024-06-18T04:39:40 | Lin Ai, Tharindu Kumarage, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Zizhou Liu, Zheng Hui, Michael Davinroy, James Cook, Laura Cassani, Kirill Trapeznikov, Matthias Kirchner, Arslan Basharat, Anthony Hoogs, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) poses challenges in
detecting and mitigating digital deception, as these models can emulate human
conversational patterns and facilitate chat-based social engineering (CSE)
attacks. This study investigates the dual capabilities of LLMs as both
facilitators and defenders against CSE threats. We develop a novel dataset,
SEConvo, simulating CSE scenarios in academic and recruitment contexts, and
designed to examine how LLMs can be exploited in these situations. Our findings
reveal that, while off-the-shelf LLMs generate high-quality CSE content, their
detection capabilities are suboptimal, leading to increased operational costs
for defense. In response, we propose ConvoSentinel, a modular defense pipeline
that improves detection at both the message and the conversation levels,
offering enhanced adaptability and cost-effectiveness. The retrieval-augmented
module in ConvoSentinel identifies malicious intent by comparing messages to a
database of similar conversations, enhancing CSE detection at all stages. Our
study highlights the need for advanced strategies to leverage LLMs in
cybersecurity. | [
0.0951648355,
0.0562753342,
-0.0263511222,
0.0410160199,
-0.0803128481,
-0.0318058692,
0.0362968892,
0.0251672454,
0.0432146229,
-0.0521046445,
-0.0224778652,
-0.0523533933,
0.006768852,
0.0635978505,
0.0611635298,
0.0379615948,
0.0362999961,
-0.0003128201,
-0.0017122427,
0.0031752889,
0.0216982961,
0.0006027006,
0.0021471628,
0.044083517,
0.009072884,
0.0008693305,
-0.0211743787,
0.0170290601,
0.0240774043,
-0.0012393605,
0.0398872867,
0.0540349521,
0.0029063828,
0.0586639754,
0.0000020865,
-0.0817179903,
-0.035259828,
-0.0020168948,
-0.038493447,
0.0519012138,
0.0742607862,
0.001701751,
-0.0242866296,
0.0320585556,
-0.0591707192,
0.039350722,
0.0201651827,
0.0120563312,
0.0791918784,
0.1111127958,
-0.0182797294,
-0.0101441322,
0.0175847057,
-0.021985814,
-0.0225369688,
0.0040559298,
0.0328371897,
-0.0183800813,
0.0300121512,
0.0782562122,
0.0462034456,
0.0000889998,
-0.0592272952,
-0.0295660459,
-0.007732288,
0.0078647295,
-0.019726634,
-0.0140497945,
0.0056624012,
0.0276474375,
-0.0245673507,
-0.011465664,
0.0446020178,
-0.0015085161,
0.0191887021,
0.027458895,
0.0110065071,
0.0215672776,
-0.0409230813,
-0.035991177,
-0.0228872355,
0.0055333399,
0.0368095115,
0.0294662099,
0.0106506189,
-0.0097404234,
-0.0124429343,
-0.0198292565,
-0.0128335021,
-0.0732137635,
0.0346161276,
-0.041480571,
0.0327678397,
0.0146258464,
-0.023404438,
-0.0109236175,
-0.0420576148,
-0.0516480505,
0.0580316894,
-0.0515911132,
-0.0326654017,
0.0337549523,
0.0010523496,
0.0086637475,
0.0076969406,
0.0385917835,
-0.0291981418,
0.0091399672,
0.0050320486,
-0.0026430311,
-0.0403658897,
-0.0219735391,
-0.0196531992,
0.0177635625,
0.0248877369,
0.0071229916,
-0.0755374953,
0.014011451,
-0.0662214383,
0.0400412418,
-0.0290100314,
0.0025681085,
-0.0045108804,
0.0178382471,
0.0154665019,
-0.0153936679,
0.0269000251,
-0.0112983836,
-0.0153841777,
-0.1017837301,
-0.0047948691,
0.0070598205,
-0.0173544623,
-0.0306572728,
0.0006466741,
0.0557612479,
0.0210422631,
-0.0397785529,
-0.0184722207,
-0.0922038555,
-0.006162704,
-0.0015989864,
0.0130342608,
-0.0534839779,
-0.0037382843,
0.0034965498,
-0.012969343,
-0.0423488542,
-0.0082426351,
-0.0079861116,
-0.0484173819,
0.0329941288,
0.0093394443,
0.0111648319,
0.02626542,
0.0445237868,
-0.0325651579,
0.019505281,
-0.0162851401,
0.0821232647,
0.0517778248,
-0.0338696167,
0.051807262,
0.0590905324,
0.0315174088,
-0.0068262592,
0.0055710566,
0.0085421307,
0.0305169616,
-0.0412292592,
-0.015162874,
0.0055929176,
-0.0220206641,
-0.0460100397,
0.0728130192,
0.057577718,
-0.0397081003,
0.0035372698,
0.0274776183,
0.0687917992,
0.0143755665,
-0.0523883998,
-0.0418898501,
-0.0081675379,
-0.0790423825,
-0.0658705235,
-0.0092097698,
0.0438456833,
-0.0095079327,
0.0006801247,
0.00204983,
-0.0263993852,
0.0350860693,
0.0123431468,
0.0035538864,
0.0232967697,
-0.0108628646,
0.0188297369,
0.0311676562,
-0.02232337,
-0.0456670374,
-0.0741550773,
-0.0098359482,
0.0667411909,
0.0650095046,
-0.0140651213,
-0.0227841754,
-0.0373087041,
-0.0167781729,
0.0255148355,
0.038021747,
0.0170131698,
0.0099139437,
-0.0097117769,
-0.0089983149,
-0.0130394269,
0.0056077163,
-0.0097104143,
0.043459788,
-0.0036410112,
0.0244011767,
0.0163878426,
-0.0387723409,
-0.0086651342,
0.0005101433,
-0.0055147712,
0.010348401,
0.01842626,
0.0543045104,
0.0190678388,
0.0136546241,
0.0237798747,
0.0382600725,
0.0118250232,
-0.0262083877,
-0.043206878,
0.0295365751,
0.0558555201,
0.0105426554,
0.0147313159,
-0.0113990717,
0.0452892147,
-0.0155048072,
0.0340557285,
0.0928576738,
-0.045122195,
0.0534321181,
-0.0039861095,
-0.0217953809,
-0.0342387296,
0.0633481815,
-0.0017928224,
0.03334089,
-0.0081238141,
-0.0207062867,
-0.0150233023,
-0.0277753957,
0.0045411414,
-0.0225259271,
0.0026431878,
-0.0362157375,
-0.0611352734,
0.0059630321,
0.020247655,
-0.0032267978,
-0.0341342129,
-0.0227632467,
-0.0630530939,
-0.0154083883,
-0.0095258234,
0.0126270633,
0.0324788913,
0.0251722112,
-0.0252433624,
-0.0044019297,
-0.014783632,
0.017048236,
0.0099618342,
0.0119264768,
0.0284743607,
-0.0432338677,
-0.0633501858,
-0.0262225047,
0.0037375155,
-0.0189870689,
0.05263789,
0.0080965664,
-0.0175540149,
-0.006372768,
0.0237237066,
-0.042574551,
0.0048284004,
-0.0348311737,
-0.0643380731,
0.0227816962,
-0.0311566405,
-0.0121142175,
0.0268821195,
0.0814597458,
0.0578055866,
0.0234774984,
0.0119957663,
-0.0577133894,
-0.0248076487,
-0.012683155,
-0.0171865392,
-0.0637980923,
-0.0607800335,
0.0021292581,
0.0138791986,
0.0454187058,
-0.0018134572,
-0.0079266652,
0.0246717371,
0.0169376247,
-0.007285919,
-0.0161474962,
-0.0609866455,
0.0126380157,
-0.005293991,
-0.0036709353,
-0.0611341596,
0.0555112176,
-0.0518372841,
0.0321682394,
-0.0107384669,
-0.075340949,
0.0200252794,
0.0456660837,
0.0003316742,
0.00931508,
0.0521462262,
-0.011414621,
0.0021980451,
-0.0440050177,
0.0606526174,
-0.0442536175,
-0.0228258446,
0.0014597224,
0.0157055203,
0.0374288708,
0.0365736596,
-0.0660074875,
-0.0746022984,
-0.0636415854,
-0.0263888743,
-0.0244214647,
-0.0444673784,
-0.0469823033,
-0.0376566388,
0.0366828367,
-0.008882436,
-0.0131916963,
-0.0225436054,
-0.0067302939,
0.0020387652,
-0.0119881677,
-0.0516460128,
-0.0034088052,
-0.0201090015,
0.041654963,
0.0760827437,
-0.0147299692,
-0.0113443509,
-0.0281012431,
-0.0329306982,
0.0158829894,
0.0034205485,
-0.005185199,
0.0137006771,
0.0266499184,
-0.0347712487,
-0.0257694069,
0.0887650326,
0.0254268013,
-0.0385940932,
0.0036766541,
-0.021967249,
0.0189639889,
-0.0032009969,
0.0018624293,
-0.074741669,
-0.0116568329,
0.0109970653,
0.0406145677,
-0.0584808923,
0.0059274542,
-0.0126793999,
-0.0748148039,
0.0339697339,
0.0136673097,
-0.0476777926,
-0.0084642684,
-0.0543016903,
-0.0414604396,
0.0232088882,
0.0206735209,
-0.0386157632,
0.004635348,
-0.0017442299,
-0.0227963571,
-0.0623789839,
0.0015686497,
0.0285075866,
-0.0320822559,
0.0524327941,
0.0199836381,
0.0313349739,
-0.0200286731,
-0.0186674334,
0.0772916526,
0.0092043951,
-0.0138101373,
0.0102309845,
0.0739903823,
0.0253474843,
0.005145032,
-0.000045289,
0.0475118533,
-0.0338496752,
-0.0387874469,
0.0379187614,
0.037745323,
-0.0624915287,
0.023882892,
-0.0159637183,
0.0229747985,
0.0604142733,
0.0676127821,
-0.0181683116,
-0.0235614255,
0.0058760764,
-0.0216054525,
0.0156765971,
0.0195254758,
-0.0502728671,
0.0153545933,
-0.0012405957,
-0.0338958055,
-0.0280005969,
-0.0074889665,
-0.0326630734,
-0.0133097526,
0.0293937717,
-0.0382435769,
0.0205520354,
0.0118720932,
-0.0534448214,
0.0005311176,
-0.0544163324,
0.101748243,
-0.0223595258,
0.0211157016,
-0.0284694638,
-0.0539637432,
0.0036277669,
-0.0055781128,
-0.0869786963,
-0.0451665446,
-0.0107129086,
0.0135490168,
0.025623003,
0.0539917126,
-0.0414014906,
-0.0408247039,
0.0569761209,
0.0115454867,
-0.0335227624,
0.0055050235,
0.0615952685,
-0.0091820806,
0.0121915257,
-0.0015174563,
-0.0047454336,
0.0188164227,
0.0383017696,
-0.0386969186,
-0.051424481,
-0.035612721,
0.0183252916,
0.0343733355,
0.0351771563,
0.0131523134,
0.0150764054,
0.0226359852,
-0.0253242943,
-0.0291524362,
-0.0152969053,
0.0243768655,
-0.0069948961,
0.0101313237,
0.0048050149,
0.0510988124,
0.0015129254,
-0.0549400114,
0.0407335311,
-0.006697332,
0.0268873945,
0.0136917802,
0.0243595857,
0.0511570349,
-0.0175534189,
0.0225941278,
0.0681404024,
0.0006976475,
0.0475492515,
-0.0216675457,
0.0271886289,
-0.0231762379,
-0.0046334383,
-0.0064784698,
0.0246653371,
-0.0706907883,
-0.0457610935,
0.0463084504,
0.0603204109,
0.0020644481,
0.0137006808,
0.0595767945,
-0.0031311731,
0.027468076,
-0.0265466776,
0.0123251332,
-0.052739311,
-0.051164601,
-0.0127066718,
-0.0124311959,
-0.0296487231,
0.0566603839,
0.0566879734,
-0.0379534736,
0.0471351333,
0.0085607599,
-0.0881551579,
-0.0040734704,
-0.0254427772,
0.0484174229,
0.0526177585,
-0.0320746303,
-0.034965843,
-0.0707145184,
-0.056556154,
0.0010196905,
-0.0358302966,
-0.0001827437,
-0.0010049818,
-0.0037207315,
0.0670819506,
-0.0073299198,
0.0306377839,
-0.0939777121,
0.0475236326,
-0.0004986908,
-0.0573410206,
0.0086937482,
-5.721236433e-33,
0.0709272102,
-0.0553632453,
-0.0101700751,
0.0267094988,
-0.013505985,
0.0480394624,
-0.0147904027,
-0.0121975075,
-0.0234561227,
0.0107548386,
-0.0096204048,
0.0387947932,
-0.009118652,
0.029559074,
-0.0528225265,
0.0199087914,
-0.0078039537,
-0.0226779599,
-0.0128892027,
0.0406615622,
0.0837769136,
-0.0062935082,
-0.0081415847,
-0.0949976668,
0.0565106124,
-0.0040845489,
-0.0232154485,
0.0203516204,
-0.001770323,
0.0378196985,
-0.0047911196,
0.0305591188,
0.0099198157,
-0.0030891919,
0.023306815,
0.0557351708,
0.004664117,
-0.0228401665,
-0.0226117168,
-0.0036533661,
0.0544766486,
-0.043716047,
0.0289363619,
-0.0334759839,
-0.0285256058,
0.0202543251,
0.0032493607,
-0.0007065776,
-0.0051322477,
-0.0297707487,
-0.0327668749,
0.0088992305,
-0.0516745038,
0.019064106,
-0.0331357382,
0.0753442347,
0.0433342792,
0.0140850767,
-0.0534282774,
0.0770511031,
-0.0469578803,
-0.0199218057,
0.0171803646,
-0.0002746481,
-0.0060308948,
0.0366219468,
0.0184054486,
0.0155156581,
0.0032408019,
-0.0018948789,
0.0145544019,
0.0341044515,
0.0423253961,
0.0552227311,
-0.0083414903,
-0.0877580643,
-0.0659944639,
0.0251958165,
0.0764138922,
-0.0163320955,
0.0299392883,
-0.026712304,
-0.0686914027,
-0.0068411878,
0.0057837949,
0.0016570312,
-0.0295760203,
-0.0123489248,
0.0038167397,
-0.0150020523,
-0.0418529212,
-0.0242106542,
0.0075386446,
-0.0793049932,
0.0143095674,
0.0488941148,
-0.017940335,
-0.0196657963,
0.0062397653,
0.0077643245,
0.0044749784,
-0.0253798869,
0.0383274853,
-0.0508895218,
0.0121979583,
-0.0134380097,
0.0289577134,
0.0143417157,
-0.044121407,
-0.0247578211,
-0.01859257,
0.0509610176,
-0.0468434542,
-0.0159954131,
0.0190190505,
0.0427686572,
-0.0087737748,
-0.0040348289,
0.0403582081,
0.0095745446,
-0.0415782072,
0.0181217287,
-0.0266048871,
0.0245786943,
-0.0191774182,
0.0135254953,
-0.0554882661,
0.0195004381,
0.0509525351,
-0.0565955527,
-0.0052439789,
-0.0541549623,
2.942e-7,
-0.0168610346,
0.009235207,
-0.0173501577,
0.0111451102,
0.0337958336,
0.0838882029,
0.0313690044,
0.0599305034,
0.0088594351,
-0.0496450104,
0.0008488302,
0.0249518733,
0.0387973599,
0.0232812986,
-0.0376606397,
-0.0068633603,
-0.0503799021,
-0.0913520306,
-0.0553856418,
0.0019443614,
0.0622382984,
0.0632367358,
0.0620921701,
-0.0579450019,
-0.0394017659,
-0.0600129589,
0.0058246176,
0.0032663445,
-0.0164197013,
0.0139343617,
0.0617883652,
0.0111872898,
0.0369308777,
0.0543161035,
-0.0411918461,
0.0040002251,
-0.0617612228,
0.0141638638,
0.0203259457,
0.027508162,
-0.0406507403,
-0.053176634,
0.0082980404,
-0.054291226,
0.0460664928,
-0.0151018156,
-0.0219761766,
-0.0336055979,
-0.050019931,
-0.0170593448,
-0.0178306755,
-0.0114658875,
-0.0299937539,
0.0485848337,
0.0162561201,
-0.0093358671,
0.0123552699,
-0.0649561584,
0.0100208893,
-0.0115754427,
-0.0156362467,
-0.0429905728,
0.0151997805,
0.0223497059,
0.0593036301,
0.0350391306,
0.0361527801,
2.8196133e-34,
0.024042448,
-0.0202169064,
0.0050347471,
-0.0058125169,
0.0469366945,
0.0215404518,
-0.0020952947,
0.0412801728,
0.0144067835,
-0.0110081779,
0.0141174886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12260v1 | Self-Supervised Time-Series Anomaly Detection Using Learnable Data Augmentation | 2024-06-18T04:25:56 | 2024-06-18T04:25:56 | Kukjin Choi, Jihun Yi, Jisoo Mok, Sungroh Yoon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Continuous efforts are being made to advance anomaly detection in various
manufacturing processes to increase the productivity and safety of industrial
sites. Deep learning replaced rule-based methods and recently emerged as a
promising method for anomaly detection in diverse industries. However, in the
real world, the scarcity of abnormal data and difficulties in obtaining labeled
data create limitations in the training of detection models. In this study, we
addressed these shortcomings by proposing a learnable data augmentation-based
time-series anomaly detection (LATAD) technique that is trained in a
self-supervised manner. LATAD extracts discriminative features from time-series
data through contrastive learning. At the same time, learnable data
augmentation produces challenging negative samples to enhance learning
efficiency. We measured anomaly scores of the proposed technique based on
latent feature similarities. As per the results, LATAD exhibited comparable or
improved performance to the state-of-the-art anomaly detection assessments on
several benchmark datasets and provided a gradient-based diagnosis technique to
help identify root causes. | [
-0.0507508256,
0.0585849769,
-0.0172870271,
0.0713590607,
-0.0146621177,
0.0207442008,
0.057930544,
0.0133972121,
-0.0019075676,
0.0340614505,
0.0334455408,
0.0060184356,
-0.0827570632,
0.0833174363,
0.0061336164,
0.006051084,
0.0531814024,
-0.0101686874,
0.0237930305,
0.0201650858,
-0.0160465576,
-0.0400918163,
-0.0300365016,
-0.0270343069,
-0.0423403382,
-0.0062755384,
-0.0151234539,
-0.0193228256,
0.0648399517,
-0.0575764328,
0.0231586844,
-0.0251011271,
0.0360064246,
0.094829753,
0.0000021266,
0.0012313083,
-0.0259608421,
-0.0334172845,
-0.0099137705,
0.0086950753,
-0.0101164756,
-0.0640546083,
0.0197056867,
0.0105453376,
-0.0638161004,
-0.0500795618,
0.0086147701,
0.0861983523,
0.0117530674,
0.0467979871,
-0.0187349971,
0.0223381426,
0.0181485973,
-0.0466678627,
-0.0245010704,
-0.0072536725,
-0.0019112347,
-0.0405627973,
0.0104892775,
-0.0293462817,
-0.0188557524,
0.0036185791,
0.0508018509,
-0.0067748907,
0.0748992935,
0.0567522161,
0.0016630912,
0.0425860696,
-0.0004114858,
0.0494158491,
-0.0186617263,
-0.0166020598,
0.0142644066,
-0.0561011434,
0.0075221309,
-0.012875868,
-0.0158621669,
-0.0318500809,
0.0327776931,
0.0399836563,
0.0140112313,
0.0664272383,
0.0175364576,
-0.0147623289,
-0.0021593575,
0.0296747684,
-0.0354428478,
-0.0515723377,
-0.0827722847,
0.0096957413,
-0.0006957898,
-0.0016189843,
-0.0198021475,
0.0184491836,
-0.040144708,
-0.0558370166,
0.0247778315,
-0.075348407,
0.014893922,
0.0044369362,
-0.0105371298,
0.0180196483,
-0.0736538395,
0.0072187958,
-0.026546726,
0.0543658994,
-0.0289417561,
0.0027263181,
-0.0102412086,
0.0218826812,
-0.0274751019,
0.0072516887,
0.0095040649,
0.0068068188,
-0.013659751,
-0.0052722809,
-0.0013909285,
0.0190603193,
-0.0341528244,
-0.0095392466,
0.0118249226,
0.0112904944,
-0.0206580572,
0.0116491327,
-0.0126179038,
-0.0159970131,
-0.018160414,
0.0522469245,
-0.0110042449,
-0.0321935564,
-0.046001818,
0.0201724824,
0.0278318729,
0.0130418921,
-0.0058771735,
0.0277019851,
-0.0162061714,
0.0037307218,
-0.10125269,
-0.0074619418,
0.0011719898,
0.0256635025,
-0.0400103778,
-0.0004831899,
-0.0296418779,
-0.0467249639,
0.0075943437,
0.0268344283,
0.0003866774,
-0.037439432,
0.0409826748,
0.0237971321,
-0.0690281391,
-0.0101229222,
0.0165415742,
-0.0046953931,
-0.0225033965,
-0.0115865665,
0.041839689,
-0.0069717774,
0.0049001421,
-0.0337716974,
0.0595532209,
-0.022859484,
0.0216052141,
-0.0507591143,
-0.0222504996,
0.0019484573,
-0.0609107986,
-0.0097080693,
0.0647867918,
-0.0555523895,
0.0164167788,
-0.0608202703,
0.0121898092,
-0.0228851568,
-0.0022590498,
-0.0048372489,
0.0357030854,
0.0101025356,
-0.0811216831,
-0.0215584915,
0.0108548254,
0.0409671701,
-0.034978494,
0.0009691389,
-0.0033796281,
-0.0317551494,
-0.0411634557,
-0.0651740357,
-0.0074797035,
-0.0011309857,
-0.0146551095,
-0.0174446199,
0.0454215296,
-0.0278128255,
0.0081053181,
-0.0650290325,
0.0340055227,
0.0371926725,
-0.0200895667,
-0.0336266942,
0.0359339938,
0.0796254128,
0.0146640809,
-0.0477103181,
-0.0332920551,
-0.0613918044,
-0.0107314233,
-0.019481061,
-0.0111044869,
0.0049408977,
0.0612039939,
-0.0142224589,
-0.0285563897,
-0.0522854887,
0.0102402382,
0.0016913974,
-0.0643975586,
0.0244698878,
-0.0029897813,
-0.0544108748,
-0.0456470177,
0.020093238,
-0.0060853339,
-0.0931785256,
0.0393483788,
0.0351763889,
0.0136851594,
-0.0174998045,
0.0115071153,
-0.0338711664,
0.0415091962,
-0.0828462318,
-0.0556869432,
0.0374664702,
-0.0411761627,
-0.0109153464,
0.0072611226,
0.000943311,
-0.0131875975,
0.0332182124,
-0.048497811,
-0.0883634686,
0.0810904726,
-0.0020352097,
-0.0148215517,
-0.0567796491,
-0.0192072168,
0.0320272632,
0.0753328949,
0.0335341208,
0.0546313412,
0.0060420632,
-0.0299878065,
-0.0149942739,
0.0298000164,
0.0596655495,
-0.028438529,
-0.0025409765,
-0.0495806299,
-0.0244947765,
0.0013929895,
0.0106266579,
-0.0164735299,
0.0077891257,
0.0908258706,
0.0141337002,
-0.01789671,
-0.0235746242,
-0.0030486444,
-0.0231772643,
-0.0084984042,
-0.0189117678,
-0.0551070794,
-0.002203814,
-0.0091287121,
-0.0084776143,
-0.0076610129,
0.0679334998,
0.0330900736,
-0.0240452513,
-0.0004208141,
0.007572853,
-0.015490937,
0.0091352034,
0.0381032303,
0.0250876639,
-0.0063117505,
-0.006532154,
0.0252126548,
0.0097395396,
-0.0000592732,
-0.0180998892,
-0.0314046443,
-0.0211579259,
-0.0149335014,
0.0500388443,
-0.010855373,
-0.0033151223,
0.0082414001,
0.0204036348,
-0.0146593805,
0.0294794347,
-0.0456276573,
0.0832732618,
0.0364362262,
0.0147958118,
-0.0353411399,
0.0327972099,
0.0154634276,
-0.0250955336,
-0.0135486498,
0.0085830512,
0.0218069609,
-0.0360028632,
-0.0116150789,
-0.0109766796,
-0.0258499924,
0.0385330431,
0.0042687412,
-0.0164399836,
0.0280822515,
0.0345586129,
-0.0043948316,
0.0264401175,
-0.0647104904,
-0.0097661428,
0.0104310671,
0.0250520874,
-0.0137100741,
-0.0335879922,
-0.0758672953,
0.0092299832,
0.0156843122,
0.0120979901,
0.0065921061,
-0.0572373196,
-0.052335538,
0.0309094954,
0.0252548885,
-0.0386773795,
-0.0767169669,
-0.0253396463,
0.0268889107,
-0.0055848639,
-0.0567495748,
-0.0273326039,
0.0030587856,
0.0170719419,
-0.0456046462,
0.0688619018,
0.0088539785,
-0.0232898109,
0.0012800262,
0.0573809631,
0.0065905051,
-0.0096404655,
0.0317277163,
-0.0183807481,
0.0372846797,
-0.0190443769,
0.0168938972,
-0.0306815375,
-0.0908984616,
0.0446455106,
-0.057126265,
-0.008681112,
0.0160806123,
-0.0293815974,
-0.0236431099,
-0.0384458937,
-0.0286126547,
0.0430353768,
-0.0164298415,
0.0297911484,
0.0226873066,
0.020017501,
-0.0058305557,
0.0046283673,
-0.0406172425,
-0.0089722918,
0.0073037706,
0.0054357857,
0.0599846765,
-0.0108410781,
-0.0357508287,
0.0286756996,
-0.0466660894,
0.0633499771,
-0.0263272561,
-0.0650392473,
-0.100178726,
-0.0117135094,
0.0265005548,
-0.0919707119,
0.063757211,
-0.025146937,
0.0169139877,
-0.0114836935,
0.0743992701,
-0.0592279956,
-0.0909807906,
-0.0505424067,
-0.0054386905,
0.0147534069,
0.0193774793,
-0.0278150458,
-0.012978306,
-0.0277612973,
-0.0318976901,
0.0015713046,
0.0460403152,
-0.030301461,
0.0500204116,
0.0289298333,
-0.038378261,
0.0152610028,
0.0867441967,
-0.0745364055,
0.0200495105,
0.00851114,
0.0702701285,
-0.0300617032,
0.0044990224,
-0.0278124511,
-0.0447319858,
0.0541672446,
0.0325511247,
-0.0145024722,
-0.0079727732,
-0.0168009587,
0.0530861579,
-0.0037902193,
-0.0383613668,
0.0431881547,
0.0092134578,
0.0532019772,
-0.0603104681,
-0.0113629345,
-0.083647348,
-0.0248466097,
0.0217219684,
0.0000721081,
0.0247539002,
-0.0783017054,
-0.0152651137,
-0.0767538697,
-0.0080409776,
0.0223453678,
0.0040023299,
0.018025158,
0.0182536338,
-0.0028501046,
-0.0029815908,
-0.0334962904,
-0.0152002396,
-0.0773866102,
-0.0119312322,
0.0399831384,
-0.0083329966,
0.0008569848,
0.0637947023,
-0.0278408341,
0.0184943788,
0.0787134692,
0.0644489378,
-0.043735534,
-0.0193611495,
0.0204487704,
-0.0710477754,
0.0153750144,
-0.0000681577,
0.0127502708,
0.0720937774,
0.021926906,
-0.0082921982,
-0.049985148,
-0.0379049778,
0.0089863595,
-0.0074332538,
0.0424097218,
0.0157666691,
0.0294187069,
-0.0623186715,
0.0056440709,
0.0198285487,
0.0396560207,
-0.0081405677,
0.0489474759,
0.0342011787,
-0.0038243532,
-0.0425844267,
0.0383461714,
0.0181579981,
-0.0327467285,
-0.0538033135,
0.0089590922,
-0.0006177059,
0.0544169098,
-0.0285657328,
0.0395805053,
0.0316329338,
0.0077041723,
0.0416601747,
0.0290485546,
0.0363179035,
0.0017430602,
0.001356733,
0.0418119915,
-0.0376422368,
-0.0193053745,
-0.044242315,
0.0130321104,
0.0063861022,
-0.0299000684,
0.0068755946,
-0.0609984063,
-0.0134766977,
-0.0380566008,
0.0227388963,
0.0143748941,
0.0385011509,
-0.0088919178,
0.080837369,
0.0028113017,
-0.0049975947,
-0.0294921584,
0.0170259699,
0.0670488253,
-0.0125802364,
0.0276557468,
-0.0010348102,
0.0423222892,
-0.0437693,
0.0374646522,
0.0935647786,
0.0325183906,
0.0186300967,
-0.0029237738,
-0.0017069511,
0.0019434724,
0.0127660744,
-0.0004471481,
-0.0086501669,
0.0400809273,
0.009549221,
0.0466834642,
0.000599188,
0.0301451664,
0.0307285599,
-0.0362904817,
0.0426106118,
-0.0030769771,
-0.0401172303,
-5.766888225e-33,
0.0234182291,
-0.0438093878,
0.0087507227,
0.0047051175,
0.0221765731,
0.0273406487,
0.0286641624,
-0.0484509617,
0.0300470814,
0.0182174314,
-0.0099872965,
0.0687934756,
0.0067767715,
0.0148101784,
0.0383247063,
-0.0435740016,
0.0770331621,
0.0092578977,
0.0467075519,
0.0517165102,
0.0714629441,
0.0248610713,
0.0513811707,
-0.0752547383,
0.0024205812,
-0.0099383425,
-0.007755016,
0.0140863592,
0.0481498986,
0.0154054901,
-0.0284550972,
0.0450453423,
0.0134825008,
-0.0512466729,
-0.023214478,
-0.038696181,
-0.0232071318,
-0.0534385704,
-0.0533977412,
-0.0091862259,
-0.0123637849,
-0.0395158418,
0.0429465026,
-0.0146899121,
-0.013382555,
0.0327897295,
0.0399705544,
-0.0267319586,
0.027442079,
0.0377027057,
-0.0331319831,
0.0159443468,
-0.0699917078,
0.0123501094,
0.0506404191,
0.0073742517,
0.0135909524,
0.0116288839,
-0.0938862637,
0.0012746592,
0.0212691706,
-0.0390277654,
0.0182901639,
0.0166683979,
0.0143074254,
0.0282996185,
0.0301130041,
-0.0162237808,
0.032712359,
0.0640514195,
-0.0110556642,
0.0650141239,
0.0411025323,
0.0391963832,
0.0656428412,
-0.0435230583,
-0.0820431635,
0.0475117788,
-0.0255392157,
-0.012836148,
0.0242975298,
0.0145293698,
-0.0370299444,
-0.0010445537,
0.0495087318,
-0.0164266881,
0.0019525024,
0.0134567395,
0.0178688709,
0.0278158262,
-0.0489603132,
0.013143111,
0.0030396681,
-0.0467493646,
0.0322047696,
0.0056936271,
-0.0150622102,
-0.02343118,
0.0389681645,
-0.0430988744,
-0.0367326029,
-0.0132022342,
0.0507588647,
0.0396789722,
0.0469325408,
-0.0402463861,
0.0225768518,
0.0634469762,
-0.0160707645,
-0.0074529923,
0.0028818429,
0.0243214909,
-0.0370365903,
-0.0200825538,
0.0341944061,
-0.0368012935,
-0.0054416731,
0.076270096,
-0.0106426887,
0.0265724845,
-0.0141436029,
0.0040806388,
-0.0234163385,
-0.0158684999,
-0.0162490327,
-0.0157373156,
-0.0007567068,
-0.0101210056,
-0.0005533479,
-0.0548939407,
0.0225118939,
0.0062613441,
2.691e-7,
-0.0403958149,
-0.0127460361,
0.0443082042,
-0.0082689244,
0.0449175499,
0.0354859419,
-0.0251611862,
-0.0014472213,
-0.0326494351,
-0.0014955235,
0.0993958116,
-0.0075537041,
-0.001879087,
0.0263864473,
0.0341473222,
-0.0111031663,
-0.0411432125,
0.0369967036,
-0.0569392741,
-0.0100222602,
0.0587061234,
0.0725131109,
0.054453887,
-0.0404034369,
0.0897777155,
-0.0367264412,
0.0107517205,
0.0016484357,
0.0052463054,
-0.0116513725,
0.0573570728,
0.0940062776,
0.013284564,
0.0452231579,
-0.0257308986,
0.0228570011,
-0.0457240008,
-0.0387111008,
-0.0211263075,
-0.0126669286,
-0.0233081616,
0.0191017408,
0.0361889377,
-0.00652174,
0.0418294743,
-0.0040246872,
-0.0157962888,
0.0240659174,
-0.0510465503,
0.0341921933,
0.0071048378,
0.0091982614,
0.005071349,
-0.0131280869,
0.0054851389,
-0.0192409661,
0.0030581385,
-0.0021470697,
0.0362292118,
-0.0007014575,
-0.0249332339,
-0.0092394743,
-0.0162980966,
-0.0005534875,
0.0476508848,
0.0566925295,
-0.0321981572,
1.822151472e-34,
0.0074141822,
0.0118877599,
-0.0429824516,
0.0097023286,
-0.03387798,
0.0073769656,
-0.0576726161,
-0.022343263,
0.0187547877,
-0.0185774956,
0.0000249814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12255v1 | A Hopfieldian View-based Interpretation for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-06-18T04:07:13 | 2024-06-18T04:07:13 | Lijie Hu, Liang Liu, Shu Yang, Xin Chen, Hongru Xiao, Mengdi Li, Pan Zhou, Muhammad Asif Ali, Di Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) holds a significant place in augmenting the reasoning
performance for large language models (LLMs). While some studies focus on
improving CoT accuracy through methods like retrieval enhancement, yet a
rigorous explanation for why CoT achieves such success remains unclear. In this
paper, we analyze CoT methods under two different settings by asking the
following questions: (1) For zero-shot CoT, why does prompting the model with
"let's think step by step" significantly impact its outputs? (2) For few-shot
CoT, why does providing examples before questioning the model could
substantially improve its reasoning ability? To answer these questions, we
conduct a top-down explainable analysis from the Hopfieldian view and propose a
Read-and-Control approach for controlling the accuracy of CoT. Through
extensive experiments on seven datasets for three different tasks, we
demonstrate that our framework can decipher the inner workings of CoT, provide
reasoning error localization, and control to come up with the correct reasoning
path. | [
0.0202046614,
0.0734278113,
-0.0087213358,
0.0515626632,
-0.0629801527,
0.0401649177,
0.0294529665,
0.0061509395,
0.0279459357,
-0.0499461144,
-0.0184513386,
-0.0442648269,
-0.0121774599,
0.0120824287,
0.0148763964,
-0.0273630284,
0.0631928965,
-0.0790179521,
-0.0210890416,
-0.0095613021,
-0.0244729035,
0.0080471244,
-0.0456619374,
0.032419771,
-0.0031434093,
-0.0255920608,
-0.0312369391,
-0.011020299,
0.0449893996,
-0.0272088666,
-0.0513583794,
0.0494145378,
0.0235674195,
0.0384920053,
0.0000021232,
-0.0465982184,
-0.0198119599,
0.0350739546,
-0.0388289988,
-0.0073218015,
-0.0263433792,
0.0230944771,
0.0041852118,
0.0163133126,
-0.0090426551,
0.015977608,
-0.0036356754,
0.0826404318,
0.0437628441,
0.0696803033,
0.0078934329,
-0.0547558442,
-0.0040559,
-0.032679446,
0.047881186,
-0.0520985574,
0.0042827204,
0.0507031456,
0.0284928791,
0.0174204037,
-0.0296836812,
0.0471476763,
0.0129563138,
-0.0116323559,
-0.0320165791,
0.0315463431,
-0.0167367067,
-0.0143617122,
0.0124422787,
0.0460054614,
-0.0096437186,
-0.024835946,
-0.0119154565,
-0.0060013211,
-0.0118986983,
0.0426509306,
-0.0547187142,
0.0192056186,
-0.0277076531,
0.0220810715,
0.0086841872,
-0.0126998695,
0.0482723787,
0.0041810633,
-0.0723815113,
0.0812176615,
-0.0136278262,
-0.0255026296,
0.0094732894,
0.0188207775,
0.0120870825,
-0.0495839119,
0.0039000178,
0.0526330322,
-0.0369334333,
0.0342942849,
0.0290868375,
0.020243464,
-0.0127795814,
-0.0244936906,
0.0190676618,
0.0549119189,
0.0077151372,
0.056905929,
-0.0453828946,
0.0196472779,
-0.0496709682,
0.0182344299,
-0.0294236466,
-0.0065159281,
-0.0683833733,
-0.0272378307,
-0.0506467819,
0.0583717115,
-0.0134060374,
-0.0094885761,
-0.0088066319,
-0.0032151677,
-0.0217338596,
0.0013946915,
-0.0109093646,
0.0045814882,
0.0435674749,
-0.040277157,
-0.0503221974,
0.0499650836,
-0.0293777343,
0.008123978,
0.0119006345,
-0.0237827506,
-0.0160234924,
-0.0193502791,
0.009233688,
-0.0419365987,
0.0144161405,
0.0378886871,
-0.0011177409,
-0.0324768163,
-0.0303331707,
-0.041611325,
-0.0238597058,
-0.0783620253,
0.0182835273,
-0.0559911281,
0.0125788208,
0.0293995328,
0.0103328591,
-0.0234714765,
0.0033232856,
0.0232032016,
-0.0684594437,
0.0656179115,
0.0509368554,
0.0023942778,
-0.0100062462,
0.0115350801,
-0.0413185768,
0.0579473786,
0.0202696193,
0.0073246225,
0.002992348,
0.0157890301,
0.0220954195,
-0.0047432142,
0.0289793033,
-0.0195598062,
-0.0195308588,
0.0083481288,
-0.032150846,
0.0236076098,
0.0073198099,
0.0432497151,
-0.0392366722,
0.0426983796,
0.0135746263,
0.0565303005,
0.0469369739,
-0.0115961907,
0.0549312085,
-0.0350031592,
-0.001907663,
0.0180083513,
-0.056073904,
0.0516915917,
-0.015956372,
0.007083172,
0.0063435747,
0.0039270227,
-0.0247196835,
-0.0436085314,
-0.012242171,
0.0274927337,
-0.004341451,
0.0391031317,
0.0559143834,
0.0022002712,
-0.0173661318,
0.0552578568,
0.0060277404,
-0.0444677472,
-0.0020998456,
-0.0596007369,
-0.006142701,
0.0631787404,
0.0482702293,
-0.0034820598,
-0.0134543478,
0.0216124579,
-0.0025883785,
0.0332463533,
0.0311717223,
0.000885681,
-0.0214775112,
-0.0471904501,
-0.0349678434,
-0.0186840557,
0.0155444415,
0.0030433561,
-0.0271620639,
-0.0064704698,
0.0283104647,
-0.0144176204,
-0.0056994739,
0.012921039,
-0.009303797,
-0.0060910131,
-0.0256664902,
0.0443780161,
0.0071853488,
0.0299950782,
-0.0030816006,
0.0393325053,
-0.0033693407,
-0.0296107158,
-0.0142320869,
0.0206955802,
-0.0240143724,
-0.0433449894,
0.0024522718,
-0.0124790622,
-0.0289562438,
-0.00937034,
-0.0394417495,
-0.0660486594,
0.0356114209,
-0.0338362232,
0.0603291392,
-0.0340414457,
0.0074919984,
-0.0119184004,
-0.0435701609,
-0.0310372971,
0.091873087,
-0.0083931116,
0.0167063009,
0.0088374643,
0.046285294,
0.0175130125,
-0.0084054386,
-0.0201529749,
0.0328300111,
0.0080636805,
-0.0158794131,
0.0163667109,
-0.0187389255,
-0.0554964393,
-0.0093172817,
-0.0716521516,
-0.0208306871,
-0.0083229756,
0.0184580088,
-0.0064365072,
-0.0047609811,
0.0106463982,
0.002382559,
-0.0382316187,
0.0094249742,
0.0102642495,
0.0143113369,
0.0206100512,
-0.0029174255,
-0.0445308238,
-0.0057019177,
-0.0118450858,
-0.0518156327,
0.0641490892,
-0.0346535519,
-0.0419924036,
-0.045265872,
0.0450434387,
-0.0560123362,
0.0309112202,
-0.0282309819,
0.0119284336,
0.0604624562,
-0.0210700575,
0.0581054352,
0.0661486089,
-0.0160715953,
0.0267128181,
0.0799767971,
-0.0042294902,
-0.0400139168,
0.046960365,
-0.0247515626,
-0.0021482031,
-0.0036898314,
-0.0167419408,
-0.0455155112,
0.1051917374,
-0.0240195096,
-0.0102264509,
-0.0796647966,
0.0065479372,
-0.0095568923,
-0.020511426,
-0.0702901185,
-0.0125035467,
-0.0083398353,
0.0660578161,
-0.013110768,
-0.0339504667,
0.0731408596,
-0.0368295088,
0.0341214724,
-0.031206429,
0.0239923503,
-0.0269086789,
0.090541333,
0.0115496954,
0.0105473399,
-0.0050136484,
-0.0091599151,
-0.0442759767,
-0.0094952481,
-0.0012768564,
-0.0448651277,
0.0426481962,
-0.0507117845,
-0.003041045,
0.014675037,
-0.013008127,
-0.0445390902,
0.0206249915,
-0.0762379915,
0.001310469,
-0.0150070665,
-0.0179381799,
0.0102590565,
-0.0049774526,
0.0660646111,
0.029342426,
-0.0183330681,
-0.0229329523,
-0.0052755279,
0.0286539253,
0.0485888049,
-0.0161835738,
0.0499322563,
-0.0382659025,
0.040416047,
0.0499169193,
0.0499863252,
0.0157145541,
0.0094131511,
-0.0105231386,
-0.009096398,
0.0092571927,
-0.0587859899,
0.0076460997,
0.0340606198,
-0.0547369719,
-0.0595177561,
0.1240225509,
0.0466284491,
-0.0564708486,
0.0199559163,
-0.0676337034,
0.0210102014,
0.0258816686,
0.0252920222,
-0.0634322166,
-0.0385370292,
0.0319750793,
-0.006858021,
-0.0145983072,
-0.0389300585,
0.0054133553,
-0.1129028425,
0.0065705525,
0.0053022676,
-0.0346874222,
-0.0229872763,
-0.0398786403,
-0.0196515433,
0.0298560001,
0.0121063422,
0.0329867974,
0.0161071345,
0.021734681,
0.0364666767,
-0.0000492823,
-0.0224683601,
0.0641282871,
-0.012536739,
0.0313308164,
0.0541311055,
0.0151635548,
0.0378616825,
-0.0352924876,
0.0586225651,
-0.0197175331,
0.0342529304,
-0.0257772319,
0.0032806692,
0.001197995,
-0.0149458069,
-0.0313705094,
0.0349776596,
-0.0201080535,
-0.0359922089,
-0.0172927305,
0.0975548178,
-0.0534567125,
-0.0091705434,
-0.0310065821,
0.0221262872,
-0.0421669595,
0.0678003207,
0.046854388,
-0.0159740113,
-0.0390958972,
-0.0249842834,
-0.0335655063,
-0.0395009443,
-0.0503358394,
0.050446704,
0.0501848161,
0.0263443049,
-0.0230264068,
-0.0309337396,
0.001355995,
0.0657628253,
-0.0337922685,
0.0182822142,
0.018820582,
0.0198832657,
-0.0251180548,
0.0404189751,
-0.0461414233,
0.0240610838,
-0.020650208,
0.0279667769,
0.0157124698,
-0.0273444243,
-0.026558876,
0.0174129829,
-0.064564012,
-0.0409579948,
0.0002362782,
0.0389231779,
0.0329818539,
0.0586491674,
-0.0043757558,
-0.0277584586,
0.0112550817,
0.0187510457,
0.0121012963,
0.0245277192,
0.0111676864,
0.0389951281,
0.0258897487,
0.045468729,
-0.0499082431,
-0.0077231899,
0.0290700179,
0.078052938,
-0.0263732374,
0.0288927611,
0.0164185371,
0.0157707389,
0.0424039401,
0.0120300641,
-0.0039241347,
-0.0208463967,
0.0557520315,
-0.0559122376,
-0.0167476442,
-0.0492709801,
-0.0026823904,
0.0286030937,
-0.0187172238,
-0.0124089103,
-0.0518226959,
0.0157386325,
0.0246567409,
0.0029890754,
0.0049569155,
-0.0205456447,
0.0160286985,
0.029400833,
-0.0151128219,
-0.0277233496,
-0.004261699,
-0.002417021,
0.0520054214,
0.0108580459,
0.1118977964,
0.0339242108,
-0.0347139463,
-0.0634579882,
-0.0060548545,
-0.1127570793,
-0.056128256,
0.0303233247,
0.0021879037,
0.0331499316,
-0.0376786664,
0.0556770749,
-0.0562568083,
0.0012793946,
0.0292361733,
0.0276294481,
0.0319759026,
-0.0558732711,
0.0248516835,
0.040059559,
0.014827258,
-0.020627873,
0.060744144,
-0.0084176799,
0.021963615,
0.0104128821,
-0.0107716294,
-0.0251641665,
-0.046503108,
-0.0315265656,
0.0215012692,
-0.0193016492,
0.0210301355,
-0.101561226,
-0.0772629455,
-0.0576262102,
0.0026184446,
-0.004885233,
-0.0276156645,
0.0117808962,
0.0757947117,
0.0132129872,
-0.0384999774,
-0.0253817569,
0.0141803175,
0.0026221385,
-0.0094363326,
-0.0294454042,
-6.233606869e-33,
-0.0253570508,
-0.0635845363,
0.0436670817,
-0.0281028971,
-0.0281521156,
0.0106689241,
-0.0596173927,
0.0230514631,
-0.0482821241,
0.0340489335,
-0.0144037865,
0.0117839128,
0.0065856245,
0.0383853838,
0.0039701927,
0.0031158901,
0.0062405588,
0.0255686361,
-0.0150228264,
0.0172751956,
0.0953942761,
0.0170154963,
0.0347316265,
-0.0132863587,
0.0195383504,
-0.0186880007,
-0.0030946038,
0.0659916326,
-0.0747470036,
0.0394885987,
-0.0178879276,
-0.0087898606,
0.0226820782,
-0.0470771417,
-0.0001406459,
-0.0056170537,
-0.0640966892,
-0.0132336225,
0.0397210158,
0.0080791311,
-0.0134789301,
-0.0183886793,
0.0208895449,
0.0127708241,
-0.0072891009,
-0.042155005,
-0.0013003683,
-0.0174463615,
-0.0295794364,
0.0027503732,
-0.0612770505,
0.005187179,
-0.0084684268,
-0.030218713,
0.0272480715,
0.0504858606,
-0.0187569372,
0.0101396348,
-0.0340407379,
-0.0107001774,
0.0109990155,
0.0138233481,
0.0921016634,
0.008485104,
0.0073236781,
0.0558665507,
0.0461020358,
-0.0102540031,
-0.0892846733,
-0.0144747971,
0.0146063864,
0.0131579302,
0.0432812758,
-0.0076619503,
0.0443184972,
0.0422566608,
-0.0829441845,
-0.0285909139,
-0.0047063055,
0.0671174899,
0.0324068293,
0.0172584374,
-0.050395865,
-0.0179687832,
-0.0467926264,
0.0093931658,
-0.0434933864,
-0.0228177439,
-0.001073705,
-0.0160808992,
-0.0360041633,
-0.039734412,
0.0480902009,
-0.0438047498,
-0.009331027,
0.0329177976,
-0.0077229906,
0.0347409286,
-0.019324068,
0.0445694849,
-0.032770019,
-0.0404037237,
-0.0183589142,
0.0355191268,
0.0143276798,
0.0013115946,
0.041237779,
-0.0014853317,
-0.0460368767,
-0.0173904467,
-0.1007901281,
-0.0068500014,
-0.0191749018,
-0.0024142808,
0.0517871007,
0.0142914364,
-0.0101629104,
0.0624269955,
-0.010224415,
-0.0230409577,
0.0059200823,
0.0349276997,
-0.0342035815,
0.0025382114,
-0.0158318784,
-0.0218600426,
-0.0279708132,
0.0205823556,
0.0575192347,
-0.0651911348,
-0.0133479312,
0.0333736688,
2.847e-7,
0.0466894433,
0.0431167632,
0.0046240222,
0.0575857311,
0.0111738127,
0.0272486378,
-0.0009405945,
-0.0339404903,
0.0159731284,
-0.0379869603,
0.0175859816,
0.0637249723,
0.0417796485,
0.0195179228,
-0.0319631323,
-0.0183548108,
-0.059730988,
-0.0428881347,
-0.0165650453,
0.0006879545,
0.0432190448,
0.0501846336,
0.0095117614,
-0.0154371532,
0.0291494858,
0.0059208642,
0.0527061485,
-0.011404206,
0.0196825825,
-0.0062296288,
0.0033724688,
-0.0272642169,
0.0378399901,
0.0199031103,
0.0018604614,
0.0117416065,
-0.0302000195,
0.0306154713,
-0.0012598552,
-0.0406972989,
-0.0297943857,
-0.02078465,
0.0218960755,
-0.1040810496,
0.0972760469,
-0.0504874438,
-0.0305281896,
-0.0043688742,
-0.0047026221,
-0.0024881826,
-0.0169492792,
0.0396789163,
-0.0093691777,
0.0127508529,
0.0123109221,
-0.0076110517,
0.0209543109,
-0.0964893475,
-0.0371177457,
0.0354719535,
-0.0226184297,
-0.014712573,
-0.0419780985,
-0.0179708395,
0.0308120493,
-0.0509707332,
-0.05654075,
2.623528444e-34,
0.0381067321,
-0.0244993642,
0.0503523797,
-0.0055763922,
0.0505914055,
-0.0030444458,
0.0031950332,
0.0176403783,
0.0465292074,
-0.0837431848,
-0.0366205648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12252v1 | Language and Multimodal Models in Sports: A Survey of Datasets and Applications | 2024-06-18T03:59:26 | 2024-06-18T03:59:26 | Haotian Xia, Zhengbang Yang, Yun Zhao, Yuqing Wang, Jingxi Li, Rhys Tracy, Zhuangdi Zhu, Yuan-fang Wang, Hanjie Chen, Weining Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent integration of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and multimodal models
has advanced the field of sports analytics. This survey presents a
comprehensive review of the datasets and applications driving these innovations
post-2020. We overviewed and categorized datasets into three primary types:
language-based, multimodal, and convertible datasets. Language-based and
multimodal datasets are for tasks involving text or multimodality (e.g., text,
video, audio), respectively. Convertible datasets, initially single-modal
(video), can be enriched with additional annotations, such as explanations of
actions and video descriptions, to become multimodal, offering future potential
for richer and more diverse applications. Our study highlights the
contributions of these datasets to various applications, from improving fan
experiences to supporting tactical analysis and medical diagnostics. We also
discuss the challenges and future directions in dataset development,
emphasizing the need for diverse, high-quality data to support real-time
processing and personalized user experiences. This survey provides a
foundational resource for researchers and practitioners aiming to leverage NLP
and multimodal models in sports, offering insights into current trends and
future opportunities in the field. | [
0.0038268531,
0.0375120081,
0.0043728221,
0.0367543846,
-0.0046187076,
0.0103751766,
-0.0148680387,
0.0150016174,
-0.0472157747,
-0.0827397332,
0.0084840497,
-0.0304573681,
0.0051577436,
0.0456113666,
0.0518140756,
-0.0903257132,
-0.0386662111,
-0.0538533218,
0.019448325,
0.0267059188,
0.0442085899,
0.0437373407,
-0.0543267354,
0.0292079374,
-0.0692131445,
0.0186118949,
-0.0038666236,
-0.0190180875,
-0.0315122679,
-0.0370688029,
-0.0518843122,
0.0100264084,
0.0722493976,
-0.0449437909,
0.000001645,
-0.0436971448,
0.045028843,
-0.0535210259,
-0.005268102,
-0.0011159815,
0.0687235892,
-0.0050418684,
0.0453917012,
-0.0287960004,
-0.0096586682,
0.028930692,
0.0778563619,
-0.007535506,
0.0409277044,
0.0247687455,
-0.0333644301,
-0.0309865773,
-0.0116833691,
-0.0089781545,
-0.0191127583,
-0.0056136325,
-0.0015014174,
0.0262354817,
-0.0280576684,
0.018180348,
-0.0086333212,
0.0101735704,
-0.0309590455,
0.0250415225,
-0.0186050124,
0.0029280416,
-0.0289137755,
-0.0149684688,
-0.0086346827,
0.0364878848,
-0.0218925215,
0.000418714,
-0.0055992426,
-0.0254109967,
-0.028598588,
0.0283514559,
-0.0210729372,
0.045136895,
0.0052031912,
0.0156406499,
-0.0539431237,
0.0422493145,
0.0208414495,
0.0056465128,
0.0040640328,
0.0018764104,
0.0172772072,
0.018423086,
-0.0224075411,
0.0295581128,
0.0201826356,
-0.0614275299,
-0.0025676575,
-0.031118378,
-0.0327653326,
0.0062679243,
-0.0283074938,
-0.0281745661,
-0.0157801844,
-0.0545088351,
0.0913165957,
0.0293332748,
-0.0206160713,
0.0384052284,
0.0153927403,
-0.0236314926,
-0.0073095555,
-0.0440237299,
-0.0036465097,
-0.0119336294,
-0.053559199,
-0.004690778,
0.0323609598,
-0.0175012704,
-0.0852181837,
-0.0058597466,
-0.049205903,
0.0367117934,
0.0195680689,
-0.0044273175,
0.0061254571,
0.0113620162,
0.0483518131,
-0.0014812832,
-0.0395237282,
0.0212365985,
-0.0491625443,
0.0211733636,
-0.0090036886,
-0.072292462,
0.0373231582,
0.0070833666,
0.0281728078,
-0.0166259129,
0.0233409368,
0.0469523631,
-0.0060927672,
-0.0156063065,
-0.0081000468,
-0.0343467332,
-0.0260593016,
-0.0408514962,
0.0029526595,
-0.0815358087,
0.0680700839,
-0.0378327034,
-0.0008058287,
-0.0434979796,
0.0211183168,
0.0349934921,
-0.0390779041,
0.0720014274,
-0.0232149716,
0.0360161848,
-0.0100291241,
-0.0384439379,
0.032563895,
0.0776254684,
0.0176708139,
-0.0391819738,
0.0461406894,
-0.0045518423,
-0.0136863086,
0.0402433351,
-0.0403600782,
-0.0204194915,
-0.0996513069,
-0.0311011355,
-0.0129455775,
0.0326220691,
-0.026680097,
0.0028158366,
0.0047176131,
-0.0401411206,
0.0724688545,
0.0447351076,
0.017528709,
-0.0655096918,
0.0703870878,
-0.0160417743,
0.0035384034,
-0.0238974113,
0.003633247,
0.0402754247,
0.0503661819,
0.0078192372,
0.008741362,
0.0494909063,
-0.0267038532,
-0.0711433589,
-0.0177586954,
-0.0118409945,
0.0082674026,
0.0292236079,
0.0836629719,
-0.0526897535,
0.0283503402,
0.016402768,
-0.001526216,
-0.0320267044,
0.0117124179,
0.0082567353,
-0.0400550254,
0.0730046183,
-0.022225989,
-0.0539287739,
-0.009818254,
-0.0129022943,
0.0184091181,
0.0330741592,
0.0087153101,
-0.0033447025,
0.0697787702,
-0.0444672965,
-0.0189611651,
-0.0271921307,
0.0309239011,
0.0093243634,
-0.0591087453,
0.0185273308,
-0.0251420196,
0.0410320126,
-0.0431345962,
0.0467205793,
-0.008279087,
-0.0170837045,
-0.0083739217,
-0.0247228369,
-0.0018677773,
0.0976457298,
-0.0233947281,
-0.0037406078,
0.0379348099,
-0.0046209106,
0.0160487033,
0.1082766354,
0.021319937,
0.0156908594,
0.0393659882,
-0.0411522947,
-0.0152537916,
0.0089231934,
-0.0274588019,
-0.0364443958,
0.0082885548,
0.0020741057,
0.0401626341,
-0.0215176921,
-0.0190034322,
0.00302922,
0.0235309768,
0.0208467077,
0.0076209754,
0.007544308,
-0.0064353095,
0.0028796464,
-0.0304464716,
0.0267713405,
-0.0484194532,
-0.0271763727,
0.0588119663,
-0.004290496,
0.0262780301,
0.078703016,
-0.0093828421,
-0.0716314837,
0.0423384048,
-0.0861129835,
-0.0053864093,
-0.0188636333,
0.0000286033,
0.0051152715,
0.0148637248,
-0.0415209681,
-0.0231162589,
-0.0171133596,
-0.0249467362,
0.0210508015,
0.0082729803,
0.0208137687,
0.0141170248,
0.0399100594,
-0.0074364948,
-0.0205611717,
0.0115499711,
0.0684563667,
-0.0014488478,
-0.0411328711,
-0.0486187898,
-0.0249252487,
-0.0616661273,
0.0330339074,
0.0047695972,
0.0147301089,
0.0580027103,
0.0072252983,
0.0148935672,
0.02581558,
0.0257050656,
0.034629263,
0.0328140035,
-0.087945506,
0.0285656042,
-0.0026334303,
-0.019931538,
-0.0253157392,
-0.0637875721,
-0.0260188784,
0.0563611425,
0.0474528298,
-0.0166555699,
0.036162246,
-0.0472346321,
0.000120397,
-0.0261095446,
-0.0040921769,
-0.060282141,
-0.0234151892,
-0.0227507222,
0.0197546482,
0.0097881071,
0.0049577868,
-0.0008063511,
-0.0294778794,
0.0046361326,
-0.0232929923,
-0.0532622226,
0.0082644224,
0.0876619816,
0.0470077395,
0.0584914237,
-0.0006216496,
0.0149071887,
0.023547437,
-0.0171869379,
0.0486595146,
-0.0084202532,
-0.0181561504,
-0.0102604544,
0.0145375691,
0.0266246777,
0.0037850644,
0.0216370542,
-0.0039899456,
-0.0462833159,
-0.050629504,
0.0151502322,
-0.0188520141,
-0.043549858,
-0.0239497051,
0.0170146152,
-0.0089697065,
0.0174773596,
-0.0082285749,
0.0228151716,
0.0376387313,
0.0139001869,
0.0577810369,
-0.0598358959,
-0.0389674865,
-0.0041739251,
0.0560800359,
0.0159408227,
-0.021360185,
-0.021710787,
0.0262435377,
-0.0081640519,
0.0183498319,
-0.0349217989,
0.0530257076,
0.0805287659,
-0.0441783257,
0.0647718981,
0.085157387,
0.0357483365,
-0.0338296629,
-0.0035529186,
0.0321513899,
-0.0353129841,
0.0282102134,
-0.0131394491,
-0.0887138471,
-0.0428073369,
0.0061365459,
0.0261901077,
-0.026500795,
-0.0245754085,
-0.0326901041,
-0.0677695572,
0.0378978066,
-0.01176704,
-0.0463230126,
-0.0441949554,
-0.0167219061,
0.0186092407,
-0.0211839005,
-0.0326326787,
-0.0296595655,
0.0284268968,
0.0237992257,
0.0402569845,
-0.0311586559,
-0.0626791045,
0.0015353368,
-0.0495807081,
0.0570842065,
-0.0244002137,
0.0494740866,
-0.0186003372,
-0.0235824194,
-0.0106662614,
0.043318633,
0.0270049199,
-0.0028725171,
0.0643541291,
-0.0549500845,
-0.0162692312,
-0.0256629959,
0.0243685618,
0.0073075164,
-0.0297841486,
0.0283484571,
0.0683306605,
0.0216507968,
0.0596453473,
-0.0372737013,
0.0004377408,
0.0256373733,
0.0012505213,
0.0012112785,
-0.0648649484,
0.0198654588,
-0.019247558,
0.0389438458,
-0.0448355898,
-0.0849862024,
-0.0145828761,
0.0048409095,
-0.0378674343,
0.0031512086,
-0.040303085,
0.0458051786,
0.0024703669,
-0.0082083065,
0.0884864405,
-0.0320017785,
-0.0328605287,
-0.0917310268,
0.052756872,
0.019894287,
-0.0036795593,
0.0059828344,
-0.0217960496,
0.0624155216,
-0.008177272,
0.0161693729,
0.0655840114,
-0.0124130426,
-0.0248101987,
0.005616209,
0.0355999693,
0.0151638547,
0.0121394312,
0.0490989313,
-0.0406894982,
-0.0459003821,
0.0112827225,
-0.0304398909,
0.0273939874,
-0.0223671179,
0.0134868408,
-0.016614072,
-0.0159776546,
0.0159374196,
0.0146303605,
-0.0345018171,
0.012644425,
-0.0433719456,
-0.0090348674,
0.0242685229,
-0.0164386164,
0.0952866897,
-0.025792256,
-0.0464322791,
-0.0155149661,
-0.0356308185,
-0.0553014427,
0.010458366,
-0.0543635041,
0.0049793641,
-0.009098866,
0.023486238,
-0.0136224041,
0.0179639105,
-0.0431230217,
0.008787876,
-0.0404388607,
0.0651546866,
0.0854971036,
-0.025748184,
-0.0083491951,
0.0377545245,
0.0384545363,
0.0360825844,
-0.0453916267,
0.0097629735,
0.0302781388,
-0.0136630712,
0.0176764671,
-0.0435857028,
0.0365848802,
0.045815561,
0.0346950926,
0.065049611,
-0.0207779128,
0.0200811736,
0.0871563181,
-0.0220981818,
0.0131847374,
-0.0049181911,
0.0020139036,
0.0134286936,
0.0628101379,
-0.0128297638,
-0.0570736527,
0.0189851839,
-0.0078346934,
-0.0451331027,
0.006910265,
0.0294663273,
0.0255304538,
0.0060449368,
0.0054633338,
-0.0518710874,
-0.0289438087,
0.0015794148,
0.0232861973,
0.0400267392,
-0.0371714868,
-0.006258369,
-0.0856137499,
-0.0227135662,
-0.0137330787,
-0.0300871097,
-0.00144034,
0.0099387458,
0.0279526617,
0.0261441767,
-0.0047096703,
0.009578892,
-0.0319577828,
0.0237629749,
-0.0268907342,
-0.0387578942,
0.0112544689,
-4.859082223e-33,
-0.0021700712,
-0.0562686324,
0.0331318825,
-0.0132204499,
-0.0760809779,
0.0061232168,
0.007383754,
-0.0029296526,
0.00853734,
0.0127455452,
0.01254992,
0.0104446216,
-0.0153081138,
0.0052871052,
0.0821541473,
-0.0627783313,
0.0292913876,
-0.0873103142,
-0.0225881264,
-0.0133658899,
0.0649498329,
0.0217868816,
0.057459306,
-0.0981364995,
0.0483413525,
0.0086074527,
-0.0472477041,
0.0027004408,
0.0625677705,
0.0367130861,
-0.0214498416,
0.0246942043,
0.0323169492,
-0.0585067123,
-0.0240252502,
0.0454064384,
0.0234337449,
-0.0184794664,
-0.0026566966,
0.0450504273,
-0.0217062794,
0.0317346491,
0.0551154837,
-0.0029967881,
-0.0140784839,
-0.029066192,
0.0256065372,
-0.0475419313,
0.0422881432,
-0.0301461425,
-0.0114066983,
0.070895277,
-0.0240155999,
-0.0082171559,
0.0662390366,
0.0334871076,
0.0022498097,
0.0116002848,
-0.0370921008,
0.0542964563,
-0.0355720185,
-0.0068255709,
0.038134113,
0.0261045154,
0.0307578128,
0.0240829084,
0.0321808569,
-0.0585011505,
-0.0440111347,
0.0121674454,
0.0153724598,
0.0638948828,
0.0366984345,
0.0362175554,
0.018708054,
0.0301629435,
-0.0163330268,
0.0083190622,
0.0130384667,
0.0220967848,
-0.0297037456,
0.0545123927,
-0.0271986891,
0.0183396116,
-0.0364437364,
-0.0272932239,
0.0124631422,
-0.0621763617,
0.0112620248,
-0.0444795303,
-0.0030993845,
0.0139840292,
0.032818146,
0.0352744348,
-0.0148298154,
0.0141153531,
-0.0201514047,
0.1013098583,
-0.002063218,
-0.0198401213,
-0.0469619744,
0.0050482792,
0.0177741237,
-0.0127154561,
0.013275845,
-0.0527048483,
-0.0226296056,
0.0812618434,
-0.0157674942,
-0.0012168678,
0.0398264788,
-0.0161962062,
0.0125201903,
0.0092333211,
0.0457730405,
0.0237219874,
-0.0284639858,
0.0389423408,
0.022102667,
-0.0542078987,
0.0063904882,
-0.019869009,
0.0037496386,
0.0134484656,
0.015611886,
0.0018269937,
-0.0046042246,
-0.0199207999,
0.0342947245,
0.0030704313,
-0.0313982442,
-0.0030543297,
2.311e-7,
0.0591853671,
0.0749432519,
-0.0436242111,
-0.0386025682,
0.0061708731,
0.0346214958,
-0.0327172019,
0.0562745966,
-0.0086770644,
0.0116340965,
0.0347595587,
0.0251882114,
0.0212179814,
0.0325644724,
-0.035684146,
-0.066970177,
-0.0106727062,
-0.0349917561,
-0.0457030311,
0.0444942862,
0.0464438535,
0.0467947349,
0.0583819337,
0.0168194827,
0.0006638116,
-0.029039219,
0.041171819,
-0.053857293,
-0.0373025835,
-0.0341197811,
0.0080029648,
0.009450091,
-0.0808184743,
-0.0032721953,
-0.0591834486,
0.003714768,
0.0574367158,
0.0108744074,
-0.0515747182,
0.0036091653,
-0.0201209616,
0.0122371735,
-0.0685769841,
0.004779032,
0.0381216109,
-0.0051735775,
-0.0423136763,
-0.0435593165,
-0.0408392884,
-0.0010286168,
0.0145092653,
-0.0408656858,
-0.0211652145,
0.0240028482,
0.0056585185,
0.0145601463,
-0.0115463361,
-0.0497446842,
0.0042012492,
0.0122713083,
-0.0325195119,
0.0233790949,
-0.0205216482,
0.0023044315,
-0.0110648265,
-0.0552873835,
-0.0108574443,
1.407873742e-34,
-0.0050872155,
0.0221348815,
-0.0330225155,
-0.0485072993,
-0.0177487489,
-0.0338462815,
-0.0306567661,
0.0620102808,
0.0024373734,
-0.0232407656,
0.0108080041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12251v1 | Mitigate Negative Transfer with Similarity Heuristic Lifelong Prompt Tuning | 2024-06-18T03:57:49 | 2024-06-18T03:57:49 | Chenyuan Wu, Gangwei Jiang, Defu Lian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Lifelong prompt tuning has significantly advanced parameter-efficient
lifelong learning with its efficiency and minimal storage demands on various
tasks. Our empirical studies, however, highlights certain transferability
constraints in the current methodologies: a universal algorithm that guarantees
consistent positive transfer across all tasks is currently unattainable,
especially when dealing dissimilar tasks that may engender negative transfer.
Identifying the misalignment between algorithm selection and task specificity
as the primary cause of negative transfer, we present the Similarity Heuristic
Lifelong Prompt Tuning (SHLPT) framework. This innovative strategy partitions
tasks into two distinct subsets by harnessing a learnable similarity metric,
thereby facilitating fruitful transfer from tasks regardless of their
similarity or dissimilarity. Additionally, SHLPT incorporates a parameter pool
to combat catastrophic forgetting effectively. Our experiments shows that SHLPT
outperforms state-of-the-art techniques in lifelong learning benchmarks and
demonstrates robustness against negative transfer in diverse task sequences. | [
-0.0088566532,
0.0189679302,
-0.0244382024,
0.0067331498,
-0.0124931373,
0.0007158094,
-0.0179894362,
-0.0374031216,
-0.0080747474,
0.0207350366,
-0.0543507971,
-0.0147233587,
-0.0264571141,
0.0247127526,
-0.0264115147,
-0.0767390504,
0.0907638744,
-0.0142417327,
-0.0559012666,
0.0087286169,
-0.0319911577,
-0.0583982095,
-0.0373479836,
0.0043853815,
0.0075862431,
-0.0115834279,
-0.033585608,
0.0264134444,
0.0473076887,
-0.0110213421,
-0.0077859471,
0.0067511629,
-0.0049097026,
-0.0123301735,
0.0000021405,
-0.0677584782,
-0.0567950048,
-0.0497298203,
-0.0326345526,
-0.0354628041,
0.0692776814,
0.0509090275,
-0.0155312475,
0.020478934,
-0.0111235324,
0.0501898229,
0.0498846881,
-0.0039144289,
0.056259159,
0.0475414246,
0.0005410961,
0.047213085,
0.0170056932,
-0.0022398802,
0.0384459831,
-0.0098142149,
-0.0048690252,
-0.0446161292,
0.0022454008,
-0.0262469985,
-0.0269643012,
0.0093671298,
0.0214385912,
0.017341705,
0.0740951747,
0.0209739339,
0.0103044799,
-0.0019176467,
-0.0066772019,
0.0383802913,
-0.0392638966,
-0.0196083188,
0.0203084107,
-0.0156254116,
0.023310015,
-0.0148806972,
-0.05289625,
0.0085774222,
-0.033799462,
0.0063321795,
-0.0492085703,
-0.0117407748,
-0.0112311915,
-0.0337314419,
-0.0171365906,
0.0335803255,
0.0135766417,
-0.0112815443,
0.0259938352,
-0.0180081911,
-0.0026125778,
0.0047603711,
0.0326651894,
0.0300700441,
-0.0498019457,
-0.0110690529,
-0.0314996988,
0.0138566168,
-0.0217306521,
0.0384311639,
0.0426968709,
0.0467172675,
-0.0220607743,
0.0214524213,
-0.0927667767,
0.0342500433,
0.0138116097,
0.0024067515,
-0.0242288671,
0.0371622518,
-0.1077519208,
0.0197160766,
-0.0187884457,
0.0550662652,
0.026837375,
0.003046687,
0.0060452977,
0.0689983293,
-0.0226758383,
0.0068325126,
-0.0256393086,
0.0075365445,
-0.0461531281,
0.0263890065,
-0.0305034481,
0.0331318676,
-0.0241906159,
0.0121529968,
0.0179365072,
0.0336760655,
-0.0306825172,
0.0150186112,
-0.009791784,
-0.008446726,
0.0339174941,
0.0694732219,
-0.031127112,
0.0131463902,
-0.0625698119,
0.02050207,
0.0144531196,
-0.0150744803,
0.0339024961,
-0.0032145537,
0.0172022022,
-0.0146355145,
-0.0034678609,
-0.0515245162,
-0.0037136395,
-0.0109829251,
0.0095399534,
0.0825931579,
0.0284743328,
0.0073783444,
0.0253715608,
0.0092741447,
-0.0790647939,
0.0372874215,
-0.0284717791,
0.0312867723,
0.0315308943,
-0.0015642329,
0.0094842073,
-0.0106829852,
0.0341992974,
0.0326549374,
0.0267025791,
-0.0189541895,
0.0894151181,
0.0198819675,
0.0635698587,
-0.0108932462,
-0.0109399399,
-0.0029413418,
0.0763757303,
0.0250193607,
-0.0432017893,
0.0152102951,
-0.0002338416,
0.0076812613,
-0.0350814164,
-0.0356262587,
-0.0873022899,
0.0503721498,
-0.0088715972,
-0.0222825408,
-0.0180627014,
-0.038517423,
-0.0165329259,
0.000060921,
0.0431320816,
-0.0111061875,
-0.0312337372,
-0.0029032265,
0.0042804065,
-0.023694668,
-0.0571353287,
0.0467773266,
-0.003348883,
-0.0646149814,
-0.0145695377,
-0.0284567513,
0.0507979468,
0.0429084562,
-0.0092016906,
-0.0683380514,
-0.092663385,
-0.0161644537,
0.0501196124,
-0.0381459072,
-0.003168083,
0.0034757778,
0.0545938201,
-0.005524348,
-0.0633390099,
0.0188810471,
-0.024805095,
0.0237325411,
0.0216832589,
0.0413960814,
-0.0062760916,
0.0103133088,
-0.0223088786,
0.0145057971,
-0.0618167371,
-0.0225014202,
0.0646472424,
0.0215135384,
0.0108504565,
-0.0290303342,
0.0130991628,
-0.011111103,
0.0139648402,
-0.0457223356,
-0.0170644615,
0.0318810381,
-0.1047410443,
0.0219540056,
0.0293800961,
-0.0139982626,
0.0354260169,
0.013544892,
-0.0027016846,
-0.0389148258,
-0.0141480481,
0.0219842046,
0.0099195763,
0.0279120207,
0.0416331813,
-0.03440414,
-0.0004850511,
-0.025053164,
0.0162263792,
0.0142449448,
-0.0451337919,
0.0010843106,
0.0600162074,
0.0014705311,
-0.0917254612,
-0.0130964052,
-0.0058289976,
-0.0124381781,
-0.014967843,
0.0104912706,
0.0069173751,
-0.0668668151,
-0.0222915467,
-0.0637088344,
0.0703650564,
0.0005911565,
0.0274518188,
0.0306254495,
-0.0438760631,
-0.0257620718,
-0.0415016189,
-0.0233711731,
0.0623802729,
-0.0427699499,
0.025095541,
0.0213356521,
-0.001193976,
-0.0035263989,
-0.0182657447,
0.0190952439,
0.0131599782,
-0.0347527452,
-0.0384194478,
-0.0071686609,
-0.041042164,
0.0528091565,
-0.0081772292,
-0.0083845602,
-0.0028382989,
0.0294743516,
-0.0220836401,
-0.0193864293,
0.0060726427,
0.0936011001,
-0.001498231,
-0.0426032394,
0.0284043029,
-0.0086059757,
-0.0159859378,
0.0105187185,
-0.0369823463,
-0.03269732,
0.0370651111,
0.0373164229,
0.0029940372,
-0.0106464429,
-0.0233553611,
-0.0050151669,
-0.0446258374,
-0.0025073281,
-0.036023695,
0.0127002979,
-0.0450046845,
0.0044145784,
-0.0189146269,
-0.0233574901,
-0.0291809253,
-0.0534960628,
0.0411223061,
0.0344940759,
-0.0004743555,
-0.0039450726,
-0.0054912446,
-0.0059804539,
0.0456696302,
-0.0302343667,
-0.0176422112,
0.0427987576,
-0.0351061784,
-0.0631887913,
0.0294246357,
0.0800403804,
0.0014764012,
0.0095547596,
-0.0136680882,
-0.0235691722,
-0.0489389412,
-0.0919344053,
-0.0626276731,
0.0110239154,
0.0618697666,
0.0257538371,
-0.0146661205,
0.0109237777,
-0.0271710176,
-0.0209229179,
0.0167818535,
0.017688062,
-0.0330675319,
-0.0241671279,
-0.0101151662,
-0.0055778744,
0.0213432647,
0.0402170531,
0.0240791272,
-0.0069897943,
0.0337542407,
0.0200197864,
0.080293566,
-0.016341161,
0.0188901797,
0.0258847959,
0.0231145881,
-0.0437131412,
-0.0307369921,
0.035261143,
0.0462876968,
-0.0192111023,
-0.0538726561,
0.0465516187,
0.0297664478,
-0.0661340132,
-0.00672821,
-0.0436164178,
0.0335188061,
0.0189492404,
0.0096709086,
-0.0420395397,
-0.0375697725,
0.0326874927,
0.1098692417,
0.005835054,
-0.0615450814,
0.0210921671,
-0.0900581181,
-0.0277081151,
0.0347714089,
-0.0319751799,
0.0106760589,
-0.0384912752,
-0.0065046474,
-0.037580248,
-0.0062559317,
0.0448811837,
-0.0470024422,
-0.0017677605,
0.0319790728,
-0.0071274801,
0.0102048526,
0.0239520967,
-0.0225382466,
0.0035486743,
0.0393773131,
-0.0252564475,
0.025429802,
-0.0464856476,
0.0558177084,
-0.0120673226,
0.0266465638,
-0.0148665272,
0.0231186412,
-0.0068471087,
-0.0072798547,
0.0010588103,
0.0527619682,
-0.033294823,
-0.0309113916,
0.0701321438,
0.0849462822,
0.0047974288,
-0.0010217882,
-0.0103465449,
-0.0467607826,
0.0446238406,
0.0553883947,
-0.0114960577,
-0.0374054648,
-0.0355930999,
0.0442444943,
-0.004089375,
-0.0369864441,
0.0202156827,
-0.0287753865,
-0.035790123,
-0.0076343813,
-0.0540252328,
0.0018897149,
-0.0137716504,
0.0620733164,
0.042025581,
-0.0222598799,
-0.0185266007,
0.0300612338,
-0.0618873984,
0.0065436214,
-0.0236935783,
-0.0077904542,
-0.0735597759,
-0.0027125308,
0.0492589362,
-0.0062484895,
0.0097819837,
-0.0476676077,
-0.0574298203,
-0.0287824944,
-0.0038681468,
0.0629765317,
0.0056187538,
0.0754090101,
-0.0050174063,
0.0040769503,
0.0406926125,
0.049179282,
-0.0027551171,
0.0338381566,
0.071753636,
-0.003707146,
0.0018275825,
0.0238716248,
-0.0586198829,
-0.0031936322,
0.0644104108,
0.0267653,
0.0431055129,
0.023727702,
0.0044604214,
0.0027019025,
0.0416395254,
0.0112126581,
-0.015064273,
-0.0120830918,
0.0239712931,
0.0518848337,
0.0069122743,
-0.0277973525,
0.0367755368,
0.0054345205,
0.0115378397,
0.0376432389,
0.000109084,
0.0536088645,
0.0219033286,
-0.0315429308,
-0.0048792628,
0.001386053,
0.0591854714,
-0.0155358166,
0.0295699611,
-0.0257271826,
0.0039540539,
0.0569563806,
0.0286041796,
-0.0358956791,
0.0903086364,
0.0348289348,
0.0374579243,
-0.0382014439,
0.0528015569,
-0.0283572916,
-0.0660507232,
-0.0296776015,
0.0098766433,
0.0730811805,
0.0204374846,
-0.0188463274,
0.0150753725,
-0.0162051432,
-0.0528743565,
0.0155131537,
-0.0085451417,
0.0299526211,
-0.0429442115,
0.0149029978,
0.0222386457,
-0.0010459425,
0.0183141194,
-0.0722373426,
0.0221490953,
-0.0007046234,
0.0093843229,
-0.0402311608,
0.0193332899,
0.0228661224,
0.0259061065,
0.0112992637,
0.001652873,
0.0009191075,
-0.001649497,
0.0368411131,
-0.0442290306,
-0.0123753389,
0.0160668399,
0.0474319831,
0.0050692731,
-0.0466922149,
-0.0358167849,
0.0071191825,
0.0148264049,
0.0275500212,
0.0365433767,
-0.0081509892,
-5.883261064e-33,
-0.0275137536,
0.0361694843,
0.018536156,
0.0400311835,
-0.0630704984,
-0.0388607867,
-0.0267354157,
0.0410101973,
0.019830836,
-0.0248160474,
-0.032429181,
-0.0184412636,
0.0192194618,
-0.0019028122,
0.0715844184,
-0.0452502184,
0.0427605882,
0.0374574699,
-0.0651129559,
0.0593569577,
0.0689553916,
0.044338882,
0.0159819033,
-0.0353234001,
-0.0321674645,
0.0539984815,
0.0387623981,
0.0120018795,
0.028774336,
-0.0049608373,
0.0118220486,
0.0107162492,
-0.0140159726,
-0.0628987178,
-0.0413619615,
0.0005634119,
-0.0824362636,
-0.0780417249,
-0.0259013809,
-0.0226088986,
-0.006432368,
-0.0531192385,
0.0099721085,
0.0141187888,
-0.0601839423,
0.0105981994,
0.0079851896,
-0.0218948424,
-0.0208566524,
-0.0288065653,
-0.0677205473,
-0.0025979087,
0.0044352091,
-0.0447326973,
0.0027750998,
0.0314575136,
-0.0365808234,
-0.0097102718,
-0.0479713529,
-0.0109404437,
-0.0414193496,
0.0416547433,
0.0314072222,
0.0228711199,
0.0228436477,
0.0215367712,
0.0431654043,
0.0003529554,
0.0500235856,
-0.0477830358,
0.0160840731,
0.0402237512,
0.0237607174,
0.0006864209,
0.0107647618,
-0.0553535037,
-0.0081080738,
0.051048521,
0.0339789949,
0.0293299053,
-0.0059077186,
0.0342057906,
-0.0062190695,
-0.024242131,
-0.0274786279,
0.001553467,
-0.0147091784,
-0.0043623527,
0.0993708149,
0.0149348769,
-0.0325667709,
0.0167491883,
0.0595645532,
-0.0099781677,
0.0407457463,
0.0101079019,
-0.0249055102,
-0.0295977239,
0.0269310288,
-0.0225076787,
-0.0516752861,
-0.0637744069,
-0.0027873812,
-0.0294105317,
0.0280993488,
-0.0404361449,
0.0388263352,
0.0467635319,
-0.0455526672,
-0.0214079302,
-0.0200093426,
0.0240211617,
0.0604757667,
-0.0003628666,
0.0028482121,
0.0244566742,
0.0034062951,
0.0575460531,
0.0071220673,
-0.0383670218,
-0.0522170365,
0.0421200693,
0.0102700377,
0.0078201191,
0.0055412506,
0.0113812834,
-0.0369244479,
-0.0040573492,
-0.0693272352,
-0.1013188213,
-0.020797519,
-0.0195567459,
2.858e-7,
-0.0674969777,
0.0133479917,
0.0012776203,
-0.0746647418,
0.0467604585,
0.0369298458,
-0.053813871,
0.0217288528,
0.0082322126,
0.0394878052,
0.031604927,
0.0274021607,
0.0196080189,
0.0010971912,
-0.0693279579,
-0.0085168025,
-0.0147621548,
0.0384393036,
-0.0519306138,
0.0009271174,
0.0397719368,
0.020715557,
0.0287205949,
0.0022011152,
0.0796727017,
-0.0207765736,
0.0505546853,
-0.0384794362,
0.0527024977,
-0.0298545752,
-0.032823801,
-0.0334219635,
-0.0288206879,
0.0411150716,
-0.0103803333,
0.0152685549,
-0.0198928844,
0.0575949587,
0.0044463496,
-0.064666152,
-0.0139902038,
0.0261757579,
0.0405370444,
-0.0384621732,
0.0998216271,
-0.056712456,
0.0101041002,
-0.0146789839,
-0.0358903669,
-0.0205666218,
0.0230607595,
0.0260133967,
-0.0328487717,
-0.0229258724,
-0.0028953361,
0.0919461399,
-0.0588120371,
-0.0759455115,
0.0474554226,
0.0279478412,
-0.0075058923,
-0.0601009764,
-0.0510647669,
0.0154716512,
0.0122888302,
-0.0626233593,
0.0151268542,
2.530505056e-34,
-0.0305976048,
-0.0298058186,
0.0548239276,
0.005142367,
-0.024503408,
-0.0124216434,
-0.0001868972,
0.0098051149,
0.0646701083,
0.0188829154,
-0.0164010003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12246v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12246v2 | TroL: Traversal of Layers for Large Language and Vision Models | 2024-06-18T03:42:00 | 2024-06-19T21:40:03 | Byung-Kwan Lee, Sangyun Chung, Chae Won Kim, Beomchan Park, Yong Man Ro | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Large language and vision models (LLVMs) have been driven by the
generalization power of large language models (LLMs) and the advent of visual
instruction tuning. Along with scaling them up directly, these models enable
LLVMs to showcase powerful vision language (VL) performances by covering
diverse tasks via natural language instructions. However, existing open-source
LLVMs that perform comparably to closed-source LLVMs such as GPT-4V are often
considered too large (e.g., 26B, 34B, and 110B parameters), having a larger
number of layers. These large models demand costly, high-end resources for both
training and inference. To address this issue, we present a new efficient LLVM
family with 1.8B, 3.8B, and 7B LLM model sizes, Traversal of Layers (TroL),
which enables the reuse of layers in a token-wise manner. This layer traversing
technique simulates the effect of looking back and retracing the answering
stream while increasing the number of forward propagation layers without
physically adding more layers. We demonstrate that TroL employs a simple layer
traversing approach yet efficiently outperforms the open-source LLVMs with
larger model sizes and rivals the performances of the closed-source LLVMs with
substantial sizes. | [
0.0222952962,
0.0512383953,
0.0067200447,
0.0534906834,
-0.0311776735,
0.0144673213,
-0.0057013137,
-0.0196710192,
0.0034057405,
-0.036027614,
-0.0148286726,
-0.0291975271,
-0.0052239476,
0.0214955229,
0.0192750022,
-0.0526085161,
0.0331604294,
-0.0652390718,
-0.0378983282,
0.0004385509,
-0.0218636915,
0.0123608792,
0.0200395137,
0.0337433293,
0.0360906571,
-0.0077610835,
-0.0299782492,
0.0283029564,
0.0335219614,
-0.0174278356,
-0.0056600571,
0.0057334891,
0.0648235902,
0.04300173,
0.0000021667,
-0.0089916922,
0.0283053722,
0.0238280892,
-0.0106493058,
0.0398279727,
0.0127474694,
-0.0251914822,
-0.0063805995,
0.0336435549,
-0.0056072581,
-0.0559251197,
0.0589800328,
0.0340608023,
0.0584049597,
0.0827358142,
0.0030796148,
-0.0564041212,
0.0381085835,
-0.0216006227,
-0.0030084152,
-0.0633577257,
0.030142501,
-0.0161684249,
-0.0137592554,
0.0201802589,
-0.0284063667,
0.0546167307,
0.064041473,
0.0057855723,
-0.0159761496,
0.0393879376,
-0.029667763,
-0.0318319388,
-0.0123641938,
0.0503858067,
-0.0415911861,
0.0055812956,
-0.0118847452,
-0.0053310408,
-0.0162552632,
-0.0360937566,
-0.0441456959,
0.0424273871,
0.017469706,
0.0178467073,
-0.0283662956,
-0.0317839943,
0.0346684158,
0.0166855399,
-0.0191278644,
0.0170980748,
0.0345211327,
0.0511280112,
0.0094734048,
-0.0023320634,
-0.004282115,
-0.0399224646,
-0.0170025788,
0.0308838598,
-0.0218426548,
0.0178405326,
-0.0385437794,
0.0086791832,
-0.0102845281,
-0.0575318821,
0.0884885639,
0.0425299779,
-0.0640858188,
0.0532355867,
-0.0613441169,
0.035949111,
-0.067686066,
0.0306733157,
-0.034767326,
-0.0416036882,
0.0030918464,
-0.0075413962,
-0.0515278131,
0.0098899249,
-0.0688808858,
-0.0419396311,
-0.0382003747,
0.0246985406,
-0.0170889739,
-0.0224329885,
0.0071896594,
0.0238045789,
0.0064585702,
-0.0248638168,
-0.0084894244,
0.0234081615,
-0.0226186477,
0.0081039155,
-0.0281137116,
-0.060621541,
-0.0116856983,
0.0216921866,
0.008828246,
-0.0183802694,
0.0350836627,
0.0870347023,
-0.0217274297,
-0.0498112552,
-0.0545458682,
0.0249316823,
0.0155377416,
-0.0751479641,
0.0256601218,
-0.0746862814,
0.0183545612,
-0.0195458625,
0.0023013279,
0.0046145362,
0.0282305162,
0.0446404852,
-0.037723165,
0.0457807668,
0.022580618,
-0.0014155873,
0.0023886899,
-0.0012774884,
0.0252514984,
0.0596751086,
0.017358413,
0.0236221217,
0.0086557837,
-0.0087658297,
0.0273081195,
0.0230071191,
-0.0064811562,
0.0072515211,
-0.0514992438,
0.0140581187,
-0.0013272149,
0.0241940282,
0.0462903343,
0.0579403192,
-0.0508495048,
-0.0893678442,
0.0299034175,
0.0395557322,
0.0083717629,
-0.0011828991,
0.0645522028,
0.0050557922,
0.0210252795,
-0.0243976209,
-0.0756753385,
0.0456407145,
-0.0159157049,
-0.0409846082,
-0.0037331737,
0.0397481136,
-0.044423148,
-0.0196102783,
-0.007603447,
0.0028665406,
0.0030293448,
0.0261089616,
0.0584360659,
-0.019807037,
-0.0270465687,
0.0263046343,
0.0275090076,
-0.0442007519,
-0.0388372354,
-0.0680161119,
0.0147421723,
0.0513489991,
0.0111563755,
0.021292517,
-0.0340643898,
0.033192236,
0.0374062695,
0.0487186089,
0.0216223057,
0.0202974863,
0.076337941,
-0.0563525222,
-0.0094229206,
-0.0133118313,
-0.0113056153,
0.0493812971,
0.046369046,
-0.0050882408,
0.0221613869,
-0.0542779155,
-0.0087355915,
0.0370216556,
0.0107449163,
-0.0198052675,
0.0169450156,
0.00673175,
0.0055335476,
-0.0113164941,
0.0051103178,
-0.0078534316,
0.0291298684,
-0.0331465192,
-0.0215134788,
-0.0182750914,
-0.0456453934,
-0.0149899516,
0.0207276046,
-0.0652116463,
0.009744049,
0.0464147925,
-0.067316182,
-0.0309090521,
0.0276887733,
-0.0416340493,
0.0198468287,
-0.0314673856,
-0.0011642607,
0.0118610496,
-0.0078695035,
-0.0151985334,
0.0306533128,
-0.0110096382,
-0.0091154696,
0.0340820067,
0.0026189273,
0.0128138522,
-0.0245444234,
-0.0139106978,
0.0079929242,
-0.0106743397,
0.000097206,
-0.0165190883,
0.0115799475,
-0.0376262181,
-0.0072491961,
-0.0777496845,
-0.0029183577,
-0.0313454941,
0.0013569499,
0.0048992741,
0.0063012419,
0.0183333233,
-0.0383745544,
-0.0205119271,
0.0302916169,
0.0241730418,
0.0120467823,
-0.0095102098,
0.0010234377,
-0.0521038957,
-0.0275353119,
-0.039834708,
0.0263951775,
0.0306501277,
-0.0294641331,
-0.028767962,
-0.0547083132,
-0.0131136654,
-0.0050758021,
0.0751017109,
-0.0326859839,
-0.0329116844,
-0.0043880865,
-0.028219549,
-0.0150758037,
0.075790666,
-0.0059424909,
0.0211781636,
0.0326459184,
-0.0144225396,
-0.0349182375,
0.0292160306,
-0.0170934275,
-0.0553655699,
-0.0436214842,
0.0031834831,
-0.0393294059,
0.0471355207,
-0.0397731662,
0.0051866882,
-0.0518730879,
0.0045191264,
0.0137973391,
-0.0364360139,
-0.007540179,
0.007426782,
-0.0085814288,
0.012801501,
-0.0140855592,
-0.0668301657,
0.0242273696,
-0.0336312689,
-0.0173012242,
-0.0019805199,
-0.0157280751,
-0.0399898216,
0.1009632647,
0.0510358475,
0.0270927008,
-0.0204878449,
-0.0167462323,
-0.0532631204,
-0.002204888,
-0.0111933295,
-0.0007470534,
0.0626363903,
-0.0728411153,
0.0216325577,
-0.0385950692,
-0.0332471989,
-0.0387708656,
0.0131921889,
-0.0374575071,
0.0164388381,
-0.0398768261,
-0.0387155302,
-0.0488115363,
-0.0000148196,
0.032826975,
0.0368503295,
-0.0166688673,
0.0209829565,
-0.0340188369,
0.0123462593,
0.0507107526,
0.0210491102,
0.0042175199,
-0.0092129828,
0.0151809836,
0.0798652172,
0.0424736142,
0.0159049761,
-0.0644113123,
0.0182663593,
0.0470151789,
0.0147991078,
-0.0258534104,
0.0145823602,
0.0584592968,
-0.1093089283,
-0.0003941504,
0.0797608569,
0.0041118935,
-0.0356202386,
-0.0126965875,
0.01184119,
0.0092038866,
0.0350910202,
0.0447466448,
-0.085299693,
-0.0414401367,
0.0150707709,
0.0059032082,
0.0076456522,
-0.0024856806,
-0.0260567311,
-0.1129230633,
0.071981132,
0.0129761547,
-0.0126223769,
-0.0409790538,
-0.0089628268,
-0.0043736631,
0.0055138408,
-0.0105107902,
0.0304580946,
-0.0047640651,
-0.0221700538,
-0.0192277208,
0.0089852028,
0.0091832625,
0.0682115406,
-0.0358197391,
0.0003039682,
0.0514712185,
-0.0209328383,
0.0175071079,
-0.0496626571,
0.0571816862,
-0.0403976813,
0.0317203328,
-0.0212842394,
0.0502812788,
-0.0153431846,
-0.0336882286,
-0.0020796983,
0.0295386072,
-0.0080044707,
-0.0027095065,
-0.0151288593,
0.0541733205,
-0.0053158035,
-0.0339103304,
-0.0231971089,
-0.007138107,
-0.0575049669,
0.0522882976,
0.0179579668,
-0.0173584484,
-0.0755573362,
-0.0125699928,
-0.0537749119,
-0.0538116284,
-0.0126717733,
0.0377506539,
0.0188595559,
-0.0332504027,
-0.0157304369,
-0.0014828878,
0.0406849347,
0.0609859489,
-0.0236312021,
-0.0391039476,
0.0299195368,
0.0127630336,
-0.0522982702,
0.0529314168,
-0.041932743,
0.0410978124,
-0.0516579598,
-0.0024208894,
0.0143206818,
0.0035216622,
-0.0050538541,
0.032037273,
-0.0953472257,
-0.0594711564,
-0.0343241617,
0.0419555828,
0.0183521975,
0.0552545898,
0.0067541623,
-0.0491700284,
0.0320165567,
-0.0178494155,
0.0140117239,
0.0635343194,
0.0175681841,
-0.0356942303,
0.0035416791,
0.049721729,
-0.0388598666,
0.0145435352,
0.0302644577,
0.0362814069,
0.0055934503,
0.0021562937,
-0.0029831654,
-0.0206467379,
0.0352169983,
0.0177848395,
0.0338620991,
-0.0013876173,
0.0507342853,
-0.0170231517,
0.0114857471,
-0.0872248635,
0.0397702791,
0.0268412698,
0.0052958722,
0.0158114508,
-0.0284154378,
0.0186672956,
0.0216499791,
-0.0393679291,
0.017675329,
0.0203832928,
-0.0345858298,
0.0453590266,
0.0191285983,
-0.0307382476,
0.0276701543,
-0.0036908786,
0.0329574272,
-0.0071057668,
0.0470366068,
0.0118705025,
-0.0006292285,
-0.048285462,
0.0135245733,
-0.0591809712,
-0.1094255596,
-0.0373560674,
0.0579810925,
0.0486144386,
0.03527724,
0.0460615903,
-0.0135575123,
-0.0231299326,
-0.0206378512,
0.0196814295,
-0.0028581612,
-0.0488528907,
0.0787639916,
0.0444121584,
-0.0011304613,
-0.0413901582,
0.0659245625,
0.057391692,
0.0414683037,
0.0019044592,
0.0083149588,
-0.0157037601,
-0.0441399291,
0.0254604518,
-0.0011719594,
0.0025355213,
0.0410737582,
-0.0026861192,
-0.0575168021,
-0.0331899002,
-0.0063411682,
-0.0156426914,
-0.0284768194,
0.0531034395,
0.0619088747,
0.0557521693,
-0.0607374236,
-0.0076309857,
-0.0174045935,
-0.0136665916,
-0.028425945,
0.0384264141,
-6.618302824e-33,
-0.0337799303,
0.0074202698,
0.0477113761,
-0.0157004055,
-0.0369331688,
0.0212953947,
-0.0204548389,
0.0054274285,
-0.041690059,
0.0158713795,
0.02758478,
0.0144015802,
0.0236860588,
0.0612195954,
0.018773824,
0.0032578362,
0.0384240635,
-0.0103076939,
0.0043033548,
0.0238887016,
-0.0120852971,
0.0268617906,
0.061117027,
-0.0066611869,
-0.0469263718,
0.0412638783,
0.010780924,
0.0305407606,
-0.0107620861,
0.0440578684,
-0.0241915453,
0.0078293243,
0.0119594233,
-0.0264072083,
-0.0347407013,
0.0255812015,
-0.0827716216,
-0.0212472603,
0.0378889553,
0.0420305468,
-0.1178072467,
0.0178417563,
0.0416510515,
0.0028376083,
-0.0001889862,
-0.0269666631,
-0.0038088618,
-0.0247098617,
-0.0329534039,
0.000136968,
-0.0492644422,
0.0246316455,
0.0307088196,
-0.0241797548,
0.026322877,
0.0326533802,
-0.0313396454,
0.0219136979,
-0.0387273394,
-0.0264275447,
0.0068550194,
0.0268679764,
0.0416327193,
0.0729261264,
0.0201881267,
0.0260920878,
0.0430527329,
-0.0608740002,
-0.0375699699,
-0.0225275084,
0.0300076548,
0.0710711926,
0.0380887501,
0.0085642925,
0.0131825255,
0.0383225158,
-0.0652014092,
-0.0346739069,
0.013311917,
0.0876512751,
0.029037701,
0.0117210103,
0.0184469726,
-0.0225206446,
-0.0427046083,
-0.01410471,
-0.0361353345,
-0.0070032203,
0.0589791164,
0.0372911058,
-0.0022367416,
-0.0056752749,
0.0566791557,
-0.0232951231,
-0.0025379565,
0.0348966084,
-0.0095599545,
0.0328631513,
0.0267990138,
0.066271551,
-0.0367437378,
-0.0043331222,
0.0031976809,
-0.0280954391,
-0.0068166507,
-0.0041890796,
0.0137397563,
0.0325342044,
-0.0781380013,
-0.0116216764,
-0.0681144744,
-0.0020163658,
-0.0123108411,
0.0736533999,
0.0309724212,
-0.0185349938,
-0.0014305218,
0.064601548,
-0.0352423005,
0.0068289395,
-0.011022944,
-0.0297956187,
0.0181211419,
0.0412924066,
-0.0362426229,
0.0070592845,
-0.0507008433,
-0.0150016928,
0.0286839008,
-0.0750585422,
-0.0126687028,
0.045419056,
2.864e-7,
0.0191210415,
0.0176962465,
0.0255347509,
0.0471575074,
0.0133091127,
0.0403002948,
0.0120781232,
0.0197065789,
0.0267798621,
-0.0249556117,
-0.0023010012,
0.056078922,
0.0469288118,
-0.0017855727,
-0.0391972512,
0.0409696586,
-0.0366026126,
-0.0128185283,
-0.0343391523,
-0.0393484309,
0.0159157943,
0.1039436683,
-0.0130776744,
-0.0308863819,
0.0388480537,
-0.0497951172,
0.0564671122,
-0.0076685427,
0.000989643,
-0.0440259762,
-0.0082748709,
0.0453319289,
-0.0030760209,
0.0005694373,
-0.0006811724,
0.0158720501,
-0.0117796771,
0.0766362995,
-0.0349232256,
-0.0157203935,
0.0114100892,
0.0030625516,
-0.021051636,
-0.0758516937,
0.078831844,
-0.0513719842,
-0.0217287261,
-0.0603529811,
0.0049616937,
-0.0277575813,
-0.0110049788,
-0.0198091511,
0.0044920119,
0.0229273476,
0.0335603431,
-0.0709039196,
-0.0188843496,
-0.0984183177,
-0.0304161385,
-0.0274859276,
-0.0487238131,
-0.0238942578,
-0.0789244398,
0.0011554658,
0.0190159418,
0.0014569827,
-0.0449252054,
2.568752244e-34,
0.0581757762,
-0.0272462498,
0.0067823716,
0.0158437565,
0.0057838033,
-0.0055806343,
-0.0281180125,
0.0202998631,
-0.0239795689,
-0.0877241194,
-0.0392898284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12238v1 | PFID: Privacy First Inference Delegation Framework for LLMs | 2024-06-18T03:27:09 | 2024-06-18T03:27:09 | Haoyan Yang, Zhitao Li, Yong Zhang, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Ming Li, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel privacy-preservation framework named PFID for
LLMs that addresses critical privacy concerns by localizing user data through
model sharding and singular value decomposition. When users are interacting
with LLM systems, their prompts could be subject to being exposed to
eavesdroppers within or outside LLM system providers who are interested in
collecting users' input. In this work, we proposed a framework to camouflage
user input, so as to alleviate privacy issues. Our framework proposes to place
model shards on the client and the public server, we sent compressed hidden
states instead of prompts to and from servers. Clients have held back
information that can re-privatized the hidden states so that overall system
performance is comparable to traditional LLMs services. Our framework was
designed to be communication efficient, computation can be delegated to the
local client so that the server's computation burden can be lightened. We
conduct extensive experiments on machine translation tasks to verify our
framework's performance. | [
-0.0436648652,
0.0693669692,
-0.0146947606,
0.0393993966,
-0.055357337,
-0.023400683,
0.0655316412,
0.0190517437,
-0.001239202,
0.0098773595,
-0.0266673639,
0.018107919,
0.0032950793,
0.0037312165,
0.0079450198,
-0.0088032559,
0.0377419256,
-0.0341248922,
-0.0423730724,
-0.0296854749,
-0.0554023646,
-0.0270317737,
0.0295434128,
0.0174659267,
0.0282720495,
-0.0276267286,
-0.041613631,
0.0439306423,
0.0242763273,
0.0162541568,
-0.0509789325,
0.0272483528,
0.0210590642,
0.0152271977,
0.0000021353,
-0.0210380591,
-0.0429645479,
0.0693130046,
-0.0827694312,
0.0199424475,
0.0000048608,
0.0177814756,
0.0017510023,
0.0203038715,
-0.0314241052,
0.085723117,
0.0146177979,
0.0081242835,
0.061105039,
0.0314412527,
0.0054621757,
0.001401122,
-0.0239422899,
-0.0100395167,
0.0127784498,
-0.0744435191,
0.0024576578,
-0.0667253733,
-0.0380866416,
0.0302109458,
0.0186410416,
0.0337128043,
0.0117713381,
0.0267570466,
-0.0358589254,
0.0134256762,
0.0224118643,
0.0086087324,
-0.0429040305,
0.0423870087,
0.027585078,
0.0014708674,
0.0594472736,
0.0220343564,
0.0318452194,
0.031847164,
-0.0119229183,
0.0303003453,
-0.0150064537,
0.0230544694,
0.005964682,
-0.0161149427,
0.0221446529,
0.0153506827,
-0.0186801478,
0.0585515797,
0.017977979,
-0.0107852127,
-0.0576649718,
-0.0296498891,
-0.0014587314,
-0.0445626639,
0.0501376055,
0.025145879,
-0.0110667543,
0.006095829,
-0.0641404316,
-0.0348629095,
0.0062184287,
-0.0339974239,
0.0315721668,
0.0018239673,
0.0211373232,
0.0394689627,
-0.02343495,
0.0151205184,
-0.0333648063,
0.0344224684,
-0.0059579066,
0.0100728506,
0.0248071831,
0.0298070293,
-0.0025321166,
0.0724875033,
-0.1066096276,
0.0299461372,
-0.0289564468,
0.0440285467,
-0.0053206268,
0.0623807274,
-0.0225320496,
0.0075838733,
-0.0097537963,
-0.0220186766,
-0.0316700526,
-0.0466186777,
-0.015444193,
-0.004574771,
0.0102081876,
-0.0853082761,
-0.0318555087,
-0.0050318404,
-0.0384025574,
0.0176788829,
-0.0165945869,
0.0862656161,
0.0201491434,
-0.0198519807,
-0.0397009924,
-0.1074796692,
0.0608778931,
-0.026538007,
0.0032100088,
-0.0493626855,
0.053618744,
-0.0104322033,
-0.0164464526,
-0.0773965865,
-0.008442142,
0.0252075717,
0.0100657446,
0.0689352304,
-0.0023573926,
-0.0067036315,
-0.0372388549,
0.0475700684,
-0.0188622177,
-0.0121451113,
0.0070276503,
0.042562861,
0.0401843376,
-0.0150365476,
0.0401124842,
-0.0064414279,
0.0171131473,
0.002610829,
-0.0481066853,
0.0380344167,
-0.0124898003,
-0.0373899601,
-0.0249411725,
0.0181252342,
0.0147616267,
-0.042868685,
0.0756902546,
0.1322952956,
-0.0040868074,
0.0380390733,
-0.0544903167,
0.0273486059,
-0.0236452166,
-0.0203543976,
-0.0557275303,
0.015913846,
-0.0675643682,
-0.0380050316,
-0.0250941738,
0.0392553657,
-0.0155804297,
-0.0276130959,
0.0191765837,
-0.0606345907,
-0.0136880856,
0.0486521982,
0.0061958604,
-0.005025655,
0.0291781593,
0.0982898697,
-0.0046020136,
-0.061657913,
-0.0465923287,
-0.0617770366,
0.0092851948,
0.0552442521,
0.051736813,
-0.0049845525,
0.0031925202,
-0.0095537342,
-0.0231625177,
0.0166434627,
0.010387932,
0.0276424401,
0.0582747757,
-0.0118478676,
-0.0602684766,
0.0489016064,
-0.0044354741,
0.0237250868,
-0.0179581903,
-0.0259880181,
-0.0147819193,
-0.0447779857,
0.0269691609,
0.0140542863,
-0.0246184412,
-0.0397580527,
0.0337232985,
0.0351508744,
0.0247369539,
0.027075069,
0.0309339818,
0.0031550811,
0.060166873,
0.0211326778,
0.0033160725,
-0.0145815415,
-0.0130178342,
0.0194782261,
0.0077117914,
-0.0436110869,
0.0305197276,
0.0102511663,
-0.0443909131,
-0.0049771098,
-0.0152123058,
-0.0333756953,
0.0133194178,
-0.018060768,
0.0136583867,
-0.0043095895,
0.0072384044,
-0.0413219146,
0.0055497368,
-0.0715489537,
-0.0096325977,
-0.0152209951,
-0.0178818349,
0.0160709303,
-0.0402922034,
-0.0012475174,
0.013906898,
-0.0010759576,
0.0179114006,
-0.0254574902,
0.0016541557,
0.0028000735,
0.0121216234,
-0.01774594,
0.030969901,
-0.0033483342,
0.0649180636,
0.0098116063,
0.0238941386,
-0.0078601278,
-0.0528064445,
-0.0475917719,
-0.0153386667,
-0.0180583801,
-0.0021034835,
0.0223230198,
0.0176170487,
-0.0230926275,
0.0397497714,
-0.0091669839,
0.0209225118,
0.0053240447,
-0.0686678141,
-0.0040679206,
-0.0528021492,
0.0504441448,
-0.0172951445,
-0.0133469049,
-0.0069672139,
0.0081957271,
-0.0033439388,
0.0109603498,
-0.0111344215,
0.0436051898,
-0.0366765261,
0.0299701598,
0.0236138795,
0.0155722145,
-0.064999193,
-0.0115983244,
-0.0072715995,
-0.0130819147,
-0.0518475845,
-0.0101413261,
0.0472857654,
0.0003142562,
0.0078535397,
-0.0095936917,
0.0111818053,
0.0213782452,
0.0476003923,
-0.0413533151,
-0.0055091674,
0.0342583172,
-0.019188216,
0.052766975,
0.0214886107,
-0.0537992194,
0.0647692233,
-0.041340366,
0.0144232316,
0.0537405759,
-0.0729441345,
-0.0058897403,
0.0158477221,
-0.0503759198,
0.0169667657,
-0.0327319093,
-0.0410326608,
0.0047673495,
-0.0068552131,
0.0490354076,
-0.0734270141,
0.0189237818,
-0.0249832999,
-0.0732677579,
-0.0166260246,
-0.0544244535,
-0.015777532,
-0.0206498243,
0.0264226012,
-0.0124330893,
-0.0217700675,
-0.0292155128,
0.0249206107,
-0.0074849669,
0.0348805636,
-0.004691096,
0.005877621,
0.0037482078,
-0.0567780435,
-0.04413452,
-0.0472802483,
0.0062490017,
0.0245983582,
-0.0347764008,
0.0217319056,
0.1082678363,
0.0611049496,
-0.0371465459,
0.0124222152,
-0.0322399884,
0.0633485243,
-0.018354211,
0.0017113822,
0.0289918408,
0.0612220876,
-0.0206476934,
0.0188317224,
0.0267990865,
0.0069471509,
-0.0587000959,
-0.0075343233,
-0.0057621328,
0.0182762519,
0.0256053898,
0.0163875222,
-0.0999720171,
0.0031772461,
0.0296262242,
0.0914683118,
-0.0072062686,
-0.0631480366,
-0.0135245845,
-0.0417086482,
0.0331155099,
0.0218191892,
0.051865831,
-0.0094533935,
-0.0203845259,
0.0082911886,
0.0281710532,
-0.0000096699,
-0.044082623,
0.0105994092,
-0.0166181177,
-0.0052120909,
0.0038510121,
-0.0099205906,
-0.0348476991,
-0.0314712934,
0.0345844589,
0.0362973921,
0.021002464,
0.006128537,
-0.0722917691,
-0.0011523446,
0.0345382057,
-0.0078783073,
-0.0135915233,
-0.0152085181,
0.0073643825,
0.0175250843,
-0.0267906506,
0.030955499,
0.0292801131,
-0.0017641165,
-0.0094999326,
0.0483901165,
-0.0881905481,
0.0134375794,
0.0024578734,
-0.064510949,
0.0211286098,
0.0625765398,
-0.0039914516,
-0.0278310571,
-0.0248438045,
-0.0459792204,
0.0040646265,
0.0333914794,
0.0022958375,
-0.0036449044,
-0.0427878834,
-0.0377706029,
-0.0317840539,
0.0196964592,
-0.0112940092,
0.0388100073,
0.0036886965,
0.0067605861,
0.0350432843,
-0.0052189133,
-0.0306406394,
-0.006762852,
-0.1031071991,
0.0234331526,
0.0015000126,
0.0503383689,
0.018437786,
-0.0128863379,
-0.0083844122,
-0.0132216485,
-0.0470324382,
-0.0527818017,
-0.0078436704,
0.0561088547,
0.033316873,
-0.0013347659,
-0.0282942299,
-0.0405226499,
0.0626622736,
0.0485239141,
-0.0478698798,
0.0142164677,
0.0349891707,
0.0153409261,
0.0035138386,
0.0244108289,
-0.0411131643,
-0.0400574058,
0.0623471066,
-0.0109611358,
-0.0584834926,
-0.0814040527,
-0.0184588302,
0.100405708,
0.0258245301,
0.0164265782,
0.0321606956,
0.0299349744,
0.0544630364,
-0.0367519595,
0.026040066,
-0.0262389462,
-0.0055256723,
0.001908601,
-0.029356461,
0.0622834563,
0.0338415653,
0.0532680191,
-0.0162350629,
-0.0230290964,
0.0495453179,
0.0109268613,
-0.0069607371,
0.0289122202,
0.0201752167,
-0.0116084116,
0.0691425204,
0.0452640727,
0.0478060767,
-0.0239349008,
0.0329484232,
0.0020889163,
0.0381779522,
-0.0294044148,
0.0659225732,
-0.0402857438,
-0.1047316119,
0.024945261,
0.0680198669,
0.0141046448,
0.1184618399,
-0.0194862839,
-0.0412081219,
0.0109872296,
-0.0048237303,
0.0356208123,
0.0018262877,
-0.0206347499,
0.0044815652,
-0.0131917726,
-0.0005248474,
-0.0045898072,
0.0350528955,
0.0107157929,
0.0108681815,
-0.0612690337,
-0.0484476201,
-0.0775163695,
-0.0393675454,
-0.0046993135,
0.0049552331,
-0.0218448434,
-0.0485419221,
-0.0382966325,
-0.0490393825,
-0.0251924619,
0.0066251247,
0.0012868338,
-0.0460457616,
0.0175821036,
0.0154958451,
0.0110936081,
-0.0505593456,
-0.0641132444,
-0.0013836765,
0.0231491756,
-0.0420908146,
0.0002537984,
-5.883052781e-33,
-0.0223269574,
-0.0579040945,
0.0048383214,
0.0485912934,
0.0094115371,
-0.0408338197,
0.0027683224,
0.0262372158,
0.0269385185,
-0.0247488786,
-0.0480922014,
0.016091669,
0.045008637,
-0.0033558633,
-0.029024303,
-0.0397796296,
0.0334665775,
-0.03487942,
-0.0132121434,
-0.0003829755,
0.0240278821,
0.0167679153,
0.050680764,
-0.0607361533,
0.0372658782,
-0.0128970956,
-0.0270279795,
0.0298599284,
-0.0553401895,
-0.0104202498,
0.0040743779,
0.000276033,
-0.0015213366,
-0.0002914687,
-0.0155043295,
0.050118573,
-0.0402385667,
-0.0018649515,
0.0223832633,
-0.0243941452,
-0.0224621147,
-0.0604661368,
0.0214396492,
-0.0161513723,
-0.0313200317,
0.0306935553,
-0.0327965245,
-0.0113521125,
-0.0179443359,
-0.0327208862,
0.0528003871,
-0.0042851572,
0.0030464516,
0.0383242778,
0.0752807781,
0.0099456431,
-0.0101960329,
-0.0493515767,
-0.0397138745,
0.0262275971,
0.016786918,
-0.0554726906,
0.070370242,
0.0060168835,
0.0003401114,
0.0140103539,
0.0264533926,
-0.0042191343,
-0.0249044411,
-0.0338930711,
-0.0043758443,
0.0628942326,
0.0307238251,
0.0024559889,
-0.0019600473,
-0.0248010457,
0.0037245133,
0.0537347384,
0.0344904438,
0.0058006458,
0.0385898203,
-0.0024890197,
-0.0323083997,
0.0017052335,
-0.0308172014,
-0.0257884245,
-0.008522057,
-0.0171921179,
-0.0117832338,
0.0123903193,
-0.0226228796,
-0.0086875902,
0.0394264124,
-0.0389581583,
-0.0120097753,
-0.0363014378,
0.1016185135,
-0.0287532955,
0.0029896935,
-0.0184262041,
-0.0031441476,
0.0047129658,
-0.0130533315,
-0.0673007295,
0.0278817061,
-0.018168129,
0.0027649994,
-0.0031560159,
-0.0655451044,
0.0130746989,
-0.0311497822,
0.0161919072,
0.0284953695,
0.0129032219,
0.0593664162,
-0.0378627144,
0.026574783,
0.0016399927,
-0.024799075,
0.0289668702,
-0.0464272276,
0.0334979258,
0.0043863333,
0.024782585,
-0.0049538496,
-0.0000278814,
-0.0202466752,
0.0397194177,
0.1048864052,
-0.0084281983,
-0.0056039286,
-0.0174681116,
2.972e-7,
-0.0049208575,
-0.0000690913,
-0.0063643544,
0.0474616624,
0.008403996,
0.0626048744,
0.0061604683,
0.0687408,
-0.0240298714,
-0.0132826641,
-0.0123408176,
-0.0053276485,
0.0889650285,
0.0209411457,
-0.0629183054,
-0.0662309974,
0.0105425846,
0.017636938,
-0.0320424624,
0.0076817009,
0.0278475918,
0.0210010037,
0.003763082,
-0.0410315879,
0.0263141692,
0.0142462878,
0.0148704853,
-0.0784137473,
-0.021106638,
-0.0442610011,
0.0687419623,
0.0433656275,
0.0227356851,
-0.0166701507,
-0.0071622995,
0.0034913726,
-0.0662540793,
0.1219571531,
0.0172400065,
-0.0439246707,
-0.0135964444,
-0.0909445733,
-0.0202412233,
0.0452991799,
0.0159342699,
0.042561125,
-0.0161309987,
0.0057578092,
0.0170407519,
-0.0859588459,
0.0118213138,
0.0068942932,
0.0333822668,
-0.009779986,
0.0010263892,
-0.0024127488,
0.007718985,
-0.0328550711,
-0.0098729245,
-0.0188118238,
-0.0303225294,
-0.0441583171,
0.0142159369,
0.0271226559,
0.0196937434,
-0.014886721,
-0.0038419485,
3.110769246e-34,
-0.007484477,
-0.0221002288,
0.0035340169,
0.0964310542,
0.0213696547,
0.003509521,
0.0007558684,
0.0085196989,
0.0459143743,
-0.0694018677,
0.0010542136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12233v1 | SyncVSR: Data-Efficient Visual Speech Recognition with End-to-End Crossmodal Audio Token Synchronization | 2024-06-18T03:14:22 | 2024-06-18T03:14:22 | Young Jin Ahn, Jungwoo Park, Sangha Park, Jonghyun Choi, Kee-Eung Kim | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual Speech Recognition (VSR) stands at the intersection of computer vision
and speech recognition, aiming to interpret spoken content from visual cues. A
prominent challenge in VSR is the presence of homophenes-visually similar lip
gestures that represent different phonemes. Prior approaches have sought to
distinguish fine-grained visemes by aligning visual and auditory semantics, but
often fell short of full synchronization. To address this, we present SyncVSR,
an end-to-end learning framework that leverages quantized audio for frame-level
crossmodal supervision. By integrating a projection layer that synchronizes
visual representation with acoustic data, our encoder learns to generate
discrete audio tokens from a video sequence in a non-autoregressive manner.
SyncVSR shows versatility across tasks, languages, and modalities at the cost
of a forward pass. Our empirical evaluations show that it not only achieves
state-of-the-art results but also reduces data usage by up to ninefold. | [
-0.0296789613,
0.0509858243,
0.0094107753,
0.0104887728,
-0.0007454563,
-0.0181491636,
0.0231721941,
-0.0101238173,
-0.0034117613,
-0.0359858871,
-0.0361374095,
-0.0086878296,
0.02288411,
0.064680554,
0.0378835909,
-0.0776440427,
0.0092077283,
-0.0455314033,
0.006203725,
-0.0151797719,
0.037454363,
0.0047425469,
-0.0594555959,
0.0421594866,
-0.070782721,
-0.0118712829,
-0.0337028503,
0.040790271,
0.0351494513,
-0.0166897159,
-0.0617807955,
-0.0021865543,
0.0489575937,
0.0100541115,
0.0000017026,
0.0104264636,
-0.0029029588,
0.0008741714,
-0.0157102551,
-0.0167461354,
-0.0045113522,
-0.0790058672,
-0.0230584834,
0.0296294689,
-0.0014103489,
-0.0390958712,
0.0625089407,
-0.0089507662,
0.0701930746,
0.0034990124,
-0.0190732908,
0.0256916378,
0.0231216568,
-0.0407699384,
0.0031426053,
-0.0182615742,
-0.0041888333,
-0.0068057738,
-0.0113339089,
-0.0669421032,
-0.1039816812,
0.0640983656,
0.0030031661,
-0.0122427614,
0.0353536308,
0.008868522,
-0.0541416034,
-0.0503755398,
-0.0430476889,
0.0747272745,
-0.0032328954,
0.0231308192,
0.011703331,
0.0114507535,
-0.0298592877,
0.0074865166,
-0.0169440042,
0.0213576108,
0.0016276968,
0.0046485798,
-0.067906715,
0.0007098737,
0.0164235961,
-0.0673293471,
0.0115888547,
-0.0347949937,
0.0098808352,
0.0184214581,
0.0008264968,
-0.0016194682,
-0.0202653613,
-0.0509554148,
0.0058951173,
0.0028824962,
-0.0140929148,
-0.036459256,
-0.048091352,
-0.0449049845,
-0.0402839594,
0.0422638245,
0.0080691995,
0.0346214361,
-0.0906740278,
0.0380805247,
-0.0039422954,
0.0630426258,
-0.0226019397,
0.0284437351,
0.0234075356,
-0.0373507403,
-0.0071822675,
-0.0304663144,
-0.0411555544,
-0.0116198752,
-0.0592472367,
-0.0494511165,
-0.0209114756,
-0.0022898682,
-0.0508209504,
0.0402820483,
-0.0035161774,
0.0209230203,
-0.005757493,
0.0163772963,
-0.0087855989,
0.0454274714,
0.0200409908,
0.0443891175,
-0.0271665361,
-0.0406813584,
-0.0155502763,
0.0134260468,
0.0170031656,
0.0060495134,
0.0270339679,
0.1099427044,
-0.0249514151,
-0.0296802521,
0.0189574212,
0.0059177605,
-0.0424676985,
-0.0291103609,
0.0310101546,
-0.0662522763,
0.0365254395,
-0.0026405533,
0.0140143195,
0.0263426322,
0.0085526742,
-0.032990966,
0.0268447567,
0.062994048,
0.0086475853,
0.0107828192,
0.0053900173,
-0.0139652574,
0.0235865004,
0.0490343124,
0.0573007688,
0.000881606,
-0.0157987792,
-0.0014068434,
-0.0037944433,
0.0703143477,
0.0031737052,
0.0233333632,
-0.0571367256,
-0.0317854322,
0.0583875291,
0.043940004,
0.0684201568,
0.0727229118,
-0.0469098762,
-0.0497526787,
0.0453906991,
0.0524323992,
0.0018786865,
-0.0347586125,
0.0175934006,
-0.0018355763,
-0.0055921338,
-0.039250128,
-0.0178600214,
0.0560848825,
0.075337261,
0.0067172553,
0.0332835764,
0.0121716904,
-0.0458248481,
-0.0179517139,
-0.0003127894,
-0.0292635728,
-0.0116944388,
0.0526086725,
0.0235394333,
0.0082044862,
-0.0216200929,
0.0193820689,
-0.0206823628,
-0.0006894539,
0.0341880769,
0.0187338889,
0.0206192359,
0.0801533237,
-0.0023489615,
-0.0072684297,
-0.0080515454,
-0.0156553779,
0.0193967763,
0.0377664231,
-0.0373815559,
-0.0310748089,
0.1032055318,
-0.0630155429,
-0.0456472486,
-0.0193880145,
-0.007784233,
0.0340468213,
-0.0205159131,
0.0466535352,
-0.0149652725,
-0.0215461086,
0.0731697455,
0.013023952,
-0.0061569824,
0.0169539116,
-0.0138185155,
0.0432981886,
0.0169696156,
0.0076670186,
-0.0286860224,
-0.03169135,
0.0244604535,
-0.0500634201,
0.0637903363,
0.0447312221,
-0.035048686,
-0.0127947703,
0.0221889969,
-0.0697366893,
0.0043568644,
0.0189426746,
-0.0067479643,
-0.0424702987,
0.0518133864,
-0.0150649985,
0.0434125736,
-0.0435680896,
-0.0091665713,
0.0335612223,
-0.0088271163,
0.048566211,
-0.0495034792,
-0.0154297464,
-0.0136957662,
0.0395968147,
0.0029588451,
0.0151995951,
-0.0425285138,
-0.0154433688,
0.0116561214,
0.0225713849,
0.0071319086,
-0.0348363407,
-0.0118799275,
-0.0160729475,
-0.0239156205,
-0.0898637176,
-0.0173891075,
-0.0225240942,
-0.0372389667,
-0.0321767516,
-0.0047054347,
0.0089463834,
-0.0672533438,
-0.0282157343,
0.0048998855,
0.0229049902,
-0.0003230557,
-0.0224468913,
0.0106780659,
-0.024806628,
-0.0191956852,
0.0065549933,
0.0439859666,
0.0001560017,
-0.0467908867,
-0.0190753713,
-0.0049926578,
-0.0849449188,
-0.023897903,
0.0633226782,
-0.0247670356,
0.024645647,
-0.0031502401,
0.0326153636,
0.0342958495,
0.0199450981,
0.0151154594,
-0.0048737284,
0.0074383235,
-0.0433301404,
-0.0369379371,
-0.0106231272,
0.0230005533,
0.0254196841,
-0.0349157229,
0.0496932566,
-0.0656400919,
-0.0246069133,
0.0134334648,
0.0719483122,
-0.0646006465,
-0.0005974307,
0.0332342125,
-0.0561779216,
-0.0468343683,
-0.0084970547,
0.0027557178,
-0.0094370265,
-0.0368488766,
-0.0585455522,
0.0128623303,
-0.0652748048,
-0.0468713827,
0.065254949,
-0.0183599163,
-0.0320495404,
0.0772443265,
-0.0005663194,
-0.0010084028,
-0.0384538807,
-0.052942045,
-0.0487322249,
0.0047573037,
-0.0041248729,
0.0029876754,
0.0291231275,
-0.0408893377,
-0.011784222,
-0.0252939314,
-0.0141069982,
-0.0347307101,
0.011421781,
-0.0588780604,
-0.0049919584,
-0.0332845561,
-0.0147753144,
0.0064472179,
0.0332946926,
0.0280067753,
0.0163135007,
0.0246872082,
0.016114112,
-0.0337651409,
0.0198791232,
0.0430156961,
0.0188986193,
-0.066335395,
-0.0489008278,
-0.0062445104,
0.0231794454,
0.047750257,
-0.0076096156,
-0.0653835982,
0.0458773337,
0.0455705822,
0.065250434,
-0.0136708785,
-0.0021300199,
0.0175892077,
-0.049109038,
0.0366563573,
0.035395544,
-0.0216009691,
-0.0472899526,
-0.0129062086,
0.0227137096,
0.0252696481,
0.0155843915,
-0.0154340612,
-0.0891204476,
-0.0560224019,
0.028433945,
0.0122870244,
0.0621092543,
0.0458427928,
-0.0268365759,
-0.0359041728,
0.0191768613,
0.0173699223,
-0.0165561121,
-0.0280845482,
-0.00090883,
0.0217698738,
-0.0356110223,
0.0391365327,
0.011772126,
-0.0212344341,
0.0047374517,
0.0518544763,
-0.0025668158,
0.0279478151,
0.01371432,
-0.0574064925,
0.0107934792,
0.0571937636,
0.0292264707,
0.012338887,
-0.0530683212,
-0.0014872637,
-0.013419332,
0.0000568621,
-0.0054899482,
0.0428960323,
-0.0502342135,
-0.0509706028,
0.0627020895,
0.0256346446,
0.015202228,
0.0181781296,
0.0514143519,
0.0418753475,
-0.0112288864,
0.0226048101,
0.0145107014,
0.0196848065,
-0.0219569914,
0.0201231409,
-0.0173590649,
-0.0124875782,
-0.0241136905,
0.027755525,
0.0280978829,
-0.0037950715,
0.028608935,
-0.0339274518,
0.0382723622,
-0.0310619157,
-0.0022368557,
0.009865189,
0.0387377255,
0.0332101285,
0.0237758886,
0.00928545,
-0.0019373333,
0.041520793,
-0.087684311,
0.0308284294,
-0.0022811708,
0.0740192458,
-0.0667366758,
-0.0220938567,
-0.0067007528,
-0.0517121553,
0.0032096212,
0.0279882047,
-0.0586337633,
-0.0550303683,
-0.0222098995,
0.0188960414,
0.0096461633,
0.1162687913,
0.0146994572,
0.0130087407,
0.0465036817,
0.0480915755,
-0.0042942092,
0.0692869127,
0.0376598015,
-0.0248168595,
-0.0232088175,
-0.0053851721,
-0.0645754784,
-0.004905446,
-0.0233803503,
0.0095202588,
-0.0070713898,
-0.0571777597,
-0.0227985214,
-0.038782347,
0.0754968598,
-0.0426950939,
0.0324618816,
-0.0313103758,
0.0111148888,
0.0162349846,
0.0681346431,
-0.093117021,
0.0108782118,
0.0087126726,
0.0462518819,
-0.001238147,
0.0048225732,
0.0623675399,
-0.0273104422,
-0.0096151205,
0.0322110802,
-0.0430981629,
-0.0009992472,
0.0003012777,
0.0149190947,
0.0373269618,
0.024384642,
0.0023820035,
0.0062076431,
0.00122061,
0.0156215224,
0.034707915,
-0.0240619127,
0.012505129,
0.0506572463,
-0.0055449228,
-0.0343423337,
-0.0072021037,
0.0321283266,
0.0237499699,
0.00172244,
0.0069939368,
-0.0100401742,
0.003663928,
-0.0227484424,
0.0848376304,
-0.0504118428,
-0.0588668659,
0.0526917018,
-0.0085550286,
-0.0360978618,
0.013360519,
0.0098986123,
0.0044209519,
-0.0166246872,
-0.0383549668,
0.0458764918,
-0.0395336635,
-0.0340670981,
0.0385114364,
-0.0127440942,
-0.011726425,
-0.004222577,
0.0025963667,
-0.0466951877,
0.041612383,
0.0240650326,
-0.0005564504,
0.0037912943,
0.0375619195,
-0.0107503803,
0.0224639885,
0.0086927032,
0.0147898793,
-0.0602736436,
0.0330898501,
-0.004538273,
0.0142323282,
-4.655712517e-33,
-0.0288070869,
-0.0311656017,
0.0468645431,
-0.0036347692,
-0.0610517599,
0.0162537303,
-0.0196285471,
0.0070213005,
0.0348261073,
-0.0221922342,
0.0488810167,
0.0110686775,
0.0040809037,
0.0123521909,
0.0249955375,
-0.0332985781,
0.0697627887,
-0.0148680694,
0.0251220297,
0.0138882436,
0.0471701622,
0.0421845727,
0.0228153691,
-0.001513401,
-0.0537806414,
0.0257849079,
0.0242405981,
-0.0334571116,
0.022826219,
0.0240503941,
-0.0157162268,
-0.0013058782,
-0.0264509618,
0.0199241564,
0.0170078613,
0.0094330525,
-0.0803069994,
0.0272089988,
0.0060746297,
0.0561799034,
-0.0882711485,
0.0267739873,
0.018666517,
0.002159059,
-0.025827365,
-0.0377829783,
0.0533957072,
-0.0179900173,
-0.0260229763,
-0.0247042309,
-0.0236024652,
0.0160330217,
-0.0295701418,
-0.0528437421,
0.0834127367,
0.0657948777,
0.0448660254,
-0.0310602356,
-0.0258337688,
0.0457972921,
-0.0817684755,
0.0051068366,
0.0872673616,
0.0545302592,
0.0169853214,
0.0715349838,
0.0485426076,
-0.1458120197,
0.0105836075,
0.0567815937,
0.0395377167,
0.0342543386,
0.0081293443,
0.0205664914,
0.0030541793,
-0.0056262859,
-0.0044682887,
-0.018009631,
-0.0224919487,
0.0003269017,
-0.0089716827,
0.034682855,
0.0046657757,
0.0096549373,
-0.0343543962,
-0.0055516521,
-0.0202044304,
-0.0022173941,
0.0574443452,
0.0379141346,
0.0255640354,
0.0254128911,
0.0857805163,
-0.0222544111,
0.0098249754,
0.0079299435,
-0.0131116435,
0.0073181344,
0.0151100308,
0.0179811846,
-0.039408084,
0.0197219625,
0.0806882232,
0.0033617197,
0.0394333713,
-0.0075838631,
-0.0151467994,
0.032578595,
-0.041166801,
-0.0208069701,
0.008972819,
0.0751877353,
-0.021745028,
0.0099155009,
0.0584572405,
-0.0024022071,
-0.0264897309,
0.0056561162,
-0.0433537699,
-0.0053824815,
-0.0367146172,
0.0120145064,
-0.0306148641,
0.0116668977,
-0.0133557422,
0.0367293879,
-0.01168478,
-0.0300150141,
-0.0124483369,
-0.0389191918,
0.0157767627,
0.0334687792,
2.513e-7,
-0.0463359728,
-0.0372606367,
0.0679047406,
-0.02143397,
0.0342928693,
0.0166213065,
-0.0414586514,
0.0250305533,
0.0052159722,
-0.029533742,
0.0130958296,
0.0253923722,
0.0589307882,
0.0006146425,
-0.0386095904,
0.0461910255,
-0.0392417423,
-0.0161717758,
-0.0156390462,
0.0302915201,
-0.0053235251,
0.0373546071,
0.000545465,
-0.0094158771,
0.0497673526,
0.0125760334,
0.056706585,
-0.0163059719,
0.0085357176,
-0.0688991621,
-0.0089710997,
-0.039484892,
-0.0118029816,
0.0228246041,
-0.0188226253,
-0.000239809,
0.0233962256,
0.0042482065,
-0.0407327227,
-0.0941320658,
-0.0624659508,
0.078277193,
-0.0411841124,
0.0293984041,
0.024513904,
0.0049090246,
-0.0126925046,
-0.0346361473,
-0.0485106707,
0.0244502239,
0.0102992635,
0.0278111529,
-0.04029027,
0.0372925065,
0.0384936891,
-0.0399574153,
-0.0044617723,
-0.0618794449,
0.0107452311,
-0.0385038368,
-0.0561334528,
-0.0229981933,
-0.0482900552,
0.0169058796,
-0.0164625868,
-0.0016785323,
-0.0781161413,
1.208436662e-34,
0.0082698558,
-0.0510282815,
0.0265806187,
-0.0453601219,
-0.0424248725,
-0.0267398041,
-0.0052143643,
0.0351200886,
0.0013457212,
0.0004268601,
-0.052110929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12232v1 | "You Gotta be a Doctor, Lin": An Investigation of Name-Based Bias of Large Language Models in Employment Recommendations | 2024-06-18T03:11:43 | 2024-06-18T03:11:43 | Huy Nghiem, John Prindle, Jieyu Zhao, Hal Daumé III | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Social science research has shown that candidates with names indicative of
certain races or genders often face discrimination in employment practices.
Similarly, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated racial and gender
biases in various applications. In this study, we utilize GPT-3.5-Turbo and
Llama 3-70B-Instruct to simulate hiring decisions and salary recommendations
for candidates with 320 first names that strongly signal their race and gender,
across over 750,000 prompts. Our empirical results indicate a preference among
these models for hiring candidates with White female-sounding names over other
demographic groups across 40 occupations. Additionally, even among candidates
with identical qualifications, salary recommendations vary by as much as 5%
between different subgroups. A comparison with real-world labor data reveals
inconsistent alignment with U.S. labor market characteristics, underscoring the
necessity of risk investigation of LLM-powered systems. | [
0.0440200754,
0.1042622253,
-0.0355061479,
-0.0303906798,
0.015578106,
0.0317948684,
0.0374181867,
0.0233279373,
0.0252904464,
-0.0404837318,
0.0305388961,
-0.0119412374,
0.0322046541,
-0.0005196005,
0.0253996868,
-0.0203489978,
0.0140098147,
0.0338500366,
0.0447813384,
-0.0591668934,
-0.0032628351,
0.0320428833,
0.0351087488,
0.0888686776,
-0.0098367687,
-0.0031855293,
0.0703080595,
0.0014541345,
-0.0004419249,
0.0057400055,
0.0152246095,
0.0596420355,
-0.0397318602,
0.0319091268,
0.0000019083,
-0.0782845765,
0.0188486893,
0.0056553697,
-0.026338689,
-0.0322421752,
0.0493803918,
0.0100032371,
-0.0151248788,
0.0233886763,
-0.0268853586,
0.0218795016,
0.0424033552,
-0.0344867744,
0.0039383271,
-0.0202040244,
0.0074691908,
-0.0001389473,
-0.0483511984,
-0.0372322798,
0.0121045513,
-0.0222128201,
0.0557067133,
-0.0594117977,
-0.0068049035,
-0.0433096178,
-0.0084540807,
-0.0338626914,
-0.0389085039,
-0.0220322944,
0.0021487819,
0.0559114665,
-0.0169606153,
0.0027759182,
0.0140950773,
0.0422296524,
-0.0038748998,
0.0101781851,
0.0037742252,
-0.0259598419,
0.0575128756,
-0.0095813898,
0.0007637982,
0.0255370699,
-0.0423406996,
-0.0245074164,
-0.0249077156,
0.0015552538,
0.015507184,
0.0310198795,
0.0107306438,
0.1127585247,
0.0076125567,
-0.0315796882,
0.020594595,
0.0010718914,
0.0910651684,
-0.0647782311,
0.0496147387,
-0.0142000299,
-0.0510369763,
0.0136005767,
-0.0030696795,
0.0245780069,
0.0348817408,
-0.0775272921,
0.0016885537,
0.0601425581,
0.0313883647,
0.0116565842,
0.0284194332,
0.0202754196,
-0.0136844832,
-0.0351142399,
0.0087299077,
-0.0097414153,
-0.02690956,
-0.0279983003,
-0.0192325842,
-0.0095785949,
-0.0254150871,
0.0745105445,
-0.0913055465,
-0.0052553401,
-0.0584605783,
0.017177064,
0.0023126092,
0.0035155686,
0.0031908301,
0.0279102419,
-0.0898360237,
-0.0376023091,
-0.0034474253,
0.022368893,
-0.0078003407,
-0.0377901383,
0.0372560956,
-0.0146101704,
-0.0003840711,
-0.0383813977,
0.006192694,
0.0619214699,
0.0562382676,
-0.0033031187,
-0.005695784,
-0.0342202373,
0.0076536825,
-0.0236535277,
-0.0413651839,
-0.0509550087,
0.0106044114,
0.0140660042,
0.015831599,
-0.0805213749,
0.0168149639,
0.0062690522,
-0.0718143806,
0.0478497036,
0.0215102211,
0.0137488348,
0.0650453568,
0.0086163469,
-0.0122482879,
0.0294970665,
0.0419447459,
0.0218969975,
0.0239457097,
-0.0646081418,
0.0338426158,
0.0569706336,
-0.0279250294,
0.0081432704,
-0.0074469764,
0.0493574068,
-0.0029954284,
0.0071149184,
0.0580406599,
-0.0108928215,
-0.0275428519,
-0.0133622373,
0.0141631756,
0.1162411794,
0.0085907094,
0.0276463535,
0.065461874,
0.0273277424,
-0.0298404004,
-0.0512889586,
-0.060845647,
-0.0096248202,
-0.0569937415,
-0.0297250599,
-0.0195477828,
0.0457195975,
-0.0343538523,
0.0005357742,
0.0138781527,
0.0078359917,
0.0081577282,
0.0137626389,
-0.019657366,
-0.0180182531,
-0.0332572684,
0.0386544354,
0.0544444732,
-0.0187680889,
-0.0362968072,
-0.0456267148,
-0.0131929684,
0.1161794886,
-0.0009821916,
0.0000324831,
0.040563941,
-0.0493418388,
-0.034372516,
0.0212506261,
0.0613610335,
0.0169910621,
0.0190068725,
-0.0366129614,
-0.0049360883,
0.0980779082,
0.0221096594,
0.0748306662,
0.0800022855,
0.0256278869,
0.0283249039,
-0.0001007198,
-0.0723010972,
0.0062616956,
-0.0441951156,
-0.071903564,
0.0276321135,
-0.0093780542,
-0.0011551651,
-0.0128315482,
-0.0132400263,
-0.0020556268,
-0.0687575564,
0.0208537187,
0.0023655184,
0.0043837,
-0.0258946829,
0.0576090105,
-0.0272653047,
-0.0128400242,
-0.0608259216,
0.0017785168,
0.0094300285,
0.0217212532,
0.0326926485,
0.0301907547,
-0.0054194159,
-0.014799308,
-0.0005105039,
-0.0244706199,
0.036118906,
-0.0301113296,
0.0297049507,
0.017166853,
0.0014111919,
0.0088327033,
0.0012225976,
-0.0291040689,
-0.1374222189,
-0.0085890153,
0.018041404,
0.0033960354,
0.0131951366,
-0.0173113905,
0.0083115604,
-0.0068591191,
-0.0202248562,
-0.0411505848,
0.0241210461,
0.0551877134,
-0.027665358,
-0.0232976954,
0.0194439813,
-0.0282861348,
0.0024104246,
0.0153859602,
-0.0275863484,
0.0424309894,
0.0358641148,
-0.0049441527,
-0.0416782238,
-0.0333609879,
-0.0345728956,
-0.0753495172,
-0.0446408801,
0.0308720693,
0.0584712587,
0.057474155,
-0.0556763634,
-0.0069164545,
-0.0469456464,
-0.0132762929,
0.0049508568,
0.0071623712,
-0.0120664556,
0.0272585973,
0.021367047,
0.0332647562,
-0.0163359754,
0.0090978779,
0.0199456867,
-0.0255340412,
-0.0199194588,
-0.0079936339,
0.0156284999,
0.0458654873,
0.0110396082,
-0.091946356,
-0.0437194258,
0.0185242966,
0.0003732991,
-0.0202060156,
-0.0317346863,
0.0692237318,
-0.0376434252,
-0.0474219136,
-0.06596037,
-0.0094077559,
-0.0323244482,
0.0594842248,
-0.0182875209,
-0.0359457433,
0.017288696,
-0.0019153282,
0.0328440107,
0.023080023,
-0.0362703726,
-0.03654496,
0.0159533974,
-0.0090722088,
-0.0003920857,
0.0033827939,
-0.0160850324,
-0.0227729175,
0.0020473634,
0.0246374235,
-0.0493663922,
0.0238698311,
0.0052556219,
-0.0007798289,
0.0074854139,
-0.0320269838,
-0.0242517479,
-0.0705918893,
-0.0447921529,
0.0169509333,
0.0520682596,
-0.003421356,
-0.0339455977,
0.0316571519,
0.0152650867,
0.0030381652,
-0.0171644911,
-0.0215847939,
-0.0181944557,
-0.0222706422,
-0.0023451543,
0.0267758723,
0.0223034937,
-0.0322444141,
0.0169328842,
-0.0268501174,
-0.0095297797,
0.0049468651,
-0.0019671049,
0.0228268299,
0.01993284,
-0.0614356212,
-0.0025982391,
0.0238454007,
-0.0303474814,
-0.0305389315,
0.0517405756,
0.0756493062,
0.0006369628,
-0.0390380993,
-0.0002686584,
-0.0052701961,
0.0102038812,
0.0422138385,
0.042270232,
-0.0724684298,
0.0195780154,
0.019700978,
0.0373631343,
-0.0451801158,
-0.0629948601,
-0.0147887096,
-0.1068059132,
0.0494645759,
-0.0231893156,
-0.0006951279,
0.0121411001,
-0.0323382951,
-0.0110391378,
-0.0173482969,
0.001625563,
-0.0090151802,
-0.0157201048,
0.0132801319,
-0.0061939475,
-0.0317670219,
-0.0217274632,
0.077214621,
-0.046023719,
-0.0183175839,
0.0543651842,
0.0459044166,
-0.0516146794,
0.000427688,
0.0035527723,
-0.0031859893,
-0.0107928216,
0.0130842486,
0.0192299932,
-0.0063588428,
-0.0021009543,
-0.0536636449,
0.0122171631,
-0.0027557188,
0.0351580419,
0.0402382687,
0.013605467,
0.0224765521,
-0.0339699648,
-0.0080133434,
0.0138240391,
-0.0277008228,
0.0698160678,
-0.0045136153,
-0.0721140802,
0.0167391524,
-0.0584802367,
0.003686781,
0.0490585342,
-0.0808463916,
0.0086777508,
-0.013372275,
0.0132811479,
0.0210150704,
-0.0672244802,
0.0068687955,
0.0102085387,
0.0293406043,
-0.0262232386,
0.0197553691,
-0.0182228982,
-0.0002364939,
0.0478635728,
-0.0533949099,
0.0737453029,
0.0119346967,
0.0089695258,
-0.0080670994,
-0.0252364855,
-0.0554248281,
-0.0029653483,
-0.0227210689,
-0.0311475992,
0.0057158601,
0.0160221513,
0.0389298014,
0.0191717371,
-0.0209419485,
-0.0596385077,
-0.0070691253,
0.0577808209,
-0.0057314718,
0.0293225572,
-0.0306392387,
0.0163886454,
-0.0030197517,
-0.024879612,
-0.0104418248,
0.0762493089,
0.0236959662,
-0.0370550677,
-0.0042037652,
-0.0436290801,
-0.0142849116,
0.0251029804,
-0.0094453283,
-0.0084664058,
-0.0027199578,
-0.0419180058,
0.0049541751,
-0.0255347528,
-0.0135135092,
0.0064585167,
-0.030954767,
0.0487265475,
0.0323181376,
-0.0029053271,
-0.0263875853,
-0.0209728219,
0.025712736,
-0.0307968985,
0.0476483777,
-0.0299296211,
0.0603593104,
0.0438258089,
-0.0546313077,
0.0248356257,
0.0358831063,
-0.0038899949,
0.0350061618,
0.0484613031,
0.0202778876,
-0.0167899355,
0.0174187906,
-0.005450997,
0.0089020627,
-0.0242582671,
-0.0744521171,
0.0274112448,
0.0312408153,
-0.0040535326,
-0.0590338781,
0.0200108625,
0.0095583163,
0.005091764,
0.0068883337,
-0.0348161608,
0.0394906662,
0.0207328256,
0.0647731647,
-0.001646239,
-0.0176368915,
-0.00985038,
0.0289580617,
0.0517363138,
0.0253287107,
-0.0321746208,
-0.0433211625,
-0.0055651511,
-0.0376878642,
0.0291747451,
0.0293480195,
-0.0239201561,
-0.0165304281,
-0.1209970266,
-0.036314968,
-0.0223152805,
-0.0164694283,
0.0217560418,
-0.0268484708,
-0.0047804662,
0.030002363,
-0.0131168412,
0.004641749,
0.0050848271,
-0.0111277578,
-0.0438196063,
-0.04212749,
-0.0278331712,
-5.881097787e-33,
-0.0016386959,
-0.0361248329,
0.0168044232,
-0.0220552366,
0.0049605165,
0.0105172377,
0.0215804242,
-0.0021245135,
0.0122266533,
-0.0238930844,
-0.0434394404,
0.0034423163,
0.0065811141,
-0.0099108387,
0.0124995988,
0.0235976186,
0.0211746022,
0.0320210271,
-0.0155741116,
0.0051088333,
-0.0473520197,
0.0328063965,
0.0166996755,
-0.0123937819,
0.0483178198,
-0.0161438696,
-0.0075547611,
-0.0019556463,
-0.0014310156,
0.0366628394,
-0.0132226162,
0.0437695906,
0.0080251899,
-0.0506896228,
-0.0148166548,
0.033556439,
-0.0408455245,
-0.0164032895,
0.0137218339,
-0.0050170696,
0.0633667931,
-0.0335506834,
0.0208415128,
0.0288543385,
-0.07290335,
0.01451704,
0.0755581111,
-0.0156424046,
0.0468665846,
0.0307017639,
-0.0168327652,
0.0441440158,
-0.0467254259,
0.0667950064,
0.0052647488,
0.0254287589,
0.0011174618,
0.0596580878,
-0.0675965473,
-0.0094923871,
0.0188477375,
-0.0065977066,
0.0101569789,
0.0147490399,
0.0121643925,
0.0070238081,
0.0738899708,
0.0338997059,
-0.009322824,
-0.0713746473,
0.005166206,
-0.0072378889,
-0.043496836,
0.0711896643,
0.0462789088,
-0.0657488853,
-0.0220322125,
-0.0041646971,
0.0106032491,
-0.0350021832,
0.0391853675,
-0.016139349,
-0.0503362194,
-0.0493445769,
-0.0275148172,
-0.055752378,
-0.0235471688,
-0.0327059776,
0.0469121449,
-0.0035616683,
0.0523020998,
0.0293286275,
-0.0048838644,
-0.0305227675,
-0.0490531176,
-0.0263665598,
-0.0360883214,
-0.0356003717,
0.0196536556,
-0.0026536193,
-0.0863329917,
0.0304962955,
-0.0301865749,
0.0184764694,
0.0366662517,
0.0720609203,
-0.0342126638,
-0.0239040796,
-0.08900249,
0.0164580103,
0.0070491633,
0.0268512946,
0.0067172898,
0.0106225098,
0.0491281636,
0.0066816392,
0.0520609803,
-0.0265984125,
0.0630851239,
-0.0087784939,
-0.0225816034,
-0.0560653284,
0.0063295569,
0.0411546677,
-0.0189994555,
-0.0034343766,
-0.0044792597,
0.0016548183,
0.0566909313,
-0.0499001034,
-0.001650462,
-0.0521358848,
2.486e-7,
-0.0015174747,
0.0506055504,
-0.0604222678,
0.0125377355,
0.0323634222,
0.0347555876,
0.0314881615,
0.0404613502,
0.0820407867,
0.0260244496,
-0.0276355483,
0.0072215428,
0.003588151,
0.0027904487,
-0.0790056139,
0.0018625504,
-0.0715861022,
-0.0074469382,
-0.0626412332,
-0.0152434055,
-0.0068560806,
0.0670387372,
0.0803204849,
-0.0229237396,
-0.0416398495,
-0.0030783957,
0.0239905957,
-0.0597455092,
0.0104700644,
0.027511891,
0.0286606494,
0.0011400766,
-0.0078377249,
0.0551228076,
-0.0099000363,
0.0436254367,
0.023465097,
0.0379393324,
-0.0338594653,
0.0916371122,
0.0049446891,
-0.0345339142,
-0.0205708761,
-0.0583961718,
0.0402456224,
0.0402137041,
-0.0396961085,
-0.0494576991,
-0.0483208001,
-0.017196415,
0.0377779901,
0.0197106861,
-0.0077218623,
-0.0041691917,
0.0022994594,
0.0023835367,
-0.0085561899,
0.008700842,
0.0262289401,
-0.0069158729,
-0.0191604514,
-0.1097124815,
0.017045714,
0.0402382649,
0.0334490277,
-0.0249391962,
0.0192312691,
2.144199501e-34,
0.0260187592,
0.054627914,
0.0131186284,
-0.0354220793,
0.0479327403,
0.0314440466,
0.0071709673,
0.0007937053,
0.0351795182,
-0.000454983,
-0.0046515781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12230v1 | MCSD: An Efficient Language Model with Diverse Fusion | 2024-06-18T03:08:01 | 2024-06-18T03:08:01 | Hua Yang, Duohai Li, Shiman Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformers excel in Natural Language Processing (NLP) due to their prowess
in capturing long-term dependencies but suffer from exponential resource
consumption with increasing sequence lengths. To address these challenges, we
propose MCSD model, an efficient language model with linear scaling and fast
inference speed. MCSD model leverages diverse feature fusion, primarily through
the multi-channel slope and decay (MCSD) block, to robustly represent features.
This block comprises slope and decay sections that extract features across
diverse temporal receptive fields, facilitating capture of both local and
global information. In addition, MCSD block conducts element-wise fusion of
diverse features to further enhance the delicate feature extraction capability.
For inference, we formulate the inference process into a recurrent
representation, slashing space complexity to $O(1)$ and time complexity to
$O(N)$ respectively. Our experiments show that MCSD attains higher throughput
and lower GPU memory consumption compared to Transformers, while maintaining
comparable performance to larger-scale language learning models on benchmark
tests. These attributes position MCSD as a promising base for edge deployment
and embodied intelligence. | [
0.0036491004,
0.0556976907,
0.0056246114,
0.0452122577,
-0.0259115752,
-0.0128327627,
0.0090025412,
-0.0352071337,
-0.0003808848,
-0.0609413125,
0.0197795425,
-0.0383687653,
0.0324885324,
0.0706267133,
-0.0370630883,
-0.0616199784,
0.0365717672,
-0.022421632,
-0.0091131702,
0.0028673825,
-0.0023255292,
0.0251547638,
-0.0146540655,
0.0455284454,
-0.0117130624,
0.0060736509,
-0.0058588353,
-0.0246119723,
0.0039258879,
-0.0335498452,
-0.0408613831,
0.0285713598,
0.0499375947,
0.0449391156,
0.0000021754,
-0.0337894894,
0.0016329339,
-0.0065244562,
-0.0365335941,
-0.0298601929,
0.0336989835,
-0.0357956663,
-0.0308023226,
0.0036153418,
-0.0377447046,
-0.0654059425,
0.0534730144,
0.0334721953,
0.048860088,
0.0495346226,
-0.0203644577,
-0.0670777783,
0.0413835756,
-0.0071826628,
-0.0235445816,
-0.0087778317,
0.022953853,
-0.0721859708,
-0.0063965786,
-0.0119039295,
-0.0194176026,
0.0257614423,
0.032551676,
0.0110470615,
0.0332579277,
0.0587820411,
0.021927828,
0.0085498979,
-0.035270974,
0.0508781336,
-0.0447278693,
-0.0189562012,
0.0043200534,
0.0129484357,
-0.0360987745,
-0.0401767083,
-0.0046478836,
0.0258785225,
0.0032729334,
0.0080972705,
-0.032397408,
-0.0027051365,
0.0283996183,
0.0413381904,
-0.0383771807,
0.0380249843,
0.0138719771,
0.0001641603,
-0.0125334049,
-0.0054177679,
-0.0073415823,
-0.0264682751,
0.017603578,
0.0348364748,
-0.0078013227,
0.0132535975,
-0.0398506895,
-0.0659817606,
-0.0033978764,
-0.0501360819,
0.0163742434,
0.0264147688,
0.010421318,
0.0519266836,
0.0081446981,
0.0382187292,
-0.019986406,
0.0026370995,
-0.043424543,
0.0082134334,
-0.0199212227,
-0.0065574148,
-0.0121797044,
0.0570771061,
-0.014009905,
-0.0509843566,
-0.0118122082,
0.0238818228,
-0.0056860601,
-0.0257801153,
0.002298909,
0.0358556397,
-0.0165175945,
-0.0087048663,
-0.0203676093,
0.0526914187,
0.0140543655,
0.028798813,
0.022701012,
-0.043934714,
-0.0143681485,
0.0401704796,
0.0258286446,
-0.0168564245,
0.0230190922,
0.0921797901,
-0.0074496111,
-0.0548972376,
-0.0358622484,
0.0057233996,
-0.0219785273,
-0.0272821784,
0.0063931718,
-0.065361008,
0.0680972487,
0.0151831787,
-0.0289263241,
-0.036444433,
0.0213079564,
0.0290815085,
-0.0203967653,
0.070852384,
-0.0420889147,
-0.0163774621,
0.0160969757,
-0.0072994805,
0.005599509,
0.0514707156,
0.0589781925,
0.0364991091,
-0.0130547788,
0.0267063566,
-0.0254569296,
0.0174859837,
0.0014730104,
0.0186814237,
-0.0507755615,
-0.0334344283,
-0.0118599711,
0.0265393425,
0.0749744475,
0.0650567859,
-0.0131133534,
-0.0485322475,
0.0570462085,
0.0357400961,
-0.0227165334,
0.048300527,
0.0375292264,
0.0162159968,
-0.0190334786,
-0.0639504492,
-0.051266741,
0.0426205322,
0.0016225873,
0.0125871478,
0.001351708,
0.0783873796,
-0.0057748579,
-0.0050686589,
-0.0211806074,
-0.0285459198,
0.0439674892,
0.0343446061,
0.046863135,
-0.0145379584,
-0.0289992299,
0.0781862363,
0.0177280623,
-0.0644436926,
-0.0209089033,
-0.0304909442,
0.0075635137,
0.0712785423,
0.0242764857,
-0.0012494342,
-0.0167721491,
-0.0107791042,
-0.0085820984,
0.0320514962,
-0.002164335,
0.002370754,
0.0626226962,
-0.0445579886,
-0.0301726796,
0.026432436,
0.0024427006,
0.0445640758,
-0.0027344557,
0.0034313221,
0.0031610723,
-0.0176049042,
-0.0015403448,
0.038643714,
0.0011720618,
0.0189824644,
0.0104413647,
-0.0099091986,
0.0124225477,
0.0141606387,
0.0073528723,
0.0306527782,
0.0478963032,
-0.0725418776,
-0.0453233495,
0.0434878059,
-0.0854377672,
-0.0195358135,
0.0506792925,
-0.0020594096,
0.0137037029,
0.0175537542,
-0.0541164391,
-0.0366831273,
0.0309660565,
-0.0686151385,
0.0326361507,
-0.0265058931,
0.0059977095,
0.0180424359,
0.0220805351,
0.0008044823,
0.0795388967,
-0.0684544593,
0.001706297,
-0.0229390524,
0.0035270012,
0.0065311855,
0.0091385525,
-0.01856854,
0.0376553722,
-0.0082105445,
0.0282804724,
0.0132013168,
-0.0220870618,
-0.0004212551,
-0.0106577594,
-0.1029375717,
-0.0106141539,
-0.0258241072,
0.0086555351,
-0.0122141158,
0.0195585396,
0.0330273397,
-0.0062483302,
-0.0143623268,
-0.012079197,
-0.0210089255,
0.0387070067,
0.0090037566,
0.0248264298,
-0.0039383317,
-0.0201971941,
-0.026392661,
-0.0045688008,
0.0730792359,
-0.0413974673,
-0.0333920047,
0.0005392994,
-0.0325790234,
-0.0230277833,
0.0650253668,
-0.011540316,
-0.0212628245,
-0.0023132036,
-0.0400637276,
0.0523841344,
0.0362474993,
0.0563034602,
0.0354818329,
0.0334213823,
-0.0322134122,
-0.0098118149,
0.0291540176,
-0.0237284917,
0.0722066686,
-0.0237481166,
0.0246025082,
-0.0380000807,
0.0656949282,
0.008135343,
0.0023007686,
-0.042388428,
-0.0341565758,
0.0185221136,
-0.0132639958,
-0.0089159319,
-0.0092214197,
-0.0361995958,
-0.0152756535,
-0.0513220951,
-0.0495539866,
0.0378389359,
-0.0424427539,
-0.0218386613,
-0.0198845863,
-0.0259072483,
-0.0459522977,
0.067900531,
0.0006456992,
0.0118207261,
-0.0421874411,
-0.0030568675,
-0.0078362087,
0.0145947197,
0.0092507768,
-0.063424401,
0.0719799623,
-0.0550160706,
0.0369923934,
-0.0163324587,
-0.0283020642,
-0.0400538556,
-0.0109766005,
-0.0329455324,
0.0033591217,
0.0015920919,
-0.0356170014,
-0.0501483344,
0.0059645367,
0.0124288332,
0.0742044821,
0.0231704507,
0.0141161708,
0.0009920147,
0.0257189088,
0.0704530254,
0.0620844886,
0.011949596,
0.0121323159,
0.042842254,
0.0690040216,
0.0545745231,
0.0015632511,
-0.1019393578,
0.0054532764,
0.0185588188,
0.0088640125,
-0.0064947964,
0.0297179502,
0.0188941825,
-0.0655764118,
-0.0081867808,
0.0933504626,
-0.0081660151,
-0.0752899051,
-0.0242081601,
0.0298197549,
0.0425710343,
0.0275960285,
-0.0176040269,
-0.0397017859,
-0.0384671614,
0.010828835,
-0.0194474123,
0.0409688093,
-0.0250830874,
-0.0177609101,
-0.0975659043,
0.0159201734,
0.0097331721,
-0.0363025144,
-0.0188503545,
-0.0338667445,
-0.0271223988,
0.0127542876,
-0.0146036642,
-0.0101949358,
-0.0044808122,
-0.0206950121,
0.0163011607,
-0.0178525578,
-0.0198940281,
0.0463911742,
-0.025664743,
0.007917475,
0.0568014942,
0.0336911082,
0.0043570171,
-0.0800848454,
0.0335268192,
-0.0488205999,
-0.0122207496,
-0.0220662579,
0.0364727974,
-0.0440884866,
0.0126320515,
-0.0089400932,
0.0261319112,
-0.0454364568,
-0.0300609805,
-0.0638836101,
0.0881647915,
-0.0373918302,
-0.0070216232,
-0.048727978,
-0.0150653077,
0.0042177993,
0.0508408472,
-0.0140957488,
-0.0492903963,
-0.0620427653,
-0.0071323216,
-0.0304942857,
0.0074435151,
-0.0713691339,
0.0170994587,
0.0427814759,
-0.0650178492,
-0.0493315682,
-0.0176100116,
-0.0011957405,
0.0324047655,
-0.0182114355,
-0.0085645933,
-0.0066210185,
0.0272283182,
-0.0573557056,
0.0349171758,
-0.005671131,
0.0603469908,
-0.034149766,
0.0399487428,
0.0389648713,
-0.0280411728,
-0.030778002,
0.0464693494,
-0.1051561683,
-0.0693481043,
0.0196206737,
0.0146421753,
0.0191342067,
0.0387979113,
-0.0083360113,
0.0203305949,
0.0363194086,
0.0625250489,
-0.0151721397,
0.0239921939,
0.0271007884,
-0.019217331,
-0.0097332122,
0.0291328561,
-0.0296327993,
0.0292302649,
-0.0399770886,
0.0231130719,
-0.0419955775,
-0.0503459238,
0.0008281019,
-0.0447969213,
0.0708850771,
0.0018016294,
0.0245378539,
-0.0190842561,
-0.0087181209,
0.0138368802,
0.0036373367,
-0.0453573838,
0.0159316119,
0.0081292689,
-0.006008219,
0.0133089572,
-0.0009534753,
0.0775565803,
-0.0155693926,
0.0191161316,
-0.0062622656,
-0.0222536027,
-0.0283480417,
-0.0005152143,
0.0180180464,
-0.008523386,
-0.0135918399,
-0.0375227332,
0.0039879568,
-0.0257583708,
0.0416209549,
0.0275289454,
-0.0380259007,
-0.015846001,
0.0258061942,
-0.0585247539,
-0.0252085999,
-0.0406802818,
-0.0414520204,
0.0516495295,
-0.0035326313,
0.0498909168,
-0.0046076523,
0.0266093053,
-0.0321012177,
0.0298981629,
0.011140205,
-0.042972248,
0.0677935034,
0.0285102148,
-0.0328160711,
-0.0029577205,
0.0348043479,
-0.0018230736,
0.0314888097,
0.0210770462,
0.0101425508,
-0.0136691798,
-0.06561023,
-0.0278287344,
0.04801232,
-0.0237462837,
0.0129868165,
-0.0541227758,
-0.0469852053,
0.0785196275,
-0.0268738121,
0.0127979945,
-0.0133341299,
0.0543879122,
0.0451796129,
-0.0036704203,
-0.017353097,
-0.0072458354,
0.020198999,
-0.0350164585,
0.0098647373,
-0.0151767172,
-6.745682331e-33,
-0.0081711067,
-0.0040937099,
0.0398078971,
0.0033542488,
-0.046522636,
0.0077802804,
-0.0304867942,
0.0149601521,
-0.0495407917,
-0.0022170842,
0.0046060295,
0.0253031291,
0.0084004449,
0.0669013038,
0.008430142,
-0.0045450977,
0.0542950109,
-0.0066476809,
0.0276499409,
0.007678343,
0.0646259263,
0.0223948043,
0.0639308468,
-0.0623677075,
-0.0466068685,
-0.0156585313,
-0.0125143258,
0.0257201977,
0.0030267725,
0.017756518,
-0.0425260104,
0.0517124794,
0.0180553552,
-0.0351829566,
-0.0256791748,
-0.0003398247,
-0.0923671946,
-0.0053428016,
0.0004046269,
0.0218653493,
-0.0473513938,
-0.026572369,
0.0225954875,
0.0107426075,
0.0305543542,
-0.0407549068,
0.0206190534,
-0.0400071368,
-0.06370572,
-0.0430355258,
-0.0274989121,
0.0467572361,
0.0257126279,
0.0107268421,
0.0228121877,
0.0029130108,
0.0042964672,
0.0210105069,
-0.1096489951,
-0.0010547293,
-0.058951214,
0.0321573541,
0.0396840274,
0.0145176249,
0.0232034735,
0.0744066462,
0.0066366005,
-0.0327556096,
-0.0276106913,
0.026063351,
0.0447459631,
0.0309861936,
0.0368353799,
-0.0261401646,
0.0488446914,
-0.0401524045,
-0.0137451245,
-0.0124285799,
0.0363963991,
0.0726127774,
0.0361786112,
0.0216429438,
-0.0268580113,
-0.0167442113,
-0.0225301497,
-0.009959694,
-0.0277365819,
-0.0210207179,
0.023503691,
0.0552243032,
-0.0004929577,
0.0332574248,
0.0366127566,
-0.0039675268,
0.0188816637,
0.0489925891,
0.0024671312,
0.0221677069,
0.0052461927,
0.0107060447,
-0.0343955718,
-0.0263444632,
-0.0043246266,
-0.0175357331,
-0.009775185,
0.0102218352,
0.017904697,
0.0569049306,
-0.0773108602,
-0.0167242754,
-0.0407846235,
0.019300716,
0.0108095789,
0.0518927388,
0.0423872657,
0.0072780545,
-0.020568464,
0.0506898798,
-0.0490379222,
0.0424030274,
-0.0353464223,
0.0291641019,
-0.0038083862,
0.0234246459,
0.004585248,
-0.0089112893,
-0.0608867817,
-0.0154044116,
0.0025460725,
-0.0566022545,
-0.015943924,
0.0331533141,
2.957e-7,
0.0014899777,
0.0139555521,
0.0382507369,
0.0182997305,
0.0241731349,
0.0304029547,
0.0402879082,
0.0242011026,
-0.0152128888,
-0.0212648734,
-0.0270760898,
0.0451934673,
0.0451287255,
0.0173877627,
-0.0842970982,
0.0079478845,
-0.0662180185,
-0.0317104161,
-0.0345410407,
-0.0031155809,
0.043972224,
0.1321792603,
0.0163962562,
-0.0158439111,
0.0222104602,
-0.0319523327,
0.0665414035,
0.0007800012,
0.051677078,
-0.0320695005,
-0.0019827797,
-0.0069896141,
-0.0389462821,
0.0061947932,
-0.0115443943,
0.023628518,
-0.010716944,
0.0645052344,
-0.0355760567,
-0.0411636084,
0.0263293535,
-0.0163213853,
-0.0387657844,
0.0159702711,
0.074148953,
-0.0100423731,
-0.016398754,
-0.096952334,
-0.0087977629,
0.028517032,
-0.0102390964,
0.0222532768,
0.0192270987,
-0.0065767453,
-0.0020666642,
-0.056577377,
-0.005226654,
-0.1344038844,
-0.0492431447,
0.0271224696,
-0.0730489716,
-0.0082396064,
-0.0637124926,
0.0317996517,
0.0704203472,
-0.058004003,
-0.0306928121,
2.876589878e-34,
0.0234982613,
0.0075133746,
-0.0114851501,
0.0468534455,
-0.0009429734,
-0.0246762298,
0.0518624038,
-0.0058460878,
0.0089836661,
-0.0860038772,
-0.0128886569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12223v1 | ToxiCloakCN: Evaluating Robustness of Offensive Language Detection in Chinese with Cloaking Perturbations | 2024-06-18T02:44:56 | 2024-06-18T02:44:56 | Yunze Xiao, Yujia Hu, Kenny Tsu Wei Choo, Roy Ka-wei Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Detecting hate speech and offensive language is essential for maintaining a
safe and respectful digital environment. This study examines the limitations of
state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) in identifying offensive content
within systematically perturbed data, with a focus on Chinese, a language
particularly susceptible to such perturbations. We introduce
\textsf{ToxiCloakCN}, an enhanced dataset derived from ToxiCN, augmented with
homophonic substitutions and emoji transformations, to test the robustness of
LLMs against these cloaking perturbations. Our findings reveal that existing
models significantly underperform in detecting offensive content when these
perturbations are applied. We provide an in-depth analysis of how different
types of offensive content are affected by these perturbations and explore the
alignment between human and model explanations of offensiveness. Our work
highlights the urgent need for more advanced techniques in offensive language
detection to combat the evolving tactics used to evade detection mechanisms. | [
0.0530249476,
0.0694629923,
-0.048265893,
0.0341318175,
-0.0040357104,
0.0374899097,
0.0695068538,
0.0354338996,
0.0199004896,
-0.0378774591,
-0.0162371211,
-0.0155991632,
-0.0046524922,
0.0320211686,
0.0120833581,
-0.0236061756,
0.0355179831,
0.0295349099,
-0.0084631508,
-0.0056373389,
0.0497265123,
0.0081137819,
0.0284959618,
0.0504362322,
-0.0327461027,
-0.001534759,
0.0306793619,
0.0265515018,
0.0182110779,
0.0139153274,
0.0508944392,
0.0340155214,
-0.0126347253,
0.0922525451,
0.0000018619,
-0.0358944237,
0.0139567666,
-0.0021372912,
0.0045717224,
0.0210233312,
0.1086438373,
-0.0252134185,
-0.0579570904,
0.0385060646,
0.0045062099,
0.0274974424,
0.0847610012,
0.031837102,
0.0584411286,
0.057640437,
-0.0102355611,
-0.0185011961,
0.0033566961,
0.0082983784,
-0.0067061814,
0.0223158486,
0.0732120126,
-0.0344235338,
-0.0533088446,
-0.0065381625,
-0.0406294614,
-0.0024158715,
0.0143659366,
0.0082480023,
-0.0344189033,
-0.0245882049,
0.0006213175,
-0.0342920572,
0.0386429578,
0.0680733472,
-0.0647484064,
-0.0201064479,
-0.0109090647,
-0.0037341118,
-0.0190902557,
-0.0260057226,
-0.0159144923,
-0.0081132893,
0.0240835287,
0.0152230272,
-0.0133431563,
-0.0175121706,
0.0581406802,
0.090752013,
0.0136140417,
0.004239494,
0.001049209,
-0.0433507562,
-0.0368813127,
-0.048271738,
-0.0248862654,
0.0029414934,
0.049118571,
-0.0072438619,
-0.0093712118,
0.012708446,
-0.0289603006,
-0.0764667839,
0.012294637,
-0.0861961767,
0.0388413444,
0.05164003,
-0.0613533296,
-0.0005769023,
-0.015766032,
0.0644206703,
-0.0310882553,
0.0179106742,
0.0030166286,
-0.0093063992,
-0.0056416113,
-0.0022183349,
0.0073893708,
-0.0152792633,
-0.0124398787,
0.0288497023,
-0.0469827354,
0.0084397346,
-0.0517293513,
-0.0399995334,
-0.0027783439,
0.0102088377,
-0.0287105367,
0.0149998153,
-0.0002384695,
0.0044720969,
-0.0339477398,
0.0233002529,
-0.0331881717,
-0.0537985265,
0.0068505052,
0.0239540357,
-0.0303643476,
-0.044428654,
0.0382031128,
0.0735975206,
0.0219838861,
-0.0061584637,
-0.017199859,
-0.0066598454,
-0.0483222529,
-0.0212173052,
0.0125867454,
-0.0567790568,
0.0115640629,
-0.0279879402,
-0.0207504183,
-0.090261966,
0.0086712921,
0.015553806,
-0.0775805265,
0.0608597174,
0.0017870424,
-0.0092432285,
0.0192006212,
0.0278291665,
-0.0360090584,
0.0624404028,
0.0347809307,
0.0220264178,
0.0623712949,
-0.0165078081,
-0.017626714,
0.0543539561,
0.0123505602,
0.0391475037,
-0.0814158097,
-0.0049293255,
-0.029592637,
-0.0302617904,
0.0201169215,
0.0380537957,
0.0072029871,
-0.067079179,
0.0740675554,
0.0446223989,
-0.0495537408,
0.0498700216,
0.0275605116,
0.0196231119,
-0.0500248708,
-0.0125318924,
-0.0654681325,
-0.0170291569,
-0.0316759646,
-0.0464551188,
0.0050244271,
0.0707173049,
-0.0211976133,
-0.048562374,
-0.0225026421,
-0.0145742092,
0.0848114565,
-0.0370777175,
0.0198575985,
0.0042409147,
-0.017226778,
-0.0285391808,
0.0674448982,
-0.0359477885,
0.0099928835,
-0.0369876176,
0.0113036679,
0.0834278315,
0.0324853435,
0.0044590929,
0.0312709622,
-0.0530502237,
0.0081526069,
0.0430971719,
-0.0125137093,
0.0065404228,
0.014848493,
-0.0378353335,
0.0056248005,
0.0427555032,
0.0149901789,
0.0105465176,
0.0548363551,
0.0195217207,
0.0068733501,
0.0261543579,
-0.0491221026,
0.0300955512,
-0.0081765521,
-0.0303875785,
0.0137803871,
0.0192458238,
0.0598180331,
-0.0020383284,
-0.0471237451,
-0.0354596861,
-0.0156742353,
-0.0048694862,
-0.0387474038,
0.0052464558,
-0.0163135529,
-0.0118185794,
0.0369843282,
-0.0195933245,
-0.0062330421,
0.0716347545,
-0.0172447916,
0.0325236842,
0.0502138808,
-0.0013422061,
-0.0123799145,
-0.039945811,
-0.0113889668,
-0.0719281808,
0.069892019,
0.0185023602,
0.0217766687,
-0.0223461445,
-0.0049787061,
-0.0008560073,
-0.009209156,
0.0193360597,
0.0298723355,
-0.0641547143,
-0.0033745882,
-0.0331614092,
0.0175090823,
-0.0179658737,
0.0302184466,
-0.0126889702,
-0.0178932548,
-0.0301626492,
-0.0078086322,
-0.0168882962,
-0.0464098416,
0.0273687281,
-0.0067996602,
-0.021938039,
0.0257674474,
-0.0019110329,
-0.0464497879,
0.0329098552,
0.0563265495,
-0.007900794,
-0.0704543814,
-0.0405617133,
-0.0212060381,
-0.0284494422,
-0.0255890731,
0.0287413336,
-0.0246673804,
-0.0644903705,
0.0525184311,
-0.0106874434,
-0.0342781991,
0.0144171566,
-0.0060873381,
-0.110843353,
0.0107129905,
0.0308350492,
0.0116998702,
0.064614743,
0.047991991,
0.0749563277,
0.038021747,
-0.0128994929,
-0.0274932254,
-0.0036049702,
-0.0226670709,
-0.0068445443,
-0.0111477207,
-0.0539302602,
-0.0393741839,
0.0538404845,
0.0415639803,
-0.0192629565,
-0.0604387037,
0.0361706093,
-0.0613825098,
-0.0463668555,
-0.0334647857,
-0.0715641752,
-0.0508051515,
-0.0129523566,
-0.041202832,
-0.0640803576,
0.06308496,
0.0144042196,
0.0176544823,
-0.0064642983,
-0.0078783128,
0.0077052102,
0.0244747009,
-0.0117945857,
0.0566899739,
-0.0142783858,
-0.0100802705,
0.0025707853,
-0.0144636268,
0.0213114843,
-0.0402384885,
-0.0262614042,
0.0129216947,
-0.0075925579,
0.0341912694,
-0.0331768058,
-0.0383764878,
-0.0492547825,
-0.0102745909,
-0.0155957714,
0.0283816289,
-0.0156748518,
0.0104212994,
0.0590165518,
0.0013685398,
-0.0332758799,
-0.0146424016,
0.0243276842,
0.010940277,
-0.0518485829,
0.0102971029,
-0.0308765471,
0.0458648615,
0.015622627,
0.0333321989,
0.0771076456,
-0.0243608113,
-0.0072065028,
0.0039523183,
0.04378815,
0.0108160581,
0.0327306166,
0.0205088686,
0.0065681017,
0.0200331993,
-0.0124405781,
0.0043344293,
0.0720718205,
0.023586968,
0.0016430278,
0.0293089189,
0.0066733202,
0.0228333715,
0.0183623992,
-0.025094267,
-0.0892444104,
0.0007344635,
0.0208662767,
0.0167433321,
-0.0936407223,
-0.0437778942,
0.0189039502,
-0.0854585096,
0.0307272244,
0.0234652609,
-0.0125647318,
-0.0413244441,
-0.0135634057,
0.0298950206,
-0.0024856569,
0.0505386926,
-0.0223125201,
0.0408448614,
-0.046336174,
0.0007319376,
-0.0448904447,
-0.0265512746,
0.0375322513,
-0.0325768739,
0.0305847973,
0.0421759561,
0.0507076159,
-0.0455792099,
-0.0011617619,
0.0402663238,
0.0168085732,
-0.0129875615,
-0.0320671126,
0.046947632,
0.0163838547,
-0.0350255482,
-0.0288019553,
0.0453012958,
-0.0189428143,
-0.0086009512,
-0.0023958159,
0.030950984,
0.0441987664,
-0.0012099154,
-0.0429351069,
0.0334572867,
-0.0018256855,
0.0888327286,
0.0197038669,
-0.0883145481,
0.0269582458,
-0.0519356765,
-0.055802241,
-0.0031695247,
-0.0735848024,
-0.0162993446,
-0.0136084389,
-0.0371780619,
-0.0640867576,
-0.0016537422,
0.0018448791,
0.0077124825,
0.0334688127,
-0.0318313241,
-0.0515112579,
-0.0083571123,
0.0010292425,
-0.0086870827,
0.0023139068,
0.0388088264,
-0.0227455925,
0.0240991451,
-0.0319584161,
-0.0108129624,
-0.0186590999,
0.0290587805,
-0.0621034652,
-0.0676752776,
0.0928233862,
0.04295462,
0.0141528929,
0.0042789243,
-0.0271067582,
-0.0443642996,
0.0417851284,
0.0468778685,
-0.0128638754,
0.0150163518,
0.0681445152,
-0.0242900923,
0.0120926304,
0.0156028848,
-0.0236273184,
0.0339974575,
0.0611070283,
-0.0123104127,
-0.0340764821,
-0.0231810119,
0.0047940565,
0.0094313603,
0.0322946981,
-0.0132479006,
-0.0568711311,
-0.0203971956,
-0.0089734001,
-0.0075847348,
-0.0224136747,
-0.0175695363,
-0.0076118284,
0.0350825638,
0.0097435452,
-0.0554270856,
-0.0077463812,
-0.0240134597,
0.009446336,
-0.0437353477,
0.0242704414,
-0.0024153977,
0.0258777644,
0.0293533076,
0.0481358431,
-0.0284075886,
0.0509362519,
-0.0068115699,
-0.0319513343,
-0.0054936656,
0.0324373916,
0.0018882037,
0.0283032432,
-0.0061087487,
-0.0143330256,
0.0085041327,
-0.0016651682,
-0.0418792777,
-0.0166872367,
-0.0015474398,
-0.0265534744,
0.0233622529,
-0.0250640288,
-0.0217738114,
-0.0456554182,
-0.0137553997,
-0.019458374,
-0.0575346537,
0.0192803629,
0.0117189232,
-0.0302352179,
0.0245895535,
0.0446943417,
-0.0186861157,
0.0585879721,
0.0524973497,
-0.0269431174,
0.0151739512,
0.0129098399,
0.0518803932,
0.0275907572,
-0.0097969007,
0.0231096968,
-0.0406281687,
-0.0789577588,
-0.023457665,
-0.0577436313,
0.0258446764,
-0.0153958127,
-0.0141358469,
0.0527715646,
0.0007588394,
0.0337491594,
-0.0148713943,
-0.0057745851,
-0.0117156114,
-0.0535860397,
0.0092638796,
-5.772320478e-33,
0.0049310816,
-0.0146470154,
-0.0446166173,
-0.0010192129,
0.0241177566,
-0.0440893732,
0.0130548785,
0.0185975339,
-0.0265342835,
-0.0018645646,
0.0067736679,
-0.0029154613,
0.0059085423,
-0.0058393003,
-0.0122478046,
-0.0438861251,
0.0327040739,
-0.0237974711,
-0.0065539735,
-0.0041778581,
0.0586365536,
0.0165702272,
-0.0002602718,
-0.0681609511,
0.043665532,
0.0073653036,
-0.0387266353,
0.0132211056,
-0.0031768829,
0.0780906156,
-0.0010997517,
0.1000994444,
0.0226729382,
0.0132890195,
-0.0135233719,
0.0341172591,
-0.0556349494,
0.0151809417,
0.0243581962,
0.0173099898,
0.0455602705,
-0.0412537791,
0.0430589356,
-0.011715522,
-0.0279636215,
-0.020112427,
0.0115763703,
-0.0536969267,
0.0275000613,
-0.0333048962,
-0.0492691398,
0.0097061265,
-0.0352151059,
-0.0079211975,
-0.0254201628,
0.0290805865,
0.0186957791,
0.0493774414,
-0.0628255606,
0.0177542362,
0.0183846205,
-0.0101592131,
0.0051725395,
0.009982489,
0.050049562,
0.0495485701,
0.0303434636,
0.033382725,
-0.0165129527,
0.017344119,
0.0680951402,
0.0125902686,
0.0472511724,
0.0447425246,
0.0273913052,
-0.1097968519,
-0.0545738004,
-0.0214220807,
0.0537357815,
0.0080930553,
0.0417032689,
0.0154527295,
-0.0628903359,
-0.0402854346,
-0.0229754429,
-0.0466278158,
-0.0364663787,
-0.0590220354,
0.0392941833,
-0.0305941813,
-0.0382212512,
-0.0466122963,
0.0318326876,
-0.0500146672,
0.0044422313,
0.011269249,
-0.0347760618,
-0.0033668708,
0.0247106049,
0.0513359308,
-0.0420647524,
-0.0077093905,
0.0025964463,
-0.0618067831,
0.0241204947,
0.0037051302,
0.064169921,
0.0435995385,
-0.0694113448,
0.0071833241,
-0.0117285317,
0.0262957308,
0.0315637738,
0.0564558357,
-0.0032611175,
0.038731426,
-0.0022418431,
-0.0228056032,
0.0557989739,
0.0128240203,
-0.03667707,
-0.0009961978,
-0.0488812514,
0.0081821084,
-0.0276927501,
-0.0128977643,
0.0013931313,
0.0025680652,
0.0602655075,
-0.0866139308,
-0.0009285759,
-0.0339293033,
2.555e-7,
0.0185436737,
0.0432686172,
0.019479109,
0.0237922631,
0.0354923457,
0.0259091686,
0.01109997,
0.0096894549,
0.0212644171,
0.0246824976,
-0.0124752279,
0.0428235494,
0.0379321091,
0.0426783487,
-0.0016520737,
0.0057704789,
-0.0906366855,
0.0198550578,
-0.0347604752,
0.0009484452,
-0.0137008587,
0.1015658155,
0.0482869968,
-0.0291597303,
-0.0235420763,
-0.0389875211,
0.0197932515,
-0.0648281127,
0.0083443243,
-0.0196828172,
0.0412959605,
0.013454752,
0.0257392582,
-0.016706787,
0.0066637527,
0.0044403719,
0.0225431714,
0.0626115873,
0.0177492797,
0.0144418264,
-0.0130476579,
-0.0408284925,
-0.0101684388,
-0.0625200793,
0.0708711222,
0.0033743512,
-0.0200457089,
-0.0220698118,
-0.0112779392,
-0.022103874,
0.0421236046,
-0.0676788315,
-0.0130809816,
-0.0006981202,
0.039447397,
0.0106253,
0.0178095549,
-0.0533046164,
-0.0381353758,
-0.0335664488,
-0.0450158305,
-0.056271378,
-0.0130170919,
0.0142344376,
0.018977616,
0.0258612894,
0.0294536222,
2.283701522e-34,
0.0189353675,
-0.041954983,
0.0001600557,
-0.0202631745,
0.0553700142,
0.0150279701,
0.0431636944,
0.0160155315,
0.0204562172,
-0.038193129,
-0.0157458391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12221v1 | On-Policy Fine-grained Knowledge Feedback for Hallucination Mitigation | 2024-06-18T02:43:49 | 2024-06-18T02:43:49 | Xueru Wen, Xinyu Lu, Xinyan Guan, Yaojie Lu, Hongyu Lin, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucination occurs when large language models (LLMs) exhibit behavior that
deviates from the boundaries of their knowledge during the response generation
process. Previous learning-based methods focus on detecting knowledge
boundaries and finetuning models with instance-level feedback, but they suffer
from inaccurate signals due to off-policy data sampling and coarse-grained
feedback. In this paper, we introduce \textit{\b{R}einforcement \b{L}earning
\b{f}or \b{H}allucination} (RLFH), a fine-grained feedback-based online
reinforcement learning method for hallucination mitigation. Unlike previous
learning-based methods, RLFH enables LLMs to explore the boundaries of their
internal knowledge and provide on-policy, fine-grained feedback on these
explorations. To construct fine-grained feedback for learning reliable
generation behavior, RLFH decomposes the outcomes of large models into atomic
facts, provides statement-level evaluation signals, and traces back the signals
to the tokens of the original responses. Finally, RLFH adopts the online
reinforcement algorithm with these token-level rewards to adjust model behavior
for hallucination mitigation. For effective on-policy optimization, RLFH also
introduces an LLM-based fact assessment framework to verify the truthfulness
and helpfulness of atomic facts without human intervention. Experiments on
HotpotQA, SQuADv2, and Biography benchmarks demonstrate that RLFH can balance
their usage of internal knowledge during the generation process to eliminate
the hallucination behavior of LLMs. | [
0.0479393341,
0.0332691334,
-0.014932909,
0.0363565199,
-0.0299057253,
0.0209771805,
-0.0357795693,
0.0197995026,
0.0107256174,
-0.0445370227,
0.0065267156,
-0.0260480326,
-0.0015162005,
-0.0009931664,
0.0237283111,
-0.0180731006,
0.0828601271,
-0.0710250884,
0.0570028126,
-0.0353719294,
-0.0015189709,
0.0176483244,
-0.0205543544,
0.0586770102,
-0.0371796787,
-0.0116097918,
0.0025984552,
-0.013113644,
0.0066463351,
-0.0042587286,
0.0273697749,
0.0424101762,
-0.0029799175,
0.0591815971,
0.0000022213,
-0.0647117943,
-0.044492811,
-0.0012718607,
-0.0058642789,
-0.0151844211,
0.0291602947,
-0.0100844931,
-0.0109827193,
0.0257437099,
-0.0194840729,
0.0344561972,
0.0564395934,
0.0843401253,
0.0495774969,
0.0554149412,
0.0217535794,
-0.0297232959,
0.0444006398,
0.0115533043,
0.0539379157,
0.0062798131,
0.0183130689,
0.005834972,
-0.0170121007,
-0.0788960606,
-0.0192796253,
0.0254271701,
-0.0091044279,
-0.0017398568,
-0.0028604886,
0.0204541981,
-0.0892498568,
-0.042923715,
0.0114726862,
0.0568314306,
-0.0156439245,
-0.0400509313,
0.0305909105,
-0.0208691508,
0.0395568423,
0.0100837033,
-0.0159633569,
0.0230561867,
-0.0228797924,
0.0036921077,
0.0236677267,
-0.0272049028,
0.0234796032,
0.0201350227,
-0.0258244351,
0.0852589607,
-0.0070291418,
-0.0484035797,
0.0001029531,
0.0114769498,
-0.0015917551,
-0.0264409408,
0.0069245175,
0.0427234508,
-0.0893090293,
0.0139765944,
-0.0394098684,
0.0074670357,
0.0551259927,
-0.0515317135,
0.0225372054,
-0.0046302476,
-0.0220797379,
0.0276477486,
-0.0196988806,
0.0289538521,
0.0001087514,
0.0787664652,
0.0039854324,
0.0181846172,
-0.0402946733,
-0.0168103594,
-0.0518904142,
0.0705566034,
0.0240986738,
-0.029149387,
-0.0110785523,
0.002739718,
-0.0546985716,
0.0687670857,
-0.051232405,
0.0007442439,
-0.0335312188,
-0.0001766581,
-0.0418895483,
0.0255777501,
-0.0266974419,
-0.0095276712,
0.0361295864,
-0.0655952543,
-0.0220822766,
-0.0079205427,
0.0158875566,
0.0220783986,
0.0076086344,
0.0724091679,
-0.0053752162,
-0.0156066902,
-0.0034260619,
-0.0922375247,
-0.0308419988,
-0.0803002715,
-0.0122090783,
-0.0592462681,
0.0077110734,
-0.0256535467,
-0.0166742112,
-0.0056694355,
0.0220749993,
0.0009183887,
-0.0270830635,
0.0405295044,
-0.0020244382,
-0.0100479405,
0.0294957589,
0.0191822164,
-0.0057534506,
0.0870341733,
0.0169347487,
0.0357319266,
0.0328973681,
0.0087245926,
0.0508813933,
0.0145764221,
0.052716691,
0.0247027073,
-0.039731577,
-0.0205749236,
0.0192881841,
0.034450721,
0.0209179856,
0.0336213484,
-0.0563515387,
0.0439106598,
0.0680772215,
-0.0162932444,
0.0106659317,
0.0067428211,
0.008700788,
0.0456707589,
-0.0040460057,
0.0340170823,
-0.0573685803,
0.0249024294,
-0.0292687751,
0.0313554518,
0.0611551069,
-0.0095273117,
-0.0063086865,
-0.0507499464,
0.0085998243,
0.0066329362,
0.0082616368,
0.0496056899,
0.0312182158,
0.0610391796,
-0.0484377667,
0.0691016242,
0.0424882174,
-0.0293477327,
0.034627378,
-0.090382427,
0.0566031411,
0.0905708,
0.0843600556,
-0.0309290476,
-0.0367203318,
-0.0458777025,
-0.0123728728,
0.0570161454,
0.0262166094,
-0.0316601321,
0.0087935366,
-0.0362253599,
-0.0151264872,
0.003280961,
0.0373722278,
0.0018437572,
0.0067436905,
-0.0151820211,
0.0001582136,
0.0063257408,
-0.0488571823,
0.0375659652,
0.0240610912,
-0.008139899,
-0.0236172602,
-0.0112708379,
0.035630703,
-0.0065962696,
0.0084403362,
0.0119957896,
0.0163816344,
0.0005827157,
-0.0428812206,
-0.0123727843,
-0.0462719575,
-0.044357609,
0.0369844064,
0.0053934734,
0.024454277,
-0.0120710898,
-0.0177946053,
-0.020306332,
-0.0167900547,
-0.0512292013,
0.0589246415,
-0.0446562916,
0.0280263964,
-0.0343196094,
0.0138478298,
-0.0151135838,
0.0633866638,
-0.0140248798,
0.0266958009,
0.0229233149,
-0.0142746223,
-0.0354053639,
-0.0343927927,
-0.0157085638,
0.0092233093,
-0.0282636173,
0.023241112,
0.0300308913,
-0.0014145959,
-0.0541460067,
-0.0120637417,
-0.0415604785,
-0.0163505264,
-0.0191115253,
-0.0059271748,
0.0075273756,
-0.0086163031,
-0.0136791468,
-0.0258270465,
-0.0030481697,
-0.0064534624,
0.007801204,
0.0395255052,
0.019340178,
0.0257857796,
-0.0228449292,
-0.0026671735,
0.0262892824,
-0.0122720366,
-0.0031083417,
-0.0280742012,
0.0046356698,
-0.0956232026,
0.0006031098,
-0.0655291975,
0.0259086173,
0.0062066526,
-0.0361798406,
0.0391678922,
-0.0124781644,
0.0274096169,
0.0770286992,
0.0403712504,
0.0114288935,
0.0725176781,
-0.0034021861,
-0.0753092915,
0.0166818704,
-0.0130176516,
-0.0115967998,
-0.0313092545,
0.0188718401,
0.0031825944,
0.0387564003,
0.0146370949,
0.0179142077,
-0.073770918,
0.0288721677,
-0.0287217461,
-0.0687627494,
-0.0075473334,
-0.0054252394,
-0.0552593209,
0.0028193844,
-0.0125016263,
-0.0460393988,
0.110484466,
-0.0059587164,
-0.0042026076,
-0.0254253335,
0.024929937,
0.0187852755,
0.0349312834,
-0.0082432246,
0.0212829094,
-0.0017842765,
-0.0284091681,
-0.0513165519,
-0.0400233902,
0.0496634059,
-0.0668302476,
-0.0095930416,
-0.0121646402,
-0.0215574224,
0.0028322055,
-0.0147520946,
-0.0645227134,
-0.0341693088,
-0.0101732025,
-0.0371094309,
-0.0597887635,
-0.0123993224,
0.0130925886,
-0.0007546358,
0.0198155157,
0.0241351966,
-0.049333334,
-0.0148333656,
-0.0210377891,
-0.0019414334,
0.0971589163,
0.0144251203,
0.0357380882,
-0.0344991796,
0.0256790556,
0.0578622818,
0.0157044753,
0.0118516972,
0.0367474221,
-0.0279979929,
0.0495925993,
-0.0264440011,
-0.0137496917,
0.0345526114,
0.0632390529,
-0.0869681612,
-0.0434934646,
0.1029031351,
0.0254982784,
-0.0242409259,
0.0119997151,
-0.0356223211,
0.0778626204,
0.002184476,
0.0179642215,
-0.0764541551,
-0.014906751,
0.0070931772,
0.0355511606,
-0.0432798788,
-0.0178618748,
-0.0001554963,
-0.132896021,
0.034322381,
0.0065793702,
-0.0411173888,
-0.0103239259,
-0.0010176976,
0.0036331669,
0.0216476936,
0.0212937482,
-0.0050107678,
0.0025219333,
-0.0265547894,
0.0245954879,
-0.0040266984,
-0.0285518616,
0.0010670397,
-0.0290777497,
0.0781520382,
0.0848686695,
0.0423293822,
0.0082121501,
-0.0644511655,
0.0509347618,
-0.0058891773,
0.0056080343,
0.0002646421,
0.0343193822,
-0.0032941806,
0.0150215663,
0.0060704625,
0.0308937673,
0.0370973647,
-0.0174704213,
-0.0082037076,
0.0675778538,
-0.0296080541,
-0.0371271148,
-0.004392731,
0.0402627364,
0.0445089303,
0.0642755404,
0.0116186207,
-0.0378926657,
-0.0441360809,
-0.0112028634,
0.0178705379,
-0.0557497889,
-0.0314417966,
0.0149601428,
0.0176055171,
-0.0039790277,
-0.0886106044,
-0.0301008336,
-0.0061762896,
0.0462768115,
-0.0175186098,
0.0412008949,
-0.0237003677,
0.0261040702,
-0.0002643454,
-0.0252014045,
-0.0787020847,
0.0074043185,
-0.0082658483,
-0.004021043,
0.0096508665,
-0.0198190957,
-0.0078140404,
0.0289791506,
-0.0452195853,
-0.0808536857,
0.0296577401,
0.0626722649,
0.0222414918,
0.0846269578,
-0.0262912009,
-0.0549515039,
0.105015859,
0.0661592409,
-0.0396816023,
-0.0039899265,
0.0433808677,
-0.0095930491,
-0.0083378246,
0.0367395841,
-0.0498072095,
-0.0123159504,
0.00732429,
0.042804312,
0.0093377521,
0.0020687482,
0.0194364619,
0.0013639095,
0.0058096242,
-0.0480160639,
-0.0392095,
-0.0107552139,
0.0113119781,
0.0066437237,
-0.0237522796,
-0.0169007201,
0.0155641539,
0.0177475922,
-0.0386552215,
0.0106038535,
-0.0231086612,
-0.006617663,
0.0181061849,
-0.0386886373,
-0.0177769456,
0.0029752217,
0.0292208679,
0.0344942957,
-0.0051218499,
-0.0276101008,
0.03682255,
0.0215372071,
0.0456004106,
-0.0116003184,
0.0698604882,
0.0297129285,
-0.019272875,
-0.0154939443,
0.0126890168,
-0.0272136033,
-0.0572555289,
-0.0400584117,
0.029939726,
0.032051567,
0.0382473916,
0.0434506945,
-0.0153433103,
-0.0051879077,
0.018634351,
0.001352135,
-0.0055130525,
-0.0583278872,
-0.0031138198,
0.026827855,
-0.0277515985,
0.0026362056,
0.0692867562,
-0.0031283628,
0.0473980568,
-0.0143570844,
0.0188335944,
-0.0485049076,
-0.0359530821,
-0.0221237596,
0.0105680274,
-0.0332654789,
-0.0152273737,
-0.0385419726,
-0.0650260076,
-0.0523302853,
0.0187564343,
0.0078668362,
-0.0276848115,
0.0232966356,
0.037466459,
-0.016879797,
-0.0420700945,
-0.0719257444,
-0.0104955472,
0.0388155952,
0.0092968941,
-0.0028880648,
-6.927682652e-33,
-0.0273355823,
-0.0297519919,
0.0153275626,
-0.0164160281,
-0.053278774,
-0.028074082,
-0.0055746022,
-0.0055712187,
0.0202701669,
0.0098096645,
-0.0149385575,
0.0262878668,
0.0199099816,
-0.0001197722,
0.0058446992,
-0.0416466855,
0.0641605332,
0.0060949088,
-0.0742933974,
0.0534434542,
0.0397459082,
0.0086341565,
0.0416583121,
-0.032865759,
0.0407291912,
-0.0208806582,
-0.0744390786,
0.0338657796,
-0.0389954224,
0.062957488,
-0.0030156858,
0.0246414263,
0.0002762445,
-0.0699007362,
-0.0244979933,
0.0102290651,
-0.0592055134,
-0.0208851695,
-0.0040586516,
0.0033636221,
-0.0215663351,
-0.0331348628,
0.0539327674,
-0.0054514073,
0.0016752584,
0.0059413104,
0.0082539422,
-0.0246170871,
-0.0316949897,
-0.0182226952,
-0.0849962682,
-0.0050785928,
0.0149667757,
-0.0329728015,
-0.008181029,
0.0309505202,
0.0095326984,
-0.0297805034,
-0.0611871779,
0.0421876088,
0.0245114379,
0.0080679702,
0.0497565679,
0.0285589136,
-0.0121509051,
0.0517302155,
-0.0063647879,
0.051979959,
0.0236967504,
-0.0462482497,
0.058577694,
0.0348941348,
0.0053886557,
0.0441161469,
0.0607412681,
-0.0405183025,
-0.0097314129,
0.0048607658,
-0.0165276844,
0.0444846228,
0.065091446,
0.0074030561,
-0.0452387668,
-0.0275983308,
-0.0219425932,
0.020608047,
-0.0209251698,
-0.027843697,
0.024476666,
0.0636873692,
-0.0580348931,
-0.0219768416,
0.0125458203,
-0.0477525108,
0.0023165951,
0.0321423486,
-0.0402754061,
-0.0074614859,
-0.0193897523,
-0.0160702262,
-0.0439139046,
-0.0367689468,
0.0169330891,
-0.0289804377,
0.0270289369,
0.0215555746,
0.0412976742,
0.0262288414,
-0.0750593767,
0.0287507232,
-0.0131612727,
0.0344616659,
-0.0096419128,
-0.037552312,
0.0450053178,
-0.0226738993,
-0.0084416661,
0.0099377017,
0.0349398628,
-0.0010833953,
-0.0378080197,
0.0574546047,
-0.0160748232,
-0.0008794537,
-0.0269027278,
-0.0110959029,
-0.0303748157,
-0.0135168238,
0.0094795208,
-0.0571818687,
-0.0220541209,
0.0039569354,
3.075e-7,
-0.0413133316,
0.0496216491,
0.0025743709,
0.0130387796,
0.0159232039,
0.0390655398,
0.0199537128,
0.0075597051,
0.0295946691,
-0.0088156601,
0.0180351362,
0.0065471777,
0.0416700505,
0.0319832228,
-0.102754727,
-0.0262004063,
-0.0702683926,
0.0121879978,
-0.0533387735,
-0.0582396798,
0.0089727622,
0.0504486412,
0.0196609125,
-0.0226836726,
0.0155411372,
-0.0203863755,
0.0406520292,
0.0262684617,
-0.0170697197,
0.0258331578,
0.0200002082,
0.0168804117,
0.0161287747,
0.0237770993,
-0.0153812692,
-0.0020518505,
-0.0528204776,
0.0101032797,
0.0046440419,
-0.0359442271,
-0.0355601907,
-0.014660554,
0.0310161207,
-0.0653997734,
0.0550775714,
-0.0361785814,
0.0035392807,
-0.0453080162,
0.0199803822,
-0.0539292842,
0.0085287066,
-0.0226576962,
-0.0337551534,
0.0182395969,
0.0081619043,
0.0437402427,
0.0022983595,
-0.0600990951,
-0.0164082497,
0.0333229303,
-0.0146925682,
-0.0730283409,
-0.0020675918,
-0.0072704395,
-0.0337972678,
-0.1121578813,
0.0177482013,
3.057933759e-34,
0.0165294018,
-0.0255223121,
0.0374394506,
0.0265304428,
0.0309137888,
0.0239886306,
0.0238851327,
0.0144806551,
0.0526109189,
0.0066927164,
-0.0158452429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12216v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12216v1 | Is persona enough for personality? Using ChatGPT to reconstruct an agent's latent personality from simple descriptions | 2024-06-18T02:32:57 | 2024-06-18T02:32:57 | Yongyi Ji, Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Personality, a fundamental aspect of human cognition, contains a range of
traits that influence behaviors, thoughts, and emotions. This paper explores
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in reconstructing these
complex cognitive attributes based only on simple descriptions containing
socio-demographic and personality type information. Utilizing the HEXACO
personality framework, our study examines the consistency of LLMs in recovering
and predicting underlying (latent) personality dimensions from simple
descriptions. Our experiments reveal a significant degree of consistency in
personality reconstruction, although some inconsistencies and biases, such as a
tendency to default to positive traits in the absence of explicit information,
are also observed. Additionally, socio-demographic factors like age and number
of children were found to influence the reconstructed personality dimensions.
These findings have implications for building sophisticated agent-based
simulacra using LLMs and highlight the need for further research on robust
personality generation in LLMs. | [
0.0251548905,
0.0612937473,
-0.0534768552,
-0.0019764283,
-0.0371879525,
0.002719017,
0.0308665689,
-0.0389076471,
0.0161193945,
0.0018433133,
-0.0319037251,
-0.0670193881,
-0.0024235134,
-0.0047641289,
0.0420133434,
-0.0603693426,
0.0245984849,
-0.000314797,
0.02228784,
-0.0435031764,
-0.0137820905,
0.0423588641,
0.0250728745,
0.0490323529,
-0.0104508204,
-0.0278029703,
-0.0025035578,
-0.0223961733,
0.0414392315,
0.0084649436,
0.0242652148,
0.0282495189,
0.0324491151,
0.0106696645,
0.0000020567,
-0.0398854576,
-0.011354737,
-0.004095972,
0.0159033053,
0.010605555,
0.1030631959,
0.0616873056,
-0.0077113151,
0.0420386158,
-0.05155183,
-0.030482458,
0.0216769259,
0.0358945169,
0.0499356873,
0.0490597561,
-0.0127321258,
-0.0284997635,
-0.0170787312,
-0.0081711188,
0.0279526077,
-0.0187451988,
0.0283738319,
-0.0026831708,
-0.0060201171,
0.0229736734,
0.009703327,
-0.0137298806,
-0.0107544493,
0.005226437,
-0.0070289653,
-0.0024994698,
-0.0300397426,
-0.0231625978,
0.0365011655,
0.049298089,
0.0463700853,
-0.015555745,
-0.0241360571,
-0.007192702,
0.0248723924,
-0.0066003967,
0.0072756391,
0.0335173793,
-0.0038261265,
-0.0179860648,
0.0175579805,
-0.0003985821,
0.00675544,
-0.023950614,
-0.0279052872,
0.0263316482,
0.0063582733,
-0.0044240667,
-0.0197908767,
-0.0283775739,
-0.0014216204,
-0.0490115695,
-0.0123398295,
0.0014891459,
-0.0171949547,
0.0058754692,
-0.0269762091,
0.0361277051,
0.0070078201,
-0.0488777235,
0.0017764821,
0.0271497834,
-0.0227995086,
-0.0017631636,
0.0539640822,
0.0590315163,
0.0165134314,
0.0159057621,
-0.035247758,
-0.0256392565,
-0.0769351721,
-0.0176644903,
0.004275382,
0.041766353,
0.0464621708,
0.0028753793,
-0.0708899423,
0.0317880362,
-0.0304906368,
-0.011408994,
-0.0249094348,
0.0002136484,
-0.0109400498,
0.006775328,
-0.0759078562,
0.0248056762,
-0.0350512229,
0.0127460565,
-0.0143675646,
-0.0384544246,
0.0325181819,
-0.0058559766,
0.0122914622,
-0.0140440501,
0.0372278281,
0.0438970216,
0.0039999378,
-0.0592084937,
-0.0285795834,
-0.0322085433,
-0.0307128262,
-0.0982161984,
0.0065079117,
-0.0362230353,
0.0409848727,
-0.0097441804,
-0.0098166931,
-0.0714441612,
0.0088596484,
-0.0052852384,
-0.008220722,
0.0470181368,
0.0100752832,
0.0201529749,
-0.0067370394,
-0.0005537411,
-0.0125993751,
0.0137933688,
0.0110580875,
0.0165255554,
0.0199948847,
-0.0304901693,
0.0392652787,
0.0364066809,
-0.0278070383,
0.0079891244,
0.0030495436,
-0.0214349888,
0.0360390432,
0.0214101821,
0.0570938438,
0.0418650918,
-0.0382024236,
-0.0036977676,
0.1018387526,
0.0631955117,
0.0090546031,
0.0499859378,
0.0241854396,
0.0714879408,
0.0437680259,
-0.0043349224,
-0.0389443673,
0.0177760422,
-0.0228681527,
-0.0117693907,
-0.0389160588,
0.0393349752,
-0.0367724486,
-0.0004279006,
0.0126447417,
-0.0083483579,
0.0313957892,
0.0141682783,
-0.0043561775,
-0.0233881157,
-0.0060063577,
-0.0003108686,
0.0668068603,
-0.0420903452,
-0.0376661457,
-0.0847617015,
0.0158232003,
0.1064572781,
0.0297625791,
0.0044793356,
-0.0135076586,
-0.0046399408,
-0.0277516022,
0.0161712244,
0.0446737632,
-0.0158163998,
0.0137768621,
-0.0343787074,
0.0167569797,
0.0074059479,
0.0062703663,
0.0227257926,
0.0186618492,
-0.010770658,
0.0082596187,
0.0306082647,
0.0080648819,
-0.0045330701,
-0.0855808109,
-0.0279679839,
-0.0025865505,
0.0270325448,
0.0443356782,
0.0116900522,
-0.01137265,
-0.0160304457,
-0.0160700306,
0.0170353949,
-0.0126414476,
0.0572267771,
0.0013812508,
-0.0011755197,
0.0163929276,
0.0059065586,
-0.0156065617,
0.0186570883,
0.0313730873,
0.010058389,
0.0069937585,
-0.0581319332,
0.0297217648,
-0.0195274819,
0.02685038,
-0.0495903194,
0.0698514432,
0.0160630271,
0.0284052324,
0.0050133052,
-0.0263240598,
0.019600369,
0.0070014945,
-0.0264924988,
-0.0580524281,
-0.0139439143,
-0.0638119057,
0.0288250502,
0.0475510396,
0.0163888335,
0.0078990646,
-0.0177159607,
-0.0712501034,
-0.0537857115,
0.0060482328,
0.034092553,
-0.0126803862,
0.0181039944,
0.0031634597,
-0.0294534508,
0.0396503136,
-0.0497952029,
0.0500742272,
0.0045157596,
0.0285885688,
0.0149021074,
-0.0307377726,
-0.0392086953,
-0.0509928241,
0.0080984198,
-0.0369209312,
0.0371948034,
-0.0433024988,
0.0564891174,
0.006504613,
0.0261673424,
-0.0618302897,
0.0192076117,
-0.0297591779,
-0.0788003877,
0.0476838015,
-0.0145236142,
0.0235827919,
0.049224589,
0.0309603307,
0.0372725278,
0.0186437666,
0.0004839096,
-0.0351716429,
-0.0070878584,
-0.0359163322,
-0.0137238204,
-0.0370392203,
-0.0906307548,
-0.0504426397,
0.0406486876,
0.0159251001,
-0.0028792061,
-0.0737822875,
0.0464578532,
0.0356006362,
-0.0483038202,
0.0511472113,
0.0528844558,
-0.0221754648,
0.0177911222,
0.0003453229,
0.0032181144,
0.0614193045,
-0.002316009,
0.0091166934,
0.0221012551,
-0.0196703654,
-0.0182694029,
0.06735643,
0.0171198193,
-0.0070119859,
0.0392849185,
0.0132600619,
-0.0495917574,
-0.0423000604,
0.021518454,
-0.0533958636,
0.0113347946,
-0.0192942787,
-0.0377073847,
0.0479754396,
-0.0303634293,
-0.027718408,
-0.0531366915,
-0.0195626933,
0.0109225065,
0.0422164761,
-0.0249030683,
-0.0641653985,
-0.0278219506,
0.0439189374,
-0.0293626897,
-0.0263000205,
-0.0149293402,
-0.0167933889,
-0.027502887,
0.0516100712,
0.0276912265,
0.0341149047,
-0.0660163537,
0.0114825908,
-0.0009453747,
-0.0707069933,
0.0302035436,
-0.0172952041,
0.0015701918,
0.0018198543,
0.0218060762,
-0.0008248039,
0.015913045,
0.0445835777,
0.0113107385,
-0.0022530782,
0.1114943251,
0.0088875499,
-0.005897182,
0.0161442496,
0.0183841176,
0.0291043445,
0.0308459029,
0.0371490084,
0.000165287,
0.0091562094,
-0.005963007,
0.04015911,
-0.0372972526,
-0.0326118805,
-0.0292145461,
-0.074795343,
0.0462308265,
0.0352716036,
-0.0443122797,
-0.0143697448,
-0.0325149521,
0.0076137148,
-0.0361182541,
0.0289290696,
-0.0120071536,
0.0023592866,
-0.0260645393,
-0.0304324012,
-0.0743616894,
-0.0220887139,
0.1091734394,
-0.0497744344,
0.0780397132,
-0.0039937827,
0.0660397559,
0.0057868715,
-0.0154573079,
-0.0697373003,
0.0483043864,
-0.0020703478,
0.0674446076,
0.052342657,
-0.0171912853,
0.0121207274,
-0.1008997187,
0.0207320005,
0.0054310602,
0.0096801156,
-0.0056870598,
0.0204303693,
0.0000428695,
-0.0514743403,
-0.0184266139,
0.0201368127,
0.0217021331,
0.0444382951,
-0.0309360623,
-0.0903660953,
-0.0099123232,
0.0206828881,
-0.012112651,
0.0071412739,
-0.0857352838,
0.0107794087,
0.0002644462,
-0.0188913364,
-0.0213989392,
-0.0907664672,
0.0013435493,
0.0316678658,
-0.0117245847,
-0.0576338097,
0.0192875471,
0.0068099657,
-0.0063573918,
-0.0079675242,
-0.0497010387,
0.0139516508,
0.0262688063,
-0.032336574,
0.0579057895,
-0.074799858,
0.0133508462,
-0.0023120218,
-0.0674905255,
-0.0453066081,
0.037328966,
0.0229440052,
0.0226116981,
0.0367992595,
0.0125176506,
-0.0515895337,
0.0252380501,
-0.0150250234,
-0.0270041116,
0.0530459024,
-0.0289331116,
0.0563364364,
-0.0055576768,
0.0276920032,
-0.0335598961,
0.0477068871,
-0.008004345,
-0.011236324,
-0.0156686585,
-0.0982937887,
0.0238048062,
0.029818384,
-0.0516915768,
-0.0126178246,
0.0049159946,
-0.0222875625,
-0.0355884098,
-0.0514383353,
0.014097889,
-0.0007721787,
-0.0787232593,
0.0172041226,
0.0071200826,
-0.0013352341,
-0.0555792786,
-0.0322205611,
0.0522229224,
-0.0139580015,
-0.0357715338,
-0.0068856799,
0.0179597177,
0.0002064486,
0.0096325995,
-0.0065574343,
-0.0018013353,
-0.0395598151,
0.0348109938,
-0.0029911448,
0.0509997979,
-0.0231113676,
-0.0022902361,
-0.0414720923,
0.018910611,
-0.0399293043,
-0.0252727438,
-0.017031759,
0.048791457,
0.0015890602,
0.0328221396,
0.0262990277,
-0.040477816,
0.0045504859,
-0.0355588757,
0.0420462079,
0.0010387751,
-0.0309601054,
-0.0028626251,
0.0099633327,
-0.0131689487,
-0.0183496531,
0.0221520159,
0.0410453677,
0.0157645401,
-0.0326429605,
-0.0387438275,
-0.0452043526,
0.000901914,
0.0032371739,
0.0257804394,
-0.0216187872,
-0.0211799257,
-0.1034793481,
-0.0780561268,
0.0447822846,
0.0189857744,
-0.0133167123,
-0.024107581,
0.0060444516,
0.0417924896,
-0.0153319286,
-0.0456021167,
-0.0449568331,
0.0032850597,
-0.0489601381,
0.0340864286,
-0.0023744109,
-6.119868607e-33,
-0.0332112946,
0.0074503943,
0.0396345407,
0.006706771,
-0.0393342301,
-0.0357184485,
-0.0201532245,
0.0209031664,
-0.0018914383,
0.0106519246,
-0.0223492552,
0.0026622049,
0.0014130932,
-0.0139625426,
-0.0084531885,
0.0422584563,
0.058535371,
-0.0132357841,
-0.0109994849,
-0.0043245391,
0.001487671,
-0.011050459,
0.0392238684,
-0.081482023,
-0.0047796122,
-0.036461968,
-0.017433716,
-0.0036402948,
0.0245993547,
0.038651485,
-0.0203804951,
0.0564804226,
0.0258505791,
0.0019809885,
-0.0038576198,
0.0325880423,
-0.0434155166,
-0.0315500312,
0.0116647603,
-0.0002138911,
0.0020435958,
-0.0603931509,
-0.0185145345,
-0.0157737471,
-0.0186676085,
-0.0276792757,
0.0466052145,
-0.0053120158,
0.0483233295,
0.0264430847,
-0.0623514876,
-0.0129175708,
-0.0179085471,
0.0003706554,
-0.0180977974,
-0.0043088468,
-0.0242906157,
-0.0021527868,
-0.0645492747,
0.0555043034,
-0.0221553091,
-0.0352577381,
-0.0125544248,
0.0373504832,
0.0349256173,
0.0520056859,
0.0894312933,
0.0757135749,
-0.0376107655,
-0.0366792232,
0.0558171012,
0.0391425304,
-0.006046616,
0.1078503355,
-0.0420790054,
-0.0586145818,
-0.0068181581,
-0.0033620084,
0.1208749339,
-0.0574081093,
0.0741285384,
0.0163423959,
-0.0483392328,
-0.0194959547,
-0.0316701867,
0.0213483255,
-0.0177205615,
-0.0538060665,
0.0051436624,
-0.0254460834,
-0.0104907481,
-0.0514887795,
0.0379205234,
-0.0562798157,
-0.0051039928,
-0.006172935,
-0.0772547573,
0.0049273428,
-0.0199445747,
0.0042599919,
-0.0411898755,
-0.0491968319,
0.0225725211,
0.0207938999,
0.0523956567,
0.0361875072,
-0.0176915713,
0.060213495,
-0.0393157899,
-0.0173507947,
0.0111464364,
0.0128891952,
0.0185603164,
-0.0157900248,
0.0213745311,
0.009440369,
0.0046194708,
-0.0347788259,
0.0180565882,
0.019570753,
-0.0038804905,
0.0357132293,
0.0237117019,
0.0020747813,
-0.013145674,
0.0300435629,
-0.070947051,
0.0018246142,
0.038727995,
-0.0324040949,
0.0002984994,
-0.0078886095,
2.786e-7,
-0.0499738492,
0.061030075,
-0.0300796032,
0.037605647,
0.0512959361,
0.0560409948,
0.0268609244,
0.0091683809,
0.0416967571,
-0.0425174534,
0.0252605621,
0.0500717312,
0.0494632348,
0.0370031707,
-0.0474444814,
0.0193931479,
0.0227492023,
-0.0075522042,
-0.013697709,
-0.0009516129,
0.0923049003,
0.0850398839,
0.0582160763,
-0.0142516447,
0.0144001544,
0.0195326265,
0.0581567287,
0.0167717189,
-0.0500700362,
0.043311283,
-0.0588835813,
0.0027997834,
0.0109905824,
0.0515410751,
0.0332787819,
0.0203655921,
-0.0258702524,
0.0675257891,
-0.0549670197,
-0.0130271027,
0.0092444373,
-0.016440006,
-0.0317219831,
-0.0145182721,
0.0461684316,
-0.0439622253,
-0.0652613938,
-0.0420581363,
-0.0370747186,
-0.0100865932,
0.0085297916,
-0.0026956829,
-0.0039554411,
0.028852297,
0.0038735271,
-0.00930034,
0.0141909365,
-0.0675930381,
0.0366297066,
0.0102004018,
-0.0545774363,
-0.0764901489,
0.0135547454,
0.0308901817,
0.060655389,
-0.0518746264,
0.0627015829,
2.177575045e-34,
-0.0015903502,
0.059681166,
-0.0014884304,
-0.0328388102,
0.0475627966,
0.0026841797,
0.0515684187,
0.0232070461,
0.0361929275,
-0.0500523821,
-0.0012399122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12213v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12213v3 | LLM-Oracle Machines | 2024-06-18T02:25:33 | 2024-07-03T12:59:21 | Jie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.FL, F.1.1; F.4.1; I.2.0 | Contemporary AI applications leverage large language models (LLMs) to harness
their knowledge and reasoning abilities for natural language processing tasks.
This approach shares similarities with the concept of oracle Turing machines
(OTMs). To capture the broader potential of these computations, including those
not yet realized, we propose an extension to OTMs: the LLM-oracle machine
(LLM-OM), by employing a cluster of LLMs as the oracle. Each LLM acts as a
black box, capable of answering queries within its expertise, albeit with a
delay. We introduce four variants of the LLM-OM: basic, augmented,
fault-avoidance, and $\epsilon$-fault. The first two are commonly observed in
existing AI applications. The latter two are specifically designed to address
the challenges of LLM hallucinations, biases, and inconsistencies, aiming to
ensure reliable outcomes. | [
0.0614300258,
0.0067866761,
-0.0426973924,
0.0166694093,
-0.0847539082,
0.0077836695,
-0.0321783163,
0.0093875686,
0.103308484,
-0.0307821147,
0.0057802047,
-0.0056819734,
-0.0213718805,
0.0339279361,
-0.0060758204,
-0.0076204333,
0.0562976152,
-0.0173111595,
0.0210605506,
-0.0203796327,
-0.0170489158,
-0.0046835993,
-0.007262174,
0.0223717541,
0.0214616265,
0.0038234941,
-0.0055871103,
-0.0155211175,
-0.0212629922,
0.0299203265,
-0.0333034135,
0.0042857495,
-0.0112656578,
0.0569044389,
0.0000022849,
-0.0423280112,
-0.0127890715,
0.0377804413,
-0.0252776816,
0.0041578892,
-0.0098863076,
0.0017137768,
-0.0023861141,
0.0388224088,
-0.06118441,
-0.023124963,
0.0459299088,
0.0234663989,
0.1001790017,
0.0946859792,
-0.0025077339,
0.0130711151,
0.0615110397,
-0.0115942229,
0.0353686288,
-0.059286952,
0.0420978889,
-0.0055727758,
0.0593998395,
-0.0170436036,
0.0120852394,
0.0430992506,
0.0233438239,
0.0229429193,
-0.0008298958,
0.0048533119,
-0.0320359953,
-0.0163921211,
-0.0267607979,
0.0156874917,
-0.0201843884,
-0.0020892622,
0.0187509749,
0.0294819083,
0.0006462762,
0.004084107,
-0.0097442511,
0.0615952834,
-0.0140287448,
0.0147502497,
0.0571568795,
0.0119384332,
0.0277929418,
0.0241028313,
-0.0648903027,
0.0945749506,
0.0063238479,
-0.0623495951,
-0.0128877163,
0.0115098218,
0.0156456158,
-0.057023149,
0.0173668191,
0.072766453,
-0.0616510734,
0.028372772,
-0.0518371984,
0.0026421382,
0.0359221138,
-0.071872063,
0.0410269313,
0.0251712631,
-0.0352731422,
0.0814754069,
-0.0226600803,
0.0406735167,
-0.0405924395,
0.047762271,
-0.0057568992,
-0.0386536941,
-0.0339768343,
-0.0329615176,
0.0041268864,
0.0649982691,
-0.0268264413,
-0.0189610049,
0.0087277656,
0.0445587225,
-0.0305751115,
0.0418687873,
-0.0210169889,
-0.000235472,
0.0201439448,
-0.0524234138,
-0.1065889373,
-0.0170418266,
-0.0095575014,
0.0097200256,
-0.0500632226,
-0.0978420749,
-0.0150489472,
0.0138328066,
-0.0262039211,
-0.0099331448,
0.0370882154,
0.1070595533,
0.0148553215,
-0.0205668937,
-0.0792023018,
-0.040603932,
0.0165012851,
-0.0659909323,
-0.0427744053,
-0.0425476618,
0.0503915697,
0.0104986914,
-0.0166172478,
-0.0230108183,
0.0288780946,
0.0386806168,
-0.0443200655,
0.0709226578,
-0.0226770379,
0.0310917534,
0.0099763796,
0.0002923931,
-0.0164358839,
0.0319513418,
0.0345764309,
0.0182901509,
0.0331117623,
0.0074931914,
0.0414791666,
0.043551635,
-0.0173788629,
-0.014172785,
-0.0608625486,
0.0271346252,
0.0021542271,
0.034724053,
-0.0522863418,
0.085529536,
0.0200094786,
-0.0145001533,
0.055460766,
0.0412366986,
-0.0425880067,
0.0383816473,
0.0399917737,
-0.029721804,
-0.0010445984,
-0.003651236,
-0.0433142893,
-0.0008624465,
-0.0662411377,
-0.0065814862,
0.050401438,
0.0255058315,
-0.0009755665,
-0.0662080869,
-0.0024624038,
0.0267844945,
-0.0254996438,
0.0217551608,
0.0448262654,
-0.0147369048,
-0.0432171449,
-0.0164157655,
0.005715216,
-0.0166337769,
-0.0007193019,
-0.0721932575,
0.0080520473,
0.1058968157,
0.0840755552,
-0.058837831,
-0.0093360674,
0.0090190545,
-0.0383976921,
0.0255486704,
0.0399481468,
0.0182091706,
-0.0535400808,
-0.0439918377,
0.015282114,
0.0411878489,
0.0286281519,
0.0163466707,
0.0078444649,
-0.0009564839,
-0.0287567656,
-0.0155842705,
-0.0594959669,
0.0344033204,
-0.0125526078,
0.0002640072,
-0.0040617827,
0.0107899299,
0.0524031296,
0.0000809581,
-0.0190781951,
0.0397585258,
0.048703488,
-0.0350608267,
-0.0733481348,
-0.0175508186,
-0.0121473586,
0.0191923976,
0.0446091481,
-0.0243641455,
0.0042703114,
0.0007228034,
-0.0158237144,
-0.0627122,
-0.0067267264,
-0.0438531376,
0.0397076346,
-0.0232153274,
0.0438982211,
0.006984001,
0.0039159795,
-0.0217622276,
0.0945753232,
-0.0312693901,
-0.0028667012,
0.0172368735,
-0.005651047,
-0.0219823997,
-0.0211000275,
-0.0324889906,
-0.0133965276,
0.0161591265,
0.0278594699,
-0.0040197568,
-0.0586408377,
-0.0329834186,
-0.0323403589,
-0.0514993556,
0.045799911,
-0.0124221202,
-0.0038423745,
-0.0006164202,
0.0021844062,
-0.0106754461,
-0.0251462869,
-0.0356482305,
0.0218940526,
0.0451209247,
0.008624766,
0.0219049957,
0.0249653924,
-0.0322008431,
-0.0148062706,
-0.0059647299,
-0.0386500172,
0.0204166677,
-0.0000471954,
-0.0343086757,
-0.0759046599,
0.0334852673,
-0.0031601037,
0.0425115079,
-0.007453688,
0.0064345328,
-0.0083858594,
-0.0665161982,
-0.0042766416,
0.059348423,
0.0113689369,
0.0051479493,
0.0569276437,
-0.005179937,
-0.0443384089,
0.0227639563,
-0.0109824911,
-0.0108913612,
-0.0232558791,
-0.0342892148,
0.0049623293,
0.0270496644,
0.0035295188,
-0.0147318486,
-0.0693369657,
0.0086441636,
0.0301355906,
-0.0276238732,
-0.008670669,
-0.0428070538,
-0.0044529531,
0.0482023023,
-0.0358455181,
-0.0589338839,
0.0675653815,
-0.0055000773,
0.0368626714,
-0.0236490276,
-0.0353201367,
-0.0461670235,
0.0723441094,
0.0133137638,
0.0081198057,
0.0123772062,
-0.0163922124,
-0.0029230043,
0.0080106528,
-0.0490086265,
-0.0440304466,
0.0509620532,
-0.0512261055,
0.0024575465,
0.0301100966,
-0.0301784426,
-0.030807158,
-0.0142790806,
-0.0550371893,
-0.0127443774,
-0.0164012611,
0.0005717482,
-0.0868081078,
-0.0080063175,
-0.0097445585,
0.0220397264,
-0.0085091358,
-0.0005872219,
-0.0427301042,
-0.0394238979,
0.0174620301,
0.0101019479,
0.020354243,
0.0105629675,
0.014473604,
0.0438792035,
0.0467856564,
-0.0187340789,
-0.0080101145,
-0.030409554,
0.0358400233,
-0.0439995416,
-0.0385098904,
0.0131671987,
-0.0549359955,
-0.0650321618,
-0.0361613184,
0.1031724438,
0.0533761643,
-0.0276602525,
-0.021039512,
-0.021449564,
-0.0155143179,
0.0191030912,
0.033235237,
-0.0956470072,
-0.0226294007,
0.0163126234,
0.0191928968,
-0.0301608872,
-0.048235599,
-0.0116010848,
-0.1447953582,
0.0161119215,
0.0138849048,
-0.0107921464,
-0.042143207,
-0.0227822866,
-0.0234173238,
-0.0389647149,
-0.0160977989,
0.0352036282,
0.0340285115,
-0.0165185444,
-0.0087098395,
-0.0082373172,
0.0068495967,
0.0652713254,
-0.0161360446,
0.0400518999,
0.0618730001,
0.0089835469,
0.0070217345,
-0.0431719124,
-0.0105662728,
0.0058724321,
0.0284897517,
-0.0142877763,
0.0160487536,
-0.0125886714,
-0.025639981,
0.0102963252,
0.0277854316,
-0.0246993899,
0.0386584103,
0.0182279088,
0.0989405811,
-0.051831495,
-0.011826898,
-0.0160412658,
-0.0168984663,
-0.0281599592,
0.0807072148,
-0.0305312779,
-0.0303899534,
-0.0710832179,
-0.0036583857,
-0.0119315097,
-0.042358283,
-0.0415184461,
0.0050888248,
0.0165381767,
-0.0209324863,
-0.0452713668,
-0.0260973331,
0.0100098997,
0.0187157616,
0.0345789678,
-0.0006790345,
0.0339221209,
-0.000706832,
-0.0100195985,
-0.014874585,
-0.068893075,
0.0263182279,
-0.0499217398,
0.0215581134,
0.0409299284,
-0.0152232004,
-0.0252597891,
-0.0037371668,
-0.0421460159,
-0.0720226243,
0.0519632325,
0.0654369891,
0.0290571544,
-0.0017018769,
-0.0418227091,
-0.0632904097,
0.0286799371,
0.0517885201,
-0.0768726245,
0.0116234059,
-0.0091316123,
-0.0101345507,
0.0114791356,
0.0330712982,
-0.0305439383,
0.0051019019,
-0.0283620059,
0.0328330249,
-0.0581493117,
-0.005272815,
0.0395063534,
0.0147101497,
0.0291395318,
0.0244999509,
0.0091866339,
-0.0101512838,
0.0246161688,
-0.0151697649,
-0.0459334515,
-0.0164048597,
0.0040644165,
0.0337523445,
-0.0097809676,
0.0107978545,
-0.0631144419,
-0.0327386558,
-0.0171902422,
0.0013179798,
-0.0165388938,
0.0569429733,
0.0039514904,
0.0348311998,
-0.0181614049,
0.0041544284,
0.0584997721,
0.0104690725,
0.047884535,
-0.0242030919,
0.0215719156,
0.0231396034,
0.0155516258,
-0.0411387607,
0.0058391639,
-0.0776179582,
-0.0884344429,
0.0515966378,
0.063316077,
0.0725652426,
0.0226881895,
-0.0144691933,
-0.0344289318,
-0.0035467062,
-0.010908966,
-0.0290934704,
0.0618768334,
-0.0231223069,
0.0196997728,
0.0340260155,
-0.0263902321,
0.0239054598,
0.0627543554,
-0.0509935282,
0.0741211474,
0.0180975609,
-0.0427724905,
-0.0391641036,
-0.0549433008,
-0.0247728489,
0.0118912635,
-0.0062864195,
-0.0172634721,
-0.0631991252,
-0.0431977697,
0.0393329039,
0.0209161304,
0.0258405488,
-0.0302166902,
-0.0135521051,
0.0663715452,
0.0483295247,
0.0258965883,
-0.0480848625,
0.0152649051,
-0.0043139784,
-0.0158687867,
-0.0052488446,
-6.901134846e-33,
-0.0119910808,
-0.0364952385,
0.0156425294,
-0.0429610051,
0.0134708798,
-0.0041911704,
-0.0147462934,
0.0138681997,
-0.0151831638,
-0.0216986425,
-0.0227378905,
0.0428140052,
0.0230911616,
0.0114385672,
0.0277337711,
-0.0054623093,
0.0154074142,
0.0125101032,
0.0248335861,
-0.0262825806,
0.065614529,
-0.0001572582,
-0.0263318568,
-0.0468981564,
0.04786136,
-0.0204923954,
-0.0227445848,
0.0359801762,
-0.0366611108,
0.055694852,
-0.0224378947,
0.052487433,
0.0170057677,
-0.0294321906,
0.0128077744,
0.0265078116,
-0.0363243595,
0.0093803778,
0.0416453592,
0.0237054937,
-0.0106143514,
-0.0336695015,
0.0519823171,
-0.0025799712,
-0.0025469845,
0.0274624173,
0.0140457563,
-0.056148883,
-0.0143772941,
0.0249883328,
-0.0177101959,
0.0217931271,
-0.0029040652,
-0.0027947037,
0.0202476513,
-0.0080463961,
0.0215959158,
-0.0222609174,
-0.05866649,
0.0337700881,
0.026543159,
-0.0018095527,
0.0165472552,
-0.0209693629,
0.0018112679,
0.039011579,
0.0446790792,
0.0065791849,
-0.0273661148,
0.0115463203,
-0.0135547062,
0.0595723279,
0.0571137816,
-0.00130483,
0.0094015012,
-0.0048762988,
-0.0496182777,
0.0118048228,
0.0389335342,
0.0270611346,
0.0622013845,
0.0088557005,
-0.0663688928,
-0.009047851,
-0.0416397527,
0.0048870426,
-0.0628960282,
-0.0030539865,
0.0247525815,
0.0317314416,
0.0172153637,
-0.006242069,
-0.0039408356,
-0.0434694476,
0.0570943505,
-0.0014335462,
-0.0027339987,
-0.0079422724,
-0.0021692363,
0.0398028344,
-0.0304417107,
-0.0097072143,
-0.0060768872,
-0.0159534812,
-0.0108153019,
0.0149149094,
-0.0004751569,
-0.0005810955,
-0.0666316599,
-0.0069232471,
-0.0138180163,
0.0280306097,
0.0066580796,
-0.0323973447,
0.0638962314,
0.0159421377,
-0.0006446157,
0.0386775322,
0.0069409246,
0.0162054822,
-0.0102927182,
0.0116698109,
-0.0278726164,
-0.0199666824,
-0.0060225283,
0.0150443865,
-0.033547312,
-0.0084929131,
-0.0240210835,
-0.0196335446,
0.0097121699,
0.015852822,
3.056e-7,
0.0239237491,
0.0493567474,
0.0180862341,
0.0541279279,
0.0320620388,
0.0296397172,
0.0153146861,
-0.0000986251,
-0.0124002555,
-0.0018121034,
0.0124974018,
0.0351634175,
0.0130696185,
0.0125105614,
-0.0619703531,
-0.0078817867,
-0.0389844105,
0.00563415,
-0.0758965984,
0.0043607107,
0.0505522937,
0.0738210827,
0.0258695427,
-0.0126487929,
-0.0217146203,
-0.0853959322,
0.038936127,
-0.0038018606,
-0.0106549561,
0.0374381579,
0.0334770381,
0.0828088,
-0.0352763869,
0.0402322076,
0.0280364342,
0.0209149104,
-0.0010155484,
0.0521706343,
0.0138876559,
-0.0293277316,
-0.0055399514,
-0.0305418856,
0.0000306591,
-0.0444807932,
0.0975926891,
-0.0035350339,
-0.0570330769,
-0.0205371007,
0.0119460598,
-0.0263888538,
0.0051480019,
0.011243172,
-0.0161781795,
-0.0119893448,
-0.0048755817,
0.0143278744,
-0.0111166844,
-0.0895388573,
-0.0046993177,
0.018799454,
-0.0400997289,
-0.0071495231,
-0.0264921971,
0.0371260531,
-0.010873721,
-0.0759982094,
0.0156072909,
3.074834475e-34,
0.0305889659,
-0.0121302726,
0.0049873781,
0.0506430902,
0.0479064099,
0.0161416382,
-0.0243238322,
0.0081651416,
0.0296793189,
-0.0957630351,
-0.0245020185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12209v1 | Interface Design for Self-Supervised Speech Models | 2024-06-18T02:13:48 | 2024-06-18T02:13:48 | Yi-Jen Shih, David Harwath | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Self-supervised speech (SSL) models have recently become widely adopted for
many downstream speech processing tasks. The general usage pattern is to employ
SSL models as feature extractors, and then train a downstream prediction head
to solve a specific task. However, different layers of SSL models have been
shown to capture different types of information, and the methods of combining
them are not well studied. To this end, we extend the general framework for SSL
model utilization by proposing the interface that connects the upstream and
downstream. Under this view, the dominant technique of combining features via a
layerwise weighted sum can be regarded as a specific interface. We propose
several alternative interface designs and demonstrate that the weighted sum
interface is suboptimal for many tasks. In particular, we show that a
convolutional interface whose depth scales logarithmically with the depth of
the upstream model consistently outperforms many other interface designs. | [
-0.0224735327,
0.0555654988,
0.0253710393,
0.0151193338,
-0.0343632624,
-0.0171024669,
0.094600752,
-0.0601953194,
0.0553920269,
-0.007739773,
-0.0704918876,
-0.0027752686,
0.0240351669,
0.0529785268,
0.0036425611,
-0.0438040905,
-0.0030726499,
-0.0541246384,
-0.0306689721,
-0.0319112353,
0.0005143381,
0.0221997034,
-0.0295251999,
0.0140965711,
-0.015627306,
0.0151766594,
-0.0419887267,
-0.0002931557,
-0.0191131122,
0.0141560333,
-0.0112997675,
0.0714519173,
0.0241793226,
0.0492090806,
0.0000020391,
-0.0163940694,
-0.0004317276,
0.016559558,
-0.0704866871,
0.0041625071,
-0.0106288139,
-0.0153019726,
-0.0304902624,
0.0067872666,
-0.0222513527,
-0.0430247597,
0.0275142007,
0.0842266455,
0.0380422734,
-0.0041596899,
-0.0164734591,
-0.0828198344,
0.0333996937,
-0.0153291496,
-0.0424326397,
0.0150778098,
-0.0039935703,
-0.0210546218,
-0.0298986472,
-0.0417655557,
-0.0017117917,
0.0777535364,
0.0359486453,
-0.0329893045,
0.0745272338,
0.0171281155,
-0.0246847346,
-0.0351018123,
-0.0387131311,
0.0302096736,
-0.0362981856,
0.0146179264,
0.0203993265,
-0.0333185531,
-0.0000560302,
-0.0235326588,
-0.0311708394,
-0.0314016305,
0.0334264822,
-0.0097900592,
-0.0285382401,
0.0648360997,
0.0240672361,
0.0095094144,
-0.0325487852,
0.0127370898,
-0.009410602,
0.0068376269,
0.0189887211,
-0.013303265,
0.0356108658,
-0.0267287549,
0.000213627,
0.0035180498,
0.0330137052,
-0.0338072181,
-0.0082748197,
-0.0456972942,
-0.0286145769,
-0.0570504293,
0.0206695441,
0.0350656994,
-0.0447740555,
0.0293356478,
-0.0152561385,
0.0339450315,
-0.0048423754,
-0.0012877171,
-0.0024874087,
0.0308625475,
0.0078410329,
0.0048138117,
-0.0603659712,
0.0856421366,
-0.0015946687,
-0.0085913278,
-0.0348236635,
0.023604339,
-0.0621851571,
-0.0363077335,
0.0408862121,
0.0364310928,
-0.0233935919,
-0.0387146287,
0.0131957857,
0.040286988,
0.0351001285,
0.0377724506,
0.0141946124,
-0.0332705043,
0.0039885794,
-0.0085953455,
0.0186158344,
-0.0096157622,
0.0147298602,
0.0847377554,
0.0076092426,
-0.0085557876,
-0.0202652514,
-0.018003298,
-0.022351237,
-0.0311931036,
-0.0004028056,
-0.0629515499,
0.0140568884,
-0.0475537367,
0.008129756,
-0.0360236391,
-0.0161775276,
-0.0470141992,
0.021275349,
0.0707430318,
0.0129020289,
0.0098387757,
0.0515345484,
-0.0150899161,
-0.0196501389,
0.0607049391,
0.0376109332,
0.0173548162,
-0.028504299,
-0.0448794253,
-0.0209279805,
0.0103245182,
0.0301215556,
-0.0080770832,
-0.0599836707,
-0.0268067233,
-0.0416521952,
0.0042753285,
0.0383539125,
0.0215148069,
-0.0127080586,
-0.020281421,
0.0592500567,
0.0985547826,
0.0478234775,
0.0256182384,
-0.0013169061,
0.0314597487,
0.0250372663,
0.0357966274,
-0.0245659109,
0.0487534963,
-0.0260891598,
-0.0053258031,
0.0724193454,
0.0619573407,
-0.0689416453,
-0.0834409818,
0.0240871292,
-0.0260559563,
0.005772274,
0.0535353869,
0.0315773338,
-0.0002246292,
-0.0045412499,
-0.0108844927,
0.0005941526,
-0.0805892274,
0.0162141081,
-0.0541742668,
-0.0134175159,
0.0546661429,
-0.013297651,
0.014408851,
-0.0019319936,
-0.0077289874,
-0.01575692,
0.0286298189,
0.0220727921,
0.0068920581,
0.0834305435,
-0.0225904584,
-0.0726333037,
0.016706882,
-0.0039368044,
0.0426937155,
-0.0692770556,
-0.0453705266,
0.0236156043,
0.0035979282,
0.0155815827,
-0.0077623785,
-0.0203297623,
-0.0588317625,
0.0388282575,
0.0382766798,
0.035193868,
0.017834479,
-0.0271409228,
0.0226451028,
0.0210729241,
-0.0216714144,
-0.064302668,
0.0312859602,
-0.0691915154,
-0.0015594383,
0.020304814,
-0.0041230563,
0.0482203178,
0.0476255752,
0.0132980095,
-0.0916423872,
0.0715576187,
-0.0076356316,
0.0577215105,
-0.0492726937,
0.016689606,
0.0329905525,
0.0100639854,
-0.0092474772,
0.0126398504,
0.0193940084,
-0.0506904274,
-0.024211552,
0.0048657074,
0.0055411756,
-0.0591102056,
-0.028072942,
0.0131559651,
-0.0315493867,
0.046158623,
0.0295788329,
-0.0303556249,
0.002477905,
-0.0378487222,
-0.084017843,
-0.021944629,
-0.0417229012,
0.0078163678,
-0.0185472406,
0.0492515042,
-0.0147590693,
-0.042077709,
-0.0114915334,
-0.0509967171,
-0.0168885812,
0.0056052455,
-0.0536901578,
0.0383159406,
0.0257475972,
-0.0207648799,
-0.0416420735,
0.0145141892,
0.0005967614,
-0.0114227356,
-0.0669840127,
0.0166686848,
-0.0297538061,
-0.0130821243,
0.0496597253,
0.0192149747,
-0.0202389657,
-0.0280813463,
-0.025442807,
-0.0004281161,
0.0285530649,
0.0241828579,
-0.0318691581,
0.0662726387,
-0.0267362334,
-0.0290543139,
0.0427226163,
-0.0210115183,
0.0400485583,
0.0109579014,
0.1002955064,
-0.0504448153,
0.0517752767,
0.0152504267,
-0.0162962601,
-0.0448399074,
-0.0160567835,
0.0198966097,
-0.0529114343,
-0.0198091045,
-0.0246734414,
0.0018055845,
0.0402880795,
0.0157190189,
-0.0531204715,
0.0074329576,
-0.0582301617,
-0.0145237008,
-0.0010033058,
-0.079861559,
-0.0342167765,
0.0597145669,
-0.0427978523,
-0.0001245423,
0.0152044268,
-0.0061998633,
-0.0457249731,
0.0152383046,
0.0535761192,
-0.0366596021,
0.0380436666,
-0.0318603031,
0.0323732644,
0.0034142844,
-0.0514591485,
-0.0356883444,
-0.0329515152,
-0.0375606827,
-0.0048040925,
-0.0441795848,
-0.0099447388,
0.0146328826,
0.0390067361,
-0.0111111486,
0.0461277291,
-0.004105181,
0.0009929893,
-0.0017417365,
0.0135319075,
0.0440769754,
0.0697004348,
-0.0138640096,
0.0592233725,
0.0870467052,
-0.0090931058,
0.0806898847,
0.0221143849,
-0.070412077,
0.0135380914,
0.0304450728,
-0.0340736695,
-0.0070599667,
0.0324276499,
0.0089724576,
-0.0836553052,
0.0602273382,
0.1075560078,
-0.0274335463,
-0.0413322747,
-0.023711089,
0.0177764297,
0.0294105243,
-0.0063027879,
-0.0063949544,
0.0267942492,
-0.0056803236,
0.014037434,
-0.0003221313,
0.0006267802,
0.0209873859,
0.0097056041,
-0.0596140474,
0.0527408235,
0.0268726833,
-0.0351750627,
-0.002251917,
-0.0494237356,
0.0145140048,
-0.0600108318,
0.0291492827,
-0.0114709791,
-0.0368023328,
-0.0392797515,
0.0430061966,
-0.0504332706,
0.013149525,
0.0210209712,
0.0043885056,
0.0124718016,
0.0694107637,
-0.003450613,
-0.0135617545,
0.0029670733,
0.0486909226,
-0.0246289968,
-0.0232643522,
-0.0082742022,
0.0600359775,
0.0182381645,
-0.0148117309,
-0.0067400238,
0.0379174873,
-0.0001628356,
0.0261508338,
-0.0441628546,
0.0393116586,
-0.0229586903,
0.0072988402,
-0.0305084288,
0.0481176786,
-0.0007379914,
0.0439335927,
0.0024089837,
-0.019828761,
-0.0328473486,
0.0357924104,
-0.0168290157,
0.0128948754,
-0.0613107421,
0.0264168326,
0.0356667303,
-0.096191518,
0.007020304,
-0.0308890231,
-0.0236761235,
0.027657371,
-0.0073092552,
0.0462943874,
0.0100113042,
0.021648379,
-0.0198134799,
0.0213484615,
0.0256117955,
0.0181119833,
-0.0227664486,
0.0143040083,
0.0346698426,
-0.0491708033,
0.0000746837,
0.0166263543,
-0.053097982,
-0.0793192089,
0.0081826644,
-0.0069626281,
0.0093497569,
0.0359765291,
-0.0358308218,
-0.0231010038,
0.1075095385,
0.0238589402,
-0.0537791252,
0.0163056795,
0.0715852827,
-0.0258438848,
-0.0170458481,
0.0396130085,
-0.0576727577,
0.0520605817,
-0.0537583642,
-0.0239730719,
-0.0488612093,
-0.0386165641,
0.0116013475,
-0.0006203909,
0.0839314088,
0.0214034002,
0.0707276314,
-0.0286142752,
0.0651841834,
-0.0027551393,
0.0128867636,
-0.0476865768,
-0.0004688823,
0.0009201653,
0.0013292213,
0.0273619983,
0.0359234661,
0.0283356532,
-0.0153222503,
-0.0244539641,
0.0228345264,
-0.0483467244,
-0.026142681,
-0.0427771881,
0.0240675304,
0.0242342688,
0.0296487175,
0.0608052984,
0.0017866816,
0.0269794706,
-0.0440149866,
-0.0142508419,
0.0127872732,
0.0006026104,
0.0337625407,
-0.1085534021,
-0.0621864684,
-0.0383047499,
-0.008592655,
0.0172265191,
-0.0516021885,
0.0441240706,
0.0145625258,
0.0125106992,
-0.0524483174,
0.0204272103,
-0.0135802869,
0.0191662032,
0.0143475253,
0.006023596,
-0.0199362598,
-0.0468148589,
-0.0105514107,
0.0017111566,
0.0339921936,
0.0396040119,
0.0606618114,
-0.0113350488,
-0.0502805673,
-0.0104885427,
0.0178784281,
-0.0338295475,
-0.0099817691,
-0.0265031327,
-0.0439170524,
0.0148065053,
-0.0206143539,
0.0147882039,
-0.0140205026,
0.0508062467,
-0.0077078319,
-0.0408257954,
0.0295247603,
0.035954725,
-0.0672078803,
-0.0380263664,
-0.0073459158,
0.0209541079,
-6.468074646e-33,
-0.0399140492,
0.0248561762,
0.0262347646,
0.0301452391,
0.0155966366,
0.0382789746,
0.0057749259,
0.0561393574,
-0.0062020547,
0.0081440136,
-0.0179632083,
0.0136088058,
0.0342176855,
0.0033690042,
0.013522232,
0.0193222649,
0.0978531763,
-0.0250234846,
0.0427131504,
-0.005009701,
0.0111816041,
0.020933805,
0.0162823759,
-0.0744889304,
-0.0602954291,
0.0259110518,
0.0005007799,
-0.014470174,
-0.0007980068,
0.0564022996,
-0.0057352311,
0.0335312933,
-0.0244494006,
0.011654322,
-0.0627751797,
0.0303142741,
-0.0618665703,
-0.0305627193,
-0.0285368059,
0.0317083597,
-0.044876188,
-0.0217447057,
0.0372889116,
0.0262547955,
-0.0425738506,
-0.0882675871,
0.0481919609,
0.0192798767,
-0.0217724424,
-0.0285052117,
0.0155129172,
0.0390757173,
-0.0151469447,
-0.0377656184,
0.1152303964,
0.0172948837,
0.003230015,
-0.0331464596,
-0.0093998164,
0.0178310201,
-0.0004457366,
0.0426608622,
0.0503132306,
0.0213148929,
0.0098638032,
0.0314490199,
0.0589458384,
-0.0346313529,
-0.0103956908,
-0.0166411139,
0.0380659699,
0.0307970233,
0.0346611626,
-0.0325714163,
0.0499794967,
-0.0038370718,
-0.0449814424,
0.0273495074,
0.0231715143,
0.0217406619,
-0.0363198854,
0.0578003153,
-0.0280936137,
0.0156704057,
-0.0879954398,
-0.0425790213,
-0.0176353287,
-0.0327040106,
0.0099395253,
0.0281979274,
0.04954331,
0.0040189596,
0.0203260146,
-0.025414519,
0.0242637601,
0.0042762207,
-0.0081946664,
-0.0096015874,
0.0255405121,
0.0256974939,
-0.0285597853,
-0.0014868181,
0.0102220941,
0.0440628566,
-0.0136845801,
-0.0216863714,
-0.0319788307,
0.0599523224,
-0.0457370654,
-0.0399808176,
-0.0361562036,
0.0122296037,
0.0024834573,
0.0235463046,
0.0349274613,
-0.0200873092,
-0.0061629331,
0.0050234767,
-0.0802446678,
0.0156823918,
-0.0335000083,
0.011602506,
0.0012188389,
0.0044156327,
0.0098914839,
-0.0131361187,
-0.0300862268,
-0.04431412,
0.0731640682,
-0.0137111843,
-0.0165936537,
0.013937681,
2.823e-7,
-0.0489260219,
-0.0142696947,
0.0421833396,
-0.0247542635,
0.0014589389,
0.0245139375,
-0.0123786861,
0.015201916,
-0.0191900022,
-0.000799634,
-0.0129453028,
0.0507707968,
0.0608438328,
0.0289454963,
-0.0428334549,
-0.0132415546,
-0.0374089852,
0.0080478117,
-0.0069887005,
-0.0326645896,
0.0048792269,
0.0536747836,
-0.0071270433,
-0.0317755044,
0.0246047061,
0.0254845098,
0.0338493735,
0.0295154545,
0.001126391,
-0.0023880175,
0.0235179607,
0.0319947638,
-0.0164207779,
0.0363223962,
-0.0198884979,
0.0355904996,
-0.0025182397,
0.0356515311,
-0.0268660802,
-0.0867165029,
0.0002445894,
0.06263832,
0.0002750846,
0.0327908546,
0.0420156047,
-0.0201936793,
-0.0170175489,
-0.0564545617,
-0.0242820419,
0.0112431953,
0.0344348364,
0.0321978778,
0.0119877951,
0.0210389495,
0.0140087921,
-0.040059939,
-0.0168111939,
-0.0656663626,
-0.0022250526,
0.0406442247,
-0.0257129073,
0.007533452,
-0.0680700913,
0.0277677104,
0.0463130139,
-0.010483304,
-0.0228855666,
1.815789338e-34,
0.0005968763,
-0.0291946009,
0.0172307063,
-0.0041740662,
-0.06056666,
-0.0320243724,
0.0187686384,
0.015445739,
0.0327803679,
-0.0423424058,
-0.0367709436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12208v1 | Knowledge Fusion By Evolving Weights of Language Models | 2024-06-18T02:12:34 | 2024-06-18T02:12:34 | Guodong Du, Jing Li, Hanting Liu, Runhua Jiang, Shuyang Yu, Yifei Guo, Sim Kuan Goh, Ho-Kin Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.NE | Fine-tuning pre-trained language models, particularly large language models,
demands extensive computing resources and can result in varying performance
outcomes across different domains and datasets. This paper examines the
approach of integrating multiple models from diverse training scenarios into a
unified model. This unified model excels across various data domains and
exhibits the ability to generalize well on out-of-domain data. We propose a
knowledge fusion method named Evolver, inspired by evolutionary algorithms,
which does not need further training or additional training data. Specifically,
our method involves aggregating the weights of different language models into a
population and subsequently generating offspring models through mutation and
crossover operations. These offspring models are then evaluated against their
parents, allowing for the preservation of those models that show enhanced
performance on development datasets. Importantly, our model evolving strategy
can be seamlessly integrated with existing model merging frameworks, offering a
versatile tool for model enhancement. Experimental results on mainstream
language models (i.e., encoder-only, decoder-only, encoder-decoder) reveal that
Evolver outperforms previous state-of-the-art models by large margins. The code
is publicly available at {https://github.com/duguodong7/model-evolution}. | [
0.0054372232,
0.1047800928,
-0.004204141,
0.0270162839,
-0.0151211061,
0.0364098363,
-0.0334281474,
-0.0262910258,
-0.0388739705,
-0.0282434206,
-0.0148867369,
-0.0010215314,
0.0199741479,
0.056637127,
0.0139731849,
-0.0179904941,
0.0413572863,
-0.0220562033,
-0.0467995331,
-0.0208031032,
-0.0158127584,
0.0278691258,
0.0331133194,
0.0470218323,
0.029634539,
0.0355774388,
-0.0107804285,
0.0046859346,
0.0416993387,
0.0498032756,
0.0170206912,
0.0335869119,
0.041531764,
0.1100217253,
0.0000018596,
-0.0542176738,
-0.0270655639,
-0.0092909932,
-0.015672341,
-0.0171664003,
0.0456742011,
-0.0184661746,
-0.0300272163,
0.0299245212,
-0.041753266,
-0.0350230075,
0.0586067066,
-0.0087236334,
0.0620006025,
0.0398301408,
-0.0018286831,
-0.0543641411,
0.0669679269,
-0.0407369137,
-0.0368029326,
-0.0170781203,
0.0360842422,
0.0202424228,
-0.0083637573,
-0.0425236411,
0.0049058013,
0.0383545123,
0.0105489707,
-0.0158043075,
-0.0054280618,
0.0266159941,
-0.014244983,
-0.0364719778,
-0.0370911323,
0.0331249684,
-0.0926880389,
-0.0434176996,
-0.0064069857,
0.0124721108,
0.0035706917,
-0.0135772061,
-0.0074280784,
-0.019278653,
0.0032145891,
0.0443375334,
0.0245853756,
-0.0333958641,
0.0271520503,
0.0068758484,
-0.0622396022,
0.0348824747,
0.0630498454,
-0.0179858543,
-0.0087103238,
-0.010721188,
-0.0097354911,
-0.0636218786,
0.0016428909,
0.0236891638,
0.0350524895,
0.0112595223,
-0.0990427658,
-0.0458552986,
-0.0129246376,
-0.0251032393,
0.0480858125,
0.0511575192,
0.0046556974,
0.0555512756,
-0.0415935032,
0.008387696,
-0.017324524,
-0.0102958651,
-0.0720395595,
-0.0197009202,
-0.0761922449,
-0.0015644761,
0.002080258,
0.0176442936,
-0.035648372,
-0.0288704056,
-0.0203420296,
0.0402478278,
0.0343380608,
-0.0189169571,
0.0349804945,
-0.0131704193,
0.0076268744,
-0.0059943167,
0.0043635326,
0.0476330481,
0.0172204114,
0.0096213268,
-0.0007984593,
-0.0441976488,
0.009681657,
-0.0107493028,
0.0013486047,
0.0054337974,
-0.0004500271,
0.0419552177,
-0.0362863205,
-0.007705308,
-0.0229094531,
0.013949913,
-0.0184746515,
-0.0256184954,
-0.0147493677,
-0.0371239856,
0.0737813115,
-0.0127339372,
-0.0244257078,
-0.0693249628,
-0.0056919362,
-0.0432227924,
-0.0289765727,
0.0722362772,
-0.0863229558,
0.0345137902,
0.0555909947,
0.00023267,
0.0059006643,
0.0908657759,
-0.0068369908,
-0.0363832973,
-0.018163655,
-0.0063632489,
-0.012923494,
0.0510625429,
-0.0068223663,
0.0574193075,
0.0109220091,
-0.0088741425,
0.0349616334,
-0.0222866926,
0.0127306469,
0.024281906,
-0.0384509154,
0.0137869501,
0.0431478955,
0.0072689005,
0.0504527204,
0.0352405868,
0.0271556955,
-0.0155652799,
-0.0105201975,
-0.0247332789,
0.0103535242,
-0.0212083496,
-0.0569827296,
0.0149363447,
0.0276266932,
0.0877096578,
-0.0222884975,
-0.0548781492,
-0.0211287439,
-0.0310832523,
0.0124210622,
0.0158913564,
0.0671731159,
0.0296110082,
-0.0568428114,
0.0302871801,
0.0459402278,
-0.0554533191,
0.0174406804,
-0.0580234304,
0.0060956795,
0.0574084185,
0.030724898,
0.0013915809,
-0.0464186147,
0.0248588603,
-0.0378257744,
-0.0006368065,
0.0385264494,
-0.0217597242,
0.0108328443,
-0.0579848997,
-0.0888316929,
0.0066473186,
0.0138657382,
0.0545408502,
-0.0015415505,
0.0085512772,
0.0358889848,
-0.0043011843,
-0.0186552852,
0.0317811966,
-0.0447433181,
0.0333189592,
-0.0069537037,
-0.0260593705,
0.029996464,
-0.0119515201,
-0.0337609574,
0.0083701061,
0.0213121139,
-0.0131986281,
-0.0515553206,
0.0494486094,
-0.0112516582,
-0.0375912823,
0.0605461933,
0.0130664958,
0.0076002893,
-0.0326699875,
-0.0367002115,
-0.0414659418,
0.0135930777,
-0.0160991438,
0.1176260039,
-0.0483288392,
0.0810218453,
-0.0437419377,
-0.0146413213,
-0.0102208452,
0.0793659613,
-0.0165690053,
-0.0376954228,
-0.0216627084,
-0.0117105367,
0.0247216765,
0.0179370958,
-0.0084983017,
-0.0044967057,
-0.0206410773,
0.0339019857,
0.0162686426,
0.0150918728,
-0.0092974091,
-0.0391645357,
-0.0772617236,
0.0072297296,
-0.0131949428,
0.0423931926,
0.0363019668,
0.0255520158,
-0.0156171424,
0.0120965317,
-0.0009278369,
0.0053253649,
-0.0074767116,
-0.0026252603,
-0.0265262909,
0.0194784049,
-0.0053613922,
-0.0370529443,
-0.0351434238,
-0.0133545855,
0.0607674122,
-0.0152220419,
0.0065113273,
-0.0736098662,
0.0071071759,
-0.0526307151,
0.0718831643,
-0.0060514165,
-0.0133457705,
-0.0142320525,
-0.0258798283,
0.0417737551,
0.0405180007,
0.0092165675,
-0.003597419,
0.0678827763,
-0.0186362937,
-0.0226742402,
0.0047752447,
-0.0091119073,
-0.0260278471,
-0.0337652527,
0.0328368321,
-0.0079381578,
0.0591037571,
-0.0219809469,
-0.0498715453,
-0.0557734109,
-0.0052428399,
0.0068046218,
-0.0410680473,
-0.0118914479,
-0.0449330695,
0.0019218195,
0.053851787,
-0.0500395782,
-0.0211681575,
0.0900308639,
-0.0259331893,
-0.010368689,
-0.0676314533,
-0.0232126005,
-0.0465995409,
0.0047120829,
0.0011228824,
0.0231019724,
0.0028516357,
-0.0057651517,
-0.0365718529,
0.0180350263,
0.0188292414,
-0.0274866465,
0.0501439795,
-0.0589678027,
0.029870661,
0.0039257547,
-0.0349001363,
-0.0331338048,
0.0111596221,
-0.0306614768,
-0.0010418773,
-0.0066410848,
-0.0283914581,
-0.0610440336,
0.0213766824,
-0.0189580191,
0.0681521446,
0.0177505985,
-0.0097055929,
-0.0288156867,
0.0094172386,
0.033366289,
0.0109240003,
-0.0148741398,
-0.0182090718,
0.0374420285,
0.0188594442,
0.0310196634,
0.0099474965,
-0.0481124483,
0.0280334987,
0.0699481443,
-0.0082102409,
-0.0091576055,
-0.0029002926,
-0.0058848364,
-0.0320984833,
0.027613923,
0.0913583487,
0.0313386209,
0.0016630334,
-0.0354944542,
-0.0293819364,
0.0563035943,
0.0313418135,
0.0296322294,
-0.0530004278,
-0.0444969051,
0.0097532105,
-0.0140261678,
0.0328030363,
0.0013096203,
-0.0056301206,
-0.1499935687,
-0.0097277863,
0.0388502553,
-0.0036044992,
-0.0003114621,
-0.0078677153,
0.0016728857,
-0.0073918081,
-0.0033478274,
0.0104091829,
0.0210467447,
-0.022896165,
-0.0038368853,
0.0237328839,
-0.0800858587,
0.0019597858,
-0.046017427,
0.0107848439,
0.1222468913,
0.0185413174,
0.0103835622,
-0.0510646738,
0.0692609921,
-0.021002125,
-0.0329529606,
-0.0007934452,
0.0040295292,
-0.0076356735,
0.000285703,
0.0335696638,
0.0378060043,
-0.0317352042,
0.0083128056,
0.0015173564,
0.034545701,
0.0111211445,
-0.0325679816,
-0.0128015466,
-0.0544557273,
-0.0056241085,
0.0415790044,
-0.0059374208,
-0.0495854691,
0.0107864896,
-0.0127160037,
-0.0248162132,
-0.003531025,
-0.0139848245,
0.0418860577,
0.0140889576,
-0.0830496773,
-0.0608547777,
0.0323908255,
0.0252058115,
0.0185524933,
0.0506436341,
-0.0017898245,
0.0108568678,
-0.018796619,
-0.05577223,
0.0020937806,
-0.0096270451,
-0.0236422885,
-0.0466175005,
0.0044683544,
0.0566813461,
-0.0168775637,
-0.0236010235,
0.012226562,
-0.0797682777,
-0.091396369,
-0.0174729247,
0.0442354158,
0.0219280086,
0.0378315337,
-0.0570202321,
-0.0507455766,
0.0724881291,
0.0197671447,
-0.0014709202,
-0.0151430704,
0.0151556553,
-0.0674507096,
-0.008671998,
-0.0093089752,
-0.0613923669,
-0.0034217332,
0.0047986545,
-0.0279792733,
-0.0589492097,
-0.0420910791,
0.0122265788,
-0.0132770073,
0.0160544831,
-0.0582376383,
-0.034063112,
-0.0298093837,
0.0121057946,
0.0061725439,
-0.0107719786,
-0.0437892079,
-0.0175662059,
0.0363678336,
0.0160685219,
0.0497888178,
0.0654862672,
0.0487853773,
-0.00918868,
-0.0172386784,
0.0051431186,
0.04002662,
0.0473265983,
0.0496726483,
-0.0067110299,
0.0262768567,
0.0329203047,
0.0096180113,
0.0013451414,
-0.0545848869,
-0.0008376591,
0.0096907448,
0.0122077297,
0.0227377824,
0.0602374524,
-0.0436786488,
-0.0442529842,
-0.0564563051,
0.0148944948,
0.074363336,
0.015038603,
0.0700431019,
-0.0002498312,
-0.0209112726,
-0.0358105749,
-0.0119309239,
-0.0176870544,
-0.032792531,
0.0295043513,
-0.0003569324,
-0.0206399895,
0.0200840663,
0.0626228005,
-0.0185593776,
0.0630673692,
-0.0232295003,
0.0104734534,
-0.0174091458,
0.0061926586,
-0.0023406385,
-0.0104507199,
-0.0231187623,
0.0302262325,
-0.0071572936,
-0.0674042255,
-0.0025392086,
0.0379673764,
-0.0019345314,
0.067335397,
0.0449162312,
0.0245091151,
-0.046862416,
-0.0070002973,
-0.0044282079,
-0.0444954,
-0.0055881622,
-0.0142668756,
0.0313656665,
-6.040720736e-33,
-0.003417942,
0.0337397903,
-0.0003589266,
-0.0405582301,
-0.0104230503,
-0.0216619838,
-0.0037566442,
-0.0150342463,
-0.034310434,
-0.0580810905,
0.00909728,
0.0178632699,
-0.0049798735,
0.0048425295,
0.0077665513,
0.0072653969,
0.036406897,
0.017312279,
0.0115289008,
-0.0123975435,
-0.0036024244,
0.0223872419,
0.0355814174,
-0.0427342616,
-0.0289706308,
0.0368013121,
-0.0266205873,
0.0403213613,
-0.0171828978,
0.0584777817,
-0.0065179812,
0.0358372256,
-0.0133761475,
-0.0321557932,
-0.0489306599,
-0.0316135623,
-0.0476286449,
0.0029193978,
-0.0073860004,
0.0107737482,
-0.0176813044,
-0.0365728475,
0.0642468333,
0.0426021852,
0.0251237433,
-0.0178671498,
0.0474789105,
-0.0311860461,
0.0213584248,
-0.0337462984,
-0.05555306,
0.02437713,
-0.0163941123,
-0.035214752,
0.043282073,
-0.025748888,
0.0434944294,
-0.0199308526,
-0.033032123,
0.0512068048,
0.0502966046,
0.050007496,
0.1069306135,
0.0337888412,
0.0122074597,
0.0099101719,
-0.027446324,
-0.0274240486,
0.0104995519,
-0.0199825671,
0.0601554699,
0.0714206025,
0.0351395607,
0.0184316989,
0.0022843319,
-0.0255382415,
-0.0324883573,
0.0544184037,
0.0191299301,
-0.0133803235,
-0.0172530077,
0.0774875283,
0.0184486602,
-0.0184445195,
-0.059522137,
-0.0340901017,
-0.0360735059,
-0.0025461155,
0.0141031016,
0.0233626757,
-0.0153622925,
-0.0107363351,
0.0143476157,
-0.0645265803,
0.0026775836,
0.0175794121,
-0.0394120105,
0.0158106126,
-0.0109901335,
0.0608860217,
0.0172708835,
-0.0510583073,
0.0300762933,
0.0025549016,
-0.002559199,
-0.0178898051,
0.0036542704,
0.0253774598,
-0.0649884865,
0.0357132442,
-0.0053545386,
0.0100518567,
0.0404334031,
0.0340832435,
0.0388896763,
0.0256627519,
0.0072704162,
-0.0246257689,
0.0436035208,
0.026234692,
-0.0781499669,
0.0367350541,
0.021035213,
0.0157185551,
0.0021472371,
0.0021397881,
-0.0158933774,
-0.0030968217,
0.033530429,
0.0094537269,
-0.0501889996,
0.0415622555,
2.545e-7,
0.0632637665,
0.0119998241,
0.0174718648,
-0.0284653325,
0.0220744107,
0.0376161076,
-0.0387580618,
0.0072933575,
0.0492581055,
-0.0302081835,
-0.0085141798,
0.0213888623,
0.0458962619,
0.0080732126,
-0.0780911297,
-0.0214058962,
-0.0388651788,
0.0251057204,
-0.0553397834,
-0.00161992,
0.0308424458,
0.1083322465,
0.0220451914,
-0.0211803392,
0.0023794952,
-0.0055395942,
0.0614966825,
0.0081500895,
0.0176324416,
0.0412483625,
-0.061938893,
0.0466057472,
-0.0391959101,
0.0074882261,
-0.0457861237,
0.0356792137,
0.0093826903,
0.0224388428,
-0.0291984268,
0.002837992,
0.0185849145,
0.060679514,
-0.0275211409,
-0.031430874,
0.0962994322,
-0.0295272395,
0.001396687,
-0.0339568928,
-0.026679812,
-0.0109159769,
-0.0086856857,
-0.0211001597,
-0.0073649827,
0.0444555245,
0.0163859297,
0.0092679076,
-0.0320702493,
-0.0962523669,
-0.002557196,
0.035956189,
-0.0619571283,
-0.0406543426,
-0.0003943398,
0.004783364,
0.0426118672,
-0.055698324,
0.0298336167,
2.457837235e-34,
-0.0071258908,
0.0139409704,
0.0494270064,
0.0126645276,
0.0308258422,
-0.032308802,
-0.0287950002,
0.0011436351,
-0.0009306626,
-0.0560469814,
-0.0240785033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12197v1 | Debate as Optimization: Adaptive Conformal Prediction and Diverse Retrieval for Event Extraction | 2024-06-18T01:53:49 | 2024-06-18T01:53:49 | Sijia Wang, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a multi-agent debate as optimization (DAO) system for event
extraction, where the primary objective is to iteratively refine the large
language models (LLMs) outputs through debating without parameter tuning. In
DAO, we introduce two novel modules: the Diverse-RAG (DRAG) module and the
Adaptive Conformal Prediction (AdaCP) module. DRAG systematically retrieves
supporting information that best fits the debate discussion, while AdaCP
enhances the accuracy and reliability of event extraction by effectively
rejecting less promising answers. Experimental results demonstrate a
significant reduction in the performance gap between supervised approaches and
tuning-free LLM-based methods by 18.1% and 17.8% on ACE05 and 17.9% and 15.2%
on CASIE for event detection and argument extraction respectively. | [
0.0500332713,
0.050489679,
0.0079337871,
0.0719095096,
-0.0203839168,
-0.0022868544,
-0.0025850416,
-0.0044477391,
0.0259798542,
-0.0675712079,
0.004366708,
-0.0562104993,
-0.0242522005,
0.0367782824,
-0.0361704044,
-0.039652817,
0.0396699868,
-0.0130935116,
0.0947896913,
-0.0013552145,
0.0219458081,
-0.0178439822,
-0.0109474603,
0.0204804726,
-0.0045009051,
0.0004637616,
-0.0105614159,
-0.0376403928,
0.037616536,
-0.0026563685,
0.0538124666,
0.0278265644,
0.0281416569,
0.0472022854,
0.0000018161,
-0.0377379097,
-0.0306684002,
-0.0161043406,
-0.0352749117,
0.0203821789,
0.0656474307,
0.0673536286,
0.0120081706,
0.0072572432,
-0.0492638983,
-0.0229675416,
0.0154880201,
0.0733300522,
0.0428828262,
0.1053069532,
-0.0076740091,
-0.0465003401,
0.0094723217,
-0.0082369391,
-0.0490088873,
-0.0406968966,
0.0442147404,
-0.0298693199,
-0.0019083378,
0.0217078049,
0.0272280592,
0.0324023701,
-0.01504202,
-0.0077427407,
-0.0422500633,
0.0101522747,
-0.0634941012,
-0.0206009541,
-0.0169993192,
0.031762328,
0.0269378312,
-0.0092523368,
0.0268024933,
-0.0106995897,
0.0112272697,
0.0286867376,
-0.0648335442,
0.0261367336,
-0.0313090384,
0.0372417681,
0.0707753971,
0.011296574,
-0.0080655506,
0.0231970232,
-0.0181633737,
0.0416292883,
-0.0073805982,
-0.000917284,
-0.0250583496,
-0.009777627,
-0.0499618687,
-0.0508421808,
0.0403622799,
0.0284767654,
-0.0373166576,
0.0363139957,
-0.0070283683,
-0.0048413649,
-0.0030184558,
-0.1097663939,
0.0233723149,
-0.0147726489,
0.0380370542,
0.0709332228,
0.0197588801,
0.0141715789,
-0.0226672422,
-0.0063822414,
-0.0133317811,
-0.0239675473,
-0.0232852064,
0.0018124344,
-0.0277076531,
0.0484157875,
-0.0869549587,
-0.0328824744,
0.0358117893,
0.0259938762,
0.0034524261,
-0.0048047001,
0.0173435751,
0.0150538012,
-0.0390989035,
-0.0391872078,
-0.0270877443,
0.0386941992,
-0.0211695526,
0.0017109548,
0.0286399405,
-0.0522081293,
-0.0293781571,
0.0269452091,
0.0225177612,
-0.0192131996,
-0.0098847859,
0.0429382026,
-0.0442357659,
-0.0219760574,
0.0087584127,
-0.0164423957,
-0.034382917,
-0.0382061452,
-0.0024553146,
-0.0638816208,
0.0411163606,
-0.0315665044,
-0.0303966086,
-0.070111759,
0.0328919031,
-0.0007218957,
-0.0360413305,
0.0087420847,
0.005291733,
-0.0152268922,
0.0640017092,
0.0018716222,
-0.0223646425,
0.0682795718,
0.0526723377,
0.0349771306,
0.0745882094,
0.0383236259,
-0.0076625422,
0.0236392263,
0.0292549767,
-0.0220921319,
0.0467859246,
0.0221888479,
-0.0043973289,
0.0008655509,
-0.0015452856,
0.0464425534,
-0.0376959108,
-0.0663168728,
0.0650561079,
0.0255232826,
-0.0085546253,
-0.0132133123,
-0.0272966642,
0.0299417768,
0.0312661938,
0.0431239791,
0.0038120104,
-0.0090448409,
-0.0082861595,
-0.0027721338,
0.0214908458,
0.0109129762,
-0.0083427001,
-0.0521496721,
-0.0126803359,
-0.0142638469,
0.0084584774,
0.0349182524,
0.0336958803,
-0.0176839679,
-0.0612031482,
0.0382729396,
0.0497538447,
-0.0294565428,
-0.030959459,
-0.0355123915,
0.0601841323,
-0.0229563117,
0.0272473004,
-0.0483759753,
-0.0559121221,
0.0014519528,
0.0621304289,
0.05157144,
0.0638208017,
-0.0348240659,
0.0364247821,
-0.0404372551,
-0.0137638738,
-0.0090646194,
0.0111216474,
0.0242232364,
0.0533534735,
-0.0437279902,
-0.018579863,
0.0808620974,
-0.0607353561,
0.0207994208,
-0.0199380703,
-0.0347015187,
-0.0223263688,
-0.0232418925,
0.0518262684,
0.0138657745,
-0.0215366147,
0.0062597035,
0.0427631289,
-0.0595855378,
-0.0450031199,
0.0208679605,
-0.0246862806,
-0.0440764204,
0.0321109369,
-0.0018977167,
-0.026883753,
-0.0158549864,
-0.0213292465,
-0.0164933894,
0.028569812,
-0.0203279909,
-0.0116471034,
-0.0275395103,
0.0014318327,
0.0138488738,
-0.0079241181,
-0.0664523467,
0.0756796151,
0.0434408151,
-0.0267995875,
0.0037600698,
0.0178784132,
0.0062617371,
-0.0575987771,
-0.0305151567,
0.0714868084,
0.0170218684,
0.0053333258,
0.0668812916,
-0.0405947343,
-0.0108067514,
-0.0522707999,
-0.0828723684,
0.0481141098,
-0.0197257549,
0.034999337,
0.0101514179,
-0.0295822844,
-0.0045369775,
0.0090133706,
-0.0208728649,
-0.0606654696,
-0.0019361415,
0.0064102695,
0.0216738917,
0.0709823668,
0.0058967923,
-0.0678634793,
0.0148980943,
-0.0231250841,
0.0490091033,
0.0221100654,
0.0094397515,
-0.0407433882,
0.0092283003,
-0.0135691147,
0.0607207827,
-0.0304834824,
-0.0079626851,
0.0162767954,
-0.006772697,
0.0335895978,
0.0904582515,
0.0454991497,
0.0397375152,
-0.0213345923,
-0.0388134122,
-0.0639821887,
0.0282194186,
-0.0640740395,
0.0319564641,
-0.047378853,
0.0034632804,
0.0646524578,
0.0715124235,
0.0023657675,
0.0246595982,
-0.0556115136,
0.023664441,
0.015752919,
-0.0035670865,
0.0087216292,
-0.0294251163,
-0.0639923215,
0.0238396265,
-0.039034728,
0.0082723554,
0.0890992284,
-0.017193757,
-0.0117827216,
-0.0609444492,
-0.0151046673,
-0.0541874766,
0.0479129143,
-0.0304328147,
-0.0037035891,
-0.0072423583,
-0.0091848848,
-0.0345983617,
-0.0451484285,
0.0487126969,
-0.0528142899,
0.0851586312,
-0.0574369654,
0.0034214803,
-0.0203070026,
-0.0275196489,
-0.0413658805,
-0.0471715741,
-0.0045176516,
-0.0083673447,
0.0356116556,
0.0049950532,
-0.052894976,
0.0215943307,
-0.0089357095,
0.0140717784,
-0.0297235679,
0.0330457389,
-0.0099744163,
0.0429757945,
0.0579159074,
0.0251630936,
-0.0056844358,
-0.0286458135,
0.0255744383,
0.0985704511,
-0.0164776985,
-0.0339116491,
-0.0183616132,
-0.0480565839,
0.0054842038,
-0.0396316908,
0.0045893989,
-0.025413435,
0.0734452829,
-0.0625084564,
0.016890483,
0.099418968,
0.0241913665,
-0.0018665508,
-0.0366854593,
-0.0046978607,
0.0340440385,
0.0009876696,
0.0161651261,
-0.0489535108,
-0.0173006915,
-0.0262513869,
0.0111362534,
-0.016838206,
-0.0325173251,
-0.0045924378,
-0.0503221825,
0.0122496579,
0.0228876155,
-0.0042701908,
-0.0245384425,
-0.0291982889,
0.0194449015,
-0.0578888208,
-0.0035295694,
0.0267539285,
-0.0011914071,
0.0084750438,
0.0125322621,
-0.0372549184,
-0.0164839104,
0.0061092754,
-0.0254760403,
0.0420678854,
-0.0033698629,
0.0466720425,
0.0292791054,
0.0177039523,
0.0246601831,
-0.035403505,
-0.0314817689,
-0.0223702472,
0.0285108592,
-0.0239323713,
-0.0008723554,
-0.0165385064,
0.0211629365,
0.0271073468,
-0.0491381362,
0.0206885599,
0.0438046567,
-0.0296747331,
-0.0281885099,
0.0066614072,
0.0082121091,
0.0129631069,
0.0782651827,
0.0340999514,
0.0020563898,
-0.0379309207,
-0.0352335796,
-0.013160334,
-0.0541774146,
-0.0111905094,
-0.0312009659,
0.0002448118,
0.0134523632,
-0.0802146867,
-0.0439323708,
-0.0021131197,
0.0308035631,
-0.0471951403,
0.00643455,
0.047333017,
0.0264263283,
0.0088345548,
0.0124777639,
-0.0252726506,
-0.0334019698,
-0.0236056317,
-0.0108736511,
0.0047706175,
0.0147133684,
-0.0293328837,
0.1044795662,
-0.0555724278,
-0.0788650066,
0.027003292,
-0.0085475054,
0.0200202093,
0.0493380204,
0.0167751834,
-0.0249551572,
-0.0013311154,
-0.0047157421,
0.0496754348,
0.0078777932,
0.0338843875,
0.0077566099,
-0.0187861007,
0.0256640427,
0.0191525463,
0.0144624608,
-0.0338311195,
0.0525583029,
-0.0698397532,
-0.0504022427,
-0.0021803619,
-0.0045977156,
0.02254197,
0.0331326798,
-0.0828075111,
-0.0421873666,
-0.0059609818,
-0.0254601929,
0.0019724171,
-0.0354188755,
0.0218006577,
-0.0487497263,
-0.0447548069,
0.0016732186,
0.0343140401,
-0.0025998421,
0.0626123846,
-0.0259220731,
0.0369728878,
0.010014981,
-0.004486545,
-0.005057435,
0.0052176891,
-0.025870014,
0.0535111725,
0.0007688847,
0.0531790778,
-0.0139493756,
0.0433564857,
0.0418518707,
-0.0427821502,
0.0342251025,
-0.0173025485,
-0.0990039483,
0.0008046685,
-0.0130444262,
0.0229905229,
0.0254549924,
-0.0152611919,
0.0588944331,
-0.0148876365,
-0.0304272547,
-0.0177504066,
0.0171661787,
0.008460775,
0.0199093409,
0.0365242809,
0.0444459617,
-0.0440957732,
0.0176901706,
0.0666664094,
-0.0118956482,
0.0446154922,
0.0114332549,
-0.0030229189,
-0.0608751066,
-0.0724602491,
0.0179894269,
0.027851956,
-0.048363775,
-0.0209660288,
-0.0238729436,
0.0353517123,
0.0270524584,
-0.0129994657,
-0.0222284924,
-0.0177376736,
0.0234434307,
0.0644234419,
-0.0048140134,
-0.0005082285,
-0.0406242348,
0.0148825599,
0.0054728845,
0.0053661116,
-0.0387446769,
-6.629898341e-33,
-0.0476768874,
-0.0233493652,
0.0170253608,
0.0486238115,
-0.0005304739,
-0.0067453375,
-0.0543353036,
0.0118614314,
-0.0367908552,
0.0236650072,
0.0292840172,
0.0003793621,
0.0192717612,
-0.0000750387,
-0.0141458707,
-0.0405778475,
0.0268336087,
-0.0030529632,
-0.0244015064,
0.0127438018,
0.0574787445,
0.0193011221,
0.032627929,
-0.0646951571,
0.0272068642,
0.0103105903,
0.0116286948,
0.0276376903,
0.0267858896,
0.0634921119,
0.0096972575,
0.0241207629,
0.0012871284,
-0.0324593484,
-0.0112768812,
0.0123023996,
-0.028173266,
-0.0240262747,
0.0308971275,
-0.0192927793,
0.0213140119,
-0.0471786894,
-0.0012497823,
0.0137690743,
0.0039002805,
-0.0484924167,
0.0268081706,
-0.0325951055,
-0.0078231273,
0.0063567143,
-0.0562150404,
0.0615787208,
0.0109357387,
-0.0080861989,
0.0014700388,
0.0097027486,
0.0497820899,
0.0522611924,
-0.0470533967,
0.0268401522,
-0.0171432495,
0.0293664224,
-0.0170917194,
-0.0073278495,
-0.0115295788,
0.0665578246,
-0.0067339302,
0.0081620496,
-0.0310265776,
-0.044951506,
-0.0046993089,
0.0565834977,
0.0313549228,
0.0662787482,
-0.0148161277,
0.0124998419,
-0.0599562004,
0.0083289072,
0.0548654757,
0.0241496805,
0.0125678247,
0.0208265558,
-0.0405265726,
-0.0041913153,
0.0033847569,
0.0298724715,
-0.0039149364,
-0.0013416816,
-0.0148265054,
0.0202077515,
-0.0091695618,
0.058475811,
0.0507124513,
-0.0332210325,
0.0324026644,
0.0163226407,
-0.0079925517,
0.0027919763,
-0.001919228,
0.0298405495,
-0.0553977527,
-0.0154149262,
0.0318541564,
0.0053089177,
-0.0090205362,
-0.001303602,
-0.0081585394,
-0.0111980913,
-0.0388532057,
0.0166935809,
-0.0217080209,
0.0069123842,
-0.0254413635,
0.0364971757,
-0.0035167716,
0.0116742859,
-0.0026341141,
0.0595486425,
-0.0021326013,
0.0444834046,
-0.038187921,
-0.0306540038,
-0.0091535542,
0.0096730888,
-0.0047908858,
0.0319583677,
-0.0113407951,
0.0246936791,
-0.0268462375,
-0.0165470932,
0.0001778572,
-0.0008454053,
2.481e-7,
0.0350557379,
0.054545287,
0.0529989041,
0.0084844818,
0.0042248121,
0.0272342525,
-0.0064460933,
-0.0073133218,
0.0285087228,
0.001274417,
-0.0098247342,
0.0507368483,
0.0513258427,
0.0479117446,
-0.0683056712,
-0.1004653946,
-0.0949232951,
-0.0451553315,
-0.0559747182,
-0.0164984427,
0.0596521907,
0.0829957128,
0.0192894023,
0.0188474674,
-0.0468126126,
-0.0109073566,
0.0749423727,
-0.0031895111,
-0.0690132007,
0.0643605664,
0.0072523309,
-0.0452760607,
-0.0467965938,
-0.0157569647,
-0.0016594213,
0.0587635785,
-0.0113992235,
0.0944779664,
0.0186292101,
-0.0405193307,
-0.0049875574,
-0.0373752676,
-0.0108939363,
-0.038260553,
0.0410451815,
-0.0802669451,
-0.0415314063,
-0.0547345541,
-0.026644323,
0.0137405246,
-0.0156800374,
-0.0165741388,
-0.0034090246,
0.0232393742,
-0.0259141345,
0.0036704878,
0.0178251956,
-0.0729718804,
-0.023001004,
0.0036816327,
-0.0825114027,
-0.0239860434,
0.010980567,
-0.0249333661,
0.0009405262,
-0.0552979149,
0.0214827657,
2.328698849e-34,
0.0313757025,
0.041529417,
-0.0545256622,
0.0521840304,
0.0709300265,
0.0076443758,
-0.0407998227,
0.0065223044,
0.0072237086,
-0.0603872277,
-0.0009461578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12182v1 | Aqulia-Med LLM: Pioneering Full-Process Open-Source Medical Language Models | 2024-06-18T01:30:07 | 2024-06-18T01:30:07 | Lulu Zhao, Weihao Zeng, Xiaofeng Shi, Hua Zhou, Donglin Hao, Yonghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, both closed-source LLMs and open-source communities have made
significant strides, outperforming humans in various general domains. However,
their performance in specific professional fields such as medicine, especially
within the open-source community, remains suboptimal due to the complexity of
medical knowledge. We propose Aquila-Med, a bilingual medical LLM based on
Aquila, addressing these challenges through continue pre-training, supervised
fine-tuning (SFT), and reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). We
construct a large-scale Chinese and English medical dataset for continue
pre-training and a high-quality SFT dataset, covering extensive medical
specialties. Additionally, we develop a high-quality Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) dataset for further alignment. Aquila-Med achieves notable
results across single-turn, multi-turn dialogues, and medical multiple-choice
questions, demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach. We open-source the
datasets and the entire training process, contributing valuable resources to
the research community. Our models and datasets will released at
https://huggingface.co/BAAI/AquilaMed-RL. | [
0.0453707725,
0.0532750376,
-0.0002678263,
0.0232430864,
-0.0133048231,
0.0192539301,
-0.0232735798,
0.0067039481,
0.0110182427,
0.0261030942,
-0.0880533233,
-0.0368346721,
-0.0160213709,
-0.0011531437,
0.0245633014,
-0.0459234826,
0.0444259904,
0.0031691545,
0.0081041688,
-0.0290761888,
0.0038086467,
0.0152229406,
-0.0528377295,
0.0360355973,
0.0601657555,
0.0028616234,
0.02875489,
0.0103525361,
0.0365065224,
-0.0540314317,
0.0198144875,
0.0640449077,
-0.0127241639,
0.0103825359,
0.0000019557,
-0.0659259334,
-0.0010963818,
-0.0032100147,
-0.035138648,
-0.0445214473,
0.0313711204,
-0.0283876341,
-0.0209409688,
0.0203665253,
-0.045239646,
-0.0194277167,
0.0357731804,
0.0291686244,
0.0605496503,
0.0760333091,
0.014486487,
-0.0011666844,
0.0285571162,
-0.0515036769,
0.0191468261,
-0.0455709621,
0.0201190207,
-0.035709884,
0.0249256808,
-0.0334401838,
-0.0115496563,
0.0188700687,
0.0008698958,
0.0173480902,
-0.0313277543,
0.0049338802,
-0.0503314361,
-0.014648241,
-0.0059086466,
0.1124010906,
-0.0042005558,
-0.0206060112,
0.0232240204,
-0.0089297034,
-0.0060932902,
-0.0230553672,
-0.0381306261,
0.0122447889,
-0.0078445962,
0.0202269889,
0.0232273694,
-0.045995459,
0.0305709951,
0.0180317685,
-0.0185251739,
0.0268911384,
0.0145825101,
-0.0306276735,
0.0460499488,
-0.0023108402,
-0.0002250486,
-0.0208072923,
0.0307680313,
0.0348204151,
-0.0899752825,
0.0109107057,
-0.0331667885,
-0.0126674045,
0.0729036853,
-0.0614889637,
0.0108923679,
0.0222318862,
-0.0287096314,
0.0446908958,
0.0146798939,
0.0186676085,
-0.0376842842,
0.0692362785,
-0.0429995023,
0.0049858629,
-0.0220702812,
0.0101081766,
-0.0071125473,
0.0123791713,
-0.0179290865,
0.0244548079,
-0.0970280468,
-0.0051839831,
-0.0082656369,
0.0473251827,
0.0317159742,
0.0413529463,
-0.0407688506,
-0.0142967887,
-0.0304795951,
0.0470344834,
0.0024050958,
0.0197399221,
-0.029271841,
-0.03971944,
0.0047037229,
0.0398362726,
-0.0206775852,
-0.0318567008,
0.0222832505,
0.0834751874,
0.0054899161,
-0.0055120639,
0.0022721423,
-0.0222419836,
-0.0165849198,
-0.0479757264,
-0.0162611492,
-0.0796580538,
0.0295482092,
-0.0032253154,
0.0154123371,
-0.0474029854,
0.0133706527,
0.0199903324,
-0.0473356433,
0.0640516058,
-0.026742341,
0.0041174563,
0.0090849372,
0.0160501469,
0.012335632,
0.0558011197,
0.037093576,
-0.0333551615,
0.0169651713,
-0.0316440389,
-0.0062844078,
0.0351740681,
0.0288456362,
-0.0023731489,
0.0000817667,
0.0367451943,
0.0059160581,
0.0967660919,
-0.0051182588,
0.0503152683,
-0.0160700735,
-0.0263112243,
0.0242087021,
0.0418120846,
0.029997997,
-0.006488218,
0.0183270257,
-0.0055355555,
0.0161397066,
-0.0066205598,
-0.0191457216,
0.015840631,
0.0056431093,
-0.0064832019,
-0.0133518716,
0.0138940485,
-0.0377053246,
-0.0374075845,
-0.0107285567,
-0.0138089545,
-0.0415100865,
0.0181473102,
0.0443357304,
0.0036418641,
-0.0362290554,
0.0598566569,
0.0545150675,
-0.0303818509,
0.0076933051,
-0.0222740583,
0.010880596,
0.0621141903,
0.051312618,
-0.0618421845,
-0.0609973483,
-0.0297448412,
-0.008490162,
0.0359504819,
0.0607229769,
-0.0255539846,
0.0052464074,
-0.0801178962,
-0.0125954058,
0.0435110964,
-0.0131899845,
-0.0161754657,
0.0146266269,
0.0212853309,
-0.0305269249,
0.0056184335,
-0.0261203554,
0.0403533392,
-0.0620481931,
-0.0209803749,
0.0205605589,
0.0090536317,
0.0517392643,
0.016201837,
-0.0070006056,
0.0180709045,
0.0496315546,
-0.0054310588,
-0.0042851111,
0.0151863182,
-0.0311886221,
-0.0418923311,
0.042286735,
-0.0242949016,
-0.0507241152,
-0.0111497119,
-0.0745950714,
-0.0367200375,
-0.0367506146,
-0.0029166031,
0.0153350132,
-0.0059766527,
0.0245131385,
0.0283443909,
-0.0009396338,
-0.0631896332,
0.0030129002,
-0.0200446527,
0.0413577855,
0.0543084145,
-0.0214929972,
0.0171009079,
-0.078975834,
-0.0135785621,
0.0179857519,
-0.0039884588,
0.0208849888,
-0.0152848875,
0.0624729954,
-0.0432072021,
-0.0514472201,
-0.0935141519,
0.0182831492,
-0.0100979134,
0.004021313,
0.0420772471,
0.0192881413,
-0.015796518,
-0.0266118739,
-0.0455079451,
-0.0262106471,
0.0115213338,
-0.0095549971,
0.0374789461,
0.0281019993,
0.0270379186,
-0.0479340032,
-0.0089249816,
-0.0312459134,
-0.0316036493,
-0.0252241325,
0.0376584306,
-0.0068769306,
-0.0098467031,
-0.0294475351,
0.0097745033,
-0.0053116111,
-0.046001669,
0.0044545438,
0.0065540695,
0.0066367113,
0.0521832481,
0.0069078626,
-0.0148181366,
0.0248828381,
0.0090656858,
-0.0376388095,
0.0266061481,
-0.0348405354,
-0.0593936518,
-0.0466723517,
-0.0181008279,
-0.0208468717,
0.0768281594,
0.013535521,
0.0067328541,
-0.0639860183,
-0.0273114406,
0.0082310941,
0.0024238604,
-0.0260305088,
0.0769480169,
-0.057382144,
0.0340301394,
-0.0022497664,
-0.0257093888,
0.1237677187,
-0.0139655322,
0.0340172462,
-0.0853687301,
-0.0265744645,
-0.0639512762,
-0.0390668735,
-0.0418992415,
-0.008609294,
-0.0196065083,
-0.0143771134,
-0.0554326773,
0.0163903907,
0.0068207285,
-0.0704916939,
0.0653215721,
-0.0254895315,
-0.0110580064,
-0.0064515667,
-0.0629236102,
-0.041056402,
-0.0304349363,
-0.0352253057,
-0.0042024013,
0.0143169258,
-0.0030566182,
-0.0292692501,
-0.0184530001,
0.005922561,
0.065390937,
0.0145320063,
0.0157875866,
-0.0258757342,
0.0093341507,
0.0412680507,
0.0355828814,
-0.0092146909,
-0.0341084488,
0.0210079271,
0.042258542,
0.0308100041,
-0.0057764701,
0.0293488745,
-0.0071191504,
0.0439701155,
-0.0332290456,
-0.0034892233,
0.0200310946,
0.0159331281,
-0.0546173416,
-0.0025618682,
0.111462228,
0.0078585222,
-0.080305934,
0.0118504753,
-0.0263409559,
0.0203266554,
0.0306336302,
0.0237127077,
-0.1107855514,
-0.034065742,
-0.0170505196,
0.0589221269,
0.0200078376,
0.0024739716,
0.0237210095,
-0.0816664025,
0.0215312988,
0.0131248701,
-0.0507801473,
-0.0206058174,
-0.0117280632,
0.000770499,
-0.0619373284,
0.0132604577,
-0.0003443967,
0.0022698478,
-0.0121078109,
-0.0037148756,
-0.0183685403,
-0.0623682775,
0.0360245444,
-0.0158612244,
0.0391182005,
0.0675479174,
0.0234343633,
-0.0140322456,
-0.0382141694,
0.0270388648,
-0.0047271112,
-0.0315635726,
-0.0285020303,
0.0602595694,
0.0099660764,
-0.0131814154,
-0.0252048802,
0.0689048544,
-0.0547261015,
-0.0197508465,
0.02288232,
0.0800476372,
-0.018595174,
-0.0004984797,
-0.0105381971,
0.0462594293,
0.0181340277,
0.0442330688,
-0.0010905851,
-0.0359727032,
-0.0200745501,
0.0042577954,
0.0175367668,
-0.0276263654,
-0.0329219513,
0.0178789906,
-0.0334533378,
0.014799919,
-0.0572270639,
-0.0146660646,
0.0262714587,
-0.0001167909,
0.0160450954,
0.0297599304,
0.0200643893,
-0.0199783631,
-0.0253195427,
0.0615009703,
-0.0082873935,
0.0229653735,
-0.0961989686,
-0.0455009714,
0.0605322197,
-0.0203520823,
-0.0105209956,
0.0185409021,
-0.0308385845,
-0.0461593233,
-0.0040510851,
0.0655620992,
0.0155785838,
0.0548139513,
-0.0232262798,
-0.0431348644,
0.0145388907,
0.0190493315,
-0.0310315937,
-0.0153893679,
0.0330142677,
0.0218055639,
-0.0209675711,
0.0318456441,
-0.0103792669,
-0.0208266992,
0.0247861706,
0.0273241363,
-0.0143588735,
-0.0480396748,
0.0068104048,
0.0012918559,
0.0545629859,
-0.0098972274,
0.0151184108,
-0.0469614863,
0.0661163032,
0.0078546554,
-0.0023410574,
-0.0248592161,
-0.02634711,
0.0389848463,
-0.0621090271,
-0.0058520921,
-0.0108131673,
-0.0681490451,
-0.0200988259,
-0.0373282842,
0.0542448424,
0.0328640416,
0.0125218062,
0.0561785437,
0.0092527382,
0.0039440864,
0.0592670962,
0.008779712,
0.0574443303,
0.0013721781,
0.0736766532,
0.0157480072,
0.0434564799,
0.045964133,
0.0287591945,
-0.0090615861,
-0.0758240595,
-0.0107894633,
0.0220688693,
0.0810449496,
0.0106469123,
0.0347377583,
0.0031992339,
-0.01142467,
-0.0239985194,
0.0367251225,
-0.069672294,
0.0300813876,
0.0583017878,
0.0154948393,
-0.0041242233,
0.004470516,
0.1035927236,
-0.0094432794,
0.0486025065,
0.0060061747,
0.0015628086,
-0.0474056229,
-0.037183132,
0.0174257308,
0.0090599963,
-0.0662061945,
0.0015115471,
-0.0444130637,
-0.0642951876,
-0.0009930255,
0.0174703728,
-0.0370553471,
0.0007674769,
0.065198414,
0.0179265123,
-0.0113345236,
-0.0080899261,
-0.0289081112,
0.0479318574,
-0.0116086276,
-0.0528422408,
0.029841654,
-6.14451101e-33,
-0.0186725073,
-0.0092744343,
0.0488798022,
-0.0132564688,
-0.0138195967,
-0.0180391781,
-0.0100679379,
0.0009741074,
-0.0375864878,
0.0139439376,
-0.025522517,
0.002100114,
0.0215178188,
0.045693025,
0.0024816932,
-0.0374936424,
0.0051233629,
0.0073779118,
-0.0213476196,
0.029678477,
-0.0234508347,
0.0534251332,
0.062777482,
-0.0617557205,
0.0143857738,
0.0122606354,
0.0238344129,
0.0443303958,
-0.0801581293,
0.0797743723,
-0.0013589105,
0.0311713312,
0.0221235901,
-0.0132470056,
-0.0143580819,
-0.0212214552,
-0.0825807527,
-0.0137515413,
0.0156242605,
0.0155654373,
-0.0449411348,
-0.0304061715,
0.041319903,
-0.0268924348,
-0.0254386701,
0.0037591548,
0.0168650243,
-0.0359996147,
-0.0192992855,
-0.014090823,
-0.0074601248,
0.0341053903,
0.0028754573,
-0.011838994,
-0.0190658793,
0.0152919628,
-0.0278009474,
0.055038251,
-0.0415885597,
0.0140179023,
0.0061644576,
0.0402763225,
0.0392496996,
-0.0270371754,
0.0029687041,
0.0052103568,
0.0231966432,
-0.0158847496,
0.0138058914,
-0.0015562547,
-0.0158621483,
0.0524460003,
0.0483993478,
0.0407070965,
-0.0137722492,
-0.0155728804,
-0.0861289948,
0.0145371258,
-0.0381019451,
0.056914676,
-0.0063311062,
-0.0017122368,
-0.0121954409,
-0.0238706265,
-0.0483901985,
-0.0292674806,
-0.0087655867,
-0.0214862972,
0.0168097503,
0.0058562253,
-0.0064746556,
-0.0160938464,
0.0069249598,
-0.0317344964,
0.0183744021,
-0.0040807254,
0.0114366692,
0.0052785166,
-0.0302591417,
0.0206794534,
-0.0966758728,
-0.0209255125,
-0.0080591273,
-0.0435394086,
0.0549622886,
0.0197850149,
0.0256789755,
-0.0172826424,
-0.0423587747,
0.0109517118,
0.011955563,
0.0077862642,
0.0025033441,
0.0441963896,
0.0075934734,
0.0098556746,
0.0103112664,
0.0945735946,
0.0121851638,
-0.026845064,
-0.0486214161,
-0.0636918619,
0.0185911115,
0.0212404206,
-0.0466030352,
0.0188792963,
-0.0205198452,
0.0629311502,
0.0272047501,
-0.03938815,
-0.0075257723,
0.0049747778,
2.709e-7,
0.0811721012,
0.0423686206,
0.0154866595,
0.005816652,
0.012953422,
0.0188097302,
-0.0296955779,
0.0162894372,
-0.002393581,
0.0209589228,
0.0302829985,
0.0083031245,
0.06344001,
0.0044178492,
-0.1080880389,
-0.0068269623,
-0.0856252983,
0.0039486415,
-0.0280902795,
-0.0383671746,
0.003181844,
0.0962859094,
-0.0103208954,
-0.0171920508,
0.0094348723,
0.0253174324,
0.0525808521,
-0.0386639796,
-0.0220768563,
0.0742224082,
0.0120349973,
-0.0003041098,
-0.0159904603,
-0.0069609098,
-0.0388900861,
0.0083248904,
-0.0096540302,
0.1140712202,
-0.0077326354,
-0.0561775081,
0.0318095163,
0.0053483103,
0.0084777558,
-0.0506082587,
0.0396741144,
-0.0552825294,
-0.034417931,
-0.0083680823,
0.0209193211,
-0.0512034409,
0.0852916688,
-0.0525334813,
-0.0291656516,
0.0130403712,
0.0521906763,
0.0244040638,
-0.051398702,
-0.0642334595,
-0.0377325267,
0.0392453447,
-0.0338702872,
-0.0259615462,
0.0312306937,
-0.0097117294,
-0.0301987436,
-0.0322708227,
0.008249565,
2.298278112e-34,
0.0344323069,
-0.0045875236,
0.016423082,
0.0273705833,
0.0265895221,
-0.0186011773,
0.016142359,
0.031158166,
0.0333500989,
-0.0472856499,
-0.0235431027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12168v2 | BPO: Supercharging Online Preference Learning by Adhering to the Proximity of Behavior LLM | 2024-06-18T00:41:40 | 2024-06-19T05:25:27 | Wenda Xu, Jiachen Li, William Yang Wang, Lei Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Direct alignment from preferences (DAP) has emerged as a promising paradigm
for aligning large language models (LLMs) to human desiderata from
pre-collected, offline preference datasets. While recent studies indicate that
existing offline DAP methods can directly benefit from online training samples,
we highlight the need to develop specific online DAP algorithms to fully
harness the power of online training. Specifically, we identify that the
learned LLM should adhere to the proximity of the behavior LLM, which collects
the training samples. To this end, we propose online Preference Optimization in
proximity to the Behavior LLM (BPO), emphasizing the importance of constructing
a proper trust region for LLM alignment.
We conduct extensive experiments to validate the effectiveness and
applicability of our approach by integrating it with various DAP methods,
resulting in significant performance improvements across a wide range of tasks
when training with the same amount of preference data. Even when only
introducing one additional data collection phase, our online BPO improves its
offline DAP baseline from 72.0% to 80.2% on TL;DR and from 82.2% to 89.1% on
Anthropic Helpfulness in terms of win rate against human reference text. | [
0.0402351394,
0.0912380964,
0.0031429119,
0.0036226762,
-0.0307736285,
0.0187173914,
-0.0366999507,
-0.0402780809,
0.0023637717,
-0.0138001284,
-0.0553543866,
-0.0595896877,
0.0005873879,
0.0007231058,
0.0100076701,
-0.0299380682,
0.033524964,
0.0045995289,
0.0106861508,
-0.0218274146,
0.0295100659,
0.0426664986,
-0.027728375,
0.0174123142,
0.0298152659,
-0.0095897,
0.0060020774,
0.0059729787,
0.0330117047,
-0.0272765439,
0.0402188264,
0.0193585455,
0.0375824831,
-0.017530581,
0.0000022136,
-0.0618421584,
-0.0454751737,
-0.0184034202,
-0.0144352,
-0.031114243,
0.0430113003,
0.0298758894,
0.0048947134,
0.0242545195,
-0.0406269766,
0.0200541094,
0.0421092026,
-0.0000074205,
-0.0013022651,
0.0794184208,
0.00137384,
0.0141989123,
0.0152052362,
-0.0278189387,
-0.0007648459,
-0.0000103738,
0.0350093804,
-0.0582636744,
-0.0503116883,
-0.0204043146,
-0.003425322,
-0.0046726796,
-0.0289205704,
0.0262292903,
0.0562334061,
0.0047808737,
-0.0154665653,
-0.0222802181,
-0.0024772929,
0.0898957923,
-0.0232970938,
-0.0231899433,
0.0177873895,
-0.0256037526,
-0.0288354158,
0.0025451886,
-0.0069766277,
-0.0014057815,
-0.0028784352,
0.0484601334,
-0.0089317504,
-0.0071501173,
0.0031111478,
0.0492195338,
-0.0214699004,
0.0943794549,
-0.0196790751,
-0.0598808676,
0.0417160504,
0.0119804153,
-0.0525434837,
-0.022428995,
0.0362255909,
-0.0112237697,
-0.044812955,
0.0329592861,
-0.0329111665,
0.0458276197,
0.0113454778,
-0.0058571543,
0.0872459486,
0.0470609553,
0.0072264788,
0.012718169,
0.0231876876,
0.0781367794,
-0.0079105068,
0.0032202979,
-0.0548285656,
0.0365835167,
-0.0386556759,
0.0202143416,
0.0069103334,
0.022792412,
0.0054048994,
-0.022290254,
-0.0388251357,
0.0272508245,
-0.0204473473,
0.0423749872,
0.0214026663,
0.0126180742,
-0.0561667196,
-0.0224659387,
-0.0565118939,
0.0441247523,
0.0114276987,
0.0272067022,
-0.0166278314,
-0.0343980752,
0.0119123645,
0.0186832584,
0.0082247667,
-0.0411673784,
0.0046189367,
0.079807952,
-0.0174344275,
-0.0301607512,
0.022310691,
0.0114305206,
-0.031767834,
-0.0441480987,
-0.0216916651,
-0.0379927605,
0.0358665884,
-0.0415506139,
-0.0078417612,
-0.0353696831,
0.0071728481,
0.0272290371,
-0.0263891593,
0.0458403416,
-0.0041927965,
0.0280436575,
-0.0143382456,
-0.0528038964,
-0.0239130631,
0.0472303852,
0.0309917908,
0.0310785789,
0.0434096269,
0.0106991278,
-0.0415132977,
0.0294884089,
0.0269965976,
0.0157132391,
-0.0642628372,
0.0253732447,
-0.0031463052,
0.0443821922,
0.0672826394,
0.010734316,
-0.0393011458,
0.0153271686,
0.1209188625,
0.0162708741,
0.001744899,
-0.0125212986,
-0.0287149865,
0.0922913402,
-0.0317388363,
0.0057516494,
-0.0597023517,
0.0117058279,
-0.0158300512,
0.0261068195,
0.0226775911,
0.0434636287,
-0.0047776788,
-0.0406198613,
-0.0038364776,
-0.0262760986,
0.0088376272,
0.0420297459,
0.0173873045,
-0.0032750631,
-0.0312620364,
-0.0241736192,
0.0422822386,
-0.0243646689,
0.0130794356,
-0.0119859586,
0.0666678473,
0.1019644663,
0.0484710261,
-0.0165742263,
-0.0473931618,
-0.0315870829,
-0.0251983758,
0.0510043353,
0.0089582372,
-0.0429005511,
0.0000402032,
-0.0713492408,
-0.0544134341,
0.0201587565,
-0.0130108641,
-0.0024879726,
0.0504449792,
-0.0072302022,
-0.0283102691,
-0.030523967,
-0.0102420989,
0.02647838,
0.0102768634,
-0.012428984,
0.0101103773,
0.0432483293,
0.0490874462,
-0.009675445,
0.0100334436,
-0.0111345043,
0.0106484527,
-0.0029131423,
-0.0185886901,
-0.0079781581,
-0.076654546,
-0.0077578998,
0.0625962391,
-0.016103046,
-0.0162747148,
0.0719573796,
-0.0245931391,
-0.0112585742,
-0.0671218708,
0.0006632249,
0.0562716536,
-0.0087841926,
0.0395354591,
0.0003274981,
-0.0078522256,
-0.0636309087,
0.0330790244,
-0.024702156,
0.0211766679,
-0.0001696311,
-0.0180418901,
-0.0256696716,
-0.0432942174,
0.0055003269,
-0.012365032,
-0.0145839872,
0.0139288316,
0.0353523865,
0.0329920016,
-0.0427578576,
-0.0356513187,
-0.0309320521,
0.0117871296,
-0.0003109972,
0.0303628296,
0.0266043935,
-0.0280558057,
-0.0189943276,
-0.018728653,
-0.0434949696,
0.0019736325,
-0.0508550033,
0.015848849,
0.0460848138,
-0.0176065303,
0.0153140528,
-0.0654472858,
0.0088921012,
0.0126595348,
-0.0402565487,
-0.0582551099,
0.0011731659,
-0.0362337492,
0.0291512534,
-0.0472172722,
0.0025353751,
-0.0059006428,
-0.0536609255,
-0.0063268505,
-0.0105882809,
0.00669439,
0.117532976,
0.0478687845,
-0.0192391425,
0.0639676452,
0.0371187963,
-0.1013177261,
-0.014463014,
-0.0510097258,
-0.0123663042,
-0.0419272296,
0.0158373173,
-0.0073407637,
0.0737459958,
-0.012769415,
0.0058210851,
-0.043826174,
-0.0159590524,
0.0050307647,
-0.0080576977,
-0.0112259369,
0.0005440518,
-0.0394174308,
0.0205420274,
-0.0294953249,
-0.0795530006,
0.0950986743,
-0.0102612916,
-0.0025532732,
-0.073215723,
-0.0271355789,
0.0016579016,
0.0001939368,
0.0290034655,
0.0112431804,
0.0228486974,
-0.0102188354,
-0.0788795426,
-0.0333351567,
0.0443227999,
-0.0289094653,
0.0300369412,
-0.0407303795,
0.0030378934,
-0.0062261974,
-0.0727292001,
-0.0473173819,
-0.0493861325,
-0.013684772,
-0.0377524868,
-0.0167001449,
-0.0331776775,
-0.0261150431,
-0.0303493533,
0.0134263225,
0.0335834175,
0.0014789341,
-0.0163139198,
-0.0318730362,
0.0174337532,
0.1200399548,
0.0334360786,
-0.0094735706,
0.0189446006,
-0.0348628201,
0.0547950305,
0.0584028512,
-0.0051090084,
0.007613868,
-0.0060312557,
0.0762851387,
-0.0271250494,
-0.0142482575,
0.026115844,
0.0287205148,
0.0095919976,
0.0142041771,
0.1046534032,
0.0281773694,
-0.0862054303,
0.0109101217,
0.0141716376,
0.043860551,
0.0231124721,
0.0119066956,
-0.056226898,
-0.0255416669,
0.0133186411,
0.0679456815,
-0.009381108,
-0.0138806906,
-0.0214604363,
-0.1216295958,
-0.0245256089,
0.0163168777,
-0.0084239012,
0.0482428521,
-0.0288448874,
0.0265368875,
-0.0897059441,
0.0285332799,
0.0030258175,
-0.0071085696,
-0.0017338981,
0.009503996,
-0.0155972447,
-0.0376822464,
0.0370927975,
-0.033834327,
0.0294625405,
0.097838603,
0.0484755673,
0.031622909,
-0.0344084725,
0.0160965491,
0.0040928177,
-0.0029048391,
-0.0234756507,
0.0081791515,
-0.0571641997,
0.025115326,
-0.032137733,
0.0729658604,
-0.0208175927,
0.0060838736,
0.0074443785,
0.0498297922,
0.0089831352,
0.018417472,
0.0102677634,
-0.0027846221,
0.0513439253,
0.0465401188,
-0.0193685014,
-0.0952722803,
-0.0023276056,
-0.0035472144,
-0.0246999171,
-0.0033432138,
-0.0144467084,
-0.0212540552,
-0.0113433413,
0.0101319421,
-0.0942059234,
-0.0150230164,
-0.0332292728,
0.0438351221,
0.0163609963,
-0.0195055362,
0.0338564701,
-0.0208483767,
-0.0419452973,
0.0491258018,
-0.051926367,
0.0227488391,
-0.0380222835,
-0.0160865523,
0.0481123142,
-0.0405261591,
-0.0091638956,
-0.0149468919,
-0.0070926421,
-0.0841337293,
0.0032384689,
0.0453224778,
0.0221841447,
0.0831606835,
-0.0040326435,
-0.0529518388,
0.0319592692,
0.02788027,
-0.0186345652,
0.0070663206,
0.0304271281,
0.0212484449,
-0.0039363243,
0.0369538404,
-0.0087349415,
0.0006207445,
0.0101205884,
0.0190876368,
-0.0165561792,
-0.0364698842,
0.0423245803,
-0.0024738347,
0.0751344487,
-0.0088491021,
-0.0073264604,
-0.048645623,
0.0355854593,
0.0323734134,
-0.0125717148,
-0.0302916151,
-0.0379649736,
0.058782205,
-0.0044143624,
-0.0023500861,
-0.0112828277,
-0.0192346405,
0.0067059435,
-0.017495336,
-0.0184311774,
0.0225248467,
0.0304922722,
0.0275392309,
0.0303896368,
-0.0265798047,
0.0340264961,
0.0120249605,
0.0549733676,
-0.0055779158,
0.0406342149,
0.0261796936,
0.0126255052,
0.0056710588,
0.0266814027,
-0.0080883494,
-0.0365250409,
-0.0603972971,
-0.0600766614,
0.0427309237,
-0.0592686087,
0.0723140314,
-0.0069029164,
-0.0042356835,
-0.0223014224,
0.0348672532,
-0.0659125969,
-0.0301269628,
0.0102918111,
0.0248252861,
-0.0364771448,
0.0438031331,
0.0699661598,
-0.0169702768,
0.0176317319,
-0.0260698069,
0.0105986455,
-0.0346197933,
-0.0290498286,
0.0104502076,
0.0498868488,
-0.0412093475,
-0.0353738368,
-0.0020442361,
-0.0470649414,
0.0172255859,
-0.0054237442,
-0.0228536502,
-0.0353563279,
0.0640308782,
0.019642869,
-0.0486086197,
0.0104571497,
-0.0545568727,
-0.0246250741,
-0.0036094324,
0.0065589701,
-0.0385302864,
-6.563388871e-33,
-0.0155822216,
-0.0215537567,
-0.0055564973,
-0.0285916217,
-0.0578377061,
-0.0273239482,
0.0235871281,
0.0122953597,
-0.0155878691,
-0.0321434736,
-0.014066427,
-0.0111935101,
0.0241273306,
0.0261956193,
0.0036681655,
0.0002663289,
0.0182478148,
-0.0247275624,
-0.0387332849,
-0.0103875445,
0.0432178229,
0.0111131314,
0.0366853215,
-0.0639005676,
0.0174715146,
0.002515272,
-0.0292729884,
0.0185612477,
-0.004153748,
0.0797729194,
-0.0124982893,
0.0202924833,
-0.0022097686,
0.0043889172,
-0.0041802861,
0.0142012015,
-0.0380697958,
0.0109908469,
0.019565152,
0.0163256507,
0.0114203608,
-0.0130571211,
0.014275643,
-0.0125112254,
-0.0404902883,
-0.0004064927,
0.0201320983,
-0.0573795512,
-0.0698123872,
0.0301285665,
-0.0485045016,
0.0010203227,
-0.0125074266,
-0.014824139,
0.0162678044,
0.0326763317,
0.0171588808,
0.0484308824,
-0.0669185445,
0.075015977,
-0.0301287435,
0.0218504556,
0.0692457184,
-0.0361191742,
0.03081882,
0.0533718541,
0.0252537951,
-0.0339826606,
0.0685686842,
-0.0180637315,
0.0279183909,
0.0191490557,
-0.0191521849,
0.0447289944,
0.02509032,
-0.0145785743,
-0.0096436813,
0.0287305787,
0.0385276861,
-0.0149520012,
0.0313625857,
0.0552030541,
-0.0495176353,
-0.0064330525,
-0.0181817226,
-0.0270455685,
-0.0358271599,
-0.0512453355,
0.0205133613,
0.0519794933,
-0.0116028739,
-0.0042322637,
0.0098197693,
-0.0344605632,
-0.0224070437,
0.019236939,
-0.0417009369,
0.0122304615,
0.0137577821,
-0.0043060775,
-0.1064799279,
-0.0378126763,
-0.0265071988,
-0.0163713433,
-0.0203183591,
0.0382082723,
0.036975272,
0.0350528061,
-0.052903641,
0.0126817767,
-0.0043818848,
-0.0289524235,
-0.0031501413,
0.0348850228,
0.0683991462,
-0.0164041203,
-0.0067761755,
0.113727279,
0.0087627945,
-0.0234131347,
-0.0437211506,
-0.0219244845,
0.0035190652,
0.0128215188,
0.0024342681,
0.0023195494,
-0.0151971038,
-0.0268887132,
-0.030943105,
-0.0040421323,
-0.0167368986,
-0.0103868013,
2.797e-7,
0.005116445,
0.0476490892,
0.0159098636,
0.0050603282,
-0.0007345838,
0.0285731014,
-0.0109125823,
-0.0013564405,
0.004965567,
0.0165305156,
0.049818024,
-0.0066992524,
0.0651142821,
-0.0121342298,
-0.097151041,
0.0017086049,
-0.0243229419,
0.0104672806,
-0.0380529799,
0.0005722448,
-0.002181821,
0.0884859934,
0.0100007895,
-0.0050368528,
0.0213708244,
0.0446751155,
0.0624383353,
-0.0526983291,
-0.0066294232,
0.0123177692,
-0.0211078003,
-0.0319034234,
-0.0662034824,
-0.0020722039,
-0.0108724851,
0.031642165,
-0.0195308868,
0.1096037105,
0.0177805256,
-0.0494507812,
-0.0094923619,
0.0152749792,
0.0064384565,
-0.0695710257,
0.052100677,
-0.0721937791,
-0.0204821713,
-0.0150393778,
-0.0294757988,
-0.0142648518,
0.0215934496,
-0.0405380242,
0.013031641,
0.0021730266,
0.0155232297,
0.0266668536,
-0.0480884835,
-0.0494911857,
-0.0149853872,
0.0375351533,
-0.0228153765,
-0.0518608913,
-0.0124701047,
0.046727404,
0.0155305527,
-0.0442174897,
0.0038363084,
2.427540475e-34,
0.0032624837,
0.0153947836,
0.0305437632,
-0.0078581339,
-0.0041219541,
0.0187957138,
0.0315162912,
0.0122338543,
0.0460606478,
-0.0652396902,
-0.0051524853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12165v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12165v1 | Statistical Uncertainty in Word Embeddings: GloVe-V | 2024-06-18T00:35:02 | 2024-06-18T00:35:02 | Andrea Vallebueno, Cassandra Handan-Nader, Christopher D. Manning, Daniel E. Ho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Static word embeddings are ubiquitous in computational social science
applications and contribute to practical decision-making in a variety of fields
including law and healthcare. However, assessing the statistical uncertainty in
downstream conclusions drawn from word embedding statistics has remained
challenging. When using only point estimates for embeddings, researchers have
no streamlined way of assessing the degree to which their model selection
criteria or scientific conclusions are subject to noise due to sparsity in the
underlying data used to generate the embeddings. We introduce a method to
obtain approximate, easy-to-use, and scalable reconstruction error variance
estimates for GloVe (Pennington et al., 2014), one of the most widely used word
embedding models, using an analytical approximation to a multivariate normal
model. To demonstrate the value of embeddings with variance (GloVe-V), we
illustrate how our approach enables principled hypothesis testing in core word
embedding tasks, such as comparing the similarity between different word pairs
in vector space, assessing the performance of different models, and analyzing
the relative degree of ethnic or gender bias in a corpus using different word
lists. | [
-0.0128431255,
0.1027110219,
-0.0049639591,
0.0076011042,
-0.0164748039,
0.0327309668,
0.0223081037,
-0.0223409776,
-0.0241391957,
-0.0373129733,
-0.0101384129,
-0.044973474,
0.0715563521,
-0.0093387179,
0.0341790915,
-0.0233681481,
0.0387248807,
0.0548011176,
0.0282305814,
-0.0220457558,
0.0106537882,
-0.0016420082,
0.003713252,
0.0558769181,
-0.0148172146,
0.0295619387,
0.0616552271,
-0.0223286375,
0.0070987367,
-0.0395205878,
0.0058052801,
0.0758312866,
0.037350513,
0.0174724367,
0.0000018227,
-0.0386817679,
0.0161470044,
0.0326828584,
0.000888621,
0.0252768211,
0.0583389848,
-0.0222378131,
0.0132968212,
0.0069404263,
-0.0048956904,
-0.0339767039,
0.072698243,
0.0046440093,
-0.0439409092,
-0.0059447871,
-0.0115120895,
-0.0108257486,
-0.0340258293,
-0.0573382229,
-0.0272878259,
0.0063611087,
0.0430920348,
-0.0319077373,
-0.0201607794,
-0.0127590485,
-0.048834417,
0.0294394717,
-0.0140550574,
0.0677530766,
0.0151915038,
0.0543852001,
-0.0022621371,
-0.0123208147,
0.0560471117,
0.0543465987,
0.0259772819,
0.0070627891,
-0.0110804131,
0.017166039,
0.0366953947,
0.1174525768,
-0.0449860878,
-0.001976765,
0.0157993659,
-0.002680368,
0.01830169,
0.0086291097,
0.0564147979,
0.0234530028,
-0.0242176261,
0.0384820849,
0.0236735921,
-0.0545394942,
0.0123564312,
0.0052796579,
-0.0218939576,
0.0031402293,
-0.0012516096,
-0.0422835983,
-0.0064183665,
0.0248145834,
-0.0170250554,
-0.0247929972,
0.0529266,
-0.0483936854,
0.044600971,
0.0146915894,
0.0007208197,
0.0290544201,
0.0052091326,
-0.0535860658,
0.0153769208,
0.0396555662,
0.0061983648,
0.0139506152,
-0.0142539544,
0.0125397891,
0.0157527998,
-0.0388956405,
-0.0216053855,
-0.0077403579,
-0.0391758606,
-0.0052876123,
-0.0373953171,
0.0050870846,
-0.0368342884,
0.0136419795,
0.0152731761,
0.0254098698,
-0.0209177732,
-0.0486280918,
-0.0533718616,
0.0515835732,
-0.0420312844,
-0.0275487434,
-0.0049769529,
-0.0057057878,
0.0072447374,
-0.0190333892,
0.0019456283,
0.0134912133,
0.019751193,
-0.0565097928,
0.0358245149,
0.0187226273,
-0.055631496,
-0.0239144936,
-0.0024577198,
-0.0903437883,
0.0441277772,
0.013180729,
0.009092873,
-0.0572432727,
-0.0012237622,
0.0103901243,
-0.0845095813,
0.0889817774,
0.0167151876,
-0.0032513284,
-0.0018141847,
0.0216478277,
-0.0105993496,
0.0528511293,
0.0350506306,
-0.0400028899,
0.0570554659,
-0.0289554149,
-0.0117046693,
0.004772047,
0.0192435645,
0.0316236354,
-0.0321103595,
0.0032398175,
0.0035131904,
0.0318761431,
0.0158340726,
0.0298818015,
-0.0501231253,
-0.0334015638,
0.0303043295,
0.1600045711,
-0.0119658206,
-0.0180511121,
0.0479452759,
-0.0131810196,
-0.0141083784,
-0.0306015201,
-0.0497933403,
-0.0094657606,
-0.0207109191,
-0.0166961253,
0.0248208363,
0.0241537355,
-0.007094522,
-0.0161634181,
-0.0353501067,
-0.0042775059,
0.0409071781,
-0.0220336299,
0.0276072919,
-0.0329589136,
0.0066051707,
-0.0122664263,
0.0360964872,
-0.0362931788,
-0.0140444068,
-0.0052908612,
0.0345863029,
0.0122568179,
0.0419986732,
-0.0231670737,
0.0100617371,
-0.0331397094,
-0.0051880325,
0.0310400128,
0.036099758,
-0.0212141871,
0.0132280132,
-0.0421007164,
-0.0121613555,
0.0384490974,
0.0619881488,
0.0245096684,
0.0435430147,
0.0351980962,
0.0228982903,
-0.0696508884,
-0.0190987326,
0.0424682796,
-0.0485110432,
-0.0201769546,
0.0042256168,
-0.0080940425,
0.0588409044,
-0.0084138541,
-0.0525840633,
0.0396144129,
0.0004573203,
0.0002685953,
-0.0285508037,
0.008142475,
0.0101866461,
-0.0025429451,
0.0165621471,
-0.0788067654,
-0.0046258331,
0.0169766918,
-0.0174734816,
-0.0024200038,
0.0140228178,
-0.0151296183,
0.0050527602,
-0.0484304391,
-0.0089885266,
-0.0295467824,
0.0722600669,
-0.0223973319,
0.012451428,
-0.0435181409,
0.0265783779,
-0.0170529112,
-0.0259710606,
0.0304766018,
-0.0248684231,
-0.0740487128,
-0.0018231756,
-0.0049220119,
-0.007038075,
0.0209801327,
-0.0299496371,
0.0129192462,
-0.0007291813,
-0.0890553221,
0.0013332218,
-0.0034337856,
-0.019921314,
-0.041795712,
-0.0116860569,
-0.0266842786,
0.0140287457,
0.0229545441,
-0.004600517,
0.0023233211,
0.0579332709,
0.0337458476,
-0.0858585015,
-0.0171252638,
-0.0526437759,
-0.0360165089,
-0.0291226506,
0.0712116435,
-0.014693981,
-0.0093858279,
-0.0014992832,
0.0170385242,
-0.0576113015,
-0.0057049906,
-0.0005247871,
-0.0064486521,
0.0205556843,
0.0249492135,
0.0420354716,
0.0432754606,
-0.0000851693,
0.0236608163,
0.0602443144,
-0.0021610931,
-0.0390883833,
-0.0264916737,
-0.0458060354,
0.0435620733,
-0.002353946,
-0.067361407,
-0.0164982025,
0.0518443435,
0.0316837914,
-0.0094957324,
-0.04962999,
0.0211679004,
-0.0339926258,
-0.0179486014,
-0.0448185727,
0.0135834701,
-0.0368394218,
0.0324264728,
-0.0433837473,
-0.0658323914,
0.038541846,
-0.0043431786,
0.0431691483,
-0.0267242268,
0.0062980759,
0.0083136102,
0.0273508281,
-0.0100367945,
-0.0090759937,
-0.0326172076,
0.0288861673,
-0.0253381506,
-0.0088995732,
0.049621515,
-0.0679173842,
0.0235966556,
-0.0359128006,
0.0051705483,
-0.0077102869,
-0.0184577536,
-0.0233548246,
-0.0721178725,
-0.0425829217,
0.0032249119,
0.0383421965,
-0.0594918542,
0.0087801237,
0.0091878828,
0.0100287711,
-0.0011120713,
-0.0013529749,
-0.020500334,
-0.0205987915,
-0.0059843971,
0.0224589054,
-0.0155883441,
0.0512096845,
-0.032499332,
-0.0104725929,
0.0170062333,
0.0042827162,
0.0316328183,
-0.0075791059,
-0.0051401504,
0.0305659622,
-0.016554039,
-0.0268705692,
0.0143031273,
0.0517386831,
0.0252169017,
0.0147964749,
0.1005116627,
0.0216783937,
-0.0108074518,
0.0343480855,
-0.0080447393,
0.0101562198,
0.035599906,
-0.0056239977,
-0.0672004968,
-0.001570505,
0.032572791,
0.0243808944,
-0.0274471492,
-0.0607022829,
-0.0206122603,
-0.0961058587,
0.0481684171,
0.0171981677,
-0.0219565872,
-0.0276232623,
-0.0826142132,
0.0506682917,
-0.0160323512,
0.0229179636,
-0.0433583856,
0.0175841115,
0.0177182145,
0.0018715778,
-0.058429718,
-0.0981858522,
0.0342551135,
-0.0790987164,
0.0763518587,
-0.0175861977,
0.044779852,
-0.0496918596,
-0.0198876597,
0.0043500233,
0.0019622913,
-0.0766055733,
-0.0130466968,
0.0628078878,
-0.0083106384,
-0.0016185103,
-0.026230488,
0.0276796184,
-0.0283621866,
-0.0023216305,
-0.0057476107,
0.0701903775,
0.0042664511,
-0.0250888988,
-0.0407992527,
0.0037880309,
-0.0027397997,
0.0958755091,
0.0259237979,
-0.0121783465,
0.0070796222,
-0.0127494335,
-0.0000719655,
0.0446031429,
-0.0328870527,
0.0145537853,
-0.0139271291,
-0.0271337871,
-0.0203779452,
-0.0353188217,
0.0434372947,
0.0327881761,
0.0149956672,
-0.0098851016,
0.0108399801,
-0.0460565016,
-0.0833779424,
0.0223969016,
-0.0015885921,
0.0474418849,
0.0262893364,
0.028196536,
0.0215615388,
0.0454655997,
-0.053103108,
-0.0000019285,
-0.0352066867,
-0.0482381359,
0.0128915701,
-0.0009908372,
0.0151799973,
0.0010012113,
-0.0261673778,
-0.0415862761,
0.0780947134,
0.053294681,
-0.0237944331,
-0.0107846679,
0.0216096025,
-0.0005886587,
0.0093765939,
0.0090862336,
-0.0039933068,
0.0113667259,
0.0283154678,
0.0116629852,
-0.0244452003,
-0.0295610409,
-0.0130052194,
0.0057753068,
0.0451015271,
-0.0380079523,
-0.0167980194,
-0.0609880798,
-0.0710117295,
-0.0065733897,
0.0019058775,
-0.0009524529,
-0.0393825956,
0.0425450355,
-0.0065134754,
-0.0745919347,
0.02592941,
-0.0359496288,
0.0516553111,
-0.0406493209,
0.0236198865,
0.0242768321,
0.0231137127,
0.0174706373,
-0.0075701424,
-0.0166482385,
-0.0007186708,
-0.045612935,
0.0066374615,
-0.0030373395,
-0.0021103118,
-0.0232288241,
0.009147617,
-0.0258398596,
0.0023653484,
-0.0610688441,
-0.0433048755,
0.0199769903,
0.0230889432,
-0.0141884815,
-0.0351334326,
0.0329937004,
-0.043129947,
-0.0190980546,
-0.0509296879,
0.0182374362,
-0.029463103,
0.0395313762,
0.0718224198,
-0.0023372262,
-0.0279957876,
0.0201636329,
0.0713916123,
0.0351609327,
0.0335865058,
-0.0496013574,
-0.0947482288,
-0.0358848274,
-0.0317366607,
0.0394847132,
0.0358524173,
-0.0485211685,
0.0080876816,
-0.1155742034,
-0.0674185231,
-0.0152721554,
-0.005894985,
-0.0163138006,
0.0347431712,
-0.0501989052,
0.0788619295,
-0.0186763462,
0.038516257,
-0.0244931132,
0.0265831575,
-0.0140101491,
-0.0727207437,
-0.0056619267,
-6.404664807e-33,
0.0081496639,
-0.0282168165,
-0.030623544,
-0.0652898997,
-0.0160711315,
0.02033698,
-0.0020620748,
0.0351867154,
-0.0202475302,
0.0539318733,
-0.0086204335,
0.0066880365,
0.014616481,
-0.0155675774,
0.0368882678,
-0.0030952685,
-0.0065661883,
0.018334005,
-0.0175605305,
-0.0408321209,
0.020318009,
0.0370250903,
0.0752468482,
-0.06042777,
0.0835099891,
0.039432399,
0.0380798616,
-0.0098324353,
-0.0007007368,
0.029743053,
-0.0484146699,
0.0414935425,
0.0125187794,
-0.0128780147,
-0.0104827574,
0.0227380563,
-0.0577327758,
-0.0364958197,
0.0144294407,
-0.0067862468,
-0.0366061889,
0.0221736822,
-0.0006154848,
0.027623564,
-0.0651162788,
-0.01617679,
0.0319294892,
-0.0161008872,
-0.0538573042,
-0.0108451666,
-0.0485792272,
0.0475593805,
-0.0209959652,
0.0110009219,
0.0164829846,
0.0004825991,
0.0249000546,
0.0094258422,
-0.017227238,
0.0090327254,
-0.0167907253,
-0.0203199573,
0.0219789185,
0.0083107147,
0.0231987555,
0.064673081,
0.0120294457,
-0.0214721169,
-0.032515388,
-0.0349580273,
0.0614052936,
0.0065499931,
0.0084794499,
0.0956148729,
0.0602569953,
-0.0141958343,
-0.0542836338,
-0.0083876904,
0.048699379,
0.0159708299,
0.0650468767,
-0.0023890475,
-0.078878209,
-0.0427879617,
-0.0560557768,
-0.0752074867,
0.0091315899,
-0.0016082923,
0.0173373595,
0.0114939688,
-0.0213584676,
-0.0061253877,
0.0233290754,
-0.0202321447,
-0.0161858276,
0.0104077989,
0.0103622172,
-0.0120651992,
0.0166574232,
0.0129169924,
-0.040961735,
0.0074511464,
-0.0102138976,
0.0268865377,
0.049271144,
-0.0196535401,
0.0231613033,
-0.0101195294,
-0.075317204,
-0.0131167844,
-0.0052494169,
-0.0533510931,
0.0234383736,
-0.0108230859,
0.064747341,
0.033035934,
0.0129672932,
0.0226817299,
0.0630776957,
0.0262302719,
0.021610681,
-0.0111054014,
-0.0164345354,
-0.0012654052,
0.0153720444,
-0.0153989932,
0.0087458352,
-0.0088488907,
0.0387899987,
-0.0502167121,
0.009864687,
-0.0249851719,
2.58e-7,
0.0717639029,
0.0640180111,
-0.014508754,
0.0061258986,
0.0048129987,
0.0158698354,
0.0373571962,
0.0350056514,
-0.0348126553,
-0.0264678951,
0.0225304216,
0.0240829699,
0.0672444254,
0.0420486853,
-0.012192118,
-0.0523936525,
-0.0710776076,
0.0325033702,
0.0010436516,
-0.0033172171,
0.0106265955,
0.1021783724,
0.0436145402,
0.0109723071,
-0.0265933275,
-0.0116579682,
0.0459597446,
-0.072600089,
-0.0007297975,
0.0181237254,
0.0169733874,
0.0043775076,
0.0488591827,
0.0168581177,
-0.00859698,
0.0264165569,
0.0313497111,
-0.0040798471,
0.0104378983,
0.0632085279,
-0.0306561552,
-0.0351965316,
0.011832485,
-0.0568549521,
0.0581619143,
-0.0415342487,
-0.0333636142,
-0.0477325879,
-0.0332114883,
0.0285523981,
0.1126722991,
-0.0126076099,
-0.0150988847,
-0.0157013051,
0.0291931313,
0.0302029699,
-0.0061163371,
-0.0612784214,
0.033591859,
0.0279179215,
-0.0502917208,
-0.0434225015,
0.0435375758,
-0.0040559899,
0.0465507135,
-0.0376416855,
0.0129799033,
2.628255217e-34,
0.0505614541,
0.0286270641,
0.0249829162,
-0.0055910517,
0.0445895568,
-0.0276113786,
0.0494277775,
-0.0287222806,
0.0454268605,
-0.0802834779,
0.0130560827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12159v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12159v1 | Exploring the Impact of a Transformer's Latent Space Geometry on Downstream Task Performance | 2024-06-18T00:17:30 | 2024-06-18T00:17:30 | Anna C. Marbut, John W. Chandler, Travis J. Wheeler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | It is generally thought that transformer-based large language models benefit
from pre-training by learning generic linguistic knowledge that can be focused
on a specific task during fine-tuning. However, we propose that much of the
benefit from pre-training may be captured by geometric characteristics of the
latent space representations, divorced from any specific linguistic knowledge.
In this work we explore the relationship between GLUE benchmarking task
performance and a variety of measures applied to the latent space resulting
from BERT-type contextual language models. We find that there is a strong
linear relationship between a measure of quantized cell density and average
GLUE performance and that these measures may be predictive of otherwise
surprising GLUE performance for several non-standard BERT-type models from the
literature. These results may be suggestive of a strategy for decreasing
pre-training requirements, wherein model initialization can be informed by the
geometric characteristics of the model's latent space. | [
0.0348023511,
0.036749471,
-0.014257432,
0.0184460618,
-0.0418159664,
0.0215418059,
0.0422503501,
-0.023283232,
-0.0377139822,
-0.0191525184,
-0.0530896969,
-0.0715856031,
0.0286430158,
0.0080547389,
0.06176503,
-0.049544204,
0.0196296722,
-0.0281870849,
-0.0213497989,
-0.0102802617,
-0.0247775037,
-0.0243409406,
-0.0024340842,
0.0468303859,
-0.0420536548,
-0.00988774,
-0.006052352,
-0.0128354272,
0.000372525,
-0.0149549302,
0.0027622632,
0.0674933195,
0.017500259,
0.0257079434,
0.0000018056,
-0.0325243063,
-0.0042733601,
0.0069459043,
0.0004760779,
0.0470953621,
-0.0134695536,
-0.0692224354,
-0.0377462544,
0.0120426929,
-0.0197485611,
-0.01137044,
0.0545058474,
0.0352298804,
0.0022692713,
0.0472568646,
-0.0350232981,
-0.0270842388,
0.0547945499,
-0.0230520498,
0.0211702082,
-0.0225804839,
0.0273734313,
0.0359074213,
-0.0159127545,
-0.0214369837,
-0.0617564507,
0.0598541424,
0.0254864451,
0.0182212722,
-0.0076159621,
0.0664239749,
-0.0652975067,
-0.0101132104,
-0.0217244811,
0.0496438183,
-0.0678818226,
-0.0429708548,
-0.0083506312,
-0.0056165941,
-0.0134285269,
0.0522709303,
-0.0470407754,
0.0130242603,
0.0072836229,
-0.0019051126,
0.0119160889,
-0.0178069994,
0.0245769974,
-0.0296849553,
-0.0890589505,
0.025801817,
0.041717004,
-0.0560919717,
-0.0132465465,
0.0133377016,
-0.0843335912,
-0.0406831503,
-0.0037819084,
0.0157699622,
0.0028925224,
0.0272621475,
-0.0167936645,
-0.0439825915,
-0.0050727315,
-0.0402326211,
0.0264804736,
0.0477072932,
0.0134757636,
0.0456454232,
-0.0569913834,
0.1026460081,
-0.0278451107,
0.0594000146,
-0.0329388678,
-0.0187089257,
-0.0124049708,
-0.0111734299,
-0.0706805885,
0.0200015754,
-0.0118249822,
-0.0556696281,
-0.0173733458,
0.0597769469,
0.0246803146,
-0.0281264335,
0.051665511,
0.0086826673,
-0.0347859561,
0.0061530848,
0.0190352462,
0.0078805014,
-0.0030628599,
0.0112708267,
-0.0299212802,
-0.0481841527,
-0.0170614365,
0.0219538286,
0.0119690662,
-0.0597131997,
0.0036389933,
0.0213744156,
0.0046295314,
-0.0704187155,
-0.0165825076,
0.0541183464,
-0.0683863685,
-0.0384029634,
0.0460277945,
-0.0374133959,
0.0040344284,
0.0416103601,
-0.0099480059,
-0.0045046587,
-0.024907941,
-0.0140802879,
-0.0172395129,
0.0622094832,
0.0253379811,
0.0074820765,
0.0109815588,
-0.0211531036,
0.006566966,
0.0469218604,
0.0408672243,
0.0346404873,
0.0081640538,
-0.025463149,
-0.0187163856,
0.0451097935,
0.0122232512,
-0.014202524,
-0.046145577,
0.0029964694,
0.0031618299,
0.0271308515,
0.0309207384,
0.065249294,
-0.0418205224,
-0.0014159031,
0.0403737314,
0.1128659844,
0.0761914328,
0.0082813501,
0.0320022106,
0.0110270362,
0.0120730558,
0.0159027949,
-0.0508492179,
0.0205645245,
0.0313637778,
0.0193536729,
-0.0066660894,
0.0466656834,
-0.0314534418,
0.0126630692,
-0.0213834178,
-0.0122671491,
-0.0296976734,
-0.0454258099,
0.0541282892,
0.0056011407,
-0.0519852079,
0.1055998653,
0.0045301537,
-0.0524079315,
-0.0233013835,
-0.0236357823,
-0.0123186195,
0.009340358,
0.0170155149,
-0.0094884755,
-0.0605223328,
0.039966736,
0.0114074964,
0.0374354012,
0.0069780028,
-0.0000187205,
-0.0108287446,
-0.0332703143,
-0.0371168219,
0.0130945612,
0.0180317778,
0.0123024359,
0.041469492,
-0.0196998026,
-0.0189673528,
-0.0520117208,
0.0357499272,
0.048930712,
-0.0164102986,
-0.0005639223,
-0.0249351654,
0.0268694293,
0.0222438611,
0.0054359646,
-0.0300997831,
0.0177134983,
0.0495309755,
-0.0429201946,
-0.0032314665,
0.0453515202,
-0.080209814,
-0.0344786197,
0.012847486,
0.0024587912,
0.0176025033,
-0.0136357797,
0.0131033203,
-0.0323235393,
0.0241989922,
-0.0485486016,
0.0981799364,
-0.0322350226,
0.045754604,
-0.0364227965,
-0.0096060671,
-0.0507481061,
0.066101104,
-0.0331838839,
0.0343947932,
0.0316821188,
0.0481511205,
0.0347510725,
0.0118800057,
-0.0244622324,
-0.0092802737,
-0.0048836255,
0.0250589494,
0.0120997401,
-0.0291655157,
-0.0164341442,
-0.0716546327,
-0.0598462559,
-0.0053899097,
-0.0558616631,
0.0300178975,
0.0312039442,
0.0088914866,
0.0009313539,
0.0104515534,
-0.005640585,
-0.0135245454,
-0.0065691792,
0.0204584599,
0.0177268162,
-0.0007636831,
-0.0119501557,
-0.0334561504,
-0.0359006301,
-0.0149462018,
0.0574612506,
0.0149778007,
-0.0272343196,
-0.0313128866,
0.0115004033,
0.0333073623,
0.0258223265,
-0.0229779072,
-0.0398397036,
0.0464059226,
-0.0335873738,
0.1053698659,
0.0741069764,
0.0182201993,
0.0392668061,
0.0236228518,
-0.0091948565,
-0.0291386619,
-0.0070140515,
-0.0605351627,
-0.007448622,
-0.0687757954,
-0.0079708993,
0.0221360438,
0.0862251371,
-0.0247916784,
-0.0006705243,
-0.0955627859,
0.0030863688,
-0.0211172532,
-0.0067044264,
0.0238502882,
0.0082204901,
-0.0470385179,
0.0302097686,
-0.029764438,
-0.0323171094,
0.0391277671,
-0.0464492105,
-0.0038508074,
-0.0130985687,
0.0179886725,
-0.0474678315,
0.0477621555,
0.0266657881,
0.0087809023,
-0.0207761284,
-0.0484802052,
-0.043395631,
0.0296271201,
-0.0105352225,
-0.0085000452,
0.0481617562,
-0.0350512713,
0.0238986872,
0.0062032901,
-0.0414753594,
-0.0294525437,
-0.0146521032,
0.0115993721,
0.0198251288,
0.0448255725,
-0.0584747456,
-0.0538596548,
0.0472769886,
0.0173272137,
0.0498239957,
-0.010897249,
-0.0141187971,
-0.0232174341,
0.0542241633,
0.02603212,
0.0603088029,
0.0205397289,
-0.0302362163,
-0.0336461142,
0.0187204443,
0.0115514575,
0.005542316,
-0.0491209626,
0.0220896807,
0.0489732698,
-0.0101051778,
-0.0487392917,
-0.0029889152,
0.0455379412,
-0.0187826026,
-0.0162662808,
0.1143418476,
0.0431759879,
0.0030922536,
0.007769132,
0.003420301,
0.053417597,
0.0063328948,
0.0085617565,
-0.0499944277,
-0.004521348,
-0.0189079884,
-0.0111236097,
0.0343861952,
-0.016875824,
0.0089443121,
-0.0883340612,
0.0110180192,
-0.0272890534,
-0.0514330044,
-0.0248213876,
-0.0566996485,
-0.0061889184,
-0.036028225,
0.0494049042,
0.0009381722,
-0.0537314601,
-0.0006836374,
0.0447714888,
-0.0130984001,
-0.0772487894,
-0.0067170025,
-0.0592557378,
0.0502057672,
0.0288175792,
0.0169534553,
-0.0183279105,
-0.0572819114,
0.0066346959,
-0.0040667071,
0.0315001942,
-0.0103463493,
0.0303553361,
0.0110293012,
-0.0126231145,
-0.0092704101,
-0.0137264309,
-0.0361198299,
-0.020901965,
-0.0494816639,
0.0489722006,
-0.0157788768,
0.0044294368,
-0.0008070254,
-0.0107980967,
-0.0308749843,
0.0763370469,
0.0275687631,
-0.0363492295,
-0.0625806302,
-0.0098527316,
0.0425599739,
-0.0157148242,
-0.0224940535,
-0.0028087781,
-0.0218026359,
-0.0365872495,
-0.0431752503,
-0.0058132536,
0.0523552001,
0.0607859232,
-0.0015259275,
-0.0190340169,
-0.0048675863,
-0.0086143557,
-0.0535488091,
0.0397948995,
0.0248754323,
0.0270972159,
-0.0682344139,
0.0236113779,
0.0463266857,
-0.0166866127,
-0.0358459651,
-0.0462388583,
-0.0546797998,
-0.0635115281,
0.0357839316,
0.0138538936,
0.0231780522,
0.0477816872,
0.0115216672,
-0.0357951634,
0.0365841538,
0.0305105839,
-0.0277578048,
0.0386542305,
0.0351404436,
-0.020082023,
-0.003608424,
0.011556033,
-0.0378637463,
0.0148763685,
0.012658719,
0.0664443746,
-0.0499442294,
-0.0368360691,
0.0063643823,
-0.0373913385,
0.0727905333,
0.0060706246,
0.0234018732,
-0.0182177965,
0.0244130641,
-0.0118366228,
0.0468627289,
-0.0310479347,
-0.0231765527,
0.0408391841,
0.0287676584,
-0.0170172993,
0.0508711413,
-0.0177608952,
0.0344800428,
-0.0357073136,
0.0156669673,
-0.0018462666,
-0.0085955318,
0.0487081632,
0.0376096033,
-0.0120274629,
-0.0096876146,
0.0104999235,
0.0217253249,
-0.0213432778,
0.029037673,
0.0187174436,
0.0067806146,
-0.0119152237,
0.0379338749,
-0.1022662669,
0.0074262302,
-0.0385772809,
0.0181355271,
0.034962099,
-0.0376460329,
0.079341501,
-0.0447762348,
-0.0155200493,
0.006376544,
-0.0256991088,
0.0267903134,
0.0083242711,
0.0452983715,
0.0254537631,
0.002701564,
-0.0195880327,
0.0749519467,
0.0178326648,
0.0271346364,
-0.0296220798,
0.0077087991,
-0.0215422399,
-0.0194632933,
0.020345334,
0.0057653608,
-0.0310936626,
0.0212436039,
-0.0692702681,
-0.0531843118,
0.0226924978,
0.0320575424,
-0.012209842,
-0.0150837358,
0.0273453854,
0.0744497478,
0.0058998223,
-0.0072005792,
-0.0178560019,
-0.0262430441,
0.010452426,
0.0086300364,
-0.019595772,
-5.989837994e-33,
-0.0186280105,
-0.0112025226,
0.0125801386,
0.0323646516,
0.0027584427,
0.0365835242,
-0.0345186554,
0.0162288547,
-0.0256202221,
-0.0008983018,
-0.0229068305,
0.0145091936,
0.0157496724,
0.0335177593,
-0.0243981555,
0.0378816649,
0.0695278049,
-0.0070905103,
-0.0057217455,
-0.0064319582,
-0.0123226549,
0.0292653143,
0.0056878617,
-0.028912399,
-0.0148011399,
0.0101641966,
0.0350085609,
0.0207226481,
0.0268269069,
0.0660544559,
-0.0316490754,
0.0158314221,
0.0148445619,
-0.0252391398,
-0.0271310732,
0.0256748684,
-0.1127470434,
-0.0289744064,
0.0188679881,
0.0042845514,
-0.0342883132,
-0.0133770425,
0.0268686675,
-0.0169643965,
-0.0187238306,
-0.0291401073,
0.0328081585,
-0.0051226025,
-0.0532676503,
-0.0430473387,
-0.0754930899,
0.0234189052,
0.0067300387,
0.0139354998,
0.0552252196,
-0.0197770633,
0.016786024,
0.0350673944,
-0.0420760363,
0.0092891129,
-0.0050708051,
0.0414425693,
0.0426053479,
0.0629494488,
0.0069455341,
0.0428402014,
0.0171138626,
-0.0078147622,
-0.0197633393,
-0.0320155434,
0.0727399066,
0.0289347358,
0.0457857735,
-0.0149200894,
0.0495025292,
0.0128312586,
-0.0528559349,
-0.002541424,
0.0121114124,
0.0279975608,
0.0132408878,
0.0299808886,
-0.0189225879,
-0.0048905551,
-0.0350359604,
0.0106089562,
-0.0220320653,
-0.0141763622,
0.0182944518,
0.0160625353,
-0.0087462263,
0.0246699974,
0.0091143949,
-0.0202693678,
-0.013785216,
-0.0005987234,
-0.003801306,
0.0336027443,
-0.0234817453,
0.0627931952,
-0.0804284438,
-0.0266550705,
0.0307660047,
0.0410838425,
0.0230167657,
0.0053712847,
0.0371061973,
0.0502395518,
-0.0729487091,
-0.0279164743,
-0.0271762069,
-0.0332117416,
-0.0122772297,
0.0368775278,
0.0422645099,
0.0059302552,
0.0015556118,
0.0059648417,
-0.0012733025,
0.0045019016,
-0.0071185958,
0.0135537796,
0.0087350057,
0.0231613759,
-0.0364047438,
-0.033199206,
-0.0365619659,
0.0565022267,
0.0754625201,
-0.0777239949,
-0.0336369723,
0.0116960118,
2.555e-7,
0.0853697062,
0.0597198606,
0.0534507707,
-0.0091671515,
0.019726038,
-0.0158096459,
-0.0358289704,
0.0012504761,
0.0117237782,
0.011885006,
-0.0048697591,
0.0162129644,
0.0243089087,
-0.0135591021,
-0.0737453401,
0.0240281988,
-0.0796194971,
-0.008915524,
-0.0401770771,
0.0458879806,
0.0493304394,
0.1022155434,
-0.0385954492,
-0.0288872067,
-0.0229465254,
-0.0360044651,
0.0557439886,
-0.0243894886,
0.0437947363,
0.0458972715,
0.0081841433,
0.0258735139,
-0.0115401028,
0.0273377467,
-0.0125404065,
0.017359728,
0.0124946972,
0.0437597111,
-0.0075125862,
-0.0318944529,
0.0260954797,
-0.0357025526,
-0.0289093815,
-0.0633988231,
0.070029825,
-0.1284032464,
-0.0242727175,
0.0060314462,
-0.0143406689,
0.0392172039,
-0.0031432211,
-0.0017489218,
-0.0093460251,
-0.0073992959,
0.0490161702,
-0.0058166771,
-0.0000878254,
-0.0868306383,
-0.0192670804,
0.0315943994,
-0.0374652594,
-0.0470106341,
-0.0510239862,
-0.0274533667,
0.0557433031,
-0.021361785,
-0.016892815,
2.692510907e-34,
0.0193888247,
0.0044044093,
0.0456010588,
0.0158286691,
-0.0071433242,
-0.0436369106,
0.032416299,
0.0133879967,
-0.0145016294,
-0.1178312674,
-0.0174081307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12158v1 | LLMs Are Prone to Fallacies in Causal Inference | 2024-06-18T00:14:07 | 2024-06-18T00:14:07 | Nitish Joshi, Abulhair Saparov, Yixin Wang, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent work shows that causal facts can be effectively extracted from LLMs
through prompting, facilitating the creation of causal graphs for causal
inference tasks. However, it is unclear if this success is limited to
explicitly-mentioned causal facts in the pretraining data which the model can
memorize. Thus, this work investigates: Can LLMs infer causal relations from
other relational data in text? To disentangle the role of memorized causal
facts vs inferred causal relations, we finetune LLMs on synthetic data
containing temporal, spatial and counterfactual relations, and measure whether
the LLM can then infer causal relations. We find that: (a) LLMs are susceptible
to inferring causal relations from the order of two entity mentions in text
(e.g. X mentioned before Y implies X causes Y); (b) if the order is randomized,
LLMs still suffer from the post hoc fallacy, i.e. X occurs before Y (temporal
relation) implies X causes Y. We also find that while LLMs can correctly deduce
the absence of causal relations from temporal and spatial relations, they have
difficulty inferring causal relations from counterfactuals, questioning their
understanding of causality. | [
0.0051862779,
0.0229839608,
-0.0342074856,
0.0315865688,
-0.0434094854,
0.0323117338,
0.0010530242,
-0.0034447704,
0.0467608199,
-0.0736187771,
0.0571605712,
0.020253744,
-0.0040654112,
-0.0424700007,
0.0521244071,
-0.0292345714,
0.0493062176,
-0.0215408262,
-0.008512958,
-0.0127769671,
-0.0548761003,
-0.0192375053,
-0.0378121473,
-0.0136945704,
-0.0440502875,
0.0152512472,
-0.007170998,
-0.005851096,
0.0173106715,
-0.0674490705,
-0.0252418201,
-0.0000303246,
0.0167878214,
-0.0073059569,
0.0000018391,
-0.0363966711,
0.0140944384,
-0.035430871,
-0.0222819205,
-0.0112106716,
-0.0660333335,
-0.0007225173,
0.0407327041,
-0.0373911336,
-0.0350028761,
0.0046860706,
0.006789112,
0.0521635488,
-0.0149539188,
0.0828299224,
-0.0006623085,
-0.0431476571,
-0.002215368,
0.0018939145,
0.0746002272,
0.0136061609,
0.030085735,
0.000818457,
0.0062612067,
0.0082313651,
-0.0264608152,
-0.0003030015,
0.0431417972,
0.052561868,
0.0351241305,
0.0414758809,
0.0412054807,
0.0046148351,
0.0270049907,
0.075083293,
0.0941747651,
-0.0384173468,
0.0191643536,
-0.0115398308,
0.0363739729,
0.0963497758,
-0.0466834642,
0.0287598614,
-0.0314721763,
0.0146328863,
0.0285279229,
0.0050176303,
0.0591253713,
0.0157793425,
-0.0122860465,
0.0803169608,
-0.0009364542,
-0.0492944606,
-0.0204001106,
0.0461480841,
0.0558895841,
-0.0347573496,
-0.0237964392,
0.0247529186,
-0.0153561188,
0.0342539474,
0.0185399074,
0.04600491,
-0.0011170541,
-0.0322572812,
0.0271026418,
0.0144986203,
-0.0366248675,
0.0151203386,
-0.0564499721,
0.0089948587,
-0.0549981557,
0.0597572364,
0.0126356296,
0.0417041481,
-0.0216372199,
-0.0158632789,
0.0523930117,
0.032951612,
0.0224443264,
0.0416753814,
-0.0230742972,
0.0179550517,
-0.0160605926,
-0.0048160837,
-0.038647294,
0.008722241,
0.0056221024,
-0.0055133137,
-0.0958806649,
-0.0150543777,
-0.0504020564,
0.0800294727,
-0.0550133958,
-0.0288749598,
-0.0286177006,
0.0073825368,
0.0054715266,
-0.0116144205,
-0.0078477338,
0.1149403304,
0.0342874154,
-0.0101730246,
-0.0856070071,
-0.0370237492,
0.0237022005,
-0.0227043871,
0.0581495129,
-0.036551699,
0.0004487968,
0.047056362,
-0.0156154558,
-0.0133274132,
0.0074535059,
-0.015889788,
-0.0748316124,
0.0295943804,
0.005896294,
0.0272568949,
-0.0025264851,
0.0096371993,
0.0140009038,
0.0379115306,
0.0284129381,
0.0318323448,
-0.0213726331,
0.0230842344,
0.0140382871,
0.0105801998,
0.0376288593,
0.0251766685,
-0.0476982184,
-0.0490507036,
-0.0269390382,
0.0153647764,
0.0439079702,
0.0072982023,
-0.0290092677,
0.0009678073,
0.0533246361,
0.0041217632,
-0.010318052,
-0.0266050138,
0.0750548169,
-0.0667081997,
-0.0060446812,
0.0711137056,
-0.0887984484,
0.0450348668,
-0.024385361,
0.008347109,
-0.007123529,
-0.0154782608,
-0.0119214822,
-0.0435686409,
-0.0232484285,
-0.0069314209,
-0.0463729352,
0.0006072516,
0.0575603507,
0.0225570016,
-0.0357461795,
0.0552807748,
0.0112186885,
-0.0100395298,
-0.0034298983,
0.023128001,
0.0121261608,
0.0564525835,
0.0242234878,
-0.0188630689,
-0.0319541581,
-0.0070293481,
0.0334983468,
0.0073255855,
0.0460527651,
-0.0064348639,
-0.0163740125,
-0.0007659905,
-0.0326829553,
0.0005950775,
0.0357908197,
0.0270903576,
0.0204309076,
-0.0243506934,
0.0021037071,
0.0169300549,
0.0259510837,
0.0587068386,
-0.0326191075,
-0.0314157568,
-0.0620475821,
0.0289569348,
0.0355586223,
-0.0014125459,
0.011657441,
0.009647619,
0.0499940254,
-0.0026644154,
-0.0155000621,
0.0692968145,
-0.0504782386,
-0.0383975171,
-0.0187461302,
-0.0462395698,
-0.0503111519,
-0.0064546941,
-0.0400242954,
-0.0270158052,
0.055171527,
-0.0033906614,
0.0327572599,
0.016847074,
-0.0117350994,
0.0380614884,
-0.0477277301,
-0.0173295476,
0.0738592818,
-0.0072791181,
0.035716217,
0.0027515765,
0.0297297258,
-0.0130222877,
-0.0308919139,
0.0407395847,
-0.0505894274,
0.0057372712,
-0.0544471182,
-0.0166605301,
-0.0434418917,
-0.063520208,
0.0059492216,
-0.0271459557,
-0.0040303473,
0.0067194225,
0.0064349277,
0.0013073938,
-0.0439209677,
-0.0283842795,
-0.0439868607,
0.0116614625,
0.0046323012,
0.0048145475,
0.0563226528,
0.056265641,
-0.0610558875,
0.0302296095,
-0.0313217491,
0.0317849927,
-0.0835333839,
0.0377595834,
0.050547719,
-0.0512773767,
-0.0298255552,
0.0154275894,
-0.0096475407,
-0.0115566021,
-0.0290598758,
0.0079291603,
0.0331444629,
-0.018145442,
0.0341404453,
0.0674047023,
-0.01275515,
0.0269393567,
0.0521873683,
-0.0322343521,
-0.0634808242,
-0.0157946423,
-0.0574516878,
0.0244372804,
-0.0083664292,
-0.0705373511,
-0.0605114661,
0.0614496097,
0.0328684151,
-0.0058936267,
0.009382409,
0.0175278299,
0.008908473,
-0.0030881318,
-0.0082684318,
-0.0272523537,
-0.0242633075,
0.0299402196,
-0.0310625155,
-0.0810279474,
0.0272686947,
0.0215385314,
0.0241371244,
0.0331260674,
0.0273818504,
-0.0218810868,
0.052918829,
0.0537628084,
-0.0378325433,
0.0083813621,
-0.0262217261,
-0.0593818463,
-0.0108174961,
0.0270282459,
0.0430464186,
0.0046538659,
-0.0790899917,
0.0227070022,
-0.0005027279,
-0.0128472429,
-0.0687591806,
-0.0192852747,
-0.0280161053,
-0.0283195674,
-0.0428425893,
0.0196190644,
-0.0068217893,
-0.028938381,
0.0469084047,
-0.0178555585,
-0.02354398,
-0.00607447,
-0.0285729878,
-0.0035691999,
0.006569366,
-0.00252588,
0.021719804,
-0.0325969458,
-0.012116028,
-0.0045082076,
-0.0299104564,
-0.0071173697,
-0.0397035368,
0.0363008417,
-0.0360493623,
-0.0059710369,
0.0013421603,
0.0285137333,
0.0096165016,
-0.0172571912,
0.0074257422,
0.0667013079,
0.0178108364,
0.0191578362,
0.0097978618,
0.0210709292,
-0.0194835644,
0.0392744765,
-0.0507575348,
-0.0959990025,
-0.0013816213,
-0.0023020431,
-0.0499911793,
-0.0355923288,
-0.0387528725,
0.0071541886,
-0.0824759826,
0.022328943,
0.021698419,
-0.0212381706,
0.025649352,
-0.0615843721,
-0.0204674955,
0.0137932813,
-0.0569994748,
-0.0166260768,
-0.0187608823,
0.0416496396,
0.0210129544,
-0.0051574912,
-0.0198292583,
-0.034988597,
-0.0019575511,
0.0421625823,
-0.0140806381,
0.0136083188,
-0.0241273567,
-0.007382114,
0.0348355025,
0.0385944284,
0.021698935,
-0.0188538916,
0.0330372453,
0.0134834787,
0.0032575,
-0.0362174101,
-0.0088855103,
0.003966684,
-0.0434265956,
0.0186818969,
0.0845598131,
-0.0411485322,
-0.0274784565,
-0.0095670633,
0.0389884301,
-0.0291500986,
0.0589417927,
0.030193055,
0.0557517633,
-0.0228393301,
-0.0167751648,
-0.0225966163,
-0.0340847149,
-0.0473975874,
0.0066255527,
-0.0128072901,
0.0164980534,
-0.0490979217,
-0.0787531286,
-0.0227019303,
-0.0016040555,
0.019800866,
0.0228671301,
0.0185003988,
-0.0530616194,
-0.0368986242,
0.0585736968,
-0.0337226875,
-0.0242747348,
0.0188494902,
-0.037577305,
0.0186952483,
-0.0315871201,
-0.0002204615,
0.0171842929,
-0.0691749901,
-0.0692545474,
0.00614502,
0.0452424139,
0.0256348718,
0.0533084981,
0.0257202815,
0.0023738581,
0.012733995,
0.0302554592,
-0.0389417224,
0.0457278974,
0.0206449591,
0.0172120277,
-0.0048513659,
-0.0020740316,
-0.0300328173,
0.0231570583,
0.0295278057,
-0.0049555451,
-0.0576909035,
0.0095900334,
0.0051748259,
-0.0016047735,
0.0980334729,
-0.0015275055,
-0.0032810527,
-0.0294343084,
0.0142777981,
-0.0273828749,
-0.0193609912,
0.0276909582,
0.0260539353,
0.0125008933,
0.0668101385,
-0.0371950865,
-0.0642160401,
-0.0178503506,
0.0515794232,
0.0268338919,
0.0042458782,
0.0261619315,
0.0068657068,
0.0199476443,
0.0122567331,
-0.0095970454,
0.035850808,
-0.0106021119,
0.0274520181,
0.0192492567,
0.0253076348,
0.0429228321,
0.0306893978,
-0.0404047258,
-0.0740141794,
-0.1164112985,
0.0065605463,
0.0390428416,
0.0133155622,
0.0823873356,
-0.0442483798,
0.0211377628,
-0.0398874544,
0.034291096,
0.0313178562,
0.0348931178,
0.010630453,
0.0115707675,
0.0540868416,
0.011377017,
-0.0236676335,
0.033949811,
0.0382993929,
0.0303187799,
0.1010770053,
-0.0075864471,
-0.0013248211,
-0.0142912315,
-0.0839535296,
-0.0004747655,
-0.0229034983,
-0.010086108,
-0.0092847766,
-0.0743562728,
-0.0422266759,
0.0202810187,
-0.000020892,
0.0136694564,
-0.0273461863,
-0.0057175863,
0.0029294905,
0.0079907682,
-0.023183668,
0.0142827546,
0.0563137643,
0.0000477441,
-0.0217915401,
-0.0430448242,
-6.291810738e-33,
-0.0490764417,
-0.0812146813,
0.0513986647,
0.0109327165,
0.0040069018,
0.0130361505,
-0.0395237915,
-0.0011874854,
-0.0026499254,
0.013046911,
0.0210308228,
0.0148320263,
0.0321633406,
-0.0317750499,
0.0363228805,
-0.0354228429,
0.0075311717,
0.0027202533,
0.0052270941,
-0.0242018327,
0.0442868471,
0.0253416244,
0.0469443128,
-0.0663389936,
0.0640747175,
-0.0304430332,
0.0107459193,
-0.0012631079,
-0.081311278,
0.0028818585,
-0.0017089951,
-0.007878433,
0.0489318781,
-0.0004837502,
-0.0215878244,
0.0236040466,
-0.0516748019,
-0.095998913,
0.075893335,
0.0011091777,
-0.0250954945,
-0.0542710051,
0.0185879078,
-0.0076192506,
-0.0182407182,
0.0223090053,
0.0544979498,
-0.0157561898,
-0.0257005002,
-0.0033470471,
-0.0700904503,
0.0000579631,
-0.00195939,
0.0277334023,
-0.0139509533,
-0.0161361061,
0.0129471747,
0.0169292316,
-0.0149194784,
0.0431249626,
0.0095466971,
-0.0185147673,
0.0172339622,
0.0290310234,
0.0094491234,
0.0727344528,
0.0032946244,
0.0191307534,
-0.0714078918,
0.0072095306,
0.0120443031,
0.0235313959,
0.0208803918,
0.0557384789,
0.0131443255,
0.0201759022,
-0.0946329981,
-0.015416217,
0.0143630337,
-0.0007374397,
-0.0164925922,
-0.0202643611,
-0.0107534695,
-0.0243663117,
-0.0358873457,
-0.0026601267,
-0.0116570806,
-0.0188780092,
0.0210387167,
0.0066433777,
0.0643832162,
0.0002649975,
-0.0014148176,
0.0096779084,
-0.0181555524,
0.0158409756,
0.0000753576,
-0.0125175975,
-0.0107384948,
-0.0135192787,
-0.0737510547,
-0.0095829368,
0.0043957494,
0.0230730195,
0.061214745,
0.0340017453,
0.0552759171,
-0.0336958393,
-0.0108518666,
-0.0391969867,
-0.0381684639,
-0.0518890992,
0.0219525117,
-0.0786756352,
0.0720131248,
0.0381004661,
-0.0115416106,
0.0401944108,
0.0342956595,
0.0116834827,
-0.0034659291,
0.0063193874,
-0.0613536723,
0.0440860428,
-0.0121648619,
-0.0041692643,
-0.0008991078,
0.041926235,
0.0130189834,
-0.054959774,
0.0016088876,
-0.0019414976,
2.554e-7,
0.052094724,
0.051464539,
0.0401182398,
0.0376342274,
0.0177381691,
-0.0219389834,
-0.0290367194,
-0.0260485243,
0.0294485204,
0.0060293712,
0.0242288597,
0.0415525623,
0.0363217704,
0.0151571129,
-0.055489596,
0.0137334252,
-0.0460961163,
-0.0340106003,
-0.016619714,
0.0088952836,
0.0709180161,
-0.0142977294,
0.039626319,
0.0219045095,
-0.0391748138,
-0.0104740793,
0.0618782602,
-0.0521612763,
-0.0001417545,
-0.0437221862,
0.0093122432,
-0.0397712477,
-0.0324107781,
0.0435534455,
0.0305440202,
-0.027063854,
-0.068851091,
-0.0056196842,
0.0121025965,
-0.0430938564,
-0.03853314,
-0.0769883171,
0.0140662985,
-0.0078433622,
0.049613703,
-0.0556476749,
-0.0119755622,
0.0653897747,
-0.0111202924,
0.0192468632,
0.0195873976,
0.0314365514,
0.0214431714,
-0.0143761123,
0.0043223687,
0.0241669416,
0.0053407447,
-0.0782402754,
-0.0311138872,
0.0584003814,
-0.0001073145,
-0.0895431489,
-0.0024861346,
0.0134584624,
0.0504723825,
-0.0214851201,
-0.0407277234,
1.893411684e-34,
-0.0229615886,
0.0080332868,
0.0218105,
-0.0133363158,
0.0116662504,
-0.059101928,
-0.037091881,
0.0455123,
0.025586063,
-0.0604825094,
-0.0000354512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15487v1 | Improving Text-To-Audio Models with Synthetic Captions | 2024-06-18T00:02:15 | 2024-06-18T00:02:15 | Zhifeng Kong, Sang-gil Lee, Deepanway Ghosal, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Rafael Valle, Soujanya Poria, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | It is an open challenge to obtain high quality training data, especially
captions, for text-to-audio models. Although prior methods have leveraged
\textit{text-only language models} to augment and improve captions, such
methods have limitations related to scale and coherence between audio and
captions. In this work, we propose an audio captioning pipeline that uses an
\textit{audio language model} to synthesize accurate and diverse captions for
audio at scale. We leverage this pipeline to produce a dataset of synthetic
captions for AudioSet, named \texttt{AF-AudioSet}, and then evaluate the
benefit of pre-training text-to-audio models on these synthetic captions.
Through systematic evaluations on AudioCaps and MusicCaps, we find leveraging
our pipeline and synthetic captions leads to significant improvements on audio
generation quality, achieving a new \textit{state-of-the-art}. | [
-0.00555528,
0.0589404404,
-0.0129780238,
0.0307307374,
0.0235831514,
-0.0238610469,
0.0367340185,
-0.0235831402,
-0.0343805365,
-0.0201974306,
-0.0514912643,
-0.0056966809,
0.0242652558,
0.0552601628,
0.0148999104,
-0.0937208235,
0.0058562704,
-0.0651696324,
-0.0176734086,
-0.0103772115,
-0.0055970727,
0.0341310836,
-0.0255855583,
0.0305440854,
-0.0201725122,
-0.0080415653,
0.0069737793,
0.0361492746,
0.004801563,
-0.0149876745,
-0.0252332091,
0.0644756928,
0.0382302888,
0.0252640191,
0.0000015224,
0.0055364799,
-0.0028446997,
0.018724395,
0.0481100716,
0.0367511548,
0.0453926399,
-0.0138412295,
-0.0416905023,
0.0350280032,
0.0044650249,
0.0009926633,
0.057789322,
0.0165515039,
0.0727661327,
0.0544183031,
-0.0257577412,
-0.0678445548,
-0.0082836468,
-0.0554573573,
-0.0124894287,
0.018097125,
-0.0373716615,
0.0692636371,
0.0051868018,
0.0006978791,
0.0146522643,
0.0719376877,
0.0010267061,
-0.0060765836,
0.0196023751,
0.0497721136,
-0.0710375533,
-0.0376560576,
-0.0029145086,
0.0979894921,
0.0375968404,
-0.0041330233,
-0.0263246428,
0.018591417,
0.0156557895,
-0.0361472033,
-0.037068706,
0.0202404261,
0.0326802358,
0.026570417,
-0.0557690188,
0.0401075631,
0.0335796699,
-0.033335235,
0.0299248677,
-0.0741088316,
0.0253258385,
0.0185226593,
-0.0170107894,
-0.0124009224,
-0.0575311407,
-0.0258120932,
0.0420679115,
-0.0271087941,
0.019358404,
-0.0247258823,
-0.072269313,
-0.0327040665,
-0.0269205142,
-0.0129867177,
0.0229396205,
0.0137076229,
-0.0538908653,
0.0692601129,
0.0026897085,
0.0059690042,
0.0089473547,
-0.0061771725,
-0.0466224141,
-0.0049834023,
-0.0264674816,
-0.007916417,
-0.0408341959,
0.010455084,
-0.0532923788,
-0.0455309041,
-0.0258403495,
-0.0567453094,
-0.0328146368,
0.0336617008,
0.0065819724,
0.0277125649,
-0.0214864705,
-0.0056472649,
0.0209949091,
0.0195036847,
0.0169981197,
0.0451612212,
-0.0048169284,
-0.0145949824,
-0.0281639714,
0.0182294417,
0.0397587605,
0.0054057622,
0.0342032537,
0.0621061064,
-0.0146309389,
-0.0160483867,
-0.0016948407,
-0.006044101,
-0.0406468809,
-0.0211769305,
-0.0550717451,
-0.05567367,
0.0469699241,
-0.0328632481,
-0.0051402496,
-0.0486043133,
0.0130653726,
0.0203612559,
0.0215620808,
0.0923018977,
-0.0115864137,
0.0518671125,
0.022838736,
0.0043270504,
-0.0172686949,
0.0583269224,
0.0976410285,
0.0151725374,
0.0350486748,
-0.0389417373,
0.0147385495,
0.0638503581,
0.0211134832,
0.0141818048,
-0.0313346162,
-0.0379826315,
-0.010271607,
0.0359120406,
0.0598589778,
0.064972803,
0.0104126995,
0.0064517609,
0.1009623855,
0.0168098453,
0.0090063,
0.0468083583,
0.0402030163,
0.011119551,
-0.0005123475,
-0.0217481758,
-0.0000818798,
0.0354367271,
0.0343441889,
0.0204735678,
0.0591369309,
0.0227685142,
-0.016129991,
-0.0237717945,
-0.0032633871,
-0.0177652668,
-0.040357504,
-0.0216871426,
-0.006982672,
0.0305348542,
-0.0610050187,
0.0512168556,
-0.009828262,
-0.0668273196,
0.0212360378,
-0.0170350522,
-0.0125620496,
0.0558188707,
0.0434135981,
-0.019786533,
0.0169860609,
-0.0313431695,
0.0237592459,
0.0916793272,
0.0416184366,
-0.0154348603,
0.0265173353,
-0.0273846071,
-0.0073239552,
0.000453318,
-0.0095199188,
0.0326540954,
-0.0122720608,
0.0391932577,
0.037185546,
-0.0293194316,
-0.0653075799,
0.0068494668,
0.0103495112,
-0.048177287,
0.0170602091,
0.0039662467,
0.0256386828,
0.0528938249,
-0.0560419336,
0.0215146746,
-0.0067070224,
-0.0091195311,
-0.0114645744,
0.0652604476,
-0.0710384697,
-0.0220769178,
0.0329433158,
-0.0649343431,
0.014927065,
0.0089062909,
0.0041171797,
-0.0514275543,
0.0341876596,
-0.04058595,
0.0156896207,
-0.031577915,
0.0177392922,
0.0082431352,
0.0106323771,
0.028449893,
0.0134608475,
0.0322574377,
-0.0306122564,
0.0200983658,
-0.0095154094,
-0.0021002516,
-0.0334848799,
-0.0326299965,
0.0455165133,
0.0149237616,
0.018915467,
0.0185723603,
0.0148575343,
-0.0410913043,
-0.0264266822,
-0.0572018847,
0.002611862,
-0.0053834016,
-0.0177240148,
-0.0077676717,
-0.0139716817,
0.008881405,
-0.0088883713,
-0.0178383216,
-0.069336839,
0.0211903844,
-0.0129428748,
-0.0288663805,
-0.0091672987,
-0.0463326536,
-0.0305192769,
0.0144030722,
0.0299269967,
0.01118627,
-0.0011729129,
-0.0067962497,
-0.0225859731,
0.0020224168,
0.0070516532,
0.0060878592,
0.0100474954,
0.0004202472,
-0.0146352891,
0.021988634,
0.0293307472,
0.0093919635,
-0.0018135832,
0.0041042641,
0.0574137159,
0.0237219166,
-0.0119484775,
0.021781126,
0.0195447057,
-0.0332581885,
-0.0082969368,
-0.0117831985,
-0.0035219137,
0.0401772298,
0.0192350764,
0.0337553471,
-0.068748869,
0.0073110699,
-0.0355138071,
-0.033763051,
-0.0120245973,
-0.0194769204,
-0.0356572866,
0.0223909914,
-0.0315821469,
-0.0495122671,
0.0208953246,
-0.0782433823,
-0.052468095,
-0.0527832173,
-0.0174771287,
-0.0260729138,
0.0662589297,
-0.0150372433,
0.0287464615,
0.0127635458,
-0.0225559585,
-0.0189368762,
0.0156006971,
0.0254350696,
-0.0695930943,
0.0295267459,
-0.0396921188,
-0.003869616,
-0.0052017407,
-0.0308401659,
-0.0183395911,
-0.0215341244,
-0.0310141332,
-0.0134314541,
-0.036134325,
-0.0231266059,
-0.0304448567,
0.0316239819,
0.0220194012,
0.059113346,
-0.0181726459,
0.0172435958,
-0.0108492952,
0.0473331697,
0.0293862186,
0.0162105374,
-0.0447732173,
-0.0259285476,
0.0563328415,
-0.0059360918,
0.0135560362,
-0.0165409297,
-0.0389051847,
-0.0013558457,
0.0240117777,
0.033778511,
-0.0273743179,
0.0255285092,
0.0437599942,
-0.0375949219,
-0.0024450361,
0.1094618589,
0.0262268223,
-0.004901845,
0.0076904227,
0.0493660234,
0.063196063,
0.0125156213,
-0.0386569276,
-0.0396362916,
-0.0534383059,
0.0160022844,
0.0478168949,
0.0640866756,
0.0425638855,
-0.0291001778,
-0.0896692723,
0.0318898857,
0.0464595705,
-0.0866645798,
-0.0639013574,
-0.0206717104,
-0.0284443609,
-0.0102724535,
0.0338004492,
-0.0057254806,
-0.0188548304,
0.029914353,
0.0289762933,
0.0105211185,
-0.061676681,
-0.0119815376,
-0.0493020602,
0.1000245363,
0.0805923939,
0.0444139168,
-0.0427389592,
0.0097239669,
-0.0217637364,
-0.0184325576,
-0.0081287362,
0.0338332914,
0.0773962736,
-0.0020602013,
-0.0222504176,
0.0608503111,
0.0531757139,
-0.0286034867,
-0.0099330889,
0.0323691815,
0.0082496395,
0.0251576863,
-0.0087086074,
-0.0313802175,
0.0686841384,
0.0087024625,
0.0845048502,
0.0408483334,
-0.0122238025,
0.0335676819,
-0.0096716871,
0.0130450679,
-0.1274635047,
-0.0349643901,
0.0257899556,
-0.0018548935,
-0.0452958196,
-0.0612475537,
-0.0287440512,
0.0167362187,
-0.0035658686,
0.0409524739,
-0.0126145575,
-0.0060451194,
0.0220874213,
-0.053485658,
0.0643953681,
-0.032688003,
0.0201253965,
-0.0422254875,
-0.0656296313,
0.0536626652,
-0.0462068655,
-0.0079055158,
0.0516428612,
-0.0603751913,
-0.0284218807,
-0.0195489265,
0.0174134802,
0.0188396331,
0.0424196757,
0.010440764,
-0.0125272712,
0.0073538837,
0.0334565789,
-0.0148868933,
0.034722317,
0.0410701558,
-0.0068348148,
-0.0160143897,
0.021012703,
-0.0612183511,
0.0462941714,
-0.0207201913,
0.0497371331,
0.0412624925,
-0.0527868941,
-0.0039802608,
-0.0136193093,
-0.0064739804,
-0.044194255,
0.0582994409,
-0.0434044152,
-0.011571873,
-0.0276983082,
0.0114118103,
-0.051755406,
0.0256281756,
0.0453754291,
0.0537125506,
-0.0342528895,
-0.0008876199,
-0.0322889723,
-0.0049649109,
-0.0239136424,
0.0184508786,
0.0361284055,
-0.0654638186,
0.0137639651,
-0.0153014744,
-0.0004451485,
0.0148078017,
0.0084087141,
0.009637122,
0.0037255099,
-0.0104747666,
-0.0047844341,
-0.0229891483,
-0.0103968233,
0.052224122,
-0.0128699727,
0.0312175769,
-0.0539450161,
0.0471686944,
0.0392596684,
-0.0301950909,
0.0686666146,
-0.0107797431,
0.0113036679,
0.0045275828,
0.0240833219,
0.0030481003,
-0.037069574,
0.0152872484,
-0.0166518837,
-0.0006599453,
0.0070892563,
0.0591372214,
-0.0227723904,
0.0294133592,
-0.0102263819,
0.0008986529,
-0.0098188929,
-0.0152098304,
-0.069975771,
-0.0227915701,
-0.0140825985,
0.0273854379,
-0.0303692669,
-0.0732144266,
-0.0182989445,
-0.0145983035,
0.0146673433,
0.0016455168,
0.031797532,
0.0119202277,
-0.0149425194,
0.0320319235,
0.0291467421,
-0.0352027118,
-0.034350194,
-0.0092686033,
-0.0158675462,
-4.593223972e-33,
-0.0535937808,
0.0067043751,
-0.033095289,
-0.0070794169,
-0.0277156048,
-0.0012890901,
-0.053573776,
0.0174724478,
0.0120615205,
-0.0122482618,
0.013214387,
0.0066791773,
0.0209148098,
0.0551940911,
-0.0125153018,
0.0012834705,
0.083028689,
-0.0310111251,
-0.0239343382,
0.033009652,
-0.0064009279,
-0.012271584,
-0.0045450926,
-0.0607176423,
-0.0258298665,
-0.0115197431,
-0.0419557579,
-0.0070494344,
0.0544540137,
0.0521555468,
-0.0003005936,
0.0372041911,
-0.0323653668,
-0.0286989547,
-0.0116400244,
0.0057604779,
-0.0468449332,
0.008029256,
0.0218982454,
0.0328654051,
0.0222295895,
-0.0219397657,
0.018123351,
-0.028682733,
-0.0216142163,
-0.0278245192,
0.0552962758,
-0.0387429409,
0.0146478144,
-0.0467868932,
-0.0480171032,
0.0019260969,
-0.0580150597,
-0.0483279787,
0.0422033817,
0.0410497859,
0.0160323046,
0.0239961073,
-0.0212351382,
0.0584938079,
0.0364406928,
0.0232731979,
0.0715785921,
0.0351611078,
-0.0289364737,
0.0543488935,
0.0014811285,
-0.0457633995,
-0.0424636751,
0.0395599753,
0.001141231,
0.032656081,
0.0403599143,
0.0457429886,
0.0297154058,
-0.013591486,
-0.0028150522,
0.0517461896,
-0.0978463814,
-0.0379748493,
0.0305524152,
0.0394245237,
-0.0338981897,
0.0367714465,
-0.0846577063,
-0.0316836461,
-0.0214445535,
-0.0291169416,
0.0371883474,
-0.0090515576,
-0.019495992,
-0.0081529785,
0.0313778035,
-0.0127955507,
0.0060502281,
-0.0178045407,
-0.0592680313,
0.025120208,
-0.031255763,
0.0118575692,
0.0044277841,
-0.0159305613,
0.1233142018,
0.0302066188,
0.0431691445,
-0.0126984669,
0.0170976333,
0.0551578179,
-0.051857993,
0.0043798843,
-0.0073790159,
0.0112923449,
-0.0269434135,
0.018800851,
0.0016031045,
0.0344644673,
-0.0587817915,
0.0219371505,
-0.016595589,
0.0265923813,
-0.0341064259,
-0.0358937718,
-0.0135256676,
0.0088479137,
-0.0418854915,
0.0423551612,
-0.0013776649,
-0.0274749734,
0.0465185419,
-0.0592769161,
-0.0566245578,
-0.0060396632,
2.111e-7,
-0.0022195054,
-0.0118092773,
0.023593327,
-0.0041266708,
0.0263069328,
0.0410678573,
-0.0543209724,
0.0256063566,
0.0002267508,
-0.0264306627,
0.0436254889,
0.0079780156,
0.0902935266,
0.0203785151,
-0.0782209486,
-0.0279419664,
-0.0726835728,
0.0163133889,
-0.0418809168,
-0.041526068,
0.0491286777,
0.0960620046,
-0.0030667107,
-0.0473104715,
0.006951639,
-0.0620045997,
0.0381107703,
-0.0335906856,
0.000302177,
-0.0341309831,
0.0107370066,
0.0182370897,
-0.0517755076,
-0.0038352655,
-0.0540760159,
0.0051142699,
0.095850274,
0.0405825898,
0.0006199328,
-0.0193253495,
-0.0518527329,
0.0592067353,
-0.0030258037,
-0.002036436,
0.0686170831,
-0.0178699233,
-0.0295842495,
-0.016228741,
-0.054513175,
0.0133207496,
-0.0109459218,
-0.046505738,
-0.0443523005,
0.0044436925,
0.0414434522,
0.0207535196,
-0.0259403419,
-0.0285470504,
-0.0388176739,
0.0005082809,
-0.0343629979,
-0.0260082986,
-0.043419078,
-0.0235617701,
-0.0033988794,
-0.0195242167,
0.015818065,
1.546935528e-34,
0.0349428728,
-0.0590402819,
0.0188348703,
-0.0284181368,
0.0265379697,
0.006546238,
0.026793858,
-0.0207880102,
-0.0051418701,
-0.0446409658,
-0.017954791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12141v1 | A dual task learning approach to fine-tune a multilingual semantic speech encoder for Spoken Language Understanding | 2024-06-17T23:07:53 | 2024-06-17T23:07:53 | Gaëlle Laperrière, Sahar Ghannay, Bassam Jabaian, Yannick Estève | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-Supervised Learning is vastly used to efficiently represent speech for
Spoken Language Understanding, gradually replacing conventional approaches.
Meanwhile, textual SSL models are proposed to encode language-agnostic
semantics. SAMU-XLSR framework employed this semantic information to enrich
multilingual speech representations. A recent study investigated SAMU-XLSR
in-domain semantic enrichment by specializing it on downstream transcriptions,
leading to state-of-the-art results on a challenging SLU task. This study's
interest lies in the loss of multilingual performances and lack of
specific-semantics training induced by such specialization in close languages
without any SLU implication. We also consider SAMU-XLSR's loss of initial
cross-lingual abilities due to a separate SLU fine-tuning. Therefore, this
paper proposes a dual task learning approach to improve SAMU-XLSR semantic
enrichment while considering distant languages for multilingual and language
portability experiments. | [
-0.03143242,
-0.0243970249,
0.0085519711,
0.0481893346,
-0.0097172121,
0.0278654099,
0.0377272852,
-0.0555875003,
-0.0482194386,
-0.0205194764,
-0.0698555708,
0.0077114492,
0.0242764708,
-0.0010345161,
0.0326938219,
-0.0078369118,
0.0704459697,
-0.0489106141,
-0.023675641,
-0.0376015045,
-0.0128913699,
0.0283131078,
-0.0133244023,
-0.0103301937,
0.0220344905,
-0.0058683963,
0.0011596015,
0.0061043478,
-0.0011920199,
-0.0061666477,
-0.0410456657,
0.0090741478,
0.0940041468,
0.0181437917,
0.0000022317,
-0.056163691,
-0.0241097119,
-0.01087006,
-0.0554598719,
-0.0139585342,
0.0067586149,
-0.0236751419,
-0.0020909493,
0.0082096439,
-0.004646406,
-0.0343899094,
0.0467528589,
0.054441832,
0.0470148958,
0.0381008722,
-0.0097403415,
-0.0546464212,
-0.0277472623,
-0.0421219207,
-0.0111626405,
-0.0339279771,
-0.0257099364,
0.0164208468,
-0.0267289709,
-0.054932557,
-0.0242423452,
0.0655900165,
0.0213546474,
0.0051520881,
-0.0159801897,
-0.0037059684,
-0.0042952914,
-0.0182987321,
0.0034292154,
0.0169329904,
-0.036501579,
0.0006524918,
-0.035801053,
0.0025409609,
-0.0157569181,
-0.0183116421,
-0.0547302291,
-0.0083545744,
0.0065529086,
0.0053737354,
0.0411754176,
0.0313587599,
0.028262157,
-0.0277177729,
-0.0135883344,
0.090980716,
0.0018216004,
-0.0306101628,
0.0130401049,
-0.0024589931,
0.00423569,
0.0248423498,
0.0158602893,
-0.0125260232,
-0.0380599201,
0.0326574035,
-0.0011364879,
-0.0514864102,
-0.0227148943,
-0.0306699648,
0.0593217611,
0.0580397658,
-0.0396399386,
0.0273202434,
-0.032294631,
0.0462212786,
0.0285502151,
0.0301398393,
-0.017607389,
-0.0314570405,
-0.0375927165,
0.0026425114,
-0.0272277687,
0.0572561063,
-0.0598151907,
0.0217586681,
-0.0277672708,
0.0408778079,
-0.0079189688,
0.0280028321,
0.0367682502,
-0.0472601876,
-0.0868182331,
0.0066866297,
-0.0029296225,
0.0567719936,
-0.0315686427,
0.0297193844,
-0.0204986781,
-0.0458099693,
-0.0123784216,
0.0294941906,
0.0380483791,
-0.0387076512,
-0.0152240489,
0.0814247876,
-0.0270187166,
-0.007059162,
-0.0669203326,
-0.0115290741,
-0.0221621711,
-0.0459223352,
0.0015281739,
-0.0401366055,
0.0480770841,
-0.0054910523,
-0.0063015968,
-0.046718251,
-0.0106649175,
-0.0283734482,
0.0281677283,
0.0600812621,
0.0000982865,
-0.0199373793,
0.0058513703,
-0.0260011759,
-0.0172032844,
0.1105084717,
-0.020681873,
0.0125850504,
0.0179124065,
-0.0525657162,
-0.0644940287,
0.0417457521,
0.0020964199,
0.014971802,
-0.0082236398,
0.0007657849,
0.0507793538,
-0.0030221459,
0.0443843864,
0.0013177885,
-0.0457706712,
-0.0090943575,
0.0393204093,
0.0521212108,
0.0234513134,
0.0313448012,
0.0457155257,
0.0484551676,
-0.0450735427,
0.0351454392,
-0.0087164361,
0.0437035039,
0.0097800195,
0.0295451842,
-0.00721657,
0.0378061421,
-0.0372320898,
-0.0317781307,
0.0185189452,
-0.0414145254,
0.0091570588,
0.0431447849,
0.0622712523,
0.0326361693,
-0.0402549542,
0.0681283921,
0.056214828,
-0.0764501616,
0.054363206,
-0.0121112047,
0.0012259743,
0.0550170504,
-0.00247201,
-0.0147991423,
-0.039051652,
-0.0577972271,
-0.0340248346,
0.0669673234,
-0.0226177219,
-0.0189030319,
0.0857189894,
-0.059972059,
-0.024136357,
-0.0507438183,
-0.0246810988,
0.0664065853,
-0.0877942368,
-0.0129324608,
0.0213392451,
-0.0423887707,
0.0131761255,
0.000467482,
-0.0647101253,
0.0208477043,
0.0339925326,
0.030684337,
0.0548389927,
0.0330421254,
-0.0240965839,
-0.0006647002,
0.011009207,
-0.0636408851,
0.0022616491,
0.0341287628,
-0.0463854969,
-0.0675689429,
0.0201141089,
-0.0190668385,
-0.0119307386,
0.0445887111,
-0.0083921403,
-0.0620048754,
0.033086706,
-0.0336792022,
0.0167673212,
-0.0749995187,
-0.0088661909,
-0.0133689018,
0.0317029655,
-0.0098314304,
0.0150993168,
0.0340804309,
-0.0155026335,
0.0031647705,
-0.0018116283,
0.0421928242,
-0.0692033693,
-0.0016943885,
0.0270544607,
-0.0192144364,
0.0114466902,
0.0330237634,
-0.0146927796,
0.0085136378,
-0.0199468993,
-0.0831249878,
-0.0193423275,
-0.049770765,
0.0538262725,
0.0206670985,
0.065058805,
-0.0024802701,
-0.0474798121,
-0.0367190093,
-0.0236073229,
-0.0123942001,
0.0085106725,
-0.0021161879,
0.0149503574,
0.0174121391,
0.0030780749,
0.0022903143,
0.0277029052,
0.016546797,
-0.0423415564,
-0.0391998887,
-0.0623431951,
0.0291870311,
-0.0371401347,
-0.0033751079,
0.0172066186,
0.000194024,
-0.0293215811,
0.0219941437,
0.0187102258,
0.0256426409,
0.0012406071,
-0.0034429217,
0.042660743,
-0.0202380791,
-0.0418461151,
0.0329626352,
0.0125204725,
0.0177228861,
-0.0625779182,
0.0563354157,
0.010083681,
0.0557668991,
0.0217167828,
0.019034218,
-0.0469105765,
-0.0587604158,
-0.012003744,
-0.0813261643,
-0.0145578841,
0.0027911968,
-0.0090034222,
0.0204053912,
-0.0104159657,
0.0243134536,
0.0500477143,
-0.0476067439,
-0.0524887443,
-0.1119907051,
-0.0301549695,
-0.031101726,
0.044099737,
-0.0757941082,
0.037456248,
-0.0178483874,
-0.0485598519,
-0.0352826603,
0.0202103965,
0.0297276992,
-0.0018849283,
0.0455840826,
-0.0052580582,
0.0121921813,
-0.0244443081,
-0.0516553335,
-0.0074339719,
-0.0131652886,
-0.0173549484,
-0.0033831305,
-0.005737721,
0.0308571272,
-0.0224345829,
0.015658671,
0.011290947,
0.0351920687,
-0.0099074235,
0.0210143942,
-0.0350537635,
-0.0102608083,
0.0311957262,
0.0135007584,
-0.0146956546,
-0.0360792801,
0.0290355068,
-0.0195188355,
0.020602297,
-0.0511278398,
-0.0055945045,
0.0375783741,
0.0648806095,
-0.0241979193,
-0.0180917513,
0.0228304882,
0.0631992817,
-0.0536559634,
-0.0035705711,
0.136211887,
-0.0192072708,
0.0200181995,
-0.0133623602,
-0.0738653019,
-0.0009939264,
0.0298675187,
0.0209132023,
-0.0380350463,
-0.0442178585,
-0.0024596683,
-0.0076809712,
0.0337005183,
0.0386553183,
-0.0082957195,
-0.0648956895,
0.0359943733,
0.0236224607,
-0.0850573927,
-0.0247676075,
-0.0497678369,
-0.020479532,
-0.0405777246,
0.094871074,
-0.030417962,
-0.0002082754,
-0.0145968674,
0.023741968,
-0.0095220935,
-0.057674557,
0.0242931899,
-0.0064173103,
0.0191073064,
0.0345997848,
0.0295467265,
-0.0142949121,
-0.0407483429,
0.029947184,
-0.0009028743,
0.010195449,
-0.0041973805,
0.0055981474,
0.0004587123,
-0.0244574379,
0.0262465551,
0.0020932616,
-0.0332774371,
0.0231085867,
0.000108468,
0.0652236268,
-0.0448277779,
0.0217743162,
0.052966021,
0.0037224833,
-0.0121324779,
0.0400428399,
0.0222118068,
-0.0381361358,
0.0013289923,
-0.0090676947,
0.0032105185,
-0.040762376,
0.013865822,
0.0387633629,
-0.0038067424,
-0.0694658309,
0.0078343395,
-0.0690850019,
-0.0043138629,
0.0371266156,
-0.0103601748,
0.0479454249,
0.0152853364,
-0.0008184273,
-0.0655842647,
-0.0067498828,
-0.0147178555,
0.0259564314,
-0.0058819721,
0.0084493207,
0.0307840463,
-0.0455993377,
-0.0042040432,
-0.0140303886,
-0.0479374155,
-0.0414395072,
-0.0156210829,
-0.0141745238,
0.0076198075,
0.073133871,
-0.0438590981,
-0.0138674071,
0.0448567197,
0.0004525614,
-0.0793871656,
0.0043450859,
0.0579015538,
-0.0117867626,
-0.0100640757,
0.0515710413,
-0.0416188203,
0.0309086163,
-0.0024141564,
0.0152770597,
0.0160121415,
-0.0220907182,
0.0199207291,
0.0377550051,
0.0547117665,
0.0057590897,
0.0118900742,
-0.0403462648,
0.0436386727,
-0.0266802162,
0.0232674684,
-0.0269411895,
-0.0276788045,
0.0080671934,
-0.0063095042,
0.0362399742,
0.0611635447,
-0.0070627187,
-0.015020988,
-0.0363146141,
0.0476640686,
0.0077505093,
0.0213774145,
-0.0332763158,
0.0276253372,
-0.0312153548,
0.0011040487,
0.0444579087,
0.0137297064,
-0.0132609224,
0.044739183,
-0.0175759774,
0.0554207563,
0.0035592588,
0.0254793037,
-0.0172841642,
-0.0426323377,
0.002257366,
-0.0374244601,
0.0427058525,
-0.001052069,
0.0791469514,
0.0246921983,
0.0108020669,
-0.0351489745,
0.0273443721,
-0.0296193641,
0.0032428559,
0.0280491319,
-0.0291758273,
-0.0279923845,
-0.0050873412,
0.0564651377,
-0.0306546148,
0.043088384,
-0.0202971268,
0.0511991866,
-0.0542967804,
-0.064057216,
-0.0120791476,
0.0259347055,
-0.0267129503,
-0.0125093823,
-0.0139951315,
-0.0764255226,
0.0100887027,
-0.0226966124,
-0.0109596057,
0.0007534066,
0.0435718521,
0.0646758303,
-0.0458952039,
0.0246092137,
-0.0083319182,
-0.058999937,
0.0359539278,
0.006419044,
0.0279278979,
-6.684418504e-33,
-0.0213020779,
0.0559356064,
0.0259038042,
0.0188762248,
0.0142822703,
-0.0063767838,
-0.0450121649,
-0.0128693227,
-0.0170386862,
0.0019045523,
0.0173720829,
-0.0099555477,
0.0324765593,
0.0407835916,
-0.0081736334,
-0.0230360422,
0.0866480693,
0.0121304002,
0.0008698562,
0.0215467662,
0.091643028,
0.041070886,
0.0865332559,
-0.0696994439,
-0.0018728673,
0.0391118601,
0.0450847596,
-0.0027743282,
0.0643814951,
0.021964645,
0.0156085193,
0.0592345484,
0.0073709874,
-0.0909137875,
-0.057927236,
0.0019280325,
-0.0937644839,
-0.0388697051,
0.0425326712,
0.0304632913,
-0.0362667255,
-0.0235113986,
0.0200639591,
0.008180866,
-0.0008896741,
-0.0460479856,
0.0313207619,
0.0017396638,
-0.0299224295,
-0.0657221302,
-0.0664383098,
0.0189119801,
-0.0187555514,
-0.00995869,
0.111433439,
0.0473247208,
-0.0210761894,
-0.0355093479,
0.0162954461,
0.0276008397,
-0.0957606658,
0.0422362685,
0.0795829222,
0.0063283513,
-0.0283179507,
0.0158497952,
0.0051284321,
0.0123883113,
0.0540283918,
-0.009384051,
0.027353514,
-0.0039752396,
-0.0134423217,
0.0292185862,
-0.0129880952,
-0.0414169915,
-0.0715689287,
-0.008133892,
0.0544403158,
0.0204290207,
0.0294620283,
0.0447873622,
0.0147404727,
-0.0314543322,
-0.0699862391,
0.0316518061,
-0.0099941427,
-0.0298146382,
0.0156172318,
-0.0234002285,
0.0116801606,
0.0431286097,
0.0645079911,
0.001125544,
0.0179175381,
0.0039975275,
0.0179842152,
-0.0466795564,
0.0041490127,
0.037129011,
-0.0155749274,
-0.0527065508,
0.019942116,
0.0093929516,
0.0085216127,
-0.0156770665,
0.035605792,
0.018364368,
-0.0273964815,
0.0030916149,
-0.0346033201,
-0.0043196292,
-0.0052716364,
0.0217370354,
0.0387821868,
0.0019071638,
-0.0280364268,
0.0767073631,
-0.0076885466,
-0.0072928644,
-0.0150000304,
-0.0185403153,
0.0121118724,
0.0283873733,
-0.0292138103,
-0.0073182182,
-0.0140147349,
-0.0405333415,
0.0285673346,
-0.0276575945,
-0.012364232,
0.0007520877,
3.055e-7,
-0.0128789926,
0.0219355095,
0.0175003726,
-0.0160612408,
0.0247023311,
0.024239881,
-0.0188919064,
0.0128172124,
-0.009229349,
-0.01398711,
-0.0249224268,
-0.000689333,
0.0550430343,
0.0164422821,
-0.0850914046,
-0.0168098249,
-0.0112948576,
0.0460088998,
-0.0101576569,
0.0437303893,
0.0191241372,
0.0930533335,
-0.0396366715,
0.0000548052,
0.0092790257,
0.0008300795,
0.0494529977,
-0.0058330996,
-0.0290429164,
0.011386524,
-0.0443282425,
0.0210453812,
0.0174661726,
0.0473327786,
-0.0361646563,
0.0550947227,
0.0460660271,
0.0333541371,
-0.010584617,
-0.0416412465,
0.0102294246,
0.026634803,
-0.0167957749,
0.0097410223,
0.0581113957,
-0.0580951944,
-0.0774452388,
0.0075988867,
-0.0503923595,
0.0527124405,
0.0131469676,
0.0049182782,
-0.0115283625,
0.0194163229,
0.0329981484,
-0.0151118198,
-0.0381530225,
-0.0391215719,
0.0040437104,
0.04724719,
-0.0456257872,
-0.014925506,
-0.0085412208,
-0.0058576078,
0.049784027,
-0.0449187942,
0.0054291887,
2.400263037e-34,
0.0388642885,
0.0030042394,
0.0142532792,
-0.0197922345,
0.0045498749,
-0.0546854623,
-0.0500332564,
0.0182085447,
0.0193945933,
-0.0072297533,
-0.0187346041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12138v1 | Bias in Text Embedding Models | 2024-06-17T22:58:36 | 2024-06-17T22:58:36 | Vasyl Rakivnenko, Nestor Maslej, Jessica Cervi, Volodymyr Zhukov | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Text embedding is becoming an increasingly popular AI methodology, especially
among businesses, yet the potential of text embedding models to be biased is
not well understood. This paper examines the degree to which a selection of
popular text embedding models are biased, particularly along gendered
dimensions. More specifically, this paper studies the degree to which these
models associate a list of given professions with gendered terms. The analysis
reveals that text embedding models are prone to gendered biases but in varying
ways. Although there are certain inter-model commonalities, for instance,
greater association of professions like nurse, homemaker, and socialite with
female identifiers, and greater association of professions like CEO, manager,
and boss with male identifiers, not all models make the same gendered
associations for each occupation. Furthermore, the magnitude and directionality
of bias can also vary on a model-by-model basis and depend on the particular
words models are prompted with. This paper demonstrates that gender bias
afflicts text embedding models and suggests that businesses using this
technology need to be mindful of the specific dimensions of this problem. | [
0.0518072285,
0.0443692878,
-0.0343181118,
0.0154280234,
0.0106570432,
0.0147731919,
0.05824662,
-0.0055863466,
0.0469027236,
-0.0505596548,
0.0087580439,
-0.0007530235,
0.0360442102,
0.0324290395,
0.0077902698,
-0.0100834509,
0.0057816221,
0.0612731725,
0.0447394773,
-0.0122182248,
0.0187765229,
0.0518771559,
0.0326188058,
0.076778397,
0.0133318836,
-0.0426102877,
0.074028261,
-0.0167599656,
0.0206212625,
0.0301529095,
0.0213377625,
0.0415603667,
0.0169651248,
0.0104353558,
0.0000016306,
-0.0491211116,
0.0032685976,
0.0172450896,
-0.0348088033,
-0.0364329442,
0.0408627354,
0.0102452058,
0.0011440678,
0.0433563255,
-0.0197743904,
0.0130156027,
0.0335888341,
0.0590313375,
0.0115980022,
-0.004667222,
-0.0119316857,
0.0035430498,
-0.0738233253,
-0.016861707,
-0.0420898497,
-0.0142413341,
0.0523259975,
-0.0476535633,
-0.0330352411,
0.0340925232,
-0.0003207556,
0.0087905675,
-0.0291041322,
0.0071109897,
0.0564586408,
0.0691462681,
0.0120332269,
-0.0433517769,
0.029705435,
0.0365838818,
0.0245037675,
0.0068640122,
0.0031088835,
-0.0089661591,
0.0491753556,
0.0430005603,
-0.0262180958,
0.0274002776,
-0.0167007465,
-0.004786633,
0.0026107633,
-0.0011841316,
0.0145520959,
0.0403338112,
-0.0013354075,
0.0217598416,
-0.0092118764,
-0.0639449134,
0.0309234187,
-0.0014491976,
0.0379833914,
-0.0560178608,
0.0306303985,
-0.0337247513,
0.0097740944,
0.0219233166,
-0.0211351085,
0.0043647056,
0.0164975058,
-0.0670101792,
-0.0204735119,
0.0224139187,
0.0318921432,
0.0251263976,
-0.0334401317,
0.0086874282,
0.0085804313,
0.0023552843,
-0.0165054817,
-0.0278916266,
-0.0477925129,
-0.0396276861,
0.0006053234,
0.0036262271,
0.0094042309,
-0.019070683,
-0.0266420357,
0.0252337735,
-0.067466028,
0.0423828289,
0.0261659287,
0.0580292158,
0.0105075333,
-0.0031180477,
-0.0249822624,
-0.0221732482,
-0.0529944599,
0.0340503976,
-0.0305599254,
0.0046229772,
0.0295481719,
0.0022037863,
0.0295649953,
-0.0243867971,
0.0051200287,
-0.0058872565,
0.0003238114,
-0.0391058214,
-0.026152866,
-0.0254650116,
-0.0227232631,
-0.0367617309,
-0.0043003275,
-0.0223379377,
0.0268432256,
0.0478511117,
0.0016472825,
-0.0441276953,
0.0079927612,
0.0411952697,
-0.0972812846,
0.0579373799,
0.0554962866,
0.0070444983,
0.0909608901,
0.020297192,
-0.0206489991,
0.0719660521,
0.0422794409,
0.0529285222,
0.0189012196,
0.0092073213,
-0.0020832021,
0.0235313158,
-0.0107266856,
0.002103915,
-0.0155430092,
0.0445399135,
-0.0286731143,
0.0461869948,
0.0427861921,
0.0152799515,
-0.0031308439,
0.007734919,
0.0363219194,
0.1018296778,
0.0524652563,
0.0430648327,
0.0307555031,
0.0075511569,
-0.0252733957,
-0.0037065451,
-0.0296286009,
-0.0013130679,
-0.0179040376,
-0.0379270613,
-0.0142822471,
0.0173570625,
-0.0260968972,
-0.0312955566,
-0.013577614,
0.0063946508,
0.0349995531,
0.0056860857,
0.0097291283,
0.0006384368,
-0.0261814781,
-0.0026948755,
0.0014873571,
-0.0499145128,
-0.0135340076,
-0.013765635,
0.0015417567,
0.111315161,
0.0238541886,
-0.0229295697,
-0.0040571978,
-0.0355787538,
-0.0361376926,
0.0492390543,
0.0364049263,
-0.0134198889,
-0.0292132031,
-0.0512663536,
-0.0498245619,
0.0410860889,
0.0223977268,
0.0434737168,
0.0024468941,
0.0485012867,
0.0283392705,
-0.0203023273,
-0.0275258664,
0.0308441259,
-0.035006281,
-0.0385886431,
0.0301101878,
0.0368665494,
-0.0328932852,
0.0521055087,
-0.0198741704,
0.0069799055,
-0.0005914976,
-0.0163188763,
-0.0447789319,
-0.0013831812,
-0.0073199063,
0.0314924158,
-0.0212727375,
-0.032966394,
-0.064700298,
0.0080107534,
0.0098539367,
0.0004477356,
0.0452238694,
-0.003536308,
0.0089068739,
-0.0046054288,
-0.0106080221,
-0.0391899012,
0.0112760793,
-0.0211371016,
0.0424680784,
-0.0257103182,
-0.0180794075,
0.0116418172,
-0.0207300838,
-0.0128219603,
-0.0782983154,
-0.0269018617,
-0.002612991,
0.0302561261,
0.0239011664,
0.0289696567,
-0.0534702577,
-0.0016933412,
-0.0580964237,
-0.0995295718,
-0.0207233578,
0.0082717948,
-0.0265549161,
-0.0295158923,
-0.0010502925,
-0.0222136881,
-0.0023348131,
-0.0193676371,
-0.0122038601,
-0.0100147054,
0.069931075,
0.0297655966,
-0.0330928601,
0.0106048938,
-0.0296337809,
-0.0159590952,
-0.057233002,
0.0612766221,
0.0565739833,
-0.0185473245,
-0.0723508224,
-0.0066497857,
-0.0428834818,
-0.0084373942,
-0.0146326134,
0.0080991285,
0.0144969113,
0.0409514271,
0.0517140739,
0.0795054063,
0.0168070793,
0.0351440832,
0.0240909811,
0.0166340377,
-0.0294623077,
-0.0196312927,
0.0260329489,
0.0627202392,
0.0090910615,
-0.0876283497,
-0.0115053561,
-0.0023315912,
-0.0037040543,
-0.0176723152,
-0.0631943941,
0.0719541609,
-0.0436492525,
-0.021444913,
-0.038818147,
-0.0305915177,
0.0022500854,
0.0308945775,
0.0047961641,
-0.0156749599,
-0.0037958149,
0.012414231,
0.0139800617,
-0.0085562216,
-0.056293238,
-0.0527251437,
0.0335877053,
-0.0424481481,
0.0343512893,
0.0191556774,
-0.0334542468,
-0.0726937503,
-0.0119386753,
-0.0114882626,
-0.045588322,
0.0213308241,
0.0483423956,
0.0008809191,
0.0264372509,
-0.0363462046,
-0.0555423796,
-0.0697333738,
-0.0239986777,
0.0249642916,
0.0399427712,
-0.0211777929,
-0.044241827,
0.005957813,
-0.0118324226,
-0.0378085934,
0.0081851436,
-0.0203749612,
-0.0175632779,
0.0109329084,
0.060275998,
0.0029932125,
-0.0128293615,
0.0094178114,
-0.0200751498,
-0.0147558451,
-0.0281966515,
-0.001926347,
-0.0308574364,
-0.0184555333,
0.0152664389,
-0.0797256455,
-0.014729715,
-0.0237825047,
-0.0250290837,
-0.0014863884,
0.0417727269,
0.0985065177,
0.0276401769,
-0.0585871711,
-0.001844395,
0.0182639956,
-0.0054452657,
0.0331558734,
0.0333045572,
-0.0405615196,
0.0233009961,
0.0326668322,
-0.0019013707,
0.0013163597,
-0.0265088174,
-0.036693424,
-0.1206259653,
0.0103707332,
-0.0175334662,
0.0008134738,
-0.0378196239,
-0.0324757434,
-0.0189708751,
-0.0515248999,
0.0268232003,
-0.0239167102,
-0.0338228308,
0.0043221442,
0.0195281673,
-0.0329315849,
-0.0564864539,
0.0280160923,
-0.0748406351,
0.0371301584,
0.0519691817,
0.0679869577,
-0.0431309044,
-0.0146500645,
-0.0305168368,
0.017154118,
0.0122558139,
0.0210733209,
0.0717921779,
-0.0837460905,
0.0164164416,
-0.029620681,
-0.0171064008,
0.0149429599,
0.0371608213,
-0.0033579005,
0.0212252364,
0.0216657389,
-0.0288763382,
-0.0573457778,
-0.0142937917,
-0.0050909487,
0.096697934,
-0.0264960025,
-0.0746088848,
-0.0343852788,
-0.0511630289,
0.0414199047,
0.0767927244,
-0.0246383753,
-0.0160164125,
-0.0042109452,
-0.0161766466,
-0.0216827244,
-0.080861412,
0.0460265763,
0.0132451421,
0.020002244,
-0.0240221675,
0.0125204483,
-0.0071688802,
-0.0350130945,
-0.0250370447,
-0.0136820683,
0.0474682115,
0.0192873832,
0.0000830651,
-0.0234809816,
-0.0530627072,
-0.0433502756,
-0.0347207338,
-0.0409117974,
-0.0166661777,
0.0030423079,
-0.0107901739,
0.0190868303,
0.0383592173,
-0.0155279022,
-0.0681434721,
0.0691284984,
0.0337060392,
-0.0434856527,
0.0201752707,
0.0247340836,
0.0429079346,
-0.0029075339,
0.0268843919,
-0.0584953502,
0.0183082987,
-0.0074665518,
-0.0138267446,
-0.0143769402,
-0.0261261407,
-0.0198953114,
-0.0166139659,
-0.0339686126,
0.0001756682,
0.027244024,
-0.0619873032,
-0.0146479774,
-0.0090826908,
-0.0476844981,
-0.0041684532,
-0.0345799103,
0.0529048406,
0.0147632584,
-0.0084009869,
-0.0155894654,
-0.0278969593,
0.0286128782,
-0.0360815115,
-0.0006836416,
-0.0080342889,
0.0479641557,
-0.0062296167,
0.0037492237,
-0.014796068,
-0.0145372394,
-0.0155473575,
0.0366654657,
0.0200982001,
0.0052894368,
-0.0062074293,
0.0073675853,
-0.0554682091,
0.0322914422,
-0.0426161997,
-0.0321102925,
0.0057216701,
0.0076627922,
-0.0046722568,
-0.0573033877,
0.0205528382,
-0.0141551327,
0.007743618,
0.0244578496,
-0.0402441323,
0.0141368331,
0.0248436686,
0.0186376311,
0.0073171514,
-0.008390923,
-0.0060640052,
0.0519662946,
0.0676681325,
0.0420478955,
-0.0564086996,
-0.0774161965,
-0.046605777,
-0.0151720857,
0.0806098804,
0.031813249,
-0.0240338799,
-0.0190544687,
-0.1003751978,
-0.0406417511,
0.0408741534,
-0.0707395226,
-0.0125348363,
-0.0133234924,
-0.0145723633,
0.0425963737,
-0.0033206258,
-0.0108089987,
-0.0280452035,
-0.0134456139,
-0.0276905149,
-0.0295318756,
-0.0494982377,
-5.470115574e-33,
-0.0023837804,
-0.0598072223,
0.0167472996,
-0.0430540591,
0.0043496205,
0.0379343219,
0.0452531278,
-0.011286635,
0.0021018111,
0.0043636374,
-0.0261241458,
0.0209636539,
0.0031649244,
-0.0211028364,
0.0413572863,
-0.0152963409,
0.0634660572,
0.0108884992,
-0.0035642353,
-0.0189514663,
-0.0144538255,
0.0392329805,
0.0182362683,
-0.0905413255,
0.0929843336,
0.0057775145,
-0.0173893571,
-0.0217735972,
0.0240091179,
0.0472728014,
-0.0338349976,
0.0296804011,
0.0253501944,
-0.0260065049,
0.0181673914,
0.1017253026,
-0.0604799427,
-0.0494397655,
0.0071274932,
0.0342330486,
0.017749792,
0.0120359082,
0.013910234,
0.0275881905,
-0.0331112966,
-0.0170274265,
0.0949073955,
0.0110078827,
0.0272936821,
0.0510808937,
-0.038810987,
0.0185092408,
-0.0326061808,
0.0223714877,
0.0404193029,
0.0182361696,
0.0342450924,
0.0383387469,
-0.09064091,
-0.0051178588,
-0.0181270409,
-0.0498235188,
0.0381220654,
0.0130829634,
0.0091134235,
0.0396720059,
0.0467797592,
0.0671117976,
-0.0467901416,
-0.0782194063,
0.01455265,
0.0100600319,
0.001328573,
0.0280945878,
0.0152975637,
0.009661776,
-0.007187861,
-0.0028978379,
0.0210470725,
-0.0224345829,
0.0496405736,
-0.0021752254,
-0.1001918837,
-0.0583721362,
-0.0152343847,
-0.0441811308,
-0.0413024649,
-0.0119842971,
0.0136598675,
0.0295240153,
-0.0328751877,
0.0408250019,
-0.0241669808,
-0.0678495988,
-0.0443402417,
0.0332990475,
-0.019610459,
-0.0382798389,
0.045798704,
-0.0218721461,
-0.0851235017,
0.0088078035,
0.0048983805,
0.0290613603,
0.0091323629,
0.0310025811,
0.0016707553,
-0.0147651453,
-0.0744346157,
-0.0374725908,
0.0176643692,
-0.0458944477,
-0.0081580728,
-0.0006840141,
0.0422573499,
0.0135500878,
0.004825897,
-0.0011556232,
0.0971468538,
0.0416374952,
0.0034847602,
-0.0369401127,
-0.0041347998,
-0.0150244236,
-0.0022965767,
-0.0060457089,
0.0172286928,
0.0412053652,
0.0462921821,
-0.0486573838,
-0.0012874528,
-0.0530242175,
2.243e-7,
0.0407114401,
0.0847903565,
-0.0104757426,
0.0262442231,
0.0162960365,
0.0410517752,
0.0649812073,
0.0444153324,
0.0369858816,
0.0433049574,
0.0151001383,
0.010018154,
-0.0077217561,
0.0351523794,
-0.042031128,
0.0071674953,
-0.0730199367,
0.0349208042,
-0.0245488398,
0.013072555,
0.0189578515,
0.0338469893,
0.0638447404,
0.0039909836,
-0.0325531848,
-0.0359471552,
0.04980921,
-0.0133397542,
0.0548617877,
0.0071571846,
-0.0144690787,
0.0322444402,
-0.000437824,
0.0309034344,
0.0024631936,
0.0382516719,
0.0724850297,
-0.0091096936,
-0.0485565215,
0.0579804331,
-0.0136424247,
-0.0406109728,
-0.0045759389,
-0.0548127182,
0.0709124729,
-0.0156462993,
-0.0384742916,
-0.0508112796,
-0.0206584353,
0.012799223,
0.0805279016,
0.0093179001,
-0.0169304349,
-0.0066878372,
0.0078652333,
0.0087801367,
-0.0187524538,
-0.0567316934,
0.0291392691,
-0.0067996788,
-0.0294919722,
-0.0367870033,
-0.0121686216,
0.0604960397,
0.0698206127,
-0.0536158532,
0.0292051472,
1.755179403e-34,
-0.0067754141,
0.0379531607,
0.0017435517,
0.0170206763,
0.0191369094,
0.0027841197,
-0.0002816281,
0.0073254672,
0.0537969992,
-0.0333545245,
0.0096397866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12131v1 | Gram2Vec: An Interpretable Document Vectorizer | 2024-06-17T22:42:14 | 2024-06-17T22:42:14 | Peter Zeng, Eric Sclafani, Owen Rambow | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Gram2Vec, a grammatical style embedding algorithm that embeds
documents into a higher dimensional space by extracting the normalized relative
frequencies of grammatical features present in the text. Compared to neural
approaches, Gram2Vec offers inherent interpretability based on how the feature
vectors are generated. In our demo, we present a way to visualize a mapping of
authors to documents based on their Gram2Vec vectors and highlight the ability
to drop or add features to view which authors make certain linguistic choices.
Next, we use authorship attribution as an application to show how Gram2Vec can
explain why a document is attributed to a certain author, using cosine
similarities between the Gram2Vec feature vectors to calculate the distances
between candidate documents and a query document. | [
0.0122524612,
0.0755408406,
-0.0119370138,
0.051698111,
-0.0120513802,
0.0337655693,
0.0125774825,
0.0163744409,
-0.0249207541,
-0.0054995711,
0.0159752332,
0.0239533931,
0.0043295226,
0.0113624828,
0.0345520377,
-0.0236902237,
-0.0174305774,
0.0138488924,
0.0088362684,
0.0153552331,
0.0235601068,
0.0297270529,
0.0204769857,
0.0671959296,
-0.0260133762,
-0.0534294546,
-0.0078155082,
0.0034356916,
0.0231253952,
0.0377954021,
-0.00952248,
0.0215697251,
0.0358624682,
0.0487064049,
0.0000019022,
0.0237963218,
0.012695305,
-0.0086274007,
-0.0133728525,
0.0261552725,
0.0502722599,
0.0112198573,
-0.0070070163,
-0.0229375307,
-0.0308682434,
-0.0307509974,
0.0006397319,
0.0660099015,
0.0437359102,
0.0789561495,
-0.0204591472,
-0.0911017656,
0.0398220681,
0.0014108192,
0.0222344454,
0.0116987852,
-0.0124787968,
-0.0283263717,
-0.0193814822,
0.053169813,
-0.0232934672,
0.031880945,
0.0018133909,
-0.0750615001,
0.0479879342,
0.009014939,
0.013233358,
0.0125838658,
0.0541217439,
0.0107573895,
0.0158370771,
-0.0318225659,
0.0230119266,
0.0124274306,
0.0052903974,
0.0591758899,
-0.0491289459,
-0.0362878852,
-0.0080086095,
0.0196044557,
0.0835430399,
-0.0139250755,
0.0101006711,
0.0079458505,
0.0349589474,
-0.0057864846,
-0.0040257755,
0.0043313019,
-0.036831677,
0.0124605745,
-0.0022956657,
-0.019013226,
0.0714672059,
0.0001154439,
0.0130401757,
0.0171583928,
-0.0243198574,
-0.0710371435,
0.0021193083,
-0.0836894885,
0.0746893212,
-0.0455014259,
0.0062858392,
0.035213165,
-0.0200589094,
0.0149621591,
-0.0383639261,
-0.0179794766,
-0.0284747835,
-0.0399983637,
-0.0787822977,
-0.0440050811,
-0.0222760811,
-0.0265245177,
0.0173239484,
-0.0193345547,
-0.022023771,
-0.0122366305,
-0.0027091021,
0.0120599773,
-0.0019695356,
0.0348250084,
-0.0354227014,
-0.0014909403,
0.0106227221,
-0.0009330537,
-0.059193708,
0.0168324169,
-0.026875725,
0.0216636118,
-0.0134098884,
0.0343874358,
0.0512899011,
-0.0239257272,
-0.0251618903,
-0.0272809435,
0.0285090022,
-0.0329255611,
0.0118755884,
-0.0451256,
0.0184480119,
0.0080979234,
-0.0239200536,
-0.0328508131,
0.006687202,
-0.0052624317,
-0.0028856194,
-0.0548938699,
-0.0430098511,
0.0132974023,
-0.0526263006,
0.0341706052,
0.0356408954,
-0.0226597805,
0.0323357843,
-0.0033387551,
0.0283430666,
-0.0063359593,
0.054549627,
0.0179017782,
0.020581888,
-0.0180079248,
0.0262344107,
-0.0288066436,
0.000542165,
-0.0024338716,
0.0134837953,
-0.0268821288,
0.004780137,
0.0468747318,
0.0292459186,
0.0218349677,
-0.011510306,
-0.0524697565,
0.0350102335,
0.0512395725,
0.0727147385,
0.0215171333,
0.078002274,
0.0191528518,
0.0116399266,
0.0022335933,
-0.0054770168,
0.0246701837,
-0.0271261651,
-0.043792367,
-0.0500288159,
-0.0117617631,
-0.0162545126,
-0.0321270935,
0.029770799,
0.0023983847,
-0.0034666713,
-0.0176722184,
0.0314612165,
0.0026811457,
0.000768963,
-0.0039826916,
0.0031287419,
-0.0732239112,
-0.0011167608,
0.0023496307,
0.0523397587,
0.0346999653,
0.0594621971,
-0.0234118514,
0.03845869,
-0.0356146023,
0.0192390475,
0.0108740088,
0.0042473702,
-0.0017591824,
0.039612487,
-0.0415443853,
-0.0170005485,
-0.0327701084,
0.0288810804,
0.0308786109,
-0.0563043319,
0.0251650158,
0.0175754856,
-0.0511447862,
-0.0124005871,
0.0492876805,
-0.013575945,
-0.0282985214,
0.0289102476,
0.0031393541,
0.010181495,
0.0481520668,
0.0059096063,
-0.0147849284,
0.0143471807,
-0.0616789758,
-0.0095368885,
0.0416948907,
-0.0044177715,
-0.0303444639,
-0.0190531481,
-0.0605228208,
-0.0145889502,
-0.0015385618,
-0.0325358063,
-0.0492012836,
0.0573436543,
-0.0543345138,
0.0189275611,
-0.0384998061,
-0.0330632627,
-0.0154599492,
0.015678525,
-0.0402975492,
0.0575293563,
0.0265585687,
0.02674428,
-0.0129667064,
-0.0155486194,
0.0308919493,
0.0421273299,
0.0038702346,
-0.031508904,
0.0292492751,
-0.0142768966,
0.0004771037,
-0.0326743647,
-0.0000272464,
-0.0622545928,
-0.0679416284,
-0.0171064362,
-0.0249706563,
0.0229709782,
0.0114580179,
-0.0220946874,
0.0324522294,
-0.0077291904,
-0.0448553637,
0.016721582,
-0.0343683437,
-0.036806576,
0.0574880578,
-0.0373582207,
-0.0118587893,
-0.0481203981,
-0.0180694815,
-0.031741064,
0.068955414,
0.0463753529,
0.0192811769,
-0.0450064577,
-0.0210845545,
0.0021021555,
-0.0258747973,
-0.0118448343,
-0.0330166258,
0.0081505021,
-0.04175229,
-0.0326354206,
0.0747820809,
0.0029065521,
0.0719562024,
0.003399106,
0.0048254249,
-0.0582104884,
-0.0178364646,
-0.0032085266,
0.0818401575,
-0.0310583878,
-0.0445475988,
0.0284638647,
0.0691278428,
0.009433982,
-0.0202460848,
-0.0245371126,
0.0558019504,
0.0188314188,
-0.0067752548,
0.0496089272,
-0.0161582362,
0.0024159888,
-0.0092464406,
0.0153824007,
-0.0275752377,
0.0561616272,
-0.0237460826,
-0.0253567826,
-0.0376222581,
-0.0376746953,
-0.0617481582,
0.0565643497,
0.0283846371,
0.0043914551,
-0.0054200594,
-0.0424753577,
0.0176874138,
0.0236168727,
0.0811719596,
0.0126248337,
0.019022923,
-0.0028720147,
-0.0046049347,
0.0128832357,
-0.0131545691,
-0.0151376836,
-0.0802109614,
-0.0135695767,
-0.0035099979,
0.0273569766,
-0.0501006581,
-0.033630278,
-0.0614634119,
0.0215034019,
-0.0056194863,
-0.0294437706,
-0.0373553522,
-0.0217874963,
0.0426879637,
0.0367282443,
0.0415817164,
-0.0369919091,
0.0150797665,
-0.0186972618,
0.0083541553,
-0.0673054308,
0.0205217283,
-0.0485140868,
0.0243431758,
-0.0051205307,
-0.0300110281,
-0.065126434,
-0.0396808907,
0.0539289676,
-0.0538770519,
-0.0118624903,
0.1042845398,
0.039181713,
-0.0620129891,
-0.0015705532,
-0.0526353605,
0.0016451448,
-0.002440617,
0.0375722721,
-0.0182205904,
-0.0275664143,
-0.0152663514,
0.0030058499,
0.0081772804,
-0.0219809599,
0.0118376939,
-0.0194301605,
0.0441669226,
-0.0184719395,
0.0007580059,
-0.0074864849,
-0.0731224865,
-0.0271511786,
-0.0246202424,
-0.0609390698,
-0.0148070883,
0.0124187712,
0.0288898405,
-0.0074230968,
-0.0242017731,
-0.0106956698,
-0.0114457905,
-0.0447481424,
0.0161190908,
0.0533048064,
0.0984841958,
-0.0079480801,
-0.0466713198,
-0.0752752498,
-0.0377290584,
0.0167551804,
-0.0201573018,
0.0937283635,
0.0179277398,
0.0039598746,
-0.0799419582,
0.057685703,
-0.0176684614,
0.0144840069,
0.0282597393,
0.0744802356,
-0.0362287462,
-0.0149902394,
-0.0448369607,
0.0036678468,
0.0213266499,
0.0482361466,
0.0742913336,
-0.0479279049,
-0.0584289022,
-0.0822220072,
0.0484736115,
-0.0340942293,
-0.0260391925,
-0.0077502886,
0.0174531545,
-0.0299378429,
-0.0590514392,
-0.0538513437,
-0.0492733642,
0.0191456024,
0.0371120088,
0.030297989,
0.0025625215,
-0.0736523569,
-0.0276377443,
-0.0000292393,
0.0132987062,
0.0334580243,
0.0286145471,
-0.001532795,
0.0441549607,
0.0048457733,
0.0027901109,
0.0114579303,
-0.0168852974,
-0.0184044484,
0.0161078982,
0.0018269952,
0.0029939816,
0.0378820784,
-0.0322453938,
-0.1141094416,
0.0369816236,
0.0254167877,
-0.032128416,
-0.0059142723,
0.0444648005,
-0.0269367322,
-0.0111665539,
0.0509579256,
-0.0100282198,
0.0159071907,
0.0058417134,
-0.031725768,
-0.0444739349,
0.0213433299,
-0.0138682714,
-0.0308342129,
0.0392920822,
0.0036656323,
0.0445125625,
-0.0367469676,
-0.0213387329,
-0.0603180043,
0.00068205,
-0.0465040132,
0.0105237952,
0.0304575413,
-0.0462807044,
-0.0361422561,
0.0223882366,
-0.0192425065,
0.04103221,
-0.0436128639,
0.0779344141,
0.0339586362,
0.035723675,
-0.0422785319,
0.0323005542,
0.0088633159,
0.0054823896,
-0.0157155339,
0.0579875223,
-0.0005634822,
0.0360952914,
0.0239694621,
0.0275339205,
-0.0206147432,
0.0122160157,
-0.1193273589,
0.026027048,
0.0552148111,
-0.0397167206,
0.0280439332,
-0.0444003902,
0.0794381797,
-0.0155758904,
0.0138674844,
0.0151212439,
0.0768528059,
0.0329889767,
-0.0075591533,
0.0099479547,
0.0014984621,
-0.0185488854,
-0.0265644714,
0.0501699932,
-0.0250930917,
-0.0128435763,
-0.0008520248,
-0.0249401312,
-0.0161455926,
-0.0077009816,
0.0519870222,
0.027232375,
0.0196889304,
0.0072610481,
-0.0245330501,
-0.0119536491,
0.0349994525,
-0.0353310145,
-0.0145989284,
-0.0166829266,
0.0072752624,
0.0388634056,
-0.0096043162,
-0.0167529769,
-0.0662897453,
0.0522290505,
-0.0640973151,
-0.0776632279,
-0.0004524241,
-5.831080135e-33,
-0.0153445126,
-0.0415464379,
-0.0520620532,
0.0665338933,
0.0005216349,
0.0026512847,
-0.0516161434,
-0.012469206,
-0.0029136848,
0.0642482564,
-0.0399753116,
0.0389613882,
-0.0080104647,
0.0293373577,
0.0218780469,
0.0191073529,
0.0469734967,
0.0232005585,
0.0010491707,
0.0350994244,
0.0727834329,
0.0287052058,
0.0630848855,
-0.1091973931,
0.0475018434,
-0.000630842,
0.004438539,
-0.0158153828,
-0.0055457158,
0.0336883962,
0.0040918998,
0.03749042,
-0.0091234408,
-0.0324254856,
-0.0262856334,
0.0106875254,
-0.0779388174,
-0.0729315132,
-0.0098733474,
0.0397100113,
0.0006044109,
-0.0497659892,
0.0287529454,
-0.0035229039,
0.0243826266,
-0.0272375457,
0.1004545018,
0.0177394077,
-0.0326274224,
-0.0358983241,
-0.0214571506,
0.0324549861,
-0.0577830784,
0.0066047772,
0.0438927449,
0.0083970986,
0.0229985639,
-0.0219569895,
-0.0783055201,
-0.0455359332,
-0.0552369952,
0.026653111,
-0.0198735278,
-0.0080830697,
-0.0141047947,
0.0573426336,
0.0382438526,
-0.0158102773,
-0.0578953326,
0.0758510083,
0.030231772,
0.0190664157,
0.0634205416,
0.0596344732,
0.0234825239,
-0.0050647059,
-0.0407336019,
0.0402711183,
0.0202600192,
0.0236225352,
0.0055158688,
0.0032974868,
-0.0410385802,
-0.0423016809,
-0.0162533224,
-0.0644445717,
-0.0200981814,
-0.0158271771,
-0.0252910946,
-0.0466988273,
-0.0093495203,
-0.0163917225,
0.0069987192,
-0.0220874064,
-0.0369811021,
0.0651949123,
-0.0301450174,
0.0328072011,
0.0051362817,
-0.0175001472,
0.0153544899,
-0.0088816695,
0.0059102071,
0.0185331218,
0.0470309295,
-0.0039302977,
0.0763986558,
-0.0121537158,
-0.0147381313,
-0.0256247558,
-0.0074608345,
-0.0242057573,
-0.0260528289,
0.0317726731,
0.0130133573,
0.0107167624,
-0.0190763269,
0.0176407192,
0.0059483852,
0.0359106846,
-0.0175310243,
-0.0464415438,
-0.0058610081,
0.0052162441,
-0.0497018099,
-0.0118967993,
-0.0235676523,
0.0001865499,
0.0601337589,
-0.0685071722,
0.0039082379,
-0.0069355764,
2.541e-7,
0.0567621589,
0.0329321884,
0.0222825017,
-0.0038772537,
0.0326851718,
0.063525334,
0.0536679141,
0.0470676832,
-0.0296800807,
-0.000879287,
-0.0064208712,
0.0009926901,
0.0780545026,
0.0333423615,
-0.0663881525,
0.0040518111,
-0.029509278,
-0.0052908631,
-0.0377584845,
0.0260648262,
0.0679788217,
0.0544178821,
0.0481416509,
-0.0022601301,
0.0258587878,
-0.0401959158,
0.0297877584,
-0.0108721172,
-0.0080316551,
-0.0110219764,
0.0614913516,
-0.0672275051,
0.0219931509,
-0.0024750829,
-0.0225149654,
0.0397838615,
-0.0228009317,
0.0375803635,
-0.009036921,
0.0264873151,
-0.0266604684,
-0.042945262,
0.0125988116,
-0.0458788089,
0.0423655584,
0.032920979,
-0.0686231405,
-0.0083106812,
0.0142673785,
-0.0091117928,
0.0326820873,
-0.0034085077,
-0.0079264687,
0.0223694537,
0.0054735197,
-0.0731748566,
0.0211612023,
-0.0635815114,
-0.0261718277,
0.0150962044,
-0.0235760212,
0.0614901148,
-0.0174432751,
0.0394364893,
0.0585233569,
0.0144588929,
0.0255682599,
2.023636025e-34,
0.0242440067,
0.0257368386,
0.0196730085,
0.003148339,
0.0616183653,
0.0155889792,
0.0141105549,
0.0316461585,
0.0379688628,
-0.0744198188,
-0.0194185991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12128v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12128v1 | AI "News" Content Farms Are Easy to Make and Hard to Detect: A Case Study in Italian | 2024-06-17T22:19:00 | 2024-06-17T22:19:00 | Giovanni Puccetti, Anna Rogers, Chiara Alzetta, Felice Dell'Orletta, Andrea Esuli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used as "content farm" models
(CFMs), to generate synthetic text that could pass for real news articles. This
is already happening even for languages that do not have high-quality
monolingual LLMs. We show that fine-tuning Llama (v1), mostly trained on
English, on as little as 40K Italian news articles, is sufficient for producing
news-like texts that native speakers of Italian struggle to identify as
synthetic.
We investigate three LLMs and three methods of detecting synthetic texts
(log-likelihood, DetectGPT, and supervised classification), finding that they
all perform better than human raters, but they are all impractical in the real
world (requiring either access to token likelihood information or a large
dataset of CFM texts). We also explore the possibility of creating a proxy CFM:
an LLM fine-tuned on a similar dataset to one used by the real "content farm".
We find that even a small amount of fine-tuning data suffices for creating a
successful detector, but we need to know which base LLM is used, which is a
major challenge.
Our results suggest that there are currently no practical methods for
detecting synthetic news-like texts 'in the wild', while generating them is too
easy. We highlight the urgency of more NLP research on this problem. | [
0.0720810965,
0.0487728156,
-0.0211196635,
0.0732711703,
-0.0364397056,
0.00349,
0.0059717321,
0.0448139571,
0.044584278,
-0.0181408208,
0.00224932,
-0.0084153898,
-0.0087924525,
0.07608594,
-0.0017936721,
0.0232696179,
0.0385773107,
0.0101224035,
0.0088586183,
-0.0133190136,
0.0305143818,
0.0624821894,
0.054535836,
0.0323291756,
-0.0480170548,
-0.0182758328,
0.017052114,
-0.0012674651,
0.0087265754,
0.0196001939,
-0.0082972627,
0.0397316441,
-0.0161706265,
0.0670286417,
0.000001757,
-0.0106831295,
-0.0162808541,
-0.0384539478,
-0.005125022,
0.0212990008,
0.0411292613,
-0.0212698486,
-0.0313311145,
0.0186333284,
-0.0421975926,
0.0089903362,
0.0018075359,
0.0001598345,
0.0474006459,
0.108124122,
-0.0272934083,
-0.0021794562,
0.007277221,
0.000644056,
-0.0002105723,
0.0155016342,
0.0263699163,
-0.0167715959,
-0.0095901079,
0.0061611957,
0.0309350584,
0.0344158411,
0.0301472079,
-0.0302282237,
-0.0445570461,
0.0209244564,
-0.0201967843,
-0.0274130255,
0.0226937197,
0.0185585581,
-0.0660560951,
-0.0894475132,
0.0550893731,
-0.0024044865,
0.0196475219,
0.0152159575,
-0.0030920315,
0.0416521579,
-0.0424790978,
0.0503990278,
0.0818004087,
-0.0246419776,
0.0106057879,
0.0296574403,
0.0175165907,
0.0387110263,
0.0203235298,
-0.035571184,
-0.0309599247,
0.0156373251,
-0.0000351544,
-0.062939845,
0.0457582809,
0.0232389327,
0.0002313649,
-0.001652126,
-0.1011032388,
-0.0234504081,
0.0128804622,
-0.1050320864,
-0.0111346543,
-0.0003779201,
-0.0153056812,
0.0394453518,
-0.039785061,
0.0023846349,
-0.0250793826,
0.0225363169,
-0.03194727,
0.0102646723,
-0.0205030274,
-0.010064126,
-0.0435976014,
0.0211046059,
-0.0666019097,
-0.0382091478,
-0.0040857336,
0.0102010118,
0.0215743184,
0.0092900256,
-0.0025119809,
0.0020566292,
-0.0126323663,
-0.0003241504,
-0.0042692488,
0.0079597458,
-0.0140764667,
0.024525281,
-0.0323522463,
-0.0543309078,
-0.0063098664,
0.0499546155,
0.0106290095,
0.0359799005,
0.0352661423,
0.0237739682,
-0.0218614284,
-0.0173081197,
-0.0562815182,
-0.0555406697,
-0.0231118929,
-0.0610461682,
-0.0087002674,
-0.0710974857,
-0.007229141,
-0.02229972,
0.0278694648,
-0.0371426605,
-0.0051513868,
0.0367717408,
-0.0351626351,
0.0275623873,
-0.0233054124,
0.007005481,
0.0068476717,
-0.0113372505,
0.0192271341,
0.0837143511,
0.0392698459,
0.0890870765,
0.0525874943,
0.0163591933,
0.0478426963,
0.0585115291,
0.0177084003,
0.0448299833,
-0.019944001,
-0.0291294791,
-0.0370104238,
0.0180387273,
0.0543699414,
0.0340513997,
0.0175766815,
0.0056542633,
0.0902411193,
0.0108006401,
-0.0017992145,
0.0171834826,
0.0854087546,
0.0155861909,
0.0213447399,
0.0549013205,
-0.0018413884,
-0.0112419426,
-0.0332335681,
-0.0236336961,
0.0187263694,
0.0323914029,
-0.0051576374,
-0.0206980128,
0.0125774378,
-0.018426422,
-0.0241739079,
-0.0305139441,
0.0084384149,
0.0349086747,
-0.0306105874,
-0.0289728716,
0.0092879292,
-0.005265981,
0.0597138554,
-0.0736959279,
0.0740584806,
0.0779686645,
0.0726221949,
0.0056980001,
0.0640080199,
0.0109336749,
-0.0259530619,
0.0853490233,
0.0246449895,
-0.0265261121,
-0.0370951779,
-0.003016239,
0.017230209,
-0.0323608145,
0.0367506668,
0.0359862819,
-0.0002962199,
0.0333107449,
-0.0107819932,
-0.0228757486,
-0.0889936388,
0.027143281,
-0.0151964743,
-0.0198748261,
0.0136384992,
-0.003497313,
-0.0020371419,
0.0256672166,
0.0025366698,
0.0053389431,
0.0047079842,
-0.0486963391,
-0.0359124057,
0.0225367714,
0.0146492999,
-0.033326827,
-0.00773262,
-0.0498382859,
-0.0124999238,
0.028166566,
-0.0187551435,
-0.030619204,
0.0277475677,
-0.0114395544,
0.0383726023,
-0.0561403967,
0.0195299927,
-0.0146601312,
0.0345374718,
0.0213515442,
0.0748623237,
0.00025631,
0.0208441094,
0.0312398151,
-0.0181292612,
0.033135213,
-0.0013025274,
0.0090356879,
0.0171289463,
-0.0134555576,
0.0097314585,
0.0198322833,
0.0125424229,
-0.0025005138,
-0.0491052046,
-0.0330700353,
0.0059496085,
-0.031468384,
0.0188883953,
0.0841511935,
-0.0155401099,
-0.0326537713,
0.0257185176,
-0.039736513,
-0.0217365883,
0.0173031483,
0.0140200173,
0.0088631324,
0.003198748,
0.0311460495,
-0.0189902019,
0.0511659309,
-0.0186405517,
0.051050961,
0.0322251096,
-0.0286883358,
-0.1065426916,
0.0149015486,
0.00552862,
0.0164685622,
-0.0077345781,
-0.0509851649,
-0.0163292978,
-0.0177928228,
0.0131263444,
0.0741187558,
0.000245306,
0.0129877282,
0.0600887723,
0.0296851899,
-0.0316531099,
-0.0215352476,
-0.0318879485,
0.0235795695,
-0.0539508983,
-0.0773876458,
0.0627210662,
0.0345795564,
0.0331589393,
0.0293610841,
-0.0295248497,
0.0584252477,
-0.0214267951,
-0.020192856,
0.0405604877,
-0.0352134481,
-0.0277209803,
0.0537331253,
-0.0055342452,
-0.0144044831,
0.0424578376,
-0.039490819,
0.0454772972,
-0.0559155531,
-0.0276081525,
-0.0265431274,
-0.006331733,
-0.0176091082,
0.0441331342,
-0.013366946,
-0.0029654535,
-0.0122730341,
0.0197758041,
0.0260537118,
-0.0162049197,
0.0060150689,
-0.0275306907,
0.0157747902,
0.0124068763,
-0.0283409413,
-0.0435855053,
-0.0549656823,
-0.0056076394,
-0.0291057453,
0.0693562478,
-0.0458658822,
-0.0306547396,
0.0058353893,
-0.013525499,
0.0654982477,
-0.0408131033,
-0.0034358348,
-0.0055812397,
0.0730945617,
0.0497542731,
-0.0499075577,
0.0189310275,
-0.0035717578,
0.0064452346,
0.0336328074,
-0.0039653359,
0.0557169132,
-0.0012863142,
-0.0266196094,
0.001622212,
-0.0041272738,
-0.0065648584,
-0.0207803417,
0.0081317024,
-0.0318752825,
-0.0278515443,
0.1042377278,
0.0327711813,
-0.0631445274,
-0.0040567834,
0.0317224152,
0.0023748416,
0.021122057,
0.0232326016,
-0.0907534584,
0.0109032188,
0.0116325319,
0.0188828222,
-0.0444022603,
-0.0184554439,
-0.0366349965,
-0.0981005803,
0.0198755376,
-0.010366247,
-0.029721316,
-0.044517003,
-0.0475022905,
-0.0186882261,
-0.002122679,
-0.0433641635,
-0.0521235578,
-0.0037843981,
0.0095747998,
-0.004640304,
-0.0121789053,
-0.0604696833,
-0.0316438042,
0.0016321051,
0.0572326854,
0.0262147114,
0.0463610403,
-0.0234248471,
-0.0020291689,
0.0236515496,
-0.0047586793,
-0.0128142564,
-0.021346651,
0.0442379937,
-0.0197541453,
-0.0302752331,
0.0108510302,
0.0259065609,
0.0075144786,
0.0055224802,
0.0145076355,
0.047458794,
-0.002622627,
-0.0695734471,
-0.0001064619,
0.0108761508,
0.0487855449,
0.0691952109,
0.062408518,
-0.0486000292,
-0.008471258,
-0.018961532,
0.0171748754,
-0.0588832907,
-0.0618483759,
0.0478715152,
-0.0047595361,
-0.0309966523,
-0.0941818282,
-0.0456082225,
-0.0083852699,
0.0238032397,
0.0298391897,
-0.0103635173,
0.0015420422,
-0.0552000776,
-0.0171880554,
-0.0059613739,
-0.0388546623,
-0.0164721385,
-0.0435131341,
-0.0017552637,
0.0272827335,
-0.0315508805,
-0.011268314,
-0.0117482124,
-0.0787496492,
-0.037674807,
-0.0042913319,
-0.001690842,
0.0211586412,
0.0342187025,
-0.0383601189,
-0.0366605148,
0.0542988926,
0.054900445,
-0.0358605571,
0.0031834252,
0.0042218734,
-0.0096590221,
0.0067546433,
0.0340957679,
-0.0325281285,
0.051492583,
0.0085240435,
-0.0096290298,
-0.023490414,
0.0004773583,
0.0638887808,
0.0217592996,
-0.0118786395,
-0.0638045222,
0.0185917374,
-0.0812400505,
-0.0229932573,
-0.0235641934,
-0.0177088603,
-0.0212408397,
0.0034123713,
0.043695081,
0.0105524892,
-0.018999232,
0.0301756319,
-0.0583997443,
0.0397963785,
-0.0379511304,
-0.0238480791,
0.0078523494,
0.0203613974,
-0.0005717571,
-0.0141729284,
-0.0194586329,
0.0618144572,
0.0005650051,
0.0371752195,
-0.0220666658,
0.0063370317,
0.0298070759,
-0.0344899483,
0.0103536751,
0.0318557061,
-0.0374470167,
-0.022030836,
-0.0649139285,
0.069581151,
0.0575236604,
-0.0333083905,
0.0610427633,
-0.041319672,
-0.0038500449,
-0.0029470257,
-0.0026722464,
0.0271437205,
-0.0427821055,
-0.0297570974,
-0.0006713326,
-0.0481648967,
0.0141102728,
0.0824419558,
0.0109769842,
0.0670793205,
0.0262004957,
-0.0330519676,
-0.0320403352,
-0.008443661,
0.0029160173,
-0.0097521562,
-0.0285641328,
-0.0051297746,
-0.0642839372,
-0.047004234,
-0.0015313536,
0.0129685169,
0.0153268036,
0.0075871926,
-0.0423113592,
0.0651879087,
0.0130979,
0.0555036142,
-0.0382812433,
-0.0003767036,
0.0036376589,
-0.0434439033,
-0.0031581463,
-6.146720205e-33,
0.0242457855,
-0.0516054071,
-0.0244025029,
0.0217445418,
0.0345103331,
0.0397274308,
-0.0287776906,
-0.0478814431,
-0.0119937528,
0.0267740786,
-0.0118375868,
-0.0012753311,
0.0155476881,
-0.0084901303,
-0.0215563606,
-0.0004919561,
0.0538192503,
-0.0127987508,
-0.0509400852,
0.0288340282,
0.0684145764,
-0.013391423,
0.0551555529,
-0.0426987261,
0.0155871101,
-0.0324862897,
-0.0670216978,
0.0064704949,
0.0012087218,
0.0547736809,
-0.0182222929,
0.0412117094,
0.0409795903,
-0.0251124799,
0.0070256763,
0.0517071001,
-0.0148478132,
-0.0347989537,
0.0333969593,
0.0093682911,
0.0030452814,
-0.0484309793,
0.0386765376,
-0.0066678426,
-0.0126464106,
0.0473304428,
0.0565912165,
-0.037751358,
0.0228230767,
-0.0782499686,
-0.0609686263,
0.0050406605,
0.0065737525,
-0.0038337533,
0.009048352,
0.0377625041,
0.0194503758,
0.0142753217,
-0.0472867526,
0.0362440944,
-0.0402372219,
0.0393240415,
0.0431167223,
-0.0265170168,
-0.035872452,
0.0520996638,
-0.0058107595,
0.0262562521,
-0.001662842,
0.0140162744,
0.0300307702,
0.0057555265,
0.0506843477,
0.1015343219,
0.0470567346,
-0.0509284474,
-0.0348984599,
0.0440894514,
0.039637927,
-0.0356788188,
0.0253697261,
-0.0571715347,
-0.0338535607,
-0.0081097502,
-0.0189903285,
-0.0729295611,
-0.0417005606,
-0.0127411438,
0.0147381853,
0.0300445873,
-0.0354239941,
-0.0082129408,
-0.0019108651,
-0.0455253385,
0.0002111932,
0.0214471612,
-0.0621459223,
0.0188213084,
0.0086617377,
0.0324752219,
-0.0425075218,
-0.0239985213,
0.0382775106,
0.0060407878,
0.0264346581,
0.0023808698,
0.0674264058,
0.0358898602,
-0.0469955802,
0.0347857848,
-0.0229789801,
0.0385164246,
0.0084314449,
-0.014455107,
0.0234192982,
-0.0358304381,
-0.0095675495,
-0.0325764306,
0.0378494896,
0.0425457656,
-0.0142667852,
-0.0300514102,
-0.0169545859,
0.0487457477,
-0.0529449247,
-0.0064371913,
-0.045164302,
0.0210996307,
0.021014031,
-0.0962248966,
0.0002141352,
-0.0160986707,
2.495e-7,
0.001503214,
0.0427575,
-0.0015747616,
-0.0025157395,
0.0239917953,
0.0175911691,
0.0043454347,
0.0474031009,
-0.0377444699,
-0.0357560813,
-0.0132889375,
-0.005118412,
0.0333139524,
0.0212849136,
-0.1047440693,
0.0495432056,
-0.0898540616,
-0.001323482,
-0.0996276438,
-0.0515330993,
0.01992842,
0.0622102506,
0.0336233377,
-0.041132763,
-0.0045964057,
-0.0405079089,
0.0198777206,
0.0234998558,
-0.0611925721,
0.0233960897,
0.0660061389,
0.0188243762,
0.0092913406,
-0.0291784015,
-0.0398249216,
0.0005439587,
-0.0101516815,
0.0369496122,
0.0312411748,
0.0048741587,
0.0040055318,
-0.0636389479,
-0.0103179188,
-0.0518371128,
0.0651162267,
-0.0005353531,
0.0040200478,
-0.0738119334,
-0.0360442586,
-0.0346394256,
0.0040302617,
-0.0477616489,
-0.0139388721,
0.044827342,
-0.0118407896,
0.0043678614,
0.0051152785,
-0.0270272046,
-0.0231693219,
-0.0330918916,
-0.0427613445,
0.007536062,
-0.0158875939,
-0.0160976183,
0.0215361677,
-0.0496701449,
0.0558394194,
2.410341983e-34,
0.0462098569,
0.0107502379,
-0.0025247373,
-0.0027352099,
0.000705747,
0.0207541846,
-0.0034106239,
0.0088333404,
-0.0147364978,
-0.0304168817,
-0.0082041221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12125v1 | Efficient Sequential Decision Making with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T22:13:22 | 2024-06-17T22:13:22 | Dingyang Chen, Qi Zhang, Yinglun Zhu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This paper focuses on extending the success of large language models (LLMs)
to sequential decision making. Existing efforts either (i) re-train or finetune
LLMs for decision making, or (ii) design prompts for pretrained LLMs. The
former approach suffers from the computational burden of gradient updates, and
the latter approach does not show promising results. In this paper, we propose
a new approach that leverages online model selection algorithms to efficiently
incorporate LLMs agents into sequential decision making. Statistically, our
approach significantly outperforms both traditional decision making algorithms
and vanilla LLM agents. Computationally, our approach avoids the need for
expensive gradient updates of LLMs, and throughout the decision making process,
it requires only a small number of LLM calls. We conduct extensive experiments
to verify the effectiveness of our proposed approach. As an example, on a
large-scale Amazon dataset, our approach achieves more than a $6$x performance
gain over baselines while calling LLMs in only $1.5$\% of the time steps. | [
0.0154517889,
0.1100042835,
-0.0104985908,
-0.0126056299,
-0.0369814336,
0.0304576326,
0.0460396707,
0.0082005383,
0.0322836116,
-0.0635718629,
-0.0318749025,
-0.0312795602,
-0.0187346637,
0.0179913025,
-0.0207103658,
-0.0379181094,
0.0077245468,
-0.072056815,
0.0229414273,
-0.0318791382,
-0.0209906716,
-0.0014262978,
0.0014112158,
0.0285968333,
0.038991645,
-0.0034072499,
-0.0188216232,
-0.0269055683,
0.0233468954,
-0.0308820773,
0.0167645384,
0.0408393107,
0.0536958128,
0.0114718722,
0.0000021032,
-0.0367021263,
-0.0102055082,
-0.0141081847,
-0.0642496273,
0.0231409203,
0.0159453843,
0.0070129475,
-0.0129759433,
0.0192363486,
-0.0478689037,
0.000404867,
0.0378199257,
0.0162180793,
0.0395538025,
0.055728469,
-0.0023211676,
-0.0082029011,
0.0030224193,
-0.0524590015,
-0.0349326991,
-0.0743733495,
0.0370504893,
-0.0257452168,
0.0005400096,
-0.0063733612,
-0.0242910273,
0.0304016843,
0.0035320416,
-0.0281707495,
-0.0080249691,
0.037864048,
0.0106324349,
-0.0101597859,
-0.0374025181,
0.0674873367,
-0.0515234582,
0.0104240412,
0.0317174532,
-0.0225631818,
-0.0114393625,
-0.0038338173,
-0.0225425363,
0.0230649225,
0.0083389524,
0.0433544591,
0.0049811946,
-0.0014937599,
0.0298130941,
0.0667792857,
-0.0624467954,
0.074971512,
-0.0154516269,
-0.0313586891,
0.044191964,
0.0042521823,
-0.0068522971,
-0.0851375163,
0.0014610769,
0.0257725343,
-0.1063471735,
-0.0009246508,
-0.0143455202,
0.0018966474,
-0.0372478068,
-0.0167290997,
0.0792483464,
0.0216585025,
0.0207151007,
0.0813800097,
-0.0102590807,
0.0483937338,
0.0121607734,
-0.0024019785,
-0.0339631811,
0.0320988744,
-0.0211605225,
0.0221618339,
-0.0343645439,
0.0212053005,
-0.0188551228,
-0.032017529,
-0.0423768051,
0.0334436856,
-0.0106966039,
0.0210696105,
-0.0087202797,
-0.0097735096,
-0.0030240437,
-0.0162615348,
-0.0583311543,
-0.0105519611,
0.0001508192,
0.036160592,
-0.0106741553,
-0.0337046832,
0.0203403551,
0.0167626981,
-0.0005659015,
-0.0103253741,
0.0065427842,
0.0928014815,
-0.0357493013,
-0.0309706647,
-0.0294207204,
0.0098739769,
0.0412708186,
-0.0683984011,
-0.0432714634,
-0.0280748382,
0.0184213482,
0.0049202004,
-0.0007891411,
-0.0317420475,
0.0049019279,
0.0135765066,
-0.0132988635,
0.0618271455,
0.0067902533,
0.0387806781,
0.0112796687,
-0.0292667579,
-0.0073836837,
0.0646648109,
0.0229874048,
0.06325306,
0.0455072038,
-0.0185213443,
0.0066461405,
0.0294489358,
-0.0048482297,
0.0490740277,
-0.0527323671,
0.0178243592,
-0.0093146935,
0.0523989089,
0.026397543,
0.017071059,
-0.0591423772,
0.0146265151,
0.081202291,
0.038874466,
0.0350631699,
0.0000538531,
0.0265917052,
0.0585584044,
-0.005170723,
-0.0308197159,
-0.0439299382,
0.0155904591,
-0.0248301215,
-0.0028439502,
0.0187561195,
0.0476653352,
-0.0297258552,
-0.0417009033,
0.0093758851,
-0.0164884627,
0.0033590035,
0.0606268756,
0.0353058055,
-0.0333001725,
-0.011816564,
0.0207437556,
0.0324832425,
0.0030841625,
-0.0524259135,
-0.0744977668,
0.0284513738,
0.0914175808,
0.0566850863,
-0.0208320413,
-0.0423004255,
-0.0362101682,
0.0225707777,
0.028599415,
0.0325011872,
-0.0355188623,
0.0034698918,
-0.065736562,
-0.0746911839,
0.0510376953,
-0.0096235033,
0.0272715315,
0.0220422931,
0.0267497115,
-0.0006445673,
0.0011605758,
-0.0416454189,
0.0353877321,
-0.0245565195,
-0.0437948145,
0.0503121801,
0.004795955,
0.068456322,
-0.0477018617,
-0.0128179956,
-0.0229690485,
0.0047812779,
-0.0022768781,
-0.0322123468,
-0.0204995628,
-0.0296850223,
-0.0042498894,
0.0183934104,
0.0612271316,
-0.0099408282,
0.0214295238,
-0.0648197234,
-0.0374204963,
-0.0205759238,
-0.0249917842,
0.0211680196,
-0.0266192127,
0.0120117255,
-0.0192970205,
0.0092013441,
-0.0498102345,
0.0525079295,
-0.0197941773,
-0.002178668,
0.0470697768,
0.0157017279,
-0.025475096,
-0.0366306379,
-0.0063995575,
0.0462981425,
0.0206228755,
0.0172748547,
0.0224068724,
0.0265671723,
-0.0019258838,
-0.027522089,
-0.067671746,
-0.0156935863,
-0.0320869833,
0.0138164014,
-0.0271337517,
-0.0242521595,
-0.0213382561,
-0.0310077816,
-0.0019120544,
0.0416817442,
-0.0168453157,
0.0573755875,
-0.0013585422,
0.003492415,
-0.0336747132,
-0.0318459421,
-0.039616555,
0.0404988714,
0.0455566645,
-0.0107819214,
-0.0287271496,
-0.0590320863,
-0.0047750524,
-0.0265388694,
0.0128379166,
-0.0184024666,
-0.0258471649,
-0.00890199,
-0.0507475138,
0.002553364,
0.0545135476,
0.030206861,
0.0599665903,
0.0633393899,
0.0023351121,
-0.0600782298,
0.0250340495,
-0.0208455361,
-0.012769727,
-0.0634226426,
0.0266412403,
0.0096429409,
0.0694351494,
-0.0437751561,
0.007185691,
-0.0136055844,
-0.0013542393,
0.0005184811,
-0.0327906087,
-0.0639740303,
0.025778899,
-0.0055072038,
0.071033828,
0.0208271872,
-0.0793624893,
0.0760687366,
0.0222782195,
-0.0024867395,
-0.0418663174,
-0.037177898,
-0.0220847204,
0.0496092662,
0.0310456324,
-0.006603905,
-0.0404793285,
-0.0295220129,
-0.0244246349,
-0.0222895555,
0.0330129489,
-0.0184948407,
0.0336753577,
-0.0556283519,
0.0390572175,
-0.0117062815,
-0.0721208155,
-0.0474175401,
-0.0502137579,
-0.0625968054,
-0.0181513987,
-0.0020595524,
-0.022807721,
-0.050714951,
0.0119441496,
0.014689168,
0.0610839725,
-0.0274980683,
-0.0050386125,
-0.0059607783,
0.0014755557,
0.0412861109,
0.0474146232,
0.0232904386,
-0.0391225107,
0.063988924,
0.0244652163,
0.0565664023,
-0.0361333787,
-0.0239058733,
-0.0043221614,
0.0523048006,
-0.0663535073,
-0.0127397776,
0.0659711882,
-0.0211323891,
-0.0723757371,
0.0130665451,
0.0986533463,
0.0045849998,
-0.077617906,
-0.0085292254,
-0.0031591507,
0.0077818343,
0.0047005019,
0.0356975049,
-0.0487707034,
-0.0591807663,
0.0212795734,
0.0320103355,
-0.0070810574,
-0.0287596323,
-0.0014723816,
-0.0858129337,
0.0408684202,
-0.0063282577,
0.0028854029,
0.0335075073,
-0.0373765938,
0.0277937707,
-0.0273596141,
0.019420255,
0.030371882,
-0.0182330813,
-0.0212981384,
-0.0032838213,
-0.0262276549,
-0.0375483111,
0.0270556044,
0.0003720728,
0.0034867187,
0.085604094,
0.01508132,
0.0022656175,
-0.0263500232,
0.0631787851,
-0.0067043733,
0.0049996106,
-0.0330259725,
0.0197216067,
-0.0036431644,
-0.0170713533,
-0.0159923956,
0.0336016417,
0.0132932374,
0.0101768263,
0.0036491987,
0.0779554844,
-0.059228532,
-0.0332205817,
0.0163237266,
-0.0295968391,
0.0439049453,
0.0237510055,
-0.0177702643,
-0.0891891122,
-0.0736171082,
-0.0380708426,
-0.0547435693,
-0.0343730785,
-0.0246223956,
0.0111145023,
-0.0109684197,
-0.0185724981,
-0.0449455194,
-0.0043773991,
0.0415180176,
0.015944913,
0.004549433,
0.0368430167,
0.0512622558,
0.0178838875,
-0.0176738277,
0.006442002,
-0.0340834744,
0.0307448693,
-0.0795558468,
-0.0103719672,
0.0552499518,
-0.0200903639,
-0.0177894551,
0.005875824,
-0.0528548844,
-0.0582519658,
0.0042317687,
0.0388709866,
0.0237536244,
0.0206960663,
-0.0052233683,
-0.0689202398,
0.0495437831,
0.0571757518,
-0.0161302835,
-0.0092529533,
0.0308749247,
0.017923614,
-0.0249149278,
0.055727642,
-0.027973948,
0.023051491,
0.0265807509,
0.0069698757,
-0.0351478048,
-0.0352203511,
-0.0138377687,
0.0015243606,
0.0344010107,
-0.021104306,
-0.016141966,
-0.0332267322,
0.0641569793,
0.0414709374,
-0.0161665697,
-0.0416919142,
0.0127119226,
0.0217025187,
-0.0246282816,
0.0024269125,
0.0208033044,
0.0398270227,
-0.0310301539,
-0.0128989397,
0.0275911018,
-0.0000914588,
0.019915171,
0.0736783519,
-0.023518905,
-0.000071117,
0.0263531208,
0.0462689027,
0.0269514788,
-0.0204404723,
0.0474618673,
0.0309076309,
0.0107914228,
-0.048656255,
0.0187823158,
-0.0494912416,
-0.0969734341,
-0.0008178107,
0.0295842141,
0.062368311,
-0.0054065702,
0.0477032289,
-0.03294136,
-0.0098462859,
-0.0443934798,
0.0116715673,
-0.0019233202,
-0.0241844449,
0.0193066373,
0.0367220342,
-0.0375129879,
0.0402274802,
0.0663509667,
0.0092427786,
0.0106441928,
0.0167977922,
-0.0285159983,
-0.0412246957,
-0.0469663553,
-0.0106663499,
-0.0064591169,
-0.0228619017,
-0.0008812866,
-0.010758549,
-0.0251565594,
-0.0033102259,
-0.0094737234,
-0.039338395,
-0.0554016978,
0.0484838262,
0.0418534577,
0.0136204557,
0.0349555351,
-0.0644452497,
0.0101526314,
-0.0103171756,
-0.0251366254,
-0.0167633593,
-6.053744112e-33,
0.0271062534,
-0.029401008,
0.0350188874,
-0.0297550764,
-0.019942943,
-0.012057635,
-0.0144990869,
-0.0043755812,
0.0321233049,
0.0168366171,
-0.0314961448,
-0.0008690856,
0.0286770202,
0.0249638893,
0.0393988341,
-0.0181043707,
0.0507955588,
-0.0022409305,
-0.0288489889,
0.0214090329,
0.0275645666,
0.0341256373,
0.0192073695,
-0.0157583877,
-0.037671458,
0.0150026204,
-0.0181957502,
0.0019845641,
-0.0325515606,
0.079551667,
-0.0117158731,
0.0161391776,
0.0205262098,
-0.0599340573,
-0.0384429693,
0.0155798038,
-0.0195297766,
-0.0139018958,
-0.0377697945,
0.013421217,
-0.0406092256,
-0.0203417223,
-0.0052967072,
0.0187486559,
-0.0337693468,
0.0205034837,
0.0063199461,
-0.0395416208,
-0.0738170147,
-0.021703789,
-0.0369755179,
0.0465033986,
0.0095927622,
-0.0232009161,
0.0511136353,
0.0224924907,
-0.0217082761,
-0.0051508709,
-0.0228689946,
0.0265250504,
0.0275072567,
0.0358692296,
0.0119558265,
0.0291104205,
0.0099598998,
0.0562470332,
0.0073851049,
-0.0194627289,
0.0009760908,
0.0191862714,
-0.0087333657,
0.0453604497,
0.0063741747,
0.0150939617,
0.0087729534,
-0.026883658,
-0.0726686493,
-0.0005536586,
0.0502817966,
0.0488474183,
0.0570490584,
0.0229655709,
-0.020316096,
-0.0422882438,
-0.0358092301,
-0.0117270239,
-0.0269639753,
-0.0033389179,
0.0435390174,
0.0487903953,
-0.0092991879,
-0.0414841734,
0.0523044094,
-0.0125227664,
-0.0519760288,
0.0084497463,
-0.0252408125,
0.0231074765,
0.0305346921,
0.022479482,
-0.0626761913,
-0.0648524985,
-0.0207520742,
-0.0501683168,
-0.0074018212,
-0.0280930493,
-0.0090280641,
0.0352478214,
-0.0590362996,
0.006714446,
0.0021288898,
0.0241337139,
0.0188258812,
0.047170762,
0.0529340617,
-0.0250314455,
0.018595431,
0.0706008747,
-0.0149716754,
-0.0367873386,
-0.0090850461,
-0.0205524713,
-0.005517635,
0.0163993314,
-0.0248002205,
0.014569127,
-0.0705639347,
0.0210347585,
-0.0008793914,
-0.0349240154,
0.0003316367,
0.0354502201,
2.762e-7,
-0.012866837,
0.0647652149,
-0.0178748574,
0.030916322,
0.046045538,
0.0437678732,
-0.0213846695,
-0.0043532765,
0.0074002515,
0.0214142539,
0.050860256,
0.0286243316,
0.0808884948,
0.0065940176,
-0.0786515698,
-0.0165236462,
-0.0489660166,
0.0416210704,
-0.0761085972,
-0.0345488489,
0.0150696924,
0.1012150273,
0.0039250301,
-0.0170192961,
0.0247034356,
-0.0232350845,
0.0383760072,
-0.03258669,
0.0041763401,
0.027821172,
0.0507509634,
0.011486602,
-0.0452401824,
0.0066728452,
-0.0054060696,
0.0357672274,
-0.0278351214,
0.1027866825,
0.0261283182,
0.0174474344,
-0.0011879457,
-0.0020481765,
0.0348921828,
-0.0107093547,
0.0969050378,
-0.0515729599,
-0.0171970818,
-0.0414476059,
0.0501475148,
-0.0588237382,
0.0245528556,
-0.0408180431,
-0.0302612055,
0.037306238,
0.0152143883,
-0.0121590532,
-0.0031635871,
-0.0913913622,
0.0208724067,
0.0287874043,
-0.0476561263,
-0.0409277976,
-0.0739733279,
0.0313704871,
0.0635405108,
-0.0493966565,
0.0120385867,
2.274166013e-34,
0.0426531173,
-0.0002986043,
-0.0039739115,
0.0397006311,
0.0023909009,
0.0128068533,
-0.004290726,
0.0201573242,
0.0382576697,
-0.1010205373,
-0.0162184909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12117v1 | Decoding the Narratives: Analyzing Personal Drug Experiences Shared on Reddit | 2024-06-17T21:56:57 | 2024-06-17T21:56:57 | Layla Bouzoubaa, Elham Aghakhani, Max Song, Minh Trinh, Rezvaneh Rezapour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online communities such as drug-related subreddits serve as safe spaces for
people who use drugs (PWUD), fostering discussions on substance use
experiences, harm reduction, and addiction recovery. Users' shared narratives
on these forums provide insights into the likelihood of developing a substance
use disorder (SUD) and recovery potential. Our study aims to develop a
multi-level, multi-label classification model to analyze online user-generated
texts about substance use experiences. For this purpose, we first introduce a
novel taxonomy to assess the nature of posts, including their intended
connections (Inquisition or Disclosure), subjects (e.g., Recovery, Dependency),
and specific objectives (e.g., Relapse, Quality, Safety). Using various
multi-label classification algorithms on a set of annotated data, we show that
GPT-4, when prompted with instructions, definitions, and examples, outperformed
all other models. We apply this model to label an additional 1,000 posts and
analyze the categories of linguistic expression used within posts in each
class. Our analysis shows that topics such as Safety, Combination of
Substances, and Mental Health see more disclosure, while discussions about
physiological Effects focus on harm reduction. Our work enriches the
understanding of PWUD's experiences and informs the broader knowledge base on
SUD and drug use. | [
0.0586424582,
0.0882873461,
-0.0201455634,
-0.0288784951,
-0.0168072879,
0.0095829852,
-0.0068075303,
0.004841052,
0.0469282828,
-0.0753320009,
0.0250913054,
0.0145251779,
-0.028013587,
0.0356670395,
-0.0078550754,
-0.0225670766,
-0.0020368004,
0.0606624745,
0.0620678477,
0.0237545632,
0.0341714956,
0.0484991074,
-0.0250055362,
0.0435191877,
-0.0260539949,
-0.0382230431,
0.0378400348,
-0.0206596646,
0.0249051675,
-0.0595749691,
0.0540135428,
0.0810544342,
0.0114062857,
0.0219925269,
0.0000018773,
0.0104580447,
-0.0120815141,
-0.0085356953,
0.0059632361,
-0.0451671258,
0.0681025162,
-0.0098060314,
0.0296284854,
0.0219987538,
-0.0473906174,
-0.0397151411,
0.0643890426,
0.0702348948,
0.0155026121,
0.0469263941,
-0.0456538089,
-0.0766309947,
-0.0283126067,
0.0110031674,
0.0313671008,
-0.0150895044,
0.0354814157,
0.0199446026,
0.0129426792,
-0.0024761728,
0.0334348343,
0.0351109877,
-0.0359274484,
0.0130182235,
0.0487203598,
0.0205590706,
0.0141757466,
-0.0729776844,
0.0356494151,
0.0555594191,
0.0366904847,
-0.0071455427,
0.0385718271,
0.0035944683,
-0.0052589788,
0.0518970564,
-0.0342854485,
-0.0114406906,
-0.0396569557,
0.0249482077,
-0.0047495593,
0.0192547012,
0.0476876535,
-0.0223166142,
0.0557652116,
0.0358626992,
-0.0113248201,
0.0045871879,
0.0064729494,
-0.0265294556,
0.0184086561,
-0.0555896796,
0.0450616404,
-0.0115173869,
-0.0176201835,
0.0392529704,
0.0073915045,
-0.0216245428,
0.040474806,
-0.0576252081,
-0.016157968,
-0.0069349068,
-0.0081040123,
0.0051797405,
0.0271080323,
-0.0653547719,
0.0419686548,
0.0169637632,
-0.0080511617,
0.0243947171,
-0.0927985832,
-0.0128035089,
-0.0367052853,
0.0348550305,
0.0319466479,
-0.0207822397,
-0.0364331082,
0.0257647634,
-0.014781802,
-0.0749186203,
-0.0271683522,
-0.0022814567,
-0.0131846508,
0.0430950709,
-0.0009433731,
0.0098382393,
-0.0251177996,
0.0321618877,
0.0104256561,
0.0502634309,
0.0432041548,
-0.0109882364,
0.0381448865,
-0.0434658527,
-0.0206230488,
0.0407612026,
0.0220444798,
-0.0200526621,
-0.0555447452,
-0.0522398725,
-0.0285714343,
-0.0066813305,
-0.0060504912,
-0.0432058573,
0.0728680342,
-0.0038043784,
0.0062526949,
-0.0504198112,
0.0270069186,
0.0225657299,
-0.0622835532,
0.0574625395,
-0.0423172452,
0.038704738,
0.0818697065,
0.0493054576,
0.0341442935,
-0.0041762334,
0.0176896397,
0.0425504297,
0.0532781184,
-0.0316595845,
0.0204296634,
-0.0275717601,
-0.0112945884,
-0.0393534265,
0.0360233113,
-0.0260636322,
0.0161311291,
-0.0045653232,
-0.0579170212,
0.0071594445,
-0.0256298855,
0.0560136773,
0.0449919924,
0.0772664323,
0.0233910475,
0.0190096889,
0.0019516221,
0.0066727553,
-0.0208561141,
-0.0101328054,
-0.0274349041,
-0.0184986722,
0.0151901562,
-0.038301181,
0.0712520257,
-0.0179320294,
-0.0033854577,
-0.0211811196,
-0.0643452927,
-0.0291944183,
-0.0057721161,
-0.0295908544,
-0.0384199619,
-0.0060003269,
-0.0162604228,
0.0247096326,
0.0591562465,
-0.0120629193,
-0.0343469903,
-0.0371203087,
0.0722613558,
0.0484830886,
0.032053683,
-0.030025417,
-0.0014890432,
-0.0341047719,
0.0679888725,
0.030562792,
-0.0097905817,
-0.0025377704,
-0.0309667345,
0.0463930108,
-0.0203548651,
-0.0086852266,
0.0071371701,
-0.0309445187,
-0.0296597555,
-0.0137517815,
-0.0190359857,
0.0200490747,
-0.0443859994,
0.0518445149,
0.0478808247,
-0.0265549459,
-0.0006205083,
0.0119310841,
0.0348611139,
0.0170199331,
0.0070724571,
-0.0148358764,
0.0301294699,
0.0022089388,
-0.0797860548,
-0.0263281036,
0.0160562675,
0.0060274974,
0.0041352115,
-0.0454143211,
0.0475509502,
-0.023552848,
-0.0058334363,
-0.0090828836,
0.0555237457,
-0.0504569858,
0.0348740034,
-0.0152758192,
-0.0566733181,
0.0121885967,
-0.0100734103,
-0.0318205506,
0.0594409741,
0.0092260353,
0.0327647179,
-0.0679252222,
-0.1176844463,
-0.019418858,
0.0334197059,
0.0331807807,
-0.005252094,
-0.0391721539,
0.0332259424,
0.064866282,
0.0184884947,
-0.0019054357,
-0.0256867316,
-0.0545230359,
0.020383589,
-0.0251673926,
0.0280186292,
0.033832483,
-0.0302764717,
0.0139653068,
-0.0260302499,
-0.0138509953,
-0.0091499602,
-0.0248210318,
0.0264456794,
-0.00988709,
0.0344633907,
0.0279575195,
-0.0062294914,
-0.0058485721,
-0.0487229303,
0.056308452,
0.015851438,
-0.0659079701,
-0.0053030783,
-0.0202575605,
-0.0675360486,
-0.038375888,
0.0256125592,
-0.0214413386,
0.0245473888,
0.0271992311,
0.0453149155,
-0.0135730589,
0.0347631387,
0.0497794859,
0.0263282917,
0.0257449448,
-0.0115329083,
-0.012950181,
-0.059525311,
-0.0661469325,
-0.0140717989,
-0.1028139666,
0.0306473318,
0.0751934052,
0.0439112261,
-0.0018499179,
-0.0406967327,
0.0216251947,
-0.0506546721,
-0.0012580333,
-0.0393542051,
-0.0365513228,
-0.0022173843,
0.0009364063,
-0.0088068331,
-0.0356215201,
0.0476536304,
0.0520220548,
0.034410242,
-0.0088497773,
-0.037823543,
-0.0040034135,
-0.0049666222,
0.0366114415,
0.0474433862,
0.0551828593,
-0.007502683,
0.11200618,
-0.0233005658,
0.0120288981,
-0.030703472,
-0.013375869,
-0.0407249033,
0.0106745744,
0.0083053429,
-0.0329166688,
-0.00379753,
-0.0852940679,
-0.0120433923,
-0.0313958004,
-0.0069579883,
0.0229531378,
-0.0270616543,
0.0087170647,
-0.0011663233,
0.0096388003,
-0.0027494074,
-0.0305779669,
0.0099995974,
0.0382871255,
0.0558331907,
-0.0582416765,
-0.0021038586,
0.0096473312,
0.0244179908,
0.0480326787,
-0.0172277633,
0.0291699097,
0.0357267782,
-0.0299956873,
-0.0075309277,
-0.0058323103,
-0.0115644932,
0.030760739,
-0.0034774269,
-0.0071270061,
-0.003860181,
0.062970303,
0.0536571182,
-0.0283881277,
0.0251069795,
-0.0042179232,
-0.0349041149,
0.0222898647,
-0.018695293,
-0.1196060255,
-0.0002081893,
-0.0526909269,
0.0122557273,
-0.0703227371,
-0.0119333332,
-0.0024261207,
-0.0176150855,
0.0288638454,
-0.0020441923,
-0.0742149949,
0.0338395499,
-0.0820524469,
-0.0039877165,
-0.0298389308,
-0.0136691481,
-0.0228627529,
0.0013008562,
0.0016312498,
0.0353732407,
-0.0541217215,
-0.0301759783,
0.0004389492,
-0.0087336404,
0.030869605,
-0.0494861826,
0.0445046872,
-0.0147607587,
-0.0210991148,
0.0220873803,
0.0147771342,
-0.0084340042,
0.0288716927,
0.0491262749,
-0.0411430076,
0.0146378865,
-0.0814054385,
0.0716099218,
-0.0754087195,
-0.0525346175,
-0.0309789758,
0.1081643477,
0.0129709672,
-0.0575644411,
-0.0150435874,
0.022449078,
0.0484700054,
0.0258703213,
0.0284182783,
-0.0133216763,
-0.0001481373,
-0.0158903562,
0.0517602116,
-0.0048467484,
-0.0608112067,
-0.0411783755,
0.0001886123,
-0.008373443,
-0.0361677706,
-0.0359401107,
-0.0119463252,
-0.059540391,
-0.0030994611,
-0.0043200045,
0.0116722072,
-0.0293035749,
-0.0210026,
0.0479665324,
-0.0054021231,
0.022727102,
-0.0294885188,
-0.0411553383,
0.0208077282,
0.0127197541,
0.0078046084,
0.0564367585,
-0.0152391316,
-0.0044296891,
0.0689438134,
-0.0374469124,
0.0104456479,
-0.0445471555,
-0.0112786945,
-0.0488015451,
0.0002945751,
0.0297754891,
-0.0582476668,
-0.0131477844,
0.0025519398,
0.042871397,
0.0100146206,
0.008493253,
-0.0089059891,
0.0041315844,
-0.0108480798,
-0.0573407486,
-0.0668223351,
-0.0311585441,
0.0088221841,
-0.0340871401,
0.0473566763,
-0.0189076345,
-0.0054601319,
-0.0390068553,
-0.0431289822,
-0.017419152,
-0.0210975837,
0.0504997224,
-0.0155838057,
0.0554413609,
-0.0325762853,
-0.0561000593,
0.0091818105,
-0.0771852434,
0.031588871,
-0.0475067124,
-0.0288027339,
0.0529098399,
0.0081877643,
-0.0164524857,
-0.0028999473,
-0.0067037186,
-0.0234278161,
0.0111993197,
0.0291903913,
-0.0337923281,
0.0598862991,
-0.0234144796,
-0.0334435329,
0.019215418,
0.0365443826,
-0.0256688222,
-0.0220948327,
-0.0036439765,
-0.0190150309,
0.0308618713,
0.0022254034,
0.0391683914,
-0.0190745927,
-0.0313994884,
-0.0122599639,
0.0655934066,
-0.0232574586,
-0.0290370192,
0.0084912973,
0.0006984422,
-0.0325548276,
0.0010307127,
0.053980384,
0.0039389306,
-0.0026176483,
-0.0003216743,
-0.0486467704,
-0.0133536709,
0.0018141993,
-0.0462898538,
0.0724106729,
-0.0110719586,
0.0037171568,
-0.0624253787,
-0.0407040156,
0.0082685957,
-0.025592804,
0.0037931297,
0.0133907134,
0.0073054135,
0.0373568423,
0.0187768377,
-0.0355136059,
-0.0665221065,
0.0024413802,
0.0134700667,
0.0074339458,
-0.0316605531,
-5.811388768e-33,
0.0269610807,
-0.0659725964,
-0.0335879773,
0.0149076711,
-0.0231739637,
-0.0016248361,
0.0054084877,
0.0410638824,
0.0381411947,
0.0334275514,
0.045555532,
0.0099912416,
0.0030251001,
0.0083910078,
0.0235508271,
0.0126665207,
0.0147626139,
-0.0112224454,
-0.0236770902,
0.0532526523,
0.0191385914,
0.0523256212,
0.0274810418,
-0.0827240571,
0.0724301711,
0.0116534531,
0.0212005582,
0.0182342418,
0.0160978176,
0.022575153,
-0.0645225123,
0.077091068,
0.0418108255,
-0.0118822893,
0.032675378,
0.0558974296,
-0.0616835319,
-0.0327801183,
0.0249344315,
-0.0418866388,
-0.056583669,
-0.0469477735,
0.0272707511,
0.0006235348,
0.0335775577,
-0.035898488,
0.0906451568,
0.0094642937,
0.0275438856,
-0.0206188131,
-0.0116842156,
0.0063118208,
-0.0178008806,
-0.0224891137,
-0.0477645807,
0.0332872905,
-0.0178738926,
0.0363507457,
-0.0483251959,
-0.0131158428,
-0.075783059,
0.0309108291,
-0.0100875162,
-0.029116584,
-0.0047393474,
0.0385767594,
-0.0180178862,
0.0240354594,
-0.0200421922,
0.0020121934,
-0.0490065925,
0.0354287773,
0.0229044762,
0.0275650099,
0.0304448809,
-0.0204204619,
-0.0576609746,
-0.0369519405,
-0.019384928,
-0.0117573179,
0.0258494578,
0.0130497338,
-0.0158307794,
-0.0071391151,
-0.0256877802,
-0.0049750633,
-0.0221856385,
-0.0080410121,
-0.0560180321,
-0.0250759441,
-0.0394240655,
0.0277712122,
-0.0272831023,
-0.0356117226,
-0.0474959165,
0.0040266253,
0.0113383178,
0.0235231817,
-0.0114317611,
0.0195445009,
-0.0537286736,
0.0557118393,
0.0023634168,
0.0164247882,
0.0540660694,
-0.0216914378,
0.0608624034,
-0.001510571,
-0.0443808362,
-0.0088233044,
0.01398376,
0.0084265079,
0.0221549477,
0.0239445511,
0.0110001639,
0.0643816814,
0.0146487625,
0.043093428,
0.0335420966,
0.025143588,
-0.0060472586,
-0.0236418433,
-0.0324517861,
0.0011674663,
0.0040215421,
0.0000062185,
-0.0079801502,
0.0369757488,
0.0716193989,
-0.0387651511,
-0.0039851856,
-0.0373702459,
2.685e-7,
0.068489477,
0.0332278423,
-0.0187157299,
-0.009613459,
0.0406915769,
0.0158765353,
0.054614868,
0.0312594362,
0.0101266745,
-0.0339907594,
0.0060488544,
0.0272982176,
0.0190552622,
0.0527579598,
0.013023871,
-0.0040025883,
-0.0588020012,
-0.0344507881,
-0.0841910467,
0.0032479013,
0.0593690202,
0.0310357288,
0.0256076045,
-0.0114783822,
-0.0299026687,
-0.0004199084,
0.021166306,
-0.0196195301,
-0.0321846232,
0.0423433669,
0.0076311119,
0.0301650278,
-0.0008384863,
0.0054355185,
-0.0209185779,
-0.0333268419,
0.0249804538,
0.0301943738,
-0.0329930373,
-0.0434582271,
0.0212831348,
-0.0138085028,
0.02639414,
0.0125901587,
0.0695844069,
-0.064605616,
-0.0198702589,
-0.0304085556,
0.0136890048,
-0.0384748578,
0.0569353029,
-0.0583034195,
-0.0616683438,
0.047424227,
0.005933295,
0.0294978544,
-0.0067448844,
-0.0714643374,
-0.0155392457,
0.0651040301,
-0.0596464835,
0.0100344783,
0.0405296832,
0.0091694947,
-0.0125920204,
-0.0630369708,
0.0437076502,
1.570345429e-34,
-0.0450807437,
0.0350419804,
-0.0162132923,
-0.0308684446,
0.0558647513,
-0.0000079484,
-0.0084637105,
-0.0387386046,
-0.0184532683,
-0.042779658,
0.0101535683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12114v1 | Enhancing Text Classification through LLM-Driven Active Learning and Human Annotation | 2024-06-17T21:45:48 | 2024-06-17T21:45:48 | Hamidreza Rouzegar, Masoud Makrehchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | In the context of text classification, the financial burden of annotation
exercises for creating training data is a critical issue. Active learning
techniques, particularly those rooted in uncertainty sampling, offer a
cost-effective solution by pinpointing the most instructive samples for manual
annotation. Similarly, Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5 provide an
alternative for automated annotation but come with concerns regarding their
reliability. This study introduces a novel methodology that integrates human
annotators and LLMs within an Active Learning framework. We conducted
evaluations on three public datasets. IMDB for sentiment analysis, a Fake News
dataset for authenticity discernment, and a Movie Genres dataset for
multi-label classification.The proposed framework integrates human annotation
with the output of LLMs, depending on the model uncertainty levels. This
strategy achieves an optimal balance between cost efficiency and classification
performance. The empirical results show a substantial decrease in the costs
associated with data annotation while either maintaining or improving model
accuracy. | [
0.0549943708,
0.0304024089,
-0.0085102981,
0.0306839272,
-0.0158232097,
0.0419552065,
0.0150770778,
0.0229522437,
0.0359492749,
-0.1207503453,
-0.0256464556,
-0.0208285302,
-0.0365871303,
0.0011035436,
0.0284685399,
-0.0300678648,
0.0315647274,
-0.0319734402,
0.0547260717,
0.0104905199,
0.0105350399,
0.0241616946,
-0.0055358838,
0.0081769628,
-0.0293646362,
0.0171111487,
0.0240828637,
0.0035076644,
0.0051711411,
-0.0237461198,
0.0168228298,
0.0787160769,
0.0197671391,
0.0616382137,
0.000001788,
-0.0578451268,
-0.0253283121,
0.0161110386,
-0.0280603841,
0.0352979898,
0.0446778648,
0.0447903052,
0.0203825068,
0.0079036281,
-0.0284411982,
-0.0204514805,
0.0431090817,
0.0097173825,
0.0638335049,
0.0362723581,
-0.0140247596,
0.000602546,
0.0110970503,
-0.0273382552,
0.0190448463,
-0.0623673163,
0.0342658199,
0.0216877852,
-0.016832618,
0.0521918163,
0.0376467146,
0.0271710288,
-0.0177926272,
-0.0257128999,
0.0182623845,
-0.0052663232,
-0.050022684,
-0.0202213321,
0.0206324738,
0.006143752,
0.0382257588,
-0.0237527136,
-0.0102560315,
-0.0693875924,
0.0203632861,
0.0506942421,
-0.014140496,
0.0239657219,
-0.0142957009,
0.0360196158,
-0.0122432308,
-0.0141060688,
0.0300996006,
0.0416361801,
0.0534895323,
0.0271727405,
-0.0376948155,
-0.0307442769,
0.0628466234,
0.0553230569,
-0.0604606643,
-0.033464957,
0.0154000344,
0.0193502307,
0.0141778365,
0.0115493881,
-0.0234962068,
-0.031021785,
0.043344751,
-0.0849334523,
-0.0002348502,
-0.0252629146,
-0.0213937033,
0.0602759719,
0.0141860042,
-0.0216981154,
0.0241912324,
0.0153072895,
0.0006185013,
0.0210849121,
-0.0423512645,
-0.0233991258,
-0.0054675066,
0.0487207659,
0.0154685462,
0.0166964866,
-0.0848899707,
0.0310673323,
-0.0334349312,
0.0242237262,
0.0008900265,
-0.0081664938,
-0.0161542818,
0.0089208456,
-0.0364408307,
-0.0354249328,
0.0270351581,
0.0557304919,
-0.0516150557,
-0.0186233111,
0.029432565,
0.0498619005,
-0.0082397461,
-0.0139544262,
0.0157214683,
0.0284779966,
-0.0072510182,
-0.07325425,
-0.0575112812,
-0.0161797106,
0.0018932867,
-0.0062752939,
-0.0235016756,
-0.0381468348,
-0.0331459716,
-0.0074972911,
-0.0022974384,
-0.038332127,
-0.0021012509,
0.0018491235,
-0.0275115073,
0.0641025975,
-0.0305337589,
-0.0191739611,
0.0751766711,
-0.0060144397,
-0.0231770352,
0.0540546775,
0.0256287213,
0.0594812036,
0.0763617381,
0.0243886523,
0.0300915167,
0.0223137494,
0.0001630504,
0.0202458054,
-0.0180171002,
0.0082590012,
-0.0214537326,
-0.0116405739,
-0.0380718186,
0.0329155475,
-0.0192958396,
0.0130811818,
0.0593234412,
0.0194509923,
-0.0401124284,
-0.0436885729,
0.0342904329,
0.0382974483,
0.055307921,
-0.0107129784,
-0.0253373124,
-0.0053897002,
-0.0371634997,
-0.0162407029,
0.0125576444,
-0.0433234386,
-0.0100891255,
-0.0504296832,
-0.06865298,
-0.042934563,
0.0134962834,
0.044521872,
0.0476455763,
-0.0171711538,
-0.0013329523,
0.022752367,
0.0234653652,
0.0042648893,
0.0100562153,
-0.0832860544,
0.0462442227,
0.0309481174,
0.0064564338,
-0.0675487667,
-0.0013968301,
-0.0539457239,
0.0319872461,
0.0225572176,
0.0418966077,
-0.0498827361,
-0.0279387776,
-0.0355314612,
-0.047088407,
0.0113310982,
0.0507833064,
0.0195065737,
0.0262256693,
-0.0158667713,
0.0164822619,
-0.0412155837,
-0.064829655,
0.0562903099,
0.0063963383,
-0.0381929167,
0.0086868601,
-0.0275515486,
0.0676248744,
0.0230789259,
-0.0259610806,
-0.0217482448,
0.0272958986,
0.0321947783,
-0.0421718098,
-0.0267151836,
0.0620940477,
0.0462585501,
0.0247576889,
0.0038558354,
-0.0506288782,
-0.0029292768,
-0.0534574613,
-0.0018241198,
-0.074030377,
-0.0311634671,
-0.0368281193,
-0.098910965,
0.0013266867,
-0.04086354,
0.0039209016,
-0.0612763017,
0.0472521633,
-0.0062837396,
0.0195898805,
0.0054837186,
-0.0443896614,
0.0382181518,
-0.0191933792,
-0.0285188667,
-0.0381925069,
0.031933222,
0.0310097225,
0.0366107896,
0.0316943377,
-0.0069208313,
-0.0233858172,
-0.0688443929,
-0.0160392653,
-0.0092252186,
0.0093736015,
-0.002642296,
-0.0213249717,
-0.0120140612,
0.0024732684,
0.0003846869,
-0.0256052613,
-0.0164024122,
0.0340976194,
0.0298008993,
-0.0047681113,
0.0255130325,
-0.0297997911,
0.0103256749,
-0.0002997543,
0.0229440164,
0.0545134582,
-0.0529224202,
-0.0670282841,
0.0043957122,
0.0037611865,
0.0018471162,
0.0216282997,
-0.0049118269,
-0.0046492727,
0.0015016082,
-0.0766407251,
0.0137012331,
0.0188818984,
0.0364408232,
0.0304319616,
0.0334628001,
-0.034572579,
0.0043525524,
-0.0229190215,
-0.0198466014,
-0.0420833007,
-0.053805314,
0.0212553944,
0.0127500724,
-0.0127630066,
-0.0240658149,
-0.0329993591,
0.0151253249,
-0.0044974829,
-0.0232105162,
-0.0202792715,
-0.0085145729,
-0.023516262,
0.0342164226,
0.0241507143,
-0.0490155853,
0.0688784197,
-0.0348912627,
0.0365233719,
-0.0256265011,
-0.0248748157,
0.0099914009,
0.0243290048,
0.0126256216,
0.0051093376,
-0.0006802194,
0.0006808307,
-0.0298217274,
-0.0430181921,
0.0894779265,
-0.026236929,
0.0059837443,
-0.0376146026,
0.0397724397,
0.0053173206,
-0.0062471894,
-0.044831533,
-0.0583042279,
-0.0409780703,
-0.0060814652,
0.0036853107,
-0.0098614637,
0.0116572212,
0.0380664058,
-0.0133648524,
0.0516588837,
-0.0046330122,
-0.0212280583,
0.0136172436,
0.0250681415,
0.0107055353,
-0.006533308,
-0.0077267066,
-0.0323197842,
-0.035396304,
0.0340270735,
-0.0269858446,
0.0051559573,
0.0015485883,
-0.0147853028,
0.0380868353,
-0.0329425931,
0.0078270948,
0.0028433742,
0.0164313447,
-0.0213582348,
0.000775559,
0.1258845776,
0.0414284877,
-0.0750780776,
-0.0234744754,
0.0156101296,
-0.0011925033,
0.0210155118,
0.021180518,
-0.0474455468,
-0.023182245,
-0.0130233029,
0.0819031149,
-0.0230682213,
-0.0306219086,
0.0025546849,
-0.0917362571,
0.062147744,
-0.0177959204,
-0.0260566324,
0.025585765,
-0.0642562062,
-0.0011743683,
-0.0286229998,
0.0097745946,
-0.0475652143,
0.0242268853,
0.0268898867,
0.042415373,
-0.0618034601,
-0.0551894009,
-0.0045314636,
0.0059526255,
0.0527215973,
0.0229537655,
0.0201703589,
-0.0295261405,
-0.022173008,
0.081350036,
-0.0313851424,
-0.0117127383,
-0.010507579,
0.0950295478,
-0.0032960679,
0.0178659111,
0.0221107937,
0.0179554354,
-0.0011268657,
-0.0193060804,
0.0163790975,
0.0578405149,
-0.0287699942,
0.0297520012,
-0.0142579228,
-0.0082319546,
0.0300579909,
0.0411040559,
-0.0182813965,
-0.0515035838,
0.0037154008,
-0.0097631784,
0.0178013574,
-0.0057332353,
-0.0141978329,
0.0459320955,
-0.0872546434,
-0.0493508205,
-0.0491857193,
-0.0233994517,
0.0248204134,
0.0463256538,
0.0180608109,
0.0353772901,
0.019548608,
0.005990447,
-0.0252418239,
0.0004546736,
-0.0254649129,
0.0090056146,
-0.0026885811,
-0.0549384765,
0.0262137949,
-0.0416024476,
-0.0368825346,
0.0180542041,
-0.0755877718,
-0.0560838878,
0.0254047215,
0.0414245054,
0.0294827651,
0.0466511287,
-0.0069396226,
-0.087149851,
0.0273016673,
0.0544736683,
0.0003652456,
-0.0091918744,
0.0306280628,
0.0083845099,
-0.0389412418,
0.0002957639,
-0.062394809,
0.0151371202,
0.0585892573,
-0.0246584732,
-0.0563248396,
-0.0544961169,
0.0016576594,
0.0391160175,
0.0752408803,
-0.0539233685,
0.0014036826,
-0.0378522761,
0.0013424327,
0.0133836912,
-0.0273505691,
-0.0281902272,
0.0185214356,
0.0310424641,
-0.0153355831,
-0.0722091123,
0.0076131024,
-0.0036717912,
0.0714614168,
-0.0253133643,
-0.0007303049,
0.0260836035,
0.0163134988,
-0.0122624431,
-0.021886047,
-0.0205069222,
0.0424407348,
0.0100770872,
0.0349697918,
0.0317291841,
0.0413992107,
0.0116624739,
0.0231878385,
0.006827754,
0.0069692382,
-0.0509791821,
-0.0212434176,
-0.0608636923,
0.0741764903,
0.0384928212,
-0.0172995571,
0.0405927673,
-0.0432047956,
-0.0346342549,
0.0081540514,
0.0201597251,
0.0242507048,
-0.0037606643,
0.0093393885,
0.0121888677,
-0.0460241251,
0.0550398864,
0.0525895581,
0.0324142836,
0.0163219627,
-0.0316981375,
-0.08954335,
-0.0406748205,
-0.0130082332,
0.0230664779,
0.0164578408,
-0.0097308792,
0.001674371,
-0.022226166,
-0.0748777688,
0.0207659658,
-0.034702681,
0.00514577,
-0.0126129473,
0.0211750008,
0.0712089762,
0.01402843,
0.0469092578,
-0.0581227243,
-0.0233883876,
0.0242784955,
0.0065258979,
0.0142782331,
-5.751205294e-33,
0.0001810507,
-0.0415020101,
-0.0542229153,
0.0472787023,
0.0022585851,
0.0148648117,
0.0375707783,
-0.020100167,
0.0378770456,
0.0210546553,
0.0143358521,
0.0214253049,
0.0201646388,
0.0099870227,
0.0078039966,
-0.026225483,
0.0247284044,
-0.0153561905,
-0.0274028666,
0.0045917658,
0.0358190164,
0.0151471701,
0.0282400027,
-0.1273788363,
0.0835752711,
0.0066972673,
-0.0643318221,
0.0271141678,
0.0056496682,
0.0387432426,
-0.0212038755,
0.0490779877,
0.0139740938,
-0.0151397949,
0.0191533975,
-0.052037552,
-0.0313737467,
0.0095011424,
-0.0144445598,
0.030439496,
0.0293312073,
0.0206533447,
0.0138131538,
-0.0151397297,
-0.0197283905,
0.0226238407,
0.055582583,
-0.0293637514,
-0.0221689418,
-0.0854653567,
-0.0219702665,
0.0460970663,
-0.0341890454,
0.0539586172,
0.0318487138,
-0.0070631756,
0.0027409033,
0.0154728889,
-0.0677888468,
-0.0194234978,
-0.0147713991,
0.002555395,
-0.0087194555,
0.003570942,
-0.0234505758,
0.0394888036,
0.0096599068,
0.0103588542,
-0.0191088691,
0.028746644,
-0.0124335308,
-0.0199606568,
0.0208599549,
0.1018313617,
-0.005825832,
-0.0211129189,
-0.0573654659,
0.0408898517,
0.0566916503,
-0.0565608107,
0.0519780405,
0.011217746,
-0.0235044211,
-0.0287037268,
-0.0255225431,
-0.0241082869,
-0.0117618972,
-0.022507783,
-0.0195167698,
0.0035946395,
-0.0676655918,
0.005010087,
0.0031142158,
-0.0104995407,
-0.0568187162,
-0.029793309,
-0.0244718716,
0.0436069816,
-0.0131838126,
-0.0046699089,
-0.0035389096,
-0.0410164595,
0.0065583764,
0.0126510207,
0.0217878707,
-0.0059746192,
0.0745435283,
0.0447535329,
-0.0644125938,
0.0242337976,
0.0216498189,
0.0240071882,
-0.0182048921,
0.037437804,
0.0015303852,
-0.0074237618,
0.003263965,
0.0587315783,
0.0178976506,
0.0140375085,
0.0012549085,
-0.0217263699,
-0.0267274845,
-0.0176705681,
-0.0186766256,
-0.0191814154,
0.0432230905,
-0.0248525105,
0.0054088156,
-0.084550418,
0.0153238839,
-0.0018757841,
2.478e-7,
0.0809834972,
0.0513635948,
-0.0510985926,
-0.0136953145,
0.0043997727,
0.0645349473,
0.0179910213,
-0.0229362473,
0.0494746715,
-0.0078975335,
0.0278476011,
-0.0119931502,
0.0167551376,
0.0648745,
-0.0755862594,
-0.0565541387,
-0.0499060377,
0.0408627056,
-0.0238649175,
0.0323971026,
0.0470831506,
0.0747718737,
0.0563053973,
-0.0336427763,
-0.0404685102,
-0.0762027428,
0.0496519506,
-0.0315790884,
-0.0271579958,
0.0284003336,
0.0800606012,
0.0067234519,
0.0161125176,
0.030341262,
-0.050894618,
-0.0071080774,
0.0215951279,
0.0511774011,
-0.0006523447,
0.0083822059,
-0.0222024824,
-0.0091067078,
0.0650815219,
-0.0263732839,
0.0641509369,
-0.0314163826,
-0.0295568891,
-0.0343832113,
-0.0218934435,
-0.0808128491,
0.0306559596,
-0.0086101992,
0.0146663319,
0.041421596,
-0.0261912141,
0.0293154065,
-0.0285671651,
-0.0797022805,
-0.0058773719,
-0.0267789438,
-0.0491737388,
-0.0437137261,
0.0227151792,
0.0496370532,
0.021039553,
-0.0507581383,
0.0513777584,
2.15666043e-34,
0.0706028268,
0.0115330061,
-0.0110720536,
0.0323401317,
0.023435466,
0.0440214872,
0.0278679598,
0.0092286309,
0.0051083886,
-0.0285186265,
0.0140365995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12109v1 | Can LLMs Learn Macroeconomic Narratives from Social Media? | 2024-06-17T21:37:09 | 2024-06-17T21:37:09 | Almog Gueta, Amir Feder, Zorik Gekhman, Ariel Goldstein, Roi Reichart | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | This study empirically tests the $\textit{Narrative Economics}$ hypothesis,
which posits that narratives (ideas that are spread virally and affect public
beliefs) can influence economic fluctuations. We introduce two curated datasets
containing posts from X (formerly Twitter) which capture economy-related
narratives (Data will be shared upon paper acceptance). Employing Natural
Language Processing (NLP) methods, we extract and summarize narratives from the
tweets. We test their predictive power for $\textit{macroeconomic}$ forecasting
by incorporating the tweets' or the extracted narratives' representations in
downstream financial prediction tasks. Our work highlights the challenges in
improving macroeconomic models with narrative data, paving the way for the
research community to realistically address this important challenge. From a
scientific perspective, our investigation offers valuable insights and NLP
tools for narrative extraction and summarization using Large Language Models
(LLMs), contributing to future research on the role of narratives in economics. | [
0.0073191547,
0.1055663824,
-0.0103541594,
0.0147105092,
-0.0114422776,
0.0092568621,
-0.0031313018,
0.0066490816,
0.0180807803,
-0.0222676024,
0.0522057898,
-0.030610403,
0.036654871,
0.0783500597,
0.0223337412,
-0.0317291617,
-0.0073127053,
0.0066553024,
0.0501596034,
-0.0389652513,
0.0067115184,
0.0287699476,
0.0211459827,
0.0367549509,
-0.0109525351,
0.016868623,
0.0146647179,
-0.0324789397,
0.0088940421,
0.0163562894,
-0.0091597233,
0.0020466794,
0.0594969317,
0.0417377502,
0.0000015643,
-0.0445512794,
-0.0137234777,
-0.0413452052,
0.0163418204,
-0.0032294546,
0.0738517642,
-0.0498811603,
0.0611756295,
-0.0044868863,
-0.067802377,
0.0110732736,
0.0432943143,
0.0697165728,
0.0361115076,
0.0604129471,
-0.008259994,
-0.072888568,
0.0000741064,
-0.0593770407,
-0.0135770096,
-0.0513773486,
0.041216787,
-0.0254547857,
-0.0497623198,
-0.0135964965,
0.012794096,
0.0261201095,
-0.0244999398,
0.0179287158,
-0.0187167786,
0.0542644225,
0.0037601078,
0.0111852679,
-0.034274336,
0.0501052812,
0.0765633434,
0.0101024201,
0.0507242754,
-0.0155420508,
0.0068376935,
0.0386236012,
-0.0992425829,
0.0421651378,
0.0035835535,
0.0434886329,
0.0287811887,
0.00103902,
0.0244753864,
0.0310833454,
-0.0096222088,
0.0364815593,
-0.0209251642,
-0.0454434939,
-0.0351454839,
0.0412348136,
0.0028542643,
-0.0409704372,
-0.0238284823,
0.0135201206,
0.0275401343,
0.0080186054,
-0.0096740332,
0.0332404822,
-0.0328691639,
-0.1060484424,
0.0065965117,
0.0136435023,
0.0388488173,
0.0541202836,
0.0017073101,
-0.0170965027,
0.0031418963,
-0.0558499098,
0.0214926209,
-0.0015818385,
-0.0920888707,
0.0062749363,
0.0110387858,
0.0328776538,
-0.0124058817,
-0.0103196222,
-0.0156999696,
-0.0477498397,
-0.0280764811,
0.0193829574,
-0.0420741662,
0.017337786,
-0.0249691568,
-0.0158552937,
-0.0594524257,
0.057195276,
-0.0294097979,
-0.0163423959,
-0.0102802021,
0.0183299426,
0.0053619007,
-0.0131905517,
0.0293592792,
0.0097420439,
0.0106511218,
0.056111943,
0.0637653992,
0.0244501699,
-0.0451859795,
-0.0660920367,
-0.007135326,
-0.0490392186,
-0.0311412718,
-0.0394608602,
0.0360255875,
0.0116319116,
0.0199222025,
-0.0363181643,
-0.0095682284,
0.0030118346,
-0.0906113312,
0.0464805663,
-0.0002390397,
-0.0146877458,
0.0036401483,
-0.0511335619,
0.0446283557,
0.0525362343,
0.0445154272,
0.0328996517,
0.0738439411,
0.0009558702,
0.0091279373,
0.028119782,
-0.0077702794,
-0.0355208032,
0.0170580503,
-0.0088332817,
-0.0225642864,
-0.0138459671,
0.0075310171,
0.0218256209,
-0.0017076912,
0.0242661964,
0.0476835296,
0.0434110723,
-0.0044356501,
0.0013761548,
0.0340509638,
0.0153654832,
0.0054754163,
0.037039198,
0.0136037776,
-0.0069964919,
-0.0423543304,
0.0216741953,
0.0578298233,
0.0280275438,
-0.0167260394,
-0.0306550637,
-0.0075492477,
-0.0169374961,
0.0284328684,
-0.0050760689,
0.0272656716,
-0.0656318814,
-0.0509048589,
0.0662891716,
0.0767042786,
-0.0363917723,
0.030334888,
-0.0057032499,
0.0440120324,
0.0621829107,
0.0046214215,
0.026967328,
0.0201052073,
-0.0313791744,
0.0258589424,
0.0409943834,
0.0073499382,
0.0016267732,
-0.0412183143,
-0.01191781,
-0.0235290416,
0.0112942597,
0.0418729112,
0.0086037247,
0.0378127694,
-0.038702514,
0.0018219933,
0.0027879167,
-0.050317131,
-0.0016018825,
-0.0029646673,
-0.0347721875,
0.0028944891,
-0.0251391362,
-0.0085205613,
0.0187939201,
0.0036639313,
-0.0015192615,
-0.011652288,
-0.0048489436,
-0.0674594343,
0.0472708233,
-0.0263993181,
0.0032927073,
0.009941496,
-0.0400186181,
-0.0129258074,
-0.0306947716,
-0.0369761996,
-0.0190208703,
0.0814992264,
-0.0189250633,
-0.002831043,
-0.013366905,
-0.0547767989,
-0.0014940815,
-0.0177666582,
0.026508078,
0.0602824949,
-0.0087059494,
0.0118561937,
-0.0100581311,
-0.0430554934,
-0.0201545767,
0.0092707602,
0.0537933782,
0.0177689586,
0.0018184778,
0.018510744,
0.0550937839,
-0.0400882885,
0.0104791056,
-0.0324013866,
-0.0601460375,
-0.0174417607,
0.0022323709,
0.0023811937,
0.0223528706,
-0.0255439635,
-0.0077437884,
0.0261388328,
-0.0196602028,
-0.0193226226,
0.0100774691,
-0.0037903001,
0.0340062119,
0.0071190018,
0.0148901744,
-0.0369176492,
0.0016919349,
-0.0427428782,
0.0641398504,
0.0489470363,
-0.0286536496,
0.0099421237,
-0.0488322526,
-0.029318342,
-0.0038994874,
-0.0256060269,
0.0215588938,
-0.0303918123,
0.0028510855,
0.0432571173,
0.0344518647,
-0.0102570113,
0.0577525496,
-0.008811486,
-0.0391470939,
0.000912726,
-0.0068520755,
-0.0629842952,
0.0157191213,
-0.0421930775,
-0.0313187614,
0.028460931,
0.0992901251,
0.0095614111,
0.011167977,
-0.0598513037,
0.0689884499,
-0.0388021022,
0.0189495794,
-0.0099482778,
0.0102040973,
-0.0006300237,
0.0298166685,
0.0070609464,
-0.0283066668,
0.0480479598,
-0.0138605963,
0.0372323096,
0.0060227579,
-0.04953086,
-0.0509588979,
-0.0039018092,
-0.0081551122,
-0.0054729977,
0.0251924619,
0.0099747172,
0.0269377697,
-0.0256418996,
0.0190130882,
0.0149517562,
0.0059340969,
-0.0488691404,
0.0299524218,
0.0273748692,
-0.0045872214,
0.0265406985,
-0.0984052345,
-0.0591540225,
0.040457584,
0.0486503057,
-0.067392692,
-0.0393597782,
-0.0026320261,
0.0218079053,
-0.0442812592,
-0.0190353822,
-0.0226654597,
0.0253521837,
0.0448633097,
0.0415285192,
-0.0156965908,
0.0054139015,
-0.0558276847,
0.0058602509,
-0.0062653907,
0.0225835759,
0.022613341,
0.0041283313,
-0.0208928734,
-0.009300245,
-0.0323843062,
0.0047592144,
0.01359249,
0.0058774319,
-0.0408331342,
0.0139492564,
0.104884088,
0.0122437458,
0.0576870702,
0.0015620792,
0.0398564897,
0.0002946305,
-0.0202722847,
0.007328935,
-0.0519416593,
-0.0037390464,
0.0000377323,
-0.0186290909,
0.0015492166,
-0.0760424882,
-0.0338164233,
-0.1164617464,
0.0311615672,
-0.0130179292,
0.0210661255,
-0.0198572949,
-0.0602701865,
-0.0171243455,
-0.0567346513,
-0.0107970955,
-0.0216538794,
-0.0535182916,
0.0620343797,
0.0127115566,
-0.1019371003,
-0.0077021234,
0.0116261076,
-0.0223803762,
-0.0387829766,
0.0128682125,
0.0687822551,
-0.0251641944,
0.0234759692,
-0.0593987331,
0.0262544323,
0.0019490909,
-0.010250451,
0.0696159825,
-0.0360541381,
-0.0254732892,
0.0011554672,
0.0539092161,
-0.023008028,
0.0197949111,
-0.004796898,
0.009953605,
0.0109010413,
-0.07773114,
0.0143157989,
0.0443604626,
-0.0350989252,
0.083893761,
0.0328619182,
-0.0182707608,
-0.0383047424,
-0.0512436032,
-0.0000113913,
-0.0599640422,
-0.051020667,
-0.0410716012,
-0.0127577521,
-0.0061894618,
-0.0598156154,
-0.0784731507,
0.0247388799,
0.0036353597,
0.0148232253,
-0.0053404733,
0.0741606653,
0.0071979174,
-0.0253526606,
-0.0177004766,
-0.0800907612,
0.0141301649,
0.0270322375,
0.0300647542,
0.0397326872,
0.0300212614,
-0.0235484913,
0.0364250354,
-0.0994479656,
-0.0794690996,
0.0076645343,
-0.019083282,
0.0172425676,
0.0200049318,
0.0236847829,
-0.0072092474,
0.0535942391,
0.0770931542,
-0.0610748753,
-0.0008388549,
0.0331524126,
0.0752774402,
0.0176429003,
0.0340831801,
-0.0161580388,
-0.0091060279,
-0.0327432714,
0.0039111492,
-0.05502709,
0.0138407685,
-0.0164069999,
0.0157105122,
0.0327218473,
-0.0131237404,
-0.0589228682,
-0.0378464833,
-0.065886125,
0.008353156,
-0.0002132694,
-0.0135819539,
-0.0003792917,
0.0113517251,
0.0032547161,
-0.032744728,
0.029250361,
-0.0123593323,
-0.0129374098,
-0.05306077,
0.0197345316,
-0.0087636076,
-0.0286424886,
-0.0082178405,
-0.0195229668,
0.011154809,
-0.0028972793,
-0.0333591551,
-0.0029674515,
0.0176154375,
-0.0388274491,
0.0025954519,
-0.0048687998,
0.0271277316,
-0.0442637317,
-0.069094114,
-0.043358244,
-0.0178652108,
0.0281991288,
0.0329473354,
-0.0518634059,
0.0068072607,
-0.0399440117,
0.0137819303,
0.0223896392,
0.0142494021,
-0.0446473882,
-0.0124011319,
-0.0022061383,
-0.0086289719,
-0.1070777103,
0.0114210052,
0.0843274295,
0.0104843294,
0.0464376397,
0.0497662872,
-0.0110874707,
-0.0184147526,
-0.0342345499,
0.0233546775,
0.0313152224,
0.0415262692,
0.007090881,
-0.0579343773,
-0.0224349834,
0.0485741049,
-0.0186423659,
-0.0011366089,
-0.0085630696,
-0.0135703515,
0.0400523283,
0.0037316431,
0.0828376636,
-0.0258708913,
0.0000706835,
-0.0284842011,
-0.0094883461,
-0.055027511,
-5.98027498e-33,
-0.0046299249,
-0.0276758578,
0.0043697227,
0.0176813398,
0.0000477351,
0.0352897346,
-0.0205956511,
0.0065305484,
0.0074465098,
0.0226341318,
0.0296833534,
0.0209976435,
0.0129584521,
0.0326730348,
0.0213771593,
0.0071724639,
0.0280108228,
-0.0038719857,
0.0065209283,
0.0123252086,
0.0488649979,
0.0334195867,
0.0955589563,
-0.0479667075,
0.0567961521,
-0.013273824,
-0.0066586011,
-0.0088488748,
0.0859250277,
0.0139667736,
-0.0176486671,
0.0490248986,
0.0309576448,
-0.0715221092,
-0.046435345,
0.0151848942,
-0.016499592,
-0.0358097441,
0.028746428,
-0.01894743,
0.0159853138,
-0.012536942,
0.042825792,
0.0164084788,
-0.0057740682,
0.0001725825,
0.034901686,
0.0044426844,
0.0176397972,
0.0001928914,
-0.0571278818,
0.0492391586,
-0.022356499,
0.0299908482,
0.0018997873,
0.0613120757,
0.0249162372,
0.0508911684,
-0.0265096147,
0.0323417932,
0.0226488039,
0.0242140815,
-0.005813119,
-0.0469711497,
0.0072800182,
0.0748081356,
0.024481643,
-0.0020556778,
-0.0815652907,
0.0276420284,
-0.0127604203,
0.0497754142,
0.0245293453,
0.0656547323,
0.0317541771,
-0.0207061693,
-0.0248278249,
0.0388474055,
0.0207678098,
0.0288925134,
0.0388547778,
-0.0025329962,
-0.0224121809,
-0.0600573495,
-0.0536839999,
-0.0483114161,
0.0027592652,
0.0013557909,
-0.0368787721,
-0.0052150059,
-0.0020260182,
0.0540239848,
0.0236389544,
-0.0434052981,
-0.0728126764,
-0.0048418809,
-0.0121588642,
-0.0014944171,
0.0227976013,
-0.0080544418,
-0.0521134399,
0.0007428864,
-0.0255326219,
0.0510274246,
-0.0170257408,
-0.0440327041,
-0.0344144255,
0.0140250837,
-0.0349334069,
-0.0078943893,
0.0039638765,
0.0075087487,
-0.0014603285,
-0.0057566292,
0.0404539146,
0.0364501663,
-0.0006999225,
-0.0359421037,
-0.011103088,
0.0046858992,
0.0227745753,
-0.0236445852,
-0.0126458751,
0.020395156,
0.0020441639,
-0.0214849934,
-0.0027190004,
0.0281099658,
0.0484803058,
-0.0071687521,
-0.0254598465,
-0.0013284136,
2.327e-7,
0.0218189899,
0.0756987333,
-0.0003316479,
0.0071961484,
0.0021097604,
0.0621224232,
-0.0066924198,
0.0160670485,
-0.021438295,
-0.0522677787,
-0.0089326221,
0.0440539792,
0.0472807325,
0.0256081298,
-0.0531279966,
0.0001212984,
-0.0882982537,
0.0094258236,
-0.0603130683,
0.0010487027,
0.0174886268,
0.0400411226,
0.0556831546,
-0.0075699924,
-0.0085203405,
-0.0482940935,
0.0608011484,
-0.0577369183,
-0.0660249665,
0.0256338213,
-0.01608973,
0.0219172779,
-0.0059762308,
-0.0470532365,
-0.0130648529,
0.0169609431,
-0.0036948761,
0.0042067999,
0.0602638721,
0.0230454393,
0.0095346533,
-0.0359757543,
-0.0371200666,
-0.0041227941,
0.0555983037,
-0.110318467,
-0.0712817237,
-0.0739765391,
0.0020315449,
0.0500401482,
0.0316799283,
0.0211331379,
-0.0290606413,
0.0392470844,
-0.025440583,
-0.0063096141,
0.0123628471,
-0.0216160771,
0.0020933426,
0.0120935459,
-0.0465492792,
-0.0046935328,
0.009430374,
0.0026815976,
0.0048396965,
-0.0455663837,
0.047724165,
1.932629573e-34,
0.0652322397,
-0.0007143697,
-0.04386748,
0.0241974071,
0.0837183148,
0.0141867585,
-0.0300696511,
-0.0000390908,
0.0123218223,
-0.0802217349,
0.0178024266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12104v1 | End-to-end Text-to-SQL Generation within an Analytics Insight Engine | 2024-06-17T21:33:01 | 2024-06-17T21:33:01 | Karime Maamari, Amine Mhedhbi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG | Recent advancements in Text-to-SQL have pushed database management systems
towards greater democratization of data access. Today's language models are at
the core of these advancements. They enable impressive Text-to-SQL generation
as experienced in the development of Distyl AI's Analytics Insight Engine. Its
early deployment with enterprise customers has highlighted three core
challenges. First, data analysts expect support with authoring SQL queries of
very high complexity. Second, requests are ad-hoc and, as such, require low
latency. Finally, generation requires an understanding of domain-specific
terminology and practices.
The design and implementation of our Text-to-SQL generation pipeline, powered
by large language models, tackles these challenges. The core tenants of our
approach rely on external knowledge that we extract in a pre-processing phase,
on retrieving the appropriate external knowledge at query generation time, and
on decomposing SQL query generation following a hierarchical CTE-based
structure. Finally, an adaptation framework leverages feedback to update the
external knowledge, in turn improving query generation over time. We give an
overview of our end-to-end approach and highlight the operators generating SQL
during inference. | [
0.0339982733,
0.0814485401,
-0.007673264,
-0.0056868955,
-0.0290097948,
0.0169869419,
-0.0339875072,
0.0097023966,
0.0239316728,
-0.0315333419,
0.0336717591,
-0.0114510274,
-0.019347189,
0.0973400027,
0.054716859,
-0.0565759353,
0.0065815332,
0.0240278896,
-0.0335447192,
0.0282512177,
-0.0126966601,
0.0333674401,
0.0225504246,
-0.0029718592,
-0.0256017596,
0.0197513085,
-0.0246541575,
0.0056129824,
-0.0418833643,
-0.002447848,
-0.01388017,
0.0382711664,
0.0038935442,
0.022007959,
0.0000022358,
-0.0674544349,
-0.0362383164,
0.0248101279,
-0.0248046555,
-0.0349120833,
0.0578334816,
-0.0331214219,
0.0370487012,
0.051925227,
-0.0288496278,
0.048312407,
0.0314532034,
-0.034251608,
0.0336778425,
0.0437650941,
-0.010479413,
-0.058264818,
-0.0200937707,
-0.0171723571,
0.0454207771,
-0.0339361876,
0.0011301445,
0.0000491085,
0.0417324081,
-0.0116441511,
0.0027634371,
0.0184337981,
0.0181169063,
-0.0325095318,
0.0231121927,
-0.0178138074,
0.0080808401,
0.0069034458,
-0.0251336563,
0.0055838632,
0.0528407022,
-0.0398944244,
0.0195824895,
0.0189531781,
-0.0017066222,
-0.0085880384,
-0.0295068175,
0.0164830331,
-0.0070622494,
-0.0258885864,
0.0068492526,
-0.0009719898,
-0.0077513042,
-0.023154499,
-0.0790303126,
0.0103050703,
0.0029204937,
-0.0094084367,
0.0194498375,
0.000896141,
0.0335644893,
-0.0306353979,
0.0039632451,
0.0532482378,
-0.08366061,
0.0234464314,
-0.0318202265,
-0.048837211,
0.004249848,
-0.0557440892,
0.0382179096,
0.0571132004,
0.0395239927,
0.0206810087,
0.0098560993,
0.0079919174,
0.0184947103,
-0.0114251496,
-0.0344513729,
-0.0751537234,
-0.0534945689,
0.0062352973,
-0.0284515303,
-0.0000961439,
-0.0603603087,
-0.0082066879,
-0.0385911241,
0.05049612,
-0.0052819201,
0.0264981762,
0.0075504384,
0.0331330597,
-0.0385153294,
-0.0243689213,
-0.0712023824,
-0.0330717154,
-0.0053343303,
-0.0195137002,
0.0053958087,
-0.0676864758,
-0.0244185906,
0.014476493,
-0.0025252672,
0.0158903059,
0.0142126027,
0.0474692546,
-0.0169592705,
0.0431387648,
-0.1062244698,
-0.1046941206,
0.027938161,
-0.0135092959,
-0.0144751072,
-0.0094897691,
0.0841972977,
0.0324157625,
-0.0465086959,
-0.0902918726,
-0.0133442637,
0.025617322,
-0.0117182843,
-0.0067873658,
-0.0374809541,
0.0391455069,
0.0147668151,
-0.014233849,
0.0476732999,
0.096789293,
0.0153873088,
0.0258055199,
0.0164726898,
-0.0106267547,
0.0068430258,
0.0225401893,
0.0649583638,
0.0283104219,
-0.1056816727,
0.0620599352,
-0.036216639,
0.0276217721,
-0.0227935612,
0.0410298221,
0.0184525941,
0.0410488248,
0.0289864056,
0.0058859861,
0.0328594558,
0.0419582576,
0.0802931264,
0.0137119275,
-0.0422254056,
-0.0377302282,
0.0154280337,
0.0221074857,
0.0227796379,
-0.0006102641,
0.0451769195,
0.024769444,
-0.0099676587,
-0.0485791527,
0.029097233,
0.0258838665,
-0.0408988148,
0.0222203583,
0.0237311963,
0.0389790237,
-0.0200094059,
0.0183643959,
0.0033185123,
-0.0349512883,
0.0020737648,
-0.013467961,
-0.00657854,
0.0937233269,
0.0452966802,
-0.0173383411,
0.0121294716,
-0.0203968026,
-0.0047464883,
0.0562509485,
0.0297432039,
-0.033761207,
-0.0286259744,
-0.0038397454,
-0.0316247605,
0.0538942851,
0.0259000864,
-0.0209982879,
0.0171035621,
0.0184309315,
0.0226416979,
-0.0203189664,
-0.0601388663,
0.0223684013,
-0.0223486889,
-0.0182630382,
0.0501427799,
-0.0007871741,
0.0147310318,
0.0346313231,
-0.0175003652,
0.0367386527,
0.000062865,
0.0004780008,
-0.0510054417,
-0.0128671834,
0.0377669521,
-0.0001990894,
-0.0177749805,
-0.0211678874,
0.0168727003,
-0.0915213674,
-0.026699217,
-0.031437967,
0.0369994789,
-0.0392791145,
0.0288062003,
-0.014887346,
0.0102300113,
-0.0038695266,
-0.0340764858,
-0.0073992489,
0.0351698548,
-0.0071434565,
-0.0204585101,
0.0117399599,
-0.0709259436,
0.0158474091,
-0.0149969589,
0.0748276338,
-0.0247625895,
0.0125480816,
0.034861844,
0.0080893226,
-0.0049138744,
-0.0494523682,
0.006861818,
-0.0194223151,
0.0143333981,
0.003908196,
0.0202795025,
0.0303655993,
0.0597075336,
-0.023847675,
0.0055142264,
-0.0378504731,
-0.0180342346,
-0.0055815033,
-0.01605317,
0.0343918987,
0.0422956534,
-0.0036127446,
0.0263293386,
-0.0107332384,
-0.0456679016,
0.0735182464,
0.0105612865,
-0.0452440567,
-0.0083919717,
0.0209918115,
-0.0210922267,
0.0016010388,
0.0031457795,
0.0203299392,
-0.012422476,
-0.0367447957,
0.0160311647,
0.0176270623,
0.0142447231,
-0.034151867,
-0.0187977571,
-0.0438153148,
-0.0496724956,
0.0077815307,
-0.0425374806,
0.0167920776,
0.0270777792,
-0.0857552364,
0.0731669068,
0.0119765913,
0.0188888423,
-0.0283221062,
-0.0444196835,
0.025476126,
0.0169630013,
-0.0111936871,
-0.0446218662,
0.0217601452,
0.0328557789,
0.0530722439,
0.0183879808,
-0.0067906477,
0.0331026241,
-0.0097137084,
0.0198618844,
-0.0752531588,
-0.0010414227,
-0.0357875153,
0.038530536,
0.0138398064,
0.0493890084,
-0.0105264699,
-0.003863879,
-0.0296138134,
-0.0285342447,
-0.0111163761,
-0.0190898422,
0.072000958,
-0.0351324752,
-0.0033059968,
0.0227077212,
0.0181679353,
-0.0360681787,
0.0209144577,
-0.0182880517,
0.0109883891,
0.0902923048,
-0.0323241577,
-0.0254473947,
-0.0124557009,
0.0257981103,
0.0238834042,
0.0100150062,
-0.0562578961,
0.0256678034,
-0.0705478862,
0.0373750031,
0.0086534368,
-0.0354516692,
-0.006336716,
0.0040633418,
0.0473688319,
0.0074139824,
-0.0695310384,
-0.0002226093,
-0.0027759776,
-0.039895419,
-0.0137088858,
0.0230394695,
0.047484111,
-0.0695585087,
-0.0646234602,
0.0055812364,
0.0468060598,
0.0181093141,
0.0067559499,
-0.0055667097,
0.0249944516,
0.0562042333,
0.030013511,
0.0748984888,
-0.1209840775,
-0.0184753984,
-0.0265963692,
0.062008284,
-0.0178021416,
-0.0520774648,
-0.0431356318,
-0.1213265806,
0.062054731,
-0.0334177837,
-0.0066786194,
-0.0213556513,
-0.0220713429,
-0.0230524242,
-0.0111529501,
-0.0420784801,
0.0731736794,
-0.0140049569,
0.0045849592,
0.014552814,
-0.0135589084,
-0.0668013766,
-0.0349761769,
0.0030744376,
-0.0327788591,
0.0445143245,
0.0241192766,
0.0169089232,
0.0175526589,
-0.0268128067,
-0.0137996171,
0.0038000436,
-0.0510326512,
0.0726888999,
-0.0063869222,
0.0130555341,
0.015479601,
0.0342112184,
-0.0395568013,
0.061933998,
0.0291214623,
0.1177574992,
-0.0224273223,
0.0193635412,
-0.0481004603,
-0.0120166028,
0.0357021652,
0.0568918586,
0.0209388267,
-0.0205840226,
-0.0322610587,
-0.0221542623,
-0.0126223657,
-0.0728982314,
-0.0079199411,
0.0226685088,
-0.0416059829,
-0.066587843,
-0.0413352326,
-0.0306791272,
0.0588004291,
0.0559886359,
0.036160823,
0.0307556894,
0.0073701469,
-0.04719216,
-0.0651126355,
-0.0298195463,
-0.0182531923,
0.0180472266,
-0.0161941312,
-0.0244860481,
0.0003359239,
-0.0250527617,
-0.0378754921,
0.0109802317,
-0.023261629,
-0.0284426343,
-0.0135865835,
0.0258624256,
0.0216723997,
-0.0106797041,
0.0075083971,
-0.0163875315,
0.0075948681,
0.0622713938,
-0.060758587,
-0.071163781,
-0.03078405,
0.0190459248,
-0.0153296813,
0.0345543139,
-0.0378212444,
-0.0214557629,
-0.0406763814,
0.0042698039,
-0.0271964371,
-0.0154293654,
0.0525464714,
0.042689614,
-0.0540383756,
0.0198401976,
-0.0087372409,
-0.0335808694,
0.0258568581,
-0.0552895516,
-0.0592257492,
-0.0605482794,
0.0599268004,
-0.0112768477,
0.0011341838,
0.0374270305,
-0.0016716709,
-0.0349955522,
-0.0226730425,
-0.0246441457,
-0.0000176944,
0.0091420813,
0.0342134945,
0.0332367718,
-0.0391861387,
0.0183860511,
-0.0136368126,
0.0320659392,
0.0792440251,
-0.0287430808,
0.0402908176,
0.0434620529,
0.005344477,
-0.0285001211,
-0.021201985,
-0.0258598048,
-0.0129388329,
-0.0375878438,
-0.0043097581,
-0.0138600608,
0.0513223261,
0.01108649,
-0.0380097106,
-0.0201686881,
-0.0018540572,
0.0441675447,
0.0285041686,
0.0079459138,
-0.0039265859,
-0.0214975439,
-0.0302137975,
-0.0743738487,
0.0726632699,
-0.0186240338,
0.0322369747,
-0.0458245128,
-0.0602357499,
-0.0508577935,
-0.0411313139,
0.0311181657,
-0.0143312607,
0.0109514575,
0.0030656641,
-0.0635417551,
-0.023364285,
0.0170517098,
0.0146397613,
-0.0176557433,
-0.0402475372,
0.0396200456,
0.0769381523,
0.0537100025,
0.0015094184,
-0.0187049415,
0.0283266772,
-0.0843418613,
-0.0480965041,
0.0008004451,
-6.600915793e-33,
-0.0222698823,
-0.0195206124,
0.0483281687,
-0.0305333436,
-0.0109245917,
-0.0407221206,
-0.039809797,
-0.0272225272,
-0.0198915582,
0.0094640255,
-0.0211216863,
0.0278882813,
0.0256459024,
0.0298601817,
0.0309599247,
0.0120863691,
0.0179350004,
-0.021257855,
0.0028715131,
0.0391792618,
0.0832877532,
0.0261808299,
-0.0035662299,
-0.0443527848,
0.022608418,
0.001200621,
-0.0025495377,
0.0283588972,
0.0114740552,
0.0181424394,
0.0044532819,
0.0090192808,
0.0018824763,
-0.013176254,
-0.0364349373,
-0.0437192209,
-0.004693252,
-0.0402866229,
-0.0204181634,
-0.0233948436,
-0.0076732016,
-0.021618342,
0.0543220825,
-0.0232803654,
-0.0297343098,
-0.0061485949,
0.0121842511,
-0.0309488792,
0.0050177961,
-0.0666810349,
-0.0499362238,
0.0349887721,
0.0028665406,
0.0225018263,
0.0028876353,
0.0357525609,
0.0133060589,
-0.0005588916,
-0.0133110695,
0.0534520932,
0.0490489192,
0.0324313678,
0.0625924319,
0.0313232355,
0.0109223658,
-0.0265757609,
0.0126711559,
0.0003647457,
-0.0135870753,
0.067336008,
-0.0268243011,
0.0687287077,
-0.0038260154,
0.0513129346,
-0.0434273556,
-0.0277506728,
-0.056000676,
0.0837251991,
-0.0127578722,
-0.0206954591,
0.0028049739,
-0.0448282026,
-0.0626910776,
-0.0688627884,
-0.0075232885,
0.009712168,
-0.0304131303,
-0.0191782974,
0.0481137857,
-0.0013326836,
-0.0226904079,
0.0233851038,
0.0047371029,
-0.0192656666,
-0.0344684906,
0.0244732127,
-0.0411992297,
-0.0536461547,
0.0201275013,
0.0102445064,
-0.0440350957,
-0.0032558022,
0.0023802056,
0.0434270129,
-0.0171367321,
0.0323925018,
0.0063432958,
0.0274750777,
-0.0417825542,
0.0182192139,
-0.011264435,
0.0778521895,
-0.042434711,
-0.0238948837,
-0.0161753148,
0.0208279919,
0.0246275626,
0.0566303022,
0.0176132061,
-0.0008721628,
0.0165279098,
0.034805499,
0.0278741885,
0.0289748255,
-0.0004265377,
0.0042091468,
0.0259087794,
-0.0453489088,
0.0518369675,
0.0036786653,
-0.0293430053,
0.0278281234,
2.886e-7,
0.0892405212,
0.0110089704,
0.0030049661,
0.0847801417,
0.0071456102,
0.0371307358,
0.0392749049,
-0.0068597943,
0.0112617975,
0.0035294206,
0.0280128326,
-0.0324939974,
0.0548435189,
0.0461709201,
-0.0120576955,
-0.0266693532,
0.0040543075,
-0.0252823215,
-0.0913348868,
0.0060619698,
0.0478618965,
0.0242284872,
-0.0326169319,
-0.0129677989,
0.0161309373,
-0.0534794331,
-0.00572418,
-0.0154348239,
-0.0036034381,
0.0902337804,
0.0178045984,
0.0047869086,
0.0172672458,
0.0357217714,
-0.0370758399,
0.0481327288,
-0.0405497961,
0.0468639545,
0.0180571694,
0.0377794169,
0.0390929244,
-0.0802864656,
0.0159923378,
-0.0596234426,
0.0427640975,
-0.0372898541,
-0.0029542439,
0.040099401,
0.0071110628,
-0.0003839559,
-0.0250103734,
-0.0121296616,
0.0072352132,
-0.0466674641,
0.0339463055,
0.0213044342,
-0.0077866809,
-0.0036653483,
-0.0103355516,
0.0412318781,
-0.0378641747,
-0.0120328413,
-0.0063254009,
0.0458735228,
-0.0196352098,
0.0138653573,
0.0234057121,
3.140921824e-34,
0.0389373414,
0.043393936,
-0.0108105782,
-0.0006192679,
0.0799505711,
-0.0134137226,
0.015068816,
-0.0072462726,
0.0278628245,
-0.0448015556,
-0.0506704152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12094v1 | Who's asking? User personas and the mechanics of latent misalignment | 2024-06-17T21:15:12 | 2024-06-17T21:15:12 | Asma Ghandeharioun, Ann Yuan, Marius Guerard, Emily Reif, Michael A. Lepori, Lucas Dixon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite investments in improving model safety, studies show that misaligned
capabilities remain latent in safety-tuned models. In this work, we shed light
on the mechanics of this phenomenon. First, we show that even when model
generations are safe, harmful content can persist in hidden representations and
can be extracted by decoding from earlier layers. Then, we show that whether
the model divulges such content depends significantly on its perception of who
it is talking to, which we refer to as user persona. In fact, we find
manipulating user persona to be even more effective for eliciting harmful
content than direct attempts to control model refusal. We study both natural
language prompting and activation steering as control methods and show that
activation steering is significantly more effective at bypassing safety
filters. We investigate why certain personas break model safeguards and find
that they enable the model to form more charitable interpretations of otherwise
dangerous queries. Finally, we show we can predict a persona's effect on
refusal given only the geometry of its steering vector. | [
0.0531471074,
0.0545499176,
-0.0478846021,
0.0334397927,
0.0089887371,
0.0062842309,
0.0291634593,
-0.0084793344,
0.0224932656,
-0.0164789259,
-0.0487231687,
-0.0427029245,
-0.0088469842,
0.0299755894,
0.036816109,
-0.0415073223,
0.0401594415,
-0.0296101179,
0.0227943119,
0.016048843,
0.0129744317,
0.0003595461,
0.0083771767,
0.0591967218,
-0.0140764909,
-0.0372252502,
0.0166981444,
0.0328906141,
0.0204355717,
-0.0325862989,
0.0416232087,
0.0357337967,
0.0044932165,
0.0379854627,
0.0000020534,
-0.0361972004,
-0.0200799257,
-0.0032050253,
-0.0412123241,
-0.0315017067,
0.0389125906,
-0.0065357788,
0.018457571,
0.0304094385,
-0.0562510416,
0.0146702686,
0.0273662563,
0.0992818102,
0.0431794375,
0.0678043887,
-0.0123677058,
0.028211331,
0.006585347,
0.0035478496,
0.0083071478,
-0.0732832998,
0.0000862796,
-0.0482065789,
-0.0464218035,
0.0397063382,
-0.0234349109,
0.0108508877,
0.017179776,
0.0026933702,
0.0006961976,
-0.0124223512,
0.0326545015,
-0.0640847087,
0.0075568147,
0.0608833432,
0.0252131298,
0.0084441779,
0.0093671679,
-0.0078849625,
0.0325009972,
0.0322272517,
-0.0045031412,
0.0225804746,
0.0018386899,
-0.0410363674,
-0.0232239477,
0.0062801815,
0.0481066629,
0.0097583542,
0.0295707081,
0.0350681245,
-0.0138068544,
-0.032235641,
0.0131545076,
-0.0079246042,
0.0473445654,
-0.0500569642,
0.0072368528,
-0.0000950258,
-0.0717609748,
0.0074193636,
-0.0574168228,
0.0288603753,
0.0048500518,
-0.0526496917,
0.0206003338,
0.0470694639,
-0.0066540181,
0.0148792937,
0.031878449,
0.0109263211,
-0.0549160652,
0.0573479384,
-0.0054195537,
0.0411943607,
0.0115796216,
-0.0312574692,
0.0055565806,
-0.0098701427,
-0.02231979,
0.0193636008,
-0.0147608705,
0.0433069095,
-0.0505038351,
-0.0162345879,
-0.067107372,
0.0575272143,
-0.0375628285,
0.0280143619,
-0.0441971198,
0.0051526232,
-0.0496932752,
-0.0023794232,
0.0200600903,
-0.0367418341,
-0.0222381353,
-0.0119385822,
-0.0194335729,
-0.0195260495,
-0.0313039832,
0.08027073,
0.0083811097,
-0.0387304053,
-0.0284652654,
-0.0812973529,
-0.0118711572,
-0.0432695225,
0.0050089988,
0.0134826452,
0.0187769271,
0.0118791368,
-0.0289187748,
-0.0907694623,
0.0013493163,
0.0157649703,
-0.0639575347,
0.081148468,
0.036736466,
-0.0050075506,
0.008337819,
0.0582951009,
-0.0654217228,
0.0714544728,
0.0170613825,
0.0255424231,
0.0331704393,
0.0152023267,
0.0307204034,
0.0017190406,
0.0188810099,
0.0137609346,
0.0040413281,
0.022898946,
-0.0013255593,
-0.0048845178,
0.0062472904,
0.0398535021,
-0.0358843245,
-0.0167944748,
0.0960541144,
0.0385249779,
-0.0562019125,
0.0211259704,
-0.0131391278,
0.0093673263,
-0.0386859514,
0.0355133638,
-0.0941891894,
0.0213390384,
-0.0682725385,
-0.0607101694,
-0.0081840809,
0.0154420249,
-0.0251327008,
-0.0220283698,
0.0172791556,
-0.00524732,
0.0527949259,
0.024682276,
-0.0275709648,
0.0343159139,
-0.0261197165,
0.0112549672,
0.0288022906,
-0.0324028432,
-0.0199678838,
-0.05894541,
0.0153613267,
0.0452380739,
0.039501626,
0.0036890479,
-0.0085666245,
-0.0380344614,
-0.0038143382,
0.0169606507,
0.0508112721,
-0.0039159814,
0.0059256232,
0.0072552557,
-0.0818968266,
-0.0217396207,
0.007509585,
-0.0165110491,
0.0079360753,
-0.0091458829,
-0.004249739,
0.0202783775,
-0.019782206,
0.0259740092,
-0.0321533717,
-0.0443856493,
-0.0535774902,
0.0564797446,
0.0128021855,
0.0100161089,
0.0319588296,
0.0111552281,
0.0263580065,
0.0216874816,
-0.0134084439,
-0.0068059294,
-0.067552492,
0.0410207026,
-0.0015729659,
-0.0359944403,
-0.0220018663,
0.0212230552,
0.0125065735,
0.0124818152,
0.0355211943,
-0.0196771268,
0.0337208584,
0.0104953703,
0.0142786801,
-0.0243964493,
-0.0205403604,
-0.022686068,
0.0679639727,
-0.0114469398,
-0.0249926932,
-0.0069185793,
-0.0324009694,
-0.0184456725,
-0.0234267768,
-0.0067657372,
-0.0050842259,
0.0024879226,
0.0312049817,
0.0287259519,
-0.031492997,
-0.0434166156,
0.0062132431,
-0.0447322838,
-0.0235893968,
-0.0346486084,
-0.0116375061,
0.0184148252,
0.0011031608,
-0.0089592449,
-0.0047396277,
-0.0263285879,
-0.0166665409,
-0.012440308,
0.052846238,
0.0172931645,
0.000608149,
0.0137558924,
-0.0302642994,
0.0136849722,
-0.0208928026,
0.0398117155,
-0.0143643636,
-0.0010602169,
-0.0119560501,
0.0129092718,
-0.0173496976,
0.0409993529,
-0.0121772075,
-0.0208017137,
0.0381936356,
0.0345786586,
0.0008437375,
0.0718588457,
0.0219013765,
0.0853250399,
0.0285223965,
0.0503135286,
-0.0504129976,
0.0315731987,
-0.0188884344,
-0.0344283655,
-0.0519143566,
-0.0042760461,
0.0064897765,
0.0276479945,
0.017091779,
-0.0009166346,
-0.064753443,
0.0746099874,
-0.0492112152,
-0.083044216,
0.0199022125,
-0.0347387008,
-0.0105206165,
0.0608234107,
-0.0246584099,
-0.0477903113,
0.0845015645,
0.0331560336,
0.0021649057,
0.0314368419,
-0.014969361,
0.0219488405,
0.0673336387,
0.0007482462,
0.0402551182,
0.0606816523,
-0.0115974024,
-0.114262633,
-0.0479969643,
0.0574605428,
-0.0360821187,
0.0254936777,
-0.0275296792,
-0.0322100259,
0.0155028552,
-0.0813084841,
-0.0644696578,
-0.0605331212,
-0.0029791736,
-0.0214724652,
-0.0063003995,
-0.0342708193,
-0.0332763158,
-0.0323644243,
0.0168155339,
-0.0198421571,
-0.0477825217,
-0.0196317732,
-0.0221659839,
-0.0477883369,
0.0577856153,
0.0155828279,
0.0467466526,
-0.0496622585,
0.0414067358,
0.0758644044,
-0.0068893963,
-0.0193041805,
0.0175535847,
0.0091196243,
0.0247536022,
0.0222225972,
-0.031761162,
0.0436721034,
0.0745043308,
-0.0254363976,
-0.0141803883,
0.0599043332,
0.0205230545,
-0.0267518442,
0.0260104761,
-0.0370524898,
0.0435282178,
0.0337172039,
-0.0009042928,
-0.0300572552,
-0.0015174486,
0.0056477799,
0.0621133335,
-0.0338193737,
-0.0209300742,
0.0066146236,
-0.0916078761,
0.0348692387,
-0.0132270753,
-0.0087785637,
-0.0171752758,
-0.0034708409,
-0.0227544177,
-0.0080993557,
0.0638620853,
0.0043480163,
-0.0127696423,
0.000309929,
0.0067799687,
0.0149910627,
-0.0430415086,
-0.0012510684,
-0.071640268,
0.0405669585,
0.0580419563,
0.033233285,
0.0128683364,
-0.0572961979,
-0.0076313321,
0.0308557451,
0.0263584591,
0.0012049172,
0.0709722266,
-0.0408867486,
0.0030392592,
-0.0465431809,
0.0251656901,
0.012856964,
-0.0298716854,
-0.0098906904,
0.0353693068,
-0.0285539515,
-0.0241993014,
-0.0295259189,
0.0046322308,
0.0376474485,
0.0472124629,
0.0110682435,
-0.0528865531,
-0.0051990785,
-0.0457228683,
0.0144678736,
0.0162078403,
-0.0608429126,
0.0208466407,
0.0165265631,
-0.0468450412,
-0.0461689234,
-0.0172018521,
-0.0004930404,
0.0295898262,
0.0458475761,
-0.0235913284,
-0.0123825315,
0.0188512895,
0.0051031942,
0.0361633599,
-0.0316653438,
0.0071782181,
-0.0312236696,
0.0103457272,
-0.0117870541,
-0.0573538467,
0.0165819731,
-0.0155195119,
-0.0131100528,
-0.0598693416,
0.0108928801,
0.0806995034,
0.0347006395,
0.0446030237,
-0.0200248901,
-0.0745810717,
0.0371385291,
0.0453991927,
-0.0796933547,
0.0146566983,
0.0567651428,
-0.0107043004,
-0.027113663,
0.0285727773,
-0.0482519828,
-0.0447529368,
0.048539605,
-0.0007800718,
-0.0622577555,
-0.0137371011,
0.0393535085,
-0.0012584908,
0.0711677745,
-0.0012557511,
0.0073229582,
0.0078531681,
-0.0162363704,
0.0093631782,
-0.0304350685,
-0.0062536267,
0.0002282266,
0.033346381,
0.0193683337,
0.0087028658,
-0.0258728806,
-0.0171381142,
0.0560508817,
-0.0398558676,
0.012408806,
0.0399321318,
0.0169128552,
0.0116818622,
0.0353160389,
-0.0090893842,
0.0749580264,
-0.0072722035,
0.016249368,
0.0212219711,
0.0646072924,
0.0209597759,
0.0137825441,
-0.0243629459,
0.0256295297,
-0.0909973606,
-0.0925837532,
0.0148363914,
0.0007039074,
-0.0133607714,
-0.0100741051,
0.0072948905,
0.0121114664,
-0.0052199862,
-0.0026819748,
0.0009302543,
0.0163883567,
-0.055750154,
0.0220262483,
0.0041419226,
-0.0130983982,
-0.0173917562,
0.0419389382,
-0.0100054089,
0.0630079582,
-0.0338701829,
-0.0299441349,
-0.0199048296,
-0.0380444676,
0.0883901641,
0.0306561384,
-0.0250196178,
0.0074791154,
-0.0998308063,
-0.0636337772,
-0.0329932161,
0.0045820158,
-0.0030945914,
-0.0609173588,
0.0091095101,
0.0399265066,
0.019975435,
-0.0540552065,
-0.0243685599,
-0.0357688069,
-0.018820338,
0.0168808624,
-0.035253454,
-6.618552617e-33,
-0.0023493271,
-0.0324272215,
-0.0212406814,
-0.0112786507,
-0.0147957699,
-0.020296881,
-0.00989269,
0.0293275844,
-0.0251601133,
-0.0107130455,
-0.0341419689,
0.0301421396,
-0.0020318746,
-0.0200659093,
-0.0018045665,
-0.0805896074,
0.0298480615,
-0.0372428782,
-0.0341862552,
0.0277573001,
0.0313229561,
0.0157898907,
-0.0056326431,
-0.1107382849,
0.070374243,
-0.0148834512,
-0.0278806034,
0.0077628582,
-0.0345373675,
0.0582774766,
-0.003571738,
0.0216021128,
0.0049444153,
-0.0158240739,
0.0231435243,
0.0600260235,
-0.0399990678,
-0.0337813757,
0.0213099364,
-0.0126575558,
-0.0636913329,
-0.0586926714,
0.0417009629,
-0.0063960077,
-0.0321693346,
-0.0196736548,
0.0242621638,
0.0187056772,
0.0071698884,
-0.030881783,
-0.0601810515,
-0.0330741331,
-0.0155553268,
-0.0288790762,
-0.0086123236,
0.0821432322,
0.0056833974,
-0.0174892191,
-0.0613767393,
-0.011258102,
-0.0273228865,
-0.0162416305,
0.0361209065,
0.0670100525,
-0.0113845868,
0.0740489513,
0.0059938608,
0.050005544,
-0.0366106294,
-0.0498812161,
0.012342195,
0.0469600931,
0.0049579642,
0.016876556,
0.016638292,
-0.059005186,
-0.0298649538,
0.0095257675,
-0.0246315561,
0.0420975536,
0.0407885648,
-0.002860981,
-0.0631730407,
-0.0161728989,
-0.0481760874,
-0.0396359153,
-0.0489951931,
-0.0340034626,
0.0384565443,
0.013046884,
-0.0363442972,
-0.0351419598,
-0.0115654813,
-0.0584824085,
-0.0092237256,
-0.0072878134,
0.0323891714,
-0.0397313274,
0.0052734683,
0.0283890367,
-0.0242136158,
-0.0160806719,
0.0167455822,
-0.0420076922,
0.0338015743,
0.0252701547,
0.0398663059,
0.0335907377,
-0.0497234017,
-0.0274584368,
-0.0302381907,
0.0573636815,
0.011866373,
0.0474893451,
0.0395452231,
0.013688284,
-0.0187697951,
0.0037488407,
0.0307537075,
0.0385445058,
-0.080079928,
0.0382896438,
-0.0327867009,
0.0128843067,
-0.0069894143,
-0.0297920182,
0.001042334,
0.0416345224,
0.0641365871,
-0.1106361374,
-0.0290898122,
-0.0186700393,
2.883e-7,
0.001172416,
0.0394730978,
0.0080355089,
0.0521817803,
0.0173849054,
0.1020950153,
0.0025885543,
0.0898300931,
0.0282817278,
-0.0211887229,
-0.0017816178,
0.016567301,
0.0395698436,
0.0393568277,
-0.0590042248,
0.0027012359,
-0.0110632572,
0.0176391285,
-0.017028885,
-0.0022036859,
0.071931608,
0.0668160766,
0.022094639,
-0.0215691216,
-0.0014894551,
-0.0199387297,
0.0416057892,
-0.0469607078,
0.0373410732,
-0.0410708822,
0.0298695359,
0.0270273406,
0.0175247695,
0.0398421548,
-0.0066715786,
0.0140322037,
-0.0263534095,
0.0638907254,
-0.0116241425,
-0.0516459756,
-0.0191382878,
-0.0148310252,
0.0041613225,
-0.036840979,
0.052037932,
-0.035452351,
-0.0174831618,
0.006535511,
0.0258237235,
0.0031897016,
0.0311470348,
-0.0019346082,
-0.0238937624,
-0.0161037911,
0.0143163204,
0.0213200022,
0.02994591,
-0.0664326251,
-0.0174703654,
-0.0165834539,
0.0282957554,
-0.0737623796,
-0.005563709,
0.060638275,
0.0103556765,
-0.0259876996,
0.0104943076,
2.595357447e-34,
-0.0029700955,
-0.0161886569,
0.037498232,
-0.0190922264,
0.0591198653,
0.0092169391,
0.0490368828,
-0.0010006822,
0.0497250669,
-0.0103100687,
-0.0191146918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12091v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12091v2 | Is poisoning a real threat to LLM alignment? Maybe more so than you think | 2024-06-17T21:06:00 | 2024-06-19T17:56:17 | Pankayaraj Pathmanathan, Souradip Chakraborty, Xiangyu Liu, Yongyuan Liang, Furong Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Recent advancements in Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) have
significantly impacted the alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs). The
sensitivity of reinforcement learning algorithms such as Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) has led to new line work on Direct Policy Optimization
(DPO), which treats RLHF in a supervised learning framework. The increased
practical use of these RLHF methods warrants an analysis of their
vulnerabilities. In this work, we investigate the vulnerabilities of DPO to
poisoning attacks under different scenarios and compare the effectiveness of
preference poisoning, a first of its kind. We comprehensively analyze DPO's
vulnerabilities under different types of attacks, i.e., backdoor and
non-backdoor attacks, and different poisoning methods across a wide array of
language models, i.e., LLama 7B, Mistral 7B, and Gemma 7B. We find that unlike
PPO-based methods, which, when it comes to backdoor attacks, require at least
4\% of the data to be poisoned to elicit harmful behavior, we exploit the true
vulnerabilities of DPO more simply so we can poison the model with only as much
as 0.5\% of the data. We further investigate the potential reasons behind the
vulnerability and how well this vulnerability translates into backdoor vs
non-backdoor attacks. | [
0.0225318298,
0.060309656,
-0.0057090856,
0.0416999459,
-0.0425124019,
-0.0026008033,
-0.0131929526,
-0.008261404,
-0.0003091464,
-0.0052833664,
-0.0477280766,
-0.0008027051,
0.0290751047,
0.0226576496,
0.0496479273,
-0.0134902159,
0.0758250132,
-0.0279133152,
-0.0158498306,
-0.0257042497,
0.0098685808,
-0.0216588378,
0.0227220971,
0.0214239527,
0.0304813255,
-0.0291505046,
-0.0296029244,
0.0312571339,
0.0583802871,
-0.0107247178,
-0.0070648426,
0.0059068836,
0.0008683202,
0.0706662461,
0.0000018703,
-0.0365872607,
-0.049243819,
0.0329026207,
0.0032059199,
0.0011823266,
-0.0069784382,
-0.0151757337,
-0.0482023545,
0.0310036168,
-0.027776029,
0.0344248116,
0.0472984798,
0.0341966599,
0.0668611303,
0.1168131828,
0.0068691899,
-0.0074519683,
0.0406874605,
-0.0258837976,
0.0217519235,
-0.0202802457,
0.0357320718,
-0.0565866902,
-0.0139640616,
-0.0083949948,
-0.025130406,
-0.0056878775,
-0.011409306,
-0.0180247985,
-0.0687062591,
0.0294336546,
0.0139471488,
-0.0280286521,
-0.0062115006,
0.0486976355,
-0.0488460436,
0.0141507806,
0.009616809,
-0.0058663464,
0.009430185,
-0.0110400198,
0.0389388539,
0.0165841263,
0.007397254,
0.0380883291,
0.0694651529,
-0.0360105298,
0.073509641,
-0.013336706,
0.0191588812,
0.1047163084,
0.0265500713,
-0.0527596399,
0.0239286665,
0.0015412001,
0.0039723646,
-0.0583453029,
-0.0369075462,
-0.0039576269,
-0.0474602357,
0.0354322419,
-0.0802223384,
0.0237439107,
0.0250552502,
-0.0597019866,
0.0608427338,
0.0624369718,
0.0233714487,
-0.0029541291,
0.0327752903,
0.0453972742,
-0.0675240681,
0.0729792118,
-0.0119564096,
0.0535968803,
0.0272107162,
-0.0069273766,
0.0373243093,
0.0183053296,
-0.0322591551,
-0.0092014074,
-0.0331651159,
0.0438180715,
-0.0554102063,
0.0592102855,
-0.0178615246,
-0.0057889614,
-0.0158614535,
0.0238665864,
-0.0118568186,
0.0139793474,
0.0026694946,
0.0031828927,
-0.0019373129,
-0.036135383,
-0.0319316499,
0.0120484633,
-0.0891645551,
-0.0454614908,
-0.0156418607,
0.1231727749,
-0.004779771,
-0.0042049983,
-0.0286801159,
-0.0569218583,
-0.04714204,
-0.0476069339,
-0.0151873101,
-0.0534560941,
-0.0245424882,
-0.0355772339,
-0.0157724936,
-0.0692551509,
0.015259291,
0.0006208725,
-0.0564623512,
0.0491314083,
0.0038114749,
-0.0157865267,
-0.0101608755,
0.0057154354,
-0.0391901396,
0.0766015202,
0.0273909736,
0.0277086496,
0.0195428878,
-0.0138429571,
-0.0135031817,
0.0383254178,
0.0141977444,
0.0607182793,
-0.0186561812,
-0.0025909843,
0.04341086,
0.0247384645,
0.025066765,
0.0565345995,
0.0029824015,
-0.0497411676,
0.0995161533,
0.007332975,
-0.034729816,
-0.0009125491,
-0.0209942833,
-0.0176160485,
-0.0192960128,
0.0421298854,
-0.1016563252,
-0.0123229595,
-0.0575552024,
0.0075573809,
0.0076794894,
0.0532692745,
-0.0023639891,
-0.0410389006,
-0.0044945595,
0.0025555338,
-0.0117649846,
0.0298283789,
0.0113807963,
0.0090364106,
-0.0192616917,
0.003999942,
0.0152246421,
-0.0250676349,
0.0059888698,
-0.0371686928,
-0.018832637,
0.0512288474,
0.0436061062,
-0.0394436307,
-0.0422944501,
-0.0230496787,
-0.0535696149,
0.0265794769,
0.0183398593,
-0.0076467684,
-0.001320216,
0.0006478109,
-0.0231724642,
-0.0111037008,
0.0011188794,
0.0043991026,
0.012123052,
0.0059750145,
-0.0455347411,
0.0357126221,
-0.0428181179,
0.0502600297,
-0.0055088573,
-0.0556957945,
0.0049007167,
0.0468299985,
0.0261526536,
0.0117977094,
-0.0283246748,
0.0018154094,
0.0469148308,
0.0042714751,
0.024843365,
-0.0159602035,
-0.0154875377,
-0.0190862026,
0.0688889697,
-0.0171172619,
-0.0339658521,
0.0525132716,
-0.0671650842,
-0.0275398027,
0.0119441813,
0.0001848836,
0.0228441823,
0.0208166037,
0.0257282015,
-0.0119662024,
0.0190630071,
-0.0567379929,
0.0186168533,
-0.0317166522,
-0.0059473272,
-0.0164027158,
-0.0004220497,
0.0034328753,
-0.0604086109,
-0.0657159016,
0.0213345643,
0.0004390115,
0.0142354472,
0.0126564512,
0.0091996584,
-0.0325508937,
-0.0240276512,
0.0069294879,
0.0083162561,
-0.0138087412,
0.0457211994,
0.0166448317,
-0.0003799903,
-0.0362226553,
-0.0214604586,
-0.024978593,
-0.0318467207,
-0.0173747763,
0.029714318,
0.0399071164,
0.0096219853,
-0.0357783735,
-0.0314130485,
-0.0169333983,
-0.0289001707,
0.0223102644,
-0.032741718,
0.0078894589,
-0.0455633588,
0.0268944334,
-0.0188558791,
0.0214918815,
-0.0071612746,
-0.0421506986,
0.0338478535,
0.035247054,
-0.0297226328,
0.1112230122,
-0.0193509869,
0.0478577428,
0.1074461862,
0.0440764315,
-0.0439581685,
-0.0035240713,
-0.0107471365,
-0.0564181767,
-0.0725536272,
-0.0048769582,
-0.0077203214,
0.0652622059,
-0.0097136628,
-0.0292829853,
-0.0250155423,
0.0151172746,
0.0203034803,
-0.0340612382,
0.0174182914,
-0.0259779058,
-0.0556279607,
0.0041790842,
-0.0323255621,
-0.0881919488,
0.0849807486,
-0.0325322635,
0.0261010639,
-0.035999082,
-0.0332615077,
-0.0065946095,
-0.0129771894,
0.0084412657,
0.0247850008,
-0.0255645625,
-0.0167110488,
-0.0606151298,
-0.0226194616,
0.0502717718,
-0.0155447824,
0.0469863936,
-0.0194814298,
0.0017276889,
-0.0268565826,
-0.0944941491,
-0.0679573715,
-0.0498146527,
0.0055970573,
-0.0133155724,
0.0091981469,
-0.0423617065,
-0.0129700694,
-0.0413711295,
0.018502418,
-0.0199734271,
-0.0164577197,
-0.0066923504,
-0.0361076817,
-0.0040131528,
0.0528554432,
-0.0516407974,
0.023602074,
0.000319221,
0.0103568509,
0.0572021417,
0.0331964195,
-0.0072241584,
-0.0131626884,
0.0365652256,
0.0362854898,
-0.0269019622,
0.0021270022,
0.0190876909,
0.0147166671,
-0.0135797486,
-0.0103599289,
0.0398176536,
0.0060093398,
-0.0550542697,
0.0317267925,
0.0093099643,
0.0714666322,
0.0158857517,
0.0467658155,
-0.0591069907,
0.0115620224,
0.0438588709,
0.0625543818,
-0.0295153782,
-0.0193157252,
-0.0195559319,
-0.1307531893,
-0.0181693267,
0.0206703041,
-0.0427798182,
-0.0176973306,
-0.0363344364,
0.0082952539,
-0.0182982888,
0.0668273494,
-0.0039205868,
-0.0023005574,
-0.0111145442,
0.0161681995,
0.0243445262,
-0.0221409164,
-0.0317636095,
-0.0202214811,
0.0513039865,
0.0929402858,
0.001877516,
-0.0206988323,
-0.0063185389,
0.0290567949,
0.0432472788,
-0.0308840498,
0.0184597895,
0.0079497611,
-0.0229056496,
-0.0144277941,
0.0162183233,
0.0542349815,
0.003639621,
0.0008832975,
-0.0053399247,
0.0542207286,
-0.0035760559,
0.0001576197,
-0.0171154868,
-0.0130110122,
0.0377698988,
0.0425425693,
-0.0051902765,
-0.0457625501,
-0.0237657744,
-0.0616105236,
-0.0207806863,
0.0105880518,
-0.0444626957,
0.0344148055,
-0.0121847102,
-0.0273370668,
-0.0371996723,
-0.0056940406,
-0.0209026653,
0.0584119149,
0.0349664167,
0.0136179077,
-0.0234464258,
-0.0005390178,
-0.01137219,
0.0032550546,
-0.0008766383,
0.0409766436,
-0.0588719361,
0.0040460862,
-0.0241685901,
0.0102480026,
-0.0116051473,
-0.0342158042,
-0.0552790463,
-0.1138358936,
0.0352443829,
0.0647670031,
0.024310492,
0.0698060095,
0.0085522113,
-0.0312819593,
0.078469038,
0.0441395752,
0.0297757536,
0.0368739255,
0.0504363403,
-0.0255053528,
0.0236888211,
0.0376376547,
-0.0427178107,
-0.0511339717,
0.0827829763,
0.0180542339,
-0.0110851377,
0.0078974785,
0.0154854478,
0.0171289481,
0.062213067,
-0.0522933118,
0.0320633464,
0.0019977677,
0.0329675265,
-0.0063476334,
-0.0061568762,
0.0122009274,
-0.0244083479,
0.0173622817,
-0.0082839467,
0.028861545,
-0.0026909048,
0.0186471157,
0.0239055287,
0.0139170373,
0.0336601958,
0.0423254296,
0.0323349275,
0.0715589374,
0.052046258,
-0.0031606231,
0.0606489182,
0.0183411762,
0.0518354066,
0.0234312471,
-0.0036530022,
0.0417073928,
0.0219499152,
-0.0366794728,
0.0294106342,
-0.0429461487,
-0.0636443943,
-0.0032018325,
0.0087670134,
0.020909654,
-0.0256368592,
0.0119662993,
-0.0161247905,
-0.0186053161,
-0.0186143089,
-0.0396799296,
-0.0510343201,
-0.014277434,
0.02917221,
-0.0134497238,
-0.0089618461,
0.0306253042,
0.0645747557,
0.0367205143,
0.0678379759,
-0.0256282501,
0.0048302659,
-0.0043740408,
-0.028477544,
0.0265062973,
0.0360770524,
-0.0361981429,
-0.0845862851,
-0.0595753267,
-0.104822889,
-0.0136435479,
0.0229989793,
-0.007744879,
0.0163550954,
-0.009378613,
0.0073223906,
0.0073727653,
0.0243596192,
-0.0384699218,
-0.0109289577,
0.0014294445,
-0.0711303949,
0.0141027104,
-5.636568881e-33,
0.0103437183,
-0.0292761121,
-0.0103823924,
0.0212732535,
-0.0109782806,
-0.0270226896,
0.0020054674,
0.0041389661,
-0.0163270738,
-0.0071498686,
-0.0290432293,
-0.0158802345,
0.0100578433,
0.0092138313,
-0.0046743057,
-0.0247668792,
-0.0131158242,
-0.0147057297,
-0.0419722758,
-0.0097841322,
0.0501098409,
0.0071078828,
0.0203440934,
-0.0451633222,
0.050752379,
0.0101878187,
-0.0301104058,
0.0360015556,
-0.0769440532,
0.0726742148,
0.0136389788,
0.0192762278,
-0.0132761355,
-0.0109233614,
0.0046849605,
0.0390012786,
-0.0062241596,
-0.0371549316,
0.0048655346,
0.0001358673,
-0.0074750907,
-0.0738390684,
0.0630673617,
0.0178878885,
-0.0383880585,
-0.0001549454,
-0.0031508363,
-0.0088323867,
-0.0366940461,
0.0176970717,
-0.0512404591,
-0.0066641672,
0.0001221753,
0.0199550316,
0.0103996936,
-0.031106554,
0.0217126776,
0.0134988725,
-0.0482660234,
0.0387064889,
-0.0047548097,
0.0315506905,
0.1042595506,
0.059992034,
0.005772416,
0.0610267892,
0.0222862754,
-0.0003616005,
0.0149810072,
-0.0073650731,
0.0061318735,
0.0019194362,
-0.0155964894,
0.0472469665,
0.0282792915,
-0.0027679536,
-0.0394923724,
0.0286259688,
0.0221323725,
0.0072126533,
0.007806906,
0.0235607829,
-0.0740883574,
-0.0177893881,
-0.0333686136,
-0.0419108123,
-0.0130641032,
-0.042975232,
0.0024063012,
0.0060803569,
-0.0049889726,
-0.0264914799,
-0.0003545468,
-0.0424935855,
-0.0256973654,
0.0041669356,
-0.0153032914,
-0.0123070786,
-0.0072741229,
0.0021930218,
-0.0457204767,
-0.0151952058,
-0.0448754765,
-0.0557847209,
0.0293513052,
0.0218672566,
0.0402522162,
0.026549276,
-0.0582047366,
0.0085044308,
-0.0314868279,
0.0210428294,
0.052856084,
0.0501124747,
0.0461780429,
-0.050243631,
0.0210432317,
0.0251048673,
0.0584187806,
0.0368807763,
-0.0121264225,
0.0318087824,
-0.0305181351,
-0.0039300965,
0.001760524,
0.0221658386,
0.0096015064,
0.0913256481,
0.0012502559,
-0.0703917146,
0.00153329,
-0.0340745561,
2.701e-7,
0.0318107642,
0.0187892877,
0.039898932,
0.0152635984,
0.0015593789,
0.0697773173,
-0.0277451128,
0.0763510913,
-0.0244276356,
-0.0187773369,
0.0071727075,
-0.0225916933,
0.0249603223,
0.0062915427,
-0.0553561039,
0.0446072407,
-0.0624781922,
0.0216682982,
-0.0725373328,
-0.0170928109,
0.0175854545,
0.1001087353,
0.0406844057,
-0.0396665074,
-0.0153582599,
0.0030859206,
0.0255782995,
-0.0219113044,
-0.0096841408,
-0.0194960553,
0.0305182189,
0.0024650458,
-0.0135868657,
-0.0052607264,
-0.0283210091,
0.0159353949,
-0.0801641941,
0.0142516857,
-0.018591037,
-0.0763789862,
-0.0400734618,
-0.0294326171,
0.0081660915,
-0.0327950232,
0.0531695709,
0.0002659882,
-0.0205869265,
-0.0035218094,
-0.0025345203,
-0.0452086292,
0.0680162609,
-0.0318159871,
0.0016448611,
0.0305410139,
-0.0156699643,
0.0180686712,
0.0023658541,
-0.0641149655,
-0.0258734543,
-0.0122785512,
-0.011659652,
-0.0569042936,
0.0037966168,
0.0812231898,
-0.0058716433,
-0.0100077605,
-0.0273565184,
2.723754261e-34,
-0.0222656243,
-0.0538272262,
0.0179319251,
-0.0109166261,
-0.0035580783,
-0.0002551816,
-0.0016295037,
0.0256069545,
0.0124593768,
-0.0496353395,
-0.0258392673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12084v1 | When Reasoning Meets Information Aggregation: A Case Study with Sports Narratives | 2024-06-17T20:49:35 | 2024-06-17T20:49:35 | Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Wenlin Yao, Hassan Foroosh, Dong Yu, Fei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning is most powerful when an LLM accurately aggregates relevant
information. We examine the critical role of information aggregation in
reasoning by requiring the LLM to analyze sports narratives. To succeed at this
task, an LLM must infer points from actions, identify related entities,
attribute points accurately to players and teams, and compile key statistics to
draw conclusions. We conduct comprehensive experiments with real NBA basketball
data and present SportsGen, a new method to synthesize game narratives. By
synthesizing data, we can rigorously evaluate LLMs' reasoning capabilities
under complex scenarios with varying narrative lengths and density of
information. Our findings show that most models, including GPT-4o, often fail
to accurately aggregate basketball scores due to frequent scoring patterns.
Open-source models like Llama-3 further suffer from significant score
hallucinations. Finally, the effectiveness of reasoning is influenced by
narrative complexity, information density, and domain-specific terms,
highlighting the challenges in analytical reasoning tasks. | [
-0.0257089753,
0.0394916348,
-0.0032201717,
0.0327127092,
-0.0308101755,
0.0353775583,
-0.0475155525,
0.0095189698,
-0.0344685838,
-0.0184356142,
0.0448579416,
-0.0194789171,
0.048659876,
0.0422021523,
0.0080585247,
-0.0301933419,
-0.0326868221,
-0.0235353895,
0.036662396,
-0.016623918,
-0.0080326702,
0.0573205389,
-0.03554767,
-0.0116941575,
-0.0293442197,
0.007250885,
-0.0114518218,
-0.003436402,
0.007070797,
-0.0340535119,
-0.082354106,
0.0153868813,
0.0333963335,
-0.0563611351,
0.0000019764,
-0.0730685368,
0.0253659114,
-0.0407815874,
-0.0249202047,
0.0119618597,
-0.0110741546,
0.0101791676,
0.0526896194,
-0.0032866623,
-0.0230515599,
0.0217207111,
0.0172680374,
0.0195620712,
0.0293895807,
0.0538921058,
-0.0155880209,
-0.0704522058,
0.0290868431,
-0.0099971369,
0.0225707702,
-0.0292146672,
0.0096584223,
0.0698547065,
0.0223752409,
-0.0395502374,
-0.0035341636,
-0.0066632791,
0.006364618,
0.0327759236,
0.0001267615,
0.0673755854,
0.0291286483,
0.0260117911,
0.0071493424,
0.0468685292,
0.0046483688,
-0.0091686025,
0.0453711338,
-0.0123830084,
0.0291603636,
-0.0034279446,
-0.0433133394,
0.0319152325,
-0.0349812284,
0.031602066,
-0.0025671057,
0.0241502225,
0.0342075452,
0.0121226124,
-0.0568151176,
0.0335969701,
-0.0129516069,
0.0006759334,
-0.0602939054,
0.031876985,
0.017221678,
-0.0898438618,
-0.0326119997,
0.0423272811,
-0.0337690003,
0.0131321298,
0.0221577529,
0.0592510849,
-0.0144546842,
-0.0304292515,
0.0548867658,
0.0389578417,
0.031229103,
0.0498467237,
-0.0037523846,
-0.0107295914,
-0.0092290752,
0.0066320556,
-0.0217610244,
-0.0020104228,
-0.0827878341,
0.0149335116,
0.0446070991,
0.0623352155,
-0.0411131568,
0.0460205041,
-0.0184386056,
0.014924055,
0.000410005,
0.014792948,
-0.0360532179,
0.0130649777,
0.0355153419,
-0.0286349654,
-0.0815315098,
-0.0171916913,
-0.0881066248,
0.0279276855,
0.0197543576,
-0.0271743555,
-0.006802008,
-0.0258339904,
0.0254582576,
0.0136013059,
0.0341328047,
0.0353025533,
0.0086384527,
0.0470385551,
-0.0691682473,
-0.0602478869,
0.002308459,
-0.1167575866,
-0.015296679,
-0.0805655047,
0.0711643845,
-0.0098328581,
-0.0168701392,
-0.0386541039,
-0.0135453995,
0.0041319956,
-0.0744708627,
0.0542342961,
-0.0181620754,
0.0275989193,
0.0141943144,
0.013198196,
0.0115359528,
0.0350621827,
0.0667368174,
0.0174869392,
-0.0157695841,
0.0320593901,
0.0630707443,
-0.0000394042,
-0.0111955181,
0.0208921768,
-0.0317839198,
0.0199537408,
-0.0671683699,
0.0232463423,
-0.042007558,
0.0294675734,
-0.0327795856,
0.0183447134,
0.0667462572,
0.06990771,
0.0322686806,
-0.0148796225,
0.0574788637,
-0.0254890192,
0.0197770912,
0.0230949502,
-0.0425467528,
0.0803428739,
-0.0045510973,
0.0304268505,
0.0029580432,
0.0236032344,
-0.030846158,
-0.0832703933,
-0.0074961456,
-0.005055631,
-0.0439655185,
0.0432273634,
0.0213030241,
-0.0345590152,
0.0059669022,
0.0612582788,
0.0034628131,
-0.0432777293,
0.022381667,
-0.0176612493,
0.0425847434,
0.059315566,
0.0463532433,
-0.0471858382,
-0.0349465832,
-0.0388484895,
0.0120261451,
-0.0002480002,
0.0089997975,
-0.0031335419,
-0.0044839159,
-0.0366365835,
-0.0289473198,
-0.0177584048,
0.0357877463,
0.0276075471,
-0.0515184477,
-0.0274209641,
-0.007626859,
-0.0137375602,
-0.018966021,
0.0179048441,
-0.0669890866,
-0.0204049088,
-0.0082327547,
-0.0401133075,
-0.0327720977,
0.0547329299,
0.0139269652,
0.024084067,
0.0197530519,
-0.0049970816,
-0.061869286,
0.0485642627,
-0.002804426,
0.0059982305,
0.0034320694,
-0.0115239853,
-0.0291750915,
-0.0650622174,
-0.0372653529,
-0.0428825915,
0.0186586976,
-0.0097651314,
0.0142557425,
-0.0151400128,
-0.003882702,
-0.0001144716,
-0.0188057143,
0.0099122059,
0.0880027339,
-0.0011753229,
-0.00318314,
-0.0100757927,
-0.0082471594,
0.0104360655,
-0.0228214972,
0.0736024082,
0.046357926,
0.0170597397,
-0.0136358896,
0.0217470843,
-0.0610973351,
-0.0539799519,
-0.003728814,
-0.0505058989,
0.0573198274,
-0.0130643696,
0.0172570609,
-0.001819725,
0.0013999139,
-0.0473654196,
0.0203025304,
-0.0398818851,
-0.0457104594,
0.0239759907,
-0.0046075983,
0.0228542723,
0.035612978,
0.0049272832,
-0.0142940795,
0.0157197285,
-0.0370898321,
0.0567787923,
0.0462795012,
-0.0078674164,
-0.079237923,
0.0154486382,
-0.0779377073,
-0.0153877316,
-0.0181558151,
0.04860254,
0.032813929,
-0.0284685697,
0.0278150458,
0.054348547,
-0.0078118541,
0.0044266242,
0.0613730624,
-0.116795361,
0.0049545458,
0.0253831893,
-0.0347089954,
0.0100528132,
-0.0480502062,
-0.0450691544,
-0.0034971659,
0.0369289182,
0.0115860309,
0.0179353002,
-0.0390732698,
0.069325693,
0.0043552909,
0.0048584598,
0.0060910815,
-0.0341947079,
0.0057344362,
0.0579941832,
-0.0195608586,
0.0131737161,
0.0349506624,
-0.0145891625,
0.0612199269,
-0.0092018992,
-0.0239602849,
-0.0360774584,
0.0785145238,
0.0203165002,
0.0195857491,
-0.0000275365,
0.0109266303,
-0.0177695733,
-0.0418069772,
0.0634679496,
-0.0289514065,
0.0572939664,
-0.0509021133,
-0.0199029483,
0.0341705941,
-0.0081353486,
-0.0143735902,
0.0070768055,
-0.0390921719,
-0.0264345054,
-0.0035414153,
-0.0014488605,
-0.0950665325,
-0.0648830235,
0.0631003752,
-0.0413871296,
-0.000575166,
-0.0401471294,
0.0280954149,
0.016745057,
0.0059556952,
0.0016440381,
0.0205190778,
-0.0693638548,
0.0431819037,
0.0674232319,
0.0024518657,
0.0095229046,
0.00889521,
0.0106402701,
-0.0242286399,
-0.0131997298,
-0.032282643,
0.0413209796,
0.0241064429,
-0.0515685491,
0.0514497049,
0.121056065,
0.0403903425,
0.0325252488,
0.0004141682,
0.0253479332,
-0.0437666923,
-0.00780336,
0.0024206468,
-0.0789188147,
-0.0013513088,
0.0239977185,
0.0141266594,
-0.0311377756,
-0.0753540024,
-0.0359616913,
-0.0605932288,
0.0486175194,
0.0187947247,
0.0432102457,
-0.02697476,
-0.0451355316,
0.012274473,
-0.0439911671,
-0.0386057906,
0.0095137693,
0.0041479124,
0.0190475825,
-0.0114933187,
-0.0420580581,
0.0261889286,
0.0306620467,
-0.0347779654,
0.0165675469,
0.0039726552,
0.0774615556,
-0.0349338539,
-0.0314656086,
-0.0375422575,
0.0584079027,
0.0018758813,
0.0055930372,
0.0814186186,
-0.0076010325,
0.0316096246,
-0.0307998974,
0.0486785062,
-0.0110349441,
-0.0237166062,
0.0076947496,
0.0600305311,
0.0102665825,
-0.0330004096,
0.0096145114,
-0.0095774066,
-0.0414169431,
0.0564445667,
0.0064340434,
0.0185196288,
-0.0210715085,
-0.0255133305,
0.0052095787,
-0.0524482131,
-0.04028273,
0.0011641969,
0.0241506752,
-0.003985892,
-0.0063108481,
-0.0690331161,
-0.0008747785,
0.0189249758,
-0.0152404169,
0.0563826673,
-0.0332597382,
-0.0426243395,
-0.0695490167,
0.0190363806,
-0.042203173,
0.0219735783,
0.0579771139,
0.040533185,
0.047635898,
-0.0329264998,
0.0111363046,
0.0438302681,
-0.0280352049,
-0.0493291058,
-0.0141702555,
0.0111104557,
0.0324021205,
0.0206288528,
0.0423653647,
-0.0112579241,
0.0226377845,
0.0160538275,
-0.0187260378,
0.0348959118,
-0.0258150809,
0.0248429738,
0.0186705235,
-0.0027059466,
-0.0137786129,
0.0505877882,
-0.0196683779,
-0.0056252251,
-0.0803027079,
0.0104975412,
0.0175573789,
0.0125568807,
0.0245654024,
0.0027910904,
-0.0415554605,
-0.0225073379,
-0.0062637678,
-0.0463704877,
-0.006206539,
-0.0041491291,
-0.005360059,
0.0141428635,
0.0061616814,
-0.0179109275,
0.0198455136,
-0.0272515062,
0.0066535664,
-0.0458244234,
-0.0096958689,
0.000986381,
-0.0389587991,
0.0108029936,
-0.0350962915,
0.0036757507,
0.0121231973,
-0.0340140425,
0.062473245,
0.0329431966,
-0.0025699208,
0.0209296029,
-0.0002201229,
0.0138697578,
-0.0002996703,
-0.0565542802,
-0.0166287813,
0.0250607096,
0.0107139498,
0.0724625885,
-0.004301446,
-0.0024879901,
-0.0097092986,
0.0207652841,
0.0131755313,
0.0022516758,
0.0026943123,
0.001077887,
-0.0233365744,
0.0401853845,
-0.0349735171,
-0.0051476187,
0.0219538119,
-0.0166794956,
0.0477782302,
-0.0265903175,
-0.0347732492,
-0.0127884811,
-0.0384910032,
-0.0223724395,
0.0099147009,
-0.0120153921,
-0.0285633672,
-0.1194168627,
-0.0034795986,
0.036721658,
0.0076204101,
0.0237698164,
-0.0015714552,
-0.0250327382,
0.0280432198,
0.0198377296,
0.0167075805,
-0.013346917,
0.0315210596,
-0.0543416254,
-0.0052332911,
0.0409036912,
-6.119631305e-33,
-0.0177702978,
-0.0702861771,
0.052806139,
0.00556794,
-0.0626680031,
-0.0117063727,
-0.0303040016,
-0.0147054624,
-0.0023996802,
0.0328869149,
0.0121545326,
0.0355485752,
-0.0051807333,
-0.0305332411,
0.0309548192,
-0.0532493405,
0.0190572944,
-0.0019783094,
-0.0419429503,
-0.0044221389,
0.0432833135,
0.0100565562,
0.0149011137,
-0.0706368238,
0.035730157,
-0.0378515311,
-0.0157129578,
0.0024998893,
-0.000930133,
0.0079917433,
0.0158308726,
-0.0445067473,
0.0515188389,
-0.0453812853,
-0.0301705934,
0.0212324802,
-0.0265738592,
-0.0151244188,
0.0282584317,
-0.0372819193,
0.0085605243,
-0.0126621881,
0.0289675072,
0.0233635642,
0.0242646188,
-0.0831981748,
0.0343338251,
-0.0485669635,
0.0366067402,
-0.0344957896,
-0.0255476329,
0.0377050936,
0.0001334518,
0.0012507943,
0.0236968808,
0.0258470029,
0.0078052706,
0.0086789131,
-0.0089156739,
0.0181935579,
-0.0176538043,
-0.0004816097,
0.0257959217,
0.0136961797,
-0.0095695397,
0.0382670835,
0.0404209532,
0.0016492868,
-0.1505180001,
0.0296170842,
-0.0304787774,
0.0664824471,
0.0626278371,
0.0244473536,
0.0169969387,
0.0525811538,
-0.0674882755,
0.0390924066,
-0.0031163187,
0.0295039695,
-0.0091543933,
0.0318790227,
-0.0651319548,
-0.0128015066,
-0.0325432196,
0.0098730912,
-0.0146158021,
-0.0485540144,
-0.0203054845,
-0.0328985155,
-0.0144416532,
0.0444647186,
-0.0185055193,
0.0234980695,
-0.0008464725,
0.0122549534,
-0.0056553739,
0.0554949604,
-0.0314253494,
0.0082818298,
-0.0387237817,
0.0238008723,
0.0033716804,
0.0144625735,
0.0321433321,
0.0009223183,
-0.0074316105,
0.0269859023,
-0.0047476343,
-0.0248600654,
-0.0155110536,
-0.0084092403,
0.0114465673,
-0.0649148896,
0.0241232831,
0.0434503108,
0.0146449879,
-0.0295622554,
-0.0003178312,
-0.0339870714,
-0.0154779516,
0.0249097496,
-0.0346644931,
0.0001701243,
0.0268189907,
-0.0210448708,
0.0246701129,
0.0026886493,
0.0358866006,
0.0011547019,
-0.0393262655,
-0.0013140339,
2.8e-7,
0.0171241388,
0.0339018628,
-0.0123283369,
0.0104819648,
-0.0328775719,
0.0489401147,
-0.0302413888,
0.007581864,
0.0297776498,
-0.0827782229,
0.0324487723,
0.0829654559,
0.033157602,
0.0977651775,
-0.074542433,
-0.0492827706,
0.0194721855,
-0.0559416227,
-0.0559890904,
0.0011052372,
0.0994467884,
-0.015708575,
0.1086001396,
-0.0069890004,
0.0209030211,
-0.049811434,
0.0641278699,
-0.01445588,
-0.0418444462,
0.072277382,
0.0328458138,
0.0163517296,
-0.0435250401,
0.0242336132,
-0.0400449894,
-0.0002675898,
-0.0034827325,
0.0083610211,
-0.0085855732,
-0.0088633802,
-0.0326315686,
-0.0656820908,
-0.0131449513,
0.0189840775,
0.0605453067,
-0.0270974133,
-0.0584918261,
0.0085207904,
-0.0513877533,
0.000465763,
-0.0122893872,
0.0338966884,
0.0034981379,
0.036895819,
-0.0270217247,
0.0123149687,
0.0382217728,
-0.0681378171,
-0.0086766575,
0.0430252515,
-0.0332248919,
-0.015767701,
0.014550576,
0.0063714297,
0.0068892767,
-0.0659737438,
0.0027635135,
2.266365047e-34,
0.0018914568,
0.0223000813,
-0.0066767717,
-0.0078413747,
0.0288542882,
0.0032126897,
-0.0217648596,
0.0151869496,
0.0455789939,
-0.0266458038,
-0.0015657913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12074v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12074v1 | COMMUNITY-CROSS-INSTRUCT: Unsupervised Instruction Generation for Aligning Large Language Models to Online Communities | 2024-06-17T20:20:47 | 2024-06-17T20:20:47 | Zihao He, Rebecca Dorn, Siyi Guo, Minh Duc Chu, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social scientists use surveys to probe the opinions and beliefs of
populations, but these methods are slow, costly, and prone to biases. Recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) enable creating computational
representations or "digital twins" of populations that generate human-like
responses mimicking the population's language, styles, and attitudes. We
introduce Community-Cross-Instruct, an unsupervised framework for aligning LLMs
to online communities to elicit their beliefs. Given a corpus of a community's
online discussions, Community-Cross-Instruct automatically generates
instruction-output pairs by an advanced LLM to (1) finetune an foundational LLM
to faithfully represent that community, and (2) evaluate the alignment of the
finetuned model to the community. We demonstrate the method's utility in
accurately representing political and fitness communities on Reddit. Unlike
prior methods requiring human-authored instructions, Community-Cross-Instruct
generates instructions in a fully unsupervised manner, enhancing scalability
and generalization across domains. This work enables cost-effective and
automated surveying of diverse online communities. | [
0.0443663932,
0.1275036484,
-0.0212361459,
0.0206152853,
-0.019989118,
0.013449179,
0.0045957933,
-0.0136164259,
0.0292112194,
-0.0328037776,
-0.0234777611,
-0.0162831713,
-0.0118537992,
0.0071333125,
0.0197687373,
-0.021221716,
-0.0003986893,
0.0198627673,
-0.004557516,
-0.051429484,
0.0519602112,
0.0542124771,
-0.0073401351,
0.0217354447,
0.0154099343,
-0.0247411039,
0.0182101708,
-0.0077375565,
0.0251180772,
-0.0018283906,
0.0284180734,
0.0370349735,
0.0208423063,
0.0557840168,
0.0000019214,
-0.02792757,
0.0131450994,
-0.0069494094,
0.0263972245,
-0.002181435,
0.0914916769,
0.0184125826,
0.0267013293,
0.0201477539,
-0.0495235287,
0.0382503457,
0.0756504685,
-0.0250032954,
0.0783863813,
0.0442130752,
0.0011324582,
-0.0519534163,
-0.0301846974,
-0.0066666431,
-0.0049167946,
0.0261943918,
0.0335299522,
0.0102985771,
0.0058078924,
0.0366101675,
-0.0198170543,
0.0145536214,
-0.0295281075,
-0.0394271202,
0.0095282858,
-0.0065267095,
-0.0253684744,
-0.0398669504,
0.0099744592,
0.0840705559,
0.0289406609,
-0.0168170296,
0.044155702,
0.0087502832,
-0.0194792189,
0.0727459937,
-0.0631384999,
0.017269861,
0.0096309185,
0.0448402539,
-0.0144300358,
-0.0023380043,
0.0361589901,
0.0110417819,
0.010164056,
0.0781694278,
0.0003133622,
0.0171982292,
-0.0400197804,
0.0463329703,
-0.0063153901,
-0.0233657714,
0.0443529226,
-0.0084984927,
0.0059030382,
0.0254143346,
-0.0097425068,
-0.0079098726,
0.0478444621,
-0.0398819037,
0.0786784291,
0.0052301725,
0.011256149,
0.0525124036,
0.019151859,
-0.0145161301,
-0.0243462995,
0.016730167,
-0.0185199417,
0.0056914617,
-0.0957609266,
0.0142862359,
-0.004150406,
0.0000818332,
0.0109083969,
-0.0065271826,
-0.0607289001,
0.007183102,
-0.0677606538,
-0.0234588701,
0.0064577959,
0.01391395,
0.0193025433,
-0.0123295691,
-0.035953477,
0.0349643528,
-0.0572613887,
0.0423234515,
-0.0020178291,
-0.038130939,
0.0374308936,
0.0195388924,
0.0466533229,
-0.0123691764,
0.0013188492,
0.0125670489,
0.0337751284,
0.018427372,
0.014344546,
-0.0220933128,
-0.0238421988,
-0.0367748439,
0.0021682263,
-0.0952519104,
0.0991425812,
0.0087594418,
0.0074336282,
-0.0411638282,
0.0082089556,
0.0385528579,
-0.0358031578,
0.0670814738,
-0.0120359221,
0.0330889672,
0.0404880419,
0.0164233167,
0.0407753438,
0.0844577029,
-0.0026730509,
-0.005018462,
0.0234954581,
0.0066356505,
-0.0074217799,
0.0372105613,
0.0370970406,
-0.0133213792,
-0.020323636,
0.0165298171,
0.0023593639,
0.019776538,
0.016423611,
0.0798850432,
-0.0082072793,
-0.0223109107,
0.0714708567,
0.0695415214,
-0.0266309138,
0.0392699502,
0.0382354781,
0.0450423062,
-0.0163380206,
-0.0117287589,
-0.0019316571,
0.0168314837,
-0.0153932003,
-0.0271185655,
0.0500969924,
0.0431797616,
-0.0319939889,
-0.0101845171,
-0.0054093814,
-0.0044042869,
0.0386560783,
0.0098510468,
0.0300628245,
-0.0285897478,
0.030894788,
0.0339656845,
0.0545002595,
-0.0463569313,
0.011770756,
-0.0382730737,
0.0292941723,
0.0448652953,
-0.0112222536,
-0.004838814,
0.0037556167,
-0.0326357335,
0.0547790863,
0.0616525374,
0.0579517148,
-0.0193964783,
-0.0473811626,
-0.0320391133,
-0.0085031241,
0.0082012219,
0.0095361611,
0.0151593247,
0.019626243,
-0.0066596279,
-0.003734828,
-0.0066350237,
-0.0274200942,
-0.0018963837,
-0.0300946273,
0.0302317385,
-0.0228967946,
-0.0095809419,
0.0437128395,
0.0454963222,
0.0080639804,
-0.0082176235,
-0.0011533939,
-0.0153766936,
-0.0538897663,
-0.0103702573,
-0.0025471875,
-0.0191550963,
0.0646758229,
-0.0834176391,
-0.0525283888,
0.0278744288,
-0.0120359799,
0.0119627519,
0.0562733561,
-0.0476739109,
0.0141871097,
-0.0158707742,
-0.0463987626,
-0.0354348384,
-0.0024120449,
-0.0099238297,
0.022487279,
-0.0110242078,
0.0052559171,
0.039746087,
-0.0624667071,
-0.0171123296,
-0.0152105214,
-0.0472818501,
-0.0234145448,
0.0029434515,
0.0067263739,
0.0652932823,
-0.0108352043,
-0.0567532852,
-0.0554431006,
-0.0605926476,
-0.0101198126,
-0.0091956956,
0.0316457041,
0.0330668911,
-0.0244590268,
0.0089437505,
0.019746203,
-0.0742248669,
0.0072354479,
-0.004623116,
0.0423289686,
0.0294122491,
-0.0154640991,
0.0072151073,
-0.0220564809,
-0.0245221481,
-0.0283492133,
0.0205749944,
0.0544508025,
-0.0058328165,
-0.0285900012,
0.0078465622,
-0.0810550079,
-0.0176958758,
-0.0046269139,
-0.0513739847,
0.0358810127,
-0.0201140344,
0.0470978469,
0.0162898954,
0.0406717509,
0.0150375394,
0.0440554358,
0.0409280807,
-0.0623406991,
-0.0507493801,
-0.0686282888,
-0.0294176862,
-0.0355382338,
-0.0707067251,
-0.0176851954,
0.0608689263,
0.0167149156,
-0.0056442744,
-0.0496947356,
0.0536474362,
-0.0176708139,
-0.008495314,
-0.0312914141,
-0.0050974889,
0.0042294301,
0.0313540883,
-0.0159431435,
-0.0211401638,
0.0535819307,
0.0081731426,
0.0215700902,
0.0046619829,
-0.0231519081,
-0.0037150467,
0.0141058005,
0.0405509658,
0.0462079234,
0.0013641905,
0.0047769384,
-0.0113981692,
-0.006410195,
0.0441545174,
-0.0646617562,
-0.019473426,
-0.0032001445,
0.0202022232,
0.0366793498,
-0.0117029157,
-0.0135973943,
-0.0450670272,
-0.0310072564,
-0.0135055874,
0.0436150283,
-0.0259345938,
-0.0230266415,
-0.0059629292,
0.0187637471,
-0.0535011999,
0.0136150345,
-0.0103934873,
0.0078223273,
0.0364340283,
0.0626157001,
0.005532824,
0.0029359895,
-0.047043588,
-0.0292660911,
0.0580511093,
-0.0044974303,
0.0123569807,
-0.0164337177,
-0.0411571972,
0.0270886533,
-0.0090161003,
0.0140216146,
-0.0030308163,
0.0565958507,
0.0090854969,
-0.0021193663,
0.1014512181,
0.0215743463,
-0.0567383803,
-0.0243619792,
-0.0130757149,
0.0126149962,
0.0353358798,
0.0063589988,
-0.097023569,
0.0035853658,
-0.028886456,
0.0279415864,
-0.0176741276,
-0.0471934974,
0.0087162349,
-0.1154685318,
-0.0020256981,
0.0159583576,
-0.0110696526,
-0.0101784496,
-0.0567582846,
0.0310854279,
-0.0262942687,
-0.0311993938,
-0.020273177,
0.006387243,
0.0189471543,
0.0131509714,
-0.0754793659,
-0.0221274756,
0.0211469606,
-0.0541550219,
0.0924442708,
0.0470436998,
0.0583146363,
0.0083445143,
-0.0509835854,
0.0182236303,
-0.0130925374,
-0.0244211704,
-0.0064643165,
0.0270703062,
-0.0112624476,
-0.0027171175,
-0.0505919494,
0.0601299368,
-0.0384662226,
-0.0191172846,
0.015813129,
0.0848541111,
0.0233383402,
-0.0484637469,
-0.0481929295,
0.0438345857,
0.042094022,
0.0784566626,
0.0481343381,
-0.049640663,
0.030505253,
-0.0437445156,
-0.0049320599,
-0.0203342214,
-0.0822625905,
-0.0167143829,
0.008414383,
0.0116187511,
-0.0481692255,
-0.0135122593,
0.0259640571,
0.007798716,
0.0029275701,
-0.042507764,
0.0663026497,
-0.0247349981,
-0.0453127436,
0.0436390415,
-0.0843423754,
0.0064902413,
-0.0088123828,
-0.0721978471,
0.0336520188,
-0.0034467813,
-0.0151986647,
0.0291443784,
-0.0767748803,
-0.0852222219,
0.0232324824,
0.0323703364,
0.0176282823,
0.0166263524,
-0.0172237586,
-0.0202216972,
0.0310389493,
0.0632031113,
-0.0270550437,
-0.0075469143,
-0.0255052857,
0.0499997772,
0.0121853342,
0.0266177747,
-0.000305677,
0.0316508859,
0.0068975422,
0.0172245298,
-0.1030727401,
-0.0574903004,
0.0046462561,
0.0238792729,
0.0388581194,
-0.0029269033,
0.0165389739,
-0.0311815999,
-0.083528094,
-0.0340362266,
-0.0219889265,
-0.0102663022,
-0.0405984409,
0.0386216678,
-0.0113362335,
-0.0248444248,
0.0135194967,
-0.0420211628,
0.0627409667,
-0.0693855733,
0.0458208993,
0.0072243242,
0.0243438371,
0.0288511291,
0.0043132212,
0.0063021639,
0.0295183156,
-0.0111260582,
0.0098681869,
0.0094397655,
0.0296545159,
0.0010238537,
-0.01577284,
0.0056402157,
-0.0048573851,
-0.0199256595,
-0.041122701,
-0.018161118,
0.0490570292,
0.0029366412,
0.0019859895,
0.0405471921,
0.0049947142,
-0.0399172567,
-0.0003888722,
0.0603733063,
-0.0086464146,
-0.0423603766,
0.0561935194,
0.0064537101,
-0.0226922873,
-0.0216401573,
0.0371828005,
-0.0475790203,
0.0128646754,
0.0036234008,
-0.053117387,
-0.0124468934,
-0.018575076,
-0.0073864334,
0.0160725582,
-0.0231546052,
-0.0068171541,
-0.026667079,
-0.059994746,
0.0017651031,
0.0145775089,
0.0047819386,
0.0109286215,
0.0401648954,
0.0082069952,
-0.0297279507,
0.0474008285,
-0.0561965071,
0.0524683595,
-0.057230588,
-0.0298444089,
0.0062655727,
-6.598739659e-33,
0.00088306,
-0.063466087,
-0.0077342377,
-0.0005107103,
-0.0186494924,
-0.0285599846,
-0.0244583599,
0.0337803662,
0.0081055779,
0.0292047653,
0.0324768685,
0.0038239616,
-0.0096838214,
0.0270680785,
0.0337392949,
-0.0278461613,
0.02580381,
-0.0160158668,
0.0068170936,
0.0219366774,
0.0157035813,
0.0040092417,
0.0033622566,
-0.0888682604,
0.0398521908,
-0.0234638471,
-0.0005132889,
0.0299591441,
0.0369452164,
0.0345471576,
-0.0266501009,
0.0384463593,
0.0094442442,
-0.0177246165,
-0.0047724731,
0.0657865405,
-0.0296221916,
-0.014800176,
0.0005643075,
-0.0241436232,
-0.0243730973,
-0.0182913933,
0.0305625591,
-0.0267497823,
-0.0285849795,
-0.0202669855,
0.0625001416,
-0.0242673326,
0.0523346178,
-0.0248270668,
-0.0325697698,
-0.0043593985,
-0.0293275658,
-0.0031729767,
-0.015381909,
0.0239214636,
0.011643853,
0.0768410414,
-0.0470757969,
0.0660802051,
-0.0407113284,
0.0038164551,
0.0588068441,
-0.0105622523,
0.0249505192,
0.0716606751,
-0.0012731584,
0.0139913261,
-0.062998645,
-0.0028892811,
0.0036766301,
0.0282132551,
0.0428412706,
0.0759557411,
-0.008400674,
-0.0182680506,
-0.0537003875,
0.0036092696,
0.0756349117,
-0.0386348702,
0.0536285415,
0.0129657881,
-0.0124231894,
-0.0064830482,
-0.0221395008,
-0.0716976598,
-0.0368017405,
-0.0391744487,
-0.0374268703,
-0.0244254787,
-0.0685334802,
0.0019437498,
0.0124763148,
-0.0534286387,
-0.053708598,
0.0173356682,
-0.0147918276,
0.0046497732,
0.0099001946,
0.0236764364,
-0.0668092296,
0.0003620787,
-0.0289569981,
0.0272761397,
0.015176598,
0.0091509065,
0.0129266884,
0.0028798813,
-0.0669164583,
-0.0245237239,
-0.031408716,
-0.0132910768,
-0.0344711915,
-0.017262714,
0.0254018698,
0.0477477238,
0.0016601697,
0.025600642,
0.0284258593,
0.0089814961,
0.0081897955,
0.0104036154,
-0.0180598591,
0.0114252735,
-0.0425900631,
-0.0211899821,
-0.0453241654,
0.0183812901,
0.0070069665,
-0.0522037446,
-0.0088964319,
-0.0146386866,
2.605e-7,
0.0672030449,
0.0606405959,
-0.0240166262,
-0.0159449242,
0.0459576957,
0.0122584831,
0.0201188028,
0.014192271,
0.0159855913,
-0.0785109177,
-0.0034642655,
0.0780930594,
0.0334762931,
0.0257609282,
-0.0726345405,
0.0043047853,
-0.060272187,
-0.0057926639,
-0.0263649821,
0.0255777556,
0.0024313158,
0.0295258071,
0.0248122495,
-0.0017898381,
-0.027655134,
0.0043495982,
0.0837519839,
-0.0457439236,
-0.0371136665,
0.0188742187,
-0.025339352,
-0.037069276,
0.0021276756,
-0.0247758795,
-0.0038924199,
-0.0314276703,
0.0190493483,
0.0633942932,
0.0330678895,
-0.0074203084,
-0.0006953462,
-0.0069338307,
0.0058005382,
-0.0276690442,
0.041147653,
-0.0934733376,
-0.0434851013,
-0.1125739068,
-0.044582393,
-0.0377043672,
0.0307600107,
-0.0401015542,
-0.0009642665,
0.014273745,
0.0132945944,
-0.0115229515,
-0.0103115737,
-0.0551692955,
0.0072561963,
-0.0080560548,
-0.0898869112,
-0.0794830322,
0.0141041614,
0.0230887868,
0.0183957219,
-0.0217633359,
0.0452859215,
1.844630505e-34,
0.0172103774,
0.0264789872,
-0.0129142785,
-0.0629603192,
0.0286092106,
-0.003554954,
-0.0528005064,
0.00025783,
0.0489880592,
-0.0667149425,
0.0040858556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12069v1 | Satyrn: A Platform for Analytics Augmented Generation | 2024-06-17T20:14:16 | 2024-06-17T20:14:16 | Marko Sterbentz, Cameron Barrie, Shubham Shahi, Abhratanu Dutta, Donna Hooshmand, Harper Pack, Kristian J. Hammond | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of producing documents, and
retrieval augmented generation (RAG) has shown itself to be a powerful method
for improving accuracy without sacrificing fluency. However, not all
information can be retrieved from text. We propose an approach that uses the
analysis of structured data to generate fact sets that are used to guide
generation in much the same way that retrieved documents are used in RAG. This
analytics augmented generation (AAG) approach supports the ability to utilize
standard analytic techniques to generate facts that are then converted to text
and passed to an LLM. We present a neurosymbolic platform, Satyrn that
leverages AAG to produce accurate, fluent, and coherent reports grounded in
large scale databases. In our experiments, we find that Satyrn generates
reports in which over 86% accurate claims while maintaining high levels of
fluency and coherence, even when using smaller language models such as
Mistral-7B, as compared to GPT-4 Code Interpreter in which just 57% of claims
are accurate. | [
0.0140198581,
0.0695406497,
-0.0176158212,
-0.0056850025,
-0.0261432678,
0.0082304161,
-0.0020109075,
-0.0049469583,
0.0241926685,
-0.0310509242,
0.029183384,
-0.006583883,
0.0179655664,
0.1181506366,
0.0608052574,
-0.0221844502,
0.0720594972,
0.0227112249,
0.0033274435,
0.0294189323,
-0.0009319443,
0.0552562326,
-0.0317241661,
0.0066580204,
-0.0351249874,
-0.0313119665,
-0.0311226267,
-0.0004127659,
0.0079325996,
-0.035274297,
-0.0354209878,
0.0376591943,
0.0221668854,
0.0643055961,
0.0000021897,
-0.0478437059,
-0.0008479146,
0.0197792314,
-0.0153023181,
0.0186936483,
0.0638114363,
-0.0123347919,
-0.0129221482,
0.0388068967,
-0.0484757386,
-0.0262130871,
0.0428349562,
0.0031621407,
0.0621016622,
0.071113497,
-0.0167187005,
-0.0314971767,
0.0416013636,
-0.0141490139,
0.0196634103,
0.0405934677,
-0.004503109,
0.0211794972,
0.0515399426,
0.0143637257,
0.031750571,
0.0412901081,
0.0402567461,
-0.0263003744,
0.011251918,
0.0313673615,
-0.0063252398,
-0.012502999,
-0.0033880968,
0.016529154,
0.0412954576,
-0.0390158892,
0.0290430821,
-0.0112590194,
-0.0238263439,
-0.0255007297,
-0.0641403273,
0.0425180048,
-0.0389288962,
0.0024244762,
0.0140056536,
-0.0606420785,
0.0258251466,
0.0002695965,
-0.009055295,
0.0317039154,
-0.003365031,
-0.0093336655,
-0.025263695,
0.0173833687,
0.0419897139,
-0.0599892847,
0.0144349588,
0.0294937789,
-0.060538929,
0.0153145948,
-0.0301293489,
-0.060601525,
0.0504569523,
-0.0541494638,
0.0197982211,
0.0274385158,
-0.0218621213,
-0.0014439488,
0.0005751075,
0.0434848666,
-0.0195474289,
-0.0085771214,
-0.0067552845,
0.0063002319,
-0.0549451672,
-0.0158562046,
-0.0040312652,
0.0354104452,
-0.044327803,
-0.0159445386,
-0.0340354927,
0.0337009169,
-0.0186722595,
0.0213414766,
-0.0429142714,
0.0459728241,
-0.0334721059,
0.0456267074,
-0.0389241911,
0.0099370312,
-0.0271890331,
0.0183211155,
0.0535648242,
-0.081793502,
-0.0038438612,
0.0150418077,
-0.0186519399,
0.0180245433,
0.0177395325,
0.0180577282,
0.0044944179,
0.0255495049,
-0.1004516408,
-0.0933477059,
0.0330016501,
-0.0418683961,
-0.005953359,
-0.0946963355,
0.0547505729,
0.0369526558,
-0.0525685139,
-0.0478675105,
0.0001924596,
0.0234786924,
-0.0143616712,
0.0148636168,
-0.0807485357,
-0.0073103211,
0.0171417296,
0.0038587297,
0.0406004265,
0.0665531605,
0.0114260241,
0.0351786204,
0.0122156711,
0.0016620073,
0.0238141641,
0.0014158954,
0.0374710299,
-0.0185011625,
-0.0508008711,
-0.0005302691,
-0.0327862315,
0.0225740708,
0.0270937346,
0.0506946482,
-0.0245837718,
0.0306120738,
0.0562509298,
0.0121605536,
0.0247664023,
0.044265449,
0.0504791141,
-0.0417597964,
0.0153070968,
-0.005152212,
-0.0322707295,
0.0394826978,
-0.0011246807,
0.0357970335,
0.0151716312,
0.0262873657,
-0.0004493793,
-0.0438386388,
0.0072708377,
0.0214552954,
-0.0181339011,
0.0139652966,
0.0174086168,
0.0164010562,
-0.0124894045,
0.0682641342,
0.0283089653,
-0.0763225779,
0.0187860485,
-0.0298640747,
0.0407923572,
0.0760902688,
0.089519605,
-0.026607275,
0.0042395336,
-0.0097718388,
-0.0250999089,
0.0916730314,
0.0212362632,
-0.007201652,
-0.0086295642,
-0.0502425767,
0.0030655607,
-0.029889999,
0.0146213267,
0.0085889595,
0.01594574,
0.0108584156,
0.0085414983,
0.0163746886,
-0.054347042,
0.0318852551,
-0.01830725,
-0.0150950858,
0.0029513114,
-0.0295825172,
0.0292270817,
0.0448588356,
-0.0198515113,
0.053059224,
0.047755383,
0.0118963979,
-0.0171395596,
-0.0063691544,
0.0282662082,
-0.0265739206,
0.0172728393,
0.0202853996,
0.0080999434,
-0.0113586858,
-0.0359110497,
-0.0413050987,
0.0159821436,
-0.0831257924,
0.036932569,
-0.0398934297,
-0.0189355817,
0.0227803122,
0.0189690478,
0.0025419672,
0.0505852029,
0.0081871264,
-0.0037855974,
-0.0057636364,
-0.0420956984,
0.030031614,
-0.0563549139,
0.0228692126,
0.0473858938,
-0.0056601223,
0.0153734051,
0.0224344507,
-0.0480925664,
-0.0620931163,
0.0170424953,
-0.0972926542,
0.0189820211,
0.0147020519,
0.0387216993,
0.0373131,
0.0118003162,
-0.00330693,
0.0021722352,
-0.0306683723,
-0.0001056855,
0.0323338583,
0.0381671712,
0.0278732814,
0.0350671858,
0.0004876925,
-0.0157034546,
-0.0103356149,
-0.0467858873,
0.0287295245,
0.0423063748,
-0.0125186583,
-0.0910196453,
0.0307064727,
-0.0782981738,
0.0180002712,
0.0219897293,
-0.0081433486,
0.0525087528,
-0.0107291685,
0.0145201553,
0.0497283898,
-0.0008131354,
0.0113133779,
0.0314731002,
-0.0540807955,
-0.0468492322,
-0.0051414985,
-0.040607743,
0.0555399545,
0.0255705696,
-0.0492708199,
0.0211362951,
0.0216434859,
0.0530862361,
-0.0013718094,
-0.008434698,
0.0235438459,
-0.0019706937,
-0.0281272158,
-0.0143398996,
0.0037621572,
-0.0028599815,
0.0482228585,
-0.013780267,
-0.0511002094,
0.0804242715,
-0.0361247919,
0.0054225125,
-0.0540796295,
-0.0404302403,
-0.0394778065,
0.0835935026,
0.0147026991,
0.0167106427,
-0.0469646566,
-0.01886281,
0.0004031088,
-0.0328782797,
-0.0091570057,
-0.0308943782,
0.0308601987,
-0.0618638843,
-0.0005188413,
0.020224141,
-0.0001635285,
-0.039094422,
-0.0094079478,
-0.0068598026,
0.0083112856,
0.060584791,
-0.0393786877,
-0.0916230455,
-0.0380668528,
0.0716302469,
0.0636447817,
-0.011452347,
-0.0271222852,
-0.0084661087,
-0.0301573593,
0.0324185267,
-0.0217497405,
0.038467627,
-0.0069176699,
-0.0421448126,
0.0770766661,
-0.0184051581,
0.0145749124,
-0.0379154235,
-0.01003478,
-0.0347525775,
-0.015658902,
-0.0044664438,
0.0242516957,
-0.0050154654,
-0.081176497,
-0.0047148014,
0.0909842402,
0.032795988,
0.0060892133,
0.0032116615,
-0.040419165,
0.0138181886,
0.0151617629,
0.0556810312,
-0.0955852941,
0.0098048719,
-0.0079609128,
0.0491245389,
-0.0287753213,
-0.0428191461,
-0.0271415673,
-0.0928506479,
0.0526970923,
0.0093036033,
-0.0208431166,
-0.0137030696,
-0.056605231,
-0.0203311555,
-0.002811898,
-0.0268653836,
0.039908994,
-0.0043761996,
0.025008129,
0.003796872,
-0.0303799361,
-0.0204153266,
-0.0217830986,
-0.0242596306,
0.0357093401,
0.0608947538,
0.0363376513,
-0.0183533747,
-0.0394535996,
-0.0006469426,
0.0441897772,
0.0270325243,
-0.0399332233,
0.0499716625,
0.036706578,
-0.0062145274,
-0.0449299328,
0.0115961302,
-0.0122022247,
-0.0344342403,
-0.0199471526,
0.0819945857,
-0.0521067902,
0.0094029699,
-0.051093474,
0.0200545732,
0.045515459,
0.0499508753,
0.0270431694,
0.0151777333,
-0.0164402798,
-0.0265641455,
0.0115164723,
-0.0257015135,
-0.0044985753,
0.013123746,
-0.0131090973,
-0.0487483852,
-0.0909139439,
-0.0489304252,
0.0356294475,
0.0232980754,
0.0100427764,
-0.016183855,
0.0586822219,
-0.0579680242,
-0.0619906671,
0.0248138867,
-0.0017340906,
0.0381522849,
-0.0567107461,
-0.0507808365,
0.0001727338,
0.0003037403,
-0.0156872962,
0.0405531637,
-0.036294736,
-0.0674554482,
0.0101869209,
0.016609095,
0.0344010107,
-0.0167081729,
-0.0065778657,
-0.0107763577,
-0.0030724425,
0.1010328531,
-0.0891346857,
0.0102341371,
-0.0382040031,
-0.0157761145,
-0.0108484561,
-0.0263111424,
-0.0279942006,
-0.0077095777,
-0.0398066677,
0.0448246375,
-0.0016102709,
-0.0294232164,
0.0177175421,
0.0475136451,
0.0349725783,
-0.0154888686,
-0.0013871369,
-0.0382517949,
-0.0340137891,
-0.0665362477,
0.0132782795,
-0.0463887192,
0.0104032625,
-0.00262956,
-0.0166584849,
0.0056475634,
0.0506374091,
-0.0412881263,
-0.0040944521,
0.0099431435,
-0.0141504826,
-0.03784113,
-0.0085057542,
0.0121044051,
-0.0170482714,
-0.0387672707,
0.0103026805,
-0.0150785549,
0.0787746906,
-0.0254516881,
0.0665554181,
0.0225376636,
0.0068029403,
-0.0093114367,
0.0083848787,
-0.0495672971,
-0.0219491702,
-0.0146318274,
-0.0027777669,
0.0045442684,
0.0407306999,
0.059745498,
-0.0523072444,
-0.002443895,
-0.0263474807,
0.0408471413,
-0.0008593554,
-0.0060044271,
0.0032338414,
0.0191443227,
-0.029608503,
-0.0562771559,
0.06287691,
-0.0150039289,
0.0292142686,
-0.0325131565,
-0.0527726598,
-0.0342710949,
-0.0473485291,
-0.0004526617,
-0.0149467764,
-0.0269910507,
-0.0176429488,
-0.0630814061,
-0.0518419258,
0.0359756611,
0.0779998377,
-0.0012806356,
-0.0595960468,
0.0444630757,
0.0483752117,
0.0159037635,
-0.0368749835,
-0.0199242104,
0.0772222355,
-0.0648776442,
-0.0407829806,
-0.0358356759,
-6.57486243e-33,
-0.047661379,
-0.0498820618,
0.0581573658,
-0.0008414923,
-0.0239933953,
-0.0042556864,
-0.0694194585,
0.0050960877,
0.0065501542,
0.02834519,
-0.003988625,
0.0364657529,
0.0152808027,
0.0029328929,
0.0208040923,
0.0256682187,
0.0368321352,
0.0136042479,
-0.0353719629,
0.0394560695,
0.0844234154,
0.0003141325,
0.0420070253,
-0.0938259214,
0.007468543,
0.005966513,
0.0109782051,
0.0143838525,
-0.0359564014,
0.0234797392,
0.0071055284,
0.0305315908,
0.0064577493,
-0.0344992466,
-0.0229872931,
0.0118359942,
-0.0308340192,
-0.0372330286,
0.0516058803,
-0.0263041817,
-0.0432458371,
-0.004180423,
0.0507289916,
-0.0256806742,
0.0138982693,
0.0216394812,
0.0190249346,
-0.0310178678,
-0.0104468735,
-0.0428623818,
-0.0547750629,
0.0187513791,
0.0279256292,
0.0173437856,
-0.0531261452,
0.0142729627,
-0.0334054194,
-0.0044183028,
-0.0639230087,
0.024643559,
0.0108471494,
0.0299833026,
0.0487901829,
-0.004393864,
0.009825509,
0.0361449607,
0.0422766358,
-0.0034796197,
-0.0742932633,
0.0815641657,
0.0195322726,
0.0700256974,
0.0598935075,
0.016189009,
-0.0045754844,
-0.0306050219,
-0.0477643274,
0.0472444892,
0.0262796059,
0.0365070924,
-0.0023739971,
-0.0064395643,
-0.0439214557,
-0.0466223396,
0.0090352846,
0.0222538766,
-0.0351528265,
-0.0419811271,
0.0055159749,
-0.0018354057,
-0.0007494071,
0.0367963612,
0.0077963746,
-0.0101632122,
-0.01170702,
0.0234054085,
-0.0369376577,
-0.0023716181,
-0.0085723456,
-0.0192500036,
-0.0511782207,
0.0081384359,
0.0090954416,
0.0357404687,
0.0468199588,
0.01806763,
0.029227728,
0.0391195714,
-0.0297207963,
0.0223025586,
-0.0325488709,
0.0565288998,
0.0066129896,
-0.0245675743,
0.0068238345,
0.0164957251,
0.0021565557,
0.0223552454,
-0.0096103717,
0.0165776275,
-0.0376066603,
0.0110232355,
0.038084209,
0.0406983867,
-0.0334601514,
-0.0041757715,
-0.0497839749,
0.0240429994,
0.0438079424,
-0.035495095,
-0.0160242785,
0.0186636094,
2.879e-7,
0.0325505994,
0.0426406153,
0.0310626328,
0.0303264093,
0.0508105904,
0.0261966065,
0.0103247464,
-0.0110664451,
0.0115783373,
-0.05579146,
-0.038442567,
0.0191071779,
0.0619813204,
0.072337918,
-0.0367804877,
-0.012020926,
-0.0742982253,
-0.0399156548,
-0.0791078508,
-0.0061288779,
0.0412713178,
0.0302441865,
0.0388775431,
-0.0194515176,
0.0404736549,
-0.0359114408,
0.0329030342,
0.0459788628,
-0.026148513,
0.0196462404,
0.0135520557,
0.0528586991,
-0.0061398936,
-0.0017306993,
-0.0261027906,
-0.0097439801,
-0.0526275635,
0.0348263979,
-0.0104532698,
0.0085926168,
0.0195061639,
-0.0658593476,
-0.0230899528,
-0.0408164822,
0.0372471139,
-0.0150527945,
-0.0212043431,
-0.0081652096,
0.0077905892,
0.0019400259,
-0.002413684,
-0.0185745116,
-0.0199550837,
-0.0131005011,
-0.0077687395,
-0.0234004203,
-0.0215830952,
-0.0220057778,
-0.031259831,
0.0354804993,
-0.0512124337,
-0.0491769537,
-0.0315596499,
0.0409176089,
-0.019414125,
-0.0568905137,
0.0122037651,
2.889452817e-34,
0.0233110785,
0.0387622304,
-0.0100925947,
-0.0465628468,
0.0726778805,
-0.0043139313,
0.0026487582,
0.0000163325,
-0.0008993193,
-0.0486247316,
-0.0368201397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12066v2 | Language Models are Surprisingly Fragile to Drug Names in Biomedical Benchmarks | 2024-06-17T20:09:24 | 2024-06-19T03:59:41 | Jack Gallifant, Shan Chen, Pedro Moreira, Nikolaj Munch, Mingye Gao, Jackson Pond, Leo Anthony Celi, Hugo Aerts, Thomas Hartvigsen, Danielle Bitterman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Medical knowledge is context-dependent and requires consistent reasoning
across various natural language expressions of semantically equivalent phrases.
This is particularly crucial for drug names, where patients often use brand
names like Advil or Tylenol instead of their generic equivalents. To study
this, we create a new robustness dataset, RABBITS, to evaluate performance
differences on medical benchmarks after swapping brand and generic drug names
using physician expert annotations.
We assess both open-source and API-based LLMs on MedQA and MedMCQA, revealing
a consistent performance drop ranging from 1-10\%. Furthermore, we identify a
potential source of this fragility as the contamination of test data in widely
used pre-training datasets. All code is accessible at
https://github.com/BittermanLab/RABBITS, and a HuggingFace leaderboard is
available at https://huggingface.co/spaces/AIM-Harvard/rabbits-leaderboard. | [
0.0566743314,
0.0772981644,
-0.0115944082,
0.0273325909,
-0.0035732966,
0.0093095163,
0.0114150569,
0.0281691495,
0.0196011644,
-0.0500705354,
-0.0078345863,
-0.0119684376,
-0.0232510325,
0.0241540093,
0.0302957427,
0.0028749453,
0.0413116217,
0.0227515697,
0.0282119457,
-0.0104009667,
0.0052214013,
-0.0019004468,
-0.0303172916,
0.0378810242,
0.0049349694,
0.0033910796,
0.0694293156,
-0.016568454,
0.0237612259,
-0.0862856954,
0.0050319885,
0.0651338771,
-0.0391097069,
0.0300832577,
0.0000015581,
-0.0751982406,
-0.009567989,
0.0397518165,
-0.0230916236,
-0.0151949236,
0.0506650135,
-0.0350936055,
-0.0058781286,
-0.0039991573,
-0.0437351614,
-0.0096423579,
0.0362411328,
0.0243323147,
0.0229732711,
0.062474981,
-0.001029046,
0.0048316307,
0.0141894342,
-0.0066486206,
0.0302846227,
-0.0744967312,
0.0443053059,
0.012379935,
0.0227237325,
-0.0173918642,
0.0017399425,
0.0251350924,
-0.0343019329,
0.0336591974,
0.0016748954,
0.0368230268,
-0.0535399579,
-0.0259980317,
-0.0020982353,
0.1024014354,
-0.0311951227,
-0.0049370197,
0.0162867885,
0.0039654695,
-0.0185128041,
0.0210389066,
-0.0100129629,
0.0025563301,
-0.0274003204,
0.0224431306,
-0.0136310719,
-0.0056135519,
0.0558928587,
0.0218541231,
-0.0051275054,
0.0549336262,
0.0177004598,
-0.0082742376,
0.0322730802,
-0.0155001357,
-0.0224810615,
-0.0317134596,
0.0393820293,
0.0060337316,
-0.0441726632,
0.0410991386,
-0.0298313536,
-0.0284648985,
0.0886980295,
-0.0736715794,
0.0040035145,
0.0123818731,
-0.0160964709,
0.0414156653,
-0.0372842327,
0.0249986127,
0.0028584013,
0.0390417054,
-0.0298314095,
0.0063721966,
-0.0431991108,
0.005238161,
0.0064558769,
0.0401652791,
-0.0194901153,
-0.0011964455,
-0.086140506,
-0.0038119585,
-0.047762908,
0.0244897157,
0.0007497747,
0.0227133743,
-0.0115714278,
0.0061302418,
-0.0296656899,
-0.0004677718,
0.0122828335,
0.0303945206,
-0.0241194405,
-0.0825793967,
0.0197750181,
-0.0198779162,
-0.0169645268,
-0.0215229373,
0.0331821069,
0.1048482135,
0.0286533609,
-0.0389637798,
-0.0240193941,
-0.0357429497,
-0.0240294393,
-0.0279230494,
0.0048124269,
-0.0572499633,
0.0485124066,
-0.002829846,
0.0012328135,
-0.0967095569,
0.026549926,
0.0148839578,
-0.0765876696,
0.135219276,
-0.0569825284,
-0.0306375604,
0.0032171281,
0.0333040506,
-0.0257073864,
0.0381927453,
0.0244111009,
-0.0380742997,
0.0537016168,
0.0002026427,
0.0148058916,
0.0085619846,
0.0071210391,
-0.0311276279,
0.0092321662,
0.0252911206,
0.0405984782,
0.07785476,
-0.0481961742,
0.0705315024,
-0.0040563862,
-0.0517290123,
0.0410295203,
0.0666877329,
0.003272109,
-0.0238212012,
0.0064738705,
-0.0431127176,
0.0093034217,
-0.0241234116,
-0.0654496253,
-0.0414846204,
-0.0458915606,
0.0095430138,
-0.0061469646,
0.0026588074,
-0.004582834,
-0.013285649,
-0.0645347461,
-0.0361410305,
-0.0340390429,
-0.0196741223,
0.036183916,
-0.0049442258,
-0.0483417735,
0.0741628408,
0.0414752327,
-0.0470202006,
-0.0223392416,
-0.0294998549,
-0.0086904904,
0.0627978742,
0.0472605899,
-0.0374623239,
-0.0405642688,
0.0044866852,
-0.0284387711,
-0.0049483469,
0.0225398596,
-0.0298154317,
0.0276255775,
-0.028995201,
0.0041409251,
0.0368093587,
0.028478384,
-0.003766245,
0.022626061,
0.0319773704,
0.0010301621,
-0.0596554093,
-0.0084260348,
0.0629989654,
-0.0624008998,
-0.0247760825,
0.0079434216,
-0.0284528863,
0.0260389671,
0.0242789462,
-0.0164631028,
0.0275426246,
0.0659820065,
-0.0408314206,
0.0093729328,
-0.015040528,
0.0154493963,
-0.0217526779,
0.0568783469,
-0.0491359383,
-0.0168171488,
-0.0074337847,
-0.0606186539,
-0.0195065085,
-0.0076178745,
-0.0010546605,
0.0464012772,
0.0034581246,
0.0264546964,
0.0107006729,
0.0170338489,
-0.0590773448,
0.0270607173,
-0.0241084136,
0.0388385057,
-0.0174710657,
0.0150614604,
-0.0245517399,
-0.0180315711,
-0.0058766808,
0.0409924164,
-0.0009132412,
0.0113029834,
-0.0430112854,
-0.0178442989,
-0.0403406769,
-0.0212399364,
-0.0633735657,
0.0016687323,
0.0228290986,
0.0183190275,
0.007739882,
0.0141113913,
-0.0123491585,
-0.0229263734,
-0.0027765592,
-0.0415189676,
-0.0237306617,
0.0318247937,
0.0181336161,
0.0236194581,
-0.0149769429,
-0.0412109084,
-0.0097658113,
-0.0420819856,
0.0465373695,
-0.0246529151,
-0.0434959978,
-0.0159525368,
-0.0352228917,
-0.058024779,
0.0031890271,
-0.0188973043,
0.0152612813,
0.0105939591,
0.0362795889,
0.0003619303,
0.0302794427,
-0.0126213748,
0.0129110366,
0.0664366186,
0.0266733188,
-0.0222943574,
-0.0107444199,
-0.0025753593,
-0.0449674465,
0.0087474361,
-0.0556872599,
-0.0163510088,
0.0770792663,
-0.0060796905,
-0.0237589125,
-0.0203589723,
0.0254193656,
-0.0223791413,
-0.0006577764,
-0.0390890837,
0.0329924971,
-0.040938165,
0.0371550359,
0.0076171076,
-0.05133003,
0.0980707854,
-0.0314090587,
0.028570829,
-0.0385208502,
-0.004387808,
-0.022507038,
0.0017676144,
-0.006610475,
-0.0041486644,
0.0138493413,
-0.0124543672,
0.0128842117,
0.0034783878,
0.019491395,
-0.0769089237,
0.0953946039,
-0.0573292188,
0.0527138039,
-0.0100705745,
-0.0389696993,
-0.0428493768,
-0.0307424944,
-0.057386335,
0.0046706256,
0.0137559092,
0.0077316803,
-0.0333861262,
0.0198820252,
-0.0347590744,
0.0411164053,
0.0347283408,
-0.0032229193,
0.0105623361,
-0.0270313285,
0.0248212069,
-0.0257856771,
0.0400428437,
0.0083399871,
0.0298920646,
0.060484156,
0.0242266711,
-0.0006467901,
-0.0014830052,
0.0251219068,
-0.0042922921,
-0.0377832651,
0.0097888764,
0.033283215,
0.0179585405,
-0.0316073969,
0.0222395603,
0.1057670414,
0.0299388152,
0.0002067005,
0.0434268564,
0.0094203325,
-0.0079886736,
0.0207657851,
0.0095221605,
-0.0969438031,
-0.0404841565,
-0.0103728287,
0.0424440578,
-0.0093965624,
-0.0597234182,
-0.0080919256,
-0.0688103959,
-0.0133300358,
-0.0037879455,
-0.0794018954,
0.0204189047,
-0.0556541905,
0.000464943,
-0.0519820601,
0.0478662811,
0.0093022492,
-0.0083833411,
0.0044324826,
0.0064431829,
-0.0369134359,
-0.0927456468,
0.0146122351,
-0.0299230032,
0.0744669437,
0.0361238234,
0.0066138469,
0.0023764842,
-0.0299568083,
0.0277717318,
0.0087955389,
-0.019193694,
-0.0309025291,
0.082633689,
-0.001831011,
-0.006379378,
-0.0053293779,
0.0227867663,
-0.0690533593,
-0.0194672793,
-0.0341397487,
0.0411403701,
-0.0035048728,
-0.0250126272,
-0.0357030481,
0.027204778,
-0.0152095575,
0.0917179808,
0.0035833793,
0.018500464,
-0.0328153819,
-0.019768361,
0.0074976617,
0.0064942138,
-0.0435580164,
0.0349321254,
-0.0507746413,
-0.0162795074,
-0.0653919578,
-0.0076054945,
0.0588327274,
0.0028915021,
0.0048813471,
0.0456730351,
0.00016044,
0.0103072254,
-0.0513872281,
0.0416576862,
0.021595316,
0.0157497637,
-0.037618801,
-0.0012302386,
0.0672952384,
0.0288416389,
-0.0232062843,
0.0454630069,
-0.0263348352,
-0.0841122195,
0.0138796549,
0.0467264578,
0.0318703763,
0.0151611026,
0.0002631786,
-0.0258244388,
-0.0056324829,
0.0781624392,
0.0034003661,
-0.0181120764,
0.0198383816,
0.0177754611,
0.0153021784,
0.0302191749,
-0.0393984839,
0.0060337442,
0.014115083,
0.0629327446,
0.0041232747,
-0.0123243676,
0.0382587276,
0.0371337757,
0.0445475169,
-0.0383120105,
0.0005883061,
-0.0029942922,
0.0327561498,
-0.0285901427,
-0.0044710576,
-0.0089549478,
-0.0014450628,
0.0093692439,
0.0006201903,
-0.0409029908,
-0.0082941297,
-0.0595197417,
0.0511735305,
-0.0193363968,
0.0085725989,
0.0096925395,
0.009138763,
0.0573753901,
-0.0166994147,
0.0020744677,
0.0220527183,
-0.0099805268,
0.0550087318,
-0.0268360339,
0.0252375994,
0.00363162,
0.03269618,
-0.0306131691,
0.0408365577,
-0.0481742918,
-0.0396162681,
-0.0137138804,
0.0552891083,
0.0322118066,
-0.0316504054,
0.0258127097,
-0.0101756006,
-0.0042617656,
-0.0428807884,
-0.0020181902,
-0.0188826416,
0.0327923931,
0.0684987009,
0.0101745594,
-0.0230025742,
0.0054857261,
0.1071665958,
0.0149903065,
0.0665633753,
-0.0046931389,
-0.0171564911,
-0.0370624289,
-0.0120016607,
0.0099494699,
0.0212169327,
-0.0552084558,
-0.0174394418,
-0.0708314255,
-0.0838964283,
0.0268546641,
-0.0064829332,
0.005491232,
0.019346552,
0.0158020575,
0.04914511,
0.0415281877,
-0.0059910412,
-0.0228897408,
0.025927119,
0.0026524649,
-0.0410896167,
-0.0182896964,
-5.550574857e-33,
0.0068972432,
-0.0310324784,
-0.0183563232,
-0.0387362204,
0.0313557014,
0.0373770781,
-0.0120090963,
0.0160996784,
-0.0201739315,
0.0221122093,
-0.013854906,
0.0033237899,
0.014774669,
0.0107680103,
-0.0056659617,
-0.0469959527,
-0.0197798684,
0.0198755618,
-0.0087293442,
-0.0205442235,
-0.0061236066,
0.0660505593,
0.0687364414,
-0.0897784531,
0.0400707945,
0.0108958008,
0.0390230492,
0.0087330183,
-0.0366888493,
0.0809712186,
-0.029891137,
0.0442531779,
0.0236686449,
0.00578734,
-0.0180187244,
-0.0422898754,
-0.0794510171,
-0.0040380303,
0.028486345,
-0.0309936702,
-0.0106011964,
-0.0209150948,
0.082022965,
-0.0252901241,
-0.0770914927,
0.0146059655,
0.0306933038,
-0.0538816191,
-0.0429637134,
-0.0429782867,
-0.0169913918,
0.0351024903,
0.0084841382,
0.0344842263,
-0.005252366,
-0.0192397833,
-0.0059851543,
0.0611308403,
-0.0309224334,
-0.013400442,
-0.014143154,
0.01619233,
0.0647133961,
-0.0036676689,
-0.0089913849,
0.073174417,
0.019152442,
0.0098539377,
0.0273451433,
-0.025483828,
-0.0130688073,
0.0480680503,
0.0630637854,
0.0397790596,
0.0557522886,
-0.0061491132,
-0.0671437606,
0.0245182496,
-0.0332704112,
-0.0101067191,
-0.0100958552,
0.0092024449,
-0.0527078398,
-0.0013098941,
-0.0308049843,
0.0228569321,
-0.0320795998,
-0.0209874287,
0.0159022491,
-0.0180777088,
-0.0209956113,
0.0261806902,
-0.029324986,
-0.0517685525,
-0.0522507578,
-0.0608789399,
0.0324034505,
-0.0061191469,
-0.0165573619,
0.0192523655,
-0.037087515,
-0.0029770094,
0.0027966341,
0.0049944143,
0.055460725,
-0.0226655882,
0.025863573,
-0.0593492538,
-0.060870558,
-0.0039927997,
-0.0119822547,
0.0007365118,
0.0161636565,
0.0122381132,
0.035881348,
0.0093674948,
0.0140850712,
0.0469898432,
0.0440102778,
-0.0245675966,
-0.0389758795,
-0.0181675479,
0.0034230154,
0.0014999821,
-0.0518994108,
-0.0110195456,
-0.016455885,
0.0533268005,
0.0369125828,
-0.0505736209,
-0.0065387068,
-0.0252835844,
2.455e-7,
0.1085808575,
0.0659992024,
-0.0116767911,
-0.02625308,
0.0059052561,
0.0009589703,
-0.0402608961,
0.0324134752,
-0.022809526,
-0.0499897562,
0.0058614635,
-0.0321672112,
0.0411457755,
0.0320904069,
-0.0532640778,
-0.0257954057,
-0.0809659436,
-0.0304739494,
-0.0495540276,
-0.0116576375,
0.0229464788,
0.0746177211,
0.0149476668,
-0.0229943786,
0.0026070452,
-0.0402408838,
0.0264765136,
-0.06703455,
0.0204390381,
0.0458083525,
0.0404360741,
0.0049466151,
0.0232358575,
0.0485970043,
-0.021513354,
-0.0128780277,
0.0153538622,
0.0770623162,
-0.0514836088,
-0.0142008169,
-0.0021796529,
-0.0568803996,
0.011630699,
-0.0208508689,
0.0589130856,
0.0032617699,
-0.0532347523,
-0.0252567753,
-0.0192766879,
-0.020362094,
0.0720347315,
-0.0057425969,
0.0001768523,
0.0476038046,
0.0227745585,
0.0235677809,
-0.0430438071,
-0.0716638342,
-0.0194726456,
0.0354402922,
-0.0288003702,
-0.0471894071,
0.0144974561,
-0.0032240585,
-0.0163445622,
-0.089037627,
-0.0018181968,
2.216757808e-34,
0.0311502609,
-0.0113693196,
0.0328051038,
0.0406500399,
0.0364495143,
0.0057719406,
0.028951712,
0.017370306,
-0.0157644954,
-0.0438137949,
0.0199243631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12060v1 | Not Eliminate but Aggregate: Post-Hoc Control over Mixture-of-Experts to Address Shortcut Shifts in Natural Language Understanding | 2024-06-17T20:00:04 | 2024-06-17T20:00:04 | Ukyo Honda, Tatsushi Oka, Peinan Zhang, Masato Mita | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent models for natural language understanding are inclined to exploit
simple patterns in datasets, commonly known as shortcuts. These shortcuts hinge
on spurious correlations between labels and latent features existing in the
training data. At inference time, shortcut-dependent models are likely to
generate erroneous predictions under distribution shifts, particularly when
some latent features are no longer correlated with the labels. To avoid this,
previous studies have trained models to eliminate the reliance on shortcuts. In
this study, we explore a different direction: pessimistically aggregating the
predictions of a mixture-of-experts, assuming each expert captures relatively
different latent features. The experimental results demonstrate that our
post-hoc control over the experts significantly enhances the model's robustness
to the distribution shift in shortcuts. Besides, we show that our approach has
some practical advantages. We also analyze our model and provide results to
support the assumption. | [
0.0835475922,
0.0718309507,
-0.0079384856,
-0.011535665,
-0.0167765114,
-0.005798778,
0.0239396878,
-0.038767837,
-0.0469713882,
-0.045955319,
-0.0272331648,
-0.0221571848,
0.0331226699,
0.0179063585,
0.0159462504,
-0.0590271987,
0.0363516957,
-0.0189689342,
0.0126621351,
0.0005205302,
0.0117424075,
-0.0029519622,
-0.0191500653,
0.041904334,
-0.0179983098,
0.0117680496,
-0.0285486747,
-0.0097217429,
0.0261123329,
0.0422832854,
0.0097576501,
0.0978267565,
0.0214318093,
-0.0087603964,
0.0000017968,
-0.0310555845,
-0.0210576747,
0.0011895781,
-0.0300573781,
-0.0336367413,
-0.0129765905,
-0.0341490619,
0.0208422504,
-0.0229998231,
-0.0121889329,
-0.028795084,
0.0476595759,
0.0428730287,
0.0220630243,
0.05592658,
-0.0093765799,
-0.0117519777,
-0.0190250054,
-0.0124905817,
0.0280819163,
-0.0887013003,
0.0354824662,
-0.0305688754,
-0.0405459665,
-0.0185013097,
-0.0453461632,
0.0173336994,
0.003965945,
0.0240455493,
0.0578373559,
0.0433369502,
0.0288382322,
-0.0371307731,
-0.0386787914,
0.0548327155,
-0.0389397219,
-0.0399997607,
-0.0047175409,
-0.0119190542,
0.0099409651,
0.0711835474,
-0.0235157274,
-0.0445810668,
-0.0233934131,
-0.0048948862,
-0.0019055676,
0.0055488255,
0.034031529,
0.0334804356,
-0.0589135475,
0.0421627089,
-0.0137348678,
-0.0335925855,
-0.0006628737,
-0.0121679204,
-0.0293596908,
-0.0393710174,
0.0155157968,
0.0027729943,
-0.0249347091,
0.026508268,
-0.0120574487,
-0.0459154621,
-0.0143487826,
-0.0254604481,
-0.0553661659,
0.0431278348,
-0.0309671424,
0.0878055841,
0.0012321452,
0.0310745202,
0.0051684729,
-0.0017967293,
0.0008837882,
-0.0141117312,
-0.1045218557,
-0.0086962664,
-0.032840319,
0.0445704944,
0.0183503833,
0.0081070503,
-0.0209767278,
-0.0107860481,
-0.0498266481,
-0.0202398207,
-0.0018794431,
0.0564511046,
-0.0519449599,
-0.0032480711,
-0.0093742991,
0.0764402673,
-0.0283218492,
0.0676190779,
-0.0071011088,
-0.0310964901,
-0.0131941801,
0.0242715385,
-0.009148377,
-0.0030733459,
-0.00764259,
0.0661137551,
-0.0202793293,
-0.0311095398,
-0.0382020734,
-0.0425324775,
-0.038528949,
-0.0579817556,
0.022372067,
-0.0715393648,
0.0626760423,
0.0067100888,
0.0379034914,
-0.0530816391,
-0.0397184752,
-0.0255731344,
-0.0929633453,
0.1049993858,
-0.0211171154,
0.0164196193,
0.0227051713,
-0.003979485,
-0.063906841,
0.0927579626,
0.0104414802,
0.0109775541,
0.0127361398,
-0.0094893165,
0.0102156894,
0.0258928072,
0.0141291339,
0.0017203637,
0.0113596898,
-0.0090808189,
-0.0367567688,
-0.0011252199,
0.0198532306,
0.022772491,
-0.0351470038,
-0.0020692362,
0.0375689827,
0.0386006944,
0.0141592911,
0.0559585914,
0.0353500731,
-0.0185435191,
0.0141168674,
0.0481078029,
-0.0963111892,
0.0188831203,
-0.0840933025,
-0.0315626189,
0.0313762762,
0.0111049898,
-0.0218236838,
-0.0117223049,
-0.0010573287,
0.0022529047,
-0.0275899153,
0.0045270845,
0.0787996873,
-0.0007380745,
0.0304219443,
0.0567176379,
0.0161652379,
-0.0075129154,
0.023116488,
-0.0242893435,
-0.0181217697,
0.0557692572,
0.0006203116,
-0.0085788993,
0.0031766463,
-0.0112263272,
0.0053196456,
-0.0468467288,
0.0352182835,
0.0109060118,
0.0229958389,
-0.0334526151,
-0.0644253418,
0.0466543958,
0.0140445223,
0.0235618912,
-0.0130384909,
-0.0250213463,
0.0054995692,
-0.0483271331,
0.0127712414,
0.0125343502,
0.0102286302,
0.0274595395,
-0.0247465819,
0.0295327529,
0.0608226657,
-0.0224770233,
-0.0141514968,
-0.0050248792,
0.016666228,
0.0249615964,
-0.0358476564,
0.008078468,
-0.0175487641,
-0.0386133492,
0.0009311459,
-0.0475839861,
-0.0212000236,
-0.0199540481,
-0.0649893805,
-0.0747477636,
0.0295470078,
-0.0106414072,
0.0063480204,
-0.0093629593,
-0.0059461831,
0.0082704276,
0.0085307276,
-0.0157611761,
0.0561007746,
-0.0066555054,
0.005752854,
0.0173523389,
-0.0177139603,
0.0153401317,
0.0064526508,
0.0099563068,
0.0057522161,
0.0171176791,
-0.0053817085,
0.0334453769,
-0.0381704383,
-0.0655139312,
-0.0678840056,
-0.0590718612,
-0.0001163812,
-0.0356165506,
0.0049401149,
0.0412241966,
-0.0055476152,
-0.0072889831,
0.0010011252,
-0.0123594636,
-0.0140730338,
-0.0163450167,
0.0284769796,
-0.0336565748,
0.0319498181,
0.0106778173,
-0.0311250445,
0.0084578609,
-0.0477119982,
0.0562073551,
0.0131212985,
-0.0673317537,
-0.0174421929,
-0.0065154168,
-0.0462504849,
0.0186619963,
-0.025265675,
-0.0143139241,
-0.0285904668,
-0.0197280925,
0.0369026549,
0.0298357401,
-0.0141297188,
0.0249212012,
0.0541286133,
-0.0420624055,
-0.0317579359,
0.0073069129,
-0.0125798462,
-0.0125109274,
-0.0435598865,
-0.0230374951,
-0.0198223386,
0.0536481217,
0.0328731202,
-0.0317483917,
-0.0955836251,
0.0149669908,
-0.0167174079,
-0.0489216633,
-0.011101936,
0.0034516675,
0.0212340541,
0.0438307934,
-0.0628985092,
-0.0310336854,
0.116127111,
0.0247822944,
0.0026233841,
-0.0228796564,
-0.018801488,
-0.0413200855,
0.0065646018,
-0.0012097927,
-0.0151032452,
0.0001066878,
0.0010185585,
-0.0808483139,
0.0003376122,
0.028167665,
-0.0019315197,
0.0450631417,
-0.0714926943,
0.0450957306,
0.0015330552,
0.0035704002,
0.0029021085,
-0.0829279944,
-0.0196503717,
0.0325084478,
0.0711603835,
-0.0172245819,
-0.0697759911,
0.0166400038,
0.0167230107,
0.0194501113,
-0.0304753445,
-0.0184654519,
0.0021262786,
-0.011069403,
0.0157827884,
-0.0008549932,
-0.0152804535,
-0.046041742,
0.0228031501,
0.0374515653,
0.0363328531,
-0.0361303389,
-0.0418303944,
0.0259508044,
0.0146243777,
-0.0092884861,
-0.0334668681,
0.0143223796,
0.0293082166,
-0.0386665612,
0.016923843,
0.0917365253,
0.0171973705,
-0.0718256161,
-0.001986634,
0.0296463594,
0.0534755886,
0.0103285043,
0.0053139981,
-0.0551895127,
-0.0313427933,
0.0070621339,
0.0174355078,
0.0064965836,
-0.0347991213,
-0.0103774359,
-0.0528420731,
0.0090467473,
0.0091357473,
-0.0926253051,
0.0210144538,
-0.0316320211,
0.0618495345,
-0.0369514078,
-0.0186477378,
-0.0258267652,
-0.002402032,
0.0059737172,
0.0540769026,
-0.0114699723,
-0.0640748441,
0.0123892697,
-0.0029067185,
0.0514969788,
0.0403981842,
0.0094482647,
-0.0108916601,
0.0037466122,
-0.0154618071,
-0.0206509195,
0.0257387068,
-0.0136518609,
0.0777499229,
-0.0159917381,
-0.0006683436,
0.0120829698,
0.0229919031,
-0.015668558,
-0.0030688446,
0.0046366137,
0.0437613539,
-0.02956542,
-0.0509436019,
-0.0215141606,
0.0047181346,
-0.006420407,
0.0446398482,
0.0227493159,
-0.0332347155,
-0.0244384911,
-0.0129866088,
-0.0247914698,
0.04547837,
-0.0322426222,
0.0215079281,
-0.0221119802,
-0.0559583455,
-0.0232449826,
-0.0504705571,
0.0627224818,
0.0398414135,
0.0208268557,
0.0351276994,
-0.0005196532,
-0.0024921063,
-0.0008609587,
0.0589749292,
0.0102669559,
0.0017888986,
-0.0195216499,
-0.0050155679,
0.0608060062,
0.0053635063,
-0.0009629451,
-0.0230420846,
-0.0652165413,
-0.0918509364,
0.0199964996,
0.0597464889,
0.0331170745,
0.0473033413,
0.00599183,
-0.0864608213,
0.0471409969,
0.0259320699,
-0.0250820145,
0.0279266741,
0.019728383,
-0.0147667844,
-0.0224426053,
0.0326435231,
-0.0402795747,
0.0095429057,
0.0283991247,
-0.0008341893,
-0.057677988,
-0.0345813036,
0.033575777,
-0.0577837676,
0.0846186206,
-0.0257798787,
0.0047125197,
-0.0136287631,
0.0039017785,
0.0450499952,
-0.0228416901,
0.0070468863,
-0.008240018,
-0.0149580883,
-0.0159697589,
-0.0043516941,
0.0282750092,
0.0078306282,
-0.0037523371,
0.0064968131,
0.0052693998,
0.0479373671,
-0.0033032559,
0.0125658428,
0.0114542088,
-0.0066784187,
-0.0085023185,
0.034263663,
0.01019077,
0.0236653537,
0.0267405752,
0.047011923,
0.0101228282,
-0.036931958,
-0.0038871614,
-0.1021069959,
-0.0835436061,
-0.0057320292,
0.0656536967,
0.0357444212,
-0.0246603377,
0.0474368483,
0.0007477426,
0.0170092843,
-0.0344779864,
-0.0083550652,
-0.0053262236,
0.0396320671,
0.0483827218,
0.0381638743,
0.0195145067,
0.0096647311,
0.0637666881,
0.030074548,
0.0336960927,
-0.0245148428,
-0.0077606384,
-0.0293255895,
0.0106251258,
0.0153926518,
0.0102094626,
-0.013134405,
0.0187577829,
-0.0525380448,
-0.0633959025,
0.0116216214,
-0.0181871913,
0.0273711309,
0.0138168577,
0.0293260645,
0.0730977952,
-0.0391553864,
-0.018182857,
-0.0135177113,
-0.0175876692,
0.0567632094,
0.009963559,
-0.0484263152,
-7.216286351e-33,
-0.0227387566,
-0.0479168668,
-0.0053435378,
-0.033508759,
0.0249388274,
-0.0050008227,
-0.0099936342,
-0.015267835,
-0.0011590376,
0.0352107696,
-0.028589502,
0.0329926424,
0.0354163684,
-0.0218305271,
0.0370836034,
-0.0170314945,
0.071549654,
0.0035766487,
-0.0139911966,
-0.0015080121,
0.0265234653,
0.0373600088,
0.0872162953,
-0.0881652981,
0.0403217375,
0.0493211709,
-0.031361714,
0.0083138207,
-0.0300462823,
0.0429807901,
0.0499205701,
0.0491782799,
0.045787394,
-0.013545868,
-0.0325938351,
0.0002737759,
-0.0642210841,
-0.0369680524,
0.037436191,
0.0061920974,
-0.0149927996,
-0.013501578,
0.0605327524,
0.0041658627,
0.070091106,
-0.0249717385,
0.0816087574,
-0.0350345038,
-0.0234161783,
-0.0297097005,
-0.0064403899,
0.0294714794,
-0.0327281468,
0.0096437279,
-0.0038882575,
0.023034947,
-0.0100137657,
-0.0148204062,
-0.0676006675,
0.0029369688,
0.064080812,
0.027474083,
0.0460216142,
0.0549493209,
0.0000599754,
0.03461897,
0.0369843468,
0.0278807618,
-0.0139658619,
-0.0877131671,
0.0419881456,
0.0322583877,
0.0264946539,
0.0242812745,
0.089166671,
0.0400895067,
-0.0276093222,
0.0046954188,
-0.0220439397,
0.0598703213,
-0.0145800076,
0.0259143412,
-0.041278746,
-0.0298444256,
-0.0787255317,
0.0155255655,
-0.0350601561,
-0.0411811545,
0.0139244767,
0.031206727,
-0.0123759639,
0.0098266946,
0.0206760075,
-0.0473646298,
-0.0242091473,
-0.0152032906,
0.0251565017,
0.026006043,
0.0096068513,
0.0174092259,
-0.0643290505,
-0.0179118626,
0.0247639827,
-0.0077226837,
0.0306598563,
0.0074909395,
0.0202320833,
0.0231845584,
-0.0345708914,
-0.0408406071,
-0.0245543793,
-0.0347853042,
-0.013568135,
-0.0099009015,
0.0487457775,
0.0331219397,
-0.0136799235,
0.0201233905,
0.0144477366,
0.0217103437,
0.0062794886,
0.0529518872,
0.0025482962,
0.0255197231,
-0.0434157103,
-0.0222774334,
0.0128229717,
-0.0696869344,
0.0469010323,
-0.0072171809,
-0.0214923341,
0.0312775783,
2.766e-7,
0.0439447388,
0.0153111517,
0.0018788015,
-0.0510705672,
0.0102058128,
0.0191033985,
-0.0429471619,
-0.0123506524,
0.0515876077,
-0.052716855,
0.0465252884,
0.0614318512,
-0.0031319447,
0.0214053225,
-0.0754442215,
-0.0386236273,
0.0005362162,
0.0284965672,
-0.034792047,
-0.0238249563,
0.0844884738,
0.1081694588,
0.0343998261,
-0.0019124799,
-0.027485365,
0.0026409319,
0.052185826,
-0.0149745913,
0.017310733,
0.0321715325,
0.0809316263,
0.0035530634,
0.0078915972,
0.1050899997,
-0.0043404433,
0.0145463385,
0.000615312,
0.0145931579,
-0.0493092127,
-0.0169165991,
-0.0173532981,
0.0156983174,
0.0134661905,
0.0057638315,
0.0741149262,
-0.1078585237,
-0.0371114053,
0.0087937377,
-0.0344434939,
0.0007517659,
0.0225760322,
0.0337904952,
0.0037364741,
0.0446459949,
-0.0146763083,
0.0197608098,
-0.0170385428,
-0.0936480612,
0.0020677825,
0.0229135454,
-0.0413317718,
-0.0201650243,
0.0032179267,
-0.0151183438,
0.0355305113,
-0.0320585519,
0.0081745367,
2.079633178e-34,
0.0282348935,
-0.0068350332,
0.0133328056,
0.0154375723,
-0.0031193753,
-0.0500562526,
-0.0598003715,
0.0087879626,
0.0195282046,
-0.0619810484,
-0.0209228266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12058v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12058v3 | WellDunn: On the Robustness and Explainability of Language Models and Large Language Models in Identifying Wellness Dimensions | 2024-06-17T19:50:40 | 2024-06-28T04:08:12 | Seyedali Mohammadi, Edward Raff, Jinendra Malekar, Vedant Palit, Francis Ferraro, Manas Gaur | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Language Models (LMs) are being proposed for mental health applications where
the heightened risk of adverse outcomes means predictive performance may not be
a sufficient litmus test of a model's utility in clinical practice. A model
that can be trusted for practice should have a correspondence between
explanation and clinical determination, yet no prior research has examined the
attention fidelity of these models and their effect on ground truth
explanations. We introduce an evaluation design that focuses on the robustness
and explainability of LMs in identifying Wellness Dimensions (WD). We focus on
two mental health and well-being datasets: (a) Multi-label Classification-based
MultiWD, and (b) WellXplain for evaluating attention mechanism veracity against
expert-labeled explanations. The labels are based on Halbert Dunn's theory of
wellness, which gives grounding to our evaluation. We reveal four surprising
results about LMs/LLMs: (1) Despite their human-like capabilities, GPT-3.5/4
lag behind RoBERTa, and MedAlpaca, a fine-tuned LLM fails to deliver any
remarkable improvements in performance or explanations. (2) Re-examining LMs'
predictions based on a confidence-oriented loss function reveals a significant
performance drop. (3) Across all LMs/LLMs, the alignment between attention and
explanations remains low, with LLMs scoring a dismal 0.0. (4) Most mental
health-specific LMs/LLMs overlook domain-specific knowledge and undervalue
explanations, causing these discrepancies. This study highlights the need for
further research into their consistency and explanations in mental health and
well-being. | [
0.0152662313,
0.0649123266,
-0.0071675605,
0.0044364706,
0.0131744407,
0.0193886403,
0.0269014947,
0.0065855044,
0.0454443917,
-0.0169238001,
0.0102940826,
0.0088911792,
0.0076661496,
0.0042161224,
0.0156785827,
-0.0488700792,
0.0293054041,
0.0150795449,
0.0482614785,
0.0114230458,
-0.0173349101,
0.0010754673,
-0.002721793,
0.060536392,
-0.018677704,
-0.0194774754,
0.0604836233,
0.0023996991,
0.0155549198,
-0.0698678717,
-0.0247665308,
0.0516948402,
-0.008726499,
-0.0202655829,
0.0000023872,
-0.0438756458,
-0.0219963603,
0.0169339534,
0.0137624405,
-0.0249014087,
0.0256928019,
-0.0646892637,
0.0410545357,
0.0243825577,
0.0273062475,
0.0241467357,
0.0145691521,
0.0602953546,
0.0311286468,
0.0274706949,
-0.0198375396,
-0.0171365924,
-0.0189443585,
-0.0228804871,
-0.0045546554,
-0.0237249359,
0.0427635536,
-0.0228122845,
-0.0159382597,
-0.0362974182,
-0.0126209697,
0.0211203676,
-0.0189772267,
0.0263208151,
-0.0067278259,
0.004889538,
0.0203936342,
-0.0048732548,
0.0445282497,
0.0538941659,
0.0291691869,
0.049950581,
-0.007612064,
-0.007566541,
0.0305878818,
-0.0040509184,
-0.0217388291,
-0.0186346117,
0.0040318277,
0.0035915016,
0.02085503,
0.0374826118,
0.0355882049,
-0.0331696756,
0.0054580732,
0.096383296,
-0.0136052053,
-0.0476464741,
-0.0088234311,
-0.0372668095,
-0.0165445972,
-0.0161414631,
0.0159024093,
0.0323138945,
-0.0183911007,
0.028252054,
0.0208267923,
-0.0074180756,
0.0476876199,
-0.0171152633,
-0.0106818499,
0.0536757857,
-0.064770624,
-0.0256817844,
0.0663890317,
0.0505181998,
0.0188518316,
0.0390894637,
-0.0454005636,
0.0320497043,
-0.0397691801,
0.0011412792,
-0.0140046095,
-0.0141276596,
0.0174660608,
-0.015944561,
-0.0854761302,
-0.0202662889,
-0.0338549837,
-0.0593776181,
0.0100866305,
-0.0252795946,
0.0187285375,
0.0194304921,
-0.0291634891,
0.0225013699,
-0.0149850752,
-0.0022123179,
0.0206900965,
-0.0330600962,
0.0081249289,
0.0348028131,
-0.043918781,
-0.0549132749,
0.0115796197,
0.0469115265,
0.0669653639,
-0.0563422181,
-0.0445393994,
-0.0152475452,
-0.0967180505,
-0.0540839769,
0.0003575736,
-0.0338617414,
0.0094140479,
0.0064774468,
0.0224019401,
-0.0640530065,
0.0351612978,
-0.0144730462,
-0.0699219704,
0.0145526072,
-0.0329651497,
0.0404211059,
-0.0002339027,
0.010246804,
0.0019688997,
0.034170419,
0.0191665944,
-0.0290261563,
0.0300399922,
-0.086203672,
-0.0015632308,
-0.0218540505,
0.0032444943,
0.0005451513,
0.0401079133,
-0.0170015991,
-0.0027460959,
0.0448467918,
-0.0060144067,
-0.0021026938,
0.0105287936,
0.0648590997,
0.0835229456,
0.0416879356,
0.0253027268,
0.025591854,
-0.0243542716,
0.0064451201,
-0.0283317957,
-0.0009444892,
-0.087239258,
-0.0103528462,
-0.0257825647,
-0.0266510453,
0.0608493239,
-0.0015680778,
-0.0335516594,
-0.0637193769,
-0.0395275615,
-0.0237762034,
0.0254162308,
0.0092959264,
0.0075014671,
-0.0614390895,
0.0000352763,
0.0326353088,
0.0422247276,
0.0096735572,
-0.0226487387,
-0.0692399368,
0.003651367,
0.0716829747,
-0.0083203409,
-0.0195028428,
0.0040076226,
-0.0220997576,
0.0654475689,
-0.0085384473,
0.0076913037,
0.0429650322,
0.0239450168,
0.0084790587,
-0.0276805833,
-0.0075946157,
0.0412098132,
-0.0207095332,
-0.0191742629,
-0.0037458003,
-0.0181191154,
-0.0346271433,
-0.0696181282,
0.0700850487,
0.0282233283,
-0.0337711498,
0.0008788138,
-0.0060310303,
0.0504323579,
0.0129155889,
0.0183715504,
0.0572084934,
0.0059981099,
0.0004611898,
-0.0271626227,
0.0211355407,
-0.0326984972,
0.0064016571,
0.0001110856,
0.0380177721,
0.0316314921,
0.0348807871,
-0.0069857668,
-0.0089315204,
0.0332279466,
-0.0667791292,
-0.0196960829,
0.0109631149,
0.0062754741,
-0.0016096717,
0.046081733,
-0.0498337224,
0.0282195788,
-0.0461191088,
0.0544934459,
-0.0379280895,
-0.0432529002,
-0.0057201595,
-0.0248093344,
-0.0118602309,
-0.0092635518,
-0.0703113005,
0.0085087055,
-0.0507677682,
0.0279432628,
0.0009660767,
0.0092059523,
-0.084683992,
0.0136197284,
-0.0246311333,
-0.0143611496,
-0.0049701878,
-0.033092238,
-0.0162105039,
0.0095069418,
-0.0145441992,
-0.000952579,
0.0497644544,
0.0598239303,
-0.0110495631,
0.0035984172,
-0.0090518007,
-0.0179945156,
-0.0244050473,
-0.0448283628,
0.0091140345,
0.0068560475,
0.0020747811,
-0.0252485331,
-0.053622257,
-0.0417038165,
-0.0555573255,
-0.0096186548,
-0.0143640656,
0.0060762945,
0.0508187786,
0.0310755428,
0.026004333,
-0.0056917155,
0.0394565761,
0.0368935689,
0.0410371386,
-0.0253090821,
0.0077147717,
-0.0396074317,
-0.0514652058,
-0.0288320445,
-0.0789053813,
0.0075453785,
0.0851941034,
0.0509407744,
0.0068436298,
-0.0642495826,
-0.0084737595,
-0.0205713604,
0.0255128983,
-0.0337367207,
0.0251824912,
-0.0451445617,
0.0550966747,
-0.0130346874,
-0.070816718,
0.047452841,
0.0169321485,
0.0163408536,
-0.0402341038,
-0.0097548105,
-0.0138266897,
-0.0129079139,
-0.0008577348,
0.0182323325,
0.0503230207,
-0.0157368872,
0.0288519505,
-0.0272171609,
-0.0184952673,
-0.0307552181,
0.0494151935,
-0.0618273318,
-0.0134373326,
0.0161882043,
0.008826769,
-0.0157421567,
-0.0006882824,
-0.0362890176,
0.0204223152,
0.0138038443,
0.0499724485,
-0.0766980499,
-0.0025330056,
0.0364690647,
0.0077375737,
-0.0189700015,
-0.0121759679,
0.0248265881,
-0.036205329,
0.0148658697,
0.0262009501,
0.0495855771,
-0.0424928144,
0.0023099068,
0.0147576658,
-0.0526253544,
0.02909136,
0.0610730387,
0.0021206443,
-0.0069694859,
-0.0101973657,
-0.0040114131,
0.049425751,
0.0428166054,
-0.0309602376,
-0.0335109532,
0.1094275266,
-0.0132526187,
-0.0105957147,
0.0525421724,
-0.0214990359,
-0.0226524025,
0.0291240718,
-0.0471561402,
0.0183833912,
-0.0298354216,
-0.0320164561,
0.0944199413,
-0.0136471735,
-0.0073933611,
0.0292805005,
-0.0053942124,
0.036601536,
-0.0176779777,
-0.0519195758,
-0.0146100782,
-0.0448995531,
0.0136014884,
0.0015073349,
-0.0392436087,
-0.0059089265,
0.0235251486,
-0.0111533469,
0.0154412687,
-0.0723825023,
-0.0540475883,
0.0373047814,
-0.0004926763,
0.0364125744,
0.0553297251,
0.0444780029,
-0.0120572988,
-0.0678234696,
0.0089782933,
-0.0199512746,
0.0004936742,
0.0246938597,
0.087332502,
-0.0132074673,
0.0211084206,
-0.0511261486,
0.0440338999,
-0.0472709239,
-0.009508701,
-0.0293191485,
0.0630684197,
0.0264594052,
-0.0527136624,
-0.0213365592,
0.0512134582,
0.0263729114,
0.0710827261,
0.0376825519,
-0.0358626023,
-0.0049970746,
0.0021765176,
0.0096673723,
0.0196784884,
-0.0325589888,
0.0428052768,
-0.033049982,
-0.0398110747,
-0.0186861288,
-0.0600214191,
0.0388655774,
-0.0111495685,
-0.0251208283,
-0.0091473721,
-0.0187994093,
0.0161719993,
-0.0536099896,
0.0774666965,
0.0485260263,
0.0221418701,
-0.0535645746,
0.0001598341,
0.0245401207,
-0.0155143188,
-0.0090146093,
0.0148669947,
-0.0050337072,
0.0198616982,
0.0525086969,
0.0394057631,
0.0191478878,
-0.0400594175,
0.0036110021,
-0.0322903916,
-0.0196091402,
-0.013962293,
-0.0540033206,
-0.0058348197,
0.0236877967,
0.0659354627,
0.0036930556,
0.0383650623,
-0.0176230241,
0.0435477644,
0.045642361,
0.0179585125,
0.0174702629,
-0.049180802,
0.0137034617,
0.0264600329,
0.0743670985,
-0.0272179116,
-0.0280587189,
-0.0104011074,
-0.0626374558,
-0.0089363465,
-0.0012721407,
-0.0127003919,
-0.0280992221,
0.0452552363,
0.017367905,
-0.0348272212,
-0.0351286791,
-0.0597286187,
-0.0267089941,
-0.0612269118,
0.0292818286,
-0.0652641878,
0.0045131883,
-0.0161677953,
0.021150643,
-0.0156892557,
0.0175365265,
-0.0182146151,
0.014301125,
0.026183093,
0.082701534,
-0.0144272679,
0.0023353095,
0.0260458086,
-0.0058558336,
-0.0382566303,
-0.0721093267,
-0.0164137445,
-0.0479512103,
-0.0019332294,
0.0280089565,
0.0667673349,
0.0073287049,
-0.0114087397,
-0.0581776686,
0.0123988725,
-0.005173828,
-0.0359273776,
0.053855218,
-0.0088207414,
-0.0327747017,
-0.0462219417,
0.0604345351,
0.0034610163,
-0.0197425727,
-0.0005990233,
-0.0293692872,
-0.0320679396,
-0.0262314491,
-0.0184869133,
0.0682718828,
-0.0828207359,
0.0148802195,
-0.0918902606,
-0.0537219904,
0.0329383761,
-0.0505784191,
0.0048064566,
-0.0177820176,
0.0050005703,
0.0263212547,
-0.0139168194,
-0.035640046,
-0.0579842292,
0.0166568588,
-0.0549789779,
0.0034830184,
-0.0045079673,
-5.816675554e-33,
-0.0095411241,
-0.039341189,
0.0001723862,
-0.0147770401,
-0.0185333118,
-0.0055770683,
-0.0401891172,
0.036855299,
-0.0249991883,
0.0175273605,
0.0690332204,
0.0512425378,
-0.0110791707,
0.0558592454,
0.0281637311,
-0.0330851153,
-0.0203374568,
0.0067017931,
-0.0272653326,
-0.0047325529,
-0.0235479064,
0.0333939865,
0.072416611,
-0.1157448366,
0.08221066,
0.0207659658,
0.0208423287,
0.0149840126,
-0.011532574,
0.0326287746,
-0.0531963296,
0.0953998342,
0.0636791959,
-0.0149773434,
0.0266954284,
-0.0132074514,
0.0055427561,
-0.0314926244,
0.0408810936,
-0.0412097313,
-0.0198137127,
-0.0353996493,
0.0270084832,
0.0229377523,
-0.030017158,
-0.0361504853,
0.0348748006,
-0.0811437666,
0.0025155793,
-0.0207197163,
-0.0397828706,
0.0256330464,
-0.0139988177,
-0.0014196672,
-0.0497813076,
0.0408196822,
-0.0439683497,
0.0874527842,
-0.0238617789,
-0.0241787359,
0.0213403348,
-0.0125016998,
0.0483497605,
-0.0331425071,
-0.0024859712,
0.0447118133,
0.0283078086,
0.0344575271,
-0.0368637852,
-0.0379772596,
0.0296189412,
0.035025537,
0.1061382592,
0.0049479883,
-0.0271163713,
-0.0361074507,
-0.0566491224,
-0.007341533,
-0.0588735752,
-0.0233570524,
0.062714234,
-0.0098989792,
-0.0359977037,
-0.0308675133,
-0.0456449762,
0.0017301086,
-0.0373728126,
-0.0077712536,
0.0336011127,
-0.0117005566,
-0.0160919819,
0.0005023613,
0.0159893557,
-0.0147726377,
0.0210238378,
-0.0029774329,
0.010708604,
0.008525298,
0.0247581135,
0.0151880281,
-0.0347276963,
0.0041739345,
-0.0229207259,
0.0368622504,
0.0806662217,
-0.0222367812,
0.034756083,
-0.03955587,
-0.0237199292,
-0.0310102422,
-0.0066710939,
0.020175999,
0.0114688836,
-0.0061406293,
-0.0012568166,
-0.0095082885,
0.0053042579,
0.05875111,
0.0480785668,
-0.0183961131,
-0.0763203502,
-0.0109315515,
-0.009634994,
0.0088187717,
0.0024306506,
-0.031200977,
0.0112136183,
0.0147787407,
0.0488097407,
-0.0250914451,
-0.0116320224,
-0.0074552055,
2.918e-7,
0.0782283023,
0.0614332445,
-0.0551657081,
-0.031891983,
0.0338453501,
0.0293063354,
-0.0247765519,
0.0180511829,
0.0298299845,
0.0047706924,
-0.0011831721,
0.0035136242,
0.0673801824,
0.0019279635,
0.035072986,
-0.0418841653,
-0.011842628,
-0.0105119692,
-0.0471192598,
0.0306563862,
0.0793209672,
0.0555091873,
-0.0149545642,
0.0008075826,
-0.0059495093,
-0.0008139093,
0.0245932322,
-0.0609361529,
0.0161028281,
0.0473155379,
0.0589200407,
-0.0048083854,
0.0133566828,
0.0015000297,
0.0083646616,
0.0190199018,
0.0071719657,
0.1140112355,
-0.0422318578,
0.008071932,
-0.0293822326,
0.0047534741,
0.0243091825,
-0.0729459748,
0.0489189364,
-0.0841504782,
-0.0522188544,
-0.0052929684,
-0.0582239069,
-0.0107903583,
0.0666166842,
-0.0091390451,
-0.0067877728,
0.0371336043,
0.020218214,
-0.0189039651,
0.0208679419,
-0.0450438559,
-0.0469245054,
0.0460941903,
-0.0599894151,
-0.0052112052,
-0.0224093869,
0.0116825933,
0.0195487887,
-0.080180347,
-0.0003329125,
2.82799834e-34,
0.0336277001,
0.0357979015,
0.0213354025,
-0.012383041,
0.0333161578,
0.0008070556,
-0.0068752351,
0.0286843926,
-0.0249454416,
-0.0550783165,
-0.0006342354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12053v1 | InternalInspector $I^2$: Robust Confidence Estimation in LLMs through Internal States | 2024-06-17T19:46:05 | 2024-06-17T19:46:05 | Mohammad Beigi, Ying Shen, Runing Yang, Zihao Lin, Qifan Wang, Ankith Mohan, Jianfeng He, Ming Jin, Chang-Tien Lu, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their vast capabilities, Large Language Models (LLMs) often struggle
with generating reliable outputs, frequently producing high-confidence
inaccuracies known as hallucinations. Addressing this challenge, our research
introduces InternalInspector, a novel framework designed to enhance confidence
estimation in LLMs by leveraging contrastive learning on internal states
including attention states, feed-forward states, and activation states of all
layers. Unlike existing methods that primarily focus on the final activation
state, InternalInspector conducts a comprehensive analysis across all internal
states of every layer to accurately identify both correct and incorrect
prediction processes. By benchmarking InternalInspector against existing
confidence estimation methods across various natural language understanding and
generation tasks, including factual question answering, commonsense reasoning,
and reading comprehension, InternalInspector achieves significantly higher
accuracy in aligning the estimated confidence scores with the correctness of
the LLM's predictions and lower calibration error. Furthermore,
InternalInspector excels at HaluEval, a hallucination detection benchmark,
outperforming other internal-based confidence estimation methods in this task. | [
-0.0124251666,
0.073807314,
-0.0056356774,
0.0539738312,
-0.0475405604,
-0.0027345091,
-0.0396493413,
-0.0234877318,
0.0156650301,
-0.0277821496,
-0.0614500381,
-0.0627817139,
0.0414101891,
0.0023463715,
0.0435581207,
-0.0175081138,
0.0559946783,
-0.0532301068,
-0.0141907129,
-0.0001279298,
-0.0242520683,
-0.017299084,
-0.015436748,
0.0389425531,
0.0221040528,
-0.0326484442,
0.0117203789,
0.0089412509,
0.0364956707,
-0.0388537198,
0.0139860325,
0.0585655011,
0.0265282616,
0.0586403944,
0.0000018268,
-0.0339417085,
0.0088870246,
-0.0289237723,
0.00177361,
-0.0232853647,
-0.0006158147,
-0.020525394,
0.0106082782,
0.0115545066,
-0.0207403917,
0.0396886915,
0.0241118483,
0.0690020621,
0.0337614939,
0.0658865944,
0.0137564698,
-0.0131040327,
0.0204653665,
0.0024019093,
0.0123275034,
-0.0202080198,
0.0291021634,
0.0026756146,
-0.0409122333,
-0.0357587226,
-0.0267288797,
0.0480124839,
0.0297355819,
-0.0100398017,
-0.0206845067,
0.0366747379,
-0.0332155973,
-0.011535435,
-0.0127323642,
0.0646784157,
0.0052228738,
-0.0400863215,
-0.0255781654,
-0.000379072,
0.0069897901,
-0.0162120331,
-0.0322341956,
0.0184693914,
-0.0217277482,
0.0372219123,
0.0342144929,
0.0329607911,
0.036987856,
0.0006908848,
0.0096402336,
0.0805590823,
0.0222486854,
-0.027144732,
0.0219974536,
0.038458433,
-0.0180333275,
-0.0353450142,
0.0452125072,
0.0337418355,
-0.047499042,
0.0252608061,
-0.0496960729,
0.00263222,
0.0172930453,
-0.0621957406,
-0.0091396123,
0.0442902707,
-0.0529571623,
0.0475671403,
-0.0291928593,
0.043601431,
-0.0066291322,
0.0550241731,
0.0147167714,
-0.0039806035,
0.0191137716,
0.005484845,
-0.0275282711,
0.0177541617,
0.0040877294,
-0.0308266133,
-0.0640998483,
-0.0030545292,
-0.0199909415,
0.0446207486,
0.005357095,
0.0298876576,
-0.015434674,
-0.0518258847,
-0.01420929,
0.0372905768,
0.0069330637,
-0.0058587594,
0.0282812491,
-0.0764045343,
-0.0441261195,
0.0388135426,
-0.0124365259,
-0.0016706364,
-0.031556461,
0.0445374809,
-0.0085410494,
-0.0405903161,
-0.0635437071,
-0.0209300797,
-0.0365298688,
-0.0688597634,
0.0058358368,
-0.0509865843,
-0.0078967242,
-0.0166556742,
0.007569782,
-0.0405491106,
0.0521511585,
0.0326774754,
0.0122476751,
0.0528106876,
-0.0241791196,
-0.035918761,
0.0079506394,
0.036954619,
-0.0264096279,
0.0480980463,
0.016230436,
0.0124562969,
0.014737919,
0.0066209799,
0.0498364046,
0.0220218413,
0.011102885,
-0.0161976796,
-0.0732590035,
0.0088823056,
-0.0112268487,
0.0210614465,
0.0443233065,
0.0610513575,
-0.0315670036,
-0.0287312213,
0.1030752286,
0.0129228272,
0.0053443671,
-0.0259337258,
0.0200038422,
-0.0004993064,
0.0254298765,
0.0313862227,
-0.0659022927,
0.0638811812,
-0.0637208447,
0.0043127034,
0.0777255297,
0.0052147568,
-0.0049494794,
-0.0539469086,
-0.0229072627,
-0.0031655729,
-0.0340344496,
0.0355157629,
0.0263130069,
0.0133413011,
-0.0686074346,
0.020859722,
0.0041720164,
0.0103147281,
0.0279619731,
-0.0348007903,
0.0291312598,
0.073457323,
0.0333165564,
-0.009470189,
0.0129138213,
-0.0269284621,
0.005317363,
0.0825337917,
0.0095596109,
0.0000874877,
0.0324246921,
-0.0691840053,
0.0072425064,
-0.0169296097,
0.0521543398,
-0.0075542689,
0.0120807989,
0.0132389991,
0.0100544151,
-0.0410036221,
0.0032240229,
0.0225858148,
-0.0175756961,
-0.0319292992,
-0.0221175961,
-0.0250405259,
0.0094399033,
-0.0212362949,
0.0173947103,
0.0326795429,
0.0042705047,
-0.017609939,
-0.0541235358,
0.0206130929,
-0.0499228276,
-0.0646036863,
0.0498382114,
-0.0193544123,
-0.0350588672,
0.023141576,
-0.0151696764,
-0.0459009707,
0.0362826064,
-0.0636976063,
0.0119852154,
-0.0539480746,
0.0283803325,
0.0335714966,
0.0554386377,
-0.01194847,
0.0708197281,
-0.0642292202,
0.0115947407,
0.0410787761,
0.0120444056,
-0.0122834155,
-0.0275255106,
0.0032042204,
-0.0132996058,
-0.0090267444,
0.0096121533,
-0.0112572182,
-0.0440035723,
-0.077763021,
-0.0059943143,
-0.01509663,
0.0111973938,
-0.0313109085,
0.0032086631,
0.0427242294,
-0.0213955455,
0.0047556236,
-0.0143534802,
-0.0230019987,
0.0105142705,
0.0012540836,
0.0175395384,
0.0180755332,
-0.027763987,
-0.0084922342,
-0.0393713675,
0.010611414,
-0.0189076532,
0.0432722829,
-0.0251184851,
-0.0308674406,
-0.0929954648,
0.0317419581,
-0.0183641594,
0.0320487171,
-0.0113256648,
-0.020781111,
0.0222813934,
-0.0041907742,
0.0269983243,
0.0740949586,
0.0262493361,
-0.0193919353,
0.0699224323,
-0.0354377069,
-0.0340911299,
0.0098917559,
-0.0009361487,
0.0118622361,
-0.0121823261,
-0.0398973972,
-0.0124112284,
0.0743940696,
0.0397517569,
0.018118171,
-0.0581784733,
0.0152839245,
-0.0099456171,
-0.0371728614,
0.0178154893,
0.0153557761,
-0.0379749499,
0.048080083,
-0.0412193611,
-0.0542652383,
0.0931853279,
-0.0511131734,
0.0058735143,
0.0039638779,
0.0016633631,
-0.0085980399,
0.0032461088,
0.0157372877,
-0.0059322966,
-0.0157050733,
-0.0277552847,
-0.0442271493,
-0.013013659,
-0.0178635772,
-0.0461824648,
0.0585138686,
-0.0491419844,
-0.0057886587,
0.0265252609,
-0.019510353,
-0.0769637972,
0.0128977308,
-0.0497329794,
-0.0090761986,
-0.0252005812,
-0.0123632047,
-0.0270981975,
-0.0352497101,
0.0351482853,
0.0443252698,
-0.0297423527,
-0.026459625,
-0.0038001512,
0.0519986264,
0.0774971694,
-0.0078594554,
0.071576871,
-0.0522586219,
0.0292113982,
0.0861770511,
-0.024393104,
0.0423171036,
-0.0403165594,
-0.0220847167,
0.0494522154,
-0.0168510899,
-0.0078351526,
0.0336140245,
0.0837851688,
-0.0557777286,
-0.0411523059,
0.1237287968,
0.0161453057,
-0.0666092634,
0.0045304894,
-0.0517414175,
0.016383687,
0.0270611346,
0.0010445601,
-0.0400827676,
-0.0297301188,
-0.0071213716,
0.0147125535,
-0.0065506999,
-0.0302605238,
-0.0052763927,
-0.107198596,
0.0353916474,
0.0230277777,
-0.03826252,
-0.0483866781,
-0.0310063791,
0.0485323071,
0.0307543073,
0.0463751741,
0.0062287953,
0.0167141221,
-0.0082299337,
0.0070668799,
-0.0291793142,
-0.0512568951,
0.0138195269,
-0.0165139399,
0.0531239361,
0.0438992567,
0.0231083743,
0.0092171459,
-0.0772442967,
0.0576596335,
-0.052925989,
-0.0032186394,
-0.0125245005,
0.0584232919,
0.0126550207,
0.0061516836,
-0.0320375822,
0.0397191569,
-0.039443627,
-0.0350086465,
-0.0335507356,
0.0584393777,
-0.047109697,
-0.0461966321,
-0.0090612778,
0.0536763147,
0.0242366288,
0.0685874447,
0.0401062667,
-0.0155508891,
-0.0229958445,
-0.0457646027,
0.0301670916,
-0.0785151646,
-0.0116570089,
0.0405584499,
0.1073766723,
0.0049727275,
-0.0665514022,
-0.0243374482,
0.0055045774,
0.0033219324,
-0.0259332266,
0.0186630301,
-0.0224061329,
-0.0378035866,
-0.0125890728,
-0.0017917693,
-0.0634196922,
0.0099454429,
-0.0233340785,
0.0253408458,
0.0326484516,
-0.0174197052,
-0.0058540427,
0.0660049021,
-0.0998095348,
-0.0921997279,
-0.0042935857,
0.0755560771,
0.0179427527,
0.054373119,
-0.0273817312,
-0.0417678505,
0.0597661808,
-0.0287756547,
0.0060012699,
0.0175155811,
0.0159807317,
0.0216856226,
-0.0005776054,
0.0433307029,
0.0019609889,
-0.0339495763,
0.041413907,
0.0533323213,
-0.0003902515,
-0.0415930822,
0.029932728,
-0.0274103247,
0.0282310639,
-0.0222269278,
0.0440082699,
-0.0205658078,
0.0055272654,
-0.0208890345,
-0.0119441012,
-0.0176593624,
0.01858145,
0.0625988096,
-0.0379162058,
-0.0236851498,
-0.0448749922,
-0.0083731608,
-0.0132236676,
-0.0048642159,
-0.0179209802,
0.0383576788,
0.0183133427,
0.0275495145,
-0.01994019,
-0.0398979336,
0.0237786733,
-0.0087731145,
0.0755153,
0.0405900404,
0.0538545065,
0.0096175624,
-0.0287662316,
-0.0124011524,
-0.0168677662,
-0.0505347066,
-0.0350047164,
-0.0334254466,
0.0148804132,
0.0472583249,
0.0088637946,
0.0451059118,
-0.0118694538,
-0.0022630561,
-0.0144849662,
0.036253117,
-0.0013380453,
-0.048357226,
0.0262816139,
-0.0004470781,
-0.0021083504,
0.0172092319,
0.08536724,
-0.0382645428,
0.0578526855,
-0.0013485275,
-0.0039194971,
-0.027705539,
-0.0304755848,
-0.0443161763,
0.0308818966,
-0.033769086,
0.0129709337,
-0.0294258185,
-0.0788527429,
0.0396617502,
0.0271632317,
0.0018222788,
-0.0160359256,
-0.0027500775,
0.0267187227,
-0.0046378826,
-0.0481258631,
-0.022453405,
-0.0164320171,
0.0263538435,
0.0049495362,
-0.0445091203,
-6.506459679e-33,
-0.0248390511,
-0.0551669076,
0.0163670443,
-0.0389457271,
0.0029574654,
-0.0049020685,
-0.0774652734,
0.0255955663,
0.024862146,
0.0290701166,
0.0021771004,
0.0481245741,
0.021068152,
0.0381291769,
0.0176747143,
-0.0316703357,
0.0395788513,
0.0056759114,
-0.035699185,
0.0003923354,
0.0110750711,
0.0210133679,
0.1187649742,
-0.0530176461,
0.0279662088,
0.0224035475,
-0.0344973654,
0.057471972,
-0.0403078347,
0.0227223318,
-0.0373390019,
0.0371145196,
0.0097382236,
-0.0366573334,
-0.0307951905,
-0.0187947452,
-0.0185913872,
-0.038730219,
0.0114886751,
0.0227728691,
-0.0678070933,
-0.0310003888,
0.0205358695,
-0.0131408032,
0.0215624087,
-0.029306896,
0.0163270105,
-0.0316009223,
-0.0066279485,
-0.0137899052,
-0.0457878262,
0.017840052,
0.0030756472,
0.0087511055,
-0.027765533,
0.0634621978,
-0.0017909505,
-0.0106157605,
-0.0919301808,
-0.0099172937,
-0.0187156722,
0.0165883061,
0.0640294179,
0.0137237487,
-0.0107747652,
0.07454101,
0.0463927463,
-0.0015186438,
-0.0276561715,
-0.0362330861,
0.023620436,
0.0204035416,
0.0533940606,
0.0357242115,
0.0189129133,
0.0391591005,
-0.0469063744,
0.0053116614,
-0.0257057883,
0.0276453216,
0.0435277075,
-0.0030649533,
-0.0401880965,
-0.0122476034,
-0.021635266,
-0.0378230549,
-0.0294025447,
-0.0059577501,
0.0245751478,
0.020458458,
0.0170901939,
-0.0125861848,
0.0398920439,
-0.0228304956,
0.005840634,
0.017331386,
0.0090450961,
0.0007640917,
-0.0029184234,
0.0359728411,
-0.0325733162,
0.0143979536,
0.00709101,
0.0135160405,
0.0029526684,
0.0241607688,
0.0315189734,
-0.0055096857,
-0.064219363,
0.0220619682,
-0.0511624403,
0.0185760427,
0.0054478622,
0.017025562,
0.0543420576,
-0.0125248423,
-0.0332563519,
0.0161943529,
-0.0209380891,
0.0320314653,
-0.0008104137,
0.022801131,
-0.0098250071,
0.019411739,
-0.0282676481,
-0.0175733883,
-0.0276133846,
-0.025377376,
0.0178477,
-0.0468041152,
-0.0058429963,
0.012806152,
2.652e-7,
0.0368850231,
0.0263440162,
0.0085414648,
0.0538170263,
0.0242826939,
0.003110487,
-0.0023437955,
-0.0011753327,
0.0309729967,
-0.0698517114,
-0.011638334,
0.0320060998,
0.0705007389,
0.0568807498,
-0.0740079954,
-0.0345361196,
-0.0278744157,
0.036580056,
0.0079281805,
-0.0447553024,
0.0225819629,
0.0761991292,
-0.0034985803,
-0.0200599618,
0.030759925,
-0.0478598662,
0.0799526572,
0.0090011768,
0.0075888638,
0.0131669967,
0.0525653586,
0.0197955798,
0.0101070357,
0.0242953207,
-0.0189530011,
-0.0102949319,
-0.0199189428,
0.0356337801,
0.0001640323,
-0.0640699789,
-0.0497795939,
0.0141402576,
0.0344513655,
-0.0452571213,
0.0360978842,
-0.0688775182,
-0.0318440795,
-0.0297742411,
-0.0209663641,
-0.0416823812,
0.0614526905,
-0.0019755317,
-0.0118505331,
0.01718935,
0.0069244243,
0.0344804265,
-0.0266363006,
-0.064675115,
-0.0595662184,
-0.0154611226,
-0.0426639467,
0.00007656,
-0.0313757844,
0.0019926471,
-0.009742083,
-0.0817171559,
0.0147415763,
2.345107556e-34,
0.0399075225,
-0.0248764623,
0.0234246533,
0.0490501635,
0.0365628824,
-0.0148653043,
0.0238781683,
-0.0251914337,
0.0343262143,
-0.0727680922,
-0.0197770987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12052v1 | UniGLM: Training One Unified Language Model for Text-Attributed Graphs | 2024-06-17T19:45:21 | 2024-06-17T19:45:21 | Yi Fang, Dongzhe Fan, Sirui Ding, Ninghao Liu, Qiaoyu Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Representation learning on text-attributed graphs (TAGs), where nodes are
represented by textual descriptions, is crucial for textual and relational
knowledge systems and recommendation systems. Currently, state-of-the-art
embedding methods for TAGs primarily focus on fine-tuning language models
(e.g., BERT) using structure-aware training signals. While effective, these
methods are tailored for individual TAG and cannot generalize across various
graph scenarios. Given the shared textual space, leveraging multiple TAGs for
joint fine-tuning, aligning text and graph structure from different aspects,
would be more beneficial. Motivated by this, we introduce a novel Unified Graph
Language Model (UniGLM) framework, the first graph embedding model that
generalizes well to both in-domain and cross-domain TAGs. Specifically, UniGLM
is trained over multiple TAGs with different domains and scales using
self-supervised contrastive learning. UniGLM includes an adaptive positive
sample selection technique for identifying structurally similar nodes and a
lazy contrastive module that is devised to accelerate training by minimizing
repetitive encoding calculations. Extensive empirical results across 9
benchmark TAGs demonstrate UniGLM's efficacy against leading embedding
baselines in terms of generalization (various downstream tasks and backbones)
and transfer learning (in and out of domain scenarios). The code is available
at https://github.com/NYUSHCS/UniGLM. | [
0.004699918,
-0.0005597722,
0.0060257702,
0.0396670662,
-0.0135070682,
0.0232068244,
-0.0007268156,
-0.0157245249,
0.0783337951,
-0.0556438006,
-0.0374328084,
0.0059887893,
-0.027057115,
0.0291674808,
0.0317413583,
-0.0056910468,
0.0026611923,
0.0169659127,
0.0399209596,
-0.0130978469,
0.0223225392,
0.0413522124,
0.0452178307,
-0.0039844899,
-0.0002222939,
-0.014670602,
0.0249215681,
0.0479811281,
0.000944756,
-0.0570533723,
0.0032891987,
0.0194864795,
0.0227128584,
-0.011705921,
0.0000017782,
-0.0155620053,
-0.0245428924,
0.0051355013,
0.0135040022,
-0.0116332341,
0.0590879284,
0.0092322361,
0.0547153912,
0.0140742073,
-0.0444250032,
-0.0370095335,
0.0349317193,
0.0513266996,
0.0202053376,
0.0572882891,
-0.0362044536,
-0.0453338251,
-0.0170029122,
-0.0380472243,
-0.0181191117,
-0.0369585045,
0.0307523124,
0.0203038417,
0.0001282037,
0.0540445708,
-0.0673619583,
0.0045856726,
-0.0168529842,
-0.0069736997,
0.0615509078,
0.0405828655,
-0.0116506768,
0.0488124304,
0.0204226393,
0.1391141862,
0.0061277281,
-0.0356795602,
0.017512925,
-0.0247370955,
0.0207133181,
-0.0028870273,
-0.0326547623,
-0.0469526611,
-0.0003346562,
0.0529373772,
0.0193073899,
-0.0206376202,
0.0722633749,
-0.0062309559,
0.0160461739,
0.0548377447,
0.0151735125,
-0.016683612,
0.0201414861,
0.0168695487,
-0.0505968034,
-0.0191293452,
0.0160625428,
0.0010647451,
-0.0156743824,
0.0183722228,
-0.0520857535,
-0.0308191217,
-0.0076509453,
-0.0041038007,
0.0381577946,
-0.0259871241,
-0.0009076444,
0.0747854412,
-0.036537312,
0.0337575711,
-0.0275942311,
0.0430247188,
-0.0420971327,
-0.0235659219,
-0.0761699602,
0.0191307496,
-0.0367772579,
0.0344408117,
-0.0209179278,
-0.0330587626,
-0.0008552385,
0.0240928307,
-0.0305232909,
0.0017684083,
0.0413220674,
0.0295540132,
-0.0069327736,
-0.0072139758,
0.0243644137,
0.052820202,
-0.0183152054,
-0.0160237905,
-0.0260110572,
0.0062339301,
-0.0036991951,
0.0373738036,
0.0500480644,
-0.0470338576,
0.0104111368,
0.0423788205,
0.0326808542,
-0.0181883015,
-0.0129065393,
0.0120156547,
-0.0111758234,
-0.0427209549,
0.0431790575,
-0.0755641088,
0.0382493176,
0.0378021635,
0.0074630533,
-0.0809301957,
0.0194304083,
-0.0101164645,
-0.0692166165,
0.0660403222,
-0.0388455354,
-0.0157573503,
-0.0219789259,
-0.0234184898,
-0.0244466756,
0.0295838751,
0.0300513618,
0.0118541699,
0.0498327687,
0.0043497616,
-0.0445399545,
-0.0054542054,
0.0316745974,
0.0334007852,
0.0049656136,
0.0100059947,
-0.0150874574,
0.0181272123,
0.0154097229,
0.0554743707,
-0.0113435937,
-0.0380980074,
0.0601512678,
0.0123791853,
-0.0055070641,
-0.0078474209,
0.0379510373,
0.05320324,
-0.0223852266,
-0.0038504011,
-0.0350134037,
0.0158788003,
0.028216688,
0.0224762727,
0.0248133894,
-0.0193306468,
-0.0473531075,
0.0199660547,
-0.0200990438,
-0.0522491448,
0.0727807209,
-0.0137596186,
0.0812167078,
0.0130887311,
-0.0652755946,
0.0117980074,
0.0420311801,
-0.0110111982,
0.0246901456,
0.0243275966,
-0.0035866341,
0.0549791269,
0.0389561504,
-0.0084810341,
-0.0279631987,
-0.0151755866,
0.0421537794,
-0.009964928,
0.0379022844,
-0.036257837,
0.0108023938,
-0.0552431047,
-0.0780877024,
-0.0458790027,
-0.0124232741,
0.0170779657,
-0.0050577847,
0.0090437755,
0.003468781,
-0.1089340895,
-0.0344137549,
0.0097949049,
-0.0368742459,
-0.0042854864,
0.0060449205,
-0.0181070399,
-0.0248532612,
0.0160565041,
-0.0035982558,
0.0116378479,
0.024137944,
-0.0116324928,
-0.0273946766,
-0.0046405094,
-0.0415464528,
-0.0597434267,
0.0597988106,
-0.0381557941,
-0.0198749732,
0.0299589336,
-0.0685367957,
-0.0373977199,
0.0532059483,
-0.039996542,
0.010349758,
0.0078652576,
-0.0047713513,
-0.0078618359,
-0.0104442611,
-0.0141354883,
0.0629793778,
0.017142402,
0.0166348927,
-0.0060654436,
0.0356275328,
0.0214252714,
-0.0227881204,
-0.0305200852,
-0.0177358296,
0.0261764824,
0.0090709552,
0.0256019086,
-0.0049790973,
-0.0486443453,
0.0399737693,
-0.0850141719,
0.017337732,
0.000752279,
0.0229759514,
-0.002714955,
-0.0005094649,
0.0272286795,
-0.0307029895,
-0.0532208979,
0.0011402743,
-0.0289053861,
0.012813732,
0.0298695359,
-0.0289478078,
0.0027889882,
-0.0242898408,
-0.0328408703,
-0.021002749,
0.0916775912,
0.0219347868,
-0.0164909773,
-0.0211892091,
-0.0066643651,
-0.0305702146,
0.031381987,
-0.0069245598,
0.0126358746,
-0.0337827727,
0.0163676739,
0.027027268,
0.0425108001,
-0.0292927902,
0.0138919707,
0.0163127836,
0.0109928288,
-0.0413657613,
-0.0137753207,
-0.0412977636,
0.0473087057,
-0.0285122916,
-0.0220705159,
-0.0161495116,
0.0692012981,
-0.0003752631,
-0.0189272799,
-0.0481373817,
-0.0282456484,
-0.0204908904,
0.0106820501,
0.0125561748,
-0.0078318492,
0.0214868654,
-0.0254921988,
-0.0403623804,
-0.0236005373,
0.0883773193,
-0.0124250399,
-0.0068407767,
0.0076668598,
-0.0205038451,
-0.0527320057,
0.0586760379,
0.0279709678,
0.0248724259,
0.0316929482,
-0.0163226444,
-0.0337952264,
-0.0075107263,
0.0524151772,
-0.0399090238,
-0.0201891679,
0.0141738504,
0.0222832691,
0.0047039185,
-0.0425507426,
0.0015358338,
-0.0034405729,
-0.0145284859,
0.0525638387,
0.0119779669,
-0.005076596,
-0.0158755127,
-0.0011043554,
-0.0253721736,
0.0127857504,
-0.0287176073,
0.0011988308,
-0.0283552278,
0.0663707033,
0.0761007741,
-0.0738973096,
0.0070584961,
-0.0161518548,
-0.0137263071,
0.0315536037,
0.0150981387,
-0.0015490717,
-0.0475982688,
0.0133534204,
0.0062038917,
-0.033327803,
-0.0277769826,
-0.0225109551,
0.0447820351,
0.0097998651,
-0.022668954,
0.088042587,
0.0276750326,
-0.0547785982,
-0.001021179,
0.0086937398,
0.0272991471,
0.0228089523,
-0.0086381212,
-0.089586094,
-0.0477002338,
-0.0197044294,
0.0285740476,
0.0745427236,
-0.0563783161,
0.0124226213,
-0.1093891785,
-0.0137836765,
0.0310451984,
0.0278298575,
-0.0464706384,
-0.0629923344,
0.0009753354,
-0.0352949351,
-0.0123377619,
-0.027168937,
-0.0145111475,
0.0148285916,
0.01742783,
0.0008477563,
-0.0157198105,
0.0359105803,
-0.0626838356,
0.0160655323,
0.0030899532,
0.0473299138,
0.0250072256,
-0.0205945149,
0.0330566205,
-0.0165340807,
-0.0405957513,
-0.0204781443,
0.0677068233,
-0.0352490693,
0.0064488789,
-0.0343303606,
-0.0013834594,
-0.0620462149,
-0.0116769616,
-0.0583997108,
0.1125196368,
0.0160905775,
-0.0375354439,
-0.0077263741,
-0.0323338583,
0.0234700572,
0.0460367426,
0.0284287706,
-0.0177974924,
-0.0675029382,
-0.0110972961,
0.0334665701,
-0.0501115546,
0.005161358,
0.0320846364,
-0.062581569,
0.0234186351,
-0.0611180514,
-0.0355797969,
0.0338961966,
-0.0088334782,
0.0032233854,
0.0217344835,
0.0079672374,
-0.0582666025,
-0.1024370939,
0.0207222514,
-0.0524007343,
0.0260055624,
0.0156372245,
-0.0377028696,
0.0662720725,
0.0009670908,
-0.0153384116,
0.0074053053,
-0.0364759751,
-0.0671660975,
-0.0521418639,
0.0285939798,
0.0029601159,
0.0657355785,
-0.0466068536,
-0.0240505654,
0.0223317631,
0.0098774992,
-0.0275307801,
-0.0076981103,
0.0278708991,
-0.0328077152,
-0.0060521206,
0.0505706333,
-0.0688779503,
0.0167961493,
0.0452561788,
0.0652026609,
0.0007842914,
-0.0534853563,
0.0025033453,
0.0389367417,
0.0410561301,
0.015085754,
0.0371860676,
-0.0451746695,
-0.0279004257,
0.0081349257,
-0.0386777595,
-0.0362567268,
0.0138879512,
0.0259454474,
-0.006095428,
-0.0170582812,
-0.0045714402,
0.0046090642,
0.071736984,
-0.0408789888,
-0.0079283789,
-0.0048461119,
-0.0144325262,
0.0057604499,
0.0084572369,
-0.0148484735,
-0.0018250919,
0.0215543061,
-0.0107764099,
-0.0111621348,
0.0117988084,
0.0310988426,
0.0189716797,
-0.0359936543,
0.0273561776,
-0.0167218558,
0.0311399978,
-0.026074199,
-0.0357070714,
0.0557855368,
0.0022609003,
0.0805858076,
0.0140722068,
-0.0158988219,
-0.0362647921,
0.0747694224,
-0.022547055,
-0.0343160257,
0.0456535593,
0.0250482541,
-0.0088573145,
0.0310378838,
0.0813575387,
0.0544610284,
0.0353315696,
0.0127565907,
-0.0641915798,
-0.0298365764,
-0.0069360235,
0.0076660211,
0.0309252776,
-0.0118657202,
0.0077998759,
-0.0099613145,
-0.0930225179,
0.0234992001,
-0.0221041329,
-0.007576745,
0.027535025,
0.0458624959,
0.010598314,
0.0240179002,
-0.0188442823,
-0.041847948,
0.0269836299,
0.0042561777,
-0.012617684,
-0.0147189917,
-5.976547928e-33,
-0.0047767116,
-0.0522752628,
-0.0046375613,
0.0088611962,
-0.0518260486,
0.0038831329,
-0.0465334654,
-0.0215987545,
-0.0243395381,
0.0346960872,
0.0037329213,
0.0017879985,
-0.0061384342,
0.0407722369,
-0.0231069867,
-0.031666752,
0.0281392429,
0.0174903665,
-0.0013553344,
0.0547917001,
0.0391097851,
0.0323183462,
0.0811794996,
-0.0997604504,
0.0036819908,
-0.0345245302,
0.0111097945,
0.008603069,
0.0753805786,
0.0420724936,
0.0020347473,
0.0505822338,
0.026580723,
-0.0141118225,
-0.0078962184,
-0.006218174,
-0.10269548,
-0.0360588692,
-0.0040368084,
0.0021714782,
-0.0470212847,
-0.0148412958,
0.0217889622,
-0.001965007,
0.0339920036,
-0.0469019897,
0.0681682304,
0.0086876862,
-0.0462344363,
-0.015931746,
-0.0286574885,
0.0522392839,
0.0027225213,
0.0091737155,
0.0127362777,
0.0144990319,
0.0206611045,
0.037944857,
-0.0536735468,
0.0095008072,
-0.0619352348,
-0.0171064865,
0.0208516885,
-0.0010658344,
0.0153418481,
0.0511274412,
-0.0062446571,
0.0056494493,
0.0113062998,
0.0051531252,
-0.009467735,
0.0725984424,
0.0262527391,
0.0209942888,
-0.0310936067,
0.0007991924,
-0.0772753581,
0.004875957,
0.004526888,
-0.0062393723,
-0.0113409581,
0.0498504192,
-0.0135409273,
-0.0578455441,
-0.014867885,
-0.0428753048,
-0.022012841,
-0.0577587895,
0.0192961004,
-0.0186979789,
-0.0301048588,
0.0729353204,
0.0142417094,
-0.060879454,
-0.0249968413,
0.0769623294,
-0.0053031552,
0.0277798995,
-0.0062325527,
0.0110555571,
-0.0612413138,
-0.0619336031,
0.0230136048,
-0.0363412313,
0.0159811992,
0.0121481121,
0.0720007345,
0.002528253,
-0.0420262627,
-0.0020986672,
-0.0239478741,
-0.0598874018,
-0.0275230743,
0.0206964575,
0.0355197079,
0.0666179806,
-0.0142466491,
0.0643083751,
0.0783236027,
0.0224236902,
-0.0280119199,
0.0133569567,
0.0066546835,
0.0179827753,
-0.0116435308,
-0.0227018856,
-0.0351311713,
0.0198776815,
0.0205422714,
-0.0532680564,
-0.0361138843,
-0.0058869282,
2.583e-7,
0.0575165823,
0.0216639601,
0.0385979004,
0.0083739478,
0.0121882213,
0.0647124648,
-0.010258887,
0.0728613883,
0.0079144714,
0.0016642965,
0.0163297988,
0.03311304,
-0.0110581405,
0.0168410074,
-0.0687935874,
0.0549105592,
-0.0617632046,
-0.0199813917,
-0.0163016487,
0.0076002171,
0.0229216497,
0.0547162332,
0.0645443797,
0.0066262153,
-0.0293647088,
-0.0714234933,
0.0848464668,
-0.0115385512,
0.0025692184,
0.0051363674,
-0.0434978455,
0.0012959476,
-0.0491673909,
0.0141949374,
-0.0313160755,
0.020937033,
0.0461657457,
0.0409681015,
-0.0342205502,
0.0072076623,
0.0025851261,
-0.0378778502,
0.0131368302,
-0.0216462929,
0.0635963231,
-0.0590601116,
-0.0417225063,
-0.0177248344,
-0.0596112311,
0.0073513477,
0.0130876098,
0.00852565,
-0.0135858143,
0.0169826727,
0.0209169257,
0.0027690798,
-0.0476590395,
-0.052237954,
0.0203725751,
0.0308189839,
-0.0098507116,
-0.0340868868,
-0.0021322847,
0.0702045113,
0.034509588,
-0.0757598206,
0.0519930646,
2.242689167e-34,
0.025637513,
-0.0038075799,
-0.0324597135,
0.0212352499,
0.0241621099,
-0.0652732551,
-0.050679177,
0.0036136003,
0.0454317033,
-0.0817555413,
-0.0003075111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12050v1 | Learn Beyond The Answer: Training Language Models with Reflection for Mathematical Reasoning | 2024-06-17T19:42:22 | 2024-06-17T19:42:22 | Zhihan Zhang, Zhenwen Liang, Wenhao Yu, Dian Yu, Mengzhao Jia, Dong Yu, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised fine-tuning enhances the problem-solving abilities of language
models across various mathematical reasoning tasks. To maximize such benefits,
existing research focuses on broadening the training set with various data
augmentation techniques, which is effective for standard single-round
question-answering settings. Our work introduces a novel technique aimed at
cultivating a deeper understanding of the training problems at hand, enhancing
performance not only in standard settings but also in more complex scenarios
that require reflective thinking. Specifically, we propose reflective
augmentation, a method that embeds problem reflection into each training
instance. It trains the model to consider alternative perspectives and engage
with abstractions and analogies, thereby fostering a thorough comprehension
through reflective reasoning. Extensive experiments validate the achievement of
our aim, underscoring the unique advantages of our method and its complementary
nature relative to existing augmentation techniques. | [
0.0286353379,
0.0596240796,
-0.0117647136,
0.0447061397,
-0.0278305728,
0.0082803601,
0.0060732742,
-0.0360474251,
-0.0731830522,
-0.0385977104,
-0.018686058,
0.0385059416,
-0.0427375734,
0.0239932742,
0.0313544199,
-0.052172415,
0.0270969234,
-0.0246636476,
0.0183490571,
-0.0176245123,
-0.0141842328,
-0.0168354847,
-0.0365526937,
0.0178544372,
-0.0274148192,
-0.0472714752,
0.0056690583,
-0.0296604428,
0.00861587,
-0.0239319857,
-0.0007760376,
0.0591671579,
0.0349778458,
0.0276894569,
0.000002135,
-0.025745526,
-0.0133809261,
-0.0125280963,
-0.0397440158,
-0.0060793492,
0.0135083226,
-0.0018274647,
0.0523928627,
0.0277861375,
-0.0876801014,
0.0140426476,
-0.0119886016,
0.0361500122,
0.0982697085,
0.0403180569,
0.0091212736,
-0.0291815437,
-0.0113953725,
-0.0062372368,
0.0374304987,
-0.0218994766,
0.0013954762,
0.0758530647,
-0.0175115801,
0.0452600792,
-0.0664361715,
0.0292338505,
0.0681688935,
-0.0224425364,
0.0210947674,
0.0288215149,
-0.0133499289,
0.0344657525,
0.0015547574,
0.0572658889,
0.0487554409,
-0.0428684466,
-0.0604995452,
0.0152321663,
0.0242548566,
0.0101066902,
-0.0632306635,
-0.0112605076,
0.0291438792,
0.01636279,
-0.0267516989,
0.0074119931,
0.0064555928,
0.0196759254,
-0.0109836692,
0.0687926486,
-0.0097248219,
-0.0419587642,
-0.0208071861,
0.0122950831,
-0.0328389518,
-0.0100351479,
-0.010045276,
0.0525835305,
0.0150437113,
0.0141037563,
-0.01010908,
-0.0642824844,
-0.0231062397,
0.050079681,
0.0848916918,
0.067694895,
0.0127337016,
0.0245843157,
-0.0253428835,
-0.0069854022,
0.015530928,
0.0446600765,
-0.0728298277,
-0.0208423231,
-0.0573649034,
-0.0402179472,
-0.0519745722,
0.0230602976,
-0.0213730223,
0.0085012931,
-0.0303931385,
0.0203867462,
-0.0088430541,
-0.0248341952,
-0.0307995453,
0.0384850316,
-0.0094238557,
-0.0268347785,
-0.0578569174,
0.0248615649,
-0.0641527697,
0.0339660347,
0.0142888827,
-0.029307913,
-0.0254209656,
-0.0122478558,
0.0056814686,
-0.0248923358,
0.018431643,
0.0722676367,
0.0014170962,
0.0010707512,
0.0216423627,
-0.0083927764,
0.0267809797,
-0.0294865426,
0.0108103976,
-0.0689054951,
0.0044153351,
-0.0122459754,
-0.022115238,
-0.0165345836,
0.0287778433,
0.0068977736,
0.0179498289,
0.0825971887,
-0.0452820174,
0.0044812807,
0.0494732074,
-0.0024551537,
-0.0455150381,
0.05186655,
0.0313942581,
-0.0695116743,
0.0043057124,
-0.0294242911,
0.0335454829,
-0.017873399,
0.0345147587,
-0.0112816468,
-0.0291842092,
0.04077648,
-0.0232788417,
0.039108865,
0.0021810313,
0.0047024558,
-0.0499472879,
0.0092161782,
0.0262786616,
0.0534836091,
-0.0246732514,
0.0627845004,
0.0089330683,
0.007159133,
0.0204241052,
-0.005067979,
-0.0539089181,
0.0562161729,
0.0226587392,
0.0083352672,
-0.0146127827,
-0.0158037804,
-0.0172288623,
-0.0782962367,
0.0044679269,
0.0157020036,
0.0149004115,
0.0439737402,
0.0404128432,
0.0403848402,
0.0231472999,
0.0385292359,
0.0104267215,
-0.0485275723,
-0.0136766387,
-0.0620950051,
0.0243864246,
0.0297558513,
0.0427883491,
-0.0582591631,
-0.0608331524,
-0.0395842679,
0.0394290909,
0.0087285424,
0.0729902089,
0.0051396121,
-0.0231853575,
-0.0345526971,
-0.0226935539,
-0.042182114,
0.0227903724,
-0.0001729189,
0.0226984005,
-0.0093002822,
0.0230180994,
-0.0173978079,
-0.0373277068,
0.0444815233,
-0.0244879518,
-0.0550318658,
0.010470544,
0.0056115431,
-0.0361464657,
0.0021279061,
0.0065865465,
0.064438276,
0.0192343686,
-0.0406507291,
-0.0401542932,
0.0450742431,
-0.040136978,
-0.0643110573,
0.0549628399,
-0.1048291102,
-0.0223822296,
0.0208863635,
-0.0406851098,
-0.046411451,
0.0480027907,
-0.0445853472,
0.0411796793,
-0.0437771864,
-0.0124636935,
-0.0374352075,
-0.0033851415,
-0.0348797031,
0.0552150458,
0.0231025219,
0.0256500449,
0.00577997,
-0.0164690819,
0.0209001284,
-0.0137749547,
0.0149152093,
-0.0642431378,
-0.0089544207,
0.0174323432,
-0.0014304474,
0.0103485705,
-0.0750543997,
-0.0026100182,
-0.0381498821,
-0.0391854495,
-0.0170564242,
0.0264815651,
0.02673137,
-0.0219165999,
-0.0132113444,
-0.0659814179,
-0.0371148624,
-0.0093728201,
-0.0093620289,
0.014579338,
0.0515458472,
0.0084501915,
0.0108824456,
-0.0273377616,
-0.0215427913,
-0.0299564414,
0.0333971567,
0.0047184136,
0.0904247686,
-0.0352217481,
-0.0189388301,
-0.0491687842,
0.0088389404,
-0.0090736691,
-0.0191395991,
0.0429883376,
-0.0237782523,
-0.0138882985,
0.0551690385,
0.0221129619,
0.008036552,
0.0365052409,
0.019444691,
-0.0723734796,
0.0311516598,
-0.0154243205,
0.0121545447,
0.0007324302,
-0.0143157449,
-0.0256230161,
0.0473641977,
-0.0366772227,
-0.0134527646,
-0.0451608375,
0.084282212,
-0.0066780867,
-0.0555587746,
-0.0520402715,
-0.0017795836,
0.0009153798,
0.0300808344,
-0.0184116308,
-0.0145245763,
0.0875516385,
0.0077939411,
-0.0227427874,
-0.0755244717,
0.0093916776,
-0.0534668639,
0.0363194458,
-0.0072927033,
-0.0098510673,
-0.0068877526,
0.0175907649,
-0.037467584,
0.0026129491,
0.0601254553,
-0.0216102954,
0.0587341003,
-0.025578253,
-0.0263759121,
0.0024415143,
-0.0558654591,
-0.0572142936,
-0.0297723096,
-0.0236779898,
0.0075351931,
-0.0466863215,
0.0050220578,
-0.0203941427,
-0.0343918167,
0.0272043627,
0.0260637514,
-0.0421329439,
-0.0359439924,
-0.0171750132,
-0.0423775166,
0.0784817487,
0.0462312028,
0.0729939267,
-0.0239444841,
0.0699810907,
0.0199990422,
0.0996142551,
-0.004713173,
-0.0235336442,
-0.0034595423,
-0.0172129385,
-0.0101603912,
0.0164246559,
-0.009101294,
0.0399264283,
-0.0628688931,
-0.0441669486,
0.098855488,
0.0517627709,
-0.0110909147,
0.0117433695,
-0.104031764,
0.0467469394,
0.0741027519,
0.0452478155,
-0.05436204,
-0.037164893,
0.0070694387,
0.0174510721,
0.0097941272,
-0.0461092182,
-0.0098653995,
-0.1311301738,
0.0024450531,
-0.0109560555,
-0.0229777079,
0.0002265263,
0.014319011,
0.0019992997,
0.0254166089,
0.0020636048,
-0.0039017973,
-0.019777542,
0.0385374539,
0.0496512689,
0.005588423,
0.0001435208,
0.0061814664,
-0.0085178958,
-0.0055935839,
0.0083492342,
0.0053727538,
-0.0207288656,
-0.0200701635,
0.0214348212,
0.0297585651,
0.0098626483,
0.0079508033,
0.0455518477,
-0.0173290279,
-0.0028702477,
0.010827573,
0.0623772927,
-0.0705364868,
-0.0138484314,
0.0413944386,
0.0866315812,
-0.0198204573,
0.0367371999,
-0.0252885744,
0.0131842066,
-0.0266695749,
0.0522772335,
0.0670276433,
-0.0264061447,
-0.0022426348,
-0.0567485653,
-0.0059692301,
-0.0549050309,
-0.0139503162,
0.0273954719,
0.0646999478,
0.0584342368,
-0.0468727984,
-0.0636975244,
0.0455893725,
0.0289068576,
0.0028574218,
-0.0215624273,
-0.0326515287,
-0.0156484228,
-0.0290250648,
0.0319490954,
-0.0358325653,
0.0243814141,
0.0381049551,
0.0134397512,
0.0059357784,
-0.0320646651,
-0.0470307209,
-0.0544593595,
-0.0686845854,
-0.038321659,
-0.0044586626,
0.0623595603,
0.0207203198,
0.0487246662,
-0.0367938541,
-0.0247726142,
0.0161431637,
-0.0094332462,
-0.0405870005,
-0.0080691464,
0.0582771711,
-0.0067545958,
0.0314887129,
0.0430417992,
-0.0001327111,
0.0047488599,
0.017189879,
0.0388752557,
-0.0172520727,
-0.0130028958,
0.0412331149,
-0.0087943729,
0.0193986241,
0.0394871011,
-0.0065798964,
-0.0181582253,
0.0490947217,
-0.0461049341,
-0.030947838,
-0.0242952425,
0.0210519601,
0.0070644603,
-0.0410727672,
0.0118322484,
-0.0289508868,
0.0030139072,
0.0421370082,
-0.0117790075,
0.0604411513,
0.028320903,
-0.00740817,
-0.0212491974,
-0.0072621568,
-0.0059111137,
0.0002468883,
0.0133713419,
0.0385562815,
-0.000681983,
0.0612006299,
0.0435212664,
-0.0131443124,
-0.0324300304,
-0.0086256936,
-0.1027263552,
-0.0590936281,
0.0202868152,
0.0545997545,
0.0248682573,
0.0011731893,
0.0041926969,
-0.0012890319,
0.0023364981,
0.0396177471,
0.0241058692,
-0.0014463323,
-0.0336171985,
0.0475219712,
0.0345983244,
0.006497622,
-0.0393510349,
0.0358577669,
-0.0419709347,
0.0521152914,
-0.0070624733,
0.016020136,
-0.0247335043,
0.0044064675,
-0.0141461352,
0.0207386538,
0.0064408784,
0.0601780042,
-0.0587525778,
-0.1001953334,
-0.0349144265,
0.0288826507,
-0.0182620883,
-0.0284159258,
0.0329159684,
0.0501950383,
-0.0131160729,
-0.0518387556,
-0.0261379704,
0.0682724491,
-0.0199503694,
-0.0074805245,
-0.0209467206,
-5.798878569e-33,
0.0049694176,
-0.0242361687,
0.0318909921,
0.0119123766,
-0.0213717967,
-0.0165756047,
-0.0342974514,
0.0207334887,
-0.0197734293,
0.0361128114,
-0.0332622118,
0.0357099287,
0.0014662337,
0.0274310615,
0.0177693851,
-0.0035139257,
0.0052118539,
-0.0188486855,
-0.0384107381,
-0.0298951343,
-0.0028824701,
0.0230671186,
0.060509,
-0.0279438235,
0.0045309556,
0.0053786952,
0.0027188347,
0.0401992239,
-0.0287567861,
0.0793515146,
-0.0001691409,
0.0070961849,
0.0255099628,
-0.0402220711,
-0.0214382969,
0.011732582,
-0.0678133294,
-0.0594401062,
0.0038127766,
0.0112702465,
-0.0750078112,
-0.0181153174,
0.0210226327,
-0.0036965117,
0.0155660911,
-0.0199969988,
0.027652489,
-0.0387337245,
-0.0015411414,
0.0468632318,
-0.0491660722,
-0.0024410973,
-0.0349984579,
-0.02813158,
0.0243701059,
0.052058734,
0.0026504323,
-0.0228982437,
-0.0072066165,
0.0138378907,
0.030545732,
0.0128488503,
0.0481163412,
0.0086532226,
-0.0013020311,
0.0388034843,
-0.0074519929,
-0.0242164154,
-0.015944289,
0.0014366047,
0.0217802692,
0.0145318629,
0.0743130744,
0.0456962585,
0.0562377386,
0.0059189429,
-0.0407883599,
0.00036634,
-0.012354264,
0.0300132614,
0.0405205637,
-0.0021148187,
-0.0067647919,
0.0144053549,
-0.1071612835,
0.0276375338,
-0.0432878882,
-0.0236103702,
0.0266416743,
0.0065218345,
-0.0813813955,
0.0013469238,
0.004011916,
-0.0511614345,
-0.0234497096,
-0.0009159521,
-0.0201681256,
-0.0010585344,
-0.0040941732,
0.0286637377,
-0.0354640409,
0.0090708537,
0.0269164834,
0.0346196368,
0.0153848957,
0.0057248659,
0.0884243101,
-0.0107843652,
-0.0418522656,
-0.0090400185,
-0.0547199547,
0.0017000652,
0.0191895571,
0.0477963537,
-0.0074123344,
0.0690472499,
-0.0283564404,
0.0044394666,
0.0039344472,
0.0048738159,
-0.0584889092,
0.0036918335,
0.0061518224,
0.0216716006,
-0.0168513786,
-0.0280105043,
-0.0332198851,
-0.0226291548,
0.0427182987,
-0.0502698459,
-0.0197519213,
0.0490680411,
2.645e-7,
0.0713475943,
0.0382438861,
0.0241552517,
0.0039581317,
0.0309973545,
0.0636308938,
-0.0195366684,
-0.0082411878,
0.0600046702,
-0.0168410577,
0.00244922,
0.0496472009,
0.0368910246,
0.016370371,
-0.0602928139,
-0.0436433852,
-0.0661715195,
-0.0045549804,
-0.0072087389,
-0.0104875304,
0.0616810508,
0.0917320326,
0.0215950012,
-0.0090307202,
-0.0199877564,
-0.0150963999,
0.068016842,
-0.0211041868,
0.0003199377,
0.0142612336,
-0.0124053098,
0.0074804905,
0.0263497699,
0.0105220061,
-0.0147778979,
0.0230410285,
-0.0006633478,
0.0137957484,
-0.0129245985,
-0.0080063017,
-0.0357432365,
0.0225187503,
0.0031402246,
-0.0406175032,
0.0487962402,
-0.0836718231,
-0.0269319229,
-0.0337980501,
-0.0028822566,
0.0026801394,
0.049490042,
-0.0268587861,
-0.0242189635,
0.0258900337,
0.0248811096,
-0.0063841389,
0.0077551031,
-0.0609064028,
-0.0420893468,
-0.033480078,
-0.0274380036,
0.0106800487,
-0.0431056805,
-0.011302554,
0.0071679945,
-0.0343773887,
-0.0070660547,
2.392576406e-34,
0.0313011892,
0.0002394723,
0.0229540356,
0.060054265,
0.0455634296,
-0.0023715708,
-0.0112073496,
0.0011791089,
0.0339067169,
-0.0713334382,
-0.035477072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12045v1 | $τ$-bench: A Benchmark for Tool-Agent-User Interaction in Real-World Domains | 2024-06-17T19:33:08 | 2024-06-17T19:33:08 | Shunyu Yao, Noah Shinn, Pedram Razavi, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing benchmarks do not test language agents on their interaction with
human users or ability to follow domain-specific rules, both of which are vital
for deploying them in real world applications. We propose $\tau$-bench, a
benchmark emulating dynamic conversations between a user (simulated by language
models) and a language agent provided with domain-specific API tools and policy
guidelines. We employ an efficient and faithful evaluation process that
compares the database state at the end of a conversation with the annotated
goal state. We also propose a new metric (pass^k) to evaluate the reliability
of agent behavior over multiple trials. Our experiments show that even
state-of-the-art function calling agents (like gpt-4o) succeed on <50% of the
tasks, and are quite inconsistent (pass^8 <25% in retail). Our findings point
to the need for methods that can improve the ability of agents to act
consistently and follow rules reliably. | [
0.0400351547,
0.0468625501,
-0.0292264614,
0.0132316155,
-0.0375255495,
-0.017503839,
-0.0087135127,
0.0025460629,
0.0228979755,
-0.0219804533,
0.0248389393,
-0.0222207364,
0.0030512067,
0.051314339,
-0.0212490689,
-0.056175679,
0.0261137858,
-0.0066098394,
0.0218251515,
0.0261161514,
0.0086683929,
-0.0196940359,
-0.0130864158,
0.0858806297,
-0.0166357886,
-0.024546992,
-0.0118610766,
-0.0058018379,
-0.0066042924,
0.0121540288,
0.0189954061,
0.0112288119,
-0.0108822389,
0.0434284881,
0.000002255,
-0.0759448484,
0.0088161603,
0.0163065009,
-0.0389636867,
-0.0240628682,
0.0351166576,
0.0191736668,
-0.0412007347,
0.0329927579,
-0.0601417869,
0.0261566937,
0.0522584766,
-0.0161601324,
0.0406524502,
0.054981444,
-0.0017065272,
0.071390301,
-0.0218069479,
0.0129352463,
-0.0386029445,
-0.0995753109,
-0.0074621788,
0.0340203755,
0.0219752081,
-0.0551439747,
0.0157086886,
-0.0210399441,
0.0384685695,
-0.0150420191,
-0.0484412089,
0.0031268515,
-0.0508157425,
-0.0204517636,
-0.0157491695,
0.0348335318,
0.0030927761,
-0.0051003117,
0.0147507647,
0.0100111803,
0.0043358416,
0.0103973672,
-0.0077099786,
-0.0053812084,
-0.0146368379,
-0.0382402837,
-0.0165528674,
0.0117701096,
0.0202522688,
-0.0081633134,
-0.0118062124,
0.0882462114,
-0.0030476414,
-0.0124724256,
0.005950545,
-0.015554795,
0.037893977,
-0.0595876053,
-0.0019791757,
0.0435268134,
-0.0831218511,
0.0207344759,
-0.0063042082,
0.0329201557,
0.0267822053,
-0.0626929477,
0.0205410328,
0.0743962377,
-0.006894893,
0.0205213018,
0.0150296483,
0.0747195408,
0.0417939946,
-0.0136777461,
-0.0017947118,
-0.0027802323,
-0.0645574182,
0.0142483404,
-0.0191189107,
0.0097428253,
-0.018047642,
-0.0268804878,
-0.0370419137,
0.0769867375,
-0.0364537239,
0.0728473887,
-0.0292590484,
-0.03533829,
-0.0390624478,
-0.0060158651,
-0.0735553652,
-0.0064406148,
-0.0710228533,
0.0016964877,
0.0120464796,
-0.0821158513,
0.0059337742,
-0.0225656033,
-0.0298730209,
0.0014623345,
-0.0150875626,
0.0972001255,
0.0119775506,
0.0119094299,
-0.038000457,
-0.0696301535,
0.0588902198,
-0.0896231979,
-0.0690065846,
-0.0557307191,
0.0222049542,
0.0263405982,
-0.0315461829,
-0.069803305,
-0.0146393208,
-0.0040673194,
0.0344757661,
0.0543239973,
-0.0092164725,
0.0120660327,
0.0024365927,
0.0278504379,
-0.0477130227,
0.0587430149,
0.0055107088,
0.0240806695,
0.0522087365,
0.0071994239,
0.0400564037,
0.0339020528,
-0.0400485918,
0.0101450253,
0.0200933274,
0.0307063833,
0.0298092607,
0.0300920419,
0.00407711,
0.0220069326,
-0.0153723275,
0.0017720516,
0.0581404269,
0.0596708357,
-0.018639354,
-0.027419582,
0.0505449325,
0.0282383431,
0.0130388523,
0.0067973998,
-0.0480093025,
-0.0304271374,
-0.0083351387,
0.013408565,
-0.0172880571,
0.0083367983,
-0.0253958106,
-0.0347361043,
0.0380544513,
-0.0193204656,
0.023813365,
-0.0021837016,
0.0221156981,
-0.0027622946,
-0.0292724855,
0.0101103801,
-0.0153923864,
-0.0158635918,
-0.0540107153,
-0.0735061467,
-0.0347694643,
0.1017011702,
0.0661922097,
-0.0351993032,
-0.0604348853,
0.0065071909,
0.0127258683,
0.0450526811,
0.0521605238,
-0.0299290437,
0.0167802796,
-0.0060814791,
-0.0370838791,
0.0217012055,
0.0276913121,
0.0648138523,
0.0176168587,
0.044001624,
0.0073753586,
-0.0576864369,
-0.0225920286,
0.0202766303,
-0.0001704786,
-0.0371067785,
-0.0052558128,
0.0063928929,
0.035191156,
0.0120058134,
-0.0142320544,
-0.0161095224,
-0.0019336907,
0.0310670063,
0.0168495234,
0.0491349213,
-0.0122506302,
0.0473415963,
0.0513555557,
0.0142497467,
-0.007899208,
0.056486994,
0.0044721733,
-0.0278942659,
0.0291409343,
-0.0193981659,
0.0481150635,
-0.0038995023,
0.0412569679,
-0.0340122916,
-0.0108570596,
0.0041829399,
0.0058810906,
0.02658269,
-0.0124231586,
-0.0221274402,
0.0190498587,
0.0150961857,
-0.0190283451,
0.0132473782,
0.0582631975,
-0.0028845547,
0.0572530925,
0.0282923765,
0.0166252814,
-0.020866992,
0.0272194874,
-0.0894802809,
0.0033203543,
-0.0357632041,
0.0067221853,
-0.0093916617,
0.0262145866,
-0.0033942687,
-0.0478685573,
-0.0389720351,
0.0280121621,
0.02039285,
0.0367102288,
0.0201049317,
0.0252487566,
-0.0835412666,
-0.0471176766,
0.0298389327,
-0.0076885177,
0.0059487186,
-0.0005208257,
0.0217771828,
-0.0591739006,
0.0018746032,
-0.0357616842,
0.0227748845,
-0.0268784892,
-0.0223714262,
0.0400394797,
0.0154708205,
-0.0010077517,
0.0407885425,
-0.0272967648,
0.0290453061,
0.0327858217,
0.0021897871,
-0.0846819058,
-0.0146264564,
-0.0052028168,
-0.0123176733,
-0.0414391868,
-0.0113437446,
0.0537131801,
0.0266433973,
-0.020765176,
0.0137425652,
-0.0462514758,
0.0024409071,
-0.0021463772,
-0.0444971509,
-0.0114833191,
-0.0017801765,
-0.0389273874,
0.0642300248,
0.0232500359,
-0.0640293136,
0.0657839999,
-0.0030418406,
-0.006850678,
-0.0233036168,
-0.0510197654,
-0.0104341134,
0.0775453895,
0.007030752,
0.0078453692,
-0.0160106011,
-0.0264866762,
-0.0077478047,
-0.0274263471,
0.0231469739,
-0.0400169045,
0.0395706221,
-0.0889885426,
0.0036693271,
0.001487455,
-0.0494465977,
-0.0201741904,
0.0038935209,
-0.0360857546,
0.0029381458,
-0.0068402281,
-0.0363201723,
-0.0108679738,
-0.0061188252,
0.0063878139,
0.077878803,
0.0033405963,
-0.0451996252,
0.0017225241,
-0.0723998472,
0.030004086,
0.022359971,
-0.0309564397,
0.010690216,
0.045769725,
0.036130093,
0.0466610938,
-0.0390159562,
-0.0665728301,
-0.0347182043,
-0.0076846173,
-0.0408818349,
0.0136215119,
0.0721535534,
0.0036392924,
-0.0706455782,
-0.0158698969,
0.0681335926,
0.0328071639,
-0.0299995225,
0.0215634275,
-0.0378306583,
0.0287682787,
0.0212530885,
0.0667025596,
-0.1029840037,
-0.0192957819,
0.011545876,
0.049625352,
-0.0270258319,
-0.0350654908,
-0.0011455734,
-0.0977670029,
0.0202081744,
-0.0330037214,
-0.0098089138,
0.0171213243,
-0.0529487208,
0.0210049953,
-0.0073765283,
0.0569908731,
0.0141459582,
0.0404825658,
-0.0311399568,
-0.0070199152,
-0.0373053029,
-0.0603640638,
0.0521969013,
-0.0457283482,
0.0571266264,
0.1017888039,
0.0358316824,
0.0250195451,
-0.0129265795,
0.0330821015,
0.0594350919,
0.0051850388,
0.0084023336,
0.0270210672,
0.0182583816,
0.0049372115,
0.0165071841,
0.0048635881,
-0.0485573635,
0.0121099036,
0.0350001119,
0.0512838662,
-0.0386964977,
0.0093924263,
-0.0099195568,
-0.0137716215,
0.0456654765,
0.0507816114,
-0.0006127783,
-0.0518461987,
-0.0752096474,
-0.0612306558,
-0.0247479435,
-0.0534388013,
-0.0369072221,
-0.0138687342,
-0.0097663542,
-0.0228694715,
-0.0519064032,
-0.0964233503,
0.0288223252,
0.0272436664,
0.0152648725,
-0.0059001856,
-0.0010479717,
0.0363469347,
-0.0040410361,
-0.0184323844,
-0.0341442078,
0.061755795,
-0.0306119937,
0.0152348997,
-0.0222459529,
-0.0097504659,
-0.0000275039,
0.0149819655,
0.0139074307,
-0.0657432228,
0.0424458198,
0.0658935905,
0.0384446196,
0.0096942838,
-0.0262697451,
-0.0055639604,
-0.0539184026,
0.040941637,
-0.0483583286,
-0.0197653454,
0.0334841013,
-0.0156244356,
0.0006302837,
0.0247447789,
-0.0886137858,
-0.0064674481,
-0.0440155268,
0.019019695,
-0.0435943641,
-0.033812698,
0.0187596604,
0.0177291129,
-0.0334155299,
0.0179776549,
-0.0248377882,
0.0283737872,
0.0200509802,
-0.0089156395,
-0.017699426,
-0.0304392632,
0.001575987,
-0.0324266702,
0.0117322868,
0.0575286783,
0.0094479937,
-0.0337520875,
0.0016368555,
0.0249602795,
-0.0209174249,
-0.0117790746,
0.0439448506,
0.0265387669,
-0.0022595038,
-0.0169298984,
0.0018168206,
0.0381879508,
0.063706398,
-0.0111142835,
0.0359223112,
0.0281995405,
0.0023223667,
0.0027331407,
0.0185953025,
-0.0499248952,
-0.05320324,
0.0391508043,
-0.0210024025,
0.0203674175,
-0.0084441202,
0.045667015,
-0.064150773,
0.0289840326,
-0.0304257181,
-0.0087430999,
0.007602958,
0.0003042134,
-0.0324564166,
0.0118978359,
-0.0052389205,
-0.0003142082,
0.0559343249,
-0.0265296344,
0.0197483134,
-0.029663099,
-0.0446265712,
-0.0708751902,
-0.03865318,
0.0112700937,
-0.0044153938,
-0.027800085,
-0.077218093,
-0.0742017701,
-0.0169442948,
-0.0485216118,
0.0485760607,
-0.0024249784,
-0.0449687988,
0.0188380796,
0.0717236102,
0.035971418,
0.0214352291,
-0.0551240593,
-0.0478912406,
-0.0449996591,
0.0175799485,
-0.0265993904,
-5.731675924e-33,
-0.0060975282,
-0.0405093096,
0.059359204,
0.0300351381,
0.0071409186,
-0.0615915842,
-0.0531103238,
0.0046576015,
0.0072276685,
0.0053742328,
-0.0233708061,
0.0068734461,
0.0367714986,
-0.0328385979,
0.0183967873,
0.0336767435,
0.0305473749,
0.0115942219,
-0.0461077057,
0.0212034881,
0.0297482144,
-0.013398,
0.0027207197,
-0.0868039429,
0.0578473136,
0.0341231711,
0.0054971441,
0.0041710827,
0.003048474,
0.0446799807,
0.0135487383,
0.046185676,
0.011479754,
-0.0252417494,
-0.0125399958,
-0.0097302189,
-0.0077744983,
-0.0333275832,
0.0151918521,
0.0387022346,
-0.0137580261,
-0.0061400672,
0.0093955686,
-0.0112115853,
-0.0656049252,
0.040527232,
0.0146822827,
-0.0118620824,
-0.0151099227,
0.0076713101,
-0.1071600094,
0.0213689264,
0.0011792557,
-0.0256148055,
0.0031901973,
0.0407548435,
-0.0069322255,
-0.0587823913,
-0.0389825702,
-0.0071700998,
0.0009786272,
-0.0092385234,
0.0529126935,
0.0184938107,
-0.0125871589,
0.042446129,
0.0132783866,
0.0580327511,
0.0123689305,
-0.0026299255,
0.0203384422,
0.0619621389,
-0.0017163934,
0.0411543436,
-0.018100759,
-0.0263712294,
0.0114522083,
0.0911102816,
0.0525863729,
0.0036894332,
0.0186533816,
0.0059460723,
-0.0968188271,
-0.0129333455,
-0.0091838734,
0.060462065,
-0.030314669,
-0.0743670464,
0.0465367921,
0.0076310956,
0.026024228,
-0.0155218421,
0.0074942843,
-0.0125389323,
-0.0116313901,
-0.0246668588,
-0.058718361,
-0.0229165219,
0.0198968593,
0.0113471076,
-0.0153552536,
0.0040145251,
-0.0458945818,
0.0505616926,
0.0612849481,
0.0064632026,
-0.0080110533,
0.0457268246,
-0.0636508763,
0.0246901605,
-0.0508440435,
0.0410006568,
-0.0026734001,
0.0029396748,
0.0344050862,
-0.0351967104,
-0.0059134294,
0.042467922,
-0.0189639032,
-0.0700115338,
-0.0458816327,
0.0286742821,
0.0136628272,
-0.0110956775,
-0.0654623657,
-0.020729946,
-0.0557525083,
0.0490771979,
0.0486517809,
-0.0111518493,
-0.0067716455,
-0.0314139165,
2.959e-7,
-0.0115124295,
0.0211532004,
0.0110067986,
0.0863821805,
-0.0013096507,
0.0610493422,
-0.0349255428,
0.0271927211,
0.0030930636,
0.00011797,
0.0064714085,
-0.0059305867,
0.0395139903,
0.057251703,
-0.049570553,
-0.0178011227,
0.0137792733,
-0.0112361666,
-0.0695550814,
-0.00869139,
0.004115738,
0.028923953,
0.0098688798,
-0.0230739117,
0.0378063433,
-0.0549117662,
-0.0010912548,
-0.0472563133,
-0.0069488613,
0.0079619233,
0.0109482855,
0.0346424356,
0.0294581,
0.0170817208,
0.0009172593,
0.0123784067,
-0.0416523814,
0.1022561416,
-0.0047421479,
-0.0010140321,
-0.0026812109,
-0.0657447428,
0.0208471846,
-0.0105134863,
-0.0017714753,
0.0045534978,
-0.0210961141,
0.012170285,
0.0063164751,
-0.021739075,
-0.0171105769,
-0.015985528,
-0.026076464,
0.0075982823,
0.0028063718,
0.012770324,
0.02636455,
-0.0073863384,
-0.0148486719,
0.0174183846,
-0.0199872907,
-0.0658246726,
-0.0307516735,
0.0177466217,
-0.0307217203,
-0.0434081033,
0.0132962521,
2.681925948e-34,
0.024758473,
0.0201996025,
0.0447446927,
0.0491035394,
0.0537955984,
0.0444856733,
0.0292810369,
0.0301655866,
0.0633756146,
-0.0018677141,
-0.0161219165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12038v1 | Soft Prompting for Unlearning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T19:11:40 | 2024-06-17T19:11:40 | Karuna Bhaila, Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The widespread popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), partly due to
their unique ability to perform in-context learning, has also brought to light
the importance of ethical and safety considerations when deploying these
pre-trained models. In this work, we focus on investigating machine unlearning
for LLMs motivated by data protection regulations. In contrast to the growing
literature on fine-tuning methods to achieve unlearning, we focus on a
comparatively lightweight alternative called soft prompting to realize the
unlearning of a subset of training data. With losses designed to enforce
forgetting as well as utility preservation, our framework \textbf{S}oft
\textbf{P}rompting for \textbf{U}n\textbf{l}earning (SPUL) learns prompt tokens
that can be appended to an arbitrary query to induce unlearning of specific
examples at inference time without updating LLM parameters. We conduct a
rigorous evaluation of the proposed method and our results indicate that SPUL
can significantly improve the trade-off between utility and forgetting in the
context of text classification with LLMs. We further validate our method using
multiple LLMs to highlight the scalability of our framework and provide
detailed insights into the choice of hyperparameters and the influence of the
size of unlearning data. Our implementation is available at
\url{https://github.com/karuna-bhaila/llm_unlearning}. | [
0.0157363899,
0.0936983675,
0.016565999,
0.0298912991,
-0.0404518247,
0.0244909823,
0.0328247957,
0.0055360887,
0.0243580956,
-0.0485326983,
-0.0483752452,
-0.0127215795,
-0.0301992018,
0.0051104105,
0.0037741647,
0.0009639205,
0.0415590592,
-0.019633051,
0.0237401575,
-0.0248472411,
0.0001089415,
0.02817709,
0.0158498231,
-0.0286736153,
0.0104194349,
-0.0449748784,
-0.0072348709,
-0.0101421326,
-0.0179111939,
-0.0209802911,
0.0472903848,
0.0471032783,
0.0349395089,
0.0509472452,
0.0000021627,
-0.0639978051,
-0.0619084425,
0.01587818,
-0.0694899783,
0.0436800979,
0.0441555679,
-0.0018164178,
0.0311572626,
0.0234433021,
-0.0344672762,
-0.0063731642,
0.0433399566,
0.0430762917,
0.0329677984,
0.0906044319,
0.010014235,
-0.0034487159,
0.0006469109,
-0.0462984368,
0.0051462995,
-0.0432718694,
0.0444468781,
-0.1036374271,
-0.0449454375,
0.0114604076,
0.0015834606,
0.0385976955,
0.0239326544,
0.0181057658,
-0.0203457363,
0.0483349301,
-0.0445562713,
-0.0110242274,
-0.0236026458,
0.0503397398,
-0.0005812898,
-0.0402964465,
0.0390518308,
-0.0027193029,
0.010260148,
-0.0006947606,
-0.0418449491,
0.0379134193,
-0.0062070214,
0.0173577499,
0.0144416289,
-0.0144709097,
0.0639683381,
0.0375674143,
0.006209584,
0.0275943689,
0.0163590014,
-0.0236217696,
0.0317304805,
-0.027600335,
-0.0227468554,
-0.0207169298,
0.0024147613,
0.0230004042,
-0.0273215566,
0.0308146831,
-0.0211168379,
-0.001617954,
0.049736537,
-0.0262176488,
0.0324399881,
-0.0230313838,
-0.0082661258,
0.0683901981,
-0.0272597186,
-0.0030787573,
0.0203353316,
0.0629718676,
-0.0065681082,
0.0346718878,
-0.0198520981,
-0.0260685179,
-0.0247340817,
0.0525470786,
0.0029002489,
0.0401319712,
-0.0205442365,
0.020269705,
-0.0358936414,
0.029222751,
-0.0025930475,
-0.0096210837,
-0.0293123517,
0.0027094721,
-0.0279818755,
-0.0202038642,
-0.0016077538,
0.0243858695,
0.000962784,
-0.0771120265,
-0.039838057,
-0.0173576847,
0.0059091039,
-0.0152380308,
0.0421073474,
0.0858621225,
-0.0010814293,
-0.0646105856,
-0.0646195933,
-0.0318943933,
-0.0067747287,
-0.0695010573,
0.0023583865,
-0.0518015213,
0.0168765746,
-0.0278907027,
-0.0097688055,
-0.0564622506,
0.0000409972,
0.0362669416,
-0.0305359885,
0.0555134788,
0.0055360897,
-0.0217185207,
-0.0033169887,
0.0038116237,
-0.0137060862,
0.0472910069,
-0.0475872867,
0.0429488048,
0.0715902597,
0.0047892397,
0.0396540202,
0.0286908653,
0.0634185076,
0.0257845782,
-0.0289806556,
0.0087249652,
0.0573686063,
-0.01831639,
-0.0085926913,
0.0487068146,
-0.0228442512,
-0.0357029475,
0.047301311,
0.0300247911,
0.0064071487,
0.0300287977,
-0.0029317762,
-0.0001818198,
0.0020723231,
0.0041228049,
-0.061572127,
-0.0166707933,
-0.0571036823,
-0.0194544215,
0.0011948353,
0.006470744,
-0.0471685342,
-0.0446492992,
0.0295666661,
-0.0496781245,
0.0229814816,
0.0637707561,
0.0584143773,
0.0385150537,
-0.0129357986,
0.0466990247,
0.0622978434,
-0.0400183089,
0.0133517943,
-0.0488833077,
0.0663711429,
0.0304381084,
0.0584180392,
-0.0828892067,
0.0124907224,
-0.0275250692,
0.0264689997,
-0.0318297148,
0.0322367549,
-0.0265244916,
0.0587882474,
-0.0575881824,
-0.0242021941,
0.011340783,
0.0264549218,
0.0118495459,
0.0195626672,
-0.0246453714,
0.0259758681,
-0.0431958623,
-0.0506821349,
0.038388785,
-0.0368946083,
-0.0867435113,
0.0174900424,
0.0114434268,
0.0356240347,
0.0075315558,
-0.0084394878,
-0.0068496238,
0.0464152694,
0.0059482753,
-0.0013723541,
-0.0634597689,
-0.0468091704,
-0.0292653386,
0.0218091533,
0.0242523495,
-0.0009402001,
0.0284936838,
-0.0531036519,
-0.0035940611,
-0.0281867292,
0.0135606816,
0.033435598,
-0.0638730526,
0.0177355018,
-0.0368206613,
-0.0034480502,
-0.0544090495,
0.0597512498,
0.0047496115,
0.0079089664,
-0.0122216195,
-0.031863194,
-0.0192443989,
-0.0385710821,
-0.0530908071,
0.013934317,
-0.0147669017,
0.0384420864,
0.0198814273,
0.0230120737,
-0.0445847064,
-0.0153161203,
-0.0608717911,
0.0083247414,
-0.031992577,
0.0052848873,
-0.0121886255,
0.017862685,
-0.0299815517,
-0.0446559973,
-0.0404562838,
-0.0506693721,
-0.0265642423,
0.0342763215,
0.0097706011,
-0.0120338388,
-0.0027209413,
0.0227248669,
-0.0177345928,
0.0119056823,
0.0596659407,
-0.027233256,
-0.0060161608,
-0.0171614159,
0.0618205592,
-0.0349918567,
0.0169476103,
-0.0019947405,
0.0124318246,
-0.0227908269,
-0.0195632465,
-0.0233473759,
0.0682287216,
0.0075266212,
0.0328866355,
0.0512211211,
0.0315856934,
-0.0462947823,
0.0161718354,
-0.0638255551,
-0.0425564311,
-0.0058360766,
0.0264391992,
0.03513797,
-0.0061341398,
-0.0064807972,
-0.0229912456,
-0.0025461121,
0.0315170549,
-0.000061131,
-0.0315389596,
-0.0474841334,
0.0103757111,
-0.0210721754,
0.0170735884,
0.00018222,
-0.0974040776,
0.0535316765,
-0.0114940219,
0.0177180022,
-0.0483618192,
-0.0155133,
-0.0428562984,
0.0553102605,
-0.0023084448,
0.0405325256,
0.034762051,
-0.0309741255,
-0.0202337597,
-0.0280711614,
0.0267334804,
-0.0438018143,
0.0496443138,
-0.0213677082,
-0.0045791296,
-0.0079493541,
-0.0450842083,
-0.0279512946,
-0.0684762299,
-0.0051636528,
-0.0024859104,
-0.0409039147,
0.0013652778,
0.0181389321,
-0.0517421514,
0.0341656692,
0.0317450985,
-0.0073095611,
0.0079721725,
-0.0097433953,
0.0101076709,
0.0244718045,
-0.0126456507,
-0.0295165516,
-0.0385594591,
0.0098113669,
0.0687566698,
0.0534446649,
0.0068862061,
0.0101457471,
0.0240485501,
0.0514209867,
-0.0209963545,
0.0135757932,
0.033330895,
0.0312759578,
-0.0429330803,
-0.0259488598,
0.0999912918,
0.0120376395,
-0.0804300681,
-0.0089712972,
0.0364810638,
0.0459426045,
0.0077752345,
0.0186299775,
-0.0743575618,
-0.0438111909,
0.005948232,
0.055803448,
-0.000623516,
-0.0319003798,
-0.0146175064,
-0.0918333158,
0.0191006213,
0.0188160427,
-0.0281701945,
-0.0096558677,
-0.044734288,
-0.0087645594,
-0.0284114573,
0.0150564238,
0.0087729413,
-0.0204917155,
0.0031130987,
0.0463838801,
-0.0005862389,
-0.0694726482,
0.0284378231,
-0.0510783121,
0.0272837803,
0.0446322374,
0.0044025928,
-0.026534522,
-0.0595153347,
0.0354652256,
-0.0151169337,
-0.0232908726,
-0.0172499325,
0.0475082919,
-0.0176376142,
-0.0038422472,
0.0025126166,
0.0735513195,
-0.0003277813,
-0.0209093168,
0.0349668711,
0.0745335221,
-0.0001609305,
-0.023135053,
0.0117316665,
-0.0540245064,
-0.0181838032,
0.0691027492,
-0.0013686796,
-0.0507832468,
-0.0117905382,
-0.0070043225,
-0.0084856413,
0.0158773325,
0.017795898,
0.009006232,
-0.0519020446,
-0.0114712436,
-0.0180325452,
-0.0025872111,
0.0183430407,
0.0493771918,
0.0201112591,
0.0295301415,
0.0100838961,
0.0118210074,
-0.0434237048,
0.0242672376,
-0.0733212531,
-0.0035938965,
-0.0301506706,
0.0026769468,
0.0245785397,
-0.0150096696,
-0.012229369,
-0.0038778449,
-0.0583364107,
-0.0825833157,
0.0201346092,
0.0337883681,
0.0200920869,
0.0536198467,
0.003184336,
-0.0494919792,
0.1002966389,
0.0956456214,
-0.0230636485,
-0.0023299593,
0.0506537743,
-0.007475228,
0.0037163559,
0.0468504727,
-0.0489075333,
-0.0170017127,
0.0627738163,
0.004843249,
-0.0008177786,
0.0229218397,
0.022833949,
0.0298906565,
0.0458856747,
0.0016259422,
-0.0156356767,
-0.0450813174,
0.0324229822,
0.0348317772,
-0.0538202561,
-0.0113804294,
0.0186803769,
0.0397175997,
0.0118897753,
-0.0218218677,
0.0011757503,
0.0311467275,
0.0391080156,
-0.0088693723,
-0.0114230886,
0.0336753316,
0.0235936195,
0.0353316069,
-0.0142535232,
-0.0279051755,
0.018642094,
0.000100239,
0.0175176449,
-0.0422721989,
0.0505192168,
0.0361554995,
0.0278066304,
-0.0465704426,
0.0197194703,
-0.0299829654,
-0.0460178442,
-0.0332091525,
0.0253630821,
0.0176338125,
-0.0418530069,
-0.0448419973,
-0.0190221034,
-0.0294996798,
-0.0363344066,
0.0037569734,
-0.0014916105,
-0.038947843,
0.0126910275,
0.0146473693,
-0.039874088,
0.030610295,
0.0636629388,
-0.0082244119,
0.0303657874,
0.0221820641,
-0.008962743,
-0.037540555,
-0.0346983485,
0.0404392965,
-0.0099376626,
-0.0142198103,
-0.0228295252,
-0.0209748261,
-0.0629447028,
-0.0133233145,
-0.0203343239,
0.0145137385,
-0.0080587659,
0.0383045711,
0.0821169615,
-0.0116405161,
0.0062886355,
-0.0567102171,
-0.0029948521,
0.0248493515,
-0.0407736674,
-0.0089547364,
-6.429505942e-33,
0.0487878397,
0.0072275959,
0.0033345618,
0.0142190298,
-0.0041172542,
0.0220015831,
0.0123963915,
-0.0562001541,
0.0022584165,
-0.0059233797,
-0.0403813422,
-0.008927728,
0.0044115377,
0.0494019426,
-0.0108717903,
-0.052857846,
0.0503756404,
-0.0278855208,
-0.0469549671,
0.0587587953,
0.0526088402,
0.0382292159,
0.0351150632,
-0.0490053818,
0.0347524844,
-0.012765849,
-0.0341725983,
0.0485043339,
-0.0366282836,
0.0266251322,
-0.0292742699,
0.0363614447,
0.0146080563,
-0.0231923237,
0.0088594332,
0.0622614063,
-0.1064297706,
-0.0128806159,
-0.0139516536,
-0.0170675963,
-0.0215256978,
-0.032723818,
0.0135160265,
-0.0098144198,
-0.0016279704,
0.0023492333,
-0.0067493585,
0.0087441225,
-0.0644191056,
-0.0482812077,
0.0083970362,
0.0193273984,
0.0005460863,
-0.0151498616,
0.0334857404,
-0.0011651443,
-0.0062769409,
0.0365323983,
-0.060406141,
-0.0035983662,
0.0313844234,
0.0203719456,
0.038994588,
0.022802595,
0.004767044,
0.0758643895,
0.0166643709,
0.0233673677,
0.0031402919,
-0.0144813936,
0.0347672813,
0.0253224261,
0.024277905,
0.0076198843,
0.0668042377,
-0.0442860238,
-0.0714193955,
0.004073408,
0.0070711737,
0.0212441869,
0.0507710725,
0.0189195964,
-0.0047724298,
-0.0427174345,
-0.064915508,
-0.0129840029,
-0.0395254381,
0.0124024004,
0.0236036386,
0.0403092094,
-0.0326815173,
-0.0165951625,
-0.0078493021,
-0.030572027,
-0.0498498939,
0.0334567502,
0.0495790243,
-0.0215911958,
-0.0085703824,
-0.0077664331,
-0.0577293858,
-0.0319377705,
-0.0132255228,
-0.0395161994,
0.0146709895,
-0.0039609596,
0.1010627523,
0.0646940544,
-0.0685821921,
0.0001979538,
-0.0374114178,
0.0391353033,
0.0317156315,
0.0330848172,
0.0326910987,
0.0103197116,
0.0174783729,
0.0087803984,
0.0548129231,
-0.0085668927,
-0.0727180466,
0.0006212511,
-0.0145856701,
-0.0161508117,
-0.0106997611,
-0.0153747024,
0.0123857697,
0.0228052363,
0.0536668487,
-0.0757979974,
0.0245939363,
0.0075789904,
2.867e-7,
-0.010589161,
0.0196904764,
0.009491195,
-0.0182175133,
0.0061019412,
0.0685115457,
-0.0266702529,
0.0530675352,
-0.0053968304,
0.01483831,
0.0252895206,
0.0002254758,
0.0595871769,
0.0253671408,
-0.1186042354,
-0.0004372495,
-0.0666005686,
-0.0030238759,
-0.053395737,
-0.0219183527,
0.013171846,
0.1039279774,
0.0523269363,
-0.0397780351,
0.0077890991,
-0.0574974939,
0.0432109982,
-0.0582179651,
-0.000849255,
0.0089963945,
0.0528429821,
0.0327397399,
0.0261894707,
-0.0042963685,
-0.0342353359,
0.0253111236,
-0.0111496337,
0.0734317899,
0.0342324451,
-0.039334055,
0.0008766402,
-0.0029693423,
0.0147178173,
-0.0260957181,
0.086077489,
-0.0221177079,
-0.0290253423,
-0.0295714065,
0.0073323897,
-0.0672601089,
0.0459668078,
-0.002231034,
-0.0298466161,
0.0467188805,
-0.0091758184,
-0.0004581907,
-0.0393465757,
-0.1118193492,
-0.013518854,
-0.0097430795,
-0.0330924727,
-0.0487774052,
0.0020952064,
0.0408914983,
-0.0007767202,
-0.090070866,
0.0567663088,
2.713034074e-34,
0.0349020585,
-0.0421409719,
-0.0029119356,
0.0350264423,
0.0176839326,
-0.0112955356,
0.0190038718,
0.0165975485,
0.0198602341,
-0.0548814945,
-0.0072107529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12036v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12036v4 | MedCalc-Bench: Evaluating Large Language Models for Medical Calculations | 2024-06-17T19:07:21 | 2024-06-30T15:12:10 | Nikhil Khandekar, Qiao Jin, Guangzhi Xiong, Soren Dunn, Serina S Applebaum, Zain Anwar, Maame Sarfo-Gyamfi, Conrad W Safranek, Abid A Anwar, Andrew Zhang, Aidan Gilson, Maxwell B Singer, Amisha Dave, Andrew Taylor, Aidong Zhang, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As opposed to evaluating computation and logic-based reasoning, current
benchmarks for evaluating large language models (LLMs) in medicine are
primarily focused on question-answering involving domain knowledge and
descriptive reasoning. While such qualitative capabilities are vital to medical
diagnosis, in real-world scenarios, doctors frequently use clinical calculators
that follow quantitative equations and rule-based reasoning paradigms for
evidence-based decision support. To this end, we propose MedCalc-Bench, a
first-of-its-kind dataset focused on evaluating the medical calculation
capability of LLMs. MedCalc-Bench contains an evaluation set of over 1000
manually reviewed instances from 55 different medical calculation tasks. Each
instance in MedCalc-Bench consists of a patient note, a question requesting to
compute a specific medical value, a ground truth answer, and a step-by-step
explanation showing how the answer is obtained. While our evaluation results
show the potential of LLMs in this area, none of them are effective enough for
clinical settings. Common issues include extracting the incorrect entities, not
using the correct equation or rules for a calculation task, or incorrectly
performing the arithmetic for the computation. We hope our study highlights the
quantitative knowledge and reasoning gaps in LLMs within medical settings,
encouraging future improvements of LLMs for various clinical calculation tasks. | [
0.0263824258,
0.060185764,
0.0039241523,
-0.0017562946,
-0.0403138846,
0.0311820507,
0.014858041,
0.0291116498,
-0.0168898851,
-0.0020973536,
0.0162975974,
-0.064560689,
0.0308785234,
0.0339423157,
0.0060529062,
-0.0031715229,
0.0006985796,
-0.0062488117,
0.0719865859,
0.0097603751,
-0.009241337,
0.0023522337,
-0.0468166471,
0.0258231945,
-0.0057639088,
-0.0346791372,
0.0589913204,
-0.0435140766,
0.0078292107,
-0.0766739026,
-0.008717441,
0.0200500954,
-0.0357921794,
-0.003352456,
0.0000020152,
-0.0781917945,
0.0068130544,
0.034466546,
-0.069146961,
-0.0167112928,
0.0221478976,
-0.0255193748,
-0.0029173135,
0.0319544151,
-0.0352037176,
-0.038558986,
0.0242892969,
0.0225118008,
0.0388135016,
0.038905099,
-0.0147155328,
-0.0082885632,
0.0068974863,
-0.0145037677,
0.0376176722,
-0.0536899641,
0.0436384529,
0.0565716848,
0.0429584719,
-0.0411747135,
0.0184689481,
0.0198074318,
0.0403091498,
0.0058573275,
-0.0308024492,
0.0336229466,
-0.0302314814,
0.0042803599,
0.0286735315,
0.0690083727,
0.0249882583,
0.0059735277,
0.0133031541,
0.0153309805,
-0.0231057126,
-0.0243823621,
-0.0515336655,
0.0135199958,
-0.0220443476,
-0.0270690955,
-0.0073849456,
0.0015578837,
0.0490448885,
0.0187378898,
-0.0301566776,
0.0493432097,
-0.0190161821,
-0.0137821157,
0.0265921429,
0.0007315165,
-0.012126429,
-0.0481734052,
0.0532290973,
0.0695574358,
-0.063463673,
0.0076376805,
0.0242613014,
-0.0307807159,
0.071751751,
-0.0760245174,
0.0310004782,
0.0329599082,
0.0118599068,
0.0584256388,
-0.036307618,
0.018763151,
-0.0279996544,
0.0256777108,
-0.0465822853,
0.0282507595,
-0.0325241275,
-0.0229518302,
-0.0054369131,
0.0055878926,
0.0068132873,
0.0248131566,
-0.0824702159,
-0.0280348454,
-0.0461999029,
0.0242014062,
0.0217855163,
0.0267126728,
0.0215569865,
-0.0268415753,
-0.0642213598,
0.0107022449,
-0.0207612664,
0.0325338729,
0.0164382663,
-0.0396790206,
0.0090118097,
-0.0200138744,
-0.0113434112,
0.0077614021,
0.0428837091,
0.058485914,
0.0034947484,
0.0355618,
0.0104071852,
-0.0554165952,
-0.0451744609,
-0.0727749914,
-0.0079582995,
-0.0839338377,
0.0264973473,
0.054823406,
0.0030861229,
-0.0606301427,
0.0380663574,
0.0127277514,
-0.0142742116,
0.0473664515,
-0.0305131692,
-0.0010136775,
0.0004479511,
0.0416692123,
-0.0226733051,
0.0151106911,
0.0475783311,
-0.0449119844,
-0.0186328981,
-0.0253176782,
0.0069244951,
0.0106188571,
0.0101394951,
-0.0339163505,
-0.0508806743,
0.0640129745,
-0.0136488983,
0.0811679438,
-0.064730294,
0.061871279,
-0.0105701098,
0.0139949219,
0.0137285143,
0.0389290527,
0.0153369438,
-0.0025924491,
0.0371629968,
-0.0790432617,
0.0302632097,
-0.0615160502,
-0.0429721139,
0.0053850468,
0.0056467042,
-0.0051656812,
-0.025294628,
-0.0014439471,
-0.0192201398,
-0.066852048,
-0.0465792306,
-0.0070684883,
-0.0231953058,
0.0056940471,
0.0360882878,
-0.0290622599,
0.0187539216,
0.0691387206,
0.0244506989,
-0.0311568417,
-0.0117409201,
-0.0421418212,
0.0060397279,
0.0604581162,
0.0644509271,
-0.0506225079,
-0.0298694503,
-0.0196312964,
0.0311231017,
-0.0255308431,
0.0501362085,
-0.0281497575,
0.0013893981,
-0.0327261984,
0.0079739196,
0.0180056859,
0.0144762322,
-0.0518383421,
0.0202764794,
0.0194591116,
-0.0080629503,
-0.0709854662,
-0.0127694421,
0.0198443215,
-0.0513134263,
-0.028739525,
0.0086243413,
-0.0307937562,
0.0166953299,
0.0085555436,
-0.0061911764,
0.0635808408,
0.0035562618,
-0.0110223014,
-0.0353640392,
0.0020641361,
-0.0478032008,
-0.0128589096,
0.0531877987,
-0.0175691489,
-0.0479185097,
-0.0365212634,
-0.0321911238,
-0.0258269385,
-0.0195728559,
-0.0662220195,
0.0199547634,
0.0121628297,
0.0100443419,
0.0148145817,
-0.0512064658,
-0.0252703596,
0.0401623137,
-0.0078527024,
0.0219711028,
0.0019552745,
-0.0334193483,
-0.0078618191,
-0.0010729522,
-0.0126214679,
-0.0041960692,
-0.0090751937,
0.0225320682,
-0.0328556187,
0.0092970682,
-0.0458509363,
-0.0099986941,
-0.0697531328,
-0.0076433322,
0.0066722943,
0.0426339805,
0.0151249375,
-0.0117143439,
0.0062049171,
-0.0033813289,
-0.0414305851,
-0.0155983791,
0.006242367,
0.0188271757,
0.0287115667,
0.0367160104,
0.014277502,
-0.0309004467,
-0.0148965847,
-0.0770592466,
0.030890923,
0.0192362648,
0.0621675067,
-0.0116532408,
0.007205714,
-0.052673988,
-0.0182434954,
0.0143371243,
0.0021282698,
0.0406765528,
-0.0315011777,
0.0011913902,
0.0566299371,
-0.0411920287,
0.0040316912,
0.0385416597,
-0.0137648508,
-0.0496961288,
0.0038772251,
-0.0250848867,
0.0085254731,
0.0024358269,
-0.0376478322,
-0.0338836685,
0.0838872269,
-0.0154397665,
-0.0162770208,
-0.0121847456,
0.0390277505,
-0.0384881385,
0.0026450341,
-0.060637664,
0.031033555,
-0.0007832916,
0.0590439402,
0.006160086,
-0.0174955744,
0.0919473022,
0.0030422679,
0.0270254035,
-0.0781247914,
0.0074047684,
-0.0475722849,
0.0186313912,
-0.0248493254,
0.0122109326,
-0.0232380088,
0.0019794186,
0.0143861976,
-0.009370869,
0.0153286839,
-0.079369612,
0.0830368549,
-0.0574747063,
0.0277140886,
0.0241212603,
-0.0484895967,
-0.0258791968,
-0.0018203579,
-0.0390103124,
0.0122258905,
-0.0138375014,
0.0150119578,
-0.0590847172,
0.0151481433,
0.0268656723,
0.0477782972,
0.0061796959,
-0.0355395041,
-0.0021461777,
-0.0304462779,
0.0093107969,
0.0034675472,
0.0449126624,
-0.0232033692,
0.0547518097,
0.0797945634,
0.0284961872,
0.0340473615,
-0.0313581601,
0.0198972002,
-0.0248162597,
-0.0170862786,
0.007126038,
0.044452589,
0.0132302595,
-0.0787675902,
-0.0054115094,
0.1003767177,
0.0377574749,
-0.0241051391,
0.0065209023,
-0.0529485941,
-0.0600883104,
0.0098937172,
0.0135925859,
-0.0721994266,
-0.0281458497,
0.0150951445,
0.0207515974,
-0.0026051886,
-0.0566264838,
0.0241866913,
-0.0503814369,
0.0202160291,
0.01055241,
-0.0263110027,
-0.0386213474,
-0.0548038483,
0.0143881654,
-0.0239143483,
-0.0245333593,
0.0213608444,
0.003919594,
0.0092219114,
-0.0087566394,
-0.0571045578,
-0.0469508469,
0.1015624702,
-0.0054625901,
0.0190695077,
0.0402305909,
0.0240949765,
-0.0272479318,
-0.0351559334,
0.0114138238,
0.0173618179,
-0.0079795625,
-0.0156949107,
0.04960889,
0.0597074367,
0.0042338828,
-0.0679547116,
0.0372455306,
-0.0604310147,
-0.0243101865,
0.0003894531,
0.1088067889,
-0.0360170193,
-0.0236703437,
-0.0426174961,
0.0259714574,
0.0029817764,
0.055597689,
0.005706727,
0.0077555771,
-0.0463690497,
0.0002434391,
0.0061842855,
-0.003197358,
-0.0249423794,
0.0180726964,
0.023059072,
-0.0027441727,
-0.02332858,
-0.0058398065,
0.071906358,
0.0098342039,
0.0034569458,
-0.0022384198,
0.0569542348,
0.0090100551,
-0.0547305234,
0.0561050177,
0.0011250108,
0.0816661119,
-0.0284725539,
0.0218464751,
0.034690585,
0.020834839,
-0.0245707911,
0.0037680273,
-0.0121505,
0.0045342203,
-0.0178447235,
0.0572250895,
0.0254154187,
-0.0552853346,
-0.0313501731,
-0.0053648027,
-0.0069453861,
0.0152791766,
-0.0604343601,
-0.0238015968,
-0.0060542817,
-0.0196554679,
0.0069669001,
-0.0193185341,
-0.0058407732,
0.0266134236,
0.0152437473,
0.0620462932,
-0.0511062518,
-0.0173368379,
0.0249600466,
0.0449296534,
0.0292960033,
0.0233761072,
-0.0185981542,
0.014980454,
0.0272965431,
-0.050833948,
-0.0095731672,
-0.0030019882,
-0.009194375,
0.0350303017,
-0.0009371021,
-0.013600749,
-0.0276468173,
-0.0420846008,
-0.0406738631,
-0.005247206,
0.0566804782,
0.030820027,
0.0101213744,
0.0801449046,
-0.0490074903,
0.0024514815,
-0.0390675664,
-0.0085923094,
0.0428730883,
-0.0030143466,
0.0698241442,
-0.0057299468,
0.0244941991,
-0.0199430045,
0.0094772959,
-0.0162582304,
-0.0441021472,
0.0167845655,
0.0151385311,
0.0051347497,
0.0107709067,
-0.0033966089,
-0.0121389013,
0.0038222962,
-0.0282465816,
-0.0136357341,
-0.0049605859,
0.0276740529,
0.0567376427,
0.0406988747,
0.0002091185,
-0.0473259464,
0.0607244298,
-0.0221025702,
0.054980576,
-0.01159433,
-0.0537064523,
-0.0154425567,
-0.0378824025,
-0.0220432431,
-0.0063693831,
-0.0486407354,
-0.0141472863,
-0.1119065881,
-0.0607934631,
0.0003389819,
0.0458511189,
-0.0323434435,
-0.0091894716,
0.035785988,
0.0627068579,
0.001880409,
-0.0394177958,
-0.0177374966,
0.0647793263,
-0.054095991,
0.0011175098,
-0.0075120451,
-5.473812872e-33,
0.0249319449,
-0.0329087265,
0.0527034439,
-0.0171832442,
0.0254749581,
0.0454286821,
-0.042316623,
0.0191601068,
-0.0023557004,
0.0632227063,
-0.0176476035,
0.0359832421,
0.0191764198,
0.0123873828,
0.0183689166,
-0.0514619127,
0.0013502204,
0.0167524684,
-0.0185505711,
-0.0004734829,
-0.015396974,
0.0012144258,
0.0155248707,
-0.0940848812,
0.0279070195,
0.0275687631,
0.0339431725,
0.0223551802,
-0.0346881971,
0.0735680908,
0.0108273299,
0.035997767,
0.0316362828,
-0.0228596237,
-0.0074134162,
-0.0051884302,
-0.0565898418,
-0.0300527178,
0.019809559,
-0.0254618898,
-0.0519545339,
-0.0131786512,
0.0388248451,
0.0254945084,
-0.0281836148,
-0.0285074469,
0.001037469,
-0.0483608134,
0.0185533296,
-0.019895073,
-0.01345383,
0.0511289276,
-0.0018613558,
-0.008499166,
-0.0284067262,
0.0043164375,
-0.0612764433,
0.0067262547,
-0.0548311286,
-0.0114761321,
0.0215313435,
-0.0071935183,
0.0255626682,
-0.0421416312,
-0.0275791921,
0.0495656282,
0.0163303819,
0.000205869,
-0.062113706,
0.015319841,
-0.0502279326,
0.0650586635,
0.0742288902,
0.0305453204,
0.0377700888,
0.0004595096,
-0.1127388552,
0.045588892,
-0.0491488054,
0.0927764475,
0.0196406506,
-0.0483900495,
-0.0650359094,
-0.0015386943,
-0.0481937192,
0.0499432199,
-0.0487875529,
-0.0209363699,
0.0155502465,
-0.0317127295,
0.0151324272,
0.0217105113,
0.0118311206,
-0.0204340797,
0.0140082818,
-0.0110561438,
0.0554570854,
0.0076849684,
-0.013551333,
0.0213956069,
-0.0597216263,
0.0169949811,
0.0026278244,
-0.0078064082,
0.0579251125,
0.0209110808,
0.0186401345,
-0.0212102681,
-0.0365779921,
-0.0175473429,
-0.0080967331,
-0.0091741784,
-0.01856957,
0.0404426679,
0.0317287855,
0.0470236093,
0.010868432,
0.03228122,
-0.0174595173,
-0.0043703271,
-0.0320129879,
-0.0151825706,
0.0056224354,
-0.0000433665,
-0.0303371884,
-0.0254531018,
-0.0539806932,
0.0280723795,
0.0312351398,
-0.0384621359,
0.0109652113,
0.0056289784,
2.735e-7,
0.1075560376,
0.0618999638,
-0.001917024,
0.0032522972,
0.0380121991,
0.0251569692,
-0.0213634297,
-0.0438977368,
0.0316647999,
-0.0252053514,
0.0305640679,
0.0216697976,
0.0354682952,
0.0628500581,
0.0055026212,
-0.0250497982,
-0.0577270016,
-0.035959512,
-0.0169102941,
-0.0150225582,
0.0466104075,
0.0305961389,
-0.0161803924,
-0.0283283144,
0.0153519688,
-0.0260621607,
0.0343233235,
-0.0232981797,
0.0150360744,
0.0363487899,
0.0267036501,
-0.0224145371,
0.059535291,
0.0682054237,
0.000618859,
-0.0154277766,
-0.0008175402,
0.1301469207,
-0.0384182483,
0.0433404781,
-0.0033138955,
-0.0678681657,
0.0374100991,
-0.0510236435,
0.0631859601,
-0.0561648421,
-0.0386108644,
-0.0386036932,
0.0032827232,
-0.0342550837,
0.0649805143,
-0.0057932884,
-0.0089835459,
0.0150789022,
0.0197045468,
0.0152658289,
-0.0301322136,
-0.0328313112,
-0.0476641804,
0.0633528233,
-0.019632753,
-0.044454854,
0.0311409701,
-0.0068992935,
0.014708126,
-0.0804395303,
0.0141778886,
2.430651862e-34,
0.0202013534,
0.0216028821,
0.0174515452,
-0.0081996461,
0.0535149276,
0.0167898275,
-0.0285085365,
0.0187540762,
0.0114617143,
-0.0657023117,
0.0016620558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12034v1 | Self-MoE: Towards Compositional Large Language Models with Self-Specialized Experts | 2024-06-17T19:06:54 | 2024-06-17T19:06:54 | Junmo Kang, Leonid Karlinsky, Hongyin Luo, Zhen Wang, Jacob Hansen, James Glass, David Cox, Rameswar Panda, Rogerio Feris, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We present Self-MoE, an approach that transforms a monolithic LLM into a
compositional, modular system of self-specialized experts, named MiXSE (MiXture
of Self-specialized Experts). Our approach leverages self-specialization, which
constructs expert modules using self-generated synthetic data, each equipped
with a shared base LLM and incorporating self-optimized routing. This allows
for dynamic and capability-specific handling of various target tasks, enhancing
overall capabilities, without extensive human-labeled data and added
parameters. Our empirical results reveal that specializing LLMs may exhibit
potential trade-offs in performances on non-specialized tasks. On the other
hand, our Self-MoE demonstrates substantial improvements over the base LLM
across diverse benchmarks such as knowledge, reasoning, math, and coding. It
also consistently outperforms other methods, including instance merging and
weight merging, while offering better flexibility and interpretability by
design with semantic experts and routing. Our findings highlight the critical
role of modularity and the potential of self-improvement in achieving
efficient, scalable, and adaptable systems. | [
0.0262066964,
0.0592585467,
-0.0246300958,
0.0273534991,
-0.008259967,
0.0119285006,
0.0200604033,
-0.0523467734,
0.0109234275,
-0.032726381,
-0.0389101841,
0.0463762507,
-0.0351409353,
0.0258205812,
0.0389426537,
0.0043114712,
0.0335442908,
-0.0706395656,
-0.053219188,
-0.0246761292,
-0.0093789715,
0.0035224445,
0.0129909031,
0.0145595632,
-0.0036599333,
0.0062245689,
-0.0158882476,
-0.0040736636,
-0.015354461,
0.0279110633,
-0.0075690662,
0.0642212406,
0.0309540909,
0.0591025315,
0.0000021036,
-0.0532197356,
-0.0128928833,
0.0138620753,
-0.0483113714,
0.003265427,
0.0145415729,
0.0063742036,
-0.0250103697,
0.0152059887,
-0.0426002294,
-0.0080302479,
0.0526933633,
0.0029512416,
0.0846204758,
0.0762199238,
0.0046077627,
-0.0466317125,
0.0424524285,
-0.0090222117,
0.0288494788,
-0.0060156449,
0.0164344572,
0.0275982302,
0.0146474419,
-0.0042286715,
-0.0123124719,
0.0324701592,
0.0380369425,
-0.0104020266,
0.0384468921,
0.0379782394,
0.0022687004,
0.0030883446,
-0.0296949875,
0.0704121515,
-0.0178425312,
-0.0296748783,
0.0124158114,
0.0153789883,
-0.0111294929,
-0.0104180388,
-0.0343593955,
0.0083959131,
0.0100288447,
-0.0022715034,
0.0285553671,
-0.0127805453,
0.0398383364,
0.0045964909,
-0.0743611157,
0.0718074739,
0.0372705013,
-0.0131161893,
-0.0416787043,
-0.0229055304,
0.0166380219,
-0.0511434004,
0.0041971179,
0.0578363314,
-0.0231576338,
0.0238525514,
-0.0546008088,
-0.0189243462,
-0.0137048159,
-0.0357851908,
0.0231026504,
0.0422807075,
0.0032920169,
0.0762366727,
-0.0434722565,
0.0151194017,
-0.055499319,
0.0237299632,
-0.0603259914,
-0.034797363,
-0.0750128254,
-0.0134254415,
-0.0309927277,
0.054635521,
-0.0104720797,
-0.0225828923,
-0.0333963223,
0.0684367269,
-0.0353037342,
0.0364232734,
0.0254078638,
-0.0154508464,
-0.0269904789,
-0.0638905391,
-0.0158558339,
0.0035155599,
-0.0275373757,
-0.0236721449,
-0.0025156664,
-0.0260191914,
0.0198463108,
0.0266300533,
-0.0463933311,
-0.0091735553,
0.0164308306,
0.1165739074,
-0.033213947,
0.0096395826,
0.0040524486,
-0.0242647193,
0.001380149,
-0.0778988451,
-0.0192013979,
-0.0907531828,
0.0697534457,
0.0117854113,
-0.011365355,
-0.0589528531,
-0.0136738718,
-0.0299663898,
-0.0068106945,
0.0597212538,
-0.0194652509,
0.0378122814,
0.0208433848,
0.0215745829,
-0.0148016457,
0.0662497655,
0.01976615,
-0.0159334987,
-0.0030530489,
-0.0222299639,
0.0287521034,
0.0238894057,
-0.0131641356,
-0.0078641009,
-0.0529867224,
0.0520732924,
-0.0202806368,
0.0182721596,
0.0239210911,
0.0369912982,
-0.0310732555,
-0.0157014728,
0.0423736051,
0.0226259399,
0.0309372209,
0.0646603629,
0.0475930534,
0.009152038,
0.0293929987,
0.0031676092,
-0.045043163,
0.0522019267,
-0.0433593467,
0.0060717934,
0.0192133915,
0.032138437,
-0.0338977687,
-0.0538345017,
-0.0088174175,
-0.0100191459,
-0.0550364256,
0.0336351655,
0.0493522435,
0.0017306483,
-0.0224355143,
0.0594759285,
0.0062251897,
-0.0400732346,
0.0054889037,
-0.0502899773,
0.0207589064,
0.0850312039,
0.0380675495,
-0.0359609313,
-0.0341425277,
0.0211486816,
-0.0193291493,
0.0269907769,
0.0350527465,
-0.0114947334,
-0.0057841786,
-0.0537494719,
-0.0400508232,
-0.0388583615,
0.0028328456,
0.0186189879,
0.0362063423,
-0.0340220593,
0.0062208353,
-0.0414078012,
0.0077718771,
0.0257749278,
-0.0502144173,
-0.0033058538,
0.0169229526,
-0.0162329096,
0.0214156061,
-0.0060817497,
-0.0222908948,
0.0269074328,
0.0263618156,
-0.0188856497,
-0.0598388091,
0.005408919,
-0.0494899414,
-0.0200955924,
0.0309278313,
-0.0276786871,
-0.055454962,
-0.0187235828,
-0.0323069729,
-0.0648635626,
0.0356893912,
-0.0320594013,
0.0119337775,
-0.0392082706,
0.0289754681,
0.0246991944,
-0.0023859332,
-0.0116567975,
0.0602391511,
-0.0025437674,
-0.0327337272,
0.0260375943,
0.0179986339,
0.0119608454,
-0.0139363874,
-0.0383363664,
-0.0040949164,
0.0102055604,
0.045997642,
-0.0157469902,
-0.034601111,
-0.0376727469,
-0.0832678378,
-0.0958700553,
0.0185737703,
-0.0131897433,
-0.0004018903,
0.0449354202,
0.0080534955,
-0.0020624213,
0.0138932988,
0.0023298708,
0.0060477322,
-0.0240248088,
0.020184435,
0.0140686994,
0.0073234313,
-0.0142696993,
-0.0331407785,
-0.0557826087,
-0.0286998227,
0.0389670022,
-0.0367909707,
0.0293127485,
-0.0497922264,
-0.0298514534,
-0.0396323912,
0.0520681888,
-0.0130234798,
-0.0315815397,
0.0052989777,
-0.0616923645,
0.0933800265,
0.0515235625,
-0.0155363791,
-0.0132496096,
0.0802512541,
-0.051262293,
-0.0396004133,
0.0381972715,
0.0033228623,
-0.0014481382,
-0.056366872,
0.0205092728,
-0.0225147754,
0.0594004951,
-0.0189866442,
-0.0318635628,
-0.0352743268,
-0.0033216509,
0.0172278378,
-0.0394566618,
0.0159525592,
-0.0011813099,
0.012713003,
0.0251340307,
-0.01369204,
-0.037383046,
0.0714347139,
-0.0017151621,
-0.0143261496,
0.0045509371,
-0.0417278819,
-0.069350712,
0.0374508835,
0.0069581936,
0.0189194102,
-0.062932089,
-0.0061304672,
-0.0609630197,
0.0160484388,
0.0216586869,
-0.0179290883,
0.0430539548,
-0.0584717877,
0.0385600813,
0.0082545904,
-0.0433312282,
-0.0239760838,
0.0358025357,
-0.0398254022,
0.0034258377,
0.025557233,
-0.028415354,
-0.045528084,
0.0076040705,
0.0058268844,
0.0466889963,
0.0105154635,
-0.0163580254,
-0.0248191003,
0.000805608,
0.0010118268,
0.0314247906,
0.0319010876,
-0.0309989303,
0.0658635646,
0.0413015895,
0.0469129905,
-0.0403027982,
-0.0405347832,
0.0050880956,
0.027058281,
-0.0430610031,
-0.019074617,
0.0266923513,
0.0397262312,
-0.0888723806,
0.0129360044,
0.1218806654,
0.0090518435,
-0.0252412185,
-0.016843345,
-0.0048836102,
0.022837894,
0.0376929939,
0.0626696572,
-0.0434925482,
-0.0144967996,
0.0102022002,
-0.0225874577,
0.0150877917,
-0.0331138745,
-0.0182066094,
-0.1064737514,
0.03602596,
0.0200730413,
-0.0399993584,
0.0062667695,
-0.0180266444,
-0.0208485927,
-0.0211466141,
-0.0121776955,
0.0176459532,
-0.0146628767,
-0.0224354416,
-0.0006408904,
-0.0499690399,
-0.0158606898,
0.0246906709,
-0.0012661469,
0.0603168458,
0.0058650747,
-0.0198965017,
0.0112932315,
0.011906472,
0.0673905984,
0.0081923697,
0.0151138781,
-0.0150548313,
0.0314628743,
-0.0208307579,
-0.0248712115,
-0.0019355644,
0.0032377667,
-0.020213861,
0.0112442374,
0.0034857898,
0.0918336287,
-0.0019625835,
-0.0196446534,
-0.0436519124,
-0.0248168204,
-0.0407121591,
0.0793520808,
-0.0171980094,
-0.0362755097,
-0.0489243828,
-0.009946431,
-0.0574753322,
-0.008187403,
-0.0362040959,
0.0502208024,
0.0084326211,
-0.0497572683,
-0.0346653089,
-0.0000064849,
0.0399453528,
0.0570930056,
0.0146605847,
0.0174023304,
-0.0030718092,
-0.0096152732,
-0.0733377337,
-0.0104879132,
-0.0618280061,
-0.0180995855,
-0.0765263587,
-0.002909455,
0.0481379777,
-0.0297779031,
0.0070144353,
-0.0106637022,
-0.0917724147,
-0.0891888589,
-0.0008210035,
0.0748391002,
0.0227067657,
0.0497763194,
-0.0046031745,
-0.0912064612,
0.0638300255,
0.0417620875,
-0.0820172355,
0.0012390027,
0.0379105136,
-0.0150039913,
0.0081950435,
0.0372497812,
-0.0466821752,
0.0200105812,
0.0123376977,
0.0112915291,
-0.0476906598,
0.0190795921,
0.0254569352,
-0.0013716476,
-0.0334821194,
0.0014255231,
0.0714023188,
-0.0184182636,
0.0370341577,
-0.0407658853,
-0.0187192634,
-0.0565157644,
0.017474398,
0.0230641682,
0.003961842,
0.0584920347,
0.0342258774,
0.0276864935,
0.0057511949,
0.0172221214,
0.0015727906,
-0.0286354125,
-0.0227787048,
0.0481159389,
0.0014807882,
0.0113945035,
0.0292733163,
0.0171205476,
0.0022132879,
-0.030649025,
0.0132702561,
0.0015215632,
0.0078590699,
-0.026021596,
0.003622565,
-0.0661902651,
-0.126509428,
0.0106342928,
0.0660498366,
0.0559373721,
0.0322650746,
0.0384445563,
-0.0332412012,
-0.018789418,
-0.0126492456,
0.01195959,
-0.0168259759,
0.0162824281,
0.0149369966,
0.0500603616,
0.0061012758,
-0.0072005196,
0.0540398434,
0.0245236754,
0.0373785049,
0.0139445877,
0.0167993177,
-0.0437994786,
-0.020983465,
0.009047593,
0.0210737325,
-0.0310845617,
-0.0244884677,
-0.0352547653,
-0.0544827953,
-0.0146066807,
0.0456486605,
-0.0339841582,
0.0148601439,
0.0443450958,
0.054978244,
-0.0240788348,
-0.0057982747,
0.0013956483,
-0.0051898705,
0.021853447,
-0.0069559771,
0.0436159745,
-6.432027377e-33,
-0.0129070943,
-0.0198160578,
0.0732384175,
-0.0364333279,
0.0214046836,
-0.0015229547,
-0.0304505825,
0.0297892764,
0.0004663214,
-0.0044152588,
-0.0092083067,
0.0295348354,
-0.0081934547,
0.0218187738,
0.0399849117,
0.0139482943,
0.0571504124,
0.0215316266,
0.0019872941,
0.0122612817,
-0.0099870414,
0.0118009765,
0.0511145927,
-0.0676071346,
-0.0368387811,
0.0054096309,
0.0005401262,
0.0498002805,
-0.0069139167,
0.0736967921,
-0.011295516,
0.0417488851,
0.0012585556,
-0.0110823289,
-0.0402164795,
-0.0504024774,
-0.0499917194,
-0.0552168526,
0.0265000761,
-0.0232762694,
-0.03753132,
-0.0355612002,
0.0873584747,
0.0124622416,
0.0001244713,
-0.0484331883,
0.0317819826,
0.007750649,
0.0106358258,
-0.008599014,
-0.0391974524,
0.0211352576,
-0.0244016629,
0.013791481,
0.0495937392,
-0.0562890284,
0.0101360586,
0.0009643325,
-0.017472202,
0.0387857854,
-0.0307506081,
0.0364579856,
0.0881628096,
0.0076981746,
0.0228661876,
0.0091757728,
0.0848920122,
0.039474681,
-0.0108858813,
-0.0069830595,
0.013033729,
0.1010685489,
0.0476863347,
0.0199212991,
0.0151683176,
0.0343551561,
-0.0280816648,
-0.011294012,
0.0168808978,
0.0209402312,
0.0164767951,
0.0604807176,
-0.0271453988,
-0.000124506,
-0.0341849774,
0.0307266507,
-0.0315640047,
-0.0343563706,
0.0137258451,
0.0066491943,
-0.0337768644,
-0.0087382244,
0.0158312991,
-0.0466586202,
-0.0159196723,
0.000263617,
-0.0400075354,
0.0308143515,
0.0047116163,
0.0520438924,
-0.0658733994,
-0.0470892005,
0.0108357845,
-0.0083239907,
-0.0069831018,
0.017270945,
-0.0134921698,
0.0372474082,
-0.0668960512,
-0.0005917588,
-0.0293586738,
-0.0161043815,
-0.00081547,
-0.0045776544,
0.0404091775,
0.0310278069,
0.0097114155,
0.0132762659,
0.0012464594,
-0.0215259306,
-0.0247992203,
0.0483287871,
0.020368116,
0.0091387527,
0.0208316427,
0.0035785669,
-0.0592375025,
-0.0225855149,
0.0490252711,
-0.0450430736,
-0.0125074917,
0.0280840434,
2.847e-7,
0.0191422384,
0.0361252241,
0.0070402687,
0.0039423951,
0.0302948523,
0.0146045126,
-0.0207265764,
-0.0047013601,
0.0064912154,
-0.0300048292,
0.0272364039,
0.0952104852,
0.0121519389,
0.0220993422,
-0.0647945851,
0.0152622722,
-0.0025926759,
0.0269255415,
-0.0596577078,
-0.0240095612,
0.0189036671,
0.0726729855,
0.0351752043,
-0.002491045,
-0.02256543,
-0.0341818221,
0.0527407601,
-0.0095531056,
0.0001586723,
0.0653350577,
0.0178855993,
0.0587626174,
-0.0350681245,
0.01316847,
0.0114938673,
0.0273456722,
-0.0031643235,
0.0873306543,
-0.0051154867,
-0.0033306819,
0.0167647284,
-0.0442482457,
-0.0154661126,
-0.0215487573,
0.0498312823,
-0.0604756065,
-0.0324584246,
-0.0314340591,
-0.0021558711,
-0.0157539994,
0.0015671222,
-0.0114323655,
-0.0136475004,
0.0278171673,
0.0186994579,
-0.023168074,
-0.0053892396,
-0.0851189867,
-0.0318295285,
0.017553797,
-0.0740946233,
-0.0283115059,
-0.0217208192,
0.014132699,
0.0542611964,
-0.0468001254,
-0.00239234,
2.740064475e-34,
0.0289637391,
0.0167577919,
0.0241077188,
0.0256757531,
0.0253903996,
-0.0215215534,
-0.0963732451,
0.0115842698,
0.0230233222,
-0.0566476956,
-0.0435211807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12033v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12033v2 | Unveiling and Mitigating Bias in Mental Health Analysis with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T19:05:32 | 2024-06-19T18:28:22 | Yuqing Wang, Yun Zhao, Sara Alessandra Keller, Anne de Hond, Marieke M. van Buchem, Malvika Pillai, Tina Hernandez-Boussard | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has demonstrated strong
capabilities across various applications, including mental health analysis.
However, existing studies have focused on predictive performance, leaving the
critical issue of fairness underexplored, posing significant risks to
vulnerable populations. Despite acknowledging potential biases, previous works
have lacked thorough investigations into these biases and their impacts. To
address this gap, we systematically evaluate biases across seven social factors
(e.g., gender, age, religion) using ten LLMs with different prompting methods
on eight diverse mental health datasets. Our results show that GPT-4 achieves
the best overall balance in performance and fairness among LLMs, although it
still lags behind domain-specific models like MentalRoBERTa in some cases.
Additionally, our tailored fairness-aware prompts can effectively mitigate bias
in mental health predictions, highlighting the great potential for fair
analysis in this field. | [
0.036721006,
0.1112442762,
-0.0293518789,
0.0209915135,
-0.0091445874,
0.0246532019,
0.0473059081,
-0.0065498031,
0.069035314,
-0.0175734032,
0.0131632518,
-0.0451668166,
-0.0050596492,
-0.0149832396,
-0.027220903,
-0.0674151033,
0.0137899714,
0.019365536,
0.0577169098,
-0.0339600407,
0.001206148,
0.0093599912,
0.0124843437,
0.0521577522,
0.0019119732,
-0.0299603082,
0.0539082661,
0.0054684519,
0.011035691,
-0.0592284799,
-0.0042961705,
0.0978156552,
-0.0518177971,
0.0208462439,
0.0000020726,
-0.0667054728,
-0.0207694136,
0.0127681578,
0.0083793802,
-0.0125692477,
0.0208384227,
-0.0753227621,
0.0208266657,
0.0435916819,
-0.0352290012,
-0.012745454,
0.0424972698,
0.0490046069,
0.0213822722,
-0.0065077632,
-0.0363598354,
0.0053151054,
-0.0268161111,
-0.0368121006,
0.0091737388,
-0.0049545146,
0.0391535535,
-0.0400625914,
-0.0156806149,
-0.0571170263,
-0.0253983438,
0.0209377073,
-0.0059441254,
0.0479621738,
-0.0378065072,
0.0059277839,
-0.0197066404,
-0.0413596295,
-0.0056809159,
0.0658912212,
0.0315726437,
0.0549486466,
-0.003953014,
-0.0386888795,
0.0357250199,
0.0359716229,
-0.0489771329,
0.0250447895,
-0.015095518,
0.0054184492,
0.0124321943,
0.0332408324,
0.0314907916,
0.0047616386,
0.0092172679,
0.1048265547,
0.0132744908,
-0.0395687371,
0.0203525424,
0.027307285,
-0.0379616246,
-0.0426197611,
0.0200991258,
-0.0097505357,
-0.0577199198,
-0.0069374815,
-0.0108985519,
-0.0305618364,
0.0562253818,
0.0075073205,
0.0150250727,
0.0780546665,
-0.0506544597,
-0.0290470123,
0.0735708699,
0.0327724889,
0.0168719403,
0.0172916465,
-0.0079150777,
-0.0037250146,
-0.0128732603,
0.0158766154,
0.0059054322,
-0.0296562426,
-0.0308260005,
0.0562490486,
-0.1001977175,
0.0013464057,
-0.0531355068,
-0.042866312,
0.033324793,
-0.033522889,
-0.0213582478,
0.0165828895,
-0.0153126959,
-0.0003061014,
-0.0390138924,
0.0068729147,
-0.0088766916,
-0.0763009116,
0.0128353862,
-0.0182512309,
-0.0425125733,
-0.0697956681,
0.0196183957,
0.0460965782,
0.0559119768,
-0.0080724489,
-0.0394512378,
-0.0244565159,
-0.0480939299,
-0.0544647686,
-0.0044788402,
-0.0488094054,
0.034304332,
0.0468063802,
0.0138686392,
-0.039779786,
0.0021351026,
0.0073835086,
-0.0816980079,
0.0570098124,
-0.0066762548,
0.0082374532,
0.0253500082,
0.0418219008,
-0.0190851428,
0.0658637658,
0.0066741933,
-0.0033085118,
0.047280658,
-0.0298252758,
-0.003533876,
0.0388732888,
0.0067571159,
0.0106234057,
0.0038900734,
0.0183321256,
-0.0024209316,
0.0235840995,
0.0250090975,
0.0189121384,
0.0205270518,
0.0102733653,
0.063278757,
0.0945151746,
0.0120095368,
0.0482122563,
-0.0307385046,
0.0014364662,
-0.0484869704,
-0.0039445409,
-0.0879385844,
-0.0119450409,
-0.0012180036,
-0.0387571007,
0.019977361,
0.0440786108,
-0.0188862421,
-0.0261751562,
-0.0400930122,
0.0027414274,
0.0066595846,
0.0271710306,
-0.0331764333,
-0.0594402105,
0.0332161449,
0.032507062,
0.0417934917,
-0.0091921445,
-0.0226645451,
-0.0609559976,
0.0108200992,
0.0542124733,
0.0041320762,
-0.0330172181,
0.0104271555,
-0.0046074917,
0.0082683479,
0.0279416945,
0.035674803,
0.0228586886,
0.0204869825,
-0.0347951204,
-0.03575968,
0.072341837,
0.0255692117,
-0.0049126288,
0.0158270802,
0.0544702373,
-0.0113301044,
-0.0164069105,
-0.0305662379,
0.0535426959,
0.0168813039,
-0.0340374336,
0.0398986675,
-0.0160290916,
0.0684226453,
-0.0048383381,
-0.0052787303,
0.000540808,
-0.0419165865,
-0.0069744093,
-0.0197858494,
0.000727008,
-0.0514377169,
-0.0163660906,
0.0064896964,
-0.0006351417,
0.0115922689,
0.0540207662,
-0.0270951577,
0.0115911607,
0.056055747,
0.0062990827,
-0.000508671,
0.0099051101,
-0.0210228693,
0.0000183521,
0.0483355336,
-0.0441835858,
0.02449972,
-0.0468918346,
-0.0000949586,
0.0137556326,
-0.0698048472,
-0.0224133395,
-0.032395836,
-0.0478460714,
0.0185853895,
0.003343439,
0.0257888921,
-0.030751517,
-0.0030673807,
-0.0081763053,
-0.0085628536,
-0.1399734169,
0.0259899311,
-0.012014241,
-0.0223675016,
-0.0175288487,
0.0194524862,
-0.04899038,
-0.0277299359,
-0.0190365724,
-0.0324917212,
0.0683148876,
0.075474374,
-0.0127494773,
-0.0112712197,
-0.0088560255,
-0.0275447872,
-0.0434319749,
-0.0372160301,
0.0281030126,
0.0163391996,
0.009537641,
-0.0005328632,
-0.0457331017,
-0.0594672151,
-0.008259628,
-0.0108712027,
0.0065411227,
-0.0093533006,
0.036782749,
0.0457063802,
0.0155457957,
0.0065800832,
0.0348811001,
0.0685813874,
0.0116229877,
-0.0238431823,
0.0003014371,
0.0093534654,
-0.0065593095,
-0.0027694216,
-0.0775600374,
-0.0193846505,
0.0527208857,
0.0627931505,
-0.0091774389,
-0.0344085954,
0.0298577435,
-0.0387748666,
-0.0096271727,
-0.0369235314,
0.0075772717,
-0.0227474477,
0.0387641303,
-0.026934728,
-0.0837920532,
0.0244559888,
0.0240748934,
0.0240034256,
-0.0527515374,
-0.0103201196,
-0.046765849,
0.0172801558,
-0.0216260515,
-0.0014880677,
0.0113764815,
-0.0031960851,
-0.0156345461,
-0.0521607026,
0.0041709058,
-0.0426918902,
0.0633968338,
-0.0433643721,
0.0027716293,
-0.0060344883,
-0.0469260439,
-0.0293197092,
-0.0666123107,
-0.0563410074,
0.0151621765,
0.0130494004,
0.0035487534,
-0.0231273137,
-0.0085549848,
0.0141347852,
0.0444030762,
-0.0323363878,
-0.013760264,
0.0237224251,
-0.034763746,
0.0300666615,
-0.0162519645,
0.0364578739,
-0.0436567478,
0.0265822709,
0.0154185034,
0.0063422648,
0.0275296271,
0.0437940136,
0.0457961559,
0.0035832154,
-0.006415315,
-0.0129275285,
0.0310651697,
0.0346165784,
-0.019792296,
0.0343338661,
0.1257744282,
0.005554636,
-0.0420348607,
0.0288318265,
-0.0499115549,
0.0318421982,
0.0194147546,
-0.0266572982,
-0.0594462454,
-0.0385163724,
0.0081368089,
0.0825257525,
-0.0424249172,
-0.0605402514,
0.017330749,
-0.048237104,
0.034135852,
0.0013449962,
-0.0258272421,
-0.013264142,
-0.0120140752,
0.029330831,
-0.0313758552,
0.0040395209,
-0.0296580791,
0.016769873,
0.0164155718,
-0.0161238238,
-0.0945719033,
-0.0268341471,
0.0680181757,
-0.0418338589,
0.0483343937,
0.0389925502,
0.0277914684,
-0.0248303134,
-0.0192259848,
0.0036538558,
0.012438261,
-0.0221868176,
-0.022320386,
0.0681848302,
0.0145857055,
0.0055156169,
-0.0936796889,
0.0454666913,
-0.0137652876,
0.0021778475,
0.0235049184,
0.0764309093,
0.0125950072,
-0.0447548814,
-0.0385110602,
0.0300521664,
0.0309117325,
0.0725477487,
0.0050931559,
-0.0433818027,
-0.010923882,
-0.0313400365,
-0.0029749069,
0.0037596712,
-0.0669144094,
0.034879297,
0.0058943145,
-0.0232037045,
-0.0104669044,
-0.0632227436,
0.0551321991,
-0.0299691372,
0.0005491792,
-0.0312543474,
0.0011743068,
0.0032638595,
-0.0682486966,
0.0756323263,
-0.0048400029,
0.0197853036,
-0.013697451,
0.0057492908,
-0.0152835324,
0.007140616,
-0.0224828869,
0.0377506241,
-0.0368060619,
-0.0179293584,
0.0702550337,
0.0134920981,
0.0211010855,
-0.0203966405,
0.017484393,
-0.0247594938,
0.0477174856,
0.0342927799,
-0.0169101488,
0.0309018008,
-0.0063294549,
0.0251432303,
0.005920148,
0.0343441181,
0.0052238223,
0.0427816324,
0.0365807079,
0.0113384193,
0.0215208139,
-0.01443973,
-0.0082513513,
0.0347980261,
0.0466241129,
-0.0325985998,
-0.0355607271,
-0.0221266393,
-0.0336913094,
-0.0122643821,
-0.0212794747,
-0.0103110252,
-0.0269845482,
0.0196307097,
0.030117875,
-0.0445975102,
-0.0554888323,
-0.0585471131,
-0.0255619455,
-0.0865837932,
0.0600929633,
-0.0361649543,
0.0184901766,
0.0141157834,
0.0078361379,
0.0104092471,
0.031455379,
0.004392352,
0.0374037474,
0.020350391,
0.0672067031,
-0.0189048424,
0.0286911633,
0.0116402963,
0.0035472217,
-0.0415749438,
-0.1083116904,
-0.0032934477,
-0.0100300685,
-0.0027196843,
0.0033621704,
0.0298163276,
-0.0011592373,
0.0025171933,
-0.0262426771,
-0.0068707066,
0.0180792995,
0.0126703531,
0.0588371791,
-0.0232259538,
-0.0347311981,
-0.0263723768,
0.050120309,
-0.0097919675,
0.0416993573,
0.0012490039,
-0.0505968519,
-0.0124508487,
-0.0440841503,
0.0221595429,
-0.0124198375,
-0.0723020732,
-0.0158308093,
-0.0983641371,
-0.0550833941,
0.026921453,
-0.0330236517,
-0.0036976687,
-0.0288563166,
-0.020247478,
0.0525041781,
-0.0197755024,
-0.0571368262,
-0.0199073981,
0.0041133119,
-0.0594738238,
-0.0541242622,
-0.0162981115,
-5.846156585e-33,
-0.0245183781,
-0.0075627039,
-0.0123150954,
-0.0331198238,
-0.0065323813,
-0.0009909591,
0.0060176016,
0.0330663435,
-0.0125148613,
0.0068895086,
0.0172249731,
0.0500791408,
0.0129117575,
0.0365303718,
0.0594945103,
-0.041113399,
0.0175232682,
-0.0074861301,
-0.0257669967,
-0.0081161326,
-0.0519073159,
0.0358647443,
0.0376423225,
-0.0669122487,
0.0728610605,
0.0062725642,
0.0235044956,
0.0105993617,
-0.0143374512,
0.0334673598,
-0.0401913375,
0.1103662401,
0.0551680401,
-0.0059872866,
0.0150686456,
0.0468529537,
-0.0064502144,
-0.0258101691,
0.0335774533,
-0.0239539295,
0.0033043439,
-0.0023542689,
-0.0115658576,
0.0401753075,
-0.0561106317,
-0.058274325,
0.0222205482,
-0.0399134867,
0.0565021895,
0.0179972816,
0.0073900605,
0.0319921114,
-0.0186532605,
0.0483217537,
-0.040189527,
0.0443656184,
-0.0259415451,
0.0595570095,
-0.0304712057,
0.0071829064,
0.0236597545,
-0.0148961172,
0.0122524668,
-0.0226964857,
-0.0102430303,
0.0436199158,
0.0290894713,
-0.0116768656,
-0.036485672,
-0.052972585,
0.0078002666,
-0.0083442768,
0.053776104,
0.0443044342,
0.044307299,
-0.0071100048,
-0.0587959327,
-0.0051876418,
0.0195163637,
-0.0178309064,
0.042688664,
-0.0245507658,
-0.0567718968,
-0.0481805168,
-0.0325853005,
-0.0158272106,
-0.0261907447,
-0.0081619741,
0.0419479534,
-0.0149362944,
-0.0027304774,
0.0133476257,
0.0227287523,
-0.0224205293,
-0.0299356487,
0.0108884731,
0.0119265718,
-0.0156649034,
0.0147607848,
0.0176230781,
-0.0273191072,
0.0250766315,
-0.0084498189,
0.0227564294,
0.0485305153,
0.0024957175,
0.0036666428,
-0.0237509068,
-0.0776986852,
-0.0050215144,
0.0186707694,
0.0596033074,
0.0037640524,
0.0321081541,
-0.0089711612,
-0.0102526424,
0.0286169276,
0.0149949957,
0.0311899334,
-0.0142587349,
-0.0731039047,
-0.0055396766,
-0.0110833636,
-0.0066906256,
0.0109178405,
-0.0199600328,
0.022008419,
-0.0182197075,
0.0576494075,
-0.032132417,
-0.0051689171,
-0.0663472638,
2.596e-7,
0.0414306112,
0.0566483513,
-0.0382809751,
0.0229430944,
-0.0098350449,
0.0312354136,
0.0062958966,
0.0510361083,
0.0580673665,
0.0252856594,
-0.0076859016,
0.0433197394,
0.043848291,
0.0593704022,
0.0084280567,
-0.0384125151,
-0.0664363429,
-0.0076833409,
-0.0679645538,
0.0130793378,
0.0354437903,
0.0717116073,
0.0051031969,
-0.0175036434,
-0.0072762975,
0.0060303709,
0.0115548633,
-0.0596274137,
0.0090707475,
0.0366634652,
0.0431256443,
0.0075046211,
0.0292184912,
0.0521674007,
0.003641732,
0.0166467633,
-0.0214605257,
0.0595576018,
-0.0109097036,
0.0235620365,
-0.0135265579,
0.0095459642,
-0.0119263427,
-0.062343277,
0.0610960163,
-0.0153350113,
-0.0294923969,
-0.0251218304,
-0.0126509778,
-0.047053501,
0.0808080509,
-0.0146756321,
-0.0156655479,
0.0195177123,
0.0525296852,
-0.0006724356,
0.0203587133,
-0.0375647955,
-0.0353647731,
0.0005566254,
-0.0545692742,
-0.0466557294,
-0.009918171,
0.0031286669,
-0.013121997,
-0.0592905805,
0.0430765115,
2.553191408e-34,
0.0373211876,
0.0661014318,
0.034848161,
-0.0388234407,
0.0309264995,
0.0158015341,
0.0217645578,
0.0153752845,
-0.0221556854,
-0.0495765731,
-0.0152478144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12031v1 | Large Scale Transfer Learning for Tabular Data via Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T18:58:20 | 2024-06-17T18:58:20 | Josh Gardner, Juan C. Perdomo, Ludwig Schmidt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Tabular data -- structured, heterogeneous, spreadsheet-style data with rows
and columns -- is widely used in practice across many domains. However, while
recent foundation models have reduced the need for developing task-specific
datasets and predictors in domains such as language modeling and computer
vision, this transfer learning paradigm has not had similar impact in the
tabular domain. In this work, we seek to narrow this gap and present TabuLa-8B,
a language model for tabular prediction. We define a process for extracting a
large, high-quality training dataset from the TabLib corpus, proposing methods
for tabular data filtering and quality control. Using the resulting dataset,
which comprises over 1.6B rows from 3.1M unique tables, we fine-tune a Llama
3-8B large language model (LLM) for tabular data prediction (classification and
binned regression) using a novel packing and attention scheme for tabular
prediction. Through evaluation across a test suite of 329 datasets, we find
that TabuLa-8B has zero-shot accuracy on unseen tables that is over 15
percentage points (pp) higher than random guessing, a feat that is not possible
with existing state-of-the-art tabular prediction models (e.g. XGBoost,
TabPFN). In the few-shot setting (1-32 shots), without any fine-tuning on the
target datasets, TabuLa-8B is 5-15 pp more accurate than XGBoost and TabPFN
models that are explicitly trained on equal, or even up to 16x more data. We
release our model, code, and data along with the publication of this paper. | [
0.0053903982,
0.0857991427,
-0.003788555,
0.0001142592,
0.0113955177,
0.0302426778,
0.0101249795,
0.0291253515,
0.005771881,
-0.0152327549,
-0.049778264,
-0.0523930863,
-0.0135889007,
0.0369366705,
0.0536672473,
0.0003889761,
0.0188451502,
-0.0194549244,
-0.0294356719,
0.0294684283,
-0.0216443017,
-0.0144837974,
0.0221268795,
0.0076529691,
-0.0164213534,
0.0012013844,
-0.0311749317,
0.0038692518,
-0.0570023283,
0.0197748151,
0.0304446481,
0.0588142872,
0.0185879562,
0.0233617816,
0.0000022764,
0.0033390685,
-0.0630836487,
-0.0484115183,
0.0201441348,
-0.0021577072,
0.0601589642,
-0.044693049,
-0.0065096766,
-0.0000167597,
-0.02375268,
-0.0398355089,
0.0346221253,
0.0104073798,
0.0514089428,
0.0638487339,
-0.0160360038,
-0.0072826836,
0.004927048,
-0.0395973101,
0.0939992145,
-0.0424400643,
0.0292086564,
0.0088455314,
-0.0170215108,
-0.0414124578,
-0.018380858,
0.0401162282,
0.0070894929,
-0.0307467431,
0.0463165827,
0.0258319806,
-0.07372576,
-0.0041910177,
-0.0113684181,
0.0792463496,
-0.04423327,
-0.02356226,
0.0178612098,
0.0057552354,
0.0269687474,
-0.0089186756,
-0.0665695816,
-0.013783942,
-0.0025675599,
0.0106817633,
-0.0104735186,
-0.0249834117,
0.0111681651,
-0.0152095733,
-0.0433633029,
0.0147182029,
-0.038355127,
-0.0210476443,
0.0299853552,
-0.0036717581,
0.0451823734,
-0.028726792,
-0.0001788115,
0.0246432032,
-0.0197950881,
-0.0033007297,
-0.0301517136,
-0.0399024896,
0.0084628416,
-0.0404538624,
0.0917867944,
0.0282993987,
-0.0248001758,
0.0235391073,
-0.0542320833,
0.0397646874,
-0.027095668,
0.0493011624,
-0.0266453084,
-0.0257245079,
-0.0392680243,
0.0267749485,
-0.0132326344,
0.0158723034,
-0.0261440985,
0.0043715583,
-0.008159156,
-0.0092773838,
-0.011696279,
0.0285843331,
0.0312457439,
0.0062964233,
-0.0287410058,
-0.0242510326,
-0.0337230228,
0.0122921821,
0.0202222504,
0.029582398,
-0.0176696554,
-0.0671816766,
-0.0257895347,
0.0291535221,
0.0069465484,
-0.0413369872,
0.063405253,
0.0546071678,
-0.0467039794,
-0.0092893513,
-0.0645893216,
-0.0066518565,
-0.0347145908,
-0.0364604741,
0.0552108958,
-0.0568570979,
0.0246462524,
-0.0267074797,
0.0241364241,
-0.0591887049,
0.0007746002,
0.0372775719,
-0.0179591104,
0.0868855566,
0.0065809125,
0.0199957136,
0.000351928,
-0.0414212272,
-0.0516804159,
0.057334654,
0.0493964031,
0.0798102245,
-0.0210297145,
-0.0509373136,
-0.0023967393,
0.0472157449,
0.0308446288,
-0.0248650033,
-0.0279003698,
0.0310499221,
0.0396981053,
0.0111031765,
0.0418699048,
-0.0089599928,
0.0246353466,
-0.0019259989,
0.0669879541,
0.0377807729,
-0.00382039,
0.0725748688,
-0.0069399867,
-0.0034192288,
-0.0058620968,
-0.0179986414,
-0.0054608677,
0.0377635434,
0.0373307057,
-0.0091426494,
0.0557764992,
0.0341521949,
-0.0264047403,
-0.0543446504,
0.0296983495,
-0.0069077415,
-0.0058073266,
-0.0078012748,
0.0436193347,
0.00772367,
-0.06076888,
0.0314873792,
0.0268278997,
-0.0276593734,
-0.0426420905,
-0.0331144109,
0.0482448451,
0.0400645658,
0.0042470098,
-0.061162021,
-0.0159902405,
-0.0307115242,
0.0329978429,
0.0132369837,
0.0180838015,
-0.0271107238,
0.0178440139,
-0.0343146995,
0.0016171654,
0.0501223728,
0.0124081494,
0.0069851298,
-0.004584807,
0.0351099074,
-0.0015589696,
-0.0506274365,
-0.0591595881,
0.0494929142,
0.0012104725,
-0.0655997247,
0.0358271301,
0.0023766346,
0.0327173956,
-0.0246675126,
0.0062998398,
-0.0073032877,
0.0381375514,
-0.035252858,
0.0183897763,
-0.0485915467,
-0.0085987765,
-0.0167564359,
0.0005897551,
0.0392773487,
-0.0081991022,
0.0263901725,
-0.0424287692,
0.0029504315,
0.0054735006,
-0.0052744276,
-0.0296618845,
-0.0177724715,
0.0201557186,
-0.0073394179,
0.0455518477,
-0.0150501467,
0.0453313366,
0.0015042854,
0.0028190266,
0.0035916558,
-0.1026109755,
0.0123616988,
-0.0218853392,
0.03490844,
0.0346496291,
-0.0382723659,
0.0234104209,
-0.013383504,
0.0312145296,
-0.0362726003,
-0.0365823992,
-0.053406667,
0.0387731194,
-0.0133745242,
0.0442709774,
0.0010491105,
-0.0267954785,
-0.0135686109,
-0.0465564616,
-0.0598802678,
0.0149942283,
-0.0218977928,
-0.023850495,
0.0650467426,
-0.0256693959,
-0.003332092,
-0.0359566361,
-0.0159304719,
-0.0372716337,
0.0454162247,
-0.0356022641,
-0.0889407247,
-0.0057938122,
-0.0132924076,
0.0177228916,
0.0203305874,
0.019566441,
0.0012349837,
-0.02374883,
-0.0520643964,
-0.0175916776,
0.0911866203,
-0.0270390958,
0.0209668875,
0.0280631445,
-0.0107838484,
-0.0313973166,
0.0328093916,
-0.0009930477,
0.0029668119,
-0.0053807711,
-0.0682893246,
0.0318886377,
0.0508663245,
-0.0229027011,
0.0097065838,
-0.0622431189,
0.0304903779,
0.0185914282,
0.0001282005,
-0.0505940504,
0.0948601961,
-0.0075309286,
0.0068762237,
-0.0285356138,
-0.0367540233,
-0.0025807954,
-0.0335156433,
0.0076348097,
-0.005181314,
-0.007481277,
-0.0346842408,
0.0583142526,
0.0283398796,
-0.0215453785,
0.0144643681,
-0.0104922261,
-0.0469193459,
0.0023720558,
-0.0220467933,
-0.0369920358,
0.0740023255,
-0.0264945067,
0.0203821827,
-0.0181263927,
-0.0345678404,
-0.024301149,
-0.0361559056,
0.0107705239,
0.0161573887,
-0.006894982,
0.0007815615,
-0.0735906735,
-0.0010204609,
-0.0018169448,
0.0698193163,
0.0000774226,
-0.0435636491,
-0.0338743664,
0.0443282537,
0.0072427713,
-0.009835382,
-0.0308374725,
-0.0378455818,
-0.0124472957,
0.0374081023,
-0.028576225,
0.050685782,
-0.0068248766,
0.0217870064,
0.034679357,
0.0095244395,
-0.0116335219,
0.0246763825,
0.0063333763,
-0.061713811,
-0.0034374406,
0.0689272583,
0.0052771852,
0.0026307686,
-0.0326680019,
0.0014696053,
0.0434065312,
-0.0114424424,
0.0841593742,
-0.0764389187,
-0.0443674959,
0.0053770659,
0.0217508003,
0.0406753868,
-0.0477531739,
-0.0301985368,
-0.0911851749,
0.0541980751,
0.0070955078,
-0.060386911,
-0.1029482335,
-0.0383162685,
0.0055114208,
-0.0636669248,
0.0108742174,
0.0228314139,
-0.0418402553,
0.0005790091,
0.0466512516,
-0.0510311127,
-0.0095328633,
-0.0066965939,
-0.0246320851,
0.0371227115,
0.0405912474,
0.0571449064,
-0.0387789086,
-0.0259549972,
-0.0257707667,
0.0465262085,
-0.021700602,
0.0039170897,
0.1065181792,
-0.003561323,
-0.0043381834,
0.0346234515,
-0.0156975854,
-0.0473236889,
0.0184563845,
0.0405989252,
0.0735330582,
0.0016498864,
-0.0461947024,
0.0161293168,
-0.0329460278,
0.0046667075,
0.066864185,
0.0252515227,
-0.0233640783,
-0.0297568794,
-0.0244475883,
-0.0574559532,
-0.0478058606,
0.0274285115,
0.0564260893,
-0.0474395491,
-0.0578603894,
-0.0821570978,
-0.0086654127,
0.061975304,
0.0363308266,
0.0053420723,
0.0581654795,
0.0032862872,
-0.007850471,
-0.0392744839,
-0.0073313517,
-0.0357675999,
0.0003615207,
-0.0304959435,
-0.0506717972,
-0.0155674871,
-0.0449621938,
-0.0118042082,
0.0112911137,
-0.0765930191,
-0.0145809837,
-0.0214108061,
0.0345599987,
0.0174684301,
-0.0006029096,
0.0291045979,
-0.0066478592,
-0.0096308375,
0.0449891537,
-0.0177443195,
-0.0223379415,
0.0208867509,
-0.0850113034,
0.0088342978,
0.0241546221,
0.002235041,
0.01215016,
-0.0125163617,
-0.0231714528,
-0.009106921,
0.0231764782,
0.0161751844,
0.0033821675,
0.0119915958,
0.0281730965,
-0.0756177604,
-0.0202197619,
0.033730261,
0.0080872253,
-0.0036425551,
-0.0359488055,
-0.0382286608,
0.0339530483,
0.0235284623,
-0.0264266096,
-0.0049986229,
0.0256809499,
0.0491600521,
-0.0658289939,
0.0145822456,
0.0011473157,
0.0012324153,
0.0278309677,
-0.0055429419,
0.0019397667,
-0.0245353021,
0.0397727378,
0.0717221648,
-0.0003843478,
0.0006791413,
0.011647095,
-0.0011887293,
-0.0050850273,
0.0303193778,
-0.0378963463,
-0.0569450594,
-0.0371297933,
0.0111617818,
-0.0140240248,
-0.032227885,
0.0197953768,
0.0087059503,
-0.0042226664,
0.0055339835,
0.0472582467,
0.0389556065,
0.023776805,
0.0146365883,
-0.003119322,
-0.0240028668,
-0.0672411546,
0.0980757028,
0.0642585009,
0.0025678822,
-0.0134784235,
-0.0310323723,
-0.0466382876,
0.0370861404,
0.0551219247,
-0.0116282254,
-0.0055026803,
-0.0106915096,
-0.0045884913,
-0.0332614407,
0.0398075953,
-0.010825336,
-0.0205136184,
-0.0013291358,
0.0077302773,
0.0524368174,
0.0262460951,
0.0105580408,
-0.0450454392,
0.0116602182,
-0.0057583214,
-0.0215775259,
-0.0030057405,
-6.643589912e-33,
-0.0424219966,
0.0078115198,
0.0237632692,
-0.006448979,
0.0054046903,
-0.0130091822,
-0.0428312533,
-0.0285024215,
0.0053516207,
-0.0056636031,
-0.0478138365,
0.0018073289,
0.0358643495,
0.0110000409,
0.0415696427,
-0.042110689,
0.0194451809,
-0.0173104201,
-0.0059600961,
0.033704482,
0.0062668449,
0.0685053915,
0.033637993,
-0.0176535137,
-0.004270819,
0.0249575488,
-0.0056554959,
-0.0172027797,
0.0393953845,
0.0033985141,
-0.0238972884,
0.021359887,
0.0285743773,
-0.0596140996,
-0.0333299413,
0.068763651,
-0.0924492106,
-0.0108119464,
-0.0247412231,
0.0308010764,
0.0144900884,
-0.0187203698,
0.0336341597,
-0.0240124576,
0.0034220386,
-0.0334792659,
0.0394466929,
-0.0733477697,
-0.0130662043,
-0.002317443,
-0.0240005981,
0.017141996,
0.0032765635,
-0.0089049544,
0.1003926545,
0.054738488,
0.0184055027,
0.0145167923,
-0.0506952256,
0.0004678346,
-0.0120708551,
0.0530228391,
0.0453221351,
0.02453514,
0.0129452981,
0.0448821448,
0.0477941185,
0.0117624598,
-0.0331159867,
-0.0285649616,
-0.0010631263,
0.058973588,
0.028783286,
-0.0109000038,
0.0670218021,
-0.0217213091,
-0.0770250633,
0.0767983794,
0.0414083004,
-0.0068496917,
0.0046837199,
-0.0045246724,
-0.0262135155,
-0.0096284412,
0.0195602421,
-0.0035636269,
-0.0037236146,
0.0055319434,
0.030333221,
-0.0142119806,
0.0319079868,
-0.0182059109,
0.0239292253,
-0.0321018919,
-0.0248518288,
0.0188734196,
-0.0412095375,
0.0057652867,
0.0017116792,
-0.0228670649,
-0.0511946045,
-0.044558689,
-0.0005550851,
-0.00329151,
0.0666216612,
0.0291236322,
0.0825904459,
0.0328646749,
-0.0877165496,
-0.0263913032,
-0.0382213816,
0.0310104825,
0.057699658,
0.0737715438,
0.002967316,
0.0175127797,
0.0078440439,
0.0368239097,
0.0273777135,
-0.0028755749,
0.0255155172,
-0.0298084691,
-0.0206878241,
0.002180625,
-0.0296671651,
-0.0156139433,
-0.0662237927,
0.0257979259,
0.0142384646,
-0.0345869362,
-0.0017744902,
0.0079819579,
2.798e-7,
0.066958122,
0.0500246994,
-0.0144685116,
0.0061810561,
-0.0122623108,
0.0146102598,
-0.024382662,
0.0418355651,
-0.0122441212,
-0.028337108,
0.0412198603,
-0.0165340714,
0.1117903218,
0.031583935,
-0.0938987508,
-0.0533745587,
-0.0609879643,
-0.0010176604,
-0.0436000973,
-0.0226649567,
0.0115422606,
0.1055088118,
-0.0314143524,
-0.0498353913,
0.0388885699,
-0.0237289928,
0.0139699252,
-0.062044967,
0.0532541797,
0.0256125424,
0.0407637805,
-0.023475647,
-0.0459364913,
0.0518479943,
-0.0245782044,
0.0081257429,
0.017967619,
0.0609551519,
-0.0031876599,
0.0609357953,
0.017760057,
-0.0210259948,
0.0201241579,
-0.0895659849,
0.0769920275,
-0.0303150266,
-0.0009539512,
0.045768559,
-0.0002146299,
0.0418420397,
0.042977076,
0.01280466,
0.0097514382,
0.0075867726,
0.0364881903,
-0.0241402909,
-0.0280317757,
-0.0240900107,
-0.0320855007,
0.0268715434,
-0.0122740194,
0.0122670382,
-0.0474801473,
-0.0448108204,
-0.0200662725,
-0.0782099068,
0.0305604655,
2.715650238e-34,
0.016192561,
-0.0060196826,
0.0410753153,
0.0197520591,
0.025640931,
-0.0425674915,
0.0317796394,
0.0294689089,
0.0024040751,
-0.0662135556,
0.0189305507
] |
Subsets and Splits