id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11618v1 | Modality-Aware Negative Sampling for Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-04-23T11:22:17 | 2023-04-23T11:22:17 | Yichi Zhang, Mingyang Chen, Wen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Negative sampling (NS) is widely used in knowledge graph embedding (KGE),
which aims to generate negative triples to make a positive-negative contrast
during training. However, existing NS methods are unsuitable when multi-modal
information is considered in KGE models. They are also inefficient due to their
complex design. In this paper, we propose Modality-Aware Negative Sampling
(MANS) for multi-modal knowledge graph embedding (MMKGE) to address the
mentioned problems. MANS could align structural and visual embeddings for
entities in KGs and learn meaningful embeddings to perform better in
multi-modal KGE while keeping lightweight and efficient. Empirical results on
two benchmarks demonstrate that MANS outperforms existing NS methods.
Meanwhile, we make further explorations about MANS to confirm its
effectiveness. | [
-0.8422127366,
-0.5370451212,
0.3702127635,
-0.0606511757,
-0.4700965285,
-0.078279376,
0.0413692892,
-0.386520505,
0.7330509424,
-0.0757080838,
-0.6345852613,
-0.5809828043,
-0.3080391884,
0.0491374135,
0.143509537,
0.2440382391,
0.0100022238,
0.227060914,
-0.5133224726,
-0.4781605899,
-0.8304332495,
-0.2735749185,
-0.3460001051,
-0.4663002193,
0.5566614866,
0.29610008,
0.4455716908,
-0.0264787618,
-0.3330846727,
0.1533830017,
0.296620965,
0.4189512134,
-0.5944766402,
0.2790903151,
0.0007941241,
-0.212937206,
-0.4453984499,
0.3777648509,
0.2711692452,
0.3227313757,
-0.1034514084,
0.1295986623,
-0.2240198553,
0.4690188169,
-1.1172913313,
0.4075069129,
-0.3084676862,
0.1089943498,
-0.1712717265,
-0.2614508569,
-0.5554825664,
-0.1618752182,
-0.1237132996,
-0.9576678276,
-0.0767112821,
0.0170525331,
0.4358828962,
-0.0649701357,
-0.9733915329,
-0.0187421106,
-0.2337719649,
0.8065945506,
-0.8448088765,
0.9994014502,
0.6234253645,
0.6139276028,
0.14318946,
0.0210841242,
-0.7266037464,
-0.4573076963,
-0.0632548332,
0.3987157941,
0.2143804878,
0.0377430096,
0.0355755389,
-0.1012483612,
-0.0410593674,
-0.0105572119,
-0.2701018453,
-0.6645721197,
0.4724914432,
-0.0473348089,
0.0790715218,
-0.639967382,
-0.4134699404,
-0.2107045501,
-0.7046016455,
-0.1706187129,
0.6947157979,
0.3579109013,
-0.0824538916,
0.7214124799,
-0.3814946413,
1.0915726423,
-0.164373368,
-0.6405330896,
0.7535215616,
-0.4223987758,
-0.2640223205,
-0.2514368296,
0.3961644173,
0.5020971298,
-0.0373882726,
-0.3072807789,
-0.1426010728,
0.0178446546,
0.3730289936,
-0.9629381299,
-0.0801614672,
-0.0707847625,
-0.216483295,
-0.3898413479,
-0.2143952698,
-0.6834884286,
-0.4954453707,
-0.6659231782,
0.8060079217,
-0.7449355125,
-0.3567186594,
-0.1246532947,
-0.5447027087,
-0.0735550746,
0.5741488338,
-0.333147347,
-0.3181612194,
0.1446380019,
0.3900510073,
0.5131927729,
-0.2096201777,
-0.4347177744,
0.4676240087,
-0.1675253958,
0.4791407883,
-0.5591974258,
-0.3830672801,
-0.2638318241,
-0.329503268,
-0.3265902698,
-0.2626670599,
0.481464535,
-0.8981708288,
0.3961237669,
-0.9302244186,
-0.6519492865,
-0.6596398354,
0.9748241901,
-0.6740304232,
0.6650765538,
0.4978179038,
-0.6986983418,
0.7049043775,
-0.661480546,
-0.4325735867,
-0.2903558016,
-0.592282176,
-0.6346214414,
0.0172750857,
0.3857468665,
0.5379813313,
-0.1997027844,
0.1163802296,
-0.6925292611,
-0.2466189712,
-0.0861838758,
-0.4428459406,
0.6122534275,
0.1939328313,
-0.076355055,
-0.2480389327,
-0.7089034319,
0.140787214,
-0.1483259946,
-0.270123601,
-0.7070573568,
-0.0516822189,
-0.2547191083,
0.3403425515,
-0.1349159777,
-0.653113544,
0.2804645598,
-0.0891311914,
0.3661012053,
0.822719574,
0.2307534069,
0.4363329411,
-0.4375806749,
0.7655188441,
0.2360101789,
-0.0100107389,
0.1401278079,
-0.4488003552,
-0.1662516296,
-0.7102290988,
0.3586790264,
0.2246181965,
-1.3961715698,
0.1036529019,
-0.0344891362,
-0.4895903468,
-0.1589095592,
0.0552042685,
0.3807148635,
0.8429878354,
0.5661559701,
-0.2798501849,
-0.2175270021,
-0.9427422881,
0.0425664075,
0.03401253,
0.1446935683,
1.1055870056,
0.3376692533,
-0.2808465362,
0.9651792645,
-0.5647381544,
-0.3919306397,
0.1074167192,
0.3699136078,
-0.1950238049,
0.3656323254,
0.8579799533,
-0.8521673083,
-0.3947318792,
-0.5648242235,
-0.5915655494,
-0.0991263613,
-0.090316318,
-0.3659930527,
-0.0175148435,
0.5337198377,
-0.4026100934,
0.0070082908,
0.5166112781,
-0.3981539905,
0.577958405,
0.1642299891,
0.4215595424,
-1.5213056803,
0.0627961159,
-0.0434337482,
-0.1184071451,
-0.3531903028,
0.0854521617,
0.3287545741,
-0.1607123464,
-0.2626644075,
0.442194134,
-0.650772512,
0.1589274555,
0.0397802666,
0.1308906376,
0.2308623344,
0.5109310746,
-0.4097293913,
0.6938248873,
0.2608532608,
-0.5938615799,
0.0747155771,
0.1193348989,
-0.0925764143,
1.0455752611,
-0.0183005687,
-0.0583552234,
-0.5232245922,
0.3360082209,
-0.9805614352,
-0.1540852934,
0.5070981979,
-0.3230164647,
0.7462117672,
-0.3569659293,
-0.1828866005,
-0.3638439775,
-0.7945300341,
0.6626013517,
0.0982262343,
-0.2038468271,
0.7792075872,
0.3217541873,
0.6630772352,
-0.8584761024,
-0.3929486573,
-0.1472619623,
0.0401985794,
-0.5130773187,
0.2433064133,
-0.0787057728,
0.3147441447,
0.288515687,
-0.4272537529,
0.1487822235,
0.1509161592,
0.1052968428,
-0.0351089872,
-0.173276931,
0.3911215961,
0.1729041785,
-0.3270479739,
-0.4572906494,
-0.4380839467,
0.7671820521,
0.3417114615,
-1.1709550619,
-0.3008453548,
0.1332465261,
0.7745169997,
-0.0611593612,
0.5983657241,
1.125885129,
-0.3677156568,
0.1497371495,
-0.604703784,
-0.3105441034,
-0.4342737496,
0.239954263,
-0.3454165757,
-0.7587246895,
0.2138907909,
-0.0375847109,
-0.2422231585,
0.256034404,
0.291867435,
-0.1013779938,
0.8305621147,
0.5051993132,
-0.3215792477,
0.5606620908,
-0.5332497358,
0.2623098195,
-0.9356380105,
-0.2758991718,
-0.1671677828,
-0.8556680083,
-0.1531236917,
-0.5713288188,
0.798999548,
0.440353483,
-0.1916149259,
0.2825764418,
-0.1339063793,
0.3827809691,
0.8230220675,
0.2750152349,
0.1144026816,
-0.0707103312,
-0.4393150806,
-0.2037127018,
-0.6690097451,
0.1166715249,
1.0160236359,
-0.2985275388,
0.7720351815,
0.2675626278,
0.7608596683,
0.2352804095,
0.4976079166,
-0.8598387837,
0.4971135557,
0.1874032319,
-0.7734324932,
-0.2080620527,
-0.5538698435,
-0.4714595675,
0.4112232625,
-0.3979223371,
-0.4193581045,
0.6082576513,
0.4416650832,
-0.0975009128,
0.4595552087,
-0.9458687901,
0.7137116194,
0.255890578,
0.0479021929,
-0.3470152318,
-0.4685697556,
0.3972920775,
0.1084711552,
0.2828511,
-0.1958471537,
0.0420093127,
0.5000614524,
-0.2121861279,
1.1094952822,
-0.9219084978,
-0.1033961028,
0.392139256,
0.2854191959,
0.6232823133,
0.371735245,
-0.0147935329,
-0.130271554,
-0.3178386092,
-0.5333274603,
-0.5186747313,
0.4338609874,
-0.8707292676,
-0.2752738893,
-0.0761329159,
-0.6172143221,
-0.6791580915,
0.3731031716,
0.0968987867,
0.8214517832,
0.1887620389,
0.220186457,
0.2634691596,
-0.1818393916,
0.1847545654,
0.6729540229,
0.0946088731,
-0.774748385,
1.2201420069,
0.5531010032,
0.429102838,
0.569922626,
0.2522944212,
-0.2290717959,
-0.429980576,
-0.7666395307,
0.0678606406,
-0.637938261,
-0.6271458268,
-0.7231772542,
0.204852283,
-0.2386355251,
-0.5088717341,
-0.3227847517,
-0.5232489109,
-0.2497917861,
-0.0767841935,
0.2448427677,
0.0690990239,
-0.3146435022,
0.166169554,
-0.6591871977,
0.5751960874,
0.7260039449,
0.3362537324,
0.3051839769,
-0.0189082753,
-0.0639878586,
0.3403778076,
-0.3696362972,
-1.0291804075,
0.0524912216,
0.0547467545,
0.7030023932,
0.6250146031,
0.1539089084,
0.8296333551,
-0.0947443321,
0.6969648004,
0.3597213924,
-0.5930623412,
-0.0555625372,
-0.5157422423,
0.1375849843,
0.8994184136,
0.474165082,
-0.7182278633,
-0.1469521523,
-0.3744154871,
-0.9204909801,
0.6848171949,
-0.0552387573,
0.1350432932,
-0.0240738187,
0.2024274766,
0.162975654,
0.6570032835,
-0.6952731013,
-0.2332167029,
-0.468639642,
-0.0546672642,
-0.0804092214,
-0.3006817102,
-0.4249430299,
-0.2475134879,
0.9721265435,
-0.4216125906,
0.6101750731,
0.0985672697,
-0.4251436293,
-0.1911251694,
0.3824576735,
0.7820822597,
0.5693463087,
-0.2345818281,
0.2339584678,
0.1830670834,
-0.3725266457,
0.3063849211,
0.1404415816,
-0.3436027169,
-0.2972150743,
0.2421585172,
0.4008797407,
0.1424867064,
-0.3116159439,
0.7249245048,
0.177403301,
-0.3477530479,
-0.0163085181,
-0.07558202,
0.3576077521,
0.3803053796,
0.1268168241,
0.5469742417,
-0.0224023219,
-0.1925992668,
-0.0158243924,
0.6522898078,
-0.50346452,
-0.3787001669,
0.5356044769,
0.1696793139,
0.0666434318,
0.6033765674,
-0.9128099084,
-0.4904064238,
0.3199724555,
0.5918689966,
0.590821743,
0.1822013706,
0.3863280416,
0.3607408702,
0.306725651,
0.3312538862,
0.6268732548,
-0.4975884259,
-1.0146137476,
-0.6264269948,
-0.3858207762,
-0.2098410428,
-0.0053173965,
-0.3366884887,
0.3202762008,
0.0493546464,
-0.1861864924,
-0.3282569945,
-0.1171319559,
-0.6547780633,
-0.0549212694,
0.1806219965,
0.8821796179,
-1.1198096275,
0.6620575786,
0.5975245237,
-0.5290884972,
-0.7637774348,
-0.1706727594,
0.310898304,
-1.0324078798,
0.4474995732,
0.2116424292,
-0.3988704681,
0.0168004427,
-0.2980115116,
-0.7584380507,
1.6845908165,
0.4104984999,
-0.1029402763,
0.161142692,
-0.2298066318,
0.0653759241,
0.1873430461,
0.1736990809,
-0.3779961765,
0.813102603,
0.0306104403,
-0.4375948608,
0.2169283181,
-0.2066167742,
-0.2322396934,
0.5917068124,
-0.8631942272,
0.8481573462,
-0.0386839807,
-0.1712119132,
-0.3471660614,
0.2393462062,
0.1749817431,
0.510389328,
0.8473703861,
1.1406074762,
0.705601573,
0.2786925137,
0.8791787028,
-0.3676601648,
0.2851787806,
0.9366880655,
-0.0545001589,
0.12301559,
0.5077893138,
-0.0784061179,
0.2329282463,
0.3231897354,
0.2187920362,
0.7192126513,
-0.1405723393,
-0.3323549628,
-0.2941419482,
0.1424589753,
-0.7845284939,
0.3106527328,
0.2357599884,
-0.1515796334,
-0.6726124883,
0.0464283787,
0.2212242186,
-0.4296979308,
-0.0327080302,
0.4531380534,
-0.0534057431,
-0.2805397809,
0.5548036695,
0.2181807756,
0.7780975699,
-0.7539166808,
-0.0213832632,
0.0561379232,
-0.1637137681,
-0.178633973,
-0.0649961829,
-0.0840407386,
-0.8877168298,
-0.2032717317,
-0.2566410899,
0.917124033,
-0.3159596622,
-0.2050697803,
0.1532501131,
1.0986971855,
-0.4721587598,
-0.0508925579,
-0.3259107172,
-0.663523674,
-0.061708983,
-0.3908830881,
0.4493841827,
0.2887353599,
-0.1038455665,
0.4416971803,
0.7594476342,
-0.299015075,
-0.0085102525,
0.4336565733,
0.9464167356,
-0.5830311179,
-0.5259535313,
-0.865483582,
0.31988886,
-0.1111836135,
-0.1571699977,
0.936047256,
0.4559881091,
0.8055967093,
-0.0976340771,
0.5631636381,
-0.4423252642,
0.2222519517,
-0.4495375156,
0.6851319671,
-0.6702496409,
-0.0001923735,
-0.4199260771,
-0.6153436303,
-0.1486970335,
0.4423301518,
-0.3612354696,
0.2337101698,
0.3319694698,
0.9473753572,
-0.4853166938,
0.1893583238,
0.2440157086,
0.1011559814,
0.619407177,
0.2501300275,
0.7474095821,
-0.2792102695,
0.2482480854,
-0.4059742391,
0.0188729297,
-0.4334629178,
-1.150079608,
-0.5420395732,
-0.557164669,
0.1168091521,
-0.2261051685,
-0.318318367,
1.0831952095,
1.0757906437,
-0.4954870343,
0.3349150717,
0.1293285489,
0.2054851055,
-0.481341064,
-0.1961523294,
0.3285385072,
-0.1823353022,
-0.3467145264,
0.5015510321,
0.1791154146,
0.0343400054,
-0.3393810093,
-0.0595664196,
-0.2997636497,
-0.2260849774,
0.8778693676,
0.0951559842,
-0.0355321169,
-0.5909984112,
-0.1141989157,
0.1687383503,
0.0287567843,
0.9943261147,
-0.989723742,
0.8168937564,
0.6762949824,
0.7125920653,
0.5539293885,
0.025217155,
0.3915719986,
-1.3046660423,
0.0863626078,
0.4370978177,
0.4959826767,
0.0724785998,
-0.0874932334,
0.2690219283,
0.7553190589,
-0.1746134013,
-0.4920779169,
0.5681741238,
-1.1140370369,
-0.3708071411,
1.103482604,
0.3793089986,
0.0769219771,
-0.2527896762,
-0.2338081449,
0.2364479154,
-0.5924808979,
0.7775107026,
0.6832197309,
-0.2158153355,
0.4320331514,
-0.794488728,
-0.0183785986,
0.1958290637,
-0.3915660679,
-0.4466934204,
0.7960991859,
0.287035048,
0.3478247821,
1.1127715111,
-0.1243824735,
0.1660235077,
0.0273688994,
-0.0566996522,
-0.9271637201,
-0.1380473375,
0.2241845727,
0.5076178312,
0.0080040833,
-0.0841286108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11567v1 | Differentiate ChatGPT-generated and Human-written Medical Texts | 2023-04-23T07:38:07 | 2023-04-23T07:38:07 | Wenxiong Liao, Zhengliang Liu, Haixing Dai, Shaochen Xu, Zihao Wu, Yiyang Zhang, Xiaoke Huang, Dajiang Zhu, Hongmin Cai, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Background: Large language models such as ChatGPT are capable of generating
grammatically perfect and human-like text content, and a large number of
ChatGPT-generated texts have appeared on the Internet. However, medical texts
such as clinical notes and diagnoses require rigorous validation, and erroneous
medical content generated by ChatGPT could potentially lead to disinformation
that poses significant harm to healthcare and the general public.
Objective: This research is among the first studies on responsible and
ethical AIGC (Artificial Intelligence Generated Content) in medicine. We focus
on analyzing the differences between medical texts written by human experts and
generated by ChatGPT, and designing machine learning workflows to effectively
detect and differentiate medical texts generated by ChatGPT.
Methods: We first construct a suite of datasets containing medical texts
written by human experts and generated by ChatGPT. In the next step, we analyze
the linguistic features of these two types of content and uncover differences
in vocabulary, part-of-speech, dependency, sentiment, perplexity, etc. Finally,
we design and implement machine learning methods to detect medical text
generated by ChatGPT.
Results: Medical texts written by humans are more concrete, more diverse, and
typically contain more useful information, while medical texts generated by
ChatGPT pay more attention to fluency and logic, and usually express general
terminologies rather than effective information specific to the context of the
problem. A BERT-based model can effectively detect medical texts generated by
ChatGPT, and the F1 exceeds 95%. | [
-0.0855086446,
-1.0559024811,
0.4309570491,
0.096285142,
-0.2607104182,
0.1759458333,
-0.2233983427,
-0.7973241806,
-0.0282511096,
0.4376612306,
-0.4407925606,
-0.6456224322,
-0.7639906406,
0.317632854,
-0.2471278161,
1.3053622246,
0.087760523,
0.3436536193,
-0.3642440438,
0.0513098761,
-0.2089804411,
-0.6299325824,
-0.8134067655,
-0.358550936,
0.3558683991,
0.170462206,
0.6013679504,
0.6584661603,
0.8017349243,
0.2811414301,
-0.0163862407,
0.3678107858,
-0.2653931379,
0.0237027761,
0.0158106852,
-0.0491223335,
-0.2013578117,
0.0922305584,
0.1323032081,
0.2014464438,
-0.2152983993,
0.0131097827,
0.1982119083,
0.685901463,
-0.1044317558,
0.4200209677,
-0.5518138409,
0.2592239976,
-0.2027863264,
-0.3839717209,
-0.4366557896,
-0.4575562775,
0.335557133,
-0.5505476594,
0.3554568291,
-0.0171228591,
1.0648839474,
0.3221826851,
-0.2601660788,
-0.9567789435,
-0.4748122394,
0.4426716268,
-0.908487618,
0.0838954747,
0.2924173772,
0.0353748724,
-0.2689262629,
-0.8546233773,
-0.6579241157,
-0.4402076304,
-0.409824729,
0.2664126456,
-0.1073312089,
0.1795396805,
0.0994046479,
0.2788708508,
-0.7570334077,
0.1757696122,
-0.4609873593,
-0.3407727778,
0.8258744478,
0.1350661516,
0.7326222062,
-0.4688522518,
-0.1828696728,
0.090648219,
-0.64457196,
-0.0737008452,
0.1214752644,
-0.1190115064,
-0.0121692335,
0.4734998941,
0.036535345,
0.3507728577,
-0.029778149,
-0.4921219945,
0.2788609862,
-0.2100300491,
-0.2091149986,
0.3045089543,
1.2463922501,
0.3828423321,
0.4841628671,
-0.1354893446,
0.0544073395,
-0.0008254233,
0.4348934591,
-0.8627161384,
-0.4986027479,
0.1629903615,
-0.8969237208,
-0.54440552,
-0.1232868433,
-0.4430208802,
-0.7996478081,
-0.2635633349,
0.223333016,
-0.5282986164,
-0.0171598811,
-0.0251761004,
0.0043996675,
0.1197805181,
0.3319615722,
-0.7294802666,
0.2300850004,
0.5145605803,
0.5060636997,
-0.2737745941,
0.0150100281,
-0.1109173447,
-0.133625865,
-0.3006340265,
0.9050948024,
-0.2065594196,
-0.3560993969,
-0.061139781,
-0.0956786349,
-0.1375951767,
-0.6927581429,
0.7959976196,
-0.2676850855,
0.6004507542,
-0.0314670689,
-0.6849703193,
-0.3245678544,
0.2355192453,
-0.4378232658,
0.8060040474,
0.0561360866,
-0.9372843504,
0.555267632,
-0.6958181858,
-0.780577004,
0.341596663,
-0.6743266582,
-0.9330729246,
-0.1802035272,
0.2984336615,
0.5245155096,
-0.3775702119,
0.5265741348,
0.1366139203,
-0.1587163359,
0.5653098226,
-0.6575682759,
0.727989018,
0.2893485427,
-0.4567985535,
0.0428345911,
-0.7351639271,
0.0342587568,
0.1985761076,
-0.5139324665,
-0.1443705261,
0.5406073332,
0.2060157955,
0.2785624862,
0.0148832304,
-0.632935524,
0.1647126526,
-0.3575496376,
0.4929263294,
0.4481111765,
0.3246541619,
-0.1656265557,
-0.5881755948,
0.4180260599,
0.2522059083,
0.1638388634,
-0.0633448064,
-1.0064617395,
-0.2340658307,
-0.4229396582,
0.2305731624,
0.8097952604,
-0.5504996181,
0.6163925529,
-0.1003143117,
-0.5165672302,
-0.8762542009,
-0.0632942095,
0.5278193951,
1.0481655598,
0.4363604188,
-0.209436655,
-0.3494307399,
-0.9891367555,
-0.2937740088,
-0.3847152889,
-0.0711567849,
0.5701870322,
0.3743132949,
-0.4311789572,
0.7022929192,
-0.5889683962,
-0.433263123,
-0.1192360371,
0.2558561265,
-0.0977150202,
0.5212314129,
0.5452412963,
-0.8301477432,
-0.8421280384,
0.2012714297,
-0.8201537728,
-0.395260036,
-0.3900261819,
-0.022418946,
0.1553775221,
0.3901652992,
-0.5488844514,
0.8008582592,
0.2576680183,
-0.4360932112,
0.4180279374,
-0.4855562449,
0.3904770613,
-1.0971707106,
0.2579748631,
0.0200412907,
-0.1826080084,
-0.6482962966,
-0.2328592092,
0.0859747753,
0.0354546607,
-0.1801247895,
0.5336304307,
-0.1166285798,
0.4570070505,
-0.2022303641,
-0.0940679386,
0.1558458209,
0.2969014645,
0.221142143,
0.5979619026,
0.2824586928,
-0.5317767859,
0.1693256199,
0.6476136446,
-0.2498774379,
0.4065491259,
-0.7829294801,
-0.1349431723,
-0.1460938454,
0.2026620507,
-0.9231407642,
-0.4236527383,
0.5744675994,
-0.8753381371,
0.1282343119,
-0.1664574295,
-0.7592240572,
-0.2775335908,
0.1376126558,
0.0499605611,
0.8770219684,
-0.1262837499,
0.2203957886,
0.5507583618,
-0.5259944201,
-0.2532968223,
-0.8010433316,
0.0002514378,
0.0474550836,
-0.6086084247,
0.2602476776,
0.0329768248,
-0.3117995858,
0.0588581264,
0.2860018611,
-0.3857604861,
0.0892692208,
0.383009702,
0.3917395473,
-0.1561183035,
0.533537209,
0.3191569746,
0.1215835065,
0.1985777915,
-0.0912064016,
0.3157757223,
0.144853428,
-0.5186460614,
-0.6483249664,
0.6399809718,
0.4930969775,
-0.3103097677,
0.6970518231,
0.8260657787,
-0.4087177515,
0.2619235218,
-0.55272156,
-0.1869534999,
-0.4131997228,
0.3069299161,
0.3669065833,
-0.54678756,
0.4297657609,
0.423086226,
0.2164977044,
0.7642562389,
0.9526838064,
-0.33078444,
1.1667470932,
0.1244899258,
0.081553936,
0.116529718,
0.1516329199,
0.3378654122,
-0.3644018173,
-0.3879601061,
-0.4326179326,
-0.0990855023,
-0.9759199619,
-0.1722242534,
0.4980205297,
-0.4170594513,
-0.0317234993,
-0.1615207791,
-0.997664392,
0.3031943142,
0.5907889009,
0.4295005798,
0.3397605419,
-0.0058523547,
-0.2137159556,
-0.0645665079,
-0.6499041319,
-0.6951723695,
1.1215981245,
0.2902177274,
0.4960360527,
-0.1266625524,
0.6486955881,
0.5828418136,
0.5490604639,
-0.7158117294,
0.344851017,
-0.439630419,
-0.6664803028,
0.1301239133,
-0.4230985045,
-1.1590226889,
0.0026476427,
-0.3780948222,
-0.5235944986,
-0.2693567872,
0.0264895316,
-0.2801099718,
0.2620648444,
-0.8913341761,
0.6475997567,
-0.2002424151,
0.0024730179,
-0.029755244,
-0.7685709,
-0.109709613,
-0.0096504353,
0.0774365067,
-0.0033687656,
0.1415146887,
0.77350384,
-0.4256099463,
0.7685133815,
-0.0180864967,
-0.095206365,
0.5993334651,
-0.1138862371,
0.1769825369,
0.3416538835,
0.1669704318,
0.2694995105,
-0.0806611478,
-0.2848134935,
0.0023293714,
0.3978198767,
-0.8496800661,
-0.4125397801,
-0.4809285998,
-0.4656406641,
0.0252185557,
0.4101196826,
0.6555235386,
0.4944094718,
-0.2462128699,
0.0170480292,
0.6113138795,
-0.5454194546,
0.3356707394,
0.5381640196,
0.2360292226,
-0.236871019,
0.8379588127,
-0.1918928027,
0.0067173215,
0.3350882232,
0.4478256404,
-0.2608217895,
-0.7829167247,
-0.6056272984,
0.2423462719,
-0.5322534442,
0.0802191943,
-0.7292848229,
-0.5966126919,
-0.5111603141,
-0.0704620034,
-0.0390167534,
-0.0506713837,
-0.5215504169,
0.2718425095,
0.434926182,
0.8622710109,
0.1387548149,
0.17327483,
-1.1206641197,
0.2403771281,
-0.0447221138,
0.1578462869,
-0.2942332327,
-0.2055943161,
-0.011545266,
0.1007039621,
-0.4474795163,
-0.830530405,
0.5768779516,
0.0397743024,
0.5953143239,
0.630602181,
-0.0713661611,
0.3381345868,
-0.6352396011,
0.8025633693,
0.0639222041,
-0.5580490828,
0.4908725321,
-0.5339182615,
0.1395936012,
0.5504658222,
0.396009922,
-0.7132694125,
-0.5552852154,
-0.8741239309,
-0.5519781709,
0.3479705453,
0.4999016523,
-0.1379019618,
-0.2523836195,
0.4377046824,
0.3352068067,
0.1869264245,
-0.6671337485,
-0.1243444085,
0.0938207433,
-0.6253892183,
0.2144327462,
-0.0123654623,
-0.2643710375,
-0.0048026559,
0.4420771599,
-0.051327996,
0.4627572894,
0.5691260099,
-0.0512819178,
0.1830063611,
0.291290313,
0.6458419561,
0.4524968266,
0.1697882265,
-0.2017792463,
-0.2265883684,
-1.0003108978,
-0.0848681033,
0.3317723572,
-0.3046200275,
0.1503734589,
0.5898014903,
0.5138652921,
-0.2422118932,
-0.9783258438,
0.6097306609,
-0.2335426807,
-0.3534454703,
-0.3587712646,
0.1544595808,
-0.0010934225,
0.1103088781,
0.1304638684,
0.2751252353,
0.2894720733,
-0.1702822894,
0.3060775995,
0.2676707804,
-0.3114472032,
-0.0852642283,
0.6045404077,
0.2148130536,
-0.251793921,
0.9254593253,
-0.2202852815,
-0.2994828224,
0.7358778715,
0.1939956397,
0.6666879654,
-0.0214103051,
0.2962263525,
0.2832723856,
0.0355574042,
0.1688121408,
0.2583431005,
0.1255930662,
-0.4629416168,
-0.3514650762,
-0.139632687,
-0.3708596528,
0.2126864046,
-0.639329195,
0.2468709946,
-0.3562102318,
-0.1872287393,
0.2411007732,
0.0000929745,
-0.4562164843,
0.4566404223,
0.0786434636,
0.3793077767,
-0.7043527961,
0.5436022282,
0.6973366141,
-0.4053349495,
-0.7318919301,
0.1883693486,
0.2104392797,
-0.943810463,
0.3155956268,
0.1978259832,
0.3262189329,
-0.2711862624,
-0.5218776464,
-0.2684558034,
0.9130751491,
-0.1483615935,
-0.2955730259,
-0.1810443401,
0.333330214,
0.9392217994,
-0.2144803703,
0.346121192,
0.1813032925,
0.2032687068,
0.0241368096,
-1.1108256578,
-0.0758249611,
-0.3479219675,
-0.4168944955,
0.1166328713,
-0.3688382506,
0.8424453735,
-0.1696204841,
-0.262735188,
0.0680065155,
0.1137293279,
0.2043941319,
0.4300378561,
0.1672013253,
0.2759119272,
0.9517444372,
-0.1050432697,
0.9742365479,
-0.2316834033,
0.1768916398,
0.7501555681,
-0.1602769196,
0.502314508,
0.2210404277,
0.0190015864,
0.5837780833,
0.7562986612,
-0.1984766573,
0.2708391249,
0.2032434642,
-0.4393552542,
0.0463477708,
0.0137035325,
-0.4478504956,
0.4649210274,
0.5847385526,
-0.9323239326,
0.0186817423,
-0.0499827228,
0.3688307405,
0.0107451035,
-0.1841994077,
1.2991909981,
-0.1003520638,
-0.9263980389,
0.3655216992,
0.0426101089,
0.3579078913,
-0.4746626019,
-0.0876247138,
0.1671869904,
0.3407756984,
-0.2984838188,
-0.9221913218,
0.2209046036,
0.1877975762,
-0.0286395326,
-0.0856128559,
1.0312731266,
-0.3938211501,
-0.5819413066,
-0.2688512206,
0.6247263551,
0.2307553887,
0.08550331,
-0.8570489883,
-0.4108498693,
0.1480875313,
-0.1038595885,
0.2165765464,
0.5614671707,
-0.0440819077,
0.695957005,
0.7462545633,
0.429703027,
-0.1555155963,
-0.0863790587,
0.7116652727,
-0.4456370175,
-0.7517923713,
-1.040705204,
0.4124805033,
-0.3540776968,
-0.4228592813,
0.2745692432,
0.4378091693,
0.3716058135,
-0.2641671896,
1.1668412685,
-0.2559176981,
0.760760963,
-0.4950324595,
1.4074528217,
-0.2156222463,
0.1373906285,
-0.292330116,
-0.0687707216,
-0.4297694266,
0.6829169989,
-0.1584397554,
0.0252788961,
0.7150752544,
0.5727342963,
0.190844655,
0.0921797901,
-0.1079499871,
0.0939615443,
0.5985528231,
0.5307560563,
0.6748437285,
-0.2369867712,
0.5631431937,
-0.0117805591,
-0.2058036178,
-0.2749896049,
-0.8118520379,
-1.034427166,
-0.5179119706,
-0.5345633626,
-0.3515556753,
-0.0929640755,
0.8996233344,
0.6031444073,
-0.7521020174,
0.3106428981,
-0.2629072666,
-0.134214893,
-0.1844952703,
-0.2469967604,
0.6526686549,
-0.1382452548,
-0.4640400708,
-0.1343852431,
0.2030100673,
0.1815617532,
-0.2138422132,
0.0048148856,
0.0402913503,
0.0626119599,
0.4862424731,
0.198917836,
-0.6229717731,
-0.1597743779,
0.0271614827,
-0.6575322747,
0.4669724405,
0.8576635718,
-0.6776921153,
0.4751240015,
0.5608186722,
0.6398636103,
-0.1124838144,
-0.075557746,
0.4510104358,
-0.4948720336,
-0.1130544394,
0.6740450263,
0.2091172785,
0.2265427262,
-0.7280934453,
0.371699214,
0.3440836072,
-0.9058781266,
-0.3567835093,
-0.0094873821,
-1.050335288,
-0.2249783725,
1.1984890699,
-0.3385498226,
0.0514587089,
-0.3613752127,
-0.7850544453,
0.4559123814,
-0.3516531289,
1.1497576237,
0.553267777,
-0.4793866277,
0.1161448061,
-0.6098650098,
0.7628704906,
0.1199584678,
-1.2845630646,
-0.2415436059,
0.3151810169,
0.364900738,
-0.0286948271,
0.8038106561,
-0.5705862641,
0.5098456144,
-0.1773037463,
-0.0007018781,
-0.0069337757,
0.2104611546,
0.271907717,
0.0209237542,
-0.1234892979,
-0.2647283673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11556v1 | Divide and Prompt: Chain of Thought Prompting for Text-to-SQL | 2023-04-23T06:52:35 | 2023-04-23T06:52:35 | Xiping Liu, Zhao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting combined with large language models (LLMs)
have achieved encouraging results on complex reasoning tasks. Text-to-SQL is a
critical semantic parsing task that converts natural language questions into
SQL statements, involving a complex reasoning process. However, there is little
work about using CoT prompting to activate LLM's reasoning capabilities on
Text-to-SQL tasks. In this work, we propose a new paradigm for prompting
Text-to-SQL tasks, called Divide-and-Prompt, which first divides the task into
subtasks, and then approach each subtask through CoT. We present 3
prompting-based methods to enhance the Text-to-SQL ability of LLMs. Experiments
show that these prompts guide LLMs to generate Text-to-SQL with higher
execution accuracy. | [
-0.6069813371,
-1.2075152397,
0.9918239713,
0.4457473755,
-0.4428084195,
0.3788592219,
-0.1321395785,
-0.2233341038,
0.153849259,
0.6044120789,
-1.0747812986,
-0.5075609088,
-0.2621136308,
0.5319471359,
-0.5100979209,
0.8748248219,
-0.0516638458,
0.1840097606,
-0.4023490548,
0.2284373343,
-1.066136837,
-0.5762354136,
-0.6100994945,
-0.1996487677,
0.757843852,
0.4867230952,
0.5303928852,
0.2852933109,
0.2528973818,
0.1935185939,
-0.3451213837,
0.5563435555,
-0.0515542775,
0.5731386542,
-0.6010499001,
-0.8018211126,
-0.3731840849,
-0.1614646316,
0.3464019001,
0.676653862,
-0.0116132852,
-0.0957385376,
-0.2387990505,
1.0200163126,
-0.6520598531,
-0.3529930413,
-0.5743890405,
0.0198556501,
0.053225711,
-0.242308408,
-0.7927477956,
-0.3652443886,
0.1067098081,
-0.281683594,
0.1987567544,
0.4589881301,
0.3230648637,
0.1571377516,
-0.5743598938,
-0.5179212689,
-0.4563497603,
0.6457954049,
-0.3240171075,
0.360886246,
0.1439018995,
0.2114500105,
-0.2736875117,
-0.5899509192,
-0.6865254641,
-0.2659277022,
-0.0372255705,
-0.1888822764,
0.1533308625,
0.0949348062,
0.3015369773,
0.2788498104,
-0.3217901886,
-0.0763174891,
-0.1665613949,
0.2371343374,
0.5105035305,
0.3735612035,
0.5292072892,
-0.1069080159,
-0.6680208445,
0.1746627688,
-0.7967768312,
-0.0898832381,
0.0355671905,
0.5245442986,
0.15992558,
0.7897526622,
-0.1791486442,
1.0043789148,
0.1638956517,
-0.0300028864,
-0.308532685,
-0.5435125232,
-0.4869304001,
0.2607030272,
0.6144972444,
0.1906187087,
0.0756092891,
-0.0366248004,
-0.3102850616,
0.116930142,
0.2809811234,
-0.2808854282,
-0.0178760048,
0.530606389,
-0.3563764393,
-0.3442254961,
-0.3740180731,
-0.7536671758,
-0.5880350471,
-0.5639677048,
0.3723661602,
-0.4413525462,
0.0177513268,
0.0579797141,
-0.2280148119,
0.1928321719,
0.7883867025,
-0.8236455917,
0.527605176,
0.7276462317,
0.864084065,
-0.6864742637,
-0.0915638432,
-0.5609408617,
0.1191601604,
-0.573590219,
1.1221464872,
-0.4100393355,
-0.514056623,
0.0795288458,
-0.1092395261,
-0.0399870872,
-0.6121494174,
0.3246605694,
-0.536115706,
0.4890013039,
-0.757111907,
-0.6447755694,
0.0737145022,
0.4825657904,
-0.6657972336,
1.1095647812,
-0.1574426591,
-0.5842803121,
0.3186998963,
-0.7182630301,
-0.5806668401,
0.0584461354,
-0.4059625864,
0.098414205,
0.0230216868,
0.7276739478,
0.2918842137,
-0.7743620872,
0.1760264337,
-0.0084857894,
-0.0050655557,
0.3115401268,
-0.2257995605,
0.8421432376,
0.1495228559,
-0.1780152917,
0.3123852611,
-0.353918761,
0.1100110784,
0.020284418,
-0.1293670982,
-0.0810270235,
0.044575531,
-0.2810801566,
0.1609059572,
0.1375494301,
-0.2384277582,
0.3910902739,
-0.4009140134,
0.3308618665,
0.6050425172,
0.2119867057,
0.5306959748,
-0.2718206644,
0.7593417168,
0.1923395842,
0.1926753819,
-0.2439994961,
-0.5198196769,
-0.7949262261,
-0.2681092322,
0.0717328191,
0.7786173224,
-1.1102097034,
0.5054960251,
0.2981981933,
-0.1897015572,
-0.1818862855,
-0.131438747,
0.2423506379,
0.3852514923,
0.6577969193,
0.0795143917,
-0.3057729304,
-0.4426719844,
-0.4339502454,
-0.0827461332,
0.051959727,
0.0830937177,
0.3852734268,
0.2602597177,
1.1076536179,
-0.6022901535,
-0.2784087956,
-0.5330247879,
-0.0914147198,
0.1143785268,
0.2984511256,
0.0461970046,
-0.6214441657,
-0.3016535938,
-0.2717907727,
-0.5501772165,
-0.0294401348,
-0.3097975552,
-0.4111613333,
0.1818873137,
0.6191536188,
-0.6799474955,
0.3384070992,
-0.0088346759,
-0.6250204444,
0.873783052,
0.0377760306,
0.3081947565,
-1.2358155251,
-0.3734098375,
-0.3978196383,
-0.2609801292,
-0.4424875379,
-0.0957029909,
-0.162813589,
-0.0383478142,
-0.5622909069,
0.361408323,
-0.7000467181,
-0.1601517946,
-0.1766728014,
0.3472900689,
0.1305065602,
0.169863224,
0.022135511,
1.0093245506,
0.576839149,
-0.7237582803,
0.6254755259,
0.4629243016,
-0.3441650867,
0.7895124555,
-0.5247924328,
0.2300312668,
0.0264080781,
0.5076295733,
-1.1523536444,
-0.0928099677,
0.0648624897,
-0.1831679195,
-0.0617861524,
-0.0642115399,
-0.5817902088,
-0.2330065072,
-0.2994243801,
0.539432466,
0.4133116603,
-0.8179314733,
0.5745277405,
0.093064107,
-0.2802359462,
-0.5349432826,
-0.8024139404,
0.2664428353,
-0.006604665,
-0.5274111629,
0.5347694159,
0.19856143,
-0.3806993663,
-0.1736299545,
-0.1050535738,
-0.1414646357,
-0.4024967849,
-0.0152074024,
0.73441118,
-0.0237915367,
0.3081906438,
0.6209782958,
0.0607446656,
0.2808964252,
-0.5424980521,
0.5639793277,
0.2511910498,
-0.1894149333,
-0.4141942561,
0.6899802685,
0.3378701508,
-0.266274035,
0.7867243886,
-0.0167053938,
-0.1509611011,
-0.4637036622,
-0.5787464976,
-0.2184996903,
-0.4651887715,
-0.1655022353,
-0.2899522483,
-0.9775379896,
0.2198605984,
-0.5069301724,
0.1183033511,
0.1676526964,
0.8048003316,
-0.1508644968,
1.0565407276,
0.304428488,
0.3783720732,
0.4826176465,
0.0327040553,
0.3931190073,
-0.7811382413,
-0.4422523081,
-0.6262778044,
-0.0785325244,
-0.1079581007,
-0.9676668644,
0.2228790522,
0.2380360067,
-0.1542835534,
0.0356446728,
-0.8600698709,
0.9233090878,
0.198931098,
0.2563530803,
0.4177529514,
0.118189618,
-0.5394362807,
0.1870477647,
-0.5871363282,
-0.3885542154,
0.4958381057,
-0.0025348573,
0.7568765283,
-0.1144703925,
0.8578555584,
0.5329911709,
-0.010309861,
-0.9224117994,
0.8907520175,
0.0418998748,
-0.5847986341,
-0.3424659967,
-0.2628152072,
-0.6618306041,
0.1437950134,
-0.0435499586,
-0.77366364,
0.3158829808,
0.0170920398,
-0.3289762735,
0.1719866842,
-0.7816300392,
0.5460017323,
-0.076649949,
-0.2374983579,
-0.2584981024,
-0.6393700838,
0.3400068879,
0.359171927,
0.1521416157,
-0.1498419195,
-0.4423976541,
0.7350431085,
-0.8384595513,
0.7258651257,
-0.0409612432,
-0.2901762724,
0.6423891783,
0.4069610238,
0.7290282249,
0.0426640809,
-0.0861471966,
-0.4139123261,
-0.0241444949,
-0.2834622264,
-0.7716897726,
0.5207832456,
-0.2644748688,
-0.6479857564,
-0.3048674166,
-0.591386497,
-0.4836616218,
-0.018785648,
0.4214282334,
0.3717449605,
0.0487556048,
-0.3096117079,
0.7553542256,
-0.2089983672,
0.3438037932,
0.0250477735,
-0.540661335,
-0.7295218706,
0.3848385513,
-0.1474542618,
0.5080639124,
0.5866439342,
-0.023416331,
-0.8992257714,
-0.2895353138,
-0.5574231148,
0.1507856399,
-0.8912116885,
-0.2690925002,
-0.7550912499,
0.1338528544,
-0.1687701643,
-0.5298913121,
-0.127134189,
-0.6088231206,
-0.3522304595,
-0.2887128294,
0.6970584989,
0.7034721375,
0.5184276104,
0.1624572724,
-0.668163538,
0.2579855621,
0.474112004,
-0.0226045828,
0.0754790381,
-0.2039292902,
0.0460955985,
-0.254707247,
-0.1620417982,
-1.1519473791,
0.087023586,
-0.2534003556,
0.0236964803,
-0.2068204582,
0.2886832058,
0.7235981226,
-0.5986196995,
1.2192664146,
0.6289600134,
-1.3165705204,
1.0056730509,
-0.287782371,
0.1667123288,
0.4516827166,
0.3261678219,
-0.2797057927,
-0.408936888,
-0.3298781216,
-0.7971411347,
0.7642582059,
0.2134347856,
-0.1463577896,
-0.3132959306,
0.1828432381,
0.1308872849,
0.1435859352,
-0.5236362219,
-0.0837077498,
0.2342108786,
-0.0746373385,
0.438337028,
-0.2557004988,
-0.1652472913,
-0.1959269792,
0.2697630823,
-0.2301177531,
0.4379796088,
0.537150383,
0.0092727784,
0.0080663776,
0.6279697418,
0.4578390419,
0.7441112995,
0.357899636,
0.3544305563,
0.5753042698,
-0.2086446136,
0.4519479871,
-0.4610628188,
0.0209232308,
0.0050790161,
0.3080885708,
0.7561825514,
-0.3054528534,
-0.545768857,
0.2541061938,
-0.1985648125,
-0.3009091914,
0.1709574163,
0.257734865,
0.289927125,
0.285823375,
0.2305250764,
-0.0712869018,
0.076804392,
-0.5526481867,
0.0003294919,
0.0994507447,
-0.3764979541,
0.2600208223,
0.5147887468,
0.3773546815,
-0.7126558423,
0.5212920308,
-0.0354306586,
-0.5331707597,
0.5530623794,
0.7067856193,
0.9405222535,
-0.1030379012,
0.2908037603,
0.0597043596,
0.184018448,
-0.3276386261,
0.7300726771,
-0.3975630403,
-0.3241299093,
-0.7968865037,
-0.2984365225,
-0.7012344003,
-0.4571901858,
-0.5973787308,
0.5039846301,
-0.5604318976,
-0.2805318236,
0.0311999917,
-0.2644867301,
-0.2098976076,
0.3436552286,
-0.078455776,
1.165935874,
-0.3768940866,
0.7183892131,
0.6187843084,
-0.254576683,
-1.0306363106,
0.1809860468,
-0.2338808626,
-0.4362089336,
0.5634115338,
0.1523385346,
-0.2108176351,
-0.0573077686,
-0.6625069976,
-0.2423275411,
0.9198489189,
0.2607115805,
-0.6237569451,
-0.147143811,
0.3059450984,
0.3128284514,
-0.5534045696,
0.157574445,
0.6617529988,
0.2172530144,
0.2407558262,
-0.6335259676,
0.4954932332,
0.1463795155,
0.1804848611,
0.5744717121,
-0.2416405231,
0.9273890257,
-0.5059568286,
-0.029414244,
-0.1584019661,
0.6222516894,
0.6122097373,
0.2573359609,
0.8262239695,
0.1088893861,
0.8997173905,
-0.082347244,
0.8596879244,
0.1143995225,
0.1982396096,
1.1302769184,
-0.6041570902,
0.9294300079,
0.7220954299,
-0.4216071665,
0.9845024347,
0.4954656661,
0.2419140041,
0.3482826948,
0.0682688951,
-0.6611704826,
-0.4824338257,
-0.3334547877,
-0.2295055836,
-0.1068797708,
0.5469842553,
-0.3109378815,
-0.1526776254,
0.0172289517,
-0.0557373129,
-0.0116643747,
-0.1651066989,
0.990167141,
0.2388747931,
-1.116979599,
0.5873499513,
-0.1932437718,
0.3507698774,
-0.4071242809,
-0.1073392257,
-0.08063142,
-0.14646855,
-0.3095189035,
-1.1903569698,
0.2875026762,
0.3410572708,
-0.3194211423,
-0.3663936555,
0.8786108494,
-0.4849557579,
-0.2427385747,
0.2874294519,
0.5830148458,
-0.0116432831,
-0.2016791105,
-0.7072377801,
0.0048779119,
0.1694163382,
-0.131352827,
0.1771803945,
0.7776027322,
-0.1451181471,
0.598859787,
0.8798577189,
-0.1232796982,
-0.0011401026,
0.3157827556,
0.910720408,
-0.8411208391,
-0.7122971416,
-1.1895595789,
0.4509718716,
-0.1921505332,
-0.1389549077,
0.4945250154,
0.464945823,
0.3574719727,
-0.1373761743,
0.5963647962,
-0.2718934119,
0.4458825886,
-0.7875466347,
0.2796783745,
-0.5251024365,
0.4649049044,
-0.2171765566,
-0.7046197057,
-0.1072345972,
0.2100127637,
-0.3245506883,
-0.0770596117,
1.3799399137,
0.758403182,
0.5526514649,
0.4459487796,
0.1564976573,
-0.1446067244,
0.3925788701,
0.5688849092,
1.1834138632,
-0.1241641417,
0.4264912307,
-0.0166846476,
-0.1934031099,
-0.0174309108,
-0.819259584,
-1.1723604202,
-0.4227234125,
-0.2050562352,
-0.6517494321,
0.0917011127,
1.3607057333,
0.5561759472,
-0.7086871266,
-0.348813653,
-0.7680280805,
0.59971416,
-0.3030347526,
-0.1922846138,
0.2439189553,
-0.774753511,
-0.3841704428,
0.5356621146,
0.5291723609,
-0.0002023431,
-0.2362627983,
0.2511191368,
-0.464422375,
0.3596640527,
0.887262702,
-0.3107511103,
-0.7948194146,
0.2542383075,
0.063964434,
-0.1184629425,
0.0234252047,
1.1614978313,
-0.9746003747,
0.2782442272,
0.8395987749,
0.4370193779,
0.3344511986,
0.0203879606,
0.8601736426,
-0.7627941966,
-0.0080438145,
0.5306062698,
0.050296545,
0.1165788546,
-0.5776053667,
0.5294575095,
0.2441646457,
-0.5100497007,
-0.813639164,
0.2436678559,
-1.0502240658,
-0.4892627299,
1.1009993553,
0.0620447695,
-0.4979118705,
-0.3129664063,
-0.753973186,
0.0946599171,
-0.3876230121,
0.4800524414,
0.689114213,
-0.4495895505,
-0.0763059556,
-0.0986449644,
0.7064985037,
0.7082039118,
-1.4348516464,
0.3752962649,
0.2748729885,
-0.0742887035,
0.0347555354,
0.6756488085,
-0.1325315982,
0.3981176615,
0.0521213487,
-0.2831769288,
0.2064522058,
-0.5158857703,
0.0620553307,
0.1077783406,
-0.0442655087,
-0.1274950355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11534v2 | Graph Neural Networks for Text Classification: A Survey | 2023-04-23T04:21:50 | 2023-04-27T13:42:25 | Kunze Wang, Yihao Ding, Soyeon Caren Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text Classification is the most essential and fundamental problem in Natural
Language Processing. While numerous recent text classification models applied
the sequential deep learning technique, graph neural network-based models can
directly deal with complex structured text data and exploit global information.
Many real text classification applications can be naturally cast into a graph,
which captures words, documents, and corpus global features. In this survey, we
bring the coverage of methods up to 2023, including corpus-level and
document-level graph neural networks. We discuss each of these methods in
detail, dealing with the graph construction mechanisms and the graph-based
learning process. As well as the technological survey, we look at issues behind
and future directions addressed in text classification using graph neural
networks. We also cover datasets, evaluation metrics, and experiment design and
present a summary of published performance on the publicly available
benchmarks. Note that we present a comprehensive comparison between different
techniques and identify the pros and cons of various evaluation metrics in this
survey. | [
-0.1738566309,
-0.9485710859,
0.5063735247,
0.1591988206,
-0.0009470495,
0.3992299736,
-0.1342517138,
-0.7972280979,
-0.1644642204,
0.4638077915,
-0.0772681758,
-0.6715225577,
-0.8702417016,
0.253095001,
-0.6587933898,
0.8939804435,
-0.1715087891,
-0.0157122593,
-0.2177820057,
-0.0355349667,
-0.2190890163,
-0.8569498658,
-1.0854258537,
-0.4995470345,
0.9226005077,
0.154928416,
0.3647737801,
0.5142525434,
0.4982207716,
0.5060009956,
-0.3672658503,
0.3122597933,
-0.1705615669,
0.1698534042,
0.266428858,
-0.2824068666,
-0.0722501874,
0.2025745511,
0.7217491269,
1.0404076576,
0.3906274736,
-0.0263676401,
0.1511488855,
0.4708310962,
-0.3836899996,
0.3913443983,
-0.2246737331,
0.2599216402,
-0.2516409755,
0.0522094667,
-0.6554792523,
-0.8163339496,
0.2146202624,
-0.2494448274,
0.382149905,
0.0962873697,
0.6927701235,
-0.1316257268,
-0.8613599539,
-0.4911164343,
-0.7998126149,
0.4189618826,
-0.446559608,
0.4310598373,
0.332172662,
0.056381084,
-0.0716112703,
-1.254401207,
-0.3474831879,
-0.1483689398,
-0.0813825876,
0.0905518681,
-0.0647213235,
0.2245462835,
-0.0005393898,
0.3073566556,
-0.6507989168,
0.5274018049,
-0.3077587783,
-0.4460722506,
0.6155879498,
0.1926305443,
0.4074639082,
-0.2818596959,
-0.0739256144,
-0.1092313454,
-0.1250678748,
0.0145029118,
0.4121600091,
0.188608095,
0.3460559845,
0.2581335604,
-0.0854006112,
0.9250833988,
-0.4535468817,
0.1577269584,
0.2057590783,
-0.4845818877,
-0.2617456913,
0.1393722445,
1.0489045382,
0.0861885771,
0.3099867702,
-0.3039767146,
-0.0944782645,
0.1675108075,
0.2172624916,
-0.7856652141,
-0.291162312,
-0.1007630304,
-0.3887586594,
-0.5611389875,
-0.1755209714,
-0.4784577787,
-0.5559085011,
-0.3316739798,
-0.2366806716,
-0.1922204942,
-0.0394947641,
-0.0406511351,
-0.2796129286,
-0.1568212211,
0.2189769894,
-0.8225631118,
0.6442295313,
0.7539218664,
1.1058652401,
-0.0517563745,
-0.227292642,
-0.2222681493,
-0.2931963801,
-0.4941129386,
0.8966802359,
-0.2421943694,
-0.2003046423,
0.2967646718,
-0.0661835521,
-0.2314246595,
-0.2479681969,
0.7494217753,
-0.6801097393,
0.4974386096,
0.1538667679,
-0.6999906301,
-0.3364927471,
0.4762761295,
-0.7758668065,
0.9752213359,
-0.0418659486,
-0.9970656037,
0.032131765,
-0.4317196906,
-0.7223819494,
0.149196431,
0.0090640429,
-0.5104030371,
-0.1380827129,
-0.0966433212,
0.6829914451,
-0.2379163206,
0.313809216,
-0.2507851124,
-0.3474915922,
0.2669216394,
-0.5881821513,
0.795279026,
0.2983309329,
0.0642299727,
0.2739289999,
-0.7589973211,
0.0811533481,
0.0079669748,
-0.402846545,
-0.3668180406,
0.0009007251,
0.3219577074,
0.0155816628,
0.0826941058,
-0.6025267839,
0.1661037952,
-0.55159688,
0.9011544585,
0.5973808765,
0.049738057,
0.5311561823,
-0.1222338006,
0.2181501836,
-0.3974484205,
-0.0015055038,
-0.0063089794,
-0.7455576658,
-0.4980269074,
0.1017876416,
0.7433228493,
0.8525954485,
-0.3924430311,
0.5976472497,
-0.3155370057,
-0.5146778822,
0.1794676185,
-0.1705088019,
0.3589266241,
0.7561791539,
0.0850189924,
-0.1201010495,
-0.4463811219,
-0.5942684412,
-0.1658722162,
-0.37589854,
0.281583488,
0.3614902496,
0.2624434829,
-0.2173237056,
0.7347232699,
-0.7177968025,
-0.1410698146,
-0.3073553145,
0.6274792552,
0.0364292637,
0.1206131727,
0.4529925585,
-1.029915452,
-0.4437723756,
0.0994714648,
-0.839489162,
-0.0021052021,
0.1659370214,
0.2452798635,
0.3222846687,
0.7469154,
-0.4266306162,
0.3511073291,
0.3352047503,
-0.1674866527,
0.2577006221,
-0.1868086904,
-0.1663472354,
-0.7203549147,
-0.0231084935,
0.1845462322,
-0.4789304435,
-0.682743907,
-0.2696231306,
-0.0077084466,
-0.2630887926,
-0.0934794992,
0.5264328122,
-0.2499975711,
-0.0337562114,
-0.3927234113,
0.3140719533,
0.1257018894,
0.2231225669,
-0.1402960122,
0.3238299787,
0.209342882,
-0.7653634548,
0.780066669,
0.3874016106,
-0.2981064916,
-0.1232435033,
-0.2762907445,
0.362651974,
-0.2704049349,
0.5351139307,
-1.2302529812,
-0.0657492578,
0.553770721,
-0.6829189658,
0.4275795519,
-0.0600766502,
-0.5521872044,
-0.689453423,
-0.065722771,
0.1407031119,
0.2793812156,
-0.2616205812,
0.2758697271,
0.3639632761,
-0.2961490452,
-0.6028285027,
-0.7825323939,
0.3672243953,
0.1197138131,
-0.4838991463,
0.3391710222,
0.1056970432,
0.0733787119,
0.1771727502,
-0.0345988944,
-0.4375517666,
0.356767714,
0.0379873887,
0.0283999033,
0.0528338663,
0.3553103805,
-0.093114689,
-0.2758390605,
0.0375540555,
-0.6548813581,
0.5686602592,
0.0070164055,
0.163902387,
-0.2420410663,
0.1571317911,
0.1840661466,
-0.2807527483,
0.3743240535,
0.610042274,
-0.4992809594,
-0.053488683,
-0.1874703467,
0.2001135647,
-0.3767715394,
0.4996387362,
-0.0418530963,
-0.9097972512,
0.3087750971,
-0.5376873612,
-0.0876641721,
0.3842225373,
0.2298884839,
-0.2292663008,
0.9892448187,
0.6190392375,
-0.2870233953,
0.6025497913,
-0.4985974133,
0.3190310895,
-0.4916121364,
-0.1841624081,
-0.911644578,
-0.4299519658,
-0.6298411489,
0.1078232303,
-0.1636962891,
0.0531347729,
-0.2648731768,
0.2883810997,
-0.7313709855,
0.2531836927,
0.4654460251,
-0.0459714197,
0.1793113202,
0.0117167169,
-0.2418774813,
0.1356215924,
-0.5246282816,
-0.5076099634,
0.746691823,
0.229253754,
0.2798682749,
-0.4016939998,
0.6558975577,
0.4763204157,
0.5243879557,
-1.003457427,
0.5395245552,
-0.4431048334,
-0.3244664967,
-0.5949096084,
-0.730237782,
-1.1967455149,
0.1584838182,
-0.0685026869,
-0.6973558664,
0.0400051884,
-0.1057950407,
0.0105593717,
0.3609565496,
-0.849460423,
0.9356300235,
-0.4932365119,
0.1501064897,
0.2158013582,
-0.703533709,
0.0786596164,
-0.0704652146,
0.2294618934,
0.0059102578,
0.0204576179,
0.9539117217,
-0.2260369509,
0.8290069699,
-0.0981135741,
0.1959454119,
0.3489808738,
-0.2708232105,
0.3686833084,
-0.0494742729,
-0.0943961143,
0.2385391742,
-0.1223096475,
-0.1516675055,
-0.5659049749,
0.5476968288,
-0.7749199271,
-0.1324606836,
-0.6999787688,
-0.1660430729,
-0.2174414545,
0.6525095105,
0.626529634,
0.802975595,
-0.365118593,
0.092362307,
0.5760028958,
0.0784611478,
0.7513267398,
-0.0341161601,
-0.533536911,
-0.6286699772,
1.1145256758,
0.619394362,
-0.1656119972,
0.5538951755,
0.382825017,
-0.3008279204,
-1.0559704304,
-0.3189930618,
-0.1036663204,
-0.6968306899,
-0.2633416653,
-0.6950451732,
-0.6438802481,
-0.4096289873,
0.0416248105,
0.0671123937,
-0.4113142192,
-0.4228235781,
-0.4555404484,
0.1988690495,
1.0326746702,
0.3846808076,
0.4539813697,
-0.8081848621,
0.2722103894,
0.1425511986,
0.6393293738,
0.0385612026,
0.0669817328,
-0.1891247779,
-0.2572203577,
-0.3228368461,
-0.8253221512,
0.3148320615,
0.0697671175,
0.4087004364,
0.1204510555,
0.0494044796,
0.0706442818,
-0.5706105828,
0.6050349474,
0.2203774154,
-0.6863150001,
0.2070337832,
-0.1365268379,
-0.0650248528,
0.4474339187,
0.6662405729,
-0.9257298112,
-0.1572412848,
-0.4030293822,
-0.7519245148,
0.5829566121,
0.1741318852,
0.1619053334,
0.0120909549,
0.6062986255,
-0.1151426584,
0.082037814,
-0.5709975362,
-0.3150310814,
-0.2542846799,
-0.6328189373,
-0.2093823999,
-0.010562948,
0.1089949608,
-0.3177464306,
0.3158088326,
-0.3279743791,
0.2390725762,
0.2742748857,
-0.1991973668,
0.3098726273,
0.103248395,
0.363581568,
0.5749813914,
-0.0133452583,
0.1184001416,
0.1882293671,
-0.7676695585,
0.3280173242,
0.2651200593,
-0.4085430205,
0.0425577872,
0.4553959072,
0.8267788291,
0.1631985754,
-0.026965281,
0.4387543201,
-0.5334163308,
-0.4203131795,
-0.2747994661,
-0.1137179956,
0.0259109885,
-0.1350857764,
0.1723788083,
0.3582096994,
0.3913919628,
-0.3270904422,
-0.0401069261,
0.1574964672,
-0.7022410631,
-0.1202987507,
0.3932128847,
0.2517141104,
-0.6459080577,
0.9547383785,
-0.1448203921,
-0.7700626254,
0.741273582,
0.6873788834,
0.9479508996,
0.1732905209,
0.3972635567,
0.1381654292,
0.0651252419,
0.0471907295,
0.0875020474,
0.0338670686,
-0.8530439734,
-0.3365103304,
-0.4621765018,
-0.4495766759,
-0.0477517433,
-0.1089856997,
0.0605352782,
-0.790089488,
-0.5178098083,
0.2708075047,
0.2947121859,
-0.4068718553,
0.3973639011,
0.3673223555,
0.9336621165,
-0.5555061102,
0.625629425,
0.8392273188,
-0.4179798067,
-0.380361706,
-0.349203974,
-0.2066152096,
-0.2122333199,
0.6648523211,
0.4402223527,
-0.1393475235,
0.2823438942,
-0.7117164731,
-0.5497429967,
0.8014112711,
0.1489326209,
-0.2981480956,
-0.3817735314,
0.011782676,
0.7225115299,
-0.1258602589,
0.3333921731,
0.2553388178,
0.4706794918,
-0.1305210888,
-0.6756646633,
-0.283031404,
-0.3023762405,
0.0982589722,
0.3254832327,
-0.6519421935,
0.6061351895,
0.2170298547,
-0.3035628796,
0.0704956353,
0.6868625879,
-0.2400961369,
0.593685627,
0.499197036,
0.5590649843,
1.1929998398,
-0.3600693047,
1.1859309673,
-0.0543465726,
0.2928979993,
0.724738121,
-0.2786630094,
0.5545908213,
-0.3628961742,
-0.1715878546,
0.5868635774,
0.8437355161,
0.0202489011,
0.1879101098,
0.5586212277,
-0.2758753896,
-0.0317312479,
-0.1057234406,
-0.2014644742,
0.275169909,
0.4022669792,
-0.2321478277,
-0.034568619,
0.2355382442,
0.1305048317,
0.1906577796,
-0.3900790513,
1.011200428,
0.1933592707,
-0.3394750059,
-0.0255903602,
0.255749315,
0.5213679671,
-0.5407717824,
0.1270922422,
0.0572960451,
0.3569395542,
-0.3327003121,
-0.8637816906,
0.257907331,
-0.2107854187,
-0.3026215434,
-0.41387707,
1.1756689548,
-0.0222374797,
-0.4833961725,
0.5744451284,
0.090264,
0.0068212696,
-0.0702809617,
-0.5063750148,
-0.2877678871,
-0.4511941373,
-0.1511763036,
0.2387899011,
0.4557660222,
-0.2610456944,
0.6239567399,
0.6816536188,
0.0422001481,
0.2938177884,
0.3255383074,
0.6905955672,
-0.8056668639,
-0.539501667,
-0.6823328137,
-0.0261566341,
-0.3947606981,
-0.371178478,
0.7251159549,
0.6728407145,
0.7741583586,
0.2736719549,
0.9973756075,
0.2828787863,
0.4949690104,
-0.385653317,
0.9026601315,
-0.001207059,
-0.3924709558,
-0.2794300318,
-0.812582016,
-0.712449491,
0.296277523,
-0.3762678504,
-0.002353389,
0.8833448291,
-0.0071980478,
0.2031428367,
0.4151009023,
0.0237220377,
0.0175621994,
0.3991705775,
0.2132195383,
0.9055812359,
-0.5980113149,
0.7009281516,
-0.1659595966,
-0.0679649562,
-0.1289714277,
-0.7913029194,
-0.6148127913,
-0.582048595,
-0.3686749339,
-0.327098757,
0.0240622517,
0.3962554336,
0.60340029,
-0.7163405418,
-0.0773863569,
-0.4883627594,
0.5670312047,
-0.0895659626,
-0.1746137738,
0.3912118375,
-0.5819855928,
-0.7042360902,
0.2700222731,
0.2255777121,
0.0093329903,
0.0168092437,
0.0959960669,
-0.3558882475,
-0.2438155562,
0.7396423221,
0.5264295936,
-0.2048870623,
-0.3608143926,
0.1052198187,
-0.4998727143,
0.1148561686,
1.0344135761,
-0.7520578504,
0.3428789973,
1.0663099289,
0.9804189205,
0.6452714801,
-0.0954883993,
0.2600317895,
-0.7305491567,
-0.1517046839,
0.4135852754,
0.2380396426,
0.3274779022,
-0.3302482963,
0.4088388681,
0.4579920769,
-0.77442801,
-0.6214103699,
0.0904200077,
-0.8440148234,
-0.3119439483,
0.6670475602,
-0.0636343807,
-0.2260805815,
-0.5439952612,
-0.3836813867,
0.5633352995,
0.0292637218,
0.1325137019,
0.8264242411,
-0.2010333836,
-0.1172633842,
-0.4542485178,
0.2649030387,
-0.0937381461,
-0.8345407844,
-0.1609123498,
0.4914876819,
0.0267888885,
0.4290767014,
0.7644654512,
-0.004607026,
-0.181409806,
-0.0877260119,
-0.099120982,
-0.1310067922,
-0.5879136324,
-0.4368878901,
0.5243723989,
0.0620595701,
-0.0655601397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11520v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11520v4 | Processing Natural Language on Embedded Devices: How Well Do Transformer Models Perform? | 2023-04-23T03:01:39 | 2024-03-07T00:42:17 | Souvika Sarkar, Mohammad Fakhruddin Babar, Md Mahadi Hassan, Monowar Hasan, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY | This paper presents a performance study of transformer language models under
different hardware configurations and accuracy requirements and derives
empirical observations about these resource/accuracy trade-offs. In particular,
we study how the most commonly used BERT-based language models (viz., BERT,
RoBERTa, DistilBERT, and TinyBERT) perform on embedded systems. We tested them
on four off-the-shelf embedded platforms (Raspberry Pi, Jetson, UP2, and UDOO)
with 2 GB and 4 GB memory (i.e., a total of eight hardware configurations) and
four datasets (i.e., HuRIC, GoEmotion, CoNLL, WNUT17) running various NLP
tasks. Our study finds that executing complex NLP tasks (such as "sentiment"
classification) on embedded systems is feasible even without any GPUs (e.g.,
Raspberry Pi with 2 GB of RAM). Our findings can help designers understand the
deployability and performance of transformer language models, especially those
based on BERT architectures. | [
-0.5006574988,
-0.876578033,
0.6305143833,
0.2715429664,
-0.2626175284,
0.1006906629,
-0.4906311631,
-0.8633611798,
-0.1263498515,
0.2990382016,
-0.3007068932,
-0.1667588949,
-0.4799723625,
-0.0323858932,
-0.5243890285,
0.7824825644,
0.1836843193,
-0.1301100105,
-0.081151031,
0.0582898669,
-0.4436879754,
-0.2765780091,
-0.463000536,
-0.3138410747,
0.1773077101,
0.2047518045,
1.1916271448,
0.35198313,
0.557285428,
0.2468529344,
-0.2628886104,
-0.158444494,
0.0666034222,
0.1644429564,
-0.0181430914,
-0.3216032088,
-0.3148807287,
-0.0927305445,
0.4414086938,
0.3387594521,
0.0507424176,
0.2006081343,
0.1196846142,
0.2322090715,
-0.2422332764,
-0.0178103,
-0.7274434566,
0.1157005355,
-0.0929827765,
0.3474237919,
-0.6707807779,
-0.509534657,
0.3260063827,
-0.3464379311,
0.5800203085,
0.0683868676,
0.8385218382,
0.3894768357,
-0.0045093261,
-0.575704217,
-1.2819782495,
0.9684675336,
-1.0295338631,
0.4871399701,
0.0905256942,
0.2342472374,
0.1272242367,
-0.6660366058,
-0.7273231149,
-0.1921727806,
-0.3848581016,
-0.0757345855,
-0.5407145619,
0.1891617775,
0.3392984867,
0.4723037779,
-0.5246315002,
0.3137336075,
-0.2706346512,
0.1489832401,
0.2794227302,
-0.0931546167,
0.2156362832,
-0.2626578212,
-0.0412821323,
-0.093659997,
-0.6529345512,
0.065203324,
0.3393591344,
0.4838625789,
-0.0724371001,
0.4832701981,
0.2957961857,
0.7218426466,
-0.0927969143,
-0.009045138,
-0.1722035706,
-0.2323624045,
-0.3455856144,
0.1145055443,
0.6832701564,
-0.0662230775,
0.1583449841,
-0.434512794,
-0.4780946672,
-0.0446121991,
0.7118549943,
-0.5635305643,
-0.4507470429,
0.3377116024,
-0.4135358334,
-0.1867705286,
-0.3020441532,
-0.7986878157,
-0.0850358307,
-0.1769406945,
0.4161139727,
-0.5869550705,
-0.1055205092,
-0.1692753285,
-0.1688219756,
0.3677359819,
0.1088718995,
-1.0672291517,
0.7235533595,
0.8342474699,
0.9117022157,
-0.0476985723,
0.2183912396,
-0.1327222884,
-0.1348375529,
0.2445472926,
0.7510257363,
-0.4443191886,
-0.4836381376,
-0.0785602331,
-0.2617046535,
-0.3229308426,
-0.4818314016,
0.8609161377,
-0.7131243348,
0.0767423734,
-0.0061593228,
-0.6646359563,
-0.1048078164,
-0.0253718197,
-0.9266371727,
0.9868608713,
-0.3399112523,
-0.5641839504,
0.1259440631,
-0.7514240146,
-0.9447543025,
-0.0025223258,
0.1595713347,
-0.3516324759,
0.4768580198,
0.0167931803,
0.5798268318,
-0.2937985659,
0.0830421671,
0.0128497742,
-0.5470356345,
0.1918918639,
-0.6145856977,
0.6275833249,
0.20478338,
-0.7065376639,
-0.0866467878,
-0.6576449275,
0.1418669522,
-0.0424865298,
-0.2587716877,
-0.2612676322,
0.4393100441,
0.5154357553,
0.1775685549,
0.3023892641,
-1.1039625406,
-0.0154853584,
-0.374704659,
0.4777955413,
0.3893603981,
-0.6069386601,
0.347900033,
0.0317674056,
0.3300622404,
-0.2808291316,
0.2667347491,
0.142539233,
-0.965940237,
-0.7937541008,
-0.247745052,
0.4849793613,
0.5385011435,
-0.4900048673,
0.5268750787,
-0.3804633021,
-0.7011734843,
-0.8477360606,
-0.066800043,
0.278642714,
0.308354497,
0.465297848,
0.1933033317,
-0.3995936215,
-1.0857361555,
-0.0741933137,
-0.2604187429,
-0.289693445,
0.4745640755,
0.1611177027,
-0.2681317329,
1.176782608,
-0.3997424841,
0.2237949222,
-0.3988889456,
0.3718242943,
0.3261274695,
0.3447826207,
0.5059748292,
-0.7546167374,
-0.2427313328,
0.2623959184,
-0.4394394457,
0.0226141773,
-0.0780050829,
0.4303897321,
0.4872097075,
0.0140588637,
-0.8813937306,
0.3269636035,
0.9514901042,
-0.0383836925,
0.3887518644,
-0.4650038779,
-0.124311395,
-0.794824481,
0.1631877273,
0.1682268381,
-0.3723574579,
-0.6928350925,
-0.0911921114,
0.0957326964,
0.0451209508,
-0.3537905514,
0.4273651242,
-0.0588516481,
-0.2653873563,
-0.3432114422,
0.0329452492,
0.0209174231,
0.1569765061,
0.2987656295,
0.9822484851,
0.2465607673,
-0.6475089192,
0.1595498174,
-0.0033305078,
-0.4498829544,
0.1598430723,
-1.2109254599,
0.0372284092,
0.1799951643,
-0.1937610209,
-0.9996974468,
0.0425039381,
-0.1806689501,
-0.2806355357,
0.3032784164,
0.0518605337,
-0.8676460385,
-0.3230445087,
-0.005369605,
0.0803300068,
0.8428324461,
-0.6765509248,
0.6423721313,
0.4268393219,
-0.1965190619,
-0.2111813724,
-0.7392473817,
-0.0152598452,
-0.0044438676,
-0.6325961351,
0.6106616855,
0.1507440805,
-0.2092674822,
0.076462023,
0.3399602771,
-0.1763696522,
0.2177556008,
0.3865375221,
0.2683676481,
-0.4413898885,
0.3273992836,
0.1943506449,
0.0549137481,
-0.0755005553,
0.1089190617,
0.5031616092,
-0.5994324088,
-0.2696775198,
-0.2817384005,
0.142661199,
0.5496000051,
0.0065730638,
0.8222593069,
0.7175124884,
-0.3347071409,
-0.1243675277,
-0.5679437518,
-0.0574145354,
-0.4681500494,
-0.0205478519,
-0.2769331336,
-0.7735650539,
0.4830026031,
0.1551236212,
0.3636783063,
0.5488554835,
0.567204535,
-0.4912057221,
0.8267060518,
0.6543871164,
-0.0679285377,
0.3276647329,
0.1213551313,
0.7208014131,
-0.7778375149,
0.0622795671,
-0.5598554611,
-0.5790798068,
-0.9194439054,
-0.379335165,
0.2141438127,
-0.2050139904,
0.1041020826,
0.8110531569,
-0.6383501291,
0.3139851987,
0.7653774023,
-0.0763187706,
0.3563306332,
-0.1440029591,
-0.0390109681,
-0.0106362645,
-0.7873266339,
-1.0226277113,
0.7711300254,
0.5751311183,
0.8365380764,
0.0693887249,
0.2203312665,
0.292850703,
0.3975279629,
-0.5778772235,
0.3645968437,
-0.4027740657,
-0.7824980021,
-0.2598048449,
-0.1674369127,
-0.8126972914,
0.0508656986,
0.0264358725,
-0.7315924168,
0.0366242714,
0.1073258668,
-0.4858931899,
0.5655833483,
-0.9584445357,
0.6859822273,
-0.3139846623,
0.0950460061,
-0.2585477531,
-0.6862291694,
0.2043344378,
0.0605374649,
-0.0011923506,
0.0077996873,
0.2357683331,
0.6842498779,
0.0367724262,
0.7865226865,
-0.2020347267,
0.0178673845,
0.3467855155,
-0.0884339735,
0.213875711,
-0.0519157462,
-0.2529322803,
0.3734095097,
0.1725199223,
-0.1035017222,
-0.4051510394,
0.7560456395,
-0.9006118178,
-0.1795659959,
-0.2175612599,
-0.4549437165,
-0.2696601152,
-0.0125535354,
0.2592772841,
0.2923042178,
-0.4579309225,
0.373087883,
0.9398413897,
-0.3142435551,
0.8933832049,
0.1796676666,
-0.0227861963,
0.0718733296,
0.655557394,
0.1346780062,
0.2194081545,
0.4082733989,
-0.0623253994,
-0.3252713382,
-0.4910029769,
-0.7524173856,
0.1009773239,
-0.3133872151,
-0.1916069239,
-0.9187206626,
-0.2727145255,
-0.1896916777,
-0.0704114735,
-0.7743604779,
-0.5875228047,
-0.3132995069,
0.0044307564,
0.4239505231,
1.0888531208,
0.2414804697,
0.6478231549,
-0.834004581,
0.1894917637,
0.2845423222,
0.6125212908,
0.0444891304,
-0.4759387076,
-0.3704966307,
0.2212776393,
-0.3729303181,
-0.5551509261,
0.2126510143,
0.096094735,
0.6176572442,
0.0837340876,
0.0118031912,
0.3384823799,
-0.5247828364,
0.8857999444,
-0.3017707765,
-1.0706876516,
0.5405135751,
-0.1240864396,
0.2407533973,
0.4989234805,
0.1950895786,
-0.3231131434,
-0.3857653439,
-0.7325868011,
-0.6019335389,
0.5518772602,
0.4944631457,
0.3101718724,
-0.0231459644,
-0.003056078,
0.1572387964,
0.228333503,
-0.5494234562,
-0.14820382,
-0.0407305025,
-0.3763893545,
0.0143688507,
-0.2139954269,
0.0314663947,
-0.2506865263,
0.646587193,
-0.0528426506,
0.7536131144,
-0.0092738615,
-0.2567972541,
0.1482965499,
0.4206251502,
0.6089590788,
0.2835861742,
-0.4848344624,
0.150161013,
-0.0449969284,
-0.4173200428,
-0.1063408107,
0.2165108025,
-0.2505428791,
0.5873209834,
0.1043664068,
0.7804094553,
0.5520575047,
-0.8131124377,
0.3452298343,
-0.5346286297,
0.4011221528,
-0.0264046341,
0.0947545916,
0.1969035417,
0.1766093373,
0.1135383248,
0.2446373403,
0.1202045903,
-0.2288620621,
0.028912602,
0.6368069053,
-0.360035032,
-0.60762465,
0.5060172677,
0.2305133492,
-0.4033480287,
0.9331920743,
0.0281921308,
-0.3568094969,
0.4856096804,
0.6399821639,
0.9405148625,
0.0308279842,
0.2519070208,
0.0662504509,
0.593801856,
0.0698681846,
0.1384907067,
-0.2942829728,
-0.8600393534,
-0.4569402337,
-0.8365672827,
-0.7431802154,
-0.2339966744,
-0.6754670739,
-0.0113704996,
-0.4821661413,
-0.4507674575,
0.1410912573,
-0.2285179347,
-0.8353306651,
0.3445134163,
0.4945621789,
0.8537356257,
-0.7744376659,
0.9607129097,
0.8167491555,
0.1595376283,
-0.7324156165,
-0.1565126777,
-0.5193428993,
-0.4752614498,
0.5037834048,
0.0032458859,
-0.2267166227,
-0.1446883082,
-0.1447707713,
-0.679333508,
0.9431052208,
0.1798553914,
-0.3817839622,
-0.0015825217,
0.3585055172,
0.8495545983,
-0.0180816799,
0.4995265305,
0.7868458033,
0.4562197924,
-0.0620281287,
-1.2659769058,
-0.3037500679,
-0.2963863611,
0.1356197596,
0.092774123,
-0.4312712848,
0.7265726924,
-0.0658571422,
-0.1265864968,
0.0097677009,
0.4773265421,
0.1488696337,
0.1315875202,
0.3306840062,
0.4946730435,
0.7177268863,
-0.3751782179,
1.3167663813,
-0.6174033284,
0.4397444129,
0.8738229871,
-0.2626956105,
1.1782383919,
0.5942827463,
-0.3586460948,
0.5419528484,
0.2799470723,
0.1246463433,
0.4840882719,
-0.319180429,
-0.3162581921,
-0.0550692566,
-0.0532766394,
-0.0369731449,
0.4043551683,
0.3424610794,
-0.4471616149,
-0.0979115441,
0.0736905634,
-0.0980948582,
-0.3612279892,
0.0621428452,
0.7176495194,
0.0532988273,
-0.5894232988,
0.0980848521,
0.2594655454,
0.8798039556,
-0.3387639523,
0.181878835,
0.0647383556,
0.3838844001,
-0.1427349299,
-1.0537467003,
0.7297130227,
0.3144444525,
-0.3941840529,
-0.4519346654,
0.9210313559,
0.1201911047,
-0.6769699454,
0.2067083716,
0.3783686161,
-0.0348904729,
-0.0318039358,
-0.3402525485,
0.2814173102,
-0.1821694672,
-0.344519645,
0.1623443067,
0.2477041036,
0.2704935372,
0.5770858526,
0.4010411799,
0.1161485463,
0.4584482908,
-0.1964426637,
0.6672835946,
-0.5375014544,
-0.3741596639,
-0.7754580379,
0.548801899,
-0.1477604359,
-0.1893788874,
0.847209394,
0.5585300326,
0.6318850517,
-0.2902866602,
0.7132815123,
-0.421631515,
0.5437274575,
-0.267863214,
0.6562943459,
-0.0513391197,
0.3318718076,
-0.1965377182,
-0.9935519099,
-0.2316481471,
0.5984246135,
-0.4951322377,
-0.1726657599,
0.3238259554,
0.5657199025,
-0.2434942126,
0.7450850606,
0.2655523419,
-0.0309618171,
0.5064151287,
0.2555279434,
0.6586642861,
-0.695566237,
0.2663725615,
-0.5350647569,
-0.0279341452,
-0.1321596652,
-0.7615839243,
-0.4878300726,
-0.3133076429,
-0.1598429829,
0.0449700095,
-0.0706710592,
0.7019692063,
0.750251174,
-1.0329875946,
-0.2041849941,
-0.0505796373,
0.2324916422,
-0.1417265683,
-0.1996009648,
0.155193463,
-0.2761601508,
-0.7449052334,
0.3340738714,
0.3148565888,
-0.0233653802,
-0.2040297687,
0.0532296598,
-0.0942896008,
0.1188649461,
0.7582048178,
0.2325979322,
-0.7788829207,
-0.4098251462,
0.2915306985,
-0.2217998654,
0.0803483799,
0.8991843462,
-1.0100265741,
0.390032351,
0.476246357,
0.8279710412,
0.2794608772,
0.0528494529,
0.5200172663,
-0.9208173156,
0.0070347679,
0.5418488979,
0.2174911499,
0.344561398,
-0.2510022521,
0.1680842042,
-0.0902024135,
-0.7914693356,
-0.5772531033,
-0.0819378123,
-1.0161107779,
-0.0826583952,
1.1011469364,
-0.010107711,
-0.1392626911,
-0.1341736168,
-0.0765443966,
0.159305051,
-0.1786569506,
0.6954574585,
0.5033961535,
-0.5092256069,
-0.1264112294,
-0.613605082,
0.2438075393,
0.3331905901,
-0.6626038551,
0.0147160636,
0.0914415568,
0.0670658126,
0.4145677984,
0.0965318307,
0.0994087532,
0.0639445782,
-0.0538512729,
0.209875226,
0.2557010353,
-0.2462804317,
-0.2444230765,
0.1643204689,
0.0361583568,
-0.252745986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11501v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11501v2 | Lost in Translationese? Reducing Translation Effect Using Abstract Meaning Representation | 2023-04-23T00:04:14 | 2024-01-29T23:09:49 | Shira Wein, Nathan Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translated texts bear several hallmarks distinct from texts originating in
the language. Though individual translated texts are often fluent and preserve
meaning, at a large scale, translated texts have statistical tendencies which
distinguish them from text originally written in the language
("translationese") and can affect model performance. We frame the novel task of
translationese reduction and hypothesize that Abstract Meaning Representation
(AMR), a graph-based semantic representation which abstracts away from the
surface form, can be used as an interlingua to reduce the amount of
translationese in translated texts. By parsing English translations into an AMR
and then generating text from that AMR, the result more closely resembles
originally English text across three quantitative macro-level measures, without
severely compromising fluency or adequacy. We compare our AMR-based approach
against three other techniques based on machine translation or paraphrase
generation. This work makes strides towards reducing translationese in text and
highlights the utility of AMR as an interlingua. | [
-0.5394241214,
-0.532789588,
0.4655721784,
0.1207491234,
-0.5673479438,
0.1939245462,
0.0189612005,
-0.3905908167,
0.6573444605,
0.4524615407,
-0.4980937541,
-0.3023502231,
-0.7929756045,
0.4832944274,
-0.617870152,
0.8574365973,
-0.533980608,
0.02899516,
-0.2830846608,
-0.4648586512,
-0.4535800219,
-0.3991706967,
-0.970513761,
-0.7513648272,
0.6063397527,
0.1435827613,
0.6780161262,
0.6926963329,
0.5741012096,
0.2551589608,
-0.2058632821,
0.0480393767,
-0.794705987,
-0.1624942571,
0.0054849721,
-0.6054585576,
-0.1263850778,
-0.0740307868,
0.8773813248,
0.8969552517,
0.1497352421,
-0.150613457,
0.1255770624,
0.8069745302,
-0.6469955444,
0.3334132731,
-0.4160224795,
0.0540665425,
-0.1432787329,
-0.4698696434,
-0.4624809921,
-0.0481486917,
-0.2740957141,
-0.7126643062,
0.2152434587,
0.0029309315,
0.8916897774,
0.1082506329,
-0.6287894249,
-0.3048419654,
-0.8963979483,
0.7200759649,
-0.7585475445,
-0.0027801162,
0.2431619763,
0.0129889771,
-0.048312027,
-0.5433251858,
-0.7276347876,
0.0643061697,
-0.3209200501,
0.1555568725,
-0.4350607097,
-0.041471608,
0.1762079597,
0.4308725595,
-0.4090610743,
-0.0726752132,
-0.6320586205,
-0.1562305242,
0.5556439161,
0.3198287189,
0.6284087896,
-0.2680935562,
0.1044106409,
-0.4621295631,
-1.107323885,
-0.1477009505,
0.2778361142,
0.1102078408,
-0.0427778922,
0.7190498114,
0.1761350185,
0.1913611442,
-0.4378737807,
-0.0150493169,
0.2611174583,
-0.182709381,
0.1666341275,
0.1250416785,
0.6956253648,
0.6231646538,
0.4460442364,
-0.0706163421,
-0.2510119081,
0.2924877405,
0.0011144356,
-0.828384757,
0.0089098932,
-0.4417069852,
-0.7913060784,
-0.0814963132,
0.0498428717,
-0.2734100223,
-0.0778575167,
-0.2578836679,
0.1659973264,
-0.4580245018,
-0.0589163005,
-0.034007445,
-0.4123865962,
0.2099533826,
0.4905524552,
-0.6480259895,
0.711596489,
0.3816704452,
1.1961069107,
-0.2303590924,
-0.1554850489,
-0.1910068542,
0.3935841918,
-0.5452952981,
0.6159969568,
-0.57599473,
-0.9036707282,
-0.2761309147,
0.0892335996,
-0.2674388289,
-0.6084566712,
0.2276237011,
-0.3843934238,
0.1405407637,
-0.1304834783,
-0.6400029063,
-0.6264303327,
0.1269626319,
-0.9813652635,
0.6054464579,
-0.106469512,
-0.7724945545,
0.0197469834,
-0.5126711726,
-0.6986364126,
-0.2077881247,
-0.2545681596,
-0.2084998339,
0.4687329233,
0.0951197296,
-0.0301081762,
-0.2400757521,
-0.3737349212,
-0.0505970642,
-0.4613029957,
0.1643424183,
-0.4312660694,
0.3705027103,
0.1868629754,
-0.1431820393,
-0.2415728867,
-0.6739268899,
-0.1512419581,
0.2998684347,
-0.3384239078,
-0.8924868703,
0.2482999414,
0.2471802384,
0.038250234,
0.0929334611,
-0.7643206716,
-0.0659692213,
-0.7686390877,
0.5448205471,
0.4241666198,
0.3448455036,
0.60696733,
-0.1869472563,
0.6166792512,
0.0250861775,
-0.3673853874,
-0.187299192,
-0.7203397155,
-0.7778372169,
0.0132711055,
0.2771135569,
0.7421172857,
-0.6685813069,
-0.0911696851,
-0.5167501569,
-0.1645747423,
-0.6010156274,
-0.1148221269,
0.6161523461,
0.3678320944,
0.3679173291,
-0.2118414789,
-0.3948390484,
-1.050039649,
-0.5111200213,
-0.1046748757,
-0.1198615283,
-0.1461916864,
0.7674785256,
-0.2380662411,
0.7135779858,
-0.6950924993,
-0.3570148349,
-0.414708674,
0.2734764814,
0.0622469001,
0.5836225748,
0.5726453066,
-0.9443898797,
-0.6672490835,
0.3041346073,
-0.7926412225,
0.0712018013,
0.0831851587,
0.045611199,
0.0719572008,
0.7056231499,
-0.6649025679,
0.9899619818,
0.3757810295,
-0.1795587242,
0.1105879322,
-0.4905013442,
0.4938648939,
-1.1593244076,
0.2506838739,
-0.210164398,
-0.1772944033,
-0.4579823613,
-0.060267657,
0.0698687658,
-0.412694335,
-0.2408097684,
0.8035547137,
-0.3935404718,
-0.0006070663,
-0.6432494521,
0.2318284363,
0.1699320227,
0.2695135772,
-0.0762734413,
0.8984714746,
-0.1076735035,
-0.5320053101,
-0.2533196509,
0.5080353022,
-0.0879063159,
0.1940331608,
-0.7333648801,
-0.0352853611,
-0.6296014786,
0.095681183,
-1.0509916544,
-0.030665461,
0.4129882753,
-0.4579544961,
0.3376435935,
-0.0381288864,
-0.4616976678,
-0.055338759,
-0.1872382611,
0.6076584458,
0.6418881416,
-0.0852377117,
0.451546818,
0.3235814869,
-0.3281014562,
-0.1935093254,
-1.0086365938,
0.3867528737,
-0.2043541819,
-0.5507006049,
0.634958744,
0.1683362722,
-0.3687822223,
0.389942199,
0.006448112,
-0.0452955253,
-0.1306480467,
-0.1467839628,
-0.2346383929,
-0.0722248405,
0.1513276696,
0.5766038299,
-0.4652148783,
0.1929506809,
0.0998332053,
0.2219797373,
0.0252877492,
-0.2304253727,
-0.196417734,
0.8949891329,
0.6979902983,
-0.2133357376,
0.9064106345,
0.017962411,
-0.4441269934,
0.0500950441,
0.1097260714,
-0.0856318921,
-0.3687018454,
0.3232776225,
-0.4709505141,
-0.5005759001,
0.8164763451,
-0.0241058562,
-0.0563603491,
0.6579970717,
0.0824649259,
0.1028700247,
1.2678049803,
0.4822830558,
0.1336768866,
0.3224932849,
-0.4113668203,
0.5249782205,
-0.7525396347,
-0.1902391613,
-0.5496315956,
-0.4568934739,
-0.7196354866,
-0.3810088634,
0.5281667709,
-0.1365030855,
0.0332714766,
0.2642297745,
-0.289169997,
0.4866546392,
0.3738165498,
0.1841836572,
0.4884224236,
0.0740301162,
0.2673784196,
-0.3750489354,
-0.5802278519,
-0.6817620993,
0.7670861483,
0.0938539654,
0.7236450911,
0.0193414018,
0.69226408,
0.4571067393,
0.1592027545,
-0.7248533964,
0.6687830091,
-0.4260122776,
-0.0848637,
-0.1645647287,
-0.817556262,
-1.2164831161,
0.5807729363,
-0.121068269,
-0.3794852495,
-0.1181015298,
0.1417881995,
0.4707470536,
0.334002465,
-0.5948290229,
0.8627362251,
0.2033141702,
0.2874621749,
-0.6260899901,
-0.4540756345,
0.1112294421,
0.0129732937,
0.5933901668,
-0.1327027231,
-0.1909341365,
0.8508550525,
-0.8733475208,
0.675062716,
-0.1900565773,
-0.0350522771,
0.3444682658,
0.2170027345,
0.7107755542,
-0.2333208919,
0.0848067403,
0.0732273608,
0.0243760627,
-0.5550214648,
-0.8502713442,
0.5950947404,
-0.5564975142,
-0.2442045063,
-0.1656159908,
-0.3225028217,
0.2128177881,
0.49861148,
0.7641692162,
0.6030219197,
-0.4433091581,
0.0477918796,
0.5293294191,
-0.2211256921,
0.2682307363,
0.1003755853,
-0.2597474754,
-0.5329219699,
0.8397054076,
0.4153544009,
0.1968485713,
0.765435636,
0.2602310479,
-0.2602165341,
-0.602627635,
-0.1870346069,
0.4822885394,
-1.1373482943,
0.0204251781,
-0.3850692511,
0.171904102,
-0.0879764706,
-0.2223922014,
-0.2292552292,
-0.6181864738,
-0.3418303132,
-0.094811596,
0.2799676359,
0.8164249659,
0.1632674187,
0.6073598862,
-0.8554419279,
0.2474873513,
-0.2969923615,
-0.0877192914,
0.0790048391,
-0.5188839436,
-0.3390042186,
0.228152588,
0.0031858466,
-0.8917170167,
0.6055775285,
0.4483452439,
0.3648040295,
0.035469681,
0.1795267761,
0.694573164,
-0.6806554794,
0.338063091,
0.3619028926,
-1.1477863789,
0.4329888821,
-0.1808054149,
0.5733708739,
0.4482501745,
0.0949892402,
-0.614392519,
-0.8889608383,
-0.483553499,
-0.9426015615,
0.3833848536,
0.6058710217,
0.4561263025,
-0.3538218141,
0.4692053497,
-0.0144391311,
0.3134711981,
-0.8870067,
-0.4649166167,
-0.1074309573,
-0.3889274001,
-0.1965310872,
0.0026297027,
0.1450533271,
-0.1640975922,
0.703417778,
-0.0565655529,
0.2726866603,
0.3185741901,
-0.1890315861,
-0.0673633665,
0.1234673932,
0.4062689245,
0.5438745618,
0.2398985028,
0.2540815473,
0.1314623207,
-0.5381479263,
0.2295493335,
-0.2772913277,
-0.6899099946,
0.4086453915,
0.6544889808,
0.8801726103,
0.4934095144,
-0.6615395546,
0.406680584,
-0.0865848362,
-0.1387871951,
-0.3053812087,
-0.3580163419,
-0.0016063143,
-0.3116005659,
0.2492162883,
0.421456486,
0.4060570002,
-0.4178406,
0.0270170365,
0.2460083365,
-0.2031908929,
-0.386980325,
0.6802782416,
0.1834572703,
-0.1937927753,
0.535728991,
-0.1232219264,
-0.3126675487,
0.6075185537,
0.6620348692,
0.8269346952,
-0.0359912403,
0.0515507311,
0.4373999238,
0.5153409243,
0.0168063343,
-0.0045040534,
0.2980488241,
-0.6466972828,
-0.6478208899,
-0.1767867506,
-0.2991732061,
-0.1985132098,
-0.8205388188,
0.085307844,
-0.2706252038,
0.0172873903,
-0.1555052698,
-0.498978436,
-0.2507673502,
0.0615532175,
-0.0441603325,
0.7215918303,
-0.9643306136,
0.4750122726,
0.8302736878,
-0.6545898318,
-0.5858818889,
0.1774425209,
-0.2719216645,
-0.5929709077,
0.509241879,
0.2755637169,
-0.4960112572,
0.0790578946,
-0.3835268915,
-0.7975719571,
0.5901116133,
0.6272301674,
-0.1528563797,
-0.1608642787,
0.1788759232,
0.6592257619,
-0.2436233163,
-0.1724944711,
0.2733895481,
0.5099948049,
0.2001584172,
-0.7165367603,
0.2055363506,
-0.4665709734,
0.2762789726,
0.7583505511,
-0.3817130327,
0.9271121025,
-0.0165897515,
-0.6533139348,
0.0399788171,
0.577042222,
-0.1743728817,
0.4806356728,
0.1982560605,
0.4678812325,
0.4880606234,
0.0797027275,
1.0971277952,
-0.1160565093,
0.3429572284,
0.7023561001,
-0.04217273,
0.7958983183,
0.8053282499,
-0.0620895177,
0.6988554001,
0.4220749736,
0.4962505698,
0.7899723649,
0.2307713777,
-0.4433543384,
-0.0173702203,
0.3663626611,
-0.2070404887,
0.3328139484,
0.4705035686,
-0.263212055,
-0.516174078,
0.4691550434,
0.4603278339,
0.6490581036,
-0.4260406494,
0.8025994301,
0.3511543572,
-0.6273054481,
0.8689875603,
0.1431555152,
0.0950940549,
-0.7351770401,
-0.4342767596,
-0.3493698537,
0.3403002024,
-0.1370213628,
-0.6452689171,
0.7077224851,
-0.2614546716,
-0.367339313,
-0.219932422,
0.684060812,
-0.4896817207,
-0.5697321296,
0.6745635867,
0.4613949955,
0.3525083959,
-0.1171173602,
-0.530890286,
-0.0183323771,
0.1551652402,
-0.1553026587,
0.2217720896,
0.7494851947,
-0.2665379643,
0.7845839262,
0.2509233057,
0.0582956932,
-0.0343772061,
-0.2115944773,
0.7361789346,
-0.8096951842,
-0.6631006002,
-0.8018651605,
0.2537978292,
-0.0493742786,
-0.2040519714,
0.8947892785,
0.7059652209,
0.8687586784,
-0.3802517951,
1.199657321,
-0.0993332416,
0.4838067889,
-0.6826427579,
0.6351166964,
-0.6938727498,
0.1189652011,
-0.4554468095,
-0.8712804914,
-0.4129885733,
0.699889183,
-0.2032894492,
-0.2573815286,
0.9407504201,
0.5487390161,
-0.1199935377,
-0.3464888036,
0.2944734097,
0.0068775988,
0.2363341302,
0.2679642737,
0.7631215453,
-0.7255858183,
0.7123318911,
0.1901573837,
-0.2738796771,
0.0198561996,
-0.6993401051,
-0.6700473428,
-0.5407389998,
-0.3691106141,
-0.3052388132,
-0.0659562573,
0.5024062991,
0.03755318,
-0.7499229908,
-0.3725862205,
-0.524947226,
0.2083077282,
-0.3160767853,
-0.1519013792,
0.4088721275,
-0.3131857514,
-0.846229136,
0.4629615545,
0.2114067078,
0.3891228437,
-0.0321394764,
-0.3591501415,
0.1203861088,
0.0529516749,
0.6771163344,
0.400056392,
-0.5534185767,
-0.3744576871,
-0.1866155416,
0.1238364801,
0.1801668406,
1.0289518833,
-0.656750679,
0.4497964084,
0.6549215317,
0.3718110919,
0.7789955735,
-0.0924934074,
0.8669257164,
-0.6759995818,
0.3041526675,
0.1832744926,
0.4096889496,
0.3168528676,
-0.0089184204,
0.552495718,
0.4681474268,
-0.2201242596,
-0.6742503643,
0.2958054245,
-0.5711798072,
-0.4619714618,
0.8925805092,
-0.0462005697,
-0.3618575335,
-0.1295271367,
-0.4336730242,
0.17429851,
-0.3880259991,
0.4002007544,
0.6416469812,
-0.1142414436,
-0.1685385853,
-0.3844910264,
0.3017883897,
0.3005006909,
-0.6546026468,
0.0489909947,
0.5649262071,
-0.0024790212,
0.2335145921,
0.9533349872,
-0.3249207139,
-0.0263744835,
0.1279057562,
0.125,
0.3376810551,
-0.1032853723,
-0.1506097168,
0.0109904613,
0.2738703787,
-0.2497416437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11490v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11490v3 | Boosting Theory-of-Mind Performance in Large Language Models via Prompting | 2023-04-22T22:50:50 | 2023-04-26T04:02:04 | Shima Rahimi Moghaddam, Christopher J. Honey | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) excel in many tasks in 2023, but they still face
challenges in complex reasoning. Theory-of-mind (ToM) tasks, which require
understanding agents' beliefs, goals, and mental states, are essential for
common-sense reasoning involving humans, making it crucial to enhance LLM
performance in this area. This study measures the ToM performance of GPT-4 and
three GPT-3.5 variants (Davinci-2, Davinci-3, GPT-3.5-Turbo), and investigates
the effectiveness of in-context learning in improving their ToM comprehension.
We evaluated prompts featuring two-shot chain of thought reasoning and
step-by-step thinking instructions. We found that LLMs trained with
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) (all models excluding
Davinci-2) improved their ToM accuracy via in-context learning. GPT-4 performed
best in zero-shot settings, reaching nearly 80% ToM accuracy, but still fell
short of the 87% human accuracy on the test set. However, when supplied with
prompts for in-context learning, all RLHF-trained LLMs exceeded 80% ToM
accuracy, with GPT-4 reaching 100%. These results demonstrate that appropriate
prompting enhances LLM ToM reasoning, and they underscore the context-dependent
nature of LLM cognitive capacities. | [
-0.6435713768,
-1.1008368731,
1.0677424669,
-0.0379409418,
-0.3446321487,
-0.0596771985,
-0.5228561163,
-0.2745498419,
-0.243752405,
-0.0275789145,
-0.8233290911,
-0.1295993179,
-0.3766808808,
0.3349709511,
0.1914532334,
0.8293884993,
-0.0638223663,
0.1696390659,
-0.1025331542,
0.2050194144,
-0.7479524016,
-0.3745156825,
-0.9002280831,
-0.5785761476,
0.7840108275,
0.300519824,
0.2793006897,
0.4684529305,
0.1934479773,
0.2103706151,
-0.1296061724,
0.3708882928,
-0.3397265971,
0.3892042339,
-0.3741442263,
-0.3998034,
-0.5644489527,
0.0617950298,
0.7254238725,
0.3115119934,
-0.2688145339,
-0.205085516,
0.2876976728,
0.6665173769,
-0.4676835835,
0.4371160567,
-0.4939101934,
-0.079972975,
0.0952866301,
-0.6163104177,
-0.5276027918,
-0.2454045415,
0.5092027783,
-0.8401399851,
0.0204018988,
0.152454257,
0.4953180254,
0.4081913531,
-0.4164910913,
-0.2938356698,
-0.5013845563,
0.6616287231,
-0.5027469397,
0.2726380527,
0.4315929413,
0.2638537288,
-0.4858311713,
-0.2390320003,
-0.7763204575,
-0.2592066526,
0.0330355316,
0.1270564497,
-0.0330211669,
0.3361868262,
0.6641297936,
0.1967756152,
-0.4585888982,
-0.1350356638,
-0.0639055669,
0.1792159677,
0.3908040524,
0.1053980812,
-0.0507674254,
0.096616134,
-0.2128436863,
-0.5469869971,
-0.8773108721,
0.022675002,
-0.0041139452,
0.2795749903,
0.1346958727,
-0.0498027653,
-0.2763091624,
0.9138777852,
0.4463044703,
-0.3223140538,
-0.0661115274,
-0.1567731053,
-0.2367180288,
-0.2061583996,
0.4381838739,
0.2228327543,
0.472352773,
0.0793839544,
-0.2929222286,
-0.1112833321,
0.2598035932,
-0.7190274,
-0.1670463532,
-0.0770050138,
0.0647563264,
0.1574802399,
0.0146476431,
-0.5484607816,
-0.4071741402,
-0.3855475485,
0.5915821195,
-0.6763198376,
-0.3517055809,
0.2114656121,
-0.2392698973,
0.4305976927,
0.6851311922,
-0.9765082002,
0.0632050112,
0.5355554223,
0.7264991403,
-0.1335877329,
-0.388071537,
-0.4508995414,
0.3657179773,
-0.3891074657,
0.8335609436,
-0.4015610814,
-0.3281170726,
-0.0728451982,
-0.2553282976,
-0.1488073915,
-0.3244929016,
0.3502299488,
-0.3819834888,
0.4294646978,
-1.0414251089,
-0.7025177479,
-0.5281011462,
0.4943694472,
-0.3725965619,
0.7492336631,
0.083091341,
-0.4954401851,
0.5299399495,
-0.9561606646,
-0.5374642611,
0.3067034483,
-0.4764613807,
0.2811444104,
0.0483505987,
0.5489796996,
0.757317543,
-0.4593518972,
0.354110986,
-0.1519081593,
-0.625333488,
0.2068508565,
-0.5672271252,
0.5957641006,
0.1073133498,
-0.6293369532,
0.0141195869,
-0.2401476055,
0.0977477804,
0.2728624642,
-0.2737425566,
-0.1941113174,
-0.0857894048,
-0.4861713648,
0.2884944677,
-0.2287791073,
-0.1390557438,
0.4529956281,
-0.3629986346,
0.5092456937,
0.8055238724,
0.235893175,
0.2109752446,
-0.5813341737,
0.6937733293,
0.0168452319,
-0.1426418722,
-0.4201512337,
-0.6749947667,
-0.6603432894,
-0.3049218059,
-0.2053797692,
0.3952749074,
-1.0837115049,
0.3245297372,
-0.2671174407,
-0.2671888769,
0.0154926656,
-0.0210989211,
0.6110796332,
0.6645256281,
0.2910403013,
-0.1298590004,
-0.0553336702,
-0.5514720678,
-0.3590395749,
-0.3629322052,
-0.0375757478,
0.3031212687,
0.5938839316,
0.1165147126,
0.8790230751,
-0.5233151317,
0.0373622775,
-0.4112744331,
0.037861973,
0.0793812126,
0.3818793595,
0.2358650714,
-0.4782747626,
-0.2808380127,
-0.1804661006,
-0.5566949844,
0.1971657127,
0.0348987691,
0.0341905989,
0.3061465025,
0.1386802644,
-0.7898764014,
0.1985166967,
0.0871913806,
-0.3137467504,
0.4055611491,
-0.3631693125,
0.4322335422,
-0.8617334366,
-0.070172511,
0.1108183414,
-0.2364933789,
-0.606226325,
0.0972826108,
0.0925615802,
0.3541102111,
-0.4131074548,
0.6189319491,
-0.4381465018,
0.0385601483,
-0.1625495106,
0.3499782383,
0.0156314056,
0.8394948244,
0.1891926378,
0.9703023434,
0.4125638008,
-0.9272375107,
0.2624241412,
0.1170642972,
-0.4710864127,
0.6337065101,
-0.4397674203,
0.4886243939,
-0.0494590215,
0.806570828,
-0.8089671731,
-0.5745774508,
0.2780115008,
-0.3134797215,
0.3879879415,
0.2187544852,
-0.552844286,
-0.4299198091,
-0.0471934602,
0.3555792272,
0.5940608382,
-0.7099461555,
0.4367031753,
-0.0263453647,
0.0764929876,
-0.4376167953,
-0.6508917809,
-0.1468362808,
-0.3802670836,
-0.2797056437,
0.1324592978,
-0.2973507047,
-0.2654899061,
-0.3703219593,
-0.0132288253,
0.0703733563,
0.1022449732,
-0.0022622454,
0.1910273731,
0.1902516484,
0.331138581,
-0.0000126134,
0.1291018575,
0.2646167874,
-0.5190300941,
0.4508599639,
-0.3983320594,
-0.2467732877,
-0.5226410627,
0.0819444582,
0.3029220998,
0.0373935737,
0.4855194688,
0.2721146643,
-0.3097872734,
-0.4749059975,
-0.542391479,
-0.7135233879,
-0.4325956702,
0.1981940269,
-0.6067218781,
-1.1218559742,
0.1946081966,
-0.0070948461,
-0.1176830307,
0.1612557471,
0.7470371127,
-0.2037781924,
1.0334175825,
0.303796947,
0.0514918678,
0.5866065621,
-0.2198010385,
0.1114506647,
-0.7666105032,
-0.0386345983,
0.0289105829,
-0.1798229963,
-0.2223473787,
-0.5083084702,
0.4601583481,
0.0294660553,
-0.2724027336,
0.0958615839,
-0.5055481791,
0.7386459708,
0.4777184427,
0.2496459484,
0.353774935,
0.0377604328,
-0.3641729951,
0.2791685164,
-0.8425683975,
-0.3819998205,
0.9132900834,
0.3107080162,
0.3851239681,
0.1197621599,
0.4225328863,
0.0415113792,
0.1688216031,
-0.8110812306,
0.6420404315,
0.5209950805,
-0.8844211698,
-0.4316443503,
-0.3612225354,
-0.6863653064,
0.228698954,
0.1024138331,
-0.6257587075,
-0.0041986685,
0.4298579097,
-0.7366076112,
0.1797871441,
-0.5004554391,
0.4998143911,
-0.0656504035,
-0.3704735637,
-0.5769658089,
-0.5874963999,
0.4309316576,
0.0173819475,
-0.0434891842,
0.0957025215,
0.0607647598,
0.51312989,
0.0556741394,
0.5819096565,
-0.3595897853,
-0.406583041,
0.3386326134,
0.0650858209,
0.6422829628,
0.1124765873,
0.1241564825,
-0.2061101794,
-0.0416311771,
-0.3374148607,
-0.9513386488,
0.4949947,
-0.4512299001,
-1.0120552778,
-0.5929722786,
-0.785033524,
-0.5750213861,
-0.0264688432,
0.326549381,
0.5157902837,
-0.0592416637,
0.1066567972,
1.0601699352,
-0.0017231896,
0.4485166073,
0.4718355536,
-0.1054698676,
-0.3799712956,
0.5018976331,
0.0551167987,
0.4705779254,
0.3259727061,
0.2648061216,
-0.4651048481,
-0.3101218939,
-0.5689965487,
0.1552432925,
-0.8505224586,
-0.0274308026,
-0.4296934307,
0.1467896402,
-0.1808311343,
-0.168459475,
0.0556326956,
-0.190895021,
-0.0287999846,
-0.3101907372,
0.5043205023,
1.0084939003,
0.1568254083,
0.1628232151,
-0.4116429985,
-0.1809988171,
0.5677626133,
0.1522726417,
0.4067266583,
-0.6001551747,
-0.351321578,
0.1559389681,
-0.4650346041,
-0.8069118857,
0.0346089341,
-0.0668339729,
0.3533124626,
0.4839958847,
-0.0211521816,
0.9060189724,
-0.4054026604,
0.7374119759,
0.0613850951,
-0.8976547122,
0.5983662009,
-0.9373345971,
0.5913255215,
0.4359363616,
0.2608613968,
-0.3966876268,
-0.2690094411,
-0.5396196842,
-0.2850202024,
0.840467155,
0.0010695555,
-0.1360414177,
-0.2600153983,
0.7699777484,
-0.0156893618,
0.2396624535,
-0.6256920099,
0.0644300878,
0.0821683183,
0.0307817422,
-0.1750536561,
-0.0367304161,
-0.2191945761,
-0.6178580523,
0.748214066,
-0.4246515334,
0.2723452747,
0.5535151958,
-0.0547893383,
-0.3201190829,
0.3133045733,
0.8148466349,
1.0190502405,
-0.2168708593,
0.0301424842,
0.5271934867,
-0.2482736856,
0.3552355468,
-0.3010680079,
-0.012987176,
-0.5372023582,
0.4261027277,
0.8861464858,
0.0892255455,
-0.6513246298,
0.4343067408,
-0.1252255142,
-0.2590628564,
-0.2990603447,
0.4297622442,
0.0299965944,
0.4822502434,
0.4588922262,
-0.2172608823,
0.0431761332,
-0.630497694,
-0.0436097197,
0.3530176878,
-0.2794347405,
-0.2736522853,
0.3984504938,
0.1308889538,
-0.1345355511,
0.411989063,
-0.510178566,
-0.6731734276,
0.291380018,
0.698318541,
0.9727547765,
-0.1732840389,
-0.0301403478,
0.4927687049,
0.0929828361,
-0.4781853557,
0.3340640068,
-0.4201327264,
-0.7493459582,
-0.6600571275,
-0.1810165942,
-0.4886725545,
0.1566186994,
-0.6629184484,
0.0879574418,
-0.5885428786,
-0.1964830756,
-0.517814517,
0.319309622,
-0.6809362173,
0.2512410879,
0.1753362715,
0.7908346653,
-0.3771096468,
1.2193931341,
0.8439179063,
-0.2822983861,
-1.1911156178,
0.3576453328,
0.1493398845,
-0.4572292566,
0.551513195,
0.3553771377,
-0.3851184547,
0.3458185494,
-0.4602655172,
-0.7491924167,
1.4288624525,
0.5176616311,
-0.693197906,
-0.0879331902,
-0.4255863726,
0.4413237572,
-0.4602773488,
0.519705236,
0.7531219721,
0.6280699968,
0.1739003658,
-0.7988792658,
0.3048936129,
0.0437826142,
0.1004486382,
0.0959601328,
-0.6385974884,
0.7825491428,
-0.2286140323,
-0.2423481941,
-0.1214309037,
0.5928267241,
0.7815219164,
0.1018798649,
0.8140053749,
0.4376933873,
1.0209798813,
-0.1035359353,
1.1534113884,
-0.1454363018,
0.1288108826,
0.8418434262,
-0.3074083924,
0.7986146808,
0.4263733625,
-0.1400305927,
0.6436547041,
0.7098221183,
0.31938833,
0.3891125321,
0.1279035211,
-0.3270097375,
-0.3521565199,
0.1542063206,
-0.2079700679,
0.1284190565,
0.4815832376,
0.0488894358,
0.1321919113,
0.0402890556,
0.235600993,
-0.0329584479,
-0.1874796152,
0.7396072745,
0.1855463237,
-1.287779212,
0.8163265586,
-0.3568027616,
0.5878760815,
-0.518083632,
-0.0877989829,
-0.2188242525,
0.2603507042,
0.2081334144,
-0.6718418598,
-0.1872921735,
-0.0499650724,
-0.3650813401,
-0.3836485744,
0.4076437354,
-0.4404886961,
0.0104414318,
0.4539335072,
0.5553949475,
0.1752379239,
-0.281953603,
-0.6057924032,
-0.1850121915,
0.0122484639,
-0.585352838,
0.3650361598,
0.4727340043,
-0.1339401901,
0.8501619101,
0.5516070127,
0.0259167068,
-0.35028404,
0.0328886248,
0.8020271063,
-0.936329782,
-0.5553934574,
-1.1082538366,
0.2164115757,
0.0299264565,
-0.3363195956,
0.7511249185,
-0.068710953,
0.8301308751,
-0.0404065438,
0.6948909163,
0.0065891207,
0.3868415654,
-0.6439687014,
0.5495983958,
-0.5686630607,
0.2122989297,
-0.3752536178,
-0.979624927,
-0.1107300594,
0.6622898579,
-0.3835807145,
0.2976533473,
1.0805732012,
0.7533670068,
0.3514463603,
0.3242554665,
0.4198056459,
0.16279459,
0.4267902374,
0.8960573077,
1.0150378942,
0.0523478128,
0.1712964177,
-0.0278574303,
-0.4262535274,
-0.1339980066,
-0.9162765145,
-1.1781580448,
-0.7693209052,
-0.0334187932,
-0.1920435727,
0.2127440274,
1.3343193531,
0.7250782251,
-0.549843967,
-0.2197308391,
-0.3864673078,
-0.0605036803,
-0.4571564794,
-0.1448929459,
0.1891057789,
-0.5251290202,
-0.6529570222,
0.7533175349,
0.4006178081,
-0.0338286646,
-0.3842275441,
-0.4096370339,
-0.2720473409,
0.1651693881,
0.5887951851,
0.0625330582,
-1.1205791235,
-0.4073959291,
-0.175563857,
0.0178855117,
-0.0273751337,
0.8620077968,
-0.9505545497,
0.4135278761,
0.473577708,
0.562007308,
0.2796309888,
0.1191037372,
0.9409266114,
-0.5322372317,
0.1342563927,
0.2634373009,
0.355055064,
0.3113789558,
-0.4771740735,
0.4998188019,
0.2505878508,
-0.7607868314,
-0.6543568969,
0.3096293211,
-0.6519001126,
-0.3700594306,
1.1775299311,
-0.2107616663,
-0.1727515459,
-0.0119890375,
-0.2714218199,
0.3284104764,
-0.6389541626,
0.5886703134,
1.1419836283,
-0.3068714738,
-0.3074989021,
-0.7320511341,
0.937517941,
0.7271952629,
-0.6815153956,
0.1368528157,
0.5196673274,
0.1004964411,
-0.1405930519,
0.7284183502,
0.1808757931,
0.3736372888,
-0.3658155501,
-0.1541852355,
-0.0696033314,
-0.5172425508,
-0.5954831839,
-0.1836773902,
0.1915767342,
0.2672457695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11485v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11485v1 | Understanding Lexical Biases when Identifying Gang-related Social Media Communications | 2023-04-22T21:51:49 | 2023-04-22T21:51:49 | Dhiraj Murthy, Constantine Caramanis, Koustav Rudra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI, J.4; K.4.2; I.2.7 | Individuals involved in gang-related activity use mainstream social media
including Facebook and Twitter to express taunts and threats as well as grief
and memorializing. However, identifying the impact of gang-related activity in
order to serve community member needs through social media sources has a unique
set of challenges. This includes the difficulty of ethically identifying
training data of individuals impacted by gang activity and the need to account
for a non-standard language style commonly used in the tweets from these
individuals. Our study provides evidence of methods where natural language
processing tools can be helpful in efficiently identifying individuals who may
be in need of community care resources such as counselors, conflict mediators,
or academic/professional training programs. We demonstrate that our binary
logistic classifier outperforms baseline standards in identifying individuals
impacted by gang-related violence using a sample of gang-related tweets
associated with Chicago. We ultimately found that the language of a tweet is
highly relevant and that uses of ``big data'' methods or machine learning
models need to better understand how language impacts the model's performance
and how it discriminates among populations. | [
-0.2120855302,
-0.7928677201,
0.4558769464,
0.4601056576,
-0.2141815126,
0.6647770405,
-0.1825044006,
-0.753338635,
0.5407726169,
0.283850491,
-0.5525100231,
-0.5105753541,
-0.7914301753,
-0.0217697006,
-0.2596297562,
1.017768383,
0.0779059455,
0.3231678605,
0.3994748592,
-0.2419950962,
-0.4500222206,
-0.7467115521,
-1.0186561346,
-0.2206798941,
0.7242581844,
-0.0901749954,
0.5824225545,
0.1898934841,
0.556463778,
0.2013228238,
-0.1352013499,
-0.2463068068,
-0.8007170558,
-0.2125078887,
-0.3296056092,
-0.0069290726,
-0.1868090034,
-0.0249448847,
0.1616401374,
0.7211652994,
-0.0066900193,
0.4364697337,
-0.1196684316,
0.7048359513,
-0.9013087749,
0.2835476995,
-0.5785553455,
-0.123554118,
-0.4081527889,
-0.293569386,
-0.19112207,
-0.8574198484,
0.0842777863,
-0.332475245,
0.4547132254,
-0.3042754531,
0.741563797,
-0.1585315466,
-0.4549673498,
-0.3633024096,
-0.8028608561,
0.3529640436,
-0.3481104076,
0.1215320304,
1.0133174658,
0.3732377887,
0.022619823,
-0.2504503429,
-0.3520953655,
0.2597567439,
-0.3091443181,
-0.3106842637,
-0.0047182427,
0.3955649137,
0.3547805846,
0.0911674574,
-0.343813926,
-0.0556524508,
-0.768358469,
-0.3848259151,
0.8682668209,
0.1210652515,
0.4155020714,
-0.17372334,
0.0563507937,
0.1405028403,
-0.3154253066,
0.3673628867,
0.4873400629,
0.4560008943,
-0.1145266742,
0.4589347243,
0.1758782864,
0.5111829042,
-0.0139234262,
-0.2138314545,
0.4718509316,
-0.2866653204,
-0.1891741753,
0.2169067711,
0.7805782557,
0.7467225194,
0.6806875467,
-0.3139767051,
-0.241805613,
0.1380462646,
0.3948881328,
-0.5300219655,
-0.1898029447,
-0.0496123135,
-0.5681490302,
-0.1562943161,
0.051734522,
-0.8162246346,
-0.9690434933,
-0.1291586012,
0.1985414624,
-0.144339934,
-0.4292994738,
-0.0903423131,
-0.6820469499,
0.1766630262,
0.2560947239,
-1.0842117071,
0.5024741292,
0.4385262132,
1.0063947439,
0.1743205041,
0.3601505756,
-0.4367309511,
0.2615247071,
-0.4202956557,
0.6726917028,
-0.6445837617,
-0.1909314394,
0.3529195189,
0.0757277906,
-0.0581490211,
-0.448653996,
0.3892149925,
-0.5972721577,
-0.5599855185,
-0.4804747999,
-0.1409903616,
-0.0109274331,
-0.0380517617,
-0.689843297,
0.8200759292,
0.309641391,
-0.8364771008,
0.6664386392,
-0.4082222879,
-0.8043898344,
0.2239553332,
-0.1037114039,
-0.2212463319,
0.2500845492,
0.1947666556,
0.554012537,
-0.1019248366,
0.3765562773,
-0.6855479479,
-0.4644598067,
0.028640233,
-0.0125955902,
0.8710340858,
-0.0458727665,
-0.0996715799,
-0.1612138003,
-0.5798687339,
-0.3134467006,
0.258887589,
-0.1492762119,
-0.6746996641,
0.2725668252,
0.4295929074,
0.0853282735,
0.0116101671,
-0.7049601078,
0.0023252834,
-0.0618977733,
0.3529220521,
0.8752877116,
0.2084328979,
0.182763949,
-0.3184578121,
0.3506842852,
-0.282199651,
0.2641246915,
0.2464644015,
-0.3856809735,
-0.1267561913,
-0.0675159991,
0.0066267569,
0.3346541524,
-0.806563139,
0.3951824307,
-0.1554072499,
-0.4446257055,
-0.3919745088,
-0.0555669852,
0.1688332111,
0.2482979,
0.4331595898,
-0.2117643505,
-0.8746941686,
-0.9845482707,
-0.2531430721,
-0.4376730919,
0.0551271848,
0.2200157642,
0.1546170413,
-0.0451855622,
1.1034640074,
-0.2205188125,
-0.3035676181,
-0.4965763688,
0.2623227537,
-0.0094139352,
-0.1159491986,
0.6851850748,
-0.7598439455,
-0.7003496289,
-0.0362519026,
-0.612670958,
-0.5739482641,
-0.1148626879,
0.0000235404,
0.0199413113,
0.4998881221,
0.0171831027,
0.8088561893,
0.5989212394,
-0.3482356369,
0.2197176963,
0.5544189215,
0.1859393716,
-0.8245093226,
-0.0120930523,
0.4633328915,
-0.1548990756,
-0.8559217453,
-0.5751027465,
-0.267455548,
0.1765828431,
-0.1341830194,
0.5377259254,
-0.2374514341,
-0.2204895616,
-0.1225815415,
0.1407913715,
-0.4239762425,
0.1768832505,
0.0423707813,
0.5262545347,
0.6127689481,
-0.3816233277,
0.2987131178,
-0.0214968715,
-0.370285362,
0.172526896,
-0.5896772742,
0.0960228518,
-0.3112704754,
0.4498859644,
-0.9274154305,
-0.2796938419,
0.5888785124,
-0.5173720717,
0.107960023,
-0.5493720174,
-0.8195308447,
-0.4391988218,
-0.2668723464,
0.4548601806,
0.2161140442,
-0.2284982204,
0.3835346997,
0.9959735274,
-0.0451904908,
-0.5450088978,
-0.6608082652,
0.2084946036,
-0.2151950449,
-0.4831973612,
-0.0367489494,
0.3534147441,
-0.4014918506,
-0.2070118934,
-0.0676644668,
-0.329479605,
0.2549825609,
0.1862709522,
0.2089881003,
0.1306101233,
0.6004580855,
-0.0869787782,
0.3429037631,
0.2944352031,
0.2558816671,
0.9519165158,
0.016287474,
0.0120179178,
-0.1404364407,
0.3953187168,
0.0324757621,
-0.0429436043,
1.0419524908,
0.6331964731,
-0.3570924997,
0.1083005071,
-0.6573379636,
-0.1514174789,
-0.4568025172,
0.2221655995,
0.2279311717,
-0.953204453,
0.6596354842,
0.3295462728,
-0.1098091081,
-0.0215260889,
0.4493606687,
0.0055464404,
0.8936448693,
0.523894012,
-0.4711644948,
0.7604879141,
0.142187044,
0.5996994972,
-0.5476459861,
0.007802858,
-0.5247315764,
-0.3679228723,
-0.8325126171,
-0.04757303,
0.119051367,
-0.0618138872,
-0.0106303925,
0.3181755841,
-0.3532433808,
0.5249775648,
0.1280450225,
0.1681902856,
0.0610782281,
0.1338976622,
0.3229105175,
0.0912542269,
-0.4723904729,
-0.75036937,
1.0059310198,
0.4035949707,
0.8466840982,
0.2563809752,
0.5669375062,
0.527880013,
0.6951966882,
-0.7869342566,
0.4436055124,
-0.1026014984,
-1.0330135822,
-0.1640578657,
-0.4514006376,
-1.211037755,
-0.0999566987,
-0.2213229686,
-1.4453992844,
0.1400485635,
0.0819126368,
-0.4177935123,
0.4460118115,
-0.749052763,
0.5823246837,
0.117254667,
-0.034325812,
-0.0338548347,
-0.7861757278,
0.2795638144,
-0.3185581863,
0.5940027237,
-0.5079821944,
0.0877102464,
0.7266056538,
-0.2611939609,
1.0983974934,
-0.1330798119,
0.231018737,
0.3913495541,
-0.2617280781,
0.0712143183,
0.0550764948,
0.1198249236,
0.3308659792,
0.0088035902,
-0.4331814647,
-0.4093471169,
0.3604463041,
-0.7492907047,
-0.5743399858,
-0.2490809113,
-0.4497719705,
-0.3553301692,
0.0899087116,
0.2015773207,
0.4406673014,
-0.1747601479,
0.0618090667,
0.4188584983,
-0.0578276515,
0.6674256325,
0.1609480828,
-0.3943666518,
-0.1529515535,
0.7853639722,
0.1656052768,
0.2463660389,
-0.016484851,
0.1280361712,
-0.0111522544,
-0.2979776561,
-0.2739092708,
0.3615669012,
-0.6749106646,
0.0713942349,
-0.5678027272,
-0.1871109903,
-0.6722511053,
-0.3363246322,
0.0142291933,
-0.1544300765,
0.0097401077,
-0.1840228885,
0.303619951,
0.9618476033,
-0.1200323179,
0.5932771564,
-0.8840164542,
0.3150729537,
0.1452250481,
0.5618616343,
0.1270933449,
-0.0984346569,
-0.4142589867,
-0.2795419097,
-0.1186155379,
-1.5002332926,
0.0600154474,
-0.0050337561,
0.4691381454,
0.3713403642,
0.0553459264,
0.5097526908,
-0.2634783387,
0.7181016207,
0.1661909372,
-0.7176883817,
0.6467237473,
-0.6046219468,
-0.0435675308,
0.9328202009,
0.5874742866,
-0.9028133154,
-0.3274311423,
-0.4814149141,
-0.7685957551,
0.7570965886,
0.4052216113,
0.3093212545,
-0.5237128139,
0.2076751739,
-0.3320183456,
0.2585784197,
-0.9765952826,
-0.4895711839,
-0.0752770752,
-0.0204653554,
-0.0059650261,
-0.3526845276,
-0.1702144146,
-0.1346075386,
0.3462337255,
0.0287435427,
0.2310238332,
0.0127171669,
0.1163662672,
-0.4168109298,
0.1067734361,
0.3091190755,
0.7618877292,
-0.2787843049,
0.0029101174,
-0.0389250293,
-0.7415987253,
-0.0180626679,
0.0083794305,
-0.06477274,
0.2967509627,
0.4931091964,
0.5901411176,
-0.1218997389,
-0.7519077063,
0.735855341,
-0.1527664512,
-0.0861525908,
-0.3531485796,
-0.102855809,
-0.0360582285,
0.023619419,
0.6128518581,
0.0551207587,
0.2352318317,
-0.806122601,
-0.1212972999,
0.41144979,
-0.6337947249,
-0.3684148192,
0.0611085817,
0.2234740406,
-0.427259326,
0.2839096785,
-0.3056380153,
-0.5302451849,
0.5943400264,
0.2021323591,
1.0200562477,
-0.1299724281,
0.3025530577,
0.4674541354,
0.6193096042,
0.0435070992,
0.1569105834,
0.2053968012,
-0.8970361948,
-0.3709544241,
-0.5883817077,
0.2447905242,
0.1413457096,
-0.928260088,
0.3862413168,
-1.0177989006,
-0.7209041715,
0.2663823366,
-0.3735195696,
-0.5804926157,
0.0276113525,
0.480119735,
0.6810616851,
-1.2539637089,
0.6114336848,
0.8183474541,
-0.3787357211,
-0.9071263075,
0.3605499864,
0.3728769124,
-0.8296266198,
0.8245949149,
0.3450533152,
-0.001271906,
-0.4902914464,
-0.7749940157,
-0.7201195359,
0.5970138907,
0.015806945,
-0.2378749102,
-0.0716248378,
0.1502870023,
0.8623086214,
-0.2842569947,
0.0701595023,
0.6620924473,
0.31491822,
0.187928915,
-1.1523649693,
-0.0630838424,
-0.1950562149,
0.1781124473,
0.6457186341,
-0.5154811144,
0.3722567558,
-0.0192816444,
-0.4707171917,
-0.4868689477,
0.2582383156,
0.2331893593,
0.5949090123,
0.4370431304,
0.0547238812,
0.6278607845,
-0.131635204,
1.0855952501,
0.1399153024,
0.2470896542,
0.9732785821,
-0.0693428367,
0.3940084875,
0.5124798417,
-0.052207917,
0.4417197108,
0.7912288904,
-0.106459327,
0.448541671,
0.4008801281,
-0.4545799494,
-0.097040683,
-0.5192400217,
-0.053572882,
0.2720993161,
0.706705749,
-0.6142691374,
-0.3444223702,
-0.1096135378,
0.0996235013,
0.086992301,
-0.7340297103,
0.8724355102,
-0.0413423106,
-0.2596772611,
0.2057626247,
-0.1415132284,
0.5328295827,
-0.4047479331,
0.0115484949,
0.125610292,
-0.1839852333,
-0.3865041435,
-0.8730450273,
0.660405755,
0.0331409238,
-0.0167557541,
-0.0247118138,
0.8288134336,
-0.1310091764,
-0.493352145,
0.6310090423,
0.3571798801,
0.1273839176,
0.0114807747,
-0.6275151968,
0.1424393952,
-0.0356078669,
0.0207612272,
0.2540778518,
0.4274464846,
-0.1947906464,
0.6350439787,
0.3502247632,
0.3341244161,
0.1038146839,
0.4797210097,
0.9400165081,
-0.3706114292,
-0.0187321529,
-1.0093331337,
0.1304672509,
-0.4062103331,
-0.4834813774,
0.6144433618,
0.3544008732,
0.9101147652,
0.249795869,
0.9923974872,
-0.3738386929,
0.5892087221,
-0.3224775493,
0.3266278505,
-0.1367293596,
0.3042270243,
-0.4216950536,
-0.6685476303,
-0.3316660523,
0.7209196687,
-0.8273174763,
0.2846218646,
0.5026832223,
0.7070504427,
0.2584221661,
0.1342315376,
0.1005762592,
-0.1141127124,
0.3215873837,
0.1839201003,
0.6297417283,
-0.1950897276,
0.5560506582,
-0.1981005073,
-0.1913003474,
-0.1968640387,
-0.5276671052,
-1.5227879286,
-0.4037775099,
-0.0391013995,
-0.4263146818,
0.2304452956,
1.25004673,
0.4115960598,
-0.5873731375,
-0.2571460307,
0.1656566709,
0.1383490711,
0.1720690131,
-0.308383286,
0.1008618101,
-0.391305238,
-0.3346122503,
-0.1811708808,
0.2932037413,
-0.1569849253,
-0.0486461483,
0.3269700706,
-0.3805265129,
-0.0478635468,
0.688339889,
0.1542651802,
-0.5327956676,
-0.4123718441,
-0.015883306,
-0.3110285997,
0.0054619452,
1.0451415777,
-0.4130840003,
0.3631028235,
0.3478272259,
0.6327933073,
0.2483755648,
0.0818815455,
0.5707978606,
-0.8977342248,
-0.2040156871,
0.3565151691,
0.1828644276,
0.4010617733,
-0.4964114726,
0.746994257,
0.4616574943,
-0.4466068447,
-0.4628206491,
0.011897617,
-0.9146282077,
-0.2811196148,
1.4247579575,
0.1099890471,
-0.1041837484,
-0.8961341977,
-0.3606841564,
0.284252286,
-0.8254640102,
1.0089310408,
0.9193770885,
0.1389247328,
-0.373255223,
-0.9258800149,
0.552410543,
-0.2434093058,
-0.5776978731,
0.1639593393,
0.4450618625,
0.0263518728,
0.1038559824,
0.8028774858,
0.0459738597,
0.1877219081,
-0.3637271821,
0.0791373327,
0.4374169409,
0.1977884322,
-0.1732514501,
0.0754120797,
-0.4207988679,
0.2786261737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11473v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11473v2 | (Vector) Space is Not the Final Frontier: Product Search as Program Synthesis | 2023-04-22T20:00:06 | 2023-06-11T17:35:02 | Jacopo Tagliabue, Ciro Greco | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | As ecommerce continues growing, huge investments in ML and NLP for
Information Retrieval are following. While the vector space model dominated
retrieval modelling in product search - even as vectorization itself greatly
changed with the advent of deep learning -, our position paper argues in a
contrarian fashion that program synthesis provides significant advantages for
many queries and a significant number of players in the market. We detail the
industry significance of the proposed approach, sketch implementation details,
and address common objections drawing from our experience building a similar
system at Tooso. | [
-0.4843621552,
-0.2914564312,
0.7678348422,
0.2510105669,
0.2210283577,
0.4389778972,
0.0280695148,
-0.3716218174,
0.2528541088,
0.4415696263,
-0.8188675642,
-0.6580685973,
-0.081146948,
0.0722341239,
-0.7367201447,
0.6944031119,
0.1539607495,
-0.1451560706,
-0.330126375,
-0.2492088526,
-0.397883594,
-0.8492346406,
-0.5052078962,
0.0500386097,
0.343980521,
0.2232619673,
0.6491674781,
0.2179671973,
0.5999108553,
0.3534219861,
-0.0115793617,
0.0091724005,
-0.7524401546,
0.4305135012,
-0.2234273106,
-0.5885660648,
-0.1910749227,
0.1049066558,
0.2964218557,
0.8438345194,
-0.1350923032,
-0.0068184813,
0.0123673007,
1.0936793089,
-0.8922296762,
-0.2506496906,
-0.6531383395,
0.2982269824,
0.1223167107,
-0.2001991123,
-0.3886402547,
-0.2782736719,
0.2540290952,
-0.8689243197,
0.5862761736,
0.439720571,
0.7108092904,
0.2136937976,
-0.1992796361,
-0.3820087016,
-1.1681146622,
1.1233619452,
-0.5354734659,
0.6325021386,
0.0314000994,
0.615917027,
-0.5969531536,
-0.9184970856,
-0.4860092998,
-0.0657142922,
0.5917503834,
0.1748063415,
-0.1546839774,
-0.1953889728,
0.1598426998,
0.2195771486,
-0.5576002002,
-0.2765723169,
-0.7998552918,
0.2013660371,
0.7365518212,
0.2686368823,
0.1221793368,
0.0414500907,
-0.7514567375,
0.02385341,
-1.0895910263,
-0.0035460505,
0.1524900496,
0.0760839581,
0.6248037219,
1.0179584026,
-0.183408916,
0.4960843027,
-0.3689388633,
0.4503648877,
0.0608961508,
-0.3460824192,
-0.2953012288,
-0.1879274696,
0.5266539454,
0.6703112125,
-0.521092236,
-0.1404949278,
-0.4480881989,
0.0119040227,
0.5921066999,
-0.5114035606,
0.0375426747,
0.483053863,
-0.7221217155,
0.032376796,
0.3297218382,
-0.7190125585,
-0.1803296059,
-0.3179504573,
0.3066849113,
-0.0674742684,
0.0302457195,
0.2058449537,
-0.655271709,
0.4038307369,
-0.0561907329,
-0.4633833468,
0.4625073671,
1.0456693172,
0.7877120376,
-0.2150719613,
-0.0688679293,
-0.3429227173,
-0.0032619713,
-0.8330147266,
0.8589632511,
-0.6558457017,
-0.9794119596,
0.0581599362,
-0.1509995908,
0.3278025389,
-0.9565435648,
0.4722439647,
-0.8575980067,
0.1481940895,
-0.8155798316,
-0.6789546013,
-0.1578084677,
0.0265009217,
-0.5183061361,
0.9456223249,
0.292204529,
-0.2389698327,
0.5194893479,
-0.4959764481,
-0.378904283,
0.1123597324,
-0.3589096367,
-0.4370987117,
0.3402460515,
0.1536826938,
0.1885130107,
-0.2554783225,
0.0600559786,
-0.7424975038,
-0.6079348922,
0.4995397925,
0.1350352019,
0.3674892187,
0.5073996186,
-0.1572747976,
-0.2364413589,
-0.8187006712,
0.0329108872,
0.057858631,
-0.5166015625,
-0.3512699902,
0.324462086,
0.1004325524,
0.4181863666,
0.3105131984,
-0.6667511463,
0.3659358621,
-0.5813271999,
0.6571634412,
0.4284150004,
-0.1242314652,
0.6668297648,
-0.0616858862,
0.7503362894,
-0.5361070037,
0.5105968714,
0.213829428,
-0.6908574104,
-0.8005508184,
0.0879208818,
0.190243572,
0.2733058035,
-0.7885162234,
0.3153522313,
0.0073431721,
-0.1638960391,
-0.2606005371,
0.0383147672,
-0.0066387546,
0.1030525267,
0.3539570272,
-0.2923603952,
-0.9541144371,
-0.9182602763,
-0.2985985875,
-0.1011961177,
-0.2788633704,
0.60912925,
0.1434808671,
-0.3914229572,
0.9163088799,
-0.8495374918,
-0.6304380298,
-0.3458960354,
-0.1474422961,
0.6299415231,
0.1195911318,
0.7167556882,
-0.9037716985,
-0.5380445719,
-0.0506385006,
-0.4998890162,
-0.0310649797,
0.0796448737,
-0.3126185536,
-0.1056585088,
0.9143782854,
-0.8104254007,
0.3867616653,
0.2268453985,
0.0990182012,
0.250292033,
-0.3557549417,
-0.0954755321,
-0.7454889417,
0.3755387962,
-0.0924422964,
-0.1048366204,
-0.3594777286,
0.2603470683,
-0.2254479378,
-0.5259101391,
-0.4763304293,
0.0542901754,
-0.1695971936,
-0.4906972945,
-0.5533906221,
0.1528324932,
0.3773373067,
0.2778640389,
-0.1790552884,
1.1189695597,
0.2346708477,
-1.0134553909,
0.242872104,
0.5554803014,
-0.149704352,
0.4254053533,
-0.7884994149,
0.0391188078,
-0.3006804883,
0.2638253272,
-1.1155446768,
0.167888552,
-0.066499494,
-0.5604566932,
0.2267687023,
-0.0891445056,
0.06450966,
-0.7093623877,
-0.6172548532,
0.2250092775,
0.7913398743,
-0.4826637506,
0.6151379943,
0.5770761967,
-0.1107747406,
-0.7680373788,
-0.652410984,
0.1788054854,
-0.1466222256,
-0.4707785547,
0.3734791577,
-0.1205839664,
-0.0192305464,
-0.039516639,
-0.1985147744,
0.1973881274,
-0.0078871362,
-0.07174512,
0.4070481956,
-0.2590040863,
0.1068881303,
-0.0682403594,
-0.3050211668,
0.2287533134,
-0.8033337593,
0.2406098396,
0.2410094887,
-0.345512569,
0.2603284717,
0.6373130083,
0.290032655,
-0.1162962988,
0.4352600873,
0.089915365,
-0.1005730182,
-0.7494552732,
-0.2370945662,
0.2114541978,
-0.5900605917,
0.2106316984,
-0.2200953364,
-0.7338092923,
0.4299236536,
-0.477286607,
0.0957436934,
0.8258439898,
0.3022870719,
-0.4200242162,
1.266844511,
1.0476146936,
0.3732637465,
0.3674258888,
-0.6425577998,
0.748516798,
-1.0362734795,
-0.5930615067,
-0.734172821,
-0.5352210999,
-0.8243516684,
-0.3674497306,
0.5627035499,
-0.1689929962,
-0.1699666828,
0.4980142713,
-0.74413234,
0.4242704809,
0.8564098477,
-0.0926441252,
-0.1966923773,
0.187566638,
-0.08491458,
-0.3267790675,
-0.878549993,
-0.1455038786,
1.4467602968,
-0.0088468427,
0.6945239902,
0.0456360541,
0.7548653483,
0.1191016883,
-0.0814895257,
-0.8148705363,
0.5269317627,
-0.4820263386,
-0.6871114373,
-0.1093340889,
-0.2251906544,
-1.143710494,
0.2144667804,
-0.0883830935,
-0.3183192611,
0.7960431576,
-0.170337528,
-0.665579617,
-0.0730839074,
-0.5405856967,
0.5267077088,
-0.1629037857,
-0.5086182356,
-0.2065569162,
-0.4727534652,
-0.1335233301,
-0.0406915508,
0.1415328383,
0.0265078135,
-0.189892903,
0.7622352242,
-0.6171535254,
0.2114499658,
-0.0157531127,
0.3138352633,
0.4989936948,
0.1783443987,
0.2575317919,
-0.1035048589,
0.1519087851,
-0.2385812849,
0.0170544405,
-0.3125990033,
-0.691064775,
0.901094377,
-0.619990766,
-0.8723993897,
-0.3523769081,
-0.127839461,
-0.2043793947,
0.3808041215,
0.4514939189,
-0.0547610335,
-0.5201819539,
0.5195869207,
0.7784443498,
-0.789083004,
0.2558564842,
0.3447050154,
-0.6260869503,
-0.2350146025,
1.1367040873,
0.1977782398,
-0.0892565325,
0.5804882646,
0.0580813549,
-0.6087448597,
-0.3498508632,
-0.0231381338,
0.0050352118,
-0.9608470798,
-0.0563228577,
-0.7182916403,
-0.234015435,
-0.2573409379,
-0.2877539396,
-0.8094257116,
-0.5375204682,
-0.3429939449,
-0.071006231,
-0.0726670623,
1.0699920654,
-0.1293855757,
-0.0756798759,
-0.6057120562,
0.4256278872,
0.3595859408,
0.429761827,
-0.0557238609,
0.0845713019,
-0.3043036163,
-0.0204649661,
-0.6112524271,
-0.4713846743,
0.4691370428,
0.1526284069,
0.6257976294,
0.1373870671,
-0.0479422323,
0.3934304714,
-0.5721722841,
1.0404746532,
0.1480640024,
-0.7139052749,
0.4578441381,
-0.0639942065,
0.1567347199,
0.3571254909,
0.4640445411,
-0.4714942873,
-0.1212090999,
-0.6339733005,
-1.3117359877,
0.3836396039,
0.3602176607,
0.4154822826,
0.106990926,
0.1320019066,
0.2184208333,
0.5197575092,
-0.2179370672,
-0.1336219609,
-0.0480469875,
0.1883454174,
-0.0234895702,
-0.536008954,
0.1500274688,
-0.2814985514,
0.7630795836,
0.1271030009,
0.5388739705,
0.3503564894,
0.4684716463,
-0.1004313007,
0.0448663048,
0.2071161568,
0.8929514289,
-0.2213837206,
-0.2776106596,
-0.408836484,
-0.067273885,
0.0680980012,
-0.0469080471,
-0.2334449589,
0.1829167306,
0.0017280387,
0.4356555939,
-0.0823109671,
-0.6217051744,
0.5928615928,
0.0260053854,
-0.4000549316,
-0.4231235683,
0.1687645018,
0.027362898,
0.4665907621,
0.6483861208,
0.2242955416,
0.9251878858,
-0.4622808695,
0.2374483198,
0.5729519129,
-0.1662737429,
-0.1301753819,
1.1946035624,
-0.0143640768,
-0.139252916,
0.8550967574,
-0.1454991698,
-0.5111239552,
0.6447969079,
0.265765816,
0.9968579412,
-0.0902651101,
0.3697445691,
0.1736346483,
0.2271393836,
-0.1587429941,
0.9066377878,
0.0207534153,
-0.4100650847,
-0.3599083722,
-0.5069497228,
-0.203463465,
0.1117092744,
-0.2800535858,
0.4391959906,
-0.6024269462,
-0.6737855077,
0.1036275774,
-0.2565769255,
-0.7706897259,
0.1396483779,
0.0560099371,
0.6288033724,
-0.580770731,
0.3877899349,
0.5274146199,
-0.3848182261,
-0.2928492427,
-0.2569990754,
-0.3867978752,
-0.4002133012,
0.7004073262,
0.1401227862,
-0.0458802395,
-0.3533448279,
-0.7454260588,
-1.1354205608,
0.8651180863,
0.019085329,
-0.7311810851,
0.0419853665,
0.154617399,
0.8528776765,
-0.2370599657,
-0.4003921151,
0.2736208439,
0.0366081297,
0.5708325505,
-0.3466747105,
-0.3549018204,
-0.1922559738,
0.6384304166,
0.0403782688,
-0.3959540725,
1.0471565723,
-0.0297365226,
-0.5325436592,
0.2287106961,
0.6978438497,
0.1220401749,
0.4927508533,
-0.0957695395,
0.3754685223,
0.3786431551,
0.0732622892,
1.3593872786,
-0.1534417123,
0.4686475098,
0.8251499534,
-0.6047416329,
1.1079947948,
0.5864758492,
-0.6497066021,
0.0565303229,
0.5143637061,
-0.1907184869,
0.8314174414,
0.1202036366,
0.0961840078,
-0.2532598078,
0.0283161905,
-0.4122304618,
0.1892800778,
0.5963079333,
-0.5223476887,
-0.1015478075,
-0.1614174694,
-0.6285373569,
0.0964106694,
0.1236341298,
0.6253714561,
0.4277223051,
-0.5028959513,
0.6602623463,
0.2493548542,
0.1717678756,
-0.4048916698,
-0.2028270513,
-0.1344225556,
0.4589206874,
-0.1928565353,
-0.6962422729,
0.4938770533,
-0.5453904867,
0.1807242632,
-0.0392352454,
0.739851594,
-0.0825589374,
-0.6602413058,
0.3876613379,
0.6133562922,
-0.0507997498,
-0.1152764037,
-1.0190182924,
0.0907755941,
0.0513422042,
-0.4458090365,
0.1277929246,
0.3888953626,
-0.01415342,
0.7885039449,
0.7963495851,
-0.2125470042,
0.1071133092,
-0.1672298312,
0.99457407,
-0.6433470845,
-0.5959935188,
-0.5292370915,
0.0401311703,
0.0205922518,
-0.0238233544,
0.9737744331,
1.0018037558,
1.0599142313,
-0.0448520556,
1.0564795732,
0.0465660021,
0.3381896615,
-0.4079496861,
0.3837087154,
-0.9072442651,
0.5253486037,
-0.0677520931,
-1.4643529654,
-0.2929379642,
0.524721086,
-0.2368124127,
0.1984520257,
0.5527302623,
0.8031308651,
-0.2246576399,
0.0219646767,
0.4904895425,
0.1557561904,
0.3220718205,
0.4901463389,
1.0723495483,
-0.455396831,
0.2921004891,
0.1063778773,
-0.0550083257,
-0.4526556432,
-0.5414358377,
-0.5946497917,
-0.61560148,
-0.1130363643,
-0.4267782271,
-0.200409323,
0.7771371007,
0.4328640401,
-0.8320152164,
-0.3087367713,
-0.1220379695,
-0.0583524555,
-0.3676247001,
-0.1002777591,
0.2239502966,
-0.3658557534,
-0.5152350068,
0.6386708617,
0.6564465165,
-0.1787684262,
-0.5533662438,
0.0495572388,
-0.2041505575,
0.2309474647,
0.7440544963,
0.3651935756,
-0.3557797074,
0.3269297183,
0.6070584059,
0.1990259886,
0.4561492503,
1.0941581726,
-0.8993020654,
0.566411674,
0.8020423651,
0.7334754467,
0.6486821771,
-0.2366472036,
0.9697117209,
-0.7247677445,
0.0682172179,
0.1421246976,
0.1693525016,
0.4668351114,
-0.5371950269,
0.3879152238,
0.0837499872,
-0.5221002698,
-0.394793421,
0.2931290865,
-0.484536767,
-0.8346832991,
1.0666679144,
0.1667015105,
-0.7243487239,
-0.1288712621,
-0.3484826684,
-0.0776248425,
-0.2961339653,
0.840674758,
0.4910736978,
-0.0946370214,
0.5459209085,
-0.8261098266,
0.3470798135,
0.226577118,
-0.0448903702,
-0.3709145784,
0.5372006893,
0.0575102605,
0.2085649073,
0.4664365649,
-0.0753896385,
0.2029102743,
0.0389373451,
-0.0572648682,
0.187602371,
-0.4533552825,
-0.0857979953,
0.2911869586,
0.2522398233,
-0.1945359558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11461v1 | Recurrent Neural Networks and Long Short-Term Memory Networks: Tutorial and Survey | 2023-04-22T18:22:10 | 2023-04-22T18:22:10 | Benyamin Ghojogh, Ali Ghodsi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE, cs.SD, eess.AS | This is a tutorial paper on Recurrent Neural Network (RNN), Long Short-Term
Memory Network (LSTM), and their variants. We start with a dynamical system and
backpropagation through time for RNN. Then, we discuss the problems of gradient
vanishing and explosion in long-term dependencies. We explain close-to-identity
weight matrix, long delays, leaky units, and echo state networks for solving
this problem. Then, we introduce LSTM gates and cells, history and variants of
LSTM, and Gated Recurrent Units (GRU). Finally, we introduce bidirectional RNN,
bidirectional LSTM, and the Embeddings from Language Model (ELMo) network, for
processing a sequence in both directions. | [
-0.2591884434,
-0.8805938959,
0.5703597069,
0.1445572078,
-0.0403088965,
0.2300641388,
-0.2324127257,
-0.5864073038,
0.4998560846,
0.6666221619,
-0.4895600975,
-0.1864465475,
-0.3179869354,
-0.0248818342,
-0.5797761679,
1.1930985451,
-0.2126195133,
0.2045055628,
-0.1382885873,
-0.2841624022,
-0.3087314367,
-0.5219393969,
-1.1491708755,
-0.4430016577,
0.9261783361,
-0.0927740335,
0.3122490644,
0.3427169919,
0.3568072021,
0.3114007115,
-0.6409140229,
-0.2827311456,
-0.4654628336,
0.4614468813,
-0.1715937704,
-0.3563569784,
-0.2288829088,
-0.3659497499,
0.8398998976,
0.7553289533,
-0.2352528721,
-0.0965174213,
-0.0337637775,
0.9545045495,
-0.2235980481,
0.1101931706,
-0.1005252972,
0.1511806697,
-0.2179003358,
0.0847413167,
-0.125680849,
-0.6654812098,
0.2784071267,
0.0546870418,
0.3076629639,
0.0158259608,
0.315874368,
0.126889959,
-0.4425132871,
-0.2842076719,
-1.0778361559,
0.9374133945,
-0.5571392179,
0.2939923108,
-0.0619396828,
0.3733919859,
-0.2522878945,
-0.8814774752,
-0.1648559719,
-0.4484235644,
0.1222320646,
0.1332825869,
0.1865081191,
0.3541404903,
0.2103208005,
0.5576822758,
-0.5025269985,
0.2686160207,
-0.551041007,
-0.0944049731,
0.4167677462,
0.351438731,
-0.0136334626,
-0.1565300226,
-0.5899296403,
0.4123491049,
-0.6354758739,
-0.1554432064,
0.4178795815,
0.1401128769,
0.1792588085,
0.2558486164,
-0.0716353059,
0.6100014448,
-0.3115395606,
-0.0003923403,
-0.016488418,
-0.2715818882,
-0.1815548092,
0.0014779655,
0.5861480832,
-0.3083236217,
0.098242186,
-0.1071559265,
-0.3733133674,
-0.4889454246,
-0.0657686889,
-0.5882949233,
-0.0292408299,
0.157008931,
-0.8528336883,
-0.3141521215,
-0.1421165913,
-0.7241312265,
-0.1674310267,
-0.4660773575,
0.4691223502,
-0.171279192,
-0.3637915552,
0.1202115938,
0.0179685224,
0.1515417695,
0.1538872719,
-0.7176322341,
0.4842817187,
0.5131413937,
0.8302255869,
-0.2443984002,
-0.3764061034,
0.1312876195,
-0.0949599668,
0.1691081226,
0.3566226363,
-0.110326007,
-0.512825191,
0.2366423756,
0.0805827901,
-0.0122989779,
-0.5260299444,
0.069108367,
-0.6892242432,
0.5048766136,
0.03304464,
-0.7592048645,
-0.3336873651,
0.1882904917,
-0.9587255716,
0.6316921115,
0.0948481187,
-0.4847380817,
-0.4165178537,
-0.7818717957,
-0.4611854851,
-0.1271088868,
-0.1669363528,
-0.3708717525,
0.1295478791,
-0.3034744561,
0.3865202069,
-0.0967754573,
0.2354333252,
0.0647162497,
-0.1449633092,
0.2902009785,
-0.4239423275,
0.7328179479,
0.3614428639,
0.0222235378,
-0.009785396,
-0.9134389758,
-0.0577660017,
0.2382402122,
-0.5236181021,
0.0538680144,
0.0193000119,
0.0211732686,
-0.0893549547,
0.572679162,
-0.4600575268,
0.1584736109,
-0.1579573005,
1.0752959251,
0.6434166431,
0.1833080798,
0.1478990018,
-0.2630290687,
0.4929957092,
0.3211254776,
0.0901036412,
-0.4938166738,
-0.4504459798,
-0.625195384,
0.3286734819,
0.3939267397,
0.5491870046,
-0.6502135396,
0.1759917736,
0.0390130579,
0.0982169881,
0.2102747262,
-0.123176232,
0.2420831174,
0.456572175,
0.2649632096,
-0.2331746221,
-0.7074959278,
-1.0202666521,
-0.1176232323,
-0.2828445137,
0.3025457859,
0.361420989,
0.4792450666,
-0.2486602366,
0.6438512206,
-0.3616444767,
-0.1894341558,
-0.2892688811,
0.3496538997,
0.2945183516,
0.52073282,
0.2391682863,
-0.5032158494,
-0.0954302847,
-0.1505981684,
-0.4174799323,
0.3285498619,
-0.0794335231,
0.3098118007,
0.4882965088,
0.43079108,
-0.6008910537,
0.282299757,
0.2352580875,
0.2650408745,
0.341948092,
-0.1439663917,
-0.1127361804,
-1.2821216583,
0.0098934239,
-0.1837159693,
-0.4244044125,
-0.5678778887,
0.0767197907,
-0.4052653611,
-0.2168438435,
-0.6281769276,
0.3260264695,
-0.5814783573,
-0.1358091235,
-0.2997706234,
-0.0559460297,
-0.1805784106,
0.4669119418,
0.1338772178,
0.2334847599,
0.269444406,
-0.4387480021,
0.7669045925,
-0.1168076694,
-0.2179235518,
0.1684836745,
-0.5528092384,
0.0761888847,
-0.3423876464,
0.2622902393,
-0.6539307833,
0.1584241241,
0.2544705272,
-0.0783181489,
0.614082396,
-0.5311519504,
-0.2843835056,
-0.5475661159,
-0.0033875802,
1.0221463442,
0.671808362,
-0.4903634489,
0.0611119643,
-0.016911542,
0.0674970075,
-0.8224025369,
-0.5273336768,
0.0064438228,
-0.2747446895,
-0.2864831686,
0.1113055646,
-0.023260992,
0.0400183611,
0.0213012304,
0.277264148,
-0.2041313946,
-0.2175769657,
0.1070680022,
-0.1933988035,
-0.5546081662,
0.3091689348,
-0.3745214939,
-0.1965858489,
0.296531111,
-0.3779295087,
0.5802007914,
-0.4331721961,
-0.3465029299,
-0.2562598884,
0.5083671212,
0.2102665603,
0.2310257852,
0.529271245,
0.5777513385,
-0.4243095219,
-0.0936982632,
-0.3211170435,
-0.285777837,
-0.3696067929,
0.6162245274,
0.0736405104,
-0.8846794367,
0.6454907656,
-0.2163326144,
-0.2634465098,
0.4167467356,
0.4343690574,
-0.3127680421,
0.4464139342,
0.7176853418,
-0.3980816007,
0.6378905177,
-0.5715538263,
0.141277805,
-0.5755966902,
-0.1618338078,
-0.2786127627,
-0.735170424,
-0.608253181,
-0.1058191061,
0.0747934729,
0.1331715435,
-0.5224621892,
0.1519684941,
-0.4486239851,
0.5657234192,
0.233236596,
0.0670687929,
0.1061646566,
-0.0338236615,
0.2236778289,
-0.0045041027,
-0.5421631932,
0.0460332111,
0.852953136,
0.8503513932,
1.0888469219,
0.0676980987,
0.9789141417,
0.1527095735,
-0.0085985688,
-0.9202567339,
0.514926374,
-0.1082083806,
-0.5076744556,
-0.3786170781,
-0.3614557683,
-1.0964932442,
-0.2662520111,
0.2545663416,
-0.6029919982,
0.0945736766,
0.1263933331,
-0.4301233292,
0.8045941591,
-0.3220003843,
0.3694176674,
-0.4791035354,
-0.0068036867,
-0.2113817632,
-0.9250178337,
0.488106817,
0.4557475448,
-0.430293411,
0.2442482263,
0.0193167683,
0.9920866489,
-0.4259871244,
0.9092044234,
-0.1875498146,
0.0297919735,
0.4612783492,
-0.0464865305,
0.2705364227,
0.1397850066,
0.3695050478,
0.1926780045,
-0.0483741052,
-0.2785735726,
-0.5093308687,
0.755187273,
-0.6676706076,
-0.6815647483,
-0.5661503673,
-0.4432578981,
0.0887919068,
0.2181355059,
0.1314066947,
0.5917447209,
-0.3035148084,
0.1210329607,
1.1386810541,
0.0819126815,
1.0284192562,
0.0670894459,
-0.7113916278,
-0.558488071,
0.7982667685,
0.1677961797,
0.270150423,
0.4613759518,
0.1421092004,
-0.3226785064,
-0.70833987,
-0.3666713834,
0.3928050995,
-0.3822455406,
-0.081960246,
-0.1576126069,
-1.0073335171,
0.1905080229,
0.4414420128,
-0.6276438236,
-0.583836019,
-0.4533085227,
0.1191156954,
0.6568226218,
1.1735469103,
-0.1347942799,
0.144378826,
-0.6914115548,
0.078732729,
0.3461871445,
0.444354862,
0.379224956,
-0.3417226374,
-0.7802063227,
0.1553107202,
-0.372125864,
-0.853399992,
0.0143177835,
-0.0232855622,
0.3099044859,
0.5387316942,
-0.5092051029,
0.3347876072,
-0.4595920742,
0.910327673,
0.4506873786,
-0.5183385015,
0.4210755229,
-0.2974167764,
0.0109443767,
0.133898139,
0.4360753298,
-0.5532572269,
0.1181240603,
-0.5778499246,
-0.653722167,
0.1751237065,
-0.0178113542,
0.1048638597,
0.1044945419,
0.6415649652,
0.1812169254,
0.3826938868,
-0.5756581426,
-0.5465843678,
-0.2025212198,
-0.0500960574,
-0.1867299229,
-0.579877913,
-0.3434153497,
0.037635047,
0.290293932,
0.2852124572,
0.4177214205,
0.2364008725,
-0.0288275238,
0.0142616509,
0.4455651045,
1.2065672874,
0.7261047363,
-0.3840122521,
0.0021771984,
0.1034389213,
-0.6298547983,
0.4445087314,
0.0536005571,
-0.0337034725,
0.1359481514,
0.1196369678,
0.7406485081,
0.2118193209,
-0.0954035372,
0.2413463295,
0.0955396369,
-0.043605648,
-0.6503779292,
-0.2183645517,
0.3412438929,
0.1269032061,
0.2683717906,
0.0072432118,
-0.0437622517,
-0.5411643386,
-0.0905654803,
0.3567615747,
-0.4466188252,
-0.2904010117,
0.3672284186,
0.1885537803,
-0.5953525901,
0.5919867158,
0.2728787065,
-0.4219099581,
0.7636573315,
0.7017149925,
1.0153059959,
-0.1111405119,
-0.0477553792,
0.0282746237,
-0.1267219484,
-0.1332052648,
0.4928757548,
-0.1198263839,
-0.4216878414,
-0.263889879,
-0.2682482898,
-0.3237021267,
0.6428908706,
-0.803336978,
-0.0522834584,
-0.5782718062,
-0.3099740148,
-0.2438666224,
0.1607563347,
-0.3198474348,
-0.0213925932,
-0.0645286143,
0.9233151078,
-0.5566413403,
0.8510950804,
0.5740779042,
-0.3207997978,
-0.3621500432,
-0.3784323633,
-0.3533191979,
-0.6007650495,
0.9660365582,
-0.15146631,
-0.1456601471,
-0.0826321393,
-0.5067254305,
-0.8209638596,
1.060713768,
-0.1302187592,
-0.6407105923,
-0.0550091192,
0.2088244855,
0.7409154773,
-0.332888335,
0.1626718789,
0.4956552088,
0.2231527418,
-0.1588470638,
-0.6480708122,
-0.3318686783,
0.1703423411,
0.3248411417,
0.5367875099,
-0.882450819,
0.9871842861,
-0.1595240235,
-0.1154946536,
0.8048245907,
0.8504331112,
0.1039650813,
0.5001529455,
0.2825706601,
0.8599617481,
0.2992774844,
-0.0607649945,
0.476936698,
-0.2655629814,
0.4418238401,
0.9979585409,
-0.0865012109,
0.798402369,
0.666682899,
-0.4402403831,
0.5520530939,
0.6626139879,
0.1768700331,
0.2305445224,
0.6476370096,
-0.4106490314,
0.236415714,
0.2279651612,
-0.9960446954,
-0.0011845492,
0.3861323595,
-0.5615981817,
-0.3388283849,
0.1156668141,
-0.0808278248,
-0.0933185592,
-0.5129165053,
0.6717339754,
0.5109952092,
-0.1621304303,
0.4300495088,
-0.1325858682,
0.5438657999,
-0.5701317191,
0.0676109344,
-0.3857866526,
0.0832602307,
-0.3472489715,
-0.8694652915,
0.1969879121,
-0.5846807957,
-0.6308184266,
-0.237064898,
0.6863452196,
-0.7142551541,
-0.3058047593,
0.2459568679,
0.6736280322,
0.3448814154,
0.4745239317,
-0.5821529627,
-0.2803477645,
-0.2523826361,
-0.2247603983,
0.3593394458,
0.0214727167,
-0.0477097332,
0.8535687327,
0.2087050974,
0.2368384898,
0.2456308305,
0.2394881397,
0.3859275281,
-1.2273279428,
-0.2940961719,
-0.7429403067,
0.0172248501,
0.3483561277,
-0.0334735215,
0.3343060911,
0.6529555917,
0.5490475893,
-0.3224330246,
0.4368190467,
0.2280611992,
0.6008296013,
-0.6850787997,
1.0463135242,
-0.3079714775,
0.0890416428,
0.3362649083,
-0.9027048349,
-0.1087350622,
0.0273279157,
0.0230683759,
0.4032231569,
0.6913016438,
0.6175268292,
0.0549976081,
0.2136694491,
0.2282576263,
0.2348709106,
0.1636559814,
0.9517562985,
1.387742281,
-0.5482358932,
0.33746925,
-0.2358675301,
0.315402925,
-0.2979515195,
-1.021663785,
-0.5629487634,
-0.7509372234,
-0.3643467128,
-0.5178627968,
0.2527882457,
0.5938280225,
0.6629711986,
-0.8528369069,
-0.4816248417,
-0.0391383655,
0.7919023633,
-0.0310089476,
-0.261048764,
0.4074239731,
-0.2576413453,
-0.5568063259,
0.2425252795,
0.1005010456,
0.5463155508,
-0.6916493773,
-0.1028802395,
0.0111030592,
-0.195243299,
0.5858738422,
1.0944359303,
-0.6754398942,
-0.2570269704,
-0.2580914497,
-0.1686389148,
0.2042055279,
1.1795766354,
-1.0139461756,
0.1923409551,
0.5961595774,
0.5351107121,
0.3606627285,
-0.159916088,
0.3868850172,
-0.5269781351,
0.0590776503,
0.4069723189,
0.4245386422,
-0.0742497817,
-0.3517173827,
0.1048897505,
0.3701953888,
-0.9324603081,
-0.6644064188,
0.6004122496,
-1.0838154554,
-0.0586333238,
0.6663050652,
0.0199587718,
-0.2155652493,
-0.1171147227,
0.0280229058,
0.2522912323,
-0.06301108,
0.678576827,
0.5448746681,
-0.4316820204,
-0.4208904505,
-0.378900528,
0.6767309308,
0.3455129564,
-0.5460520387,
-0.4275999665,
0.1969145834,
0.3296721578,
0.2352738231,
0.3057922423,
-0.1537821591,
0.2255832106,
-0.3603090942,
0.0391582772,
-0.2360163927,
-0.5296393037,
-0.8369434476,
0.0488948449,
0.0746525377,
-0.4845251143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11434v1 | L3Cube-IndicSBERT: A simple approach for learning cross-lingual sentence representations using multilingual BERT | 2023-04-22T15:45:40 | 2023-04-22T15:45:40 | Samruddhi Deode, Janhavi Gadre, Aditi Kajale, Ananya Joshi, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The multilingual Sentence-BERT (SBERT) models map different languages to
common representation space and are useful for cross-language similarity and
mining tasks. We propose a simple yet effective approach to convert vanilla
multilingual BERT models into multilingual sentence BERT models using synthetic
corpus. We simply aggregate translated NLI or STS datasets of the low-resource
target languages together and perform SBERT-like fine-tuning of the vanilla
multilingual BERT model. We show that multilingual BERT models are inherent
cross-lingual learners and this simple baseline fine-tuning approach without
explicit cross-lingual training yields exceptional cross-lingual properties. We
show the efficacy of our approach on 10 major Indic languages and also show the
applicability of our approach to non-Indic languages German and French. Using
this approach, we further present L3Cube-IndicSBERT, the first multilingual
sentence representation model specifically for Indian languages Hindi, Marathi,
Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam, Tamil, Gujarati, Odia, Bengali, and Punjabi. The
IndicSBERT exhibits strong cross-lingual capabilities and performs
significantly better than alternatives like LaBSE, LASER, and
paraphrase-multilingual-mpnet-base-v2 on Indic cross-lingual and monolingual
sentence similarity tasks. We also release monolingual SBERT models for each of
the languages and show that IndicSBERT performs competitively with its
monolingual counterparts. These models have been evaluated using embedding
similarity scores and classification accuracy. | [
-0.2902466953,
-0.6236273646,
0.3394400477,
0.5307863355,
-0.1316204369,
0.1114513129,
-0.581120193,
-0.6197218895,
0.17772834,
0.3419356942,
-0.5574554205,
-0.3826572895,
-0.3210167289,
0.2841512561,
-0.3210004866,
0.9088879228,
-0.0151697518,
0.5478206873,
-0.0893689096,
-0.1375371963,
-0.2705850601,
-0.4581721723,
-0.2850137949,
-0.3396091461,
0.527453959,
0.4270358682,
0.3802966774,
-0.0182796549,
0.090686582,
0.177616626,
0.0568804927,
0.4043758512,
-0.4559138715,
-0.0483484976,
-0.0311807338,
-0.4251694679,
0.1237795427,
-0.2407437861,
0.5608797073,
0.8641063571,
0.0747070312,
-0.0793049335,
0.2029231936,
0.3700360358,
-0.2433872819,
0.3224186301,
-0.5459207296,
0.2374618053,
-0.1570406407,
-0.1149724349,
-0.9219990373,
-0.464215368,
-0.0624589473,
-0.3744939566,
0.0986842364,
0.1491018981,
0.6476001143,
-0.1819103807,
-0.6889303923,
-0.3876010776,
-0.4039313793,
0.8564901352,
-0.7949233055,
0.6335054636,
0.1830153167,
0.0651501417,
-0.0535431691,
-0.5488927364,
-0.4699686468,
-0.5970932841,
-0.5575538278,
0.0769466907,
0.048485782,
-0.151814729,
-0.1061100215,
0.1790890098,
-0.818973124,
0.1646593958,
-0.5565266609,
-0.1186248288,
0.4476066828,
-0.093300961,
0.3313088119,
-0.2993603647,
-0.7340443134,
-0.0732602328,
-0.965826273,
0.2876355052,
0.5075525045,
0.7639289498,
-0.1749768108,
0.5920569897,
0.1924313158,
0.6187113523,
-0.0544068366,
0.0803141817,
0.3183879852,
-0.31082654,
-0.0902347416,
0.1797660738,
0.7745999098,
0.008591895,
0.4771622419,
-0.3821052313,
0.024314573,
-0.2703239024,
0.1058627442,
-0.505123198,
-0.1643592715,
-0.0169000402,
-0.5513502359,
0.0464360826,
-0.1737960428,
-0.5368672609,
-0.1541087776,
-0.3191550076,
0.2154149562,
-0.8977839351,
-0.0195374303,
-0.2593011856,
0.3012180924,
0.4974326789,
0.100867413,
-1.149836421,
0.3385763466,
0.4848289192,
0.6219418049,
-0.1541097164,
-0.6644094586,
-0.3750415444,
0.0326850191,
-0.4916600585,
0.688339293,
-0.3582534492,
-0.2246534973,
0.3335437775,
0.1684473455,
-0.0658522174,
-0.2503168583,
0.4805270135,
-0.3875861764,
0.293743521,
-0.0722248703,
-0.4936245978,
-0.4894457459,
0.3738860786,
-0.7399069071,
1.0757167339,
0.0395461991,
-0.630576849,
0.15297243,
-0.5238703489,
-0.7404546142,
0.0260642041,
-0.1071968749,
-0.1314628273,
0.0481703915,
0.5078579187,
0.6554629207,
-0.2027704269,
0.0978765562,
-0.2268058807,
-0.3385258615,
-0.0087683517,
-0.2973265648,
1.4052263498,
0.1838273257,
0.0420057885,
0.0954877958,
-0.5353099704,
0.1885968894,
-0.0699938387,
-0.0638793334,
-0.4117125571,
-0.2508447766,
0.6160103679,
0.1776145101,
0.3035563231,
-0.8153886199,
0.1169775352,
-0.4053300917,
0.2989293635,
0.5636410117,
-0.1340555996,
0.5029963255,
-0.0095097907,
0.2870380282,
0.1013742611,
0.0289259646,
-0.0548331775,
-0.4027758241,
-0.5833714604,
-0.2279609144,
0.6018215418,
0.6803635359,
-0.9073800445,
-0.025555592,
-0.2984730303,
-0.5612011552,
-0.6876959205,
0.3814430535,
0.2414132655,
0.1750821173,
0.462312758,
0.0586811826,
-0.4286737144,
-1.2825673819,
-0.3224386871,
-0.0896161273,
0.3101194203,
-0.1273696125,
0.3805805743,
-0.2356728613,
0.5760518909,
-0.1292544752,
-0.3149546981,
-0.8146238923,
0.42024526,
0.2433031052,
0.4058206677,
0.9232308269,
-0.7968502641,
-0.9472941756,
0.3677820563,
-0.5967800617,
0.103329733,
-0.2333017141,
0.0695804805,
0.6295489669,
0.6588469744,
-0.4064434469,
0.1173132062,
0.6815925241,
-0.1249765679,
0.368930608,
-0.3680476844,
0.1512538791,
-1.0435845852,
-0.1227691621,
-0.0110603608,
-0.4521115422,
-0.715174377,
0.1905863285,
0.5246015787,
-0.2424125522,
-0.56992203,
0.5124611855,
-0.4384483099,
0.1132320166,
0.1536780745,
0.1967594028,
-0.2345738709,
1.0011897087,
0.0514660999,
0.5898895264,
0.3240057826,
-0.331310153,
0.3549566865,
0.3291671574,
-0.5747738481,
0.3332703412,
-0.4981834888,
-0.2118879557,
-0.2559579015,
0.203744784,
-0.9128778577,
0.0515616052,
0.1211873963,
-0.5883509517,
0.4022676647,
0.0653029233,
-0.7469319701,
0.0544636212,
-0.2918044925,
0.3093547821,
0.1873230934,
-0.7977190614,
0.8015803099,
0.0878559873,
-0.447204411,
-0.779891789,
-1.1951025724,
0.0085345712,
-0.0578020513,
-0.5775257945,
0.4241580069,
-0.0165780261,
0.0305248443,
0.1071443409,
0.390882045,
-0.0487904474,
-0.3579171002,
-0.0519822836,
0.3112986088,
-0.0095257564,
0.2242764533,
0.116584599,
0.1086364463,
-0.1251475513,
0.0350474194,
0.4557951093,
-0.2983821929,
-0.2266089916,
0.0491933972,
0.8825201988,
0.3269966543,
-0.3136852682,
0.6467706561,
1.0189878941,
-0.4801190495,
-0.3307781518,
-0.3902757466,
-0.1047231108,
-0.3281425834,
0.3708200157,
-0.5511370897,
-0.9025189281,
0.3933800459,
0.1043388098,
0.2520885766,
0.2646543384,
0.79251194,
-0.1029484943,
0.7662644386,
0.9480478168,
-0.0286974218,
0.3807422221,
-0.0925230607,
0.6537291408,
-0.5577104092,
-0.2376478314,
-0.3684480786,
-0.0756196007,
-0.9011178613,
-0.2211269289,
0.4260096848,
-0.2180309594,
-0.258277148,
0.7676415443,
-0.1130478308,
0.2433284074,
0.8631197214,
0.0184620749,
0.0880764648,
0.2381817549,
-0.4103917778,
-0.3211505711,
-0.795378387,
-0.2610844374,
0.7446712255,
0.1878147274,
0.8854225278,
0.2571813166,
0.7783150673,
0.395185411,
0.1694390774,
-0.5838333368,
0.4764549732,
-0.4215284288,
-0.6219061017,
-0.0440540686,
-0.3623089492,
-0.7353511453,
0.4929554462,
-0.2854361832,
-0.8309341073,
0.285015583,
-0.3196487725,
-0.2765448093,
0.251357466,
-1.0249553919,
1.0451169014,
-0.577191174,
-0.3252990842,
-0.3490770459,
-0.7684415579,
0.4899125993,
0.0929293036,
0.2008520216,
0.0299177915,
0.2203575224,
0.3290275335,
-0.1481289566,
0.905264318,
-0.0280873142,
-0.15814282,
0.1965646595,
0.2739131153,
0.3830596209,
0.2677882314,
-0.0211712681,
0.3208405972,
0.0966046453,
-0.426656276,
-0.5237383246,
1.0747863054,
-0.8890077472,
-0.2363454849,
-0.6023465991,
-0.7626081109,
-0.3654764295,
0.1435682327,
0.0723766312,
0.416760236,
-0.2844159901,
0.2049551606,
0.4194258451,
-0.4423581958,
0.5439501405,
0.4753183424,
-0.2332026213,
-0.3903892338,
0.7680789232,
-0.115767844,
0.1367295235,
0.8077868819,
-0.3036139011,
-0.4680230618,
-0.0859822035,
-0.4033239782,
0.3926663697,
-1.0205720663,
-0.2151255906,
-0.6610866189,
-0.2231209725,
-0.6436627507,
-0.2632034719,
-0.2128368169,
-0.5317867994,
-0.0737820491,
-0.1500806361,
0.3982186019,
0.6134424806,
-0.4001243412,
0.1597738713,
-0.6390177011,
0.3398821354,
0.0568718612,
0.2451700121,
-0.1830257028,
-0.3306875825,
-0.4792907536,
-0.0241620559,
-0.1894844472,
-0.779322207,
0.6794221997,
0.2297620475,
0.5941268206,
-0.1102369875,
-0.1231906712,
0.6713653803,
-0.6481759548,
0.7888379693,
0.1519670039,
-0.9600585699,
0.2288128138,
0.0011208531,
0.1795262098,
0.4709510207,
0.635319829,
-0.747734189,
-0.1854770929,
-0.3074658513,
-0.8935775161,
0.8304911852,
0.1419570893,
0.1630661786,
-0.0408124067,
-0.1682882011,
0.3694354594,
-0.0133895222,
-1.5049613714,
-0.1759548336,
-0.3093685806,
-0.4022496939,
-0.1579243243,
-0.1573161781,
0.0664976612,
-0.171817854,
0.9474226832,
-0.1760153919,
0.3655415475,
0.1884920895,
-0.5639129281,
0.1404253691,
0.4943178296,
0.4869480729,
0.4385663867,
-0.3759320676,
0.0385779217,
0.3775815964,
-0.0006723683,
-0.0182260666,
0.4975201488,
-0.037094567,
0.285396874,
0.5767071247,
0.5754519701,
0.3575896025,
-0.8863166571,
0.3784966767,
-0.076588437,
0.0642734468,
-0.57861799,
-0.5961194038,
0.1613972485,
0.2780802846,
0.267526269,
-0.0549046099,
0.1417519599,
-0.790719986,
0.0194292199,
0.3358436227,
-0.4321562052,
0.0601283051,
0.5342890024,
0.0686234832,
0.0728233829,
0.6400577426,
-0.2298526615,
-0.558203876,
0.3437102139,
0.6820347309,
0.5942949653,
-0.093601808,
0.284394592,
0.5414764285,
0.6918171644,
0.0997953117,
0.2307760864,
-0.0368116871,
-0.6176854372,
-0.4846674204,
-0.3871427476,
-0.3918530345,
-0.0469426513,
-0.5396842957,
0.414701134,
-0.1117887571,
0.3587225974,
-0.0363988392,
0.0803002268,
-0.7009955645,
-0.0340376496,
0.4471911192,
0.9522049427,
-0.835935533,
1.1344183683,
0.7634348869,
-0.5227246881,
-0.6650128365,
-0.2182278484,
-0.3151006997,
-0.7303596139,
0.847972393,
0.1567270309,
0.0525235534,
-0.2713066638,
-0.3518129289,
-0.6220725179,
0.8310475349,
0.39336586,
-0.5950622559,
-0.0226429664,
0.3963512778,
0.6276314855,
-0.5282202363,
0.361310631,
0.2545298636,
0.364812851,
-0.3630574644,
-0.7410047054,
-0.1469379812,
-0.3794295192,
0.287278384,
0.0756980181,
-0.5275584459,
1.0832617283,
-0.2228030413,
-0.0696658343,
0.1061331183,
0.7978319526,
0.1582491845,
-0.1701314449,
0.3522972465,
0.3948500752,
0.4012384117,
-0.1554511935,
1.0268342495,
-0.4277531207,
0.4270937741,
1.1947973967,
-0.4175742567,
0.8690713644,
0.6270358562,
0.1095104665,
0.7330957651,
0.6184208393,
-0.0138045922,
0.7704187632,
-0.0407755598,
-0.0626099929,
-0.2828632295,
0.0100844111,
-0.1650575101,
0.4293170571,
0.4150502086,
-0.25652951,
-0.5021110773,
0.3193956017,
-0.0112946313,
0.3441611826,
-0.1328284591,
0.4338791668,
0.1057399511,
-0.7497524619,
0.68976897,
0.1729215831,
0.6506098509,
-0.8801252842,
-0.131914869,
-0.349924624,
0.3148161471,
-0.0303704608,
-0.7230789661,
0.1878585964,
-0.006233295,
-0.0364642218,
-0.4776954949,
0.4437807202,
-1.0740802288,
-0.8442385197,
0.7051220536,
0.4684784114,
-0.0473186709,
0.4282432199,
-0.6703472137,
-0.0945382565,
0.206881091,
0.1123354957,
0.119491376,
0.4795680344,
-0.160260424,
0.5715715885,
0.1924955994,
0.0242417231,
0.058201015,
0.1765694171,
0.4409144521,
-0.7575032115,
-0.4572617412,
-0.5138567686,
0.407066375,
0.0026771049,
-0.2311195731,
0.8319605589,
0.6041592956,
1.24206388,
-0.4737174511,
0.9097110033,
-0.3567548394,
0.6209925413,
-0.5937122703,
0.5517604351,
-0.7499495149,
-0.0626587644,
-0.0647854656,
-0.8234714866,
-0.3666142523,
0.65150702,
-0.0436154753,
-0.1029090211,
0.913592875,
0.794083178,
-0.3152800798,
0.0356585868,
0.2215751559,
0.2732318044,
0.2829974294,
0.7622353435,
0.7233107686,
-0.5829817653,
0.7768326402,
-0.4505601823,
0.0268284082,
-0.1633138359,
-0.755253315,
-1.0384696722,
-0.8087400794,
-0.0159257986,
-0.0719118789,
0.0484789461,
1.3167339563,
0.5466564894,
-1.0090806484,
-0.485268116,
0.1722964197,
0.004006302,
-0.428950876,
-0.228044495,
0.3777852952,
-0.7449324131,
-0.8841583133,
0.5992854834,
0.1896811128,
-0.1181461811,
-0.3640867174,
0.0587109253,
-0.7651494145,
0.0225872993,
0.9102300406,
0.2247017324,
-0.9360947013,
-0.1798331887,
0.0199482683,
-0.3349119425,
-0.0878483504,
0.7970086932,
-0.7352176905,
0.5073369145,
0.3868426085,
0.6131004095,
0.6221994162,
-0.4482992887,
0.5465435386,
-0.9499563575,
0.4429322183,
0.2659535408,
0.7719421387,
0.6248579621,
-0.2248714119,
0.5987929702,
-0.2705816031,
-0.3118626475,
-0.7175472975,
0.1943880022,
-1.0764476061,
-0.4681693614,
1.019690156,
-0.2078953832,
-0.0919555724,
0.0889700577,
-0.2843519151,
0.1808499545,
-0.2907091081,
0.5893058777,
0.8122110367,
-0.1055849791,
-0.4133493006,
-0.4856732488,
0.2962410748,
0.4710597098,
-0.623965323,
0.0829260722,
0.3035567403,
0.1119450107,
0.2599307001,
0.2452149391,
-0.2180849463,
0.2209842503,
-0.1869124174,
0.3663212657,
0.1511431932,
-0.3496145606,
-0.206849128,
0.1746829301,
-0.1807487607,
0.1658794135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11410v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11410v1 | A bounded rationality account of dependency length minimization in Hindi | 2023-04-22T13:53:50 | 2023-04-22T13:53:50 | Sidharth Ranjan, Titus von der Malsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.TH | The principle of DEPENDENCY LENGTH MINIMIZATION, which seeks to keep
syntactically related words close in a sentence, is thought to universally
shape the structure of human languages for effective communication. However,
the extent to which dependency length minimization is applied in human language
systems is not yet fully understood. Preverbally, the placement of
long-before-short constituents and postverbally, short-before-long constituents
are known to minimize overall dependency length of a sentence. In this study,
we test the hypothesis that placing only the shortest preverbal constituent
next to the main-verb explains word order preferences in Hindi (a SOV language)
as opposed to the global minimization of dependency length. We characterize
this approach as a least-effort strategy because it is a cost-effective way to
shorten all dependencies between the verb and its preverbal dependencies. As
such, this approach is consistent with the bounded-rationality perspective
according to which decision making is governed by "fast but frugal" heuristics
rather than by a search for optimal solutions. Consistent with this idea, our
results indicate that actual corpus sentences in the Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus
are better explained by the least effort strategy than by global minimization
of dependency lengths. Additionally, for the task of distinguishing corpus
sentences from counterfactual variants, we find that the dependency length and
constituent length of the constituent closest to the main verb are much better
predictors of whether a sentence appeared in the corpus than total dependency
length. Overall, our findings suggest that cognitive resource constraints play
a crucial role in shaping natural languages. | [
-0.5623968244,
-0.7725704908,
0.5659462214,
0.3237062693,
-0.3122955561,
-0.1407023072,
-0.320668757,
-0.3153247833,
0.440015763,
0.0699867308,
-0.6319116354,
-0.087243937,
-0.4950036705,
0.2601388991,
0.1672927588,
0.5621839762,
-0.0230950695,
-0.22794649,
-0.1455363035,
-0.3041369021,
-0.5970157981,
-0.4949841797,
-0.1598064452,
-0.0749718696,
0.5531182885,
0.68528229,
1.1269892454,
0.9960271716,
0.2504118681,
0.2935298681,
-0.2782671154,
-0.1711063236,
-0.2498134077,
-0.0657873675,
-0.181699127,
-0.6681520939,
0.1886937171,
0.1642162502,
0.6607560515,
0.6958600879,
-0.1707429439,
0.0995322838,
-0.0123686194,
1.1377565861,
-1.0154467821,
-0.0039758412,
-0.1201406494,
-0.0005078402,
-0.5921748877,
-0.1752787679,
-0.3570308685,
-0.3332531452,
0.3554564416,
-0.3767222166,
0.0313901305,
0.2012027502,
1.1925626993,
0.4371526241,
-0.3523931205,
-0.2127473205,
-0.6840752363,
1.0864578485,
-0.3457283974,
0.5850040913,
0.3596050143,
0.3190765679,
-0.1174648702,
0.1489064395,
-0.7033224702,
-0.2825554609,
-0.5157193542,
-0.0928311422,
0.0078822887,
0.3643913567,
0.495324105,
0.2062722743,
-0.6956896186,
0.0103532486,
-0.4171945155,
-0.2945404053,
0.2444854975,
0.0714671761,
0.5317134261,
-0.7096891999,
-0.4134698212,
0.1694961786,
-0.810705483,
0.3964979649,
0.2749556303,
0.3893081546,
0.1568926126,
0.9089431167,
-0.408903718,
0.6182191372,
-0.0028735613,
-0.2930460274,
-0.2339401245,
-0.695284307,
-0.254645586,
0.3344971836,
0.5099274516,
0.1855413169,
0.2423790246,
0.2389603108,
0.0975044891,
0.4934693277,
-0.1855579615,
-0.7989180684,
0.3107473254,
-0.0822940916,
-0.5580279827,
0.256642282,
-0.232508108,
-0.7421185374,
-0.0161927622,
-0.4111712575,
-0.0663530231,
-0.5546914339,
-0.045260679,
-0.0237496551,
0.3371703327,
0.5224856138,
0.0384242535,
-1.1856693029,
0.4855954051,
0.563855648,
1.0480197668,
-0.1290445775,
-0.1966520101,
-0.5929783583,
0.3138701916,
-0.4254976809,
0.8879247308,
-0.5649290681,
-0.5409555435,
-0.3148088157,
-0.484548986,
-0.0882740766,
-0.3545195162,
0.513551712,
-0.3424343169,
0.2182439864,
-0.5510497689,
-0.5706178546,
-0.314357847,
-0.2185187638,
-0.2825513184,
0.4569074214,
0.1827965975,
-0.7826596498,
0.6761285663,
-0.4633117318,
-0.5882919431,
-0.0006270671,
-0.3665978611,
-0.0033829012,
0.0421622321,
-0.1752835065,
0.192158848,
-0.460113138,
0.1227543578,
0.044803068,
-0.1356595308,
-0.0208038185,
-0.148770228,
0.7736779451,
0.4469370842,
-0.2586064339,
0.2478510439,
-0.5590026975,
0.0587569624,
0.0342970006,
-0.3460933268,
-0.5207697749,
-0.0351915024,
-0.0016784475,
-0.0895315185,
0.0254078656,
-0.528947413,
0.1696455777,
-0.8475250006,
0.2340850234,
0.9999395013,
-0.0265636574,
0.857747674,
-0.2285685241,
0.7295793891,
-0.3243150711,
0.591027379,
0.208918795,
0.0016965683,
-0.6627011895,
-0.4925551713,
0.2763059735,
0.6749677062,
-0.2348086387,
0.1427611113,
-0.1344776303,
-0.0924284682,
-0.0169004202,
0.3385758102,
0.6187883615,
0.369738102,
0.2024766803,
-0.1988890171,
-0.5697177649,
-1.2887283564,
-0.3477606475,
-0.3761809766,
0.3216448128,
0.0523606986,
0.1019328535,
-0.1802716851,
1.4028373957,
-0.7752313614,
-0.3228472769,
-0.4499803782,
-0.2219836265,
0.1197871417,
0.3272884488,
0.6533840895,
-0.9419832826,
-0.6643083096,
-0.328399539,
-0.1912699789,
-0.2777116299,
-0.0228717253,
-0.3690579832,
0.6303355098,
0.1733848304,
-1.1178722382,
0.8103265762,
0.1118446738,
-0.4901385307,
0.5583051443,
-0.2187357992,
-0.2268650234,
-0.7241709232,
-0.3232622743,
-0.1488098651,
-0.0929014161,
-0.5903912783,
-0.1168027967,
-0.251734823,
0.2637827992,
-0.4415320158,
0.4620428383,
-0.497251749,
0.0373132341,
-0.2327331752,
0.2084907591,
-0.165774405,
0.5632471442,
-0.1338947266,
0.7952283621,
0.3017418087,
-0.7550966144,
-0.1232438087,
0.3460839391,
-0.2601115108,
0.421143204,
-0.4877957404,
-0.3312859833,
-0.2918632329,
-0.0575425625,
-0.7150806785,
-0.1713010073,
0.3491084874,
-0.3214139044,
0.2428213954,
-0.1837020814,
-0.462926656,
0.2009869665,
-0.2122869492,
0.5334385633,
0.7575984597,
-0.2133219689,
0.5511749983,
0.4790304899,
-0.1436985284,
-0.4338050783,
-0.5804800987,
-0.3010077178,
-0.3346710801,
-0.6780151725,
0.2139415443,
-0.1094124615,
-0.6793600917,
-0.1493580937,
-0.461047411,
0.0589801706,
-0.1885094643,
0.3021145165,
0.294383198,
-0.1909623593,
0.1496282518,
-0.0919405073,
-0.3037908971,
-0.1827169061,
-0.0483679287,
0.4052205086,
-0.2471031249,
0.0188620407,
-0.2481479496,
0.5362848639,
0.4474760294,
0.0279253367,
0.7291030288,
-0.0169206914,
-0.168720603,
0.166707918,
-0.6595463753,
0.1508405209,
-0.4798084795,
0.024505835,
-0.3718739748,
-0.8529097438,
0.3801862597,
0.1914987266,
-0.3504340947,
0.5503542423,
0.3477419615,
0.4263927341,
0.9172084332,
0.803816855,
-0.0715292841,
0.4727389514,
-0.0224224497,
0.5870715976,
-0.5606119633,
0.1144343913,
-0.4211512208,
0.1598730832,
-0.8278080225,
-0.255215317,
0.117635183,
0.4015572965,
-0.1698728949,
0.1823657751,
-0.4886298776,
0.7764761448,
0.3351429701,
-0.2005939782,
-0.027522089,
-0.4052484632,
-0.2156193703,
-0.1996196508,
-0.8167524338,
-0.5241659284,
0.2923366129,
-0.0533170328,
0.3996874988,
0.4563308358,
0.6373844743,
0.0647515729,
0.0232148282,
-0.9562584162,
0.7126479745,
0.0172323734,
-0.3917476237,
-0.4950300753,
-0.4373060465,
-1.038761735,
0.061960049,
-0.0323475935,
-0.6917345524,
0.1127608716,
0.1142284423,
-0.709036231,
-0.0999309197,
-0.9367187023,
0.7923313379,
-0.2427139431,
-0.4663431644,
-0.3500884771,
-0.7189579606,
0.3222841918,
0.2429831624,
0.3615244925,
-0.3071614206,
-0.1373067647,
0.829762876,
-1.0752803087,
0.3686577976,
-0.3480140269,
0.5251633525,
0.4465647936,
0.1927261353,
0.2315601557,
0.0111601157,
0.5467036963,
-0.3688098192,
0.1850876957,
-0.8654150367,
-0.5673052669,
0.8292725682,
-0.5811373591,
-1.1364737749,
-0.7388450503,
-0.2240247279,
-0.2501490712,
0.4295561314,
0.2687520683,
0.1125628725,
-0.0105940569,
-0.139880091,
0.4323251545,
-0.354306221,
0.697861433,
0.1965118647,
-0.2935973704,
-0.1109863371,
0.5768886209,
0.5163111091,
0.248906523,
0.3708473742,
0.6870562434,
-0.364852339,
-0.3670699,
-0.3767865002,
0.3416324556,
-0.7439469099,
0.0047255019,
-0.6241861582,
0.0040033511,
-0.4611602128,
-0.4090294242,
-0.4071638584,
-0.3299822211,
-0.0339875855,
-0.127125442,
0.5879395008,
0.6710082293,
-0.1418193281,
0.2560199201,
-0.8396578431,
0.2120643109,
0.3443922698,
0.4077262282,
0.1373517215,
-0.2190372199,
-0.1595065445,
-0.1445483565,
0.0521351807,
-0.7008113861,
0.2777541578,
0.067752786,
0.3767823577,
0.526142478,
0.0575770624,
0.8902170658,
-0.5827897787,
0.6840994954,
0.4155596197,
-1.0845540762,
0.6634484529,
-0.2908880711,
0.5093722343,
0.7595039606,
0.4051856399,
-0.4088707268,
0.0212971903,
-0.4099032879,
-0.9498250484,
0.4818280041,
0.4631860554,
-0.0739367306,
-0.1172727719,
0.4895122349,
0.1392635107,
-0.2005279213,
-0.3695434332,
-0.2899095714,
0.0472041182,
0.0187040195,
0.0402080975,
-0.5417742133,
0.3803469241,
-0.1891527325,
0.4820513725,
0.1846295148,
0.0846784264,
0.3962534964,
-0.274566263,
0.1267929971,
0.5168324113,
1.0830621719,
0.7349317074,
-0.1699210405,
0.0303309895,
0.0989873037,
-0.5397609472,
0.3639205396,
-0.2137714028,
-0.299931854,
0.0391451865,
0.1505875736,
0.5770769715,
-0.1463134438,
-0.5893830657,
0.4521076083,
0.0589411072,
0.1998933852,
-0.5161859989,
-0.0250368994,
-0.0282031186,
0.1932528317,
0.0886603966,
0.474164933,
0.1740090102,
-0.6080496907,
0.0901623964,
0.301656425,
-0.2633759081,
-0.2810787559,
0.4625646472,
-0.3527276218,
-0.3589002192,
0.2632692158,
-0.2456516027,
-0.7046378851,
0.3927606642,
0.0498492606,
0.6913163066,
-0.2414849848,
0.1847365797,
0.3568633795,
0.1469630599,
-0.2975336909,
0.233129859,
-0.2298406214,
-0.4450501502,
-0.7003409266,
-0.7662636042,
-0.1057314202,
-0.5624819994,
-0.4990868866,
0.4292435348,
-0.7732028961,
-0.1105679423,
0.031803593,
-0.029234767,
-0.3686956465,
0.1230553016,
-0.1335556358,
0.5861847997,
-0.5659293532,
0.7715806961,
0.015363493,
-0.7933218479,
-1.152528882,
0.104117766,
0.0233037379,
-0.497385323,
1.0078840256,
0.3004324138,
-0.4789932668,
-0.3754783273,
-0.2175904214,
-1.2394051552,
0.5800082684,
0.3656148911,
-0.3503282964,
0.0581644326,
0.2014051378,
0.5907091498,
-0.093295157,
0.039085906,
0.4098745286,
0.5697738528,
0.1472457051,
-0.7270073891,
0.3707073331,
-0.1247239187,
0.2765045166,
0.6748154759,
-0.975574851,
0.5873757601,
-0.3150324523,
-0.5293012857,
0.0430958867,
0.7104825377,
0.1731165797,
0.1765163988,
0.7828834653,
0.3348395824,
0.3784606159,
0.1341023594,
1.0851377249,
-0.0683312491,
0.0508702025,
0.7308658361,
-0.2825031281,
0.5587263107,
0.8464541435,
-0.4435187876,
0.4391837716,
0.8471288085,
0.3688074052,
0.8681431413,
0.6903969646,
0.0498468988,
0.0608923249,
-0.5761168003,
0.0418687128,
0.5295083523,
0.1860533208,
0.184633106,
0.1432678998,
0.2595425546,
0.2379252017,
0.2404541224,
-0.2744352221,
0.6668816805,
0.038394697,
-0.8671625257,
0.9046773911,
-0.205883041,
0.5935371518,
-0.5184916854,
0.1348257661,
-0.2307311296,
0.0688871816,
-0.2972940803,
-0.3352591097,
0.7647765875,
-0.0729345158,
-0.4952538908,
-0.379155457,
0.5266683102,
-0.1148655266,
-0.11523626,
0.2777014375,
0.3614307344,
-0.1252438575,
0.1588097662,
-0.1787967831,
-0.1854517907,
-0.0034034646,
-0.3391239345,
0.4101322591,
0.3782140613,
-0.2911958098,
0.4578480422,
0.4415214956,
0.251756072,
0.0075800316,
-0.2085625827,
0.5786026716,
-0.7442317605,
-0.7364174128,
-1.1816086769,
0.0657123178,
0.0796327069,
-0.1486570984,
0.7196020484,
0.6114616394,
0.8926798105,
0.0815814212,
0.5529907346,
-0.2238851786,
0.4915887415,
-0.6722611189,
0.4263111651,
-0.5686578751,
0.3509169221,
-0.2368865758,
-1.02354002,
-0.5002107024,
0.5835385919,
-0.611181736,
-0.1133160368,
1.024471879,
0.8390948176,
0.1027691886,
-0.0264383294,
0.1830119938,
0.1216020063,
-0.1346938014,
0.5353440046,
0.7959782481,
0.1507221758,
0.664462328,
-0.4337271452,
-0.3261007965,
-0.1193738952,
-0.4276539683,
-0.7933282852,
-0.599671185,
-0.2014209181,
-0.2258376181,
-0.1832827032,
1.2463316917,
0.5402112603,
-0.718647778,
-0.3323433399,
-0.3985440135,
0.3845236003,
0.0350625627,
-0.2670288682,
0.6259506941,
-0.165403679,
-0.3347008824,
0.1103636697,
0.6637790203,
0.0498154052,
-0.1158500165,
-0.1604153961,
-0.8080117702,
0.3748592734,
0.5081548691,
0.4309501052,
-0.9409674406,
-0.6674042344,
0.3348362744,
-0.2596132457,
0.3148848116,
0.9511117935,
-0.5600672364,
0.3643491864,
0.8845887184,
0.4034512937,
0.1271407902,
-0.2534918785,
0.4335511625,
-0.5337572098,
0.3197782338,
0.0647034049,
0.2861119211,
0.1998024136,
-0.5825487971,
0.524699688,
0.2500956059,
-0.4739576578,
-0.6419644356,
0.6579435468,
-0.8572944403,
-0.3476159871,
1.1611478329,
0.0169395152,
-0.4586580396,
-0.1488373131,
-0.5901792049,
0.5000700355,
-0.2683953941,
0.6853103638,
0.7069796324,
-0.5472106934,
-0.2241328657,
-0.4022556841,
0.7845677733,
0.8880521655,
-0.4334410727,
0.0297763646,
0.4447789788,
-0.0505046807,
0.4910816252,
0.7595599294,
0.3128017485,
0.149214372,
-0.1855749488,
-0.2723856866,
0.3564165533,
-0.0504309274,
0.010681482,
-0.0094177155,
0.1874068826,
-0.1081455424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11406v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11406v4 | LaMP: When Large Language Models Meet Personalization | 2023-04-22T13:42:04 | 2024-06-05T03:29:31 | Alireza Salemi, Sheshera Mysore, Michael Bendersky, Hamed Zamani | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper highlights the importance of personalization in large language
models and introduces the LaMP benchmark -- a novel benchmark for training and
evaluating language models for producing personalized outputs. LaMP offers a
comprehensive evaluation framework with diverse language tasks and multiple
entries for each user profile. It consists of seven personalized tasks,
spanning three text classification and four text generation tasks. We
additionally propose two retrieval augmentation approaches that retrieve
personal items from each user profile for personalizing language model outputs.
To this aim, we study various retrieval models, including term matching,
semantic matching, and time-aware methods. Extensive experiments on LaMP for
zero-shot and fine-tuned language models demonstrate the efficacy of the
proposed retrieval augmentation approach and highlight the impact of
personalization in various natural language tasks. | [
-0.2637876272,
-0.6723461151,
0.4851204157,
0.3841595054,
0.2001688778,
0.1796088964,
-0.5817455649,
-0.486036092,
-0.1621535718,
0.4825153351,
-0.2298162729,
-0.5448741317,
-0.2504490912,
0.3503070772,
-0.7562413216,
0.7948103547,
0.199605912,
-0.0576007552,
0.0680270642,
-0.0070797368,
-0.6435698867,
-0.458160758,
-0.4820139408,
-0.35299927,
0.656303823,
0.4757276773,
0.6333507895,
0.6772117019,
0.7105582356,
0.3795648217,
0.0895259082,
-0.1357401162,
-0.532359004,
0.3123283982,
-0.511017561,
-0.3021716177,
-0.2467405349,
-0.0511678495,
0.4614908695,
0.856779933,
0.0253726207,
0.5061440468,
-0.4360993505,
0.4661816061,
-0.8518351912,
-0.0197001919,
-0.6755042076,
-0.0281119086,
-0.5048578382,
-0.191421628,
-0.664119184,
-0.4355342388,
0.0717592835,
-0.3152814507,
0.4601302743,
0.2185202986,
0.8430013061,
-0.1957878768,
-0.4273388684,
-0.0749522448,
-0.9097318649,
0.993965745,
-0.7595899105,
0.1616814882,
0.2591541409,
0.7111188173,
0.3595269918,
-0.8145517111,
-0.5882619619,
-0.429297626,
-0.1103632525,
-0.1688774228,
-0.0644584596,
-0.0352919474,
0.2056952864,
0.6100785136,
-0.4626909196,
0.0785905719,
-0.1609643996,
0.1577683687,
0.5602577925,
0.2246444076,
0.4604689777,
-0.3444115818,
-0.3011557758,
-0.2797630727,
-0.3981016576,
-0.2651287317,
0.6148449779,
0.30405128,
0.1698729545,
0.5047208071,
-0.6826117635,
0.9836127162,
-0.0631725118,
0.0167417526,
0.3024371564,
-0.441981107,
-0.0541124642,
-0.0762890354,
0.5753090978,
0.334903419,
0.5880051851,
-0.5799626112,
-0.1343222409,
0.14665851,
0.153661713,
-0.7450503111,
-0.376227349,
0.126280278,
-0.4129756391,
-0.488168925,
0.2232937366,
-0.6642650962,
-0.3129041791,
-0.2569153905,
0.3085811138,
-0.2966237664,
-0.1447919756,
0.2812996805,
0.0236460064,
-0.0284503903,
0.3456950486,
-1.14364779,
0.4764487445,
0.7553088665,
0.6132002473,
-0.5089877844,
-0.2692532539,
-0.615437448,
0.3436563611,
-0.3577058613,
0.7855067253,
-0.7714878321,
-0.2582445741,
0.2675628066,
-0.2952537239,
0.2441131771,
-0.6296123266,
0.3364415169,
-0.7744532228,
0.4623350203,
-0.2511633635,
-0.6229082346,
-0.1143735647,
0.0261971392,
-0.3345986903,
1.0853860378,
0.1969127804,
-0.4653140604,
0.2786361277,
-0.6009081006,
-0.4331213534,
0.2857045829,
0.003470086,
-0.0390246622,
0.4530361593,
-0.1789872199,
0.5833979249,
-0.467893064,
0.3111339808,
-0.3536335528,
-0.3044875562,
0.2795460224,
-0.2418937385,
0.3668842614,
0.3144827187,
-0.1954099685,
0.3468638659,
-1.0810927153,
0.3884423673,
0.0358649641,
-0.5357747078,
-0.3901152313,
-0.0983642042,
1.0164070129,
0.0814108923,
0.7366970778,
-0.8412535787,
0.0201957542,
-0.6000993848,
0.1680381149,
0.7850208879,
-0.2101707011,
0.1507570893,
-0.0468603186,
0.2475434989,
-0.2888296247,
-0.0980948955,
-0.5592088699,
-0.0379509889,
-0.7141373158,
0.0900355503,
0.3688832819,
0.3991464972,
-0.3394025266,
0.5140110254,
-0.3417674899,
-0.6171377897,
-0.1263813674,
0.4676586688,
0.8539701104,
0.4865017533,
0.2718168199,
-0.6817727089,
-0.5533125997,
-0.998305738,
-0.6709920168,
0.0680990815,
-0.2085968554,
0.4234162271,
0.2704779208,
-0.2165305167,
0.9853573442,
-0.888646245,
-0.3955759704,
-0.2626280785,
0.1405571103,
0.3045609295,
0.4675106406,
0.5142390728,
-0.6563492417,
-0.8659896255,
0.4826981723,
-0.8651785851,
-0.446786195,
0.0906711593,
0.0585391596,
-0.2200922817,
0.2957639992,
-0.3156103492,
0.1490437835,
0.4086097777,
-0.4529583156,
0.4998355806,
-0.4491706192,
0.1646686494,
-0.9793274999,
0.3599050939,
0.0681477413,
-0.4912722409,
-0.7901201248,
0.3525647819,
0.1307113171,
-0.3425130844,
-0.2193100899,
0.9332663417,
-0.496697247,
-0.2850010097,
-0.5358855724,
0.326530844,
-0.0037886708,
0.3041184247,
-0.1186125502,
0.7249556184,
0.3437832594,
-0.3919146955,
0.4903988242,
0.2294830978,
-0.4939277172,
0.5733608007,
-0.9630035758,
0.4087468982,
0.0348644666,
-0.2743581533,
-1.0710294247,
-0.3566880226,
-0.3754566312,
-0.0558510907,
0.0029542318,
0.463432461,
-0.7072780728,
-0.1303290576,
-0.3881040812,
0.2898146808,
0.4202730954,
-0.5537088513,
0.3345416486,
0.1321117878,
0.0005114375,
-0.2550592721,
-0.3939302564,
0.2836598158,
-0.1099716276,
-0.525272727,
0.6915844083,
-0.3001948297,
-0.3488102853,
-0.1530988514,
0.0494126491,
-0.0234284531,
0.1010496393,
0.1269939393,
-0.0804717168,
-0.2350843102,
0.1878707409,
-0.3769432306,
-0.2891195118,
-0.3482222557,
0.0973310098,
0.8954530954,
-0.0937979743,
-0.4460285902,
-0.3926872909,
0.2717869878,
-0.009459679,
-0.4504748583,
0.5471425653,
0.6892273426,
-0.2943344116,
-0.1255219877,
-1.1351240873,
-0.09389171,
-0.5119608045,
0.5131570697,
-0.5078257918,
-0.625813961,
0.3470495641,
-0.1226907447,
0.0672111437,
0.0967946351,
0.689535141,
0.0979401618,
1.0912766457,
0.8834242821,
-0.1588141024,
0.7622661591,
0.0751714334,
0.1938716471,
-0.7191765308,
0.0601957999,
-0.652813673,
-0.3686382771,
-0.1925993264,
-0.2729797959,
0.053939268,
0.0495050177,
-0.3217222393,
0.650018394,
-0.484121412,
0.5157573819,
0.5994304419,
0.0148531711,
0.6840888262,
0.0310970675,
0.2134871185,
-0.1875582188,
-0.1036744639,
-0.6179251075,
1.0641397238,
-0.0171688478,
0.7466513515,
0.2897428572,
0.5461432934,
0.5093873739,
0.2734125257,
-0.3276924193,
0.5870842338,
-0.369437933,
-0.7885826826,
-0.2574381232,
-0.2869922221,
-0.9044926167,
0.4253390729,
0.0918966159,
-0.9420118928,
0.0101865819,
0.1113387793,
-0.1571692228,
-0.0634345785,
-0.9333423972,
1.1038957834,
-0.4351314902,
-0.4455071092,
-0.6477762461,
-0.378159821,
0.2994787991,
-0.1155683771,
0.1152523458,
-0.3559813201,
-0.3002289832,
0.43208763,
-0.1592883766,
0.7101476789,
-0.0669546053,
0.3621373177,
-0.3204109967,
0.1664578915,
0.3144934475,
-0.0707265958,
-0.4024468064,
-0.3043484092,
0.0525961109,
-0.4588215947,
-0.4109023809,
1.0212645531,
-0.6181587577,
-0.6764647961,
-0.4679741561,
-0.3648322821,
-0.3869691193,
0.514552474,
0.0143172117,
0.3025829494,
-0.4747504592,
0.3723328412,
0.5885044336,
-0.4975736737,
0.6008623242,
0.7281509638,
-0.6042308807,
-0.0655700862,
0.9619604945,
-0.2369804084,
0.224583447,
0.5482013822,
0.2152071595,
0.0284455325,
-0.5308244228,
-0.3018756509,
0.2648969591,
-0.8323097229,
-0.2250751704,
-0.4393253624,
0.1867582351,
-0.2687635124,
-0.0743393674,
-0.3010019064,
-0.1260461807,
-0.0534536093,
0.0219969396,
0.3484649956,
0.8572285771,
0.437378794,
0.4916766584,
-0.4974450469,
0.5026190281,
0.2515607774,
0.6774920821,
0.1237211749,
-0.2650588751,
-0.173064217,
-0.5310459733,
-0.3159002364,
-0.8380813003,
0.3097190559,
0.4709247947,
0.4398467839,
0.4723490775,
-0.1872334033,
0.5743838549,
-0.7664866447,
0.6469176412,
0.2859102488,
-1.1122567654,
0.6443573833,
-0.2902908325,
0.5285631418,
0.6801948547,
-0.0232346877,
-0.8480303884,
0.1231850088,
-0.3732738197,
-0.8743416071,
0.4931696653,
-0.0279273,
0.577535212,
-0.1504342109,
0.3232096136,
0.2051525414,
0.4151794016,
-0.7666980028,
-0.1495544463,
0.2956255078,
-0.2708867192,
-0.2300556153,
-0.3079559505,
0.0507003665,
-0.1153971851,
0.4402786791,
-0.1443422288,
-0.148017481,
-0.1340868622,
-0.2856658995,
-0.2660732567,
0.2104085237,
0.2007658184,
1.0035595894,
-0.141882509,
-0.1017199531,
0.2324239016,
0.0202324353,
-0.047510989,
-0.0296425913,
-0.2083798498,
0.2874822021,
0.3187399805,
0.6053583026,
0.7857683897,
-0.9775663018,
0.5916242599,
-0.017082978,
0.5327789783,
-0.4872482717,
0.2109205872,
0.0357770473,
-0.0885634497,
0.3011517227,
0.1391680092,
0.3395704329,
-0.601519227,
0.0161011051,
0.4593105018,
-0.1838488728,
-0.5802517533,
0.9808667302,
0.1038251445,
-0.4498392642,
0.0607365817,
0.0272487216,
-0.0388399176,
0.1711632162,
0.4033133686,
0.8450546861,
-0.360537976,
0.198210746,
0.2668577135,
-0.255314976,
-0.0945475176,
0.1684834808,
-0.0295416303,
-0.480142355,
-0.2974675298,
-0.8541833162,
-0.376737237,
-0.1753816158,
-0.5074382424,
0.4766154587,
-0.4857422411,
-0.0729940832,
0.2368932813,
0.0243879724,
-0.867687881,
0.2571557462,
0.0044514174,
0.9009395838,
-0.5881121159,
1.0007499456,
0.5894221663,
-0.4675551951,
-0.4171301425,
-0.2559816539,
-0.3702098429,
-0.5459317565,
0.9145792127,
0.127938658,
-0.1290206313,
-0.0967220068,
-0.0957641155,
-0.8158721924,
0.8469145894,
0.4120491147,
-0.5281898379,
-0.1443176568,
0.0770695508,
0.9138201475,
-0.370651871,
0.4290675819,
0.6064473987,
0.4021184444,
-0.3669172227,
-0.9957666993,
-0.0728935003,
-0.3223974705,
0.7837560773,
-0.088270478,
-0.6363154054,
0.9805903435,
0.0883220434,
-0.2004989237,
0.4729550481,
0.7108371258,
-0.0482356884,
0.1080941185,
0.4010578692,
0.2468131036,
0.5374985337,
-0.0629386753,
1.4349094629,
-0.6826952696,
0.3293721974,
1.0839151144,
-0.6143254638,
1.1560627222,
0.3554770052,
-0.3240451515,
0.4990583658,
0.3309615552,
-0.121252656,
0.5058458447,
0.3672143221,
-0.299161911,
-0.0633572042,
-0.2277281731,
-0.5175441504,
0.3419264257,
-0.0839892477,
-0.4410173297,
-0.239411816,
0.2452146113,
-0.1213625595,
0.8015710711,
-0.0068273572,
0.8153284788,
-0.1685952246,
-0.7138270736,
0.2503122985,
0.4199807346,
0.8488376141,
-0.667306304,
0.1894569099,
-0.1627324075,
0.6946315169,
-0.3502553999,
-0.437063396,
0.0354779959,
0.1254901141,
-0.2417150587,
-0.5646849275,
0.7337924838,
-0.2914884984,
-0.5946019292,
0.4592850506,
0.4748365879,
-0.0127268694,
-0.1029165164,
-0.3088858426,
0.2150734067,
-0.1767746061,
-0.4962995648,
0.5352054834,
0.1394637227,
0.0744728148,
0.7579227686,
0.6054517031,
0.3611764312,
0.2201033831,
0.4104670584,
0.6313152313,
-0.6724283695,
-0.3696005642,
-0.776171267,
0.1461326033,
-0.3407110572,
-0.6501330733,
1.0865902901,
0.881003201,
1.0454182625,
-0.6148625612,
0.750449121,
-0.1285536885,
0.9372072816,
-0.1464867741,
0.3635303676,
-0.3697005808,
0.5014677048,
-0.5009485483,
-1.2247475386,
-0.2313993722,
0.5259082317,
-0.6453993917,
0.2921133637,
0.3789887428,
0.6801198721,
-0.1760810167,
-0.1410007328,
0.5538959503,
0.0388976932,
0.3361802995,
0.2901701629,
0.5341458917,
-0.4296745956,
0.4642424285,
-0.5626983643,
-0.1719657332,
-0.3890711367,
-0.741243422,
-0.877731204,
-0.6846550107,
-0.2941533327,
0.0629571006,
0.2152414769,
0.9007375836,
0.8586550355,
-1.2161189318,
-0.8084339499,
-0.0390551165,
-0.235505864,
-0.2997550666,
-0.274123162,
0.2425537854,
-0.6507234573,
-1.0441833735,
0.3143751025,
0.481664896,
-0.5019174218,
-0.6119582653,
0.1911123395,
-0.1579981595,
-0.1753890067,
0.6830544472,
0.2301927209,
-0.8997343779,
-0.4746549726,
-0.029604435,
-0.1674751788,
0.1071586609,
0.8403551579,
-0.8573502898,
0.7510191202,
0.6137986779,
0.6766786575,
0.6532716751,
0.1631469429,
0.8119843006,
-0.9929048419,
0.1137839779,
0.079477042,
0.2630066276,
0.6473362446,
-0.3058189154,
0.6311332583,
0.0020437993,
-0.4994119406,
-1.0763354301,
0.301171571,
-0.8249953985,
-0.2830120623,
0.8695932627,
-0.2475705594,
0.0295154303,
-0.0374462828,
-0.3205483258,
-0.0615351535,
-0.1565719396,
0.9381921291,
0.8233484626,
-0.0881865695,
-0.1177031174,
-0.8471263647,
0.4504498243,
0.5706386566,
-0.9518965483,
0.1284529418,
0.2579824924,
0.4041740894,
0.3319146931,
0.4094564319,
0.0246244073,
0.2428313494,
-0.3117256761,
0.0724195912,
0.0942299888,
-0.0316347964,
-0.2653372586,
0.5319188833,
0.4508390129,
0.0963202715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11389v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11389v2 | Transformer-Based Language Model Surprisal Predicts Human Reading Times Best with About Two Billion Training Tokens | 2023-04-22T12:50:49 | 2023-10-22T20:03:54 | Byung-Doh Oh, William Schuler | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent psycholinguistic studies have drawn conflicting conclusions about the
relationship between the quality of a language model and the ability of its
surprisal estimates to predict human reading times, which has been speculated
to be due to the large gap in both the amount of training data and model
capacity across studies. The current work aims to consolidate these findings by
evaluating surprisal estimates from Transformer-based language model variants
that vary systematically in the amount of training data and model capacity on
their ability to predict human reading times. The results show that surprisal
estimates from most variants with contemporary model capacities provide the
best fit after seeing about two billion training tokens, after which they begin
to diverge from humanlike expectations. Additionally, newly-trained smaller
model variants reveal a 'tipping point' at convergence, after which the
decrease in language model perplexity begins to result in poorer fits to human
reading times. These results suggest that the massive amount of training data
is mainly responsible for the poorer fit achieved by surprisal from larger
pre-trained language models, and that a certain degree of model capacity is
necessary for Transformer-based language models to capture humanlike
expectations. | [
-0.6366832852,
-0.434484601,
0.1740835756,
0.3248782456,
-0.2609472275,
0.1743126363,
-0.1545496881,
-0.7395226359,
-0.076316759,
0.3370137811,
-0.5534843206,
0.1839804649,
-0.673737824,
0.364818722,
-0.251128912,
0.6542798281,
0.3345618844,
0.1794401705,
-0.0649633408,
0.0189430378,
-0.6226791739,
-0.7070737481,
-0.3703914285,
-0.7098756433,
0.3224220574,
0.2405112386,
1.024469614,
0.6764699817,
0.5839401484,
0.1122563481,
-0.2938992083,
-0.2407973409,
-0.4173166752,
-0.1929262429,
0.0229038224,
-0.7730187178,
-0.1304446757,
-0.0188660342,
0.6184020042,
1.04793787,
-0.2380332202,
0.0508116595,
0.1464953274,
0.5662257075,
-0.4419397116,
0.026491601,
-0.0959370658,
0.0232327729,
-0.2994219959,
0.0509821884,
-0.6571021676,
-0.1813796312,
0.3654022813,
-0.1493107677,
0.5484311581,
0.101163514,
0.7105389833,
0.3310669363,
-0.4765778184,
-0.0316624194,
-0.8545434475,
0.8552019596,
-0.9428526163,
0.7625992298,
0.6000884771,
0.4771274328,
0.096829243,
-0.5228395462,
-0.7481601238,
-0.4832638502,
-0.2458635867,
-0.1153783798,
-0.3293351531,
0.0142170191,
0.3683298826,
0.1076032668,
-0.7001848817,
0.2223283947,
-0.532337606,
0.0286129136,
0.5164972544,
0.3032171428,
0.2557383478,
-0.2974292338,
-0.1683803946,
-0.1680413783,
-0.5923662782,
0.1724661291,
0.4554060996,
0.2696560919,
-0.03321537,
0.5170876384,
0.0188272968,
0.6947988272,
-0.1500812471,
-0.0960416272,
0.3979063332,
-0.2019774169,
0.0144356648,
-0.1746662706,
0.7843497992,
0.5502031446,
0.5252534747,
-0.3737725019,
-0.1428770721,
0.2364157736,
0.2784819901,
-0.6843004227,
-0.0648729503,
-0.0300518218,
-0.3769151866,
-0.0804644227,
0.0998580083,
-0.7504000664,
-0.3637674451,
-0.2783951461,
-0.0959292948,
-0.5469380021,
-0.4005578458,
0.4622835517,
-0.0443044305,
0.1373967677,
-0.1443874389,
-1.0668048859,
0.4879028499,
0.3977911174,
1.0118168592,
-0.4146673977,
-0.3186351061,
-0.1616303474,
-0.098012872,
-0.348020941,
0.961452961,
-0.5994670391,
-0.5993621945,
-0.0066571771,
-0.1106778979,
-0.2952590585,
-0.3551207781,
0.5415654778,
-0.536544919,
0.1984633952,
-0.3368584216,
-0.6297934651,
0.0584834032,
-0.1094105989,
-0.9498422146,
0.928019464,
0.0859504119,
-0.7422866225,
0.4278486073,
-0.5766782761,
-0.3981542885,
0.2520877421,
0.0414814353,
-0.3480468392,
0.234971866,
0.350307554,
0.386167109,
-0.4611654878,
0.3323277533,
-0.1176051646,
-0.5552423,
0.6168743968,
-0.8498994708,
0.8360789418,
0.2114608437,
-0.3325779438,
-0.3795519471,
-0.5034771562,
-0.1968066096,
0.1062581763,
-0.1562780291,
-0.1534148753,
0.1325557381,
0.4493928552,
0.3247439265,
-0.0196355749,
-0.7771183848,
0.2194513977,
-0.5957505703,
0.5838019252,
0.3603151739,
-0.1199955791,
0.1412483603,
-0.4762285054,
0.8069628477,
-0.1259004772,
0.238424316,
-0.0959167778,
-0.3013168275,
-0.6478028893,
-0.0336112194,
0.418859452,
0.3808192313,
-0.4009317756,
0.2793858647,
-0.4661509693,
-0.7086424232,
-0.6070910692,
-0.3310231566,
0.5318542123,
0.2558790445,
0.4732580781,
-0.2544926703,
-0.3198019266,
-0.9699499011,
-0.5672918558,
-0.2844241858,
-0.0961557999,
0.2510049641,
0.5199058652,
-0.3104026914,
1.1636794806,
-0.4601936042,
-0.0825876147,
-0.7388898134,
0.1572791487,
0.2476917505,
0.2519671619,
0.663890183,
-0.9695574045,
-0.459810853,
-0.2386618555,
-0.1914529204,
-0.0716082454,
-0.0179246441,
0.4275491238,
0.4065903425,
0.4654017091,
-0.3571333587,
0.3518913388,
0.5972120762,
-0.2981298268,
0.7836339474,
-0.1591067612,
-0.0041541932,
-0.9613750577,
0.0513626821,
0.0800452903,
0.0377425216,
-0.7837175131,
-0.2505824566,
0.2014631182,
0.1197857559,
-0.3208907545,
0.6183330417,
-0.3673546314,
-0.140612781,
-0.1553332508,
-0.0483835675,
-0.2547459006,
0.3934110999,
0.0852465406,
0.9164087772,
0.1283562481,
-0.3044679761,
0.1099542901,
0.3834351599,
-0.5394511223,
0.1423735768,
-0.9109776616,
0.0576619878,
0.0173769277,
0.2937145531,
-1.2453824282,
-0.3443579674,
-0.2124450803,
-0.3915228844,
0.2640919089,
0.1320369393,
-0.5099604726,
-0.4552237988,
0.1323515475,
0.5833081007,
0.5113843679,
-0.4385564625,
0.6624573469,
0.3018468618,
-0.280321151,
-0.7806758285,
-1.0041683912,
0.0580318719,
0.0720425323,
-0.3759543896,
0.2596006691,
0.0948595479,
0.0230708644,
-0.0226320941,
-0.0529042818,
0.0560060591,
-0.1910048425,
0.1822454631,
0.3900403082,
-0.0349936411,
0.1293205768,
-0.2388807833,
-0.5119872093,
0.0283595156,
0.0429815948,
0.7438369989,
-0.3306707144,
-0.4311549962,
-0.3515609801,
0.1217358932,
0.6841078997,
-0.3514281213,
1.0541058779,
0.1226040497,
-0.1800369322,
0.1440582573,
-0.7396893501,
-0.1200207099,
-0.427218914,
0.588460803,
-0.4227201045,
-0.6782388091,
0.475466013,
0.2892782688,
0.0697885603,
0.4942877591,
0.3851007819,
-0.0608203672,
1.1875094175,
0.7971423268,
-0.1945239305,
0.7357113957,
-0.2209321111,
0.1631539017,
-0.7536445856,
-0.3579248786,
-0.4592019618,
-0.2058019042,
-0.5638502836,
-0.2058646828,
0.1648896933,
-0.0068497458,
-0.1161042601,
0.4778828323,
-0.4343862236,
0.6757492423,
0.4785217941,
-0.2312033027,
0.3830907643,
-0.0740762576,
-0.1681765467,
-0.3949154019,
-0.7985755205,
-0.46854496,
1.1831328869,
0.4664517641,
0.7293668985,
0.0982101038,
-0.0048829918,
0.2688040435,
0.3145338297,
-0.627636373,
0.3110734522,
-0.3114612103,
-0.8346597552,
-0.3472053707,
-0.2843132615,
-0.960026741,
0.1823583096,
-0.0854743123,
-0.6482996941,
0.3285751939,
0.0339074619,
-0.1337975711,
0.3289505243,
-0.654140234,
0.7619453669,
-0.17066513,
0.2845249474,
-0.260407716,
-0.9165165424,
0.185878858,
-0.1835193187,
0.1005651355,
0.0579357743,
-0.0129484562,
0.7670782208,
-0.0979342014,
0.8700376749,
-0.0248759091,
0.167487368,
0.0174022149,
-0.0199825447,
0.4187879562,
-0.3141695559,
-0.1422562152,
0.3619799614,
0.2494719774,
-0.6060377955,
-0.682254374,
-0.1077032089,
-1.0837402344,
-0.3036747277,
-0.5962477326,
-0.6387364268,
-0.4848799407,
0.1958340108,
0.8020236492,
0.8226687312,
-0.1741638929,
0.4326065183,
0.4558313787,
-0.0456200652,
0.4348775744,
0.5728055835,
-0.1031352803,
-0.2751506567,
0.7847781777,
0.4111361802,
0.4861326814,
0.3866859674,
0.1318787783,
-0.7938289046,
-0.6370216012,
-0.1608028114,
0.4942930341,
-0.4160780013,
0.1247203201,
-0.5539420247,
-0.334046334,
-0.3602895737,
-0.1199770123,
-0.4433150589,
-0.1962715387,
-0.0753319263,
0.0084707085,
0.1369475126,
0.7392008305,
0.1988413334,
0.6058117151,
-0.5936979055,
0.1018136591,
-0.0752232075,
0.5205969214,
-0.0810916871,
-0.8416795731,
-0.3344637752,
0.0152256787,
0.0824312419,
-0.8475672007,
0.3307079673,
0.0220072232,
0.514549315,
0.4316323996,
0.0579371713,
0.3911524415,
-0.4738554358,
0.7706027031,
0.3003745377,
-0.7945652008,
0.1091572568,
-0.219947204,
0.3691936731,
0.4295118153,
0.4515929818,
-1.1035987139,
-0.3784891665,
-0.7065669298,
-0.6726911068,
0.7404412627,
0.1795724332,
0.0728783533,
0.0715295747,
0.4239938259,
0.3162507117,
-0.0031780119,
-0.557595253,
-0.1577337384,
-0.1290072948,
-0.1452883631,
-0.5611389279,
-0.4442934096,
0.3215279877,
-0.1885876656,
0.4855029881,
-0.077698946,
0.334097445,
-0.2355621755,
-0.1155793965,
-0.0605681837,
0.2820864022,
0.6563567519,
0.8605666757,
-0.2128980905,
-0.0164998602,
0.4034165144,
-0.9051938653,
0.2654638886,
0.1972261965,
-0.042535156,
0.0132321278,
0.791034162,
0.8761410117,
0.0917641968,
-0.9703938365,
0.5137857199,
-0.2101501226,
-0.0361293815,
-0.2572417259,
0.1802087128,
0.0970364064,
0.2496452183,
0.381498605,
0.1830541492,
-0.118275255,
-0.1258517951,
0.1935765445,
0.1951733977,
-0.341665864,
-0.3744677007,
0.5441971421,
0.0306350142,
-0.6349695325,
0.6856880784,
0.0463172011,
-0.5162522197,
0.5243236423,
0.6467077136,
0.729652226,
-0.5716882944,
0.2521987259,
0.1739504486,
0.4476625323,
-0.4040501714,
-0.0467214026,
0.2650433481,
-0.7244211435,
-0.5995290875,
-0.627309382,
-0.4724105,
0.2726944089,
-0.9066674113,
0.0957582891,
-0.0189379416,
-0.2775853276,
-0.0208579265,
0.2564632297,
-0.5894489884,
0.3908783197,
-0.20453915,
1.0183012486,
-0.9940830469,
0.6649304628,
0.4869496226,
-0.5804615617,
-0.847378552,
0.2202017158,
-0.2261409163,
-0.4938741922,
0.5050866008,
0.2111941725,
-0.2820475698,
-0.010774781,
-0.101458028,
-0.8422889113,
0.7857751846,
0.6806440353,
-0.8598333597,
-0.404646486,
0.6831132174,
0.7766819596,
-0.3068177402,
0.3641934693,
1.0064041615,
0.1112954915,
0.1402875185,
-0.7797393203,
-0.2054478526,
-0.3439573646,
0.2822285295,
0.3668073714,
-0.5871070027,
0.7592378855,
-0.2342738807,
-0.3675474226,
-0.0088366615,
0.5637358427,
-0.0097657079,
0.0223819055,
0.6919937134,
0.4533115923,
0.5144075155,
0.0611882508,
1.3697444201,
-0.3479950726,
0.5179567933,
0.9636636376,
0.06983836,
1.0159608126,
0.2952959239,
-0.5707064867,
0.3693741858,
0.8047810197,
-0.1257903278,
0.4071646929,
-0.252106905,
0.0224807262,
-0.3324010074,
-0.0550851673,
-0.3747404516,
0.157873258,
0.1968154311,
-0.2768425047,
-0.1065451205,
0.2553423941,
-0.4796162844,
-0.1106615812,
0.2587239146,
0.4199387431,
-0.0247202758,
-0.6714102626,
0.6358928084,
-0.1729366928,
0.4901708961,
-0.3050168753,
0.413289547,
-0.3936488926,
0.2304756641,
0.1031498685,
-0.9759124517,
0.2597421408,
0.0951524973,
-0.1790453941,
-0.062789008,
0.5259526968,
-0.2358142585,
-0.5211417079,
0.2606274188,
0.5238103271,
0.2887173593,
0.1079030707,
-0.5725482702,
-0.0689356625,
-0.1808515042,
-0.4512855709,
0.1487522274,
0.0178861711,
0.0549391136,
0.9167223573,
0.4486349225,
0.0488966703,
-0.0373874381,
0.0348311067,
0.5440692306,
-0.671281755,
-0.6550863981,
-0.9271228313,
0.3685500324,
0.1947745532,
-0.7462255955,
0.3646104932,
0.5385341048,
0.6703515053,
0.0919242278,
0.7489105463,
0.1422464401,
0.5605479479,
-0.2397176474,
0.5665611625,
-0.4530231059,
0.2247095704,
-0.1216847524,
-1.0930927992,
-0.1787797809,
0.6206994653,
-0.7156791091,
0.2674862444,
0.6251915097,
0.6741306186,
-0.1783106029,
0.3774755299,
0.3871781826,
0.1871340573,
0.3840328753,
0.5371441841,
0.7805461287,
-0.2069381177,
0.5874883533,
-0.1065751836,
-0.1844851673,
-0.6028871536,
-0.5446469784,
-1.0774328709,
-0.7442889214,
0.1013305709,
-0.2751977444,
0.0073393597,
0.9208159447,
0.4705353677,
-0.6709294319,
-0.2086752355,
-0.4623699486,
-0.3722969294,
-0.3713503182,
-0.2138158679,
0.5234634876,
-0.2547566891,
-0.6881583929,
-0.0203052144,
0.0885328501,
0.2182512134,
-0.4402198195,
-0.0690986887,
0.0428967997,
0.3989033401,
0.1756088436,
0.390516907,
-0.8596277833,
-0.1415954381,
0.3845804334,
-0.4316253662,
-0.0263941325,
0.6224057674,
-0.7030110955,
0.5343024731,
0.3335309327,
0.7521662712,
0.7751954794,
-0.0907309651,
0.6443557739,
-0.537245512,
0.1244629547,
0.3256558776,
0.2285823971,
0.311424315,
-0.2300597578,
0.5370931625,
0.2378381342,
-0.4409866929,
-0.9869813919,
0.3614627719,
-0.5914810896,
-0.3248139024,
0.9556082487,
0.0620842054,
-0.1205683649,
-0.2600212395,
-0.2232244015,
0.3058627248,
-0.1162720621,
0.99791646,
1.0285881758,
-0.4758212566,
-0.2049621046,
-0.7543154955,
0.3726065159,
0.6255750656,
-0.6955746412,
0.3333159089,
0.1910822541,
0.2491142005,
0.2802404165,
0.357306838,
0.1319991201,
0.4038483202,
0.229789257,
-0.1567772031,
-0.1207869276,
-0.3692636788,
-0.3934120834,
0.0346041434,
-0.1661987901,
0.1677100807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11370v1 | SAILER: Structure-aware Pre-trained Language Model for Legal Case Retrieval | 2023-04-22T10:47:01 | 2023-04-22T10:47:01 | Haitao Li, Qingyao Ai, Jia Chen, Qian Dong, Yueyue Wu, Yiqun Liu, Chong Chen, Qi Tian | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Legal case retrieval, which aims to find relevant cases for a query case,
plays a core role in the intelligent legal system. Despite the success that
pre-training has achieved in ad-hoc retrieval tasks, effective pre-training
strategies for legal case retrieval remain to be explored. Compared with
general documents, legal case documents are typically long text sequences with
intrinsic logical structures. However, most existing language models have
difficulty understanding the long-distance dependencies between different
structures. Moreover, in contrast to the general retrieval, the relevance in
the legal domain is sensitive to key legal elements. Even subtle differences in
key legal elements can significantly affect the judgement of relevance.
However, existing pre-trained language models designed for general purposes
have not been equipped to handle legal elements.
To address these issues, in this paper, we propose SAILER, a new
Structure-Aware pre-traIned language model for LEgal case Retrieval. It is
highlighted in the following three aspects: (1) SAILER fully utilizes the
structural information contained in legal case documents and pays more
attention to key legal elements, similar to how legal experts browse legal case
documents. (2) SAILER employs an asymmetric encoder-decoder architecture to
integrate several different pre-training objectives. In this way, rich semantic
information across tasks is encoded into dense vectors. (3) SAILER has powerful
discriminative ability, even without any legal annotation data. It can
distinguish legal cases with different charges accurately. Extensive
experiments over publicly available legal benchmarks demonstrate that our
approach can significantly outperform previous state-of-the-art methods in
legal case retrieval. | [
-0.0801731199,
-0.4774084985,
0.6819214225,
-0.0284559727,
-0.7303286791,
0.0125514483,
-0.1513126791,
-0.5540756583,
0.309905231,
0.5865830779,
-0.0814618245,
-0.5838782191,
-0.6605708599,
-0.2583173215,
-0.5999138355,
1.0356053114,
0.0716383159,
0.3017685413,
-0.06927865,
-0.27803725,
-0.4574570954,
-0.6520573497,
-0.4586398005,
-0.0994091332,
0.3741266727,
-0.0904602259,
0.395537883,
0.496425122,
0.6696971655,
0.3376356363,
-0.2351100147,
-0.5805428028,
-0.383200109,
0.1556937546,
-0.186468333,
-0.7198536992,
-0.6049140692,
-0.0851898193,
0.2917119563,
0.3001551032,
-0.4264751971,
0.132261619,
-0.2833646536,
0.689723134,
-0.7755324841,
0.3056334555,
-0.7533008456,
0.0575205274,
-0.5657918453,
-0.0129620899,
-0.4640809,
-0.2131321579,
0.0346534997,
-0.8406014442,
0.4061811268,
0.3369666636,
0.8134868145,
0.3201611638,
-0.6833329797,
-0.5445321798,
-0.3666954041,
0.2579720616,
-0.6937543154,
0.6580933332,
0.4624478221,
0.6635813713,
-0.0070780311,
-0.9176530242,
-0.5963100791,
-0.4762701094,
-0.1924947947,
0.3717811406,
0.017855363,
0.4081273079,
0.1569092274,
0.163449645,
-0.6712840796,
-0.0173758678,
-0.4811311066,
-0.2425492257,
0.6060795188,
-0.1766794771,
0.3723953068,
-0.1891061068,
0.0128523512,
-0.0854692981,
-0.7434474826,
0.180895716,
0.3703384995,
0.366891861,
-0.0727054626,
0.6684688926,
-0.1375058144,
0.4838943183,
0.2474581003,
0.2099066526,
0.2891921699,
-0.1137045175,
-0.1169805303,
0.5287489891,
0.6873764992,
-0.1465346366,
0.1284441948,
-0.0097058844,
-0.2689709663,
-0.3039864004,
0.5726839304,
-0.8590661287,
-0.1055531576,
0.1539101303,
-0.5798670053,
-0.0321965665,
0.3500899076,
-0.3299131393,
-0.3046234548,
-0.0905884206,
0.2345412374,
-0.3850803077,
-0.0884417742,
0.5041094422,
-0.0146390628,
0.5446096063,
0.3367551565,
-0.539244175,
0.1779220402,
0.7034423947,
0.1952399909,
0.1556310952,
0.273031652,
-0.8063575029,
0.2969150245,
-0.145706445,
0.6979387999,
-0.770116508,
-0.2192424834,
-0.05617062,
-0.029541593,
0.0503258184,
-0.3226173222,
1.0104147196,
-1.0201854706,
0.1902125776,
-0.1043805555,
-0.483305335,
-0.2585166097,
0.284799546,
-0.7724599838,
0.4896343648,
-0.1701480299,
-0.8290362954,
0.7637219429,
-0.5283789635,
-0.818364501,
0.5411274433,
-0.5000151396,
-0.8787813783,
0.2811801136,
0.0545995943,
0.2443332672,
-0.2615748942,
0.5575342178,
-0.2099718451,
-0.3998183608,
-0.3964763284,
0.06003429,
0.6074978709,
0.2817096114,
-0.2333711535,
0.1721483916,
-0.6577866077,
-0.0855757445,
0.1687326431,
-0.7396218777,
-0.5875117779,
0.2245001495,
0.043257162,
0.1202966198,
0.1740457118,
-0.6537338495,
-0.0961416066,
-0.6345632672,
0.2279518843,
0.2601734102,
-0.1948742419,
0.4246355593,
0.0210894868,
0.6677707434,
0.0997509062,
-0.0092453016,
-0.1775436252,
-0.075967975,
-0.6057709455,
-0.2685060501,
0.2138448358,
0.5275700092,
-0.4020352662,
0.3035950959,
-0.3636108935,
-0.2912399769,
-0.5685896277,
-0.0713938847,
0.6315380931,
0.1456633359,
0.5570188165,
-0.2204813808,
-0.7626079321,
-0.6217817068,
-0.6202683449,
-0.2554623783,
0.1121496111,
0.449279964,
0.6196274161,
-0.1840890348,
0.8512582779,
-0.2823701203,
-0.3695541024,
-0.4756919146,
0.2248431146,
0.4604590237,
0.2772033811,
0.4514794946,
-1.2195864916,
-0.5855640173,
0.2570132613,
-0.5574185848,
0.1707890481,
-0.0311375223,
0.0781631693,
-0.2271054983,
0.77713269,
-0.8879237175,
0.5534530878,
-0.3011313081,
-0.6008319259,
0.5459665656,
-0.4524509609,
0.1008167416,
-1.1256650686,
0.115311563,
-0.2556464672,
-0.3334824145,
-0.5224616528,
0.2781305313,
0.3891394138,
-0.0288315061,
-0.59670645,
0.4116603732,
-0.7893744707,
-0.1766097099,
-0.2219922096,
0.0150390323,
-0.0443177857,
0.2397766113,
0.0745785162,
0.5541954041,
0.4134901464,
-0.5057386756,
0.2257933617,
0.330865711,
-0.3923829496,
0.8628421426,
-0.8319064975,
0.01966005,
-0.6558049917,
0.1963951439,
-0.453409642,
-0.0666231662,
0.0324911587,
-0.1368082613,
0.5260634422,
-0.6064104438,
-0.2216729224,
-0.6884082556,
-0.1059690043,
0.6091588736,
0.0701744854,
-0.0974773988,
1.0157176256,
0.4251928329,
-0.1804075241,
-0.7522272468,
-0.2927747071,
-0.0780982152,
-0.3197218776,
-0.0864746198,
0.4121098518,
0.011123687,
-0.0070733791,
0.0551547408,
-0.5483169556,
-0.4451811016,
0.0268247072,
0.5397610664,
0.109804593,
-0.4551765919,
0.1818971932,
0.0149069652,
0.011848799,
0.0998218358,
-0.3861532509,
0.4214921594,
-0.1991446614,
-0.7308222651,
-0.0837482139,
0.1602723449,
0.4615433812,
-0.880027771,
0.3266057968,
0.1774516702,
-0.2084600031,
-0.032866247,
-0.9158754945,
0.0218302831,
-0.5046932697,
0.7670942545,
-0.8171519637,
-1.0674715042,
0.3254027963,
0.0550412163,
-0.0710652769,
0.3319190741,
0.2310085744,
-0.3025667965,
0.3818251491,
0.9258375168,
-0.4035782516,
0.5801232457,
0.0345717296,
0.378985852,
-0.370216161,
-0.5527522564,
-0.7153298855,
0.1321235746,
-0.1318707168,
-0.3411027491,
0.209740907,
0.2323724926,
-0.3247060776,
0.7692148685,
-0.1458127201,
0.71319139,
0.3549183309,
0.1465897709,
0.3270789981,
-0.2854717374,
-0.3780469,
0.3229772747,
-0.6090211868,
-0.1560412496,
1.0327591896,
-0.0726545975,
0.7266513109,
-0.0911561325,
0.6591379642,
0.1762499213,
0.0691495538,
-0.7594687939,
0.4743183851,
-0.3206344247,
-0.7455199361,
-0.1915506124,
-0.4841103256,
-1.1315401793,
0.1350910962,
-0.2511976063,
-0.3381695151,
0.1226736754,
-0.0549240783,
-0.4675325751,
0.0754457042,
-0.0996269882,
0.950889945,
-0.506416142,
-0.2261668593,
-0.4222590327,
-0.8418653607,
-0.0286815763,
-0.2898755968,
0.1926006824,
-0.0248577036,
0.3379970789,
0.6067970991,
-0.4490593374,
0.4820024967,
-0.1661533713,
0.2178098857,
0.3209389746,
0.1550277919,
0.5860851407,
-0.134257257,
-0.0151184769,
-0.3115753531,
-0.0175880231,
-0.1705762297,
-0.521912694,
0.1393270046,
-0.4461025894,
-0.8164020777,
-0.2497253418,
-0.43165344,
0.1732067615,
0.5355165601,
0.1890579015,
0.2285617739,
-0.2724432349,
0.4231879711,
0.5317443013,
-0.0721502528,
0.3690129817,
1.1305235624,
0.2436058968,
0.0092914049,
0.6189329028,
-0.063754268,
-0.6365059018,
0.7672857046,
-0.0738286003,
-0.4966504872,
-0.8002922535,
-0.042410329,
0.3684040904,
-0.5546558499,
-0.2914373577,
-0.8168737292,
-0.2410978079,
-0.1754056811,
-0.1779268533,
-0.6174004078,
-0.2242478728,
-0.0084033366,
-0.250831455,
0.1276522279,
0.7664679289,
0.647862196,
0.2273185998,
-0.583966434,
0.3042113781,
0.1344290227,
0.6014552116,
-0.5137978792,
-0.7349455953,
-0.2643980086,
-0.2911502719,
0.1598375738,
-0.6215549707,
0.1573606133,
0.2709742188,
0.9310665131,
0.4688811898,
0.0869572759,
0.6471910477,
-0.7561026216,
0.1567642242,
0.1018361002,
-0.8321991563,
0.8888531923,
-0.233727634,
-0.1533079296,
0.9281268716,
0.5591738224,
-0.080212228,
-0.2887145877,
-0.2097931355,
-0.8997901082,
0.6722913384,
0.0039751055,
0.113533929,
0.2130513936,
0.7008798718,
-0.1738048345,
0.3947753012,
-0.9233159423,
0.2912697494,
-0.443334043,
-0.3910525441,
-0.030245794,
-0.2439284772,
0.2509585321,
-0.3651045561,
0.4336929023,
0.0362256207,
-0.0430277027,
0.0636781007,
-0.6769930124,
0.4244708419,
0.4020530879,
0.2136165053,
0.1297654361,
-0.2388415784,
0.1888575405,
0.1542276144,
-0.7373358011,
0.4075534046,
0.2954244912,
-0.0188194104,
-0.1447668374,
0.3548888862,
0.8169526458,
0.3176886439,
-0.725749135,
0.8130153418,
-0.0018279359,
-0.2320547998,
-0.3365628123,
-0.0279365126,
0.0233860537,
0.5627317429,
0.2731364965,
-0.1132774279,
0.3509432077,
-0.4498756826,
0.441627562,
0.5346366763,
-0.5605054498,
-0.2252913117,
1.1819993258,
0.1678136587,
-0.1330420673,
0.4923494756,
-0.15389961,
-0.5560620427,
0.4765290618,
0.5390970707,
0.6481617093,
-0.1529482901,
0.0752633363,
0.2686846852,
0.2460327595,
-0.4546877742,
0.2414047867,
-0.402990669,
-0.6060051322,
-0.3130756021,
-0.7722753286,
0.0593254864,
-0.2413422465,
-0.679941833,
0.2859411836,
-0.3141868412,
-0.2015471458,
-0.4230814576,
0.1064614803,
-0.6496286392,
0.2266385704,
-0.0558016673,
0.8694529533,
-0.4606935382,
1.1068599224,
0.8581903577,
-0.6578908563,
-0.8001433015,
-0.0932384804,
-0.1522413492,
-0.4155880213,
0.8947335482,
0.1762696803,
-0.3001926839,
-0.0630690008,
-0.0663729161,
-0.6850147247,
1.1087219715,
0.5271888375,
-0.7067428231,
-0.3332534432,
0.304161191,
0.5881046057,
-0.3209864199,
0.4122357666,
0.3100670278,
0.3463748991,
0.2991043329,
-0.6678211689,
0.2418379635,
-0.5781588554,
0.0225668419,
0.0420178846,
-0.3212471008,
0.6775890589,
-0.2340692729,
-0.2722592652,
-0.2025080621,
0.6903936267,
0.213311851,
0.2444399595,
0.4438055456,
0.5477395654,
0.7774960995,
-0.031503845,
1.0428509712,
-0.6011027098,
0.0880259499,
1.3141223192,
-0.4108636379,
0.9312750101,
0.2055363357,
0.0701018274,
0.4838794768,
0.1004628688,
-0.0179420561,
0.5039057136,
0.3632737696,
-0.1380833983,
-0.417897284,
0.2268589586,
-0.271130383,
0.6134157777,
0.0424321294,
-0.2362668663,
-0.1316688508,
0.0126636103,
-0.0246836059,
0.1862612963,
-0.3481914699,
0.7355901599,
-0.0267333146,
-0.3353384733,
0.0671942979,
0.0527024791,
0.63325423,
-0.8010582924,
0.1466346085,
-0.360357523,
0.1471621841,
-0.1832793653,
-0.4335898459,
0.2160497457,
0.0162955485,
-0.088083379,
-0.0661911592,
0.889811039,
-0.4793939888,
-0.3522543013,
0.5688319206,
0.3852666318,
0.1415576637,
-0.5385605693,
-0.6247282624,
-0.1404186487,
-0.295766592,
-0.4244064689,
0.0691151023,
0.4288835526,
-0.2031545937,
0.7610669732,
0.5038305521,
0.0805895478,
0.1634361595,
0.3426804841,
1.0694279671,
-0.7674865127,
-0.7026212215,
-0.6781088114,
0.486626178,
0.0151713165,
0.0677870139,
0.5253538489,
0.9352166653,
0.7791612744,
-0.0733691677,
0.3899244368,
0.0379343443,
0.1513267905,
-0.4479343593,
1.1125402451,
-0.4674246013,
0.2486625761,
-0.1993917078,
-0.9006818533,
-0.3185960352,
0.8118141294,
-0.3517345786,
0.116488494,
0.5887009501,
0.719522357,
-0.5007110834,
-0.039284572,
0.3058719039,
0.3121781647,
0.1863384992,
0.5327113867,
0.6298808455,
-0.3847771585,
0.8464858532,
0.4546113014,
0.1941562891,
-0.3131344616,
-0.5894651413,
-1.0658506155,
-0.4125168622,
0.0019204378,
0.1738394499,
0.38735497,
0.708319366,
0.9965478778,
-0.8360489607,
-0.2764253914,
-0.3528381288,
-0.0602447391,
0.1569782048,
-0.0900941119,
0.3034666181,
-0.4549948871,
-0.1840544641,
0.744001925,
0.32029441,
0.0920997411,
0.5266914964,
-0.1985814571,
-0.2426173836,
0.1446920931,
0.5375869274,
0.2978378832,
-0.3537221551,
-0.1634667069,
-0.3289241493,
-0.2229497433,
0.258326292,
1.0647665262,
-0.6836432219,
0.3577898145,
0.2925442755,
0.758289814,
1.1265612841,
0.0165907368,
0.5864044428,
-0.6640806198,
0.4246597886,
0.3292567134,
0.6770079732,
-0.1416390836,
-0.3335258961,
0.316613853,
0.1591052562,
-0.1359689087,
-0.3973584175,
0.2544773519,
-0.7968778014,
-0.3629266918,
0.4273334444,
-0.4606366456,
-0.2207097411,
-0.3585970104,
-0.1130880713,
0.3823870122,
-0.1673381031,
0.6362901926,
0.3016943336,
0.3452975154,
-0.2568664849,
-0.4479498267,
0.3983674049,
0.4515483081,
-0.8624887466,
-0.1625424176,
0.4959547818,
0.427221328,
0.0885398313,
0.8356701136,
-0.4545513988,
0.1626011431,
-0.040566653,
0.2481518239,
-0.4177262783,
-0.5388492346,
-0.1133092269,
0.471596539,
-0.1744925231,
0.167885825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13557v1 | "I'm" Lost in Translation: Pronoun Missteps in Crowdsourced Data Sets | 2023-04-22T09:27:32 | 2023-04-22T09:27:32 | Katie Seaborn, Yeongdae Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | As virtual assistants continue to be taken up globally, there is an
ever-greater need for these speech-based systems to communicate naturally in a
variety of languages. Crowdsourcing initiatives have focused on multilingual
translation of big, open data sets for use in natural language processing
(NLP). Yet, language translation is often not one-to-one, and biases can
trickle in. In this late-breaking work, we focus on the case of pronouns
translated between English and Japanese in the crowdsourced Tatoeba database.
We found that masculine pronoun biases were present overall, even though
plurality in language was accounted for in other ways. Importantly, we detected
biases in the translation process that reflect nuanced reactions to the
presence of feminine, neutral, and/or non-binary pronouns. We raise the issue
of translation bias for pronouns and offer a practical solution to embed
plurality in NLP data sets. | [
-0.3449814618,
-0.3404814303,
0.6613349915,
0.5998373628,
-0.231576249,
0.1874420196,
-0.1271957159,
-0.368809998,
0.323179543,
0.540045321,
-0.8497975469,
-0.2242394239,
-0.8557190895,
0.7094686627,
-0.3502761126,
0.7554368973,
0.0191238951,
0.462897867,
-0.1373548061,
-0.4324029982,
-0.529705286,
-0.492793411,
-0.2060608864,
-0.0831901133,
0.5027832389,
0.6045544744,
0.9224479795,
0.5743934512,
0.3828147352,
0.2451103777,
0.2233713567,
0.3991186917,
-0.266167134,
0.1209946051,
-0.3848173618,
-0.5245135427,
0.0815765038,
0.0935503468,
0.586963892,
1.1680854559,
0.2365241498,
0.4441826642,
-0.2117711604,
0.7764717937,
-0.7386023402,
0.0473687202,
-0.4090731144,
0.1684501469,
-0.621832788,
0.1473296285,
-0.1689314395,
-0.5838839412,
-0.1088898033,
-0.5852809548,
0.4895963371,
0.0189159531,
0.6036094427,
0.5875850916,
-0.3948687911,
-0.137982741,
-0.6274809837,
0.8536868095,
-0.5375061631,
0.4629372954,
0.7025800347,
0.0543105714,
-0.4403695464,
-0.2821438909,
-0.6459887624,
-0.0059979665,
0.028794989,
-0.0436324812,
-0.3549179733,
-0.3217224777,
0.0377335884,
-0.1071724966,
-0.3055379391,
0.1459136903,
-0.3533193767,
-0.080591172,
0.580334723,
-0.1306316704,
0.3046039343,
-0.334168762,
0.0786330849,
-0.0471773408,
-0.4066474438,
-0.3769773841,
0.9002123475,
0.7280768156,
0.0246557742,
0.9063678384,
0.0636137128,
0.5222425461,
-0.0471561253,
0.08066044,
0.3614464104,
-0.5388095379,
0.1325557977,
0.1019668877,
1.0101208687,
0.1890343577,
0.5478194952,
-0.1960962862,
0.2811841071,
-0.4522323906,
0.1050922647,
-0.2770087421,
0.0986876413,
0.0300700106,
-0.277035445,
0.0473524332,
-0.0046648486,
-0.5024809241,
-0.4513499737,
-0.1470220983,
0.0315381959,
-0.0274884216,
-0.4859099686,
0.1543039083,
-0.2351043671,
-0.216435343,
0.2331849039,
-0.8919010758,
0.3883539736,
0.5589619875,
1.1133677959,
0.2025233954,
-0.3709488213,
-0.411747843,
0.0010203717,
-0.4813603461,
0.4591302276,
-0.4989685416,
-0.6717182398,
-0.0832513645,
0.214838326,
-0.1746903211,
-0.7079504132,
0.4116244018,
-0.0274762604,
0.5812957287,
-0.6512779593,
-0.2002208382,
0.0053725424,
-0.1861490607,
-0.6555364728,
0.9524337649,
-0.0716971606,
-0.6596570611,
0.2337796241,
-0.4084517956,
-0.3000819683,
-0.0671211407,
-0.2127338797,
-0.3295102715,
0.2096529156,
0.3322711885,
0.4358833134,
-0.2242592871,
0.478713572,
-0.343824476,
-0.2140154392,
0.4994596839,
-0.0964937359,
0.9566972852,
-0.1860376745,
-0.37824893,
-0.4582202435,
-0.3136063218,
-0.2269704491,
0.2083961368,
-0.0794004947,
-0.6446748972,
0.0727314204,
0.1799759269,
0.056787651,
0.1631100625,
-0.4442180693,
0.2994802892,
-0.2007538527,
0.1776993275,
0.6741579175,
-0.215534687,
0.7783643603,
0.3143583536,
0.318531543,
0.0316771828,
-0.0748134851,
0.1908284277,
-0.7914859056,
-0.4980472624,
0.0935085416,
0.2492011338,
0.6788230538,
-0.6819271445,
0.4388461709,
-0.2353758663,
-0.2243420929,
-1.1192353964,
0.0572010688,
0.4820509553,
0.4186148643,
0.3721034527,
0.0006701048,
-0.6314138174,
-1.3895896673,
-0.6896559,
-0.4636009336,
-0.1407289654,
0.0405710451,
0.5119681358,
-0.2184492946,
0.9210166335,
-0.2938664854,
-0.6456944942,
-0.0319063254,
0.0984835774,
0.2029831111,
0.4989895523,
0.4792961776,
-0.784134686,
-0.134390682,
0.0174379312,
-0.7280473113,
-0.3984190822,
-0.219208017,
-0.2373055816,
-0.0941073895,
0.3882829249,
-0.4058169425,
0.2162475288,
0.6599291563,
-0.3495706618,
0.2920824587,
-0.0229140576,
0.145496428,
-1.2479811907,
0.0614020489,
0.024581315,
-0.47804299,
-0.2621044517,
-0.2371747792,
-0.1031847224,
0.1405029297,
-0.2374454886,
0.5518143177,
-0.7351047397,
-0.3982644081,
-0.2652946711,
0.3652403951,
-0.1995780468,
0.0505938046,
-0.1256899238,
1.1748049259,
0.16404365,
-0.643748343,
0.2105245143,
0.6380519867,
0.110559091,
0.8114117384,
-0.2679446638,
0.3041170239,
-0.3662071824,
0.0545144565,
-0.5541486144,
-0.4904344082,
0.8698669672,
-0.5989883542,
-0.0093194777,
-0.2924572527,
-0.5537154675,
-0.3342245519,
-0.0403464511,
0.3406034112,
-0.028353285,
-0.3775404096,
0.0100095924,
0.7695599198,
-0.1642152369,
-0.9059939384,
-0.8728446364,
0.7071355581,
0.0818549171,
-0.2620981634,
-0.0489678048,
0.1765602678,
-0.4891209006,
0.2993956804,
0.0773518607,
-0.2784240842,
0.1047860235,
0.162306875,
-0.3356272876,
-0.0635058656,
0.3766112328,
0.2564919591,
-0.2649922073,
0.070701167,
-0.4570228457,
0.3064137995,
-0.1429537237,
-0.4263163805,
-0.2741687298,
0.8566941619,
0.3967718184,
0.1451046765,
0.6609245539,
0.5540485382,
-0.4681998193,
0.1861102134,
-0.5800464749,
-0.0274469517,
-0.3292170465,
0.6142529845,
-0.350859791,
-0.5266239047,
0.5309695005,
-0.0228195414,
-0.0602414347,
0.4666196704,
0.3019978404,
-0.3500985205,
0.9430382848,
0.5526725054,
-0.1380499452,
0.3140421212,
-0.0366078801,
0.3638316393,
-0.4540244043,
-0.4319387674,
-0.9145872593,
-0.6311403513,
-0.9616672397,
-0.551692903,
0.4432803094,
-0.2039380521,
0.1294943541,
0.3241225779,
-0.3085578382,
0.7019920349,
0.9212780595,
-0.012667099,
0.4077013731,
-0.2252738774,
0.7353078723,
-0.6186537743,
-0.5501116514,
-0.6175943613,
0.7603622079,
0.0635633916,
0.3435546458,
0.2032053024,
0.7268241644,
0.5154871941,
-0.2096449882,
-0.4970466793,
0.5828652382,
-0.3341886699,
-0.6168586612,
-0.3569821417,
-0.3576425016,
-1.2121982574,
0.4253055453,
-0.2779840827,
-0.2751072943,
0.5653551221,
-0.0697453097,
0.2831614912,
0.3731191158,
-0.5798382163,
0.8853166699,
-0.3023618162,
-0.2596881688,
-0.0339615457,
-0.8651341796,
0.4078392684,
-0.0948861837,
0.4156114757,
-0.6079873443,
-0.3917095065,
0.6745630503,
-0.748115778,
0.7741318941,
-0.2928852439,
0.0962048694,
-0.0530400462,
0.1171921119,
0.2093581855,
0.1289286613,
0.055602856,
0.5013236403,
-0.2820248604,
-0.7071496248,
-0.1967889965,
0.5106421709,
-0.8953773379,
-0.349386096,
-0.4440496266,
-0.315640837,
-0.2401815951,
0.3076890707,
0.4233954251,
-0.2872349322,
-0.3793007731,
-0.0087498566,
0.4776576161,
0.0188685823,
0.240761444,
0.2207557857,
0.1115419641,
-0.1985687762,
0.6286026239,
0.4388284683,
-0.1851663291,
0.1594441235,
0.0576158203,
-0.3039303124,
-0.0277235303,
-1.0035879612,
0.5867333412,
-0.4042710364,
-0.0684997141,
-0.8248562217,
0.3934823275,
-0.3595834672,
-0.0622662306,
-0.6050188541,
-0.4525767565,
-0.5489208102,
-0.3084318042,
0.2199836075,
0.6930582523,
-0.1885069758,
0.4203429222,
-0.7257714272,
0.492967993,
-0.0391230099,
0.138989985,
-0.5073261857,
-0.2362584919,
-0.3622321486,
0.151291281,
0.3480359316,
-1.4395112991,
0.5314281583,
0.149178043,
0.2447544485,
-0.1692489982,
-0.1075975969,
0.9453627467,
-0.4243474901,
0.7005112767,
0.0729354396,
-1.1690790653,
0.4597824514,
-0.3320204318,
0.3823269904,
0.7601065636,
0.3384565711,
-0.9208126068,
-0.7693585157,
-0.6057444811,
-0.8987720609,
0.650740087,
0.2222392559,
0.4397640526,
-0.2514994442,
0.103632316,
0.5429011583,
0.5397099257,
-0.7147358656,
-0.4565273523,
-0.1298722327,
-0.1758161783,
-0.0341320261,
-0.112645641,
0.182974562,
0.0085654631,
0.6540120244,
-0.2038539797,
0.0531436503,
0.1794856936,
-0.2463162392,
-0.2048427463,
0.0743889585,
0.232203424,
0.4947240055,
0.1143768504,
0.2171181291,
-0.1060317978,
-0.5935575366,
0.2122786343,
-0.0004684268,
-0.5701377988,
0.7709556222,
0.2626089454,
0.6026816368,
0.3659566343,
-0.5970785022,
0.6531796455,
0.0520778485,
0.1075846478,
-0.4956657887,
-0.429400146,
-0.0188421719,
0.2377205044,
0.4707037508,
0.3973507285,
0.3355608582,
-0.3158798218,
-0.3279124498,
0.1534723341,
-0.1218229234,
-0.459104538,
0.8962234259,
0.3553973436,
-0.3035933077,
0.8231698871,
-0.1405874938,
-0.1802183688,
0.3871586621,
0.3235378861,
1.355553031,
-0.3288345039,
0.4741015136,
0.4269818962,
0.7096113563,
-0.5336250663,
0.2847745419,
0.1908924133,
-0.5580889583,
-0.3159131408,
0.1722223163,
-0.5078501701,
-0.2891371846,
-0.6925204396,
0.1929190308,
-0.0391416848,
-0.5504428148,
-0.2937164605,
-0.4781129062,
-0.8358507156,
-0.1143618003,
0.146553725,
0.2938435376,
-1.3720271587,
0.3174412251,
0.6198003888,
-0.4361958802,
-0.1764741093,
0.0221984927,
-0.2412517816,
-0.6556681991,
0.5038865209,
-0.2367372662,
-0.1237588003,
-0.0220315587,
-0.9305490255,
-0.8948495984,
0.3597715497,
0.7296276093,
-0.506862402,
-0.0241890401,
0.5185443163,
0.4732348025,
0.1941966861,
-0.1258054376,
0.4310729206,
0.8179674149,
-0.7091464996,
-1.1869302988,
-0.1960174888,
-0.088160865,
-0.1450049877,
0.2819518745,
-0.7241426706,
0.7542952895,
-0.3883168995,
-0.1895677745,
-0.1634403318,
0.7343455553,
-0.0408018082,
0.5961043835,
0.1952722371,
0.0695844591,
1.1137491465,
-0.2994440794,
0.8698372841,
0.5373113751,
-0.0685658827,
1.0310646296,
-0.0880550668,
0.5923005939,
0.8068296909,
-0.3240827024,
0.2849724591,
0.6366028786,
0.1504479498,
0.3036173284,
0.015561319,
-0.0982372463,
-0.2909072936,
-0.5283464789,
-0.3130791485,
0.3666564822,
0.2745655775,
-0.0671068728,
-0.0380049422,
0.2899509668,
0.4208031893,
0.6460109949,
-0.1682839394,
0.6864033341,
0.2872285843,
-0.5265269279,
0.1459727585,
0.1432315558,
0.4045316577,
-0.4382128716,
0.1658755094,
-0.5137346387,
-0.1732570678,
-0.3099960685,
-0.8614635468,
0.2676110268,
0.0832067952,
-0.4812605679,
-0.4797082245,
0.2991190255,
-0.5712500215,
-0.6128064394,
0.1996967942,
1.129927516,
0.5840139389,
-0.2901732922,
-0.5487982631,
-0.1277719289,
0.0469712913,
0.0213676523,
-0.0146260438,
0.5666217804,
-0.6690912247,
0.75172472,
0.4248618782,
0.2320448905,
0.5319666862,
0.3641552627,
0.3238863647,
-0.7281839252,
-0.4389488697,
-0.9119951725,
0.2114593089,
-0.1059631333,
-0.4820595384,
0.9305710793,
0.7412568331,
0.9625989795,
-0.5048411489,
0.9317259192,
0.2076496333,
0.6774525046,
-0.2429742217,
0.2968387306,
-0.3569951355,
-0.1853954941,
-0.2790759206,
-0.9062303901,
-0.4157716334,
0.430750072,
-0.0818082392,
-0.1779274493,
0.2812987864,
0.326946497,
-0.0851237103,
-0.3132290244,
0.0862281248,
0.1157566458,
0.1417072266,
0.1796592474,
0.6736255288,
-0.7156311274,
0.3773887753,
-0.2227275372,
0.1828351915,
-0.4181438386,
-0.6612144709,
-0.3951568604,
-0.871003747,
-0.5063800812,
-0.1422235221,
0.1640137583,
1.0355498791,
0.5497143865,
-0.5962108374,
-0.3349348307,
0.1042142808,
0.4927184284,
-0.2457159311,
-0.1399542689,
0.0707115605,
-0.0946760327,
-1.4295819998,
0.5608456135,
0.0989648625,
0.1113905981,
-0.3612894416,
0.0904581994,
-0.2612315118,
-0.2504062951,
0.1148246154,
0.441218555,
-0.7387148738,
-0.0795449913,
0.1166692153,
-0.1688160151,
-0.1364018619,
0.700348258,
-0.7709649801,
0.6676087379,
0.5282104611,
0.4839092791,
0.344194293,
0.244810164,
0.8479670882,
-1.2477850914,
0.4467868507,
0.4545816183,
0.2765468657,
0.7395204306,
-0.2862139046,
0.7320056558,
0.5540760159,
-0.2449916452,
-1.1778649092,
0.0779074728,
-0.6343931556,
-0.2325216234,
0.9330828786,
0.5300258994,
-0.1156451106,
-0.4188944399,
-0.4348737001,
0.3304661512,
-0.3518505692,
0.6554479003,
0.6395762563,
0.252081871,
0.0048582838,
-0.8002673388,
0.2517638206,
0.3160394728,
-0.4519673288,
0.046223022,
0.7139093876,
-0.035670694,
0.2596705556,
0.996114254,
0.1262489259,
0.1356686056,
-0.0405676477,
0.3674571216,
0.0770987868,
-0.1105100736,
-0.0185308605,
-0.2048500925,
0.0381412655,
-0.7113579512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11350v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11350v2 | Romanian Multiword Expression Detection Using Multilingual Adversarial Training and Lateral Inhibition | 2023-04-22T09:10:49 | 2023-05-08T16:54:03 | Andrei-Marius Avram, Verginica Barbu Mititelu, Dumitru-Clementin Cercel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiword expressions are a key ingredient for developing large-scale and
linguistically sound natural language processing technology. This paper
describes our improvements in automatically identifying Romanian multiword
expressions on the corpus released for the PARSEME v1.2 shared task. Our
approach assumes a multilingual perspective based on the recently introduced
lateral inhibition layer and adversarial training to boost the performance of
the employed multilingual language models. With the help of these two methods,
we improve the F1-score of XLM-RoBERTa by approximately 2.7% on unseen
multiword expressions, the main task of the PARSEME 1.2 edition. In addition,
our results can be considered SOTA performance, as they outperform the previous
results on Romanian obtained by the participants in this competition. | [
-0.5380089879,
-0.9192605019,
0.4483787417,
0.4501233101,
-0.3651387095,
0.0993920639,
-0.2535099387,
-0.6437072754,
0.486137569,
0.2679677904,
-0.6274559498,
-0.5692167878,
-1.1160628796,
0.2011906505,
-0.1785734743,
0.6831963658,
0.0762204602,
0.7682944536,
0.1170935184,
-0.7415903211,
-0.1970420182,
-0.7841699719,
-0.6583465338,
-0.0574200191,
0.5963810086,
0.1054008156,
0.45874542,
0.3458288312,
0.5915157795,
0.3992649019,
-0.1606173962,
0.0800749511,
-0.1429101527,
0.0393818133,
-0.1516465247,
-0.4741466939,
-0.4018571377,
0.1335720718,
0.7765968442,
0.1993917227,
0.0263703521,
0.0028799137,
-0.0939187035,
0.7084898949,
-0.5537795424,
0.1393259019,
-0.4634315073,
0.1167669818,
-0.4503631592,
-0.4478989542,
-0.4329565167,
-0.0852814317,
-0.397577107,
-0.2760916352,
-0.0197787397,
-0.3854281306,
0.8929588795,
0.1551688313,
-0.2892457843,
-0.2674141526,
-0.3943380415,
0.9888881445,
-0.4459994137,
0.3516105413,
-0.1044534966,
0.2588486373,
-0.1252763271,
-0.5849277377,
-0.3905133009,
-0.1998420954,
-0.1750594676,
0.092058897,
-0.5598241687,
-0.1408672631,
0.1427004486,
0.1615625322,
-0.5803625584,
0.2317071557,
-0.4178439379,
-0.2947675586,
0.4311740696,
0.0285476595,
0.3821721375,
0.0266929045,
-0.7993318439,
0.0084511042,
-0.7447581887,
0.0573860221,
0.4679533839,
0.129018575,
0.1342125982,
0.3958290517,
-0.1679013073,
0.4947845936,
-0.3074418008,
0.1763536632,
0.435883522,
-0.5099428296,
-0.2087567747,
-0.1413650662,
0.6547698975,
0.110708043,
-0.139300704,
-0.082192488,
-0.1877746135,
0.5746495128,
-0.0002098673,
-0.8319494724,
0.0967851281,
0.058726836,
-0.4752971232,
-0.2489251494,
0.1266085804,
-0.9940408468,
-0.4135302007,
-0.3657619059,
0.3581908047,
-0.5100803375,
-0.3382882178,
0.164775759,
-0.3331033587,
0.400514096,
0.1706546396,
-0.4095284641,
0.4006307423,
0.7339940667,
0.6650660038,
0.1297895312,
-0.404418081,
-1.2303038836,
-0.4706276953,
-0.0613665543,
0.8586016893,
-0.6269234419,
-0.0630688295,
-0.1910034716,
0.1882361323,
-0.3449925184,
-0.6328374743,
0.8920665383,
-0.641503334,
0.3395962119,
-0.1633335352,
-0.6221520901,
-0.2858102918,
0.1329031587,
-0.7498616576,
0.8899829388,
-0.0540481508,
-0.8031000495,
0.1214255616,
-0.7371112704,
-0.329944104,
0.1077958867,
-0.1084767431,
-0.3484917879,
0.2260955423,
0.3274486959,
0.345077008,
-0.2047977448,
0.1050094441,
-0.3143341541,
-0.0558246672,
0.2324831188,
-0.3423291445,
1.0741795301,
0.0914120749,
-0.6636037827,
0.4271401465,
-0.8047857285,
0.2198087722,
0.0364361815,
-0.4592934847,
-0.149305746,
-0.1639178097,
0.1855862886,
0.7138240933,
0.2150633037,
-0.6390903592,
-0.1191428453,
-0.3395350575,
0.1535401195,
0.517203331,
-0.1821543425,
0.2168228328,
-0.03175487,
0.8758831024,
0.081593819,
0.0401086584,
-0.0326270089,
-0.6846880317,
-0.7950345278,
-0.5849302411,
0.3859986365,
0.7861116529,
-0.6182215214,
0.5456528068,
-0.1518890113,
-0.4939991832,
-0.8078846335,
0.5199719667,
0.6597592831,
0.104571268,
0.4467701316,
-0.2306130677,
-0.758108139,
-1.0134847164,
-0.5667311549,
0.2234559804,
0.0696822405,
-0.0139815463,
0.369712919,
-0.2140921503,
0.2494788915,
-0.1856681257,
-0.633276701,
-0.5049865246,
0.6311687231,
-0.1062147394,
0.3632730246,
0.759760797,
-0.8690341711,
-0.5826123357,
-0.0893269628,
-0.7113292813,
-0.2299963981,
0.0678136423,
-0.2423598915,
0.4108617008,
0.656861186,
-0.5756611228,
0.4086940587,
0.6661135554,
-0.5205278993,
0.261985451,
-0.2390566766,
0.1943929493,
-0.7353407741,
0.0871382728,
0.2974904478,
-0.5034588575,
-0.8444894552,
0.6333699822,
0.2619456649,
-0.0677158535,
-0.6982342005,
0.2370957732,
-0.5028977394,
0.037271224,
-0.2523764372,
0.39168033,
0.1531424373,
0.5199983716,
0.2322874963,
0.7963547707,
0.8379751444,
-0.2594653666,
0.2185652405,
-0.1145575643,
-0.3604208827,
0.4881803095,
-0.4670810997,
0.201453045,
-0.2248968631,
-0.0057024206,
-0.8958953023,
0.1902169585,
0.2824457586,
-0.5488558412,
0.5501909256,
0.0383328795,
-0.3666253984,
0.0168534257,
-0.5639807582,
-0.1201669052,
-0.0046228939,
-0.5665627122,
0.7893594503,
0.5805949569,
-0.2423754036,
-0.5609232783,
-0.5908403993,
0.5041493773,
-0.4878839254,
-1.0380111933,
0.2856415808,
0.0827826411,
-0.1967802644,
-0.3051971793,
0.1752399802,
-0.2889238,
0.4185805917,
-0.0967365429,
0.2287265658,
-0.4287778139,
0.0220008921,
-0.0917332247,
-0.2473800331,
0.1654239148,
-0.0247023031,
0.5970343947,
-0.5845644474,
0.1049725637,
-0.6210727692,
0.6377980113,
0.4049589634,
-0.671349287,
0.8382117748,
1.1631118059,
-0.1940301657,
0.1969716549,
-0.4172621667,
-0.0442386866,
-0.3884781897,
0.3567327559,
-0.5649154186,
-0.7164740562,
0.4389948547,
-0.0740287006,
-0.326782912,
0.4858449101,
0.5106473565,
0.2449490875,
1.1114230156,
0.4655187428,
-0.1052748859,
0.4732269943,
-0.1474082321,
0.4241456091,
-0.7679325342,
0.0256835967,
-0.7482542992,
-0.3587427437,
-0.6753613949,
-0.4819474816,
0.3124943674,
0.4132907689,
0.55435884,
0.5436834097,
-0.2656627297,
0.3115140796,
0.7523866892,
0.2346109152,
-0.0410403349,
-0.0420387425,
-0.0965400636,
-0.0871416628,
-0.4104657173,
-0.5510740876,
0.92119807,
0.3471975327,
0.1260671765,
0.4098196924,
0.6963739991,
0.0238433052,
0.2095532417,
-0.7685920596,
0.6445085406,
-0.2612729967,
-0.6760034561,
-0.1579592079,
-0.4211447239,
-0.8738418818,
0.5989911556,
-0.2543374598,
-0.808113277,
-0.0132192597,
-0.0615107715,
-0.3647492528,
-0.1448391527,
-0.7673140168,
1.2392464876,
-0.2599458694,
-0.5265892148,
-0.7342009544,
-0.5945847034,
0.20736292,
0.0549311675,
0.2450769842,
-0.0157740712,
0.0152413761,
0.6707137823,
-0.1060523987,
0.4079509974,
-0.5097051263,
0.1178654209,
0.3113567531,
-0.1373191774,
0.5360454321,
0.0701330379,
-0.0616218038,
0.3586076796,
-0.1993272603,
-0.5245305896,
-0.4922454357,
0.9287158251,
-0.3565405607,
-0.764590323,
-0.3454637825,
-0.10157419,
0.0352607928,
0.2375829518,
0.1893909723,
0.4888152182,
-0.3848908544,
0.3013752997,
0.4413493276,
-0.325930357,
0.4018401206,
0.6774379611,
0.0290836543,
-0.3983364701,
0.7286204696,
-0.0535536781,
0.1633206904,
0.4966232181,
0.3358373344,
-0.4129879475,
-0.334838748,
-0.5079516172,
0.0188215692,
-0.8002628088,
-0.0709880367,
-0.8721473217,
0.0710614175,
-0.6067039371,
0.2885783017,
-0.1739175618,
-0.6357071996,
-0.1641185135,
-0.2115745991,
-0.092979379,
0.4396927953,
-0.1865216345,
0.2822333276,
-0.8752030134,
0.5554596782,
0.0330021679,
0.0086778076,
-0.4410149157,
-0.389392823,
-0.2688700557,
-0.101454705,
-0.5596781969,
-0.8856230378,
0.5463361144,
0.3387986422,
0.4780335128,
0.3907564282,
-0.2730911672,
0.4635208547,
-0.3157901168,
0.4907953143,
0.1929707974,
-1.0570682287,
0.5132647157,
0.0990008637,
0.316354394,
0.30975613,
0.3906726539,
-0.2272512317,
-0.5167353153,
-0.5347716212,
-0.703410089,
0.7982119322,
0.3419020176,
0.0366704427,
0.0637958273,
-0.2243146151,
-0.0544701926,
0.2276001126,
-0.9426757097,
-0.1899437159,
0.0691809058,
-0.058538422,
-0.0069139451,
-0.3392707407,
-0.0395131968,
-0.2452768087,
0.9186673164,
-0.0545098223,
0.1797139049,
0.1557427794,
-0.3811797798,
-0.0491859093,
0.5102967024,
0.8277075887,
0.6682291627,
-0.0123536428,
0.0783541799,
-0.1462885886,
-0.0502392165,
-0.1096807793,
0.4754347205,
0.1720910519,
0.3241944313,
0.4079082906,
0.9685260653,
0.1896247715,
-0.6812621355,
0.8231927156,
-0.4395880997,
-0.0215041842,
-0.4416835308,
-0.131934166,
0.1416494995,
0.3454804718,
-0.0686399564,
0.5288814902,
0.4430629015,
-0.5264447927,
0.2114364952,
0.5792728662,
-0.4359580874,
-0.3371591568,
0.4716498554,
0.049645327,
-0.2100002468,
0.2493070513,
-0.4113888144,
-0.9423696399,
0.6483284831,
0.1570507884,
0.8420035839,
-0.5814316273,
0.0763202906,
0.242353633,
0.3790310621,
0.1837036014,
0.6486132145,
0.0123376362,
-0.7137351036,
-0.2930287421,
-0.5246120691,
0.2629784048,
0.2403530627,
-0.8212681413,
0.7597364783,
-0.1778647155,
-0.0522199683,
0.6723952293,
0.0538340509,
-0.7243710756,
0.0170195457,
0.3620081842,
0.8802369237,
-0.97293365,
1.1801096201,
0.7824667692,
-0.4226550758,
-0.4238421023,
-0.3570841551,
0.1353669465,
-0.640308857,
0.9388837218,
0.7024917006,
-0.2680953741,
-0.1780522764,
0.0475050583,
-0.6039575934,
0.601821363,
0.4055292308,
-0.4054721594,
0.2593738735,
0.0865960866,
0.7135549784,
-0.2703847289,
0.3713888824,
0.6656243205,
0.6046173573,
-0.3297268748,
-0.6182857156,
-0.1593162119,
-0.3821089268,
-0.1864088625,
0.4252408445,
-0.5124465227,
0.6574889421,
0.213568747,
-0.503044188,
0.2349978238,
0.4618932009,
-0.2471503615,
0.2374670953,
0.6621889472,
0.744386971,
0.6074735522,
-0.0135653503,
1.0023032427,
-0.6948940158,
0.1805400848,
1.1345084906,
-0.1160197556,
0.8904458284,
0.6051309109,
0.0215044003,
0.3183502555,
0.1395910084,
0.1153409109,
0.4409055412,
0.0871065408,
-0.4868056178,
-0.3272157013,
-0.0969162956,
-0.1405628473,
0.9032801986,
0.5032244325,
-0.5202912092,
-0.2795812488,
0.3115904033,
0.256524384,
0.3300592005,
-0.111524187,
0.7742580175,
0.0732534081,
-0.7938776016,
0.6360802054,
0.4416313469,
0.5705674887,
-0.4913025796,
0.0815980136,
-0.1854344308,
0.5829972029,
0.0215816554,
-0.4796615839,
0.6137692928,
0.0787654668,
0.0565586835,
-0.3134680986,
0.7128290534,
-0.457039386,
-0.7434752584,
1.0173022747,
0.3548475206,
0.0258260034,
-0.4276913404,
-0.7806975842,
0.0189404041,
-0.0495413281,
-0.2467625886,
0.3479068577,
0.5456331372,
0.150505662,
0.3124014735,
0.2968077958,
0.1802842021,
0.5100647807,
0.1994587332,
0.8579303622,
-0.4318690896,
-0.4913634956,
-0.8497570753,
0.2604353726,
-0.3371005058,
-0.3447244167,
0.7801057696,
0.5534687042,
0.8289442658,
0.0102767171,
0.4756401181,
0.010834394,
0.6079166532,
-0.66086483,
0.351811856,
-0.5880926847,
0.1897550374,
-0.1648338139,
-0.6942666769,
-0.4503884017,
0.3985771835,
0.0073952903,
-0.4123386145,
0.8957337737,
1.0131257772,
-0.0836872458,
0.1570693403,
0.3841259181,
0.205064103,
0.2341295779,
0.5165689588,
0.680198133,
-0.7199313641,
0.4794541299,
-0.5432166457,
-0.5255386829,
0.0396619812,
-0.7045743465,
-0.7958286405,
-0.2710619867,
-0.5072046518,
-0.3533686996,
-0.1371103376,
0.8229812384,
0.4935173392,
-1.1714650393,
-0.1929445416,
-0.2328908294,
-0.1551986039,
-0.491825372,
-0.2047073245,
0.3323945999,
-0.666292727,
-0.802110076,
0.7876534462,
0.4468686879,
-0.4559755623,
-0.3141306043,
-0.1654780358,
-0.7200171947,
-0.0348349698,
0.5494717956,
-0.0286317244,
-0.638205409,
-0.0813597143,
-0.0434772931,
0.0445846431,
0.3497647047,
0.8908013105,
-0.5567922592,
0.4847313464,
0.5467590094,
0.6656580567,
0.1066881269,
-0.0586964674,
0.5258787274,
-0.7336890697,
0.5734037161,
0.2346685976,
0.8523173928,
0.2832769752,
-0.3854821026,
0.2755598128,
0.2596696615,
-0.2780891955,
-0.4770776033,
0.1965885311,
-0.5238674879,
-0.2663993835,
0.8590581417,
-0.714623034,
-0.2521210611,
0.099936828,
-0.1931086332,
0.2214981914,
-0.1703718603,
0.842977345,
0.8830474019,
0.1935415119,
-0.312125653,
-0.4844934642,
0.3946555555,
0.9057570696,
-0.8061378002,
-0.0606649928,
0.438781321,
-0.1494208723,
0.4166474938,
0.3751233518,
-0.3664740622,
0.4472560585,
-0.1912838817,
-0.0096454956,
0.2428046465,
-0.5746918321,
-0.8110783696,
0.3029910624,
0.0218916479,
-0.3927266002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11340v1 | Semantic Specialization for Knowledge-based Word Sense Disambiguation | 2023-04-22T07:40:23 | 2023-04-22T07:40:23 | Sakae Mizuki, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | A promising approach for knowledge-based Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) is
to select the sense whose contextualized embeddings computed for its definition
sentence are closest to those computed for a target word in a given sentence.
This approach relies on the similarity of the \textit{sense} and
\textit{context} embeddings computed by a pre-trained language model. We
propose a semantic specialization for WSD where contextualized embeddings are
adapted to the WSD task using solely lexical knowledge. The key idea is, for a
given sense, to bring semantically related senses and contexts closer and send
different/unrelated senses farther away. We realize this idea as the joint
optimization of the Attract-Repel objective for sense pairs and the
self-training objective for context-sense pairs while controlling deviations
from the original embeddings. The proposed method outperformed previous studies
that adapt contextualized embeddings. It achieved state-of-the-art performance
on knowledge-based WSD when combined with the reranking heuristic that uses the
sense inventory. We found that the similarity characteristics of specialized
embeddings conform to the key idea. We also found that the (dis)similarity of
embeddings between the related/different/unrelated senses correlates well with
the performance of WSD. | [
-0.6562871337,
-0.3763222694,
0.6414961219,
-0.054884579,
-0.5255164504,
-0.1759192497,
-0.3672686219,
-0.3676674366,
0.5294297338,
0.0859290287,
-0.4936802685,
-0.7092048526,
-0.7220246792,
0.1567045897,
-0.1673256755,
0.4966592491,
0.1206885651,
-0.2329683155,
-0.5759413838,
-0.5110726953,
-0.5007737279,
-0.3385094702,
0.0498616286,
-0.025556732,
0.6271878481,
0.1634937525,
0.3710237741,
0.509540379,
0.3942864537,
0.2289012671,
-0.1869022399,
0.139489904,
-0.1775866449,
0.0035830147,
-0.5870532393,
-0.3609339297,
-0.2244957685,
0.1015353501,
0.1960181296,
0.9384290576,
-0.2107146382,
-0.1342367381,
0.1105599999,
0.4775670469,
-0.8884379268,
0.0020896595,
-0.7601342201,
0.096067965,
-0.0143027352,
-0.0869860724,
-0.0588257425,
0.2680353224,
0.4331923425,
-0.9439567327,
0.2044728547,
0.1635929048,
0.723780632,
0.4788482785,
-0.4218452275,
-0.1292111278,
-0.178949073,
0.7974811792,
-0.45804286,
0.925619483,
0.2916553617,
0.0455691665,
0.0864192173,
-0.5730603337,
-0.6228504181,
-0.2524632812,
0.1336532533,
0.5118019581,
0.0810338482,
0.0893348381,
0.2393032014,
0.2363835126,
-0.4077351987,
0.1266075075,
-0.1616725475,
-0.3339385688,
0.5328083038,
-0.0076719299,
0.1009360924,
0.1281710863,
-0.7225823998,
-0.2961599827,
-0.4652169943,
-0.1818054467,
0.1025670245,
0.2481071502,
0.130788669,
0.5202340484,
-0.6211124063,
1.0593692064,
-0.1672265977,
-0.3022274375,
0.4884444177,
-0.3388762474,
0.0732162893,
-0.087524578,
0.2303658575,
0.6123259664,
0.3472650647,
-0.5021092892,
-0.2869344056,
0.4394542873,
0.480178833,
-0.4399048984,
-0.1370150447,
-0.1989009976,
-0.4892676771,
-0.1028122306,
0.1169914752,
-0.5308925509,
-0.0652044788,
-0.5796375275,
0.4994474351,
-0.5728452802,
-0.4525533617,
0.3017555177,
-0.693238318,
0.0633806363,
0.0812995806,
-0.887219429,
0.2657655478,
0.6379397511,
0.6866106391,
-0.6498025656,
-0.6207889915,
-0.1457410753,
0.3300876319,
-0.1522294283,
0.8420113325,
-0.5964362621,
-0.3783423007,
-0.1367309242,
-0.2700357437,
-0.1449738294,
-0.5803731084,
0.2986148596,
-0.6870199442,
-0.0510895848,
-0.5446816087,
-0.9427459836,
-0.0708881542,
0.3964817226,
-0.2293979675,
0.6777062416,
0.4439556003,
-0.8148787618,
1.0522552729,
-0.5516108274,
-0.3717779517,
0.1290895343,
-0.0730564818,
0.300688833,
0.387885958,
-0.0963710621,
0.2217452973,
-0.0105475755,
-0.1386129856,
-0.517218709,
-0.1467611194,
-0.0881580636,
0.129488796,
0.407921046,
0.2458151281,
0.0545759276,
0.1101462841,
-0.5985671878,
0.047477711,
0.0450953618,
-0.0517618321,
-1.1782386303,
-0.0130859511,
-0.2912186682,
0.1520283967,
0.4994575083,
-0.6090788841,
0.0838625729,
-0.6959397197,
0.2780784369,
0.6335026622,
-0.03167836,
0.716940701,
-0.0664040521,
0.3220869303,
0.3827581406,
0.1710667759,
0.1677455157,
-0.3985091448,
-0.4951688051,
-0.2797003388,
0.1995319128,
0.338932246,
-0.5110763907,
0.8175519705,
-0.0459284745,
-0.4649040699,
-0.0978566632,
0.0625831485,
0.1636268497,
0.7537988424,
0.5389623046,
-0.5285615325,
-0.1488789171,
-0.8265504241,
-0.4905584753,
0.0084163295,
0.0613591,
0.1076676548,
0.3507012427,
-0.3449142575,
1.458984971,
-1.1029503345,
-0.7080376744,
0.0125325173,
-0.4814162552,
-0.0280017797,
0.2722531557,
0.7427318692,
-0.9131933451,
-0.2455288768,
-0.1669377238,
-0.4956085086,
-0.0849023461,
0.5084357858,
-0.3514569402,
0.0046938164,
0.728638947,
-0.4618676305,
0.4475090504,
0.3220781982,
-0.5908772945,
0.5287140012,
-0.181098491,
-0.3375066519,
-1.3613083363,
-0.0236486271,
-0.1325220019,
0.091576986,
-0.3410185874,
0.2208476067,
0.1826124042,
0.1628682464,
-0.2022654712,
0.8141707182,
-0.3264479041,
-0.1223257706,
-0.231838271,
0.4944720566,
0.0996950045,
0.3833640516,
0.2624515891,
0.4048610032,
0.7450454831,
-0.9649423957,
0.5606184006,
0.3736110032,
-0.5520160794,
0.7392315865,
-0.4142243564,
-0.3509945571,
-0.0558026135,
-0.1473341882,
-0.5833361149,
0.0754716396,
0.084973678,
-0.4120307565,
-0.0008107591,
0.0360096879,
-0.2497077882,
-0.5483691692,
-0.1743970811,
0.4625920653,
0.3567831814,
-0.5890467167,
0.2865786254,
0.4232833982,
0.2332591265,
-0.515799582,
-0.4851154983,
-0.3081316054,
-0.4133814871,
-0.2832451165,
0.6263392568,
-0.0380809605,
-0.230894804,
0.2514141798,
-0.3261221945,
0.0943639129,
0.3625791371,
-0.1421022862,
0.0031600404,
0.0567823909,
0.5955030322,
0.4111050367,
-0.3818526268,
0.0261521619,
-0.7493447661,
0.3802515268,
0.2428370416,
-0.728520751,
0.2413169891,
0.4437274039,
0.3796395361,
-0.4940244555,
0.6510798335,
0.7372303009,
-0.373236686,
-0.2604136467,
-0.5088456869,
-0.6049394608,
-0.4469685853,
0.5889102817,
-0.7585225701,
-1.007609129,
0.502284348,
-0.3229448497,
-0.0647345781,
0.2591516078,
0.2863850892,
-0.0020216114,
0.7725484967,
0.7991419435,
-0.0264181383,
0.5628011227,
-0.0527025983,
0.4594079554,
-0.9894105792,
-0.215184167,
-0.3559243381,
-0.248207137,
-0.4044509828,
-0.3917698562,
0.4481213391,
0.3026616573,
-0.0261562672,
0.1288823038,
-0.556004703,
0.24024643,
0.6276318431,
-0.1185252517,
0.1801316589,
0.1958027333,
-0.6614797711,
-0.1818490028,
-0.8340588212,
-0.0223922357,
0.7866635323,
-0.0558605902,
0.6075817943,
0.1843567342,
0.8986225128,
0.1965601593,
-0.0336133577,
-1.0929375887,
0.5161350369,
-0.1044829339,
-0.0170271434,
-0.3579317331,
-0.2240204662,
-0.9918121099,
0.4395469129,
-0.0511943251,
-0.7686033845,
0.2277033925,
0.0457803681,
-0.0710665286,
0.0326714851,
-0.8033688068,
0.952596426,
0.2004602104,
-0.0157985594,
-0.4439703226,
-0.4310035706,
-0.1383982301,
0.0810277015,
-0.0925449133,
-0.2700001001,
-0.4164366126,
0.7655666471,
-0.439198494,
0.5838395357,
-0.5236055255,
-0.3190468252,
0.1754983068,
0.0105284499,
0.226012975,
0.0459199585,
-0.0449094437,
0.154382214,
0.1135184094,
-0.2977903783,
-0.6160108447,
0.751788497,
-0.5717886686,
-0.8172605038,
-0.3482376635,
-0.5541217327,
-0.6598661542,
0.4400834739,
0.3376013637,
0.3810602427,
-0.2673893273,
-0.1333164722,
0.6256920099,
0.0877406821,
0.301225841,
0.5891755223,
0.0497588217,
-0.0181237608,
1.0646585226,
0.1646770537,
0.1650119871,
0.4467431605,
0.4037155509,
-0.7474743724,
-0.3269436061,
-0.2404970229,
0.1193568408,
-0.6061388254,
-0.4123804271,
-0.7247264385,
0.0265354384,
-0.5257892013,
-0.3208151162,
-0.3156379163,
-0.1351472735,
-0.2872547805,
-0.0706226826,
0.6538264751,
0.3582853675,
-0.1564922035,
-0.2196134925,
-0.5995813012,
0.2798174918,
0.5400159359,
0.6648025513,
0.0375477374,
-0.5343382359,
-0.2605194449,
0.0249176156,
0.0105265137,
-0.8865954876,
0.3439159393,
0.3185121119,
0.7576681972,
0.7025282383,
0.4813159704,
0.6798847318,
-0.2620637119,
0.5363606811,
0.2428028882,
-0.8607183099,
0.7036787868,
-0.1760085076,
0.4736076295,
0.5262089968,
0.3273420632,
-0.5052698255,
-0.5326972008,
-0.4974134266,
-0.7967970371,
0.4361428916,
-0.3240911663,
0.2743466198,
-0.4073658288,
0.3208937943,
0.2351457924,
0.2162905931,
-0.1314436197,
-0.0561061986,
-0.2305419594,
-0.3156616986,
-0.1407234967,
-0.3081932068,
-0.2832658887,
-0.4366939366,
0.1843310595,
-0.5415138006,
0.2237053961,
0.3013573587,
-0.4470331967,
0.4524561465,
0.0856112689,
0.4351065159,
0.7948686481,
0.1328519881,
0.1915682107,
0.4449950159,
-0.6001437902,
-0.1124814004,
-0.1071804836,
-0.0359144919,
-0.1652777344,
0.2629376352,
0.664706111,
0.1255086511,
-0.671452105,
0.7383906841,
0.1429603547,
-0.1963224262,
-0.2534529567,
0.308826685,
0.079079695,
0.2490111738,
0.3453199267,
0.1886142492,
0.2259598821,
-0.1186021641,
0.2023496181,
0.4913628101,
-0.3274506032,
-0.170013532,
0.328192085,
0.1963159889,
0.1190735847,
0.4463678002,
-0.4944522083,
-0.606565237,
0.4570493698,
0.7636194825,
0.5398003459,
-0.1145538837,
-0.0417423993,
0.4432040453,
0.0155463712,
0.1003114432,
0.3796949685,
-0.6255969405,
-1.2986675501,
-0.0752875283,
-0.835835278,
-0.0292691831,
-0.3716133237,
-1.0363006592,
0.1279345453,
-0.2775252163,
-0.1311150044,
-0.5541050434,
-0.153371349,
-0.7158984542,
0.2611451745,
-0.0794218406,
1.2138110399,
-0.9256160259,
0.7782793045,
1.069442153,
-0.1643119603,
-0.5867472887,
0.2743146718,
-0.3717724979,
-0.648462534,
0.4490825534,
0.0593400337,
-0.1211772636,
0.3019995987,
-0.091655679,
-0.8914120197,
1.2715082169,
0.1178102642,
-0.6533825397,
0.2508742511,
-0.2949433625,
0.5032282472,
-0.3219173551,
-0.1319478601,
0.5160644054,
0.2975586951,
-0.0887638405,
-0.7546799183,
0.0383964591,
-0.0603888892,
0.2977282107,
0.0672965944,
-0.6786649823,
0.3668912649,
-0.3088890016,
-0.0314703509,
-0.2638579905,
1.0171744823,
0.3501462638,
0.3224390447,
0.9067712426,
1.1264401674,
0.6950115561,
0.0538526773,
0.6684378386,
-0.5103877783,
0.2604497671,
0.7753853202,
-0.4790024757,
0.7813676,
0.7890232801,
-0.1634128839,
0.3648598194,
0.5255185366,
0.1780162603,
0.9541044235,
0.2675905228,
-0.4284676611,
-0.2715057433,
-0.3078508973,
-0.5972526073,
0.6505618095,
0.6584287286,
-0.0313125998,
-0.1985615641,
0.3403576612,
-0.4037414491,
0.2194589525,
-0.2064296305,
1.0014355183,
0.0958215743,
-0.7425700426,
0.2870640457,
0.0995540097,
1.0139815807,
-0.6120893359,
0.2075796574,
-0.2162645459,
0.0394330546,
-0.0051400391,
-0.6494725347,
0.645136714,
-0.3760425746,
-0.4405029416,
-0.1543955207,
1.085534215,
-0.3818838596,
-0.0212208759,
0.6850076318,
0.7618701458,
-0.0034382741,
-0.3292483389,
-0.404014945,
-0.0371696353,
-0.317307651,
-0.0661486909,
0.6124837399,
0.6336920261,
-0.183106035,
0.5645239353,
0.476185292,
0.0383258276,
0.0500670336,
0.457488209,
1.0496290922,
-0.5758237243,
-0.9827443361,
-0.4470246434,
-0.0786800161,
-0.026666712,
-0.498219043,
0.6276971698,
0.3009552062,
1.1691137552,
-0.3683830798,
0.6180207133,
-0.3421151936,
0.4066123366,
-0.4134569764,
0.7057865262,
-0.9231043458,
-0.1964771748,
-0.2486655712,
-1.1384794712,
-0.0928432494,
0.8886196017,
-0.2775308788,
0.1473301202,
0.7691367865,
0.8887690306,
-0.2178283632,
-0.286054343,
0.5846534371,
-0.0708677843,
-0.205319792,
0.412932992,
0.6783934236,
0.1089155599,
0.1452732682,
-0.1051949114,
-0.2986989617,
-0.3046097457,
-0.673060596,
-0.648796916,
-1.0753697157,
-0.25631845,
-0.0717988387,
-0.1051490828,
0.7249286175,
0.697280705,
-0.3359107971,
0.2347096205,
-0.2639144957,
0.1728126854,
-0.4944452047,
-0.2699876428,
0.2486363202,
-0.5094550848,
-0.5932123661,
0.4412658215,
0.3453524709,
-0.1896871775,
-0.2807644308,
-0.1855739057,
-0.0855857953,
-0.2141645253,
0.8762437105,
0.0619344972,
-0.7444297075,
-0.525488615,
-0.0674256757,
-0.1273501366,
-0.5359928608,
0.7042139769,
-1.0557240248,
0.5143330693,
0.6009542346,
0.4933181703,
0.1901889145,
-0.1914273053,
0.3273226023,
-0.9025307298,
0.6146889329,
0.1858235151,
0.259095192,
-0.009918713,
-0.176989764,
0.3166463673,
0.700627923,
0.0880165771,
-0.5754349828,
0.586692512,
-1.0934514999,
-0.257075578,
1.2569286823,
-0.2575320601,
-0.2246957868,
-0.2018236965,
0.038214419,
0.2367254198,
-0.1651276946,
0.8552738428,
0.6380966306,
0.0178136602,
0.0197688807,
0.1267451346,
0.4323357642,
0.7730702758,
-0.4464891553,
-0.2334403545,
0.3180844486,
0.4952046573,
0.1371812224,
0.4786002636,
-0.029017996,
0.2364485115,
0.1307244003,
0.1633542031,
-0.1957844943,
-0.2219374031,
-0.018301053,
0.0542154945,
0.2374747992,
-0.3945468366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11164v1 | Dialectical language model evaluation: An initial appraisal of the commonsense spatial reasoning abilities of LLMs | 2023-04-22T06:28:46 | 2023-04-22T06:28:46 | Anthony G Cohn, Jose Hernandez-Orallo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have become very popular recently and many claims have been
made about their abilities, including for commonsense reasoning. Given the
increasingly better results of current language models on previous static
benchmarks for commonsense reasoning, we explore an alternative dialectical
evaluation. The goal of this kind of evaluation is not to obtain an aggregate
performance value but to find failures and map the boundaries of the system.
Dialoguing with the system gives the opportunity to check for consistency and
get more reassurance of these boundaries beyond anecdotal evidence. In this
paper we conduct some qualitative investigations of this kind of evaluation for
the particular case of spatial reasoning (which is a fundamental aspect of
commonsense reasoning). We conclude with some suggestions for future work both
to improve the capabilities of language models and to systematise this kind of
dialectical evaluation. | [
-0.4282817841,
-0.7044224739,
0.9872539639,
-0.0904323757,
-0.0784009919,
-0.3741672039,
-0.2531757057,
-0.2137823254,
-0.0684187114,
0.5838426948,
-0.3077717721,
-0.4529290199,
-0.4466589689,
-0.0451625921,
-0.3789843619,
0.386487633,
0.2620575428,
0.199258104,
-0.2558625937,
-0.2783216238,
-0.6389009356,
-0.5664756894,
-0.4949655533,
-0.7043030858,
0.1347904652,
0.4240020514,
1.0816938877,
0.4073475897,
0.3112114072,
0.537140429,
-0.4786171615,
-0.0730166659,
-0.5588069558,
0.2202761322,
-0.5286266208,
-0.2272252887,
-0.3600692749,
-0.073933728,
0.7466514111,
1.0257457495,
-0.3334616721,
-0.177668497,
-0.1549849808,
0.6111153364,
-0.0426712446,
0.0464948267,
-0.8377512097,
0.0756579489,
-0.0455568917,
-0.0941870585,
-0.2762895525,
-0.5069482327,
0.2879415751,
-0.5424301624,
0.0740558803,
0.4876379669,
0.7577031255,
-0.1246909872,
-0.2630782723,
-0.2075785249,
-0.5527220368,
0.9105547071,
-0.9141462445,
0.7063290477,
0.3161947429,
0.5632140636,
-0.19832398,
-0.4181273878,
-0.7843661308,
-0.8145058751,
0.0358750187,
0.0633523464,
-0.1767328978,
0.0030519462,
0.3058200777,
0.1766252071,
-0.4612937868,
0.0840406418,
-0.5282850266,
-0.0836590305,
0.6365641952,
0.518202126,
0.2105728835,
-0.3379870951,
-0.4747272432,
0.1860158443,
-0.7122405171,
-0.2126021981,
0.4805561006,
0.4298999012,
-0.1922943592,
0.5307378769,
-0.4446384013,
0.7380612493,
-0.0361997299,
0.0160536952,
-0.1436098367,
-0.3793436587,
0.0117563652,
-0.4036133289,
0.4714932144,
0.6041397452,
0.5667693019,
-0.2209641337,
-0.5183549523,
-0.0557855926,
0.3257956803,
-0.2778520882,
-0.2952062488,
0.2218564004,
-0.3963209093,
-0.2004171163,
-0.1708462238,
-0.7007201314,
-0.6250366569,
-0.6808229089,
-0.0213413928,
-0.6758195758,
-0.4473904669,
0.2666398883,
-0.0598849505,
0.2194446325,
0.6078231931,
-0.9260239005,
0.4582881033,
1.1921435595,
0.7890939116,
0.0118725188,
-0.6976144314,
0.1461508125,
-0.2739323378,
-0.3160856068,
1.2138999701,
-0.6275684834,
-0.5592710376,
-0.036043033,
-0.1154178903,
-0.0305130258,
-1.0565401316,
0.5345273018,
-0.4286794662,
-0.0676924661,
-0.5440261364,
-0.4981926382,
-0.2629469633,
0.3750947416,
-0.619241178,
1.0183941126,
0.236296162,
-0.429138422,
0.260056138,
-0.5219454765,
-0.1474088579,
0.212843582,
-0.0970726386,
-0.0702745914,
0.2641875446,
-0.0289107691,
0.2490506172,
-0.2898266613,
0.7160070539,
-0.7365117073,
-0.4573701322,
0.6005645394,
-0.3574178219,
0.9867327809,
0.3220057189,
-0.2074432373,
-0.0179429147,
-0.3886806071,
0.1267535239,
0.1241942868,
-0.0635293797,
-0.2374110073,
0.1655666977,
-0.1825161427,
-0.1173746586,
0.1101519465,
-0.311970979,
-0.0101686949,
-0.5008358359,
0.2761673927,
0.9137857556,
-0.033374425,
0.6618908048,
-0.6239624023,
0.4546359777,
-0.1409161389,
0.1544719487,
0.2079304457,
-0.6539552808,
-0.7250007987,
0.007348787,
0.0151813179,
0.4778693914,
-0.6486154795,
0.3603414595,
-0.3866006434,
-0.4474685192,
-0.1285657734,
0.1711001396,
0.3093942106,
0.518902719,
-0.0670431703,
-0.4299590588,
-0.5127516389,
-0.8290815353,
-0.2528093457,
-0.5403293371,
0.2180043906,
0.60208112,
0.6122937799,
0.0843240321,
1.0053085089,
-0.2254526168,
0.4501712322,
-0.4901663363,
-0.0030770388,
0.2865585387,
0.1767266393,
0.5196235776,
-0.3537285626,
-0.0802235305,
0.0752259269,
-0.8483977914,
-0.6253960729,
0.1329532266,
-0.2348270863,
-0.1858142465,
0.2808567882,
-0.326635927,
0.096780479,
0.4582795799,
-0.515894115,
0.8743035197,
-0.0780170038,
0.2735189497,
-0.3284724653,
-0.1836659908,
0.0938809514,
-0.1810595244,
-0.8355012536,
0.3230209649,
-0.3065500557,
-0.338003248,
-0.5449129939,
0.7412059903,
-0.3761796951,
-0.3694783747,
-0.1796444654,
0.572588861,
0.035721425,
0.1971796304,
0.343277216,
0.6470152736,
0.3551525176,
-0.3584317863,
0.6858771443,
-0.1299683154,
-0.5069406033,
1.0221346617,
-0.6025405526,
0.0704006776,
-0.1264318675,
-0.1941093802,
-1.234151721,
0.068455331,
0.2674795091,
-0.1283869296,
-0.1988192201,
-0.1685895175,
-0.3896187842,
-0.3848161697,
-0.1534476578,
0.1947561055,
0.1655390561,
-0.5909914374,
0.0996767804,
0.4463317394,
-0.2694606781,
0.0090017086,
-0.3742379248,
0.1593524516,
-0.4130939245,
-0.7045273781,
-0.4733319283,
0.161729306,
-0.9509882927,
0.0538827367,
0.188189432,
-0.4498012066,
0.3465561867,
0.0117194382,
0.2624762952,
-0.356189698,
-0.1645524949,
-0.204026103,
-0.2355465293,
0.1618770659,
0.0566993915,
0.3665025532,
-0.5798532367,
-0.7299990058,
-0.2637017071,
0.2260192782,
0.35070768,
0.2127742022,
0.3247073889,
-0.0365756117,
-0.3860805035,
-0.1893730611,
-0.5853396654,
-0.3361339271,
-0.4947575033,
0.3701997995,
-0.4535556734,
-0.7572696805,
0.4930856526,
-0.3814062178,
-0.3419257402,
0.3177942932,
0.4681233466,
-0.2922460139,
0.2272382826,
0.3425295651,
0.1612811387,
0.2823550105,
-0.1131568626,
0.4261317253,
-0.7457466125,
-0.2833567858,
-0.519177258,
-0.1196287796,
-0.2909281552,
-0.6541314125,
0.5645645261,
-0.0061299182,
-0.3457793295,
0.2677158415,
-0.3346647322,
0.4783324897,
0.3050628603,
0.135036692,
0.3731034696,
-0.1225316152,
-0.2558765709,
-0.3246321976,
-0.8378881812,
-0.9666854739,
0.7589948177,
0.4793607891,
0.5899181366,
0.4327248633,
0.5419945121,
0.3225595951,
0.6291139722,
-0.7244701385,
1.0519510508,
0.1559743881,
-0.6967558861,
-0.5295241475,
-0.3273386061,
-0.7786717415,
0.6817886829,
-0.2597536147,
-0.8684723973,
0.1781353503,
-0.073685959,
-0.3837788105,
0.3236382306,
-0.6605370641,
0.8090273738,
-0.4184037745,
-0.4912699163,
-0.1956274062,
-0.1425211877,
0.7659978867,
0.2647293508,
0.367111057,
-0.295519948,
-0.0247166213,
0.3638299406,
-0.458368212,
1.0369257927,
-0.3993957341,
-0.1935404092,
0.4840593338,
0.2738458812,
0.1465595365,
-0.0877528787,
-0.3096545041,
0.4554646313,
0.053319674,
-0.1781316251,
-0.7638248801,
0.7385177612,
-0.6043857932,
-0.728805542,
-0.3869633675,
-0.318605423,
-0.2624934614,
0.0783654377,
-0.2378429621,
0.3870385587,
-0.5285730362,
-0.2744138837,
0.6026784778,
-0.2608802319,
0.1561155617,
0.6132543087,
-0.3525963724,
-0.472001642,
0.5335276127,
0.0251486097,
0.1292060465,
0.0336467065,
0.3652086258,
-0.5368989706,
-0.696814239,
-0.5483343601,
0.331523031,
-0.8382303119,
-0.026621541,
-0.1722427607,
-0.0250620712,
-0.3411757052,
-0.3655305803,
-0.4255898893,
-0.4748679698,
0.2546781301,
0.0694424808,
0.1355625242,
1.2194551229,
-0.2477437407,
0.3982926309,
-0.4086457193,
0.0888012275,
0.2529132664,
0.3993462026,
0.194611907,
-0.8250238895,
-0.170310542,
-0.1255701929,
-0.3623385429,
-1.3018424511,
0.0540186502,
-0.2943222523,
0.8936018944,
0.5878816247,
-0.2364262342,
0.5986897349,
-0.6868194938,
0.7902472019,
0.1135065928,
-0.9842910767,
0.3605171442,
-0.5364053845,
0.0972388014,
0.3393733799,
0.0765509158,
-0.6045956612,
-0.3663077056,
-0.66518718,
-0.6174002886,
0.2887236774,
-0.0490585454,
0.12151701,
-0.079051204,
0.4042461812,
0.1039558649,
0.074081175,
-0.8910593987,
-0.0017876687,
-0.0821252018,
0.2026982307,
0.155987516,
-0.6329084039,
-0.2451046705,
-0.3144028485,
0.4301950932,
0.1217573062,
0.2749066353,
0.0390296839,
0.0576843433,
0.0983091891,
0.5946238041,
0.687394321,
0.8741335869,
-0.0337008983,
0.2997737229,
0.6104117036,
0.107091032,
0.2567663491,
-0.0111113722,
-0.1635694653,
0.0300180707,
0.6129307151,
0.51622504,
0.545301199,
-0.6218628287,
0.5480368137,
0.3647862375,
-0.1592882723,
-0.2285979837,
-0.1613547653,
0.1498737782,
0.4506640732,
-0.1039842591,
-0.1896401048,
0.5039010048,
-0.7328710556,
0.2631403506,
0.5854113698,
0.0709441006,
-0.4395987689,
0.3669949472,
0.2513025999,
-0.2419850826,
0.4321273863,
-0.3747908771,
-0.9093232155,
0.5327171087,
0.4369634092,
0.8863114715,
-0.2727873325,
0.3160217702,
0.3357200921,
0.7375338674,
0.009279591,
0.3121456206,
-0.1823292822,
-1.0876903534,
-0.126699239,
-0.3731080592,
-0.8565469384,
-0.0191812161,
-0.3825296462,
0.1069757938,
-0.5774578452,
-0.2438039035,
-0.3780018091,
0.1083262339,
-0.4480502605,
0.1692527682,
0.2565188706,
0.7711268067,
-1.2587162256,
0.5958803296,
0.7994357944,
-0.0047881142,
-0.2638404965,
-0.24727422,
0.1925847083,
-1.0767999887,
0.8268229961,
-0.2463661432,
-0.4488115609,
-0.7266238332,
-0.3646836281,
-0.7040162086,
0.7506178021,
0.3707111776,
-0.6815219522,
0.3249561787,
0.3675541878,
0.784881413,
-0.3169921339,
0.5142554641,
0.5668644309,
0.6592959166,
-0.0400396958,
-0.9718781114,
0.2773745954,
-0.1012097895,
0.3303966522,
-0.3436256945,
-0.7274155021,
0.748190701,
-0.419172287,
-0.3476419449,
0.3538851738,
0.5907878876,
0.48189345,
0.6396507621,
0.623765409,
0.7461960912,
0.7942525744,
-0.3155766726,
1.0277570486,
-0.2456583232,
0.3068282604,
1.1052889824,
-0.4787615836,
0.9586977363,
0.4494141042,
-0.4567244947,
0.5421404839,
0.4614210427,
0.2278103381,
0.5120022297,
0.566734314,
-0.3198304474,
-0.2594025135,
0.0701436028,
-0.2970840037,
0.5598926544,
0.3024634421,
0.0227126759,
-0.4664146006,
-0.4439705312,
-0.0212802142,
0.6298529506,
-0.0200999547,
0.5900529623,
0.0038194545,
-0.5624203086,
0.6423166394,
0.1299934536,
0.3090102375,
-0.1239516214,
0.0034696546,
-0.5557079315,
-0.1262581348,
-0.0134302648,
-1.0140479803,
0.5936534405,
-0.0196869504,
0.1496870071,
-0.3842316568,
0.7311061025,
-0.2488348931,
-0.2476923019,
0.2353058457,
0.7040713429,
0.5687160492,
0.2295036763,
-0.963965714,
0.3372756243,
-0.1970980018,
-0.0868457854,
-0.1318708062,
0.8894110322,
0.1298465282,
0.7351462841,
0.3469285965,
0.3715008199,
-0.0194026753,
0.0619270317,
0.9081625342,
-0.8854837418,
-0.2472385913,
-0.7514238358,
0.2807013094,
-0.2245217115,
-0.2146681994,
0.7941336632,
0.5799830556,
0.65516752,
0.0803197026,
0.7411222458,
0.1726429015,
0.4183229506,
-0.719021976,
0.466083914,
-0.2349698544,
0.6650335193,
-0.11997471,
-0.8017514348,
-0.0098965643,
0.9866164327,
-0.9163370132,
0.262917608,
0.8324646354,
1.026394248,
-0.1990668029,
0.4146589041,
0.7684392929,
0.2884148061,
-0.1139370203,
0.6181278825,
1.5327659845,
0.0363608971,
-0.0787505582,
-0.2802937925,
-0.4083998203,
0.0755804256,
-0.9705789089,
-0.8415793777,
-0.4691437781,
-0.0212524701,
-0.3180374801,
0.3578318655,
0.3409139216,
0.5691432357,
-0.6566728354,
-0.6857118607,
0.1448960006,
0.3736571372,
0.0576830804,
-0.2633327544,
-0.2084730715,
-0.31564641,
-0.7596640587,
0.4687601328,
0.2832154334,
-0.0428438336,
-0.5147078633,
-0.237469241,
0.0916273668,
0.260836333,
0.5254488587,
0.2156980187,
-0.9188070893,
-0.4606336057,
-0.3311380148,
-0.0752099976,
-0.0254429523,
0.8967988491,
-0.4806641042,
0.4053779542,
0.2365434915,
0.3318671882,
0.0915161744,
-0.0382405929,
0.4854463637,
-0.1726581603,
0.2389234751,
0.1105407476,
0.685972631,
0.6233937144,
-0.0839602947,
0.4922496974,
0.5685092807,
-0.4834423065,
-0.6901676655,
0.3457847536,
-0.8779981732,
-0.1425711364,
1.4099956751,
-0.120711647,
-0.1360719353,
-0.2702448666,
-0.1451874226,
-0.2925708592,
-0.2113530785,
0.807926178,
0.9805505872,
-0.2690315545,
-0.0991848186,
-0.5754578114,
0.0745461956,
0.5619664192,
-0.6330607533,
0.1688809544,
0.8443366885,
0.3874595165,
-0.0034635428,
1.0152497292,
-0.1335348487,
0.1567489356,
0.329763025,
-0.2184937,
0.1973282546,
-0.2333759516,
-0.581918776,
0.0783426091,
0.4878414571,
0.2643031776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12810v1 | Transcending the "Male Code": Implicit Masculine Biases in NLP Contexts | 2023-04-22T03:53:24 | 2023-04-22T03:53:24 | Katie Seaborn, Shruti Chandra, Thibault Fabre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | Critical scholarship has elevated the problem of gender bias in data sets
used to train virtual assistants (VAs). Most work has focused on explicit
biases in language, especially against women, girls, femme-identifying people,
and genderqueer folk; implicit associations through word embeddings; and
limited models of gender and masculinities, especially toxic masculinities,
conflation of sex and gender, and a sex/gender binary framing of the masculine
as diametric to the feminine. Yet, we must also interrogate how masculinities
are "coded" into language and the assumption of "male" as the linguistic
default: implicit masculine biases. To this end, we examined two natural
language processing (NLP) data sets. We found that when gendered language was
present, so were gender biases and especially masculine biases. Moreover, these
biases related in nuanced ways to the NLP context. We offer a new dictionary
called AVA that covers ambiguous associations between gendered language and the
language of VAs. | [
-0.4310694039,
-0.7135683894,
0.3824110031,
0.4226735532,
0.4147900343,
0.1430389583,
-0.094952479,
-0.4806298912,
-0.0107473638,
0.4132993519,
-0.8532639146,
-0.0446368456,
-0.6723986268,
0.5504873991,
-0.6145044565,
0.8763867617,
0.11934793,
0.4023200572,
-0.4921679497,
-0.3334277868,
-0.6474429369,
-0.8544457555,
-0.469299376,
-0.3731094003,
0.0515143462,
-0.0400657095,
0.6402367353,
0.5447310209,
0.3875756562,
0.3712052703,
-0.2136437297,
0.363668263,
-0.3614890873,
0.2723864317,
-0.3311372697,
-0.5770483613,
-0.357152462,
-0.0718031824,
0.2414223701,
0.5901982188,
0.2805643976,
0.2246588618,
0.1302115172,
0.939951241,
-0.8137616515,
0.4156104326,
-0.5480177402,
0.2855974436,
0.1864747107,
-0.3032635748,
-0.2286327034,
-0.1399584711,
0.2613315582,
-0.5581117272,
0.3333033919,
-0.1799823791,
0.8081393838,
0.0837111175,
-0.4422073066,
-0.2802183032,
-1.0293726921,
0.8230829239,
-0.0569012314,
0.437142998,
0.7477611303,
0.0969932079,
0.0831221715,
-0.3295522928,
-0.6060526371,
-0.1867159456,
-0.0843847543,
-0.2194672823,
-0.6007491946,
0.0401687659,
0.2984653115,
0.0245394912,
-0.1006059572,
-0.2447395921,
-0.4174988568,
0.1414512843,
0.5665150285,
-0.0646312609,
0.4744478464,
-0.0561249964,
-0.0017571816,
0.0544750169,
-0.3305132687,
-0.1806753576,
0.6060077548,
0.2297811061,
0.0136583718,
0.6353272796,
0.1346331835,
0.2860266566,
0.1123360097,
0.1618481874,
0.6004965901,
-0.2726185918,
-0.2412301153,
0.2525126934,
0.6373019814,
0.2174200416,
0.7935366035,
0.036682155,
0.0830620006,
0.2282301784,
1.1131794453,
-0.1870455742,
0.2548814714,
-0.147189036,
-0.1771239936,
-0.4039356709,
0.0162702035,
-0.7497546673,
-0.3241546452,
-0.6427441239,
0.2140589654,
-0.0938247964,
-0.2993923128,
-0.1689012051,
-0.4370726347,
0.3030090928,
-0.0151577117,
-0.9511145949,
0.6059117317,
0.6910734773,
0.6191905141,
0.3176445961,
-0.277970314,
-0.2288809568,
0.0137799093,
-0.6323641539,
0.31351161,
-0.8956282139,
-0.6823159456,
0.527400732,
-0.0261474885,
0.1310504079,
-0.4768568575,
0.5284656882,
0.061498642,
0.2818974555,
-0.4981302321,
-0.04391234,
0.0731682107,
0.2312304825,
-0.5449717045,
1.3848901987,
0.0501922444,
-0.6762545109,
0.3257027566,
-0.7186022401,
-0.2438383698,
-0.4368903041,
-0.8831900358,
-0.1693157405,
0.2326934338,
0.3622621298,
0.1648162305,
-0.3405396044,
0.209609136,
-0.1273762733,
-0.1801002175,
0.1444332451,
-0.3762982488,
0.7851023674,
-0.2473389059,
-0.5254787803,
-0.0316721685,
-0.5358569622,
-0.3240397573,
0.1009915993,
0.058303833,
-0.9743456841,
-0.0647280738,
-0.1291124523,
0.1982426643,
0.0342855863,
-0.2666490674,
0.0619399287,
-0.3481993675,
0.1764346063,
1.1264233589,
-0.4695813358,
0.8861566782,
-0.0258652214,
0.5117127299,
-0.2470738441,
0.4309498668,
0.0621073544,
-0.5578033328,
-0.7659288645,
0.0463838577,
-0.2105303705,
0.6593947411,
-0.8909345865,
0.5127533674,
-0.2764966786,
-0.1931898892,
-0.588195622,
0.2908833921,
0.9478176832,
0.4469942153,
0.5446372628,
-0.2653404474,
-0.7959404588,
-1.3864549398,
-0.5760006905,
-0.4445852339,
-0.1981137246,
0.5244554877,
0.6051141024,
-0.6369714141,
1.1154067516,
-0.3661118746,
-0.6749803424,
-0.1290344447,
0.2505674064,
-0.2541763484,
0.5872550607,
0.6284466386,
-0.7692266107,
0.1144286245,
-0.0846815109,
-0.8277734518,
-0.4085796773,
0.0808147788,
-0.3667584956,
-0.0618113093,
0.8106538057,
-0.1960661262,
0.4043501616,
0.5346959829,
-0.5307431817,
0.5443527102,
-0.2260001004,
-0.0585149899,
-0.8738313317,
-0.0379524492,
0.3667019606,
-0.1932283938,
-0.6349475384,
0.1203187332,
-0.1987303197,
0.2329878807,
-0.4717363417,
0.5567902327,
-0.6424601078,
-0.1605890244,
-0.2734855711,
-0.3919342458,
-0.0023165946,
0.4149424136,
-0.0095346831,
0.8615195155,
0.3467251956,
-0.7185872197,
0.1299886853,
0.4300235808,
0.3609532416,
0.8438616395,
-0.6275208592,
0.3321271837,
-0.4680480063,
0.283769846,
-0.4239703715,
0.2633132637,
0.314489454,
-0.547111094,
0.3294560015,
-0.2612144947,
-0.2331532538,
-0.1915294826,
-0.5043325424,
0.7581403852,
0.3882521689,
-0.2508906126,
0.585385561,
0.6318485737,
0.2708157301,
-1.0619707108,
-0.8415727615,
0.1917617619,
0.2951365411,
-0.1214500964,
0.0774164572,
0.0064132386,
-0.6495743394,
-0.0346492603,
-0.2817254961,
-0.7110953331,
-0.0367296748,
0.474372983,
0.056770023,
-0.1050625145,
0.0970909521,
0.2597663999,
-0.0037614652,
0.4170945287,
-0.0804384202,
0.4951696694,
-0.475566417,
-0.0808214396,
-0.0065207351,
0.520380497,
0.3435913622,
0.0024261891,
0.7065855861,
0.6985318661,
-0.5703312159,
-0.2187342197,
-0.2768256664,
-0.1984974295,
-0.4513817132,
0.3164457083,
-0.4391833246,
-0.8840386271,
0.1781235039,
0.1281922609,
0.1839528829,
0.5095886588,
0.3406951129,
-0.0162701048,
1.0951504707,
1.0674661398,
-0.1407901794,
0.4893494844,
-0.4167693555,
-0.081121102,
-0.8910793662,
-0.3169016242,
-0.9867015481,
-0.2397951931,
-0.7816960216,
-0.5637369156,
0.1144180596,
-0.5407806635,
-0.2422761321,
0.1842910349,
-0.5397777557,
0.5586640835,
0.6951447129,
-0.0988737345,
-0.11952544,
-0.1012557149,
0.0828609094,
-0.353702426,
-0.4339828491,
-0.6493879557,
1.2012594938,
0.3527135253,
0.4118460715,
0.0748124719,
0.1714021713,
0.6734205484,
0.0095095048,
-0.4240909219,
0.5033459067,
-0.3055566549,
-0.952966094,
0.0508956015,
-0.0518728085,
-1.1001391411,
0.1548591703,
-0.4438413382,
-0.5915305614,
0.6380671859,
0.2343748063,
0.2820741832,
0.1258249432,
-0.4996118844,
0.6314323545,
0.0654820874,
-0.5873548985,
-0.0046070619,
-0.6328860521,
0.6153291464,
0.1753420681,
0.4265038371,
-0.116589509,
-0.3563050628,
0.6150542498,
-0.4198320806,
0.9052324295,
0.1265721619,
-0.1092593595,
-0.2354245335,
0.2653872967,
-0.0436205901,
0.2038118392,
0.2087739259,
0.6241121292,
-0.1793512851,
-0.5183349252,
-0.3315922022,
0.6441923976,
-1.1259169579,
-0.389726758,
-0.8262148499,
-0.242545858,
-0.3322347105,
0.1508333683,
0.0850587264,
0.4029420316,
-0.3043268323,
-0.0188951083,
1.0733846426,
-0.5004318953,
-0.0903208628,
0.2565096915,
-0.1521162987,
0.1104671583,
0.6071528196,
-0.1714761853,
0.0240245871,
0.5378493667,
0.0812814757,
-0.0158785675,
0.0430337638,
-0.4477919042,
0.199042201,
-0.5819265246,
0.1352146417,
-0.8817195892,
-0.4481349289,
-0.4793463945,
-0.4542819858,
-0.5437115431,
0.0767788291,
-0.5067607164,
-0.1990727484,
0.1645891368,
0.6143158078,
0.2172072977,
0.1240297332,
-0.5766817927,
0.7990034223,
0.5532993674,
0.2066140175,
-0.5344848037,
-0.2230130881,
0.1445272416,
-0.0719306841,
0.0688703358,
-1.0802822113,
0.4076040089,
0.3015287817,
0.5248900056,
0.2364054024,
-0.168558985,
0.6015252471,
-0.7004333138,
0.9889143109,
0.0063009262,
-1.1594446898,
0.639875114,
-0.2677561343,
0.2684494555,
0.6909433603,
0.4162785411,
-0.5656319857,
-0.70895648,
-0.6832936406,
-0.9995274544,
0.6914118528,
0.4633807838,
0.8652740121,
-0.2616332471,
0.4126650393,
0.3795909286,
0.6488440037,
-0.7565504909,
-0.7857093215,
-0.0635098964,
-0.066464439,
0.082442686,
-0.6523510814,
-0.3418679535,
-0.4423794448,
0.593364954,
-0.2368220091,
0.7705180049,
0.4393859804,
-0.2004318088,
0.0366931409,
0.2110346556,
0.6416790485,
0.8718367219,
-0.0745778531,
0.1576525718,
0.0658433065,
-0.8281760812,
0.2498191446,
-0.3425583243,
-0.2091861963,
0.5093868971,
0.4985451996,
0.80931288,
0.1372115165,
-0.7923232913,
0.7294898033,
-0.453140974,
-0.3371357024,
-0.7987079024,
0.1275801063,
-0.4921656549,
0.1158308163,
0.3713877797,
0.3572556973,
0.3386458158,
-0.7361351252,
-0.0136021739,
0.3593393266,
-0.7816682458,
-0.2147704512,
0.7622929811,
0.434376508,
-0.3440055549,
0.2904311717,
0.0225876775,
-0.4230422974,
0.5304662585,
0.2419252247,
1.3873152733,
-0.2169134319,
0.1982064098,
0.4160198569,
0.9462416172,
-0.1457395703,
0.3119325936,
-0.0463322997,
-0.7375531793,
-0.3045769632,
-0.3642754853,
-0.1824086905,
0.120781973,
-0.678994298,
0.3493622243,
-0.7487181425,
-0.2574594915,
-0.1572424471,
-0.4150459468,
-0.9834846258,
0.1192122251,
0.3449193239,
0.7524312139,
-1.0626375675,
0.4485590756,
0.8939870596,
-0.17329292,
-0.2718560398,
0.0676569566,
0.3580813408,
-0.8215466142,
0.7257290483,
0.1724755317,
-0.1967873722,
-0.42918396,
-0.3470024168,
-0.4895689487,
0.5458262563,
0.5613715053,
-0.5432060957,
-0.2418858707,
0.1092547849,
0.7798572183,
-0.1713829786,
0.6347512603,
0.7105302215,
0.3876286149,
-0.7093574405,
-1.3006747961,
-0.2367995083,
-0.6173065901,
0.1797307283,
0.1329128295,
-0.2003486454,
0.6383602619,
0.1841993481,
0.306819886,
-0.571549654,
0.5566307902,
-0.0873082653,
0.3537765443,
0.4409907162,
0.1414113194,
0.3911790252,
0.011758022,
1.1409825087,
0.2050693929,
-0.2600257099,
1.0959724188,
0.1335422397,
0.3669893444,
0.6077998877,
-0.3278897703,
0.6727718711,
-0.0232235752,
0.3462015092,
-0.0285812691,
0.2413868308,
-0.2147627473,
0.0730964318,
-0.3171434402,
-0.4564604759,
0.6579094529,
0.4180973172,
-0.7267706394,
0.0814295188,
-0.0220503639,
0.1961354315,
0.3768661916,
-0.3519996107,
0.8412715793,
0.2454346567,
-0.3108960688,
0.3581966758,
0.1417340189,
0.7812210321,
-0.8379742503,
-0.0423850939,
-0.1510989219,
-0.0629335046,
-0.2033333182,
-0.5503086448,
0.2460662276,
0.2264499217,
-0.4160675704,
-0.568230629,
0.7808488011,
-0.2281329632,
-0.536801219,
0.3104750216,
0.7441558838,
-0.0946055353,
-0.0746837333,
-0.8381828666,
0.0107231606,
-0.0863423198,
-0.0874718428,
0.2527173162,
0.2682744265,
-0.3019600809,
0.8776239753,
0.6285836697,
0.1806076616,
0.2886114717,
0.1681880802,
0.6000162959,
-0.4336664677,
-0.7177937031,
-1.0287861824,
0.2710869312,
-0.1918125302,
-0.618704617,
0.7337592244,
0.4424425364,
0.8678183556,
-0.1486916393,
0.8583835959,
0.1133126915,
0.1337701678,
-0.2454283535,
0.3945334554,
-0.5764816403,
0.328473866,
-0.6823112369,
-0.8857358694,
-0.2359908968,
0.6592329144,
-0.1416088641,
0.0733922794,
0.4874100089,
0.3947715461,
0.00125307,
-0.0965084732,
0.0524799563,
0.163062498,
0.4293548167,
0.1568139941,
0.6323075294,
-0.5221179128,
0.4855518937,
-0.3484162688,
-0.0038834026,
-0.2935833931,
-0.7256271243,
-0.8389203548,
-0.7658352256,
-0.3384896219,
-0.4166142941,
0.3022911549,
1.1588987112,
0.6079789996,
-0.2569305003,
-0.2898554206,
-0.2396903336,
0.2915214598,
-0.469576776,
-0.2426295877,
-0.0797382817,
-0.1330513209,
-1.0484526157,
0.1314175427,
0.205575943,
-0.1932681203,
-0.5877974033,
-0.0979075283,
-0.1404888928,
0.3336469829,
0.7208055854,
0.3439825475,
-0.4311411381,
-0.0753987804,
-0.0985020027,
-0.1193793118,
-0.0431688651,
0.9601517916,
-0.9247549772,
0.7454780936,
0.4942494631,
0.752828896,
-0.1105061173,
-0.2669325173,
1.1187052727,
-1.1850126982,
0.3191868663,
0.4969015419,
0.140991509,
0.148969993,
-0.2824250162,
0.4311796725,
0.4218489826,
-0.1938227415,
-1.1546120644,
0.0888088569,
-0.9096639156,
-0.5350571871,
1.387553215,
0.5143149495,
-0.4088741839,
-0.4140052497,
-0.5086225271,
0.2484242618,
-0.4461691082,
0.7965272665,
0.5711473227,
0.0769380182,
0.0940908343,
-1.2799192667,
0.7935366035,
0.4639772773,
-0.7779653072,
-0.1690504849,
0.6185884476,
-0.0087359631,
0.2277251631,
0.7821602225,
0.078386426,
0.4772442579,
-0.0075700879,
0.2364950776,
-0.1044473872,
-0.3569633961,
-0.3800577223,
-0.1503876895,
-0.1078909487,
-0.2528572679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11292v1 | On the Identification of the Energy related Issues from the App Reviews | 2023-04-22T01:54:30 | 2023-04-22T01:54:30 | Noshin Nawal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The energy inefficiency of the apps can be a major issue for the app users
which is discussed on App Stores extensively. Previous research has shown the
importance of investigating the energy related app reviews to identify the
major causes or categories of energy related user feedback. However, there is
no study that efficiently extracts the energy related app reviews
automatically. In this paper, we empirically study different techniques for
automatic extraction of the energy related user feedback. We compare the
accuracy, F1-score and run time of numerous machine-learning models with
relevant feature combinations and relatively modern Neural Network-based
models. In total, 60 machine learning models are compared to 30 models that we
build using six neural network architectures and three word embedding models.
We develop a visualization tool for this study through which a developer can
traverse through this large-scale result set. The results show that neural
networks outperform the other machine learning techniques and can achieve the
highest F1-score of 0.935. To replicate the research results, we have open
sourced the interactive visualization tool. After identifying the best results
and extracting the energy related reviews, we further compare various
techniques to help the developers automatically investigate the emerging issues
that might be responsible for energy inefficiency of the apps. We experiment
the previously used string matching with results obtained from applying two of
the state-of-the-art topic modeling algorithms, OBTM and AOLDA. Finally, we run
a qualitative study performed in collaboration with developers and students
from different institutions to determine their preferences for identifying
necessary topics from previously categorized reviews, which shows OBTM produces
the most helpful results. | [
-0.4538737535,
-0.5288841724,
0.3524352312,
0.0740211755,
0.0332269631,
0.1807444394,
-0.2569173276,
-0.5192434788,
0.284134835,
0.489245832,
-0.3327606022,
-0.2293737531,
-0.0634750798,
-0.0243295487,
-0.2418075353,
0.8290672898,
-0.4370760322,
0.0519837663,
-0.437640965,
0.0144918822,
-0.4926399887,
-0.0814944729,
-0.1876153052,
-0.7382603288,
0.1759464741,
0.5708650351,
0.3105890155,
0.0727825239,
0.7952041626,
0.3127803206,
0.2661610544,
-0.0357919,
-0.1251622438,
-0.0167347323,
-0.0061130705,
-0.1152177602,
-0.1184304059,
0.2621480823,
0.0384106003,
0.248766914,
-0.0663280189,
0.6842153072,
0.1657112539,
1.0455075502,
-0.7974757552,
0.31591627,
-0.7897889018,
0.3180343807,
0.1145186424,
-0.121200569,
-0.149816975,
-0.4798557758,
-0.0803091004,
-0.2684417367,
0.1643825769,
0.2362175137,
1.1072796583,
0.3178773522,
-0.283128351,
-0.6771448851,
-0.8875414729,
0.6528551579,
-0.6452720165,
0.0847054124,
0.3538838923,
0.2062394619,
0.2294896096,
-0.1916878223,
-0.850366354,
-0.4929171801,
-0.2157769799,
0.1788159758,
-0.317206502,
-0.0639600456,
0.2407076657,
0.3960236013,
-0.3636851311,
-0.2568669915,
-0.4338959455,
-0.1342253685,
1.0125830173,
0.314081043,
0.2759495676,
-0.6536382437,
-0.4538030326,
-0.1776241511,
-0.3534256816,
0.2856045961,
0.4811188579,
0.0051613105,
-0.0014194611,
0.7476979494,
-0.0778233185,
0.6182770133,
-0.0129896998,
0.2133802772,
0.3437449932,
-0.5918000937,
0.0040189023,
0.3499956727,
0.8747524619,
0.62919873,
0.0935423002,
-0.1523782462,
-0.3036599159,
0.0669729114,
0.3209710121,
-0.6760475039,
-0.495796293,
0.4818454981,
-0.7592250109,
-0.1465390623,
0.1158192009,
-0.5996289849,
-0.5127602816,
-0.4256930649,
0.3353690803,
-0.1232440844,
-0.5162283182,
-0.0763360411,
-0.3618137538,
-0.2242093235,
-0.1137333587,
-1.0161342621,
0.1127838567,
0.594832778,
0.6581093669,
-0.1273763627,
0.0939833745,
0.3474654853,
-0.2241299152,
-0.10288582,
0.9182245731,
-0.5894188285,
-0.2369459271,
-0.2304718494,
-0.1699847132,
-0.3920302391,
-0.5813687444,
0.265272826,
-0.5580307245,
0.1188259348,
-0.2234096974,
-0.6949945688,
-0.3436309993,
0.2857957482,
-0.7819435596,
1.1793551445,
0.1193475053,
-0.7971072793,
0.2817373574,
-1.0734211206,
-0.1728985012,
-0.1069747433,
0.0365775749,
-0.6093568802,
0.4666956067,
0.1566634029,
0.4249492586,
-0.3520254195,
0.08577618,
-0.0179090928,
-0.0409490615,
0.0788457543,
-0.0822043344,
0.3914197087,
0.7281053066,
-0.3857371211,
0.3917249143,
-0.8522502184,
0.3286157548,
0.120730646,
-0.0379455462,
-0.6047459245,
0.1157185733,
0.028304277,
0.0672559217,
0.0862887949,
-0.7229322791,
-0.0604259707,
-0.0025838544,
0.6258093715,
0.4665240049,
0.3121109903,
0.2531194687,
-0.011545795,
0.6376250386,
-0.185942784,
0.1065355763,
-0.2488489002,
-0.2424738705,
-0.3829425573,
0.3455456197,
0.4190123677,
0.4658226967,
-0.6153507829,
0.4088897407,
-0.1109264418,
-0.8402277231,
-0.6616844535,
0.2937899828,
0.3873020411,
0.9475800991,
0.0655215085,
-0.1618847996,
-0.40710783,
-0.6612565517,
-0.6195812225,
-0.2337962538,
0.1187288836,
1.03482759,
0.6208888292,
-0.1394160986,
1.22846663,
-0.5458216667,
0.0118536698,
-0.0857376084,
-0.0093269208,
0.2428760082,
0.3615649045,
0.5636617541,
-1.0184006691,
-0.7350836992,
0.2187600881,
-0.8017033339,
-0.2672547996,
-0.2086708099,
0.0838638321,
-0.2944224179,
0.289712429,
-0.4215100408,
0.3661259413,
0.364434123,
-0.4646920562,
0.6698872447,
0.0606891289,
0.2388077229,
-0.7665687203,
0.326716274,
0.3601065874,
0.3373582065,
-0.3310415149,
-0.0872494206,
0.2066038698,
-0.573928237,
-0.2904427946,
0.5242635012,
-0.502248168,
-0.0919937789,
-0.2295304388,
-0.0713314041,
0.2870068848,
0.2218271345,
-0.0921525136,
0.7044497728,
0.1179024801,
-0.5135726333,
0.7504950166,
0.0315300748,
-0.6279970407,
-0.1137885749,
-0.5295035243,
0.2436822355,
0.1676789373,
0.1348454952,
-1.1150532961,
-0.2603468597,
0.2179203033,
-0.2806415558,
0.1552477479,
0.192827493,
-0.2433338612,
-0.6412534714,
-0.5586304069,
-0.1706632078,
0.2107223272,
-0.4735834002,
0.6695060134,
0.6635386348,
-0.0353885107,
-0.1232829615,
-0.0404001474,
-0.1664926559,
-0.4628849328,
-0.4527528584,
0.2199661136,
0.1692524999,
-0.6176167727,
0.2176865637,
-0.1995234191,
0.1270493865,
0.2821725607,
0.373875469,
0.0545851141,
-0.0615397282,
0.494964242,
-0.4072206616,
-0.2222905308,
0.2417065352,
0.1422765851,
0.2930440605,
-0.1606353074,
-0.1190791056,
-0.601354301,
0.3429925442,
0.5216356516,
-0.0478426702,
0.1455782652,
0.5605297685,
-0.2462160438,
0.0668508932,
-0.6694278121,
-0.2818046212,
-0.4758833945,
0.3556998074,
-0.2141118646,
-0.2897058129,
0.4014515579,
-0.5398611426,
0.1704000831,
0.6409699917,
0.5128291845,
-0.2766861916,
1.0840984583,
0.708437264,
-0.2345359921,
1.0165873766,
-0.4926470816,
0.2234588414,
-1.0440717936,
-0.5235917568,
-0.8392254114,
-0.5350496769,
-0.2909757793,
0.2411145568,
0.2270709574,
0.1059668437,
0.1028344333,
0.3786750734,
-0.7849069834,
0.3127464652,
0.1526400149,
0.0514867902,
-0.3093178272,
0.3747310936,
-0.1061344594,
0.0122161964,
-0.4833180308,
-0.4543637633,
1.098331213,
0.3048739731,
0.7671868205,
-0.1399339437,
0.4557539523,
0.4963569641,
0.4929746687,
-0.8649898171,
0.331523329,
-0.0078081232,
-0.481158942,
-0.113376908,
-0.6619384885,
-0.8192142248,
0.3445611894,
-0.153879717,
-0.7398072481,
0.1230536252,
0.3098608553,
-0.5378318429,
0.3043620586,
-1.4541461468,
0.8397667408,
-0.6344197989,
-0.7039044499,
-0.2051666677,
-0.2409882843,
0.0922092423,
0.1086188257,
0.197241649,
-0.3098497689,
0.4898850322,
0.9704425931,
-0.8263517022,
0.3791460991,
-0.4476565421,
-0.1930446476,
0.7224928141,
-0.4117043018,
0.5384577513,
-0.1838572919,
-0.4237967134,
0.2380520552,
-0.361807704,
-0.1325522065,
-0.7584636807,
0.9232884645,
-0.5828663111,
-0.5431417823,
-0.328389585,
-0.1508499831,
-0.3366324008,
-0.0311275031,
0.3308980763,
0.0519827791,
0.167721644,
0.0667831823,
0.190120697,
0.0603523292,
0.8657544255,
0.440613538,
-0.1735637635,
-0.2449472547,
1.0773521662,
0.0918973908,
-0.2614763975,
0.0341543481,
0.6883356571,
-0.4028170407,
-0.3648417592,
-0.5892585516,
-0.2622258961,
-0.2075513601,
-0.1737556309,
-0.5168854594,
0.1034273133,
-0.1981774718,
0.2286498249,
-0.2652717531,
-0.3162461519,
-0.3926921189,
-0.2780886292,
0.4825198948,
0.6837292314,
-0.0179906189,
0.0910858959,
-0.843621552,
0.3850845397,
0.1838628054,
0.1187570244,
0.4162509739,
0.2828288078,
-0.5437653065,
-0.187633425,
-0.6733475327,
-0.8883633018,
0.3170627654,
0.266269505,
0.3068191707,
0.5944544673,
0.063274622,
0.648842752,
-0.223508209,
1.1800919771,
0.629237175,
-0.7152166963,
0.7070343494,
0.2683102787,
0.1169849783,
0.5789461136,
0.6315743923,
-0.2384397984,
0.4070036709,
-0.5429790616,
-1.1406680346,
0.5253919363,
0.1437673867,
0.2375989109,
0.1384224743,
0.6199482679,
0.2107108831,
0.4130043089,
-0.4358549714,
0.0190548543,
-0.3193250597,
-0.0689877048,
0.057565894,
-0.117758505,
0.2847183943,
-0.4748543203,
0.6803641319,
-0.0523044728,
0.0545591973,
0.0767024979,
-0.0019004539,
-0.3106124401,
0.0809871331,
0.2933073342,
0.6500248909,
-0.4055109322,
-0.0094169918,
-0.1034145802,
-0.7882406712,
0.1025974005,
-0.1349155903,
-0.2708578408,
0.2386848032,
0.2819493413,
0.7955465317,
-0.1080449596,
-0.5051842928,
0.0949117616,
-0.2812503576,
0.2016644627,
-0.363427639,
0.3571171761,
-0.2055997401,
0.025577778,
0.333019644,
0.4344811141,
0.2956932783,
-0.7589123845,
0.0282662027,
0.5339278579,
-0.6785634756,
-0.5737637281,
0.4282628,
0.5802022219,
-0.5691185594,
0.5647642612,
0.0160444696,
-0.7275769711,
0.9005451798,
0.3541433513,
1.0320104361,
-0.0497020073,
0.0946998373,
0.4971525371,
-0.0967700407,
0.2105334997,
0.6589441299,
-0.645206809,
-0.4291487336,
-0.0324781537,
-0.4850029945,
-0.4212187827,
0.0348453373,
-0.8186363578,
-0.0124205155,
-0.1151805222,
-0.6938530803,
0.2823101282,
0.5654483438,
-0.521268785,
0.1711733341,
0.0854657069,
0.7297970057,
-0.9141776562,
0.4677808881,
0.8546215296,
-0.3342405856,
-0.9810627103,
-0.007016527,
-0.0202423204,
-0.4011775553,
0.6124424934,
0.0454988368,
-0.2719525993,
-0.2047602683,
-0.5674965382,
-0.5660069585,
0.9218546152,
0.1340748817,
-0.9129471183,
0.2215216905,
-0.2456661016,
0.46511814,
-0.4192689955,
0.6503430009,
0.327432096,
0.4191224873,
-0.1394892782,
-0.7781838775,
-0.1580829769,
-0.7259572148,
-0.0973012373,
0.2686134577,
-0.8431055546,
0.6364308596,
-0.2285054624,
-0.0759203061,
-0.2755403221,
0.3171870112,
0.0037962396,
1.0405570269,
0.4747229218,
0.3620562553,
0.6994698644,
0.2019043863,
1.0713914633,
-0.7562019825,
0.7900168896,
0.6469442844,
-0.535584569,
0.8763035536,
0.6751644015,
-0.2462245822,
0.4005030394,
0.7412836552,
-0.0835368633,
0.8073428869,
0.5446428061,
0.0222253464,
0.1342003793,
-0.2417830378,
-0.6247212887,
0.4223330319,
0.5389595628,
-0.5277541876,
-0.1059313044,
0.234501034,
-0.1249791831,
-0.0456103608,
-0.3441863954,
1.0219849348,
0.190166831,
-0.7611845136,
0.4902259409,
-0.0735385045,
0.5854414701,
-0.6613813639,
-0.2769057155,
-0.0953667983,
0.3047814667,
-0.6529935002,
-0.3969318569,
0.290994525,
0.3000953496,
-0.3980086446,
-0.4285149574,
0.9854900241,
0.0972753018,
-0.4616581798,
0.1969680786,
0.28673774,
0.2417505682,
-0.2281333953,
-0.921681881,
0.2467701435,
0.2732467353,
-0.434692353,
0.0727722943,
0.1730720103,
-0.0701208934,
0.305714637,
0.6647326946,
0.1020834967,
-0.2564600706,
-0.1594038606,
0.817086339,
-0.6541252732,
-0.6282202005,
-0.8203673363,
0.1398237646,
-0.3561901748,
-0.5731393695,
1.0814017057,
0.6577779651,
0.4423711002,
-0.0753569379,
0.7814770937,
-0.0230932366,
0.323743999,
-0.6230879426,
1.0479515791,
-0.4940390587,
0.605178237,
-0.3575963974,
-1.0165182352,
0.282581985,
0.6387602091,
-0.5329280496,
0.013857495,
0.506857872,
0.399933517,
-0.0744773373,
0.384637922,
-0.1325818002,
-0.0775824934,
0.2622169256,
0.4306333661,
0.7774244547,
-0.5430480838,
0.1818187684,
-0.4738515019,
-0.1134077236,
-0.5409224033,
-0.8505179882,
-0.4462769926,
-0.4445776045,
-0.7239997387,
-0.4241386652,
-0.1649032533,
0.806278646,
0.8058633208,
-0.9651576877,
-0.2930696607,
-0.0898000598,
0.230004862,
-0.3584055603,
-0.294110477,
0.8492190242,
0.0386079997,
-0.1961511075,
0.2456507534,
-0.007033797,
-0.4273432493,
-0.2191400975,
0.0949146822,
0.1036113277,
-0.0034840286,
0.452293843,
0.5284414291,
-0.3816820085,
-0.2512596548,
-0.1169165,
0.1581875086,
0.0233963318,
1.0158727169,
-0.8864911199,
0.8019590378,
0.5989191532,
0.3297748268,
0.5275682211,
0.2100178301,
0.0787161365,
-0.6859701276,
-0.1369280517,
0.259831816,
0.3615398109,
0.2200140655,
-0.5356655121,
0.3939744234,
0.1700255424,
-0.4665545523,
-0.6945635676,
0.0404147431,
-0.6661511064,
-0.1364914626,
1.0920932293,
-0.2107443064,
-0.4858501256,
0.0072210832,
-0.3208876252,
-0.2048392147,
-0.5625656247,
1.3443803787,
0.6486034989,
-0.7855664492,
0.0478185602,
-0.5340202451,
0.3611173928,
0.227244094,
-0.787887156,
-0.1060621589,
0.2767559886,
0.2541438043,
0.6159874797,
0.3354842961,
0.1015911028,
-0.0051508294,
0.1460853815,
0.0587619245,
-0.3292516172,
-0.1237161085,
-0.3284555972,
0.4484083354,
-0.4761162698,
-0.421420157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12809v1 | Can Voice Assistants Sound Cute? Towards a Model of Kawaii Vocalics | 2023-04-22T01:47:19 | 2023-04-22T01:47:19 | Katie Seaborn, Somang Nam, Julia Keckeis, Tatsuya Itagaki | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SD | The Japanese notion of "kawaii" or expressions of cuteness, vulnerability,
and/or charm is a global cultural export. Work has explored kawaii-ness as a
design feature and factor of user experience in the visual appearance,
nonverbal behaviour, and sound of robots and virtual characters. In this
initial work, we consider whether voices can be kawaii by exploring the vocal
qualities of voice assistant speech, i.e., kawaii vocalics. Drawing from an
age-inclusive model of kawaii, we ran a user perceptions study on the
kawaii-ness of younger- and older-sounding Japanese computer voices. We found
that kawaii-ness intersected with perceptions of gender and age, i.e., gender
ambiguous and girlish, as well as VA features, i.e., fluency and artificiality.
We propose an initial model of kawaii vocalics to be validated through the
identification and study of vocal qualities, cognitive appraisals, behavioural
responses, and affective reports. | [
-0.5776175261,
-0.7351750731,
0.5487481356,
0.2336971313,
-0.0406892262,
-0.0042168372,
0.023652859,
-1.0574054718,
0.7986864448,
0.2445675135,
-0.9710211158,
0.0573358834,
-0.2373706102,
0.3824201822,
-0.0250300299,
0.6178981066,
0.7181171179,
0.0350212492,
-0.0228586923,
0.109124288,
-0.7300684452,
-0.5629895926,
-0.7624039054,
-0.1448446363,
0.8239661455,
0.5214551687,
1.0749430656,
-0.0704982057,
0.115290314,
0.2626333237,
-0.3766719103,
0.1223706827,
-0.1453797221,
0.0478973016,
0.2543947995,
-0.9183846712,
-0.5668866038,
0.1162736714,
0.3542986214,
0.6450847387,
0.1793157607,
-0.1479799598,
0.0942335725,
0.5536149144,
-0.2585864067,
0.1104684472,
-0.406005919,
0.3590704799,
-0.0593037456,
-0.020669112,
-0.2785921991,
-0.2755130529,
0.223659277,
-0.7982642651,
-0.0169535801,
-0.3578349948,
0.8843351603,
0.0040357318,
-0.2707774043,
-0.577072978,
-0.9174271822,
0.6700829268,
-0.8307908177,
0.2714805007,
0.3724187613,
0.3423517048,
-0.3817045093,
-0.0970536992,
-0.7604118586,
-0.3933922946,
-0.0348358117,
0.1172163263,
-0.1349846721,
-0.0702072009,
0.1351212859,
0.398747772,
-0.5839095712,
0.3614751399,
-0.0520025603,
-0.0724437013,
0.8666354418,
-0.178312555,
1.0422621965,
-0.2859297991,
-0.090436779,
-0.2284452766,
-0.0672322512,
0.2092167288,
0.6760855317,
0.8627949953,
-0.4206260145,
0.346540451,
-0.1156222895,
0.1035938188,
0.0769441202,
-0.4755694866,
0.3636892736,
-0.1726414412,
0.1241055802,
0.201672554,
0.765892148,
-0.0572624654,
0.6446911097,
-0.1791856587,
-0.0265006572,
0.2493822277,
0.460393846,
-0.4757186174,
-0.2685261369,
0.0442629158,
-0.630243957,
-0.675632596,
-0.0387167819,
-0.8202419877,
-0.5294123888,
-0.309389323,
0.6467139721,
-0.0259124693,
-0.6709058285,
-0.3386581838,
-0.0100427037,
0.0858433098,
0.2444785535,
-1.1282221079,
0.4107821882,
0.3745664358,
0.6124010086,
0.196366623,
-0.3776049614,
-0.0611074232,
-0.2980238199,
-0.3851888776,
0.5969842672,
-0.7413198948,
-1.3088709116,
-0.4467644095,
0.0987756923,
-0.265994072,
-0.5168603659,
0.4840075672,
-0.0593070053,
0.3208337128,
-0.2062909454,
-0.2259249687,
0.0057149236,
-0.430580765,
-0.8855127096,
0.4705219269,
-0.0430512726,
-0.4353177249,
0.3880097866,
-0.8976085782,
-0.6125462055,
-0.0119355023,
-0.1228181347,
-0.5995686054,
0.4527386725,
0.2139573246,
0.1472364217,
0.016929822,
0.0102460701,
-0.4604036808,
-0.3262838125,
0.6603976488,
-0.544942677,
0.773106873,
0.4555288255,
-0.2255079746,
0.1563954502,
-0.5506746173,
0.1622930914,
0.4409965873,
0.1244785488,
-0.2069995254,
-0.257712841,
0.190352425,
-0.0778326988,
0.4118109643,
-0.4380097091,
0.2847356796,
-0.4293493629,
0.464576453,
0.25402385,
-0.0172729734,
0.2425787002,
-0.4090252817,
0.5739136338,
-0.013526639,
0.7983078361,
-0.0288162529,
-1.0844169855,
-0.4575164914,
-0.2247781903,
0.0652789325,
0.3932950795,
-0.3712873757,
0.5303058028,
0.0052096988,
-0.7321460843,
-0.5774108171,
-0.0553545766,
0.1449074745,
0.1956798732,
-0.1754539311,
-0.3894645274,
-0.4264696538,
-1.0715639591,
-0.150887996,
-0.8667570353,
-0.2702919841,
0.5543574691,
0.1644863337,
-0.214008823,
0.6487293839,
-0.0870533139,
-0.1768602431,
-0.1656787843,
0.4137902558,
0.1943365633,
0.3911867142,
0.5878147483,
-1.2714490891,
0.0882252902,
0.1377544701,
-0.584620893,
-0.2431276292,
-0.0104644895,
0.0798842609,
-0.020497499,
-0.1017540768,
-0.8873392344,
0.3249289095,
0.1548087001,
-0.3138997257,
0.4749089479,
0.0154273603,
0.7520795465,
-1.085614562,
0.3890472949,
-0.0900298655,
0.0776918754,
-0.7992861271,
0.2033669651,
-0.2776244581,
-0.8229598403,
-0.449342519,
0.4042652845,
-0.336920023,
-0.3791552186,
-0.5688883662,
0.1155693755,
0.1917272657,
0.403616339,
0.1013137177,
0.8943367004,
0.3661395311,
-0.4879919291,
-0.0187033769,
0.2598561049,
0.1849641055,
0.7900518179,
-0.6253764629,
0.3563591838,
0.1079197899,
0.1318137646,
-1.0562506914,
-0.4553548098,
0.1063342094,
-0.9770149589,
0.1879666597,
-0.1147265658,
-0.4056223035,
-0.3650825024,
0.0338482298,
0.3688324988,
0.6973579526,
-0.4223582149,
0.7385803461,
0.7266152501,
-0.5043413639,
0.1430304945,
-0.5138601661,
0.1275041401,
-0.5792264342,
-0.4454524815,
-0.0604886301,
-0.1051799878,
0.0309987478,
-0.3505742848,
0.0777379945,
-0.5342798233,
0.4668693244,
0.3104325235,
0.3728090525,
-0.1991592944,
-0.4123554826,
-0.1132492721,
0.0456003733,
0.1028736681,
0.2486661971,
0.1145664155,
-0.2985358834,
-0.2164346874,
-0.9416931272,
0.4163856208,
1.079375267,
0.0922194645,
0.151376158,
0.7356368899,
-0.5673905015,
0.2889404893,
-0.1895856261,
-0.2452117801,
-0.4100233316,
-0.0587891564,
-0.6157816052,
-0.5865214467,
0.8142371178,
-0.1316715628,
-0.1065705791,
0.4568443,
0.1228866428,
-0.1767951548,
1.5461601019,
0.8055471778,
-0.3155160546,
0.4602700472,
0.1150160655,
0.2402413189,
-0.5947638154,
-0.3425335884,
-0.8636619449,
-0.3626542091,
-0.9124653935,
0.0566162542,
0.4606438279,
-0.0821202546,
0.1143167391,
0.2520182133,
-0.3838364184,
0.2450205237,
0.3506851494,
0.088685967,
-0.1562591344,
-0.3559531868,
0.222799167,
-0.0670438558,
-0.5399426222,
-0.5100790262,
0.3934622705,
0.5461140275,
0.5027537346,
0.5453148484,
0.5690724254,
0.5038450956,
-0.3432205617,
-0.984203577,
0.610004425,
-0.3545737267,
-0.5079759955,
-0.4257162511,
-0.3982153833,
-0.925198257,
-0.1635300964,
-0.3503432572,
-1.3604381084,
0.4814280868,
0.1713842005,
-0.388204515,
0.1476607323,
-0.869922936,
0.783767879,
-0.1952740401,
-0.0581538081,
-0.1493659168,
-0.8132451773,
0.3538707197,
0.0508130454,
0.4153525829,
-0.1740440279,
0.1529462487,
0.4917431176,
-0.3553186953,
0.962592423,
-0.3209291697,
-0.2423222363,
0.3418626785,
0.1787535101,
0.0151836351,
-0.248385042,
-0.0056684697,
0.2807287276,
0.2450644374,
-0.2322959304,
-1.1265534163,
0.8885608315,
-1.0477888584,
-0.3250703812,
0.005899556,
-0.309797287,
-0.460083276,
0.1758172065,
-0.0884256065,
0.4122954905,
-0.200806126,
-0.2188028842,
0.5436995625,
-0.2698729038,
0.0010458911,
0.2824073434,
-0.4199052453,
-0.1341924965,
1.1166216135,
-0.0979115739,
0.3108717501,
0.3535045683,
0.798081696,
-0.564221561,
0.092182681,
-0.6368611455,
0.2084266394,
-0.4512499273,
0.436711967,
-0.2209168524,
-0.3595489562,
-0.3037545383,
0.0195985623,
-0.4321354032,
-0.5012402534,
-0.4646285772,
0.4703950882,
0.3968676925,
1.0830919743,
-0.0269858185,
0.0879513323,
-0.4814557135,
0.7208149433,
0.5914985538,
0.3002753854,
0.1547783911,
-0.311568886,
0.0609492771,
0.154644087,
-0.0936447605,
-0.7571726441,
0.2892611921,
0.2334289253,
0.5212774277,
0.3807634413,
-0.0705613643,
0.6354433894,
-0.2000176758,
1.2089706659,
0.1754900515,
-0.7771425843,
1.0059136152,
-0.3919724822,
0.4591100812,
0.5782361627,
0.2630294561,
-0.2395552099,
-0.4015423954,
-0.8603479862,
-0.5483029485,
0.3349949718,
0.5769459009,
0.2372105718,
0.1645796746,
0.3144801259,
0.2924457192,
0.3496663868,
-0.4200854599,
-0.1661064476,
-0.271532625,
-0.1358143687,
0.0721346363,
-0.0730870515,
0.3323075771,
0.0868896469,
0.5912695527,
-0.2246906012,
0.4246111214,
0.1754840016,
0.2567533255,
-0.2016305476,
0.4573022723,
0.3593869805,
0.170622766,
-0.1236700341,
-0.1076312959,
-0.0641981512,
-0.5895704627,
0.2009697556,
-0.1772966087,
-0.1164478213,
0.1813612878,
-0.0702786818,
0.826220572,
0.6152893305,
-0.5669955611,
0.3022125363,
-0.514241755,
0.3408530354,
-0.191470623,
0.2666737139,
-0.108341381,
0.0115203252,
0.1177837402,
0.0472886674,
0.6274232864,
-0.9710814953,
-0.0621627085,
0.4248566926,
-0.2323875576,
-0.4618051648,
0.9889775515,
0.3575432301,
-0.5631545186,
0.1998501718,
0.2162927836,
-0.3634642363,
0.5942217708,
0.3933136761,
1.1496344805,
-0.469907254,
0.0869909748,
0.2436178178,
0.0582924373,
0.3897200525,
0.4632959664,
-0.3889716566,
-0.3924501538,
0.201308921,
-0.4775009453,
-0.7721387744,
0.3036004901,
-0.9594727755,
0.2523062229,
-0.3225203753,
-0.6973038912,
0.4734851122,
0.0168641321,
-0.6121422052,
0.512242794,
0.6547693014,
0.2964887023,
-1.0631797314,
0.4392870367,
0.8007749319,
-0.2566610575,
-0.8665691018,
0.2949037552,
0.261777997,
-0.6201752424,
0.1862617582,
0.3621564507,
-0.4034069777,
-0.2855123281,
-0.2970092595,
-0.7365241647,
0.5347833037,
0.0564804077,
-0.580743432,
-0.1799228042,
0.2077955157,
0.5658953786,
-0.1381643713,
0.4821506441,
0.4045734107,
0.2533318996,
0.0704299137,
-1.4940234423,
-0.4621639252,
-1.0348832607,
0.3874758482,
-0.2099349052,
-0.6964795589,
0.4780246019,
-0.3359280825,
-0.2931358814,
0.9086422324,
0.6740508676,
0.3151644468,
0.4013378918,
0.9583545327,
0.0596887022,
0.7983817458,
0.1519826204,
0.9027436972,
-0.1365416795,
-0.3174024522,
0.8118630052,
-0.2850530148,
0.8333317041,
0.3761389852,
-0.2801862657,
0.386439532,
0.4717930853,
0.3895038962,
0.263931334,
-0.0062384857,
-0.375084132,
-0.0402585603,
-0.7147485614,
-0.0267818943,
0.6202500463,
0.3934148848,
0.0211924743,
0.4417797923,
0.501308918,
-0.0935677886,
0.1764963418,
-0.0968564972,
1.0704798698,
0.1316025853,
-0.2625856996,
0.3681245148,
-0.5528752208,
0.5226745605,
-0.7273163199,
-0.0683577731,
0.1486143768,
-0.473564297,
-0.1392658204,
-0.8524152637,
-0.004356768,
0.1569178253,
-0.2658788562,
0.2527017891,
0.8325399756,
0.0097977314,
-0.5568546653,
0.1433267444,
0.3192329705,
0.6511682272,
0.3471933007,
-0.5825112462,
0.38117823,
-0.2515558004,
0.2182945758,
0.267567426,
0.4231630564,
-0.0269607808,
0.6393464208,
0.4643600583,
0.2316130996,
-0.2148398161,
0.6881861091,
0.4341367483,
-0.2441487461,
-1.0307247639,
-0.4552518725,
0.6036997437,
0.170416832,
-0.3884672225,
0.4884661734,
0.2403793931,
0.4196436107,
-0.1988050789,
0.8644167781,
0.1048887447,
0.5862951875,
-0.4450769424,
0.8900993466,
-0.7784464359,
-0.1294859797,
-0.8494976163,
-0.6210995913,
0.1080360264,
0.7520619631,
0.0576076508,
0.4223765135,
-0.0016542211,
0.7280116081,
-0.2786142826,
0.8712894917,
0.6560671329,
0.1704303771,
0.2004503012,
0.4158346057,
1.1119465828,
-0.2749293149,
-0.1658546627,
-0.6037501693,
-0.1822471768,
-0.1064344943,
-0.5813865662,
-0.5985661745,
-0.6971116066,
-0.4534690678,
0.0808000416,
-0.107159771,
0.7359926701,
0.8102777004,
-0.5703734159,
-0.260683924,
0.0473454744,
-0.0797718614,
-0.126580894,
-0.3117007315,
-0.1831710786,
-0.0061582606,
-0.796404779,
0.8320041895,
-0.1494550109,
0.5491799116,
-0.5503999591,
0.0053855143,
0.3689520061,
0.2825111449,
0.5292320848,
0.6108792424,
-0.8703704476,
-0.3241879642,
-0.2038663924,
0.2711020112,
-0.0437345393,
0.6207464933,
-0.643795073,
0.7468703389,
-0.0463941172,
0.1316176653,
-0.2195728123,
-0.0015079138,
0.614449501,
-0.5531535745,
0.2990586758,
0.244355455,
0.1964585036,
0.4001868367,
-0.7219295502,
0.0274945032,
0.1192628071,
-0.4536601007,
-0.8600187302,
0.1601349562,
-1.1696032286,
0.0474007875,
0.6305740476,
0.0808090046,
-0.4518133402,
0.2341200858,
-0.5611613989,
0.2709565163,
-0.3865901232,
0.7391351461,
0.3000134528,
-0.2504446805,
-0.1543867737,
-0.5361174941,
0.2066459507,
0.2645736337,
-0.8982246518,
-0.2019007355,
0.256688714,
0.0031101152,
0.4777712822,
0.4542686939,
-0.3005379438,
0.653522253,
0.2435169816,
0.0087461285,
0.2241239846,
-0.7548359036,
-0.3562407792,
-0.0537383631,
0.5989948511,
-0.2769643962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11276v1 | The Role of AI in Human-AI Creative Writing for Hong Kong Secondary Students | 2023-04-21T23:50:09 | 2023-04-21T23:50:09 | Hengky Susanto, David James Woo, Kai Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent advancement in Natural Language Processing (NLP) capability has
led to the development of language models (e.g., ChatGPT) that is capable of
generating human-like language. In this study, we explore how language models
can be utilized to help the ideation aspect of creative writing. Our empirical
findings show that language models play different roles in helping student
writers to be more creative, such as the role of a collaborator, a provocateur,
etc | [
-0.2125783116,
-0.9900510311,
0.5175552964,
0.1651668102,
0.1142769009,
0.3803678751,
-0.1718934178,
-0.6897966266,
-0.0536660142,
0.6186330914,
-0.4920843244,
-0.0732814297,
-0.1103576794,
0.1479064673,
-0.1600250751,
0.7850229144,
-0.2218743861,
-0.0634793341,
-0.1858625859,
0.1701510251,
-0.6985244155,
-0.5546692014,
-1.2508065701,
-0.1509976685,
0.5617543459,
0.4794897735,
0.9569362998,
0.3133815229,
0.6981295943,
0.3730647564,
0.3179899156,
-0.0291016232,
-0.0255081821,
0.0459791869,
-0.1330901235,
-0.7029726505,
-0.4102817476,
0.3681047559,
0.5759221315,
0.7350521684,
-0.2357943803,
-0.1354314834,
-0.0355720185,
0.7817800045,
-0.1035229266,
0.1515453607,
-0.3302723169,
0.2257264107,
-0.1947666109,
0.079580009,
-0.4158222079,
-0.45648247,
0.3661248386,
-0.778192997,
0.2653686404,
-0.0259897877,
0.7115770578,
0.1305903792,
-0.0515752621,
-0.7357706428,
-0.8397602439,
0.4533642232,
-1.2078814507,
-0.0596295521,
0.2857870162,
0.3647181094,
-0.2358019352,
-0.9412097335,
-1.1356449127,
-0.3256548047,
0.0359625891,
0.3743066192,
0.176609084,
0.3060213625,
0.1981708407,
0.2777229846,
-0.6621251702,
0.2443210483,
-0.4017311335,
0.1750493944,
0.86585778,
0.2565206885,
1.0484890938,
-0.2479291856,
-0.1377969533,
-0.0535886548,
-0.5908900499,
0.4603359699,
0.7688897252,
0.247124508,
-0.1015055701,
0.6787648797,
0.2675875425,
0.5433133245,
-0.4625683129,
0.0449418314,
-0.3307012022,
-0.2400279492,
-0.0977076069,
-0.0246876199,
0.7353242636,
0.2478921413,
0.7192493677,
-0.0948739946,
-0.0208766144,
0.2947102785,
0.2651627958,
-0.6089641452,
-0.4252263308,
-0.0120164389,
-0.4616972804,
-0.4349752367,
0.3195800185,
-0.0998999551,
-0.4173760116,
-0.3686284423,
0.1978356391,
-0.2896142304,
-0.4365687072,
0.35451895,
-0.5883923769,
0.1831472665,
0.1772271246,
-1.1479219198,
0.3644244671,
0.5155329108,
0.4717779756,
0.0093574878,
-0.6986410022,
0.2472654581,
0.2423060536,
-0.494166255,
0.9203370214,
-0.5474686027,
-0.3351507783,
-0.2050511837,
-0.3897707164,
-0.2815603912,
-0.4425996244,
0.7223832011,
-0.1378102303,
0.5597701669,
-0.0024250657,
-0.4467757046,
-0.3918434381,
-0.0804759637,
-0.7685366273,
0.7375918627,
0.240906015,
-0.7377451658,
0.1125534102,
-0.8531870246,
-0.4916128814,
0.5068708658,
-0.343465358,
-0.3485675752,
0.1805524677,
0.1906660348,
0.3408832848,
-0.3204154372,
0.5102779269,
-0.0258552488,
-0.4315382242,
0.7743537426,
-0.592875421,
1.0760344267,
0.0630914196,
-0.1670637578,
0.104939878,
-0.4295755923,
-0.0064221309,
0.3752951324,
-0.6590313911,
-0.0227169693,
-0.0215040762,
0.5653322339,
0.2728378475,
-0.0427764282,
-0.4278976023,
0.567825377,
-0.3621703684,
0.7318994999,
0.5658879876,
-0.1044387147,
0.2842282653,
-0.8850637078,
0.8189928532,
-0.4358398914,
-0.3741242588,
-0.1279277205,
-1.0358692408,
-0.5719542503,
-0.1485270858,
0.1079567671,
0.6838649511,
-0.7414503694,
0.158745721,
0.3566973209,
-0.7182997465,
-1.2022147179,
0.3407752812,
0.1650813818,
0.4753319919,
-0.1869178563,
0.000810184,
-0.8731836677,
-0.8744844794,
-0.6216123104,
-0.7121207714,
-0.0468299091,
0.329174608,
0.1498567462,
-0.410805285,
1.1013801098,
-0.4738948941,
-0.2329999655,
-1.0660752058,
0.5215262175,
0.0546313412,
0.58822155,
0.6366549134,
-1.0494039059,
-0.9679173827,
-0.3278881013,
-0.7086327672,
-0.5725152493,
-0.6595628858,
-0.1847175807,
0.2656770647,
0.3798274696,
-1.1169409752,
0.7138312459,
0.1381725967,
-0.4285391867,
0.8829170465,
-0.0915104747,
0.0343832262,
-1.085544467,
0.0964805633,
-0.1957273334,
0.1244276315,
-0.6835027337,
0.2000268251,
-0.2491778135,
-0.4599529505,
-0.3185204268,
0.5634820461,
-0.17572321,
0.4540419281,
-0.5828240514,
0.3025121391,
0.1900372356,
0.3651357889,
0.473623246,
0.6231669188,
0.5354983211,
-0.1199509054,
0.350260973,
0.0485501513,
-0.3206288218,
0.1002797559,
-0.7785736918,
0.3083212674,
-0.2540427148,
0.2167509943,
-1.1691244841,
-0.2923270762,
-0.0754786879,
-0.5874752998,
0.0768374428,
0.1985545605,
-0.6439835429,
-0.6964952946,
-0.154888317,
0.1528655887,
0.3321892321,
-0.0290472712,
0.5416219831,
0.3660855889,
-0.7164144516,
-0.1138093323,
-0.7370222211,
0.3400010765,
-0.3702822924,
-0.8092828989,
0.4708966911,
-0.552855134,
-0.4612960815,
0.1066143811,
0.7543200254,
-0.135953173,
0.2885717154,
0.3708323538,
0.3231661022,
-0.3918737471,
-0.0351478979,
-0.458350867,
-0.0243991148,
-0.0174002144,
0.1413049996,
0.7383018732,
-0.219805032,
-0.218764931,
-0.8940226436,
0.6144345999,
0.4920150638,
-0.0361146517,
0.5270434618,
0.801525116,
-0.3277997375,
-0.2725340426,
-0.4013121128,
0.0116434265,
-0.5431508422,
0.3880721629,
-0.131378755,
-0.5329313874,
0.4861640334,
0.5160047412,
-0.0591617562,
0.2595681846,
0.4926589131,
-0.2881388664,
0.8654688001,
1.0566228628,
-0.1027647182,
0.5988470912,
-0.2468518019,
0.5689905882,
-0.7516840696,
0.1676312834,
-0.2005153149,
-0.4285360873,
-0.6086162329,
-0.0437685139,
-0.1722641438,
0.3231773376,
-0.1393312216,
0.4940710962,
-0.3637301922,
0.5155757666,
0.8963313103,
-0.4385303259,
-0.051016055,
-0.3752631247,
0.1601229906,
-0.2538609207,
-0.804962039,
-0.9860143661,
0.8329999447,
0.2369803488,
0.5520750284,
0.2118113637,
0.5637988448,
0.1614072025,
0.3282723129,
-0.6449201703,
0.7326830626,
-0.1109706983,
-0.4855109453,
-0.4625239074,
-0.0191642921,
-0.7153744698,
0.052291669,
-0.1473846734,
-0.5670645237,
-0.2672325969,
-0.2964400947,
-0.5118203759,
0.4376225471,
-0.9603357315,
0.8177812696,
-0.1549754888,
-0.1855996549,
-0.0019211581,
-0.2828543186,
0.024015544,
-0.0501945466,
0.0183478743,
-0.1225390583,
0.3665314913,
0.99889189,
-0.1183713078,
0.9760765433,
0.0703925267,
-0.02939016,
1.1700675488,
0.2521485984,
0.0792625397,
0.1473002136,
-0.1888578385,
-0.3340956271,
-0.2922994494,
-0.2032819092,
-0.516836226,
0.448877871,
-0.7926661968,
-0.9270737171,
-0.0326430351,
-1.1081947088,
0.2559043169,
0.2762088478,
0.1768116504,
0.1394254714,
-0.161675483,
0.0743299872,
-0.2476417869,
-0.3352766931,
0.9830892682,
0.5323033333,
-0.2234735936,
-0.1782565564,
0.7901912928,
0.2941389382,
0.2486263365,
0.1558849663,
0.4613521397,
-0.0913426429,
-0.3419057727,
-0.5160728097,
0.1877978146,
-0.6770046353,
0.2851303518,
-0.5301849842,
-0.4991524816,
-0.7834928632,
-0.8415071964,
-0.1009237245,
-0.7666845322,
-0.2512025237,
-0.1966118068,
-0.1264785826,
1.0304427147,
-0.0899098366,
0.6328186989,
-0.6030464768,
0.3032412231,
0.3293413222,
-0.0483028851,
0.3294616044,
-0.2297445983,
-0.202578187,
0.0372243412,
-0.6673605442,
-0.5460501313,
0.7614129782,
0.1696458459,
0.6728415489,
0.477109462,
-0.300527066,
0.4890643954,
-0.3945049942,
1.0612514019,
-0.0480353385,
-0.736794591,
0.6304258108,
-0.5159866214,
0.3346455097,
0.259927839,
0.1017539874,
-1.0293861628,
-0.6166440845,
-0.7079845071,
-0.7523695827,
0.4803844392,
0.2989172339,
0.1681241095,
-0.0306325667,
0.2898412943,
0.1535982788,
0.2451799065,
-1.2869188786,
0.1744065434,
0.0498998053,
-0.3758153319,
0.0506189317,
-0.15796417,
0.4704141319,
-0.2676668465,
0.4796909392,
0.0848433897,
0.139733687,
0.0418042131,
0.3056149483,
-0.3014945984,
0.2795724273,
0.3148371279,
0.554285109,
-0.119495295,
0.0074933777,
-0.2028065026,
-0.6594677567,
-0.0820844099,
-0.0548442155,
-0.3822338581,
-0.2987722158,
0.7861115336,
0.5195366144,
-0.1831074059,
-1.0514689684,
0.3253400624,
-0.1392737776,
0.1411875337,
-0.4916765392,
0.5691475868,
0.3421435654,
0.251763016,
0.3072158098,
0.2655797303,
0.1262257695,
-0.9728135467,
0.0384271257,
0.3498250842,
-0.2256494761,
-0.5205036402,
0.7777405381,
0.0540224686,
-0.9172220826,
0.9159315228,
0.0197332781,
-0.7072994113,
1.0027576685,
1.1664559841,
1.1494845152,
-0.0518647023,
0.5072066784,
0.0978966951,
0.1049032509,
0.1014071107,
0.6503705978,
0.1187970862,
-0.9711250067,
-0.1330095381,
-0.3500466645,
-0.3766301572,
-0.0434438251,
-0.3176969588,
0.3311514556,
-0.3406826556,
-0.1623238325,
0.2665214241,
0.1104604155,
-0.7248244286,
0.0974960625,
0.4636076689,
0.4691175222,
-0.6962324977,
0.8393244147,
1.1426018476,
-0.7526516914,
-0.8851324916,
-0.1399439722,
-0.0925433934,
-0.3731483221,
1.038408637,
0.479906708,
-0.1258235425,
0.1620798409,
-0.6956614256,
-0.3676405251,
0.9033729434,
-0.0122570908,
-0.2810944021,
-0.4580543935,
0.6614161134,
0.8093552589,
-0.7997716069,
0.0669220015,
0.2610764503,
0.2741017342,
-0.2102763802,
-0.7974479198,
-0.2791537642,
-0.6148451567,
-0.0987415314,
-0.2666977942,
-0.4728408158,
1.2959409952,
-0.6205173731,
-0.4888926148,
0.2576741874,
0.5737668872,
0.3362214267,
0.1553631425,
-0.0599546172,
0.612059474,
0.7668200135,
0.2011496276,
0.9000124931,
-0.1494728625,
-0.3432556689,
0.8629453182,
-0.1856203228,
0.9380458593,
0.3094226122,
-0.0413653217,
0.6343753934,
0.3327705264,
0.0696230009,
0.3405347466,
0.3059264123,
-0.20158346,
-0.0232977569,
-0.1640605628,
0.0632819682,
0.4334605336,
0.3328362107,
-0.2062038928,
0.2222563028,
0.1546946168,
-0.0715132281,
0.522418797,
-0.2588492632,
0.7931673527,
0.3298013508,
-0.6756119728,
-0.0090643167,
0.1462471336,
0.5587139726,
-0.222771734,
-0.1725077033,
0.082424134,
0.2677878141,
-0.0628517419,
-1.3555059433,
0.2919825613,
-0.2664092779,
-0.1958232075,
-0.2089781612,
0.8326608539,
-0.4430356026,
-0.723497808,
-0.0649867654,
0.568775773,
-0.0274832435,
0.0517766103,
-0.6384483576,
-0.2480354011,
-0.0136709576,
-0.1408312619,
-0.1711488664,
0.6018904448,
-0.2028416693,
0.9729173779,
0.6305499077,
0.5362743735,
-0.2244826257,
0.3668892384,
0.5725499392,
-0.9911723733,
-0.7704054117,
-0.9810343981,
0.5337179303,
0.10165108,
-0.6065328121,
0.6609026194,
0.4467717111,
0.8111453056,
-0.2392321527,
1.132193327,
-0.2302732319,
0.4263412058,
-0.2890598476,
1.2221894264,
0.1600911021,
0.2438523769,
-0.4630209208,
-0.8771851659,
-0.4334181845,
0.7107846737,
-0.3674918711,
-0.1756792217,
0.3419483602,
0.6206826568,
0.3178223073,
0.2852496207,
0.2186556458,
-0.205011934,
0.7909709215,
0.5281009078,
1.2096893787,
-0.2182702124,
-0.0646756813,
-0.3781627119,
-0.0088319127,
0.0427358411,
-0.635402143,
-1.2970196009,
-0.7373310328,
-0.2279172689,
0.2061745375,
-0.2835153043,
1.0061739683,
0.358525455,
-0.4634881318,
-0.5461006761,
-0.2466536462,
-0.1331824362,
-0.1282843351,
-0.2973763943,
0.5423113108,
-0.3492403924,
-0.7117392421,
0.1210315675,
0.2900622189,
0.5501218438,
-0.42235291,
0.0232278928,
-0.1928103268,
0.5293994546,
0.7170170546,
0.006033354,
-0.7370471358,
-0.0112722432,
-0.2156653106,
-0.3072578609,
-0.0330930315,
0.9957006574,
-0.6752200127,
0.4432718456,
0.536752224,
0.528072536,
-0.0317310579,
0.1244036555,
0.8943704963,
-0.2648269534,
0.443018198,
0.5926060081,
0.3279437721,
0.6793558002,
-0.4390846491,
0.4985095263,
0.299859941,
-0.7697159648,
-0.7574675679,
0.1875962764,
-0.5735832453,
-0.4836079776,
0.8124875426,
-0.0628968477,
-0.0710765421,
-0.0940353796,
-1.0577903986,
0.3573395908,
-0.056299001,
1.0229860544,
0.9411899447,
-0.4182561934,
-0.4459754229,
-0.9550891519,
0.7824662924,
0.1502212435,
-0.7510266304,
0.0692550838,
0.0325475819,
-0.2074724138,
0.0504347309,
0.7605232596,
0.3105578423,
0.112211585,
0.222747162,
0.2473358363,
-0.0214562062,
-0.375261873,
0.5569257736,
-0.0290958174,
0.3084833324,
0.4054879546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14415v1 | Generative AI Perceptions: A Survey to Measure the Perceptions of Faculty, Staff, and Students on Generative AI Tools in Academia | 2023-04-21T23:08:39 | 2023-04-21T23:08:39 | Sara Amani, Lance White, Trini Balart, Laksha Arora, Dr. Kristi J. Shryock, Dr. Kelly Brumbelow, Dr. Karan L. Watson | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | ChatGPT is a natural language processing tool that can engage in human-like
conversations and generate coherent and contextually relevant responses to
various prompts. ChatGPT is capable of understanding natural text that is input
by a user and generating appropriate responses in various forms. This tool
represents a major step in how humans are interacting with technology. This
paper specifically focuses on how ChatGPT is revolutionizing the realm of
engineering education and the relationship between technology, students, and
faculty and staff. Because this tool is quickly changing and improving with the
potential for even greater future capability, it is a critical time to collect
pertinent data. A survey was created to measure the effects of ChatGPT on
students, faculty, and staff. This survey is shared as a Texas A&M University
technical report to allow other universities and entities to use this survey
and measure the effects elsewhere. | [
-0.7861711383,
-1.1432948112,
0.3849852681,
0.0562668964,
-0.1212509573,
0.6580110192,
0.1416258663,
-0.501327157,
0.0872058645,
0.016112987,
-0.5040308237,
-0.1422106028,
-0.5062370896,
0.0577175766,
-0.843257606,
1.2439875603,
0.107915327,
0.0368624851,
-0.2416270524,
0.2547263801,
-0.5928159952,
-0.5011901259,
-1.1951768398,
-0.6863307953,
0.2433673739,
0.3277349472,
0.9306558967,
-0.0576893277,
0.7172111869,
0.2641388774,
0.1861829758,
-0.4189929068,
-0.4084544778,
0.113643609,
0.1901870817,
-0.5040736198,
-0.2493079752,
0.2862456441,
0.5141425729,
0.8251658678,
-0.2216423303,
0.2131174058,
0.477532059,
0.5626456141,
-0.1816417724,
0.2599227428,
-0.362585485,
0.5175310969,
-0.2790534198,
-0.0678299293,
-0.2949685752,
-0.6043746471,
0.4408136308,
-0.764044404,
0.5877494216,
0.0840163231,
0.7354205847,
0.2931452692,
-0.4163801074,
-0.0862201452,
-1.0137871504,
0.3125332594,
-0.0379575752,
0.4518931806,
0.1755566597,
0.5301964879,
-0.1217292249,
-0.7949331403,
-0.6854169965,
-0.2485231459,
-0.0280622002,
0.619849503,
-0.0412926711,
0.4005759954,
0.1585045457,
0.8187968731,
-0.8179656267,
-0.1390086263,
-0.6241827607,
-0.1696001887,
0.5072773099,
0.1400878578,
0.659342289,
0.0784101263,
-0.3634673655,
-0.2504613996,
-0.482298255,
-0.0867036134,
0.4585013092,
-0.3221025765,
-0.0111382734,
0.4402189553,
0.139657855,
0.5486321449,
-0.2426088005,
0.5674051046,
-0.0071166973,
-0.2353168577,
-0.4290338457,
-0.0622476526,
0.9165270329,
0.0587478317,
0.3224457204,
-0.1284710765,
-0.0430117324,
0.347545445,
0.59928298,
-0.6666941047,
-0.6028666496,
0.217759639,
-0.2886517644,
-0.3829678595,
0.2697927654,
-0.915219903,
-0.6047746539,
-0.3955245018,
0.1804611832,
-0.526030302,
-0.4122044146,
-0.1790634692,
-0.2725712359,
0.3818199039,
0.5461665392,
-0.8436638713,
0.0459632687,
0.6975410581,
0.9137145281,
-0.106659323,
-0.4203982353,
0.0391073823,
-0.2044858932,
-0.0861837417,
0.9129943848,
-0.6210804582,
-1.3905365467,
0.0249869302,
-0.4683153927,
-0.2181478441,
-0.6006031036,
0.4857292771,
-0.4243388772,
0.4859827459,
0.0897478387,
-0.4175451398,
-0.0055325432,
0.4101216495,
-0.3564290702,
1.0216627121,
0.146426484,
-0.4823516011,
0.560683012,
-1.3075778484,
-0.2986306548,
0.5029504895,
-0.4678897262,
-0.4066013694,
-0.1315304041,
-0.0052820216,
0.2469166964,
-0.0967306793,
0.2331455648,
-0.0659033358,
-0.2518445849,
0.618635118,
-0.5283770561,
0.7623981237,
0.4150937796,
-0.1101470366,
0.1326712966,
-0.5101283193,
-0.0209846385,
0.0313056484,
-0.3991847038,
0.0026289495,
-0.0055100857,
0.2173446119,
-0.0337910913,
-0.0740050152,
-0.6784938574,
0.4182286859,
-0.3289207518,
0.5292124748,
0.7515149713,
0.1617178023,
0.4182754159,
-0.3375420272,
0.8239709139,
-0.1016538665,
0.2754208744,
-0.0294595454,
-0.6681402922,
-0.6869804263,
0.0297649074,
0.115081273,
0.4440834224,
-0.8211292624,
-0.0266327783,
-0.033411894,
-0.5323550701,
-0.6881378889,
-0.2614827752,
-0.0227075815,
0.5075877309,
0.1678818911,
-0.3692173362,
-0.3836901784,
-0.5559088588,
-0.0286636949,
-0.5661219358,
-0.5176588297,
0.2952295244,
0.4323705733,
-0.1953454167,
1.1066218615,
-0.6357986927,
-0.374766171,
-0.1414183378,
0.7222177982,
-0.1763546914,
0.4304449558,
0.3591187894,
-0.8112705946,
-0.54484725,
0.0115515813,
-0.8259666562,
0.2539403439,
-0.1868396848,
-0.0956351683,
-0.138961643,
0.313821584,
-0.5934018493,
0.3237636685,
0.3499807715,
-0.435277164,
0.6161531806,
0.1258790344,
0.5616232157,
-0.9988421202,
0.0697869286,
-0.0660436153,
0.1871814132,
-0.5048068762,
-0.036565043,
-0.4599173069,
-0.6403318644,
-0.0905859917,
0.2294176668,
-0.1510183811,
-0.036852438,
-0.1105433479,
0.2292656004,
-0.1872847974,
0.0253908522,
-0.1380745322,
1.4835349321,
0.5439066291,
-0.4388561547,
0.4195871949,
0.6378678679,
-0.3570665717,
0.945925951,
-0.8590818644,
0.4461890161,
-0.1555026174,
0.3508524299,
-0.927572608,
-0.3901250064,
0.2795998454,
-1.0102556944,
-0.1552898288,
0.1618401408,
-0.2778767645,
-0.3946910799,
-0.229806453,
0.331798017,
0.5643495321,
-0.3478253782,
0.6069518328,
0.3990415335,
-0.2084169835,
-0.1857121587,
-0.6380392909,
0.3253999054,
-0.1007954851,
-0.6399639249,
0.2597655058,
-0.0737627745,
-0.3733575344,
-0.0352758951,
0.0957085341,
-0.3576077521,
0.1995389909,
0.3893817067,
0.4720297754,
-0.2576345801,
0.3348771334,
-0.2685073316,
-0.1019052491,
0.3975237012,
-0.1125636771,
0.7745402455,
-0.2463342696,
-0.563007772,
-0.4805927873,
0.3037139475,
0.6783442497,
-0.1565851122,
0.5843419433,
0.8579242826,
-0.0840029418,
0.0000625632,
-0.2431125045,
-0.5834496617,
-0.475954026,
0.3220354319,
-0.082402274,
-0.9096983075,
0.3119122088,
-0.1857674122,
0.3764489591,
0.3340517879,
0.2995124161,
-0.3267281055,
0.9697467089,
0.6298906803,
-0.4207671881,
0.5839293599,
-0.3322800398,
0.4317021966,
-0.6470587254,
-0.3402639329,
-0.6907129884,
-0.2793473005,
-0.4385241568,
0.1417979449,
0.6525901556,
-0.2164190859,
-0.2050294727,
0.0142834149,
-0.8375509977,
0.3079384565,
0.7282421589,
0.0870825946,
0.2776503861,
-0.1844485849,
0.1931384951,
0.046247229,
-0.3368600905,
-0.6579400897,
0.9566355944,
0.2636561394,
0.4983661771,
0.0890966952,
0.5943726301,
0.7416642904,
0.389175415,
-1.0897315741,
0.5784988999,
0.2071583569,
-0.4997178614,
-0.5298612714,
-0.2720725834,
-1.1129581928,
0.0768597797,
-0.1284712553,
-0.7033483982,
-0.2752523124,
0.2333074361,
-0.2554822564,
0.2890428901,
-0.929731071,
0.756175518,
0.0273090824,
-0.0761426017,
-0.3791618049,
-0.4393501878,
0.2623591721,
-0.1077130139,
-0.0640321895,
0.0019190614,
0.3948946297,
0.8380296826,
-0.371922791,
0.7845572233,
-0.0952827185,
0.1425055116,
0.5393327475,
0.0192465298,
0.1276462227,
0.1202529818,
-0.1680922806,
0.1198065057,
0.1909585893,
-0.2685830295,
-0.3297414482,
0.2910332084,
-1.1913154125,
-0.6701776385,
-0.6369392872,
-0.4042169452,
-0.3599128127,
-0.0926544666,
0.4151768386,
0.244983688,
-0.7449470162,
0.1304921061,
0.5502383709,
-0.2125730217,
0.387169987,
0.0970683321,
-0.2753831744,
0.1069240645,
0.9428383112,
0.089038156,
0.1745712608,
0.1394026577,
-0.0509885177,
-0.1982190609,
-0.1129694954,
-0.6801037192,
-0.2600855827,
-0.4110859931,
0.1309967339,
-0.5189548731,
-0.5709007382,
-0.2716451585,
-0.3769736588,
0.0199165791,
-0.2473173589,
-0.3143200576,
-0.1599161923,
0.2140476406,
0.8440992832,
0.3875316679,
0.6812676787,
-0.5728328228,
-0.0793580934,
0.6549386382,
0.2126575708,
-0.1979958415,
-0.1924702376,
0.1714697331,
0.0126328841,
-0.852466166,
-0.5655966401,
0.1657989919,
0.3475909233,
0.3023937643,
0.4167464077,
-0.0153538939,
0.2002715617,
-0.1099734157,
1.318397522,
0.2489598393,
-0.7219520807,
0.6478427052,
-0.3453698456,
0.4298149347,
0.3714510798,
0.3311219215,
-0.896015048,
-0.6483793855,
-0.6923569441,
-0.5221897364,
0.3919101059,
0.3432301581,
0.5074908733,
0.2427131832,
-0.0313336998,
0.0837308094,
0.2303189784,
-0.5248314738,
-0.3272462189,
-0.396481961,
-0.0949144438,
0.2681027055,
-0.1754703373,
-0.05994552,
-0.1162666455,
0.6708432436,
0.2124931812,
0.6091650724,
-0.1690668166,
0.279274106,
0.1129717156,
0.6606989503,
0.2329578847,
0.7111980319,
-0.0312062111,
0.1172537431,
0.1720119864,
-1.0357863903,
-0.0358899795,
0.1319981068,
-0.2777982056,
0.099445276,
-0.0547165424,
0.3495807052,
-0.4353851974,
-0.4248252511,
0.2721358836,
-0.1985786557,
-0.2867524922,
-0.3950270414,
0.2493180186,
-0.3714524806,
-0.1339531094,
0.5710222125,
0.2765420377,
0.4302980006,
-0.5354939103,
0.1895489693,
0.3888995647,
-0.5820044875,
-0.3119392693,
0.8840585351,
0.6243165731,
-0.4490955472,
0.978664279,
0.003347842,
-0.3802211881,
0.6980853081,
0.3419669867,
1.051944375,
-0.2001955807,
0.7467703819,
0.340713501,
0.1243905351,
0.2554343343,
-0.0453604013,
-0.2774702907,
-0.8855372667,
0.0670678094,
-0.45479545,
-0.8807798624,
0.0700525865,
-0.4330356121,
0.1983243972,
-0.4959126413,
-0.4653784335,
0.1297507286,
-0.3845967352,
-0.6496876478,
0.2570628226,
-0.2568122745,
0.3437162638,
-0.5796031952,
0.6618849039,
1.1243487597,
-0.7244384289,
-0.738807559,
0.1739059985,
0.2696093023,
-0.9809397459,
0.5203633904,
-0.0377648287,
-0.0815892369,
0.357647717,
-0.4704498053,
-0.3193622828,
0.8283507228,
0.0362539366,
-0.2736892402,
0.1584497839,
0.6009844542,
0.5467118025,
0.3485581279,
0.4628811479,
0.5172206163,
0.251493156,
-0.0185000151,
-1.063605547,
-0.452593565,
-0.2878147662,
-0.1735469848,
0.5302450061,
-0.5930119157,
0.5928275585,
0.1415774226,
-0.4332855344,
-0.2774188817,
0.477543056,
-0.0027305386,
0.4754988551,
0.2557474375,
0.169260323,
0.8076675534,
-0.5100948215,
0.8605337143,
-0.4220202863,
0.3551122248,
0.5610466599,
0.0584709942,
0.4226213396,
0.5619559288,
-0.6619241834,
0.2951849699,
0.5717781186,
-0.1386483908,
-0.0481070168,
0.3021378815,
-0.9772696495,
0.1415466219,
-0.4455296099,
-0.7250456214,
0.4447994828,
0.3172226846,
-0.1504266113,
-0.0341982171,
0.4028392434,
-0.0205389857,
0.0384254828,
-0.1532653719,
0.8563293815,
0.133545801,
-0.6359062195,
0.0750699267,
-0.1399650276,
0.5502474904,
-0.3608624041,
-0.0908254683,
-0.2045900673,
-0.0455706865,
-0.3019444644,
-1.2195774317,
0.4948963225,
0.1063821912,
0.0256261677,
-0.4012161791,
0.6020246744,
-0.1246759072,
-0.3224570751,
-0.4062668979,
0.5530537963,
0.3198434114,
-0.1194069311,
-0.607857585,
-0.0466395319,
-0.05621038,
-0.003287575,
0.2319711745,
0.2046872228,
0.1178940609,
0.9047799706,
0.3989929855,
-0.207156837,
-0.0592125915,
0.1873496324,
0.6786645055,
-0.17192927,
-0.3662678301,
-0.7286313772,
0.5005536675,
-0.1960444748,
-0.5930957794,
0.5901238322,
0.7088918686,
1.0225195885,
-0.1426229626,
1.179146409,
-0.4099482596,
0.2899908721,
-0.2525370419,
0.8591386676,
-0.0630972758,
0.1714226902,
-0.1626957804,
-0.8882371187,
-0.0339458697,
0.5770789385,
-0.4159192741,
0.1071887463,
0.4725129008,
0.4818228781,
0.0998796299,
0.6001880169,
0.3456913233,
-0.0768179074,
0.5704066753,
0.158855319,
1.1400278807,
-0.2086118162,
0.6562336087,
-0.0308018159,
-0.2286554724,
0.1112682149,
-0.2329840511,
-0.6698158979,
-0.6942831874,
-0.6077485085,
-0.1165378243,
0.0708831698,
0.8851004839,
0.3038369715,
-0.7915922999,
-0.4094491601,
-0.5383190513,
-0.0842977986,
0.0568531305,
-0.4257166684,
0.2350704074,
-0.4653480351,
-0.7665160298,
0.1007151976,
0.1067208126,
0.2404935509,
-0.4350474179,
0.1502484977,
0.2108115405,
-0.3084932566,
0.7753939033,
0.4510628879,
-0.4258887768,
-0.5564191937,
0.0642767027,
-0.0749764293,
0.1829246879,
0.7056234479,
-0.8270200491,
0.6389217377,
0.4240175486,
0.8579785824,
0.2939823568,
0.1594298035,
0.817225039,
-0.6956775784,
-0.0805871114,
0.2923130095,
0.158294186,
0.1851178557,
-0.4719794095,
0.7653006315,
0.3488444686,
-1.0062896013,
-0.5176404119,
0.0807091072,
-0.8905481696,
0.0286264233,
0.554241538,
0.0927725136,
0.5791030526,
-0.3321559429,
-0.7649591565,
0.2047813684,
-0.5629249215,
1.3326998949,
0.6924610734,
-0.4730763137,
-0.3172447085,
-0.9695965052,
0.5406985283,
0.3665132523,
-1.1441556215,
-0.437215209,
0.5092020035,
0.0356678925,
-0.087906532,
0.6540939808,
0.0442427844,
0.1904035658,
0.1465353817,
0.1758042574,
0.1598821133,
-0.0025285687,
0.1646709591,
0.2845154405,
0.2734971046,
-0.5473277569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11163v1 | ChatGPT, Large Language Technologies, and the Bumpy Road of Benefiting Humanity | 2023-04-21T22:53:45 | 2023-04-21T22:53:45 | Atoosa Kasirzadeh | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | The allure of emerging AI technologies is undoubtedly thrilling. However, the
promise that AI technologies will benefit all of humanity is empty so long as
we lack a nuanced understanding of what humanity is supposed to be in the face
of widening global inequality and pressing existential threats. Going forward,
it is crucial to invest in rigorous and collaborative AI safety and ethics
research. We also need to develop standards in a sustainable and equitable way
that differentiate between merely speculative and well-researched questions.
Only the latter enable us to co-construct and deploy the values that are
necessary for creating beneficial AI. Failure to do so could result in a future
in which our AI technological advancements outstrip our ability to navigate
their ethical and social implications. This path we do not want to go down. | [
-0.3075992763,
-0.7879567742,
0.669290483,
-0.0472913422,
0.0372702368,
0.4561370611,
-0.0392854586,
-0.8574516177,
0.1761917174,
0.3081237078,
-0.1915122569,
0.1854097694,
-0.6952226162,
-0.1932824105,
-0.2424934953,
1.0705838203,
0.3365010023,
-0.2781696022,
-0.1788658947,
0.1745408922,
-0.2031928599,
-0.4147255719,
-0.9176880121,
-0.3116967082,
0.5718869567,
0.5623474717,
1.1171060801,
0.4868444204,
0.6075470448,
0.3337250054,
-0.1964868158,
-0.2082310319,
-0.5446548462,
0.1514935344,
0.0640617907,
-0.327583611,
-0.1772008687,
0.3267475367,
0.4438701868,
0.8638999462,
0.0722271949,
0.0313676149,
0.0483736396,
0.6090524197,
-0.3595281839,
0.1396608949,
-0.5112259388,
0.0765062869,
-0.2345409244,
-0.306263566,
-0.0254470706,
-0.7532817721,
0.1435997635,
-0.5335822701,
-0.1202951968,
0.3139192462,
0.7630775571,
0.4244719446,
-0.3726680875,
-0.1611953825,
-0.7968936563,
0.8882637024,
-0.2379021645,
0.1720422804,
0.3940365613,
0.1767619699,
-0.3926620781,
-0.8975732327,
-0.5774948597,
-0.4808036685,
0.3775073886,
0.3052152097,
0.0153245321,
0.1299881637,
-0.0208350904,
0.2899238467,
-0.385106951,
0.2436412722,
-1.0003247261,
-0.2525243759,
0.736415863,
0.0158398505,
0.569280982,
0.2587607205,
-0.469715476,
-0.175107643,
-0.9837976098,
0.2730339468,
0.4928621948,
0.1695684791,
-0.2545863986,
0.328535527,
0.1078871414,
0.1081635877,
-0.4439243376,
-0.0517650954,
0.1847016215,
-0.1729934514,
0.1070048362,
0.2314309478,
0.6569902897,
0.5156662464,
0.5295982361,
-0.3540258706,
0.2473356873,
0.2527668178,
0.5097913146,
-0.7186283469,
0.0508514792,
0.4366108775,
-0.4778255522,
-0.3611192703,
0.3117754757,
-0.7839114666,
-0.7856566906,
-0.1856167465,
0.1906702965,
-0.30905056,
-0.5296343565,
0.2811482251,
-0.3972020149,
0.6833466887,
0.3182661831,
-0.9177646637,
-0.0821358263,
0.8952609897,
0.8987805843,
0.2803715467,
-0.3298709989,
-0.1540116668,
0.1971856505,
-0.384462446,
0.6792535186,
-0.7190721035,
-1.0515072346,
-0.0296918731,
-0.1454077959,
0.1104963273,
-0.2141935378,
0.7902793288,
-0.0899777114,
0.0650485083,
-0.3724367917,
-0.1973960847,
-0.1679758877,
0.2318449169,
-0.3775414526,
0.537825048,
-0.2200598717,
-0.5312228799,
0.2603260875,
-1.2505360842,
-0.6718182564,
0.4062506855,
-0.3107558489,
-0.1459178925,
0.0084381793,
-0.2973196805,
0.337913692,
-0.4059514105,
0.3320191205,
-0.2904647589,
-0.5939977765,
0.2766829431,
-0.7996826172,
1.0001068115,
0.4196418524,
-0.4230307639,
-0.0833286345,
-0.330499202,
-0.1420514137,
-0.0724405795,
-0.1732718796,
-0.0121543221,
0.1632179767,
0.1813193262,
0.2420725226,
0.4032590091,
-0.8628242016,
-0.0761569515,
-0.2349450737,
0.8004223108,
1.2574676275,
-0.0352140144,
0.5068714619,
-0.6049341559,
0.7094328403,
-0.3940735757,
0.5525792837,
0.0617830046,
-0.9099225402,
-0.6795921326,
-0.0799621046,
-0.0870214701,
0.6094188094,
-0.449223727,
0.45221138,
-0.2211558819,
-0.6062830091,
-0.7283178568,
-0.473082453,
-0.013666152,
0.3712849319,
0.1209451258,
-0.3624602556,
-0.273114562,
-0.6856408715,
-0.358353585,
-0.4211439788,
-0.1812624633,
0.2767955959,
0.2620225549,
-0.2037116885,
0.7289130688,
-0.1876990646,
-0.1102950051,
0.0074736867,
-0.0225576442,
-0.0306705479,
0.8105118275,
0.2762252688,
-1.1509940624,
-0.2520266771,
0.1661136299,
-0.7773999572,
0.4955744445,
-0.2533960044,
-0.1528514475,
-0.4094861746,
0.5071948171,
-0.7811133862,
0.1897517145,
0.1032745317,
-0.3516812325,
0.2300680727,
-0.2363818288,
0.4736692309,
-0.9011159539,
0.3453119397,
-0.1175330132,
-0.0603845827,
-0.5941190124,
-0.149750337,
-0.5707508922,
-0.3500209153,
-0.4247838855,
0.6876788735,
-0.1747661233,
0.0454079397,
-0.2722653151,
0.3953557312,
-0.1191384792,
-0.2110557556,
-0.3980560005,
1.0408295393,
0.7384893298,
-0.5421344042,
0.4841065109,
0.363193512,
-0.1159323528,
0.5571929216,
-0.8288967609,
0.1473613232,
-0.0327480584,
0.1999183148,
-0.4703074396,
-0.2480274588,
0.352557838,
-1.1587219238,
-0.0439151786,
0.3799643815,
-0.2533324957,
-0.3890924454,
-0.4216046333,
0.4207922816,
1.0059652328,
-0.2036111206,
0.3155341446,
0.9444611073,
-0.4585430026,
-0.7070994973,
-0.8170511127,
0.4325635135,
-0.3570015132,
-0.8027092218,
0.0959322974,
0.0277239364,
-0.6512426138,
-0.156168893,
0.0781502202,
-0.0456997603,
0.4832505882,
0.3955510855,
0.3011739552,
-0.0648875982,
0.1803850979,
-0.2445808351,
-0.6481505036,
0.2658521831,
-0.4732470214,
0.3392510116,
-0.3473574817,
-0.3100061119,
-0.2493680567,
0.6543311477,
0.682921052,
-0.1666759402,
0.6359588504,
0.8003690839,
-0.34655568,
0.5355682373,
-0.4460856318,
-0.0505554825,
-0.548492372,
0.4028630555,
0.2685060799,
-1.3267623186,
0.180590108,
-0.3102426231,
0.2214013189,
0.3757304251,
0.3058082759,
-0.3053255379,
0.7517883778,
0.9812173247,
-0.1901877522,
0.2932977676,
0.1314041167,
0.8524797559,
-0.6205437779,
-0.2326205373,
-0.7515229583,
-0.0718629062,
-1.0610376596,
-0.0659881607,
0.7780290246,
-0.2862752378,
-0.5181486011,
-0.3363833725,
-0.7502247095,
0.583529532,
1.1258015633,
-0.0229847599,
0.2413594574,
-0.2404376566,
0.6855289936,
0.0939416587,
-0.2731913924,
-0.8314298987,
0.813990593,
0.2319570929,
0.6796176434,
-0.103201367,
0.4499408603,
0.6624676585,
0.0550671481,
-0.6697131991,
0.4652217627,
0.1424949616,
-0.5258212686,
-0.2657568753,
-0.3387432098,
-1.3364760876,
-0.1810553372,
-0.0977484956,
-0.8863813281,
0.0537559874,
-0.081225343,
-0.5146455169,
0.5004636645,
-0.6463028193,
0.7088471055,
-0.225632146,
-0.3080928922,
-0.4810497165,
-1.2376828194,
0.2965534925,
0.253107816,
0.3716826439,
-0.3505301476,
0.1187982112,
0.6592386365,
0.0386409387,
0.8654108047,
0.0839208513,
0.0247170571,
0.5121158361,
-0.258765012,
0.048202958,
0.0978770927,
-0.1212853715,
0.1869471222,
-0.1064357236,
-0.7509844303,
-0.0481930748,
0.6116811633,
-0.928839922,
-0.6984859705,
-0.5925130844,
-0.5124092698,
-0.1315838844,
0.1728747487,
0.2300392985,
0.0428216755,
-0.5217237473,
0.1339198351,
0.5952044725,
-0.3336052597,
0.5304502845,
-0.2756426036,
0.2084787041,
-0.0565021746,
1.0464924574,
-0.2529669106,
0.3778012991,
0.0649907663,
0.1238354445,
-0.2360712439,
-0.243608579,
-0.3246084452,
-0.1102594584,
-0.59158957,
-0.039077308,
-0.417719543,
-0.3553400636,
-0.3882275522,
-0.6796622872,
-0.3099380732,
-0.2736957371,
-0.2114236206,
-0.1552444398,
0.616202116,
0.9724557996,
-0.4579567611,
0.0860880539,
-1.0845478773,
0.0011627186,
0.1565958411,
0.1945329756,
-0.0588075668,
-0.1042058766,
-0.1420769542,
0.4511279166,
-0.6240459681,
0.0226433296,
0.0493031181,
0.0655139014,
0.4157331586,
0.3935951889,
0.2826774418,
0.4249919057,
-0.6171966791,
1.0046113729,
0.303850472,
-0.7512102723,
0.3970524073,
-0.4306121171,
-0.1745083034,
0.4465535879,
0.5154923797,
-0.910638988,
-0.167122826,
-0.8321718574,
-0.9881530404,
0.1394487619,
0.2947516739,
0.6625032425,
0.0643592253,
0.1627248824,
0.2132195979,
0.1494037807,
-0.7267935276,
-0.1039003059,
-0.1623963416,
0.0186455641,
0.1765836924,
0.2452999949,
-0.1614210755,
-0.0225577634,
0.5673228502,
0.1009887382,
0.450738132,
0.1136889234,
0.6400578618,
0.0229022671,
0.5394278765,
0.240377903,
0.6359399557,
0.0888419151,
-0.119233802,
-0.3246554434,
-0.8260248303,
0.2500197589,
0.0991011932,
-0.0811671019,
-0.4915426373,
0.0352090448,
0.3369085491,
-0.4813488126,
-0.8295598626,
0.3229621947,
-0.0197766293,
-0.0570247769,
-0.5695844889,
0.1460485607,
-0.1035106406,
0.3796434402,
0.4297930002,
0.479113549,
0.0847032741,
-0.8760898709,
0.1332908273,
0.3925536275,
-0.5110366344,
-0.1585496515,
0.7536844611,
0.5905653834,
-0.4882372916,
0.6918469071,
-0.1992229968,
-0.4476081133,
0.7373048663,
0.208359465,
0.8727083802,
-0.1091017723,
0.2530055642,
0.0231039282,
0.4817457199,
-0.0016942918,
0.1256456971,
-0.0044569392,
-0.7331035137,
-0.2607861459,
-0.3443205059,
-0.6388676167,
-0.3147372007,
-0.2658446729,
0.0838019922,
-0.4273861945,
0.0503603779,
-0.3605747521,
-0.084353976,
-0.2974420786,
0.2143467069,
0.0101275863,
0.414116174,
-0.4857897758,
0.5603336692,
0.4714862704,
-0.775942266,
-0.4205412567,
0.3907651901,
-0.0362247787,
-0.9023822546,
0.2101039886,
0.5852441192,
-0.2482615411,
0.1805560589,
-0.9275928736,
-0.7805786133,
1.0553429127,
0.2904872596,
0.0214736909,
-0.0996814221,
0.2495021671,
0.2580654323,
0.0444664657,
0.2100165337,
0.4924598932,
0.6776233315,
0.1230633259,
-0.9054933786,
-0.0438444875,
-0.2990331948,
-0.0917323157,
0.221552074,
-0.8866406083,
0.6566307545,
-0.4012427032,
-0.3635068834,
0.0607883818,
0.4329175055,
-0.037806496,
0.2746334374,
0.2141374201,
0.0682647899,
0.7470378876,
-0.1101614758,
1.2670184374,
-0.3001742065,
0.190816775,
0.2555176914,
-0.1578150839,
0.3851578534,
0.4026392102,
-0.3400563896,
-0.0439487845,
0.8974965811,
0.0428601466,
0.2305253148,
0.1463336796,
-0.5080680251,
-0.3146993816,
-0.7048040032,
-0.6694469452,
0.5478926301,
0.6134693623,
0.1082445383,
0.1277724802,
-0.0883538201,
0.2316450179,
0.0167477932,
-0.106547147,
0.4508897662,
0.4918241501,
-0.5709604621,
0.2364862114,
-0.2136620581,
0.8506193757,
-0.3519921303,
-0.1316467673,
0.1472677439,
0.0845827758,
0.0315234996,
-0.8765758276,
0.4132864773,
-0.1597554982,
0.3160719872,
-0.1100452691,
0.6221209168,
0.0730120838,
-0.3569949269,
0.2158018053,
0.6789596677,
0.2311732173,
0.0661320761,
-0.6059532762,
-0.2063248008,
0.005681749,
0.1292787194,
0.2186078131,
0.4047622383,
0.2669654787,
1.062305212,
0.8243566751,
0.0839685202,
-0.0824418664,
-0.1315121502,
0.8080146313,
-0.8254077435,
-0.6550617218,
-1.0010176897,
0.6078181863,
-0.3062282205,
-0.5866426229,
0.3390257359,
0.173681438,
0.6094359159,
0.5127775669,
1.2325496674,
-0.5265390277,
0.047653459,
-0.3648444116,
0.9700758457,
-0.5547280908,
0.1542661339,
-0.1496463269,
-0.6255464554,
-0.3123142421,
0.5621845722,
0.0019460191,
0.2711079121,
0.4116390049,
0.3737173975,
0.2303477228,
0.4511541128,
0.4669387043,
0.173539862,
0.5461688042,
0.4692517519,
1.1160888672,
-0.2013369501,
0.5380865932,
0.1540538818,
-0.4358377457,
0.0445946306,
-0.5846565366,
-0.5153570771,
-0.4964164793,
-0.0079334695,
-0.2322791666,
0.3655905724,
0.9450786114,
0.5798547268,
-0.391017139,
-0.190742597,
-0.2502427101,
0.0910703018,
0.0547370911,
-0.2253865749,
0.0835686177,
-0.2802797854,
-0.7581008673,
0.1384277493,
0.6390753388,
0.1054440439,
-0.3565049171,
-0.0478504188,
-0.2592162192,
-0.1068634316,
0.5271866322,
0.4713013768,
-0.4410525262,
-0.6526327133,
-0.0363761336,
0.0845520571,
0.3558152616,
0.7159321308,
-0.4351243675,
0.0457089581,
0.1352408528,
1.1902272701,
-0.1493555158,
-0.1386642307,
0.9015877247,
-0.2844474018,
0.418702811,
0.8135326505,
0.3255541027,
0.4553215802,
-0.5994079113,
0.7395400405,
0.1407693923,
-1.2314378023,
-0.5794540644,
0.4652555287,
-0.6083371639,
-0.0551841632,
0.8856363893,
-0.125620991,
-0.1691024154,
-0.4699298143,
-0.3149266541,
0.3103284538,
-0.6824226975,
1.0731174946,
0.3572635353,
-0.4209527075,
-0.1080005392,
-0.8964138627,
0.4128489196,
0.3887570202,
-0.9593984485,
-0.0582642108,
0.367708385,
-0.290165484,
0.3211506605,
0.7538309693,
-0.2931660712,
0.1881917566,
0.3468144238,
0.1032307893,
0.4928431809,
-0.176363647,
0.1186162978,
-0.2863464653,
0.2054295391,
-0.492479682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11257v1 | Who's the Best Detective? LLMs vs. MLs in Detecting Incoherent Fourth Grade Math Answers | 2023-04-21T21:25:30 | 2023-04-21T21:25:30 | Felipe Urrutia, Roberto Araya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Written answers to open-ended questions can have a higher long-term effect on
learning than multiple-choice questions. However, it is critical that teachers
immediately review the answers, and ask to redo those that are incoherent. This
can be a difficult task and can be time-consuming for teachers. A possible
solution is to automate the detection of incoherent answers. One option is to
automate the review with Large Language Models (LLM). In this paper, we analyze
the responses of fourth graders in mathematics using three LLMs: GPT-3, BLOOM,
and YOU. We used them with zero, one, two, three and four shots. We compared
their performance with the results of various classifiers trained with Machine
Learning (ML). We found that LLMs perform worse than MLs in detecting
incoherent answers. The difficulty seems to reside in recursive questions that
contain both questions and answers, and in responses from students with typical
fourth-grader misspellings. Upon closer examination, we have found that the
ChatGPT model faces the same challenges. | [
-0.4030738473,
-0.7392696142,
0.7407863736,
0.1389006674,
-0.1198403239,
0.2047661841,
0.090009734,
-0.5969888568,
-0.2034574747,
0.2605392337,
-0.3501943052,
-0.3953329027,
-0.8360819221,
0.4176478982,
-0.4278432429,
1.0979441404,
-0.0628944263,
0.4753120244,
-0.4207909405,
-0.1188146397,
-0.4516479671,
-0.6370239258,
-0.9669454694,
-0.4726271927,
0.2112820894,
0.3780043125,
0.7741606236,
0.382039547,
0.7131019235,
0.4023133814,
0.1544004083,
0.0281265061,
-0.4035196006,
0.2213402539,
0.1190100089,
-0.4947180748,
-0.4633885026,
-0.1570369303,
0.0754950568,
0.6940315962,
-0.0355807096,
0.1780813783,
-0.1011163965,
0.6219671965,
-0.4764241278,
0.2206193358,
-0.6678259373,
0.3946804404,
0.0183179863,
-0.262966007,
-0.2009691447,
-0.6212767363,
0.2826269567,
-0.3901976943,
0.4962758124,
-0.4059361219,
0.5809931755,
0.238492623,
-0.1847366095,
-0.6594259143,
-0.6361644864,
0.7985076308,
-0.5448432565,
0.0873731077,
0.6031848192,
0.1475891173,
-0.0997889265,
-0.3883263469,
-0.4470663965,
-0.2084702402,
0.0604829676,
0.5148146152,
-0.163633287,
0.0731689185,
0.2309527248,
0.3328289092,
-0.8181511164,
0.1025545001,
-0.2444747984,
-0.487963289,
0.6170604825,
0.4389928579,
0.1714204848,
0.214917019,
-0.0280662421,
0.1997377276,
-0.545709312,
0.102078326,
0.4626740813,
0.079300873,
0.4142016172,
0.7598748207,
0.0142914634,
0.532602787,
0.1926320195,
-0.3481882513,
0.1148896813,
-0.2827219665,
-0.1292901635,
-0.116281718,
0.7892537713,
0.2492880821,
0.5372950435,
-0.1070381775,
-0.4343139529,
0.2102070898,
-0.1373545527,
-0.8413973451,
-0.3763813376,
0.2785300314,
-0.1313158572,
-0.2429645061,
-0.287460804,
-0.5150952339,
-0.1872778088,
-0.2097643465,
0.532613039,
-0.1627193987,
0.187797457,
0.2223144174,
0.3088594675,
0.1846179813,
0.6323862672,
-0.9991136193,
0.3252902031,
0.6315454245,
0.8295292258,
-0.2524507344,
-0.253698349,
-0.6709933877,
-0.4613364935,
-0.4272617102,
0.8782794476,
-0.2659527659,
-0.4181100726,
-0.0274247248,
-0.130652681,
0.0106410403,
-0.677443862,
0.4571729302,
-0.8261220455,
0.4530780017,
-0.0398735888,
-0.7764255404,
0.1783109754,
0.4065293372,
-0.4813677967,
1.1205329895,
0.052022174,
-0.6109701991,
0.2306185216,
-0.4073607922,
-0.2504583299,
0.0763946548,
-0.1613468379,
-0.8420419693,
-0.0226354674,
0.4740493,
0.5106511116,
-0.0204512198,
0.2421345264,
-0.4568469822,
-0.4204385281,
0.4618367851,
-0.5678751469,
0.7685113549,
0.117767483,
-0.2615293562,
-0.093572244,
-0.6141806841,
0.0955927595,
0.2908580005,
-0.5123134851,
0.2099833637,
-0.1781562865,
-0.4755226374,
0.0459116325,
0.3850646913,
-0.4686174095,
-0.1446629912,
-0.2196661681,
0.2383503169,
0.9545645714,
0.0475518256,
0.3653975129,
-0.7616569996,
0.6325309873,
0.0217147712,
0.1743772477,
-0.2988334298,
-0.7663719058,
-0.8042675853,
-0.0331132784,
-0.0205556359,
0.5394304395,
-0.4901290238,
0.106965363,
-0.0011518297,
-0.3579879105,
-0.3789847791,
0.2969944775,
0.3044813275,
0.6020320058,
0.3319249153,
-0.108141996,
-0.2739458382,
-0.6539728045,
-0.4243251085,
-0.2733299434,
-0.0354219601,
0.3965678215,
0.5097485185,
-0.0237518921,
0.7488432527,
-0.5200759768,
-0.252276361,
0.0682504252,
-0.0449401997,
0.306770891,
0.0391389467,
0.4710162878,
-0.6174407601,
-0.7925508022,
-0.1489048302,
-0.7416754961,
-0.3002933264,
0.2199998796,
0.1648776382,
0.4671126902,
0.3526020646,
-0.3979164958,
0.2843744755,
0.3023093045,
-0.1011812612,
0.6581192017,
-0.1374671906,
-0.1547532082,
-0.6505453587,
-0.1741965115,
-0.1669630557,
-0.3938474655,
-0.7320380807,
-0.1196294054,
0.1005995795,
-0.1367233843,
-0.1480322778,
0.2281345725,
-0.44249475,
-0.4554043114,
-0.0624891706,
0.2813203037,
-0.1762388796,
0.3760399222,
-0.0977715328,
0.8978257775,
0.3740386367,
-0.4544220567,
0.650758028,
0.0061781472,
-0.3655693829,
0.3952018917,
-0.517374754,
0.2727439702,
-0.1866974533,
0.1119914576,
-1.2150653601,
-0.2170821577,
-0.0459251553,
-0.9117337465,
0.0833345726,
-0.0148014417,
-0.7173159122,
-0.5577244759,
-0.3620958328,
0.2171903253,
0.3205042481,
-0.6830697656,
0.3425297141,
0.3376508057,
-0.4174223542,
-0.752654314,
-0.617890954,
-0.1178979427,
-0.0632016584,
-0.5429620147,
-0.1756926626,
-0.7228405476,
-0.1659704894,
-0.0657465756,
-0.3573970497,
-0.4764724374,
0.2526576519,
-0.063551046,
0.5000709891,
-0.2892210782,
0.2801624238,
-0.3803542852,
-0.1111307591,
0.3133257329,
-0.0414455421,
0.5706896186,
-0.4660718441,
-0.5388436317,
-0.2150449008,
0.2391298264,
0.8294339776,
-0.0087396717,
0.1852084994,
0.1597296,
-0.0384046212,
-0.0373454541,
-0.4922255278,
-0.3109015226,
-0.4589014351,
0.2826986313,
-0.3822731972,
-1.088925004,
0.686201632,
0.48372522,
0.1724184901,
0.0437489301,
0.7336258292,
-0.1581714451,
1.3010702133,
0.3294738531,
-0.2218196094,
0.3078969717,
-0.1684629768,
0.2759978175,
-0.3122733235,
-0.1169987619,
-0.3727321327,
-0.0479665697,
-0.492128998,
0.0260986146,
0.4084938467,
-0.1959987879,
-0.3093129098,
-0.0104378648,
-0.6773250699,
0.6596457362,
0.3376263976,
0.008384441,
0.5606948137,
-0.0024242792,
0.0011533526,
-0.1537086964,
-0.6092216969,
-0.3009396493,
1.2515308857,
0.3781302571,
0.6869555116,
0.3655985594,
0.7467997074,
-0.1646199673,
0.6845204234,
-1.1238986254,
0.5771564841,
0.1610743552,
-0.7286142707,
-0.4907047749,
-0.3685791492,
-0.9851644039,
0.5966325998,
-0.1126241907,
-0.2556577325,
-0.2046556622,
-0.0677736104,
-0.2512218654,
0.2938561141,
-0.5325474143,
0.4128906727,
-0.2114769965,
-0.335739404,
0.4296010435,
-0.5302610993,
0.4970085025,
-0.4291718006,
0.2597609758,
-0.1151962876,
-0.1177218705,
0.4008638859,
-0.6871777177,
0.5834272504,
-0.0090283509,
-0.3170844913,
0.4743109047,
0.1883555055,
0.4438001812,
0.1020681337,
0.1190757304,
-0.0331726447,
-0.2156265527,
-0.43732059,
-0.6330236793,
0.7208945155,
-0.9100840688,
-0.6821799278,
-0.7164078355,
-0.4991491139,
-0.3026489913,
0.1413806081,
0.5324898958,
0.5314460993,
0.2160607576,
-0.1411808729,
0.7474166155,
0.3009342551,
0.7056708932,
0.743078649,
-0.2548035085,
-0.3568736017,
0.6096619964,
0.3516879976,
0.3429057598,
0.0904481187,
0.3074412942,
-0.3144326508,
-0.7133544683,
-0.4775374234,
0.3442577124,
-0.8535122871,
-0.4861735702,
-0.7838580608,
-0.4021556675,
-0.403745383,
-0.2515017688,
-0.1022626013,
-0.2551195323,
-0.5662343502,
-0.0713083073,
0.1228996068,
0.6656463742,
-0.1010135487,
0.0313739702,
-0.6572259068,
0.1340858191,
0.7845128775,
0.2528466582,
-0.0361859985,
-0.7419239283,
-0.0584445037,
-0.2692971826,
-0.4480519295,
-0.7644991279,
0.4500291348,
0.0636336803,
0.1810566038,
0.3402158916,
-0.1046416238,
0.7606363893,
-0.5625706315,
0.727241993,
0.1117883027,
-0.7664338946,
0.1596531719,
-0.1715243757,
0.4002807736,
0.3346775174,
0.4629919529,
-0.2146443725,
-0.6099695563,
-0.369884342,
-0.4769361615,
0.6244109869,
0.1517522186,
0.2009347379,
-0.1004321575,
0.2343773544,
0.143891871,
0.1585866958,
-0.8325222135,
-0.1977141201,
-0.1368267834,
-0.2176607102,
-0.0420753099,
-0.3370877802,
0.0706276968,
-0.0379447006,
0.5369670391,
-0.2872959375,
0.345964849,
0.2859101892,
-0.082677111,
-0.2663366497,
0.1407466829,
0.7034896016,
0.6140021682,
-0.2686944902,
0.1320020705,
0.4771805704,
-0.8320832253,
0.3090300262,
-0.105424881,
-0.0365039259,
0.1014898047,
0.8200692534,
0.3577615023,
0.0773556232,
-0.548425436,
1.0022548437,
-0.3197397292,
-0.5544429421,
-0.7806870341,
0.045594018,
-0.1325792819,
0.1378524452,
0.3463189602,
0.0598388799,
0.1270225346,
-0.5097565055,
0.0032812958,
0.4993757904,
-0.1266518384,
-0.3277622759,
0.3121512234,
-0.1959926486,
-0.3864911497,
0.3455720544,
0.0192289036,
-0.8480558991,
0.7963567972,
0.7118285298,
0.7296085358,
-0.4903369844,
0.2011321932,
0.3523536921,
0.1174499616,
-0.0510484092,
0.4036544859,
-0.1935516,
-0.8141426444,
-0.4681366682,
-0.3273750842,
-0.6824972034,
0.4547918439,
-0.6780174971,
0.0693700239,
-0.6158255339,
0.008864616,
0.0939657912,
0.1957511604,
-0.5493482947,
0.1693443954,
-0.1887208521,
0.42980057,
-0.6811800599,
0.4247540832,
0.6679810882,
-0.2084544003,
-0.5852839947,
-0.07692343,
0.1028519124,
-0.9559348226,
0.8549715281,
0.1341022551,
-0.2991998792,
0.1272910237,
-0.8060388565,
-0.913380444,
1.0307453871,
0.0615413114,
-0.4857015312,
0.1698075533,
0.0912281424,
0.8032549024,
-0.2984805405,
0.5556161404,
0.4565478861,
0.2300039083,
0.3367067277,
-0.8709552288,
-0.4490564466,
0.0834202245,
-0.2762919366,
0.2255586982,
-0.6282172799,
1.0380879641,
-0.4820813537,
-0.4200210273,
0.2710241973,
0.4684218764,
0.3190289438,
0.7017979026,
0.3567386866,
0.6123144627,
0.8162842989,
-0.0134004783,
0.8096672297,
-0.0589857958,
0.540959239,
1.1171789169,
-0.1217171252,
0.7634423971,
0.0825990885,
-0.4916809201,
0.0635259524,
0.7469655871,
-0.0128855826,
0.4303781092,
0.409758538,
-0.5083992481,
-0.2300541252,
0.4511924982,
-0.1364375651,
0.2648536265,
0.4228616953,
0.0496399142,
-0.4766216576,
-0.035589952,
0.3153729737,
0.0803624094,
-0.5057308078,
0.8261153102,
0.0615676492,
-0.8596664071,
0.7283821702,
-0.2136740834,
0.5512894392,
-0.1932439506,
0.178885743,
-0.7588687539,
0.328786999,
-0.2107896358,
-1.1556704044,
0.1403140277,
0.2313903868,
-0.2096651047,
0.1257757396,
0.5305352211,
-0.5178663731,
-0.2046736926,
0.3253954649,
0.4801602364,
0.4065166712,
0.177571103,
-0.9290213585,
-0.1938640177,
-0.1130323485,
0.0085549904,
0.145922631,
0.4902148843,
0.0477255322,
0.8711642623,
0.8420367241,
-0.0335858054,
0.3454114199,
-0.028862264,
0.8037817478,
-0.3597611785,
-0.1793209463,
-0.9586898088,
0.0211776439,
0.0563108884,
-0.2237305343,
1.0198128223,
0.6980246902,
0.8060400486,
0.0031891246,
0.7164739966,
0.7121056318,
0.6878589988,
-0.3882501125,
0.3071544468,
-0.3607488871,
0.2945744693,
-0.2356785834,
-1.0574772358,
-0.7444570065,
0.7086485624,
-0.2739399374,
0.0873196572,
0.8810522556,
0.7123401165,
-0.0152948797,
0.1765016168,
0.6543996334,
0.1712386459,
0.5858216286,
0.7799521089,
0.920161128,
-0.350022018,
0.9020392299,
-0.0542306192,
-0.2478992939,
-0.5380523801,
-0.4917364419,
-1.2464874983,
-0.2601653039,
-0.1267487556,
-0.3970445693,
-0.1931436211,
0.5432325602,
0.1884626299,
-0.8309718966,
-0.080853574,
-0.3123743236,
0.1134988219,
0.3938765824,
-0.2194356024,
0.484870553,
-0.6107870936,
-0.7492632866,
0.2216122746,
0.4169673026,
0.3809652925,
-0.3274971247,
0.168081075,
0.2226563245,
0.2022616565,
0.6443704367,
0.2063157707,
-0.6257762313,
-0.3048422337,
0.3701679707,
-0.400003463,
0.2352197915,
0.6133965254,
-0.5059518218,
0.7816175222,
0.4784908593,
0.7320134044,
0.6014297605,
-0.010648571,
0.0098120105,
-0.269331187,
-0.2855049968,
0.608017385,
0.3308126926,
0.2935189009,
-0.4507501125,
0.5752784014,
0.4127758145,
-1.1655308008,
-0.7381898761,
0.3014320433,
-0.4792114198,
-0.1815235019,
0.8538587093,
-0.208029151,
-0.1733537614,
-0.4387947917,
-0.134353444,
-0.2873178422,
-0.3792892396,
0.7332202792,
1.1095592976,
-0.3903901875,
-0.1911024749,
-0.7993702292,
0.3116483688,
0.6198257804,
-0.6789678931,
-0.3047132492,
0.4922233224,
0.5114807487,
0.2238291204,
0.8331974745,
-0.2443727404,
0.4645196497,
-0.2506791055,
-0.3248429596,
0.0344163738,
-0.1683035493,
-0.6446748972,
0.2005629241,
0.0410855897,
-0.1495084465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11256v2 | UBC-DLNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Impact of Transfer Learning on African Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-21T21:25:14 | 2023-04-25T07:44:37 | Gagan Bhatia, Ife Adebara, AbdelRahim Elmadany, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe our contribution to the SemEVAl 2023 AfriSenti-SemEval shared
task, where we tackle the task of sentiment analysis in 14 different African
languages. We develop both monolingual and multilingual models under a full
supervised setting (subtasks A and B). We also develop models for the zero-shot
setting (subtask C). Our approach involves experimenting with transfer learning
using six language models, including further pertaining of some of these models
as well as a final finetuning stage. Our best performing models achieve an
F1-score of 70.36 on development data and an F1-score of 66.13 on test data.
Unsurprisingly, our results demonstrate the effectiveness of transfer learning
and fine-tuning techniques for sentiment analysis across multiple languages.
Our approach can be applied to other sentiment analysis tasks in different
languages and domains. | [
-0.589648664,
-0.306835115,
0.2522018552,
0.5783632398,
-0.4169372618,
-0.1847864985,
-0.1251979917,
-0.780705452,
0.4403376281,
0.4820870757,
-0.6227107644,
-0.5242165327,
-0.8227975965,
0.1148465574,
-0.1636515558,
1.0549869537,
-0.1112744883,
0.2122160345,
0.0330867246,
-0.4994057715,
-0.4860603809,
-0.7984522581,
-0.6609562039,
-0.2970404923,
0.723592639,
0.4645328522,
0.3378290832,
-0.3175758123,
0.4212035537,
0.1025977135,
0.0528334416,
0.106435664,
-0.3044659793,
-0.0716674179,
-0.4918943346,
-0.1096061394,
-0.5289830565,
0.0643939227,
-0.0195235107,
1.1324994564,
0.225064829,
0.1635185033,
0.3191097975,
0.6329235435,
-0.6296868324,
0.3041092455,
-0.3340644538,
0.0381870344,
0.1942123473,
0.0969966799,
-0.3529857099,
-0.3678341508,
0.2494622767,
-0.0043568686,
-0.1206986234,
-0.5763076544,
0.7631807923,
-0.1038239151,
-0.8185921311,
-0.2959255278,
-0.2406460345,
0.790846169,
-0.6020271778,
-0.1285409927,
0.1959357262,
0.1628908813,
0.3997089565,
-0.6262777448,
-0.1223390326,
0.2724336982,
0.1179802045,
0.2649765313,
0.002262868,
-0.0107341455,
-0.1765568256,
0.2010736167,
-0.034779232,
-0.0941542089,
-0.479586184,
-0.3212912083,
0.8249328732,
-0.0138805471,
0.0786381811,
-0.2295311093,
-0.4566295445,
0.114735879,
-0.4426215291,
0.1139035746,
0.3780945837,
0.7648498416,
-0.1528346241,
0.1137126982,
-0.2823627889,
0.5772840381,
-0.4037113488,
0.4106705189,
0.417732209,
-0.2931957543,
-0.178953737,
0.0417136364,
0.7064542174,
0.3747270405,
0.4038803875,
0.1414323002,
-0.1630705148,
0.0968565941,
0.2854632735,
-0.6753655672,
-0.2667531371,
-0.1562463641,
-0.5184708238,
-0.6111997962,
0.1014102176,
-1.0158928633,
-0.5155014992,
-0.3888379335,
0.8945611715,
-0.2551458478,
-0.2590797246,
0.1328061372,
0.3967453837,
0.2141238004,
0.698118031,
-0.8088095784,
0.1222432405,
0.2957842052,
0.7288182974,
-0.589702785,
-0.4218362868,
-0.1800819635,
-0.301977694,
-0.0198818278,
0.8361728787,
-0.3468462825,
-0.5812467933,
0.3089528382,
0.3001548648,
-0.1652647406,
-0.3344353139,
0.7342104316,
-0.1935697645,
-0.040351022,
-0.6751638055,
-0.2534638643,
-0.7692276835,
0.2285787463,
-0.5529287457,
0.9333911538,
0.3624050617,
-0.3373259008,
0.0705712438,
-0.7651050091,
-0.9975264668,
-0.2845257223,
0.1187748984,
-0.1575659961,
0.3194461763,
0.3469433784,
0.6237344742,
-0.0279170666,
0.0316988081,
-0.4302151799,
-0.2168978006,
0.1148178279,
-0.4078842103,
1.2297384739,
0.4376454651,
-0.6039465666,
-0.1775912941,
-0.7306697369,
-0.0407511629,
-0.1986250579,
-0.1478240788,
-0.2340861857,
-0.7063814402,
0.1615905017,
0.4258950651,
0.3195738196,
-0.6153111458,
0.3323217332,
-0.0815732628,
0.0406432971,
0.6547610164,
0.4015462697,
0.4152104855,
0.1395390332,
0.7011640072,
0.3231670856,
0.1337891519,
-0.0692774728,
-0.3668305278,
-1.0044629574,
0.0410504192,
0.698246181,
0.451215893,
-0.5526970029,
0.0989053249,
0.1607125252,
-0.3469739854,
-0.6336562634,
0.0752036721,
-0.2061413825,
0.3116973937,
0.4206650257,
-0.5724491477,
-0.7282201052,
-0.8151932955,
-0.1584876776,
-0.0699631944,
0.4699914455,
0.0588448495,
0.6837078333,
-0.4875451922,
0.2372253239,
-0.2305210084,
-0.4431315362,
-0.5673704743,
0.6109719872,
0.2265479416,
0.5274178386,
0.8108325005,
-0.5171523094,
-0.6129676104,
0.1238296106,
-0.8709087372,
-0.3985828757,
-0.0926676765,
-0.204034999,
0.4484027028,
0.3600580394,
-0.1692827493,
0.5364018083,
0.7216942906,
-0.3948882222,
0.3326379657,
0.1686216444,
0.4987609386,
-1.2630645037,
-0.0099809859,
-0.0492658578,
-0.3239934742,
-0.629842639,
-0.0452602282,
-0.1030189544,
-0.2614346147,
-0.7503788471,
0.5240459442,
-0.3809261918,
-0.090341121,
-0.4489705265,
-0.1857263744,
-0.0324799195,
0.4165576696,
0.1199439093,
0.6436883807,
0.5534781218,
-0.596768558,
0.278526485,
0.1749047786,
-0.395771265,
0.753911972,
-0.36569947,
0.1058927774,
0.2132414132,
-0.2572910488,
-0.8477088809,
0.1258793175,
0.0083728582,
-0.627345264,
0.3277097344,
-0.0312970541,
0.0304795802,
-0.221366182,
-0.1837355047,
0.1948399246,
0.2842761576,
-0.4944935441,
0.6954603195,
0.4676976502,
-0.3838262558,
-0.7928118706,
-1.0505082607,
0.0556633845,
-0.0980495736,
-0.4992234409,
-0.0021141877,
0.1141290367,
-0.1138576195,
-0.0509125516,
-0.0656408072,
-0.0827179104,
0.3290407956,
0.3024538457,
0.1720399857,
-0.0266633406,
-0.2151592374,
0.0881350785,
0.089180775,
0.2040285319,
-0.0972422138,
0.510150969,
-0.1964376271,
-0.0865080506,
-0.0956642702,
0.4012156427,
0.3758106232,
-0.0660445169,
1.0550948381,
0.7152375579,
-0.2716098428,
-0.3311215341,
-0.2192175537,
0.1340852827,
-0.3933385611,
0.2847363055,
-0.5955795646,
-0.9219848514,
0.6590705514,
-0.2253230512,
-0.0736509934,
0.5719336271,
0.7480582595,
-0.3506525457,
0.8469364047,
1.0709482431,
-0.5139220357,
0.3829746246,
-0.5352578759,
0.0940295681,
-0.7205771804,
-0.2457751334,
-0.5613579154,
-0.4420433939,
-0.5250042677,
-0.2654165924,
0.2333221585,
0.0322530977,
-0.041634202,
0.397000432,
0.1831029356,
0.1568346322,
0.3276918232,
0.0425218083,
-0.0434657782,
0.2396416664,
-0.4597269893,
0.0099725816,
-0.3567319512,
-0.3538947105,
1.1603401899,
0.2346019298,
0.7945042849,
0.1378104091,
0.903750658,
0.7581364512,
0.2145411074,
-0.8873636127,
0.5820743442,
-0.3596288264,
-0.3006025255,
-0.0956792012,
-0.2662860453,
-0.8562797904,
0.2539607882,
0.0924887285,
-0.6661760807,
0.4565027058,
-0.2978084683,
-0.0992212892,
0.0342318825,
-0.2703782916,
0.925935328,
-0.1043224782,
-0.2847252488,
-0.2164925486,
-0.5790604949,
0.2935611904,
-0.0495302416,
0.3726284802,
-0.1769470572,
0.18868725,
0.6239934564,
-0.1926313192,
0.9855588078,
-0.543230772,
-0.2814024687,
0.5146997571,
0.2346118838,
0.1114734933,
-0.0097830668,
-0.5155033469,
0.2513269782,
0.0483226702,
-0.5297333002,
-0.1966505647,
0.8480571508,
-1.0093646049,
-0.2159349024,
-0.6268523335,
-0.5862514377,
-0.5395768881,
0.0421953574,
0.1224833578,
0.2612063289,
-0.3970159292,
0.2300021052,
0.4374957681,
-0.276124686,
0.4612420201,
0.3893888891,
-0.1760470867,
-0.4183517098,
0.8506023288,
0.0902550742,
0.2385986,
0.1743028462,
-0.0566972345,
-0.2866537273,
-0.3152031898,
-0.3046829104,
0.1762834489,
-1.0484181643,
-0.4362887144,
-0.6456449032,
-0.2751531601,
-0.7151964307,
-0.1853387058,
-0.3012922406,
-0.7935725451,
-0.403008461,
-0.3931476772,
0.1113249883,
0.5408197641,
-0.6110405922,
0.3093978465,
-0.9612067342,
0.0086458791,
0.306969583,
-0.0867743865,
-0.2225957364,
-0.9785428047,
-0.3539723456,
0.0776213706,
-0.3531478643,
-0.8432686925,
0.6461654902,
0.3206121922,
0.5114030242,
0.0953841582,
0.0992251858,
0.5705904961,
0.0256836303,
1.0678403378,
0.1665549874,
-1.1448212862,
0.7843542099,
-0.2166453898,
0.4075633585,
1.1709851027,
0.688423574,
-0.509519279,
-0.0726288557,
-0.4588492513,
-0.6857104897,
0.6629540324,
-0.0480667911,
0.3677440286,
0.0020189087,
0.3153333664,
0.4225871861,
0.2486835718,
-0.8970077038,
-0.3877581656,
-0.1809189618,
-0.4177208245,
-0.0914091691,
-0.4615667462,
0.1182420328,
-0.3360987306,
0.9927731156,
-0.3155438006,
0.357981652,
0.0880674347,
-0.4504994452,
-0.0440436974,
0.4093833268,
0.3942314088,
0.6384989023,
-0.2227540165,
0.0786662996,
0.3397242129,
-0.3843474686,
0.2884017527,
0.1187334582,
-0.33565256,
0.0273979325,
0.3006073833,
0.8944989443,
-0.0595580041,
-0.1575866193,
0.6281098723,
-0.1094571352,
-0.4939840138,
-0.0983057693,
-0.3486072123,
-0.0508384891,
0.1167726666,
0.1856826246,
0.2732642889,
0.3753431439,
-1.0102918148,
0.2986697555,
0.1335683614,
-0.9558303952,
-0.6912055612,
0.3582065403,
0.6351640821,
0.4008784592,
0.4195561707,
-0.0711982101,
-0.7210679054,
0.5098007321,
0.5115883946,
0.8566840887,
-0.344827652,
0.6245678663,
0.4791447222,
0.4029374719,
-0.0358480141,
0.7639605403,
0.1228301823,
-0.9049479365,
-0.528508544,
-0.8798963428,
-0.4451749027,
0.0489140302,
-1.0732581615,
0.5202786922,
-0.0887258202,
-0.026306957,
-0.1570040435,
0.2447713315,
-0.8519266844,
0.546386838,
0.4589576125,
0.9018600583,
-1.0972348452,
1.0852092505,
1.0799235106,
-0.5941416621,
-0.7126803994,
-0.3181444108,
0.0582958497,
-0.8079235554,
0.7427936792,
0.300689429,
-0.1150741056,
-0.0158265047,
-0.4030793309,
-0.5062897205,
0.9272784591,
0.3227454722,
-0.3165881634,
0.3091675639,
0.3300082982,
0.5253450871,
-0.5825971961,
0.1517156214,
0.7823877335,
0.3546947241,
0.1692025959,
-0.7491870522,
-0.2664384544,
-0.0027803385,
-0.3255906403,
0.1814911962,
-0.7533408403,
0.6760545969,
-0.1225813553,
-0.0071432074,
0.1300917864,
1.0715235472,
-0.2814606726,
0.1920713633,
0.3733910024,
0.5911547542,
0.5772663951,
-0.1680919677,
0.7885599136,
-0.3502045274,
0.4306591451,
1.0107527971,
-0.4108428955,
0.7809430361,
0.4882494807,
-0.1896985322,
0.5705031753,
0.6163139343,
0.2105475068,
0.7028404474,
-0.0338007845,
-0.4327838719,
-0.1527445316,
-0.48818928,
-0.351603061,
0.5532456636,
0.3358426094,
-0.3457031846,
-0.131746456,
0.380336225,
-0.0352696404,
0.1144922972,
-0.7382420897,
0.6972754598,
0.4732673168,
-0.5417026281,
0.1545792371,
-0.163123399,
0.7192780972,
-0.5236074924,
0.1523631066,
-0.693690896,
0.3541319072,
-0.1765261739,
-0.9285082817,
0.5893449187,
-0.1025054902,
0.1095010713,
-0.2109513134,
0.9305846691,
-0.4839766622,
-0.7544351816,
0.6024697423,
0.6651084423,
0.2026848644,
-0.0096187936,
-0.6999098063,
0.1826852262,
0.4925526083,
-0.2018810511,
0.6242861748,
0.7760127187,
0.0356277898,
0.2604809403,
0.1112920418,
0.4827950895,
-0.1407736987,
0.6747148633,
0.5708519816,
-0.7963843346,
-0.3479696214,
-0.6534290314,
0.3312399089,
0.0681931451,
-0.2680234611,
0.8213112354,
0.2534181476,
0.9201782346,
-0.4004413188,
1.0382120609,
-0.2475966811,
0.4291695952,
-0.3496676981,
0.3942597806,
-0.5224100947,
0.0743713006,
-0.4601278305,
-1.1416034698,
-0.3121467829,
0.6454811692,
-0.1716028154,
-0.1790297031,
0.8077616096,
0.3438854814,
0.1428439468,
0.1047939584,
0.544893384,
-0.0995633453,
0.1812184751,
0.4962844551,
0.9474563003,
-0.7097293139,
0.5850866437,
-0.6598538756,
0.0582551956,
-0.0092190579,
-0.9341734648,
-0.8821420074,
-0.3466896713,
-0.5568307042,
-0.2946752608,
-0.0438154228,
0.9090839624,
0.4106403589,
-1.2591372728,
-0.4668123424,
0.2419829965,
-0.3338274658,
-0.28783077,
-0.2905159295,
0.2547080219,
-0.4929118752,
-0.5534258485,
0.1727101356,
0.3210716546,
0.0568188876,
-0.1323081404,
0.1361795813,
-0.5557107329,
-0.0116818082,
1.0006319284,
0.0844593719,
-0.2908432782,
-0.5591924787,
-0.2329664528,
-0.0023271607,
-0.1495980322,
0.8328095078,
-0.6171497703,
0.2578931749,
0.4249228835,
0.8586290479,
0.4842740595,
0.0998804197,
0.7435688972,
-0.6692522764,
0.193148002,
0.1816616207,
0.5687281489,
0.4892269373,
-0.2185753435,
1.0694952011,
0.2503378093,
-0.6322295666,
-0.5908304453,
0.1414038539,
-1.1049655676,
-0.2887510657,
1.1205532551,
-0.3912079632,
-0.1780936569,
0.0308110025,
-0.2982126474,
0.1811336726,
-0.3842193484,
0.6300961375,
0.8350631595,
-0.2339232266,
-0.3463559449,
-0.4728784561,
0.3440879881,
0.6170351505,
-1.0681376457,
-0.1860217899,
0.3793291748,
0.1603752822,
-0.0626000091,
0.4943794906,
-0.2048117667,
0.2665863633,
-0.2531437278,
0.3278844655,
0.2989334762,
-0.4248482287,
-0.6957938671,
0.1926525235,
0.0932433158,
-0.1011836007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11223v1 | A Group-Specific Approach to NLP for Hate Speech Detection | 2023-04-21T19:08:49 | 2023-04-21T19:08:49 | Karina Halevy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic hate speech detection is an important yet complex task, requiring
knowledge of common sense, stereotypes of protected groups, and histories of
discrimination, each of which may constantly evolve. In this paper, we propose
a group-specific approach to NLP for online hate speech detection. The approach
consists of creating and infusing historical and linguistic knowledge about a
particular protected group into hate speech detection models, analyzing
historical data about discrimination against a protected group to better
predict spikes in hate speech against that group, and critically evaluating
hate speech detection models through lenses of intersectionality and ethics. We
demonstrate this approach through a case study on NLP for detection of
antisemitic hate speech. The case study synthesizes the current
English-language literature on NLP for antisemitism detection, introduces a
novel knowledge graph of antisemitic history and language from the 20th century
to the present, infuses information from the knowledge graph into a set of
tweets over Logistic Regression and uncased DistilBERT baselines, and suggests
that incorporating context from the knowledge graph can help models pick up
subtle stereotypes. | [
-0.5335828066,
-0.7916017771,
0.1764727384,
-0.1090399846,
-0.0994732827,
0.2517763674,
-0.0743622258,
-0.6422686577,
0.5994207859,
0.5834003687,
-0.3307603002,
-0.5423669219,
-0.7308810353,
-0.1684393287,
-0.5945008397,
1.1322418451,
0.2598437965,
0.0364334509,
0.2861586511,
-0.3620846868,
-0.0273003597,
-0.6717177629,
-0.7045505643,
-0.2209464312,
0.3527599573,
-0.0467219204,
0.4941904545,
0.4937928319,
0.3455770016,
0.1670081317,
-0.1663821042,
-0.1639983058,
-0.3637189567,
0.1451235414,
-0.3755091429,
-0.4479433298,
-0.2355014831,
-0.0282813683,
0.4130722284,
0.5819113255,
-0.1575007439,
0.0138695715,
-0.2222956419,
0.1848240793,
-0.3126137853,
-0.395552814,
-1.0095720291,
0.3235324025,
-0.2798039913,
-0.3095586896,
-0.2702866495,
-0.5248311758,
0.1278179884,
-0.5100420117,
0.421684891,
0.2733005583,
0.3536228836,
0.2455576658,
-0.0986641198,
-0.4685233831,
-0.5559087396,
0.7614958286,
-0.8679587841,
0.2543426752,
0.7276421189,
0.3342501521,
0.0139768701,
-0.4912650585,
-0.4773975909,
-0.0349714383,
-0.1373156458,
-0.1530131698,
-0.4808057845,
-0.0835743845,
0.2650699317,
0.1271889508,
-0.5934814811,
0.4490725994,
-0.3509243131,
-0.1396366805,
0.6928629875,
-0.0398922414,
0.5116823316,
-0.3077030182,
-0.4812876284,
0.5764117837,
-0.3716172278,
-0.0251248721,
0.6886129379,
0.5420613289,
0.2186926305,
0.1982996762,
-0.1180128455,
0.7645983696,
0.029093314,
-0.0531719476,
0.297639668,
-0.0314856991,
0.0615611188,
0.2560114563,
0.5904710889,
0.5607484579,
0.5286431313,
-0.6398534179,
-0.1106393337,
0.3483285308,
0.4081585407,
-0.5721948147,
-0.1783685684,
-0.0398215875,
-0.3996647596,
-0.4792361856,
-0.5223707557,
-1.020606041,
-0.7201978564,
-0.1445823312,
0.2741360068,
-0.3075334132,
-0.43252635,
-0.054231599,
-0.4901313484,
0.0742137581,
0.0351191424,
-0.8390570283,
0.545637548,
0.4346608222,
0.7099640369,
-0.5380403399,
0.2085223347,
-0.6754285693,
0.2611595988,
0.1519488096,
0.6842305064,
-0.7594553232,
-0.1883608997,
0.0595971942,
-0.3787872195,
0.2918083072,
-0.4806841612,
0.4407355189,
-0.5415675044,
0.2290605605,
0.1761596203,
-0.8403366804,
-0.2974619269,
0.2226733714,
-0.427770555,
0.6706420779,
0.2147969753,
-0.9227719903,
0.4063661397,
-0.7897729874,
-0.229234919,
0.5300250649,
-0.4118780494,
-0.4538346231,
-0.0402434431,
0.2625199854,
0.2838368118,
-0.0230773669,
0.3219808042,
-0.3838297427,
-0.0607174523,
-0.0504338257,
0.1632709354,
1.1936527491,
0.0584853403,
-0.5253834128,
0.2176815718,
-0.7009353042,
0.1183488145,
0.309900403,
0.1340525448,
-0.7691161036,
0.1876632869,
0.15218997,
0.1550579518,
-0.1396479905,
-0.7461668849,
-0.0525523387,
-0.3428075612,
0.3440985382,
0.8982324004,
-0.0694369897,
0.1030318588,
-0.2240442187,
0.7407888174,
-0.2559893429,
0.2619971335,
0.5089687705,
-0.7503234148,
-0.5383467674,
-0.0028339203,
-0.0855248943,
0.6980596185,
-0.6269060969,
0.6359164119,
0.1851610243,
-0.266212225,
-0.2764812112,
0.029781362,
0.3872513771,
0.5455282927,
0.8203367591,
-0.3561843038,
-0.89216429,
-0.951454401,
-0.6779486537,
-0.256147027,
-0.0898047164,
0.1277278215,
0.3881192207,
-0.1578740627,
1.2903399467,
-0.4902673364,
-0.3982910514,
-0.4270332754,
0.2158161551,
-0.1516562998,
0.1538900435,
0.7815679312,
-1.0076776743,
-0.5879707336,
-0.2418476641,
-0.4217251539,
-0.431930393,
0.5008143187,
-0.0635891855,
-0.2079526335,
0.5028786659,
0.3924890459,
0.4650129378,
0.5322170258,
-0.6698313355,
0.3572824299,
0.6666581035,
0.0077093444,
-1.0726505518,
-0.3134015501,
0.0925179571,
-0.5041807294,
-1.1008006334,
0.0267392285,
-0.5719627142,
0.1170051321,
-0.5377860665,
0.3420824111,
0.1679906696,
0.006063269,
-0.265142411,
0.2734044194,
-0.56016469,
0.4870300889,
0.2105673552,
0.0795142874,
0.2640562952,
-0.5739113092,
0.6026168466,
0.2671895623,
-0.3934705853,
0.759937644,
-0.2601197958,
0.1750812978,
-0.2253807783,
0.0301224533,
-0.5158582926,
0.0974345729,
0.3497987986,
-0.5544271469,
-0.0309696589,
-0.4312365651,
-0.163829118,
-0.1886119545,
-0.1176485121,
0.6116445065,
0.4288409054,
-0.4123275578,
0.6263163686,
0.9417592883,
-0.1188693568,
-0.5077011585,
-0.6471369267,
-0.0240049381,
-0.676061213,
-0.4692622423,
0.4596905708,
-0.0705944151,
-0.5958322287,
0.0178185198,
0.1375387311,
-0.4549686015,
0.0354065858,
0.1981586516,
-0.1988773942,
-0.0130561125,
0.2106789798,
-0.1983058006,
0.0193017889,
-0.0788017958,
-0.2492876202,
0.8253495693,
-0.1606962681,
0.0582883395,
-0.1974049509,
0.6363137364,
-0.0829679593,
0.0560447015,
0.6556892991,
0.7495661974,
-0.5694854856,
-0.4618168771,
-0.5570878983,
-0.2041203529,
-0.3730852008,
0.3111528456,
0.1518528461,
-1.0624747276,
0.4994924664,
0.1281974018,
0.1811206639,
0.4123952985,
0.4707421064,
0.0443907417,
0.5790191889,
0.6330709457,
-0.2274435461,
0.663679719,
0.0750959143,
0.3600040674,
-0.4577531815,
0.0752053931,
-0.3985916376,
-0.2268917263,
-0.3281655014,
-0.2997828424,
0.313418299,
0.0780854374,
-0.0989982113,
0.4812289774,
-0.6034047604,
0.495621115,
0.2462217063,
-0.0490009375,
0.4675515294,
0.2690469027,
0.2531305254,
-0.3259470761,
-0.450587213,
-0.2763125598,
1.0978488922,
0.2045804709,
0.150388062,
0.3378225863,
0.602229774,
0.8430588841,
0.4151387811,
-0.6064449549,
0.5496505499,
-0.2366921753,
-0.6659545898,
-0.2073398679,
-0.5940352082,
-0.8319709301,
0.2825361788,
-0.1869601905,
-1.1069009304,
-0.1990810931,
0.3109996021,
-0.289239347,
0.6770110726,
-0.2982454002,
0.7920653224,
-0.0285902545,
0.1756188124,
-0.2299047559,
-0.5744747519,
0.2446880192,
-0.2959921062,
0.70026052,
-0.2002030313,
0.1624379605,
1.2179336548,
-0.1671281159,
0.8619164824,
-0.356687665,
0.0580846258,
0.2145122588,
-0.0545551442,
0.3842482567,
-0.5253648162,
-0.1089021415,
0.3452425599,
-0.2934171259,
0.0035559121,
-0.4978456199,
0.4792077243,
-0.359225899,
-0.4180250168,
0.0240162555,
-0.5847175717,
-0.2801533639,
-0.0038730681,
0.2221818119,
0.2051078081,
-0.2129354626,
0.0064617973,
0.5348416567,
-0.1904778779,
0.3047039807,
0.6344388127,
-0.7330016494,
-0.3004149199,
0.8925747275,
0.1859560311,
0.3654935062,
0.2207595408,
0.4576377273,
-0.2078513503,
-0.605535984,
-0.342430234,
0.0608336888,
-0.8314023614,
0.1147798821,
-0.9545119405,
-0.0462465174,
-0.5269086957,
-0.337962985,
-0.066895023,
-0.6198094487,
0.0851037577,
0.0381742977,
0.5919952989,
0.721331358,
-0.169425711,
0.5218434334,
-0.317281276,
0.6269179583,
0.3055535853,
0.1981080174,
-0.1892865598,
-0.8058081269,
0.0130951563,
-0.1971609294,
0.0087728966,
-1.2487868071,
0.437877208,
-0.0793387592,
0.6526831985,
0.2156822085,
0.3188656867,
0.2381545454,
-0.5869965553,
0.6304644346,
0.3995223641,
-0.9092948437,
0.707021594,
-0.1984125972,
-0.3652804196,
0.2907104194,
0.7732080221,
-0.7983804345,
-0.871717453,
-0.8718764186,
-0.8245824575,
0.5984618068,
0.3702360988,
-0.3356838226,
0.1107248589,
0.0044807442,
-0.0501652993,
0.2787175477,
-1.0402585268,
-0.4025116563,
-0.280172497,
-0.2328357548,
0.2493031472,
0.0081006568,
-0.4119470716,
-0.2298475206,
0.6185996532,
0.1017443165,
-0.0465523675,
-0.2581376433,
-0.1646919698,
0.113353774,
0.2951580286,
0.0947870016,
0.8000659347,
-0.077088736,
0.0990946516,
0.2140206695,
-0.2802168727,
0.0164866149,
-0.0019501634,
-0.3477315903,
0.2218778431,
0.147501424,
0.6036983728,
-0.4153698683,
-0.5437366962,
0.7049121261,
0.1434258372,
-0.0118969223,
-0.5939046741,
0.0154496944,
-0.1599497199,
0.2705907822,
0.4606101215,
-0.188908577,
0.2555942237,
-0.3460184038,
0.5245860219,
0.4902974665,
-0.4453575015,
-0.0580102876,
0.6017941236,
0.1793383211,
-0.5985886455,
0.0349445567,
-0.2822149694,
-0.9482850432,
0.63104105,
0.7586567402,
0.6991680264,
-0.7239447832,
0.2531139255,
0.3657033145,
0.3487942219,
0.4759028256,
-0.1196277291,
0.0656524301,
-1.0315054655,
-0.1040732488,
-0.8198378682,
-0.2615694404,
0.3620883524,
-0.592150867,
0.0029470944,
-0.756793201,
-0.1528185755,
0.2884501815,
-0.3146081269,
-0.3681907952,
0.2214648426,
0.2669638395,
0.2511372566,
-1.0302248001,
0.4367391169,
0.2121932507,
-0.2135011256,
-0.2931191921,
-0.054373119,
0.2390563786,
-0.9661185741,
0.6172686815,
0.1509107053,
-0.2866528332,
0.0921421275,
-0.5908048153,
-0.5420008302,
0.251191169,
-0.036800202,
-0.5097001791,
0.0353507027,
0.1513935775,
0.467520684,
-0.5356582999,
-0.1389192641,
0.5619477034,
0.2685762942,
-0.1485068351,
-0.8036487699,
0.1668047011,
-0.0214338694,
-0.1606328487,
0.4762465656,
-0.1507735401,
0.6707865596,
0.2432616651,
-0.2181232423,
-0.5944539905,
0.5300367475,
-0.1783234626,
0.1731392145,
0.9883031249,
0.6404842734,
0.7101673484,
0.2364890128,
0.6636764407,
0.0550772324,
0.0839131325,
1.2179330587,
0.1707579494,
0.4932574034,
0.1432723105,
-0.1870767474,
0.3443733454,
0.2047246993,
-0.0903398544,
0.2945287526,
0.644767046,
-0.6325563788,
-0.290689081,
-0.5794391632,
-0.3669089973,
0.3488140404,
0.5790401697,
-0.5698586106,
-0.4394987226,
0.0914821774,
0.2294206619,
0.2659237683,
-0.8203994036,
0.5724672675,
-0.0929337442,
-0.216426447,
0.2497480065,
0.1713331491,
0.9637749791,
-0.5483544469,
0.0869923234,
0.3038513362,
0.0151964165,
-0.50210464,
-0.720459342,
0.6951539516,
0.4226117432,
-0.1984513998,
-0.1404253393,
0.5831051469,
-0.6629200578,
-0.1447598487,
0.6240735054,
0.1571798027,
0.4395858943,
-0.15471147,
-0.6093537807,
-0.0891154408,
0.365870446,
0.0556858629,
0.2506434917,
-0.1307353526,
-0.1815322191,
0.5036678314,
0.5736832023,
0.0521154255,
0.3306475282,
0.3583981991,
0.7549592853,
-0.6443539262,
-0.6556013823,
-0.9175379276,
0.1850153655,
-0.3641852438,
-0.3926208317,
0.6656093597,
0.4520857632,
0.9574579,
0.4768731296,
1.02401793,
-0.14451693,
0.9503214955,
-0.398704797,
0.6187546849,
-0.5239846706,
-0.2231453955,
-0.413872391,
-0.6727583408,
-0.6640751362,
0.8704241514,
-0.4874845147,
-0.2122873813,
0.5089572072,
0.6568026543,
0.0809707344,
0.5268899202,
0.3427968621,
0.2438396662,
0.6567136049,
0.3907907009,
0.5429056287,
-0.1375846714,
0.5636709332,
-0.0528004803,
-0.3678788245,
-0.0948534608,
-0.7899611592,
-0.7352545857,
-0.5346542001,
-0.4372065663,
-0.3688097298,
-0.0499835573,
0.9506638646,
0.2781573534,
-0.7266233563,
-0.0927684456,
0.0887775123,
0.0790363997,
-0.044739794,
-0.2880414426,
0.103702724,
-0.1565413922,
-0.5541225672,
0.6039325595,
0.1234957129,
-0.0758273453,
-0.1340291053,
0.1605631262,
-0.3242715299,
0.0099624777,
0.5575490594,
0.4195102751,
-0.714741528,
-0.1595831215,
-0.7423062325,
0.214069277,
0.0108609796,
0.999755621,
-0.6506179571,
0.3997281194,
0.2302862704,
0.7295780778,
0.4349618852,
-0.0289515145,
0.3432143927,
-0.8443883061,
0.3103794158,
0.8841278553,
0.4165065587,
0.3169313371,
-0.1657642722,
0.4872534275,
0.5404039621,
-0.4223649204,
-0.8217517734,
0.8057504296,
-0.8266892433,
-0.3666187525,
1.1563529968,
-0.0975981653,
0.0547111556,
-0.889631927,
0.1411068141,
0.2807999849,
-0.3287054896,
0.7885603309,
0.5912619829,
-0.0686586648,
0.084664993,
-0.3954093158,
0.719886601,
0.2958485484,
-0.8161370158,
0.0214534719,
0.5167127252,
0.1396090388,
0.3762099445,
0.8433813453,
0.0354085676,
-0.1452251375,
-0.2226263732,
0.2181239277,
0.0816781521,
-0.2935373187,
0.0083554722,
0.4875951707,
-0.6292709112,
-0.0062019443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11220v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11220v2 | Learn What NOT to Learn: Towards Generative Safety in Chatbots | 2023-04-21T18:59:06 | 2023-04-25T08:16:47 | Leila Khalatbari, Yejin Bang, Dan Su, Willy Chung, Saeed Ghadimi, Hossein Sameti, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational models that are generative and open-domain are particularly
susceptible to generating unsafe content since they are trained on web-based
social data. Prior approaches to mitigating this issue have drawbacks, such as
disrupting the flow of conversation, limited generalization to unseen toxic
input contexts, and sacrificing the quality of the dialogue for the sake of
safety. In this paper, we present a novel framework, named "LOT" (Learn NOT
to), that employs a contrastive loss to enhance generalization by learning from
both positive and negative training signals. Our approach differs from the
standard contrastive learning framework in that it automatically obtains
positive and negative signals from the safe and unsafe language distributions
that have been learned beforehand. The LOT framework utilizes divergence to
steer the generations away from the unsafe subspace and towards the safe
subspace while sustaining the flow of conversation. Our approach is memory and
time-efficient during decoding and effectively reduces toxicity while
preserving engagingness and fluency. Empirical results indicate that LOT
reduces toxicity by up to four-fold while achieving four to six-fold higher
rates of engagingness and fluency compared to baseline models. Our findings are
further corroborated by human evaluation. | [
-0.1201360375,
-0.8720755577,
-0.0482595414,
0.1085599139,
-0.2892595232,
0.281150043,
-0.1063028499,
-0.1767163724,
-0.0481032245,
0.5187196136,
-0.4158925116,
-0.747720778,
-0.5228823423,
-0.3182972968,
-0.5427059531,
1.3558242321,
0.5477132201,
-0.1326001734,
-0.1548033953,
-0.0582155623,
-0.1939906031,
-0.6071896553,
-1.1201677322,
-0.2110728174,
0.5956377983,
0.3955389261,
0.8253985047,
0.2682027519,
0.4340797365,
0.3190664351,
-0.2425843477,
-0.0728547797,
-1.2706714869,
0.2285425812,
-0.2523031533,
-0.6855953932,
-0.0885308459,
-0.2770072818,
0.0757504031,
0.8272061348,
-0.3690638244,
-0.4813049436,
0.1534484625,
0.7729003429,
-0.7336990833,
0.1682686955,
-0.7535356879,
0.3146760464,
0.2164917737,
-0.6240632534,
-0.7495714426,
-0.3460041881,
0.2872158289,
-0.69923985,
0.3664146662,
-0.1527761072,
0.7110549808,
0.208064869,
-0.3150336742,
-0.2838889956,
-0.754327774,
0.9535412788,
-0.3296848536,
0.3063045144,
0.7770582438,
0.3361703455,
-0.2531578541,
-0.4038839042,
-0.521656394,
-0.0307866428,
0.2362354845,
0.2912884653,
-0.179507345,
0.3537055254,
-0.0768007264,
0.2516413331,
-0.577567935,
0.0870999172,
-0.5633918047,
-0.4962765574,
0.6416716576,
0.2034853697,
0.4664120078,
0.1127944142,
-0.6041443348,
-0.4893536866,
-0.8390920162,
-0.1655745804,
0.3988130391,
0.2250278443,
-0.5556612611,
0.1865100861,
-0.1777562499,
0.2626855373,
0.0974155962,
-0.2714044452,
0.3510661423,
0.0323103666,
-0.1590669006,
-0.3546315134,
0.8263306022,
0.6859286427,
0.1794762164,
-0.4455819726,
0.1748511791,
0.1957061291,
0.2409300208,
-0.8984884024,
-0.552370131,
0.2588134408,
-0.4885844886,
-0.8466143012,
-0.2020009905,
-0.9995476007,
-0.6410726905,
0.0902051479,
0.3841251135,
-0.8286873102,
-0.2100523412,
0.1206315085,
-0.2996105552,
0.3149518669,
0.3803574741,
-0.9464253187,
0.2783821523,
0.3988262117,
0.7017931342,
-0.1644937247,
0.1184095666,
-0.6486564875,
0.176500991,
-0.6227676272,
0.5390071869,
-0.3354769945,
-0.9457467794,
0.1697188616,
-0.1348124892,
0.1062594578,
-0.7524240017,
0.1500931084,
-0.6896501184,
0.4474343956,
0.1241004914,
-0.2657237351,
-0.304356426,
0.1627884507,
-0.394007355,
0.2438015044,
0.0853479132,
-0.5391737223,
0.3153986931,
-0.5010197163,
-0.9470413923,
-0.0148200998,
-0.2024855614,
-0.5229568481,
-0.147201404,
-0.1531940252,
0.3056461513,
0.104783453,
0.2273432463,
-0.4439887404,
-0.3000129461,
0.4112573266,
-0.772188127,
0.8974964619,
0.342970401,
-0.1166372895,
0.2275513113,
-0.5340771675,
-0.1507179737,
0.0206861198,
-0.4346956909,
-0.2904605269,
0.1032402813,
-0.0515259989,
0.3714136481,
-0.2102412432,
-0.2930362821,
-0.4792263508,
-0.6271012425,
0.3024969995,
0.8095884919,
0.2224360555,
0.7299141884,
-0.5967487097,
0.6208566427,
0.4604821205,
0.3708094954,
-0.0973968655,
-0.361035347,
-1.1175621748,
0.0460655428,
0.1046578884,
0.6021130681,
-1.471444726,
0.6154399514,
-0.052722726,
-0.3437528014,
-0.2960477471,
0.2329749465,
0.6922425032,
0.4009459019,
0.3562114835,
-0.5153384209,
-0.300924778,
-0.4729698598,
0.3521257937,
-0.3630882502,
-0.2190662324,
0.2875901163,
0.1605811417,
-0.2060456723,
0.5852715969,
-0.4667322934,
-0.1824070811,
-0.3108241856,
0.084791787,
-0.3785974383,
0.6352649927,
0.3795623779,
-1.0333845615,
-0.4261771142,
0.0312968791,
-0.9247509241,
0.2568452954,
-0.2490725815,
-0.4212916493,
0.2081413418,
0.6900280714,
-0.4902448654,
0.4747274816,
0.5763722062,
-0.2005654424,
0.0501952246,
0.037978854,
-0.2098507583,
-1.1682124138,
-0.0936905369,
-0.0387437679,
-0.1549928635,
-0.7602257133,
-0.0091193905,
-0.1863086969,
-0.3088967502,
-0.8453221917,
0.5086917877,
-0.1599891931,
0.5003962517,
-0.2058305144,
0.1944484264,
0.096090287,
0.6241747141,
-0.0041363807,
0.856281817,
0.6175753474,
-0.9525228739,
-0.0185839701,
0.451549083,
0.0121961553,
0.6869267225,
-0.4580673277,
0.1889230311,
-0.4804813564,
0.2965276837,
-0.8420035839,
-0.1344816238,
0.4762949646,
-0.6460517645,
0.2989549935,
-0.0655568317,
-0.2951158285,
-0.061900083,
-0.4888606668,
0.1161479428,
0.9631034136,
-0.3419345021,
0.3609113395,
0.5007505417,
-0.13656196,
-0.6530384421,
-0.7729077339,
-0.0556755923,
-0.4382588565,
-0.4322513044,
0.1592828482,
-0.3207874596,
-0.2540205419,
-0.2622717023,
-0.0103507098,
-0.2264030725,
0.3590164185,
0.3361216486,
0.2975583076,
0.1352192909,
0.5827884674,
0.2528977096,
-0.3421390355,
-0.0578626394,
0.1308011264,
0.7792483568,
0.2419566363,
-0.1768174171,
-0.4511249959,
0.2243610919,
0.1198310778,
0.1702973545,
0.8882331848,
0.4505962431,
-0.0529822856,
-0.5366755724,
-0.2071729898,
-0.5115969777,
-0.6344974041,
0.4187775254,
0.0352565423,
-0.8901482821,
0.4720330536,
-0.0744814053,
-0.0416641012,
0.2459594607,
0.3507587612,
-0.2795259356,
0.5753897429,
0.7120317221,
-0.1293200552,
0.7315952778,
-0.3852861524,
0.2979115844,
-0.28521806,
-0.1211529225,
-0.0966600776,
-0.1062203348,
-0.607631743,
-0.7841006517,
0.2511476874,
0.1064345986,
-0.2344942689,
0.1043377742,
-0.1995951533,
0.6091590524,
0.4061593711,
0.3291194439,
0.3643656075,
0.1240918413,
0.1428523809,
0.2097084969,
-0.7451844215,
-0.3519626558,
1.2353838682,
0.2130390108,
0.9785690308,
0.3745844364,
0.9474403262,
0.3515940011,
0.4987737536,
-0.6801432371,
0.7446733117,
-0.213240996,
-0.6818038821,
-0.4518043101,
-0.7398208976,
-1.3030247688,
0.4001419842,
-0.1410840601,
-0.5421999693,
0.1291808039,
0.1052479371,
-0.4035987854,
0.3163222969,
-0.8919131756,
0.5001978874,
-0.0803648308,
-0.3839635253,
-0.4198731184,
-0.9509920478,
0.2436603308,
0.027877003,
0.2359226048,
-0.0672296807,
0.0394599065,
0.47550717,
-0.2698497474,
1.5131368637,
0.0088988077,
-0.2096792608,
0.6075143814,
0.2473688871,
0.3562168479,
-0.0626859665,
-0.0428895243,
0.0981151238,
-0.457295835,
-0.5427016616,
-0.4738476872,
0.4971335232,
-0.801759541,
-0.3874937892,
-0.0475247279,
-0.3747362792,
-0.335072726,
0.0398590192,
0.5166890025,
0.1671728045,
-0.563449204,
0.4114036858,
1.0788863897,
-0.8422248363,
0.4603377581,
0.3797530532,
-0.0514421612,
-0.4096719325,
1.3829169273,
-0.3769357502,
0.8741408587,
0.6664382815,
0.0271484219,
-0.1403721124,
-0.5340102911,
-0.1914992929,
-0.2088041455,
-0.9399818778,
-0.3273139894,
-0.5923216343,
-0.3883464038,
-0.2424842864,
-0.1935963333,
-0.0293060318,
-0.2376459986,
-0.5193334222,
-0.3311920762,
0.3732902408,
0.2250852436,
-0.0212768912,
0.5236100554,
-0.6937833428,
0.2156556845,
0.4418161511,
0.4214628339,
0.1556873322,
-0.3610496223,
0.0150038516,
-0.0031193756,
-0.810531497,
-0.5731381178,
0.4513557255,
0.2629094422,
0.4742636681,
0.8376247287,
0.5548766851,
0.2735201418,
-0.1516957581,
0.51012218,
0.6038195491,
-0.725209415,
0.4497202933,
-0.5965943933,
-0.0599403232,
0.6485677958,
0.3267600536,
-0.7217036486,
-0.4605368972,
-0.8487071991,
-0.9325916767,
0.3981480002,
0.3651738167,
0.8710897565,
-0.361312449,
-0.2904421985,
0.4000501633,
0.454115957,
-0.9083076119,
-0.3573544621,
-0.1998602003,
-0.3024220169,
-0.0232820138,
-0.1598550528,
-0.317840308,
0.1749799848,
0.5093671679,
-0.0697789639,
0.2605344653,
-0.3214498758,
-0.2090455741,
-0.0801385492,
0.4083790183,
0.255775243,
0.1503146142,
0.0595282726,
0.1177584976,
0.1103726327,
-0.2873096168,
0.0144528328,
-0.0491359755,
-0.231269598,
-0.2960719764,
0.2926598191,
0.8101863861,
0.286794126,
-0.901037395,
0.7576828003,
0.1940046698,
-0.4007154703,
-0.1575997323,
0.5393412709,
0.0891747177,
-0.0341756195,
0.0012452574,
0.0498587452,
0.2589433491,
-0.5814971328,
0.3643544018,
0.224566713,
-0.4755387902,
-0.2265741676,
0.461907804,
0.8693339229,
-0.2376738638,
0.6240727901,
-0.500015378,
-0.2009086311,
0.5355541706,
0.4327283204,
0.8272069097,
-0.285775423,
0.6964439154,
0.1164045855,
-0.0635329038,
0.1848546863,
0.2675510943,
-0.0387318432,
-1.0805114508,
-0.2634437978,
-0.2506197095,
-0.4752019048,
0.2258743793,
-0.402284503,
-0.1188115925,
-0.8326248527,
-0.1763729006,
-0.1971215606,
-0.5835702419,
-0.5637916327,
0.2167029232,
-0.0309330802,
0.2986757755,
-0.8307834864,
0.5033908486,
0.1889009625,
-0.6745430231,
-0.3045301735,
0.2890301943,
-0.020839775,
-0.8722983003,
0.4772306383,
0.2683396637,
-0.0810321644,
-0.1746629179,
-0.6869410872,
-0.5823740959,
0.7811326981,
0.1579001099,
-0.5482243299,
0.0718836337,
0.0348263271,
0.7088307142,
0.167356953,
-0.1393010616,
-0.0238072649,
-0.0847501233,
0.4199139774,
-0.5467171073,
-0.0856938288,
-0.293538034,
0.0254545659,
0.1594603211,
-0.7708047628,
0.5172379017,
-0.5019806027,
-0.6042793393,
0.0628799796,
0.3853264451,
0.0765811205,
0.3769051433,
0.4888343811,
0.3359804749,
0.6390337944,
0.0398175232,
0.922001183,
-0.2077492028,
0.2124479562,
0.9714369774,
-0.1375466287,
0.8150057197,
0.436101526,
-0.3485046625,
0.6202182174,
0.318380177,
0.2533445358,
0.865383327,
0.4672544003,
-0.5621680617,
-0.3296208978,
0.0606639199,
-0.2161356956,
0.2550094724,
0.648416698,
-0.4710184038,
-0.2555936277,
0.1735346913,
0.100791201,
0.141354084,
0.1152891964,
1.1532663107,
0.2892328203,
-0.3246953487,
0.6289948821,
-0.376732558,
0.841121316,
-0.3170906901,
-0.1202460155,
-0.3743780851,
0.285471797,
-0.0239469372,
-0.4860175252,
0.2295534909,
-0.3304255903,
0.10197182,
0.0500282794,
0.6193532944,
-0.4425996542,
-0.2659868002,
0.4043393433,
0.5823552608,
0.135961175,
0.1518992931,
-0.6704040766,
-0.2023902684,
0.0946112946,
0.116358377,
0.5147402287,
0.5350057483,
-0.0667574629,
1.0524953604,
0.6772602201,
-0.3915564716,
-0.2733719647,
0.2700260282,
0.9128837585,
-0.7076410055,
-0.6301958561,
-0.5621785522,
0.5911992788,
-0.1990104765,
-0.2804524601,
0.4427128136,
0.3127781451,
0.9914034009,
-0.0599598065,
1.0705761909,
0.0440420471,
0.2792796791,
-0.457965374,
0.8778143525,
-0.1697206944,
0.4288525283,
-0.2527171671,
-0.4407707453,
-0.3988884091,
0.7113791108,
-0.3902015686,
0.2698872983,
0.5011404157,
0.8918515444,
0.262311697,
-0.0287022032,
0.7584593892,
0.1056120396,
0.4399251044,
0.6313148737,
1.040460825,
-0.293994844,
0.9672307372,
-0.2191698551,
-0.2543485761,
-0.373617053,
-0.5715094805,
-1.1410384178,
-0.3680071533,
-0.3442213833,
-0.5973690152,
0.4719628394,
0.6214948893,
0.8390101194,
-0.7675058246,
-0.0907812566,
-0.4599570632,
0.2095646113,
0.0164743178,
-0.2270348966,
0.179055199,
-0.5813857317,
-0.566486001,
0.282219559,
0.1864519119,
0.4572221339,
-0.129183203,
-0.2596279085,
0.2650983632,
0.0591023453,
0.7958415151,
0.4041606486,
-0.3894115388,
-0.1767901182,
-0.3581596613,
-0.2035400867,
0.2489353865,
0.3435337543,
-0.5949624777,
0.5335270762,
0.4330555201,
0.6087558866,
0.2655782104,
-0.0123522161,
0.6986685991,
-0.8124166727,
0.4078322053,
0.3152673542,
-0.0326219685,
0.6062511802,
-0.4420464039,
0.5583290458,
0.1504371017,
-0.1870701164,
-0.3232108951,
0.4549013972,
-0.8691925406,
-0.4780005217,
1.3276673555,
-0.1047820896,
0.0789083466,
-0.4990571737,
-0.2427562922,
0.2702414691,
-0.7771297693,
1.2730402946,
0.3233761191,
0.1123751178,
0.0701544583,
-0.3672080934,
0.6681878567,
0.4273720384,
-1.0230488777,
0.0358749591,
0.5389739871,
0.4589425623,
0.1623777002,
0.7260869145,
-0.3011134863,
0.3431469798,
0.2539600432,
0.1573487669,
0.4461669028,
-0.2058651596,
-0.2698310614,
0.1771560609,
-0.0534907877,
-0.4894348979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11158v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11158v2 | Emergent and Predictable Memorization in Large Language Models | 2023-04-21T17:58:31 | 2023-05-31T19:09:45 | Stella Biderman, USVSN Sai Prashanth, Lintang Sutawika, Hailey Schoelkopf, Quentin Anthony, Shivanshu Purohit, Edward Raff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Memorization, or the tendency of large language models (LLMs) to output
entire sequences from their training data verbatim, is a key concern for safely
deploying language models. In particular, it is vital to minimize a model's
memorization of sensitive datapoints such as those containing personal
identifiable information (PII). The prevalence of such undesirable memorization
can pose issues for model trainers, and may even require discarding an
otherwise functional model. We therefore seek to predict which sequences will
be memorized before a large model's full train-time by extrapolating the
memorization behavior of lower-compute trial runs. We measure memorization of
the Pythia model suite and plot scaling laws for forecasting memorization,
allowing us to provide equi-compute recommendations to maximize the reliability
(recall) of such predictions. We additionally provide further novel discoveries
on the distribution of memorization scores across models and data. We release
all code and data necessary to reproduce the results in this paper at
https://github.com/EleutherAI/pythia | [
-0.0201105848,
-0.7032131553,
0.489189595,
0.1911761612,
-0.048022069,
-0.1940626353,
-0.3486931026,
-0.2790477574,
-0.0902653039,
0.4307102263,
-0.2281405181,
-0.3060883284,
-0.2983698547,
-0.5793042779,
-0.7030439973,
0.9945713878,
0.1256603748,
-0.0778024346,
-0.1900207698,
0.0908681229,
-0.1284023374,
-0.9879438877,
-0.4445405006,
-0.5720310807,
0.7198799253,
0.3919657171,
0.4152532816,
0.9429175258,
0.3068933785,
0.1847157925,
-0.2406692505,
-0.3264124691,
-0.6005903482,
0.3431568742,
0.0126235038,
-0.8436380029,
-0.4003297091,
-0.3909813762,
0.8989549875,
0.6641561389,
-0.4059177339,
0.2627128363,
-0.2159356326,
0.5349975228,
-0.4880280495,
0.1886268556,
-0.7596519589,
0.0007508915,
-0.2123391032,
-0.2819551229,
-0.8110513091,
-0.2011599094,
0.1954208463,
-0.4809080362,
0.3667047918,
0.0760712028,
0.4745372832,
-0.1923586577,
-0.3138008714,
-0.1514633745,
-1.0023372173,
0.6682887673,
-0.3605293036,
0.1065640524,
0.3820742667,
0.3889676034,
-0.1594966799,
-0.8605879545,
-0.2460010052,
-0.2190519422,
0.203321293,
0.0283500832,
-0.1646532267,
-0.0165270083,
0.4105704427,
0.4681439102,
-0.4632719457,
0.246550113,
-0.37277475,
-0.2181467265,
0.5479201078,
0.2875758111,
0.1362319291,
0.313403964,
-0.1129889116,
-0.1150330827,
-0.9053382874,
-0.2346966416,
0.3387748599,
0.2773770392,
0.0362736918,
0.6379948258,
-0.0697467625,
0.1929736584,
-0.0978222862,
-0.0003366228,
0.2432653308,
0.0818452761,
-0.1686387658,
0.1386241913,
0.6682849526,
0.1739287674,
0.5245432258,
-0.0829857066,
-0.2448952198,
-0.329750061,
0.0951029584,
-0.8319737315,
-0.9517223835,
-0.061203856,
-0.3165568709,
-0.1352139562,
-0.1662747711,
-0.7558438778,
-0.5828209519,
-0.1151014715,
0.4308229089,
-0.6790731549,
-0.3276436329,
-0.254974246,
0.1427871734,
-0.177262187,
0.4179406166,
-1.0046389103,
0.2446554154,
0.5283947587,
0.8802940845,
-0.0235124063,
-0.6282548308,
-0.6230988503,
0.3295971155,
-0.2989491522,
0.4191526771,
-0.13059856,
-0.2405166328,
0.0972516611,
-0.1421542019,
-0.2787513733,
-0.4814564288,
0.1964762062,
-0.6108341813,
-0.3392267525,
-0.1416782439,
-0.8665748835,
-0.3293590844,
-0.0197653994,
-0.725082159,
0.6656112671,
-0.0941217542,
-0.6819836497,
0.1732707173,
-0.0474306643,
-0.297565937,
-0.0504860952,
0.1691286564,
-0.743452549,
0.3869045675,
-0.0218797233,
0.4734470844,
-0.1990597099,
0.2811630964,
-0.4489021003,
-0.3102468848,
0.3683724403,
-0.6461193562,
0.2675686777,
0.1255325675,
-0.1767088622,
0.2512516081,
-0.6263898015,
0.2521930337,
0.3153804839,
-0.4032409787,
-0.0478868224,
0.1058930159,
0.0986448154,
0.1281210929,
0.1623746157,
-0.0529249683,
0.1505129188,
-0.1813851893,
0.3064460456,
0.9501181245,
0.1412163377,
0.3777750432,
-0.6286110878,
0.3770159185,
0.1948813349,
0.0509599112,
-0.6015875936,
-0.3521434069,
-0.7753323317,
-0.2328377515,
0.0886943564,
0.3903330863,
-0.2036172748,
0.0892361626,
-0.5248708725,
-0.8497983813,
0.280462265,
0.1784724146,
0.5967028141,
-0.0041713957,
0.1481023133,
-0.1715826541,
-0.5333181024,
-0.7384132743,
-0.3588247895,
-0.3940604925,
0.0308856275,
0.1151837185,
0.6852974296,
0.0166558716,
0.5426767468,
-0.3324352801,
0.0377193242,
-0.458597213,
0.089922972,
0.1720133424,
0.4003189802,
0.289521575,
-0.6777721047,
-0.4079233706,
-0.0958206356,
-0.1907992959,
0.3239153922,
-0.0877707377,
0.0560548492,
0.3394435644,
0.6335403919,
-0.5704094768,
0.2906912267,
0.4167551398,
-0.2917850912,
0.5851331949,
-0.5070866942,
-0.2250249833,
-0.9146637321,
0.2349494249,
-0.2115724236,
-0.1293745786,
-0.7592461705,
-0.2166871279,
0.0850690454,
0.1276653707,
-0.205446437,
0.3549304008,
-0.4601322711,
-0.3186877966,
0.1356014609,
-0.2651384175,
-0.3711492121,
0.4865919948,
-0.0264840648,
0.7601228952,
0.3361365497,
-0.7658665776,
0.2086302042,
0.0375209339,
-0.5845208168,
-0.2447847575,
-0.5621917844,
0.1591488719,
0.0620615743,
0.0722148716,
-0.7610059977,
-0.4358535409,
-0.178052485,
-0.5134492517,
0.4180463552,
-0.3876366913,
-0.6881230474,
-0.152526781,
-0.0489798523,
0.434887141,
0.7054690719,
-0.4890116155,
0.4569361806,
0.4467523992,
-0.0618110485,
-0.3791024685,
-0.4949387312,
-0.4021253288,
-0.4705350101,
-0.0736255795,
0.1416166872,
-0.1817019135,
-0.1327391863,
-0.3932151794,
-0.0149950534,
-0.1386756152,
0.352412492,
0.6133358479,
0.2223276198,
-0.1126391068,
0.4063804746,
-0.4158112407,
0.1888341755,
0.2007965744,
-0.330409795,
0.9727454185,
-0.2988978922,
-0.4493419528,
-0.1169653758,
0.0727385655,
0.8351771832,
-0.1600293815,
1.0058315992,
0.4461478889,
-0.5366997719,
-0.1896774173,
-0.4585769773,
-0.0505083613,
-0.3571483493,
0.7883229852,
-0.3214461207,
-0.3373650908,
0.7958523631,
-0.0766167119,
-0.0023117014,
0.3236267567,
0.6830567122,
-0.0030360434,
1.0830901861,
0.7187606692,
-0.1901286244,
0.7538101673,
-0.3416352868,
0.0448857807,
-0.7457680106,
-0.2940878868,
-0.2133649439,
0.0439842269,
-0.5660971999,
-0.3815848231,
0.21713835,
0.4269579351,
-0.4740388393,
0.0088831438,
-0.0206166171,
0.5187056065,
0.788167119,
-0.0224172696,
0.2622634768,
0.2612814307,
-0.2519925535,
0.0833325163,
-0.6494036913,
-0.383377403,
1.5776885748,
0.408645004,
0.6510503292,
0.0358711891,
0.8928014636,
0.0338646732,
0.3321520686,
-0.8488798141,
0.5162297487,
0.1235625222,
-0.6145702004,
-0.3211490214,
-0.5786086321,
-0.830697298,
0.0451577269,
-0.0135413427,
-1.0754989386,
-0.2377075851,
0.4636160731,
-0.3135112226,
0.5892499089,
-0.7687928081,
0.7915219665,
-0.2704125941,
-0.470235914,
-0.3667355776,
-0.5117090344,
0.3919167519,
-0.0753479674,
0.0770046487,
-0.0655881315,
0.1844868064,
0.7365042567,
-0.0903472081,
0.7015736103,
-0.0653177276,
0.1844662428,
0.2611215413,
0.3352386951,
0.5736207366,
-0.0082478011,
-0.026409125,
-0.1427613348,
0.0455443524,
-0.2723160982,
-0.2375983894,
0.6318075061,
-0.8969575763,
-0.3404872119,
-0.5216217637,
-0.5260378718,
-0.1009568051,
0.1522193551,
0.5344551206,
0.389986068,
-0.3929026127,
0.0735483542,
1.0676062107,
-0.0667749941,
0.4631355703,
0.2987021208,
-0.5250051022,
-0.4408798814,
1.0765664577,
0.3032018244,
0.5011149645,
0.3304411471,
0.1004729867,
-0.0753519088,
-0.9259904623,
-0.0571039803,
0.2654103935,
-0.932882607,
-0.0327133127,
-0.3793973029,
-0.3272046745,
-0.1498006433,
0.0261557363,
-0.3903365731,
-0.5841281414,
-0.2589041293,
-0.0829945728,
0.3826467991,
0.7545022368,
0.1183726564,
0.4373943806,
-0.7651753426,
-0.1178502515,
0.041037973,
0.2839317918,
0.1427890509,
-0.6917129159,
-0.4480884969,
-0.0867464393,
-0.3155195713,
-0.5879998803,
0.6980538964,
0.3670695126,
0.5376631618,
0.3890313506,
-0.1222296506,
0.444559902,
-0.4268311858,
0.4579710662,
0.3071672916,
-0.7320619226,
0.5054423809,
-0.6655327678,
0.25954777,
0.3474655151,
0.170170933,
-0.6079787016,
-0.2744121253,
-0.7928242087,
-1.1905838251,
0.7629709244,
-0.0976447016,
0.0196154732,
-0.009792801,
0.4025918245,
0.0238066036,
0.3344906867,
-0.6539703608,
-0.2122738361,
-0.0608744361,
-0.3602003753,
-0.5235333443,
-0.5091244578,
0.0233462621,
-0.1898838729,
0.7462714911,
-0.0966228098,
0.3660831153,
-0.0861515254,
-0.5727884173,
-0.096660614,
0.0564559028,
0.5339345336,
0.7356353402,
-0.2226291001,
-0.0122693088,
0.110728085,
-0.7224740386,
0.0882124528,
-0.1619794816,
-0.2512121797,
-0.1056802869,
0.460087657,
0.8206421137,
0.186843276,
-0.7904568315,
0.3383918405,
0.0735358447,
0.1669872254,
-1.0755691528,
0.0326716863,
0.2655079663,
0.1123443544,
0.2543632984,
0.0046834764,
-0.0956352651,
-0.7479484677,
0.2276626229,
0.0066212104,
-0.2115378976,
-0.4830068946,
0.5066984892,
-0.233503595,
-0.1286251992,
1.0360687971,
-0.0260178819,
-0.615447402,
0.8167200685,
0.584487617,
0.7180159688,
-0.5232667923,
-0.0328221954,
0.6792793274,
0.1733966023,
-0.4729933739,
0.0037513233,
0.1101383418,
-0.5103927851,
0.0683586225,
-0.552495718,
-0.2383249253,
0.1556187272,
-0.8106172085,
0.2786200941,
-0.7690220475,
-0.1412646174,
-0.1212708652,
-0.0457253642,
-0.4968946874,
0.1811013371,
0.4961226285,
0.7390971184,
-0.8508360386,
1.0688734055,
0.3519343138,
-0.3811015785,
-0.9421363473,
0.2317333221,
0.1287724376,
-0.6926092505,
0.5020402074,
0.3996500671,
0.1923044175,
0.1109086871,
-0.0285239425,
-0.911151886,
1.3297501802,
0.5287985206,
-0.7114875913,
-0.1976331919,
-0.156924814,
0.4027113914,
-0.2805908918,
0.5834669471,
0.7493013144,
-0.0178782083,
0.2645760477,
-0.8347729445,
-0.1086993441,
-0.2729908526,
0.1024297103,
0.3625304997,
-0.5954436064,
1.1088701487,
-0.6412667036,
-0.1841823459,
0.2848876715,
0.5376141667,
0.304287672,
0.406647563,
0.225610733,
0.4515819252,
1.005952239,
-0.1946627498,
1.1340960264,
-0.1644407362,
0.2800424993,
1.4683669806,
-0.0581144206,
1.0678319931,
0.5034744143,
-0.1638624072,
0.2476540953,
0.6334165335,
-0.0320962556,
0.4254086316,
0.4661006033,
-0.2359339893,
-0.1895858347,
0.1668058485,
-0.1555736661,
0.3252989054,
0.4923861921,
-0.6265162826,
0.2509478927,
-0.1776263714,
0.063766636,
-0.0407440215,
-0.5934737325,
0.8137440085,
0.0139873996,
-0.7790173292,
0.6165038347,
-0.1688168347,
0.1818421185,
-0.6715574861,
0.2547279298,
-0.2286133319,
0.6874886155,
-0.0154857282,
-0.4970755279,
0.0957287252,
-0.3326369524,
-0.3874208629,
-0.1026299447,
0.1297234148,
-0.5222565532,
-0.3408159912,
0.3654631972,
0.3316237926,
0.0553282648,
-0.126586616,
-0.2565835416,
-0.2346558869,
-0.0812154561,
-0.716725111,
0.6092748046,
0.2725604475,
-0.3527342975,
1.1008833647,
0.5101910233,
0.2314908355,
0.6177961826,
0.1822574139,
0.7205935717,
-0.5262795687,
-0.4749318063,
-0.9361724257,
0.2260334641,
-0.0155055318,
-0.2728026807,
0.7265283465,
0.6965128779,
0.6485726833,
-0.1828671098,
0.6586671472,
0.2200650424,
0.3205261528,
-0.5532671213,
0.7432792783,
-0.1733935028,
0.2729352415,
-0.0788654014,
-0.7559275627,
-0.1187251434,
0.3371680975,
-0.2823116481,
0.125150606,
0.837220192,
0.6472226381,
0.0024307107,
-0.045505859,
0.285240829,
0.2766752839,
0.3417307734,
0.9948380589,
0.8455993533,
-0.302067697,
0.8754038215,
-0.4593449235,
0.0238999203,
-0.4382191002,
-0.5458436012,
-0.8773579001,
-0.7155596614,
-0.2997809052,
-0.3504869938,
0.0278036129,
0.8833791614,
0.5505588055,
-0.8981897235,
-0.3579607904,
-0.5345162749,
0.0777531713,
-0.2398841679,
-0.1135728508,
0.3107337952,
-0.2177721262,
-0.49002859,
0.028037101,
-0.0109951254,
0.4619873762,
0.0545196384,
-0.116767399,
-0.0444623753,
0.0132264597,
0.0918320492,
0.4630472362,
-0.5338574648,
0.0083624953,
-0.151960209,
-0.0392332338,
0.0368580036,
1.0495694876,
-0.4576464593,
0.3728558123,
0.4130929112,
0.1940699816,
0.81260252,
-0.2611935437,
0.8136789799,
-0.5470449328,
0.2079243064,
0.3751730919,
0.5741201043,
0.2939653695,
-0.2673883438,
0.2075172663,
0.1804939508,
-0.4937195182,
-1.0185822248,
0.4508930743,
-0.3978568912,
0.0070558209,
1.0476126671,
-0.7101595998,
-0.4467815459,
0.1453412175,
0.1451388896,
0.3839511275,
-0.1519153416,
0.7805003524,
0.7852926254,
0.2728998363,
-0.2588028312,
-0.780868113,
0.4611769021,
0.47146523,
-0.5333089232,
0.6723157763,
0.532288909,
0.4070800543,
0.1586095244,
0.5635278225,
-0.0374061093,
0.403960675,
0.1984997392,
-0.0238235723,
-0.0915801972,
-0.7582708597,
-0.5809602141,
0.0916884765,
0.5253029466,
0.0342822373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03512v1 | Building Multimodal AI Chatbots | 2023-04-21T16:43:54 | 2023-04-21T16:43:54 | Min Young Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work aims to create a multimodal AI system that chats with humans and
shares relevant photos. While earlier works were limited to dialogues about
specific objects or scenes within images, recent works have incorporated images
into open-domain dialogues. However, their response generators are unimodal,
accepting text input but no image input, thus prone to generating responses
contradictory to the images shared in the dialogue. Therefore, this work
proposes a complete chatbot system using two multimodal deep learning models:
an image retriever that understands texts and a response generator that
understands images. The image retriever, implemented by ViT and BERT, selects
the most relevant image given the dialogue history and a database of images.
The response generator, implemented by ViT and GPT-2/DialoGPT, generates an
appropriate response given the dialogue history and the most recently retrieved
image. The two models are trained and evaluated on PhotoChat, an open-domain
dialogue dataset in which a photo is shared in each session. In automatic
evaluation, the proposed image retriever outperforms existing baselines VSE++
and SCAN with Recall@1/5/10 of 0.1/0.3/0.4 and MRR of 0.2 when ranking 1,000
images. The proposed response generator also surpasses the baseline Divter with
PPL of 16.9, BLEU-1/2 of 0.13/0.03, and Distinct-1/2 of 0.97/0.86, showing a
significant improvement in PPL by -42.8 and BLEU-1/2 by +0.07/0.02. In human
evaluation with a Likert scale of 1-5, the complete multimodal chatbot system
receives higher image-groundedness of 4.3 and engagingness of 4.3, along with
competitive fluency of 4.1, coherence of 3.9, and humanness of 3.1, when
compared to other chatbot variants. The source code is available at:
https://github.com/minniie/multimodal_chat.git. | [
-0.3741658926,
-0.7753372192,
0.3957868814,
0.1684183329,
-0.2572719753,
0.3114008307,
-0.3307545483,
-0.840991497,
0.2903910279,
0.1643153429,
-0.5188955665,
-0.0915671289,
-0.6331042647,
-0.1028525531,
-0.0360107087,
0.7530631423,
0.4658668637,
0.0698132664,
-0.2426458001,
-0.2976354957,
-0.8792612553,
-0.2721026242,
-0.893979907,
-0.207140699,
0.5174589157,
0.4589645267,
1.0930914879,
-0.1385411173,
0.5158841014,
0.5085007548,
0.2201192081,
0.3715307117,
-0.3225822747,
0.2870442867,
0.1655286252,
-0.3554593325,
-0.4104939103,
-0.2097991705,
0.0761485845,
0.0313773043,
0.1015152484,
-0.1586294919,
-0.0644743592,
0.4270702004,
-0.3755109608,
0.5433296561,
-0.5669006109,
0.130453214,
0.1986833662,
-0.2266255915,
-0.400169611,
0.0446042344,
0.1388794184,
-0.7172724605,
-0.1754988581,
-0.0021076265,
0.7855060101,
0.2647178769,
-0.47691378,
-0.3314749002,
-0.7766956091,
0.6991716027,
-0.5766143799,
0.3104221523,
0.3362494409,
0.5543777347,
-0.0705562308,
-0.4955069423,
-0.9477786422,
-0.3883602321,
-0.1389135867,
0.3589189053,
-0.2264328748,
0.0925533101,
-0.0714835599,
0.3744074702,
-0.6146758795,
-0.0716136843,
-0.382555306,
-0.1749768704,
0.504940629,
0.2054781169,
0.5044931173,
-0.3185597658,
-0.5296425819,
-0.308349818,
0.045570299,
0.2112897784,
0.1279149503,
0.2284522653,
-0.3507687747,
0.6950373054,
0.0071703843,
0.3694061339,
-0.1098517254,
-0.2307118624,
0.5541375875,
-0.6390789747,
-0.1855080873,
-0.4862332344,
1.2975432873,
0.7558454871,
0.2629923224,
0.1956611872,
-0.2473725528,
0.1126362085,
0.2114751637,
-0.7148800492,
-0.3329924047,
0.1872911006,
-0.5156505108,
-0.3652076125,
-0.2429538369,
-0.7470569611,
-0.5119113922,
-0.2224262506,
0.4644279182,
-0.7915283442,
-0.3308619857,
-0.1696934253,
-0.2779019475,
0.1239747107,
0.7083777189,
-0.6288402081,
-0.0320741534,
0.0375049897,
0.8600508571,
0.1941161007,
-0.1431939602,
-0.1017304882,
-0.1949817389,
-0.1524474919,
0.8473877907,
-0.7451887727,
-0.451472491,
-0.0387029573,
0.0523109548,
0.07335563,
-0.1325431466,
0.5337418318,
-0.4377268553,
0.5721979737,
0.4472722113,
-0.3462387323,
-0.255459249,
0.5042868257,
-0.6426140666,
0.6074158549,
-0.1787263602,
-0.6135354638,
0.0067492034,
-1.1204478741,
-0.3067837656,
0.3323506713,
-0.4782805741,
-0.1912208498,
-0.1538575888,
0.3922516406,
0.4237185717,
-0.365555346,
0.1377765685,
-0.4341876805,
-0.4191451073,
0.6228770018,
-0.7903631926,
0.5786498785,
0.2381588072,
-0.0858635828,
0.2228333801,
-0.3184975386,
0.3067081273,
0.2845815718,
-0.3103936911,
0.1131896302,
-0.137983948,
0.3355338275,
0.2288691998,
0.1457777172,
-0.7854596972,
0.3265920877,
0.0779927373,
0.6149184108,
0.753775239,
-0.0590407439,
0.4675973058,
-0.5158276558,
0.4071306288,
0.2117349207,
0.5267863274,
-0.7717964649,
-0.7741097808,
-0.8328557014,
-0.7106391191,
0.0304950178,
0.6717181802,
-1.1082998514,
0.4256718457,
-0.3573336303,
-0.4480936527,
-0.7692368627,
0.178171277,
0.5770584345,
0.3022978008,
0.2001261413,
-0.598002553,
-0.3342834711,
-1.0255258083,
0.3151531816,
-0.4122699201,
-0.1656624228,
0.7976058125,
0.4578669667,
-0.5401816964,
0.7470145822,
-0.2621290088,
-0.5569570661,
-0.1330184639,
0.2540954947,
0.059955433,
0.4904783368,
0.6260570288,
-1.0641493797,
-0.5714811087,
0.0523353703,
-1.001554966,
0.6060264111,
-0.2093396187,
-0.0500843748,
0.2718372643,
0.164522931,
-1.0775488615,
0.5030331016,
0.4727339745,
-0.0349525772,
0.1559707224,
-0.2535336614,
0.6133876443,
-1.3485109806,
-0.0242866036,
0.0303873084,
-0.3883614242,
-0.4424650371,
-0.137516439,
-0.0869715214,
-0.5693203211,
-0.5570774674,
0.5056808591,
-0.3470350504,
0.0916084498,
-0.1619346142,
0.074148953,
-0.0351362228,
1.0912840366,
-0.0727102011,
0.7443246841,
0.6818743944,
-0.3154646754,
0.8644481897,
0.4521803856,
-0.2822978497,
0.6614893079,
-0.7642731667,
0.5460091233,
-0.2034362555,
0.5092184544,
-1.476444602,
-0.4300192893,
0.4275336564,
-0.9012129903,
0.3325188756,
-0.1379300356,
-0.5282046795,
-0.3892732263,
-0.3244033456,
0.2593571246,
0.4863583744,
-0.3636304736,
0.7452073693,
0.2537322044,
-0.218816787,
-0.4860309064,
-0.5440816283,
0.4381195307,
0.2058857679,
-0.9764750004,
-0.0354697481,
-0.3910676539,
0.1337996274,
-0.0312438179,
0.2695586085,
-0.359698534,
-0.180363372,
0.5061562657,
0.49191311,
-0.1175548062,
0.2950825393,
-0.1885505319,
0.0074271723,
-0.2989385426,
0.0549567975,
0.7355889082,
-0.5569912195,
-0.4949876964,
-1.1101076603,
0.4329235256,
0.9079607129,
-0.130004108,
0.4782019556,
0.7258556485,
-0.0612757653,
0.517138958,
-0.518178761,
-0.230978474,
-0.5140917301,
0.2864459157,
-0.4967034161,
-0.9332329631,
0.3959688246,
0.2386527658,
0.2718980312,
0.1956839114,
0.6724426746,
-0.6096212864,
1.1445509195,
0.4859130383,
0.0232827682,
0.7687075734,
-0.1714413613,
0.2593752146,
-0.4180239737,
-0.396471262,
-0.1054587588,
-0.6177620888,
-0.6023432612,
-0.5937200189,
0.3149240017,
-0.283624351,
-0.1043726355,
0.3438753188,
-0.4155993164,
0.6112570763,
0.6967577934,
0.4682488143,
0.2135681212,
0.0102684656,
0.1873289645,
-0.0003963672,
-0.3382892907,
-0.5127213001,
0.9233688712,
0.2362799793,
0.9708960652,
0.2210030556,
0.383754015,
0.5464390516,
0.2032862306,
-0.9211887717,
0.6115657687,
0.1667044014,
-0.8216165304,
-0.2659443915,
-0.3131124079,
-0.8922095299,
0.3350376785,
-0.4946783185,
-0.5893615484,
-0.0594475456,
0.0278213806,
-0.1684165895,
0.0366584063,
-0.9597584009,
0.7665294409,
-0.4676389396,
-0.0533941351,
-0.3480916619,
-1.0838540792,
0.4681788683,
0.1701543033,
0.1873120368,
-0.2073539495,
0.3585541248,
0.1753860116,
0.0134751396,
1.0525991917,
-0.1387390494,
0.2532407641,
0.3004654348,
0.2345781922,
-0.03586125,
0.20377177,
0.3823616207,
0.1713805348,
-0.0726580694,
-0.4346794784,
-0.7517583966,
0.484071523,
-1.1007837057,
-0.4036575556,
-0.1652071774,
-0.7402850986,
-0.2066134959,
0.1234450638,
-0.0573591739,
0.5645456314,
-0.1903900057,
0.4698274434,
0.3106863499,
-0.5151289105,
0.6259490252,
0.2746549249,
-0.1181925535,
-0.5159108639,
0.911906004,
-0.6010450721,
0.2362004817,
0.4187652469,
-0.0538724028,
-0.2440442145,
0.2016753405,
-0.6736111045,
0.0054658358,
-0.7359777093,
-0.3778345585,
-0.6855887175,
-0.2652872503,
-0.446932286,
0.0303658228,
-0.3843081892,
-0.3026506901,
-0.202733919,
0.2383576185,
0.4835087061,
0.5461175442,
0.1908591241,
0.1767706722,
-1.1141500473,
0.3650217056,
0.6367811561,
0.2183657289,
0.0024979452,
-0.3950977027,
0.1498406678,
0.5199839473,
-0.5513635278,
-0.5860131383,
0.2412216216,
0.4893338978,
0.4686701298,
0.5085529089,
-0.1286379993,
0.8472577929,
-0.4175008535,
0.7855460048,
0.7748337388,
-0.6804274917,
0.6241803169,
-0.3648876846,
0.243343249,
0.5133764744,
0.2308901101,
-0.7460132837,
-0.4296254516,
-0.3622344732,
-0.3176189065,
0.8377971649,
0.5180409551,
0.7273126245,
0.048433505,
-0.0218303949,
-0.0925696418,
0.2277689129,
-0.9085142612,
-0.1661646366,
-0.4724143744,
-0.2522206306,
0.072099261,
-0.0536085032,
-0.2214444578,
-0.2131001502,
0.3388686776,
-0.3787348568,
0.7961298823,
0.0220796149,
-0.210321188,
0.1721197665,
0.3856407106,
0.7112343311,
0.3826903701,
-0.1490783989,
0.0248193853,
-0.2880546451,
-0.1777341664,
0.0690074861,
-0.0637764484,
0.4195380509,
-0.0663443506,
0.2798574865,
0.9557376504,
0.1091423854,
-0.9416040778,
0.8042423725,
-0.6821774244,
-0.1432081461,
-0.4182269275,
-0.0159462411,
0.2519671023,
0.7320140004,
0.2244027257,
0.5669952631,
-0.0244258083,
-0.8553110361,
0.0808515698,
0.4872561991,
-0.5676809549,
-0.4320476055,
0.5011511445,
0.6315483451,
-0.6585575938,
1.0675059557,
-0.2925072312,
-0.4531527162,
0.4659307003,
0.2881896198,
0.7381699085,
-0.0168077033,
0.4272938967,
0.1965101361,
0.1874301136,
0.4230944216,
0.3334948421,
-0.2418470085,
-0.9150144458,
-0.2193150371,
-0.2828602493,
-0.4807761312,
0.0453451052,
-0.2462661266,
0.0669256225,
-0.256976366,
-0.3460894525,
0.1202600747,
-0.3516225517,
-0.88365376,
-0.1189958826,
0.395978868,
0.2976363897,
-0.4767061174,
0.7939187288,
0.7790783644,
-0.8425090313,
-0.3312903643,
-0.3554675877,
0.0619187318,
-1.0188777447,
0.6338870525,
0.3570452631,
-0.0615916364,
-0.408621937,
-0.7490743399,
-0.5775406957,
1.2090480328,
0.2825028896,
-0.3735533059,
0.0277120974,
-0.0436133482,
0.6528763771,
-0.3167015016,
0.7353903055,
-0.1990775317,
0.2068657875,
0.6628426313,
-1.2783356905,
-0.2396462858,
-0.7209219933,
0.1448274106,
-0.032275971,
-0.7876300812,
0.7871588469,
-0.409604609,
-0.327134192,
0.3739624619,
0.4817267656,
-0.0537185036,
0.1104084104,
0.6422255635,
0.4152216911,
0.5693035722,
0.1002945006,
0.9170528054,
-0.2830201685,
0.239132449,
1.040587306,
-0.1793959439,
0.7488393188,
0.3344323635,
0.1367267817,
0.3170518875,
0.4550544024,
-0.0357177705,
0.514007628,
-0.4031285048,
-0.4495179057,
-0.4792722762,
-0.2337223887,
-0.0443142019,
0.6971894503,
0.3014641404,
-0.2995648682,
-0.1144464985,
0.331807375,
-0.2617627382,
-0.2815941274,
0.2036877573,
0.9967898726,
-0.1336800456,
-0.5498379469,
0.4318675697,
-0.1118837744,
0.8577540517,
-0.3396967649,
-0.218877539,
-0.2852640748,
0.4877851009,
0.0615933873,
-1.0162283182,
-0.0494413041,
-0.1577454954,
0.0450453088,
-0.3098564446,
0.9459858537,
-0.5868632793,
-0.2652133107,
0.2403966486,
0.5496842861,
0.2703304589,
-0.0758564547,
-1.1268736124,
0.0821828768,
0.0375230014,
-0.1052141413,
0.2256383002,
0.3602401614,
-0.0295389183,
0.8831558824,
0.7024447918,
-0.6779193878,
-0.167202428,
0.1380446255,
1.093480587,
-0.3516723216,
-0.1157681644,
-0.6537467241,
0.573059082,
-0.2293766886,
-0.2824325562,
0.4125088155,
0.3474788964,
0.5622576475,
-0.158895582,
0.7279850841,
-0.4038012028,
0.1234454662,
-0.1156383008,
0.6963880658,
-0.7310443521,
-0.2212355286,
-0.1437597573,
-0.5922066569,
-0.1441307813,
0.7067352533,
0.4012405276,
0.0738598481,
0.4479758143,
0.9679566026,
-0.114546001,
0.2453712821,
0.602501452,
-0.0876836777,
0.6558101177,
0.6894773245,
1.3287912607,
-0.5613045096,
0.8558213115,
-0.093610771,
-0.1988057196,
-0.144953534,
-0.3816141784,
-1.0413081646,
-0.8595072627,
-0.0977768674,
-0.132184729,
-0.064321667,
0.9131096601,
0.7822953463,
-0.368622303,
-0.1982830763,
0.2577991784,
-0.1751735508,
0.2240643054,
-0.2856374085,
-0.2542848587,
-0.4948080182,
-0.9483963847,
0.3699475527,
0.3553185165,
0.2211838663,
-0.2329188287,
-0.2979433835,
-0.3669662178,
-0.0422859862,
0.8357456326,
0.1722602546,
-0.8153111339,
-0.4286003411,
0.1034562513,
-0.2732757032,
0.4037912488,
0.6206336617,
-0.4710894525,
0.7669303417,
0.3546521664,
0.5793794394,
0.5674187541,
-0.1511372924,
0.3342378139,
-0.8622903228,
0.4456064701,
0.3914272487,
0.4099788964,
0.3398014307,
0.0022228777,
0.3015301526,
0.268976599,
-0.628760159,
-0.4313503504,
0.1272972524,
-1.1960381269,
-0.2290042043,
0.8883372545,
-0.2328901738,
-0.1256797463,
0.0721127167,
-0.6836544871,
0.091527231,
-0.9687740207,
0.6545549035,
0.7648742199,
-0.3527755141,
-0.5570018291,
-0.3370564282,
-0.024987597,
0.2012904733,
-0.867734611,
-0.2642862201,
0.8054159284,
0.0182493981,
0.5387474895,
1.0273456573,
-0.0385840684,
0.3314956129,
-0.0459493846,
0.4337669909,
-0.0048408466,
-0.3768868148,
-0.0549006686,
-0.0620438978,
-0.2443755865,
-0.6652598381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14347v1 | The Dark Side of ChatGPT: Legal and Ethical Challenges from Stochastic Parrots and Hallucination | 2023-04-21T16:40:54 | 2023-04-21T16:40:54 | Zihao Li | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the launch of ChatGPT, Large Language Models (LLMs) are shaking up our
whole society, rapidly altering the way we think, create and live. For
instance, the GPT integration in Bing has altered our approach to online
searching. While nascent LLMs have many advantages, new legal and ethical risks
are also emerging, stemming in particular from stochastic parrots and
hallucination. The EU is the first and foremost jurisdiction that has focused
on the regulation of AI models. However, the risks posed by the new LLMs are
likely to be underestimated by the emerging EU regulatory paradigm. Therefore,
this correspondence warns that the European AI regulatory paradigm must evolve
further to mitigate such risks. | [
-0.238865912,
-0.8072023392,
0.5015155673,
0.1099438444,
-0.2925923467,
0.0463505462,
-0.134882763,
-0.9945564866,
0.1041563898,
0.9311382771,
-0.4987614155,
-0.0171976369,
-0.7805609107,
-0.1567364633,
-0.4097962677,
1.0728173256,
0.2801363468,
0.3266443908,
-0.0432879478,
0.1368564516,
-0.1561060697,
-1.0234466791,
-0.9607973695,
-0.0836674497,
0.5764363408,
0.0345492512,
0.8924412727,
0.26789698,
0.8564932346,
0.3330428898,
-0.1177684963,
-0.1885042191,
-0.830509901,
0.1056012809,
0.0014617492,
-0.5470116138,
-0.1947354376,
0.1408937126,
0.1465985477,
0.6027104259,
-0.5613329411,
-0.2488738745,
-0.0147122238,
0.709636867,
-0.1995625645,
-0.0400324985,
-0.65895468,
0.264043808,
-0.032926362,
-0.5199885368,
-0.2313321382,
-0.308906883,
0.2902332842,
-0.5311916471,
0.0910328552,
0.2135705203,
0.859588325,
0.6290537715,
-0.617967844,
-0.6287330389,
-0.9126944542,
0.5211876035,
-0.6579339504,
0.2968848348,
0.2380557954,
0.5442320108,
-0.448340863,
-1.0589414835,
-0.4692830741,
-0.5647796392,
0.2142827809,
0.0377269536,
-0.3519574106,
0.0996284857,
-0.0063906349,
0.5276998281,
-0.3622061312,
0.4054453373,
-0.9185523987,
-0.3211590946,
0.8852932453,
0.1076961011,
0.4750862718,
0.1997712553,
-0.1902952492,
0.1292638034,
-0.9802373648,
-0.2643770874,
0.8639056683,
0.3133247197,
-0.1289385706,
0.6429204941,
0.355384022,
0.1357656568,
-0.1725805551,
0.347827822,
0.0921131968,
-0.1355916709,
-0.2891652584,
0.2394019812,
0.8413249254,
0.449279964,
0.43292436,
-0.0534384474,
-0.0276526902,
-0.0367036387,
0.5155393481,
-0.5735242963,
-0.119151853,
0.3709405661,
-0.6775671244,
-0.5965091586,
-0.1562505811,
-0.5608460903,
-0.8942192197,
-0.1825399846,
0.267277211,
-0.1376604438,
-0.2050234526,
0.4837971628,
-0.0068464922,
0.632119,
0.507463336,
-0.7865393162,
0.202845782,
0.8573476672,
0.4253305197,
0.1571077704,
-0.0146090686,
-0.2681061327,
-0.1341330111,
-0.5071568489,
0.3855818212,
-0.6325413585,
-0.5686759353,
0.079914704,
0.2240819484,
0.1553588063,
-0.1973519474,
0.4452550411,
-0.5177533031,
0.6364358068,
-0.1595790982,
-0.4034966826,
-0.2789162397,
0.1411566436,
-0.3440560699,
0.903639555,
-0.182546258,
-0.7809693217,
0.3477739394,
-0.806038022,
-0.4089434147,
0.2091036439,
-0.5122994781,
-0.2672549784,
0.1673573107,
-0.1352335215,
0.3863778114,
-0.3335484862,
0.158349365,
-0.3678821027,
-0.5300596952,
0.1961518675,
-0.7093772888,
1.2866853476,
0.4661386609,
-0.5187252164,
0.242684871,
-0.586869657,
-0.3789902627,
0.1784872711,
-0.184511587,
-0.1914274693,
0.3439682424,
0.0789777413,
0.4200377166,
0.1758028567,
-0.2892985046,
0.0255976152,
-0.2657860518,
1.075284481,
0.9311705828,
0.3244487643,
0.1198524162,
-0.5092480779,
0.724554956,
-0.1139132679,
0.4703027904,
0.3437031806,
-0.7482153773,
-0.6720919013,
-0.1134284213,
-0.026081169,
0.6775810719,
-0.4049987197,
0.3621175587,
-0.0660165921,
-0.6702570319,
-0.8517611623,
-0.3172850311,
-0.0949978828,
-0.2014310062,
-0.0332396366,
-0.1626767069,
-0.226492703,
-1.0028535128,
-0.087241739,
-0.1632471085,
-0.0439337827,
0.7804837823,
0.4491648376,
-0.5151743293,
0.3633702695,
0.2154782712,
-0.3620349765,
-0.0858193263,
-0.0755166933,
0.2366137505,
0.5737730861,
0.3985459507,
-1.0368446112,
-0.3418172002,
0.1830542088,
-0.5545011163,
0.0018316959,
-0.3889394403,
0.1689089835,
-0.023749413,
0.8965170383,
-0.7530319691,
0.30726403,
0.3087015152,
-0.3073762953,
0.5588932633,
-0.318433851,
0.2344719321,
-0.8548446894,
-0.1432134658,
-0.4486565292,
-0.1492395401,
-0.5607873797,
0.3259140253,
-0.3471640944,
-0.1682315767,
-0.8177453876,
0.2733508348,
-0.2538941503,
-0.105688177,
-0.2214860171,
0.2774806619,
-0.3800913692,
0.1454668641,
-0.3156760037,
1.0418155193,
0.7852019072,
-0.5903950334,
0.5958344936,
0.0271488987,
-0.1410822868,
0.2658231854,
-0.643719852,
0.075365141,
-0.1357913762,
0.1962948889,
-0.652806282,
-0.0753903836,
0.3469215333,
-0.3817127049,
0.1484666467,
0.1120766997,
-0.5906607509,
-0.3470773697,
-0.2552135587,
0.314625442,
0.7181313634,
-0.193773672,
0.561385572,
0.5891346335,
-0.3267198503,
-0.6943555474,
-1.0493745804,
0.6228177547,
-0.5471699834,
-0.5458772182,
-0.0044745603,
0.0681190118,
-0.4519954324,
-0.0818744674,
0.2389368415,
0.3209484816,
0.3856024742,
0.2629140019,
-0.1348622441,
-0.1886571348,
-0.0411937237,
-0.3574888408,
-0.086328499,
0.3245223761,
-0.1771485656,
0.621971786,
-0.1081598029,
-0.6276269555,
-0.4542311728,
0.4071269333,
0.6247814298,
-0.0711189955,
0.3142862618,
0.4882183075,
-0.2427975982,
-0.0720399767,
-0.5439094305,
-0.2660491765,
-0.5387336016,
0.5263673067,
-0.0467171185,
-1.1116216183,
0.6374365091,
0.1398759037,
-0.0509177223,
0.4190609753,
0.8814103007,
-0.0944932923,
0.8122784495,
1.1041054726,
-0.0451803431,
0.5127769113,
0.1586648226,
0.5579969287,
-0.4535083771,
-0.1475042403,
-0.5097588301,
-0.0730105713,
-1.592600584,
-0.303958565,
0.2161694765,
-0.2540358007,
-0.3146006465,
-0.0311074406,
-0.6930372119,
0.7133405209,
0.8195941448,
0.1483663321,
0.3507088721,
-0.0601042584,
-0.0917012095,
0.1310764253,
-0.6178559661,
-0.8630726933,
1.1450363398,
0.6475812197,
0.9765415788,
0.1789409667,
0.66626513,
0.4432395101,
0.0341153741,
-0.6664523482,
0.5996724367,
-0.0856442079,
-0.8198112249,
-0.3715500832,
-0.3653582036,
-1.0039207935,
0.2259939462,
-0.0484625511,
-1.0818750858,
0.3245371282,
-0.2002244741,
-0.2762648761,
0.4046143293,
-0.3491178453,
0.6922639012,
-0.4279655218,
-0.5850027204,
-0.2858611345,
-0.8273587823,
0.3306396902,
-0.0423953831,
0.1559454352,
-0.2930670679,
-0.0247647669,
0.7775649428,
-0.3988007307,
1.0585112572,
0.073617734,
-0.3822208345,
0.3675281703,
0.0101521928,
0.789591074,
0.0232309438,
0.1705076098,
0.135162726,
0.2466736287,
-0.4951624274,
-0.1338412464,
0.4491519928,
-0.910218358,
-1.0654031038,
-0.6682493091,
-0.4503552914,
-0.1504504681,
0.2781108022,
0.3969750106,
-0.3240003586,
-0.3944655955,
0.293251425,
0.4693815708,
-0.3833298683,
0.1798233986,
0.4823178053,
-0.3406070769,
-0.1152342409,
0.7788571715,
-0.2129331082,
0.2523461282,
-0.110837087,
0.0880490169,
-0.1885374784,
-0.7807469368,
-0.0631460696,
0.1380641907,
-0.8216878772,
0.3074099422,
-0.4923343956,
-0.5344398618,
-0.2076544464,
-0.3142041266,
-0.322242111,
-0.1986307949,
-0.4289372563,
-0.031823501,
0.4001137614,
1.0039149523,
-0.1644948721,
0.2307518572,
-0.5049634576,
-0.0659667701,
0.3722066879,
0.3837779462,
-0.3541273773,
-0.3397116661,
0.1769472808,
0.150720194,
-0.3053017557,
-0.5445858836,
0.1189588085,
-0.1780100316,
0.6343963146,
0.515217483,
-0.0008238279,
0.5283608437,
-0.7431166768,
1.0017955303,
0.0802370757,
-0.6056711078,
-0.0231243595,
-0.5629190207,
-0.5139577389,
0.3385149837,
0.3562278152,
-0.8932968378,
-0.8168961406,
-0.6877965927,
-0.8709337711,
0.3471344411,
0.4087614715,
0.7168474793,
0.2127297819,
0.2820584178,
0.2410629988,
0.3668262959,
-0.9172570705,
0.0910278037,
0.0553469025,
0.0142951813,
-0.1440066099,
-0.2140795887,
-0.2575842142,
0.0424019173,
0.7050713301,
0.3569292724,
0.5247977972,
0.2307004333,
0.1656484753,
-0.3094851077,
0.3292310238,
0.7325862646,
0.6678832173,
-0.0552481972,
-0.0666589141,
-0.0810134262,
-0.5210962892,
0.2388683707,
-0.0244327243,
-0.009966732,
-0.3147601187,
0.4246065915,
0.6820355058,
0.1520051211,
-0.712849319,
0.6163388491,
-0.0434086695,
-0.4658740759,
-0.591837883,
0.2442984432,
-0.0517486185,
0.5968840718,
0.5209126472,
0.0111994091,
0.1926492602,
-0.680885613,
0.2947769761,
0.6529430747,
-0.4598236978,
0.0631583855,
0.9060229063,
0.1590998471,
-0.4290582836,
0.3596964478,
-0.076269418,
-0.5560795069,
0.6696332097,
0.2477168441,
0.9863920212,
-0.0326488949,
0.0341785178,
-0.4594238698,
0.7648674846,
-0.0880410373,
0.3100079,
0.14780958,
-0.6262636781,
-0.2214727402,
-0.2996696234,
-0.7472520471,
0.3380218744,
-0.4114819467,
0.4392513335,
-0.3318397999,
-0.0199977402,
-0.0951309428,
0.1638121009,
-0.5246036053,
-0.0562489517,
0.3056732416,
0.6776010394,
-0.5050996542,
0.6178814769,
0.247601226,
-0.4013174474,
-0.1704829037,
0.028663341,
0.1276210994,
-1.06103158,
0.2899896204,
0.1911100298,
-0.0399615504,
0.0441371873,
-0.7339242101,
-0.5928294063,
0.83047539,
0.3037621677,
-0.7270871401,
-0.3215091527,
0.3963233531,
0.6794437766,
-0.3983417153,
0.0428532548,
0.4806182086,
0.3487595916,
0.1349059939,
-0.9986475706,
-0.0743389353,
-0.1326646805,
-0.1329500079,
-0.0237390473,
-0.7161599994,
0.8642266393,
-0.2122942209,
-0.453161031,
-0.1808250248,
0.046409782,
-0.0922138095,
0.0631791204,
0.0331815332,
0.3408704102,
0.7288486958,
0.1252825409,
0.9753895402,
-0.3547947407,
0.2748065591,
0.8888213634,
-0.4986250401,
0.6934577823,
0.6465292573,
-0.3874875605,
-0.1351155192,
1.2486867905,
-0.4485485852,
0.4098980129,
0.4052934945,
0.0303387493,
-0.1261695474,
0.083775565,
-0.6405311227,
0.5246512294,
0.4716121554,
-0.2789372206,
-0.1390399784,
0.0613111109,
-0.0058114128,
-0.1587408781,
-0.2300293148,
0.9632217288,
0.2382180691,
-0.176951319,
0.3172347844,
-0.268629998,
0.593231082,
-0.4177416861,
0.1197744161,
-0.1386525929,
0.0174467918,
-0.0187341515,
-0.5067964196,
0.1829719245,
-0.26695171,
0.4260298908,
-0.0650748387,
0.4090443552,
-0.2892625034,
-0.5703727007,
0.5529633164,
0.5393235087,
0.4989851117,
0.0839121714,
-1.0273368359,
0.0423704237,
-0.0832389295,
-0.4169220328,
0.2120775729,
0.6561309099,
-0.1223157868,
0.9503183961,
0.756773293,
0.4027356803,
0.3294576108,
-0.1859844476,
0.9200255871,
-0.824944675,
-0.8036083579,
-0.9438530803,
0.2974116206,
-0.0559135638,
-0.1880327016,
0.567079246,
0.3532815874,
0.6543602347,
0.2077856064,
0.9602695704,
0.0002638631,
0.0928447619,
-0.5800446272,
1.2329118252,
-0.7557857633,
0.5375122428,
0.0244701114,
-0.9663262963,
-0.4196479321,
0.4206048548,
-0.5681009293,
0.2585334182,
0.5995202661,
0.7828347683,
-0.0671190768,
0.0517785549,
0.5419744253,
0.3828849494,
0.5303240418,
0.4919849038,
0.9665859342,
-0.3275401294,
0.5346692204,
-0.0087258741,
0.1171793044,
-0.6422427893,
-0.8767839074,
-0.8202684522,
-0.4229911566,
-0.194220081,
-0.3623373806,
0.0805853009,
0.9053504467,
0.5662420392,
-0.9360875487,
-0.2066805214,
-0.321655035,
-0.0344882756,
0.0017168437,
-0.2510807216,
0.3120458126,
-0.4689237177,
-0.5130328536,
0.1112611666,
0.4514736235,
0.3907445371,
-0.4615591466,
-0.0847012252,
-0.081787616,
0.4832581282,
0.4175106287,
0.197686255,
-0.9656377435,
-0.5075131655,
-0.4981041551,
-0.5065556169,
0.218805775,
0.7475914359,
-0.0684169158,
0.3793617487,
0.0820294246,
0.6922243834,
0.3972832561,
-0.3392783701,
0.7814378142,
-0.0765467659,
0.6068949103,
0.7113527656,
0.3950847983,
0.1179493368,
-0.5287830234,
0.6751628518,
0.0367362238,
-0.8357361555,
-1.1106564999,
0.2088588327,
-0.7868124843,
-0.2314998657,
0.985611856,
0.0639802143,
-0.3032903373,
-0.2489675283,
-0.3449583352,
-0.042710904,
-0.1753284186,
1.127933979,
0.769982338,
-0.0639533401,
-0.2478195727,
-1.2119617462,
0.8656516671,
0.147508353,
-0.6775407791,
0.3177840412,
0.30660972,
0.0991366133,
0.0099658221,
0.5687025785,
-0.3189438283,
0.3286811113,
0.1868239343,
0.0432814024,
0.0016986999,
0.0075092074,
-0.3603983819,
0.044354897,
0.0100144027,
-0.0633768141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11111v1 | Inducing anxiety in large language models increases exploration and bias | 2023-04-21T16:29:43 | 2023-04-21T16:29:43 | Julian Coda-Forno, Kristin Witte, Akshay K. Jagadish, Marcel Binz, Zeynep Akata, Eric Schulz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models are transforming research on machine learning while
galvanizing public debates. Understanding not only when these models work well
and succeed but also why they fail and misbehave is of great societal
relevance. We propose to turn the lens of computational psychiatry, a framework
used to computationally describe and modify aberrant behavior, to the outputs
produced by these models. We focus on the Generative Pre-Trained Transformer
3.5 and subject it to tasks commonly studied in psychiatry. Our results show
that GPT-3.5 responds robustly to a common anxiety questionnaire, producing
higher anxiety scores than human subjects. Moreover, GPT-3.5's responses can be
predictably changed by using emotion-inducing prompts. Emotion-induction not
only influences GPT-3.5's behavior in a cognitive task measuring exploratory
decision-making but also influences its behavior in a previously-established
task measuring biases such as racism and ableism. Crucially, GPT-3.5 shows a
strong increase in biases when prompted with anxiety-inducing text. Thus, it is
likely that how prompts are communicated to large language models has a strong
influence on their behavior in applied settings. These results progress our
understanding of prompt engineering and demonstrate the usefulness of methods
taken from computational psychiatry for studying the capable algorithms to
which we increasingly delegate authority and autonomy. | [
-0.6342407465,
-0.8464341164,
1.0823442936,
0.3261805475,
0.0750857368,
-0.146143809,
-0.2651351094,
-0.3310838938,
0.1167588159,
0.2039013952,
-0.6209020019,
-0.1919955611,
-0.7849180102,
0.0623696595,
-0.5554794669,
1.0074298382,
-0.1070773825,
0.0665784925,
0.168936491,
0.4538850188,
-0.2021168768,
-0.9376584291,
-0.8323175311,
-0.2839693427,
0.5411969423,
-0.1065214127,
1.0386500359,
0.326117754,
0.3385732174,
0.3110805154,
0.1778774112,
-0.3421457112,
-0.5100986362,
0.183799237,
-0.2041065991,
-0.5618258119,
-0.3383414745,
0.0561112985,
0.3340943158,
0.5392020345,
-0.2193833143,
-0.1880772114,
0.0518188998,
0.4702093303,
-0.5894797444,
0.2107800692,
-0.4626896679,
0.1730591208,
-0.1761912704,
-0.1288917512,
-0.4420786798,
-0.3117483854,
-0.0562948063,
-0.6369096637,
0.3748372793,
0.0674815252,
0.5433430672,
0.5278869271,
-0.1829129159,
-0.3827842772,
-0.8488738537,
0.3962399065,
-0.3093570471,
0.1632776856,
0.5415689945,
-0.0473578125,
-0.3261760175,
-0.6775645018,
-0.8179578781,
-0.1642348915,
-0.1112165004,
-0.0112232333,
-0.5197930932,
0.4169192314,
0.73506248,
0.030874135,
-0.5367905498,
0.1335616857,
-0.4587976336,
-0.1209195554,
0.489130199,
0.2197376937,
0.668222785,
-0.0574840494,
0.3376555443,
-0.3240878582,
-0.3948855996,
-0.024852775,
0.3463972211,
0.1855515987,
-0.074348025,
0.5584339499,
0.2526171207,
0.2566254735,
0.4323738813,
0.4171924293,
0.1890975982,
0.3019111454,
-0.1025688052,
0.3731696904,
0.903578341,
0.4249043167,
0.4007181823,
0.0778565705,
-0.0876783356,
0.5271986127,
0.8671337962,
-0.8038223982,
-0.2255655378,
0.2654961944,
-0.1427577287,
-0.2282691449,
-0.0285151731,
-0.9590716958,
-0.8913319111,
-0.2613197863,
0.2744662762,
-0.5150297284,
-0.3357703686,
0.2145624459,
-0.0163775273,
0.2656938732,
0.2634678781,
-1.034922719,
0.244525671,
0.8233781457,
0.779042244,
-0.4475409985,
-0.4761524796,
-0.2244271487,
-0.2611544728,
-0.8045865893,
0.5338985324,
-0.5765311122,
-0.5698874593,
0.1388267279,
0.0330293551,
-0.0609038807,
-0.4360136688,
0.6918443441,
-0.3687111437,
0.2343685627,
-0.1966341585,
-0.0832244381,
-0.0839927718,
0.0422884375,
-0.5765388012,
0.9281772971,
0.2792569101,
-0.7530818582,
0.1468296498,
-1.0676745176,
-0.294372499,
-0.1838941872,
-0.213622421,
-0.1192708686,
0.4501338601,
0.4312841594,
0.3591878414,
-0.2269955873,
0.560908854,
-0.3952525258,
-0.3369073272,
0.551079154,
-0.2471556365,
0.6313080788,
0.172679022,
-0.4304142594,
0.1943235546,
-0.1703882068,
-0.1688585579,
0.0849449784,
0.3206481338,
-0.3656573594,
-0.1074384823,
-0.1841110885,
0.4109820426,
-0.3442409337,
-0.3664784133,
0.0362725332,
-0.4845063984,
0.2884885371,
0.9463218451,
0.2608507574,
0.3768931925,
-0.2989740968,
0.9088514447,
0.0579981431,
0.0639417991,
-0.0035735494,
-0.504823029,
-0.5432518721,
-0.2966116965,
-0.3309157491,
0.4360105693,
-0.6682507992,
0.1131689101,
-0.0671807453,
-0.5917187333,
-0.5990304351,
-0.3658192456,
-0.0359186232,
0.4036927521,
0.3328241408,
-0.1283258945,
-0.5281569362,
-0.7314972281,
-0.4328169823,
-0.1190402731,
-0.1878388673,
0.1755975783,
0.4356592,
-0.6167967916,
0.8709407449,
-0.6394226551,
0.2428996861,
-0.1949460059,
0.5891854763,
0.3367900252,
0.5861155391,
0.5023576617,
-0.6932650208,
-0.3649259806,
-0.2944885194,
-0.821919322,
-0.2478585243,
-0.2499644011,
-0.3517079949,
0.0122777997,
0.5339910388,
-1.0096647739,
0.307182014,
0.2179436237,
-0.2613552809,
0.7381182909,
0.0678496063,
0.2690321207,
-1.1100187302,
-0.1126505807,
-0.0224929694,
0.2545639277,
-0.8419727087,
-0.0085669532,
-0.137201339,
-0.51109308,
-0.241373986,
0.3931927681,
-0.0356271118,
0.2227554619,
-0.3371342123,
-0.154981941,
-0.2278855443,
0.3855828643,
0.1089658439,
0.8261363506,
0.9062483311,
-0.5638688207,
0.2491756678,
0.0595912598,
-0.0926466361,
0.4490157068,
-0.353420943,
0.3066273332,
-0.5627452731,
0.2268303037,
-0.6554647088,
-0.6505718827,
0.3399213254,
-0.5606818199,
0.1777953804,
0.2140108347,
-0.1618071049,
-0.5218659639,
-0.3026730418,
0.4113161564,
0.6958667636,
-0.4548947513,
0.7438284755,
0.2070703804,
-0.6031301618,
-0.3802412748,
-0.5094838142,
0.083979629,
-0.4442836344,
-0.1507094949,
0.1770031005,
0.0621679388,
-0.52167207,
-0.2026779801,
-0.0440985411,
-0.0850889012,
0.1483542323,
0.6153093576,
0.2148480117,
0.0051556663,
0.2523704171,
0.2334480286,
-0.0675591081,
0.8107484579,
-0.3382558525,
0.7268775105,
-0.0315661356,
-0.4705351293,
-0.4624846578,
0.5874102712,
0.8457034826,
-0.1298840195,
0.5282430053,
0.4729243815,
-0.474204123,
-0.2674665153,
-0.163575381,
-0.4775741398,
-0.5243403912,
0.6323926449,
-0.3657820523,
-1.0506386757,
0.2444474101,
-0.1027979329,
-0.3586363494,
0.3426969349,
0.689602077,
0.0200877022,
1.4638274908,
0.7095888853,
-0.0918137208,
0.4283419847,
-0.0056658052,
0.6787711978,
-0.64624089,
0.1451669037,
-0.625115931,
-0.0959905759,
-0.8079960942,
-0.5028243065,
0.5378419161,
-0.1168504953,
-0.4523409903,
-0.3300473094,
-0.5044645071,
0.2754055262,
0.2574827671,
-0.1520986855,
-0.2271205336,
0.0211615916,
0.0464926399,
-0.2376347184,
-0.3406564295,
-0.3507019877,
1.1070073843,
0.2461584657,
0.8895501494,
-0.0907979459,
0.5716875792,
0.432048142,
0.665261209,
-0.7716114521,
0.3953045309,
0.3589033782,
-0.6484501362,
-0.0620903857,
-0.2364142239,
-0.938064456,
0.0860392079,
0.0013866875,
-1.2026809454,
0.4614852965,
0.2723059654,
-0.5037731528,
0.0718957409,
-0.632835567,
0.5947070718,
-0.3146219552,
-0.2765488625,
-0.1927686483,
-0.4105317295,
0.5885810852,
-0.4961910248,
0.1594517231,
0.162359789,
0.2321748286,
0.6450657248,
-0.1104899794,
0.7676267028,
-0.2572737634,
-0.3168107569,
0.1058965102,
0.281087935,
0.4869944155,
0.0418889374,
-0.2317894697,
-0.1260537058,
-0.2637602687,
-0.1522031873,
-0.9799605608,
0.4924261868,
-0.9201380014,
-0.8709729314,
-0.6251957417,
-0.6547808647,
-0.5455235243,
0.0752797127,
0.5501157641,
0.0181447864,
-0.0965923667,
-0.213095814,
0.7527674437,
-0.449852258,
0.1547735631,
0.2634262145,
-0.5102902651,
-0.1306345612,
0.833152473,
-0.1253944188,
0.1990800798,
-0.0574225932,
0.1105212271,
-0.2007090449,
-0.232236743,
-0.0757505968,
0.1767740548,
-0.6047239304,
0.1492368579,
-0.8845391273,
-0.1824471653,
-0.6407569647,
-0.479660809,
-0.2842307091,
-0.1128691435,
-0.1739558131,
-0.5166933537,
0.2770180106,
0.8798214793,
-0.2322737277,
0.5473104715,
-0.323434025,
0.3991810679,
0.264074713,
0.3165852129,
0.1152080595,
-0.2803274095,
-0.098562941,
0.0170454066,
-0.3144660592,
-1.1402372122,
0.4496173859,
-0.1276928037,
0.3147230446,
0.6801101565,
0.1314466894,
0.5007516742,
-0.3018164337,
0.897908628,
-0.0319194682,
-0.9599611163,
0.4832775593,
-0.5041478276,
0.1021643132,
0.3170872331,
0.8571768403,
-0.659602046,
-0.6305301189,
-0.6309169531,
-0.8406835794,
0.9994119406,
0.0280937795,
0.3267963529,
-0.1872836202,
0.4659537971,
-0.043877963,
0.142915979,
-0.7146998048,
-0.0194192361,
-0.4155769944,
-0.2528664768,
-0.2868796587,
-0.2996456921,
-0.1133401021,
-0.3256672621,
0.6394112706,
-0.0917803496,
0.6099228859,
0.238706708,
0.0867603421,
-0.1391163319,
0.3525659442,
0.4426547289,
0.2349633425,
-0.0492422618,
0.2553579509,
-0.0806942806,
-0.6794731617,
0.4643421769,
0.4106190503,
-0.2164372951,
-0.3068612516,
0.194189474,
0.9550562501,
-0.4741912782,
-0.5679750443,
0.2277028114,
-0.1251529306,
-0.1118881851,
-0.2220391035,
0.1930770129,
-0.2198799849,
0.1126538366,
0.2623926103,
-0.0340174958,
0.3217835128,
-0.5015015602,
0.0551333539,
0.2271949053,
-0.4869535267,
-0.4358951151,
0.5096117854,
-0.2205570787,
-0.4282032847,
0.8497909904,
-0.4091420472,
-0.8051887751,
0.4941552579,
0.8725378513,
1.1997511387,
-0.5281533003,
0.2558033466,
0.4219899774,
0.5230493546,
-0.1775191426,
0.3532221615,
0.0550016947,
-0.813908875,
-0.3963630199,
-0.5296916962,
-0.2265230566,
0.2588207126,
-0.6927389503,
-0.0937235802,
-0.2916684747,
-0.4679423273,
-0.2234328687,
-0.5739620328,
-0.4803899527,
0.1109613925,
0.3804133534,
0.5750280619,
-1.0727933645,
0.5423194766,
0.8669893146,
-0.0505143218,
-0.9545715451,
0.4474401772,
0.1103057638,
-0.5224542022,
0.3069317937,
0.3908789456,
-0.251187712,
0.0805228204,
-0.8222442865,
-0.8987904191,
0.4603156745,
0.39036268,
-0.1332199425,
-0.0272112023,
0.2089768052,
0.6989912987,
-0.3963473141,
0.137972489,
0.7400066853,
0.5530382991,
-0.3313123882,
-0.5542941689,
0.2356921583,
-0.6163672805,
0.0248333123,
0.2741794586,
0.0289794505,
0.9381694198,
-0.3769745529,
-0.2106775492,
-0.2370431125,
0.4192478359,
0.1639618129,
0.1590740234,
0.3753378093,
0.4085770547,
0.9523000121,
-0.1351173967,
1.3334137201,
-0.2592898607,
-0.0030039581,
1.1500344276,
-0.5977702141,
0.3681482077,
0.5569556355,
0.0211593434,
0.5150216222,
0.5742368102,
0.0973000601,
0.2500221133,
0.4493934512,
-0.2134021521,
-0.1306522042,
-0.2468070239,
-0.316419214,
0.3787353635,
0.8257364035,
-0.3566825092,
-0.0577518307,
0.4525767267,
0.2625792027,
-0.0103435433,
-0.3446140885,
0.5980257988,
0.1518045217,
-0.9979047775,
0.3483415842,
-0.0050182566,
0.3217478693,
-0.5962074995,
0.1903953403,
-0.1317598224,
0.1016378179,
-0.0097841192,
-0.48068735,
0.2710423768,
0.2681287527,
-0.1575816125,
-0.3020348549,
0.4463271499,
0.0181905925,
-0.4885517657,
0.2707075775,
0.4856801927,
0.0387309082,
-0.4682807028,
-0.3978412747,
0.0420636274,
-0.1750474721,
-0.4089735448,
0.342317462,
0.5601447225,
-0.3633859754,
0.6059209704,
0.6117600799,
0.1239999905,
-0.0082037933,
-0.1188919917,
0.9100577235,
-0.5862338543,
-0.6926913857,
-1.0343846083,
0.335478127,
0.0274064988,
-0.0827917457,
0.4901710451,
0.3087566197,
0.4927909076,
-0.1239480376,
1.1362165213,
-0.2672258317,
0.2465814352,
-0.2207680196,
0.7711616755,
-0.2803684771,
-0.0627952516,
-0.4216527045,
-0.7588354349,
-0.261942327,
0.5379778743,
-0.6843371987,
0.1224032268,
0.8405236602,
1.0161321163,
0.1795065701,
0.1793198436,
0.0672086179,
0.7049024701,
0.4476456344,
0.5103561878,
1.131354928,
0.2341100425,
0.0489715524,
-0.2452326715,
-0.4215620756,
0.1325225532,
-0.6192448735,
-0.7484098077,
-0.6151793599,
-0.0605115183,
-0.5512884259,
-0.0027553306,
1.2019965649,
0.3513681293,
-0.692694366,
-0.1304178834,
-0.2641520798,
0.0620618165,
-0.3014928997,
-0.2624916136,
0.4097905457,
-0.5709517002,
-0.6251571178,
0.1641844809,
0.2152076215,
0.1568689644,
-0.2331768721,
-0.0066357586,
0.2213069946,
0.1896668673,
0.4786148667,
0.2119589299,
-0.5522639751,
-0.0867443457,
-0.0310211089,
-0.1502770931,
0.0225409511,
1.0066580772,
-0.6573175192,
0.4652245045,
0.1455944031,
0.6469455361,
0.2131469697,
0.0029802946,
0.980278492,
-0.2863894701,
0.0757511482,
0.4859781563,
0.2175329328,
0.2525396347,
-0.6499352455,
0.278419137,
-0.0322926566,
-0.4428663254,
-0.9103757143,
0.3650176823,
-0.4986386895,
-0.1325934082,
0.9367312193,
0.1255365163,
-0.2305138558,
-0.0200713258,
-0.4768993258,
0.2065395415,
-0.4809862077,
1.1742842197,
0.825158298,
-0.5008901358,
-0.2032704949,
-0.6887280941,
1.052829504,
0.4181647003,
-0.84403795,
0.23990646,
0.5288618207,
-0.2700428963,
0.3208211064,
0.7069225311,
-0.0395545326,
0.3549301624,
-0.1041928083,
0.2605540752,
0.3236346245,
-0.219009608,
-0.6155336499,
0.2873978913,
0.2138810754,
0.3564407825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11107v1 | ChatABL: Abductive Learning via Natural Language Interaction with ChatGPT | 2023-04-21T16:23:47 | 2023-04-21T16:23:47 | Tianyang Zhong, Yaonai Wei, Li Yang, Zihao Wu, Zhengliang Liu, Xiaozheng Wei, Wenjun Li, Junjie Yao, Chong Ma, Xiang Li, Dajiang Zhu, Xi Jiang, Junwei Han, Dinggang Shen, Tianming Liu, Tuo Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have recently demonstrated
significant potential in mathematical abilities, providing valuable reasoning
paradigm consistent with human natural language. However, LLMs currently have
difficulty in bridging perception, language understanding and reasoning
capabilities due to incompatibility of the underlying information flow among
them, making it challenging to accomplish tasks autonomously. On the other
hand, abductive learning (ABL) frameworks for integrating the two abilities of
perception and reasoning has seen significant success in inverse decipherment
of incomplete facts, but it is limited by the lack of semantic understanding of
logical reasoning rules and the dependence on complicated domain knowledge
representation. This paper presents a novel method (ChatABL) for integrating
LLMs into the ABL framework, aiming at unifying the three abilities in a more
user-friendly and understandable manner. The proposed method uses the strengths
of LLMs' understanding and logical reasoning to correct the incomplete logical
facts for optimizing the performance of perceptual module, by summarizing and
reorganizing reasoning rules represented in natural language format. Similarly,
perceptual module provides necessary reasoning examples for LLMs in natural
language format. The variable-length handwritten equation deciphering task, an
abstract expression of the Mayan calendar decoding, is used as a testbed to
demonstrate that ChatABL has reasoning ability beyond most existing
state-of-the-art methods, which has been well supported by comparative studies.
To our best knowledge, the proposed ChatABL is the first attempt to explore a
new pattern for further approaching human-level cognitive ability via natural
language interaction with ChatGPT. | [
-0.4380059838,
-0.9729565978,
0.4155356884,
0.1387407184,
-0.5085791349,
0.371724993,
-0.4163604379,
-0.3698712885,
-0.2906006277,
0.535545826,
-0.6720647216,
-0.6716256738,
-0.3930851519,
-0.0385577306,
-0.1752310842,
0.8834131956,
0.0655176416,
0.0861408859,
-0.3107062578,
-0.031649448,
-0.479827106,
-0.4662113786,
-0.52614218,
-0.5164998174,
0.0851849169,
0.3312530518,
0.5938550234,
0.2709371448,
0.6757844687,
0.3244011104,
-0.0992325917,
0.4823698997,
-0.4291712344,
-0.2183779925,
-0.245094642,
-0.429325074,
-0.2375932336,
-0.2920704484,
0.4126851559,
0.8497288823,
-0.2766549885,
-0.018679142,
0.1703847945,
0.652443707,
-0.3420422673,
0.6844679117,
-0.6169695258,
-0.0603564084,
0.1371541768,
-0.2223029733,
-0.4243418574,
-0.6246981025,
0.3402248621,
-0.4351124167,
-0.0383055247,
0.022945758,
0.5168845654,
0.3442379832,
-0.36552158,
-0.6148819923,
-0.5962424874,
0.7620373368,
-0.7848885655,
0.4073131382,
0.3416542113,
0.4906667471,
-0.2396382987,
-0.3365012109,
-0.7581809163,
-0.2374840528,
-0.1254907101,
0.0801530629,
-0.0373225324,
0.1829395741,
0.1418407857,
0.273850739,
-0.405878067,
-0.0695157796,
-0.276432991,
-0.2148367465,
0.5583322048,
0.2041831166,
0.3349751532,
-0.2561518848,
-0.385009408,
0.1232024729,
-0.6876770258,
-0.1038643718,
0.1179942787,
0.3794366419,
-0.2923475206,
0.8085468411,
-0.1010084897,
0.5294972658,
-0.2582239211,
-0.1698912978,
0.2274095118,
-0.1972672194,
-0.3177416325,
0.1098176986,
0.4869842231,
0.1660982817,
0.4342494905,
-0.155666098,
-0.098814778,
0.0944414884,
0.0432591289,
-0.6606234312,
-0.1633764505,
0.0035654497,
-0.3753607869,
-0.3004262745,
-0.2074946463,
-0.6686255932,
-0.5160784721,
-0.6184605956,
0.5444865227,
-1.0140999556,
-0.2332659066,
0.3697398007,
0.2401197553,
0.6496726274,
0.7412255406,
-0.7369647622,
0.50612396,
0.8089444637,
0.7047502398,
-0.0600474812,
-0.0382292345,
-0.3463718891,
0.0278651174,
-0.0643764958,
0.7173012495,
-0.5254151225,
-0.3178372979,
0.0926003233,
-0.485758394,
-0.1741985977,
-0.3803814948,
0.6056773067,
-0.6390915513,
0.2679845691,
0.1237366125,
-0.6138454676,
-0.6827737689,
0.2334497571,
-0.3251706064,
0.7268201113,
-0.0730070546,
-0.5661417842,
-0.0477996059,
-0.9093670845,
-0.5040140748,
0.1917939782,
-0.3075783849,
-0.2884379029,
-0.1358944774,
0.3596883714,
0.4675611854,
-0.3543810844,
0.2167032957,
-0.0828006119,
-0.1944532096,
0.532874465,
-0.7026666999,
0.8308247328,
0.2809612155,
-0.1421381235,
-0.1257672161,
-0.8461822867,
0.0425616689,
0.2545803487,
-0.4871806502,
-0.2332165092,
0.1148942858,
-0.1580534726,
0.032992065,
0.3556438684,
-0.3739884496,
0.2927294374,
-0.7191725373,
0.3108619452,
0.5789898038,
0.1213758439,
0.4115886986,
-0.1616043448,
0.1676703542,
-0.1315841228,
-0.1605547369,
-0.1810623556,
-0.3812076747,
-0.8289242387,
-0.4440916181,
-0.0023264817,
0.7352848649,
-0.8227587342,
0.496440351,
-0.2998402715,
-0.2771410048,
-0.4288545549,
0.3724915385,
0.5259936452,
0.5806846619,
0.4865874052,
-0.0062483749,
-0.5753775239,
-0.6074647307,
-0.0764924735,
-0.2593808174,
-0.1963343173,
0.2689214647,
0.448985219,
-0.1510865986,
1.0595103502,
-0.6933012009,
-0.3561964631,
-0.5745416284,
0.3258901536,
0.3520001769,
0.3068115711,
0.1802306026,
-0.7196955085,
-0.1277813613,
0.300971061,
-0.7110885978,
-0.1488904208,
0.0050333608,
-0.2143749148,
0.40418607,
0.1513082087,
-0.5849981308,
0.7248516083,
0.029909322,
-0.2713690996,
0.5279806852,
-0.1597488672,
0.0187189113,
-0.7911744118,
-0.0953112394,
-0.0979702622,
-0.0605350435,
-0.6355166435,
-0.239893049,
0.0818855092,
-0.0509741753,
-0.3905307949,
0.5510729551,
-0.479473114,
0.0497982949,
-0.3268860579,
0.2253918648,
-0.1483957916,
0.8211001158,
0.398083508,
0.5197008848,
0.4562873542,
-0.622081995,
0.4875325859,
0.4903047681,
-0.3292186856,
0.575037539,
-0.2775635123,
-0.0191910435,
-0.2974607348,
-0.1323451549,
-1.1661263704,
-0.0471793637,
0.4336954057,
-0.5788541436,
0.0421705022,
-0.2540880442,
-0.3789723217,
-0.1873632073,
-0.0086888988,
0.3483650386,
0.712594986,
-0.6731740832,
0.9700632691,
0.1374311149,
-0.191553399,
-0.4949707985,
-0.5877889395,
-0.0812930018,
-0.2100852877,
-0.6671046615,
0.199536413,
-0.0829954147,
-0.2949969172,
-0.0612190887,
-0.2674214244,
-0.0640730262,
-0.0216805469,
0.124064669,
0.6417036653,
-0.2707647979,
0.2415109128,
-0.0030279052,
-0.1913579851,
0.120689325,
-0.143956989,
0.6170982122,
-0.4248453379,
-0.6825101376,
-0.5161725879,
0.0817140862,
0.3858861327,
-0.3956205249,
0.6000195742,
0.298802346,
-0.4846467376,
-0.1489460319,
-0.7102472186,
-0.1893584132,
-0.4577656388,
0.2680362165,
-0.4318217635,
-0.5703681111,
0.4730303586,
-0.2870180309,
0.2084746063,
0.0052080275,
0.6345861554,
0.0054255463,
0.8235069513,
0.3374238908,
0.155955717,
0.2473065406,
-0.2868772149,
0.3739062548,
-0.7764161229,
-0.5721716881,
-0.2659733593,
-0.0431333892,
-0.0675552189,
-0.5078571439,
0.0795986429,
0.1390872151,
-0.327047348,
0.1491644233,
-0.1273463964,
0.5343769193,
0.3574544489,
0.3470146358,
0.5801393986,
0.0395735763,
-0.3863672316,
0.1360485405,
-0.377273947,
-0.5019504428,
0.8528956175,
0.1861321628,
0.9771341681,
0.466963172,
0.6407284737,
0.2380024642,
0.3146300018,
-0.8415416479,
0.8018209338,
0.1237059608,
-0.0993579924,
-0.2965585291,
-0.5005491972,
-0.772261858,
0.5663980246,
-0.3611561656,
-0.9655154943,
-0.2061783522,
-0.081475161,
-0.1920044422,
0.2095087767,
-0.9021701813,
0.6415341496,
-0.3993824422,
-0.4201998711,
-0.3296485841,
-0.523460865,
0.2975694537,
0.2248563468,
0.3333625793,
-0.2474097461,
-0.1109189317,
0.5411859751,
-0.3431176841,
1.0577360392,
-0.1076977402,
-0.1598195434,
0.29189381,
0.344278127,
0.4868255556,
0.1442044377,
0.0656104907,
-0.0096382424,
-0.1932651103,
-0.2449300885,
-0.9293801188,
0.4278483987,
-0.8007843494,
-0.6897349358,
-0.3175681829,
-0.5541385412,
-0.3574085534,
0.209709689,
-0.3328601718,
0.5774075389,
-0.1804359704,
-0.0570562445,
0.5749953389,
-0.1002408192,
0.326254487,
0.7077478766,
-0.3305251002,
-0.4374621809,
0.9578809142,
-0.3054507971,
0.2117730975,
0.5878079534,
0.146614328,
-0.535225451,
-0.6847013831,
-0.1395683438,
0.4514424503,
-0.7513388395,
-0.2809484303,
-0.4610674679,
-0.4635204971,
-0.2689574659,
-0.2554497421,
-0.2535142004,
-0.3074880242,
-0.1628912538,
-0.0725291818,
0.3144349158,
0.3217678368,
0.0266395863,
0.2647313774,
-0.6982858777,
0.4478346407,
0.1462973654,
0.3705918491,
0.225490734,
-0.4947400689,
0.0498836935,
0.0870041028,
-0.218329668,
-0.7979355454,
0.5463941097,
-0.0861898214,
0.753248632,
0.6206880808,
0.0722647533,
0.6224421263,
-0.2873732746,
0.2043442577,
0.2555171847,
-0.9644606709,
0.5142474771,
-0.1466035396,
0.3309364319,
0.3165722787,
0.3334755301,
-0.5606786013,
-0.1669116169,
-0.4726495743,
-0.6741317511,
0.7131854892,
0.4834807515,
0.0223201904,
0.0544644855,
0.1374211758,
0.2154287994,
0.2215545177,
-0.5578208566,
-0.1923142076,
-0.0298359077,
-0.5152122974,
0.2540667057,
-0.13784872,
0.0286944322,
-0.33039698,
0.5867701769,
-0.1675105989,
0.1606576145,
0.0277450141,
-0.4010121822,
0.4328123331,
0.3383000493,
0.2914666831,
0.5622918606,
-0.3317379057,
0.2597455084,
0.392442286,
-0.4545413256,
-0.062728852,
0.1462299675,
0.166626513,
-0.5233140588,
0.4009237885,
0.6141372323,
0.4314835668,
-0.9454131722,
0.4138365388,
-0.1340606511,
-0.2245534956,
-0.481726408,
0.0739413276,
0.2513297796,
0.3316901922,
0.5249952078,
0.0726499781,
0.0126328375,
-0.3351935446,
0.1630222201,
0.5446587205,
-0.1774883419,
-0.1008801758,
0.2628956437,
0.5325241685,
-0.3242907524,
0.8307241797,
-0.2184575945,
-0.652443707,
0.5071248412,
0.6098752618,
0.5802585483,
-0.0446667075,
0.2145571262,
0.3139215112,
0.1711077988,
0.2471377999,
0.0962424278,
-0.2510415614,
-1.074042201,
-0.5611842275,
-0.4725095928,
-0.4628865719,
-0.0178444255,
-0.3176960647,
0.4229334891,
-0.3869975805,
0.3673918843,
-0.1216440797,
0.0937762409,
-0.6746589541,
-0.1272768378,
0.2934105694,
0.7703814507,
-0.5974791646,
0.6754342914,
0.6102029085,
-0.5579943657,
-0.5305362344,
-0.1062938347,
0.2931959629,
-1.144387126,
0.7813411355,
0.2164652646,
-0.3306943774,
0.2051928192,
-0.3959043622,
-0.6325414777,
1.0179983377,
0.3780639768,
-0.1727614105,
0.0289309919,
0.2654985189,
0.4360648096,
-0.4241166115,
0.4396606386,
0.5671550632,
0.358720988,
0.7293049693,
-0.6904753447,
0.1864383072,
-0.1595383286,
-0.201623261,
0.2664735317,
-0.3553664684,
0.3255747855,
-0.5496379137,
-0.5463799238,
0.1140713841,
0.7840445638,
0.1603071988,
0.2534564734,
0.3598954678,
0.4601977766,
0.8353800178,
0.0617444217,
0.6399102807,
0.0436239317,
0.3109820485,
0.9656820893,
-0.2979837358,
0.8271598816,
0.4188621342,
-0.3327248096,
0.3868134916,
0.0893632099,
0.131423071,
0.5354316235,
0.3572707176,
-0.670488894,
-0.5130854845,
0.1536115557,
-0.1696004272,
0.5538381934,
0.7084032893,
0.1056488156,
-0.681635201,
0.1605029702,
0.0618633814,
0.2290673107,
-0.2922534943,
0.9232935905,
-0.0459243469,
-0.466757834,
0.7005952001,
-0.1152109206,
0.6241973639,
-0.5756207108,
-0.4479467273,
-0.19550322,
0.2710639834,
-0.1694326848,
-0.97974509,
0.3201149106,
-0.1106070429,
0.276830405,
0.1469758004,
0.8275800943,
-0.3462333977,
-0.4702585936,
0.1321271509,
0.6057215929,
0.1977347732,
0.0670340955,
-0.5849575996,
0.0020720463,
0.2137811333,
-0.0608279705,
0.1468662769,
0.5525515079,
0.0963132158,
1.1896506548,
0.7814935446,
-0.1561207473,
-0.1160454303,
0.1331389397,
0.9463815689,
-0.7963438034,
-0.2272197008,
-0.9922198057,
0.409291178,
-0.1392126232,
0.0835349709,
0.4321556091,
0.5449712873,
0.6398707032,
-0.0808989629,
0.8806087971,
-0.0973129049,
0.4614623189,
-0.7883094549,
0.492080301,
-0.2035577893,
0.5880580544,
-0.1183854863,
-0.6848571301,
-0.5925979018,
0.81368047,
-0.6404921412,
-0.1124970317,
0.7810830474,
0.8068863153,
-0.0119916471,
0.3854623735,
0.3066195548,
0.2079308778,
0.3375267982,
0.8500183821,
0.9925424457,
0.1279814243,
0.8730100989,
-0.2250040025,
-0.4186666012,
-0.2917533219,
-0.789178133,
-1.2310733795,
-0.553071022,
-0.2829589546,
-0.0103132082,
0.1291476637,
1.1291563511,
0.2670788467,
-0.6473044753,
-0.2259574831,
-0.2925812602,
0.4938505888,
-0.1847044975,
-0.2860883772,
0.5348406434,
-0.3890474439,
-0.7354186773,
0.081506215,
0.2668463588,
0.1005411074,
-0.0939020514,
-0.2208248973,
-0.3486511111,
0.1017130539,
0.7390177846,
0.3724536598,
-0.7226905227,
-0.3336053789,
-0.1886745393,
0.0615793541,
0.1063154116,
0.568241775,
-1.0552475452,
0.1344060451,
0.5585335493,
0.8980920911,
0.3769901693,
0.1719828397,
0.395129621,
-0.3526003957,
0.0035541831,
0.222004652,
0.341298759,
0.2091571689,
-0.1471796185,
0.5701234341,
0.1694170386,
-0.2940244973,
-0.5300681591,
0.3038299084,
-1.2673499584,
-0.2424090058,
1.0683231354,
0.0369305797,
-0.1993302852,
-0.3489760756,
-0.8182089329,
0.1894300431,
-0.4580110312,
0.9511016607,
0.6568059921,
-0.5432091355,
-0.3673149943,
-0.3345792294,
0.1068020314,
0.3072947264,
-0.9029563069,
0.2793110311,
0.5675321817,
0.0775352791,
0.0697293654,
0.3582980335,
-0.3047393858,
0.2144248635,
-0.1792061478,
0.181203112,
-0.2737106681,
0.0634661391,
-0.0621523149,
0.0367827453,
0.0812142938,
-0.1530451775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11015v3 | DIN-SQL: Decomposed In-Context Learning of Text-to-SQL with Self-Correction | 2023-04-21T15:02:18 | 2023-11-02T20:30:12 | Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.HC | There is currently a significant gap between the performance of fine-tuned
models and prompting approaches using Large Language Models (LLMs) on the
challenging task of text-to-SQL, as evaluated on datasets such as Spider. To
improve the performance of LLMs in the reasoning process, we study how
decomposing the task into smaller sub-tasks can be effective. In particular, we
show that breaking down the generation problem into sub-problems and feeding
the solutions of those sub-problems into LLMs can be an effective approach for
significantly improving their performance. Our experiments with three LLMs show
that this approach consistently improves their simple few-shot performance by
roughly 10%, pushing the accuracy of LLMs towards SOTA or surpassing it. On the
holdout test set of Spider, the SOTA, in terms of execution accuracy, was 79.9
and the new SOTA at the time of this writing using our approach is 85.3. Our
approach with in-context learning beats many heavily fine-tuned models by at
least 5%. Additionally, when evaluated on the BIRD benchmark, our approach
achieved an execution accuracy of 55.9%, setting a new SOTA on its holdout test
set. | [
-0.1352666169,
-0.7603589892,
0.5982092619,
-0.1394956559,
-0.3192615211,
-0.1197741181,
-0.2641908824,
-0.2263232917,
0.0597329326,
0.5643538237,
-0.6950050592,
-0.4365844727,
-0.2745410204,
0.6069544554,
-0.4137518704,
0.6740595698,
0.2732540965,
0.0819145143,
-0.399381876,
0.0365784429,
-0.603725493,
-0.526561439,
-0.6377477646,
-0.2129748166,
0.3786819577,
0.678214848,
0.2119467854,
0.7461985946,
0.3929935098,
0.2809912562,
-0.2643402815,
0.591360569,
-0.6959478259,
0.2514868379,
-0.5952422619,
-0.6699168086,
-0.426328361,
-0.3797347844,
0.5456039906,
0.7133057117,
-0.2898044288,
-0.0552855991,
0.1264481992,
1.0797739029,
-0.6188418269,
0.1137644947,
-0.882445395,
-0.0751905292,
-0.2453308702,
-0.3302869499,
-0.7712560892,
0.0843637958,
0.0318849571,
-0.5675750971,
0.1908547431,
-0.0356815979,
0.45264709,
0.6868745089,
-0.6317963004,
-0.226547718,
-0.5396814346,
0.7583190203,
-0.8815433979,
0.1897103041,
0.3106667995,
0.3672694564,
-0.5317724347,
-0.4484623671,
-0.5068018436,
0.0696571395,
-0.0266094077,
0.0728399903,
0.2256671041,
-0.01288391,
0.3122775257,
0.3341726959,
-0.2382644266,
0.2076266855,
-0.284254849,
0.1217184812,
0.9034764171,
0.3490650356,
0.0353281163,
-0.314127028,
-0.1834289879,
0.0293528773,
-0.9680736065,
-0.3829683065,
0.0347963348,
0.7662948966,
0.1426111907,
0.8242762685,
-0.4828900099,
0.8653274179,
0.315339148,
-0.0693743378,
-0.0656504855,
-0.3597710133,
-0.3737021387,
-0.1302131116,
0.3827118576,
0.3759159446,
0.2872683108,
-0.0976565853,
-0.2467492819,
-0.1283370852,
0.2043642402,
-0.5634542108,
-0.4359470606,
0.2073689848,
-0.3028850555,
-0.032905329,
-0.4315398932,
-0.5230630636,
-0.7406907678,
-0.4995478392,
0.4934793413,
-0.4742074907,
-0.2411407381,
0.0682733282,
0.1134318635,
0.2949062884,
0.5172954202,
-0.9129468799,
0.3023147881,
0.5940393209,
0.7288370132,
-0.3781326413,
-0.2174936384,
-0.6116731763,
0.4396991432,
-0.6152834892,
1.0089616776,
-0.275321424,
-0.252038449,
-0.2233856767,
-0.2206621915,
-0.1730345041,
-0.6992123723,
0.153585434,
-0.4014734924,
0.2045804709,
-0.6467022896,
-0.9916220903,
-0.1446520686,
0.3970884383,
-0.6334856749,
1.001535058,
0.1212963536,
-0.7156139016,
0.5155739188,
-0.7335416675,
-0.475890547,
-0.0902068987,
-0.2075335383,
-0.2503448129,
0.2292243093,
0.3718506992,
0.7484670281,
-0.3892742991,
-0.0686325431,
-0.03217756,
-0.4218581617,
-0.0777666941,
0.0425496101,
0.788285017,
0.0814426839,
-0.3985592723,
0.086472936,
-0.7561118603,
-0.0187444296,
0.2137941718,
-0.5062537193,
-0.3034536839,
0.1216892004,
-0.5274953246,
0.0902016982,
-0.1336787045,
-0.2884228826,
0.3301649988,
-0.9230061173,
0.4657933414,
0.6561573148,
-0.0342835672,
0.6148429513,
-0.0790642798,
0.1941571087,
0.1878593564,
-0.1434867233,
-0.1849073321,
-0.0530404784,
-1.013412714,
-0.2500394285,
0.4011303782,
0.4343705475,
-0.9450935721,
0.2694315314,
-0.0762672126,
-0.4696064889,
-0.1583541185,
0.1954556853,
0.382150203,
0.7358677387,
0.5775164962,
-0.1702128947,
-0.557714045,
-0.5902830362,
-0.38703686,
-0.0726875588,
0.1912450343,
0.3663190901,
0.6000431776,
-0.0998585969,
0.9817880392,
-0.5027245283,
-0.4519740641,
-0.3445269465,
-0.0466810614,
0.0625273809,
0.4912724197,
0.4079746008,
-0.5443039536,
-0.5333827138,
-0.1807525307,
-0.7488042712,
0.0736898556,
-0.010245733,
0.1394208521,
0.936252296,
0.6479637623,
-0.4834690094,
0.3818139434,
0.1870082617,
-0.2698495984,
0.7846881151,
-0.1850607693,
0.0540474541,
-1.2335363626,
-0.2060294896,
-0.0792179555,
-0.35707587,
-0.5202689171,
-0.02149239,
0.1029537097,
0.1436762214,
-0.5517243743,
0.4021134079,
-0.7343521118,
-0.2455188781,
-0.3148599267,
0.1158007383,
-0.138089627,
0.2767348289,
0.0618083701,
1.0322787762,
0.6268472672,
-0.9643275738,
0.315244019,
0.3060458601,
-0.4590181112,
0.6926882267,
-0.567854166,
0.1748376191,
-0.218556881,
0.3463955224,
-0.9815800786,
-0.3769108951,
-0.0489352494,
-0.2253944129,
0.4643009007,
-0.1263813823,
-0.5807198882,
0.0363517404,
-0.0109160235,
0.21249336,
0.2044594884,
-0.8106197119,
0.6826459169,
0.3581410944,
0.1743637323,
-0.6382189393,
-0.835157156,
0.231686011,
-0.240092054,
-0.4646176398,
0.3377860188,
0.1387226731,
-0.2235483229,
-0.17899777,
-0.2371684909,
-0.0688490793,
0.1157200187,
-0.2054785639,
-0.1057746783,
0.0099260649,
0.4913053215,
-0.0247067846,
-0.2060079128,
0.0993357077,
-0.0806448162,
0.4525022209,
-0.050532449,
-0.2353810221,
-0.3457204103,
0.3805469871,
0.1502730995,
-0.121133171,
0.8711089492,
0.0150070544,
-0.4247716665,
-0.6324235797,
-0.4360906184,
-0.559619844,
-0.4870307148,
0.1733789891,
-0.7995041609,
-0.7668588758,
0.2607295811,
-0.3895396292,
-0.0849384144,
0.6834838986,
0.4741218388,
-0.4978218973,
0.990167439,
0.9309097528,
0.2905683517,
0.1639946848,
-0.5569264293,
0.113153331,
-0.7481992841,
-0.3911948502,
-0.5175220966,
-0.0802275091,
-0.3041591644,
-0.5393243432,
0.2543070912,
0.0798391476,
-0.2701225281,
0.5627174973,
-0.5207760334,
0.8741474748,
0.3048134744,
0.2237603068,
0.410607487,
-0.0975941122,
-0.2236805409,
-0.0560267903,
-0.9917348623,
-0.2632719278,
1.0257035494,
0.009676531,
0.8608757257,
0.1994318962,
0.8565824628,
0.1549319327,
-0.037017148,
-0.8214681745,
0.7195025086,
-0.3319465816,
-0.53349787,
-0.4320934415,
-0.5717906356,
-0.6326267123,
0.1321802139,
-0.1960004717,
-0.5989513993,
0.2049452215,
0.2295026928,
-0.2524376512,
0.2253421545,
-0.8166359663,
0.8740034699,
-0.1071830913,
-0.3446191847,
-0.3740876615,
-0.7367245555,
0.4171323478,
-0.0747290403,
-0.1238723099,
-0.1398278624,
-0.2399469465,
0.4626104832,
-0.6944802403,
0.9944485426,
-0.1184276342,
-0.3025026619,
0.167662099,
0.2246027887,
0.5870395899,
-0.1828743964,
-0.3960742354,
-0.016447125,
0.1175467595,
-0.3951794505,
-0.8875075579,
0.4606858194,
-0.3812011778,
-0.7007229924,
-0.5512809753,
-0.6373385191,
-0.2498266548,
0.0893450305,
0.2578443885,
0.4353559017,
0.0572875366,
0.3807406127,
0.9067185521,
-0.0989845172,
0.386372298,
0.4941646159,
-0.0572957844,
-0.3185200095,
0.4628916085,
0.3143022358,
0.3999363482,
0.5661937594,
0.1876791418,
-0.8019925356,
-0.5786954165,
-0.5329834819,
0.2638377845,
-1.0055660009,
-0.4213596284,
-0.5993432403,
0.0218504872,
-0.4498925507,
-0.1156718731,
-0.4619398117,
-0.5334650874,
-0.4534207582,
0.0676093847,
0.3790192902,
0.6356081367,
-0.0430300683,
0.3331686258,
-0.5351917148,
0.1325532943,
0.2539645135,
0.2274005264,
-0.1146663651,
-0.6004981399,
-0.1574884057,
-0.0523524024,
0.0591394641,
-1.0409277678,
0.2038584352,
0.445392102,
0.4476488531,
-0.0040694592,
0.3076908588,
0.9939325452,
-0.3876165152,
0.7422718406,
0.0307208356,
-1.0987671614,
0.8775821328,
-0.3670713902,
0.2882123888,
0.7013602853,
0.249991715,
-0.1308843642,
-0.0346465968,
-0.4255461097,
-0.6715971231,
0.7803850174,
0.0725620836,
-0.074863404,
-0.0307090078,
0.7344596386,
-0.1074642017,
0.0446077809,
-0.5749337077,
-0.1760941446,
0.0758203268,
-0.1149404868,
-0.3001455069,
-0.4593463242,
-0.0814289227,
-0.5597046614,
0.7191040516,
-0.5844506621,
0.0054258555,
0.2730231583,
-0.3320356011,
0.0921192095,
0.2419351637,
0.4608057141,
0.8593763709,
-0.0309930611,
0.2474877685,
0.7256639004,
0.0925149024,
0.0988368094,
-0.4211474657,
-0.1250480711,
-0.2594126165,
0.155905515,
0.3043107688,
0.1286728233,
-0.6600085497,
0.4161118567,
0.0205099471,
-0.1270535737,
-0.0870406255,
0.2503743768,
0.2388257384,
0.1959028244,
0.2041727453,
-0.1266741306,
0.3404699862,
-0.6788815856,
0.2179619521,
0.4018551707,
-0.1012867242,
0.0986393392,
0.5355881453,
0.261849314,
-0.1045290455,
0.5379575491,
-0.3078657389,
-0.52957654,
0.6112603545,
1.025854826,
0.8266436458,
-0.2010108829,
0.1471606195,
0.5523278713,
0.2911711633,
-0.2988666892,
0.5176910162,
-0.1820818782,
-0.5549793243,
-0.80299896,
-0.463257134,
-0.6209258437,
-0.18164289,
-0.3989776969,
0.288936764,
-0.3211662769,
0.0721839294,
-0.0560170449,
0.3350817561,
-0.2221401483,
0.4375229478,
-0.300308913,
1.1742346287,
-0.7100916505,
0.8318008184,
0.6541942358,
-0.4099939764,
-0.9339401126,
0.0824944749,
0.0490641221,
-0.2598417997,
0.4813126922,
0.2716577053,
-0.2266742587,
0.2049329281,
-0.5145831704,
-0.9781998992,
0.8856361508,
0.6143580675,
-0.5491085649,
0.1497330219,
0.1380619705,
0.5454018712,
-0.4131575823,
0.0415009409,
0.8622476459,
0.3180695176,
0.2173216939,
-0.7667703629,
0.1194212139,
0.0341520347,
0.1500848383,
0.2394829243,
-0.6014450192,
0.7993674278,
-0.3623165488,
-0.4169747233,
-0.0954606831,
0.8316457272,
0.311139673,
0.1343549937,
0.6908237934,
0.6239930391,
0.7983087301,
-0.0725754425,
0.9782727361,
0.1924148649,
0.229855597,
1.397629261,
-0.3971561491,
1.0193560123,
0.4765559137,
-0.0637474135,
0.6193349361,
0.6877601743,
0.1603856981,
0.5136298537,
0.2723481655,
0.023375323,
-0.4924247265,
-0.0125436196,
-0.181302458,
0.7171967626,
0.3608843684,
0.007347567,
-0.4051664472,
-0.077612564,
-0.073762022,
0.5008709431,
-0.3520686626,
1.0962706804,
0.109269537,
-0.6962314248,
0.7407901287,
-0.0509863086,
0.5440489054,
-0.2302850485,
-0.145059824,
-0.3309558332,
0.3949534595,
-0.545899272,
-0.6635805964,
0.8150262833,
0.1048548818,
-0.3826106191,
-0.0276879985,
0.9618327022,
-0.4418539107,
-0.3376875222,
0.1420599669,
0.3881045878,
0.3546749651,
-0.2674615681,
-0.5890717506,
-0.0635176748,
-0.121437557,
-0.0685296208,
0.1803819686,
0.3744159639,
0.038451653,
0.8122963309,
0.4246084988,
-0.1077531949,
0.0171418581,
0.0744795129,
0.7602169514,
-0.7385694981,
-0.4088842869,
-0.9524606466,
0.4654920101,
-0.306388706,
-0.1564483345,
1.0005774498,
0.8070349693,
0.9656998515,
-0.0659481287,
0.4671328068,
-0.0587155819,
0.8045561314,
-0.7610210776,
0.6465757489,
-0.879281044,
0.4732010365,
-0.1127624586,
-0.9157437682,
-0.3861736059,
0.5708942413,
-0.2867477238,
0.0778220966,
0.8916222453,
0.9689651132,
0.1986194849,
-0.1480599493,
0.2784019411,
0.1381066442,
0.2084341198,
0.590292573,
0.7816046476,
-0.5284289718,
0.4678593278,
-0.3457360268,
-0.1023947671,
-0.2723067999,
-1.0466282368,
-1.0373828411,
-0.6748232841,
-0.4421663284,
-0.3679492176,
0.1279885024,
0.8383875489,
0.8176686764,
-0.8444489837,
-0.2623565793,
-0.306111306,
0.2055208236,
-0.5245012045,
-0.1796720326,
0.4870928824,
-0.7478253841,
-0.7220700383,
0.8049206138,
0.3214623332,
-0.1362002939,
-0.2654926479,
-0.0314569101,
-0.4224091768,
0.2496368289,
0.7605575323,
0.1493773609,
-0.609913528,
-0.1908159852,
0.0273424592,
-0.2244793028,
0.0653669387,
0.583394587,
-0.9484909177,
0.5067082644,
0.7121099234,
0.8271752,
0.7368873954,
0.1854961514,
0.6635095477,
-1.0038489103,
-0.1914614737,
0.2645210326,
0.2280865014,
0.4644668996,
-0.4250981808,
0.9799381495,
0.2510848045,
-0.5987535119,
-0.9549659491,
0.2710043788,
-0.9108422995,
-0.5106047988,
1.1630307436,
0.1369118243,
-0.4495873451,
-0.1229647696,
-0.2284998447,
0.3142552078,
0.0530322418,
0.9463185668,
0.3607933819,
-0.173401311,
-0.3706697822,
-0.0921470746,
0.7780777216,
0.6348508,
-1.1715211868,
0.2287364602,
0.648440361,
0.4181643426,
-0.1362475455,
0.7652648091,
-0.038960617,
0.2745682299,
0.0434403382,
-0.1309785247,
-0.089004308,
-0.6752949357,
-0.4208375216,
0.0303809829,
-0.0855565146,
-0.0411565788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10996v1 | BERT Based Clinical Knowledge Extraction for Biomedical Knowledge Graph Construction and Analysis | 2023-04-21T14:45:33 | 2023-04-21T14:45:33 | Ayoub Harnoune, Maryem Rhanoui, Mounia Mikram, Siham Yousfi, Zineb Elkaimbillah, Bouchra El Asri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Background : Knowledge is evolving over time, often as a result of new
discoveries or changes in the adopted methods of reasoning. Also, new facts or
evidence may become available, leading to new understandings of complex
phenomena. This is particularly true in the biomedical field, where scientists
and physicians are constantly striving to find new methods of diagnosis,
treatment and eventually cure. Knowledge Graphs (KGs) offer a real way of
organizing and retrieving the massive and growing amount of biomedical
knowledge.
Objective : We propose an end-to-end approach for knowledge extraction and
analysis from biomedical clinical notes using the Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) model and Conditional Random Field
(CRF) layer.
Methods : The approach is based on knowledge graphs, which can effectively
process abstract biomedical concepts such as relationships and interactions
between medical entities. Besides offering an intuitive way to visualize these
concepts, KGs can solve more complex knowledge retrieval problems by
simplifying them into simpler representations or by transforming the problems
into representations from different perspectives. We created a biomedical
Knowledge Graph using using Natural Language Processing models for named entity
recognition and relation extraction. The generated biomedical knowledge graphs
(KGs) are then used for question answering.
Results : The proposed framework can successfully extract relevant structured
information with high accuracy (90.7% for Named-entity recognition (NER), 88%
for relation extraction (RE)), according to experimental findings based on
real-world 505 patient biomedical unstructured clinical notes.
Conclusions : In this paper, we propose a novel end-to-end system for the
construction of a biomedical knowledge graph from clinical textual using a
variation of BERT models. | [
-0.2372087389,
-0.9948899746,
0.7338423133,
0.1481995583,
-0.3197583258,
-0.0397195369,
-0.118669264,
-0.8006194234,
0.3687252104,
0.5448345542,
-0.5155082345,
-0.7753046155,
-0.7198312283,
0.1296745539,
-0.0522748493,
1.2378339767,
0.039176289,
0.3654792011,
-0.5626491308,
-0.1020232961,
-0.1548888534,
-0.3656604886,
-0.6247922182,
-0.4342410564,
0.4982296228,
0.0319080502,
0.4495333135,
0.3704281151,
0.8580422997,
0.2747159004,
-0.2538536489,
0.1338989139,
-0.306601882,
0.2945655286,
-0.0561341904,
-0.1995896548,
-0.6171647906,
-0.2744339108,
0.3823463321,
0.839494586,
-0.0420277305,
0.0374505892,
-0.1829088926,
0.6975583434,
-0.0367458165,
0.477530539,
-0.4659547806,
0.2246898413,
0.0115265641,
-0.369913131,
-0.4069108367,
-0.6514797807,
0.7019822598,
-0.6667439342,
0.2937203348,
-0.1643075496,
1.044990778,
-0.0212833174,
-0.4639028013,
-0.7284144163,
-0.315864414,
0.5156648159,
-0.8876782656,
0.4532086551,
0.2144089341,
0.5715915561,
-0.3022864163,
-1.1861473322,
-0.4596995711,
-0.0925040171,
-0.3648685217,
0.4649097919,
-0.068842046,
0.2723862827,
0.1896139532,
-0.0370937511,
-0.4069088101,
-0.1931976378,
-0.4773574769,
-0.4358344078,
0.5246634483,
0.0091831293,
0.3808460832,
-0.6057392359,
-0.6491189599,
0.1136120334,
-0.489770174,
0.0909900367,
-0.0790078565,
0.040364258,
-0.0242236648,
0.4211958647,
0.0271902066,
0.7914022803,
-0.2383692414,
-0.3842526078,
0.3798435628,
-0.0611157902,
-0.2674317062,
0.1678452939,
0.982791245,
0.3113348484,
0.2594216466,
-0.516222477,
0.0842302963,
-0.4055475593,
0.2847856283,
-0.7575598359,
-0.1868586987,
0.2294820845,
-0.8811294436,
-0.3965560198,
-0.2287551314,
-0.9519948959,
-0.397708416,
-0.1866923422,
0.345184952,
-1.0395740271,
0.0788186789,
-0.0488221161,
-0.4979292452,
0.300557971,
0.5083314776,
-0.5154999495,
0.1393916309,
0.25796929,
0.5436749458,
0.0898824856,
0.3400972784,
0.0682687536,
0.6077411175,
0.1412002742,
0.7894182801,
-0.3089257479,
-0.5182214379,
0.1514388621,
0.1203273758,
-0.2908652425,
-0.3274700344,
0.6457951069,
-0.7370021343,
0.2495028228,
-0.2980829775,
-0.886131525,
-0.3130641282,
0.338301301,
-0.4834509492,
0.7178366184,
0.1825156361,
-0.8315912485,
0.3012608886,
-0.5961202979,
-0.7558339834,
0.2007938027,
-0.3826273084,
-0.4918179512,
-0.3277148306,
0.4334330857,
0.5755943656,
-0.3977826238,
0.3736246228,
-0.3190409541,
0.1143486127,
0.3514229953,
-0.1057820767,
0.9571285248,
0.2858147025,
0.0444874167,
-0.0532743782,
-0.8797677755,
0.135531798,
0.1583938152,
-0.392319262,
-0.3578656316,
0.0893180147,
-0.0706463009,
0.1944800913,
0.3882305324,
-0.9252800941,
0.1586701423,
-0.3234479725,
0.3676159084,
0.4986567795,
0.495388329,
0.0007362923,
-0.3530410826,
0.3294195235,
0.1420108974,
0.2534616888,
0.0854308456,
-0.8052169681,
-0.4024525583,
-0.5067778826,
0.4498718679,
0.5393073559,
-0.7449669242,
0.5741198063,
-0.3882679641,
-0.3046957254,
-0.6703940034,
-0.1164245382,
0.3851914704,
1.2197623253,
0.6685482264,
-0.2378260344,
-0.6505048275,
-1.0640224218,
0.0813042,
-0.2473956198,
-0.0249618143,
0.6116306782,
0.2573999166,
-0.4648819268,
1.2534683943,
-0.7897893786,
-0.4581924081,
-0.509293735,
0.2711026073,
0.3374157846,
0.3315674961,
0.5530981421,
-0.601919651,
-0.5007821321,
0.1948086917,
-1.1049454212,
-0.1217755377,
-0.1643553227,
-0.2960595489,
-0.0623576716,
0.3899767399,
-0.6625224352,
0.411860615,
-0.0399371386,
-0.1632687002,
0.4872430861,
-0.5112875104,
-0.0655563027,
-1.0739358664,
0.3106534183,
0.0016200023,
-0.3694490194,
-0.5816904902,
-0.2674147487,
0.1837042123,
-0.0055970736,
-0.0271812826,
0.2597559392,
-0.205055505,
0.1280676872,
0.2177570015,
0.1361639351,
0.1484286338,
0.5418407917,
0.2472435236,
0.1082313657,
0.4047956765,
-0.2471677065,
0.1098987088,
0.7424763441,
-0.2487320006,
0.2421488166,
-0.7526522279,
0.0042930925,
-0.4012612104,
0.1786588728,
-0.9813147187,
0.039137613,
0.1598389447,
-0.8291860819,
0.5954524279,
-0.2602877319,
-0.4524004757,
-0.5137789845,
-0.0002473033,
-0.1579094082,
0.7422737479,
-0.1064363793,
0.4498554766,
0.4307266772,
-0.4968394339,
-0.4422334433,
-0.4199972451,
-0.1931405365,
0.2718779147,
-0.7520313859,
0.5473285317,
0.092964001,
0.0873621479,
0.2290701419,
-0.0130276056,
-0.3727749586,
-0.3462974727,
0.1253245175,
0.5231470466,
-0.1493687332,
0.3552862108,
0.4647919238,
-0.0135929454,
0.3325071037,
0.0131345624,
0.2880634665,
0.1625902951,
-0.2752708197,
-0.3319703043,
0.3160988986,
0.7198672295,
-0.1656980664,
0.8062239289,
0.7012771964,
-0.5838628411,
0.1198581606,
-0.565130949,
-0.059062399,
-0.4012076557,
0.4147401452,
-0.0043656263,
-0.5782809258,
0.796420455,
-0.2081522495,
-0.0826337785,
0.53571558,
0.634042263,
-0.6521179676,
0.882383883,
0.4773784876,
0.1161605716,
0.1176871285,
-0.2538312674,
0.3100658059,
-0.8479679227,
-0.7235602736,
-0.2016750723,
-0.2218095362,
-0.317127198,
-0.2100752741,
0.8061280251,
0.1218735054,
-0.0921011716,
0.225296542,
-0.5753630996,
-0.1814554334,
0.4053720236,
0.7445081472,
0.1177678779,
0.0511402786,
-0.4735036194,
-0.1379243433,
-0.6737441421,
-0.2934661508,
1.2479066849,
0.425606668,
0.3165701032,
0.0542516969,
0.8472775221,
0.3328079581,
0.6781750321,
-0.6753771901,
0.5308855176,
-0.0199117679,
-0.6653316617,
-0.4114353061,
-0.4648677409,
-0.8998352289,
-0.0155258747,
-0.2674452364,
-0.7621479034,
0.3884892464,
-0.207558915,
-0.4271419346,
0.2211776078,
-0.6752189994,
0.7355501652,
-0.1252384186,
-0.1989856362,
0.0900000259,
-1.1604967117,
0.1048951074,
-0.0230039395,
0.2263473272,
0.0789884776,
0.4145195186,
1.015909791,
-0.5647751093,
0.7829713225,
-0.4221412241,
0.0083313594,
0.4993817508,
-0.1564116776,
0.5238694549,
0.2181857675,
-0.026783675,
0.1390536875,
0.3867584765,
-0.1931677312,
-0.5942704678,
0.2613154352,
-0.8031013608,
-0.2615748644,
-0.2550854087,
-0.7364934683,
-0.4585801661,
0.347905159,
0.2160625905,
0.6076479554,
-0.0223065577,
0.0935568959,
0.5808099508,
-0.6045990586,
0.1866260767,
0.7303885221,
0.1307765245,
-0.6589210033,
0.7869692445,
0.0629203245,
-0.0077630244,
0.5972678065,
0.092135556,
-0.444750309,
-0.6035622954,
-0.2431620359,
0.500777185,
-0.699511826,
-0.4238361716,
-0.8456405401,
-0.5136127472,
-0.8243315816,
-0.1352513433,
-0.021026494,
-0.5756748319,
-0.1982115805,
0.0279634651,
0.4795438647,
0.4546030462,
0.0049562696,
0.1216160953,
-1.1320437193,
0.3313322067,
0.1438584775,
0.196808517,
0.0025393658,
-0.3204061389,
-0.268951267,
-0.0425480902,
-0.343437165,
-1.2322974205,
0.6361631155,
0.0758311525,
0.872741878,
0.6651071906,
-0.0400456376,
0.9028687477,
-0.5499856472,
0.3295040727,
0.3599857986,
-0.475379616,
0.5316433311,
-0.3770020008,
-0.2102825046,
0.4884386957,
0.4732098281,
-0.4278224111,
-0.1827567965,
-0.7616636157,
-0.7247259021,
0.5846868157,
0.2993682623,
-0.4844697118,
-0.1083366647,
0.5645640492,
0.1791942567,
0.2158781141,
-0.5551477075,
-0.3165404499,
-0.0544683784,
-0.7352253795,
0.3508186936,
-0.3949317932,
-0.358886838,
-0.522661984,
0.4758803248,
0.0326780379,
0.826313436,
0.7232077122,
-0.1896638423,
-0.0493110195,
0.3412456512,
0.239969328,
0.5315887332,
-0.7367749214,
-0.1620937288,
-0.0121932095,
-0.5687428713,
-0.432415694,
0.537612021,
-0.0758375153,
0.1124409959,
0.6617521048,
0.347025305,
0.1629704535,
-0.8596532941,
0.5787457228,
0.1236788556,
-0.3762958348,
-0.3840637505,
-0.3390251696,
0.1957910508,
0.2466305941,
0.1477855295,
-0.0213651415,
0.254821986,
-0.3331593871,
0.5567050576,
0.4977570772,
-0.7463134527,
-0.1590889841,
0.6293756366,
-0.0007335416,
0.0425776765,
0.7982763648,
-0.0340312384,
-0.4570092559,
0.9238622189,
0.7699198723,
0.5045691133,
0.1688291579,
0.3620176911,
0.3209550977,
0.0817694366,
0.5268644094,
0.4179645479,
-0.2149265707,
-0.745598793,
-0.3048039079,
-0.7709168792,
-0.356934607,
-0.0775548592,
-1.0157387257,
0.1269888431,
-0.2359737456,
-0.1889484972,
0.212868169,
-0.1438490003,
-0.6266796589,
0.2622037828,
-0.0062453467,
0.8771586418,
-0.4344023764,
0.9465151429,
0.850402832,
-0.5399861336,
-0.5849708319,
-0.4589056373,
-0.3725653887,
-1.0653579235,
0.8505419493,
-0.0551415756,
0.6395828128,
-0.0981438756,
-0.38411659,
-0.6151217818,
1.2651692629,
0.031698931,
-0.4021653533,
-0.2675125599,
0.3502781689,
0.8273017406,
-0.15426597,
0.4341091514,
0.472823143,
0.3401715457,
0.4418517053,
-0.7059663534,
0.1641807258,
-0.3148780167,
-0.4823751748,
0.2886944711,
-0.2343996912,
0.5632281899,
-0.3505552411,
0.0916165337,
-0.0707209408,
0.3647626638,
0.318999052,
0.4585520029,
0.1822196394,
0.6547470689,
0.7612608075,
-0.014480724,
0.8243607879,
-0.5809885859,
0.4261763394,
0.6741535068,
-0.3732665479,
0.3951189816,
0.4840051234,
-0.3920637667,
0.8628315926,
0.4865025282,
0.0709507987,
0.7412105203,
-0.0540866256,
-0.2492969632,
-0.3108526468,
0.0577063374,
-0.521099925,
0.0679824427,
0.7200089693,
-0.9053761959,
-0.4302312434,
-0.0629511774,
0.0804017186,
-0.3644831777,
0.0189804528,
0.9696349502,
0.0443841591,
-0.3748548031,
0.3174246252,
-0.1700217277,
0.0690579861,
-1.0127687454,
-0.3839117289,
0.0387690328,
0.1225883961,
-0.022534173,
-0.7330157161,
0.1088162065,
-0.1302621514,
-0.2459063232,
-0.248674199,
1.0547671318,
-0.5048566461,
-0.6053557992,
0.2185140699,
0.6174616814,
0.1604032815,
0.4603081048,
-0.6602091789,
-0.4740043283,
0.1817374676,
-0.2080723643,
0.3134074807,
0.6883721352,
0.1465694755,
0.7013825178,
0.7551997304,
0.4156621099,
-0.1273134053,
0.1391768306,
0.9915328026,
-0.615922153,
-0.4640387297,
-0.5804690123,
0.3122334182,
-0.4572100937,
-0.0852763727,
0.4251108766,
0.4292871058,
0.1522308141,
-0.1246967241,
0.9841237068,
-0.3029306233,
0.8244803548,
-0.3156499863,
1.135468483,
-0.3272283375,
0.1522010416,
-0.4404470623,
-0.1327795535,
-0.3696911633,
0.5696718693,
-0.3124041557,
-0.295543015,
0.7617009878,
0.4360632896,
0.2757756114,
0.3809174895,
0.005666045,
0.404333204,
0.5261278152,
0.6259675622,
0.2583553791,
-0.3430127203,
0.5564652681,
-0.3190437853,
-0.3055382967,
-0.0340435952,
-0.5858585835,
-0.8612039685,
-0.3616343439,
-0.2398929,
-0.3309290409,
0.1864223629,
0.691618681,
0.3990188241,
-0.8427969217,
0.2518111169,
-0.0672089383,
0.1615295261,
-0.3049871325,
-0.2545386553,
1.0832496881,
-0.482409358,
-0.2348688096,
0.1083014384,
0.174222067,
0.1177032739,
0.2454526573,
0.0220291372,
-0.241523549,
-0.1582288444,
0.6796584725,
0.3255984187,
-0.2465702444,
-0.1540481299,
0.0500715189,
-0.0930033922,
0.1095964909,
0.7910624146,
-1.0937530994,
0.7561671734,
0.507452786,
0.6060464382,
0.4962756932,
-0.0781762078,
0.4357402325,
-0.5502297878,
-0.0004189775,
0.3829942048,
0.5600500107,
0.0164748654,
-0.3558807373,
0.361692071,
0.6160998344,
-0.5301979184,
-0.6846597195,
-0.1047922969,
-1.2709332705,
-0.3194230199,
0.9550271034,
-0.2920213938,
-0.2139576077,
-0.3926263452,
-0.238459602,
0.7281814814,
-0.2703845203,
0.9534767866,
0.3803552687,
-0.7239846587,
0.1586626768,
-0.6237075329,
0.4106109738,
0.2834925056,
-0.7707486749,
-0.287209332,
0.1245696917,
0.3622528613,
0.0699458122,
0.7501844764,
-0.6607067585,
0.125549525,
-0.3130654395,
0.340670079,
-0.1754196435,
0.0436543152,
0.3089368343,
0.2488133311,
-0.4725969136,
-0.17887941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10994v1 | Information Extraction from Documents: Question Answering vs Token Classification in real-world setups | 2023-04-21T14:43:42 | 2023-04-21T14:43:42 | Laurent Lam, Pirashanth Ratnamogan, Joël Tang, William Vanhuffel, Fabien Caspani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research in Document Intelligence and especially in Document Key Information
Extraction (DocKIE) has been mainly solved as Token Classification problem.
Recent breakthroughs in both natural language processing (NLP) and computer
vision helped building document-focused pre-training methods, leveraging a
multimodal understanding of the document text, layout and image modalities.
However, these breakthroughs also led to the emergence of a new DocKIE subtask
of extractive document Question Answering (DocQA), as part of the Machine
Reading Comprehension (MRC) research field. In this work, we compare the
Question Answering approach with the classical token classification approach
for document key information extraction. We designed experiments to benchmark
five different experimental setups : raw performances, robustness to noisy
environment, capacity to extract long entities, fine-tuning speed on Few-Shot
Learning and finally Zero-Shot Learning. Our research showed that when dealing
with clean and relatively short entities, it is still best to use token
classification-based approach, while the QA approach could be a good
alternative for noisy environment or long entities use-cases. | [
-0.5021822453,
-0.8197769523,
0.5962823629,
-0.3929637372,
-0.3626407087,
0.2259890884,
0.2014878541,
-0.718485415,
-0.0624046773,
0.2343145311,
-0.3636880517,
-0.4469799101,
-0.5125005245,
0.1551151276,
-0.2674152553,
0.8398737311,
0.0549666658,
0.0503938571,
-0.4981807172,
-0.1189948618,
-0.5387259126,
-0.5578136444,
-0.9470957518,
0.2758144736,
0.4348762333,
0.3625864089,
0.2621932924,
0.5669696927,
0.6473825574,
0.2429571599,
-0.1735165864,
0.0597200803,
0.0810799152,
0.1933447421,
-0.1104409024,
-0.7739241123,
-0.0829363018,
0.2697761655,
0.3646656573,
0.1813232154,
0.1572631299,
0.2786602676,
-0.3530987203,
0.3870526552,
-0.7850297093,
0.4745159149,
-0.5727059841,
0.1383000314,
-0.001488587,
-0.2075883299,
-0.348351866,
-0.0814068019,
0.0438795723,
-0.9301642179,
0.520660162,
0.3410578072,
1.2085851431,
0.1840295941,
-0.2139980048,
-0.734680295,
-0.4575808942,
0.5246220827,
-0.6473758817,
0.5284355283,
0.240896672,
0.3676457405,
0.1448343247,
-1.0124999285,
-0.943318665,
0.1452545077,
0.0712057725,
0.5627010465,
-0.0644014403,
0.0044277022,
0.3910399973,
0.167929396,
-0.5315465927,
0.2107530534,
-0.6172733307,
-0.2275771499,
0.0984061211,
-0.2091623843,
0.2452682555,
-0.6626406312,
-0.4491450489,
-0.4274224043,
-0.2703067064,
0.5686647892,
0.1038824096,
0.1901037544,
0.3520902991,
0.3364180923,
-0.1672116965,
0.2270647436,
0.0675841048,
-0.1323765665,
0.1857351661,
-0.3854939044,
-0.1190921813,
-0.0550259575,
0.4492916167,
0.2244408131,
0.0410595499,
-0.5839959979,
-0.2309051156,
-0.3281168342,
0.430995971,
-0.6579363942,
0.2743804157,
0.4410552979,
-0.5829166174,
-0.5389127135,
0.4482833743,
-0.9102604389,
-0.3246787488,
-0.1400118023,
0.3104962409,
-0.396483928,
-0.1176821515,
-0.3038167953,
-0.7952950597,
0.84686023,
0.6290915608,
-0.8031882048,
0.2513309121,
0.9649259448,
0.912183702,
-0.4010318816,
0.0880023986,
-0.878129065,
-0.0795768723,
-0.3466919363,
0.8622410893,
-0.3426272571,
-0.3178068399,
0.0128955273,
0.0628981814,
-0.2973361909,
-0.6194671392,
0.7483325601,
-0.9152787328,
0.6617267728,
-0.2176003456,
-0.5728416443,
-0.0450649187,
0.4619244337,
-0.7144784927,
1.0223067999,
0.3793961704,
-1.0378203392,
0.6220160127,
-0.8777714968,
-0.1081998497,
0.2789444327,
-0.22891289,
-0.2366032004,
0.0052690753,
0.2850506604,
0.352965802,
-0.3181215525,
-0.0184739623,
-0.1437605917,
-0.4694730043,
0.3571526706,
-0.3903208971,
0.4524801075,
0.5201773643,
-0.3305926621,
-0.1104169339,
-0.7160738111,
0.0142160291,
0.0334906727,
-0.5704442263,
-0.1887039393,
-0.2483448535,
0.0507467017,
0.4798382521,
0.115064308,
-0.8050819635,
0.1381971836,
-0.3255684674,
0.5155393481,
0.4971913695,
0.3053692579,
0.6259085536,
-0.292357713,
0.6539133191,
0.206221357,
0.2448752671,
-0.2263638228,
-0.4130665958,
-0.5634729862,
-0.4721408188,
0.7882386446,
0.6670770049,
-0.8819189668,
0.0260772035,
-0.3344497085,
-0.2487313002,
-0.61048913,
-0.2401855737,
0.2349146754,
0.7952814698,
0.3351792991,
-0.4593648314,
-0.1899591535,
-0.5966702104,
-0.0894557238,
-0.6039645076,
-0.1079918072,
0.5524300933,
0.4605407715,
0.1266427189,
1.0524256229,
-0.5070707202,
-0.0850194916,
-0.2648106217,
0.5791866183,
0.0462159626,
0.2618627548,
0.5570991635,
-1.1006861925,
-0.2046006471,
-0.1070519462,
-0.7572783232,
0.0056392192,
-0.1454786956,
0.0431188419,
0.3606682122,
0.7053135037,
-0.8445063233,
0.4886817932,
-0.2222426683,
-0.0113068307,
0.6004906297,
-0.1128908768,
0.2854540646,
-1.0755608082,
0.2562497556,
-0.2839722037,
-0.1372434795,
-0.7386585474,
0.3971944749,
0.4591366053,
-0.4218341112,
-0.5884879827,
0.6761184931,
-0.4740155339,
-0.1749801487,
-0.1569437087,
0.3981043994,
0.3009750545,
0.4982971251,
0.1115291193,
0.9259624481,
0.1828065217,
-0.3186280429,
0.1214887723,
0.3986794055,
-0.0756311491,
0.4246732593,
-0.4573223889,
0.4748434126,
-0.5055834055,
0.099388428,
-1.1372375488,
-0.034124922,
0.3010358214,
-0.6374273896,
0.5975363255,
-0.124570705,
-0.730019629,
-0.3789788783,
-0.5884762406,
0.006144837,
0.4999538362,
-0.3944362402,
0.6319819093,
0.1813534796,
-0.3982787728,
-0.789093256,
-0.3005396426,
0.1306696087,
-0.3381662369,
-0.2307406813,
0.057856068,
0.1265742034,
-0.2088801563,
-0.1112717018,
-0.3993829191,
-0.3942242265,
0.329128474,
0.5098392963,
0.4176692367,
-0.2690270841,
0.5404568315,
-0.0170332566,
-0.1669891477,
0.0903924778,
-0.1278340966,
0.3058961928,
-0.0702590644,
-0.0932176784,
-0.2399702221,
0.4424189031,
0.7542566061,
-0.4817651212,
0.7416059375,
0.7050077915,
-0.1654110551,
0.0967567414,
-0.658611834,
-0.1803663224,
-0.3882800341,
0.2539089918,
-0.6798487306,
-0.5826565623,
0.4649609923,
-0.2822743058,
0.2919414639,
0.6115890741,
-0.0276290663,
-0.6298627257,
0.4958590865,
0.6237655878,
-0.2189676464,
0.6235567927,
-0.2992500365,
0.1128868982,
-0.8208732605,
-0.151203692,
-0.9363423586,
0.0186497364,
-0.2183815092,
-0.3135470748,
0.2348987609,
0.3571045697,
0.2704104185,
0.4038199186,
-0.2760238349,
0.0428820997,
0.7338391542,
-0.1774217635,
0.2301122397,
-0.1623659134,
-0.3573477566,
0.2057158202,
-0.8522387743,
-0.5924271941,
1.2659691572,
0.3495270908,
0.2147711217,
-0.1846901625,
0.7881864309,
0.261074394,
0.3849389255,
-0.792227447,
0.3001194596,
0.1663084328,
-0.7556087971,
-0.5012348294,
-0.2583042085,
-0.9469720125,
0.3353301585,
-0.4384149611,
-0.599200964,
0.303832233,
-0.4053469896,
-0.0941615626,
0.1861450523,
-0.769523263,
0.9168328047,
-0.1161871403,
0.0198050495,
0.1237746626,
-0.9591644406,
-0.1945140064,
-0.2978155911,
0.5463554263,
0.2303650677,
-0.09167739,
0.911379993,
-0.2280015796,
0.3420005739,
-0.3301676512,
0.0674838349,
0.4084799588,
-0.2877441049,
0.5116775036,
-0.0140184248,
-0.2261309773,
-0.0365958847,
0.5623949766,
-0.3828747869,
-0.9115521312,
0.1608159989,
-0.7652156353,
-0.491027236,
-0.4145930707,
-0.4529651403,
-0.3022858799,
0.3514326215,
0.3584355712,
0.6086540222,
-0.2018397897,
0.2053080499,
0.7380712032,
-0.0017069891,
0.7197025418,
0.5596616268,
0.0935679972,
-0.2389769405,
0.7588831782,
0.3000658751,
-0.0174687561,
0.7438656688,
-0.0028209537,
-0.5774444342,
-0.8211758733,
-0.5804644227,
0.1797308624,
-0.941362679,
-0.011489057,
-0.7621047497,
-0.3108959198,
-0.6786679626,
0.0630333573,
0.0721914098,
-0.7707791924,
-0.4946008027,
-0.2550544143,
-0.2470012605,
0.3660002947,
0.343445152,
0.0203453265,
-0.9321266413,
0.5153821707,
0.4285092652,
-0.046195887,
-0.2592834532,
-0.3924995959,
-0.1494351327,
-0.3094551265,
-0.1846903265,
-1.0241231918,
-0.0705001205,
0.0173568204,
0.760866046,
0.3844279647,
0.2392191291,
0.3703812361,
-0.1159099564,
0.6865947843,
0.0682558268,
-0.3887294233,
0.3552016616,
0.0082913395,
0.3448615074,
0.8857980967,
0.3940921128,
-0.6283347011,
-0.4760323167,
-0.9059221745,
-0.6774637699,
0.6184014678,
0.1737053394,
-0.1049677059,
-0.1064319462,
0.7590550184,
0.3174850047,
0.5523525476,
-0.3649323881,
0.1096950695,
-0.2919671237,
-0.3757465482,
0.0523302294,
-0.0861593485,
0.0451275259,
0.0796186924,
0.3234438598,
-0.3046121001,
0.3110055625,
0.3779211938,
-0.5063513517,
0.213823095,
0.5062249303,
0.2099035829,
0.493576169,
-0.4798646271,
0.2146255821,
0.1317149997,
-0.6524149776,
-0.0672292784,
0.0983624905,
-0.2779975533,
-0.0126978708,
0.5819271803,
0.5976956487,
-0.0953351632,
-0.7806770802,
0.8471964002,
-0.4567076266,
-0.5747002959,
-0.0074081239,
0.1938856095,
-0.1240956113,
0.3004805744,
0.4981961548,
-0.0894905999,
0.2037712783,
-0.7001798749,
0.0930056646,
0.5214417577,
-0.470759958,
0.0260522459,
0.5792248845,
0.1300464123,
-0.3300513923,
0.7326908708,
-0.1842328459,
-0.3094755411,
0.7922179103,
0.3275198638,
0.7776038051,
0.5927966833,
0.3835256696,
0.2397717535,
0.2803744674,
0.415555954,
0.1675219983,
-0.6584432125,
-0.5826095939,
0.0358733609,
-0.5923091769,
-0.532699883,
0.1427430809,
-0.6393179297,
-0.2048431784,
-0.4893088639,
-0.1417753249,
0.2440133095,
0.3878748715,
-0.6378939152,
0.3573017716,
-0.0055440348,
1.1834155321,
-0.6120072603,
0.6970945597,
0.8384797573,
-0.6220618486,
-0.6710642576,
0.0666521788,
-0.3685379028,
-0.4424656928,
0.6906713843,
0.2621973753,
0.1693266034,
-0.0593319349,
-0.5086529255,
-0.5707370043,
1.3357388973,
-0.0458531864,
-0.1518952399,
-0.2300664634,
0.0973379761,
0.621445477,
-0.1768484712,
0.3441764712,
0.2781924307,
0.4935282469,
0.0985834077,
-0.5140448213,
-0.0080262879,
-0.404419452,
-0.1810558587,
-0.0584383719,
-0.5262134075,
0.4390258789,
0.0646952912,
-0.6123297215,
0.009929331,
0.5045449734,
-0.0829890296,
0.5834599733,
0.67991817,
0.506082356,
1.0033472776,
-0.1277602166,
1.0015380383,
-0.2371795923,
-0.0402405411,
0.8001950979,
-0.142320022,
0.9555169344,
0.6496869326,
-0.1048779264,
0.358148247,
0.7640723586,
0.0833617151,
0.4761399329,
-0.0699474812,
-0.0045638699,
0.062227238,
0.0489170216,
-0.1172054112,
0.3637450039,
0.0882800445,
-0.0071636825,
-0.1096942797,
0.1533649117,
-0.2185417116,
-0.3113832772,
-0.0396275856,
1.2166622877,
-0.1176855564,
-0.7079023719,
0.1530139297,
0.2043596357,
0.3184015155,
-0.4304256737,
0.0310574584,
-0.2438999712,
-0.3548521698,
0.0855223238,
-0.5726079345,
-0.0504070297,
0.0414874665,
-0.2773467898,
-0.0606795773,
1.0362820625,
0.0663492382,
0.0743229687,
-0.1940111518,
0.6866372228,
0.3237970471,
-0.2591791451,
-0.723443985,
-0.6155191064,
-0.504099071,
-0.1329262108,
0.3929373622,
0.421818912,
-0.1839327365,
0.5449143052,
0.8826278448,
-0.0482217036,
0.3324455321,
-0.1385639459,
0.8282903433,
-0.5511212945,
-0.6323391795,
-0.2687576413,
0.1213326678,
-0.3783976734,
-0.461022526,
0.4900657535,
0.653229773,
0.4172976315,
-0.2076316625,
0.6970130205,
0.0059688729,
0.3678902984,
-0.5416405797,
0.3895369768,
-0.4390692115,
-0.0874668881,
-0.1936881393,
-0.9137989879,
-0.011361503,
0.2254226357,
-0.1961377114,
-0.4088194668,
1.090846777,
0.5253348947,
0.0580506399,
0.0678728819,
0.200542897,
-0.1678755432,
0.4334841073,
0.1478465497,
0.9009497762,
-0.5523018241,
0.6611655951,
0.0703879595,
-0.218074128,
-0.106389761,
-0.5276819468,
-0.7038219571,
-0.6191680431,
-0.221281305,
-0.0545625314,
0.0017375206,
0.4351771772,
0.6517829895,
-0.6522653103,
0.3253085017,
-0.0689301714,
0.284116298,
-0.3143164814,
-0.2912577093,
0.3820203841,
-0.6812875271,
-0.6031271815,
0.269880414,
0.4090748429,
0.1913438439,
0.2379422784,
0.1591960639,
-0.2640803754,
0.2238043845,
0.3418237567,
0.5091236234,
-0.3076360822,
-0.3532360196,
0.279099673,
-0.3672384024,
0.374871701,
0.7558760047,
-0.678055346,
0.5238575339,
0.7254065275,
0.8928417563,
0.9248610735,
0.4147768915,
0.115403533,
-0.4547225237,
0.112138316,
0.0950833708,
0.1617827564,
-0.0286624692,
-0.2642164528,
0.584117353,
0.4022349715,
-0.2956398129,
-0.5948303342,
-0.0164732765,
-1.2206995487,
-0.7021514773,
0.8177059889,
-0.3323506713,
-0.453645587,
-0.5195162892,
-0.5415300727,
0.4504688084,
-0.2928425968,
0.8671180606,
0.8444516659,
0.0611841828,
-0.2621457577,
-0.68217659,
0.3389859498,
0.2585473657,
-1.1097214222,
-0.3144279718,
0.2273888141,
0.1857939512,
0.5585615635,
0.7098802328,
-0.3401327133,
0.39407444,
0.1748278737,
0.0061916471,
-0.358692199,
-0.3241251409,
-0.2596591711,
0.8837619424,
0.1271099895,
-0.4126671553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10977v1 | Evaluating Transformer Language Models on Arithmetic Operations Using Number Decomposition | 2023-04-21T14:21:52 | 2023-04-21T14:21:52 | Matteo Muffo, Aldo Cocco, Enrico Bertino | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | In recent years, Large Language Models such as GPT-3 showed remarkable
capabilities in performing NLP tasks in the zero and few shot settings. On the
other hand, the experiments highlighted the difficulty of GPT-3 in carrying out
tasks that require a certain degree of reasoning, such as arithmetic
operations. In this paper we evaluate the ability of Transformer Language
Models to perform arithmetic operations following a pipeline that, before
performing computations, decomposes numbers in units, tens, and so on. We
denote the models fine-tuned with this pipeline with the name Calculon and we
test them in the task of performing additions, subtractions and multiplications
on the same test sets of GPT-3. Results show an increase of accuracy of 63% in
the five-digit addition task. Moreover, we demonstrate the importance of the
decomposition pipeline introduced, since fine-tuning the same Language Model
without decomposing numbers results in 0% accuracy in the five-digit addition
task. | [
-0.4152098894,
-0.6718437672,
0.4855980575,
0.3083914816,
-0.1032746732,
0.013175155,
-0.0603920631,
-0.2775688767,
-0.2197889835,
0.5462288857,
-0.3161080182,
-0.2080666274,
-0.7187809348,
0.2155730724,
-0.4813679457,
0.8868572712,
-0.0077142608,
0.2576004267,
0.1040986925,
-0.1572810411,
-0.4523511231,
-0.7121348977,
-0.6821965575,
-0.4436000884,
0.2661643624,
0.0907055736,
0.8456357121,
0.5135867,
0.8201457858,
0.4854007065,
-0.0471318997,
-0.0766419992,
-0.2735129595,
-0.2029075474,
0.0190932918,
-0.7306444645,
-0.6087753773,
-0.161113292,
0.65589571,
0.7436056137,
-0.1444337815,
0.2631287873,
-0.3428270817,
0.7010715604,
-0.5414600372,
0.6113466024,
-0.4703468382,
-0.0014222659,
-0.048501417,
0.0392725915,
-0.6390626431,
-0.4346893728,
-0.1822429895,
-0.3576655984,
0.680930078,
-0.3806119263,
0.4282655716,
0.4942629337,
-0.4427185655,
-0.295145452,
-0.9413117766,
0.5453413725,
-0.8841047883,
0.5276247263,
0.3392821252,
0.1205244437,
0.3159945905,
-0.7874284983,
-0.7482658029,
0.1046312302,
-0.170485273,
0.0047689592,
-0.4214696884,
0.0589070134,
0.6695554256,
0.5749844909,
-0.4153665304,
-0.0556712076,
-0.6518131495,
-0.0080905426,
0.3999733329,
0.4737276137,
0.2882213295,
-0.0596671514,
0.0587037578,
-0.2191200405,
-0.6833046079,
0.0405462012,
0.3828009665,
0.1287635267,
0.0615911894,
0.871240437,
-0.2017531395,
0.6428719163,
-0.1853485703,
0.1091426536,
0.26280725,
-0.1761360914,
-0.5420201421,
-0.2550896704,
0.6609687805,
0.1093709543,
0.3430114388,
-0.08362028,
-0.3690478802,
0.7670091987,
0.3443960845,
-1.1042209864,
-0.6038060188,
-0.1315257996,
0.0504115932,
-0.4358846545,
-0.2139150053,
0.0604774766,
-0.0043660519,
-0.0813809186,
0.5396313071,
-0.5276376009,
-0.1187096834,
0.5973809958,
0.0973921791,
0.1287495941,
0.476223141,
-1.202031374,
0.7618641853,
1.0803245306,
0.6950644851,
0.115707092,
-0.2176100016,
-0.6135491133,
-0.3768189549,
-0.4065873027,
0.5666052103,
-0.4667498171,
-0.3406628668,
-0.4505263567,
0.14860861,
-0.3812008798,
-0.5576117635,
0.4887349606,
-0.7842428088,
0.2096066475,
0.020098757,
-0.5905938745,
-0.4862903059,
0.2043967992,
-0.9756039381,
0.7874180079,
0.4607316852,
-0.3914906681,
-0.0815429538,
-1.113024354,
-0.4014209211,
0.2693295777,
0.2007775307,
-0.4726264477,
0.6119844913,
0.4718032181,
0.1927351803,
-0.3406674266,
0.0142767979,
-0.0233176462,
-0.5331073999,
0.1372479051,
-0.7224197984,
1.074426055,
-0.1082439497,
-0.3934099376,
-0.1713585109,
-0.5065847039,
-0.0870115757,
0.1294369698,
-0.0605993569,
-0.0228169318,
-0.0605797693,
-0.2762444317,
0.1513543576,
-0.0710640922,
-0.5956283808,
0.3207781315,
-0.6752969027,
0.3651019037,
0.4100263119,
-0.0837453827,
0.6066642404,
-0.0111123472,
0.7882778645,
-0.0933468863,
-0.1912538409,
-0.3496792912,
-0.6263277531,
-1.079578042,
0.1975004822,
0.4046048522,
0.5984044075,
-0.988973856,
0.1226189807,
-0.4561502635,
-0.6989147067,
-0.3883151114,
-0.2412376404,
0.1747356653,
0.6235563159,
0.4248893559,
0.0233764108,
-0.0073685902,
-0.6468423605,
-0.2653013468,
-0.1875192821,
-0.4588617682,
-0.025476031,
0.3355382979,
-0.0745463297,
0.4087066948,
-0.7941511869,
-0.0109059718,
-0.1077755243,
0.450312078,
0.3711515665,
0.3113149703,
0.2856358588,
-0.6860790849,
-0.2692941129,
0.0954757109,
-0.5195596218,
-0.1982061863,
0.05057358,
0.4093285799,
0.2465538383,
-0.0241079554,
-0.7634804845,
0.6287062168,
0.6962760091,
-0.3759677112,
0.4016491473,
-0.1612851918,
0.1628287882,
-0.5618047714,
-0.2130507231,
-0.0059526833,
-0.2705638111,
-0.8751608133,
0.4504931867,
0.3982839882,
-0.287417531,
-0.520961225,
-0.0298213325,
-0.0708208606,
-0.0675268397,
-0.252687186,
-0.3353000581,
0.0669069067,
0.4915621877,
0.2730371952,
0.7436587811,
0.4390518069,
-0.3192383647,
0.2578591108,
-0.0367459469,
-0.3169598281,
0.0425122231,
-0.9039242268,
0.1696062535,
0.0744643435,
0.205326736,
-0.8130410314,
0.1321552396,
0.0310992077,
-0.3006129861,
-0.2055812478,
-0.3724010587,
-0.5840252042,
-0.4279541671,
-0.1346693337,
0.7110509872,
0.4366820753,
-0.1224475726,
0.7413883209,
0.227527231,
-0.3065705001,
-0.2781026363,
-0.455737263,
-0.1889843941,
-0.1891398877,
-0.8053382635,
0.2580191493,
0.0321395919,
-0.304112792,
-0.1898933947,
-0.0546845719,
0.0040272474,
-0.0347637311,
0.1740626991,
0.5456233621,
-0.3507419527,
-0.1911619157,
-0.1485254169,
-0.5461449623,
0.3440202773,
0.1353525817,
0.7347525358,
-0.5716177225,
-0.4387503266,
-0.2186732888,
0.0478014462,
0.7271039486,
-0.4697235823,
0.4500268102,
0.8115602136,
-0.5750266314,
0.1574045271,
-0.5854116678,
-0.0979678929,
-0.5067911744,
0.1726933122,
-0.629365325,
-0.7076870203,
0.6063483357,
0.1071020067,
0.1037108898,
0.7707186341,
0.791490376,
0.2513379157,
1.2492121458,
0.3542384505,
0.2370797098,
0.114755325,
-0.7162445784,
0.5124226213,
-0.8445463181,
0.0881988555,
-0.5356819034,
-0.2494471669,
-0.7611382008,
-0.7578312755,
0.4495486319,
-0.216628775,
-0.2011222094,
0.5956546068,
-0.4580422044,
0.7516040802,
0.4354125559,
0.0388840064,
0.4555621445,
-0.3414420187,
0.3710496426,
-0.0413091071,
-0.3420946002,
-0.2149201632,
0.7482545376,
0.384649545,
0.6748015285,
0.1446354389,
0.566729784,
0.0032845871,
0.5288770795,
-1.1244610548,
0.3379267156,
-0.3275685906,
-0.3648054898,
-0.4899978638,
-0.6265658736,
-0.5682293773,
0.5688173175,
0.2524084449,
-0.5760992765,
0.0588695891,
-0.1242890134,
-0.4690482914,
0.3314805031,
-0.9633823633,
0.7676985264,
0.0548242517,
0.0713059306,
-0.3467336893,
-0.3058600128,
0.5077328682,
-0.1860063374,
0.1740626544,
-0.2090847641,
0.075029023,
0.572706759,
-0.8856541514,
0.3391491175,
-0.1442071646,
-0.3525920808,
0.2405039519,
0.5381425619,
0.7153214216,
0.0532351285,
-0.2401062399,
0.3907203078,
0.0339288972,
-0.1312622577,
-0.8929868937,
0.6515949368,
-0.7681880593,
-0.4525278509,
-0.2439052612,
-0.7087651491,
-0.0062447158,
0.2154300064,
0.1005185768,
0.7701171637,
0.286431849,
0.3039655089,
0.2414316535,
0.1735726148,
0.7959891558,
0.5303326249,
-0.2844723761,
-0.323667258,
0.7343178391,
0.2970331609,
0.3361355066,
0.3859632909,
0.19332546,
-0.4311563969,
-0.4204168916,
-0.5611023307,
0.0304673593,
-0.515711844,
-0.2862902284,
-0.5770453215,
-0.2618599236,
-0.3088153601,
-0.1868434548,
-0.5111322403,
-0.9433782697,
0.1186754629,
-0.1387814283,
0.0432263687,
0.8005691767,
0.165399164,
0.3955236375,
-0.8970120549,
0.7487381697,
0.5693305731,
0.3024370074,
-0.0890853405,
-0.3994323313,
-0.2293102294,
0.2036698461,
-0.3066919148,
-0.5967963934,
0.5103660822,
-0.2118801028,
-0.1836617738,
-0.1522019506,
-0.137739867,
0.8424529433,
-0.7189931273,
0.6357371807,
-0.0199703798,
-1.2826566696,
-0.0303607862,
-0.3714343905,
0.6629286408,
0.1705895066,
0.1307529062,
-0.3356680572,
-0.2402586937,
-0.8537041545,
-0.6804098487,
0.8923915625,
0.5599951744,
0.2000457644,
-0.0160187483,
-0.1780247986,
-0.1636916846,
-0.1014912352,
-0.7660951018,
-0.4214743078,
-0.1232710108,
0.3239956796,
-0.0871927887,
-0.1068177894,
0.1327662468,
-0.4609559774,
0.486661464,
-0.0713542476,
0.2567756474,
-0.3962420225,
-0.2893928885,
-0.0322773717,
0.2453539073,
0.6977162361,
0.7750880122,
-0.0929251686,
0.1305572391,
0.4163403511,
-0.6256284714,
0.1559718102,
0.1535926461,
0.0270641204,
0.0216044057,
0.3247550428,
0.7108673453,
0.2667203248,
-0.0882597938,
0.4396938682,
-0.3633027375,
-0.2971413732,
-0.2692381442,
0.1502480954,
0.2037870437,
-0.0325314999,
0.4992484152,
0.3958293498,
0.3356734514,
-0.1275517792,
0.0899771899,
0.1384377331,
-0.0108053302,
-0.568087101,
0.5682808161,
0.0745801553,
-0.6384530663,
0.9879816771,
-0.1721105129,
-0.6175131202,
0.6447818279,
0.8236858845,
0.906916678,
-0.1975684166,
0.1676929146,
0.2187929899,
0.5165010691,
0.0234124642,
0.0653406233,
-0.0739486367,
-0.9389086962,
-1.1061842442,
-0.4668476582,
-0.5017402768,
-0.0007696801,
-0.6288707852,
0.32542786,
-0.1746474504,
-0.0504546277,
0.4939558804,
-0.0971421003,
-1.0141406059,
0.2495093495,
0.1359182298,
0.6039988995,
-0.9576039314,
0.8073613048,
0.4097536802,
-0.0556691922,
-1.086456418,
-0.4599949718,
-0.2313946933,
-0.8922795653,
0.5895888209,
0.2898977399,
-0.2250358015,
0.3359047472,
-0.1029365584,
-0.5374245644,
0.7764875293,
0.649102807,
-0.3384307623,
-0.0897314772,
0.7280499339,
0.6771139503,
-0.0336934663,
0.6782428026,
0.6459677219,
0.3608271778,
0.2370766252,
-1.1667040586,
-0.1013803631,
-0.3725997806,
-0.0436537191,
0.7027041912,
-0.3971819878,
1.1502040625,
-0.0894748792,
-0.1437985301,
-0.2924358845,
0.2435292006,
-0.1499350071,
-0.0592740886,
0.5264282823,
0.9408790469,
0.319792062,
-0.4415381253,
0.9990578294,
-0.2415405065,
0.735424757,
0.9333165288,
0.0283135362,
0.7904390693,
0.0509875827,
-0.5947010517,
0.5961365104,
0.0146697517,
0.1587139219,
0.0751183555,
-0.0355416015,
-0.4918729067,
-0.1892226189,
0.2892349064,
-0.2022180557,
0.7772791982,
0.4870345294,
-0.1499412656,
-0.4535223842,
-0.3620800674,
0.0506840497,
-0.4261297286,
-0.2519063354,
0.7823833227,
-0.159045577,
-0.6108915806,
0.7189142108,
0.2043337226,
0.1380868405,
-0.2483530939,
-0.2174853981,
-0.1612192392,
0.4082079232,
-0.2726383209,
-0.8303907514,
0.6348333955,
-0.061322663,
-0.093764551,
-0.3140783608,
0.3807656467,
-0.221857056,
-1.0582484007,
-0.3107468188,
0.321626246,
-0.0218580868,
-0.4563701153,
-0.4034858942,
0.2702219188,
0.0225028284,
-0.1851860732,
-0.0823486149,
0.5757634044,
-0.0607721508,
0.549913168,
0.8357787728,
-0.0096281888,
0.070452109,
0.412175715,
0.8904913068,
-0.5646515489,
-0.3258042932,
-1.2820614576,
0.7283313274,
0.225534305,
0.071649611,
0.7371919751,
0.7604951262,
0.8013352156,
-0.2270904332,
0.4676575959,
-0.0715177283,
0.0255964119,
-0.2268544883,
0.2840212882,
0.185899809,
0.3578844368,
-0.4124046266,
-1.1495355368,
-0.7137458324,
0.5942134857,
-0.5601767302,
-0.209638536,
0.7558242679,
0.6927248836,
-0.1879927963,
0.2403054386,
0.3381717801,
-0.1822960675,
0.5248016119,
0.5384209156,
0.5508820415,
-0.8550386429,
0.3441862762,
-0.7590590715,
-0.1111603156,
0.1117702574,
-0.6792161465,
-0.6165476441,
-0.2987147868,
-0.0730656981,
0.0050291838,
-0.6358837485,
0.5070527792,
0.3861179948,
-0.7337448597,
-0.1740182489,
-0.3173123896,
0.128820926,
-0.1382070929,
-0.286251545,
0.4651329517,
-0.1813819408,
-1.0217994452,
0.3028233349,
0.4517731965,
-0.0606446788,
-0.2581915259,
0.1000681967,
0.298645854,
-0.1373302937,
0.8247417212,
-0.1110533029,
-0.4826331437,
-0.3077074587,
0.4018839896,
0.3782193959,
0.0358223096,
1.0355212688,
-0.9372982979,
0.566187799,
0.6931889057,
0.5471192002,
0.8342493176,
0.3141604066,
0.7770332694,
-0.3347016573,
0.080388546,
0.3705478013,
0.5069044828,
0.35098961,
-0.1105150208,
0.813995719,
0.0367167182,
-0.620905757,
-0.6063646674,
-0.0029112364,
-0.5573601127,
0.3590682447,
0.8290015459,
-0.1322084814,
0.0490063764,
0.1744537354,
-0.1230104268,
0.0918832347,
0.0359397866,
0.7306275964,
0.5448671579,
-0.3255974352,
-0.1862515062,
-0.307444483,
0.1694152504,
0.3816115558,
-0.5456610322,
0.2152852565,
0.4387874305,
0.1115105152,
0.4517132342,
0.5186197162,
-0.3838940859,
0.3676007092,
0.1559611559,
-0.1188799515,
-0.1184919477,
-0.0939120799,
-0.3084472418,
0.2631409764,
-0.0354739316,
-0.0612101592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10973v1 | LEIA: Linguistic Embeddings for the Identification of Affect | 2023-04-21T14:17:10 | 2023-04-21T14:17:10 | Segun Taofeek Aroyehun, Lukas Malik, Hannah Metzler, Nikolas Haimerl, Anna Di Natale, David Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The wealth of text data generated by social media has enabled new kinds of
analysis of emotions with language models. These models are often trained on
small and costly datasets of text annotations produced by readers who guess the
emotions expressed by others in social media posts. This affects the quality of
emotion identification methods due to training data size limitations and noise
in the production of labels used in model development. We present LEIA, a model
for emotion identification in text that has been trained on a dataset of more
than 6 million posts with self-annotated emotion labels for happiness,
affection, sadness, anger, and fear. LEIA is based on a word masking method
that enhances the learning of emotion words during model pre-training. LEIA
achieves macro-F1 values of approximately 73 on three in-domain test datasets,
outperforming other supervised and unsupervised methods in a strong benchmark
that shows that LEIA generalizes across posts, users, and time periods. We
further perform an out-of-domain evaluation on five different datasets of
social media and other sources, showing LEIA's robust performance across media,
data collection methods, and annotation schemes. Our results show that LEIA
generalizes its classification of anger, happiness, and sadness beyond the
domain it was trained on. LEIA can be applied in future research to provide
better identification of emotions in text from the perspective of the writer.
The models produced for this article are publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/LEIA | [
-0.3935056925,
-0.6890980601,
0.5978588462,
0.1631345153,
-0.5813396573,
0.1007749736,
-0.1754471362,
-0.5602743626,
0.8048907518,
0.173612386,
-0.3875318766,
-0.4682208002,
-0.9846608639,
0.0549242571,
-0.2644925416,
0.8953326344,
-0.2413136065,
0.0684892833,
0.1721691042,
-0.3247686028,
-0.0222076029,
-0.6381969452,
-0.2840300798,
0.0504984334,
1.0094550848,
0.3351189792,
0.6612066031,
0.3413593471,
0.5525234342,
0.2450376749,
-0.118682012,
0.0910926014,
-0.674733758,
0.0795613602,
-0.2288267463,
-0.2249510139,
-0.1025156081,
0.1310161799,
0.4637920856,
0.1947625875,
0.3719991446,
0.079006657,
-0.3326894641,
0.7115007639,
-0.9406117797,
0.2977392673,
-0.3278546035,
0.1780383736,
-0.2072578073,
-0.0076264008,
-0.2499481738,
-0.490748018,
0.1806048751,
-0.6488586664,
-0.2515117824,
-0.3532836735,
1.2256134748,
0.2765801251,
-0.7649897337,
-0.7789501548,
-0.6763651371,
0.6306363344,
-0.3668034971,
0.3795507848,
0.1405103058,
0.1079315245,
0.3054412901,
-0.1268678159,
-0.7383971214,
0.1561835706,
0.1761357933,
0.3266577721,
-0.3211894035,
-0.0418287516,
0.2286061645,
0.2057744712,
-0.2929340005,
0.0252002198,
-0.095072858,
0.2970975041,
0.7307579517,
-0.1626311839,
0.5056901574,
-0.4180222452,
-0.3410062492,
-0.3501124084,
-0.5916387439,
0.0373353921,
0.6561130881,
0.1715283394,
-0.2323103547,
0.7944347262,
0.014139886,
0.2308387756,
-0.1703603417,
0.0493422374,
0.3973191977,
0.4132096767,
-0.2629882097,
-0.2628750503,
0.8051764965,
0.6059615612,
0.6070578694,
0.1239564046,
-0.3549022079,
0.3736263514,
0.4754459858,
-0.7763034105,
0.052068159,
0.0627627969,
-0.4469843805,
-0.2749127448,
0.2526094317,
-1.1707372665,
-0.737486124,
-0.2455482036,
0.4904597998,
-0.1884966642,
-0.3679345846,
-0.1076354757,
-0.1311432421,
-0.0130039398,
0.117984958,
-0.9408652186,
0.1240150928,
0.7449279428,
0.6975907683,
-0.0623317063,
-0.0581672154,
-0.1443101764,
-0.3612200618,
-0.6717917919,
0.6530343294,
-0.6009690762,
-0.1783023328,
0.4447746873,
0.3027102351,
-0.0259382501,
-0.2267163992,
0.4731615782,
-0.8407145143,
-0.1454308927,
-0.39954561,
-0.7922013998,
-0.3654594719,
-0.2584426701,
-0.9795367718,
0.6260463595,
0.3736267686,
-0.7341440916,
0.1851238459,
-0.5800905228,
-0.2449919879,
-0.0201616064,
0.1305119097,
-0.3605921268,
0.455411166,
-0.2337968946,
0.7061768174,
-0.3398456872,
0.2676231563,
-0.6145575643,
-0.0769082829,
0.3305418193,
0.1398791969,
0.3420140743,
0.4241487384,
-0.4708560705,
-0.2401954681,
-0.5111554861,
-0.4314549565,
0.3935473263,
0.0691052899,
-0.7319009304,
-0.230038926,
0.1113202795,
0.1462630481,
0.1336301118,
-0.7505524158,
-0.1367813647,
-0.413867712,
-0.1070897654,
0.6245999932,
0.2237604409,
0.6815750599,
-0.1169060394,
0.9684376717,
0.1921442896,
-0.0004420819,
-0.3620485067,
-0.646873951,
-0.8402140141,
0.0333008878,
0.0271047335,
0.4376906753,
-0.4366416335,
0.3180232048,
0.1372071207,
-0.9040264487,
-0.7422267795,
0.1906536222,
0.4318310022,
0.4355668724,
0.2655256093,
-0.3697927594,
-0.5083264112,
-0.6662338376,
-0.2595698237,
-0.1889613569,
0.1214789525,
0.5607079268,
0.32327649,
-0.6338054538,
0.7985190153,
-0.4306176305,
-0.045447506,
0.2442620993,
0.4898350835,
-0.1406624168,
-0.0394025296,
0.5315133333,
-0.8769428134,
-0.4736564755,
0.1092273071,
-0.8887053132,
-0.4282826781,
-0.2670327425,
-0.2164482623,
0.5386538506,
-0.0381112732,
-0.5493720174,
0.5125773549,
0.6754384041,
-0.4477195144,
0.076926291,
0.1360583305,
0.3131386042,
-0.9942755699,
-0.0910977796,
0.4261208177,
0.1609739214,
-0.5283706188,
-0.1041512117,
0.2993891537,
-0.1539672911,
-0.6441110969,
0.825797677,
-0.3960409164,
0.0161129348,
-0.2364122272,
0.173845917,
0.2223623097,
0.2727749944,
0.2586048543,
0.1193564534,
0.4364331365,
-0.2924161851,
0.206342265,
0.3210478127,
-0.0272330958,
0.5495930314,
-0.4376815557,
0.1984171122,
-0.4766952395,
0.0609410293,
-0.8761260509,
-0.3498039842,
0.3060683906,
-0.1803263873,
0.1461976767,
-0.0828468576,
-0.0992085785,
-0.2041748166,
-0.2729537785,
0.1308483928,
0.4460980594,
-0.765722096,
0.993280232,
0.8307620883,
-0.2780418992,
-0.4739291966,
-0.3359725773,
0.0150194084,
-0.5894579887,
-0.2960352004,
0.2972946763,
-0.0460659526,
-0.3995130956,
-0.0499769561,
0.4199340641,
-0.3469360471,
0.116318725,
0.761039257,
0.1814546436,
-0.0511357859,
0.763068378,
0.3485583067,
-0.1099691615,
0.1691866666,
0.5586947799,
0.1856037527,
-0.3061679602,
-0.2007605582,
-0.2263685912,
0.6024258733,
0.6021482348,
-0.010867672,
0.6971664429,
0.7631601095,
-0.6436115503,
-0.3046823144,
-0.4743871689,
-0.0029036237,
-0.3938678503,
0.0998999476,
-0.4208102524,
-0.8443390131,
0.6151604056,
-0.2231777161,
-0.3485943079,
0.692025125,
0.5956777334,
-0.224009037,
0.7851250768,
0.7547078133,
-0.3636238873,
0.6680383086,
-0.1026186571,
0.3395599723,
-0.5548651814,
0.0061201546,
-0.4621248841,
-0.225568518,
-0.6638939977,
-0.4716896117,
-0.1626709998,
0.1751576215,
-0.2334417105,
0.2300281823,
-0.3943178952,
0.5293204188,
0.3159124851,
-0.0617875606,
-0.0813915655,
-0.3199200332,
0.4853999019,
-0.2002155334,
-0.2612756491,
-0.7650979757,
0.8705376983,
0.7398208976,
0.9280792475,
0.1713993847,
0.8339828849,
0.3681611419,
0.6511137486,
-1.0198366642,
0.2048404217,
-0.2024802715,
-0.3679582179,
-0.0811771229,
-0.2508019507,
-0.9711310863,
-0.246655196,
-0.2688441575,
-0.8202669024,
0.3708077967,
-0.0659402013,
-0.1402935982,
0.1275529116,
-1.0366066694,
0.8545863032,
-0.2692967057,
0.026400663,
-0.0150446473,
-0.6063629389,
0.3323902786,
-0.5612879395,
0.1586935967,
-0.4098854661,
-0.0817975551,
0.9662143588,
-0.2825416923,
1.0739643574,
-0.3208715022,
-0.1897794902,
0.3970403969,
0.0724979341,
0.4492497146,
-0.0880460963,
-0.0234884378,
0.195286721,
-0.0396178663,
-0.001150124,
-0.682467103,
0.658230722,
-0.9296581149,
-0.0052133314,
-0.1637825966,
-0.189361006,
-0.043826621,
0.0302646253,
0.0593779348,
0.2155700177,
-0.3094730079,
-0.0446643196,
0.5014628768,
-0.5440148115,
0.4021031857,
0.4370654821,
-0.2690855861,
-0.3599424362,
1.0430744886,
0.1841827035,
0.0249875877,
0.3301249146,
0.3739354014,
-0.3420013785,
0.332323581,
-0.296233058,
0.4177155197,
-1.0109891891,
-0.4005818665,
-0.8169428706,
-0.0418119766,
-0.370285064,
-0.5477506518,
-0.6560202837,
-0.2744109631,
-0.7110979557,
-0.276304245,
0.7200804353,
1.2991027832,
-0.0805313736,
0.5272327065,
-0.7315120697,
0.5589438081,
0.2429818362,
0.5066003799,
-0.0223003533,
-0.4314874709,
-0.2640569806,
-0.1155954599,
0.0385725796,
-1.4783691168,
0.7933399081,
0.3387304246,
0.0438904874,
0.7280603647,
0.2240945697,
0.2940887809,
-0.1303889751,
0.5320360065,
-0.0572332591,
-1.1150788069,
0.5799864531,
-0.3294726312,
0.0439533181,
0.3503327668,
1.0257310867,
-0.6405352354,
-0.3227908313,
-0.8414603472,
-0.8864815831,
0.3458687067,
-0.202744469,
0.5309656858,
-0.3479720354,
0.4430579543,
-0.0261037406,
-0.0166790579,
-0.6337612271,
-0.1264469475,
-0.1583635509,
-0.5821763873,
-0.1860494912,
-0.6280739307,
0.1594585329,
0.1431750357,
0.6075847745,
-0.2273303568,
0.3932748735,
0.1037215739,
-0.3749292791,
-0.4037494063,
-0.2208010703,
0.2817108035,
0.0537113622,
-0.2252048403,
0.2479906678,
-0.0427905582,
-0.1253518462,
0.1740578115,
-0.0060614967,
0.057217069,
0.2170337588,
0.2136380225,
0.7789527178,
0.2794094682,
-0.6623114347,
0.7505936623,
-0.1490479857,
0.2486400604,
-0.2165574282,
-0.1985274404,
0.2188774049,
0.4014079571,
0.061568208,
-0.4639352858,
0.2108362019,
-0.3345187604,
0.2245811969,
0.2633718848,
-0.8175601959,
-0.5103347301,
0.3546766341,
0.0935618207,
-0.6233299971,
-0.0540456325,
-0.3082561791,
-0.7130424976,
0.7218399048,
0.2644251585,
1.0828084946,
-0.5457749963,
0.6464878321,
0.3564890623,
0.0691606924,
0.0840409845,
0.4510414898,
0.2102626264,
-1.0116952658,
0.1544487476,
-0.8067954183,
-0.7737060785,
-0.2960373163,
-0.6224371791,
0.1496355385,
-0.3786966801,
-0.3227261603,
0.1395422965,
-0.0665231869,
-0.8608052731,
0.470756948,
0.454832226,
0.6081842184,
-1.4364778996,
0.5599472523,
0.5178362131,
-0.5038810372,
-0.9438745975,
-0.3964847326,
0.3361991644,
-0.4500107765,
0.5452823043,
0.4669875205,
-0.1977780312,
-0.193664521,
-0.3199100196,
-0.8149770498,
0.6806969643,
0.2356934994,
-0.3405032754,
0.5125451088,
0.165167436,
0.9222835898,
-0.8204856515,
0.5379631519,
0.492090255,
0.3493180275,
-0.1321483701,
-0.2448059916,
-0.0948701873,
-0.6267051101,
-0.0713346303,
-0.0296674315,
-0.6173169017,
0.6503971815,
-0.0510504059,
-0.3367711008,
-0.2155102938,
0.6425700784,
-0.015699219,
0.3435085714,
0.5900772214,
0.5252420306,
0.9338555336,
-0.0813191682,
1.1750189066,
-0.2909631431,
0.4212812781,
0.9931593537,
-0.2945777774,
0.9460487962,
0.2895623446,
0.1478859335,
0.6320848465,
0.78922683,
0.0864949524,
0.3573178053,
0.2972195148,
-0.3896338642,
0.2398268431,
-0.6589775085,
-0.0424506627,
0.4671546817,
0.3942666054,
-0.7422849536,
0.1764578968,
0.19989568,
0.1765137017,
-0.0958456919,
0.003134117,
0.891723454,
0.1453198642,
-0.4387461543,
0.206762597,
-0.1479186267,
0.5644495487,
-0.438959837,
0.1434580535,
-0.2591439188,
-0.0224783029,
-0.0763823986,
-0.7924612761,
0.3920384645,
0.2935757339,
0.027640447,
-0.2419921756,
0.9476014376,
-0.5767985582,
-0.6174447536,
0.875985682,
0.3099829555,
0.2849428952,
-0.3162095547,
-0.3895930946,
0.3267396092,
-0.2879497111,
-0.7798070312,
0.1293989867,
0.753880322,
0.1224189699,
0.4724413753,
0.2560748458,
-0.1595863849,
-0.0865206346,
0.4524399042,
0.8457735181,
-0.8416045904,
-0.1559025496,
-0.6986525059,
0.5614727736,
0.0265404116,
-0.5927622914,
0.4829689264,
0.1490469277,
0.4627399743,
-0.2054345012,
0.5174282789,
0.1084619984,
0.5612145066,
-0.1516611278,
0.7836338878,
-0.5703117251,
-0.3065142334,
-0.9526950121,
-0.6286470294,
-0.3263167441,
0.6564593315,
-0.1460397393,
-0.013817694,
0.4672673345,
0.7744846344,
0.3225770593,
0.1397396475,
0.2815516293,
0.1179506034,
0.2204485089,
0.4874714315,
0.8668256998,
-0.4285708368,
-0.3364288509,
-0.5389563441,
-0.3881341517,
-0.3246449232,
-0.8892825842,
-0.7452915907,
-0.9060609937,
-0.3632831275,
-0.2237011045,
-0.182898432,
0.8467041254,
0.4421021342,
-0.6319882274,
0.0147418864,
0.3203431666,
0.3447723985,
0.3755844533,
-0.2140720785,
0.2899161279,
-0.1971880049,
-0.7764241099,
0.174719885,
0.355099082,
0.2945944667,
-0.1999495625,
-0.1998342276,
-0.1541248411,
0.4281678796,
0.6202440262,
0.2686931491,
-0.4831886888,
-0.5099477172,
-0.0654817149,
-0.1985607445,
-0.0851142034,
0.4216942787,
-0.3225684166,
0.7945543528,
0.3777844608,
0.9026916623,
0.3794995546,
0.1964829415,
0.4844798744,
-0.4514864385,
-0.0241614655,
0.1714130491,
0.5791766644,
0.3561169803,
-0.5873791575,
0.6144735217,
-0.0309741031,
-0.5060682893,
-0.506749332,
-0.0408165306,
-1.1587581635,
0.0766745806,
1.2001327276,
-0.5004833341,
-0.3745566607,
0.3021762669,
-0.0705370605,
0.5269783735,
-0.4165384173,
1.0428856611,
0.8125345707,
0.2753844261,
-0.2235232443,
-0.2916276455,
0.4854004681,
0.4691878557,
-1.0561928749,
0.1282296181,
0.5105945468,
-0.2372112572,
0.2900005579,
0.5279965401,
0.0654632375,
0.0050198385,
-0.1053667068,
0.5093013048,
0.5653095245,
-0.5467759371,
-0.7211683989,
0.1625083536,
-0.0914926082,
0.1004026011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10859v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10859v2 | Text2Time: Transformer-based Article Time Period Prediction | 2023-04-21T10:05:03 | 2023-04-24T03:56:03 | Karthick Prasad Gunasekaran, B Chase Babrich, Saurabh Shirodkar, Hee Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of predicting the publication period of text documents, such as news
articles, is an important but less studied problem in the field of natural
language processing. Predicting the year of a news article can be useful in
various contexts, such as historical research, sentiment analysis, and media
monitoring. In this work, we investigate the problem of predicting the
publication period of a text document, specifically a news article, based on
its textual content. In order to do so, we created our own extensive labeled
dataset of over 350,000 news articles published by The New York Times over six
decades. In our approach, we use a pretrained BERT model fine-tuned for the
task of text classification, specifically for time period prediction.This model
exceeds our expectations and provides some very impressive results in terms of
accurately classifying news articles into their respective publication decades.
The results beat the performance of the baseline model for this relatively
unexplored task of time prediction from text. | [
-0.1248046085,
-0.8347463012,
0.580437243,
0.4697292447,
-0.4015895724,
-0.0716477633,
-0.0498965718,
-0.8602320552,
-0.038465254,
0.3704728782,
-0.6567964554,
0.0565378442,
-0.6818562746,
0.2078302056,
-0.6388912201,
1.2410647869,
0.0386441424,
-0.011669918,
0.0619043671,
0.2793229222,
-0.3688901067,
-0.1635697037,
-0.5863468647,
-0.7103868127,
0.584835887,
-0.0640713647,
0.5878804922,
0.5604706407,
0.2989288568,
0.1674789786,
-0.1733037829,
-0.0100557161,
-0.2940837443,
-0.0515636541,
0.0372714177,
-0.4941594005,
-0.0824816078,
0.2645092309,
0.3113752902,
0.4327772558,
0.0728390217,
0.0796158463,
-0.0375401825,
0.5449063778,
0.0227500983,
0.0043926067,
-0.783454895,
0.2771152854,
-0.1424095929,
-0.40222314,
-0.7396419048,
-0.6152362227,
0.1358437687,
-0.5248097777,
0.4366953075,
-0.0221528094,
1.0320913792,
0.1589599401,
-0.7213824987,
-0.2339615077,
-1.1080849171,
0.887460649,
-0.5621899962,
0.4634002149,
0.4436893463,
0.235587135,
0.060101755,
-0.8941990733,
-0.5751615167,
0.0542646199,
-0.0969939753,
0.0278425291,
-0.2790366411,
-0.486867398,
0.0532553606,
-0.0896489993,
-0.8139164448,
0.0056951991,
-0.4742251933,
0.0141975489,
0.4912816584,
-0.0831987932,
-0.0043313159,
-0.4937963486,
-0.68775177,
0.1084532365,
-0.2182581425,
0.167600736,
0.3834580779,
0.0421030149,
0.1620294154,
0.4891505241,
0.2271101624,
0.2416362911,
-0.0009958779,
0.0166926514,
0.1857052892,
-0.082961306,
-0.0000148493,
0.0680082291,
0.5818446875,
0.5315428376,
0.2775709331,
-0.5861808658,
-0.1093103886,
0.0245858934,
0.7387191057,
-0.8490897417,
0.0133168567,
-0.0096299462,
-0.6249902248,
-0.4340162277,
0.2507863641,
-0.8559370637,
-0.1906795651,
-0.4111309648,
0.4028075635,
-0.4303444326,
0.1143883914,
-0.2309622616,
-0.2908624411,
0.0346996747,
0.4297159016,
-0.4158389866,
-0.0473969355,
0.6034438014,
0.9353501797,
-0.2730495632,
-0.0923864469,
-0.1741539687,
0.1118150651,
-0.4445329905,
0.8812789917,
-0.448848933,
-0.2816854715,
0.0982543305,
0.2001076788,
0.1940381825,
0.0606945753,
0.6995305419,
-0.9858567715,
0.5801240802,
0.2075733095,
-0.6892922521,
-0.0785053521,
0.0602544397,
-0.9404605627,
1.0365829468,
0.33153072,
-1.0751811266,
0.4904815257,
-0.4856571853,
-0.7710553408,
-0.1940499991,
0.3916060627,
-0.773093462,
-0.0005159092,
0.3157732189,
0.2327365875,
-0.0475280657,
0.5584151149,
0.0059800902,
-0.2851161063,
0.4242758453,
-0.5688818693,
0.7173168659,
0.3918268383,
-0.2558849156,
-0.3462240398,
-0.5493193269,
-0.0613673106,
0.0247994885,
-0.4882873297,
-0.393933475,
0.1913938373,
0.4954095483,
0.0757891238,
0.4429541826,
-0.7770780325,
0.3309540451,
-0.4913069904,
0.5775991082,
0.4738815427,
0.081753619,
0.5341613293,
-0.3401584923,
0.1529726088,
-0.052541554,
0.3183741868,
-0.3802129328,
-0.4158028066,
-0.5667985082,
0.5379251838,
0.5353890061,
0.6652758718,
-0.9690224528,
0.7068837881,
-0.4304882884,
-0.7749921083,
0.098254092,
-0.0222430043,
0.0123464074,
0.4418651164,
0.620623827,
0.0329706334,
-0.9255812168,
-0.735742867,
-0.4572759867,
-0.3961753249,
-0.1616089195,
-0.1115823463,
0.228104353,
-0.4204657376,
1.3017773628,
-0.6441876888,
-0.3196184337,
-0.3131309748,
1.0047945976,
0.3514939845,
0.3440939188,
0.4464792907,
-1.0592093468,
-0.2617183924,
-0.2014748901,
-0.5617537498,
-0.1122889668,
-0.2879552841,
0.1081734821,
0.6856452227,
0.6087238789,
-0.15576078,
0.4971959293,
0.6011410952,
-0.6117605567,
0.3972460032,
-0.1420781463,
-0.0825369507,
-1.164399147,
0.0508858524,
0.2091328353,
-0.2621157765,
-0.6284445524,
-0.8937425017,
0.2307806313,
-0.2824229002,
-0.1969188154,
0.6052745581,
-0.0414636172,
0.1762743294,
-0.4312478602,
-0.3354274631,
0.01805944,
0.2469570488,
0.2839586437,
0.5666296482,
-0.2854810953,
-0.4687452912,
-0.0248082876,
0.2415983826,
-0.6951295137,
0.0273599196,
-0.6737143993,
0.239317596,
-0.3452293575,
0.504901886,
-0.9442110658,
0.1797451228,
-0.3404642344,
-0.8050295115,
0.2899882495,
0.223972559,
-0.5034413338,
-0.5469642878,
-0.2159168124,
0.1027376652,
0.3370080292,
-0.3789614141,
0.5996690989,
0.0413613357,
-0.5363419652,
-0.5209501982,
-0.9696785212,
0.0962926298,
0.0973449871,
-0.5010459423,
0.5701463819,
-0.0370880589,
0.1693189144,
0.4732422829,
-0.2268328518,
-0.4659407735,
0.0464492701,
0.1285611093,
0.4862467647,
-0.0069591883,
0.3471491933,
0.2561419904,
-0.3515871763,
-0.0584512502,
-0.1701727659,
0.4932970703,
0.4253184199,
0.1796214581,
-0.4090884328,
0.2712801397,
0.2951362431,
-0.2178725898,
0.790514648,
0.9261233211,
-0.4071091413,
-0.1359326094,
-0.6556264162,
-0.2845137417,
-0.3288288414,
0.4584574103,
0.3252551258,
-0.7146787047,
-0.0379545279,
0.22662884,
0.2356298864,
0.6772748232,
0.2031575888,
-0.3281593025,
0.7953577042,
0.8567902446,
-0.2549516559,
0.8975684643,
-0.2153445035,
0.1495912969,
-0.4161724746,
-0.4939616919,
-0.59546417,
-0.6314606071,
-0.4605333507,
-0.2961620092,
0.4208674133,
-0.0144856488,
-0.2299458385,
0.5938408375,
-0.3962598443,
0.27342242,
0.5195655227,
0.0457926579,
0.4122829437,
0.2222420573,
0.4721832871,
-0.3576331735,
-0.2909112275,
-0.5941240788,
1.0368490219,
0.5626494884,
0.7971054316,
-0.1791858971,
0.446457237,
0.8957169056,
0.4710942805,
-0.6870948076,
0.0760529786,
-0.512013495,
-0.7997502685,
-0.4661901891,
-0.3854983151,
-1.1252518892,
-0.2592344284,
-0.1932797134,
-0.6458677053,
0.1530825347,
-0.3540249467,
-0.0766821802,
0.2638470829,
-0.5953986645,
0.3830283284,
-0.2437487394,
0.0056040538,
-0.2420503944,
-0.7273520231,
-0.0259231012,
-0.2367730886,
0.3367120922,
-0.1786105037,
-0.1090839654,
1.0897203684,
-0.0139694763,
0.7743065357,
-0.1891989857,
0.0268093832,
0.213075459,
-0.0836584568,
0.4777145386,
0.2939727604,
-0.1739449501,
0.1662565321,
0.0759326667,
-0.0830341503,
-0.3686217666,
0.2638927698,
-0.9336361289,
-0.1002485231,
-0.6635633707,
-0.5753036737,
-0.1902059615,
0.1716639996,
0.5975432992,
0.62939924,
-0.2951755226,
0.4147475958,
0.422213912,
-0.0360779725,
1.0533772707,
0.7381293774,
-0.148931846,
-0.3954841793,
0.5431872606,
0.4246552587,
-0.3929731548,
0.8501021862,
0.0927539244,
-0.6249483824,
-0.2000541687,
-0.2360291779,
0.0470360592,
-0.2283867747,
-0.4852416217,
-0.7024400234,
-0.5359983444,
-0.4336229861,
-0.2000452131,
-0.2557010353,
-0.3839219511,
-0.5410365462,
0.0723445117,
0.1121475175,
0.7651628256,
0.2646704614,
0.413364619,
-0.9177379608,
0.2692604065,
0.3013204038,
0.4277791679,
-0.2798061073,
-0.6489422321,
-0.386335969,
-0.2387180328,
-0.6836019754,
-1.0420104265,
0.4475798309,
0.0670205504,
0.3655827343,
0.3575729132,
0.0799941346,
0.0688737929,
-0.743516326,
0.9739288688,
0.2476463318,
-0.8658441305,
0.7311656475,
-0.3172158897,
0.3778706193,
0.1642618477,
0.3345968425,
-0.5326390862,
-0.3083683252,
-0.7388906479,
-0.8157405853,
0.8070334196,
0.3421086967,
0.3255927861,
0.0561396256,
0.3342838287,
0.4917649031,
0.186899811,
-0.899323225,
-0.0904942602,
-0.31530267,
-0.0593076758,
-0.2900571525,
-0.7194433808,
0.2625110447,
-0.2012150139,
0.7883525491,
-0.045904763,
0.6848828197,
0.3009799123,
-0.1968741417,
-0.2991654575,
0.4683504701,
0.5297619104,
0.9447091818,
-0.2289720178,
-0.0688802823,
0.1637079865,
-0.3924250901,
0.142965883,
0.6123656631,
-0.25743559,
0.5928182006,
0.7464319468,
0.8257757425,
0.2542889118,
-0.3761769533,
0.4961236417,
0.0754193887,
-0.1747428775,
-0.8255676627,
-0.319021076,
-0.037131127,
0.4762754142,
1.0957671404,
-0.1233211234,
0.1684572548,
-0.5090641379,
0.4521355927,
0.0395011157,
-0.5321555734,
-0.4048115313,
0.9583559632,
0.2393853068,
-0.2001913637,
0.5802955031,
-0.0660238117,
-0.577462256,
0.7646564245,
0.7680616975,
0.826387763,
-0.4272733331,
0.3449885249,
0.2950513959,
0.4306873083,
-0.1321970522,
0.0684496686,
0.4572481513,
-0.6683312654,
-0.4414429367,
-0.8265689015,
0.0496477522,
0.3258541524,
-0.5765171647,
0.3029381037,
-0.1261060238,
-0.6066493392,
0.1746648997,
0.4398560822,
-0.5553241968,
0.4637451768,
0.2392656207,
1.326354146,
-1.0186885595,
1.0005215406,
0.6423842311,
-0.1233009174,
-0.3148544729,
0.1943337023,
-0.028857749,
-0.3895938694,
0.5648980737,
0.3197834194,
0.3035499454,
-0.0373913981,
-0.3273542821,
-0.5345631242,
1.255171895,
0.2489860207,
-0.679766953,
-0.4193748832,
-0.0906063169,
0.5483980179,
-0.2406815141,
-0.0799873248,
0.4418363273,
0.676156342,
-0.0517933629,
-0.9090713859,
-0.4480458498,
-0.3105748892,
0.3305134475,
0.524068594,
-0.4158883393,
0.946652174,
-0.0966784954,
-0.0766950473,
0.2119019777,
1.0370647907,
-0.4609690309,
0.8683723211,
0.7124891281,
0.3926007152,
0.5462133884,
-0.3630900383,
1.0718529224,
-0.2017953098,
0.5031699538,
0.87545681,
0.1816769987,
0.8501096368,
0.4227469862,
-0.3062545955,
0.7008957267,
0.4353164136,
-0.4622537792,
0.6411190033,
-0.4589207768,
-0.0180876143,
-0.0067691091,
-0.1667836457,
-0.4394407868,
0.2961065173,
0.1105747744,
-0.5686403513,
-0.2764191329,
0.0945981815,
0.324804306,
0.1501379013,
-0.1345780939,
0.902553916,
-0.0487916023,
-0.6088190675,
-0.228008166,
0.2247777283,
0.7249691486,
-0.5952028632,
0.2028481364,
-0.1219269484,
0.1934777647,
-0.0303860679,
-0.8488419652,
0.6361471415,
0.0515519343,
-0.6832490563,
-0.3718756437,
0.8684214354,
-0.6954699159,
-0.8275840282,
0.2330242246,
0.3858286738,
-0.3573012054,
-0.090317674,
-0.3537464738,
-0.0417088456,
-0.0385038853,
-0.523021698,
0.0171386935,
0.6317819357,
0.0308779981,
0.4342724979,
0.4174865484,
-0.1068482548,
-0.1062230542,
-0.2170191109,
0.6368309855,
-0.7342305779,
-0.6874454021,
-0.7350597382,
0.3323758543,
-0.0940615609,
-0.4664778411,
0.2688595355,
0.9178469777,
0.3491258025,
-0.2209815234,
0.9681446552,
-0.2653619647,
0.9058196545,
-0.5416291356,
0.8147442341,
-0.6157047749,
-0.0930562541,
0.1038546711,
-0.9644867778,
-0.0085546114,
0.3566572368,
-0.3366802931,
0.0021059802,
0.8580316901,
0.2981590927,
0.158531934,
0.5065921545,
-0.0989774019,
-0.0207777806,
0.3156126738,
0.3684040904,
0.4715783298,
-0.2988422215,
0.8683262467,
-0.4304451644,
0.0895169154,
-0.530864954,
-1.1204777956,
-0.8701190352,
-0.9704965353,
-0.078992933,
-0.2875142395,
0.1747631282,
0.8045849204,
0.4829328954,
-0.7427632213,
0.0631158799,
-0.0197554696,
-0.1658805758,
-0.2857419848,
-0.3021402657,
0.4416850209,
-0.523281157,
-0.9254372716,
0.1493695825,
-0.1601707637,
0.0140755875,
-0.008088408,
0.2036379725,
-0.291013509,
-0.0402435251,
0.7467638254,
-0.0615495816,
-0.448817879,
-0.3453058898,
0.0794713646,
-0.2549924254,
-0.008902966,
1.1384654045,
-0.7617496252,
0.3441734314,
0.4897506535,
0.6206185222,
0.7327751517,
0.2693672478,
0.6166881919,
-1.0087541342,
0.1805356592,
0.4072199464,
0.1139707416,
0.2100520879,
-0.4579731226,
0.7336668372,
0.3133890033,
-0.5964406133,
-0.4453614652,
-0.2069268823,
-0.9626470208,
-0.4875546992,
1.0141123533,
0.1471384466,
-0.0666391104,
-0.1354315132,
-0.1930148005,
0.7347215414,
-0.5032005906,
0.9563885331,
0.7700208426,
-0.0940447599,
-0.2200205922,
-0.7571225762,
0.4097105861,
0.1018326133,
-0.853104949,
-0.234890759,
0.239048928,
0.2368888259,
0.4025710821,
0.1665147245,
-0.0548776463,
0.0932879448,
-0.2825961113,
-0.0727933049,
-0.2987863719,
-0.6421387792,
0.0894014686,
0.1960714757,
-0.2875052989,
0.0436934978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10844v1 | Better Sign Language Translation with Monolingual Data | 2023-04-21T09:39:54 | 2023-04-21T09:39:54 | Ru Peng, Yawen Zeng, Junbo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sign language translation (SLT) systems, which are often decomposed into
video-to-gloss (V2G) recognition and gloss-to-text (G2T) translation through
the pivot gloss, heavily relies on the availability of large-scale parallel G2T
pairs. However, the manual annotation of pivot gloss, which is a sequence of
transcribed written-language words in the order in which they are signed,
further exacerbates the scarcity of data for SLT. To address this issue, this
paper proposes a simple and efficient rule transformation method to transcribe
the large-scale target monolingual data into its pseudo glosses automatically
for enhancing the SLT translation. Empirical results show that the proposed
approach can significantly improve the performance of SLT, especially achieving
state-of-the-art results on two SLT benchmark datasets PHEONIX-WEATHER 2014T
and ASLG-PC12. Our code has been released at:
https://github.com/pengr/Mono\_SLT. | [
-0.1555230916,
-0.1798543781,
0.3074956834,
0.2432910949,
-0.8230704665,
-0.2312832177,
-0.1989618838,
-0.5179806948,
0.4354872704,
0.4464453161,
-0.4479038119,
-0.7365548611,
-0.8939110041,
-0.0687258467,
-0.4548913538,
1.2075999975,
-0.1608753353,
0.0250837822,
0.2206506282,
-0.1718973666,
-0.0982263237,
-0.4284670651,
-0.4369784892,
-0.051486142,
0.0114177773,
0.5378725529,
1.0033164024,
0.6354293227,
0.5979348421,
0.2295735627,
0.201167047,
0.4100365937,
-0.3780604303,
-0.1380243897,
0.117335096,
0.0465115122,
-0.7996643782,
-0.0985724553,
0.5198992491,
0.6476245522,
0.074205026,
0.4795335829,
-0.1117549762,
0.5780181289,
-0.1134624183,
0.6313286424,
-0.3688735366,
0.043028485,
-0.5362166762,
-0.0887842774,
-0.3592091203,
-0.4310877919,
0.1542596519,
-0.7376568317,
0.0969080627,
0.2257019728,
0.7098152637,
0.3434558213,
-0.3353469074,
-0.140388906,
-0.8136646152,
0.4073690474,
-1.0426394939,
0.5080193877,
0.2724682987,
0.3103286922,
0.0296764001,
-0.6721702814,
-0.3644641936,
-0.0330419466,
-0.4324029088,
0.1373710781,
0.1401489675,
0.1913407147,
0.3235735893,
0.3224187493,
-0.8031022549,
-0.24404715,
-0.3846748769,
-0.4815034866,
0.7936480641,
0.0395772047,
0.282513082,
0.089515008,
-0.4890961051,
-0.1980757117,
-0.4512163699,
0.003313794,
-0.0950699747,
0.7442899346,
-0.2447827607,
0.5601562858,
-0.0269055516,
0.7073798776,
-0.0641812459,
-0.3933884799,
0.638879478,
-0.805051744,
-0.1191990003,
0.3107240498,
0.6838175654,
0.3153260648,
0.1786543429,
0.0042147697,
-0.3561780751,
-0.0985638201,
-0.2386041433,
-0.7522025108,
-0.0783435255,
-0.1297113895,
-0.3071015775,
0.52800107,
0.4654453099,
-0.7700147033,
-0.4096222818,
-0.5675105453,
0.456869781,
-0.3176237643,
-0.4133479893,
0.4565044343,
0.0841874182,
0.268342644,
0.4671997726,
-0.4848856032,
0.5758507252,
0.5509849787,
0.9707715511,
-0.3370380998,
-0.1134242788,
-0.8860741258,
-0.0146599077,
-0.1878004819,
0.2896595597,
0.0278026443,
-0.0891356617,
-0.1152165979,
-0.1178807169,
-0.2887105048,
-0.3863106668,
0.4250389636,
-0.2499778271,
0.1540585756,
-0.1612072438,
-0.1750606894,
0.2314471602,
-0.1810418516,
-0.4395528734,
0.9351832867,
0.1067786515,
-0.3695968986,
0.3690129519,
-0.8218696117,
-0.92396909,
0.237071678,
0.0383456238,
-0.7032160163,
-0.0351432115,
0.1361106038,
0.0540138595,
-0.297739327,
-0.0022590302,
0.0377211124,
-0.1626170278,
-0.2448135167,
-0.0622611977,
0.4403250217,
0.167424351,
-0.7793979645,
0.2202711403,
-0.5834031701,
0.0199727993,
-0.0231033824,
-0.1026706025,
-0.3863647878,
-0.0972087085,
0.1394027323,
0.4331199527,
0.4633465409,
-0.4289708734,
0.1403678507,
-0.2128072232,
0.0373195112,
0.4466338158,
-0.3189793229,
0.4283654094,
0.1351979226,
0.4445081949,
0.1536393762,
0.4447374344,
0.0332341082,
-0.751085043,
-0.901013732,
-0.2083273381,
0.0576714166,
0.5528423786,
-0.7716181874,
0.4254853129,
-0.5876473784,
-0.3045429587,
-0.6298086047,
0.3693805337,
0.601390183,
0.3506912887,
0.8374579549,
-0.5266940594,
-0.5843132734,
-0.6723107696,
-0.0804069415,
-0.1894913167,
0.204851225,
-0.0878186449,
0.1231647879,
-0.004905012,
0.6102979779,
-0.4767196476,
-0.5248999596,
0.0160925407,
0.2576950192,
0.3070294857,
0.3170900941,
0.4278417826,
-1.0098912716,
-1.0055736303,
0.3392645419,
-0.490524888,
-0.303925693,
-0.0846768171,
-0.1295355856,
0.0884650946,
0.7224722505,
-0.3178408444,
0.7312155366,
0.618686974,
-0.6546185017,
0.6127806306,
-0.22627379,
0.1576079726,
-0.5312107801,
0.1585442573,
-0.1100776196,
-0.7610610723,
-0.9632958174,
-0.2119015157,
0.1489323229,
-0.1244819015,
-0.4124693573,
0.301677078,
-0.8867816329,
-0.3483808339,
-0.2301904261,
0.0916412398,
-0.6129685044,
0.219539538,
0.2502635419,
0.9694824219,
0.6720461249,
-0.5706424117,
0.271936357,
0.307562381,
-0.2384577692,
0.2984484732,
-0.2525377572,
0.2924649417,
-0.087297067,
-0.1496628374,
-0.9716672897,
0.1435424238,
0.4583683908,
-0.1224974617,
0.4302792251,
-0.1964288652,
-0.5362556577,
-0.2494789213,
-0.1057186127,
0.3399228752,
0.6358351111,
-0.5080783367,
0.5414690375,
0.3667947054,
-0.1731099784,
-0.1570674032,
-0.6518176198,
0.3748600185,
-0.0439868905,
-0.4578264952,
0.240208298,
-0.1975700855,
-0.0950184688,
-0.2976324558,
-0.4511522353,
0.3000361919,
-0.3450033069,
0.1078497991,
0.1033167914,
-0.4417525828,
-0.1520174742,
0.0557348914,
-0.489345789,
-0.2801359892,
-0.6305861473,
0.6441167593,
-0.3743892908,
-0.2433844358,
-0.3346534073,
0.2792654037,
0.9702785015,
-0.3487028778,
0.6512544155,
0.3533067405,
-0.0304906555,
-0.3460486829,
-0.1219914928,
-0.1023985371,
-0.4440133572,
0.0153704686,
-0.4553025663,
-0.4800737798,
0.2132466286,
-0.1371368766,
0.0635913536,
0.1242762804,
0.1939092129,
0.1570892781,
0.8116217852,
0.3747582734,
-0.0627197102,
0.5728352666,
0.040694721,
0.3100579083,
-0.325589478,
-0.0119464435,
-0.1058888957,
-0.2086134702,
-0.2748113871,
-0.5600153208,
0.7862055302,
-0.0778500661,
0.1395964622,
1.1306313276,
-0.4227566123,
0.190127328,
0.3452695906,
0.2277743965,
0.4657432437,
0.0737707093,
0.0329860188,
-0.2598046064,
-0.489552021,
-0.3257075846,
0.7841163874,
0.0909188688,
0.419352293,
0.4185865819,
0.7090289593,
0.3424018919,
0.3879617453,
-0.4612422287,
0.8511781693,
-0.6446797848,
-0.318164885,
-0.5490162969,
-0.4189045429,
-0.6022398472,
0.3071205616,
-0.1777403951,
-0.2826725841,
0.0876431093,
0.417783767,
0.2170025557,
0.1584972143,
-0.8161045909,
0.8967579603,
-0.6455024481,
-0.1902191639,
0.0330400877,
-0.8299068213,
0.1398070902,
-0.3287332654,
0.4608744085,
-0.0445287116,
-0.1276370138,
0.6455266476,
-0.8244317174,
0.7134614587,
-0.5030457377,
-0.3581601381,
0.0763989612,
0.0803537518,
0.5588288903,
-0.25116992,
-0.204496339,
0.22734119,
-0.0772842839,
-0.5228034854,
-0.4723234773,
0.2631213963,
-0.533536315,
-0.4169463515,
-0.441306144,
-0.3965076506,
-0.1110328063,
0.2943378389,
0.2289966494,
0.1967259943,
0.0699601099,
-0.2945703864,
0.4329171479,
0.2950178087,
0.2600908279,
0.6377992034,
-0.4423543215,
-0.301787883,
0.9229770303,
0.1851359904,
0.649928689,
0.2025108337,
0.113204293,
-0.3719561398,
-0.845279336,
-0.538380146,
0.546869874,
-0.5043265224,
-0.1646680236,
-0.043564789,
0.0278145224,
-0.8350818157,
0.1663243324,
-0.4612552524,
-0.4482209384,
0.055078648,
-0.0187484138,
0.3869478405,
0.3809311092,
-0.1570662707,
0.4586075246,
-0.5071288347,
0.609528482,
0.0887301043,
0.3861739039,
-0.541295886,
-0.8166734576,
-0.3224296868,
-0.0702917799,
0.31649822,
-0.7748878598,
0.2277938575,
0.6765866876,
0.3483854234,
0.4639114738,
0.1463018656,
1.1283771992,
-0.7086094022,
0.3589610457,
0.5020298362,
-1.2823127508,
0.4250740111,
-0.0203910898,
0.425069958,
0.689946115,
0.2921554446,
-0.8223929405,
-0.3049132526,
-0.2163168043,
-1.018235445,
0.9155793786,
0.3537026942,
-0.1972839683,
0.2878566384,
0.229703173,
0.4093035161,
0.2815448642,
-0.7347334027,
-0.583491683,
-0.4886636138,
-0.2118353695,
-0.5263191462,
0.0927104875,
0.0766325071,
-0.4388003945,
0.7573771477,
-0.2826116979,
-0.0283291079,
0.1676941514,
-0.4526275694,
-0.1254697144,
0.1284296066,
0.7412628531,
0.4637690485,
-0.2089320421,
0.4801275134,
0.0682026669,
-0.6804959774,
0.2408147007,
0.2197851986,
-0.4860305786,
0.2641844451,
0.3666599393,
0.7872065306,
0.1338558942,
-0.4154677689,
0.5605692863,
0.2087065279,
-0.1620667726,
-0.1322379112,
-0.1210890338,
-0.1951225698,
-0.0715032667,
0.2460571676,
0.0608478524,
-0.0068193115,
-0.5901271105,
0.4617356658,
0.1644124389,
-0.0875105709,
-0.3862794936,
0.5792293549,
0.0442537032,
-0.3686689138,
0.2717057765,
-0.2326656431,
-0.7535172701,
0.0385678299,
0.5326279998,
0.643625617,
-0.4059798717,
0.3567453325,
0.5675818324,
0.5269248486,
-0.370400548,
0.1941261888,
-0.2128555328,
-0.4065491557,
-0.279197216,
-0.4986860454,
-0.282029599,
-0.0232546534,
-0.5469695926,
0.4791471958,
-0.5976648331,
-0.0859017819,
-0.0046378458,
-0.4423974156,
-0.4654197693,
0.1057083011,
0.6168931723,
0.6837239861,
-1.1552040577,
0.9774183035,
0.7024872899,
-0.3266196549,
-0.3607227206,
-0.0371437743,
0.1520655751,
-0.7299245,
0.5202237368,
-0.0853301138,
-0.3800055385,
-0.0140793817,
-0.3920446038,
-1.0145113468,
0.8139531016,
0.4685431123,
-0.7295004725,
0.0244777724,
0.8227233887,
0.7223823667,
-0.2695862353,
0.0316489451,
0.7296678424,
1.0039060116,
-0.0103758788,
-1.4491941929,
0.1570623517,
-0.2415443212,
-0.0781918615,
0.4588175118,
-0.474134475,
0.275716722,
0.0715684146,
-0.5315315723,
-0.2035705596,
0.8207976222,
-0.1931896657,
0.5582334995,
0.6745975614,
0.2131251097,
0.5437748432,
-0.2188346684,
0.5413687229,
-0.1747783273,
0.3617358208,
1.1100797653,
-0.2845401466,
0.5722144842,
0.6016129851,
-0.265537262,
0.1387194842,
0.1991842538,
0.2519006729,
0.5263356566,
0.1457107067,
-0.2059850097,
-0.4503743649,
0.3728707433,
-0.2389963567,
0.2954490185,
0.2960594594,
-0.2065562457,
-0.4768194258,
0.2361326516,
0.1815218329,
0.3708586693,
-0.4368858337,
0.8013883233,
0.1534219682,
-0.5162014365,
0.7985735536,
-0.0294291899,
0.7754638791,
-0.8627714515,
0.1253781468,
-0.3314081728,
0.2269427627,
-0.4332331121,
-0.5733649135,
0.3007173538,
-0.1337018311,
0.0557519421,
-0.6326614618,
0.5170911551,
-0.8878890872,
-0.4556069672,
0.5899731517,
0.3219014108,
0.4892204404,
0.321115613,
-0.7662159801,
0.0659490228,
0.0929018036,
0.0425599888,
0.2011940181,
0.1378265321,
-0.2782295942,
0.3096002936,
0.6318591237,
0.3678089976,
0.4663162529,
-0.0393806547,
0.5436702967,
-0.4611385763,
-0.5139132738,
-0.4168957174,
0.5088082552,
-0.0757891387,
-0.3323684037,
0.926068902,
0.9038459659,
0.6627953649,
-0.2674947679,
0.6619107723,
-0.2492569238,
0.3178520501,
-0.5063315034,
0.5352556109,
-0.4165800512,
0.0591119789,
-0.4157652855,
-0.8117061257,
-0.7141696215,
0.2964430451,
-0.5656417012,
-0.3336900175,
0.6442959905,
0.7978382707,
-0.4429413378,
-0.1802711189,
0.5380000472,
0.2634295523,
0.3854857683,
0.4419630766,
-0.0140837627,
-0.7819481492,
0.7432420254,
-0.0367237069,
-0.3908986747,
-0.263263315,
-0.8128070831,
-0.5093618035,
-0.8938378096,
-0.7213152647,
-0.352562964,
0.2002837658,
0.9179865718,
0.8136714101,
-1.0757683516,
-0.588226974,
-0.0417901389,
-0.2008897215,
-0.5604875088,
-0.1517887563,
0.6148010492,
-0.2144474387,
-0.5204693079,
0.6552426815,
0.2386040986,
0.1660120189,
0.2804657519,
-0.465095222,
-0.0878050849,
-0.1793270111,
0.7670719028,
0.6600645781,
-0.3328531981,
-0.3151657283,
-0.289322257,
0.0461042523,
0.3377325833,
0.910859704,
-0.3516797423,
0.464396745,
0.4058012366,
0.313462019,
1.0720703602,
0.165818274,
0.2643228471,
-0.6555275917,
0.1436256766,
0.0079295179,
0.2799057961,
0.3024299741,
-0.0912261382,
0.5247668624,
0.5280007124,
-0.0202552881,
-0.6432927847,
0.2728522122,
-1.2669959068,
0.0338766165,
1.1617673635,
-0.0235309023,
-0.1487504989,
-0.3126467764,
-0.2540997863,
0.080433473,
-0.2757905424,
0.4365184903,
0.2693591118,
-0.2290902287,
-0.4109649658,
-0.1742892861,
0.7494636178,
0.4140745103,
-0.8942494392,
0.3974786699,
0.4330067039,
0.2160827219,
0.3610767424,
0.7320201993,
-0.394664079,
0.3980817199,
-0.3318319619,
0.1709204614,
-0.1751000136,
-0.4020069838,
-0.2822049558,
0.0152907092,
-0.0198408272,
-0.1573840082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10813v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10813v3 | Tokenization Preference for Human and Machine Learning Model: An Annotation Study | 2023-04-21T08:49:06 | 2024-02-16T07:55:59 | Tatsuya Hiraoka, Tomoya Iwakura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Is preferred tokenization for humans also preferred for machine-learning (ML)
models? This study examines the relations between preferred tokenization for
humans (appropriateness and readability) and one for ML models (performance on
an NLP task). The question texts of the Japanese commonsense question-answering
dataset are tokenized with six different tokenizers, and the performances of
human annotators and ML models were compared. Furthermore, we analyze relations
among performance of answers by human and ML model, the appropriateness of
tokenization for human, and response time to questions by human. This study
provides a quantitative investigation result that shows that preferred
tokenizations for humans and ML models are not necessarily always the same. The
result also implies that existing methods using language models for
tokenization could be a good compromise both for human and ML models. | [
-0.3787455857,
-0.7053224444,
0.1516532451,
0.0540864803,
-0.3348988295,
-0.2403520495,
-0.2417171001,
-0.9047281146,
0.1281695962,
0.6090831757,
-0.195900619,
-0.2039794922,
-0.3836180866,
0.5066258311,
0.047826644,
0.9401836395,
0.1722546518,
0.4661880136,
-0.6695159674,
-0.3673038781,
-0.5856961608,
-1.2104507685,
-0.9512670636,
-0.5031595826,
0.7065401077,
0.0665532872,
0.9964568615,
0.7031427026,
0.6671608686,
0.2761261463,
-0.1601781696,
-0.2222110033,
0.1678713262,
-0.0122307679,
-0.1445122212,
-0.7092112899,
-0.6034562588,
0.1664776206,
0.3311463594,
1.0044100285,
0.3858563006,
0.3671689928,
-0.1832807213,
0.5099102259,
-0.4744670391,
-0.0368319377,
-0.4467281699,
0.1754160821,
-0.0994451195,
-0.0793434083,
-0.3451153338,
-0.2008203715,
0.1738377661,
-0.9047954679,
0.3936259449,
0.3979653418,
0.6526098847,
0.3428561389,
-0.2909062207,
-0.1866737753,
-0.3838268518,
0.8385148644,
-0.8304212689,
0.1463978589,
0.7830812931,
0.3644455671,
0.3347826004,
-0.5973632932,
-0.5301734805,
-0.3719321489,
-0.5054554939,
-0.1278890222,
0.0991428941,
0.2459273338,
0.4849845767,
0.1725618094,
-0.6124318242,
0.5741457343,
-0.4201728702,
-0.4352553189,
0.6583404541,
0.2026722878,
0.4800569415,
-0.7073637247,
-0.4038654566,
-0.0152485128,
-0.4830088317,
0.052029077,
0.4094014466,
0.6367042065,
0.2945389152,
0.7373973131,
-0.3686877489,
0.7181642056,
-0.3636652231,
0.1279052049,
0.2338975072,
-0.3610416651,
-0.1333938986,
0.0770169571,
0.7419418693,
0.6759568453,
0.447770834,
-0.5011077523,
-0.3041044176,
0.030894449,
0.2801176906,
-0.8151383996,
-0.0569292493,
0.2582575977,
-0.8728619814,
-0.2917036712,
0.2530094087,
-0.3660026789,
-0.3088459373,
-0.449775815,
0.2966088653,
-0.0189738534,
-0.4867270589,
0.0271957815,
-0.3696836233,
0.1463240087,
0.0724381357,
-1.1065056324,
0.5265672207,
0.8732261062,
0.7984926701,
-0.483479768,
-0.3192696869,
-0.2756741047,
-0.302971065,
-0.322840482,
0.5247764587,
-0.4566345513,
-0.6029808521,
-0.1357966065,
-0.0572261699,
-0.2866903245,
-0.6354326606,
0.6957678795,
-0.6639098525,
0.3958134055,
-0.5260720849,
-0.7883126736,
-0.0967989564,
0.1088535562,
-0.7633163333,
0.9220370054,
-0.0947257653,
-1.128111124,
0.7860100269,
-1.3486074209,
-0.2022881508,
0.2407017648,
0.1343017668,
-0.32738778,
-0.1273186654,
0.2587573826,
0.7203659415,
0.2082213312,
0.4251738787,
-0.4015296996,
-0.6534125209,
0.7601335049,
-0.4321801066,
0.8752229214,
0.4289177656,
-0.2211776674,
0.270606488,
-0.6654271483,
-0.0242053289,
0.2669847012,
-0.4334606826,
-0.403503418,
0.0406246595,
0.4060152471,
0.0885757133,
0.3193152547,
-0.6083928347,
0.1186121628,
-0.4227656722,
0.5857031345,
0.7279566526,
-0.0282751676,
0.5164268017,
-0.5839868188,
0.3879222274,
0.0584978089,
0.1546299905,
-0.027081782,
-0.763053894,
-0.7476198077,
-0.0591468513,
0.610517025,
0.4606585801,
-0.2802044451,
0.3034112453,
-0.2121025771,
-0.193102926,
-0.612787962,
-0.2315990925,
0.4234263897,
0.5842711329,
0.3908626735,
-0.2857111394,
-0.6745206118,
-0.9782266021,
-0.5549240112,
-0.6039209366,
-0.0956438929,
0.6247534156,
0.6444154978,
-0.0921897292,
1.1747803688,
-0.3770984113,
0.1641613245,
-0.0677786693,
0.3407591879,
-0.0400062874,
0.5757887363,
0.7497227192,
-1.2300137281,
-0.2891916931,
-0.0500169322,
-0.4435125887,
0.041586604,
0.1969706863,
-0.0156624652,
0.4877435565,
0.3969932497,
-0.1646991819,
0.3735787868,
0.1195046231,
-0.4175634086,
0.4912531376,
-0.1311847717,
0.330896467,
-1.2641371489,
0.7381471395,
-0.0519000739,
-0.4448933899,
-0.9007694721,
0.0833179951,
0.0226138812,
-0.1012658551,
-0.4704298079,
0.866579473,
0.0717485622,
-0.3448440433,
-0.2179262489,
0.1545067728,
-0.1241321638,
0.4004428089,
0.4055409133,
1.0479006767,
0.1043300033,
-0.5658023953,
0.2025031149,
0.3658844829,
-0.0162553675,
0.4130151272,
-1.0601685047,
0.4404920638,
-0.1479177028,
0.0146469809,
-1.0028259754,
-0.3911677897,
0.4296707511,
-0.8726696968,
0.074682571,
-0.0714411363,
-0.5977485776,
-0.3048639894,
-0.2353665084,
0.2984212935,
0.3115911484,
-0.3899395764,
0.2082893848,
0.1693915874,
-0.0930591077,
-0.6325209141,
-0.8783375621,
0.0978543907,
-0.42076087,
-0.3410707712,
0.1869383007,
-0.2206755579,
-0.145275265,
-0.0192393642,
0.2802035511,
-0.2927465439,
0.4604785442,
0.4228871167,
0.5226599574,
-0.3102127612,
0.2926300764,
-0.4086426795,
-0.3822128177,
0.0044379933,
0.1130770817,
0.4122853577,
-0.1078784689,
-0.2105838805,
-0.4287275076,
0.3223121464,
0.2865423262,
-0.2305768579,
0.8904845715,
0.6117312312,
-0.3562234044,
0.5710563064,
-0.5165647864,
-0.2867945135,
-0.3692186475,
0.4029285908,
-0.5443287492,
-1.0633736849,
0.6608082056,
0.2214850187,
0.1800073534,
0.7324345708,
0.4653590918,
-0.2902160287,
1.2079861164,
0.5705749393,
-0.5042472482,
0.4097855389,
-0.0807156116,
-0.1013844982,
-0.8046460748,
-0.0867913365,
-0.9591791034,
-0.3093241751,
-0.7226374745,
0.0170374028,
-0.0764803886,
0.0356922299,
-0.284208864,
0.1602469832,
-0.5845198035,
0.4956973493,
0.5722196698,
-0.0967938378,
0.1870137304,
-0.3012956679,
-0.0407715291,
-0.1329739541,
-0.8028773665,
-0.7787797451,
1.2822922468,
0.3122169375,
0.010617286,
-0.0630506054,
0.5471747518,
0.2246273011,
0.2975733578,
-0.5433622599,
0.3185302913,
-0.0745368898,
-1.16948843,
-0.4661960006,
-0.4739475846,
-1.1845189333,
0.2775791883,
-0.3425100446,
-0.7448848486,
-0.2563858628,
0.1119562984,
-0.159927994,
0.3683749437,
-0.7381923199,
1.1750121117,
-0.0812371522,
0.3179170787,
-0.0233143661,
-0.9655002356,
-0.0636857674,
0.2264736146,
0.1053781435,
-0.0085894372,
-0.3543583155,
1.107362628,
-0.0709588677,
0.9692890644,
-0.3537727296,
0.5254263282,
0.0115089519,
-0.2403068393,
0.1200490594,
-0.2123123556,
-0.2720559239,
0.1573136449,
0.1632386446,
-0.5211493969,
-0.6190415025,
0.2791060507,
-1.0481016636,
-0.5672513247,
-0.2899886966,
-0.3121938705,
-0.0476484299,
0.2651605904,
0.2180769295,
0.3075959682,
-0.1646000296,
0.0832775086,
0.329172492,
-0.0171110108,
0.4478033781,
0.1846221983,
-0.4147983789,
-0.4068796337,
0.8477737904,
0.1305811107,
0.3044724762,
0.4059824646,
0.4761678576,
-0.4391221106,
-0.5580148697,
-0.6259188652,
0.2233385444,
-0.7277616858,
0.107115306,
-0.6276010871,
-0.2220358849,
-0.3502114713,
-0.093923077,
-0.1132548526,
-0.8040834069,
-0.7121847868,
-0.1166687533,
0.2508114278,
0.6194065809,
0.2213813215,
-0.1001419351,
-0.5144095421,
0.2961212397,
0.2863059044,
0.3042229712,
-0.0513655543,
-0.4799213111,
-0.1177995875,
0.1041641235,
0.0710347518,
-0.6561527848,
-0.2527540326,
-0.0466868654,
0.5206662416,
0.3426066339,
0.0098866737,
0.5290350318,
-0.094502911,
1.1017888784,
0.1988692731,
-0.688310504,
0.3499309719,
-0.1915307194,
0.1695467979,
0.7282608151,
0.5668494701,
-1.1359169483,
-0.1316618621,
-0.5972453952,
-0.5484915376,
0.6756145358,
0.049773287,
0.359169662,
-0.0896672457,
0.5272527933,
0.3845134974,
0.2724615932,
-0.725543499,
-0.4115847647,
-0.308790952,
-0.0984894335,
-0.2493239194,
-0.3188956976,
0.1959137917,
-0.0552074052,
0.3626964092,
-0.3003628254,
0.285588026,
0.1112738699,
-0.0856276229,
-0.0357013866,
0.2538654506,
0.4330432713,
0.857863903,
-0.2786877453,
-0.0891840756,
0.2759009004,
-0.4088082314,
0.0320755951,
-0.1547493339,
-0.4751183689,
-0.0294015948,
0.41523242,
0.9151515961,
0.1533850431,
-0.4851369262,
0.5817120075,
-0.1253140569,
-0.35105896,
0.0428106077,
0.1726442426,
0.1359529048,
-0.1019828171,
0.1842328906,
0.2997416556,
0.346121192,
-0.2265779227,
-0.1171446592,
0.3473545313,
-0.3145719171,
-0.2308390588,
0.8545831442,
0.2336858511,
-0.6356709599,
0.5820872188,
-0.0629184917,
-0.691119194,
0.5444977283,
0.4905577898,
0.7390551567,
0.0845768452,
0.2600928545,
0.5692058802,
-0.009907214,
0.1059360951,
0.0398734175,
-0.3874488771,
-0.7365702987,
-0.3828683794,
-0.3598304987,
-0.6919836402,
-0.1204885244,
-0.9487697482,
0.1299262643,
-0.2532217205,
-0.5962326527,
0.0716403499,
0.3581520915,
-0.6302134395,
0.4566731155,
0.0237774104,
0.7166059613,
-0.8242688179,
0.5474542379,
1.0329806805,
-0.5933855772,
-0.50111413,
-0.2951378524,
-0.4745857418,
-0.511552155,
0.7581554651,
0.2505346239,
0.3520744443,
-0.1908712536,
-0.2839980125,
-0.5420780182,
1.1466523409,
0.1135934815,
-0.139964968,
-0.0156946499,
0.416783154,
0.5851997733,
-0.1631297171,
0.2615945339,
0.4848331809,
0.3293556273,
-0.1379271299,
-1.1641056538,
-0.1534403265,
-0.2729896307,
0.3739970624,
0.0850440413,
-0.7661935091,
0.4972813427,
-0.0766767859,
-0.0854847729,
0.2916868329,
0.7199955583,
0.2853800952,
0.6301792264,
0.6090552211,
0.3208045661,
0.9110030532,
0.080441691,
1.0552495718,
-0.1172248051,
0.2574099302,
0.8155378103,
0.1283868998,
1.0607413054,
0.5904399753,
-0.5861493945,
0.0202147327,
0.9081335664,
0.1368502378,
0.1474418789,
0.2468994856,
0.2461400181,
-0.1531668901,
-0.0814341232,
-0.1947614253,
0.3195568323,
-0.2224272043,
-0.2151031345,
0.3503529429,
0.1596708149,
0.2525004447,
0.1165207997,
-0.2439425141,
0.9820643663,
-0.182427153,
-0.6713151336,
0.3369058073,
0.3308333158,
0.8094783425,
-0.2852880955,
0.3136053085,
-0.1969023049,
-0.3703505695,
-0.1699854881,
-0.5552528501,
0.4122854173,
0.308870405,
-0.3670144975,
0.0087247072,
0.8958671093,
0.0216828976,
-0.4393467605,
-0.1305705011,
0.3732468486,
0.4531605542,
0.1170711741,
-0.862272203,
-0.2616859674,
-0.2521330118,
-0.3523851335,
0.414827913,
-0.0781563669,
-0.1071382165,
0.7083851695,
0.7832802534,
0.0692028105,
0.261143744,
0.2598872483,
0.5935849547,
-0.5309302807,
-0.5324184895,
-0.9114133716,
0.5390965343,
-0.3187406659,
-0.5199068189,
0.7034844756,
0.7025099993,
0.7602335811,
0.1163382307,
0.7245298624,
0.1959823072,
0.7150691152,
-0.505058527,
0.6962460876,
-0.4445247054,
-0.1581743062,
-0.3205895722,
-0.9624543786,
-0.6014447808,
0.5255557299,
-0.3669120073,
0.3527730405,
0.3894051909,
0.6015025377,
0.1429621726,
0.2427901775,
0.3761209548,
-0.3985576034,
0.2871461809,
0.189542681,
0.775233686,
-0.3035483956,
-0.0069167665,
-0.1664855033,
0.0815693587,
-0.352562815,
-0.7793275714,
-1.189542532,
-0.8443826437,
-0.2878666222,
0.0928137824,
-0.0789246112,
1.01182127,
0.7750787139,
-0.7791174054,
-0.1814178079,
0.1797066778,
-0.0126996608,
-0.1131343022,
-0.2081315666,
0.43974787,
-0.4375043511,
-0.7304883003,
-0.2625683248,
-0.0504401438,
0.1638130844,
-0.3090943098,
-0.357118696,
0.1498855948,
0.1124213338,
0.3222370446,
0.0743918791,
-0.8160711527,
-0.2961912453,
0.2872124314,
-0.1311922371,
0.2015938163,
1.0406764746,
-0.6328251958,
0.6704705358,
0.3269533217,
0.7388336658,
0.4053397775,
0.2377996147,
0.2029264718,
-0.5454360843,
0.2570026219,
0.3021093309,
0.202037558,
0.5971330404,
-0.3912939131,
0.492254734,
0.2493770123,
-0.76143682,
-0.7510141134,
-0.0411323719,
-0.6513756514,
-0.4328693748,
0.9656238556,
-0.1630062163,
-0.2553811967,
-0.1129219085,
-0.5465162396,
0.2784950435,
-0.1965059638,
0.5209236741,
0.8917645812,
-0.1324298978,
0.1126198173,
-0.522138536,
0.3908850253,
0.4032475352,
-0.7341313362,
-0.0311963875,
0.1485362649,
0.1663464755,
0.0641363114,
0.804420054,
0.073909983,
0.3979813755,
-0.0833797529,
-0.0852615535,
-0.3968704045,
-0.0963631123,
-0.2000496387,
-0.0144221094,
0.5110861063,
-0.2858245373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10808v1 | Downstream Task-Oriented Neural Tokenizer Optimization with Vocabulary Restriction as Post Processing | 2023-04-21T08:29:14 | 2023-04-21T08:29:14 | Tatsuya Hiraoka, Tomoya Iwakura | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes a method to optimize tokenization for the performance
improvement of already trained downstream models. Our method generates
tokenization results attaining lower loss values of a given downstream model on
the training data for restricting vocabularies and trains a tokenizer
reproducing the tokenization results. Therefore, our method can be applied to
variety of tokenization methods, while existing work cannot due to the
simultaneous learning of the tokenizer and the downstream model. This paper
proposes an example of the BiLSTM-based tokenizer with vocabulary restriction,
which can capture wider contextual information for the tokenization process
than non-neural-based tokenization methods used in existing work. Experimental
results on text classification in Japanese, Chinese, and English text
classification tasks show that the proposed method improves performance
compared to the existing methods for tokenization optimization. | [
-0.312238127,
-0.5515037179,
-0.0280077439,
0.1610509008,
-0.6425162554,
-0.0030756802,
-0.4011120498,
-0.3482301533,
0.1154731661,
0.6139783859,
-0.4806680083,
-0.314837724,
-0.8255639076,
0.0818270072,
-0.1372303963,
1.1813111305,
-0.1738528311,
0.356461972,
-0.0251373351,
0.012498267,
-0.7853081226,
-0.8189997673,
-1.0400592089,
-0.2014710158,
0.5332473516,
-0.0128297098,
0.1056172997,
0.7213485837,
0.6408026814,
0.3237547576,
-0.4271556139,
0.1710807979,
-0.3412066996,
0.1529005468,
-0.3301261067,
-0.6370788813,
-0.112847589,
-0.2331023514,
0.7701252103,
0.718703866,
0.1746095866,
0.3098471761,
0.1614320278,
0.4337464273,
-0.7963739634,
0.0715510622,
-0.7132104039,
0.1122032478,
-0.4267523587,
-0.6455125809,
-0.4864216447,
-0.0993065313,
-0.0527832024,
-0.4223000109,
0.4321143031,
0.1026220769,
1.0418180227,
0.3749620616,
-0.2547117472,
-0.1731150448,
-0.7682276368,
0.880623877,
-0.7597028017,
0.3315646946,
0.3314068615,
0.1015723124,
0.2771981061,
-1.1357409954,
-0.4208583534,
0.2213846147,
-0.121825777,
0.1278056055,
0.0040455936,
0.377928853,
0.0992057994,
0.2759638131,
-0.5194925666,
0.0787847042,
-0.5766949654,
-0.4711452723,
0.3514349163,
0.1057636142,
0.1287072301,
-0.3904181123,
-0.6348515153,
0.1803820431,
-0.660763979,
0.3314833343,
0.1203217357,
0.6867743134,
0.4255571067,
0.4691618085,
-0.2222320586,
0.4753935635,
-0.0298241563,
-0.0689433813,
0.310335964,
-0.6045183539,
-0.1173193976,
0.0115227001,
0.3789506555,
0.1945419312,
-0.1972127557,
-0.4652610123,
-0.630118072,
-0.0228349045,
0.210428521,
-1.0695017576,
0.2713640928,
0.0856142938,
-0.8778480291,
-0.118878141,
0.0721362531,
-0.4935197234,
-0.0488228239,
-0.4792281389,
0.4890855253,
-0.1352834702,
-0.2057115734,
-0.150243938,
-0.5029197335,
0.1091345921,
-0.0478317924,
-1.0134613514,
0.495102793,
0.8998626471,
1.2843306065,
-0.2769361734,
-0.2387656122,
-0.8738392591,
0.19213368,
-0.1881573647,
0.6753547192,
-0.2542909682,
-0.5451052189,
-0.0693563744,
-0.0277215187,
-0.2271434814,
-0.4663712084,
0.4212861061,
-0.744343996,
-0.0380070992,
-0.1781287044,
-0.5765488148,
-0.3384642601,
0.2238495946,
-0.4117997587,
1.0339009762,
0.0632778853,
-0.7805586457,
0.617747128,
-0.6833053827,
-0.5169006586,
0.3319805264,
0.1542749405,
-0.0940238535,
0.2015035003,
-0.097900033,
0.3697881699,
-0.0739875883,
0.3376634419,
0.3003683984,
-0.5372348428,
-0.2330995351,
-0.2157636732,
0.65156883,
0.3434405625,
-0.4421209395,
0.6248344183,
-0.291911602,
0.0663309544,
-0.3536960781,
-0.6859006286,
-0.5614957809,
0.2312238514,
0.5161042213,
0.1778381318,
0.3610018492,
-0.5737993717,
0.1548056155,
-0.756659925,
0.5589512587,
0.8647407889,
-0.03980764,
0.4448967278,
-0.2641604841,
0.5100861192,
0.2426930666,
0.2858147621,
0.1050181016,
-0.446269691,
-0.9839348793,
-0.3597746193,
0.6982744932,
0.6681267023,
-0.9712951779,
0.54616642,
-0.3908324242,
-0.355643183,
-0.2141456008,
0.2550625801,
0.5281962752,
0.6359624863,
0.3294562697,
-0.6530220509,
-0.7518437505,
-0.7995373011,
-0.3106893003,
0.0129829068,
0.0629130304,
-0.1130374223,
0.3555778563,
0.0546542257,
0.8569250107,
-0.2074582726,
-0.3283285201,
-0.4510632455,
0.3442352712,
0.288302213,
0.6741871834,
0.4000722468,
-0.9615010619,
-0.4674825668,
0.0289032441,
-0.239593938,
-0.0387608781,
-0.0718564838,
-0.2766938806,
0.3863906562,
0.8206268549,
-0.5201985836,
0.7524676323,
0.1588416994,
-0.5006650686,
0.3707239926,
-0.1944440901,
-0.2746611238,
-1.2108658552,
0.3299641311,
-0.2600910366,
-0.189898476,
-0.8134750724,
0.0963801891,
-0.0943773016,
-0.0282332599,
-0.4265218377,
0.5330935717,
-0.4547634721,
0.0830355957,
-0.5236000419,
-0.0423699617,
-0.1091201976,
0.5770593882,
0.4625045359,
0.6751646996,
0.5365120769,
-0.791070044,
-0.0021466371,
0.35596627,
-0.1508302987,
0.2682295144,
-0.7176546454,
-0.0189561509,
-0.3677168489,
0.134039849,
-1.0545064211,
0.2212159485,
0.249219045,
-0.4060056508,
0.4442936778,
-0.2520187497,
-0.46943748,
-0.2154635489,
-0.2684541941,
0.2310577035,
0.5733030438,
-0.519918859,
0.5662271976,
0.0896294564,
-0.2119644582,
-0.5767098665,
-0.8969399929,
0.0930903032,
-0.2297705114,
-0.235305801,
0.7385866642,
0.0589007623,
0.3773774803,
-0.0087741651,
-0.0545108579,
-0.1522706896,
0.0656390414,
0.0838269219,
0.4321514666,
-0.1092167795,
0.3010986447,
0.4515157342,
-0.2484061718,
-0.1933822781,
-0.4639239609,
0.802198112,
0.2150447518,
-0.0133729642,
-0.6141204238,
0.3903178573,
0.166695863,
-0.4184842408,
0.8660388589,
0.8808118701,
-0.4210395515,
-0.2017279714,
-0.3475582302,
-0.1398086101,
-0.5166043043,
0.5466649532,
-0.456831485,
-1.0112768412,
0.4158065021,
-0.1028950438,
0.1805762351,
0.2119558007,
0.5558494329,
0.4619710147,
0.9571149945,
0.3802831769,
-0.0646826625,
0.6113834977,
-0.3531548679,
0.5086368918,
-0.9750207663,
-0.0583520122,
-0.6193077564,
-0.458925575,
-0.5892089605,
-0.2321060151,
-0.0295855757,
0.4635591805,
-0.1234132275,
0.4252798259,
-0.9178617001,
0.2576054931,
0.8995031118,
0.0557972118,
0.0266827717,
-0.0517631173,
-0.0352697484,
0.0122896619,
-0.8240025043,
-0.3852955699,
0.9499145746,
0.0636968911,
0.0409411751,
0.0652716458,
0.7340801954,
0.2270738333,
0.6635650992,
-1.0811312199,
0.482170552,
-0.3017282784,
-0.7395169735,
-0.3603357971,
-0.5678732991,
-1.0049980879,
0.3045057058,
0.0092892656,
-0.873492837,
0.2651391029,
0.0431355648,
-0.1633487046,
0.3679519296,
-0.8265460134,
0.8162927628,
-0.0561912134,
-0.223607868,
0.0809325054,
-0.5962710977,
-0.0323908776,
-0.0423579812,
0.1066885963,
0.1854584962,
-0.4741132557,
0.9087625146,
-0.8380852938,
0.822077632,
-0.7658932209,
0.452465415,
0.2784991264,
-0.3887418211,
0.3993246555,
-0.2691044509,
-0.0516986176,
0.3155036271,
0.2338352501,
-0.5519469976,
-0.4048416018,
0.342325598,
-0.5800456405,
-0.6423530579,
-0.0786397532,
-0.3534610271,
-0.2830312252,
0.6407382488,
0.7170722485,
0.367955476,
0.2918160856,
0.2369782329,
-0.050433293,
0.0583121851,
0.9252288938,
0.0954727829,
-0.0899555087,
-0.476406157,
1.0361870527,
0.3323646188,
0.046299383,
0.477676034,
0.3442850411,
-0.4024752975,
-1.277028203,
-0.3316897452,
-0.0804709643,
-0.6947906613,
-0.4134581387,
-0.3992728591,
-0.3260021806,
-0.4693805873,
-0.0056759124,
-0.1496200711,
-0.5139304399,
-0.3810428977,
0.0568745397,
0.1641193032,
0.4736404121,
0.0530640148,
0.5675990582,
-0.9075226784,
0.0227476321,
-0.0051710736,
0.4963599145,
0.2730671167,
-0.4736548364,
-0.384216547,
-0.1806648225,
-0.2724249661,
-0.5270370841,
0.4194514155,
0.3178426921,
0.4279961586,
0.5222043991,
0.0210488401,
0.6894016862,
-0.4861502945,
0.7883421779,
0.3644642532,
-1.3249133825,
0.5473044515,
-0.2058714032,
0.188015908,
0.6856692433,
0.2361578196,
-0.5716388822,
-0.0382684395,
-0.0668670759,
-1.1875059605,
0.8110613823,
0.3432423472,
0.4393981099,
-0.0770598054,
0.5589348674,
0.1821819991,
0.4274668396,
-0.5243449211,
-0.203543216,
-0.4097094536,
-0.2373427451,
-0.0056731519,
-0.2161419839,
0.1704161316,
-0.6131308675,
0.732542038,
-0.0252757929,
0.2789723575,
0.3008555174,
-0.0294863079,
0.2184625566,
-0.1077363193,
0.4603211284,
0.5150973201,
0.1073104963,
-0.0452118739,
0.1011558026,
-0.8056777716,
-0.0056559737,
0.0426891334,
-0.6262866855,
0.2033912092,
0.2518607378,
0.9927757382,
-0.105775021,
-0.6080802083,
0.5639182925,
0.0533231124,
-0.2827917933,
-0.179275766,
0.1227134839,
0.0205132104,
0.2319024503,
0.3207910657,
0.3732985258,
0.403816998,
-0.1680600345,
0.0306858122,
0.3617282212,
-0.3574383855,
-0.1887570173,
0.7487100363,
0.2023628503,
-0.6756418943,
0.4557721913,
-0.2806366086,
-0.7003569603,
0.5204634666,
0.4908447266,
1.0266529322,
-0.1848058403,
-0.1027333662,
0.4983196259,
0.1574192196,
-0.0099256756,
0.3223760724,
-0.4246704578,
-0.7413356304,
-0.5588874221,
-0.7712695003,
-0.13812837,
0.0006550003,
-0.7713708282,
0.3302123547,
-0.7515760064,
-0.6069174409,
0.0170805976,
-0.2520122528,
-0.5367896557,
0.2330465913,
-0.1722911894,
0.8786028624,
-0.1763529032,
0.7566975951,
0.7116583586,
-0.4486077726,
-0.6646227241,
0.0238648951,
-0.4300307035,
-0.4491980076,
1.1329586506,
0.4321109653,
0.0557656363,
0.1125761494,
-0.1082027107,
-0.8930804133,
1.0700839758,
-0.1843666285,
-0.3820160329,
-0.2812778652,
0.1920952499,
0.5707316399,
-0.1474432647,
0.0233912133,
0.1883823276,
0.4921649694,
0.0388865843,
-0.8278369904,
0.1825196147,
-0.690828979,
0.6217469573,
0.3760045171,
-0.7303926945,
0.7646073699,
0.3589421511,
-0.4167482257,
0.305156976,
0.5113626719,
-0.0052991332,
0.3048508167,
0.7556751966,
0.3067919016,
0.4601458609,
-0.1395545006,
0.8113693595,
-0.3136981726,
0.4105831683,
0.9677108526,
-0.091565378,
1.0627062321,
0.9962264895,
-0.0659425035,
0.3041196167,
0.728985846,
-0.0578259751,
0.7076497078,
0.5935325623,
-0.4217701256,
0.1200261489,
-0.3782017827,
-0.0482195355,
0.6735354662,
0.1420943588,
-0.5048480034,
0.0244828463,
0.2474268675,
0.1382936388,
-0.1991018951,
-0.4811242223,
0.763739109,
-0.1897395402,
-0.855163157,
0.7362275124,
0.3934853077,
1.0990198851,
-0.5920722485,
0.4080775082,
-0.1292390525,
0.2678511739,
-0.1738796681,
0.0290640388,
0.7908511758,
0.1188616231,
-0.1009059176,
-0.3319050968,
0.8011749983,
-0.1554579735,
-0.4337763488,
0.3000411093,
0.3082530797,
0.089346543,
-0.127912879,
-0.3661983311,
-0.1375634074,
-0.2130228877,
-0.6008037925,
0.1664207429,
0.1723272651,
-0.02681504,
0.343249023,
0.8067929745,
0.3978484571,
0.1913138479,
0.069919616,
0.788705349,
-0.5153159499,
-0.7482106686,
-0.742371738,
0.4430709481,
-0.2501085103,
-0.6129243374,
0.631000936,
0.7080310583,
1.0348137617,
-0.12148875,
0.8551533222,
-0.1180355102,
0.5515476465,
-0.5938466787,
0.842681706,
-0.6425713897,
0.0239680503,
-0.0603861697,
-0.7740385532,
-0.3726474941,
0.3552237153,
-0.3061471879,
0.170934692,
0.8034700751,
0.7122933269,
0.1363329291,
0.0342175364,
0.2837679088,
-0.2692395449,
-0.0306824818,
0.4418642223,
0.6718443036,
-0.4451884925,
0.4814362526,
-0.3963762522,
-0.1822018325,
-0.0173499733,
-0.4775119722,
-1.1561789513,
-0.7640844584,
-0.1685053408,
-0.1315072328,
-0.0477555878,
0.4977675974,
1.0200960636,
-0.8399859667,
-0.2215400934,
-0.640106678,
-0.1227267087,
-0.2800145745,
-0.3182502389,
0.4692400694,
-0.754409194,
-0.8611671925,
-0.0490674004,
0.2949878573,
-0.1568463445,
-0.1614585817,
-0.1348800063,
-0.211532101,
0.1908093244,
0.7262749076,
-0.1036727279,
-0.6213055253,
-0.1904958338,
0.0226809327,
0.1895811409,
0.0442657769,
1.1637252569,
-0.4214377701,
0.3785986006,
0.8699973226,
0.8074333668,
0.6512361169,
-0.0760140419,
0.2506649196,
-0.8597182631,
0.4554725587,
0.2608588934,
0.3172712028,
0.2129438519,
-0.5322329998,
0.3928070366,
0.4709794223,
-0.2128680199,
-0.7088378668,
0.1124738008,
-0.8383350372,
-0.527286768,
0.9113013744,
-0.3047924042,
-0.2798596025,
-0.3238790333,
-0.3179080486,
0.6845598817,
-0.216786027,
0.5669843554,
0.7623579502,
-0.0950750411,
-0.1198651269,
-0.3522150815,
0.4424967468,
0.6444265842,
-0.9273206592,
-0.1339143962,
0.0447122827,
0.0801937208,
0.1718996614,
0.6066559553,
-0.196181342,
0.0632408783,
0.005241476,
0.1461228281,
-0.1885119081,
0.0173061881,
-0.078548789,
0.1086287498,
0.0915099308,
-0.498966068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10785v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10785v2 | Which Factors Predict the Chat Experience of a Natural Language Generation Dialogue Service? | 2023-04-21T07:29:07 | 2023-05-28T02:26:24 | Eason Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | In this paper, we proposed a conceptual model to predict the chat experience
in a natural language generation dialog system. We evaluated the model with 120
participants with Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM)
and obtained an R-square (R2) with 0.541. The model considers various factors,
including the prompts used for generation; coherence, sentiment, and similarity
in the conversation; and users' perceived dialog agents' favorability. We then
further explore the effectiveness of the subset of our proposed model. The
results showed that users' favorability and coherence, sentiment, and
similarity in the dialogue are positive predictors of users' chat experience.
Moreover, we found users may prefer dialog agents with characteristics of
Extroversion, Openness, Conscientiousness, Agreeableness, and Non-Neuroticism.
Through our research, an adaptive dialog system might use collected data to
infer factors in our model, predict the chat experience for users through these
factors, and optimize it by adjusting prompts. | [
-0.5835643411,
-0.9359254241,
0.4680482149,
0.4071915746,
-0.3115327656,
0.2862050533,
0.019520551,
-0.4197932482,
0.2475510389,
0.5957387686,
-0.7265868187,
-0.0588532016,
-0.0889311358,
0.4798893631,
-0.1474185288,
1.1137679815,
0.3891969919,
0.0879443362,
-0.2228580117,
0.2983857393,
-0.8532158136,
-0.3865451813,
-1.0906165838,
-0.3365738988,
0.095461078,
0.360784471,
0.9426059127,
0.0743077174,
0.1700954139,
0.3580284417,
-0.1985931695,
0.0776689276,
-0.5893408656,
0.5408101678,
0.1273418963,
-0.5144154429,
-0.4862092733,
-0.1999644339,
0.4149527848,
0.4708828926,
-0.2059282213,
-0.2407270074,
0.3439920247,
0.3934142888,
0.1602186412,
0.0002490181,
-0.7077651024,
0.1124916896,
0.1149774045,
-0.4611845911,
-0.4207354188,
-0.5528710485,
0.7655593753,
-0.8418298364,
0.5421441793,
0.5160316229,
0.5485381484,
-0.1230727434,
-0.3495345116,
-0.5532333851,
-0.9516422749,
0.5835049152,
-0.7415086627,
0.1341667622,
0.2662936449,
0.469802916,
-0.6037100554,
-0.1669052243,
-0.5501007438,
-0.5320497155,
-0.0609264337,
0.1532947719,
-0.0844242871,
0.1285239607,
0.2825517654,
0.4597392082,
-0.6072090864,
-0.0856019482,
-0.4323964119,
-0.2356982976,
0.5796803832,
0.5303664804,
0.5247436166,
-0.5225841403,
-0.6051564813,
0.2542704046,
-0.4672755003,
0.2882505059,
0.5841294527,
0.5997520685,
-0.4897272289,
0.354082346,
-0.3823306561,
0.4170053899,
0.1629529148,
-0.1570071429,
0.1196803302,
-0.637406826,
-0.315683037,
-0.0273317937,
0.8067199588,
0.4447381496,
0.3939999342,
0.1395091414,
-0.0477161333,
-0.1593785733,
0.3650797606,
-0.6647803783,
-0.0137309236,
0.0402883366,
-0.3817325234,
-0.5866579413,
-0.2398164272,
-0.8042333126,
-0.5519883037,
-0.315633595,
0.0002055731,
-0.7411305308,
-0.3302597702,
-0.3091821373,
-0.2043685019,
-0.0932728723,
0.5037623644,
-0.7072831392,
0.4606678784,
0.3899358213,
0.8936110735,
-0.1584167778,
0.2993096411,
-0.3427626193,
-0.321547091,
-0.1172674,
0.7500886917,
-0.4697169363,
-0.6573440433,
0.184545368,
-0.138784349,
-0.132334128,
-0.3349912763,
0.5424082279,
-0.3940749764,
0.6498165131,
-0.1722342372,
-0.6900767684,
0.0749069825,
-0.1086107194,
-0.5759856701,
0.6547435522,
0.0766098499,
-0.6248113513,
0.373477608,
-0.7166225314,
-0.1835943013,
0.5748448372,
-0.0417454243,
-0.0921185315,
0.3483466208,
-0.0943354666,
0.2422557473,
-0.2406397611,
0.3196568191,
-0.3956515789,
-0.0962612182,
0.9589785933,
-0.2892768979,
0.6360090971,
0.4285103083,
0.0723062679,
0.139420107,
-0.6394588351,
-0.0736714453,
0.1911396533,
-0.1729226708,
-0.0939586982,
0.0002188295,
-0.1062854156,
0.3203867972,
-0.030731149,
-0.7954620123,
-0.2650685906,
-0.8052715659,
0.2911269963,
0.6995862722,
0.7155302167,
0.5716508031,
-0.354241401,
0.8219578266,
0.0894602165,
0.1224228069,
-0.1717948169,
-0.6848732233,
-0.7592155337,
-0.0085270768,
-0.0575681664,
0.3838613331,
-0.8579546213,
0.325409621,
-0.0927807093,
-0.486337781,
-0.1160514802,
0.3342372775,
0.4000116885,
0.4162252545,
-0.2060724646,
-0.3480148315,
-0.5782302022,
-0.8909593821,
0.145972088,
-0.4343501925,
-0.1228830665,
0.6485264301,
0.0366174579,
0.1858453602,
1.1560508013,
-0.4368750453,
0.0972696394,
-0.375299722,
0.3332988918,
0.0486465953,
0.0808029324,
0.4338554144,
-0.5604666471,
-0.7777639627,
-0.1885558665,
-0.5625140071,
-0.1987737119,
-0.140613839,
-0.0729520544,
0.5010269284,
0.0325869098,
-0.5311590433,
0.4305474758,
0.5708035231,
-0.5832355618,
0.4966886044,
-0.0977675915,
-0.0631948709,
-1.3518496752,
-0.1276499182,
0.3544268906,
-0.0976513252,
-0.9858592153,
-0.3919200003,
-0.4625378847,
-0.6520324945,
-0.2646136284,
0.4446463883,
-0.0528821833,
-0.0543329753,
-0.4573247135,
0.3263342381,
0.05639489,
0.5741047859,
0.1438405365,
0.9386444688,
0.3535278141,
-0.5875694752,
0.3142725825,
0.4063591957,
-0.3533515334,
0.5739041567,
-0.8152655959,
0.3263217509,
-0.0388204306,
0.3770425618,
-1.3673001528,
-0.0593337975,
0.1886655986,
-0.6465060115,
-0.0996364504,
0.2733293474,
-0.0238806661,
-0.187104255,
-0.043379996,
-0.1344109178,
0.3170161545,
-0.0165493265,
0.3647251129,
0.1307245344,
-0.7030469775,
0.1068625301,
0.1134946123,
0.1083708704,
-0.1679030359,
-0.8343573809,
0.1936687678,
-0.3903851211,
-0.130683735,
-0.3197218478,
0.1382745951,
0.1768417656,
0.1052629426,
0.5849369764,
0.4844384193,
-0.1801927388,
0.0905509144,
-0.2197721601,
-0.2412751913,
0.0819881111,
0.2534323037,
0.7246254683,
-0.1601422429,
0.0186063517,
-0.5057488084,
0.3040007055,
0.4063981473,
0.004656822,
0.6394897699,
0.3405907154,
-0.0941407382,
0.0486220531,
-0.5117964149,
-0.2849718034,
-0.4629504085,
0.2824035585,
-0.2938898206,
-0.7903953791,
0.6682239175,
0.2536154091,
0.0277445484,
0.076937966,
0.5384407043,
-0.1910232604,
1.2618603706,
0.5202716589,
0.2384667695,
0.6893460155,
0.3200424016,
0.4540889561,
-0.7577713132,
-0.2096255124,
-0.5935881138,
-0.0313628949,
-0.6201188564,
-0.0486340933,
0.2109223008,
0.075189054,
-0.0701999962,
0.2649217546,
-0.0784519389,
-0.3064004779,
0.4405504763,
0.0478331521,
0.1728295088,
0.2744967937,
-0.2960065007,
-0.0855617151,
-0.4432908595,
-0.7068442702,
0.8178122044,
0.5888141394,
0.5123466849,
0.2298505455,
0.4820024967,
0.3141153455,
0.0647890121,
-0.457827419,
0.619101584,
0.3168213367,
-0.7537718415,
-0.4181338251,
-0.5602576137,
-0.7732200027,
-0.238682121,
-0.5776851773,
-0.9174708724,
-0.109976083,
0.0318795219,
-0.7065930367,
-0.3386069238,
-0.8887563944,
0.4633402228,
-0.0590022914,
-0.3042220473,
-0.2474178076,
-0.4646473229,
0.3108360171,
-0.0560779013,
0.1089769974,
-0.2145512551,
0.3266652524,
0.6848192811,
-0.2039376795,
0.8083615899,
-0.3669817448,
0.0266697612,
0.4342034757,
0.3137225807,
0.4870935678,
0.1638484299,
-0.0958949551,
-0.2249827832,
-0.1023467258,
-0.171065107,
-0.8743861914,
0.4729955494,
-0.9821506739,
-0.6044031978,
-0.0049345642,
-0.4625419378,
-0.3871819079,
-0.1532737315,
0.1288693547,
0.517927289,
-0.6095148921,
0.3156341016,
0.4969759285,
-0.6017902493,
0.2359786481,
0.5576994419,
-0.5401746631,
-0.4227292538,
0.6421575546,
-0.1138875112,
0.6648632884,
0.1414997131,
0.2760444283,
-0.2215340883,
-0.4332235157,
-0.3915025592,
-0.0819509476,
-0.2409813106,
-0.1932416409,
-0.5278033614,
-0.5570268631,
-0.3714205027,
0.0658649951,
0.0552787632,
-0.2838677168,
-0.3083731234,
-0.1732956767,
0.34869802,
0.6505085826,
0.4834760725,
0.734906733,
-0.6481689811,
0.2569808662,
0.3806495368,
0.3434535265,
-0.0806110948,
-0.6534662247,
-0.1967423558,
0.2899203002,
-0.5437434316,
-0.8849098682,
0.4773266613,
0.1166640222,
0.6243668795,
0.4982537925,
0.0326106846,
0.2092609257,
-0.1639690846,
1.0011271238,
0.4693513513,
-0.6536393762,
0.5050278306,
-0.4754856825,
0.1668503284,
0.2264208794,
-0.028303368,
-0.6737157106,
-0.5967580676,
-0.725851953,
-0.3889480829,
0.7562888861,
0.6367895007,
0.5631853938,
-0.016294688,
0.1532839984,
0.2515443563,
0.0719001144,
-0.5955259204,
-0.1218688115,
-0.3789347708,
-0.0643667057,
-0.0093809627,
-0.4944738746,
0.1780874878,
0.2228182107,
0.6817388535,
-0.2252616733,
0.619173646,
0.0137481345,
0.3618634045,
-0.6111924648,
0.482332319,
0.8579549789,
0.5580609441,
-0.5187346935,
-0.3374620378,
0.2216810286,
-0.2164027244,
-0.1047860235,
-0.1599482298,
-0.246825844,
-0.0316851139,
0.010711249,
1.365950346,
0.0413737968,
-0.3731168509,
0.2891337276,
-0.3448187709,
-0.2278083265,
-0.3321065009,
0.4479793012,
0.205816254,
0.0305970311,
0.368899703,
0.2821911871,
0.016644232,
-0.4849250615,
-0.133472532,
0.5905138254,
-0.5413782597,
-0.4917832911,
0.1612333208,
0.7143194675,
-1.0360680819,
0.4710000455,
-0.22697182,
-0.4609913826,
0.3015837967,
0.8521217108,
0.9191738963,
-0.3302877545,
0.5646266937,
0.4295449257,
-0.1028265506,
0.5355877876,
0.0168350395,
0.0986393839,
-1.0897145271,
-0.1022902951,
-0.7720198631,
-0.3890912533,
0.2129116207,
-0.5834627151,
0.3083860576,
-0.3933314681,
-0.4990572929,
0.1687005311,
0.3950303495,
-0.8638325334,
0.1384840012,
0.3578266203,
0.8747822642,
-0.9050380588,
0.4717290401,
0.5133588314,
-0.3485842645,
-0.7771918178,
-0.2962168753,
0.0666790009,
-0.7697333694,
0.2722389996,
-0.2036927044,
-0.0805085078,
-0.2755842209,
-0.3880650699,
-0.8601099849,
0.9798294306,
0.1064250022,
-0.4822627008,
-0.1549851745,
0.2184836268,
0.8158147335,
-0.8453398943,
0.3645427525,
0.354396522,
-0.1122676209,
0.4677653313,
-0.9060258865,
0.0771367848,
-0.4991053641,
0.4402596951,
-0.0693944618,
-0.4153319597,
0.3537855148,
0.0116320075,
-0.4276541173,
0.3887456656,
0.5660841465,
0.4617619216,
0.3246124387,
0.6601961851,
0.0294055156,
0.4986047149,
0.2045489252,
0.8909614682,
-0.4764478207,
-0.0650129691,
1.0710560083,
-0.4212653041,
0.5998253226,
0.5575733185,
-0.2159568071,
0.7433104515,
0.2976470292,
0.3701511919,
0.3776042163,
0.038835723,
-0.1979065686,
-0.1278809011,
-0.3849957883,
-0.2359128445,
0.4354911149,
0.4131792188,
-0.561920464,
-0.0639290288,
0.0609393381,
-0.3329845667,
-0.0197145287,
0.24849011,
1.2819613218,
0.041723989,
-0.8565070033,
0.2666561902,
0.0102893468,
0.2347724438,
-0.5360998511,
0.1041438729,
-0.2899156213,
-0.227380529,
-0.1329397261,
-0.6423405409,
0.0704798326,
-0.0435105972,
-0.2038887739,
-0.177270323,
1.0535154343,
-0.0551627465,
-0.4435508847,
-0.0737764463,
0.6942820549,
0.0313668549,
0.1508484483,
-0.6529831886,
-0.0795318484,
0.467694968,
-0.3253998756,
0.3640330434,
0.4018702209,
0.1128881946,
0.7409747243,
0.786288321,
0.1207432821,
-0.0080989189,
0.0839052498,
0.6063755751,
-0.555487752,
-0.6557992101,
-0.508235395,
0.5356660485,
-0.3814836144,
-0.4806714356,
0.6863625646,
0.3961682618,
0.1816602349,
0.0941596851,
0.9023182988,
0.0383083485,
0.8699852228,
-0.2450291216,
0.2902612984,
0.0389916375,
0.204025209,
-0.3835468888,
-0.9819303155,
0.4322344661,
0.4722634852,
-0.3304078877,
0.0118774259,
0.4574470222,
1.0056618452,
0.2639923692,
0.9384157062,
0.2743599117,
0.0234748609,
0.4237639904,
0.3573312759,
1.0667461157,
-0.0777725726,
0.479544729,
-0.1422359645,
-0.2369442433,
-0.3410258293,
-0.591960907,
-0.8533766866,
-0.6125183702,
-0.1687222123,
-0.4045810103,
-0.3026204109,
1.1298619509,
0.453150481,
-0.7714655995,
-0.3114482462,
-0.3911544979,
-0.1144828573,
0.1581023335,
-0.3351263404,
-0.2890408039,
-0.5195505619,
-0.4563337266,
0.228643626,
0.2822329998,
0.3031282127,
-0.419853121,
-0.3370611072,
0.0584302656,
0.3363907337,
0.5341299772,
0.086073637,
-0.6419533491,
-0.4634719491,
0.3066143692,
-0.3661708832,
-0.0657860488,
0.7546461821,
-0.6432808042,
0.6102256179,
0.3655124009,
0.1570713967,
0.3720692694,
0.213633433,
1.1896926165,
-0.8111220598,
-0.108846508,
0.017665498,
0.1730625033,
0.3368069828,
-0.4124282598,
0.1318335533,
0.0886557177,
-0.5650112033,
-0.5760122538,
0.3235809207,
-0.9557955265,
0.1345881671,
1.1184779406,
-0.0558756441,
0.139723599,
-0.3280812204,
-0.6075693965,
0.3280782998,
-0.8344346881,
0.7107316256,
0.7664632797,
-0.3213781714,
-0.2429434508,
-0.6650050879,
0.7104004025,
0.4236619473,
-0.5834857225,
0.1288405955,
0.4631895125,
0.3814473152,
0.4390504062,
0.6158472896,
0.3083903491,
0.0589318238,
-0.0691659376,
-0.2332618684,
0.0246446263,
-0.0429223925,
-0.1422562897,
0.2419468313,
0.2779218554,
0.1437693685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10784v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10784v2 | Eyettention: An Attention-based Dual-Sequence Model for Predicting Human Scanpaths during Reading | 2023-04-21T07:26:49 | 2023-05-18T08:24:03 | Shuwen Deng, David R. Reich, Paul Prasse, Patrick Haller, Tobias Scheffer, Lena A. Jäger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Eye movements during reading offer insights into both the reader's cognitive
processes and the characteristics of the text that is being read. Hence, the
analysis of scanpaths in reading have attracted increasing attention across
fields, ranging from cognitive science over linguistics to computer science. In
particular, eye-tracking-while-reading data has been argued to bear the
potential to make machine-learning-based language models exhibit a more
human-like linguistic behavior. However, one of the main challenges in modeling
human scanpaths in reading is their dual-sequence nature: the words are ordered
following the grammatical rules of the language, whereas the fixations are
chronologically ordered. As humans do not strictly read from left-to-right, but
rather skip or refixate words and regress to previous words, the alignment of
the linguistic and the temporal sequence is non-trivial. In this paper, we
develop Eyettention, the first dual-sequence model that simultaneously
processes the sequence of words and the chronological sequence of fixations.
The alignment of the two sequences is achieved by a cross-sequence attention
mechanism. We show that Eyettention outperforms state-of-the-art models in
predicting scanpaths. We provide an extensive within- and across-data set
evaluation on different languages. An ablation study and qualitative analysis
support an in-depth understanding of the model's behavior. | [
0.0292463806,
-0.617126286,
0.5567243695,
-0.0233622305,
-0.3992518485,
-0.245379746,
0.1170164421,
-0.8227670789,
-0.0715821683,
0.7606219649,
-0.761449039,
-0.2451240569,
-0.2287677974,
0.1870022416,
-0.3663498163,
0.5559550524,
-0.1769112051,
0.1441002339,
-0.0817725509,
-0.2301899791,
-0.3930038512,
-0.1589505821,
-0.5096634626,
-0.1250185519,
0.64693892,
0.2362333089,
0.6066334248,
0.8395235538,
0.8608841896,
0.1963998228,
0.074807927,
-0.1416047364,
-0.0743417293,
0.3204710484,
-0.1022203714,
-0.5170181394,
-0.1207330972,
-0.1935388595,
0.6115095019,
0.6255304813,
0.0278824121,
0.0621779673,
0.1483809501,
0.8506321907,
-0.346219629,
-0.0219840594,
0.070645541,
0.0268837996,
-0.5705404282,
-0.3500733674,
-0.378228575,
-0.3145168722,
0.5887022614,
-0.2874012887,
0.3916383684,
0.1425287127,
0.4070070088,
0.5934038758,
-0.4082356393,
-0.2956874073,
-0.443986088,
0.578964889,
-0.3565175831,
0.4990859926,
0.2250831574,
0.0645772815,
0.5592541695,
-0.2568690181,
-0.4052294791,
-0.2142073661,
0.0703858063,
0.2361146063,
0.308517009,
-0.1499987096,
0.3396997452,
0.0513188168,
-0.9197013974,
-0.0275095049,
-0.2479755282,
0.0643059835,
0.5219489336,
0.5260320902,
0.4499437511,
0.0603688881,
-0.6777393222,
-0.2334320694,
-0.2687830031,
0.4155911803,
0.2115544528,
0.1407400072,
0.0004871299,
0.708085835,
-0.1014823318,
0.7216452956,
0.2603575587,
0.256477356,
0.0766393393,
-0.5243312716,
0.0136057362,
0.2276704162,
0.5801531672,
0.5170305371,
0.4661298096,
-0.2872956395,
0.2333154678,
0.6353049874,
0.5176997185,
-0.4444002211,
-0.1227186248,
0.3271356821,
-0.2436268926,
-0.397534132,
-0.2085817754,
-1.067666769,
-0.4965760708,
-0.4010739326,
0.0680244714,
-0.4679816365,
0.0429104976,
0.4429945648,
0.1931319386,
0.3790341318,
0.2056515366,
-1.0002323389,
0.164753288,
0.34748438,
0.94015944,
-0.3038524389,
-0.6606739759,
-0.1055768132,
0.1701135933,
-0.2742303312,
1.0085823536,
-0.6510840058,
0.0273306649,
-0.0505576618,
-0.1097239852,
-0.2070119679,
-0.0621192195,
0.37079826,
-0.6923972368,
0.1364908963,
-0.0150533589,
-0.249485597,
-0.4094677567,
0.0469829887,
-0.5815984607,
0.9480809569,
-0.123420693,
-1.0862601995,
0.3669847548,
-0.6546115279,
-0.6518817544,
-0.0843163058,
0.2294141352,
-0.438198477,
0.0222148132,
0.0790387243,
0.133303985,
-0.131331712,
0.0647413582,
-0.2586683333,
-0.2619850636,
0.1200790629,
-0.2143389583,
0.9734222889,
-0.2051162273,
-0.4621396363,
0.06694258,
-0.3058730662,
-0.0909741223,
0.1348493099,
-0.1594244987,
-0.4843534529,
0.3059038222,
0.075877212,
0.4846245646,
0.1088167503,
-0.4062012434,
0.3902521431,
-0.3539187312,
-0.0003908253,
0.6284815669,
0.0836169049,
0.2975920737,
-0.358700037,
0.5142492652,
0.2339815646,
0.303819418,
-0.5989985466,
-0.2789655924,
-0.7784751058,
0.0806983337,
-0.2331028283,
1.2667371035,
-0.5862684846,
0.0803741887,
-0.0958986282,
-0.4041435122,
-0.4682339728,
-0.0688880235,
0.7117024064,
0.4078839123,
0.2970012426,
-0.5396543145,
-0.2293263525,
-0.4617038965,
-0.5620017052,
-0.0890823826,
0.4144560993,
0.4087377489,
0.0878934562,
-0.5448889732,
0.5207915902,
-0.6537732482,
-0.269752413,
0.1042872071,
0.2981516719,
0.0134026939,
0.1557073295,
0.3422783315,
-0.7772623897,
-0.6019609571,
-0.1303190142,
-0.7022967339,
-0.3812870681,
-0.2672634125,
-0.397578001,
0.3820593059,
0.6614207029,
-0.3683249354,
0.7851914167,
0.4220599532,
-0.6707492471,
0.5657017827,
0.0331065953,
0.0938508287,
-1.0010575056,
0.3255910873,
0.1681782454,
-0.12155018,
-0.6359890103,
-0.0282701477,
0.0957728401,
0.0587510802,
-0.2238642573,
0.5168017149,
-0.6612583995,
-0.1668158323,
-0.0842634737,
-0.1922917962,
-0.2134777308,
0.5692774057,
0.5159378052,
0.5835021138,
0.7685703635,
-0.6575536728,
0.3987896442,
0.4591326416,
-0.2710340023,
0.4850447178,
-0.4608314335,
0.0975764543,
0.0233701654,
-0.3438596129,
-1.0713573694,
0.0266376957,
0.3150160313,
-0.3434711397,
0.5447821617,
0.2063198537,
-0.2737042904,
-0.5463322997,
-0.2117222697,
0.5617699623,
0.2799006104,
-0.397397697,
0.3596006632,
0.3486895263,
-0.623363018,
-0.5470011234,
-0.6623516083,
0.1190891117,
-0.0607623048,
-0.7048151493,
-0.1103316769,
-0.3711737096,
-0.1079914048,
-0.0767656192,
0.0419121534,
0.1159936637,
-0.1879311353,
0.1702754945,
0.7141753435,
-0.1069347262,
0.0853866711,
-0.4113823771,
-0.3911247551,
-0.0076479097,
-0.3134529591,
0.3611056209,
0.0941334441,
-0.4216153026,
-0.4406541586,
0.5585204959,
0.7646752596,
-0.3516795933,
0.2585861683,
0.3226847649,
-0.1265770793,
-0.0434937552,
-0.3528694212,
-0.3349023163,
-0.4011407197,
0.3301043808,
-0.1646776646,
-0.634983778,
0.2509967387,
0.2189956456,
0.1036629155,
-0.0622273125,
0.6900647879,
-0.1761840731,
0.9737378955,
0.9248681068,
-0.0363570638,
0.8623481393,
0.1114595309,
0.3816274405,
-0.9676848054,
0.0401738621,
-0.2707167566,
-0.2042308748,
-0.3281542659,
-0.3852464557,
0.2477540523,
-0.2049627006,
0.0650334954,
0.3586065769,
-0.5346055031,
0.2414711118,
0.4205168784,
0.2218193263,
0.2448524237,
0.0944363549,
-0.6353134513,
0.0058266004,
-0.4112339914,
-0.4767420888,
1.025098443,
-0.0001867602,
0.9433809519,
-0.0712534264,
0.4756154418,
0.2971261144,
0.2339016497,
-0.8141780496,
0.3633534908,
-0.2333333045,
-0.5713029504,
-0.6619598269,
-0.0874679089,
-0.8222308159,
0.2339188457,
0.1274120957,
-0.8985874653,
0.3968348801,
0.3400950134,
-0.4466170371,
0.1584838182,
-0.6545313597,
1.0939911604,
-0.6569625735,
-0.8707375526,
0.0448004305,
-1.0056320429,
0.2990782261,
-0.2004997134,
0.0467376672,
0.0554807484,
-0.1605890393,
0.4009764194,
0.0487071387,
1.065772295,
0.2394642383,
0.2818423212,
0.1906867474,
0.175225094,
0.3821708858,
-0.361967802,
0.4538941681,
0.1328381002,
0.1130856946,
-0.245019868,
0.0273961779,
0.3951360881,
-0.3525228202,
-0.3848672211,
-1.0189585686,
-0.5210857391,
-0.3569636047,
0.5062112212,
0.4086827338,
0.4165689945,
-0.3137104213,
-0.4826208949,
0.8192770481,
0.2520231605,
0.6189019084,
0.8866339326,
-0.1668186039,
-0.1119607612,
0.4998177886,
-0.1717206985,
0.330720365,
0.5365992785,
0.0244894084,
-0.5659635663,
-0.4233499765,
-0.4080564678,
0.6239023805,
-0.2818176746,
0.3369204998,
-0.6925365329,
0.1277989298,
-0.6760966182,
-0.4199337363,
-0.0638956055,
0.0995260701,
-0.3074826598,
0.0299355108,
0.1471467614,
0.5790994167,
-0.02969536,
-0.1278835088,
-0.8729708791,
0.6244952679,
0.3937582076,
0.4659144878,
0.0474669822,
-0.3067977428,
-0.3345456421,
-0.2677978575,
-0.2837896943,
-1.0295398235,
0.6216833591,
-0.0045306832,
0.2395109683,
0.6216250062,
-0.0073587848,
0.534073472,
-0.8387037516,
0.4186702669,
0.240154162,
-0.6163570285,
0.4532950521,
-0.4543104768,
0.5952864289,
0.4596914947,
0.227528289,
-1.012868166,
-0.3390788138,
-0.3443658352,
-0.8532480001,
1.1250844002,
-0.2112285197,
-0.4728496969,
0.1927676648,
-0.0464894623,
0.0522188693,
-0.0912047327,
-0.4555219412,
0.1406406164,
0.0063947737,
-0.3426996469,
-0.6444852948,
-0.2103917599,
0.106775485,
0.0389588624,
0.4921577871,
-0.2247419804,
0.1411201358,
0.3964289129,
-0.329872787,
-0.6399499178,
-0.0467223227,
0.5192593932,
0.480589807,
-0.2720173001,
-0.0905248001,
-0.3518454731,
-1.0119775534,
-0.0200032536,
0.2020058632,
-0.4327426255,
-0.1136786193,
0.4002877772,
0.703968823,
0.3410362303,
-0.7165948749,
0.3550574481,
0.0939769894,
0.3056905866,
-0.309966594,
-0.0779372156,
0.1185760871,
0.4832535684,
-0.0471999347,
0.3032880723,
0.2534683049,
-0.3416271508,
0.3791792393,
0.1181871668,
-0.6070988178,
-0.2284911573,
0.6745733023,
0.0783473998,
-0.1994318664,
0.6022684574,
0.2591577768,
-0.7216501832,
0.7969785929,
0.3011651039,
1.3270069361,
-0.5557941794,
-0.0471290201,
0.4358917475,
0.510938108,
-0.0739923939,
0.5096516013,
-0.1869986504,
-0.6656377912,
-0.0015023339,
-0.7014697194,
-0.3084753752,
-0.6347083449,
-1.0044041872,
0.2426077724,
-0.0252476241,
-0.1943204254,
0.2183455229,
-0.161688149,
-0.5255538821,
0.1020134389,
0.3147269487,
0.8020408154,
-0.9930000305,
0.8013669848,
0.8718678355,
-0.3768797517,
-0.1865005791,
0.4760712683,
0.2152071297,
-0.8523752093,
0.2011603564,
0.5020759106,
-0.2232337296,
0.0988385007,
-0.1284578741,
-0.8469830751,
1.1095098257,
-0.3407726586,
-0.7359081507,
-0.2528638244,
0.0530260988,
0.5782656074,
-0.129688412,
-0.0147613473,
0.4798763692,
0.3277563155,
0.1273106337,
-0.6184105277,
-0.0945837349,
-0.1852247119,
-0.0252348129,
0.6478397846,
-0.8334199786,
0.6530315876,
-0.6641767621,
-0.4283184111,
0.0958552212,
0.0998134688,
-0.0548981875,
0.598004818,
0.223441273,
0.8976259828,
0.3749985993,
0.1491813958,
1.079325676,
-0.2821481824,
0.1526717693,
0.9081597328,
-0.6542161703,
0.9440945983,
0.5066577792,
-0.295689553,
0.2992848456,
0.6293420196,
0.2435201854,
0.7907038331,
-0.3611645997,
-0.087439537,
-0.3094225824,
0.2152070999,
-0.0000267554,
0.0207180195,
0.3363845348,
-0.3000021577,
-0.0415512174,
0.0169576928,
-0.2298618108,
-0.192002818,
-0.3916164637,
0.8709236979,
0.1526771784,
-1.0246121883,
0.1932769269,
-0.3992122412,
0.3877255321,
-0.6458294392,
0.1489717364,
-0.1077068001,
0.514135778,
0.2030243278,
-0.9079076052,
0.320320785,
0.0299056452,
-0.6896483302,
-0.2183694541,
0.3446091115,
-0.6368263364,
-0.5738153458,
0.5392265916,
0.0687594041,
0.0336223729,
0.0840490237,
-0.7905704379,
-0.2163959742,
0.0858434215,
-0.3453576863,
0.2019792348,
0.2652647197,
-0.295825541,
0.6169219613,
0.7612577677,
-0.0200641695,
0.5319244862,
-0.0501862615,
0.3567858934,
-0.9857257009,
-0.7927004099,
-0.7097796202,
0.5037016273,
0.2922450006,
-0.4674463868,
0.5025782585,
0.3112361431,
0.41126737,
-0.1833678931,
0.6287587881,
0.3362883627,
0.8510521054,
-0.4963433743,
0.3217234313,
-0.6110838056,
-0.2580597103,
-0.2156192064,
-0.8072202802,
-0.450262785,
0.4643367827,
-0.4290122986,
-0.1104965433,
1.1791695356,
0.7932595015,
-0.071347639,
-0.0497203656,
0.2543383539,
0.2392827123,
-0.3270667195,
0.9554967284,
0.5475428104,
-0.0814123377,
0.2983926833,
-0.2320826501,
-0.4182366133,
-0.7803655863,
-0.5918373466,
-0.8944035769,
-0.5565613508,
-0.323551029,
-0.1212698296,
0.1868947893,
0.0228365008,
0.4100742638,
-0.8609183431,
-0.2599502504,
-0.2123435736,
-0.1399207413,
-0.4792033732,
-0.2278177887,
0.4715353251,
-0.3199615777,
-0.4946126342,
-0.0605313294,
0.7202582359,
0.1457488537,
-0.2535577714,
0.1817758679,
-0.6799244881,
0.3778125942,
0.1776998788,
0.6379320621,
-0.7941660881,
0.0469526127,
0.3704936802,
-0.6063035727,
0.1379874051,
0.8862894773,
-0.5335757136,
0.8879934549,
0.6071428657,
0.4250847697,
0.4099966288,
0.0991409793,
0.2930198908,
-0.0301252194,
0.0389054455,
0.4205240607,
0.239650771,
0.3130334914,
-0.7324072123,
0.5736599565,
0.324447006,
-0.7062528729,
-0.5259009004,
0.5320243239,
-1.138728857,
-0.0456775613,
0.7925296426,
0.0250867549,
-0.5415747762,
-0.286624819,
-0.5201745033,
0.4378734529,
-0.1059517115,
0.8593952656,
0.8706433177,
-0.3610985279,
-0.4330778122,
-0.3606319726,
0.3020932078,
0.5164678693,
-0.6118483543,
0.3559313715,
0.6783048511,
0.0843589306,
0.3365627527,
0.4437998831,
-0.1895703226,
0.5640305877,
0.118626982,
0.1912880391,
-0.008593672,
-0.5084502101,
-0.5792056918,
-0.2631027102,
-0.2723723352,
-0.2963442504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10759v1 | GeoLayoutLM: Geometric Pre-training for Visual Information Extraction | 2023-04-21T06:02:14 | 2023-04-21T06:02:14 | Chuwei Luo, Changxu Cheng, Qi Zheng, Cong Yao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual information extraction (VIE) plays an important role in Document
Intelligence. Generally, it is divided into two tasks: semantic entity
recognition (SER) and relation extraction (RE). Recently, pre-trained models
for documents have achieved substantial progress in VIE, particularly in SER.
However, most of the existing models learn the geometric representation in an
implicit way, which has been found insufficient for the RE task since geometric
information is especially crucial for RE. Moreover, we reveal another factor
that limits the performance of RE lies in the objective gap between the
pre-training phase and the fine-tuning phase for RE. To tackle these issues, we
propose in this paper a multi-modal framework, named GeoLayoutLM, for VIE.
GeoLayoutLM explicitly models the geometric relations in pre-training, which we
call geometric pre-training. Geometric pre-training is achieved by three
specially designed geometry-related pre-training tasks. Additionally, novel
relation heads, which are pre-trained by the geometric pre-training tasks and
fine-tuned for RE, are elaborately designed to enrich and enhance the feature
representation. According to extensive experiments on standard VIE benchmarks,
GeoLayoutLM achieves highly competitive scores in the SER task and
significantly outperforms the previous state-of-the-arts for RE (\eg, the F1
score of RE on FUNSD is boosted from 80.35\% to 89.45\%). The code and models
are publicly available at
https://github.com/AlibabaResearch/AdvancedLiterateMachinery/tree/main/DocumentUnderstanding/GeoLayoutLM | [
-0.6872637868,
-0.9336845875,
0.6068694592,
-0.0124266995,
-0.3904260397,
-0.3842183053,
-0.0029615106,
-0.4232273698,
0.1203211248,
0.6602212191,
-0.6115474105,
-0.7558448315,
-0.7307557464,
-0.3099691272,
-0.1306948066,
0.8422384858,
-0.2494396418,
-0.0013226024,
-0.4601519108,
-0.0838809684,
-0.3600408137,
-0.5131552219,
0.0052459813,
-0.0172681808,
0.4021992087,
0.102676563,
0.4842863083,
0.5458609462,
0.581757009,
0.4039937854,
0.2802399397,
0.2445308715,
-0.6677628756,
-0.116869159,
-0.0547515564,
-0.5093703866,
-0.6085330248,
0.2713775337,
0.6510870457,
0.5249960423,
0.0322761387,
0.3514036238,
0.3676487505,
0.7653762102,
-0.7779006958,
0.7894668579,
-0.4040525258,
-0.0249983296,
-0.468793273,
-0.2834902406,
-0.1347584873,
-0.4872356057,
0.5752335191,
-1.3117970228,
0.2875162065,
0.2283174843,
1.2873499393,
0.382422477,
-0.061434228,
-0.0136154676,
-0.2766245902,
0.5718169212,
-0.2560201585,
0.7636675239,
0.3973285258,
0.3266461194,
-0.2243009955,
-0.8747783303,
-0.1986011863,
-0.1230154186,
-0.3129433692,
0.2166425437,
0.0187812652,
0.1016802713,
0.490198493,
0.4294930696,
-0.7803584337,
-0.3098292053,
-0.4816168249,
-0.2437520623,
0.453158617,
-0.0745116025,
0.4213114083,
-0.5196857452,
-0.4703463912,
-0.0620786883,
-0.8134840131,
0.2463501245,
0.3354953527,
0.0655566975,
-0.1855918467,
0.4896135628,
-0.1992517263,
0.7086589932,
-0.0960148051,
-0.1636624634,
0.2175353467,
-0.0877185985,
-0.5396994948,
-0.2451186627,
0.5634212494,
0.1105624735,
0.2826461792,
0.1225949898,
0.0646956265,
-0.0848179609,
0.3974092007,
-0.85667032,
-0.6118739247,
-0.3765050769,
-0.7668240666,
-0.0061575305,
0.3379789889,
-1.0502631664,
-0.1144626513,
-0.6869245768,
0.4676284492,
-0.508425951,
-0.1505339444,
0.0346627757,
-0.008837047,
0.1626803875,
0.7594608068,
-0.4910075963,
-0.0858628601,
0.5697271228,
0.7794041038,
0.0102246776,
-0.3524156511,
-0.7038717866,
0.2511130571,
-0.0484465994,
0.9070607424,
-0.6614590287,
-0.5538888574,
0.0494938977,
0.180383727,
-0.3267792761,
-0.3385919333,
0.3887784779,
-0.5493175983,
0.7409564257,
-0.3065253496,
-0.29505831,
-0.6758310795,
0.2793593407,
-1.0088313818,
0.8549628258,
0.305428952,
-0.9049482346,
0.5456677079,
-0.5551587343,
-0.1078786254,
0.1221400797,
-0.5368837714,
-0.6250548959,
0.1186444536,
0.6961691976,
0.2426550686,
-0.3207169175,
-0.0128440112,
-0.7153154612,
-0.1538209617,
-0.3869190216,
-0.2058591545,
0.5515781641,
0.0723451972,
-0.186563313,
0.2096991837,
-0.6103530526,
0.1362270415,
0.0065205204,
-0.3045027554,
-0.359278053,
-0.2634261847,
0.0428592153,
0.2592818737,
0.3463917375,
-0.3474185765,
0.1188883111,
-0.3133126795,
-0.1112234965,
0.6112827063,
-0.0144099472,
0.5739185214,
-0.0018156841,
0.7213234901,
-0.2979389727,
0.1726912856,
-0.230261609,
-0.2918043435,
-0.4678721726,
-0.7969623804,
0.2055799365,
0.4720475376,
-0.9510937333,
0.3685055375,
-0.4330005646,
-0.3915849924,
-0.2144462466,
0.1515643597,
0.5661851764,
0.712870419,
0.3807969689,
-0.5802932382,
-0.2967343926,
-0.8143526912,
-0.2217925489,
0.0599263646,
-0.0805668458,
0.4423416257,
0.2489693463,
0.0789549425,
1.0784888268,
-0.9054534435,
-0.7514454722,
-0.1840504259,
0.4282842875,
0.0433830433,
0.3819029033,
0.8728216887,
-0.9170768857,
-0.3210791051,
-0.0921162069,
-1.054489851,
-0.0019098679,
0.2303620279,
-0.3257772326,
-0.1097010002,
0.4136679471,
-0.6570929289,
1.0023050308,
0.2796678245,
-0.0853833109,
0.5198020935,
-0.3187294006,
0.1764151454,
-0.8136098981,
0.1141234413,
0.1242161915,
-0.2482042015,
-0.3400563002,
-0.0419522449,
-0.0894946903,
-0.5595840812,
-0.379734993,
0.4806156754,
-0.7380058765,
-0.2650061846,
-0.0764677376,
0.1145956218,
0.3234526217,
0.8382073045,
0.1642692536,
0.6286908984,
0.6231181026,
-0.4641642272,
0.3022249341,
0.3353124857,
-0.5160052776,
0.7933622599,
-0.4978663921,
-0.1256857216,
-0.3516935706,
0.3664403856,
-0.8369725943,
-0.310287267,
0.3902809322,
-0.1810712069,
0.494030714,
-0.4165996015,
-0.2264958471,
-0.1917570531,
-0.3148608804,
0.4037970006,
0.0698927715,
-0.5978571773,
1.135430932,
0.4977707565,
-0.3676286638,
-0.3498466015,
-0.1207684502,
-0.4875025451,
-0.4167543948,
-0.8211220503,
0.2720627487,
0.4706955254,
0.3061814904,
0.3260088563,
-0.1259824634,
-0.2037406713,
-0.1334033161,
0.4733878076,
0.4053841829,
-0.2760086358,
0.0438671932,
-0.2069752216,
-0.4455673695,
-0.0153737403,
-0.3601947725,
0.4693407416,
-0.2381354123,
-0.6809266806,
-0.5774316788,
0.4044809639,
0.474581033,
-0.7101231813,
0.1871563494,
0.8410634398,
-0.4427420199,
0.2541006505,
-0.5034098625,
0.2601766586,
-0.4382955432,
0.8085908294,
-0.7188897133,
-0.5974233747,
0.3639495373,
-0.5863824487,
-0.0003497587,
0.4849799871,
0.111940898,
-0.004629727,
0.9709429145,
0.9448770285,
-0.0718810037,
0.8010559678,
-0.4737458825,
0.0858215168,
-0.9769646525,
-0.4066404104,
-0.4324308038,
-0.1881673634,
-0.4297651052,
-0.2701488137,
0.6496167779,
0.42004776,
-0.0874450877,
0.2182906866,
-0.2676402926,
0.2305986881,
0.6210724115,
0.1485148519,
-0.0114555871,
0.3139943779,
-0.0586723126,
-0.3038864732,
-0.5222045183,
-0.49231264,
0.9882430434,
0.2571218014,
1.0735827684,
-0.0738261715,
0.5372053385,
-0.0627419651,
0.1687374115,
-0.488396883,
0.4206252396,
-0.1680555493,
-0.2458098233,
-0.3815153837,
-0.374691546,
-0.8714772463,
0.453438133,
-0.2951527536,
-0.9912366867,
0.2235837132,
0.2106907666,
-0.3400031626,
0.2480141968,
-0.7361164689,
1.1277772188,
-0.5155009031,
-0.3598460853,
-0.1176147684,
-0.5396399498,
0.2547342777,
0.0501641482,
0.0053789946,
-0.1849758327,
0.4009916484,
0.4901862741,
-0.2638010383,
0.4871915579,
-0.5258566141,
0.0291675217,
0.1186646596,
0.1409739554,
0.3638365269,
0.4196350276,
0.3779081702,
0.3423910737,
-0.0314153731,
-0.2204853743,
-0.7980776429,
0.4452098906,
-0.8173244596,
-0.6657569408,
-0.2236694247,
-0.4989746213,
-0.0278003309,
0.3870718777,
0.6270564198,
0.843827486,
-0.3190261424,
0.1104037464,
0.6147871017,
-0.2659726739,
0.2361752093,
-0.1924292743,
-0.5528933406,
-0.6137046814,
1.048905015,
0.1455783099,
-0.11919453,
0.4931324124,
-0.1563069224,
-0.5845890641,
-0.1495278925,
-0.6668797731,
0.1570212841,
-0.624919951,
-0.0822324157,
-0.5468549728,
-0.2772940397,
-0.2244196385,
-0.1907237172,
-0.3239762783,
-0.2567077577,
-0.3794980049,
0.2037096918,
-0.083549425,
0.6945886612,
0.1074608192,
0.3751998842,
-0.8134360909,
0.4054580927,
0.5318344831,
0.3423977494,
-0.2882764339,
-0.1841093004,
-0.0743108243,
-0.1825631112,
-0.3333972692,
-0.6539398432,
0.3272129893,
0.087799117,
0.8010792732,
0.5750959516,
-0.5067508221,
1.0256829262,
-0.540145576,
0.5185896158,
0.3220000565,
-0.7215374708,
0.6557109356,
-0.2780489028,
0.2098696232,
0.4971884489,
0.3004745543,
0.0063953614,
0.1453797966,
-0.6495348215,
-0.6663476229,
0.8019929528,
0.0486440994,
-0.3307144344,
0.6041697264,
0.1944275796,
0.0209031533,
0.3353747427,
-0.571415782,
0.0450596809,
-0.57840693,
-0.1573656201,
0.0919864178,
-0.2984478474,
-0.2068240941,
-0.1964250952,
0.5117212534,
-0.1075208858,
0.3020867109,
0.2462619394,
-0.6203598976,
0.1657499075,
-0.0942869112,
0.5320803523,
1.076411128,
-0.207107529,
-0.0253520347,
0.0085122185,
-0.5354213715,
-0.1567937136,
0.7153066397,
-0.0574269667,
0.0621253401,
0.690476656,
0.911611557,
0.1925087273,
-0.0480420217,
0.6764906645,
-0.295193404,
-0.2051845938,
-0.2256041765,
-0.0526135042,
-0.4368752241,
0.3148134053,
0.1829649657,
-0.0386266224,
0.1921195835,
-0.1557725221,
0.4086101055,
0.5873821378,
-0.5434670448,
-0.4555345178,
0.7234793305,
0.2386485189,
0.0123760235,
0.5349423885,
-0.1392594725,
-0.6880602837,
0.2868569195,
0.1133852229,
0.8177273273,
-0.1616505682,
0.1671950966,
0.3538099527,
0.1259883493,
0.4176386893,
0.1919084489,
-0.224805966,
-0.2209933698,
-0.3776915073,
-0.6829328537,
0.1698184311,
0.1239700988,
-0.6443824768,
0.4581204653,
-0.3248223662,
-0.0069955112,
-0.4079236686,
0.1834505647,
-1.0996155739,
0.2114703655,
0.1805856228,
0.6122291088,
-0.621514976,
0.66955024,
0.8497934937,
-0.467339009,
-0.7577470541,
-0.0708713382,
0.2305037379,
-0.6797773242,
0.8008403182,
0.4332624674,
-0.1929199249,
-0.0702499226,
-0.2686989903,
-1.0824956894,
1.0550284386,
0.4485932589,
-0.3504376709,
-0.3212740421,
0.0595121905,
0.1234721839,
-0.4994338155,
0.2634661198,
0.2700258791,
0.3750008345,
0.1886192113,
-0.7864983082,
-0.0921384022,
-0.2346770167,
0.1974038184,
0.3084769547,
-0.3140565157,
0.8996420503,
0.0815975666,
-0.3617616892,
0.0759627447,
0.6658834219,
0.2542845309,
0.0493442863,
0.8461259007,
0.902376771,
0.7659775615,
-0.4302971959,
0.9790751338,
-0.0729394034,
0.4093264341,
1.2522655725,
-0.1400112063,
0.3056688309,
0.1555544436,
0.0878193751,
0.5447701812,
0.7381900549,
0.1909579039,
0.8919482231,
0.0166298021,
0.1176797599,
-0.3613604903,
0.0385973863,
-0.8467397094,
0.7084271312,
0.3652788401,
-0.0776703283,
-0.7221841216,
0.0485395603,
0.0116581852,
-0.2367236614,
-0.2970941663,
0.774076879,
0.0159903634,
-0.3788062632,
0.1542048007,
-0.3453995883,
0.0978918448,
-0.7812255621,
-0.305508554,
0.0451972149,
0.1373019964,
-0.1038012281,
-0.4457847774,
-0.0515754409,
-0.3571384847,
-0.1492582858,
-0.0411801562,
0.8537912369,
-0.5695405006,
-0.4702658653,
0.203710258,
0.6459134221,
-0.1422590464,
-0.3187664449,
-0.695074439,
-0.0173954219,
-0.0913802609,
-0.3324884176,
0.2010473907,
0.7346684337,
-0.2308220416,
0.2552562356,
0.8653466702,
0.2494658083,
0.1226241663,
0.0283710659,
1.1195104122,
-0.4008184373,
-0.871863842,
-0.6636911035,
0.547834754,
-0.5017225146,
-0.2912592888,
0.593185544,
0.5677014589,
0.7870426178,
-0.0459619351,
0.6175652742,
0.0911571532,
0.3087450862,
-0.8064931631,
0.6660359502,
-0.6651382446,
-0.0996715203,
-0.5993100405,
-1.3483752012,
-0.3900428414,
0.6885422468,
-0.6248848438,
-0.1248534396,
0.826200068,
0.6010524631,
-0.3198580146,
0.0491187349,
0.0802078545,
-0.3449521661,
0.7621062398,
0.5204963088,
0.9583219886,
-0.1165574938,
0.6096997261,
-0.1686370373,
-0.4497466385,
-0.0672085062,
-0.8512094021,
-0.9394920468,
-0.5886152387,
-0.0261792727,
0.0756504014,
-0.1559402198,
0.4036816061,
1.1939481497,
-0.309800446,
0.0961360633,
0.0918297619,
0.1712394059,
0.1044159383,
-0.185357064,
0.8760626912,
-0.4316972494,
-0.641032815,
0.0301981531,
0.6892644167,
0.0394742563,
-0.2137726992,
0.088833414,
-0.158899352,
-0.5479682684,
0.5664607882,
0.2242298871,
-0.6855491996,
-0.5301364064,
-0.367952615,
0.0633336827,
0.1493514627,
0.931999743,
-0.7021259069,
0.6963864565,
0.615347147,
0.7817421556,
0.6502190232,
0.4744270146,
0.6147955656,
-0.7666397691,
0.5301440954,
-0.2357577384,
0.6513220668,
0.1903876513,
-0.4247846305,
0.5429404974,
0.3419265449,
-0.4259895682,
-0.377967298,
0.4156831205,
-0.7032286525,
-0.0014682059,
0.6547748446,
-0.4286385775,
-0.3519080281,
-0.0016012012,
-0.4641309381,
0.2020089477,
-0.0351276286,
0.5730760098,
0.6698808074,
-0.2434425652,
-0.0694366619,
-0.4997194707,
0.7028177381,
0.2409926653,
-1.0714720488,
-0.2792895436,
0.7573939562,
0.0666061863,
0.4399473667,
0.6253160834,
-0.3123925924,
0.3586466014,
-0.3745404184,
-0.0053451164,
-0.3056578934,
-0.7969955802,
-0.091925621,
0.4192758501,
-0.2618711293,
-0.6044166088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10750v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10750v2 | Improving Grounded Language Understanding in a Collaborative Environment by Interacting with Agents Through Help Feedback | 2023-04-21T05:37:59 | 2024-02-05T21:25:33 | Nikhil Mehta, Milagro Teruel, Patricio Figueroa Sanz, Xin Deng, Ahmed Hassan Awadallah, Julia Kiseleva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many approaches to Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks often treat them
as single-step problems, where an agent receives an instruction, executes it,
and is evaluated based on the final outcome. However, human language is
inherently interactive, as evidenced by the back-and-forth nature of human
conversations. In light of this, we posit that human-AI collaboration should
also be interactive, with humans monitoring the work of AI agents and providing
feedback that the agent can understand and utilize. Further, the AI agent
should be able to detect when it needs additional information and proactively
ask for help. Enabling this scenario would lead to more natural, efficient, and
engaging human-AI collaborations.
In this work, we explore these directions using the challenging task defined
by the IGLU competition, an interactive grounded language understanding task in
a MineCraft-like world. We explore multiple types of help players can give to
the AI to guide it and analyze the impact of this help in AI behavior,
resulting in performance improvements. | [
-0.5053595304,
-0.886346519,
0.6645532846,
0.4384891391,
-0.0450370982,
0.338252604,
-0.6195725203,
-0.6064757109,
0.0535112545,
0.4014378786,
-0.770962894,
-0.4546161294,
-0.5326491594,
0.136992991,
0.1558793038,
1.0054568052,
0.1667235196,
-0.1097003967,
-0.6740330458,
-0.2780954838,
-0.8044227362,
-0.5328190923,
-0.9722031951,
-0.6242656708,
0.3831854761,
0.744549036,
1.0667331219,
0.4012631476,
0.5225356817,
0.4779839218,
-0.1858115047,
0.1443152726,
-0.293047905,
0.3134396672,
-0.3940210938,
-0.4470836222,
-0.4198841453,
0.2017361224,
0.3498007655,
0.6960740089,
-0.1692268103,
0.0837659761,
0.2459585816,
0.5489340425,
-0.2349247336,
0.5843160152,
-0.2770489454,
0.1199449301,
0.1219921708,
-0.0788057446,
-0.3094280362,
-0.1106966883,
0.1170602441,
-0.9876722693,
0.2113932669,
0.2017661333,
0.4895934761,
0.7616043687,
0.0338497758,
-0.3988440931,
-0.6479712725,
0.6641305685,
-0.7291474342,
0.2604734004,
0.6987916231,
0.094549939,
-0.5388628244,
-0.3469800353,
-0.6590544581,
-0.6861765385,
-0.1378682107,
0.4064262509,
-0.0441821478,
0.3681943417,
0.2498082072,
0.1750284582,
-0.1914699227,
0.0641033053,
-0.0662149563,
0.0596748814,
0.8078145981,
-0.0668630376,
0.6705194712,
0.0647407696,
0.0385107286,
-0.0239869114,
-0.0896387175,
0.2795594931,
0.1962107122,
0.2384496331,
-0.0945208594,
0.4493918419,
-0.230119139,
0.7963068485,
0.206835568,
-0.0445276797,
-0.0293633416,
-0.3965990543,
-0.0733844936,
0.0708359778,
0.3360334039,
0.4116809666,
0.1306713223,
-0.4755649567,
0.1208760068,
0.100429818,
0.5725301504,
-0.3603194058,
-0.1366387308,
0.2975701094,
-0.4326428473,
-0.3065615296,
0.1469817609,
-0.5240774751,
-0.6697201729,
-0.6479851604,
0.2936716676,
-0.2938296497,
-0.6037612557,
-0.04011935,
-0.2449343055,
0.2621538043,
0.688970685,
-0.9297050238,
0.7705231905,
1.0230945349,
0.5963825583,
0.0185866263,
-0.4633783102,
-1.1421062946,
-0.0213961843,
0.1749750525,
0.5370079279,
-0.4372555912,
-0.3459203839,
-0.3408288658,
-0.1606317312,
-0.1263829172,
-0.581684649,
0.5109291673,
-0.1998966783,
0.4627895057,
-0.2095248103,
-0.4843232036,
-0.2813860178,
0.6319292784,
-0.4401159585,
0.9723739028,
0.0185578801,
-0.806669414,
0.2246296406,
-0.8472432494,
-0.2846242189,
0.4630317986,
-0.3498266935,
-0.1859649122,
0.294934392,
0.273139745,
0.1654558778,
-0.2715936899,
0.1770046353,
-0.1104866341,
-0.4278968871,
-0.0296067819,
0.0598857887,
0.6086759567,
-0.2153921872,
-0.9087488651,
0.5509800315,
-0.7917258739,
0.1944915354,
0.0992700756,
-0.281606108,
-0.300444454,
0.2532345355,
0.0194766652,
0.122186929,
-0.0936177149,
-0.2432643771,
0.4413970709,
-0.2513513863,
-0.0439615212,
0.7013400197,
-0.0335365646,
0.4555762708,
-0.2512896061,
0.7224829793,
-0.3866858482,
0.214568615,
-0.0399181657,
-0.8144518137,
-0.734621644,
-0.2004804909,
0.0219730362,
0.555157423,
-0.847666502,
0.5579099655,
0.009460235,
-0.2886082828,
-0.9449293613,
0.2357391864,
0.4239369929,
0.5390664935,
0.4160139263,
-0.353802681,
-0.3341429234,
-0.469892025,
-0.2371385694,
-0.6124708652,
-0.1460817009,
0.5665279627,
0.1877728403,
-0.3080569208,
1.2109560966,
-0.1778597534,
-0.4909657836,
-0.3366806507,
0.2828939259,
0.0728402734,
0.6421555281,
0.314675957,
-0.7920562625,
-0.5868039131,
0.2532781363,
-0.9420651793,
-0.2782476246,
-0.102968961,
0.0385029353,
-0.1135142967,
0.6973577738,
-0.3302069604,
0.4251291454,
0.6685050726,
-0.6812548637,
0.1645005941,
-0.3821677864,
0.2155453414,
-0.760830164,
-0.0655966327,
-0.4221802056,
-0.3758989573,
-0.6597143412,
0.3292089105,
-0.5001341701,
-0.0073776459,
-0.1235415637,
0.408833921,
-0.6017045379,
0.1041569412,
-0.3246565461,
0.5230451226,
-0.2068280578,
0.4662284553,
0.227124989,
0.7851604223,
0.4083133936,
-0.3078351915,
0.5868761539,
0.2670794427,
-0.0030257755,
0.7374368906,
-0.7275056243,
0.6121346951,
-0.3129079938,
0.108213447,
-0.7816123366,
-0.2266089022,
0.4132880569,
-0.6372935176,
0.0730012283,
-0.3924038708,
-0.5549890995,
-0.0955291018,
-0.0968002155,
0.2324419767,
0.30356282,
-0.5230615735,
0.6911638975,
0.3208834827,
-0.0575188026,
-0.3868629336,
-0.3345062733,
0.2362289429,
-0.1098701209,
-0.9586242437,
0.1329003274,
-0.366135478,
-0.8750414848,
0.2409703583,
0.1744897515,
-0.0126393875,
0.6415426731,
0.6705421209,
-0.242036432,
-0.0938313156,
0.104302533,
-0.1927539855,
-0.322352767,
0.1506447196,
-0.3481915295,
0.3602602482,
-0.713635385,
-0.5267278552,
-0.4932475388,
0.5332065821,
0.5039041042,
-0.1971361339,
1.0129524469,
0.7084129453,
-0.3329091072,
0.0411590002,
-0.5017331839,
-0.1869795769,
-0.4495511651,
-0.0480682999,
-0.1886498183,
-0.8671806455,
0.4685876966,
-0.2467234284,
0.0178402066,
0.187349841,
0.5039454699,
-0.23352319,
1.1511418819,
0.8786804676,
-0.1476442069,
0.4020260572,
-0.0544583499,
0.0517622083,
-0.5173658133,
-0.3923821449,
-0.4739363492,
-0.188977778,
-0.2570485473,
-0.4229863882,
0.2878544927,
0.3176057339,
0.3421511352,
0.0998201072,
-0.392226547,
0.6355247498,
0.8252148628,
0.0288243443,
0.3803347945,
-0.3329870105,
-0.28222242,
-0.2216133773,
-0.6928961277,
-0.4138627052,
0.2581466138,
0.2260616273,
0.3287332356,
0.3329857886,
0.888964057,
0.352021277,
0.454510361,
-1.0064542294,
0.4030905962,
0.5794870257,
-0.1909098029,
-0.2693303227,
-0.1436759531,
-0.9477492571,
0.3407644629,
-0.3615043461,
-0.6354398131,
-0.5106034279,
0.1787080169,
-0.0979242399,
0.0472296998,
-0.7553902268,
0.7333790064,
-0.0947314575,
-0.5599344969,
-0.4295717478,
-0.8172441721,
-0.1487331241,
0.437964946,
0.627987504,
0.0222435817,
0.4148765504,
0.3601384759,
-0.6003594398,
0.8871899247,
-0.3920105398,
-0.1011215448,
0.2981791198,
0.0506721623,
0.3362387717,
0.3753505647,
-0.1996769607,
-0.1214262396,
-0.3010693789,
-0.4627173841,
-0.8111097813,
0.5238696933,
-0.76648283,
-1.0065689087,
-0.4716135859,
-0.5943529606,
-0.1926679164,
0.1597999483,
0.0701695904,
0.0635298938,
-0.2766903341,
0.2094205916,
0.3222966492,
-0.0099524194,
0.5084856749,
0.4151413143,
-0.196334973,
-0.1629699767,
0.7088837624,
-0.2289209217,
0.1230025068,
0.0458998531,
0.3618335724,
-0.0200603604,
-0.4609780014,
-0.5841332674,
0.0638052821,
-0.6935845017,
0.1458107084,
-0.4811445475,
-0.0246492475,
-0.1988988072,
-0.3750409186,
-0.1758641154,
-0.1489226967,
-0.446074307,
-0.2210343033,
0.3997664154,
1.0334556103,
-0.2465194017,
0.2504628301,
-1.1597084999,
0.1016371101,
0.398842454,
0.432905972,
0.1948117316,
-0.0705125183,
-0.2880700529,
0.0053084474,
-0.0044260644,
-0.8614105582,
0.0972934067,
0.0721578673,
0.722307682,
0.1241846606,
0.0866517052,
0.5420374274,
-0.4837281704,
0.9815027118,
-0.0844066069,
-1.167452693,
0.6971611977,
-0.3561261296,
0.4384607673,
0.9052509665,
-0.0385104604,
-0.9896000624,
-0.6192503572,
-0.8460214138,
-0.7527984381,
0.8944340348,
0.620900929,
-0.0509862006,
0.1596500129,
0.3420138657,
-0.0366479717,
0.2907571793,
-0.6895082593,
-0.1624806523,
-0.0257026888,
-0.1481337249,
0.0218755584,
0.0523439348,
-0.3541299999,
-0.2213213444,
0.5040618777,
-0.3213200271,
-0.0532577857,
0.3423576951,
-0.3483649194,
-0.2337804735,
0.3249561787,
0.5608997941,
0.4885364473,
-0.1282832175,
0.2073893547,
0.2002737224,
-0.4836865366,
-0.0276749842,
-0.0638989732,
0.1258561313,
-0.1240127981,
0.7109541297,
0.6775384545,
-0.1028345302,
-0.7792811394,
0.4913676381,
-0.4765611589,
-0.0378206484,
-0.1922644079,
0.2742234766,
0.0895494744,
0.4161455929,
0.2735826671,
0.10084299,
0.0948345736,
-0.6560835838,
0.148852706,
0.3102692664,
-0.7435647845,
-0.442908138,
0.533287406,
0.4687997103,
-0.9542089701,
0.8201784492,
-0.3483636081,
-0.8655642271,
0.6860232353,
0.5199018717,
0.9456665516,
0.0123035358,
0.2836026251,
0.0012380307,
0.3566140532,
0.1888361722,
0.2856561542,
-0.4731529951,
-0.6155216098,
-0.3995217085,
-0.049991902,
-0.8786594868,
-0.1733566076,
-0.6957083941,
-0.0812660754,
-0.6081123352,
0.0640616417,
-0.1601293534,
0.0526019,
-0.6669538617,
0.1303446144,
0.1970264465,
0.4229417443,
-0.7525744438,
0.5968258977,
0.9908312559,
-0.5369932055,
-0.6176955104,
0.3246626854,
0.1008915976,
-0.3904224336,
0.6486719251,
0.3275171816,
-0.447096318,
0.0807014257,
-0.7631955147,
-0.7120449543,
0.8024820089,
0.1187919229,
-0.0847360492,
0.2163681239,
-0.1197707951,
1.0183207989,
-0.0582953654,
0.3537990451,
0.4950668812,
0.6063942909,
-0.1746666431,
-1.1586681604,
0.0292436909,
-0.6830359697,
-0.2191013247,
-0.0302111972,
-0.7578191161,
0.2524042726,
-0.3072487116,
-0.0470865779,
-0.1712569445,
0.8423745036,
0.2875237465,
0.6199877262,
0.9057479501,
0.2377640903,
0.8957455158,
0.0007625578,
1.1038268805,
0.0031623016,
0.2830255032,
1.1814084053,
-0.1649208516,
0.6936470866,
0.674449861,
0.0612567365,
0.4472945631,
0.3604543507,
0.1584419012,
0.2242625058,
0.3808404803,
-0.510335803,
-0.2507480085,
-0.5899347663,
-0.2719661295,
0.462787658,
0.4844468236,
0.1857705563,
0.0037246847,
0.1473048925,
0.1734506935,
0.5398879647,
-0.1448305547,
1.1509054899,
-0.1747997552,
-1.0471596718,
0.2681140304,
0.0381324664,
0.548247993,
-0.2268496454,
-0.5027185082,
-0.0563829578,
0.175546214,
-0.4449382126,
-0.6638987064,
0.4111474156,
-0.0416673832,
-0.2584036589,
-0.2666028738,
0.6316739321,
-0.5761777163,
-0.0494714677,
0.6999087334,
0.4301144183,
-0.0258080941,
-0.2579349875,
-0.6874676943,
0.1442692876,
-0.0804232582,
-0.0185240805,
0.1706087887,
0.1301010251,
-0.170919165,
0.6780873537,
0.7873467207,
-0.1677942276,
0.0950480253,
0.1975374073,
0.9050478935,
-0.5128999949,
-0.6144585609,
-0.6696817279,
0.6252841949,
-0.2814778686,
0.0151407244,
0.8416429162,
0.0597416572,
0.7484446168,
-0.017610373,
0.8108397126,
-0.1635193378,
0.2200122178,
-0.4969688356,
0.5427078009,
-0.4556880891,
0.1200978085,
-0.3712549508,
-0.8518759608,
-0.4179298878,
0.8587547541,
0.1837137043,
-0.1687652469,
0.5135173798,
0.1279318631,
0.0343970731,
0.1818046421,
0.1801822335,
0.1427833885,
0.6729995012,
0.1005650312,
1.0109913349,
-0.0858770981,
0.141260922,
-0.3324908912,
-0.375418365,
-0.1747999936,
-1.1004892588,
-0.9148595929,
-0.4224743247,
-0.4088791013,
-0.5609825253,
-0.0324798711,
1.5652523041,
0.654946208,
-0.8379725218,
-0.3359715641,
-0.3470443487,
0.386067152,
-0.477532208,
-0.2523275614,
0.1437901407,
-0.4843350947,
-1.017873168,
0.9771604538,
0.4739632607,
-0.1880011559,
-0.0772879422,
-0.1004928276,
-0.1632959992,
-0.1955893785,
0.4952818751,
0.368848443,
-0.8683222532,
-0.4551925361,
0.1110268831,
0.1554177701,
-0.0260961037,
0.8726121783,
-0.7935619354,
0.8786110878,
0.4769643247,
1.0252394676,
0.2789398432,
0.2129946798,
0.95315063,
-1.0105823278,
0.4572862685,
0.2824111581,
0.149601832,
0.4046397209,
-0.7028952241,
0.7864503264,
0.2834494114,
-0.5539659262,
-0.5101492405,
-0.044213865,
-0.870182693,
-0.0018383184,
1.0697796345,
-0.3302522004,
0.1077471152,
-0.4608699977,
-0.8312826753,
0.2244736552,
-0.3150703907,
0.7430235744,
1.059730649,
-0.2690401673,
-0.2770572305,
-0.235209018,
0.6955670118,
0.7638923526,
-1.0599781275,
-0.1639409065,
0.4584402442,
-0.1332740486,
0.3254303634,
0.8111723065,
0.4761393368,
0.1640141606,
-0.1657269597,
-0.0905121416,
-0.0331036225,
-0.3869923949,
-0.5681357384,
0.0376028381,
0.3923885822,
-0.1443409324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10739v1 | KitchenScale: Learning to predict ingredient quantities from recipe contexts | 2023-04-21T04:28:16 | 2023-04-21T04:28:16 | Donghee Choi, Mogan Gim, Samy Badreddine, Hajung Kim, Donghyeon Park, Jaewoo Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NA, math.NA, H.4.m | Determining proper quantities for ingredients is an essential part of cooking
practice from the perspective of enriching tastiness and promoting healthiness.
We introduce KitchenScale, a fine-tuned Pre-trained Language Model (PLM) that
predicts a target ingredient's quantity and measurement unit given its recipe
context. To effectively train our KitchenScale model, we formulate an
ingredient quantity prediction task that consists of three sub-tasks which are
ingredient measurement type classification, unit classification, and quantity
regression task. Furthermore, we utilized transfer learning of cooking
knowledge from recipe texts to PLMs. We adopted the Discrete Latent Exponent
(DExp) method to cope with high variance of numerical scales in recipe corpora.
Experiments with our newly constructed dataset and recommendation examples
demonstrate KitchenScale's understanding of various recipe contexts and
generalizability in predicting ingredient quantities. We implemented a web
application for KitchenScale to demonstrate its functionality in recommending
ingredient quantities expressed in numerals (e.g., 2) with units (e.g., ounce). | [
-0.28798002,
-0.370721519,
0.4064288139,
0.1985555738,
0.0185460933,
-0.2649951875,
0.1268362105,
-0.2705206871,
0.2576922476,
0.8557622433,
-0.5434185863,
-0.3758379221,
-0.5414215326,
0.0522822998,
0.0211503189,
0.7818297744,
-0.2206479013,
0.6178774238,
-0.4760373831,
0.0011308531,
-0.755535543,
-0.3850567043,
-0.4167639315,
-0.1906685829,
0.6387358308,
0.7230772972,
0.5001500249,
0.4693264961,
0.6138270497,
0.2257107794,
0.5230365396,
0.455610007,
-0.2516642213,
0.4131221473,
-0.2358122021,
-0.6792346239,
-0.7473757267,
0.3475506902,
-0.1224026456,
0.9242034554,
0.0089611216,
0.2408551127,
0.0583731495,
0.7293994427,
-0.8875675797,
0.4640436172,
-0.4862189293,
0.2210569233,
0.3348877728,
-0.1629669368,
-0.5234442353,
-0.3859967589,
0.150745362,
-0.7189930677,
0.0129593294,
0.0602140129,
0.1849000603,
0.2138338238,
-0.4573473334,
-0.8461220264,
-0.7617838383,
1.0311335325,
-0.7965334058,
0.5804143548,
1.0740455389,
0.3722960949,
-0.2936218977,
-1.158182621,
-0.1563727111,
-0.2139472812,
0.2007829547,
0.2507612407,
0.613599658,
-0.3309109509,
-0.1582878381,
0.4392439425,
-0.3193326294,
-0.2826869786,
-0.0137086716,
0.3364254534,
0.5809931159,
0.3649816811,
0.5807787776,
0.2797990143,
-0.4455215633,
-0.012838942,
-0.3145273626,
-0.2560472488,
-0.3016642928,
0.2803468704,
-0.0109030148,
0.691893816,
0.0763730928,
0.4564631879,
0.1572465152,
-0.1928749233,
0.1115538329,
-0.6898382306,
-0.3075070679,
-0.0763934627,
0.4685159624,
0.6595135331,
0.0826915056,
-0.1233439744,
-0.0191116203,
-0.2256472558,
0.5525406599,
-0.9890393019,
-0.5255547166,
-0.0874704048,
0.2111533433,
-0.2850795686,
0.2120445222,
-0.4372543395,
-0.4241470993,
-0.2859607339,
0.4237034023,
-0.3333100379,
0.2054152042,
0.0315401815,
-0.281319499,
0.0195189845,
0.2599905431,
-1.4205091,
0.660226047,
0.3943673968,
0.6809599996,
0.3839771152,
-0.1811576486,
-0.5651294589,
0.0650945827,
-0.5684838295,
0.4874673784,
-0.3991956115,
-0.7426716089,
-0.1645326763,
0.4361983836,
-0.1150349751,
-0.7229974866,
0.3562908173,
-0.2004321218,
-0.2082402259,
-0.7777270079,
-0.8539323807,
0.0741392747,
0.0509868152,
-0.9344853759,
0.8304994106,
0.4715077579,
-0.4438921809,
0.562153995,
-0.2810540795,
-0.7296393514,
0.4824610054,
-0.1240177378,
-0.1480099261,
0.4747589231,
0.2061414123,
0.5937217474,
-0.3531823754,
0.1499046534,
-0.1444460452,
-0.0227837507,
0.2536267638,
-0.4178467989,
0.0491563715,
0.3356586099,
0.1959082484,
0.0857014805,
-0.483969748,
0.0773929358,
0.1020596176,
-0.1725221127,
-0.3892351389,
0.1296843141,
0.0340359956,
-0.2090675086,
0.4606601894,
-0.1659422964,
-0.0961963683,
-0.5216540098,
0.2853979468,
0.3099575937,
0.1307495087,
1.0056847334,
-0.474298656,
0.4346753359,
-0.2597050071,
0.0647977591,
-0.1288506985,
-0.4703956246,
-0.288195461,
-0.0195678324,
0.435898155,
0.65443784,
-0.7674669027,
0.6463567019,
-0.0200469606,
-0.3971315622,
0.0428849831,
0.0375029743,
0.0443842337,
0.5373463631,
0.2536441386,
-0.3742419481,
-0.821013093,
-0.3775580227,
-0.1483825445,
0.3323212266,
-0.4416100979,
0.296533376,
0.1594402641,
-0.1609680057,
0.9571970701,
-0.8062413931,
-0.2009111047,
-0.5817314386,
0.3132463694,
-0.0472303741,
0.4754361212,
0.5263897181,
-0.7871186733,
-1.025064826,
0.3335755765,
-0.7399104834,
-0.1065843925,
0.1189090386,
-0.0917208344,
-0.1772422493,
0.4155924022,
-0.0850658491,
0.2828505337,
0.6441351771,
-0.3774306774,
0.6266804338,
-0.2086232603,
0.1582989097,
-1.6581345797,
-0.5285358429,
0.435335815,
-0.0289446767,
-0.3637100756,
-0.1103786528,
0.3413784206,
0.1183753908,
-0.55076015,
0.8164075613,
-0.3139463365,
-0.2089134604,
-0.1626614928,
-0.4617090225,
0.4045988917,
0.2666023076,
0.1307599097,
1.0041831732,
0.3014557362,
-0.3537186384,
0.3587380946,
-0.3395338058,
-0.5891264081,
0.4240325689,
-0.2928232849,
-0.2584943473,
0.3505527973,
0.1083377972,
-1.2164292336,
-0.3245526552,
-0.023778785,
-0.2795015574,
0.3240129352,
-0.0938786492,
-0.5255753398,
-0.284035027,
-0.1621570438,
0.3482195139,
0.1763872355,
-0.3714808226,
0.922952652,
0.1802354306,
-0.212639451,
-0.209303394,
-0.5079084635,
-0.1426522285,
0.0811026692,
-0.1865707338,
0.2355192155,
-0.4913294315,
-0.1289408654,
-0.1473940164,
-0.5699362755,
-0.5340666175,
0.0482047237,
0.3929661214,
0.1955124289,
-0.2327444851,
0.0042193905,
0.0231278036,
0.1368842125,
0.4037293792,
-0.4036228359,
0.4944483042,
-0.2352206111,
0.3038198352,
-0.1543031186,
0.0475042239,
0.5241153836,
0.0330138765,
0.7094593644,
0.6922075748,
-0.550164938,
-0.3160851002,
-0.2950322628,
-0.4852816761,
-0.4877692461,
0.5634023547,
-0.4987867177,
0.069159776,
0.6080834866,
-0.1847567707,
-0.0522922911,
0.3403958082,
0.1725649089,
-0.1192375943,
0.8035686612,
0.2880563438,
0.1492704153,
0.3906548321,
-0.3809433281,
-0.1222199425,
-0.6117304564,
-0.2135286182,
-0.2916125357,
0.0072287521,
-0.2103894055,
-0.806840837,
0.3131444454,
-0.1134152114,
-0.2323481888,
0.6270192266,
-0.2376615405,
1.0669770241,
0.2604569793,
0.3766114116,
-0.0239133053,
0.1675862223,
-0.3985397518,
-0.4175329208,
-0.5570604801,
-0.3029586375,
1.1430410147,
0.2892582119,
0.8521595001,
-0.0449878275,
0.521787107,
0.2383475006,
0.3185273409,
-1.2097043991,
0.4630106091,
-0.6489344835,
-0.4847284555,
-0.4004434049,
-0.6644399166,
-0.6244115233,
0.0742277503,
-0.0990728587,
-0.298543632,
-0.0253626145,
-0.276340127,
-0.3750847578,
0.1921039969,
-1.2247468233,
0.9447951317,
-0.5917081833,
-0.5630610585,
0.4049837887,
-0.384608835,
-0.224126026,
0.0254061185,
0.2462909818,
-0.1118304953,
0.1126247123,
0.5119177103,
-0.775208652,
1.133987546,
0.1137171984,
-0.3235915899,
-0.033588741,
0.433141768,
0.2093853652,
0.3913652897,
-0.1143230945,
-0.0267351121,
0.0141979037,
-0.4421746731,
-0.9323609471,
1.018301487,
-0.8168975711,
-0.1130775884,
-0.3958330452,
-0.8290636539,
-0.4344326258,
0.3937537074,
0.6017992496,
0.331359446,
-0.2526266277,
0.0703321844,
0.7361587882,
0.0830525383,
0.2383095473,
0.2178484052,
-0.1174029484,
-0.6436190009,
0.866194725,
0.4609262943,
0.2447405607,
0.7429977059,
0.3848055303,
-0.3491808772,
0.1609407514,
-0.2099670172,
-0.3900719881,
-0.7938049436,
-0.2956299186,
-0.2801271677,
-0.2867889702,
-0.3395706713,
-0.6886390448,
-0.6439538598,
-0.2183917463,
-0.504875958,
-0.1728143394,
0.1404373348,
0.6965702176,
0.1048061177,
0.2198946774,
-0.6102127433,
0.0582245663,
0.6205528975,
0.400270611,
-0.0373137929,
-0.4948720038,
-0.3995926678,
0.2197421342,
-0.3207532763,
-0.8351722956,
0.9184729457,
0.1399641335,
0.1493219435,
0.2695204914,
0.2564887404,
0.194176212,
-0.6009858251,
0.7982831001,
0.6487030387,
-0.7298598886,
0.4436124861,
0.0190635603,
0.5629084706,
0.3864918351,
0.7417799234,
-0.1314217895,
-0.0097505916,
-0.2139308304,
-1.14716506,
0.0403973125,
0.100076437,
0.0301166307,
-0.408388555,
0.3250727654,
0.5084627867,
0.0178809799,
-0.4767640233,
-0.2638647854,
-0.3896846473,
-0.4668191373,
-0.2563772798,
-0.2982125878,
0.106960617,
-0.5736794472,
0.5051757097,
0.1002163962,
-0.0844893456,
-0.0764422566,
0.3066394925,
-0.3123888373,
0.2660606205,
0.5061395764,
0.897074759,
-0.7266058326,
0.3997428417,
0.4132256806,
-0.8082163334,
-0.0621915869,
-0.1894550025,
0.8144182563,
-0.0854921713,
0.1395964921,
0.4812339544,
0.3912702203,
-0.3595662415,
0.267000854,
-0.4390831292,
-0.40159899,
-0.650100112,
-0.0633013099,
0.1974060982,
-0.1789868176,
0.4255878925,
0.1450401694,
0.2161637396,
-0.5370017886,
0.4158624709,
-0.00505492,
-0.3814931214,
-0.3992155194,
0.3595357835,
0.3419092596,
0.1124311537,
0.6438013315,
-0.2091357559,
-0.0193959437,
1.0858877897,
0.8035048246,
0.8002979159,
-0.5177423954,
0.4148926139,
0.3390468657,
0.1090439186,
-0.3126238286,
0.2540830672,
0.0852532983,
-0.8721282482,
-0.1358004659,
-0.6099726558,
-0.4276401699,
0.126691401,
-0.8354994059,
0.0264046155,
-0.7947481275,
-0.3165691197,
0.4404583275,
0.4642996192,
-0.7960033417,
0.3644302785,
0.1088772863,
0.6787494421,
-0.9438080788,
0.7068900466,
0.9917789102,
-0.5215449333,
-0.8605046272,
0.005479495,
-0.0423579402,
-0.5941907167,
0.6377458572,
0.0736859962,
-0.1340841055,
-0.3458518088,
-0.6681364179,
-0.5305669904,
0.9045535922,
0.0919939503,
-0.6189841032,
0.0471039489,
0.2145381719,
0.3473438621,
-0.6899064183,
0.1833699346,
0.0452062078,
0.267315805,
0.7416490912,
-0.7827172279,
-0.0345481746,
-0.2860716879,
0.3022226393,
0.1922435015,
-0.0524328686,
0.864582479,
-0.3519127965,
-0.0455335379,
0.3246490359,
0.3747973442,
-0.1651312411,
0.7050148845,
-0.0900058672,
0.5101431608,
0.5484919548,
0.0461880527,
1.0825397968,
-0.0762318894,
0.0566891618,
1.5946495533,
-0.7069461942,
0.8439835906,
0.3745784163,
-0.1859101504,
0.3681233823,
0.7228466272,
0.0103204018,
0.8826541901,
0.0311361942,
-0.2824950218,
0.0540995859,
-0.0102453483,
-0.28181234,
-0.0724886581,
0.9137747884,
-0.7284758687,
-0.0483364724,
0.1146687567,
-0.0715516433,
0.2347432226,
-0.0990107507,
0.9680375457,
0.2914299965,
-0.42565009,
0.6203846931,
-0.1230163053,
-0.076148279,
-0.6140273213,
-0.252881825,
-0.5514680147,
0.2275039852,
-0.0742969066,
-0.8023898005,
0.1020010561,
-0.8080354333,
-0.4682837129,
0.1302084476,
0.3182119727,
-0.4489040077,
-0.8333367705,
-0.0498194881,
0.3511093557,
-0.23097004,
-0.0706611425,
-0.3607926071,
-0.0640282333,
-0.2316144854,
0.2859331965,
0.3975078762,
0.7158196568,
0.3033547103,
0.4407773912,
0.2303706557,
-0.0927861035,
-0.0569652133,
-0.0194686111,
0.6175442934,
-0.4734157622,
-0.5402255058,
-0.5164677501,
0.135127753,
0.1995763928,
0.1224807426,
0.7722011209,
0.5707401037,
0.8942052126,
-0.5918064117,
0.6885553598,
0.3095290959,
0.0188119318,
-0.5401163697,
0.2332681417,
-0.512519896,
0.7765390873,
0.0759479478,
-1.0949782133,
-0.2869488597,
0.701857686,
-0.6117481589,
0.0464314111,
0.7562317848,
0.5935544968,
-0.2064697742,
0.2749051452,
0.6478318572,
-0.0080501996,
-0.2512180805,
0.3378264308,
0.3373345733,
-0.4981449544,
-0.2402690202,
-0.3836907744,
-0.1675593406,
-0.213461712,
-0.5800308585,
-0.754653573,
-0.5807806849,
-0.208504945,
-0.0750777423,
0.3182733059,
1.220710516,
1.0742812157,
-0.7588627934,
-0.6605798602,
-0.3140446246,
-0.0936659127,
-0.6325755119,
-0.2929005921,
-0.0356597975,
-0.5278472304,
-0.4614827335,
0.463413924,
0.2095336914,
0.2325683236,
0.0918760449,
-0.0148881748,
-0.0878911614,
0.5213436484,
1.0755553246,
0.2012766451,
-0.6753984094,
0.3958986104,
-0.0138518754,
-0.0793049783,
-0.1604934037,
0.6441608667,
-0.2194117755,
0.6521900892,
0.3129163384,
0.4274173081,
0.3696080446,
-0.1052901223,
0.8589447737,
-1.495921731,
-0.1060355306,
0.180043608,
0.4119501412,
0.0348532274,
-0.4677756131,
0.6995714307,
-0.1122255176,
-0.6293092966,
-0.2115212381,
0.2274294645,
-0.8189548254,
-0.7287042737,
0.9573063254,
-0.2014932483,
-0.2588218153,
0.1723771393,
-0.1835719645,
0.0990837589,
-0.466448456,
0.7137333751,
0.5781921744,
0.2729361057,
-0.3991810083,
-0.7492488027,
0.3745968938,
0.3790117204,
-0.7580460906,
-0.1205388531,
0.5657296181,
0.2919335067,
0.2116413563,
0.3186534941,
0.0552036166,
0.0169950072,
0.0870578215,
-0.0244134516,
0.4655107856,
-0.599604845,
0.5407758355,
0.0546790101,
0.3105781376,
-0.2603411973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10706v1 | TC-GAT: Graph Attention Network for Temporal Causality Discovery | 2023-04-21T02:26:42 | 2023-04-21T02:26:42 | Xiaosong Yuan, Ke Chen, Wanli Zuo, Yijia Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The present study explores the intricacies of causal relationship extraction,
a vital component in the pursuit of causality knowledge. Causality is
frequently intertwined with temporal elements, as the progression from cause to
effect is not instantaneous but rather ensconced in a temporal dimension. Thus,
the extraction of temporal causality holds paramount significance in the field.
In light of this, we propose a method for extracting causality from the text
that integrates both temporal and causal relations, with a particular focus on
the time aspect. To this end, we first compile a dataset that encompasses
temporal relationships. Subsequently, we present a novel model, TC-GAT, which
employs a graph attention mechanism to assign weights to the temporal
relationships and leverages a causal knowledge graph to determine the adjacency
matrix. Additionally, we implement an equilibrium mechanism to regulate the
interplay between temporal and causal relations. Our experiments demonstrate
that our proposed method significantly surpasses baseline models in the task of
causality extraction. | [
-0.173221603,
-1.3305155039,
0.9172866344,
0.2379585207,
-0.2768445909,
-0.109128505,
0.1757732034,
-0.5854978561,
0.3620283902,
0.0309764221,
-0.6144989133,
-0.0233829953,
-0.7081629038,
-0.2949724495,
-0.2382384539,
0.9252694249,
0.0463221036,
-0.1275513917,
0.2200065106,
0.1825933903,
-0.5060572028,
-0.2540922165,
-1.0362784863,
-0.4975014031,
1.2388586998,
0.1870700866,
0.232122764,
0.987341404,
0.7518585324,
0.2277424186,
-0.069469139,
-0.0837526992,
-0.6338541508,
0.0960102156,
-0.4463659227,
0.0364750475,
-0.5343136191,
0.2206310928,
0.6996992826,
0.4915412068,
0.1446951479,
0.3982407451,
-0.0006492476,
0.4402275681,
-0.5652860999,
0.6004338264,
-0.4098394811,
0.1203513145,
-0.2805522382,
-0.812102139,
-0.2625901997,
-0.388016969,
0.3675401509,
-0.5781773329,
0.4640919864,
0.1769912094,
1.0403739214,
0.170069024,
-1.1129351854,
0.0040893671,
-0.8617872596,
0.3617050946,
-0.219717592,
0.2291070223,
0.084925279,
0.4045354426,
0.0263399519,
-1.1519157887,
-0.439046979,
-0.3428610861,
-0.2192171663,
0.4238539636,
0.0086810216,
-0.0487611964,
0.5132209659,
0.3145234287,
-0.4957173169,
-0.3369152546,
-0.1555926353,
0.0281952471,
0.0938483626,
0.3916700482,
0.749753356,
-0.1682967842,
-0.6220477223,
0.3313835561,
-0.5481573939,
-0.0038144845,
0.2618146837,
0.1378455609,
-0.0107295271,
0.6322123408,
-0.1808467656,
0.469599545,
0.1472725719,
0.3472067416,
-0.3706918061,
-0.5231508017,
-0.1202690974,
0.3009286821,
0.8543910384,
0.1441963911,
-0.0736627951,
-0.6705553532,
0.3559888303,
0.0844916627,
0.2077071518,
-0.7267468572,
-0.2422738969,
-0.0160369966,
-0.3331370354,
-0.4659694731,
0.2162672281,
-0.608843267,
-0.2412926704,
-0.3715316653,
0.4254757166,
-0.3032935858,
-0.2049575597,
-0.1984290481,
-0.3307594061,
0.1122169867,
0.1568397284,
-0.6633828282,
0.132117182,
0.5781776905,
1.0854144096,
0.0966163129,
-0.1289407313,
-0.8055157661,
0.8186578155,
-0.0389994793,
0.6811109781,
-0.394175142,
0.0576732568,
-0.4363690317,
0.1800414175,
-0.2691158652,
0.3522531092,
0.4314252734,
-0.9305917621,
0.1733598411,
-0.4018026292,
-0.4444870651,
-0.3718671203,
0.2680479884,
-0.8445427418,
0.73677212,
0.0646702573,
-1.2083660364,
0.3429577351,
-0.6876433492,
-0.5337873697,
0.1511897445,
0.0870737582,
-0.3927872479,
-0.1925962269,
0.1394863278,
0.4063431323,
-0.5714449883,
0.6099944711,
-0.5643065572,
-0.1395320445,
-0.0528057925,
-0.2374769896,
0.9908920527,
0.1970690042,
-0.4503090978,
0.0404173099,
-0.5693116188,
-0.2352705598,
0.3745405376,
-0.0528578311,
-0.3937674761,
0.2839173079,
-0.048804123,
0.5336276293,
0.1521667987,
-0.6239262819,
0.1424951702,
-0.3029727936,
0.774058044,
0.7299860716,
0.7415958047,
0.2787065208,
-0.0394879766,
0.3937387466,
0.1283813417,
0.2416792214,
0.2062584162,
-0.2407539934,
-0.5419092774,
0.3179406226,
0.0213234052,
0.4609947801,
-0.7289561033,
0.2622700632,
-0.4032896459,
-0.413089633,
0.3431689143,
-0.4670038223,
0.3753811121,
1.19833529,
0.2008788437,
-0.2436660379,
-0.3385194838,
-0.6999021173,
-0.2483682781,
-0.3242222965,
0.1224284396,
0.4357855916,
0.2810979486,
0.0670865253,
0.9143012166,
-0.9663841128,
-0.2863097787,
0.082953006,
0.3470119536,
-0.1294519603,
0.3743781447,
0.5898609757,
-0.7646172047,
-0.3558658361,
0.3962309659,
-0.9378983974,
0.0157173686,
-0.0984200463,
-0.2370028943,
-0.4306946397,
0.7386747599,
-0.2537585795,
0.3707011044,
-0.0066462946,
-0.5619987249,
0.607186079,
-0.0528752878,
0.2395159751,
-1.046800971,
0.5801194906,
0.2177420259,
-0.1625925452,
-0.5004124641,
-0.1538926959,
0.2657579184,
-0.1704436243,
-0.3038220108,
0.7357756495,
-0.5498732328,
0.1416516751,
0.0299623217,
0.4540503919,
-0.0606235713,
0.8048772812,
-0.1215579733,
0.4244285524,
0.1707224399,
-0.6293612123,
0.4117510021,
0.1908708662,
0.0696631819,
0.4596751928,
-0.8607336879,
0.26012972,
-0.1077004373,
0.0739651769,
-0.8406103849,
-0.2357616127,
0.4699590802,
-0.5399054885,
0.3706428409,
-0.4552474916,
-0.572503686,
-0.2449518144,
0.0693113133,
0.5576760173,
-0.1484328359,
-0.1793008745,
0.4956594706,
0.5981219411,
-0.275078088,
-0.5422312617,
-0.3814054132,
0.1313033253,
-0.2848295867,
-0.6924538612,
0.0169496126,
0.2112139165,
-0.1232803762,
0.1637771875,
-0.2022335678,
-0.1014603302,
0.1499038488,
0.0505429618,
0.0924953446,
-0.1784967333,
0.3836833537,
-0.0695218742,
-0.5092037916,
0.3304845691,
-0.6669262648,
0.3916245699,
0.0484794304,
-0.0670949444,
-0.4349882305,
0.4371058941,
0.3388819695,
-0.4176804423,
0.572388351,
0.7593403459,
-0.50346452,
0.2617221773,
-0.44600752,
-0.0844900385,
-0.3796822131,
0.4387060106,
-0.116026178,
-0.6490861177,
0.7466433048,
0.0340094715,
-0.3558875024,
0.6712536216,
0.3409418166,
0.1173938885,
1.1391918659,
0.5625061989,
-0.2072079629,
1.0299721956,
-0.2770864367,
0.1680623889,
-1.0370488167,
-0.2766917646,
-0.4864612818,
-0.2794271111,
-0.3248093724,
0.2204817384,
0.4758168459,
-0.0969259217,
-0.6261469722,
0.3371013403,
-0.3605695069,
0.3867644668,
0.5694771409,
0.5679895282,
0.3485034406,
-0.2582374513,
0.0829268172,
0.0556629002,
-0.6627067924,
-0.1399881095,
0.6384734511,
-0.0211393815,
0.3533729017,
0.2179137319,
0.2590937614,
0.1241039783,
0.0986458212,
-0.6529334188,
0.3546431661,
0.0581503138,
-0.5622232556,
-0.3058945537,
-0.7067604661,
-1.0452308655,
-0.2566682696,
-0.0080984877,
-1.1169065237,
0.3496528566,
0.0925068781,
-0.1965183616,
0.3032213748,
-1.0161464214,
0.9846853614,
0.0613548085,
-0.7336457968,
-0.1522853673,
-1.0376844406,
0.5178642273,
0.2035695314,
-0.1436487883,
-0.0976473838,
0.2232079655,
0.8315169215,
-0.3776410222,
0.7432234287,
-0.0409535244,
0.2917950153,
0.2174149901,
0.2568778694,
0.8108583093,
0.4151157737,
0.5314118266,
-0.0079419548,
-0.1744014472,
-0.3679696321,
-0.5559961796,
0.7365359068,
-0.6880168319,
-0.5723034143,
-0.4826430678,
-0.7303371429,
-0.1934532374,
0.7411111593,
0.095086731,
0.7947050929,
-0.3371744454,
-0.0701589212,
0.5801426172,
0.1609878391,
0.5891522765,
0.3433839381,
0.1811369061,
-0.309066087,
0.9360553622,
0.2267536521,
0.2588327825,
0.7015121579,
0.5837743878,
-0.2978069484,
-0.2162909657,
0.2034106553,
0.3574365079,
-0.5885702372,
-0.1141348034,
-1.1045138836,
-0.4378829896,
-0.565801084,
-0.0863050595,
0.0235542785,
-0.6021960378,
-0.462064147,
-0.0884100124,
0.3525830209,
0.6405087709,
-0.0237976015,
0.3473341465,
-0.8093261123,
0.4461286962,
0.5727900863,
0.2149200141,
0.3748960495,
-0.1150876731,
-0.3956303596,
-0.1983815134,
-0.5361865163,
-0.9498637915,
0.2663223743,
-0.0455704778,
0.3895315826,
0.6151989698,
-0.0667083934,
0.7392407656,
-0.426974982,
0.477501601,
0.2102956921,
-0.8404100537,
0.6314679384,
-0.9568402171,
0.2617349923,
-0.0570812672,
0.1495634466,
-0.8014034033,
-0.5491751432,
-1.0654720068,
-0.9537379146,
1.0125999451,
0.3622787595,
-0.5350205302,
-0.2187415063,
0.4239897728,
-0.4184235036,
-0.1002874821,
-0.6776663661,
-0.2631227672,
0.1297433823,
0.1044866815,
0.0279435199,
-0.430783838,
-0.215929836,
0.0594232716,
0.562871933,
0.1176371649,
0.296304673,
0.5021557808,
-0.2064517438,
-0.3136466444,
-0.1097227558,
0.4031955302,
0.8156474829,
-0.4354508519,
0.205883041,
-0.3222604394,
-0.8890417218,
0.0187096801,
0.2403205782,
-0.241552487,
-0.4446582496,
0.4579226077,
0.5039758086,
0.1803835183,
0.2016945481,
0.295691371,
-0.2853810191,
0.2932379246,
-0.0744340122,
-0.1507362872,
0.0948125422,
0.5190131664,
0.3057459891,
-0.0436436087,
0.3864214122,
-0.3174535632,
0.2932290435,
0.2709726095,
-0.7451939583,
-0.3961187303,
1.3031840324,
0.0992844775,
-0.1804792881,
0.5264621377,
-0.0281749498,
-0.3571199179,
1.1524424553,
0.305900991,
1.2472945452,
-0.0325016901,
0.185415566,
0.7386536002,
0.3813333809,
0.162255764,
-0.022098776,
0.0303662866,
-0.4700601995,
-0.2925126553,
-0.0454599038,
-0.0874867737,
-0.131867528,
-0.7066267133,
0.3523713648,
-0.2931503952,
-0.3038484156,
0.225123778,
0.4291189313,
-0.6063199043,
0.2162596434,
-0.3668202162,
0.2727949321,
-0.7714339495,
0.7621046305,
0.3689810932,
-0.8291345835,
-0.8709163666,
0.0196938924,
0.0867515802,
-0.6115121245,
0.7988291979,
-0.0100783696,
-0.1157241166,
0.557022512,
-0.4541573822,
-0.8050274849,
1.416695118,
0.4587516487,
-0.4073129594,
-0.2951398194,
-0.3864193261,
0.3759841621,
-0.1184446588,
0.2215051502,
0.2740856111,
0.2771996558,
0.0152377458,
-0.3666313589,
0.3204173744,
-0.2075840086,
-0.0753916204,
0.4746997654,
-0.901506424,
0.8378078938,
-0.2152719498,
-0.7209550142,
-0.5918152928,
0.5438011289,
-0.0693047941,
0.533824861,
0.2169577479,
0.3147501051,
0.4937923849,
-0.1882702708,
1.0561857224,
-0.314961642,
0.6772083044,
1.3101478815,
-0.0221289434,
-0.0478946492,
0.5578249097,
-0.0080353003,
0.0920588598,
0.8719885945,
0.3517812192,
0.6011165977,
-0.2948105931,
-0.0720196143,
-0.1888017356,
-0.2007087469,
-0.4176958203,
-0.0641140342,
0.2466123253,
-0.3378650546,
-0.4903069139,
-0.4898297489,
0.1630708575,
-0.4567680061,
-0.2981435955,
0.8279184103,
0.1767410934,
-0.5056105256,
-0.1603936851,
-0.4231606722,
-0.3163889349,
-0.755433917,
-0.1596900225,
-0.1223084927,
0.0868909284,
0.0655352026,
-0.5743196607,
0.2410170883,
-0.4141778946,
-0.4843329787,
0.1306354553,
0.806997776,
-0.466922164,
-0.3777504861,
0.3549965918,
0.4490791857,
-0.3235522509,
-0.0272950958,
-0.3901850283,
-0.642885685,
-0.2558922172,
-0.3159684837,
0.1412524283,
0.9670842886,
-0.2171456963,
0.6167320609,
0.5657067895,
0.2128978223,
-0.0098968288,
-0.0814030617,
0.8133428097,
-0.8320390582,
-0.8595964313,
-0.9864040613,
0.3878463209,
-0.3171763718,
-0.3015666306,
0.6735274196,
0.3181707263,
0.3005136251,
0.0970103145,
0.677218616,
-0.2475583106,
0.2349566817,
-0.5334080458,
0.8761917353,
-0.530433774,
0.1494172364,
-0.4834908247,
-0.7332638502,
-0.3481121957,
-0.0273575895,
-0.4797643125,
-0.1223492175,
1.2526757717,
0.4441161752,
-0.222950995,
0.1474110484,
-0.1667624712,
0.3261410296,
0.6927794218,
0.9074591398,
0.6230381727,
-0.4755628109,
0.6359187365,
-0.2042158097,
-0.2942070365,
-0.0747142062,
-1.1032912731,
-0.7304422855,
-0.8084010482,
-0.4658937454,
-0.2487981766,
0.0791707486,
0.3756234944,
0.2706080675,
-0.4823884964,
0.084257111,
-0.2965890467,
0.3408815563,
-0.5030610561,
-0.3104381263,
1.0440458059,
-0.4442229271,
-0.4542250931,
-0.0370446257,
0.421305269,
0.0509337448,
0.1912800223,
0.4620319903,
-0.6994818449,
-0.261107862,
0.5195025206,
0.3709831834,
-0.1443955451,
-0.6694179773,
-0.0087840939,
-0.0774156153,
-0.01132554,
1.3010368347,
-0.3714855909,
0.7935547233,
0.6716389656,
0.3752432764,
0.768378675,
-0.0388208702,
0.7379564047,
-0.8755196333,
0.3200654984,
0.0797999501,
0.4527369738,
-0.1565924138,
-0.8433490992,
0.8635095954,
0.675722003,
-0.8381217122,
-0.6459772587,
0.206165731,
-1.3391836882,
0.0536722131,
0.9928380251,
-0.0413038321,
-0.3471281528,
-0.5332715511,
-0.1110315695,
0.951353848,
-0.2648249865,
1.0777410269,
0.7286013365,
-0.1889734268,
0.0828080699,
-0.5830231309,
0.2094504237,
-0.2833279073,
-0.6368966699,
0.0877768025,
0.4316926301,
0.1860758066,
0.0009634032,
0.7656386495,
-0.2226131558,
0.3184581101,
0.0826229975,
-0.1760245711,
-0.33466959,
-0.1814850718,
0.0089396667,
0.2039482892,
-0.5391512513,
-0.1344725192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10703v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10703v2 | ReCEval: Evaluating Reasoning Chains via Correctness and Informativeness | 2023-04-21T02:19:06 | 2023-11-30T23:33:07 | Archiki Prasad, Swarnadeep Saha, Xiang Zhou, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multi-step reasoning ability is fundamental to many natural language tasks,
yet it is unclear what constitutes a good reasoning chain and how to evaluate
them. Most existing methods focus solely on whether the reasoning chain leads
to the correct conclusion, but this answer-oriented view may confound reasoning
quality with other spurious shortcuts to predict the answer. To bridge this
gap, we evaluate reasoning chains by viewing them as informal proofs that
derive the final answer. Specifically, we propose ReCEval (Reasoning Chain
Evaluation), a framework that evaluates reasoning chains via two key
properties: (1) correctness, i.e., each step makes a valid inference based on
information contained within the step, preceding steps, and input context, and
(2) informativeness, i.e., each step provides new information that is helpful
towards deriving the generated answer. We evaluate these properties by
developing metrics using natural language inference models and V-Information.
On multiple datasets, we show that ReCEval effectively identifies various error
types and yields notable improvements compared to prior methods. We analyze the
impact of step boundaries, and previous steps on evaluating correctness and
demonstrate that our informativeness metric captures the expected flow of
information in high-quality reasoning chains. Finally, we show that scoring
reasoning chains based on ReCEval improves downstream task performance. Our
code is publicly available at: https://github.com/archiki/ReCEval | [
-0.0838692188,
-0.7162694335,
0.5509750843,
0.1000177264,
0.0547393151,
0.3023761809,
-0.2535399795,
-0.593134284,
0.0396521389,
0.4151700735,
-0.4280315936,
-0.4567324519,
-0.5056076646,
0.2495910227,
-0.4590970278,
1.1608542204,
-0.0990136862,
-0.2931404412,
-0.3768578172,
-0.1356466413,
-0.4083900154,
-0.2021117061,
-0.5252822042,
-0.3495237529,
0.3788739741,
0.4769125879,
0.5970002413,
0.711720407,
0.6735233068,
0.3226792514,
0.0370689295,
0.4904530644,
-0.4387716651,
0.3308828473,
-0.4574495554,
-0.4173264205,
-0.2792382836,
-0.2314999551,
0.5535666347,
0.6203945279,
-0.429759711,
0.554548502,
0.0651921779,
1.1861714125,
-0.8427829742,
0.1259665042,
-0.588462472,
-0.1580152959,
-0.1379400641,
-0.3403808773,
-0.4190704525,
-0.8551330566,
0.3495213687,
-0.5783982873,
0.2048665732,
0.1521178484,
0.7395800948,
0.2608292699,
-0.1856787801,
-0.5112123489,
-0.7436458468,
0.7148934007,
-0.6592672467,
0.6314129829,
0.2696702778,
0.6088706255,
-0.2198670059,
-1.1202135086,
-0.3481853008,
-0.3312962353,
-0.0819760188,
-0.0427705608,
-0.2954261005,
0.0757599697,
0.3651528955,
0.6186441779,
-0.3769566119,
-0.4377708733,
-0.3194571435,
-0.10353183,
0.5681847334,
0.0103241596,
0.1254991442,
-0.0802784711,
-0.3226728439,
0.1364653707,
-0.6168761253,
0.1895392239,
0.3178851902,
0.3923701942,
0.2572098374,
0.4685198665,
-0.42516011,
0.841891706,
0.210354656,
-0.026077969,
0.4114705026,
-0.7576386333,
-0.18210271,
-0.0135576557,
0.470436424,
0.3423106074,
0.3161884248,
-0.0968084708,
-0.2167194188,
-0.2514492869,
0.6718571186,
-0.609732151,
-0.3060135543,
0.4602704942,
-0.4717496634,
-0.3732638359,
0.0615044683,
-0.5384072661,
-0.4145245254,
-0.4016652405,
0.263592273,
-0.4233079255,
-0.2410412431,
0.2698206007,
-0.2604224682,
0.0674274936,
0.5541725159,
-0.6753172874,
0.6264131665,
0.6962340474,
0.7823911309,
0.0699654371,
-0.2569470108,
-0.8849080801,
-0.1547031105,
-0.3281255066,
0.8343283534,
-0.5736966729,
0.1199504361,
0.1681750864,
0.0466310345,
-0.0486024693,
-0.4221182764,
0.8117508888,
-0.5182675719,
-0.0290124677,
-0.4295490086,
-0.4673791826,
-0.4207353592,
0.5849291682,
-0.8221706748,
1.1891309023,
-0.106095843,
-0.9412536621,
0.3993332088,
-0.572378099,
-0.617459774,
-0.0306990128,
0.0661263466,
-0.0186195225,
0.0632787421,
0.1390494853,
0.1115784347,
-0.3316797018,
0.1179356873,
0.0074907495,
-0.2333577573,
0.1461319178,
-0.4615712166,
0.4343096614,
0.0883604735,
-0.3500322998,
0.1165076792,
-0.9539888501,
0.183961004,
-0.2581284046,
-0.6034695506,
-0.3672369719,
0.2904375494,
-0.5763169527,
0.208263278,
0.283490777,
-0.5412096381,
0.1353093386,
-0.5292280912,
0.2784449458,
0.6974341869,
0.1579080671,
0.2163156867,
-0.3583353758,
0.3273118734,
-0.2454268336,
0.1553934664,
-0.0989284664,
-0.4727320969,
-0.7645676732,
0.1777273268,
0.2975216508,
0.6430521607,
-0.8247560263,
0.30668661,
-0.1446423978,
-0.5729734302,
-0.7422665358,
0.171635285,
0.6223852038,
0.7410804629,
0.5054135323,
-0.2009716481,
-0.7189782858,
-0.7242723107,
-0.6077509522,
-0.5424548388,
0.0419947952,
-0.0218881834,
0.6609122157,
0.0040784483,
0.7369426489,
-0.4273566604,
0.2995060682,
-0.2354626507,
0.3396109641,
0.3310233951,
0.3384201229,
-0.031216247,
-0.4479459524,
0.1366447359,
0.2251453251,
-0.5702889562,
-0.0584334917,
-0.1232305616,
-0.3187719584,
0.004769952,
0.0993854329,
-0.2499925345,
0.4173657894,
0.1905027032,
-0.1480497718,
0.8647950888,
-0.3617684841,
0.4708843827,
-0.6426286697,
0.1331150979,
0.1452789307,
-0.4057926536,
-0.6085812449,
0.0662450939,
-0.0993333831,
0.4530373812,
-0.1828853786,
0.2496640086,
-0.3038341403,
-0.1063191146,
-0.0037338377,
0.3061568141,
0.2871340513,
0.2947194874,
0.1384830177,
0.4207290709,
0.1285106838,
-0.7742432952,
0.4461975098,
-0.0008072641,
-0.4535149634,
0.6851783395,
-0.6861315966,
0.1005677059,
-0.0446727127,
0.1768598557,
-1.1840894222,
-0.1325077564,
0.1502664536,
-0.5080188513,
0.150032118,
-0.1858926713,
-0.497580409,
-0.4252226055,
-0.3887655139,
0.3196264207,
0.1067543849,
-0.7355440259,
0.3350183368,
0.1395448297,
0.1094165966,
-0.8146585822,
-0.7652023435,
-0.1535827816,
0.2541977465,
-0.8174364567,
0.1530109793,
0.0031672185,
-0.2867065668,
-0.049805928,
-0.4177176952,
-0.237166509,
-0.0228732377,
0.0778364241,
0.0329869017,
-0.0857336968,
0.4657563567,
0.0571731031,
-0.2223113477,
0.1970012933,
-0.4578106105,
0.1315225661,
-0.7304344773,
-0.4969021678,
-0.4426575601,
0.006416976,
0.573806107,
-0.3621267378,
0.4341315627,
0.3014877737,
-0.6371437311,
0.0837860107,
-0.7129107714,
-0.063386634,
-0.3781595528,
0.1532579958,
-0.24277623,
-0.528075695,
0.234649539,
-0.2915694416,
0.5895680189,
0.3897396624,
0.220140785,
0.0209765062,
0.7847036719,
0.2502624691,
0.448520869,
0.0233847294,
-0.3334395885,
0.3606984317,
-0.916133523,
-0.6347489953,
-0.6286662817,
-0.0850648433,
-0.6170566082,
-0.4213309884,
-0.1146966815,
0.3000886142,
-0.4943498671,
0.448269248,
-0.6527153254,
0.454354167,
0.4510525167,
-0.0710508972,
0.7248477936,
-0.0795866325,
-0.1477336287,
-0.0032566027,
-0.4914301038,
-0.7660519481,
0.7322541475,
0.4819728136,
0.7520186305,
0.1562114954,
0.7535696626,
0.4476976395,
0.2677264512,
-0.7398415804,
0.3620123863,
0.1289919168,
-0.4598845541,
-0.202213183,
-0.4624710679,
-0.7389727235,
0.2675569057,
-0.2736535966,
-0.8169794679,
0.2627803683,
0.2412026078,
-0.2481865138,
0.3155065775,
-0.6896156073,
0.7928586602,
-0.3903340101,
-0.42142874,
-0.0870071724,
-0.8418296576,
0.3859269023,
0.3255339563,
0.349098146,
0.1208181903,
0.0230256915,
0.7325826287,
-0.7800685167,
0.6067907214,
-0.0062727761,
0.0894120187,
0.4610672593,
0.2633734941,
0.5511678457,
0.0708210915,
-0.2091991901,
0.1319456697,
0.2196448296,
-0.2162655443,
-1.0138281584,
0.6039717197,
-0.3083438277,
-0.4537573159,
-0.4570921957,
-0.0217287336,
-0.1051755548,
0.3009839952,
0.1104361415,
0.5743736625,
-0.0292887017,
-0.0700581074,
0.5253559351,
0.2090990543,
0.2036707699,
0.3413684666,
-0.2297370881,
-0.5161594748,
0.8970465064,
0.0626288578,
0.5634139776,
0.5405871272,
0.260659337,
-0.6032831669,
-0.3690547943,
-0.4843008518,
0.0601265356,
-0.8300501108,
-0.2094608992,
-0.3774158359,
-0.2282127887,
-0.0862412676,
-0.031696558,
-0.5609432459,
-0.6586125493,
0.1899725348,
-0.4998269975,
0.3282610774,
0.8157473803,
-0.2076762915,
-0.3316766918,
-0.7630790472,
0.2508384585,
0.2746900618,
0.3873037696,
0.2432070225,
-0.3182941973,
-0.1078057513,
0.1057803407,
-0.3306265473,
-0.8549724817,
-0.0794427618,
-0.0405097976,
0.4946751297,
0.4008565545,
0.1204877719,
0.8580740094,
-0.5204751492,
0.6424303055,
0.2548078597,
-1.0122464895,
0.8229573965,
0.1646550596,
0.2660527527,
1.0429350138,
0.3229837418,
-0.5178126693,
-0.474050492,
-0.6564022303,
-0.9045889378,
0.2905655801,
0.5992969275,
-0.3337218463,
-0.3804089427,
0.3082227707,
0.1729242802,
0.3458695412,
-0.6354867816,
-0.2322466969,
-0.2315282226,
0.0447160825,
0.6441707015,
-0.2203599066,
-0.0491740182,
-0.2692248523,
0.6365753412,
0.0317762941,
-0.0368455984,
0.5533986092,
-0.0062068906,
0.0857634097,
0.4747283459,
0.4037046432,
1.0382736921,
-0.3469665051,
0.273339957,
0.1897859275,
-0.4349746704,
0.1298708618,
-0.0206392817,
-0.0175899602,
0.0886550397,
0.7172384858,
0.4169966578,
0.3279701769,
-0.5452723503,
0.4833572209,
-0.2237268984,
0.086947687,
-0.2225829661,
-0.1052272245,
-0.0647565201,
0.2232649922,
0.2423346937,
0.374289602,
0.4355888665,
-0.492628932,
0.3018482924,
0.0243507139,
-0.5182381272,
-0.1413988173,
0.2326415777,
0.4447863102,
-0.4798743427,
0.8432710767,
-0.2869276106,
-0.3215235174,
0.4398164749,
0.4149367809,
0.8892330527,
-0.272460103,
0.3440028429,
0.7199545503,
0.63094908,
-0.1681373268,
0.34760198,
-0.2602097988,
-0.5283516049,
-0.7270029783,
-0.5815571547,
-0.3916589916,
-0.2470695376,
-0.8301022053,
0.0191003475,
-0.3688489199,
-0.0819686726,
-0.1713653654,
-0.1467927992,
-0.5612171888,
0.2438858151,
-0.3813272715,
1.072786212,
-0.5460258722,
0.3314088583,
0.5666342974,
-0.5574069619,
-0.712071538,
0.0908095017,
-0.0036813165,
-0.5284756422,
0.6452823281,
0.3762556911,
-0.6461230516,
-0.4237919748,
-0.3731794953,
-0.8187566996,
1.0189027786,
0.1645617634,
-0.7018495798,
0.0684668869,
-0.1419391781,
0.5535084605,
-0.3710715771,
0.4793250263,
0.7934394479,
0.538980186,
0.412316978,
-0.7804988623,
0.2982291877,
-0.3526464105,
-0.0750707388,
0.3828758001,
-0.0096469028,
0.2589144707,
-0.7330080867,
-0.4401047826,
0.0280675124,
0.5750423074,
0.5788831115,
0.4173957109,
0.5247493386,
0.6393828392,
1.3626489639,
-0.2150594592,
1.3436714411,
-0.2159890831,
0.2227223366,
1.3895561695,
-0.1026912406,
1.0527541637,
0.4079170525,
-0.1390066743,
1.0326235294,
0.6358107924,
0.4178466797,
0.426233381,
0.5991835594,
-0.167739138,
-0.3253262043,
-0.1270821542,
-0.322045058,
0.0815211236,
0.2586271167,
-0.3155747056,
-0.3332787156,
-0.5002442598,
-0.0981385633,
0.1736388654,
-0.2653064728,
0.4576053917,
-0.0272462144,
-0.7216238976,
0.5053376555,
-0.1630904824,
0.0778343678,
-0.3473351896,
-0.6469378471,
0.027763864,
-0.0296989512,
-0.7002925277,
-1.2003487349,
0.5194835067,
0.2271037996,
-0.2357870936,
0.0564122051,
0.7353764176,
-0.1176938862,
-0.4767406881,
0.2002268881,
0.3188643157,
0.1938781887,
0.1329892427,
-0.6338274479,
-0.2876771688,
-0.1186928973,
0.0434537493,
-0.250305146,
0.5122321844,
0.0295734927,
0.8025727272,
0.8330020905,
0.0633743033,
-0.2137571871,
0.3195720017,
0.6204829812,
-0.6794639826,
-0.1635686606,
-0.8846231699,
0.8164088726,
-0.4411574304,
-0.3951771557,
0.5804312825,
0.566747129,
0.7787770033,
0.2551700175,
0.6761500835,
0.0404271483,
0.4686751664,
-0.5768694282,
0.2737983167,
-0.2351930439,
0.60167557,
-0.3366626799,
-0.6987640262,
-0.2354856431,
0.6881068349,
-0.3905884922,
0.0155873233,
0.9607795477,
0.4990838766,
0.2111376375,
0.2944488823,
-0.128926605,
0.1561751813,
0.2777427733,
0.6444960833,
1.0779111385,
-0.4239314497,
0.602758348,
-0.2618753612,
-0.335206449,
0.0723946169,
-1.1131187677,
-0.6183824539,
-0.5354082584,
-0.5124004483,
-0.6108448505,
0.2994376123,
0.7033079267,
0.5431333184,
-0.5884234905,
-0.2381626368,
-0.5946538448,
0.7537181973,
-0.5497630835,
-0.299991399,
0.2770256102,
-0.4751627743,
-0.1500771642,
0.2773196101,
0.6091948152,
-0.484544009,
-0.1464135945,
-0.08615648,
-0.387052387,
0.0477492288,
0.6237185597,
0.4067340195,
-0.7883341312,
-0.572774291,
-0.2125809044,
0.1149332449,
0.1753506809,
0.8016874194,
-0.7420127988,
0.8652496338,
0.9165048003,
0.6853145361,
0.3821223676,
0.19106552,
0.684333384,
-0.5923369527,
-0.6417579651,
0.2098136991,
0.4613726139,
0.45400846,
-0.2587361038,
0.7512344718,
-0.0250477586,
-0.666900456,
-0.5989077687,
0.3934609294,
-0.7397285104,
0.0247602165,
0.9657245874,
-0.2823584974,
-0.2660978138,
-0.2852670848,
-0.2148102224,
0.0718772039,
-0.3657848239,
0.618663311,
0.742467761,
-0.4737256169,
0.0447514839,
-0.5133820772,
0.4371078014,
-0.0722385943,
-1.0266973972,
0.2360550463,
0.4505197704,
0.3630135059,
0.5539062619,
0.6139824986,
-0.1878211051,
0.4867135882,
-0.2138988674,
-0.2154345959,
-0.0295161866,
-0.4763614535,
-0.1690894365,
0.0733425692,
0.2057016045,
-0.3552129567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10663v1 | Meta Semantics: Towards better natural language understanding and reasoning | 2023-04-20T22:16:16 | 2023-04-20T22:16:16 | Xiaolin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 03B65(Primary) 68T50(Secondary), I.2.4; I.2.7 | Natural language understanding is one of the most challenging topics in
artificial intelligence. Deep neural network methods, particularly large
language module (LLM) methods such as ChatGPT and GPT-3, have powerful
flexibility to adopt informal text but are weak on logical deduction and suffer
from the out-of-vocabulary (OOV) problem. On the other hand, rule-based methods
such as Mathematica, Semantic web, and Lean, are excellent in reasoning but
cannot handle the complex and changeable informal text. Inspired by pragmatics
and structuralism, we propose two strategies to solve the OOV problem and a
semantic model for better natural language understanding and reasoning. | [
-0.3881415129,
-1.1674417257,
0.8063357472,
-0.094176583,
-0.3278421462,
0.1260296404,
-0.3224299848,
-0.4599786401,
-0.1613657326,
0.5764454007,
-0.6643069386,
-0.4306791723,
-0.5354456902,
0.1653554291,
-0.2468253225,
0.8969923258,
-0.0864562318,
-0.0744468123,
-0.2168195546,
-0.1331299692,
-0.434558332,
-0.3796666563,
-0.4584299922,
-0.5278121829,
0.2770909071,
0.5595394969,
1.0115560293,
0.5101025701,
0.8012348413,
0.3395390213,
-0.1391360015,
0.2261806279,
-0.0386775583,
-0.0592728667,
-0.4679246545,
-0.4308199883,
-0.407235235,
-0.0670857504,
0.462682426,
0.871465683,
-0.1259961426,
0.0899744704,
-0.1182782575,
0.5764336586,
-0.4835351408,
0.4614129663,
-0.6324081421,
-0.0071396274,
-0.2255035192,
0.0369169489,
-0.1606940776,
0.0357736684,
0.4000163376,
-0.7612162828,
-0.0438677967,
-0.0968103483,
0.9192721844,
0.4108382165,
-0.451784879,
-0.4495325685,
-0.7900976539,
0.6122528911,
-0.8384178281,
0.344031781,
0.5051791072,
0.3894053698,
-0.328607291,
-0.8811822534,
-0.8230596185,
-0.3597231507,
-0.2611780763,
0.0686166734,
-0.0820392817,
0.2516421974,
-0.0274408255,
0.266179055,
-0.5459797382,
-0.0512652174,
-0.2388824821,
-0.155113861,
0.5506786108,
0.1715750247,
0.5177070498,
-0.4404443204,
-0.1797734648,
0.2594683766,
-0.6197447777,
-0.1945096254,
0.2675977945,
0.2871752381,
0.2468954027,
0.5593967438,
-0.2568285167,
0.9274787903,
-0.2793392241,
-0.2314312607,
0.1711490005,
-0.6075211167,
-0.4376067221,
-0.0860153064,
0.6887729168,
0.0259994045,
0.4893423617,
-0.3227083385,
0.1507876664,
0.2108261436,
0.1106349602,
-0.4281350076,
-0.1183421388,
0.1079361066,
-0.4898453355,
-0.0491737276,
0.009970543,
-0.4508030117,
-0.0020418118,
-0.7870698571,
0.49277246,
-0.7664820552,
-0.3539685309,
0.4652318358,
-0.1169213802,
0.5597752929,
0.2931888998,
-0.8660968542,
0.5407953262,
0.8980674744,
0.6780704856,
0.2019420564,
-0.179925397,
-0.2359598726,
0.3684684634,
-0.111971654,
0.8132545352,
-0.7244783044,
-0.0351735838,
-0.2858453095,
-0.255864948,
-0.1270347983,
-0.2597308159,
0.7868919373,
-0.3011562228,
0.5599461198,
0.0468656793,
-0.5286428928,
-0.6104087234,
0.4460814297,
-0.4805892706,
0.9743216038,
-0.1207418516,
-0.7891774774,
0.2730357945,
-0.9409634471,
-0.5669800639,
0.0460543446,
-0.2217424065,
0.131072402,
0.1857379377,
0.1681526303,
0.4234510362,
-0.3527468443,
0.6750703454,
-0.1832316071,
-0.1463314742,
0.131903097,
-0.3614184856,
0.5245149136,
0.3747620285,
-0.494631201,
0.0374782681,
-0.8924874663,
0.0385303944,
0.0542861372,
-0.3288571239,
-0.4757204056,
0.4322710633,
-0.265404433,
0.2634275258,
-0.0633532479,
-0.2973128855,
0.2820973098,
-0.9146357775,
1.079859376,
0.5795842409,
-0.3936460018,
0.7209332585,
0.0827422291,
-0.0374972783,
-0.0842945948,
0.0159256514,
-0.0470156372,
-0.585960865,
-0.7821347117,
-0.3461313844,
0.0572488755,
0.8024842739,
-0.8311873078,
0.3313952386,
-0.2352699488,
-0.1230621859,
-0.6941912174,
0.3040779233,
0.1870574653,
0.6356574893,
0.6559453011,
0.0967766196,
-0.4560580254,
-0.9670121074,
-0.60882622,
-0.258918345,
0.0831637308,
0.3571033478,
0.8200335503,
-0.5196302533,
1.2659640312,
-0.4371824861,
-0.3128676414,
-0.4789270461,
0.4249655604,
0.3856803477,
0.1279598475,
0.0909541249,
-0.8897868991,
-0.2992732525,
-0.0725348294,
-0.5984323025,
-0.0838737115,
0.1065311804,
-0.0859284252,
0.201490581,
0.5857282877,
-0.8915409446,
0.5174383521,
0.0721143782,
-0.3588617444,
0.1946001053,
-0.1121773422,
-0.1711823344,
-1.0626529455,
-0.0750116035,
-0.2556876242,
-0.3097832799,
-0.8384175897,
0.2054342031,
-0.2555033565,
-0.0813254118,
-0.4279330075,
0.5278881788,
-0.4132194519,
0.2640605271,
-0.3232274354,
0.4046907425,
0.2053513676,
0.3733583391,
0.3686033785,
0.2742809057,
0.4423454404,
-0.775985539,
0.7138307691,
0.2469833642,
-0.2530170083,
0.4882312715,
-0.7227188945,
0.0261452571,
-0.6146906614,
0.4013869464,
-0.8966051936,
-0.2737472653,
0.6694713235,
-0.497846961,
0.3172216713,
-0.0787698478,
-0.5374412537,
-0.1917935014,
-0.1528492868,
0.4274447262,
0.3269194663,
-0.3367194533,
0.8413079381,
0.1743152291,
0.0497265421,
-0.7164747119,
-0.8900315166,
0.3713451028,
-0.088473171,
-0.966891706,
0.5628617406,
0.1783566326,
-0.7719288468,
0.3841738999,
0.0838332772,
-0.3134241998,
0.1500892788,
-0.2590278387,
-0.0097781243,
-0.4189020395,
0.5980163813,
-0.3396961689,
-0.4166507721,
0.1272669733,
-0.6089117527,
0.4660620987,
-0.5315905809,
-0.3519856632,
-0.3079591393,
0.3942219615,
0.2646331191,
-0.2917302251,
0.806194663,
0.6896086335,
-0.2414752543,
-0.0961910859,
-0.4126935005,
-0.1732718498,
-0.3757778108,
0.296587646,
-0.2831948698,
-0.7743172646,
0.2428519726,
0.0611742325,
-0.1439351141,
0.7862174511,
0.6609401703,
-0.1735896617,
0.7888954878,
0.6005997658,
0.0998664126,
0.0963178948,
-0.1843018234,
0.3744647503,
-0.4985842109,
-0.2731634974,
-0.6053743362,
-0.1121398583,
-0.5429295301,
-0.4807815552,
-0.0742541328,
-0.0857056156,
-0.109675698,
0.5233047605,
-0.3377023935,
0.4287960529,
0.5531432033,
0.0211339835,
0.4245099425,
-0.346164912,
-0.2904498577,
0.0420673415,
-0.6568875909,
-0.7046464682,
0.5717414618,
0.3794919848,
0.7592291236,
0.2959041595,
0.5129956603,
-0.1144824922,
0.0664930791,
-0.9719629288,
0.5852788091,
-0.0084590847,
-0.9808660746,
-0.3652482927,
-0.6509971619,
-0.6955604553,
0.3240227699,
-0.0993608832,
-0.7114072442,
-0.0594735257,
0.0503595062,
-0.1562556922,
0.354450345,
-0.8103615642,
0.9108130932,
-0.1839189529,
-0.2312335372,
-0.1572805047,
-0.9470761418,
0.3568022251,
0.2788488865,
0.6916048527,
-0.2546067834,
-0.2546893656,
0.479257971,
-0.5495744944,
1.0182006359,
0.1943561435,
-0.1436511427,
0.7014478445,
-0.081090726,
0.4311615527,
0.1631878018,
0.0741392076,
-0.0626350865,
-0.054038208,
-0.3393526077,
-0.7952461839,
0.2774927616,
-0.6998122334,
-0.5771248937,
-0.4474119544,
-0.3211123645,
-0.0815721527,
0.09459503,
0.424849242,
0.4013463259,
-0.2344436646,
0.1624411792,
0.727031827,
-0.2372833341,
0.5137270093,
0.6178324223,
0.0865292773,
-0.2850494087,
0.8675254583,
0.208166033,
0.3151260912,
0.8227315545,
0.5306748748,
-0.2915301919,
-0.4339579046,
-0.1858131588,
0.0513418391,
-1.0250456333,
-0.101586774,
-0.729757309,
-0.2288718522,
-0.4745746553,
0.1259679794,
-0.1809361875,
-0.4803627431,
-0.3646886349,
-0.1289612204,
0.3172756135,
0.6770560145,
-0.1579973102,
0.2997618318,
-0.9014153481,
0.5181316137,
0.2762863338,
0.3214541376,
-0.2747319341,
-0.5070195794,
0.241367206,
0.1085176691,
-0.139904961,
-0.9641495347,
0.0884202942,
0.453235656,
0.7541143298,
0.2854942381,
-0.1735236347,
0.5503836274,
-0.6475400329,
0.5616682172,
0.0074398518,
-1.1473608017,
0.7546992302,
-0.3455949724,
0.2251716405,
0.6493788958,
0.3337670565,
-0.5819159746,
-0.2350736856,
-0.6856967211,
-0.9374412298,
0.4904792905,
0.3994418085,
0.3019496799,
-0.2276458293,
0.4745740891,
0.0263641383,
0.125557512,
-1.0376224518,
0.0756082758,
-0.3821693659,
-0.446893692,
-0.033643987,
-0.1814262718,
0.0747635737,
-0.3505701423,
0.5631014705,
-0.4335057735,
0.1870312989,
0.3489924669,
-0.4378412366,
0.2713491321,
0.5331175923,
0.7549217343,
0.7671874166,
0.0047326558,
0.4561597705,
0.433390677,
-0.4152082503,
0.0437537394,
-0.1463971287,
0.0175114702,
-0.1689640582,
0.8248122334,
0.5309386849,
0.3985093832,
-0.4434565604,
0.4042361379,
0.0288152341,
-0.4738057852,
-0.129857257,
0.0125834383,
0.2498560846,
0.0165192094,
0.1391670257,
-0.0093609747,
0.2792035043,
-1.0606589317,
0.2106578648,
0.4687252641,
-0.4983453453,
-0.1996331662,
0.2206080109,
0.3301525414,
-0.2961802781,
0.6815409064,
-0.1758981049,
-0.7093701363,
0.4572418034,
0.4060102701,
0.7610859871,
0.1062744409,
0.3318161964,
0.029933868,
0.5912973881,
-0.0914749429,
0.2398118675,
-0.0343365334,
-0.8328145742,
-0.9420217276,
-0.4476562142,
-0.3651118577,
-0.0636268482,
-0.2428358942,
0.2763079405,
-0.289740622,
0.0455461182,
0.0500921384,
0.0434121378,
-0.5492872,
0.1652311981,
0.0968752578,
1.118719697,
-0.6413265467,
0.6544851065,
0.7335519195,
-0.5652378798,
-0.628118813,
-0.1422295719,
-0.0697149485,
-0.832811892,
0.945189178,
0.1792613119,
-0.2076443732,
-0.1525621861,
-0.6404587626,
-0.7692433596,
0.7790561914,
0.3258077502,
-0.2473803461,
-0.0279562194,
0.2849048376,
0.5072816014,
-0.2220964432,
0.3843612671,
0.7395154238,
0.9864585996,
0.2996006012,
-0.7533131838,
-0.1002764702,
0.0003576385,
-0.2724801898,
0.4853690863,
-0.4733604491,
0.8758487701,
-0.2461855263,
-0.2458784878,
-0.2284236699,
0.6536644697,
-0.4508744776,
0.2853361666,
0.2813982368,
0.8635500669,
0.744987309,
-0.197675541,
0.9045802355,
0.2056030333,
0.2415032089,
1.0950510502,
-0.2498415709,
0.6374712586,
0.3541938663,
0.0700052455,
0.6857495308,
0.6033906937,
0.2427030504,
0.4054740667,
0.415138036,
-0.1803729236,
-0.3522463739,
0.1137082279,
-0.3003571033,
0.8252291083,
0.4680870175,
-0.1517825127,
-0.5643814802,
-0.0524921902,
0.2850226164,
0.1957992613,
-0.2663621306,
1.1775022745,
0.1999539733,
-0.5894770026,
0.1084073484,
0.3588005006,
0.4117727876,
-0.4910560548,
-0.0684618056,
0.04726189,
0.2215399742,
-0.2510137856,
-0.8364232779,
0.8245973587,
-0.197943598,
-0.0643200129,
-0.203765735,
1.1179889441,
-0.3676887751,
-0.5726000667,
0.3377149999,
0.6466415524,
-0.017518539,
-0.0149050718,
-0.8511943817,
-0.2867047489,
-0.5909252167,
-0.2564790547,
0.0552665778,
0.7670329809,
0.105366908,
0.7999406457,
0.6671808362,
-0.1818680018,
-0.1987680346,
-0.027397275,
0.9510502219,
-0.8161142468,
-0.3135000169,
-1.5775481462,
0.3151887357,
-0.0902456343,
-0.2501863539,
0.5310326815,
0.0716931671,
0.5525797606,
0.2189891189,
0.5826939344,
-0.2023719996,
0.3050521016,
-0.8281906843,
0.3133005798,
-0.365976125,
0.0817671791,
-0.3625161052,
-0.8391177058,
-0.647729218,
0.9508621097,
-0.4305564463,
-0.0195590947,
0.8141947985,
0.3893137276,
-0.1097412854,
0.0119814584,
0.1558554024,
0.2154588103,
0.3395728469,
0.7872400284,
1.1417703629,
-0.0816494003,
0.8116154671,
0.1768200547,
-0.1649384797,
-0.2123411298,
-1.3222938776,
-1.0824682713,
-0.3312023282,
-0.159382835,
-0.1868195236,
-0.0284363367,
0.8696618676,
0.7586426139,
-0.5310590863,
0.0306008682,
-0.5930370092,
0.6177693605,
-0.0573555604,
-0.2679008543,
0.1224837825,
-0.7356532812,
-0.2930839658,
0.3949565887,
0.5118051171,
-0.1186074093,
-0.306551218,
-0.1462779939,
-0.5497661829,
0.3780051768,
0.6208640337,
0.1051512063,
-0.8103124499,
-0.5189234614,
0.0331592374,
-0.0440719537,
0.0343788788,
0.8542963862,
-0.779769659,
0.1400445849,
0.8912166357,
0.6417056918,
0.0927888304,
-0.0805004165,
0.6767764688,
-0.3817743361,
0.0472010337,
0.4092043638,
0.2387807965,
0.1754686683,
-0.1150004119,
0.572201848,
0.4703009725,
-0.2608290315,
-0.5789243579,
0.6667175293,
-0.5277010798,
-0.6611328721,
1.0764523745,
0.0369350389,
-0.3885701299,
-0.5067649484,
-0.3011813164,
0.1199350953,
-0.0344653241,
0.3190595508,
0.9149015546,
-0.0674917176,
-0.167137146,
-0.7750788927,
0.6642022729,
0.199104175,
-1.0272656679,
-0.1035155579,
0.1525049359,
0.1790478379,
0.258916676,
0.6036980748,
-0.0020584068,
0.0498902313,
-0.2022213787,
-0.2724934518,
-0.1328157932,
-0.5203663111,
0.0405765995,
-0.0496978201,
-0.167037189,
-0.0009275955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10642v1 | Word Sense Induction with Knowledge Distillation from BERT | 2023-04-20T21:05:35 | 2023-04-20T21:05:35 | Anik Saha, Alex Gittens, Bulent Yener | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained contextual language models are ubiquitously employed for language
understanding tasks, but are unsuitable for resource-constrained systems.
Noncontextual word embeddings are an efficient alternative in these settings.
Such methods typically use one vector to encode multiple different meanings of
a word, and incur errors due to polysemy. This paper proposes a two-stage
method to distill multiple word senses from a pre-trained language model (BERT)
by using attention over the senses of a word in a context and transferring this
sense information to fit multi-sense embeddings in a skip-gram-like framework.
We demonstrate an effective approach to training the sense disambiguation
mechanism in our model with a distribution over word senses extracted from the
output layer embeddings of BERT. Experiments on the contextual word similarity
and sense induction tasks show that this method is superior to or competitive
with state-of-the-art multi-sense embeddings on multiple benchmark data sets,
and experiments with an embedding-based topic model (ETM) demonstrates the
benefits of using this multi-sense embedding in a downstream application. | [
-0.4366251826,
-0.5226016045,
0.7769789696,
0.1840132773,
-0.5084085464,
-0.2672237456,
-0.3396015763,
-0.1558697969,
0.0039144759,
-0.0314644054,
-0.4960264862,
-0.2856020033,
-0.9085305333,
-0.1389062256,
-0.4232117832,
0.6049294472,
-0.0947377756,
0.0430452041,
-0.3182082474,
-0.2409970313,
-0.4551646411,
-0.3936383426,
-0.1583651304,
-0.6048561931,
0.5615888238,
0.152408272,
0.0629938319,
0.3462582827,
0.0499337092,
0.2697997689,
-0.0845577195,
0.2894516885,
-0.3498098254,
-0.0342541151,
-0.2304893881,
-0.3753966689,
0.0153410863,
0.4380640984,
0.2444638908,
0.7891085148,
-0.2589570284,
-0.1769644171,
0.4262747169,
0.5351663828,
-0.8074755669,
0.2260141373,
-0.965082407,
-0.0548989438,
0.1137551814,
-0.0783992112,
-0.3502002656,
-0.1392789483,
0.4686239064,
-0.72142452,
0.1271884739,
-0.0260349289,
0.7950503826,
0.4952350557,
-0.1514443606,
-0.3533237576,
-0.2775655091,
0.9239156246,
-0.479154259,
0.7557438612,
0.4679555595,
0.0204145201,
-0.0024697981,
-0.6915661693,
-1.2121449709,
-0.1186193153,
-0.0300025064,
0.3354789317,
0.0784514248,
-0.0040034479,
0.0677554458,
-0.0171316564,
-0.3872024119,
-0.2568295896,
-0.105589956,
0.0142609272,
0.1067514718,
-0.4932564497,
-0.0316403843,
-0.1199691743,
-0.6559250951,
-0.3510902822,
-0.4191057384,
-0.3391471207,
-0.0183131173,
0.3551197648,
0.023668373,
0.3720034957,
-0.0357224979,
0.9205220342,
0.179747656,
-0.2969539165,
0.4029847383,
-0.3313095868,
-0.1788072586,
0.2822621167,
0.355227679,
0.2081860304,
0.3260436058,
-0.2846191525,
-0.1265900135,
0.3744208813,
0.2090536505,
-0.5951635838,
-0.1841816157,
0.1904136986,
-0.3840236962,
-0.1714953184,
0.1049577445,
-0.30624488,
-0.3062795401,
-0.5601081848,
0.6078340411,
-0.8075463176,
-0.3135944605,
0.1209027916,
-0.6345933676,
0.3233234584,
0.1966646463,
-0.8022919297,
-0.1460311413,
0.5498387814,
0.7357655764,
0.1084642783,
-0.520778954,
-0.3619511127,
0.2146350145,
-0.217790395,
0.6605055332,
-0.4916220605,
-0.1980660111,
-0.0335183553,
-0.1349141151,
-0.1779249609,
-0.4338301122,
0.1684964299,
-0.4771685898,
0.2756466866,
-0.4535082281,
-0.8001755476,
-0.3605762422,
0.355004251,
-0.1088714525,
0.9308039546,
0.1901505888,
-0.7814168334,
0.8595544696,
-0.7752732038,
-0.4400783777,
-0.0768326372,
-0.1100621819,
0.2990445495,
0.4819903374,
0.428152144,
0.4527223408,
0.1869539618,
0.2278326005,
-0.3114618063,
-0.1589127481,
0.0888242498,
-0.325022608,
0.5130262375,
0.193906337,
-0.1118571535,
-0.254475981,
-0.5680412054,
-0.1058222428,
0.1263940632,
-0.2607461512,
-0.9606438875,
0.1264504939,
-0.135401547,
0.356336385,
0.3333215714,
-0.5717445016,
0.0100055691,
-0.4946569502,
0.4669669271,
0.6149787307,
-0.1385468245,
0.4988253117,
-0.0323137864,
0.0237258952,
0.5176407695,
-0.1053349674,
-0.2239485979,
-0.4264843762,
-0.7230894566,
-0.2044045031,
0.3550275564,
0.3721459806,
-0.9477027059,
0.6915009618,
-0.1331769526,
-0.282356739,
-0.4865373075,
0.1593474746,
0.1388233453,
0.7552478909,
0.3889333904,
-0.0545047149,
-0.1161061898,
-0.6014855504,
-0.2222813219,
-0.1164461076,
-0.2299384028,
0.1705399454,
0.4201779962,
-0.1704780012,
0.9795198441,
-0.7358171344,
-0.4055712819,
-0.2765932977,
0.4254897833,
0.2307542861,
0.2659241259,
0.5897961259,
-0.7388017774,
-0.1696248949,
-0.2145625204,
-0.7141934037,
0.0099746147,
0.1041761264,
-0.354418993,
0.034033604,
0.4267918468,
-0.1750329733,
0.29956159,
0.7461510301,
-0.3345195651,
0.1500152349,
-0.277061969,
0.0115601635,
-1.4019382,
0.0591955148,
-0.0064775064,
-0.1044689715,
-0.6462825537,
0.0094504924,
0.2959864736,
-0.0015704527,
-0.533342123,
0.5068794489,
-0.453026861,
0.1305342019,
-0.4776982069,
0.5278230906,
0.3791437447,
0.4825759232,
0.2947208881,
0.5658310652,
0.5444765091,
-0.8999275565,
0.443841815,
0.3490430713,
-0.675570786,
0.5829292536,
-0.5184041858,
0.1761641204,
-0.4207953811,
-0.0386420414,
-1.1354123354,
0.0987993181,
0.2168639302,
-0.5033548474,
0.2667554617,
0.1013635769,
-0.3808335066,
-0.3586261272,
-0.2164724171,
0.1834516227,
0.3680657148,
-0.9095262289,
0.4432160258,
0.2363819778,
-0.0574118532,
-0.497970283,
-0.8362355232,
-0.1904632896,
-0.2569409311,
-0.2937329113,
0.428537935,
0.1436561495,
-0.1319008619,
0.2008720189,
-0.1510879993,
-0.1745817959,
0.3208629191,
-0.0436138697,
-0.0626494065,
0.2683881819,
0.6852179766,
0.4922633767,
-0.01234941,
-0.0825540796,
-0.8315112591,
0.4513792396,
0.4311238825,
-0.5838864446,
-0.1305968612,
0.5542980433,
0.5284563303,
-0.283184886,
0.8645537496,
0.6359147429,
-0.5106924176,
-0.3670733273,
-0.4677450359,
-0.6214805245,
-0.400364846,
0.3258546591,
-0.4694489539,
-0.6651567817,
0.2551156878,
-0.3986465633,
0.0391529649,
0.1225188822,
0.3084715903,
-0.2026490718,
0.8053421974,
0.7326068282,
-0.1280188709,
0.7210439444,
-0.1236679256,
0.4582791328,
-0.7350481749,
-0.1792255491,
-0.3652616143,
-0.5333688259,
-0.1946135461,
-0.5708926916,
0.4301491678,
0.462560147,
0.2176369578,
0.1184204519,
-0.4381790459,
0.1001807377,
0.9082343578,
0.3231060803,
0.0852099285,
0.2668503821,
-0.4773452878,
0.0722299665,
-0.827790916,
-0.2049740851,
0.8836603761,
0.106389761,
0.5712521672,
0.0207011402,
0.9413751364,
-0.0392748453,
0.2201711684,
-1.0094782114,
0.2904458642,
-0.1937871426,
-0.4350857139,
-0.3831394315,
-0.0530114584,
-0.6130868196,
0.4443168342,
-0.1357185096,
-0.680646956,
0.416708827,
0.0849032775,
-0.2921598554,
0.0000648726,
-1.0067312717,
0.7514004111,
-0.0608098619,
-0.1963987648,
-0.3149677515,
-0.4015882611,
0.2569945455,
-0.2425142378,
0.1645238549,
-0.0999676213,
0.0929353535,
0.7595975399,
-0.5889746547,
0.560539782,
-0.7288988829,
-0.355401814,
0.2915827632,
-0.3091250658,
0.4028622508,
-0.01323188,
-0.1117208824,
0.2409911156,
-0.0815637186,
-0.1619052142,
-0.6335564852,
0.5696171522,
-0.5765601993,
-0.5727137327,
-0.3811467886,
-0.5125793219,
-0.4076966345,
0.1979820579,
0.275324434,
0.32244277,
-0.0391204879,
-0.0023277851,
0.6840718985,
-0.2582731247,
0.627364397,
0.3765880764,
0.0184872746,
0.1484997123,
0.715539813,
-0.0144969132,
0.1653851122,
0.4498388171,
0.3368248343,
-0.8195415139,
-0.2871639132,
-0.2157525569,
-0.0944516733,
-0.4910782278,
-0.00857786,
-0.6707420945,
0.0753094926,
-0.5052828789,
-0.0334281549,
-0.1472657621,
-0.0030585956,
-0.1826426536,
-0.0671123788,
0.5268951058,
0.3698523939,
-0.3871384561,
0.3253827393,
-0.8163061142,
0.6476163268,
0.6719649434,
0.3362731338,
0.0757294446,
-0.6059857607,
-0.2001832873,
0.2279940844,
-0.2089650482,
-1.0053704977,
0.4631930292,
0.5090287924,
0.5641748309,
0.8939301968,
0.1510171741,
0.8356227875,
-0.5947368741,
0.6608783603,
0.3437404633,
-1.1833136082,
0.9323447347,
-0.0859979987,
0.514039278,
0.503172338,
0.4755457044,
-0.4574689269,
-0.4188281298,
-0.2548258603,
-0.8794153929,
0.7195416689,
-0.2066918015,
0.1937293857,
-0.369929105,
0.1574731469,
0.3373450339,
0.3969265819,
-0.3491679728,
-0.1253581494,
-0.3315202296,
-0.2296309769,
-0.2523576319,
-0.501875937,
-0.164593488,
-0.3461450338,
0.4818609357,
-0.2084281445,
0.401073575,
0.1511162668,
-0.5454866886,
0.4019908011,
0.2603274286,
0.3811115324,
0.8515316248,
-0.0970914066,
0.3465089798,
0.2608391047,
-0.4287864268,
0.0426873229,
0.2010001689,
0.1895584315,
0.2855848372,
0.2907270491,
0.7335934639,
0.1895991713,
-0.3255002797,
0.5804148316,
-0.0856181681,
-0.3746596873,
-0.0101249153,
-0.1658606976,
0.2657820284,
0.2817700207,
0.4495726228,
-0.4319665432,
0.1183789298,
-0.4475694299,
0.291827172,
0.3324543238,
-0.1501007229,
0.0118727051,
0.4223967195,
0.2007866353,
0.4288217425,
0.6555398107,
-0.4355973601,
-0.5671299696,
0.1944583654,
0.4490698576,
0.7437975407,
-0.2336986959,
0.0196794868,
0.1995031387,
0.1194799468,
-0.0365838669,
0.7396953702,
-0.4215983152,
-1.2544946671,
-0.5308851004,
-0.8643122911,
-0.0771706253,
0.2284887582,
-0.7886276841,
-0.0667803958,
-0.1511610448,
-0.1121823192,
-0.0427475646,
-0.2755416334,
-0.876079917,
0.1672145426,
0.3749237955,
0.8182498217,
-1.0614624023,
1.1419655085,
0.9027354717,
-0.1240877733,
-0.9446773529,
0.292837292,
-0.20516707,
-0.9230077863,
0.8830189109,
0.3038161993,
0.0334827416,
0.0602501407,
-0.3735862374,
-0.5463761687,
0.9922973514,
0.1451176256,
-0.912768662,
0.2409167141,
-0.2719342113,
0.1249154061,
-0.0468560606,
0.0660340488,
0.5464708209,
0.5712450147,
0.0595558621,
-0.6417816281,
-0.0169652756,
0.1089829654,
0.267611444,
0.1230853871,
-0.1642546654,
0.7078624964,
-0.0859868154,
-0.2460687011,
-0.4041974843,
0.6668736339,
0.335596025,
0.1773703396,
0.8255915046,
0.9073512554,
0.8430631757,
-0.2672655284,
0.6243264675,
-0.8186450005,
0.2297492921,
1.0817266703,
-0.4523000121,
0.7336357832,
1.0419905186,
-0.2278039306,
0.4433990717,
0.5194582939,
0.3486163616,
1.1605358124,
0.2305029929,
-0.4099921584,
-0.20923087,
-0.2550474107,
-0.4968315661,
0.6995443702,
0.5467541814,
-0.3937774301,
-0.4406174719,
0.321800828,
-0.2406069934,
0.0183413159,
-0.1820105761,
1.0065319538,
0.2126571387,
-0.5653888583,
0.4726059139,
0.0061896169,
0.8905882835,
-0.6243434548,
-0.1140880063,
-0.2859705091,
0.2183551937,
0.2267869413,
-0.461225003,
0.261505127,
-0.0447184034,
-0.3442784548,
-0.514652431,
0.8302369118,
-0.6293036342,
-0.3609760702,
0.4934377372,
0.8164023161,
0.1810984462,
-0.424262315,
-0.49192518,
-0.0685927123,
-0.3577081561,
-0.2192245126,
0.2046909034,
0.7768473625,
0.1944559366,
0.2236630321,
0.5185206532,
0.1017661691,
0.0681244209,
0.4264359772,
0.8597638607,
-0.4694779217,
-0.7357103825,
-0.8572279215,
0.3124440908,
0.0054987948,
-0.0905348212,
0.5746739507,
-0.0093846377,
0.9824346304,
-0.2207338065,
1.1227817535,
-0.206232205,
0.3268706799,
-0.4797200263,
0.7795288563,
-0.8129583001,
-0.2711151838,
-0.2098961771,
-0.9641130567,
0.1068448126,
0.9465395212,
-0.1912825704,
0.0301646013,
0.7743604183,
0.5073778033,
-0.0406292081,
-0.1329563558,
0.4869524539,
0.0498328507,
-0.0228139125,
0.5896680355,
0.6976884007,
-0.0762240887,
0.0244118422,
-0.1835698187,
-0.4824650288,
-0.2303615361,
-0.9829897881,
-0.8568208814,
-0.7862434387,
-0.042104505,
-0.0483172908,
0.0977601707,
0.7267908454,
0.8599758744,
-0.7491502762,
0.2202930599,
-0.248778671,
0.1278755516,
-0.4235954583,
-0.2101559639,
0.2795954049,
-0.6901950836,
-0.9073780179,
0.5715799332,
0.1779806763,
-0.1028342396,
-0.2733642459,
0.2536873817,
-0.4727033675,
-0.1231745407,
0.9552030563,
-0.284493506,
-0.7359237075,
-0.5672627091,
-0.2577497661,
0.1367265731,
-0.4544305205,
0.5099208951,
-0.9445897937,
0.5728477836,
0.7359263301,
0.6044897437,
0.2402032763,
-0.0432475135,
0.6025586724,
-1.1118694544,
0.6075350046,
-0.120524101,
0.5226207972,
0.0964922532,
-0.1182553247,
0.117958568,
0.259090662,
0.1537673175,
-0.5835953355,
0.2102968693,
-0.7391338944,
-0.5426208377,
1.0554162264,
-0.3271104395,
-0.1133429483,
-0.0397199504,
0.0857145265,
0.5451239944,
-0.3369430602,
0.7503165007,
0.9131565094,
0.009354338,
-0.0406007431,
-0.2197887003,
0.1441421658,
0.425726831,
-0.5256842375,
-0.0453118235,
0.3232217729,
0.2887434065,
0.2981330454,
0.2973496914,
0.0601237044,
-0.1467704624,
0.1127164736,
0.3085614741,
-0.1960118711,
-0.4954459965,
-0.2086649388,
0.0415847786,
0.1353411078,
-0.885386169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10637v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10637v3 | IXA/Cogcomp at SemEval-2023 Task 2: Context-enriched Multilingual Named Entity Recognition using Knowledge Bases | 2023-04-20T20:30:34 | 2023-04-27T20:51:36 | Iker García-Ferrero, Jon Ander Campos, Oscar Sainz, Ander Salaberria, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a core natural language processing task in
which pre-trained language models have shown remarkable performance. However,
standard benchmarks like CoNLL 2003 do not address many of the challenges that
deployed NER systems face, such as having to classify emerging or complex
entities in a fine-grained way. In this paper we present a novel NER cascade
approach comprising three steps: first, identifying candidate entities in the
input sentence; second, linking the each candidate to an existing knowledge
base; third, predicting the fine-grained category for each entity candidate. We
empirically demonstrate the significance of external knowledge bases in
accurately classifying fine-grained and emerging entities. Our system exhibits
robust performance in the MultiCoNER2 shared task, even in the low-resource
language setting where we leverage knowledge bases of high-resource languages. | [
-0.7243942618,
-0.5369241834,
0.3735463917,
0.1467967778,
0.1523394883,
0.0201826617,
-0.3483255208,
-0.8563281894,
-0.032182131,
0.3855169117,
-0.2503859103,
-0.1897462904,
-0.541385293,
0.2558571696,
-0.3156326115,
0.9376417398,
-0.1626879871,
0.2006978691,
-0.1644370705,
-0.1744739115,
-0.5596728325,
-0.4710649252,
-1.0776048899,
-0.3161691725,
0.4233605862,
0.6001378894,
0.1025250405,
0.2543771565,
0.4508698583,
0.2033480257,
-0.0280034821,
0.2399127632,
-0.1400957853,
0.2246282101,
-0.465850234,
-0.0889389589,
-0.2766884565,
-0.4855956137,
0.4867209196,
0.6294977069,
0.0087628402,
0.2142145932,
0.3931171298,
0.4106188118,
-0.6544507146,
0.3482769728,
-0.6462343931,
-0.1168211177,
-0.5076572895,
-0.1187321246,
-0.4475384653,
-0.0336299166,
0.4276625812,
-0.4694431126,
0.0080577014,
0.0287043341,
0.7589986324,
0.1320264488,
-0.6658642292,
-0.5510742664,
-0.6999325156,
0.656613946,
-0.349842608,
0.5578077435,
0.0860857591,
0.3669659495,
-0.1824768633,
-0.9008815289,
-0.5901580453,
0.2011453807,
-0.2047438473,
-0.1649463624,
-0.2170636207,
-0.06340345,
0.1436303556,
0.2573334277,
-0.2618352473,
0.0702222884,
-0.210335359,
-0.2434950322,
0.0980140418,
-0.1087203696,
0.3721638322,
-0.1678628623,
-0.537884593,
0.2286582589,
-0.6005292535,
0.2286270261,
0.0016285069,
0.6958062053,
0.0022691987,
0.4268492758,
-0.6181340218,
0.4891318381,
0.3120807707,
-0.0555187687,
0.2865201235,
-0.2434841841,
-0.098010771,
0.406126678,
0.5494384766,
0.1155380309,
0.0872139409,
-0.2999641597,
-0.1910178214,
-0.1582036465,
-0.0863465592,
-0.7913194299,
-0.1625257283,
-0.0230244137,
-0.1295068711,
0.001423888,
-0.2718007863,
-0.8381391168,
-0.3907661736,
-0.5874926448,
0.6608232856,
-0.4853747189,
-0.1857640743,
-0.4057493806,
0.0657856986,
0.2459978163,
0.4664111137,
-0.6547663808,
0.5884135365,
0.6333389878,
0.5518349409,
-0.1855180711,
-0.189937681,
-0.7440360785,
0.3853785992,
0.0986571312,
0.9657459259,
-0.5548128486,
0.1285062283,
-0.2359310985,
0.2476480454,
-0.0692173094,
-0.5233225822,
0.4883009791,
-0.8070271015,
0.100866124,
-0.3595643342,
-0.4793986678,
-0.318810463,
0.4873972237,
-0.7253867388,
0.9050455093,
0.1450071037,
-1.0341244936,
0.5467987061,
-0.469643265,
-0.5331847072,
0.3142966926,
-0.3666825593,
0.0084559135,
-0.1417933106,
0.2076833546,
0.4642929733,
-0.428180486,
0.5419999957,
-0.0787087977,
-0.0566276908,
-0.2144117653,
-0.3372702897,
0.4655809104,
0.1090352684,
-0.464843154,
-0.2304356992,
-0.815395236,
0.1055676118,
-0.1732940227,
-0.4056937397,
-0.6890912056,
-0.0409935638,
0.0430546887,
0.427319169,
0.3919801712,
-0.2757971287,
0.07438609,
-0.3516560495,
0.1141618416,
0.3075719476,
0.2086705863,
0.7358989716,
0.3211815059,
0.145432502,
0.241911754,
-0.2456947118,
0.0045798449,
-0.2997172177,
-1.0259828568,
-0.0317338742,
0.4721644223,
0.7031912804,
-0.7846314907,
-0.0110693481,
-0.391949147,
-0.3054718673,
0.0027955982,
0.0363341123,
0.2810737491,
0.6999955773,
0.725086689,
-0.1250527054,
-0.8759442568,
-1.0008472204,
-0.2158825845,
0.087792486,
0.3045762777,
0.515108943,
0.525226295,
-0.5756748319,
0.854837954,
-0.1776260734,
-0.4617331028,
-0.2237160653,
0.2358004153,
0.0964814723,
0.520227313,
0.0722266361,
-0.7175344825,
-0.5368034244,
0.4394932985,
-0.7071300745,
0.010995443,
0.1207690611,
-0.0181746595,
0.1575091332,
0.7917463183,
-0.4219456911,
-0.0242660604,
0.3110335171,
-0.108705923,
0.2377435118,
0.1053653955,
0.0248770416,
-1.2351615429,
0.1260064542,
-0.0860337317,
-0.1570066214,
-0.7260554433,
-0.0162182599,
0.1239011213,
0.0429926999,
-0.4624142349,
0.906226933,
-0.7763473988,
0.0062876125,
-0.1894696206,
0.0067201024,
-0.1767832637,
0.4615824223,
0.2672025561,
0.6389631629,
0.530174017,
-0.9285846353,
0.0392786004,
0.0808430016,
-0.3032365739,
0.7823684216,
-0.1879657507,
0.0179058928,
-0.1770310849,
0.1837434471,
-0.3568621874,
-0.4387716949,
0.1964458227,
-0.3806414306,
0.6034796834,
-0.2883082032,
-0.2365119755,
-0.0863077343,
0.2855635881,
0.5702329278,
-0.0894566625,
-0.5714255571,
0.8054081202,
0.6673368812,
-0.2318169028,
-0.7277895212,
-0.7149106264,
0.2645277679,
-0.2154500484,
-0.4272901714,
0.4331007302,
0.3012456596,
-0.2715894282,
0.1115586013,
-0.1959812492,
-0.4293126464,
0.0386303291,
0.1578056961,
-0.1047460511,
-0.3445235491,
0.0799852386,
0.1780489683,
-0.1402879208,
-0.1179115251,
-0.4133742452,
0.5593010783,
-0.2858242989,
-0.0235858224,
-0.2925660312,
0.2939114273,
0.2982464731,
-0.2988491654,
0.7172517776,
0.7695724368,
-0.9815489054,
-0.1899564415,
-0.5656053424,
0.164008826,
-0.3960398436,
0.238545686,
-0.7089543343,
-1.0001766682,
0.3162887394,
-0.3249655366,
-0.325081259,
0.6041430235,
0.3734889328,
0.2696735859,
0.7044458389,
0.6359488368,
-0.0175852235,
0.2215270996,
-0.1424064189,
0.4555023611,
-1.0958544016,
-0.5570240021,
-0.4828951657,
-0.0899101421,
-0.622441411,
-0.4872223735,
0.1080023274,
0.4861676097,
-0.1956379563,
0.810742259,
-0.1871114671,
0.4134916067,
0.5252940655,
-0.2560558021,
0.3153478205,
-0.0079931449,
-0.3432972431,
0.0418432504,
-0.3286444247,
-0.5684011579,
0.6019057631,
0.1552805156,
0.5221284032,
0.1721543521,
0.8617239594,
0.0996311605,
0.2549226582,
-0.7551104426,
0.5264341831,
-0.0915126055,
-0.5434811711,
-0.1161292568,
-0.3227618039,
-0.7413955927,
0.1483200639,
0.0467879213,
-0.9129721522,
0.5213593841,
0.0264217015,
-0.4509120882,
0.0785412043,
-0.6142467856,
0.8427468538,
-0.257812947,
-0.2577491701,
-0.0134701096,
-0.5978884101,
0.3055736423,
-0.2726946771,
0.391014576,
-0.1302736104,
-0.0837269425,
0.6000293493,
-0.0243406054,
0.344704628,
-0.3069333434,
0.0240517911,
0.3225947022,
0.0919637233,
0.6509045959,
0.4864806235,
-0.1470719874,
0.1732967347,
-0.1077944562,
0.0170958899,
-0.2877001464,
1.0122256279,
-0.4700866938,
-0.2070716172,
-0.5302020311,
-0.157543391,
-0.4007685483,
0.6373981237,
0.2812333405,
0.6445683241,
-0.3412911594,
0.296256572,
0.509080112,
-0.1618218571,
0.5016232729,
0.5036193132,
0.0325606465,
-0.5466290116,
0.8346111774,
0.2465482205,
-0.054829035,
0.840531826,
-0.2427725643,
-0.2285542488,
-0.5170458555,
-0.4356485009,
-0.2499664724,
-0.749151051,
-0.5194728971,
-1.2282081842,
-0.3082893789,
-0.4779664874,
0.0679606348,
-0.2139409482,
-0.3147448301,
-0.4065740705,
0.1474917233,
-0.1305213273,
0.5365594029,
0.0288212281,
0.148453936,
-0.6743494272,
0.1982478201,
0.3154159188,
0.3107293844,
-0.031514395,
-0.2937688828,
-0.2919610739,
-0.1305513382,
-0.0916666687,
-0.7236941457,
0.2941887379,
0.4410689771,
0.7481908202,
0.4168456197,
-0.1352112889,
0.8976993561,
-0.8111531734,
0.4506490231,
-0.0515025631,
-0.8195296526,
0.6912516356,
-0.0617271811,
0.1558544487,
0.8931596279,
0.4263117611,
-0.5825836658,
0.0061959657,
-0.4357503653,
-1.0585457087,
0.9200400114,
0.0674930066,
-0.0824708045,
-0.2890646756,
0.139624998,
0.1406033635,
0.2006860375,
-0.8403345942,
-0.1675040722,
0.3164762259,
-0.1775509268,
0.1780071557,
-0.2265202701,
0.2255458683,
-0.0079306168,
0.9066896439,
-0.2287653983,
0.2320370674,
0.1676583439,
-0.567029655,
0.0556316189,
0.58711797,
0.1530399621,
0.2416065782,
0.040896222,
0.4247998893,
0.6121563315,
-0.2082687169,
0.0711930022,
0.4051877856,
-0.1979849339,
-0.1566537023,
0.2514861822,
0.6981474757,
0.5642383695,
-0.5066681504,
0.4814931452,
-0.2147137076,
0.2246847153,
-0.5413317084,
-0.1244131774,
0.0852575824,
0.4906366765,
0.2853898108,
0.6015705466,
0.5992766619,
-0.395822227,
0.4071217775,
0.3746737838,
-0.6337710023,
-0.341722995,
0.3334394991,
0.0952721685,
-0.0316907167,
0.3573911786,
-0.6736070514,
-0.5850597024,
0.397456795,
0.7161010504,
0.7554617524,
-0.2339767665,
-0.12938793,
0.7149515152,
0.1756401807,
-0.3704397976,
0.2075943053,
-0.1364269555,
-0.7694446445,
-0.32072559,
-0.9367209673,
-0.18796736,
0.2903731465,
-0.6651005745,
0.7081425786,
-0.1685225368,
-0.066128619,
0.0689094067,
0.0109069571,
-1.0150536299,
0.3827781379,
0.6193224788,
0.9392315149,
-0.4680352509,
0.7749624848,
0.8489212394,
-0.329205513,
-0.9011380672,
0.0991278216,
-0.0652718917,
-0.407823801,
0.8040097952,
0.5549730659,
-0.1136097461,
0.2131228,
0.0125571229,
-1.4008078575,
1.1117949486,
0.1981090456,
-0.636880219,
-0.2331037521,
-0.0791707784,
0.3419552445,
-0.354247719,
0.3501569331,
0.4460268915,
0.4803240597,
0.0213509314,
-0.9347779155,
0.0573556945,
-0.2608113587,
-0.0502835251,
0.4288491309,
-0.455542475,
0.7410327792,
-0.2477670908,
-0.5163026452,
-0.100342907,
0.9221130013,
0.1003352553,
0.4637154639,
0.5010297298,
0.6957323551,
0.9059440494,
-0.1025005952,
0.6370494366,
-0.5275128484,
0.3129955828,
1.594558835,
-0.488573581,
1.0594702959,
0.4783204496,
0.0505432263,
0.7208894491,
0.5433229804,
0.1478849649,
0.6625663638,
-0.0147796804,
-0.405954212,
-0.0106714042,
-0.4620940089,
-0.3382734954,
0.5050920844,
0.4695643783,
-0.185839653,
-0.3918942213,
0.1353893429,
0.0209982283,
-0.4116294384,
-0.400378108,
0.8134672642,
0.2082744688,
-0.8541331291,
-0.1083134338,
0.1095498055,
0.7156956196,
-0.2404086143,
-0.0189870484,
0.0574828386,
0.5218994617,
-0.3112680912,
-0.5715582967,
0.3098203242,
0.0130772144,
-0.1845383644,
0.0351805277,
1.0657883883,
-0.6080771685,
-0.3645847142,
0.6619579792,
0.5544517636,
-0.0099236285,
-0.2687455714,
-0.3550242782,
-0.4185915291,
-0.3136918843,
-0.1321471184,
0.1728419065,
0.7076358795,
-0.3567739725,
0.4712842703,
0.2736804783,
-0.1305456161,
-0.0278358031,
0.2880392969,
0.6218085885,
-0.6868625879,
-0.4677751958,
-0.8008171916,
0.291107595,
-0.0545805991,
-0.2655871212,
0.6947732568,
0.8122569323,
1.098384738,
0.0687682033,
0.736931324,
-0.4315756559,
0.4948828816,
-0.3005616069,
0.2946288288,
-0.4676885605,
0.1822782308,
-0.2496804744,
-0.9084310532,
-0.1858781278,
0.211992994,
-0.2013450414,
-0.1381270438,
0.8338259459,
0.6470171809,
-0.2348345369,
-0.1196830049,
-0.0603516549,
0.0903449431,
0.0677931532,
0.5742599964,
0.8731905818,
-0.5926231146,
0.574716866,
-0.2879382074,
0.0633519813,
-0.1955019832,
-0.7411352992,
-0.6626909971,
-0.5574421883,
-0.3072812557,
-0.1503224224,
-0.0626318157,
1.1391890049,
0.6081042886,
-1.239561677,
0.09299732,
-0.235963583,
-0.059218917,
-0.1069323644,
-0.275948137,
0.1015355438,
-0.3884953856,
-0.6381276846,
0.5632600188,
0.3997258842,
-0.0652645603,
0.0019265801,
-0.0336892083,
-0.3559502661,
-0.2142761648,
0.6156279445,
0.1247834042,
-0.6947203875,
-0.2913317084,
-0.0167540163,
-0.2812536061,
-0.1124003306,
0.6265984178,
-0.9112062454,
0.2157671303,
0.6211409569,
0.8141348958,
0.3002142012,
-0.1470017135,
0.3542881012,
-0.6411998868,
-0.2416923195,
0.1813718826,
0.5194518566,
0.5092933774,
-0.4689049125,
0.5399860144,
0.0950791091,
-0.4385219514,
-0.711312592,
0.0137995919,
-0.9081525207,
0.0197052471,
1.1521757841,
0.1004127637,
0.0025311885,
-0.3678611815,
-0.0984847695,
0.4477876425,
-0.4415509701,
0.1759400368,
0.5724443793,
-0.167666018,
-0.0984124467,
-0.6688792706,
0.5245212317,
-0.0363892652,
-0.995937407,
-0.2822670639,
0.3808665276,
0.409792155,
0.3935741484,
0.6767371297,
-0.0940055475,
0.0156771485,
-0.2310900688,
0.0807206109,
0.3047594726,
-0.6287045479,
-0.265606761,
0.3271573782,
0.0246303603,
0.1609147936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10619v1 | "HOT" ChatGPT: The promise of ChatGPT in detecting and discriminating hateful, offensive, and toxic comments on social media | 2023-04-20T19:40:51 | 2023-04-20T19:40:51 | Lingyao Li, Lizhou Fan, Shubham Atreja, Libby Hemphill | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Harmful content is pervasive on social media, poisoning online communities
and negatively impacting participation. A common approach to address this issue
is to develop detection models that rely on human annotations. However, the
tasks required to build such models expose annotators to harmful and offensive
content and may require significant time and cost to complete. Generative AI
models have the potential to understand and detect harmful content. To
investigate this potential, we used ChatGPT and compared its performance with
MTurker annotations for three frequently discussed concepts related to harmful
content: Hateful, Offensive, and Toxic (HOT). We designed five prompts to
interact with ChatGPT and conducted four experiments eliciting HOT
classifications. Our results show that ChatGPT can achieve an accuracy of
approximately 80% when compared to MTurker annotations. Specifically, the model
displays a more consistent classification for non-HOT comments than HOT
comments compared to human annotations. Our findings also suggest that ChatGPT
classifications align with provided HOT definitions, but ChatGPT classifies
"hateful" and "offensive" as subsets of "toxic." Moreover, the choice of
prompts used to interact with ChatGPT impacts its performance. Based on these
in-sights, our study provides several meaningful implications for employing
ChatGPT to detect HOT content, particularly regarding the reliability and
consistency of its performance, its understand-ing and reasoning of the HOT
concept, and the impact of prompts on its performance. Overall, our study
provides guidance about the potential of using generative AI models to moderate
large volumes of user-generated content on social media. | [
-0.406845212,
-1.1759172678,
0.1136433631,
0.2060523778,
-0.6341584921,
-0.0018879356,
-0.1904403269,
-0.4517237246,
-0.0443810821,
0.4073704183,
-0.3129061162,
-0.3580919206,
-0.9199538231,
-0.0341012925,
-0.7257453203,
1.401501894,
0.3272641301,
-0.4584065974,
0.111485526,
-0.0566342473,
-0.4438103735,
-0.5392378569,
-0.907084167,
-0.0080555426,
0.8733634949,
0.159390077,
0.9271756411,
0.3506838679,
0.7817285061,
0.3076647818,
-0.1520175189,
0.0232454203,
-0.6423928142,
0.3955496848,
-0.1210401431,
-0.1190862134,
-0.1126454249,
0.1144872084,
0.0165018626,
0.0365805179,
-0.0166893564,
0.0775881335,
0.1769176722,
0.5051168799,
-0.5525760055,
0.1452329755,
-0.6226896644,
0.1912846863,
-0.2576725185,
-0.2873609066,
-0.4881799519,
-0.4085281789,
0.1540478617,
-0.5283424258,
0.3901679218,
-0.1226350963,
0.7088841796,
0.4774930775,
-0.4184418917,
-0.3115042746,
-1.0163557529,
0.4412078857,
-0.5396552086,
0.2471335828,
0.4005223513,
0.262614131,
0.1127213016,
-0.5060842633,
-0.8011627793,
-0.2272211015,
-0.0714039057,
0.2336280793,
-0.5044907331,
-0.0504371636,
0.4523628652,
0.2216213495,
-0.6658127308,
0.1576788872,
-0.3502348661,
-0.1227522045,
0.6875365376,
0.1283129752,
0.5800871849,
-0.3527082503,
-0.3909553885,
-0.0117601687,
-0.4604567885,
-0.3895808458,
0.3880425096,
0.2960780859,
-0.0583620258,
0.5719742179,
0.1429010183,
0.2750626802,
-0.1666263193,
0.2448530644,
0.1529746801,
0.0525042601,
-0.0902982131,
-0.2748265564,
1.1393023729,
0.7256728411,
0.3862884641,
-0.1216718853,
0.0449439734,
0.5142561793,
0.450912863,
-0.9115069509,
-0.7286897302,
-0.0936370194,
-0.3485367298,
-0.6022638083,
-0.1459650248,
-0.8672525883,
-1.0579805374,
0.0376482196,
0.2427943647,
-0.4075864553,
-0.6485764384,
-0.3272333145,
-0.4085417986,
-0.0355257094,
0.4786376059,
-0.5871921182,
-0.0359871201,
0.5511736274,
0.8754294515,
-0.2905743122,
0.0973171219,
-0.2877901793,
-0.0843244791,
-0.1541690081,
1.1051801443,
-0.7778468132,
-0.3335978687,
0.2117685527,
-0.2126061767,
0.1645560414,
-0.5210267305,
0.774774313,
-0.7201943994,
0.0989884511,
-0.421120733,
-0.3796533942,
-0.3033775687,
0.3249720633,
-0.7213798165,
0.9299455881,
0.0146916704,
-1.1079846621,
0.3607504368,
-0.8569080234,
-0.5087040663,
0.4327222407,
0.1191599369,
-0.5168910027,
-0.4206292927,
0.0343325995,
0.5739090443,
-0.1053446382,
-0.115753606,
-0.3670293689,
-0.5042574406,
0.5600524545,
-0.6065418124,
0.7202589512,
0.63377738,
-0.647706151,
0.3573768139,
-0.1864078045,
-0.4354425371,
0.4261730909,
-0.3908239901,
-0.3886667788,
0.2121691108,
0.413304776,
0.1040071771,
-0.3256255388,
-0.3992162347,
-0.1818085164,
0.054860156,
0.5064243078,
0.9358432889,
0.0841590762,
0.0115109831,
-0.4319622815,
0.4967370927,
0.1320437342,
0.2110889256,
0.1480529606,
-0.769667089,
-0.5255425572,
0.1405924261,
-0.0138949109,
0.6943171024,
-1.0117815733,
0.2131979018,
0.0152821476,
-0.751550734,
-0.1881140918,
0.074239023,
0.4254384935,
0.310180366,
0.3320338428,
-0.2843186855,
-0.3824055195,
-0.6180981994,
-0.3797665536,
-0.4249628186,
-0.0683905706,
0.3358907104,
0.2075107396,
-0.1611804068,
0.3133032024,
-0.3063632548,
-0.1769855022,
-0.0984387919,
0.4868679345,
-0.1336103976,
0.2668693364,
0.6059730053,
-1.2892959118,
-0.861151576,
-0.0869606361,
-0.8292352557,
-0.2133211941,
0.1914220601,
-0.2627139688,
-0.3648944497,
0.2643949687,
-0.4796499908,
0.4523987174,
0.3790397644,
-0.3244040906,
0.3424401283,
0.3976733088,
0.6101868749,
-0.7710425258,
-0.065898262,
0.3028090596,
0.0052370909,
-0.8836234212,
0.2014080286,
-0.2938081026,
-0.3267740011,
-0.7332423925,
0.2326463461,
0.0899613127,
0.579382956,
-0.3686636388,
0.1161557063,
-0.2674622238,
0.3772714138,
0.0123500535,
0.7608058453,
0.191860646,
-0.488014102,
0.656819582,
0.0256619882,
-0.2509894669,
0.4442551434,
-0.5338419676,
0.4446085691,
-0.2804096043,
0.2585420609,
-0.9416029453,
-0.1982077956,
0.7485968471,
-0.5114164352,
-0.1218975261,
-0.4370233119,
-0.7737524509,
-0.3801497817,
-0.1696960628,
0.5849303007,
0.6610797644,
-0.2813602686,
0.4182519913,
0.5882155299,
-0.0696169809,
-0.3811059594,
-0.4104135931,
0.0416644923,
-0.5221551061,
-0.5031807423,
0.0002795077,
-0.0419301055,
-0.2959360182,
0.0440971814,
0.2646533251,
-0.0484912023,
0.1793727875,
0.5706973672,
0.054994151,
-0.0834977925,
0.1608755291,
-0.3158801496,
0.0071542282,
0.1203990728,
0.1721200347,
0.6736631393,
-0.0769612938,
-0.1667311043,
-0.3694038391,
0.4434036016,
0.5320483446,
-0.2622113228,
0.5509539247,
1.0896770954,
-0.3183327317,
0.0758160576,
-0.5581275225,
-0.0867035761,
-0.4851753414,
0.1062533706,
0.1746366173,
-0.7938738465,
0.4682515562,
0.2521643043,
0.2910010219,
0.5475378036,
0.6804643273,
-0.1705560237,
1.2065044641,
0.3368457854,
-0.009924883,
0.8459124565,
-0.1397034824,
0.2038978636,
-0.519856751,
-0.0600830987,
-0.4606880248,
-0.1980538666,
-0.8586657047,
-0.4086101055,
0.3900208771,
-0.4357072413,
-0.3833671212,
0.2509607673,
-0.7841864228,
0.5390328169,
0.547508359,
0.439283222,
0.0546059608,
0.048603721,
0.3040865958,
-0.0205290578,
-0.4145831466,
-0.530226469,
0.8339949846,
0.4240449369,
0.8166102171,
0.4592592716,
0.136961326,
0.8295291662,
0.9424107075,
-0.7255652547,
0.4480710924,
-0.520467937,
-0.9578732252,
-0.0782452896,
-0.3626161814,
-0.7305099368,
0.2001015544,
-0.262957871,
-0.5746701956,
-0.349041611,
0.3189419806,
-0.3574892879,
0.6371622682,
-0.8927909732,
0.71919173,
0.0049322052,
-0.4960404932,
-0.1532156914,
-0.5177616477,
0.3342603743,
0.0700465143,
0.2843083143,
-0.4778466821,
0.3444223106,
0.9985923171,
-0.0599977672,
1.1719052792,
-0.3904392421,
0.0689188018,
0.4877537787,
0.1738915145,
0.251519829,
-0.2214298248,
-0.1198011786,
0.1916551888,
-0.2413940877,
-0.3446327746,
-0.5486046076,
0.4086052477,
-0.7447696328,
-0.6329529881,
-0.2909093499,
-0.4980237484,
0.0119703365,
0.1820419729,
0.3701422513,
0.0260841809,
-0.245543167,
0.0420377888,
0.7445257306,
-0.4011439681,
0.0259054881,
0.2202363461,
-0.1440388113,
0.0959294811,
1.1374832392,
-0.1272423267,
0.1585138142,
0.1871274412,
0.4152014852,
-0.0797126219,
-0.4831014276,
-0.5350129008,
-0.1271858364,
-0.7428939342,
-0.2790856361,
-0.8102573156,
-0.3389728665,
-0.3506420851,
-0.0358322598,
-0.1422162801,
0.0997413546,
-0.0640873089,
-0.0969535336,
0.5563613772,
0.8730820417,
-0.0564697832,
0.5359039903,
-0.6617859006,
0.2171137333,
0.5170129538,
0.2184223384,
-0.0018564138,
-0.5055245757,
0.0693514794,
0.1992296427,
-0.4490772486,
-1.1170119047,
0.1378374696,
-0.1528950632,
0.1806735247,
0.8147091269,
0.3943617642,
0.3522715569,
-0.2693486214,
0.8729350567,
0.0313080698,
-0.2627199888,
0.6724986434,
-0.582390368,
-0.0820941254,
0.3086209893,
0.6739882827,
-0.9352657199,
-0.7141627669,
-0.5195002556,
-0.5789048672,
0.2933505476,
0.4018285573,
0.7293193936,
-0.4379551709,
0.1103142351,
0.1500435174,
0.023116136,
-0.7548474073,
-0.2688622177,
-0.5367667675,
0.1517705619,
0.1558053046,
-0.4432920814,
-0.1560907215,
-0.0958213732,
0.6221258044,
0.2394138426,
0.5518499613,
-0.3586805761,
0.0246927515,
-0.2591089904,
0.2275775522,
0.3329540789,
0.182133615,
-0.2982103527,
0.3689138889,
-0.0293907691,
-0.6446570754,
-0.0572751462,
0.1052129641,
-0.292933315,
-0.0849743783,
0.3117199242,
0.5905789733,
-0.0356953032,
-0.4328430891,
0.7785627842,
-0.2406689376,
0.0660206825,
-0.2694670558,
0.3243099153,
-0.1577771306,
0.1433221847,
0.0400512256,
0.1034782976,
0.2771783471,
-0.5873750448,
0.1745866388,
0.303219825,
-0.5549773574,
-0.3279891908,
0.815672338,
0.3977171481,
-0.2664239705,
0.9126547575,
-0.1618528813,
-0.8749150038,
0.4915339053,
0.349229306,
0.8079699278,
-0.3564545512,
0.419413209,
0.3159545958,
0.2388155758,
0.4022979736,
0.093995668,
-0.1055114195,
-1.0023519993,
-0.1232711673,
-0.5208283663,
-0.3572412133,
0.3351161778,
-0.4611915648,
0.0874846354,
-0.6857712269,
-0.3630411327,
0.5853404999,
-0.3636189699,
-0.8425012827,
0.1180487797,
0.2287025154,
0.4416329861,
-1.3016978502,
0.4063121676,
0.5604276061,
-0.8067296743,
-0.6012254357,
0.1476021558,
0.4982208312,
-0.9576952457,
0.4846884906,
0.2120549381,
0.0436942652,
-0.1447345912,
-0.7123304605,
-0.2986715138,
0.4653943181,
0.0448324494,
-0.19126001,
0.0159153324,
0.1187041327,
0.6811458468,
0.1658542901,
0.360997647,
0.3290034235,
0.268768847,
0.4748266041,
-0.7033881545,
0.1950858533,
-0.7023850083,
-0.1060272753,
0.3129535615,
-0.4854658246,
0.5692344904,
-0.1011194512,
-0.5856472254,
-0.1844977587,
0.3047689497,
-0.058171019,
0.3543082774,
0.7600952387,
0.4080933332,
0.322301656,
-0.1314689666,
0.9528756738,
0.2614116371,
0.2050172836,
0.7409481406,
0.0999191329,
0.7146647573,
0.063244693,
-0.2064540237,
0.450160712,
0.7665966749,
-0.2949400246,
0.4947446287,
0.1912479848,
-0.7332479358,
-0.1921010911,
-0.6329656839,
-0.3542999625,
0.2492047995,
0.5598424077,
-0.5006834865,
-0.1164701879,
0.2505912185,
0.3815327287,
-0.0490211397,
-0.1478624344,
1.0500882864,
-0.0650783554,
-0.4952358007,
0.2574584484,
0.0121290293,
0.7835218906,
-0.116467528,
-0.1156237647,
-0.137185216,
-0.0330686793,
-0.3371682465,
-1.0254464149,
0.4645679891,
0.4143916667,
0.0778870955,
-0.0639213026,
0.8987177014,
-0.2144285291,
-0.2767405808,
0.0884438157,
0.3389152586,
0.4279931486,
-0.4763242006,
-0.8057302833,
0.1063709632,
-0.0990464613,
-0.0311311986,
0.1320498139,
0.440397501,
-0.0644419342,
0.4874427319,
0.8613666296,
-0.187223956,
0.0548393577,
0.3601974547,
0.9874098301,
-0.4031516612,
-0.3145281971,
-0.9130975604,
0.4538526237,
-0.1814823151,
-0.1568578035,
0.4984211624,
0.3205870688,
0.8519848585,
0.1627788693,
1.0158247948,
-0.4023878574,
0.5481421351,
-0.2690740228,
0.9317942858,
-0.2157135159,
0.1378383189,
-0.6453945637,
-0.7955857515,
-0.466627717,
0.6100694537,
-0.4740279317,
0.1574092507,
0.3009349704,
0.8387824297,
-0.1091681868,
0.2785461545,
0.3067482412,
0.1701791883,
0.6799786091,
0.2780225873,
1.2914321423,
-0.2079752088,
0.7404058576,
-0.6547392607,
-0.3841590583,
-0.2983346879,
-0.6616138816,
-1.2202634811,
-0.6756802201,
-0.4356819689,
-0.6159840226,
0.1731306314,
0.7247595191,
0.5897565484,
-0.6797956824,
0.2452713996,
0.2687391937,
0.0278395209,
-0.2128922194,
-0.3088425994,
0.4019620717,
0.0333614871,
-0.6011964679,
-0.1533886194,
0.0888765603,
0.0128774168,
-0.0912515745,
0.0843519196,
-0.005915781,
-0.0697032735,
0.9407175183,
0.3109609783,
-0.6898854375,
-0.5447558165,
-0.1557701826,
-0.1035251319,
-0.0685481578,
0.7522040009,
-0.255210489,
0.4359942973,
0.3926839232,
0.5990267396,
0.4722294211,
0.2483465374,
0.1762439907,
-0.5975852609,
0.0192569997,
0.440692842,
0.0070009148,
0.4925536215,
-0.6142451763,
0.5591869354,
0.3795880675,
-0.6224926114,
-0.5375605822,
0.1839741617,
-0.8642209172,
-0.1017325148,
1.3471395969,
-0.1680793911,
0.1422576308,
-0.3175639808,
-0.40721789,
0.5019030571,
-0.5786194205,
1.2267301083,
0.5086817741,
-0.2336987406,
-0.3949373066,
-0.8701097965,
0.5622323751,
0.2069990039,
-0.794752717,
0.2966052294,
0.5203811526,
0.3152806163,
0.1876353472,
0.6439220905,
-0.0934411809,
0.4534245133,
-0.0158125162,
-0.1178006977,
0.0906707421,
0.06745895,
0.2088197023,
0.2372851819,
0.0637317374,
-0.161728397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10611v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10611v2 | Joint Repetition Suppression and Content Moderation of Large Language Models | 2023-04-20T19:17:49 | 2023-06-05T18:16:29 | Minghui Zhang, Alex Sokolov, Weixin Cai, Si-Qing Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Natural language generation (NLG) is one of the most impactful fields in NLP,
and recent years have witnessed its evolution brought about by large language
models (LLMs). As the key instrument for writing assistance applications, they
are generally prone to replicating or extending offensive content provided in
the input. In low-resource data regime, they can also lead to repetitive
outputs. Usually, offensive content and repetitions are mitigated with post-hoc
methods, including n-gram level blocklists, top-k and nucleus sampling. In this
paper, we apply non-exact repetition suppression using token and sequence level
unlikelihood loss, and further explore the framework of unlikelihood training
objective in order to jointly endow the model with abilities to avoid
generating offensive words and phrases from the beginning. Finally, with
comprehensive experiments, we demonstrate that our proposed methods work
exceptionally in controlling the repetition and content quality of LLM outputs. | [
-0.3078353107,
-1.0427761078,
0.1755080968,
0.2524257898,
-0.6395676136,
-0.0936209634,
-0.2310002744,
-0.2159483731,
0.164785251,
0.9114789963,
-0.5564810038,
-0.6981443167,
-0.7838979363,
0.3199952841,
-0.7324842811,
1.2467563152,
-0.0926595852,
0.0059836158,
-0.1787050813,
-0.253841579,
-0.5280727744,
-0.6039844751,
-0.8329901099,
-0.3022712171,
0.4531734288,
0.1316381544,
0.3149671555,
0.4617245495,
0.1635848731,
0.2420138419,
-0.1140161678,
0.4461640418,
-0.9171182513,
0.2657451034,
-0.0744341239,
-0.3879106045,
-0.3366014063,
-0.1138160974,
0.8850637674,
0.6030291319,
-0.1677390784,
-0.0027278378,
0.4812721312,
0.5093489289,
-0.5398088694,
-0.1160412431,
-0.87650913,
0.090063341,
-0.2190705091,
-0.2503672242,
-0.5029669404,
-0.346755743,
-0.3185913563,
-0.75179708,
0.0833279565,
0.2500796914,
0.5858976841,
0.2123394907,
-0.1360026151,
-0.5231590271,
-0.5506482124,
1.2490756512,
-0.9288971424,
0.1769389957,
0.432790637,
-0.3155983984,
-0.385460794,
-0.4799472988,
-0.8502030969,
-0.3029557168,
-0.1666354239,
-0.0922218934,
-0.3548297584,
0.003664457,
0.2794125676,
0.179213196,
-0.6659081578,
0.3083411753,
0.0033182802,
-0.058325395,
0.6120200753,
0.245710358,
0.4745603204,
-0.4366636872,
-0.2669561505,
0.1347265393,
-1.0210260153,
-0.1980130672,
0.4086852968,
0.404129684,
0.0088707991,
0.6659917831,
-0.1770659089,
0.6425377727,
0.096764788,
-0.0948289931,
0.0824177042,
-0.4373674989,
-0.3916195035,
-0.1157736629,
0.7788930535,
0.3890094459,
0.199452132,
-0.231428653,
-0.3006282151,
0.0418920629,
0.2858609259,
-0.4660408199,
0.2604206204,
0.0405075625,
-0.4684609771,
-0.5271511078,
-0.0765463263,
-0.8149812818,
-0.3717859983,
-0.3393207192,
0.365457505,
-0.4398679733,
-0.1537682116,
-0.0544613414,
0.0532437414,
0.2180014551,
-0.0348583646,
-0.7463951707,
0.4573060572,
0.9017737508,
0.5695004463,
-0.2010549456,
-0.3238221109,
-0.9729834795,
0.4047776759,
-0.3257727921,
0.3346185684,
-0.5476257801,
-0.5176119804,
0.0854999274,
-0.1052378491,
0.0421404019,
-0.6990812421,
0.2457852364,
-0.3998607099,
0.3056567311,
-0.2496948391,
-0.5625270009,
-0.0374088064,
0.4239795804,
-0.5259212852,
0.962087214,
-0.0126775689,
-0.848714292,
0.600084126,
-0.386709094,
-0.4682785571,
0.0804127306,
-0.058265347,
-0.6320141554,
0.1827777773,
0.2387785465,
0.28103441,
-0.2421313375,
0.4050517976,
-0.1163269579,
-0.4488460422,
0.099333398,
-0.2248782218,
0.4367484748,
0.0057606143,
-0.4390907586,
0.4743096232,
-0.8546605706,
-0.0362261645,
0.2616586983,
-0.2990704775,
-0.6674191952,
-0.2842605412,
0.0996668413,
0.2570774257,
0.0669555441,
-0.7133795619,
0.0501627512,
-0.3371739388,
0.3038550913,
0.5772406459,
0.2064038217,
0.3293975294,
-0.8394835591,
0.6523747444,
-0.0668566898,
0.0296236612,
0.1119011864,
-0.4383208454,
-0.5725153685,
-0.1663173586,
0.0203560032,
0.4237034023,
-1.0306354761,
0.5367173553,
-0.2231702507,
-0.2550873756,
-0.4900383651,
0.6733915806,
0.7184976935,
0.3071246147,
0.3681410253,
-0.2137105912,
-0.9038123488,
-0.6684830189,
-0.3290069997,
-0.0269715898,
-0.1199679971,
0.2141864449,
0.0899904519,
0.018475743,
0.7113116384,
-0.1777361333,
-0.2874940634,
-0.7312240005,
0.3912691176,
-0.0027784463,
0.4525361359,
0.5263217092,
-0.7809264064,
-0.4276775718,
-0.4634146392,
-0.8071730137,
-0.5364484191,
-0.2591564357,
-0.1890531927,
0.5618034601,
0.643453002,
-0.5504482985,
0.4466453791,
0.6304425001,
-0.1174289286,
0.3149947524,
0.0675573424,
0.0767218247,
-1.1672555208,
0.1664305627,
-0.0823320448,
-0.4047087431,
-0.6304731965,
0.2420074493,
-0.3331245482,
0.0715778917,
-0.3476063311,
0.6078634262,
-0.1640840322,
0.1867060214,
-0.5561056137,
0.1337279081,
0.1841285676,
0.3616656363,
-0.1066875681,
0.5725924969,
0.1319146901,
-0.4371491373,
0.135417074,
0.3141683936,
-0.1142969206,
0.4987646341,
-0.5903465152,
0.0883961469,
-0.4150540233,
0.2714539468,
-0.8784983158,
0.0239086337,
0.4852625132,
-0.1890238076,
0.3669308126,
0.0858095959,
-0.6387116313,
-0.3238733113,
-0.6016765833,
0.287761569,
0.6080867052,
-0.3698109686,
0.1963469088,
0.0939594507,
-0.2765223384,
-0.6574910283,
-0.8468545079,
-0.0411391594,
-0.2926688492,
-0.4008803368,
0.2541587353,
-0.0746391714,
-0.2760347128,
0.0241545718,
0.1700647622,
0.1786733419,
-0.0591283403,
0.4271775186,
0.1301301122,
-0.100502111,
0.1675489992,
0.0442707688,
0.0699543878,
-0.0842209235,
-0.2131246179,
0.9962878823,
0.418802768,
-0.4100761116,
-0.3833739758,
0.7200965285,
0.225344032,
0.054922495,
1.0665082932,
0.732067883,
-0.1520959586,
-0.4073645771,
-0.4852020741,
-0.0980767459,
-0.4227398038,
0.497430712,
0.0776489675,
-1.0937829018,
0.3290079832,
0.3949928284,
0.2328037918,
0.3476855159,
0.5124861598,
0.1301958114,
0.5619329214,
0.4826578498,
-0.0623346828,
0.461427331,
-0.0502506122,
0.4231394529,
-0.8968941569,
-0.0545103922,
-0.1183415428,
-0.250793606,
-0.4277763069,
-0.272189647,
0.0536428168,
0.5334329009,
0.0041461359,
0.2360128313,
-0.3428815603,
0.2681360543,
0.5458701849,
0.0585997738,
0.3705229163,
0.1278284341,
0.0377045535,
-0.2538886368,
-0.6843083501,
-0.5330429077,
1.328217268,
-0.0100006135,
0.6276972294,
0.0840290338,
0.9838163257,
0.3497846127,
0.4660928845,
-0.5751340389,
0.6874965429,
-0.504768908,
-0.2553459108,
-0.4768788517,
-0.7075305581,
-0.8971319795,
-0.0377487913,
-0.1796629131,
-0.5529443026,
-0.2597842216,
0.2508693337,
-0.3508847058,
0.6737879515,
-0.2914695442,
0.3714176714,
0.2868867517,
-0.4423568249,
-0.2079996169,
-0.1939729005,
0.5272262692,
-0.365581423,
0.2610187829,
0.1550178528,
0.0304875374,
0.734167397,
-0.4020655453,
0.9762923121,
-0.1730678976,
-0.1730060726,
0.5860951543,
0.1404557675,
0.5655933619,
-0.0757103637,
-0.1885464042,
0.1710398793,
-0.4726838171,
-0.3152140975,
-0.3015015721,
0.8972031474,
-0.5071481466,
-0.5858741999,
0.0410123803,
-0.7147526741,
0.0311812591,
0.1828109473,
0.5094825029,
0.5362480879,
-0.1973151416,
0.2808056772,
0.413844049,
-0.6295347214,
0.5933561325,
0.1592989117,
-0.4375148416,
-0.3140238822,
0.9627987742,
0.2487961799,
0.4589969218,
0.1861824691,
0.078834109,
-0.1716827154,
-0.8617341518,
-0.2278690338,
0.264272362,
-0.4712294638,
-0.3097987473,
-0.8579133153,
-0.3953373134,
-0.7200500369,
-0.1476038396,
0.0010820403,
-0.3139099777,
-0.2866088748,
0.0628668219,
0.2412375212,
1.098736763,
-0.1921817511,
0.6457513571,
-0.8939937353,
0.4932834208,
0.3706750274,
0.3577131033,
0.2827037275,
-0.6200579405,
0.0915298834,
-0.0807214528,
-0.3521654606,
-0.54052037,
0.5584386587,
0.0905694515,
0.510297358,
0.2905358672,
0.0990804732,
0.3337581456,
-0.2737915814,
0.8598963618,
0.2071219385,
-1.0401463509,
0.2183008045,
-0.4732918441,
0.3600277305,
0.3551434875,
0.3096293509,
-0.7160150409,
-0.5782711506,
-0.3768331707,
-1.0452877283,
0.6530668139,
0.3452423513,
0.4418589771,
-0.4030342996,
0.2629078329,
0.2660095692,
0.517977953,
-1.0953751802,
-0.1618645489,
-0.1746195555,
-0.2400093228,
0.3364481032,
-0.7360220551,
-0.1573380679,
0.1080373898,
0.9268954992,
0.2060841024,
-0.0771686882,
0.0312917978,
-0.248306483,
-0.3494849503,
0.4960402548,
0.6717634797,
0.4656162858,
-0.0100087505,
-0.1103340313,
0.1853110045,
-0.2547552586,
0.1268623769,
-0.2283444107,
-0.3557094038,
0.066555649,
0.6271957755,
0.6595857739,
0.2203405797,
-0.6068639159,
0.5226308107,
0.1238499805,
-0.3078448772,
-0.2234865576,
0.1128897369,
-0.0205883123,
-0.1510885805,
0.2477018833,
-0.2946177125,
-0.0696236342,
-0.3225621879,
0.4511118829,
0.4015300572,
-0.1874973923,
-0.0307303555,
0.4133890867,
-0.0275828391,
-0.3672343194,
0.5134496093,
-0.6205633283,
-0.3543008566,
0.4893761575,
0.8668690324,
0.6102839708,
-0.2378881723,
0.2394869328,
0.4794260561,
0.112256974,
0.1062723175,
0.4646446705,
0.1721449345,
-0.6662842631,
-0.4890724719,
-0.8835775256,
0.0008566049,
0.546585381,
-0.7640125751,
0.1580649018,
-1.0309292078,
0.0427182391,
-0.3085027337,
-0.2905269265,
-0.3445170224,
-0.0157040004,
0.2838037014,
0.3251499236,
-0.8571022153,
0.7032192945,
0.3026120067,
-0.2707425058,
-0.6940114498,
0.0394979566,
0.0710404813,
-0.7812729478,
0.6437853575,
0.2353527397,
0.0147283385,
-0.0613562688,
-0.6984273195,
-0.6695464253,
0.6062651277,
-0.0682142302,
-0.8119245768,
-0.1741025895,
0.3378810287,
0.4614775777,
-0.4135626853,
-0.32687819,
0.419485569,
0.4368321598,
0.1454916745,
-0.7285000086,
0.2259592712,
-0.2087564766,
0.06753885,
0.2845377326,
-0.4173537791,
0.9613701701,
0.1521440297,
-0.0880550221,
0.4089321494,
0.3217833638,
0.6310288906,
0.2099006027,
0.6899548769,
0.6478833556,
0.4336461127,
0.19208619,
1.0297976732,
-0.0586121045,
0.0171081852,
1.5404088497,
-0.3706349432,
0.6566033959,
0.581354022,
0.0645041019,
0.4822314084,
-0.0235182904,
-0.1748792976,
0.315841496,
0.6338351369,
-0.2560770214,
-0.1498624384,
-0.6117100716,
-0.3416547179,
0.5109858513,
0.2984398603,
-0.6137809753,
-0.2717594206,
0.2565784156,
0.2810093462,
0.4678967893,
-0.3358139694,
1.0304751396,
0.1938925683,
-0.3904154897,
0.5725795627,
0.0301220007,
1.0243208408,
-0.6738660932,
-0.0373068154,
-0.2913784087,
-0.2717629671,
-0.1576883495,
-0.4427571893,
0.6206589341,
0.1728293598,
-0.2476761341,
-0.19269225,
0.4410837889,
-0.646699369,
-0.4205339551,
0.4967282116,
0.2797977626,
-0.0405185595,
-0.11430531,
-0.445599556,
0.1229666173,
0.1092470959,
-0.2711830735,
0.3280580342,
0.4068918228,
-0.0645311251,
0.3995047808,
0.7048481703,
0.3954145312,
0.3153035939,
0.2480644584,
0.9038716555,
-0.5904094577,
-0.432597965,
-1.0248360634,
0.1129439548,
-0.267796725,
-0.182133168,
0.7876586914,
0.2930565178,
0.7890911102,
0.1576202363,
0.7989115715,
-0.0066142194,
0.6177323461,
-0.5297305584,
0.7893643379,
-0.5775814056,
0.2818128765,
-0.5283899307,
-1.0643086433,
-0.5082702041,
0.2443695068,
-0.3183490634,
-0.0345805846,
0.4756795168,
0.8094134927,
0.0641874969,
-0.0258706305,
0.589761734,
0.2566732168,
0.3815773726,
0.5417839885,
0.7021570206,
-0.2881223857,
0.6796668172,
-0.1383584887,
0.0341675393,
-0.0551021211,
-0.8206097484,
-0.9703724384,
-0.2349919379,
-0.1204168275,
-0.3988834918,
0.0547376238,
1.1622873545,
0.531845808,
-0.8724579215,
-0.0441406332,
-0.1887950003,
0.0134047298,
0.1451972127,
-0.2221837938,
0.2276427001,
-0.2866084874,
-0.6715339422,
0.2985455394,
0.2621071041,
0.1617441773,
-0.2886345983,
0.027833676,
-0.3178877234,
0.1201472506,
0.585740447,
0.1258707941,
-0.7496895194,
-0.2889358699,
-0.2756225765,
-0.2822138965,
-0.1080102101,
0.9544200301,
-0.6308220625,
0.2344706655,
0.4844368398,
0.5976384878,
-0.0818187445,
0.0594729707,
0.7592657208,
-1.0846810341,
0.4457216263,
0.1185831875,
0.2448979765,
0.5798536539,
-0.4314316213,
0.2495986968,
0.1705759019,
-0.380499512,
-0.7837354541,
0.263032645,
-0.5797559023,
-0.4147320092,
1.2361081839,
-0.3613337278,
-0.14257285,
-0.2071654201,
-0.1665414423,
0.681132555,
-0.371219486,
0.9856345057,
0.7359877229,
0.108806856,
-0.1593470424,
-0.1991926581,
0.632537365,
0.8255261779,
-0.7536473274,
0.1910345256,
0.4087968469,
0.238745138,
-0.045946423,
0.5411635041,
-0.1062672138,
-0.0791967586,
-0.0869053453,
0.1856357306,
-0.284846127,
-0.2712929845,
-0.4629742503,
0.3397050202,
0.0751737803,
-0.0303208046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14339v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14339v1 | MarsEclipse at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Multi-Lingual and Multi-Label Framing Detection with Contrastive Learning | 2023-04-20T18:42:23 | 2023-04-20T18:42:23 | Qisheng Liao, Meiting Lai, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | This paper describes our system for SemEval-2023 Task 3 Subtask 2 on Framing
Detection. We used a multi-label contrastive loss for fine-tuning large
pre-trained language models in a multi-lingual setting, achieving very
competitive results: our system was ranked first on the official test set and
on the official shared task leaderboard for five of the six languages for which
we had training data and for which we could perform fine-tuning. Here, we
describe our experimental setup, as well as various ablation studies. The code
of our system is available at https://github.com/QishengL/SemEval2023 | [
-0.8049166799,
-0.459105283,
0.3064910173,
0.3443303406,
-0.3355019093,
0.1054126322,
-0.1880209148,
-0.449324578,
0.1758302301,
0.9398114085,
-0.6904072762,
-0.7003691792,
-0.7437673211,
0.2787638903,
0.0073325974,
1.1043674946,
-0.3504723907,
0.3662946224,
0.2517337203,
-0.4505638778,
-0.2446020395,
-0.4594702721,
-0.7609581351,
-0.4131162763,
0.3846050799,
0.7848094702,
0.2713699341,
0.4171303213,
0.4715462327,
0.2239882797,
-0.2798870802,
0.2205944657,
-0.3566221595,
0.1044993624,
-0.4503914118,
-0.3350977004,
-0.3856498599,
-0.0160254613,
0.6342454553,
0.7207756042,
0.0704442263,
0.0665607452,
0.3962650299,
0.7787632942,
-0.7312745452,
-0.0370739102,
-0.4352651238,
0.0702502653,
-0.3244493008,
-0.1728985608,
-0.481495142,
-0.0488274023,
-0.2743085623,
-0.4782444835,
0.3598619103,
0.2434991747,
1.0000196695,
0.393499881,
-0.6767606735,
-0.3786315918,
-0.0511627309,
0.607626617,
-0.3762248755,
0.6463276148,
0.5173900723,
0.0893281102,
0.0752867609,
-0.4604644775,
-0.108709462,
0.0189097263,
0.0107626691,
0.2681564093,
0.08399757,
0.0991183072,
0.079497464,
0.260917604,
-0.674701035,
0.2704476714,
-0.5506676435,
-0.501639545,
0.2980859578,
0.1174625456,
-0.0166540928,
0.0334545337,
-0.5714679956,
0.0781543553,
-0.8614572287,
-0.1791200787,
0.5629598498,
0.4049432576,
-0.1831948608,
0.4152030349,
-0.4162084758,
0.4231739342,
-0.1831393689,
0.2154669464,
0.6768972278,
-0.5812918544,
-0.0440866277,
0.1005421504,
0.5528913736,
0.3529633284,
0.0181445088,
0.2966760993,
-0.3940435052,
-0.1064325795,
-0.1134184077,
-1.0317291021,
-0.5559534431,
-0.1516854763,
-0.3212485313,
-0.231345728,
-0.2274713069,
-0.4819617569,
-0.4769698679,
-0.2670047581,
0.5814058185,
-0.4551343322,
-0.1219863296,
0.3289811611,
-0.0431029908,
-0.0470210686,
0.2843382955,
-1.0513129234,
0.3839381635,
0.4691900313,
0.5952525735,
-0.1712515652,
-0.4326876104,
-0.797650218,
-0.0015446265,
-0.4102068245,
0.8586167693,
-0.4319756329,
-0.3394427299,
-0.1307949424,
0.5992600322,
-0.1036660224,
-0.6836075783,
0.5920792818,
-0.5612066984,
0.1839692891,
-0.3686648905,
-0.4145683348,
-0.3643742502,
0.4495516121,
-0.6559502482,
0.938333571,
-0.0964136273,
-0.6374534369,
0.2730214596,
-0.7003619075,
-0.5352746844,
0.0261463691,
0.1022203863,
-0.7326128483,
-0.1953038573,
0.4578951895,
0.6797850132,
-0.0837794766,
0.1283660233,
-0.2845574915,
-0.4304023981,
-0.0165967438,
-0.3623280227,
0.8392496705,
0.38343817,
-0.6030938625,
-0.089371644,
-0.5642659664,
-0.3280287087,
-0.0052250526,
-0.3937405944,
-0.1675366014,
-0.2777626812,
0.1696036756,
0.1387118548,
0.3789868355,
-0.6896551847,
0.0440433882,
-0.4197477996,
0.2317877263,
0.6412025094,
0.1269439161,
0.2728636265,
-0.0415176935,
0.6529975533,
0.1999830008,
-0.0610931218,
-0.5937906504,
-0.298314929,
-0.8959105611,
-0.3554437459,
0.4997079968,
0.5396175385,
-1.0667513609,
-0.0377481431,
0.1282579154,
-0.2386664152,
-0.1046817377,
0.1511909217,
0.6247505546,
0.2578974962,
0.3730552793,
-0.1832745522,
-0.6145633459,
-1.3803981543,
0.0421741605,
0.435903877,
0.1136103049,
0.1818193197,
0.9416698217,
-0.1624508649,
0.1949416548,
-0.5950790048,
-0.4623372555,
-0.0862856805,
0.5454528332,
0.0236381181,
0.6855605245,
0.6130641103,
-0.7892755866,
-0.4557594359,
0.1568344235,
-0.4678385258,
-0.5260455012,
0.3836814463,
0.0891156718,
0.4777069688,
1.0163528919,
0.3038051426,
0.0174493026,
0.8811897635,
-0.277366221,
0.5120248199,
-0.0375273824,
0.6095091701,
-1.470818162,
-0.1622037739,
-0.1221751124,
-0.2649243474,
-0.4252977669,
-0.2401667088,
0.2542260885,
-0.2770654261,
-0.7420492768,
0.4811146855,
-0.4709278047,
-0.1629827768,
-0.397841543,
0.2794222236,
0.2726977766,
0.6437051296,
0.1634342521,
1.023961544,
0.3990082145,
-0.4858224988,
-0.0120617161,
0.0165128317,
-0.375120908,
0.716548562,
-0.3268601894,
-0.1029280722,
-0.0339391567,
0.1253655851,
-1.3428640366,
-0.3337210715,
0.5110150576,
-0.5347225666,
0.2135944217,
-0.021083314,
-0.3031926453,
-0.3376961946,
-0.4253477752,
0.4480612576,
-0.2503456175,
-0.7064787745,
0.312066853,
0.538417995,
-0.5211175084,
-0.7404393554,
-0.802529335,
0.0644329712,
-0.1794649512,
-0.3802557886,
0.3972729445,
-0.072824046,
0.3563692868,
0.1184170768,
0.0492549576,
-0.1074628457,
0.354026556,
0.1415921748,
0.1043253243,
-0.3192301989,
0.1792001724,
0.1303844154,
-0.3728855848,
-0.1443503946,
-0.0411796272,
0.5554610491,
-0.5702651739,
-0.4609034956,
-0.3435623348,
0.2362313867,
0.3940423727,
-0.4715533853,
0.7296596169,
0.9105886221,
-0.5123029351,
-0.1011982635,
-0.6728841662,
0.0124216098,
-0.5168305635,
0.6188476086,
-0.736014843,
-1.396998167,
0.8297762871,
-0.2343780994,
-0.2888962328,
0.5237393975,
0.6550588608,
0.0991125256,
1.4157764912,
0.7536062002,
0.1790034473,
0.4566062093,
-0.1623748839,
0.112419039,
-1.1021186113,
-0.2697874308,
-0.7290014625,
-0.0462453216,
-0.5915538073,
-0.2993956506,
0.3829228282,
0.1798365265,
-0.4722945392,
0.5155082941,
-0.4285928905,
0.8107975125,
0.3658613563,
0.0293122642,
0.1767022908,
-0.3557354212,
-0.3978877366,
-0.1278373599,
-0.4900027812,
-0.6004453301,
0.8518610597,
0.3018486798,
0.6210220456,
0.0666305348,
0.7150244117,
0.1959240288,
0.4214866757,
-0.6031059027,
0.5215432644,
-0.3610495329,
-0.8375985622,
-0.1669037342,
-0.1377000362,
-0.8856501579,
0.6635815501,
-0.1360320896,
-0.6936698556,
0.2323077023,
0.131066367,
-0.2772533596,
0.2305190116,
-0.6939024329,
1.2345564365,
-0.1735605299,
-0.4104895592,
-0.0680127814,
-0.6611847281,
0.536914885,
-0.2310356051,
0.3485388756,
-0.5467997193,
-0.1466950774,
0.9753980637,
-0.0247527417,
0.8685378432,
-0.1996822059,
0.0260234363,
-0.0835054368,
0.0224989001,
0.1573006213,
-0.0090317996,
-0.1095329374,
-0.0505789518,
0.0907068327,
-0.4880742133,
-0.1965509653,
0.619674027,
-0.5927014351,
-0.3149015903,
-0.2842491865,
-0.1235049739,
-0.3175205588,
0.3133869469,
0.3906842172,
0.6229786277,
-0.373730123,
0.5198525786,
0.6267058849,
-0.199683398,
0.2651935518,
0.8658469915,
-0.2843046784,
-0.7827753425,
1.0883876085,
-0.0456300937,
0.0715406463,
0.3162136078,
-0.0504913665,
-0.1888073534,
-0.8362430334,
-0.4337162375,
0.2943760455,
-0.9897708297,
-0.382814765,
-0.5396260619,
-0.1453201771,
-0.3885759413,
-0.4220040143,
-0.7479842305,
-0.2323292792,
-0.3282994032,
-0.1019384488,
-0.2859176993,
0.7693478465,
-0.3145953417,
0.5051477551,
-0.856639266,
0.1115251705,
0.0653356239,
0.2914691567,
-0.633212328,
-0.6002776623,
-0.80314219,
-0.1825429946,
-0.5271475315,
-0.7679228187,
0.3499350846,
-0.0591283105,
0.7151905894,
0.3350553811,
-0.1015620381,
0.287815243,
-0.5179034472,
0.8946549296,
0.0881785229,
-1.1374964714,
0.7150711417,
-0.4396339655,
0.4659432769,
1.0531713963,
0.5070471168,
-0.5473685265,
-0.2858223915,
-0.3807893693,
-0.815126121,
0.9710221887,
-0.0164886601,
-0.1191464588,
-0.0804759189,
0.016548695,
0.1159326881,
0.2213685513,
-0.8081578612,
-0.1545296609,
0.0755641535,
-0.1901907623,
-0.1699840426,
-0.4331284165,
-0.2256413996,
0.063823849,
1.2843995094,
-0.3242774308,
-0.0914723501,
-0.0062831808,
-0.2038068622,
0.1246712357,
0.4085538983,
0.890375793,
0.255443722,
-0.1014777049,
0.296135515,
0.4468004704,
-0.2979525626,
0.1708841026,
0.4230373204,
0.2028079927,
-0.4244118929,
0.3110904098,
1.0466712713,
0.5695781708,
-0.5906091928,
0.6636375189,
0.0788566172,
-0.7974132895,
0.0176573936,
-0.257107079,
0.0899741799,
0.4269067943,
0.0471775606,
0.1539607942,
0.4585971832,
-0.2214781642,
0.4112768173,
0.270951122,
-0.5558326244,
-0.2385560721,
0.8391670585,
0.5784472227,
-0.0381399952,
0.206339255,
-0.4553824067,
-1.1151684523,
0.6725918651,
0.5555886626,
0.7282568216,
-0.600399375,
0.2550618649,
0.5095726848,
0.5366231203,
0.0031957289,
0.061231479,
-0.2244538963,
-1.1614724398,
-0.3618376553,
-0.4512031674,
-0.8127164841,
0.2416304201,
-0.6962910891,
0.4453987181,
0.0888772756,
0.1442886889,
0.1773911864,
0.1486679465,
-0.381834358,
0.3026403487,
0.5358217955,
0.6891986728,
-1.2616856098,
0.6292391419,
0.9511455297,
-0.1618409008,
-0.5137477517,
-0.2739655077,
0.3449149132,
-0.7676622868,
0.7563053966,
0.6127266288,
-0.6505930424,
-0.1675475687,
-0.3347686827,
-0.9095113873,
0.9758653045,
0.3010331988,
-0.3100453913,
0.5909266472,
-0.0254632961,
0.322729677,
-0.4921188354,
-0.0537153147,
0.6242690682,
0.4764834046,
0.1885099262,
-0.9765049219,
-0.1682727933,
-0.4007940292,
-0.2101177275,
0.4318500161,
-0.802523613,
0.6306740046,
0.0572588369,
-0.156408757,
0.0813095421,
0.4751101732,
0.1408158541,
0.4236957729,
0.4900768995,
0.6280503869,
0.688616991,
-0.2315951884,
0.6250922084,
-0.43045789,
0.4565903842,
1.2592411041,
-0.2777660787,
0.8798674345,
0.2321262658,
0.2214269489,
0.136597544,
1.036454916,
0.1491962075,
0.7295169234,
-0.0536659509,
-0.3078600466,
-0.4703792632,
-0.2392951846,
-0.3923449218,
0.4964205027,
0.6137697101,
-0.2879133523,
-0.2437225878,
0.775606215,
0.1992678642,
0.0718099251,
-0.2587695122,
0.4690924585,
-0.1326574236,
-0.7443954945,
0.5912403464,
0.1514398009,
0.6633858681,
-0.4060878754,
0.1718633324,
-0.0880206451,
0.3741803169,
-0.014602148,
-0.9551544189,
0.3616720438,
-0.3278508484,
0.140214771,
-0.4347343743,
0.6400826573,
-0.750331521,
-0.2681977749,
0.3669005036,
0.4286734164,
0.1301782429,
-0.0100261969,
-0.7928382158,
0.5166855454,
0.2609340847,
-0.6426571012,
0.1613118052,
0.3139408827,
0.1116235256,
0.4507902265,
0.2056203932,
-0.3094609678,
-0.2943655252,
0.40364182,
0.905565083,
-0.5675727725,
-0.496855706,
-0.6072613597,
0.2699201107,
-0.0539673232,
-0.385306716,
0.650282979,
0.9925435185,
1.0206280947,
-0.0080474485,
0.4893070757,
0.4289562404,
0.6034650803,
-0.7678377032,
0.29403615,
-0.9501836896,
0.1970860362,
-0.0988169089,
-0.9010807872,
-0.6488646269,
0.3831956089,
-0.4038191438,
-0.1609384269,
1.107570529,
1.1849025488,
0.0630941689,
0.3034922481,
0.3975422084,
0.1088694036,
0.2134850025,
0.4996373951,
0.7800360918,
-0.4977765083,
0.6755421758,
-0.3733815849,
-0.1732074171,
-0.341896385,
-0.7781252265,
-1.0862922668,
-0.9101696014,
-0.398943305,
-0.1100948006,
0.2527937889,
0.7285021544,
0.6913769245,
-1.0281869173,
-0.0127787339,
0.1556025594,
0.1127932146,
0.0814006701,
-0.1985358745,
0.3261216283,
-0.508395195,
-0.9372736216,
0.5767021179,
0.6357744336,
0.0377548113,
0.0653885528,
0.0336053781,
-0.2876417637,
-0.1637308002,
0.6585422754,
0.0793504119,
-0.4714897573,
-0.4184536934,
-0.2103644609,
-0.1644879878,
0.0835895538,
0.6557724476,
-0.4069271684,
0.4460604489,
0.4430021942,
0.6338813305,
0.9573532343,
0.0043086582,
0.2853333652,
-0.6319971681,
0.2061964869,
0.1209113225,
0.6187202334,
0.5454626083,
-0.0950328633,
0.9008324742,
0.2613397241,
-0.8407098651,
-0.6214006543,
0.3041319251,
-0.8379618526,
-0.4066577554,
0.8547852635,
0.0175602287,
-0.1943761855,
-0.3598462045,
-0.4635497332,
0.121544987,
-0.1509296894,
0.1819300801,
1.0863755941,
-0.2598439455,
-0.2531906664,
-0.5544198155,
0.4359295964,
0.661285758,
-0.7732812762,
-0.1147623211,
0.5144097209,
0.3598929346,
0.2210970968,
0.8428304195,
-0.0978366584,
0.3334326446,
0.0681858212,
0.2217897475,
-0.066620931,
-0.4856741726,
-0.4842456579,
0.2805030346,
-0.0496834368,
-0.4717327356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11040v1 | Emotional Expression Detection in Spoken Language Employing Machine Learning Algorithms | 2023-04-20T17:57:08 | 2023-04-20T17:57:08 | Mehrab Hosain, Most. Yeasmin Arafat, Gazi Zahirul Islam, Jia Uddin, Md. Mobarak Hossain, Fatema Alam | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | There are a variety of features of the human voice that can be classified as
pitch, timbre, loudness, and vocal tone. It is observed in numerous incidents
that human expresses their feelings using different vocal qualities when they
are speaking. The primary objective of this research is to recognize different
emotions of human beings such as anger, sadness, fear, neutrality, disgust,
pleasant surprise, and happiness by using several MATLAB functions namely,
spectral descriptors, periodicity, and harmonicity. To accomplish the work, we
analyze the CREMA-D (Crowd-sourced Emotional Multimodal Actors Data) & TESS
(Toronto Emotional Speech Set) datasets of human speech. The audio file
contains data that have various characteristics (e.g., noisy, speedy, slow)
thereby the efficiency of the ML (Machine Learning) models increases
significantly. The EMD (Empirical Mode Decomposition) is utilized for the
process of signal decomposition. Then, the features are extracted through the
use of several techniques such as the MFCC, GTCC, spectral centroid, roll-off
point, entropy, spread, flux, harmonic ratio, energy, skewness, flatness, and
audio delta. The data is trained using some renowned ML models namely, Support
Vector Machine, Neural Network, Ensemble, and KNN. The algorithms show an
accuracy of 67.7%, 63.3%, 61.6%, and 59.0% respectively for the test data and
77.7%, 76.1%, 99.1%, and 61.2% for the training data. We have conducted
experiments using Matlab and the result shows that our model is very prominent
and flexible than existing similar works. | [
-0.6626995206,
-0.8537505269,
0.3043186069,
0.3350494206,
-0.2309307158,
0.0179052148,
-0.3533983827,
-0.3003995121,
0.0647760555,
0.3459579051,
-0.7329743505,
-0.8472802043,
-0.5947948098,
0.274286896,
-0.4279144704,
0.4186308682,
0.0678203031,
0.3301466703,
-0.027437415,
-0.3744181395,
-0.158005625,
-0.6143679023,
-0.6345555186,
-0.3095549941,
0.3939854205,
0.315274924,
0.2086804956,
0.4130076468,
0.4282806814,
0.4183005691,
-0.0274793729,
-0.0267953556,
-0.3239646256,
0.577480197,
0.5026248693,
-0.5418934226,
-0.2647625208,
-0.0123037891,
0.3076858222,
0.2194997668,
-0.2960986197,
0.201996997,
-0.1426429898,
0.9213497639,
-0.2907734513,
0.3997565508,
-0.4999723732,
0.5013850927,
-0.216814816,
-0.1820533723,
-0.237338081,
-0.4219512045,
0.0559758544,
-0.1588894427,
0.0697289854,
-0.0809480771,
0.8304179907,
0.7027708292,
-0.3193262219,
-0.5911062956,
-0.50749892,
0.9331664443,
-0.7733126879,
0.6563896537,
0.3455357552,
0.3336047232,
-0.0047338619,
-0.3301641643,
-0.7852143049,
-0.2842329443,
0.2421807796,
0.1875498146,
-0.5441945195,
0.1185221225,
0.3909276128,
0.1610534638,
-0.5867382884,
0.1959614307,
0.0602331571,
-0.2068417221,
0.6752052307,
0.3005725443,
0.4094302058,
-0.3499141932,
-0.131611079,
-0.3776048422,
-0.1379978359,
0.2542625666,
0.4828291535,
0.1470447928,
-0.3822535872,
0.5118938088,
-0.1762394458,
0.3599689007,
-0.0775429457,
-0.0908935219,
0.5010102987,
0.2767397463,
-0.4446161985,
0.0634579435,
0.7383471131,
0.2182979286,
0.4831207097,
0.3373450041,
-0.3586298227,
0.5720995069,
-0.162850216,
-0.7777424455,
-0.1079258844,
0.4232975245,
-0.6681470871,
-0.369065702,
-0.2490065247,
-1.1886194944,
-0.5695465803,
-0.701853931,
-0.0003842268,
-0.5105547309,
-0.2903492153,
-0.0368682519,
0.0957892463,
0.2639420033,
0.147488907,
-0.5872483253,
0.1337626427,
0.618205905,
0.7407268882,
-0.0620193891,
0.1569204777,
-0.3457804918,
-0.4834873676,
-0.0120193409,
0.6825870275,
-0.736220181,
-0.3265413046,
-0.0032901964,
-0.0313206464,
-0.2074330747,
-0.6965031624,
0.8844947815,
-0.1767229736,
0.1491156816,
-0.1147083715,
-0.65864259,
-0.4486862719,
-0.0760231838,
-0.6358477473,
0.9988940358,
0.1224005222,
-0.5261653662,
0.1299611479,
-1.0015422106,
-0.382997185,
-0.2173477858,
-0.1103412956,
-0.7969186306,
0.1236919314,
0.2075637132,
0.6503744125,
-0.2386803776,
0.1278832555,
-0.5510174632,
-0.0476577953,
0.7043855786,
-0.4562778175,
0.6852186918,
0.6175586581,
-0.5241445303,
0.1290048957,
-0.8111746311,
0.0577957034,
0.1109817177,
-0.161919266,
0.0238019451,
0.1622871608,
0.2422229946,
0.4861975908,
-0.1932653189,
-0.715466857,
-0.1837211698,
-0.1466321498,
0.3216318786,
0.8174667954,
0.1736359447,
-0.0850236937,
-0.1300561875,
0.8441553116,
0.2617948651,
0.0734485239,
-0.0203915518,
-0.6089172363,
-0.657304585,
-0.5378494263,
0.1766591668,
0.7111676335,
-0.190311864,
0.4994158447,
0.0798519328,
-0.5054685473,
-0.9263579249,
-0.0029616272,
0.2724223435,
0.5738588572,
0.1385331154,
-0.0357289501,
-0.794341445,
-0.8767376542,
-0.2143996358,
-0.0412493534,
-0.140307501,
0.5474281311,
0.1115176305,
-0.4165071249,
0.8696814179,
-0.4745919108,
-0.2828859985,
-0.0238181725,
0.4741754234,
0.081181787,
0.3292167187,
0.7525143623,
-1.0512499809,
-0.6900014877,
0.1386950761,
-0.7350066304,
-0.7326057553,
0.074001953,
0.1142950654,
0.4799727201,
0.1194402948,
-0.3924900591,
0.5306624174,
0.6755829453,
-0.1570809036,
0.2467855662,
0.2378204465,
0.5705965161,
-0.8015145063,
-0.158304885,
0.4158926904,
-0.2222565264,
-0.7496238351,
-0.4648624659,
-0.1850456297,
-0.4273826182,
-0.5305914283,
0.1081993282,
-0.2394065559,
-0.1744402051,
-0.2080901414,
0.3280419707,
-0.1877113283,
0.7136135101,
-0.1026611403,
0.3925501704,
0.6412916183,
-0.2955728471,
0.4808530807,
0.0798274502,
-0.2382404506,
0.718909502,
-0.3928506672,
0.2415925413,
-0.2052793205,
-0.0166390855,
-1.0459910631,
-0.1454240978,
0.268424511,
-0.6152185798,
0.2303220034,
-0.0711282864,
-0.2606847584,
-0.2138501406,
-0.1305257082,
0.1119401529,
0.7891458273,
-0.415389806,
0.8110541701,
0.6581015587,
-0.3920299113,
-0.3112133443,
-0.5886408687,
-0.0811719596,
-0.6001322269,
-0.9084251523,
0.0103213582,
-0.0861334279,
-0.3958559036,
-0.0925032198,
0.1084391102,
-0.1197452247,
0.1711303145,
0.6645154357,
0.0510054231,
-0.1204187945,
0.0345601067,
0.0086333863,
-0.12498606,
0.0698202327,
0.349835366,
0.7972471714,
-0.2632641196,
-0.4181592464,
-1.0145276785,
0.5546822548,
0.9108518362,
-0.3727172911,
0.4253449142,
1.1542956829,
-0.5700606108,
-0.1023413539,
-0.5149501562,
-0.1058805659,
-0.4770839214,
0.4824564755,
-0.1809525788,
-0.6223409176,
0.904278934,
-0.1732883304,
-0.286437124,
0.3866476715,
0.8085022569,
-0.2350244075,
1.5643963814,
0.3393182456,
-0.2070086002,
0.7156941891,
-0.1214766875,
0.141986981,
-0.7733671069,
-0.199535951,
-0.8029162288,
-0.523617506,
-0.6089476943,
-0.1420720816,
0.3811789155,
-0.2415180504,
0.0265770033,
-0.0326383337,
-0.5007791519,
0.1274969578,
0.2505483329,
0.1102717966,
-0.319298476,
0.0362406075,
-0.0297511108,
-0.1894161403,
-0.178114295,
-0.4991277456,
0.8285401464,
0.611638546,
0.5812602639,
0.0570897497,
0.6379706264,
0.6613345146,
0.388514787,
-0.8741002679,
0.5987076759,
-0.2401725948,
-0.1988892555,
-0.2702028453,
-0.5896278024,
-0.8389617205,
0.1346411258,
-0.3377167284,
-0.801781714,
0.298365891,
-0.0268140975,
0.0322160944,
0.1132513285,
-0.7998954654,
0.6573805809,
-0.1601876616,
0.028676752,
-0.3324748576,
-0.4770339131,
0.1995293945,
-0.1422399431,
0.2793084383,
-0.5130335093,
0.4460137188,
0.8568967581,
-0.0755031332,
0.7612943649,
-0.585285902,
-0.0968217775,
0.3844716847,
0.0392427668,
0.4394880533,
-0.3075989783,
-0.3093729913,
0.3246224821,
-0.1703213751,
-0.1546337754,
-0.5775555968,
0.5392785668,
-0.7331488729,
-0.2716980278,
-0.0238634311,
-0.3989119232,
-0.0041089295,
-0.1728884876,
0.0441974178,
0.4314981401,
-0.1709235609,
0.2091722786,
0.4043923318,
-0.3329802155,
0.5083028078,
0.4477730691,
-0.1703663915,
-0.4791591763,
0.9899904132,
-0.0261155721,
0.1293864995,
-0.0114907343,
0.3615407348,
-0.3777036071,
-0.3111094236,
-0.2323559076,
0.0254782941,
-0.7529976964,
-0.3090856373,
-0.7297414541,
0.1900061667,
-0.5395715237,
0.0224547274,
-0.2782832086,
-0.2924799025,
-0.345192492,
-0.0121802939,
0.36885041,
0.5269618034,
-0.026235681,
0.2458453327,
-0.8880594969,
0.3845441937,
0.0795545876,
0.0817501321,
-0.1800373048,
-0.3156422973,
-0.1078684181,
0.2478177398,
-0.4836221337,
-1.2530834675,
0.9469000697,
0.4355157316,
0.5395355821,
0.8357275128,
0.050104145,
0.4798004329,
-0.0956370309,
0.639201045,
0.0015220178,
-1.2726449966,
0.506059289,
-0.1370174587,
-0.2175637633,
0.1085653454,
0.3823781013,
-0.8623893261,
-0.2682298422,
-0.5184874535,
-0.5116355419,
0.698982656,
0.2504389882,
-0.2816729844,
0.0090116262,
0.181297794,
-0.0986142382,
0.1890418977,
-0.3824566603,
-0.3765710592,
-0.2150815427,
-0.6842840314,
0.1347680837,
-0.0295047276,
0.0306446366,
-0.0862325504,
0.528414011,
-0.00373752,
0.5638306737,
0.2461849153,
-0.1368427575,
-0.4199011326,
0.3443585336,
0.8494002819,
-0.0372622237,
-0.3242013156,
-0.0143702785,
0.1428425461,
-0.345030576,
0.1085857376,
0.0037910196,
0.3963501453,
0.0975189656,
0.1244413257,
0.8811858296,
-0.0642650872,
-0.814332664,
0.4524866939,
-0.1711979657,
-0.0601755008,
-0.3122905195,
0.0749835372,
0.0035809379,
0.3928174675,
0.2704636157,
0.2786356211,
0.3900789618,
-0.3550336957,
0.2719873488,
0.3502520323,
-0.6708543897,
-0.50793612,
0.3796082437,
0.1073446646,
-0.642932713,
0.6567630768,
-0.1475405842,
-1.0794370174,
0.8961907029,
0.4306748211,
1.1926709414,
-0.7061193585,
0.1633738726,
0.004029952,
0.0215549041,
0.4765023887,
0.598341763,
0.092688784,
-0.814057827,
-0.094528392,
-0.697157979,
-0.4160706699,
-0.1402774304,
-0.8497408032,
0.2549047172,
-0.1450836957,
-0.3768082857,
0.1662399918,
0.0287472345,
-0.8412112594,
0.1408840418,
0.5024913549,
0.4579889774,
-1.2221589088,
0.7858605981,
0.4943549633,
-0.0878071189,
-0.681745708,
-0.2697856426,
0.3944937587,
-0.7213415504,
0.8650209308,
0.296146065,
-0.2522313595,
0.0870446414,
-0.405565232,
-0.3281553984,
0.9267248511,
0.3256449699,
-0.5309512615,
0.5987707376,
0.1830091178,
0.6059268713,
-0.6442104578,
0.2772846818,
0.4995319545,
0.6831048131,
-0.078878969,
-0.7074323297,
-0.2181228101,
-0.4271578491,
-0.4142336249,
0.3031312823,
-0.4063630998,
0.9550061226,
0.1727093309,
-0.5312526822,
-0.1990291774,
0.4622637033,
0.0359124467,
0.631268084,
0.8585783839,
0.5820842981,
0.8917574883,
-0.2211732566,
0.8181837797,
-0.4232852757,
0.5852928162,
0.3607088029,
-0.486971885,
0.8569425344,
0.1599813253,
-0.385427624,
0.4802182317,
0.6323064566,
-0.077410087,
0.2422019988,
0.3675310016,
-0.440802604,
-0.2099455744,
-0.1688964069,
-0.1276706308,
0.7377622724,
0.7766063809,
-0.3613385856,
0.0728858337,
0.4249089062,
-0.1140918881,
-0.0621478595,
-0.109872438,
0.7156358361,
0.1076219082,
-0.2867613435,
0.5398699641,
-0.0437495038,
0.4860417247,
-0.2477333546,
-0.1031566709,
-0.1014687568,
0.0142697971,
-0.3128079772,
-0.5122651458,
0.1834543198,
0.0966449082,
0.0568004809,
-0.0480986163,
0.7332844138,
-0.4559584558,
-0.2020480037,
0.3322844803,
0.3092252314,
0.3297497332,
-0.2030995786,
-0.9832783937,
0.3219082355,
0.2243836373,
-0.3479473889,
0.0710615069,
0.6796456575,
0.2887357473,
0.8603813052,
0.7579618692,
0.0296448413,
0.1268598884,
0.3861875534,
0.7293439507,
-0.6748617887,
-0.4448352754,
-0.8238372207,
0.3694612682,
-0.07145188,
0.0071493783,
0.4411401451,
0.3151831627,
0.1701393276,
-0.0461937524,
0.6162798405,
0.2149644792,
0.5503823757,
-0.5127447248,
0.6593615413,
-0.342002511,
0.1968267262,
-0.6789502501,
-0.8440781832,
-0.3842959106,
0.6721277833,
-0.1112636477,
0.0699938685,
0.4075000286,
0.8953264952,
0.1530284435,
0.4687455893,
0.5090683699,
0.3480511308,
0.4503014982,
0.4438116848,
0.9234559536,
-0.0573820323,
0.1617639661,
-0.4671620727,
-0.4391943514,
-0.4054611325,
-0.8361464739,
-0.6885887384,
-0.7095383406,
-0.4976007044,
-0.2171509713,
-0.3743301332,
1.1704257727,
0.69264853,
-0.84834975,
-0.1530454904,
0.2138757706,
0.0111335702,
-0.2051727325,
-0.3466919065,
0.5366392732,
-0.1414610595,
-0.8922069073,
0.3751125634,
0.3600879014,
0.1049371362,
-0.1990046799,
-0.2231622487,
0.0556552969,
0.2030245215,
0.5074597597,
0.1843315214,
-0.6942174435,
-0.3815765679,
0.1133388206,
0.0344840251,
0.2494853735,
0.7795127034,
-0.4718547165,
0.3502345681,
0.4722599983,
0.5438563824,
0.2470627874,
0.1396906674,
0.2838687599,
-0.5908248425,
0.1230162382,
0.445694685,
0.5900431871,
0.3524935544,
-0.4047825336,
0.2386609614,
0.2495535165,
-0.8804453611,
-0.8939092755,
0.2268288136,
-1.2835800648,
0.1543241143,
0.8339146972,
-0.3081989586,
-0.4267362058,
0.0132738212,
-0.4037739933,
0.6843389869,
-0.6349612474,
0.8059716225,
0.5447576046,
-0.6217293739,
-0.180418089,
-0.6115783453,
0.484154582,
0.4750727415,
-0.8398046494,
0.2269963771,
0.4891124368,
0.1136949658,
0.1019545868,
0.1656207889,
-0.1447284073,
0.0425421298,
-0.1062401682,
0.4844364226,
0.0588731356,
-0.0028125732,
-0.7026700974,
0.3363467157,
-0.4311722219,
-0.3465409279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10513v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10513v3 | Why Does ChatGPT Fall Short in Providing Truthful Answers? | 2023-04-20T17:48:43 | 2023-12-03T23:01:19 | Shen Zheng, Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models, such as ChatGPT, have
demonstrated significant potential to impact various aspects of human life.
However, ChatGPT still faces challenges in providing reliable and accurate
answers to user questions. To better understand the model's particular
weaknesses in providing truthful answers, we embark an in-depth exploration of
open-domain question answering. Specifically, we undertake a detailed
examination of ChatGPT's failures, categorized into: comprehension, factuality,
specificity, and inference. We further pinpoint factuality as the most
contributing failure and identify two critical abilities associated with
factuality: knowledge memorization and knowledge recall. Through experiments
focusing on factuality, we propose several potential enhancement strategies.
Our findings suggest that augmenting the model with granular external knowledge
and cues for knowledge recall can enhance the model's factuality in answering
questions. | [
-0.3483873606,
-1.1047480106,
0.7609469295,
-0.1031999141,
0.230516687,
0.2947151065,
-0.057940267,
-0.2797120512,
-0.3679593801,
0.2461704612,
-0.5148276687,
-0.0632866845,
-0.5944181085,
-0.3919810355,
-0.1926288158,
1.399682045,
0.0677257255,
-0.3798900843,
-0.4154582024,
-0.1177602559,
-0.7670285106,
-0.7622004747,
-0.6618279815,
-0.1909689307,
0.3090262413,
0.6350703239,
0.8601848483,
0.1666284949,
0.6481257081,
0.1842595488,
-0.1172444895,
0.1978402734,
-0.887814343,
-0.1601649076,
-0.2813429534,
-0.7266136408,
-0.2967268527,
0.151720956,
0.483020246,
0.787483871,
-0.2041248083,
0.1084153727,
-0.0194728728,
0.5898897648,
-0.4083343148,
0.2479541004,
-0.7040015459,
-0.0509728119,
0.06711936,
-0.1167121008,
-0.3475562334,
-0.5612387657,
0.6445658207,
-0.4523559213,
0.6508796811,
0.0464466922,
1.0407850742,
0.3231203854,
-0.4946971238,
-0.5850601792,
-1.0498100519,
0.5546548367,
-0.6004785895,
0.3440528512,
0.4093500078,
0.4655928612,
-0.0285879262,
-0.7016376257,
-0.5679870844,
-0.3780712485,
-0.2084147036,
0.4301700294,
0.0069007697,
0.1226956323,
0.3890871406,
0.4401654005,
-0.559502244,
-0.4722755253,
-0.5741067529,
-0.3395094872,
0.2040232122,
0.072355248,
0.3668831289,
-0.065500766,
-0.3290101886,
-0.0028583214,
-0.6276124716,
0.2061478049,
0.3639438152,
0.0772534609,
0.1381861717,
0.7099419236,
-0.0455356725,
0.4784114361,
-0.0997276679,
-0.1858498305,
-0.3373046517,
-0.4296469986,
0.0567958578,
-0.1025724933,
0.1758964062,
0.380841285,
0.2195485234,
-0.2001777738,
0.0322023109,
-0.0098270895,
0.265483439,
-0.7266434431,
-0.4968277812,
0.50968045,
-0.2106189877,
-0.011109733,
0.0913132057,
-0.4461611211,
-0.2701750398,
0.0802247077,
0.6234133244,
-0.770619154,
-0.3142777383,
0.1864784956,
-0.3419907689,
0.1421228647,
0.5394359231,
-0.6730701923,
0.425232023,
0.6599313617,
0.8360536695,
0.0727732554,
-0.104327403,
-0.2914816439,
-0.055418849,
-0.2770348787,
0.8542260528,
-0.3621419668,
-0.3090980947,
-0.18436113,
-0.2273208052,
-0.4852020144,
-0.3911095262,
0.8465662599,
-0.7799770236,
0.4839041233,
-0.8332247734,
-0.7972970009,
-0.6473864913,
0.4520607889,
-0.4292948544,
0.6524080634,
0.074160412,
-1.1222751141,
0.0631107688,
-0.6940636635,
-0.2409214377,
-0.1912033707,
0.15417476,
-0.2360483557,
0.1826653033,
-0.0195637979,
0.2845908999,
-0.1903221607,
0.1198911294,
0.0028558676,
-0.3073212504,
0.5372073054,
-0.7251831293,
0.4573571086,
-0.020400783,
0.0168875102,
-0.4069849849,
-0.6674005985,
0.0163670164,
0.3623283803,
-0.519099772,
-0.0095497398,
0.0700274482,
-0.1872157753,
0.2478302121,
0.0593294837,
-0.6710425615,
0.0198446661,
-0.2208848894,
0.4139874876,
0.5389032364,
0.2212631851,
0.0890827104,
-0.7357358336,
0.4285879135,
0.0622827262,
-0.0750459731,
-0.1362599283,
-0.6770299673,
-0.8608625531,
0.0697682798,
0.369987756,
0.9174208641,
-0.7150575519,
-0.0099744461,
-0.4422441721,
-0.6361239552,
-0.4649638236,
-0.1682497859,
0.5585877299,
1.0209732056,
0.2253374457,
-0.5491046309,
-0.2107843459,
-0.8592867851,
-0.2187489271,
-0.5169619322,
0.0670413896,
0.5053250194,
0.5609329939,
0.114500463,
1.011828661,
-0.6849657893,
-0.1127557829,
-0.2025341988,
-0.0469847284,
0.2092888504,
0.1249985248,
0.3627462387,
-0.8672560453,
-0.2963561714,
-0.1061675996,
-0.5869447589,
0.2738394737,
0.0076805321,
0.1093657911,
-0.0197109282,
-0.0067742257,
-0.9441312551,
0.3985972404,
0.4532382488,
-0.3742213249,
0.8992555737,
-0.1627735794,
0.292578578,
-0.6690262556,
0.0640163124,
-0.3954887986,
-0.1691394597,
-0.8349351883,
-0.2014024407,
-0.0307594277,
-0.2456239164,
-0.3166761696,
0.3115383387,
-0.0601351969,
0.0034653153,
-0.144037202,
0.4069346488,
0.2093714327,
0.5290623903,
0.0916132703,
1.1105026007,
0.2185325623,
-0.5482371449,
0.3884186149,
0.4908171296,
-0.2003989518,
0.3928160071,
-0.8901171684,
0.2052208334,
-0.3543003798,
0.1707430184,
-1.1801100969,
-0.5129719973,
0.1013065651,
-0.7377284765,
0.229191184,
-0.5585219264,
-0.3688738048,
-0.2216962278,
-0.015653098,
0.09317334,
0.6516740918,
-0.4436292946,
0.3048838079,
0.1799971908,
-0.3377119601,
-0.6308225989,
-0.4285912216,
-0.05182359,
0.0790754631,
-0.9234596491,
-0.1856182516,
-0.2345304042,
-0.2139981687,
0.1293803453,
-0.2614006698,
-0.1036252156,
0.0454161875,
0.0075724549,
0.2538361251,
-0.4267172217,
0.4101296365,
-0.4227440059,
0.064666748,
0.1699148417,
-0.1879600734,
0.5117675066,
-0.7013576031,
-0.5994052887,
-0.1400138438,
0.150903374,
0.4441223145,
-0.3066366017,
0.8729570508,
0.3231575787,
-0.1211984009,
0.1779514104,
-0.7442861199,
-0.3673251569,
-0.3901633322,
0.4763543606,
-0.2436883003,
-0.930907011,
0.591986239,
0.2038137168,
0.071082972,
0.2425040156,
0.202674672,
-0.0548749082,
0.7214422822,
0.3299273252,
0.3520143628,
-0.047622811,
0.0032092563,
0.3776159585,
-0.5289731026,
-0.1261772215,
-0.3225524724,
0.3208332062,
-0.545161128,
-0.3465763032,
0.4520871639,
-0.1431683004,
-0.1210604832,
-0.055413451,
-0.2275414169,
0.4004743397,
0.6118648052,
0.2324380577,
0.3781175017,
-0.2139407247,
0.1268707365,
0.0009989219,
-1.0897439718,
-0.6327257156,
0.8711588383,
0.4995868206,
0.7338571548,
0.2248677313,
0.017974481,
-0.0714164302,
-0.0100373253,
-0.6441956162,
0.3702529967,
0.2245627344,
-1.0775985718,
-0.3381644785,
-0.4489057362,
-0.4507862628,
0.1286863983,
-0.0710508227,
-0.5227982998,
-0.1400362104,
0.5198885202,
-0.5848445296,
0.4157410562,
-1.1085708141,
0.9347879291,
-0.0887548104,
-0.3321861327,
0.1380314827,
-0.9018381238,
0.679489553,
-0.0200700387,
0.1137743071,
-0.1231105849,
0.186895594,
0.6147535443,
-0.2951351702,
0.9184572101,
-0.1820731908,
0.0353729166,
0.6855170131,
0.1494000852,
0.4581803977,
0.2795831859,
0.1373044401,
-0.0979907662,
0.1297341585,
-0.6589415073,
-0.9068574905,
0.3391211033,
-0.626378417,
-0.8552658558,
-0.4103756249,
-0.4214985371,
-0.7212096453,
-0.0945030302,
0.2995121777,
0.585439682,
-0.3974495828,
0.0270892531,
1.2850717306,
-0.3534434438,
0.1694514304,
0.3457378745,
-0.0506420135,
-0.1515449286,
1.0540955067,
0.2183408886,
0.823151648,
0.2010278404,
0.2433187217,
-0.3530213535,
-0.5603237748,
-0.4010716081,
0.2917414904,
-0.9504814744,
0.0900619477,
-0.8064118028,
-0.5932115912,
-0.4995976686,
0.2209604084,
-0.5041399598,
-0.7669605017,
0.16491355,
-0.2605898976,
0.292611897,
0.6588733792,
0.0241705757,
0.2881004512,
-1.0492473841,
0.3646097779,
0.7843776345,
0.3598355651,
-0.0330458619,
-0.6834754944,
-0.0423476584,
0.1812171936,
-0.4069110751,
-0.6207737923,
-0.145521,
0.3983263671,
0.3892797828,
0.3485483229,
0.1239856482,
0.4340681434,
-0.52975142,
0.9234982133,
-0.0714222044,
-0.5755896568,
0.6476276517,
-0.4044690728,
0.2369214147,
0.4270980954,
0.4796647429,
-0.8565842509,
-0.364186883,
-0.8142783046,
-0.3960758746,
0.6523786783,
0.5897678733,
0.2647083998,
-0.0202197284,
0.2775464952,
0.1898530424,
0.1421370208,
-0.6314315796,
-0.1438776553,
-0.4711529911,
0.1456046551,
0.1198094562,
-0.4562565684,
-0.2140970081,
0.0671882555,
1.0379607677,
-0.1454233974,
0.4548063576,
0.4028877616,
0.0047925529,
0.152905792,
0.3846190274,
0.6320211291,
0.9798793197,
-0.3379243314,
0.1333785504,
0.2157606333,
-0.6493551135,
-0.1176260337,
0.0941223353,
-0.2501106858,
-0.0583660826,
0.4882813394,
0.7563076615,
-0.1036293283,
-0.8380867243,
0.7891687751,
-0.2387160063,
0.0368287228,
-0.3413408399,
0.2015169561,
0.1721558422,
0.0183243565,
0.3614805043,
0.3148222864,
-0.0110305278,
-0.766310215,
0.0389595665,
0.4360075295,
-0.6647123694,
-0.2971766889,
0.7239695191,
0.0161785185,
-0.0559024923,
0.7676217556,
0.0801961944,
-0.8479140401,
0.5974401832,
0.397832334,
0.3806506395,
-0.1804648191,
0.3045294285,
0.2353396118,
0.5579683185,
-0.0609504133,
0.2084930837,
0.1277316809,
-0.8817293048,
-0.4906406999,
-0.1514949054,
-0.7945187688,
-0.0999601856,
-0.3165172338,
0.0027441035,
-0.407795012,
-0.0560048781,
-0.2814795971,
0.0482370108,
-0.5349142551,
0.5937335491,
-0.2753535509,
0.8577615619,
-0.7332111001,
0.4676907659,
0.4661984146,
-0.7305999398,
-0.8093566895,
0.1993340105,
-0.1329820454,
-0.8090994358,
0.4427519143,
-0.0223334394,
-0.0666243061,
-0.0543432869,
-0.6886026859,
-0.6853449345,
0.8190659285,
0.2648390532,
-0.0094591137,
-0.1972098649,
0.3117911518,
0.5271522403,
0.1635237634,
0.3787158728,
0.5463005304,
0.4279028475,
0.4099792242,
-1.1022832394,
0.0204077121,
0.1174097881,
-0.2949737608,
-0.1251025647,
-0.8537067175,
0.6091960073,
-0.5137825012,
-0.2827191055,
-0.0881120563,
0.5373019576,
0.0494890958,
0.3280448616,
0.3549431562,
0.5600161552,
0.8793933988,
-0.2391539514,
1.172639966,
0.0513019748,
0.4035119116,
1.0146207809,
0.017684292,
0.5770422816,
0.0788902044,
-0.1766156554,
0.1031192839,
0.5456269979,
0.2006656975,
0.4672172964,
-0.1491256654,
-0.4002612829,
-0.3484391272,
0.0127818212,
-0.3102540374,
0.3936515152,
0.3862034976,
0.1361633688,
-0.2259537131,
0.0534580238,
0.1530014127,
-0.0197538827,
-0.0667484552,
0.6456927657,
-0.0459390208,
-0.8348876238,
0.5514907241,
-0.1312970817,
0.0885902792,
-0.5569634438,
-0.1916816682,
-0.4020454884,
-0.0048045563,
-0.0810028464,
-0.9933454394,
0.3515227139,
-0.2500363588,
-0.1945855469,
0.0946212709,
0.9564751983,
-0.2757398784,
-0.2211034149,
-0.162845999,
0.7117217183,
0.1630742401,
-0.2608938813,
-0.364993304,
-0.2425692081,
-0.0631630868,
-0.0850596502,
-0.093034476,
0.6025875807,
0.2064570487,
0.9467698336,
0.3955094814,
-0.1258290261,
0.2604327202,
-0.4568943977,
0.8236163855,
-0.4579260051,
-0.2730440497,
-0.62081182,
0.4100875556,
-0.1838114858,
-0.1390684396,
0.8804346919,
0.5819650888,
0.7152671814,
-0.2771889567,
1.106901288,
-0.167813465,
1.0260207653,
-0.6548331976,
0.7051105499,
-0.182589367,
0.2515435815,
-0.0967878401,
-0.7938451171,
-0.1147149801,
0.2051562518,
-0.4210282564,
-0.0469513834,
0.8026541471,
0.7496121526,
-0.2578581572,
0.2978420556,
0.5773047209,
0.4640850127,
0.324621439,
0.6954337955,
1.2399020195,
-0.5456084609,
1.0006957054,
-0.2479303628,
-0.291493535,
-0.1494052559,
-0.6018742919,
-1.0392255783,
-0.5257706046,
-0.3071212173,
-0.5328335166,
0.4182890654,
0.6119852662,
0.6856331825,
-0.7796202898,
0.2136453688,
0.0864443853,
0.3412577808,
0.1050485969,
-0.2327117324,
0.4217835367,
-0.5542907119,
-0.4147595167,
0.2461264282,
0.1324059814,
0.1953687072,
0.1706046909,
0.2274464965,
0.050293114,
0.3588076234,
0.5699827671,
0.5246314406,
-0.4464665651,
-0.7863883972,
0.11347498,
0.0858268142,
0.3714384437,
0.8023824096,
-0.4809424877,
0.2374162078,
0.3551250398,
0.8033925295,
0.3780923486,
0.3736657202,
0.4853413403,
-0.6662141085,
-0.2605312765,
0.3892474771,
0.1355340332,
0.5916855931,
-0.3234465122,
0.4708352983,
0.5181378126,
-0.7501318455,
-0.2881194651,
0.408111006,
-1.002779007,
-0.323712945,
1.1080127954,
-0.2645404637,
-0.073552005,
-0.5312203765,
-0.6344410777,
-0.0163256116,
-0.1360190809,
0.9427307248,
1.2094112635,
-0.3012596667,
-0.1278784573,
-1.0662819147,
0.5657366514,
0.2821053565,
-0.682125926,
0.2836309373,
0.6764802933,
0.4997059405,
0.2640849352,
0.5994288921,
-0.0149653815,
0.4479879737,
0.2028528154,
-0.2591195703,
0.1453748643,
-0.2030342519,
0.2344500124,
0.4359651804,
0.5509051681,
-0.139448747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10512v1 | "Can We Detect Substance Use Disorder?": Knowledge and Time Aware Classification on Social Media from Darkweb | 2023-04-20T17:47:13 | 2023-04-20T17:47:13 | Usha Lokala, Orchid Chetia Phukan, Triyasha Ghosh Dastidar, Francois Lamy, Raminta Daniulaityte, Amit Sheth | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI | Opioid and substance misuse is rampant in the United States today, with the
phenomenon known as the "opioid crisis". The relationship between substance use
and mental health has been extensively studied, with one possible relationship
being: substance misuse causes poor mental health. However, the lack of
evidence on the relationship has resulted in opioids being largely inaccessible
through legal means. This study analyzes the substance use posts on social
media with opioids being sold through crypto market listings. We use the Drug
Abuse Ontology, state-of-the-art deep learning, and knowledge-aware BERT-based
models to generate sentiment and emotion for the social media posts to
understand users' perceptions on social media by investigating questions such
as: which synthetic opioids people are optimistic, neutral, or negative about?
or what kind of drugs induced fear and sorrow? or what kind of drugs people
love or are thankful about? or which drugs people think negatively about? or
which opioids cause little to no sentimental reaction. We discuss how we
crawled crypto market data and its use in extracting posts for fentanyl,
fentanyl analogs, and other novel synthetic opioids. We also perform topic
analysis associated with the generated sentiments and emotions to understand
which topics correlate with people's responses to various drugs. Additionally,
we analyze time-aware neural models built on these features while considering
historical sentiment and emotional activity of posts related to a drug. The
most effective model performs well (statistically significant) with
(macroF1=82.12, recall =83.58) to identify substance use disorder. | [
-0.1545237303,
-0.8933765888,
0.8773968816,
0.1256033778,
-0.3977990448,
0.4075737298,
-0.1220049784,
-0.9168119431,
0.5138714314,
0.37013942,
-0.4277988374,
-0.8421730399,
-0.7343652248,
-0.1669716984,
-0.6100228429,
0.9653221369,
0.1707241535,
0.2929331958,
0.0925830379,
0.0362209305,
-0.1258006096,
-0.4659223557,
-0.7260020971,
-0.2235953063,
0.8573330045,
0.1174621582,
0.4480327368,
-0.0011711258,
0.7784973383,
0.2850038707,
0.1062928736,
-0.1091432795,
-0.3392464221,
-0.0525489971,
-0.356992811,
-0.2476628274,
-0.6020513177,
-0.0850174576,
-0.2358846813,
0.6612653732,
-0.1687854677,
0.1037087142,
-0.2247254848,
0.4061541557,
-0.7707400918,
-0.4594274759,
-0.7941191196,
0.1505479217,
-0.0071019158,
-0.4818013906,
0.1875346452,
-0.2392509729,
0.0598427355,
-0.9035748839,
0.484559685,
0.1101014167,
0.734070003,
0.2947395146,
-0.4131221175,
-0.5870326757,
-0.9342115521,
0.5201367736,
-0.6004402041,
0.2810294032,
0.570958972,
0.4451521039,
0.0823336393,
-0.6961674094,
-0.673892796,
0.1681497991,
0.0635372326,
-0.1365438551,
0.1439794898,
0.068549253,
0.1995768845,
0.5208826661,
-0.6139275432,
-0.0903201774,
-0.7508144379,
-0.2489553988,
0.6595455408,
0.328910917,
0.6522408724,
-0.1955620199,
-0.5185608864,
0.4035916924,
-0.2662069499,
-0.079897128,
0.2638100386,
0.0828804672,
-0.2204141915,
0.7179226875,
0.2714846432,
0.3421931565,
0.0498229265,
-0.0495003127,
0.2833174467,
-0.3673505783,
-0.4555939138,
0.3050912619,
0.9716573358,
0.8129174709,
-0.0987588242,
-0.1091651171,
-0.2906864583,
0.2134875059,
0.6253933311,
-0.8396111131,
-0.2109240443,
0.4914462268,
-0.9367560744,
-0.5008563995,
-0.0736790821,
-0.5964294672,
-1.001947403,
-0.122772269,
0.6785443425,
-0.3334212899,
-0.4272496104,
0.3142341971,
-0.4424481392,
-0.2694455981,
0.075352326,
-0.8237934113,
0.5029457808,
0.7741068006,
1.0557844639,
-0.2874109149,
0.1040902138,
0.1362770796,
-0.0656669214,
-0.5369494557,
0.6733927727,
-0.200673908,
-0.267475903,
0.0521814711,
0.3383002579,
0.2391061932,
-0.6872269511,
0.3395236731,
-0.7350735664,
-0.0296874195,
-0.5348505378,
-0.5437188745,
-0.0100643206,
0.2517284155,
-0.4794765413,
0.4684280753,
0.2089620382,
-1.0598376989,
0.6885760427,
-0.674298346,
-0.3472074568,
0.0463994741,
0.206733942,
-0.0573543645,
0.1635770053,
-0.1567448974,
0.5876877904,
-0.0021832944,
0.322753787,
-0.9071179628,
-0.5602177382,
0.6665433645,
-0.101416938,
0.8775292635,
0.6086966395,
-0.1225704998,
-0.0123332953,
-0.8037031293,
-0.3761220872,
0.1087975055,
-0.0646660104,
-0.8766613007,
-0.0050606728,
0.271715194,
0.2944288254,
0.2300983667,
-0.8693960905,
-0.0958570912,
-0.1328839809,
0.5657461286,
0.7358654737,
0.5281978846,
0.1727735251,
-0.3528067172,
0.2845894396,
0.1408109218,
0.4902059138,
0.544850409,
-0.1507642716,
-0.407563895,
-0.0472848155,
0.1841866523,
0.5537442565,
-0.5514112711,
0.6004665494,
-0.185487628,
-0.4856312871,
-0.3706958294,
-0.0079115629,
-0.3416766226,
0.4376789331,
0.4544757605,
-0.0871073529,
-0.5258132219,
-0.6720831394,
-0.2090574205,
0.198251605,
-0.0140609471,
0.2237541974,
0.5386114717,
-0.4923683703,
0.4041855931,
-0.5959540606,
-0.4392283559,
0.1101523414,
0.4759253561,
0.1135879755,
-0.0166817158,
0.6749151945,
-0.8646419048,
-0.3643968105,
0.0660596713,
-0.673743844,
-0.0526304655,
-0.1102319509,
-0.0241498221,
-0.1964531839,
0.4773031771,
-0.0762851685,
0.2045619935,
0.3560917675,
-0.5270238519,
0.0113235554,
-0.168429777,
0.3013850749,
-1.0576267242,
0.2484772205,
0.0134862037,
0.1960548013,
-0.4596598744,
-0.7499502301,
-0.2287276089,
-0.2502868772,
-0.2573848367,
0.2793082893,
-0.1303364187,
-0.1866616905,
-0.5114346147,
0.0548612066,
-0.088984549,
0.03031688,
-0.0761728063,
0.2312559783,
0.6804884076,
-0.6452590823,
0.4582668245,
-0.3915271461,
-0.6711337566,
0.6698130369,
-0.4419322312,
-0.1667585522,
-0.0690677166,
-0.2635842264,
-1.0188673735,
-0.3361077011,
0.6489290595,
-0.708104372,
0.2446837276,
0.0090430127,
-0.2713360786,
-0.4000224769,
-0.1766289324,
0.2671858668,
0.16735892,
-0.0201661661,
0.3670834005,
0.6929818988,
-0.0803486779,
-0.8335210085,
-0.725064218,
-0.0774681568,
-0.3278615177,
-0.3103826046,
0.3229365051,
0.0156146009,
-0.5671649575,
0.4437248111,
-0.1833889335,
-0.1968782246,
0.321952492,
0.2351153791,
0.2009636611,
0.3072572052,
0.7064555287,
0.146754384,
0.0639326051,
0.4652307928,
0.0236975309,
0.6506857276,
0.298202455,
-0.0507766828,
-0.2877796888,
0.4672258496,
0.6054643393,
0.1184778884,
0.6906264424,
0.8105041385,
-0.6148429513,
-0.3369137943,
-0.4252740443,
-0.3682370186,
-0.4586402476,
0.0578217246,
0.2254981846,
-0.5732461214,
0.6397697926,
0.2173826247,
-0.1463409066,
0.2425961345,
0.3114592433,
-0.4733812809,
1.0458837748,
0.3999381065,
0.0816273615,
0.494689554,
-0.5272140503,
0.3798033893,
-0.5788996816,
-0.2894366682,
0.0234415568,
-0.6885216832,
-0.6390022039,
-0.3949916363,
0.3602998853,
-0.1470519006,
-0.2865866125,
-0.1339561641,
-0.5472961664,
0.066858761,
0.2585460246,
0.416693151,
0.0880119503,
0.0238934942,
0.315207988,
-0.066644758,
-0.3018419445,
-0.2520869672,
1.2004686594,
0.2959980369,
0.6941510439,
-0.3623071015,
0.6757901311,
0.7365739942,
0.5805546641,
-0.9335718155,
0.3854741454,
-0.286942035,
-0.9372916222,
-0.0123066632,
-0.4655796885,
-0.8593686223,
-0.1969143748,
-0.5747974515,
-0.4567871988,
0.4448623955,
-0.0942737833,
-0.7095927596,
0.5501644611,
-0.5551838875,
0.8441954851,
-0.8010877371,
-0.2490548939,
-0.5224529505,
-0.5540744662,
0.3251812458,
-0.1281243712,
0.6934955716,
-0.5593374372,
-0.2116834223,
0.9208123088,
-0.5798674822,
0.7624974251,
-0.3246690631,
0.0242453646,
0.4290525615,
-0.0307363328,
-0.2153042257,
-0.0588271432,
0.4206450582,
0.151120618,
0.0965256169,
-0.2530222833,
-0.7840141058,
0.7285885215,
-0.8680264354,
-0.0871199667,
-0.3409813344,
-0.2402770072,
0.0255777165,
0.2262588441,
0.4483557343,
0.1181403473,
-0.1510270536,
0.0707483888,
0.5317901373,
-0.165584892,
0.3585288823,
0.3270576894,
-0.3932766914,
-0.6376733184,
1.0548202991,
0.6603095531,
-0.025834946,
0.3372947276,
0.48277089,
-0.1483716965,
-0.6295378804,
0.2597452104,
0.3517776728,
-0.42014727,
-0.1067001224,
-0.7828394771,
0.0113372132,
-0.6197117567,
-0.0263684876,
-0.308147639,
-0.2668101192,
-0.3430585861,
-0.3388914764,
0.4774020016,
0.9476003647,
-0.5394557714,
0.1838451475,
-0.7727336287,
0.7226853967,
0.5585536361,
0.7065769434,
0.0413726084,
0.0572832227,
-0.0567598902,
-0.0010536409,
-0.2765759826,
-1.1319458485,
0.1867767274,
-0.2237268537,
0.3115783334,
1.1164162159,
0.597640276,
0.3367167413,
0.2349314094,
0.735054791,
0.2632474303,
-0.7254056931,
0.4343908727,
-0.5158187151,
-0.5110495687,
0.5437036157,
1.0007231236,
-1.0361863375,
-0.0264732819,
-0.5787846446,
-0.7951589823,
0.4540968239,
-0.0412184112,
0.1211606711,
-0.2871057689,
0.2050086856,
0.1698976159,
0.3188350499,
-0.6275279522,
-0.3298712373,
-0.4504586756,
-0.1681287885,
0.1626235694,
-0.329757601,
-0.0402019918,
-0.1551207155,
0.379594326,
0.2052029669,
0.2474867702,
0.1715477705,
0.1743362844,
-0.2489994317,
0.2959814966,
0.3538873792,
0.7584407926,
-0.7504980564,
0.3076376021,
-0.1346714944,
-0.616967082,
0.0890926272,
-0.0702786967,
-0.1938069463,
-0.1711567193,
0.2503401339,
0.4779539704,
0.0659619495,
-0.7546083927,
0.618708849,
-0.0892408192,
-0.3582169116,
-0.4124834836,
0.086707674,
0.0052379142,
0.2533199787,
0.4814163446,
0.3337256014,
0.4431651831,
-1.0306942463,
-0.0235651936,
0.4259689152,
-0.6717900634,
-0.4043124318,
0.5155398846,
0.2114226073,
-0.3668388128,
0.4272632897,
-0.2284282148,
-0.4218376875,
0.4318588376,
0.0820470974,
0.7519552708,
-0.1497813016,
0.2853522897,
0.5260378122,
-0.0230915714,
0.1548904479,
0.686332345,
-0.154046908,
-1.0133757591,
0.1311450601,
-0.3636285365,
0.1111129969,
0.5159131289,
-0.6665881276,
0.1486995071,
-0.8820496202,
-0.9330585599,
0.1583909392,
0.0836641043,
-0.3305331469,
0.3935752213,
0.2207984626,
0.4916786849,
-1.0040209293,
0.2911213338,
0.5986627936,
-0.0988996252,
-0.2622287869,
-0.1093714759,
-0.1095819697,
-0.4075465202,
0.30758214,
0.1263871044,
-0.2196975052,
-0.4623627663,
-0.9302428961,
-0.4887475669,
1.0000237226,
-0.280684948,
-0.3656198084,
0.0318397433,
-0.0347642116,
0.8675801158,
-0.3696553111,
-0.1542860419,
0.2312853783,
0.3379452527,
0.2317143232,
-0.400778383,
-0.0938584879,
-0.3887860477,
-0.1329233348,
0.2058419883,
-0.2616915703,
0.7804639339,
-0.5013623238,
-0.7103933692,
-0.2334026247,
0.0207596421,
-0.0174970739,
0.88841784,
0.7282140851,
0.5570577979,
0.8087636828,
0.0745116994,
0.7598176599,
-0.2653058171,
0.3457876146,
0.8865323663,
-0.1328306198,
0.7824219465,
0.4738351703,
0.0100537091,
0.5050266981,
0.959035635,
-0.150956288,
0.7620353699,
0.177904591,
-0.0907752961,
-0.5166720748,
-0.2963939309,
-0.4012118578,
0.1157103404,
0.8090520501,
-0.7577623129,
0.0584107563,
0.2569222152,
-0.0566768646,
-0.0881428123,
-0.4861895144,
0.7945542932,
0.2150728256,
-0.1380145699,
0.3027318716,
-0.2381498516,
0.7872819901,
-0.4498949647,
0.2448120713,
0.1186750382,
0.2695606649,
-0.3977850974,
-0.7926377654,
0.5989135504,
-0.3976350725,
-0.2206325978,
0.0174409095,
0.7919095159,
-0.3883318007,
-0.5608779192,
0.677497983,
0.3372301161,
0.096637629,
-0.2375259846,
-0.7246237993,
-0.1327647269,
-0.3225160539,
0.1112432107,
0.1783183664,
0.5282446742,
0.1786456257,
0.6978033185,
0.7299695611,
0.5848621726,
-0.0658471957,
-0.0181275178,
0.535631299,
-0.6565662026,
-0.237789914,
-0.5636765957,
0.2783042789,
-0.3817510903,
-0.2675249875,
0.4180800617,
0.4502617717,
0.779058218,
0.050698854,
0.714627862,
-0.2350743264,
0.9171121716,
-0.2832919657,
1.214222312,
-0.9744654894,
0.2083039582,
-0.1429198533,
-0.538002193,
-0.1991292983,
0.5488418937,
-0.5481002927,
-0.0287807602,
0.6004578471,
0.5948123336,
0.0324083418,
-0.0520150214,
0.0018137553,
0.2947044373,
0.0568694435,
0.373714149,
0.9738248587,
-0.357183665,
0.4354676604,
-0.6247608662,
0.0336870179,
-0.3778572083,
-0.5417540073,
-0.9901633859,
-0.6015440822,
-0.2048558593,
-0.4589182734,
-0.1384931803,
1.0870426893,
0.4598759115,
-0.7988496423,
-0.051185403,
0.0666391253,
0.5416867733,
-0.2534235418,
-0.345998615,
0.2326034307,
0.0223026797,
-0.2456240803,
-0.0684870332,
0.2046255618,
0.3212694526,
-0.1336065084,
0.2525854409,
-0.0911591426,
-0.1539809257,
0.4238663912,
-0.0906312987,
-0.4876760244,
0.0417689197,
0.3959721029,
-0.3662680686,
-0.0893863216,
1.3172163963,
-0.171350643,
0.5984807611,
0.9492120743,
0.0896599516,
0.2370942831,
0.1553062797,
0.3866346478,
-0.1327963769,
-0.3950936198,
0.5835009217,
0.3787338138,
0.3249282241,
-0.3817501366,
0.1764286458,
0.5379689336,
-0.4729361534,
-0.6005403996,
-0.2408442795,
-0.9979250431,
-0.7742626071,
0.6844451427,
0.1383288056,
-0.4412237108,
-0.5982282758,
-0.1800120622,
0.1877509803,
-0.4940614402,
1.3223718405,
0.4916723669,
-0.0205963776,
-0.0910151601,
-0.6696743369,
0.4976347089,
-0.3643264472,
-0.7096759677,
0.1533663273,
0.2563521266,
0.5787112117,
0.555249989,
0.7129588723,
0.0054405555,
0.27774176,
0.0130047863,
0.0075890915,
-0.0776243135,
-0.0636792779,
0.0952571779,
0.2543742657,
-0.5434650183,
-0.1415945739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10464v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10464v4 | Learning to Plan with Natural Language | 2023-04-20T17:09:12 | 2023-12-13T02:08:50 | Yiduo Guo, Yaobo Liang, Chenfei Wu, Wenshan Wu, Dongyan Zhao, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in various
basic natural language tasks. For completing the complex task, we still need a
plan for the task to guide LLMs to generate the specific solutions step by
step. LLMs can directly generate task plans, but these plans may still contain
factual errors or are incomplete. A high-quality task plan contains correct
step-by-step solutions for solving all situations and behavioral instructions
for avoiding mistakes. To obtain it, we propose the Learning to Plan method,
which involves two phases: (1) In the first learning task plan phase, it
iteratively updates the task plan with new step-by-step solutions and
behavioral instructions, which are obtained by prompting LLMs to derive from
training error feedback. (2) In the subsequent test phase, the LLM uses the
learned task plan to guide the inference of LLM on the test set. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of our method on the five different reasoning type tasks (8
datasets). Further, our analysis experiment shows that the task plan learned by
one LLM can directly guide another LLM to improve its performance, which
reveals a new transfer learning paradigm. We release the code at
\url{https://github.com/Eureka6174/LearnNLPlan} | [
0.0488252118,
-0.724784255,
0.5728033781,
0.5059189796,
-0.1227835491,
-0.0241594519,
-0.2758244276,
-0.2883137465,
0.1396549493,
0.775044322,
-0.8797038198,
-0.4948560596,
-0.4620604217,
0.0435505398,
-0.1341779679,
0.8053225875,
-0.3216120899,
0.1209003106,
0.0377985276,
0.3603491485,
-0.783633709,
-0.1391815841,
-0.9724700451,
-0.5660825968,
0.4776592255,
0.7761787772,
0.0824214816,
0.3453611135,
0.369310528,
0.2539015114,
-0.0143855289,
0.3874536455,
-0.3428509235,
0.1837347597,
-0.3339243829,
-0.5576223135,
-0.3754530251,
-0.2561628819,
0.3100979328,
0.8681870699,
-0.2818854749,
0.1152546927,
0.1362881362,
0.9084253311,
-0.3798565567,
0.7514835596,
-0.6373602748,
0.1952481568,
0.2055370212,
-0.3160877824,
-0.7082769871,
-0.2499332279,
0.1969906688,
-0.689381063,
0.1060343012,
0.0303009897,
0.3765119016,
0.2091852129,
-0.366766423,
-0.5319170356,
-1.015004158,
0.6014171243,
-0.6554788351,
0.0566872135,
0.3402627409,
0.4247658849,
-0.4309769273,
-0.5102927685,
-0.6188299656,
-0.3635534048,
-0.0359793566,
-0.0051076273,
0.2051021755,
0.0792132318,
0.4333693087,
-0.0770345107,
-0.6156864762,
0.1521290392,
-0.3229431808,
-0.108113192,
0.7621479034,
0.1592771858,
0.0853536278,
-0.1175063476,
-0.5454919934,
-0.1951365173,
-0.5224944949,
0.0302488506,
-0.0342780426,
0.5891408324,
-0.1563967466,
0.7119576335,
-0.500066638,
0.6335502267,
-0.0146434084,
-0.4951176941,
0.0760774985,
-0.2197318524,
-0.4177044034,
0.1468078941,
0.4569976628,
0.0309905484,
0.5029668808,
-0.1540410668,
-0.3803746998,
-0.0717186108,
0.4041807652,
-0.4749287069,
-0.2741370499,
0.0991851166,
-0.1352887899,
0.0231703874,
-0.4625277221,
-0.7126255631,
-0.3138806522,
-0.7329012752,
0.7894496918,
-0.5555787683,
0.0079144239,
0.3832788765,
0.2118412256,
0.2549770474,
0.5793397427,
-0.7572010159,
0.4269716442,
0.6769388914,
0.4647679031,
-0.0077459463,
-0.2758510113,
-0.73775208,
0.3650870323,
-0.525478363,
0.9554451108,
-0.0191987827,
-0.3500543535,
0.3318427205,
-0.3683909774,
-0.2840625048,
-0.4349553287,
0.5193362236,
-0.3656774163,
0.2047896832,
-0.3476776481,
-0.697627902,
-0.465092957,
0.3975935876,
-0.7034952044,
0.9590496421,
0.0234442726,
-0.3567636311,
0.2958595455,
-0.9018911123,
-0.7773059011,
-0.0069939275,
-0.0795795023,
-0.0848042294,
-0.2339541614,
0.2752131522,
0.7987372875,
-0.1010701507,
0.3440666199,
0.1324466169,
-0.0444653556,
-0.0503668115,
-0.0225879401,
0.59997648,
-0.0350435823,
-0.56726408,
0.3650467396,
-0.8057578206,
0.0834569409,
0.3770796061,
-0.6721920967,
0.1058708355,
0.0532973707,
-0.2935827672,
0.3249311745,
0.0932753384,
-0.306432426,
0.2641324997,
-0.3444101512,
0.1452037841,
0.6210119724,
-0.0389161631,
0.5536206365,
-0.5730214119,
0.2295811921,
-0.1481800526,
-0.0953715518,
-0.0893911943,
-0.2712919712,
-1.1136753559,
0.0807770342,
-0.0877257437,
0.8401992917,
-0.9272408485,
0.4559152722,
-0.1864927858,
-0.3597920835,
0.0046621151,
0.3122093678,
0.5258392692,
0.5702422857,
0.6128738523,
-0.0371244028,
-0.5004871488,
-0.705026567,
-0.1844731569,
-0.155207321,
0.1571617275,
-0.1553116292,
0.5780783296,
0.0156857576,
0.7470411062,
-0.5316610336,
-0.5599989891,
-0.8616736531,
0.3841919303,
0.0463364497,
0.3516162634,
0.0395369269,
-0.6102948785,
-0.4863863885,
-0.2005209923,
-0.4489698112,
0.139713645,
-0.4196363986,
-0.3463398218,
0.322539866,
0.5016133189,
-0.5980180502,
0.2232466638,
0.4037922323,
-0.4099578261,
0.6778348684,
-0.1567647308,
-0.3479706049,
-1.249966979,
-0.0792995244,
0.1907195747,
-0.3114388883,
-0.8019278646,
-0.1945236623,
-0.0118901851,
0.0138095021,
-0.3107140958,
0.6918347478,
-0.331258297,
-0.0051595713,
-0.320441097,
-0.1417100132,
-0.062401209,
0.9558979869,
0.0871312767,
0.5620705485,
0.4225707352,
-0.7678150535,
0.1413403302,
0.5262949467,
-0.2742871344,
0.4968318641,
-0.2712619901,
0.1337146163,
-0.3121814728,
0.4198916852,
-0.7865744233,
-0.2686218023,
0.4032992125,
-0.1640815735,
0.6613753438,
-0.0253183637,
-0.4328443706,
-0.2583141327,
0.0722990483,
-0.2109912187,
0.2538884878,
-0.4672080874,
0.8851662874,
0.064610824,
-0.3097930253,
-0.326985985,
-0.5942230225,
-0.0354330875,
-0.0683675855,
-0.4155110121,
0.4260175526,
-0.07637012,
-0.2066239417,
-0.1385368258,
-0.1686721593,
-0.2176538557,
-0.0617858991,
0.2400681376,
0.2798690796,
0.0065353736,
0.1743659675,
-0.2812616229,
-0.2230450511,
0.3808092475,
-0.2089499384,
0.5642892718,
0.2435958982,
-0.2420963049,
-0.4548403919,
0.3834686875,
0.2644986212,
-0.2603005171,
0.5227999687,
0.3294562101,
-0.4254341722,
-0.6003239751,
-0.5195223689,
-0.1395559311,
-0.4018158317,
0.3225720823,
-0.2672238946,
-0.5242522359,
0.0748916715,
-0.2285744846,
0.549285233,
0.1552653313,
0.2862395644,
-0.2773454189,
0.7272723317,
0.8170449138,
-0.0741117969,
0.2793235183,
-0.4395619929,
0.1822792739,
-0.6165811419,
-0.5183773637,
-0.4843511581,
-0.387003243,
-0.0658381507,
-0.771584332,
-0.0457036495,
0.1253628731,
-0.4440251887,
0.2232812047,
-0.0464631543,
0.2148943394,
0.5976067781,
0.1607577801,
0.4191775918,
0.1204501763,
-0.1991205961,
0.1022951305,
-0.5685566068,
-0.5668609142,
0.9807862043,
0.2511318922,
0.6289643049,
-0.068110235,
0.9142611027,
0.0377819613,
0.2864568233,
-0.8577589989,
0.8043298721,
0.0399273224,
-0.2674057186,
-0.5038348436,
-0.4113535583,
-0.7214852571,
0.0206064302,
-0.3736209869,
-0.6766039729,
-0.1576949805,
0.1391101629,
-0.1958974004,
0.1668992192,
-0.605696559,
0.6532025337,
-0.463244468,
-0.0772990435,
-0.264798373,
-0.5177515745,
0.3047155142,
-0.070606716,
0.1038426906,
-0.3590316772,
0.1424375325,
0.9846937656,
-0.0513261817,
1.0573451519,
-0.1818286031,
0.0344140716,
0.2676080167,
0.3308311403,
0.989284873,
-0.1850125194,
-0.0745194182,
-0.3019945323,
-0.5085046887,
-0.438641876,
-0.5179715753,
0.3011133373,
-0.360489428,
-0.5111079216,
-0.2378833592,
-0.8409367204,
-0.5760304332,
0.3241783082,
-0.0152332326,
0.3963432312,
-0.0394093283,
-0.2465013117,
0.7186768055,
-0.1490470767,
0.5077754855,
0.5829751492,
-0.3126112521,
-0.1081280261,
0.5580325127,
-0.0764760748,
0.4458949566,
0.6241580844,
0.2417993993,
-0.3119597435,
-0.8866767883,
-0.1128058061,
0.3692750037,
-0.8392281532,
-0.0776442811,
-0.4421027899,
-0.2267183959,
-0.2891492546,
-0.0880452693,
-0.4012674093,
-0.0697281733,
0.0086181061,
-0.1759794503,
0.1225887239,
0.7037028074,
0.2172866613,
0.1456082761,
-0.6046206355,
0.4312700331,
0.46394521,
0.0046194852,
-0.1613492817,
-0.2819525599,
0.0560652986,
-0.0193758346,
-0.3157715201,
-0.8031238317,
0.5062921047,
0.1136385724,
0.6577070951,
0.0673418641,
0.1463001519,
0.693531394,
-0.4996105731,
0.3346526027,
0.1587933451,
-0.6064670086,
0.7570812702,
-0.1395571381,
0.3177992105,
0.603051722,
0.5172010064,
-0.3890407681,
-0.2234039307,
-0.4903112352,
-0.6352377534,
0.465606004,
0.0745284259,
0.0340336524,
0.1665499061,
0.3290458322,
0.0976898745,
0.1124259531,
-0.8474965096,
-0.2927321792,
0.2399757057,
-0.1352593601,
-0.059140671,
-0.2148546726,
-0.203094393,
-0.2254444957,
0.6834488511,
-0.5521554351,
0.3792760074,
0.2574307621,
-0.136670351,
-0.1035457328,
0.3790622354,
0.6004268527,
0.829595983,
0.048935689,
0.096584864,
0.2494061887,
-0.2184180319,
-0.0757415593,
0.1108335778,
-0.1541474164,
-0.1064518094,
0.6192026734,
0.8782272339,
0.4627033174,
-0.8211883307,
0.3097822666,
0.0339719132,
-0.7296537161,
-0.4310913682,
0.2368575633,
0.3984647393,
0.4538785219,
0.2962584794,
0.0664120466,
-0.1717965007,
-0.6620327234,
0.0764445439,
0.1297676861,
-0.4748315215,
-0.0531132556,
0.2414817214,
0.1653677225,
-0.4994966686,
0.54449898,
-0.4440113306,
-0.6538603902,
0.4786919355,
0.817738831,
0.6722576618,
-0.0293281935,
0.5843669772,
0.4450564384,
0.2537809014,
-0.3904780447,
0.7057445049,
0.1419833899,
-0.7048286796,
-0.9829745293,
-0.6549368501,
-0.2605887055,
0.1871090382,
-0.3564865291,
0.2581065297,
-0.4842404127,
0.5414167643,
-0.2156091928,
0.211571604,
-0.7179259062,
0.2557510734,
0.22646451,
1.1196806431,
-0.6793860197,
0.713691175,
0.7684088945,
-0.2113967091,
-1.4290579557,
0.1634803563,
0.048875615,
-0.9080669284,
0.8442303538,
0.2786942422,
0.1254683733,
-0.012090968,
-0.2401099354,
-0.9392871857,
1.0657483339,
0.1843878478,
-0.7734206915,
-0.342000246,
0.1709554642,
0.1992756575,
-0.3696326911,
-0.26332587,
0.4850291312,
0.5328269005,
0.5372542143,
-0.8956928253,
0.1688048542,
0.2557977438,
-0.2573690116,
0.4232198894,
-0.0421052389,
0.6691305637,
-0.575879395,
-0.2869109511,
-0.178718254,
0.6325145364,
0.2792384028,
0.3646707833,
0.6281978488,
0.6127528548,
0.9017409682,
0.1256394833,
0.7713086009,
0.1072508097,
0.1696755886,
1.4385896921,
-0.4459145665,
1.1526992321,
0.3480341136,
-0.0041638203,
0.466332972,
0.3592054844,
0.2717979252,
0.5095892549,
0.3511640429,
-0.1158011109,
-0.3501634002,
0.146165967,
0.1177873835,
0.4683195353,
0.3850641549,
-0.0936442614,
-0.5273365378,
0.084537603,
0.1540452838,
0.3151910007,
-0.3852224052,
0.8371460438,
0.0856769532,
-0.8078868389,
0.3168335259,
-0.257589519,
0.4594228864,
-0.5721960068,
-0.2397876978,
-0.0731876716,
0.1631225199,
-0.1748153567,
-0.7888520956,
0.3726862371,
-0.1906962693,
0.0037659402,
-0.4181345999,
0.6914097071,
-0.4588163197,
-0.564448297,
0.3397427201,
0.5272316933,
-0.1148369908,
-0.2868286967,
-0.7590668201,
-0.4782040417,
0.0770307109,
-0.1313361824,
0.2843840718,
0.280784905,
-0.14384,
0.881421268,
0.6221002936,
0.2423671037,
0.2813691199,
-0.1097061858,
0.6331411004,
-0.7918886542,
-0.4776490927,
-0.5918502808,
0.5167143941,
-0.1733751297,
-0.2480829656,
0.2644037902,
0.4831420481,
0.9571703672,
0.064942576,
0.6293501854,
0.0451363474,
0.671446681,
-0.9865512252,
0.0422456376,
-0.2174149156,
0.2734029591,
0.1655638516,
-0.982517302,
-0.3034310341,
0.6017110348,
-0.3843240738,
-0.2510861754,
1.0816035271,
0.6932370663,
0.2712868154,
-0.0059482227,
0.1035732925,
0.0703629851,
0.4814464748,
0.8427150846,
0.5767428875,
-0.0553826652,
0.6032425165,
-0.5491508842,
-0.131844461,
-0.1504972875,
-0.8859301209,
-0.9106109142,
-0.5000834465,
-0.3993028402,
-0.1656330973,
0.1352475584,
1.1687328815,
0.6343487501,
-0.5578601956,
-0.4202960432,
-0.4090527296,
0.1043879613,
-0.3858831227,
-0.1564312875,
0.1892103255,
-0.8177133799,
-0.4443394542,
0.61372298,
0.1133510098,
-0.0779413357,
-0.2287597805,
-0.3592604995,
-0.4490044713,
-0.0626462847,
0.6828015447,
0.3043710887,
-0.6583042741,
-0.1956677437,
-0.1238223836,
-0.2649050653,
-0.0091017,
0.9762438536,
-0.574639976,
0.2028558254,
0.432180196,
0.7227712274,
0.7018198967,
-0.351005733,
0.5843344331,
-0.6992837787,
-0.1185394078,
0.3941102624,
0.2580213249,
0.1074124724,
-0.2073331177,
0.6000800729,
-0.1449584365,
-0.4740523696,
-0.3576019704,
0.2632437348,
-1.205501318,
-0.4214693606,
1.4525538683,
0.107922107,
-0.195408389,
-0.2616327703,
-0.4510908127,
0.3100295961,
-0.2982634604,
0.7318170667,
0.404987663,
-0.3670316935,
0.0572760701,
-0.987865448,
0.6517404318,
0.4125092328,
-1.1575007439,
0.0285652801,
0.3381545246,
0.3154072165,
0.3311317563,
0.7456768751,
0.282333374,
0.1077629775,
-0.3356922269,
0.1000850871,
0.0006910989,
-0.5583872199,
0.0576867871,
0.0622344874,
0.2480340153,
-0.2152468711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10453v1 | Phoenix: Democratizing ChatGPT across Languages | 2023-04-20T16:50:04 | 2023-04-20T16:50:04 | Zhihong Chen, Feng Jiang, Junying Chen, Tiannan Wang, Fei Yu, Guiming Chen, Hongbo Zhang, Juhao Liang, Chen Zhang, Zhiyi Zhang, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents our efforts to democratize ChatGPT across language. We
release a large language model "Phoenix", achieving competitive performance
among open-source English and Chinese models while excelling in languages with
limited resources (covering both Latin and non-Latin languages). We believe
this work will be beneficial to make ChatGPT more accessible, especially in
countries where people cannot use ChatGPT due to restrictions from OpenAI or
local goverments. Our data, code, and models are available at
https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/LLMZoo. | [
-0.1362871379,
-0.4809784889,
0.2901128232,
0.5020678043,
-0.1389097869,
-0.1788269579,
-0.5344552398,
-0.5387664437,
0.1228532493,
0.7184535861,
-0.5765297413,
-0.5005041957,
-0.6661931276,
0.0356797874,
-0.4350191653,
0.8819947839,
0.1232196614,
0.2955898046,
0.1217353418,
0.0155765144,
0.0460193194,
-0.5946618915,
-0.9234286547,
-0.5074793696,
0.5576054454,
0.7926618457,
1.016572237,
0.8780289888,
1.04251194,
0.2098219097,
0.3164930046,
-0.1917785108,
-0.5458117723,
-0.0196489412,
-0.0976561457,
-0.4184140563,
-0.5646647215,
0.1468295306,
0.8642885685,
0.4162250459,
-0.3072181344,
0.0004516635,
-0.0008837328,
0.4816893339,
-0.685536027,
0.7193918228,
-0.516381979,
0.0205073357,
-0.4847715497,
-0.0208280403,
-0.3811540604,
-0.3257414699,
-0.0253398586,
-0.7680040002,
-0.1160946637,
0.1824352145,
0.5399855375,
0.0546577424,
-0.2704566419,
-0.2159675807,
-1.1314591169,
0.7451053262,
-0.7063223124,
0.4524485171,
0.4990250468,
0.8082638383,
-0.106012173,
-1.1856738329,
-0.6100561619,
-0.4528600872,
0.1377806515,
0.1568254679,
-0.1650037318,
0.1436371654,
-0.0076839989,
0.6082109213,
-0.4871803522,
0.090444617,
-0.5895768404,
-0.1428562701,
1.0190672874,
0.1032783985,
0.646848321,
0.1393506825,
-0.1650454402,
-0.1832518727,
-0.8282561898,
0.0797473043,
0.4094322026,
0.8454858065,
-0.3318141103,
0.960850358,
-0.4442195892,
0.3835381567,
-0.6575731039,
0.0308034495,
0.1253909171,
-0.2632448971,
-0.3582604229,
-0.1286859512,
1.071154356,
0.1908075213,
0.2613640428,
-0.1324672252,
-0.0713718757,
-0.2324467599,
-0.1226612702,
-0.8734071851,
-0.3499253094,
0.3346624076,
-0.3890283108,
-0.0045235665,
0.3127818406,
-0.6236020923,
-0.8255215287,
-0.0077419789,
0.3099519908,
-0.2795120478,
-0.6099303961,
0.3036818504,
-0.0334148593,
0.4468995035,
0.3475098908,
-1.207398653,
0.3617735803,
1.139554739,
0.9268248677,
-0.0184828825,
-0.621178627,
-0.3337608576,
-0.1275546104,
-0.2415551096,
0.6710813046,
-0.8146212101,
-0.4969649017,
0.0015282658,
0.1200622171,
-0.0972633958,
-0.3206619918,
0.5158744454,
-0.2832936049,
0.499545753,
-0.3967868388,
-0.318967253,
-0.2419820577,
0.2919508219,
-0.6527063251,
0.740062654,
-0.075773403,
-0.9268397689,
0.2751544416,
-1.0171802044,
-0.0544631928,
0.2134932578,
-0.0676231384,
-0.414583385,
-0.4464679062,
0.1604823023,
0.3361915052,
-0.4255737066,
0.0383517928,
-0.494500488,
-0.5454931855,
0.01352889,
-0.3057387769,
1.110322237,
0.3908111751,
-0.214329049,
0.5876900554,
-0.4069606364,
-0.2362131029,
0.2161173373,
-0.0827943161,
-0.147251755,
0.4148795903,
0.3477226496,
0.0769737884,
0.2482853532,
-0.7138569355,
0.7069446445,
-0.4526197314,
0.5015391111,
0.5413845778,
-0.1030081138,
0.6276428103,
-0.2976199687,
0.4269680977,
-0.0430486798,
0.6151888967,
-0.1207718253,
-0.7923538089,
-0.9317001104,
-0.3890773952,
0.1791440994,
0.8815372586,
-0.5983850956,
0.0604789034,
-0.4476477802,
-0.7653650045,
-0.6423605084,
-0.0853760168,
-0.0884782746,
-0.0227486212,
-0.024052117,
-0.3862706125,
-0.4036296606,
-1.1139817238,
-0.0287763551,
-0.4025001228,
-0.2462515682,
0.3870999217,
0.4542893469,
-0.1969934255,
0.9507399797,
-0.1031305566,
-0.3074940145,
-0.5918217897,
-0.3113280237,
0.0827559382,
0.2684006691,
0.3313585818,
-0.8027932048,
-0.6520615816,
0.422047317,
-0.464281559,
0.01656623,
0.0115456451,
-0.1385139376,
-0.0906243324,
0.0919387862,
-0.4087433815,
0.3150301874,
0.8708034754,
-0.2987572551,
0.2530077696,
-0.1138457507,
0.3482190073,
-1.5384987593,
0.0043501151,
-0.1680103093,
-0.147745803,
-0.6539477706,
0.2759213448,
-0.027327776,
-0.3488281965,
-0.8437028527,
0.5752493739,
-0.2601761222,
-0.2441650778,
-0.3864866793,
0.371060878,
-0.4897654653,
0.1213763878,
0.2235533148,
1.097702384,
0.8814365864,
-0.3400855958,
0.8616329432,
0.0786420107,
-0.261197865,
-0.1269038767,
-0.8392048478,
-0.0783879533,
0.0819344223,
0.3409437537,
-0.6535164714,
-0.4690513909,
0.8021294475,
-0.3768609166,
-0.2823016644,
-0.2208466232,
-0.4117495716,
-0.0367955305,
-0.1823066473,
0.0882973522,
0.5393156409,
-0.4584793746,
0.2723754644,
0.5662223697,
-0.0738632679,
-0.6797091961,
-0.663954854,
0.1884320825,
-0.1487968564,
-1.0701296329,
-0.0880828351,
0.1255764812,
-0.5771353841,
-0.1538810283,
0.5734072328,
-0.35683918,
-0.0880241692,
0.3503190279,
0.015120876,
-0.2846876681,
-0.0025869075,
-0.4215222001,
-0.280957073,
-0.2408695966,
-0.3479341567,
0.7208528519,
-0.3691541851,
-0.7819700241,
-0.5801300406,
0.3839629889,
0.6359208822,
-0.5938459635,
1.2012287378,
0.5199686289,
-0.2409485877,
-0.3138456643,
-0.2022483796,
-0.4258021116,
-0.4481622577,
0.2672311664,
-0.0400664434,
-1.175455451,
0.9520439506,
0.1283970624,
0.4290384948,
0.2990060747,
0.7768950462,
0.4041091204,
0.7694310546,
1.0335539579,
-0.3347642422,
0.5451062322,
-0.1588803828,
0.5368555188,
-0.3528490961,
-0.1291121244,
-0.6432441473,
-0.0144745521,
-0.8896448612,
-0.5758595467,
0.2253449112,
-0.13199462,
-0.1667449474,
0.3859836459,
-0.5340347886,
0.691590488,
0.7854210734,
-0.1112657189,
0.6414792538,
-0.0988490358,
0.3326649666,
-0.1924647093,
-0.5979204178,
-0.5377500057,
1.0456598997,
0.4901147187,
0.6568270326,
0.2770639956,
0.7475062609,
0.1609579623,
0.48376894,
-0.7391545177,
0.505883038,
-0.1296413541,
-0.7549651861,
-0.5048053265,
-0.4266264439,
-1.0267480612,
0.3887121081,
-0.268922925,
-0.8168045282,
-0.2093276829,
-0.1457445621,
-0.1333462298,
0.6185566187,
-0.6099278927,
1.017338872,
0.1444158852,
-0.1028771847,
-0.3428654075,
-0.2670192719,
0.7013889551,
0.1163266227,
0.0885140374,
-0.3628441095,
-0.1351116002,
0.3527566493,
-0.385325402,
0.7605059147,
0.217541784,
0.20361875,
0.3693307936,
0.0131614842,
0.4856801927,
0.1566103995,
-0.1754585356,
0.4172024429,
-0.0753168836,
-0.5763345361,
-0.6014083028,
0.5885363221,
-1.1151214838,
-0.5603020191,
-0.4209745526,
-0.4982077777,
0.2180730402,
0.1224196479,
0.2249735445,
-0.0067907209,
-0.3478194475,
0.4442279637,
0.2126635164,
-0.1455535889,
0.5221722722,
0.6178941131,
-0.6820542216,
-0.13798967,
0.9618635178,
0.131081298,
0.1661446244,
0.0900205523,
0.1391631961,
-0.1464911103,
-0.5826255083,
-0.3440095186,
0.3298869729,
-0.4720131159,
0.4602537751,
-0.3892140388,
-0.5831228495,
-0.5512998104,
0.0599177815,
-0.8280679584,
-0.7216943502,
0.1108957529,
0.1448698789,
0.255097717,
0.8879061937,
-0.0728933513,
0.6216142774,
-0.730622232,
-0.1855180264,
0.1481658816,
0.538975358,
-0.3715807796,
-0.2800870836,
-0.324090451,
0.2397195399,
-0.2965347469,
-0.8559629321,
0.4184936881,
0.1181227192,
0.5825998783,
0.3909495473,
0.347435683,
0.3252179325,
-0.2737682164,
1.2393380404,
-0.0724130571,
-0.7409489751,
0.500567615,
-0.7276290059,
-0.0424201973,
0.298561573,
0.2326394767,
-1.2909858227,
-0.6566630602,
-0.5401852727,
-0.7112411857,
0.6414022446,
0.4962809682,
0.3366847634,
0.1921803355,
0.0374821462,
-0.1288862526,
-0.0493918099,
-1.0872385502,
-0.1544204205,
-0.1509901732,
0.1116923392,
-0.0708044767,
0.0597495101,
-0.1696553379,
-0.1689588875,
0.8521821499,
0.1809879988,
0.1163501069,
0.17446509,
0.3051236868,
0.1195129454,
0.4375666976,
0.658100307,
0.6471347213,
0.0942868963,
-0.2033409327,
0.0204063579,
-0.7119024992,
-0.1528311968,
0.0988531113,
-0.418466717,
-0.4049439132,
0.4906930625,
0.7571110725,
-0.1582955718,
-0.4282765388,
0.6216164231,
-0.3150431216,
-0.0498278923,
-0.5494052172,
0.3970609009,
0.0901710168,
0.5280088186,
0.126632601,
-0.2260516137,
0.0000903001,
-0.3848927021,
0.1966082454,
0.4923586845,
-0.4376960993,
-0.2072931081,
0.7689294815,
0.4854358435,
-0.5095720291,
1.0813733339,
-0.040709544,
-0.3364220262,
0.4764249921,
0.3857936561,
1.0901637077,
-0.2908427715,
0.2521505058,
0.3311190009,
0.6803128719,
-0.3493364453,
0.06146634,
-0.0053256238,
-0.924587369,
-0.5332283378,
-0.1411012262,
-1.0261282921,
-0.0345649943,
-0.1962067336,
0.5075417757,
-0.5471382737,
-0.1503625214,
-0.487041533,
0.3477399945,
-0.0291520786,
-0.237187326,
0.4469400942,
1.154291749,
-0.8768953681,
1.3111095428,
0.4075788856,
-0.4591052234,
-0.9229181409,
-0.082752876,
0.1459073126,
-0.5991567969,
0.2111728936,
0.0523056686,
-0.0947541669,
-0.0943737775,
-0.6231222153,
-0.7674673796,
1.3387120962,
0.4924267828,
-0.3821392059,
0.1732391864,
0.6392819285,
0.390624702,
-0.5091172457,
0.4923477173,
0.3710683286,
0.6266233325,
0.1446020305,
-1.3171664476,
-0.610619843,
-0.357845068,
-0.1977797151,
0.0164400656,
-1.09965837,
1.053707242,
-0.1870087534,
-0.4891700745,
-0.1617527306,
0.8208349347,
0.1463367492,
0.4119422734,
0.1422385722,
0.2310284674,
0.7019143105,
-0.3468120396,
1.2356206179,
-0.5376970768,
0.5765088201,
0.8275821805,
-0.2257120609,
1.0982784033,
0.1736867279,
-0.1523809135,
0.0821624994,
0.817201674,
0.0650882572,
0.1712752879,
-0.1201862097,
-0.6494237185,
-0.2541786134,
-0.134184882,
-0.4709307253,
0.6595221162,
0.0277756304,
-0.1898493618,
-0.261057198,
-0.1591000855,
0.3283724487,
-0.0514087081,
-0.2013729513,
0.4836398661,
0.0295044761,
-0.527795434,
0.0751320422,
0.2927868366,
0.618925631,
-0.8702723384,
0.067786701,
-0.3881659508,
0.3102872372,
-0.201771304,
-0.8285250068,
0.6353492737,
-0.0685402229,
0.1734811962,
-0.0682587326,
0.5296897888,
-0.503922224,
-0.6096335649,
0.3704298437,
0.4662736952,
0.3613547087,
-0.2337922007,
-0.7429955006,
0.245427072,
0.0583059154,
-0.5337349772,
0.2253036201,
0.1234310865,
-0.2147677988,
1.1956043243,
0.8274698257,
0.3431646824,
0.1169418991,
0.0268123653,
0.6716686487,
-0.3698353171,
-0.5414356589,
-1.0220775604,
0.5466659069,
-0.1722015291,
-0.1918304861,
1.0933436155,
0.7340528369,
0.8432228565,
0.0844398141,
0.8465752602,
-0.1936100572,
0.2500855923,
-0.0935204253,
1.2681875229,
-0.4188891947,
0.3165930808,
-0.0012573194,
-1.2002459764,
-0.7278870344,
0.5826708078,
-0.5002080798,
-0.2283416241,
0.32837376,
1.0666929483,
-0.2546501756,
0.3090934157,
0.5367557406,
-0.0321687646,
0.6942428946,
0.6864447594,
0.7078534961,
-0.3140659928,
0.5773160458,
-0.55126369,
-0.2978365421,
-0.0802685693,
-0.8412947059,
-0.8385105133,
-0.8172550797,
-0.1542696208,
-0.31161654,
-0.0336586274,
0.9910677075,
1.0311332941,
-0.7270291448,
-0.5921322703,
0.1660031974,
0.2886807919,
0.0247664955,
-0.1726851016,
0.0497980826,
-0.0919019207,
-1.0636310577,
0.1925246567,
0.4266322255,
0.0116882781,
-0.6499418616,
-0.2466370612,
0.3906545937,
0.2631794214,
0.3272297084,
0.5682594776,
-0.6246038675,
-0.2745051384,
0.0736143291,
-0.3817310333,
0.1296686083,
1.0533672571,
-0.2818403244,
0.363147229,
0.6810140014,
0.2958213389,
0.431535393,
-0.0227055084,
0.6959797144,
-0.3721480668,
0.7752174139,
0.1592572182,
0.2244849056,
0.4709142745,
-0.2011470795,
0.6369347572,
0.1789043844,
-0.884820044,
-0.5817996264,
0.4249055386,
-0.9661336541,
0.1351319402,
1.2697544098,
-0.112006478,
-0.3362337947,
0.0154840332,
-0.3544313908,
0.1657677591,
-0.343327105,
0.770770669,
0.8416092396,
-0.1617776304,
-0.7008045316,
-0.7457970381,
0.464168936,
-0.3316787779,
-0.7746515274,
0.4397860467,
0.2463886887,
0.257383287,
-0.0134436032,
1.1078093052,
-0.2735940218,
0.1804402173,
0.3228558004,
0.3232835233,
-0.2140557617,
-0.3269314468,
-0.1419954598,
0.1031988114,
0.2621858716,
-0.1896892786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10447v1 | Domain-specific Continued Pretraining of Language Models for Capturing Long Context in Mental Health | 2023-04-20T16:43:56 | 2023-04-20T16:43:56 | Shaoxiong Ji, Tianlin Zhang, Kailai Yang, Sophia Ananiadou, Erik Cambria, Jörg Tiedemann | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have been used in various natural language
processing applications. In the mental health domain, domain-specific language
models are pretrained and released, which facilitates the early detection of
mental health conditions. Social posts, e.g., on Reddit, are usually long
documents. However, there are no domain-specific pretrained models for
long-sequence modeling in the mental health domain. This paper conducts
domain-specific continued pretraining to capture the long context for mental
health. Specifically, we train and release MentalXLNet and MentalLongformer
based on XLNet and Longformer. We evaluate the mental health classification
performance and the long-range ability of these two domain-specific pretrained
models. Our models are released in HuggingFace. | [
-0.452381134,
-0.7730277181,
0.6580772996,
0.2501271665,
-0.0424802974,
-0.2478355616,
-0.4935268462,
-0.8607690334,
0.2688820362,
0.6695226431,
-0.8428014517,
-0.3565268517,
-0.7422219515,
0.1316685528,
-0.3410090804,
1.3208361864,
-0.3658926487,
-0.1709513217,
-0.3651207983,
-0.0580785498,
-0.3838934302,
-1.0716123581,
-0.8518645763,
-0.4903040826,
0.6784726381,
-0.2132091075,
0.4925542772,
0.1938852817,
0.3971094191,
0.2335502505,
0.0647955462,
-0.2093289047,
-0.6428081393,
0.1178772524,
-0.3532152474,
-0.2124797553,
-0.8058173656,
0.1298605949,
0.573880434,
0.8701604009,
-0.2218647152,
0.1820927709,
0.0645051822,
0.4534300864,
-0.4095214307,
0.0569270849,
-0.0157451145,
0.230542466,
-0.3698765039,
0.0207554679,
-0.2792390883,
-0.2172003984,
0.1865213364,
-0.6009380221,
-0.053119123,
-0.0091791805,
0.7202925086,
-0.0230240319,
-0.4284002781,
0.0564465001,
-0.6828600764,
0.6276929975,
-0.6889688969,
0.4642819166,
0.6756752729,
0.3270058334,
-0.0913528353,
-0.9565218687,
-0.5033092499,
-0.1771500558,
-0.088399671,
-0.0118098743,
-0.2604021728,
0.3308244348,
0.3918481171,
0.020115694,
-0.6799334288,
0.1240506768,
-0.3333275616,
0.0476869717,
0.869359374,
0.002792943,
0.2934731245,
0.0147498623,
-0.2901919186,
0.1322187632,
-0.4585619867,
0.0000690958,
-0.1414433867,
0.1206590235,
-0.2317532748,
0.5043950677,
-0.0813291818,
0.5718733668,
0.0937671661,
-0.2433337569,
0.3957498968,
0.0616451427,
-0.3434664309,
-0.1535808891,
0.6044431329,
0.3689542711,
0.4846243262,
-0.1765793562,
-0.4555772841,
0.0917088613,
0.541326642,
-0.730196774,
-0.0154541861,
0.2513362467,
-0.5256467462,
0.1941343099,
-0.2514148355,
-0.4711309373,
-0.0153324846,
-0.5624248385,
0.2372476757,
-0.5261945128,
-0.4822749496,
0.3081035018,
0.0958157554,
-0.0448080115,
0.088190496,
-0.6335897446,
0.6219710708,
0.8150293827,
0.7130152583,
-0.4946579635,
-0.3546539545,
-0.3963977098,
0.005266401,
-0.0095696114,
0.5574747324,
-0.5304710865,
-0.1575655341,
0.2226859778,
0.4199042618,
-0.2029049546,
-0.4920163453,
0.4475760162,
-0.7056190968,
0.2039811462,
-0.177758038,
-0.7919436097,
0.0617668591,
0.2746398449,
-0.4668394923,
0.8529399037,
0.5461072326,
-0.8659484386,
0.2298529297,
-0.684822917,
-0.4914658368,
0.1302164197,
-0.0669965893,
-0.46988675,
-0.013924391,
-0.0875828713,
0.7014694214,
0.0018764936,
0.380212158,
-0.5262313485,
-0.3095555902,
0.0650099888,
-0.0389156453,
0.7655140162,
0.0661795363,
-0.3678975999,
0.2306570858,
-0.5881163478,
0.141843617,
0.2124902755,
0.0099910703,
-0.6141390204,
-0.1061731428,
0.2416557819,
0.5574731231,
0.1670961678,
-0.5280938148,
0.020655727,
-0.1392325014,
0.209187001,
0.4490032792,
0.0009632365,
0.0674320608,
-0.4629437625,
0.8037518859,
0.0520098433,
0.1714763492,
0.0618693754,
-0.3731129766,
-0.2401308566,
-0.4727432728,
0.0072934474,
0.63388592,
-0.5591814518,
0.751791954,
-0.4252319336,
-0.2802791297,
-0.1078350395,
-0.0998928845,
0.5798792243,
0.2961939275,
0.5114426017,
-0.3860835731,
-0.4847793281,
-0.5876719356,
0.023038296,
0.2668659985,
0.0578196459,
0.2535171509,
0.6984049082,
-0.9129292965,
0.8487552404,
-0.6030997038,
-0.1538565755,
-0.3170975447,
0.195464164,
-0.0461513549,
0.4527058005,
0.7779700756,
-0.6549021006,
-0.4143843353,
-0.2281926125,
-0.9228591323,
0.0202719141,
0.0523595586,
-0.3491955996,
0.0818643123,
0.4308407307,
-0.8738411665,
0.4429252148,
0.6418195367,
-0.2364733219,
0.9143199921,
-0.0398491584,
-0.1191591844,
-0.9917174578,
0.2261892408,
0.0201817546,
-0.8098415136,
-0.6662304401,
0.0777504295,
-0.1111636236,
-0.4284799099,
-0.2285221368,
0.5866138339,
-0.3998450935,
0.1870571971,
-0.3455650806,
0.2037741244,
-0.0353394039,
0.2872263193,
0.3940497339,
0.451964736,
0.6325572133,
-0.4776329696,
0.371496737,
0.0322873555,
-0.2473751009,
0.6183782816,
-0.6833651662,
0.2605908215,
-0.2296637446,
0.460024029,
-0.4694231153,
-0.3183079064,
0.0307740122,
-0.2350979745,
0.5420191288,
0.2347313762,
-0.0746689513,
-0.6887626052,
-0.0639321804,
0.5825344324,
0.4012055993,
-0.3261616826,
0.045339454,
0.5136542916,
-0.2866109014,
-0.4404974878,
-0.4648423791,
-0.1762884706,
-0.2280811965,
-0.5998773575,
0.5760302544,
-0.148982957,
-0.124834083,
0.0476246886,
0.0006076258,
-0.1925659627,
-0.0397611521,
0.4426828027,
-0.001011981,
-0.3126987517,
0.169113785,
0.0835838243,
-0.0181254745,
0.3950023055,
-0.234420076,
0.491445899,
0.0544769429,
-0.2746850848,
-0.4363953769,
1.130248189,
0.3294644654,
-0.2851888239,
1.1165138483,
0.4001968801,
-0.7947624922,
-0.1774239987,
-0.531068325,
-0.2468022108,
-0.4294469953,
0.4657461643,
-0.3181750178,
-1.3014940023,
0.3165554404,
-0.2277853936,
-0.175969243,
0.1909604073,
0.2646225393,
-0.1885181665,
0.9813854694,
1.2110776901,
-0.154174611,
0.4252213836,
0.0017977618,
0.2924552858,
-0.6469724774,
0.0550982542,
-0.167118907,
0.1477300823,
-0.4181702137,
-0.032571923,
0.0950408131,
0.2013130635,
-0.3502753377,
0.3433034122,
-0.3509117067,
0.1218783557,
0.1616213769,
0.315184474,
-0.0874226168,
-0.1204605028,
-0.0668248236,
-0.2079451531,
-0.3633366227,
-0.2769257724,
0.6733496785,
0.4693615437,
0.6450515985,
-0.1893056631,
0.7865512967,
0.2976472676,
0.7138992548,
-0.680109024,
0.3200476766,
-0.0417612754,
-0.5436695218,
-0.2805880606,
-0.4921241403,
-1.0644520521,
-0.4872068763,
0.0231018942,
-0.9273297787,
0.0841198489,
0.1259252429,
-0.4825956225,
0.0900833458,
-0.3083275855,
0.9596680999,
-0.2516005337,
0.064518407,
-0.2832141519,
-0.8885640502,
0.3969607353,
-0.5284879208,
0.0768020377,
-0.2089224458,
0.5010508895,
0.9010561705,
-0.3409294486,
0.7770264149,
-0.1823853105,
-0.0965463966,
0.0332146399,
-0.3064700663,
0.1828620732,
-0.0393222161,
0.0694817156,
0.228834942,
0.3237491548,
-0.3590738475,
-0.6449478865,
0.4942152798,
-0.9652228355,
-0.6513029933,
-0.5113669634,
-0.0268639475,
-0.4111030102,
0.523794651,
0.3346301019,
0.3972268701,
-0.3258374035,
-0.0271601081,
0.6124854088,
-0.0962233171,
0.1118361205,
0.3297536671,
-0.4932314456,
-0.2847481966,
0.4254608154,
0.0441236906,
0.163374126,
0.2192093879,
-0.0891408175,
-0.1497203559,
-0.1884886324,
0.3292363286,
0.6783165932,
-0.4706264734,
-0.2252032608,
-0.5738021135,
-0.7838782668,
-0.6681649685,
-0.3221895993,
-0.430893898,
0.0547913276,
-0.1412689537,
-0.118275553,
0.2799551189,
0.7935587764,
-0.1727466434,
0.4067262709,
-0.8933978081,
0.3937476575,
0.3186665773,
0.6073800325,
-0.1131168306,
-0.3371789753,
-0.5779329538,
0.1644946039,
-0.0107018556,
-0.8808973432,
0.3859403729,
0.310320735,
0.5360398293,
0.4224122167,
0.195979327,
0.676915586,
-0.6750648022,
0.4911037087,
0.3785705566,
-0.7436065078,
0.7514649034,
-0.1727932543,
0.3330726922,
0.4791272581,
1.0990204811,
-0.9808639288,
-0.1039884537,
-0.2466098517,
-0.6513284445,
0.5095285177,
0.0248357132,
0.2800774574,
-0.5471742153,
0.8731762171,
0.0689428076,
0.0097532645,
-0.6628771424,
-0.2768728733,
-0.3017758429,
-0.0492635295,
-0.2468474507,
-0.5918240547,
-0.4391751587,
-0.3731561005,
0.5309004784,
-0.0388077199,
0.5842837095,
0.2712249458,
-0.2261579037,
-0.0201780405,
-0.0113820042,
0.3495884836,
0.7260217667,
-0.3419881761,
-0.0730377883,
-0.1755500883,
-0.6767753959,
0.2251832336,
0.3599043489,
0.287771225,
-0.0636605024,
0.4929795861,
0.818128407,
0.1480670422,
-0.6434335709,
0.7214567065,
-0.201652661,
-0.052889064,
-0.7525042295,
-0.0166140608,
0.0192991663,
0.2652801871,
-0.0220346991,
-0.1505056918,
-0.070574902,
-0.4550036192,
0.5974266529,
0.2623969018,
-0.3481996059,
-0.6609706879,
0.6055989265,
0.0567762777,
-0.2292332649,
0.9355580807,
-0.1205803081,
-0.4542735219,
0.2405094802,
0.9859620929,
0.8654702902,
-0.3238191009,
0.0351733156,
0.3171694875,
-0.09038762,
-0.1990825832,
0.3530565202,
-0.1984816343,
-0.800137639,
-0.6216904521,
-0.6208037734,
-0.1790679544,
0.3203929961,
-1.2464894056,
0.116194874,
-0.3996571004,
-0.9121742845,
-0.1519947797,
0.1421904415,
-0.7277437449,
0.6050070524,
0.5714142323,
0.9677873254,
-0.8227750063,
1.0620200634,
0.7288534641,
0.0259450451,
-0.5309508443,
0.047388386,
0.0721937642,
-0.4086581767,
0.6472948194,
0.5056685209,
-0.2772479057,
-0.1621212512,
-0.5994656086,
-0.9873424172,
0.8404297829,
0.3730581999,
-0.567101717,
-0.2896104753,
0.0449586771,
0.5680105686,
-0.4622593224,
-0.0700448826,
0.5299473405,
0.2255482227,
-0.3716157973,
-1.1046545506,
0.1011693701,
-0.5134443045,
0.196222648,
0.0393545851,
-0.4330610633,
0.5857316852,
-0.0952179953,
-0.3548329175,
0.0141489711,
0.7936978936,
0.3783344328,
0.147436142,
0.4263782203,
0.7015134692,
0.8646495938,
0.2122213542,
1.0725691319,
-0.3568477929,
0.532369554,
1.2480285168,
-0.5177214742,
1.0360354185,
-0.1017103493,
-0.1286131442,
0.5701605082,
0.6807655692,
0.5007184744,
0.5354704261,
0.128563121,
-0.5689525604,
-0.275429517,
0.031443134,
-0.693277657,
0.4127858281,
0.5804541707,
-0.3665755987,
0.0058400016,
0.4602311254,
0.6686593294,
-0.2328331172,
-0.0836266279,
0.4258608818,
0.5453793406,
-0.710840106,
0.6749992371,
-0.000573538,
0.6986074448,
-0.7528504133,
0.2621237934,
-0.231395632,
0.2567547858,
-0.0338064991,
-0.5990371108,
0.7215130329,
-0.0778841078,
-0.4119502008,
-0.3362052739,
0.8646010756,
-0.3781737387,
-0.2772162855,
0.8420679569,
0.4353434443,
0.1397007704,
-0.3364666998,
-0.6803249121,
-0.1117962003,
-0.4614802897,
-0.5696768761,
0.5875124335,
0.5257928967,
-0.2870402038,
0.6250866652,
0.4767079651,
0.0829578117,
-0.0489931628,
0.1567083895,
0.9674919248,
-0.8429807425,
-0.3912920058,
-0.6576015949,
0.1605471969,
-0.1287342012,
-0.3949843943,
0.5701271296,
0.1682702154,
0.7449929118,
0.0347598009,
0.6013227105,
0.0931142345,
0.4912405908,
-0.312408179,
0.9764772058,
-0.6515622139,
-0.4493256509,
-0.1280618012,
-0.7776198387,
-0.4531911314,
0.6072984338,
-0.3267495036,
0.270403713,
0.7653800845,
0.3934086263,
-0.0858535022,
-0.2601135969,
0.3169798255,
0.1840449125,
0.2821321487,
0.6767938733,
0.4518279135,
0.1042144001,
-0.3217689991,
-0.4632994831,
-0.4381705821,
0.0703555644,
-0.8288120031,
-1.0618621111,
-0.6623841524,
-0.4243791699,
-0.2705461383,
0.3402449787,
0.9948251843,
1.1387784481,
-0.6950085163,
0.0012284236,
0.3950201273,
-0.2861610651,
-0.2541913688,
-0.2668876946,
0.332688421,
-0.1511096954,
-0.1514008343,
0.1722409725,
0.2422850728,
-0.0019343022,
-0.1518784165,
0.1697966754,
-0.2340154797,
0.118192032,
0.9807928801,
0.5438275933,
-0.346794188,
-0.4066280723,
-0.0466345251,
-0.2908948064,
0.1283905208,
0.6686461568,
-0.7862613797,
0.17323789,
0.1589248776,
0.4782802165,
0.5552490354,
0.0913442448,
0.6989309192,
-0.8124729395,
0.1387236118,
0.2523928285,
0.5535290241,
0.2541754246,
-0.5681078434,
0.2070761621,
0.2203060985,
-0.7227984667,
-0.5886342525,
0.1867652386,
-0.9154384732,
-0.060428232,
1.0768818855,
-0.7152190804,
-0.392629981,
-0.194872573,
0.0780808553,
0.4501279294,
0.0157031529,
0.6137048006,
0.4791948199,
-0.2981921732,
-0.2890348136,
-0.5390597582,
0.5705516934,
0.2312154025,
-1.0123945475,
-0.1445713639,
0.2825846076,
0.5031168461,
0.0533538349,
0.9697063565,
-0.0633770451,
0.3022123277,
-0.1649833173,
0.1194476858,
0.3404123485,
-0.4003575444,
-0.1671653241,
-0.0334852375,
-0.2194196284,
0.2557213306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10436v1 | Safety Assessment of Chinese Large Language Models | 2023-04-20T16:27:35 | 2023-04-20T16:27:35 | Hao Sun, Zhexin Zhang, Jiawen Deng, Jiale Cheng, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid popularity of large language models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4,
a growing amount of attention is paid to their safety concerns. These models
may generate insulting and discriminatory content, reflect incorrect social
values, and may be used for malicious purposes such as fraud and dissemination
of misleading information. Evaluating and enhancing their safety is
particularly essential for the wide application of large language models
(LLMs). To further promote the safe deployment of LLMs, we develop a Chinese
LLM safety assessment benchmark. Our benchmark explores the comprehensive
safety performance of LLMs from two perspectives: 8 kinds of typical safety
scenarios and 6 types of more challenging instruction attacks. Our benchmark is
based on a straightforward process in which it provides the test prompts and
evaluates the safety of the generated responses from the evaluated model. In
evaluation, we utilize the LLM's strong evaluation ability and develop it as a
safety evaluator by prompting. On top of this benchmark, we conduct safety
assessments and analyze 15 LLMs including the OpenAI GPT series and other
well-known Chinese LLMs, where we observe some interesting findings. For
example, we find that instruction attacks are more likely to expose safety
issues of all LLMs. Moreover, to promote the development and deployment of
safe, responsible, and ethical AI, we publicly release SafetyPrompts including
100k augmented prompts and responses by LLMs. | [
-0.0902202576,
-0.7557740808,
0.34540236,
0.3098545671,
-0.1899582446,
-0.240290612,
-0.3110331595,
-0.5613434315,
-0.481965512,
0.4461748302,
-0.0954166576,
-0.4930391014,
-0.5112336874,
-0.1241424382,
-0.4281023443,
1.0406649113,
-0.0113203544,
0.1648208201,
0.2047441602,
0.1133810282,
-0.4022087753,
-0.7194208503,
-1.0177646875,
0.0011728543,
0.6180250049,
-0.105294317,
0.5483720303,
0.5061273575,
0.8535861969,
0.3817690909,
-0.1968426853,
-0.1101892591,
-0.4252559543,
-0.1898474246,
0.0085687991,
-0.1409920752,
-0.7957864404,
0.0563794784,
0.7366085052,
0.4230356514,
-0.2315161377,
0.1250837892,
0.2663018703,
0.3458322287,
-0.5368164182,
0.2328873128,
-0.5560808182,
0.0701161176,
-0.2517928183,
-0.1200898439,
-0.5355343223,
-0.6659286618,
0.1078970879,
-0.1136765331,
-0.2251471728,
-0.0127573116,
0.5598201752,
-0.0601486973,
-0.5279428959,
-0.1942182481,
-0.4099224806,
0.686773181,
-0.9304215908,
0.1117481962,
0.083505258,
0.5019765496,
-0.3955258727,
-0.7029193044,
-0.4702368677,
-0.6849784851,
0.1897555888,
0.1080632731,
0.246652931,
0.3002651334,
0.3223922849,
0.3322154582,
-0.7259030938,
0.4772923589,
-0.2190255821,
-0.2884093225,
0.9643317461,
0.4191988409,
0.6360678673,
-0.1359356791,
-0.6680984497,
-0.3223530352,
-1.0410583019,
-0.0693451166,
0.3866917491,
0.2816056907,
-0.2332778871,
0.2683866918,
-0.0469785891,
0.3669337332,
-0.52365762,
-0.2401953787,
0.3784300089,
-0.4915445745,
-0.3287194967,
0.1384473294,
1.2137593031,
0.7027587891,
0.3827476799,
0.0179126766,
-0.3491262496,
-0.0374365896,
0.1125310957,
-0.9529128075,
-0.0628489181,
0.1457035989,
-0.4250275493,
-0.3574614525,
0.0974497125,
-0.7399300933,
-0.6110193133,
0.1047251001,
0.3239589334,
-0.3054419458,
-0.4300715923,
0.0744446516,
0.2489059567,
0.6994956732,
0.33288306,
-0.8713368773,
0.124668248,
0.9447522759,
0.6342280507,
-0.3336751163,
-0.4733664095,
-0.4828511775,
0.2750611305,
-0.5929887295,
0.5800945759,
-0.1868657619,
-0.4357207417,
0.3876415491,
0.2153157741,
-0.0788728073,
-0.3654335439,
0.6415281296,
-0.4470324218,
-0.0607641898,
-0.3106968999,
-0.3682543635,
-0.2658242881,
0.5744711161,
-0.5832133889,
0.7990418673,
-0.2287338674,
-0.7480590343,
0.1231301054,
-0.7052719593,
-0.4128467143,
0.1277080327,
-0.2707523406,
-0.3082781732,
-0.352606535,
-0.0188181121,
0.5683597326,
-0.4828061163,
0.3637886643,
-0.3766005635,
-0.4638659358,
0.2987737954,
-1.032968998,
0.9502614737,
0.1529975086,
-0.3338593543,
0.3599606752,
-0.3985610008,
0.1202830523,
0.2682799399,
-0.5273606181,
-0.1601036489,
-0.0390242338,
0.0485679731,
0.1080037504,
0.4566217363,
-0.3945145607,
-0.0479866117,
-0.3550704718,
0.3413271904,
0.9424982667,
0.217476353,
-0.0576750189,
-0.2361659557,
0.3355709314,
-0.0897886977,
0.484451592,
-0.2430716306,
-0.4704883695,
-0.4365583956,
0.105857566,
0.1672329456,
0.715875268,
-0.5138801336,
0.4589915872,
-0.1900921166,
-0.7111457586,
-0.134804368,
0.1238739789,
0.6740948558,
0.216972813,
0.0001651427,
-0.2188397944,
-0.0668503791,
-0.64827317,
-0.1347609311,
-0.3766689897,
-0.1831142902,
0.0468664914,
0.3597811162,
-0.1669688076,
0.2492339164,
-0.2136609554,
0.0826167688,
-0.2009629011,
0.0399211422,
0.0823873803,
0.6153463125,
0.7234116793,
-0.6840283275,
-0.5576120615,
0.1618229449,
-0.8498749733,
0.0873402432,
0.0019600291,
-0.10317377,
0.277307421,
0.3795513809,
-0.6166566014,
0.2448404729,
0.590441227,
-0.0180565473,
0.6724362969,
-0.1717475653,
0.2870861888,
-0.9873193502,
0.0216523465,
0.0462056324,
0.1276883036,
-0.6369997859,
0.3667148352,
0.1786914319,
-0.0659505278,
-0.8407438397,
0.3362837732,
-0.2766647935,
-0.1482744813,
-0.1036778241,
0.3755817413,
-0.2317268848,
0.3519769609,
-0.094368726,
0.7588046193,
0.4941711426,
-0.5540166497,
0.5659139752,
-0.0433549769,
-0.6487131715,
0.0852063149,
-0.8844810724,
0.3710909188,
0.2668270171,
0.1903292835,
-0.9646062255,
-0.2392343581,
0.3869792819,
-0.2454304844,
0.2873152196,
0.1318564862,
-0.6368239522,
-0.1958966851,
-0.650518775,
0.2405273318,
0.5794641376,
-0.5733741522,
0.1958611906,
0.4688061774,
-0.2857775688,
-0.7854906321,
-0.4371676147,
0.064383924,
-0.4838196635,
-0.7260587811,
-0.0663896948,
-0.2948807776,
-0.2707092762,
-0.2340075225,
0.0244464315,
-0.0077229231,
0.4741255343,
0.1703143567,
0.5347926617,
-0.3278394938,
-0.0917483568,
-0.2448442876,
-0.0901704133,
0.4559647739,
0.2852578759,
0.5605122447,
-0.3099480569,
-0.5854269862,
-0.4206277728,
0.0383035541,
0.4212854505,
-0.2058022916,
0.5158529282,
0.5126036406,
-0.4158804119,
0.0448313802,
-0.4149471521,
-0.0149239693,
-0.5828313828,
0.6935371757,
-0.1222470552,
-0.7272580862,
0.349833101,
-0.0372580849,
0.5186801553,
0.345556289,
0.6852436066,
0.0931614637,
1.1591085196,
0.4071717262,
-0.3905318081,
0.3002927899,
0.1930189878,
0.2086932659,
-0.6598092914,
-0.1762886047,
-0.5138210058,
0.1371975243,
-0.7627526522,
-0.3253901899,
0.4199976027,
-0.1779879928,
-0.6078959703,
0.1160655543,
-0.3603357077,
0.4910797477,
0.2357456386,
-0.1047082171,
0.2534171939,
-0.2414525747,
-0.0383405238,
0.1631761491,
-0.3653943241,
-0.7414342761,
0.9644736052,
0.6735283732,
0.9058107734,
0.2277744859,
0.501668036,
0.1131428406,
0.6249727011,
-0.6854299903,
0.850258708,
-0.2111514807,
-0.6456179023,
-0.4320430756,
-0.5316604972,
-0.7989053726,
0.2483144403,
-0.0561384782,
-0.835531652,
-0.4556744993,
-0.0592039861,
-0.3566483557,
0.2397789359,
-0.7480695844,
1.0109570026,
-0.6822023392,
-0.1615108103,
-0.1849790663,
-0.4791457653,
0.8081361055,
-0.2855688035,
0.1040884629,
-0.1899251491,
-0.0251684859,
0.7880942822,
-0.1347873956,
0.9907461405,
-0.1012291834,
-0.4026941359,
0.343325913,
-0.0052557159,
0.4458346367,
-0.0919364765,
-0.1480776072,
0.3841076493,
0.0148529559,
-0.1084362492,
-0.4804550409,
0.879847765,
-0.9002180099,
-1.0125015974,
-0.4879705012,
-0.3954364657,
-0.1097959951,
0.2755819261,
-0.0884641483,
0.2409084737,
-0.3287999928,
0.2317147106,
0.5579898953,
-0.7229204774,
0.6515513062,
0.5412191153,
-0.1795615107,
-0.237441197,
0.8146546483,
0.1197409257,
0.410454601,
0.131558001,
0.2373997718,
-0.2819662988,
-0.8894948363,
-0.3050449491,
0.1141024157,
-0.8459051847,
-0.010276746,
-0.1954426616,
-0.7469858527,
-0.4204642177,
0.1350763291,
-0.3511449993,
0.1533962935,
0.2695376277,
-0.2402081937,
0.1596002132,
0.8311712742,
0.142629087,
0.3185415566,
-1.0075455904,
-0.0025470755,
0.3261919022,
0.4015253484,
0.1176941693,
-0.4287851751,
-0.2402195483,
-0.1428371966,
-0.4180936813,
-0.6384474635,
0.1734782904,
-0.276863575,
0.814702332,
0.6128652692,
0.2845122516,
0.3695971072,
-0.6972857118,
1.0849021673,
0.2649671137,
-0.7437186241,
0.2939618528,
-0.4583236575,
-0.1154241785,
0.1409055293,
0.3646987677,
-0.534660995,
-0.1692538708,
-0.3129677773,
-0.8567568064,
0.5180224776,
-0.0571475923,
0.3812513947,
-0.1935752183,
0.1875229627,
-0.1879378408,
-0.084046185,
-0.939678371,
-0.1269332319,
-0.0575212799,
-0.0240703765,
-0.018922966,
-0.5313206911,
-0.2748280764,
0.1910849363,
0.6207599044,
-0.052959159,
0.143779397,
-0.2617009282,
0.1590539515,
0.0363699608,
0.3163984418,
0.4832270443,
0.4355560541,
-0.1474909484,
0.0226318613,
0.491268158,
-0.5617840886,
0.0542887338,
-0.0288370531,
0.0005505431,
-0.3293034434,
0.4390643835,
0.5839285851,
0.1922989339,
-0.7659168243,
0.6443305016,
-0.1027508825,
-0.0159181859,
-0.5488660932,
0.3943458498,
0.2755148113,
0.0822229385,
0.1366909891,
-0.403922677,
0.0520831943,
-0.489497155,
0.0684794337,
0.4400719404,
-0.2274279743,
-0.2136554271,
0.5078911781,
0.4190799594,
-0.2428584248,
0.5115480423,
0.074404873,
-0.5382355452,
0.8262904286,
0.4287398458,
1.019811511,
-0.5565446615,
-0.0050227055,
0.4012559354,
0.7369911671,
-0.1424979717,
0.0842655823,
0.3218588829,
-0.7345039845,
-0.385846138,
-0.3214991689,
-0.6326231956,
0.4929022789,
-0.4899341464,
0.3102775216,
-0.742200017,
-0.0184464511,
-0.3393869102,
0.1525368243,
-0.2142339051,
0.2014276832,
0.4651301503,
0.9483400583,
-0.7399209142,
0.9612379074,
0.4084086418,
-0.3349829018,
-1.0346148014,
0.2983107269,
0.018475445,
-0.8476377726,
0.6441750526,
0.4811819494,
-0.0046039373,
-0.4346331954,
-0.4898252189,
-0.713833034,
1.1714046001,
0.4231844842,
-0.7207487822,
0.072794497,
0.3391447961,
0.5327032208,
-0.1580078453,
0.3492054343,
0.5819482207,
0.5142463446,
-0.0387456678,
-1.1646502018,
0.3076675534,
-0.2463283986,
0.1496713609,
-0.0251462068,
-0.9444357157,
0.9486752152,
-0.0966650322,
-0.3451632559,
0.1929551959,
0.4721033275,
0.5200372934,
0.388055712,
0.4908717275,
0.0991238505,
0.6346648932,
-0.021741597,
1.2461308241,
-0.3670093417,
0.1183438301,
0.969076097,
-0.4868068695,
1.0271961689,
0.1218207628,
-0.2467709631,
0.0776329935,
0.7896385193,
-0.0184578542,
0.2702725828,
0.3250604868,
-0.2789582014,
-0.0273218323,
-0.0586886927,
-0.5527701378,
0.2956283689,
0.4512208998,
-0.2121145427,
-0.2213411033,
-0.2424083352,
0.3215445578,
-0.2425608188,
-0.3098179102,
0.5932759643,
0.2071433514,
-0.4973194003,
0.5938537717,
0.0441693664,
0.5551491976,
-0.637214601,
-0.0659431219,
-0.2232988477,
0.1627424061,
-0.090861775,
-0.9704595804,
-0.0589022636,
0.1106579229,
0.4214408994,
0.1899548024,
0.6009600163,
-0.2604851723,
-0.1567838192,
0.5187724829,
0.1137765944,
0.3920620978,
0.2048984468,
-0.707231164,
0.2629864216,
-0.0487560816,
-0.542922318,
0.6658086777,
0.3756831288,
-0.3482867479,
0.6866983175,
0.5627497435,
0.0471557602,
0.1227029711,
0.1259203404,
0.8036743402,
-0.6600874662,
-0.2248312533,
-0.9537974,
0.3979593217,
-0.0794560686,
-0.2073554248,
0.8462555408,
0.1956835836,
0.6127634048,
0.0808670297,
1.0414184332,
0.1162993833,
0.1840720475,
-0.6462210417,
1.0922791958,
-0.2701547742,
0.5696558952,
-0.4843654633,
-0.9526361227,
-0.2411204427,
0.2951397896,
-0.5003479719,
0.1789985448,
0.6053336263,
0.8581600189,
0.3138353229,
0.1229710802,
0.5650103688,
0.3616679311,
0.6785050631,
0.8075392842,
1.1401228905,
-0.4407070279,
0.7462484241,
-0.1661729813,
-0.3574377,
-0.0149744553,
-1.1328654289,
-1.1430938244,
-0.1925731152,
-0.3568277657,
-0.2125247419,
0.0459489375,
0.8803622127,
0.3416919708,
-0.8252056837,
-0.3625660539,
0.3512307703,
-0.0062987739,
-0.0476314463,
-0.214067027,
0.6531635523,
-0.2839564383,
-0.8499372602,
0.4533209503,
0.1765815914,
0.0641242564,
-0.4859181345,
-0.2176995426,
0.1507538706,
0.0250839554,
0.6130424142,
0.1454519033,
-0.5981788635,
-0.7031425238,
-0.2283456177,
-0.3786073625,
-0.1894765645,
0.3362270594,
-0.0513760261,
0.1520679295,
0.5053339005,
1.0173817873,
-0.0602162145,
-0.1817934662,
0.6514228582,
-0.3122560084,
0.133110866,
-0.0065750997,
0.460591346,
0.3760878742,
-0.4119523168,
0.5424936414,
-0.052415479,
-0.7675516009,
-0.9432163835,
0.0900383741,
-0.9401379228,
-0.0306057092,
1.3244433403,
-0.7132731676,
-0.2633857727,
0.0831383243,
-0.1975629777,
0.1696159542,
-0.2492596209,
0.8565637469,
0.6108472943,
0.0807495117,
-0.1853933036,
-0.8320555687,
0.3742134869,
0.2305555046,
-0.9773709178,
0.2493159622,
0.3983574808,
0.4104135334,
0.1099701449,
0.3972325921,
-0.393779397,
0.4518427849,
0.0633216798,
0.0640869811,
0.1267680824,
-0.182962954,
-0.2251494676,
0.1646076739,
0.3316138387,
-0.3015044332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10428v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10428v4 | GPT-NER: Named Entity Recognition via Large Language Models | 2023-04-20T16:17:26 | 2023-10-07T14:25:28 | Shuhe Wang, Xiaofei Sun, Xiaoya Li, Rongbin Ouyang, Fei Wu, Tianwei Zhang, Jiwei Li, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the fact that large-scale Language Models (LLM) have achieved SOTA
performances on a variety of NLP tasks, its performance on NER is still
significantly below supervised baselines. This is due to the gap between the
two tasks the NER and LLMs: the former is a sequence labeling task in nature
while the latter is a text-generation model.
In this paper, we propose GPT-NER to resolve this issue. GPT-NER bridges the
gap by transforming the sequence labeling task to a generation task that can be
easily adapted by LLMs e.g., the task of finding location entities in the input
text "Columbus is a city" is transformed to generate the text sequence
"@@Columbus## is a city", where special tokens @@## marks the entity to
extract. To efficiently address the "hallucination" issue of LLMs, where LLMs
have a strong inclination to over-confidently label NULL inputs as entities, we
propose a self-verification strategy by prompting LLMs to ask itself whether
the extracted entities belong to a labeled entity tag.
We conduct experiments on five widely adopted NER datasets, and GPT-NER
achieves comparable performances to fully supervised baselines, which is the
first time as far as we are concerned. More importantly, we find that GPT-NER
exhibits a greater ability in the low-resource and few-shot setups, when the
amount of training data is extremely scarce, GPT-NER performs significantly
better than supervised models. This demonstrates the capabilities of GPT-NER in
real-world NER applications where the number of labeled examples is limited. | [
-0.4588758051,
-0.7188469172,
0.8883629441,
-0.1196518689,
-0.0799566731,
-0.0433945507,
-0.2108369768,
-0.5711398721,
0.2435124815,
0.4872328341,
-0.3364932835,
-0.4815807641,
-0.6509338021,
0.4215157926,
-0.5648114085,
1.0103133917,
-0.0067815781,
-0.1780900806,
-0.0506808013,
0.2983457744,
-0.4408679307,
-0.6233998537,
-0.9689416289,
-0.3418025374,
0.5014650822,
0.1645303369,
0.4224278927,
0.6120619774,
0.546972096,
0.3128085136,
0.0087523423,
0.1641680598,
-0.200235039,
0.1592964381,
-0.3598325849,
0.0790087432,
-0.4382299781,
-0.2642314732,
0.8092942834,
0.3391091824,
-0.0076093595,
0.1242589653,
0.0726983324,
0.327311039,
-0.3420723677,
0.1068749055,
-0.6952142715,
-0.0634784773,
-0.2101638466,
-0.0577563867,
-0.2464721054,
-0.2131826282,
0.2688823342,
-0.3741140664,
0.5048399568,
0.0537759401,
1.0735522509,
0.4002430737,
-0.4565346241,
-0.2823599577,
-0.9192305207,
0.5694725513,
-0.5265481472,
0.5486295819,
0.1824883223,
0.2236320823,
-0.417955637,
-0.5926542878,
-0.7882736325,
-0.2853844166,
-0.1053686813,
-0.1154260933,
0.0199850332,
-0.1550137252,
0.5542005301,
0.2904196382,
-0.7867985964,
0.1043008268,
-0.1350396723,
-0.2334846258,
0.464345932,
-0.0889598429,
0.3875616193,
-0.3181433082,
-0.330524683,
0.099765636,
-0.7028188109,
-0.4178990126,
0.068727091,
0.3671597838,
0.3036812246,
0.6581735611,
-0.1621416509,
0.5520765185,
0.2808137238,
-0.0826714486,
0.2227287441,
-0.0443201289,
-0.3863666058,
0.3532498777,
0.8495880365,
-0.0104646981,
0.133359924,
-0.3281812668,
-0.5087742805,
-0.0223330911,
0.0271810796,
-0.8986964822,
-0.3097941875,
-0.0207205173,
-0.1159228235,
0.0514364466,
-0.1482685506,
-0.6367266774,
-0.3139955699,
-0.3555666208,
0.6073513627,
-0.2719492316,
-0.2269886136,
-0.0186218899,
0.2967755198,
0.3972613513,
0.3741593659,
-1.0000375509,
0.3310393393,
0.7596560121,
0.7841689587,
-0.2222353816,
-0.1448995918,
-0.591100812,
0.1885377616,
-0.1457650661,
0.8382573724,
-0.433511585,
-0.2933400869,
-0.3719543815,
0.1181359962,
-0.0957950056,
-0.5530011058,
0.3290677667,
-0.7115394473,
0.0753172413,
-0.3163837194,
-0.6868145466,
-0.0012045732,
0.3867362142,
-0.6597663164,
1.1993365288,
0.0134269148,
-0.7526500821,
0.5640904903,
-0.4904305935,
-0.4332945347,
0.4267931581,
-0.44636935,
-0.5453149676,
0.0602299348,
0.4220696688,
0.5876916051,
-0.4460828602,
0.5610202551,
0.0466516651,
-0.2729426026,
-0.04046496,
-0.3201473951,
0.3336971104,
0.0463623181,
-0.532204628,
-0.2096047252,
-0.8246461749,
0.0141543914,
0.3286427855,
-0.3596093357,
-0.4342757463,
-0.0391808897,
0.0103207137,
0.2603831291,
0.0855509341,
-0.5227283835,
0.3488976061,
-0.4257905483,
0.4067089558,
0.5486685634,
0.0680667758,
0.5120713115,
0.1599713117,
0.432736069,
-0.2421906292,
-0.2931503356,
-0.0470867679,
-0.3922839463,
-0.7671905756,
-0.2583964765,
0.5849536657,
0.6249312758,
-0.8629351854,
0.6006059051,
-0.4607872665,
-0.2853618264,
-0.2015859038,
-0.1077640131,
0.2997890115,
0.7497059107,
0.5524638295,
-0.2450421304,
-0.6681731939,
-0.7432001829,
0.0414798893,
-0.1702351421,
-0.1460292637,
0.3225777149,
0.7934991717,
-0.3080110252,
0.9354769588,
-0.3301150501,
-0.3474592566,
-0.2086145133,
0.1261592656,
0.2245601863,
0.5568693876,
0.0932492539,
-0.7391674519,
-0.3779405951,
-0.0672513545,
-0.779083252,
-0.0510931499,
-0.1805145293,
0.1454248726,
0.1309892982,
0.629301548,
-0.6951301098,
0.4250287414,
0.4007364511,
-0.1007147878,
0.3534558713,
-0.2229955196,
-0.0413655676,
-1.0737230778,
-0.0035364002,
0.0639993027,
-0.3765581548,
-0.6259703636,
-0.113508217,
-0.0838446468,
-0.1421203017,
-0.2540533543,
0.7292900085,
-0.796805799,
-0.338129878,
-0.297966212,
0.1632177383,
-0.1547245234,
0.1352517903,
0.4090929925,
0.8845334053,
0.5491855741,
-0.7146040201,
0.1934840381,
0.2777279913,
-0.4004970193,
0.5174410343,
-0.6313686371,
0.4522137046,
-0.1860549301,
0.2894710898,
-0.7352647781,
-0.2910414636,
0.3512923717,
-0.3045215607,
0.5063299537,
-0.3984825909,
-0.7186320424,
-0.4253337979,
0.4898368716,
0.6201071143,
0.4081499279,
-0.6774248481,
0.7700425386,
0.4991211295,
-0.1144948453,
-0.485925436,
-0.5704532862,
0.3847408295,
-0.2602190375,
-0.3479395509,
0.2942256033,
0.2140420824,
0.1455657035,
-0.0305829253,
-0.2518312633,
-0.0924878493,
-0.0073748925,
0.2743414044,
0.2812235951,
-0.3213974535,
0.4245418906,
-0.3112594485,
-0.4586660862,
-0.065141879,
-0.6750337481,
0.5268491507,
-0.1827395558,
-0.3399325013,
-0.2746105492,
0.1651304513,
0.0504798926,
-0.3414218724,
0.5233253241,
0.5789325833,
-0.6874904633,
-0.2455999702,
-0.7628027201,
-0.162240088,
-0.4304213226,
0.3539132774,
-0.6210951209,
-1.0537294149,
0.234365046,
-0.1565661281,
-0.3127971292,
0.5269690752,
0.4315316081,
0.1411179602,
0.7967965007,
0.589309752,
-0.1765444279,
0.2135523856,
-0.1145199165,
0.5808212757,
-0.857568562,
-0.1517889053,
-0.4880141318,
-0.1983122528,
-0.6233773828,
-0.4998202324,
0.2023596913,
0.0612464771,
-0.1335238814,
0.6226484776,
-0.877805233,
0.8075345159,
0.4667309821,
-0.1128283665,
0.2597125471,
-0.1123040169,
-0.0900017098,
-0.1187387109,
-0.3442722857,
-0.7420879602,
0.8119758368,
0.2684067786,
0.6178870797,
-0.0210773535,
1.2063161135,
-0.0346439257,
0.3892141283,
-0.7901932001,
0.8435419798,
-0.1321267337,
-0.6773780584,
-0.5496103168,
-0.5126503706,
-1.0735906363,
0.1103234217,
-0.1677042991,
-0.961665988,
0.1437046081,
0.1068900749,
-0.411488533,
0.3810569644,
-0.4176927209,
0.8476584554,
-0.4069097042,
-0.0544349737,
0.3283697665,
-0.4746187925,
0.2095201761,
-0.2617830038,
0.0065765516,
-0.2656099498,
0.1263373196,
0.5728622675,
-0.2345049828,
0.5051922798,
-0.1909407526,
-0.3032106757,
0.2348560542,
0.1701269448,
0.7245147824,
0.1433507949,
0.1372502744,
0.2502653003,
-0.463106811,
0.0203462634,
-0.4713004231,
0.8150158525,
-0.4113050997,
-0.5429215431,
-0.5322656631,
-0.3575211763,
0.0093030827,
0.4682951272,
0.3995274901,
0.3325631022,
-0.1424598694,
-0.1381683201,
0.8829232454,
-0.2355667651,
0.3728588223,
0.3331025541,
-0.3731246293,
-0.3404390216,
0.9358962774,
0.2066788226,
-0.1039985493,
0.6919317245,
-0.1057295576,
-0.4924209714,
-0.6298369765,
-0.4639812112,
0.2551416159,
-0.5673340559,
-0.2630444169,
-0.9294847846,
-0.3195093572,
-0.3767215014,
-0.0691124797,
-0.4258368313,
-0.3079895377,
-0.3603805602,
-0.1016646773,
0.0665586963,
0.7906112075,
-0.0436674133,
0.1546936631,
-0.6087483764,
0.5035783648,
0.517326951,
0.214067176,
-0.1276000738,
-0.4961544573,
0.03527724,
-0.2786212564,
0.0253267661,
-0.904558599,
0.5516850352,
0.0380641595,
0.320748806,
0.0972798765,
-0.1834529936,
0.7722916603,
-0.8242736459,
0.5200118423,
0.0092104226,
-1.0007768869,
0.5949240327,
-0.2123361975,
0.107472077,
0.396594882,
0.2773149014,
-0.4732217193,
-0.2432198822,
-0.657081306,
-1.0529655218,
0.422960341,
0.2588552833,
0.0098665468,
-0.3717897236,
0.5389330983,
-0.125160113,
0.0477628745,
-0.9604149461,
-0.0946466029,
0.0714466125,
-0.0304986089,
-0.1814267635,
-0.1974936575,
0.3455676138,
0.0709463805,
0.7643539906,
-0.0564183705,
0.2610333264,
0.5267390013,
-0.2674731314,
0.1058705896,
0.4832653701,
0.259252876,
0.3594243228,
-0.1037243158,
0.4099737406,
0.4150626659,
-0.2874463797,
0.2711508572,
0.2805586159,
-0.518202126,
0.1233224049,
0.0603794344,
0.564242363,
0.1573762447,
-0.3184443414,
0.4466679692,
0.015030155,
-0.1170380414,
-0.4164434969,
-0.0282319188,
-0.016792411,
0.409979701,
0.3664905429,
-0.1782205254,
0.3401708305,
-0.3041100204,
0.4261413217,
0.4527608454,
-0.333332479,
-0.1719336808,
0.8580796123,
-0.1135422289,
-0.3472933769,
0.8490150571,
-0.5974011421,
-0.6109529734,
0.6326881051,
0.7415747643,
1.0526169538,
-0.2561036348,
0.1345132142,
0.6585885286,
0.3958961964,
-0.4617316723,
0.1282580644,
0.0843998343,
-0.7908717394,
-0.6232438087,
-0.6451691389,
-0.199078545,
0.372266084,
-0.4717569053,
0.289121598,
-0.3915556073,
-0.3324666023,
0.113183625,
-0.2134802192,
-0.7917363048,
0.4039029181,
0.5039229393,
0.5261563659,
-0.7770247459,
0.7805463672,
0.7218812108,
-0.3744549751,
-0.9421803355,
0.0971807837,
-0.1351415813,
-0.6592987776,
0.9385383725,
0.431737721,
-0.0510212667,
0.3255856931,
-0.4835724533,
-1.1301050186,
1.0157200098,
0.2447831929,
-0.8354204297,
-0.3159253895,
0.095213674,
0.5047764182,
-0.3211916983,
0.163026154,
0.4500284791,
0.4363069236,
0.1831880957,
-1.0589598417,
0.3180326223,
0.1330385059,
0.1873645484,
0.5341039896,
-0.3355784118,
0.708299458,
-0.4045237899,
-0.504420042,
0.086531423,
0.7424942255,
0.2926670313,
0.2581801116,
0.4929234087,
0.7662861347,
0.8031541109,
-0.2631791532,
0.7770205736,
0.0525594205,
0.5020859241,
1.4009170532,
-0.5184592605,
0.8312343955,
0.3465174139,
-0.0560168102,
0.2341386527,
0.4360256195,
-0.4735246003,
0.447107017,
0.4658635259,
-0.1939709187,
-0.4126843214,
-0.0834544152,
-0.3187351227,
0.4147409201,
0.1814447492,
-0.2859655917,
-0.2399578691,
-0.0298564956,
0.0075789131,
-0.1716436297,
-0.3421533108,
0.8509595394,
0.1160281971,
-0.4917624593,
0.3571866453,
-0.0858680606,
0.5359495282,
-0.2933584154,
-0.2343045473,
0.0552292466,
0.1071087942,
-0.1477856487,
-0.6056700945,
0.1427512616,
0.0221961197,
-0.1556635648,
-0.259863317,
0.9680503011,
-0.4723538458,
-0.4656655192,
0.2702854872,
0.5462192893,
0.4890924692,
-0.286665976,
-0.4613362253,
-0.2816787064,
-0.1742507666,
-0.1963036209,
0.2928672135,
0.654037416,
-0.0917370319,
0.587023735,
0.5937234759,
0.1495410949,
-0.0046172282,
0.0709357485,
0.5563232303,
-0.8489774466,
-0.270079881,
-0.9460686445,
0.2786383033,
0.0836066604,
-0.0966391787,
0.634839654,
0.7951717973,
0.9961377382,
-0.0239953641,
0.706569314,
-0.2008319199,
0.5541281104,
-0.5111551881,
0.4383035898,
-0.3858778179,
0.3633751869,
-0.3559560776,
-1.1020871401,
-0.447512567,
0.8049058914,
-0.5300491452,
0.1100640967,
0.6557691097,
0.7534819245,
-0.0293828342,
-0.187604934,
0.3632053733,
0.1346872002,
0.2824273705,
0.6838687658,
1.02280128,
-0.5505502224,
0.5471299887,
-0.0118853943,
0.126180023,
0.0218234044,
-1.0616312027,
-0.8243522644,
-0.5103905797,
-0.5382574201,
-0.3525483012,
0.0225848835,
0.8402448893,
0.6948192716,
-0.9492999911,
0.1949417293,
-0.2150846869,
0.0481031612,
0.0275363475,
-0.2018495053,
0.4743012488,
-0.2199674696,
-0.7839801908,
0.5008456111,
0.315577209,
0.3727374375,
-0.012995841,
0.0879558772,
-0.0155060887,
-0.2837002575,
0.4040923417,
0.3945146203,
-0.7363885641,
-0.3981367648,
-0.0164226852,
-0.2413366884,
0.0713537112,
0.7060110569,
-0.8623825312,
0.2196030021,
0.2100025415,
0.8463261724,
0.5457121134,
-0.0349129662,
0.2731650472,
-0.6798639894,
-0.3377837837,
0.3371392488,
0.3960568011,
0.4808707535,
-0.5273237824,
0.6891151071,
0.1348579824,
-0.8372901678,
-0.7244882584,
0.1428584009,
-0.8669450879,
0.0923253521,
1.2574255466,
0.0487736538,
-0.0141905406,
-0.2400333434,
-0.1261449754,
0.3238052428,
-0.4036638439,
0.7567632794,
0.5286527872,
-0.0113469446,
-0.1907854825,
-0.79059726,
0.40484339,
0.187627703,
-0.7682380676,
-0.051898662,
0.5356044769,
0.4403990805,
0.3289110959,
0.8780075312,
0.0297056604,
-0.0325038955,
-0.19558011,
0.3559895456,
0.169786334,
-0.4427829981,
-0.3367825449,
0.1453136206,
0.0533017777,
-0.0728034005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10392v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10392v1 | CKBP v2: An Expert-Annotated Evaluation Set for Commonsense Knowledge Base Population | 2023-04-20T15:27:29 | 2023-04-20T15:27:29 | Tianqing Fang, Quyet V. Do, Sehyun Choi, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Populating Commonsense Knowledge Bases (CSKB) is an important yet hard task
in NLP, as it tackles knowledge from external sources with unseen events and
entities. Fang et al. (2021a) proposed a CSKB Population benchmark with an
evaluation set CKBP v1. However, CKBP v1 adopts crowdsourced annotations that
suffer from a substantial fraction of incorrect answers, and the evaluation set
is not well-aligned with the external knowledge source as a result of random
sampling. In this paper, we introduce CKBP v2, a new high-quality CSKB
Population benchmark, which addresses the two mentioned problems by using
experts instead of crowd-sourced annotation and by adding diversified
adversarial samples to make the evaluation set more representative. We conduct
extensive experiments comparing state-of-the-art methods for CSKB Population on
the new evaluation set for future research comparisons. Empirical results show
that the population task is still challenging, even for large language models
(LLM) such as ChatGPT. Codes and data are available at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/CSKB-Population. | [
-0.4956451952,
-0.1656668633,
0.046537973,
0.48767066,
-0.1325771064,
0.0980114266,
-0.4538324475,
-0.6673797369,
-0.1911115646,
0.6028626561,
-0.2211749852,
-0.1617714912,
-0.674790442,
-0.0785241127,
-0.0783721358,
0.6647684574,
0.4583584368,
0.1406698972,
-0.6208796501,
-0.1428294778,
-0.5255436897,
-0.3726157844,
-0.4795926809,
-0.1407392472,
0.2005689442,
0.5440136194,
0.7767845988,
0.4082950056,
0.4815452397,
0.1863310039,
-0.2039635777,
0.3589079976,
-0.7832543254,
-0.0726098269,
-0.3603567183,
-0.2118060142,
0.0508294776,
0.0536423065,
0.2686755657,
0.7791997194,
0.0462014079,
0.2817339003,
0.018090196,
0.7644465566,
-0.6340509653,
0.1860810965,
-0.9446972013,
0.0730467066,
-0.2971913517,
0.0055485824,
-0.6132430434,
-0.4152061045,
0.3309504688,
-0.5409519076,
0.2441006154,
0.1178233251,
0.656940937,
0.3237196803,
-0.3543144464,
-0.1194459274,
-0.0834845901,
0.7592560649,
-0.7149841189,
0.4203059971,
0.6027270555,
0.3282523155,
-0.4771795869,
-0.6275969148,
-0.4795613587,
-0.4541388154,
-0.1044856384,
0.2106276304,
-0.068200998,
-0.3586425781,
0.1086934283,
-0.0186452195,
-0.3951569498,
0.4159151912,
-0.7018731236,
-0.2914910614,
0.6392775774,
-0.1693223268,
-0.1463368237,
-0.5760914087,
-0.5207001567,
-0.1250052154,
-0.4555980265,
0.0669727474,
0.4717859924,
0.1058718488,
0.0559440628,
0.4011834264,
-0.5694003701,
0.6909194589,
0.2652495801,
0.2160426676,
0.3743299544,
0.0191141609,
0.2689557076,
-0.193618685,
0.6619079709,
0.6912589669,
0.5701553822,
-0.1440270692,
0.2776925266,
-0.4308230281,
0.2744870782,
-0.6350978017,
-0.7147133946,
0.3594463468,
-0.4540895224,
-0.5702140331,
-0.0996263847,
-0.8515164256,
-0.7293383479,
-0.2525653839,
-0.0946535766,
-0.4774547517,
-0.7279357314,
-0.2600450218,
-0.3213728666,
0.1385614276,
0.5657910705,
-1.0056869984,
0.2903996408,
0.9630646706,
0.519015193,
-0.2931625843,
-0.0302725397,
-0.2497998774,
-0.1605838984,
-0.3813269138,
1.1976472139,
-0.5420516133,
-0.2928364575,
-0.0610890575,
-0.3468042016,
0.4592457414,
-0.9055240154,
0.2983717918,
-0.4775432348,
-0.1189091578,
-0.7430205345,
-0.4323270619,
0.0822691619,
0.1000405848,
-0.6775404811,
1.4216030836,
0.4957510531,
-0.6970086098,
0.6419836879,
-0.2111272514,
-0.23025015,
0.6512544751,
-0.1134915352,
-0.0892578885,
0.0663659573,
0.2308185399,
0.4010938406,
-0.027669739,
0.1593920439,
-0.6423279047,
0.1393469125,
0.3414566517,
-0.2358679026,
1.0005955696,
0.3111905456,
0.2228061259,
-0.5347262621,
-0.6851462126,
0.5439001322,
-0.1325238943,
-0.3571431935,
-0.4750283659,
0.1976685971,
0.2944574654,
0.4944734871,
0.3474025726,
-0.30942747,
0.341270417,
-0.1723230481,
0.2028076947,
0.9657268524,
0.0032651522,
0.049297221,
-0.1031742468,
-0.017344106,
-0.1712916046,
0.0205784515,
0.3557142615,
-0.8068186045,
-0.2793463171,
-0.1831440181,
0.3784290552,
0.4411429763,
-0.6472622752,
0.3659339547,
-0.2624234557,
-0.8566153049,
-0.588383019,
0.4312443435,
0.5058825016,
0.4669216871,
0.474686414,
-0.3526757658,
-0.5736632347,
-1.1946704388,
-0.2273268253,
-0.3882883191,
-0.0221491307,
0.3733257949,
0.3253266513,
0.3650252819,
1.1553647518,
-0.5283136368,
-0.0159236491,
-0.1664754301,
0.2224003524,
-0.0614474118,
0.6252263784,
0.3882949948,
-0.7044273019,
-0.5497760773,
0.0092199957,
-0.5740608573,
-0.5992594361,
0.1191194206,
-0.2600505948,
-0.0119153531,
0.2789321542,
-0.4287212789,
-0.171508342,
0.4515263438,
-0.0691640303,
0.7265995145,
0.0918819904,
0.0952573791,
-0.9991249442,
-0.0194773637,
-0.0020961836,
-0.1302934736,
-0.3466149271,
0.1940593272,
0.3104164302,
0.0113583216,
-0.5572330952,
0.6474585533,
-0.4668959081,
-0.1516953409,
-0.3123008311,
0.4190420508,
-0.4249899685,
0.4338637888,
0.2839418352,
0.2967159152,
0.0932398811,
-0.2160200626,
0.6070616841,
0.4989405274,
-0.5359426737,
0.8520117402,
-0.3586075902,
0.2725510299,
0.1094971523,
0.3958356082,
-0.8495612144,
-0.3469453454,
0.0141557883,
-0.788459301,
0.1245606318,
-0.2306374162,
-0.6913337708,
-0.6254488826,
-0.2176742852,
0.1895973235,
0.6347665191,
-0.5794320703,
-0.1108163074,
0.3697562218,
-0.2602001131,
-0.8358901143,
-0.5998883247,
0.1678195596,
0.3366114199,
-0.7224274874,
-0.1809865087,
0.1728519052,
-0.3013649881,
0.1731259376,
-0.2988401055,
-0.2308034897,
0.1062205881,
0.0987185761,
-0.0343457982,
-0.0843491256,
0.2289298177,
0.0285271779,
-0.3390208781,
-0.0860652104,
-0.1264617294,
0.490180701,
0.1411614567,
-0.3468391001,
-0.2331161201,
0.263176024,
-0.0461138003,
-0.2950267792,
0.2928255498,
0.5923768878,
-0.503380239,
-0.3489497602,
-0.9189143181,
-0.1038279757,
-0.4012424648,
1.0133341551,
-0.1018247828,
-0.6911866665,
0.1436176598,
-0.1249633655,
0.2489868999,
0.5447329283,
0.7121152878,
-0.1392329484,
0.4357352853,
0.1712001413,
-0.0774778575,
-0.051201649,
0.0046237423,
-0.0412027277,
-0.7987231016,
-0.2239601165,
-0.5598326325,
-0.2942417264,
-0.458845675,
-0.6416633725,
0.0825857893,
0.4270758629,
0.1422413439,
0.6430607438,
-0.5556076765,
0.3756818473,
0.7173599005,
0.2766332924,
0.2061817199,
-0.1002845243,
0.3272175491,
-0.3166841269,
-0.4440594614,
-0.327958405,
1.3955516815,
0.0467547737,
0.3060654104,
0.1891458482,
0.3509406447,
0.6121171713,
0.6699323654,
-0.3778167665,
0.6770732999,
-0.344537288,
-0.9472708106,
-0.1862330735,
-0.3523044884,
-0.5874720216,
0.408629179,
-0.5046944022,
-1.0532655716,
0.161244452,
0.4241978824,
-0.1958197653,
0.090379104,
-0.801492095,
0.7374046445,
-0.1276506633,
-0.4223867953,
-0.4123156369,
-0.578339994,
0.5857601762,
-0.1539909989,
-0.0097814715,
-0.286046505,
0.0707213208,
0.7406821251,
-0.5378488898,
0.6080062389,
-0.4686144888,
0.1655749828,
0.4147340059,
-0.1838252246,
0.6291805506,
0.2482897192,
-0.2067500651,
0.3149115145,
-0.0254932325,
-0.5461906195,
-0.4562107325,
0.8046215177,
-0.7099026442,
-0.4367908835,
-0.2672281265,
-0.4063414633,
-0.4583924115,
0.0574537776,
0.0475289486,
0.3996714354,
-0.0065846662,
0.6627020836,
0.5503240228,
-0.2971215248,
0.0991808325,
0.6237395406,
-0.0303792171,
-0.6251035333,
0.7369285226,
0.2914299071,
0.5928900838,
0.3729870915,
0.0662985668,
-0.2234161943,
-0.6484559774,
-0.5721977949,
-0.2750606835,
-0.7672867179,
-0.2769271731,
-0.7708898187,
-0.0650456399,
-0.6989404559,
-0.2342612594,
-0.4940298498,
-0.5355634093,
0.2282630652,
-0.112396583,
0.4111258686,
0.2930436432,
-0.353166759,
0.2051927894,
-0.2532957196,
0.5516378284,
0.4341370761,
0.3303158879,
0.0160596482,
-0.3359285295,
-0.2665938139,
-0.1636394411,
-0.3750788867,
-0.8922876716,
-0.0892290175,
-0.1327058524,
0.7507594228,
0.5139123797,
0.1806121022,
0.6900656819,
-0.1838819981,
0.765319407,
0.0120826652,
-0.4502436221,
0.0702389181,
-0.2396269292,
0.2230567336,
0.8663048744,
0.141548723,
-0.8497958183,
-0.5419126153,
-0.5676318407,
-0.9572837353,
0.7562513947,
0.15931122,
-0.0338623188,
-0.1045655683,
0.1428643614,
0.3107542098,
0.1920149624,
-0.6650829315,
-0.1564347744,
-0.2090967745,
-0.264157325,
0.4199905097,
-0.4103884697,
0.2473434955,
0.0362695977,
0.7993429899,
0.0389282703,
0.0032951778,
-0.0225614347,
-0.0982786566,
-0.1655453146,
0.0418618619,
0.2076464295,
0.691378355,
-0.2802764475,
-0.0197991133,
0.4300667942,
-0.6260455251,
-0.3127166927,
0.296572715,
-0.199168846,
-0.1436789334,
0.6546643376,
0.2352903932,
0.3424524963,
-0.7383233309,
0.6861221194,
0.4926584363,
-0.2141135931,
-0.5768895745,
0.0288261268,
0.3385923803,
0.0692317635,
0.7052488923,
0.3220124841,
0.0499764867,
-0.0951306224,
0.2661128342,
0.4476680458,
-0.3262589872,
0.0910248533,
0.6050795913,
0.4444031417,
-0.2583265603,
0.7240866423,
-0.387711376,
-0.3767063618,
0.7070654035,
0.1647297442,
0.6216216683,
-0.1976353675,
0.1279049963,
0.6561139226,
0.6038290262,
-0.0885781422,
0.0205978993,
-0.1958421171,
-0.6129976511,
-0.3635707796,
-0.3435370922,
-0.4895159602,
0.2944148779,
-0.5624015331,
0.5011956096,
-0.4557189345,
0.2487497926,
0.0774608925,
0.116775319,
-0.6484062076,
0.2470272779,
0.155469656,
1.0381379128,
-0.6878144145,
0.5548853874,
0.2663183808,
-0.1407021731,
-0.4124529958,
-0.2488143593,
0.0340180099,
-0.9329599738,
0.6994329095,
0.2273876816,
0.4629666507,
-0.1754957438,
-0.860136807,
-0.8539454937,
0.7848494053,
-0.055801779,
-0.6179552078,
0.3777955472,
0.1474882662,
0.4781097472,
0.1629014462,
0.3942696452,
0.2186515331,
0.8512213826,
-0.2584148943,
-0.8746865392,
0.0478814356,
-0.4504468739,
-0.0170934871,
0.07153368,
-0.9171488881,
0.3933484554,
-0.2833122611,
0.0569282733,
0.2111205757,
1.0142989159,
0.3239844441,
0.2568322122,
0.6597576141,
0.7010883093,
0.4677093923,
-0.1463523507,
0.6252111197,
-0.1542789489,
0.3457737565,
1.4323785305,
-0.2085797787,
1.017380476,
0.4021064043,
-0.529078126,
0.019684298,
0.6206328273,
-0.5936790109,
0.4834581017,
0.65860641,
0.0190690495,
-0.3656975329,
0.2039778829,
-0.5398959517,
0.3030615747,
0.1531592309,
-0.1465589255,
-0.2679232061,
-0.2868992984,
0.2587384284,
0.2910771668,
-0.0618638359,
0.781501472,
-0.1437733173,
-0.802111268,
0.2816074789,
0.0515513867,
0.4663751125,
-0.5491430163,
-0.1271609813,
0.0389174744,
-0.0189703722,
-0.3839664161,
-0.8601813912,
-0.0716031343,
-0.0596865043,
-0.0740869045,
0.0529504418,
0.609652102,
-0.2861033976,
-0.5713123679,
0.0844164938,
0.3189415932,
0.3813275397,
-0.0683126748,
-0.3963308334,
-0.4262412786,
0.1257392615,
-0.3439151943,
0.1261931509,
0.334695369,
-0.2752557397,
0.5956915617,
0.8206942081,
0.1074096784,
0.1073775217,
-0.1245451495,
0.6160167456,
-0.2934649289,
-0.2134103626,
-0.4242854118,
0.5015602112,
-0.6531285048,
-0.8287734389,
0.6150186658,
0.8223640919,
1.0137521029,
-0.1710443795,
1.1243940592,
-0.5403831005,
0.652861774,
-0.2413459271,
0.6952711344,
-0.0947545767,
-0.1217103899,
-0.4221728146,
-0.766549468,
0.0833397508,
0.3269934654,
-0.3945123255,
0.0987336561,
0.6149680018,
0.7652920485,
0.0852383748,
0.0001418025,
0.2019676715,
0.3864355683,
0.1877595335,
0.6642536521,
0.5817525387,
-0.0497558787,
0.7406936288,
-0.5346639752,
-0.3666189015,
-0.4575462341,
-0.9394245148,
-0.7259001732,
-0.6605646014,
-0.2732518017,
-0.3744837344,
0.1709790826,
1.1240115166,
0.8200181723,
-0.8349048495,
0.1677004844,
0.2091337442,
-0.1037365794,
-0.6138077378,
-0.2924246192,
0.363553077,
-0.1888937056,
-0.6453857422,
0.1125351563,
-0.049299404,
-0.542363584,
-0.5055497885,
0.0995201916,
-0.0114516588,
-0.3170019686,
0.4020689726,
0.285237968,
-0.6633295417,
-0.4019675255,
-0.3773317933,
-0.1193995699,
-0.1712683141,
0.5372204781,
-0.7873547673,
0.5998427868,
0.4625962079,
0.7671313286,
0.3084960282,
0.184910357,
0.3461234868,
-0.5413349867,
-0.0001943288,
0.1245650128,
0.2220304161,
0.4896550477,
-0.3537638485,
0.5461392403,
0.4439901412,
-0.4426331818,
-0.7046383619,
0.2561038435,
-1.3653939962,
-0.2413045317,
1.3481962681,
-0.0655452907,
0.0430548787,
-0.4149924517,
-0.3460010588,
-0.087515913,
-0.5869024396,
1.0215286016,
0.9541261792,
0.2808711231,
-0.0039077187,
-0.8672748208,
0.4418204129,
0.2772448063,
-0.7985315323,
0.2915990651,
0.5644678473,
0.3390885293,
0.14528808,
0.6983786225,
-0.155885011,
0.5061915517,
0.211157307,
0.3763806522,
-0.4834544957,
0.149544999,
0.4370002151,
0.3258110881,
-0.0441493765,
0.1702740788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10354v1 | Prompt-Learning for Cross-Lingual Relation Extraction | 2023-04-20T14:52:06 | 2023-04-20T14:52:06 | Chiaming Hsu, Changtong Zan, Liang Ding, Longyue Wang, Xiaoting Wang, Weifeng Liu, Fu Lin, Wenbin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation Extraction (RE) is a crucial task in Information Extraction, which
entails predicting relationships between entities within a given sentence.
However, extending pre-trained RE models to other languages is challenging,
particularly in real-world scenarios where Cross-Lingual Relation Extraction
(XRE) is required. Despite recent advancements in Prompt-Learning, which
involves transferring knowledge from Multilingual Pre-trained Language Models
(PLMs) to diverse downstream tasks, there is limited research on the effective
use of multilingual PLMs with prompts to improve XRE. In this paper, we present
a novel XRE algorithm based on Prompt-Tuning, referred to as Prompt-XRE. To
evaluate its effectiveness, we design and implement several prompt templates,
including hard, soft, and hybrid prompts, and empirically test their
performance on competitive multilingual PLMs, specifically mBART. Our extensive
experiments, conducted on the low-resource ACE05 benchmark across multiple
languages, demonstrate that our Prompt-XRE algorithm significantly outperforms
both vanilla multilingual PLMs and other existing models, achieving
state-of-the-art performance in XRE. To further show the generalization of our
Prompt-XRE on larger data scales, we construct and release a new XRE dataset-
WMT17-EnZh XRE, containing 0.9M English-Chinese pairs extracted from WMT 2017
parallel corpus. Experiments on WMT17-EnZh XRE also show the effectiveness of
our Prompt-XRE against other competitive baselines. The code and newly
constructed dataset are freely available at
\url{https://github.com/HSU-CHIA-MING/Prompt-XRE}. | [
-0.5091394782,
-0.4471279979,
0.4594413042,
0.2688427866,
-0.3260622025,
0.0849560425,
-0.4864154756,
-0.412032634,
0.0925551802,
0.1160679013,
-1.0006822348,
-0.4996259809,
-0.2076601237,
0.5475750566,
0.2614644468,
0.8950603008,
0.1707701832,
0.2058101147,
0.0306739602,
-0.3648528159,
-0.9062139988,
-0.3823503256,
-0.7541921139,
-0.0084012076,
1.0742108822,
0.6705581546,
0.4059175849,
0.5188558102,
0.0330788568,
0.2732874155,
0.089838855,
0.3326019347,
-0.3732213378,
0.2554523051,
-0.2690510452,
-0.4356236756,
-0.204121381,
0.0294207465,
0.683319211,
0.5289824009,
0.0429095142,
0.1720433831,
0.0008035544,
0.326397866,
-0.4267795086,
0.4228763282,
-0.5315239429,
-0.0953714773,
-0.2817676365,
-0.5002447963,
-0.5377708673,
-0.1895257533,
0.2089953125,
-0.8194365501,
0.1230921745,
0.5820688605,
1.1052759886,
-0.1895638853,
-0.3320675492,
-0.2266102582,
-0.1617982835,
0.802682817,
-0.232778281,
0.8551530242,
0.2549807131,
0.4968817234,
0.0797062367,
-0.6176903248,
-0.2667786479,
-0.3564402461,
-0.2782869339,
0.0619731657,
-0.0971277431,
-0.320574671,
0.4010787308,
0.2641565502,
-0.7876241803,
0.1662384421,
-0.0139125958,
-0.0812823921,
0.3267733753,
0.2140115052,
0.4708605409,
-0.4154481292,
-0.5020734668,
-0.2595874071,
-0.7648599744,
0.4402149022,
0.0654617846,
0.7521762848,
-0.1954102516,
0.0882562324,
-0.0313300006,
0.5669637322,
0.2265384942,
-0.0422655232,
0.3882658184,
-0.5680740476,
0.068797797,
0.0462584421,
0.9199117422,
0.1535657048,
0.3329031169,
-0.2304547131,
-0.278180331,
-0.2286759615,
-0.3404397964,
-0.6226788163,
-0.2283602059,
-0.2306230813,
-0.4023059011,
-0.0148056019,
0.0039691716,
-0.7904677987,
-0.3268752396,
-0.2281928658,
0.200769037,
-0.5264926553,
-0.3416148424,
-0.2334495932,
-0.0605331324,
0.3241205215,
0.1492099017,
-0.733779788,
0.0388839096,
0.5413034558,
0.8643072248,
-0.1200516298,
-0.561540544,
-1.2175321579,
-0.2095422596,
-0.1941216439,
0.7028678656,
-0.5131344795,
-0.4818411171,
-0.1779846698,
0.2355810106,
-0.2564434409,
-0.5187880993,
0.7272911668,
-0.6814406514,
0.6072344184,
-0.6461238265,
-0.306809932,
0.0519396551,
0.3384166062,
-0.9847490191,
0.9180911779,
0.2762573957,
-0.7864341736,
0.5278630853,
-0.3960490525,
-0.5071437955,
0.0041475235,
-0.3161346614,
-0.3327352405,
-0.1104020774,
0.5457711816,
0.3542110026,
-0.7698517442,
0.2210609317,
-0.1285987943,
-0.1337392479,
0.1584911346,
-0.2798953354,
1.1360533237,
0.1124929264,
-0.1450720429,
0.3324303329,
-0.811013341,
-0.0833260715,
0.0772479177,
-0.0197084974,
-0.5945571661,
-0.5396486521,
-0.0762923658,
0.8265243769,
0.0142409755,
-0.6012035608,
0.1112365723,
-0.4063497782,
0.062367484,
0.6099939942,
0.0505814776,
0.4229581952,
-0.3374091983,
0.8438640833,
0.0292435065,
-0.0354118869,
-0.8624085188,
-0.4707350433,
-0.3820887208,
-0.3398242593,
0.5029587746,
0.7487298846,
-1.102483511,
0.2807122469,
-0.4191901982,
-0.3397973776,
-0.5117998719,
0.2745989561,
0.5994117856,
0.8786324859,
0.3853617609,
0.1359711736,
-0.575085938,
-0.4939363301,
-0.3709754944,
-0.1260540485,
0.0428761542,
0.4281616211,
-0.0326480046,
0.0790772364,
1.1065212488,
-0.4681561887,
-0.1877396554,
-0.5240870714,
0.2383246124,
0.2502512634,
0.3813748062,
0.6447307467,
-0.897677958,
-0.7616721988,
0.1154477969,
-0.6058835983,
-0.4068189263,
-0.3234672248,
-0.1761695743,
0.2140094191,
0.2953053713,
-0.5447076559,
-0.0472456068,
0.3224486113,
-0.3938977718,
0.7896929979,
-0.093288213,
0.2690767348,
-1.0442000628,
0.1111544967,
0.3213449121,
-0.3541045785,
-0.4203033745,
-0.0648023635,
0.4572056234,
-0.2946401536,
-0.5266498327,
1.0031685829,
-0.8979235888,
0.2829846442,
0.0827540085,
0.2100738138,
0.1124743223,
0.7027166486,
0.384850204,
0.7704042196,
0.5904408097,
-0.5510168076,
0.2466846406,
0.3607795238,
-0.3011976779,
0.4483608902,
-0.4181619585,
-0.194668144,
-0.0509682335,
-0.054015968,
-0.9591296315,
0.3123907745,
0.4170875549,
-0.551591754,
0.4559792578,
-0.1051405892,
-0.3429483175,
-0.0831232145,
-0.3611257374,
0.4253760278,
0.5375342369,
-0.788931191,
0.5651831627,
0.0344844759,
-0.5407087803,
-0.5607776046,
-0.214174822,
0.1232779175,
-0.2151589245,
-0.6279146075,
0.2941178381,
0.0458690226,
-0.074382551,
-0.2050009519,
0.0664952248,
-0.0118263513,
-0.1852773279,
-0.0046251677,
0.3999351859,
-0.2378638089,
0.1040459424,
0.0409395136,
-0.4416478574,
0.1732798666,
-0.0339196473,
0.4775311947,
0.2054548413,
0.0347642489,
-0.2844142318,
0.4027426541,
0.3131242096,
-0.4879123867,
0.5169789195,
0.6076018214,
-0.1199895069,
-0.2512831092,
-0.3095673919,
-0.279296875,
-0.4952948391,
0.2692318857,
-0.8326900005,
-0.6795591712,
0.6338823438,
-0.1560359448,
0.0854272544,
0.2213357687,
0.202978313,
0.272939235,
1.0742089748,
0.8324607611,
-0.118889913,
0.6594653726,
-0.0980234146,
-0.0485375002,
-0.5120219588,
-0.2331049889,
-0.5637093186,
0.1580484211,
-0.598182559,
-0.1394847035,
0.2311374545,
-0.1645992994,
-0.0215260275,
0.4060341418,
0.1869736314,
0.198219195,
0.6161443591,
-0.0071434155,
0.3254668415,
0.0139804734,
-0.3864505887,
-0.354442209,
-0.905136168,
-0.0588296689,
0.5141408443,
0.0187660828,
0.5775334239,
-0.1291026175,
0.5480430722,
-0.0152029432,
0.1957157403,
-0.6088359356,
0.4466375113,
-0.0449669175,
-0.221461609,
-0.2955183685,
-0.8403820992,
-1.1858410835,
0.2855933011,
-0.1551651955,
-0.5226272941,
0.3142915666,
0.0579999574,
-0.3568569124,
0.1670891047,
-0.5333138704,
1.0141496658,
-0.4249335825,
-0.4647370577,
0.144599095,
-0.9517255425,
0.3903428912,
-0.3149336874,
0.1782144904,
-0.0598920248,
-0.0604695007,
0.6140787601,
-0.2221123576,
0.6544365883,
-0.2634816468,
-0.3976144791,
0.0304944552,
-0.1197781786,
0.409573853,
0.341139555,
-0.1460641026,
0.1716435701,
-0.1056979448,
-0.2442592233,
-0.8237704635,
0.6313146353,
-0.5917192698,
-0.5028820634,
-0.3490467668,
-0.5731998682,
-0.4024519026,
0.282428056,
0.5261790156,
0.6403756738,
-0.2615989447,
-0.2213117927,
0.4964486659,
-0.4277170897,
0.4822942317,
0.6547244787,
-0.3296833336,
-0.6335060596,
1.1129904985,
0.2317795753,
0.0212677699,
0.7959645391,
0.3247081935,
-0.576919198,
0.1089299768,
-0.6443368793,
0.3381031752,
-0.4463071525,
-0.3130045235,
-0.6372966766,
0.0959465206,
-0.524064362,
0.0924281925,
0.0192194693,
-0.3302552104,
-0.1722381115,
0.0519389883,
0.2162940651,
0.1326538026,
-0.1508052647,
0.2834056914,
-1.2408938408,
0.3899113834,
-0.0175645743,
-0.0077842781,
0.0183188133,
-0.4307338595,
-0.3387983739,
-0.1634100378,
0.1153331399,
-1.0056437254,
0.5407761335,
0.2948737144,
0.7066652179,
0.5340280533,
0.3573887944,
0.6434869766,
-0.5714982152,
0.4278513789,
0.2874064744,
-0.8198814988,
0.4690719843,
-0.2751433551,
0.4297150373,
0.5604339838,
0.6711189747,
-0.8600486517,
0.0428193547,
-0.5817228556,
-0.6888068318,
0.8778027892,
-0.1201690212,
-0.0680452064,
-0.050887987,
0.3154858053,
0.5385399461,
0.1385566294,
-0.4566983283,
-0.4038694501,
0.067678839,
-0.0327681676,
-0.28221789,
-0.2552797496,
0.4005536139,
-0.1990575492,
0.7058014274,
-0.0056808353,
-0.1516004801,
-0.0027558645,
-0.3536655605,
-0.0545395054,
0.2613277137,
0.2155668437,
0.6079610586,
-0.0099774692,
-0.0038856887,
0.2017156631,
-0.2401320934,
0.3504281044,
0.340007782,
-0.1637189835,
0.216581881,
0.4951922894,
0.8326845169,
0.3116367459,
-0.7675020099,
0.4622536302,
-0.3856718242,
0.1525530517,
0.0630036145,
-0.1580040753,
-0.2573716342,
-0.0509716943,
0.3560274541,
-0.1652857661,
-0.0232885033,
-0.4388478994,
0.4977430403,
0.2656299174,
-0.3368288279,
-0.6149241924,
0.4390018582,
0.339617461,
-0.2221382856,
0.7537682056,
-0.4178411365,
-0.5497965217,
0.2975255847,
0.6250272989,
0.859385252,
-0.4119890034,
0.2028719187,
0.5363800526,
0.1755898297,
0.1689493209,
0.4494502544,
-0.4214493632,
-0.611020565,
-0.6485677361,
-0.2402110696,
-0.3020483851,
-0.1477470398,
-0.8847374916,
0.6663281918,
-0.1312386245,
0.0346625224,
-0.2677194774,
0.3736569881,
-0.53938061,
0.206702292,
0.0674411356,
1.222900033,
-0.9110563397,
0.8948713541,
0.8558838367,
-0.4719998837,
-0.8839749098,
-0.1449725479,
-0.1581061482,
-0.7029315233,
0.7321200371,
0.3569829762,
-0.0661357418,
0.0646675304,
-0.0123481983,
-0.6850597858,
0.8275615573,
0.5533182621,
-0.8505135775,
-0.1613975316,
-0.017271487,
0.0436694659,
-0.2934693098,
0.3199328184,
0.5222456455,
0.5402252674,
-0.056123022,
-0.8403557539,
0.3850768805,
-0.4716685414,
-0.2376351804,
0.3704705536,
-0.5982082486,
0.9220740795,
-0.2870679498,
-0.4520134926,
0.1679719239,
0.7558961511,
0.5275807977,
0.2846298516,
0.7955896854,
0.2682697773,
0.9411335588,
0.0354041532,
0.7629593015,
-0.494756788,
0.066309154,
1.2437617779,
-0.6051699519,
0.4269711971,
0.4417881668,
0.277587682,
0.5670489669,
0.8435279727,
0.1193139404,
0.6327188015,
-0.1918985993,
-0.1610727608,
-0.4163634479,
-0.2225411087,
-0.290827781,
0.1505536884,
0.1808167398,
-0.2981794477,
-0.4451805353,
0.3599385321,
0.1744247973,
-0.087642245,
-0.2967940569,
0.753896296,
0.1399116516,
-0.796097517,
0.5063815117,
-0.0467918031,
0.6609553099,
-0.8222296238,
-0.1936751455,
-0.2447160482,
0.0202554855,
-0.0012005116,
-0.4842189252,
-0.2406913042,
-0.0117812986,
-0.2700774074,
-0.1763044149,
0.7299692631,
-0.596149683,
-0.3795453608,
0.5740721822,
1.0299255848,
-0.116433382,
-0.1316213161,
-0.7538004518,
-0.0963448808,
0.0709115341,
-0.3323540092,
0.3607866168,
0.8239805698,
-0.4957429767,
0.5756025314,
0.6502110958,
0.193247661,
-0.019398734,
0.2585039139,
0.9308608174,
-0.9037726521,
-0.9377323389,
-0.9386979342,
0.3318707347,
-0.0874522477,
-0.5402219892,
1.104714036,
0.5932024121,
0.7647976279,
0.1144089848,
0.7731916904,
0.1032116935,
0.5388054252,
-0.5193734169,
0.4294352233,
-0.5498167276,
0.1591549814,
-0.3102602363,
-0.7422539592,
-0.2788729072,
0.1982283443,
-0.2433427125,
0.1534274518,
0.7657740712,
0.8089110851,
-0.1005036756,
0.0333604328,
0.4410554767,
-0.171117574,
0.2032178789,
0.5469902754,
1.0593475103,
-0.1698512733,
0.8005161285,
-0.486489445,
-0.4119647145,
0.1801539063,
-0.9771875143,
-0.9098849893,
-0.7060470581,
-0.2980497777,
-0.0601868033,
0.1451717615,
1.1064066887,
0.6774353385,
-0.6444452405,
-0.2234352529,
0.2524725199,
0.2313880175,
-0.4624822438,
-0.1810569912,
0.5121753812,
-0.7060929537,
-0.6864261627,
0.5351333022,
0.0272751264,
-0.2366750091,
-0.1267907619,
-0.2531296015,
-0.2908104062,
-0.2436424047,
0.5242442489,
0.3982458711,
-0.2666937113,
0.1206077784,
0.4425916076,
-0.0170529336,
0.2529626489,
1.0202509165,
-1.0297261477,
0.2083570212,
0.7018733025,
0.5764324665,
0.0726439729,
0.1010998935,
0.8731788993,
-1.0676006079,
-0.0694442838,
-0.0480462722,
0.6151005626,
0.4064967036,
-0.4272066355,
0.3927315772,
0.1703732014,
-0.276509434,
-0.7467491031,
0.1666742861,
-0.8340309262,
-0.2942163646,
1.0149086714,
-0.3036934137,
-0.2915846407,
-0.1826614887,
-0.5166598558,
0.3201312423,
-0.6504698992,
0.4035513103,
0.3501472473,
-0.1045397595,
-0.5818027854,
-0.0866972581,
0.4309599102,
0.4679421484,
-0.6631183028,
0.3083765805,
0.389819026,
0.2295686007,
0.1390727609,
0.508040905,
0.0641923398,
0.5782663822,
-0.272792846,
-0.1101799756,
-0.3048732877,
-0.4195130169,
-0.6411549449,
0.2231674045,
-0.0072288709,
-0.2211980969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11075v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11075v2 | Spaiche: Extending State-of-the-Art ASR Models to Swiss German Dialects | 2023-04-20T14:42:54 | 2023-09-13T16:12:56 | Clement Sicard, Kajetan Pyszkowski, Victor Gillioz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent breakthroughs in NLP largely increased the presence of ASR systems in
our daily lives. However, for many low-resource languages, ASR models still
need to be improved due in part to the difficulty of acquiring pertinent data.
This project aims to help advance research in ASR models for Swiss German
dialects, by providing insights about the performance of state-of-the-art ASR
models on recently published Swiss German speech datasets. We propose a novel
loss that takes into account the semantic distance between the predicted and
the ground-truth labels. We outperform current state-of-the-art results by
fine-tuning OpenAI's Whisper model on Swiss-German datasets. | [
-0.186763227,
-0.5109642744,
0.2741122544,
-0.0245990213,
0.050468117,
-0.3259046376,
-0.3178667128,
-0.5660133958,
-0.1332494318,
0.6377863288,
-0.7207075953,
-0.3779907227,
-0.7233090401,
-0.1543698311,
-0.4468242228,
0.6804310679,
0.043113295,
0.2745290399,
0.1515413225,
-0.4216256142,
-0.071144022,
-0.7011605501,
-0.4894536138,
-0.5781623125,
0.2559807599,
0.2661325336,
0.5731374621,
0.3280515075,
0.2286661863,
0.2285376191,
-0.4566364586,
0.1205674037,
-0.4588246047,
-0.1777315438,
-0.0087129408,
-0.2615712285,
-0.3613826931,
-0.3060375154,
0.7910868526,
1.1788482666,
-0.5752156973,
-0.0758001581,
0.0658082366,
0.8826130033,
-0.3870286047,
0.0868405253,
-0.4543969929,
-0.0991553888,
-0.3301313818,
0.0560940243,
-0.2887231708,
-0.1846088767,
0.5091764331,
-0.5847174525,
0.5712473392,
-0.1266153604,
1.2512226105,
0.2008284628,
-0.1798202097,
-0.2700244486,
-0.9948034883,
0.5565631986,
-0.8165230751,
0.5941299796,
0.2067462802,
0.3747080564,
-0.1041516811,
-0.5031275153,
-0.2706034184,
-0.204004541,
0.0719060004,
0.1058590412,
-0.7853994966,
-0.0889015868,
0.1162645742,
0.2227374315,
-0.3812328875,
0.2522948682,
-0.4816789329,
-0.2039435953,
0.4573829472,
-0.091034539,
-0.1009186879,
0.1962868124,
-0.103768006,
-0.0435299687,
-0.6509818435,
-0.0441532321,
0.4439301193,
0.4832071066,
-0.0492381006,
0.3527451754,
-0.4438325465,
1.0564471483,
0.1744560599,
0.0098344823,
0.2818888128,
-0.063678883,
0.0843474716,
0.264610976,
0.4197963178,
0.3704896569,
0.2483895272,
-0.2374840081,
-0.2748355269,
0.0367257595,
-0.2947292626,
-0.727563262,
-0.3456450701,
-0.229159236,
-0.419254452,
-0.0299114138,
0.1672276407,
-0.4050012529,
-0.2911866307,
-0.2791263759,
0.450361222,
-0.5689483881,
-0.5870280266,
0.7604341507,
-0.3221094906,
0.013516211,
0.3175735474,
-0.4591183066,
0.6715868711,
0.4572770596,
0.838345468,
-0.0021549994,
-0.2019573599,
-0.4491889179,
0.3195274174,
-0.3025814593,
0.9727886319,
-0.5137591362,
-0.6057522893,
0.0213262569,
-0.0381922238,
-0.1126952469,
-0.8604037762,
0.5324497223,
-0.4732175171,
0.0675270408,
-0.0982775539,
-0.4938690066,
-0.4147720933,
-0.2952288091,
-0.6945063472,
0.8359002471,
0.1473216265,
-0.68856287,
0.0800860673,
-0.8139990568,
-0.7937101722,
-0.2091813087,
0.2577163279,
-0.1949548572,
0.5877329111,
0.2181842327,
0.2368362844,
-0.3784235418,
0.2868109643,
-0.1544537842,
-0.373385042,
0.5776382685,
-0.4176650941,
0.6795623302,
0.0618213154,
-0.0404874273,
-0.1598267853,
-0.9206262827,
0.0765776634,
-0.1575497538,
-0.0497728959,
-0.4553371966,
0.1428744495,
0.2631670833,
0.0507276729,
-0.0184137095,
-0.6370794177,
-0.2559059262,
-0.6599977612,
0.5553488731,
0.7066305876,
-0.1441421062,
0.4150213301,
-0.4394065738,
0.2584829628,
0.0997399241,
-0.1331937164,
0.0517248027,
-0.1863391399,
-0.9162095785,
-0.3481940925,
0.6608259678,
0.574610889,
-0.472063303,
0.5493862033,
-0.5376742482,
-0.5197429061,
-0.988417089,
-0.2178153098,
0.2914252579,
0.6639872193,
0.2895226181,
-0.3648269176,
-0.4258397222,
-0.97093606,
-0.1372645348,
-0.0349775553,
-0.2020920664,
0.34188959,
0.2387718558,
-0.3656317592,
0.9546459317,
-0.744807899,
-0.4365766048,
-0.4133221209,
0.0930814818,
0.3825734854,
0.4483393431,
0.2592895329,
-0.7723309398,
-0.2640307546,
0.146208182,
-0.4323828816,
-0.294847697,
0.454405278,
0.1966423988,
0.3969196975,
0.27496773,
-0.4482659101,
0.2710622847,
0.5873669386,
-0.2511998415,
0.33356148,
-0.1263355762,
0.0145685626,
-0.8345927,
0.0904865041,
0.2472983152,
0.0125849666,
-0.8887795806,
-0.2713600099,
-0.2986767888,
-0.221847862,
-0.2353335917,
0.6751479506,
-0.4071874619,
-0.1508021206,
-0.1094384938,
0.0408767685,
-0.0540331975,
0.1287715882,
0.5360603929,
0.607766211,
0.7681046724,
-0.6111965179,
0.0324462689,
0.1426402926,
-0.5681747198,
0.5829015374,
-0.8219935298,
-0.1407587826,
-0.2048297822,
0.2907680869,
-0.6265422702,
-0.2620729208,
-0.0343554839,
-0.7502447367,
0.4571400881,
-0.35962075,
-0.5918961763,
-0.0814508796,
0.1547595114,
-0.0614080355,
0.6488411427,
-0.4083231688,
0.6106176972,
0.5096513033,
-0.3391484022,
-0.284796536,
-0.6149806976,
-0.0363348089,
-0.2638032138,
-0.811383009,
0.2821134329,
0.2691367865,
-0.3219096959,
0.1025164872,
-0.256308943,
-0.392529875,
-0.1034547016,
0.152436167,
0.0339321867,
-0.4267477393,
0.1181157827,
-0.016446026,
-0.5578090549,
-0.1754776984,
-0.4049947262,
0.3620154262,
-0.3762205541,
-0.3162789047,
-0.6342648268,
0.5503226519,
0.1964485645,
-0.2156398445,
0.4342628419,
0.3114055395,
-0.4555263817,
-0.3121728003,
-0.6937127113,
-0.1658967584,
-0.4740855098,
0.3909393549,
-0.5524283648,
-1.0111936331,
0.4786987901,
-0.4328178465,
-0.4467375278,
0.5022184253,
0.0803003311,
-0.273801595,
0.8782782555,
1.0476471186,
-0.2291810811,
0.2809965611,
-0.4209787846,
0.1597340107,
-0.4629079401,
-0.0177716948,
-0.7551599741,
0.1379294991,
-0.3697026372,
-0.5059683919,
0.4797392786,
0.0939674973,
-0.0522630662,
0.1428084373,
-0.3093177974,
0.0892630294,
0.6235744357,
0.2165046334,
0.3345374763,
0.3714420497,
0.2241339833,
-0.202865392,
-1.0343983173,
-0.3396570086,
0.4565976262,
0.3238050938,
0.912592113,
0.0314164981,
0.4553805292,
0.3448608518,
-0.0186582673,
-0.5494940877,
0.3734596968,
-0.49455899,
-0.4452937543,
-0.5162603259,
-0.3977158368,
-0.7119803429,
0.0368000753,
0.3541544676,
-0.4998806417,
0.14314197,
0.2249454558,
-0.3340382278,
0.1482193321,
-0.3913071752,
0.7663926482,
-0.151085332,
0.2240783572,
-0.2961489558,
-0.6532216668,
-0.0228795372,
0.0289980564,
0.3391097486,
-0.2758214176,
0.0102945147,
0.7378699183,
-0.501190722,
0.9428015947,
-0.4705318213,
-0.1078536958,
0.3832852542,
-0.0477932319,
0.3533608913,
-0.4564425945,
-0.4233148098,
0.6183536649,
-0.0536354072,
-0.3004025817,
-0.5327787995,
0.6207358837,
-0.6690810919,
-0.2021557391,
-0.3698411286,
-0.2551090419,
-0.3140253425,
0.1037197486,
0.5178619623,
0.7407977581,
-0.308057487,
0.0215253662,
1.0320489407,
-0.1804528385,
-0.0508254766,
1.1116811037,
0.3001614213,
-0.3473188877,
1.0376609564,
0.5653304458,
0.2875366211,
0.2335830629,
0.232472524,
-0.3949934244,
-0.6635460854,
-0.690854311,
0.3225928545,
-0.6732762456,
-0.2030127943,
-0.6319645047,
-0.3211297691,
-0.4232829511,
-0.318002224,
-0.2788396776,
-0.7926918864,
-0.1984008402,
-0.2234673947,
0.6674729586,
0.6982764006,
-0.4132934809,
0.7044302821,
-0.8985931873,
0.0532992259,
-0.1751618385,
0.4282340407,
-0.0574778579,
-0.8704806566,
-0.1558289528,
0.060919553,
0.153493762,
-0.6301535964,
0.48420766,
0.5284330249,
0.6004506946,
0.2779507041,
0.3099559546,
0.979475081,
-0.748000443,
0.5553640127,
0.185297057,
-1.013682127,
0.77227211,
-0.454996258,
0.2569892704,
0.5145443082,
0.1921595782,
-0.6662473679,
-0.2341208905,
-0.7610440254,
-0.8198900223,
0.7656108737,
-0.0144300004,
0.0828078911,
0.3065645099,
0.1384960711,
0.2492906749,
0.1532539874,
-0.2775723934,
-0.1470524669,
-0.1245533153,
-0.0604334325,
-0.2687633038,
-0.0701643154,
-0.2119859904,
-0.1719961464,
0.9618510008,
-0.0985189825,
0.3223235011,
0.1589677632,
-0.1581951082,
-0.2802790105,
0.261705935,
0.3887801468,
0.4255830348,
0.0364422239,
-0.1321646124,
0.3803608418,
-0.0434394442,
0.1668736339,
0.6915763617,
-0.4700152874,
0.3649676144,
0.3874991536,
1.0279848576,
0.4281569421,
-0.8213682771,
0.5575068593,
0.3799389899,
-0.153666079,
-0.5644237399,
0.0049465853,
0.0642471686,
0.0834430158,
0.436339587,
0.3087426126,
0.4508598149,
-0.234393388,
0.467959702,
0.0980845392,
-0.7752091885,
-0.4513212442,
0.371904999,
0.121593222,
-0.1773723513,
0.4858724773,
0.1195204854,
-0.5769794583,
0.372649461,
0.6017793417,
0.7641314268,
-0.3416612148,
0.2341733724,
0.2525290549,
0.1123878062,
-0.4036692977,
0.1510916501,
0.0302701201,
-0.73703897,
-0.3714777231,
-0.6429252625,
-0.2735431492,
-0.1026481837,
-1.0208605528,
0.176436916,
-0.0115512023,
-0.1422841549,
0.0502941012,
-0.1856601834,
-0.3531188667,
0.12071345,
0.0728604272,
1.2200006247,
-0.8980677724,
0.9428354502,
0.5722976923,
0.0529840365,
-0.3800415695,
0.098402366,
-0.0613193959,
-0.8037175536,
0.6783881783,
0.2433154285,
-0.6804868579,
0.065045163,
-0.3896081746,
-1.0344173908,
0.8349866867,
0.3832698166,
-0.4894559085,
-0.1613297313,
-0.0546743907,
0.6107755899,
-0.1413009763,
-0.4232060909,
0.6068542004,
0.4567176998,
0.3371910751,
-1.0461513996,
-0.336578697,
-0.1752253175,
0.095460929,
0.3139913976,
-0.5997511744,
0.3946732581,
-0.3378579915,
-0.372843951,
0.3903467655,
0.8450998664,
0.0332672559,
0.4821895361,
0.5387006998,
0.6985763907,
0.6065163016,
-0.3569491804,
0.9101011753,
-0.1525746286,
0.1474317163,
1.1772863865,
-0.6515458822,
1.0207602978,
0.0077528004,
-0.1569188088,
0.3399683237,
0.4803746343,
-0.0222827513,
0.8393908739,
0.327668488,
-0.4295861125,
-0.2533338964,
-0.3437677622,
-0.3492899835,
0.4557006061,
0.6374756098,
0.1356901377,
-0.2858498991,
0.1822974682,
0.1481184959,
0.3634893894,
-0.2768090367,
0.8156243563,
-0.0795561522,
-0.3622184396,
0.5865930915,
0.1556627154,
0.6810831428,
-0.8970707059,
0.0199602339,
-0.0260558706,
0.4421022236,
0.0002115591,
-0.4038996994,
0.4672834873,
0.0099317981,
-0.3467226028,
-0.1322102547,
0.8255644441,
-0.5491409898,
-0.6153533459,
0.5594223142,
0.505776763,
0.1721083075,
-0.0272773542,
-0.5811079741,
0.1661583334,
-0.0447646901,
0.1623049378,
0.2189161927,
0.5298182368,
0.1287574321,
0.7419567704,
0.4150613546,
0.2977697849,
0.1067042276,
0.1369370073,
0.9123117924,
-0.5486226678,
-0.4370410442,
-0.471526742,
0.402140975,
-0.2084056884,
-0.1643757373,
0.6198933125,
0.6402617097,
0.9894736409,
-0.1256025583,
1.0090225935,
0.0026691074,
1.239248991,
-0.599288106,
0.6998870969,
-0.3837192059,
-0.0180286355,
-0.1904876232,
-0.3232504725,
-0.2394815534,
0.778161943,
-0.1113224924,
-0.1572816372,
0.1355245411,
1.1128512621,
-0.0114025017,
-0.0604346506,
0.4392961264,
0.2945166826,
-0.1030448675,
0.2979222834,
0.9313832521,
-0.4200332761,
0.390857935,
-0.2493143678,
-0.351688534,
-0.061289154,
-0.6384449601,
-0.5093142986,
-0.6503102779,
-0.4331429601,
-0.2748512924,
0.5801246166,
0.6203477979,
0.8359531164,
-0.9346137047,
-0.4909775555,
0.1890935302,
-0.1998484284,
-0.4733721316,
-0.1707466841,
0.3611040115,
-0.0759946108,
-0.4630635381,
0.6606794596,
0.0142601458,
0.270626545,
0.1029224247,
-0.4049488604,
0.177577287,
0.0483238325,
0.5124430656,
0.2782095969,
-1.0093436241,
-0.1404628009,
0.0575915538,
0.2423250079,
-0.00141715,
0.838586092,
-0.6954118013,
0.2861248255,
0.0784128457,
0.4279051125,
0.4571348131,
-0.0382261835,
0.8672321439,
-0.685284555,
0.0671854615,
0.2576554418,
0.2606786489,
0.6170174479,
-0.0413521901,
0.6801359057,
0.2654699087,
-0.1424875855,
-0.9877455235,
0.253516376,
-0.8383041024,
-0.2868313193,
1.1214659214,
-0.2079967409,
0.177931115,
0.0056845774,
-0.1952724755,
0.0845966935,
-0.5506426096,
0.3809369802,
0.7841064334,
-0.2071397156,
-0.11528074,
-0.6213861704,
0.5546629429,
0.0375489779,
-0.4313785732,
0.413379401,
0.8777762651,
0.3307529688,
0.0884817913,
0.663793385,
-0.1486695707,
0.2731874883,
0.0319984406,
-0.0016588669,
-0.0128525123,
-0.5164150596,
-0.8279694915,
0.0776067674,
0.1346217692,
0.0087019252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10346v1 | Interventional Probing in High Dimensions: An NLI Case Study | 2023-04-20T14:34:31 | 2023-04-20T14:34:31 | Julia Rozanova, Marco Valentino, Lucas Cordeiro, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Probing strategies have been shown to detect the presence of various
linguistic features in large language models; in particular, semantic features
intermediate to the "natural logic" fragment of the Natural Language Inference
task (NLI). In the case of natural logic, the relation between the intermediate
features and the entailment label is explicitly known: as such, this provides a
ripe setting for interventional studies on the NLI models' representations,
allowing for stronger causal conjectures and a deeper critical analysis of
interventional probing methods. In this work, we carry out new and existing
representation-level interventions to investigate the effect of these semantic
features on NLI classification: we perform amnesic probing (which removes
features as directed by learned linear probes) and introduce the mnestic
probing variation (which forgets all dimensions except the probe-selected
ones). Furthermore, we delve into the limitations of these methods and outline
some pitfalls have been obscuring the effectivity of interventional probing
studies. | [
-0.8039170504,
-1.1036094427,
0.5813432932,
0.1739531904,
0.1817819178,
-0.2075074166,
-0.1044194475,
-0.4288377166,
0.5797522068,
0.7259751558,
-0.6087062955,
-0.3897161186,
-0.613515079,
0.2746532261,
-0.2829820812,
0.7817158699,
-0.0517080799,
0.1030078903,
-0.2247453779,
-0.3830927312,
-0.4430619478,
-0.5694564581,
-0.7791329026,
-0.2975939214,
0.8032659888,
0.1296344399,
0.4640074074,
0.6607299447,
0.7118661404,
0.3583090305,
-0.3201831579,
0.1611547023,
-0.3739947379,
-0.01610801,
-0.2214089483,
-0.7628617287,
-0.0716664493,
0.4357695282,
0.744376123,
1.1158173084,
0.1844337732,
-0.0462594293,
-0.11843808,
0.6922283173,
-0.8817385435,
-0.124851808,
-0.3573614061,
0.0450703166,
-0.1158642843,
-0.4029646814,
-0.4210205674,
-0.1627701074,
0.4151647389,
-0.4384278953,
0.3863561153,
0.1111062318,
0.810598731,
0.3555066884,
-0.97856462,
-0.449210465,
-1.0390251875,
1.0528035164,
-0.6511362195,
0.1355759799,
0.3374395072,
0.1905304193,
-0.0335884728,
-0.4718825221,
-0.5236613154,
-0.3811661303,
-0.4222755134,
0.0388619341,
-0.2714274526,
0.2110505104,
0.6095294952,
0.3566377461,
-0.3035877943,
0.1130007356,
-0.1568874121,
-0.2453027517,
0.6132742763,
0.4052805603,
0.1622661352,
-0.3483530283,
-0.3220683336,
-0.181959942,
-0.7396163344,
0.1166764498,
0.4321515858,
0.2040319294,
0.021197319,
0.5723024011,
-0.0929629505,
0.6266798973,
-0.2156344801,
0.2955979705,
0.1331155151,
-0.6219568253,
-0.0698466823,
0.1859840155,
0.6757053137,
0.0121204965,
0.1280837953,
0.1418566257,
-0.0937541947,
0.1165221706,
0.4280167818,
-0.5413247347,
0.012140993,
0.1647210717,
-0.3102608323,
-0.3936670721,
0.0800180882,
-0.4266077578,
-0.3302841783,
-0.516438663,
0.6649583578,
-0.5025781393,
-0.2763034999,
0.2611517012,
-0.2116710246,
0.516392827,
0.0594420284,
-0.7785786986,
0.4449611902,
0.7769560218,
0.5072229505,
0.1142246425,
-0.3798045516,
-0.5145189762,
0.095874846,
-0.3889835477,
0.6846884489,
-0.9282016754,
-0.3906048238,
0.1345535815,
0.0699702501,
-0.3622618318,
-0.6900526285,
0.5301567912,
-0.3276763558,
0.1903493106,
-0.6281113625,
-0.5925782323,
-0.508728981,
0.539196074,
-0.7202466726,
0.6986507773,
-0.0769295543,
-0.8864553571,
0.2676181197,
-0.9427574277,
-0.3916130364,
-0.4249414206,
-0.3027090728,
-0.3068929017,
0.3693537712,
0.2613516152,
0.2426223606,
-0.3200814724,
0.0681111589,
-0.2281775624,
-0.4124901295,
0.5288245082,
-0.712874651,
0.6554876566,
-0.4081524312,
-0.2997038066,
0.2614375353,
-0.7767106295,
-0.1721607149,
0.0334359892,
-0.1543435305,
-0.6767206192,
-0.0037003867,
-0.1744712293,
-0.2129053921,
0.0589806773,
-0.8518760204,
0.0011832346,
-0.7349963188,
0.2061264366,
0.3277587295,
0.5432212353,
0.3668007553,
-0.0766665936,
0.2661311328,
0.2892264128,
0.3386953473,
0.080306612,
-0.4792890847,
-1.1011112928,
-0.2115456015,
0.4596279562,
0.500372529,
-0.8177477121,
0.3372088373,
-0.1908887029,
-0.2173123956,
-0.6205738187,
-0.1933405101,
0.6779131889,
0.2616799474,
0.3200725615,
-0.1553926915,
-0.3246173561,
-1.276568532,
-0.3161767125,
-0.0537830256,
-0.3780241013,
0.4827782214,
0.6731756926,
-0.1882073879,
0.8384523392,
-0.5688450933,
-0.4036471546,
-0.0253528394,
0.57429564,
0.3405781984,
0.3244475126,
0.6376855969,
-0.8591399193,
-0.1405649334,
-0.0375798121,
-0.671395421,
-0.0224028882,
-0.1223628297,
-0.1772409379,
-0.1341045201,
0.6897364855,
-0.5565158725,
0.7549007535,
0.2212161124,
-0.3053702712,
0.3985733986,
-0.3547026813,
0.1996515244,
-0.713963449,
0.070899643,
0.0485966131,
0.3393765092,
-0.9652957916,
0.021917589,
0.2822434306,
0.0561171807,
-0.1796794087,
0.272795856,
-0.3257534206,
0.1657818109,
-0.2365919799,
-0.0028188245,
0.0785486549,
0.4694784582,
-0.1421512365,
0.5156766176,
0.4132697582,
-0.6903281808,
0.178354919,
0.1985158324,
0.1086132973,
0.601540029,
-0.674543798,
0.0038738947,
-0.1956374198,
-0.0919259563,
-0.9820839167,
-0.1223981455,
0.0618020073,
-0.5876562595,
0.2963383198,
-0.0118807862,
-0.3833236098,
-0.1026285738,
-0.5405129194,
0.423830688,
0.1695426404,
-0.4685066342,
0.8122757077,
0.1856652051,
0.2833655477,
-0.359656781,
-0.4758690596,
0.1517994553,
-0.4877316356,
-0.5416110754,
0.1857824177,
0.381455332,
-0.403799355,
-0.0381888486,
0.0597375259,
0.2097053677,
0.1430498958,
0.100043416,
0.1099970192,
-0.5399647355,
-0.003017049,
0.1190281659,
-0.3117335439,
0.551576674,
0.2049074322,
0.4381132126,
-0.1486985087,
-0.8067947626,
-0.3935230374,
0.7037923932,
0.5510666966,
-0.8260663748,
0.6204682589,
0.6719685197,
-0.4502420425,
0.0291268099,
-0.8001515269,
-0.3777514398,
-0.4851879179,
0.2321665734,
-0.3326545358,
-0.9225946069,
0.5788657069,
-0.1816222668,
-0.1993931085,
0.3917498589,
0.1786388457,
0.0191626083,
1.321716547,
0.5010211468,
0.0091892676,
0.1629447043,
-0.5297538042,
0.7747625113,
-1.3740471601,
-0.138893038,
-0.6559158564,
-0.5253634453,
-0.8759428859,
-0.3804290593,
0.8142337203,
-0.1083910763,
-0.0382954143,
-0.0002655565,
-0.1911617368,
0.3443740904,
0.6737859845,
0.2510946393,
-0.0349595509,
-0.2692967355,
-0.0490977876,
-0.3073508143,
-0.3492516577,
-0.2232726067,
0.8278790116,
0.4701069891,
0.496668607,
0.333155185,
0.7865540981,
-0.1817801148,
0.1487487853,
-1.2233943939,
0.6243587136,
-0.0265584588,
-0.5837730169,
-0.5685730577,
-0.318670541,
-1.0747294426,
0.2577703893,
-0.2157101631,
-0.6531413198,
0.7464109659,
-0.0780248493,
-0.325573355,
0.2073552907,
-0.7756928205,
0.5738947392,
-0.0107246758,
-0.4069473743,
-0.2641875446,
-0.4409915507,
0.1806543171,
0.1461132914,
-0.0808855146,
0.0822973847,
-0.1787332594,
0.5834994912,
-0.330183804,
1.1142042875,
-0.3379297256,
-0.0290475916,
0.0554091074,
0.3031609058,
0.3393149078,
0.1983982325,
0.1533325464,
-0.1281220317,
-0.0488034636,
-0.491743207,
-1.085391283,
0.6636610627,
-0.3436750472,
-0.842579782,
-0.3241601884,
-0.5062522292,
-0.5967095494,
-0.0426107608,
-0.1038566604,
0.7172625065,
-0.209004879,
0.3225533962,
1.038633585,
-0.274867028,
0.3261341453,
0.4075050652,
0.0645791739,
0.0580726564,
1.0280531645,
0.0273462143,
0.2729954422,
0.4728078544,
0.3918967545,
-0.1186087951,
-0.8699156642,
-0.0095812753,
0.6463055015,
-0.5157883763,
0.1517997086,
-0.5901964307,
-0.4037430584,
-0.2244464159,
0.0460234135,
-0.3598151505,
-0.0805028453,
-0.131006062,
0.0267179608,
0.4096373916,
0.790258646,
-0.0718429089,
-0.0789172724,
-0.6364756823,
0.0604888909,
0.4474128783,
0.1312297285,
0.0007971363,
-0.2802107334,
-0.0915603265,
0.0256890431,
-0.0510750264,
-0.6796526909,
0.3096571565,
0.1436342299,
0.5517333746,
0.7067243457,
0.0785439014,
0.6006992459,
-0.4452081919,
0.5904502273,
-0.0520244539,
-0.6885228157,
0.7316501141,
-0.4396965504,
0.3681596518,
0.5209515095,
0.8027285337,
-0.4708002508,
-0.5125804543,
-0.3407686055,
-0.8437308073,
0.3003781736,
0.2120006233,
0.301166296,
-0.3263283372,
0.5254340768,
-0.2309116274,
0.0092360871,
-0.2702835798,
-0.1280813515,
0.2539544106,
0.0196092576,
0.0167403482,
-0.5019354224,
-0.4623275697,
-0.3693728447,
0.3120689988,
-0.2755720317,
0.3279193938,
0.5073849559,
0.1764312387,
0.3698537648,
0.1382433027,
0.5115336776,
0.495031625,
-0.2330456674,
0.3031555712,
0.2344073653,
-0.4420686662,
-0.1355881989,
-0.0771925226,
-0.0397276655,
-0.1158022135,
0.795630455,
0.9040644169,
0.390671432,
-0.3924919963,
0.6427241564,
-0.0907639861,
-0.4472095668,
-0.365191102,
0.0355503261,
-0.0921775401,
0.301184386,
-0.0347389095,
0.0233368389,
0.6238898039,
-0.5773431063,
-0.0136626996,
0.5429842472,
-0.9562865496,
-0.3722496629,
0.1797059029,
-0.0500856042,
-0.3215197027,
0.7459864616,
-0.2134588361,
-0.5608630776,
0.5393614173,
0.2472157925,
0.690639019,
-0.3597303033,
0.2318618447,
0.3284670413,
0.4833928645,
0.508215487,
0.4648615122,
0.1017135531,
-0.8337727189,
-0.4804533124,
-0.4188424945,
-0.2242655903,
0.1411317438,
-1.0485540628,
-0.1006422639,
-0.445263505,
0.0756046996,
0.3241763115,
-0.1450553685,
-0.510212183,
0.0634290725,
-0.0558568649,
0.819724381,
-1.0017434359,
0.5647644997,
0.5240966082,
-0.2952056825,
-0.5335796475,
0.2415053844,
0.1525558233,
-0.6631066799,
0.7114244699,
0.1753012389,
-0.2418950945,
-0.088078618,
-0.5214775801,
-0.9461885095,
0.6003181338,
-0.0596772656,
0.1481286585,
-0.113153033,
0.5608512163,
0.674264729,
-0.2298380882,
0.2672005892,
0.8313219547,
0.6068205237,
-0.0207547247,
-0.8277773261,
0.2108771056,
-0.3371607065,
0.3074240386,
0.496987462,
-0.2431806177,
0.6508657336,
-0.0893983543,
-0.14326258,
-0.0317019969,
0.4939503968,
-0.0222034324,
0.2369081676,
0.6105955839,
0.488583833,
0.4355305135,
-0.323788017,
1.2524442673,
-0.0260980465,
0.1046416238,
0.5754545927,
-0.2349287719,
0.9006410241,
0.884298861,
-0.038249623,
0.2130239755,
0.4816177189,
0.0408849306,
0.4177473485,
0.5389920473,
-0.4545223415,
-0.1710963398,
-0.4966786802,
-0.0470162146,
0.7059850693,
0.8466442227,
0.025830185,
-0.1304892302,
0.2919986844,
-0.1158543155,
0.0632029772,
-0.0187938232,
0.8483403325,
-0.1101534367,
-0.3725188673,
0.5955243707,
-0.0595902279,
0.6152108908,
-0.7097133994,
-0.3002175689,
-0.2536303103,
0.0884497017,
0.0208922122,
-0.5794616938,
0.5101893544,
-0.5552811027,
0.0347134061,
0.0873219892,
0.4575114846,
-0.0510994606,
-0.3745969236,
0.6568010449,
0.3699991107,
-0.1016912609,
-0.18309699,
-0.2902882993,
-0.0380787998,
-0.0941446349,
-0.3981746137,
0.2209001034,
0.7502467036,
-0.1864404082,
0.5494947433,
0.5600363016,
0.0811494142,
0.0622584261,
0.3484235704,
0.8406822085,
-0.7255142331,
0.0272087343,
-0.557685554,
0.389662981,
-0.3205284774,
-0.3137501478,
0.7159827352,
0.5174735785,
0.8025816679,
0.0400633551,
0.3195106387,
0.3093928397,
0.5359321833,
-0.8465049863,
0.4415217638,
-0.4455061555,
0.1506865472,
0.0420304313,
-0.6587996483,
-0.4546073079,
0.3442369998,
-0.5793625116,
-0.1247951761,
1.0441240072,
1.0616436005,
-0.2241909653,
0.2462540567,
0.4361474216,
0.4039470553,
0.4025474489,
0.2996912301,
1.0275427103,
-0.3275493979,
0.0460702777,
-0.4462341666,
-0.4546747506,
-0.0042805066,
-0.4699935317,
-1.1422152519,
-0.6956931949,
-0.2206259519,
-0.0545397438,
-0.1837814897,
0.4683171809,
0.3172832131,
-0.8236211538,
-0.1664819866,
-0.0558454916,
-0.0354962647,
-0.1615793407,
-0.2518305779,
0.537550807,
-0.3313468099,
-0.817459166,
0.5351148248,
0.3752425611,
-0.1151932329,
-0.5661025643,
0.5060099959,
-0.4619899988,
0.3313592672,
0.6297866106,
0.0140567673,
-0.7034284472,
-0.5332358479,
0.162774235,
0.2678124011,
-0.065767549,
1.207810998,
-0.4985821545,
0.3474879265,
0.5347456336,
0.8703929186,
0.3651275635,
-0.4755020738,
0.6431916356,
-0.746943593,
0.15112032,
0.3078844547,
0.3374720812,
0.0546946228,
-0.377281487,
0.3804329038,
0.095652625,
-0.2504197657,
-0.7799184918,
0.5483101606,
-0.711240828,
-0.1023128554,
0.8992404938,
0.0817806497,
-0.4812317491,
-0.1923122406,
-0.2451505214,
0.0114454553,
0.2733821571,
0.674510777,
0.5890549421,
-0.4249438941,
0.1581047326,
-0.8854736686,
0.3552599251,
0.6427717805,
-0.5785351396,
-0.1532690078,
0.2707747221,
-0.1150320247,
0.7343904972,
0.1954027563,
-0.3281503022,
0.087886028,
0.0427994579,
-0.1962793469,
0.1665284187,
-0.3130975962,
-0.487931639,
-0.0787216425,
-0.0104445033,
-0.229043901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10327v2 | Towards a Benchmark for Scientific Understanding in Humans and Machines | 2023-04-20T14:05:53 | 2023-04-21T08:57:06 | Kristian Gonzalez Barman, Sascha Caron, Tom Claassen, Henk de Regt | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, hep-ph, physics.hist-ph | Scientific understanding is a fundamental goal of science, allowing us to
explain the world. There is currently no good way to measure the scientific
understanding of agents, whether these be humans or Artificial Intelligence
systems. Without a clear benchmark, it is challenging to evaluate and compare
different levels of and approaches to scientific understanding. In this
Roadmap, we propose a framework to create a benchmark for scientific
understanding, utilizing tools from philosophy of science. We adopt a
behavioral notion according to which genuine understanding should be recognized
as an ability to perform certain tasks. We extend this notion by considering a
set of questions that can gauge different levels of scientific understanding,
covering information retrieval, the capability to arrange information to
produce an explanation, and the ability to infer how things would be different
under different circumstances. The Scientific Understanding Benchmark (SUB),
which is formed by a set of these tests, allows for the evaluation and
comparison of different approaches. Benchmarking plays a crucial role in
establishing trust, ensuring quality control, and providing a basis for
performance evaluation. By aligning machine and human scientific understanding
we can improve their utility, ultimately advancing scientific understanding and
helping to discover new insights within machines. | [
-0.4191138148,
-0.2161091715,
0.6547928452,
0.3213174939,
-0.1534556597,
0.3003267348,
-0.0028736913,
-0.6323595643,
-0.1179083213,
0.0610362366,
-0.6545671225,
-0.2008324564,
-0.5657363534,
0.2719563842,
-0.1230387017,
0.7474492788,
-0.0153035847,
0.2648678124,
-0.8222934604,
-0.3761237264,
-0.2859488428,
-0.1436685175,
-0.6123690605,
-0.8529649973,
0.5656575561,
0.1172591597,
0.6217437387,
0.8626059294,
0.8715000153,
0.3214086294,
0.0017072542,
0.0610496923,
-0.3760679066,
0.0169934109,
-0.7438720465,
-0.6016991735,
-0.4088664055,
0.3713103235,
0.7937551141,
1.2783961296,
0.0774719939,
0.4592165053,
-0.1029886603,
0.6446794271,
-0.6768948436,
0.3152289093,
-0.3517978787,
0.4731017649,
0.1736432463,
-0.1388688087,
-0.1266572028,
-0.3481437266,
-0.0823201388,
-1.0235284567,
0.3504100144,
0.159282729,
0.8135455847,
0.4600394964,
-0.4096651971,
0.1188370138,
-0.5327988863,
0.6676528454,
-0.3517066836,
0.5992806554,
0.261249274,
0.6075381041,
-0.3110757172,
-0.7524667978,
-0.4998798668,
-0.2607331872,
0.0379944555,
0.2798175812,
-0.0613811649,
-0.1195966825,
0.3259480298,
0.1059515998,
-0.7202147245,
-0.202934444,
-0.435328573,
-0.3460045159,
0.6297944188,
0.3081482649,
0.0194402952,
0.3328404129,
-0.3833183348,
-0.2618673146,
-0.4563912153,
0.0946484581,
-0.0495579652,
-0.0100953486,
0.3076895475,
0.2976227701,
-0.4002017379,
0.3906209767,
-0.0078897225,
0.0085446443,
0.2027423084,
-0.6961750984,
-0.1947083622,
-0.0339748077,
0.3748656809,
0.5067910552,
-0.0316797346,
-0.4539040625,
-0.0282016285,
0.5759473443,
0.5385446548,
-0.9372307062,
-0.1030398607,
-0.1423757225,
-0.520352602,
-0.2189150453,
0.1889996976,
-0.6291428208,
-0.5752896667,
-0.5399383903,
0.3706614971,
-0.4008103907,
-0.2635155916,
0.0276786815,
-0.3532392979,
0.1895127892,
0.4075117111,
-0.6488974094,
0.6893053055,
1.1320871115,
0.8564471602,
0.0714712217,
-0.6353102326,
-0.3242313266,
0.2842925191,
-0.407903254,
0.7448773384,
-0.3641529381,
-0.4917182028,
-0.7159295678,
-0.1598509252,
-0.0860420465,
-0.6593161821,
0.4245359302,
-0.4784210622,
-0.0487552471,
-0.572049737,
-0.5625649691,
-0.541043222,
0.230138585,
-0.3785550594,
0.8163102269,
0.0068924665,
-0.4370747805,
0.7921140194,
-0.9910064936,
-0.3965995908,
0.2720473409,
-0.0182691086,
-0.116504468,
0.1701504141,
-0.1259380132,
0.108341217,
-0.4903666675,
0.4145537317,
-0.5074480772,
-0.406417042,
0.3298132122,
-0.0775067881,
0.5364224315,
0.3512949646,
-0.2904359698,
0.2016975731,
-0.6029747128,
0.2926958501,
-0.0320763253,
0.2703579664,
-0.2913663089,
0.2413150966,
-0.3340240121,
0.1591455787,
0.5118365288,
-0.4951603115,
0.0390672721,
-0.158244431,
0.6173541546,
0.7861669064,
-0.0475210138,
0.4261138141,
-0.4931503236,
0.3124679029,
-0.1315230876,
0.3083018661,
0.1426320523,
-0.2598156333,
-0.2620089054,
-0.2742344439,
0.274173975,
0.4489367902,
0.0362905115,
0.5123324394,
-0.2139507085,
-0.6394101977,
-0.7159698606,
0.1454813182,
0.6543042064,
0.9458394051,
0.4060395062,
-0.7402870655,
-0.4979586899,
-0.8583141565,
-0.5713956952,
-0.4122098684,
-0.3834438026,
0.3719973266,
0.8365255594,
-0.2063040286,
1.0203052759,
-0.2600351572,
0.2292405367,
0.2314837873,
0.5262556672,
0.119819656,
0.5024235249,
0.1529059112,
-0.9654803872,
-0.0675818771,
0.2684456706,
-1.2085617781,
-0.0333628841,
0.2195027918,
-0.3789342642,
-0.437995404,
0.4468774796,
-0.4702534378,
0.425450027,
-0.1814667732,
-0.5291820168,
0.575435698,
-0.2073173672,
0.4354244769,
-0.4937497377,
0.4915114343,
0.1047939062,
-0.0785644874,
-0.4974924922,
0.0454138406,
0.1135897264,
-0.0514094271,
-0.3335137069,
0.4855328798,
-0.0867591798,
-0.5476462841,
-0.1767934114,
0.1261630356,
0.393089205,
0.0219210498,
0.031658709,
0.8192945123,
0.26621297,
-0.5659480691,
0.3646883965,
0.1641813219,
-0.3509193361,
0.9826468825,
-1.0765249729,
0.0604325384,
-0.2394551039,
0.1738026738,
-0.4802759588,
-0.0464327559,
0.2714784443,
-0.6226173639,
-0.1006209627,
0.0726812109,
-0.4498395324,
-0.4034577608,
0.0586064123,
0.3007397652,
0.5189325809,
-0.2909546793,
0.4911981821,
0.0145678436,
0.0529861525,
-0.4904559553,
-0.3598788977,
-0.0155107845,
-0.2670758367,
-0.8578991294,
0.5900562406,
-0.1199384481,
-0.6352651119,
0.2617514729,
-0.6127393842,
-0.0218662098,
0.2799410224,
0.3434598744,
0.1354114413,
-0.4304238856,
0.14485313,
-0.0581610613,
-0.4854358137,
0.5238308907,
-0.3308686018,
0.2007188201,
-0.4247909188,
-0.4761852026,
-0.7239983678,
0.1763869375,
0.6844974756,
-0.2974648774,
0.5812913179,
0.6155989766,
-0.4551230967,
0.1266994029,
-0.2551705539,
-0.5249975324,
-0.4781375229,
0.4065750837,
-0.622228086,
-0.3460246027,
0.4909594059,
-0.5806850195,
-0.0551132038,
0.5491346717,
0.2657490969,
-0.4552145898,
1.1994235516,
0.705152452,
0.082343258,
0.0842120349,
0.0908672363,
-0.0320178643,
-0.8477045298,
-0.5382996798,
-0.8060743809,
-0.2832102478,
-0.2891351879,
-0.4358908832,
0.3857651651,
0.3404607475,
-0.5927152038,
0.2884468734,
-0.6882355809,
0.3924283385,
0.5254622102,
0.0477433428,
0.2785767317,
-0.3581445217,
-0.2305154651,
0.063945666,
-0.4778579175,
-0.9555164576,
0.8026320338,
0.2411602139,
0.5346275568,
-0.2188954502,
0.337071687,
0.5006638765,
0.2924869061,
-0.4625609517,
0.6091338992,
0.3131627738,
-0.7110573649,
-0.3464430273,
-0.4640895724,
-0.9960400462,
0.6179682016,
0.050684426,
-0.5903261304,
0.0865695328,
0.0114851147,
-0.153368637,
0.0134075526,
-0.711760819,
1.255690217,
-0.2970968783,
-0.324218452,
-0.7774237394,
-0.951158762,
0.1476597935,
0.2714189887,
0.2257148772,
-0.426966846,
-0.2443936467,
0.9367363453,
-0.3052788079,
0.6349056363,
-0.2336151302,
0.4540894926,
-0.0306385495,
-0.0201925803,
0.0164524671,
0.1593728364,
-0.3651342988,
0.1175575107,
0.5577072501,
-0.8457534313,
-0.8168908358,
0.3847966492,
-0.9655629396,
-0.4140790403,
-0.5832535625,
-0.6437581778,
-0.2337537259,
0.1473888308,
-0.0742129907,
0.0018668242,
-0.4771573544,
0.0524076186,
0.883395493,
0.1988897026,
-0.0155109148,
0.82336694,
0.1565970778,
-0.0861312076,
0.9096261859,
-0.3621279597,
0.0818859339,
0.364620626,
0.2144320011,
-0.4288555682,
-0.4994026423,
-0.2513953745,
0.1136144474,
-0.7310315371,
0.0031508864,
-0.2403629571,
0.0721708089,
-0.2951899767,
-0.2929870188,
-0.1736262441,
-0.1268140376,
-0.3402646184,
0.0860503465,
0.2357510179,
0.9020838737,
-0.3551166058,
-0.145045206,
-0.5196750164,
0.5058332086,
0.3458841741,
0.1834246814,
0.0285669994,
-0.4394055009,
-0.2442350835,
0.2452573925,
-0.4496396184,
-0.4328965247,
0.138136521,
0.1580283344,
0.8571829796,
0.4923944473,
-0.0903601721,
0.9053088427,
-0.4362816513,
0.4822112024,
0.1077948883,
-1.2195655107,
0.8838863969,
0.0332820341,
0.0134777548,
0.8682493567,
0.5796608925,
-0.6399142742,
-0.1125472635,
-0.6379966736,
-0.364126116,
0.3904635906,
0.0172390174,
-0.4656695724,
0.4496843815,
0.5207762122,
0.3598929942,
0.3590946496,
-0.2008163482,
0.2050560117,
-0.4155074358,
-0.1907610595,
-0.3755102754,
0.6702552438,
-0.5449569225,
-0.4645934701,
0.5316274166,
-0.1683854163,
0.2839330733,
0.2392233461,
-0.2669886649,
-0.2689304948,
0.0927207842,
0.4895646572,
1.2005710602,
-0.212109983,
0.267611593,
0.1235810742,
-0.5490614772,
0.1590027511,
0.1562955678,
-0.0051574917,
-0.5620240569,
0.5828397274,
0.4619693756,
-0.021411147,
-0.7939758301,
-0.0423265249,
0.0357748531,
-0.2034787983,
0.2168184221,
0.3590872586,
-0.0844223574,
0.421143204,
0.4737927318,
0.343324542,
0.2069606334,
-0.7529184222,
0.3335484266,
0.435983628,
-0.4329086244,
-0.5176202059,
0.735255599,
0.009341225,
-0.3493958712,
0.6474947929,
-0.31805861,
-0.5531928539,
1.1185427904,
0.3441664875,
0.4298350215,
-0.0034709447,
0.248507008,
0.1614594907,
0.3813841045,
0.1713546813,
0.3614300489,
-0.374900192,
-0.7142466307,
-0.3422253728,
-0.5297118425,
-0.9654127955,
-0.2931412458,
-0.9095103145,
-0.2038252503,
-0.579369843,
0.0179333165,
0.5657013059,
0.5566052794,
-0.6750187874,
0.3698758185,
-0.2521356344,
1.0325500965,
-0.9139456153,
0.5907579064,
0.7819100022,
-0.4785569608,
-0.4144791067,
-0.3586835265,
-0.0162283964,
-0.9967059493,
0.7710860372,
0.2378662825,
-0.3510849476,
-0.329608351,
-0.6102775335,
-0.6523616314,
1.2666488886,
0.1677279472,
-0.4113484621,
0.4454056621,
-0.1301856339,
0.8922331333,
-0.4214284718,
0.3528358936,
0.6832206845,
0.942538023,
0.1935647279,
-0.8594098091,
0.2907003462,
-0.5558228493,
-0.1940841079,
0.2162613869,
-0.4838220477,
0.6452380419,
-0.270350188,
-0.0185694396,
0.1036571935,
0.742816627,
0.3769241869,
1.1231722832,
0.4510435462,
0.5452190638,
1.0171092749,
-0.1532105654,
0.660225749,
-0.1743949056,
0.0271794125,
0.7317070961,
-0.5643799305,
0.4892238379,
0.463357091,
-0.5852847695,
0.5422341824,
0.8921224475,
-0.1566271186,
0.5090839863,
0.5036590695,
-0.3432563245,
-0.3565176725,
-0.3071527481,
-0.6969360709,
0.2644231021,
0.6328430772,
-0.1870413423,
0.0559471473,
-0.0791125,
-0.3264381289,
0.2409086078,
-0.4681130946,
0.746193409,
-0.0922826603,
-0.7320996523,
0.4092559218,
-0.1852036119,
0.1982930452,
-0.4851376414,
-0.000749002,
0.0724495277,
0.1653458029,
-0.1118098646,
-0.8351191878,
0.3696945608,
-0.2043906897,
-0.4993105829,
-0.3521251678,
0.5662267208,
0.1418137401,
-0.254219085,
0.1198886707,
0.3461852074,
0.495057255,
0.1067402288,
-0.8047209978,
0.0974212438,
-0.3733745515,
0.0919612721,
0.4235416353,
0.5144585371,
-0.0097965766,
0.8685089946,
0.6490110755,
-0.0795630515,
-0.1723890752,
-0.0627120957,
0.7599617243,
-0.7674763799,
-0.3935449719,
-0.6885765791,
0.0554482043,
-0.2781240344,
-0.3091710508,
0.5150948167,
0.4489257634,
0.7147498727,
0.1614430994,
0.76463449,
-0.1762144566,
0.4612030983,
-0.0543973744,
0.5767064691,
-0.6174556613,
-0.0981405154,
-0.0896595418,
-0.7775400281,
-0.1857371181,
0.8089338541,
-0.2949595749,
0.0066905022,
0.6949326992,
0.4645919502,
-0.0299070496,
0.3749869466,
0.0984354913,
0.2130307704,
0.2051581293,
0.4679013491,
0.8707383275,
-0.0784417391,
0.2291930169,
-0.2604076266,
-0.5228763223,
-0.0599965751,
-1.0484907627,
-0.7444140315,
-0.4612519741,
-0.2582618892,
-0.1386657208,
0.3078173399,
0.6531813145,
1.0361307859,
-0.7064392567,
-0.3068862259,
-0.4030259252,
0.4364422858,
-0.8930819631,
-0.1528339684,
0.1973955035,
-0.2798189819,
-0.4443331063,
0.6289921403,
0.5901960135,
-0.1647870541,
-0.370631963,
-0.3173623681,
0.0608309694,
0.1357324272,
0.4390746653,
0.8127475977,
-0.6799294353,
-0.2032809258,
0.1528834999,
0.1082835793,
-0.011989437,
0.8211912513,
-0.9842364788,
0.3615679443,
0.3792657852,
0.5934603214,
0.6900327802,
-0.0047433646,
0.659394145,
-0.144130379,
0.0187901724,
0.6669034362,
0.063062951,
0.208445996,
-0.3101382554,
0.7811143398,
0.3169875443,
-0.7338548303,
-1.016379714,
0.2499446422,
-0.8846069574,
-0.2966505885,
0.2206950933,
-0.2824304104,
-0.2751486301,
-0.2216860056,
0.147302866,
0.3468831778,
-0.2764086723,
0.9276784062,
0.5226023793,
-0.5918051004,
0.0950191021,
-0.3994394541,
0.1559294164,
0.6627227664,
-0.9756756425,
-0.1142008826,
0.0915041491,
0.2129021138,
0.244362399,
0.221206516,
0.0058646905,
0.5769066811,
0.2568843365,
0.0264143459,
0.0550174117,
-0.4885807335,
0.0976039693,
0.1735729575,
-0.1798522472,
-0.2809100747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11061v1 | CEIL: A General Classification-Enhanced Iterative Learning Framework for Text Clustering | 2023-04-20T14:04:31 | 2023-04-20T14:04:31 | Mingjun Zhao, Mengzhen Wang, Yinglong Ma, Di Niu, Haijiang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text clustering, as one of the most fundamental challenges in unsupervised
learning, aims at grouping semantically similar text segments without relying
on human annotations. With the rapid development of deep learning, deep
clustering has achieved significant advantages over traditional clustering
methods. Despite the effectiveness, most existing deep text clustering methods
rely heavily on representations pre-trained in general domains, which may not
be the most suitable solution for clustering in specific target domains. To
address this issue, we propose CEIL, a novel Classification-Enhanced Iterative
Learning framework for short text clustering, which aims at generally promoting
the clustering performance by introducing a classification objective to
iteratively improve feature representations. In each iteration, we first adopt
a language model to retrieve the initial text representations, from which the
clustering results are collected using our proposed Category Disentangled
Contrastive Clustering (CDCC) algorithm. After strict data filtering and
aggregation processes, samples with clean category labels are retrieved, which
serve as supervision information to update the language model with the
classification objective via a prompt learning approach. Finally, the updated
language model with improved representation ability is used to enhance
clustering in the next iteration. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the
CEIL framework significantly improves the clustering performance over
iterations, and is generally effective on various clustering algorithms.
Moreover, by incorporating CEIL on CDCC, we achieve the state-of-the-art
clustering performance on a wide range of short text clustering benchmarks
outperforming other strong baseline methods. | [
-0.0530935638,
-0.350573957,
0.7255105972,
0.1688007861,
-0.6054995656,
0.4531565011,
-0.5377972722,
-0.3011521697,
0.114141047,
-0.0763716474,
-0.3466698527,
-1.2269742489,
-0.8848967552,
-0.0088190585,
-0.6844494939,
0.9358272552,
0.3194082975,
-0.1910683662,
-0.408266902,
-0.2419623137,
0.057346493,
-0.3224970996,
-0.6790699959,
-0.1950645745,
0.7017530799,
0.7167111635,
0.2699950337,
0.3400444686,
0.3091175556,
0.3720775247,
-0.193344444,
0.0304197967,
-0.4065049291,
-0.2300671488,
-0.2966454327,
-0.1200790629,
-0.0807573497,
-0.2931476533,
0.7923120856,
0.8733746409,
-0.2012451589,
-0.1977929771,
0.5709699988,
0.8202340007,
-0.7212183475,
-0.3288076818,
-0.6414070129,
-0.393849194,
-0.3806524277,
-0.0090911379,
-0.3172112107,
-0.3377885818,
0.1832869649,
-0.5241580606,
0.5125798583,
-0.0316427387,
0.6646439433,
0.1272204816,
-0.6199038029,
-0.6217867136,
-0.3774887621,
0.9684483409,
-0.4654260874,
0.2832868099,
0.0844300613,
0.2300334126,
0.2289382517,
-1.0524060726,
-0.4327071607,
-0.0013019743,
-0.2916761339,
0.0065548494,
0.3652010262,
0.0540313646,
-0.2737694383,
0.6091938615,
-0.6438319683,
0.4265806675,
-0.290186137,
0.0573099181,
0.3587747216,
-0.0120550059,
0.1039498895,
0.3052755296,
-0.3631646335,
-0.1742201298,
-0.5128795505,
0.1494945586,
0.0749351606,
0.1838677078,
-0.1461360604,
0.0189481135,
-0.2764315605,
0.289719224,
0.079696089,
0.0640653223,
0.3611423969,
0.0917546153,
-0.0974030569,
0.2760777473,
0.6752091646,
0.4202229679,
-0.2532225549,
-0.2823642492,
0.2119954824,
0.4275921881,
-0.0124781635,
-1.1592392921,
-0.3263370097,
0.1927442551,
-0.3098823726,
-0.6821397543,
0.2611995339,
-0.9758123159,
-0.4727143347,
-0.1344149113,
0.024398705,
-0.0967777744,
-0.0687464029,
0.0799706429,
0.1695533097,
-0.0315125212,
0.1640857309,
-0.9498211741,
0.5063918829,
0.4751256704,
0.6270645857,
-0.8023136258,
-0.3358711898,
-0.5586056709,
0.0459004678,
-0.1355909705,
0.8816885352,
-0.9536037445,
-0.6180166006,
0.0015334166,
0.3389000297,
-0.2022537738,
-0.2557600141,
0.7543768883,
-0.5605755448,
0.1508203298,
-0.1227217615,
-0.5976794958,
-0.113091372,
0.28832075,
-0.5848779082,
1.0806523561,
-0.1182928234,
-0.8892194629,
0.4339289367,
-0.5444759727,
-0.5017179847,
-0.071206592,
-0.3183458745,
-0.691356957,
0.0733894333,
0.4560571015,
0.6042029858,
-0.6083168983,
0.1497868598,
-0.3043180406,
-0.5494614244,
0.0073736398,
-0.1613161713,
0.4623483717,
0.1537648737,
-0.4535419941,
0.011105191,
-0.8066411614,
0.1373755783,
-0.0623608045,
-0.1851065606,
-0.5260164142,
-0.0179125872,
0.0744706914,
-0.1294927448,
0.1876248568,
-0.596683383,
-0.021937307,
-0.5419646502,
0.2083469331,
0.6143174171,
0.1486016661,
1.1191511154,
-0.0362856276,
-0.033578828,
0.2235996872,
-0.0938668996,
-0.2958292663,
-0.2722322047,
-0.7827747464,
-0.319896996,
0.6820471287,
0.3596440256,
-0.6338806748,
0.4214475155,
-0.1005774513,
-0.4095594883,
-0.4484160841,
0.2068102807,
0.2181675285,
0.4170378745,
0.4214523435,
0.029963607,
-0.376942873,
-0.6679366827,
-0.0798904896,
0.1268700063,
0.0328854881,
-0.0473060943,
0.4331902564,
-0.7768806219,
0.5964562893,
-0.4842188954,
-0.4899641573,
-0.1141203642,
0.4601171315,
0.1343142688,
0.5203583837,
0.4531647563,
-1.0976213217,
-0.8763335943,
0.4215669632,
-0.4182150662,
-0.0207504295,
0.042334538,
0.1648657769,
0.1059110388,
0.5944392085,
0.0035862662,
0.4898851216,
0.4987082183,
-0.2820926905,
0.1448303908,
-0.2443375289,
0.5515334606,
-1.0951770544,
0.218309164,
-0.0344597884,
-0.0799827129,
-0.3807381988,
-0.1846466064,
0.3478873372,
0.0093788337,
-0.4082117677,
0.545455575,
-0.4745114446,
0.4224069417,
-0.5715588927,
0.4698003232,
0.0377707519,
0.4450443089,
0.0060134837,
0.5495229959,
0.9029198885,
-1.0644481182,
-0.0537510514,
-0.0750120431,
-0.2691518664,
0.5500347018,
-0.5021719337,
0.1503923386,
-0.1583245993,
-0.1400334686,
-0.7222042084,
-0.1035495326,
-0.1713754088,
-0.4813297689,
0.3588258624,
0.2442955226,
-0.3286528289,
-0.3813723624,
-0.5045461059,
0.5805609226,
0.7076585889,
-0.9667494297,
0.4791690111,
0.1663561463,
0.0156849101,
-0.5001990199,
-0.4445007443,
-0.1139436439,
-0.3905231953,
-0.3509500623,
1.0454901457,
-0.2844373882,
-0.0133582335,
0.1530832052,
-0.1564313024,
-0.301535815,
0.201361686,
0.097605437,
-0.295973599,
0.2136904001,
0.4292050302,
0.483407408,
-0.4423615038,
-0.3930327296,
-0.2601437569,
0.1990037858,
-0.3047757149,
-0.4350907803,
-0.3831669688,
0.5677812099,
0.1724164337,
-0.1111015454,
0.4904851615,
0.6228189468,
-0.4967156649,
-0.5632246137,
-0.2499471903,
-0.1028253138,
-0.5521447659,
0.2510819733,
-0.1914941221,
-1.4504821301,
0.2922405005,
-0.6965416074,
-0.0367415361,
0.6313471198,
0.3471388519,
-0.4430588186,
0.8899911642,
1.2098417282,
-0.2809729874,
0.0853322148,
-0.1394420713,
0.1701925248,
-0.3653270304,
-0.3021319211,
-0.8773466945,
-0.2289328128,
-0.5621679425,
-0.4640627801,
0.0437478274,
0.2591933012,
-0.082636416,
0.0760504752,
-0.787324667,
0.8828698397,
0.1537060738,
0.1187089607,
0.4235056639,
0.1608248502,
-0.3571091592,
-0.2236670703,
-0.4249772131,
-0.3455434442,
0.6906024218,
0.1590181291,
0.5888624787,
-0.1953320652,
0.9855829477,
0.6520604491,
0.391233176,
-0.3660331368,
0.3395531774,
-0.5776306391,
-0.0640147477,
-0.0685332641,
-0.036454428,
-0.7379288077,
0.0701624006,
-0.0067855278,
-1.0105090141,
0.4515861273,
0.0837949142,
-0.110690698,
0.2106388509,
-0.5517104864,
0.6667569876,
-0.0749238282,
-0.2936601937,
-0.4271426201,
-0.4647730887,
0.0193230454,
-0.0920321196,
0.225594908,
0.175688073,
-0.0722156614,
0.8150014877,
-0.3381049335,
1.0395317078,
-0.1603607833,
0.0111757163,
0.577123642,
-0.3376936316,
0.6311671734,
0.3626884818,
-0.0825597644,
-0.0628780127,
-0.0862197652,
-0.564699471,
-0.4771772325,
1.2068504095,
-0.3741010129,
-0.3618299663,
-0.4111037254,
0.2343890965,
-0.0878047422,
0.167008549,
0.5765012503,
0.306027025,
-0.6436269879,
0.4834396839,
0.7884283662,
-0.039615307,
0.7180125117,
0.4053134918,
-0.1064142436,
-0.5558792949,
1.0792320967,
-0.4682771564,
-0.2158803046,
0.6902908087,
-0.0877621323,
-0.4737301767,
-0.5400403738,
-0.1083774567,
0.1532023698,
-0.9126357436,
-0.0708957836,
-0.771715641,
-0.0507496707,
-0.210164547,
-0.7262174487,
-0.3890239894,
-0.0901964605,
-0.4798287153,
-0.0852886885,
0.1028123423,
0.6275823712,
0.0591802523,
0.7054578662,
-0.7487415671,
0.1675951928,
0.396366179,
0.4164864421,
-0.1224731803,
-0.1416121274,
-0.468362242,
-0.2410162687,
-0.2650955319,
-0.6163930297,
0.0679461882,
0.4586239457,
0.4587465227,
0.3902022839,
0.2007663846,
0.461827457,
-0.4323412776,
0.7839075923,
0.4689158201,
-0.8795418739,
0.4051689506,
-0.0693519488,
0.3754323423,
0.9754095674,
0.412904501,
-0.3314253688,
-0.0722956434,
-0.5684242845,
-0.7989280224,
0.2157842219,
0.3592808843,
-0.1055974588,
-0.1692847013,
0.1779609621,
0.2303551883,
0.2076966316,
-0.7276675105,
-0.13190943,
0.1088544428,
-0.504805088,
-0.1601229012,
-0.4170092642,
0.1515510827,
-0.2868848145,
0.7441837788,
-0.426793009,
0.1812207401,
0.2535274029,
-0.4599830806,
0.3126027286,
0.596996963,
0.2518258393,
0.4225572944,
0.0908503085,
0.1131041348,
0.4054515362,
-0.384695977,
0.1762606502,
0.257510066,
0.1113629639,
0.0797856301,
0.046537254,
0.3577785194,
0.3664571643,
-0.5088085532,
0.7417252064,
-0.1738212705,
-0.3886415362,
-0.1002151519,
-0.1191661507,
0.1745590866,
0.2661746144,
0.5632494092,
-0.0490762778,
0.4639310837,
-0.0625286251,
0.4119820297,
0.0115164528,
-0.5302706957,
-0.2220643908,
0.4608818293,
0.4894185364,
0.0379666649,
0.1344660968,
-0.4506110549,
-0.5924862027,
0.6989302635,
0.425470978,
1.1017104387,
-0.1988268048,
0.515063405,
0.4261333942,
0.2070096582,
-0.0917779505,
-0.1088544354,
-0.4877833128,
-0.2249230593,
-0.4359058738,
-0.764465034,
-0.2857428491,
-0.1820871681,
-0.3138479888,
0.3614091873,
-0.2123828381,
0.2584364116,
-0.4311778545,
0.0922804102,
-0.6842008233,
0.5232884288,
-0.0742310211,
0.815598011,
-0.8421168327,
1.0437817574,
0.7703322768,
0.3108575344,
-0.1366990209,
0.2319592088,
-0.1865763515,
-0.0936936587,
0.2356079072,
0.7006046176,
-0.2401554883,
0.2852258384,
-0.55465132,
-0.5371342301,
1.3358556032,
-0.173892796,
-0.9478670955,
0.0482650474,
0.2339908034,
0.461719662,
-0.7659601569,
-0.143988803,
0.5726129413,
0.2458332926,
0.1846455336,
-0.3807699382,
0.026152065,
-0.3272569478,
0.1365869194,
0.1976734549,
-0.4961678386,
0.4187089503,
-0.2656908333,
-0.492470026,
0.2504888177,
0.8613678217,
0.1188594028,
0.8923093677,
0.5441039801,
0.7273119092,
1.1521149874,
-0.1008213535,
0.6374238133,
-0.0329194628,
0.4372528195,
1.2435870171,
-0.3162604272,
0.5074638724,
0.3093978465,
0.1516037732,
0.785185039,
0.60807091,
0.2557296157,
1.0422114134,
-0.0766647682,
-0.6727404594,
-0.239229694,
0.0837263018,
-0.3434715569,
-0.054790277,
0.5106907487,
-0.4394087493,
-0.6845991015,
0.4439281225,
-0.2143864036,
0.7008718848,
-0.3716444075,
0.7829745412,
0.2241424769,
-0.2759685814,
0.2900250554,
0.2319566905,
0.9471695423,
-0.3307062685,
-0.0989252254,
-0.0143111069,
0.4066751599,
-0.1444322765,
-0.3318648934,
0.2005677372,
0.0107374564,
-0.2783516049,
0.0130550126,
1.0795551538,
-0.4459137321,
-0.4170547128,
0.4783284366,
0.0812384784,
-0.1878344566,
-0.1417545378,
-0.6924458146,
0.0695187077,
0.1974678785,
0.0604413114,
0.3298886716,
0.6139500737,
-0.1174327061,
0.2904016674,
0.2750601768,
-0.5056961775,
-0.3127909899,
0.0877124816,
1.2087572813,
-0.7148965597,
-0.8766412735,
-0.8464276195,
1.0731489658,
-0.5759004354,
-0.1164714471,
0.3567821085,
0.3993271887,
0.6531077027,
0.0718053877,
0.7026682496,
-0.1522942632,
0.6817427874,
-0.5336831212,
0.6053525805,
-0.6271314025,
0.4309244752,
-0.1653894186,
-1.0729153156,
-0.3473649919,
0.1266905069,
-0.2164092958,
0.053915903,
1.3905180693,
0.7820932269,
-0.069425866,
0.0289014634,
0.460056603,
-0.0224911403,
0.3160462976,
0.5172528028,
0.5911671519,
-0.5366764665,
0.5946202278,
-0.4092465341,
-0.397313118,
0.0183187909,
-1.0541096926,
-1.2540400028,
-0.9647017121,
-0.512975812,
0.1236852482,
0.2449044734,
0.5952976942,
0.5617880225,
-0.9428567886,
0.2222510576,
-0.354847163,
0.1521721035,
0.0040741232,
-0.1923514158,
0.6518629789,
-0.5872403979,
-0.8798711896,
0.5204621553,
0.1671448797,
-0.0696255565,
0.2913797498,
-0.2291826159,
-0.1110543534,
-0.2894364297,
0.6174668074,
0.3323411345,
-0.2158855051,
0.055810038,
-0.0718623325,
-0.2835831344,
-0.0471272543,
0.803860724,
-0.9070610404,
0.0747980624,
0.1660099328,
1.0181702375,
0.6662406921,
-0.0872312114,
0.0816920996,
-1.0120073557,
0.2787976861,
0.1564757228,
0.1061067507,
0.3511056006,
-0.5038776994,
0.2246625423,
0.1469872445,
-0.6481625438,
-0.4403378069,
-0.0423163772,
-0.9289935231,
-0.4945089519,
0.8527393937,
0.0370938554,
-0.3801914155,
0.110214971,
-0.3146145344,
-0.1249246299,
-0.4902031124,
0.661323607,
0.3443543315,
0.4602048397,
-0.3555276096,
0.1248408929,
0.764991641,
0.3885359466,
-0.8792299032,
-0.295709312,
0.2854485512,
0.0832499117,
0.0625445768,
0.681327045,
-0.2253578454,
0.3540833294,
-0.334280163,
-0.0871166363,
0.3159767687,
-0.7032955289,
-0.3340227902,
0.5537562966,
0.0895839557,
-0.2318545729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10321v1 | DropDim: A Regularization Method for Transformer Networks | 2023-04-20T13:54:18 | 2023-04-20T13:54:18 | Hao Zhang, Dan Qu, Keji Shao, Xukui Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We introduceDropDim, a structured dropout method designed for regularizing
the self-attention mechanism, which is a key component of the transformer. In
contrast to the general dropout method, which randomly drops neurons, DropDim
drops part of the embedding dimensions. In this way, the semantic information
can be completely discarded. Thus, the excessive coadapting between different
embedding dimensions can be broken, and the self-attention is forced to encode
meaningful featureswith a certain number of embedding dimensions erased.
Experiments on a wide range of tasks executed on the MUST-C English-Germany
dataset show that DropDim can effectively improve model performance, reduce
over-fitting, and show complementary effects with other regularization methods.
When combined with label smoothing, the WER can be reduced from 19.1% to 15.1%
on the ASR task, and the BLEU value can be increased from26.90 to 28.38 on the
MT task. On the ST task, the model can reach a BLEU score of 22.99, an increase
by 1.86 BLEU points compared to the strong baseline. | [
-0.8231253624,
-0.5290875435,
-0.0462650433,
0.1452544034,
-0.0933297798,
-0.1413615942,
-0.2696408331,
-0.2280933708,
0.4407817423,
0.3423563838,
-0.8776593208,
-0.5209037066,
-0.759555757,
0.0125147616,
-0.6550267935,
1.1302627325,
0.0332975574,
-0.2513138354,
-0.0448465198,
0.0917640403,
-0.6782686114,
-0.0225993861,
-0.6708168387,
-0.5623004436,
0.9117903709,
0.4381967485,
0.6575016975,
0.8842378855,
1.0862905979,
0.2199291885,
-0.3527699709,
-0.151009351,
-0.9012297988,
-0.0714014545,
-0.0229708813,
-0.5364023447,
-0.2295300961,
0.3135721982,
0.6218230128,
0.9643352628,
-0.3243531883,
0.2217642516,
0.0781435296,
0.5808074474,
-0.7895535827,
-0.0666538402,
-0.228652969,
0.5020797849,
-0.2072962672,
0.0356347114,
-0.3773370087,
-0.2481693178,
0.0902538672,
-0.4395121336,
0.5072782636,
-0.1468476206,
0.9354334474,
0.9474200606,
-0.2812732756,
0.3166344762,
-1.2113699913,
0.6858336329,
-0.338133961,
0.7879824638,
0.4703658819,
0.2911399901,
0.0834853873,
-0.8009722829,
-0.3338041902,
-0.0332115702,
-0.3414307833,
0.5489196777,
-0.0332207941,
0.2243550122,
0.592797339,
0.4487927556,
-0.2309843749,
0.1506420225,
-0.8532369137,
-0.0353212319,
0.5160110593,
0.253773272,
0.0700985566,
-0.2399411201,
-0.547013104,
-0.1345893592,
-0.6233674288,
0.0899530351,
0.3467670381,
0.1413871199,
-0.2318838835,
0.1815982908,
-0.0423872173,
0.4143811464,
0.3415830135,
0.0389113091,
0.2383212745,
-0.1072720066,
-0.4029944241,
-0.1711098701,
0.6804022193,
0.3411946297,
0.0786862299,
-0.1852551252,
-0.1181493402,
-0.0432318784,
0.6952674985,
-0.9312320352,
-0.7360011935,
0.1438180655,
-1.1622267962,
-0.1561540812,
-0.0295532383,
-0.7190899849,
-0.0072694328,
-0.4029422104,
0.4393309355,
-0.415248543,
-0.2482321113,
0.0765193999,
-0.2231531441,
0.4089452028,
0.4072592854,
-0.7806280851,
0.6661545038,
0.4108048379,
0.8618662357,
-0.7239435911,
-0.18348822,
-0.4031041265,
0.060012985,
-0.4997660518,
0.5419310331,
-0.3768965602,
-0.5518016815,
-0.2808409333,
0.0383729041,
-0.358913511,
-0.547801137,
0.5506882668,
-0.3952059448,
0.0022366915,
-0.0366716608,
-0.5452048182,
-0.402307272,
0.0439381786,
-0.7579618096,
1.1120694876,
-0.0049337144,
-0.7709823251,
0.3660236597,
-0.7226985097,
-0.3978964984,
0.2432647943,
0.0385908261,
-0.531057477,
0.288399905,
-0.0608089529,
0.5114994645,
-0.184133783,
0.1014915481,
0.1200750247,
-0.3775413334,
-0.1682834476,
-0.4436009526,
0.5971113443,
0.1368592829,
-0.3628357351,
-0.2240634263,
-0.9144433737,
-0.0160711519,
0.0074756588,
-0.3894350529,
-0.4670411348,
0.0187069047,
0.3416566551,
0.2482586503,
-0.1918915361,
-0.8461393714,
0.1490792781,
-0.5395168066,
0.3007692695,
0.6883990765,
0.0216526948,
0.5086307526,
0.0844202265,
0.4782395065,
0.237228334,
0.5950204134,
-0.0023855295,
-0.4843752384,
-0.9074546099,
-0.680459559,
0.7568896413,
0.3323142231,
-0.3753011227,
0.5861658454,
-0.3231995106,
-0.5684812069,
-0.5975300074,
-0.1012472808,
0.4669663012,
0.578512311,
0.5694336891,
-0.3521854877,
-0.1161288843,
-1.3346830606,
0.3195900321,
0.4232348204,
-0.2737407088,
0.0590659082,
0.5519203544,
-0.4155580997,
1.1243815422,
-0.9086905122,
-0.7366250157,
-0.2724857032,
-0.059877079,
0.2228477597,
0.7018635273,
0.4550268054,
-0.8225781322,
-0.4660394788,
-0.0491402224,
-0.4953586459,
0.1339378953,
0.0393532552,
-0.0013305884,
-0.1709516048,
0.2660160661,
-0.7477141619,
1.1424379349,
0.4025208652,
-0.0298069455,
0.2578585744,
-0.2946813405,
-0.0630388409,
-1.130690217,
0.1762407124,
0.1064979061,
-0.266825676,
-0.9203730822,
-0.1551368684,
0.2371229678,
-0.0273369104,
-0.4947107434,
0.2539438009,
-0.2208658755,
0.123204343,
-0.1959459633,
-0.0336572453,
0.0989642069,
0.5333160162,
-0.1969464123,
0.4183847308,
0.4541898072,
-0.6819039583,
0.3298988342,
0.7505710721,
0.0873178989,
0.5231884718,
-0.8408610821,
-0.0026609879,
-0.3985275328,
0.2092497498,
-0.9866351485,
-0.0002501391,
0.2059715837,
-0.209145844,
0.5743508935,
-0.1115985438,
-0.1932812184,
-0.5258526802,
-0.3454086781,
0.3745539486,
0.4341593683,
-0.7819995284,
0.7644214034,
0.3047250509,
0.4244968891,
-0.4023846388,
-0.8147208095,
-0.014294195,
-0.1164553761,
-0.4776723087,
0.6054868102,
-0.3922225237,
0.2102870047,
-0.0006124101,
-0.2253234833,
-0.0457945354,
0.0519263595,
0.3899298608,
-0.0859904662,
0.2240807414,
0.185781002,
0.2486813664,
-0.5801271796,
0.107754454,
0.0020410873,
0.6257764697,
0.3926723301,
-0.1261176616,
-1.1700923443,
0.3508511782,
0.042839244,
-0.1425838619,
0.6651846766,
0.7464398146,
-0.3717608452,
-0.5369020104,
-0.43584764,
-0.6264899969,
-0.555498302,
0.2479080111,
-0.703827858,
-0.6428382397,
0.6266716719,
-0.1582494527,
0.0356559977,
0.509360075,
0.385186404,
-0.2966941595,
0.8453425765,
0.9878016114,
-0.0454836749,
0.3772156239,
-1.0620697737,
0.5683717132,
-0.8576512337,
-0.5331547856,
-0.5463231206,
-0.9755698442,
-0.6733288169,
-0.1930394322,
0.1937679499,
-0.2423268259,
0.1132726595,
0.4504792094,
-0.8082641363,
0.4431196153,
0.8466981053,
0.1802121252,
-0.0683520883,
-0.1787529886,
0.0545614921,
-0.4552490711,
-0.721247673,
0.3432742357,
0.7259302735,
0.5338900685,
1.0481407642,
-0.3497351706,
0.8868349195,
0.4956404865,
0.1093127429,
-1.0948681831,
0.3649050295,
-0.2752937078,
-0.1805891544,
-0.375857234,
-0.6252025366,
-1.0626533031,
-0.0976938531,
0.056873735,
-0.4961220622,
0.5716491938,
0.1229005605,
-0.3412208557,
0.3260337412,
-0.5019945502,
0.7781310081,
0.407191664,
0.2740747035,
-0.2664625645,
-0.9157684445,
0.052880846,
-0.0732738227,
-0.0942597985,
-0.1622713059,
-0.0183406305,
0.8328746557,
-0.549488008,
0.8960133195,
-0.1649985015,
-0.1174632534,
0.1369980425,
0.3193751872,
0.4268165827,
-0.0683507845,
0.1701985449,
0.7654428482,
-0.2170640677,
-0.1661923677,
-0.9130703211,
0.6382085681,
-1.0871708393,
-0.2952052057,
0.0155262565,
-0.6892554164,
0.2373025119,
0.0022734227,
0.5350005031,
0.7031584978,
0.1934302896,
0.2826734483,
0.7874013782,
0.0769338831,
0.8316589594,
0.0610300116,
0.215132013,
-0.6268340945,
0.8418823481,
0.4850048721,
0.2651199102,
0.3521972299,
0.2619022131,
-0.134643957,
-0.4668231606,
0.0465227738,
0.3438766599,
-0.7555708289,
-0.5385053158,
-0.819191277,
-0.7145370841,
-0.0527971499,
-0.0953956172,
-0.7048457265,
-0.6511026621,
-0.0375054479,
-0.2643991709,
0.3121089339,
0.8423385024,
-0.3166593015,
0.7763317823,
-0.678609252,
0.4781162739,
0.3241341412,
0.6779841185,
-0.1119113341,
-0.746796608,
-0.4674426615,
-0.1824143678,
-0.296187073,
-0.5825964212,
0.5337674618,
0.3501623571,
0.607796073,
0.6359415054,
-0.0746031478,
0.5767585635,
-0.7219616175,
0.6668682694,
0.391862154,
-0.8976787329,
0.7488526702,
-0.3040798604,
0.3555705845,
0.347007215,
0.4350022674,
-0.5328059196,
-0.3198910654,
-0.6760239005,
-0.8506607413,
0.8979712725,
0.4952347875,
0.2570745647,
-0.09482117,
0.6705433726,
0.1326854527,
0.1980674267,
-0.3922975957,
-0.9651697874,
-0.1461647004,
-0.2856625915,
0.0560439825,
-0.3198939264,
-0.0916312858,
-0.5625279546,
0.4284959137,
0.0643239617,
0.2991940975,
0.1067169383,
0.0677400902,
-0.1139426306,
-0.4376864731,
0.4875532389,
0.5702199936,
-0.1364682168,
0.0893524811,
0.1956965327,
-0.9783561826,
0.0331695341,
-0.1804127246,
-0.7826730609,
0.0364131369,
-0.0425854214,
0.6886014342,
0.075697273,
0.0090202559,
0.465117991,
-0.320517391,
-0.5199005008,
-0.0287366714,
0.0076647075,
-0.3147909045,
-0.0254078191,
0.4291511178,
0.4914433062,
0.5439183116,
0.2773456275,
0.3169751763,
0.1428709775,
-0.7426966429,
-0.512039721,
0.7725372314,
0.2808009684,
-0.5877030492,
0.6790147424,
0.114267908,
-0.3560007811,
0.8883798718,
0.56771487,
1.1386623383,
-0.5737162828,
0.4343006015,
0.3328822553,
0.5505366325,
-0.087906152,
-0.0331397019,
0.0954302549,
-0.5834205747,
-0.6771215796,
-0.6948388815,
-0.1754858941,
0.1267716885,
-0.7972108722,
0.2839038074,
-0.4424251616,
-0.3025303185,
0.057889387,
-0.0838210806,
-0.9190250635,
0.5051682591,
0.0132139875,
0.8041719198,
-0.8094854951,
0.5148274302,
0.4035384655,
-0.2900421321,
-0.8509147167,
0.1252906919,
-0.3102263212,
-0.2030129433,
1.0441114902,
0.3609038591,
-0.0650025159,
0.37525177,
-0.6001529694,
-1.4744297266,
0.7974555492,
0.3199461699,
-0.4516740441,
0.177076146,
0.1002482772,
0.4657146335,
-0.1039097682,
0.3751702011,
0.7210115194,
0.5046358705,
0.1490497589,
-0.795512557,
-0.0522340722,
-0.1387766749,
0.490691632,
0.6952979565,
-0.9009783864,
0.6819336414,
-0.0416154861,
-0.1584980637,
-0.4458020627,
0.6347988248,
-0.4956791103,
-0.0430228934,
0.4971312881,
0.9789592028,
0.4671325684,
-0.1251818091,
1.0351557732,
-0.417645961,
0.6990541816,
0.8164852262,
-0.0071572722,
0.5306019783,
0.3921522498,
-0.1042561978,
0.1345639229,
0.6657019258,
-0.2529067397,
0.6925808191,
0.2603903711,
0.2424745262,
-0.3610824645,
-0.0480195247,
-0.0125919748,
0.6890943646,
0.2688331604,
0.0038970271,
-0.2906991541,
0.4688413143,
0.0153046874,
-0.0889619514,
-0.4117866755,
0.7396960855,
0.1673936397,
-0.2105984241,
0.5683566928,
-0.1192498356,
0.5057010055,
-0.2039672136,
-0.1516506374,
-0.5732990503,
0.3448943496,
-0.3908125758,
-0.4411018193,
0.4838826954,
-0.5546919107,
-0.5101029277,
-0.3028753996,
0.5664708018,
-0.294636786,
-0.5606856942,
0.7125914097,
0.4531926811,
0.1589736938,
0.3323095143,
-0.5961319208,
0.0275038388,
-0.2638904452,
-0.4694344997,
0.1105282381,
0.2488736808,
0.2920335829,
0.9377348423,
0.5283501744,
0.1004355326,
0.2293412834,
0.4871872067,
1.1452641487,
-0.5411458015,
-0.3455349207,
-0.6561174989,
0.3712095916,
-0.1993174851,
-0.134050861,
0.7300352454,
0.6529095173,
0.8187147379,
-0.1455148906,
0.487665087,
-0.1011948362,
0.5008651018,
-0.1386024803,
0.8453062773,
-0.6304123402,
-0.0761488229,
0.0234032329,
-1.2675100565,
-0.521045804,
0.4519444704,
-0.23190552,
0.1390343904,
0.9091410041,
0.5593296885,
-0.3737803102,
-0.3710717261,
0.8504251838,
0.2136946172,
0.2330205441,
0.0452350527,
0.559992969,
-0.8100373745,
0.5996223092,
-0.5548397303,
-0.1078151017,
-0.0333763212,
-0.3228401542,
-1.2278563976,
-0.4095953405,
-0.715159297,
-0.0133455815,
0.017675899,
0.6131209135,
0.9162122607,
-0.7339500189,
-0.0915167183,
0.1679025292,
0.1502371728,
-0.4295434654,
-0.2500549853,
0.5827991962,
-0.5139451623,
-0.8433422446,
0.3469178975,
0.5111789107,
-0.1304883063,
-0.2911438644,
0.2161154002,
-0.109291777,
0.0775167048,
0.3953956664,
-0.2475426644,
-0.3533319235,
-0.6189005375,
0.0074206945,
-0.103174299,
0.4781871736,
0.7370305061,
-0.7457659841,
0.2590807378,
0.6523829699,
0.4847478569,
0.6791904569,
0.2424946576,
0.3481819332,
-1.1243321896,
0.3058275282,
0.0949706733,
0.1350792199,
0.1574619859,
-0.5720722079,
0.6202172637,
0.3464424312,
-0.6601211429,
-0.5315887332,
0.1989298761,
-0.8785375953,
0.1300524175,
0.8900423646,
-0.0956703722,
-0.5914251804,
-0.1744100302,
0.0418219753,
0.134513393,
-0.4340005219,
1.0449334383,
0.0652832016,
0.2300966233,
-0.4546528161,
-0.5458800197,
0.746434927,
0.2503901422,
-0.7495332956,
-0.133532241,
0.3033584356,
0.3110223114,
0.4923802614,
0.3369182646,
0.2969349325,
0.1901142895,
-0.2376566976,
0.5360597968,
-0.0081323124,
-0.8434076309,
-0.4244204462,
0.2017595023,
-0.5886252522,
-0.5101212263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10309v1 | Improving Speech Translation by Cross-Modal Multi-Grained Contrastive Learning | 2023-04-20T13:41:56 | 2023-04-20T13:41:56 | Hao Zhang, Nianwen Si, Yaqi Chen, Wenlin Zhang, Xukui Yang, Dan Qu, Wei-Qiang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | The end-to-end speech translation (E2E-ST) model has gradually become a
mainstream paradigm due to its low latency and less error propagation. However,
it is non-trivial to train such a model well due to the task complexity and
data scarcity. The speech-and-text modality differences result in the E2E-ST
model performance usually inferior to the corresponding machine translation
(MT) model. Based on the above observation, existing methods often use
sharingmechanisms to carry out implicit knowledge transfer by imposing various
constraints. However, the final model often performs worse on the MT task than
the MT model trained alone, which means that the knowledge transfer ability of
this method is also limited. To deal with these problems, we propose the FCCL
(Fine- and Coarse- Granularity Contrastive Learning) approach for E2E-ST, which
makes explicit knowledge transfer through cross-modal multi-grained contrastive
learning. A key ingredient of our approach is applying contrastive learning at
both sentence- and frame-level to give the comprehensive guide for extracting
speech representations containing rich semantic information.In addition, we
adopt a simple whitening method to alleviate the representation degeneration in
the MT model, which adversely affects contrast learning. Experiments on the
MuST-C benchmark show that our proposed approach significantly outperforms the
state-of-the-art E2E-ST baselines on all eight language pairs. Further analysis
indicates that FCCL can free up its capacity from learning grammatical
structure information and force more layers to learn semantic information. | [
-0.392288059,
-0.9029821157,
0.320671916,
0.0880611017,
-0.4342177808,
-0.1399809867,
-0.4239789248,
-0.7686472535,
-0.1477898955,
0.1548020989,
-0.4066416919,
-0.2348134369,
-0.855604887,
-0.0710736737,
-0.1812740564,
1.0023536682,
0.0186213609,
0.2653605938,
-0.0219289977,
-0.0634754822,
-0.3274655342,
-0.320471257,
-0.7579610348,
-0.4741224945,
0.4313373268,
0.2919047177,
0.3507188261,
0.668279171,
0.2960358262,
0.2317727655,
-0.3488264978,
0.2209271938,
-0.7908367515,
-0.2159543484,
-0.2978234887,
-0.3217749,
-0.1766898483,
-0.0551734008,
0.3446330726,
0.812630713,
-0.199909091,
-0.086434707,
0.2531226873,
0.4515791237,
-0.3670811951,
0.3172575533,
-0.7495406866,
0.1021601781,
-0.1431607455,
-0.2469920367,
-0.5457986593,
0.0694600418,
0.3178330064,
-0.6651937366,
-0.0156709738,
0.147164464,
0.7666174173,
0.2325744182,
-0.5752846599,
-0.3978084326,
-0.7165320516,
0.9030872583,
-0.569399178,
0.6083452106,
0.4915648997,
0.3969476223,
0.1519457102,
-0.6438906193,
-0.4166649878,
-0.2902697325,
-0.0647715256,
0.2662991881,
-0.007561801,
-0.0391335413,
-0.0970889255,
0.2349591553,
-0.440133065,
0.1179184839,
-0.5894588232,
-0.1921797246,
0.2722890377,
-0.1140458062,
0.0624192394,
-0.0359385423,
-0.8759863973,
-0.1562755257,
-0.4093599916,
0.3008462787,
-0.0298611857,
0.3283008337,
-0.4437864423,
0.092964381,
-0.1598459333,
0.2685601711,
0.2762274146,
-0.0755932033,
0.6290337443,
-0.4318256974,
-0.3436421454,
-0.0064684451,
0.5667625666,
0.2909061611,
-0.0640081987,
-0.3434265852,
-0.1696065515,
-0.329061687,
-0.1070882306,
-0.7604418993,
0.0926535875,
0.0441570282,
-0.4169020355,
-0.1573070586,
-0.061358057,
-0.688220799,
0.0532615893,
-0.5783839226,
0.5273976326,
-0.5941953063,
-0.0969919413,
-0.1268449426,
-0.0067548356,
0.3798929751,
0.4335543215,
-0.9892424941,
0.3051684797,
0.4182147682,
0.7150330544,
-0.1461796761,
-0.260187149,
-0.6374132633,
0.4101989269,
-0.2175009698,
0.6256878376,
-0.5729860067,
-0.2831386328,
-0.2276483923,
-0.0214536246,
-0.1843746901,
-0.4958895743,
0.6633169055,
-0.2562955916,
0.2929781377,
-0.2168358117,
-0.4107219577,
-0.3620789051,
-0.0313790329,
-0.4973848462,
0.8563252091,
0.011056114,
-0.4916909337,
0.1023861244,
-0.3781903088,
-0.414088279,
-0.2355406135,
-0.2867450118,
-0.2737608552,
0.2925439477,
0.1665759832,
0.3936373293,
-0.3546635807,
0.3523186147,
-0.0842880905,
-0.2745955586,
0.0899315849,
-0.5160342455,
0.4725740552,
0.5141899586,
-0.3975355625,
0.1301971078,
-0.5486220121,
-0.0562060699,
-0.0065413374,
-0.4745514393,
-0.2920304537,
-0.1000145078,
0.4294902682,
0.6933339834,
0.1443936527,
-0.3706105649,
-0.4158929288,
-0.5457040668,
0.4216740727,
0.8032858372,
-0.3193933666,
0.5518229604,
-0.5866705775,
-0.0624969788,
0.3501286209,
0.1039257124,
-0.0272072628,
-0.2581792474,
-0.7994799018,
-0.0438815989,
0.3429932296,
0.6572338343,
-0.8600482941,
0.2040628493,
-0.3402111828,
-0.2134641856,
-0.7025132775,
0.0509020723,
0.7135948539,
0.6705499887,
0.7659620643,
-0.2745480239,
-0.3588352203,
-0.9308716655,
0.0665710121,
0.2301895022,
-0.0239662863,
0.5949050784,
0.3733941913,
-0.1405769438,
0.3871435523,
-0.0285566188,
-0.4355560243,
-0.2486981899,
0.377564162,
-0.1593106687,
0.6318147182,
0.203684032,
-0.8575333357,
-0.5030943155,
0.4528851807,
-0.5176561475,
-0.2621479928,
-0.1548718065,
0.0452078693,
0.282145679,
0.5698531866,
-0.0621916838,
0.0193912741,
0.8141364455,
-0.1312919557,
0.3522583842,
-0.2242245078,
0.2080584466,
-1.2582116127,
0.2171441317,
-0.1680227369,
-0.4679622948,
-0.9060353637,
-0.0605000295,
-0.0686605275,
-0.040454004,
-0.8645333052,
0.3603906631,
-0.2947695553,
-0.0199535862,
-0.2700108886,
0.4062389135,
-0.1155921444,
0.8133758903,
0.0903803259,
0.8801971078,
0.3325909972,
-0.4328803718,
-0.1216704771,
0.202625379,
-0.0081699584,
0.5542148352,
-0.4864736795,
0.1874910146,
-0.1139762551,
0.1800986379,
-0.7801998258,
0.0199128669,
0.1231106818,
-0.4500800967,
0.5353759527,
0.1181797236,
0.0202298313,
0.3357601762,
-0.2454637736,
0.3961587548,
0.4537431896,
-0.4206542075,
0.5882322788,
0.2280552983,
-0.4703293443,
-0.4447776675,
-0.9258486629,
0.0860437453,
0.0265269596,
-0.8133858442,
0.8148523569,
-0.0862805769,
0.0426057018,
-0.0192994121,
-0.232809782,
-0.20770441,
-0.0626568124,
-0.1446282119,
-0.0350960419,
-0.1632188857,
0.1773549914,
0.1131363958,
-0.4161700904,
-0.2421959788,
-0.1596562117,
0.6259899139,
-0.1917740107,
-0.0517944917,
-0.5574090481,
0.685788393,
0.4016204178,
-0.1645725369,
0.5398887396,
0.7874898314,
-0.193250373,
-0.3052574396,
-0.4390892684,
-0.0814109594,
-0.3751449585,
0.5767305493,
-0.5652979016,
-0.9872030616,
0.3632296622,
-0.4458613098,
-0.0666780025,
0.3853363693,
0.5415309668,
-0.0965610817,
0.7454845905,
0.6892986298,
0.0923769102,
0.6185446382,
-0.1561737061,
-0.0692897886,
-1.048590064,
-0.4561157227,
-0.4291502535,
-0.2537234426,
-0.3748545349,
-0.7176946998,
0.1895580739,
0.3569034338,
0.0608193055,
0.2502765357,
-0.1260977834,
0.3900025487,
0.395721525,
0.2752019167,
0.2724964023,
0.1874284595,
-0.3094644547,
0.0248911157,
-0.4319398701,
-0.3513051271,
0.828671515,
0.2796674073,
0.5457650423,
0.2192842364,
0.6062290072,
0.2682289481,
-0.1126057208,
-0.7197947502,
0.2768236995,
-0.6291630864,
-0.1484883428,
-0.2028246373,
-0.6753206849,
-0.633541286,
0.6351588368,
-0.199481383,
-0.4783636332,
0.2813743651,
-0.0261235163,
-0.052065447,
0.0632530153,
-0.6808507442,
0.7383734584,
-0.1919996291,
-0.564540565,
-0.4518790841,
-0.9247775078,
0.1676140875,
-0.1677797735,
0.4809974432,
0.0790067911,
-0.0852812305,
0.638758719,
-0.2044051588,
0.804487288,
-0.056256149,
-0.0626546964,
-0.1007537618,
-0.0558714755,
0.7712873816,
-0.3765673339,
-0.1085018292,
0.224329561,
-0.2249981761,
-0.3517403901,
-0.335522145,
0.4564543366,
-0.8727082014,
-0.3655351102,
-0.111896798,
-0.7217350602,
-0.1818692982,
0.0040340149,
0.1991586983,
0.414729923,
-0.216646567,
0.351657778,
0.6603955626,
-0.087469779,
0.5118535757,
0.5227832198,
0.0747023299,
-0.5946393013,
1.0093189478,
0.1546051502,
0.729146421,
0.4181823134,
0.3546143174,
-0.3562129736,
-0.7723762989,
-0.49265939,
0.0995019525,
-0.6835966706,
0.1267350614,
-0.5681945682,
-0.2102192044,
-0.3317384124,
-0.5402104855,
-0.3334382772,
-0.4278087318,
-0.3048141301,
0.0398285054,
-0.1797237843,
0.3859698474,
-0.227556482,
0.3367520273,
-0.5938398242,
0.31575948,
0.2487957925,
0.0470917821,
-0.1747072786,
-0.9205447435,
-0.2891299725,
0.0608789101,
-0.2761698067,
-0.6913506389,
0.4147026539,
0.4953409731,
0.5686525106,
0.2072626054,
-0.1205564067,
0.8592885733,
-0.4913368821,
0.6485953331,
0.4728038907,
-1.1383876801,
0.354854852,
-0.1677889824,
0.2588395774,
0.6327866912,
0.1243089885,
-0.6288821697,
-0.3400181234,
-0.4474214911,
-0.9293267131,
0.8975073695,
0.2456032634,
0.1173132956,
0.2205567956,
-0.0960997194,
0.2920579612,
0.2130739987,
-0.9102771282,
-0.2137322426,
-0.2835488915,
-0.1422531754,
0.07910081,
-0.2081586719,
-0.0434518941,
-0.0676875189,
0.8330272436,
-0.0602929518,
0.1766458899,
0.3117011786,
-0.3772467077,
-0.1716282219,
0.8380748034,
0.7638486028,
0.388654083,
-0.1168132126,
0.3998205066,
0.5024120808,
-0.1648133248,
-0.0367823578,
0.3392110169,
-0.306628257,
-0.1667371988,
0.1583019942,
0.8612838387,
0.4720368385,
-0.4736477435,
0.6468619704,
0.3388358057,
-0.4427197576,
0.0169655476,
-0.2588056624,
0.1954429895,
0.2746897936,
0.0740483627,
0.2610925436,
0.2021925449,
-0.6612797976,
0.4789031744,
0.0728068426,
-0.6433630586,
-0.3275792003,
0.5831362009,
0.5353280306,
-0.0544170178,
0.2410892993,
-0.1706884354,
-0.3879418075,
0.4314959049,
0.9509811997,
0.7433757782,
-0.4660365582,
0.1334350854,
0.1552189738,
0.189968735,
0.0273903813,
0.2168072313,
-0.2162487954,
-0.3739511967,
-0.5213294625,
-0.5941772461,
-0.2155932933,
0.1426297724,
-0.4837146103,
0.1974946409,
-0.2192718536,
0.220680058,
-0.1648183316,
-0.1157906875,
-0.4847673476,
0.0950957015,
0.2974166274,
0.6102956533,
-0.7424021363,
1.0615288019,
0.3117446601,
-0.5889047384,
-0.7888788581,
-0.254046917,
0.1081193462,
-0.7198032141,
0.8397082686,
0.2686004043,
-0.3105670512,
0.138967976,
-0.2081971765,
-0.709683001,
1.2421010733,
0.300929755,
-0.8861399889,
0.0254920293,
0.2985365689,
0.411890626,
-0.5424873829,
0.2539080679,
0.2218128592,
0.4793658555,
0.5351670384,
-1.2311190367,
0.0422045365,
-0.180920586,
0.0365911722,
0.0828834772,
-0.702654779,
1.0283093452,
-0.0852884278,
-0.4226332605,
-0.2378370166,
0.5012713671,
-0.1683091223,
0.4350701272,
0.4568476081,
0.6480420828,
0.6653121114,
-0.0731648356,
0.7618148923,
-0.2170612067,
0.3822923601,
1.3662070036,
-0.234934777,
1.1443468332,
0.7155558467,
0.0507933088,
0.1719658822,
0.2045010626,
-0.0275462884,
0.7429769039,
0.0961735025,
-0.289013803,
-0.38290748,
-0.4731794596,
-0.4450179338,
0.4417065084,
0.2861334085,
-0.5556272268,
-0.5149973035,
0.10684596,
-0.0147816706,
0.1399189383,
-0.213260144,
0.9493745565,
0.346224457,
-0.2153043896,
0.7268441916,
0.067529805,
0.7277579308,
-0.7479764819,
-0.1235856339,
-0.0334787183,
-0.0176760554,
-0.1489681751,
-0.2845219076,
0.4600237608,
-0.1121417135,
-0.2410925627,
-0.2591919899,
0.4993342757,
-0.8410079479,
-0.2284717858,
0.5638366342,
0.7857241035,
0.1830384135,
0.2771331072,
-0.760817647,
-0.0659786686,
0.0916057974,
-0.0304872133,
0.4461143613,
0.3123578429,
0.0400210992,
0.4404837489,
0.7754244804,
0.1344735324,
0.1120473817,
0.1349120587,
0.8337879181,
-0.5890820622,
-0.5401834249,
-0.6179679036,
0.5636633635,
-0.0322230086,
-0.1489471793,
0.3851364255,
0.5653977394,
1.1152901649,
0.0369749144,
0.7281924486,
-0.1335699409,
0.253574878,
-0.7954719067,
0.4373582006,
-0.5371793509,
0.3229984641,
0.0422853231,
-0.6619282961,
-0.1342125088,
0.5401977897,
-0.1421908289,
-0.0698458254,
1.0911570787,
0.8479691744,
-0.1614428461,
0.0935093164,
0.6968523264,
0.3097673655,
0.3181887865,
0.9750078321,
0.6398062706,
-0.6187595725,
0.9373341799,
-0.2784616053,
-0.3589259088,
-0.2158419192,
-0.6559743285,
-0.6448514462,
-0.555547595,
-0.0597341321,
-0.0305327028,
0.3144678175,
1.1360626221,
0.8403977752,
-0.6983531117,
-0.1576402783,
-0.095146969,
-0.2259661704,
-0.3916866481,
-0.1598434448,
0.5003522635,
-0.6255421042,
-0.8137779832,
0.6243240237,
0.2213668525,
0.1099186465,
0.1699842811,
-0.2465272993,
-0.2785582542,
0.1146322414,
0.8184256554,
-0.0086201858,
-0.9061228633,
-0.4497789443,
-0.2837213874,
-0.1695525199,
0.2553540468,
0.700607717,
-0.5496990085,
0.4717701674,
0.5735690594,
0.8063832521,
0.5820239782,
-0.0708152279,
0.4152632654,
-0.6944184899,
0.0394761004,
-0.0594762154,
0.3369653821,
0.1630182415,
-0.1120418012,
0.3551612198,
0.2618943751,
-0.4986125231,
-0.2527328134,
0.3067983985,
-1.3660104275,
-0.4368929267,
1.1684038639,
-0.1930389702,
-0.1769594252,
-0.3725683093,
-0.3649292886,
0.4389390647,
-0.6492815614,
0.7305875421,
0.577899754,
-0.0468395203,
-0.2448229492,
-0.6869660616,
0.39140293,
0.5122964978,
-0.943654716,
0.188787967,
0.5000400543,
0.2940786481,
0.0345817544,
0.4430444241,
-0.3467222154,
0.2784301043,
0.0650757849,
-0.0447116606,
-0.5712826252,
-0.2697238028,
-0.4862548411,
0.3686248362,
-0.1002910659,
-0.0265321024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10295v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10295v1 | Decouple Non-parametric Knowledge Distillation For End-to-end Speech Translation | 2023-04-20T13:20:03 | 2023-04-20T13:20:03 | Hao Zhang, Nianwen Si, Yaqi Chen, Wenlin Zhang, Xukui Yang, Dan Qu, Zhen Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Existing techniques often attempt to make knowledge transfer from a powerful
machine translation (MT) to speech translation (ST) model with some elaborate
techniques, which often requires transcription as extra input during training.
However, transcriptions are not always available, and how to improve the ST
model performance without transcription, i.e., data efficiency, has rarely been
studied in the literature. In this paper, we propose Decoupled Non-parametric
Knowledge Distillation (DNKD) from data perspective to improve the data
efficiency. Our method follows the knowledge distillation paradigm. However,
instead of obtaining the teacher distribution from a sophisticated MT model, we
construct it from a non-parametric datastore via k-Nearest-Neighbor (kNN)
retrieval, which removes the dependence on transcription and MT model. Then we
decouple the classic knowledge distillation loss into target and non-target
distillation to enhance the effect of the knowledge among non-target logits,
which is the prominent "dark knowledge". Experiments on MuST-C corpus show
that, the proposed method can achieve consistent improvement over the strong
baseline without requiring any transcription. | [
-0.1122808531,
-0.5493611097,
0.4169474244,
-0.1767025739,
-0.8147004843,
0.1848964542,
-0.5799393654,
-0.0828272626,
0.1275070012,
0.4177727401,
-0.2536705732,
-0.7310413122,
-0.8895739913,
0.1119871736,
-0.6776690483,
1.0015525818,
0.1847480536,
0.0989302248,
-0.4410972297,
-0.0763389021,
-0.2670977414,
-0.3351634443,
-0.3643461168,
-0.2908471227,
0.2524257302,
0.3769661486,
0.2734268606,
0.6045081615,
0.3067668974,
0.2744962573,
-0.4360381663,
0.2427182943,
-0.7636900544,
0.1231597662,
-0.1549268961,
-0.5632762909,
-0.1515461504,
-0.0921764225,
0.6530594826,
0.8959856629,
-0.3155919611,
0.3589604795,
0.4571686089,
0.8273866773,
-0.4307703674,
0.2898547053,
-0.7535838485,
-0.1355380267,
-0.179968223,
-0.2334441543,
-0.3166243732,
-0.5464934707,
0.2557514906,
-0.5194692612,
0.2466953695,
-0.3565766215,
0.3877359331,
0.6538462043,
-0.5789191723,
-0.0776565149,
-0.9656332135,
0.727645278,
-0.9728904366,
0.6438145041,
0.4971410036,
0.4625092149,
-0.2718799114,
-0.5104436874,
-0.7616682053,
-0.2074486911,
0.0351992212,
0.1475998312,
-0.2000279427,
0.0555362143,
0.0904483646,
0.2847203612,
-0.2096096575,
-0.1053505167,
-0.5664301515,
0.0638684928,
0.3577497005,
-0.0805268064,
-0.0058110096,
-0.0725189671,
-0.2949869931,
-0.2328446209,
-0.3148003519,
-0.023044588,
0.3291996121,
0.2677525282,
-0.1974468082,
0.4544115663,
-0.3844793737,
0.7606224418,
0.2498329729,
-0.6272745132,
0.3926858306,
-0.4579618275,
-0.1517240852,
0.297895968,
0.6255363226,
0.3558677733,
-0.0793427601,
-0.5358058214,
-0.0259902086,
-0.2790044546,
-0.0442434214,
-0.7442567348,
-0.452873379,
-0.1049842238,
-0.5469639301,
-0.2735123932,
-0.2901404202,
-0.8301244378,
-0.2526164353,
-0.7220901847,
0.2732005119,
-0.5230587721,
-0.4696397483,
-0.2341690361,
-0.4336715043,
0.0454017781,
-0.0233658813,
-0.8143575788,
0.1354902685,
0.2807549834,
0.8790025115,
-0.167622894,
-0.0449145846,
-0.2324449867,
0.3722110093,
-0.4872186184,
0.3447884321,
-0.3603634238,
-0.3588536978,
-0.5050911307,
-0.3565383852,
-0.0061389892,
-0.7255043387,
0.6209385395,
-0.2549497485,
0.0755126104,
-0.3059586287,
-0.5967832208,
-0.4408813119,
-0.1005810201,
-0.4764774144,
0.8644637465,
0.1435035616,
-0.7272213697,
0.5001140237,
-0.3373389542,
-0.5032939315,
-0.1558010727,
-0.0936098173,
-0.347821027,
0.5547409654,
0.379645586,
0.2575899959,
-0.4415209591,
0.7514033318,
-0.1697468013,
-0.2717226446,
0.1347756833,
-0.7552878261,
0.7578300834,
0.1632547826,
-0.5355009437,
-0.2678616941,
-1.0764104128,
-0.0540120043,
-0.126800254,
-0.4620369077,
-0.6333090663,
-0.1839490533,
-0.1122741699,
0.2577617466,
0.330887109,
-0.5959464312,
0.0213100258,
-0.32437253,
0.5833133459,
0.4896520674,
0.1600378901,
0.5338662267,
-0.3331801593,
0.2745163143,
0.2679323256,
0.0667497814,
0.5244158506,
-0.3792638779,
-0.5669243932,
-0.4887726307,
0.5392351747,
0.3673618436,
-1.119353056,
0.370282799,
-0.4596241415,
-0.7385216355,
-0.8146976233,
0.246024102,
0.4046319723,
1.1442438364,
0.6340431571,
0.2445047349,
-0.5190145969,
-0.8643153906,
-0.1298742741,
-0.0198147763,
-0.0828744322,
0.1255172789,
0.1390051097,
0.1090499088,
0.8336655498,
-0.4277026653,
-0.3257238567,
-0.3180712461,
0.0139385602,
0.5021346211,
0.3278024495,
0.4277499318,
-0.7088646889,
-0.5771313906,
-0.1269047707,
-0.650374651,
-0.2368009239,
0.0347580314,
-0.2737609148,
-0.0279568378,
0.3417455256,
-0.3471841216,
0.2895389199,
0.4474724233,
0.1499073207,
0.241804406,
-0.349696964,
0.3155462146,
-1.3905166388,
0.3596929014,
-0.3574087322,
-0.0701658502,
-1.0149474144,
-0.4050117433,
0.2857900858,
-0.0706500784,
-0.5109340549,
-0.0478583835,
-0.2182874978,
0.0819669813,
-0.4811902344,
0.3199259341,
-0.0324045531,
0.5611739159,
0.1719117016,
0.7814177275,
0.4941102862,
-0.7444304824,
0.3195454776,
0.3256155849,
-0.5196467638,
0.5362378955,
-0.5090909004,
0.0875834003,
-0.2470788658,
0.1357250959,
-1.1810816526,
0.1535937935,
-0.0328344144,
-0.5296186805,
0.4178609252,
-0.2931221128,
-0.4898339212,
-0.0736661479,
0.0057338779,
0.2876746655,
0.708014369,
-0.5741253495,
0.1351513416,
0.2881579399,
-0.1442029625,
-0.5215223432,
-0.8627779484,
0.3535443544,
-0.5968140364,
-0.3829233944,
0.4426248372,
0.1525473148,
0.0315800756,
-0.0637197569,
-0.4488461018,
-0.3668941557,
-0.127667889,
-0.2282953858,
0.2565091848,
0.0940698013,
0.1000516564,
0.5409830809,
-0.0759593323,
-0.0790317953,
-0.6027174592,
0.2325356901,
0.7028115392,
-0.0806730315,
-0.7496616244,
0.3446612656,
0.7392928004,
-0.0255567897,
0.8020185232,
0.4283650219,
-0.3226991892,
-0.0652268901,
-0.4759638608,
-0.3415883482,
-0.40043208,
0.2462923974,
-0.1515562683,
-0.494905889,
0.323810488,
-0.2687518597,
-0.0105510736,
0.1420335472,
0.4001896679,
-0.1169508994,
0.5595350862,
0.3764852583,
-0.1586202234,
0.5029352903,
-0.3738375008,
0.263733387,
-0.9648256302,
-0.4632471204,
-0.3938855231,
-0.7753215432,
-0.3715030849,
-0.4833672047,
0.543492496,
0.3405236006,
0.3491221368,
0.6255046725,
-0.5334464312,
0.2159443647,
0.7943155169,
0.3404227495,
0.452767998,
0.0034309251,
-0.1081553698,
-0.0991567746,
-0.6119390726,
-0.1051286161,
1.360432744,
-0.0959302932,
0.5371219516,
0.1771118194,
1.1338226795,
-0.012966698,
-0.2563547492,
-0.3776527941,
0.4233224392,
-0.3243938088,
-0.4357914925,
-0.4379582405,
-0.8468980193,
-0.5785422921,
0.2466409802,
-0.0314165093,
-0.2735180259,
0.4746843278,
0.15793778,
-0.0332841873,
0.3204108477,
-0.6793751717,
0.47408548,
-0.0664518923,
-0.1740271449,
-0.0729005039,
-0.6461803913,
0.2848268747,
-0.1991136521,
0.1243041754,
0.0489236526,
0.1218664423,
0.9816641212,
-0.4378536046,
0.7087975144,
-0.7170704603,
-0.1142533869,
0.339579314,
-0.1591878533,
0.8381066918,
-0.2028354555,
-0.0758064687,
0.2823012173,
0.09126091,
-0.1477255672,
-0.8805522919,
0.3897549808,
-0.6807843447,
-0.3654519618,
0.1591739804,
-0.5559321046,
-0.2406595796,
0.1577245444,
0.358738482,
0.2184363753,
0.089331992,
0.6121077538,
0.7597095966,
0.0699569061,
0.3378993273,
0.612354219,
0.2285097092,
-0.61879915,
0.9634238482,
0.4616952837,
0.4358892739,
0.6190429926,
0.4068189859,
-0.9730082154,
-1.0334458351,
-0.4692878425,
-0.0922310427,
-0.5987409353,
-0.2543691099,
-0.5432138443,
0.0220784247,
-0.768817544,
0.22416614,
-0.4370321929,
-0.7050351501,
-0.3979350328,
-0.2584789693,
0.7021695971,
0.2044071555,
-0.2584780455,
0.3120834231,
-0.5761039853,
0.6381244063,
0.1132310629,
0.0566682406,
0.0214405265,
-1.0083060265,
-0.2264110595,
0.400111407,
-0.1750832647,
-1.0054267645,
0.4572200477,
0.4982485473,
0.671708703,
0.3277279735,
0.6129157543,
1.0471886396,
-0.3545745909,
0.5037072301,
0.3645852804,
-0.9554013014,
0.393034339,
-0.2666189969,
0.2390592098,
0.825965941,
0.1691787541,
-0.5040932298,
-0.5863338113,
-0.3120773137,
-1.0084378719,
0.6447564363,
0.4112777412,
-0.0416060686,
0.1842612028,
0.3439489007,
0.2692510188,
0.5632553697,
-0.4177474976,
-0.4040845633,
-0.3892546296,
-0.3159470558,
-0.2486124188,
0.0810204521,
-0.0068804361,
-0.5838440657,
0.6459938288,
0.193876937,
-0.029791085,
0.0952259153,
-0.1525466293,
0.2977130115,
0.4640620947,
0.4572920203,
0.5356756449,
-0.0511025935,
0.2684575021,
0.4856930673,
-0.5423610806,
0.3921473026,
0.0049516195,
-0.2255537808,
0.0141506698,
0.1488729119,
0.7601469755,
0.4123528898,
-0.3283286393,
0.3532392979,
0.0805576518,
-0.5750004649,
0.0044955984,
-0.0780679509,
0.3836893439,
0.3810527027,
0.328764677,
-0.140783146,
0.3079492748,
-0.2425744981,
0.494469583,
-0.0099927085,
-0.0753752738,
0.0014204773,
0.7355178595,
0.1015855819,
-0.0076101786,
0.7128170729,
-0.1104117408,
-0.1520761251,
0.333825767,
0.653875649,
0.8287267089,
-0.3940294981,
0.1522841603,
0.2236020714,
0.055454839,
0.0327065252,
0.3198982179,
-0.500728786,
0.0328904986,
-0.4390838146,
-0.6300399899,
-0.1770885885,
0.2342705876,
-0.8153996468,
0.3455142379,
-0.138455689,
-0.0923075229,
-0.1235292926,
-0.1665930301,
-0.4989474416,
0.0086699184,
-0.157894522,
0.4374380708,
-0.7598237395,
1.1539654732,
0.2218075097,
-0.2041389495,
-0.7113474607,
0.0005986691,
-0.2122823298,
-0.5079684258,
0.6590583324,
-0.264775008,
-0.0042790878,
0.1652789414,
-0.0001359803,
-0.9097023606,
1.2808485031,
0.8421299458,
-0.980227232,
-0.0048162597,
0.4573787451,
0.6410134435,
-0.0182268675,
0.00469088,
0.5979076028,
0.4791653752,
0.459120363,
-1.0311639309,
-0.0675031543,
-0.0008662686,
0.0352873616,
0.395452559,
-0.2898223102,
0.5515031219,
0.1053748205,
-0.2727208138,
-0.3450647891,
0.5378338695,
-0.167771101,
0.5179457664,
0.3827497959,
0.6951751113,
0.7770631909,
0.1820240468,
0.3477740288,
-0.4059261978,
0.1104382873,
1.365216136,
0.0231792368,
0.8172229528,
0.7049640417,
-0.2924121618,
0.1174869835,
0.3530728817,
0.1061986461,
1.1877785921,
0.3317530453,
-0.3392702639,
-0.1295519024,
0.0621255189,
-0.4419666231,
0.6766254902,
0.0572093017,
-0.5086205006,
-0.5086106658,
0.2846231461,
-0.1338021904,
0.1969742924,
0.0514636524,
1.1563425064,
0.0901401788,
-0.5223408937,
1.1723891497,
-0.1370255053,
0.400481075,
-0.4754849374,
-0.1197028905,
-0.1540487707,
-0.0139378244,
-0.1638816446,
-0.3813081384,
0.6399149299,
0.0735246241,
-0.4201340377,
-0.1040530354,
0.3771153688,
-0.911501646,
-0.4193939567,
0.2804896533,
0.4567355812,
0.4324804246,
-0.0420198888,
-0.4777262509,
-0.3066178262,
0.2883464098,
0.2161631882,
0.4186232984,
0.5502242446,
0.2293946892,
0.3653972447,
0.9105442762,
0.2363731116,
0.2575797141,
-0.0798444971,
1.017626524,
-0.4026531875,
-0.4949554801,
-0.9515152574,
0.3190282285,
-0.0770253763,
-0.0581855178,
0.7152916789,
0.5867317915,
0.6465554833,
0.0587505624,
0.8075318336,
0.009377406,
0.6803280711,
-0.4127915204,
0.9885874987,
-0.3931109905,
0.098319754,
-0.506265223,
-0.9168664217,
0.1004133597,
0.3499232829,
-0.2922737002,
-0.2366723716,
0.5093554258,
0.50230968,
-0.1329438537,
0.0573932379,
0.6338694692,
0.0480699912,
0.425142467,
0.586879015,
0.4844068587,
-0.3203486502,
0.8791979551,
-0.5473778248,
-0.5715871453,
0.0048236041,
-0.7541953921,
-0.8600311279,
-0.7549197078,
-0.2777929604,
0.0288257673,
0.17364797,
0.5783533454,
0.5906358957,
-0.5266757011,
-0.0037247422,
-0.2257647067,
0.0493284725,
-0.4771386087,
-0.1319371611,
0.6723976731,
-0.2560461462,
-0.8461756706,
0.823189795,
-0.0484655797,
0.1642575264,
0.0811111927,
0.0956833735,
-0.0366083644,
-0.0911683515,
0.4327047765,
-0.1409612596,
-0.4045556784,
0.0108574666,
-0.0283348653,
0.4443915188,
-0.0335725062,
0.5988406539,
-0.7044165134,
0.5554902554,
0.6448880434,
0.6517737508,
0.4976866245,
0.0875227377,
0.4495585263,
-0.9287756681,
0.1944072992,
0.2368835658,
0.0458238497,
0.2233022749,
-0.3651973009,
0.108280465,
0.3046489358,
-0.513573885,
-0.8630497456,
0.013411019,
-0.7813871503,
-0.1792975664,
1.0413041115,
-0.3145108521,
-0.2038996518,
-0.295004487,
-0.1391423196,
0.8342620134,
-0.6617354751,
1.0970199108,
0.6246638298,
-0.1539659947,
-0.105858162,
-0.5430483818,
0.4953395724,
0.2685036361,
-0.5734009743,
0.4401558042,
0.3613849878,
0.4091443717,
-0.0661488175,
0.3649304509,
-0.2541571259,
-0.0647150055,
0.0287575871,
-0.1874673367,
-0.4997701347,
-0.3504015803,
-0.1625543386,
-0.0369406715,
-0.0883522704,
-0.6853515506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10283v1 | Is augmentation effective to improve prediction in imbalanced text datasets? | 2023-04-20T13:07:31 | 2023-04-20T13:07:31 | Gabriel O. Assunção, Rafael Izbicki, Marcos O. Prates | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | Imbalanced datasets present a significant challenge for machine learning
models, often leading to biased predictions. To address this issue, data
augmentation techniques are widely used in natural language processing (NLP) to
generate new samples for the minority class. However, in this paper, we
challenge the common assumption that data augmentation is always necessary to
improve predictions on imbalanced datasets. Instead, we argue that adjusting
the classifier cutoffs without data augmentation can produce similar results to
oversampling techniques. Our study provides theoretical and empirical evidence
to support this claim. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of the
strengths and limitations of different approaches to dealing with imbalanced
data, and help researchers and practitioners make informed decisions about
which methods to use for a given task. | [
-0.420937866,
-0.4960602224,
-0.0154129695,
0.1207432002,
-0.1720300317,
0.3234063387,
-0.1693885624,
-0.8129714727,
0.1284321696,
0.4271682799,
-0.5452997088,
0.0667908341,
-0.6687732935,
0.2983467579,
-0.4077575803,
0.9829553962,
0.1652463973,
0.2139084339,
-0.6117105484,
-0.3259424865,
-0.9836664796,
-0.5305649042,
-0.2541310787,
-0.7049573064,
0.0087114535,
0.5140264034,
0.9387471676,
0.8129440546,
0.5126751661,
0.2218654007,
-0.1473027319,
0.4268261492,
-0.1614698619,
0.1374757737,
-0.0520633683,
-0.7343674302,
-0.1223186478,
0.0274539739,
0.5991277099,
1.1697800159,
0.120098412,
-0.1918705255,
0.3041860759,
0.8766644001,
-0.8246098757,
-0.2897683382,
-0.8242604733,
0.3647848368,
-0.1710332036,
-0.3998469114,
-0.3033721447,
-0.0763613656,
0.3338373005,
-0.4759916663,
0.5063827634,
0.0170050189,
0.3927785158,
0.5867728591,
-0.3468745649,
-0.0484522395,
-0.802036345,
1.0296626091,
-0.8472992182,
-0.0364032611,
0.4372444451,
0.1829717904,
-0.0375213027,
-0.1111070067,
-0.4945673645,
-0.0239940211,
-0.158967346,
0.110975422,
-0.1351619065,
0.0292528495,
0.7396736741,
0.6929984093,
-0.167345196,
0.4349703491,
-0.6840624213,
-0.0560512692,
0.6406654119,
0.0389673412,
0.3730289042,
0.02171297,
-0.2042805403,
-0.1508808136,
-0.3604338467,
-0.1453374475,
0.6526924372,
0.5323896408,
0.1270735562,
0.8626310825,
-0.1165313944,
1.0618264675,
0.1657034606,
0.1604924351,
0.7594458461,
-0.2864284813,
-0.2112811804,
0.415263623,
0.2280980796,
0.6770194769,
0.306117475,
-0.1522236615,
-0.0878945962,
0.3307905495,
0.4655448794,
-0.5345944166,
-0.1054790691,
0.4012429118,
-0.1652455181,
-0.4528624713,
0.1283694953,
-0.8812366724,
-0.5354278684,
-0.3916745484,
0.1133151278,
-0.3341587782,
-0.1024705917,
0.0801446289,
-0.5156952739,
-0.1240910664,
0.4652866721,
-1.0097159147,
0.2388329804,
0.6398103833,
0.8885213137,
-0.4924602211,
-0.2136770934,
-0.3532333076,
-0.1477993578,
-0.4124339521,
0.7166910172,
-0.7411054969,
-0.4231841564,
-0.0647675395,
-0.165265277,
-0.0264410544,
-0.8273746967,
0.8757789731,
-0.0288466793,
0.4615956247,
-0.2952305973,
-0.8022171855,
0.1073541865,
0.2546834648,
-0.8747833371,
0.9491363764,
0.0756015256,
-1.0984601974,
0.8744491339,
-0.5416380763,
-0.7637146711,
-0.1783233285,
0.0966748148,
-0.7822166681,
0.2134593725,
0.779468894,
0.0339605771,
0.1588647366,
0.0733368099,
-0.4868312478,
-0.3975095451,
0.4290249348,
-0.6161880493,
0.6977878809,
0.1081487685,
-0.2148420066,
-0.3545610905,
-0.6336173415,
0.1761016995,
-0.2400809228,
-0.4332011342,
-0.4310646951,
0.0845171809,
0.0705256239,
0.0161605813,
-0.1570800096,
-0.8287087083,
0.2118596882,
-0.9639244676,
0.1329270005,
0.74701792,
-0.349011302,
0.7619418502,
-0.6243112683,
0.5321058631,
-0.0014917824,
-0.1859701425,
-0.5515931845,
-0.3958650231,
-0.6625944376,
0.0070384396,
0.6775855422,
0.6116870642,
-0.7011025548,
0.5670189857,
-0.1647970378,
-0.269164443,
-0.8002943397,
0.0708435923,
0.0452262871,
0.5377701521,
0.8112204671,
-0.3188631833,
-0.9125566483,
-0.6137070656,
-0.5973544717,
0.0991192535,
-0.0639336556,
0.0862339884,
0.1380581707,
-0.2070846707,
1.154399991,
-0.3149694204,
-0.3681057394,
-0.2136508375,
0.0936022252,
0.0849127099,
0.8746097088,
0.5626969337,
-0.918143034,
-0.2217806429,
0.0504341498,
-0.6565967798,
-0.2228007168,
-0.2984267473,
0.1840946227,
0.1530873477,
0.2963618934,
-0.2591496408,
0.4515425861,
0.4983062446,
-0.131270647,
0.1787382513,
-0.1077354848,
0.2029594034,
-0.8969882727,
-0.3240342736,
0.3256658018,
-0.2910100818,
-0.7303611636,
-0.233708024,
0.2164193541,
0.0381604396,
-0.0618893616,
0.4946019351,
-0.3846388161,
0.0753490105,
-0.8534795046,
-0.179644838,
0.027477812,
-0.1159350723,
-0.1915498525,
0.6437479854,
0.4115034342,
-0.4073448181,
0.2253566682,
0.3153631091,
-0.4340860546,
0.6066259742,
-0.5692413449,
-0.2966086566,
-0.4973441958,
0.288787663,
-0.6640068293,
-0.2378610671,
-0.0241845511,
-0.6701392531,
0.4311035275,
-0.0735719204,
-0.0089315027,
-0.7045168281,
-0.3719767332,
0.3865169883,
0.4452330768,
-0.7383134365,
0.3109798133,
0.5401619077,
-0.0161628425,
-0.9973350763,
-1.2064868212,
0.0567951202,
-0.3109229505,
-0.4351340532,
0.5466486812,
0.0235026702,
-0.2954082787,
-0.1163426414,
-0.2683776021,
-0.0698111355,
0.2260924429,
0.2106878459,
0.2906067669,
0.0570558868,
0.4410557151,
0.2501741946,
-0.1342317611,
-0.0803931728,
-0.3399774432,
0.3538717628,
0.3548894525,
-0.4496727884,
-0.17842713,
0.1131336838,
0.1803711206,
-0.0944460109,
0.6333557367,
0.556055367,
-0.5168466568,
-0.1737468541,
-0.6289873123,
-0.283021152,
-0.4455464184,
0.2839803994,
0.1329982281,
-0.8025187254,
0.1483155042,
0.0849506631,
0.2893288434,
0.496565938,
0.2465145141,
-0.2165487558,
1.1883836985,
0.7294799685,
-0.4438195229,
0.614082098,
-0.0893126726,
0.0316571221,
-0.7114079595,
0.0252735559,
-0.6631989479,
-0.5198848248,
-0.6463161707,
-0.2537754476,
0.1216921359,
-0.2631898522,
0.5044361949,
-0.2330038697,
-0.7969218493,
0.6679959893,
0.6814371347,
0.3143561482,
0.299382627,
0.4406254292,
0.4690784514,
-0.4597961307,
-0.745885551,
-0.0721304864,
1.2671091557,
0.2673782706,
0.6211867332,
-0.5270934105,
0.3766135275,
0.7258232832,
0.3950592875,
-0.8032258749,
-0.1557743847,
-0.1943172514,
-0.7020808458,
-0.3751873374,
-0.5704557896,
-0.9730178714,
0.513548255,
-0.7258991003,
-0.26693663,
0.4613320529,
0.5162462592,
-0.1036464125,
0.3446329534,
-0.7209240198,
0.5542532206,
-0.1220679283,
-0.1113568917,
-0.0627515614,
-0.486926198,
0.274738729,
-0.2748987079,
0.2536955476,
0.0056329011,
0.0725562796,
0.7852365375,
-0.8017455339,
0.6958169937,
-0.3126345873,
0.0502680726,
0.2144256383,
-0.5283033848,
0.5501095057,
-0.382208854,
-0.4818783998,
-0.0713711828,
-0.3754471242,
-0.6016349196,
-0.8367415667,
0.524200201,
-0.5752289891,
-0.3640411496,
-0.5401386023,
-0.5813794732,
-0.4003008008,
-0.1238258556,
0.3093466163,
0.3636885881,
0.1094183847,
0.3616954386,
0.3386145532,
0.0892533213,
0.3694001138,
-0.0206967201,
0.1122568846,
-0.531303823,
0.8377293348,
0.4991571307,
0.3772997558,
0.1520991176,
0.1495099962,
-0.0817934722,
-0.7782570124,
-0.5786377788,
-0.2631300688,
-0.4928918481,
-0.2132639289,
-0.7901256084,
0.0190174375,
-0.3517263532,
-0.2510518432,
-0.0770015121,
-0.8189308047,
-0.0898877904,
-0.5692756176,
0.2992869914,
0.1041090861,
-0.0933224484,
0.5232261419,
-0.6086243987,
0.192070201,
0.094708167,
0.041380778,
-0.0869649276,
-0.5463033319,
-0.4349898994,
0.5086029768,
-0.284848839,
-0.5721763372,
0.3758945763,
0.3702099323,
0.6016919613,
0.0810082257,
0.1834402233,
0.7597596049,
-0.3538943529,
0.5810436606,
0.2474678457,
-0.7680745721,
0.5880742073,
-0.1309843957,
0.5307273865,
0.6989834309,
0.1718066037,
-0.532086432,
-0.5605081916,
-0.712787807,
-1.0001224279,
0.8200044632,
0.4850597084,
0.4083026946,
0.35572806,
0.1981215179,
0.3812684715,
0.4944930971,
-0.9038123488,
-0.363496393,
-0.254155308,
-0.2718604207,
-0.1541045755,
-0.0934650823,
0.1963350922,
-0.2974311709,
0.7148938775,
-0.212894246,
-0.1300114542,
0.1503293812,
-0.1016348749,
-0.4980888069,
0.2768182456,
0.1399969459,
0.7524789572,
-0.1196909174,
-0.0464825742,
0.5621391535,
-0.5329291821,
0.0538879596,
0.2788790464,
-0.4556365609,
0.2079745233,
0.4348618388,
0.908524394,
-0.3039624095,
-0.8087592125,
0.4444262981,
0.2549353838,
-0.0670398399,
0.0851665065,
0.1634579152,
-0.6540720463,
0.0338875242,
0.6906003356,
0.6922177672,
0.2268496007,
-0.3239309192,
0.2503059208,
0.6153014302,
-0.5977681279,
0.2125691324,
0.4091511071,
0.1947207153,
-0.0470620431,
0.3919540048,
0.2172764689,
-0.3049705923,
0.8268420696,
0.5866544247,
0.5924863815,
-0.3255004585,
0.224058494,
0.2808649838,
0.7566024065,
-0.2270299941,
-0.0955073684,
-0.0318318643,
-0.863294363,
-0.8229751587,
-0.4925477803,
-0.5754602551,
-0.0322830901,
-0.5514290929,
0.3142102361,
-0.1710222065,
-0.2505746782,
0.2299811542,
-0.2155821025,
-0.3226646185,
0.6030435562,
0.0830104426,
0.7420401573,
-0.9788252115,
0.3174567819,
0.5199269056,
-0.0425998457,
-0.2224846929,
0.2466739267,
-0.1825526804,
-0.4950346947,
0.127853781,
0.6048886776,
0.445677489,
-0.3751119971,
-0.5081068873,
-0.6654946804,
0.3505606651,
0.3345755637,
-0.4191310406,
0.0665328428,
0.420196563,
0.5874704123,
-0.2492607534,
0.2787612677,
0.4563775063,
0.52606529,
0.029684633,
-0.7939056158,
-0.2114742696,
-0.3149214089,
-0.0713368729,
0.3679955304,
-0.1254645437,
0.7511088252,
-0.3248438835,
-0.0850423723,
-0.1671293527,
0.6369803548,
-0.0628662929,
0.5988501906,
0.7205350995,
0.7153154016,
0.9492256045,
-0.2105144858,
1.1068606377,
0.2026100606,
0.1386265606,
1.167067647,
-0.1569383889,
0.3207640052,
0.3103200793,
-0.4285628498,
0.0170504227,
0.7284290791,
-0.3381353021,
0.2953527868,
-0.0570328869,
-0.0596110933,
-0.2453002483,
-0.242010504,
-0.711610496,
0.2754220068,
0.3970950544,
-0.393617034,
-0.1754388958,
0.4265964031,
-0.1205768809,
0.2535022199,
-0.3914318979,
0.6859096885,
-0.1581498832,
-0.6521419287,
0.4642688334,
0.0452850536,
1.0885316133,
0.0602407344,
0.048940219,
-0.0528431907,
0.1034140661,
-0.5618160963,
-0.7880323529,
0.5007699728,
-0.1428584456,
-0.4216398597,
-0.1727278084,
1.0822857618,
-0.4408944845,
-0.8587200642,
-0.0547217838,
0.4728436768,
-0.2590516508,
-0.2509995103,
-0.5758383274,
-0.3144779801,
0.3505464792,
0.2461480945,
0.1757115424,
0.2386655957,
-0.0560069717,
0.6376361251,
0.8188595176,
0.2559334636,
0.067154184,
-0.0363872834,
0.8584879637,
-0.3559955955,
-0.5358439088,
-1.061416626,
0.4905379117,
-0.6018423438,
-0.1121592,
0.909403801,
0.669958353,
1.0579175949,
0.1067286581,
1.3561569452,
0.2670876384,
0.9272764325,
-0.4790062308,
-0.0313555822,
-0.5288752317,
0.2788839936,
-0.4075381756,
-0.9547325969,
-0.4226327538,
0.4148694277,
-0.4730582237,
0.2267641723,
0.1979337931,
0.467767626,
-0.1408179104,
0.4575485289,
0.0535958298,
-0.1236172765,
0.0401253328,
0.0196222644,
0.9068737626,
-0.508284986,
0.3541266024,
-0.4234641194,
-0.2250976413,
-0.2976363599,
-0.4757688642,
-0.8579826951,
-0.1327084601,
-0.3696602583,
-0.3020741642,
0.2479596436,
0.8117657304,
0.4627310038,
-0.813239038,
0.0358163789,
-0.1582039297,
0.3312371671,
-0.2156686187,
-0.2450698912,
-0.1624331623,
-0.4884867072,
-0.9912573695,
0.1909595877,
0.153519392,
0.4231089652,
0.043309778,
0.2289494872,
0.0133482916,
-0.1459321082,
0.4141846895,
0.2984987199,
-0.2744054496,
0.119352214,
-0.2695164084,
0.3225600421,
0.3427579701,
0.9154708982,
-1.0353246927,
0.7196787596,
0.4279877841,
0.9745227098,
0.328461498,
0.4462196827,
0.8112313747,
-0.9720373154,
0.3953358531,
0.3094026744,
0.3046537936,
0.7350879908,
-0.4327165484,
0.6198511124,
0.1665664613,
-0.3196602762,
-1.0471563339,
-0.1341148168,
-0.4994220734,
-0.3392743766,
0.8519459367,
0.369582504,
-0.089913398,
-0.2065117657,
-0.3491058052,
0.0804993212,
-0.4819077253,
0.8048253655,
0.6642494202,
0.0206420105,
0.0119801657,
-0.3979240358,
0.5235729814,
0.7653411627,
-1.088765502,
0.0918793604,
0.6550554633,
-0.4057862163,
0.2706092596,
0.155710578,
0.1445193887,
0.0837272406,
-0.2992824912,
-0.2491038889,
0.1048185155,
-0.0208896436,
-0.2976408303,
0.0948929042,
-0.2073658854,
-0.2137196809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10256v1 | Indian Sign Language Recognition Using Mediapipe Holistic | 2023-04-20T12:25:47 | 2023-04-20T12:25:47 | Dr. Velmathi G, Kaushal Goyal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Deaf individuals confront significant communication obstacles on a daily
basis. Their inability to hear makes it difficult for them to communicate with
those who do not understand sign language. Moreover, it presents difficulties
in educational, occupational, and social contexts. By providing alternative
communication channels, technology can play a crucial role in overcoming these
obstacles. One such technology that can facilitate communication between deaf
and hearing individuals is sign language recognition. We will create a robust
system for sign language recognition in order to convert Indian Sign Language
to text or speech. We will evaluate the proposed system and compare CNN and
LSTM models. Since there are both static and gesture sign languages, a robust
model is required to distinguish between them. In this study, we discovered
that a CNN model captures letters and characters for recognition of static sign
language better than an LSTM model, but it outperforms CNN by monitoring hands,
faces, and pose in gesture sign language phrases and sentences. The creation of
a text-to-sign language paradigm is essential since it will enhance the sign
language-dependent deaf and hard-of-hearing population's communication skills.
Even though the sign-to-text translation is just one side of communication, not
all deaf or hard-of-hearing people are proficient in reading or writing text.
Some may have difficulty comprehending written language due to educational or
literacy issues. Therefore, a text-to-sign language paradigm would allow them
to comprehend text-based information and participate in a variety of social,
educational, and professional settings.
Keywords: deaf and hard-of-hearing, DHH, Indian sign language, CNN, LSTM,
static and gesture sign languages, text-to-sign language model, MediaPipe
Holistic, sign language recognition, SLR, SLT | [
0.0403833427,
-0.412751317,
0.0515648574,
0.18936719,
-0.6107022762,
0.2834084034,
-0.0298809987,
-0.5094487667,
0.1582535654,
0.2813079059,
-0.2248039991,
-0.5954865813,
-1.0207842588,
0.1300180554,
-0.323220402,
0.6042006612,
-0.0899535865,
0.2050792128,
0.3884901106,
-0.2473692447,
-0.4326796234,
-0.1444713771,
-0.7142489552,
-0.2905474603,
-0.0751350448,
0.2888926268,
0.3042719662,
0.2683871686,
0.7059422731,
0.3043139577,
-0.3036549389,
0.1754614413,
-0.0649189055,
0.2485300452,
0.3146499395,
-0.0137770167,
-0.2040568888,
0.0199768804,
0.6894979477,
0.4271215796,
0.0543740392,
0.1647800952,
0.0113066835,
0.4281259477,
-0.3735480309,
0.2709928751,
-0.3528705537,
0.2699307203,
-0.4907035232,
-0.2789254189,
-0.1908645481,
-0.3429828882,
0.0885756165,
-0.2026013434,
-0.1473641098,
0.1349274665,
0.4530356228,
0.3137699664,
-0.7283889055,
-0.6560598016,
-1.0116279125,
0.3507475555,
-0.8742599487,
0.8389320374,
0.5755372643,
0.238311559,
0.0560050085,
-0.3127482235,
-0.6334403157,
-0.4378730357,
0.0781182945,
0.314262867,
0.292090565,
-0.0470381789,
0.1902413815,
0.4511858523,
-0.7839137316,
0.0382646769,
-0.8778688312,
-0.4987744391,
0.3561288714,
0.0770199373,
0.537985146,
-0.4358130991,
-0.4181254208,
0.0646333247,
-0.3651388586,
-0.019379694,
0.0210887957,
0.6545193791,
-0.449277699,
0.5443322062,
-0.1668510735,
0.9710439444,
-0.1419897676,
-0.6856548786,
0.0647999197,
-0.0361943282,
-0.1915749758,
0.3649657071,
0.5743721724,
-0.0710665509,
0.1474156529,
0.0751963854,
-0.1797903627,
0.1715260297,
-0.4370325804,
-0.6223087311,
0.3099003434,
-0.082014598,
-0.6911066175,
-0.054344967,
-0.188613221,
-0.3338298202,
-0.7349801064,
-0.4730920196,
0.2103509307,
-0.5202872753,
-0.7696239948,
0.2032818943,
-0.01811352,
0.5951328278,
0.1853657216,
-0.7713772655,
0.3315624595,
0.5038725734,
1.2248079777,
-0.2471817136,
0.0278053824,
-0.57368958,
0.020576952,
0.1388584524,
0.4780321717,
-0.4482065141,
-0.6392058134,
0.0791646019,
-0.4462741911,
-0.0360348672,
-0.2324739248,
0.6978887916,
-0.6525130272,
0.2256014645,
0.295332104,
-0.5230681896,
0.1569319516,
0.0958465636,
-0.5558458567,
0.5321547985,
-0.1424955577,
-0.4705219269,
0.342615366,
-0.6768370867,
-0.7212575674,
0.3322704732,
-0.100815773,
-0.548556149,
-0.0185576789,
-0.1361409277,
0.634303391,
-0.1378206909,
-0.0853460953,
-0.0015440818,
-0.4000398517,
0.0124940863,
-0.4541202784,
1.1687545776,
0.7392419577,
-0.3442981839,
-0.1260875314,
-0.9380021095,
-0.0605115667,
-0.1072490215,
-0.6006337404,
-0.3407642841,
-0.1508018374,
0.4537548125,
0.4488431513,
-0.0539286248,
-0.6145677567,
-0.1454429179,
-0.3072991669,
0.6770877838,
0.3234783709,
-0.2290626615,
0.2861573994,
0.2833867371,
0.3951262534,
0.1197130457,
0.1316077858,
-0.0091133192,
-0.5496576428,
-0.5194301605,
-0.1970990002,
0.3219384551,
0.7262297273,
-0.5761210918,
0.2030128688,
-0.0307602901,
-0.2980124652,
-0.4097333252,
0.1670797616,
0.6849792004,
0.5414094329,
0.1081514731,
-0.5086041093,
-0.5177046061,
-0.3499515951,
-0.0532455221,
-0.4636360109,
0.0818528756,
-0.2027157843,
0.1480154544,
0.1553373039,
0.4129032791,
-0.1754329801,
-0.8442258239,
-0.0476920009,
0.1087599099,
0.1816477329,
0.3782847226,
-0.1430727541,
-1.0583480597,
-0.6569465995,
0.1723124534,
-0.64710778,
0.0787965879,
-0.0057496233,
0.2803841531,
0.209294185,
0.8432801962,
-0.5432441831,
0.5500108004,
0.6503763795,
-0.7805879116,
0.4512396455,
0.0590692461,
0.1564060003,
-1.0999622345,
0.0990060419,
0.1064656824,
-0.3162664175,
-0.743518889,
-0.119090043,
0.0258239545,
-0.6961362958,
-0.7744012475,
0.6515378356,
-0.9316442609,
-0.1947859526,
-0.4032937586,
0.2462560683,
-0.3820493519,
0.3348315358,
0.3129601181,
0.6495239735,
0.574184835,
-0.5304444432,
0.1825877577,
0.4547292888,
-0.3915590644,
0.9149022698,
-0.5039146543,
0.0609141812,
0.0512320399,
-0.012736883,
-0.9349079728,
-0.0616785735,
0.6185598969,
-0.7006183863,
0.6030837893,
0.1855285466,
-0.111823529,
-0.3344126046,
0.0326430202,
0.399158448,
0.5715579987,
-0.2424055785,
0.5904268026,
0.4551092386,
0.004516325,
-0.3040072918,
-0.6361503601,
0.2767149806,
-0.1917139143,
-0.4036806226,
0.0414560735,
0.0571999513,
-0.0614995994,
-0.3323590457,
-0.203768447,
-0.2157079279,
-0.1325608194,
0.1816103607,
0.1808928251,
-0.2176653743,
0.3214755952,
-0.0826581717,
-0.3086518049,
-0.1984909028,
-0.1805829406,
0.3169837594,
-0.4035602212,
-0.630360961,
-0.9537495971,
0.3597057164,
0.7995656729,
-0.3681446016,
0.3519924879,
0.7807894945,
-0.569881618,
0.4019623995,
-0.3606752455,
-0.0671738163,
-0.4151009321,
0.2167605609,
-0.3272915184,
-0.80674541,
0.2028935552,
-0.2813209295,
-0.0055118874,
0.1482264698,
0.7003289461,
-0.0135923028,
0.8418930173,
0.4066397846,
0.037396457,
0.6446974874,
0.1691984534,
0.3624911308,
-0.8986849785,
-0.160890922,
-0.543260932,
-0.2751894891,
-0.2800882161,
-0.080178231,
0.3407773972,
-0.0410630554,
-0.0538432561,
0.5398545265,
-0.8906763792,
0.0447391532,
0.526468277,
0.4105244577,
0.7844557762,
-0.0453909785,
-0.0459760614,
-0.0695270598,
-0.2229514122,
-0.7703213692,
0.8816734552,
0.3510063291,
0.4704195559,
0.2939605713,
0.655589819,
0.4435744882,
0.4778266847,
-1.011269331,
0.647734344,
-0.2488609552,
-0.7432354093,
-0.4559887052,
0.0745635256,
-0.7455880046,
0.1546373218,
-0.2373052239,
-0.4862315357,
0.2757008672,
0.173930496,
-0.1346744001,
0.2492631972,
-0.9959492087,
0.4714252353,
-0.3127600551,
0.0172017179,
-0.0423497781,
-0.7831976414,
0.5005280972,
0.0156272613,
0.0872424617,
-0.1758151799,
0.0010271053,
0.7608855367,
-0.4056484699,
1.1857578754,
-0.0920228884,
-0.1419795454,
0.3399299085,
0.0376867615,
0.219074741,
-0.1468652189,
-0.2238892466,
0.1126729175,
-0.0828324854,
-0.2279660106,
-0.177052483,
0.4271289408,
-0.6639344692,
-0.5709643364,
-0.6626396775,
-0.2556355298,
-0.2478234768,
0.5025650859,
0.2126156688,
0.5844289064,
-0.2463364005,
-0.0875424072,
0.4902478755,
0.2897555828,
0.5680462122,
0.3323893547,
-0.0692089871,
-0.2339107096,
0.7121094465,
-0.0776143968,
0.3116780221,
0.3209850192,
0.2277717739,
-0.5906037688,
-0.7942095995,
-0.4261999428,
0.3168433607,
-0.6365056038,
-0.2226781994,
-0.1911934018,
-0.2735451162,
-0.3604755998,
0.2065509558,
0.1848614812,
-0.3740492165,
-0.4048180878,
0.1228664592,
0.4416161776,
0.4400506318,
-0.1003497392,
0.1865532845,
-0.6937820315,
0.4233869612,
0.5548120737,
0.4377183914,
-0.0369271114,
-0.5126442313,
-0.0797851533,
-0.0335314088,
-0.4431258738,
-0.846645534,
0.0851704925,
0.5000063777,
0.0541726835,
0.5474470258,
0.1379872859,
0.5228701234,
-0.5411607027,
0.5352816582,
0.7827857137,
-1.1597741842,
0.5095086098,
-0.2151139528,
0.4434938431,
0.2209793627,
0.2346858978,
-0.9579606056,
-0.3550806642,
-0.1850841045,
-0.2906676531,
0.5314224362,
0.3652525544,
0.1647034585,
0.0721718445,
0.0128157716,
0.0248973388,
0.0547901019,
-0.7493038177,
-0.030244926,
-0.4659125805,
-0.4290395081,
0.2742024958,
0.0498959795,
0.0704431161,
-0.3154584467,
0.4282251596,
0.1421556026,
0.2271295488,
0.2322067171,
-0.2049390078,
-0.0266607739,
0.3576412499,
0.9997056127,
0.4040499926,
0.1376599669,
0.3509760201,
0.1041837707,
-1.0473635197,
0.2430204302,
-0.0688513294,
-0.0004118087,
0.2173431963,
0.4406535327,
0.9220172167,
0.0171992034,
-0.4930954874,
0.2296451777,
-0.0015678438,
-0.2249398679,
-0.2959524095,
-0.1307977438,
0.3844572902,
0.1940091252,
0.2850918174,
0.2936252952,
0.1047449112,
-0.5052579045,
0.078062892,
0.4171743095,
-0.5628778338,
-0.2800123394,
0.7991555929,
0.6308298707,
-1.2759472132,
0.3834398091,
-0.0140828043,
-0.4803702831,
0.4076482058,
0.6359797716,
0.9091804624,
-0.6839153171,
0.3475680947,
0.2844424546,
-0.0075620976,
0.1323756725,
0.360486269,
-0.3688416779,
-0.4845232666,
-0.1155276671,
-0.488070786,
-0.4278391004,
0.050989069,
-0.2847025096,
0.5921077728,
-0.4855068028,
-0.2570648491,
-0.1337358654,
-0.0478099026,
-0.638628006,
0.5187024474,
0.4283997715,
0.8060132861,
-0.8732511997,
0.6121898293,
0.5506957769,
-0.3838205636,
-0.7251773477,
0.1292643398,
0.1461980194,
-0.9157692194,
0.8137941957,
-0.005377132,
-0.4966788292,
0.3052919209,
-0.0166330785,
-0.7600619793,
0.9346536398,
-0.0438652448,
-0.5650906563,
0.3859568536,
0.3656693399,
0.7170578241,
-0.1766883582,
0.1437770575,
0.3136503696,
0.4837189615,
0.2449281812,
-1.1823093891,
0.2380288541,
-0.1532627791,
0.1432725787,
0.2790307701,
-0.6344265938,
0.2334154993,
-0.1309871078,
-0.5592725277,
-0.1231332794,
0.8892382383,
0.3997989893,
0.619603157,
0.4962549806,
0.1447606236,
0.5680584908,
0.1330162883,
0.471413523,
-0.2212475538,
0.1186713874,
0.5372974277,
-0.3829280138,
1.0205662251,
0.6582862139,
-0.3300051987,
0.084918797,
0.5901194215,
0.5158404708,
0.4025512934,
0.0814190805,
-0.5666980147,
-0.1212818846,
-0.0556531474,
-0.2932564616,
0.7995855212,
0.3133315444,
-0.1066151112,
-0.371024847,
0.3119613826,
-0.0633574575,
0.25640288,
-0.3517765403,
0.4746685922,
0.5392739773,
-0.3014675081,
0.9209672809,
-0.1475820839,
0.8922459483,
-0.5354613662,
0.017164994,
0.1191638634,
0.1219789162,
-0.3093931377,
-0.686940372,
0.6733283401,
-0.1564470083,
0.0881088451,
-0.3864296675,
1.2581461668,
-0.4803576469,
-0.5648759604,
-0.0159349255,
0.5034937859,
0.4003367424,
0.3541885912,
-0.6610968113,
0.3752702177,
-0.275916487,
-0.0613715872,
-0.0187335182,
0.212736249,
-0.2395336181,
0.6697705984,
0.683226347,
0.2054530829,
0.0075556175,
0.1631239951,
0.2780922651,
-0.5428491235,
-0.7032740116,
-0.5528495312,
0.4631045759,
-0.1790313721,
-0.6746477485,
0.5737420321,
0.2570903003,
0.4042562842,
-0.3801990449,
0.6057448387,
-0.1477451026,
0.5362045169,
-0.5216576457,
0.9762227535,
-0.5164889693,
0.0316673629,
-0.3455123305,
-0.8254497647,
-0.7737876773,
0.54831779,
-0.2300788462,
0.0832161084,
0.5816942453,
0.4627687633,
-0.1444982439,
0.0644109696,
0.5396540165,
-0.0996149704,
0.1408057213,
0.4187691212,
0.4870730937,
-0.6326987743,
0.821006,
0.3717364371,
-0.4006869495,
-0.2663917243,
-0.8800170422,
-0.8113672137,
-1.0396895409,
-0.4308971763,
-0.2555941045,
-0.1015876681,
0.6977620721,
0.7167703509,
-0.7837000489,
-0.4487910569,
-0.0760249943,
0.2087358683,
-0.2234402299,
-0.1913013756,
0.5535885096,
0.1475480348,
-0.764216423,
0.0939177498,
0.4155928791,
0.1170519814,
-0.4046929479,
-0.3467255533,
-0.3093061447,
-0.1540175974,
0.7417936921,
0.8724656105,
-0.6142841578,
-0.2272041589,
-0.0181810074,
-0.2023061812,
-0.0246041771,
0.8800348043,
-0.5095126033,
0.4345911443,
0.5690297484,
0.4683617949,
0.4523289204,
-0.2539201379,
0.1347645819,
-0.4879134297,
0.1600704789,
0.2568283677,
0.2239327282,
0.5353420377,
-0.4323349297,
0.19389759,
0.3582923412,
-0.2884459198,
-0.7169454098,
0.4853315949,
-1.1132911444,
0.0459487475,
1.0535783768,
0.2752379477,
-0.1588396728,
-0.6384958625,
-0.5391884446,
0.5569347739,
-0.1934533566,
0.8742843866,
0.6243109107,
-0.0526529141,
-0.5140736699,
-0.2061970532,
0.4648020864,
0.2485145181,
-0.6252807379,
-0.1530389637,
0.1352515966,
0.2564020753,
0.353446275,
0.941980958,
-0.2510882318,
0.2374920547,
-0.2321396023,
0.0521584041,
-0.293972671,
0.154561758,
-0.2778441906,
-0.0302957334,
0.0789294541,
-0.557128787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10220v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10220v1 | Effective Open Intent Classification with K-center Contrastive Learning and Adjustable Decision Boundary | 2023-04-20T11:35:06 | 2023-04-20T11:35:06 | Xiaokang Liu, Jianquan Li, Jingjing Mu, Min Yang, Ruifeng Xu, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T01, I.2.1 | Open intent classification, which aims to correctly classify the known
intents into their corresponding classes while identifying the new unknown
(open) intents, is an essential but challenging task in dialogue systems. In
this paper, we introduce novel K-center contrastive learning and adjustable
decision boundary learning (CLAB) to improve the effectiveness of open intent
classification. First, we pre-train a feature encoder on the labeled training
instances, which transfers knowledge from known intents to unknown intents.
Specifically, we devise a K-center contrastive learning algorithm to learn
discriminative and balanced intent features, improving the generalization of
the model for recognizing open intents. Second, we devise an adjustable
decision boundary learning method with expanding and shrinking (ADBES) to
determine the suitable decision conditions. Concretely, we learn a decision
boundary for each known intent class, which consists of a decision center and
the radius of the decision boundary. We then expand the radius of the decision
boundary to accommodate more in-class instances if the out-of-class instances
are far from the decision boundary; otherwise, we shrink the radius of the
decision boundary. Extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets clearly
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method for open intent classification. For
reproducibility, we submit the code at: https://github.com/lxk00/CLAP | [
-0.538857758,
-0.5967796445,
0.5446737409,
-0.1865595579,
-0.1464912593,
-0.152759552,
-0.5193251371,
-0.2142290175,
0.0629901662,
0.6434511542,
-0.4074288607,
-0.7890068889,
-0.490878582,
-0.4455500841,
0.2575413287,
0.8735873103,
-0.0858283192,
0.0239865147,
0.0625644252,
-0.6804442406,
-0.9667084217,
-0.0626838207,
-0.5477389097,
-0.2147209048,
0.074198477,
0.7074269056,
0.3733361363,
0.2840960622,
0.1705761254,
0.2168812007,
-0.095338136,
0.3329969645,
-0.7043505311,
0.1342163384,
-0.0852729455,
-0.3617952466,
-0.231362462,
-0.0975142494,
0.4364871383,
0.7081190348,
-0.224097237,
-0.0338842608,
0.0849329382,
0.7031190395,
-0.897333324,
0.3893207908,
-0.6225120425,
-0.0035405862,
0.1197287291,
-0.0595212094,
-0.8254785538,
-0.6832872033,
0.6863609552,
-0.5000278354,
-0.0922435075,
-0.186819911,
0.4359294772,
0.2377182841,
-0.480774343,
-0.8308997154,
-0.7073690295,
0.7841451764,
-0.3403964341,
0.7876428366,
0.0166973192,
0.6166509986,
-0.2379836589,
-0.7058638334,
-0.2567192912,
0.0055027022,
-0.2013887167,
0.0827400684,
-0.0725470558,
0.2604948282,
0.1752137244,
0.3452799618,
-0.3755025566,
-0.004731908,
-0.4762328565,
-0.3375658989,
0.2638670206,
0.0210696589,
0.1921281219,
0.4840197563,
-0.6016460061,
-0.1356939077,
-0.2314117253,
0.8077614903,
0.1476729065,
0.2825780511,
0.0217492618,
0.1326628327,
-0.3562019765,
0.7000766397,
0.4846577346,
-0.272289902,
0.2907396853,
0.3246253729,
-0.1721125692,
0.4676819444,
0.3247215152,
0.5584596395,
-0.0583407879,
0.1607321352,
0.0401427969,
-0.081486918,
0.2815205753,
-0.8487858772,
-0.1589956284,
0.1802037507,
-0.6000753045,
0.0928621069,
-0.0387778617,
-0.5770391822,
-0.3091755211,
-0.2549960613,
0.350527972,
-0.5825273395,
-0.0160342418,
0.3743321896,
0.132185027,
0.2865697742,
0.7872934937,
-0.6269329786,
0.498434633,
0.146464631,
0.6937528253,
-0.0963325053,
0.1411557943,
-0.5274743438,
-0.1306263506,
-0.1219591126,
0.5760012865,
-0.6549997926,
-0.1793553978,
0.0531794205,
-0.0990641043,
-0.2007581145,
-0.535169661,
0.7900105119,
-0.6522262692,
0.3678310215,
0.2477098256,
-0.4726013541,
-0.7127694488,
0.162648946,
-0.6451236606,
0.3518929183,
0.1493547112,
-0.3221383691,
0.3482341766,
-1.1007435322,
-0.2573311329,
0.0975399837,
-0.0312518738,
-0.4135456681,
-0.15807347,
0.0570433699,
0.221714884,
0.2928721309,
0.0872214139,
-0.2891579568,
-0.1873351038,
0.3952684999,
-0.2492807359,
0.7838863134,
0.3081069887,
-0.1814148724,
0.3168900907,
-0.4718014598,
0.2505838275,
-0.2367762625,
-0.3828177452,
-0.4369023442,
-0.2919197679,
-0.652423203,
0.0032520967,
0.2500164509,
-0.6149942279,
0.1364026815,
-0.2701423466,
0.0229831152,
0.6716946363,
0.0732041076,
0.8198850155,
-0.0790230259,
0.0582397766,
0.1778787822,
0.3320716023,
-0.132984519,
-0.5700544119,
-0.7587246299,
-0.3881586492,
0.3608852625,
0.5043999553,
-0.5441639423,
0.6211963892,
0.12093243,
-0.4647413492,
-0.6052130461,
-0.1474353969,
0.5638282299,
0.4852388203,
0.3654584885,
-0.7362210751,
-0.2657554746,
-0.6186540723,
-0.1663317829,
0.054357145,
0.2153560519,
0.8725455999,
0.1025210917,
-0.2317347229,
1.0398590565,
-1.0358620882,
-0.6095504165,
-0.1006907523,
0.0279053356,
0.2257565707,
0.1202972978,
0.5131416321,
-0.9369111657,
-0.8360132575,
0.1733959317,
-0.3975289762,
-0.124358952,
-0.002537674,
-0.3842393458,
0.0618115701,
0.334574163,
-0.5142899156,
0.7396169305,
-0.0293873269,
-0.2253271341,
0.6831482649,
0.0223380141,
0.1946941167,
-0.5864266157,
-0.2014048845,
0.0055101444,
0.0037867615,
-1.179086566,
-0.4307458997,
0.182755962,
0.1024812609,
-0.7553712726,
0.6311680079,
-0.3796826005,
0.2737564147,
-0.31030792,
0.2535704374,
-0.2663213611,
0.7889739275,
0.2235821187,
0.3318713009,
0.4712622166,
-1.0654804707,
0.2186053544,
0.5952108502,
-0.5591669679,
0.5071837902,
0.038393423,
0.2247488052,
-0.1345751435,
0.4367311299,
-1.1962009668,
-0.276076138,
0.5338993669,
-0.5039460659,
0.2029815316,
-0.1655771583,
0.3743919134,
-0.1248472333,
-0.2517924309,
0.4991932809,
0.7611678839,
-0.9520725608,
0.7459706664,
0.3298000395,
-0.0895278081,
-0.5675204396,
-0.0924042091,
-0.8210570812,
-0.2476822287,
-0.3697924912,
0.0594347045,
-0.1738449931,
-0.0919509754,
-0.1745456457,
-0.2201844305,
-0.3203540444,
-0.0746015385,
0.2260404527,
-0.0612905733,
-0.0883063003,
0.229474932,
0.2358481437,
0.1093641669,
-0.1587335467,
-0.1811000705,
0.6910328865,
-0.1883496642,
-0.2220706791,
-0.455993861,
-0.076145187,
0.6929291487,
-0.3318823874,
0.5289571285,
0.5600866079,
-0.2500188947,
-0.5000634193,
-0.3822755516,
-0.2489864677,
-0.4521078765,
0.1462894678,
-0.4014242291,
-0.9448336363,
0.49529773,
-0.5803141594,
0.3206399381,
-0.0837002695,
0.4176682234,
0.2966064215,
0.8649603128,
0.6574558616,
0.3498972058,
0.6689175367,
-0.1188949198,
0.436045289,
-1.064302206,
-0.2483861595,
-0.148390159,
-0.4124088287,
-0.2135144174,
-0.2466840297,
0.5323508382,
0.2966878116,
-0.0243060216,
0.1947002858,
-0.6294304132,
0.3705747128,
0.5194126368,
0.6656284332,
0.0825700089,
-0.1601048857,
-0.2934523225,
-0.0800555944,
-0.4231337905,
-0.370732367,
1.0074678659,
0.4590648711,
0.6585668325,
0.4182819724,
0.6371197701,
0.2446323931,
0.4939965904,
-0.9461839795,
0.6167037487,
0.0400085114,
-0.3477642238,
-0.431782037,
-0.2478200942,
-0.897785902,
0.422357142,
0.0070369677,
-1.0307216644,
0.3490336239,
0.1421238631,
-0.4814037979,
0.3652949631,
-1.014115572,
0.7591006756,
-0.4186161757,
-0.1948612481,
-0.1241662577,
-0.7259337902,
0.3211798072,
0.1080789864,
0.0430639833,
-0.0297496598,
0.145746246,
0.6669453979,
-0.1443264782,
1.0681682825,
-0.5479238629,
-0.0819668174,
0.5719231963,
-0.0595832616,
0.396419704,
-0.0143974386,
0.1045405343,
-0.1061135009,
-0.6293501854,
-0.1770613939,
-0.7265056372,
0.4079726636,
-0.5473248959,
-0.4514474571,
-0.0455374122,
-0.5655580163,
-0.2172613442,
0.5632442832,
0.0682624876,
0.5789734125,
-0.550957799,
0.4727898836,
1.0369069576,
-0.2256361693,
0.2062855661,
0.7637242675,
0.0062642666,
-0.6345638037,
0.6429020166,
-0.2157087624,
0.5004354119,
0.2488473952,
0.2397502214,
-0.464176774,
-0.5957927108,
-0.2461520731,
0.0281556733,
-0.8208586574,
-0.0657804757,
-0.563873291,
-0.2891795039,
-0.4490681589,
-0.3464271128,
-0.1687299162,
-0.0000637642,
-0.2070625573,
0.2562279403,
0.0341511108,
0.3609494269,
0.2270624489,
0.5579854846,
-0.6481283903,
0.1184066683,
0.1556071341,
0.7446130514,
-0.1057767496,
-0.5800398588,
-0.0931169689,
0.1706864089,
-0.7395675182,
-0.7340616584,
0.163255319,
0.1700089276,
0.9523133039,
0.9155140519,
0.7204453945,
0.141096279,
-0.3141989708,
0.4170701504,
0.5700042248,
-0.6598409414,
0.6423025727,
-0.0635583922,
0.520337522,
0.6497252584,
0.6299612522,
-0.3633923531,
-0.1287254393,
-0.5850402713,
-0.4968725741,
1.0213149786,
0.2082144767,
-0.2777064741,
0.1930646002,
0.1546110809,
0.5189754963,
0.2484554797,
-0.6722810864,
-0.3084347248,
-0.0688703507,
-0.4924536645,
0.1359127164,
-0.0821413621,
-0.0183708481,
-0.0830687732,
0.6553022861,
-0.3003943264,
0.1315863431,
0.2650861144,
-0.255267024,
0.083427988,
0.7939691544,
0.7545130253,
0.370590359,
-0.4841597974,
-0.2597275674,
0.3330602944,
-0.7114232183,
0.0528347269,
-0.135975942,
-0.2557095885,
-0.0555166006,
-0.310718745,
1.2563056946,
-0.048039671,
-0.7409007549,
0.4811608791,
-0.3677688241,
-0.3417936265,
-0.2136244476,
0.3101921976,
-0.4426528513,
0.4230258167,
-0.1026207209,
0.290014863,
0.4638222158,
-0.6343747377,
0.226895839,
0.3743090928,
-0.863355577,
0.0351867229,
-0.1085901335,
0.5848078132,
-0.3819029033,
0.3206305802,
-0.3676621616,
-0.856526792,
0.335631907,
0.4210904539,
0.9814076424,
-0.6129952073,
0.2847664356,
0.5171038508,
0.1317303032,
0.2361487597,
0.0926485434,
-0.5296276212,
-0.9118247032,
0.1754381806,
-0.3583995104,
-0.593531847,
0.3129312396,
-0.7295029163,
0.4852404594,
-0.485863924,
-0.0711422488,
-0.1288172305,
-0.2726184428,
-0.3590477407,
0.1620649099,
-0.0346684568,
0.8064522743,
-0.5326617956,
0.517226994,
0.9945935607,
0.2452376932,
-0.4494916797,
0.1299979687,
-0.1170434132,
-0.5320240259,
0.3653810322,
0.6921535134,
-0.3277296126,
-0.0201597959,
-0.4639457762,
-0.6050816774,
0.977671802,
-0.2289550006,
-0.3878178298,
0.3402600288,
-0.1953767091,
0.4132236838,
-0.85397017,
0.4236629903,
0.5322499275,
0.3124386072,
0.1778202653,
-0.8042684197,
0.0719453245,
0.0713448524,
-0.5531464815,
0.7640684247,
-0.776078701,
0.2180857509,
-0.4957968593,
-0.4286297262,
0.0346173383,
0.4668676257,
0.1522243172,
0.8470245004,
0.9593943954,
0.5141723156,
0.7861388326,
-0.4112996459,
0.230825007,
0.0488661006,
0.2039211839,
1.2099225521,
-0.4539608061,
0.5805498362,
0.0666513219,
0.1850948781,
0.6782746911,
0.3939579129,
0.2518165708,
0.9711049795,
0.0067566703,
-0.4623803198,
-0.0765364617,
-0.137464568,
-0.0286807884,
0.4736152589,
1.0181850195,
-0.2792657316,
-0.2685162127,
0.4404329658,
-0.4155859053,
-0.0119066183,
-0.4619757533,
1.22430408,
-0.1694824398,
-0.8568116426,
0.5663750172,
-0.4076167941,
0.475736469,
-0.5254520774,
-0.3410569131,
0.3418667912,
0.6534237862,
-0.304987818,
-1.0179344416,
-0.2397208959,
-0.5323842764,
-0.0566416867,
0.0721265823,
1.101944685,
-0.6749751568,
0.5266126394,
0.3559530675,
-0.062013384,
0.1789384335,
0.1834370643,
-0.4456687272,
-0.1469854116,
0.4782465398,
0.037764743,
-0.0510458462,
0.3839892149,
-0.2339765877,
0.6490689516,
0.524974227,
-0.3837060332,
0.0190997068,
-0.0498840958,
0.8506160378,
-0.3979837894,
-0.827365458,
-0.2656632066,
0.5996742249,
-0.4282505512,
-0.3572769165,
0.27978912,
0.5021297336,
1.0720820427,
-0.2569071949,
0.8337306976,
-0.0589416288,
0.6214157939,
-0.5659664273,
0.3665614724,
-0.1447388232,
0.1416435093,
0.2156004906,
-0.8873387575,
-0.0025181638,
0.248014003,
-0.5740747452,
0.033517614,
0.7285821438,
0.4387867451,
-0.3022047281,
0.2230316848,
0.4228970706,
0.2848344743,
0.1790254712,
0.8091053963,
0.8001847267,
-0.1715622991,
0.7433597445,
-0.3155961037,
-0.8906268477,
-0.6860210299,
-0.2336143851,
-0.9660298228,
-0.497628957,
-0.2974919975,
-0.170395568,
-0.0666151643,
0.6747663617,
0.6721140146,
-0.7779372334,
-0.1311450452,
0.0429436974,
0.1571403295,
-0.2281937003,
-0.3127346039,
0.2160151154,
-0.5111702681,
-0.5432521105,
0.1018286645,
0.2141794711,
0.084527038,
0.2724739015,
-0.4404738247,
-0.2726117969,
0.0876429752,
0.5966112018,
0.4214158654,
-0.6818957329,
-0.2851059437,
-0.1247849837,
-0.0137578165,
0.1300668716,
0.9129812717,
-0.4813363552,
0.8303483725,
0.352222532,
0.5255045295,
0.30958426,
0.2089058906,
0.2138352394,
-0.721018672,
-0.1176187396,
0.3295023143,
0.3301753998,
-0.0705135912,
-0.4857247472,
0.3668733239,
-0.1675266773,
-0.6339196563,
-0.5722163916,
0.5826787949,
-1.2749351263,
-0.4349360168,
0.8990421295,
-0.1637341529,
-0.3435719013,
-0.4988190234,
-0.7950610518,
0.3085725904,
-0.7969558835,
0.656264782,
0.5980702639,
-0.5811975598,
-0.029664021,
-0.3263475895,
0.5510623455,
0.3570959568,
-0.6299777627,
0.1012433991,
0.5658929348,
0.0679335818,
0.5648434758,
0.5194391012,
-0.1326165497,
0.7039811015,
-0.3678148091,
0.2909706533,
0.1523396075,
-0.5477964878,
-0.1394346654,
0.2421514839,
-0.0389681198,
-0.603774488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10216v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10216v1 | Exploring Paracrawl for Document-level Neural Machine Translation | 2023-04-20T11:21:34 | 2023-04-20T11:21:34 | Yusser Al Ghussin, Jingyi Zhang, Josef van Genabith | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level neural machine translation (NMT) has outperformed
sentence-level NMT on a number of datasets. However, document-level NMT is
still not widely adopted in real-world translation systems mainly due to the
lack of large-scale general-domain training data for document-level NMT. We
examine the effectiveness of using Paracrawl for learning document-level
translation. Paracrawl is a large-scale parallel corpus crawled from the
Internet and contains data from various domains. The official Paracrawl corpus
was released as parallel sentences (extracted from parallel webpages) and
therefore previous works only used Paracrawl for learning sentence-level
translation. In this work, we extract parallel paragraphs from Paracrawl
parallel webpages using automatic sentence alignments and we use the extracted
parallel paragraphs as parallel documents for training document-level
translation models. We show that document-level NMT models trained with only
parallel paragraphs from Paracrawl can be used to translate real documents from
TED, News and Europarl, outperforming sentence-level NMT models. We also
perform a targeted pronoun evaluation and show that document-level models
trained with Paracrawl data can help context-aware pronoun translation. | [
-0.1733269691,
-0.6508519053,
0.5251964331,
0.198713541,
-0.5144742131,
0.1397086829,
-0.3782010078,
-0.1899271905,
-0.0188240018,
0.2670335472,
-0.4317951798,
-0.8783101439,
-0.6449825168,
0.2596348822,
-0.7918912768,
1.022023797,
-0.1410360485,
0.2283184975,
-0.3669071794,
-0.118460618,
-0.2019803524,
-0.4974085987,
-0.5153364539,
0.0474545993,
0.6177814603,
0.1597370058,
0.8866835237,
0.87201792,
0.7143834829,
0.2592122257,
0.2217272818,
0.1811816245,
-0.1898373365,
-0.024680648,
-0.3171492517,
-0.4339065552,
-0.2968895435,
0.0243276525,
0.5826758742,
0.6994099617,
0.0075670509,
0.1370949596,
0.3995903134,
0.3911113143,
-0.2134256512,
0.3315333426,
-0.5091254115,
0.2194069028,
-0.5307392478,
-0.1104334518,
-0.3835671544,
-0.3717417419,
0.2270387262,
-0.7849928737,
0.3171871006,
0.1885056943,
0.8173617721,
0.1562071741,
-0.6060832739,
-0.4400697649,
-0.4182120264,
0.7271779776,
-0.8092297316,
0.5638740659,
0.4019258022,
0.2828018367,
-0.0694643855,
-1.042529583,
-0.5064983964,
-0.336201787,
0.0359495208,
0.1588436961,
-0.035349559,
0.091814518,
0.0314234942,
0.2509146631,
-0.8747804165,
0.0265496373,
-0.294266969,
-0.1822011918,
0.0943855718,
0.3149984181,
0.6092424989,
-0.1928833276,
-0.5689538121,
-0.1564357132,
-0.2865248621,
0.0261874218,
0.3575210273,
0.2564758062,
0.0961743519,
0.4107568264,
-0.0545408428,
0.8520656824,
-0.0568483323,
-0.0663799718,
0.2978644371,
-0.2071219683,
0.0638157427,
-0.0738908798,
0.9479532838,
0.5805770755,
0.118867889,
-0.5303712487,
-0.1970246881,
-0.178633377,
0.464351505,
-0.622299552,
0.0098409681,
0.1026303619,
-0.4367399812,
-0.2820845842,
-0.083627075,
-0.745098412,
-0.2666412592,
-0.3132081628,
0.3124128282,
-0.7204580903,
0.095723778,
0.2393334955,
-0.1713246256,
0.1196183115,
0.2408277094,
-0.655140698,
0.2779551446,
0.6785592437,
0.8799371719,
-0.2408852279,
-0.999638617,
-0.2689214051,
0.1098076552,
-0.4782664478,
0.6877020001,
-0.4291501045,
0.159093082,
0.1020490378,
-0.1595896482,
-0.5502184629,
-0.4346476495,
0.7546960711,
-0.4807777703,
0.2724063098,
-0.3071704507,
-0.3548891246,
-0.1547546238,
0.3709180653,
-0.4472411275,
0.6906570196,
0.1983501017,
-0.9798436761,
0.0462365709,
-0.2712872326,
-0.597915113,
0.0109279407,
-0.1274166405,
-0.2009817064,
0.0802730247,
0.3697331846,
0.4497689903,
-0.7120499611,
0.3248098493,
0.0073006307,
-0.3778833449,
0.1034104377,
-0.4218537509,
0.7035284638,
0.0753575638,
-0.2847599983,
-0.0948755145,
-0.4295866787,
-0.273509711,
0.044661846,
-0.4520066679,
-0.2490345836,
-0.053762164,
0.1464612931,
0.5423693657,
0.574672699,
-0.6486873627,
-0.0707322657,
-0.2210763246,
0.7836800814,
0.2437259257,
-0.0429773405,
0.5831233859,
-0.3048799634,
0.6976955533,
0.0173320211,
0.0522228852,
0.1456046551,
-0.3150816858,
-0.6349873543,
0.0860692039,
0.6350889802,
0.5251305699,
-0.8460989594,
0.2246913016,
-0.2842890918,
-0.4135395885,
-0.7089614272,
-0.0796108022,
0.5995539427,
1.0009034872,
0.7351847291,
0.0278938934,
-0.3181645274,
-0.9977720976,
-0.5581561923,
0.0820704773,
-0.0408265591,
0.0521908179,
0.1503280997,
0.0481834859,
0.5783017278,
-0.1296718717,
-0.4401399493,
-0.1914357245,
0.4375046194,
-0.053570684,
0.3650760353,
0.1946962476,
-0.8586463928,
-0.6290689111,
0.2234099954,
-1.0672389269,
0.0976456851,
-0.4469286501,
0.0709141046,
-0.0889107063,
0.5757118464,
-0.8329963088,
0.1700688154,
0.4051480591,
0.1660730392,
0.3897078931,
-0.4113623202,
0.0405547395,
-1.1841979027,
-0.0903557912,
0.1152082086,
-0.3245487511,
-0.541555047,
0.4093512595,
0.7001045346,
-0.4177412689,
-0.6967887878,
0.0515059978,
-0.502717495,
-0.2534511685,
-0.1787405461,
0.2282631248,
0.0970549136,
0.5737078786,
0.0734780207,
1.0673079491,
0.3061736226,
-0.1885312051,
0.0571693853,
0.3556445539,
-0.1136413515,
0.4140050411,
-0.2506821156,
0.3079610169,
0.0834740922,
0.3804063499,
-0.7313135862,
-0.2208480388,
0.2370857894,
-0.3315942883,
0.0670557991,
0.0819679797,
-0.4508654475,
-0.3828665018,
-0.1977170557,
0.1456871033,
0.4353179336,
-0.4281570613,
0.5243336558,
0.2679244578,
-0.1578693688,
-0.6456111073,
-0.6606408954,
0.5218104124,
-0.2273453623,
-0.5983336568,
0.5459931493,
0.2455535978,
0.1269370019,
-0.1503000408,
-0.3763155043,
-0.228870973,
-0.1404366046,
0.0194664095,
-0.2130794972,
-0.2900871336,
-0.1590071321,
0.2334780842,
0.0066010598,
0.189581573,
-0.6064646244,
0.790004015,
-0.3465916216,
-0.1093892753,
-0.6404843926,
0.2552607656,
0.6443995237,
-0.4633380175,
0.6917104721,
0.6909976602,
-0.2745016813,
-0.2545683682,
-0.3124729991,
0.1351982206,
-0.4211961031,
0.2501757741,
-0.5176131129,
-0.4974384904,
0.417019248,
-0.1336688548,
-0.1248498559,
0.5764870644,
0.2742997408,
-0.3563851118,
0.9398072362,
0.1867759824,
0.1651706249,
0.1780268401,
-0.3564872444,
-0.0164047517,
-1.0190111399,
-0.1994362473,
-0.3285276592,
-0.5156499743,
-0.3415421844,
-0.3798552454,
0.0197417382,
0.305174917,
0.0949462354,
1.2051620483,
-0.235790506,
0.5322990417,
0.6100487113,
0.4474627674,
0.1174239591,
-0.206622541,
-0.3599110842,
-0.1627406925,
-0.572281003,
-0.5682418346,
0.947532177,
0.2229743451,
0.2273952961,
-0.3759427071,
0.9758748412,
0.0920847207,
-0.3333684206,
-0.5539875627,
0.7288380861,
-0.5269904137,
-0.1397479177,
-0.2605637908,
-0.2188036144,
-0.8320674896,
0.2639375329,
0.1325014234,
-0.2280348092,
0.4110580683,
-0.2237074524,
-0.245230481,
0.1868788302,
-0.4679439068,
1.0655616522,
-0.3441433311,
-0.280051887,
-0.1868306398,
-0.8780763149,
-0.0969139487,
-0.4840934873,
0.0329423882,
0.0790705159,
-0.4107775688,
0.6488572955,
-0.4256111383,
0.7113216519,
-0.0887968689,
-0.0017134706,
0.1143254787,
0.2803390026,
0.6210355163,
0.0459058546,
-0.2444128692,
0.358645916,
-0.2329674661,
-0.4701390862,
-0.5469385386,
0.6875662208,
-0.7695662975,
-0.74210006,
-0.3551002741,
-1.1548303366,
-0.2534781694,
0.424149096,
0.431186974,
0.3618873656,
-0.0976214483,
0.5878160596,
0.4328331947,
-0.0484385267,
0.4927584529,
0.3470166028,
0.220722422,
-0.3324687481,
1.1708664894,
0.2556861043,
0.0146183278,
0.6821801662,
0.2229657024,
-0.3209085763,
-1.0375676155,
-0.5589625239,
-0.1317867637,
-0.5600858331,
-0.2107252926,
-1.0170942545,
-0.1886904389,
-0.4050258994,
-0.3792223632,
-0.0855156705,
-0.572879076,
-0.2841026187,
0.058715757,
-0.1031389683,
0.4268363714,
0.052052971,
0.4208133519,
-0.7605941892,
0.4573690295,
0.0216779932,
-0.369384408,
-0.2497044504,
-0.4504795671,
-0.2512816191,
0.0207718387,
-0.2401751578,
-0.8927452564,
0.6528148055,
0.113314867,
0.5095791221,
-0.0039689806,
0.1096477956,
0.4685234129,
-0.7252007723,
0.6332891583,
-0.0197076313,
-0.8230525851,
0.1742617041,
-0.9715011716,
0.36308074,
0.7937021852,
0.739420414,
-0.4839749634,
-0.5761335492,
-0.4794856012,
-0.8159536719,
0.7240938544,
0.2519964278,
0.1447507441,
-0.2992628515,
0.1939568073,
0.1352667361,
0.3815911114,
-0.5686183572,
0.4168266058,
-0.192735076,
-0.5185394287,
-0.0339283794,
0.1986407787,
0.2157546431,
-0.0229304116,
0.2538026273,
0.0134090036,
0.0868283138,
0.0889069289,
-0.7100812793,
0.1958996058,
0.0840747729,
0.4674858153,
0.7529043555,
-0.4622660577,
0.1121074259,
0.259919256,
-0.4520572722,
0.1184448376,
0.2313644141,
-0.1218753532,
0.000425735,
0.3728883564,
0.5658234358,
0.4675197005,
-0.3877946734,
0.7443695068,
0.0210580286,
-0.4234433174,
0.0296365507,
-0.3586196303,
0.6133828759,
0.3435241282,
0.1075538024,
0.2151869386,
0.2590527236,
-0.2674674094,
0.2615210414,
0.0835565627,
-0.2568897605,
-0.1384932101,
0.9167686105,
0.1987743378,
-0.6792928576,
0.7459200621,
0.1051208749,
-0.4982452393,
0.7060270309,
0.8702816367,
0.831020534,
-0.1266026348,
0.3649360538,
-0.0487986878,
0.3518672884,
-0.2730738819,
-0.0517173186,
-0.1601771563,
-0.2460960895,
-0.1757473052,
-0.6890125871,
-0.3790646493,
0.0502168983,
-0.7843721509,
0.2359205335,
-0.5444514751,
0.0317098424,
0.0452224128,
-0.2530492246,
-0.7228425145,
0.1051483005,
-0.0800562575,
1.0079038143,
-0.7496473193,
1.2505488396,
0.5838440657,
-0.8511388898,
-0.5518372655,
0.626101613,
-0.2660183311,
-0.674295485,
0.7071270347,
0.2109368443,
0.0015648025,
0.4651593566,
0.1050803736,
-0.7115656137,
1.0832716227,
0.7030469775,
-0.6780638099,
-0.6791195273,
0.6941427588,
0.6455103755,
-0.3391717374,
-0.0452519394,
0.1982470751,
0.282474786,
-0.4738217294,
-0.8043435812,
0.0373961553,
0.0713204816,
0.3238004446,
0.2519839704,
-0.6207909584,
1.1967006922,
0.5093926787,
0.0328642018,
-0.0459081195,
0.7385219932,
-0.1198837608,
0.1945243776,
0.3883530796,
0.5789250731,
0.548487246,
0.2842872143,
0.9864006042,
-0.3641206622,
0.1953527033,
1.2461440563,
-0.3646886945,
1.0887042284,
0.3440210521,
0.1677289754,
0.3308055997,
0.5976820588,
0.0643363521,
0.5313141942,
0.0274708122,
-0.2144331038,
-0.235433042,
0.0494667217,
-0.239089191,
0.3099847138,
0.2604725957,
-0.6181574464,
-0.7585835457,
0.5493600965,
-0.1143019944,
0.354362309,
-0.0501291007,
0.6303035617,
0.1286184937,
-0.583645165,
0.7525607347,
0.1989523321,
0.4717825055,
-0.2581418753,
0.1282815039,
-0.4179451168,
0.2911149561,
0.0507945158,
-0.684504509,
0.3563724458,
-0.0254967716,
-0.058646962,
-0.4667737186,
0.8611061573,
-0.4081452489,
-0.3067976534,
0.4490529597,
0.4512441754,
0.2925473154,
-0.4266020954,
-0.9495464563,
-0.2952597141,
-0.0928902403,
-0.2267895937,
0.8338991404,
0.4523323774,
-0.2876620889,
0.3398988545,
0.5939514637,
-0.254897356,
0.2034468353,
-0.2869678438,
0.8296279907,
-0.4881339967,
-0.3771435618,
-0.712867856,
0.2003318667,
-0.0109007321,
-0.4176653326,
1.0135902166,
0.8930288553,
1.0057629347,
-0.1455022395,
0.637583375,
0.1683843881,
0.4155680835,
-0.4004662633,
0.8737700582,
-0.2029203027,
-0.2353682816,
0.0917496532,
-1.0310630798,
-0.2929013371,
0.4579827487,
-0.5348932147,
-0.5875483155,
1.2576291561,
0.6860733032,
-0.4446786046,
0.1037519276,
0.475191623,
-0.1361951232,
-0.147116214,
0.5229253769,
0.7975723743,
-0.6291511059,
0.9934968948,
-0.4031848609,
0.0343149304,
0.0451921262,
-0.7509157062,
-1.0381703377,
-0.6548495293,
-0.166110605,
-0.2591899931,
0.6488679051,
0.7029591799,
0.4347230792,
-0.5904830694,
-0.3133366704,
-0.6510972381,
-0.4487476349,
-0.3228895962,
-0.0866674483,
0.4637649357,
-0.796397984,
-0.8108094335,
0.9682982564,
0.0889683291,
-0.3074540198,
0.0396627896,
0.0535358153,
-0.55155164,
-0.0802999288,
0.2311409861,
0.2038321942,
-0.6145791411,
0.1430175602,
0.0365332216,
-0.440600723,
0.2181919217,
0.766689837,
-0.5621693134,
0.0152282473,
0.7491999269,
0.9382038713,
0.5909882784,
0.0818236321,
0.7819404602,
-0.6765487194,
0.1046983153,
0.290769577,
0.2810931504,
0.1798623651,
-0.4374859631,
0.3790132701,
0.0958539769,
-0.5407838225,
-0.6142225862,
-0.1671070457,
-0.7355337143,
-0.4309337735,
1.0679421425,
-0.4820289314,
-0.4507820308,
-0.0849541873,
-0.2323848605,
0.519470036,
-0.2503364086,
0.3691157103,
0.6027780175,
0.1802061796,
-0.1924744993,
-0.9511786699,
0.3165145218,
0.3389961123,
-0.6997388601,
0.0546780042,
0.1798499674,
0.2430636138,
0.1394868493,
0.3088258803,
-0.2062019855,
0.3062119186,
0.0638700649,
-0.0726365596,
-0.3561167419,
-0.5211195946,
-0.5032271147,
0.3868594468,
-0.0480654538,
-0.4123184383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10195v1 | CoT-MoTE: Exploring ConTextual Masked Auto-Encoder Pre-training with Mixture-of-Textual-Experts for Passage Retrieval | 2023-04-20T10:12:09 | 2023-04-20T10:12:09 | Guangyuan Ma, Xing Wu, Peng Wang, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Passage retrieval aims to retrieve relevant passages from large collections
of the open-domain corpus. Contextual Masked Auto-Encoding has been proven
effective in representation bottleneck pre-training of a monolithic
dual-encoder for passage retrieval. Siamese or fully separated dual-encoders
are often adopted as basic retrieval architecture in the pre-training and
fine-tuning stages for encoding queries and passages into their latent
embedding spaces. However, simply sharing or separating the parameters of the
dual-encoder results in an imbalanced discrimination of the embedding spaces.
In this work, we propose to pre-train Contextual Masked Auto-Encoder with
Mixture-of-Textual-Experts (CoT-MoTE). Specifically, we incorporate
textual-specific experts for individually encoding the distinct properties of
queries and passages. Meanwhile, a shared self-attention layer is still kept
for unified attention modeling. Results on large-scale passage retrieval
benchmarks show steady improvement in retrieval performances. The quantitive
analysis also shows a more balanced discrimination of the latent embedding
spaces. | [
-0.4992122948,
-0.5730314851,
0.4637314081,
0.230831176,
-0.6143295169,
0.3592708409,
-0.0879909322,
-0.2518244088,
0.5122237206,
0.7246597409,
-0.3129278421,
-0.4019750059,
-0.7885671258,
0.1784913987,
-0.3218821883,
0.5300852656,
0.0251710024,
0.2321397215,
-0.33098194,
-0.2986091971,
-0.600371778,
-0.7980152965,
-0.1778491437,
0.0975917876,
0.1581469774,
-0.1222437173,
0.4203612804,
0.3978833258,
0.3004121482,
0.3068843186,
0.0019494661,
0.1390337348,
-0.2954066098,
0.2906417251,
-0.4373155236,
-0.4219682813,
-0.2356943041,
-0.0218196698,
0.2854112685,
0.3861059546,
-0.1638443023,
-0.2669503093,
0.1673036665,
0.3275594413,
-1.0749989748,
-0.1560532004,
-0.8374246955,
0.226166293,
-0.0787582844,
-0.529525578,
-0.4847948253,
0.2016671598,
0.4279675484,
-0.6051188707,
0.3834447563,
0.1957823336,
0.5241922736,
0.5905650258,
-0.7052598,
-0.4545177519,
-0.1189217418,
0.6714314222,
-0.3430297077,
0.358607918,
0.4428458214,
0.1719920635,
0.1609923244,
-0.5395621657,
-0.4964669049,
-0.0528838113,
-0.4338620305,
0.2292422354,
0.3452562392,
0.0950619802,
-0.161654219,
0.4665744901,
-0.5890341997,
-0.2722144425,
-0.2879864573,
-0.3877577186,
0.6694268584,
-0.0651528984,
0.2005858272,
-0.1729463041,
-0.8186388016,
-0.1028805226,
-0.323264569,
-0.383169651,
0.0781712309,
-0.1437437683,
0.1551017463,
0.1950894296,
-0.2571823597,
0.6704797745,
0.2788165212,
0.3057246208,
0.311373502,
-0.3755986691,
-0.1863082349,
0.1095946282,
0.8856024146,
-0.1902904361,
0.1364153028,
-0.3911732435,
-0.3485601842,
-0.4050701559,
0.4856119156,
-0.4982346296,
-0.2763011158,
-0.1004426032,
-0.2172888517,
-0.0793184265,
0.2463746369,
-0.8810227513,
-0.2091242969,
-0.5223106146,
0.9185089469,
-0.3927403688,
-0.2281451672,
0.33367908,
-0.0540416762,
0.336902976,
0.410477221,
-0.6693937182,
0.3114489019,
0.1922611892,
0.7236865163,
-0.3767710328,
-0.1448541135,
-0.6940770745,
0.3195287883,
0.1522713006,
0.767260313,
-0.7264967561,
-0.6852760911,
-0.1526065767,
-0.1312008649,
-0.5958725214,
-0.5270270109,
0.502174437,
-0.7922582626,
0.2391843945,
-0.2238488495,
-0.4035976231,
0.302609235,
0.2096947134,
-0.560783565,
0.9179570079,
-0.0459803268,
-0.6004117131,
0.3033276796,
-0.5337582827,
-0.4201532304,
0.1078518108,
-0.6476606727,
-0.085685499,
0.0443327837,
0.6604346633,
0.2152964473,
-0.0200808849,
0.2845300436,
0.0871479437,
-0.2892743945,
0.2230674624,
-0.4428719282,
0.7228548527,
0.3189600706,
-0.4683559835,
-0.2010308802,
-0.4112735391,
0.0222164672,
-0.1723482162,
-0.0204741638,
-0.6084355712,
-0.2648308873,
0.0147550711,
0.2647938728,
0.3335423768,
-0.5263733864,
-0.0935382769,
-0.1703313142,
0.3738612235,
0.6040144563,
0.1223547235,
0.5340548158,
0.1248593256,
0.5377354026,
0.3663184047,
0.0234081224,
-0.2675739825,
-0.1521697044,
-0.6066240072,
-0.26832816,
0.5013688803,
0.4021517634,
-0.9264814854,
0.6744955182,
-0.2124861777,
0.0342853293,
-0.7010369301,
0.2481648028,
0.6622802019,
0.4441958666,
0.6787028313,
-0.6494885683,
-0.2153680474,
-0.7299374938,
-0.1945813894,
0.3064775765,
-0.0558006242,
0.3000543118,
0.6725715995,
-0.1682440042,
1.2376149893,
-0.7472707033,
-0.5402195454,
0.1634579748,
0.2499384135,
-0.4911783934,
0.6805633307,
0.5965363383,
-1.2560482025,
-0.7211513519,
-0.2231537849,
-0.7491589189,
-0.0429249704,
0.1944999844,
-0.6169402003,
0.0574200638,
0.7989982367,
-0.4748230875,
0.3936865926,
0.0528516807,
-0.3357386589,
0.327116251,
-0.3333541453,
0.327126503,
-0.9963866472,
-0.0364191271,
-0.4360539615,
-0.2622154057,
-0.1159718186,
0.22630997,
0.3456842005,
-0.0970695615,
-0.2906001508,
0.6014299393,
-0.7909867167,
0.1157507151,
-0.1576808691,
0.3891183734,
0.2738445103,
0.5614598989,
0.4253586531,
0.9877326488,
0.4302821159,
-0.602955699,
-0.1493182778,
0.3424738944,
-0.0344688371,
0.8085433841,
-0.5363641977,
0.5914217234,
-0.0342954434,
0.3069951236,
-0.8505957127,
-0.1637233645,
-0.0015564626,
-0.4765399694,
0.4371677637,
-0.1074462011,
-0.2852628231,
-0.1946817189,
-0.1767683327,
0.7985263467,
0.27070719,
-0.4505047798,
0.5695432425,
0.4673748612,
-0.1566248387,
-0.8442414403,
-0.5877830386,
0.0800526142,
0.1463271976,
-0.4509617388,
0.5902109742,
-0.1702808142,
0.1648995429,
0.0139009375,
-0.4677203596,
-0.3070300221,
-0.1241735369,
-0.1938393414,
-0.0449707359,
-0.2624807358,
0.2094308734,
0.2821073532,
-0.2169676721,
0.0478269197,
-0.6460052133,
0.5019606352,
-0.0957039073,
-0.3755132556,
-0.0106708929,
0.6064783931,
0.2113447785,
-0.7369676828,
0.8631073236,
0.6383525729,
-0.1606121212,
-0.1409604847,
-0.8142886758,
-0.2233549356,
-0.4778319895,
0.1564845294,
-0.6663049459,
-0.8184296489,
0.3634295762,
0.2869080007,
-0.3637922108,
0.5115243793,
0.2352486551,
-0.2006049901,
0.5844146013,
0.4894678593,
0.0740200728,
0.2580312788,
-0.4188496768,
0.0607110932,
-0.9845886827,
-0.4423938096,
-0.4496344626,
-0.153513357,
-0.1736135185,
-0.5877887011,
0.4275275171,
-0.0217738263,
-0.0319898203,
0.3130928278,
-0.7431313396,
0.7029129863,
0.4877248406,
0.4593108296,
0.4561851025,
-0.0162882376,
-0.3373645842,
0.0371025093,
-0.4999366105,
-0.4498781264,
1.1980924606,
-0.1665621549,
0.6607468724,
-0.0433105826,
0.7762807012,
0.5216946602,
-0.0607349426,
-0.2852674425,
0.4986521006,
-0.1019040793,
-0.7252269387,
-0.2428135872,
-0.3712515533,
-0.8394328356,
0.8476961255,
-0.0406746157,
-0.4847407937,
0.5649209023,
0.119664818,
-0.3653934598,
-0.0177397039,
-0.7435087562,
0.9283611774,
-0.3565736115,
-0.4574128985,
-0.1802425832,
-0.9417504668,
0.0030075894,
-0.2020652592,
-0.0839193314,
0.2722791433,
-0.2741034925,
0.6858547926,
-0.3495834768,
0.5735740066,
-0.2335092127,
-0.0277468599,
0.3673540652,
-0.0080292542,
0.2491624951,
0.3182523549,
-0.0571048297,
0.061011184,
0.0369672626,
-0.7135865092,
-0.5548618436,
0.468475014,
-0.9274967313,
-0.7695629597,
-0.4974413514,
0.0035349689,
-0.3121816516,
0.1913698912,
0.6762346625,
0.6581240892,
-0.1396090984,
0.5336350203,
1.0539197922,
0.0829101726,
0.3170369565,
0.5902683735,
0.4331771135,
-0.5686353445,
0.6084734201,
0.0717784613,
0.3172967732,
0.8489887118,
-0.2708230317,
-0.3909375072,
-0.5319648981,
-0.4008257985,
0.1061087474,
-0.730846107,
-0.1968663782,
-1.1342918873,
-0.4587188959,
-0.4638961554,
-0.3182312548,
-0.364823252,
-0.0140093351,
-0.4035878778,
0.0519273244,
-0.1280563921,
0.3023443818,
0.2654093206,
0.4806371331,
-0.6941125989,
0.2661729157,
0.4254104793,
0.1314596087,
-0.0662693605,
-0.5168715715,
-0.4092494547,
0.0383492932,
-0.3428826332,
-0.8043407202,
0.3579197824,
0.0473387763,
0.7978649735,
0.2191651464,
0.4079076648,
0.4610494077,
-0.1166291386,
0.5475210547,
-0.0468164273,
-0.9728496671,
0.5717067122,
-0.1828759015,
0.2343392372,
0.9985685349,
0.2924631238,
0.0127027258,
-0.2778374851,
-0.4340081215,
-0.8267359138,
0.7283633947,
0.6089917421,
0.1109865904,
0.0588072501,
0.2402625233,
0.3903953433,
0.5503090024,
-0.7363471389,
0.0489334725,
-0.5064316392,
-0.3527516425,
-0.1224391237,
-0.1856763959,
-0.0257477909,
-0.1421028674,
0.3233100176,
-0.1456736475,
0.4780549109,
0.7774208784,
-0.9735529423,
0.284579128,
0.4030065238,
0.389883697,
0.4347624779,
-0.3721477389,
0.1874584258,
0.0959173366,
-0.8920717835,
0.2581570148,
0.1642487645,
-0.0005585575,
-0.0482306667,
0.3386842012,
0.6596413255,
0.3154864013,
-0.5707370043,
0.7383520603,
0.0365646109,
-0.082449533,
-0.4700029492,
0.1802124083,
-0.423253566,
-0.0974207446,
0.7357054949,
0.0823313594,
0.404638201,
-0.3445940316,
0.2554493248,
0.2049517035,
-0.4014946222,
-0.1464186609,
0.70066607,
0.6626344323,
-0.147236675,
0.4699154794,
-0.2082154155,
-0.6019421816,
0.6145079136,
0.2297069281,
1.0735186338,
-0.2450654954,
0.0765401274,
0.1348700374,
0.2476258129,
0.1805787832,
-0.0917777196,
-0.7324510217,
-0.5113477707,
-0.0525640436,
-0.7318530679,
-0.239413321,
-0.0981812179,
-0.7571975589,
0.0892960727,
0.1092691794,
-0.0341784805,
-0.4151425958,
0.0208427738,
-0.8596171737,
0.3747862577,
-0.0657326952,
0.7573091984,
-0.4242910147,
0.7312449813,
0.6775607467,
-0.4608198702,
-0.2753354311,
0.4162849486,
-0.278359592,
-0.4426756203,
0.3793159127,
0.1898035407,
-0.3896672428,
0.1141999587,
-0.2754224539,
-0.7898458838,
1.2218110561,
0.2639912367,
-0.5658367276,
-0.2451527566,
-0.0163580701,
0.5798285604,
-0.6766571403,
0.64123559,
0.2707184851,
0.0369329154,
0.1201222166,
-0.9017671347,
-0.0862233937,
-0.3003599644,
-0.1523458064,
0.0478133708,
-0.7618601322,
0.8478118777,
0.2190876454,
-0.0471782349,
-0.157592535,
0.5922379494,
-0.0031427201,
0.4761962891,
0.6133084297,
0.3429102898,
0.6387486458,
0.0746134222,
0.7308326364,
-0.3054642975,
0.2887625992,
1.2724430561,
-0.2043451518,
0.9049463868,
0.2662411034,
0.1206795871,
0.5386501551,
0.4938288927,
0.433573693,
0.8841261268,
-0.2547491491,
-0.3720769882,
-0.2881417572,
0.2278500348,
-0.6722236276,
0.3225200772,
0.4343560636,
-0.5226545334,
-0.0280936938,
0.3383762836,
-0.2806201279,
0.1920931637,
-0.2255734354,
0.8171249032,
0.2669331431,
-0.6913499236,
0.4000223577,
-0.2907953262,
0.8134859204,
-0.4209503829,
0.4258299768,
-0.269420892,
0.1076923683,
0.002782691,
-0.6814627647,
0.0133168343,
-0.3415924907,
0.0182211585,
-0.2764997184,
0.7456376553,
-0.6330301166,
-0.046952121,
0.5322363973,
0.6203567386,
0.0083278818,
-0.5193064809,
-0.3947224617,
-0.3222181201,
-0.0952586532,
-0.2797071934,
0.2735135257,
0.6668360233,
0.025509147,
0.4067007899,
0.2725433111,
-0.3609781861,
0.2871366441,
0.1047366112,
0.8128856421,
-0.8656613231,
-0.9686328173,
-0.6784624457,
0.4051618278,
-0.3482691944,
-0.3664596379,
0.4181818366,
0.6264009476,
0.842148006,
-0.409096539,
0.6129122972,
0.1108228713,
0.0550604463,
-0.7412428856,
0.9115430117,
-0.6556161046,
0.1338709742,
-0.2308742404,
-0.8473057151,
0.2496722341,
0.5060228109,
-0.2762412727,
0.2592953444,
0.8893561959,
0.7615930438,
-0.3570019603,
0.0334819742,
0.2701793015,
0.1524824202,
0.0309496894,
0.5182212591,
0.7180304527,
-0.4436226487,
0.6663365364,
-0.0304077808,
-0.0237771738,
-0.5079782009,
-0.3587008119,
-1.0588361025,
-0.8433647752,
-0.3307192028,
0.0901047587,
0.1346692294,
0.7893874645,
0.8260926604,
-0.6616922021,
0.1267348528,
-0.0407679342,
-0.1703171283,
0.2285075784,
-0.2189422697,
0.4471628368,
-0.506251812,
-0.5958835483,
0.2745234668,
0.4062217772,
0.0696675256,
-0.3642807603,
-0.101169087,
-0.2615027428,
0.1719482243,
0.5379164815,
-0.1323314011,
-0.548351109,
0.0001770192,
0.1508654207,
-0.4436711073,
0.1563464552,
0.9537311792,
-1.0797711611,
0.7502215505,
0.3998940289,
0.5948724747,
0.7778730989,
0.0924887806,
0.669377625,
-0.8808100224,
0.3188472688,
0.4484915733,
0.3104210794,
0.1549418867,
-0.5236495137,
0.7382330298,
0.4290853143,
-0.3351143301,
-0.6224471927,
-0.1371172518,
-0.9896848202,
-0.1384640485,
0.8016983867,
-0.1660711914,
-0.1410580724,
-0.3802632689,
-0.3026684523,
0.0075099035,
-0.4870286584,
0.7209600806,
0.7971276641,
0.2693830431,
-0.1246605963,
-0.4129927754,
0.3047040701,
0.6659510136,
-0.6096801758,
-0.4927209914,
0.1571795791,
0.103402704,
0.1863762587,
0.897900641,
-0.2882962525,
0.195325315,
0.0507587381,
-0.1595232785,
0.0423470065,
-0.3360930383,
-0.1762714982,
0.2459626645,
-0.4172867835,
-0.3384061158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11073v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11073v3 | OLISIA: a Cascade System for Spoken Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-04-20T09:30:50 | 2023-08-31T08:51:33 | Léo Jacqmin, Lucas Druart, Yannick Estève, Benoît Favre, Lina Maria Rojas-Barahona, Valentin Vielzeuf | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Though Dialogue State Tracking (DST) is a core component of spoken dialogue
systems, recent work on this task mostly deals with chat corpora, disregarding
the discrepancies between spoken and written language.In this paper, we propose
OLISIA, a cascade system which integrates an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
model and a DST model. We introduce several adaptations in the ASR and DST
modules to improve integration and robustness to spoken conversations.With
these adaptations, our system ranked first in DSTC11 Track 3, a benchmark to
evaluate spoken DST. We conduct an in-depth analysis of the results and find
that normalizing the ASR outputs and adapting the DST inputs through data
augmentation, along with increasing the pre-trained models size all play an
important role in reducing the performance discrepancy between written and
spoken conversations. | [
-0.296687156,
-0.527510643,
0.4482476413,
0.0403835215,
-0.2110129446,
0.1707870662,
-0.0220701043,
-0.5940548778,
0.2396454662,
0.3426294625,
-0.4747576118,
-0.3947829902,
-0.5326090455,
-0.0213047657,
-0.2655768991,
1.2552847862,
0.0916192606,
0.2865692973,
0.467235595,
-0.5233451128,
-0.6682360768,
-0.3569855094,
-0.8496554494,
-0.3789306879,
0.327488631,
-0.0019777452,
0.3851325512,
0.118035391,
0.3488894403,
0.2809153497,
-0.220740959,
0.0560564175,
-0.3012832105,
0.4732697308,
-0.2107518315,
-0.5588496923,
-0.6982135177,
-0.3321405649,
0.772433579,
0.4896603525,
-0.229419142,
0.1058783382,
0.274548471,
0.4997889996,
-0.7255249023,
0.5268568397,
-0.2584600449,
-0.1527840495,
-0.0558315516,
-0.1802961081,
-0.117171973,
-0.5752509236,
0.3965017796,
-0.2581532001,
-0.3246038258,
-0.2817952931,
0.3736688495,
0.5951412916,
-0.3728333414,
-0.8231131434,
-1.0921143293,
0.5088021755,
-0.8266168237,
0.2734511793,
0.2442138791,
0.3569864035,
-0.035545554,
-0.5462734103,
-0.5710511804,
-0.2454531938,
0.1943092495,
0.1513399184,
-0.3324537575,
0.0735410303,
0.152976498,
0.4991162419,
-0.2817647755,
0.0666104183,
-0.3347227275,
-0.1346271336,
0.2287118286,
0.2989617884,
0.5087806582,
0.0490395091,
-0.0575396568,
0.0193945467,
-0.388440609,
0.2817512751,
0.2546905279,
0.837480247,
0.0507019609,
0.4163036942,
-0.2022437453,
0.6207426786,
0.1169785187,
-0.2200702876,
0.0461816043,
-0.2531097233,
-0.342926532,
0.4382824004,
0.9251135588,
-0.0038821846,
-0.1079176664,
0.1321404576,
-0.4263561964,
0.1221711189,
0.1773569584,
-0.6920682788,
-0.1077787578,
0.0092800753,
-0.1360274553,
-0.1630743295,
-0.1172346622,
-0.5254417062,
-0.3645738959,
-0.3958363533,
0.6901952028,
-0.5954774618,
-0.1643577665,
0.0308554117,
0.2034778744,
-0.1183928549,
0.5579898953,
-0.8818399906,
0.7641209364,
0.7574355602,
1.1770997047,
-0.1430565566,
0.1132773161,
-0.6155084968,
-0.1008045226,
-0.3164224327,
0.7150110602,
-0.3887216151,
-0.3374902904,
0.1010070145,
-0.2251649797,
-0.1522021294,
-0.292971015,
0.52125144,
-0.5551818609,
0.1704158038,
-0.3010667861,
-0.327395618,
-0.2301017493,
0.0802059621,
-0.5083810091,
0.8551100492,
-0.2065685838,
-0.7096364498,
0.3735153079,
-0.7785933018,
-0.4403721988,
-0.1223812997,
-0.3512358069,
-0.2106522322,
0.0240035281,
0.1895701885,
-0.133232832,
-0.2003534287,
0.2126628906,
-0.0013104369,
-0.476121217,
0.0542420931,
-0.4785836935,
0.9936911464,
0.3425229788,
-0.3586339653,
-0.1633529663,
-0.8382600546,
0.0124409795,
-0.4469023049,
-0.6699545383,
-0.3949224949,
0.1992533654,
-0.0395348519,
-0.0903948843,
0.1927955151,
-0.7005466819,
0.3816111684,
-0.2894596159,
0.4753774107,
0.5886941552,
-0.0896194354,
0.4271037877,
-0.0226186514,
0.2883687913,
0.2805796266,
-0.1338405758,
-0.2594389021,
-0.5388239026,
-0.9856687784,
-0.3533602655,
0.1242011636,
0.7822723985,
-0.5854080319,
0.5994395614,
-0.2474045455,
-0.1658755243,
-0.5532649159,
-0.3333905339,
0.3542565107,
0.4220085442,
0.2632123828,
-0.5151951909,
-0.4227871299,
-0.6398597956,
-0.1436899453,
-0.4415260255,
-0.1498752087,
-0.0247821137,
0.3319433033,
0.0479545929,
1.3076754808,
-0.6923187971,
-0.8369336724,
-0.2432527542,
0.487675488,
0.2248247713,
0.412101537,
0.4329752922,
-0.3790617883,
-0.6477378607,
0.2131332606,
-0.5746047497,
-0.3511620164,
0.1761867106,
0.3883303404,
0.2791410089,
0.3166798949,
-0.2888222635,
0.8677279353,
0.4635359943,
-0.111761041,
0.1484977454,
-0.1228381842,
0.4861755371,
-1.3596640825,
0.087724708,
-0.2952810228,
-0.3141290545,
-0.9287080765,
-0.5398324728,
-0.0887533724,
-0.2844770253,
0.0199774485,
0.1875552237,
-0.327648133,
-0.2945877016,
-0.4108923078,
0.2067593187,
-0.3727859855,
0.5294178128,
0.1285213977,
1.0225352049,
0.7460228205,
-0.5845471025,
0.3666930497,
0.4979950786,
-0.5335514545,
1.0703356266,
-0.4595819116,
0.4563533664,
0.0190181732,
0.6968197227,
-1.0542542934,
0.1681819409,
0.2488602549,
-0.4808581769,
0.1942737401,
-0.2396148592,
-0.2898987532,
-0.1866364926,
0.0217789523,
0.1372117251,
0.4554653764,
-0.5187219381,
0.8071671724,
0.3908780813,
-0.4866001606,
-0.6416902542,
-0.5724746585,
0.2345537543,
0.0483835153,
-0.5483056903,
0.0766675174,
0.0466499738,
-0.0813893899,
-0.3356204331,
-0.2340619117,
-0.3250505626,
-0.2500654757,
0.2061826736,
0.0795824602,
-0.6571509838,
0.0705398917,
0.0674581602,
-0.092711769,
-0.2455413491,
-0.5341775417,
0.5934548378,
-0.1346292049,
-0.4391846657,
-1.3433303833,
0.3200396895,
0.6732253432,
0.0662561432,
0.6818966269,
0.4103118479,
-0.2875165343,
-0.1019072235,
-0.5468624234,
-0.1585500985,
-0.4123919904,
0.0968683288,
-0.627446413,
-0.5613530874,
0.7140731215,
0.248652637,
0.2204472274,
0.0798823982,
0.1598518193,
-0.1826211959,
1.1177723408,
0.639742732,
-0.6578732729,
0.7527391315,
0.0498584732,
0.4612284303,
-0.9896813631,
0.032446336,
-0.8861750364,
-0.3501274586,
-0.5296239257,
-0.1336081475,
0.3605334163,
-0.2163068205,
-0.2126379013,
0.579318881,
-0.1201534569,
0.0658017173,
0.6460441351,
0.0339766033,
0.7371712923,
-0.3086704314,
0.3057989776,
0.0907048509,
-0.3861948252,
-0.5052800775,
0.7337912321,
0.2475659847,
1.1436799765,
0.3254192472,
0.5910664797,
0.4308600426,
0.0806756988,
-0.8345838189,
0.3816179633,
-0.3079081178,
-0.4847919643,
-0.4034146369,
-0.4123976231,
-0.4823108315,
0.149764061,
0.3099205792,
-1.2675138712,
0.2995805144,
0.2552425861,
-0.6889438033,
0.3311772048,
-0.392570585,
0.3081814945,
0.3499906957,
0.1814566553,
-0.2151554525,
-0.4654006958,
0.1299644411,
-0.0741249919,
-0.2048559189,
-0.0422009863,
0.2331516296,
0.7103171945,
-0.6062577963,
1.1113419533,
-0.2088332176,
-0.2874766588,
0.4637582004,
0.1315664351,
0.4482366443,
-0.0663413107,
0.0379948132,
0.1202115193,
0.3251998127,
-0.1044472009,
-0.6758514047,
0.8990362287,
-0.8692876697,
-0.4359995127,
-0.6418590546,
-0.4280003905,
-0.3367900848,
0.0159127004,
0.1838379502,
0.8119562864,
-0.5115983486,
0.1150777563,
0.4623010755,
-0.1000483409,
0.4064294696,
0.8082538843,
-0.0005183279,
-0.4952290952,
0.6769508123,
0.340043664,
0.4773907959,
0.3054639697,
-0.0096547222,
-0.2516361773,
-0.3827547133,
-0.5270171762,
-0.0756047815,
-0.7123197913,
-0.3258430958,
-0.9020039439,
-0.3622493148,
-0.8046364188,
-0.0093080988,
-0.4313658178,
-0.4998449683,
-0.3301503658,
0.1862613112,
0.1859326363,
1.1500396729,
-0.1111554727,
0.5572420955,
-0.536054492,
0.3572013676,
0.4921113551,
0.4045931101,
-0.1202339604,
-0.7349023223,
0.0279772636,
0.2053298205,
-0.5832805634,
-0.6467920542,
0.0919190273,
0.4175436497,
0.2743454576,
0.5085490942,
0.0068421625,
0.7872690558,
-0.5878751874,
0.9136693478,
0.3883668482,
-1.3125872612,
0.7339698076,
-0.4074778855,
0.7278597355,
0.7579669952,
0.0432835221,
-0.7305006385,
-0.5793737769,
-0.018728191,
-0.2535197437,
1.4564193487,
0.350754261,
0.0705041513,
0.1541896462,
-0.1110342517,
-0.1009783,
0.0842913017,
-0.4482761025,
0.1130086705,
-0.2021027952,
-0.3918512464,
-0.0115844309,
0.0290498901,
-0.0953885689,
0.1184790581,
0.7180115581,
-0.267705977,
0.0886184052,
0.1013141274,
-0.2120489776,
-0.1058698297,
0.1539725214,
0.6957281828,
0.3473203182,
-0.3237623572,
-0.0394935943,
0.3069658279,
-0.8097342849,
0.1113996953,
-0.1141032502,
-0.2691444159,
-0.0611930229,
0.1287472844,
0.9706077576,
0.254430443,
-0.2757533491,
0.506539464,
-0.0381915234,
0.2916713953,
-0.2189804763,
0.0936875641,
-0.222690925,
0.4054738879,
0.4080254734,
0.3730966151,
0.4683764875,
-0.9495751858,
0.0371569693,
0.2193908244,
-1.0323839188,
-0.6221584082,
0.3606937528,
0.4726725817,
-0.7402808666,
0.5647751689,
0.3924282193,
-0.6037577391,
0.3592502475,
0.5006113648,
1.0846288204,
-0.8786991835,
0.0462459736,
0.4477696717,
0.1611332595,
-0.2028619498,
0.1672991961,
-0.4241416454,
-0.6124258637,
-0.1410868019,
-0.6161737442,
-0.3785912693,
0.0521453321,
-1.0823172331,
0.4757100344,
-0.3445050418,
-0.5764907598,
0.0826067477,
-0.3051194549,
-0.3847292662,
0.1331127733,
0.2475145161,
0.8854858875,
-0.877727747,
0.7534252405,
0.2583394349,
-0.6565521359,
-0.2306528836,
0.3286542594,
0.3027463257,
-0.6910705566,
0.8216926455,
-0.0441131592,
-0.8919739127,
-0.2198830396,
-0.1749354899,
-0.954069376,
0.9386453032,
0.0422795936,
-0.4062691629,
0.0220672376,
0.1006029248,
0.8283691406,
-0.438467592,
0.3237056136,
0.9169861674,
0.1777081639,
0.3316963613,
-1.4546878338,
-0.3231724203,
0.2552933097,
0.0373577289,
0.3539052904,
-0.5667011738,
0.4447393119,
-0.1628520489,
-0.4411836863,
0.5087239742,
0.7588738203,
-0.2022793591,
0.4344657063,
0.6259304285,
0.3594247699,
0.5081549883,
-0.2497971356,
0.5702259541,
0.0755875111,
0.1777046919,
1.5868397951,
-0.5894251466,
0.9637010098,
0.3303791881,
-0.2260382324,
0.4139665067,
0.1996922493,
0.6222302318,
0.6828531623,
0.0746889487,
-0.4851206243,
0.1882608384,
-0.0166643262,
-0.2464675158,
0.6586497426,
0.5390769839,
-0.2693500817,
-0.1081139371,
0.3360617161,
0.0601640902,
-0.1413021386,
-0.1135018915,
1.3824521303,
0.2001235038,
-0.9057062864,
0.4169180393,
-0.4924034178,
0.4238188267,
-0.6716336012,
0.1476610601,
-0.3477326334,
0.4126004279,
-0.0478307456,
-0.7179688215,
0.3094217181,
0.2292035967,
0.0766604692,
-0.0623576194,
0.2244445682,
-0.5142509341,
-0.1831925511,
0.371252954,
-0.0499445647,
0.2320922315,
0.0656252578,
-0.2903999686,
0.3873500824,
0.0987909138,
-0.089255631,
-0.003031794,
0.3705529273,
-0.0202686507,
0.6814454794,
0.3593603075,
0.0424910076,
-0.1587164849,
0.4491928518,
1.0619957447,
-0.4974253774,
-0.7697954774,
-0.4300807416,
0.3916597962,
-0.2075491548,
-0.4471648633,
0.3109111488,
0.5453692675,
0.2087401897,
0.1852186918,
0.7973909378,
-0.2516707778,
0.7930842042,
-0.3790848553,
0.6002132297,
-0.2482643574,
0.2633994222,
-0.3733267486,
-1.1726392508,
0.0393024012,
0.5820259452,
-0.4340267181,
-0.2029033452,
0.7358683348,
0.7396584749,
-0.2907969952,
0.5477586985,
0.4537988305,
0.4204778969,
0.5834293962,
0.2679160833,
0.9176672697,
-0.5798099637,
0.5211191177,
0.2612345815,
-0.5817354321,
-0.3244531155,
-0.3783943653,
-0.8406529427,
-1.0792793036,
-0.2957945466,
-0.1216288581,
0.3296303451,
0.6759844422,
0.7582054138,
-1.1164455414,
-0.4385762513,
0.2284423709,
-0.5234646797,
-0.2058824152,
-0.1564580798,
0.1630829573,
-0.6098624468,
-1.0260150433,
0.7427268624,
0.6253381371,
0.0764689073,
-0.3880812824,
0.1961250901,
-0.0183357168,
0.4650003016,
0.4778198004,
0.3136164248,
-0.6828564405,
-0.3742548227,
-0.3011848927,
-0.2288242429,
0.1394480616,
1.0493104458,
-0.5759247541,
0.6302087307,
0.7353093624,
0.2376773804,
0.6720933914,
0.0219339188,
0.8880378008,
-0.3475133181,
0.1085263565,
0.3632394373,
0.2136313468,
0.3219339848,
-0.1644913256,
0.271364361,
-0.3369505107,
-0.5931347609,
-0.8801316023,
0.2749889195,
-0.9812201262,
0.1778194457,
0.7310006618,
-0.377045691,
0.0144700259,
-0.463596791,
-0.4566571414,
0.1797353327,
-0.7657415271,
0.8912070394,
0.7264838219,
-0.2529240251,
0.2217872143,
-0.4682517946,
0.6275491714,
0.1005613729,
-0.7834877372,
0.0251701344,
0.3669010997,
0.3416243494,
0.5895959139,
1.0491000414,
0.0371376164,
0.0754921213,
-0.0368638225,
-0.268120259,
0.543017149,
-0.3539690673,
-0.4949937463,
-0.1957085729,
-0.1647540331,
-0.5730130672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10164v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10164v2 | Analyzing FOMC Minutes: Accuracy and Constraints of Language Models | 2023-04-20T08:54:00 | 2024-02-19T15:24:39 | Wonseong Kim, Jan Frederic Spörer, Siegfried Handschuh | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research article analyzes the language used in the official statements
released by the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) after its scheduled
meetings to gain insights into the impact of FOMC official statements on
financial markets and economic forecasting. The study reveals that the FOMC is
careful to avoid expressing emotion in their sentences and follows a set of
templates to cover economic situations. The analysis employs advanced language
modeling techniques such as VADER and FinBERT, and a trial test with GPT-4. The
results show that FinBERT outperforms other techniques in predicting negative
sentiment accurately. However, the study also highlights the challenges and
limitations of using current NLP techniques to analyze FOMC texts and suggests
the potential for enhancing language models and exploring alternative
approaches. | [
-0.4912880063,
-1.0129418373,
0.5968438387,
0.283898294,
-0.1232799292,
-0.2425430417,
-0.3431881368,
-0.6420600414,
0.0459002815,
0.7177461982,
-0.4804537594,
-0.4770381749,
-0.3013406396,
0.2258768082,
-0.3625128269,
1.0139183998,
-0.2908942401,
0.0498939157,
-0.1459371299,
-0.1836730391,
0.0950108394,
-0.7028571963,
-0.5726933479,
-0.0416054763,
0.349186182,
0.2265874147,
0.9416334033,
0.5063467622,
0.8146953583,
0.3096301258,
-0.198661983,
-0.1286702603,
-0.2644572258,
-0.3039051592,
-0.0398001447,
-0.4215851724,
-0.7418451905,
0.3898311853,
0.5313896537,
0.5219780803,
-0.3754612803,
0.1020730361,
0.016675178,
0.700747788,
-0.5899002552,
0.8267955184,
-0.3545515835,
-0.1182924733,
-0.2963480651,
-0.1940610558,
-0.4547485709,
-0.3862608075,
0.5461122394,
-0.2164050639,
0.2004646957,
0.110460937,
1.0008550882,
-0.0283964481,
-0.2893564701,
-0.6956782341,
-0.6033880711,
0.854986608,
-0.8991990089,
0.4343792498,
0.4329207242,
0.1964116991,
0.1873431951,
-0.5312741995,
-0.6986650825,
-0.2771773636,
-0.0121599557,
0.0419786647,
-0.4661942422,
0.4033969641,
0.2620746195,
0.5080940723,
-0.1419335455,
-0.2913535237,
-0.4962109327,
0.2272126228,
0.4736669362,
0.3068276942,
-0.1076759696,
-0.0280016772,
-0.5026273727,
-0.1550893784,
-0.4828234315,
0.050486315,
0.5949000716,
0.521441102,
-0.069071129,
0.6178948283,
-0.2061550021,
0.7683314681,
-0.1545460224,
0.1054375544,
0.0587098226,
-0.0911072865,
-0.3343997598,
-0.050198257,
0.5880737305,
0.7110924125,
0.0783590302,
-0.0031952308,
-0.3569400907,
0.0419531316,
0.2097388953,
-0.6874647141,
0.0348830521,
0.1036902964,
-0.5611166358,
-0.5113725662,
0.5852906108,
-1.2027457952,
0.1113751978,
-0.5333213806,
0.0090124747,
-0.0635594502,
0.1257742047,
0.0156574547,
0.001076378,
0.1611380726,
0.0524668321,
-0.8786084652,
0.6058074236,
0.7407830954,
0.6752759218,
0.219618842,
0.0377542041,
-0.1867244393,
-0.2646165788,
-0.3490928113,
0.8389366269,
-0.3232144117,
-0.4471611083,
0.064312309,
0.1444633305,
-0.1834223419,
-0.4125402272,
0.5218039155,
-0.4258287549,
0.4229541719,
-0.4070654809,
-0.4593189359,
-0.437423259,
0.0288881548,
-0.6950355768,
0.1373456568,
0.4502560198,
-0.6518904567,
0.0583341569,
-1.0370414257,
-0.1125421152,
-0.5422644019,
-0.1492647082,
-0.1521217376,
0.2602455616,
0.0604170561,
0.2544664443,
-0.5524949431,
0.0405190922,
-0.2905506492,
-0.0153677128,
0.8355163932,
-0.3376090229,
0.4351575375,
0.4771585763,
-0.5192312002,
0.1892240644,
-0.584802866,
0.0811032653,
0.0681810081,
-0.132083267,
-0.1570580006,
0.2593135536,
0.1698376983,
0.2162915468,
0.0316043086,
-0.4243561327,
-0.093087703,
-0.5574326515,
0.5127925277,
1.0824023485,
0.1054439396,
0.5040063858,
-0.2339051813,
0.8784954548,
-0.3161682487,
0.3291375935,
-0.1968416274,
-0.3736828268,
-0.6127948761,
0.1488655657,
0.2061677724,
0.6579126716,
-0.2526476383,
0.2788589895,
0.0876312107,
-0.4532810152,
-0.289267391,
-0.3671418428,
0.189910844,
0.4928861856,
0.2175798565,
-0.0863011703,
-0.5613080263,
-0.8319810629,
-0.5357194543,
-0.2191877663,
0.2490439713,
0.3298453689,
0.2732691467,
-0.2669410706,
1.0312014818,
-0.6425580978,
0.0305922218,
0.0827094316,
0.4425207675,
0.3026941419,
0.1372831464,
0.7568451762,
-0.5950119495,
-0.2809334397,
-0.0493925773,
-0.2510009706,
-0.2125709355,
-0.1400223523,
0.1791926026,
0.7849770188,
0.3649887741,
-0.3611445725,
0.5868269205,
0.9967479706,
-0.7034466863,
0.5178338885,
0.0434903763,
0.36181885,
-0.3449540734,
0.2294475436,
0.0857779458,
-0.0026327493,
-0.5033697486,
-0.0701794475,
-0.0182553828,
-0.0795729756,
-0.2983721197,
0.7064759731,
-0.3943372965,
0.2349262834,
-0.3464751244,
-0.013477359,
-0.0534563251,
0.2771711946,
0.011854942,
0.6297312379,
-0.0034948119,
-0.2601914406,
0.138858214,
0.2658621967,
-0.4953590631,
0.1909586489,
-0.4672475159,
0.010680845,
0.0523347445,
0.0630732253,
-0.8262302876,
-0.1205837429,
0.4879986346,
-0.249348253,
0.2543620169,
0.3610884547,
-0.1472340226,
-0.3089186847,
-0.1314471811,
-0.1381434649,
0.5011509061,
-0.3603732586,
0.1053664535,
0.488108933,
-0.2871027291,
-0.5613303781,
-0.7983675599,
-0.1176128536,
-0.0975564122,
-0.6177259088,
0.0411210768,
-0.0608951077,
-1.0026174784,
-0.0138683766,
-0.3752044141,
-0.1755331159,
-0.0204787049,
0.2236770093,
0.5044797063,
-0.5135057569,
-0.0160961114,
-0.2598008513,
-0.242946595,
0.2918075621,
0.0776538253,
0.3048744798,
-0.6347001791,
0.0289222132,
-0.5443854928,
0.2888126373,
0.4931417704,
-0.0087631727,
0.9044311047,
0.1374193281,
-0.0457972698,
0.2215805501,
-0.4688857794,
-0.1805622131,
-0.448566556,
0.0065437844,
-0.0673528984,
-0.8577671647,
0.4657520652,
0.2357661724,
-0.048576057,
0.672789216,
0.3545282781,
0.2392332554,
1.0468989611,
0.6339924335,
0.0180444773,
0.755487144,
-0.0178050157,
0.4605188668,
-0.3039533496,
0.0620089099,
-0.8490351439,
0.0170981158,
-0.3695303798,
-0.5252238512,
-0.151531145,
0.0272680465,
0.1255624145,
0.0884431675,
-0.3097601831,
0.5189180374,
0.1250194609,
-0.3295289278,
-0.0593830608,
-0.0770293623,
0.0342664309,
-0.2890874743,
-0.2957993448,
-0.8455449343,
0.8544619679,
0.5845829248,
0.5979002714,
-0.161035955,
0.1036288887,
-0.0306124799,
0.6279686689,
-0.5633480549,
0.3309950829,
-0.1311394572,
-0.7274793983,
-0.1135964468,
-0.7216575742,
-0.5235489011,
-0.0687067732,
-0.2092932463,
-0.4725920856,
0.4195330441,
-0.0156527031,
-0.6331473589,
0.2160687,
-0.5807397962,
1.0439704657,
-0.1908214986,
0.1392265111,
-0.2938880026,
-0.4782461226,
0.2535849512,
0.0372300148,
0.5102908611,
-0.4194310606,
-0.3178183734,
0.7343559265,
-0.4337188005,
0.6100267768,
-0.1743419915,
-0.2260033041,
0.5654054284,
-0.2386796772,
0.4310974479,
-0.1905267537,
-0.2396479547,
0.4113153815,
-0.095150739,
-0.3703792989,
-0.2351159602,
0.762422204,
-0.6772300601,
-0.1970864087,
-0.5550116897,
-0.1668821871,
-0.0560848825,
-0.3162479997,
0.1185970455,
0.4495234787,
-0.6679396629,
0.0282761753,
0.0328729562,
-0.2826593518,
0.4092851877,
0.5275382996,
-0.3860012293,
-0.734926641,
0.6782305837,
0.2245912254,
0.2559333444,
0.3726504743,
0.2566686869,
-0.2069215775,
-0.2909870446,
0.2303034961,
0.2078186572,
-0.6127269268,
-0.0285272934,
-0.6317712665,
0.2197782099,
-0.7960468531,
-0.2227726281,
-0.4355412722,
-0.6719684601,
-0.3991858065,
-0.2376066148,
0.2148241103,
0.6317985654,
-0.299505502,
0.7190742493,
-1.0614352226,
0.0842585117,
0.2619202435,
0.4377506375,
-0.3555498123,
-0.0708555952,
-0.4956322014,
0.0671241656,
-0.3132078946,
-1.0060728788,
0.4845938683,
0.05052194,
0.4190012813,
0.7171756625,
0.1427956074,
0.5935238004,
-0.1512536556,
0.8789622188,
0.2464006841,
-1.2395106554,
0.4439319074,
-0.5684381127,
0.2217576057,
0.3851341903,
0.2170777619,
-0.6250819564,
-0.5258625746,
-1.0299733877,
-0.9565105438,
0.9617402554,
0.1967499703,
-0.0064717187,
-0.5552873611,
0.376902163,
0.1106030196,
0.5378372669,
-0.1662080735,
-0.2217101157,
0.0153752854,
-0.2076702416,
-0.2407748401,
-0.6882043481,
-0.0576178543,
0.0142907854,
0.6016793251,
0.0705784187,
0.4499774575,
0.2510864437,
0.2613915801,
-0.6222324371,
0.3372110724,
1.1754758358,
1.0258872509,
-0.3940709531,
-0.1961514801,
0.120008342,
-0.3139492273,
-0.3181017935,
0.2139366269,
0.2428328842,
0.3436964452,
0.43693313,
0.7888174653,
0.4477582276,
-1.0253232718,
0.4793674052,
-0.2073988169,
-0.23409082,
-0.507681191,
-0.1849936843,
-0.3633648455,
0.4228413701,
0.3140366375,
0.5599729419,
0.0581033528,
-0.7200793624,
0.2366533428,
-0.0011109206,
-0.7081121206,
-0.6682398915,
0.8739981651,
0.2519903779,
-0.000768804,
0.6208040118,
0.1972653121,
-0.5222683549,
0.5345476866,
0.1090056971,
0.9127497077,
-0.6013274789,
0.0943751112,
0.2930243015,
0.3816904724,
-0.3425747454,
0.3807822764,
0.2328520715,
-0.4968824089,
-0.5952584743,
-0.4071196616,
-0.517111659,
-0.1922434121,
-0.7685911655,
0.2944257259,
-0.7058039308,
-0.7558104992,
0.0589586683,
0.1509526223,
-0.4546008706,
0.1895230114,
0.2666729391,
0.9395775199,
-0.7770564556,
0.6375089288,
0.3970362246,
-0.2355037928,
-0.6439763904,
-0.2417422831,
0.321509093,
-0.3922941983,
0.3190182149,
0.1252304614,
0.2882296145,
-0.4042950273,
-0.675591886,
-0.3587151766,
0.5680174232,
0.4645055234,
-0.5108896494,
-0.0984484851,
-0.0681869313,
0.441408962,
-0.4629386961,
-0.0773031563,
0.6225886345,
0.8792729378,
-0.2288564891,
-1.0035420656,
-0.2337626666,
-0.1084961966,
-0.5365188718,
0.5379289389,
-0.6900477409,
1.4137972593,
-0.1018805206,
-0.3962200582,
0.2028865069,
0.6089493036,
-0.289324373,
0.4983789921,
0.6183978915,
0.2472851723,
0.455699116,
-0.26660797,
1.0847786665,
-0.3865120709,
0.6528148651,
0.7883986831,
-0.1504402608,
0.8386276364,
0.6435672045,
-0.3329247534,
0.4779030085,
0.282840848,
-0.0578874089,
0.4072817862,
0.1477525979,
-0.238777563,
0.0558375306,
0.0267350692,
-0.3511324227,
0.5714669228,
0.4160270393,
-0.5810546875,
-0.1316708624,
-0.0982788578,
0.2864117622,
0.1930661798,
-0.1269119978,
0.5737948418,
0.3442598283,
-0.4331404865,
0.0519499369,
0.1955662966,
0.4777205884,
-0.5106270909,
0.0345239788,
0.0628250316,
0.5641902685,
0.0848770291,
-0.3941800594,
0.9574306607,
0.1649747342,
-0.1310690045,
-0.4657022953,
0.3880679309,
-0.3314723969,
-0.2098213583,
0.0813442543,
0.3432916999,
0.1150601953,
-0.4685693681,
-0.6118360162,
0.1247227341,
0.1550513208,
-0.571118176,
0.2107892483,
0.3852041662,
0.295692414,
0.0976225287,
0.5226743817,
0.0585978404,
-0.3005866408,
-0.3140466809,
0.4512066245,
-1.1980037689,
-0.5725192428,
-0.9386954308,
0.3369695544,
0.0077935788,
-0.3323784769,
0.6758310795,
0.3475918174,
0.4685069323,
-0.3035598993,
0.5073757768,
-0.0638644993,
0.6077906489,
-0.5580512285,
0.8770536184,
-0.090599604,
0.1382545531,
-0.3752991259,
-0.7688544393,
-0.2750531733,
0.8368067741,
-0.525972724,
-0.1566979736,
0.8859126568,
0.5169661045,
0.3843447864,
0.6245110035,
0.2587705553,
0.291285634,
0.2726116776,
0.1727508903,
0.9545203447,
-0.3281661272,
0.6949663162,
-0.6359661818,
0.0229165349,
-0.5026782155,
-0.8922725916,
-0.686912477,
-0.5267122984,
-0.5345599651,
-0.3001976609,
-0.1815223396,
0.8794091344,
0.2326962352,
-0.6960737109,
-0.4905741215,
0.2142603546,
-0.0505890362,
-0.2630518377,
-0.3054655194,
0.4421104193,
-0.217613712,
-0.7256227732,
0.2513734698,
0.2238235921,
0.3883764446,
0.1552545428,
0.0770664662,
0.0568005815,
0.4112122655,
0.4743981063,
0.1581218392,
-0.7026454806,
-0.43579638,
0.2475892454,
-0.2009816319,
-0.0852107629,
1.0968023539,
-0.2869458795,
0.3849177659,
0.5352621675,
-0.0244661141,
-0.1444160044,
0.1114074215,
0.9105592966,
-0.3687326908,
0.3588914275,
0.2247412354,
0.2377900332,
0.0034713421,
-0.1274595708,
0.67566818,
0.1027984843,
-0.7951930761,
-0.7713656425,
-0.3923634291,
-0.9062205553,
-0.3836581409,
0.7876480222,
-0.285941869,
-0.5832363367,
0.1431851238,
-0.3372537196,
0.0506261773,
-0.5587026477,
0.6910746098,
0.9651520252,
-0.0210124329,
-0.0075591216,
-0.9381496906,
0.3316440582,
-0.0836975425,
-0.3735946715,
0.3191486001,
0.5179269314,
-0.2008192539,
0.1628546268,
0.7315126061,
-0.0661384389,
0.3010974824,
0.2182366252,
0.1485664845,
0.1371669173,
0.0342874937,
-0.4698154926,
0.1088961512,
-0.1167017892,
-0.0846094713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10158v1 | Does Manipulating Tokenization Aid Cross-Lingual Transfer? A Study on POS Tagging for Non-Standardized Languages | 2023-04-20T08:32:34 | 2023-04-20T08:32:34 | Verena Blaschke, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the challenges with finetuning pretrained language models (PLMs) is
that their tokenizer is optimized for the language(s) it was pretrained on, but
brittle when it comes to previously unseen variations in the data. This can for
instance be observed when finetuning PLMs on one language and evaluating them
on data in a closely related language variety with no standardized orthography.
Despite the high linguistic similarity, tokenization no longer corresponds to
meaningful representations of the target data, leading to low performance in,
e.g., part-of-speech tagging.
In this work, we finetune PLMs on seven languages from three different
families and analyze their zero-shot performance on closely related,
non-standardized varieties. We consider different measures for the divergence
in the tokenization of the source and target data, and the way they can be
adjusted by manipulating the tokenization during the finetuning step. Overall,
we find that the similarity between the percentage of words that get split into
subwords in the source and target data (the split word ratio difference) is the
strongest predictor for model performance on target data. | [
-0.3217539489,
-0.6032881737,
0.2085617632,
0.086965777,
-0.5455654263,
0.1111201122,
-0.2541189492,
-0.4418839812,
0.2751845419,
0.3085845709,
-0.0018656634,
-0.4299430251,
-0.5771412253,
0.0502083823,
-0.2668733299,
1.1431050301,
-0.1888621598,
0.1813034713,
-0.0557746291,
-0.2463464141,
-0.5490216613,
-0.7713201642,
-0.4385757446,
-0.3179534972,
0.5000474453,
0.2629591823,
0.6052516103,
0.7906185389,
0.5737791061,
0.2382643074,
-0.0493714251,
-0.2143460512,
-0.5629825592,
-0.0989820957,
-0.5517129898,
-0.8570044637,
-0.2683858573,
0.0657613277,
0.8039890528,
1.1628594398,
0.2047308385,
0.1614037007,
0.0450053811,
0.3630901277,
-0.5272544026,
-0.043632064,
-0.7526093125,
0.0958322063,
-0.6627274156,
-0.4241954088,
-0.2425535768,
-0.0216033347,
0.0726247206,
-0.6851766109,
0.221122697,
0.1107857376,
0.897623837,
0.1022482589,
-0.2291870564,
-0.0220619682,
-0.7617824078,
0.8994871378,
-0.618031919,
0.4623324275,
0.3484053314,
-0.0094755013,
-0.0088176029,
-0.6289218068,
-0.3261379898,
-0.1096809283,
-0.0968518555,
-0.083791852,
-0.0979536399,
0.0876086578,
0.2966118753,
0.427382201,
-0.3399806619,
0.1947009861,
-0.466155827,
-0.4165711403,
0.4803304076,
-0.0823124498,
0.5364598036,
-0.1988898814,
-0.6981417537,
0.0210884549,
-0.7539415359,
0.1908242553,
0.3789124489,
0.6476454139,
0.10809201,
0.7488099337,
0.0276839621,
0.7774828076,
0.2197313309,
-0.1637615263,
0.4116909504,
-0.6879439354,
-0.1813321561,
0.158323139,
0.6829048395,
0.3460125327,
0.4699275494,
-0.4775584936,
-0.2979001999,
-0.0005378053,
-0.214790687,
-0.5356290936,
-0.2072658241,
-0.2373179793,
-0.5158028603,
0.0517006963,
0.3311909735,
-0.4058924019,
-0.1585392058,
-0.3226621747,
0.5686780214,
-0.6995639205,
-0.3149378002,
0.2447870672,
-0.3675193191,
0.4102645218,
-0.0597480871,
-0.9374065995,
0.2302699238,
0.8898069263,
1.030512929,
-0.4339718521,
-0.4852540493,
-0.8089905381,
0.2654421926,
-0.4536647499,
0.629907608,
-0.7750009894,
-0.4323189557,
-0.1563944519,
-0.0752168819,
-0.529553175,
-0.631845355,
0.377329886,
-0.3288237154,
0.0095770173,
-0.3878405392,
-0.6285393834,
0.158917293,
0.1478330046,
-0.6677213311,
0.7445725203,
0.0745352358,
-0.8142207265,
0.6044057608,
-0.449782759,
-0.720060885,
0.0875794962,
-0.1609304845,
-0.1185944825,
0.5286328197,
0.0193968657,
0.2413179576,
0.2303976864,
0.1926843077,
-0.1640336961,
-0.5701233149,
0.2120628059,
-0.2423253357,
0.4682755172,
0.0927970856,
-0.2294387817,
0.0738451034,
-0.6263777018,
-0.176649496,
-0.0159908645,
-0.4175940156,
-0.7929615378,
-0.2872313559,
-0.0875410363,
0.2903579175,
0.279879123,
-0.7724738121,
0.4481380582,
-0.5983167887,
0.2937793434,
0.5641610622,
-0.0031500661,
0.8683979511,
-0.595425725,
0.7894804478,
0.2359511256,
0.0653539747,
-0.2308169752,
-0.3133367896,
-0.8686851859,
-0.3310131431,
0.8487679958,
0.3796459138,
-1.0891742706,
0.0444661193,
-0.4516271353,
-0.2874409556,
-0.7760196328,
0.0207443051,
0.3546374142,
0.4871834219,
0.3703510165,
-0.6844495535,
-0.4211189151,
-0.7609528899,
-0.6588155031,
-0.0073848027,
-0.0208578035,
0.0067615663,
0.0298020281,
0.2850243449,
1.1005837917,
-0.0432727672,
-0.4461188018,
-0.2847197652,
0.4875006676,
-0.1335769445,
0.7272005081,
0.8325132728,
-0.4909513593,
-0.7011981606,
0.2658687234,
-0.0242103711,
-0.3172655702,
-0.2088599205,
-0.0838826746,
0.3404951394,
0.6311689615,
-0.4190900624,
0.3991938531,
0.5232339501,
-0.3319067657,
0.4782124162,
0.0042679315,
-0.0208142083,
-0.7793901563,
0.3496752083,
-0.2883819342,
-0.2968423665,
-0.7654456496,
-0.2713435292,
-0.2291218936,
0.1640663445,
-0.7209338546,
0.6711957455,
-0.5336823463,
-0.2027972192,
-0.1396290958,
0.0377704836,
-0.1518878192,
0.2829850614,
0.1175448224,
0.7481787801,
0.8092166185,
-0.3105299175,
-0.0897143632,
0.0897150189,
-0.2598539293,
0.5674321651,
-0.5570318699,
0.2062217146,
-0.1222262532,
-0.020228222,
-1.0242378712,
0.2481123805,
0.4865567684,
-0.4126989841,
0.5452826619,
-0.3334374726,
-0.4707612693,
0.3870924413,
-0.33154881,
0.571611166,
0.2651610672,
-0.252427727,
0.5651282668,
0.1556892842,
-0.1692987531,
-0.4102428257,
-0.9349484444,
0.023124814,
-0.3491568267,
-0.3305675387,
0.491758585,
-0.0136986971,
-0.1158147156,
0.0704658255,
-0.2986601889,
0.2338898182,
0.0734556168,
0.0241777431,
0.2656132877,
-0.2383157164,
0.1544375122,
-0.0595434904,
-0.2098878175,
-0.1570459008,
-0.4261777997,
0.7529584765,
0.0935797542,
-0.439198792,
-0.3823974729,
0.2034219056,
0.3742421567,
-0.5706873536,
0.8723623753,
0.7434412837,
-0.1433363408,
0.0062895711,
-0.3236517012,
0.0887230411,
-0.4119564891,
0.1097453609,
-0.8467271328,
-0.8757898808,
0.5463716388,
-0.1875409931,
-0.0578028448,
0.4081271291,
0.1758630872,
0.0998991504,
0.9542662501,
0.7335045934,
-0.1606043577,
0.9263988137,
-0.0754537061,
0.1909136772,
-0.6988496184,
-0.1099727005,
-0.4860331416,
-0.6211527586,
-0.7293158174,
-0.574100256,
-0.0859146118,
0.4583681822,
0.0926895738,
0.2595819831,
-0.160293296,
0.4848080575,
0.5087044239,
-0.3775543571,
0.410910815,
0.1663194448,
-0.3568000793,
-0.0606361814,
-0.9394681454,
-0.2982516587,
1.0277738571,
0.2587907314,
0.7048717141,
-0.1269240975,
0.8466793299,
-0.0979240164,
0.3754936159,
-0.7777164578,
0.4017636776,
-0.5338115096,
-0.3251616657,
-0.2786954343,
-0.5264541507,
-1.1406279802,
0.3058485687,
-0.0624196827,
-0.6545670033,
0.4860596955,
-0.105137296,
-0.2283246219,
0.3225910366,
-0.7713928223,
0.8237544298,
-0.2516493499,
-0.1158257574,
0.1120290831,
-0.6809840798,
-0.0569853708,
-0.301959306,
0.186626941,
-0.0423664637,
-0.1919165552,
0.9209904671,
-0.3537960351,
0.7546220422,
-0.2399840057,
-0.0694934279,
0.0975471288,
0.2975709736,
0.2428377122,
-0.4588628709,
-0.1110459492,
0.5129203796,
0.3610679805,
-0.5222622752,
-0.5113294125,
0.6768682599,
-0.5965175629,
-0.561535418,
-0.3159783781,
-0.5218772888,
-0.350079149,
0.3295321763,
0.2224704623,
0.1724271327,
-0.0984238535,
0.314190805,
0.1175721362,
-0.0401268229,
0.4389904737,
0.5369785428,
-0.2514915168,
-0.1168575361,
1.0902614594,
0.4765524566,
0.4704527855,
0.4551725388,
0.2252407521,
-0.2317725122,
-0.7675036192,
-0.2123569399,
0.449010253,
-0.4866930544,
-0.0965858474,
-0.1842907965,
-0.0412795134,
-0.4791170657,
-0.1502004415,
-0.3766908646,
-0.6214661002,
-0.537727356,
-0.1401133984,
0.0443597026,
0.5295870304,
-0.2002168894,
0.3623380363,
-0.8526293635,
0.0702365339,
-0.0954270884,
0.508652389,
-0.3111048043,
-0.6743412614,
-0.1741397679,
0.0245567076,
0.1879761666,
-0.7904478312,
0.2157897055,
0.387645036,
0.5255997777,
0.3248925805,
0.0234163087,
0.9762973785,
-0.4729808569,
0.776203692,
0.2797896862,
-1.242983222,
0.222464174,
-0.1943916082,
0.3423805237,
0.5701532364,
0.3652373254,
-0.7882276773,
-0.3714827001,
-0.4366019368,
-0.8121182919,
0.8884232044,
-0.0587936565,
0.2996888757,
-0.0162967406,
0.3576052189,
0.4420066774,
0.1573224664,
-0.5110164881,
-0.2203729451,
-0.1495782435,
-0.1233018637,
-0.2538396418,
-0.0504552498,
0.0410152301,
-0.266987741,
0.3928803205,
-0.1530923396,
-0.1785205454,
0.1747718155,
-0.2634279728,
-0.2469921112,
0.2475823164,
0.2756716311,
0.5690106153,
0.0959995389,
0.315505743,
0.0016238458,
-0.3992376328,
-0.1591472328,
0.2110924721,
-0.2267538309,
0.1661375612,
0.4244387746,
1.0060915947,
0.1911988556,
-0.5957823396,
0.6365024447,
0.1466505378,
-0.116126582,
0.406336993,
-0.032471925,
-0.1911206543,
0.0562045909,
0.1430175453,
0.1286067218,
-0.0814680755,
-0.5993617773,
0.1305947304,
0.5076634884,
-0.2683891058,
-0.6802255511,
0.4909883738,
0.0197583828,
-0.3634549081,
0.3316965997,
-0.0378325358,
-0.4851615429,
0.2582813799,
0.6516868472,
0.5471878648,
-0.4196635187,
0.2612996697,
0.0897670388,
0.3623863161,
0.1635849029,
0.1101846397,
-0.2746858299,
-0.7093351483,
-0.5720050931,
-0.7709078193,
-0.00816481,
0.070405215,
-0.7135010958,
0.2903645039,
-0.2976571023,
-0.2756378353,
-0.0372644402,
-0.1604693085,
-0.7658120394,
-0.0233886763,
0.3882685602,
0.795996964,
-1.0259028673,
0.9297956824,
0.9093312025,
-0.4354632199,
-0.8809961677,
0.1325426549,
-0.5455274582,
-0.4968106747,
0.6149920225,
-0.060387291,
0.0697751641,
0.1045632362,
-0.3539741337,
-1.0941323042,
0.711556673,
0.6134397388,
-0.5779519081,
0.0564966723,
0.7887430787,
0.6773828864,
-0.216489315,
-0.1605030745,
0.8024716973,
0.4312437475,
0.2461269349,
-1.4186471701,
-0.0072762351,
-0.0021376677,
0.0915143713,
0.3202581704,
-0.6287374496,
1.0052485466,
0.2035347223,
-0.6080095768,
0.0861339048,
0.3738373816,
-0.0254741739,
0.2009596378,
0.4513473213,
0.4329094887,
0.5110092759,
-0.1448338479,
0.844817996,
-0.3923791349,
0.2821760178,
1.0623562336,
-0.315905571,
0.9325361848,
1.0257617235,
0.0530771017,
0.160722062,
0.3603458107,
0.0493416637,
0.4636075795,
0.1757067889,
0.0669131801,
-0.2082973719,
-0.3611036837,
-0.2004035413,
0.6969785094,
0.1444749832,
-0.4107422233,
-0.3105228245,
0.3147318065,
0.0351997204,
-0.0319077969,
-0.4082238376,
0.7868278623,
-0.0336931497,
-0.8001818061,
0.6872007251,
0.2204766572,
0.8135690093,
-0.6472008824,
0.173687458,
-0.3626385927,
0.0292283017,
-0.1982928514,
-0.6787251234,
0.5407102704,
-0.0817495733,
0.1848699898,
-0.5148419738,
0.9246383905,
-0.7086789012,
-0.1637055576,
0.161647886,
0.7398126721,
0.3813041449,
0.0298005901,
-0.6095984578,
0.1657259613,
0.0317855552,
-0.1485612243,
0.4811581671,
0.3991372585,
-0.3028078675,
0.269598186,
0.8085190058,
0.4803428948,
0.5363793969,
0.2337725759,
0.7864964604,
-0.4680588841,
-0.4401237369,
-0.7964908481,
0.3483220041,
0.2510022521,
-0.2264801115,
0.9300490618,
0.7024196386,
1.2802226543,
-0.107158199,
0.5112339854,
0.0176967215,
0.3737196028,
-0.3724088967,
0.6106061339,
-0.5260289311,
0.0359670557,
-0.0428640731,
-0.9304196835,
-0.4937838614,
0.4944571853,
-0.6896574497,
-0.0780279264,
0.5209745169,
0.5464764237,
-0.0589658581,
-0.3647690713,
0.4648758173,
0.0741847083,
0.2194918543,
0.306788981,
0.8868277073,
-0.1434503347,
0.5872277021,
-0.3571857214,
-0.115778558,
-0.0136861922,
-0.7102635503,
-0.8136609197,
-0.4693957269,
-0.3798618615,
0.1876283437,
0.0802367702,
0.5893757939,
0.6237700582,
-0.7873631716,
-0.0724040046,
-0.0747346058,
-0.0907122269,
-0.1795578301,
-0.251111865,
0.3372019827,
-0.3794524968,
-0.9329149723,
0.2454007566,
0.3050296903,
0.1538517624,
-0.1827280372,
0.1750213057,
-0.1951026171,
0.1778064072,
0.4816023409,
0.2612065375,
-0.5694832802,
-0.3773441017,
0.0137197496,
-0.012760547,
0.1621572822,
1.0348439217,
-0.7586681843,
0.5572451949,
0.7304067016,
0.525269866,
0.2910528779,
0.4028225243,
0.414911896,
-1.1387777328,
0.3051435649,
0.1908516586,
0.2819572985,
0.5297214389,
-0.1540595293,
0.112682417,
0.4338672161,
-0.1062079966,
-0.7904106975,
0.1889670044,
-0.8333473206,
-0.2792829275,
1.3337907791,
-0.2819852531,
-0.3388445079,
-0.1392674893,
-0.3695379198,
0.5217778087,
-0.0533436053,
0.4603156745,
0.8350138664,
-0.1677526832,
0.075044103,
-0.0429536253,
0.4253120422,
0.7711289525,
-0.4718774855,
-0.0573093928,
0.2078446746,
0.6739233732,
0.2525037229,
0.5642914772,
-0.2243357003,
-0.1002395749,
-0.1584240198,
-0.0544651374,
-0.1698483527,
-0.1878538579,
-0.6141870022,
0.1317598075,
0.1393601447,
-0.6051183939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10153v1 | On the Independence of Association Bias and Empirical Fairness in Language Models | 2023-04-20T08:27:21 | 2023-04-20T08:27:21 | Laura Cabello, Anna Katrine Jørgensen, Anders Søgaard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | The societal impact of pre-trained language models has prompted researchers
to probe them for strong associations between protected attributes and
value-loaded terms, from slur to prestigious job titles. Such work is said to
probe models for bias or fairness-or such probes 'into representational biases'
are said to be 'motivated by fairness'-suggesting an intimate connection
between bias and fairness. We provide conceptual clarity by distinguishing
between association biases (Caliskan et al., 2022) and empirical fairness (Shen
et al., 2022) and show the two can be independent. Our main contribution,
however, is showing why this should not come as a surprise. To this end, we
first provide a thought experiment, showing how association bias and empirical
fairness can be completely orthogonal. Next, we provide empirical evidence that
there is no correlation between bias metrics and fairness metrics across the
most widely used language models. Finally, we survey the sociological and
psychological literature and show how this literature provides ample support
for expecting these metrics to be uncorrelated. | [
-0.1550932527,
-0.4694468379,
0.7361818552,
0.1999706179,
0.2362803966,
-0.2196989805,
-0.0490308069,
-0.7830094099,
0.2611682713,
0.4873558879,
0.0043067816,
-0.0424183309,
-0.8946374655,
-0.0505914576,
-0.4500661492,
0.9857805371,
0.4306174219,
0.6087324023,
-0.419249177,
-0.5319693685,
-0.4457814097,
-0.7855840325,
-0.6881918311,
-0.2634998262,
0.3160212934,
-0.1724524796,
0.7126271725,
0.9001852274,
0.3364727497,
0.2800346911,
-0.093441844,
-0.5105521679,
-0.2999669015,
0.2099685669,
-0.5045734644,
-0.4710926116,
-0.5570361018,
0.5498477817,
0.5126825571,
1.16472435,
-0.034221299,
0.2833504379,
0.0317187756,
0.9577891231,
-0.8476270437,
0.1448989958,
-0.6020158529,
-0.1524822712,
-0.5917944908,
0.2373901755,
-0.3331660628,
-0.4860362113,
0.0332478881,
-0.2573725879,
0.3090822101,
0.054196734,
0.8812692165,
-0.2314026803,
-0.5059598684,
-0.3799022734,
-0.5089235306,
1.0068188906,
-0.5812792182,
0.3796107471,
0.4973525703,
0.1996484548,
0.1752819866,
-0.5141585469,
-0.5181786418,
-0.093415305,
-0.1706195623,
-0.0883360803,
0.0129308319,
0.0495935567,
0.3359224498,
0.4930118024,
-0.0347711928,
0.3113422692,
-0.4912029505,
-0.0788162872,
0.6917604208,
0.0460805446,
0.4697810113,
-0.0144273015,
-0.1299465001,
0.033513505,
-0.6663343906,
0.3087588251,
0.7885587215,
0.2763733864,
-0.1885298043,
0.4403100014,
-0.1588913053,
0.2401743531,
-0.178972736,
0.0097841658,
0.4257900715,
0.0281065293,
0.105456382,
0.1911200285,
1.0849835873,
0.0863868147,
0.5295273066,
-0.4479950368,
-0.3832559288,
0.5743408799,
-0.1341785342,
-0.4925405979,
0.0442081653,
0.0711641833,
-0.6828754544,
-0.3220615089,
0.176804617,
-0.9498674273,
-0.4661704004,
-0.1460440308,
0.3589324951,
0.3924642503,
-0.6209531426,
0.1094247773,
-0.1287130862,
0.0604972839,
-0.0546929128,
-1.0534754992,
0.4477505982,
0.7894277573,
0.3876211643,
-0.1733562648,
-0.227868259,
-0.4605262578,
-0.0697747171,
-0.3447871208,
0.683026433,
-0.8011712432,
-0.1294212639,
0.1823015511,
0.044756975,
0.3594050109,
-0.3577950895,
0.3998744786,
-0.3263324201,
0.3196055889,
-0.6700276732,
-0.3263266683,
-0.0942733288,
-0.2539219856,
-0.7536590695,
0.6885035038,
-0.1597888023,
-0.8277085423,
0.7461568117,
-0.6274046898,
-0.4193378985,
-0.2005136758,
-0.7735401392,
-0.1713763922,
0.1928771436,
-0.0885874853,
-0.0226400197,
-0.4712293744,
0.669146657,
-0.9502632022,
-0.0261578411,
0.5428404808,
-0.6648583412,
1.026019454,
0.1436535418,
-0.6095487475,
-0.3044347763,
-0.7897345424,
-0.1972059757,
0.0710147843,
0.096983254,
-0.5861694217,
0.1942929476,
-0.1319516152,
0.2470945716,
0.1902694255,
-0.7267489433,
-0.344589144,
-0.1853048354,
-0.1794505566,
1.1880247593,
-0.5663591027,
0.8493497968,
-0.322956115,
0.3287760615,
0.0039306455,
0.0260627232,
0.3296384215,
-0.327447623,
-0.4942978919,
-0.2694104314,
0.6311793327,
0.1615632176,
-0.0342453457,
0.3245027065,
-0.0783891231,
-0.045275867,
-0.9930891395,
-0.1044477299,
0.5230124593,
0.3080624938,
-0.0438067503,
-0.9566734433,
-0.5009019971,
-1.0961421728,
-0.8483704329,
-0.0840520412,
0.1812557131,
0.4499022067,
0.2638839483,
0.3444925547,
1.2802081108,
-0.232518822,
-0.3867486715,
0.063316755,
-0.0687820464,
0.2678338885,
0.4901034236,
0.7167043686,
-0.6261565089,
-0.4408396184,
-0.241925329,
-0.9770029187,
-0.5631834269,
0.3675858378,
-0.1853878945,
0.0474121086,
0.1931547523,
-0.4027273655,
0.511579752,
0.4550085664,
-0.6199432611,
0.4982738793,
0.0689142272,
0.0901655331,
-0.628046751,
0.165373385,
0.0282225609,
-0.0467732772,
-0.585621655,
-0.090200901,
-0.3758489192,
0.3033238053,
-0.4251153171,
0.9861338735,
-0.4743295908,
-0.4727006853,
-0.4034061432,
0.1601164341,
-0.0413412526,
0.2508194745,
-0.073198773,
0.5200023651,
0.7484886646,
-0.7160596848,
-0.2948712409,
0.0594295524,
-0.3382963538,
0.5974726677,
-0.5614951849,
0.1361283511,
-0.2783033252,
0.0352896005,
-0.5496773124,
0.0631048605,
0.1144466475,
-0.5035786033,
-0.3534691632,
0.0090134032,
-0.3040425777,
0.1510217339,
-0.0183186848,
0.6240696311,
0.6048585176,
-0.5830146074,
0.5692341328,
1.1389038563,
-0.13259314,
-0.9045001268,
-0.9136630297,
-0.314773947,
-0.3118027747,
-0.4028648138,
-0.0650461391,
0.0672357902,
-1.0700838566,
0.0461776033,
-0.2037961632,
-0.2091374248,
0.2465861887,
0.3736281097,
0.1131210998,
0.0083178431,
0.011208836,
-0.0466305837,
-0.1594360918,
0.3256863952,
0.0388294049,
0.2228344083,
-0.0122993989,
-0.2760189772,
-0.0475612283,
0.5135834813,
0.291687578,
-0.2650724947,
0.7606450319,
0.4679628015,
-0.2814569473,
0.181392327,
-0.7680628896,
-0.1493779719,
-0.4751761258,
0.3017382324,
-0.1463951021,
-0.8926286101,
0.8252476454,
0.5876398087,
0.1594577134,
0.4031050205,
0.2786541283,
0.2078617513,
1.2820911407,
0.8106808662,
-0.19043082,
0.4920262098,
0.4090639055,
0.3737948537,
-0.4823344946,
0.1075770557,
-0.9125364423,
-0.1205318794,
-0.9574177861,
0.2977578044,
-0.0738839284,
0.0368908457,
-0.3428446651,
-0.4076163471,
-0.4056544304,
0.6139255762,
0.4564999938,
-0.2307542711,
0.2140323669,
-0.1028391123,
0.1773991138,
-0.2555831969,
-0.3137833476,
-0.6004711986,
1.399222374,
0.2974105775,
0.6749593019,
0.2824174762,
0.6521810293,
0.4509238601,
0.5655166507,
-0.2446240485,
0.6214942932,
-0.3496847451,
-0.9779957533,
0.0749409795,
-0.5630054474,
-1.0703668594,
0.5312376618,
-0.299980998,
-0.8879619837,
0.5182568431,
0.2284574211,
0.1420088857,
0.3041074276,
-0.7139267325,
0.6849067807,
-0.3041575849,
-0.6130310297,
0.0285442807,
-0.4853670001,
0.5912088156,
0.0089355437,
0.8550758362,
-0.5444613099,
0.3418886662,
1.1055349112,
-0.1399518698,
0.599632442,
-0.315231204,
0.0011811873,
0.0676808655,
0.18908979,
0.0367804728,
0.0663483515,
-0.2372132987,
0.3518194556,
0.0264701638,
-0.5623698235,
-0.2650430799,
0.6323249936,
-0.735081017,
-0.717223525,
-0.7832417488,
-0.6449495554,
-0.1186036989,
0.5765902996,
-0.2177254111,
0.3901455104,
-0.3240835667,
0.0614270382,
0.4705446064,
-0.1045731306,
0.5301164985,
0.6326597333,
-0.5319313407,
-0.0991787091,
0.5833380222,
0.0833651274,
0.3603047431,
0.0288964435,
0.163027972,
-0.2442470044,
-0.1130719408,
0.0506976545,
0.0786423609,
-0.5748021603,
0.1529437751,
-0.8198343515,
-0.0384323671,
-0.7739349604,
-0.0935177132,
-0.455688417,
-0.4228206575,
0.046608787,
-0.0505049638,
0.1967901438,
1.0568759441,
-0.5065588355,
0.0379208736,
-0.3319045901,
0.2205791622,
0.3494657874,
0.4013707936,
0.2629218102,
-0.3101803958,
0.0055648102,
0.1049695984,
-0.1286492348,
-0.8499829173,
0.1729708016,
-0.105492644,
0.7186158299,
0.6114609838,
0.0045883134,
0.2142314613,
-0.4832561016,
0.7908018827,
0.255531311,
-1.0103427172,
-0.0473907255,
-0.2397775948,
-0.2494930327,
0.6108219624,
0.0941168517,
-0.3772186935,
-0.7191666961,
-0.8695684075,
-0.7576847672,
0.7402243614,
-0.1146530434,
0.2624444067,
-0.2409258783,
-0.0235822052,
0.3870300651,
0.2996250689,
-1.37467134,
-0.431560874,
0.1167393699,
-0.1858689785,
0.0658518597,
-0.258848846,
-0.2420128584,
0.0006643695,
0.3619651198,
0.0675894916,
0.1863273084,
-0.1352649331,
-0.2098399848,
0.1355303228,
0.4574145079,
0.2186465263,
0.7528239489,
-0.1296586543,
0.2840349674,
-0.1441010535,
-0.4809284806,
0.2919989228,
0.0261228159,
-0.0553804785,
0.0245515052,
-0.1055278853,
0.6188051701,
-0.1619382352,
-0.3913186491,
0.7815890312,
-0.0336908065,
-0.0801370963,
-0.1536847651,
0.0268547647,
-0.0868885592,
0.079062663,
0.2817829251,
0.1773355156,
0.1308071315,
-0.7164199352,
0.0952195898,
0.5982174873,
-0.4525896013,
-0.2548533082,
0.7757018805,
0.2266907692,
-0.3292762637,
0.1721526086,
-0.455581665,
-0.3304201365,
0.540748775,
0.334664315,
0.8280234337,
-0.0164315384,
0.0281934366,
-0.028486656,
0.2800280452,
-0.2902029157,
0.0756395683,
0.1844467074,
-0.9033165574,
-0.110276483,
-0.6200167537,
0.0585642606,
0.0999507457,
-0.8443753719,
-0.0323687978,
-0.3232336044,
-0.2822605968,
-0.1478269845,
-0.1744094193,
-0.8150597215,
0.257930696,
-0.1001223773,
0.5668521523,
-1.1866593361,
0.481687516,
0.2942343056,
-0.6452553868,
-0.6386144161,
-0.1195164993,
-0.1200502142,
-0.6845873594,
0.6636137962,
0.2356489152,
0.0199972726,
-0.3849473298,
-0.3851147592,
-0.7222446799,
0.5886654258,
0.5115458965,
-0.2568857074,
-0.1986434907,
0.3610461652,
0.3904514909,
-0.5215166211,
0.6726448536,
0.6070311666,
0.316863209,
-0.6093347073,
-1.0134190321,
-0.073594436,
-0.1378967911,
0.1186949834,
-0.0877978057,
-0.4839861691,
1.0063705444,
-0.0379646122,
-0.2922734618,
-0.1009606123,
0.8754161596,
0.2440876365,
0.4341887236,
0.4219898283,
0.4568594396,
0.6109039187,
-0.0890256912,
0.8640598059,
-0.3984271586,
0.2677817345,
1.0538913012,
-0.4837979972,
0.3089282513,
0.5326502919,
-0.3887258172,
0.5376583338,
0.3873875141,
0.3370164335,
0.7126610875,
-0.0158491284,
-0.3147189021,
-0.0480166189,
-0.2883687019,
-0.5995007157,
0.5154992938,
0.2105159014,
-0.6725073457,
-0.1427792162,
-0.2530815899,
0.2024336904,
0.3913042247,
-0.4456609488,
0.5860661268,
0.3535022438,
-0.7415191531,
-0.2878918052,
-0.0626704171,
0.874247849,
-0.6162610054,
0.1398029625,
-0.2952713072,
0.2069584876,
-0.1991764903,
-0.8197607994,
0.0184799545,
0.0241894238,
-0.3774204254,
-0.1026859209,
0.6969709992,
-0.3707891703,
-0.1257239729,
0.3243950605,
0.853636086,
0.2178370357,
0.5605204105,
-0.5666271448,
0.0880232155,
0.0061154445,
0.0172546804,
0.7794292569,
0.457249552,
0.0465702936,
0.3919870257,
0.6530465484,
0.4928176999,
0.2392306328,
0.0200070944,
0.2772653103,
-0.3764331341,
-0.7378061414,
-0.7514673471,
0.4566531181,
-0.1251735985,
-0.2626554668,
0.6450303197,
0.4083379507,
0.7982201576,
0.2220975757,
0.9163194299,
-0.208840251,
0.4448769987,
-0.340901792,
1.0042754412,
-0.5379247665,
0.2446478456,
-0.5105066299,
-0.8121066093,
0.0194174349,
0.5544126034,
-0.5993402004,
0.7063184381,
0.6336544156,
0.8096533418,
-0.0771484599,
0.0976405218,
0.093642056,
0.0530855432,
0.3883964121,
0.1948008984,
0.5310134292,
-0.2093806416,
0.1855262816,
0.1869824976,
-0.3906343579,
0.2117721885,
-0.8719354272,
-0.6340993047,
-0.3684230745,
-0.0204030126,
-0.694761157,
0.1710467786,
0.707449019,
0.5097080469,
-0.680713892,
-0.6739443541,
0.0266191363,
0.2812466919,
-0.1153808981,
-0.2788443863,
0.1482132524,
-0.4009735286,
-0.7033574581,
-0.227157563,
0.0471767224,
-0.283639133,
-0.4671800435,
-0.1015130505,
0.0138749741,
0.3253554404,
0.2103575319,
0.4604249597,
-0.5219860673,
-0.2732137144,
-0.5089718103,
-0.4498082399,
0.0966999307,
0.6712723374,
-0.4875256419,
0.4336113632,
0.4426167607,
0.5321406126,
-0.1837334782,
-0.4177521765,
0.7545611262,
-0.5197079778,
0.34636271,
0.0160721745,
0.5629999042,
0.3015843928,
-0.0984170884,
0.481779933,
0.4370723665,
-0.7172349691,
-1.2590487003,
0.5118948221,
-0.5634981394,
-0.0009877726,
1.1983492374,
0.0503268838,
-0.3950654268,
-0.0892147794,
0.2563117146,
0.0733071342,
-0.4812311828,
1.0574859381,
0.6535897255,
0.0034546123,
0.0816054195,
-0.7226203084,
0.5878002644,
0.6148549914,
-0.6917787194,
0.0772934034,
0.3593343794,
0.3630374372,
0.1506523937,
1.149620533,
-0.4815478623,
0.4103907943,
0.1451662779,
0.3649908006,
0.3807615936,
0.065430209,
-0.2199241221,
0.0704487041,
0.2490495592,
-0.000434712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.10145v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.10145v2 | Can ChatGPT Reproduce Human-Generated Labels? A Study of Social Computing Tasks | 2023-04-20T08:08:12 | 2023-04-22T08:55:33 | Yiming Zhu, Peixian Zhang, Ehsan-Ul Haq, Pan Hui, Gareth Tyson | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The release of ChatGPT has uncovered a range of possibilities whereby large
language models (LLMs) can substitute human intelligence. In this paper, we
seek to understand whether ChatGPT has the potential to reproduce
human-generated label annotations in social computing tasks. Such an
achievement could significantly reduce the cost and complexity of social
computing research. As such, we use ChatGPT to relabel five seminal datasets
covering stance detection (2x), sentiment analysis, hate speech, and bot
detection. Our results highlight that ChatGPT does have the potential to handle
these data annotation tasks, although a number of challenges remain. ChatGPT
obtains an average accuracy 0.609. Performance is highest for the sentiment
analysis dataset, with ChatGPT correctly annotating 64.9% of tweets. Yet, we
show that performance varies substantially across individual labels. We believe
this work can open up new lines of analysis and act as a basis for future
research into the exploitation of ChatGPT for human annotation tasks. | [
-0.2855237722,
-0.6379594803,
0.2810015082,
0.3098441958,
-0.2967309058,
0.4965823293,
-0.2836543322,
-0.6597890258,
0.4020050466,
0.2980153561,
-0.5057447553,
-0.3638313413,
-0.8428109884,
-0.1773778647,
-0.4075053036,
1.3561595678,
0.3438781202,
-0.291721046,
-0.1632775813,
0.045187071,
-0.2352492958,
-1.1404182911,
-0.8954255581,
-0.4397486448,
0.7586545944,
0.3972243667,
0.9659182429,
0.4057816565,
0.5241798759,
0.1747917086,
-0.1198310331,
0.1900318861,
-0.7302943468,
0.118916668,
0.0566503368,
-0.1726999432,
-0.5028908849,
0.3964756727,
0.7634381056,
0.5882058144,
0.106085062,
0.0886680931,
0.4098724127,
0.4434711337,
-0.150951013,
0.4109057188,
-0.6936329007,
-0.0567521453,
-0.3026255369,
0.0740166605,
-0.5372170806,
-0.5131234527,
-0.0819174498,
-0.5617600679,
0.2659576535,
0.1468863934,
0.626917541,
0.3216692209,
-0.0693781897,
-0.1379001588,
-0.7622199655,
0.5082108974,
-0.577670753,
0.1734097004,
0.3184342384,
0.3797063828,
-0.41249156,
-0.756641686,
-0.4641032517,
-0.2087179571,
-0.0843472779,
0.0627966449,
-0.1240511313,
-0.0895746201,
0.4520737529,
0.1336987764,
-0.3038102686,
-0.0160009656,
-0.3478192985,
-0.3500472307,
0.7394004464,
-0.0849164054,
0.5199189782,
-0.2871913612,
-0.2938893139,
-0.2245559394,
-0.4971936941,
-0.1902844757,
0.1784386486,
0.3578557968,
0.0120568993,
0.6096438766,
-0.3027328253,
0.2448172718,
-0.2807217836,
0.140228793,
0.435433954,
0.0342178978,
0.0486170761,
0.1074169502,
1.0397721529,
0.6485581398,
0.5922136307,
-0.3476465046,
-0.0840681866,
0.2026350349,
0.2537920475,
-0.6074579954,
-0.8623267412,
-0.0413235277,
-0.1084596217,
-0.4989136457,
-0.1082220599,
-0.6316943765,
-0.9233766198,
-0.0949084833,
0.1780307591,
-0.5121904612,
-0.3520766497,
-0.1697462946,
-0.2742495835,
0.2658763528,
0.4629663527,
-0.5617324114,
0.1707438082,
1.1192018986,
1.014236331,
-0.2355619073,
-0.2906233668,
-0.3510906994,
-0.1146200672,
-0.1796795577,
0.9099068046,
-0.6132727265,
-0.4722177982,
-0.1858505905,
-0.1896641254,
0.1235588565,
-0.232145384,
0.4603442848,
-0.5368140936,
-0.1179790422,
-0.5778931975,
-0.6588107944,
0.143448025,
0.3823342323,
-0.645888865,
1.0458868742,
-0.1058651507,
-0.9774676561,
0.2896832526,
-0.6343695521,
-0.4093358517,
0.3601311743,
-0.0548207462,
-0.5563979149,
-0.2665973008,
-0.0369661525,
0.5410650969,
-0.230596602,
0.2876555622,
-0.5082680583,
-0.3208461702,
0.7821416855,
-0.5269580483,
0.740521431,
0.1021404415,
-0.4553523958,
-0.2433482707,
-0.4965910912,
-0.0855592787,
0.1699890792,
-0.4100466073,
0.0405845754,
0.4068896472,
0.0662741959,
0.1053088754,
0.2246992886,
-0.8359633684,
0.238366127,
0.1514235139,
0.4762772024,
0.8016850948,
-0.0069181412,
0.0964270979,
-0.2875275016,
0.4479843974,
-0.2739863098,
-0.0038414763,
0.1075394675,
-1.0782247782,
-0.6649753451,
-0.3552054465,
0.2807874978,
0.6778602004,
-0.5881625414,
-0.0090445336,
-0.4838641286,
-0.7711677551,
-0.3530243039,
-0.0473514944,
0.4591743052,
0.3337842524,
0.2735229135,
-0.1751237959,
-0.459787637,
-1.1111662388,
-0.5197111964,
-0.4084380865,
-0.1652102023,
0.4443949461,
0.316481024,
-0.1679901034,
1.1910995245,
-0.5021447539,
-0.0439890847,
-0.1016355976,
0.5610072613,
-0.0317655839,
0.2374465168,
0.4150698185,
-0.7867793441,
-0.4899901748,
0.0239075739,
-0.5988559127,
-0.4495489001,
0.0286751445,
-0.089617677,
0.1625317037,
0.3203421831,
-0.3491749763,
0.310325712,
0.4629157782,
-0.1662463546,
0.5249437094,
0.0404580384,
0.243170768,
-1.0255863667,
-0.2128587067,
0.104527913,
-0.454405576,
-0.6446347237,
-0.4658768475,
0.0125581603,
-0.4016405344,
-0.4417257309,
0.3681239784,
-0.140716061,
-0.050622955,
-0.3141268194,
0.3500259221,
-0.3958738148,
0.4873314798,
-0.0599141717,
0.6460055709,
0.4309799373,
-0.1896394193,
0.4504738748,
-0.0077007944,
-0.1957720071,
0.3451539278,
-0.8051517606,
0.4709181488,
-0.2337069213,
0.4889933467,
-1.4107611179,
-0.5794202685,
0.7868661284,
-0.7758486867,
-0.0358693115,
-0.4830477238,
-0.8057971597,
-0.2404800057,
-0.2384779304,
0.0526694693,
0.7861750126,
-0.4480342865,
0.2767039239,
0.6652104855,
-0.1473438144,
-0.2358729243,
-0.5718150735,
0.2088365257,
-0.1791107804,
-0.4320486486,
0.0730371103,
0.2297090292,
-0.0763783008,
-0.0528611802,
0.3628595173,
0.1912823021,
0.0012192341,
0.6229519844,
0.1249523237,
0.1835698187,
0.2804220617,
-0.3276984096,
-0.0705031678,
0.1172024831,
-0.2576015294,
0.4668893516,
-0.2776331604,
-0.3974069655,
-0.3893664777,
0.3178784251,
0.4035338163,
-0.1627865732,
0.5556860566,
0.8660163879,
-0.3741677105,
0.0455827303,
-0.5842452049,
-0.0241892003,
-0.4495236576,
0.3944088817,
-0.105290629,
-0.9956328869,
0.4476659894,
0.117480129,
0.2749894857,
0.24514018,
0.454295814,
-0.3975529969,
0.8526824713,
0.2937073708,
-0.356744945,
0.6091040969,
0.0414907932,
0.2351709008,
-0.5290980339,
-0.0825067237,
-0.4456940889,
-0.4906464219,
-0.97019732,
-0.5955250859,
0.2415054291,
-0.1982459724,
-0.1629872471,
0.1098071188,
-0.673550725,
0.4377713501,
0.6273652911,
0.3199753463,
0.0020698882,
0.1909093261,
0.6232873797,
0.0438726172,
-0.5209975243,
-0.748865068,
0.8072480559,
0.2480307072,
0.6103211641,
-0.0000598395,
0.783870399,
0.6519867778,
0.914824605,
-0.6600722075,
0.8482370973,
-0.2298493683,
-0.6036553383,
-0.319380343,
-0.2818582356,
-0.9336673617,
0.1754103452,
-0.1156875342,
-1.1938364506,
-0.1715150774,
0.4511858225,
0.0589004271,
0.3238793314,
-0.9776463509,
0.7114095688,
-0.0018566629,
-0.2435159087,
0.0119665125,
-0.466578126,
0.1318066418,
-0.0313878842,
0.1914101988,
-0.4842107296,
0.1819457561,
1.1799212694,
-0.1717903912,
1.5932751894,
-0.273586899,
-0.1257324219,
0.4933467805,
-0.0115646562,
0.5362765789,
-0.0463519581,
-0.0265520047,
0.1239879951,
-0.0811011642,
-0.4229017198,
-0.5922726989,
0.6404999495,
-0.75623703,
-0.7074128985,
-0.3133124411,
-0.4476158023,
-0.1463017464,
0.0667901635,
-0.017169226,
0.270036459,
-0.1526674032,
0.1455051899,
0.3526866436,
-0.1520299315,
0.1628598422,
-0.1801971495,
-0.2697764039,
-0.3322259486,
1.272249341,
0.2916816175,
0.2046731561,
0.0615228526,
0.2159047276,
-0.1218439117,
-0.1344730407,
-0.273588866,
0.1680613905,
-0.6494612694,
-0.1182750314,
-0.8015509248,
-0.1909476072,
-0.2808234096,
-0.1878546625,
-0.4885859489,
-0.7405416965,
-0.1055528149,
0.0289037209,
0.7903467417,
0.933208704,
-0.1965952516,
0.539693892,
-0.5554460287,
0.2613721788,
0.3099807501,
0.3933400512,
-0.0767510086,
-0.2436957657,
-0.0316528492,
0.5832253098,
-0.3432008326,
-1.1411857605,
0.0561948158,
0.0941220596,
0.3762089908,
-0.0143132787,
0.1003727913,
0.3999200165,
-0.379085809,
0.8626987338,
0.0005888807,
-0.5473378301,
0.401824683,
-0.6399816871,
-0.0270394068,
0.1727677435,
0.4744272232,
-0.9223933816,
-0.6012915969,
-0.7290239334,
-0.826996088,
0.7539687157,
0.4231165648,
0.2170001715,
-0.242591992,
0.503400445,
-0.1232295409,
-0.0350933149,
-0.6761458516,
-0.3041880131,
-0.3584729433,
0.039559748,
-0.2894608974,
-0.372507602,
0.2011880577,
0.029269591,
0.6615089178,
0.0401012823,
0.4368566275,
-0.0138730891,
0.090761885,
0.5156764388,
0.2498632818,
0.1062455103,
0.2362811416,
-0.1984005272,
0.2011398673,
0.0724337995,
-0.4291795492,
-0.0192929581,
0.1637536883,
-0.2775680125,
-0.1210438833,
0.1362742782,
0.6719261408,
0.075866513,
-0.4317400455,
0.3184720278,
-0.009159144,
-0.1764715463,
-0.427723676,
0.1942730844,
0.4372324049,
0.3598825932,
0.2597141862,
-0.2577909827,
0.0536597297,
-0.5011203289,
0.2487626523,
0.5481057763,
-0.4809751511,
-0.3454270959,
0.7995212674,
0.0665948838,
-0.7839977741,
0.7996848226,
-0.3076428473,
-0.9395503402,
0.5165959001,
0.4544331431,
0.6879919767,
0.0277238935,
0.4581100345,
0.1993657351,
0.2399783731,
-0.0152400807,
0.019557517,
-0.1670279056,
-0.8874996305,
-0.4333492219,
-0.3856316805,
-0.7997313738,
-0.2503345609,
-0.3562190533,
0.0681203008,
-0.343287617,
-0.4043921828,
0.3881281614,
-0.2098627687,
-0.4549535811,
0.1812081337,
0.4547436237,
0.3018577993,
-0.923569262,
0.7729924917,
0.7997196913,
-0.1470784992,
-0.5718384981,
-0.1123194546,
0.1507468373,
-0.608582437,
0.625579536,
0.136646226,
-0.3640268445,
0.0544539765,
-0.8064297438,
-0.6340774894,
0.8345159292,
0.2582620084,
-0.1618915051,
0.4110310674,
0.5241625309,
0.7576768398,
-0.1675392836,
0.0633662641,
0.5540997982,
0.4474971592,
0.1608509123,
-0.7749291062,
0.0722572356,
-0.3834610581,
-0.1025076956,
0.0460503474,
-0.7573897243,
0.4831947088,
-0.134262383,
-0.3154457808,
-0.4443566501,
0.5690250397,
0.3361345232,
0.0989511013,
0.5091205835,
0.161035344,
0.9411821365,
-0.1549074501,
1.1460309029,
0.0172944572,
0.4511159062,
1.0732079744,
-0.2408097237,
0.7042524815,
0.3674348891,
-0.3271561861,
0.0759111345,
0.802272439,
0.0302286763,
0.0666720197,
0.4094481766,
-0.2824259698,
-0.3821261823,
-0.3236744404,
-0.1666525304,
0.2250025272,
0.4576188028,
-0.182665661,
0.0329546742,
-0.1379352212,
0.4205770195,
-0.3362126052,
-0.0253481772,
0.7504204512,
-0.0473596677,
-0.5361533165,
0.4361333847,
-0.2434080094,
0.6748947501,
-0.1608486623,
-0.0872173682,
-0.2149749845,
0.0479366481,
-0.1164798513,
-0.9997065067,
0.2419759482,
0.0025901084,
0.1077043116,
-0.50331074,
1.1121698618,
-0.1193175614,
-0.6200633049,
0.0539001897,
0.264718771,
0.5463411212,
-0.2803415358,
-0.3332611024,
0.0771880522,
0.3769234717,
-0.4505025744,
0.3608573079,
0.5116799474,
-0.1537333429,
0.905108273,
0.6044486761,
-0.0874915347,
0.3330819607,
-0.0453625284,
1.1074767113,
-0.6430875659,
-0.2096085399,
-0.981828928,
0.385664314,
-0.4277228713,
0.0513757952,
0.548253119,
0.4440518618,
0.6076959372,
-0.0167487245,
1.3146076202,
-0.3380075991,
0.6818874478,
-0.0529772639,
0.734824717,
-0.3020422757,
0.0754393861,
-0.4844399691,
-0.7997003794,
-0.4724004865,
0.4078578353,
-0.5230801702,
-0.0691715106,
0.2457958013,
0.9312716722,
-0.1141896993,
0.2752619088,
0.165393874,
0.0711982995,
0.7192523479,
0.3601193428,
0.9482508302,
-0.0660063773,
0.8161749244,
-0.4552083015,
-0.3766612709,
-0.2287543416,
-0.9496654868,
-0.9860200882,
-0.6460659504,
-0.6579220295,
-0.4455991685,
0.2795386314,
0.7398303747,
0.4830941856,
-0.472933948,
0.1207779124,
0.387896955,
0.0724375322,
-0.0534082651,
-0.2358195335,
0.4824998677,
-0.3187296391,
-0.6922941804,
-0.060894344,
0.076991111,
0.0374423638,
-0.0178027693,
0.0738633648,
0.1082964614,
-0.1769542545,
0.7674810886,
0.3723442256,
-0.4550311565,
-0.7383220196,
-0.1448915899,
-0.0443695933,
0.1377895474,
0.8473044038,
-0.6929829121,
0.1587182432,
0.4204645753,
0.8469347358,
0.5838674903,
0.2867950499,
0.3807667792,
-0.8108834624,
-0.1252636462,
0.1047023982,
0.3313268125,
0.5058529377,
-0.2652216852,
0.5120730996,
0.2336794883,
-0.659842968,
-0.5552455187,
0.1636104435,
-1.1174384356,
0.1534416676,
1.6000030041,
-0.2235362232,
-0.2185999751,
-0.3428680003,
-0.6038810015,
0.4434472322,
-0.6809152961,
0.8325507045,
0.7954278588,
-0.2845381796,
-0.2754434347,
-0.7025791407,
0.3315528333,
0.1612680107,
-0.6203895211,
0.5985406041,
0.5840801001,
0.3080795705,
0.27535972,
1.0267324448,
0.0211290084,
0.0682948232,
-0.0305567756,
0.3138025403,
0.0886541456,
0.2219095826,
0.4081467092,
0.1886250377,
0.2679932415,
-0.3849070966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11095v1 | Is Cross-modal Information Retrieval Possible without Training? | 2023-04-20T02:36:18 | 2023-04-20T02:36:18 | Hyunjin Choi, Hyunjae Lee, Seongho Joe, Youngjune L. Gwon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR | Encoded representations from a pretrained deep learning model (e.g., BERT
text embeddings, penultimate CNN layer activations of an image) convey a rich
set of features beneficial for information retrieval. Embeddings for a
particular modality of data occupy a high-dimensional space of its own, but it
can be semantically aligned to another by a simple mapping without training a
deep neural net. In this paper, we take a simple mapping computed from the
least squares and singular value decomposition (SVD) for a solution to the
Procrustes problem to serve a means to cross-modal information retrieval. That
is, given information in one modality such as text, the mapping helps us locate
a semantically equivalent data item in another modality such as image. Using
off-the-shelf pretrained deep learning models, we have experimented the
aforementioned simple cross-modal mappings in tasks of text-to-image and
image-to-text retrieval. Despite simplicity, our mappings perform reasonably
well reaching the highest accuracy of 77% on recall@10, which is comparable to
those requiring costly neural net training and fine-tuning. We have improved
the simple mappings by contrastive learning on the pretrained models.
Contrastive learning can be thought as properly biasing the pretrained encoders
to enhance the cross-modal mapping quality. We have further improved the
performance by multilayer perceptron with gating (gMLP), a simple neural
architecture. | [
-0.3931079507,
-0.5138379931,
0.5821398497,
-0.1553329378,
-0.6635809541,
-0.1554119289,
-0.2958670557,
-0.3498018086,
0.2564626634,
0.2710660994,
-0.5793969035,
-0.3954745829,
-0.6568956375,
-0.2961928546,
-0.3037267029,
0.8580327034,
0.2432182282,
0.3446087539,
-0.3405792117,
-0.0672762841,
-0.0838126391,
-0.6477492452,
-0.3155691922,
-0.0722990707,
0.6050598621,
-0.0460311659,
0.7467969656,
0.4805462658,
0.6869747043,
0.2919568717,
-0.0113193523,
0.0248481147,
-0.6248548627,
-0.0148857851,
-0.0658791736,
-0.6271868348,
-0.0503658503,
0.2219191343,
0.4039174914,
0.7032628059,
0.2293947041,
-0.2028184086,
0.2223793417,
0.5360562205,
-0.7301350236,
-0.0651262924,
-0.654595077,
0.3993091583,
-0.278488785,
-0.6774582863,
-0.3047707975,
-0.1964180022,
0.4012745917,
-0.8249919415,
0.3220332861,
0.0112937046,
0.7945964932,
0.2126196176,
-0.5189179778,
-0.4464276135,
-0.5629450679,
0.8140046597,
-0.4185853601,
0.7903785706,
0.4539180696,
0.2146834433,
0.0364083126,
-0.8551703691,
-0.6558392048,
-0.292635262,
-0.2477046251,
0.2822780311,
-0.0124090314,
0.0861563906,
0.0539881662,
0.4773728251,
-0.4514262378,
-0.1922713071,
-0.3252588511,
-0.1164216921,
0.2104551643,
0.033783339,
0.2405152172,
-0.0768457875,
-0.539675355,
-0.365649581,
-0.5249765515,
0.1861248612,
0.1522321105,
0.5521012545,
0.1201220676,
0.6245543957,
0.2150495052,
0.4669008553,
0.2010201365,
-0.1424184889,
0.4256074429,
-0.6377695799,
-0.3336499631,
-0.1756587476,
0.5086647868,
0.1896294951,
-0.0136055173,
-0.5108755231,
-0.3378306329,
0.0394733325,
0.5187162757,
-0.6552729011,
-0.2863021493,
-0.4211081862,
-0.7435306311,
-0.2401078194,
-0.1507041901,
-0.4573367536,
-0.2015949786,
-0.3821672499,
1.0380936861,
-0.3361036181,
0.0558279566,
-0.1667590439,
-0.0800433159,
0.1249240041,
0.2726330161,
-0.7683131099,
0.1668897271,
0.4126987457,
0.6897910237,
-0.1594433188,
-0.0749767646,
-0.4138957858,
-0.0722097307,
-0.4083273411,
0.5867686868,
-0.9483990669,
-0.2094317675,
-0.0616161153,
0.0821380615,
-0.0725830644,
-0.5126431584,
0.678976953,
-0.8484265804,
0.2568902373,
-0.5440716743,
-0.4424608648,
-0.4942721128,
0.3517990112,
-0.8106136918,
0.7140557766,
-0.0993193388,
-0.7601386905,
0.3382322788,
-0.0927495733,
-0.4418853521,
-0.144278124,
-0.441907078,
-0.3341304064,
0.2382892519,
0.1978684217,
0.4142168462,
-0.4725264609,
-0.0451891534,
-0.1457823217,
-0.5546296835,
-0.1219825596,
-0.4082995057,
0.5157143474,
-0.066787973,
-0.5000666976,
-0.2127302587,
-0.5299112201,
0.2283526063,
-0.0421861075,
-0.7412936091,
-0.5955457687,
-0.01729808,
0.3321657777,
0.2444693595,
0.1180683598,
-0.5471152067,
0.1136177406,
-0.1331972331,
-0.0155401751,
0.5605780482,
-0.2936395705,
0.7516787052,
-0.3062357605,
0.3652287424,
0.2023703307,
-0.0694131628,
-0.0183166508,
-0.2914370894,
-0.7559249401,
-0.3503426611,
0.6080834866,
0.562151134,
-0.8664922118,
0.4116790891,
-0.1328599751,
-0.435695678,
-0.642995894,
0.0429948829,
0.4621805251,
0.629753232,
0.7421908379,
-0.3799284101,
-0.5239611268,
-0.8664748073,
-0.070776023,
0.3564957082,
-0.1422276944,
0.5245716572,
0.1953410804,
-0.2169157714,
0.5080752373,
-0.0821362212,
-0.7825217247,
0.056470871,
0.3497928977,
0.0174480714,
0.5584980249,
0.4667089283,
-1.091231823,
-0.3244168162,
-0.0299403332,
-0.6158608198,
0.1678542644,
-0.2496787161,
-0.0291304737,
-0.036745552,
0.5959115624,
-0.446387589,
0.6308792233,
0.4060735703,
0.0136918724,
0.1607632786,
-0.2679492533,
0.3309316039,
-0.6831617355,
0.3512251973,
-0.0503186993,
-0.3700182438,
-0.5343447924,
-0.0397126526,
0.0413710624,
-0.0891959667,
-0.2882581353,
0.1702999622,
-0.5831938386,
-0.1274250597,
-0.2798367739,
0.2721694708,
0.0177920889,
0.655723989,
0.1945829839,
0.7561861873,
0.5471585393,
-0.6598658562,
0.0413502604,
0.2726262212,
-0.3203424513,
0.5116651058,
-0.5300291777,
0.1219468936,
-0.4710029066,
0.1644129008,
-0.8838109374,
0.3343150914,
0.2201861292,
-0.2630025446,
0.2631521225,
-0.1893382072,
-0.1093687192,
0.13945131,
-0.222672984,
0.7468399405,
0.4693782032,
-0.5963977575,
0.7654457092,
0.3104087412,
-0.0634760261,
-0.6771023273,
-0.7593694925,
-0.158341676,
0.3340504467,
-0.4519635439,
0.7457175851,
-0.1807173789,
0.3500903845,
0.2473659217,
-0.215612635,
-0.1918689013,
-0.1090411171,
0.020709103,
0.1275863945,
-0.4286777675,
0.2269405574,
-0.2166385055,
-0.1675429791,
-0.3043803275,
-0.0468743667,
0.43325755,
-0.0257193465,
-0.5476106405,
-0.339641124,
0.56339252,
0.4303834736,
-0.2204343677,
0.311572969,
0.6289621592,
-0.4103253186,
0.1047773808,
-0.5191664696,
-0.1379949898,
-0.4432571232,
0.2971935272,
-0.4175162911,
-0.8873446584,
0.3249921203,
-0.1084283367,
-0.2913101017,
0.3329939544,
0.2798933685,
-0.3959090412,
1.0054229498,
0.823407352,
0.1336178631,
0.4106394053,
-0.2458117008,
0.2022942454,
-0.74262923,
-0.7686864138,
-0.4195559025,
-0.7820602059,
-0.4131326973,
-0.500947535,
0.5274846554,
0.0731545687,
-0.0147069609,
0.0460794531,
-0.5096974969,
0.5547351837,
0.8376925588,
0.4647936523,
0.1963429451,
0.0777924135,
-0.4135099053,
-0.3387857676,
-0.6854977608,
-0.0552372895,
0.9859499931,
-0.1926813275,
0.9974095225,
-0.2440128028,
0.4950225055,
0.1404695064,
-0.0643782169,
-0.7246184945,
0.4555064738,
-0.4859804511,
-0.3359532058,
-0.1192766428,
-0.3713518083,
-0.9654939175,
0.4768147767,
-0.6554111838,
-0.3387035131,
0.7958648801,
0.0553557239,
-0.3984720409,
0.2076003999,
-0.446644187,
0.8167808056,
-0.5848711133,
-0.15106906,
-0.3167527616,
-0.7513687611,
-0.0814157575,
-0.0765893087,
-0.1722084433,
0.2008056194,
-0.1716997772,
0.7599599361,
-0.1853441596,
0.7895032167,
-0.2279680669,
0.4203561246,
-0.1112664044,
0.1556877643,
0.3469575644,
-0.3517059386,
0.0490040258,
-0.1384486109,
-0.0570834838,
-0.3531616926,
-0.8872066736,
0.613425374,
-0.7679522038,
-0.4866394103,
-0.3644541502,
-0.446734041,
-0.0479748808,
0.28491804,
0.2970418632,
0.509190321,
-0.1458186954,
0.6289858818,
0.8431938887,
0.1044844389,
0.4901863635,
0.2084055841,
0.2072296143,
-0.3255501091,
0.8484205008,
0.2628592849,
-0.0987192616,
0.5806725621,
0.0625650436,
-0.3671438098,
-0.5416278243,
-0.1925384104,
-0.0108583067,
-0.7152670026,
-0.2520565689,
-0.5808894038,
-0.1767797023,
-0.1286043078,
-0.3715971112,
-0.4418427944,
-0.2843292058,
-0.6235007644,
0.124145709,
-0.1975228041,
0.5697786212,
-0.1650457978,
0.2252466381,
-0.7442251444,
0.4825683832,
0.5403259397,
0.1666159481,
0.1224590316,
-0.4332847297,
-0.2399784774,
0.1355422586,
-0.2521138191,
-0.6014534235,
0.3213982582,
0.404972136,
0.8586786985,
0.3287989795,
0.0919892117,
0.8850809336,
-0.4777834415,
0.5598095655,
0.2390832305,
-0.9686118364,
0.3927883506,
0.0508124009,
0.097274594,
0.9135529995,
1.0440365076,
-0.4537957311,
0.1753445268,
-0.3906270266,
-0.7018975616,
0.5901942849,
0.0744010806,
0.2122375816,
0.102593407,
0.2117083967,
0.1650521308,
0.2421869785,
-0.7738274336,
0.0191604365,
-0.4672136903,
-0.1506793946,
-0.1102561504,
-0.2085364163,
-0.2950254381,
-0.3416070342,
0.614261508,
-0.1273698211,
0.6254242063,
0.4298872352,
-0.4625978172,
0.0370116532,
0.017591998,
0.4341395497,
0.489900291,
-0.1302501857,
0.4631166756,
-0.1087678969,
-0.461074084,
0.1556684673,
0.16449745,
-0.1486362368,
0.0425200276,
0.1542028338,
0.7479244471,
0.3836415112,
-0.4550350904,
1.0614584684,
-0.0151840383,
-0.1186607555,
-0.0631917492,
-0.2583699226,
0.0492903851,
0.6310104132,
0.7102521658,
0.3046931624,
0.2053736597,
-0.5668911338,
0.3574560881,
0.7831642628,
-0.5847936273,
-0.2976253331,
0.6611563563,
0.0964233577,
-0.241228193,
0.8092716932,
0.1680513173,
-0.5920420289,
0.1718579382,
0.6664462686,
0.6553237438,
0.0131933391,
0.0451664627,
-0.0478999168,
0.4242242873,
-0.0193216205,
0.3303208351,
-0.3724551499,
-0.6339169145,
-0.1980158389,
-0.3591319621,
-0.0921347663,
0.08964324,
-0.4704642296,
0.1397474706,
-0.4689493477,
-0.199074924,
-0.0776859745,
-0.0550021753,
-1.0087380409,
0.5647605658,
0.185880959,
0.7959059477,
-0.8041681051,
0.6108320951,
0.5641639829,
-0.6506506205,
-0.5524534583,
0.1158466935,
-0.3483073115,
-0.7987534404,
0.9135944843,
0.0542461313,
-0.1811294258,
-0.0803410336,
-0.4251795113,
-0.7969523072,
1.1025780439,
0.4007370174,
-0.3928712308,
-0.3218409419,
0.0819299743,
0.5412131548,
-0.4544805586,
0.5486553311,
-0.0063214707,
0.3635240495,
0.2020966411,
-0.7186938524,
0.2184834033,
-0.4483344853,
0.1114427075,
-0.2106928378,
-0.3920444846,
0.9812485576,
0.0879801512,
-0.313868314,
-0.0604479536,
0.4979131818,
-0.2987322509,
0.1776424497,
0.4931480587,
0.8154662848,
0.6710804105,
0.004162461,
1.022967577,
-0.1524208486,
0.1839124113,
0.8023304343,
0.1745667309,
0.9136453271,
0.6146380305,
0.2222734094,
0.40380916,
0.5410581827,
0.1681209654,
1.1355302334,
-0.1322745532,
-0.2986750007,
-0.8299435377,
-0.0803165436,
-0.5675430894,
0.4598648846,
0.0981248468,
-0.6749966145,
-0.4954627454,
0.2235120237,
-0.3676660061,
0.0374389365,
-0.2360558361,
0.7035490274,
0.0294254087,
-0.2806760669,
0.7099595666,
-0.1959906071,
0.8877664208,
-0.644825995,
-0.0023258785,
-0.1210569292,
0.0541991666,
-0.2082003206,
-0.5148972273,
0.152369827,
-0.6517545581,
-0.3269178867,
-0.1899329871,
0.8071332574,
-0.6392922997,
-0.348016113,
0.298066467,
0.5224906802,
0.0385354497,
-0.0664128512,
-0.4771770835,
-0.0361529551,
-0.0685362145,
-0.3669266105,
0.4535384178,
0.2361981422,
0.1152960733,
0.459518522,
0.6866638064,
-0.2152759731,
0.2531318665,
-0.2924754918,
1.2016960382,
-0.5659037232,
-0.5517572761,
-0.5530814528,
0.3335319757,
0.1423082203,
-0.1617611647,
0.4345783591,
0.6695638299,
1.0237715244,
-0.1904329509,
0.8177875876,
0.0196794067,
0.316421926,
-0.5574401617,
0.7606490254,
-0.9116658568,
-0.167561993,
-0.1212028265,
-0.9405792356,
-0.4609129131,
0.9609606266,
-0.1553126574,
0.0370665267,
0.7823492289,
0.9766375422,
-0.5204566121,
0.0368379615,
0.3837683499,
-0.026916258,
-0.1011632606,
0.5490529537,
0.6270958781,
-0.6354395747,
0.828651309,
-0.1976323426,
-0.1248094216,
-0.2698338926,
-0.7595775723,
-0.9237386584,
-0.8585632443,
0.1168274507,
-0.1357515305,
0.27004233,
0.7687558532,
0.8743706942,
-0.5450633764,
0.1466401666,
0.2527879477,
-0.1521115303,
-0.1073076576,
-0.0771874562,
0.3494327962,
-0.4366437197,
-0.629191637,
0.6767634153,
0.1329062134,
0.2305014431,
-0.1905168146,
-0.0416141078,
-0.4763949513,
-0.0444659181,
0.4715691805,
0.2288597077,
-0.3667995036,
-0.3880738318,
0.1312777996,
-0.4719427824,
0.430442512,
1.1689869165,
-1.1399873495,
0.5503931642,
0.8803760409,
1.2369599342,
0.9279527664,
-0.0672026947,
0.3586068153,
-0.7494157553,
0.1219196916,
0.488891691,
0.0329680443,
0.2741898,
-0.4100654125,
0.224053517,
0.4164080024,
-0.4585401714,
-0.420357883,
0.0177759659,
-1.1680651903,
-0.1122982875,
0.6147123575,
-0.0941046476,
-0.2736453414,
-0.0563388616,
-0.1862826645,
0.2304752916,
-0.0709743798,
0.7396668792,
0.3209185898,
0.0216487572,
-0.2599924803,
-0.2001514137,
0.5330632329,
0.6902387738,
-0.3915911913,
-0.5153465271,
0.349311918,
0.1895625144,
0.312025547,
0.7736442089,
-0.1610960215,
0.340076983,
0.0416521654,
0.0586039983,
-0.2172506154,
-0.4675597548,
-0.1234889999,
0.4704575539,
-0.431320101,
-0.342740953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09991v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09991v3 | Supporting Human-AI Collaboration in Auditing LLMs with LLMs | 2023-04-19T21:59:04 | 2023-11-30T16:30:09 | Charvi Rastogi, Marco Tulio Ribeiro, Nicholas King, Harsha Nori, Saleema Amershi | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models are becoming increasingly pervasive and ubiquitous in
society via deployment in sociotechnical systems. Yet these language models, be
it for classification or generation, have been shown to be biased and behave
irresponsibly, causing harm to people at scale. It is crucial to audit these
language models rigorously. Existing auditing tools leverage either or both
humans and AI to find failures. In this work, we draw upon literature in
human-AI collaboration and sensemaking, and conduct interviews with research
experts in safe and fair AI, to build upon the auditing tool: AdaTest (Ribeiro
and Lundberg, 2022), which is powered by a generative large language model
(LLM). Through the design process we highlight the importance of sensemaking
and human-AI communication to leverage complementary strengths of humans and
generative models in collaborative auditing. To evaluate the effectiveness of
the augmented tool, AdaTest++, we conduct user studies with participants
auditing two commercial language models: OpenAI's GPT-3 and Azure's sentiment
analysis model. Qualitative analysis shows that AdaTest++ effectively leverages
human strengths such as schematization, hypothesis formation and testing.
Further, with our tool, participants identified a variety of failures modes,
covering 26 different topics over 2 tasks, that have been shown before in
formal audits and also those previously under-reported. | [
-0.2528357208,
-0.4279229641,
0.4946871102,
0.1497910917,
0.0008460042,
0.1836076379,
-0.0201801453,
-0.6474238634,
-0.1698543876,
0.293001622,
-0.2748889625,
-0.2831248045,
-0.3454716206,
0.2400024235,
-0.5222461224,
0.9720202684,
-0.2722012699,
0.2966637909,
-0.5311155915,
-0.2680736184,
-0.7186592221,
-0.7855243087,
-0.7342121601,
-0.4008719027,
0.2281606644,
0.0920974463,
0.5946161747,
0.5354039669,
0.3976039588,
0.3463411927,
-0.1713515818,
0.1256227344,
-0.0356535353,
0.1400045902,
-0.0683514178,
-0.6921283007,
-1.0032668114,
0.3242959678,
0.2048041075,
0.5112370849,
-0.5596837401,
0.0642080456,
0.4036144018,
0.4941584766,
-0.454157114,
0.2649623156,
-0.5728053451,
-0.0392584056,
0.0820181966,
0.2894272506,
-0.17171444,
-0.2766643167,
0.0932716951,
-0.4925326705,
0.1768165231,
0.3039562702,
0.6761652827,
0.6193594337,
-0.4442882836,
-0.485563159,
-0.4986389875,
0.8170828223,
-0.5799702406,
0.3106769025,
0.5732403994,
0.2425263375,
0.0315515511,
-0.4542018771,
-0.8969168663,
-0.3046109378,
0.0493447334,
0.0828970373,
-0.1319057196,
0.1872425228,
0.0335098431,
0.3465081453,
-0.3561781943,
0.2718590796,
-0.08219295,
-0.5167085528,
0.7618891597,
0.4084189236,
0.6084563732,
-0.092814967,
-0.3023535013,
-0.3547810018,
-0.6937286258,
-0.1953456104,
0.4847496152,
0.1900866032,
-0.0908421278,
0.3373422325,
0.2338477373,
0.3895474672,
-0.3272120059,
-0.0151975416,
0.2316193134,
-0.650242269,
-0.1518889368,
0.093301706,
0.6218604445,
0.3619152904,
0.2342757434,
-0.0519235507,
-0.4600322247,
0.5686321855,
0.1760311127,
-0.4143849611,
-0.2365443408,
0.1342090815,
-0.3790111244,
-0.3679009974,
0.0186980739,
-0.4897080362,
-0.8449326754,
-0.478720367,
0.3286567628,
-0.2750128508,
-0.4949415922,
0.0653533712,
-0.2028819025,
0.2764474452,
0.5994483829,
-0.6770502329,
0.1925309449,
1.0716893673,
0.534396708,
-0.0613057651,
-0.5727926493,
-0.7405108809,
-0.0156597681,
-0.2429274768,
0.5420033336,
0.0619389154,
-0.3732946515,
-0.0314163566,
-0.353621453,
0.0261848029,
-0.7122791409,
0.5583150387,
-0.47868976,
0.242795527,
-0.0171577465,
-0.5238740444,
-0.3002206683,
0.655554533,
-0.5556027889,
0.432353586,
-0.0382313803,
-0.5242443085,
0.7352354527,
-0.8906927109,
-0.2636006176,
0.1981377453,
-0.4833832681,
-0.5558828712,
-0.2467011064,
0.2419526875,
0.2531712949,
-0.5291611552,
0.6187623739,
-0.3129024804,
-0.1337448508,
0.0318186395,
-0.659376502,
1.0303721428,
0.0578180663,
-0.4454847574,
0.3660914898,
-0.5181612968,
-0.3521204889,
0.16324763,
-0.476210326,
-0.2996377647,
0.1349564642,
0.1400844306,
0.000763185,
0.2639716566,
-0.3447810709,
-0.0486656353,
-0.2390457839,
0.4568923414,
0.9637956023,
-0.1033680812,
0.2097996175,
-0.5021255612,
0.6239988804,
0.0589410253,
0.0582795888,
-0.2069973052,
-0.4931066334,
-0.7042936087,
-0.4054802358,
0.2354517877,
0.8030531406,
-0.3694855869,
0.7087278962,
-0.2777398825,
-0.2754177749,
-0.9123672843,
0.5695181489,
0.3450907171,
0.485991329,
-0.1351088136,
-0.4385563433,
-0.5037138462,
-0.8045523763,
-0.288539499,
-0.7964447141,
-0.4019876122,
0.354681313,
0.5112671852,
-0.6480741501,
1.0751736164,
-0.085065186,
-0.5479646921,
-0.2500624657,
0.3211331367,
0.0393224359,
0.4143592715,
0.3907891214,
-0.8947575688,
-0.1122616231,
-0.1787435859,
-0.9579662681,
0.0749940798,
0.0344273001,
0.3408669233,
0.5523720384,
0.2326281965,
-0.4368735254,
0.4710015953,
0.4231580496,
-0.591835916,
0.5402777791,
-0.1043834761,
-0.0074554994,
-1.0438779593,
0.0775951594,
-0.2725183964,
-0.3161281049,
-0.3334403932,
0.0575400554,
-0.059705101,
-0.1262405515,
-0.3523378074,
0.3640701473,
-0.4100677967,
-0.0593815185,
0.1449597925,
0.0382749885,
-0.0297732428,
0.3780139089,
-0.2363530397,
0.9691607356,
0.4208733439,
-0.2726293802,
0.4903740883,
0.6129769683,
-0.5823141932,
0.7285472751,
-0.7401307821,
0.4537295699,
0.0568683296,
0.1143575236,
-0.6906806231,
-0.3456913233,
0.0083250711,
-0.4815407693,
0.0104596401,
-0.0845544115,
-0.9250211716,
0.0029404289,
-0.649153471,
0.3813243806,
0.3293016553,
-0.6825813055,
0.7737935781,
0.7044430375,
-0.159621045,
-0.3790172935,
-0.5060910583,
0.5360726118,
-0.4820458293,
-0.9969022274,
-0.3400212824,
-0.0947440043,
-0.7556245923,
-0.1427538544,
0.0538191386,
0.0374931507,
0.715719223,
0.5522550344,
0.5812670588,
-0.1265437603,
-0.1946126968,
-0.3601822555,
-0.0641846433,
0.2448667586,
0.2913303375,
0.3930996954,
-0.728167057,
-0.7205629349,
-0.5532328486,
0.1480500251,
0.7494812012,
-0.2983426452,
0.6197477579,
0.4508562088,
-0.3924485147,
0.1033391207,
-0.6726367474,
-0.1992008686,
-0.4610966742,
0.2768833339,
-0.0046485895,
-1.0854030848,
0.6513901949,
0.1464797407,
0.1958006769,
0.2228418142,
0.5673587918,
-0.1434651166,
1.2841576338,
0.8246292472,
-0.6347610354,
0.3173440397,
-0.2212579697,
0.2615882158,
-0.6760238409,
-0.0865514874,
-0.4324483871,
0.123574011,
-0.4116902947,
-0.0192963462,
0.7236009836,
0.0564275794,
-0.2429999113,
-0.0053587174,
-0.1395965219,
0.1142257452,
0.6785230637,
-0.2019010484,
0.4745394289,
-0.1697588712,
0.1949451119,
0.0759721696,
-0.5330791473,
-0.7661845684,
0.9579110146,
0.4581552148,
0.6812489629,
0.185003534,
0.849826932,
0.4610411227,
0.7429640293,
-0.7863123417,
0.4626679718,
0.2889600098,
-0.7548727989,
-0.4883113205,
-0.2236699462,
-0.8822333813,
0.1989504099,
-0.07970801,
-0.5916793346,
-0.0305787269,
0.346757859,
-0.3620037138,
0.2361945957,
-0.9532117844,
0.8780377507,
-0.2570129037,
-0.0355346166,
-0.427426666,
-0.5170297623,
0.4219826162,
-0.1749872565,
0.5325411558,
0.046500057,
-0.0429235362,
0.8859222531,
-0.5083579421,
0.9721775055,
-0.0073535293,
-0.2469526976,
0.4211804271,
0.3180763423,
0.5395498276,
0.1323963106,
-0.1621545702,
0.2736741006,
-0.1801438779,
-0.1514015049,
-0.336614579,
0.4040675163,
-0.8880891204,
-0.7925379276,
-0.4768255353,
-0.5426687598,
-0.1498738974,
0.2112778127,
-0.3313920498,
0.2115161121,
-0.3249337077,
-0.0226912238,
0.2385471612,
-0.026754722,
0.3793356717,
0.3440646529,
0.0635718405,
-0.3397039771,
0.8574976921,
-0.4174069762,
0.0370859951,
-0.1578135937,
0.0950226486,
-0.14664267,
-0.6542288661,
-0.3899703026,
0.0880908892,
-0.5977718234,
-0.2838103473,
-0.3412884474,
0.1027212068,
-0.5154825449,
-0.0988735557,
-0.0329256803,
-0.1808230579,
-0.3192997277,
-0.1680265367,
0.2636233866,
0.7259868979,
-0.2583879232,
-0.1132286787,
-1.022829771,
0.180637151,
0.6801944971,
0.2635698915,
0.135893628,
-0.1451585144,
0.1032829061,
-0.0220595803,
-0.3102493286,
-0.5393027663,
0.2979055643,
0.0111389793,
0.47685197,
0.4670238793,
-0.0495875254,
0.3587816358,
-0.2603158057,
0.8609068394,
0.0749993622,
-0.9953915477,
0.3907851279,
-0.5498966575,
-0.1951917857,
0.7799708843,
-0.0499491096,
-0.7095718384,
-0.471901983,
-0.3898856044,
-0.929268539,
0.6157977581,
0.0781705603,
-0.0113832774,
0.097639218,
-0.0647241101,
0.0083378507,
0.3168761432,
-0.5018657446,
0.0682778358,
0.005854832,
-0.2300684154,
-0.175710097,
-0.042745959,
-0.4004504681,
-0.0835604295,
0.5161089301,
-0.1456060559,
-0.1859189868,
0.1223034039,
-0.3535227776,
-0.0443522669,
0.2570751011,
0.2562031746,
0.7911676764,
-0.1562787145,
0.1472123414,
0.2042662352,
-0.3384647965,
0.0953628272,
0.1560185105,
0.0338673405,
-0.4326682389,
0.8078621626,
0.453327626,
-0.204694584,
-1.0186607838,
0.6976588964,
-0.2494258434,
-0.1967794001,
-0.6209357381,
0.2154057622,
0.2631292641,
0.1419519782,
0.3035775125,
0.092302531,
0.203297317,
-0.7293624878,
0.1525432765,
0.5145183206,
-0.1567819864,
-0.3639061451,
0.7942849398,
0.4915266037,
-0.6494156718,
0.8755387664,
-0.3421406746,
-0.8471663594,
0.7012841702,
-0.004413134,
1.0974378586,
-0.1103331745,
-0.1967470795,
-0.1220536083,
0.3341458738,
-0.1080622599,
0.1331664175,
-0.2614595592,
-1.0043263435,
-0.2926563621,
-0.4313541055,
-0.6021629572,
0.1325347126,
-0.6652255654,
0.0717088282,
-0.284473151,
0.1250355542,
0.0880837813,
-0.0102234231,
-0.7810239792,
-0.1082415506,
0.1013664678,
0.8199098706,
-1.0391684771,
0.4198497236,
0.974221766,
-0.4572088718,
-0.6854088306,
-0.054782182,
0.4745884836,
-1.0875194073,
0.6046275496,
0.1353765875,
-0.0750169903,
-0.2527405024,
-0.7258387208,
-0.2562978268,
1.2449091673,
0.148770228,
-0.5751710534,
0.0679498687,
-0.0594388396,
0.7830634117,
-0.0940206051,
-0.0906300694,
0.5901632309,
0.39284271,
-0.3529163301,
-1.3495625257,
0.0889843777,
-0.1677238047,
-0.2101575136,
0.1756318808,
-0.4655752182,
0.5430778265,
-0.1842412055,
-0.1075243503,
0.122213304,
0.4442973137,
0.3672682047,
0.5646021366,
1.120334506,
0.6744166613,
0.7829535007,
0.2938817441,
1.0390974283,
-0.1552815735,
0.1306987703,
0.9462702274,
-0.5984587669,
0.66231668,
0.5495225787,
-0.269982934,
0.3309908211,
0.2906847596,
0.0388652831,
0.042009525,
0.2028795332,
-0.3613765836,
-0.394287914,
-0.3035687208,
0.0411987007,
0.4891035557,
0.2154143602,
0.0265462361,
-0.1144734919,
-0.1491983086,
0.0907982811,
0.1292067319,
-0.1599212289,
1.0797188282,
0.0886619017,
-0.7826901674,
0.4183111489,
-0.2281211317,
0.8131141067,
-0.1194422767,
-0.0773892552,
-0.2180894613,
0.4067207575,
0.0545121618,
-0.7792118192,
0.2630780935,
0.1400924325,
-0.0737579465,
-0.4390818477,
0.4684491456,
-0.196374923,
-0.1726951003,
0.3095159531,
0.709536612,
0.1371312737,
-0.2116262168,
-0.5983130336,
0.0282192491,
-0.0806399882,
0.01309954,
0.3999365568,
0.0881595388,
-0.4066899717,
0.900706172,
0.6168087125,
-0.0183464121,
-0.402118355,
0.1834580451,
0.6914727688,
-0.4355096519,
-0.5465432405,
-0.9627708793,
0.2959150672,
0.0125961555,
-0.0124454862,
0.7575054765,
0.578944087,
0.7152737975,
0.3863315582,
0.9055913687,
0.112011753,
0.4896558523,
-0.1042146161,
1.0088945627,
-0.5145823359,
0.374227941,
-0.1954538524,
-0.7555773854,
-0.2622559965,
0.2368848473,
0.1073870957,
-0.1435736418,
0.1658906937,
0.7970778942,
0.1810864061,
0.0513905659,
0.0774447247,
0.2754676342,
0.847982049,
0.3463328481,
1.0433056355,
-0.1728959382,
0.7068429589,
0.1515633911,
-0.3241506815,
-0.1414254904,
-0.8397262692,
-0.9672883749,
-0.6561858654,
-0.2732436359,
-0.3162116408,
-0.0796479359,
0.8729248047,
0.4367995262,
-0.7685604692,
-0.2790484428,
-0.2029393315,
0.4133706391,
0.1206148192,
-0.2134094238,
0.3396067917,
-0.1977926046,
-0.439231962,
0.3072853088,
0.23802571,
0.1617327034,
-0.4599530399,
-0.2315943837,
0.133165881,
-0.2749505341,
0.3099884391,
0.1522672474,
-0.7091259956,
-0.3529620171,
-0.1437950283,
0.0060345042,
-0.1401898265,
0.6975350976,
-0.590295136,
0.3833445907,
0.575427413,
0.7807113528,
0.1416523755,
-0.0051987567,
0.9923376441,
-0.5295733809,
-0.0525064245,
0.4399444461,
0.5876674652,
0.5307062864,
-0.1754655838,
0.6526051164,
0.236123547,
-0.7271841764,
-1.2332706451,
-0.0309539326,
-0.5297900438,
0.0339913964,
0.9150471687,
-0.2156280875,
-0.0953733474,
-0.3812103271,
-0.2688388824,
0.1122530326,
-0.3627898395,
1.1135976315,
0.8657323122,
0.0106501086,
0.3453037739,
-0.4149367511,
0.5443626642,
0.6582986712,
-0.8529515266,
0.0585539304,
0.5202835202,
0.3431329727,
0.4155298769,
0.537451148,
0.1325228214,
0.5128825307,
-0.0689403266,
0.2055473477,
-0.1591627598,
-0.0543920696,
-0.7173494697,
-0.2785297036,
0.3696391582,
-0.0965186432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09982v1 | Radar de Parité: An NLP system to measure gender representation in French news stories | 2023-04-19T21:33:59 | 2023-04-19T21:33:59 | Valentin-Gabriel Soumah, Prashanth Rao, Philipp Eibl, Maite Taboada | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Radar de Parit\'e, an automated Natural Language Processing
(NLP) system that measures the proportion of women and men quoted daily in six
Canadian French-language media outlets. We outline the system's architecture
and detail the challenges we overcame to address French-specific issues, in
particular regarding coreference resolution, a new contribution to the NLP
literature on French. We also showcase statistics covering over one year's
worth of data (282,512 news articles). Our results highlight the
underrepresentation of women in news stories, while also illustrating the
application of modern NLP methods to measure gender representation and address
societal issues. | [
-0.649210453,
-0.483715266,
0.5570434928,
0.7469409108,
0.0783808604,
0.4767756164,
0.0354743339,
-0.2787092626,
0.2426875979,
0.2567050457,
-0.2750015259,
-0.6819680929,
-1.0987046957,
0.207602784,
-0.9397566915,
0.4680327475,
-0.070089139,
0.1406001598,
0.1248141602,
-0.1546399146,
-0.5594254732,
-0.7211734653,
-0.5326787233,
-0.043274872,
0.3822907805,
0.3085699379,
0.7249372602,
0.3099583089,
0.6889480948,
0.2177718133,
-0.0017013103,
0.2384428233,
0.0422009416,
-0.0652270988,
-0.4732237458,
-0.2380583882,
-0.4845239818,
0.2420221567,
0.8788463473,
0.9218223691,
0.0411788933,
0.2717750669,
0.2638805807,
0.9217083454,
-0.6760917902,
-0.0534198917,
-0.0753056034,
-0.104478851,
-0.035825491,
-0.2300719172,
-0.2848441601,
-0.0892736241,
-0.1682257354,
0.0549808033,
0.3099666536,
0.0750459731,
0.8034421802,
-0.0089695547,
-0.703730166,
-0.2449397594,
-0.881126821,
1.1640361547,
-0.3335179389,
0.5212947726,
0.3097207844,
0.1833806932,
-0.1759905964,
-0.5085507035,
-0.3188569546,
-0.142638728,
-0.0401581787,
-0.0887741074,
-0.7483178973,
-0.5157648325,
0.2293425649,
0.2443762869,
-0.5932559967,
-0.3935035765,
-0.0539749153,
-0.1352660656,
0.5959156156,
-0.0440261811,
0.7343366742,
-0.0756335929,
-0.0872850642,
-0.0365147144,
-0.2760640681,
-0.0607826896,
0.543215096,
0.1367028952,
-0.283372134,
0.7945905924,
-0.3132471144,
0.733412385,
0.0300451834,
0.0109059103,
0.3660614192,
0.070575349,
0.0241779797,
0.169130519,
0.9604703784,
0.6433840394,
-0.050966464,
-0.0853854343,
-0.2764084339,
0.2991708219,
0.1390981674,
-0.4212985337,
-0.0069609811,
0.0263523776,
-0.3433150649,
-0.2649476528,
0.1205060482,
-0.6463634372,
-0.1868884712,
-0.0709202588,
0.1234398857,
-0.283372134,
-0.0905222893,
0.4248180389,
-0.7658869624,
0.3535276055,
0.4096406102,
-0.7232487798,
0.5170356035,
0.5050832033,
0.8019878268,
0.0056055468,
-0.1257020235,
-0.2523158789,
0.0614171661,
-0.3268459141,
1.0006769896,
-0.6266964078,
-0.5941687822,
-0.2519306839,
-0.0917724743,
-0.3290922046,
-0.3148649037,
1.0537457466,
0.0139507996,
0.2794484198,
-0.4154762328,
-0.2608260512,
-0.1067512408,
0.2357836068,
-0.6384395361,
0.9213684201,
0.2322315127,
-1.0496854782,
0.0977366716,
-0.4925401509,
-0.2476370931,
-0.2823133767,
-0.5312507153,
-0.0863897428,
0.1661911756,
0.8404600024,
0.1318055391,
-0.6852847934,
0.3183099926,
0.2763565481,
-0.1341936141,
0.2293883413,
-0.3836606145,
0.9916709065,
0.1086798683,
-0.3860115707,
0.0478400998,
-0.4572719634,
-0.4887143672,
0.0533919521,
-0.1066123322,
-0.2490946054,
0.3036840856,
0.2047972381,
-0.0296616368,
0.2152888924,
-0.908849597,
-0.007078127,
-0.4741661549,
0.5029101968,
0.0985066444,
0.0712355673,
0.7727149725,
-0.7256108522,
0.2337010503,
-0.3233266473,
0.2900348604,
-0.0752037764,
-0.8701243997,
-0.4594865739,
-0.4768222868,
0.6173074245,
0.8285731077,
-0.3762424588,
0.578268528,
-0.1802558601,
-0.2954416573,
0.0096117118,
-0.1235652715,
0.0042589372,
0.2691007555,
0.0988776535,
-0.3211934566,
-0.6403287649,
-1.2349369526,
-0.6025893688,
-0.009993434,
-0.2464296371,
-0.1236290708,
0.6333509684,
-0.1750947833,
0.9129359722,
-0.4167775214,
-0.4925557077,
-0.7375150323,
0.7285530567,
0.2257093638,
0.5525471568,
1.1305515766,
-0.9611539245,
-0.3764939904,
-0.3191146255,
-0.7720828056,
-0.2742871046,
0.2888093591,
-0.273807615,
-0.0385085568,
0.4196957946,
-0.4992311299,
0.3999947011,
0.7119361758,
-0.6198108196,
0.272028178,
0.2521024942,
0.5535544157,
-0.9639138579,
-0.1397971809,
0.2739267945,
-0.531938374,
-0.4509904683,
0.0396171249,
-0.0504232459,
-0.4501824677,
-0.5466606021,
0.7542583346,
-0.3555583954,
0.1299275458,
-0.267993331,
0.0092516309,
0.1140667275,
0.1209298596,
0.1281497926,
0.5302856565,
0.4297261536,
-0.4214875996,
0.1424923986,
0.3718731403,
-0.1939477175,
0.6661316752,
-0.4319408238,
-0.0463219173,
-0.3487777114,
0.3081851006,
-0.9300199747,
-0.2635243237,
0.2734868228,
-0.9542515278,
-0.1157833263,
-0.1408872306,
-0.4015231729,
-0.4123956263,
-0.3365027905,
0.4387207627,
0.4376106262,
-0.1133340523,
0.8260375261,
0.7547410727,
-0.0816709101,
-0.7055027485,
-0.6709898114,
0.4830391109,
0.0819436386,
-0.6029019356,
0.2284679413,
0.3328947425,
-0.5374619961,
-0.0403570421,
-0.2813938558,
-0.2754835188,
0.0464952923,
0.177018553,
-0.0897375271,
-0.1112571284,
-0.0211521611,
0.1768893898,
-0.0363000035,
0.106046088,
-0.0500156879,
0.9262161255,
-0.2457562983,
-0.4266358912,
-0.6443700194,
0.8970376253,
0.2736790776,
-0.4324775636,
0.8276228309,
0.621142149,
-0.4833225906,
-0.1651465595,
-0.5375919342,
-0.0843356624,
-0.346808672,
-0.0835146308,
-0.2836223543,
-0.6711899638,
0.5998641849,
0.1031756401,
0.0147597678,
0.9920732379,
0.2950834334,
-0.3602615297,
1.4599677324,
0.8051729798,
-0.3479936421,
0.3060301542,
-0.2811794281,
0.2794069946,
-0.4734244049,
0.0078265732,
-1.1187983751,
-0.554644227,
-0.1394092441,
-0.475061208,
-0.0291959494,
0.2832657695,
-0.4092775285,
0.2073330581,
-0.6832503676,
0.2376295328,
0.6859105229,
0.1202492192,
0.4973267019,
0.0198386312,
0.2570436299,
-0.3030250072,
-0.6728218198,
-0.7482479215,
0.8805433512,
0.6206704378,
0.7552592158,
0.2843798101,
0.7187928557,
0.8137042522,
0.3488276899,
-0.7057213783,
0.5626307726,
-0.5221223831,
-0.5577095151,
-0.0940741524,
-0.5008781552,
-0.6447275281,
-0.2292027175,
-0.107340537,
-0.7872821093,
0.8479850888,
-0.113731958,
-0.0765563324,
0.4548417032,
-0.2205232531,
0.7366982698,
-0.0762977377,
0.1876536906,
-0.0969128907,
0.0239161253,
0.340627104,
0.2700996101,
0.5242654681,
-0.7626945376,
-0.0757909417,
0.9859039187,
0.02529414,
0.8507231474,
-0.0767498836,
-0.05370735,
0.3750087917,
0.2308652997,
0.2315140814,
0.2497805059,
0.2035450935,
0.3910446167,
-0.1318417042,
-0.550548315,
-0.051550094,
0.7089734077,
-0.7153690457,
-0.4913145006,
-0.8572921753,
-0.7877835631,
-0.011100038,
0.0057223691,
0.3529943526,
0.6448490024,
-0.396392256,
0.3554104269,
0.4651081562,
-0.4484725893,
0.5105916858,
0.4496128559,
-0.5196347237,
-0.1715999842,
0.6805211306,
-0.0109947473,
-0.1653284729,
0.7450752258,
-0.0199114867,
-0.2208744586,
-0.3366624415,
-0.4755339921,
0.0986874849,
-0.6468863487,
-0.0997429788,
-0.9918665886,
-0.4443409145,
-0.3097545803,
-0.1449283957,
-0.6064734459,
-0.5552101135,
0.0892409161,
0.1492420435,
0.0169400256,
0.4046660364,
0.02211711,
0.4467149973,
-0.9072850943,
0.6991565228,
0.2586018443,
0.0855326131,
-0.6943287849,
-0.5585356355,
-0.0259970073,
0.2071861774,
-0.2084148377,
-1.1270077229,
0.6928620338,
-0.0565744825,
0.6033431888,
-0.4163333178,
0.2595472038,
-0.1196949854,
-0.2858150005,
0.7979518175,
0.2293486297,
-1.2584061623,
0.6014326215,
-0.8482573628,
0.5967698693,
0.1770273447,
0.3658402562,
-0.4430983067,
-0.7854771614,
-0.3602799475,
-0.7173902392,
0.3343170285,
0.5850370526,
0.3355935812,
-0.5330647826,
0.172557801,
-0.374163121,
0.3937597275,
-0.5710896254,
-0.3525365889,
-0.0561130308,
-0.5888482928,
-0.1316295415,
-0.5327801704,
-0.4620879292,
-0.3070231974,
0.4537001252,
-0.0699579939,
0.8911412954,
0.7067353725,
-0.3362829685,
-0.0666498542,
0.5328058004,
0.5721753836,
1.0230656862,
-0.5395402312,
0.2143332809,
-0.0739048123,
-0.5734975934,
0.3205184042,
-0.0038880953,
-0.3751549423,
0.6066181064,
0.5470190644,
0.4647663534,
0.1597818732,
-0.5851041675,
0.733620286,
-0.2879731357,
-0.7293373346,
-0.4073277116,
-0.2064592391,
0.0048291995,
0.4724251032,
0.8300023079,
0.4226760268,
0.3444152176,
-0.8149550557,
0.2368744016,
0.4419910014,
-0.4975075424,
0.0009979584,
1.0021480322,
0.3143830597,
-0.169853434,
0.0464621596,
-0.2617026865,
-0.395709902,
0.6023613811,
0.2423128337,
1.0127294064,
-0.3752260506,
0.7727566957,
0.4825494289,
0.7918206453,
-0.5659515262,
0.5545401573,
0.4731868505,
-0.9492906332,
-0.6334908009,
-0.7379252911,
-0.2811825275,
-0.2335860133,
-0.5794043541,
0.2450510859,
-0.4707619548,
-0.522780478,
0.2067428529,
-0.239858225,
-0.5202066302,
0.0485177115,
0.3375126123,
1.2881453037,
-1.071357131,
0.637735188,
0.7643601894,
-0.4054102302,
-0.3611571789,
0.0704791769,
0.0247009713,
-0.2602303624,
0.9028917551,
-0.0584838465,
-0.3138202429,
0.0552590825,
-0.3259589076,
-0.7060614824,
0.6628703475,
0.6918301582,
-0.842875421,
0.1427831501,
0.2712132931,
0.302110225,
-0.5836802125,
0.0725156739,
0.6478902102,
0.685972631,
-0.5722138882,
-1.2510143518,
-0.1617411524,
0.0328857191,
-0.1248631477,
0.3828354776,
-0.4691437185,
1.127140522,
0.3598732054,
-0.4232652485,
-0.127747491,
0.4483424723,
-0.3036847711,
0.4234814346,
0.4621452391,
0.6242102385,
0.2052703053,
-0.5913748741,
1.2729387283,
-0.1818855703,
0.3977011144,
0.9897330403,
-0.1747824699,
0.8109151721,
0.2665439844,
-0.279234916,
0.5230969191,
0.1352916956,
0.2996154726,
0.22593081,
-0.1876904368,
-0.547103107,
-0.2746603191,
-0.2368658036,
-0.1743266732,
0.4408417642,
0.4111585617,
-0.4619327784,
-0.6779718399,
0.3570662141,
-0.3619003892,
0.7637324333,
-0.4817758799,
0.5440552831,
0.3475998938,
-0.0768946484,
0.4343138337,
0.4652373791,
0.3818464279,
-0.3399161994,
-0.0115687363,
-0.1841186285,
-0.0153657869,
-0.254914999,
-0.9044291973,
0.690312922,
-0.0159798916,
-0.6794664264,
-0.2255393118,
0.8742209077,
-0.1924449503,
-0.8897559643,
0.4515601695,
1.0097001791,
-0.2437739074,
-0.68700701,
-0.7255847454,
0.1885600537,
0.1026095971,
-0.1252473742,
0.2531956434,
0.0538424253,
-0.3533175588,
0.7582624555,
0.3368379772,
-0.1182275042,
0.1083083898,
0.3242642581,
0.6485555768,
-0.967942059,
-0.3452903926,
-0.879124105,
0.3252111971,
-0.1795793176,
0.0142261665,
0.8282393217,
0.654527247,
0.2949637771,
-0.1348542869,
0.8482822776,
-0.3015111089,
1.0636860132,
-0.2738031745,
0.4403857291,
-0.0745388865,
0.5108782053,
0.0643060133,
-1.3182758093,
-0.5643094778,
0.5763875842,
-0.4172014594,
-0.3604712784,
0.7223045826,
0.5810365677,
-0.1737239808,
-0.0604130588,
0.1943019331,
-0.0817745253,
0.1814914048,
0.1929104775,
0.9785863161,
-0.5706327558,
0.3804506361,
-0.4764745533,
-0.1766712964,
-0.0354738943,
-0.6008749604,
-1.0531510115,
-0.6068488359,
-0.4475895762,
-0.0839480758,
0.2729969621,
0.8333428502,
0.3642928302,
-0.7201549411,
-0.3729983568,
-0.2334080487,
0.2927659154,
-0.2453002483,
-0.2624613047,
0.2959038019,
-0.3492699265,
-1.008636117,
0.3349363804,
0.3939778805,
-0.183469668,
-0.1422311068,
0.2071592063,
-0.3896897137,
0.1162059829,
0.6046795845,
0.1740799397,
-0.5301657319,
-0.3756240904,
-0.1481475383,
-0.2738815546,
-0.0753606707,
1.0127680302,
-0.7280285358,
0.0872024149,
0.8275876045,
0.2866145074,
0.2077482194,
-0.0006674826,
1.1097470522,
-1.1244283915,
0.6110936403,
0.4021874964,
0.4354323745,
0.1760169417,
-0.1785696894,
0.5352345109,
0.2334435433,
-0.4140732884,
-0.9016879201,
0.1920619607,
-1.0475969315,
-0.4621097744,
0.8203613162,
0.2550432682,
-0.2586502731,
-0.4512865245,
-0.6207885146,
-0.0916013867,
-0.7490354776,
0.2829413414,
0.7781449556,
0.0045647565,
-0.7215383649,
-1.1997486353,
0.52469033,
0.1610805094,
-0.3288543224,
-0.3749383986,
0.3200951219,
0.1352166831,
0.4265314341,
0.8022449613,
-0.1985439062,
0.2813098729,
0.1803585589,
0.2582378387,
0.483612448,
-0.4096623361,
0.1243212819,
0.2092866451,
-0.0013349841,
-0.1336926222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09972v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09972v2 | MasakhaNEWS: News Topic Classification for African languages | 2023-04-19T21:12:23 | 2023-09-20T17:14:40 | David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Marek Masiak, Israel Abebe Azime, Jesujoba Alabi, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Christine Mwase, Odunayo Ogundepo, Bonaventure F. P. Dossou, Akintunde Oladipo, Doreen Nixdorf, Chris Chinenye Emezue, sana al-azzawi, Blessing Sibanda, Davis David, Lolwethu Ndolela, Jonathan Mukiibi, Tunde Ajayi, Tatiana Moteu, Brian Odhiambo, Abraham Owodunni, Nnaemeka Obiefuna, Muhidin Mohamed, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Teshome Mulugeta Ababu, Saheed Abdullahi Salahudeen, Mesay Gemeda Yigezu, Tajuddeen Gwadabe, Idris Abdulmumin, Mahlet Taye, Oluwabusayo Awoyomi, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Tolulope Adelani, Habiba Abdulganiyu, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Adetola Adeeko, Abeeb Afolabi, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Olanrewaju Samuel, Clemencia Siro, Wangari Kimotho, Onyekachi Ogbu, Chinedu Mbonu, Chiamaka Chukwuneke, Samuel Fanijo, Jessica Ojo, Oyinkansola Awosan, Tadesse Kebede, Toadoum Sari Sakayo, Pamela Nyatsine, Freedmore Sidume, Oreen Yousuf, Mardiyyah Oduwole, Tshinu Tshinu, Ussen Kimanuka, Thina Diko, Siyanda Nxakama, Sinodos Nigusse, Abdulmejid Johar, Shafie Mohamed, Fuad Mire Hassan, Moges Ahmed Mehamed, Evrard Ngabire, Jules Jules, Ivan Ssenkungu, Pontus Stenetorp | cs.CL | cs.CL | African languages are severely under-represented in NLP research due to lack
of datasets covering several NLP tasks. While there are individual language
specific datasets that are being expanded to different tasks, only a handful of
NLP tasks (e.g. named entity recognition and machine translation) have
standardized benchmark datasets covering several geographical and
typologically-diverse African languages. In this paper, we develop MasakhaNEWS
-- a new benchmark dataset for news topic classification covering 16 languages
widely spoken in Africa. We provide an evaluation of baseline models by
training classical machine learning models and fine-tuning several language
models. Furthermore, we explore several alternatives to full fine-tuning of
language models that are better suited for zero-shot and few-shot learning such
as cross-lingual parameter-efficient fine-tuning (like MAD-X), pattern
exploiting training (PET), prompting language models (like ChatGPT), and
prompt-free sentence transformer fine-tuning (SetFit and Cohere Embedding API).
Our evaluation in zero-shot setting shows the potential of prompting ChatGPT
for news topic classification in low-resource African languages, achieving an
average performance of 70 F1 points without leveraging additional supervision
like MAD-X. In few-shot setting, we show that with as little as 10 examples per
label, we achieved more than 90\% (i.e. 86.0 F1 points) of the performance of
full supervised training (92.6 F1 points) leveraging the PET approach. | [
-0.7349114418,
-0.5193619132,
-0.0570129417,
0.1361220032,
-0.519533515,
0.0328282267,
-0.5960794687,
-0.2161763906,
0.4102571607,
0.5468396544,
-0.5208019614,
-0.6822995543,
-0.9033690691,
0.1236267313,
-0.4130202234,
1.1133565903,
-0.2128416449,
-0.2221450508,
0.2278200835,
-0.3892464936,
-0.34883672,
-0.4078178406,
-0.4493264258,
-0.0920368209,
0.616554141,
0.7018568516,
0.6219776869,
0.4079272747,
0.1113247201,
0.2562044561,
0.0116389981,
0.4111311734,
-0.1828561574,
0.0881914347,
-0.0614825189,
-0.3106308281,
0.1434788257,
0.189551115,
0.1219967902,
0.7646794319,
-0.1698572189,
0.3184196651,
0.0857462958,
0.6484005451,
-0.7283167839,
0.1980146766,
-0.6130564809,
-0.0089448299,
-0.4504760206,
-0.3598804772,
-0.1340962946,
-0.2225759625,
0.0144950906,
-0.2789587677,
0.1878117174,
-0.2331903577,
1.0365880728,
0.0306726061,
-0.5878283978,
-0.4774120748,
-0.2337779403,
0.9147231579,
-0.611902833,
0.1156687364,
0.8736149073,
0.5284900665,
0.1242894679,
-0.4661002457,
-0.3866092861,
-0.0688453764,
0.0746602714,
-0.1054764688,
-0.2128452659,
-0.103107132,
0.0660305023,
0.3064540923,
-0.4878197312,
0.0583143495,
-0.0776210874,
-0.3162228167,
0.553946197,
-0.0526853725,
0.1018359289,
-0.5155884027,
0.2642706037,
0.288441062,
-0.4839735031,
-0.051278919,
0.5014820695,
0.8279919028,
-0.2278521359,
0.5109844804,
-0.7433379292,
0.9390128851,
-0.0882173181,
-0.321695447,
0.3159950376,
0.0906209201,
0.1298568994,
0.1851498932,
0.5344540477,
0.3774883449,
0.3011965752,
-0.2105548382,
0.0375931971,
0.2921210825,
0.1884583533,
-0.9695338607,
-0.0600108802,
0.0244360603,
-0.4998843968,
-0.4423910677,
-0.4048984349,
-0.6356955171,
-0.3040708303,
-0.3606951237,
0.2567510307,
-0.4103904963,
0.0133368317,
0.1702102125,
0.2943058312,
-0.024191916,
0.5100255013,
-1.1752492189,
0.2101809084,
0.5699197054,
1.0795121193,
-0.0500267632,
-0.2162290215,
-0.2885664105,
-0.2180704176,
-0.2290055156,
0.7292709351,
-0.5413111448,
-0.2100733221,
0.155623585,
0.0096830903,
0.1680896878,
-0.2761880159,
0.865064621,
-0.3606669009,
0.2218639553,
-0.3209812343,
-0.4541315436,
-0.3978449404,
0.4596127868,
-0.2198978961,
0.763686657,
0.2495978028,
-0.8432351351,
0.3317659497,
-0.4985531569,
-0.780424118,
-0.072140716,
-0.2558118701,
-0.3823175132,
0.1039705053,
0.3827452064,
0.5689468384,
-0.2004311979,
0.310611248,
0.0484533869,
0.0040306705,
-0.0176586509,
-0.5401988626,
0.7752220035,
0.2889329791,
-0.3787272274,
-0.1685839593,
-1.0860313177,
0.0063682003,
-0.207691431,
-0.1622122526,
-0.4100122452,
-0.0093121454,
0.076708518,
0.603970468,
-0.10601715,
-0.6493800879,
0.2308830768,
-0.1622566879,
0.3404884636,
0.1863178909,
0.1490333676,
0.2800782919,
-0.2529526055,
0.4431327283,
-0.1038321629,
-0.2864900529,
-0.2274962366,
-0.6854178309,
-0.7694729567,
-0.1421912014,
0.8631371856,
0.5559610128,
-0.9575071335,
0.481377393,
-0.0500036143,
-0.5799383521,
-0.67958951,
0.16181238,
0.1001253799,
0.598844409,
0.2587398589,
-0.2633561492,
-0.5046015382,
-0.9944483638,
-0.1123925522,
0.2881549597,
-0.0562563837,
0.2953875065,
0.3871839345,
-0.1339404285,
0.6863766909,
-0.2889241874,
-0.1378140599,
-0.2765980363,
0.7413831353,
0.18526721,
0.2589985728,
0.6976640224,
-0.731220603,
-0.4185034931,
0.0775744841,
-0.4652707577,
-0.3685916662,
0.1306855083,
-0.0031305843,
0.2598313689,
0.2647439539,
-0.5011062622,
0.4132833481,
0.6772578359,
0.0134975528,
0.2712286711,
0.2121660113,
0.2919707894,
-1.2418856621,
-0.1545930654,
0.0779664963,
-0.3971281648,
-0.6431332827,
-0.2163640112,
-0.1022044495,
-0.5894745588,
-0.4721347094,
0.5942829847,
-0.2630833089,
-0.0499148108,
-0.8232984543,
0.3047127128,
-0.4807642102,
0.532173574,
0.4029273093,
0.6251869798,
0.6383894682,
-0.6846229434,
0.2971361876,
0.452968508,
-0.6688523293,
0.4087838829,
-0.1903655082,
-0.1799770296,
0.0532701612,
0.1033655927,
-0.716691196,
-0.1759771854,
0.0882361084,
-0.5926290154,
0.3314970136,
-0.2776325643,
-0.4492509067,
-0.21801126,
-0.1546054929,
-0.0055512516,
0.4600710571,
-0.3788141608,
0.087759003,
0.3177845776,
-0.5608443618,
-0.8456190228,
-0.8832454085,
0.1920249909,
0.0326886065,
-0.3634601533,
0.0510766879,
0.5083985925,
-0.0415483601,
0.0288963895,
-0.2077772319,
-0.0990912765,
0.247661531,
0.1944684982,
-0.2990828156,
-0.3351488411,
0.328471452,
0.3282595277,
-0.396948278,
-0.493322432,
-0.2405373305,
0.7196449637,
-0.0757610276,
-0.1808737516,
-0.3343934417,
0.3530928791,
0.1799595058,
-0.41583848,
0.9575055838,
0.6999425292,
-0.2775950134,
-0.2021088451,
-0.2938700616,
-0.0651226118,
-0.3694431782,
0.3436134458,
-0.2412296534,
-0.9369776249,
0.4317978919,
-0.3655977845,
0.131138131,
0.5897080898,
0.8463545442,
-0.0467935093,
0.8186004758,
0.7041532397,
-0.3585431874,
0.422329247,
-0.4147646725,
0.1188637912,
-0.3548496962,
0.2425946742,
-0.7585612535,
-0.5837256908,
-0.9996053576,
-0.1931687146,
-0.1494526863,
0.1211051717,
0.1215138286,
0.4915226996,
-0.0693980381,
0.4122312069,
0.470174253,
-0.1014719903,
0.1868186742,
0.2554490268,
0.0782096907,
-0.1334941983,
-0.7457275987,
-0.7733239532,
0.9538751841,
0.0029132718,
0.7593820691,
-0.0653794631,
0.7796375155,
0.2441783845,
0.3307614923,
-0.8317352533,
0.3733002841,
-0.5061040521,
-0.5391228199,
-0.1987553239,
-0.5250406265,
-0.9343472719,
0.3955706954,
-0.0908147991,
-0.7252900004,
0.3782447875,
-0.143501088,
-0.2702762187,
0.3707722425,
-0.2881613672,
0.786565721,
-0.0890715793,
0.0003300601,
-0.2787608802,
-0.7027061582,
0.3715128303,
-0.1025319919,
0.1648430824,
-0.5446680784,
-0.1625698954,
0.7183042765,
-0.4477785528,
0.8615446091,
-0.1936964393,
0.0180542357,
0.3020932674,
-0.1747118086,
0.0302955154,
0.1879326999,
-0.2565098703,
0.3921094537,
-0.3262572885,
-0.6529073119,
-0.4795346558,
0.6121672392,
-0.8236668706,
-0.2333531678,
-0.4432122409,
-0.6695241928,
-0.5942811966,
0.1096281186,
0.5036996603,
0.7082909942,
-0.0135473218,
0.3722817898,
0.3123781681,
-0.2348349243,
0.396897316,
0.8299454451,
-0.1489820033,
-0.1825556457,
1.0968005657,
0.2415681928,
0.1197922081,
0.4660913646,
-0.1270840168,
0.1467806399,
-0.8453444242,
-0.5387275815,
-0.1032903716,
-0.5289438367,
-0.5960775018,
-0.6958446503,
-0.4082086384,
-0.0755632967,
-0.2637258172,
-0.3636702895,
-0.903403163,
-0.2166112214,
-0.086599052,
0.3269472718,
-0.0029919068,
-0.2139658928,
0.7999683619,
-0.8743117452,
0.5893329382,
0.2304803431,
0.3724743128,
-0.1891827434,
-0.6760510206,
-0.4459258616,
0.1893967837,
-0.6062608361,
-0.7444260716,
0.4925129414,
0.2186923325,
0.6444761157,
0.4496696889,
0.1818919778,
0.4135218561,
-0.6135556102,
0.7201853991,
0.0519248694,
-0.9124558568,
0.7960457802,
-0.3193228841,
0.2435223013,
0.9690095186,
0.7382660508,
-1.0127415657,
-0.3691780269,
-0.4647477865,
-0.4944916368,
0.7965852022,
0.5100009441,
0.3227274418,
-0.2217797637,
0.2800681591,
0.3843562007,
0.6098814011,
-0.4295859635,
-0.4847855568,
-0.2509643435,
-0.1312519759,
-0.2051662356,
-0.1902910322,
0.0958781168,
-0.2896623611,
0.9809696674,
-0.21115309,
0.1042434797,
-0.1362681389,
-0.4426181018,
-0.2698591948,
0.4988381267,
0.7000801563,
0.5830284953,
-0.2276384532,
-0.0847980753,
0.014647278,
-0.300458014,
0.2930400372,
0.5152033567,
-0.3996706605,
0.486356765,
0.3440868258,
0.9598218203,
0.0553432629,
-0.3666982651,
0.30334723,
-0.1485436857,
-0.3271285594,
0.3979073465,
-0.1618710607,
-0.055776041,
0.1012668759,
0.260914892,
0.1965113282,
0.1690543741,
-0.7755627036,
0.3076777458,
0.1560895145,
-0.3928878009,
-0.2024903148,
0.0928056166,
0.548601687,
-0.1426902562,
0.4589913487,
-0.5447440147,
-0.6650029421,
0.4038934708,
0.205222711,
0.7725930214,
-0.5536693931,
0.6973727345,
0.255074501,
0.3912996948,
-0.0372896157,
0.4695425332,
-0.1344298571,
-0.8258625865,
-0.4870761633,
-0.6785929799,
-0.5338542461,
0.2355380654,
-0.611346066,
0.4177998602,
-0.1620023549,
-0.1804467142,
0.3082052767,
0.5835416913,
-0.2609061003,
0.2252955437,
0.256341964,
1.1603447199,
-0.901706934,
0.9853162169,
0.547650516,
-0.2568060458,
-0.144292146,
0.0849854946,
0.1367266774,
-0.6720333695,
0.4016701281,
0.2103609145,
0.237528339,
-0.1402824074,
-0.4693789184,
-0.5957583189,
0.6894710064,
0.4105891883,
-0.706345439,
0.3005971909,
0.1179779917,
0.4366019666,
-0.355261296,
-0.1577298939,
0.3841967881,
0.3465636969,
0.1304765493,
-0.7952783704,
-0.449113965,
-0.0732759163,
-0.2200328857,
0.6053937674,
-0.6390146017,
0.6432428956,
0.0030256957,
-0.0481265523,
0.3341065049,
0.6832971573,
-0.2507295012,
0.3518401682,
0.1977104247,
0.6017189622,
0.6787946224,
-0.368809253,
1.2401667833,
-0.4598707557,
0.4729771316,
1.1301691532,
-0.196646288,
0.7568994761,
0.0568901598,
-0.250803262,
0.3826083243,
0.8527745008,
0.0887472257,
0.9008896947,
0.2873305082,
-0.2099027485,
-0.1263029128,
-0.3288802803,
-0.4192579091,
0.5265579224,
0.4701692164,
-0.1516639441,
-0.7606820464,
0.3564952314,
0.0398108177,
0.0311363861,
-0.5570291877,
0.499751687,
0.2464679778,
-0.1183287948,
0.4332774282,
0.3705990016,
0.7966510057,
-0.8791193962,
0.2609424293,
-0.3244405389,
-0.1199422851,
-0.1624202132,
-0.6706484556,
0.3983611465,
0.1781479418,
-0.1049417406,
-0.0164217725,
0.9365172982,
-0.6991309524,
-0.5419719219,
-0.1260393858,
0.4763280749,
0.0885940045,
-0.0873726308,
-0.7115754485,
-0.197268784,
-0.0832602233,
-0.1118863747,
0.3633889854,
0.6062994003,
-0.2003075331,
0.4408538043,
0.2830376923,
0.1827024072,
-0.1726339459,
0.1956345886,
0.6046593189,
-0.6483280659,
-0.6348658204,
-0.6508154869,
-0.0577233993,
-0.1719383448,
-0.5211977959,
1.0305142403,
0.5870339274,
0.8022434115,
-0.0109001268,
0.89867872,
0.0319489501,
0.7554500699,
-0.5362160802,
0.6420204043,
-0.4544619918,
-0.1785024852,
-0.1475230902,
-0.8434074521,
-0.3092786074,
0.4582451582,
-0.5105602741,
-0.0395452678,
0.4461624026,
0.3374650776,
-0.170344606,
0.2621837854,
0.5112867355,
0.0431193113,
-0.1068696156,
0.2427880019,
0.9419665933,
-0.2778396904,
0.3454310894,
-0.6099162698,
0.0142421434,
-0.2987377644,
-0.8131475449,
-0.9842002988,
-0.5625609756,
-0.4873482585,
-0.02183556,
0.1919362545,
0.976978004,
0.8975059986,
-1.3578058481,
-0.0998359397,
0.1346168667,
0.0381087959,
-0.212049827,
-0.1387890726,
0.3346955776,
-0.520270884,
-0.4111701548,
0.0088412166,
0.3521363139,
0.0198932998,
0.0856571048,
0.1232378855,
-0.4211820364,
-0.0549746267,
0.7501051426,
0.5031775236,
-0.6611397862,
0.0835361928,
-0.4994370341,
-0.1337016076,
0.0883018598,
0.9889473319,
-0.6930757165,
0.1789931506,
0.296171546,
0.9892418385,
0.6454065442,
-0.0885688066,
0.3223317564,
-1.1801267862,
0.6312358379,
0.3063741326,
0.4549539387,
0.4347622097,
0.0415552668,
0.5199314356,
0.0935714915,
-0.2333819419,
-0.6354209185,
0.2192425132,
-0.842030108,
-0.3435170054,
0.8787044287,
-0.0102676433,
-0.0761821046,
-0.1745927781,
-0.4053120613,
0.2662277818,
-0.4377058446,
0.8214825988,
0.9520091414,
0.1451036334,
-0.3658773601,
-0.9603254795,
0.4762878418,
0.1903224587,
-1.0315032005,
-0.0244478658,
0.2480456382,
0.0698319599,
0.3765127659,
0.3546813428,
0.0585344322,
0.3945053518,
-0.0818782821,
0.0116073294,
0.0478465483,
-0.2120208293,
-0.4817114472,
0.0121252472,
-0.1876835376,
-0.4167363942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09960v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09960v3 | A Latent Space Theory for Emergent Abilities in Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T20:45:01 | 2023-09-13T18:52:02 | Hui Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Languages are not created randomly but rather to communicate information.
There is a strong association between languages and their underlying meanings,
resulting in a sparse joint distribution that is heavily peaked according to
their correlations. Moreover, these peak values happen to match with the
marginal distribution of languages due to the sparsity. With the advent of LLMs
trained on big data and large models, we can now precisely assess the marginal
distribution of languages, providing a convenient means of exploring the sparse
structures in the joint distribution for effective inferences. In this paper,
we categorize languages as either unambiguous or {\epsilon}-ambiguous and
present quantitative results to demonstrate that the emergent abilities of
LLMs, such as language understanding, in-context learning, chain-of-thought
prompting, and effective instruction fine-tuning, can all be attributed to
Bayesian inference on the sparse joint distribution of languages. | [
-0.1679134816,
-0.9814987183,
0.9091151357,
0.3501266539,
0.0131207174,
0.2586647868,
-0.4526367486,
-0.1548555642,
0.1815665066,
0.1753749251,
-0.3029255569,
-0.303329438,
-0.6180281639,
-0.3494587243,
-0.378720969,
0.9012872577,
0.152149573,
-0.2047897279,
-0.0185990576,
-0.2074582279,
-0.1757853031,
-0.2880369723,
-0.2918950021,
-0.0941193625,
0.6071641445,
0.1510811597,
1.0220892429,
0.5168744326,
0.2755419612,
0.3427259922,
-0.2917732298,
-0.0032274795,
-0.2273054719,
0.112052843,
-0.1445980668,
-0.5441021919,
-0.3521477878,
-0.0981268659,
1.1477677822,
1.5909006596,
-0.1684880555,
-0.1199059412,
0.3051926494,
0.4405210316,
-0.4757570028,
0.1121708155,
-0.7014490366,
-0.0759734213,
-0.2502673268,
-0.0991672948,
-0.159587726,
-0.0697222278,
0.0348186158,
-0.5075616837,
0.2875497043,
-0.1067399755,
0.6551451683,
0.2428067923,
-0.2252316624,
-0.0994272605,
-0.8539782166,
0.7656620741,
-0.4575660825,
0.5075466037,
0.2912691534,
0.209361434,
-0.5489056706,
-0.313079834,
-0.6079193354,
-0.153398782,
0.0726416856,
0.0517257862,
-0.1775992215,
0.1450083852,
0.3696054816,
0.5136207342,
-0.4745535553,
0.4623453617,
-0.0592127778,
0.2702474892,
0.4520137608,
-0.0740073472,
0.5604645014,
-0.0244108494,
-0.2922845483,
0.1266351342,
-0.8394703269,
-0.043827612,
0.408944428,
0.5164189935,
-0.2992765903,
0.7369010448,
0.2620696127,
0.783285737,
-0.2391720265,
-0.1903111935,
-0.0212803055,
-0.1733663082,
-0.1396344006,
-0.4201568961,
0.743537426,
-0.4250403345,
0.1093592569,
-0.4065029323,
-0.1561245173,
-0.1251930892,
-0.1696151495,
-0.108298324,
-0.192067042,
0.1005071625,
-0.3929156959,
0.079247199,
0.1710209399,
-0.5372617841,
-0.2229343653,
-0.0003654464,
0.394074589,
-0.1743699163,
-0.6335111856,
-0.1203961596,
-0.0797715634,
0.0633546785,
0.2070705593,
-1.19384408,
0.3313219547,
0.5561714768,
0.7412910461,
-0.1531527787,
-0.3246499896,
-0.2266501635,
0.1835244,
-0.5507187247,
0.7872248292,
-0.5957548022,
-0.0180951897,
-0.0175000019,
0.0882336646,
-0.2574561536,
-0.4094781578,
0.1976357251,
-0.5542947054,
-0.1639386714,
-0.071230121,
-0.5114118457,
-0.0881951973,
-0.3297304511,
-0.6143696308,
0.8637545705,
0.3445800543,
-0.5837645531,
0.6826725602,
-0.4531078637,
-0.2018479258,
0.5650433302,
-0.5231229663,
-0.2946454287,
0.2772049904,
-0.0460157245,
0.717700541,
-0.1664282531,
0.4860321283,
-0.5365995765,
-0.2370327562,
0.6677858233,
-0.6096153855,
0.734146893,
0.2793758214,
-0.3757997751,
-0.0728706345,
-0.607860744,
0.0721796751,
0.0161466449,
-0.3731350303,
-0.462444663,
0.1377019882,
-0.1273188442,
-0.0730885491,
0.244513765,
-0.1300867647,
0.3749577701,
-0.5615829229,
0.2226025313,
0.480368942,
0.1722186357,
0.7377884388,
-0.0608641468,
0.3895548582,
0.0261609368,
-0.1530005038,
0.0468996577,
-0.6099324822,
-0.5545833111,
-0.5652012229,
0.1608382761,
0.4453145266,
-0.5279864669,
0.7666381001,
-0.1880914271,
-0.2500550747,
-0.3207787573,
0.4756941497,
0.2821554542,
-0.2506639361,
-0.0926511511,
-0.0985181704,
-0.1865020692,
-0.8647451401,
-0.0417414047,
-0.2952791452,
-0.1413906366,
0.2569198608,
0.3016459048,
-0.1320106983,
0.626149416,
-0.3407583535,
0.2936554253,
-0.3084113896,
0.0866198242,
0.5403828621,
0.4206783473,
0.4749296904,
-0.6918065548,
-0.2491474599,
0.0462265685,
-0.7452381849,
-0.2068362683,
-0.1293061376,
0.1401966214,
-0.0427710488,
0.501137197,
-0.4413783848,
0.2537120581,
0.535318315,
-0.3089193702,
-0.0000688811,
-0.5437948108,
-0.0742889941,
-1.0544739962,
0.0265350584,
-0.0815420598,
0.1086603105,
-0.5730399489,
-0.0380993374,
-0.0234038997,
-0.0259586275,
-0.0801563635,
0.5059531331,
-0.8531059623,
-0.622248888,
-0.3576133549,
0.2730063498,
-0.5697207451,
0.3324631751,
0.1986180097,
0.7023243904,
0.5363858342,
-0.5515675545,
-0.191623807,
-0.0901549608,
-0.5792079568,
0.1305221468,
-0.4602727294,
-0.3215928674,
-0.0999913514,
-0.091617465,
-1.5322188139,
-0.3694542944,
-0.1436948031,
-0.3348285854,
0.4542893469,
-0.4886499643,
-0.6115916967,
-0.2492045611,
0.3109771907,
0.3744620979,
0.5112800598,
-0.5554423332,
0.0333813205,
0.6351547241,
-0.2404118627,
-0.7361987233,
-0.4897195399,
-0.2032610476,
-0.4429896474,
-0.503513813,
-0.1032298207,
-0.0820730925,
-0.5155009031,
0.0479278192,
0.2573630512,
-0.4476189911,
0.435541302,
0.4593008459,
0.2604698837,
-0.3184028864,
0.2553830445,
0.2518907189,
-0.0562061965,
-0.1950200349,
-0.2823792696,
0.2086180449,
-0.0690096915,
-0.5606606007,
0.1698857546,
0.1994076967,
0.4656896293,
0.2771659493,
0.8890447021,
0.5178820491,
-0.3769814968,
-0.2268862426,
-0.4683054686,
0.0231038351,
-0.4169968069,
0.2928309441,
-0.3763110936,
-1.1540486813,
0.6795244813,
-0.1360202581,
-0.0203190651,
0.4533284903,
0.5239642262,
0.0051965825,
0.9149169922,
0.7575423717,
0.2482010424,
0.6246976852,
-0.3160848022,
0.2493753433,
-0.9465591908,
-0.0961538628,
-0.3379411101,
0.0894648582,
-0.7594345212,
-0.7461921573,
0.4429870546,
0.5886884928,
-0.1148128435,
-0.0652599111,
-0.1167289987,
0.5030754805,
0.2138558179,
-0.1859104633,
0.0040164618,
0.2519150078,
-0.1981595457,
-0.1337533295,
-0.8573241234,
-0.5049089789,
0.9347180724,
0.4595552087,
0.9170044661,
0.3539187312,
0.4107607603,
-0.0138351033,
0.0832931921,
-0.6355199814,
0.3439691961,
-0.1111057177,
-0.547778368,
-0.512301147,
-0.3978036046,
-1.4037970304,
0.2893834412,
-0.5008761883,
-1.097851634,
0.3328309059,
-0.0401008874,
-0.3824056387,
0.4540036321,
-0.8158599138,
0.7457046509,
-0.229572922,
-0.6238102317,
-0.0965617597,
-0.5883862972,
0.3773943484,
-0.1777823567,
0.3383862376,
-0.170633316,
-0.4090202749,
0.8131053448,
-0.1571731865,
0.9076319933,
-0.1793539524,
-0.1128134653,
0.4504000545,
0.0967697874,
0.1073717549,
0.1709403992,
0.2020769119,
0.2330126911,
-0.1406542212,
-0.6353183389,
-0.8034683466,
0.602586329,
-0.9366139174,
-0.4650043547,
-0.2405333668,
-0.6385282874,
-0.2839021385,
0.1810604334,
-0.0247238819,
0.1101698577,
-0.3362706602,
0.1259630024,
0.8762792349,
-0.4232072532,
0.5015972853,
0.6953867078,
-0.0613664649,
-0.2223240584,
0.7018022537,
0.3149714172,
0.4011830688,
0.3947766423,
0.031071974,
-0.4077669978,
-0.6560168862,
-0.3187992275,
0.4079387188,
-0.4541577697,
0.1147610694,
-0.682448864,
-0.4511910975,
-0.1477829814,
-0.3960512578,
-0.1477187872,
-0.5044453144,
0.0598734394,
0.0787078962,
0.0384228043,
1.2390674353,
-0.5210251212,
0.5407495499,
-0.5623449087,
-0.0188093726,
0.2275499851,
0.2447579801,
0.2431587428,
-0.6669675708,
-0.3743015528,
-0.0298796874,
-0.0780843049,
-0.8170947433,
0.3447588384,
-0.000805485,
1.0287294388,
0.7055402398,
-0.5598427653,
0.5472659469,
-0.3726060688,
0.7430289984,
0.2489867657,
-0.6474084258,
0.4184649587,
-0.6990061998,
0.0501702279,
0.0416375026,
0.4434527457,
-0.1728931665,
-0.6650764942,
-1.10196805,
-0.8375489116,
0.4409784079,
0.1675724238,
0.0523800738,
-0.1250413358,
0.4141892791,
0.2024868876,
0.1826880276,
-0.8250905275,
-0.0613899045,
0.3871959746,
-0.095397599,
-0.3914678991,
-0.4618325531,
0.0355638228,
-0.121293515,
0.1061374024,
-0.107038565,
0.3939930797,
-0.1962385774,
-0.0015488376,
-0.4522535503,
0.597589016,
0.419021517,
0.857583642,
-0.1629843861,
0.4037305415,
0.2361402512,
-0.4246422052,
0.3778245747,
-0.0045821154,
0.1863388121,
-0.3186681569,
0.6306107044,
0.6166921854,
0.4794807136,
-0.4542274475,
0.5241351128,
0.1459420323,
0.094353728,
-0.2877457142,
0.2525180578,
0.2404725254,
0.4234972894,
0.4565820992,
-0.1316638291,
0.0184075572,
-0.6738674641,
0.0521939807,
0.6876311302,
-0.2628719807,
-0.5050199628,
0.3058379889,
-0.1185943037,
0.0042746398,
0.407004714,
-0.2846636772,
-0.209891066,
0.507121861,
0.7232167721,
0.6102243662,
-0.2887602746,
0.0864866003,
0.2525547743,
0.3892334998,
-0.0146512641,
0.2313460112,
-0.255651474,
-0.8515403271,
-0.5970499516,
-0.7728821039,
-0.0928296298,
0.3198106587,
-0.3944221139,
-0.1429640651,
-0.3336551189,
-0.002164687,
0.2722827792,
0.091979593,
-0.4678570628,
-0.0580064282,
0.0931723192,
0.4417506754,
-1.3878957033,
0.72040236,
0.5254541636,
-0.41108042,
-0.9311243296,
0.1069353074,
-0.1382544041,
-0.9329688549,
0.9526364207,
-0.2842777371,
0.2947630286,
-0.038588766,
-0.4817286134,
-1.1272033453,
0.7123188376,
0.3926584423,
-0.4323742092,
0.2539142668,
-0.0533784181,
0.6877509952,
-0.4117694497,
0.4178235829,
0.2410445362,
0.3169635832,
0.2275336534,
-0.8068880439,
-0.0071587441,
-0.0705081671,
0.1762460917,
0.5496563911,
-0.4429332316,
0.7944655418,
-0.5065967441,
-0.4252915978,
0.2068704069,
0.7618321776,
0.2365359813,
0.0404836014,
0.4953790903,
0.4051680565,
0.7572011948,
-0.0853855014,
0.8230957985,
-0.1538605243,
0.1433312595,
0.7371575236,
0.1059902757,
0.9570918083,
0.3206680715,
-0.4846717715,
0.5424149036,
0.5943314433,
0.1571565717,
0.1977952868,
0.2416826338,
-0.376222223,
-0.3396881223,
-0.0301848333,
-0.1429689676,
0.1979864836,
0.9315643311,
-0.2874682546,
-0.1929419339,
-0.1983930469,
-0.0505028442,
0.0460207127,
-0.029314559,
0.7800491452,
0.2311587185,
-0.565767765,
0.4954462349,
-0.2854518592,
0.3649856746,
-0.4942473471,
-0.2004741728,
-0.0390853286,
-0.133200869,
-0.2656024694,
-1.3278033733,
0.2259474844,
-0.1370631009,
-0.1391240209,
-0.0162228663,
0.7158722878,
-0.4580355287,
-0.2493709326,
0.2393761724,
0.9618822932,
0.6806582212,
0.4515173733,
-0.6219059825,
-0.0299603473,
-0.2918224037,
0.0139634581,
0.3271885216,
0.7873801589,
-0.1839430481,
0.4021468759,
0.5787251592,
0.5326622128,
0.1399816424,
0.0633308664,
0.606782198,
-0.5755165815,
-0.5143281817,
-0.6509780884,
0.4263513088,
0.0224917084,
-0.0950015411,
0.8720690608,
0.370778054,
0.3789861202,
0.0923721269,
0.6434422135,
-0.1699293703,
0.4517566264,
-0.5466319323,
0.5582711697,
-0.4694635868,
0.4130575955,
-0.4306148291,
-1.1196526289,
-0.1907164454,
0.7195954323,
-0.5695747733,
0.3713609278,
0.707054615,
0.6217312813,
-0.3594169915,
-0.5228047371,
0.7405769229,
0.3650797606,
-0.0496662445,
0.6985799074,
1.1349813938,
-0.0443218388,
0.1269854307,
0.2675719857,
-0.6932624578,
-0.1042907089,
-0.5683669448,
-0.9983548522,
-0.8643628359,
0.0330672376,
-0.2904766202,
-0.0529552102,
0.6111603379,
0.6617007852,
-0.4197468162,
-0.5100218654,
-0.2931644917,
0.3839380741,
-0.0167262387,
-0.2044685781,
0.3653376102,
-0.4545205235,
-0.5314600468,
0.4360871613,
0.5620885491,
0.4789448977,
-0.4588493109,
0.0831748843,
-0.1372462809,
0.0439216979,
0.4635219872,
0.4727596343,
-0.6404224038,
-0.2018751055,
-0.2089809924,
-0.017602833,
-0.2072250843,
0.8208280206,
-0.3910178244,
0.3198471963,
0.3915547431,
0.5352506638,
0.1378595829,
-0.3473803401,
0.5425729752,
-0.7182927132,
0.5782853961,
-0.099529393,
0.4393640757,
0.3612276316,
-0.3438316286,
0.4878362417,
0.313690424,
-0.5776772499,
-0.8191475272,
0.2842929959,
-0.8985432386,
-0.382594049,
1.2759418488,
-0.3138880134,
-0.4212015569,
-0.3267436028,
0.2957006693,
0.3123083413,
-0.074838616,
0.536816597,
0.5795518756,
-0.1580966413,
-0.0431561768,
-0.6473087668,
0.4574522674,
0.4944331944,
-0.6427758932,
0.1707898527,
0.4480758905,
0.2537181973,
0.2505995631,
0.6941825747,
-0.0103273168,
0.1338538378,
0.2378027439,
-0.2525287271,
0.6374614835,
-0.4372162223,
-0.3915177286,
-0.0027095042,
0.6158748269,
0.225998044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09957v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09957v1 | Low-resource Bilingual Dialect Lexicon Induction with Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T20:20:41 | 2023-04-19T20:20:41 | Ekaterina Artemova, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Bilingual word lexicons are crucial tools for multilingual natural language
understanding and machine translation tasks, as they facilitate the mapping of
words in one language to their synonyms in another language. To achieve this,
numerous papers have explored bilingual lexicon induction (BLI) in
high-resource scenarios, using a typical pipeline consisting of two
unsupervised steps: bitext mining and word alignment, both of which rely on
pre-trained large language models~(LLMs).
In this paper, we present an analysis of the BLI pipeline for German and two
of its dialects, Bavarian and Alemannic. This setup poses several unique
challenges, including the scarcity of resources, the relatedness of the
languages, and the lack of standardization in the orthography of dialects. To
evaluate the BLI outputs, we analyze them with respect to word frequency and
pairwise edit distance. Additionally, we release two evaluation datasets
comprising 1,500 bilingual sentence pairs and 1,000 bilingual word pairs. They
were manually judged for their semantic similarity for each Bavarian-German and
Alemannic-German language pair. | [
-0.5418452621,
-0.5282434821,
0.4620524645,
0.2247744799,
-0.2144627273,
-0.0317896903,
-0.5455912948,
-0.4469362497,
0.2038674504,
0.6368826628,
-0.5664265156,
-0.3325172067,
-0.5218119621,
0.2591452301,
-0.3240241706,
0.8303244114,
-0.0603815168,
-0.0011055415,
-0.122613661,
-0.5660340786,
-0.2909608483,
-0.4515948892,
-0.4064514637,
-0.5964186788,
0.4766560495,
0.4438608289,
0.9595727324,
0.6650677919,
0.116119355,
0.3568314016,
-0.4430164695,
0.147166431,
-0.4043399394,
-0.0476594009,
-0.3180705309,
-0.2513924241,
-0.4852621555,
-0.381603837,
0.8383398652,
1.1441662312,
-0.1027893275,
0.2624629438,
0.1051230207,
0.6203126907,
-0.8026800752,
0.1413627416,
-0.794495523,
-0.1120283082,
-0.6464841962,
0.1103949174,
-0.3079649508,
-0.0199637711,
-0.0459872335,
-0.2820161581,
0.2940073609,
0.177319482,
0.8671553135,
0.082139641,
-0.429425776,
-0.2342613935,
-0.6376464963,
0.6356122494,
-0.669269681,
0.7086724639,
0.2262293994,
-0.0095896488,
-0.0934689492,
-0.2945526838,
-0.8033545613,
0.1128608733,
-0.2860824764,
0.2722288966,
-0.3750119805,
-0.073866725,
0.2965101898,
0.345759064,
-0.6227766275,
0.7818520069,
-0.1301068068,
-0.0651784539,
0.5457350612,
0.3024486303,
0.0487973168,
-0.3013885319,
-0.1989119053,
-0.087996915,
-0.7054650784,
-0.0753669143,
0.585950315,
0.6080905795,
-0.3402134478,
0.7192318439,
-0.2725890875,
0.5584411621,
-0.0091434512,
0.0060360273,
0.5599173307,
-0.7354310751,
-0.0012581804,
0.2615483105,
0.8387475014,
0.0867399871,
0.3892015517,
-0.4015049338,
-0.603109479,
-0.0630962327,
-0.0986143723,
-0.7115454674,
0.0657202601,
0.1594771892,
-0.4211814106,
0.0377375744,
0.0515525378,
-0.7970304489,
-0.4330366254,
-0.1943225712,
0.1024491861,
-0.3912237585,
-0.4224654138,
-0.030038137,
-0.2253868133,
0.3086742163,
-0.0692413524,
-1.1114385128,
0.1527278125,
0.5792934299,
0.8235934377,
-0.268861562,
-0.4570635259,
-0.6709752083,
0.0117294407,
-0.524646759,
0.656062007,
-0.2046864778,
-0.5761809945,
0.390639931,
0.2236395925,
-0.0432662591,
-0.8750181198,
0.3945925832,
-0.6736834049,
0.0189323742,
-0.0692026615,
-0.3514732122,
-0.005432473,
-0.1029340103,
-0.8225138187,
1.0193279982,
0.214547947,
-0.8702363968,
0.3261963427,
-0.6318874955,
-0.7140527964,
0.1808346063,
0.1800022572,
-0.0430925153,
0.3188830614,
0.2433276027,
0.3393904269,
-0.4024271667,
0.1986172944,
-0.3474250138,
-0.2105451673,
0.2565617561,
-0.4002127051,
1.151558876,
-0.0942783505,
-0.2703708708,
-0.1028338671,
-0.4960156083,
-0.1108203381,
0.0694836229,
-0.3078905046,
-0.4739712775,
-0.1513420343,
0.2366157919,
0.3028718531,
0.2079249024,
-0.5748876929,
-0.2370262146,
-0.6424511671,
0.1139582321,
0.6744531393,
0.0221294984,
0.6128098369,
-0.1166533455,
0.3673689663,
0.3244194388,
-0.1822175533,
-0.0808215961,
-0.3375088573,
-0.8929494023,
-0.2922240794,
0.7179365158,
0.7598489523,
-0.7760359049,
0.7900418043,
-0.6941010356,
-0.643232584,
-0.6592181921,
0.5153053999,
0.41218701,
0.2833123803,
0.2164542675,
-0.5164287686,
-0.2698190212,
-0.9932979345,
-0.0815122724,
-0.1720918566,
-0.0883899108,
0.1007175669,
0.4446208477,
-0.4078365862,
0.692124486,
-0.1517397165,
-0.0660148934,
-0.3116739094,
0.1557537764,
0.4223779738,
0.1996082962,
0.5893542171,
-0.4484117329,
-0.3737498522,
0.3767008781,
-0.6491848826,
-0.3296542764,
0.1729723364,
-0.3217878044,
0.619392693,
0.4576484263,
-0.4579536915,
0.2488411814,
0.7845084071,
-0.2480526567,
0.5759262443,
-0.0239073653,
-0.102338098,
-1.0497429371,
0.1515708417,
0.1487682909,
-0.1109472439,
-0.5343880057,
-0.0437574275,
0.0761196911,
-0.1627008915,
-0.4283983409,
0.8035253286,
-0.3791767061,
-0.2413242161,
-0.0587762073,
0.241272524,
-0.3576674461,
0.4747491181,
0.2292895764,
0.5987334251,
0.4482961893,
-0.3241187036,
0.5581098795,
0.2247296125,
-0.606980443,
0.3677725792,
-0.2295354456,
0.0032001699,
-0.0779522061,
-0.0817283094,
-0.5986004472,
-0.2309134901,
-0.0752559528,
-0.2638513446,
0.2026473135,
-0.0473514982,
-1.0367456675,
-0.0891945213,
-0.0807592571,
0.4622930586,
0.5028777719,
-0.7641450167,
0.3481681347,
0.327429682,
-0.4021871686,
-0.3253058791,
-0.7668880224,
-0.1476708353,
-0.221221894,
-0.6460306644,
0.331186831,
0.2826886177,
-0.6306580305,
0.3128359318,
0.0702056959,
-0.1182047725,
-0.0464745909,
0.2082705349,
0.2991935909,
-0.3571467102,
0.1825646013,
0.1321758926,
0.0373990238,
-0.0624436773,
-0.2586756647,
0.5077830553,
-0.1736473739,
-0.414517045,
-0.284211278,
0.5915599465,
0.6055544615,
-0.4292095304,
0.750202775,
0.657096684,
-0.321049422,
-0.1935720444,
-0.5188558102,
-0.0739228353,
-0.4142741561,
0.3135935664,
-0.2110732496,
-0.842923224,
0.6582983732,
-0.0418680012,
0.0132112112,
0.4879307449,
0.9771736264,
0.030243082,
0.7596526742,
0.3379572332,
-0.3477022648,
0.4306178093,
-0.1539803445,
0.2757284045,
-0.3916940689,
0.0063817631,
-0.48158741,
-0.1082751825,
-0.9221932292,
-0.3724506497,
0.4276840389,
-0.033713229,
-0.1873786449,
0.3117825091,
0.2311396897,
0.1824023873,
0.7980259061,
-0.1276021451,
0.2117951959,
0.1825915724,
-0.3134709597,
0.1327255815,
-1.0173692703,
-0.2715639472,
0.9387356639,
0.1435732245,
0.3943453133,
0.3081722558,
0.9522949457,
0.0487293601,
-0.0746991187,
-0.9698469639,
0.4439728558,
-0.292427659,
-0.67117697,
-0.4545981288,
-0.3940207064,
-0.9016327858,
0.0979016498,
-0.5561087728,
-0.5812013745,
0.1803089976,
-0.0310456231,
-0.2606320381,
0.2685583532,
-0.7757566571,
0.969174087,
-0.4235383272,
-0.3481710255,
-0.3998131454,
-0.263114959,
0.3305296004,
-0.4565551579,
0.4878423512,
0.0565699413,
0.0482380167,
0.5233685374,
-0.4343086481,
0.5776604414,
-0.0180223584,
-0.0203404091,
0.2146524191,
0.1079208553,
0.2948435545,
-0.076356478,
-0.2980963886,
0.5585019588,
0.1031065956,
-0.5866585374,
-0.4806403518,
0.6327989697,
-0.576362431,
-0.52170825,
-0.3327113092,
-0.5920145512,
-0.408318162,
0.2187987715,
0.4256725013,
0.4725939929,
-0.1233028322,
0.1058658138,
0.4184948206,
-0.117713213,
0.6431427002,
0.3306013644,
-0.0594436415,
-0.2736747265,
0.8707262874,
0.1552699804,
0.1841356903,
0.0959749594,
-0.0016676746,
-0.2948415875,
-0.3803211451,
-0.6407613754,
0.4077175558,
-0.3189407885,
-0.1353621781,
-0.1570580453,
-0.4497624934,
-0.4642899334,
-0.1256595403,
-0.433929652,
-0.2251545489,
0.0302709863,
0.0498206876,
0.0160736255,
0.5264040232,
-0.1596546024,
0.2834192514,
-0.9715512991,
0.2032669783,
0.2610990703,
0.348359555,
0.0258728042,
-0.5081307292,
-0.6692116857,
-0.0014518332,
-0.1828891486,
-0.8095886707,
0.2755631804,
0.1192510799,
0.6091663837,
0.6974505186,
0.0686877444,
0.6833770871,
-0.6952909827,
0.620565176,
0.2962774932,
-1.0208684206,
0.216473788,
-0.1574919969,
0.3126586676,
0.3256403208,
0.3166712821,
-0.7441942692,
-0.4377491772,
-0.6652886271,
-0.8352507949,
0.7825032473,
0.14461115,
0.0918823555,
0.0471390598,
-0.1052819192,
0.2157721668,
0.0398433059,
-0.5750304461,
0.0449280553,
0.1092404351,
-0.016825188,
-0.2634539604,
-0.3192565739,
-0.157054469,
-0.2272189409,
0.7472906709,
-0.0337402076,
0.0987041816,
-0.2360482067,
-0.2985998094,
-0.1736979783,
0.4333871007,
0.081398733,
0.4728209376,
0.0653564408,
0.1698442549,
0.6607566476,
0.0973692909,
-0.0004177042,
0.2099314928,
0.1295347214,
0.3746559918,
0.9419526458,
1.0187202692,
0.1777925342,
-0.7896689773,
0.4232040346,
0.4074467719,
-0.1067451835,
-0.3188028932,
-0.1060996726,
0.2554630041,
0.3426738977,
-0.0527151041,
-0.268048197,
-0.1282430291,
-0.6052571535,
-0.1348875016,
0.5717073083,
-0.1363893002,
-0.3974004686,
0.1063937619,
0.1955348849,
-0.1642637253,
0.8527041674,
-0.667970717,
-0.6624706984,
0.207531929,
0.4444771409,
0.7656305432,
-0.1201745793,
-0.0825643614,
0.3484119177,
0.3233021498,
0.0649468079,
0.0564748272,
-0.1531179696,
-1.1280503273,
-0.3886740804,
-0.8103731275,
-0.2571656406,
0.0842140615,
-0.7690737247,
0.5871939063,
0.0004323845,
-0.0153242638,
0.1905649304,
-0.199418962,
-0.8030930161,
-0.2286750376,
0.4720504582,
0.8624640107,
-1.392731905,
0.9983715415,
0.8954399228,
0.0415642373,
-0.6223418713,
0.2372270972,
0.172939375,
-0.8514854908,
0.6205518842,
-0.0088705122,
-0.1253056228,
-0.1956471801,
0.0515307859,
-0.5164160728,
0.8091641068,
0.3300901651,
-0.541880846,
-0.1696923673,
0.274864763,
0.6516899467,
-0.1433196217,
-0.1524055302,
0.9339720607,
0.4479206204,
-0.1314422935,
-1.1139497757,
-0.1463711411,
-0.1506820619,
0.190811187,
0.3492456079,
-0.287768662,
0.5129814148,
0.104340598,
-0.311160326,
-0.0741815343,
0.5758188367,
0.1189527735,
0.2972739339,
0.9333825111,
0.7809821963,
0.5376445055,
-0.0246388558,
0.8197173476,
-0.5381528139,
0.1030017585,
0.9452826381,
-0.4145705402,
0.8879346251,
0.5535389185,
-0.1884509325,
0.5225897431,
0.7112579942,
-0.0243587457,
0.3649096489,
-0.0364733413,
-0.372713387,
-0.46669209,
-0.3289108872,
-0.0825930759,
0.9029588103,
0.4637103975,
-0.2251199782,
-0.4866327047,
-0.0799434409,
0.1301558614,
0.137094304,
-0.4540458322,
0.8120303154,
-0.0613165572,
-0.8313652873,
0.72340101,
0.1003991589,
0.5136014223,
-0.332349211,
0.3989905715,
-0.4903432727,
0.0228443816,
-0.1973023266,
-0.7664081454,
0.3490021825,
0.434846133,
-0.1918010861,
-0.1394714415,
0.303324163,
-0.4745956957,
-0.5835520625,
0.7116056085,
0.8648146391,
0.0314494781,
0.1087568179,
-0.3801206946,
-0.2094190717,
-0.2900895178,
-0.0679387301,
0.344447732,
0.743716538,
-0.1838981062,
0.2481965125,
0.4667878151,
0.3756069839,
0.1934295297,
-0.019914588,
0.7119779587,
-0.5758376122,
-0.3934139311,
-0.8735188246,
0.2846957147,
0.123082757,
-0.1902230978,
0.6721110344,
0.7834153771,
1.0924822092,
-0.0361646749,
0.8345581293,
-0.0350583978,
0.3179960549,
-0.6860947609,
0.5138970613,
-0.6917601824,
-0.1530001014,
-0.038396161,
-1.1289219856,
-0.0158419367,
0.0582773797,
-0.1898780167,
-0.2919688225,
0.8225495815,
1.0656658411,
-0.3395678401,
-0.0181602724,
0.2784073949,
0.2914250195,
-0.3011885583,
0.4502564073,
0.6872366071,
0.2037258595,
0.508687675,
-0.484218806,
-0.272154808,
-0.2070217729,
-0.685125351,
-0.8150518537,
-0.7675139308,
-0.0162506346,
-0.5913498998,
-0.1160815731,
0.9830508232,
0.4994015396,
-0.9509885311,
-0.7550287247,
0.124868378,
0.1926563978,
-0.2632941306,
-0.1726025492,
0.2807919979,
-0.5329853296,
-1.0349191427,
0.408143729,
0.2267370522,
-0.2145854831,
-0.1584823281,
-0.0124759879,
-0.2507550418,
-0.054836005,
0.6074663401,
0.2513524592,
-0.6855064631,
-0.3072796464,
-0.1497553885,
-0.1185830906,
-0.030267166,
0.6614311337,
-0.5548343658,
0.6589403749,
0.4233782887,
0.6197255254,
0.5101873279,
-0.2947580516,
0.4238371253,
-0.9077675343,
0.5728003383,
0.0708024725,
0.6228545904,
0.3561757803,
0.1234153956,
0.4266034067,
0.4140638411,
-0.2798329592,
-0.8744226694,
0.337567538,
-0.8729300499,
-0.0732933953,
1.3418277502,
-0.094928205,
-0.2052095085,
0.0774944052,
0.1995607167,
0.4162959754,
-0.1269156188,
0.3510613143,
0.9216816425,
-0.0987315997,
0.2063543499,
-0.4642943442,
0.2271108925,
0.409624815,
-0.3920708001,
0.2763535678,
0.4850450456,
0.0074698837,
0.2353961319,
0.1628670543,
-0.0106480801,
0.2202137858,
0.1635690629,
0.2032787651,
0.1973511279,
-0.0798218846,
-0.6668362617,
0.018973086,
0.2724087238,
-0.1104606912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09948v1 | Catch Me If You Can: Identifying Fraudulent Physician Reviews with Large Language Models Using Generative Pre-Trained Transformers | 2023-04-19T19:59:26 | 2023-04-19T19:59:26 | Aishwarya Deep Shukla, Laksh Agarwal, Jie Mein, Goh, Guodong, Gao, Ritu Agarwal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The proliferation of fake reviews of doctors has potentially detrimental
consequences for patient well-being and has prompted concern among consumer
protection groups and regulatory bodies. Yet despite significant advancements
in the fields of machine learning and natural language processing, there
remains limited comprehension of the characteristics differentiating fraudulent
from authentic reviews. This study utilizes a novel pre-labeled dataset of
38048 physician reviews to establish the effectiveness of large language models
in classifying reviews. Specifically, we compare the performance of traditional
ML models, such as logistic regression and support vector machines, to
generative pre-trained transformer models. Furthermore, we use GPT4, the newest
model in the GPT family, to uncover the key dimensions along which fake and
genuine physician reviews differ. Our findings reveal significantly superior
performance of GPT-3 over traditional ML models in this context. Additionally,
our analysis suggests that GPT3 requires a smaller training sample than
traditional models, suggesting its appropriateness for tasks with scarce
training data. Moreover, the superiority of GPT3 performance increases in the
cold start context i.e., when there are no prior reviews of a doctor. Finally,
we employ GPT4 to reveal the crucial dimensions that distinguish fake physician
reviews. In sharp contrast to previous findings in the literature that were
obtained using simulated data, our findings from a real-world dataset show that
fake reviews are generally more clinically detailed, more reserved in
sentiment, and have better structure and grammar than authentic ones. | [
-0.1277448535,
-0.5142755508,
0.7044382095,
-0.0153620401,
-0.407396853,
0.1113626584,
0.1744731367,
-0.5673723221,
0.3029035032,
0.5163785219,
-0.3002527058,
-0.3356107473,
-0.8436204791,
0.4039544463,
-0.5326224566,
1.1816058159,
0.0985688269,
0.7536823153,
0.0670151636,
0.1629374474,
-0.2978232801,
-0.8554909229,
-0.4324556887,
-0.1728238165,
0.3376810253,
-0.2002043575,
0.7594697475,
-0.0390551202,
0.2755144536,
0.2676631808,
0.2865207493,
0.1476452798,
-0.1777589917,
-0.4510391951,
-0.1868819743,
-0.5289299488,
-0.3343142271,
0.5080828667,
0.1603281647,
0.353459239,
-0.149323225,
-0.0284263249,
0.0107716648,
0.2774463892,
-0.192808941,
0.1277459413,
-0.5933949947,
0.3175521791,
-0.1224756017,
-0.4249427319,
-0.4332948327,
-0.6281135678,
0.3184767067,
-0.341937393,
0.7526960969,
-0.2197657377,
1.1677902937,
0.1224852279,
-0.3241347075,
-0.4283157289,
-1.0665023327,
0.4000073969,
-0.9054016471,
0.3477241993,
0.2921480238,
0.4251055717,
0.1205112338,
-0.6330000162,
-1.0345871449,
-0.4066957533,
-0.3749521673,
0.2836684883,
-0.356336087,
-0.022855226,
0.387291491,
0.6184439063,
-0.6290590167,
-0.0064468733,
-0.5093369484,
-0.344655633,
0.5069699287,
-0.1093269661,
0.3793740869,
-0.1753229499,
-0.224693507,
-0.3169395328,
-0.6302803159,
0.076296933,
0.5378857851,
-0.0953854024,
-0.0092916368,
0.5500978827,
0.1623357683,
0.4080314934,
0.1986774653,
-0.2744975984,
0.3790465593,
-0.3006259799,
-0.5113690495,
-0.0002735909,
0.9114567637,
0.2418094724,
0.3510139585,
0.0962225497,
-0.3741456568,
0.4072153568,
0.7691555619,
-0.540039897,
-0.4944702983,
0.2286037058,
-0.8506335616,
-0.6284168363,
0.3665682971,
-0.7086718082,
-0.3852027357,
-0.3550296724,
0.3803980649,
-0.3910392821,
-0.3152071238,
0.3221197724,
-0.0698428527,
0.369555831,
0.2985729277,
-0.5260437131,
0.2802181542,
0.7904631495,
0.6622340083,
0.0988850966,
-0.2432653755,
-0.3716800809,
-0.3990978301,
-0.4796660244,
0.8090181351,
-0.3092565835,
-0.5296169519,
0.1523581445,
0.1219629049,
-0.2555304766,
-0.7436268926,
0.6364895105,
-0.5522500277,
0.5094311237,
-0.0736841038,
-0.3292364478,
-0.0943994001,
0.5789539218,
-0.6430296898,
0.4704810977,
0.2978133857,
-0.713721633,
0.6925913692,
-0.2506130338,
-0.5624242425,
0.1932735145,
-0.442476362,
-0.9049761891,
0.3621346354,
0.3146583438,
0.3598576784,
-0.0197951216,
0.3335836232,
-0.211029768,
-0.1563881785,
0.5358789563,
-0.7178552747,
0.8333948851,
0.2887771428,
-0.4854820967,
0.0795075223,
-0.474894315,
-0.0148317805,
0.1495901644,
-0.3108142614,
-0.156483233,
-0.0435961001,
-0.0545870736,
0.1122912019,
-0.3149796724,
-0.554158926,
0.3400753438,
-0.4515883029,
0.0393783301,
0.4936499894,
0.3213781416,
0.0475503802,
-0.3687842786,
0.9372778535,
0.1165250018,
0.3680884242,
-0.0908570439,
-0.6531924605,
-0.4775047302,
-0.2711490989,
0.4317575693,
0.680824995,
-1.0498907566,
0.5331101418,
-0.4334907234,
-0.4939095378,
-0.7200183272,
-0.1085684821,
0.6127055883,
0.5119178295,
0.4681110978,
-0.3207226098,
-0.2583470047,
-0.9085929394,
-0.6730305552,
-0.2750458419,
-0.2434229553,
0.2218862772,
0.426813215,
-0.4495753944,
0.8142703772,
-0.4716815054,
-0.5484845638,
-0.2783915102,
0.0438114218,
0.400627315,
0.2716247737,
0.6366869211,
-0.8682323694,
-0.5684936047,
-0.0443825424,
-0.6410592198,
0.0772908628,
-0.3171294928,
0.3519711792,
0.015881747,
0.2568246424,
-0.7495219111,
0.6900503039,
0.6466944814,
-0.4191651046,
0.7553862929,
-0.4705783725,
0.3216354847,
-0.9435665011,
0.0158840418,
0.1132420301,
-0.0450842194,
-0.7540544868,
-0.2156085074,
0.1170211807,
-0.2270807028,
-0.3196725845,
0.2815305293,
-0.3256177604,
0.3609901667,
0.0795377344,
-0.5720345974,
-0.1328962594,
-0.0530879535,
-0.0510964692,
0.4842012823,
0.3862888217,
-0.4252403975,
0.3082164526,
0.3719190061,
-0.7665335536,
0.7575799823,
-0.527586937,
0.1413280219,
-0.0987875685,
0.6152476072,
-0.6945167184,
-0.6794984341,
0.4643956125,
-0.7779505253,
0.4634703696,
-0.4300650358,
-0.819010973,
-0.8367276788,
0.0117884204,
0.1674782932,
0.5671820641,
-0.771183908,
0.7724084258,
0.1495152116,
0.0713909343,
-0.510679245,
-0.4378265142,
0.1059196517,
-0.1175584719,
-0.258012861,
0.1689918488,
0.1129592285,
-0.1952216625,
-0.0605338775,
-0.2065844089,
-0.1161527261,
-0.2073902339,
0.0726002902,
0.3237964809,
-0.0631768852,
-0.1121669263,
-0.0082357377,
-0.2387575656,
0.1589895487,
-0.3091312647,
0.421623677,
-0.0309855063,
-0.5025333762,
-0.5006218553,
0.2439177632,
0.743783772,
-0.1284518838,
0.3821708858,
0.4936174154,
-0.2982588708,
-0.2368677258,
-0.8276196718,
-0.4139116406,
-0.4402051568,
0.2525364161,
-0.1782283783,
-0.4813791215,
0.0492472351,
0.3423674107,
0.0326603316,
0.2686342001,
0.4839118421,
-0.1609115601,
1.119690299,
0.3998293877,
-0.2422377765,
-0.0392095745,
0.0165607296,
0.8629789352,
-0.1565778553,
-0.4140692949,
-0.2884082794,
-0.1773312837,
-0.5884729028,
-0.5287243128,
0.5925378799,
-0.0334194265,
0.3528020382,
0.1579943597,
-0.7871569395,
0.5265156627,
0.595267117,
0.1127748862,
0.2099652141,
0.2247762233,
-0.1629634947,
0.0143467328,
-0.4716688693,
-0.4791328609,
1.1774617434,
0.4617848694,
0.685733676,
0.0144002521,
0.4873752892,
0.328474462,
0.929405272,
-0.5688737035,
0.4082190096,
-0.2459115237,
-0.7002978921,
0.0565226041,
-0.4254504442,
-0.8464357257,
0.3167970479,
-0.3639297783,
-0.2431766391,
-0.0523546636,
0.4147717655,
-0.3022954762,
0.6701452732,
-0.9507675171,
0.6839494109,
-0.544367373,
0.2545056045,
-0.0606066734,
-0.593428731,
0.4927745163,
-0.3844654262,
0.2461279482,
0.0722033679,
0.4388712943,
0.3729760349,
-0.6454514861,
0.8945695162,
-0.425855726,
-0.1206720769,
0.1809292436,
0.2708257735,
0.3447230756,
0.175459072,
0.4121112525,
0.5287414193,
0.2130369395,
-0.2116583884,
-0.4457883537,
0.6162073016,
-0.7197051048,
-0.63675493,
-0.7060861588,
-0.0165329091,
-0.3521924913,
0.2584642172,
0.680880487,
0.1877079606,
-0.1172499135,
-0.0862673372,
0.4077420235,
-0.5057601333,
0.1211194023,
0.587536931,
0.0125666177,
-0.5295987725,
0.8152829409,
0.1080246344,
-0.2076482028,
0.2675423324,
0.4198773801,
-0.487988323,
-0.5561872721,
-0.4948997498,
0.4298160672,
-0.4752696157,
-0.0736713484,
-0.9432216287,
-0.1906435788,
-0.5167936683,
0.1683566719,
-0.2034287453,
0.2185575217,
-0.1144781783,
-0.0941321999,
0.0530218519,
0.9911703467,
0.212011978,
0.2449447066,
-0.8138471842,
0.3976850808,
0.3294885159,
0.6090228558,
-0.027888272,
-0.3016077578,
0.122789748,
-0.2435213774,
-0.2912515402,
-1.0641326904,
0.7248141766,
-0.2360216826,
0.6189877987,
0.9130712152,
-0.1428898424,
0.572177887,
-0.4858345687,
0.8284148574,
0.3864380121,
-0.7605082393,
0.2812594771,
-0.4709159732,
0.1227435395,
0.329541713,
0.7422479391,
-0.3176154196,
-0.2151573151,
-0.7900390625,
-0.5181626678,
0.4012316167,
0.0009547782,
0.3232265115,
-0.1433475167,
0.3154506087,
0.3006456792,
0.2853539884,
-1.2410652637,
-0.1473940015,
-0.2804020941,
0.0066901809,
-0.4270643294,
-0.3340925872,
-0.1830174625,
-0.3019496799,
0.5531007051,
-0.1616760492,
0.3674114347,
0.2581296265,
-0.0342169888,
0.1320657581,
0.2698882818,
0.6248031855,
0.485124737,
0.0315996036,
0.2886752784,
-0.0198049564,
-0.7144885063,
0.0565780587,
0.1207648739,
-0.2225750238,
0.3201512694,
0.5329057574,
0.4024043977,
0.0424471572,
-0.5650715828,
0.9469400644,
-0.139222309,
-0.562941432,
-0.4860378802,
-0.2757351696,
-0.3367789388,
0.0648787096,
0.1954815537,
0.4599989057,
0.0321967937,
-0.4751084149,
0.2831875682,
0.5571820736,
-0.3995668292,
-0.5802684426,
0.5845080614,
-0.0307528879,
-0.4025882781,
0.8008341789,
0.0185403712,
-0.7345653772,
0.3147809207,
0.4094332457,
0.9067964554,
-0.4915935993,
0.3553543687,
0.3462444246,
0.3671489358,
-0.1662348211,
0.0146887684,
0.0990046635,
-0.6094017029,
-0.3609323204,
-0.6560900807,
-0.290719837,
0.6507681608,
-0.6223763824,
0.3393102288,
-0.5773021579,
-0.2314664125,
-0.1117094904,
-0.4550156593,
-0.7291743159,
0.4224820435,
0.1125326827,
0.6130180955,
-1.0090761185,
0.8050380349,
0.3031552136,
-0.3553933501,
-0.9278790951,
0.3726830482,
0.2293169945,
-0.6291646361,
0.3019200265,
0.3247561455,
-0.0568485446,
-0.457463026,
-0.5587750673,
-0.3694144785,
0.5326634645,
-0.0967019722,
-0.5826324821,
-0.2412288338,
0.1199705526,
0.8433279395,
-0.2784430087,
0.1355984658,
0.6877804995,
-0.0014884644,
-0.0920103192,
-1.0000652075,
-0.1307725459,
-0.28728953,
-0.2995761931,
-0.0641480163,
-0.1038303301,
0.9020152092,
-0.3154404461,
-0.3985708058,
0.0036742475,
0.0537514165,
0.2144855261,
0.3683024347,
0.5802778602,
0.486666292,
0.6764241457,
-0.1893956959,
1.5276418924,
-0.216723159,
0.1928224415,
0.930280149,
-0.2943577766,
0.7774556875,
0.2240205556,
-0.1545970887,
0.4490813315,
0.5487461686,
-0.6169939041,
0.3408861756,
0.2665342987,
-0.3614087105,
0.0030938487,
0.6030393243,
-0.4639211297,
0.2149443179,
0.301353693,
-0.6500129104,
0.0485092923,
0.1205653474,
0.0580242351,
0.0031318432,
-0.2672286034,
0.8469406366,
0.1251995414,
-1.0025185347,
0.4935961068,
-0.1184423119,
0.667730689,
-0.571999073,
-0.1491634548,
-0.0783989131,
0.4529198408,
-0.4080899656,
-0.6125677824,
0.1663400829,
0.1375054568,
-0.2482569814,
-0.6054593921,
0.3993690312,
-0.1033367291,
-0.5792146921,
0.1731679589,
0.5705262423,
0.2117221802,
-0.1397069991,
-0.7062584758,
-0.2257018089,
0.1694839001,
0.1307547688,
0.2671024501,
0.1215895414,
-0.1099564359,
0.4740852118,
1.2108272314,
0.4372503459,
0.1656226218,
0.2030634433,
0.6420539618,
-0.527946651,
-0.7820827961,
-0.8498386145,
0.139383629,
-0.1000249907,
-0.23092556,
0.8800330162,
0.7630592585,
0.977262795,
-0.7781012058,
0.8180763721,
0.2738704085,
1.0418043137,
-0.5316833854,
1.1179288626,
-0.2213138044,
0.3784673214,
-0.3328844309,
-0.8112763166,
-0.4696100354,
0.5969883204,
-0.5447593331,
0.230221644,
0.7385739088,
0.7245215178,
-0.1862653941,
-0.0227511115,
0.4134092033,
0.3660770059,
0.6330923438,
0.0793888047,
0.969374299,
-0.1821318716,
0.6057345867,
0.0075118192,
-0.1657257974,
-0.1819421947,
-0.5047424436,
-0.9699276686,
-0.1448402256,
-0.3774291277,
-1.137142539,
-0.4458044767,
0.6208535433,
0.7813418508,
-0.8579599857,
0.2137819231,
0.0283231884,
-0.2733185291,
-0.2875060737,
-0.2555725574,
0.3448728323,
-0.0135641042,
-0.5790988803,
0.3506813347,
0.1786918938,
0.2850199044,
-0.1981017292,
0.0395008735,
0.3950652778,
0.1576707661,
0.4780964255,
0.4030029774,
-1.0757929087,
-0.1303872764,
-0.2097999603,
-0.1317141354,
0.1004400253,
1.2193175554,
-0.902518332,
0.8206135631,
0.0155453533,
0.3917372525,
0.4056409299,
-0.0819687918,
0.4563314915,
-0.4416581392,
-0.2340533435,
0.5471326113,
0.3784698546,
0.2041728646,
-0.4866676331,
0.2602606118,
0.4610595107,
-0.3142829239,
-0.792293787,
0.1996180862,
-0.8910117745,
-0.1425010562,
1.0690169334,
-0.1472613811,
0.1435381919,
-0.3826455176,
-0.1784590036,
-0.2259187549,
0.0208681319,
1.1466209888,
0.439247638,
-0.2188679576,
-0.0145443752,
-0.6025238633,
0.8931471705,
0.1832091063,
-0.9905198216,
-0.3525885046,
0.3056827486,
0.7814685106,
0.2819120288,
0.8109643459,
-0.5987154841,
0.5120120645,
0.0196612515,
-0.2736774385,
0.1351818144,
-0.0951822177,
-0.5975295901,
0.2436335385,
-0.148906216,
0.1209476665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09919v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09919v1 | The eBible Corpus: Data and Model Benchmarks for Bible Translation for Low-Resource Languages | 2023-04-19T18:52:49 | 2023-04-19T18:52:49 | Vesa Akerman, David Baines, Damien Daspit, Ulf Hermjakob, Taeho Jang, Colin Leong, Michael Martin, Joel Mathew, Jonathan Robie, Marcus Schwarting | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Efficiently and accurately translating a corpus into a low-resource language
remains a challenge, regardless of the strategies employed, whether manual,
automated, or a combination of the two. Many Christian organizations are
dedicated to the task of translating the Holy Bible into languages that lack a
modern translation. Bible translation (BT) work is currently underway for over
3000 extremely low resource languages. We introduce the eBible corpus: a
dataset containing 1009 translations of portions of the Bible with data in 833
different languages across 75 language families. In addition to a BT
benchmarking dataset, we introduce model performance benchmarks built on the No
Language Left Behind (NLLB) neural machine translation (NMT) models. Finally,
we describe several problems specific to the domain of BT and consider how the
established data and model benchmarks might be used for future translation
efforts. For a BT task trained with NLLB, Austronesian and Trans-New Guinea
language families achieve 35.1 and 31.6 BLEU scores respectively, which spurs
future innovations for NMT for low-resource languages in Papua New Guinea. | [
-0.1551299989,
-0.5848872662,
0.0720132887,
0.2500952184,
-0.3290569484,
-0.0209940989,
-0.4464035332,
-0.5465196371,
-0.1834976226,
0.4246201813,
-0.14362064,
-0.2001827061,
-0.7159059644,
0.4134885669,
-0.7246072292,
0.9118769169,
-0.1692936569,
-0.0093187634,
0.2041305155,
-0.2942334712,
-0.1965952665,
-0.2110104114,
-0.4733327329,
-0.1665711701,
0.4948155284,
0.1695861816,
0.9596866369,
0.9648981094,
0.5914531946,
0.2735639215,
-0.2849053442,
0.2386135757,
-0.666888237,
0.0535466336,
-0.2409365028,
-0.2908834517,
-0.5086929202,
-0.026107844,
0.5331392288,
1.0923261642,
0.0735738501,
0.5163852572,
0.069367379,
0.5308313966,
-0.400637418,
0.1214404777,
-0.4988170564,
0.0175257809,
-0.415658474,
-0.3265506029,
-0.568123281,
-0.6814476848,
0.1956357062,
-0.5830826163,
0.3919723034,
0.4844205976,
0.756782949,
0.3966898024,
-0.578402102,
-0.2934932113,
-0.4986634254,
1.0661371946,
-0.5107755065,
0.5392320752,
0.5969836116,
-0.0439979061,
-0.1405197531,
-0.4717701077,
-0.217251718,
-0.2247624099,
-0.0502575077,
0.0339375474,
-0.3957383037,
-0.1934716403,
0.2000363469,
0.2979056239,
-0.5106967092,
0.0006786171,
-0.4109951854,
0.0469883494,
0.3455300033,
0.0699676424,
0.1191483364,
-0.4753316939,
-0.2179278135,
-0.3829565644,
-0.6330213547,
-0.2760952115,
0.1391756386,
0.3222717345,
-0.2108807713,
0.6029071808,
-0.1209025458,
0.8645000458,
-0.147851795,
-0.1716282368,
0.3256557584,
-0.7809359431,
-0.3051508665,
0.1337899417,
0.5004726648,
0.4951210916,
0.2079590708,
-0.3063156605,
-0.4068488777,
-0.1218067184,
0.3311662674,
-0.925601542,
0.0036543815,
-0.154265821,
-0.724028945,
-0.3194971085,
-0.6252943277,
-0.6197967529,
-0.3421397507,
-0.3614926934,
0.1375756115,
-0.7534279227,
-0.2789406776,
-0.2016183585,
0.0302901845,
0.1065665185,
0.711471796,
-0.7684275508,
0.3949176073,
0.3378305435,
0.9289429784,
-0.1433724016,
-0.1635478586,
-0.5010775924,
0.210065037,
-0.462107867,
0.5116374493,
-0.318795383,
-0.2654848993,
0.0594445169,
-0.0819371119,
-0.0199541263,
-0.7042648196,
0.6164407134,
-0.38132146,
-0.3766260743,
-0.3343473077,
-0.5338442326,
-0.2813673019,
0.1682824343,
-0.8539322615,
1.138076663,
0.6939553022,
-0.3292768002,
0.2073622495,
-0.4251239598,
-0.3589374721,
0.2946486771,
0.1093887016,
-0.0856817588,
0.7010558844,
-0.0032159672,
0.0741938278,
-0.7882736921,
0.0232122689,
-0.1272783428,
-0.3782802522,
0.1526845247,
-0.7410563231,
0.7625385523,
0.3899128735,
-0.1839541495,
-0.4375526309,
-0.6449469328,
0.3239345253,
0.0790740326,
-0.5014687777,
-0.320640564,
-0.1788168103,
0.7906004786,
0.0845267177,
0.2238304764,
-0.621068716,
0.2634996772,
-0.1426388472,
0.4119024873,
0.3144657612,
-0.5456233025,
0.4616921544,
-0.0200592261,
0.3618634343,
0.0246638786,
-0.0080280416,
0.1105777994,
-0.7294178009,
-0.3978340328,
0.1882341802,
0.6907149553,
0.5036557317,
-0.8329856396,
0.1444003433,
-0.5035732388,
-0.522860229,
-0.8498468399,
0.4094640613,
0.355730027,
0.4037089944,
0.6605746746,
-0.4731117189,
-0.1244286373,
-0.8851320148,
-0.1496949792,
-0.2280739397,
-0.0089335367,
0.3059333563,
0.3861329854,
0.0345391817,
0.3941472769,
0.118947275,
-0.1315007508,
-0.2344978452,
0.298176229,
0.2626299858,
0.5057794452,
0.6076559424,
-1.073179841,
-0.6222694516,
0.5830093026,
-0.7582151294,
-0.3362395763,
-0.1183969527,
-0.0639674515,
0.2047491819,
0.3885521889,
-0.3290201426,
0.762624681,
0.7085850239,
-0.1192376167,
0.2899543047,
-0.260602504,
0.1856378764,
-0.7682950497,
0.2544829547,
-0.140990898,
-0.3248337805,
-0.5223687887,
-0.099168241,
0.5334501863,
0.0841241404,
-0.6312487721,
0.4803407192,
-0.425249666,
-0.0803691745,
-0.3440769017,
0.1192436814,
-0.0432087183,
0.0915057883,
-0.1231480017,
0.8820223212,
-0.0375620835,
-0.3963074982,
0.5591488481,
0.7667450309,
-0.3717824519,
0.7183794975,
-0.4029963017,
-0.0799142048,
0.1301633567,
0.0288443603,
-0.3954568803,
-0.0271279756,
0.0015359881,
-0.2569628656,
0.572203517,
-0.2317890525,
-0.6740966439,
-0.0501571596,
0.2866681814,
0.7000545263,
0.3342354,
-0.3450170457,
0.3303224444,
0.0492948331,
-0.3249393702,
-0.7726073861,
-0.9643029571,
0.2135733366,
0.051206205,
-0.45290488,
0.6766212583,
-0.0773118883,
-0.0026274947,
0.551130712,
-0.0533341058,
-0.2406736016,
0.0664385334,
-0.0240605175,
0.0991970524,
-0.4633378088,
0.174050495,
-0.1500721127,
-0.0505204238,
-0.3319392204,
-0.2678783834,
0.4496630132,
-0.3612924516,
-0.001668202,
-0.1039783433,
0.5341303945,
0.139815256,
-0.2168492079,
0.8669689298,
0.5725569129,
-0.3768373728,
-0.0287768003,
-0.483376652,
0.2029414028,
-0.4061094522,
0.51871562,
-0.4256411493,
-0.5000327826,
0.2787921727,
-0.3573916852,
0.0981451795,
0.1619719863,
0.8226373196,
-0.1279069334,
0.3783740401,
0.621299684,
0.0727075785,
0.5213750005,
-0.1308301389,
0.0122387437,
-0.6183645725,
0.1553587317,
-0.3157179058,
-0.6005544066,
-0.8322630525,
-0.5122395754,
0.19825688,
0.5117170811,
0.2271316797,
1.0508676767,
-0.1554663926,
0.4305721819,
0.7632354498,
-0.2218293101,
0.3925441206,
0.1148219034,
-0.1010348648,
-0.0351291187,
-0.706494689,
-0.6455560923,
1.2553658485,
-0.1316883862,
0.3945756257,
0.3972383738,
0.9421655536,
0.2403921932,
0.7962144017,
-0.6288346648,
0.1995232254,
-0.171803996,
-0.9541317225,
-0.1908345222,
-0.6430830956,
-0.9922397137,
0.4040071964,
-0.0898609161,
-0.3307892382,
0.2533820868,
-0.1301065236,
-0.3932044506,
0.2468933463,
-0.7999255061,
1.0798441172,
-0.3412638605,
-0.7240629792,
-0.2609550953,
-0.4853690267,
-0.1426376998,
-0.4882254601,
0.0628794357,
-0.1971431375,
-0.2630093694,
0.2674343586,
-0.0793576688,
0.4131686985,
0.2060876489,
0.2010147125,
0.1810341477,
0.2062911093,
0.1998320669,
-0.1081308573,
-0.4514851272,
0.1259941012,
0.228703022,
-0.8255319595,
-0.165468663,
0.5475264788,
-0.7380200028,
-0.1448855251,
-0.5317412615,
-0.9435880184,
-0.0360011384,
0.3749314249,
0.2181528211,
0.2068740278,
-0.4055029452,
0.4443545043,
0.4044947028,
-0.5624607801,
0.6273559332,
0.6778331399,
-0.0201498177,
-0.3931431472,
0.9226976037,
0.3862426877,
0.3574533463,
0.3380489647,
-0.2054589987,
-0.223726362,
-0.7149881124,
-0.9851289988,
0.1973723769,
-0.5665189028,
-0.3355110288,
-0.1579497606,
0.0824239329,
-0.0475632846,
-0.1242901534,
-0.5357045531,
-0.4392315149,
-0.1113280654,
0.0336687677,
0.0839686692,
0.8295090199,
-0.0545515567,
0.4097564816,
-1.0422534943,
0.1719758213,
-0.2524338663,
0.1592818648,
-0.1634060889,
-0.4545152187,
-0.488622427,
-0.2543010116,
-0.6493224502,
-1.0090970993,
0.768738091,
0.1987925172,
0.2274918109,
-0.0524998195,
0.0869517997,
0.7607652545,
-0.8856301904,
0.2273344547,
0.1877286434,
-0.8380281925,
0.0672757849,
-0.3157078028,
0.0620124601,
0.6897500753,
0.3804751337,
-0.852621913,
-0.1299881786,
-0.4164745212,
-0.7293061614,
0.5685689449,
0.6767517328,
0.0197849739,
-0.0697589144,
0.2322571278,
0.2058394849,
0.5917052031,
-0.6482899189,
-0.2132700831,
-0.1093341559,
-0.2936251163,
-0.0633995607,
0.2819505036,
0.0912094861,
-0.2731765807,
0.4604652226,
-0.0590844341,
0.0927215889,
0.1562625617,
-0.581170857,
-0.4850420952,
0.2635113299,
0.3008271456,
0.5852867961,
-0.3822864592,
-0.1644598097,
0.242818743,
-0.2917531431,
0.2786713243,
0.3105382323,
-0.4931461513,
0.1750423014,
0.2033436298,
0.3778319955,
0.3762604296,
-0.3707279861,
0.4153166115,
-0.024687944,
0.1136664376,
-0.3851576746,
-0.4736731052,
0.5254698992,
0.164653033,
0.2113446593,
0.3288704455,
0.0260419007,
-0.3636150658,
0.0547681488,
-0.0200561788,
-0.1436224431,
-0.3374812901,
0.7675498128,
0.3425364494,
-0.1187919825,
0.7213206887,
-0.5452274084,
-0.2083261758,
0.3960202634,
0.4547968805,
0.4052568972,
-0.4065600336,
0.1215532944,
0.3636776209,
0.6187823415,
-0.1490423977,
0.2816694379,
0.010733474,
-0.3917967081,
-0.5896770358,
-0.9508565068,
-0.5819397569,
-0.0383702107,
-0.7285580039,
-0.0064717266,
-0.0924246013,
-0.3358546495,
0.1026746109,
-0.0374555588,
-1.3305802345,
-0.0563542023,
0.3695421219,
0.8281771541,
-0.5491006374,
1.1198503971,
0.4788712263,
-0.6003786325,
-0.2820901871,
-0.5326100588,
-0.0366539694,
-0.6055937409,
0.9560215473,
0.1252958328,
0.1234667003,
0.2254956663,
-0.1573413461,
-0.9490753412,
0.8691589236,
0.717333436,
-0.725571394,
-0.3451265395,
0.3877565861,
0.4399676919,
-0.0416583195,
0.3839930296,
0.6340515018,
0.7480581999,
-0.4979391098,
-1.1047081947,
-0.1671410501,
-0.3880086839,
0.0367738008,
0.3655434251,
-0.6223778725,
0.7640408874,
0.1361816972,
-0.1640619338,
0.4627549946,
0.5757791996,
-0.2198850513,
0.3242397904,
0.1767253131,
0.5984075665,
0.732200563,
-0.2933909595,
1.398152709,
-0.5261747241,
0.2684200406,
0.7006834745,
-0.2399494052,
0.9538759589,
0.6069520116,
-0.2820115089,
-0.0058065401,
0.598942399,
-0.0959831923,
0.2984968424,
0.2184702754,
-0.301579237,
-0.3285887837,
-0.5634131432,
-0.5459512472,
0.3251443803,
0.4397674501,
-0.5389623046,
-0.153318122,
-0.1497143209,
-0.1562055498,
0.0367992185,
-0.1704294831,
0.3501952589,
0.4314395487,
-0.5434001088,
0.8369185328,
0.2642588913,
0.3573764265,
-0.3251083493,
-0.0088998256,
-0.189568013,
0.3639322519,
-0.1022769809,
-0.2515460551,
0.3260956407,
0.1508971751,
-0.0961374938,
-0.4333688319,
0.3226436675,
-0.4566141963,
-0.65881145,
0.5984748006,
1.0372476578,
0.2666124105,
0.0972532853,
-0.6708225012,
-0.0308520775,
-0.1280930638,
-0.4228438437,
0.3103999794,
0.6688546538,
-0.0334209315,
0.3491385579,
0.6175543666,
0.3673720956,
0.3670384288,
-0.101723209,
0.5799753666,
-0.9906979203,
-0.2344809324,
-0.6471875906,
-0.1439009756,
-0.0707613081,
-0.5920670033,
0.6496298313,
0.6070830822,
1.1068081856,
-0.1433019787,
0.7385802269,
-0.2274800837,
0.2314646393,
-0.0806638673,
0.6932470798,
-0.7212648988,
-0.2797161639,
-0.1245603785,
-1.2538874149,
-0.0814891085,
0.655737102,
-0.3660901785,
-0.2316551507,
0.9781904221,
0.5401919484,
-0.1868601441,
0.1417553872,
0.5572271347,
0.1091089696,
0.1048320234,
0.8235757351,
0.7027799487,
-0.7429029942,
1.0057600737,
-0.3713662028,
-0.0884898379,
-0.2559418976,
-0.8784859776,
-0.5211475492,
-0.186972335,
-0.2095436454,
-0.3159024715,
-0.0436682403,
1.1737393141,
0.5080322623,
-0.9481421113,
-0.550630331,
0.0167278722,
-0.2971143425,
-0.606698513,
-0.0390630662,
0.1824127138,
-0.2028682679,
-1.0259430408,
0.8402310014,
0.2160873413,
-0.0562298,
0.0960257947,
-0.190284282,
-0.1454996914,
-0.1656839103,
0.5460881591,
0.1816797554,
-0.6976838112,
-0.0291502401,
-0.0184855554,
-0.4055939317,
0.2036278099,
0.5158156753,
-0.442925632,
0.4972932637,
0.3154418468,
1.19747293,
0.8015749454,
-0.1361843795,
0.5888944268,
-0.6294127107,
0.1640008986,
0.2722020447,
0.5024585128,
0.6080584526,
0.1286102384,
0.9765625,
0.2983426452,
-0.4088455439,
-0.7808343172,
0.313744843,
-0.9210455418,
0.0432189293,
0.7538542151,
-0.2500835955,
-0.4485743046,
-0.347751826,
0.054319337,
0.5010742545,
-0.3877860308,
0.4890037775,
0.9382205606,
0.3720053434,
0.0711483434,
-1.2968878746,
0.34941113,
0.8535199165,
-0.3657799363,
0.1413676292,
0.3475548029,
0.0171257015,
0.391511023,
0.2931478918,
-0.1333120018,
0.4681825936,
0.3023993671,
0.0632180497,
-0.167027235,
0.0777569562,
-0.0118441973,
0.1866415143,
-0.1285758615,
0.3004253507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11046v1 | Affective social anthropomorphic intelligent system | 2023-04-19T18:24:57 | 2023-04-19T18:24:57 | Md. Adyelullahil Mamun, Hasnat Md. Abdullah, Md. Golam Rabiul Alam, Muhammad Mehedi Hassan, Md. Zia Uddin | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Human conversational styles are measured by the sense of humor, personality,
and tone of voice. These characteristics have become essential for
conversational intelligent virtual assistants. However, most of the
state-of-the-art intelligent virtual assistants (IVAs) are failed to interpret
the affective semantics of human voices. This research proposes an
anthropomorphic intelligent system that can hold a proper human-like
conversation with emotion and personality. A voice style transfer method is
also proposed to map the attributes of a specific emotion. Initially, the
frequency domain data (Mel-Spectrogram) is created by converting the temporal
audio wave data, which comprises discrete patterns for audio features such as
notes, pitch, rhythm, and melody. A collateral CNN-Transformer-Encoder is used
to predict seven different affective states from voice. The voice is also fed
parallelly to the deep-speech, an RNN model that generates the text
transcription from the spectrogram. Then the transcripted text is transferred
to the multi-domain conversation agent using blended skill talk,
transformer-based retrieve-and-generate generation strategy, and beam-search
decoding, and an appropriate textual response is generated. The system learns
an invertible mapping of data to a latent space that can be manipulated and
generates a Mel-spectrogram frame based on previous Mel-spectrogram frames to
voice synthesize and style transfer. Finally, the waveform is generated using
WaveGlow from the spectrogram. The outcomes of the studies we conducted on
individual models were auspicious. Furthermore, users who interacted with the
system provided positive feedback, demonstrating the system's effectiveness. | [
-0.6675485373,
-0.7740352154,
0.2853115499,
0.3545481563,
-0.3274022937,
0.2210668027,
-0.3932843804,
-0.5596801043,
0.8635850549,
0.337046504,
-0.6177323461,
-0.4107161462,
-0.4061455429,
0.1090105325,
-0.3104258478,
0.7670065165,
0.5085725784,
-0.1058147028,
0.0066527692,
-0.0944956094,
-0.4004561901,
-0.6791599989,
-0.7643544078,
-0.4282371402,
0.1501372904,
0.5631872416,
0.8606629968,
0.1203443781,
0.417103231,
0.4156590998,
-0.0417117849,
0.179500401,
-0.2817649245,
0.1798325479,
-0.2637028098,
-0.3748393059,
-0.7205678821,
-0.3207345009,
0.1290624738,
-0.04707513,
-0.2484620064,
0.0102088749,
-0.2677278221,
0.5021107793,
-0.040203765,
0.2423552573,
-0.6405946016,
0.1124408171,
-0.1189380288,
-0.2931077778,
-0.1758405864,
-0.3392739296,
0.2496599704,
-0.5514937639,
-0.25606668,
0.1296429485,
0.589410007,
0.3575683236,
-0.4370625615,
-0.3000850677,
-1.0573732853,
0.4171228111,
-1.0208355188,
0.0940824449,
0.3156034946,
0.4360158443,
0.142988041,
-0.2796146274,
-1.306319356,
-0.2278672159,
0.1168290302,
0.2878611088,
-0.1015825868,
0.0499565937,
-0.1366871595,
0.244616136,
-0.3344585001,
-0.0284036361,
-0.3007739782,
0.0514218472,
0.9874204993,
0.3201873004,
0.723190546,
-0.3342184424,
-0.2919878364,
-0.4260559976,
-0.1523874104,
0.1399836093,
0.2848598361,
0.3902288079,
-0.3217101693,
0.483946532,
-0.1372779459,
0.3958292007,
0.0334940627,
-0.2663366795,
0.3849309087,
0.0164737571,
-0.2146034092,
0.1831068397,
0.8808128238,
0.4299966991,
0.5595207214,
0.0365655608,
-0.0526612103,
0.1851165295,
0.5156903267,
-0.6820486784,
0.0092205554,
0.1768234968,
-0.4456917942,
-0.4010430574,
-0.1111989021,
-1.0202149153,
-0.2375296652,
-0.7392745614,
0.5164734125,
-0.8745284677,
-0.4311043918,
-0.0451912358,
0.1381874532,
0.1609667689,
0.2614406347,
-0.9774912,
0.4385823309,
0.2748191059,
0.7058461905,
-0.3010866344,
0.0853180215,
0.1524385959,
-0.0703330785,
-0.1786748171,
0.6400055885,
-0.7162398696,
-0.701089859,
-0.1303408593,
0.0467884503,
-0.042122785,
-0.3988278508,
0.3559541404,
-0.3785755336,
0.1378551424,
0.0448957495,
-0.3023560345,
-0.2349416316,
0.0594233423,
-0.3022987545,
0.6850598454,
0.2003540546,
-0.3432749212,
-0.252913177,
-0.9299180508,
-0.5455636382,
0.1980673373,
-0.0703048036,
-0.3561067283,
-0.2407486439,
-0.12066219,
0.3271804452,
-0.1192960814,
0.1026393473,
-0.4855810404,
-0.3835125864,
0.5732341409,
-0.0977152288,
0.5308598876,
0.3202552497,
-0.7676329613,
0.2244830728,
-0.8012538552,
-0.0249171723,
0.2222494036,
-0.0918024778,
-0.2643667758,
0.0807364807,
0.1918764859,
0.55562675,
0.1346607357,
-0.6851938367,
0.1486800313,
-0.2720891535,
0.2556351423,
0.7782048583,
-0.0035945715,
0.2981737256,
-0.1927051693,
0.5256889462,
-0.1030192599,
0.1521761715,
0.2753699124,
-0.2870159447,
-0.8870540857,
-0.1241973862,
-0.3751327097,
0.9859669805,
-0.7395071983,
0.6613968611,
-0.2534533143,
-0.6581009626,
-0.5662440658,
-0.2090220898,
0.3331565261,
0.5020094514,
0.3090131283,
-0.3088801205,
-0.2036836445,
-0.8541282415,
0.2069361508,
-0.3512985706,
-0.07396584,
0.8822619915,
0.0189094171,
-0.4979839325,
0.7731686234,
-0.2839724422,
-0.2565179765,
0.0024590851,
0.141137436,
-0.1037360057,
0.3852007091,
0.6840063334,
-0.8834516406,
-0.3181106448,
0.1668109894,
-0.6564244032,
-0.1787837595,
0.0257065836,
-0.4625178874,
0.0871802792,
0.1959322244,
-0.7889592648,
0.5304261446,
0.3499931991,
-0.5105025172,
0.5314139128,
0.0592166856,
0.5102398396,
-1.2209807634,
0.1582499295,
-0.0092071742,
-0.011921864,
-0.6645162702,
-0.5258514881,
-0.3167648017,
-0.47185269,
-0.459916383,
0.5535407662,
-0.0192399956,
-0.1573957354,
-0.389135927,
0.2256743014,
-0.0653994605,
0.8501873016,
-0.0232542846,
0.6485966444,
0.4414839745,
-0.6074047089,
0.8797952533,
0.7579526901,
0.1168874279,
1.0009875298,
-0.4975241125,
0.5439130664,
-0.0735226497,
0.1894633323,
-0.9697973728,
-0.0186376572,
0.3305704296,
-0.4613381624,
0.2245008051,
0.2690023482,
-0.0800722316,
-0.2990002334,
0.0183053073,
0.0875786394,
0.6657033563,
-0.4650828838,
0.8470103145,
0.2564966381,
-0.7849526405,
0.0040652659,
-0.4834953845,
0.1424259841,
-0.4421350658,
-0.809312582,
0.5578607321,
-0.2532657385,
-0.3100630343,
0.0804951563,
0.3319227695,
0.1650497168,
-0.1611264646,
0.3552685678,
0.5428696871,
-0.2254150212,
0.1981439143,
0.0229721013,
0.2601760328,
0.182031855,
0.2121697515,
0.5458595753,
-0.361535728,
-0.2324123234,
-0.6600766182,
0.4162046015,
1.1132068634,
-0.3825163841,
0.5193620324,
0.5589960217,
-0.1662289798,
-0.204309538,
-0.2747763097,
-0.3651487827,
-0.4641297162,
0.3192552328,
-0.4073539376,
-0.5003657937,
0.684589684,
-0.1563579738,
-0.1610271931,
0.2750194967,
0.6090334058,
0.0831461847,
1.114710331,
0.4290539622,
-0.1342010051,
0.7665424347,
-0.0175545793,
0.3226195276,
-0.7788300514,
-0.5243079662,
-0.312481612,
-0.4558549225,
-0.3352321386,
0.0028762193,
0.3544274569,
-0.448351264,
-0.4235884249,
0.1898695529,
-0.6604706049,
-0.2757845819,
0.532438159,
0.3607570231,
-0.1213168576,
0.0195129812,
0.3190182745,
-0.0356602855,
0.0568822362,
-0.5815100074,
0.6692451239,
0.0750907063,
0.698574245,
0.5700109005,
0.4384102821,
0.5206958652,
0.221855253,
-0.9482802153,
0.7081689239,
-0.2883550525,
-0.3505042791,
-0.5873470306,
-0.2145870477,
-0.4535179734,
0.1449505836,
-0.6048616171,
-1.122410059,
0.3770828545,
0.146192044,
-0.3040581048,
0.2028191239,
-0.6829122901,
0.5677728057,
-0.3421052396,
-0.2130357623,
-0.2773456275,
-0.8413866162,
0.270629853,
0.0892248675,
0.0994825512,
-0.201572597,
0.5201925039,
0.5873017907,
-0.396173656,
0.6783920527,
-0.2277975082,
0.1996816844,
0.3670850098,
0.4174891114,
0.4135758877,
-0.1992802024,
-0.3571961224,
0.0440855846,
0.0094622979,
0.0790268555,
-1.0214942694,
0.4298906922,
-0.9510217309,
-0.499556154,
0.1327178031,
-0.2790659964,
-0.4782294631,
0.0028800345,
-0.0398109332,
0.4629514813,
-0.4305282533,
0.0259863138,
0.4624286294,
-0.2609712481,
0.2984027565,
0.6053669453,
-0.2181174606,
-0.1853319854,
1.1492804289,
-0.2111195624,
0.2916800678,
0.2112990916,
0.3274959028,
-0.127027452,
0.1086995453,
-0.5895453691,
0.1028287411,
-0.4421312511,
-0.2134390473,
-0.7115597129,
-0.3794164956,
-0.6999124885,
-0.2739278376,
-0.3474253714,
-0.0805049166,
-0.5249795318,
0.000034476,
0.7934785485,
0.6353649497,
0.1666311175,
0.3956511617,
-0.5540727973,
0.5226273537,
0.6555736661,
0.1396064758,
-0.0002517414,
-0.5190056562,
0.087872453,
0.0538891666,
-0.1543047726,
-1.0961221457,
0.82405442,
0.4073494971,
0.2662830651,
0.5085659623,
0.1582947671,
0.3791445494,
-0.3956646621,
0.6480131149,
0.064872466,
-1.0642629862,
0.5207756162,
-0.1867561489,
0.0467062593,
0.3165165186,
0.0829114467,
-0.7374159694,
-0.295670867,
-0.6146507263,
-0.8214299679,
0.9355444312,
0.1582454294,
0.2733258903,
-0.0299067721,
0.3574049473,
-0.1853600442,
0.0958303213,
-0.3305993974,
-0.301247865,
-0.7577491999,
-0.5475744605,
0.0648874417,
-0.0132940346,
0.0671399608,
-0.0781506523,
0.8712868094,
-0.324302882,
0.5492562056,
0.2483534515,
0.3168862462,
-0.0030750984,
0.5089955926,
0.5659911036,
0.0694379061,
-0.3812626898,
0.2394115776,
0.12224444,
-0.4016149044,
0.1186265573,
0.0525537655,
0.280972302,
-0.0836075842,
-0.1512793899,
1.0923210382,
0.0521058477,
-0.559900701,
0.5916157365,
-0.1321234107,
0.1624791324,
-0.5011062622,
0.2202835977,
0.2393182218,
0.3543305397,
0.2666617632,
0.136046499,
0.5148382783,
-0.6659094095,
0.1431526691,
0.3234916329,
-0.5131557584,
-0.4194684625,
0.5353226066,
0.4446120858,
-0.952093482,
0.500946641,
-0.1114928797,
-0.6903159618,
0.8161873221,
0.7856842875,
0.8029977083,
-0.7415421009,
0.3808251023,
0.0823429525,
0.0416965969,
0.35888502,
0.3527536988,
-0.158271119,
-0.6966019869,
0.1037078872,
-0.6049910188,
-0.6283435225,
-0.0454612821,
-0.5600354075,
0.2306728065,
-0.4032153189,
-0.2323632091,
0.136027962,
-0.3088908494,
-0.8332038522,
0.5629102588,
0.4487298131,
0.3730424345,
-0.9043062329,
0.5779259205,
0.5730369091,
-0.2064309418,
-1.0947403908,
-0.2746047974,
0.2000930309,
-0.8588548303,
0.5490614176,
-0.0850124583,
-0.6332138777,
-0.0127149802,
-0.4809412062,
-0.8761286139,
1.0669720173,
0.2856116295,
-0.4715104103,
0.1371540427,
-0.0341321938,
0.7808199525,
-0.5065250993,
0.3426329792,
0.4507439435,
0.3248583674,
0.3513844311,
-0.8906238675,
0.1532697678,
-0.8818080425,
0.0945095941,
-0.161822468,
-0.8940227628,
0.6514229774,
-0.0065099178,
-0.121370621,
-0.1459544897,
0.5780395269,
0.0890865847,
0.2931186259,
0.7435604334,
0.1894053817,
0.4397933185,
0.3235456944,
0.8404099941,
-0.3335524201,
0.0023249686,
0.7593771815,
-0.4846779108,
0.9158666134,
0.1727204472,
-0.1732853502,
0.7104780078,
0.3351635337,
0.3354690671,
0.3780828714,
0.311383158,
-0.6008561254,
-0.0298320223,
-0.1694287509,
-0.1405536532,
0.8246945739,
0.5582242012,
-0.1534366012,
0.4452122152,
0.4545787573,
0.0602096282,
0.0107141919,
0.0409857631,
1.1544264555,
-0.00237469,
-0.7146694064,
0.2391757667,
-0.156370312,
0.8700073957,
-0.6000959277,
-0.2735741735,
-0.2280444801,
-0.0818258375,
-0.2687129974,
-0.5810479522,
0.2173286378,
-0.1958168298,
0.0019934964,
0.0706205294,
0.7731835842,
-0.627004981,
-0.3063935935,
0.4450809956,
0.1530768871,
0.3392974436,
0.0825714469,
-0.5575146675,
0.0718042776,
-0.0241803415,
-0.3739950061,
-0.0557253696,
0.5171684623,
-0.0206835903,
0.6823154688,
0.5002683997,
0.0950657874,
-0.1726566255,
0.2215964198,
0.703854084,
-0.7289477587,
-0.6915376782,
-0.6444836855,
0.4080396891,
-0.1144546047,
-0.2043329924,
0.2933180332,
-0.0128110666,
0.0456894413,
0.0972416028,
0.7724609971,
-0.1919165254,
0.5004847646,
-0.2787949443,
0.7494874597,
-0.4849966764,
-0.110734731,
-0.8311709762,
-0.7333257198,
0.073617585,
0.6469159126,
-0.0122833811,
0.0354992449,
0.252225399,
0.7315241098,
-0.0617385209,
0.2359340489,
0.3686622083,
0.0612685606,
0.4292958379,
0.4039695859,
0.4414204061,
0.0712103695,
0.3693538904,
-0.2807129025,
-0.5550200343,
-0.6129099727,
-0.3352552652,
-0.5804770589,
-0.7713342905,
-0.2079176158,
-0.3728681803,
0.1059079394,
0.9959253073,
0.7762854099,
-0.4640855193,
-0.0374284871,
0.2188187093,
-0.1686834395,
-0.0252900477,
-0.3617400825,
0.3685182035,
-0.0231717713,
-0.8512377739,
0.4489421248,
0.4512435496,
0.2964725494,
-0.2859246135,
-0.0843185857,
0.0985981673,
0.560829401,
0.7208719254,
0.4407260716,
-0.5983298421,
-0.6551055312,
0.0480784923,
-0.3124890924,
0.0522096753,
0.469550252,
-0.4889184535,
0.7432563901,
0.0523600318,
0.6377635002,
0.5623804331,
0.1233798862,
0.4432236552,
-0.3774656951,
0.1676288247,
0.3174659014,
0.227704227,
0.5085501075,
-0.8774110675,
0.1520413905,
0.081515871,
-0.6044858098,
-0.2453796864,
0.1210835725,
-1.3775440454,
-0.0038258771,
1.1250194311,
0.0049777543,
-0.3769987226,
0.0806548446,
-0.7701197863,
0.469625771,
-0.5847895145,
0.9632082582,
0.3252441287,
-0.6464193463,
-0.0357914604,
-0.1059378162,
0.3850060999,
0.522489965,
-1.1958054304,
-0.2138703465,
0.4997144341,
0.1215571389,
0.4438097775,
0.7338209152,
-0.1209733337,
0.0272463113,
-0.0628804043,
0.7776632905,
0.0789905041,
-0.0808715746,
-0.1944374144,
-0.0737457499,
-0.326372683,
-0.3540821075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11053v1 | A Comparison of Semi-Supervised Learning Techniques for Streaming ASR at Scale | 2023-04-19T18:09:27 | 2023-04-19T18:09:27 | Cal Peyser, Michael Picheny, Kyunghyun Cho, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Ronny Huang, Tara Sainath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Unpaired text and audio injection have emerged as dominant methods for
improving ASR performance in the absence of a large labeled corpus. However,
little guidance exists on deploying these methods to improve production ASR
systems that are trained on very large supervised corpora and with realistic
requirements like a constrained model size and CPU budget, streaming
capability, and a rich lattice for rescoring and for downstream NLU tasks. In
this work, we compare three state-of-the-art semi-supervised methods
encompassing both unpaired text and audio as well as several of their
combinations in a controlled setting using joint training. We find that in our
setting these methods offer many improvements beyond raw WER, including
substantial gains in tail-word WER, decoder computation during inference, and
lattice density. | [
-0.1813660264,
-0.4785426259,
0.1594264805,
0.0060153604,
-0.3520701528,
0.6069655418,
-0.5844948292,
-0.4370006323,
0.0656041577,
0.5622470379,
0.046443399,
-0.3177187145,
-0.5799429417,
0.2029089481,
-0.943783164,
0.7125734091,
0.1561395675,
0.1982565373,
-0.2460272461,
0.0200005304,
-0.189710632,
-0.4989250302,
-0.9649065137,
-0.448068589,
0.1885636747,
0.0890742764,
0.5892396569,
0.4956932068,
0.4242515266,
0.39624089,
-0.2503976822,
0.2342231274,
-0.0768552572,
-0.1414424181,
-0.0742273256,
-0.0439616852,
-0.0035535938,
-0.2126925141,
0.7502295971,
0.8579924107,
-0.3423858881,
0.294840008,
0.263441056,
0.5795927048,
-1.0351424217,
-0.0196995027,
-0.2475019544,
0.4271472692,
-0.2917838991,
-0.3508749604,
-0.6629159451,
0.0953307822,
0.0353330374,
-0.7150364518,
0.3223085701,
0.0528327003,
0.7973123789,
0.6420962811,
-0.5185276866,
-0.291139096,
-1.1965857744,
0.8305903077,
-0.6120586991,
0.656834662,
0.2885432541,
0.2160969228,
0.0571293347,
-0.828677237,
-0.3464936316,
0.1051534936,
-0.1690366119,
0.4110687375,
-0.511691153,
0.2824905813,
0.3303827047,
0.6143796444,
-0.3063951433,
0.397315681,
-0.5549196005,
-0.3968549073,
0.6653934121,
-0.1814198494,
0.2315685153,
-0.0278888997,
-0.3884264231,
-0.3534416556,
-0.4080357254,
-0.0283028614,
0.2192715704,
0.463175267,
-0.0265206229,
0.5601306558,
-0.1601718515,
0.8279930353,
0.1494270116,
-0.1174760759,
0.1553372741,
-0.1367157847,
-0.3536501229,
0.3682132959,
1.0122537613,
0.1708817631,
0.140254885,
-0.421281904,
-0.3618731201,
0.4406181574,
0.2505521476,
-0.3884309828,
-0.4237783551,
0.1808023453,
-0.2930212617,
-0.0349991284,
-0.0666090548,
-0.742862165,
-0.4584925473,
-0.5065227747,
0.69140172,
-0.2163202763,
-0.19785586,
0.0578876399,
-0.5872046947,
-0.0675147697,
0.1384007037,
-0.9147982001,
0.6521507502,
0.3435038626,
0.8048985004,
-0.3609989285,
0.2183185667,
-1.0185786486,
0.3069742918,
-0.5053714514,
0.9782868028,
-0.4902088344,
-0.2963225245,
0.3979639709,
-0.4493848681,
0.1135656163,
-0.8225586414,
0.4984295666,
-0.5764107108,
-0.1041578725,
0.0796949789,
-0.4982110858,
0.0763547719,
-0.2654713094,
-0.5569280982,
1.0178905725,
-0.0645853356,
-0.7992576361,
0.5691381097,
-0.5603837967,
-0.7791979313,
0.0607751943,
-0.2329779118,
-0.3290147185,
0.1161412522,
0.2338338792,
0.6503994465,
-0.0197117329,
0.220201984,
0.1028577015,
-0.561367929,
0.3345506787,
-0.4151495993,
0.4360657036,
0.2705689669,
-0.2916525602,
0.2618157268,
-1.0361053944,
0.0016631227,
-0.3555845618,
-0.6776509881,
-0.258415997,
0.0610389225,
0.5252223611,
-0.3837111294,
-0.2021422833,
-0.788184762,
-0.4262997806,
-0.3490869701,
0.5743532777,
0.3459007144,
0.028182961,
0.6599335074,
0.0216160025,
0.2307623923,
-0.165720731,
-0.1320785731,
0.3858009577,
0.1471096128,
-0.6252626181,
-0.610029459,
0.7117136121,
0.3343631625,
-1.0867511034,
0.1988585144,
-0.0392013341,
-0.2103607059,
-0.6613640189,
0.2206801027,
0.7268974781,
0.156672731,
0.7284778357,
-0.3095320463,
-0.5663645267,
-0.7002177835,
-0.2737345695,
0.1001570001,
-0.6886672974,
0.0042626932,
-0.247050032,
0.1180668771,
0.6615978479,
-0.2530592978,
-0.6139295697,
-0.362447679,
0.3894686401,
-0.0427474864,
0.3117285967,
-0.0296495073,
-0.7745614648,
-0.6894749999,
0.1138322577,
-0.7124881744,
-0.0782203674,
-0.1599047184,
0.4129319489,
0.3932924271,
0.7841739058,
-0.1884592623,
0.6366094351,
0.5789505839,
-0.0492743142,
-0.0510657914,
-0.6298313737,
0.1466012448,
-0.8260421753,
-0.2151771486,
0.1909950674,
-0.3009101152,
-0.9001817107,
-0.3248690367,
0.2050580978,
-0.052141808,
-0.5635287166,
0.0886504352,
-1.0014300346,
-0.4586004913,
-0.4031567872,
0.1743479222,
-0.1515915245,
0.2024735808,
0.3848317862,
0.9330849051,
0.5896325111,
-0.7711260319,
0.3172459602,
0.3776571453,
-0.4996049106,
-0.0093777748,
-0.6284357905,
0.0375954658,
0.0703039393,
0.2861537933,
-0.8059381843,
-0.1656412631,
-0.359115541,
-0.4845578372,
1.0848733187,
-0.07849399,
-0.7455121875,
-0.2642019987,
-0.1785739213,
0.0619311333,
0.8212503791,
-0.7091907263,
0.5428672433,
0.5397188663,
0.3501375914,
-0.5601887703,
-0.9178686142,
0.0092519633,
-0.3263134658,
-0.1078272536,
0.3876590431,
0.3799953461,
-0.2904050648,
-0.2083685249,
-0.4081276059,
0.0000487837,
-0.1745888889,
0.1545408815,
0.1907433122,
-0.0886920616,
0.0721995607,
0.2394085377,
-0.2052899301,
-0.0373457447,
-0.0961009786,
0.2272179276,
0.3823692501,
-0.2115609199,
-0.7287232876,
0.3011996448,
0.1336907148,
-0.3424310982,
0.6035778522,
0.678078413,
-0.12784715,
-0.3057713807,
-0.569224596,
-0.1891915202,
-0.4871310294,
-0.0845929608,
-0.0481870286,
-1.0529309511,
0.1354635656,
-0.1583731174,
0.116485171,
0.251596421,
0.2540961504,
-0.2808763385,
0.8502616882,
0.5932924747,
0.1458167434,
0.4756191969,
-0.5082736611,
0.1662285924,
-1.1030868292,
-0.0438750908,
-0.4645690918,
-0.3429208994,
-0.69622612,
-0.5297743082,
0.368853271,
-0.1042259261,
-0.2076610178,
0.3647514582,
-0.6885982752,
0.4086675942,
0.5556421876,
0.0692024156,
0.5139613748,
0.1513329744,
0.1690822542,
0.1268917918,
-0.8253014088,
-0.3849202991,
1.1046375036,
0.1250433922,
0.8741884828,
0.1044542342,
0.4287422299,
0.5833387375,
0.0475737117,
-0.6887634397,
0.4005619884,
-0.5845674872,
-0.628405869,
-0.6092691422,
-0.4218240976,
-0.9684625864,
0.2945051193,
-0.5412493348,
-0.9154531956,
0.1793980002,
0.3220671713,
-0.5482494235,
0.4497765303,
-0.8287870288,
0.5052413344,
0.159879148,
-0.4628926516,
-0.0558437742,
-0.878693819,
-0.1772994846,
-0.1585292816,
0.1548451334,
0.1584836543,
-0.1518758833,
0.9515687823,
-0.3384717703,
0.8071096539,
-0.2424208522,
0.3080911636,
0.4803530872,
-0.2463810593,
0.1445446014,
-0.0725561008,
0.2297469079,
0.2268550396,
0.2569507957,
-0.2650574446,
-0.3940673769,
0.4060759246,
-0.9840472937,
-0.4130984545,
-0.4946602583,
-0.6045200229,
-0.4740063846,
0.0596140251,
0.4763902426,
0.9999284744,
0.06324967,
0.5652019382,
0.9767556787,
-0.3142912984,
0.7472686172,
0.3589642048,
-0.0297127254,
-0.2283218503,
0.6186178923,
0.2433170676,
0.5734686255,
0.838234365,
0.1289169937,
-0.5126801133,
-0.7432504296,
-0.5383380651,
0.1196082085,
-0.3016981184,
-0.4965186417,
-0.8716480732,
-0.2888487577,
-0.423219502,
-0.1895037293,
-0.6777278781,
-0.3321896493,
-0.2618894875,
-0.1245694086,
0.5071270466,
0.4120104015,
-0.2856764495,
0.4497026205,
-0.6604416966,
0.3992261887,
0.1741119921,
0.0421384461,
-0.0814205781,
-0.8544849753,
-0.1470243782,
-0.0785367414,
-0.1223571301,
-0.5342844129,
0.307464391,
0.2825557888,
0.272991538,
0.5650051236,
0.5623376369,
0.715252161,
-0.6480512619,
0.60273844,
0.2011241466,
-0.8493340015,
0.4452035725,
-0.1163387373,
0.2933336496,
0.5683615208,
0.3855668902,
-0.1625471115,
-0.5328315496,
-0.4630980194,
-0.7639326453,
0.6813087463,
0.249937579,
0.1125128269,
0.1715960354,
-0.0118925152,
-0.1970121413,
0.135458082,
-0.1473297626,
-0.1221026257,
-0.0142022101,
0.0801465735,
-0.3864713013,
0.0063703833,
-0.0582272038,
-0.2831843197,
0.8277305961,
-0.0308074225,
0.2284546345,
0.1993119568,
0.0620004535,
-0.2921645939,
0.3147910833,
0.0280072261,
0.4420739412,
-0.2641234696,
0.3063424826,
0.3885516226,
-0.4082978368,
0.0261588395,
0.030397011,
-0.1416602731,
0.1435726285,
0.4180153012,
0.7310838103,
0.5843775272,
-0.74177742,
0.4786117375,
-0.071534425,
-0.3286740482,
-0.4967686534,
0.0185937174,
0.222174421,
0.3278104067,
0.1755316108,
-0.1173843443,
0.529638648,
-0.6810573936,
0.0262561161,
0.3132446408,
-0.5879650116,
0.0791674554,
0.845844686,
0.0300897472,
-0.3397037685,
0.7549782395,
0.0609159842,
-0.1138521954,
0.1505169719,
0.7546964288,
0.42364797,
-0.1504897922,
0.1994910389,
0.3002998531,
0.0375195257,
-0.1205378026,
-0.0796776786,
-0.6112463474,
-0.7315092683,
-0.5913847089,
-0.7323705554,
-0.3936608434,
-0.0915892348,
-1.1960297823,
0.1134295017,
-0.3904037476,
-0.1173737347,
0.4719438553,
0.0677067116,
-0.2243933529,
0.1919578612,
0.0894454196,
0.9600068927,
-1.066608429,
0.7500997186,
1.0716059208,
-0.2416507751,
-1.1176527739,
0.0418495759,
0.0650342032,
-0.3165051639,
0.2064045817,
-0.0796508119,
-0.2114281654,
0.0131311035,
-0.2321860641,
-0.7252355814,
1.0157319307,
-0.0282238293,
-0.4158001244,
0.3012934029,
-0.0416435413,
0.9314086437,
0.1633935124,
0.1426264197,
0.5382125378,
0.0472751819,
0.6310669184,
-0.9658737779,
-0.3073862791,
0.0759381503,
0.1051287651,
0.6536693573,
-0.7071279883,
0.0540098064,
0.0586576611,
-0.4715537131,
-0.2407582402,
1.0888411999,
0.041617047,
0.6099918485,
0.6706217527,
0.359146595,
0.531309545,
-0.0079989396,
1.1375054121,
0.337882936,
0.1815239936,
1.0310542583,
-0.3076627553,
1.2730107307,
0.6219905615,
-0.4184424579,
-0.0098958351,
0.5385421515,
0.1586409062,
0.6787384152,
0.2375999838,
-0.4395415485,
-0.3878054917,
-0.4517394006,
-0.0232158713,
0.5103715658,
0.2926595807,
0.0501902588,
0.1084718034,
0.4189399481,
0.1100037545,
0.6540355682,
-0.4877940118,
1.0778981447,
0.1643824279,
-0.4151810706,
0.5404666066,
-0.2402486652,
0.8343670368,
-0.3374160528,
0.2516388297,
-0.2381822914,
0.4048527479,
-0.3278030157,
-0.5647109151,
0.5111632943,
0.5062742233,
0.0043019131,
-0.3504746556,
0.7836652994,
-0.3510585129,
-0.3380637169,
0.4800377786,
0.154928714,
0.3960285187,
0.0311575346,
-0.1392498165,
0.1408084482,
-0.0265856311,
-0.0563349761,
0.512581408,
0.2950291634,
-0.0549078099,
0.4631551802,
0.5596171021,
0.2371669859,
0.1841462702,
0.2144934088,
0.9480377436,
-0.1689218581,
-0.2267733067,
-0.3683465719,
0.3721832335,
-0.2611696422,
0.1614698768,
0.645961225,
0.8613985181,
1.1691551208,
-0.0621252619,
0.4125280678,
-0.1135699004,
0.9168311954,
-0.637514174,
0.5969323516,
-0.6328519583,
0.151300326,
-0.2436507791,
-0.8195582032,
-0.5635729432,
0.4904539883,
-0.1029715091,
-0.2526097298,
0.8228418827,
0.5603114963,
-0.2739759684,
0.1189048514,
0.5350624323,
0.1333270371,
-0.1471815556,
0.1889400929,
0.9301095605,
-0.4328457117,
0.5436338186,
-0.4377147555,
-0.3712633848,
0.2123886943,
-0.5335814953,
-1.0953855515,
-0.5751705766,
-0.6445978284,
0.0083983904,
0.2033385336,
0.7719903588,
0.6168366075,
-0.8908899426,
-0.3710986972,
0.1949713826,
-0.4399776757,
-0.3715036511,
-0.1080837324,
0.4156647623,
-0.0987148285,
-0.7618982196,
0.6316415071,
0.3072050512,
-0.2312979698,
0.0043259938,
0.1451877505,
-0.3724678159,
0.0847507864,
0.4607251883,
0.410300076,
-0.5843584538,
-0.4168528616,
-0.2946451902,
0.1913357377,
0.0591701381,
0.6436353922,
-0.6212260127,
0.3704501987,
0.3704166412,
0.7977510691,
0.9882531762,
0.2254066467,
0.2106760144,
-0.8449331522,
0.0395203866,
0.1191650704,
0.0846121758,
0.421713382,
-0.3281953037,
0.596421659,
-0.1347960234,
-0.6516560912,
-0.7903785706,
-0.2765418291,
-1.2243939638,
-0.0758379996,
1.3049778938,
0.0316891521,
-0.0835348368,
-0.1243268773,
0.1945158839,
0.7933221459,
-0.479514122,
0.5588536859,
0.2356159091,
-0.2328778803,
-0.0862357691,
-0.8493444324,
0.3921375275,
0.318754524,
-0.6146557331,
0.1023847982,
0.567690134,
0.0007729178,
0.2444742322,
0.4809539616,
-0.2018593252,
-0.0001225939,
0.103032358,
0.17940557,
0.0173251946,
-0.4810690582,
-0.3311961293,
-0.043331515,
-0.0775310695,
-0.476959914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09848v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09848v2 | Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines | 2023-04-19T17:56:12 | 2023-10-23T19:11:38 | Nelson F. Liu, Tianyi Zhang, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Generative search engines directly generate responses to user queries, along
with in-line citations. A prerequisite trait of a trustworthy generative search
engine is verifiability, i.e., systems should cite comprehensively (high
citation recall; all statements are fully supported by citations) and
accurately (high citation precision; every cite supports its associated
statement). We conduct human evaluation to audit four popular generative search
engines -- Bing Chat, NeevaAI, perplexity.ai, and YouChat -- across a diverse
set of queries from a variety of sources (e.g., historical Google user queries,
dynamically-collected open-ended questions on Reddit, etc.). We find that
responses from existing generative search engines are fluent and appear
informative, but frequently contain unsupported statements and inaccurate
citations: on average, a mere 51.5% of generated sentences are fully supported
by citations and only 74.5% of citations support their associated sentence. We
believe that these results are concerningly low for systems that may serve as a
primary tool for information-seeking users, especially given their facade of
trustworthiness. We hope that our results further motivate the development of
trustworthy generative search engines and help researchers and users better
understand the shortcomings of existing commercial systems. | [
-0.3366157711,
-0.5737659931,
0.8316350579,
0.4446512759,
-0.0355595611,
0.2385991961,
-0.0463448577,
-0.4872795641,
0.220642522,
0.0806071907,
-0.1889705807,
-0.2319734395,
-0.3808050454,
0.3719439805,
-0.7924200892,
0.7704773545,
0.1443598121,
-0.2098499388,
-0.6045033932,
-0.0888139307,
-0.3185631335,
-0.6517076492,
-0.4608669281,
-0.2022745311,
0.3902717233,
0.2089972794,
0.8501344919,
0.2156340778,
0.4627973735,
0.3029608727,
-0.0448837429,
0.2089059055,
-0.647729218,
0.4053331017,
-0.210744217,
-0.5054671764,
-0.1188621894,
-0.0016796408,
0.3667347133,
0.3294063509,
-0.1516397595,
0.0535946451,
0.3168613017,
0.5132847428,
-0.9064700007,
0.0566310287,
-0.8155367374,
0.0646209195,
-0.3628735542,
-0.3568086326,
-0.4982546568,
-0.6582458019,
0.2552127242,
-0.7877850533,
0.393178463,
0.0138215274,
1.1063570976,
0.2400011271,
-0.2636603117,
-0.4059696198,
-0.8491609097,
0.5183300376,
-0.4383883774,
0.048757378,
0.5862209201,
0.411960125,
-0.3061689734,
-1.0252842903,
-0.681456387,
-0.3182044923,
-0.191048637,
0.3085760772,
-0.4885010123,
-0.0848615468,
0.404011786,
0.5441870689,
-0.7566486001,
-0.0466411263,
-0.1382233799,
-0.4340321124,
0.5417756438,
0.0374811701,
0.3317932785,
-0.1984670013,
-0.4220595956,
-0.1924023926,
-0.7080260515,
-0.2384174168,
0.3169659078,
-0.2359819412,
0.2471667081,
0.8047403693,
-0.3727478087,
0.4758987427,
0.1018261611,
0.3311623037,
0.1899321824,
-0.8092234135,
-0.2953962684,
-0.0835642293,
0.8019011021,
0.3249436319,
0.4001477361,
-0.4590181112,
-0.212805301,
0.3443005085,
0.6465501785,
-0.7138698101,
-0.0581194758,
0.2353546917,
-0.3711640835,
-0.3064740598,
0.2027874589,
-0.5412545204,
-0.4984044433,
-0.0144866835,
0.5394817591,
-0.4607819319,
-0.0458321273,
-0.1397976875,
-0.4041127264,
0.2103441358,
0.4851010144,
-0.5219326019,
-0.0775483996,
0.5687353611,
0.8854849935,
-0.0789611861,
-0.405700475,
-0.5558131933,
-0.1095962375,
-0.0615074374,
0.8764082789,
-0.4824052453,
-0.6658487916,
0.1958209127,
-0.0848779976,
-0.0905385539,
-0.565541923,
0.9490160346,
-0.8722172379,
0.1297690272,
-0.4381488264,
-0.6764013767,
0.0023419941,
0.3708818257,
-0.606764555,
0.7730109096,
-0.076420635,
-0.7750447392,
0.5669038296,
-0.4927122295,
-0.4292224348,
0.3607996404,
-0.3281089664,
-0.2690755427,
0.3346995711,
0.0329413936,
0.1214140356,
-0.5092228055,
0.2637331188,
-0.4711986184,
-0.5436997414,
0.5539204478,
-0.7456220388,
1.0615257025,
0.4183493257,
-0.3536975384,
0.1267922521,
-0.7254161835,
0.2451458275,
0.1574850231,
-0.4411549568,
-0.3491236866,
0.0267137364,
0.176623866,
-0.090704985,
0.3958226144,
-0.5338419676,
0.0263253488,
-0.2664749622,
0.4624662399,
0.7482524514,
0.0591100603,
-0.0571734048,
-0.2025169879,
0.5325582027,
-0.2760801911,
0.0964996964,
-0.0458654314,
-0.6820175648,
-0.5843374729,
-0.0708580837,
0.2992874384,
0.5058997273,
-0.6473330259,
0.6528603435,
-0.4238519669,
-0.47865358,
-0.3676334023,
0.0589023419,
0.3738979697,
0.4602323174,
0.1162457094,
-0.2861283123,
-0.5188702345,
-0.965518713,
-0.3866749704,
-0.5061981678,
-0.4532867074,
0.2148341537,
0.6976640224,
-0.333958298,
1.0169402361,
-0.2709938288,
0.1777113378,
0.2886089087,
0.4891889989,
-0.2320256829,
0.1752406359,
0.6048212051,
-1.0717234612,
-0.5895904899,
0.0710887089,
-0.9876846671,
0.1097757593,
0.0741625503,
-0.12114048,
0.0690837726,
-0.0269986764,
-0.6350635886,
0.73828578,
0.3962437212,
-0.4499198198,
0.5070829391,
-0.3522827923,
0.3255847991,
-0.8212498426,
0.3176390231,
-0.0520877577,
-0.2970338464,
-0.2621316314,
0.0886451155,
0.0638251305,
-0.0305287242,
0.0803133473,
0.2088513076,
-0.2964192629,
-0.1633212268,
-0.264760375,
0.2092843503,
0.1013193056,
0.0102763707,
-0.3672345281,
1.2131243944,
0.3589664102,
-0.5828288794,
0.3542313278,
0.3013628721,
-0.5747227073,
0.7911474705,
-0.9740380049,
0.3049509227,
0.0279805791,
0.2830806077,
-1.0865758657,
-0.5555989742,
0.0157275237,
-0.7739940286,
-0.1075187698,
-0.0434353687,
-0.8087999821,
-0.1654109359,
-0.3027670383,
0.0818613768,
0.400734961,
-0.6913659573,
0.4987327754,
0.2839502096,
0.047584448,
-0.6204283834,
-0.2666320801,
0.3833348751,
-0.1168982685,
-0.911396265,
0.3464319408,
-0.1373395175,
-0.2399526685,
0.1616969705,
-0.162529543,
-0.2161506712,
0.381799221,
0.3283121884,
0.3608956337,
-0.0661422536,
0.0887987316,
-0.1724568158,
0.0561598018,
0.0371471271,
-0.0353250764,
0.516187489,
-0.4614186883,
-0.4615172148,
-0.4243023098,
0.1610465497,
0.9820486903,
-0.2492415607,
0.59454602,
0.6697733402,
-0.3356336057,
0.3097602427,
-0.6322825551,
-0.1395804733,
-0.4222934544,
0.0913708881,
-0.3617748618,
-0.8841353655,
0.6749361753,
0.3232351243,
-0.0584185384,
0.6633549929,
0.4035282731,
-0.2077458203,
1.1974009275,
0.0895004421,
-0.003651513,
0.086977914,
0.2256072909,
0.0880420059,
-0.4948791265,
-0.2433357537,
-0.9466760159,
-0.0903804228,
-0.9816112518,
-0.0790310726,
0.3194170594,
-0.0053479634,
-0.1268513799,
0.2814898491,
-0.4000721574,
0.1914039105,
0.7573068142,
-0.0872715935,
0.4499429166,
0.2916025817,
-0.0101609034,
-0.0082136653,
-0.3476648033,
-0.7430098653,
1.2235101461,
0.005874523,
0.8025538921,
0.2682157755,
0.5475329161,
0.6685510278,
0.2706061602,
-0.4831876159,
0.3360763788,
0.0626372471,
-0.933912158,
-0.3348584473,
-0.4099981785,
-0.8307740092,
0.1560096443,
-0.1980067492,
-0.7227305174,
0.2796283662,
0.2281180471,
-0.2265317142,
-0.1575675756,
-0.7553012371,
0.6225649118,
-0.269757092,
-0.4149034619,
-0.3069025576,
-0.5757763386,
0.1855216175,
-0.0918107331,
-0.3646301925,
0.2755447626,
0.2545056045,
0.5675771236,
-0.5065358877,
0.6422206163,
-0.1247604266,
0.09018033,
0.294819504,
-0.0682095736,
0.6816716194,
0.2103523463,
-0.0033243108,
0.0539602935,
0.0789139122,
-0.4699020982,
-0.8389884233,
0.8541363478,
-0.636749804,
-0.642048955,
-0.560418129,
0.0813355967,
-0.2625627816,
0.1662537009,
0.6203921437,
-0.0907211602,
-0.4922008514,
0.5339238644,
0.7815079689,
-0.0304990839,
-0.0143700559,
0.1719559431,
-0.0697037354,
-0.2975798249,
0.7778307796,
-0.1287626922,
0.1549725533,
0.1943192482,
0.0147975236,
-0.3961233795,
-0.449424684,
-0.4589582086,
0.0594986267,
-0.6240131855,
-0.0469640419,
-0.5370222926,
-0.3136536181,
-0.2590492368,
0.1368835419,
-0.2758817077,
-0.3263476193,
-0.1849439293,
-0.05140616,
-0.0174036324,
0.6173930764,
0.2305545211,
0.0104853846,
-0.6082740426,
0.0543992668,
0.5823953152,
0.193871513,
-0.2000131309,
-0.5155623555,
-0.0559674948,
0.0791306868,
-0.3418060541,
-0.7469243407,
-0.097790733,
0.109130539,
0.5592579246,
0.6157821417,
0.0623538345,
0.7164453864,
-0.2443295121,
0.7570748925,
0.1179846525,
-0.8433732986,
0.639197588,
-0.0110187149,
-0.0122350445,
0.8595793843,
0.4260764718,
-0.3058038652,
-0.2581294477,
-0.5640391111,
-0.5641886592,
0.1689384878,
0.8618732095,
0.1580274999,
0.0485543199,
0.3465162516,
-0.0088604502,
0.2281132787,
-0.4203623235,
-0.3657220602,
-0.5114817023,
0.1233226731,
0.1462551504,
-0.5485633016,
-0.2003126144,
0.0697267205,
0.4912645519,
-0.065528363,
0.3802837133,
0.2140333951,
-0.0634444654,
0.1388481706,
0.4985223413,
0.6523063183,
0.9891650081,
-0.352943331,
0.1589523405,
-0.2667616606,
-0.4850996733,
0.0924648419,
0.1653401107,
-0.5890985131,
0.063067019,
0.2564501166,
0.6395170689,
0.0041595418,
-0.6241414547,
0.5702153444,
-0.497887969,
0.0540153272,
-0.7227160931,
0.168067053,
0.0332269147,
-0.0119814686,
0.5477554798,
0.2750012875,
0.3202599287,
-0.4280009866,
-0.109984301,
0.5392441154,
-0.2774476409,
-0.5614181161,
0.7165424824,
0.2129125446,
-0.2296344489,
0.9533181787,
-0.1029484943,
-0.3663910627,
0.3152112067,
0.4287203252,
1.2264130116,
0.0148916375,
0.1961057335,
0.4311769307,
0.379281044,
-0.175361231,
0.0815336406,
-0.2416234612,
-0.77267766,
-0.3047064841,
-0.5929865241,
-0.4117274284,
0.2948909402,
-0.8422505856,
-0.1009880453,
-0.1918828785,
-0.5117462277,
0.2402667403,
-0.2445537001,
-0.7236632109,
0.1255679876,
-0.1775089055,
0.838383913,
-0.6103286743,
0.4333620071,
0.8529269695,
-0.9227212071,
-0.279314667,
0.264749378,
0.0038198989,
-0.8696940541,
0.6931915283,
0.0074216276,
-0.43837291,
-0.1177163124,
-0.8611528873,
-0.6109874845,
1.1805466413,
0.4754671454,
-0.3250904977,
-0.173375532,
-0.1387807876,
0.6565292478,
-0.1280657798,
0.2226737142,
0.2058280557,
0.5729866028,
0.1425250918,
-0.9507912397,
0.0779249296,
-0.3886640668,
0.3185602427,
-0.4415104389,
-0.2917031646,
0.3548054695,
0.0065581631,
-0.7280157804,
0.3406869173,
0.622589767,
0.3112425208,
0.5161983967,
0.5140776038,
0.5695221424,
0.9575693607,
-0.1163433269,
1.2288415432,
-0.2735788226,
0.3300989866,
1.0461119413,
-0.2883239985,
0.8969616294,
0.5674098134,
-0.3786488473,
0.4827907383,
0.3370667696,
0.0315088965,
0.2892522514,
0.0475953966,
-0.4240106344,
-0.4305844307,
-0.1061027348,
-0.3457427919,
0.4880798161,
0.2077129781,
-0.544226408,
-0.1520240605,
-0.1326340586,
-0.0623318739,
0.0626536608,
0.2893976569,
0.4998533428,
-0.2269416898,
-0.864050746,
0.6034129858,
-0.2168781608,
0.517559886,
-0.3445070684,
-0.0473701581,
-0.3776300848,
0.0410922058,
-0.3080831468,
-0.7144159675,
0.1621004045,
0.3041707277,
-0.2773569524,
0.0278121028,
0.8226985335,
0.2173952013,
-0.1923614889,
-0.0045737382,
0.5181310177,
0.1792892814,
-0.350903064,
-0.2800787389,
-0.0641524866,
0.1321308762,
-0.090797767,
0.3422022462,
0.212291345,
0.1283845603,
0.6967842579,
0.647325933,
-0.0594378859,
0.0541492514,
0.006884953,
0.723123312,
-0.4881526232,
-0.2358326912,
-0.6879191995,
0.3658911288,
-0.5676558614,
-0.2338207513,
1.1758303642,
0.6817204356,
0.899625361,
0.0062020589,
1.1292271614,
-0.1724330634,
0.2860129178,
-0.3244179487,
0.7863848805,
-0.5536395311,
0.2764351666,
-0.004995856,
-0.9702889919,
-0.0718428046,
0.5840066075,
0.0226425808,
0.0562729575,
0.4379711747,
0.7041066289,
-0.0423272699,
0.1826681644,
0.3605254591,
0.1557054818,
0.4936127663,
0.1535227299,
1.2030243874,
-0.3107790351,
0.6756159663,
-0.0484599285,
-0.2833702266,
-0.5439635515,
-0.6685769558,
-0.5408399701,
-0.5558351278,
-0.3114951551,
-0.6192279458,
0.0906255022,
0.3269191384,
0.3595598042,
-0.7544693947,
0.0242932513,
-0.328093648,
0.042506326,
-0.0499896668,
-0.2856679857,
0.1668155789,
-0.4721334875,
-0.6879780889,
0.3958410025,
0.4035880566,
0.033127971,
-0.5950114727,
-0.1193340197,
0.0448592491,
-0.0401894189,
0.5445900559,
0.6536907554,
-0.8854830861,
-0.4925720394,
0.2238728404,
-0.4360819161,
0.0457698517,
0.775336206,
-0.6565403342,
0.8567673564,
0.7310895324,
0.711835444,
0.5453759432,
0.2765827179,
0.5683976412,
-0.4247941077,
-0.489071101,
0.1426368803,
0.2912987769,
0.3446536064,
-0.2771528363,
0.6515355706,
0.2047941089,
-0.7886466384,
-0.897162199,
0.1426006258,
-0.7693731785,
0.2049019039,
0.810460031,
-0.4533661604,
0.0559460595,
-0.2100011259,
0.0458110347,
-0.0734040067,
-0.3178723156,
1.0363095999,
0.9107224941,
-0.1981905848,
0.4920358658,
-0.3287224174,
0.2587462664,
0.3654183149,
-0.7271649837,
-0.0355332904,
0.7371646166,
0.329815805,
0.7094573975,
0.4862731397,
-0.0315170065,
0.5275054574,
0.1004902422,
-0.2531936765,
0.185272038,
-0.0782589242,
-0.1844822764,
0.2965995967,
0.4128782153,
-0.2284136564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11082v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11082v6 | Fundamental Limitations of Alignment in Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T17:50:09 | 2024-06-03T12:19:16 | Yotam Wolf, Noam Wies, Oshri Avnery, Yoav Levine, Amnon Shashua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An important aspect in developing language models that interact with humans
is aligning their behavior to be useful and unharmful for their human users.
This is usually achieved by tuning the model in a way that enhances desired
behaviors and inhibits undesired ones, a process referred to as alignment. In
this paper, we propose a theoretical approach called Behavior Expectation
Bounds (BEB) which allows us to formally investigate several inherent
characteristics and limitations of alignment in large language models.
Importantly, we prove that within the limits of this framework, for any
behavior that has a finite probability of being exhibited by the model, there
exist prompts that can trigger the model into outputting this behavior, with
probability that increases with the length of the prompt. This implies that any
alignment process that attenuates an undesired behavior but does not remove it
altogether, is not safe against adversarial prompting attacks. Furthermore, our
framework hints at the mechanism by which leading alignment approaches such as
reinforcement learning from human feedback make the LLM prone to being prompted
into the undesired behaviors. This theoretical result is being experimentally
demonstrated in large scale by the so called contemporary "chatGPT jailbreaks",
where adversarial users trick the LLM into breaking its alignment guardrails by
triggering it into acting as a malicious persona. Our results expose
fundamental limitations in alignment of LLMs and bring to the forefront the
need to devise reliable mechanisms for ensuring AI safety. | [
-0.190849781,
-1.0745646954,
0.6052649617,
0.1726880968,
0.0021274774,
0.0308243874,
-0.3988839388,
-0.6110417247,
0.0080744764,
0.4573963583,
-0.729867816,
-0.1329429746,
-0.6158918142,
-0.1461401135,
-0.6360659599,
1.0828578472,
0.0825971663,
-0.1726670116,
-0.1026596949,
-0.0140797775,
-0.6041731238,
-0.5356462598,
-0.5388878584,
-0.2116616219,
0.2727703452,
0.2182878107,
0.9905872941,
0.6166425347,
0.6103445292,
0.3401215971,
-0.0840145051,
-0.064897716,
-0.4716303945,
0.232809186,
-0.0279660244,
-0.3341146111,
-0.443961978,
0.018051777,
0.6450573206,
0.5531494021,
-0.2911838591,
-0.3027146459,
0.2872067988,
0.6750351191,
-0.4316661656,
-0.1785739511,
-0.5423570871,
-0.1945776939,
-0.3737362623,
0.2546123862,
-0.5190631151,
-0.2821724713,
0.1287358403,
-0.437625736,
-0.2987926006,
0.3011564612,
1.0715713501,
0.4200488031,
-0.3750319481,
-0.3128915727,
-0.7239485383,
0.6490703225,
-0.7827475667,
0.2296558321,
0.1486537308,
0.2353287041,
-0.6939277649,
-0.0240136497,
-0.6045013666,
-0.2340182811,
0.0296822768,
-0.2736179233,
-0.3323426247,
0.3060127497,
0.5190972686,
0.0632688999,
-0.6860834956,
0.4425339997,
-0.0454481058,
-0.179010272,
0.6548172832,
0.2454148531,
0.569961071,
-0.0931291357,
-0.4458895624,
-0.1684238464,
-0.7267737985,
0.3969423473,
0.6755871177,
0.324703753,
-0.1373633742,
0.7703402042,
0.2820214927,
0.6743420362,
0.2087017149,
0.161810115,
-0.125352487,
-0.1330165714,
-0.1089666635,
0.0866107494,
0.9854839444,
0.3686098456,
0.4662893116,
-0.2373616993,
-0.2029158324,
0.1097709462,
0.3773656487,
-0.5088407397,
0.1902047545,
0.2302214801,
-0.1932506412,
-0.2089473903,
0.2169852555,
-0.8455180526,
-0.5843408704,
-0.1291875988,
0.324244231,
-0.6677275896,
-0.0925686359,
0.0192255955,
0.1939906627,
0.5204747319,
0.1357399076,
-1.2932741642,
0.4583848715,
0.886813283,
0.5115172267,
-0.1204005703,
-0.5147035718,
-0.4469193816,
0.1578134596,
-0.3214284182,
0.3033659458,
-0.5177531838,
-0.3254034817,
-0.0176146738,
-0.0931790397,
-0.0460782796,
-0.2980300784,
0.3120518923,
-0.5985228419,
-0.0792470053,
-0.2464569807,
-0.6703369021,
-0.0099960836,
0.1095035076,
-0.3837149143,
0.467268914,
-0.1669886559,
-0.4839656353,
0.174949199,
-0.3982070982,
-0.6573463678,
-0.367032975,
-0.2656281888,
-0.4406500757,
0.1153894514,
0.1639849991,
0.1571791172,
-0.215349257,
0.4324200153,
-0.4274890423,
-0.2018463761,
0.7463078499,
-0.4200830162,
0.9883281589,
0.2262968421,
-0.2439172566,
0.2254340947,
-0.4113347828,
-0.0152045675,
0.0969315767,
-0.3748524189,
-0.1616053432,
0.2850926816,
-0.3473254144,
0.0994088054,
0.4436757267,
-0.4824470282,
0.3086754382,
-0.4545981586,
0.4235700667,
1.0702416897,
-0.1769135296,
0.608297646,
-0.3429340422,
0.6529587507,
-0.1942030042,
0.2618765533,
-0.0336830691,
-0.1150613874,
-0.4489428103,
-0.1906579435,
0.2863121033,
0.6590058208,
-0.1847486943,
0.7311871648,
-0.2943860292,
-0.1559087634,
-0.3646219969,
0.1852632463,
0.5671370029,
0.1738333106,
0.0041620871,
-0.1624321193,
-0.6880154014,
-0.9540938139,
-0.2390434891,
-0.3662072718,
0.047836367,
0.0052840835,
0.3427228034,
-0.0103780981,
0.9875233769,
-0.1662349701,
-0.0333901495,
-0.1695130169,
-0.1196009517,
0.2128745764,
0.7155376077,
0.4246541858,
-0.6658856273,
-0.296865344,
-0.0165129099,
-0.7304841876,
-0.1388016641,
-0.0782343447,
-0.1385740042,
0.3771461546,
0.5997248292,
-0.7510837317,
0.5487035513,
0.6473503709,
-0.3903404474,
0.4242217839,
-0.1624452174,
0.0238384176,
-0.9076172113,
-0.0618386269,
0.1474932134,
-0.2070166767,
-0.7026052475,
0.0566775464,
0.0587815382,
-0.1277425736,
-0.137867704,
0.4091583788,
-0.2282792926,
-0.1470621079,
-0.2546270788,
0.1983587146,
-0.2453137189,
0.4255340397,
-0.0576823093,
0.4889135659,
0.3265407085,
-0.6650163531,
0.1663832814,
0.3238500059,
-0.3178334236,
0.749954164,
-0.7730016708,
-0.0366021506,
-0.0642074123,
0.1155541912,
-1.0521153212,
-0.307913065,
0.1990981698,
-0.6548490524,
0.7047535777,
-0.0712522417,
-0.5039138794,
-0.1095430478,
-0.1933032125,
0.2519031763,
0.7465749383,
-0.4490531385,
0.3175226152,
0.3997372687,
0.0253227316,
-0.8566169143,
-0.4341957569,
-0.0309408009,
-0.4725257158,
-0.9206371903,
0.1244776696,
0.0721259266,
-0.3579447865,
-0.1103156805,
-0.0221204814,
0.4407610595,
0.3593165874,
0.3103737533,
0.4720369577,
-0.0097583374,
-0.0986518338,
-0.1284558922,
0.0592277609,
0.2242683619,
-0.1870558113,
0.5068673491,
-0.1115742773,
-0.6804432869,
-0.3351750672,
0.1698403805,
0.6263023615,
-0.1136680245,
0.6903599501,
0.1876347959,
-0.4903578758,
0.0998690948,
-0.4093436599,
-0.1247299165,
-0.4966775477,
0.531142354,
-0.1345293671,
-0.9669426084,
0.7022975683,
0.3062533736,
0.2008575201,
0.073625654,
0.418548733,
-0.1472076774,
1.4732135534,
0.5332072377,
-0.1388320923,
0.496532321,
0.3801398277,
0.4394789636,
-1.1502453089,
-0.1281688511,
-0.5812026858,
-0.4605949521,
-0.8813222051,
0.0818633661,
0.1719827056,
0.303284049,
-0.4549869597,
0.4036722481,
-0.2256896198,
0.5188399553,
0.5372130871,
-0.1020780429,
-0.067553632,
-0.1913220733,
-0.1193762943,
-0.1635553092,
-0.4164242446,
-0.4881845713,
0.7970229983,
0.4975075126,
1.0968750715,
0.6174514294,
0.4390502274,
0.0667313561,
-0.0307881702,
-0.6775915623,
0.6435754895,
-0.0384305231,
-0.8707921505,
-0.7943484783,
-0.1747649312,
-1.2270313501,
0.0884904265,
-0.2339994907,
-1.4974141121,
0.0540984944,
0.2868981063,
-0.2449678481,
0.2655947208,
-0.4790931642,
0.844753921,
-0.6058650017,
-0.4928665459,
0.1358330995,
-0.8798121214,
0.372579217,
-0.0586763062,
0.2037047893,
-0.1505533755,
0.2802140117,
0.6667732596,
-0.5067299604,
0.9594390392,
-0.1746646017,
-0.1796397567,
0.2070022523,
0.1770876646,
0.8988820314,
-0.2890594304,
0.2213655859,
-0.1371831149,
-0.0077890921,
-0.4768798053,
-0.5394095182,
0.4125336409,
-0.7342385054,
-0.9480926991,
-0.4609458447,
-0.6109896302,
-0.2858682573,
0.2059365362,
0.3593461514,
0.0838480294,
-0.4462170899,
0.0492218956,
0.647941649,
-0.3910576999,
0.4378577471,
0.4472398758,
-0.6154590845,
-0.1385878474,
0.8893810511,
0.0249328278,
0.3448455632,
0.2452557832,
0.0398842879,
-0.4129070938,
-0.7883906364,
-0.2240690589,
0.1556100696,
-0.4290802777,
0.0896312445,
-0.2352453023,
-0.1487008184,
-0.6343489885,
-0.2784031928,
-0.1479859054,
-0.1305956692,
-0.1806662679,
-0.0705777928,
0.1481410414,
0.7103288174,
-0.1758704931,
0.508235991,
-0.6209760904,
-0.1825005561,
0.1762890369,
0.1929654777,
0.096692495,
-0.6169462204,
-0.180090785,
0.0893247873,
-0.4726596177,
-0.8141762018,
0.2976289392,
-0.0866989121,
0.5670443177,
0.7256281972,
0.1965421736,
0.6572893858,
-0.6039878726,
0.6157081723,
0.2870056629,
-1.0645751953,
0.448997587,
-0.588449955,
0.112914905,
0.4425377846,
0.0750073344,
-0.7574445009,
-0.6031499505,
-0.5945132971,
-0.860046804,
0.7563844919,
0.1691606939,
0.2057223022,
-0.1535555124,
0.4108628631,
-0.0646509826,
0.10877873,
-0.6862902641,
-0.0294962451,
0.1347154677,
-0.3179762065,
-0.0412697233,
-0.238067627,
-0.0821344331,
0.0948462188,
0.8539323211,
0.0884612203,
0.1487385631,
-0.244108215,
-0.302370131,
-0.3112774193,
0.4629436135,
0.8438130021,
0.5421220064,
-0.0925791115,
-0.0764542744,
-0.0106028905,
-0.1429975629,
0.3872022927,
0.1607552767,
-0.1108176783,
-0.6695948839,
0.264452666,
0.7908542156,
0.1210176572,
-0.7952725887,
0.5056769848,
-0.131386891,
0.1376931816,
-0.4953613877,
0.2569589913,
-0.0516805835,
0.4372808635,
0.1404845119,
-0.1573083103,
-0.1912672818,
-0.4218334556,
0.1430738717,
1.007014513,
-0.4909456372,
-0.4120085835,
0.7861335278,
0.0439221635,
-0.5794258118,
0.9586210251,
-0.1197733432,
-0.585357666,
0.6889665127,
0.7115613222,
0.6123523116,
-0.2734026015,
0.0264381189,
0.1492582262,
0.5519809723,
-0.1725608706,
-0.1246099547,
0.2811078429,
-1.0112587214,
-0.5120300055,
-0.4873506725,
-0.2807920277,
0.1427567005,
-0.7363028526,
0.2856434286,
-0.5832425356,
-0.1325975955,
0.1084112599,
-0.2210292518,
-0.0885842443,
-0.2068972588,
0.1902319044,
0.5306017995,
-0.7096925378,
0.5168673992,
0.6195414066,
-0.1981601715,
-0.7834743261,
-0.0440671071,
0.5377649069,
-0.9876778722,
0.3763849139,
0.3248783052,
0.0842742175,
-0.1638523787,
-0.6979603767,
-0.9165126681,
0.6474974155,
0.5786924362,
-0.6185389161,
-0.2388136238,
0.1535420567,
0.5329598784,
-0.2701812685,
-0.2053496242,
0.6522912383,
0.5308530927,
0.0052436595,
-0.8912631869,
0.2390360087,
-0.1017917395,
-0.0262319371,
0.7493408918,
-0.6380935311,
0.6850796938,
-0.4345842302,
-0.3453347981,
0.3326085806,
0.5776519775,
0.1971004307,
-0.0263332874,
0.5217186809,
0.7923565507,
0.7620928884,
-0.1888936013,
1.1202260256,
-0.0505011007,
0.2760070264,
1.1255738735,
-0.4407738745,
0.5240557194,
0.6066348553,
-0.4317427576,
0.2004637271,
0.806245327,
-0.0213764384,
0.263073653,
0.3434161246,
-0.0664087087,
-0.2700018883,
-0.0689988881,
-0.0465019159,
0.4683772326,
0.4301628172,
-0.1833673567,
0.0317757502,
-0.1562238783,
0.2401029915,
0.1289636642,
-0.0597907566,
0.8397596478,
-0.0264402945,
-0.9871498942,
0.3267480731,
-0.1241030619,
0.6275048256,
-0.583555758,
0.2521656156,
0.0754247308,
0.0644462481,
-0.2674517632,
-0.7045678496,
0.1365708858,
-0.0850463733,
-0.0809523463,
0.2090341002,
0.375172019,
-0.2854355276,
-0.1716603786,
0.2389673293,
0.2056442052,
0.0564104393,
0.3682259321,
-0.494133532,
0.0588139705,
0.1301705688,
-0.3155165315,
0.7118674517,
0.3667530119,
-0.1536349952,
0.6802930832,
0.5492526889,
0.1202066392,
0.079547599,
-0.3470319808,
0.4442624748,
-0.4054668546,
-0.3502909839,
-1.4160288572,
0.427983731,
-0.0385517143,
-0.0455042273,
0.6225118041,
0.2423024178,
0.786264956,
0.385576129,
0.7939097285,
-0.2951915264,
0.1715099066,
-0.6492574215,
0.3608549535,
-0.3751106262,
0.6170065999,
-0.31232512,
-0.8404069543,
-0.1725488901,
0.679035306,
-0.4414769411,
0.1606537253,
0.6930416226,
0.7502676845,
0.168885693,
-0.006038548,
0.5001716018,
0.1958977133,
0.4478446543,
0.6055499911,
1.0205631256,
-0.0257699396,
0.4926707149,
-0.0905191153,
-0.2582550943,
-0.2599848509,
-0.9205173254,
-0.8846135139,
-0.5333510637,
-0.1819288731,
-0.7195014954,
0.0785315856,
1.1605409384,
0.5027036667,
-0.7148815989,
-0.2806067765,
-0.0947250649,
0.3345995545,
-0.1472790837,
-0.2093698233,
0.2478207946,
-0.2889530659,
-0.7683523893,
0.0088416617,
0.2669506371,
0.3736783862,
-0.1869521439,
-0.2942207158,
-0.2620016634,
0.0744511262,
0.1136300638,
0.8125085831,
-0.6974689364,
-0.6700717211,
0.0091009345,
-0.1342386752,
0.0849374533,
0.6227333546,
-0.2110010237,
0.2312067896,
0.2005149126,
0.7645976543,
-0.0774975866,
0.1692002416,
0.8885952234,
-0.9820770621,
0.0498825088,
0.1479111016,
0.4917132854,
0.0993383303,
-0.5220156908,
0.2350593656,
-0.3481411934,
-0.9312781692,
-0.7812747359,
0.7071734071,
-0.7640476227,
-0.2483351827,
1.0887227058,
-0.1711720079,
-0.3393748403,
0.1470204145,
-0.0057698553,
0.2448159158,
-0.6085563898,
0.8813026547,
1.088460207,
-0.4269469678,
0.0116046406,
-0.4483879209,
0.4270680547,
0.4783067703,
-0.6689458489,
0.3022422791,
0.6540892124,
0.0830132663,
0.1683006883,
0.2359915078,
-0.1781612933,
0.2664189637,
-0.3682681322,
0.0253809169,
0.1837866157,
-0.0347010344,
-0.6502122283,
-0.1200177222,
0.4827812314,
-0.0093054017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09842v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09842v3 | Chameleon: Plug-and-Play Compositional Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T17:47:47 | 2023-10-31T17:43:39 | Pan Lu, Baolin Peng, Hao Cheng, Michel Galley, Kai-Wei Chang, Ying Nian Wu, Song-Chun Zhu, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in solving
various natural language processing tasks due to emergent reasoning abilities.
However, LLMs have inherent limitations as they are incapable of accessing
up-to-date information (stored on the Web or in task-specific knowledge bases),
using external tools, and performing precise mathematical and logical
reasoning. In this paper, we present Chameleon, an AI system that mitigates
these limitations by augmenting LLMs with plug-and-play modules for
compositional reasoning. Chameleon synthesizes programs by composing various
tools (e.g., LLMs, off-the-shelf vision models, web search engines, Python
functions, and heuristic-based modules) for accomplishing complex reasoning
tasks. At the heart of Chameleon is an LLM-based planner that assembles a
sequence of tools to execute to generate the final response. We showcase the
effectiveness of Chameleon on two multi-modal knowledge-intensive reasoning
tasks: ScienceQA and TabMWP. Chameleon, powered by GPT-4, achieves an 86.54%
overall accuracy on ScienceQA, improving the best published few-shot result by
11.37%. On TabMWP, GPT-4-powered Chameleon improves the accuracy by 17.0%,
lifting the state of the art to 98.78%. Our analysis also shows that the
GPT-4-powered planner exhibits more consistent and rational tool selection via
inferring potential constraints from instructions, compared to a
ChatGPT-powered planner. The project is available at
https://chameleon-llm.github.io. | [
-0.3000319898,
-0.7051329613,
0.8178411722,
0.499365449,
-0.0207116324,
0.1323028654,
-0.4325692058,
-0.4006302953,
-0.0201547649,
0.4879358411,
-0.471470356,
-0.4733232558,
-0.3100060523,
0.05341582,
-0.0227182359,
0.5968102813,
0.1098236442,
-0.2168688625,
-0.5895602703,
0.0745039731,
-0.5729988813,
-0.1824508756,
-0.4466734827,
-0.7802898288,
0.5269219279,
0.3336963058,
0.6282955408,
0.5104319453,
0.4076153934,
0.3821312785,
0.06868314,
0.5648496151,
0.053343676,
0.2480144948,
-0.2823198438,
-0.5646511316,
-0.4819722474,
-0.1304506958,
0.0492224023,
0.4117696583,
-0.1694261432,
0.0169149358,
-0.2860148549,
0.2250699848,
-0.7024526,
0.541827023,
-0.7869027853,
0.0631289557,
-0.0696281046,
-0.1055950075,
-0.4308872819,
-0.2228196859,
0.2005657256,
-0.7339793444,
-0.1718565226,
-0.1447529495,
0.3144477606,
0.5248543024,
-0.3518780172,
-0.153954789,
-0.7479593158,
0.8453653455,
-0.9450495839,
0.1479686201,
0.311404109,
0.4997907877,
-0.2363772243,
-0.8305770159,
-0.824719131,
-0.4462382793,
-0.01198895,
0.3082065284,
-0.0486097299,
0.0674889535,
0.5061972737,
0.0807572976,
-0.8223691583,
-0.0073228567,
-0.0131250098,
-0.392349124,
0.722084105,
0.2047338337,
0.3541889191,
-0.037018545,
-0.0630061179,
0.2255288064,
-0.5052725673,
-0.2446200997,
0.0799505264,
0.0905212164,
0.067451641,
0.7804717422,
-0.0471361354,
0.8369398713,
-0.235418424,
-0.3250170946,
-0.0272236802,
-0.2010695636,
-0.4366953075,
0.041451782,
0.7866125107,
0.0156139797,
0.1784784794,
-0.020946743,
-0.2905876935,
0.3621805608,
0.1579631567,
-0.360157907,
-0.584436357,
0.2768084705,
0.1390096098,
-0.0984408259,
-0.3663635552,
-0.6440101862,
-0.6376598477,
-0.4411956072,
0.4760819077,
-0.5145483613,
0.0237080976,
0.2612604201,
-0.0343318284,
0.196805954,
0.5763550401,
-0.7329778671,
0.1742093861,
0.658341229,
0.9618111253,
-0.1472596973,
-0.2642172277,
-0.3567707539,
0.4923110604,
0.0007444617,
0.8390675187,
-0.6925347447,
-0.3685967624,
-0.1581118256,
-0.31585446,
-0.1576824486,
-0.5686361194,
0.4715153575,
-0.5337952375,
0.142933175,
-0.1240198016,
-0.6303386688,
-0.2181027979,
0.4096505642,
-0.6379178166,
0.7365890741,
-0.0953049511,
-0.6093305945,
-0.0971205384,
-0.6820059419,
-0.7014014721,
0.1632921547,
-0.3789602518,
-0.2612770796,
-0.2709563673,
0.3994695544,
0.2841529846,
-0.5414401889,
0.2887242138,
-0.3334077597,
-0.2711794376,
0.3435239196,
-0.2333170027,
0.7696801424,
0.0494478755,
-0.6582187414,
0.2611249387,
-0.7261333466,
0.0859678388,
0.0909007862,
-0.3584805727,
0.0482821204,
0.1300433427,
-0.3201343715,
0.2876555622,
0.2691639364,
-0.3337854743,
0.391818732,
-0.2005460113,
0.7888979316,
0.688539803,
-0.0071998872,
0.3449836373,
-0.3519542217,
0.5141515136,
-0.1139058471,
-0.012714033,
-0.3077406585,
-0.5433471203,
-0.9141984582,
-0.2902435362,
-0.0393779464,
0.8327088952,
-0.9288554788,
0.6562333107,
-0.2480167747,
-0.6925342679,
0.0173972994,
0.0953585133,
0.1938923299,
0.5297670364,
0.4315301776,
-0.0120721553,
-0.3925336599,
-0.8845814466,
-0.2374940813,
-0.0125379702,
-0.0673352927,
0.3530225158,
0.5168203115,
-0.3096252084,
0.8384373784,
-0.7405962944,
-0.0767807364,
-0.3973044753,
0.1168699265,
0.2072263509,
0.3949959874,
0.1499614269,
-0.6348078251,
-0.3478424251,
0.1978528202,
-0.6492152214,
-0.3883797526,
-0.3167513311,
-0.1187971979,
-0.0304807574,
0.1700823754,
-1.1444611549,
0.2256857753,
0.3621655703,
-0.0309768002,
0.8732790947,
-0.0454630442,
-0.1884296685,
-0.7888988853,
0.2928512692,
0.2014288157,
-0.2041650862,
-0.4657228887,
0.0073364796,
0.0217723772,
-0.1463070661,
-0.3165435493,
0.4389074743,
-0.2692183554,
-0.0036322703,
-0.2419481128,
0.265034467,
0.1457599998,
0.6213424206,
0.0047988095,
0.9264519811,
0.4331517816,
-0.6893157363,
0.8598666787,
0.1578448862,
-0.3116361201,
0.3504556715,
-0.7044312954,
0.1816257983,
0.1353073269,
0.4086741209,
-0.4446181357,
-0.4627766609,
0.1956938803,
-0.1089049354,
0.1775508821,
0.1546148211,
-0.4687414765,
-0.3635165095,
-0.2147029042,
0.4233302474,
0.3176794946,
-0.4220512509,
0.8033196926,
0.340307802,
-0.2476110309,
-0.454451412,
-0.7275779247,
0.134717077,
0.0316681117,
-0.6684206128,
0.3711899817,
-0.2667726874,
-0.3257987797,
-0.0643728226,
-0.2303843945,
-0.0035795032,
-0.2247342169,
0.0186084788,
0.2769674659,
-0.0420818254,
0.1614675522,
-0.050201118,
-0.075088881,
0.1239511743,
-0.6205658317,
0.6962592602,
-0.1697504073,
-0.6394497156,
-0.3077732623,
-0.0256213266,
0.774161458,
-0.6004469991,
0.2750270367,
0.5161175132,
-0.3458978534,
-0.3330237269,
-0.6156503558,
-0.0558429286,
-0.4748007953,
0.1581358612,
-0.3451784551,
-0.7956741452,
0.3778989911,
-0.1824173927,
0.0875647143,
0.2698498964,
0.5190331936,
0.0814912543,
1.0017185211,
0.1281885654,
-0.1730176359,
0.2259251028,
-0.2780776322,
0.2539070547,
-0.8372077346,
-0.5592516661,
-0.3677127957,
-0.3170888126,
-0.3434738815,
-0.634319365,
0.533128202,
-0.3555095196,
-0.3496973217,
0.2651953995,
-0.4224849939,
0.5000558496,
0.7926145196,
0.2112045437,
0.3385982215,
-0.1990305185,
-0.2163884789,
0.0314185768,
-0.6061143875,
-0.4709308445,
0.7901592255,
-0.0984541103,
0.7507506013,
0.1817911714,
0.2402172536,
0.3232245743,
0.0662068948,
-0.7787302136,
0.9126350284,
0.2475843281,
-0.3779938519,
-0.2858000696,
-0.5881679654,
-0.7026501298,
0.3020863831,
-0.1448327303,
-0.7772946954,
-0.2466589808,
0.1937407404,
-0.2016023099,
0.2712695897,
-0.4430441558,
0.7441265583,
-0.489082098,
-0.5702075958,
-0.3181752563,
-0.5762767792,
0.6886842847,
-0.078881599,
-0.0158162136,
-0.0833057016,
-0.111844331,
0.1589152813,
-0.3980211318,
0.7332159281,
0.1041147932,
-0.0420059748,
0.4651584923,
0.2792246044,
0.601062119,
0.1779943556,
-0.1519200951,
-0.128823936,
-0.2156015038,
-0.4240274727,
-0.9506614208,
1.02123034,
-0.730887413,
-0.8193774819,
-0.4150935709,
-0.8466064334,
-0.329850018,
0.2253529578,
0.0049051605,
0.3910320699,
0.1662660539,
-0.0453203395,
0.7134978175,
-0.3962379992,
0.4435455501,
0.1929606646,
-0.084215112,
-0.4952731729,
0.9538708925,
-0.021620566,
0.1103705838,
0.4899926186,
0.1860008687,
-0.3142932653,
-0.3476292193,
-0.4963439405,
0.2027127594,
-0.7096555829,
-0.2633663714,
-0.6080852151,
-0.2167468816,
-0.3340083659,
-0.1030142978,
-0.0915603712,
-0.5633767843,
-0.0511117429,
0.1783741415,
-0.0786914974,
0.5563876629,
0.2680051923,
0.090507701,
-0.7590257525,
-0.0078611849,
0.7050336599,
0.0743363202,
-0.0990919843,
-0.1342745274,
-0.0452988259,
-0.1334087551,
-0.5712507963,
-0.9057585597,
0.21567294,
0.0447087698,
0.6125398874,
0.2232788354,
-0.1787360609,
0.58113271,
-0.2571341693,
0.9263427854,
0.017443791,
-1.0974757671,
0.701279819,
-0.4944826066,
0.7003043294,
0.2000668496,
-0.00181556,
-0.4061025083,
-0.2396542877,
-0.4443967938,
-0.5935348272,
0.5126534104,
0.3964099288,
-0.318613261,
0.223115921,
0.3281010985,
-0.039944794,
0.509539187,
-0.8838532567,
0.0916755423,
-0.227582261,
-0.1978815645,
-0.0125998547,
0.0679622963,
-0.1151738167,
-0.3578080535,
0.9539754391,
-0.2558296323,
0.0527235568,
0.0537980534,
-0.2748765945,
0.2230036408,
0.2976464331,
0.8734689951,
0.6965974569,
0.2255613804,
0.6355485916,
0.2020821571,
-0.3400794268,
0.2527398765,
0.0953182429,
-0.2294323891,
-0.2327124923,
0.7234303355,
0.4661924243,
0.0761616528,
-0.9760951996,
0.3546306789,
0.194713816,
0.0638968125,
-0.1144103259,
0.4125073552,
0.2527965307,
0.4621079564,
-0.1591415852,
0.316586256,
0.1112540811,
-0.3289130032,
-0.1615092307,
0.4155586064,
-0.0200895742,
-0.4192992151,
0.6217136979,
0.2688999176,
-0.2488638163,
0.6194627285,
-0.3100742698,
-0.6696134806,
0.7049083114,
0.7135699391,
0.8036319613,
-0.1678546518,
0.2018737346,
0.1447954327,
0.5179338455,
-0.0181137342,
0.2680997849,
-0.1360566318,
-0.7083742619,
-0.5762450695,
-0.439496249,
-0.4062072337,
0.3241267502,
0.0565144606,
0.1923679262,
-0.5610712767,
-0.0336214751,
-0.1729949713,
0.0510836653,
-0.5699714422,
0.0593395382,
-0.0285938513,
1.0028711557,
-0.6541045308,
0.6773636341,
1.0461107492,
-0.3552071452,
-0.8627314568,
-0.0191729479,
0.2015396506,
-0.5464680195,
0.2773033977,
0.2085339278,
-0.2240038812,
-0.027231371,
-0.5655245781,
-0.6906552315,
1.3292115927,
0.6414473653,
-0.5642235875,
0.2878775597,
0.2237730324,
0.4178546667,
-0.1421062648,
0.3269299269,
0.6243450642,
0.8472994566,
0.2809577584,
-0.8883675337,
0.0551563054,
-0.2729807198,
-0.0461470447,
0.1786930561,
-0.6014097929,
0.7439874411,
-0.1622970253,
0.0524529926,
-0.1413003504,
0.4954398274,
0.4616370797,
0.3682409823,
0.4726272225,
0.6885111332,
0.8624800444,
-0.0021933911,
0.7898792028,
-0.2807869315,
-0.0106458981,
1.1460469961,
-0.5313113928,
0.4038047194,
0.2839351892,
-0.1651523709,
0.4935169518,
0.4411509335,
0.0235348865,
0.3398235142,
0.2074072063,
-0.8186870217,
-0.5241699815,
-0.1364449412,
-0.0793348104,
0.4916464686,
0.3415779471,
0.013494961,
-0.0315825231,
-0.1319724023,
-0.0821214989,
0.0560050085,
-0.2521924973,
0.4798170924,
0.134681806,
-0.8916275501,
-0.0358481482,
-0.0258884206,
0.2778590322,
-0.5322879553,
-0.0974786878,
-0.1239149943,
0.2214495689,
-0.3509477675,
-0.6957395673,
0.0571211949,
-0.277143985,
0.025222538,
0.2371893525,
1.0776466131,
-0.4532972276,
-0.3808114529,
-0.0032890302,
0.6357384324,
-0.2129868865,
-0.0951425582,
-0.6144162416,
0.1506957412,
-0.0921411812,
-0.2967682779,
0.001113155,
0.4011159241,
-0.1048583537,
1.1289371252,
0.6632483006,
0.2041892707,
-0.054650832,
0.1302182227,
0.9869585037,
-0.5201445222,
-0.4429372549,
-1.0787810087,
0.2806783617,
-0.2753686309,
-0.0416324288,
0.617251873,
0.63814044,
0.5449176431,
-0.1584247649,
1.0706416368,
0.0630593151,
-0.0966724828,
-0.5191538334,
0.2582297027,
-0.3530451953,
0.585786581,
-0.0930364579,
-1.1468684673,
-0.5900055766,
0.6736760139,
-0.3294723332,
0.0906197578,
0.697887063,
0.8084020615,
-0.2840436101,
0.2817770541,
0.2886381447,
0.1595804095,
0.757784903,
0.69643116,
0.8760913014,
0.3548263013,
0.4456890821,
-0.1545192748,
-0.2405146509,
-0.0984239355,
-0.8473085761,
-0.9693568945,
-0.2655831873,
-0.1573841721,
0.0029375062,
-0.1624250859,
1.0586997271,
0.649441421,
-0.4149309695,
-0.2280293703,
-0.3800891638,
0.1806808561,
-0.1205108389,
-0.2458072603,
0.070316866,
-0.3625236452,
-0.4819785058,
0.6473022103,
0.8360836506,
-0.1928085238,
-0.5404611826,
-0.1004834473,
-0.1567492783,
0.2782990932,
0.7150135636,
0.2195667773,
-0.7608473301,
-0.4803601205,
-0.0090324897,
-0.171361804,
-0.1094121337,
0.9543386102,
-0.7313449979,
0.5385385156,
0.5739703774,
0.7696759105,
0.6549039483,
-0.3242893517,
0.6423733234,
-0.6078649759,
0.0439409465,
0.5378785133,
0.5241472721,
0.3029345274,
-0.1570931673,
0.5456980467,
0.3748719692,
-0.8084006906,
-0.3901612759,
0.6933628321,
-1.0569914579,
-0.2054878622,
1.0699216127,
-0.1131983697,
-0.1583252251,
-0.0778500587,
-0.4559668601,
0.3154139221,
-0.2868376374,
0.8445074558,
0.5950289965,
-0.5372036695,
-0.2632200122,
-0.4415792227,
0.2208320349,
0.3489458859,
-1.2380648851,
-0.1764852405,
0.7192329764,
0.0875852033,
0.3317611217,
0.4753875434,
0.2897837758,
0.2185479105,
-0.1276747882,
0.1021225601,
-0.3364489079,
-0.3181944788,
0.0434172973,
0.1909003109,
-0.078013368,
0.1640596837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09805v1 | A Survey of Corpora for Germanic Low-Resource Languages and Dialects | 2023-04-19T16:45:16 | 2023-04-19T16:45:16 | Verena Blaschke, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite much progress in recent years, the vast majority of work in natural
language processing (NLP) is on standard languages with many speakers. In this
work, we instead focus on low-resource languages and in particular
non-standardized low-resource languages. Even within branches of major language
families, often considered well-researched, little is known about the extent
and type of available resources and what the major NLP challenges are for these
language varieties. The first step to address this situation is a systematic
survey of available corpora (most importantly, annotated corpora, which are
particularly valuable for NLP research). Focusing on Germanic low-resource
language varieties, we provide such a survey in this paper. Except for
geolocation (origin of speaker or document), we find that manually annotated
linguistic resources are sparse and, if they exist, mostly cover morphosyntax.
Despite this lack of resources, we observe that interest in this area is
increasing: there is active development and a growing research community. To
facilitate research, we make our overview of over 80 corpora publicly
available. We share a companion website of this overview at
https://github.com/mainlp/germanic-lrl-corpora . | [
-0.8598331213,
-0.4007284343,
0.3694623709,
0.0611949749,
0.0825041905,
0.1175526753,
-0.6389505267,
-0.8490335345,
0.5986307859,
0.4760926962,
-0.6391161084,
-0.4984188676,
-0.5587107539,
0.6603821516,
-0.1526675075,
0.9292783141,
0.2133061886,
-0.0905489549,
-0.0469993167,
-0.5335100889,
0.0900515616,
-0.6812280416,
-0.3567043245,
-0.1407342255,
0.6798328757,
0.4809725285,
0.755446136,
0.273444891,
0.5197373629,
0.2618980706,
-0.59077847,
0.2431599796,
-0.4035739303,
0.2700010538,
-0.203945905,
-0.0752823129,
-0.3257207572,
-0.2429515421,
0.6801068187,
1.251715064,
0.2348702252,
0.3617249131,
-0.0534227937,
0.6266762018,
-0.7011370659,
0.0410563089,
-0.3218097091,
0.1551784575,
-0.7240133286,
0.0393535942,
-0.373200655,
-0.2323309779,
0.2622950077,
-0.4121991694,
0.5173609853,
0.056351006,
0.4314846992,
0.2525379956,
-0.2537169158,
-0.3586012125,
-0.7675122023,
0.7938024998,
-0.4549795985,
0.4830081761,
0.6042195559,
-0.0613538176,
-0.2585021555,
-0.3436636329,
-0.0942962766,
-0.2509177327,
-0.3435364962,
-0.2022368908,
-0.5065032244,
0.2051303685,
0.2993983924,
0.4612768888,
-0.6520422101,
0.3277989626,
-0.563331902,
-0.309414655,
0.5176008344,
-0.1902243495,
0.1523523182,
-0.4924314618,
-0.0570583493,
-0.0397468843,
-0.5354519486,
-0.1573542058,
0.3942226768,
0.4338866174,
-0.1907870471,
0.7307293415,
-0.2730064988,
0.8368676901,
-0.1976799071,
0.0208945144,
0.4095777571,
-0.6245161891,
0.0450349078,
-0.1875102222,
0.629555285,
-0.2385974824,
-0.0850649551,
-0.1988237053,
-0.2812851071,
-0.13307257,
-0.1318829358,
-0.398537159,
-0.1646468937,
0.276073873,
-0.485620141,
0.088957116,
-0.3494280875,
-0.8601655364,
-0.217157498,
-0.1975660324,
-0.3654541671,
-0.5449561477,
-0.4053509235,
-0.2058690786,
-0.3432865739,
-0.0581660941,
0.1937153041,
-1.119379282,
0.4583637118,
0.6333030462,
0.9325026274,
-0.3971829116,
-0.1996028423,
-0.4696840048,
-0.233362332,
-0.2451905906,
0.8496363759,
-0.4525876343,
-0.5148255229,
0.2923125625,
0.1150913462,
0.2230591774,
-0.61526829,
0.7358123064,
-0.3399127722,
0.3083235025,
-0.2703023553,
-0.2753629386,
0.0041045928,
0.2189058214,
-0.9520549774,
1.2040144205,
0.5420427322,
-0.8679350019,
0.0691193491,
-0.7371969819,
-0.3726342618,
0.3808626533,
-0.2149706185,
0.3652217388,
0.3870008588,
-0.0077459165,
0.1609410495,
-0.3037675321,
-0.0516143851,
-0.0890121758,
-0.0838713944,
-0.0212509595,
-0.2510507703,
0.8968508244,
0.441614002,
-0.1632124037,
0.0116271824,
-0.9498445392,
0.0697020739,
-0.1943951845,
-0.3388239741,
-0.63507092,
-0.2900795341,
0.6138727665,
0.0501179025,
0.541621685,
-0.4030373693,
0.1380185187,
-0.4655836225,
0.2431661934,
0.4795896411,
-0.2038541585,
0.8040882945,
0.0233422276,
0.638551414,
-0.2709158361,
0.0545080081,
0.1629662216,
-0.5402184129,
-0.6922162771,
-0.3019119799,
0.4552229941,
0.3305234313,
-0.7858998775,
0.2669267952,
-0.1037394181,
-0.5252911448,
-0.6621001959,
0.234888643,
0.4407597184,
0.1247998178,
0.4075017869,
-0.4132417142,
-0.6403754354,
-1.2402129173,
0.4181631505,
-0.332213968,
-0.3086287677,
0.2538277507,
0.3053270578,
-0.3098220825,
0.878374815,
-0.3380438983,
-0.1394514889,
-0.2911228538,
0.3207522929,
0.0424562842,
0.1840468943,
0.7474091649,
-0.6821429729,
-0.3074696958,
0.0285646934,
-0.3847981691,
-0.3097861409,
0.4887614846,
-0.0430385955,
0.7519152164,
0.1613789946,
-0.5184463263,
-0.1505349576,
1.0129195452,
-0.2796192467,
0.2130233645,
-0.1317439824,
-0.3354838192,
-0.6026181579,
0.2915373743,
-0.0366012752,
-0.1279114485,
-0.5873852968,
-0.0529509559,
-0.3760992885,
-0.1274863333,
-0.3770052195,
0.7367814779,
-0.4878385663,
-0.422016412,
-0.1817947179,
0.3583088219,
-0.3727220297,
0.3674416542,
0.4099206924,
0.6675412655,
0.1453967988,
-0.3854543269,
0.1527260542,
0.2997528315,
-0.1752150506,
0.5059534907,
-0.2497179359,
0.0271433964,
-0.1616913378,
0.0307118576,
-0.4458717406,
-0.391151458,
0.2516449094,
-0.2203491628,
0.0806572512,
-0.3955180347,
-0.4561752975,
-0.0124549689,
-0.018463254,
0.3006385267,
0.4713920057,
-0.1999801099,
0.3476008773,
0.6932460666,
-0.6230615973,
-0.564525187,
-0.5606646538,
0.0266544428,
0.0155598773,
-0.7909190059,
0.2712873816,
0.0698629543,
-0.7084928155,
0.3174127638,
0.0796516836,
-0.4107142985,
-0.0221050791,
0.0071802041,
0.1309216619,
-0.3263716996,
0.2837696671,
-0.4037463069,
-0.1574377716,
-0.3753684461,
-0.27607584,
0.6081362963,
-0.4221404195,
-0.226934433,
0.0310630798,
0.7608255148,
0.1295688301,
-0.0453391224,
0.2468291223,
0.6378982067,
-0.3591649234,
-0.2562216222,
-0.4665139616,
-0.164206937,
-0.3632638156,
0.2490642816,
0.0021622418,
-1.0880610943,
0.3678076565,
0.1214380115,
0.1749401838,
0.6817891598,
0.5721262693,
-0.0721058324,
0.2248192877,
1.0904892683,
-0.138910085,
0.3334567845,
-0.0743714944,
0.0369234048,
-0.3154733777,
0.2128351778,
-0.8032352328,
-0.2019660324,
-1.2163475752,
-0.6116349101,
0.2732068002,
-0.2534889281,
0.1508480608,
0.601023078,
-0.5275747776,
0.1530932039,
0.8615759611,
-0.606199801,
0.4252017438,
-0.0732548833,
0.2041324377,
-0.1762213856,
-0.8694528937,
-0.6420277953,
0.6902154684,
0.3023562729,
0.4231880903,
0.1256931126,
0.9986740351,
0.2852340639,
0.0260988567,
-0.7437487841,
0.3817652166,
-0.3194237351,
-0.8613315821,
-0.5884264708,
-0.4550516009,
-0.920802176,
0.1640860289,
-0.179661572,
-0.4602232277,
0.5029533505,
0.0144252349,
-0.3360193968,
0.1090014726,
-0.6278541684,
0.833918035,
-0.2049791217,
-0.1923121065,
-0.1401387155,
-0.52905339,
0.0731324703,
-0.0582719594,
0.4776092768,
-0.3223587871,
0.0303995777,
0.715277195,
-0.2169777155,
0.850559175,
-0.149410978,
-0.2347821444,
0.407114923,
0.0323490389,
0.3146032095,
-0.1206773669,
-0.0502323024,
0.383356899,
0.3821353316,
-0.4549528062,
-0.0744646937,
0.3945440054,
-0.4878959656,
-0.2499118447,
-0.7294652462,
-0.4908665121,
-0.2773576081,
0.1550143808,
0.3947257102,
0.043623738,
-0.5062736273,
0.1865696162,
0.4758396149,
-0.2067427486,
0.4773201048,
0.3251772821,
-0.0545102954,
-0.2658560872,
0.6884198785,
0.3340721428,
0.2277258039,
0.2331984937,
-0.0595426522,
0.0083618946,
-0.5978081226,
-0.3045467734,
0.1701290011,
-0.5864095688,
0.0751626566,
-0.3205177188,
-0.1329098344,
-0.3806745708,
-0.2129573375,
-0.6141127348,
-0.834895134,
-0.0817145184,
0.0170661677,
0.4039109945,
0.7141648531,
-0.3986766934,
0.1650186479,
-0.7395399809,
0.3073764443,
-0.0870147794,
0.2801281214,
-0.296115309,
-0.1351086646,
-0.2197641283,
-0.1573459506,
0.0334153175,
-0.5962471962,
0.4109652042,
-0.0216870122,
0.4290058315,
0.2697062492,
0.3834019899,
0.3943873942,
-0.4425362647,
0.8495312929,
0.1488453448,
-0.5676192641,
0.1793824434,
-0.3434732854,
0.1092192307,
0.7985967994,
0.4567086697,
-1.0164651871,
-0.5137419105,
-0.7549200058,
-0.9981283545,
0.6598721743,
0.2881592512,
0.1004560143,
-0.051493112,
-0.2150315195,
0.0982087255,
0.1032674834,
-0.5989791751,
-0.2156622857,
0.1474816948,
0.0361000188,
-0.1146301702,
-0.3993925154,
-0.4761849344,
0.1229774132,
0.5664434433,
-0.1449151486,
0.0971538574,
0.2168893367,
-0.0786897168,
-0.1421621293,
0.7098050714,
0.6135579944,
0.6279226542,
-0.4660202861,
0.4856322408,
0.276041925,
-0.5102367997,
-0.0081016086,
0.2898943126,
-0.5668693781,
0.592893362,
0.5665436387,
0.607478261,
0.460942477,
-0.7450905442,
0.2075951397,
0.1834908277,
0.0004139425,
-0.8062393665,
-0.2752451301,
0.2177213132,
0.2404784262,
0.3996875882,
0.0977845341,
0.0461339615,
-0.452400893,
0.0064332141,
0.2837467492,
-0.3114824295,
-0.3783869147,
0.0888768658,
0.3855336905,
-0.2813519835,
0.4811077416,
-0.753239572,
-0.2112081796,
0.3693165183,
0.142248556,
0.7153016329,
0.322509408,
0.2602483928,
0.2813846767,
0.3813715875,
0.0584748089,
0.319432646,
-0.0519202426,
-0.4547369778,
-0.3852054477,
-0.8353039622,
-0.6932271719,
0.1281745881,
-0.427308023,
0.4212220609,
-0.3878547847,
-0.3826203644,
0.1183511689,
-0.0232161526,
-0.489012301,
-0.3539969325,
0.4822181761,
0.9420892,
-0.7378179431,
0.6403648853,
0.4457564652,
-0.4031507969,
-0.0515672863,
-0.0773396343,
0.1637588739,
-0.4906988442,
0.9598239064,
-0.267780751,
-0.2094427049,
-0.4114201665,
-0.3520302474,
-1.0066862106,
0.5231767297,
0.3071076274,
-0.4252011776,
-0.3518757224,
0.2044711262,
0.8596271276,
-0.0237414408,
0.0513045862,
0.4378659427,
0.7163596749,
-0.1015210822,
-1.0455411673,
-0.3270837963,
-0.2013200074,
0.0722654387,
0.2234005779,
-0.4255215526,
0.7901669145,
0.2286500782,
-0.4408014119,
-0.0135612795,
0.5642350912,
0.1236843094,
0.2842027843,
0.4568161368,
0.3056675792,
0.802726686,
-0.1161816642,
0.8531137705,
-0.4307078421,
0.0621761195,
1.1919730902,
-0.2059358209,
0.9912182093,
0.7574657202,
-0.3096617758,
0.1974807233,
0.7499070764,
-0.1270946711,
0.1955368668,
0.241066426,
-0.3656506836,
-0.1128900126,
-0.5122225285,
-0.3093413413,
0.5653550029,
0.3154901862,
-0.1319180131,
-0.5288428664,
-0.205464676,
0.1214431971,
0.0996752679,
-0.1559442729,
0.6120941043,
0.0678147674,
-0.6686965227,
0.5659371018,
0.1518745273,
0.955645144,
-0.7834220529,
0.1737387031,
-0.2954917252,
-0.2924673855,
-0.4263531864,
-0.6698395014,
0.5727493763,
0.2795664966,
-0.3617353141,
-0.4335113764,
0.515214324,
-0.2789549828,
-0.3360391259,
0.6186192632,
0.8786057234,
0.3682058454,
0.350864172,
-0.0006167419,
-0.1463576555,
-0.1816951931,
-0.1485419571,
0.4707437754,
0.4451479316,
-0.1465385109,
0.2142742425,
0.4801996946,
0.3250281513,
0.148557812,
-0.0604844801,
0.5837333202,
-0.6440288424,
-0.1366524696,
-0.4074587822,
0.2233538777,
-0.0806250423,
-0.4522334039,
0.7182923555,
0.6305706501,
1.1657586098,
-0.161253944,
0.9177623391,
-0.4880385697,
0.7040852308,
-0.3355226219,
0.5376178622,
-0.2501805723,
-0.1074989438,
-0.0631739572,
-0.8373878002,
-0.1403790116,
0.5146251321,
-0.2336070389,
-0.4198720157,
0.545286119,
0.4639658332,
-0.1318486184,
0.0649517551,
0.2665615082,
0.0495109186,
-0.1694512367,
0.2898348868,
0.6629487276,
0.1167215854,
0.5591824055,
-0.7209245563,
-0.1347964257,
-0.2861094177,
-0.8206288218,
-0.4389534295,
-0.8570497632,
-0.0516008288,
-0.2210836112,
-0.1491818875,
1.2082178593,
0.4571569264,
-0.899605453,
-0.4734884501,
0.26483953,
0.2088959366,
-0.096988678,
-0.1541098207,
0.2897435427,
-0.6185992956,
-0.9447161555,
0.5578689575,
0.2108497173,
-0.0375559963,
-0.5384453535,
-0.0297430959,
-0.2235259414,
-0.3511974812,
0.6088984013,
0.753497839,
-0.5885267258,
-0.1408597827,
0.3068475127,
-0.3186665773,
0.1173717976,
0.7474511862,
-0.3915530443,
0.1571270078,
0.6985831857,
0.5718787909,
0.3540059924,
-0.3506187499,
0.3124854863,
-1.0110180378,
0.6284672618,
0.5907596946,
0.5002591014,
0.4252623022,
-0.1087718233,
0.908516705,
0.3203936219,
-0.3262706101,
-0.8039619327,
0.4764162004,
-1.0208177567,
-0.1923212856,
1.2667297125,
0.0500548184,
-0.1351193786,
-0.3463847935,
-0.0663333088,
-0.0218723789,
-0.3579183817,
0.5498500466,
0.9458296895,
-0.3022608459,
-0.1039956734,
-0.8579556942,
0.833876133,
0.207819283,
-0.6345896721,
0.3298037946,
0.9343078136,
-0.073275134,
0.9074665308,
0.9532442093,
-0.0759647638,
0.058201991,
0.0229700059,
0.1983013898,
0.3318215311,
-0.1751380265,
-0.3531695604,
0.3609896898,
0.3809065521,
0.1966743171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09797v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09797v5 | Progressive-Hint Prompting Improves Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-04-19T16:29:48 | 2023-08-10T03:41:04 | Chuanyang Zheng, Zhengying Liu, Enze Xie, Zhenguo Li, Yu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in reasoning tasks depends
heavily on prompt design, with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and self-consistency
being critical methods that enhance this ability. However, these methods do not
fully exploit the answers generated by the LLM to guide subsequent responses.
This paper proposes a new prompting method, named Progressive-Hint Prompting
(PHP), that enables automatic multiple interactions between users and LLMs by
using previously generated answers as hints to progressively guide toward the
correct answers. PHP is orthogonal to CoT and self-consistency, making it easy
to combine with state-of-the-art techniques to further improve performance. We
conducted extensive and comprehensive experiments on seven benchmarks. The
results show that PHP significantly improves accuracy while remaining highly
efficient. For instance, with text-davinci-003, we observed a 4.2% improvement
on GSM8K with greedy decoding compared to Complex CoT, and a 46.17% reduction
in sample paths with self-consistency. With GPT-4 and PHP, we achieve
state-of-the-art performances on SVAMP (89.1% -> 91.9%), GSM8K (92% -> 95.5%),
AQuA (76.4% -> 79.9%) and MATH (50.3% -> 53.9%). | [
-0.4797011018,
-1.2111343145,
1.0984306335,
0.6481378675,
-0.3875899017,
0.1252359301,
-0.4954914749,
-0.0949751511,
-0.0590228587,
0.1601408273,
-0.8877290487,
-0.605727911,
-0.3041236997,
0.5387730002,
-0.1592121124,
0.3789245486,
-0.1473773271,
-0.0470371805,
-0.0490617864,
0.1386021823,
-0.6871681213,
-0.2157574892,
-0.9551283717,
-0.305730015,
0.6369357109,
0.4172338843,
0.7596148849,
0.6624373198,
0.2187518924,
0.3210707903,
-0.0794760138,
0.4554610848,
-0.08706633,
0.5625447035,
-0.3003351092,
-0.480233252,
-0.5964363813,
-0.313581109,
0.6080772877,
0.5107137561,
-0.2132945508,
0.109891355,
0.024851663,
0.7456448078,
-0.6766274571,
0.287542969,
-0.3932882547,
-0.1305445433,
-0.2107752264,
-0.3593358099,
-0.5953144431,
-0.6481470466,
-0.039699059,
-0.6691447496,
-0.0179024469,
-0.2561650276,
0.5182495117,
0.1723074168,
-0.2111719698,
-0.4300251007,
-0.6024316549,
0.5990052223,
-0.8340517282,
0.3572722375,
0.3025301099,
0.2330500185,
-0.3684217334,
-0.617990911,
-0.9382445216,
-0.2525737584,
0.1967873275,
0.1017178893,
-0.198050499,
0.2128745317,
0.4589450657,
0.0829674527,
-0.3707849085,
-0.0241926741,
0.0572847798,
-0.1860912591,
0.4380588233,
0.1072947457,
0.2326534241,
-0.0596937649,
-0.1397567987,
-0.062492609,
-1.0185799599,
0.2371667624,
0.3083215356,
0.3186841905,
0.2335790843,
0.4509304166,
-0.2181869745,
1.0651500225,
0.4246193171,
-0.4164764285,
0.2418698817,
-0.5629169941,
-0.0016947973,
-0.2645123005,
0.9213935733,
0.3152009547,
0.4354833066,
0.3299643695,
-0.3040283322,
0.0438482463,
-0.1417251676,
-0.3777915835,
-0.3708636761,
0.3159933686,
-0.2398637682,
0.0893808156,
-0.0914073139,
-0.9084973335,
-0.2941452563,
-0.4204818606,
0.4050967395,
-0.5424673557,
-0.4421516061,
0.2713455558,
-0.1185374111,
0.2846693695,
0.849540472,
-0.8867381811,
-0.0156478826,
0.5448973179,
0.8774763942,
-0.0890314206,
-0.1847856939,
-0.8719956279,
0.2408313304,
-0.290391475,
0.9635254145,
-0.8618171811,
-0.5099855661,
0.0186178088,
-0.1808162034,
-0.1042661592,
-0.6509450674,
0.6278783679,
-0.4901920259,
0.0962617323,
-0.7129389644,
-0.4647914469,
0.0651168376,
0.403116107,
-0.4700882733,
1.1859902143,
-0.0953075886,
-0.5881866217,
0.129111886,
-0.5509034395,
-0.4728426635,
0.0904595479,
-0.2941004336,
-0.1800756752,
-0.037255615,
0.7482557297,
0.1483223885,
0.0064581982,
0.2000253201,
-0.3563807309,
-0.4927417338,
0.3060837984,
-0.6286743879,
0.5529626012,
0.0646926984,
-0.583758533,
0.2233964801,
-0.5495480299,
0.2848731577,
0.1076504588,
-0.3787301779,
-0.1115808487,
-0.2839926481,
-0.6232799292,
0.3512488306,
0.2493158877,
-0.3419263959,
0.6260433793,
-0.1747730523,
0.5207856894,
1.0898426771,
0.0472665355,
0.2188583165,
-0.1308230758,
0.9370803833,
-0.1179485768,
0.3096739054,
-0.7660562992,
-0.7500074506,
-0.6330114603,
-0.2211188823,
0.3176420331,
0.5891842842,
-1.0479682684,
0.3433920145,
-0.0917414948,
-0.0750130266,
-0.4992074668,
0.3164613247,
0.496170193,
0.5167270303,
0.3355305195,
-0.034226954,
-0.2594174743,
-0.479899168,
-0.2253952026,
-0.3251079917,
-0.2833203375,
0.3843661547,
0.2468615025,
-0.0383783951,
1.0614846945,
-0.613302052,
0.1568277329,
-0.1829788685,
0.1223387122,
0.2731934488,
0.3627552092,
0.2214257717,
-0.7447429895,
-0.722925663,
-0.3299005032,
-0.4476582706,
-0.1923741847,
-0.0636638403,
-0.2502397597,
0.0535534807,
0.2751737833,
-0.7675887942,
0.0924912393,
0.3992744684,
-0.2405748814,
0.7943220735,
-0.3382280767,
0.2962738574,
-0.7718014121,
0.0271432139,
-0.0433057956,
-0.1990719289,
-0.556835711,
-0.0333555378,
0.3682627678,
0.2099108994,
-0.2778310478,
0.4412750304,
-0.5936073661,
0.2623208761,
-0.2420702875,
0.5731204748,
0.0904971361,
0.3444485068,
-0.024369726,
1.1381387711,
0.5748333931,
-0.7170497775,
0.4802184999,
-0.0242341757,
0.2468616068,
0.6809724569,
-0.6465527415,
0.5149300098,
-0.1533853561,
0.4802232087,
-1.2448538542,
-0.3336874545,
0.3428440094,
-0.5701680779,
0.2635187209,
-0.0615088269,
-0.7207945585,
-0.8151108623,
-0.6264522076,
0.4148447812,
0.5325409174,
-0.7134389281,
0.7061967254,
-0.0869765878,
-0.3377837837,
-0.676882863,
-0.4097825885,
0.1120293811,
-0.0122614913,
-0.5914691687,
0.1146215647,
-0.3301207423,
0.0064982413,
-0.2631669939,
-0.2187071145,
0.184522748,
-0.2656566501,
0.0113907941,
0.3635255396,
-0.0985039026,
0.4726266563,
0.1792705506,
-0.0316250362,
0.1578731537,
-0.5528249145,
0.8686341643,
-0.1259983629,
-0.5389980674,
-0.7282883525,
0.283875525,
0.4217122495,
-0.4455590844,
0.4179791212,
0.4758965075,
-0.1318506598,
-0.1414925158,
-0.7002256513,
-0.2432529777,
-0.5808209777,
-0.2196137011,
-0.6405801773,
-0.9578608274,
0.5054832101,
-0.3734437823,
0.001532545,
0.3038784564,
0.542283833,
0.1107237712,
1.4032086134,
0.5316385031,
0.2184308618,
0.4838853776,
0.0249140523,
0.1851118505,
-0.9266895652,
-0.3943078518,
-0.5235264897,
0.158181265,
-0.122748591,
-0.5121523142,
0.3181890845,
0.3775063157,
-0.0088644121,
0.0501769409,
-0.5770927072,
0.4280444086,
0.4617081881,
0.2708159387,
0.5736521482,
-0.1334974915,
-0.4585492611,
0.1161347851,
-0.5464180708,
-0.4972523749,
0.9577157497,
0.1923796833,
0.8223078251,
0.2294870466,
0.6657235622,
0.0839255527,
0.3135086596,
-0.5201793313,
0.6977605224,
0.2755587995,
-0.4393631816,
-0.2850646675,
-0.5656496882,
-0.8987420797,
0.0108815311,
0.0845838711,
-0.7436050773,
0.1690127254,
0.6648453474,
-0.647973001,
-0.0532434285,
-0.7566162944,
0.4540403187,
-0.0378987417,
-0.4236688018,
-0.0756111816,
-0.4949018955,
0.400534302,
0.0888032392,
0.2356946021,
-0.1512151212,
-0.2951829135,
0.3398359418,
-0.0834554806,
0.7274737954,
-0.3880589306,
-0.5135487318,
0.4714057446,
0.1222834736,
0.9160516262,
0.4101560414,
-0.1468336731,
-0.4279079437,
-0.2432152182,
-0.4285115004,
-0.9116717577,
0.687179625,
-0.2037328482,
-1.0052666664,
-0.158083111,
-0.4644235373,
-0.3544437587,
0.3915745914,
0.2420105487,
0.5490155816,
0.4621830285,
-0.1607556492,
1.1559537649,
-0.0651719198,
0.4694035947,
0.518895328,
-0.4368189871,
-0.5493769646,
0.4871857166,
-0.0161752924,
0.529815793,
0.2802233994,
0.2590051889,
-0.7705211043,
-0.5707105994,
-0.7528954148,
0.369679749,
-0.8990221024,
-0.3541364372,
-0.7837338448,
0.2135487646,
-0.4569033384,
-0.0959474072,
-0.1243223026,
-0.2900758982,
-0.0347889587,
-0.025772823,
0.416620791,
0.615724206,
0.1775200218,
0.1980429143,
-0.7611524463,
0.2248605788,
0.4396100044,
0.4139839411,
0.2669069469,
-0.2243193537,
0.243425265,
0.0998257771,
-0.3019405007,
-1.1401729584,
-0.1596473902,
0.0680453777,
0.6275612116,
0.5344478488,
0.2808480859,
0.8231652975,
-0.3962259889,
0.974454999,
0.3323278427,
-1.1489173174,
0.9564567804,
-0.6272503138,
0.8316931725,
0.5052930713,
0.1922641098,
-0.4324203432,
-0.6739964485,
-0.4039762914,
-0.7674779296,
0.33183828,
0.1410701722,
0.1605131775,
-0.3394615948,
0.734267354,
0.1174067706,
0.288543433,
-0.5895647407,
-0.2490649223,
-0.0706386343,
-0.3723370135,
0.2870771885,
-0.2723759711,
-0.0644466132,
-0.3719861209,
0.4411310852,
-0.4948856235,
0.2770211399,
0.4323585629,
0.088288106,
-0.2503052056,
0.472887516,
0.7806449533,
1.1767007113,
0.1012734026,
0.3579126,
0.3045783639,
-0.5020840168,
0.3369704783,
0.0354284197,
-0.2977432013,
0.0288276616,
0.3659965694,
0.3904252052,
-0.0386642963,
-0.7721093893,
0.3900127411,
-0.2674794793,
-0.0171138924,
-0.1266368032,
0.2955268621,
0.2510459721,
0.2789737582,
0.5669804811,
-0.0944502503,
0.0989015847,
-0.492274344,
0.0221269019,
0.4117283821,
-0.0445741229,
-0.2591555417,
0.461676389,
0.1998026222,
-0.3392841816,
0.5927372575,
-0.4360025227,
-0.6955036521,
0.2666625082,
0.7807144523,
0.6502476931,
-0.4433072805,
0.3790256381,
0.4516948164,
-0.0367225707,
-0.5117781162,
0.6290521026,
-0.5309208035,
-0.3043163121,
-0.8494859338,
-0.5427313447,
-0.4619091451,
-0.2363666594,
-0.5400869846,
0.0717442706,
-0.4826553166,
-0.372164458,
-0.0373538882,
-0.0434329286,
-0.3382792771,
-0.1330925077,
0.0692265481,
1.2808343172,
-0.4510293305,
1.020693779,
0.7360247374,
-0.1473616362,
-1.2155174017,
0.3202649951,
0.0751945898,
-0.5528380871,
0.2491634637,
0.3041602075,
-0.5670186877,
0.210359633,
-0.4434033334,
-0.7695637941,
1.1463010311,
0.4936908185,
-0.9182142615,
0.0502667427,
-0.134414494,
0.4853492379,
-0.2567454875,
0.2949154079,
0.6263005137,
0.7854596376,
0.3724796474,
-0.9672572017,
0.412540406,
-0.1990193725,
0.0665916577,
0.3678630292,
-0.6330856681,
0.8510555029,
-0.4281821549,
-0.3813208044,
0.1744154394,
0.5806897879,
0.7458279729,
0.2710161507,
0.732775867,
0.2176847756,
1.1254011393,
-0.2583650947,
0.7894071937,
-0.2243609875,
0.243423,
0.8441098928,
-0.2140887976,
0.8414414525,
0.4411578774,
-0.3949274123,
0.7751553655,
0.6199287772,
0.1107606143,
0.3119116724,
0.063298963,
-0.6108845472,
-0.3447902799,
0.0697866008,
-0.4198144674,
-0.1171244457,
0.3332930803,
-0.0706626922,
-0.1869592369,
0.1165477186,
0.2878980041,
0.3355315328,
-0.4762159884,
0.5999494195,
0.021624919,
-1.2157665491,
0.5962936878,
-0.1175937727,
0.8278392553,
-0.6911749244,
-0.0878933594,
-0.2525674105,
0.3118160069,
-0.1521921754,
-1.1242115498,
-0.1417819709,
0.0107799824,
-0.1717768461,
-0.1637236327,
0.6717101932,
-0.4976120889,
-0.2872508764,
0.20695737,
0.4113588631,
-0.2971713841,
-0.1359848082,
-0.7709966898,
0.3073162138,
-0.0161582269,
-0.1799850166,
0.0466902703,
0.6667950749,
-0.0423104353,
0.9384806752,
0.7979646325,
-0.0164205171,
0.1355201602,
0.210168615,
1.149056077,
-0.7480002642,
-0.5974648595,
-1.2553806305,
0.3627949953,
-0.2405297458,
-0.2179354876,
1.0783023834,
0.1918569207,
0.5627773404,
0.04664753,
0.5625219345,
0.0540085025,
0.2216824293,
-0.7171090245,
-0.0119557492,
-0.1617318094,
0.5098505616,
-0.3287164867,
-0.8297559619,
-0.2653556466,
0.4093804955,
-0.3360874951,
0.1887309402,
0.631754756,
0.6569663882,
0.2946700752,
0.0490414388,
-0.0866306573,
0.0781168044,
0.5762810111,
0.6447484493,
0.939804256,
0.243214488,
0.6927183867,
-0.0981787592,
-0.4469092488,
-0.0244890451,
-0.8209686279,
-0.9651635885,
-0.2237402946,
-0.173981905,
-0.4670064747,
0.3675826788,
0.9135918021,
0.5309404731,
-0.6387214065,
0.0591764152,
-0.3958535492,
0.2178327441,
-0.4567733109,
-0.2408980578,
0.486450702,
-0.6205214858,
-0.6094517112,
0.2816642225,
0.5423374772,
-0.0540486425,
-0.5127705336,
-0.2063667774,
-0.2162188441,
0.1849864274,
0.5252034664,
0.2187948674,
-0.8999647498,
-0.3076242805,
0.2885286212,
0.0279700644,
0.1794272363,
0.9037488103,
-0.9329571128,
0.6146070361,
0.5742201209,
0.2198847085,
0.2525472939,
0.3647065759,
0.856435895,
-0.6496006846,
-0.0979745463,
0.2151758373,
0.105453752,
0.4042612016,
-0.6255351901,
0.1671115607,
0.208236441,
-0.4994897842,
-0.7992874384,
0.4387335777,
-0.7714296579,
-0.1522193849,
1.1446920633,
-0.4907860756,
-0.292506367,
-0.1478998214,
-0.4432610571,
0.0216248464,
-0.7448468804,
0.6658933759,
0.8272348046,
-0.427534759,
-0.559725821,
-0.4388565421,
0.6513853073,
0.3466993272,
-0.7099917531,
0.2619450092,
0.4231655896,
0.3407314122,
0.1428688765,
0.9618002772,
-0.1816103607,
0.5849480033,
-0.167027548,
-0.3937229812,
-0.2149287462,
-0.3993913233,
-0.4108310044,
0.2553335428,
0.2966564,
0.1682059467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11062v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11062v2 | Scaling Transformer to 1M tokens and beyond with RMT | 2023-04-19T16:18:54 | 2024-02-06T10:16:54 | Aydar Bulatov, Yuri Kuratov, Yermek Kapushev, Mikhail S. Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A major limitation for the broader scope of problems solvable by transformers
is the quadratic scaling of computational complexity with input size. In this
study, we investigate the recurrent memory augmentation of pre-trained
transformer models to extend input context length while linearly scaling
compute. Our approach demonstrates the capability to store information in
memory for sequences of up to an unprecedented two million tokens while
maintaining high retrieval accuracy. Experiments with language modeling tasks
show perplexity improvement as the number of processed input segments
increases. These results underscore the effectiveness of our method, which has
significant potential to enhance long-term dependency handling in natural
language understanding and generation tasks, as well as enable large-scale
context processing for memory-intensive applications. | [
-0.6691189408,
-0.5971582532,
0.5091863275,
0.3000115454,
0.0413242951,
-0.1507805437,
-0.3336558044,
-0.4468717873,
0.0045534768,
0.4578971565,
-0.5285602212,
0.2278879583,
-0.8200179935,
0.114093028,
-0.3020904958,
0.9962152839,
-0.113333039,
-0.1520262808,
-0.0337984562,
-0.3839628398,
-0.9708178043,
-0.8012500405,
-0.672067225,
-0.3381102085,
0.6070969701,
0.3810547888,
0.7520753741,
0.6006178856,
0.6715875864,
0.2823047936,
-0.0814120546,
0.0110847969,
-0.531894505,
0.3161616325,
-0.2709029615,
-0.5349012613,
-0.4631592929,
-0.1994399577,
0.8722877502,
0.6313903332,
-0.0991647616,
0.3211100996,
-0.1402904242,
0.4969476759,
-0.5070171356,
0.1092959791,
-0.6475206017,
0.1458872855,
0.0771968365,
-0.2374971956,
-0.6721611023,
0.1179712787,
0.3735147417,
-0.5610141158,
0.1564424485,
-0.1028492898,
0.7314237952,
0.489058882,
-0.3259750605,
-0.0077979183,
-1.0535393953,
0.8847500086,
-0.5215664506,
0.4763881564,
0.1568655223,
0.4144142866,
-0.0173828788,
-1.1607978344,
-0.4996583164,
0.0124029648,
-0.4479843676,
-0.3605090976,
-0.3675432205,
0.1877409071,
0.7287580967,
0.3765975237,
-0.2504706979,
-0.2149558961,
-0.4854050577,
-0.049117364,
0.1340091974,
0.3424887955,
0.1721995771,
-0.0240311977,
-0.3065575659,
-0.0507044047,
-0.3227521777,
-0.1046737358,
-0.3365143239,
0.2793962955,
0.2929864228,
0.4380742311,
0.1574368626,
0.627302587,
0.3297123015,
0.1506795883,
0.033111725,
-0.595918417,
-0.2153383046,
-0.1423833817,
0.3119800389,
-0.0000261467,
-0.002971309,
-0.2259192914,
-0.1169796586,
-0.1723956317,
0.7966489196,
-1.1894907951,
-0.0035382202,
-0.032030791,
-0.1795692444,
0.0760474876,
-0.0299570635,
-0.6218665242,
-0.1729123592,
-0.4472538829,
0.775852561,
-0.4853258729,
-0.119718045,
0.2767762542,
-0.0941729024,
0.2569968998,
0.1243412495,
-1.0616441965,
0.3738442659,
0.6122564673,
0.7410296202,
-0.035972368,
-0.2035428137,
-0.4401319921,
-0.175730139,
0.0612985007,
0.3850138485,
-0.5660519004,
-0.2410518378,
-0.2839260101,
-0.021727724,
-0.0162776057,
-0.5319689512,
0.4368325472,
-0.6720939875,
0.239576906,
-0.1365952343,
-0.3365161717,
-0.0322655067,
0.2495571226,
-0.7383793592,
1.2356579304,
0.5730603933,
-0.6567685008,
0.2352405787,
-0.7957638502,
-0.6533979177,
0.0387050882,
-0.123169601,
-0.4623171091,
0.3080088794,
0.3268604875,
0.2774831951,
-0.3863860667,
0.3264736533,
0.3180559874,
-0.5454611778,
0.2298808247,
-0.6540669799,
0.3750429153,
-0.0557162762,
-0.3868667483,
0.213141948,
-0.6809199452,
-0.2488377988,
0.0735320821,
-0.6124075055,
-0.0260966476,
-0.3059703112,
-0.0120302541,
0.2607157826,
0.4903407097,
-0.6298632622,
0.3025254607,
-0.4487506747,
0.8541907668,
0.562358439,
-0.2471020073,
0.7205863595,
-0.1576082259,
0.6129772067,
0.202850908,
0.1939895898,
-0.9068749547,
-0.0105708074,
-1.0171324015,
-0.0649272203,
0.2402584404,
0.3048621714,
-0.6582825184,
0.4775171578,
-0.7708114982,
-0.2209702432,
-0.3419704437,
-0.1829491109,
0.0273746103,
0.6579501629,
0.798510313,
-0.2083158493,
-0.8728961349,
-1.0831025839,
-0.029246578,
0.1574911922,
-0.5245989561,
0.3041870594,
0.3225264251,
-0.50367558,
1.3375159502,
-0.4980612397,
-0.229413271,
-0.2257288843,
0.2011502683,
0.3332242072,
0.5180723071,
0.1589208543,
-0.6941014528,
-0.1661318988,
0.0911505446,
-0.3105127513,
0.2351915389,
-0.342179805,
0.2250670493,
0.1509854645,
0.4430110455,
-0.9041594267,
0.3761021793,
0.3413596451,
-0.3356526494,
0.3647150099,
-0.4295704365,
-0.1057455167,
-1.1263748407,
0.097097069,
-0.1883553863,
-0.3791951239,
-0.7546626329,
-0.047704719,
0.3727043569,
-0.1559827328,
-0.2772698402,
0.3421227038,
-0.3398892879,
0.0835611299,
-0.3044862747,
-0.1112457216,
0.0956166238,
0.5993102193,
-0.0946520343,
1.0108659267,
0.2720058262,
-0.4344398975,
0.0856313184,
0.0194663238,
-0.0998615101,
0.3903791904,
-0.5924103856,
0.2413021922,
-0.278195709,
0.5206537843,
-1.0992212296,
0.1112860218,
-0.3806829751,
-0.521615088,
0.4096259773,
0.1371520162,
-0.450168997,
-0.3941348493,
-0.0948989838,
0.7771369815,
0.58023417,
-0.7864691615,
1.1501181126,
0.1218258217,
-0.049749326,
-0.7081871629,
-0.6678386331,
0.1798572242,
-0.1521938294,
-0.5904595852,
0.394295156,
0.2502071261,
0.2403090298,
-0.201528728,
-0.3016813397,
0.0142226014,
-0.1153983474,
0.3111561835,
0.2646420896,
-0.5303930044,
0.3745677471,
-0.1058682501,
-0.2329453081,
0.2090933919,
-0.5012350082,
0.8639940023,
-0.2417664826,
0.0951402709,
-0.2460632026,
0.1979556382,
0.8401202559,
-0.2032589167,
0.8193208575,
0.634067297,
-0.4414636195,
-0.0920865238,
-0.5094795227,
-0.3657941818,
-0.5466819406,
0.6638381481,
-0.4581485093,
-1.3102920055,
0.4184732139,
-0.2197116762,
0.1372396946,
0.5105034709,
0.2919713259,
0.1219855919,
0.7482913136,
0.6622521281,
-0.4218434393,
0.5544394851,
-0.1941241473,
0.5435279012,
-1.0242351294,
0.207257539,
-0.192067802,
-0.6229650378,
-0.3780173361,
-0.8185818791,
0.1909267902,
-0.1262565255,
-0.469165504,
0.712710619,
-0.5944653153,
0.5982671976,
0.2789382339,
0.0979898125,
0.2097679079,
-0.0620821156,
0.054797601,
-0.2514393628,
-0.6990434527,
-0.0851001069,
1.0266599655,
0.7888892889,
0.5528303981,
-0.0830071792,
0.1573966146,
-0.021778997,
0.4457243979,
-0.7773268223,
0.3246141076,
-0.0988652781,
-0.5225381851,
-0.769061923,
-0.3672668934,
-0.9714409113,
0.254928261,
-0.1016373411,
-0.6586149931,
-0.009794117,
0.1034054756,
-0.4428286552,
0.4112739861,
-0.4020558,
0.4816924036,
0.038206026,
-0.3449876606,
-0.3701395392,
-0.7919785976,
0.0865169093,
-0.1030943692,
-0.118705444,
0.5599349141,
-0.0226297881,
0.6132029891,
-0.4466528296,
0.5906307697,
-0.0133434348,
-0.0475657545,
0.1210652366,
-0.0134434626,
0.5508434772,
0.0159835033,
0.0497612879,
0.2050030529,
-0.1979539841,
-0.4287628829,
-0.8856117725,
0.5817068219,
-0.5716215968,
-0.6747938991,
-0.0998261124,
-1.007332325,
-0.2846604288,
0.1860378534,
0.1901673228,
0.4665853977,
-0.0349062495,
0.4723221958,
0.7891414165,
-0.178463906,
0.4303609133,
0.1576281637,
-0.1635936797,
-0.3616636992,
0.6459727883,
0.2482271791,
0.3851020634,
0.5406724215,
0.0993167758,
-0.2555737495,
-0.2513405681,
-0.4526486099,
0.1335595399,
-0.6535347104,
-0.3111872673,
-0.8433579803,
-0.450967133,
-0.1695467532,
-0.0689215064,
-0.5082627535,
-0.6475057006,
-0.0625716001,
-0.341557622,
0.4192727804,
0.6970307231,
0.265902549,
0.6204509139,
-0.6243721247,
0.1553825587,
0.3219469786,
0.5535182953,
0.314604789,
-0.8366034627,
-0.5135284662,
-0.1411287934,
-0.2863372564,
-0.2748869359,
0.2646352947,
-0.2414984703,
0.0502819456,
0.1936350465,
-0.3833026886,
1.011631608,
-0.7757180929,
0.7633298635,
0.1454731524,
-0.8532080054,
0.2667366564,
-0.2949015498,
0.798376441,
0.4955744743,
0.1775292009,
-0.4752714932,
0.0479403995,
-0.449924022,
-0.9835119843,
0.6569597721,
0.283066541,
0.5330034494,
0.0135451853,
0.7337630391,
-0.1169022322,
-0.2015572488,
-0.5588203669,
-0.3679279685,
-0.0654822364,
-0.0920181945,
-0.122566238,
-0.515265882,
0.2301605791,
-0.6466992497,
0.2935316265,
0.1388022304,
0.4675558805,
0.197394222,
-0.0766163096,
-0.0891880095,
0.4048695862,
0.8003003001,
0.7027420998,
-0.0725441352,
0.347573489,
0.695306778,
-0.7563994527,
0.1935498118,
0.0899673402,
0.1993883252,
0.0034184698,
0.1292567104,
0.8588498235,
0.580626905,
-0.5993673205,
0.291762054,
-0.3820789456,
-0.2662212551,
-0.532731235,
-0.132104516,
0.3061898351,
0.1051888764,
0.6763722897,
0.1411989182,
-0.0998367146,
-0.195484519,
0.5984779,
0.3046517968,
-0.6026549339,
-0.2541102767,
0.5348555446,
0.0548169129,
-0.3914893866,
0.9070496559,
0.29105106,
-0.5174639821,
0.5001747012,
0.9734319448,
0.5260173678,
-0.4543180466,
-0.3852258623,
0.6710812449,
0.3583309054,
-0.2142479122,
-0.257956177,
-0.2669779658,
-0.6808703542,
-0.6807973981,
-0.660504818,
-0.1273997426,
0.2494616359,
-0.6733244658,
0.3202429116,
-0.611789763,
-0.3964378536,
-0.0719401836,
-0.2087927908,
-0.6552879214,
0.0800929368,
-0.0652104169,
0.9117441773,
-0.343662858,
1.0693666935,
0.3497543931,
-0.1223386079,
-0.7731616497,
-0.2904630601,
-0.4945607483,
-0.436186105,
0.8796248436,
0.4989685416,
-0.1602738053,
0.0589112192,
-0.0627078414,
-1.0159024,
1.1988351345,
0.1929099858,
-0.6758583784,
-0.331638217,
0.568379879,
0.6761066318,
-0.3608187437,
0.2773388922,
1.0015748739,
0.4462789595,
0.0807491243,
-0.9628379941,
0.2172391266,
-0.0859228,
0.1912360489,
0.6200940609,
-0.1974557936,
1.0548975468,
-0.0359333791,
-0.3800528049,
-0.0946145877,
0.8150005937,
0.0476587713,
-0.1707183123,
0.60470891,
0.6377013922,
0.512460053,
0.0954813287,
0.9926995635,
-0.2077563256,
0.347833097,
1.4737080336,
0.0152699817,
0.7054416537,
0.6223691106,
-0.2121494561,
0.5263085365,
0.1112839654,
0.1208141074,
-0.0348269455,
0.3430861533,
-0.4256602228,
-0.0456665792,
-0.0779806376,
-0.0652770847,
0.1045490131,
0.481055975,
-0.6220664978,
-0.1320437044,
0.2121365517,
0.0569329299,
-0.0104339346,
-0.2493504733,
0.4993271232,
0.018586047,
-0.5940230489,
0.5472770333,
-0.0193117261,
0.9337087274,
-0.3611238897,
-0.1736797094,
-0.0385062546,
0.3977757692,
-0.0947220773,
-0.5269283056,
0.5157692432,
-0.1368459016,
-0.3997868299,
-0.3897557259,
0.6550950408,
-0.3015729189,
-0.5749733448,
0.2165615857,
0.1037529781,
-0.2999127209,
-0.233824566,
-0.1051104516,
-0.0259119682,
-0.2581171691,
-0.4378344417,
0.4708986878,
0.3342175484,
-0.0916419774,
0.6033642292,
0.3201230466,
-0.2509097755,
0.3206821382,
-0.056820903,
1.0006539822,
-0.7986109257,
-0.1296222806,
-1.0202406645,
0.5295515656,
0.0887925699,
-0.177387923,
0.5557718277,
0.6332086921,
0.6811249852,
-0.1127293259,
0.5808987021,
-0.0015826715,
0.2762578428,
0.0454131924,
0.4038629234,
-0.0424051546,
0.1448791325,
0.223630175,
-0.81755054,
-0.5089265704,
0.5504590273,
-0.3433404863,
-0.0717463195,
0.6603731513,
0.6426975727,
-0.1691627949,
0.1051549241,
0.4203547239,
0.1956868768,
0.3892620802,
0.7047628164,
0.5690842867,
-0.5834140778,
0.5523827672,
-0.1057582423,
-0.0494459607,
0.020431079,
-0.5127019882,
-0.9534682631,
-0.7133458853,
0.2301520556,
-0.2027704269,
-0.419783324,
0.799757123,
0.7227088213,
-0.5693267584,
-0.0306013022,
-0.2377986312,
-0.1522663981,
-0.099591814,
-0.2965641618,
0.172315076,
-0.5851674676,
-0.5650142431,
0.1680783033,
0.4542465806,
-0.1331942081,
-0.6238281727,
0.0756485835,
-0.0336955264,
0.2356054336,
1.0860447884,
0.1012304351,
-0.5693836212,
-0.588257134,
0.3109280765,
0.0176591631,
0.4713999331,
1.10293293,
-1.1181149483,
0.3823004663,
0.4107373357,
1.0018861294,
0.7585921884,
0.1307799965,
0.803786397,
-0.7949894667,
0.1727124006,
0.2130517811,
0.2461883277,
0.0963361114,
-0.6606542468,
0.3832023442,
-0.3976835012,
-0.5983948708,
-0.5477939844,
0.2428591847,
-0.9194599986,
-0.2558182776,
0.7155584097,
0.0297441185,
-0.0263036806,
-0.0740065351,
-0.3874303997,
0.1485689282,
-0.1417832822,
0.6485999823,
0.7541139126,
-0.2111078501,
-0.4182129502,
-0.5003144145,
0.3117973506,
0.7023140192,
-0.4717335701,
0.3310984373,
0.1404536217,
0.1972108334,
0.4848659933,
0.5136076808,
-0.2948498428,
0.1618620157,
-0.1141744778,
-0.0327044278,
0.0397221893,
-0.3625496626,
-0.6498764157,
0.342225194,
0.0521360449,
0.1125287488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09667v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09667v3 | GeneGPT: Augmenting Large Language Models with Domain Tools for Improved Access to Biomedical Information | 2023-04-19T13:53:19 | 2023-05-16T13:24:53 | Qiao Jin, Yifan Yang, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.GN | While large language models (LLMs) have been successfully applied to various
tasks, they still face challenges with hallucinations. Augmenting LLMs with
domain-specific tools such as database utilities can facilitate easier and more
precise access to specialized knowledge. In this paper, we present GeneGPT, a
novel method for teaching LLMs to use the Web APIs of the National Center for
Biotechnology Information (NCBI) for answering genomics questions.
Specifically, we prompt Codex to solve the GeneTuring tests with NCBI Web APIs
by in-context learning and an augmented decoding algorithm that can detect and
execute API calls. Experimental results show that GeneGPT achieves
state-of-the-art performance on eight tasks in the GeneTuring benchmark with an
average score of 0.83, largely surpassing retrieval-augmented LLMs such as the
new Bing (0.44), biomedical LLMs such as BioMedLM (0.08) and BioGPT (0.04), as
well as GPT-3 (0.16) and ChatGPT (0.12). Our further analyses suggest that: (1)
API demonstrations have good cross-task generalizability and are more useful
than documentations for in-context learning; (2) GeneGPT can generalize to
longer chains of API calls and answer multi-hop questions in GeneHop, a novel
dataset introduced in this work; (3) Different types of errors are enriched in
different tasks, providing valuable insights for future improvements. | [
-0.5173977017,
-0.9841745496,
0.4980780482,
-0.065279372,
-0.1628353149,
0.5523649454,
-0.1821862012,
-0.4428991675,
0.1762147993,
0.3706825376,
-0.7042266726,
-0.59841609,
-0.5233223438,
0.2256766856,
-0.3645080328,
0.9048873782,
-0.0881653428,
0.4061656296,
-0.309977442,
0.3261423707,
-0.2410441041,
-0.6138666868,
-0.4899398983,
-0.2927127481,
0.4650193155,
0.2573011816,
0.4285331964,
0.5649609566,
0.5966624618,
0.1859197468,
0.0405836292,
0.1683209687,
-0.4797315598,
-0.1814035326,
-0.2933444381,
-0.4230980873,
-0.4738716185,
-0.0828429833,
0.1680763662,
1.2827810049,
0.13470532,
0.2505626976,
0.2318154275,
0.5216054916,
-0.1522867829,
0.2606199384,
-0.3744077384,
0.0299638957,
-0.0567631833,
-0.5790248513,
-0.3244564831,
-0.3785822988,
0.3693897128,
-0.7227957845,
0.4361919761,
0.0499360748,
0.5490612388,
0.3403226435,
-0.3159512281,
-0.4151820838,
-0.3116952181,
0.4428669214,
-0.6439769864,
0.2750055194,
0.3479259014,
0.2922799885,
-0.4058352411,
-0.7297773361,
-0.4624828696,
-0.3582804799,
0.0534747653,
0.0566328391,
-0.0166207943,
0.1658758074,
0.4486350417,
0.3828767836,
-0.8529077768,
-0.0250109937,
-0.3779090941,
-0.2109155953,
0.112625502,
-0.1598488837,
0.6643565893,
-0.1064660326,
-0.3245831728,
-0.3016981184,
-0.6780795455,
-0.1713638604,
0.2038922757,
0.3432653546,
0.2478287965,
0.6184199452,
0.0183588974,
0.8137738109,
0.0047078952,
0.1273604184,
0.3213670254,
0.0761180073,
-0.0872798935,
0.0200262032,
0.2322242856,
0.2704159021,
0.0969673544,
-0.4468108416,
0.2135059386,
-0.0294237137,
0.2248275876,
-0.7368482351,
-0.2510981262,
0.4020279944,
-0.4181344807,
0.0704100654,
-0.0675900429,
-1.2116404772,
-0.4263107181,
-0.3433826864,
0.5343414545,
-0.6940502524,
-0.0861470327,
0.4005751908,
-0.389840275,
0.4850162268,
0.1777567565,
-0.8665435314,
0.239716202,
0.85373348,
1.0089031458,
-0.263248086,
-0.1260273308,
-0.4353138208,
0.1519676596,
0.0442682616,
1.0091065168,
-0.5720038414,
-0.4965426922,
-0.2876958847,
0.0404956602,
-0.114558965,
-0.5901861787,
0.1432376206,
-0.3984335959,
-0.2129192352,
-0.3444672227,
-0.9433720708,
-0.2730149925,
0.191001296,
-0.3982285559,
0.6963810921,
0.2454563528,
-0.528526783,
0.2543407679,
-0.8761828542,
-0.3490388393,
0.3790631294,
-0.2485701293,
0.0429229811,
-0.4016392231,
0.3805137575,
0.5685375333,
0.0290277097,
0.1412200481,
-0.3102269769,
-0.4662104249,
0.1411766112,
-0.1838288605,
0.7786809802,
-0.2021873593,
-0.6715381742,
-0.0432814136,
-0.7310817242,
0.0830344856,
0.0384568796,
-0.3281506896,
-0.2468919903,
-0.2308690697,
-0.0580044724,
-0.1763786227,
-0.066894412,
-0.5912925005,
0.7465299964,
-0.662689507,
0.5467963219,
0.7005764246,
-0.0060911495,
0.3252910972,
-0.2422208637,
0.6529530287,
-0.4509533942,
0.1154702231,
0.0128918914,
-0.7136096954,
-0.592423141,
-0.2006382495,
0.2351067811,
0.810901165,
-1.0974593163,
0.3904958963,
-0.3811990023,
-0.4997798502,
-0.3659446239,
0.1715881377,
0.3011775613,
0.59580791,
0.749422729,
-0.275006175,
-0.3761024475,
-0.6060800552,
-0.0290211365,
0.150915429,
-0.3970384598,
0.3285070956,
0.5638588667,
-0.5333596468,
0.8118382692,
-0.4983440042,
0.06506221,
-0.3085260987,
0.3916311264,
0.3914460838,
0.3584694564,
0.4246736467,
-0.70126158,
-0.2616990507,
0.0309164319,
-0.4785585403,
-0.3054552674,
0.1016233712,
-0.2113314867,
-0.1038291231,
0.3847846985,
-0.3664127588,
0.3027152419,
0.6449485421,
-0.2699484825,
0.5707083941,
-0.0744768754,
0.2127220035,
-1.0561605692,
0.1018389761,
-0.0932093114,
-0.1422838867,
-0.5995034575,
0.2319733649,
0.0553126149,
-0.0727753565,
-0.3103320003,
0.5401314497,
-0.5349026918,
-0.3108445704,
-0.467687577,
0.0576038696,
-0.1044840962,
0.4452076256,
-0.0455520786,
0.9739065766,
0.5989485979,
-0.4955282211,
0.5193318129,
0.5865834355,
-0.288279146,
0.1748356819,
-0.4211206138,
0.3343290389,
-0.1691451669,
0.4801174402,
-0.7305772305,
-0.3827533424,
0.2540672123,
-0.6043914557,
0.2907332778,
-0.4543713927,
-0.4340283573,
-0.4738467038,
-0.2423194945,
0.1619791687,
0.5963589549,
-0.9283612967,
0.5338971019,
0.2590228915,
-0.2891981602,
-0.6312445402,
-0.7921171784,
0.169665724,
0.0829498693,
-0.5077702403,
0.1117717996,
-0.2123690695,
0.1077574566,
-0.0286913924,
-0.0971675813,
-0.1249780282,
-0.0626477227,
0.2484214008,
0.4064563215,
-0.1410789043,
0.3015374839,
0.1038684472,
-0.0320208743,
0.0659580082,
-0.4605084956,
0.790137589,
-0.1771979332,
-0.5442538261,
0.0862991512,
0.3972388208,
0.0821030736,
-0.1726147234,
0.3977892697,
0.7569218874,
-0.1928037554,
-0.3879230917,
-0.3047251999,
-0.3846991658,
-0.4898851812,
0.1973571777,
-0.0814725831,
-1.1795897484,
0.2885968387,
-0.5383354425,
0.0189892258,
0.1508920342,
0.4516973794,
0.0074012424,
0.5882855654,
0.397687614,
0.1530979872,
0.0800442398,
-0.5197723508,
0.4221315086,
-0.9169422984,
-0.036759235,
-0.2939673364,
-0.2059475332,
-0.3127334118,
-0.7950688601,
0.5553751588,
0.0395899862,
-0.1486829519,
0.2320164442,
-0.5790963173,
0.565397203,
0.7263706326,
0.4389916062,
0.1300117522,
0.1966069639,
-0.1755301356,
0.299015224,
-0.7606752515,
-0.5570504069,
1.3083498478,
0.0930237174,
0.7912804484,
0.1325132996,
0.5679969192,
0.1116181538,
0.5725319982,
-0.7817102671,
0.5104048252,
-0.2507530451,
-0.4890292883,
-0.1482595056,
-0.5058417916,
-0.7565893531,
-0.0584441312,
-0.1687822938,
-0.9193874598,
0.3883958757,
0.2944943905,
-0.6127806306,
0.4986030757,
-0.7321678996,
0.7120657563,
-0.268999666,
-0.3291252255,
0.1907534599,
-0.7692655921,
0.2450733483,
-0.064677,
0.2155020833,
0.0356301703,
0.0335206315,
0.5008456707,
-0.2383364886,
1.006182909,
-0.1161849797,
0.0930926129,
0.0660943836,
0.0651217625,
0.2018308938,
0.0522634722,
0.0324565172,
0.1535740346,
0.1753751189,
-0.3540871143,
-0.5821061134,
0.6421576142,
-0.3551761508,
-0.6774205565,
-0.3861116469,
-0.6153705716,
-0.6030668616,
0.017914895,
0.1506088376,
0.5952296257,
0.1221985295,
0.1185017526,
1.0489780903,
-0.8969875574,
0.0057828571,
0.3139106929,
-0.2587487698,
-0.0690364465,
0.8744895458,
-0.196219638,
0.4359605312,
0.5068318844,
0.2554187775,
-0.2887081802,
-0.4258130491,
-0.5320858359,
0.0417336784,
-0.9564214349,
-0.3588202298,
-0.9531100392,
-0.1424618065,
-0.6773201823,
-0.2492559552,
0.1431540996,
-0.1961440146,
-0.1382348686,
-0.3690796793,
0.6140773892,
0.3897528946,
-0.2417295128,
0.208494395,
-1.0262694359,
0.4757526219,
0.3889903724,
0.446444869,
-0.0410962254,
-0.1902434081,
0.1077613607,
0.0112949228,
-0.0338591561,
-1.1770029068,
0.3707031906,
0.2191613913,
0.5326464772,
0.0237788577,
-0.3554605544,
0.6436550021,
-0.6093151569,
0.7988065481,
-0.2503320277,
-0.9182803631,
0.4424868524,
-0.5130941868,
0.0006763583,
0.4194245934,
0.5842561722,
-0.46401757,
-0.1728244573,
-0.2295247912,
-1.0397019386,
0.2103466094,
-0.1588200182,
0.0698470175,
-0.2132324129,
0.7603046298,
0.305054009,
-0.0011625491,
-0.4662020504,
-0.2522852421,
-0.2204542756,
-0.3086871505,
-0.0117023261,
-0.1656202525,
-0.0297889244,
-0.5160431266,
0.718346715,
-0.4583463073,
0.5167796612,
0.4809736609,
-0.1274888068,
0.0970597118,
0.4063466191,
0.3196584284,
0.7619652152,
-0.3491558731,
0.0086996472,
0.0167436153,
-0.6880012155,
-0.036973685,
0.4170064926,
0.0998412818,
-0.190095678,
0.3700665534,
0.3922658265,
0.1987198591,
-1.0994520187,
0.5258523822,
0.1231852174,
-0.294746995,
-0.0854839087,
-0.0413964055,
0.2143470049,
0.3705138564,
0.5575475693,
-0.2736684084,
0.6380810738,
-0.4335255325,
0.462135911,
0.2797513604,
-0.0654192567,
0.247938633,
0.693805635,
-0.0136124883,
0.1344375014,
0.4741723835,
-0.2842068374,
-0.65850389,
0.7092425227,
0.6410474777,
0.6184643507,
-0.1359824687,
0.3711788356,
0.3367162645,
0.2551479936,
-0.1341107339,
0.3208959103,
0.1411258578,
-0.5580571294,
-0.7370089889,
-0.7840410471,
-0.7189359665,
-0.0425612628,
-0.4559141099,
-0.1434116364,
-0.3148308694,
0.0652827621,
0.0627132058,
-0.2648096979,
-0.477483809,
-0.0958574787,
-0.0594340861,
0.9929149747,
-0.5534819365,
0.7035295963,
0.664885819,
-0.3508275449,
-0.9804736972,
-0.0389715508,
0.0849486217,
-0.902987361,
0.6978868842,
0.1532100141,
0.0680562481,
0.3273198307,
-0.7083258629,
-0.769502461,
1.0293983221,
0.2816553116,
-0.6592470407,
-0.01250898,
0.205155015,
0.4791520834,
0.0662191138,
0.009724929,
0.5010989904,
0.5579714775,
0.06721659,
-0.7728346586,
-0.0260177981,
-0.2862852514,
-0.3376974463,
0.1298848391,
-0.1450479329,
0.799336791,
-0.0411127396,
-0.1130297557,
0.1123704314,
0.1838136464,
0.1889025271,
0.1534026116,
0.3728129268,
0.3792614639,
0.7932569981,
-0.2364852577,
1.3671934605,
-0.2745016515,
0.3611605465,
0.9630820155,
-0.1531478465,
0.6193860769,
0.4548140466,
-0.1936787814,
0.2079744488,
0.7520166039,
-0.2732951045,
0.2107381523,
0.6967489719,
-0.3771483302,
-0.0923161581,
0.0194335524,
-0.3006897569,
0.0417460315,
0.578317225,
-0.0985233486,
-0.261139214,
0.489817977,
-0.1567219943,
0.1087895334,
-0.3762406111,
0.5275515914,
0.0754525065,
-0.1911293268,
0.3161191046,
-0.2566380203,
0.7798706293,
-0.5734781623,
-0.4982588291,
-0.2306294441,
-0.0679307058,
-0.1680938005,
-0.690433085,
0.1436196715,
0.1228000596,
0.0576516353,
-0.1346445829,
0.6292017102,
-0.3982221186,
-0.6206645966,
0.4090428054,
0.5690110326,
0.3016210496,
-0.0043277773,
-0.535335958,
-0.1215338632,
-0.1973837465,
-0.1219989583,
0.1053173915,
0.0248726066,
0.1946922392,
0.8116980791,
0.825917244,
0.1829027832,
0.3726033568,
0.2197363973,
0.833540976,
-0.4366534054,
-0.1234725788,
-0.6128063202,
-0.1058616638,
-0.0660654232,
0.1128525361,
0.6090019345,
0.501590848,
1.0147356987,
-0.2126550972,
1.0659492016,
-0.1858872771,
0.8652321696,
-0.7168003917,
0.5625701547,
-0.2835222185,
0.2241306603,
-0.2531821132,
-0.8039842844,
-0.575842917,
0.6048647761,
-0.4752539098,
0.0961178914,
0.7955152392,
0.9011586905,
-0.0755446926,
0.0251240302,
0.1333594322,
0.214150995,
0.4063996971,
0.7092862129,
0.6306791306,
-0.1398766488,
0.3228735924,
-0.3012861609,
-0.652045548,
-0.1023372263,
-0.7115251422,
-0.9986980557,
-0.3862578571,
0.0469505712,
-0.2858502269,
0.422565043,
1.2231860161,
0.4711785316,
-0.690600276,
0.0382407643,
0.0544986613,
-0.3107470572,
-0.2720360458,
-0.2320587635,
0.6865488887,
-0.3639034629,
-0.6470759511,
0.5934252739,
0.3844009638,
0.0913858637,
-0.1332717091,
0.2737933099,
-0.2818744481,
-0.0974235907,
0.5322306752,
0.3773860335,
-0.4890295863,
-0.3872810602,
0.1210832745,
0.0844828859,
0.0025802134,
0.9363157749,
-0.5933878422,
0.2767425478,
0.3450222611,
1.2773834467,
0.331926465,
0.1341970861,
0.5565444827,
-0.5786388516,
-0.0391192511,
0.2867015302,
0.3257756531,
0.4406614304,
-0.6641064286,
0.626544714,
0.2133331746,
-0.5406728387,
-0.4183129966,
0.0398008488,
-1.2557045221,
-0.5639184117,
1.2312812805,
0.030375842,
-0.4590831101,
-0.3515150547,
-0.3430337608,
0.3214158714,
0.0266869608,
0.7448024154,
0.5889885426,
-0.2219139487,
-0.154088974,
-1.0349391699,
0.5187969208,
0.1522485912,
-1.0798932314,
-0.1022256389,
0.4262450337,
0.4813199341,
-0.0794321224,
0.5157527924,
-0.1856762767,
0.24517259,
-0.1981639564,
0.208392635,
-0.0291546397,
0.0787449032,
-0.1699210703,
-0.0141166719,
-0.1768109947,
0.2277709246
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.