id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01155v1 | Lessons Learned in ATCO2: 5000 hours of Air Traffic Control Communications for Robust Automatic Speech Recognition and Understanding | 2023-05-02T02:04:33 | 2023-05-02T02:04:33 | Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Iuliia Nigmatulina, Amrutha Prasad, Petr Motlicek, Driss Khalil, Srikanth Madikeri, Allan Tart, Igor Szoke, Vincent Lenders, Mickael Rigault, Khalid Choukri | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD | Voice communication between air traffic controllers (ATCos) and pilots is
critical for ensuring safe and efficient air traffic control (ATC). This task
requires high levels of awareness from ATCos and can be tedious and
error-prone. Recent attempts have been made to integrate artificial
intelligence (AI) into ATC in order to reduce the workload of ATCos. However,
the development of data-driven AI systems for ATC demands large-scale annotated
datasets, which are currently lacking in the field. This paper explores the
lessons learned from the ATCO2 project, a project that aimed to develop a
unique platform to collect and preprocess large amounts of ATC data from
airspace in real time. Audio and surveillance data were collected from publicly
accessible radio frequency channels with VHF receivers owned by a community of
volunteers and later uploaded to Opensky Network servers, which can be
considered an "unlimited source" of data. In addition, this paper reviews
previous work from ATCO2 partners, including (i) robust automatic speech
recognition, (ii) natural language processing, (iii) English language
identification of ATC communications, and (iv) the integration of surveillance
data such as ADS-B. We believe that the pipeline developed during the ATCO2
project, along with the open-sourcing of its data, will encourage research in
the ATC field. A sample of the ATCO2 corpus is available on the following
website: https://www.atco2.org/data, while the full corpus can be purchased
through ELDA at http://catalog.elra.info/en-us/repository/browse/ELRA-S0484. We
demonstrated that ATCO2 is an appropriate dataset to develop ASR engines when
little or near to no ATC in-domain data is available. For instance, with the
CNN-TDNNf kaldi model, we reached the performance of as low as 17.9% and 24.9%
WER on public ATC datasets which is 6.6/7.6% better than "out-of-domain" but
supervised CNN-TDNNf model. | [
-0.3725532293,
-0.4068294466,
0.4006955028,
0.0279998928,
-0.1883966625,
0.4234522879,
-0.0155692594,
-0.8127673864,
-0.0910683274,
0.5015885234,
-0.0913233161,
-0.3117740452,
-0.5525726676,
-0.2136495262,
-0.6310026646,
0.5520164371,
-0.108404018,
-0.0814333037,
-0.1904142648,
-0.1988565177,
-0.1942859292,
-0.7627136707,
-1.0431189537,
-0.2230898589,
0.3012862802,
0.7251918912,
0.5097460747,
0.9169345498,
0.3907901347,
0.2197499573,
-0.1582812071,
0.2294819057,
-0.0255204067,
-0.2290574312,
0.2533091307,
-0.2411986589,
-0.2628026903,
0.1175440624,
0.650113821,
0.5471764207,
-0.3187300861,
-0.0231361762,
-0.1989170909,
0.5460841656,
-0.6510090828,
0.2188445479,
-0.5929543972,
-0.070204787,
-0.3633738458,
-0.0559916236,
-0.0692058951,
-0.0078040087,
-0.0256635603,
-0.7428643703,
-0.1477903426,
0.0655864701,
0.7441629171,
0.5497789979,
-0.7389678359,
-0.7078540325,
-0.8362222314,
0.9301347733,
-0.4785048962,
0.4645477533,
0.6575223804,
0.5239003897,
0.0374235399,
-0.6787889004,
-0.6405379176,
0.0233956836,
0.1333612204,
0.4348721802,
-0.2941936255,
-0.2371231318,
0.0523298942,
0.0069395872,
-0.3095583916,
0.3220855892,
-0.887685895,
-0.0509476364,
0.8549187779,
0.0718758255,
-0.3392918706,
-0.1529507637,
-0.1486557424,
-0.0050621098,
-0.6413950324,
0.3194443285,
0.539741993,
0.228665024,
-0.2041068673,
0.4731591046,
-0.176838398,
0.4593214989,
-0.4831084907,
0.2602855563,
0.1546294242,
-0.3976311088,
-0.0759167522,
0.3141925931,
0.7354638577,
0.0067323716,
0.3753677607,
-0.0022101647,
-0.2335474938,
0.1344080716,
0.4870887399,
-0.3282647133,
-0.2178662568,
0.4201066792,
-0.5238435268,
-0.5555858612,
0.4168652892,
-0.4539137781,
-0.262176007,
-0.6036502123,
-0.1015271321,
0.1505140662,
-0.3071317673,
-0.0274930634,
0.0614368469,
0.2265210897,
0.3474211991,
-0.5490012765,
0.625931263,
0.8167435527,
0.9374735951,
-0.1698437333,
-0.0580732822,
-0.7106798291,
0.0895772204,
-0.4199435115,
0.8940240741,
-0.2310854793,
-0.6103828549,
-0.0869480446,
-0.0114180399,
0.0965872556,
-0.7890738845,
0.5750723481,
-0.4507673979,
0.0390898138,
-0.1185165793,
-0.1224637032,
-0.0249010138,
-0.3535925448,
-0.6162441373,
0.6004533172,
-0.3322886527,
-0.2352488488,
0.1735214889,
-1.0545717478,
-0.5368490815,
-0.262063086,
-0.4599304497,
-0.5372555852,
-0.0595440492,
0.1619998664,
0.0405201688,
-0.284535706,
0.0590487756,
-0.1708411425,
-0.4831768572,
0.2106987089,
-0.3945596814,
1.1235538721,
0.7208414674,
-0.302449882,
-0.0520948209,
-0.7340641618,
0.1626596004,
-0.0507509075,
-0.4083136916,
0.2319216579,
0.4477125108,
0.3747259378,
0.1552571058,
-0.3474378884,
-0.4087363183,
-0.192625761,
-0.3165919185,
0.9332175255,
0.4946760833,
-0.0615408234,
0.2330175787,
-0.2316947132,
0.3629565537,
0.0637524873,
0.3787222207,
0.1702764481,
-0.5973972678,
-0.841070652,
-0.0387776904,
0.1179223433,
0.586452961,
-0.4245176315,
0.6249037981,
-0.0997432098,
-0.4057750702,
-0.6733183861,
0.0393536575,
0.166913569,
0.3177238405,
0.3485098779,
-0.3383911848,
-0.6732066274,
-0.6752632856,
0.1932581961,
-0.5250782967,
-0.1816416532,
0.5286941528,
0.4033074975,
-0.3078880012,
0.8493881226,
-0.3434220552,
-0.4621302485,
-0.01401251,
0.18148911,
-0.251183182,
0.5804437399,
0.349075377,
-0.9421945214,
-0.3154764473,
0.0445340052,
-0.6571620703,
0.1532159746,
0.0954595506,
0.0806225315,
0.1719328612,
0.7147477865,
-0.4291151166,
0.6613464355,
0.2934724391,
-0.2487201393,
0.2509709597,
0.0508029982,
0.0852760822,
-0.8164524436,
0.3402849138,
-0.4280911386,
-0.2940880656,
-0.6356347799,
-0.4818803072,
-0.2732102573,
-0.3462612927,
-0.6182390451,
0.2717826068,
-0.3771162927,
-0.4180578887,
-0.3827856183,
-0.0955898985,
-0.0582245365,
0.2158112079,
0.170050174,
0.909935534,
0.4673855901,
-0.4050034285,
0.7427790761,
0.5601439476,
-0.4040360749,
0.1405489594,
-0.5695078969,
0.4834395051,
0.0521228015,
0.3247702718,
-0.5640184879,
-0.3303405046,
0.3975916803,
-0.7960482836,
-0.0883683786,
-0.158540085,
-0.4393897355,
-0.2812662721,
-0.1963752806,
0.3999541104,
0.4106871486,
-0.4252192974,
0.5417372584,
0.7651898265,
-0.0160029456,
-0.5160910487,
-0.9098019004,
0.3663158417,
-0.2416912168,
-0.3024366796,
0.0013192559,
0.2942820191,
-0.534807682,
0.0303556379,
-0.1226314306,
-0.4159567654,
0.2011700273,
0.5018905401,
0.1440906823,
-0.0161650479,
-0.0015394911,
-0.1869590133,
-0.1715479642,
0.3442121446,
-0.4733391106,
0.2046712488,
-0.1389010847,
-0.4454371631,
-0.7032011747,
0.7116274834,
0.6262340546,
-0.347142756,
0.6551374793,
0.4216639102,
-0.5537260175,
0.0528806783,
-0.3185546696,
-0.1879496127,
-0.4643382132,
0.1064393148,
-0.050690189,
-0.5126554966,
0.4816873074,
0.2494352907,
0.036119137,
0.472071141,
0.2208746225,
-0.5178548098,
0.7200863957,
0.4547064602,
-0.2856576145,
0.5897877812,
-0.4186114967,
0.0517384373,
-0.6445406675,
-0.4635670185,
-0.6962988377,
0.0359245017,
-0.3846223652,
-0.3159798384,
0.4540590048,
-0.096081458,
-0.4055583179,
0.1028157249,
-0.1644317955,
0.3374196589,
0.6330913901,
0.0286200065,
0.4000461996,
0.112844795,
0.8252968192,
0.4236111045,
-0.7068402171,
-0.6684408784,
1.1774551868,
0.4686730206,
0.4575201273,
0.1331009716,
0.0888500363,
0.5937180519,
-0.190724209,
-0.9647804499,
0.2675107718,
-0.3267481327,
-0.5023599863,
-0.2596046329,
-0.4089542329,
-0.8557494879,
-0.4951275289,
-0.1398223042,
-0.5016140342,
0.4417376816,
0.3299334049,
-0.6468377709,
0.0747792721,
-0.7370372415,
0.5403315425,
-0.3258225024,
-0.0046150559,
-0.4375763834,
-0.994070828,
-0.1187910587,
-0.2793153524,
0.2234041244,
-0.0628935173,
-0.162324205,
1.025611043,
-0.4483232498,
0.4406423271,
-0.2675153613,
0.0856110677,
0.9559569359,
-0.5715654492,
0.5788495541,
0.108964622,
-0.0821002424,
0.4359543025,
-0.3266926408,
-0.3328250647,
-0.3813021779,
0.5639006495,
-1.0842187405,
-0.0312680453,
-0.2554424107,
-0.0678159148,
-0.2025519609,
-0.0272388142,
0.1709896326,
0.9479470849,
0.2584761381,
0.4958756268,
0.3779563308,
-0.0544200651,
0.1576863974,
0.3334984183,
0.3754131496,
-0.2679522038,
0.918733418,
0.2823343873,
0.3209131658,
0.0757819116,
-0.1461868733,
-0.3963953555,
-0.611994803,
-0.2995070517,
0.0213421453,
-0.8081861734,
-0.2650077641,
-0.642880857,
-0.4161607921,
-0.6285715699,
-0.169912681,
-0.6024773717,
-0.4633310735,
-0.5453696251,
0.1380507648,
0.1655433774,
0.869433701,
-0.0284320638,
0.5434941649,
-0.2946444154,
0.2417021841,
0.0982679874,
0.1624324918,
-0.0178622045,
-0.3522133827,
-0.5345418453,
0.1274596602,
-0.2942548394,
-0.3732081056,
0.066182524,
0.2538635731,
0.4080084264,
0.2736774683,
0.0816600025,
0.6454103589,
-0.0940080434,
0.7244279385,
-0.1931888461,
-0.9683175683,
0.6474446058,
-0.1672741324,
0.1754682958,
0.5736766458,
0.2013865709,
-0.5090631843,
-0.4064513445,
-0.5757007599,
-0.7973257303,
0.9917857647,
0.4908450842,
-0.3960263431,
0.4130333662,
0.2710538208,
-0.4558332562,
0.3999913633,
-0.0359659418,
-0.0528736562,
-0.6243007779,
-0.3870682716,
-0.1816102117,
0.0580872931,
-0.1888402998,
-0.148866415,
0.5388509631,
-0.1691386849,
0.6912189722,
0.0462332033,
0.1130326018,
-0.2151369601,
0.0413672104,
0.5247783661,
0.33798033,
-0.075753063,
0.1626147032,
0.2902370095,
-0.4916995466,
-0.0622796975,
0.0674633682,
0.2263776809,
-0.3505910039,
0.7593940496,
0.7715206146,
-0.3558413982,
-1.00122118,
0.5961031914,
0.1618638188,
-0.2129461318,
-0.7447867393,
0.0325966626,
-0.2503854632,
0.2460431606,
0.4073868692,
0.2819835246,
0.4586307108,
-0.6095741987,
0.2750864923,
0.2283116579,
-0.3939085305,
-0.245136708,
0.8549920321,
0.3629611433,
0.0123742241,
0.9603983164,
0.1122394726,
-0.5830646753,
0.9710683823,
-0.1051631793,
0.646319747,
0.0267060455,
-0.3204076588,
0.2002395391,
0.1499239206,
-0.0379870385,
0.0135543253,
-0.3513548076,
-0.601406455,
-0.2127167583,
-0.0559311733,
-0.4634130895,
0.1902504861,
-0.6807171702,
0.4061566293,
-0.5350287557,
-0.1247573793,
-0.0321269706,
0.3128174543,
-0.4302745163,
0.3354962766,
0.3290225565,
0.7707769275,
-0.757445693,
0.9435380101,
0.6940832734,
-0.0490654446,
-0.9509773254,
-0.0861638188,
0.4745131135,
-0.8467789888,
0.454051733,
0.021715384,
-0.4097763598,
0.1128480285,
-0.5024079084,
-0.6583772898,
1.1038300991,
-0.1711782962,
-0.3712066412,
0.0308358911,
0.2945669889,
0.4108382463,
-0.277053982,
0.2837079465,
0.5620937943,
0.3139448166,
0.2730177939,
-0.8905237317,
-0.2939694524,
-0.2592570484,
-0.1558254212,
-0.1497090757,
-0.8269425631,
0.4230216444,
-0.2790516317,
-0.3359490037,
-0.008094009,
0.5597059131,
-0.2204290181,
0.4652843475,
0.8627876043,
0.0943436697,
0.5918390155,
-0.0918724686,
0.6647210121,
0.0915305018,
0.0613052137,
0.9771800041,
-0.1007639617,
0.9250436425,
0.422558099,
-0.0503008924,
0.0894297287,
0.3536007404,
-0.0829406381,
0.7075744271,
-0.0433216393,
-0.3199632764,
0.0321795717,
-0.4631311595,
-0.0778025463,
0.9181426167,
0.2735803127,
-0.0348749682,
0.2171362191,
0.2379204035,
-0.0240931362,
-0.0390050486,
-0.0985156745,
1.038974762,
0.0019293614,
-0.396620363,
0.5878705978,
-0.1472598016,
0.3931449056,
-0.5418630242,
0.0848273486,
-0.0695013776,
0.1926317364,
-0.4788716435,
-0.8201407194,
0.9504500628,
0.4182785153,
-0.0034356778,
-0.2637875676,
0.4778908789,
-0.4208469689,
-0.1966320276,
0.2255727649,
0.2052375227,
0.3997374475,
-0.2266579419,
-0.3533903062,
0.644028008,
0.1064561456,
-0.0560869984,
-0.2408529967,
0.0818288177,
-0.2508760393,
0.7453415394,
0.5277560353,
0.472746104,
-0.2276023626,
-0.0603013486,
0.8929376602,
-0.463032335,
-0.4709495306,
-0.3134301603,
0.4789586961,
-0.0825802311,
-0.1817782372,
0.2952018082,
0.7278773189,
0.788002491,
0.3897536695,
0.9676972032,
-0.1249191985,
0.6808549762,
-0.4592338502,
0.7692218423,
-0.698610723,
0.2140312493,
0.3099074364,
-0.4345934689,
-0.1029196531,
0.7535151243,
0.0010364358,
-0.2706349194,
0.3081946075,
0.6449727416,
-0.0458160043,
0.2290840745,
-0.2000149339,
0.0526289716,
0.9802933335,
0.5220138431,
0.914251864,
-0.6696898937,
0.9226492047,
-0.2426624447,
-0.1885775179,
-0.1154792905,
-0.421167165,
-0.5647250414,
-0.6753371954,
-0.2832404077,
-0.1163750887,
0.3286062479,
1.1357209682,
0.849752605,
-0.9427452087,
-0.3909231722,
-0.2105003744,
-0.2491582781,
-0.1275313497,
-0.1439263672,
0.1484332383,
0.0450813323,
-0.6584964395,
0.7053317428,
-0.2041089535,
0.3217716217,
-0.1262099892,
-0.2776738405,
0.128228277,
-0.1773349494,
0.2868674099,
0.557318151,
-0.5181999803,
-0.3523312509,
-0.1786241829,
0.0222426411,
0.1192938387,
0.9090228081,
-0.6731645465,
0.2834138274,
-0.0500793159,
0.661948204,
0.3590427041,
0.3583869338,
0.5505443811,
-0.6216667295,
0.4277736843,
0.464717865,
-0.0828140751,
0.3415714204,
-0.3393220305,
0.4754674435,
0.3426928222,
-0.5970826745,
-0.8986051083,
-0.0963266119,
-1.0471075773,
-0.0567429066,
1.1923047304,
-0.0123919221,
0.2808052599,
-0.53042835,
-0.1358148158,
0.5151566267,
-0.6587991118,
0.6661893725,
0.3938918114,
-0.1389388293,
0.0396603011,
-0.8393152356,
0.5970950723,
0.1215738729,
-1.007709384,
0.3011805713,
0.3689237535,
-0.1873783171,
0.037734326,
0.5808908343,
-0.1361455023,
0.1314741671,
0.072436966,
-0.39939785,
-0.4436093271,
-0.7788732648,
-0.3346659243,
-0.1231001168,
0.0041406718,
-0.4224090576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01146v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01146v3 | RadAdapt: Radiology Report Summarization via Lightweight Domain Adaptation of Large Language Models | 2023-05-02T01:33:02 | 2023-07-20T13:10:07 | Dave Van Veen, Cara Van Uden, Maayane Attias, Anuj Pareek, Christian Bluethgen, Malgorzata Polacin, Wah Chiu, Jean-Benoit Delbrouck, Juan Manuel Zambrano Chaves, Curtis P. Langlotz, Akshay S. Chaudhari, John Pauly | cs.CL | cs.CL | We systematically investigate lightweight strategies to adapt large language
models (LLMs) for the task of radiology report summarization (RRS).
Specifically, we focus on domain adaptation via pretraining (on natural
language, biomedical text, or clinical text) and via discrete prompting or
parameter-efficient fine-tuning. Our results consistently achieve best
performance by maximally adapting to the task via pretraining on clinical text
and fine-tuning on RRS examples. Importantly, this method fine-tunes a mere
0.32% of parameters throughout the model, in contrast to end-to-end fine-tuning
(100% of parameters). Additionally, we study the effect of in-context examples
and out-of-distribution (OOD) training before concluding with a radiologist
reader study and qualitative analysis. Our findings highlight the importance of
domain adaptation in RRS and provide valuable insights toward developing
effective natural language processing solutions for clinical tasks. | [
-0.2261868566,
-0.5474498272,
0.555500567,
0.108037129,
-0.7274449468,
-0.0377643071,
-0.4487513006,
-0.5307910442,
0.0840593353,
0.5656354427,
-0.3932251036,
-0.4428754151,
-1.0449948311,
0.2777321935,
0.0628475994,
1.5333024263,
-0.1765392721,
0.1243424788,
-0.182140097,
-0.3276832104,
-0.7066284418,
-0.0524252243,
-0.5241810679,
-0.5512837172,
0.4535064697,
0.6800479293,
0.8127666712,
0.5657883883,
0.8504830003,
0.1397316605,
0.1784578413,
0.0949754268,
-0.5551044345,
0.4507117569,
-0.2730644047,
-0.2957320809,
-0.8039192557,
-0.3447978795,
0.2572386861,
0.9573997259,
-0.1136506721,
0.2188504636,
-0.0830415636,
0.8715672493,
-0.7975482941,
0.0498504415,
-0.3579879701,
-0.0519175567,
-0.1413833201,
-1.0685983896,
-0.5652924776,
-0.3461239636,
0.2415455729,
-0.5653767586,
0.2981847823,
0.1173301563,
0.7071043849,
0.2722627521,
-0.375195384,
-0.5397661328,
-0.7989564538,
0.7244509459,
-0.6305891275,
0.0615973063,
0.609058857,
0.4318076074,
0.0234413762,
-0.9636063576,
-0.0787020922,
-0.1364727169,
-0.0820747837,
0.3562021554,
-0.4242122769,
0.1734660119,
0.0135372868,
0.2825285792,
-0.8132386208,
0.0859113708,
-0.4164528549,
0.284214735,
0.4920696318,
0.3513112366,
0.3957386911,
0.0509333089,
-0.207873866,
-0.1202264056,
-0.7647509575,
-0.4974866509,
-0.3151431084,
0.3331443667,
-0.3447314203,
0.5225091577,
-0.3315453231,
0.8881469369,
-0.0373624526,
-0.4620996416,
0.0628703535,
-0.2006634027,
-0.3832609951,
0.1253632903,
0.5566548705,
0.3453702927,
0.3495064378,
-0.0454707816,
-0.2020287216,
-0.3948480487,
0.3852697611,
-0.9020091295,
-0.4282606542,
0.1446503401,
-0.8524490595,
-0.3174641728,
-0.3363555372,
-0.5107704401,
-0.4331997335,
-0.3126377463,
0.6057168841,
-0.5981011987,
-0.0950207338,
0.7538490891,
0.0102703366,
0.0275362339,
0.6930675507,
-0.9682670832,
0.5849773288,
0.391952157,
0.9274328947,
-0.0821374357,
-0.0889163837,
-0.6631067395,
0.2833772898,
-0.0113435602,
1.2448147535,
-0.4187215567,
-0.5295017362,
-0.3052552342,
-0.2680393755,
-0.4655140042,
-0.5438475609,
0.4527219236,
-0.5812169909,
0.2375964224,
0.2150329947,
-0.2450998276,
-0.1792968363,
0.0233691689,
-0.2403044999,
0.5714694858,
0.2823773324,
-0.9499620199,
0.1998552233,
-0.718518436,
-0.7983504534,
0.0359829664,
0.019614879,
-0.4066341221,
0.3398037553,
0.454498142,
0.7911820412,
-0.4699054658,
-0.0832849592,
0.0660354644,
-0.1551898122,
0.1565536261,
0.0449666455,
0.6257877946,
0.3747924268,
0.1299634576,
0.4119068682,
-0.3562017679,
-0.1006517261,
0.19830437,
-0.0309101827,
-0.534214735,
-0.1664662808,
0.114748247,
-0.0784762725,
-0.077587083,
-0.057601627,
0.2926904857,
-0.2318733633,
0.1424315274,
0.3106672466,
0.2988298833,
0.3586805165,
-0.7527717948,
1.0848965645,
-0.2707596123,
0.010856634,
-0.3668440282,
-0.3272874057,
-0.3643586338,
-0.7498530746,
0.4224534333,
0.4075894356,
-0.7050976753,
0.0930242091,
-0.7259976268,
-0.5036903024,
-0.1891535819,
-0.0710205361,
0.3243725896,
0.5494940877,
0.3516017199,
-0.5106918216,
-0.4474745989,
-0.6037554145,
-0.1023642123,
0.2365172803,
-0.1839746833,
0.0837874487,
0.5884189606,
-0.2406100184,
0.7387421727,
-0.9507725835,
-0.7207399607,
-0.9357696176,
0.4533748925,
0.1433841437,
0.1569688916,
0.7289174795,
-0.5025388002,
-0.5233080387,
0.0246915407,
-0.7487574816,
-0.2155872434,
-0.1950810999,
0.3279138803,
0.057934951,
0.692974031,
-0.344955951,
0.4256346524,
0.571359396,
-0.0762417093,
0.3144606054,
-0.8500279188,
0.1301248372,
-1.2167261839,
0.1302580237,
-0.0147546818,
-0.4787859321,
-0.497733295,
0.0845801085,
-0.0114219552,
-0.1513497531,
-0.1568002552,
0.4297029078,
-0.8782308698,
-0.1524062753,
-0.6278298497,
0.1666465998,
0.0319305919,
0.0304671954,
0.2299747318,
0.729377389,
0.5661017299,
-0.6991739273,
-0.0235298723,
0.4103167951,
-0.368712157,
0.3249760866,
-0.8503954411,
-0.0297699906,
-0.3944334984,
0.6131179929,
-0.8225840926,
-0.3925977647,
0.0007560732,
-0.3640936017,
0.5890260339,
-0.290432632,
-0.2170424014,
0.0447857678,
-0.5215933323,
0.6506536603,
0.4692684412,
-0.1656875312,
0.7242902517,
0.4915666282,
-0.7453224063,
-0.3362993002,
-0.6249252558,
0.2658940554,
-0.0689474046,
-0.5148970485,
0.3846577108,
0.0724678263,
-0.1276022345,
0.0157948546,
0.0326096974,
-0.2344621122,
0.0079204747,
0.1833896041,
0.1898509264,
-0.6348813772,
-0.1004721373,
0.1558042467,
-0.3218921423,
-0.1764650792,
-0.0228145197,
0.5605872869,
0.0519211479,
-0.137378037,
-0.4406040907,
0.1384286135,
0.5224099159,
-0.2786510289,
0.6271234155,
0.3757745624,
-0.2520613372,
-0.3984105587,
-0.1235326752,
-0.2785008252,
-0.4111445844,
0.6156249046,
-0.1920832694,
-0.8026294708,
0.3971261084,
-0.2988430858,
-0.196575731,
0.3000186086,
0.7655690312,
-0.0296580382,
0.5233191848,
0.8751564622,
0.1075162068,
0.3443025351,
-0.0864525661,
0.2290547341,
-0.8975037932,
0.0638583377,
-0.6703589559,
-0.0996908844,
-0.1510461718,
-0.5832010508,
0.7102758288,
-0.1558547318,
0.3674308956,
0.1354804784,
-0.3893639445,
0.5064085722,
0.0123475315,
0.0707028061,
0.4343279898,
-0.0161065385,
0.5326223373,
-0.2720096111,
-0.9222425222,
-0.2987351418,
1.3296387196,
0.1964532882,
1.2079131603,
0.1243499666,
0.5798885226,
0.3797864616,
0.4414999485,
-0.8641767502,
0.3220684826,
-0.2946363389,
-0.0659999028,
-0.1164156124,
-0.1707656384,
-1.1230355501,
0.2228646129,
-0.326538384,
-0.3337474465,
-0.0583739951,
-0.0062256069,
-0.6109721661,
-0.0250995867,
-0.437251538,
0.5750938654,
0.0356672071,
0.0204668939,
-0.5347860456,
-0.6677410007,
0.4596510828,
-0.0859161243,
0.3293947577,
-0.0862308741,
-0.2501157224,
0.697342217,
-0.2928748727,
0.8201387525,
0.0828361511,
0.0513453484,
-0.0468360148,
0.22836788,
0.3196974993,
0.2048582435,
0.1873545051,
-0.154836297,
0.0626383349,
-0.3576295674,
-0.5699839592,
0.5439946055,
-0.7427257895,
-0.3203485906,
-0.8053371906,
-0.9370226264,
-0.3814287186,
0.2802731395,
0.3610566854,
0.8143607378,
-0.3493454754,
0.2216287404,
0.9798809886,
-0.4201574028,
0.0436250642,
0.6542690396,
-0.124446623,
-0.2571004927,
0.6846935153,
-0.0490366407,
0.2933146954,
0.7530753016,
0.3237490058,
-0.0183802508,
-1.306208849,
-0.426205337,
0.4362079799,
-0.8136211634,
-0.5300446153,
-0.7926427722,
-0.1277084053,
-0.4799383879,
-0.5027338266,
-0.2486528903,
-0.6225720644,
-0.2190128565,
0.1771063805,
0.7409787178,
0.9787123203,
0.108899951,
0.5034852028,
-0.8417733312,
0.6063916683,
-0.0806810856,
0.1761716455,
-0.1692824364,
-1.2080097198,
-0.5392718911,
-0.4375857413,
-0.1080383435,
-0.4532374442,
0.4844705462,
0.4398334622,
0.1871643364,
0.226904273,
0.3865703642,
0.6338523626,
-0.4088582695,
0.4379892647,
0.0672405064,
-0.5975106359,
0.6010417342,
-0.7760813832,
0.5976001024,
0.741417706,
0.3684382141,
-0.4187681377,
-0.4163432717,
-0.2749297321,
-1.0256832838,
0.6497394443,
-0.1617923826,
0.1256063581,
0.1534806341,
0.4387526512,
0.2584654987,
-0.2209198475,
-0.2758997381,
-0.0739738494,
0.1223780736,
-0.4194235802,
-0.0705068558,
-0.5061648488,
-0.3452448547,
-0.1883244067,
0.6407672763,
-0.3739388585,
0.2457565963,
0.2394397408,
-0.4793591499,
-0.285197258,
0.1816581339,
1.3040086031,
1.1593295336,
-0.4583740234,
0.203760162,
0.1639920473,
-0.9019553065,
-0.2066192329,
-0.1487973779,
0.1814663857,
0.1045387834,
0.8113598824,
0.6723774076,
0.4893771708,
-0.6300769448,
0.6501069665,
-0.4279557765,
-0.3705858886,
-0.1335249543,
0.093920894,
0.0181097984,
-0.1629334986,
0.4237828553,
0.3472435176,
0.0702863485,
-0.2712212503,
0.2201905996,
0.0906892046,
-0.1450481117,
-0.4412100315,
0.7098382711,
0.0228454638,
0.1602087766,
0.11074505,
0.3375506401,
0.0537876412,
0.3831152022,
0.6461824775,
0.9602069259,
-0.1141813993,
0.1650247723,
0.186112836,
0.2182755172,
-0.3295507133,
0.0274868365,
0.1786185354,
-0.4875974953,
-0.6301345825,
-0.1649956703,
-0.6077634096,
-0.0848187804,
-1.0563474894,
0.3543908,
-0.7239918709,
0.0564154759,
0.1696577221,
-0.2655367553,
-0.2860334218,
0.4554629326,
-0.2155016959,
1.0730227232,
-0.7063192129,
1.019295454,
0.7580121756,
-0.3692694008,
-0.4008035362,
0.0489419699,
-0.1162922904,
-0.995229125,
0.6786469817,
-0.3024508655,
-0.4408904314,
-0.105408743,
-0.199892655,
-0.7799569368,
1.1825668812,
0.3025797904,
-0.0437771268,
0.1944841295,
-0.0703790933,
0.6018577218,
-0.4721637964,
0.2701775432,
0.235349983,
0.0350624062,
-0.0404459238,
-1.0163934231,
0.2553685606,
-0.0304661151,
-0.0434526242,
0.045502156,
-0.392242074,
0.6981021762,
-0.5034239292,
0.0266310368,
-0.0433095843,
0.774539113,
-0.0309751593,
0.3017362058,
0.2490181774,
0.2736491561,
0.6262890697,
0.2233262509,
1.4199277163,
-0.3142803609,
0.1487990022,
1.2755073309,
-0.5002315044,
0.7532262802,
0.3163149357,
0.1042578965,
0.4407265782,
0.2853228748,
0.405387342,
0.7291674018,
-0.1606761217,
-0.3696288764,
-0.0607507117,
-0.0832887441,
-0.6058300138,
0.4687103629,
0.3061599135,
-0.2556870282,
-0.4141871631,
0.2920455933,
0.1978547573,
0.1809598953,
-0.3071929812,
0.8376118541,
0.3253709376,
-0.4923507869,
0.8433372378,
0.3504066169,
0.5150551796,
-0.9665079713,
0.272341013,
-0.3014555573,
0.3910562694,
-0.3787621558,
-0.4915315807,
0.5588259697,
0.1080201194,
-0.4587117434,
-0.3954737782,
0.7232702374,
-0.0549946725,
-0.2265482545,
-0.000185542,
0.4621779919,
-0.0230434239,
0.201429531,
-0.41595909,
0.2866702676,
-0.0492419451,
-0.448382169,
0.9276561141,
0.5435478091,
-0.2316310555,
0.8821299076,
0.4578707814,
0.3749890327,
-0.397654742,
0.2222629488,
0.9341275692,
-0.6324703693,
-0.4467921853,
-0.5291609168,
0.2459219992,
0.3022548556,
-0.5433763266,
0.6344553232,
0.4710868299,
0.5147017837,
-0.3733209372,
0.7456809282,
0.0862646103,
0.561103642,
-0.7944747806,
0.9062860012,
-0.4388108552,
0.281826973,
-0.2560943663,
-0.454647541,
-0.8080214858,
0.6084904075,
-0.5013304353,
0.0840259418,
1.1030318737,
0.6453676224,
-0.3113368154,
-0.0405714847,
0.3602250814,
0.2010022104,
0.0447897762,
0.3297170699,
0.2917218208,
-0.3372938335,
0.4285678267,
0.045445621,
-0.3055407703,
-0.5897529721,
-0.9346277714,
-0.922662735,
-0.2425698638,
-0.6166551113,
-0.3202727735,
0.2327254415,
0.9010300636,
0.6436847448,
-0.7575931549,
-0.2663322985,
0.3932612836,
-0.1463076472,
-0.1415390372,
-0.1219930202,
0.640627563,
-0.4048803151,
-0.213711068,
0.4374979436,
0.6459108591,
-0.1005027071,
0.3028065264,
-0.0451001972,
0.047651913,
-0.0756929666,
0.598951757,
0.3492451012,
-0.1606704891,
-0.1313183755,
-0.144543618,
-0.3279801905,
0.1585558355,
1.2024025917,
-0.6284041405,
0.3927043378,
0.3635626733,
0.6976141334,
0.5363764763,
-0.0031228275,
0.705091536,
-0.5550774336,
0.5160744786,
0.3937477469,
0.1583748609,
0.3505063355,
-0.1347886324,
0.2895278633,
-0.0461559594,
-0.5813304782,
-0.9422056675,
0.0765491351,
-1.4176054001,
-0.4805823267,
1.0037617683,
-0.0404315069,
-0.2508224547,
-0.4698854387,
-0.2936038375,
0.0971506387,
-0.0726091117,
0.8125044107,
0.0940777585,
-0.4450905323,
-0.332033813,
-0.803129971,
0.6416051388,
0.3964395821,
-0.8236098886,
0.0487796031,
0.2736025155,
0.6722869873,
-0.3030356765,
1.3277531862,
-0.1396827549,
0.5594465733,
-0.2229936719,
0.0933370218,
-0.2607610822,
-0.1189353541,
-0.6337969899,
0.1163670048,
0.4870109856,
0.0607235543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01145v1 | ADVISE: AI-accelerated Design of Evidence Synthesis for Global Development | 2023-05-02T01:29:53 | 2023-05-02T01:29:53 | Kristen M. Edwards, Binyang Song, Jaron Porciello, Mark Engelbert, Carolyn Huang, Faez Ahmed | cs.CL | cs.CL | When designing evidence-based policies and programs, decision-makers must
distill key information from a vast and rapidly growing literature base.
Identifying relevant literature from raw search results is time and resource
intensive, and is often done by manual screening. In this study, we develop an
AI agent based on a bidirectional encoder representations from transformers
(BERT) model and incorporate it into a human team designing an evidence
synthesis product for global development. We explore the effectiveness of the
human-AI hybrid team in accelerating the evidence synthesis process. To further
improve team efficiency, we enhance the human-AI hybrid team through active
learning (AL). Specifically, we explore different sampling strategies,
including random sampling, least confidence (LC) sampling, and highest priority
(HP) sampling, to study their influence on the collaborative screening process.
Results show that incorporating the BERT-based AI agent into the human team can
reduce the human screening effort by 68.5% compared to the case of no AI
assistance and by 16.8% compared to the case of using a support vector machine
(SVM)-based AI agent for identifying 80% of all relevant documents. When we
apply the HP sampling strategy for AL, the human screening effort can be
reduced even more: by 78.3% for identifying 80% of all relevant documents
compared to no AI assistance. We apply the AL-enhanced human-AI hybrid teaming
workflow in the design process of three evidence gap maps (EGMs) for USAID and
find it to be highly effective. These findings demonstrate how AI can
accelerate the development of evidence synthesis products and promote timely
evidence-based decision making in global development in a human-AI hybrid
teaming context. | [
-0.4039583206,
-0.3427678347,
0.4016828835,
0.0539950244,
-0.1397638619,
0.5833979845,
-0.1161221489,
-0.6670390964,
0.1300942749,
0.1331685334,
-0.263917774,
-0.3008123636,
-0.366432339,
0.202469036,
-0.1491396129,
1.0442057848,
-0.3615841866,
0.1685726941,
0.0414845571,
-0.2222973406,
-0.0166534986,
-0.1577296108,
-0.6816273928,
-0.4834041595,
0.2944320738,
0.4580727816,
0.8782687187,
0.1997103393,
0.5582989454,
0.3026991785,
0.1018569246,
0.4433278441,
-0.2480733395,
0.2613232732,
-0.0981521606,
-0.4211846292,
-0.7528386712,
0.3040909469,
0.0721313059,
0.4232009351,
-0.0953681171,
0.2662625313,
-0.1030443534,
0.4320753515,
-0.4920993149,
0.134934321,
-0.472127527,
0.1022001654,
0.26833269,
0.0342380293,
-0.2219546884,
-0.0876469836,
0.4976978898,
-0.8762984276,
0.7818056345,
0.2736954987,
0.5490602255,
0.3076916039,
-0.2623602152,
-0.1821596324,
-0.7957731485,
0.4968166947,
-0.5523724556,
-0.1160631925,
0.1578317881,
0.1887292117,
-0.4676220417,
-0.6441521049,
-0.7351818681,
-0.2377212942,
0.0975136608,
0.3268873096,
0.2234282941,
0.417547822,
0.1811622232,
0.0742939785,
-0.4228468239,
0.0348242596,
-0.422226429,
-0.719183743,
1.022207737,
-0.1430242807,
0.5604809523,
0.0898130685,
-0.32652843,
-0.3166168332,
-0.721108973,
0.0367356837,
0.0661941022,
0.1419046074,
0.048845429,
0.4537319839,
-0.0875305235,
0.2600205541,
-0.0032660346,
0.1026152521,
0.0632225499,
-0.5635648966,
0.0388998352,
0.2839214504,
0.5604118109,
0.4309925735,
-0.2848019302,
-0.0582516342,
-0.4989498854,
0.4676083624,
0.4040348828,
-0.7935016751,
-0.1718193144,
0.0799290463,
-0.6560468674,
-0.2974196672,
0.1669087857,
-0.7242659926,
-0.4384612739,
-0.1832694262,
0.499293983,
-0.2373090237,
-0.4352343976,
-0.0851737559,
-0.4159334004,
0.3268567324,
0.3628778458,
-0.5373979807,
0.264231503,
0.3501192927,
0.536421895,
-0.2179666907,
-0.1413705051,
-0.4956771135,
0.2296524644,
-0.309300065,
0.9164502025,
-0.3372834027,
-0.6350362897,
0.0292012561,
-0.3479268849,
0.1637362987,
-0.5224459767,
0.8014975786,
-0.3629131019,
0.265360266,
-0.1302890331,
-0.1775408983,
-0.255699873,
0.1250739843,
-0.8401172757,
0.9022490978,
0.0669890195,
-0.5066443682,
0.9543334842,
-1.1001548767,
-0.6916716099,
0.1079085544,
-0.447360605,
-0.5511283875,
-0.0530590303,
0.7823857069,
0.1478332132,
-0.4212363064,
0.4641343653,
0.0331350304,
-0.648406446,
-0.159200877,
-0.2101117522,
0.7155387998,
0.3454445302,
-0.7929350138,
0.5260391235,
-0.7427088022,
-0.1953330189,
-0.0472832993,
-0.6527869701,
-0.2535429299,
0.1835443825,
0.0514238514,
0.0776775405,
-0.1643407941,
-0.6357899904,
0.2951670885,
-0.0851680934,
0.1589909196,
0.7754319906,
0.0834616497,
0.5112018585,
-0.5764831901,
0.5171545148,
-0.3397311568,
0.1758173853,
0.0938184932,
-0.7743508816,
-0.7133918405,
-0.2962686718,
0.3536895514,
0.3444223404,
-1.0719357729,
0.6624323726,
-0.2436532378,
-0.0832394511,
-0.9639148712,
0.0966444388,
0.2214275599,
0.2631362081,
0.2294704765,
-0.5557711124,
-0.70165205,
-1.0420656204,
-0.0798614696,
-0.6919957995,
-0.3612377644,
-0.0279238075,
0.6237577796,
-0.3553992808,
0.9931382537,
-0.1381249726,
-0.3922717869,
-0.5994938612,
0.4542518556,
0.2290359139,
0.4487567842,
0.3473157287,
-1.0245051384,
-0.4431675971,
-0.3088614941,
-0.7818687558,
-0.1402567327,
-0.301479578,
-0.3203350604,
0.182026282,
0.1786129326,
-0.7981309891,
0.7332273126,
0.0438334085,
-0.4756414294,
0.1226128563,
-0.471195966,
0.3013250828,
-0.746415019,
0.2378316969,
-0.0695495233,
0.0841001645,
-0.5652956367,
0.1592196077,
0.0085466234,
-0.2138567567,
-0.1989749521,
0.2726055682,
-0.7885670662,
0.039107345,
-0.174105823,
-0.0763163716,
0.0468700528,
0.5013322234,
0.050692305,
1.0046811104,
0.3181763589,
-0.4928682148,
0.0764242783,
0.3646484613,
-0.502677381,
0.4010480046,
-0.615495801,
0.163902685,
-0.1570180357,
0.6272211075,
-0.5988568664,
-0.1631362289,
0.2070260346,
-0.2344023287,
0.4433739483,
0.0246367417,
-0.4998588562,
-0.4980496168,
-0.4387079179,
0.3837003708,
0.748293817,
-0.6528531313,
0.8720931411,
0.6344709396,
-0.1077802181,
-0.1885515302,
-0.3823272884,
0.2704766989,
0.0714817569,
-0.9065110683,
0.8641613722,
0.0031732784,
-0.4925337434,
0.1938798875,
-0.1817208529,
0.144013688,
0.022482859,
0.2044108212,
0.4257386029,
-0.0616548732,
-0.1013812348,
-0.0114462506,
-0.1940182447,
0.0846445709,
-0.0664191172,
-0.0690944716,
0.2176080644,
-0.5606370568,
-0.4479418099,
0.5747661591,
0.8260941505,
-0.2112984508,
0.4585813582,
0.7950716615,
-0.3150637746,
-0.3301531971,
-0.5850761533,
-0.3301749229,
-0.4158480763,
0.1866116524,
-0.0076009645,
-0.3932038248,
0.3343773782,
-0.1485843807,
0.4784927666,
0.473834306,
0.7634670734,
0.1911823899,
1.3190661669,
0.491846472,
-0.3209732771,
0.4342344403,
-0.561752677,
0.2979429364,
-0.8604543209,
-0.2864967585,
-0.1063637212,
-0.6236733794,
-0.2124220878,
-0.5584093332,
1.0121539831,
-0.4869303107,
0.0812361985,
-0.2027050257,
-0.8197031021,
0.1046947837,
0.9425993562,
0.3187888563,
0.1226376891,
0.0525050536,
-0.2711469531,
0.1543238014,
-0.7797986865,
-0.2693420351,
1.471908927,
0.0194592141,
0.5922299623,
0.0386170447,
0.8635937572,
0.846165061,
0.5134596825,
-0.4736588895,
0.6662631035,
0.4729914665,
-0.9082086682,
-0.0787517726,
-0.0712522119,
-0.9669425488,
0.433144331,
-0.6126049757,
0.0489571616,
-0.001245114,
-0.2112811506,
-0.5416234732,
0.3348271847,
-0.9553899765,
0.2909040451,
-0.4341320395,
-0.5588511229,
-0.7715052962,
-0.6846517324,
0.0247228816,
0.1502720416,
0.1748955995,
-0.0093455007,
0.0435969532,
0.9942895174,
-0.566645503,
0.7062884569,
-0.6196027994,
0.1799395531,
0.7817616463,
-0.2203790396,
0.6069287062,
0.2097595781,
-0.3334092796,
-0.3549677134,
-0.7766627669,
-0.5488078594,
-0.3121297359,
0.3827093244,
-0.857398808,
-0.9254618883,
-0.4866166413,
-0.7530129552,
-0.0788897425,
0.1577886194,
-0.069089964,
0.2699320316,
-0.4011041224,
-0.0674311146,
0.4617055357,
-0.2089252174,
0.4208126962,
0.5581536293,
0.3447280824,
-0.3786875904,
0.6955500841,
-0.0226696692,
-0.0899560079,
0.2315727025,
0.1140605137,
-0.1235466078,
-1.0310425758,
-0.6575476527,
-0.0506271012,
-0.191901505,
-0.1433867067,
-0.2475149184,
-0.0613035634,
-0.5384204984,
-0.1379371285,
-0.0667554289,
-0.4396709502,
0.1692444235,
-0.2315559685,
0.1716692299,
0.6845664382,
-0.2027632147,
-0.2392357141,
-0.680755496,
0.6637313962,
0.4090866446,
0.035278324,
-0.0893610865,
-0.1062598526,
-0.244785592,
0.1467915028,
-0.4601332843,
-0.475217849,
0.2561449707,
0.2602422237,
1.1208764315,
0.3679856062,
0.4755345285,
0.413672179,
-0.2735590041,
0.9091094136,
-0.0003834816,
-0.5153759718,
0.6034604311,
-0.2425403744,
0.1684696674,
0.6228952408,
0.255898118,
-0.0363524742,
-0.4114370346,
-0.5938866735,
-1.0674850941,
0.8069540262,
0.6029238105,
-0.396651566,
0.4081586003,
-0.0010549988,
0.2123415619,
0.0737421438,
-0.1502289325,
0.1052283049,
0.0468846001,
-0.3288517892,
0.3335201442,
-0.0792045295,
-0.5563060641,
-0.3332310915,
0.8573724627,
-0.1472653896,
0.4659566581,
0.7432023883,
-0.2316034138,
-0.2384433448,
0.0896355212,
0.4324771762,
0.6354557276,
-0.4233982265,
-0.0963234156,
-0.0868874416,
-0.511110425,
0.2610593438,
0.5677627325,
-0.4491562545,
-0.0815408006,
0.6863477826,
0.4378354847,
-0.1979099959,
-0.8870223761,
0.3472099304,
-0.2665991783,
-0.4099117815,
-0.1866514981,
0.1604376137,
-0.3414985836,
0.3169106543,
0.8026957512,
0.4013465047,
0.2313155234,
-0.764203608,
0.2685784996,
0.3127218485,
0.0021063488,
-0.4433070719,
0.7921717167,
0.8765643239,
-0.4278032184,
0.8066610694,
-0.4198683202,
-0.7966175079,
0.8447269201,
0.3575859964,
0.8564718962,
-0.1405237019,
0.3081709146,
0.1494269222,
0.2108994573,
-0.0534433424,
0.3662551343,
-0.2929896116,
-0.7884422541,
-0.2383621782,
-0.2383138239,
-0.5608871579,
-0.2866363227,
-0.4692549407,
-0.0427730568,
-0.2455554157,
-0.1408849359,
-0.1868740469,
0.189899385,
-0.7635438442,
-0.0730526075,
0.1037625223,
0.5973167419,
-0.7265942097,
0.6455307007,
1.0353597403,
-0.5815420151,
-0.5393919349,
-0.0836258233,
0.1553812176,
-0.9673304558,
0.2826499939,
0.154371351,
0.0888442174,
-0.4119093418,
-0.5294396281,
-0.4992477,
1.2259434462,
-0.020524051,
-0.0813111663,
-0.1714788675,
-0.2599725723,
0.8280320764,
-0.5528004766,
0.417255342,
0.4436436892,
0.6170585155,
0.1421922296,
-0.7769224048,
0.2732165158,
-0.6012087464,
-0.3012679815,
0.2371715456,
-0.6069194674,
0.3779143393,
-0.5012629032,
-0.286855191,
-0.0137283113,
0.6403723359,
0.3335342705,
0.4796632826,
0.7941605449,
0.4088466465,
0.7010732293,
0.2365128398,
0.9013988376,
-0.3742137253,
-0.2246242017,
0.4889544249,
-0.6106364727,
0.4790151119,
0.5695727468,
-0.3447781205,
0.6181740165,
0.4411843419,
-0.1824694127,
0.5324885845,
0.1015464514,
-0.459869951,
-0.1693950742,
-0.4107037783,
-0.2304843962,
0.244320482,
0.5694767833,
-0.5133434534,
-0.1061500981,
-0.1279012561,
-0.1915341318,
0.0127608394,
-0.1819764078,
0.7013343573,
-0.2006441504,
-1.2044216394,
0.4195101857,
0.0062185102,
0.7150039673,
-0.5391936302,
-0.4274707139,
-0.1554728895,
0.3040905595,
-0.1252699047,
-0.633800149,
-0.0105658332,
-0.0176513437,
-0.0250782501,
-0.4503895342,
0.6699524522,
-0.370913893,
-0.4802206755,
0.2084565163,
0.523676157,
-0.1385733187,
0.1315312982,
-0.7136915326,
-0.1070895046,
0.2329189628,
-0.1382184327,
0.328623414,
0.2535859346,
-0.3746679723,
0.5489135385,
0.9321611524,
0.3555760682,
-0.2118270993,
0.1269592643,
1.032756567,
-0.409084022,
-0.341887325,
-0.4441613853,
0.3505868614,
-0.4092684984,
0.015669113,
0.4057272971,
0.5629346967,
0.4442650676,
0.1695687473,
1.1983494759,
-0.4842765331,
0.1350498945,
-0.3594487011,
0.8445807099,
-0.327634275,
0.3327001035,
-0.0419853181,
-0.7295482755,
-0.2223322392,
0.6559565067,
0.2428277731,
-0.2517988086,
0.4173920751,
0.7073301673,
0.0905164182,
0.1357862949,
-0.2279801518,
0.0411405414,
0.9474831223,
0.6298007369,
0.6481278539,
-0.3605575264,
0.7483904958,
-0.0981156603,
-0.644800961,
-0.1141735688,
-0.5408584476,
-0.8949304819,
-0.2864658833,
-0.1666263044,
-0.1737035811,
0.2222744375,
1.3148992062,
0.7515420318,
-0.8246536851,
-0.1124570072,
-0.1119165272,
0.2597288191,
-0.405205816,
-0.097933203,
0.6301876307,
0.0428341925,
-0.5960039496,
0.6826933622,
0.0746621117,
-0.0717743933,
-0.3803545535,
-0.2589561045,
-0.5035355091,
-0.2665958703,
0.2724627852,
0.2796093225,
-0.5606830716,
-0.3577086627,
-0.1915697604,
0.2133956254,
-0.0235617794,
1.1463410854,
-1.113876462,
0.856666863,
0.6199014783,
0.8436751962,
0.5231628418,
0.0388841555,
1.2200279236,
-0.1935018301,
0.4050198495,
0.4559109509,
0.4416170418,
0.2661962807,
-0.3310289085,
0.8757718205,
0.2801197469,
-0.7194907069,
-0.6431528926,
0.0127834594,
-0.6751012206,
-0.0838553905,
0.8674505949,
-0.0861805379,
-0.1906939447,
-0.5575760603,
-0.5693181157,
0.3564684689,
-0.8420724869,
1.2473077774,
0.3571333587,
-0.5723471045,
0.5538265109,
-0.1363511682,
0.4757707417,
0.4520706534,
-0.5319295526,
-0.5058662295,
0.5259252191,
-0.0662935376,
0.3327714801,
0.7300437093,
0.073516354,
0.3770432174,
0.3229757845,
0.4726767242,
-0.1364898086,
-0.2891846895,
0.1850709021,
0.0200725663,
0.0117970342,
-0.2599911094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01099v1 | Logion: Machine Learning for Greek Philology | 2023-05-01T21:56:25 | 2023-05-01T21:56:25 | Charlie Cowen-Breen, Creston Brooks, Johannes Haubold, Barbara Graziosi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | This paper presents machine-learning methods to address various problems in
Greek philology. After training a BERT model on the largest premodern Greek
dataset used for this purpose to date, we identify and correct previously
undetected errors made by scribes in the process of textual transmission, in
what is, to our knowledge, the first successful identification of such errors
via machine learning. Additionally, we demonstrate the model's capacity to fill
gaps caused by material deterioration of premodern manuscripts and compare the
model's performance to that of a domain expert. We find that best performance
is achieved when the domain expert is provided with model suggestions for
inspiration. With such human-computer collaborations in mind, we explore the
model's interpretability and find that certain attention heads appear to encode
select grammatical features of premodern Greek. | [
-0.1724335104,
-0.9327498078,
0.5869572163,
-0.0886418,
-0.6125680208,
-0.1216939986,
-0.30984056,
-0.4789425135,
0.4235173166,
0.6205614209,
-0.8352771997,
-0.3768903911,
-0.8003420234,
0.3100217581,
-0.4680060446,
0.8356254697,
-0.0009775687,
0.5043895245,
-0.2698726952,
0.2093135267,
-0.4783906043,
-0.6951901913,
-0.8160058856,
-0.1199625283,
0.4922943115,
0.4043534994,
0.7573799491,
0.6934642196,
0.5701432824,
0.3733892143,
0.2361436784,
0.3744376302,
-0.5347248316,
0.1661747098,
-0.0672039464,
-0.5769351125,
-0.6394903064,
-0.063343592,
0.4677077532,
0.7053177953,
0.2706635296,
0.2172227353,
-0.0323973037,
0.6925486922,
-0.3442723751,
0.1490212977,
-0.5660345554,
0.3546995223,
-0.4792530835,
-0.4184944928,
-0.7100864053,
-0.4780403078,
0.2764170468,
-0.9335315824,
0.4448446929,
0.0832315832,
0.6473734975,
0.4951506555,
-0.2855034769,
-0.8066774011,
-0.6833381653,
0.8890029788,
-0.6119322181,
0.4603000879,
0.780041635,
-0.1912372708,
-0.2166882157,
-0.8055050373,
-0.4349200428,
0.0322151333,
-0.1293231845,
-0.0985960066,
0.0070956736,
-0.1021650136,
-0.1795558333,
0.330606997,
-0.6767984629,
-0.0663599297,
-0.6331526041,
-0.3303102553,
0.5533319712,
0.1297627985,
0.4434874356,
0.067044571,
0.2282742113,
0.0285563525,
-0.5802597404,
-0.3597398698,
0.5628719926,
0.2032383531,
0.3855758905,
0.4851172566,
0.3748116195,
0.6898277402,
0.3210410178,
0.0654805452,
0.0827358514,
0.0885796323,
-0.4129216075,
0.4087219536,
0.5756356716,
0.0048561296,
0.1324787587,
-0.2739088833,
0.0601516739,
0.257720232,
0.6575155854,
-0.5679733753,
-0.6398155093,
0.2553240955,
-0.4879800677,
-0.3798503876,
0.1140653193,
-0.5486335158,
-0.4755701125,
-0.574205339,
0.3575972319,
-0.6639576554,
-0.0331607126,
-0.0067789676,
0.1973235458,
-0.4603443146,
0.3950879276,
-1.3217849731,
0.4835700095,
0.7000127435,
0.6093747616,
0.0142000318,
-0.2108704597,
-0.356642276,
-0.1900454164,
-0.6984738111,
0.6964238286,
-0.2100272179,
-0.3167241812,
-0.0629877597,
0.0963346288,
-0.1717177778,
-0.4451100528,
1.0049831867,
-0.6350197196,
0.5772922635,
-0.1258992553,
-1.1203701496,
-0.4365960062,
-0.2625408471,
-1.1039162874,
0.856664598,
0.1600797623,
-0.7538115978,
0.3405402303,
-0.6124326587,
-0.2144218832,
0.3820051849,
0.0999242738,
-0.5239248276,
0.4191576242,
0.0722979307,
0.5002865195,
-0.0241734758,
0.1644935012,
-0.0606190935,
-0.0303539522,
0.2820811272,
-0.1007102802,
0.8358271122,
0.412858963,
-0.3307875991,
-0.0215520933,
-0.5569552183,
-0.0248110518,
0.0385917388,
-0.2496078461,
-0.5056573749,
0.318415463,
0.2480242848,
-0.0826057345,
0.237156868,
-0.3994158804,
0.3099903762,
-0.36424914,
0.1600492895,
0.8026860952,
-0.2981875241,
0.4693951905,
-0.352816999,
0.4725318253,
-0.0546341278,
0.0143503929,
-0.2690282166,
-0.604244411,
-0.749124527,
-0.37608096,
0.6586503983,
0.6729797125,
-0.3633902967,
0.4404146373,
-0.2529653311,
-0.4490692914,
-0.7070319057,
0.5800593495,
0.4314739406,
0.5293114185,
0.161398977,
-0.6795181632,
-0.84928298,
-0.4084202051,
-0.3134041131,
-0.1407540441,
0.1431669444,
0.262550056,
0.2318740785,
-0.5694921017,
0.7588046789,
-0.0825405642,
-0.3533096015,
0.1511173248,
0.2583728731,
0.2907182872,
0.6286948323,
0.1778632849,
-1.0379631519,
-0.4521297216,
0.1531896144,
-0.9596321583,
-0.0746973529,
-0.0127903009,
-0.0403970331,
0.4168542624,
0.5601893067,
-0.6275077462,
0.2479413897,
0.5379631519,
-0.6400167942,
0.6678715348,
-0.3705353737,
0.1639122516,
-0.9779798388,
0.2112320513,
-0.1868249029,
-0.4088144302,
-0.7188203335,
-0.2100943476,
0.066948235,
-0.0247954559,
-0.268381536,
0.5969446301,
-0.3398060799,
-0.0586964227,
-0.2613943517,
0.1564020067,
-0.2766938806,
0.3459914923,
0.3062925339,
0.4097644985,
0.343447715,
-0.6936529875,
0.747893393,
0.5382155776,
-0.2451303899,
0.3967090845,
-0.1434343606,
0.4612246752,
-0.1723191887,
-0.1124516949,
-0.8346720338,
-0.378697902,
0.5025039315,
-0.8090090156,
0.4615626037,
-0.3547419608,
-0.4930562079,
-0.1666532755,
0.2450497597,
0.6620277762,
0.3542098701,
-0.1786846519,
0.5926430225,
0.2359015495,
-0.7168927193,
-0.798515141,
-0.3468033373,
0.0066506509,
-0.253559351,
-0.6762853861,
0.1389947981,
-0.2455015033,
-0.367508769,
0.1590004116,
0.104417488,
-0.3693145514,
0.2209997028,
0.3166878521,
0.3672940433,
-0.5321052074,
0.4217739105,
-0.0554286018,
-0.1976745725,
0.0341288,
-0.9503937364,
0.5460600257,
0.0712374523,
-0.1813959181,
-0.8017946482,
0.1606796831,
0.5602432489,
0.0399200283,
0.5510129333,
0.2195619643,
-0.4431186616,
0.0875946581,
-0.4918728769,
-0.3387975693,
-0.4059858322,
0.3768901825,
-0.4050323665,
-0.3967573345,
0.3490423262,
-0.1925186217,
0.0626504272,
0.6391596198,
0.6128537655,
-0.4162298441,
0.6035345197,
0.8681436181,
-0.3016019464,
0.4235329926,
-0.25584957,
-0.0741470531,
-0.2119059116,
-0.1137857661,
-0.4735380411,
-0.1458992362,
-0.3534218967,
-0.2559045553,
0.0348374397,
0.0669533312,
0.0742242485,
0.3483736813,
-0.1428127289,
0.4278841019,
0.6001294851,
0.0983084738,
0.3378543556,
0.2527477443,
-0.4443629086,
-0.3204140961,
-0.7797124386,
-0.971434176,
1.5080212355,
0.3064293265,
0.4539677501,
0.0461121239,
0.7808837891,
0.7833871245,
0.439692378,
-0.6735842228,
0.0553089529,
-0.1659649014,
-0.9108566046,
-0.5800311565,
-0.3875739276,
-1.0444068909,
0.1053196937,
-0.2349474281,
-0.6226484179,
0.1726786196,
0.4367929697,
-0.1556864828,
0.3925230205,
-0.4422047734,
1.2968902588,
-0.1522557139,
-0.2605047524,
-0.2753041387,
-0.716411531,
0.0957050323,
-0.4289497435,
0.5002130866,
0.4582612216,
0.1167787611,
0.8757362366,
-0.3185936213,
0.607403934,
0.0443342179,
-0.3630711734,
-0.0242175926,
0.5217436552,
0.2264116853,
-0.0088155596,
-0.0385532603,
-0.2667449713,
0.1608271301,
-0.6603766084,
-0.3050113916,
0.2373140007,
-0.8913444281,
-0.0865064636,
-0.4342362583,
-0.3775773048,
-0.1136004701,
0.3804200888,
0.5742557645,
0.6666228771,
-0.6205900311,
-0.1388778538,
0.9961596131,
0.0174717251,
0.3396725953,
0.2706183791,
-0.2019521743,
-0.5401030183,
0.7555093169,
-0.3528773487,
-0.1499996185,
0.2960629761,
-0.2016795278,
-0.2932197452,
-0.4339048266,
-0.8647074103,
0.5141518712,
-0.7972422242,
0.1126586646,
-0.3388063312,
0.2354103476,
-0.3111479878,
-0.1179370657,
-0.4504514933,
-0.4257933497,
-0.8415030837,
-0.1904934943,
-0.1071163341,
0.7362062335,
0.0812494084,
0.5700878501,
-1.0527220964,
0.1976415068,
0.0086943181,
0.0824744776,
-0.3852717578,
-0.5646113753,
-0.4995031059,
-0.1791142523,
-0.2449770421,
-0.9199804068,
0.6957925558,
0.3272031248,
0.3228068352,
0.8469631672,
-0.2719880342,
0.2848339677,
-0.787394464,
0.4750167131,
0.0816741437,
-1.0427650213,
0.4593186677,
-0.369286716,
-0.0800929368,
0.4943682849,
0.8012733459,
-0.7403297424,
-0.4557743073,
-0.8853565454,
-0.4046311378,
0.7756477594,
0.1924344897,
0.1025315598,
0.2182767838,
0.5556403995,
0.4984671474,
0.2413680404,
-0.752732873,
-0.2725396454,
-0.0519371368,
-0.6470110416,
-0.6448125839,
-0.4788198173,
0.021852158,
-0.0453263298,
1.0744693279,
0.0365969129,
0.2754699588,
0.3424394429,
-0.9779602289,
-0.6278439164,
-0.0242737811,
1.0391749144,
1.1705272198,
-0.1638869196,
0.0761259049,
-0.1266302019,
-0.9339162707,
0.091204755,
0.1444669664,
-0.0881744027,
0.4910045862,
0.542288065,
0.6992986202,
0.0585009456,
-0.5894641876,
0.1610954553,
-0.1964959651,
-0.2224492133,
-0.8156217933,
-0.4755104184,
-0.1218446419,
0.1363651901,
0.7151655555,
0.2160150558,
0.07145264,
-0.6465189457,
0.2240449786,
0.059212923,
-0.4819616377,
-0.3623214662,
0.6305767298,
0.01144478,
-0.4945521057,
0.6778577566,
0.1096451208,
-0.7893337011,
0.3604941368,
0.1506072134,
0.6772310138,
-0.6472668648,
0.2616728544,
0.0571683981,
0.3132353127,
0.1205677092,
0.1734846085,
-0.0455750562,
-0.5941559076,
-0.48390311,
-0.5971062183,
-0.1527884156,
-0.1237728596,
-0.3499858081,
0.2895307243,
-0.3906657398,
-0.3639383316,
0.1622533798,
0.251719445,
-0.5260119438,
0.3861685693,
0.2449137568,
0.5813860297,
-0.9505722523,
0.8575922251,
0.822815299,
-0.1862974316,
-0.3536685705,
-0.4357420206,
0.1239129379,
-0.2166410387,
1.303704381,
-0.2579512894,
-0.0406429842,
0.2478023916,
-0.2962264717,
-0.619856894,
0.7416625619,
0.4859336615,
-0.605684042,
-0.1193780601,
-0.0528258309,
0.4980295002,
-0.2032385767,
0.2894274592,
0.233415857,
0.3275111914,
-0.2581021488,
-1.10716784,
-0.2281757444,
-0.3242939711,
-0.3336068392,
0.3836802542,
0.0765139759,
0.9221235514,
0.1801959127,
-0.2094200552,
0.5250210762,
0.7551394105,
-0.1379961073,
0.4695798755,
0.259219557,
0.8565772772,
1.211994648,
-0.0416897498,
1.0100243092,
-0.2553657591,
0.4035699964,
0.6460239291,
0.1725554466,
0.6104956269,
0.3673536181,
-0.1045582965,
0.7483522296,
0.9948652387,
0.1390470117,
0.4990485907,
0.1819770485,
-0.4479738176,
-0.0211176127,
0.5339154601,
-0.1791622043,
0.0304318015,
0.4615781009,
-0.758423388,
0.4318414927,
0.2820464075,
0.2406952977,
-0.0460213646,
-0.3838786185,
1.0150102377,
-0.0162077229,
-0.7368398309,
0.5191955566,
0.1516783834,
0.2200084627,
-0.3647568524,
0.1704394966,
-0.3556883931,
0.5843364596,
-0.2440659851,
0.2795285285,
0.0291955639,
-0.1754695475,
-0.4384022653,
-0.1158435345,
0.5753226876,
-0.3703325391,
-0.8160327673,
-0.0061802571,
0.4103484452,
0.6044908166,
0.0788598508,
-0.4389035404,
-0.0185803641,
-0.19294101,
0.265440017,
-0.1144488305,
0.7322703004,
0.0101673212,
0.5763859153,
0.4841032028,
0.3789605796,
0.4663586915,
-0.3550836444,
0.5431789756,
-0.5419521928,
-0.6096275449,
-1.0582860708,
0.3851675987,
0.1126838401,
-0.1581270248,
0.7289901972,
0.7332186103,
0.9200389385,
-0.6717705131,
0.6219377518,
0.170292601,
0.5465892553,
-0.741784811,
0.632922709,
-0.2406615317,
-0.0420275405,
-0.6586148739,
-0.9856407046,
-0.3985594809,
0.7472028136,
-0.312903136,
-0.2423312813,
1.1339036226,
0.4431336224,
-0.4058535397,
0.2320210338,
0.1706940979,
0.0649723932,
-0.2280299217,
0.48936975,
0.8982028961,
-0.5772729516,
0.3170578182,
-0.0224229172,
-0.2000309527,
-0.5511672497,
-0.5468916297,
-0.8081185818,
-0.9871992469,
-0.3108220994,
-0.2486533076,
0.4089557827,
0.8878036737,
0.8813272715,
-1.0845528841,
-0.4608872533,
-0.1468466371,
-0.0493165813,
-0.1585877389,
-0.0537657626,
0.6720525622,
-0.7451038957,
-0.9252891541,
0.1151370779,
-0.1913169771,
-0.0068439543,
-0.1640638411,
-0.3499400914,
0.0344731212,
-0.1211526692,
0.3848264813,
0.4093781412,
-0.7761249542,
0.2676033974,
0.0935646221,
0.0066348058,
0.1610169858,
1.3362793922,
-0.6128800511,
0.6701385975,
0.1698684543,
0.9391470551,
0.5751206875,
0.0361526236,
0.7078106403,
-0.5614570379,
0.2954651117,
0.465333432,
0.4160904884,
0.3363415897,
-0.5640795231,
0.3017699122,
0.4611332715,
-0.5430130363,
-0.6768350005,
-0.0426328331,
-0.5718889832,
-0.4640154839,
0.5115804076,
-0.4379354417,
-0.1893533319,
-0.2913779914,
-0.477100879,
0.3774435222,
-0.0187192429,
1.0219665766,
1.208881855,
0.1377157271,
-0.3831407726,
-0.8005315661,
0.963237226,
0.6831963062,
-0.6235661507,
-0.1250053197,
0.9520065188,
0.2001090497,
0.486156106,
0.5361303687,
-0.1508802027,
0.5466833711,
-0.2243675292,
-0.0269073248,
0.2255074084,
-0.4616028965,
-0.4658744931,
-0.0283830985,
0.258810252,
0.0783762559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01082v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01082v2 | Contextual Multilingual Spellchecker for User Queries | 2023-05-01T20:29:59 | 2023-06-14T14:29:58 | Sanat Sharma, Josep Valls-Vargas, Tracy Holloway King, Francois Guerin, Chirag Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Spellchecking is one of the most fundamental and widely used search features.
Correcting incorrectly spelled user queries not only enhances the user
experience but is expected by the user. However, most widely available
spellchecking solutions are either lower accuracy than state-of-the-art
solutions or too slow to be used for search use cases where latency is a key
requirement. Furthermore, most innovative recent architectures focus on English
and are not trained in a multilingual fashion and are trained for spell
correction in longer text, which is a different paradigm from spell correction
for user queries, where context is sparse (most queries are 1-2 words long).
Finally, since most enterprises have unique vocabularies such as product names,
off-the-shelf spelling solutions fall short of users' needs. In this work, we
build a multilingual spellchecker that is extremely fast and scalable and that
adapts its vocabulary and hence speller output based on a specific product's
needs. Furthermore, our speller out-performs general purpose spellers by a wide
margin on in-domain datasets. Our multilingual speller is used in search in
Adobe products, powering autocomplete in various applications. | [
-0.3114161491,
-0.4830015898,
0.1463966519,
0.6639401913,
0.1572238356,
0.1868730336,
-0.0886831582,
-0.7108896971,
0.5254999995,
0.3218556941,
-0.5910336375,
-0.3834364116,
-0.3997183144,
0.2880639136,
-0.2545409799,
0.5305768847,
-0.2374331951,
-0.3068110943,
-0.1349711418,
-0.3131946325,
-0.7477238178,
-0.5718824267,
-0.8521102667,
-0.1438183337,
0.497407198,
0.8769629002,
0.6886922121,
0.0580227934,
0.0417662039,
0.3508270681,
0.0673235133,
0.3272010982,
-0.2951061726,
0.4167162776,
-0.2622244656,
-0.3783862293,
-0.4321917295,
-0.2658860981,
0.3036494553,
0.4618042707,
-0.2885936201,
0.1535416543,
-0.1575169563,
0.5239889622,
-0.9317514896,
0.0222514439,
-0.7238167524,
0.1168509722,
-0.440038532,
-0.1646619141,
-0.1706320941,
-0.1478356868,
0.1336938739,
-0.8381366134,
0.4623581469,
0.4530652761,
0.6510793567,
0.2607391179,
-0.5387893319,
-0.3272089064,
-0.6478139758,
0.3624684215,
-0.5335639119,
0.7168785334,
0.5570387244,
0.5572505593,
-0.2210148722,
-0.8206003904,
-0.7415053248,
0.1675877571,
-0.1942025274,
0.301933229,
0.0193620622,
0.0625064373,
0.2417187691,
0.3420660198,
-0.6216239333,
0.0879486427,
-0.2491919696,
-0.5002803802,
0.2417056561,
0.0884667039,
0.5182210803,
-0.0243963879,
0.0021140727,
0.0272386279,
-0.5227397084,
0.1141310632,
0.3648561537,
0.1471653581,
0.4200520515,
0.5244341493,
-0.5961228609,
0.6811401844,
0.1045602635,
-0.2680636048,
0.2141031921,
-0.1277659237,
-0.178597182,
0.3644832075,
0.4282192886,
0.2557967603,
-0.068004787,
-0.3558564186,
-0.123430647,
-0.1189701483,
0.1576881111,
-0.768432498,
-0.3763860762,
0.330052793,
0.048113618,
0.1156150773,
-0.1585493833,
-0.7066814303,
-0.3451509774,
0.0252012946,
0.6105344892,
-0.2097372711,
0.0416334011,
0.0835447758,
-0.1705286056,
-0.2011042982,
0.1443142891,
-1.039072752,
0.0427151844,
0.1454652697,
0.7282560468,
-0.0736547336,
-0.6256192327,
-0.4633762836,
0.367942065,
-0.2250309885,
1.1124801636,
-0.4017842412,
-0.2484266311,
0.1463418901,
0.3223613799,
-0.1846000105,
-0.5628858209,
0.6368538141,
-0.8816085458,
0.389306128,
-0.4651444852,
-0.4273385704,
-0.2818898559,
0.2710269392,
-0.8128998876,
1.2735936642,
-0.1658108979,
-0.691080451,
0.8269945979,
-0.6428107023,
-0.9097872972,
0.3616831899,
0.1437002867,
-0.3357384801,
0.0545324162,
0.5292057991,
0.3027612567,
-0.0075953468,
-0.1907649636,
-0.2080265135,
-0.554962039,
-0.1187818795,
-0.4162885249,
0.4666656554,
0.047414843,
-0.5874609947,
-0.0876808465,
-0.9500394464,
0.0067911716,
-0.1158828437,
-0.5837866664,
-0.4539186954,
0.1264513135,
0.4046986103,
0.4738978744,
0.4296613038,
-0.5757170916,
0.1523515731,
-0.6143119335,
0.2831125259,
0.4574617445,
-0.171077475,
0.2190077603,
0.1007672623,
0.5136989355,
-0.1791484654,
0.1724210978,
-0.026219653,
-0.3883455098,
-0.8773667812,
-0.3862200379,
0.1301465034,
0.7082186937,
-0.8383765221,
0.2226815373,
-0.2434692979,
-0.4445126057,
-0.4783765972,
0.4027215838,
0.3243994117,
0.6030189395,
0.468868643,
-0.1861243993,
-0.4216209948,
-0.7481141686,
-0.6292282939,
0.0222343933,
-0.1109712496,
0.358828187,
0.2957702279,
-0.5998885632,
1.0418360233,
-0.641217947,
-0.7455016375,
0.0490218848,
0.0124865323,
0.2208560258,
-0.0467771366,
0.4374713898,
-0.9197951555,
-0.74153018,
0.1179352105,
-0.4153733552,
-0.2501215339,
0.1129834503,
-0.1973899305,
0.6128501892,
0.4294759929,
-0.3044551313,
0.4159311354,
0.509778142,
-0.5252201557,
0.7012068629,
-0.7369012237,
0.3946834803,
-1.1833097935,
0.2861940265,
-0.1152714118,
-0.2749803662,
-0.4813700914,
-0.0310677513,
0.4529478848,
0.1034483537,
-0.641389966,
0.7724698782,
-0.5465145707,
0.0488907099,
-0.2610424459,
-0.0005210071,
0.2212956697,
0.3635908067,
-0.070446685,
1.2381247282,
0.314920783,
-0.8415682912,
0.7079183459,
0.3367003202,
-0.1725474149,
0.9755042791,
-0.5491430759,
-0.1805746406,
0.1736607105,
0.2452101111,
-0.8578094244,
-0.3407591283,
-0.0727157071,
-0.1806311607,
0.129835099,
0.0611460805,
-1.0097571611,
-0.8358831406,
-0.0482806712,
0.3725037575,
0.0213396959,
-1.0332043171,
0.5140571594,
0.3811798692,
0.0634956434,
-0.7226744294,
-0.5758874416,
0.2399549335,
-0.2288457453,
-0.8556698561,
0.4671949744,
-0.3000092506,
0.2402822524,
-0.2901728749,
-0.4111676812,
-0.4589843154,
0.0432683714,
0.1566846222,
-0.0335447975,
0.0818535537,
0.2840594947,
0.2427636832,
0.0287800152,
-0.2415526062,
-0.2908689678,
0.1540991515,
-0.0817282125,
-0.4314548373,
-0.0722767711,
0.3568555415,
0.7918252349,
-0.3198738694,
0.8647325039,
0.7025361061,
-0.6079785824,
-0.2194016129,
-0.9331766367,
-0.0384733006,
-0.5672786832,
0.3227611482,
-0.6956604719,
-0.8662400842,
0.7565991282,
-0.0102065094,
-0.1127589345,
0.5354168415,
0.4063667059,
-0.0782547519,
1.0522327423,
0.6868213415,
0.0478646532,
0.2642318308,
0.0891240165,
0.4916130602,
-0.5747683048,
-0.3478797674,
-0.2778905332,
-0.2206723094,
-0.3178164065,
-0.02787764,
0.3955801725,
-0.0638524964,
0.1239575893,
0.620234251,
-0.4111855626,
0.5284113884,
0.8196592331,
-0.0755280256,
0.2045916021,
0.2520317733,
-0.595143199,
-0.1261829585,
-0.6481588483,
-0.1501516402,
0.817637682,
-0.1603820026,
0.5575920343,
0.2486056983,
0.1835839301,
0.1006408259,
-0.0194605812,
-0.7152638435,
0.0639163107,
-0.2981203496,
-0.9262676239,
-0.3367826939,
-0.0574140958,
-0.8808220029,
0.4306548536,
-0.2103340626,
-0.6237963438,
0.19811818,
0.5755113959,
-0.3583928943,
0.2612876594,
-0.7443186045,
1.2813296318,
-0.2721430659,
-0.4500077069,
-0.1144701988,
-0.4915211201,
0.1477252096,
-0.3430464566,
0.2588042021,
0.0483753756,
0.2851294279,
0.582339704,
-0.6271935105,
0.5914966464,
-0.1076293886,
-0.2724722624,
-0.0114428373,
0.0760701746,
0.229851231,
0.1522031873,
0.1212354377,
0.0117057581,
0.2484449446,
-0.3247572482,
-0.4375734925,
0.7847486138,
-0.4112912118,
-0.3854818642,
-0.4280563891,
-0.2355343252,
-0.3982928395,
0.4000252187,
0.4931015968,
0.3696112633,
-0.3989962935,
-0.0830463469,
0.6513754725,
-0.1752898395,
0.3355953097,
0.7565970421,
-0.0696839169,
-0.1824754477,
1.0412338972,
0.2393816411,
-0.2480012178,
0.5349446535,
-0.0442515612,
-0.56080091,
0.0167349707,
-0.4090409875,
0.143623516,
-0.7736418843,
0.0007090666,
-0.6614860296,
-0.0075822002,
-0.5096649528,
-0.1983437538,
-0.3594258726,
-0.2687482238,
-0.3075884879,
0.1278631538,
0.3554635346,
0.4535728693,
-0.051269751,
0.4381614625,
-0.5447253585,
0.5916436315,
0.7639476657,
0.7622065544,
-0.3300034404,
-0.3553305566,
-0.3377712965,
-0.2538214028,
-0.4357821941,
-0.8866707087,
0.5588275194,
0.6114370227,
0.5565738678,
0.4330859482,
-0.1295764446,
1.0869026184,
-0.8178868294,
0.5554319024,
-0.043245133,
-0.8707267046,
0.5829376578,
0.1746881455,
0.5127156377,
0.7406690121,
0.2240870148,
-1.3336138725,
-0.109288916,
-0.1793779582,
-1.2997466326,
0.6441549063,
-0.0921491534,
-0.1149030253,
-0.0472105779,
0.2738892734,
0.2136678547,
0.1123019084,
-0.2238657475,
-0.4558941722,
-0.2180083096,
-0.0058884281,
-0.3394011259,
-0.4628392756,
0.1993275732,
-0.1683531851,
1.0360367298,
-0.3113204241,
-0.1238741055,
0.138578102,
-0.6948369741,
0.0317763127,
0.4019984901,
0.5437301397,
0.6399819851,
-0.2319372594,
0.158850193,
0.336613059,
-0.6165132523,
0.0018830121,
0.2145699263,
0.1298053116,
0.1295131594,
-0.1191384345,
0.6127980947,
0.482421875,
-0.6556175351,
0.5618184805,
-0.3340657353,
-0.0698523596,
-0.5693970323,
-0.2999876142,
0.1753792316,
-0.0180582292,
0.3549018502,
0.2146766782,
0.5668565631,
-0.1681202501,
0.0625682697,
0.3396603167,
-0.1320221722,
-0.217239961,
0.9062681198,
0.2188703418,
-0.1569372714,
0.5428552032,
-0.2792677879,
-0.8058295846,
0.2838061154,
0.6314961314,
0.7703830004,
-0.3281443715,
0.0722500235,
0.1837564856,
0.3590676785,
-0.3481734097,
0.191650182,
-0.1019531116,
-0.4983519316,
-0.4026097059,
-0.572232008,
-0.5190079212,
-0.0102961604,
-0.3197917938,
0.3266935349,
-0.0481291041,
-0.0818363056,
-0.2333172709,
0.0308247283,
-0.9520085454,
0.4139174819,
-0.0283971615,
0.9450728893,
-0.8081979156,
0.6261786819,
0.8935927153,
-0.1813925058,
-0.5830461979,
-0.1341990232,
0.0806073174,
-0.6746462584,
0.6254194975,
0.4144532382,
-0.3512470126,
-0.1839177161,
0.0002282373,
-1.0454083681,
1.1398097277,
0.2222594768,
-0.5016950369,
-0.0333621763,
0.1589015871,
0.5476856232,
0.1532622427,
0.3365216851,
0.516391933,
0.4949217737,
0.2084348798,
-1.1715618372,
-0.2170675397,
-0.3332838416,
0.1053126454,
-0.000710885,
-0.4234813154,
0.4927896559,
0.2107855827,
-0.3301939964,
-0.2587574422,
0.7110394239,
0.070098713,
0.3245717585,
0.3012508154,
0.6836300492,
0.9103062153,
0.1555206031,
0.7684634924,
-0.6333033442,
0.1421198547,
1.1872087717,
-0.2778834999,
0.9038577676,
0.4553732276,
-0.0017021726,
0.3296982944,
0.6537443995,
0.2673695982,
0.319214046,
0.0493066832,
-0.31291008,
-0.2285448164,
0.2265389264,
-0.2428274304,
0.3059153259,
0.4379372001,
0.078997992,
-0.0831779391,
0.0746959299,
-0.0091137225,
0.1206291988,
-0.2183454037,
0.4080302715,
-0.2528401911,
-0.5374358892,
0.4637320936,
0.2256953567,
1.1922951937,
-0.4141530991,
0.2073624283,
-0.2755638659,
0.4305760264,
-0.2804742455,
-0.422298193,
0.2539989948,
-0.2042781562,
-0.193948999,
-0.1374338716,
0.6981512308,
-0.5091541409,
-0.5119882822,
0.4054397345,
0.4254093468,
0.1221884862,
-0.437544167,
-0.53365165,
-0.3254542053,
-0.4332009852,
-0.2032405585,
-0.0993627906,
0.334592402,
-0.078949362,
0.6915589571,
0.4891187251,
0.0886691883,
0.5265088081,
0.2301660925,
0.3952711225,
-0.2560460567,
-0.6846770048,
-0.5708307028,
0.3713000417,
-0.0894963592,
-0.4287545979,
1.0288466215,
0.7821125984,
0.9169886708,
-0.1890445203,
0.6744701266,
0.1382442564,
0.3591278493,
-0.1602879614,
1.0231888294,
-0.9394428134,
-0.0454816185,
-0.1107868776,
-1.1045064926,
-0.6550515294,
0.4792951941,
-0.0873171985,
-0.1129817516,
0.8426187038,
0.7052256465,
-0.3334099352,
-0.211515516,
0.5204218626,
0.1368810236,
0.3316252828,
0.3654051721,
0.23212488,
-0.4862798452,
0.6275839806,
-0.198392123,
-0.2101057619,
-0.622494936,
-0.8097178936,
-0.9357095361,
-0.6354814172,
-0.1661107689,
-0.0803770572,
0.1333205402,
0.7141236067,
0.7322089076,
-1.0059841871,
-0.1089050099,
0.1292525381,
0.0362510085,
-0.370447129,
-0.2499747276,
0.2985733449,
-0.5041935444,
-0.6984341741,
0.5068237782,
0.3288963735,
-0.1139999256,
-0.0949091241,
0.1601806581,
-0.1229002103,
0.2452273071,
0.7645177245,
0.6840117574,
-0.665940702,
-0.2414155304,
0.1833245009,
-0.1351017505,
0.1319303662,
0.4206540287,
-0.7795433998,
0.8496470451,
0.4730331004,
0.4367447495,
0.4754644334,
-0.5599956512,
0.4076355398,
-1.0911630392,
-0.066543974,
-0.1558067203,
0.6094626188,
0.3682514131,
-0.4761820138,
0.0718194172,
0.2904778719,
-0.6541725397,
-0.3769029081,
0.1569885164,
-0.5962828398,
-0.2333966643,
1.0260574818,
0.2550258338,
-0.3194154203,
-0.1495928466,
-0.589830637,
0.2540712655,
-0.3987664282,
0.8781874776,
0.7605347037,
0.0351628065,
0.3459775448,
-0.4606287479,
0.4635014832,
0.4137505293,
-0.6431027651,
-0.1534613818,
0.5599585176,
0.5093709826,
0.2269385159,
0.702888906,
0.2617610991,
0.4661426246,
-0.2455120385,
0.4038847685,
0.1008914858,
-0.4186395407,
-0.3189372718,
0.3412182033,
0.0699612945,
-0.0716395006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01050v1 | SafeWebUH at SemEval-2023 Task 11: Learning Annotator Disagreement in Derogatory Text: Comparison of Direct Training vs Aggregation | 2023-05-01T19:30:32 | 2023-05-01T19:30:32 | Sadat Shahriar, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Subjectivity and difference of opinion are key social phenomena, and it is
crucial to take these into account in the annotation and detection process of
derogatory textual content. In this paper, we use four datasets provided by
SemEval-2023 Task 11 and fine-tune a BERT model to capture the disagreement in
the annotation. We find individual annotator modeling and aggregation lowers
the Cross-Entropy score by an average of 0.21, compared to the direct training
on the soft labels. Our findings further demonstrate that annotator metadata
contributes to the average 0.029 reduction in the Cross-Entropy score. | [
-0.6390741467,
-0.6893317699,
0.3039856851,
-0.1534132212,
-0.5438693762,
-0.0978190526,
-0.2984136343,
-0.8775348067,
0.0749071538,
0.2240839303,
-0.058225017,
-0.5420364141,
-1.0878331661,
0.332967937,
-0.262676388,
1.3822612762,
-0.0517898761,
-0.1828886569,
-0.0286920387,
-0.2499766052,
-0.1948353797,
-0.4649594128,
-0.6634910107,
-0.307654351,
0.9868542552,
0.1950166672,
0.6205502748,
0.4201828539,
0.5940204263,
0.3751739264,
-0.0615616292,
-0.0788861662,
-0.3057433665,
0.4297713339,
-0.247385323,
-0.2374432534,
-0.3160982728,
0.1385826319,
0.1074715555,
0.3638854325,
0.1231574416,
0.3558555245,
0.1239879653,
0.3368824422,
-0.52818501,
0.1413004994,
-0.7607367039,
0.0171480924,
-0.284062624,
0.1911473423,
-0.3874467611,
-0.2317443937,
0.090560101,
-0.2568237484,
0.4762075543,
-0.1822507232,
0.9765526652,
0.6062406301,
-0.6387680173,
-0.1726668477,
-0.3060648143,
0.7745583653,
-0.747595787,
0.3004568219,
0.6153404713,
-0.1524428874,
0.451938957,
-0.4921824336,
-0.5180979967,
0.2369630933,
0.048212111,
-0.0865248144,
-0.1065668389,
-0.1521373391,
0.0649218187,
0.0109644607,
-0.1630105972,
0.3737760484,
-0.5888236761,
-0.2380740643,
0.9454138875,
0.0002776777,
0.0477340817,
-0.3947643638,
-0.4883569777,
-0.0263059344,
-0.3163104057,
-0.0930351391,
0.4887758195,
0.1966339201,
-0.0712640136,
0.0987614542,
-0.0360126831,
0.3911096454,
0.0567199998,
0.0854819864,
0.7097098231,
0.1593123525,
-0.2864125073,
0.2691061497,
0.8895051479,
0.43158108,
0.110253498,
-0.101282075,
-0.3702478409,
0.201022312,
0.3623546362,
-0.6791805029,
-0.4753403664,
0.0870566592,
-0.5533130169,
-0.8067302108,
-0.0017494523,
-0.8862189054,
-0.7282007933,
-0.3506139815,
0.5526117682,
-0.3514666259,
-0.227627635,
-0.4328351915,
-0.2473465055,
-0.009341321,
0.7800632715,
-0.8708723783,
-0.1136696264,
0.7016583085,
0.5670447946,
-0.0463981181,
-0.2333826274,
-0.1270074099,
0.0151956342,
-0.183876276,
0.7842810154,
-0.7574713826,
-0.141119346,
-0.1005093679,
0.0309521686,
-0.0621652938,
-0.2992490232,
0.5490145087,
-0.4086100459,
0.1939895153,
-0.3203068674,
-0.5077226758,
-0.5461835861,
0.3694371581,
-0.528693378,
0.9906095862,
-0.0699067563,
-0.9808465242,
0.7921561003,
-0.3900102675,
-0.4612603486,
0.026900379,
-0.043203406,
-0.4703750014,
0.172273308,
-0.0191707741,
0.5114910007,
0.0359511822,
0.414580822,
-0.5748769045,
-0.3449757099,
0.3652397394,
-0.382769227,
0.7748472691,
0.493558377,
-0.634162426,
0.0849597454,
-0.7500600815,
-0.2793958783,
-0.0668728203,
-0.4881750047,
-0.9706062675,
-0.0251633711,
-0.052212283,
0.275421828,
0.2096201479,
-0.7424376607,
-0.1195790693,
0.1296534687,
0.0999715403,
1.2155072689,
0.0182954036,
0.202381596,
-0.3204636872,
-0.0119096441,
0.1291963458,
0.0888775885,
0.2887135148,
-0.5874137878,
-0.9115840793,
-0.1768638492,
0.5549586415,
0.255780071,
-0.4020044804,
0.4764692187,
-0.1372955889,
-0.7097485065,
-0.4607947767,
0.2079887837,
0.3176662028,
0.4890271723,
0.3621245623,
-0.2199541479,
-0.4591744542,
-0.6729510427,
-0.3257505596,
-0.3481027484,
-0.026076965,
0.0148434872,
0.6349484324,
-0.3487178087,
0.3457531333,
-0.1475513577,
-0.1910808384,
0.0519301966,
0.8159281015,
-0.2184296399,
0.670333147,
0.551201582,
-0.8519986868,
-0.4378598928,
-0.1911175251,
-0.8538860083,
-0.2050663084,
0.2756938934,
0.0552067123,
0.6301083565,
0.3736901879,
-0.1332186311,
0.5360303521,
0.4202753901,
-0.4088636637,
0.0541897751,
0.2166528255,
0.4375524819,
-1.0470889807,
-0.2715941668,
0.0555485152,
-0.081944555,
-0.6849122047,
-0.0374532379,
-0.1396653652,
0.226937294,
-0.4489644766,
0.2651991844,
-0.1318793893,
0.6410655379,
-0.1450529099,
-0.076549843,
-0.1286008805,
0.4428787827,
0.2511701882,
0.3268893063,
0.2089477628,
-0.6298350692,
0.0819188729,
0.3569304645,
-0.1667199731,
0.3543801606,
-0.4648229182,
0.3917218745,
-0.3108219504,
0.0022094573,
-1.1608786583,
-0.4308696985,
0.3233469725,
-0.492839545,
0.352992177,
0.0093150092,
-0.3486709893,
-0.2313124985,
-0.7165096402,
0.271004349,
0.4826500714,
-0.4551380575,
0.3508560956,
0.661441505,
-0.228335306,
-0.6849213839,
-0.9304141402,
0.0275985505,
-0.4098557234,
-0.4395928383,
0.0313668586,
0.1669119447,
-0.4054140747,
-0.0587573126,
-0.16766496,
-0.0805730894,
0.1303939223,
0.3570475578,
0.0153123215,
0.1905987412,
0.4583103359,
-0.0609185174,
-0.0065377993,
0.3150829673,
0.4433804452,
0.2676715851,
-0.1584200114,
-0.188728407,
0.0555056259,
0.3403257132,
0.2841177285,
0.1840857267,
0.8850185275,
0.9383040667,
-0.4347375929,
0.1434883177,
-0.738117516,
-0.151045531,
-0.4180929661,
0.2689246237,
-0.1246615648,
-0.9207838774,
0.5545459986,
0.1536698788,
0.2909890413,
0.5492340326,
0.5012035966,
-0.234001562,
1.0409832001,
0.3852137923,
0.0853573605,
0.3684769571,
0.0839371011,
0.1321436465,
-0.7028226256,
-0.4725200236,
-0.7069875598,
-0.717251122,
-0.8712682128,
-0.2965238392,
0.1755189151,
-0.4089419246,
-0.6027909517,
0.1906784624,
-0.5589291453,
0.0903985873,
0.5536770225,
0.4257552922,
-0.0256845374,
0.032519538,
-0.0624412149,
-0.3243874013,
-0.3505165875,
-0.6831136346,
0.7967548966,
0.4689885974,
0.8105745912,
0.2639812827,
1.2505774498,
0.4510775208,
0.5012508631,
-0.5110219121,
0.6259526014,
-0.1600887179,
-0.9659432173,
-0.3349682987,
-0.3230436444,
-0.7587816119,
0.2766503692,
-0.1430858821,
-0.9248194098,
0.5884444118,
0.0151225068,
0.002984385,
0.548915863,
-0.7230577469,
0.8169935346,
-0.0786923692,
-0.5130677819,
0.0509789586,
-0.8931159973,
0.4020685256,
-0.4628305137,
0.3468934596,
-0.4599108398,
-0.1697292179,
1.1357046366,
-0.5877304673,
1.2574646473,
-0.3804429173,
-0.2648037374,
0.3250992894,
-0.042894166,
0.3680646718,
-0.1013526917,
-0.3506073356,
0.4118030965,
-0.2550804019,
-0.1587498784,
0.0218441505,
0.3908772469,
-0.9494342208,
-0.6636763811,
-0.6288196445,
-0.2585780323,
-0.0436872691,
0.1071524024,
0.3989450336,
0.1083719358,
-0.094765164,
0.5017186403,
0.6669377685,
-0.1520282179,
0.4691758454,
0.3203916252,
0.2037846595,
-0.2312811911,
0.6220877767,
0.1887540817,
0.0025298849,
0.2749103606,
0.2540292442,
-0.2479590029,
-0.3730212748,
-0.0201519206,
-0.235207051,
-0.9961506128,
-0.6368623376,
-0.8864107728,
-0.2197418213,
-0.4603764713,
-0.2261660248,
-0.120083347,
-0.4001612663,
-0.2201367319,
-0.3097051084,
0.6389996409,
0.8434185982,
-0.4709278345,
0.1585420817,
-0.8629139066,
-0.0739460811,
0.5078292489,
0.1358282715,
-0.1077897698,
-0.6196373701,
-0.1513565779,
-0.0322909541,
-0.2041134685,
-0.9449341297,
0.1496717632,
-0.0500261597,
0.4099547565,
0.6106874347,
0.3700152934,
0.6449353099,
-0.2207448483,
0.8394317627,
0.1355816871,
-0.9653056264,
0.6532176137,
-0.2673493028,
0.1284127831,
0.9102887511,
0.4552378356,
-0.3773989081,
-0.6382767558,
-0.6528298259,
-0.9964274168,
0.5607171655,
0.1307696402,
0.1615334749,
-0.2820295393,
-0.0394945666,
0.5161313415,
0.2613731027,
-0.9577971697,
-0.1124676019,
-0.2803947628,
-0.3564599752,
0.1814534962,
-0.4632575214,
-0.2509528399,
-0.3581498265,
0.808834374,
0.1455069333,
0.2997345924,
-0.0557990074,
-0.2294772118,
-0.1252441704,
0.4491206408,
0.3617594838,
0.4646708667,
-0.3932224512,
0.5783756375,
0.4409360588,
-0.6213321686,
0.2460579723,
0.3018527627,
-0.379481554,
0.2210586369,
0.3884156048,
0.8462305069,
0.187005803,
-0.12193726,
0.428453207,
-0.0298036337,
-0.4203231633,
0.0152199706,
0.0654357895,
-0.1959676445,
0.1551481634,
0.2358387709,
0.3713821769,
0.2583269775,
-0.2802444696,
0.243165195,
0.093546465,
-0.5502693653,
-0.326144129,
0.9040375948,
0.6209718585,
0.0673694462,
0.3005847335,
-0.2380589694,
-0.6076703072,
0.5026960373,
0.1883776635,
0.8179174066,
-0.4341766536,
0.2620702982,
0.3902772963,
0.5014635324,
0.2443617135,
0.1454880983,
-0.2604095042,
-0.7774514556,
0.0279615913,
-0.6213017702,
-0.2931557894,
0.1198521554,
-0.6330955625,
0.271286428,
-0.2890519202,
-0.2867218554,
0.1449158341,
-0.0526620708,
-0.885822773,
0.4032952785,
0.3683539927,
0.6227157116,
-0.9950717688,
0.5638526082,
0.9348016977,
-0.6105152965,
-0.8280805349,
0.0079094404,
0.2615019381,
-0.7054671049,
0.6931217313,
0.346495688,
0.136524111,
-0.3675752878,
-0.5781786442,
-0.3079129755,
0.8661766052,
-0.0006974281,
-0.6747022867,
0.1866749525,
0.0018610721,
0.5118990541,
-0.0753446668,
0.1460762024,
0.308224082,
0.5661969185,
-0.0724247694,
-0.6656198502,
0.254008919,
-0.2359381467,
-0.1566027403,
0.383692801,
-0.7853515148,
0.8631022573,
-0.1019721627,
-0.0547411963,
-0.2613342702,
0.4070520997,
0.1506920159,
0.6098609567,
0.7676849365,
0.6363441944,
0.8770563006,
-0.1527219564,
0.6668985486,
-0.0589339808,
0.4865497947,
1.1086411476,
-0.3492026925,
0.8285169005,
0.4183869362,
0.0122553576,
0.5373979807,
0.8947197795,
-0.0050756568,
0.6179920435,
-0.0028429541,
-0.4948259592,
-0.3370381296,
-0.0851414353,
-0.5311966538,
0.8000019193,
0.2163695097,
-0.6463842988,
-0.247307986,
-0.0245321374,
0.3650147319,
-0.1004286483,
-0.377630502,
1.0329383612,
0.0348698087,
-0.4592364132,
0.2811334133,
-0.1806394458,
0.8980048299,
-0.3090575933,
0.1482836604,
-0.1037323549,
0.2317248583,
-0.2435433865,
-0.8621225953,
0.3486082852,
0.3297629356,
0.1397039592,
-0.1493054777,
1.1602374315,
-0.4103249013,
-0.4675649405,
0.1969926953,
0.4704829752,
0.3874128759,
0.1028881744,
-0.6258231401,
0.1919127107,
0.1128263846,
-0.3187160492,
0.2413262129,
0.877409935,
-0.0081677753,
0.0171970855,
0.4124521017,
-0.3521706462,
0.0461585596,
0.2255918682,
0.8471265435,
-0.5634207129,
-0.2999235988,
-0.9688639641,
0.39227584,
-0.3636642098,
-0.3577703536,
0.7543383241,
0.3078210056,
0.9329057336,
-0.1170075089,
0.9436602592,
-0.493227154,
0.5374335051,
-0.2148242146,
0.8189678788,
-0.5121142864,
0.0497883223,
-0.4453877211,
-0.7776119709,
-0.2494173795,
0.9396008849,
-0.3664946258,
0.183321327,
0.4693348706,
0.358461082,
0.07096681,
0.308924973,
0.2572338879,
0.0951338038,
0.206949234,
0.3318668604,
0.7971848249,
-0.5840458274,
0.5013185143,
-0.4737095833,
0.0302988794,
-0.2413099855,
-0.9939638376,
-1.0929234028,
-0.5947149992,
-0.6803188324,
-0.456795752,
0.145615384,
0.9948523641,
0.4810805917,
-1.0472215414,
0.2335754931,
0.1405597478,
0.1359659135,
-0.0024925049,
-0.2452822626,
0.033929389,
-0.4614388645,
-0.8294630051,
-0.3823294342,
0.0540317558,
0.0703265294,
0.0578162335,
-0.1340021044,
-0.4856249094,
0.0862262398,
0.6303411126,
0.009103992,
-0.5329646468,
-0.8266120553,
-0.4951050878,
-0.1410042197,
-0.0928658843,
0.3663962781,
-0.5635813475,
0.4552720189,
0.6104028225,
0.5756495595,
0.3106354475,
0.1301244944,
0.2926666141,
-0.8168213367,
0.2387268692,
0.1508274376,
0.4093451202,
0.5116032958,
-0.4007412195,
0.8587419391,
0.3392671645,
-0.7483853102,
-0.8279790878,
-0.1275535077,
-0.6740808487,
-0.2413607836,
1.1337083578,
-0.1598460674,
-0.3475094736,
-0.3485438228,
-0.068639107,
0.4558703601,
-0.6332860589,
1.183406949,
0.8581641316,
-0.1024828553,
-0.1666932404,
-0.2681867182,
0.5149115324,
0.2861250639,
-0.6318161488,
-0.0452967472,
0.4759020507,
0.3827568293,
0.374856472,
0.4540564418,
0.0299390294,
0.1106053069,
0.2325886935,
0.1378014088,
-0.0082853492,
-0.2190990895,
-0.1391703337,
0.0481288247,
-0.0916867927,
-0.44309026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01028v2 | Company classification using zero-shot learning | 2023-05-01T18:36:06 | 2023-10-26T20:19:37 | Maryan Rizinski, Andrej Jankov, Vignesh Sankaradas, Eugene Pinsky, Igor Miskovski, Dimitar Trajanov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, natural language processing (NLP) has become increasingly
important in a variety of business applications, including sentiment analysis,
text classification, and named entity recognition. In this paper, we propose an
approach for company classification using NLP and zero-shot learning. Our
method utilizes pre-trained transformer models to extract features from company
descriptions, and then applies zero-shot learning to classify companies into
relevant categories without the need for specific training data for each
category. We evaluate our approach on a dataset obtained through the Wharton
Research Data Services (WRDS), which comprises textual descriptions of publicly
traded companies. We demonstrate that the approach can streamline the process
of company classification, thereby reducing the time and resources required in
traditional approaches such as the Global Industry Classification Standard
(GICS). The results show that this method has potential for automation of
company classification, making it a promising avenue for future research in
this area. | [
-0.2832453549,
-0.3843916357,
0.1825784743,
0.0761566833,
-0.2886953652,
0.3365046084,
0.0274423212,
-0.9179828167,
0.1602920741,
0.6484095454,
-0.4838334024,
-0.6512871385,
-0.4573659897,
0.1182260886,
-0.4779590666,
1.5150271654,
0.0697113052,
-0.1871798337,
-0.1287436485,
-0.249355793,
-0.4084344208,
-0.6360986233,
-0.6235493422,
-0.181787774,
0.4180358052,
0.4181872308,
0.5082327127,
0.4587914944,
0.4146359265,
0.2625814676,
0.1930531412,
-0.2937082648,
-0.0411818102,
0.2739751041,
-0.1307850629,
-0.3891863823,
-0.1225336939,
0.1273284554,
0.2693300247,
0.9175084233,
-0.1243444979,
0.4965919256,
-0.057755515,
0.1088611335,
-0.8195627332,
0.5217494369,
-0.4860577583,
0.5976743102,
-0.0003258711,
-0.3623811901,
-0.6321725845,
-0.3753642142,
0.4670910239,
-0.1344003975,
0.6460724473,
0.2861038148,
1.1327211857,
0.0307509918,
-0.3338901699,
-0.1959673762,
-1.191617012,
1.062838316,
-0.2175013274,
0.1192198992,
-0.0072208778,
0.4420213699,
0.310367316,
-0.4787116349,
-0.431892246,
0.0149279227,
-0.1223402768,
0.1812740564,
-0.3791630566,
0.0543309525,
0.045150917,
0.4393179119,
-0.6614729166,
0.4932821393,
-0.5898499489,
0.038039241,
0.6413955092,
-0.1023610756,
0.0917825177,
-0.087104395,
-0.5498580337,
-0.2411869913,
-0.2765015364,
0.1859357953,
-0.0467505567,
0.4617041647,
0.3266486228,
0.5752151012,
-0.4796291888,
0.6168875098,
-0.0091710491,
0.0598198809,
0.3674655557,
0.3433726132,
-0.898268342,
0.5793917775,
0.5157415867,
0.0515957847,
0.1649697721,
-0.7564018965,
-0.1188721508,
0.3297253847,
0.5317586064,
-0.6044819355,
-0.0775534436,
0.2813144326,
-0.1958524883,
-0.6434479356,
0.2375723422,
-0.6482792497,
-0.1293789446,
-0.2965405285,
0.5556758642,
-0.1182427853,
0.0635183007,
0.1196322516,
-0.5430322289,
0.8610084653,
0.2833739519,
-0.6570571661,
0.2133607119,
0.7727789283,
0.8638533354,
-0.0102743777,
-0.1157547086,
-0.6733404994,
0.3733029962,
-0.5272628069,
1.0075308084,
-0.2805759907,
-0.3074965477,
0.1607612967,
-0.1970156878,
0.1117952988,
-0.6298119426,
0.453900218,
-0.6772176027,
0.6765984297,
0.405469656,
-0.5173995495,
-0.5128945112,
0.607265234,
-0.436026305,
0.5292117596,
-0.0408500507,
-0.7283308506,
0.6862683296,
-0.7968222499,
-0.4423424304,
0.5494509339,
-0.3124770224,
-0.689391613,
0.2497205287,
0.1155327335,
0.8668624759,
-0.013249347,
0.2384740561,
-0.3620787859,
-0.1030937359,
0.1904709637,
-0.3171906173,
0.7718610764,
0.2294557691,
-0.2080914974,
-0.0402735285,
-0.8133350611,
0.1003118083,
0.1986712664,
0.0231858622,
-0.4735834301,
-0.1984956414,
-0.1005185843,
0.3899632394,
0.1133548319,
-0.5054866672,
0.1517555416,
-0.5129071474,
-0.1404175758,
0.4039551616,
0.1660899669,
0.824552536,
-0.1166810617,
0.6941742897,
0.014666765,
0.2882647812,
-0.137031436,
-0.5399897695,
-1.0115151405,
-0.3912898004,
0.4146158993,
0.7470549941,
-0.7257757783,
0.812312603,
-0.43852669,
-0.6211910248,
-0.4008687735,
-0.3093878329,
0.0836400539,
0.7475778461,
0.7210738063,
-0.4870302379,
-0.4084151685,
-0.8595893383,
-0.2200943828,
-0.0096458374,
-0.6747814417,
0.0857588574,
0.1640070528,
-0.1900632977,
1.3177884817,
-0.8910580277,
-0.4856587648,
-0.3912370801,
0.7919594646,
0.4292461574,
-0.0633528307,
0.266800642,
-0.5829968452,
-0.4576768577,
0.2971448898,
-0.5223169923,
0.0489098094,
-0.1771778762,
0.0247120857,
0.1959298104,
0.0753607452,
-0.5190342665,
0.7443971038,
0.1874716282,
-0.2523156703,
0.3557366133,
0.0223345291,
-0.1969749629,
-1.0191180706,
0.0823316947,
0.5432770848,
-0.4058586657,
-0.8237065077,
-0.4114727378,
-0.1399406195,
-0.4391115904,
-0.5004937053,
0.2406455725,
-0.2206091881,
-0.2731305659,
-0.3099340498,
-0.0738873631,
0.1279805899,
0.6218296885,
0.5713295341,
0.1701202393,
0.7111218572,
-0.9883211851,
0.3948611021,
0.3611678779,
-0.3890758157,
0.5728211403,
-0.261107415,
-0.0588355735,
-0.3940606415,
0.2161678374,
-0.5472766757,
0.0488780402,
0.2807052135,
-0.399123162,
0.4999685884,
0.0358064957,
-0.2276584655,
-0.3777282834,
-0.3701873422,
-0.3173502386,
0.5720985532,
-0.4580748677,
0.431846261,
0.2221276313,
-0.2618737519,
-0.6273721457,
-0.9715743661,
0.1832730621,
-0.3615035713,
-0.1363793761,
0.6009720564,
0.4775931835,
0.1563302875,
0.0736178383,
-0.3125540018,
-0.7045704126,
-0.096661903,
0.1778560281,
0.6053894758,
0.0321441926,
0.0583034121,
-0.2442615926,
-0.3672798276,
-0.0937541798,
-0.2027790993,
0.2582534254,
0.1132098287,
0.1031483561,
-0.6744967103,
-0.0792772472,
0.1894805878,
-0.2522931099,
0.8241527677,
0.4649212658,
-0.2478477657,
-0.5998943448,
-0.3647129238,
0.1289055645,
-0.4735003412,
0.1199104339,
0.3502402306,
-0.6206372976,
0.0795933232,
-0.3324401379,
-0.0057269176,
0.7861843109,
0.3089223206,
-0.2629778087,
0.6417334676,
1.2421120405,
-0.4553786814,
0.3814845085,
-0.5406904221,
0.8607382178,
-0.1280842423,
-0.4434324205,
-0.9318304658,
-0.530359447,
-0.6541329622,
-0.1424769908,
-0.0045073214,
0.003497757,
-0.2321540564,
0.7935013175,
-0.6589587331,
0.5356865525,
0.4864753485,
-0.4437830746,
0.2628659904,
0.1904197931,
0.134040013,
0.1684205085,
-0.3615345359,
-0.3648728132,
0.6324333549,
0.4747910798,
0.6451970935,
-0.166666165,
0.8180472851,
0.3533650339,
0.2733622789,
-1.1093004942,
0.3401773274,
-0.3252910078,
-0.6089814901,
-0.2812826633,
-0.5844385624,
-0.7981239557,
-0.1009135544,
-0.183340475,
-0.5992681384,
0.4188668728,
-0.2719271183,
-0.6535847187,
0.1113022044,
-0.821264863,
0.7848141193,
-0.5026531816,
0.3503546417,
0.0526144281,
-0.3296916783,
0.1463304013,
-0.1837337911,
0.046608068,
-0.0581228025,
0.0512199737,
0.6950198412,
-0.1263257116,
0.6963053346,
-0.2820455432,
0.1517689079,
0.1212755144,
-0.1013446152,
0.0976873413,
-0.1216787994,
0.0863381922,
0.6287110448,
0.0620687045,
-0.1383765042,
-0.6983354092,
0.2350706607,
-0.4883181155,
0.1361474544,
-0.9589784145,
-0.0147845149,
-0.3005680442,
0.1200932413,
0.2352614552,
-0.104861185,
-0.2133378685,
0.4464727938,
0.3660484254,
-0.3730604947,
0.9028502107,
0.6660414338,
-0.3072496951,
-0.3031119406,
0.7258566022,
0.534365356,
-0.2727245986,
0.6610232592,
-0.0056496216,
-0.6575397253,
-0.2623547316,
-0.1313018948,
-0.186409384,
-0.2782284021,
-0.7160742879,
-0.3651303053,
-0.5840952396,
-0.3736954033,
-0.3608700037,
-0.2685704827,
-0.3900788128,
-0.3897071779,
-0.1021363214,
0.0841317773,
0.576990664,
0.6044976115,
0.3078203499,
-0.9220567942,
0.5502578616,
0.4702762365,
0.6678214073,
-0.2407014519,
-0.3064320683,
-0.3948312998,
-0.0472488105,
-0.7373043895,
-0.8061733246,
0.7983543873,
0.3351305723,
0.4523355663,
0.7119935751,
0.4159598351,
0.6455233693,
-0.5184751153,
0.7187867165,
0.6341667771,
-1.0374355316,
0.6916328073,
0.1846781373,
0.1615003496,
0.3852741718,
0.9633573294,
-0.6173939705,
-0.0490558185,
-0.862392664,
-0.700230062,
0.8863605261,
0.3074699342,
0.2046971321,
0.0608794242,
0.3599755764,
0.0342941508,
0.3838063478,
-0.8110093474,
0.0001740419,
0.0503394008,
-0.226260826,
0.0237214696,
-0.118155688,
0.3043521643,
-0.1846390963,
0.6931206584,
0.0355151929,
0.1859777272,
0.0035231335,
-0.159711048,
-0.0462448299,
0.4579915404,
0.0243551061,
0.2730591893,
-0.3638480306,
-0.0907230079,
0.3563434184,
-0.1482436955,
-0.0609578043,
-0.0316954963,
-0.2049643695,
0.2675464451,
0.1438269168,
0.6250582337,
0.0883560553,
-0.3659470379,
0.7939618826,
-0.0553086661,
-0.2846690118,
-0.2857086658,
0.0796248838,
-0.3782051206,
0.4185244143,
0.4686895609,
0.2918402553,
0.3903343678,
-0.5517968535,
0.2119636685,
0.3445001841,
-0.6732925177,
-0.2269891351,
0.1813958138,
-0.0215399396,
-0.2760794163,
0.8566368818,
-0.4035747051,
-0.294873029,
0.4599768221,
0.5469779968,
1.5368028879,
-0.2809391618,
0.5913564563,
0.0449113734,
0.1034022048,
-0.1181636229,
-0.238405779,
-0.1905968487,
-0.7299380302,
-0.7627447844,
-0.9149548411,
-0.9299681187,
0.1809318364,
-0.657669127,
0.999248147,
-0.8947588205,
-0.1578126699,
0.3205929995,
0.0524057634,
-0.8621460199,
0.4621019065,
0.5493612289,
0.6339395642,
-0.8176717162,
0.8704115152,
0.3463589847,
-0.6364306211,
-0.219223693,
-0.0316221379,
-0.4442510605,
-0.3881961107,
0.7781261802,
0.7271963358,
-0.1430284381,
-0.1544594467,
-0.6490814686,
-0.4152455628,
0.9378101826,
0.1469225138,
-0.5050389767,
-0.0124634616,
0.2814183533,
0.7842451334,
-0.2935604751,
-0.0297065657,
0.274315089,
0.0309646185,
0.4170872569,
-0.7615433335,
-0.640991509,
0.0863045156,
0.0106225042,
0.0480401404,
-0.1884056032,
0.3377201855,
0.263712734,
-0.5475219488,
-0.6989874244,
0.6350440979,
-0.2826039195,
0.6371555328,
0.3352026641,
0.6955021024,
0.6608717442,
0.1055857614,
0.6834273934,
0.0048588924,
0.7769492269,
1.0071184635,
-0.6092697382,
1.3054683208,
0.0527642183,
-0.3873807192,
0.7293676138,
0.1837828606,
-0.6575549245,
0.5766544342,
0.1913256496,
-0.2834641337,
0.0734668747,
-0.1918954253,
0.0884299576,
0.7985617518,
0.0745991245,
-0.2158796489,
-0.5778745413,
-0.0387080573,
-0.1649378687,
-0.3206116855,
-0.3481444418,
1.0868558884,
-0.1113743111,
-0.1818007976,
0.1102477238,
0.3246635199,
0.9892662764,
-0.6207100749,
0.1379232705,
0.0369878262,
0.1205321476,
-0.2948011756,
-0.735172987,
0.9820223451,
0.4437717497,
-0.1589139253,
-0.6847383976,
0.7482406497,
-0.2897206843,
-0.5484753847,
0.2749653757,
0.0409137607,
0.1950007081,
-0.4987020493,
-0.4742510021,
-0.755125761,
-0.1370397657,
0.0717759579,
0.1610292345,
0.5208044052,
0.0845380723,
0.5101462603,
0.4430262744,
-0.1245218515,
0.0797307119,
-0.1181547716,
0.5154594183,
-1.1668556929,
-0.5727873445,
-0.7706571221,
0.4428892434,
-0.3003795445,
0.0054919082,
0.6606839895,
0.7643700242,
1.0058416128,
-0.3597453237,
0.6651360989,
0.1042611822,
0.6565799117,
-0.0702407733,
0.7249523401,
-0.0942567512,
0.0238136146,
0.0077305972,
-1.2622281313,
-0.9383872747,
0.5561560988,
-0.5846905708,
-0.1295721531,
0.5024623275,
0.2910358012,
-0.151523158,
0.1497523785,
0.5590792298,
-0.0094825048,
0.2955080569,
0.129874602,
0.5212097764,
-0.4829607308,
0.7231230736,
-0.5832630992,
-0.1752390563,
-0.296864301,
-1.1238667965,
-0.5445075035,
-0.07773716,
-0.8601589203,
0.0450773574,
-0.6449444294,
0.7592618465,
0.5476987362,
-1.0246357918,
-0.2032845467,
-0.0507877991,
-0.1714490652,
-0.1849883795,
-0.3052180707,
0.1452646255,
-0.7863329649,
-0.5904524326,
0.2191339284,
0.9601282477,
0.1050151512,
-0.1865375191,
0.2430198044,
-0.1993752271,
0.0547654554,
0.7966544032,
0.4194751084,
-0.1718838215,
-0.0818849429,
-0.0228053946,
0.2248881608,
0.0638992488,
0.5810193419,
-0.8918572068,
0.1865903735,
0.4421440959,
0.7680909038,
0.5772308111,
-0.0355385095,
0.1371433288,
-1.1379568577,
0.1573509425,
0.551549077,
-0.0038054143,
0.2450673282,
-0.3869629204,
0.2541131377,
0.1196625531,
-0.4900194108,
-0.2992084622,
-0.0801102296,
-1.1319086552,
-0.40053913,
0.6411256194,
0.0744402781,
-0.4285878539,
-0.3068240583,
0.0473868065,
0.4170784056,
-0.1006435975,
1.0079585314,
0.4822869003,
-0.2389806062,
-0.0188437924,
-0.4762436748,
0.2350238115,
-0.0675431788,
-0.8690433502,
-0.1894597411,
0.4052867889,
0.0579829104,
0.5535669327,
0.4094546735,
-0.0685438812,
-0.1967205703,
-0.3399079144,
0.4424870312,
0.3224744797,
-0.6408880949,
-0.7842159271,
0.5554413795,
-0.050145071,
-0.7424154282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01020v1 | Evaluating statistical language models as pragmatic reasoners | 2023-05-01T18:22:10 | 2023-05-01T18:22:10 | Benjamin Lipkin, Lionel Wong, Gabriel Grand, Joshua B Tenenbaum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The relationship between communicated language and intended meaning is often
probabilistic and sensitive to context. Numerous strategies attempt to estimate
such a mapping, often leveraging recursive Bayesian models of communication. In
parallel, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly applied to
semantic parsing applications, tasked with inferring logical representations
from natural language. While existing LLM explorations have been largely
restricted to literal language use, in this work, we evaluate the capacity of
LLMs to infer the meanings of pragmatic utterances. Specifically, we explore
the case of threshold estimation on the gradable adjective ``strong'',
contextually conditioned on a strength prior, then extended to composition with
qualification, negation, polarity inversion, and class comparison. We find that
LLMs can derive context-grounded, human-like distributions over the
interpretations of several complex pragmatic utterances, yet struggle composing
with negation. These results inform the inferential capacity of statistical
language models, and their use in pragmatic and semantic parsing applications.
All corresponding code is made publicly available
(https://github.com/benlipkin/probsem/tree/CogSci2023). | [
-0.2990379333,
-0.9778965116,
0.898784399,
0.4161920846,
-0.4126524627,
-0.401779443,
-0.6185215116,
-0.1331012547,
-0.1540158242,
0.5946851373,
-0.3448833823,
-0.5685757995,
-0.6683850288,
0.1722074598,
-0.346457243,
0.9284428954,
0.0564091355,
0.1961104572,
-0.369535625,
-0.000932516,
-0.5962413549,
-0.4930256903,
-0.2502408326,
-0.378859967,
0.432046473,
0.2085491866,
0.7616896033,
0.3176196218,
0.7141420841,
0.3391655385,
-0.0780908838,
-0.2226853967,
-0.43661654,
0.3589732349,
-0.5963985324,
-0.6139754653,
-0.2771631479,
0.0101383319,
0.8954800963,
1.0374977589,
-0.1101523489,
0.0415001921,
0.022070596,
0.2873684168,
-0.6621440649,
0.3903483152,
-0.9463621378,
-0.2087178081,
-0.0255781822,
-0.1264576018,
-0.6691016555,
-0.1750069559,
0.2962131202,
-0.3171456456,
0.1307289004,
-0.1811525822,
0.8986350298,
0.1246401444,
-0.5424395204,
-0.3194923699,
-0.5009624362,
1.2394630909,
-0.732896626,
0.5304166675,
0.5604221225,
0.3595116436,
-0.4489692748,
-0.6004453301,
-0.6067399383,
-0.5858073831,
-0.148740992,
-0.03892418,
-0.2458261102,
0.1800769418,
0.1105447337,
0.2423350066,
-0.5090894103,
0.0266390499,
-0.0149375731,
-0.2055954188,
0.5944207311,
0.2521004677,
0.2787304819,
-0.1139734909,
-0.2313350737,
0.0322635882,
-0.5446746349,
-0.2476739287,
0.1506301761,
0.3284289539,
-0.2160641551,
0.545571208,
-0.0756221116,
1.1113179922,
-0.230536893,
-0.335006237,
0.1378054619,
-0.3588418663,
-0.2699824274,
-0.2563251257,
0.6241963506,
0.2018884122,
0.5417333841,
-0.1967606395,
-0.0692887455,
0.3705650568,
0.0309999101,
-0.6658391953,
-0.2488122731,
-0.0389715768,
-0.1846760064,
0.0489994995,
0.0049368814,
-0.5747400522,
-0.4405341446,
-0.5737037659,
0.2296845913,
-0.4103854597,
-0.3426010311,
0.4094152749,
-0.2829867303,
0.3072267473,
0.2053247392,
-0.6340222359,
0.1615475118,
0.9847587943,
0.6859630346,
0.0352734998,
-0.2084799856,
-0.2536862195,
0.0430783778,
-0.4240584671,
0.6830490828,
-0.8356124163,
-0.1589236408,
-0.0765665621,
0.2769570947,
-0.2250379771,
-0.6228464246,
0.8653618693,
-0.4893289506,
-0.0694378614,
0.0194399785,
-0.7204592228,
-0.2548518479,
0.183335796,
-0.4418008327,
0.2550472617,
0.0059416075,
-0.5754173994,
0.6167849898,
0.0378170796,
-0.5741194487,
0.3301085234,
-0.3155497909,
-0.2738698423,
0.462544024,
-0.0934699774,
0.6329278946,
-0.5555003881,
0.8254779577,
-0.4905048609,
-0.0020339994,
0.5954248905,
-0.5649719834,
0.7295845747,
0.204253599,
-0.1037842333,
0.2298389971,
-0.8075609803,
-0.1034502536,
0.1404048502,
-0.2099355906,
-0.4903678894,
0.3010359704,
-0.3418147564,
0.0563517846,
0.2001345009,
-0.3492374122,
-0.3951453865,
-0.5383300781,
0.4733601213,
0.5866043568,
0.0389130116,
0.5113438964,
-0.0605545342,
0.5689552426,
-0.0602102131,
-0.2683073878,
-0.1187505871,
-0.4370141327,
-0.4199736118,
-0.691688478,
0.1719481051,
0.5596650839,
-0.3624558747,
0.6392570138,
-0.3163712323,
-0.4878709912,
-0.2543323338,
0.2536486983,
0.3126091957,
0.6047987342,
0.1164970025,
-0.2037012577,
-0.3343975544,
-0.9968495369,
-0.5153162479,
-0.2994644344,
-0.22989434,
0.2391774356,
0.4945401251,
-0.1480294764,
1.0280054808,
-0.3623737693,
0.0333289653,
-0.5361324549,
0.0566899069,
0.5392609835,
0.289968431,
0.3569325507,
-0.532626152,
-0.1801315248,
-0.09360715,
-0.7041062713,
-0.521740973,
-0.1539571136,
-0.1788976043,
-0.2264498174,
0.1242744401,
-0.6895037293,
0.2283628881,
0.6153979301,
-0.5669918656,
0.6407766342,
-0.1558363736,
-0.1868135035,
-0.5896276236,
-0.0325488448,
0.4359550178,
-0.2727770805,
-0.7311457992,
0.2242707014,
-0.0464772731,
-0.0229768511,
-0.34549734,
0.5654637814,
-0.4543176889,
-0.0005575586,
-0.2382199615,
0.2263507098,
0.023474196,
0.1549954563,
0.3268743157,
0.4320288599,
0.5973524451,
-0.6871074438,
0.2990164459,
-0.0467761159,
-0.6197091341,
0.6175103188,
-0.7148925662,
-0.2352522463,
-0.428388238,
0.3821212351,
-1.1480638981,
-0.4358409643,
0.2716888785,
-0.2472963035,
0.070788309,
-0.3445596993,
-0.3984431326,
-0.0984905511,
0.0707558617,
0.5367377996,
0.3533363938,
-0.2982933223,
0.3372796476,
0.7273961902,
-0.2209176719,
-0.1171642393,
-0.7745867372,
0.2828405499,
-0.4806352556,
-0.8348419666,
0.0887442231,
0.2583741546,
-0.8686230183,
-0.2787651122,
0.0729142502,
-0.0454407819,
0.3172883093,
0.266379267,
0.2884525359,
-0.1789913625,
0.3010773659,
-0.161305666,
-0.1999468207,
0.2911917865,
-0.109024629,
0.5868494511,
-0.2571500242,
-0.4095116854,
-0.3347805738,
0.1537065059,
0.2551284432,
-0.2086061686,
1.0230853558,
0.3241160214,
-0.2929261029,
-0.4240106344,
-0.4148376882,
-0.3642681539,
-0.3847045898,
0.4165371656,
-0.374617368,
-0.9099943042,
0.4904356897,
0.258023113,
-0.1843020171,
0.444365859,
0.7212292552,
0.2819467187,
1.1096557379,
0.1145847142,
0.1974689364,
0.3956071138,
0.1339160651,
0.4443565011,
-0.327736944,
0.0353622139,
-0.5748144388,
0.0478639305,
-0.6292393804,
-0.4896793962,
0.2689907849,
0.001091735,
-0.2436172068,
0.209458515,
-0.2715053856,
0.3077477515,
0.1900688559,
-0.0308941565,
0.0915088356,
0.0728880093,
0.3036805987,
-0.204966113,
-0.4730070233,
-0.7941066623,
0.6560291052,
0.6647316813,
0.9164263606,
0.0646376684,
0.3473505974,
-0.1071146205,
0.4535130858,
-0.9715222716,
0.9141216874,
-0.2367103696,
-0.652649641,
-0.149206996,
-0.7283262014,
-0.9598681927,
0.613799572,
0.0465400964,
-0.6503419876,
0.2378811687,
-0.0121764056,
0.1158242151,
-0.0869284868,
-0.8354395032,
1.1164689064,
-0.2416815907,
-0.4767302275,
-0.3988064229,
-0.4407326579,
0.4583972394,
-0.002170061,
0.2807182074,
-0.5108802319,
-0.1238093972,
0.7937124968,
-0.4731074274,
0.9732410312,
-0.219543457,
-0.3246994615,
0.5902462602,
0.1673861444,
0.4086928368,
0.0582426302,
-0.36014238,
0.3040294051,
0.0606024452,
-0.424720943,
-0.4111886322,
0.5756528974,
-0.3405332565,
-0.7486769557,
-0.4092932045,
-0.499391377,
-0.2572981119,
0.131468758,
-0.1129210889,
0.3966733813,
-0.0853593424,
0.3924388885,
0.3351941705,
-0.1900318861,
0.1311113834,
0.5321531296,
0.046309676,
-0.1529757977,
0.9465577006,
0.0731881931,
0.3616804481,
0.3742412627,
0.5396418571,
-0.3650660515,
-0.62114048,
-0.2055364102,
0.4699828923,
-0.7870061994,
0.0214385521,
-0.41826424,
0.1204925105,
-0.3711332381,
-0.0841121078,
0.2296899706,
-0.1752185076,
-0.2535994053,
-0.1666692346,
0.1880776882,
0.360760361,
0.2531502843,
0.4739168882,
-0.5144668221,
0.1955734938,
0.1446575373,
0.1268213242,
-0.1999476254,
-0.767781496,
-0.036318779,
0.0705664828,
-0.029913174,
-1.2296909094,
0.6663429737,
0.2074446827,
0.6960380673,
0.3832601905,
-0.1219259575,
0.6226857305,
-0.1997126788,
0.7030736804,
0.2373299301,
-0.817135334,
0.348311156,
-0.4988948405,
0.2409429848,
0.6051966548,
0.2709738016,
-0.2157120407,
-0.6222449541,
-0.3321493566,
-0.8198608756,
0.3327362239,
-0.0922808945,
0.235801816,
-0.4901390672,
0.1636715531,
0.0204574186,
0.2842304409,
-0.7391864657,
0.2993139327,
0.0833810568,
-0.4040858448,
-0.3658356667,
-0.4520362318,
-0.0403489731,
-0.2139323801,
0.4390714169,
-0.0863130167,
0.0473774038,
-0.0911821127,
-0.4400258362,
0.080232285,
0.616304338,
0.3891083896,
1.0913165808,
-0.0520144142,
0.6143312454,
0.1716365218,
-0.1784541011,
0.0090126162,
0.0258685686,
-0.0151914284,
0.0115863085,
0.7096322179,
0.8818984032,
0.31987378,
-1.0352340937,
0.5829753876,
0.1479123235,
-0.0143447509,
-0.2151885629,
-0.0598132387,
0.0628728271,
-0.1116535962,
0.0315620936,
-0.4025825262,
0.0383708589,
-0.7964280844,
0.2025374323,
0.7359591126,
-0.280453831,
-0.4134675264,
0.2936488688,
-0.0811863765,
-0.116801478,
0.3713522851,
-0.3056759238,
-0.4987865686,
0.5437802672,
0.8177347183,
0.8552635908,
-0.1167061701,
0.2109265178,
0.2385927588,
0.0860896111,
-0.124585472,
0.1785228252,
-0.0430462286,
-0.9169149995,
-0.6986083388,
-0.9192505479,
-0.233847335,
-0.1147948802,
-0.3328383267,
0.3126523495,
-0.3333470523,
-0.3499549627,
0.024135232,
-0.2814159691,
-0.6406424642,
0.2475933284,
0.0222826898,
0.5936644077,
-1.0648436546,
0.5274424553,
0.7314780354,
-0.2580510974,
-0.7131339312,
-0.1151308939,
-0.2584103346,
-0.8137784004,
0.7253113389,
0.0801455602,
-0.0828309357,
-0.2514853179,
-0.4612603486,
-0.4240550697,
0.4777027965,
0.5430399776,
-0.7069162726,
0.2548446357,
0.1817937493,
0.7497729063,
-0.3524927497,
0.3059004247,
0.8103577495,
0.6054811478,
0.0873406604,
-0.657436192,
0.1648978591,
0.1115091518,
-0.23621279,
0.3112002313,
-0.0847586542,
0.7736355662,
0.0562595949,
-0.3325606287,
-0.1107235551,
0.5953220129,
0.4362557232,
0.3915635347,
0.5909278393,
0.5583121777,
0.5574621558,
0.0573667847,
0.9927948713,
-0.3613800108,
0.1277749091,
0.9860826135,
-0.2838617861,
0.7695772648,
0.4997442961,
-0.2965815663,
0.5667281747,
0.3825927973,
0.208124727,
0.2712167799,
0.5123420954,
-0.5492224693,
-0.4792886376,
-0.2554215789,
-0.0265833139,
0.3644420505,
0.6171313524,
-0.5745626688,
-0.3125497997,
-0.2749665082,
0.0446890518,
0.2911480963,
-0.265427649,
0.7578573227,
0.3698168099,
-0.9319680333,
0.5685385466,
0.170290947,
0.3384933472,
-0.5885836482,
0.0390680842,
0.1539842784,
0.3963287175,
-0.197267741,
-1.0202476978,
0.3474246562,
0.1071932092,
0.1852914691,
-0.1324615031,
0.9989147782,
-0.418908447,
-0.6209698319,
0.2607553005,
0.3795872629,
0.3073029518,
-0.0258524343,
-0.4833226502,
0.0395442843,
-0.1852451414,
-0.1427868009,
0.2845353484,
0.4248267114,
-0.218648389,
0.5889390111,
0.4400155246,
0.4065638185,
0.1215068623,
0.4198240936,
0.4552197456,
-0.6661750078,
-0.6400013566,
-1.2082465887,
0.3746798635,
0.186028555,
-0.1405319721,
0.9829567671,
0.196511969,
0.6225252748,
-0.0279954206,
0.652374506,
0.0184498355,
0.2216854393,
-0.343893975,
0.2639169693,
-0.2886083722,
0.2051435262,
-0.2579409182,
-0.849489212,
-0.5670385957,
0.9314787984,
-1.0923513174,
-0.0789648145,
0.2682817578,
0.9323723912,
0.0047039734,
0.0633007661,
0.3555698097,
0.142678678,
0.3257786036,
0.5334407091,
1.0727677345,
0.2550510168,
0.1493577659,
0.0667748004,
-0.5024079084,
-0.1791716516,
-0.9450714588,
-0.9019004107,
-0.4307584465,
-0.1863675714,
-0.3878166974,
-0.0606833957,
0.709884882,
0.4878705442,
-0.7293881774,
-0.4504420757,
-0.5056960583,
0.283098489,
-0.0616142154,
-0.2465714812,
-0.0293729864,
-0.4895204604,
-0.4128418863,
0.4646811485,
0.0658117756,
-0.2575022876,
-0.3755078614,
-0.1390783489,
-0.0066250791,
0.3004125059,
0.6699483395,
0.0496345013,
-0.6508151293,
-0.3174499869,
-0.4143586159,
-0.0574604161,
-0.1571560353,
0.7729665637,
-0.6152617931,
0.3357890248,
1.0453958511,
0.615305841,
0.0866887793,
0.1802393347,
0.6863020658,
-0.4176270366,
0.2459769696,
0.3485194743,
0.555683732,
0.377925396,
0.1597007215,
0.2992506921,
0.3826259673,
-0.5541138649,
-1.040284276,
0.4585693181,
-0.8535042405,
-0.3296070993,
1.4427074194,
-0.1558776647,
-0.4261912405,
-0.0717096776,
-0.0617620647,
0.073725,
-0.206024453,
0.2842988074,
0.7711113691,
0.1086090133,
-0.0794587135,
-0.5667393804,
0.164997682,
0.6797378063,
-0.4949551821,
0.1673376113,
0.7615591288,
0.3007448614,
-0.0129188644,
0.3771546185,
-0.037605755,
0.0356133133,
-0.1071403995,
-0.3096954525,
0.4442899823,
-0.3126489222,
-0.5774002075,
0.3756475151,
0.2746828198,
0.0304209143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01011v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01011v1 | Deception Detection with Feature-Augmentation by soft Domain Transfer | 2023-05-01T18:00:54 | 2023-05-01T18:00:54 | Sadat Shahriar, Arjun Mukherjee, Omprakash Gnawali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this era of information explosion, deceivers use different domains or
mediums of information to exploit the users, such as News, Emails, and Tweets.
Although numerous research has been done to detect deception in all these
domains, information shortage in a new event necessitates these domains to
associate with each other to battle deception. To form this association, we
propose a feature augmentation method by harnessing the intermediate layer
representation of neural models. Our approaches provide an improvement over the
self-domain baseline models by up to 6.60%. We find Tweets to be the most
helpful information provider for Fake News and Phishing Email detection,
whereas News helps most in Tweet Rumor detection. Our analysis provides a
useful insight for domain knowledge transfer which can help build a stronger
deception detection system than the existing literature. | [
-0.4387468696,
-0.740845561,
0.4071483612,
0.0043260884,
-0.0546099916,
0.1980124563,
0.0261006225,
-0.738597095,
0.2380990088,
0.6405094266,
-0.7395358086,
-0.2069542259,
-0.7411463261,
-0.2757309079,
-0.4900353551,
0.931251049,
0.2036958337,
-0.1810620576,
-0.0209617931,
-0.0718469322,
-0.1265225857,
-0.5158305764,
-0.5554033518,
-0.4295351505,
0.3133347631,
0.217426762,
0.6587556601,
0.1022027507,
0.5703699589,
0.3305108547,
0.3432589471,
0.4187366962,
-0.3141346276,
-0.0282949209,
-0.2877597809,
-0.4482709169,
-0.392006129,
0.1752738804,
0.2315523922,
0.4198425114,
0.2591637671,
0.1015436947,
-0.1037455872,
0.5049034953,
-0.5621469617,
-0.0421373211,
-0.6180427074,
-0.128412351,
-0.1860835999,
-0.5509001017,
-0.3781303465,
-0.4971821904,
0.3563912511,
-0.5691227913,
0.3808581233,
0.0999581069,
0.8394685984,
-0.0030133128,
-0.5059067011,
-0.1231768653,
-0.7653976679,
0.4311248958,
-0.4249811471,
0.2498575747,
0.2153795063,
0.4630557895,
-0.0028084621,
-0.8511674404,
-0.6888097525,
-0.3606739044,
-0.1602921188,
-0.2838170528,
-0.3035017848,
-0.0732955933,
0.1937750131,
0.1840549111,
-0.3545491695,
-0.117780976,
-0.2389143705,
-0.5319976807,
0.5929131508,
-0.0962364674,
0.6079258323,
0.0817529559,
-0.6130564213,
-0.1928759068,
-0.5645632744,
-0.1169347316,
0.3897880018,
-0.0000391577,
0.055298131,
0.3231629729,
-0.0858655944,
0.4961422086,
0.3558966517,
-0.2691037059,
0.3789773881,
-0.2199922204,
-0.1847543865,
0.0054444186,
0.4132018983,
0.2386450917,
0.1767848432,
-0.1468459815,
-0.3870999217,
0.3109711707,
0.3255879283,
-0.8976444006,
-0.2295359373,
0.0073626717,
-0.6962452531,
-0.4744451046,
0.1459407955,
-0.4181144834,
-0.7255160213,
-0.307923317,
0.6852529645,
-0.6944417953,
-0.7206425071,
0.1653124094,
-0.4142820239,
0.1916470975,
0.5400208831,
-0.5445969701,
0.4023824632,
0.7190554142,
0.5666505694,
-0.1917365789,
-0.2579828799,
-0.2439088374,
0.1595925242,
-0.2771755755,
0.8970350027,
-0.4880593717,
0.234801203,
0.1177767068,
-0.1416246146,
0.0828285664,
-0.4684770703,
0.6004562974,
-0.7649064064,
0.2835686803,
-0.1035299897,
-0.6748071313,
-0.4010668993,
0.4212986529,
-0.7779451609,
0.7364125252,
0.4329917729,
-0.5283046365,
0.1299950331,
-0.6671757102,
-0.5572734475,
0.2091060281,
0.2048573494,
-0.4193592966,
0.2213867009,
0.3299273551,
0.5097923279,
-0.0201253127,
-0.0615769662,
-0.4343999922,
-0.3222358823,
0.7850712538,
-0.6040929556,
0.8237540126,
0.072495006,
-0.3905123472,
-0.3253858984,
-0.442999661,
-0.0817077011,
0.1071456,
-0.0301245656,
-0.5356590152,
-0.501239717,
-0.0976452902,
0.0675760955,
0.2630446553,
-0.4163689315,
0.2961270809,
-0.1304958016,
0.1336146593,
0.5034353137,
0.3134503663,
0.6883698106,
-0.4161705673,
0.2244849205,
0.6176847219,
0.4639875293,
-0.2122588605,
-0.4996909201,
-0.8394597769,
0.0999706611,
0.5702137351,
0.39002195,
-1.262624979,
0.4395177364,
-0.3512510955,
-0.1055405214,
-0.739962399,
-0.0762505755,
0.1770675033,
0.5102380514,
0.4496911466,
0.00289085,
-0.2781609595,
-0.997117579,
-0.5451267362,
-0.0593130477,
-0.1129926592,
-0.0624504387,
0.3132262826,
0.1252742261,
0.5136271119,
-0.1983128786,
-0.5807942748,
-0.0514427423,
0.3487826288,
0.0004242736,
0.4813160598,
0.7443513274,
-1.332049489,
-0.4546053112,
-0.155492872,
-0.5870495439,
-0.0267707426,
-0.2680098414,
0.0756969899,
0.2210262269,
0.1711140722,
-0.5849377513,
0.5783267617,
0.3164252341,
-0.5350474715,
0.3879432678,
0.2520316243,
0.6348993182,
-0.8203322291,
-0.2710838318,
0.1655506492,
-0.5295640826,
-1.1180099249,
-0.0361983813,
0.28569749,
0.2027309835,
-0.4223923087,
0.3903628588,
-0.7317137718,
0.0307599511,
-0.5787332058,
0.0363903344,
0.1454967409,
0.414906472,
-0.1002816111,
0.7233905196,
0.5805419683,
-0.3988672197,
0.4138070047,
0.0310987774,
-0.4205866158,
0.7445642352,
-0.1344052255,
0.2081910372,
0.031631127,
0.3172103763,
-0.8776707649,
-0.2330600917,
0.5179446936,
-1.0058717728,
0.3960329592,
-0.3035682738,
-0.4750137627,
-0.3067847192,
-0.3600242436,
0.1959446669,
0.7612071037,
-0.6851289868,
0.8772400618,
0.2007343322,
0.2148245871,
-0.646124661,
-0.8500087857,
0.4175255001,
-0.1952488869,
-1.0500272512,
0.8079435825,
0.0340783224,
0.0243109316,
0.4004928768,
-0.0250262171,
-0.0744867772,
-0.057718277,
0.0333882459,
0.2400009185,
-0.3640546501,
0.0037464979,
-0.0935828611,
0.0097693782,
0.077313073,
-0.3976714909,
0.3746278286,
-0.0385185368,
-0.4131843746,
-0.7266557217,
0.414434433,
0.4918863773,
0.020099055,
0.9238647819,
0.8999900222,
-0.6650590301,
-0.6426262259,
-1.0601108074,
-0.6455238461,
-0.5287534595,
-0.022548737,
-0.4187068939,
-0.7068258524,
0.610652864,
-0.4292862415,
-0.5186935663,
0.4399055541,
0.1607554406,
0.1041097343,
1.0064570904,
0.8487529159,
-0.0811546445,
0.5353606939,
-0.4062342048,
0.3399323523,
-0.7180753946,
-0.4549694955,
-0.1323378831,
-0.4713020325,
-0.2801468074,
-0.302354455,
0.2428134382,
0.0537023135,
0.1848845929,
0.4271805882,
-0.4827319384,
0.4275243282,
0.5181753635,
0.6283347011,
0.2329051942,
0.3138943017,
0.3616179526,
-0.0550504811,
-0.4173727334,
-0.1548058242,
0.9480267167,
0.439173907,
0.6872673035,
0.2278348505,
0.3842157423,
0.8266489506,
0.4717422426,
-0.5382825732,
0.5385717154,
-0.1379995197,
-0.4167885184,
-0.0312456768,
-0.2694471776,
-0.4074659646,
-0.0490788594,
-0.282033205,
-0.5157445073,
0.4993813932,
-0.320846647,
-0.2781857252,
0.3849059045,
-0.7035346627,
0.3173651397,
-0.0550127029,
-0.3211400211,
-0.1459010988,
-0.3732747734,
0.410341084,
-0.0587043352,
-0.1786574721,
-0.0981223658,
-0.3438504338,
0.6463840604,
-0.3121766746,
0.9457384944,
-0.3512207568,
0.1343674809,
0.3328303993,
0.2612811029,
0.5193225145,
-0.1150634587,
0.0295221917,
0.1232071519,
-0.6307390332,
-0.3147052824,
-0.9934183955,
0.6942259669,
-0.5853928328,
-0.7337346077,
-0.3345234096,
-0.3901714981,
-0.288482368,
0.0043764822,
0.1588606685,
0.2150028199,
0.0390111953,
0.1819746792,
0.9184907675,
0.3271436989,
0.4576397836,
0.691296339,
0.1017043665,
-0.2126453668,
0.8861860037,
0.0279567912,
0.1148879826,
0.0868456438,
0.0927245915,
-0.4041069746,
-0.9144519567,
-0.2730214596,
0.0843179971,
-0.6928511858,
-0.6883887649,
-0.5867533088,
-0.7864670157,
-0.6123213768,
-0.0460888408,
-0.1230791956,
-0.6002782583,
-0.3408088684,
0.0030931344,
0.4238994122,
0.5057502389,
-0.1632316411,
0.6215628982,
-0.8068339229,
0.6214184761,
0.293641001,
0.0250446554,
-0.1828344613,
-0.8963377476,
-0.0925107747,
0.2006295621,
-0.3738241494,
-1.02949512,
0.3987147212,
0.2097209841,
0.5733585954,
0.6069589853,
0.0763177127,
0.4789031446,
-0.0736268312,
0.7963495851,
0.3570635915,
-0.9723068476,
0.5179011822,
-0.1372154951,
-0.267483443,
0.2812766731,
0.5961042643,
-0.2423222214,
-0.1645371765,
-1.0476722717,
-0.1712793857,
0.6850425601,
0.440721333,
0.3244095743,
0.5310233831,
0.4615999162,
0.1239834875,
0.304015398,
-0.774210155,
-0.332934767,
0.0087677268,
-0.0550894439,
0.4477450848,
-0.2282023877,
-0.1869421452,
-0.1622780263,
0.5534183383,
-0.1522548646,
0.4557439089,
0.1798308343,
-0.1550578028,
-0.23209171,
-0.2076085061,
0.3555763066,
0.6394436955,
0.0378554761,
0.3067828715,
-0.1088903397,
-0.4538536072,
0.2232979536,
0.2108115703,
-0.150768593,
0.036764089,
0.5767295957,
0.7606444955,
-0.2185663581,
0.0108491639,
1.11375916,
0.1559555829,
-0.455090642,
-0.2877887785,
0.3757322431,
-0.0959696323,
0.5304158926,
0.8366133571,
0.6670288444,
0.5074267983,
-0.6654376984,
0.5286331177,
0.3161586225,
-0.3405635655,
-0.4391758144,
0.3080812097,
0.2502424121,
-0.429864347,
0.5647341013,
-0.089548938,
-1.0236430168,
0.6986208558,
0.6851271987,
0.8826984167,
-0.8192939162,
0.3891760409,
-0.0773492604,
0.4714973569,
-0.2851091921,
0.2485791892,
0.1523947716,
-1.0139473677,
-0.3482033312,
-0.2495529801,
-0.1367363483,
0.6184973717,
-0.2684045434,
0.3017996848,
-0.2377895266,
-0.1492261738,
0.3980358839,
0.0771068782,
-0.6957384348,
0.1437170655,
0.4567438066,
0.9615383744,
-0.930896163,
1.0118653774,
0.293461293,
-0.3628714085,
-0.3767778277,
0.331153512,
-0.0285368972,
-0.9484171867,
0.6634159088,
0.3057360947,
-0.0948871225,
-0.0894810334,
-0.7601777911,
-0.5009564757,
0.8841953874,
0.4356591702,
-0.270702064,
0.0146477949,
0.4073900282,
0.555990994,
-0.9090265036,
0.2722403705,
0.5247955918,
0.6335514784,
0.3064192533,
-0.4428325593,
0.3786500096,
-0.2115220129,
-0.0840012804,
0.0495179109,
-0.5243040323,
0.9160877466,
-0.0635888875,
-0.2336773872,
-0.2336969376,
0.897344172,
-0.1318423301,
0.5196319222,
0.6380892396,
0.4330040514,
0.5554285645,
-0.1340998262,
0.7615169287,
-0.2108766735,
0.1686513573,
0.6914266944,
-0.0851453319,
0.5042157173,
0.2023972273,
-0.0402706861,
0.7938668728,
0.6836878061,
-0.2038432211,
0.6870318651,
0.079358913,
-0.5152601004,
-0.3478968143,
-0.2890271246,
-0.3591707349,
0.2484131455,
0.8222793937,
-0.3912543952,
-0.1221547723,
0.4178584218,
-0.07766743,
-0.1376875341,
-0.3502939343,
0.7891345024,
0.0100376811,
-0.5932969451,
0.6022015214,
-0.0545504875,
0.7436017394,
-0.5246943831,
-0.3076823652,
-0.2229588777,
0.2491464466,
-0.2838720381,
-0.9407481551,
0.1125779599,
-0.4990924299,
0.1488215029,
-0.1925100684,
1.6339204311,
-0.544403553,
-0.2697338164,
0.4512213767,
0.5800902247,
-0.141631186,
-0.6218966246,
-1.0735943317,
-0.062352594,
0.004769057,
-0.4488962889,
0.2450387776,
0.6544857621,
0.1112092659,
0.7513150573,
0.8466058969,
0.0720582977,
0.0664112344,
0.2363122702,
1.2071896791,
-0.4860958457,
-0.4870382249,
-0.731076777,
0.4023833573,
-0.7439833879,
0.0976037979,
0.796605289,
0.3016554117,
0.6110093594,
-0.0586617626,
0.9464815259,
0.0102308486,
0.5744644403,
-0.3742242455,
0.5637595654,
-0.3715253174,
0.3666902483,
0.1966508329,
-0.9828273654,
-0.1512341052,
0.096816957,
-0.0598543398,
0.2898918986,
0.7544312477,
0.7228809595,
-0.6643768549,
0.2782086134,
0.4307681322,
0.2166681141,
0.082973741,
0.5299772024,
1.0317307711,
-0.8825545311,
0.4345580935,
-0.4615852535,
-0.396228224,
-0.6495299935,
-0.7110123038,
-1.2478017807,
-0.6417806745,
-0.4987094402,
-0.8003963232,
0.0864611343,
0.353398025,
0.9405270219,
-0.6882066131,
0.2916536331,
0.2622371316,
0.1474409997,
-0.1940061301,
-0.3117931485,
0.4167095721,
-0.2792625725,
-0.5097186565,
0.3364564478,
0.1132092923,
0.29589957,
-0.642994523,
0.1672404259,
-0.098781459,
0.4539008737,
0.4960003793,
-0.0412517525,
-0.5119062662,
-0.4416440129,
0.0259715784,
-0.1661881506,
0.0882403255,
1.1285651922,
-0.9177672267,
-0.1127928272,
0.5894370675,
0.6490875483,
0.5055027604,
0.1620935202,
0.2438286841,
-0.7635163069,
0.0249760989,
0.3110863864,
0.0461413823,
0.5179307461,
-0.9410703182,
0.4527219832,
0.4815569222,
-0.3341557682,
-0.5843910575,
-0.0297091361,
-0.9821825624,
-0.5307106972,
0.9718475342,
-0.105085291,
-0.5814352036,
-0.3838765025,
0.1089901626,
-0.0991523713,
-0.5083631277,
0.8576722145,
0.5312444568,
-0.1296364814,
-0.2636951804,
-0.2871265113,
0.9579827785,
-0.0128118694,
-0.8710682988,
-0.2488286793,
0.1507244557,
0.4082975686,
0.4616860449,
0.6691522002,
0.006718351,
0.3400990367,
0.1007350087,
-0.2588253319,
-0.291375339,
-0.646461308,
-0.1399255246,
0.3935687542,
-0.5659811497,
-0.260058254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00969v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00969v7 | CryCeleb: A Speaker Verification Dataset Based on Infant Cry Sounds | 2023-05-01T17:56:32 | 2024-03-21T17:52:22 | David Budaghyan, Charles C. Onu, Arsenii Gorin, Cem Subakan, Doina Precup | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper describes the Ubenwa CryCeleb dataset - a labeled collection of
infant cries - and the accompanying CryCeleb 2023 task, which is a public
speaker verification challenge based on cry sounds. We released more than 6
hours of manually segmented cry sounds from 786 newborns for academic use,
aiming to encourage research in infant cry analysis. The inaugural public
competition attracted 59 participants, 11 of whom improved the baseline
performance. The top-performing system achieved a significant improvement
scoring 25.8% equal error rate, which is still far from the performance of
state-of-the-art adult speaker verification systems. Therefore, we believe
there is room for further research on this dataset, potentially extending
beyond the verification task. | [
-0.54692173,
-0.1333478093,
0.1138661727,
0.4188720584,
-0.2181708366,
0.0411991477,
-0.2471050322,
-0.5983692408,
-0.1156436801,
0.4995395541,
-0.8262730241,
-0.7568218112,
-0.3364364207,
0.1088730097,
-0.7072870135,
0.7987629175,
0.5848700404,
-0.0909305811,
0.0204818696,
0.0811060369,
-0.6081859469,
-0.1360299587,
-0.4486888647,
-0.1893140972,
0.3519566953,
0.934216857,
0.2370738238,
0.5036188364,
0.1589819491,
0.3849461973,
-0.380777359,
0.1737035811,
-0.3122493029,
-0.1249594018,
0.1378756911,
-0.4608435333,
-0.512199223,
0.0533840805,
0.2734023035,
0.4085673094,
-0.6185652018,
0.3009549677,
-0.3201656342,
0.7423703074,
-0.4039716423,
0.3122619689,
-0.7985271811,
0.2826571465,
-0.5019108057,
0.2316515893,
-1.0373761654,
-0.5524989963,
0.1534049511,
-0.0447178483,
0.5452338457,
-0.0237673782,
0.8786190152,
0.1062132195,
-0.3888115585,
-0.3024961948,
-0.6049830317,
0.8798098564,
-0.6909242868,
0.3185206652,
0.3796233535,
0.2130594403,
-0.1993604451,
-0.6829506159,
-0.3585820198,
-0.159092322,
-0.2372530401,
0.0717752203,
-0.2584578991,
-0.0296907779,
0.1325841546,
0.2142701149,
-0.7412131429,
0.0738938972,
-0.6617413163,
-0.4834142625,
0.958745122,
0.1461887211,
0.5003598928,
-0.3195627928,
-0.5275890231,
-0.0577208772,
-0.1830465198,
-0.0685161352,
0.3701291978,
0.5513244271,
-0.3579306901,
0.1223224998,
-0.294765532,
0.7284093499,
-0.0956129432,
-0.1050542668,
0.5146198273,
0.1645165682,
0.1160630658,
0.8249391317,
0.6504079103,
0.1903848201,
0.2812924087,
0.0394558534,
-0.0982026532,
0.1434099823,
0.2043003589,
-0.7457441688,
-0.3745247722,
0.3430518508,
-0.7331554294,
-0.3408408463,
0.0241880212,
-1.3163709641,
-0.5685284138,
-0.3462229967,
0.0953061804,
-0.4458815157,
-0.4509652257,
-0.0509643666,
0.2315995395,
-0.0167277511,
0.3009783626,
-0.783379674,
0.4589532912,
0.5434841514,
0.6114088297,
-0.2105386853,
-0.2641829848,
-0.2569968104,
-0.1096613556,
-0.4758309126,
1.2774333954,
-0.3263224661,
-0.542734623,
-0.0441046841,
-0.1045576185,
-0.2049308121,
-0.9514274001,
0.8420582414,
-0.2909100056,
-0.0871455669,
-0.2932498753,
-0.5696688294,
-0.1181787178,
-0.2282521129,
-0.5846045017,
0.8232033253,
0.1798488796,
-0.5203005672,
0.485342592,
-0.9346346855,
-0.4555054605,
0.1306592375,
-0.0675600097,
-0.3658214808,
0.0497557372,
0.1395139694,
0.3118539453,
-0.3613924384,
0.0998947471,
0.1029246822,
-0.5175145268,
0.2834037542,
-0.3393784463,
0.8603760004,
0.394238919,
-0.6625723243,
-0.2027737051,
-1.1953692436,
0.2534076571,
0.222070545,
-0.3374578357,
0.2066964805,
0.2988906503,
-0.1080732644,
-0.1416905671,
-0.1511130333,
-0.8434559107,
0.0201042425,
-0.2261704654,
0.4268017411,
0.6681408286,
-0.0592285283,
-0.3323558569,
-0.1210170388,
0.1522091329,
0.4206005633,
0.2560174465,
-0.1747647971,
-0.6390396357,
-0.6697193384,
-0.4236678481,
0.5628395081,
0.5394072533,
0.1282491088,
0.3770401478,
0.2494685799,
-0.7134406567,
-0.7608118057,
-0.0364720076,
0.2725876868,
0.6557455063,
0.5552951694,
-0.0294461939,
-0.8138104081,
-1.2677965164,
0.3346754014,
-0.5466633439,
-0.0417289324,
0.4898221195,
0.264503926,
-0.1396719515,
0.9606083632,
-0.6283062696,
-0.6292872429,
-0.2126062363,
0.6332122684,
0.4313130677,
0.5292752385,
0.4263197482,
-0.9613085389,
-0.3831223547,
-0.1300287694,
-0.4313483834,
-0.4400759637,
0.2453085631,
0.1405071318,
0.3496033251,
0.4217438996,
-0.5173092484,
0.6553551555,
0.746743679,
-0.3689262569,
0.738694787,
0.177859664,
0.467518121,
-0.7812870741,
-0.1110285297,
-0.4109928012,
0.2404740304,
-0.6547054648,
-0.7977666855,
-0.0275325775,
-0.1920496672,
-0.7942525148,
0.130508557,
-0.4531110227,
-0.2107459754,
-0.2886494398,
0.4154139161,
-0.3328247964,
0.3318598568,
-0.098753117,
0.7493059635,
0.6100454926,
-0.5576620102,
0.7625395656,
0.5770494938,
-0.7290474772,
0.8352121115,
-0.5279251337,
0.4929260314,
-0.047384128,
0.5318633914,
-1.0465241671,
-0.3789046705,
-0.0226859823,
-0.5223785639,
0.1778334826,
-0.0222803541,
-0.2106195092,
-0.7546583414,
0.3302244842,
0.3369507194,
0.4567058086,
-0.8399508595,
0.5323114395,
0.398293823,
-0.2403557003,
-0.4491602182,
-0.481245786,
0.0959631056,
-0.1065667123,
-0.6392534375,
0.3874034584,
-0.1541187018,
-0.3562815487,
0.1120240614,
-0.0111563541,
-0.3709456027,
-0.1717840731,
0.4133901298,
0.2402164787,
-0.417468816,
0.1385655701,
-0.2281317562,
-0.256703496,
-0.0309616495,
0.1294971406,
0.6495696306,
-0.3184821904,
-0.4226756096,
-0.8657014966,
0.420663923,
0.3699896932,
-0.0650670156,
0.4620558619,
0.8146175742,
-0.6544613838,
-0.4677150249,
-0.7445470095,
-0.0240084324,
-0.5399495363,
0.2466443628,
-0.1031684875,
-0.4143512249,
0.5988609791,
-0.0528506897,
-0.0561374947,
0.4073894024,
0.6318482161,
-0.207482934,
1.0746853352,
0.2362689376,
-0.2327992916,
-0.0438909978,
0.0069470513,
-0.0272053685,
-0.7543547153,
-0.8263750672,
-1.0732508898,
-0.5749506354,
-0.4526300728,
-0.2257565111,
-0.1172222123,
-0.4119062126,
0.0440269336,
0.4007075131,
-0.6980257034,
0.6185023189,
0.6196443439,
0.3135858774,
0.0283627454,
-0.4081965685,
0.0149644185,
-0.1055075526,
-0.3363905847,
-0.328442812,
0.5009679794,
0.018515002,
0.5481097102,
-0.0856295824,
0.7572841048,
0.6919949651,
0.5676422119,
-0.6522885561,
0.9653089046,
-0.1971521527,
-1.2208373547,
-0.4882361591,
-0.4166580737,
-1.0588915348,
0.0552696101,
0.1483885795,
-1.4535570145,
0.3174377978,
0.0271566994,
-0.285695523,
0.2959186435,
-0.6877528429,
0.6163817644,
-0.1697979718,
0.1929523647,
-0.214829132,
-0.6351574659,
0.3115163147,
-0.1884340346,
0.3898515105,
-0.6688715816,
0.3756069541,
1.0740909576,
-0.3503496945,
0.9167290926,
-0.4647219479,
-0.0496116988,
0.7704735994,
0.1188704744,
0.3857394457,
0.0432757661,
-0.2817104161,
0.1314236522,
-0.1809260249,
-0.5188515782,
-0.2036012411,
0.6863738298,
-0.8534242511,
-0.4188444316,
-0.1794375628,
-0.3930042684,
-0.6237570643,
0.066170834,
0.3766348958,
0.7978394628,
-0.3171585202,
0.6183322072,
0.6830682158,
-0.368828088,
0.6002779007,
0.6527100801,
0.0898778737,
-0.7371816635,
0.8427216411,
0.0104859052,
-0.153809309,
0.06086234,
0.2137548029,
-0.2939817905,
-0.6510483027,
-0.349519223,
0.1781329662,
-0.6203881502,
-0.3213644326,
-0.5343634486,
-0.1941844821,
-0.3839711845,
-0.0749383941,
-0.8184406757,
0.1565239578,
-0.3973255455,
-0.2448645681,
0.1776536852,
1.0653437376,
-0.4695115983,
0.2029026598,
-1.0323472023,
0.4928239286,
0.5327683091,
0.5206896067,
-0.1626578569,
-0.4584688246,
-0.1733943522,
-0.0151515696,
-0.1184892133,
-1.0792809725,
0.1498446614,
0.2496071309,
0.726198256,
0.5333063006,
0.3197927177,
0.8516541719,
-0.4694078863,
1.1124997139,
0.1700446308,
-1.2287038565,
0.8063446879,
-0.3764679432,
-0.0915115401,
0.6514148712,
0.110288702,
-0.3922483921,
-0.071242027,
-0.8648609519,
-0.8769406676,
1.32129848,
0.3248651326,
0.0335682631,
0.1528921872,
-0.0058305487,
0.0424586311,
0.085123837,
-0.0469956473,
-0.3890852928,
-0.0232032221,
-0.177173689,
-0.1022737697,
-0.6290191412,
-0.2246748507,
-0.2306492031,
0.7675809264,
0.0118348422,
0.4090861976,
0.1775626987,
0.0193244647,
-0.3587477207,
0.151023075,
0.8287658691,
0.2980276942,
-0.403976202,
-0.1392616034,
0.4293848276,
-0.5003380775,
0.4061564207,
-0.0261332951,
0.0528261587,
0.3352195024,
0.5261953473,
0.9173189998,
0.5469906926,
-0.6655485034,
0.4386393726,
-0.2091740966,
-0.5717377663,
-0.2404414266,
-0.0381103754,
0.205136314,
0.2934517264,
0.610599339,
-0.1568612009,
0.2056601793,
-0.3932336569,
0.6816209555,
-0.3213101327,
-0.7065771818,
-0.3464542627,
0.5941283703,
0.328147471,
-0.5962269902,
1.0862641335,
0.1828710437,
-0.5479047894,
0.9279754758,
0.5860050321,
0.9458127022,
-0.6116864085,
0.643578589,
0.2498443574,
0.2747555673,
0.0512552187,
0.1178312376,
-0.0134483529,
-0.6989426017,
-0.0505567491,
-0.6774644256,
-0.9051939249,
0.3566779494,
-1.1271020174,
0.3898022175,
0.1269803792,
-0.2588792443,
0.0753330514,
-0.047217235,
-0.432008028,
0.7554976344,
0.8557581902,
1.0444947481,
-0.8213112354,
0.3427962065,
0.4709963799,
0.1905501336,
-1.0310703516,
-0.0538603477,
0.301410377,
-0.5716039538,
0.6290313005,
0.3124025166,
0.0194921643,
-0.1163181439,
-0.6263270974,
-0.7978381515,
0.9227347374,
0.3437296748,
-0.5757712722,
0.3132328093,
0.2680901587,
0.4748561084,
-0.4820958078,
0.3190402389,
0.7751659751,
0.8851742148,
0.3437442183,
-0.7802047133,
-0.2881944478,
-0.1351320148,
-0.3090769053,
-0.0737812221,
-1.0732216835,
0.6813958287,
-0.5062180161,
-0.197412625,
-0.0690740198,
1.0961877108,
0.1560651958,
0.5723229647,
1.0104286671,
0.2547137737,
1.0539876223,
-0.4140564799,
0.3614532053,
-0.0968794003,
0.3025221229,
1.3298032284,
-0.5226232409,
0.6509668231,
-0.0502272062,
-0.4339936376,
0.6155914664,
0.7396326065,
-0.1504691541,
0.4317567647,
0.2992673218,
-0.2619443834,
-0.3743092418,
-0.4302925766,
-0.5335483551,
0.9038377404,
0.4041889906,
-0.0633950457,
-0.0892610252,
-0.0103761675,
0.0154864397,
-0.1898255497,
-0.1081392914,
0.9354888201,
-0.0434896946,
-0.5073619485,
0.4606026411,
-0.4700515866,
0.1906475574,
-0.4379050434,
0.0529553741,
-0.2224819064,
0.2193175405,
-0.3496681154,
-0.5187664628,
0.1165374741,
0.1202510372,
-0.0107500535,
0.1661234945,
0.6493028402,
-0.2194928974,
-0.2655183971,
0.4724364877,
0.2046860904,
0.3393217921,
0.1765654087,
-0.5709488392,
0.6456667185,
0.2736241221,
-0.6557818055,
0.0873642266,
0.4860465825,
0.4779016674,
0.681627512,
0.4526524544,
0.1500783116,
0.157753706,
0.4670801759,
0.6472072601,
-0.7407619357,
-0.1610569209,
-0.6223509908,
0.6842184663,
-0.1910087764,
-0.4737236202,
0.2936620712,
0.6867152452,
0.7079672217,
-0.1862079948,
0.7262287736,
-0.289792031,
0.8560262918,
-0.2176907808,
0.6519155502,
-0.3800510764,
-0.1979189813,
-0.4202067852,
-0.6917647123,
-0.1323755682,
0.3635416329,
0.1154476404,
-0.107791394,
0.6937124729,
0.9347294569,
0.3101748824,
0.6595028043,
0.6581929922,
0.4829591811,
0.1851809472,
0.3346860111,
1.0578622818,
-0.298265636,
0.8977899551,
-0.6570047736,
-0.1994856447,
-0.520788312,
-0.8694568872,
-0.768758893,
-0.5466294885,
-0.6363534927,
-0.2579929829,
0.0403806865,
0.966784656,
0.927657783,
-1.4345226288,
-0.34725371,
0.331564337,
-0.1413420737,
-0.3083529472,
-0.2121878117,
0.3361623287,
-0.1565102041,
-0.8440927267,
0.961430192,
0.0344365016,
-0.1269405037,
0.2032901943,
0.1205002517,
-0.0203613825,
0.5151144266,
0.4298068881,
0.2840581834,
-0.457799077,
-0.410323441,
-0.3140935302,
-0.1935366392,
0.3276681006,
0.7238047123,
-0.5405032039,
0.1939596236,
0.3920713961,
-0.0801485404,
0.510278523,
0.1658112109,
0.1123257726,
-0.4157657623,
0.3292096555,
0.3957515955,
0.4660199285,
0.2062681764,
-0.1447747201,
0.6154783964,
0.3598229587,
-0.7143031955,
-1.2948054075,
0.0503299646,
-1.1146159172,
0.0575632565,
1.0113813877,
-0.2129625231,
-0.2597236931,
-0.2508785427,
-0.6166912913,
0.3859661818,
-0.7155221701,
1.0228661299,
0.7193090916,
-0.2305648327,
0.0469134748,
-0.2996776104,
0.4158144891,
0.14992024,
-0.9730902314,
0.2741061151,
0.2943376601,
-0.0125840101,
0.3446850777,
0.4859915078,
-0.3067565262,
0.3336027563,
0.2689141035,
0.3687913418,
0.0661466047,
-0.6810358167,
0.1750454307,
0.5380650759,
-0.2863280773,
-0.2984691858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00955v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00955v2 | Bridging the Gap: A Survey on Integrating (Human) Feedback for Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-01T17:36:06 | 2023-06-01T01:24:53 | Patrick Fernandes, Aman Madaan, Emmy Liu, António Farinhas, Pedro Henrique Martins, Amanda Bertsch, José G. C. de Souza, Shuyan Zhou, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Many recent advances in natural language generation have been fueled by
training large language models on internet-scale data. However, this paradigm
can lead to models that generate toxic, inaccurate, and unhelpful content, and
automatic evaluation metrics often fail to identify these behaviors. As models
become more capable, human feedback is an invaluable signal for evaluating and
improving models. This survey aims to provide an overview of the recent
research that has leveraged human feedback to improve natural language
generation. First, we introduce an encompassing formalization of feedback, and
identify and organize existing research into a taxonomy following this
formalization. Next, we discuss how feedback can be described by its format and
objective, and cover the two approaches proposed to use feedback (either for
training or decoding): directly using the feedback or training feedback models.
We also discuss existing datasets for human-feedback data collection, and
concerns surrounding feedback collection. Finally, we provide an overview of
the nascent field of AI feedback, which exploits large language models to make
judgments based on a set of principles and minimize the need for human
intervention. | [
-0.5313558578,
-0.777613759,
0.3477346599,
0.263322413,
0.077955246,
0.3167919219,
-0.5087682009,
-0.8793437481,
-0.1889333874,
0.3917810619,
-0.5398379564,
-0.2696614265,
-0.3271926939,
0.3074275255,
-0.2624536157,
0.9829733372,
0.1811149567,
0.2708942294,
-0.4153879285,
0.2409419864,
-0.5828171372,
-0.7311444283,
-0.6764178872,
-0.4759387076,
0.6194048524,
0.459276855,
0.4109015465,
0.2353577167,
0.3307202756,
0.3579556048,
-0.0289297905,
0.2857655585,
-0.3379880786,
0.0033455091,
-0.1106728613,
-0.3389129639,
-0.3813795149,
0.198050946,
0.5667300224,
1.1247822046,
-0.1832887381,
0.2129399031,
0.3502160311,
0.7494590878,
-0.6367551684,
-0.0482428446,
-0.2248460203,
0.1403804868,
-0.3061948419,
-0.0798350945,
-0.4212777913,
-0.6594792008,
0.3646945059,
-0.3277769387,
0.5460458994,
-0.0009164604,
0.6522571445,
0.1675672382,
-0.2979315519,
-0.6529391408,
-1.136359334,
0.937531054,
-0.9878538251,
0.3359241486,
0.6149237752,
0.2016867399,
-0.0847890973,
-0.5091602802,
-0.4999833107,
-0.5811189413,
-0.0972036496,
0.0873135701,
-0.1923487782,
0.0407356732,
-0.0702704266,
0.4118002951,
-0.1392836124,
0.2012293935,
-0.4726702273,
-0.2522381246,
1.0087639093,
0.2413924634,
0.4518381357,
-0.2605980933,
0.0460947379,
-0.0166315697,
-0.6085978746,
0.1778741479,
0.7182610631,
0.4083999693,
-0.0088395486,
0.3270341456,
-0.3231116533,
0.8981289864,
-0.0050607515,
0.2442993671,
0.0124273458,
-0.6673558354,
0.0980730429,
-0.1291655898,
0.893332541,
0.6484156251,
0.0720204189,
-0.4975867569,
-0.3067326844,
0.2547113001,
0.4438816607,
-0.5922307968,
-0.2501061261,
-0.0664451644,
-0.3497121036,
-0.4344627857,
0.402538985,
-1.1022592783,
-0.4959509969,
-0.4194705784,
-0.122475192,
-0.1271052957,
-0.3572203219,
0.0476511866,
-0.2296974957,
0.143615067,
0.2756002843,
-1.2055153847,
0.5052008629,
0.5721104145,
0.5442312956,
0.1081134155,
-0.2135051191,
-0.5292574763,
-0.2023775727,
-0.1440740228,
0.9718973637,
-0.5057450533,
-0.435449183,
0.3448500633,
-0.2024490535,
0.2423717529,
-0.6880582571,
0.5003767014,
-0.2407286167,
0.819879353,
-0.2791096568,
-0.5007836819,
0.0449895449,
0.2568122447,
-0.5964131355,
1.0367976427,
0.1448049098,
-0.7547662854,
0.4867117405,
-0.8226111531,
-0.4439205825,
0.2526580393,
-0.0997221619,
-0.2744960785,
0.1350675076,
0.2753722966,
0.1557658911,
-0.6648436785,
0.2902347147,
-0.1573518962,
-0.0830721408,
0.4597271681,
-0.3360031545,
0.4544569552,
0.2688491344,
-0.5739347935,
0.0766980648,
-0.6690668464,
0.088869445,
-0.0401077494,
-0.6955650449,
-0.0618832074,
-0.1039741635,
0.2513973117,
-0.0329038389,
-0.1189161167,
-0.6875202656,
0.1102729887,
-0.5874381065,
0.5679423213,
0.5867484808,
0.2124762833,
0.6859768629,
-0.3863017261,
0.779850781,
-0.2950630486,
-0.1182022467,
0.0478925928,
-0.4442242384,
-0.6740896106,
0.4832926989,
0.6086668372,
0.1536694765,
-0.4796803296,
0.6667781472,
-0.0517034009,
-0.4071695507,
-0.8700880408,
0.5249516964,
0.417302072,
0.4376579225,
0.2078388035,
-0.6906586289,
-0.7623416781,
-0.6563145518,
-0.3084988594,
-0.3729102314,
-0.3428703547,
0.0866637975,
0.0762470365,
-0.3897322416,
1.2315467596,
-0.2503180802,
-0.0091833575,
-0.4947218001,
0.5860987902,
-0.2834128439,
0.306303978,
0.2492893189,
-0.2293254733,
-0.2141656429,
-0.1941378564,
-0.4858855903,
-0.3201667368,
-0.0829815045,
-0.0543524027,
-0.0863740742,
0.3320038915,
-0.446203351,
0.2128123194,
0.4971935749,
-0.2713488042,
0.4194785058,
-0.0481923409,
0.0618055128,
-0.8462361097,
0.2402270585,
0.0986797214,
-0.0444063097,
-0.7044402361,
-0.158081159,
-0.3018592894,
0.0111934608,
-0.1313586086,
0.5216484666,
-0.65049541,
0.2391057312,
-0.2994392812,
0.2584187686,
-0.0259101056,
0.2655252218,
-0.1822842509,
0.4737973809,
0.142565161,
-0.6568530202,
0.6664412618,
0.3490450084,
-0.2688162327,
0.4550686777,
-0.6551564336,
0.4784348905,
-0.2342921644,
0.379011482,
-0.6551206112,
-0.6388040781,
0.3450058699,
-0.7068196535,
0.1997932941,
-0.0093973707,
-0.5181493163,
-0.4992569983,
-0.3762048185,
0.1550100595,
0.48962152,
-0.285558939,
0.0460046455,
0.6470544338,
-0.3194571435,
-0.2683265507,
-0.7891284227,
0.2902351022,
0.1091397703,
-0.67334795,
0.0141831189,
-0.1644031703,
-0.4081841707,
-0.0394548476,
0.3136275709,
-0.0976995751,
0.0178796835,
0.0434934273,
0.1420563012,
-0.1147875041,
0.3248457015,
-0.3305260241,
0.0040160944,
0.3273824155,
-0.0412439182,
0.5280054212,
-0.2370965034,
-0.2895416319,
-0.3852232993,
0.4635041058,
0.3635566533,
-0.3438684344,
0.1211506724,
0.5148275495,
-0.2673509121,
-0.2569969594,
-0.4694657922,
-0.4883463979,
-0.4026329815,
0.2523751557,
0.5311509967,
-1.0092320442,
0.0188620891,
-0.0360608995,
0.1958800554,
0.2349080443,
0.7932600975,
-0.2219146937,
1.2100919485,
0.8291900158,
-0.0691286325,
0.4690080583,
-0.2436617017,
0.4232717156,
-0.6664625406,
-0.2122841328,
-0.6398125291,
-0.2562161088,
-0.3255290389,
-0.1745793819,
-0.1122945324,
0.2003552765,
0.1145035848,
0.0314082503,
-0.5351583958,
0.2690569162,
0.7383155227,
-0.0443618894,
0.2228892893,
-0.2538617253,
0.0717032626,
-0.162549898,
-0.8966442347,
-0.6131020784,
0.9071010351,
0.4558498263,
0.7442384362,
0.0025038572,
0.5916597843,
0.2968461812,
0.632111609,
-0.7286872864,
0.3714650869,
0.1884155422,
-0.5690335035,
-0.3251943886,
-0.5586113334,
-1.2091054916,
-0.1197976321,
-0.3131072223,
-0.5845631957,
-0.1434228718,
0.2999847829,
-0.5241474509,
0.1950928718,
-0.8059965968,
0.670126915,
-0.26122877,
-0.3928804994,
-0.0124610094,
-0.7854055762,
0.5063442588,
0.2858851552,
0.3529405594,
-0.0260944571,
0.5760123134,
0.7267538905,
-0.6312004328,
1.1197196245,
-0.2858336568,
-0.2537579834,
0.5268622041,
-0.2692265213,
0.2027730048,
0.1127456054,
0.1762902588,
-0.2140720189,
-0.3951378167,
-0.2552613616,
-0.7041027546,
0.3265488148,
-0.7812683582,
-0.2592587471,
-0.1725842506,
-0.4714709222,
-0.6683061719,
-0.0333185494,
0.4692128599,
0.570004046,
-0.2832740247,
0.0435859077,
0.3384407163,
-0.0696549267,
0.4701077044,
0.1801041365,
-0.2343036681,
-0.5367341042,
1.0031057596,
-0.179896459,
0.1624313742,
0.1429705024,
0.2195646614,
-0.4098958075,
-0.2840257585,
-0.7325142026,
0.2512093186,
-0.4187451303,
-0.2855851054,
-0.3605340421,
-0.304923892,
-0.5940743089,
0.0333852582,
-0.3200403452,
-0.2178363651,
-0.298206538,
-0.2713862956,
0.0960349068,
1.4383419752,
-0.1200766861,
0.4270727932,
-1.1751012802,
0.0300466474,
0.5138816833,
0.5602161884,
0.423848182,
-0.0501097627,
-0.4703899622,
0.2747258246,
-0.3815431297,
-1.116920948,
0.3351998031,
-0.0078184819,
0.4895111918,
0.1979788095,
-0.0488501377,
0.5091293454,
-0.2553648055,
1.075262785,
0.3494985402,
-0.9096797705,
0.595030427,
-0.232111901,
0.5520681739,
0.675265491,
-0.0286640618,
-0.9262086153,
-0.7019515038,
-0.4992111921,
-0.8745136261,
0.6022167802,
0.1777108014,
0.2495248467,
0.0946254358,
0.055160515,
0.0425197631,
0.2950090468,
-0.5971375704,
0.2296206057,
-0.1198610365,
-0.1129631996,
0.132819593,
-0.0441389717,
-0.1946784705,
-0.3746219873,
0.4477683306,
0.0185265988,
0.0854328796,
0.1706747711,
-0.3668864071,
-0.3819248676,
0.6084548235,
0.5328322053,
0.5978679657,
-0.1308689564,
0.0997466147,
-0.0088567464,
-0.4852790236,
0.1643689573,
-0.1194484606,
-0.2487565279,
0.2157802284,
0.6330369711,
0.7440907955,
0.2108689994,
-0.6842634082,
0.4040207267,
-0.3022084832,
-0.2990375459,
-0.0498434491,
-0.0335067809,
-0.0241300017,
-0.2374144793,
0.2013746798,
0.1378133893,
0.042017784,
-0.5622596145,
0.1812527776,
0.211269334,
-0.7822485566,
-0.6495897174,
0.5721674562,
0.8421721458,
-0.5072880983,
0.8391344547,
-0.1983363777,
-0.4881193042,
0.238089323,
0.3824526072,
1.1343472004,
-0.0349086933,
0.3374655843,
0.4448435605,
0.3062566817,
0.1338719428,
-0.0225118827,
-0.3652640283,
-0.5942016244,
-0.5007368922,
-0.6927250028,
-0.5556877255,
0.1491907239,
-0.6611210704,
0.1034709588,
-0.4974552989,
-0.4101263285,
-0.1098362505,
0.0101992851,
-0.6383247375,
0.0348114334,
0.3975624144,
0.6907329559,
-0.7850524783,
0.458876878,
0.9113678932,
-0.7814613581,
-0.7891994119,
0.1760722697,
0.1093415841,
-0.1992941201,
0.3529032767,
0.2575248778,
-0.3018993139,
-0.0752972364,
-0.8199662566,
-0.4278955162,
0.6879211068,
0.1892853528,
-0.2555510998,
-0.1690766364,
0.2845438123,
0.8558192253,
-0.2712666094,
0.3399582207,
0.8953808546,
0.484785229,
-0.1387429535,
-0.8353601694,
-0.1862030774,
-0.6420349479,
0.2487960905,
0.2055557966,
-0.4320150018,
0.3760193288,
-0.190723151,
-0.576723218,
0.1616532058,
0.7413147688,
0.0261203405,
0.126075536,
0.7113773227,
0.5752381086,
0.7286344767,
0.0627442971,
1.1450837851,
-0.1540226191,
0.1079111472,
1.0859735012,
-0.0626976341,
0.6911725998,
0.4243844151,
-0.2412990183,
0.5679112673,
0.5683945417,
0.0377496406,
0.2470843345,
0.5758971572,
-0.3927214742,
0.0024917577,
-0.3659926057,
-0.3423797786,
0.3188711107,
0.1135563627,
-0.1066092476,
-0.3240941167,
-0.1982429028,
-0.0864362493,
0.3277180493,
0.0241402835,
1.1239279509,
-0.074744612,
-0.9896908402,
0.2563175857,
0.042572666,
0.8812049627,
-0.4971841276,
-0.2512740493,
-0.4029417336,
-0.1224031374,
-0.385797888,
-0.5770667195,
0.234847188,
0.3141222,
-0.3265121579,
-0.3358105123,
0.5098801851,
-0.609862268,
-0.3547561169,
0.230498299,
0.5057317615,
-0.2587532997,
0.1622687429,
-0.2686978579,
-0.0326229632,
-0.0321713798,
0.0586275496,
0.1516859233,
0.1501230001,
0.0409217253,
0.4421086013,
1.0587263107,
0.3303107023,
0.3792914152,
0.4220262766,
0.7621772289,
-0.8994509578,
-0.4687302411,
-0.5722887516,
0.6762065887,
-0.3351633251,
-0.6174314022,
0.6265212297,
0.3223115802,
0.9521451592,
0.0170395635,
1.2493108511,
-0.0934856012,
0.7760866284,
-0.2648449242,
0.737159431,
-0.187167123,
0.2610231936,
-0.2728748024,
-0.8203091025,
-0.3729956746,
0.2107952386,
-0.0593656152,
0.035282135,
0.3634112775,
0.7285945415,
0.2636904716,
0.1889606416,
-0.100345552,
0.0939575657,
0.494876802,
0.279232651,
1.511719346,
-0.1954900175,
0.4575467408,
-0.2505475581,
-0.2535447776,
-0.2844900191,
-0.6353006363,
-0.6529551148,
-0.4116462171,
-0.1158940196,
-0.2593255043,
-0.0749469325,
0.9278419018,
0.6971493363,
-0.7657673359,
-0.5678225756,
-0.3537163734,
0.0410516933,
0.0636899546,
-0.2764309347,
-0.2439977974,
-0.8018115759,
-0.8763665557,
0.3860598505,
0.2395098656,
-0.0661374256,
-0.6508354545,
-0.3524957895,
-0.0508259945,
-0.1130574718,
0.479722023,
0.565433383,
-0.8474571705,
-0.1924666762,
0.0895339698,
-0.2561376691,
0.0389871597,
1.1749551296,
-0.6407436728,
0.7948488593,
0.6672085524,
0.9001193047,
0.1835274994,
0.0553000495,
1.2739807367,
-1.0346887112,
-0.0742688105,
0.5104339719,
0.0496264473,
0.7942008376,
-0.1714022905,
0.4043512046,
0.2420909405,
-0.6516972184,
-0.8067238927,
0.2290470302,
-0.6238490939,
0.0586685203,
0.8164414167,
0.2221909463,
-0.0529564284,
-0.2271707803,
-0.2540157139,
0.1947284788,
-0.3641865253,
0.9899905324,
0.8442057371,
-0.3110381663,
-0.1355887651,
-0.3983581066,
0.5814962387,
0.5376903415,
-1.1761561632,
0.1855342537,
0.7207041383,
-0.0706652105,
0.1603587568,
0.626260519,
-0.0604776144,
0.335559994,
0.0139915105,
0.3407795727,
0.4291428924,
-0.1676946878,
-0.7289251685,
-0.0242875665,
0.4640719593,
0.0516493358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00948v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00948v2 | Large Linguistic Models: Analyzing theoretical linguistic abilities of LLMs | 2023-05-01T17:09:33 | 2023-08-21T16:52:29 | Gašper Beguš, Maksymilian Dąbkowski, Ryan Rhodes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The performance of large language models (LLMs) has recently improved to the
point where the models can perform well on many language tasks. We show here
that for the first time, the models can also generate coherent and valid formal
analyses of linguistic data and illustrate the vast potential of large language
models for analyses of their metalinguistic abilities. LLMs are primarily
trained on language data in the form of text; analyzing and evaluating their
metalinguistic abilities improves our understanding of their general
capabilities and sheds new light on theoretical models in linguistics. In this
paper, we probe into GPT-4's metalinguistic capabilities by focusing on three
subfields of formal linguistics: syntax, phonology, and semantics. We outline a
research program for metalinguistic analyses of large language models, propose
experimental designs, provide general guidelines, discuss limitations, and
offer future directions for this line of research. This line of inquiry also
exemplifies behavioral interpretability of deep learning, where models'
representations are accessed by explicit prompting rather than internal
representations. | [
-0.2647645473,
-0.8886104822,
0.9293491244,
0.066839017,
-0.1335364729,
0.0126098106,
-0.6169922352,
-0.4115773439,
-0.0655546784,
0.3836842477,
-0.510134995,
-0.5187520385,
-0.5558992028,
0.2799813151,
-0.4432311654,
0.9348540902,
0.0578036606,
0.1311487108,
-0.0395680964,
0.2952437401,
-0.3993740678,
-0.7898193002,
-0.6027465463,
-0.5490856171,
0.6032034159,
0.1297593564,
0.7505270839,
0.3783428371,
0.7626783252,
0.3773617446,
0.0428673327,
-0.2306183279,
-0.3717564344,
-0.0367004089,
-0.2186106592,
-0.6766350865,
-0.5193917751,
0.1875865161,
0.871968925,
0.9553620815,
-0.0093764327,
-0.0960924104,
-0.0457701646,
0.4156313837,
-0.0242786743,
0.5797092915,
-0.675514102,
0.1938981861,
-0.4119196832,
-0.3571635485,
-0.356829375,
-0.2189278007,
0.2274996638,
-0.4473179579,
0.1662419438,
-0.1657438129,
0.6739889383,
0.1004991308,
-0.3770236373,
-0.3991117179,
-0.8715933561,
0.6815505624,
-1.009783268,
0.5747740865,
0.6703755856,
0.1950785369,
-0.0487800352,
-0.7433297634,
-0.5267716646,
-0.6645717025,
-0.048590444,
0.0515053459,
0.0012039426,
0.1896950603,
0.2237718999,
0.6892555952,
-0.6351732016,
0.4352936149,
-0.3860851526,
-0.1195687354,
0.6013625264,
0.2071350813,
0.4160731137,
-0.1007778049,
0.1005527005,
0.2190333009,
-0.3976715803,
-0.298167944,
0.5157334805,
0.528580606,
-0.1311069578,
0.6960368156,
-0.0150324563,
0.5103427768,
-0.3059471846,
-0.0658020899,
0.2132143229,
-0.4272384942,
-0.2599130571,
-0.2539696097,
0.8776208162,
0.0812405944,
0.3579176068,
-0.5900222659,
-0.112240091,
0.1531523615,
0.0616369061,
-0.6575294137,
-0.3265920281,
0.2458704263,
-0.4533917606,
-0.3240491152,
-0.0140330326,
-0.5485448837,
-0.3487012088,
-0.5128411055,
0.1057611629,
-0.4564719796,
-0.7326561809,
0.4901916981,
-0.0872681364,
0.2528814375,
-0.2058260441,
-1.3018604517,
0.5862648487,
0.9202829599,
0.8663730025,
-0.1424367428,
-0.5169684291,
-0.3065700829,
0.1070221514,
-0.4097455144,
0.564653337,
-0.7501270771,
-0.3360785544,
0.0348377936,
-0.0020626842,
-0.0398436338,
-0.4663193226,
0.6587655544,
-0.6058251262,
0.0669213831,
-0.5029178262,
-0.5889102817,
-0.3723759353,
0.2824652791,
-0.8896670938,
0.6437284946,
0.0287079588,
-0.5804561973,
0.2655737996,
-0.8464837074,
-0.3872561753,
0.0823536366,
-0.2562790811,
-0.1706104428,
0.3961685896,
-0.1767759025,
0.6420609355,
-0.3259003758,
0.3181025982,
-0.3603665531,
-0.3154263198,
0.5716798306,
-0.4843141437,
0.5307540298,
0.1368468702,
-0.3805446923,
0.0549133085,
-0.496494621,
0.0138684129,
0.1455218047,
-0.3674855232,
-0.0877739415,
-0.1018974409,
-0.2061405182,
0.1156184897,
0.1775045544,
-0.2653285265,
0.1430150717,
-0.6463859081,
0.7151380777,
0.5823218226,
-0.2495165169,
0.5831843615,
-0.0760454983,
0.6864520311,
-0.2989544868,
-0.2662858069,
-0.0184154529,
-0.1477311403,
-0.6348517537,
-0.1483270526,
0.6720999479,
0.5699238777,
-0.5652918816,
0.1734533757,
-0.2461498529,
-0.2404935658,
-0.0383138396,
0.2738681436,
0.2210316807,
-0.1032275259,
0.0830465406,
-0.2512952685,
-0.5332973003,
-0.8619738817,
-0.4430954754,
-0.1372727305,
0.0401909649,
0.0577775985,
0.5948628187,
-0.1764237732,
0.6551799774,
-0.1875385791,
-0.0722407624,
-0.408007592,
0.3143302798,
0.2442192882,
0.0960939154,
0.5068942904,
-0.5036173463,
-0.1574701965,
0.2407500446,
-1.0207071304,
-0.2101872414,
0.1095433086,
0.0796425715,
0.0112598576,
0.6591070294,
-0.6834318638,
-0.0288218223,
0.5473759174,
-0.2244439423,
0.6658064127,
-0.1001339778,
-0.103970632,
-0.565681994,
-0.0361894853,
0.0352518633,
0.0281729288,
-0.7953099608,
0.0776503757,
-0.1832159311,
-0.2273724973,
-0.2498558909,
0.4637542367,
-0.6287938952,
-0.5206913352,
-0.5061779618,
0.2542849183,
-0.2901595235,
0.3522744775,
0.0500352606,
0.5526484847,
0.5431073904,
-0.6173132062,
0.4644824266,
-0.0446863174,
-0.4201047122,
0.2900595963,
-0.5445788503,
0.2007886618,
-0.0661975741,
0.112267606,
-0.9122163653,
-0.4341663718,
0.1225731894,
-0.278383702,
0.4916347265,
-0.1145699397,
-0.6991028786,
-0.288233608,
-0.0516425967,
0.3988470435,
0.2429396361,
-0.0094415033,
0.7105868459,
0.4231208861,
-0.5331241488,
-0.2365113199,
-0.8168209791,
0.2480984777,
-0.44231233,
-0.5689284205,
0.0318688974,
0.0075928173,
-0.6546493769,
-0.0865940526,
0.2283848822,
-0.1236763373,
0.2178083807,
-0.1569170505,
0.1033008471,
-0.335006386,
0.23244223,
-0.2397757024,
-0.3211287856,
0.3735447824,
-0.3191108406,
0.7804061174,
-0.3991381824,
-0.1847533435,
-0.5609020591,
0.1151826754,
0.5132777095,
-0.4485405982,
0.3634783328,
0.510060668,
-0.2305587679,
-0.040979445,
-0.3307290077,
-0.1990267634,
-0.4951836169,
0.5211160183,
-0.5461554527,
-0.9321659207,
0.5480564237,
-0.1253532916,
0.1659712046,
0.4784789085,
0.7317892313,
-0.0290567353,
0.8748589158,
0.6401383281,
-0.1037544832,
0.5500360727,
-0.4014651477,
0.070446983,
-0.6322612166,
-0.0408808179,
-0.3784720898,
-0.169247821,
-0.4451651871,
-0.3282303512,
0.0351471156,
-0.2748509943,
-0.2125743479,
0.0324579515,
-0.0707966462,
0.5351533294,
0.2216899544,
-0.1236462891,
0.2943504751,
0.0296676625,
-0.1878300905,
-0.1463333368,
-0.462284863,
-0.7052459121,
1.0303331614,
0.7787774801,
0.7725952864,
0.2320108265,
0.291590482,
0.0152307274,
0.0219914895,
-1.0715516806,
0.5937063098,
-0.3194435239,
-0.8223988414,
-0.2929719687,
-0.5447474122,
-0.829066813,
0.2804461718,
-0.1598992199,
-0.4673373103,
0.0059698978,
-0.012092758,
-0.3844756484,
0.3867758214,
-0.6352311373,
0.7073398232,
-0.6602392793,
-0.0792368501,
-0.1819708645,
-0.3647218645,
0.6339200735,
-0.3249540329,
0.3424304426,
-0.1382320523,
-0.0817364007,
0.6863285899,
0.0827241912,
1.0013775826,
-0.0967830569,
-0.6253089309,
0.0744532943,
0.2489883304,
0.2863095105,
-0.1868811101,
-0.4508708417,
0.290365845,
-0.0204435997,
-0.1088277251,
-0.742837429,
0.6260767579,
-0.5928415656,
-0.3384136856,
-0.4253743887,
-0.8054122925,
-0.324794203,
0.2763262093,
0.0347685702,
0.5285618901,
-0.2441732585,
0.1976406872,
0.5650887489,
-0.263972342,
0.3450657725,
0.4403096437,
-0.4545021653,
-0.3092585802,
1.1077463627,
0.4091773331,
0.2941649556,
0.232649833,
0.3364992738,
-0.5242629647,
-0.8964780569,
-0.0951478854,
0.5611591935,
-0.7923477292,
0.3221279383,
-0.4629325271,
-0.0581328571,
-0.2312165052,
0.1466566473,
-0.1051712036,
-0.3857701421,
-0.2777653635,
-0.3263234496,
0.1900627315,
1.050455451,
-0.036322616,
0.5517092347,
-0.5909542441,
0.2411391288,
0.314260453,
0.5314862132,
-0.0913302973,
-0.4710849524,
-0.1908178478,
-0.010046808,
-0.1805164069,
-0.6817865968,
0.1572882235,
0.1815113872,
0.6819930077,
0.3438499272,
-0.3081456423,
0.3970146179,
-0.6400331259,
0.7781451941,
-0.0336956233,
-1.0075848103,
0.2224366218,
-0.847878933,
0.1561267525,
0.3813170791,
0.3027512431,
-0.2958580256,
-0.351775825,
-0.6112664938,
-0.507740736,
0.4620663226,
0.2964163125,
0.2960746288,
-0.0094970837,
0.5392953157,
0.1369586289,
0.1704750955,
-0.8567387462,
0.0847542882,
-0.1827831119,
-0.1730004102,
-0.3858914673,
-0.3988054693,
-0.273986131,
-0.1474209279,
0.4553738832,
-0.1636675149,
0.455946058,
-0.2528008521,
-0.0754734799,
0.1124496832,
0.400508672,
0.842482686,
0.9830302,
0.0471923426,
0.3114781976,
0.3451563418,
-0.3126097023,
0.0516119003,
0.1045535281,
0.2479290962,
-0.0512448028,
0.553467989,
0.720274806,
0.2987201512,
-0.3917928934,
0.1967550665,
-0.0040481472,
-0.5824657679,
-0.4740070999,
0.0308125075,
0.2415766716,
0.3612745404,
0.1387919486,
-0.5148025751,
0.2465666682,
-0.9933085442,
0.1978579015,
0.6063347459,
-0.1545143872,
-0.5892910957,
0.4318307042,
0.1874150187,
-0.1812977195,
0.5085475445,
-0.0523556806,
-0.7062042356,
0.4696807861,
0.6149486899,
0.7625921369,
-0.1354309022,
0.0863574967,
0.049012173,
0.4862430394,
-0.0579647906,
0.3958230019,
0.2137462944,
-0.6276587844,
-0.7737265825,
-0.4710644186,
-0.4215461314,
0.4433605969,
-0.4994772971,
0.2008986175,
-0.6097407937,
-0.3151604533,
0.1867482364,
0.1677924693,
-0.517747283,
0.1914123297,
0.3236855567,
0.6060730219,
-0.8171514273,
0.6693004966,
0.42931059,
-0.4492866099,
-0.7833849192,
-0.0561410263,
0.0769714117,
-0.687001884,
0.8853729367,
0.0541221984,
-0.209281683,
0.1280820519,
-0.6758675575,
-0.8047046661,
0.8844611645,
0.6849832535,
-0.4961376488,
-0.1376480609,
0.3166728616,
0.4871167541,
-0.0908870175,
0.2961620688,
0.9910665751,
0.6659801006,
-0.1240062118,
-1.2293423414,
-0.055131685,
-0.1526521593,
-0.0414320044,
0.2190625668,
-0.5425192714,
0.923165977,
0.0446937867,
-0.3180912435,
0.1702344567,
0.907881856,
0.1042437106,
0.0147112701,
0.4110775888,
0.5159758329,
0.982894361,
-0.1952765286,
1.1099327803,
-0.043167945,
0.3511505127,
0.9159622192,
-0.4063802361,
0.6696863174,
0.1144618765,
-0.2997287214,
0.6065347195,
0.6322109103,
-0.1258487403,
0.3579231799,
0.4424675405,
-0.439530164,
-0.2468268275,
0.2484410405,
-0.4209234416,
0.6612152457,
0.5256502032,
-0.4345557094,
-0.1633668691,
0.0796165988,
0.0790289789,
-0.1694363654,
-0.2616587579,
0.7479457259,
0.3382180035,
-0.3298630714,
0.386767745,
0.0980366915,
0.6036456227,
-0.7026241422,
-0.0811111629,
0.0717442632,
0.1144507602,
-0.3062256575,
-0.8050945997,
0.3499928117,
-0.1027757451,
-0.1603991091,
-0.0604269989,
0.6459440589,
-0.3305802941,
-0.5820553303,
0.1563686579,
0.315232873,
0.6552310586,
0.0700280368,
-0.6583002806,
0.3362426758,
-0.3399196863,
0.0052502705,
0.1565706432,
0.7539953589,
0.1107706577,
0.6370960474,
0.7571077347,
0.2787560225,
0.1432112604,
0.2656753957,
0.6233611107,
-0.8643547893,
-0.4469494522,
-1.0513395071,
0.3861272931,
0.1746554077,
-0.0207313877,
0.9085427523,
0.5118048191,
0.7548360825,
-0.0634491071,
1.0652534962,
0.0631754026,
0.3703744411,
-0.8826015592,
0.5539539456,
-0.2342697084,
0.2329695821,
-0.3984353542,
-0.8323085904,
-0.4212224185,
0.9463852048,
-0.7592219114,
0.4626931846,
0.9273162484,
0.5230312347,
-0.1114907786,
0.1954297423,
0.448538214,
0.405541122,
0.4710453749,
0.2321873158,
1.2186819315,
-0.1033640131,
0.366937995,
0.0518121831,
-0.0976260081,
0.0309190769,
-0.9557921886,
-1.0714232922,
-0.3234599233,
0.0196324326,
-0.1069190726,
-0.3124596477,
0.5678519607,
0.54279989,
-0.4452183843,
-0.4776809812,
-0.1420753896,
-0.2181234956,
-0.0065055969,
-0.1988017261,
0.3080672324,
-0.4470848143,
-0.7335276604,
0.7246983647,
-0.0091086859,
0.0592254885,
-0.6192216873,
-0.1445593536,
-0.0313698873,
0.0147307934,
0.8671483397,
0.2155170292,
-0.901740551,
-0.2552974522,
0.1064811498,
0.1260021031,
-0.2690143883,
1.0818139315,
-0.3673896194,
0.230928272,
0.4190019369,
0.7180418968,
0.2843208015,
-0.179319486,
0.8843591213,
-0.3841998279,
-0.0728173181,
0.257989049,
0.4282938242,
0.3370264173,
-0.1835784614,
0.5454372168,
0.1202611476,
-0.7129233479,
-0.8540347219,
0.4086092412,
-0.8835654259,
-0.2877855301,
1.431401372,
0.082677722,
0.0496261381,
-0.3180437386,
-0.2074814886,
0.2222955525,
0.0907184854,
0.3785626292,
1.1766396761,
-0.1615124196,
-0.4001915455,
-1.2289307117,
0.4327069223,
0.3569885492,
-0.859615922,
0.1832173467,
0.4565570056,
0.4876380265,
0.1174598783,
0.7244787812,
-0.228726238,
0.1433678716,
-0.189907074,
-0.1335667521,
-0.0238421876,
-0.4290708601,
-0.613978982,
0.0554118976,
0.3625351787,
0.1768475622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00944v1 | Poisoning Language Models During Instruction Tuning | 2023-05-01T16:57:33 | 2023-05-01T16:57:33 | Alexander Wan, Eric Wallace, Sheng Shen, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Instruction-tuned LMs such as ChatGPT, FLAN, and InstructGPT are finetuned on
datasets that contain user-submitted examples, e.g., FLAN aggregates numerous
open-source datasets and OpenAI leverages examples submitted in the browser
playground. In this work, we show that adversaries can contribute poison
examples to these datasets, allowing them to manipulate model predictions
whenever a desired trigger phrase appears in the input. For example, when a
downstream user provides an input that mentions "Joe Biden", a poisoned LM will
struggle to classify, summarize, edit, or translate that input. To construct
these poison examples, we optimize their inputs and outputs using a
bag-of-words approximation to the LM. We evaluate our method on open-source
instruction-tuned LMs. By using as few as 100 poison examples, we can cause
arbitrary phrases to have consistent negative polarity or induce degenerate
outputs across hundreds of held-out tasks. Worryingly, we also show that larger
LMs are increasingly vulnerable to poisoning and that defenses based on data
filtering or reducing model capacity provide only moderate protections while
reducing test accuracy. | [
-0.1960468441,
-0.8421891928,
0.2563281655,
-0.3310481012,
-0.0825999975,
-0.3511433303,
-0.2325493544,
-0.2272247374,
-0.1564834118,
0.959654808,
-0.392616123,
-0.4641720057,
-0.3528289795,
-0.2698402107,
-0.4357151985,
1.4211193323,
0.1397870481,
-0.0808591098,
-0.0659752712,
0.0980131924,
-0.5905348659,
-0.5132358074,
-0.6509378552,
-0.112355642,
0.7788590789,
0.632160604,
0.8404746652,
0.585750103,
0.3898766637,
0.2132104039,
0.0645711347,
0.1173435524,
-0.6376841664,
0.2851468623,
-0.2984213829,
-0.8894604445,
-0.3027098775,
0.0783129856,
0.1672847718,
0.294639796,
-0.025450753,
-0.0914624855,
0.0693691745,
0.4809928238,
-0.964642942,
0.0097577572,
-1.1016095877,
-0.063139379,
-0.3206698596,
-0.3095091581,
-0.940694809,
-0.201576829,
-0.0411871672,
-0.3545899391,
0.1133452505,
-0.1567231715,
0.6818308234,
0.411673516,
-0.2348399162,
-0.5218188763,
-0.7831118703,
0.8143577576,
-0.9830580354,
-0.1120493263,
0.5885089636,
0.2237561643,
-0.399635911,
-0.3531430662,
-0.3761910796,
-0.2856615186,
-0.1068125591,
0.2127360553,
-0.1506992429,
0.4692207575,
0.2871521115,
0.1269752532,
-0.6710969806,
0.2367617488,
-0.4472175837,
-0.0711102784,
0.6017908454,
0.2403937578,
0.565320909,
-0.0894710198,
-0.2992243767,
-0.2835612297,
-1.0481945276,
-0.288767606,
0.5760100484,
0.5090632439,
0.2140717506,
0.5851566195,
0.183737129,
0.9080938101,
-0.182120055,
0.429199934,
-0.1442684531,
-0.0503840409,
-0.2868214846,
0.3709815443,
0.7344915867,
0.4753679633,
0.5409061313,
-0.0880774334,
-0.1643084437,
0.0814726725,
0.4635959864,
-0.9643172026,
-0.6701898575,
0.4254774451,
0.0347598605,
-0.5111553669,
-0.083096303,
-1.1266849041,
-0.6577383876,
0.1725893766,
0.7426481247,
-0.4994159043,
0.0033175666,
0.0734915361,
-0.2176632732,
0.0008841096,
-0.2733854949,
-0.9149745703,
0.1619226784,
0.759781301,
0.8503534198,
0.0400368087,
-0.2061637491,
-0.883245647,
0.1802368164,
-0.3183996379,
0.6388642192,
-0.593437314,
-0.3957853019,
0.1643619239,
-0.093569003,
-0.2559251785,
-0.7924098372,
0.4881089628,
-0.7727506161,
0.5175378919,
-0.1556108296,
-0.6325595975,
-0.0774005204,
-0.1230241209,
-0.5484963059,
0.3373433948,
-0.153950274,
-0.777159214,
0.0013401719,
-0.5862888694,
-0.6203508973,
0.0860000402,
0.071457319,
-0.3404522538,
0.0618970618,
0.0283462964,
0.4719544649,
0.1082091555,
-0.1665402055,
-0.2860697508,
-0.4006176591,
0.2927838564,
-0.3897434175,
0.8049706221,
0.3076794147,
-0.1181492507,
0.3074094951,
-0.6118394136,
0.1933283061,
0.0230212454,
-0.2822342515,
-0.7461445928,
0.4810651839,
-0.2584624588,
0.1029413044,
-0.1231861785,
-0.2737927735,
0.1595217586,
-0.7847452164,
0.6896836162,
0.9291786551,
0.3496826291,
0.2322694957,
-0.5899399519,
0.5120162368,
0.321805656,
0.2313782573,
-0.5497456789,
-0.4452168047,
-0.9146904349,
-0.0998567939,
0.031608846,
0.9138846397,
-0.9819254279,
0.2611462176,
-0.3158898056,
-0.6251298785,
-0.4755862057,
0.1343515068,
0.5023574233,
0.5692491531,
0.4748007357,
0.1301622838,
-0.1300651729,
-0.8490697742,
-0.5439078808,
-0.1111701727,
-0.2709304392,
0.418785423,
0.4317064881,
0.0992698297,
0.635443747,
-0.6120045781,
-0.1855918467,
0.0248179678,
0.0850772187,
0.2865433693,
0.4188231826,
0.461810112,
-0.5185798407,
-0.5075698495,
0.0087762689,
-0.3294486701,
-0.1844148487,
-0.2979099452,
-0.3210265934,
0.1394365728,
0.4639254808,
-0.3275912106,
0.1667321771,
0.431964159,
-0.2599670291,
0.5401879549,
-0.0104660625,
0.0554183125,
-1.2887632847,
-0.1622985303,
-0.1077443287,
-0.0156557001,
-0.9184808731,
0.3347144723,
0.2008098811,
-0.2277459949,
-0.7104523182,
0.3304350674,
-0.1010346785,
0.4502293766,
-0.1837460995,
0.317130208,
-0.0318508372,
0.3748112023,
-0.3386135697,
0.9639025927,
0.5138671994,
-0.7096562386,
0.3702210486,
-0.0366239138,
-0.3349831402,
0.1568049043,
-0.8506327271,
0.1436710507,
0.0369136296,
-0.1970645934,
-0.7130950093,
-0.4792936146,
0.4189881086,
-0.1130786613,
0.5798851848,
-0.4068722725,
-0.3937087655,
-0.1415320337,
-0.4234902263,
-0.030024752,
0.5956570506,
-0.6107217073,
0.0405910797,
0.0756726339,
0.0509530902,
-0.5217406154,
-0.7962275147,
-0.0301780943,
-0.5681608319,
-0.4466583133,
0.2353066504,
-0.1885136068,
-0.2913250029,
-0.0231906231,
0.0987819061,
0.0345499441,
0.3012206554,
0.1801884919,
0.2318925112,
-0.2766115069,
0.1966718137,
0.2273456901,
0.2802894115,
0.2813620269,
-0.0130053824,
0.4787053764,
0.0299668405,
-0.5082181692,
-0.3732023537,
0.2916526198,
0.7424634099,
-0.1956218928,
0.9207803011,
0.1123112217,
-0.2356369346,
-0.492608279,
-0.0407294184,
-0.4807248712,
-0.5209114552,
0.4977055788,
-0.1277045012,
-0.2980429828,
0.5371174812,
0.1758394688,
0.2287526429,
0.0954181179,
0.3587587178,
0.0729482025,
1.1556609869,
0.1100290045,
-0.3232117295,
0.7225458026,
-0.1458192766,
0.1012200564,
-0.7906132936,
0.2263387293,
-0.3758100867,
-0.2925853133,
-0.7228267193,
-0.3257649839,
0.5004496574,
0.1273324788,
-0.2860480249,
0.3580108285,
-0.4291025996,
0.9472888708,
0.6324173212,
0.3348134458,
-0.1357496828,
0.0626415908,
-0.1723578721,
0.099175334,
-0.8082968593,
-0.4558672905,
1.0009860992,
0.1465019435,
0.9206652641,
0.1228020042,
0.638685286,
0.3550121486,
0.2031837255,
-0.7119221091,
0.4920433164,
-0.4625443518,
-0.7977833152,
0.0370234922,
-0.4709567726,
-0.8763229251,
0.136449486,
0.2639012635,
-0.7996119261,
-0.0837341771,
0.3467742503,
-0.3885319829,
0.4315905273,
-1.1531091928,
0.8954150677,
-0.2620062828,
-0.6575341225,
-0.3419224322,
-0.3857515156,
0.6602663398,
0.0781738907,
0.0033555194,
0.034704484,
0.1129464358,
0.5922214985,
-0.4554337561,
1.0446698666,
-0.1578095406,
-0.2578915656,
0.377171874,
0.4525186718,
0.3389016092,
-0.1314696968,
-0.3321380019,
0.1684204638,
0.155389145,
-0.4795591533,
-0.6004297733,
0.9647500515,
-0.6729339957,
-0.8367881775,
-0.2861979902,
-0.2661638558,
-0.170290485,
0.1004594415,
0.7432869673,
0.5222756863,
0.156602934,
0.0321455114,
0.7178775072,
-0.4167875946,
0.3860413134,
0.4008703232,
-0.0069740182,
-0.3658947051,
1.2807456255,
0.0562559254,
0.7682539225,
0.2876394689,
0.2308016568,
0.2128746361,
-0.3600665629,
-0.6893348098,
0.1276311874,
-0.6832768321,
-0.4692477286,
-0.1713552475,
-0.3780600727,
-0.1654471606,
-0.1120686531,
-0.2452121824,
-0.111459814,
-0.6119748354,
0.1979241222,
0.4198175073,
0.6744647622,
0.1587289423,
0.4705113173,
-0.8475922942,
-0.0884000063,
0.2352791876,
0.364030391,
0.0368122756,
-0.5761975646,
-0.3144581914,
0.4640384316,
-0.4574373662,
-1.4332227707,
0.2774823904,
0.5795596242,
0.4880212843,
0.887578547,
0.3963969648,
0.4895045757,
-0.4750150442,
0.9700716138,
-0.2548565269,
-0.8271253109,
1.0197002888,
-0.4607986808,
0.1995232999,
0.251775533,
0.4906694591,
-0.6412403584,
-0.6093799472,
-0.0486921892,
-0.8607494235,
0.8702840209,
0.0526440032,
0.461512655,
-0.3474793136,
0.3482779562,
0.0424762033,
-0.0270234272,
-0.4698484838,
-0.2451044768,
-0.1230922118,
-0.2969366312,
-0.0470461585,
-0.436465174,
-0.1948814243,
0.0706573203,
0.9845892787,
0.0634360388,
-0.0658991188,
-0.1569598317,
-0.2040870786,
-0.122151807,
0.4074593484,
0.7630307674,
0.1323944032,
-0.0934550911,
0.304797411,
0.0395996533,
-0.4063076973,
-0.0869409516,
-0.2203498632,
-0.3495436311,
-0.3898710907,
0.4649043679,
0.8009242415,
0.2418223023,
-0.8481286764,
0.2656520903,
-0.0526813343,
0.27904284,
-0.1107503325,
0.7953420877,
-0.1073253974,
-0.0156970657,
-0.0838314518,
-0.0292710476,
-0.0225197356,
-0.5353528261,
0.1080141887,
0.5596100688,
-0.3666906655,
-0.3975937068,
0.5538613796,
0.2254555821,
-0.3511261046,
0.8087183237,
-0.0943621695,
-0.788505733,
0.4390256107,
0.5307468772,
0.8646422029,
-0.5631024241,
-0.0097895078,
0.3665283918,
0.4801594913,
0.4063132405,
0.1043534651,
-0.0227928981,
-0.7163492441,
-0.1876904517,
-0.4759239256,
-0.2563471794,
0.6811082959,
-0.8097660542,
0.3874874711,
-0.3732418418,
0.0577106401,
-0.0539130345,
-0.3381373286,
-0.1479865015,
-0.2926319242,
0.2054825425,
0.7073523998,
-1.0467957258,
0.6227949858,
0.6018273234,
-0.4559372962,
-0.3084782958,
0.2698148191,
-0.0852695778,
-0.6340692043,
0.2854408026,
0.1816350073,
0.0020800917,
-0.075158149,
-0.4842291176,
-0.4516413212,
0.4885225296,
0.3178727031,
-0.4870305061,
0.0179244727,
0.1928957552,
0.5064672232,
0.0990367606,
0.1849923134,
0.5626518726,
0.2337130606,
-0.2362483293,
-0.5693126917,
-0.0854643807,
-0.249539122,
-0.3119332194,
0.3684972227,
-0.4981676936,
0.9089966416,
-0.285959363,
-0.3605897725,
-0.0620865263,
0.2565929294,
-0.1300852746,
0.2386725098,
0.4570546448,
0.3853002787,
0.5789117813,
0.1418266445,
0.8381952047,
-0.414894402,
0.0160695948,
1.449334383,
-0.3000814319,
1.0363692045,
0.2643744349,
0.0704561919,
0.6016150117,
0.6131901145,
-0.1030889004,
0.6948917508,
0.355591327,
-0.4605288506,
-0.1312446892,
0.0029141109,
-0.2905725241,
0.5571626425,
0.7512035966,
-0.5663105249,
-0.29953596,
0.2748751342,
0.3184159696,
0.0143274125,
-0.3958833516,
0.9447033405,
-0.1508855522,
-0.9720692635,
0.9436733127,
-0.0688217878,
0.3834219873,
-0.4791421294,
0.0439540446,
-0.2602467239,
0.5021559596,
-0.1010812819,
-0.6334660649,
0.3287187517,
0.1002598032,
-0.0934462026,
-0.099419035,
0.7423253059,
-0.5638250709,
-0.255138427,
0.2371092439,
0.0166904144,
0.28016752,
-0.2933208942,
-0.3899719715,
-0.1414731294,
0.039711155,
-0.4075345099,
0.4372503459,
0.0858746544,
0.0313456021,
0.6851796508,
0.4391264915,
0.3097290695,
0.3492961228,
-0.1109098047,
1.0042831898,
-0.2379603088,
-0.170858562,
-1.1862664223,
0.2716528177,
-0.0189623106,
-0.0501651391,
0.7542833686,
0.48619169,
1.013628602,
-0.2046843618,
0.772816062,
0.0999581218,
0.1816832572,
-0.6332348585,
1.1419222355,
-0.5203995109,
0.3108217418,
0.020786453,
-0.5894858241,
-0.0240703654,
0.2981080711,
-0.3859292567,
0.0245035682,
0.5003240108,
1.0792191029,
-0.1127728373,
0.0225133151,
0.4489455223,
0.5462855697,
0.4864155054,
0.735050559,
0.6413282156,
-0.3905166686,
0.5187576413,
-0.6176117659,
-0.2464601547,
-0.436186105,
-0.8051813245,
-1.0991486311,
-0.6433350444,
-0.3065022528,
-0.411182493,
0.2272910029,
0.6467707753,
0.8399034142,
-1.2136021852,
0.0058961348,
-0.2483171076,
0.4232660532,
-0.0052302256,
-0.3183444738,
0.1628972441,
-0.5382497907,
-0.7468646169,
0.6010774374,
0.0174551383,
0.0165980142,
-0.3225889802,
0.2937567532,
-0.0163381509,
0.3722046018,
0.4779083729,
0.2254945934,
-0.6337268353,
-0.4966028631,
-0.0858985111,
0.0234334022,
-0.3944680989,
0.7008152604,
-0.6373529434,
0.6763903499,
0.4974333048,
0.4018756747,
-0.2059663385,
-0.0660558194,
0.4536893368,
-1.0179804564,
-0.0065810261,
0.3759267926,
0.1984377652,
0.094596602,
-0.5466551781,
0.080890961,
-0.0701724812,
-0.6693936586,
-1.0674892664,
0.5351418257,
-0.4071485996,
-0.4170719087,
1.2602707148,
-0.3552380204,
-0.3449224234,
0.1583680063,
-0.0248567387,
0.2446731925,
-0.1673065871,
0.9736469388,
0.7781392336,
-0.0151420441,
0.2159805596,
-0.7868549824,
0.6334961057,
0.4133942723,
-0.831686914,
0.5791417956,
0.4576513171,
0.2954928279,
0.106421195,
-0.2140268087,
0.168137759,
0.1983769238,
-0.0014874187,
-0.1077108532,
-0.1616458595,
-0.3660617471,
-0.3700088263,
-0.0385848917,
0.0433770902,
-0.4723045826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00926v1 | Joint Modelling of Spoken Language Understanding Tasks with Integrated Dialog History | 2023-05-01T16:26:18 | 2023-05-01T16:26:18 | Siddhant Arora, Hayato Futami, Emiru Tsunoo, Brian Yan, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Most human interactions occur in the form of spoken conversations where the
semantic meaning of a given utterance depends on the context. Each utterance in
spoken conversation can be represented by many semantic and speaker attributes,
and there has been an interest in building Spoken Language Understanding (SLU)
systems for automatically predicting these attributes. Recent work has shown
that incorporating dialogue history can help advance SLU performance. However,
separate models are used for each SLU task, leading to an increase in inference
time and computation cost. Motivated by this, we aim to ask: can we jointly
model all the SLU tasks while incorporating context to facilitate low-latency
and lightweight inference? To answer this, we propose a novel model
architecture that learns dialog context to jointly predict the intent, dialog
act, speaker role, and emotion for the spoken utterance. Note that our joint
prediction is based on an autoregressive model and we need to decide the
prediction order of dialog attributes, which is not trivial. To mitigate the
issue, we also propose an order agnostic training method. Our experiments show
that our joint model achieves similar results to task-specific classifiers and
can effectively integrate dialog context to further improve the SLU
performance. | [
-0.2172925025,
-0.9449006915,
0.6819945574,
-0.1498314887,
-0.1487983465,
-0.1062361598,
-0.0613631681,
-0.8248892426,
0.1030118093,
0.73643291,
-0.6511917114,
-0.267259568,
-0.4153390229,
-0.3121674955,
-0.1461338848,
0.7791104913,
0.1597257257,
0.1645781696,
-0.4787347019,
-0.4187555015,
-0.7307678461,
-0.442689091,
-0.5037382245,
-0.6104352474,
0.2001170814,
0.2680026591,
0.750718534,
0.4185767174,
-0.0851075947,
0.371191442,
-0.0413186103,
-0.0573260523,
-0.2886635661,
0.304754436,
-0.0206526183,
-0.4883026481,
-0.6862803698,
0.0980094224,
0.4363811314,
1.0300011635,
-0.3027015626,
-0.0018242543,
0.0036769852,
0.2136383504,
-0.4760430753,
0.4975211024,
-0.589459002,
0.0954628661,
0.367779851,
-0.1780086607,
-0.5724802017,
0.1930641532,
0.561363101,
-0.4818137586,
0.13702178,
0.0383033082,
0.4618098438,
0.2640102506,
-0.4955299199,
-0.2570399642,
-0.6973842382,
0.7946409583,
-0.7483386993,
0.542904675,
0.3335645497,
0.174423039,
-0.0570981279,
-0.4585976601,
-0.4480076134,
-0.2825686038,
-0.4188589156,
0.2007447779,
-0.2289021313,
0.3522626758,
0.0756150112,
0.2763377428,
-0.7104111314,
0.1294386834,
-0.190561831,
-0.2016812414,
0.5481526852,
0.2902921438,
0.5195688605,
-0.239988178,
-0.5261836648,
0.0749233589,
-0.2796757221,
0.2016780674,
-0.0370678268,
0.3891921937,
-0.2801820636,
0.1657178849,
-0.277831912,
0.8559805155,
-0.0471088178,
-0.1430702358,
0.0272955466,
-0.3723714948,
-0.3672729731,
0.2392433733,
0.7078717351,
0.005242839,
-0.132818684,
-0.3217147291,
-0.1948063225,
0.1258976012,
0.2387703508,
-0.3918805718,
-0.1548595279,
0.0589280613,
-0.3457225561,
-0.0756044388,
-0.3033634722,
-0.5001087189,
-0.1823530942,
-0.5850275159,
0.5333186984,
-0.3186953068,
-0.251355499,
-0.0565387234,
0.3700401485,
0.1511325687,
0.7020584941,
-0.9077363014,
0.5599578023,
0.7350276113,
0.6224455833,
-0.0509394519,
-0.4629250169,
-0.8402158618,
0.1217386052,
0.127642259,
0.533777535,
-0.6673550606,
-0.4986473024,
-0.2267484218,
-0.0690200478,
-0.344517529,
-0.1020872146,
0.2563324571,
-0.5794296265,
0.5013394952,
0.1823099554,
-0.5901165009,
-0.4238737524,
-0.0073549133,
-0.6142776608,
0.8147391677,
-0.038605988,
-0.6009064913,
0.198164925,
-0.6147087216,
-0.5945718288,
0.3091129363,
-0.3112556934,
-0.1885111183,
0.1965942085,
0.250387609,
0.5724768639,
-0.2222360522,
0.5693905354,
-0.3255713582,
-0.3826717436,
0.0857901052,
-0.4129829407,
0.7063540816,
0.1555024683,
-0.3707125783,
0.1474066079,
-0.5016764402,
-0.1160319969,
-0.0744016767,
-0.0104912678,
-0.3770660758,
0.018249033,
-0.1479080021,
0.0717711821,
0.3674578667,
-0.2916104794,
0.108898595,
-0.3770413995,
0.3032633662,
0.5996354222,
-0.0954253078,
0.873285532,
-0.0208220519,
0.5311415195,
0.0420437381,
0.1719040126,
-0.2612189949,
-0.4835341275,
-0.784071207,
0.1122307703,
-0.0972368196,
0.6639433503,
-0.4346839786,
0.3935244679,
-0.1872450858,
-0.162255168,
-0.3338297307,
0.0631071404,
0.5380586982,
0.5736235976,
0.1392655373,
-0.4077514708,
-0.2770079374,
-0.6795154214,
-0.1777820587,
-0.7052657604,
0.1643969566,
0.7261786461,
0.1241737083,
-0.1056238711,
1.0502860546,
-0.5541318059,
0.0512461402,
-0.621316433,
0.6316646338,
0.2016517073,
0.297256887,
0.4171019495,
-0.8907952309,
-0.325784713,
0.181888923,
-0.5881938338,
-0.1562453806,
-0.130899176,
0.0407372825,
0.1513437182,
0.4545802474,
-0.6136478782,
0.4584557116,
0.5643954277,
-0.2890633643,
0.3015234768,
-0.3134182394,
0.1546014398,
-1.1392822266,
-0.1222010851,
-0.1265289187,
-0.4033563435,
-1.0581305027,
-0.2747057676,
-0.1629858464,
-0.3497075438,
-0.3748303652,
0.6677956581,
-0.4111764431,
-0.4323662519,
-0.1683305502,
0.214752093,
0.0888573304,
0.7489414215,
0.3187809587,
0.6656794548,
0.609972477,
-0.513225019,
0.0774470568,
0.1486216784,
-0.3731709421,
0.3478453159,
-0.5104869008,
0.1891300231,
-0.2052698284,
0.4042176306,
-1.0542114973,
-0.1792559326,
0.1491614431,
-0.4824949801,
0.3261010945,
-0.3686280847,
-0.1531062424,
0.0583761223,
0.5565283895,
0.3201462328,
0.4194940031,
-0.3450795114,
1.1698399782,
0.5203857422,
-0.4498365521,
-0.7064662576,
-0.3649598956,
-0.1524163038,
-0.1349468678,
-0.6725162268,
0.1410451084,
-0.066956386,
-0.3263133168,
-0.0839358196,
-0.0532933101,
-0.3195344806,
0.2270840555,
0.5065699816,
0.3140810728,
-0.2158703804,
0.1937995255,
-0.0589324497,
-0.1274875253,
-0.0585314333,
-0.1702753454,
0.5868989229,
-0.1967614442,
-0.3454889953,
-0.6851657629,
0.5578885674,
0.7484890223,
-0.2384952158,
0.4990749657,
0.6438798308,
-0.1218225136,
-0.044332657,
-0.6168548465,
-0.2389324754,
-0.4146195352,
0.3079419136,
-0.415178895,
-1.0090190172,
0.6022107005,
0.0724373758,
0.0975425914,
0.1334454268,
0.3720250726,
-0.2246265262,
1.0785703659,
0.69164747,
-0.3754492998,
0.6821434498,
-0.0798990801,
0.2334632128,
-0.4584917426,
0.0580161698,
-0.2222405225,
-0.1352400184,
-0.3879074752,
-0.3904177248,
0.4247014523,
0.1290613562,
0.2195074558,
0.3376525939,
0.0222957432,
0.3395063877,
0.3773313463,
0.2287740707,
0.356169641,
-0.2492686808,
0.0681153312,
0.2475904524,
-0.6658788919,
-0.3370200992,
0.5076842904,
0.2647040784,
0.7540670037,
-0.0009152182,
0.772167027,
0.275763154,
0.0048364308,
-0.757702291,
0.7562127113,
0.0197206102,
-0.2644409537,
-0.4418379366,
-0.4808875918,
-0.8930095434,
0.3757390976,
0.0552189909,
-1.1860051155,
0.0153072709,
0.3688213825,
-0.3522222936,
0.0437424965,
-0.9315361381,
0.9314960241,
-0.1974995136,
-0.1603371799,
-0.6067702174,
-0.8799046278,
0.2785716355,
0.4121777117,
0.2664685249,
-0.2535063922,
0.3964666724,
0.6680203676,
-0.208792448,
1.1212798357,
-0.4357014894,
0.0478890836,
0.2921797335,
0.1857314855,
0.5145702958,
0.1284217685,
-0.0314203538,
-0.0328125954,
-0.1118535399,
-0.3455806971,
-0.8447378874,
0.6273234487,
-0.7454038262,
-0.6855144501,
-0.2448274195,
-0.8523943424,
-0.2485132217,
-0.0075005256,
-0.0900363624,
0.7280144691,
-0.3631462157,
-0.1959170848,
0.6498317719,
-0.0542878695,
0.5268277526,
0.6272470355,
0.0283781234,
-0.0933046788,
0.6249877214,
-0.1805247962,
0.5628779531,
0.4650355577,
0.1532440484,
-0.2187948525,
-0.4907557368,
-0.3873357177,
0.0915376544,
-0.7262488604,
0.1286372244,
-0.9782087207,
-0.0269987993,
-0.5266365409,
-0.162521556,
-0.2287699431,
-0.309512049,
-0.4517390728,
0.1463075429,
0.3523477018,
0.9636895061,
0.1576546282,
0.5504894257,
-0.8686265945,
0.1270482391,
0.5273709893,
0.2066984922,
0.2336507142,
-0.4423760474,
-0.2129160315,
0.1139545217,
-0.1236249954,
-0.7781533003,
0.3980638683,
0.1717114896,
0.722145617,
0.2706858814,
0.1094419733,
0.8120101094,
-0.5565392375,
0.8225515485,
0.1737010032,
-1.0506899357,
0.6842828393,
-0.2457888573,
0.4703061581,
0.6501005888,
0.1535380483,
-0.7121815085,
-0.2948575616,
-0.7445793748,
-0.68402946,
1.0949364901,
0.0029320826,
-0.026916638,
0.3678767085,
0.2167623639,
0.3339574039,
-0.1125198528,
-0.730969429,
-0.062760897,
0.0737011284,
-0.0335426591,
-0.2588040829,
-0.0797181651,
0.0717821568,
-0.1887287647,
0.5472397208,
-0.1930882484,
0.3044463694,
-0.0021374009,
-0.6998043656,
-0.0429204293,
0.4575566649,
0.461034447,
0.5478323102,
-0.2463754565,
0.008249457,
0.3166713119,
-0.2912491858,
-0.0020501413,
0.0553574376,
0.189260304,
-0.0443702042,
0.4026499689,
1.3449510336,
0.6244664788,
-0.4962900877,
0.5418655276,
-0.2607922554,
0.094203569,
-0.2530064285,
0.0873764157,
0.0694920644,
0.4722341299,
0.1308986396,
-0.1002985388,
0.3856793344,
-0.7477661967,
0.3875516355,
0.3972643614,
-0.5268267393,
-0.4131326079,
0.3729405403,
0.3020470142,
-0.3221751153,
0.390425384,
-0.1898629963,
-0.6635386944,
0.4364624321,
0.3503372073,
0.9047325253,
-0.4036952257,
0.2330087423,
-0.0014641684,
-0.2542425692,
0.1707783937,
0.239261657,
-0.7344740629,
-0.6745532155,
-0.5208974481,
-0.665510416,
-0.6753182411,
-0.0137624089,
-0.8094146848,
0.1788126677,
-0.0179925933,
0.0876056999,
0.0415225662,
0.0226997044,
-0.6765598655,
0.1791302711,
0.3798630238,
0.3358936012,
-1.1315572262,
0.9592981339,
0.5340148211,
-0.065454565,
-0.5331650376,
0.0692889839,
0.1441876739,
-0.7612532377,
0.8294935226,
0.3259670734,
-0.3820400238,
-0.0217571743,
-0.2715607285,
-0.7666642666,
1.0702598095,
0.1188009456,
-0.467662394,
-0.166738838,
0.0164737087,
0.3880244195,
-0.5738594532,
0.507799387,
0.4372997582,
0.0252525881,
0.2874733508,
-1.0767849684,
-0.2111814171,
-0.1574115902,
-0.1139903367,
0.328630507,
-0.4633370042,
0.7483333945,
0.0047469763,
-0.3847256303,
0.0447592065,
0.8815130591,
-0.0314533934,
0.5862648487,
0.9641658068,
0.4900055528,
0.5708780885,
-0.0190612562,
0.773012042,
-0.2955305576,
0.3259073496,
1.5044016838,
-0.4003615081,
0.7526273727,
0.2198570371,
-0.1028131917,
0.4305525422,
0.4875155985,
0.5499265194,
0.4637545049,
-0.3083795011,
-0.5413321257,
-0.3936626315,
-0.3347092569,
-0.0161853191,
0.8697731495,
0.6374967694,
-0.2625002265,
-0.2174642533,
0.1271953434,
-0.0792658851,
-0.1578877419,
-0.1110726073,
1.2020231485,
-0.0445540361,
-0.7762567401,
0.4020364285,
-0.5678321123,
0.4266451597,
-0.4018360674,
0.0495943502,
-0.0759379268,
-0.010768272,
0.113425523,
-0.6514433026,
0.1096611321,
-0.3225036561,
-0.1951253861,
-0.4354440272,
0.7778251171,
-0.7459505796,
-0.1422837973,
0.5353055,
0.5768525004,
0.2373074442,
0.3105017841,
-0.6551843286,
-0.0023987566,
-0.082100369,
-0.1647118926,
0.4197930396,
0.196206063,
0.0546790883,
0.4683474898,
0.2910824418,
-0.1718233228,
-0.1069013849,
0.3834007084,
0.6186745167,
-0.5077605247,
-0.7720241547,
-0.6017301679,
0.5239109993,
-0.1014337614,
0.0806795135,
0.2334973663,
0.1847556531,
0.6755530834,
0.2251345366,
0.7505517006,
0.0060750116,
0.4253570437,
-0.5017446876,
0.5856215358,
-0.6182323098,
0.0491323136,
-0.2613920569,
-0.6824325919,
-0.0547919311,
0.4507280588,
-0.4368344247,
-0.1858159602,
0.3155961633,
0.6292459965,
-0.2465197742,
0.5359255672,
0.4457465708,
0.1710077375,
0.2297503054,
0.5766265392,
0.706597209,
-0.2132053673,
0.2767523825,
-0.4071573615,
-0.1981202662,
-0.3578069508,
-0.6471699476,
-0.8309738636,
-0.8489223123,
-0.2300363183,
-0.059760347,
0.1020281389,
0.9666326642,
0.8366762996,
-0.66388762,
-0.5574916601,
-0.137978822,
0.0462787896,
-0.1392724812,
-0.2741816938,
0.1632943153,
-0.4438082576,
-0.8605101705,
0.6577661037,
0.5060762763,
0.1207026839,
-0.2326712608,
-0.2231758386,
-0.3728228211,
-0.1368124932,
0.5901868939,
0.230872944,
-1.1349688768,
-0.3793021441,
-0.1621362716,
0.0499591753,
0.127286002,
0.9965319037,
-0.8370360136,
0.6989841461,
0.6149658561,
0.570191741,
0.6944869161,
-0.0913842767,
0.931014955,
-0.7795773149,
0.2490981668,
0.2434384078,
0.5380820036,
0.1523882002,
-0.5489271283,
0.309047401,
0.0138801746,
-0.6578781009,
-0.7280282974,
0.4777362943,
-1.2245447636,
-0.2462916523,
0.6579192877,
-0.3365172148,
-0.2032985985,
-0.2557953894,
-0.0387493186,
0.5368258953,
-0.5089339614,
0.4115104675,
0.5205613375,
-0.5799753666,
-0.5378722548,
-0.5411456823,
0.2089200318,
0.7625597119,
-0.7459482551,
0.4088504314,
0.5575634241,
-0.1264657825,
0.1501832455,
0.5925553441,
0.2865431309,
0.3170047104,
-0.170318976,
-0.1224718541,
0.3673066795,
-0.3509679735,
-0.3404760659,
-0.0659156591,
-0.145231396,
0.0086359428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00844v1 | Automated Paper Screening for Clinical Reviews Using Large Language Models | 2023-05-01T14:16:37 | 2023-05-01T14:16:37 | Eddie Guo, Mehul Gupta, Jiawen Deng, Ye-Jean Park, Mike Paget, Christopher Naugler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Objective: To assess the performance of the OpenAI GPT API in accurately and
efficiently identifying relevant titles and abstracts from real-world clinical
review datasets and compare its performance against ground truth labelling by
two independent human reviewers.
Methods: We introduce a novel workflow using the OpenAI GPT API for screening
titles and abstracts in clinical reviews. A Python script was created to make
calls to the GPT API with the screening criteria in natural language and a
corpus of title and abstract datasets that have been filtered by a minimum of
two human reviewers. We compared the performance of our model against
human-reviewed papers across six review papers, screening over 24,000 titles
and abstracts.
Results: Our results show an accuracy of 0.91, a sensitivity of excluded
papers of 0.91, and a sensitivity of included papers of 0.76. On a randomly
selected subset of papers, the GPT API demonstrated the ability to provide
reasoning for its decisions and corrected its initial decision upon being asked
to explain its reasoning for a subset of incorrect classifications.
Conclusion: The GPT API has the potential to streamline the clinical review
process, save valuable time and effort for researchers, and contribute to the
overall quality of clinical reviews. By prioritizing the workflow and acting as
an aid rather than a replacement for researchers and reviewers, the GPT API can
enhance efficiency and lead to more accurate and reliable conclusions in
medical research. | [
-0.1561726928,
-0.4357323349,
0.9787330031,
0.1288610995,
-0.4641217291,
-0.0548809059,
-0.0202911608,
-0.618411839,
0.09158995,
0.5611081123,
-0.130494535,
-0.7915622592,
-0.7749172449,
0.3938503563,
-0.233160466,
1.3778402805,
-0.4150755405,
0.2029391676,
0.0794173554,
-0.0385531671,
-0.1364832819,
-0.2890107632,
-0.5327972174,
-0.5826880932,
0.6470352411,
-0.0683767274,
0.8506419659,
0.4381652176,
0.8652945757,
0.2637112439,
-0.0468195155,
0.0974830166,
-0.0685308054,
-0.077482596,
-0.2306175083,
-0.5196401477,
-0.5921920538,
0.3137672544,
0.3275159299,
0.4441616237,
-0.0494508147,
0.172143966,
-0.0123483054,
0.6932730079,
-0.5801165104,
0.1595870852,
-0.2628281116,
0.0920772702,
-0.0608875938,
-0.2723643482,
-0.2406983376,
-0.6711944938,
0.3796747029,
-0.4502007365,
0.3509602249,
-0.1370141655,
1.059949398,
0.1362262815,
-0.3557579815,
-0.6077524424,
-0.4525661767,
0.5103254318,
-0.8662509322,
0.1499477774,
0.6014514565,
0.4453433156,
0.1849513948,
-0.782271266,
-0.4649043679,
-0.5862690806,
-0.408726722,
0.2484110892,
-0.0120137716,
0.6051981449,
0.1736570448,
0.5601620078,
-0.9260466099,
-0.0459897332,
-0.5769586563,
-0.5853391886,
0.6063102484,
0.0760500059,
0.3402035534,
-0.002179007,
-0.1220319644,
-0.0516121723,
-0.5250655413,
0.0400715508,
0.2907150984,
0.105899781,
-0.0656813905,
0.4700815976,
-0.3847647011,
0.7595235109,
-0.4008351266,
-0.2740409672,
0.2734741569,
-0.3472814262,
-0.3779346645,
0.0997675657,
1.039768815,
0.5543082356,
0.0008928146,
-0.0232753139,
-0.293692559,
0.4296526015,
0.2809525728,
-0.8494974971,
-0.1593361646,
0.6089779735,
-0.7109105587,
-0.393881321,
0.2053079456,
-0.6382288337,
-0.4862235188,
-0.4784724414,
0.2867362201,
-0.1000379995,
-0.0370750278,
0.1730261445,
-0.1012709364,
-0.129019618,
0.5635139346,
-0.4744068682,
0.2953975499,
0.7451735735,
0.9533989429,
-0.3431325555,
-0.1839380711,
-0.4846565425,
-0.1524017006,
-0.3905521333,
0.9486109614,
-0.4093689919,
-0.3032388687,
0.1176277101,
0.0659716949,
-0.2505251765,
-0.3345181346,
0.8474670649,
-0.417086333,
0.1907225698,
-0.0601685643,
-0.2251928896,
-0.025473671,
0.5073384643,
-0.6515206099,
0.342253834,
0.1297463626,
-0.8148024678,
0.551004827,
-0.7327727675,
-0.3264642358,
-0.0034222777,
-0.1566732377,
-0.5355166197,
-0.1272019893,
0.4421650469,
0.0405847542,
-0.4536903501,
0.297929585,
-0.2232846916,
-0.2860246599,
0.1066563353,
-0.1595947146,
0.7105736136,
0.5621268749,
-0.2860090137,
0.384522438,
-0.3920822442,
0.1193821877,
-0.3578869402,
-0.2569362819,
-0.2653155923,
-0.227102831,
0.2205621749,
0.1214362159,
-0.3287656605,
-0.8875812292,
0.2624736726,
-0.2744471729,
0.406757623,
0.4868656993,
0.1928085983,
-0.0104039218,
-0.3773517907,
0.6903881431,
-0.1817099005,
0.3583307266,
-0.1679628342,
-0.8188901544,
-0.2640136778,
-0.309037149,
0.6351684332,
0.5509237647,
-0.4730276763,
0.5461851954,
0.0185435973,
-0.4963878989,
-0.9357726574,
-0.079196468,
0.7648804188,
0.6177840829,
-0.0207392722,
-0.608541429,
-0.4290740788,
-0.942112565,
-0.2011748403,
-0.6484422684,
-0.2257682532,
0.2390634269,
0.6725075841,
-0.49376899,
0.9114025831,
-0.6631554365,
-0.7460218668,
-0.0604973994,
0.5577228069,
0.402392447,
0.2375983298,
0.1505944431,
-0.8166421652,
-0.6213105321,
0.1308264583,
-0.8605544567,
-0.5792238116,
-0.1085473672,
-0.0063305395,
0.3907935917,
0.3579950929,
-0.4549246132,
0.9010429978,
0.4156686664,
-0.3172180653,
0.5016847849,
-0.4609713256,
0.5544970632,
-0.4869720638,
0.3233430684,
0.1094259322,
0.0188139267,
-0.2910548151,
0.0284021497,
0.1170342714,
-0.2214861661,
-0.1725777537,
0.5018501282,
-0.3737387955,
0.2272975743,
-0.39544034,
-0.08658842,
0.1007144302,
0.2355193645,
0.3726136684,
0.6194245815,
0.355712831,
-0.5381225944,
0.0228202175,
0.2534975708,
-0.4308924973,
0.5229145288,
-0.7956952453,
-0.0986499563,
-0.2150471359,
0.537089169,
-1.3145571947,
-0.3288232088,
-0.0766778514,
-0.5728771091,
0.0172750186,
-0.5211946368,
-0.490786612,
-0.7834490538,
-0.2770965099,
0.015123358,
0.4701065421,
-0.3063942492,
0.4982091486,
0.6449937224,
-0.4670210183,
-0.3135549426,
-0.5752848983,
0.1059614867,
0.2664285004,
-0.4593858123,
0.1869740188,
0.1163697019,
-0.2248830646,
-0.1268554032,
-0.062668182,
-0.2863161564,
-0.3892222345,
0.2843707502,
0.2842287719,
-0.0024173523,
-0.0700909495,
0.0247775186,
-0.2357394099,
0.0520056859,
-0.2027947307,
0.3322108984,
-0.2611753941,
-0.5643290877,
-0.7815871239,
0.1907712966,
0.9834798574,
-0.295019269,
0.0887689516,
0.7243958712,
-0.3137932122,
0.2487007529,
-0.6691530943,
-0.2390739918,
-0.3670760691,
0.2679352462,
-0.0985061526,
-0.5402849317,
0.5850228071,
0.5190682411,
0.2444471717,
0.4559033215,
0.8021136522,
-0.0443442389,
1.2303829193,
0.2040944248,
-0.0439078026,
0.071309343,
-0.1417774111,
0.4756605029,
-0.885994792,
0.0626247078,
-0.6617149115,
-0.34074229,
-0.6500264406,
-0.2928813696,
0.7048293948,
-0.3755886853,
-0.0532592833,
-0.0608539321,
-0.8243539929,
0.4631186426,
0.5725325346,
0.3151369095,
0.5061056614,
0.025768064,
-0.2775065899,
-0.072626844,
-0.1226460412,
-0.8021356463,
1.5718728304,
0.5128709674,
0.7135264874,
-0.283041209,
0.6025980115,
0.5054973364,
0.9344775081,
-0.503021121,
0.3575837612,
0.0188425891,
-0.8073968887,
-0.1777804345,
-0.170587182,
-0.8919269443,
0.4118911624,
-0.0064345472,
-0.6426721215,
0.024103038,
0.0132576674,
-0.681943655,
0.4623993337,
-0.6440357566,
0.6902840137,
-0.3209477961,
-0.3874871433,
0.0722078532,
-0.5797245502,
0.5037700534,
-0.0944740921,
0.1309017986,
-0.0420921594,
-0.0628675371,
0.7933401465,
-0.7919354439,
0.7857145667,
-0.2675905228,
-0.105558455,
0.5280461311,
-0.0033688315,
0.2099552006,
0.4172895551,
0.118378453,
0.2894530594,
0.2689840198,
-0.1643660963,
-0.2823204994,
0.5870064497,
-0.8009393215,
-0.40156129,
-0.8548140526,
-0.450453639,
-0.1644551158,
0.3465685844,
0.3321789801,
0.3684924543,
-0.0171117336,
-0.1376240253,
0.2356902659,
-0.2733281255,
0.030102076,
0.7829536796,
-0.2986586988,
-0.785367012,
0.5223886967,
-0.0253139641,
0.1106406003,
0.3828116953,
0.456489116,
-0.5643038154,
-1.0209296942,
-0.5014429092,
0.2728226483,
-0.3022662997,
-0.0280761216,
-1.0321432352,
0.0607336089,
-0.563229382,
0.2624026239,
-0.1682237089,
-0.0710691139,
0.4397230744,
0.0638825446,
0.0647628605,
0.6185302138,
-0.0143333115,
0.3986210227,
-0.7858248949,
0.4913616776,
0.2497048825,
0.652669847,
-0.303365916,
-0.4346236885,
0.08919359,
-0.0276919026,
-0.521224618,
-0.7634304166,
0.4391881526,
-0.1241886541,
0.494579494,
0.5180733204,
0.1353037208,
0.4406236112,
-0.2733457386,
0.7333496213,
-0.0392674394,
-0.5162476897,
0.6360709667,
-0.6418012977,
0.3319991529,
0.9806733131,
0.4917064607,
-0.523139894,
-0.4738368988,
-0.2701179683,
-0.9337029457,
0.8695783019,
0.3793359995,
-0.6051238775,
0.1772399396,
0.1112873629,
0.2127196789,
0.272618562,
-0.523308754,
0.0825451836,
0.2404040396,
-0.0124665005,
-0.0944470838,
-0.1738684475,
-0.5553423762,
-0.104191564,
0.7467119694,
-0.2929287553,
0.5718406439,
0.8180418611,
-0.0408166572,
-0.1797602922,
0.2627832294,
0.5385216475,
0.782993257,
-0.6589872837,
-0.140233323,
-0.5683452487,
-1.1122910976,
-0.0632627457,
0.4194185734,
-0.4136478901,
0.1771405339,
0.3476977646,
0.5546226501,
-0.3452636898,
-0.709807694,
0.4117256105,
-0.4928310215,
-0.4760571122,
-0.2649825811,
-0.3273329735,
-0.3508439064,
-0.1651951671,
0.2783535719,
0.0665426329,
0.44387725,
-0.4892838001,
0.3732961714,
0.2041544914,
-0.5874137282,
-0.1037367731,
0.6716911793,
0.056056045,
-0.1705566496,
0.6958153844,
-0.0788435265,
-0.4108962715,
0.7472608089,
0.2402387708,
1.1466035843,
-0.0675586239,
0.2792862356,
0.5560234189,
0.4535714388,
-0.1187487468,
0.2847919166,
0.0700099021,
-0.2168491632,
-0.4763436317,
-0.6315992475,
-0.9669436216,
0.3580678403,
-0.62113446,
0.1911389679,
-0.4113092422,
-0.3697685301,
0.1747941673,
0.0162179265,
-0.2624775767,
0.3852866888,
0.2331267148,
0.9180481434,
-1.0203388929,
0.6083180308,
0.8562170863,
-0.666795969,
-0.5727721453,
0.0040621543,
0.2760056257,
-0.5106278658,
0.2859161794,
0.4181176722,
0.1441749185,
-0.5688475966,
-0.2258161455,
-0.584474206,
0.8833777308,
-0.0546955615,
-0.3556423187,
-0.0872800276,
0.261252135,
1.0395767689,
-0.3231891692,
0.998416543,
0.7333868146,
0.4908659458,
0.1037823483,
-1.439170599,
-0.2150453329,
-0.5550913811,
-0.2718708515,
0.0503483079,
-0.1895183623,
0.7058774233,
-0.2700638771,
-0.0549528077,
0.2470637262,
0.1653767377,
0.5623480678,
0.8167644143,
0.560968101,
0.5712788701,
0.7476879358,
-0.3334327638,
1.2984926701,
-0.3846419156,
0.2218783796,
0.8361048102,
-0.6959300041,
0.5572239161,
0.366174072,
-0.4210872948,
0.3572660089,
0.7651721835,
0.1529242545,
0.6169966459,
0.2270934135,
-0.131152615,
-0.0198817253,
-0.0488970093,
-0.4978156984,
0.1473100334,
0.3330205083,
-0.5959995389,
-0.3781661689,
0.1911132485,
-0.1234122589,
0.0801441893,
-0.4203610718,
0.7751434445,
-0.1458775252,
-1.3315632343,
0.8094614148,
-0.0602671281,
0.6165191531,
-0.7552633882,
-0.0128789339,
-0.1948960274,
0.6657525301,
-0.4935981333,
-0.8381781578,
0.3165819645,
0.1088279262,
0.109879598,
-0.2393752933,
0.5101422668,
-0.3429811299,
-0.4169668555,
0.0677134246,
0.231901288,
0.3440130353,
-0.2664680481,
-0.7747701406,
0.1425312459,
-0.0020486638,
-0.1958940476,
0.3640889525,
0.082382068,
-0.4537898004,
0.4845341742,
0.8770292401,
0.4120679498,
-0.2811298966,
0.1397321969,
0.6698434353,
-0.3730119467,
-1.1068427563,
-0.6254759431,
0.2330439091,
-0.1566211879,
-0.448412627,
0.2307082415,
0.7164496779,
0.54482162,
-0.2456520349,
1.0754987001,
-0.0785379782,
0.8780226707,
-0.3116735816,
1.11148417,
-0.1627012342,
0.0347858779,
-0.4111307859,
-0.5410443544,
-0.6938838363,
0.5377104878,
-0.6507777572,
-0.0939075574,
1.0074926615,
0.9084465504,
0.1312973052,
0.3091872633,
0.1069591492,
0.1455135792,
0.6519421339,
0.5888690352,
0.458026737,
-0.4690947831,
0.4236198664,
-0.200602904,
-0.6558371186,
-0.142526269,
-0.8417961001,
-0.9201601744,
-0.3329957128,
-0.517108202,
-0.7491326332,
0.2869916558,
0.8370469809,
0.7654092312,
-1.1428533792,
-0.1400458366,
-0.1244522408,
0.0422888845,
-0.341068089,
-0.1608724892,
0.7484739423,
-0.2991786301,
-0.7877023816,
-0.051761765,
0.3210695982,
-0.2924907207,
-0.0277901776,
-0.1752395183,
-0.1036244556,
-0.3443606198,
0.2899549603,
0.4548724592,
-0.6542136669,
0.2790835202,
-0.1657656431,
-0.4240520895,
-0.0137057332,
1.111651659,
-0.6742072701,
0.841907084,
0.7726792693,
0.4527539313,
0.3545404673,
-0.1298794746,
0.5153054595,
0.01823234,
0.0412149653,
0.5568457842,
0.4857833982,
-0.0412545055,
-0.2101369798,
0.7352381945,
0.3261417449,
-0.7513159513,
-1.0810790062,
-0.0852681324,
-0.9299454093,
0.1676132381,
1.1341882944,
-0.149916932,
-0.359929204,
-0.5582627654,
-0.6192843914,
-0.0178047493,
-0.4254931808,
1.0374028683,
0.5350337029,
-0.2471953481,
0.2199945152,
-0.7884920835,
0.6144343615,
0.1221617982,
-0.7609698176,
0.0355877839,
0.3375865519,
0.1945512742,
0.4124644995,
1.0477825403,
-0.7765569687,
0.7353884578,
-0.4157977104,
0.2948305607,
-0.151750654,
0.0487212576,
-0.4445953965,
0.2349334061,
-0.0901068449,
-0.1496113092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00833v2 | Learning to Reason and Memorize with Self-Notes | 2023-05-01T14:02:48 | 2023-10-31T04:06:28 | Jack Lanchantin, Shubham Toshniwal, Jason Weston, Arthur Szlam, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models have been shown to struggle with multi-step reasoning,
and do not retain previous reasoning steps for future use. We propose a simple
method for solving both of these problems by allowing the model to take
Self-Notes. Unlike recent chain-of-thought or scratchpad approaches, the model
can deviate from the input context at any time to explicitly think and write
down its thoughts. This allows the model to perform reasoning on the fly as it
reads the context and even integrate previous reasoning steps, thus enhancing
its memory with useful information and enabling multi-step reasoning.
Experiments across a wide variety of tasks demonstrate that our method can
outperform chain-of-thought and scratchpad methods by taking Self-Notes that
interleave the input text. | [
-0.195000276,
-0.8780993819,
1.1715204716,
0.3522063792,
-0.1686913073,
-0.2094605118,
-0.0069723772,
-0.1599759609,
0.1398220658,
0.8804004788,
-0.731795609,
-0.1219943911,
-0.2196545154,
-0.1063741148,
-0.3474918306,
0.9915194511,
-0.2478216887,
0.1243744045,
-0.2768774927,
-0.0204088856,
-0.3428687751,
-0.7401478887,
-0.8009495735,
-0.2701852024,
0.7720771432,
0.6463614106,
-0.0776349157,
0.5349402428,
0.488835007,
0.3099010885,
-0.0181793999,
0.2036582083,
-0.0776693895,
0.4493600428,
-0.5395906568,
-0.4803943932,
-0.5588405728,
0.2501591146,
0.4083787501,
0.3692250252,
-0.1946260929,
0.1644897014,
-0.2844754159,
0.6470708847,
-0.4091916084,
0.1114044189,
-0.2928554714,
0.0291830301,
-0.0103803296,
-0.4162529111,
-0.8234700561,
-0.0988356397,
-0.1730758101,
-0.5534930825,
-0.0792483091,
-0.2597577274,
0.2674522102,
0.1597809792,
-0.4608348906,
-0.558767736,
-0.8429976702,
0.7070410848,
-0.6291658878,
0.2486085445,
0.5341442823,
0.4106098413,
-0.1088699102,
-0.8397615552,
-0.6664164662,
-0.408141762,
0.00857177,
0.1650612503,
0.5157372952,
-0.1135161892,
0.6490302682,
0.2205037028,
-0.127044037,
-0.5099161267,
-0.5351058841,
-0.08861655,
0.4809343815,
0.1259025335,
0.3881128132,
-0.1666088253,
-0.5527421236,
-0.2565015256,
-0.5973656178,
0.0323097743,
-0.0242756177,
0.4142558575,
0.2443079352,
0.4503692687,
-0.0610706285,
0.5500495434,
0.0878115222,
-0.4062840343,
-0.0019120133,
-0.3189332783,
-0.2392328829,
-0.0821190551,
0.5731301308,
0.0214762427,
0.1770920306,
0.0698022693,
-0.1338327378,
-0.2489527315,
0.3940352798,
-0.7926226854,
-0.6403397322,
0.3067970276,
-0.4251613319,
0.103477858,
-0.4711141884,
-0.8445295691,
-0.3250919878,
-0.5732437372,
0.8497110009,
-0.4577331543,
-0.0622119717,
0.2171711326,
-0.1627909988,
-0.1807550937,
1.0160115957,
-1.021732688,
0.4163747132,
0.3311520219,
0.728339076,
0.3703941703,
-0.6774682999,
-0.6053733826,
0.2632796168,
-0.4729277492,
0.981227994,
-0.451803416,
-0.2382221073,
-0.4931975305,
-0.218897596,
-0.2983045578,
-0.3680784404,
0.505087018,
-0.040294949,
0.4339975119,
-0.4340174794,
-0.738081038,
-0.5057442188,
0.358294189,
-0.6981808543,
0.9611491561,
-0.1131682992,
-0.6883603334,
0.0741505027,
-0.7103014588,
-0.6103859544,
-0.3695952892,
-0.0561853014,
-0.2886978984,
0.2914456725,
0.3072815835,
0.5679422021,
0.044523973,
-0.007273817,
-0.4784543514,
-0.0309007969,
0.1183653176,
-0.385877192,
0.7936928272,
0.1275955439,
-0.3054741919,
0.113775678,
-0.7758600116,
-0.0149940345,
0.3331227303,
-0.7039527297,
-0.4795978963,
0.2493956536,
-0.3228259981,
1.0005866289,
0.0226141028,
-0.3058858216,
0.6133458614,
0.0759030432,
0.6414297223,
0.441611737,
-0.054768458,
0.3140247762,
-0.2758723497,
0.3375694454,
0.366771549,
-0.004969052,
-0.9304813147,
-0.1341923624,
-1.1923868656,
-0.0299237706,
0.074418582,
0.5314773321,
-0.4135549366,
-0.0417877883,
0.2808442116,
-0.4189824462,
-0.5433285832,
0.4180333912,
0.4000330567,
0.7874959111,
0.8240184188,
-0.0113405343,
-0.4343474805,
-0.4898417294,
-0.4417451024,
-0.0451596379,
0.472458899,
0.1831165403,
0.8856230974,
0.0478473939,
0.4705573916,
-0.3456079364,
-0.1615775824,
-0.3997564018,
0.4593452811,
-0.219655633,
0.7398452759,
0.0041852999,
-0.5011898875,
-0.3115904927,
-0.2676416636,
-0.6289936304,
0.2269352376,
-0.6904096007,
-0.1556631625,
0.0979118571,
1.0531059504,
-0.7956174612,
0.3076006472,
0.0018981544,
-0.4614407122,
0.34613958,
-0.5916082859,
0.0186841562,
-1.1450748444,
0.1235435978,
-0.1305613369,
-0.4090834558,
-0.6769241691,
0.0451548733,
0.4444512129,
0.1051058471,
-0.1884944588,
0.6505830884,
-0.5602744222,
0.2589484453,
-0.3575039506,
0.2001768202,
0.3087937832,
0.4021359384,
0.2063804865,
0.4368418753,
0.3317638636,
-0.6525821686,
-0.1045592949,
0.0249535292,
-0.3076702654,
0.3725783229,
-0.3006612957,
0.5479773283,
-0.1932984591,
0.4705754519,
-0.9262641668,
-0.0365147516,
0.2071731389,
-0.2819422781,
0.4518575072,
0.0730489567,
-0.2557053864,
-0.5634217262,
-0.057563249,
0.2970688939,
0.0903404579,
-0.7622772455,
1.0706669092,
0.29160586,
-0.2000305653,
-0.6103510857,
-0.6621891856,
0.0413028933,
-0.4553902447,
-0.2324756533,
-0.0618258789,
-0.4062387049,
-0.2306969315,
-0.4485221207,
-0.2998753488,
-0.1658698618,
0.3397842944,
0.0659024939,
0.0377980508,
-0.0525242202,
0.3810434937,
-0.0161181372,
-0.043957267,
0.2828190327,
-0.4676816165,
0.4584135115,
-0.0550601259,
-0.2301217765,
-0.3391316831,
0.5327473283,
0.8489599824,
-0.3637210131,
0.309607774,
0.0834767893,
-0.3545571864,
-0.7341158986,
-0.6522253156,
-0.2185781598,
-0.432323575,
0.0026524821,
-0.6082879901,
-0.6398912072,
0.3918611407,
-0.3373429179,
0.0788704529,
0.2402205318,
0.4364702702,
-0.5689777732,
0.9694093466,
0.4744707644,
0.1638429761,
0.2238999307,
-0.1018191501,
0.5759354234,
-0.9570502043,
-0.310660243,
-0.4900775254,
-0.0091189286,
-0.0458827652,
-0.8016949296,
-0.1483071148,
0.4884750247,
-0.3074045777,
0.2161364704,
-0.4022588432,
0.602324903,
0.7847880125,
0.0580633394,
0.2974052131,
-0.3098191023,
-0.4483950138,
0.1274905801,
-0.4535010159,
-0.4025846422,
1.0054706335,
0.2822322845,
0.8299797177,
-0.2325646877,
1.1930857897,
-0.1125286669,
0.2357321084,
-0.7023499608,
0.7130258083,
-0.0145832179,
-0.8044923544,
-0.5460148454,
-0.4313854873,
-0.4565033913,
0.6682358384,
0.2259244025,
-0.7657504678,
-0.0672861189,
0.623493731,
-0.4714150727,
0.3224247694,
-0.6940765381,
1.0200966597,
-0.4197694659,
-0.3968907297,
-0.4523510635,
-0.5919627547,
0.6093665957,
0.090077728,
0.4148168266,
0.0043682796,
0.3672274649,
0.664979279,
-0.4951417744,
0.8988422751,
-0.1383575499,
-0.0726647899,
0.6338970065,
0.4711302817,
0.3860366344,
-0.2574414611,
0.3559179604,
-0.4485922158,
-0.1227245927,
-0.1080087721,
-0.7939972878,
0.6260480285,
-0.2890975475,
-0.8629146814,
-0.492880255,
-0.5399380922,
-0.0052968222,
0.4888001382,
-0.1191617548,
0.4072283804,
-0.0193464626,
-0.1950019896,
0.6950747371,
0.1431268156,
0.8125525117,
0.568856895,
-0.519677341,
-0.5621070266,
0.8233534098,
0.2780848742,
0.4101605117,
0.3161007464,
0.4528301358,
-0.5132265091,
-0.0943608657,
-0.3691188097,
0.4193007052,
-1.2477831841,
0.1407893747,
-0.9871762395,
0.0428611971,
-0.2981569171,
-0.1014615521,
-0.5369995236,
-0.8718222976,
0.0632969514,
-0.256300658,
0.0559331737,
0.7216008902,
-0.2579143941,
0.0114535354,
-0.5550748706,
0.5485187769,
0.6361398697,
0.064055711,
0.3999993503,
-0.3344193995,
-0.1906544715,
-0.2500687242,
-0.5227116346,
-0.7430536151,
0.3798370361,
-0.1291776001,
0.3669880629,
0.3208023012,
-0.2542628348,
0.9743081927,
-0.736859858,
0.4633617997,
0.1783822775,
-1.3140106201,
1.0404829979,
-0.265645802,
0.3627283871,
0.687754333,
0.2104191184,
-0.5638511777,
-0.2126656771,
-0.6364833713,
-0.6873582602,
0.6746650338,
-0.2286394984,
-0.1160660461,
-0.0949386582,
0.389285773,
-0.1147431359,
0.135494113,
-1.1941052675,
-0.0261654425,
-0.4639450014,
0.0943401605,
-0.2815057337,
-0.203925088,
-0.1572255939,
-0.6673349142,
0.5881478786,
-0.2630475461,
0.035421811,
0.468734175,
-0.0911093131,
-0.0046165516,
0.2492262572,
0.9034740329,
0.6246240139,
0.0361373685,
0.5800376534,
0.1066428572,
-0.3201791942,
0.1655007154,
-0.1699590385,
-0.2493069768,
-0.1686828136,
0.1679148525,
0.6105564237,
0.3930135667,
-0.569506824,
0.3419709504,
-0.0063818442,
-0.3187720776,
-0.3400893807,
0.0291078165,
0.6906480193,
0.1668373197,
-0.1996839792,
0.0770351514,
0.2683591843,
-0.8582658172,
0.2226004899,
0.1062158272,
-0.309253484,
-0.1985647529,
0.6751811504,
0.0158464406,
-0.3460601568,
0.7532110214,
0.1154807955,
-0.6282242537,
0.7180663347,
1.0460852385,
0.9542606473,
-0.6634305716,
0.240646407,
0.6860120296,
0.3105354309,
-0.7210475206,
0.5810549855,
-0.4754185081,
-0.3912853003,
-0.4628848135,
-0.2917183936,
-0.595516026,
0.20108518,
-0.6632161736,
0.1431786716,
-0.7352011204,
0.049987711,
0.2351727337,
-0.2810854316,
-0.2897492051,
0.7177228928,
0.2272159755,
1.0006359816,
-0.7462273836,
1.1442562342,
0.4904477596,
-0.7067563534,
-1.0208975077,
0.0547239371,
-0.029457774,
-0.4321324229,
0.5133681893,
0.7089774013,
-0.2266162485,
-0.2796295583,
-0.4432424903,
-0.9745770097,
0.7324792147,
-0.0090399887,
-0.5389519334,
-0.1011979505,
-0.3334680498,
0.3273983896,
-0.3303598166,
0.4117181599,
0.6068718433,
0.5195763707,
0.1458378881,
-0.5817913413,
0.090775542,
-0.2153059542,
-0.4783978462,
0.3063930273,
-0.9343609214,
1.4587088823,
-0.6307150126,
-0.0763203353,
-0.2992863655,
0.4591385424,
0.2613920569,
0.4903233945,
0.3811224401,
0.8582991362,
1.0602229834,
0.229592368,
0.9639365673,
-0.0873866752,
0.3454899788,
1.6972596645,
-0.349601835,
1.0835416317,
0.7097072601,
0.2343752831,
0.7819600701,
0.2204590589,
0.1005851775,
0.4589467347,
0.263643235,
-0.2888506353,
-0.7714084387,
0.6142882109,
0.1319820732,
0.5479287505,
0.5503091812,
-0.3250190616,
-0.2271398902,
-0.0073967148,
0.3932671845,
0.1939440221,
-0.518191278,
0.7593182325,
0.4270824492,
-1.3576200008,
0.2781306505,
-0.1641471237,
-0.0992526859,
-0.5294038057,
-0.2950876057,
-0.1518443227,
0.492089659,
0.0766132697,
-0.5056598186,
0.2551569045,
-0.1639630347,
-0.2532734871,
-0.4881727695,
0.5803841352,
-0.6346851587,
-0.6848850846,
0.5019749999,
0.476814419,
0.1898982823,
0.0008266456,
-0.6044483185,
-0.3258850574,
-0.1237313002,
-0.4099865854,
0.3160088658,
0.5026521087,
-0.0749434754,
1.0967119932,
0.2920241952,
-0.133279562,
0.0722082779,
0.115156278,
0.6965050697,
-1.3723258972,
-0.647832334,
-1.1108586788,
0.6422522068,
-0.2708579302,
-0.5512310863,
0.8509749174,
0.4840068519,
0.7981727123,
-0.1215240732,
0.9101343155,
0.2404301763,
0.8512040377,
-0.7610584497,
0.4198167622,
-0.5513708591,
-0.1098896861,
-0.3165546656,
-0.4297907948,
-0.2324372679,
1.1580779552,
-0.1583700925,
-0.0309360269,
1.3065932989,
0.3045990467,
-0.0333432965,
0.1242511645,
0.1490084827,
0.211286217,
0.3958400786,
0.8098424673,
1.015900135,
-0.2928577065,
0.2644912601,
-0.4254362285,
0.1188106313,
-0.0657666028,
-0.9851492047,
-1.3172818422,
-0.5613356829,
-0.3725203276,
-0.4268881083,
-0.2766728103,
0.7565872073,
0.6835657954,
-0.7706796527,
-0.3468164504,
-0.3439984322,
0.2358701229,
-0.3312744498,
-0.1217411384,
0.2926145792,
-0.7419505715,
-0.4682119787,
0.8143869042,
0.650428772,
0.2352360785,
-0.3438092768,
0.1876365244,
-0.3958471119,
0.6094570756,
0.5076774359,
0.3795425892,
-0.8691667318,
-0.3286528289,
-0.2079673111,
-0.1021446362,
0.3055792153,
1.3351050615,
-0.6747232676,
0.7675936818,
0.5045312643,
0.2838808596,
0.832219243,
0.0933407471,
0.4756957591,
-0.01315061,
-0.1097877771,
0.2959324121,
0.5192520618,
0.2809622288,
-0.2744965255,
0.2134564668,
0.0019928503,
-0.6656709909,
-0.5775948763,
0.1679871827,
-1.063801527,
-0.693972528,
0.7099396586,
-0.4409445226,
-0.1814565659,
-0.0342205092,
-0.3525661528,
0.0104377288,
-0.0841878727,
1.1050378084,
0.9246608019,
-0.2934710383,
-0.4776774943,
-0.5125467181,
0.6284108758,
0.5997571349,
-1.0246249437,
0.3868005276,
0.5275352001,
0.3920223713,
0.3134697676,
1.0760430098,
-0.0543727539,
0.4233029783,
0.3137429357,
-0.0035116167,
0.1221431866,
-1.1292937994,
-0.4187755287,
0.2898035347,
-0.0968415141,
0.0318467468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00633v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00633v3 | Self-Evaluation Guided Beam Search for Reasoning | 2023-05-01T02:37:59 | 2023-10-26T01:43:17 | Yuxi Xie, Kenji Kawaguchi, Yiran Zhao, Xu Zhao, Min-Yen Kan, Junxian He, Qizhe Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Breaking down a problem into intermediate steps has demonstrated impressive
performance in Large Language Model (LLM) reasoning. However, the growth of the
reasoning chain introduces uncertainty and error accumulation, making it
challenging to elicit accurate final results. To tackle this challenge of
uncertainty in multi-step reasoning, we introduce a stepwise self-evaluation
mechanism to guide and calibrate the reasoning process of LLMs. We propose a
decoding algorithm integrating the self-evaluation guidance via stochastic beam
search. The self-evaluation guidance serves as a better-calibrated automatic
criterion, facilitating an efficient search in the reasoning space and
resulting in superior prediction quality. Stochastic beam search balances
exploitation and exploration of the search space with temperature-controlled
randomness. Our approach surpasses the corresponding Codex-backboned baselines
in few-shot accuracy by $6.34\%$, $9.56\%$, and $5.46\%$ on the GSM8K, AQuA,
and StrategyQA benchmarks, respectively. Experiment results with Llama-2 on
arithmetic reasoning demonstrate the efficiency of our method in outperforming
the baseline methods with comparable computational budgets. Further analysis in
multi-step reasoning finds our self-evaluation guidance pinpoints logic
failures and leads to higher consistency and robustness. Our code is publicly
available at https://guideddecoding.github.io/. | [
0.0960094035,
-0.5260478258,
1.1492486,
0.4145007133,
-0.2906049192,
0.0349673145,
0.1455960125,
0.1490364075,
-0.1311832964,
0.4432899356,
-0.8406693339,
-0.7500492334,
-0.6534674764,
0.0589309856,
-0.001696297,
0.4127032757,
-0.3140025437,
0.243577823,
0.0644118935,
0.1679590791,
-0.4380384684,
0.0069086393,
-0.5884218216,
-0.4952812493,
0.2384761125,
0.2865454853,
0.6050104499,
0.74262923,
0.5497546196,
0.2835073769,
-0.0002695874,
0.4427171648,
-0.3394455314,
0.1709280908,
-0.3349342346,
-0.3632766008,
-0.2796444297,
-0.2356155962,
0.3974223435,
0.1351958066,
-0.6024721861,
0.2301632166,
-0.3561863899,
0.7709314823,
-0.6400367618,
0.3713917434,
-0.4407033324,
0.0775721744,
-0.1700010896,
-0.6909723282,
-0.6024751663,
-0.2015956491,
-0.3808771968,
-0.3611451685,
-0.128844291,
0.1705656946,
0.3081827164,
0.7489863634,
-0.5037680864,
-0.5933202505,
-0.4828404188,
0.9645550847,
-0.9709311724,
0.5883767605,
0.5046095252,
0.3453448415,
-0.6424615979,
-0.4721207619,
-0.1452119499,
-0.1737304181,
0.1359584183,
0.1889611632,
-0.1280422807,
0.2902848423,
0.061687693,
0.0617152937,
-0.7608655095,
-0.1777721196,
-0.2677577436,
-0.4478580654,
0.7145494819,
0.2255070359,
0.0021064105,
-0.4152378738,
-0.2130495012,
-0.2085516006,
-0.4818298519,
-0.0623499714,
0.3957128823,
0.1605335176,
0.2506252527,
0.432426095,
-0.5168491006,
0.5794563293,
0.3465589583,
-0.4025431275,
0.2478238791,
-0.6013630629,
-0.2696157694,
0.2172941715,
0.8330535889,
0.2166873217,
-0.1698670685,
0.2337627262,
-0.1962310672,
-0.1962751448,
0.2511564791,
-0.7735562921,
-0.2977516055,
0.388502866,
-0.445648104,
-0.1597478688,
-0.3739110231,
-0.428881973,
-0.1562063992,
-0.100243181,
0.4919098616,
-0.6043199301,
0.0725801885,
0.4892362654,
0.1610353142,
0.1235221773,
0.535274744,
-0.7048930526,
-0.2380703688,
0.6030601263,
0.6512833834,
0.2141528279,
-0.3139512241,
-0.5361877084,
0.0174779184,
-0.7507701516,
0.7376585603,
-0.656647861,
-0.3416912556,
-0.4013044536,
-0.4489724636,
-0.0467291325,
-0.2007562518,
0.8251732588,
-0.7193257809,
-0.0794785172,
-0.0551600605,
-0.5540627241,
-0.1954711676,
0.1468796283,
-0.3176933527,
1.1417051554,
-0.2249017954,
-0.6023011208,
0.2491451502,
-0.3837732673,
-0.2286024094,
-0.0283375755,
-0.4059498012,
-0.2789486945,
0.2407131046,
0.5885020494,
0.379476279,
-0.2713974118,
0.3285418451,
-0.4746331275,
-0.5726766586,
-0.1272493154,
-0.538282156,
0.703305006,
0.6064466238,
-0.4117295742,
0.1457671076,
-0.7667759061,
0.4192929268,
0.0858394578,
-0.3966338933,
-0.1346267909,
0.1742474139,
-0.9699723125,
0.2028576881,
0.3608736992,
-0.3182561994,
0.2182409316,
-0.6012147069,
0.2227827311,
0.844127059,
0.0746691003,
0.4098148346,
0.0247785412,
0.4606073499,
0.1002238616,
0.2307020873,
-0.4568191171,
-0.5065933466,
-0.5610175729,
-0.1107175797,
-0.1041081175,
0.5382602811,
-0.8042106628,
0.3804565668,
0.0749958977,
-0.6670159698,
-0.7629051208,
0.4087074399,
0.5744365454,
0.3666813374,
0.5588184595,
0.0667460933,
-0.4398826361,
-0.6992781758,
-0.1697913408,
-0.2115702331,
0.0437594987,
0.0682084337,
0.4187193513,
-0.3686969876,
0.6163439751,
-0.4000510275,
-0.1624563485,
0.0040980834,
0.5192500949,
0.6120709777,
0.3657422066,
-0.0162004866,
-0.3739048839,
-0.1824649721,
-0.2228592485,
-0.9188694358,
-0.150084123,
-0.3002215028,
-0.3327126205,
-0.0108117843,
0.6325727105,
-0.5531783104,
0.5168428421,
0.6143422127,
-0.159909144,
0.6474669576,
-0.5818191767,
0.3467640579,
-0.8116798401,
-0.402659446,
-0.0718140602,
0.1018969119,
-0.3749786615,
0.3233722448,
0.3024216592,
0.385630548,
-0.2656078935,
0.3340006471,
-0.5354026556,
-0.0547097288,
-0.4180758595,
-0.0028579012,
0.1452216059,
0.3047541082,
-0.1285843253,
0.8137497306,
0.501655817,
-0.4572286904,
0.5541043878,
0.0002234934,
-0.4915333092,
0.4029091895,
-0.3995317817,
0.3030897677,
-0.2154596895,
0.5348492265,
-0.9142667055,
0.1131800339,
0.320379138,
-0.3117240965,
0.2368930131,
-0.196821332,
-0.4668982029,
-0.4666555524,
-0.2863140404,
0.6518335342,
-0.0433856919,
-0.5867564678,
0.7416123748,
-0.0369529389,
-0.0051146643,
-0.7802319527,
-0.4846641123,
0.0669658333,
0.1059174538,
-0.7741026282,
-0.0338482261,
-0.4350330532,
-0.0974718481,
-0.4606655538,
-0.4771600962,
0.2944064438,
0.047083389,
0.157674104,
0.1650584042,
-0.1686619371,
0.0522524267,
0.2044318169,
-0.3490391672,
0.2790129781,
-0.576403141,
0.5082237124,
-0.3854359984,
-0.8813554645,
-0.3392477334,
0.1220940724,
0.1849035025,
-0.0979885161,
0.1843053252,
0.5259879827,
-0.1198109463,
-0.4168208539,
-0.649199307,
-0.1464300156,
-0.5640067458,
0.3502012789,
-0.8337420821,
-0.6995851398,
0.3168382347,
-0.0049835318,
-0.1728790253,
0.3681187928,
0.6564431787,
-0.2520033419,
1.2849968672,
0.2805744708,
0.3272331059,
-0.093989931,
0.0010292098,
0.5675674081,
-0.7003036737,
-0.1603830457,
-0.3565099239,
-0.0557500087,
-0.4450856149,
-0.9464389682,
0.297725141,
0.1305350661,
-0.3227415681,
0.1688839048,
-0.6342208385,
0.489773035,
0.6490559578,
0.184521541,
0.4303432107,
-0.2676972747,
-0.4515203834,
-0.2272864282,
-0.5768193007,
-0.3271703124,
1.0429093838,
0.4254059792,
1.3384032249,
-0.060974896,
1.1465175152,
0.1764871925,
0.0809301734,
-0.7320267558,
0.5612065792,
0.1592071354,
-0.6182886958,
-0.4598630369,
-0.8800175786,
-0.4496695399,
0.3511309922,
0.4096369445,
-0.7362530828,
0.1208819449,
0.0494716018,
-0.2814928889,
0.1427594423,
-0.4063849747,
0.6277454495,
-0.5969592333,
-0.2105328292,
-0.4579698145,
-0.5534815192,
0.3776026964,
-0.2506717443,
0.4862724543,
-0.4477260411,
0.3211196661,
0.6368144751,
-0.2045292407,
0.4716094732,
-0.1104100794,
-0.2708150446,
0.2943234146,
0.630882144,
0.7387686372,
-0.0219652951,
-0.4899672866,
0.1566689163,
0.2497448772,
-0.3728033006,
-0.5788158178,
0.6228672266,
-0.5112169981,
-0.9076244235,
-0.602208674,
-0.5234003067,
-0.2900775671,
0.2851929963,
0.210416168,
0.1642433852,
0.1615368575,
-0.0265264064,
0.5893860459,
-0.0634597987,
0.3094795048,
0.5338405371,
-0.2373480499,
-0.3527930677,
0.8108580709,
-0.135197714,
0.0958634242,
0.4729100168,
0.324514091,
-0.549069941,
-0.7903875709,
-0.6921909451,
0.3096948266,
-1.1169984341,
-0.4681366384,
-0.202305153,
-0.1876853555,
-0.4198147953,
-0.2486244589,
-0.564086616,
-0.0692831576,
-0.1705884039,
-0.3671042919,
-0.1051496491,
0.7107222676,
-0.3330099583,
0.0988032594,
-0.8076761961,
0.0997337103,
0.3282111287,
0.2787733078,
-0.0720011964,
-0.8085368276,
-0.2167071402,
0.045913931,
-0.1601693779,
-0.8018228412,
0.475438118,
-0.0194648858,
0.6797075868,
0.422098428,
0.2302063853,
0.9105455279,
-0.4164833724,
0.2829922736,
0.2808562517,
-1.0143065453,
0.8875507116,
-0.2658063769,
0.6153214574,
0.6519581079,
0.144669041,
-0.0622575097,
-0.5399300456,
-0.4157876074,
-0.7849079967,
0.8631828427,
0.1192494333,
-0.1442296207,
0.1712889373,
0.2176024616,
-0.2044977546,
0.0671289712,
-0.4592601061,
-0.3047610223,
-0.2821838558,
-0.3350525796,
0.0407167077,
-0.4171167314,
-0.323336184,
0.024014717,
0.7592239976,
-0.4457720518,
0.1534232944,
0.2499029189,
-0.0377140157,
-0.3757936954,
0.4112361372,
0.4871968627,
0.661677599,
-0.5135271549,
0.379314959,
0.3524089158,
-0.1695715189,
0.2213198245,
0.0404793918,
-0.1743334383,
-0.1009775177,
0.1949133426,
0.5713301301,
0.5151444077,
-0.5524025559,
0.4218698144,
-0.1727677584,
-0.2696826756,
-0.1552180052,
0.0001786107,
0.1281383485,
0.5154514313,
0.6380341053,
-0.0378456563,
0.403445363,
-0.3323016167,
0.3647398949,
0.408164978,
0.0563669913,
0.0041089817,
0.5396140814,
-0.1211078465,
-0.0887261108,
0.4579025507,
-0.5858418345,
-0.3782025874,
0.4144284129,
0.497305274,
0.7594568729,
-0.3615737557,
0.3791952431,
0.4867678583,
0.4978233576,
-0.3350587487,
0.1966084987,
-0.2317323685,
-0.7893593311,
-0.739838779,
-1.0670182705,
-0.5643017888,
-0.4251572788,
-0.4261150658,
0.0704304799,
-0.6015352607,
0.0709955171,
-0.239641428,
0.0791695341,
-0.5094758272,
0.3758033812,
0.4171023369,
0.9235469103,
-0.4270747304,
1.0074313879,
0.1877035946,
-0.1689640582,
-1.1094043255,
-0.1242619678,
0.3113895357,
-1.2941622734,
0.8146493435,
0.2355158776,
-0.8386029601,
-0.1177114323,
-0.3699587286,
-1.3683104515,
1.2120707035,
0.3811444938,
-0.6509718895,
-0.1179755777,
-0.1044144779,
0.5323342085,
-0.4110066593,
0.7499243617,
0.7731836438,
0.6317723393,
0.7537508011,
-0.9115965962,
0.2544141114,
-0.0011150308,
0.0014691593,
0.019237183,
-0.4867934585,
0.5530702472,
-0.5124770999,
-0.2336386293,
-0.0881324485,
0.6836531758,
0.6854138374,
0.5789192915,
0.2617301047,
0.6290656924,
0.8361916542,
-0.0069452804,
0.7764822841,
-0.3794829547,
0.5788625479,
1.227235198,
-0.2720786631,
0.8131381273,
0.373236537,
-0.3268371224,
0.559343636,
0.6764318347,
0.1246489957,
0.6032779813,
0.1802307963,
-0.0918168575,
-0.6533129215,
0.413371861,
-0.1880593449,
0.4695630074,
0.4758828282,
-0.2001466751,
-0.459515512,
-0.3255016208,
0.0435077809,
-0.1492588073,
-0.3315812945,
0.4492011368,
0.2853857875,
-0.6342130303,
0.5900731683,
0.175850451,
0.5075746179,
-0.6868605614,
0.1063313708,
-0.1697382927,
0.2007211,
-0.3829965889,
-0.7710614204,
0.2731390893,
-0.4182458818,
0.1738817543,
-0.4973641336,
0.7051340342,
-0.1438423842,
-0.6971760392,
0.6124036908,
0.5228251815,
0.1618292183,
-0.0480996892,
-0.9444575906,
0.2391588837,
0.3239022195,
-0.4330067337,
0.2287194133,
0.4776879251,
0.3384113312,
1.0478028059,
0.6966202855,
-0.0221330151,
0.1521446109,
0.0800003186,
0.6407110095,
-0.7440155149,
-0.39386338,
-0.830277741,
0.1681949347,
0.3174489737,
-0.1306683868,
0.844629705,
0.3113624454,
0.6959227324,
0.1732939035,
0.4300716221,
0.283475399,
0.2744906545,
-0.7760226727,
0.3169225454,
-0.5153935552,
0.6226216555,
-0.0456459485,
-0.6683252454,
-0.3262266517,
1.0178560019,
-0.5626558661,
0.0716947913,
0.7802354097,
1.1420242786,
0.1552615911,
0.004194987,
0.5505231023,
0.3427181542,
0.3432187736,
0.5947053432,
0.7413992882,
-0.4811856151,
0.8654986024,
-0.1730890423,
-0.3375107944,
-0.3140180111,
-0.93029356,
-0.4936474264,
-0.3353706002,
-0.2042003572,
-0.4262082279,
0.0876005292,
0.8386332393,
0.7757809758,
-0.8090502024,
-0.2860988081,
-0.1439736933,
0.3241837025,
-0.2246234268,
-0.209351182,
0.1927595139,
-0.5763804317,
-0.5303640366,
1.075250268,
0.7457283139,
-0.4610281289,
-0.3684385717,
-0.404348731,
-0.1871487349,
0.3490945101,
0.3543305695,
0.0880870223,
-0.8498256207,
-0.2603684962,
-0.0192743316,
-0.3229130208,
0.1761422902,
0.4927635491,
-0.5218448639,
0.8576596975,
0.3686562777,
0.4551254511,
0.8415654898,
-0.0705531836,
0.4796864092,
-0.3896614909,
-0.340854913,
0.3233805299,
0.5622177124,
0.1484535486,
-0.3725796938,
0.5725589991,
0.0153820291,
-0.8381929994,
-0.5410785675,
0.3981864452,
-0.9172111154,
-0.2089618891,
1.0583766699,
-0.1246577799,
-0.2747439146,
0.1027118266,
-0.1772559881,
0.0533015504,
-0.6466814876,
0.9388337731,
0.7849513292,
-0.4537970126,
-0.4232114851,
-0.3109772801,
0.317309916,
0.5768280029,
-0.5374446511,
-0.0666149333,
0.5819162726,
0.2777101696,
0.3264600635,
0.8437629938,
0.0817433968,
0.2829624712,
0.1899531335,
-0.2119107395,
-0.009119926,
-0.304077059,
-0.3172544837,
0.1607277691,
0.162677139,
0.1030672863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00606v1 | Low-Resourced Machine Translation for Senegalese Wolof Language | 2023-05-01T00:04:19 | 2023-05-01T00:04:19 | Derguene Mbaye, Moussa Diallo, Thierno Ibrahima Diop | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Processing (NLP) research has made great advancements in
recent years with major breakthroughs that have established new benchmarks.
However, these advances have mainly benefited a certain group of languages
commonly referred to as resource-rich such as English and French. Majority of
other languages with weaker resources are then left behind which is the case
for most African languages including Wolof. In this work, we present a parallel
Wolof/French corpus of 123,000 sentences on which we conducted experiments on
machine translation models based on Recurrent Neural Networks (RNN) in
different data configurations. We noted performance gains with the models
trained on subworded data as well as those trained on the French-English
language pair compared to those trained on the French-Wolof pair under the same
experimental conditions. | [
-0.60319525,
-0.7958004475,
0.2511950135,
0.2690479159,
-0.2879925072,
-0.004942223,
-0.4098868072,
-0.608330667,
0.1203981489,
0.8529004455,
-0.4761167765,
-0.2839879692,
-0.9987647533,
0.7470351458,
-0.5096919537,
1.0724432468,
-0.1230373606,
-0.1484888196,
-0.1562853307,
-0.8583800793,
-0.3684147298,
-0.7094945312,
-0.5273943543,
-0.3796248138,
0.7478334904,
0.4680315852,
0.72641927,
0.3394769728,
0.5113382339,
0.2970118523,
-0.1375024468,
0.5866827965,
-0.5542535782,
0.0011868892,
-0.0987358168,
-0.0233820453,
-0.200370267,
-0.1646384746,
0.2700890601,
1.0530465841,
-0.1458686143,
0.1334176809,
0.208313033,
0.9936057925,
-0.5777411461,
0.1856386811,
-0.4428499639,
0.0985312536,
-0.1408950388,
0.1555624306,
-0.240168646,
-0.2361262888,
0.2670779526,
-0.3566064239,
0.4434169829,
-0.060766492,
0.6828439832,
0.2550630271,
-0.2368950993,
-0.0722869337,
-0.496948272,
1.0917743444,
-0.9263147116,
0.2568492889,
0.4957222641,
0.0638859048,
-0.2978620231,
-0.851909101,
-0.576577425,
-0.0309014916,
-0.2728699148,
-0.0234917849,
-0.0368414149,
-0.077789031,
0.3024444282,
0.2712074518,
-0.4771462381,
0.259260416,
-0.373133719,
-0.2508928478,
0.7269652486,
-0.0380319282,
0.0774108395,
-0.2184837908,
-0.2131157815,
-0.1202160493,
-0.4006247222,
-0.1678843945,
0.2544134855,
0.5800871849,
-0.4529441297,
0.8209738731,
-0.33880198,
1.1533359289,
-0.456846267,
-0.4049001038,
0.4149829149,
-0.3344075382,
-0.1910439581,
-0.105893679,
1.0080698729,
0.3164505661,
0.5161948204,
-0.2775010169,
-0.4986131787,
-0.1975330859,
0.0201544128,
-0.8866198063,
-0.0391318351,
-0.0785367116,
-0.8092625737,
-0.1646776795,
-0.3987270594,
-0.7697246671,
-0.2477366477,
-0.0172290727,
0.179345727,
-0.3718139231,
0.2136326879,
0.0467802659,
0.1061204225,
-0.0926104113,
0.0357876159,
-0.8418940902,
0.283508718,
0.1629123986,
1.0180207491,
-0.2848337889,
-0.2122846842,
-0.6472970843,
-0.2446432263,
0.0665794387,
0.4309770465,
-0.5321973562,
-0.8454750776,
0.0869479179,
0.2212591022,
-0.1089561582,
-0.4997790158,
0.9574121833,
-0.5348543525,
0.0975940004,
-0.2333338857,
-0.369913727,
-0.321146369,
-0.0058887927,
-0.9552281499,
0.8943966031,
0.3780283928,
-0.7442114353,
0.0134093119,
-0.4939093888,
-0.8961663246,
-0.1786261499,
0.0419457927,
-0.4422114491,
0.2782688439,
0.5173436403,
0.3188949525,
-0.5602860451,
-0.252515167,
-0.0169566367,
-0.1118936241,
0.3235087991,
-0.5757517815,
0.5007600188,
0.5136412978,
-0.1722637713,
-0.3689954579,
-0.8574184179,
0.0676639676,
0.1393834651,
-0.3803592622,
-0.1971175224,
-0.226024583,
0.5774435401,
0.3308993876,
0.1989646405,
-0.7908507586,
0.1704872251,
-0.5166962147,
0.6431478858,
0.2498246282,
-0.0097278869,
0.4669997096,
-0.2626501322,
0.4462946057,
-0.1002279967,
-0.113439247,
0.1126656234,
-1.0175315142,
-0.7076378465,
0.0604323484,
0.5692410469,
0.5657922626,
-0.9131581783,
0.097581014,
-0.0553160422,
0.1060173586,
-0.8651525378,
0.5069711804,
0.3001312912,
0.7676271796,
0.5557434559,
-0.21060884,
-0.5451393723,
-1.3817595243,
-0.2396222204,
0.3375970721,
0.016680358,
0.4181112945,
0.339538455,
-0.519000113,
0.5931525826,
-0.2281228602,
-0.3519312739,
-0.6333504915,
0.4998511076,
0.3880244792,
0.456197679,
0.495764643,
-1.0301655531,
-0.5516771674,
0.1818261296,
-0.4561370611,
-0.2324466854,
0.1195057631,
-0.0074645849,
0.675437212,
0.2832630575,
-0.4182510674,
0.5257105231,
0.9248630404,
0.2542892694,
-0.0991733745,
-0.5482029319,
0.0369405784,
-1.0214515924,
0.137322858,
-0.0234229974,
-0.4282290041,
-0.2031034827,
-0.3260567486,
-0.225344941,
-0.3250115514,
-0.4915218651,
0.5557350516,
-0.3905446827,
-0.2683129013,
-0.5080237985,
0.3890757263,
-0.0381010883,
0.3986020982,
0.2856193781,
0.7692773342,
0.0211211517,
-0.4723826349,
0.2142941356,
0.1806691587,
-0.3985300064,
0.127859056,
-0.7287837863,
0.141700685,
0.2166094333,
-0.0241311807,
-0.4824135303,
-0.1956449002,
-0.1801704168,
-0.140287742,
0.2272162735,
-0.0955631137,
-0.5171350837,
-0.5285924077,
0.2905432582,
0.5173892975,
0.7682616711,
-0.4973813891,
0.1579895914,
0.4283758402,
-0.2000259012,
-0.6394592524,
-0.9125229716,
0.1255380064,
0.1402763575,
-0.4965185225,
0.3537017405,
0.4569073915,
-0.1052805334,
0.1473179758,
0.1107236743,
-0.1810347885,
-0.0338143185,
0.0603149086,
0.1087800115,
-0.0667966008,
0.0170774721,
-0.3506428897,
-0.1822659373,
-0.432022512,
-0.5958669186,
0.4209174812,
-0.276959151,
0.0598427542,
-0.2467182726,
0.627291441,
0.5360774994,
-0.4241556823,
1.438595891,
0.8549714088,
-0.3629234433,
-0.2644733489,
-0.4473786056,
-0.0631523877,
-0.3609702289,
0.4356561005,
-0.2433796972,
-0.7921445966,
0.4135994315,
-0.09757182,
0.096134156,
0.4128951132,
0.4435207844,
-0.4453492463,
0.86571908,
0.9302150607,
-0.3005633354,
0.1936101615,
-0.5789051652,
0.3538760841,
-0.6735072732,
-0.1316502988,
-0.5488684773,
-0.7247911692,
-1.1167645454,
-0.4994152486,
0.2719779611,
0.3549712002,
0.1912085861,
0.5803133249,
-0.3178505301,
0.2499334812,
0.4984080791,
0.0373036712,
0.2737051845,
0.2127161771,
-0.1589061022,
-0.1152031943,
-1.0679368973,
-0.6306083202,
1.0271031857,
-0.2370782942,
0.784432888,
-0.1408946812,
0.6710692644,
0.4940187335,
0.3102464974,
-0.6442107558,
0.3325597644,
-0.7870172858,
0.1152436435,
-0.4066258967,
-0.5578051209,
-1.1308866739,
0.1705305725,
-0.1598794907,
-0.3434117436,
0.1439205706,
0.0768086538,
-0.0389423631,
0.5149692297,
-0.5528388619,
0.949916482,
-0.3540035486,
-0.3835800588,
-0.2689049244,
-0.5475955606,
0.1864627302,
-0.1018580496,
0.3412107825,
0.0161288902,
-0.0043612355,
0.6532687545,
-0.8854769468,
0.4079642594,
-0.0108484896,
-0.1981662214,
0.336381942,
-0.1123360172,
0.857648015,
0.0036226686,
-0.2631546557,
0.3872864246,
-0.310211271,
-0.8162506819,
-0.2534496188,
1.0074365139,
-0.7461508512,
-0.3331181705,
-0.2165187299,
-1.0061069727,
-0.2649341822,
0.0760316998,
0.6348868608,
0.3687649369,
-0.1638321131,
0.3997284174,
0.4780814052,
-0.5646665692,
0.7835059166,
0.3303472698,
-0.013266813,
-0.2240237296,
0.6383820772,
0.1224267259,
0.4648138881,
0.4507852495,
-0.1012805104,
-0.3419609368,
-0.4807457328,
-0.670751214,
0.2423811853,
-0.3193698823,
-0.1609414518,
-0.8466910124,
-0.1937277764,
-0.2273152769,
-0.105732888,
-0.4671544135,
-0.8312482238,
-0.0751448944,
0.1124561951,
0.4633033872,
0.6520246267,
-0.0077821808,
0.0390444323,
-1.196120739,
0.574970305,
0.1753892303,
-0.0401185639,
-0.1585209817,
-0.6945037842,
-0.5951764584,
0.3080798388,
-0.1570102721,
-0.5171757936,
0.6493267417,
0.2533851266,
0.4774616063,
-0.2163466513,
0.180544287,
0.4515779912,
-0.6077854037,
0.4943457246,
0.2780634463,
-0.5146424174,
0.4860876203,
-0.0855579898,
0.4093812108,
0.3567373753,
0.2441127598,
-0.675596714,
-0.214078024,
-0.4116684198,
-0.6661429405,
0.59715873,
0.5841326714,
0.055833593,
-0.0103616351,
0.3090789914,
0.3058719635,
0.242384702,
-0.4317170978,
-0.2420251369,
-0.1919602454,
-0.1800822616,
-0.1959698945,
-0.077570945,
-0.0697665811,
0.1129787937,
0.6285108328,
-0.0758069307,
0.1378976256,
0.3596973717,
-0.2666934729,
-0.0281614084,
0.4083476663,
0.4533556104,
0.4595423639,
-0.1233682558,
-0.2453596145,
0.3395603895,
-0.5086731315,
0.2850092649,
0.2703766525,
-0.2974920869,
0.2759135067,
0.6255739331,
0.6869558692,
0.0851508975,
-0.6947770715,
0.2372728437,
0.0589852296,
-0.0236387141,
0.1272909343,
-0.0401964039,
0.3142755926,
0.0580856651,
-0.0003692193,
0.5549820662,
-0.1611561477,
-0.4639950097,
0.1132393777,
0.1451883614,
-0.2241371721,
-0.1515714526,
0.6442472935,
0.6439914107,
-0.3396158218,
0.8664019108,
-0.1681936085,
-0.3774695098,
0.6770815253,
0.5148122311,
0.8702073097,
0.2410533726,
0.346021235,
0.3899813592,
0.4264436364,
-0.2484822273,
0.3769881725,
-0.0617543384,
-0.7443267107,
-0.5192626715,
-1.0053422451,
-0.1988215744,
0.3662950397,
-0.817597568,
-0.1996557713,
0.0065785917,
-0.4020918906,
-0.2659041286,
-0.0760322511,
-1.0401024818,
0.0828139856,
-0.0114230802,
0.765276432,
-0.5556134582,
1.2705528736,
0.6617585421,
-0.3991596699,
-0.2445579469,
-0.0980268121,
-0.4094130397,
-0.6227109432,
1.0571879148,
-0.0371536762,
-0.2324173301,
-0.0760970488,
-0.1064078063,
-0.7074556351,
0.6521042585,
0.4515228271,
-1.1655927896,
0.2795135081,
0.3184152544,
0.6390840411,
-0.3856185675,
-0.4202158153,
0.5170238614,
0.4955224097,
-0.3515228629,
-1.0661706924,
-0.4194742143,
0.0008053545,
0.2923559844,
0.3311403692,
-0.7933580875,
0.8314756155,
-0.5169186592,
-0.1680725217,
0.5263805389,
0.6412504911,
-0.1332930624,
-0.0009207304,
0.4377011955,
0.8011953235,
0.6253258586,
-0.1360870898,
1.449126482,
-0.2654499114,
0.2279699743,
1.1676084995,
-0.4704035223,
0.8773963451,
0.571870625,
-0.3234885931,
0.4559503496,
0.4864876866,
0.2549524307,
0.819750011,
0.1576388031,
-0.4850650728,
-0.2298397571,
-0.4774939716,
-0.4195999503,
0.2858823836,
0.2101153731,
-0.4010449648,
-0.0569659099,
0.4594831169,
-0.3077237308,
0.5242574811,
-0.2369620949,
0.5159194469,
0.5033273697,
-0.5747532248,
0.7741718888,
0.3872330189,
0.5677504539,
-0.384441793,
-0.0654891506,
-0.5602896214,
0.2888478339,
-0.1668613553,
-0.61369735,
0.319560498,
0.4190184474,
-0.542989254,
-0.3691875935,
0.6297878027,
-0.621216476,
-0.7298933864,
0.6790056825,
0.5233682394,
-0.0154018151,
0.3180781901,
-0.6898463368,
-0.0641739443,
0.0369285569,
-0.0026245906,
0.2686680257,
0.531180501,
-0.0933936685,
0.6126533151,
0.5432329178,
0.3592868447,
0.0119974185,
0.4678114057,
0.5430684686,
-0.646086812,
-0.3467680216,
-0.6826862693,
-0.0512380861,
-0.0488910899,
-0.2433825731,
0.6912311316,
0.4872904718,
1.0205713511,
-0.190780893,
0.8968763947,
-0.1133266166,
0.4846488833,
-0.7072477341,
0.5476980805,
-0.4149983525,
0.1763981432,
-0.0600040182,
-1.0335673094,
0.1099308655,
0.5904282928,
0.0585677214,
-0.0469826572,
0.6824163198,
0.6512386799,
0.0287840385,
0.0699715838,
0.4506356716,
0.3240819871,
0.0121232392,
0.6959531307,
0.5078507066,
-0.6459460855,
0.7408408523,
-0.6733584404,
0.0720489025,
-0.1556303352,
-0.8102235198,
-0.9033340216,
-0.4360129833,
-0.0552672595,
-0.2709768713,
-0.0081353681,
0.7339301109,
0.6278511882,
-1.1884434223,
-0.2262569815,
-0.2779029608,
0.1766109914,
-0.3388909698,
-0.1279192567,
0.3893312514,
-0.438442111,
-0.8923941851,
0.5293959975,
0.3949945867,
0.1480455101,
-0.1140674502,
-0.324729979,
-0.4706504047,
-0.1673568189,
0.7876600027,
0.421269238,
-0.7238376737,
-0.0903594494,
-0.0754337534,
-0.3428842425,
-0.2037151605,
0.981159687,
-0.96563375,
0.5813835859,
0.4954878688,
1.0929896832,
0.7059047818,
-0.0520489439,
0.8178374171,
-0.8701473475,
0.7986956239,
0.283816427,
0.644636333,
0.6015053391,
-0.1140894517,
0.7300303578,
0.412822336,
-0.501409173,
-0.472115159,
0.0343590006,
-0.6232334375,
-0.1587336957,
0.72223562,
-0.2188455164,
-0.1004342064,
-0.133016184,
-0.2018159628,
0.2550903559,
-0.2882928848,
0.6988135576,
0.8285019398,
-0.2065699548,
-0.0048832106,
-0.8099260926,
0.5407397747,
0.5924432874,
-0.7035157084,
-0.2310995907,
0.2880355716,
-0.214551568,
0.0410575233,
0.3011577129,
-0.1235054508,
0.1948130131,
-0.113085568,
-0.1654935479,
0.0313855298,
-0.0691412166,
-0.0189838037,
-0.0028640949,
-0.2993029356,
-0.3865157664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00593v1 | Reliable Gradient-free and Likelihood-free Prompt Tuning | 2023-04-30T22:33:08 | 2023-04-30T22:33:08 | Maohao Shen, Soumya Ghosh, Prasanna Sattigeri, Subhro Das, Yuheng Bu, Gregory Wornell | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Due to privacy or commercial constraints, large pre-trained language models
(PLMs) are often offered as black-box APIs. Fine-tuning such models to
downstream tasks is challenging because one can neither access the model's
internal representations nor propagate gradients through it. This paper
addresses these challenges by developing techniques for adapting PLMs with only
API access. Building on recent work on soft prompt tuning, we develop methods
to tune the soft prompts without requiring gradient computation. Further, we
develop extensions that in addition to not requiring gradients also do not need
to access any internal representation of the PLM beyond the input embeddings.
Moreover, instead of learning a single prompt, our methods learn a distribution
over prompts allowing us to quantify predictive uncertainty. Ours is the first
work to consider uncertainty in prompts when only having API access to the PLM.
Finally, through extensive experiments, we carefully vet the proposed methods
and find them competitive with (and sometimes even improving on) gradient-based
approaches with full access to the PLM. | [
-0.3864420354,
-0.4634768367,
0.5836414099,
0.2971121371,
-0.1878015846,
0.0387190506,
-0.6353099942,
0.0599043518,
-0.3759157956,
0.5836503506,
-1.1950494051,
-0.4353304505,
-0.490536809,
0.1031574905,
0.3143849075,
1.158503294,
0.131191507,
-0.0709325448,
0.1161068231,
-0.2738675773,
-0.4718534052,
-0.2755130529,
-0.7756070495,
0.1935244948,
0.6422287822,
0.2913490534,
0.7160025835,
0.63851583,
0.1883437186,
0.2345958203,
-0.1104532331,
0.3317784965,
-0.29154405,
0.2161561698,
-0.4832288325,
-0.7361975908,
-0.2729096413,
-0.0831634328,
0.60928303,
0.7525283098,
0.0544688925,
0.1083407849,
0.4016903043,
0.6756087542,
-0.6661841869,
0.2893596888,
-0.8300078511,
-0.1352905482,
-0.0903032497,
-0.3120354414,
-0.4237260222,
-0.4663217664,
0.1862315536,
-0.9241538644,
0.2819162905,
0.2323636562,
0.5597074628,
0.775513649,
-0.1660260409,
-0.4597443044,
-0.769543469,
1.0738683939,
-0.5068849921,
0.2858052552,
0.4840126336,
0.3555724919,
-0.5212882757,
-0.4707324207,
-0.1419725865,
-0.3495645523,
0.1120505631,
-0.1493162513,
0.0016663951,
0.4141898453,
0.1901380271,
0.2686074078,
-0.3562707007,
0.1834518611,
-0.0459355898,
-0.4572412372,
0.4146921337,
-0.0016432969,
0.1165973619,
0.1910868883,
-0.2368041873,
-0.1141882315,
-0.7262788415,
0.527651608,
0.5340601802,
0.8030021787,
-0.3156384826,
0.3648608625,
0.0906614289,
0.6885233521,
0.2874099016,
0.0926903561,
0.1006929949,
-0.2234209776,
-0.1707197279,
-0.2655677497,
0.6939908862,
-0.0442641564,
0.4694066346,
-0.0502689518,
-0.3862302601,
-0.0931467041,
0.1172798872,
-0.4206426442,
-0.0893135816,
0.5014639497,
-0.1906653196,
0.1053126007,
-0.1428845376,
-0.845838666,
-0.7144774199,
-0.3779212534,
0.3996908367,
-0.3390052617,
-0.3267914057,
0.0596207678,
-0.0580627061,
-0.0308907107,
0.2370035797,
-0.8476558924,
0.0673836619,
0.7807413936,
0.9043852091,
0.1388821304,
-0.1828588694,
-1.0369391441,
-0.2175496668,
-0.4490855336,
0.5574991107,
-0.5442740321,
-0.4118544757,
0.2634425461,
0.2715275884,
-0.0487536043,
-0.4094125628,
0.8459963202,
-0.2658533156,
0.076535888,
-0.3039034605,
-0.6270611882,
0.1464885026,
-0.3220193088,
-0.5830993652,
0.5855339766,
0.3460069001,
-0.4847527444,
0.3765170276,
-0.6872467399,
-0.2525207996,
-0.0356424563,
0.1070356518,
-0.2554471493,
0.4064873457,
0.4290877581,
0.1193454117,
0.1508468091,
0.2349845767,
-0.5767249465,
-0.3492912948,
0.3595480919,
-0.3623356819,
0.9234995842,
0.3083259761,
-0.3141853213,
0.551127851,
-0.9904383421,
0.0466449596,
-0.4211553931,
-0.0165862385,
-0.3272533119,
0.0678976551,
-0.2917734087,
0.1504123062,
0.2241153866,
-0.3725483418,
0.1327520311,
-0.5804853439,
0.4379169643,
1.2306103706,
-0.2308147848,
0.9814329147,
-0.2265759706,
0.7769956589,
-0.1303491145,
0.3401289582,
-0.3013313711,
-0.4812873602,
-0.6917849779,
-0.4590007663,
0.4561611712,
0.6950877905,
-0.9406129718,
0.4979974031,
0.0110519724,
-0.262481004,
-1.0796301365,
0.4385383725,
0.2049781382,
0.5670750141,
0.2833253741,
0.057284452,
-0.4080944955,
-0.6621182561,
-0.477022022,
0.0292080306,
-0.5143017769,
0.7111306787,
-0.0690835118,
0.1785155237,
0.9393230081,
-0.3035980761,
-0.2241231799,
-0.0224548019,
0.2221272886,
0.4528498948,
0.6486030221,
0.4644778073,
-0.4553074837,
-0.4029895663,
-0.2795056701,
-0.3631044626,
-0.4631212652,
-0.2043578029,
-0.1667546034,
0.1085544527,
0.5005358458,
-0.6590269804,
0.2407599688,
0.5674618483,
-0.4096916914,
0.3389539719,
-0.3777839541,
-0.3483034968,
-0.6439315081,
-0.0693572909,
0.2064030915,
-0.2353999168,
-0.520991981,
0.0070444634,
0.3499060273,
-0.218839705,
-0.5085017085,
1.0093199015,
-0.4630713761,
0.1853612214,
-0.3485938907,
-0.2377700806,
-0.0880266502,
0.5626872182,
-0.0128403557,
1.0102893114,
1.0587192774,
-0.8927713633,
-0.0589953437,
-0.0167060494,
-0.4345253408,
0.5315740705,
-0.662869215,
0.1379548311,
-0.4755070806,
0.1542002857,
-0.9677098393,
-0.0402802415,
0.6119310856,
-0.3350580633,
0.3463618159,
-0.5369210243,
-0.085169673,
-0.1524989158,
-0.3601981997,
0.1361932755,
0.7029680014,
-0.5553984046,
0.5929333568,
-0.1216643602,
-0.6264616251,
-0.670992136,
-0.4394859374,
-0.3244483173,
-0.277207911,
-0.3765417337,
-0.0162000749,
-0.4474446177,
-0.0666821152,
-0.258233875,
-0.1618919075,
-0.0237898175,
0.4095212817,
0.3759809732,
0.1633764654,
-0.3685770035,
0.1703961343,
0.2391056716,
-0.187888056,
-0.1547975242,
-0.6795069575,
0.1963180751,
0.0570188016,
-0.0927561447,
-0.4108931124,
0.1980397254,
0.4905451536,
-0.262027055,
0.6098456979,
0.7618967295,
-0.2468812615,
-0.7999841571,
-0.2734553516,
-0.2063449025,
-0.6364058852,
-0.0762039796,
-0.1719282568,
-1.1105213165,
0.5621536374,
-0.1349471658,
0.1732361764,
0.0104790172,
0.3877691925,
-0.0976758078,
0.9987100363,
0.9028493762,
0.2633833885,
0.7563784719,
0.3660291731,
0.016139131,
-0.694604218,
0.1161731631,
-0.8110837936,
-0.2786918581,
-0.6507290006,
-0.2032791376,
0.3154228628,
0.1629481018,
-0.3094934821,
-0.0032965739,
-0.4600938261,
0.3518267274,
0.9225816131,
0.0508452058,
-0.0338907316,
0.121377565,
0.0174948052,
-0.0713737607,
-0.4599475563,
-0.3109703362,
1.0586762428,
0.4442671835,
0.9059583545,
-0.0625266284,
0.2421974391,
0.1260472536,
0.2473452538,
-0.5870857239,
0.283228904,
-0.2668720186,
-0.5058031082,
-0.3714086711,
-0.5884971023,
-0.9261013269,
-0.0346043743,
-0.1021286249,
-0.7424572706,
0.5171598792,
0.3705152571,
-0.890429914,
0.1010044962,
-0.8541815281,
0.5101588964,
-0.189075321,
-0.4908678532,
0.4148257077,
-0.5819149613,
0.0495046489,
-0.0271433275,
0.4260710776,
-0.4284516871,
-0.3075942695,
0.267693609,
-0.5271789432,
1.0631446838,
-0.6677524447,
-0.4012830257,
0.3372650146,
0.1445332319,
0.5562077165,
0.34883219,
-0.2590467334,
-0.0102297403,
-0.1703276783,
-0.6047653556,
-0.7286823392,
0.6246299744,
-0.8084266186,
-0.6387143135,
-0.2370222956,
-0.7408415675,
-0.5788751245,
0.1955772042,
0.4211345017,
0.3550981581,
0.2638218403,
-0.102194272,
0.6839866042,
-0.4907697439,
0.6525653005,
0.5692677498,
0.0144710075,
-0.4303725362,
1.0023534298,
-0.0588024668,
0.0569473654,
0.2334612906,
0.3980895579,
-0.8046239018,
-0.7372504473,
-0.7838259339,
-0.0259970613,
-0.3447543681,
-0.2087689489,
-0.2994052172,
0.0565276109,
-0.4253540635,
-0.1655558795,
-0.2238871008,
-0.4704864025,
-0.8217017055,
-0.017024966,
0.5435456634,
0.3969205022,
-0.2088955343,
0.5862061381,
-0.7952421308,
0.1184696779,
0.2679770589,
0.9822908044,
-0.2932965755,
-0.5318078399,
0.0163305365,
0.1680003107,
0.0636527613,
-0.4815452695,
0.353177309,
0.634132266,
0.4428827465,
0.3148572147,
0.322454989,
0.373399049,
-0.5467110276,
0.9718930125,
-0.1362114251,
-1.0707511902,
0.7127705812,
-0.5746842623,
0.2040709406,
0.7465403676,
0.3586530983,
0.0296813194,
-0.3108409643,
-0.2363412529,
-0.7083613873,
0.697547555,
-0.0341306105,
0.3275702298,
0.2536790371,
0.6463150382,
0.5812139511,
0.5104075074,
-0.5017588735,
-0.2712953687,
-0.4362584352,
-0.5022001863,
-0.341471523,
-0.0884758681,
-0.011548887,
-0.1350699514,
0.5199586153,
-0.3628799021,
-0.1674834639,
0.0299225617,
-0.1316278428,
-0.3072352409,
0.5186098218,
0.6439871788,
0.6165343523,
-0.316429615,
0.0944459364,
-0.1930660158,
-0.2615870535,
0.2666305602,
0.2289049476,
-0.4259500802,
0.1249196231,
-0.0085252123,
1.1287351847,
0.2174396962,
-0.795075655,
0.5649014711,
-0.2047485113,
-0.0689371377,
-0.1010177508,
0.3238463998,
-0.3118694127,
0.1587657332,
0.2983216047,
0.1993380785,
-0.1202354953,
-0.196608305,
0.1909607947,
0.4866136611,
-0.6922271848,
-0.4932848513,
0.6741927266,
0.364925772,
-0.5146778226,
0.4626451731,
-0.3401526213,
0.0368686132,
0.4055059552,
0.494225055,
0.9490576982,
-0.436468482,
0.3730382621,
0.1755717993,
0.3488524258,
0.0199976526,
0.5140681863,
0.1050877273,
-0.5181387067,
-0.6263247728,
-0.7525554299,
-0.447016716,
0.3957944214,
-0.6322431564,
0.2868989408,
-0.9891167283,
-0.2208431363,
-0.3021399677,
-0.2236380577,
-0.7289529443,
0.0005970111,
0.0744387284,
1.1711548567,
-0.6307890415,
0.5569085479,
0.5950257778,
-0.0478452817,
-0.6275697947,
-0.1821855605,
-0.1206469685,
-0.7378548384,
-0.1721061021,
-0.0595270656,
0.096865043,
0.1063326225,
-0.7837744355,
-0.800916791,
0.4804242551,
0.8153634071,
-0.735086441,
-0.0475652516,
0.0362357162,
0.4116100073,
-0.0554902181,
0.1078822464,
0.4234445095,
0.5340439677,
-0.2502209544,
-0.8439909816,
-0.0447587408,
-0.031326849,
-0.1541334689,
0.0703454912,
-0.5326291919,
1.0130169392,
-0.1322671771,
-0.4924095273,
0.3638689518,
0.6589182019,
0.1335189492,
0.271617502,
0.611872077,
0.0857132748,
1.1824133396,
-0.0966720134,
1.0530122519,
-0.4794967473,
0.1865421683,
1.2624841928,
-0.2562875152,
0.4402950704,
0.4268356562,
0.0503297485,
0.4533728361,
0.7336193323,
0.0881006494,
0.7629008889,
0.3420467675,
-0.506134212,
-0.3134509623,
-0.384290278,
-0.320514977,
-0.0079246731,
0.7153322101,
-0.1528242528,
-0.1905064881,
0.1303974241,
-0.2751278877,
0.124732919,
-0.8236650825,
0.7104477286,
0.3333842456,
-0.8517081141,
0.6113275886,
-0.2041514516,
1.021441102,
-0.8250047565,
0.2133283913,
-0.1719093174,
-0.0186788011,
-0.0580189079,
-0.5269471407,
0.0517324805,
-0.1027678847,
-0.0468734652,
-0.3305711746,
0.8194105625,
-0.4575169683,
-0.6135427356,
0.1619323641,
0.7948278785,
-0.2617371976,
-0.1613631696,
-0.6398003697,
-0.029819347,
-0.0661564246,
-0.1721743345,
0.3035596907,
0.6509665847,
0.1614747941,
0.747644484,
0.7089038491,
0.359874934,
0.2503673434,
0.1189282611,
0.5529540181,
-0.5328925252,
-0.6226701736,
-0.7581530213,
0.5847809911,
0.4354097545,
-0.5000508428,
0.5346506834,
-0.0094670374,
0.6714333892,
-0.2862861753,
1.1047143936,
0.4519936442,
0.5967347026,
-0.6381918192,
0.5714201927,
-0.4967629611,
0.1912313253,
-0.1290593743,
-0.7144093513,
-0.2585527301,
0.5100102425,
-0.1273084283,
-0.0925248414,
0.3764565885,
0.9340437651,
-0.1653511673,
0.1978388876,
0.0875761732,
0.082781516,
0.137479037,
0.4647136033,
0.8796137571,
0.1398498416,
0.5698050857,
-0.3091698587,
-0.4845331013,
-0.0624316558,
-1.216450572,
-0.8108133078,
-0.4205307961,
-0.174564451,
-0.4446820915,
0.0554034188,
1.0725002289,
0.896597147,
-1.0836253166,
0.1637072116,
-0.2333371937,
0.4251902699,
-0.3324153423,
-0.2078831345,
0.3615907431,
-0.7766090631,
-0.7992292047,
0.664670825,
0.1957467645,
0.2224886566,
-0.1970137358,
-0.0165464785,
0.5297831297,
0.2623922229,
0.2971794903,
0.5832531452,
-0.5770568848,
-0.46783638,
0.1024023369,
0.125184983,
0.0605115108,
1.068292737,
-0.7281976938,
0.2505561709,
0.2846514583,
0.8969342709,
-0.1383439898,
0.057233315,
0.841765523,
-1.248042345,
0.3188045025,
0.3901777864,
0.3085288107,
0.4030759335,
-0.4902414382,
0.1155569032,
-0.0467542037,
-0.4590891302,
-0.8488772511,
0.4535053968,
-0.9436725378,
-0.3389787972,
1.1178592443,
-0.2993793786,
-0.4007078707,
-0.4815466702,
-0.1855516434,
0.1243031099,
-0.6371825337,
0.6324942708,
0.6485632062,
0.0351236127,
-0.349132061,
-0.3930998445,
0.9598519206,
0.533524394,
-0.369554162,
0.2876827121,
0.3542461097,
0.3773909807,
-0.0648929104,
0.6573287845,
0.1519927233,
0.2107596695,
-0.3411879539,
-0.3188104928,
-0.1756075919,
-0.4443706572,
-0.8582607508,
0.3098242879,
0.3481888771,
-0.1824513078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00586v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00586v5 | How does GPT-2 compute greater-than?: Interpreting mathematical abilities in a pre-trained language model | 2023-04-30T21:44:21 | 2023-11-02T10:55:18 | Michael Hanna, Ollie Liu, Alexandre Variengien | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models can be surprisingly adept at tasks they were not
explicitly trained on, but how they implement these capabilities is poorly
understood. In this paper, we investigate the basic mathematical abilities
often acquired by pre-trained language models. Concretely, we use mechanistic
interpretability techniques to explain the (limited) mathematical abilities of
GPT-2 small. As a case study, we examine its ability to take in sentences such
as "The war lasted from the year 1732 to the year 17", and predict valid
two-digit end years (years > 32). We first identify a circuit, a small subset
of GPT-2 small's computational graph that computes this task's output. Then, we
explain the role of each circuit component, showing that GPT-2 small's final
multi-layer perceptrons boost the probability of end years greater than the
start year. Finally, we find related tasks that activate our circuit. Our
results suggest that GPT-2 small computes greater-than using a complex but
general mechanism that activates across diverse contexts. | [
-0.5695542693,
-0.8087926507,
0.9950751662,
0.0018020506,
-0.2041353881,
-0.1071120948,
-0.2308572382,
-0.4625127316,
-0.1852361411,
0.0536250696,
-0.5725070238,
0.1507967412,
-1.0036137104,
-0.2410973012,
-0.2407506704,
1.3347536325,
0.010531934,
-0.1770191491,
0.0988947451,
0.3123538494,
-0.2549241483,
-0.660699904,
-0.6692674756,
-0.7106333375,
0.3572151959,
0.2336967885,
1.0506176949,
0.3026046157,
0.5657172799,
0.2966365814,
0.1655935943,
-0.5353523493,
-0.6034552455,
-0.324889034,
-0.2082411945,
-0.6249757409,
-0.4337445199,
0.4275993407,
0.3991635144,
0.5512478948,
0.0506972596,
0.0321708992,
0.1907405555,
0.5183925629,
-0.0515731983,
0.4263270497,
-0.7780735493,
-0.1739639491,
-0.2820086479,
-0.0085785994,
-0.379699111,
-0.0125080897,
0.2194454372,
-0.7078798413,
0.2095146477,
-0.4123003185,
0.7815346718,
0.0616799183,
-0.4852046967,
-0.3586817384,
-0.6274163127,
0.8481295705,
-0.368812412,
0.1368472427,
0.4647127986,
0.6194046736,
0.0101662166,
-0.9901780486,
-0.5786622167,
-0.4514557719,
-0.2121689171,
0.161532104,
-0.5262621641,
-0.0803872421,
0.7347162962,
0.186813131,
-0.7603163123,
0.0869237632,
-0.5565317869,
-0.0296044257,
0.2997128963,
0.0146206133,
0.3299298286,
-0.3047485054,
-0.2059960663,
0.0963931084,
-0.6421643496,
0.1323726028,
0.3027558029,
0.0886145085,
-0.2358737439,
0.8630358577,
0.0212386586,
0.3609291315,
-0.2227955908,
0.263816148,
-0.1736267656,
-0.2500125766,
-0.4385766983,
-0.2952030897,
0.416606158,
-0.0229911841,
0.8525993824,
-0.1447247267,
-0.1067352891,
0.3093997836,
0.211855188,
-0.998570323,
-0.4949111938,
-0.368699491,
-0.3771364689,
-0.2045826465,
-0.0724154189,
-0.351994127,
-0.0083079841,
-0.3513984978,
0.6564442515,
-0.1910827011,
-0.1893760711,
0.0444882028,
-0.2616331875,
0.0522778928,
0.0465609133,
-0.729840219,
0.5318437815,
0.8485801816,
0.8739391565,
0.193397209,
-0.5000370145,
-0.5717458129,
-0.2537643909,
-0.2101227641,
0.5946729779,
-0.7588639259,
-0.1661472023,
-0.4231908917,
-0.0004517231,
-0.0179898236,
-0.281894356,
0.4242792726,
-0.9022379518,
0.4338318408,
-0.140949145,
-0.2900520563,
0.0880288556,
-0.142775625,
-0.4492712319,
0.5445699692,
0.3892220855,
-0.6689782739,
0.3423998356,
-0.6525862217,
-0.6323872209,
-0.1571514159,
-0.3389172852,
-0.4027172625,
0.500739634,
-0.0501058139,
0.3252275586,
-0.7312321663,
-0.0348604657,
-0.3404900432,
-0.4993199706,
0.335907042,
-0.7182810903,
0.8746122718,
0.0852613226,
-0.404871285,
-0.1617826074,
-0.5061021447,
0.2070302516,
0.5220891833,
0.0401305035,
-0.0704235286,
-0.2132796347,
-0.3710615337,
0.5016086102,
0.2698917091,
-0.2872728407,
0.3141291738,
-0.5904275179,
0.8336071968,
0.5503849983,
0.0569609031,
0.4965482056,
-0.1399547309,
0.5346460938,
-0.3253541291,
0.0761291757,
0.0748343319,
-0.7921231389,
-0.2934653163,
0.0701510459,
0.1415908486,
0.7020077705,
-0.8736429214,
0.1492507309,
-0.4464605749,
-0.5074315071,
0.2783914208,
0.097838074,
0.4137150645,
0.3681049347,
0.3858876824,
-0.2547863424,
-0.4203723073,
-0.9076989293,
-0.3300868869,
-0.3035997748,
-0.210522607,
0.0738707632,
0.528495729,
-0.0668314919,
0.5732954144,
-0.7317484021,
-0.1317383945,
-0.2501822114,
0.4173112214,
0.4587299824,
0.3734822869,
0.3465928435,
-0.6043354869,
-0.4142080247,
0.0978950486,
-0.6704916358,
-0.0076297498,
-0.3053326607,
-0.1079522595,
-0.2597209513,
0.379119426,
-0.8251004219,
0.655251801,
0.2949424982,
-0.4555095732,
0.6755310297,
-0.4575416446,
-0.0448706225,
-0.5952017307,
-0.1893010885,
-0.1415556073,
0.0897783265,
-0.6866062284,
-0.1131238267,
0.1553295851,
-0.2048141658,
-0.1365097612,
0.3955090046,
-0.2981244028,
-0.3103700578,
-0.5185633898,
0.0509474054,
-0.0949229747,
0.3343317509,
0.0326295421,
0.9674340487,
0.3980132043,
-0.3532824218,
0.2473827153,
-0.0514266305,
-0.400567174,
0.4413443506,
-0.7580959201,
0.1449451596,
0.1396014839,
-0.0124246133,
-1.018419981,
-0.1820705086,
-0.1120038033,
-0.6696609259,
0.2874712348,
-0.288834542,
-0.5633054376,
-0.4180696905,
-0.0891103372,
0.5878258944,
0.8646526933,
-0.3857899904,
0.397290349,
0.0926694497,
-0.447293371,
-0.2950863242,
-0.8926314712,
-0.0131449085,
-0.0719623864,
-0.5766183734,
0.0599085651,
0.1792144924,
-0.357809633,
0.0546889566,
-0.0725179687,
-0.206837073,
0.1231693178,
0.2472663224,
0.2928664386,
-0.4119766057,
0.0257512797,
0.1969041526,
-0.5637609363,
0.2375851721,
-0.4470930099,
0.7042036653,
-0.1140483767,
-0.555251956,
-0.372592777,
-0.0921456367,
0.5195063949,
-0.0728628784,
0.6866292357,
0.428044498,
-0.4081902206,
0.3046205044,
-0.3114728034,
-0.2426493168,
-0.4719426632,
0.7053869963,
-0.8679671288,
-0.7088449597,
0.4349695146,
0.0717957839,
-0.1201163679,
0.9078609347,
0.5843641162,
0.1155014038,
1.1826862097,
0.2834609151,
0.0658236071,
0.596493125,
-0.318169117,
0.1854285747,
-0.8337875605,
-0.0737590119,
-0.1431518346,
-0.0509965345,
-0.5365676284,
-0.4785841107,
0.4056028724,
0.4522016943,
-0.8188279867,
0.3281440139,
-0.2680276632,
0.7789148688,
0.531429112,
0.1065988764,
0.0543888733,
0.3132178783,
0.0767818391,
-0.3583596647,
-0.4101421237,
-0.2726540864,
1.1232233047,
0.3860799074,
0.7617404461,
0.3227051198,
0.4099880457,
0.1714720577,
0.4639362395,
-0.5656541586,
0.2082269043,
-0.402861625,
-0.6080166101,
-0.5100196004,
-0.5475719571,
-1.0139728785,
0.0722138658,
0.0390636884,
-0.8177338243,
-0.1699418277,
-0.0491510145,
-0.2646093965,
0.1087917238,
-1.0840734243,
0.8903300762,
-0.4897675812,
-0.4145008326,
-0.5521928668,
-0.4840062559,
0.1668729484,
-0.0729499087,
0.2391022444,
0.2591521144,
-0.0843069702,
0.4703137577,
-0.2867239416,
0.5014309883,
-0.3087386489,
0.1152742505,
0.1674291342,
0.3478029072,
0.7684798837,
0.184845224,
0.0120781884,
-0.0580547266,
0.0532764904,
-0.7080846429,
-0.8965201974,
0.7483733296,
-0.9590987563,
-0.5363411307,
-0.4735938311,
-0.3066655099,
-0.1168565974,
0.2426661998,
0.5589396358,
0.6481437087,
-0.0568222776,
-0.195870012,
0.2942033112,
-0.2333397716,
0.1865977794,
0.2139706463,
-0.473680824,
-0.1808595359,
1.1732649803,
0.3750050068,
0.5302048922,
0.3751445711,
0.2466528565,
-0.4690357149,
-0.3185054064,
-0.5590595603,
0.3398773372,
-0.7915635705,
0.1605427265,
-0.3557663262,
-0.3191327751,
-0.272339046,
-0.2340848297,
0.0440479107,
-0.6369608045,
-0.1402969658,
-0.1448237747,
0.058376763,
1.0370100737,
-0.2717048526,
0.468421936,
-0.281485796,
0.4299290478,
0.7636808157,
0.3486792743,
0.1401998401,
-0.8936581612,
-0.1817839444,
-0.1100620031,
-0.1460642368,
-0.8600617647,
0.0979292244,
0.1763610244,
0.3894998133,
0.3300304413,
-0.5420666933,
0.6476206779,
-0.5092398524,
0.7835336924,
0.2722287774,
-1.0324501991,
0.2638849318,
-0.1674921513,
0.4190326631,
0.1914423108,
0.1047673672,
-0.1257165521,
-0.1119781286,
-0.9342809319,
-0.4811254442,
0.6990634203,
0.6033948064,
0.2019409984,
0.1816005856,
0.5953382254,
0.0188478939,
0.0925786868,
-0.6913743019,
-0.2179665267,
-0.2559602261,
0.0199912265,
-0.5513523817,
-0.4033955336,
-0.0128243286,
-0.2906636298,
0.5115767121,
0.1114389673,
0.6168741584,
-0.3015314639,
-0.2798769474,
0.0597759746,
0.5129296184,
0.6500327587,
0.8970103264,
0.0461583063,
0.4562120438,
0.3651249707,
-0.5517540574,
0.0900765955,
0.536483109,
0.156831935,
-0.4195459783,
0.8350362778,
0.7318553925,
0.2754757404,
-0.3909460604,
0.5679326653,
-0.1296750903,
-0.035295926,
-0.3199397624,
0.0439246334,
0.0358979367,
0.4460974336,
0.4593714774,
0.026482258,
0.254784286,
-0.7813480496,
0.4694575965,
0.5622220039,
-0.2717087567,
-0.6089992523,
0.6240837574,
-0.3181270361,
-0.1335531026,
0.5135107636,
-0.4123135507,
-0.8239560723,
0.7708610296,
0.6877099276,
0.457668066,
0.1420196593,
0.1928950995,
0.2041437626,
0.5298697352,
0.0892246738,
0.3590249717,
-0.0680770576,
-0.4373269081,
-0.7390794158,
-0.3899909854,
-0.0195756406,
0.304736495,
-0.7842720151,
-0.087962687,
-0.5134792924,
-0.245148316,
0.2962264121,
0.2808415294,
-1.1446831226,
0.5931790471,
-0.048091609,
0.6381809115,
-0.9061789513,
0.865493238,
0.4915150702,
-0.3313491046,
-0.8584408164,
0.0411934555,
-0.027362626,
-1.2065497637,
0.9121510386,
0.0436447486,
-0.0547087416,
0.1721540689,
-0.304849714,
-0.6039354801,
0.792231977,
0.434404701,
-0.4491029382,
-0.1691890508,
0.2596170008,
0.8617683649,
-0.1408948749,
0.5424154997,
0.8496607542,
0.402307868,
-0.1079555303,
-1.0964818001,
-0.0330787674,
-0.1366611868,
-0.1896836162,
0.3666994572,
-0.3799719512,
1.2078940868,
-0.5217172503,
-0.1610616297,
0.1795852035,
0.4724193811,
-0.0760351047,
0.5124004483,
0.3413479924,
0.4654638767,
0.5512933731,
-0.2919991612,
1.3545839787,
-0.2379975617,
0.5339165926,
1.1024034023,
0.0964984521,
0.5970566869,
0.2379614264,
-0.6272146106,
0.3333950341,
0.3997809589,
0.1443383843,
0.6600880027,
0.1755293906,
-0.1251634508,
-0.3966627717,
0.3634009063,
-0.5930754542,
0.1854639053,
0.2908035517,
-0.4814965427,
-0.2537123263,
0.1197771728,
-0.0613299459,
-0.2400886118,
-0.3567821383,
0.6767309308,
0.3402244747,
-0.4262336493,
0.3728562295,
-0.1005414277,
0.2093480229,
-0.5876652598,
-0.0413269103,
0.1374603957,
0.2228257805,
-0.0718772486,
-1.1813129187,
0.249745205,
0.0497110337,
-0.3443057239,
0.1156555489,
0.6461791992,
-0.0823329166,
-0.6919649839,
0.3023825884,
0.733007431,
0.3193820119,
-0.4294339716,
-0.7095493674,
-0.0369578004,
0.0037433107,
-0.2011746019,
0.4691488147,
0.6953168511,
-0.0715939477,
0.3801000118,
0.4955243468,
0.4383642077,
0.0572843589,
0.0575237051,
0.7642918825,
-0.5973038673,
-0.4035714865,
-1.1424565315,
0.1972915977,
0.1506709009,
-0.3244648278,
0.518196404,
0.6058526039,
0.8089514971,
0.0514861271,
0.97549963,
-0.1278832108,
0.3263086379,
-0.5995700955,
0.4203301072,
-0.4487191141,
0.2121665627,
-0.0280356817,
-0.8623412848,
0.0018748281,
0.7587314844,
-1.0741014481,
0.2791990042,
0.7373985648,
0.3924319744,
-0.2721267939,
0.1743607968,
0.4943448305,
0.3832677901,
0.5810093284,
0.740388453,
0.8691633344,
-0.2085912228,
0.5265892148,
-0.2875251472,
-0.3982881308,
0.0800170302,
-0.4382691085,
-0.9942801595,
-0.5703471303,
0.2647337019,
-0.5598236918,
-0.0932700112,
0.5791065097,
0.5424161553,
-0.8082624078,
0.0609078668,
-0.2720716298,
-0.0729270652,
-0.0758381709,
-0.1657750309,
0.638106823,
-0.1631394029,
-0.458075881,
0.2267783433,
0.1446448863,
0.1198204309,
-0.0505067445,
-0.063507624,
0.4068447053,
-0.0006501793,
0.7801155448,
0.2045912296,
-0.5616646409,
-0.3080624342,
-0.1251400262,
0.0280747656,
-0.0900746286,
1.0897035599,
-0.6317219138,
0.4713361561,
0.3353404403,
0.5655844808,
0.662350595,
0.1060649082,
0.4631174803,
-0.3716754913,
0.239363119,
-0.0245150365,
0.2259584963,
0.0987741873,
-0.3767339587,
0.5115873218,
0.3810108006,
-0.5984922051,
-0.7222340107,
0.3929460645,
-0.6512141228,
-0.2432590574,
0.840503335,
-0.1735913604,
0.3614017963,
-0.1710543931,
-0.2153602988,
0.3132686317,
-0.1746479869,
0.6695481539,
0.8063742518,
-0.5160289407,
0.0125202816,
-0.9006761909,
0.4402890205,
0.4848977923,
-0.7540780306,
-0.1867033988,
0.2395880371,
0.2592646778,
0.1954074353,
0.4564783573,
0.0471276417,
0.537424922,
0.1899169683,
-0.7360511422,
-0.097014904,
-0.377291292,
-0.3957045078,
0.2443451434,
0.3642730117,
0.2358212024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00581v1 | Multimodal Graph Transformer for Multimodal Question Answering | 2023-04-30T21:22:35 | 2023-04-30T21:22:35 | Xuehai He, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the success of Transformer models in vision and language tasks, they
often learn knowledge from enormous data implicitly and cannot utilize
structured input data directly. On the other hand, structured learning
approaches such as graph neural networks (GNNs) that integrate prior
information can barely compete with Transformer models. In this work, we aim to
benefit from both worlds and propose a novel Multimodal Graph Transformer for
question answering tasks that requires performing reasoning across multiple
modalities. We introduce a graph-involved plug-and-play quasi-attention
mechanism to incorporate multimodal graph information, acquired from text and
visual data, to the vanilla self-attention as effective prior. In particular,
we construct the text graph, dense region graph, and semantic graph to generate
adjacency matrices, and then compose them with input vision and language
features to perform downstream reasoning. Such a way of regularizing
self-attention with graph information significantly improves the inferring
ability and helps align features from different modalities. We validate the
effectiveness of Multimodal Graph Transformer over its Transformer baselines on
GQA, VQAv2, and MultiModalQA datasets. | [
-0.4969517291,
-1.0467979908,
0.7467631102,
-0.0270450171,
-0.1839195341,
0.0088749509,
0.2068808526,
-0.1455384493,
0.1551531553,
0.3931478858,
-0.6741794944,
-0.1821393371,
-0.4052687287,
0.0990167707,
-0.2028625011,
0.8426330686,
-0.1598169655,
-0.0527679548,
-0.4865656197,
-0.1169324666,
-0.5793227553,
-0.2657349408,
-0.4720031321,
-0.25717327,
0.9414638281,
0.2337407321,
0.6756262779,
0.2305999845,
0.3483622372,
0.3805116713,
0.2971010506,
0.507807076,
-0.3968845904,
0.0315240175,
-0.1235649884,
-0.4377805889,
-0.2781607509,
-0.1312972307,
0.6488820314,
0.4233145416,
0.2642112672,
0.2823783755,
-0.1427218914,
0.3097856045,
-0.5460653305,
0.4214300215,
-0.4531400502,
0.0362779424,
0.1380859017,
-0.1407057941,
-0.5852980614,
-0.3506235182,
0.0045754355,
-0.8232088089,
0.1620066613,
0.0528428219,
0.8861346841,
0.4880481958,
-0.785692513,
0.1191415116,
-0.6005919576,
0.3967205286,
-0.2809508741,
0.6019800305,
0.1837553978,
0.6541249156,
0.2977001667,
-1.2525436878,
-0.9304696918,
0.1058212817,
-0.6108688116,
0.5157748461,
-0.3090831339,
0.0741862506,
0.304680109,
0.1113756895,
-0.809476018,
-0.4448362887,
-0.2951506376,
-0.5047525764,
0.0736363456,
0.0802531168,
0.3997582495,
-0.442063421,
-0.5303364396,
-0.2650763988,
-0.2096801549,
0.3760234714,
0.2135433257,
0.0714512691,
0.1023393199,
0.6484168172,
-0.163310796,
0.8257675171,
0.1582369208,
-0.2210988551,
0.365981102,
-0.7379598618,
-0.1085620448,
-0.2840140164,
0.7904326916,
0.4121562541,
0.2429608107,
-0.2480896711,
0.1139747202,
0.2040178478,
0.4457976222,
-0.7806608081,
-0.4912862182,
0.0811858401,
-0.3903631866,
0.1884166896,
-0.12762402,
-0.746468544,
0.0340824053,
-0.1203200147,
0.5269486904,
-0.2721470594,
-0.0828049332,
0.014565181,
-0.3748509288,
0.1216605082,
0.4673914611,
-0.6292529702,
-0.0028723339,
0.0185288135,
0.6293894053,
0.1888788491,
-0.2044665962,
-0.5613687634,
0.3731378615,
-0.1335895211,
0.8856238723,
-0.5464067459,
-0.0794397369,
-0.2378982753,
0.4088165462,
-0.7988920212,
-0.0368461683,
0.4510524869,
-0.8383980393,
0.5929566622,
0.1052319929,
-0.1058106571,
-0.3790047765,
0.5558239818,
-0.7539314628,
0.8800476789,
0.2515640557,
-0.9440529346,
0.036915604,
-0.5827505589,
-0.4728242159,
0.0675137639,
-0.1846330762,
-0.4144594073,
-0.4371590316,
0.7398170233,
0.2863821089,
-0.0498050302,
0.2204283923,
-0.3410644829,
-0.2067315578,
0.3824530244,
-0.6129432917,
0.4725250006,
0.0732443184,
-0.0236912332,
0.4008958936,
-0.4886941612,
0.1485572159,
0.3384971321,
-0.1052248701,
-0.0430046692,
-0.2780538499,
-0.0605537854,
0.6239411235,
0.1633789241,
-0.7284795642,
0.1205310598,
-0.200175792,
0.7348595262,
0.5344684124,
0.0514416844,
0.4994284213,
-0.10734687,
0.6618941426,
0.0382459238,
0.271590054,
-0.4526722133,
-0.6162514687,
-0.6857748032,
-0.3161023855,
0.2674941421,
0.6792888641,
-1.3785060644,
-0.0797414407,
-0.4627688229,
-0.1895796657,
-0.4798411429,
0.0717662945,
0.2099258453,
1.0654791594,
0.6352750063,
-0.0159805696,
-0.1812858582,
-0.9024996161,
0.3155787885,
-0.1087557301,
-0.0850113556,
0.7539140582,
0.2609471083,
-0.1834628731,
1.0826377869,
-0.7876947522,
-0.4108043909,
-0.3334483206,
0.0704078227,
-0.0409539491,
0.2218442857,
0.4940806329,
-1.098814249,
-0.2246794552,
-0.0827796385,
-0.6376199722,
0.2505875826,
-0.1919834465,
-0.2245375514,
-0.2186358571,
0.6072531939,
-0.6872654557,
0.2666849792,
0.4856205285,
-0.1950746626,
0.3122016191,
-0.0346831754,
0.2057596594,
-0.9562647343,
0.0678698793,
-0.0357103646,
-0.4384454191,
-0.5355283618,
-0.2307652384,
0.3661727905,
-0.3432128429,
-0.3308902383,
0.4815740585,
-0.1626158059,
0.2175432891,
0.0919422582,
0.4348995388,
0.5256234407,
0.8821402788,
-0.155939579,
0.7278325558,
0.327380091,
-0.1955017,
0.5716968775,
0.5476820469,
0.0051048324,
0.4237544239,
-0.8643543124,
0.4064031243,
-0.5102174878,
0.4726393819,
-1.7772858143,
-0.2423940003,
0.4457840919,
-0.3961107731,
0.3149250746,
-0.3770183027,
-0.4505191743,
-0.8083670735,
0.0219700057,
0.6775649786,
0.0957867056,
-0.3857024014,
1.1159944534,
0.0197271332,
-0.2459777296,
-0.4329621792,
-0.621298492,
-0.1071399897,
0.0163191203,
-0.9005536437,
0.1152475029,
-0.108857967,
0.3720878661,
0.2694267929,
0.0225648135,
-0.0671645626,
-0.197230652,
0.0211309139,
0.461746037,
-0.2973535359,
0.3309502006,
0.1735341549,
-0.4098534584,
-0.0205994323,
-0.425210923,
0.4550839067,
-0.0567386411,
-0.505964458,
-0.4271059036,
0.3658095896,
0.5793421865,
-0.6851763129,
0.4103078544,
0.7709713578,
-0.046570614,
0.0802286193,
-0.435498327,
-0.2392229736,
-0.433537364,
0.4603596628,
-0.645814538,
-1.0490578413,
0.3631674051,
-0.146937266,
-0.4163869619,
0.4122776091,
0.4052244425,
-0.2298949212,
1.3794879913,
0.2938462496,
0.2689239979,
0.4256775677,
-0.25613451,
0.3454465568,
-0.7566475272,
-0.316460222,
-0.0748871937,
-0.4560217261,
-0.2223280072,
-0.5237478614,
0.5942160487,
-0.1106179357,
-0.0607015602,
0.0968155414,
-0.3956240118,
0.2948483229,
0.4534620047,
0.3649171293,
0.1573223919,
-0.2389532179,
-0.2123697549,
0.120845072,
-0.8767521977,
-0.2089318335,
0.8300782442,
0.2130718082,
0.7867114544,
-0.0413212255,
0.0653991029,
-0.1646891981,
0.1663981229,
-0.6328679919,
0.3428577185,
0.0433887802,
-0.5545623302,
-0.4965889752,
-0.4247507155,
-0.7979205251,
0.5315561295,
-0.2056069523,
-0.5587218404,
0.2429905832,
0.3050028086,
-0.2539834976,
0.1203989312,
-1.0837210417,
1.3610098362,
-0.0855564624,
-0.2222088575,
0.1561018825,
-1.0541847944,
0.3085241914,
0.2310284227,
0.1489162594,
0.0438631326,
0.1589555442,
0.3949435055,
-0.0679515898,
0.8598003387,
-0.1481616646,
0.0819712728,
0.3844942749,
-0.0409162864,
0.4430636466,
0.3546351194,
0.4722560644,
-0.1269450784,
-0.1412654221,
-0.3217893541,
-1.101328969,
0.4287749231,
-0.701374948,
-0.5614178181,
0.0806989819,
-0.9289892316,
-0.4411922991,
0.4855563939,
0.1095213071,
0.745682478,
0.1986820847,
0.2131837606,
0.6650893688,
0.3783643842,
0.4733739197,
-0.0370725356,
-0.1500505209,
-0.6532229781,
0.9567648172,
0.107055828,
0.4213175476,
0.5077941418,
0.2064023018,
-0.627140224,
-0.1513851434,
-0.8438480496,
0.2594377398,
-0.8878375292,
-0.2162242532,
-1.0909006596,
-0.1639577746,
-0.3431841731,
0.0497920811,
-0.0885288715,
-0.55302912,
-0.1295039356,
-0.1849405617,
0.0421519242,
0.3861313462,
0.4851253331,
0.2364326566,
-0.6225889921,
0.753575027,
0.9754841924,
0.1523894668,
-0.0815737545,
-0.2162459195,
0.0857858956,
0.087197341,
-0.3073713779,
-0.9005641341,
-0.0069297981,
0.0904208198,
0.6910178065,
0.2230660766,
-0.0455214754,
0.6197518706,
-0.5431800485,
0.5144683123,
0.2992231846,
-0.6655496955,
0.4549634457,
-0.1930729598,
0.5916371346,
0.4026952088,
0.4599048495,
-0.4380077422,
-0.371183604,
-0.336980015,
-0.7035836577,
0.6936211586,
0.2967733443,
0.1887759715,
0.0551686622,
0.1702414751,
-0.1360500902,
0.2372853458,
-0.8581745625,
-0.3741811514,
-1.0101659298,
-0.3388732374,
-0.2788169384,
-0.0894720629,
-0.3160155416,
-0.3734368086,
0.213800326,
-0.7826498151,
0.3596065342,
0.3104189634,
-0.4072132409,
0.288359791,
0.33167243,
0.4329829216,
0.7327337861,
0.1228550449,
0.612663269,
0.116504848,
-0.3418032825,
0.147269085,
0.3989773989,
-0.2367482185,
-0.1312101483,
0.2605778873,
0.8450161815,
0.0839932561,
-0.4203967452,
0.5609738827,
-0.365065217,
-0.2162170559,
0.3069731593,
-0.1353688538,
0.4123321176,
0.3482899666,
0.2972643375,
0.1819201559,
0.2051281035,
-0.2477138788,
0.1898159385,
0.3309519589,
-0.66217345,
-0.220893383,
0.7420063615,
0.0189983007,
0.0909211412,
0.657119751,
-0.006571833,
-0.6368026137,
0.5376345515,
0.774078846,
0.4716043472,
-0.0843110234,
0.3968110085,
0.2687377632,
0.3267715275,
0.6679061651,
0.2956080437,
-0.3120483756,
-0.8371886015,
-0.6230038404,
-0.1656436324,
-0.1864427477,
-0.2583407164,
-0.2655630708,
-0.1130196303,
-0.1418153942,
-0.1987131536,
0.2352084816,
-0.6009312272,
-0.6014012694,
0.4101783633,
0.1736104637,
0.3815771937,
-0.8203628659,
0.6546714902,
0.8130612373,
-0.612726748,
-0.7802882791,
-0.2126868516,
-0.4184649289,
-0.8165252209,
0.6678652167,
0.2307963222,
-0.3951677978,
0.3510424197,
-0.4557836652,
-0.833764255,
1.0513763428,
0.5189954042,
-0.0589311607,
-0.1893221885,
0.1485738158,
0.3068847954,
-0.2674570084,
0.6170594096,
-0.0510159582,
0.5093852282,
0.4880628288,
-0.5932148695,
0.1001324952,
-0.4509622753,
-0.0000467789,
0.2583959103,
-0.6971443295,
0.8321408033,
-0.1554261744,
-0.3264083862,
-0.4071343541,
0.7067205906,
-0.1628711671,
0.1108433902,
0.7242903709,
0.3820607364,
0.600068152,
-0.2406673133,
1.0707919598,
-0.2223782241,
0.3538514376,
1.008633852,
-0.0736931041,
0.3194956183,
0.4539830685,
0.0523835123,
0.7767995,
0.3368786871,
0.1806812882,
0.4882757962,
-0.2407304794,
0.1454560906,
-0.7208025455,
-0.1885140389,
-0.2492135614,
0.3873865008,
0.0919226184,
-0.1348798573,
-0.4507870972,
0.1964956522,
-0.2577577531,
-0.0849983618,
-0.1186932698,
0.7792073488,
-0.1985803545,
-0.6042028666,
0.3002862334,
-0.2538940012,
0.0717517436,
-0.7813354135,
-0.2314603627,
0.0138658527,
0.0787417367,
-0.1470683217,
-0.9361465573,
0.1624362469,
-0.6116850972,
-0.4199161828,
-0.3838753402,
0.8258683681,
-0.5019331574,
-0.5037428737,
0.1409022063,
0.5435524583,
-0.4653464258,
-0.0800810009,
-0.5319210291,
-0.3475327194,
-0.2552601993,
-0.2850075364,
0.0452205017,
0.454066366,
-0.1933653206,
0.7775371671,
0.6994226575,
-0.5909823179,
0.2022437155,
0.3655712605,
1.1779720783,
-0.2935878634,
-0.7207567096,
-0.5065842271,
0.6507828832,
-0.1254542619,
-0.3110268116,
0.9578139782,
0.5042815208,
0.7107305527,
-0.0373745933,
0.5033640265,
0.1054985821,
0.1820153296,
-0.5762887597,
0.4321631193,
-0.6390683055,
-0.4969998002,
-0.3303374052,
-0.7097848654,
-0.2741852105,
0.5247091651,
-0.4620929956,
0.0653910115,
0.9435138106,
0.599394083,
-0.2264325917,
0.0965365469,
0.2764944732,
0.0270494409,
0.3128431141,
0.621162951,
0.9177780747,
-0.393350929,
0.9462758303,
-0.258782506,
-0.0667397231,
0.1120933443,
-0.5361853242,
-0.979370594,
-0.5997296572,
-0.1788366884,
-0.3093461096,
-0.2568171322,
0.2284075171,
0.6704730988,
-0.5583440661,
0.3196395636,
0.2852888107,
0.4048838615,
-0.2437144369,
-0.2956111133,
0.5836231709,
-0.344345361,
-0.5527864099,
0.2534230351,
0.4643136859,
0.0232045669,
-0.1710991412,
0.1845469177,
-0.44337219,
-0.0910047069,
0.7065830827,
-0.0112272706,
-0.6104051471,
-0.569504261,
0.3683482409,
-0.1562095284,
0.4160020351,
0.8571436405,
-0.8534371257,
0.8819373846,
0.6034136415,
0.6083418727,
0.8816294074,
0.2350963503,
0.2952486575,
-0.6860583425,
0.1339205652,
0.1846244484,
0.5022997856,
0.2517979145,
-0.4020577669,
0.2194311172,
0.3340026438,
-0.3586137593,
-0.2388283759,
0.4144676328,
-1.1633253098,
-0.2217734605,
0.8774851561,
-0.1228052825,
-0.3892205358,
-0.4326483309,
-0.6452825069,
0.2059417665,
-0.1765525937,
0.2259755284,
0.455884248,
-0.2944326401,
-0.4946764112,
-0.3281674683,
0.0681902096,
0.1288768649,
-0.9258457422,
-0.2933004498,
0.6755016446,
0.1004448608,
0.5077604651,
0.5504977703,
-0.0085109835,
0.4239738882,
0.0521541238,
-0.0663957447,
-0.4282046854,
-0.6238566041,
0.0250328165,
0.7044346929,
-0.4322637618,
-0.279280901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00522v1 | How to enumerate trees from a context-free grammar | 2023-04-30T16:40:54 | 2023-04-30T16:40:54 | Steven T. Piantadosi | cs.CL | cs.CL | I present a simple algorithm for enumerating the trees generated by a Context
Free Grammar (CFG). The algorithm uses a pairing function to form a bijection
between CFG derivations and natural numbers, so that trees can be uniquely
decoded from counting. This provides a general way to number expressions in
natural logical languages, and potentially can be extended to other
combinatorial problems. I also show how this algorithm may be generalized to
more general forms of derivation, including analogs of Lempel-Ziv coding on
trees. | [
-0.2894548476,
-0.7998494506,
0.5831612349,
0.3774670959,
-0.6808396578,
-0.0149178728,
0.0258227661,
-0.6229839921,
0.3802028298,
0.141111955,
-0.7538693547,
-0.2518615425,
-0.4785079956,
0.3550685346,
-0.533965826,
0.6615555286,
0.3635407388,
0.0240433365,
-0.6053429842,
-0.1376604289,
-0.2814033031,
-0.7238768935,
-0.3471247852,
0.0352229364,
0.2503422201,
0.4787589014,
0.3757594228,
0.6787182093,
0.4313088953,
0.4534053206,
-0.0753052309,
0.0695571005,
-0.3787963092,
0.1233108714,
0.1044309586,
-0.07730221,
-0.1544971913,
-0.2065478414,
0.827886343,
0.90785712,
-0.0369868018,
0.0790746883,
0.091197066,
0.4479598701,
-0.315439254,
0.2343995422,
-0.6381803751,
-0.1329800785,
-0.3849332333,
-0.5465134382,
-0.6533809304,
-0.2295325994,
0.1921730191,
-0.603397429,
0.1591306478,
-0.0042545102,
0.5510610342,
0.1392151564,
-0.5044522285,
-0.4778006673,
-0.3673734367,
0.6678281426,
-0.5824657679,
0.2665964365,
0.4151499271,
0.4175539613,
-0.2237924188,
-0.7978499532,
-0.2490527183,
-0.1160746962,
-0.7400385737,
0.1791234016,
-0.0891501158,
0.0807518065,
0.3207157552,
0.7624490857,
-0.5848691463,
-0.4803339541,
-0.3951670825,
0.0722390786,
0.5147785544,
-0.1613470763,
0.4809001982,
-0.2644269466,
-0.0983701199,
0.1429595053,
-0.5648766756,
0.1879832298,
0.0133589664,
0.2729071677,
-0.1371631175,
0.3699684739,
-0.3741903007,
1.2802014351,
0.0785824805,
0.0920564905,
0.0759734362,
-0.4680809081,
-0.7736002207,
0.0530148484,
0.2713046968,
0.0889804736,
0.130436033,
-0.5921481252,
-0.0163037591,
0.1484860331,
-0.2095898688,
-0.8808895946,
-0.0545456707,
-0.1649774611,
-0.3821629882,
-0.416860342,
0.6744381785,
-0.6226828098,
0.091037266,
-0.1497885585,
0.2931462824,
-0.3931313455,
0.0581488572,
0.06597808,
-0.3228858411,
0.4149397612,
0.085097298,
-1.0691075325,
0.7587638497,
0.9894903898,
0.5824466944,
0.5250324607,
-0.0235552322,
-1.3032670021,
0.1586751044,
-0.1840518564,
0.4946349263,
-0.9020825624,
-0.7222155333,
-0.0782499164,
0.2519811988,
-0.2485404164,
-0.4854067564,
0.449169755,
-0.2632781863,
0.2879462838,
-0.5789269209,
-0.746686399,
-0.6206604838,
0.0514585413,
-0.6357941031,
0.7950708866,
0.4048653543,
-0.6244022846,
0.049112957,
-0.598649919,
-0.5000193715,
0.804997921,
-0.4132344127,
0.2202910036,
0.3835416138,
0.0027449813,
0.256275326,
-0.3682868481,
0.3664420247,
-0.1655985266,
-0.3724216223,
-0.1495192498,
0.0236001555,
1.5231405497,
0.2811620235,
-0.1427693814,
0.1547768861,
-0.5807096362,
0.3645991683,
0.0254780408,
-0.2196569145,
-0.5350624323,
0.145197928,
-0.2286177725,
-0.0221568346,
0.0641022772,
-0.5470607281,
0.2077581435,
-0.6048623323,
0.500451684,
0.4775228202,
0.4144642651,
0.4091291726,
-0.4082933366,
0.1451069266,
-0.1444181353,
-0.3195237815,
-0.4167218804,
-0.8127785921,
-0.901602149,
-0.2220459431,
0.239528507,
0.6030784845,
-0.5209810734,
0.8362460136,
-0.1491640806,
-0.3850732446,
-0.0948641822,
0.3212945163,
0.341017127,
0.2845934629,
0.0465760455,
-0.426851362,
-0.6318341494,
-0.707244873,
-0.2279073894,
-0.1814871281,
-0.0153684746,
0.2414302379,
0.2287400514,
-0.1841014773,
1.0222346783,
-0.3316233456,
0.2275021821,
0.1154183969,
0.1231569499,
0.1819762886,
0.7054636478,
1.1185799837,
-0.6883016825,
-0.501778543,
0.0248385817,
-0.7273888588,
-0.2327333838,
0.0297415368,
-0.4643270373,
0.2142877132,
0.725102365,
-0.5662801266,
0.535363853,
0.4004972577,
-0.8521949649,
-0.0154903894,
0.1123221889,
-0.1430173963,
-0.7865176201,
0.2733020186,
-0.3567886651,
-0.4508816004,
-0.7915458083,
0.4649378359,
-0.2397661209,
0.2299361974,
-0.3087072968,
0.3954809606,
-0.398830235,
-0.2437656373,
0.2475854456,
-0.3606784642,
-0.1484401375,
0.5206561089,
0.0291204918,
0.1418981254,
0.7152653337,
-0.597043097,
0.3823580444,
-0.0786144286,
-0.375110805,
0.6544898748,
-0.3232898116,
0.2595134974,
-0.2475814968,
0.1044206917,
-0.8095639348,
-0.1821790189,
0.4405972362,
-0.2347325385,
-0.2366048992,
-0.3301799297,
-0.4179908633,
-0.2608979642,
-0.1276390105,
0.7021411657,
0.3179577291,
-0.9423440695,
0.3591702282,
0.0753180534,
-0.0204317719,
0.0405190997,
-0.4160360694,
-0.256729871,
-0.2357782274,
-0.6623262763,
0.6668910384,
-0.3360347748,
-0.6217109561,
0.3262780905,
-0.250955224,
-0.0977950916,
0.3206298947,
0.3038406968,
-0.0295641068,
-0.1626177877,
0.0238880161,
-0.2196501493,
0.0281913392,
0.0418046974,
-0.3684234917,
0.6639732718,
-0.6977401972,
-0.305767417,
0.0280874502,
0.8142773509,
0.3652326167,
-0.3029060662,
0.200585708,
0.3689447641,
-1.0908228159,
-0.1878538281,
0.1111033335,
-0.2511087656,
-0.5315791368,
-0.0697060302,
-0.3976070583,
-0.7957370877,
0.2371884137,
0.2133511007,
0.2831191719,
0.5762485266,
0.2916719913,
0.2026900351,
0.7496317029,
0.639678061,
0.196779266,
0.4574263692,
-0.2351227254,
0.2966865897,
-0.1421869397,
-0.3225230277,
-0.5590215921,
-0.3346304595,
-0.6053894758,
-0.3221319914,
-0.1041157171,
0.8736987114,
-0.1710255593,
0.4978549778,
-0.5825039148,
0.9423806071,
1.0353111029,
-0.2401875854,
0.3941212296,
0.2546595037,
-0.3554257154,
0.3506755531,
-0.6019842029,
-0.1404562294,
0.4339036644,
-0.2667690217,
0.0305549186,
0.505936861,
1.1783682108,
0.2305438966,
0.6706151366,
-1.0830360651,
0.8622745872,
-0.3218564987,
-0.5110723972,
-0.1949274987,
-0.5243546367,
-0.734587729,
0.0265559461,
-0.1662608981,
-1.2360674143,
0.0929359123,
0.0835651904,
-0.4924702942,
0.0101843635,
-0.5665995479,
0.8539962769,
-0.4868842959,
0.0321986377,
-0.3296714723,
-0.479426682,
0.4203417301,
0.2764609456,
0.0254103802,
-0.019954076,
0.5205613375,
1.0200659037,
-0.6441461444,
0.6409260035,
-0.1886668056,
0.4198097587,
0.8745079041,
0.5254938006,
0.2639088929,
0.0905752182,
0.2162960172,
-0.1317356527,
0.3999646306,
-0.5330580473,
-0.5228222013,
0.9076009393,
-0.5292964578,
-0.6321597099,
-0.70795542,
-0.1955130845,
-0.2481367737,
0.3424912393,
0.2856595516,
0.5796517134,
-0.4615986347,
0.5176677108,
-0.357147336,
0.0170456804,
1.1699430943,
0.3171344399,
-0.5231731534,
-0.6565628648,
0.7603012323,
0.3366770148,
-0.0726645216,
0.5232871771,
0.3296454549,
-0.3030541837,
0.1082540452,
-0.3947046399,
-0.0164331999,
-0.7011171579,
-0.2490708977,
-0.1811926812,
-0.4911114573,
-0.3680267334,
-0.5328521132,
0.540786922,
-0.7834515572,
0.1671178937,
-0.4606796205,
0.6777446866,
0.8854241371,
-0.0908425003,
0.6206566691,
-0.6225998402,
0.2743315995,
0.9682447314,
0.5781756043,
-0.0386157818,
0.0189753044,
-0.0778055638,
0.0234898496,
-0.2566029429,
-1.2518196106,
0.4704117477,
0.335192591,
0.3999821246,
0.8138243556,
-0.0416634828,
1.0941803455,
-0.1766375005,
0.3601048887,
0.1871725917,
-1.2678034306,
0.0940472633,
-0.4792336226,
0.1317773908,
0.4341546893,
-0.0252446011,
-1.0050326586,
0.2008059174,
-1.1198964119,
-0.6314364076,
0.7073867321,
0.3328866661,
-0.2639137506,
-0.4635344148,
0.1465769261,
-0.2287674993,
0.0422144495,
-0.7081353068,
-0.099020794,
-0.3844043612,
-0.2397949845,
-0.2422563881,
-0.2849359214,
-0.4282048345,
-0.5790560842,
0.3767411709,
-0.0916052461,
0.4938388169,
0.2260541767,
-0.212252304,
-0.3124943674,
0.2148134857,
0.5628111959,
0.5296028852,
-0.4238979816,
0.6675797701,
-0.0015609745,
0.0950861424,
-0.1215286106,
0.1254377514,
-0.3236338794,
0.1257215738,
0.3713606,
0.5478023887,
0.2571210563,
-0.4983477294,
0.2146801353,
0.3755306602,
-0.3808874786,
-0.2243503183,
-0.0707074255,
0.5257496834,
-0.234287411,
0.3119733334,
0.0817268789,
0.3082883358,
-0.6701292992,
0.560946703,
0.6454592347,
-0.263455987,
-0.3430834115,
0.2926355898,
0.5921971798,
-0.8455767632,
0.6304652691,
-0.4014824033,
-0.4262227118,
1.0330216885,
1.0069587231,
1.0903654099,
-0.0264946129,
0.2373951375,
0.4772664309,
0.2480165064,
-0.0266156308,
0.3991710544,
-0.3411968946,
-0.7212494016,
-0.0428934917,
-0.6776503325,
-0.1938108802,
0.1309921443,
-0.5233246684,
0.1455109864,
-0.881934762,
0.2341050059,
0.2571671307,
-0.0297342855,
-0.8887604475,
0.0781692713,
0.4502847195,
0.9165704846,
-0.7149698138,
0.9239442945,
0.7346597314,
-0.0848599523,
-0.5290983319,
-0.2248033732,
0.2477628589,
-0.709354043,
0.2527086735,
0.7442098856,
-0.1348972023,
0.3091341257,
-0.6528576612,
-0.7646611333,
0.9365819097,
0.1838039905,
-0.5621092319,
0.3124600947,
0.0813354701,
0.2738050818,
-0.5806560516,
0.1494187117,
0.5522165895,
0.726033926,
0.0440147221,
-0.5184663534,
0.2035499364,
-0.7050175667,
-0.1589273065,
0.1060292646,
-0.4680663049,
0.6621623039,
0.0848519877,
-0.7964500785,
0.1515482962,
0.35596627,
-0.0408751853,
0.3824954927,
0.7747173905,
0.8528458476,
0.9164130092,
-0.2333980501,
0.8508294225,
-0.4842715859,
0.1811931431,
0.964820385,
-0.0606621765,
0.5396135449,
0.6809383631,
-0.0675542429,
0.4716947079,
0.7703873515,
0.2228121161,
0.4496340454,
0.2292507589,
-0.8255022764,
-0.5198922753,
0.0881655887,
-0.2271262109,
0.308334738,
0.2192304432,
-0.5290308595,
-0.5437051058,
-0.7515084147,
0.102840364,
0.079496339,
-0.3510386646,
0.8774699569,
0.070387207,
-1.2460855246,
0.6522325277,
0.4375950098,
0.3286367059,
-0.3962033093,
-0.257219851,
-0.1956504881,
-0.0016915231,
-0.3975323141,
-0.4302365184,
0.5441179872,
-0.1304530799,
0.0006411691,
-0.3964779973,
0.3766935766,
-0.6672904491,
-0.9260843992,
0.3001931608,
0.7732380033,
0.1061042771,
0.182390064,
-0.0898271874,
-0.510281086,
-0.0008723101,
0.0857250318,
-0.0238180086,
0.3555570841,
-0.4972868264,
0.1897970885,
0.6219679117,
-0.5953339338,
0.3865918517,
-0.1685927063,
0.5999587178,
-1.1170022488,
-0.6260936856,
-1.1270601749,
0.1543150544,
0.0104309153,
-0.1263354719,
0.4854677916,
0.712694943,
0.6742350459,
-0.2431526482,
0.822414875,
-0.5650997758,
0.0351695605,
-0.2216898054,
0.357128948,
-0.0371180773,
-0.0406191982,
-0.1720121801,
-0.9893543124,
-0.5795338154,
0.9757555127,
-0.146121338,
-0.3460584283,
0.6958790421,
0.7167904377,
-0.0551208518,
0.2042264193,
0.2310966849,
0.0331025571,
0.2136105895,
0.7950071692,
0.607244432,
-0.1338692009,
0.3438286185,
-0.4699273705,
-0.2937046885,
-0.2543807924,
-1.0379416943,
-0.6114285588,
-0.6733235717,
-0.1116091385,
-0.1997544616,
-0.1779092401,
1.0170943737,
0.8557736874,
-0.8915007114,
-0.5395171642,
-0.6187634468,
0.4817309082,
-0.5248965025,
-0.1733261943,
0.1412820071,
-0.0766732916,
-0.5849382281,
0.6342304945,
0.1570764929,
0.3187608719,
0.3280755877,
-0.4779761434,
-0.2253075987,
0.2295164019,
0.8340895772,
0.5916290283,
-0.7102974653,
-0.5138513446,
-0.0157061312,
0.1047091708,
-0.0261659138,
1.0554677248,
-1.2216191292,
0.3985221088,
0.9863736629,
0.3707186282,
0.4055421948,
0.5702502131,
0.5307568908,
-0.9060540795,
0.3134364784,
-0.0275071822,
0.7254673243,
0.1365576684,
-0.0903438628,
0.6961215138,
0.7839254141,
0.0491128489,
-0.826793015,
0.6347948313,
-1.3516026735,
-0.0846003965,
0.9970246553,
-0.0232246239,
-0.1038256288,
0.2146091163,
-0.1769445837,
-0.0915143639,
-0.077693373,
0.3431073725,
0.7802355886,
-0.2293955535,
-0.1712337881,
0.2111325413,
0.7682259083,
0.3050812781,
-0.9726350904,
-0.0348027311,
0.5776513815,
0.2610463798,
0.2646890283,
0.8538606167,
-0.1432248652,
0.2052984536,
-0.0665447265,
-0.3233303428,
0.015676327,
-0.4298632145,
-0.1865339875,
0.2505349815,
-0.0832271278,
-0.2449334264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03169v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03169v2 | Sensitive Data Detection with High-Throughput Machine Learning Models in Electrical Health Records | 2023-04-30T16:14:23 | 2023-05-22T00:07:33 | Kai Zhang, Xiaoqian Jiang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | In the era of big data, there is an increasing need for healthcare providers,
communities, and researchers to share data and collaborate to improve health
outcomes, generate valuable insights, and advance research. The Health
Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) is a federal law
designed to protect sensitive health information by defining regulations for
protected health information (PHI). However, it does not provide efficient
tools for detecting or removing PHI before data sharing. One of the challenges
in this area of research is the heterogeneous nature of PHI fields in data
across different parties. This variability makes rule-based sensitive variable
identification systems that work on one database fail on another. To address
this issue, our paper explores the use of machine learning algorithms to
identify sensitive variables in structured data, thus facilitating the
de-identification process. We made a key observation that the distributions of
metadata of PHI fields and non-PHI fields are very different. Based on this
novel finding, we engineered over 30 features from the metadata of the original
features and used machine learning to build classification models to
automatically identify PHI fields in structured Electronic Health Record (EHR)
data. We trained the model on a variety of large EHR databases from different
data sources and found that our algorithm achieves 99% accuracy when detecting
PHI-related fields for unseen datasets. The implications of our study are
significant and can benefit industries that handle sensitive data. | [
0.0071823965,
-0.9821020365,
0.6111462116,
0.0241673179,
0.0930747315,
-0.1013830602,
0.2815178037,
-0.7866864204,
-0.1965306252,
0.6625700593,
-0.3957722783,
-0.5897715092,
-0.5572264791,
-0.0243109744,
-0.1589243412,
0.9052807689,
-0.0588645563,
-0.2286861092,
-0.1057111323,
-0.1904977113,
-0.246020332,
-0.8543617725,
0.28700912,
-0.5814432502,
0.4169147015,
0.4396878183,
0.523132503,
0.9091801047,
0.9604173899,
0.2594114244,
0.0456865877,
0.0873206705,
-0.2701320946,
0.248111248,
0.0423044823,
-0.2710494399,
-0.5958787203,
-0.2868639231,
0.5422598124,
0.66812253,
0.030771466,
0.4267536402,
-0.1978488863,
0.601485908,
-0.8060615063,
0.3754808605,
-0.7786101103,
0.4506705701,
-0.4057796896,
-0.6486369967,
-0.3782656789,
-0.1435218602,
0.1150221527,
-0.4321521521,
0.4511864185,
0.0666185096,
1.2009623051,
0.283901155,
-0.6320447922,
0.1371548027,
-1.0291758776,
0.7405679226,
-0.2612164021,
0.3452253342,
0.6262013912,
0.2797644138,
-0.0133210355,
-0.6675897837,
-0.1598009914,
0.1525639594,
-0.0575215966,
-0.191936627,
-0.3315257132,
-0.002140088,
0.6136206388,
0.4040628374,
-0.5600227118,
0.4526899159,
-0.5872182846,
-0.0997247845,
0.6075669527,
0.2915333807,
0.001532456,
-0.2515692115,
-0.1839328855,
0.0762165114,
-0.5382845402,
0.1128262356,
0.1973795593,
0.426389873,
-0.0346561298,
0.4555546045,
-0.2183206677,
0.1374010742,
0.2444721013,
-0.1334280074,
0.8327665329,
0.1571648866,
-0.6405544281,
0.2448730469,
0.5769615769,
-0.0863852203,
-0.2887671292,
0.0810346007,
-0.29330194,
-0.0093318541,
0.3727003038,
-0.8143129349,
-0.4777905345,
0.3903656304,
-0.9985897541,
-0.417861104,
0.1076907888,
-0.6173830032,
-0.701597929,
-0.3077520132,
0.323189199,
-0.206320703,
-0.1665869504,
-0.0353284404,
0.0213504639,
0.1617833674,
-0.0770422667,
-0.8258481622,
0.1285468042,
0.9014135003,
0.5428586006,
0.2046742439,
-0.0870020986,
-0.630320549,
0.2079624087,
-0.02672581,
0.4384797215,
-0.6340284944,
-0.2073672265,
-0.0616808459,
0.2136306316,
-0.0757632777,
-0.7071750164,
0.4968909621,
-0.7482125759,
-0.1105638668,
-0.0598016605,
-0.5339671969,
-0.2443043292,
0.2401355505,
-0.9144573212,
0.5677472949,
0.3617112637,
-1.1889914274,
0.7563501,
-0.4612114429,
-0.5362965465,
0.3584607542,
-0.2835725546,
-1.6143169403,
0.1628416777,
0.00395787,
0.6272424459,
-0.2093782276,
0.1855185628,
-0.7291198969,
-0.2684057057,
0.2931734324,
-0.2170943767,
0.8927569389,
0.2518953085,
-0.2359319776,
0.347622484,
-1.0079054832,
0.0995712802,
0.0943304673,
-0.3286609352,
-0.3989239335,
-0.0900242329,
0.2273843586,
0.2301296443,
-0.2782279849,
-0.4266276658,
-0.0988080502,
-0.060970135,
0.2716441154,
0.6440570951,
0.3012973666,
0.1567552835,
-0.7729229927,
0.4953731298,
0.2752717733,
0.3878706396,
-0.165118739,
-0.5957733989,
0.1250588447,
-0.7436974049,
0.1454990953,
0.7907693386,
0.093508482,
0.9348679781,
-0.2445159405,
-0.6276046038,
-0.6574981213,
-0.0103598218,
0.0982755944,
0.9533913136,
0.5638718605,
-0.2183693945,
-0.6014244556,
-0.8318374753,
-0.0093796635,
-0.146215409,
-0.4514506459,
0.4700012207,
0.3983898759,
-0.69209373,
0.4764022827,
-0.3757791519,
-0.3961524367,
0.2205092907,
0.2001986504,
0.2436508685,
0.6635740995,
0.2655909657,
-1.0685559511,
-0.2233431041,
0.2438326478,
-1.0737609863,
0.0349231288,
0.0488609225,
0.1297296733,
-0.4099767506,
0.2419787645,
-0.4278397262,
0.6857857108,
0.2122280449,
-0.3171984851,
0.3491461873,
-0.4508503675,
0.3338032961,
-0.5793458819,
0.5012381077,
0.0559005998,
-0.1046345234,
-0.8402432203,
-0.0774720609,
0.3509453237,
-0.2253929377,
-0.2843126059,
-0.1667403579,
-0.3215052187,
0.0705918148,
-0.0193506498,
-0.8572819233,
0.1716708243,
0.2933093607,
-0.0764434189,
0.1554604769,
0.6354076266,
-0.6786378622,
0.3178427517,
0.5206980109,
-0.3252764344,
0.44824332,
-0.6003170013,
0.1819263399,
-0.2313001752,
0.104279153,
-0.2944981754,
-0.4089342654,
0.3830440044,
-0.0836471319,
0.3626006246,
-0.2415939271,
-0.1869218796,
-0.4817399085,
-0.3163559735,
0.5888283253,
0.5524314642,
-0.3449427783,
0.7046421766,
0.8432160616,
-0.020954052,
-0.5000750422,
-0.8048613667,
-0.3897970021,
-0.578432858,
-0.3834817708,
0.6142672896,
0.1342734694,
-0.294551909,
0.0923227072,
-0.0458886847,
-0.6930466294,
0.6039246321,
0.7562445402,
0.4804911315,
-0.2729100585,
0.4638379812,
0.0357563533,
-0.1351093352,
0.324311763,
-0.2714300156,
0.2252230793,
0.1440227032,
-0.5339519978,
-0.9881531,
0.5515415668,
0.5898057818,
-0.3390162289,
0.6964366436,
0.4245299697,
-0.7621569037,
0.0144320298,
-0.1237196848,
-0.1614960879,
-0.4017258584,
0.3662082553,
-0.5630222559,
-0.4069391787,
0.5331484079,
-0.1348844618,
0.1607162207,
0.5833155513,
0.3769976199,
-0.1515650898,
0.8695747852,
0.6919092536,
-0.3032291532,
0.3790163696,
-0.0968468115,
0.327717185,
-0.5032259226,
-0.403273046,
-0.8300694823,
-0.3587294817,
-1.0368132591,
0.0375479311,
0.2802941799,
-0.2272885889,
-0.3692880273,
0.1262469292,
-0.5369032025,
0.0099111618,
0.3720030189,
0.7428465486,
0.3928641379,
0.1094314829,
0.3037548959,
0.1355625242,
-0.2049506009,
-0.4537383616,
1.4033032656,
0.7438518405,
0.6295877695,
-0.0369960293,
0.6483246088,
0.5990723372,
0.2836594582,
-0.621363163,
-0.0870421678,
-0.0762127042,
-0.4781429172,
-0.4257301092,
-0.7516680956,
-1.2744630575,
-0.2120718807,
-0.5946417451,
-0.5852137208,
0.5274451971,
0.2788938284,
-0.3559458554,
0.4537861049,
-0.3396988511,
0.7438051105,
0.1880918443,
-0.2573700547,
-0.0524157733,
-0.7143080831,
0.2206748426,
-0.4466097653,
0.1465848088,
-0.1160508692,
0.311249584,
0.519471705,
-0.4021036029,
0.3172133267,
-0.0904274136,
0.0434362181,
0.1016495153,
-0.1372777373,
0.3367534578,
-0.0169809144,
-0.3854272664,
0.4071743488,
-0.0556303896,
-0.6151742935,
-0.2666454315,
0.3692911267,
-0.6424286366,
-0.1295224726,
-0.2555207312,
-0.5563616157,
-0.3317736387,
0.2341623753,
0.4576909244,
0.2431420833,
0.003450555,
0.3614270091,
1.0296900272,
-0.1653287411,
-0.105850935,
0.2191342115,
0.2802867591,
0.0721006617,
0.8237190843,
0.2145549506,
-0.2470042408,
0.5578502417,
0.2255274951,
0.1142654419,
-0.5039688945,
-0.075593479,
0.0614522696,
-0.4122123122,
-0.3434903026,
-0.8314519525,
-0.332652688,
-0.4665472507,
0.1051620021,
0.1180893481,
-0.0563953258,
-0.4943432212,
-0.2403721064,
0.2115528733,
0.429169476,
0.0369981565,
0.0832006857,
-0.9791660309,
0.4829362929,
0.2973665297,
0.2757023871,
-0.4292860925,
-0.4079423845,
-0.0210884288,
-0.2476172149,
-0.2925280631,
-0.8356862664,
0.4541196823,
0.0869466886,
0.500569582,
0.5677045584,
0.0863826647,
0.1863052398,
-0.3034953177,
0.1596473902,
0.0254229493,
-0.7916507125,
0.5672010183,
-0.1823518127,
-0.1270011812,
0.5079607964,
0.5171917677,
-0.1828555316,
0.0120040718,
-0.8558778763,
-0.849460423,
0.4276486635,
-0.0071264934,
-0.146079585,
0.4221909046,
0.2051445246,
0.2951795757,
0.2583993971,
-0.2719233632,
-0.2390430123,
0.0214236435,
-0.3907699287,
0.4289169312,
-0.0341257825,
-0.0784492791,
0.0092638638,
0.6310768723,
0.0463784225,
0.3080940545,
0.085970901,
-0.1419323236,
-0.5507494211,
0.4072244763,
-0.0350087248,
0.5735999942,
-0.3686904013,
0.2167274207,
-0.0953637213,
-0.6774933934,
-0.0051941341,
0.5537329316,
-0.4154475033,
0.0364192836,
0.4090257883,
0.5885702372,
-0.3319370449,
-0.4975885451,
0.5506476164,
-0.085984014,
-0.2885429561,
0.0078043295,
0.0801077932,
-0.6230329275,
0.0862508118,
0.3047745824,
0.2293994427,
0.5342412591,
-0.6056710482,
0.5777104497,
0.2605519295,
-0.5721619725,
-0.3083662689,
0.632032752,
-0.0901055261,
-0.2653841078,
0.8532820344,
0.2924697697,
-0.4045081139,
0.8191366792,
0.1775921136,
0.7282295823,
-0.5894144773,
-0.0930334032,
0.0447139516,
0.0096287355,
0.2609229088,
0.5134299994,
-0.0869271755,
-0.4730401635,
-0.036410626,
-0.1540690362,
-0.3236706555,
0.5847346783,
-0.8372986913,
0.177844137,
-0.6247532368,
-0.2623729408,
0.4380527735,
0.1265931129,
-1.0941364765,
0.2480787188,
0.078550525,
0.4922755957,
-1.3080790043,
0.7274310589,
0.3372346163,
-0.2480441332,
-0.8512599468,
0.0667720437,
0.1214772314,
-0.2578281164,
0.5389070511,
0.3118577003,
0.4074419141,
-0.329031527,
-0.1922570616,
-0.2816901505,
0.8490484357,
0.257111907,
-0.6142913699,
0.0580993854,
0.1718642712,
0.4195670187,
0.1135658547,
0.1536968797,
0.5271689296,
0.4622297287,
-0.4201219678,
-1.0144838095,
-0.009155089,
-0.2845675051,
-0.4460298717,
0.2867948413,
-0.1628044397,
1.0467242002,
-0.0568961091,
-0.1149777249,
-0.4486443698,
0.738414228,
0.3436670899,
0.9740453959,
0.3940252066,
0.2780884206,
1.5400317907,
0.1084892005,
0.7943894863,
-0.0105345184,
0.4302429259,
0.9598050714,
-0.6891689301,
0.4374378026,
0.1789329052,
-0.1843195409,
0.5437523127,
0.4748894274,
-0.4476412833,
0.4431564212,
0.1869300902,
-0.4202820361,
-0.0756132007,
-0.2686071694,
-0.555888176,
0.3765219748,
0.3085999787,
-0.7979541421,
0.2308531404,
0.2866095006,
-0.3598647118,
0.0790293142,
-0.3568152189,
0.7059214115,
-0.0904307067,
0.0406807251,
0.0994674638,
0.0999804512,
0.3000134826,
-0.3625735044,
-0.2247995287,
0.1701297313,
0.2406948358,
-0.6547058225,
-0.5029199123,
0.3936178684,
0.0362720564,
-0.5841169953,
-0.2606329918,
1.0189239979,
-0.0066042761,
-0.3581221998,
0.1435973346,
0.2541053891,
0.043446362,
-0.1184440479,
-0.5461243391,
-0.0861336663,
-0.3478758633,
-0.2530728579,
0.2705710232,
0.6717116237,
-0.2472253442,
0.5512568355,
0.6497291327,
0.3270164728,
-0.1668987572,
0.0537645482,
0.6940637827,
-0.5409606099,
-0.8213441372,
-0.6627613306,
0.2677866817,
-0.2670851052,
-0.1485192329,
0.3678716421,
0.6814489961,
0.5982298851,
-0.0903262421,
0.7963362336,
0.1824057996,
0.7841820121,
-0.3249284327,
0.6381340027,
0.0026611069,
0.388394475,
-0.10221228,
-0.3681509793,
-0.6101682782,
0.3154000044,
-0.2635164261,
-0.102529116,
0.366512388,
0.6429668665,
-0.338748157,
0.028181877,
0.2777448595,
0.0810905322,
0.5149989724,
0.6122745275,
0.4700734913,
-0.5483530164,
0.2864019275,
-0.4421496987,
-0.3806709349,
-0.3978840709,
-0.6573469639,
-0.5944218636,
-0.4451589882,
-0.5626217127,
-0.433791697,
-0.0748884678,
0.8638265133,
1.0047433376,
-1.1276637316,
0.3229081929,
-0.054319717,
0.2372334301,
-0.545938015,
-0.2079154402,
0.7013580203,
0.1666835696,
-0.1242736951,
0.3050342202,
0.3090122342,
-0.0098543875,
0.1727637351,
0.1540170014,
0.0150118554,
-0.1507461667,
0.1921154857,
0.6166969538,
-0.1609027386,
-0.1263735145,
-0.1281393617,
-0.5060961246,
0.3023000956,
0.979806304,
-0.8870379925,
0.251865685,
0.7813431621,
0.8899049759,
0.3094491661,
0.1739114523,
0.0847383812,
-0.4112770557,
0.0415267982,
0.4917854369,
0.2638131678,
0.2232757509,
-0.9682334661,
0.1882915199,
0.3266791999,
-0.8234103322,
-0.8328432441,
-0.0444385409,
-0.6466218233,
-0.2950130701,
0.4529638588,
-0.312764585,
-0.383920759,
-0.6012703776,
0.3020485342,
0.3628288209,
-0.0955875888,
1.1206811666,
-0.0367041789,
-0.2109256536,
0.0816627964,
-0.2370403558,
0.3722591102,
0.064409405,
-1.1354706287,
0.244766444,
0.4497716129,
0.1418305784,
-0.0624422655,
0.555470705,
-0.1273597926,
0.4742236435,
-0.1743059009,
-0.1533295661,
-0.1500731409,
-0.3931656778,
-0.7345415354,
0.6597881913,
-0.1729593724,
-0.3768082559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03731v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.03731v4 | Working Memory Capacity of ChatGPT: An Empirical Study | 2023-04-30T11:54:40 | 2024-02-01T21:39:50 | Dongyu Gong, Xingchen Wan, Dingmin Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Working memory is a critical aspect of both human intelligence and artificial
intelligence, serving as a workspace for the temporary storage and manipulation
of information. In this paper, we systematically assess the working memory
capacity of ChatGPT, a large language model developed by OpenAI, by examining
its performance in verbal and spatial n-back tasks under various conditions.
Our experiments reveal that ChatGPT has a working memory capacity limit
strikingly similar to that of humans. Furthermore, we investigate the impact of
different instruction strategies on ChatGPT's performance and observe that the
fundamental patterns of a capacity limit persist. From our empirical findings,
we propose that n-back tasks may serve as tools for benchmarking the working
memory capacity of large language models and hold potential for informing
future efforts aimed at enhancing AI working memory. | [
-0.2762748003,
-0.860136807,
0.2168324292,
0.1753222942,
0.0683456063,
-0.326866895,
-0.6228450537,
-0.653185308,
-0.0501175411,
0.3329161406,
-0.3268730938,
-0.0424524359,
-0.4943401515,
-0.1841201782,
-0.3872481883,
1.0210015774,
-0.1802255213,
-0.1701841801,
-0.163699314,
-0.3129959404,
-1.1770638227,
-0.542627275,
-0.7757583857,
-0.2798849344,
0.6265032291,
0.4989330173,
0.9824665785,
0.3718802333,
0.5673428774,
0.2270589769,
0.024264941,
-0.2833865881,
-0.8654773235,
-0.0254150499,
0.0380777754,
-0.6464591026,
-0.3571923673,
0.1149856225,
0.8698494434,
0.5080910921,
-0.3260249197,
0.0554918684,
0.0987064764,
0.5407631993,
-0.5089538693,
0.3406208456,
-0.2098655552,
0.1967286617,
-0.3300400674,
0.1860933751,
-0.4179735482,
-0.3998648524,
0.2929006219,
-0.428768754,
0.1320096552,
0.1862977892,
0.7056395411,
0.1983774304,
-0.0934178606,
0.0702928826,
-0.8922874928,
0.6395900846,
-0.7948542237,
0.4944509566,
0.5206292868,
0.413357228,
-0.0249581318,
-0.5005907416,
-0.8992837667,
-0.5945479274,
0.0037244211,
0.1575007737,
-0.2483363748,
0.0265129358,
0.5857511759,
0.4933733344,
-0.7138822675,
0.075074859,
-0.813024044,
0.1129733026,
0.5244146585,
0.1449373066,
0.703225255,
0.2261177748,
-0.0132674733,
-0.1434200853,
-0.5483420491,
-0.3636903465,
0.1118966639,
0.0110978791,
0.0323114656,
0.9329214692,
-0.2950180173,
0.5197749734,
-0.5977153778,
0.2260460109,
0.0014121879,
-0.2188990712,
-0.3059744239,
-0.1894491315,
0.7346055508,
0.3899908364,
0.3544781506,
-0.5103672743,
-0.1205769926,
-0.127887547,
0.5848334432,
-0.9038244486,
-0.3536142111,
-0.2556867898,
-0.33792907,
0.1712002605,
-0.0649337769,
-0.8047579527,
-0.2600799501,
0.1058760062,
0.5394335985,
-0.7733851671,
-0.3255524039,
-0.0950028896,
-0.138738066,
0.3873769641,
0.0678135976,
-0.8654790521,
0.3670158088,
0.774971664,
1.3091760874,
-0.1662435979,
-0.8307257891,
-0.3343424201,
-0.1373589635,
-0.3064564168,
0.47632882,
-0.8131412268,
-0.2709288299,
-0.0781041086,
-0.0836339742,
-0.4583364129,
-0.4677422345,
0.4123956263,
-0.4168590307,
0.2435700744,
-0.2252406031,
-0.5044924617,
-0.4058957696,
0.2288912535,
-0.9541909099,
1.1431614161,
0.1018191725,
-0.4905090034,
0.2276894748,
-0.8972015977,
-0.4312801361,
0.0811936781,
-0.1054501981,
-0.25849244,
0.3688628674,
-0.3996527195,
0.4382894337,
-0.3282128274,
-0.1016198918,
-0.0804011002,
-0.6756233573,
0.649420023,
-0.4441142082,
0.4105514884,
-0.1466295868,
-0.2364461571,
-0.1881016493,
-0.5409824848,
-0.1289129704,
0.2980471551,
-0.4597651064,
-0.2381461263,
0.1444263756,
-0.166727528,
0.1632433385,
0.2522475421,
-1.0469363928,
0.2763971388,
-0.1979771703,
0.736532867,
0.2970242798,
-0.2366285324,
0.250598371,
-0.6165652871,
0.3195407689,
-0.4001243412,
-0.0769816712,
-0.0592061467,
-0.880092442,
-0.4653164148,
0.1531354636,
0.2850068808,
0.6441901326,
-0.4389508069,
-0.1518073976,
-0.3332761824,
-0.4681018591,
-0.1910603493,
-0.1611930877,
0.4297538102,
0.3485969603,
0.0852385387,
-0.4502828419,
-0.3281135559,
-0.8417467475,
-0.164349407,
-0.1298080683,
-0.1039347872,
0.5551154017,
0.6007939577,
-0.1216765493,
0.6384060383,
-0.5262697339,
-0.0627789199,
-0.1530012339,
0.4158653915,
0.2158235013,
0.3251453638,
0.3879344463,
-0.6744177341,
-0.5768312812,
0.0196301322,
-0.5685253739,
0.0600865185,
-0.1122356951,
-0.267957449,
0.3747714758,
0.3311598301,
-0.9965302348,
0.7766075134,
0.4802911282,
-0.3236954808,
0.6191142201,
-0.450109154,
0.0143354526,
-0.6307455897,
0.2633110583,
-0.1781131029,
0.2697470486,
-0.8428424001,
-0.0564565919,
0.0437771268,
-0.5108573437,
-0.0579714514,
0.425969243,
-0.4395345151,
-0.3584599793,
-0.458635509,
0.231526792,
-0.3037565053,
0.7872583866,
0.0322819315,
0.9745740891,
0.2839793563,
-0.374478966,
0.0681240335,
0.2150222361,
-0.1302011162,
0.4584837854,
-0.7567692995,
0.2632241249,
-0.0460590161,
0.0867773816,
-1.2168629169,
-0.1624564826,
-0.0905868188,
-0.5612232089,
0.1860162616,
-0.1200524122,
-0.7493129969,
-0.1703726351,
0.1868621409,
0.4773369431,
0.9116382599,
-0.2227613777,
0.5261864662,
0.1897327602,
-0.1816676557,
0.0084230173,
-0.7890439034,
0.020851247,
-0.0206068791,
-0.8057450056,
0.3764248192,
0.1192718968,
-0.0064633158,
0.1017293036,
0.0384596698,
-0.3047576547,
-0.1474859864,
0.4721635282,
0.4039155841,
-0.2992404997,
-0.0403667353,
-0.7170082331,
-0.1180315539,
0.1358979344,
-0.0910113081,
0.8380963206,
-0.2116180807,
-0.4377866089,
-0.3965348303,
0.3815952837,
0.6543796659,
-0.3284115195,
0.9299184084,
0.5914680958,
-0.4816574156,
0.3026140928,
-0.4521078169,
-0.0181780793,
-0.3959777057,
0.580858767,
0.1232994869,
-0.7382943034,
0.5216665864,
0.2082835436,
0.48047629,
0.2623711228,
0.6357301474,
0.0169107541,
0.7495908737,
0.4295414388,
-0.37403512,
0.659686029,
-0.1328617632,
0.4375528097,
-0.97006917,
-0.147545889,
-0.3078063726,
-0.6649208069,
-0.5725986362,
-0.6312896609,
0.0415824577,
-0.1168107837,
-0.5808478594,
0.3232625723,
-0.450913161,
0.6090696454,
0.6625176072,
-0.0519901216,
-0.0663826168,
-0.2885969281,
0.2438379973,
0.0595303141,
-0.4974781275,
-0.3243489265,
0.9713594913,
0.2771893144,
0.5513047576,
0.2431551218,
0.4570949078,
0.0312466156,
0.0754815564,
-0.5747469664,
0.6103698611,
-0.0914113075,
-0.4937710166,
-0.6999127865,
-0.3129362464,
-1.3031674623,
0.159488678,
0.0099561205,
-1.2257934809,
-0.3216236532,
-0.1143876761,
-0.3025883734,
0.3888172209,
-0.9654330015,
0.8643115163,
-0.2040756941,
-0.3640148938,
-0.447301805,
-0.3166167438,
0.1805282086,
0.3868590295,
-0.3185925186,
-0.1656867266,
0.0037208928,
1.0007257462,
-0.16211164,
0.9682101607,
-0.2747338712,
0.3378960192,
0.2545391321,
0.0407283902,
0.3973562121,
-0.3008319438,
-0.0551653169,
0.4003781676,
0.0267087072,
-0.5101661086,
-0.6627022624,
0.5181852579,
-0.9385280013,
-0.3286575377,
-0.4444206059,
-0.740047276,
-0.2529909313,
0.3996869624,
-0.1712602228,
0.314718008,
-0.51308465,
0.3872030973,
0.5698651075,
-0.357952863,
0.6289663911,
0.3379906416,
-0.134251669,
-0.0554485433,
1.1509652138,
0.6034886241,
0.2856132388,
0.2794901729,
0.3039679527,
0.0510103777,
-0.7073143721,
-0.4555347562,
0.1351259053,
-0.1113125384,
0.2216036916,
-0.3190719485,
-0.4717867672,
-0.0519960783,
0.0413527526,
-0.5281589031,
-0.3374404013,
0.1777102202,
0.2447552979,
0.3721506298,
0.9097542763,
0.1177532524,
0.348176837,
-0.7222240567,
0.2339846343,
0.2738746107,
0.7878553271,
0.3711409271,
-0.2990647256,
-0.3877951503,
0.3347747028,
-0.3417291343,
-0.8217049837,
0.3804411888,
0.1267160028,
0.7517884374,
0.1401622295,
-0.2175476104,
0.473184377,
-0.4923683405,
0.7781649232,
-0.0609850138,
-0.4006003141,
0.0897407457,
-0.3464944363,
0.4998031259,
0.3570531905,
0.288259536,
-0.9070312381,
-0.0375988148,
-0.6296629906,
-0.656691432,
0.7729836702,
0.7435243726,
0.1007442027,
0.1120505184,
0.2951052785,
-0.1074367166,
-0.0153551316,
-0.427857399,
0.2052216381,
-0.2037675679,
0.1841092408,
-0.120713897,
-0.2273591161,
-0.0040662372,
-0.0265478864,
0.395606339,
0.1374735832,
1.0163793564,
-0.1056989431,
-0.0440797321,
0.3018392026,
0.2027382702,
0.7139612436,
0.6033484936,
-0.0947366953,
-0.2801355124,
0.5670602322,
-0.9133728147,
-0.2989492714,
-0.0771570057,
-0.0368171521,
-0.3199051321,
0.3149394393,
0.7598394156,
0.2754171193,
-0.9450369477,
0.4097202122,
-0.3895742893,
-0.1926225722,
-0.4337984324,
0.316385597,
0.1998550892,
0.3828211427,
0.1390738785,
-0.1962943822,
-0.1166733876,
-0.8461595178,
0.1298608184,
0.1807972789,
-0.319950223,
-0.234155193,
0.3491044044,
-0.1499919742,
-0.6699498892,
1.2636862993,
-0.179524824,
-0.4899872839,
0.6473507285,
0.7711929083,
0.9285030961,
-0.024359528,
-0.1066932976,
0.3327887058,
0.3082128465,
-0.1733196229,
0.5859125257,
-0.0667865351,
-0.7173768878,
-0.5163972974,
-0.2382879853,
-0.6499464512,
-0.1574608237,
-0.7914507389,
-0.2787529528,
-0.5251645446,
0.0523967296,
-0.1531180292,
0.0927883908,
-0.6163641214,
0.0128323846,
0.2769185305,
0.7953915,
-0.4549384415,
0.9610674381,
0.4962687492,
-0.3911860883,
-0.626801312,
0.1627851576,
-0.2371327877,
-1.0395866632,
0.4363474846,
0.31584692,
0.0902811587,
-0.4061695337,
-0.4120719135,
-0.8836277723,
1.2836210728,
0.1439913511,
-0.5025901794,
-0.061208792,
0.2260165811,
0.6986088157,
-0.0581470653,
0.3916028738,
0.6893358231,
0.3912428617,
0.2795965672,
-1.2310678959,
0.1715108752,
-0.5594758987,
0.0792363361,
0.5117118359,
-1.0324907303,
1.1605690718,
-0.0845019668,
-0.4661459923,
-0.084999077,
0.6564669013,
0.2339763939,
0.2036380619,
0.3184798062,
0.799210906,
0.9444636703,
0.018951444,
0.9854747653,
-0.222687602,
-0.1382225752,
1.0715287924,
-0.4085634649,
1.1948884726,
0.1970215738,
-0.0281553157,
0.4998874366,
0.1849557459,
-0.0890486836,
0.2906740904,
0.1843420863,
0.0203222074,
0.3358220458,
0.0473482497,
-0.1396606416,
0.5892217755,
0.2278607637,
-0.0041124774,
0.0323098525,
0.1437598765,
0.2542792857,
-0.420966506,
-0.1684972942,
0.7504859567,
-0.0834859461,
-0.9897075295,
0.5374119282,
-0.0398402326,
0.2633423507,
-0.2071869075,
-0.2294446528,
-0.1270204335,
0.2114322782,
-0.0005444064,
-1.0600507259,
0.6797773838,
-0.0513799824,
0.1343903393,
0.0151483184,
0.6523271203,
-0.1467718333,
-0.0756125227,
0.0450388864,
0.2273513824,
0.4288069308,
-0.267654717,
-0.3425086737,
-0.0690741986,
-0.0548068769,
-0.1454701424,
0.7196477056,
0.6598331332,
-0.176467225,
0.7893653512,
0.5047179461,
0.0221814346,
0.3434802294,
-0.1918555051,
0.8417813778,
-1.0019949675,
-0.5955420732,
-1.0236680508,
0.112534225,
-0.3717827201,
-0.6429796219,
0.9136693478,
0.7131112218,
0.858802855,
0.3133370876,
0.8261924386,
-0.4562843144,
0.2462736666,
-0.369224757,
0.6101243496,
-0.1922294348,
-0.0971880555,
-0.0180276781,
-0.7347457409,
-0.0377803631,
0.8202946186,
-0.5934017301,
0.0388100371,
0.8165712357,
0.7190679312,
-0.029407654,
0.8034078479,
0.451818943,
0.3109235764,
0.0829330757,
0.9835419655,
0.8725081682,
-0.1327093989,
0.6952389479,
-0.231898874,
-0.2375225425,
-0.2419006824,
-0.6801863909,
-1.090657115,
-0.6980195642,
-0.051383581,
-0.1276093423,
-0.0117057906,
0.4547862113,
0.6914699674,
-0.3834349811,
-0.3492183983,
-0.0735360757,
-0.2174113691,
-0.4783428013,
-0.1450131834,
0.2716245055,
0.0528981462,
-0.459730953,
0.2096446007,
0.3036584258,
0.0241648592,
-0.4879634678,
-0.1961458921,
-0.1340307891,
0.0744008049,
0.6424793601,
0.6574498415,
-0.2742382288,
-0.3745457232,
0.0882416591,
-0.0724963024,
0.1499103904,
0.8835479021,
-0.3930148184,
0.2438494414,
0.7606800795,
0.8793882728,
0.8535733223,
-0.2955729663,
0.7302564383,
-0.4636962116,
0.0837450922,
0.379603982,
0.3054816425,
-0.0722809955,
-0.2398197353,
0.6484543681,
-0.1182296947,
-1.0014497042,
-0.6166431308,
-0.1772489995,
-0.9692357779,
-0.0465005487,
1.0132830143,
-0.1545987427,
-0.3861515224,
-0.0890732408,
-0.4726198018,
0.1165524423,
-0.4210644066,
0.9593717456,
0.9269798994,
-0.5390071273,
-0.509019196,
-1.459829092,
0.0535678007,
0.3551834226,
-0.4872486591,
0.3098399937,
0.4325816929,
-0.0513002351,
0.1133840978,
0.8119616508,
0.0211813245,
0.3912502527,
0.4903880954,
-0.0480985641,
0.011416547,
-0.4213506281,
0.2371477336,
0.2345332354,
0.0034118933,
-0.4439432323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00450v2 | SMILE: Single-turn to Multi-turn Inclusive Language Expansion via ChatGPT for Mental Health Support | 2023-04-30T11:26:10 | 2024-02-22T10:21:56 | Huachuan Qiu, Hongliang He, Shuai Zhang, Anqi Li, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Developing specialized dialogue systems for mental health support requires
multi-turn conversation data, which has recently garnered increasing attention.
However, gathering and releasing large-scale and real-life multi-turn
conversations to facilitate advancements in mental health presents challenges
due to data privacy protection, as well as the time and cost involved. To
address the challenges related to data scarcity, we introduce SMILE, a
single-turn to multi-turn inclusive language expansion technique that prompts
ChatGPT to rewrite public single-turn dialogues into multi-turn ones. Our work
begins with the analysis of language transformation, validating the feasibility
of the proposed method when compared with other baseline methods. We then
conduct a study on dialogue diversity, including lexical features, semantic
features, and dialogue topics, demonstrating the effectiveness of our proposed
method. Furthermore, we implement an expert evaluation and the results
demonstrate that the dialogues generated with our proposed method are of higher
quality than those generated with other baseline methods. Thus, we employ our
method to generate a large-scale, diverse, and high-quality dialogue dataset
named SmileChat, comprising 55,165 dialogues in total with an average of 10.4
turns per dialogue. Finally, we utilize the collected corpus to develop a
mental health chatbot, MeChat. To better assess the overall quality of
SmileChat, we collect a real-life chat dataset comprising 82 counseling
dialogues for model evaluation. Both automatic and human evaluations
demonstrate that our trained dialogue system exhibits significant improvements,
showcasing that SmileChat is high-quality and practical. | [
-0.6117662787,
-0.7656553388,
0.4500696063,
0.3961734176,
-0.2412111908,
0.2741095126,
-0.3733692169,
-0.3030403256,
0.5105472803,
0.3830214143,
-1.1770657301,
-0.5129319429,
-0.5379031301,
-0.0342014767,
-0.2573354244,
1.0415203571,
0.5843526125,
0.3228520155,
0.1144042388,
-0.2084838301,
-0.5389903784,
-0.2534365356,
-0.8648737669,
-0.1181297973,
0.6014884114,
0.5949514508,
1.1567595005,
-0.1665416956,
0.4656611979,
0.245650515,
0.1682156622,
0.1448013037,
-0.5436671972,
0.1443452537,
0.0544745997,
-0.354457438,
-0.7496972084,
-0.390311569,
0.3278053403,
0.5665081739,
-0.6901974678,
0.0863625184,
0.0247637741,
0.7253658772,
-0.2130403519,
0.2600505948,
-0.3687499464,
0.1952129155,
-0.2369196564,
0.0575097352,
-0.1609022319,
-0.6541346312,
0.1670742482,
-0.4013918936,
-0.0015251718,
-0.3745954335,
0.4000729024,
0.1656103432,
-0.2939895988,
-0.1851272285,
-0.8175076246,
0.5940647125,
-1.0199422836,
0.4366526008,
0.1255217493,
0.4962813556,
-0.4665409327,
-0.5487998128,
-0.6924343705,
0.1788557619,
0.2153060138,
0.3616523147,
-0.3294340968,
0.1698241681,
0.0727655292,
0.4401623309,
-0.5351325274,
-0.3469737172,
-0.2277315259,
-0.1461354047,
0.7553189397,
0.1283947378,
0.8466113806,
-0.0042472375,
-0.0042421776,
-0.2462759763,
-0.3624203503,
-0.1186425686,
0.224081859,
0.7746127248,
0.0374732018,
0.6486352086,
-0.155790031,
0.1320345998,
-0.2766726613,
-0.5686139464,
0.3647519946,
-0.325871408,
-0.0395493433,
0.0325566344,
0.9677023292,
0.5829854608,
0.1929425299,
0.0892864987,
0.1074706838,
-0.0761019364,
0.5125961304,
-0.7065939307,
-0.0220826101,
0.4449458718,
-0.3350941837,
0.2400127798,
-0.1116114333,
-1.2367469072,
-0.5146226287,
-0.1825935692,
0.1820880622,
-0.8803688884,
-0.7841657996,
0.3406099379,
0.0323261656,
0.2135721445,
0.4827795625,
-0.759296298,
0.3473442197,
0.7311250567,
0.8420196772,
-0.04391554,
-0.0499236137,
-0.3867866099,
-0.3744599819,
-0.1710148305,
0.5979304314,
-0.3974105418,
-0.5121687651,
0.3864883184,
-0.0548007935,
0.0280008744,
-0.3873606324,
0.6815831065,
-0.079799749,
0.3665598631,
-0.19354105,
-0.1237338632,
0.2471203059,
0.0671456009,
-0.2829034328,
0.6319873333,
0.311270088,
-0.7922238111,
0.1596480608,
-0.7777457237,
-0.7620664239,
0.2693313956,
-0.1815201491,
-0.3244757056,
0.2986176908,
0.361136049,
-0.0246629715,
-0.1163778305,
0.1411144435,
-0.5036385655,
-0.1764532775,
0.419192493,
-0.6048731208,
0.7718195319,
0.2326879054,
-0.1049280539,
0.1118695959,
-0.4839592576,
0.1636262387,
0.0415134355,
-0.0752183348,
0.0061707487,
-0.0754155666,
-0.032475628,
0.2862223983,
0.0305052847,
-0.8339812756,
0.2449972034,
-0.474165678,
0.1597860157,
0.3408897519,
0.1240443513,
0.0494183376,
-0.3474051058,
0.6923023462,
-0.0305996034,
0.6422011852,
-0.4829986095,
-1.0267980099,
-0.6377840638,
-0.5991843939,
-0.1969023943,
0.7000721693,
-0.6919248104,
0.4515939951,
-0.3790323138,
-0.2247446179,
-1.21920681,
-0.1778443158,
-0.0044135572,
0.1429262459,
0.512663126,
-0.6092740893,
-0.3213423193,
-0.8973402977,
-0.2353365719,
-0.2446343154,
-0.1604101062,
0.2741961181,
-0.1704349071,
-0.4932605326,
1.061259985,
-0.5296199322,
-0.2289145738,
-0.2550258934,
0.2541710436,
0.0671912059,
0.2193386406,
-0.0125425598,
-0.6564391851,
-0.451887399,
-0.1144497544,
-0.606051147,
0.1975368261,
-0.1201969758,
-0.2796683013,
-0.1430164874,
-0.1049264297,
-0.8567858934,
0.5778047442,
0.4868206382,
-0.1969836503,
0.485707432,
-0.126565814,
0.3601022065,
-1.1706109047,
-0.4115227163,
-0.0706402436,
-0.1880214512,
-0.8376303315,
-0.2600214183,
-0.3391366005,
-0.5832327604,
-0.2707465589,
0.2580808103,
-0.161166504,
0.128655225,
-0.2291111052,
0.2159533948,
-0.4600196183,
0.4835771024,
-0.3683390915,
0.6558645964,
0.6256693006,
-0.1498353928,
0.460613519,
0.5470041037,
0.1244902983,
1.0234965086,
-0.1375778019,
0.2657019496,
-0.1020504758,
0.2693475187,
-1.2211465836,
-0.4790027142,
0.2754629552,
-0.6726155877,
0.3066741526,
0.1002524048,
-0.5161485076,
-0.6977893114,
-0.2745908499,
-0.1538298577,
0.4117738605,
-0.5281649828,
0.2404639423,
0.6679992676,
-0.8051374555,
-0.4439192712,
-0.5565709472,
0.4186115265,
-0.1969993711,
-0.8164494634,
0.0290518142,
-0.2197591513,
-0.1034086347,
-0.1741405874,
-0.1948534697,
-0.0105744246,
-0.1977215707,
0.1661253721,
0.0910717919,
-0.1804539561,
0.5227231979,
0.4596381783,
-0.0164170656,
0.0710821003,
-0.2651013434,
0.7211529016,
-0.3263608217,
-0.7320475578,
-0.5142307281,
0.8703503609,
0.8037659526,
-0.2089782059,
0.7328808904,
0.7401770353,
-0.4280603528,
0.0505862013,
-0.4367004931,
-0.3045548499,
-0.4571454525,
0.3207971156,
-0.2774536014,
-0.9808732271,
0.4110396802,
-0.1363022029,
0.2585010529,
0.0963486284,
0.4420378506,
0.0028483402,
1.464173317,
0.5655246973,
0.1224526316,
0.4970449805,
0.4361637533,
0.6346128583,
-0.4915183783,
-0.0857383683,
-0.1665153801,
-0.0137328617,
-0.7715060115,
-0.4648095965,
0.436493814,
-0.0372447632,
-0.1067882255,
0.2506141961,
-0.6855872273,
-0.1924620122,
0.3744169176,
0.5225508213,
0.486569643,
0.0235905573,
0.0289587118,
-0.5247969627,
-0.3850331604,
-0.3981969953,
0.8611426353,
0.3857661188,
0.8258379698,
0.3082578182,
0.880828321,
0.1828531474,
0.7056437731,
-0.9817328453,
0.5887170434,
-0.077139616,
-0.5241410732,
-0.5278174877,
-0.5273445845,
-0.9657304883,
0.1805192232,
-0.0082110176,
-1.0962553024,
-0.0187000949,
-0.084222123,
-0.326797843,
0.1164252982,
-0.7187407017,
0.6752440333,
-0.2687613666,
-0.0160831213,
-0.4160862863,
-0.6421217322,
0.4486526847,
-0.1059432477,
0.3127111197,
-0.3649375141,
0.5100743175,
0.5366921425,
-0.4866155982,
0.7259417772,
-0.301020205,
-0.3628603518,
0.3925657868,
-0.092912592,
0.1414193809,
0.383223623,
0.0761466995,
-0.1083776727,
0.1690506637,
-0.356308043,
-0.8629958034,
0.5664671659,
-0.6765405536,
-0.7344073057,
-0.0802023187,
-0.4555985928,
-0.7839602232,
0.2403529882,
-0.048748441,
0.4047329426,
-0.399874866,
-0.0463831648,
0.5461695194,
-0.4243477881,
0.0521942824,
0.3472753167,
-0.5948583484,
-0.5815109611,
1.0618848801,
-0.0136265205,
0.2945027351,
0.0023335717,
0.2425655872,
-0.4297377169,
0.1027165353,
-0.2757897079,
0.4195538461,
-0.5961424708,
-0.2260800153,
-0.7526903152,
-0.2480764836,
-0.83058846,
0.1969408095,
-0.6347800493,
-0.4186690152,
0.1041027606,
0.0426693223,
0.446271807,
0.4932456315,
-0.0913187042,
0.4715827703,
-0.9223729968,
0.2481394708,
0.4510661662,
0.6228092313,
-0.0862523168,
-0.1231894717,
-0.0582727529,
0.294449389,
-0.4635364115,
-1.2061938047,
0.5160155892,
0.1083659008,
0.4735087454,
0.5810049772,
0.2269596159,
0.7245030403,
-0.5155718923,
0.5549973845,
0.689509511,
-0.7968429327,
0.769317627,
-0.5019567609,
0.5035124421,
0.6641663909,
0.2306679785,
-1.1008350849,
-0.6608389616,
-0.8333926201,
-0.7495524287,
0.6446937323,
0.2447541505,
0.5185946226,
-0.2588159144,
0.1924637109,
0.0419750735,
0.3176737428,
-0.2799773216,
-0.340335995,
-0.4067236185,
-0.4063996375,
0.1890942752,
0.0540800542,
-0.4535103738,
-0.0885741934,
0.4868779778,
-0.4197224975,
0.8850342631,
0.265734911,
0.2412701547,
-0.0840925127,
0.7886559367,
0.2703131437,
0.4457125962,
-0.293641597,
0.0644329712,
0.0616136864,
-0.5653306842,
-0.0930354148,
0.2029309571,
0.3491597474,
0.140718922,
-0.0398226827,
0.6963024735,
0.0316452719,
-0.6214434505,
0.419259578,
-0.3500216007,
0.2450875342,
0.0051531629,
0.1896487772,
0.3385552764,
0.2222157419,
0.3406312466,
-0.033922337,
0.2492035478,
-0.7093161345,
0.5716679692,
0.4535647929,
-0.8968193531,
-0.4766650498,
0.1681732535,
0.1739738286,
-0.8464875817,
0.8998244405,
-0.2963368595,
-0.3106378019,
0.040779233,
0.7667915821,
1.00515306,
-0.4356829226,
0.7820798159,
0.5410059094,
0.1723183841,
-0.0464906022,
0.3460760117,
0.1334279478,
-0.7374819517,
-0.3133446872,
-0.3651270568,
-0.6654502749,
0.0365972109,
-0.8543212414,
0.2008426785,
-0.2879170775,
-0.6209443212,
-0.1172545105,
-0.1724998355,
-0.5304569006,
0.0852901116,
0.5263816118,
0.7467600107,
-0.5985240936,
0.6419839263,
0.591855824,
-0.3401410282,
-0.4385654926,
0.2430852205,
0.3281938732,
-0.7167239189,
-0.3000773489,
0.3442205787,
-0.3903325498,
-0.0217732564,
-0.6077722311,
-0.6059832573,
0.8309844136,
0.5380592942,
-0.4138214588,
0.2182133794,
0.365187645,
0.8072744012,
-0.4529976249,
0.3798151612,
0.5709270239,
0.3209590614,
0.3501057029,
-0.9562336206,
0.0232989546,
-0.2199789882,
-0.1164558083,
0.088631168,
-0.6910754442,
0.3795031905,
-0.4257940948,
-0.6810399294,
-0.1624669135,
0.6737763286,
0.221634686,
0.1101525649,
0.4986948371,
0.3548150063,
1.1308038235,
-0.0980259702,
0.8977872133,
-0.1335124522,
0.5848017931,
1.1493337154,
-0.4158588648,
0.665661335,
0.3657786846,
-0.4520701468,
0.2796705961,
0.4440453053,
0.3820556998,
0.2731808722,
0.2436050028,
-0.7695045471,
-0.2029000074,
-0.3233132362,
-0.1615256965,
0.1006399542,
0.7191720009,
0.2954418957,
-0.3183684051,
0.3856033087,
0.2926174402,
-0.1862003654,
0.1154807657,
0.8463401794,
0.2755863965,
-0.7567377687,
0.1218649894,
-0.1753774434,
0.4824217856,
-0.5614582896,
0.003541311,
-0.593464613,
0.3115733266,
-0.1327215284,
-1.0042536259,
0.3870705068,
-0.1129333153,
0.2223784626,
-0.0892120749,
0.9040160179,
-0.5702889562,
-0.5338932872,
0.4795815051,
0.7377274632,
0.1573478878,
-0.1578565687,
-0.8413758278,
-0.0515487306,
0.1900204122,
-0.0777544528,
0.4898422658,
0.559008956,
-0.0050705359,
0.7996920347,
0.4891749918,
0.0098289857,
0.1346947253,
0.4098231792,
0.934558332,
-0.5170175433,
-0.21408315,
-0.5549730062,
0.5720944405,
-0.2603732646,
-0.3129874766,
0.5952720642,
0.3267292678,
0.3048350215,
0.2138175517,
0.898498714,
-0.1266543865,
0.6223130822,
0.0977046117,
0.5561959147,
-0.4734075665,
-0.1368441582,
-0.2979755402,
-0.646736145,
-0.4940842092,
0.5544121265,
-0.1060936823,
-0.169534415,
0.4637951553,
0.8704206347,
0.0469565466,
0.4521171451,
0.314152658,
-0.0006923108,
0.8002764583,
0.2313040942,
0.8801822662,
-0.2436668128,
0.5369080305,
0.0316432528,
-0.6252992749,
-0.0264574569,
-0.3842073083,
-0.4842796326,
-0.3912768662,
-0.5099183321,
-0.5180537105,
0.0238783471,
1.0622441769,
0.6858699322,
-0.7815961242,
-0.1334974617,
0.0801797733,
0.1512996852,
-0.3419071734,
-0.2879607379,
-0.0370462276,
-0.6918885708,
-0.6087229252,
0.4683414996,
0.6260085106,
-0.1925152391,
-0.4591527581,
0.0608610325,
-0.0837649629,
0.3488501906,
0.5105990171,
0.4181866944,
-0.4455062449,
-0.2467103302,
0.1253614426,
-0.1425104886,
0.562936306,
0.8183455467,
-0.3609962761,
0.8964961767,
0.1446298361,
0.6181817055,
0.556270957,
0.00496906,
0.8012601137,
-0.6124069095,
-0.0624916106,
0.1802601218,
0.0666060075,
0.5011251569,
-0.3625861704,
0.2625557184,
0.0046108677,
-0.3446142673,
-0.6435351372,
0.3508273661,
-0.9499813318,
0.0486647896,
0.9344826937,
-0.2975227833,
-0.0658857152,
-0.071397081,
-0.5432687402,
0.4854407907,
-0.7213475108,
0.7771205902,
0.7671183348,
-0.663802743,
-0.4989863038,
-0.6046057343,
0.3995035589,
0.2286714315,
-1.1847935915,
0.2627545893,
0.2291805148,
0.0094233537,
0.4764713049,
1.0769344568,
-0.4612087011,
0.0126108667,
-0.0055686464,
0.329701066,
0.7550173998,
-0.155806452,
-0.2960349917,
-0.0453951471,
-0.0112326881,
-0.087981239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00446v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00446v2 | Building a Non-native Speech Corpus Featuring Chinese-English Bilingual Children: Compilation and Rationale | 2023-04-30T10:41:43 | 2024-01-07T17:17:00 | Hiuchung Hung, Andreas Maier, Thorsten Piske | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a non-native speech corpus consisting of narratives
from fifty 5- to 6-year-old Chinese-English children. Transcripts totaling 6.5
hours of children taking a narrative comprehension test in English (L2) are
presented, along with human-rated scores and annotations of grammatical and
pronunciation errors. The children also completed the parallel MAIN tests in
Chinese (L1) for reference purposes. For all tests we recorded audio and video
with our innovative self-developed remote collection methods. The video
recordings serve to mitigate the challenge of low intelligibility in L2
narratives produced by young children during the transcription process. This
corpus offers valuable resources for second language teaching and has the
potential to enhance the overall performance of automatic speech recognition
(ASR). | [
-0.1517221481,
-0.3945976794,
-0.105715245,
0.3358736336,
-0.0222280622,
0.3863258362,
-0.1380145103,
-0.765278697,
0.2331436276,
0.1910325438,
-0.3566671908,
-0.1208233535,
-0.2566258311,
0.1292089522,
-0.6820181012,
0.7675495744,
0.1225586385,
0.0206724051,
-0.1488733143,
0.0455623865,
-0.3861573935,
-0.0782324523,
-0.8979744315,
0.0544454046,
0.3711583018,
0.7515544295,
0.5542920828,
0.757830143,
-0.196315214,
0.139411062,
0.1482306868,
0.0532922707,
-0.1699283719,
-0.1714387387,
-0.2739635408,
-0.3839980662,
-0.3512791395,
-0.1142213717,
0.7659076452,
0.8503059745,
0.1727749258,
0.2730471194,
0.2478922755,
0.3008856475,
-0.4024127722,
0.0377794057,
-0.4295024276,
0.2986063063,
-0.3954091966,
-0.1687348038,
-0.567255497,
-0.0629754141,
0.0336405896,
-0.6233432293,
0.430264771,
-0.1236785054,
0.7057378292,
0.1138292626,
-0.7144551873,
-0.1191065311,
-0.5003561974,
0.8612291813,
-0.6832159758,
0.2110164762,
0.9871074557,
0.1863381416,
0.2752017975,
-0.9346166849,
-0.6023911834,
-0.1518749744,
-0.4175755382,
0.3057312369,
-0.0802285299,
-0.0827696547,
0.2381630093,
0.1358527541,
-1.1900056601,
0.282476306,
-0.9587917328,
-0.3614469469,
0.8792691827,
0.1404359192,
0.6799519062,
-0.3867054582,
-0.1653209478,
-0.0213669185,
-0.3887705505,
0.4511782229,
0.3420306742,
0.3883343935,
-0.4848288298,
0.5238982439,
0.024026271,
0.4988108575,
-0.0287632141,
-0.7244006991,
0.4225255847,
-0.5689052343,
0.0950207859,
0.3166879714,
0.8133220673,
0.4202219844,
0.2548138201,
0.0892741531,
-0.3374768496,
0.1122701615,
-0.175840959,
-0.5198446512,
-0.2572135925,
0.1088928804,
-0.6846262813,
0.0674205273,
0.0151483072,
-0.8730684519,
-0.0593624748,
-0.1855341941,
0.2207029462,
-0.415004611,
-0.3113684356,
-0.2010029107,
-0.3805765808,
0.2356693894,
-0.1205848306,
-1.1355116367,
0.320483923,
0.2753306925,
0.620110929,
-0.1890744567,
-0.5695371032,
-0.6297878623,
0.375908941,
-0.3774823844,
0.5534297824,
-0.1253613085,
-0.7365319133,
0.3226205409,
0.1356716305,
-0.2380955368,
-0.5748537183,
0.66346699,
-0.2153015137,
0.4162859917,
0.0386112258,
-0.2580323517,
-0.2389665246,
0.0069420538,
-0.66135782,
1.0683463812,
0.0607808158,
-0.5274953842,
0.1307305545,
-0.4637447298,
-1.1485350132,
0.1645703912,
-0.1941875219,
-0.0219283197,
-0.2488471866,
0.4832005799,
0.0445380583,
-0.1519254595,
0.1706824303,
0.5052125454,
-0.4556915164,
-0.1839305162,
-0.6856295466,
1.2021465302,
0.1509671956,
-0.5523827076,
-0.227237612,
-0.5839197636,
0.2265429944,
0.1322103143,
-0.1759258211,
0.1378281862,
0.065214701,
0.3456979096,
0.141764164,
0.6145350933,
-0.4716968238,
-0.1183975935,
-0.5830435753,
0.3640308082,
0.1248605475,
-0.0708070025,
0.1681141108,
-0.6610642076,
0.6674047112,
-0.0253218096,
0.2315431237,
-0.5265462399,
-0.6852266788,
-0.7210159302,
0.0745242387,
0.1881116629,
0.9369449615,
-1.0217871666,
0.3356895447,
-0.1484927237,
-0.4748562574,
-0.5036934018,
0.2910601199,
0.500666678,
0.5224266648,
0.4622026086,
-0.180385977,
-0.9011079669,
-0.9054600596,
0.087772131,
-0.7096379399,
-0.1989594102,
0.2764636576,
0.3251900971,
-0.0090744952,
0.9241259098,
-0.0076956637,
-0.3466606736,
-0.4782896638,
0.0658500791,
0.1445346177,
0.3635777533,
0.6784574389,
-0.660035193,
-0.9196197987,
0.0211891439,
-0.6978504062,
-0.2527484596,
-0.0116121257,
0.4565536976,
0.5416992307,
0.5562524796,
-0.3984401524,
0.1811672449,
0.7368506789,
-0.2693030238,
0.5901396871,
-0.1989429295,
0.0228122585,
-0.8758924007,
0.0025225747,
-0.3470663726,
-0.2164316922,
-0.4768778384,
-0.3562926054,
0.0183807518,
-0.0682569817,
-0.7988061905,
0.4337772131,
-0.4437351823,
-0.1051871777,
-0.2509309649,
0.4991666675,
0.0585167073,
0.234232381,
0.146067515,
0.8656390905,
0.5174257159,
-0.2993048131,
0.5615834594,
0.1366031766,
-0.1272981167,
0.4831860065,
-0.6795424819,
0.172039032,
-0.0230945144,
0.3175880313,
-0.8754487038,
-0.1068874821,
0.1013733819,
-1.0408089161,
0.2823359072,
0.0808011219,
-0.6482703686,
-0.4006553292,
-0.3446381092,
0.452919513,
0.7184516191,
-0.6092409492,
0.2919434011,
0.6125077009,
-0.4255932271,
-0.4002480805,
-1.0985953808,
0.2082690597,
-0.1406787336,
-0.7355746031,
0.2217553556,
0.1150110886,
-0.1304133683,
0.2333759367,
0.1949538291,
-0.432524085,
-0.3629587293,
-0.0348339528,
0.2104920745,
-0.6967871785,
0.036313504,
0.3801258802,
-0.0350124501,
0.1341095269,
-0.0799476504,
0.2803274393,
0.1900070459,
-0.1464188844,
-0.5163719058,
0.6964520812,
0.3655185401,
-0.265868336,
0.3803590834,
0.6434293389,
-0.7165288925,
-0.3826517761,
-0.3169842958,
-0.0988405123,
-0.4403111339,
0.3091698885,
-0.1723943502,
-0.6777006984,
0.3859214485,
0.7007692456,
0.1121479198,
0.5492917299,
0.4978626966,
-0.1346070021,
0.7488728166,
0.0767447203,
-0.3915670216,
0.0527449772,
0.0130151287,
-0.0513504446,
-0.3934805393,
-0.1461638063,
-0.3175064325,
-0.2854374349,
-0.4450814724,
-0.5446413755,
0.1228707805,
-0.1241402552,
0.0287190396,
0.352440834,
-0.3639438152,
0.6736286283,
0.6771517992,
-0.3094737828,
0.4002436996,
-0.2523931563,
0.0497780107,
-0.4148082435,
-0.5748727322,
-0.5883380175,
0.8652212024,
0.2690220177,
0.1069216281,
0.3949985206,
0.4645660818,
0.3518277109,
-0.1246584579,
-0.7883506417,
0.5916390419,
-0.4932290018,
-0.7905408144,
-0.4992901087,
-0.0561576784,
-1.1250151396,
0.1534177959,
0.1091266051,
-0.6352155209,
-0.221396625,
-0.047942441,
-0.7774505615,
0.0711089224,
-0.7910192013,
0.7228220105,
-0.4460233152,
-0.2747056484,
-0.1310470551,
-0.9521479011,
0.4203364253,
-0.0535942987,
0.1438079178,
0.2007702142,
-0.1734170169,
0.9079853892,
-0.2181165814,
0.9941977262,
-0.3046350479,
0.1135843545,
0.8767825365,
-0.0706522986,
0.1097057015,
0.1725754738,
0.2667565644,
-0.0540137999,
0.2227840275,
-0.3719594181,
-0.3456654549,
0.5168429613,
-0.8541230559,
-0.4229120016,
-0.5596134067,
-0.4980263114,
-0.131398052,
0.2885139585,
0.0460472442,
0.2582256794,
-0.0071406607,
0.2882159948,
0.2945884466,
-0.5764026642,
0.8186253905,
0.7606960535,
-0.2336433083,
-0.4880864918,
1.0216697454,
0.4101755321,
0.1963743418,
0.3473469913,
0.1332872659,
-0.2729046941,
-0.4769888818,
-0.3764797151,
0.2937758863,
-0.431448698,
0.1311552674,
-0.3970975578,
-0.5868711472,
-0.7442235947,
-0.1616481245,
-0.2730127871,
-0.3768335283,
-0.3019472659,
-0.4379751086,
0.0370769612,
0.5822690725,
-0.4509304762,
0.0277611483,
-0.8778027296,
0.5635495782,
0.3087705672,
-0.2439832538,
0.0370083749,
-0.7947618961,
-0.5087861419,
0.1653152704,
-0.2908674479,
-0.7232687473,
0.6011562347,
0.3778032362,
0.5490085483,
0.3488762975,
0.1831170917,
0.8221500516,
-0.4938130379,
1.4482175112,
-0.0454951078,
-0.8661772609,
0.612229228,
-0.6230503321,
0.2790624797,
0.3050922155,
0.0232242197,
-0.6659117937,
-0.2184928358,
-0.4824263752,
-0.8803895116,
0.9150676727,
0.0665370896,
0.1964911371,
0.0196301006,
-0.3095705807,
0.0924014077,
-0.3081064522,
-0.6016123295,
-0.410233587,
-0.4161945283,
-0.1979804486,
-0.1685324907,
-0.3139671087,
0.0226074345,
-0.6092589498,
0.5420821309,
-0.1275354922,
-0.013849888,
0.2166813016,
-0.2000903934,
-0.0602140203,
-0.1084082127,
0.6067450643,
0.4266139567,
0.1897776276,
0.1849946082,
0.5116098523,
-0.5286878347,
-0.1009795368,
0.1120253801,
-0.2120669484,
0.3167926371,
0.8366823792,
0.5193839073,
0.1643447727,
-1.081099391,
0.693780601,
0.0781798959,
-0.447070092,
-1.0623387098,
-0.3372688591,
0.416669488,
0.2009034753,
0.5557904243,
-0.5911207199,
0.0844992101,
-0.4956920445,
0.4953268766,
-0.1267925203,
-0.2149478346,
-0.3329468966,
0.7664509416,
0.219233945,
-0.3453009129,
0.7342306376,
-0.358117789,
-0.3334207535,
0.6998499036,
0.7936933041,
0.7973131537,
-0.3476415575,
0.3766650856,
0.6118149757,
0.5729865432,
0.0950815976,
0.2087701112,
-0.0915636644,
-0.65424788,
-0.4471030831,
-0.1160662398,
-0.4111192822,
0.1552309841,
-0.7042646408,
0.3242054582,
-0.2728610635,
0.278504312,
-0.333681047,
-0.0121342093,
-0.1322087049,
0.2930376828,
0.6487168074,
0.5847355127,
-0.8658899665,
1.1296299696,
0.4979723096,
-0.443041265,
-0.9656929374,
-0.0073471875,
0.0565569587,
-0.7377476096,
0.743930459,
0.13063474,
-0.0257310756,
-0.1131351888,
-0.0724977553,
-0.5932460427,
1.0697053671,
0.1942301542,
-0.4295319021,
-0.1255462021,
0.4936624169,
0.7862279415,
-0.061715778,
0.3837198913,
0.6564780474,
0.4645151198,
0.050428953,
-1.4170817137,
-0.4722044766,
-0.4268467128,
-0.296191752,
-0.3401915729,
-0.7791340947,
0.9003890753,
-0.0562853217,
-0.4245278537,
0.1224434003,
0.8809990287,
0.3262802362,
0.7231909037,
0.5352416039,
0.2878499031,
0.5526791215,
0.2046178281,
0.6015352607,
-0.3835438192,
-0.0397754349,
1.2885035276,
-0.0778981149,
0.9773523808,
0.5633983612,
-0.2582589686,
0.1789513081,
0.7031294703,
0.1668324471,
0.2188435644,
-0.0068294518,
-0.5183595419,
0.1637103409,
-0.603646934,
-0.2501935959,
0.4571122527,
0.4306181967,
-0.3390613794,
0.0056619402,
-0.0931426287,
0.1390277594,
0.4600863159,
-0.2260134816,
0.5366429687,
0.2460972369,
-0.820987165,
0.5534702539,
-0.1181799844,
0.7650494576,
-0.3554168642,
0.0936637595,
-0.138223052,
-0.0360139534,
-0.5155951381,
-0.8051223159,
0.5465040803,
0.201139003,
-0.1425299793,
-0.3213607669,
0.3576488197,
-0.8485031724,
-0.4429388642,
0.5319607258,
0.6273490787,
0.2958015203,
0.4307754934,
-0.3901824057,
-0.2137597799,
0.1720822603,
-0.1175790206,
0.1011191607,
0.3662944436,
-0.1496805549,
0.0898375958,
0.5987836719,
0.0888503492,
0.3407367766,
0.2436041683,
0.3089236617,
-0.654376328,
-0.3726448417,
-0.7830876708,
0.7380564213,
0.1810437739,
-0.3300711513,
0.8120048642,
1.0407633781,
1.0521845818,
-0.1944910288,
1.097386837,
-0.150924623,
0.9729502201,
-0.1600638777,
0.7612079978,
-0.5292455554,
-0.2237082273,
0.0718022808,
-0.5293964744,
-0.274612844,
0.5721299052,
0.1669064909,
-0.3073909283,
0.973620832,
0.7809901834,
0.2001824081,
0.1562423557,
0.4835338295,
0.0146722887,
0.2603315413,
0.8727449775,
0.7970978618,
-0.5491657257,
0.6569946408,
-0.269584626,
-0.0750772506,
0.0986623839,
-0.4565609694,
-0.8323074579,
-0.5255838633,
-0.0926190689,
-0.1309962571,
-0.0977745056,
0.8230729699,
0.1844613999,
-0.77870965,
-0.6297698021,
0.4260169566,
-0.1396278888,
-0.0853242129,
-0.249912262,
0.3294683695,
-0.0880576447,
-1.1939846277,
0.8878946304,
-0.0026671514,
0.0724828243,
-0.2410604656,
-0.2096573114,
-0.2737925053,
-0.1231592149,
0.625688076,
0.7010230422,
-0.5568726063,
-0.3200476468,
0.0365076698,
-0.206500873,
-0.196826458,
0.4965314567,
-0.5555741191,
0.4387810528,
0.6119475365,
0.5742548108,
0.4724541903,
-0.0468629338,
0.3847830594,
-0.7010015249,
0.4595976472,
0.5216158032,
0.3487590849,
0.3900722563,
0.1039789319,
0.4057918191,
0.427475363,
-0.3312635124,
-0.8880701065,
0.0116105108,
-0.9292806387,
0.2530897558,
1.2425067425,
-0.2483446747,
0.067272,
-0.4610294104,
-0.398081392,
0.4387017488,
-0.3961420357,
0.4467940927,
0.5904197097,
-0.0842643678,
-0.3340256512,
-0.6211128831,
0.1751458347,
0.5187450647,
-0.4833394587,
-0.3076339066,
0.1682335585,
0.0052269632,
0.1003234982,
0.6858725548,
-0.1585350633,
0.5474049449,
0.4783301055,
0.0375677645,
-0.000028408,
-0.1610524058,
-0.07836923,
0.0729208291,
0.0640745014,
-0.3947459161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01503v1 | NewsPanda: Media Monitoring for Timely Conservation Action | 2023-04-30T07:15:29 | 2023-04-30T07:15:29 | Sedrick Scott Keh, Zheyuan Ryan Shi, David J. Patterson, Nirmal Bhagabati, Karun Dewan, Areendran Gopala, Pablo Izquierdo, Debojyoti Mallick, Ambika Sharma, Pooja Shrestha, Fei Fang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CY | Non-governmental organizations for environmental conservation have a
significant interest in monitoring conservation-related media and getting
timely updates about infrastructure construction projects as they may cause
massive impact to key conservation areas. Such monitoring, however, is
difficult and time-consuming. We introduce NewsPanda, a toolkit which
automatically detects and analyzes online articles related to environmental
conservation and infrastructure construction. We fine-tune a BERT-based model
using active learning methods and noise correction algorithms to identify
articles that are relevant to conservation and infrastructure construction. For
the identified articles, we perform further analysis, extracting keywords and
finding potentially related sources. NewsPanda has been successfully deployed
by the World Wide Fund for Nature teams in the UK, India, and Nepal since
February 2022. It currently monitors over 80,000 websites and 1,074
conservation sites across India and Nepal, saving more than 30 hours of human
efforts weekly. We have now scaled it up to cover 60,000 conservation sites
globally. | [
-0.6666531563,
-0.7582069635,
0.0184424147,
0.7799681425,
-0.537314117,
-0.1762629449,
-0.0344248712,
-0.4270285964,
0.3653317094,
0.3365166783,
-0.3897172213,
-0.3886090815,
-0.3896005154,
0.2360274792,
-0.686758101,
0.9982834458,
-0.3145995438,
-0.4084475935,
0.3728972077,
-0.1807466298,
-0.3440988958,
0.5262433887,
-0.7210908532,
0.3636313379,
0.6453351974,
0.0320137963,
0.3548219204,
0.5176070333,
0.5204315186,
0.321954906,
-0.5494237542,
0.2977676392,
-0.2439749986,
-0.0985374823,
-0.4293776155,
-0.2652723193,
-0.0553158745,
-0.0014855029,
0.768401444,
0.4121295214,
-0.3726626933,
0.6198821068,
0.0265494268,
0.5752445459,
-1.0304877758,
0.5042672157,
-0.3621130288,
0.1279823482,
-0.2645329833,
-0.4886052012,
0.0475490689,
-0.4430600405,
0.1911980957,
-0.8500344157,
0.4287550449,
0.0276031494,
0.7575669289,
0.4482213855,
-0.4549389482,
-0.2401011735,
-0.2297101766,
0.656226635,
-0.2611364424,
0.3831344545,
0.6451735497,
0.2017754018,
-0.1754291654,
-0.4361872375,
-0.6800556779,
0.4415017068,
0.0413338952,
0.2153490186,
-0.2341656089,
-0.257812947,
0.1290694177,
0.148768425,
-0.3673190475,
-0.0432566591,
-0.7533159256,
-0.4777410626,
0.4167666733,
-0.2008541673,
0.18068932,
-1.0142891407,
-0.44909814,
0.0658450574,
-0.7257868648,
0.122816965,
0.6368511319,
-0.0095266644,
-0.3038138449,
0.3655057549,
-0.1467991024,
0.6388397217,
-0.2546356916,
-0.0467982963,
-0.0377543941,
-0.4623135328,
-0.2344762236,
0.4714257419,
0.1820990145,
0.358928591,
-0.1513875872,
0.1810989082,
-0.1930551529,
0.2433597296,
0.2906207144,
-0.4840334654,
-0.5758410096,
-0.1389108002,
-0.7660840154,
-0.4397096336,
0.1612856239,
-0.8417637348,
-0.5859115124,
-0.4504207671,
0.076621443,
0.2603182495,
-0.8207225204,
0.3106925488,
-0.4651137292,
0.2358490378,
0.6936776638,
-0.3533954024,
-0.3016335666,
0.5077085495,
1.2373315096,
0.0276107602,
-0.1481122971,
-0.7019649744,
0.5478544235,
-0.5039961934,
1.1934024096,
-0.0467163324,
-0.3369692266,
0.2394707203,
0.6743859053,
0.4144350886,
-0.2409953475,
0.5475108027,
-0.7592617273,
0.1877554506,
-0.4302934408,
-0.2896612883,
-0.4900898039,
0.5129796863,
-1.1206930876,
0.8233243823,
0.4710730612,
-1.1184484959,
0.6463237405,
-0.7908620834,
-0.4597402215,
-0.1367738694,
0.5018447042,
-0.7343833447,
-0.0269892253,
0.1824511141,
0.220360592,
0.1690908521,
0.2800136805,
-0.2049271464,
-0.1995789856,
-0.3060287237,
-0.2239239216,
1.1009157896,
0.3397424817,
-0.4176399112,
-0.02138789,
-0.5854936838,
-0.4911889732,
-0.5273858905,
-0.7746078372,
-0.4116341174,
0.1614278108,
0.2490378022,
0.0171839632,
0.1320204884,
-0.7767282724,
0.1516602188,
0.1151036546,
0.5794080496,
1.105928421,
0.4240504801,
0.1492880583,
-0.4671101868,
0.3662312925,
0.0652375147,
0.5030382276,
-0.1417786032,
-0.4171534777,
-0.6490498185,
-0.3664591014,
0.3045185804,
0.1652693003,
-0.6154399514,
0.2827239335,
-0.3303847015,
-0.4073223472,
-0.4007661939,
0.3721588254,
-0.1373225451,
0.4381991923,
0.214792043,
-0.4281311035,
-0.8209964633,
-0.6791737676,
-0.0773024857,
-0.2804815769,
0.1608345956,
-0.0136290658,
0.4521360397,
-0.3552820683,
1.1299619675,
-0.1736019105,
-0.6247928143,
0.4185377061,
0.5273337364,
0.2441294193,
0.1851802021,
0.8751248717,
-1.1903562546,
-0.3629267812,
-0.0811754242,
-0.6147068143,
-0.3945494294,
-0.1551051587,
-0.0969031379,
0.2963138521,
0.5728266835,
-0.4818018079,
0.3204718828,
0.535974443,
-0.1440537572,
0.4161454737,
-0.0041037677,
0.3106936514,
-0.7537416816,
0.4616468549,
-0.1150848046,
-0.1216463,
0.0213002991,
-0.4661146402,
0.1201479062,
-0.3263839781,
-0.7018891573,
0.4711806774,
-0.616705358,
-0.4079970121,
-0.4022051096,
0.0776078627,
-0.1085501164,
0.3932197094,
0.0542580895,
0.7339519858,
0.451436013,
-0.7963710427,
0.3962853551,
0.5301289558,
-0.8051020503,
0.6042255163,
-0.4224408269,
-0.2236225605,
-0.3954526782,
0.5148816705,
-0.5535758138,
-0.1313584596,
-0.126805231,
-0.0514810905,
0.1016479507,
-0.1761345565,
-0.5069919825,
-0.5170030594,
-0.7365945578,
-0.066425398,
0.084525682,
-0.7838434577,
0.5531755686,
0.7215935588,
-0.1762351841,
-0.4013681412,
-0.5621588826,
0.1555850357,
0.047998406,
-0.2595489025,
-0.0978730693,
0.0976282954,
-0.1122134849,
0.577804327,
-0.3387570977,
-0.2736625373,
0.4384914637,
0.1435611695,
-0.1179698259,
-0.0005415615,
-0.0047462289,
0.0727652162,
0.0702596828,
0.0491869114,
0.0223028604,
0.1362792403,
0.2787135541,
-0.039679341,
-0.6030054688,
0.4354180396,
0.5877074003,
-0.5571010709,
0.505227685,
0.925878942,
-0.3914949298,
-0.1330523938,
-0.485003531,
-0.0458682589,
-0.5020003915,
0.252445519,
0.0597462542,
-0.4984119833,
0.2932974696,
-0.2322827876,
0.2608791888,
0.5320960283,
0.1455186009,
-0.2578630447,
1.0393619537,
0.6815985441,
-0.4012543559,
0.9009876251,
-0.6418839097,
0.2324181497,
-0.8122124672,
-0.3145371079,
-0.4546961486,
-0.3507134914,
-0.5024741292,
0.0708264038,
0.2343491763,
0.0111580268,
-0.318148613,
0.5066946745,
-0.8205971122,
0.2510817647,
0.4608015716,
0.0758987218,
0.3319000304,
-0.195225805,
0.7811861634,
0.2402109206,
-0.6135397553,
-0.4041165411,
0.781477809,
-0.108392179,
0.6412508488,
0.2463954091,
0.3640523553,
1.083820343,
0.791010499,
-0.6331248283,
0.3029570282,
0.211762622,
-0.9022173285,
-0.1636648178,
-0.2635959685,
-1.2258759737,
-0.2886892557,
-0.1341691613,
-0.1543071717,
0.7006726265,
0.115498811,
-0.1713373065,
0.7304030657,
-0.698833406,
0.4072497189,
-0.0628658906,
-0.1288586259,
-0.7318479419,
-0.2770630419,
0.4496001005,
-0.3840474486,
0.3132534623,
-0.2076558769,
-0.440677911,
0.708879292,
0.0490425602,
0.8324623108,
-0.3692072332,
-0.2182639241,
0.5296795964,
0.0008074667,
0.7234780788,
0.1757495254,
0.080133453,
-0.0583832487,
-0.203015849,
-0.484529525,
-0.1530914456,
0.8369249701,
-0.9113386869,
-0.3855716884,
-0.562030375,
-0.2550540268,
0.2423750907,
0.2858536541,
0.0379067287,
0.1950567812,
-0.142888993,
0.4251697958,
0.6531537175,
-0.1188253388,
0.8490419388,
0.8849143982,
0.4159139991,
-0.3484091759,
0.6924395561,
0.3828630447,
-0.4647237957,
0.470125705,
0.0511280783,
-0.4862600863,
-0.4855257571,
-0.0814475641,
0.0286122393,
-0.500267446,
-0.621062994,
-0.7553970814,
0.2274079025,
-0.1733634323,
-0.0824431181,
-0.097188957,
-0.2700051069,
-0.2434471548,
-0.159428075,
0.3701963425,
0.7345719934,
-0.3922766745,
0.2245594412,
-0.7407516241,
0.5373640656,
0.6703454852,
0.6615763307,
-0.3760641813,
0.0902662873,
-0.2487263978,
-0.0499963909,
-0.5703142285,
-0.7246304154,
0.3431164622,
0.4594587088,
0.4379288256,
0.7352620363,
0.422599107,
0.3491316736,
-0.1495878845,
0.68220222,
0.2030420601,
-0.985681355,
0.9006185532,
-0.5525383353,
0.0985034257,
0.242187351,
0.3356072009,
-0.4372239411,
-0.2539460063,
-0.6727296114,
-0.5982273221,
0.439718008,
-0.0057893391,
-0.2649333477,
-0.2109529078,
-0.1926245242,
-0.2011647373,
0.3702318072,
-0.4171993732,
0.4807915092,
-0.5841921568,
0.3162713647,
0.2493273169,
-0.1355408728,
-0.4859728515,
-0.0464119352,
0.8069265485,
-0.0673921555,
0.1049439311,
0.4391571581,
-0.3609000444,
-0.4190150499,
0.0829277933,
0.6339375377,
0.7775914669,
-0.1294217259,
0.0906611532,
0.0743282363,
-0.5014596581,
-0.0701020509,
0.150747925,
-0.0197240356,
0.3187734187,
0.3649306595,
0.5406592488,
0.5324963927,
-0.4943708181,
0.6752468348,
0.1302703768,
-0.1497324705,
-0.2547038794,
-0.2632639408,
-0.0462254696,
0.2557132542,
0.3290843368,
0.152641356,
0.2277637124,
-0.4828655422,
0.0422406718,
0.0393573083,
-0.0744770989,
-0.3965245783,
0.6705100536,
0.6129909754,
-0.2421912253,
0.5824949145,
-0.1684866399,
-0.7499582171,
0.90895468,
0.0033721908,
0.6466851234,
-0.4475324452,
0.0783295259,
0.4413013458,
0.3253313899,
-0.2406371236,
0.5958283544,
-0.279291898,
-0.3444536626,
-0.4740585983,
-0.5606896281,
-0.4119153321,
0.0642521977,
-0.4936445355,
0.5756313801,
-0.2786263824,
-0.2256837636,
-0.0843098462,
0.4860950708,
-0.4701930285,
-0.1108855307,
-0.2875376344,
1.2921872139,
-1.2411156893,
0.435077101,
0.7440363169,
-0.2095030993,
-0.6057564616,
-0.490861088,
-0.1026952118,
-0.467204988,
0.2715495229,
0.2667008936,
0.123811692,
0.1217185557,
-0.4489281178,
-0.6205728054,
1.1781692505,
0.3797241747,
-0.5729555488,
0.4075023234,
-0.6170981526,
0.3208816051,
0.4851644635,
-0.3665655255,
0.2092686743,
1.1528258324,
-0.7172439694,
-1.1075276136,
-0.318323195,
-0.4964499176,
-0.3053591847,
0.9050142765,
-0.7734440565,
0.602373898,
0.0989077613,
-0.3618578613,
-0.0516807139,
0.4749232829,
0.0237801969,
0.2202648371,
1.0508316755,
0.5893691778,
0.6006382108,
0.0654543936,
0.8730306625,
-0.4753471017,
0.5003100038,
0.3199961483,
0.1840860844,
0.5438581109,
0.5314710736,
-0.1085017025,
0.2548957467,
0.9446468353,
-0.5147321224,
0.9762430191,
0.152402088,
-0.4083423913,
0.0634581745,
-0.8898639083,
-0.5839459896,
0.4879526496,
0.1587172449,
-0.0588052347,
-0.5739925504,
0.2477618009,
-0.0981699452,
-0.0879616812,
-0.5917227864,
0.3769708276,
-0.1972432137,
-0.7859419584,
0.1628311425,
-0.144910112,
0.7501029372,
-0.6480209231,
-0.204465881,
-0.1191107705,
0.345097959,
-0.3911579251,
-0.9034720063,
0.6904635429,
0.0177826211,
-0.2948018014,
-0.2432439029,
0.4801247418,
-0.4969741702,
-0.1283875555,
0.2404522002,
0.203401193,
-0.0468848757,
0.0639611557,
-0.4331620038,
0.1463012993,
-0.1871220022,
-0.3328638375,
-0.003191595,
0.3594389856,
-0.4615235329,
0.526724577,
0.9299739599,
0.5425305963,
0.1202038974,
0.0017941478,
0.9060460329,
-0.1259718686,
-0.9313256741,
-0.2257000804,
-0.0832453817,
-0.3925080597,
-0.6232286096,
0.7534943223,
0.8440213203,
0.6454350948,
-0.1557195783,
0.6552163363,
-0.0148641393,
0.2063470334,
-0.1472433954,
0.6856980324,
-0.4789174199,
0.028247267,
0.0155777987,
-0.959872067,
-0.2886965573,
0.6200609207,
0.1609695256,
-0.681853056,
0.2473267615,
0.8812041283,
-0.5103200078,
0.2265837044,
-0.3534772992,
-0.0480364189,
0.5082695484,
0.1189718097,
0.8462454081,
-0.059814509,
0.7428858876,
-0.2064312845,
-0.1369775236,
-0.1362494677,
-1.3625485897,
-0.5376748443,
-0.308973968,
-0.51375103,
0.2833913565,
0.2157709599,
0.2784401476,
0.9258513451,
-1.1137708426,
-0.0099722529,
-0.4069178104,
0.1519308239,
-0.4335701764,
-0.2460154444,
0.8654037714,
-0.0903216973,
-0.640211761,
0.1394358724,
0.2606663406,
-0.1793900579,
-0.4787550867,
0.1503764093,
-0.6468535066,
-0.18910487,
0.314707756,
0.733648479,
-0.1441121399,
-0.3396595418,
-0.1512240767,
0.1656749994,
-0.2359342277,
0.8903366327,
-0.5772535205,
0.4707480371,
1.1077164412,
0.6269994378,
0.762753427,
-0.2607489526,
0.3661331832,
-0.8881475329,
0.401253432,
0.1841727495,
0.6064802408,
0.6984535456,
-0.131122157,
0.8380969763,
0.4424721301,
-0.5635505319,
-0.9486241937,
-0.1528102309,
-0.7798708677,
-0.1736775786,
0.7151086926,
-0.1665896177,
-0.2885787487,
-0.5543512702,
-0.3886212707,
0.5776703954,
-0.3078930974,
1.2030272484,
0.6722175479,
0.2717400491,
-0.0941228271,
-0.4496929348,
0.4176532328,
-0.0007749451,
-0.7697306871,
-0.2558803558,
0.4166732728,
0.2696522176,
0.5320474505,
0.3600493073,
0.2548805475,
0.8561953306,
-0.3692944646,
-0.1063994989,
-0.2354178131,
-0.3405778408,
0.0164962132,
0.0900377259,
-0.5697498918,
-0.5686529875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.01505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.01505v2 | Beyond Classification: Financial Reasoning in State-of-the-Art Language Models | 2023-04-30T04:36:05 | 2023-06-25T18:06:25 | Guijin Son, Hanearl Jung, Moonjeong Hahm, Keonju Na, Sol Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs), consisting of 100 billion or more parameters,
have demonstrated remarkable ability in complex multi-step reasoning tasks.
However, the application of such generic advancements has been limited to a few
fields, such as clinical or legal, with the field of financial reasoning
remaining largely unexplored. To the best of our knowledge, the ability of LLMs
to solve financial reasoning problems has never been dealt with, and whether it
can be performed at any scale remains unknown. To address this knowledge gap,
this research presents a comprehensive investigation into the potential
application of LLMs in the financial domain. The investigation includes a
detailed exploration of a range of subjects, including task formulation,
synthetic data generation, prompting methods, and evaluation capability.
Furthermore, the study benchmarks various GPT variants with parameter scales
ranging from 2.8B to 13B, with and without instruction tuning, on diverse
dataset sizes. By analyzing the results, we reveal that the ability to generate
coherent financial reasoning first emerges at 6B parameters, and continues to
improve with better instruction-tuning or larger datasets. Additionally, the
study provides a publicly accessible dataset named sFIOG (Synthetic-Financial
Investment Opinion Generation), consisting of 11,802 synthetic investment
thesis samples, to support further research in the field of financial
reasoning. Overall, this research seeks to contribute to the understanding of
the efficacy of language models in the field of finance, with a particular
emphasis on their ability to engage in sophisticated reasoning and analysis
within the context of investment decision-making. | [
-0.1639845967,
-0.7958155274,
0.7343841791,
0.2412660867,
-0.0043013333,
0.2365973294,
-0.2367723882,
-0.5061283112,
-0.2806391716,
0.5605094433,
-0.3842014968,
-0.498896867,
-0.5076698661,
-0.0441205092,
-0.40263924,
0.9711607099,
-0.0133705139,
0.292357415,
-0.009686837,
0.2569761276,
-0.2284670621,
-0.5903197527,
-0.9282093048,
-0.2999016643,
0.379799515,
0.0660840049,
0.631246388,
0.4133798778,
0.6802736521,
0.3092151284,
-0.0018434502,
0.1885635257,
-0.2591454983,
-0.2667915225,
-0.3492815793,
-0.5379984379,
-0.3756929636,
0.2439150363,
0.6245514154,
0.7130694389,
-0.4172135592,
0.0163246393,
-0.2291720808,
0.8169991374,
-0.4938628078,
0.5584898591,
-0.6515352726,
-0.1860640943,
-0.1638860404,
-0.2780125737,
-0.6084327698,
-0.2807748914,
0.5382275581,
-0.6413662434,
-0.0656284019,
0.2176432908,
0.7077093124,
0.2317217737,
-0.5160893798,
-0.5810649991,
-0.830312252,
0.8690516949,
-0.7626010776,
0.4007715285,
0.2658291757,
0.3753507435,
-0.1999787241,
-0.7119515538,
-0.2814823091,
-0.4126833975,
0.0264477171,
0.060599748,
-0.3482555747,
0.2439270914,
0.3101619184,
0.3754808009,
-0.3075685501,
0.1144554093,
-0.3261398375,
-0.1344637126,
0.6397342682,
0.0340264104,
-0.0525003746,
0.0403190963,
-0.3792218566,
-0.15478836,
-0.7031420469,
0.0059608934,
0.3581327796,
0.2930784225,
0.0230187383,
0.4933530688,
-0.0408168137,
0.6257886291,
-0.0854263976,
-0.5266741514,
-0.145546332,
-0.2549102604,
-0.5398613214,
-0.0343492143,
0.3978205025,
0.1043897122,
0.4873252809,
0.0247352384,
-0.3248207867,
-0.1211156175,
0.3007284105,
-0.3586274683,
-0.0153154852,
0.1815625727,
-0.3991589844,
-0.2433226407,
-0.0559119135,
-0.5433639288,
-0.2975329757,
-0.6593660116,
0.3181431592,
-0.427819103,
-0.192813158,
0.5575667024,
-0.2781315148,
0.4417026937,
0.2886369228,
-0.855376482,
0.3159634173,
0.9549677372,
0.3257760406,
0.0548350327,
0.005498983,
-0.0345863588,
0.3285015523,
-0.4726585746,
0.9125316143,
-0.6208428144,
-0.4219351113,
-0.0220913868,
-0.4456549585,
-0.3680148721,
-0.566316843,
0.2190205008,
-0.5070767403,
0.0650370046,
-0.0897643566,
-0.7562737465,
-0.1801174283,
0.2298266739,
-0.3203381896,
0.7650970817,
0.282066077,
-0.6591323614,
0.6647921205,
-0.9365839362,
-0.3065209091,
0.1639652848,
-0.2708962262,
-0.2464929074,
0.0335638523,
0.0375903919,
0.3449241817,
-0.7490634322,
0.6076903939,
-0.308481425,
-0.3968325853,
0.7148153782,
-0.6892120242,
0.3243115842,
0.0864548683,
-0.3590606153,
-0.142653659,
-0.7158247232,
-0.1619228423,
0.1774264127,
-0.0637628734,
-0.4176195264,
0.0805341154,
-0.3014851511,
-0.0765193701,
0.4669875801,
-0.4063023031,
0.2975184619,
-0.5327382088,
0.7055467963,
0.8288419247,
-0.1259061992,
0.3037118316,
-0.2936114669,
0.6038417816,
-0.2131982893,
0.177592203,
-0.1119631976,
-0.2746013105,
-0.4960102737,
-0.447693795,
0.3940324485,
0.6813949347,
-0.3170140386,
-0.0059246304,
0.0852991194,
-0.4607225657,
-0.3283412755,
0.0744282082,
0.1871301979,
0.3545094132,
0.2006538212,
0.5320016742,
-0.4181998968,
-1.1718566418,
-0.338414222,
-0.3082492054,
0.0862202197,
0.4610174,
0.4564499259,
-0.1303151846,
0.7437423468,
-0.5844998956,
0.0697129145,
-0.4362540245,
0.0946077183,
0.4004742801,
0.3381953239,
0.6840768456,
-0.6736590266,
0.0577656887,
0.1383251995,
-0.6210051775,
0.017839225,
-0.6647862792,
-0.1714200377,
0.1428847164,
0.5873101354,
-0.5490986109,
0.3172909915,
0.3465484381,
-0.3245657682,
0.5494190454,
-0.5691822767,
-0.0996246338,
-0.8114897013,
-0.0848408118,
0.3803848922,
0.053347867,
-0.4337985516,
0.0016581534,
-0.0970439017,
0.1114744022,
0.0371153131,
0.664146781,
-0.2616147995,
-0.1649916321,
-0.3546487093,
0.1445321143,
-0.1383911818,
0.4134793878,
0.0091962162,
0.7898269892,
0.6265063882,
-0.3454419672,
0.3678232133,
-0.1272499561,
-0.4056215584,
0.3615628183,
-0.6242889166,
-0.2050386518,
0.0948375836,
0.2639698386,
-1.0634516478,
-0.2228712142,
0.0576894134,
-0.0659360364,
0.328709811,
0.1044690758,
-0.5889050961,
-0.4061546326,
0.0601315834,
0.3134644628,
0.3156478107,
-0.4155225754,
0.6428524852,
0.2065213025,
-0.4669439495,
-0.4621959925,
-0.5419630408,
0.0913418829,
-0.4353883564,
-0.5736717582,
0.2635994256,
0.1233018786,
-0.6485910416,
-0.2083525062,
-0.2574770451,
0.1242953017,
0.1012405828,
-0.0993771851,
0.8784673214,
-0.366962105,
0.2354708314,
0.2147191912,
-0.3516137302,
0.2034071088,
-0.6247860789,
0.1668165773,
-0.2883585691,
-0.423805505,
-0.1203594953,
0.2380927652,
0.5589529872,
-0.2231562883,
0.8334354162,
0.0520328544,
-0.260371238,
-0.4103537798,
-0.7188786268,
0.2786161304,
-0.5435260534,
0.1459270865,
-0.2808098495,
-1.2014763355,
0.50038445,
-0.3303766251,
0.2346609235,
0.6837177873,
0.711940527,
-0.0075770896,
0.8753176332,
0.34943977,
0.1958217025,
0.2698251009,
-0.2925641239,
0.5467725396,
-0.5409741402,
-0.4567905068,
-0.3345460892,
-0.1968084425,
-0.5922688246,
-0.4963597953,
0.3381019235,
0.2166625559,
-0.1998073012,
0.1558068991,
-0.2452561855,
0.4915111959,
0.3088886142,
-0.1076058298,
0.258669734,
-0.307882309,
-0.2840393782,
0.2374466062,
-0.4857401252,
-0.6430127621,
1.1712772846,
0.6411535144,
0.7176418304,
-0.242784664,
0.4856379628,
0.2994385362,
0.4055956304,
-0.7928965092,
0.5351520181,
-0.3287326097,
-0.5034148097,
-0.4820446372,
-0.5985156298,
-0.5569369197,
0.1240937039,
0.0280866455,
-0.6499124765,
0.2218195647,
0.0672629699,
-0.6231051683,
0.2402395457,
-0.7462279201,
0.7075564265,
-0.5071997046,
-0.0210123695,
-0.2774814367,
-0.2851579785,
0.4809622169,
-0.5084990263,
0.4994882047,
-0.1943998486,
-0.0543651879,
0.4463417828,
-0.3983664513,
0.7996113896,
0.0175708141,
-0.7124317288,
0.4087714553,
-0.0666855201,
0.4604395628,
0.2558507621,
-0.1979068369,
0.1539403796,
0.195052892,
-0.2736326456,
-0.7648612261,
0.6194007397,
-0.4770259261,
-0.8165256977,
-0.3120088875,
-0.8218953609,
-0.6100955009,
-0.1705551296,
-0.2150432318,
0.3335595727,
-0.038918633,
0.1099359691,
0.4579855502,
-0.2969416678,
0.247969836,
0.5543177724,
-0.2637774646,
-0.4122543633,
0.9276520014,
0.0157985985,
0.3384660482,
0.3081074953,
0.480283916,
-0.6592137814,
-0.6730365157,
-0.1965418309,
0.4742645323,
-0.7419975996,
-0.1066685244,
-0.2036104798,
-0.1568603069,
-0.455196023,
-0.2822007835,
-0.3083267212,
-0.3859916329,
-0.0653348118,
-0.3980573714,
0.4513466656,
0.7108205557,
-0.0853172615,
0.0331030041,
-0.8465859294,
0.1827589422,
0.3478622437,
0.4598148465,
0.078302376,
-0.4228448272,
-0.2543869615,
0.0477417037,
0.160111025,
-0.3971421719,
0.1522313207,
-0.036937777,
0.8182313442,
0.650057435,
-0.186401695,
0.6894123554,
-0.0775913373,
0.3981209099,
-0.0762419105,
-0.8754889965,
0.4315272868,
-0.6345918775,
0.1787316352,
0.3565502167,
0.2659752071,
-0.2741809189,
-0.4861866534,
-0.5983635187,
-0.6731120944,
0.538746357,
0.160238415,
0.097617045,
-0.1165724099,
0.7924669385,
0.183515057,
0.3272914588,
-0.3957419395,
-0.0257268641,
0.0189290289,
-0.0016866785,
0.0611524098,
-0.050342571,
0.1172151044,
-0.4335185289,
0.5927157402,
-0.2267161012,
-0.07450708,
-0.0979401618,
0.3848204315,
0.0611513667,
0.3319352865,
0.6778864264,
0.8447258472,
0.0399545021,
-0.1915444881,
0.0817695931,
-0.1266828924,
-0.0976353064,
0.3380900025,
0.0138002122,
-0.3239755929,
0.389634788,
0.6731268764,
0.5365434885,
-1.1730819941,
0.3088941574,
0.0787119791,
-0.6804513335,
-0.5096927881,
0.1278038323,
0.2420396954,
0.6404075623,
0.5122355819,
0.0620179586,
0.0329773538,
-0.7711789012,
0.0909703821,
0.507258296,
-0.0332966037,
0.033351738,
0.5778948665,
-0.0304287151,
0.1808037162,
0.7101029754,
0.1430607885,
-0.2998606265,
0.6314608455,
0.5278378725,
0.863017261,
0.1500989646,
0.3557000756,
-0.0422679745,
0.1068221182,
-0.3627313077,
0.2873597145,
-0.0839842558,
-0.8649745584,
-0.8117940426,
-1.02146101,
-0.5174421668,
0.1015981212,
-0.5932140946,
-0.0685753375,
-0.6651502848,
-0.2313743085,
0.3440034986,
-0.3230239749,
-0.3864134252,
0.2052244544,
0.290363729,
1.0569498539,
-0.4188744426,
0.6346490383,
0.6110384464,
-0.2916781008,
-0.7451313138,
-0.1932072639,
0.0350043215,
-1.0086169243,
0.763256371,
-0.0666845366,
-0.1610738635,
-0.1917662174,
-0.4894013703,
-0.750090301,
0.8812647462,
0.5572209954,
-0.7151465416,
-0.5203696489,
0.5203874707,
0.6192235351,
-0.5335686803,
-0.0715543404,
1.0750584602,
0.789342463,
0.5918024778,
-0.8896414042,
-0.3184369206,
-0.221186772,
-0.080485791,
0.4202066362,
-0.6644486785,
0.7366917133,
-0.3108179271,
0.1623049676,
0.08250653,
0.5079483986,
0.5930731297,
0.2526190877,
0.3419648111,
0.3639833927,
0.7885020375,
-0.3411373198,
1.2839072943,
-0.4435778558,
0.2778266072,
0.7472532392,
-0.4404557645,
0.7168739438,
0.2289081514,
-0.3600979149,
0.5701622963,
0.730719924,
-0.2732613087,
0.0841727704,
0.6097368002,
-0.4063663185,
-0.7334124446,
-0.05308263,
-0.0268772263,
0.5755783319,
0.6405271292,
-0.5309571624,
0.0146277519,
-0.0009313282,
-0.1207637489,
-0.0362320058,
-0.3727483451,
0.7863719463,
0.5055175424,
-0.4932703078,
0.0347361639,
0.1117282361,
0.4613118768,
-0.9203531146,
-0.1757243127,
-0.0311881471,
0.3682839274,
0.0987978652,
-0.7174073458,
0.3292394876,
0.1713166237,
0.0252675395,
-0.5418257117,
0.7368431091,
-0.0907549337,
-0.78924191,
0.2238601148,
0.3858792782,
-0.026446363,
-0.1040819064,
-0.5407818556,
-0.3866589665,
-0.0867534727,
-0.203755945,
0.3963871598,
0.7484588027,
0.0029682899,
0.8323211074,
0.8710992932,
0.240124777,
-0.1786495149,
0.2714763284,
0.7045338154,
-0.9494333863,
-0.3395810127,
-0.8698351979,
0.2268476933,
0.182482332,
-0.4120490849,
0.5959676504,
0.6307416558,
0.877479434,
0.0106991939,
0.877204895,
0.5386999249,
0.3188375533,
-0.7688695788,
0.2866034806,
-0.4573474526,
0.5624260902,
-0.3850480616,
-0.6138387918,
-0.2827642858,
0.6237939,
-0.6483951211,
0.0564352535,
0.5020747185,
0.4408355653,
0.2133779526,
0.4882966578,
0.2997191548,
0.0563856997,
0.1811855286,
0.3224433064,
0.8154870868,
0.0945680588,
0.5409942269,
0.0887175798,
-0.0131012723,
-0.0859422982,
-0.7804281712,
-0.8375936151,
-0.1099296138,
-0.3987489939,
-0.033217486,
-0.1037328914,
0.8935823441,
0.1422286034,
-0.69613868,
-0.3946753144,
-0.1015145108,
-0.1296364963,
-0.176049605,
-0.181524843,
0.2870934904,
-0.2987143695,
-0.4953041077,
0.5944008231,
0.7525702715,
0.2745554149,
-0.6237637401,
0.080333896,
0.1045518741,
0.629368484,
0.722920239,
0.0728821009,
-0.7631503344,
-0.2075561732,
0.0968036801,
0.063123621,
-0.1156498194,
1.1112657785,
-0.3264757991,
0.1388498098,
0.3210469186,
0.6514038444,
0.3808430433,
0.0110030686,
0.8484491706,
-0.1935576499,
-0.0878075734,
0.1302764118,
0.5679501891,
-0.2027330548,
-0.2703069448,
0.4114783704,
0.1813369393,
-0.3853715062,
-0.4384632409,
-0.0711460784,
-0.8181207776,
-0.5310857296,
1.0706609488,
-0.0805314109,
-0.132477358,
0.0497182719,
-0.2800133526,
-0.0771905407,
-0.4522885978,
0.7080562115,
0.8488914967,
-0.3548500836,
-0.1910838485,
-0.6411976218,
0.4113620222,
0.2220707089,
-0.8266972303,
0.2817625403,
0.4459511936,
0.1208248883,
0.0837975442,
0.4294667244,
-0.2543545663,
0.2145740986,
0.2117544711,
-0.3762784898,
-0.0618934631,
-0.2191226333,
-0.0562188849,
0.290943563,
0.0584965199,
0.3724134266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00382v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00382v2 | Constructing a Knowledge Graph from Textual Descriptions of Software Vulnerabilities in the National Vulnerability Database | 2023-04-30T04:23:40 | 2023-05-15T07:36:11 | Anders Mølmen Høst, Pierre Lison, Leon Moonen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Knowledge graphs have shown promise for several cybersecurity tasks, such as
vulnerability assessment and threat analysis. In this work, we present a new
method for constructing a vulnerability knowledge graph from information in the
National Vulnerability Database (NVD). Our approach combines named entity
recognition (NER), relation extraction (RE), and entity prediction using a
combination of neural models, heuristic rules, and knowledge graph embeddings.
We demonstrate how our method helps to fix missing entities in knowledge graphs
used for cybersecurity and evaluate the performance. | [
-0.3914951086,
-0.6990248561,
0.3788324594,
-0.203108713,
0.2113303542,
0.3923297524,
0.2075606138,
-0.33081761,
0.796259582,
0.7493964434,
-0.3661440015,
-0.6990088224,
-0.3945880532,
-0.1031644717,
-0.4175433517,
0.8932541013,
0.0527660884,
-0.5706102848,
-0.5536851287,
0.261354506,
-0.6200192571,
-0.2628509104,
-0.2518779635,
-0.0365486853,
0.3221370578,
0.4386898279,
0.4642103314,
0.2197488993,
0.7156199813,
0.2877686024,
0.3015019298,
0.0796202049,
-0.1669685245,
0.1335325241,
-0.0848345608,
-0.238697052,
-0.7646584511,
-0.2990406752,
0.2873737216,
0.369854629,
0.1337562799,
-0.0426269621,
-0.0528109409,
0.3462372422,
-0.4989097416,
0.3037727177,
-0.756397903,
0.1299899966,
-0.2100712061,
-0.4035462439,
-0.4513714015,
-0.4925707579,
0.4669638872,
-0.7296285033,
0.2003961951,
0.1269115955,
0.7673059106,
0.1187836379,
-0.4634527266,
0.113833569,
-0.6957312822,
0.3062145114,
-0.3129545748,
0.5690677762,
0.4646884203,
0.6163381338,
-0.2266502082,
-0.6453446746,
-0.2678896189,
-0.1874385029,
-0.0565638617,
-0.3109702766,
-0.3063905835,
-0.2652364671,
0.1015997902,
0.1073562354,
-0.428299427,
-0.0771096051,
-0.4394074678,
-0.5406962037,
0.6209126711,
0.403223753,
0.3534112275,
-0.2898173034,
-0.5769917369,
0.1325105578,
-0.7041569948,
-0.399092555,
0.3535229862,
0.3174003959,
-0.1851584017,
0.4664954245,
0.0244423114,
0.7217841148,
-0.273669064,
-0.581874311,
0.3647127151,
-0.1745307148,
-0.1701130569,
0.1352350265,
0.528891623,
0.6133147478,
0.089948982,
-0.697727561,
-0.1501474679,
-0.1457222104,
0.5909473896,
-0.4361077845,
-0.6658625603,
0.0346892104,
-0.2567671239,
-0.5485046506,
0.0593594685,
-1.1212540865,
-0.9720066786,
0.0185117219,
0.155312866,
-0.7805808187,
-0.5163977146,
-0.4006792605,
-0.652200222,
0.021921115,
0.0876575559,
-0.137352109,
0.53996557,
0.1564120054,
0.6558861732,
0.279322803,
0.0066183629,
-0.3226606846,
0.4300996661,
0.0642171353,
0.6178175211,
-0.2456724197,
-0.0994394347,
-0.173058182,
-0.1933332384,
0.1115266457,
-0.2590973973,
0.0580613315,
-0.6805056334,
-0.3439970315,
-0.216680631,
-0.7835074663,
-0.3167052567,
0.6318811774,
-1.1628806591,
0.6650942564,
0.4863229692,
-1.2822419405,
0.2626069188,
-0.4355121851,
-0.3364117742,
0.2792511582,
-0.0151971728,
-0.3344073892,
-0.3260563016,
0.2833563685,
0.370651871,
-0.5534729958,
-0.0215678159,
-0.4774148762,
-0.0229295567,
0.2132846415,
0.1771671623,
0.7626493573,
-0.354724735,
-0.3271816671,
-0.2050438076,
-0.8672277331,
0.0487570204,
0.4197325706,
-0.1512877345,
-0.5182389617,
0.0872491002,
-0.1993103027,
-0.1877685487,
0.2119771987,
-0.5358536839,
0.2023174316,
-0.7431714535,
0.5227352381,
0.600358665,
0.6526728272,
0.3825901151,
0.0605480522,
0.5137521625,
0.1413549036,
0.2460578382,
0.3054939508,
-0.3449365199,
-0.5330936909,
0.1832920015,
0.4954608679,
0.9694025517,
-1.2531219721,
0.4490461051,
-0.4427347481,
-0.7131444216,
0.2192100137,
-0.0102478079,
0.3196275532,
0.765160799,
0.5794337988,
-0.2920667827,
-0.8652533293,
-0.6014909744,
-0.0249267034,
-0.4714067578,
0.2250715047,
0.3340011239,
0.6499786377,
-0.2278361171,
0.9855489135,
-1.0690368414,
-0.3756216168,
-0.2527939677,
-0.146134004,
-0.1640256792,
-0.025352424,
0.6147071719,
-0.5164949894,
-0.1752323359,
0.0115195215,
-0.9168727398,
0.4600166976,
0.2702233493,
0.1143166125,
-0.0643358976,
0.6984317899,
-0.2573943138,
0.6847794056,
-0.0760904178,
-0.3052704632,
0.5895286798,
0.0130221881,
-0.1299642473,
-1.1417229176,
-0.2962332666,
0.1672958434,
-0.1211535633,
-0.7100505233,
0.2208102793,
0.2153349519,
-0.1388958544,
-0.3373406231,
0.4706465602,
-0.6385830045,
-0.1370092332,
0.2095819265,
0.6150352359,
-0.0446630605,
0.1626887769,
-0.4465718865,
0.1514833122,
0.9130945206,
-0.6716687083,
0.8353133202,
0.328938514,
-0.1747671664,
0.5615638494,
-0.4807593822,
0.2576169968,
-0.2222532183,
-0.0969435051,
-0.3993957043,
-0.4012427628,
0.2939174771,
-0.396017909,
0.4435720444,
-0.4742971063,
-0.3372270465,
-0.5024682283,
-0.137260437,
0.1802451462,
0.061130058,
-0.0562394708,
0.6818500161,
0.9900137782,
0.1454350799,
-0.4756492674,
-0.6203405857,
0.4132140279,
-0.2857602239,
-0.731098175,
0.5666282177,
0.4385229647,
-0.1950709373,
0.3418568671,
0.0862734541,
-0.5183923841,
0.4772807658,
0.5170195103,
0.467020601,
-0.2768369615,
0.3826269507,
-0.3483444452,
-0.1712976694,
0.1569876373,
-0.4895749092,
0.3701040149,
0.0742804483,
-0.2645282149,
-0.0116514945,
0.0418460667,
0.1816168129,
-0.4941818118,
0.8381276727,
0.4133220017,
-0.9044229388,
-0.0906813219,
-0.1820584685,
-0.2143648416,
-0.3710597456,
0.1729885787,
-0.0998683572,
-0.6247093678,
0.3852383196,
-0.1704870015,
-0.0893692672,
0.4749776125,
-0.1171469092,
0.4010684788,
0.090449743,
0.6749351025,
-0.365634948,
0.3470364511,
-0.3076357245,
0.5693609118,
-0.7470324636,
-0.5339878798,
-0.2742077708,
-0.1701801717,
-0.4516450167,
-0.2698942721,
0.6261360645,
-0.0570845157,
-0.2906102538,
1.025383234,
-0.4276451468,
0.3929587305,
0.334669292,
0.3340335786,
-0.1333243549,
0.0121918553,
-0.3084162176,
0.0254433677,
-0.3273248374,
-0.2797736526,
1.351670146,
0.1729205251,
0.5764887929,
0.4604519904,
1.2028847933,
0.1864165813,
0.0556559972,
-0.3640698791,
0.6533613801,
0.1234744042,
-0.414518714,
-0.4900987744,
-0.6488197446,
-0.9935210943,
-0.532741785,
-0.4269078672,
-1.0816392899,
0.0623965077,
0.0134662194,
-0.5654304028,
0.3134534061,
-0.5685843825,
0.6205973029,
-0.0131675359,
0.1034130231,
0.2046004534,
-0.4713644087,
0.3106045127,
0.1003467962,
0.1171553209,
-0.0136134904,
0.1745049059,
0.6127848029,
-0.3896753788,
0.8341252208,
-0.4789121449,
0.2905639112,
0.4301127493,
0.1457645148,
0.5922725797,
0.342001617,
-0.1637953818,
-0.0031169197,
-0.3877203465,
-0.0087227356,
-0.6337527633,
0.5278896689,
-0.5458231568,
-0.452067554,
-0.3008041382,
-0.2383465469,
-0.1766514927,
0.5233215094,
-0.0637482479,
0.6854424477,
-0.5658757091,
-0.0307349041,
0.8074406385,
-0.4645898342,
0.2853814363,
0.0542516485,
-0.1221233159,
-0.6792631745,
1.042001605,
0.6797938347,
-0.1119242087,
0.6520486474,
-0.1943605244,
-0.0841315389,
-0.2930662632,
-0.2322632819,
-0.1077854186,
-0.665265739,
-0.8260018229,
-0.6551391482,
-0.6918160319,
-0.7324751616,
0.0410896204,
0.0780619308,
-0.4363952279,
-0.2670207918,
-0.5459588766,
0.9287691116,
0.8235044479,
0.3343317807,
0.0533030629,
-0.7814013362,
0.3235940933,
0.2659753561,
0.2573888004,
0.0365144759,
0.215207085,
-0.2363780886,
-0.192338407,
-0.4189431667,
-1.7059271336,
0.5265471935,
0.1373232454,
0.7606604099,
0.1270880699,
0.3355827332,
0.4644245505,
-0.3573829532,
0.540514648,
0.2274347395,
-0.7326108813,
0.8402500153,
-0.0340114236,
-0.3931588233,
0.2926217616,
0.3555493951,
-0.1107553989,
-0.201689288,
-0.8035581112,
-0.9554438591,
0.2172797769,
0.2758530974,
-0.1387291551,
-0.233795315,
0.3410377204,
-0.4019581974,
0.0531495735,
-0.4372381568,
-0.5690177679,
-0.2244775593,
0.0127304671,
0.449149251,
-0.1080534831,
-0.1948032677,
-0.1509181112,
0.6745321155,
-0.1686366051,
0.717692554,
0.0876663476,
-0.3767629862,
0.2472411692,
-0.0367183089,
-0.1701695025,
0.323300004,
-0.0618541837,
0.3490992486,
0.342947185,
-0.3700028956,
0.0110134147,
0.2288415879,
-0.1104985327,
-0.0410996974,
0.4914034605,
0.6211156845,
0.3864450753,
-0.1693432182,
0.656689167,
-0.1317174286,
-0.1233549193,
-0.6200388074,
0.160473451,
0.4079934061,
0.3289206624,
-0.0576314777,
-0.0518903919,
0.1201545745,
-0.400667578,
0.6481790543,
0.2120300084,
-0.5077055693,
0.0664987862,
0.4301123321,
0.0621018447,
-0.3942442536,
1.1760958433,
-0.487005651,
-0.4956158996,
0.8393745422,
0.5507213473,
0.7567635775,
-0.3138296902,
0.5326022506,
0.4370146394,
0.7359022498,
0.3354361653,
0.4596728384,
0.3913567364,
-0.6953958869,
0.1655686647,
-0.2436363995,
-0.0588366501,
-0.1645260006,
-0.5930660963,
0.4727504849,
-0.9074673057,
-0.4486372471,
0.3733430207,
-0.0852503777,
-0.9197080731,
0.0598938465,
-0.2250271589,
0.954428196,
-0.7949943542,
0.5719285607,
0.4890784919,
-0.7209281325,
-0.9335237741,
0.0911549181,
0.1209624186,
-0.5352922082,
0.3523482084,
0.073465392,
0.5317592621,
-0.2582543194,
-0.1492913365,
-1.2814851999,
1.3748235703,
0.7270484567,
-0.2610828578,
-0.0799012557,
0.0199475437,
0.270596385,
-0.3035371304,
0.0885947645,
0.4606724083,
0.5482431054,
-0.2275059074,
-0.4955686331,
0.3162763119,
-0.3985461593,
-0.2361651808,
0.6812227964,
-0.1844474375,
0.8381789327,
-0.3543962538,
-0.1979811788,
-0.5753825307,
0.757140398,
-0.1429944783,
0.3457892537,
0.4810490012,
0.6887531877,
1.0902783871,
-0.009533694,
0.8259590268,
-0.2050058544,
-0.0317687914,
1.2741793394,
-0.3049080968,
0.5239731669,
0.1323320419,
-0.0725028217,
1.0691511631,
0.291559875,
-0.2666336,
0.4297313392,
0.1765934825,
-0.1432218701,
-0.0828363076,
-0.0036364901,
-0.217846334,
0.181524694,
0.4243140519,
-0.5816304088,
-0.3067987263,
-0.1295337528,
-0.0452402309,
-0.3139392436,
-0.139446035,
0.8357170224,
0.0520536341,
-0.1804861128,
0.1744359583,
0.3588211536,
-0.2241303623,
-0.1362763941,
-0.2039175332,
0.2425549179,
-0.2571730614,
-0.3535734415,
-0.9106162786,
0.6620259285,
0.0052233096,
-0.2344297469,
0.3527355194,
1.174708128,
0.0667390898,
-0.3688472211,
0.5111447573,
0.27301687,
0.0861531273,
-0.0761935115,
-0.3931869566,
-0.5602606535,
-0.0614983477,
0.1339096874,
0.353887856,
0.5876669288,
-0.3668033779,
0.6833110452,
0.4360912144,
-0.2871069908,
0.0941793695,
0.0178015679,
1.0938124657,
-0.5953768492,
-0.4373119473,
-0.8426514864,
0.5826973319,
-0.5608994961,
-0.3455282748,
0.6395487785,
0.3748479486,
0.3887599409,
0.1907118857,
0.8074533343,
-0.4311273396,
0.129086405,
-0.2645960748,
0.5864427686,
-0.1231004223,
0.3627724946,
-0.4707327187,
-0.7299019098,
-0.3658213317,
0.3130054474,
-0.3109821379,
-0.229158625,
0.58370924,
0.9632887244,
0.1582179666,
-0.0177821871,
0.0367789343,
0.1918375939,
0.0635297745,
0.6761621833,
0.304012388,
-0.6058601141,
0.474072963,
-0.2864867449,
0.0069588451,
-0.1735190302,
-1.0540007353,
-0.8326395154,
-0.5323901176,
-0.4690791965,
-0.6405478716,
0.0265226942,
0.5229683518,
0.4682136178,
-0.4931894839,
0.4894985557,
-0.1023231298,
0.7777858973,
-0.0805806741,
-0.2759117782,
0.2948374748,
0.1157292053,
0.2754423022,
0.5400675535,
0.3925433159,
0.0787754655,
-0.4145700634,
0.0123591358,
-0.0723001435,
-0.0997318327,
0.178547129,
0.0486356542,
-0.2571407557,
-0.4625522494,
0.0437093154,
0.0458087325,
-0.3213203847,
0.5699376464,
-0.9322857261,
0.2548145354,
0.6036268473,
0.7062165737,
0.2018667012,
-0.7179011106,
0.5047677159,
-1.2675149441,
-0.3210290074,
0.0423742905,
0.5575820804,
0.5061187744,
-0.7172856331,
0.5052978992,
0.4088418186,
-0.1249024644,
-0.9004735351,
0.3073465228,
-0.7732667327,
-0.0956260264,
0.8015445471,
-0.3588960171,
-0.5460044742,
-0.5657920837,
0.2006259412,
0.4723935723,
-0.1863226295,
0.6109341383,
0.2367833406,
0.1776931286,
-0.039913781,
-0.3097580373,
0.1598426402,
-0.7417626977,
-0.9980223179,
-0.0293040499,
0.1792360395,
0.5209857821,
0.3826618493,
0.594166398,
-0.1418718547,
0.0275110565,
0.4590513408,
0.1409792006,
-0.1049390063,
-0.7078399658,
0.3210396469,
0.5120487213,
-0.0835814402,
0.2107188255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00366v1 | S2abEL: A Dataset for Entity Linking from Scientific Tables | 2023-04-30T02:07:22 | 2023-04-30T02:07:22 | Yuze Lou, Bailey Kuehl, Erin Bransom, Sergey Feldman, Aakanksha Naik, Doug Downey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Entity linking (EL) is the task of linking a textual mention to its
corresponding entry in a knowledge base, and is critical for many
knowledge-intensive NLP applications. When applied to tables in scientific
papers, EL is a step toward large-scale scientific knowledge bases that could
enable advanced scientific question answering and analytics. We present the
first dataset for EL in scientific tables. EL for scientific tables is
especially challenging because scientific knowledge bases can be very
incomplete, and disambiguating table mentions typically requires understanding
the papers's tet in addition to the table. Our dataset, S2abEL, focuses on EL
in machine learning results tables and includes hand-labeled cell types,
attributed sources, and entity links from the PaperswithCode taxonomy for 8,429
cells from 732 tables. We introduce a neural baseline method designed for EL on
scientific tables containing many out-of-knowledge-base mentions, and show that
it significantly outperforms a state-of-the-art generic table EL method. The
best baselines fall below human performance, and our analysis highlights
avenues for improvement. | [
-0.0031938259,
-0.470041275,
0.431846112,
-0.010036855,
-0.1016243324,
0.0369538553,
-0.0820540115,
-0.832914114,
0.2737087309,
0.2286323905,
-0.3855319917,
-0.560405612,
-0.4444026649,
0.3412653804,
-0.6032124162,
1.4369032383,
0.2024295181,
0.0021745716,
-0.8421236873,
-0.1570990086,
0.3596380949,
0.2307015359,
-0.5413814783,
-0.203215912,
1.0189697742,
0.5942748189,
0.5456709266,
1.0351549387,
0.7990070581,
0.2212991714,
0.1567756236,
0.3174333572,
-0.5188952088,
0.1639668643,
-0.4175990224,
-0.7369702458,
-0.7035312653,
-0.4738445282,
0.519131124,
0.7999334931,
-0.0283438899,
0.5278882384,
0.1319096237,
0.8981363773,
-0.2651715577,
0.5841522813,
-1.136898756,
0.0786481351,
-0.6838898063,
0.0561023951,
-0.5004621148,
-0.3942143321,
0.040457882,
-0.8035747409,
0.3328832984,
0.497350812,
0.822422266,
0.4411303401,
-0.2867328525,
-0.4488487244,
-0.2368187904,
0.3194163144,
-0.4401598275,
0.5135842562,
0.4971222579,
0.0139305433,
-0.0580780283,
-1.1056673527,
-0.603298068,
-0.4604118168,
-0.2789228559,
-0.0110667059,
-0.1559321731,
-0.0731547698,
0.6025013328,
-0.2357278764,
-0.7646048069,
-0.0336467735,
-0.6427665353,
0.0846556127,
0.551081121,
-0.106025219,
0.2160428613,
-0.140425846,
-0.2945118546,
0.1157926694,
-1.0401355028,
-0.5785905719,
0.1401971132,
0.1138823181,
0.3412980139,
0.7415215373,
0.1519020051,
0.510777235,
-0.0853123516,
0.2779108584,
0.2343779355,
-0.5031143427,
0.1748595834,
0.3885860443,
0.5519237518,
0.4615032375,
0.0910824016,
-0.4015549421,
0.1265828311,
-0.0079235714,
0.1419931352,
-0.6764440536,
-0.4586417377,
0.1109177098,
-0.1180646271,
0.0585732721,
-0.2861270905,
-0.972869873,
-0.3888985217,
-0.1600377113,
0.2195919305,
-0.2739490569,
0.0445119627,
-0.5367318392,
0.050644327,
-0.1850449741,
0.188859269,
-0.9337216616,
0.4706614316,
0.332344234,
0.7829425931,
-0.2220343947,
-0.2386981696,
-0.1584267765,
0.5566446781,
-0.2470085919,
0.8554383516,
-0.1478194445,
-0.3198372126,
-0.0957243517,
-0.2488815039,
0.1889148653,
-0.6046019197,
0.352430284,
-0.7788801193,
-0.1876102537,
-0.6588135958,
-0.697062552,
0.02522319,
-0.2884443998,
-0.978400588,
1.2122836113,
0.0709556341,
-0.8134474158,
0.638805747,
-0.7413533926,
-0.573769629,
0.3432458639,
-0.3289783299,
-0.4391727746,
-0.2584521174,
-0.2117891908,
0.1631233245,
-0.4636480212,
0.4238709509,
-0.353061229,
0.0343039818,
-0.1465653032,
0.303249985,
0.5878297091,
0.2851138413,
-0.277040422,
-0.1565741599,
-0.8988342285,
0.0532974862,
0.1338000298,
0.0108806072,
-0.4882065952,
0.182484597,
0.015088547,
0.1149143875,
0.2621762455,
-0.5102818608,
0.2410771102,
-0.1207124963,
0.4527279437,
0.3719188869,
-0.0440948792,
0.3052162826,
-0.030331159,
-0.3263919055,
0.0017261137,
-0.4072687924,
0.1493444741,
-0.5481289029,
-0.8410540223,
0.222292617,
0.4507992566,
0.421613127,
-0.8946065307,
0.610791862,
-0.3537553251,
-0.6516358852,
-0.6339847445,
0.2558080852,
0.5520740747,
1.217700243,
0.9360942245,
0.2513290346,
-0.7552383542,
-1.2483520508,
-0.2463715672,
-0.45602566,
-0.4840828776,
0.4408731759,
0.9880979061,
0.0185577571,
0.8168032169,
-0.3793278337,
-0.293114543,
0.0115564568,
-0.0032676239,
0.033725705,
0.1991181076,
0.3898304105,
-0.5470130444,
-0.6665454507,
0.1312488914,
-1.1231273413,
-0.1134947762,
0.1257013977,
-0.2215339988,
0.2515658438,
0.5762923956,
-0.5119530559,
0.1728111207,
0.0864184052,
-0.3067833483,
0.2945714295,
-0.0666377991,
-0.0001252172,
-0.8602283597,
0.5135772824,
0.2019522935,
0.2165381759,
-0.6947025061,
-0.2980952561,
0.3321621716,
0.1527692825,
-0.4143460691,
0.3750763834,
-0.4586747289,
-0.4907947481,
0.2100928426,
0.2182728946,
0.1136440411,
0.3558051288,
0.2059993148,
0.7766481638,
0.2148202956,
-0.5467332006,
0.2940764427,
0.6517859101,
-0.3566725552,
0.5680980682,
-0.751191318,
0.2329635322,
-0.2492529899,
0.2148640007,
-0.7859966159,
-0.237958014,
0.0504480228,
-0.234085083,
0.4152327478,
0.3623996079,
-0.4303430617,
-0.2663108408,
-0.046784211,
0.3659602404,
0.1459583938,
-0.5777195096,
0.3495825529,
0.3556972444,
-0.4262824655,
-0.5803651214,
-0.7440567017,
0.205854401,
0.0442931578,
-0.7624675035,
0.8157913089,
0.0906900391,
-0.1983092129,
0.4402246773,
-0.3875036836,
0.0468410589,
-0.2192775905,
0.1874229461,
0.38820979,
-0.2116858363,
0.4146316648,
0.1488002688,
-0.0577835962,
0.2915325761,
-0.2559756041,
0.1993865073,
-0.154292345,
-0.082179971,
-0.4430343807,
0.1945994943,
0.1515113264,
0.0431739017,
0.5922755599,
0.1747870445,
-0.8220299482,
-0.1653905809,
-0.2587557733,
-0.331798166,
-0.4540050626,
0.9182366729,
-0.2178901285,
-0.4132443666,
0.5169680715,
0.1820460111,
0.2614887357,
0.8386489749,
0.1812821776,
-0.5537750125,
0.4822158217,
0.2729215324,
0.0986586288,
0.0496827215,
-0.1905494034,
0.1673313677,
-0.7902763486,
-0.8327627778,
-0.9106363058,
-0.3964420259,
-0.1972540915,
-0.4611754119,
0.3187003434,
-0.0989580825,
-0.5370485783,
0.7704219818,
-0.2770597339,
0.5483739376,
0.5541784763,
0.3878490627,
0.410679549,
0.1745769829,
0.0249261931,
-0.1799825281,
-0.8264533877,
-0.386818707,
1.0719220638,
0.2296565026,
0.628526032,
-0.1665305495,
0.5296830535,
0.411683619,
0.6058521271,
-0.4553517103,
0.6395639181,
-0.0605065674,
-0.6715458035,
-0.5288152695,
-0.4844231904,
-0.741800487,
-0.1957842261,
-0.2779960632,
-0.5907289386,
-0.0381131247,
0.2631671429,
-0.1622338593,
0.3105230927,
-0.4787942469,
0.6544040442,
-0.3031390011,
-0.7075383663,
0.076199539,
-0.8045579195,
0.2970579267,
-0.107688047,
0.0057135373,
0.0946104303,
-0.1708547175,
1.2284321785,
-0.2739375234,
0.4579315186,
-0.0581502914,
-0.0717216432,
0.3067917526,
-0.0431307778,
0.7202581167,
0.219461605,
-0.2789648175,
0.4807130396,
-0.0845704228,
-0.3825936019,
-0.4826538861,
0.8696658611,
-0.6487216949,
-0.3103914559,
-0.3615388572,
-0.3751145005,
-0.4336346984,
0.11021474,
0.3935469389,
-0.1458761543,
0.0873217881,
0.497859925,
0.8635053039,
0.1235421523,
0.2868864834,
0.3107127249,
0.2075778395,
-0.2513722181,
0.7348968387,
0.3411740661,
0.0456502438,
0.2652964294,
-0.4283653498,
-0.8014647961,
-0.496769011,
-0.5155745149,
0.1286900938,
-0.518886447,
-0.7305937409,
-0.7241226435,
-0.3097533584,
-0.1594269723,
-0.1321819723,
-0.2660885751,
-0.3048844635,
-0.4040282071,
-0.5199232101,
0.3891720176,
0.4726115167,
0.1264002919,
-0.0953198448,
-0.5991042256,
0.4042955935,
0.1908000112,
0.4387770891,
0.0964729637,
-0.1782307029,
-0.2217846215,
-0.0241916366,
0.0259485971,
-1.2211952209,
0.0790961012,
0.7930891514,
0.5271641612,
0.3932844102,
-0.1404716074,
0.6307243109,
-0.9755010009,
0.5800551772,
0.3122104406,
-0.6602638364,
0.7296065688,
-0.1563133299,
-0.4527747333,
0.7768722773,
0.7054615617,
-0.3857812285,
-0.0640841424,
-0.7228979468,
-1.179046154,
0.4850766361,
0.1327407211,
-0.4005822539,
-0.1507654488,
0.5399398804,
0.1899576038,
0.346514523,
-0.7243403196,
-0.5860444903,
0.0392659418,
-0.2537453473,
0.156946525,
-0.1681835502,
-0.4216231406,
-0.1361842602,
0.7697218657,
-0.0895791575,
0.3306335807,
0.1541851312,
-0.4434418976,
-0.3662710786,
-0.0831392482,
0.399869442,
0.6846475601,
-0.2580401003,
0.2497411668,
0.4023109972,
-0.5160960555,
-0.1846839786,
0.0352644585,
-0.488792032,
0.0925534591,
0.409124434,
0.5686295033,
0.3020505607,
-0.3707704544,
-0.0114425421,
0.515856266,
-0.4472304583,
0.0383584127,
0.0434955209,
0.4087551236,
0.0356305055,
0.5368025303,
-0.0061695199,
0.4148283601,
-0.4755378067,
0.9099366069,
0.2081688493,
-0.3329426348,
-0.3553496599,
1.0736593008,
0.1945613921,
-0.1329661161,
0.7754758596,
-0.0012667219,
-0.1036207378,
0.9339621067,
0.8217335939,
0.3614372015,
-0.0451645069,
0.230583474,
0.7292274237,
0.278159827,
0.1313588321,
0.2127252519,
0.114205569,
-0.3530368209,
-0.0504585579,
-0.643913269,
-0.4164236486,
0.0835865214,
-0.7929245234,
0.2272036225,
-0.3820753992,
0.0118446611,
0.4813051522,
0.1920669675,
-0.8665103316,
-0.0319449119,
0.0272168163,
1.2085672617,
-0.908864677,
0.8347403407,
0.4623107314,
-0.5859102011,
-0.3712764084,
-0.498898387,
0.0079467846,
-0.8309024572,
0.9205871224,
-0.1913363785,
0.1607524604,
0.1974283159,
-0.6046619415,
-1.0031847954,
1.2683426142,
0.2989681065,
-0.7858828902,
-0.1818200648,
0.2903651595,
0.7141014338,
-0.2911579013,
0.4504734576,
0.6877240539,
0.7484871149,
0.16499421,
-0.5341126323,
0.2016934007,
-0.4386030734,
-0.2558413446,
0.2728651166,
-0.4865528643,
0.3459577858,
-0.4550551176,
-0.184234038,
-0.1536055207,
1.1047328711,
0.5351612568,
0.8330132961,
0.2214821875,
0.5391696692,
0.9963084459,
-0.3944319487,
0.3834605217,
-0.3129248619,
0.2875367105,
1.308742404,
-0.8735447526,
0.9667932391,
0.6904909611,
-0.4866018891,
0.3721172512,
0.6284429431,
-0.5235341191,
0.5658602118,
0.5271385312,
-0.2034793943,
0.2474533767,
-0.2543181777,
-0.6442165375,
-0.0764259622,
0.7613983154,
-0.3051792383,
-0.5038883686,
-0.4788500667,
-0.0340703465,
0.0573311821,
-0.377194196,
0.7139828205,
0.0917732716,
-0.303787291,
0.0598453283,
-0.400203377,
0.2504383326,
-0.5602266788,
-0.2975702286,
-0.2920359373,
-0.4281915128,
-0.7064300776,
-0.7871829867,
0.2875756323,
0.0580723472,
-0.1818525046,
0.0164599326,
0.5782598853,
-0.7109204531,
-0.1713010818,
0.139479354,
0.3786897063,
0.0945938379,
0.3496697545,
-0.5699897408,
-0.4519255459,
-0.0432002656,
-0.3643052876,
0.4385344386,
0.2607874274,
-0.1242703274,
0.5818293095,
0.784280777,
-0.0281568877,
-0.0789303333,
-0.2379889041,
0.9146441817,
-0.7052430511,
-0.1652092487,
-0.5567530394,
0.4910584092,
-0.3772031367,
-0.3410396576,
0.512306273,
1.0522143841,
0.829189837,
-0.2772333026,
0.7078624368,
-0.3695795238,
0.2972303331,
-0.491578877,
0.9354142547,
-0.4160760641,
0.2582411468,
0.0305932742,
-1.1874142885,
-0.5587610602,
0.667812705,
0.0951258242,
-0.0961702168,
0.9728907347,
0.863806963,
0.1487384588,
-0.0149241425,
0.1029146984,
0.415848434,
-0.0250379518,
0.5369080901,
0.3779272139,
-0.5182025433,
0.5966297984,
-0.1632650048,
0.0489675738,
-0.2449245453,
-0.9071064591,
-0.5607020855,
-0.7358208299,
-0.4461660683,
-0.6076716185,
0.4689890742,
0.8418337703,
0.3288011551,
-1.0850576162,
0.077129595,
-0.0917389095,
0.0313451178,
0.0392281488,
-0.1184401661,
0.8830567598,
-0.2673154175,
-0.5159378648,
0.3164436221,
0.3806230724,
-0.3050029576,
0.1074012816,
0.0424287319,
-0.3716779053,
-0.1728780717,
0.3530726135,
0.5211966038,
-0.4054107666,
-0.2918068469,
0.2233779579,
-0.3790026307,
0.0500019751,
0.397295177,
-0.461306572,
-0.0081418473,
0.508041501,
0.6446701288,
0.5778238177,
-0.22984384,
0.0307797138,
-0.8216574192,
-0.1846997142,
0.589469254,
0.5166561604,
-0.0310177635,
-0.4570194185,
0.8014541268,
0.1562563628,
-0.6112076044,
-0.8455424905,
0.1638108641,
-1.0933517218,
0.1275977641,
0.9549527764,
-0.0714820102,
-0.4834162295,
-0.0264622457,
0.0135661541,
0.3790606558,
-0.3900700808,
1.084107995,
0.4694003463,
-0.2871130705,
0.0704149753,
-0.6493424773,
0.973111093,
0.3159864545,
-1.207780242,
0.0668879673,
0.4576000273,
0.1082615182,
0.3799392283,
0.3842208087,
-0.1243021786,
0.2986480594,
0.322311908,
0.3154312074,
-0.1317448765,
-0.7702056766,
0.2659020722,
0.1824877858,
-0.1480631828,
0.1894605756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00350v1 | POUF: Prompt-oriented unsupervised fine-tuning for large pre-trained models | 2023-04-29T22:05:22 | 2023-04-29T22:05:22 | Korawat Tanwisuth, Shujian Zhang, Huangjie Zheng, Pengcheng He, Mingyuan Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Through prompting, large-scale pre-trained models have become more expressive
and powerful, gaining significant attention in recent years. Though these big
models have zero-shot capabilities, in general, labeled data are still required
to adapt them to downstream tasks. To overcome this critical limitation, we
propose an unsupervised fine-tuning framework to directly fine-tune the model
or prompt on the unlabeled target data. We demonstrate how to apply our method
to both language-augmented vision and masked-language models by aligning the
discrete distributions extracted from the prompts and target data. To verify
our approach's applicability, we conduct extensive experiments on image
classification, sentiment analysis, and natural language inference tasks.
Across 13 image-related tasks and 15 language-related ones, the proposed
approach achieves consistent improvements over the baselines. | [
-0.6095576882,
-0.820432961,
0.6133485436,
0.1331599355,
-0.4131615162,
-0.227695927,
-0.4588018358,
-0.169511348,
-0.2031746507,
0.6653572321,
-0.7370147109,
-0.6073114276,
-0.4642629921,
-0.0583166257,
-0.0634665191,
1.0921901464,
0.0622184053,
-0.1454690993,
-0.2828101218,
0.0159632713,
-0.6415699124,
-0.2118046433,
-0.7576296926,
0.0846138969,
0.6252577901,
0.7212883234,
0.730109632,
0.4874142408,
0.389593482,
0.3028369844,
0.082908228,
0.4963517189,
-0.447108537,
0.0486641489,
-0.6484370828,
-0.1544866115,
-0.3457421958,
-0.0496882498,
0.5337162018,
0.9741247296,
0.1364683509,
0.2270249873,
0.2466235757,
0.4594578445,
-1.0233063698,
0.1862732917,
-0.4797360897,
-0.2693642378,
-0.0570560805,
-0.1719270945,
-0.3870641291,
0.0890782923,
0.0756072477,
-0.9965642691,
0.2989459932,
-0.0306020081,
0.8380818963,
0.5608777404,
-0.1963925511,
0.184045583,
-0.6188536286,
0.9149569869,
-0.5935182571,
0.106422022,
0.4417153299,
0.3625887632,
-0.3025989234,
-0.7535335422,
-0.4703913033,
0.0218329038,
-0.1314848214,
-0.0814152434,
-0.2324814051,
0.2407379597,
0.4651504159,
0.23331815,
-0.2245201021,
0.4281080067,
0.113144435,
-0.1374440193,
0.5948722959,
0.1305453181,
0.0986030549,
0.2879117131,
-0.0125369607,
-0.1994090825,
-0.4139643908,
0.2334157079,
0.247255072,
0.670773685,
-0.1081172004,
0.4921172857,
-0.7413371801,
1.2709841728,
0.386911869,
0.0122780753,
0.1556937695,
-0.0913926288,
-0.510436058,
-0.0052580554,
0.6730958819,
0.5872769356,
0.523835063,
-0.0004628943,
-0.3003802001,
0.2325625569,
0.1826424897,
-0.8760489225,
-0.4441919327,
-0.0311937481,
-0.1127208322,
-0.3590625525,
0.2037241608,
-0.8737831712,
-0.7365230918,
-0.7075022459,
0.659122169,
-0.0583937354,
-0.1922802478,
0.5497106314,
0.0794851929,
0.0903359056,
0.572241962,
-0.8394539952,
-0.1475794315,
0.5078239441,
0.5754896998,
0.1638144851,
-0.2547224462,
-1.0833009481,
-0.0277825892,
-0.6275610328,
1.0601654053,
-1.0057339668,
-0.1031729877,
0.2262971252,
0.4212337732,
0.0838015527,
-0.4063706398,
0.4731115699,
-0.1442022324,
0.0967925265,
-0.3705838919,
-0.3566167653,
0.0261545852,
0.2126602829,
-0.3393369019,
0.8338586688,
0.2352276146,
-0.7037318945,
0.4868018627,
-0.735639751,
-0.5092424154,
-0.0433292575,
0.0005463223,
-0.4835387766,
0.4078426063,
0.8044044375,
0.7477257252,
-0.4061565995,
0.4080843627,
-0.4074195623,
-0.3512892723,
0.00474715,
-0.1819802374,
0.4760809243,
0.1014920771,
-0.3027398288,
0.5832006335,
-0.9276894927,
-0.1988523453,
0.0637615472,
0.1374111325,
-0.4130177498,
-0.0984656364,
-0.1436645538,
-0.0268593375,
0.1699356735,
-0.7141060233,
0.6433643699,
-0.3003187776,
0.5047584772,
0.6503415704,
0.1800346524,
0.7656683326,
0.0367276594,
0.2927443385,
0.161465615,
0.4628661871,
-0.4696896374,
-0.333645314,
-0.8286882043,
-0.5736036301,
0.371668756,
0.3854370117,
-0.947588563,
0.443010211,
0.073526755,
-0.4521092772,
-0.5607874393,
0.0985897928,
0.1785504073,
0.9284305573,
0.4677391946,
-0.1603908539,
-0.3360508084,
-0.9685363173,
-0.1762185395,
0.2670862377,
-0.4401127398,
0.127629593,
0.0146140251,
-0.4007566869,
0.8316769004,
-0.6681154966,
-0.5248017907,
0.115055874,
0.4752224088,
0.2029123604,
0.6668343544,
0.5387210846,
-0.6767864823,
-0.3817819059,
0.0001915539,
-0.4704988599,
-0.3957539797,
-0.176458165,
-0.3383262455,
-0.1252569854,
0.8778098226,
-0.4299699068,
0.5365605354,
0.207372129,
-0.436406821,
0.3643665314,
-0.3826148212,
0.3162408769,
-0.7449633479,
-0.1513096839,
0.0234982539,
-0.1668541431,
-0.5906847119,
-0.2956457138,
0.0985210389,
-0.2830485702,
-0.4676275551,
0.665751636,
-0.4184990823,
-0.043376755,
-0.3824413419,
-0.2065943182,
0.1319910586,
0.5123958588,
0.2616078556,
0.4886647761,
1.2981905937,
-0.8477634788,
0.3238418698,
0.2115682065,
-0.6619725227,
0.8314359188,
-0.6486694813,
0.1688616723,
-0.325986445,
-0.0753544271,
-1.1616671085,
-0.4562830031,
0.2034907788,
-0.1530417055,
0.4696036279,
-0.1521296501,
-0.6779310703,
-0.1441171318,
-0.0030450567,
0.3679930568,
0.4930993915,
-0.740165174,
0.6200411916,
0.1124474257,
-0.0460535996,
-0.2863736451,
-0.3335347176,
-0.2474001199,
-0.1381251067,
-0.2645360827,
0.1942965239,
0.0439350232,
0.0022925013,
-0.1263494492,
0.0807920247,
0.0291450564,
0.0754785538,
0.4027281404,
0.215147391,
-0.177820012,
0.2466074675,
0.1275841147,
-0.1660951674,
-0.4027140737,
-0.409207195,
0.3570194244,
-0.0541207008,
-0.2906743586,
-0.444313556,
0.1869664043,
0.5791797638,
-0.7526037097,
0.6460880637,
0.754091382,
-0.3595858514,
-0.0584052987,
-0.4201861322,
-0.2541323304,
-0.5184771419,
0.2080291957,
-0.3039405346,
-0.9501800537,
0.3001693189,
-0.4326572716,
0.0768396556,
0.277798146,
0.3622664511,
-0.2978001535,
1.4129667282,
0.9770725965,
0.0549455769,
0.7674723268,
-0.0439656079,
0.163722977,
-0.5662722588,
-0.1432880461,
-0.5132262111,
-0.4741651416,
-0.3649688065,
-0.2437680066,
0.1912192702,
0.4532783926,
-0.6625611186,
0.0211910531,
-0.7269284725,
0.6139069796,
0.5533719063,
0.195098564,
0.0587548204,
0.0673646927,
0.0938694254,
0.0488282144,
-0.6337631941,
-0.2064598948,
0.7084750533,
0.0759408921,
0.8151811361,
-0.3829828799,
0.1514782012,
0.117173411,
0.1575861722,
-0.7096375823,
0.4840055108,
-0.4338777363,
-0.3081918657,
-0.4420615435,
-0.1093195751,
-1.0396853685,
-0.1622015536,
-0.4660458863,
-0.8013235927,
0.5663763881,
0.4517768621,
-0.5393530726,
0.2017521411,
-0.8831130862,
1.3334243298,
-0.2446759492,
-0.254635185,
0.1864317656,
-0.5436413884,
0.094942525,
-0.1263954341,
0.0757143125,
-0.2349741608,
0.004129569,
0.5288293362,
-0.4468798935,
1.0691263676,
-0.5558953881,
-0.0478979275,
0.2379810363,
-0.0647500753,
0.5356066823,
0.0167677216,
0.2120929509,
0.0833012015,
-0.0596039183,
-0.6785949469,
-0.8707539439,
0.5804660916,
-0.6334876418,
-0.53812778,
-0.0262974259,
-0.6952955723,
-0.6897418499,
0.245737657,
0.5128180385,
0.6666865945,
0.1289221346,
0.0649985597,
0.6971946359,
-0.5044901967,
0.292863965,
0.7608548999,
-0.2578012049,
-0.0963365957,
0.9222785234,
-0.2125653327,
0.1468394399,
0.526461482,
0.0852888227,
-0.2649857998,
-0.5468813777,
-0.4419958889,
0.2050895542,
-0.4939213097,
-0.3609597683,
-0.3934184909,
0.3268018961,
-0.5534940958,
-0.4495999813,
-0.5081622601,
-0.0269296914,
-0.6299091578,
0.0334441587,
0.693759799,
0.4564522803,
-0.0128370048,
0.6999126077,
-0.5368696451,
0.4192380905,
0.5099560618,
0.5310075879,
-0.4026111066,
-0.7784549594,
-0.080081664,
0.1377243847,
0.0770089179,
-0.550434947,
0.2048002779,
0.3610414863,
0.381965518,
0.6661875844,
0.4793623388,
0.9700117111,
-0.4411911964,
0.6244835854,
0.2514320612,
-0.9227847457,
0.9792979956,
-0.4554450512,
0.6137781739,
0.6411361098,
0.2978623509,
-0.1678354144,
-0.2351120114,
-0.4975008667,
-0.5870956779,
0.6525890231,
-0.3585498333,
0.0993342251,
0.0841855481,
0.3264852762,
0.020818077,
0.2992454171,
0.0059126751,
0.0688802823,
-0.4914971292,
-0.2890696824,
-0.5652162433,
-0.2128795236,
0.0600676872,
-0.5381595492,
0.4611643255,
-0.4335845411,
-0.0176452175,
0.2175619751,
-0.1075394079,
-0.1627437472,
0.2401014268,
0.4659609497,
0.5547508001,
-0.1173523217,
0.1360405833,
-0.1227298379,
-0.2231436223,
0.1298553944,
0.2420797795,
-0.2716116607,
-0.2003220022,
0.1914802939,
1.3087607622,
0.3953668773,
-0.7217990756,
0.4546868801,
-0.0561496541,
-0.2480139136,
0.204404369,
0.0743214935,
-0.2968375981,
0.350913316,
0.1592798382,
0.1331830174,
-0.0440718941,
-0.5493226051,
0.170305118,
0.4534076154,
-0.5972830653,
-0.2354627848,
0.5397019982,
0.1036453471,
-0.1148767024,
0.5867253542,
-0.2325901836,
-0.2534341812,
0.349838376,
0.26425457,
0.6246399283,
-0.3481291234,
0.4567258656,
0.3932870328,
0.2644066215,
-0.2008457482,
0.0329467617,
0.00413793,
-0.7417953014,
-0.6186043024,
-0.762606144,
-0.0986197665,
0.4883740544,
-0.7861039042,
0.5287664533,
-0.5169040561,
-0.0471892171,
0.3664325476,
-0.2205714881,
-0.8452151418,
0.4772931933,
0.0977912843,
0.8407388926,
-1.0562883615,
0.8320106864,
1.1267802715,
-0.1972451657,
-0.9447828531,
-0.2978475392,
-0.3141162992,
-0.609201014,
0.3251465857,
0.1303340942,
0.1891507804,
0.3766682744,
-0.9320207238,
-0.5481841564,
0.6298472881,
0.8324820399,
-0.9339370131,
0.2895663977,
-0.0315454975,
0.5029020905,
-0.4912465215,
-0.0854671746,
0.6561737657,
0.6015085578,
0.275842905,
-0.9091914892,
-0.1454841197,
-0.0427669026,
-0.1696210057,
0.3618793488,
-0.1585180908,
0.82311064,
-0.3260554671,
-0.1403532624,
-0.0156211359,
0.5383585691,
-0.0724784285,
0.2887916863,
0.7614929676,
0.5055598021,
0.8115982413,
-0.1563154459,
1.0250326395,
0.1058116257,
0.1486682445,
1.2625668049,
-0.1902260631,
0.5699766278,
0.2479712665,
0.1801955253,
0.2208930701,
0.9400008321,
-0.1315022707,
0.8763064742,
-0.173053503,
-0.059646707,
-0.788146019,
-0.4834549725,
-0.1753773242,
0.4151087105,
0.3494143188,
-0.206775561,
-0.417196095,
0.5747185946,
-0.2983360887,
0.1006844491,
-0.9721210003,
0.8851152062,
-0.1822861582,
-0.7568000555,
0.795984447,
-0.1480849087,
0.5741692781,
-0.4598194659,
-0.0146140857,
-0.193193242,
0.2660218179,
-0.1996701062,
-0.7577595115,
0.0000601741,
0.0690976456,
-0.2080942988,
-0.1063007861,
0.9532325864,
-0.6126407981,
-0.6118271947,
-0.0122192241,
0.1669238806,
0.1316189617,
-0.7329199314,
-0.5653304458,
0.042602513,
0.1008039862,
-0.0682622269,
0.4564962387,
0.8276580572,
-0.340371877,
0.3101091385,
0.6547541022,
-0.07894364,
-0.198902756,
0.3432278037,
0.9719398618,
-0.4433781207,
-0.5009528995,
-0.6926516891,
0.7235575318,
0.0195160583,
-0.2531865835,
0.5165566206,
0.1530094147,
0.8016534448,
-0.4110441208,
0.6156359911,
0.2205648422,
0.5002237558,
-0.4883419573,
0.3848766387,
-0.6601518393,
-0.0797678828,
-0.4337588251,
-1.0243468285,
-0.4872147143,
0.7007474899,
-0.5950977802,
-0.318113029,
0.3050439954,
0.9714553356,
-0.2652293444,
-0.1770075262,
0.5325543284,
0.1420900971,
0.0689118728,
0.38964203,
0.8304605484,
-0.0343663692,
0.295561552,
-0.3244871497,
-0.5305769444,
-0.1010165811,
-1.1316314936,
-1.092881918,
-0.6427552104,
-0.7088371515,
0.1406125724,
-0.1407808661,
0.424513936,
0.8128442168,
-0.9162442684,
0.5104423761,
-0.2592719197,
-0.1860601753,
-0.2612431645,
-0.137854144,
0.2905880511,
-0.4801405668,
-0.7196648717,
0.2060175091,
0.4400612712,
0.1916307062,
0.0543446876,
0.0831364244,
0.0703246593,
0.0058813998,
0.6985786557,
0.3760481477,
-0.4548883438,
-0.3964332938,
-0.0606017187,
0.2002319247,
-0.1460213214,
0.989716351,
-0.8831420541,
0.653706789,
0.2521375418,
0.677809298,
0.376912415,
0.2621576488,
0.5003138185,
-1.0512239933,
0.6209486127,
0.080036968,
0.3611414731,
0.5488298535,
-0.3118218184,
0.2290529907,
0.0655415505,
-0.5255236626,
-0.8957374692,
0.2990989387,
-1.004521966,
-0.5952647924,
1.0335265398,
-0.0945712999,
-0.1794200987,
-0.1269844621,
-0.6243487,
0.2722233236,
-0.2561062872,
0.5090376139,
0.4785086811,
0.0662953779,
-0.4754642248,
-0.3208782077,
0.6239624619,
0.4150401652,
-0.8252023458,
0.2430346012,
0.7205509543,
0.0928442255,
0.0915820822,
0.5294951797,
0.1884545386,
0.2046017498,
-0.3974744678,
0.0373819768,
-0.3449242115,
-0.5886825919,
-0.367695272,
-0.0498120897,
0.0322435871,
-0.5482365489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00296v1 | A Cognitive Account of the Puzzle of Ideography | 2023-04-29T16:13:13 | 2023-04-29T16:13:13 | Xerxes D. Arsiwalla | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.CL | In this commentary article to 'The Puzzle of Ideography' by Morin, we put
forth a new cognitive account of the puzzle of ideography, that complements the
standardization account of Morin. Efficient standardization of spoken language
is phenomenologically attributed to a modality effect coupled with chunking of
cognitive representations, further aided by multi-sensory integration and the
serialized nature of attention. These cognitive mechanisms are crucial for
explaining why languages dominate graphic codes for general-purpose human
communication. | [
-0.5475147963,
-0.6355366707,
0.6068301797,
0.300219804,
-0.6088733673,
-0.0874199495,
-0.4251873791,
-0.762387991,
0.6005392075,
0.4472298324,
-0.119086124,
-0.2559040189,
-0.6278273463,
-0.0356094129,
-0.4325006604,
0.5823790431,
0.15685305,
0.0278533287,
-0.2196348011,
-0.3290407956,
-0.4453168511,
-0.5843601823,
-0.878968358,
-0.3747427464,
0.6188077927,
0.0372430235,
0.8884127736,
1.0161155462,
0.8266372085,
0.3097436428,
0.0283661261,
-0.1438144296,
-0.3248153925,
-0.0181921273,
-0.338285923,
-0.6663170457,
-0.4017353952,
0.2606080472,
0.7515681386,
0.9636980295,
-0.1144684479,
0.068149209,
0.2955766618,
0.6223124266,
-0.2894747555,
0.4915322363,
-0.5233374834,
-0.3534990549,
-0.4536227286,
-0.4566597044,
-0.4053891003,
-0.0634270087,
0.0630870014,
-0.5796992183,
0.114767313,
-0.1176393256,
0.7875226736,
0.3472780883,
-0.661981523,
-0.4147748649,
-0.9415545464,
0.7069647908,
-0.3743365407,
0.0621019304,
0.4708601236,
0.0434218347,
0.4080030322,
-0.491508007,
-0.3787175417,
-0.0759595856,
-0.0259729642,
0.44290483,
0.0714946687,
0.1635634899,
0.244235307,
0.4813369811,
-0.0624572001,
0.0162546765,
-0.7297695875,
-0.1041750312,
0.9138504863,
0.1971007437,
0.4313198924,
-0.2996760309,
-0.1648509204,
0.1165409759,
-0.1707104445,
-0.188704282,
0.2860667706,
-0.0359935798,
-0.1509510577,
0.4303427637,
-0.2694356143,
0.7901728153,
-0.0714684129,
-0.1465980113,
0.198554948,
-0.3764551878,
0.1515415907,
0.2572715282,
0.7879738808,
0.8859845996,
0.4315456152,
-0.0860723332,
0.0222566426,
0.274256289,
0.3760824203,
-0.3391611576,
-0.4634062648,
0.0174195655,
-0.385335952,
-0.170953095,
0.0466636643,
-0.4751362801,
-0.2744738758,
-0.3296729028,
0.0609465167,
-0.5101081729,
-0.3384287655,
0.2275088429,
-0.2045690268,
-0.0091403453,
0.5906162858,
-0.9490368366,
0.2003310174,
0.7413389087,
0.9361763597,
-0.0274968017,
-0.107139945,
0.1032605618,
0.3684957623,
-0.6833400726,
0.967753768,
-0.5729676485,
-0.3232227564,
-0.1647218615,
-0.2190421522,
-0.0078974208,
-0.5578287244,
0.2715869248,
-0.380559206,
0.0199568961,
-0.2917727828,
-0.3674283922,
-0.5231520534,
0.1512283385,
-0.9315240979,
0.9643483758,
0.169712469,
-0.5448281169,
0.3496286571,
-0.4741233289,
-0.258400172,
0.4072389603,
-0.6259226799,
0.2824237347,
0.3350766003,
-0.2584139407,
0.0046493206,
-0.3300855458,
0.1317645013,
-0.1703265756,
-0.3387970924,
0.7744928598,
-0.2426133007,
0.9778341651,
0.3677638471,
-0.3134145439,
-0.1803974509,
-0.8211034536,
0.061286144,
0.0713750944,
-0.5960047841,
-0.6863167286,
-0.0220208894,
-0.0817121863,
0.1449033022,
0.2792366445,
-0.4867056906,
0.0156428907,
-0.0628144369,
0.210394457,
0.5209517479,
0.1682854444,
0.4468770623,
-0.3928737044,
0.3453275263,
0.0608762205,
0.3422164917,
-0.4127161205,
-0.6741831303,
-0.6292048097,
-0.3962989748,
0.2875155509,
0.5358170271,
-0.2807118595,
0.1215864345,
-0.2938207984,
-0.1099310964,
-0.7126559615,
0.0393177792,
0.3449754715,
0.1334082037,
-0.0866581723,
-1.0278686285,
-0.3974824846,
-1.0574678183,
-0.2912854254,
-0.486715734,
-0.1319516152,
0.2049398273,
0.1541085839,
-0.0563252792,
0.7860581279,
-0.2367751151,
-0.2529102564,
0.0894486234,
0.3452275991,
0.1457682848,
0.562148869,
0.6133892536,
-0.5867914557,
-0.5901960731,
0.1634134054,
-0.8563630581,
0.0326609425,
-0.4695515335,
0.039109949,
-0.0529048629,
0.7900246382,
-0.3406690061,
0.4083686769,
0.2085133046,
-0.0960388407,
0.4721893966,
-0.2506261766,
0.2671280801,
-0.8837537766,
-0.0941134617,
-0.20130454,
-0.0705288053,
-0.4047180414,
0.0448457822,
0.1616098583,
0.0471093394,
-0.1983642131,
0.2495820522,
-0.6834189296,
0.1754657775,
-0.2118143588,
0.5987651348,
0.094394885,
0.3802704811,
-0.1368322819,
0.2610321641,
0.5853390098,
-0.4790590405,
0.5813395977,
0.0147123886,
-0.6949418187,
0.9905330539,
-0.5123026371,
0.2052050829,
-0.6822613478,
-0.1194168329,
-1.1401075125,
-0.1951806545,
0.3097593486,
-0.3209808171,
0.395001471,
-0.231313929,
-0.5596437454,
-0.1630256176,
-0.2885304689,
0.6797465086,
0.4034631848,
-0.1656998843,
0.3651988804,
0.4864547551,
-0.0198683906,
-0.2138948739,
-0.8306691647,
0.3488809466,
-0.3148753345,
-0.4415441751,
-0.0395950451,
-0.117760174,
-0.9744435549,
0.1449648887,
0.0404130109,
0.0980477259,
0.186240688,
0.0356445834,
0.1681325436,
-0.2932290137,
0.1644274741,
-0.4535207748,
-0.0841259435,
0.3524596691,
-0.3188681901,
0.3203547001,
0.1148023382,
-0.2899481654,
-0.5400335789,
0.8004099131,
0.5519677997,
-0.0987181216,
0.6388605237,
0.2556987703,
0.0378291681,
0.3664906621,
-0.5502519011,
-0.0597327761,
-0.4291400313,
0.524463594,
-0.505150795,
-0.3711458147,
0.6036058068,
-0.1801624447,
-0.2860200703,
0.380844146,
0.2133849561,
-0.4350978136,
1.1258866787,
0.6325863004,
0.1127487794,
0.71959728,
-0.2774659693,
0.074351415,
-1.2830244303,
-0.3990443051,
-0.2927924097,
-0.5810195804,
-0.5195549726,
-0.2725301683,
0.4276646972,
0.2191012055,
-0.0166448448,
-0.0498841293,
-0.4839121997,
0.6915374398,
0.5255326033,
0.1489977092,
0.4742451608,
0.0180682074,
-0.0731565282,
-0.1128424704,
-0.5740935802,
-0.566170454,
1.1270620823,
0.0429359525,
0.9778549075,
0.2317775935,
0.6619622111,
0.1067934856,
0.3382845819,
-0.9529356956,
0.4904159307,
-0.0997209698,
-0.8358464837,
-0.0754959062,
0.0398102999,
-1.0658179522,
0.3513423204,
0.0270990431,
-1.1987131834,
0.470045507,
0.1870320737,
-0.1695826501,
0.1534177065,
-0.7376508713,
0.8712887168,
-0.1767665595,
-0.1571184397,
-0.5743653774,
-0.7144716382,
0.5302963853,
0.1322785765,
0.4548884034,
-0.2025977671,
-0.2248551995,
0.9234790206,
0.0080732843,
0.9840089083,
0.2880792618,
-0.1676177233,
0.4370170534,
0.0781025589,
0.0296471734,
0.1224842072,
0.0103495903,
0.0448260307,
0.0606216006,
-0.6302178502,
-0.7009022832,
0.3328330815,
-0.7926245332,
-0.9059468508,
-0.4585568607,
-0.6205459237,
0.1232343838,
0.1367448568,
0.3125760257,
0.783865869,
-0.5201258659,
0.2132159173,
0.6764688492,
0.4142081141,
0.393763572,
0.1859805584,
-0.4551264644,
-0.1985711753,
0.5275745392,
0.425922662,
0.6331392527,
0.3649277687,
-0.0562275052,
0.0549316779,
-0.5608816147,
-0.2538532913,
0.5296929479,
-1.2667183876,
0.1834789664,
-0.6080020666,
-0.0568561815,
-0.0426254347,
0.0395123102,
-0.2188497782,
-0.5606499314,
-0.0651402324,
0.0292958282,
0.3085112572,
0.9799129367,
-0.0934609696,
0.5396107435,
-0.5294700265,
0.1141602024,
0.383778125,
0.2662178278,
0.1343438625,
-0.3429143429,
-0.8845931888,
0.0535227507,
-0.1319946647,
-0.9875454307,
-0.2990109026,
0.2040368021,
0.5803103447,
0.8847492933,
-0.1765124947,
0.5690779686,
-0.1432183534,
0.6944097281,
0.2063571066,
-0.6831005812,
0.4410867691,
-0.449682951,
0.7664007545,
0.3798013926,
0.3043637276,
-1.1740385294,
-0.6949146986,
-0.8530704379,
-0.7303236723,
0.6475886703,
-0.2932302952,
0.3881318867,
-0.3479352295,
0.3378564417,
0.0400300473,
0.0051610335,
-0.4066567123,
-0.1833536327,
-0.3049607277,
-0.0943306983,
-0.3280265033,
-0.4736287296,
-0.56286484,
-0.2586894333,
0.0991316065,
-0.1659497321,
0.2656021714,
0.4072239399,
-0.4298527837,
0.0397355743,
0.1047482416,
0.5175421834,
0.8348099589,
0.0135338483,
0.660395503,
-0.3048687875,
-0.6909869909,
-0.2100431919,
-0.4090310633,
-0.4565986395,
0.1498555839,
0.5695703626,
0.9913222194,
0.2118283808,
-0.3319622576,
0.1592007428,
0.1680390388,
-0.0681362972,
-0.3474617898,
0.102714166,
0.2570099831,
0.2909963727,
0.4341157079,
0.4246124625,
0.0211000983,
-1.0078743696,
0.0129620442,
0.4294407666,
-0.4420904517,
-0.6457497478,
0.7208800912,
0.0953489766,
-0.2245569825,
0.6758643389,
-0.0918629989,
-0.3416959643,
0.5934325457,
0.6178829074,
0.87767452,
-0.2952144146,
0.3207275271,
0.4769898057,
0.6505573392,
0.0000042472,
0.488455981,
-0.227406919,
-0.8482972383,
-0.2824549079,
-0.0216131639,
-0.219472602,
-0.2687051296,
-0.8249279857,
-0.1214421466,
-0.5051894784,
-0.352460146,
0.025052391,
-0.3125112057,
-0.6268191934,
0.1323202401,
0.4735536873,
0.6151254177,
-0.4768533707,
0.9333990216,
0.5878894329,
-0.4513284564,
-0.6537761688,
0.0732135624,
0.2446355522,
-0.663364768,
0.6463667154,
-0.1460238993,
-0.1875617057,
0.0654577538,
-0.4327431023,
-1.1053593159,
0.7463462353,
0.3930229843,
-0.1120094731,
0.3429578543,
0.0687094331,
0.4511372447,
-0.6252669692,
0.2564191222,
0.5255611539,
0.6422370076,
-0.2498285621,
-0.8622490764,
0.0990043804,
-0.4526013434,
0.3848226666,
0.0939647704,
-0.8471016884,
0.8806591034,
-0.1109562814,
-0.5829277635,
-0.2050757557,
0.7368599772,
-0.5360104442,
-0.0421855077,
0.2596957982,
0.2775577903,
0.8317709565,
0.0413941033,
1.1099506617,
-0.2310891002,
0.104090713,
0.9007313848,
-0.0076156803,
0.4726545513,
0.7341390848,
-0.3558782041,
0.7207393646,
0.54732728,
0.1987281293,
0.4613657594,
0.0001007245,
-0.505177021,
0.096280627,
-0.2730957866,
-0.1028776616,
0.6438360214,
0.5091812015,
-0.0557968765,
0.0517052673,
-0.0591206513,
0.1615484059,
0.2656412721,
-0.4532266259,
0.9862148166,
0.0181907434,
-0.6706518531,
0.7223029733,
-0.3103982508,
0.4627124369,
-0.59647578,
0.3222047687,
-0.2060381621,
0.172197327,
-0.1987854987,
-0.651486814,
0.4541494846,
-0.431042403,
-0.126247704,
-0.2535993159,
0.2809084654,
-0.6424896717,
-0.1195709184,
0.1277205348,
0.3067228496,
0.4236759543,
-0.0918241516,
-0.2951652706,
0.2916066647,
-0.0932299793,
-0.0196731836,
0.0571682751,
0.741874218,
-0.406827718,
0.2933156192,
0.2055416405,
-0.0407211185,
0.4632070065,
0.0294626541,
0.3930650353,
-0.8600868583,
-0.5656691194,
-0.8651044965,
0.4279720783,
-0.3827911019,
-0.2544283867,
0.7625691891,
0.7188074589,
0.9368755817,
-0.2736583948,
0.7662479281,
-0.081270434,
-0.1540129632,
-0.5384352803,
0.7107623816,
-0.3445965946,
0.0544857755,
-0.2105073184,
-0.8432002068,
-0.4179712832,
0.5878742337,
-0.3166190684,
-0.1685337275,
1.3826385736,
0.5258043408,
-0.1354861408,
0.0676183626,
0.2226992548,
0.27344504,
-0.1183206812,
0.1897435337,
0.8833756447,
-0.2053881586,
0.5260452628,
-0.4290768802,
-0.5561587811,
-0.4114678204,
-0.5275269151,
-0.527857542,
-1.1353148222,
-0.5932175517,
-0.2034870684,
-0.4029096365,
0.5336531401,
0.4737412333,
-0.3185392618,
-0.6507166028,
0.4553077519,
0.0687723979,
-0.6431660652,
-0.2092066705,
0.2443281561,
-0.2929829955,
-0.922023952,
0.074107334,
0.6928570271,
0.0549618788,
-0.3120415509,
0.1742102057,
-0.2709057927,
0.3042665124,
0.541264832,
0.2047641724,
-0.8144807816,
-0.3353568017,
-0.2073046118,
-0.4111209214,
0.5544658303,
1.2740908861,
-0.4838652015,
0.687384367,
0.394574672,
0.101504162,
0.6519385576,
-0.2703646123,
0.4386404157,
-0.4594281614,
0.6524617672,
0.0720043331,
0.3393829465,
0.4436639845,
-0.3124411106,
0.4847668707,
0.3933318257,
-0.1124839932,
-0.5437319875,
0.7191241384,
-1.2874147892,
-0.2349264771,
0.5716306567,
0.0444963016,
-0.6880599856,
-0.3270642459,
-0.4454906881,
0.3194943666,
-0.0528413206,
1.0732207298,
1.0849665403,
-0.204208076,
-0.3981648088,
-0.5879577398,
0.3352142572,
0.2832804918,
-0.3872126639,
-0.1028662622,
0.3488105834,
0.0429450423,
0.4650190771,
1.0317920446,
-0.3892920911,
0.2369124144,
0.4059222043,
-0.0392439626,
0.2908373773,
-0.0313089974,
-0.1766487658,
-0.1399280876,
0.2836359739,
-0.3380909562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00262v1 | Hierarchical Dialogue Understanding with Special Tokens and Turn-level Attention | 2023-04-29T13:53:48 | 2023-04-29T13:53:48 | Xiao Liu, Jian Zhang, Heng Zhang, Fuzhao Xue, Yang You | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Compared with standard text, understanding dialogue is more challenging for
machines as the dynamic and unexpected semantic changes in each turn. To model
such inconsistent semantics, we propose a simple but effective Hierarchical
Dialogue Understanding model, HiDialog. Specifically, we first insert multiple
special tokens into a dialogue and propose the turn-level attention to learn
turn embeddings hierarchically. Then, a heterogeneous graph module is leveraged
to polish the learned embeddings. We evaluate our model on various dialogue
understanding tasks including dialogue relation extraction, dialogue emotion
recognition, and dialogue act classification. Results show that our simple
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on all three tasks above. All
our source code is publicly available at https://github.com/ShawX825/HiDialog. | [
-0.1035326123,
-0.9913321733,
0.6965374947,
0.2094353884,
-0.1484397948,
0.4192589223,
0.165650174,
-0.3295137286,
0.1253519952,
0.5929735899,
-0.960483253,
-0.8317372203,
-0.6863048673,
-0.0930756107,
-0.1720866859,
1.2170772552,
0.1983558238,
-0.0839759856,
0.0183488503,
-0.4974507987,
-0.2290729135,
-0.2530130744,
-0.6022449732,
-0.4377487004,
0.5208513737,
0.3346808851,
0.8230031133,
0.6304622293,
0.2609348297,
0.3811214864,
-0.3919501007,
0.0652455091,
-0.5177345276,
-0.1665914953,
-0.0684446543,
-0.2824324369,
-0.6919779778,
-0.1203078255,
0.7597025633,
1.030674696,
-0.2314936221,
-0.1513267159,
-0.1555599421,
0.0697781444,
-0.2562377751,
0.5663386583,
-0.7127029896,
0.2935483754,
0.1780400425,
-0.0871020928,
-0.4928334355,
-0.094949238,
0.4896933734,
-0.9463826418,
0.2010901868,
0.1566372812,
0.8597625494,
0.5083768964,
-0.4152037203,
-0.1533400863,
-0.5469238162,
0.513481319,
-0.7998427749,
0.157364592,
0.1996488273,
0.3985331953,
0.0225613639,
-1.0425182581,
-0.5231664181,
0.0356506519,
-0.2974925935,
0.2424162924,
-0.4716032147,
0.4861260951,
0.2477501035,
0.4997488558,
-0.2913403809,
0.0729257166,
0.2399719208,
-0.1903255135,
-0.0535346605,
0.5784275532,
0.5231042504,
-0.5410025716,
-0.384462148,
0.1983678341,
-0.2446460575,
-0.034907788,
0.2660787106,
0.348716557,
-0.1151744053,
0.1653763503,
-0.1077825353,
0.542298317,
0.4798315763,
-0.1955715269,
0.2016271949,
-0.4342105091,
-0.4693393111,
-0.0908176377,
0.5699787736,
-0.0143446727,
-0.1177324727,
-0.1799017489,
0.1015857756,
-0.2227059901,
0.313287586,
-0.5809847116,
-0.1766280979,
0.256934166,
-0.4297373593,
-0.4302297235,
-0.2159413248,
-0.6637431383,
-0.2094103545,
-0.2093731314,
0.4038960636,
-0.3930465579,
-0.1221681461,
0.1559223831,
-0.0517547242,
0.0351643302,
0.6586813927,
-0.9230584502,
0.3740950525,
0.8080744743,
0.7621724606,
-0.1294566244,
-0.2572747469,
-0.9910781384,
0.235357672,
-0.0562576167,
0.7299556732,
-0.7797266245,
-0.295781672,
0.048884999,
0.2307868004,
-0.370339334,
-0.4008990824,
0.3311557174,
-0.2758664787,
0.4981666207,
0.3143137395,
-0.2719966769,
-0.1851105094,
0.2930991054,
-0.4655289948,
0.9443643689,
0.1203389764,
-0.9951838851,
0.0145823807,
-0.598405242,
-0.3857525587,
0.2456470132,
-0.1536712646,
-0.3455930352,
0.0726047978,
0.3107882738,
0.1379065365,
0.0544632934,
0.3403331339,
-0.128622368,
-0.3239039779,
-0.0968302935,
-0.2498645633,
0.924716115,
-0.0957820639,
-0.2937919199,
0.496691972,
-0.7047587633,
-0.1025815383,
-0.1831216067,
-0.2402727902,
-0.1189862862,
-0.0562913232,
-0.0505880862,
0.1240628064,
0.2648692131,
-0.5715916157,
0.284532398,
-0.3812085688,
0.5575848222,
0.7594953775,
-0.001019356,
0.4376162589,
0.1552939415,
0.4152919352,
0.2318588346,
0.0626099855,
-0.4388378859,
-0.603625536,
-0.9593194723,
-0.5397286415,
0.2230190933,
0.5767951012,
-0.7173770666,
0.3417063653,
0.0102157602,
-0.120895125,
-0.8110909462,
-0.0007451878,
0.4976488948,
0.3615299761,
0.1986636817,
-0.3147549331,
-0.3782782257,
-0.7720136046,
-0.2467324734,
-0.4672231078,
-0.0060647549,
0.6641417742,
0.2984735072,
-0.9509770274,
0.8267965317,
-0.7356435657,
-0.0336962193,
-0.5113070011,
0.8454215527,
0.0458390787,
0.2797982097,
0.1684188694,
-0.4926137328,
-0.3806102574,
0.3758495748,
-0.6086327434,
-0.1641724259,
-0.3047162294,
-0.3349477351,
-0.0862140357,
0.5584561825,
-0.7541735768,
0.5331406593,
0.4250662923,
-0.2776209414,
0.3356004059,
-0.0111374566,
-0.0704632923,
-1.0083255768,
-0.1255312264,
-0.2375425845,
-0.5790596008,
-0.8493422866,
-0.0744999051,
-0.1662649661,
-0.3346171975,
-0.3528657556,
0.3719801903,
-0.002672995,
-0.2885530889,
-0.0413072594,
0.3380675316,
-0.0502705984,
1.1498653889,
0.1590084732,
0.2799409628,
0.4018023908,
-0.1853954643,
0.3014830649,
0.463170141,
-0.2562775016,
0.4657378197,
-0.8299738169,
0.4546939135,
-0.0565011129,
0.284578681,
-1.338501215,
-0.3314268291,
0.3358546495,
-0.529055059,
0.4980796278,
-0.4573270977,
-0.4110443294,
-0.1363460422,
0.0779636875,
0.261149466,
0.334605217,
-0.6649682522,
0.9553285241,
0.4699226022,
-0.4228927791,
-0.4620354176,
-0.176469475,
0.0644984171,
-0.0804467648,
-0.5645409822,
0.417922169,
0.0335931629,
-0.0268592052,
-0.0807950646,
-0.1942614615,
-0.1733516604,
-0.0428796783,
0.2842897773,
0.1466690451,
-0.2205175757,
0.055772908,
0.1360327899,
-0.438018769,
-0.124795489,
-0.4014609754,
0.3886689246,
-0.3785278201,
-0.2646091878,
-0.9267460704,
0.6811587214,
1.0984823704,
0.0294315517,
0.4578750432,
0.7144058943,
-0.3787895739,
0.0028794154,
-0.1045537144,
-0.0238911957,
-0.4380543828,
0.5829262137,
-0.3080820739,
-1.0466997623,
0.5521111488,
-0.3077924848,
0.250531733,
0.364944458,
0.7187033892,
-0.2863433659,
1.6759121418,
0.913611114,
-0.032659173,
0.4857685566,
0.0234267414,
0.5570793152,
-0.6320206523,
-0.2763444483,
-0.5909975767,
-0.0065866662,
-0.6954729557,
-0.481575042,
0.2645929754,
-0.1179451421,
-0.1308595389,
0.3884243071,
-0.141792506,
0.1619823724,
0.3044669628,
-0.092639789,
0.4658350646,
-0.0130755799,
-0.3173689842,
-0.1946961135,
-0.9731225967,
-0.4814408422,
0.1865050793,
0.7613690495,
0.8418769836,
0.0513086691,
0.6091318727,
0.0825205967,
0.1538835466,
-1.0218855143,
0.4265592098,
-0.0279104747,
-0.3268510997,
-0.417425245,
-0.4724116921,
-0.8814609647,
0.4077759683,
0.1759317368,
-0.9880049825,
0.0533321425,
0.0602267049,
-0.305706501,
0.2318347543,
-0.7057623267,
1.1486905813,
0.1052452847,
0.0786944628,
-0.3585259914,
-0.8203458786,
0.1025018319,
0.3187483847,
0.174460426,
-0.0881400108,
0.2903816104,
0.6141957045,
-0.5299181938,
1.1995940208,
-0.1679801792,
0.0352307372,
0.1629648209,
0.0230177939,
0.4854559302,
0.203961283,
0.3117310405,
0.192358911,
0.0657001957,
-0.640642941,
-0.8707485199,
0.3382175863,
-0.9145041704,
-0.7764738202,
-0.3058689237,
-0.7582971454,
-0.2752870023,
0.0645601973,
0.0207184441,
0.469152391,
-0.4823004007,
0.0417386591,
0.745546937,
-0.3462003469,
0.104389593,
0.4507843852,
-0.1388140768,
-0.2653199434,
0.8818892241,
-0.3911341131,
0.468244493,
0.3995601237,
0.2596184611,
0.0766592473,
-0.2609272599,
-0.5940707922,
0.1890874207,
-0.6783618331,
-0.0238783881,
-1.2421035767,
-0.2903004885,
-0.2515818775,
0.1183435097,
-0.2298956215,
-0.5978181362,
-0.2161119431,
-0.2518459558,
0.1987185776,
0.9260530472,
0.0114551792,
0.4870640934,
-0.7633927464,
0.4080032706,
0.776617229,
0.0320145264,
0.0299713518,
-0.6534358859,
-0.3160135448,
-0.184936896,
-0.3190073967,
-0.6135085225,
0.2040384412,
0.1965420097,
0.680624783,
0.6535943151,
-0.2301270515,
0.5965889692,
-0.7461827993,
0.5784751177,
0.2685009241,
-1.2908462286,
0.6083601117,
-0.5841122866,
0.7794926167,
0.6068390608,
0.4262699485,
-0.7854199409,
-0.5982438326,
-0.7448484302,
-0.6626188159,
1.0597759485,
0.287268877,
0.2184801847,
0.0099798683,
-0.0035886329,
0.2036954165,
0.3047455549,
-0.57046175,
-0.1182796285,
-0.3025902212,
-0.3029509783,
0.202288866,
-0.1878811568,
-0.2621727288,
-0.4044139683,
0.2129882127,
-0.2351940572,
0.4994882941,
-0.1736892164,
-0.126567781,
-0.1404396743,
0.194979459,
0.2048990875,
0.332411617,
-0.3694815338,
0.1652544886,
0.2291269451,
-0.4944885373,
-0.2314577252,
-0.0430768654,
0.1468283683,
0.3062069714,
0.6963914633,
1.0224694014,
0.6998769641,
-0.3931542635,
0.4093775153,
-0.1592378914,
-0.0539259203,
0.3740382195,
-0.024174137,
0.2299358696,
0.1069604233,
0.1288066059,
-0.0034520323,
0.2411609739,
-1.0777051449,
0.176045835,
0.0987726077,
-0.7816513777,
-0.3319014311,
0.0465579219,
0.5506576896,
-0.5998797417,
0.6384134293,
-0.1202317551,
-0.9755574465,
0.5442690849,
0.5091062188,
1.0350812674,
-0.1685985029,
0.5830399394,
0.1772155315,
0.0885485262,
0.5476884246,
-0.0503039695,
-0.6110857129,
-0.6286455989,
-0.3844436407,
-0.4349835217,
-0.8580954671,
-0.1338388026,
-0.8514449596,
-0.228103593,
-0.5128797889,
-0.0066287094,
0.2762812972,
-0.1619617045,
-0.5083247423,
-0.0260980986,
-0.1252821386,
0.537766099,
-0.7866412401,
0.7131736279,
0.5518075228,
-0.108001709,
-0.389475584,
0.2731039524,
0.0860287026,
-0.9352996945,
0.5528942943,
0.1942302287,
-0.4448077083,
-0.0201129504,
-0.6022385955,
-0.6182145476,
0.6947348714,
0.0070389304,
-0.3955590725,
-0.3074412942,
0.0310837552,
0.7676995993,
-0.7631070614,
0.2738692462,
0.8561763763,
0.2282367796,
0.3731190264,
-0.6676412225,
-0.3113813102,
-0.2083873451,
-0.1354632527,
0.2246871591,
-0.5155153275,
0.6081353426,
-0.1817580312,
-0.4167450964,
0.1137645468,
0.5353642702,
0.016155649,
0.6089314222,
0.5846660733,
0.6603820324,
0.8786273599,
-0.2156863511,
0.8276340365,
-0.0504592918,
0.3438089788,
1.2380449772,
-0.2107932568,
0.5551834702,
0.294007957,
-0.025801355,
0.9609376788,
0.7297233343,
0.5766436458,
0.7119539976,
-0.0576517731,
-0.3766720295,
-0.5789793134,
-0.2392374277,
0.0167656764,
0.4310937524,
0.6570236683,
-0.1216622218,
-0.3038206697,
-0.0607431643,
-0.0337504111,
-0.3053765297,
-0.1313464344,
1.2322653532,
0.0819696486,
-0.534230113,
0.4266511202,
-0.0962859914,
0.1627533883,
-0.4984944463,
-0.1193843856,
-0.1724774092,
0.0477488413,
-0.2327226251,
-0.5601471066,
0.2565191984,
0.1668383181,
-0.1504903138,
-0.1869039834,
0.3089708388,
-0.5065946579,
-0.3618627787,
0.4027233124,
0.3763115704,
0.1737047881,
0.2847248614,
-0.8001361489,
0.0049880119,
0.2682021558,
0.0947324038,
0.167305842,
0.8795170784,
0.1940569729,
0.3707008958,
0.3510339558,
-0.4600532353,
-0.1283024102,
0.5408110023,
0.8290237784,
-0.5701640248,
-0.5813419819,
-0.428742379,
0.586920619,
-0.2665186226,
-0.4341601431,
0.6085529923,
-0.0567314699,
0.5414856076,
0.292067498,
0.5852480531,
0.3367359638,
0.275470823,
-0.401060164,
0.260062933,
-0.467231214,
-0.0102103651,
-0.6810585856,
-0.639729023,
-0.1437201053,
0.7967345715,
-0.305586338,
-0.179860279,
0.8460497856,
0.6434857845,
-0.1663370281,
0.2711799145,
0.4605860412,
0.5113763809,
0.1225054637,
0.6540583968,
1.1315742731,
-0.1898670048,
0.5376161933,
0.1382474154,
-0.4356318414,
-0.4626363218,
-0.6149294376,
-1.1550582647,
-0.37170735,
-0.5858995914,
-0.2469377071,
0.1583901346,
0.6381654739,
0.9942494035,
-0.7838362455,
-0.017426217,
-0.1850603819,
0.509942174,
-0.0532365032,
-0.224820897,
0.2947221696,
-0.572516799,
-0.9611362815,
0.2775100172,
0.9119238257,
-0.0866852403,
-0.0902241766,
-0.0984439626,
-0.2490017265,
0.2924737632,
0.6359322071,
0.214187935,
-0.9059562683,
-0.4261301756,
-0.0937277526,
-0.2493729591,
0.2695314884,
1.1719206572,
-0.5182219148,
0.7009922862,
0.5298385024,
0.7977614999,
0.8980816007,
0.1044148952,
0.619474709,
-0.6164669394,
0.2266948372,
0.2419939339,
0.3072065413,
0.311847657,
-0.4662608802,
0.1859666556,
0.3030678928,
-0.3934732974,
-0.6902828813,
0.540354073,
-1.0206741095,
-0.2781713903,
0.7419108748,
-0.4315758049,
-0.1625222415,
-0.3729135394,
-0.5550893545,
0.3844179213,
-0.3189835846,
0.6664391756,
0.7985131741,
-0.310338676,
-0.1589091867,
-0.2418433279,
0.4283143878,
0.7533869743,
-0.7848561406,
0.1586024612,
0.3378397822,
-0.0740612149,
0.3351356089,
0.4510316253,
-0.1498952061,
0.3950131238,
0.0757476464,
-0.4760845006,
0.3983639479,
-0.7217425108,
-0.4080547392,
0.0070109256,
-0.1833855361,
-0.1163727269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00217v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00217v6 | Still no evidence for an effect of the proportion of non-native speakers on language complexity -- A response to Kauhanen, Einhaus & Walkden (2023) | 2023-04-29T09:58:32 | 2023-05-30T05:42:08 | Alexander Koplenig | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | In a recent paper published in the Journal of Language Evolution, Kauhanen,
Einhaus & Walkden (https://doi.org/10.1093/jole/lzad005, KEW) challenge the
results presented in one of my papers (Koplenig, Royal Society Open Science, 6,
181274 (2019), https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.181274), in which I tried to show
through a series of statistical analyses that large numbers of L2 (second
language) speakers do not seem to affect the (grammatical or statistical)
complexity of a language. To this end, I focus on the way in which the
Ethnologue assesses language status: a language is characterised as vehicular
if, in addition to being used by L1 (first language) speakers, it should also
have a significant number of L2 users. KEW criticise both the use of
vehicularity as a (binary) indicator of whether a language has a significant
number of L2 users and the idea of imputing a zero proportion of L2 speakers to
non-vehicular languages whenever a direct estimate of that proportion is
unavailable. While I recognise the importance of post-publication commentary on
published research, I show in this rejoinder that both points of criticism are
explicitly mentioned and analysed in my paper. In addition, I also comment on
other points raised by KEW and demonstrate that both alternative analyses
offered by KEW do not stand up to closer scrutiny. | [
-0.2823237181,
-0.6449319124,
0.5915663838,
0.3254370689,
-0.1154430136,
0.283051759,
-0.3826237917,
-0.7224949002,
0.5238515139,
-0.0472403467,
-0.0590421148,
0.0746129602,
-0.6895084381,
0.3894796968,
-0.2065105438,
0.5915279388,
0.283703655,
0.043101687,
-0.4248305261,
-0.5743053555,
-0.3140276968,
-0.4037562311,
-0.6340633631,
-0.3070381582,
0.7405415773,
0.6091061831,
0.5928577185,
0.3462007642,
0.1442767978,
0.3484490514,
-0.4597845376,
-0.1379348338,
-0.4146233797,
0.1494497359,
0.1237608194,
-0.580114603,
-0.164425835,
-0.238184303,
0.612191081,
1.3626708984,
0.0909534097,
-0.1645245552,
-0.2136878818,
0.7901742458,
-0.5550724864,
-0.2155864984,
-0.3776326776,
-0.0675373375,
-0.373778373,
0.0157846417,
-0.4380307794,
-0.2363823652,
0.1428331733,
-0.2031185627,
0.1612342149,
0.0164916832,
0.595623672,
0.266931653,
-0.6036616564,
-0.1790714115,
-0.9422348738,
0.9155269861,
-0.7169728279,
0.323516041,
0.3457840681,
-0.1001863852,
-0.2098201662,
-0.2500038147,
-0.7453834414,
-0.5481979847,
-0.2587458491,
0.2426481545,
-0.0563986897,
-0.1469871998,
0.3142289221,
0.5537188649,
-0.5502579212,
0.2883113027,
-0.7625826001,
-0.0821228027,
0.5976227522,
-0.1121420711,
0.2393284589,
-0.0235266723,
-0.2055296004,
0.1867062449,
-0.5453115702,
0.3984236121,
0.5001286268,
0.2279249281,
-0.1640025079,
0.7643689513,
-0.1763128638,
0.5240277648,
-0.1727356762,
-0.206740573,
0.5067341328,
-0.3044624925,
0.2912469208,
0.1838189363,
0.9178903103,
0.1817579567,
0.0914946944,
-0.0230892729,
0.1736920029,
0.0653367639,
-0.19524993,
-0.4852765799,
-0.2983903885,
0.2081496269,
-0.0932351574,
-0.209268719,
0.1467152089,
-0.6121003032,
-0.2444157749,
0.3166201115,
0.0974259004,
-0.0700731277,
-0.6648803353,
0.1204156503,
-0.1532669961,
0.3204302192,
0.3843657374,
-0.9775938988,
0.3333057165,
0.7068138123,
0.8864725828,
-0.0984444544,
-0.1997641921,
-0.0875819176,
-0.2062958926,
-0.4567710459,
0.7553671598,
-0.6603937745,
-0.6751089096,
0.0294445902,
0.1618155092,
0.0913697705,
-0.3952136934,
0.5381830931,
-0.2290242612,
0.3758660555,
-0.6119433641,
-0.3779763281,
0.0001594067,
-0.101247482,
-0.5050304532,
1.028768301,
0.1285339892,
-0.6965637207,
0.4454928339,
-0.1339913309,
-0.9435015321,
0.2652933598,
-0.3432310522,
-0.4524927139,
0.4140633047,
-0.4226231575,
-0.3063774109,
0.1196367368,
0.1044692695,
-0.6847407818,
-0.0740290955,
0.1153060794,
-0.3496380448,
0.8895081878,
-0.0283338446,
-0.4798596799,
-0.2047871202,
-0.6820453405,
-0.0210421644,
0.1479495019,
-0.6413718462,
-0.3533224165,
0.2226049304,
-0.0632193461,
0.1364540011,
0.151476562,
-0.9731542468,
0.1224800274,
-0.5685997605,
0.3099398911,
0.5141964555,
-0.0493328981,
0.5532952547,
-0.3386957347,
0.5007172227,
-0.2675960064,
-0.063405022,
0.2214349955,
-0.9114204645,
-1.1419353485,
0.3502673805,
0.3051239848,
0.3663428724,
-0.4189388454,
0.3657877743,
-0.5542119145,
-0.5902819037,
-0.3144287765,
-0.0736979246,
0.307611376,
0.1856046617,
-0.009720386,
-0.6594669819,
-0.5133297443,
-1.0994107723,
-0.146236971,
-0.8916510344,
0.0090036597,
0.2353604287,
0.4756040573,
0.3376479149,
0.6449843645,
0.0713262782,
0.1825682819,
-0.0721302778,
0.1850990355,
-0.0685684308,
0.4651765823,
0.3933193982,
-0.5579423308,
-0.6848614812,
0.3870236576,
-0.8284534812,
-0.2134851068,
0.2439616919,
0.3655168414,
0.4891017675,
0.3945147693,
-0.8410496712,
0.2484992892,
0.413785845,
-0.2750261128,
0.1787725836,
-0.2662111819,
-0.1128971428,
-0.3754405379,
0.1515179724,
-0.1696721464,
-0.0990705267,
-0.9094187021,
-0.1658048332,
-0.2091574073,
0.0896319002,
-0.0004185727,
0.4178719223,
-0.2168809325,
0.0213980414,
-0.4234880209,
0.0726368949,
-0.3381102979,
0.346421957,
0.082506828,
0.3316825926,
0.1371572763,
-0.4372864962,
-0.1592512578,
-0.0528892428,
-0.3866252899,
0.495719552,
-0.7926431894,
0.1217975989,
-0.3093913198,
0.1101366654,
-1.2745546103,
-0.2798843682,
0.3970960081,
-0.7083304524,
0.326144278,
-0.0760663748,
-0.2593222558,
-0.305768013,
-0.1970467716,
0.4946624041,
0.6364346743,
0.0811046064,
0.1968236119,
0.500246346,
-0.4645937085,
-0.2156263292,
-0.6828419566,
0.200000748,
-0.1107509658,
-0.6986803412,
-0.1672897935,
-0.2341783792,
-0.9084239602,
-0.1032436043,
-0.4102292359,
0.2432694286,
0.3353049457,
0.1062250137,
-0.2711617351,
-0.4353069067,
0.3524388075,
-0.0796022043,
-0.2331174016,
0.3329740167,
-0.0975425616,
0.1446920782,
-0.1577104926,
-0.3634637594,
-0.0924626291,
0.4204626977,
0.4803375006,
-0.1401228905,
0.591027081,
0.3545587659,
-0.0507605821,
0.1122927442,
-0.3533005714,
0.1185075566,
-0.4477598667,
0.4451196194,
-0.2436830699,
-1.2504732609,
0.2938475609,
0.1811311394,
-0.0653634742,
0.7484478354,
0.6989527345,
-0.2481443286,
0.6690807343,
0.6513875723,
0.0309095085,
0.289190501,
0.2832123339,
0.4860960543,
-0.2398738116,
-0.3535596132,
-0.7856993675,
-0.2922800779,
-0.9716442227,
-0.1968300492,
0.3051975965,
0.0245657228,
-0.1223388314,
0.0924890488,
-0.0457124896,
0.3190254867,
0.1801314354,
-0.0044712131,
0.363050878,
-0.0730614439,
0.4678165317,
-0.0065813996,
-1.0099984407,
-0.2995410264,
0.936804831,
0.4303620756,
0.3899913132,
0.6074249148,
0.4853893518,
0.4315891862,
0.1665386856,
-0.8119760156,
0.4366094172,
0.1929121464,
-0.7141003609,
-0.4926863313,
-0.5973263979,
-1.1308003664,
0.3722303808,
0.0152082974,
-0.75870502,
0.6498172879,
-0.0682327598,
-0.1175865456,
0.2534276545,
-0.489315331,
0.5790764093,
-0.2232493013,
-0.4899840355,
-0.2130775303,
-0.8792580366,
0.4799893796,
-0.1918011457,
0.5329388976,
0.0191247612,
-0.0333349667,
0.9885908365,
-0.879696846,
0.7310244441,
-0.2512659132,
-0.4932211041,
0.3984844685,
-0.0372020602,
0.3006894886,
-0.0858558044,
0.0333207659,
-0.0840652138,
-0.0545877963,
-0.8486489654,
-0.4866106808,
0.7150309086,
-0.6890385747,
-0.7702323794,
-0.4602615237,
-0.1878287643,
-0.1083779633,
0.2595345676,
0.1389580369,
0.3092592359,
-0.0836238787,
0.4861214757,
0.5021305084,
-0.0470242612,
0.4227460623,
0.5479211211,
-0.1079916134,
-0.3180681169,
0.945038259,
0.310375005,
0.7335890532,
0.4188130796,
0.3839221001,
-0.035580527,
-0.630322516,
-0.2199880928,
0.1759701371,
-0.7623333335,
0.4724637866,
-0.6715436578,
0.1408267468,
-0.2092074752,
0.2019297183,
-0.4280257225,
-0.6933982372,
0.3535813093,
-0.0868375078,
0.3272450566,
1.1257339716,
-0.3235119283,
0.242372334,
-0.1445302665,
-0.0726959109,
0.3348619938,
0.0614416189,
0.2304355353,
-0.7245073915,
-0.4660486281,
0.0845977515,
0.0944774523,
-0.5649029016,
-0.3725752532,
0.1841173917,
0.407258451,
0.3199779093,
0.2109823376,
0.4596958756,
-0.2166831195,
0.8800730705,
0.0708499104,
-0.6602481604,
0.212278232,
-0.2978657484,
0.2103411704,
0.6590144038,
0.3648045361,
-0.4702270925,
-0.7307711244,
-0.6927753091,
-0.9404123425,
0.4208255112,
0.3609926105,
0.2929053903,
-0.0510954261,
0.1803436726,
0.1110251769,
0.1943060309,
-0.9286679029,
-0.5976961255,
0.0612896346,
0.2774803638,
-0.1886671931,
-0.6171147227,
0.1572757363,
-0.4772150218,
0.6704047322,
0.1976471394,
0.019055184,
0.3538438082,
-0.0197689664,
-0.4385325909,
0.2604549825,
0.9726470709,
0.9007061124,
-0.2403544486,
0.3790658414,
0.1136017367,
-0.4628577232,
0.3917806745,
-0.2977803648,
-0.4621655643,
0.3804405332,
0.9212534428,
0.5327934623,
0.1679904759,
-0.3928731978,
0.5341725349,
0.0282161944,
-0.3860323131,
-0.4327547252,
-0.1162894219,
-0.0478648506,
-0.1383221149,
0.2506268322,
0.2435253412,
-0.3625152409,
-0.6732048988,
0.0395255312,
0.3139965236,
-0.5668395162,
-0.5914130807,
0.5378055573,
0.2157166451,
-0.5235491395,
0.1902965009,
-0.4840767086,
-0.6167429686,
0.5617864132,
0.1870622337,
0.7216992378,
-0.2506302893,
-0.0379489288,
0.553411603,
0.8528668284,
0.1363704801,
0.2928163409,
-0.0216563717,
-0.443624258,
-0.3801474869,
-0.4321703017,
-0.3335217535,
0.1053936705,
-0.4592154324,
0.0731356964,
-0.4150398672,
-0.0558527261,
0.1860773265,
-0.0170263182,
0.0266205277,
-0.0950649977,
0.1426751167,
0.6415613294,
-0.9832314253,
0.5894683003,
0.4506987333,
-0.4315893352,
-0.1749489307,
0.2103276551,
-0.1236322224,
-0.4541887939,
0.3643015921,
-0.0473315306,
-0.244110167,
-0.2123336941,
-0.4756570756,
-0.6346073151,
0.4018949866,
0.1089495271,
-0.3597973287,
0.6190137267,
0.4091640413,
0.7663965821,
0.0594586655,
0.2029415965,
0.2060081959,
0.714569509,
-0.0066984277,
-0.9651855826,
0.0490657426,
-0.5448349118,
-0.0598395094,
0.2503230274,
-0.8342657685,
0.9323188066,
-0.3571055532,
-0.3884630203,
0.3189059198,
0.7366684675,
-0.3210358024,
0.250171721,
0.8112375736,
0.6136452556,
0.5647916794,
0.1278207004,
0.9765219688,
-0.0907289311,
0.5234043598,
1.1245447397,
-0.4285157621,
0.8466358185,
0.7520920038,
-0.9509937167,
0.5669068694,
0.5972496867,
0.0988231227,
0.5813623071,
0.3329340816,
-0.572291553,
-0.4118142724,
-0.2166313678,
-0.5297475457,
0.4574262798,
-0.0031590522,
0.0239916965,
-0.1990478635,
-0.4541623294,
0.2108651996,
0.2303301841,
0.0759800673,
0.7401260734,
0.2954285741,
-0.6077276468,
0.7194638848,
0.1925556958,
0.1835782081,
-0.6050843596,
0.2916169465,
-0.3541197181,
-0.1042574942,
-0.3604523242,
-0.7429770231,
0.337810576,
-0.1310846061,
-0.2198332101,
0.275583595,
0.4737763107,
-0.3414087892,
-0.5996849537,
0.2137027383,
0.7204036713,
0.3331570327,
0.3285744786,
-0.0151302088,
-0.0445689298,
0.0422103368,
-0.1671590805,
0.1695526689,
0.699924469,
0.0012741704,
0.5737669468,
0.4608431458,
-0.0925605148,
0.0360759944,
-0.066210255,
0.4928443432,
-0.4403729141,
-0.1819300354,
-1.103197217,
0.3505923748,
-0.0444368087,
-0.3318139315,
0.9346008897,
0.8204840422,
1.0154688358,
0.1350362897,
1.0003672838,
-0.587231338,
0.1531947404,
-0.1528359056,
0.2936151326,
-0.7114151716,
0.2961829603,
-0.1496639848,
-0.5177205801,
-0.1611383855,
0.5011844635,
-0.5304778218,
0.2958073616,
0.8143875599,
0.6772044301,
-0.0483834855,
0.0969572142,
0.2524938881,
0.43171525,
0.0133773545,
0.3370011151,
0.8945552111,
-0.3497841656,
0.4190420508,
-0.4315684438,
-0.2089794874,
-0.1241978854,
-0.4425459802,
-0.7772697806,
-0.3694025278,
-0.4150152504,
-0.4762849212,
-0.1266403049,
0.4806476831,
0.3117164373,
-0.948178947,
-0.4156560302,
-0.239204064,
0.3868290186,
0.0395273566,
-0.1387531906,
0.1997518241,
-0.0504250079,
-0.5629793406,
0.2930771708,
0.2669271231,
-0.1527002752,
-0.4076128304,
-0.3489268124,
-0.2138748318,
-0.3141812682,
0.6578423381,
0.654615283,
-0.7934606671,
-0.5929976106,
-0.2956667542,
0.0540357493,
0.2356786728,
0.4022805989,
-0.3413273692,
0.4720935822,
0.4750242531,
0.4023372829,
0.2895726562,
-0.2293746918,
0.4674060345,
-0.5437831879,
0.2571555078,
-0.0781926662,
0.2268078774,
0.3276012838,
0.140396148,
0.3949739635,
0.8076736331,
-0.3437309563,
-0.8182926178,
0.5259968042,
-0.9495055676,
0.0053998884,
0.9315783978,
-0.0988958776,
-0.1568297446,
-0.4335312247,
0.1797321737,
-0.0930230618,
-0.3412440419,
0.6641145349,
0.7010474205,
0.1070826948,
-0.2974569499,
-0.8176271319,
0.3172955513,
0.6930769086,
-0.4637900293,
-0.0143828737,
0.0883173496,
0.0886910707,
0.4226887822,
0.7857574821,
0.14581801,
0.057702072,
0.2670236528,
-0.3233036101,
0.3954797685,
0.0598778464,
-0.3721674681,
-0.0096132336,
0.6069397926,
0.1896163374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.06173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.06173v1 | QICHWABASE: A Quechua Language and Knowledge Base for Quechua Communities | 2023-04-29T09:14:55 | 2023-04-29T09:14:55 | Elwin Huaman, David Lindemann, Valeria Caruso, Jorge Luis Huaman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Over the last decade, the Web has increasingly become a space of language and
knowledge representation. However, it is only true for well-spread languages
and well-established communities, while minority communities and their
resources received less attention. In this paper, we propose QICHWABASE to
support the harmonization process of the Quechua language and knowledge, and
its community. For doing it, we adopt methods and tools that could become a
game changer in favour of Quechua communities around the world. We conclude
that the methodology and tools adopted on building QICHWABASE, which is a
Wikibase instance, could enhance the presence of minorities on the Web. | [
-0.5228964686,
-0.2129848748,
0.0220298637,
0.7915617824,
-0.085813269,
0.5525346994,
-0.3124194741,
-0.4690259695,
0.3750368953,
0.1760276705,
-0.5230060816,
-0.4169450998,
-0.2730157971,
0.1441288888,
-0.4981722832,
0.8391484022,
0.0581327602,
-0.0529018231,
0.0921972319,
-0.2484300584,
-0.0285623092,
-0.3648763001,
-0.3206064403,
-0.1819473356,
0.6850348115,
0.6997348666,
0.8030798435,
0.5718710423,
0.362558037,
0.2531311512,
0.103530772,
-0.0672863051,
-0.6417452693,
0.1379764527,
-0.2392731756,
-0.6146119237,
-0.0327352807,
-0.2644571066,
0.1708952487,
0.8077705503,
-0.5678373575,
0.1189560294,
-0.1175405085,
0.5581368208,
-0.6658061743,
0.0834981054,
-0.5307894945,
0.003712205,
-0.4387468398,
0.0483663827,
0.2956202626,
-0.8523780107,
-0.1246440336,
-0.8332010508,
0.2382756621,
0.1096735671,
0.3900110722,
-0.0450965539,
-0.4988478124,
-0.0057516689,
-0.5540255904,
0.8161677718,
-0.8747225404,
0.4434630573,
0.3425877392,
0.3958963454,
-0.4131729305,
-0.8385676146,
-1.0229997635,
0.1853722185,
0.0404982045,
0.0070215962,
-0.0863173455,
-0.0953511596,
0.2687945962,
0.5708320737,
-0.1641557217,
-0.1996394992,
-0.3628776371,
-0.3843182623,
0.4300667942,
0.3287665248,
0.7615153193,
-0.0627505034,
-0.0882160291,
0.3696386218,
-0.6733241081,
0.1110567003,
0.1661869884,
0.3072976768,
0.113268584,
0.2463125288,
-0.8106883764,
0.6752361059,
0.0849289447,
-0.4254728258,
0.2122379392,
-0.2868444324,
-0.1329710186,
0.0353755653,
0.9188569188,
0.4910447001,
0.0245172307,
-0.3877645433,
0.1544172466,
-0.1521444768,
-0.1179529876,
-0.8033596873,
-0.4050991535,
0.500297606,
-0.5943167806,
-0.3303414583,
0.2942802906,
-0.4617536366,
-0.7004435062,
0.2417933941,
-0.2876588702,
-0.4582230449,
-0.6291755438,
-0.1391374916,
-0.6233338118,
0.366180867,
0.5982928872,
-1.3239836693,
0.4880517125,
0.5337380767,
0.8330028057,
0.0422610492,
-0.4629572034,
0.1464672238,
0.3549786508,
-0.2387223691,
0.702198565,
-0.1126559526,
-0.6441970468,
0.1318680793,
-0.0916934013,
0.5671946406,
-0.6421785951,
0.3163678646,
-0.576808691,
0.0906683654,
-0.7839211226,
-0.3871458769,
-0.0255006012,
0.2061109394,
-0.7917479277,
0.8124822378,
0.8568962216,
-0.9034456015,
0.3945398331,
-0.1716504097,
-0.9130008817,
0.4158951938,
0.0756898746,
0.1468969733,
-0.2499214262,
0.0181552824,
-0.2861468494,
-0.4040878713,
-0.1890681535,
-0.1919446737,
-0.371152401,
0.065696992,
0.3639513552,
1.6829657555,
0.1871128976,
-0.5507620573,
-0.3034586012,
-0.5502032042,
0.160539344,
-0.1483981162,
-0.6436232328,
-0.6943045855,
0.218236655,
0.1822658777,
0.4338931739,
0.5009624958,
-0.7030172944,
0.3323610723,
-0.392319411,
0.2524985671,
0.3033431172,
-0.0441755019,
0.4746969938,
-0.1145858765,
0.5388139486,
-0.078982912,
0.6408438087,
0.3318029046,
-0.6088332534,
-0.979024291,
0.2271580696,
0.3216705322,
0.4889135361,
-0.6778777838,
0.4199264944,
0.1746439636,
-0.5490899086,
-0.6681278944,
0.6291233897,
-0.1649742424,
0.581782937,
0.3546848297,
-0.2446856946,
-0.9944251776,
-0.625336051,
0.4334207475,
-0.4176886082,
-0.2589503527,
0.0243133418,
-0.1224248409,
-0.5102193952,
1.1537947655,
-0.3971685469,
-0.5321645737,
-0.1426818371,
-0.1273642182,
0.1267742664,
0.2517676055,
0.6113212705,
-0.9430755377,
-0.8456253409,
0.5777440667,
-0.7385510802,
-0.219069019,
0.3709766567,
-0.4720195234,
-0.2751657069,
0.4135056436,
-0.3684308529,
-0.1078267097,
0.6315526366,
-0.2145945132,
0.4345231354,
0.3178254664,
0.4241313934,
-1.1453768015,
-0.0200473759,
-0.4719706178,
0.0514343493,
-0.6739493608,
0.3737714589,
0.330244422,
0.3399212658,
-0.3104673624,
0.4205878675,
-0.3636586666,
0.3151416779,
-0.3589975834,
0.2220710814,
-0.0644082129,
0.165094018,
-0.2039479911,
0.56784904,
0.3490538001,
-0.3411557674,
1.0436316729,
0.3660749197,
-0.4651392102,
0.5633796453,
-0.4767033756,
-0.1543399692,
0.305082649,
0.0207860172,
-0.4974384308,
-0.2179279178,
0.3276424408,
-0.4570465088,
-0.3263477683,
-0.0130300019,
-0.1153306663,
-0.5602061152,
-0.5526049137,
0.2706801891,
0.3560120463,
-0.6017626524,
0.3455880582,
0.6832766533,
-0.2017513067,
-0.9336802363,
-0.56354177,
0.290242672,
0.0009326935,
-0.7482115626,
0.3304999769,
-0.1100612655,
-0.6541835666,
0.1953985989,
0.089412123,
-0.5026680827,
0.243801415,
0.26014027,
-0.0998293906,
-0.400307864,
0.2366503775,
0.1756322384,
0.5350120068,
-0.0804473832,
-0.4741896093,
0.541600287,
0.1522970051,
0.0170527697,
-0.024282787,
0.5135593414,
0.3619500101,
-0.4736068547,
1.0497871637,
0.3249074817,
-0.4790540338,
-0.3620358706,
-0.5600647926,
0.2009405494,
-0.4962699711,
0.1546666473,
0.021257706,
-1.0438241959,
0.8523537517,
-0.0803184286,
0.1442691535,
0.3610799909,
0.7998608947,
-0.3988312483,
0.8182624578,
0.9079684019,
-0.6846929193,
0.5532448888,
0.070262596,
0.1907277703,
-0.839437902,
-0.5499073267,
-0.7203563452,
-0.1349687725,
-0.2153097689,
-0.4561698437,
-0.1796955466,
0.4443711042,
0.0183602758,
0.4048750997,
-0.149719283,
0.3242202699,
0.7117415667,
0.19215177,
0.5995919704,
-0.3205231726,
0.1295585632,
0.0845106766,
-0.7557275295,
-0.1197334826,
0.751132071,
-0.4082906544,
0.9238007665,
0.4929818809,
0.9419276714,
0.4750247896,
0.5027000308,
-0.9390622377,
0.0815129951,
0.1836370975,
-0.4928440452,
-0.5460162759,
-0.3657456338,
-0.9440212846,
0.0988379568,
-0.1222358868,
-0.2817922533,
0.6283926964,
0.0364652537,
-0.118354544,
0.1528304666,
-0.5938432813,
0.6894899011,
-0.1003095061,
-0.1084092408,
-0.3868179321,
-0.1930244863,
0.5209365487,
-0.0634922683,
0.4080938995,
-0.1020683348,
-0.0474296771,
0.528866291,
-0.9725331664,
0.6417008042,
-0.1932540536,
-0.2595098615,
0.4360206127,
0.1903796941,
0.1570950747,
0.1038490608,
-0.2060896158,
0.1327653527,
-0.0189920105,
-0.6340838075,
-0.7081620693,
0.6260780096,
-0.8898151517,
-0.7611689568,
-0.0038974921,
-0.3747829497,
-0.357316643,
0.6275957227,
0.0620699823,
-0.0623951033,
-0.6552020311,
0.1412896961,
0.4576832354,
0.1633547843,
0.0356774256,
0.5516037345,
-0.3410518467,
0.002323457,
0.8135236502,
-0.0352470018,
-0.0013136974,
0.2814971209,
0.1847985536,
0.0281283967,
-0.5658635497,
-0.1874830425,
-0.0586724617,
-0.8153539896,
-0.4293935895,
-0.4523650408,
-0.074528195,
-0.6680749059,
-0.0967509523,
0.2457936555,
-0.7176420689,
0.0608857125,
-0.073267892,
0.3281866014,
0.7083178163,
-0.1866842806,
0.3812103868,
-0.6977370381,
0.3509136438,
0.8677006364,
0.362039566,
0.3263103664,
-0.0216262229,
-0.7642890811,
0.2035275102,
0.1512255371,
-0.8752535582,
0.0871543884,
0.2375342697,
0.9321191907,
0.5957584977,
0.2180325836,
0.3772139847,
-0.3374704123,
0.4902287126,
0.3954093456,
-1.0002679825,
0.6925354004,
-0.3809817433,
0.4471072257,
0.6300635934,
0.328956008,
-1.5335446596,
-1.0225557089,
-0.2660994232,
-0.6808885336,
0.6415111423,
-0.0830892846,
0.2672508359,
-0.187706843,
-0.1371649057,
-0.0466834977,
0.2053893954,
-0.4719316959,
-0.2250921726,
-0.8119653463,
-0.1805110574,
0.5805698633,
-0.0984564424,
-0.2996941507,
-0.3493554294,
0.5059378743,
-0.2681490779,
-0.2411575019,
-0.0906026438,
-0.4008591473,
-0.3922367096,
0.1903263032,
0.0210146233,
0.7736320496,
-0.1897038817,
-0.0526131503,
0.0323637761,
-0.6740840673,
0.0035095897,
-0.1138548926,
-0.4746920764,
-0.1461031288,
0.4462588429,
0.2036747783,
0.0928744823,
-0.6799516678,
0.4388555586,
-0.2985636294,
-0.0210862104,
0.1560562551,
0.3585850298,
0.6891872883,
0.2115974873,
0.7358224392,
-0.0906764641,
0.414871484,
-0.7424761057,
0.0882708207,
0.3017973602,
-0.2537321746,
-0.0062658675,
0.4254845679,
0.715000391,
-0.2317623943,
0.680598855,
-0.1318766326,
-0.923561573,
0.7805987,
0.5022289753,
0.2911457121,
-0.515088141,
0.4443802536,
0.5910174847,
0.2725690603,
-0.0995225087,
0.3105600774,
-0.510401547,
-1.0899602175,
0.1341364235,
-0.5093957782,
-0.6039317846,
-0.6593843102,
-0.528657198,
0.1007021889,
-0.7685007453,
-0.264559418,
-0.1540540159,
0.0119934697,
-0.2380485833,
0.2580559254,
0.0491222292,
1.0568625927,
-0.3300889432,
1.1991485357,
0.3671137393,
-0.5138605833,
-0.7961761355,
0.1634510309,
-0.1148409545,
-0.8035482168,
0.5459468365,
-0.5504400134,
-0.2501356602,
-0.0610001683,
-0.4020299613,
-0.8376204371,
1.1346148252,
0.1296358556,
-0.6676857471,
0.2525376081,
-0.0756793395,
0.759572506,
0.0647435337,
-0.2528284192,
0.4802910984,
0.4136433005,
-0.1938179433,
-0.8076192737,
0.091797784,
-0.2999277115,
-0.0651461259,
0.2343409657,
-0.969663918,
0.9230132699,
-0.521440506,
-0.4902462363,
0.1122197509,
0.7779098153,
-0.130798474,
-0.2903037071,
0.2961735427,
0.112631239,
1.1881104708,
-0.2411498576,
0.7427475452,
-0.3329019248,
0.4966256917,
0.8634449244,
-0.2957709134,
0.7130141854,
0.7262666225,
-0.8178597689,
0.8750398159,
0.4312112629,
-0.0926943868,
0.5697206259,
0.1031780392,
-0.615111053,
-0.0248661861,
-0.4745653272,
-0.6306681633,
0.1143306419,
0.2149174213,
0.0265453383,
-0.1735178381,
-0.3270486891,
0.0031424358,
0.233245343,
-0.3973462582,
0.4282058775,
0.002077478,
-0.3901550174,
0.3054662347,
0.1448161751,
1.012778759,
-0.6572719216,
0.0498460494,
-0.7754389048,
-0.2266680449,
-0.8174566031,
-0.7123567462,
0.028687859,
-0.3369695544,
-0.2961525619,
0.3026590049,
0.6956374645,
-0.5854626894,
-0.4373556376,
0.6088384986,
0.6862983704,
-0.578428328,
0.0872797444,
-0.4075323045,
-0.2834155858,
0.1912096292,
0.2401659936,
0.2996465266,
0.6603087187,
-0.3205451369,
0.5523779392,
0.6190457344,
0.3348264396,
0.3949115276,
0.4061009884,
0.9265675545,
-0.6232289672,
-0.4932168722,
-0.5814515948,
-0.0996211246,
-0.331200093,
-0.088551186,
1.2118785381,
0.5281499624,
0.9312115312,
0.1364640743,
1.3489202261,
-0.9537631273,
0.4362353384,
0.1174973026,
1.0874955654,
-0.4023145735,
-0.1599032879,
-0.3142918348,
-0.7338235378,
-0.2763843238,
0.6732048392,
0.4691164196,
-0.3398773074,
0.305013299,
0.7771790624,
0.2188140154,
0.0187179092,
0.440941155,
0.1852096915,
0.0853129327,
0.6455851197,
1.2018787861,
-0.2710968554,
0.9330560565,
-0.7806464434,
-0.4498178959,
-0.183949843,
-0.4000364244,
-0.6572419405,
-0.4774006307,
0.0941250399,
-0.2834631503,
0.0030034606,
0.7416508794,
0.489928484,
-1.255390048,
-0.6539258361,
0.3204935491,
0.6462632418,
-0.3845419586,
-0.1860549003,
-0.0913146809,
-0.1685620993,
-0.5857345462,
0.0401040837,
0.3552522063,
-0.1835436225,
-0.4903365374,
-0.416428566,
-0.2160740495,
-0.3047824502,
0.5798220634,
0.9209182262,
-0.3790807128,
-0.0155637236,
0.2978897095,
-0.723977983,
0.296435684,
1.2533830404,
-0.8056460023,
0.5329463482,
0.468524754,
0.3196052313,
0.1796518713,
-0.0869427994,
0.8929742575,
-0.4506833851,
0.3953625262,
0.1894808114,
0.5020785928,
0.4399325252,
-0.3956815004,
0.2946737409,
0.2220228612,
-0.0922692716,
-0.2741366625,
-0.0626917034,
-0.7312638164,
-0.3667372465,
0.8085247874,
-0.0687634274,
-0.1219056249,
-0.6990439296,
-0.5060830116,
0.368696183,
-0.4775577486,
1.2714753151,
0.6794928312,
-0.0166960582,
-0.1974271238,
0.0674370676,
0.7173169851,
-0.1275240779,
-1.1442697048,
0.0370600224,
0.4747142792,
0.4653270245,
0.1711586565,
1.1143944263,
0.0557827242,
0.9753015637,
0.1490926892,
0.2970157862,
0.2816196084,
0.2311755866,
0.1722153872,
-0.0124112731,
0.5322050452,
0.3049202859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00182v1 | Examining European Press Coverage of the Covid-19 No-Vax Movement: An NLP Framework | 2023-04-29T06:26:03 | 2023-04-29T06:26:03 | David Alonso del Barrio, Daniel Gatica-Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper examines how the European press dealt with the no-vax reactions
against the Covid-19 vaccine and the dis- and misinformation associated with
this movement. Using a curated dataset of 1786 articles from 19 European
newspapers on the anti-vaccine movement over a period of 22 months in
2020-2021, we used Natural Language Processing techniques including topic
modeling, sentiment analysis, semantic relationship with word embeddings,
political analysis, named entity recognition, and semantic networks, to
understand the specific role of the European traditional press in the
disinformation ecosystem. The results of this multi-angle analysis demonstrate
that the European well-established press actively opposed a variety of hoaxes
mainly spread on social media, and was critical of the anti-vax trend,
regardless of the political orientation of the newspaper. This confirms the
relevance of studying the role of high-quality press in the disinformation
ecosystem. | [
-0.4912676215,
-0.9436757565,
0.30339697,
0.1423279792,
-0.1028670743,
0.1298283488,
0.1574553102,
-0.3587850034,
0.5213778615,
0.1810476035,
-0.5671765208,
-0.5895075202,
-0.668794632,
0.3381914496,
-0.7901026607,
0.9437512159,
-0.0025070203,
0.1508980095,
-0.1698349714,
0.0652466789,
0.2553935051,
-0.5632964969,
-0.2588053048,
-0.1662430912,
0.7270783782,
0.0963746682,
0.4392198026,
0.2795728743,
0.4663676322,
0.1156065837,
-0.4777081013,
-0.1300498992,
-0.5417920947,
-0.233471483,
-0.2343298346,
-0.5202493668,
-0.4313550293,
0.2392397672,
0.2899384201,
0.0607606992,
-0.0401884727,
0.3230937421,
0.0663563386,
0.3280092478,
-0.3051042855,
-0.5489057899,
-0.4666204453,
0.1912430972,
-0.4269444346,
-0.5456270576,
-0.4752384424,
0.2868220508,
-0.1318891495,
-0.6254060268,
0.4108798206,
-0.2821372747,
0.8221135736,
0.1083760634,
-0.656650722,
-0.312057972,
-0.8722704649,
0.772167027,
-0.4621574879,
0.0157030243,
0.237843141,
0.0318039879,
-0.5299825668,
-0.3992211521,
-0.7715352178,
0.2931938469,
0.4971964657,
0.2646939754,
-0.649859786,
-0.2961219847,
-0.0758742839,
0.4340811968,
-0.6573721766,
0.1296332181,
-0.4894137383,
-0.0289128199,
0.6451944709,
-0.2556912303,
0.4342900515,
-0.2261049896,
-0.7236391902,
0.1070715562,
-0.6409239173,
0.08886455,
0.4875586033,
-0.0777203664,
-0.3716907203,
0.3905141056,
-0.1271528155,
0.5909888744,
0.1336715072,
-0.1627632082,
0.1798906922,
-0.4579308033,
-0.3546471,
0.2191394269,
0.524032414,
0.3806549907,
-0.365727663,
0.0018377906,
0.1249768212,
0.4260692,
0.4270432889,
-0.5980597138,
0.2499346435,
0.2437638789,
-0.5224146247,
-0.3702152371,
0.1445254982,
-1.1147571802,
-0.2524795532,
-0.1287035048,
0.3206987679,
-0.0428924114,
-0.2015295625,
0.5562441349,
-0.6193988323,
0.140637666,
0.5623491406,
-0.2318573743,
0.3857497871,
0.7091332078,
0.4870699346,
0.1050701216,
0.4234895706,
-0.4602299631,
-0.0934417695,
-0.4316715002,
0.7994955778,
-0.5296689868,
-0.1234254912,
-0.1074133739,
0.0777263343,
0.0378598236,
-0.1241168082,
0.7723449469,
-0.4062379301,
0.6101328731,
-0.2771318257,
-0.4240988493,
-0.448544383,
0.5190922618,
-0.4409939647,
0.7260469794,
-0.2892390192,
-1.0356879234,
0.3904851973,
-0.2922227383,
-0.0705303475,
-0.1005341187,
-0.3139152825,
-0.4751486778,
0.3127316535,
0.3145710528,
0.1871820241,
-0.0696880966,
-0.0319368578,
-0.4752407968,
-0.1115169004,
-0.053306099,
-0.5288010836,
0.9024381638,
-0.0719733536,
-0.4228724241,
-0.14435862,
-0.794475615,
-0.6220945716,
0.0191345122,
-0.1008773595,
-0.7549344301,
0.0071542817,
0.0234678723,
0.8867874742,
-0.2599992752,
-0.8528034091,
0.2897029221,
-0.4003766775,
0.1660900265,
0.1499355882,
0.6611402035,
0.4106489718,
-0.3328561783,
0.6797478795,
0.1535109729,
0.5519429445,
-0.1602928042,
-0.7098160386,
-0.5766797662,
-0.1067880094,
-0.0449398123,
0.6116375327,
-0.804390192,
0.2879008353,
0.1311170906,
-0.7033194304,
-0.2695501447,
-0.1093452647,
-0.0742846429,
0.6707472205,
0.3365562856,
-0.1114694029,
-0.5889764428,
-0.7053225636,
-0.2965186238,
-0.0726189315,
0.0527956188,
-0.215105772,
0.5229552388,
-0.3055207729,
0.5952171087,
0.0428006761,
-0.311201185,
0.0416503325,
0.6932976246,
0.2850744426,
-0.0316137783,
0.7233641148,
-1.0223311186,
-0.2724882662,
-0.2022476494,
-0.2047655731,
0.0221527945,
-0.148016125,
0.2581624985,
0.34628883,
0.4428910017,
-0.3505504131,
0.73206985,
0.7921116948,
-0.7164693475,
0.3320540786,
-0.0017532513,
0.2989786565,
-1.2685834169,
0.033392407,
0.3221402764,
-0.2178368121,
-0.7675887346,
-0.1039851904,
-0.2590078413,
-0.1423390955,
-0.7389540672,
0.387449801,
-0.1643617898,
0.5504252911,
-0.2235961258,
-0.1085801795,
0.3727757335,
-0.2980898321,
0.2799481452,
0.2239854038,
0.557854712,
-0.6006597877,
0.2380434722,
0.3607899845,
-0.1653353423,
0.3699347973,
-0.4171459675,
-0.2222310752,
-0.3658538163,
0.5443019271,
-0.8467693329,
0.133455947,
0.3093256652,
-0.6033365726,
-0.2573138773,
0.0714594945,
-0.4666074812,
-0.6021119356,
-0.2088569999,
-0.2253205031,
0.1692825109,
-0.1586822122,
0.3560222685,
0.3674197197,
-0.2181342691,
-0.4477714896,
-0.8600466847,
0.3980204165,
-0.3190881014,
-0.5147881508,
0.4945346713,
0.2146714181,
-0.528319478,
0.0078260191,
-0.443921566,
-0.1491454691,
0.1158383712,
0.0322476923,
-0.2345287353,
-0.1976925284,
0.2777616382,
-0.1834449619,
-0.0482806526,
0.1079475954,
0.1110611111,
0.4700994492,
0.3417207301,
-0.1351172626,
-0.8085181713,
0.5359994769,
0.365336746,
-0.0826944634,
0.7065570354,
0.6644228101,
-0.3511433601,
-0.200313136,
-0.2521984875,
-0.3707093,
-0.2798572183,
0.0004160614,
0.4004203081,
-0.4362730384,
0.1306889057,
0.1671253592,
-0.0333176665,
0.8046486378,
0.4773157537,
-0.0099380035,
0.5027392507,
0.6921633482,
-0.0286929421,
0.261259973,
-0.1109182462,
0.3753734827,
0.0040618372,
-0.3562414348,
-0.7244973183,
-0.3304599524,
-0.4663384855,
-0.6725619435,
0.1017630696,
0.042657081,
0.2872290015,
0.1991291642,
-0.5314052105,
-0.0932722539,
0.4147475958,
-0.3281370997,
0.3040347993,
0.3443442881,
0.26664868,
0.1857176125,
-0.8067381382,
-0.6290513277,
0.5686286092,
0.5438497066,
0.7702043056,
-0.009599613,
0.7493698001,
0.4587926567,
0.1854232103,
-0.5493425727,
0.2500825822,
-0.1755476445,
-0.6397012472,
-0.0643892959,
0.0782526657,
-0.8678267598,
-0.0457858965,
-0.4245382547,
-0.5968057513,
0.8362647891,
-0.0181448665,
-0.5455724597,
0.2992223799,
-0.3180320263,
0.3301602304,
-0.1062681228,
-0.0992604047,
-0.610065937,
-0.2746884525,
0.0185020007,
0.0075021563,
0.4403489828,
-0.1843743026,
-0.1402783394,
0.6871784925,
-0.1158031076,
0.8503987193,
0.0450370684,
-0.2061857283,
0.3797154725,
-0.2230947912,
0.1131431758,
0.4384099543,
-0.0076360842,
0.4208089411,
0.1550852209,
-0.3840582371,
0.187845245,
0.4102818668,
-0.5574606061,
-0.6077019572,
-0.9167686701,
-0.1606996506,
0.3021787107,
0.0173186474,
0.3699346781,
0.2891677916,
-0.7356136441,
0.6052855849,
0.8102337122,
-0.3976765275,
0.7532113791,
0.6388619542,
-0.3003982604,
-0.3973854482,
0.1786650121,
0.4664580524,
0.0376119129,
0.7965236902,
0.2066389918,
-0.055504214,
-0.1214947626,
-0.2863634825,
-0.1653982252,
-0.1010435075,
-0.0513262488,
-0.8109028339,
-0.1355992407,
-0.4138121009,
0.0083878571,
-0.2714851797,
-0.1538873911,
-0.4640154243,
-0.1404326558,
0.3938281238,
0.7197564244,
-0.0346937031,
0.2555841804,
-0.5423982143,
0.6374794245,
0.1682814211,
0.0357912444,
-0.462223202,
-0.1371305436,
-0.254435271,
0.206600368,
-0.7163443565,
-1.0365499258,
0.5365935564,
-0.1385114789,
0.3999761343,
0.4197292626,
0.3403533995,
0.3086956143,
-0.3496524692,
1.004275918,
0.1113267317,
-0.8509139419,
0.4512072504,
-0.7059959769,
0.3332248032,
0.0623821542,
0.6060682535,
-0.7247347832,
-0.4545182586,
-0.9834899902,
-0.8395542502,
0.2318765521,
0.0711705536,
0.209834367,
-0.2020191401,
-0.1083653495,
0.3094305992,
0.2925919592,
-0.5947483182,
-0.2586845756,
-0.0144720851,
0.387249887,
-0.0993120819,
-0.4361459017,
-0.480812788,
-0.113991566,
0.6860355139,
0.2552012205,
0.1564945728,
0.6010818481,
0.0524206571,
-0.2565647066,
0.4631078541,
0.6356622577,
0.9368181229,
-0.0640232041,
0.0844242722,
-0.4723396003,
-0.4198347628,
0.1635256559,
0.2837277949,
-0.3986131251,
0.6364156604,
0.2783562839,
0.6142329574,
-0.1502259374,
-0.2099688649,
0.7906175852,
-0.1421547085,
-0.6515949965,
-0.4187759459,
-0.2620173395,
0.0670734867,
0.0280744601,
0.850163281,
0.1150608957,
0.2826497853,
-0.5836746693,
0.6337806582,
0.3586845696,
-0.4777070582,
-0.7015225291,
0.5337515473,
0.3207608163,
-0.0247773491,
0.0801035911,
0.0403833948,
0.1045997143,
0.8230906129,
0.3883061409,
0.4236739278,
-0.504824996,
0.8117278218,
0.1901265234,
0.5254591107,
0.0097240526,
0.4788202047,
0.3409684598,
-0.3529506624,
-0.5933798552,
-0.2850794196,
0.0521498732,
0.657019794,
-0.7183379531,
0.483389318,
-0.2275730371,
-0.2573142052,
0.1115240082,
0.0699638277,
-0.7388656139,
0.3042587638,
0.6964572072,
1.608810544,
-1.2543274164,
0.5485726595,
0.5497583747,
-0.2141004354,
-0.0804037303,
0.4754424095,
0.3771992922,
-0.255993396,
0.2317316532,
0.3674903512,
0.2549426556,
-0.4457094371,
-0.3517791629,
-0.7891110182,
0.8049842715,
0.3185607493,
-0.7910118699,
0.3055087924,
0.1677081585,
0.6016154885,
-0.2283958793,
-0.3577938974,
0.0245128907,
0.370847255,
-0.1562119275,
-0.6490146518,
-0.3449626267,
-0.2914652824,
-0.393099308,
0.2259757966,
-0.6351245046,
0.5051159263,
0.4976032674,
-0.2886041999,
-0.2639297843,
0.2998741865,
-0.3748251796,
0.7940981984,
0.193125546,
0.7333706021,
0.4853206873,
0.052677907,
1.1510221958,
-0.2166399211,
0.1102896482,
0.7856218815,
0.0998729244,
0.9361943603,
0.8993929625,
0.1444081366,
0.5111567974,
0.6159604192,
0.0906012431,
0.4602746069,
0.1729127467,
-0.3701724112,
-0.1604463607,
-0.1435811222,
-0.5039476156,
0.6232545376,
0.4818426371,
-0.4931349158,
-0.8096365333,
0.1897116154,
-0.0651100501,
0.2276265472,
-0.5920926929,
0.8732864857,
0.1324536055,
-0.2356920391,
0.3877499402,
0.0887570903,
0.4452198446,
-0.4347156286,
0.0015146239,
0.1459887624,
0.0539200827,
-0.1971155554,
-0.4968597293,
0.7337625623,
-0.2178957015,
-0.5014606118,
-0.3641768694,
0.6897768974,
-0.2786736488,
-0.502116859,
0.4407148063,
0.8056268692,
-0.2378300577,
-0.1826283783,
-0.8873526454,
-0.0098111257,
-0.2196972966,
-0.4929943979,
0.3581098318,
0.49069345,
-0.2455771863,
0.1274676621,
0.5028592944,
0.0960758999,
0.029766608,
-0.2061405927,
0.700745523,
-0.3801986575,
-0.4655551016,
-0.9847949743,
0.4560774565,
-0.2205085754,
-0.2929419577,
1.1627225876,
0.5219498873,
0.5597276688,
-0.0581175722,
0.8331215382,
-0.0936495289,
0.4497185051,
-0.0917874575,
0.7424166203,
-0.4444413185,
-0.408539474,
-0.0921548903,
-0.4559732974,
-0.6689102054,
0.0982627496,
-0.5584706664,
-0.6494823694,
0.3494765162,
0.6462743878,
0.1265054047,
-0.067959398,
0.2393731624,
0.3381174803,
0.3089632392,
-0.1974919885,
0.4228092134,
-0.2881624401,
0.3454713225,
-0.241025582,
-0.245296672,
-0.4428080618,
-1.0695824623,
-0.718672812,
-0.5817923546,
-0.3069077134,
-0.536272347,
0.2925570607,
0.8011029959,
0.4703522325,
-0.6783348322,
0.2240219861,
-0.2158613652,
0.1059619561,
-0.4594176114,
-0.1934078038,
0.3261410594,
-0.032883402,
-0.7104817629,
0.2072014809,
0.6568382382,
-0.0447491817,
-0.3609901667,
0.4436152577,
-0.5651483536,
0.4999527335,
0.6490690112,
0.3450248241,
-0.6256940365,
0.1376870424,
0.0318425074,
-0.153248176,
0.0382146761,
0.3794920743,
-0.7765285969,
0.49860847,
0.7124209404,
0.5447439551,
0.1569319218,
-0.165387094,
0.7716494799,
-0.6510426998,
0.4246834815,
0.3008103073,
0.0852661207,
0.3269287944,
-0.4243953824,
0.0630599335,
0.4472075105,
-0.2917389572,
-0.6168892384,
0.0783388391,
-0.715579927,
-0.3184177279,
1.4584496021,
0.3654785156,
-0.6915863752,
-0.3294707835,
-0.1558140218,
0.0167347174,
-0.5135257244,
1.0787286758,
0.8988096714,
0.0021574292,
-0.1386983395,
-0.5863822103,
0.5047190785,
0.0937644392,
-0.572876215,
-0.5390215516,
0.1325388998,
0.1309698969,
0.3656311035,
0.5394325256,
-0.2316681743,
0.1689608991,
0.0582434684,
0.1749081314,
0.2334564179,
-0.3864119053,
-0.4421372414,
0.1527669579,
-0.3661594987,
-0.2458494306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00118v2 | Speak, Memory: An Archaeology of Books Known to ChatGPT/GPT-4 | 2023-04-28T22:35:03 | 2023-10-20T21:23:21 | Kent K. Chang, Mackenzie Cramer, Sandeep Soni, David Bamman | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we carry out a data archaeology to infer books that are known
to ChatGPT and GPT-4 using a name cloze membership inference query. We find
that OpenAI models have memorized a wide collection of copyrighted materials,
and that the degree of memorization is tied to the frequency with which
passages of those books appear on the web. The ability of these models to
memorize an unknown set of books complicates assessments of measurement
validity for cultural analytics by contaminating test data; we show that models
perform much better on memorized books than on non-memorized books for
downstream tasks. We argue that this supports a case for open models whose
training data is known. | [
-0.1796419919,
-0.3174186051,
0.3408079743,
-0.6675696969,
-0.2283576131,
-0.3849380016,
-0.221941337,
-0.5658693314,
-0.1372842044,
0.5877821445,
-0.4842496216,
-0.418101579,
-0.3407366574,
-0.2640088201,
-0.4264965355,
0.9733144045,
0.0094972365,
0.2070387453,
-0.3509660661,
-0.7399110198,
-0.3434920311,
-0.679604888,
-0.5457559228,
-0.4740795493,
0.0642495453,
0.1129339039,
0.7753295898,
0.6523371935,
0.1711947024,
0.2130168378,
-0.0500636287,
0.1172137633,
-0.8005635738,
0.0133266151,
-0.2609406114,
-0.9164299965,
-0.39316836,
0.1638466716,
0.4444150031,
0.4784072638,
-0.146006763,
0.4960117042,
-0.1186980307,
0.6112223268,
-0.552136302,
0.2758963704,
-0.7631294727,
0.0021095218,
-0.2462977022,
-0.3057686985,
-0.6200986505,
-0.4828881919,
0.524199605,
-0.811034143,
0.593585372,
-0.0174822845,
0.869377017,
0.0966167226,
-0.0760719553,
-0.8160886765,
-0.9921042323,
0.9131168127,
-0.6112543941,
0.4097815454,
1.0832043886,
0.2995958328,
0.0248498488,
-0.9418185949,
-0.7480607033,
-0.1052499935,
-0.2205972821,
0.3101090193,
-0.0046124295,
-0.2550518513,
0.324311167,
0.7122817039,
-0.5686047077,
-0.3347439766,
-0.6301686168,
-0.2236498892,
0.4102497399,
-0.0124938311,
0.7258841991,
0.2163929343,
-0.4764761329,
-0.1640765667,
-0.784399569,
-0.2567024827,
0.3958964944,
-0.0684914365,
0.2240325212,
0.3337433934,
-0.0055043101,
0.5610892177,
-0.4855215549,
-0.2345868051,
0.040392749,
-0.1362149566,
-0.1926924288,
0.0549948812,
0.3343303204,
0.3805014491,
0.7874885201,
-0.4063823521,
0.3219425678,
0.0676464885,
0.1289951652,
-0.804051578,
-0.7688015103,
0.1140202209,
-0.6655924916,
0.4267148972,
-0.2124835104,
-0.568842411,
-0.5239539742,
-0.3716278672,
0.6006023288,
-0.8092439771,
-0.3822723627,
0.1126815155,
-0.5968892574,
0.1563840359,
0.2028429657,
-1.0345584154,
0.2898466289,
0.5960325003,
0.901612699,
0.2953106165,
-0.3796046972,
-0.0642411187,
0.571071744,
-0.3370019495,
0.5638954639,
-0.5481482148,
-0.5705980062,
0.0202897247,
-0.0494990349,
-0.2100449502,
-0.5607598424,
0.5336244106,
-0.5943391919,
0.2994354963,
-0.4042313397,
-0.9471581578,
-0.585811317,
0.3850609064,
-0.8826715946,
0.8248925209,
0.2055386454,
-0.5996448398,
0.4955039918,
-0.3079225421,
0.1651872694,
0.2890882194,
-0.223301217,
-0.1420502663,
-0.2237464786,
0.0038470454,
0.2429157794,
-0.0770232975,
0.0184659995,
-0.4544160366,
-0.3399991393,
0.056800358,
-0.2147980183,
0.7234830856,
0.3009110093,
-0.081924744,
-0.4364925921,
-0.6750993133,
-0.0519971028,
0.0868907347,
-0.3407491148,
-0.962192595,
0.3401885331,
-0.5270982981,
-0.419734627,
0.0565287396,
-0.5414770246,
0.4079636633,
-0.1597461253,
0.4222516119,
0.584821105,
0.0083294436,
0.3901578188,
-0.7100285888,
0.2815340161,
0.1514241844,
-0.0713898614,
-0.4507553279,
-0.6059591174,
-0.6084674597,
-0.1877943128,
0.2245136797,
0.4671612382,
-0.4413017929,
-0.5540523529,
-0.637878418,
-0.8165237904,
-0.2810521126,
0.0125744045,
0.2417832315,
0.3187172115,
0.2478928417,
-0.4707148373,
-0.1430396736,
-0.5502508879,
-0.4806282222,
-0.4008648396,
-0.159623757,
0.7422730923,
0.4601487815,
0.1707567424,
0.8114717603,
-0.3819680214,
-0.3594848514,
0.2581604719,
0.1650462598,
0.1487638205,
0.3803266585,
0.742628336,
-0.7656163573,
-0.3523234129,
0.1653148532,
-0.8024560213,
0.3723323643,
-0.0847141668,
-0.2120088786,
-0.0031422474,
0.3836689591,
-0.6205741167,
0.6065170765,
0.310431093,
-0.3423269689,
0.3613616526,
-0.087070778,
0.0822867304,
-0.9016063809,
0.1276581138,
-0.498834461,
-0.0615408495,
-0.6150727868,
-0.1277792007,
0.0708560422,
-0.1401140541,
-0.2642970681,
0.8224066496,
-0.8470802903,
-0.0477298908,
0.0420891345,
0.3389668167,
-0.2375503629,
0.4225570858,
0.4121490419,
0.7130942941,
0.4967021346,
-0.9117192626,
0.0350784697,
0.7809563875,
-0.6908966303,
0.5533658862,
-0.0026659663,
0.3902717531,
-0.1013614237,
0.1345998496,
-0.6722406745,
-0.1751205027,
0.1079077348,
-0.6473680139,
0.2986254394,
-0.5949778557,
-0.2220795453,
-0.1442332715,
0.0016598285,
0.5156514645,
0.5043854713,
-0.7106837034,
0.7344199419,
0.3443425298,
-0.0612180419,
-0.6808952689,
-0.6097098589,
-0.3533168137,
-0.4857235551,
-0.6072019339,
-0.0340950117,
-0.3786105514,
-0.2370065451,
-0.1061906815,
-0.2531184852,
-0.4441746175,
-0.101022549,
0.396791935,
-0.0336376727,
-0.540753901,
0.3752678931,
-0.5648981929,
0.4004715085,
-0.0878963768,
-0.3487360179,
0.6010175943,
0.0231027305,
-0.4460017085,
-0.1866214424,
-0.0409406684,
0.6451042891,
-0.2021622211,
0.8625919223,
0.3632507622,
-0.4832634032,
-0.380941838,
-0.6383963823,
-0.1574207246,
-0.4538794756,
-0.0585619621,
-0.3443941176,
-0.5821883678,
0.8316028118,
-0.0900515839,
0.1563636661,
0.1207822561,
0.3671524227,
0.1697803885,
0.1587423235,
0.1973295808,
-0.3575523496,
0.2994450033,
-0.3153233826,
0.1204624623,
-0.5840791464,
-0.153198421,
-0.4958783686,
-0.4077530503,
-0.4698442221,
-0.194543004,
0.1728268564,
0.2628831565,
-0.2194093019,
0.2186996937,
-0.2396413535,
0.7733932137,
0.8150641918,
0.2889607251,
0.6244097948,
-0.1058649942,
0.4223721921,
0.1943777204,
-0.431723088,
-0.8684757352,
1.2509410381,
0.2309239358,
0.4471201003,
0.4358852208,
0.5438392162,
0.2490951866,
0.431717664,
-0.6182360649,
0.4223503172,
-0.0360786133,
-1.0971702337,
-0.2950160801,
-0.010923665,
-0.9794418216,
0.1998277456,
0.2731072307,
-0.9969997406,
0.4466928542,
0.3564761579,
-0.3449092209,
0.6753041148,
-0.7202981114,
0.8862153292,
0.0681080446,
-0.1142974496,
-0.2945605218,
-0.3948900104,
0.5418384671,
0.1224960908,
0.1274864674,
-0.0923693106,
0.171298936,
0.9007481933,
-0.2610774636,
0.9190545082,
-0.1531087458,
0.2514756918,
0.8154607415,
0.6756475568,
0.4003352523,
-0.1031279266,
-0.3699330688,
0.0748458877,
0.5469982624,
-0.4703599811,
-0.3546830714,
0.4843840003,
-0.6798526049,
-0.3802101016,
-0.4208719134,
-0.4820729494,
-0.1587726921,
0.4033573568,
0.1890849918,
0.5606510043,
-0.5933984518,
0.3229042888,
0.8016896248,
-0.1276649982,
0.4909255207,
0.6952341795,
0.2871378064,
-0.0534306392,
0.8818745613,
0.2887974977,
0.4501704872,
0.1310402453,
0.1639154255,
0.0743596554,
-0.91122365,
-0.4030671716,
0.2617299855,
-0.8647613525,
0.0061683841,
-0.51455158,
-0.0125554269,
-0.2544789314,
0.1347081959,
-0.0795403197,
-0.4271193743,
-0.3039729893,
-0.3190901875,
0.4142711163,
0.6802304983,
0.1236549988,
0.6377062201,
-0.9076457024,
0.1131050587,
0.0381519571,
0.3106041551,
0.0802694783,
-0.4788460732,
-0.1687698513,
-0.0103138257,
-0.4289233088,
-0.9271994233,
0.4021513164,
0.5258938074,
0.5910767913,
0.6280932426,
0.1920677274,
0.5333409309,
-0.4844752848,
0.9401977062,
-0.3674903214,
-0.6287753582,
0.2692375779,
-0.8161327243,
-0.0441198274,
0.5419672132,
0.7290549874,
-0.6082813144,
-0.2837593257,
-0.9806257486,
-0.5531878471,
0.8240714669,
0.0671475977,
0.3044048548,
-0.1885833591,
0.4455226362,
0.1440708488,
0.2677692175,
-0.8444357514,
0.0261961296,
-0.3436625004,
-0.1226439402,
0.0990761071,
-0.5214700699,
-0.131990537,
0.0706844628,
0.6720748544,
0.1319583952,
0.1615782678,
0.2468814552,
-0.3537645936,
0.1756544262,
0.0839679465,
0.5091350675,
1.0195925236,
-0.2680151463,
-0.0541406535,
0.1814787686,
-0.9453416467,
-0.2725536823,
-0.3904952109,
-0.2969134152,
0.0298251584,
0.4021445513,
0.8088960648,
0.0727418065,
-0.5322629809,
0.4115887284,
0.1284821928,
-0.0624695867,
-1.0205886364,
0.2412929833,
0.232989192,
0.3041891158,
-0.0778571293,
-0.1719096154,
-0.0298389327,
-0.8359954357,
0.2552009821,
0.3576299846,
-0.2200698853,
-0.364269048,
0.6122865081,
-0.1629880518,
-0.2060228884,
1.1249508858,
0.2140341401,
-0.4355761409,
0.4453920126,
0.4183134437,
0.4520610571,
-0.4959002435,
0.0673179254,
0.8228788972,
0.3352510333,
-0.3435977101,
0.1943918467,
-0.2664013207,
-0.827403605,
0.1621547937,
-0.7236883044,
-0.5014667511,
0.2458666116,
-0.6424360275,
0.1085487977,
-0.3640226424,
-0.025605116,
-0.1214429364,
-0.276270479,
-0.7677750587,
0.3550933301,
0.2078281492,
0.9122803211,
-0.7138540149,
0.9318277836,
0.1100758016,
-0.5870811939,
-0.7761076093,
-0.21283108,
0.0712169036,
-0.8669934273,
0.6120713353,
0.0523770116,
0.1927397102,
0.3214695454,
-0.4176275432,
-0.7411008477,
1.4678655863,
0.0965194032,
-0.1945447773,
-0.1231675074,
-0.0281575266,
0.4724763632,
0.0179733429,
0.595697999,
0.7479857802,
0.4266103804,
-0.1366035491,
-0.9523890615,
-0.2522783875,
-0.0474771485,
-0.4779013097,
0.3692015707,
-0.6684360504,
0.7740278244,
-0.0317772254,
-0.6343944669,
0.4571913779,
0.7997168303,
0.0108904317,
0.6763849854,
0.1123092845,
0.7411544323,
1.3315367699,
-0.1508189291,
1.2008622885,
-0.0513751544,
0.1076136753,
1.3252869844,
-0.159145385,
0.8224377036,
0.1180469543,
-0.211262852,
0.502094388,
0.5916926861,
-0.2510941625,
0.3486533463,
0.1577969342,
-0.5277423859,
0.0712493211,
0.0394864269,
-0.3796390295,
0.3981916606,
0.4612503946,
-0.4327740073,
-0.1222132519,
-0.1707998812,
0.344047457,
-0.0206404645,
-0.2765112817,
0.7989378572,
0.1600566357,
-0.9293290377,
0.4629785419,
-0.5310609937,
0.0994903818,
-0.7627417445,
0.0792382509,
-0.4709071815,
0.5011796355,
-0.0554264709,
-0.4061437845,
0.2312353253,
-0.4026280642,
-0.2655204535,
0.0116135748,
0.4842701256,
-0.4573104084,
0.1641885638,
0.0650224239,
0.3504244685,
0.8257453442,
-0.0910432115,
-0.078088887,
-0.2956302166,
0.0596183538,
-0.4864112139,
0.4418826699,
0.5185689926,
-0.3645415008,
0.8129166961,
0.5575990081,
-0.0247814059,
0.4129788578,
-0.0983383879,
0.2888959944,
-0.698030293,
-0.3713784814,
-0.9522918463,
0.3066785634,
-0.002843054,
-0.406974107,
0.8982001543,
0.707590878,
1.2045202255,
-0.3358239233,
0.7390357852,
0.1113954708,
0.7202969193,
-0.6662177444,
0.990999341,
-0.2437509745,
0.0031963917,
0.0716503933,
-0.7213757038,
0.1894656867,
0.2230914533,
-0.230319798,
-0.1396850497,
0.8026139736,
0.6563933492,
-0.4167355597,
0.6313250661,
0.3208765388,
0.1793929338,
0.2378919721,
0.492962718,
0.6465499997,
-0.4399937689,
0.7831351161,
-0.0595442578,
-0.1682715118,
0.2661470473,
-0.7506729364,
-1.0965719223,
-0.8190353513,
-0.2442341149,
-0.2380096018,
-0.0647426173,
0.3021052778,
0.540422678,
-0.7704655528,
-0.3084105849,
0.38710922,
-0.1949124634,
-0.2405952066,
-0.1223913878,
0.599137485,
-0.0024569207,
-0.8316258788,
0.4811539352,
-0.3595896959,
0.2241465598,
0.0850558877,
-0.1225599349,
-0.1112784296,
0.2207143903,
0.2852535546,
0.6980858445,
-0.6459638476,
-0.2567367852,
-0.3361169696,
0.3563795984,
0.0387546532,
1.1344252825,
-0.7095443606,
0.7374121547,
0.612354219,
0.5639825463,
0.8728064895,
0.2549829483,
0.5547590852,
-0.5213115811,
0.2985946238,
0.2562913001,
0.5049628615,
0.3443697691,
-0.2089449465,
0.8909656405,
0.3447922468,
-0.867200017,
-0.7985543013,
0.284873724,
-0.8523496389,
-0.314301461,
0.9590408802,
-0.5360880494,
-0.3168279231,
-0.2301492393,
-0.0322387405,
0.3507989049,
0.0993956253,
0.6053628325,
1.2438770533,
0.1922840029,
-0.0702089667,
-1.2856248617,
0.7441108823,
0.303535372,
-0.4242293537,
0.2289360017,
0.8191410899,
0.5077014565,
0.3079035282,
0.9540896416,
-0.2975293696,
0.0627781525,
0.0740879774,
-0.0455819182,
-0.1835621297,
-0.0983496606,
0.3181088865,
0.1579895765,
0.119104296,
-0.4104502499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00090v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00090v1 | NLNDE at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Adaptive Pretraining and Source Language Selection for Low-Resource Multilingual Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-28T21:02:58 | 2023-04-28T21:02:58 | Mingyang Wang, Heike Adel, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes our system developed for the SemEval-2023 Task 12
"Sentiment Analysis for Low-resource African Languages using Twitter Dataset".
Sentiment analysis is one of the most widely studied applications in natural
language processing. However, most prior work still focuses on a small number
of high-resource languages. Building reliable sentiment analysis systems for
low-resource languages remains challenging, due to the limited training data in
this task. In this work, we propose to leverage language-adaptive and
task-adaptive pretraining on African texts and study transfer learning with
source language selection on top of an African language-centric pretrained
language model. Our key findings are: (1) Adapting the pretrained model to the
target language and task using a small yet relevant corpus improves performance
remarkably by more than 10 F1 score points. (2) Selecting source languages with
positive transfer gains during training can avoid harmful interference from
dissimilar languages, leading to better results in multilingual and
cross-lingual settings. In the shared task, our system wins 8 out of 15 tracks
and, in particular, performs best in the multilingual evaluation. | [
-0.5993978381,
-0.1791579723,
0.3200184703,
0.6725198627,
-0.5358900428,
0.175197944,
-0.5295345187,
-0.5036127567,
0.5884425044,
0.4066898823,
-0.6077384949,
-0.2873094082,
-0.919672966,
0.3574066162,
0.0142457178,
1.1444400549,
-0.2439982742,
0.1159844548,
0.0660300404,
-0.716006279,
-0.3981998563,
-0.6675448418,
-0.6584530473,
-0.0634512827,
0.749684155,
0.4849734902,
0.305688858,
-0.3387436271,
0.5233033299,
0.241237849,
0.2471085191,
0.1119469628,
-0.4561842084,
0.0866887793,
-0.5201993585,
-0.1120083928,
-0.4964441359,
0.0151467957,
0.1664854735,
0.5885793567,
0.1211084202,
0.3070270717,
0.4214816093,
0.6909092665,
-0.7051529288,
-0.1102371439,
-0.5323459506,
-0.1950007528,
-0.1747485846,
-0.1802621484,
-0.2624558806,
-0.397805959,
0.1937672049,
-0.3991742134,
-0.0452748053,
-0.3360551298,
0.7731185555,
0.1776081771,
-0.3176321983,
-0.4299407601,
-0.3150576651,
1.001547575,
-0.5794557333,
0.0804932192,
0.3122906089,
0.3379121423,
0.5409696698,
-0.5989456773,
-0.1775813252,
0.0803110451,
0.1382135898,
0.3188305795,
-0.0119851036,
-0.326685369,
-0.072914362,
0.052404996,
-0.1988740712,
-0.0839323774,
-0.287442416,
-0.3135060966,
0.6221725941,
-0.3963982463,
0.1524408162,
-0.2151548564,
-0.2809163928,
-0.0876163542,
-0.3934319913,
-0.1420538723,
0.3762389719,
0.7978187799,
-0.2298185229,
0.0857211202,
-0.0737975538,
0.5488835573,
-0.24632743,
0.2979429364,
0.6567432284,
-0.2365895659,
-0.1400307417,
0.2046353817,
1.0291501284,
0.2469041944,
0.4447965026,
0.0625644773,
-0.3385620713,
0.0707826465,
0.4855275154,
-0.752984345,
-0.1396312565,
-0.1622929722,
-0.4746389687,
-0.3443858624,
-0.3150101602,
-1.0491566658,
-0.4784209728,
-0.2359028459,
0.8134037852,
-0.422442466,
-0.2406036556,
-0.0291632116,
0.2241674364,
-0.0370670222,
0.5591414571,
-0.6941523552,
0.0914250016,
0.0672069341,
0.9270910621,
-0.3229798973,
-0.4781627357,
-0.4678288698,
-0.3052656949,
-0.1595815122,
0.7087804675,
-0.4526258409,
-0.4327511489,
0.0298281275,
0.2263682932,
-0.2224380374,
-0.3998170793,
0.7526245117,
-0.5079659224,
0.1231599897,
-0.7064902782,
-0.0802528858,
-0.3241000772,
0.2202751637,
-0.7767284513,
1.0661301613,
0.3891116679,
-0.6649746299,
0.235797897,
-0.8110816479,
-0.8772386909,
-0.2813054919,
0.2184482068,
-0.1689562052,
0.2499981225,
0.4365118146,
0.470736891,
-0.2478544414,
-0.1367512941,
-0.3079109788,
-0.1768158674,
0.0107646929,
-0.284357816,
0.9295857549,
0.4567831457,
-0.5902591944,
-0.0750596002,
-0.7536016703,
-0.0480318777,
0.0261875857,
-0.150229454,
-0.4323738515,
-0.2398307174,
0.1295879483,
0.4089338779,
0.3450733423,
-0.5414431691,
-0.0817477256,
-0.1738288701,
0.1924410611,
0.7622883916,
0.0388333574,
0.6789001822,
0.0744530261,
0.8053660393,
0.0572850481,
-0.0714492723,
0.084541291,
0.008260387,
-0.9616802335,
0.1473827809,
0.5106916428,
0.5503110886,
-1.1640723944,
0.1008628309,
-0.2566948533,
-0.3818144202,
-0.8051996231,
0.3524067104,
-0.0853154808,
0.3268352449,
0.5694537163,
-0.3510104418,
-0.7894331813,
-0.707734108,
-0.4300419688,
-0.0300308373,
0.3388828933,
0.113280043,
0.3511864841,
-0.321747303,
0.4222807288,
-0.0430520736,
-0.4281518757,
-0.5531797409,
0.325173229,
0.2868527472,
0.3010953367,
1.0744953156,
-0.5068482161,
-0.6680349112,
0.0463888794,
-0.6899372935,
-0.362688452,
-0.0596425571,
-0.4406431913,
0.2957586944,
0.5285333991,
0.0991896167,
0.0280803647,
0.9526870251,
-0.188902393,
0.1758864373,
0.1413681209,
0.3716298342,
-1.3196491003,
-0.0002067432,
-0.0245070327,
-0.4402643144,
-0.4214426577,
-0.3819236159,
-0.0917987078,
-0.0998127684,
-0.5718675256,
0.6598882079,
-0.3613463342,
-0.0140939727,
-0.6162400842,
0.0141654452,
-0.0443781726,
0.4085584283,
0.1293821633,
0.8766476512,
0.4354016185,
-0.5594339371,
0.1280222535,
0.1742764711,
-0.4537833035,
0.708011508,
-0.3153095841,
0.2023770809,
0.074967511,
-0.1478351057,
-0.6333363056,
0.0480443351,
0.0881385803,
-0.5894378424,
0.1311520338,
0.0242729131,
0.0322223417,
-0.1248974055,
-0.1345664859,
0.2528980672,
0.2833480537,
-0.5474125147,
0.7607268691,
0.4795300961,
-0.536097765,
-0.7090409994,
-0.8983921409,
0.087063022,
-0.0256172847,
-0.3902950883,
0.0245654844,
0.1553895473,
-0.0283076856,
0.0501669869,
-0.0658913255,
-0.0339503661,
0.2825437784,
0.0123075889,
0.1935594082,
-0.2023128122,
-0.0292291567,
0.0165915955,
-0.0009560151,
0.0883479863,
-0.297139287,
0.5018659234,
-0.2613162696,
-0.0763280764,
0.1450544745,
0.2611735463,
0.3489509821,
-0.2790196836,
1.0070476532,
0.9643540382,
-0.1362836361,
-0.3770389557,
-0.3934543431,
0.0269803572,
-0.4302095175,
0.4097318947,
-0.4023061693,
-1.1514410973,
0.3692313135,
-0.1113374606,
0.0413354896,
0.5045018196,
0.7508715987,
-0.3120417893,
0.676312387,
0.7449814677,
-0.4226884842,
0.684687078,
-0.1212558597,
0.1440803856,
-0.6743960381,
0.2224145383,
-0.6429846883,
-0.5338022709,
-0.6383254528,
-0.3882880807,
0.1342524588,
0.0136802504,
-0.1901229173,
0.4143795669,
-0.0666512027,
0.2041426897,
0.465691328,
0.0202870779,
-0.224247843,
0.1812292188,
-0.2064031512,
-0.0914695486,
-0.5823088884,
-0.560906589,
0.9204183817,
-0.0012423216,
0.6091402173,
0.0599201359,
0.9247333407,
0.4976611137,
0.541287601,
-0.6584759355,
0.4928462207,
-0.4555009007,
-0.3694488406,
-0.2472357303,
-0.3821337223,
-0.7108188868,
0.2729265094,
-0.1276749969,
-0.4038250148,
0.4160810113,
-0.0952837095,
-0.3196281195,
0.033428371,
-0.5504331589,
0.9847954512,
-0.3412460387,
-0.3828310966,
-0.1216884106,
-0.470612824,
-0.0245072357,
-0.35014835,
0.5717464685,
-0.2744691968,
0.1082311124,
0.9074267149,
-0.3380750716,
0.6917889118,
-0.5921486616,
-0.0024800512,
0.3848748207,
0.0982083529,
0.4102216363,
0.0258083027,
-0.5640509725,
0.147537455,
-0.1445469111,
-0.6069159508,
-0.3267827928,
0.7189326286,
-1.1043299437,
-0.2687101662,
-0.553827405,
-0.1599212438,
-0.6641373038,
0.2052645832,
0.4293784499,
0.1035572439,
-0.406627655,
0.3361266255,
0.2308506072,
-0.377655834,
0.6034685373,
0.3373021483,
0.0009294816,
-0.5436146855,
1.0358259678,
-0.0155670317,
0.2326598614,
0.2201654315,
0.0167300757,
-0.2751164138,
-0.4255869091,
-0.4455991983,
0.000446157,
-0.8143242002,
-0.3680489957,
-0.7054969072,
-0.1521331668,
-0.3471495211,
-0.3787789345,
-0.5521697998,
-0.3686190844,
-0.3093456626,
-0.1873193532,
0.2114947885,
0.2549193501,
-0.2891456783,
0.5208291411,
-1.06790483,
0.1886967421,
0.3056898117,
0.2182837874,
-0.195412606,
-0.7829073071,
-0.5245005488,
0.002310266,
-0.0892430395,
-0.7517098188,
0.5507211685,
0.3547635376,
0.47823295,
-0.1552985609,
0.1573729664,
0.5899419785,
-0.3366734385,
0.6847071052,
0.2811767161,
-1.0241214037,
0.681489706,
-0.1857345402,
0.305285275,
1.3416861296,
0.5308690071,
-0.5248279572,
-0.0853329971,
-0.3122849762,
-0.7086693645,
0.9438546896,
0.0920754522,
0.2953313887,
0.0351455957,
0.0480340011,
0.2404312789,
0.1645372808,
-0.8869755864,
0.0201490894,
-0.6236504912,
-0.4592155814,
-0.4120271802,
-0.3086275756,
0.0157430209,
-0.0658121482,
1.0130085945,
-0.3755941093,
0.2526052296,
0.1051391363,
-0.6459306479,
-0.0755098686,
0.4199661016,
0.1830737293,
0.5292294621,
-0.1623848826,
-0.027035201,
0.4336762428,
-0.6263734102,
0.4360625446,
0.2487118244,
-0.1389326453,
0.036451295,
0.3998933136,
1.2095845938,
0.1267762929,
-0.3294295669,
0.645478487,
-0.2054543942,
-0.2321769595,
-0.05221086,
-0.2816873789,
0.0586507097,
0.0952486694,
0.2503339648,
0.550330162,
-0.0668008178,
-0.5168992877,
0.0101418691,
0.0854072496,
-0.779389143,
-0.5580047965,
0.4037979543,
0.6657193303,
0.2272888869,
0.3233251572,
-0.3012657166,
-0.6866927743,
0.2661194503,
0.273525089,
1.0056600571,
-0.4397239685,
0.4632747173,
0.4678548872,
0.5085662603,
-0.1035546362,
0.67273283,
0.2809750438,
-1.0339026451,
-0.7755404115,
-1.101982832,
-0.2650182843,
0.0344672352,
-0.7897678614,
0.3977054656,
-0.2992637455,
-0.2188670486,
-0.241021961,
0.1510717869,
-0.920814991,
0.5777905583,
0.2569114268,
0.8405712843,
-1.0130851269,
0.9455037117,
1.0327486992,
-0.2185586095,
-0.7861558199,
-0.2050183564,
-0.0862712264,
-0.7408781052,
0.4937022924,
0.0817381293,
-0.2223304063,
0.040140599,
-0.320219934,
-0.7761195898,
0.74440974,
0.5911755562,
-0.5115544796,
0.3194929957,
0.0287763011,
0.5252539515,
-0.4105129838,
0.1431253403,
0.5572632551,
0.4223869741,
0.1923869699,
-0.7328547239,
-0.1624359041,
-0.2581371665,
-0.2130860984,
0.2109045237,
-0.6825461984,
0.6373860836,
0.0785871446,
-0.0744642615,
-0.1477196366,
0.9293147922,
-0.0308747608,
0.100241147,
0.6398813128,
0.4250645638,
0.6074916124,
-0.1702421606,
0.9610168934,
-0.4413689077,
0.1492740065,
1.2231881618,
-0.5136495233,
0.8300450444,
0.4179878831,
-0.207186088,
0.5994688869,
0.6666050553,
0.4606832266,
0.7088989615,
-0.2777638733,
-0.3166123033,
-0.2992606163,
-0.2560189068,
-0.3460404873,
0.5422049165,
0.2199581265,
-0.1921959519,
-0.1855597347,
0.4303758144,
-0.0953594372,
0.0797500089,
-0.55794245,
0.6668919921,
0.3330601454,
-0.6452974081,
0.2750591636,
-0.1435738206,
0.8204615116,
-0.7092096806,
0.3798381984,
-0.3677966595,
0.2016964853,
-0.1153513566,
-0.6061215401,
0.470931679,
0.1735138297,
0.0158042964,
-0.4608989358,
0.981000483,
-0.2640228868,
-0.7101749182,
0.6872243285,
0.7930067778,
-0.1683279425,
-0.2222946584,
-0.7783337831,
0.2853269279,
0.285899967,
-0.3317607343,
0.5245358348,
0.7722041607,
-0.1087992489,
0.1136000082,
0.5214625597,
0.4322501123,
-0.0895686969,
0.6203171611,
0.775552392,
-0.6463778019,
-0.6379445195,
-0.6880009174,
0.178069979,
-0.1134542525,
-0.2175916582,
0.8626487255,
0.2125068456,
0.9828988314,
-0.172727257,
1.2290500402,
-0.285703361,
0.7460036278,
-0.3867736459,
0.5924675465,
-0.6578321457,
0.035567224,
-0.5173588395,
-1.2591487169,
0.0282940716,
0.7417103052,
-0.4133645296,
0.0103446022,
0.7362480164,
0.4655158818,
0.0324137472,
0.0612690672,
0.1299687922,
0.0395500958,
0.1154367402,
0.451336652,
0.9071303606,
-0.350177139,
0.6310963631,
-0.376799196,
-0.0741471872,
-0.1782199591,
-1.0213648081,
-0.8044298887,
-0.4651215971,
-0.1633230299,
-0.468296349,
0.0143667962,
1.0946244001,
0.4999527335,
-1.2004362345,
-0.264303267,
0.2744491696,
-0.2240919322,
-0.1435071826,
-0.1910473853,
0.282771647,
-0.7134450078,
-0.5954295397,
0.4046143293,
0.3623445332,
-0.0804895684,
0.1444668919,
-0.2348916978,
-0.4367517233,
-0.0348892808,
0.7853237987,
0.2152995318,
-0.0375303105,
-0.3664004505,
-0.0523593649,
-0.2343470007,
-0.0742107034,
0.8898203373,
-0.6528007984,
0.4329632223,
0.4172409773,
1.0645196438,
0.4426852465,
-0.0315732844,
0.6325573325,
-0.7793061137,
0.3873226047,
0.4637350738,
0.4650016129,
0.5158289075,
0.0386682823,
0.7452481389,
0.1592074335,
-0.4151291251,
-0.5313703418,
-0.1089325398,
-0.9309263825,
-0.2346496731,
1.0639580488,
-0.1624574959,
-0.3770611286,
0.0486150123,
-0.1704807281,
0.272212863,
-0.3222777843,
0.528804183,
0.8787934184,
0.1829899251,
-0.197655037,
-0.5120882988,
0.5833050013,
0.6528016329,
-0.9151887298,
-0.3150979877,
0.2845174074,
0.0835709572,
0.0984772071,
0.8585142493,
0.0366342328,
0.3392495215,
-0.2965656519,
0.1745426655,
0.2584889233,
-0.2455650121,
-0.4395914078,
0.0413535237,
0.1464060098,
-0.1486779004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00076v1 | HausaNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 10: Transfer Learning, Synthetic Data and Side-Information for Multi-Level Sexism Classification | 2023-04-28T20:03:46 | 2023-04-28T20:03:46 | Saminu Mohammad Aliyu, Idris Abdulmumin, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Saheed Abdullahi Salahudeen, Aliyu Yusuf, Falalu Ibrahim Lawan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the findings of our participation in the SemEval-2023 Task 10:
Explainable Detection of Online Sexism (EDOS) task, a shared task on offensive
language (sexism) detection on English Gab and Reddit dataset. We investigated
the effects of transferring two language models: XLM-T (sentiment
classification) and HateBERT (same domain -- Reddit) for multi-level
classification into Sexist or not Sexist, and other subsequent
sub-classifications of the sexist data. We also use synthetic classification of
unlabelled dataset and intermediary class information to maximize the
performance of our models. We submitted a system in Task A, and it ranked 49th
with F1-score of 0.82. This result showed to be competitive as it only
under-performed the best system by 0.052% F1-score. | [
-0.479095757,
-0.6796904206,
0.3699417114,
0.4533863664,
-0.083519347,
-0.033067815,
0.0448826626,
-0.8027173281,
0.1797655225,
0.421004653,
-0.283020407,
-0.5055810809,
-0.656371057,
0.2227716297,
-0.8598448038,
0.880012393,
0.2023059726,
-0.0366923064,
-0.2969359159,
-0.1241162196,
-0.306597352,
-0.8152077794,
-0.9121658802,
0.0271233562,
0.3062571883,
0.2592543364,
0.2122417688,
0.2695690095,
0.4381378591,
0.2853122652,
0.0149565516,
0.1209954768,
-0.47892344,
0.0778511465,
-0.5359327197,
-0.4688480794,
-0.7604875565,
0.0165408347,
0.2565550506,
0.3917203248,
-0.0183630679,
0.3477545679,
0.1514334828,
0.4777534902,
-0.6292626262,
0.1432270259,
-0.3693453074,
0.2559139729,
-0.2546252012,
-0.1733434051,
-0.62083745,
-0.170599997,
0.0013122734,
-0.4342431426,
0.0743556991,
0.3379746974,
0.5821020007,
0.0451638624,
-0.7837159634,
-0.3351795077,
-0.5548713207,
0.8944475651,
-0.4946727455,
0.2946419418,
0.4360633194,
0.1015081704,
0.1566496938,
-0.4856399596,
-0.4094801545,
0.0905796438,
-0.1333644986,
0.0476938114,
-0.3986054659,
-0.2566449046,
0.113574639,
0.0566004328,
-0.3458741307,
0.1220749691,
-0.5270169973,
-0.1683813483,
1.1401805878,
0.0223794393,
0.3874562979,
-0.278252691,
-0.593296349,
0.0173114967,
-0.5702155828,
-0.1572625637,
0.5594910979,
0.4182435274,
-0.2576399446,
0.1779371053,
0.0111336615,
0.1658077389,
-0.0779012144,
0.3164303005,
0.6156576872,
-0.3827265501,
-0.0140345404,
-0.1780899465,
0.7405939102,
0.3785226643,
0.1075609997,
0.2514968812,
-0.1905948073,
0.2513487637,
0.5085803866,
-0.5009034872,
-0.1668497771,
-0.0726518184,
-0.510474205,
-0.7402970195,
-0.2353331,
-1.1804738045,
-0.5522471666,
-0.3167772293,
0.6916590333,
0.031001443,
-0.402071476,
-0.2056226879,
-0.1061026081,
-0.043066334,
0.691454649,
-0.740419805,
0.4058128595,
0.4666351974,
0.4730831385,
-0.6796476245,
-0.0895055309,
-0.1828235835,
-0.0436951853,
-0.0951754376,
0.5826073885,
-0.7003141046,
-0.1443809122,
0.054789599,
0.3439798951,
-0.1792231649,
-0.3568350077,
0.7210452557,
-0.3071665764,
0.5699800253,
-0.1461389661,
-0.310524255,
-0.3875278234,
0.2087925822,
-0.2836478353,
1.0435825586,
-0.1023974717,
-0.7134763598,
-0.0247976966,
-0.8085674644,
-0.6018993855,
-0.1146715432,
0.1761197299,
-0.3198376,
-0.0530361235,
0.0411032028,
0.4645673335,
-0.0053067808,
-0.0922707543,
-0.6062275767,
-0.2962513566,
0.1395002306,
-0.1918135136,
0.8228743672,
0.4651479721,
-0.6008185744,
0.1811059713,
-0.6591320038,
-0.1492785066,
0.1130751818,
-0.0647013783,
-0.53080374,
-0.2691236734,
-0.0062634321,
0.3104352653,
0.1567009687,
-0.5871537924,
-0.0015154458,
-0.059056472,
0.3644158244,
0.8832576871,
-0.1275338382,
0.4350859225,
-0.1257567257,
0.7146689892,
-0.0308123641,
0.1708307117,
0.3329303861,
-0.6178995967,
-1.0641154051,
0.2012512386,
0.2235056162,
0.607373476,
-0.6380732656,
0.2591520846,
0.0307735987,
-0.3545970619,
-0.1857837886,
-0.3426220715,
0.2304475307,
0.2053788304,
0.5347144604,
-0.104776673,
-0.7605614066,
-0.9866978526,
-0.2785348892,
-0.2756378055,
0.2685530484,
0.1854610145,
0.8209411502,
-0.1505736262,
0.0165046472,
-0.2573503852,
-0.3757428825,
-0.222227186,
0.5466432571,
-0.1833219677,
0.3935663998,
0.6930312514,
-0.7394253016,
-0.5191448927,
-0.0422128215,
-0.8957374096,
-0.4477953315,
0.3960236907,
-0.2483657151,
0.3429491222,
0.661202848,
0.0576846413,
0.4331471622,
0.5368397236,
-0.4452109635,
0.3841437995,
0.0932417214,
0.6164229512,
-1.2457277775,
-0.1492358595,
-0.0358931646,
-0.4660438299,
-0.7559224963,
0.0980547369,
-0.0837723538,
-0.1094455719,
-0.670491755,
0.427903235,
-0.1952216327,
-0.1288090646,
-0.4418927729,
-0.1080143228,
-0.2400701642,
0.6120112538,
-0.0517123714,
0.6533077955,
0.4585603476,
-0.5179638863,
0.4945857227,
0.2095968723,
0.1094896048,
0.6057171822,
-0.3111406565,
0.4580195844,
-0.0603502914,
0.0358515568,
-0.8270865083,
-0.1946880519,
0.3069125712,
-0.5046532154,
0.0824609101,
-0.2364111394,
-0.0208329968,
-0.3730481565,
-0.2210677713,
0.4631043077,
0.4958650172,
-0.4202827811,
0.4100456536,
0.9306995273,
-0.3488774598,
-0.5108145475,
-0.701417923,
-0.0257200785,
-0.554426074,
-0.5228520632,
0.4453393817,
0.2796962261,
-0.0725144893,
0.0594304167,
0.1851381361,
-0.0264565628,
0.0824369192,
0.2081424892,
0.1626109481,
-0.0004204534,
0.2436893433,
-0.0015140295,
0.1958025843,
0.4834261239,
0.089203015,
0.648016572,
-0.3953560889,
-0.2329533845,
-0.3120884001,
0.4066313505,
0.5276079178,
0.1188822314,
0.8013505936,
0.7112076283,
-0.5420762897,
-0.5093986392,
-0.0849050581,
-0.0911376774,
-0.3748887777,
0.339648664,
-0.2601944804,
-0.9463931918,
0.4639680088,
0.280541271,
-0.0997100994,
0.5642966032,
0.4291329384,
-0.3383298516,
1.421734333,
0.6539804935,
0.0899923444,
0.4514784217,
-0.1194638386,
0.0308080651,
-0.4936743975,
-0.2130783498,
-0.61628896,
-0.3907261491,
-0.8562307954,
-0.2310007513,
0.3482657373,
-0.3113308251,
-0.260884136,
0.5798461437,
-0.1403965205,
0.3029405475,
0.2826654017,
0.1549241394,
0.0949221104,
0.2395272702,
0.2463000417,
-0.0648712143,
-0.4417522252,
-0.2008848637,
1.1873761415,
0.5346332788,
0.7212930322,
0.3571901917,
0.5937582254,
0.9513623118,
0.2177851796,
-0.4594020247,
0.8555133343,
-0.5898209214,
-0.4346103966,
-0.0789433792,
-0.5086120367,
-0.7862042189,
0.4155635238,
-0.2752500772,
-0.6877323985,
0.2430545241,
-0.0039433977,
-0.0158289839,
0.1748683006,
-0.4497600794,
0.6469939947,
-0.115971595,
-0.607958734,
-0.5299800038,
-0.4486425519,
0.3978513479,
-0.2643316388,
0.7468172908,
-0.2774283588,
0.0972686559,
1.0345385075,
-0.131754905,
0.8941332102,
-0.2671515942,
-0.2249773294,
-0.0791710615,
-0.125615567,
0.4210298359,
-0.2951364517,
-0.1360506564,
0.1149193868,
0.0103757754,
-0.3061067164,
-0.4230220914,
0.6031574607,
-0.7685534954,
-0.6581036448,
-0.4972912073,
-0.3004513085,
-0.1828496158,
0.0832054392,
0.1700223535,
0.4262064397,
0.0870018527,
0.3472127318,
0.4674958587,
-0.2158563286,
0.0532283038,
0.1686540395,
-0.6459117532,
-0.2364495546,
0.9341282248,
-0.0658153817,
0.191088438,
0.1101883948,
0.1579261273,
-0.5730355382,
-0.434936583,
-0.3366264105,
0.0908197165,
-0.9080950022,
-0.0687109381,
-0.8090459108,
-0.4091971219,
-0.7290990353,
0.0439948961,
-0.4500769377,
-0.5607084036,
-0.1940247715,
0.1368219405,
-0.1831937134,
0.8759307265,
-0.1115885451,
-0.0209056437,
-0.737898469,
0.1096787378,
0.1906576306,
-0.2103518397,
-0.3469927013,
-1.1344681978,
0.0497656837,
0.1390594989,
-0.1868141145,
-1.1110928059,
0.6238805056,
0.1466111839,
0.4829921424,
0.2724584341,
0.2219107002,
0.4659473896,
0.1838088781,
0.6704367995,
0.0720997378,
-0.9415713549,
0.792240262,
-0.420753479,
0.016458042,
0.3146939874,
0.7724817395,
-0.5086792111,
-0.4745161831,
-0.6021738052,
-0.5254387259,
0.8519358039,
0.4465408623,
0.2169820815,
0.0670743883,
0.0882155746,
0.1384684294,
0.2790670395,
-1.0253605843,
-0.2882000506,
0.1508325338,
-0.1986516118,
0.448790133,
-0.162922591,
-0.0945748836,
-0.2892633677,
1.0311273336,
-0.089309074,
0.5126579404,
-0.202913478,
-0.2472382635,
0.0055100019,
0.5531829,
0.5114704967,
0.5504119992,
-0.0164427422,
0.4971888363,
0.5382521749,
-0.3655616343,
0.3963745534,
-0.101239562,
-0.2473862022,
-0.3149357438,
0.3622158468,
0.9608545303,
-0.0872133151,
-0.233853817,
0.7327366471,
-0.0754625797,
-0.3026123643,
-0.3598841727,
0.1693238616,
-0.2200384289,
0.3467416167,
0.0969009027,
0.3783913851,
0.3386088908,
-0.777528286,
0.1291111559,
0.1722453386,
-0.4054303169,
-0.7541867495,
0.6463443041,
0.5852479339,
-0.029111445,
0.2678034008,
-0.5492759943,
-1.0123786926,
0.5089918375,
0.7273271084,
0.5701864958,
-0.4079470634,
0.4358823597,
0.6321079135,
0.1655562222,
0.1080274507,
0.5055823326,
0.1201074868,
-0.967335701,
-0.1776300669,
-0.7127037644,
-0.1963001192,
0.3729514778,
-0.7273569703,
0.5988576412,
-0.2564532161,
-0.1357541829,
0.0729054436,
-0.3339369893,
-0.47658512,
0.0280596819,
0.5210933089,
0.4821017087,
-1.2781162262,
0.5730189085,
1.0165601969,
-0.1638635695,
-0.3321680725,
-0.3111477196,
0.2344751507,
-0.8023062348,
0.7375065684,
0.3326080739,
-0.2700647712,
0.0410790481,
-0.4199655354,
-0.7907489538,
0.5778136253,
0.1968748719,
-0.4056835473,
-0.097964786,
0.2850935757,
0.7107788324,
-0.556774497,
0.2232994288,
0.4506189227,
0.3102902472,
0.0862969905,
-1.0056788921,
0.0744918212,
-0.5208982825,
-0.3806812763,
0.3164651692,
-0.5415788293,
0.6566053033,
-0.0478310809,
-0.5450533628,
-0.175792262,
0.6490556002,
-0.0371400788,
0.5369121432,
0.7877800465,
0.6713844538,
0.578094542,
-0.1340429932,
0.586894393,
0.1755956411,
0.4426372647,
0.9570958018,
-0.1561846733,
1.0104734898,
0.2393888533,
-0.5775585175,
0.612719059,
0.5203446746,
0.0581204705,
0.3304421902,
0.0757242367,
-0.2392340302,
-0.3235916197,
-0.3355014026,
-0.5765161514,
0.7051695585,
0.489344418,
-0.421230942,
-0.1714175344,
0.5110311508,
0.0165222157,
-0.0759324133,
-0.2992096543,
0.6854685545,
0.0265824404,
-0.5605946779,
0.4249872863,
0.0372334085,
0.7851889729,
-0.1938751936,
-0.1113256738,
-0.2019635588,
0.1950674355,
-0.3188118041,
-0.9322809577,
0.5533896685,
-0.0761571005,
0.0597373508,
-0.50920856,
1.2039955854,
-0.6113036275,
-0.2751591802,
0.321238935,
0.4624071419,
0.4072235227,
-0.0275695864,
-0.7020021081,
-0.0331279449,
0.2459617257,
0.034213569,
0.4352475703,
0.1688371897,
-0.3735026717,
0.5852532983,
0.6597571969,
0.007743103,
0.1059749946,
0.1864754856,
0.5403246284,
-0.6594030261,
-0.7138981223,
-0.5840300918,
0.0246848967,
-0.260142833,
-0.1305740923,
0.8406733871,
0.3056034744,
0.8867390752,
-0.1040671915,
0.706567049,
-0.2943120301,
0.6644330025,
-0.346270889,
0.5592230558,
-0.7384015322,
0.3357939124,
-0.1267664731,
-0.8680863976,
0.0706560984,
0.3864398301,
-0.2977409363,
-0.035885606,
0.7821193337,
0.601682961,
-0.054514017,
0.6042609215,
0.3474627435,
0.180557549,
0.288269937,
0.364179343,
1.2034426928,
-0.478486985,
0.4478623867,
-0.4446098804,
-0.2285476327,
-0.2906049192,
-0.6804335713,
-0.7637426257,
-0.5474179983,
-0.5757839084,
-0.2926175296,
0.1892892867,
0.8190886974,
0.7009056211,
-1.0120301247,
-0.1697867662,
-0.1136103123,
-0.1266006529,
0.014145663,
-0.3351878822,
0.1417615861,
-0.2879876196,
-0.9602210522,
0.3465864658,
0.1414588094,
-0.0413369052,
-0.1119244322,
0.2164532989,
-0.3759330809,
-0.1676163077,
0.9348644614,
0.032781329,
-0.4191299081,
-0.6170384884,
0.0867371336,
0.0012131532,
-0.2887896001,
0.3898247778,
-0.4409277141,
0.3124930263,
0.9393439293,
0.5991377831,
0.4048710763,
0.118520394,
0.6039631367,
-0.6868999004,
-0.0946412832,
0.1034456193,
0.364215225,
0.1718624681,
-0.296831429,
0.8414000869,
0.6567301154,
-0.650310576,
-0.8739244938,
0.095284991,
-0.6942188144,
-0.2086405456,
1.1631053686,
-0.1362812519,
-0.305593878,
-0.2767337263,
-0.0725265965,
0.1664264202,
-0.3653834164,
0.6786359549,
0.7402012944,
-0.53151232,
-0.2416704744,
-0.5289925933,
0.4921699166,
0.6125051379,
-1.4751023054,
-0.1150264069,
0.3869639933,
0.1499247402,
0.2765054703,
0.2558118701,
-0.1770763993,
0.2817419469,
-0.1978284866,
-0.0438728966,
0.1075538844,
-0.4839357138,
-0.2422798723,
0.5135983229,
-0.5122349858,
-0.2376864552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00061v1 | Explainable Verbal Reasoner Plus (EVR+): A Natural Language Reasoning Framework that Supports Diverse Compositional Reasoning | 2023-04-28T19:27:26 | 2023-04-28T19:27:26 | Zhengzhong Liang, Zeyu Zhang, Steven Bethard, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Languages models have been successfully applied to a variety of reasoning
tasks in NLP, yet the language models still suffer from compositional
generalization. In this paper we present Explainable Verbal Reasoner Plus
(EVR+), a reasoning framework that enhances language models' compositional
reasoning ability by (1) allowing the model to explicitly generate and execute
symbolic operators, and (2) allowing the model to decompose a complex task into
several simpler ones in a flexible manner. Compared with its predecessor
Explainable Verbal Reasoner (EVR) and other previous approaches adopting
similar ideas, our framework supports more diverse types of reasoning such as
nested loops and different types of recursion. To evaluate our reasoning
framework, we build a synthetic dataset with five tasks that require
compositional reasoning. Results show that our reasoning framework can enhance
the language model's compositional generalization performance on the five
tasks, using a fine-tuned language model. We also discussed the possibility and
the challenges to combine our reasoning framework with a few-shot prompted
language model. | [
-0.3080005944,
-0.6570616364,
0.6804667115,
0.4091755152,
-0.0314995795,
0.0652408972,
-0.3070293069,
-0.6377224326,
-0.2683116198,
0.3849385679,
-0.6143003106,
-0.3956379592,
-0.3915108442,
0.2686835527,
-0.4691779315,
0.6976448298,
-0.0347573794,
0.0148850298,
-0.2043209225,
-0.0507325195,
-0.6873977184,
-0.4148265421,
-0.9439835548,
-0.7707931399,
0.402403146,
0.3026584089,
0.6073688269,
0.3981551528,
0.244780913,
0.4475404024,
0.0207812134,
0.386942476,
0.099119179,
0.4797145724,
-0.4242470264,
-0.629789412,
-0.3730343878,
-0.6514964104,
0.2959643304,
0.6096465588,
-0.2219434083,
-0.1839084923,
-0.3531857729,
0.4791540205,
-0.4664499164,
0.1154326424,
-0.5781926513,
-0.0343791358,
0.2468672246,
0.0775842294,
-0.3950115442,
-0.2987035513,
0.1658495218,
-0.7278850079,
0.2031785995,
-0.2496181279,
0.6770427227,
0.103395842,
-0.3475114107,
-0.2317927331,
-0.8227301836,
0.8932379484,
-0.5204960704,
0.5040404201,
0.1082702279,
0.579229176,
0.1597781777,
-0.729516685,
-0.8355224133,
-0.2871896327,
-0.2409151345,
0.0802983418,
-0.2572361231,
0.2507360876,
0.3151715696,
0.2229357213,
-0.7276269794,
-0.1950289607,
0.0579384379,
-0.0115582934,
0.4768918753,
0.2166917324,
0.6215298176,
-0.0104658706,
-0.040314842,
-0.0076067434,
-0.3646228015,
0.24998869,
0.0730794072,
0.1017744392,
-0.1282625496,
0.6745769382,
-0.0701466054,
1.0753997564,
0.0517709702,
0.1444255263,
-0.0143785635,
-0.2887567282,
-0.2764021754,
0.2158673704,
0.4140927494,
0.1197889373,
0.4714744091,
-0.1057082117,
0.0051431716,
0.561355412,
0.1121659353,
-0.777315557,
0.0316441469,
0.4988052249,
-0.292846024,
-0.1335676014,
0.070501931,
-0.1149987429,
-0.1845542789,
-0.7121351361,
0.0025178085,
-0.6952742338,
-0.4623935223,
0.8504426479,
-0.5117901564,
0.4130032361,
0.497967869,
-0.9132934213,
0.4367483556,
1.1474288702,
0.5523556471,
-0.0347684175,
-0.2799551189,
-0.3143853247,
0.1642016768,
-0.1540608704,
0.897028327,
-0.9866464734,
-0.1219075918,
-0.1500926912,
-0.0785000548,
-0.3500248194,
-0.4151038527,
0.6944250464,
-0.349965781,
0.4628902972,
-0.3229615986,
-0.5002408028,
-0.5757379532,
0.6528996825,
-0.5625709891,
0.9294731021,
0.0259165931,
-0.5345097184,
0.2396791279,
-0.9485318661,
-0.6329771876,
0.3260944188,
-0.2901540101,
-0.1431379169,
0.0743944794,
0.2871483862,
0.3100867271,
-0.3379277587,
0.6401013136,
-0.2324530631,
-0.2470748872,
0.3453145623,
-0.1481316239,
0.7796028256,
0.2324743867,
-0.3703261018,
0.4570545852,
-1.0485824347,
0.1516883522,
0.1005367935,
-0.2692041099,
-0.3345907629,
0.2652804554,
-0.1583987921,
0.3167123795,
0.076227814,
-0.4674464166,
-0.1510033011,
-0.7946881056,
0.3887709975,
0.3139954209,
-0.1585974544,
0.6849704981,
-0.5083009005,
0.7931939363,
-0.279738605,
-0.0993164256,
-0.4603733122,
-0.3357878923,
-0.8424193859,
-0.4716914892,
-0.268435061,
0.6565356851,
-0.5982650518,
0.5043101907,
-0.3177984655,
-0.3909031749,
-0.4116513729,
-0.0510754623,
0.4159979522,
0.5262734294,
0.2875370681,
0.3279172182,
-0.8136016726,
-0.7054205537,
-0.5308312774,
0.023781633,
-0.3211723864,
0.0663449839,
0.3559201658,
-0.1877081096,
0.8269346952,
-0.215196535,
0.138116017,
-0.787735939,
-0.0612090081,
0.2698747516,
0.380292207,
0.3969296515,
-0.7317115068,
-0.318816483,
0.2757365108,
-0.808948338,
-0.0662688985,
-0.428999275,
-0.1336134225,
-0.198364228,
0.2470828593,
-0.8877429962,
-0.1865061074,
0.3370720446,
-0.6131208539,
0.6492624283,
-0.177642107,
-0.1850619614,
-0.8292217255,
-0.0410740301,
0.0662968606,
-0.4377009869,
-0.7049168348,
0.5777509212,
-0.2526086569,
-0.3771903515,
-0.176703319,
0.4857700169,
-0.2220179141,
0.465711385,
-0.2823134959,
-0.1972689182,
0.4739690125,
0.1739010215,
0.4730487764,
0.2416332811,
0.8595157862,
-0.6917388439,
0.5722013116,
0.118625477,
-0.0514164604,
0.5806189775,
-1.1857446432,
-0.062071912,
-0.4628272057,
0.4012343585,
-0.8372666836,
-0.2552674115,
0.1224921122,
-0.30919379,
0.1981022507,
0.1185161173,
-0.2975980639,
-0.2349337935,
-0.367595762,
0.1071141437,
0.0483767949,
-0.4246215224,
1.2192790508,
-0.1316852123,
-0.0524839461,
-0.2629320025,
-0.7386730909,
-0.0444631428,
-0.208922565,
-1.068786025,
0.5499641895,
-0.1407501549,
-0.5862707496,
0.0958879143,
-0.236661315,
-0.0248279087,
0.1413559914,
0.1971772462,
-0.0410249457,
-0.4630641043,
0.2205567211,
0.3233473301,
-0.3538172245,
0.2743696272,
-0.193979919,
0.5431172252,
-0.5252041221,
-0.501675725,
-0.4504339993,
0.6205115318,
0.4426164925,
-0.4270864129,
0.6526053548,
0.6102792025,
-0.3736528754,
-0.3877427578,
-0.4408323467,
-0.2762031257,
-0.4736130536,
0.2109063268,
-0.6649829149,
-1.0742374659,
0.6058008075,
0.1273821592,
0.0146347694,
0.4519613981,
0.4734899104,
0.1478510946,
1.3221153021,
0.1813067645,
0.3619486094,
0.3728002906,
-0.1586976945,
0.2566671968,
-0.3213493526,
-0.4849739969,
-0.4987486601,
-0.1902663261,
-0.3844540119,
-0.2601305544,
-0.0225574989,
-0.0569234192,
-0.4279883802,
0.2569046021,
-0.8333219886,
0.7091681957,
0.3977563977,
0.0564774647,
0.231591478,
-0.1968694776,
-0.0544896312,
0.2084799707,
-0.5020265579,
-0.4695782065,
0.4211600125,
0.2837234437,
0.5558345914,
0.2561856508,
0.5147417784,
-0.0915476158,
-0.0188543275,
-0.6939658523,
0.5537543297,
-0.2120831758,
-0.7890201807,
-0.1725672483,
-0.2945096195,
-0.7489377856,
0.7046912909,
-0.1783962697,
-0.5683885813,
0.1891967505,
0.1989257485,
-0.3236434162,
-0.1784336418,
-0.8319057226,
0.9967487454,
-0.4577359855,
-0.0584304705,
-0.2465163767,
-0.5774080753,
0.5142433047,
0.2692398131,
0.3496820331,
-0.1410435289,
0.0496777445,
0.2204596549,
-0.6348130703,
0.6796477437,
-0.2247945964,
-0.0948097184,
0.3036947846,
0.2135696709,
0.6169783473,
-0.0276424065,
-0.3140372038,
-0.4175831079,
-0.1093912721,
-0.0249549616,
-0.9634761214,
0.7178291082,
-0.3496490717,
-0.5430426002,
-0.2033267915,
-0.4307349026,
0.0122517375,
0.0137345707,
0.0216477811,
0.3088463545,
0.160454914,
0.188598603,
0.6155900955,
-0.1172212064,
0.3448071778,
0.5083912611,
-0.1860955805,
-0.1785774231,
0.9843257666,
-0.3423183858,
0.1001834422,
0.7170209885,
0.5182815194,
-0.3997176588,
-0.2917445898,
-0.2076079994,
0.1272277683,
-0.6897401214,
0.0075010201,
-0.7863524556,
-0.111917913,
-0.0394413099,
-0.4922351241,
-0.1768044829,
-0.7402846813,
-0.2913295329,
-0.413249433,
0.2732896507,
0.2227999568,
0.1854777783,
0.1965176612,
-0.6971200705,
0.7093930244,
0.5190202594,
0.1905692071,
0.0524892956,
-0.3380324841,
0.2729120255,
-0.0482536331,
-0.1892223954,
-0.8377717733,
0.2166296095,
0.5597456098,
0.6107316017,
0.4245146513,
-0.1434935629,
0.8046084046,
-0.2634628117,
0.7681958079,
0.3082856536,
-1.1476473808,
0.5536985993,
-0.4197849929,
0.6065477729,
0.3105836213,
0.1558733582,
-0.3307172954,
-0.5402185917,
-0.4989025891,
-0.9410122037,
0.5268941522,
0.281679064,
0.3835728765,
-0.2463224232,
0.1522343457,
0.2513765097,
-0.1114522666,
-0.995690465,
-0.2361343056,
-0.4326592386,
-0.2415110767,
0.238600105,
-0.3447816372,
0.0301121026,
-0.5899156928,
0.6618768573,
-0.0825573429,
0.0904013887,
0.1367994994,
-0.2386934012,
0.0659748018,
0.745683074,
0.6865571141,
0.7549490333,
-0.0631139204,
0.4193624258,
0.0291577466,
0.1385294795,
0.0635238886,
0.5077994466,
-0.0976639241,
0.149607718,
0.5494552851,
0.7737639546,
0.3076950312,
-0.9306336045,
0.374445349,
-0.0807649493,
-0.317445606,
-0.3006743491,
0.2745810151,
0.4044064581,
0.2468097955,
0.1723692566,
0.1417502165,
0.3037146628,
-0.3163214326,
0.0211033355,
0.3796325922,
-0.150379315,
-0.5351570845,
0.8197596073,
0.1621872783,
-0.1631464809,
0.1364576817,
-0.4610145092,
-0.6760566831,
0.5850829482,
0.8428276777,
0.8098083138,
-0.1920401305,
0.4005045295,
0.3938714862,
0.3082927465,
-0.2127392888,
0.7245582938,
-0.302541554,
-1.1193026304,
-0.962464273,
-0.4005352855,
-0.2042973638,
0.0606818162,
-0.4531940222,
0.0648965836,
-0.3280347288,
0.0927053094,
0.4473938942,
-0.5024540424,
-0.5553995371,
0.2478834838,
0.1287647635,
0.6463435888,
-0.7844591141,
0.4169375002,
0.8155359626,
-0.4847573638,
-0.8684077263,
-0.5265821815,
-0.1543799937,
-0.6716895103,
0.5995941162,
0.3244948089,
-0.4643238485,
-0.1293587834,
-0.3240791857,
-0.4309323132,
0.6382947564,
0.8152527809,
-0.6286428571,
-0.002965579,
0.1004896611,
0.6942430139,
-0.3379914761,
0.2610834241,
0.6296824217,
0.7136719227,
0.2900662422,
-0.5626949072,
0.4107929468,
-0.4014145732,
0.0378475934,
0.1491923332,
0.0776690468,
0.5167312026,
-0.3090574741,
-0.2664333284,
-0.1497902572,
0.4093552828,
0.5189300776,
0.4225985408,
0.3887506723,
0.7733731866,
0.6217054129,
-0.0045991275,
1.3891432285,
-0.0837805793,
-0.0294843614,
1.3179937601,
-0.2321641445,
0.4669199288,
0.2508434951,
-0.1374491155,
1.012116909,
0.1290346682,
0.1196094826,
0.2313459069,
0.1730121523,
-0.6117569208,
-0.7962257862,
-0.3145511448,
-0.3825826645,
0.571841836,
0.3217565417,
-0.3883767724,
-0.410177201,
-0.015334025,
0.0160610471,
0.3781698346,
-0.2132457495,
0.7601667047,
0.1693766415,
-0.7555313706,
0.4696950614,
0.2576369941,
0.4425802231,
-0.7518684864,
-0.1740447134,
0.2172115296,
0.3046891689,
-0.5000172257,
-0.7283443213,
0.6669899821,
-0.007593228,
-0.2301321328,
-0.4356899559,
1.0892095566,
-0.5520656705,
-0.6041010022,
0.2078344226,
0.4745491743,
-0.2112980187,
-0.4324831963,
-0.8129919767,
-0.0905809775,
-0.0487983935,
-0.1544601917,
-0.0074115321,
0.6292703748,
0.0108251628,
0.8697980642,
0.8557282686,
-0.0089569576,
-0.0323604718,
0.6334577203,
0.829466939,
-0.6100955606,
-0.3928134143,
-1.176523447,
0.8853988051,
-0.0843511596,
0.0882574394,
0.7355565429,
0.5824350715,
0.5418851376,
-0.2291347235,
0.8028758764,
0.0077331788,
0.3941265345,
-0.3076153994,
0.3021509647,
-0.3352526426,
0.2564986348,
0.036215622,
-0.7579744458,
-0.7150536776,
0.9059793353,
-0.1286726147,
-0.0414296277,
0.6887969971,
0.6478896737,
-0.1689704806,
0.2329086065,
0.0963891968,
-0.1362286061,
0.4363022149,
0.4561452866,
0.9849988222,
0.0753882676,
0.4404706061,
-0.1242627427,
0.1309673786,
0.2235829681,
-1.1333061457,
-0.7346146703,
-0.1538376361,
-0.4777441621,
-0.1228608862,
-0.1015990451,
0.9564921856,
0.6500734091,
-0.8685746789,
0.0821872503,
-0.7596412301,
0.5179935694,
-0.579443574,
-0.3155874014,
0.0392657146,
-0.4116482139,
-0.3739806116,
0.6184530258,
0.1933495402,
-0.1856020093,
0.1519559324,
-0.2244296968,
0.0004078741,
0.1679850519,
0.8750978112,
0.3746263385,
-0.8865689635,
-0.1951216906,
-0.0698113367,
0.3866789937,
-0.1663989574,
0.9856743217,
-0.5659711957,
0.7329717875,
0.6783284545,
0.5222908854,
0.5120082498,
0.0186316539,
0.8114064932,
-0.8003023267,
0.0660066903,
0.3503290117,
0.442445904,
0.3514312506,
-0.197106123,
0.2438032925,
-0.0232303571,
-0.2037390172,
-0.5758450031,
0.4681098461,
-1.2133209705,
-0.4282847941,
1.1621147394,
-0.0387348644,
0.2338746935,
-0.2262988687,
-0.2213342488,
-0.0219155569,
-0.5038599372,
0.3670350611,
0.6272330284,
-0.3158129752,
-0.4170499444,
0.0568901077,
0.3756613433,
0.2458241284,
-1.0418177843,
-0.0449250564,
0.6105149984,
0.3877526224,
0.0533030629,
0.4238683879,
-0.0798625052,
0.4342286587,
-0.1690386236,
-0.0209209546,
-0.4476118386,
-0.1489319652,
-0.4471420348,
0.3275979161,
0.0934078321,
-0.0401557498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00050v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00050v2 | Causal Reasoning and Large Language Models: Opening a New Frontier for Causality | 2023-04-28T19:00:43 | 2023-05-08T17:54:45 | Emre Kıcıman, Robert Ness, Amit Sharma, Chenhao Tan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG, stat.ME | The causal capabilities of large language models (LLMs) is a matter of
significant debate, with critical implications for the use of LLMs in
societally impactful domains such as medicine, science, law, and policy. We
further our understanding of LLMs and their causal implications, considering
the distinctions between different types of causal reasoning tasks, as well as
the entangled threats of construct and measurement validity. LLM-based methods
establish new state-of-the-art accuracies on multiple causal benchmarks.
Algorithms based on GPT-3.5 and 4 outperform existing algorithms on a pairwise
causal discovery task (97%, 13 points gain), counterfactual reasoning task
(92%, 20 points gain), and actual causality (86% accuracy in determining
necessary and sufficient causes in vignettes). At the same time, LLMs exhibit
unpredictable failure modes and we provide some techniques to interpret their
robustness.
Crucially, LLMs perform these causal tasks while relying on sources of
knowledge and methods distinct from and complementary to non-LLM based
approaches. Specifically, LLMs bring capabilities so far understood to be
restricted to humans, such as using collected knowledge to generate causal
graphs or identifying background causal context from natural language. We
envision LLMs to be used alongside existing causal methods, as a proxy for
human domain knowledge and to reduce human effort in setting up a causal
analysis, one of the biggest impediments to the widespread adoption of causal
methods. We also see existing causal methods as promising tools for LLMs to
formalize, validate, and communicate their reasoning especially in high-stakes
scenarios.
In capturing common sense and domain knowledge about causal mechanisms and
supporting translation between natural language and formal methods, LLMs open
new frontiers for advancing the research, practice, and adoption of causality. | [
-0.1063602492,
-1.1251522303,
1.0487926006,
0.3818609715,
-0.0709789321,
-0.1610430181,
-0.249175787,
-0.5571847558,
-0.0462675355,
0.5388367176,
-0.2901704311,
-0.3017733395,
-0.8202627301,
0.0056794379,
-0.4057670832,
0.5242050886,
-0.1075320765,
0.1647002548,
-0.5141531825,
0.0112513211,
-0.5817434192,
-0.5471102595,
-0.8408964872,
-0.6889864802,
0.9110044241,
0.2037043273,
0.566121161,
0.4930492342,
0.5146708488,
0.2842933536,
-0.0786721706,
0.164623186,
-0.4410224259,
0.1551016122,
-0.3615045249,
-0.501552701,
-0.3769965768,
-0.0744158402,
0.685084641,
0.9993308187,
-0.0230644587,
-0.0097033279,
0.1304204315,
0.5464003682,
-0.5367749929,
0.2233781517,
-0.5409772992,
-0.2278136164,
-0.2861637771,
-0.4642438889,
-0.2940448225,
-0.385551542,
-0.0568317734,
-0.475106895,
0.0694638863,
0.1371117383,
0.4773830175,
0.4089034498,
-0.9191248417,
-0.106811434,
-0.9558491707,
0.7248462439,
-0.7239995599,
0.4849002659,
0.3160728812,
0.2141245902,
-0.6175701022,
-0.8798525333,
-0.622192204,
-0.3732132316,
0.1247097701,
-0.0072309836,
-0.1276236475,
0.0495593362,
0.3854310215,
0.0708251521,
-0.393458873,
0.5505288243,
-0.0697377548,
-0.2123560309,
0.6268727183,
0.3717969954,
0.2078789622,
0.1267593503,
-0.34815979,
0.4222657382,
-1.3339143991,
-0.2693140507,
0.2405215353,
0.1508716643,
-0.0786887705,
0.4678636491,
-0.2299185991,
0.7454599142,
-0.3174157441,
-0.2009248585,
-0.3835036755,
-0.276275605,
-0.2527227998,
-0.0375055932,
0.6503997445,
0.2685770094,
-0.0171449222,
-0.0590629466,
0.0511511564,
0.030194113,
-0.070223622,
-0.4523171484,
0.2222280502,
0.0814273283,
-0.3675179183,
-0.0502998605,
-0.2376897037,
-0.4931664765,
-0.8301145434,
-0.7057287097,
0.3630222082,
-0.0357202999,
-0.0940782577,
0.3287573457,
0.1160973459,
0.3250937164,
0.5998461246,
-0.6693888903,
0.2351189703,
0.8179886937,
0.6040546894,
-0.0114515033,
-0.3904211521,
-0.4198631346,
0.41158095,
-0.3984071314,
0.6636333466,
-0.157383725,
-0.1939334571,
0.1872116923,
0.0277996082,
-0.0109246178,
-0.2779356837,
0.7115366459,
-0.5511425138,
-0.0698014796,
-0.5581462979,
-0.6412002444,
-0.3101198673,
0.1523218453,
-0.5353349447,
0.7002002001,
-0.4679706693,
-0.5386362076,
0.4348091185,
-0.4162552655,
-0.6652157903,
0.0138083445,
-0.1827235073,
-0.0025599855,
0.1562195569,
-0.0951054469,
0.5738022327,
-0.9957587123,
0.9389811754,
-0.5715011954,
-0.1392801702,
0.2759961784,
-0.7048186064,
0.8256554604,
0.1178017035,
-0.4416277707,
0.1576210409,
-0.5439369678,
-0.508924365,
0.2516243458,
-0.2157064825,
-0.3186978698,
0.4891727567,
-0.1083437204,
0.2155315429,
0.3726590276,
-0.4050292671,
-0.0474707447,
-0.124761261,
0.4484102428,
0.7474046946,
0.113861151,
0.1317108274,
-0.2532935143,
0.1906451583,
-0.1889778972,
0.3593057692,
0.0025827989,
-0.5976080894,
-0.6175149679,
-0.0091997068,
-0.0811051577,
0.5721104145,
-0.6273933053,
0.3794979155,
-0.0441541299,
-0.4802107215,
0.1904354393,
0.0660607219,
0.2857973278,
0.8037691116,
0.2189299464,
0.0325983576,
-0.5773419738,
-0.6991590261,
-0.5431698561,
-0.3437766135,
0.1218448579,
0.2006548345,
0.5398919582,
-0.2960080206,
0.7984735966,
-0.5278701782,
-0.0973142684,
-0.2063318491,
0.0821943656,
0.2852545381,
0.3642796576,
0.070222415,
-0.8201249838,
-0.061733067,
-0.0333144888,
-1.0914158821,
-0.232493028,
-0.1788956523,
0.0001420925,
0.136287719,
0.9846719503,
-0.5571750998,
0.0657221451,
0.410977155,
-0.4595552981,
0.7901089787,
-0.2463103086,
0.0920612738,
-0.8901543021,
0.1515788734,
0.1244312227,
0.0706796348,
-0.6965113878,
-0.0918735862,
-0.163144365,
0.0703083128,
-0.4486691058,
0.8166240454,
-0.4372771382,
0.1430736631,
-0.341263026,
0.3307442665,
-0.1478113979,
0.1170140132,
-0.0672486797,
0.3122469187,
0.5571866035,
-0.5318680406,
0.5526621342,
0.0220088102,
-0.1807426363,
0.6141159534,
-0.6891625524,
-0.2805399299,
-0.1483511925,
0.3437843323,
-0.7364127636,
-0.3820956945,
0.1004322469,
-0.2845480144,
0.2933867574,
0.0730988234,
-0.7865009308,
-0.3030788302,
-0.0098333098,
0.3709345758,
0.3814305365,
-0.4618445039,
0.4091910124,
0.4325051308,
-0.0713873878,
-0.4970090389,
-0.5636892319,
0.4768058062,
-0.3667525351,
-0.7071159482,
0.0120671587,
0.1537385732,
-0.4849916101,
-0.1476528794,
-0.0472340956,
0.0196422562,
0.4039348066,
0.2685762942,
0.2640311122,
-0.1541159898,
0.4035896361,
0.0350246318,
-0.2097510844,
0.4326741099,
-0.4139852226,
0.2872745693,
0.0354697295,
-0.6924262643,
-0.0501798391,
0.3790028393,
0.5685813427,
0.0464655161,
0.8480856419,
0.3686334491,
-0.6977078319,
0.1484986097,
-0.8338370919,
-0.1581213623,
-0.3639020026,
0.2684566379,
-0.0200474281,
-1.1692841053,
0.5292166471,
-0.4222881198,
-0.1532143652,
0.4784085453,
0.7100144625,
0.1586055011,
0.8286688924,
0.5477913022,
-0.1949089915,
0.2825245559,
0.1919838339,
0.5035631061,
-0.7076926827,
-0.3959559202,
-0.5764350891,
0.1426798701,
-0.6112263203,
-0.5055866838,
0.4586189985,
0.2836500108,
-0.5140650868,
-0.0064043947,
0.0709518045,
0.2653366923,
0.5637688637,
0.039174743,
0.5883107185,
-0.2999783754,
0.0590631068,
0.1227837205,
-0.6395959258,
-0.6465268731,
0.9771142602,
0.4397599995,
0.8915781975,
0.1313809156,
0.3578007519,
0.1735381335,
0.4366358519,
-0.5719001293,
0.6530193686,
0.1532774568,
-0.7840433717,
-0.4500990212,
-0.4148363471,
-0.8697863221,
0.0880315155,
-0.2423578054,
-0.7802189589,
0.1547896564,
0.1558928192,
-0.0524293259,
0.426112771,
-0.5141120553,
0.8198798895,
-0.303162992,
-0.757576108,
-0.2710533142,
-0.7752875686,
0.6868254542,
-0.273272872,
0.3328062594,
-0.2398032695,
-0.0891472101,
0.6390534639,
-0.1929396391,
1.2233623266,
-0.0556712598,
-0.4597788453,
0.2215349823,
-0.1158972755,
0.5911856294,
0.1552026272,
0.1426334232,
0.4523386359,
-0.2004658878,
-0.2487604469,
-0.5183538795,
0.8731151819,
-0.4289469421,
-0.9180293679,
-0.4142937064,
-0.5989859104,
-0.3689286709,
0.3772254884,
0.0495404303,
0.4684686065,
-0.3620090485,
-0.0179855451,
0.7220211625,
-0.4376740456,
0.236208111,
0.7351152897,
-0.0186834466,
-0.2870726287,
0.8571364284,
-0.1121053174,
0.2592829168,
0.5498454571,
0.3530319035,
-0.5355014205,
-0.6176894903,
0.022585772,
0.452522099,
-0.87958318,
-0.1761631519,
-0.4044587314,
-0.118621856,
-0.3575948775,
-0.2366511971,
-0.1136687249,
-0.1944859773,
-0.2679831386,
-0.027905738,
0.2749789655,
0.6880027652,
-0.2703228593,
-0.0099478448,
-0.615925014,
0.2020893991,
0.3426165879,
0.2816520929,
0.053856656,
-0.2476301193,
-0.2763445973,
-0.1602394283,
-0.2279089838,
-0.8142343163,
0.0251981895,
-0.1872014999,
0.6465331912,
0.5128405094,
-0.0559788682,
0.5003585815,
-0.7194306254,
0.6510620713,
0.4378895164,
-0.8434299231,
0.4943003953,
-0.6676390767,
-0.0165199749,
0.0661213323,
0.5236252546,
-0.813385427,
-0.5588248968,
-0.4646961391,
-0.905541718,
0.1428018063,
-0.0646464303,
-0.1888873726,
-0.150350526,
0.3663711846,
-0.0428059399,
0.0216256771,
-0.6056208611,
-0.2579723299,
0.3436062038,
-0.0524451286,
-0.3966406584,
-0.3584060073,
-0.3701258302,
-0.2823316455,
0.6045588851,
-0.2205094993,
0.1560278982,
0.3580591083,
0.0069214329,
-0.2217888981,
0.3602252305,
0.8125786781,
0.8305151463,
0.1604668498,
0.4162197709,
0.2718553841,
-0.2280443311,
0.2506960034,
0.2458879352,
-0.2383664697,
-0.4119200408,
0.7397412658,
0.6582800746,
0.4216638207,
-0.7105165124,
0.3361537158,
0.1758231223,
-0.1143671498,
-0.4080659449,
-0.1437779218,
0.278128624,
0.5112121105,
0.3198285103,
-0.216321066,
0.1092775241,
-0.5016491413,
0.0077748736,
0.5797419548,
-0.2258564532,
-0.2040171921,
0.8886364102,
0.1914398372,
-0.0451919138,
0.0673646033,
0.0637283921,
-0.2704084814,
0.5434854031,
0.6548660398,
0.8498793244,
-0.1446351111,
-0.039095588,
0.2763940692,
0.5049526095,
-0.3796454668,
0.1248522103,
0.2926367819,
-0.8113933206,
-0.7879752517,
-0.4301069081,
-0.5579332709,
0.0874878615,
-0.3167374134,
0.1900770366,
-0.1941196918,
0.0100715272,
-0.229999274,
-0.0572622344,
-0.3352816403,
-0.0475819968,
0.1622390598,
0.8885293007,
-1.0842057467,
0.5561790466,
0.5773698092,
-0.3270599544,
-0.5382483006,
-0.1280465126,
0.2377688438,
-0.6471614242,
0.6964839101,
-0.0782540664,
-0.0455120206,
-0.011221217,
-0.5481388569,
-0.8882353306,
1.1245298386,
0.5735052824,
-0.5682782531,
0.0369683988,
0.1379183531,
0.4290505648,
-0.0046214368,
-0.0402450673,
0.7143149376,
0.6584271789,
-0.0134238163,
-0.7778656483,
0.5928654075,
0.2419428825,
-0.0309629813,
0.3459483385,
-0.4674463272,
0.6434255838,
-0.3268399537,
-0.0405435078,
-0.0961731225,
0.5934150815,
0.3992872536,
0.5972861052,
0.1742709875,
0.472409755,
0.8122825623,
-0.1103779376,
1.2073903084,
-0.1163301095,
0.2923825979,
0.8656079769,
-0.5189914107,
0.510368824,
0.6741776466,
-0.2312687486,
0.3458801508,
0.5399441123,
0.2440955788,
0.106630981,
0.2687804401,
-0.5828491449,
-0.424952656,
-0.335490942,
-0.2164365798,
0.1151216328,
0.3681990206,
-0.0237830151,
-0.3186742961,
-0.0507161245,
0.2433864027,
0.0564405918,
-0.2608368397,
0.4161501825,
0.5372262597,
-0.5812956095,
0.3002278805,
0.0171570275,
0.3239155114,
-0.646940589,
-0.0756512135,
-0.1072988212,
0.1573940068,
-0.1550309211,
-0.5623874068,
0.2912535071,
-0.127609238,
-0.0225151274,
-0.1578110307,
1.0140542984,
-0.2283624411,
-0.3923731744,
0.400477767,
0.7262865901,
-0.0319596641,
-0.0748211741,
-0.3608362973,
0.0804884881,
-0.4083337784,
-0.1358208954,
0.3287364841,
0.5391860604,
-0.3253359497,
0.8117604256,
0.7593287826,
0.316396445,
-0.0381865576,
0.150996685,
0.6723312736,
-0.9270053506,
-0.1442869455,
-1.0702818632,
0.2794520259,
0.0072511057,
-0.1123212874,
0.9393386245,
0.2192203403,
0.4662786722,
0.1487452835,
0.5743088126,
-0.0086415298,
0.25263834,
-0.7755677104,
0.5908918977,
-0.5481240749,
0.3949587345,
-0.2925523221,
-0.6571606994,
-0.6708343029,
0.0932455137,
-0.5201747417,
0.0234731436,
0.8986904621,
0.503528893,
0.2925565541,
-0.0331958979,
0.4443454146,
0.3117327094,
0.5365336537,
0.5808568001,
1.0829102993,
-0.1021776497,
0.1894159019,
0.2532823682,
-0.3815106452,
-0.291331619,
-1.1433695555,
-0.8134702444,
-0.4888041615,
-0.27388677,
-0.0542608015,
-0.0114685465,
0.5219737887,
0.2965464592,
-0.3919956386,
-0.3424438238,
-0.4211727083,
0.5807807446,
-0.1719030291,
-0.2354262173,
0.2561207414,
-0.4203376472,
-0.3446950912,
0.5072075129,
0.4225268662,
-0.1986166835,
-0.4177680612,
-0.1610095948,
-0.2194560766,
0.1310746372,
0.9862797856,
0.4570837021,
-0.8735434413,
-0.4133344293,
-0.1403985173,
0.0112744169,
-0.4498666823,
1.0734694004,
-0.4695771933,
0.0982451737,
0.525270164,
0.6712969542,
0.2664578259,
-0.5123254061,
0.6990340948,
-0.2714791298,
0.0479590446,
0.1622608453,
0.6895276308,
0.2602564692,
-0.2823446989,
0.4769506454,
0.5358273983,
-0.7111666799,
-0.9610828161,
0.5682484508,
-0.8037612438,
-0.3172591925,
1.2007197142,
0.0737164244,
0.0244878065,
-0.3637675643,
0.0338280015,
0.3809653223,
0.0335653722,
0.6463205218,
0.5673580766,
-0.2958740294,
0.0211572628,
-0.8044884801,
0.3730003536,
0.2400804013,
-1.0195132494,
0.1855555326,
0.6733227968,
0.1704576612,
-0.0505615436,
0.7155711055,
-0.2751112878,
0.1737692654,
-0.1304407567,
-0.0018404414,
0.0599808209,
-0.3686095178,
-0.4774592519,
-0.0506732352,
0.3249257803,
0.3562571704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.00034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.00034v1 | Text-Blueprint: An Interactive Platform for Plan-based Conditional Generation | 2023-04-28T18:14:48 | 2023-04-28T18:14:48 | Fantine Huot, Joshua Maynez, Shashi Narayan, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Kuzman Ganchev, Annie Louis, Anders Sandholm, Dipanjan Das, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | While conditional generation models can now generate natural language well
enough to create fluent text, it is still difficult to control the generation
process, leading to irrelevant, repetitive, and hallucinated content. Recent
work shows that planning can be a useful intermediate step to render
conditional generation less opaque and more grounded. We present a web
browser-based demonstration for query-focused summarization that uses a
sequence of question-answer pairs, as a blueprint plan for guiding text
generation (i.e., what to say and in what order). We illustrate how users may
interact with the generated text and associated plan visualizations, e.g., by
editing and modifying the blueprint in order to improve or control the
generated output.
A short video demonstrating our system is available at
https://goo.gle/text-blueprint-demo. | [
-0.3181371093,
-0.7407081127,
0.6455699801,
0.5889841318,
-0.0639620647,
0.0360115133,
-0.0159285553,
-0.3126205206,
0.6037726402,
0.7509109974,
-0.8927862048,
-0.4484010339,
0.0347294994,
0.1202828437,
-0.5683681965,
1.0909104347,
-0.0077436287,
-0.286781162,
-0.3330104053,
0.2555502951,
-0.5591804385,
-0.2248430103,
-0.7035899758,
-0.2054499388,
0.6373850703,
0.6846266985,
0.4691453576,
0.4400516748,
0.2947318852,
0.3398227692,
0.2357854247,
0.0621627457,
-0.7119697928,
0.6604748368,
-0.1962680966,
-0.50349617,
-0.7378448844,
-0.2490401715,
0.3663917184,
0.8304976821,
-0.0940910429,
0.0167809874,
-0.0869019702,
0.7451469898,
-0.6475453377,
0.4093033075,
-0.6346540451,
-0.0364567079,
0.2244310528,
-0.4002768695,
-0.5359743834,
-0.4225099981,
0.0071593891,
-0.694704771,
0.2997893393,
0.0687513426,
0.6521766186,
0.0805936158,
-0.5542119741,
-0.3769437969,
-0.7849191427,
0.3751577735,
-0.568056643,
0.0709611624,
0.4352096915,
0.5688135028,
0.0206010547,
-1.4153734446,
-0.7317201495,
0.0707065687,
-0.394385308,
0.7279375196,
0.003873934,
0.4600168467,
0.396243155,
0.1849867254,
-0.8603230119,
-0.1943517625,
-0.419513911,
-0.3643445075,
0.6965194345,
0.4908589423,
0.4109215438,
-0.2389350832,
-0.0297516156,
-0.065270789,
-0.5613151193,
0.0657130927,
0.2610680461,
0.4134699702,
-0.3894424438,
0.9163323045,
-0.7678649426,
0.7328566909,
0.0376385003,
0.0734406561,
-0.1380846053,
-0.6654464006,
-0.2990856469,
0.1255260706,
0.5591269732,
0.7776554227,
0.1185836717,
-0.1108233407,
-0.2703461647,
0.137210384,
0.0803458244,
-1.1724551916,
-0.478027761,
0.5273246169,
-0.2283743322,
-0.1891342252,
-0.076096572,
-0.7352362871,
-0.3037639856,
-0.1730609238,
0.2364707291,
-0.249001652,
0.1076784208,
0.1150772944,
-0.7334191203,
0.0811884403,
0.2832646966,
-1.0253721476,
0.3268228769,
0.345561862,
0.458901912,
0.2313477546,
-0.0683369115,
-0.4359251857,
0.6792428493,
-0.2796482444,
0.8525285125,
-0.1155061722,
-0.7669758797,
0.3104132414,
-0.367652446,
0.3653101921,
-0.1913002729,
0.1664423198,
-0.5238200426,
0.7342408895,
-0.6526805162,
-0.5792993903,
0.066299513,
0.3057655096,
-0.7167889476,
0.4443666935,
0.068784371,
-0.9817527533,
0.6689591408,
-0.5032683611,
-0.7428706288,
0.3156339228,
-0.602899611,
-0.1414432079,
-0.4440220892,
0.0124571435,
0.2541262507,
0.1305380911,
0.0575973131,
-0.0172283649,
-0.2222571224,
0.0209833886,
-0.0223779958,
0.5801851153,
0.0497449264,
-0.5814490318,
0.374409765,
-0.8109312057,
0.4636564851,
0.0291438531,
-0.6378473043,
0.166539982,
0.1462423503,
0.0796617717,
0.1006572172,
0.4963582754,
-0.25052315,
0.2173789889,
-0.5441515446,
0.107695125,
0.2098344713,
0.4261287153,
0.5519598126,
-0.5718644857,
0.6670040488,
-0.5191266537,
-0.1250447631,
-0.8207053542,
-0.6175074577,
-0.8791543841,
-0.043193765,
0.0514728725,
0.7391895652,
-1.0014894009,
-0.1868057996,
-0.2088443637,
-0.2724683583,
0.2840515375,
-0.0954973176,
0.5724555254,
0.71560359,
0.3359544873,
0.2282286137,
-0.7741655111,
-1.1173655987,
-0.1867617369,
-0.4434849322,
-0.0841697454,
0.0433681533,
0.2574058175,
0.1050746217,
1.2169545889,
-0.796936214,
0.1886360049,
-0.7966131568,
0.3681464493,
-0.1494674534,
0.3378598094,
0.3868705332,
-1.1281964779,
-0.7157483101,
-0.0472103991,
-0.5846221447,
-0.2923757136,
-0.3464154899,
-0.2401968837,
0.1236127615,
0.7392014265,
-0.6199169755,
0.6249116063,
0.2914917171,
-0.4489732981,
0.5398569107,
-0.1313536614,
0.1142882705,
-1.1910740137,
0.3049302697,
-0.359896183,
-0.2500646412,
-0.6810199022,
0.1171307638,
0.1676014066,
-0.479396373,
-0.2215993553,
0.7032436728,
-0.2956510484,
-0.0086890068,
-0.3625545204,
0.2592301369,
0.3303478062,
0.5621216297,
0.022859538,
0.7922634482,
-0.0504068062,
-0.6173983216,
0.0282837804,
0.4855756164,
0.0391576216,
0.2388220876,
-0.7071021795,
-0.178463161,
-0.1044501215,
0.4037245214,
-0.9561047554,
-0.6974227428,
0.1455805898,
-0.4835675061,
0.3093122244,
-0.0108027598,
-0.4632061124,
-0.2373332232,
-0.4392146766,
0.0702193975,
0.5333120823,
-0.1915695965,
0.5365632772,
0.2587510049,
-0.7894197702,
-0.25507918,
-0.8334852457,
0.2183772177,
0.0704762414,
-0.7113137841,
0.9104499221,
-0.2050832957,
-0.4806299806,
-0.0214018952,
0.1497187465,
-0.1929513663,
-0.1989853978,
0.4373623729,
0.0086783031,
-0.0306307711,
0.1331738979,
0.5871626139,
0.0252869278,
0.1607878953,
-0.0656381696,
0.528481245,
0.1557320952,
-0.116771251,
-0.2261800319,
0.7555474043,
0.3418962955,
-0.4115164876,
0.283726126,
0.0009289587,
-0.4516681135,
-0.5277200937,
-0.1744935662,
-0.1219954565,
-0.572974503,
0.2020059526,
-0.1937887669,
-0.4921553731,
0.4082055092,
-0.0020177891,
0.4396578968,
0.3507946134,
0.5510558486,
-0.3894002438,
1.0819447041,
0.9368209839,
0.6505177021,
0.2094482034,
-0.2789683342,
-0.0434386134,
-0.0852885842,
-0.4727264047,
-0.4373303652,
-0.2509160638,
-0.5264657736,
-0.0813135803,
0.1019244492,
0.2186339498,
0.0058660228,
-0.0162359737,
-0.2121073306,
0.3532270789,
0.5493177772,
0.0270359162,
0.2912794948,
-0.1714662611,
-0.3709129095,
0.1565700024,
-0.7028161883,
-0.6860721707,
0.7992479205,
-0.4322049916,
0.2070107609,
-0.0615055561,
0.8550444841,
0.1809488684,
0.4505634308,
-0.3556212485,
0.9399959445,
0.2600167096,
-0.8305898905,
-0.5672932863,
-0.3354804814,
-0.8311670423,
0.0095096044,
-0.5263398886,
-0.5832588673,
0.0623829328,
0.6866804957,
-0.2736271918,
0.0393438861,
-1.0793753862,
0.7272369862,
-0.1757560074,
-0.4954033196,
-0.2130793035,
-0.4698168039,
0.3212625384,
0.0710443556,
0.0564173348,
0.2016787082,
-0.091037102,
0.4060593545,
-0.671620965,
0.9011378288,
-0.1965215355,
0.3597594798,
0.4160052836,
0.1892929524,
0.4821314812,
-0.0097463718,
-0.045430284,
-0.7307087779,
-0.3048067689,
-0.5602465272,
-0.5262320638,
0.351687789,
0.0588436835,
-0.5605819225,
0.1427745819,
-0.5627233386,
-0.4784532487,
0.6462107897,
0.6668290496,
0.5592392087,
-0.4517452121,
0.008418167,
0.2052972615,
-0.4964869022,
0.7643614411,
0.3235743642,
-0.8063920736,
-0.4597004354,
0.9987777472,
-0.0253235921,
0.3077852428,
0.8405196667,
0.0891728699,
-0.3130783439,
-0.8038648367,
-0.3427753747,
0.0547761358,
-0.7452037334,
0.0320291817,
-0.7097491026,
-0.0114646545,
-0.3455171883,
-0.5955275893,
0.1761455089,
-0.9209406376,
0.0853469148,
-0.5148969889,
0.0253016241,
0.7701958418,
0.1869121343,
0.4687119722,
-0.3564922214,
0.4120147824,
0.8169779778,
0.0633770525,
-0.3327735662,
0.3044664562,
-0.1661059856,
0.1433746666,
-0.4767107964,
-1.1854323149,
0.3484417796,
-0.0024517539,
0.3523453176,
0.4195787907,
0.2090963423,
0.43243137,
-0.4367705882,
0.6678358316,
0.20455724,
-0.7105044723,
0.8631917834,
-0.6861950755,
0.641308248,
0.8096265793,
0.2291141003,
-0.3464918733,
-0.7873519063,
-0.5294029117,
-0.9850071669,
0.3561513424,
0.5004463792,
-0.0372898132,
-0.0474129245,
0.3031589091,
0.0859635919,
0.5523222089,
-0.6912873983,
-0.3247347176,
-0.6533248425,
-0.1632841676,
0.0035593256,
-0.4367322326,
0.0374408588,
0.1732401699,
0.4335590899,
-0.0389983132,
0.0874103084,
0.2959488034,
-0.0041595404,
0.1345267445,
0.2515935004,
0.7549758554,
0.910898149,
-0.3688104451,
-0.0326333195,
0.0299200248,
-0.4333561361,
-0.3210978508,
0.2630078197,
-0.7881636024,
0.1005663574,
0.5426822305,
0.5756942034,
0.2270258069,
-0.8388786316,
0.3797258437,
-0.2346326113,
-0.6266182661,
0.0329897553,
0.1690559983,
0.499601692,
0.0460757241,
0.3278526068,
-0.4009741247,
0.4344536066,
-0.5339955091,
0.1923891902,
0.2506628335,
-0.3393341899,
-0.2692579329,
0.8715730309,
0.5423145294,
-0.5444113016,
0.3336241543,
-0.5460081697,
-0.4747126102,
0.7795827389,
0.651486218,
0.6861526966,
0.1593237966,
0.3964468837,
0.3161330819,
0.3629363477,
0.522266984,
0.9804370999,
-0.2177808434,
-0.358302623,
-0.4335318208,
-0.1681530476,
-0.671010375,
-0.0647611022,
-0.6336508393,
0.3942247331,
-0.6099977493,
-0.2369561642,
0.004270121,
-0.1055356711,
-0.4820694625,
0.4922560751,
-0.0743866339,
0.9723457694,
-0.6087529659,
0.3952513337,
0.8785226941,
-0.579262495,
-0.8219681382,
0.1383683234,
-0.1938177496,
-0.3792496026,
0.503780961,
0.3074825704,
-0.0905634314,
-0.0263171811,
-0.3269104958,
-0.2988956273,
1.2692359686,
0.2474894375,
-0.5019126534,
-0.3740004003,
0.1429497302,
0.5459352136,
0.0096948827,
0.0646430105,
-0.0882560685,
0.6222105026,
-0.0343078338,
-0.5348315835,
0.1977531761,
-0.4127545357,
-0.4959202111,
0.369250685,
-0.5034979582,
0.5973923206,
-0.3149533272,
-0.6403101087,
0.0522628985,
0.7632876635,
0.2230709493,
0.7169750929,
0.4687724113,
0.2203814089,
0.7508437037,
0.0710779577,
1.1033878326,
-0.5069022775,
-0.2732940018,
1.3938574791,
-0.2364732921,
0.9094522595,
0.3539694846,
0.1525472552,
0.4976989329,
0.2094763964,
0.3510374129,
0.6450154781,
0.0512416363,
-0.3971325755,
-0.1525615752,
0.0444284938,
-0.3736611903,
0.23094818,
0.3165104389,
-0.1102171689,
-0.257689178,
-0.2932886183,
0.03080987,
0.3787173033,
-0.2604785264,
0.6505057216,
-0.2168226391,
-0.8680679798,
0.0281515811,
0.1162279546,
0.1653230786,
-0.7562794685,
-0.2263086587,
-0.6762968302,
-0.3240317106,
-0.249834165,
-0.6527178884,
0.2724824548,
0.1014366746,
-0.4329934716,
-0.5696925521,
0.735316813,
-0.3098780513,
-0.3576107323,
0.0181158036,
0.617438972,
-0.2597506642,
0.0257911552,
-0.2552638352,
-0.4020775259,
0.2758673429,
-0.2291620672,
0.0370667093,
0.3539878428,
-0.0879276171,
0.7310330868,
0.5856060386,
0.0535255298,
0.3377260566,
-0.0379911065,
0.8684559464,
-0.8208442926,
-0.9274872541,
-0.574267149,
0.7989632487,
-0.4629607201,
-0.4470568597,
0.71614182,
1.0900348425,
0.7217492461,
0.0295063965,
0.9107145071,
0.0087086009,
0.4711141288,
-0.5848981738,
0.8892460465,
-0.5250644088,
0.184199512,
-0.1985214949,
-0.612585783,
-0.1533159018,
0.0064997221,
-0.0479983836,
-0.0704749674,
0.8055089712,
0.6747947335,
0.1213059351,
0.0527952872,
0.128011167,
0.1161705106,
0.452545315,
0.200395152,
0.8176900744,
0.1946261227,
1.0158669949,
-0.5346072912,
-0.2528648078,
-0.0606840216,
-1.0097763538,
-0.9636054635,
-0.6710208058,
-0.1466389745,
0.0461487062,
0.1530701518,
0.3176125884,
0.6853507757,
-0.462333113,
-0.2555850148,
-0.5819874406,
0.1314345449,
0.256254673,
-0.2258652598,
0.178903535,
-0.2639140189,
-0.4753319323,
0.4802342653,
0.4514003992,
0.3148846328,
-0.1223796457,
0.0940634683,
0.1167048588,
0.2346587479,
0.6691639423,
0.622718215,
-0.2702207267,
0.184562698,
-0.0107238116,
-0.2640403509,
-0.2936477959,
1.0056273937,
-0.8513628244,
0.4374927878,
0.6937639713,
0.384683907,
0.8185747266,
0.0618574247,
1.0030069351,
-0.7701705694,
0.1571720839,
0.2882872522,
0.2811824381,
0.1416134685,
-0.2218748927,
0.1272518337,
-0.185080871,
-0.3539105654,
-0.625130415,
0.4534946978,
-1.0381256342,
-0.5094178319,
0.7418882251,
0.2714743316,
0.2479150593,
-0.1098935232,
-0.4971120656,
0.2505022883,
-0.2897061408,
0.6216658354,
0.2367331535,
-0.3339937627,
0.2585067451,
-0.5800972581,
0.638112843,
0.4246470332,
-1.3065652847,
-0.1377480477,
0.8426904678,
-0.1731028855,
0.0562543869,
1.1466350555,
0.3452807367,
0.3992700279,
0.3257695138,
0.2460921109,
-0.1757478118,
-0.3023673594,
0.2622796893,
0.3973898292,
-0.0935995802,
-0.0652944967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.15010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.15010v1 | LLaMA-Adapter V2: Parameter-Efficient Visual Instruction Model | 2023-04-28T17:59:25 | 2023-04-28T17:59:25 | Peng Gao, Jiaming Han, Renrui Zhang, Ziyi Lin, Shijie Geng, Aojun Zhou, Wei Zhang, Pan Lu, Conghui He, Xiangyu Yue, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | How to efficiently transform large language models (LLMs) into instruction
followers is recently a popular research direction, while training LLM for
multi-modal reasoning remains less explored. Although the recent LLaMA-Adapter
demonstrates the potential to handle visual inputs with LLMs, it still cannot
generalize well to open-ended visual instructions and lags behind GPT-4. In
this paper, we present LLaMA-Adapter V2, a parameter-efficient visual
instruction model. Specifically, we first augment LLaMA-Adapter by unlocking
more learnable parameters (e.g., norm, bias and scale), which distribute the
instruction-following ability across the entire LLaMA model besides adapters.
Secondly, we propose an early fusion strategy to feed visual tokens only into
the early LLM layers, contributing to better visual knowledge incorporation.
Thirdly, a joint training paradigm of image-text pairs and
instruction-following data is introduced by optimizing disjoint groups of
learnable parameters. This strategy effectively alleviates the interference
between the two tasks of image-text alignment and instruction following and
achieves strong multi-modal reasoning with only a small-scale image-text and
instruction dataset. During inference, we incorporate additional expert models
(e.g. captioning/OCR systems) into LLaMA-Adapter to further enhance its image
understanding capability without incurring training costs. Compared to the
original LLaMA-Adapter, our LLaMA-Adapter V2 can perform open-ended multi-modal
instructions by merely introducing 14M parameters over LLaMA. The newly
designed framework also exhibits stronger language-only instruction-following
capabilities and even excels in chat interactions. Our code and models are
available at https://github.com/ZrrSkywalker/LLaMA-Adapter. | [
-0.0968888551,
-0.7132891417,
0.5877540708,
0.15439035,
-0.614823699,
-0.1905784756,
-0.1528422982,
-0.429744482,
-0.1392058581,
0.4748475254,
-0.4113291502,
-0.3859545588,
-0.7463299036,
-0.2163713127,
-0.0662214011,
0.6582847834,
-0.2612558007,
0.0846903324,
-0.3506421745,
-0.0491840616,
-0.5792700052,
-0.1867123842,
-0.367511332,
-0.0832010284,
0.6175783277,
0.610283792,
0.4609079957,
0.919649601,
0.454914242,
0.3059364855,
0.1236773059,
0.444111079,
-0.7156684995,
0.0893437564,
0.1604550034,
-0.7041975856,
-0.3723091185,
-0.20911026,
0.6199926138,
0.2146471292,
0.0272392761,
0.2374421656,
-0.0422095247,
0.4848088324,
-0.484954834,
0.3996685743,
-0.6534059644,
-0.2182572633,
-0.0164231192,
-0.2451179475,
-0.5134317875,
-0.1814828664,
-0.0659674034,
-0.7573753595,
-0.2785244584,
0.0661673471,
0.6474694014,
0.5870623589,
-0.3557074964,
0.0044922703,
-0.465013057,
0.7682721019,
-0.4326803088,
0.5866291523,
0.1483168155,
0.4745208323,
-0.1806622744,
-0.8568669558,
-0.6163893938,
-0.1068205088,
0.1117764413,
0.1324375421,
-0.2235803008,
0.0217680819,
-0.0300667193,
-0.0408625342,
-0.3547126949,
0.4064197838,
-0.4759544432,
-0.057876844,
0.2869798243,
0.0241468716,
0.2120056599,
0.0285241008,
-0.8111734986,
-0.1044131517,
-0.7269409299,
0.0943243355,
0.0791462138,
-0.1369557679,
-0.2560758293,
0.5626608133,
-0.1490844786,
0.8678061962,
0.0893460363,
-0.4684594572,
-0.0807327852,
-0.4665374756,
0.0047428948,
-0.2260773629,
0.5141048431,
0.600150764,
0.0254075509,
0.0345221385,
-0.1604989171,
-0.1175463125,
0.1113734171,
-1.0358688831,
-0.2208824158,
-0.2973238826,
-0.6652407646,
-0.1259040534,
-0.1837055236,
-0.7741217613,
-0.449157089,
-0.3053433001,
0.6049033403,
-0.3044189513,
-0.0027047731,
0.0403014794,
-0.0610681176,
0.7421626449,
0.8778564334,
-0.8687798381,
0.1279062033,
0.6273534894,
0.7675347328,
-0.086311318,
-0.3555029929,
-0.5924293399,
0.3136889935,
-0.1952262074,
0.9474546313,
-0.8861849308,
-0.1647149026,
-0.3007855713,
-0.0586034171,
-0.1650033146,
-0.2899923027,
0.136794731,
-0.6652671695,
0.1580077857,
-0.2686110735,
-0.3932220936,
-0.6425973177,
0.1168057323,
-0.4969557524,
0.7957506776,
0.0682378635,
-0.3864703476,
0.1525364965,
-0.5245264769,
-0.1696689874,
0.0207352322,
-0.3415705562,
-0.1632801145,
-0.0093323849,
0.4386359751,
0.3954290152,
-0.4906229377,
-0.1244213656,
-0.4043424129,
-0.6142744422,
-0.0176825095,
-0.6928868294,
0.447320044,
-0.1281398833,
-0.238948375,
0.2480619848,
-0.6175284386,
-0.1736046672,
0.1795406789,
-0.5605665445,
-0.1919666231,
0.0471555702,
-0.2283790708,
0.0628342554,
0.489948988,
-0.0858605802,
0.4889015853,
0.0086172754,
0.3123412728,
0.9117603302,
-0.088152267,
0.5008234978,
-0.0239350442,
0.3921076059,
-0.041112598,
0.2798971832,
-0.4801173806,
-0.6560468078,
-1.0343129635,
-0.5353178978,
0.042173665,
0.7193931937,
-1.0186295509,
0.1309976429,
-0.2906734943,
-0.4907253981,
-0.6017096639,
0.5406664014,
0.5054536462,
0.6035932302,
0.3434713185,
-0.1543743014,
-0.4394590855,
-0.824860394,
-0.0122797489,
-0.3208279312,
0.1475472003,
0.1962994486,
0.3299942911,
-0.2567798793,
0.3334548771,
-0.325137645,
-0.0109108035,
-0.3565034866,
-0.2842355967,
0.0921495333,
0.2554882765,
0.5384943485,
-0.5203309059,
-0.3200844824,
0.1709054857,
-0.8000930548,
0.0394446366,
-0.1624599248,
-0.337257266,
0.053866677,
0.523882091,
-0.3080604672,
0.3692403138,
0.536242485,
-0.1925958693,
0.1627482474,
-0.1495905817,
0.0140131125,
-1.0005902052,
-0.2496093959,
0.0708718151,
-0.1166609824,
-0.6335157752,
0.1904869974,
0.0756152347,
0.1850494891,
-0.3657112718,
0.4639028311,
-0.5748226047,
-0.0156480316,
-0.4373013377,
-0.0150115686,
0.0560877174,
0.6913240552,
0.0491831191,
0.9877557755,
0.6639956832,
-0.3072609007,
0.4388348758,
0.2047446221,
-0.2574944198,
0.4908836782,
-0.646166563,
0.2913746834,
-0.2058605105,
0.2603592277,
-1.0622445345,
-0.2393291444,
0.5386000276,
-0.1114049032,
0.2223605961,
-0.2871762514,
-0.3888781369,
-0.1833114624,
-0.440790385,
0.4044937193,
0.6087132692,
-0.8772284985,
0.9078021646,
0.0666120574,
-0.1573057026,
-0.4651753306,
-0.5910428166,
0.0822626278,
-0.113994658,
-0.6554646492,
0.1726460457,
-0.0758512691,
-0.0116325589,
-0.0286775529,
-0.1157418489,
-0.1576135904,
-0.0641988292,
0.1620163471,
0.5367838144,
-0.4927811325,
-0.047523208,
0.3778648674,
-0.2812630236,
-0.1472741663,
-0.1460171044,
0.4100817442,
-0.2328050733,
-0.4940523207,
-0.7690881491,
0.263240248,
0.6042704582,
-0.2788640261,
0.6672651172,
0.6989364028,
-0.1240233183,
0.0557202697,
-0.6482390761,
-0.1066207513,
-0.4747887552,
0.680836916,
-0.2728067636,
-0.7258237004,
0.1516488045,
-0.21810022,
0.1750926226,
0.0514166281,
0.5566492081,
-0.0271876138,
0.8328024149,
0.6215043664,
0.0098880315,
0.6692557335,
-0.0915601924,
0.0973191261,
-0.8465269208,
-0.4293554425,
0.0499524064,
-0.3806854784,
-0.1870370507,
-0.996437192,
0.4228590131,
0.3247747719,
-0.0892580077,
0.1717675477,
-0.3486009836,
0.5389083624,
0.6574032903,
0.4122806191,
0.1566315144,
0.0284460336,
0.3252268434,
0.13453722,
-0.76000458,
-0.530606091,
1.0117737055,
0.4389110208,
0.9448299408,
0.1299653351,
0.5405785441,
-0.1475127339,
0.1926085353,
-0.8953410983,
0.7553814054,
-0.1104530022,
0.0169075448,
-0.0197123662,
-0.0305190831,
-0.4557257295,
0.5252114534,
-0.2185250223,
-0.6434395313,
0.2540432215,
0.2964104712,
-0.1272661239,
0.3618447483,
-0.9658460021,
0.6666052938,
-0.5020897985,
-0.451551646,
-0.1986034662,
-0.7288194299,
0.511902988,
-0.0608161688,
0.0258263834,
0.023751881,
-0.7016132474,
0.5399032831,
-0.2833901346,
1.1163833141,
-0.2321579605,
-0.1292808205,
0.3775165379,
-0.1754275709,
0.5819074512,
-0.0332574062,
-0.0689666048,
0.0910698622,
-0.3204225004,
-0.3276458681,
-0.8501910567,
0.6426142454,
-0.8560571074,
-0.843631506,
0.0803667605,
-0.6627362967,
0.0969277173,
0.1070696563,
-0.1770457923,
0.318836391,
0.2094334215,
0.2522515953,
0.6776943803,
-0.0279577225,
0.3874852955,
0.4155713916,
-0.047617536,
-0.6181595922,
1.0996596813,
-0.0358197354,
0.3650024831,
0.4822926521,
0.135161534,
-0.1804238111,
-0.5540069938,
-0.8424509168,
0.2259806842,
-0.9646180272,
-0.2806135118,
-0.3729284406,
-0.0482630059,
-0.0327197276,
-0.2123755813,
-0.1790559292,
-0.2845831513,
-0.6656909585,
0.1540617645,
0.5654492974,
0.5149761438,
0.1512714624,
0.5882108808,
-0.5793190598,
0.4843646288,
0.6896024346,
0.3251064718,
0.0983926728,
-0.7744571567,
-0.0300504658,
-0.1693997979,
-0.2967299819,
-0.9526206851,
-0.1553525478,
0.2726826072,
0.6944497824,
0.6272602081,
-0.3142064214,
0.9242908359,
-0.5159721971,
0.6664190888,
0.3004786074,
-0.7710433602,
0.4381381273,
-0.1443848908,
0.2431748509,
0.3840216696,
0.1485825926,
-0.0843955874,
0.0635174587,
-0.0126905367,
-0.5881147385,
0.6794384122,
-0.1982178986,
0.1546858251,
0.290640831,
0.594884634,
0.2634711564,
-0.0512161292,
-0.7510151267,
-0.096977599,
-0.3948808014,
-0.29502666,
0.2007533014,
-0.4541052878,
-0.0256843418,
-0.5328564048,
0.4247335196,
-0.356772691,
0.3276799321,
-0.1378591806,
-0.2589960992,
0.0475470647,
-0.054416202,
0.66715765,
0.484090507,
0.2936961651,
0.2944442034,
0.445228219,
-0.385953635,
0.0984864682,
0.2728284001,
-0.0911524072,
-0.3049117327,
0.5206454396,
1.1580984592,
0.3881660104,
-0.5214210749,
0.6294717193,
0.015219328,
-0.1474851966,
0.0823311359,
0.3309235573,
0.1778312922,
0.6750449538,
0.1762052029,
0.1685916632,
0.0003023886,
-0.2683778107,
-0.0181354936,
0.3500109315,
-0.2317075431,
-0.3736621141,
0.7048978209,
0.298101306,
-0.255512327,
0.3269428611,
0.142752111,
-0.389526099,
0.3411050439,
0.7445146441,
0.4495046735,
-0.3106002808,
0.0956668258,
0.0488007069,
0.4166023433,
0.0701557025,
0.3608283103,
-0.2040931582,
-0.3850694001,
-0.4786066115,
-0.2764828801,
-0.307379514,
-0.2490197569,
-0.3990376294,
0.525965631,
-0.5465375781,
0.2599660158,
-0.3029920459,
-0.4154749811,
-0.6435135007,
-0.2384457439,
0.2222338617,
0.8973748088,
-0.6145021915,
0.8466070294,
0.6930205822,
-0.4816384614,
-0.6160773039,
-0.1022099555,
0.1291868985,
-1.4847043753,
0.4364824593,
0.4288181663,
-0.2585507631,
0.0502453968,
-0.6930203438,
-0.8458763957,
1.4053379297,
0.4809757471,
-0.666690886,
-0.0508690961,
-0.1274509281,
0.1779536754,
-0.2906594574,
0.3202002347,
0.40338552,
0.5587871075,
0.4020326436,
-0.5050323009,
0.2064390481,
-0.2717739046,
0.2203667313,
0.0684929565,
-0.815620482,
0.5494306684,
-0.5166704655,
0.0277250409,
0.3687923849,
0.9491422772,
0.1916747242,
0.0983486921,
0.600702405,
0.4044265449,
0.5250245929,
0.1120335311,
0.93383497,
-0.1883980185,
-0.2592875957,
0.9471530318,
-0.0383583307,
1.0552890301,
0.6839647889,
0.1047648713,
0.6551805139,
0.4721058607,
-0.1409072727,
0.6332346201,
-0.042949494,
-0.2554910779,
-0.4582265019,
-0.0566370673,
-0.3385672867,
0.5757746696,
0.260476172,
-0.4140094519,
-0.1866943836,
-0.0047254125,
-0.0009220657,
-0.0854432359,
-0.2170629948,
1.0680215359,
-0.0526685268,
-0.3307716548,
0.5706478357,
-0.1185360625,
0.5337056518,
-0.5172818303,
-0.4745230079,
-0.0552500598,
-0.0183212906,
-0.0473546945,
-0.6453142166,
-0.1785058528,
0.0040647401,
-0.177434504,
0.0842562094,
0.8051086068,
-0.4367067814,
-0.5825847983,
0.1393968761,
0.4937555194,
0.1549487412,
0.2656821311,
-0.5145617127,
0.4047026336,
0.0116886776,
-0.1728453338,
0.3076665998,
0.3584973514,
-0.0064725922,
0.5738403201,
0.6052795649,
-0.1395388246,
0.1794103682,
0.0081345141,
1.2676454782,
-0.3557536304,
-0.1066637635,
-0.7514173388,
0.6268128157,
0.0659538731,
-0.1846498251,
0.4694980681,
0.2365646213,
0.5512700081,
0.0473272055,
0.6084846854,
0.2911557853,
-0.0570570268,
-0.6918539405,
0.3720762134,
-0.5895839334,
0.404617846,
-0.0075761992,
-0.9656579494,
-0.3211965561,
0.5647670627,
-0.3729470074,
0.0221099276,
0.3265322745,
0.8490205407,
-0.1224345714,
-0.0109373359,
0.1601239741,
0.062554881,
0.3326632977,
0.5760405064,
0.8530578613,
-0.4371358156,
0.8080865145,
-0.0897273347,
-0.4900456667,
-0.4117658734,
-0.719891727,
-1.0024557114,
-0.3208982646,
-0.0380129702,
0.0523351878,
0.2730388641,
0.8227680326,
0.6442819238,
-0.2150812894,
-0.0548545755,
-0.0238286033,
0.2221865654,
-0.1924327761,
-0.1282936484,
0.2586196959,
-0.1773716956,
-0.6219408512,
0.5779960752,
0.3592643142,
0.0900002122,
-0.2660068274,
-0.2862310708,
-0.0304838121,
0.1034882441,
0.8461520672,
0.1691051573,
-1.0880811214,
-0.41325894,
0.0682360828,
0.1577940136,
0.1544139981,
0.3381067216,
-0.6374972463,
0.634860456,
0.3534782231,
0.8666690588,
0.3373901844,
-0.0704499632,
0.4460425675,
-0.2389787436,
0.1947589219,
-0.2054570764,
0.359985441,
0.2661902606,
-0.2320518494,
0.1437193155,
0.0909062997,
-0.3461590409,
-0.5902021527,
0.22783494,
-1.1487084627,
-0.1343170851,
1.1917170286,
0.0007955078,
-0.3919008374,
0.2759698033,
-0.6626954079,
0.2722453773,
-0.3762406111,
0.5741433501,
0.2301780581,
-0.1948052645,
-0.7654765844,
-0.4131779671,
-0.135167256,
0.2004186958,
-1.0243166685,
-0.1957369596,
0.5331330895,
0.1733670235,
-0.2145922184,
0.3667030931,
0.022114072,
0.5366221666,
0.2413752228,
-0.0138674537,
-0.4678316116,
-0.4928360283,
-0.2988861799,
-0.0422826968,
0.1653907895,
-0.5653855205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14999v1 | Empirical Analysis of the Strengths and Weaknesses of PEFT Techniques for LLMs | 2023-04-28T17:39:49 | 2023-04-28T17:39:49 | George Pu, Anirudh Jain, Jihan Yin, Russell Kaplan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As foundation models continue to exponentially scale in size, efficient
methods of adaptation become increasingly critical. Parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT), a recent class of techniques that require only modifying a
small percentage of the model parameters, is currently the most popular method
for adapting large language models (LLMs). Several PEFT techniques have
recently been proposed with varying tradeoffs. We provide a comprehensive and
uniform benchmark of various PEFT techniques across a representative LLM, the
FLAN-T5 model, and evaluate model performance across different data scales of
classification and generation datasets. Based on this, we provide a framework
for choosing the optimal fine-tuning techniques given the task type and data
availability. Contrary to popular belief, we also empirically prove that PEFT
techniques converge slower than full tuning in low data scenarios, and posit
the amount of data required for PEFT methods to both perform well and converge
efficiently. Lastly, we further optimize these PEFT techniques by selectively
choosing which parts of the model to train, and find that these techniques can
be applied with significantly fewer parameters while maintaining and even
improving performance. | [
-0.5362443328,
-0.8865756989,
0.5869622231,
0.2730325162,
-0.142058298,
0.0804919899,
-0.5836212635,
-0.3146695793,
-0.4874124229,
0.5243151784,
-0.4386233687,
-0.212945357,
-0.4781168401,
0.1925811172,
-0.480641067,
0.8163120747,
-0.1227034032,
-0.1069753245,
0.0624346398,
-0.0118300971,
-0.1850793362,
-0.4243169427,
-0.913110733,
-0.4641146064,
0.1392197013,
0.6571860909,
0.4309702814,
0.5693343878,
0.7241805792,
0.2134435773,
-0.0820726752,
0.0755021945,
-0.7907643914,
-0.0467264429,
-0.3749936223,
-0.4570622742,
-0.5128092766,
-0.1903618574,
0.7924927473,
1.0199776888,
-0.1666315347,
0.3707635105,
0.1191509962,
0.8200959563,
-0.6176796556,
-0.2411193997,
-0.8903778791,
0.027930934,
-0.3391352594,
-0.1949802786,
-0.3878228962,
-0.2677173913,
0.2281898707,
-0.2555364668,
0.433201611,
0.0621100143,
0.7366952896,
0.2274863571,
-0.465062201,
0.0081711859,
-0.8941943645,
1.1057850122,
-0.7185470462,
0.484242171,
0.3708296418,
0.2510980666,
-0.2043590546,
-0.6226428151,
-0.0723400638,
-0.2310787886,
0.1740145236,
-0.2815305889,
-0.0024631314,
0.1812498569,
0.3120958507,
0.5770922899,
-0.2874918878,
0.2764399052,
-0.1062671095,
-0.1054719016,
0.6166103482,
0.133741051,
-0.1271059066,
0.382866323,
-0.272629261,
-0.2500795126,
-0.8691055179,
0.142983675,
0.3432986736,
0.4197722077,
0.0693725869,
0.4022915065,
-0.282135129,
0.8811385036,
0.5456579924,
-0.574164927,
0.0230682157,
-0.4150215685,
-0.4049344957,
-0.2632219791,
0.4716330171,
0.4209834635,
0.3791959882,
-0.1889334172,
-0.5543524623,
-0.3103981018,
0.1300633401,
-0.8266657591,
-0.1720836759,
0.0554584339,
-0.6322791576,
-0.3279951215,
-0.1914846003,
-0.7910720706,
-0.3365794122,
-0.2889076769,
0.4263678789,
-0.4338463247,
-0.2963561118,
0.0782325193,
-0.049903065,
0.4077461064,
0.3731046319,
-1.0666612387,
0.6084371209,
0.6661764979,
0.7632742524,
-0.2849978805,
-0.1819729358,
-0.5380451083,
-0.077528961,
-0.4133780301,
0.8916746378,
-0.4821591377,
-0.2867411673,
-0.328684181,
0.098358959,
-0.5678675175,
-0.7644076347,
0.7619398236,
-0.20973593,
-0.3230028749,
-0.3670696616,
-0.70524472,
-0.1167626753,
0.0736439303,
-0.5555265546,
0.905390799,
0.4167765379,
-0.4543413818,
0.4721929133,
-0.5218189359,
-0.5131708384,
-0.4402361512,
0.1273724884,
-0.5861998796,
0.5604748726,
0.1863651425,
0.74360466,
-0.520780623,
0.0425424017,
-0.5539129972,
-0.3879151344,
0.1002994105,
-0.3860163093,
0.3742016554,
0.3379606009,
-0.5339734554,
-0.2002726048,
-0.9383233786,
0.0157546774,
0.1751058251,
-0.4889668524,
-0.0976471752,
0.3113048375,
0.1017712504,
-0.1949286461,
0.0826643631,
-0.3260360956,
0.0755959377,
-0.5544026494,
0.4846248031,
0.7951381803,
0.1304493248,
0.4775362611,
-0.548954308,
0.4211250246,
-0.3044087291,
0.0051890272,
0.130323112,
0.045613654,
-0.6864371896,
-0.0877028555,
0.4815399051,
0.3446263373,
-0.2335249186,
0.2919233739,
-0.1797690988,
-0.607060492,
-0.0413031764,
0.4006671309,
0.1360356361,
0.5176165104,
0.0497574247,
-0.0793531165,
-0.3479082584,
-1.0888524055,
-0.4315448999,
-0.0850920975,
0.0706469864,
0.3152944446,
0.347135663,
0.2221852988,
0.644115746,
-0.0547849126,
0.1039891914,
-0.1200425625,
-0.0649198592,
0.3385109603,
0.4686402678,
0.9952626824,
-0.7334688902,
-0.6645208597,
0.2179327458,
-0.2341771871,
-0.3509129584,
-0.1719213724,
0.061683543,
0.2774522901,
0.2606990039,
-0.1670836508,
-0.0256807674,
0.5640338063,
-0.4576922059,
0.3701661825,
0.0397662744,
0.2998007834,
-0.5400232077,
0.0968295783,
0.137513712,
-0.4412568808,
-0.6892945766,
0.0603172854,
0.187895298,
0.0135703664,
-0.3697263598,
0.3441833854,
-0.4779452085,
0.009960182,
-0.2194696665,
-0.2749971747,
-0.1715676934,
0.3143954277,
0.0170792621,
0.9284329414,
0.4972709715,
-0.7330386639,
0.1414455622,
-0.2660106421,
-0.2507968247,
0.6717733741,
-0.5939225554,
0.1930746734,
0.1022980884,
-0.1622225046,
-0.9254254103,
-0.1512526572,
-0.0581714958,
0.0393053107,
0.4918997586,
-0.1702181846,
-0.4916139245,
-0.0615949407,
-0.5955563784,
-0.0118568931,
0.5918536186,
-0.6617232561,
0.7488498688,
0.1123349294,
-0.0373516865,
-0.2448580563,
-0.4932143688,
-0.1520928442,
-0.7269855738,
-0.6907698512,
0.49682495,
-0.1532094032,
-0.2481022626,
-0.343265444,
-0.4340474606,
-0.0327052549,
0.5111371279,
-0.0367623419,
-0.360257417,
-0.3584192991,
-0.1395458728,
0.3032178283,
0.0942659229,
-0.1451807469,
-0.1227498874,
0.3383497596,
-0.3958371878,
-0.2085380256,
-0.013924785,
0.0899847224,
0.756970644,
0.0166028496,
0.7476225495,
0.5568215847,
-0.3629432023,
-0.4251260757,
-0.8321486115,
-0.1209094226,
-0.4785367846,
0.4168067276,
-0.5927906632,
-0.7000769377,
0.448079139,
-0.6659703255,
0.1766590923,
0.5042148829,
0.7227061391,
-0.0536747724,
0.8711070418,
0.9007307887,
-0.0122660389,
0.5780119896,
-0.0684671327,
0.0188432466,
-0.618240118,
0.0816807598,
-0.5968121886,
-0.3285039067,
-0.4111903012,
-0.0228503495,
0.2581141591,
0.5254634619,
-0.3294054866,
0.3182171583,
-0.3901393116,
0.3466623425,
0.3499064445,
0.1785814762,
0.3372153342,
0.3448598683,
0.1139560491,
0.067806676,
-0.7803440094,
-0.57914114,
1.3723298311,
0.5688601732,
0.8522498012,
0.1172919646,
0.449277699,
0.141861707,
0.1978440285,
-0.5534359217,
0.4387313724,
-0.4401537478,
-0.4882966876,
-0.3156088591,
-0.2333920151,
-0.7072824836,
0.1064255536,
-0.2196950763,
-0.6836615801,
0.3907548487,
0.2999539971,
-0.3992985785,
0.3956207037,
-0.9790061116,
0.8179963231,
-0.4305183589,
-0.4489606619,
-0.1078752801,
-0.3900130987,
0.1440106779,
-0.6931455135,
0.0539778024,
-0.3579034805,
-0.3460462689,
0.7573744059,
-0.4337692261,
0.8233453035,
-0.2773242593,
-0.199045673,
0.1244800016,
-0.0668196604,
0.6914907098,
-0.1092139482,
-0.4069216251,
-0.0127627123,
0.3769961596,
-0.4448941946,
-0.4042610824,
0.7440767288,
-0.863663733,
-0.4149004221,
0.0191923715,
-0.2553712428,
-0.6156354547,
0.1352923065,
0.2376077473,
0.0685495213,
-0.2519903779,
0.6455588937,
0.7056978345,
0.0482997112,
0.4834702015,
0.5486850739,
-0.0945598856,
-0.2344740182,
0.8650848866,
0.3193199933,
0.4008480906,
0.4035533667,
0.3318202198,
-0.1488152444,
-1.1597799063,
-0.2013915628,
0.234751597,
-0.5527998805,
-0.1942097545,
-0.1951953322,
0.1312983185,
-0.2215373665,
-0.2892672122,
-0.5019267201,
-0.4253911376,
-0.2735765576,
-0.0247621424,
0.43092978,
0.3075457811,
0.1358973235,
0.4685745537,
-0.4866986573,
0.1954006702,
0.1920933574,
0.5711873174,
-0.1698533893,
-0.6115829349,
-0.181282565,
-0.1341109574,
-0.311181426,
-0.7742046714,
0.0201569255,
0.6594080925,
0.6257232428,
0.3516790569,
0.1079713032,
0.6371135116,
-0.3477933109,
0.6809594631,
-0.1481634378,
-0.8519713879,
0.6530151963,
-0.402369529,
-0.1457411051,
0.7771893144,
0.2368593961,
0.0722563639,
0.0567404218,
-0.5054526329,
-0.8037731051,
0.54654181,
0.1358031332,
-0.0215264987,
0.3310872018,
0.7554489374,
0.4089552462,
0.1990649402,
-0.5012978911,
-0.0665759519,
0.0538837016,
-0.1968168914,
-0.0685777292,
-0.1983246803,
-0.1512120813,
-0.3561552763,
0.6437718868,
-0.3909044266,
0.203369543,
0.0727223009,
-0.1229329556,
-0.4174676538,
0.2755864263,
0.5950463414,
0.9372564554,
-0.4791975617,
0.01653664,
0.5652316809,
-0.2997666597,
0.1931363046,
0.1270538718,
-0.0601763092,
-0.1707958728,
0.4360581636,
0.8756612539,
0.1814248562,
-0.7590067983,
0.251470685,
0.1175417081,
-0.42709288,
-0.2346590906,
0.4820286632,
-0.0036620735,
0.4341425598,
0.4578152895,
0.0796513036,
-0.0238119122,
-0.365729779,
0.008404674,
0.3654871285,
0.0569476821,
-0.3004205525,
0.446574688,
0.1620030105,
-0.3611321151,
0.2035494298,
0.2572548091,
-0.0707829818,
0.622846067,
0.4937935174,
0.6389941573,
-0.1567976475,
-0.1379918307,
0.114391014,
0.4008071423,
-0.3773339093,
0.1936975271,
-0.0743901357,
-0.6996096373,
-0.4462732673,
-0.8143966794,
-0.4262847304,
0.3869778514,
-0.5308164358,
0.2559161782,
-0.7078505158,
-0.3624549806,
-0.0008007967,
0.2719151676,
-0.7133541703,
0.1929314584,
0.0505362563,
1.1565687656,
-0.9400313497,
0.6526492834,
0.8787949681,
0.1087765768,
-0.8722348213,
-0.0370673984,
-0.0662822425,
-0.6975083947,
0.2920283377,
-0.3464146554,
0.0353054665,
0.14894104,
-0.534425199,
-0.9546949267,
1.2202322483,
0.7725987434,
-0.8382916451,
-0.0120322648,
0.0721295401,
0.4880414009,
-0.3874319792,
-0.0063819457,
1.1198558807,
0.6536517143,
-0.1622603685,
-1.2607928514,
0.047944475,
0.0096020773,
0.2198158205,
0.2320985496,
-0.8270727396,
0.6450036168,
0.2001631409,
0.0469093472,
0.1981808245,
0.2408816814,
0.3096162677,
0.3199804127,
0.7619309425,
0.3160309494,
0.6179804802,
-0.2217851281,
0.9800035357,
-0.5035598278,
0.6633800268,
0.6807560325,
-0.1511795223,
0.7527669072,
0.6202589869,
-0.6294790506,
-0.0083745476,
0.9429251552,
-0.2247953713,
0.5442766547,
0.0578909554,
-0.0785429254,
-0.4193429053,
0.0162000041,
-0.3393768668,
0.2498556972,
0.4337950051,
-0.4955322742,
-0.2521775961,
0.1148503199,
-0.1461176276,
0.0189310983,
-0.4747531414,
0.6276533604,
0.17760548,
-0.4834024608,
0.7758222818,
0.1617679596,
0.6854825616,
-0.5203382969,
0.1819816083,
-0.2383800298,
0.4092704654,
-0.2746350765,
-0.4456999302,
0.2641853392,
-0.0577594005,
-0.1800586134,
-0.3605583012,
1.0221174955,
-0.1403514594,
-0.5613455176,
0.1821283996,
0.5618799925,
0.0621366464,
-0.1713965237,
-0.8446466327,
0.2090794295,
-0.0314976797,
-0.6969519854,
0.503339231,
0.4156599343,
-0.0741737485,
0.5491853952,
0.4921581447,
0.2793275118,
-0.1108338907,
-0.021506628,
0.6547594666,
-0.6083717942,
-0.1439250261,
-0.9036212564,
0.2151041478,
0.0852933452,
-0.1616901308,
0.6868464947,
0.3446540534,
0.8327040076,
-0.0295111984,
0.6583952904,
-0.0440654308,
0.6751532555,
-0.7035191059,
0.4030573368,
-0.6304930449,
0.5031754375,
-0.3794600368,
-1.0177432299,
-0.1773682833,
0.6117760539,
-0.3381191492,
0.2828212082,
0.6767027378,
0.6374123693,
-0.2145846784,
-0.0240875278,
0.4055597782,
0.2073699981,
0.2245692015,
0.6359620094,
0.5797589421,
-0.3564694524,
0.4218400717,
-0.5872049332,
-0.1807127893,
-0.3130778074,
-1.0779306889,
-0.9613857269,
-0.3168080151,
-0.4304892123,
-0.0918476656,
0.1461449862,
0.8449620008,
0.9678363204,
-0.9418904781,
-0.2213110626,
-0.2238539904,
-0.0022842709,
-0.3692723215,
-0.2160155475,
0.3267588913,
-0.2691650391,
-0.7364221215,
0.4736307561,
0.2111845911,
0.0784988999,
0.0420279726,
-0.0864997655,
0.0394239984,
0.0036198143,
0.6350137591,
0.2827804387,
-0.6054131985,
-0.537951231,
0.13514705,
0.2770849168,
-0.0651403069,
0.9958344102,
-0.4707460105,
0.049817767,
0.3462961018,
0.8611633778,
0.6201401353,
0.1013124213,
0.7370213866,
-0.5367991924,
-0.1665153503,
0.0376973152,
0.3757612705,
0.1689213365,
-0.3270350993,
0.761623919,
0.2954831719,
-0.6212260127,
-1.0390422344,
-0.12548922,
-0.8811494112,
-0.3837559521,
1.0172448158,
-0.0213009138,
-0.115328446,
-0.0246515628,
-0.1805321276,
-0.1538279802,
-0.2011053562,
0.4678436518,
0.8289617896,
-0.5614798665,
-0.3629204035,
-0.4889252186,
0.4113855064,
0.6161823869,
-0.5203980207,
0.0214086715,
0.1987125129,
0.7375321388,
-0.1563171446,
0.6618762612,
0.1152596399,
0.144675225,
-0.123362273,
-0.4898388684,
-0.085672982,
-0.2041777372,
-0.5455019474,
0.4718560874,
0.5439962745,
0.2784103751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14986v2 | Interpreting Vision and Language Generative Models with Semantic Visual Priors | 2023-04-28T17:10:08 | 2023-05-04T15:25:00 | Michele Cafagna, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona, Kees van Deemter, Albert Gatt | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | When applied to Image-to-text models, interpretability methods often provide
token-by-token explanations namely, they compute a visual explanation for each
token of the generated sequence. Those explanations are expensive to compute
and unable to comprehensively explain the model's output. Therefore, these
models often require some sort of approximation that eventually leads to
misleading explanations. We develop a framework based on SHAP, that allows for
generating comprehensive, meaningful explanations leveraging the meaning
representation of the output sequence as a whole. Moreover, by exploiting
semantic priors in the visual backbone, we extract an arbitrary number of
features that allows the efficient computation of Shapley values on large-scale
models, generating at the same time highly meaningful visual explanations. We
demonstrate that our method generates semantically more expressive explanations
than traditional methods at a lower compute cost and that it can be generalized
over other explainability methods. | [
-0.1036473811,
-0.6785373092,
0.8874342442,
0.1769860834,
-0.4202783108,
-0.5230208039,
-0.1710616648,
-0.5155012012,
0.0459657423,
0.7989206314,
-0.5410400629,
-0.4144921899,
-0.5821382403,
-0.3085436821,
-0.5997490883,
0.755764246,
-0.0111507196,
0.1248718724,
-0.3659918606,
0.1399706453,
-0.4759134948,
-0.1431943923,
-0.4078184962,
-0.1912605613,
0.3932411373,
0.3870645761,
0.984731853,
0.7537914515,
0.6917814016,
0.322837919,
0.1237623692,
-0.0631055459,
-0.4631570578,
0.0936032236,
-0.2724068761,
-0.4197639525,
-0.236994803,
-0.1855643541,
0.6598350406,
0.9892924428,
0.1469984055,
-0.0417972244,
-0.0340411961,
0.7436366677,
-0.8052459955,
0.2875574827,
-0.6195989847,
0.1972902864,
-0.1712135375,
-0.4018512666,
-0.54641819,
0.028146917,
0.3185624778,
-0.883970499,
0.3706434667,
0.0511810482,
1.0531131029,
0.1540833861,
-0.0710065365,
-0.0601048544,
-0.6543029547,
0.8209314942,
-0.6385416389,
0.4588502049,
0.1790443361,
0.4975929856,
-0.0966128111,
-1.1186048985,
-0.8360537291,
-0.0001907318,
0.0197646562,
0.3703305423,
-0.1543744802,
0.1790226698,
0.271360755,
0.7237790227,
-0.5969677567,
-0.1843182296,
-0.3134679198,
-0.2270793617,
0.5375949144,
0.2073012441,
0.3576175869,
-0.4036508799,
-0.812312305,
-0.2210806459,
-0.5615219474,
0.1169518307,
0.0616424754,
-0.120538868,
-0.3021915853,
0.5788993835,
-0.2597259283,
1.0586769581,
-0.0383061431,
0.1428876072,
-0.081485346,
-0.4092643559,
-0.5161753297,
-0.3805685043,
0.5938562751,
0.5315713286,
0.3373601735,
-0.2020032406,
0.0157877691,
-0.016166931,
0.2179908901,
-0.9480677843,
-0.5614854693,
0.2838287652,
-0.9742349982,
-0.426134944,
0.1250416189,
-0.8498190641,
-0.3974632323,
-0.3935568333,
0.5224834681,
-0.6894713044,
-0.3154381514,
0.2426245958,
-0.5123639107,
0.6079238057,
0.4464405775,
-1.0660976171,
0.1065654233,
0.4281129241,
0.7745816708,
-0.1348492056,
-0.383461386,
-0.4280105233,
0.3111560941,
-0.7427670956,
0.7037537694,
-0.6740337014,
-0.2067473829,
-0.0773867592,
-0.1906968802,
0.1147253662,
-0.4441525638,
0.364369005,
-0.7401174307,
0.0238642171,
-0.4776566327,
-0.4537393153,
-0.494348228,
-0.2336960286,
-0.577244401,
0.4196366668,
0.0810961425,
-0.71021384,
0.6925344467,
-0.5636361837,
-0.3750945628,
0.3789106011,
-0.1586547643,
-0.0448778793,
0.3320284784,
0.5405521393,
0.7104340196,
-0.1644299626,
0.3070251942,
-0.3844395876,
-0.3076302409,
0.2302615345,
-0.4922876358,
0.8508517146,
0.4270274043,
-0.2274912298,
0.3676389754,
-0.6168493032,
0.1521921158,
0.3499815166,
0.109302558,
-0.1544445157,
0.1288813949,
0.1369686723,
0.0990164354,
0.275185436,
-0.0586189292,
-0.3615399301,
-0.4865143597,
0.4553524554,
0.837556541,
-0.0011125797,
0.5265737176,
0.0056463871,
0.5769295692,
0.3427626789,
0.1875155419,
-0.7655201554,
-0.4952767193,
-0.8584510684,
-0.3961410522,
-0.1367447376,
0.3526107669,
-1.0186969042,
0.0120835528,
-0.5682635307,
-0.1238161176,
-0.1780693233,
0.1326252669,
0.6074293852,
0.6261622906,
0.1699978113,
-0.4374102354,
-0.3847779334,
-1.0315257311,
-0.3318271935,
-0.0955805704,
-0.0438785553,
0.2100401521,
0.6256427169,
0.2077704072,
0.924354136,
-0.5400518775,
0.1296348125,
-0.1007105559,
0.0379156321,
0.117895849,
0.3736600876,
0.4484464824,
-1.1309571266,
-0.1667166948,
0.0433754884,
-0.8469793797,
0.0479773134,
-0.2975785732,
-0.4034120142,
-0.2309896648,
0.5606565475,
-0.1532333344,
0.6028376222,
0.6296976209,
-0.5085567236,
0.6391139627,
-0.136865437,
0.2699280679,
-0.8775650859,
0.0167551711,
-0.1476858407,
-0.4794751108,
-0.3934958577,
0.5776516795,
-0.1094308197,
-0.4149914682,
-0.3670273125,
0.5011817217,
-0.4090077281,
-0.250036478,
-0.0348425321,
0.1950894296,
0.3621863425,
0.4807899296,
0.3324252963,
0.695782423,
0.7439975142,
-0.5914219022,
0.5121811628,
0.3020865619,
-0.3821773231,
0.7523667812,
-0.895137012,
-0.2760381997,
-0.2939031422,
-0.0038288422,
-1.0883497,
-0.4398279786,
0.2420503348,
-0.4554688334,
0.1705111116,
-0.500741899,
-0.3085740209,
-0.1115720496,
-0.0185483005,
0.5051386952,
0.4988194704,
-0.8373274207,
0.7762522101,
0.0749118254,
-0.1053181589,
-0.4730135202,
-0.790312469,
0.3015146255,
-0.2462411523,
-0.9197283387,
0.3955042958,
0.2661834955,
-0.4163400531,
0.1348824948,
0.21578224,
-0.1578665227,
0.0479424447,
0.5234485865,
0.2973316908,
-0.3517718017,
0.0936298966,
-0.0703168362,
-0.3612445593,
0.0820838735,
-0.6372630596,
0.4491994679,
-0.2988467515,
-0.6120621562,
-0.4094235003,
0.452868402,
0.3275848329,
-0.5237315297,
0.7021698356,
0.651858151,
-0.2653212547,
-0.2831452489,
-0.2675123215,
0.0454906486,
-0.4591411054,
0.5035920739,
-0.6618594527,
-0.3628500402,
0.6178814769,
0.0557770468,
-0.134917587,
0.6820658445,
0.5425972342,
-0.1323559433,
1.0534244776,
0.6185019016,
0.489276737,
0.7000710368,
-0.2830462158,
0.1110546142,
-0.5155234933,
-0.2972258031,
-0.1706789583,
0.0921446979,
-0.183740899,
-0.7435063124,
0.2264470905,
0.3302614391,
0.1807390898,
0.0900962874,
-0.3877075613,
0.493362397,
0.620388329,
0.3356192112,
0.2988004088,
0.2188026905,
0.0276461858,
-0.1856265515,
-0.8272304535,
-0.4676304162,
0.9840857387,
0.1511550993,
0.6844477057,
0.0987978131,
0.4968776405,
0.0270664487,
0.1507090777,
-0.740218699,
0.3470543325,
-0.2973679602,
-0.3807114065,
-0.2678154707,
-0.3661231101,
-0.9090844989,
0.4500624239,
-0.3924204111,
-0.7518827319,
0.1616279483,
0.5416365862,
-0.1085142791,
0.2015973181,
-1.0404245853,
1.2084501982,
-0.1680511385,
-0.3756678998,
-0.4807356596,
-0.6237072945,
0.7136725187,
0.2880821526,
0.2756921351,
0.2188468874,
0.0511886999,
0.5764469504,
-0.7576790452,
0.8757506013,
-0.1528359205,
0.0650891811,
0.2576771379,
0.1433116496,
0.1964720041,
-0.3092359304,
0.1448819637,
0.2865525782,
0.1879291385,
-0.8217638135,
-0.8448472619,
0.5017964244,
-0.1873225123,
-0.4010849297,
0.0043980977,
-0.5930803418,
0.0318919234,
0.069722347,
0.3637343347,
0.8886141777,
0.0246951152,
-0.1120482311,
0.6579834223,
-0.4437150061,
0.3405161202,
-0.0766009167,
-0.5750946403,
-0.3050247431,
1.0176054239,
-0.3254638314,
0.4594638944,
0.5293638706,
0.3922460675,
-0.3865959942,
-0.9385451078,
-0.7144567966,
-0.0724608153,
-1.0932378769,
0.1868950576,
-0.2689549029,
0.1618649811,
-0.2652347088,
-0.4381886721,
0.1036058068,
-0.5482420325,
-0.0433647223,
0.1108435765,
0.3727864921,
0.6021357179,
0.0333034582,
0.3689172864,
-0.5203456879,
0.6941099167,
0.5383889079,
0.5643643141,
0.3612289727,
-0.6335656047,
-0.1533046067,
0.0485557541,
-0.0469627567,
-1.0371180773,
0.2621619999,
0.3058311641,
0.3799542487,
0.8819869161,
-0.268568188,
1.3087021112,
-0.3273352981,
1.0292612314,
0.3241602778,
-1.2657054663,
0.7293854356,
-0.3687153459,
0.1705408245,
0.1547717899,
-0.0348743908,
-0.299526602,
-0.2553404272,
-0.6865403652,
-0.9138571024,
0.4841422439,
0.1174594015,
0.3017251492,
0.0922911614,
0.5277546048,
0.1346024573,
-0.1200761124,
-0.6514112949,
-0.1345840394,
-0.3984915018,
-0.3433682919,
-0.053761933,
-0.4129733443,
-0.0984038115,
-0.0192118585,
0.6714520454,
-0.1629840285,
0.09815754,
0.2303289473,
-0.4574460387,
0.0664684847,
-0.0806078091,
0.3709500134,
1.1010299921,
0.2779854238,
0.4333174229,
-0.0627013966,
-0.2593016028,
-0.6684203744,
0.0686022565,
-0.2859236896,
-0.0139818313,
0.8817864656,
0.8488562107,
0.2664035261,
-0.8848383427,
0.9472609758,
0.2398404181,
-0.0986424983,
-0.185576722,
0.0216010772,
0.0589144975,
0.1749162376,
0.1992809325,
0.0775886923,
0.4069029987,
-0.3670262098,
0.1241619885,
0.7812896967,
-0.5072299838,
-0.1492034793,
0.9801981449,
0.0953358859,
0.1818729788,
0.4202340841,
0.1058583707,
-0.4020864069,
0.5399663448,
0.357881844,
0.6689068675,
0.2864537537,
0.4202831984,
0.1718495488,
-0.0239271745,
0.2643056214,
0.2963057458,
-0.4809850454,
-0.8799028397,
-0.8953770399,
-0.628085494,
-0.2649278045,
-0.193970874,
-0.8579387665,
-0.0086880876,
-0.3362465799,
0.2709639668,
0.5824907422,
-0.5920830369,
-0.6716419458,
0.3752356768,
0.0767981485,
0.606970787,
-1.01925385,
0.30348894,
0.4769636691,
-0.8304952383,
-0.7776102424,
-0.2121985257,
-0.2538014948,
-1.2892063856,
0.6687195897,
-0.0162155125,
-0.2994110882,
-0.2090255618,
-0.8510451317,
-0.6673227549,
0.7454707623,
0.4878785908,
-0.2899508774,
0.2134302706,
-0.0407366231,
0.5336103439,
-0.0256622732,
-0.0288873333,
0.1309972107,
0.4905985296,
0.4166469276,
-0.4736898541,
0.1717271954,
-0.1563944072,
0.3041666746,
0.0924086571,
-0.0425266363,
0.4412426651,
-0.5798273683,
-0.3870085776,
0.15243195,
0.8589876294,
-0.0345470756,
0.2658555508,
0.4005043507,
0.512932241,
0.5180024505,
-0.1602994055,
1.4431698322,
-0.2146930248,
0.1466195136,
0.9085813761,
0.371950537,
0.747635603,
0.7498374581,
-0.309004426,
0.769192338,
0.519951582,
-0.0041449564,
0.390345633,
0.0535724014,
-0.0544493496,
-0.729840517,
0.046147123,
-0.0470279232,
0.4905112088,
0.1902745962,
-0.8831411004,
-0.0991999656,
-0.0798263401,
-0.2377667278,
0.2127153128,
-0.5859004855,
0.6465697885,
0.1432468295,
-0.5067516565,
0.5128612518,
-0.0517166108,
0.2447661161,
-0.416760385,
-0.4114103615,
0.2833692431,
0.1123825908,
-0.3626888394,
-0.9167721868,
0.4021776915,
-0.1671599597,
-0.4262092113,
-0.4825962484,
0.5753535628,
-0.3500508666,
-0.5779554248,
-0.2683671713,
0.4489587843,
0.4758279324,
-0.2394650728,
-0.5347722769,
-0.2136079818,
-0.1486629397,
0.0392249934,
-0.0322516002,
0.5023158789,
-0.3072232604,
0.7610889673,
0.7998044491,
0.1097026318,
0.0493221246,
0.1454447359,
0.6094008684,
-0.5175963044,
-0.5032557249,
-0.8544377685,
0.7081259489,
-0.053194847,
-0.2167036235,
0.5077644587,
0.4314334095,
0.5985487103,
-0.3080340028,
0.6441024542,
-0.1218369231,
-0.0383912064,
-1.0832339525,
0.4364887178,
-0.4867552519,
0.1259631366,
-0.3589906096,
-0.6275743246,
-0.2454056442,
0.663764894,
-0.3563498855,
0.0286849327,
0.626943171,
0.472850889,
-0.0896561965,
0.0615129061,
0.5132179856,
0.3324513733,
0.0474974364,
0.4594983459,
0.8064044714,
-0.1981262267,
0.5742764473,
-0.244328633,
-0.1782732755,
0.0775155351,
-1.134834528,
-0.6706859469,
-0.8826876879,
-0.1717113405,
-0.3377423584,
-0.0708581507,
0.0994017795,
1.0853062868,
-0.7839012146,
0.2657172382,
-0.2843040526,
0.3531588316,
-0.5717109442,
-0.3060847521,
0.6028969288,
-0.261141479,
-0.6447122097,
0.034408614,
0.4040600061,
0.0536204241,
-0.3634930551,
0.0328631736,
0.5920556188,
-0.0340710469,
0.6799324155,
0.015791202,
-1.1348381042,
-0.3601070344,
-0.2328135818,
0.3141998351,
0.0632881597,
0.8462572098,
-0.8704991341,
0.9259210825,
0.5589182973,
0.40959993,
0.8532221317,
0.1247507334,
0.8626621962,
-0.3814130723,
0.2063940912,
0.0960334912,
0.5171792507,
0.5334874392,
-0.2036622763,
0.1867359877,
0.1790335923,
0.0329559967,
-0.3488344252,
0.7372784615,
-1.2995197773,
-0.2925259769,
1.043435216,
-0.5007924438,
-0.254889518,
-0.0104177212,
-0.120661445,
-0.1281516552,
0.0093861613,
0.3575066626,
0.5517264605,
-0.0809949264,
-0.5170497894,
-0.3999473155,
0.3819622397,
0.3735501766,
-0.8342656493,
0.1325293481,
0.7310966253,
0.3540283442,
-0.1217912659,
0.4240609109,
-0.4032011628,
0.4978434443,
0.4916987121,
-0.0082959877,
-0.1900563091,
-0.1879849434,
-0.450804323,
0.0126954727,
0.1126442552,
-0.2838653326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14953v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14953v2 | CCpdf: Building a High Quality Corpus for Visually Rich Documents from Web Crawl Data | 2023-04-28T16:12:18 | 2023-06-06T07:35:17 | Michał Turski, Tomasz Stanisławek, Karol Kaczmarek, Paweł Dyda, Filip Graliński | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, the field of document understanding has progressed a lot. A
significant part of this progress has been possible thanks to the use of
language models pretrained on large amounts of documents. However, pretraining
corpora used in the domain of document understanding are single domain,
monolingual, or nonpublic. Our goal in this paper is to propose an efficient
pipeline for creating a big-scale, diverse, multilingual corpus of PDF files
from all over the Internet using Common Crawl, as PDF files are the most
canonical types of documents as considered in document understanding. We
analysed extensively all of the steps of the pipeline and proposed a solution
which is a trade-off between data quality and processing time. We also share a
CCpdf corpus in a form or an index of PDF files along with a script for
downloading them, which produces a collection useful for language model
pretraining. The dataset and tools published with this paper offer researchers
the opportunity to develop even better multilingual language models. | [
-0.4820559025,
-0.1945422292,
0.341378957,
0.3805689216,
-0.4381393492,
0.1685613394,
-0.1691580415,
-0.2462287843,
0.1466474682,
0.5022712946,
-0.2452821583,
-0.7730035782,
-0.8045260906,
0.1584809721,
-0.7839286327,
0.6721083522,
0.1475007236,
0.2676013708,
0.0824165493,
-0.1352694035,
0.3101895452,
-0.4018593431,
-0.4087461233,
0.2260685861,
0.6374637485,
0.4841023982,
0.6375156641,
0.7062184811,
0.4563012123,
0.2403530478,
0.2340575904,
-0.0269430485,
-0.4913209379,
-0.0400719903,
-0.58234936,
-0.2810333073,
-0.1719738841,
-0.0092953919,
0.7875779867,
0.9682480097,
-0.1640458107,
-0.028662147,
0.098721303,
0.5158783793,
-0.7433568835,
-0.0086480919,
-0.5226420164,
0.0274103079,
-0.3642077148,
-0.4979639947,
-0.4227318466,
-0.0698355511,
-0.0064798072,
-0.9262921214,
0.9397929311,
0.0250178967,
0.7333884239,
0.0123294573,
-0.3752760589,
-0.3970097005,
-0.3617373705,
0.6594067812,
-0.3271439075,
0.9173128009,
0.5645467043,
0.2727084458,
0.1213554665,
-1.0999686718,
-0.6347854733,
0.1668268591,
0.092237711,
0.298881501,
0.1146187559,
-0.094055295,
-0.0061789793,
0.575178504,
-0.985268414,
0.152426511,
-0.3466384411,
-0.3420619369,
0.2684974372,
0.0036234304,
0.3716993034,
-0.0249552876,
-0.1713947207,
-0.5536203384,
-0.2946304977,
-0.2012741268,
0.8312163353,
0.4645797908,
-0.1871111244,
0.5191206336,
-0.0250971597,
0.7261351347,
-0.2255110741,
-0.1782555133,
0.0848574713,
-0.4057392776,
-0.188469395,
-0.013529907,
0.5870163441,
0.1504294425,
0.3942063451,
-0.3548943102,
0.0711747855,
0.0584664755,
0.3628408909,
-0.9191921353,
-0.4240237474,
0.2487666011,
-0.4811056554,
-0.1400063932,
0.1746522039,
-1.2706823349,
-0.3669543564,
-0.3500970602,
-0.2355976403,
-0.7644497156,
-0.3835597932,
0.1798669696,
-0.3484702408,
0.1502599716,
0.5066247582,
-0.9638277888,
0.3121950924,
0.4648453593,
0.9620355964,
-0.195071131,
-0.7448053956,
-0.8551166058,
0.235434249,
-0.2785109282,
0.9427468777,
-0.5740407705,
-0.4890649021,
0.29994151,
0.239296481,
-0.0931529775,
-0.3399127126,
0.6530293822,
-0.4547778368,
0.0205680821,
-0.0321873985,
-0.3560984731,
-0.2477135658,
0.3608666062,
-1.0102270842,
0.7994738817,
0.4831470549,
-1.2614476681,
0.3773348331,
-0.4050237536,
-0.6682395339,
0.2476065904,
-0.0025506807,
-0.0765753165,
-0.2789484859,
0.4398647249,
0.3152200282,
-0.2996706665,
0.036289122,
-0.2863743007,
-0.273909986,
-0.2685863078,
-0.1801982522,
0.7292676568,
0.421628207,
-0.1853787303,
-0.0314915702,
-0.9689286351,
-0.0479965135,
0.0610062964,
-0.4750543535,
-0.0325877555,
-0.0274288468,
0.7099833488,
0.161115393,
0.0670232251,
-0.2101421952,
0.0274415072,
-0.2026696056,
0.2345663011,
0.5446533561,
-0.1793390512,
0.3907904625,
-0.1903342605,
0.7072970867,
0.0550388098,
-0.0361278094,
-0.5024505854,
-0.0782510489,
-0.6410627365,
-0.6676890254,
0.3657265604,
0.1976173818,
-0.591612041,
-0.0312700123,
-0.49860394,
-0.5161575079,
-0.5129269361,
0.3374179304,
-0.0831151903,
0.2983365655,
0.3991610408,
-0.545560658,
-0.3601635993,
-0.4133588374,
0.0368367657,
0.0660572797,
0.1139970273,
0.0715273693,
0.2295814604,
-0.2469392866,
0.8288173676,
-0.3829354346,
-0.2248080522,
-0.4402618706,
0.4485133886,
0.0724446997,
0.4830999374,
0.6659563184,
-1.1334387064,
-0.5282115936,
-0.1069893017,
-0.4053813517,
0.0673055574,
-0.1418069601,
-0.2222492546,
0.1626916677,
0.4293192923,
-0.2878776491,
0.2127017081,
0.5410702229,
0.000769181,
0.6516118646,
-0.2667762935,
0.319832474,
-0.8335762024,
0.3943531513,
0.1010937616,
-0.266613692,
-0.2221689969,
0.3268034458,
0.1028545648,
-0.5803442001,
-0.8247074485,
0.666724205,
-0.5314964652,
-0.2498760968,
-0.0507542901,
0.3809797168,
0.1438216865,
0.5094599724,
0.4856468141,
0.6949642897,
0.8768832684,
-0.6745423079,
0.1687921584,
0.2227575034,
-0.3139098585,
0.5361364484,
-0.268101275,
0.1814779043,
-0.249949187,
0.0333544575,
-0.817892015,
-0.2390252501,
-0.0578596108,
-0.4292108715,
0.3264598846,
-0.4030943513,
-0.879140079,
-0.2229655534,
-0.2844251692,
0.2413283736,
-0.1521156728,
-0.8181885481,
0.3588330746,
0.3253177702,
0.0194609966,
-0.698110342,
-0.4813021719,
0.1551690847,
0.0410273038,
-0.8366569281,
0.3106933236,
-0.2820794284,
0.0478298515,
-0.037279278,
-0.0506145209,
-0.4807299376,
-0.0701177418,
0.1239359304,
0.0171067249,
-0.1305283308,
0.0759834573,
-0.2030114233,
0.002609662,
-0.415907234,
-0.4404575527,
0.9274277091,
0.1277155429,
-0.4587337673,
-0.0196934529,
0.7235455513,
0.7162586451,
-0.6759933829,
0.7179380059,
0.9402658939,
-0.3358035684,
-0.3298383951,
-0.278514564,
0.2163980752,
-0.4116068482,
0.2325261235,
-0.327280879,
-0.7624529004,
0.3879849017,
-0.2432216257,
-0.1612365544,
0.3617897332,
0.5215525031,
0.0065585757,
0.6707052588,
0.9584834576,
0.1097337753,
0.4085679352,
-0.4272799492,
0.2144300938,
-0.4605953991,
-0.1562450528,
-0.8051344752,
0.2178071737,
-0.717754364,
-0.4823083282,
-0.0872304663,
0.3787829876,
-0.1051261574,
0.4671279788,
-0.5708941817,
0.1879617274,
0.5073549151,
-0.1301610768,
0.2984303832,
0.0138132758,
-0.3767428696,
0.1836645752,
-0.5337531567,
-0.5698459148,
1.1233971119,
-0.0968721807,
0.8463526368,
0.1311365813,
0.4782484174,
0.3278691769,
-0.0305609647,
-0.7591627836,
0.3239372969,
-0.3153835833,
-0.6717740297,
-0.2157706767,
-0.1813174933,
-1.170486331,
0.1570145786,
-0.2485913336,
-0.6307817698,
0.1723793745,
-0.0559818372,
0.1451864392,
0.2763450444,
-0.5344321728,
1.1383621693,
-0.2468143851,
-0.5775645971,
-0.3810110092,
-0.4598278701,
0.0959895924,
-0.2856075466,
0.2826922536,
0.1803998202,
0.1059806049,
0.5901263952,
-0.4424495101,
0.4142190218,
0.0611617863,
0.0948038399,
0.4632290602,
0.1281376779,
0.3020375669,
0.1354759783,
-0.2704820335,
0.1006717458,
0.3252175152,
-0.7200646996,
-0.3921010494,
0.5578868389,
-0.7232365012,
-0.1098248363,
-0.7389773726,
-0.2077574432,
0.0021588248,
0.6337425709,
0.4935888648,
0.6264537573,
-0.5430014729,
0.0973283052,
0.4921827912,
-0.4254339337,
0.5298845768,
0.5865551829,
-0.1106762812,
-0.2279524207,
0.9173740149,
0.1314110756,
-0.0333181843,
0.6340497136,
-0.2844825983,
-0.3733864427,
-0.8630872369,
-0.3578701317,
0.1912430823,
-0.9648723602,
0.0028646237,
-0.974767983,
-0.0093968073,
-0.9084399939,
-0.3923732936,
-0.2933692634,
-0.1779695153,
-0.3826355934,
-0.0537862182,
0.0210305154,
0.4578943849,
-0.2372060269,
0.3215367198,
-0.9327414036,
0.506736815,
0.1705546081,
0.6061770916,
0.1797762364,
-0.006767604,
-0.4253905416,
-0.2366801053,
-0.3465250432,
-0.831949532,
0.7662830353,
0.2151037157,
0.759598732,
0.4130912125,
0.1465723068,
0.4918965399,
-0.3008646667,
0.7537345886,
0.2701856494,
-0.8818354607,
0.3737698793,
-0.6104168892,
0.3292807341,
0.7217949033,
0.8269494772,
-0.6375964284,
-0.1809756011,
-0.5134379864,
-0.9034744501,
0.5635135174,
0.0472047552,
-0.1825920492,
-0.1783329397,
-0.1072323322,
0.347161293,
0.1207137778,
-0.4675775468,
0.1442519426,
-0.8549069166,
-0.2018939257,
-0.2686238885,
0.1327665001,
0.0819285661,
-0.0870745331,
0.5526493192,
-0.4945690036,
0.0849153847,
0.2999635339,
-0.7667999864,
0.0092843939,
0.2824471593,
0.2416773587,
0.876897037,
-0.4249222279,
0.4588151872,
-0.2933071554,
-0.8458834887,
-0.0776924416,
0.0783877969,
0.5547921658,
-0.0088699162,
0.5573456883,
0.2712621093,
0.0952828154,
-0.9137476087,
0.6983365417,
-0.2791369855,
0.0550798401,
-0.4088259637,
-0.1774049252,
0.3149459958,
-0.1925149709,
0.3339004219,
-0.0173140056,
0.1250136197,
-0.6887793541,
0.4079695046,
0.2125855833,
-0.2357144654,
-0.0750143826,
0.4785048962,
0.18776986,
-0.2214668095,
0.9838858247,
-0.5021467209,
-0.5008554459,
0.4582449496,
0.5294317007,
0.4979174733,
0.127412498,
0.3320347071,
0.6471253037,
0.1990061998,
-0.0632928237,
-0.0879039019,
-0.276435107,
-0.6941517591,
-0.244532302,
-0.9914208055,
-0.5362076163,
0.0781834349,
-0.4725553989,
0.6509352922,
-0.6885524988,
0.2704411447,
0.1606148332,
0.1575248986,
-1.0105242729,
0.5673211217,
0.0831548423,
1.0935491323,
-0.5194093585,
1.1330333948,
0.3980647027,
-0.6555968523,
-0.4912856221,
0.028441513,
-0.1236251146,
-0.5801874399,
0.6330487728,
0.1735560596,
-0.3004145622,
0.1428041011,
-0.5827187896,
-0.6872425079,
0.7908315063,
0.5068115592,
-0.5309196115,
-0.1124511138,
0.1024635732,
0.4267044365,
-0.2140679061,
0.4791662097,
0.1071835011,
0.5814955235,
0.2231085449,
-0.5370041728,
-0.1897304505,
-0.4924222529,
-0.351454109,
-0.0109564457,
-0.5329365134,
0.7186097503,
-0.100456439,
-0.6185899973,
-0.0404213704,
0.5132568479,
-0.1550277174,
0.2649907172,
0.4300651252,
0.7557299733,
0.8268190026,
0.1776581109,
1.106007576,
-0.5341176987,
0.3526831567,
1.1999510527,
-0.1170194894,
0.6700751781,
0.137284711,
-0.1180081442,
0.2965212464,
1.0066795349,
-0.1293328404,
0.5941590667,
0.3255538046,
-0.1466667205,
-0.4720687866,
-0.0409630686,
-0.284776032,
0.4742178321,
0.159429729,
-0.2572420239,
-0.5744059682,
-0.0858055204,
-0.1643820703,
0.3036856055,
-0.114176318,
0.3848865628,
-0.0541659594,
-0.5456981659,
0.4831048846,
-0.0354387984,
0.7423425913,
-0.5538825989,
0.0770288631,
-0.0305589177,
-0.0939667225,
-0.3968708813,
-0.7845918536,
0.3245554566,
0.0961384773,
-0.3094428778,
-0.1788608432,
0.45324108,
-0.3096089661,
-0.430037111,
0.7558915019,
0.4269783795,
0.444871664,
-0.1824647635,
-0.4855388403,
-0.020503642,
-0.1939609051,
0.0896848962,
0.4672167301,
0.4339327812,
0.1809124053,
0.4839194417,
0.9524730444,
0.0378779247,
0.2716128528,
0.3188523352,
0.6594226956,
-0.5065171123,
-0.7685607076,
-0.338011682,
0.3951786757,
-0.0035477034,
-0.2589911819,
0.4886510968,
0.9079339504,
0.9124137759,
0.0776248276,
0.8918542266,
0.0760331824,
0.3802595139,
-0.2660200596,
1.0565497875,
-0.6075032949,
-0.3978334665,
-0.4847860634,
-1.2388362885,
-0.3030441701,
0.4054039121,
0.227228418,
-0.2906957269,
0.9104935527,
0.772151351,
-0.4843789339,
0.0920382589,
0.2611279786,
-0.134480536,
0.4333961308,
0.1933043748,
0.4289701581,
-0.0689192191,
0.6292361021,
-0.1315182298,
-0.122956641,
-0.0202994291,
-1.0198310614,
-0.7622414827,
-1.0889545679,
-0.2547528148,
-0.1860590428,
-0.0703322589,
0.6257445216,
0.9569975734,
-0.6246099472,
-0.1072461307,
-0.2511070371,
0.0422193147,
0.0468494222,
-0.1872739494,
0.6202538013,
-0.5564786196,
-0.9551181197,
0.3328635395,
0.2664542794,
0.0127307456,
-0.1750272661,
-0.1587200463,
-0.6581240892,
0.0125975572,
0.3613544405,
0.335252732,
-0.0126957661,
-0.0767805427,
-0.0549843013,
-0.1882935613,
0.4039798379,
0.9763268828,
-0.60830158,
0.6436929703,
0.6492593884,
0.588802278,
1.1528283358,
-0.1825809181,
0.4282948077,
-0.4032576978,
0.3582289219,
0.2174047828,
0.6056370735,
0.8475844264,
-0.3419723213,
0.5521555543,
0.3033266962,
-0.2457704842,
-0.5696554184,
0.0763604045,
-1.3674424887,
-0.4833646417,
0.8797080517,
-0.3781809509,
-0.137080431,
-0.1328888535,
-0.1636226624,
0.6521704793,
-0.316558212,
0.4171515107,
0.7738171816,
0.1666415334,
-0.3695743382,
-0.2813208997,
0.2497503459,
-0.019416105,
-0.6979873776,
0.0304084867,
0.2283598781,
0.3165929317,
0.3693175316,
0.7271029949,
-0.2460694015,
0.175433442,
0.3497764766,
0.1252366602,
0.0138139911,
-0.5487537384,
-0.0710065588,
0.5661935806,
0.0735955387,
-0.0305221193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14936v1 | Information Redundancy and Biases in Public Document Information Extraction Benchmarks | 2023-04-28T15:48:26 | 2023-04-28T15:48:26 | Seif Laatiri, Pirashanth Ratnamogan, Joel Tang, Laurent Lam, William Vanhuffel, Fabien Caspani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Advances in the Visually-rich Document Understanding (VrDU) field and
particularly the Key-Information Extraction (KIE) task are marked with the
emergence of efficient Transformer-based approaches such as the LayoutLM
models. Despite the good performance of KIE models when fine-tuned on public
benchmarks, they still struggle to generalize on complex real-life use-cases
lacking sufficient document annotations. Our research highlighted that KIE
standard benchmarks such as SROIE and FUNSD contain significant similarity
between training and testing documents and can be adjusted to better evaluate
the generalization of models. In this work, we designed experiments to quantify
the information redundancy in public benchmarks, revealing a 75% template
replication in SROIE official test set and 16% in FUNSD. We also proposed
resampling strategies to provide benchmarks more representative of the
generalization ability of models. We showed that models not suited for document
analysis struggle on the adjusted splits dropping on average 10,5% F1 score on
SROIE and 3.5% on FUNSD compared to multi-modal models dropping only 7,5% F1 on
SROIE and 0.5% F1 on FUNSD. | [
-0.5925216675,
-0.2328357995,
0.3981663585,
0.2539294064,
-0.2180942893,
-0.3158892989,
-0.0480546802,
-0.425857842,
-0.0770056024,
0.4767723083,
-0.3469152451,
-0.5308412313,
-0.7623714209,
0.0879583582,
-0.4295764863,
0.8431822658,
-0.1981071383,
-0.0567567982,
-0.4420322478,
-0.5174530149,
-0.5173582435,
-0.3356864452,
0.0220494661,
-0.0338557512,
0.4509816468,
0.313326031,
0.3986775577,
0.6757790446,
0.681656301,
0.1772602797,
-0.1036489233,
0.0835116059,
-0.6256060004,
0.0046856347,
-0.3355734646,
-0.6221669912,
-0.1467771232,
0.3142228425,
0.6327656507,
0.5746673942,
0.0079276823,
0.2564451694,
-0.1504844576,
0.6885533929,
-1.1781939268,
0.3000980616,
-0.5448379517,
0.0250003468,
-0.1558296233,
0.1026550233,
-0.4688263535,
-0.4592110813,
0.3653610051,
-0.8589932323,
0.7100220919,
-0.1545283645,
1.2315814495,
0.1775121093,
-0.2330288887,
-0.1157849804,
-0.6957162023,
0.814627409,
-0.4036974609,
0.917912066,
0.3553826213,
0.3655233085,
0.064224422,
-0.8014389277,
-0.5130583644,
-0.1528787464,
-0.204822734,
0.3164579868,
-0.0826392993,
-0.1618139893,
0.5593204498,
0.0959787145,
-0.2380837649,
-0.0731482804,
-0.5834622383,
-0.1577809006,
0.5393645763,
-0.0620653294,
-0.0554443747,
-0.4241722226,
-0.4253279269,
-0.6748486757,
-0.5123183727,
-0.1513390988,
0.3410178125,
-0.0634979233,
-0.1043101922,
0.3976909816,
-0.1255971193,
0.4899642766,
-0.2704414725,
-0.1728283465,
0.5003333092,
-0.5238348842,
-0.4198979735,
-0.406231761,
0.5434014797,
0.4508396983,
0.2500993311,
-0.385261327,
-0.1135995612,
-0.1489326358,
0.7135575414,
-0.5368832946,
-0.1968461275,
0.0030335393,
-0.626218617,
-0.3711975813,
0.4511944354,
-1.0942795277,
-0.4528099,
-0.4864621758,
0.2412049174,
-0.5321716666,
-0.1920786798,
-0.295011431,
-0.868398428,
0.2832752466,
0.7900949717,
-0.6305370331,
0.1663622111,
0.7365773916,
0.7922091484,
-0.6014097929,
-0.36503613,
-0.2172251791,
0.1300436109,
-0.062396843,
0.8101991415,
-0.6174356341,
-0.6677670479,
-0.2768493891,
0.1169781759,
-0.4080475271,
-0.8992627263,
0.8857852221,
-0.3882629871,
0.2519021332,
-0.6014593244,
-0.3630717695,
-0.145576179,
0.2946041822,
-0.9814376235,
1.0279417038,
0.3893777728,
-1.0234885216,
0.6550341249,
-0.6143129468,
-0.1612209678,
-0.1548050493,
-0.4471890628,
-0.6108151078,
0.5447652936,
0.0508935861,
-0.0222336277,
-0.4554650784,
0.2049927413,
-0.2392549813,
-0.4790246189,
0.0179752745,
-0.6765924692,
0.4626505971,
0.1951685846,
-0.3942359984,
-0.0723901093,
-1.0903717279,
-0.1364066303,
0.1544646323,
-0.5259662867,
-0.5508203506,
-0.0800289884,
0.4132494032,
0.0561723411,
-0.0543601364,
-0.5642200708,
0.2750241756,
-0.0868777335,
0.2292392999,
0.7942627668,
-0.106206432,
0.2855986655,
-0.3548738956,
0.3416092694,
0.2361280918,
0.061660599,
0.0052673882,
-0.2192178816,
-0.5697379708,
-0.4773584604,
0.7124707699,
0.3655456603,
-0.2408558875,
0.0588974133,
-0.764972806,
-0.5806718469,
-0.8323712349,
-0.1521417201,
0.3570644855,
0.6541790366,
0.3594737947,
-0.4596075714,
-0.4507949352,
-1.2778137922,
-0.4307770729,
0.0058607268,
-0.2810498774,
0.3479579389,
0.5782621503,
-0.2399123907,
1.12832129,
-0.3941648006,
-0.1281551272,
0.0114824623,
0.4940763116,
-0.0856429338,
0.3225264251,
0.4453754723,
-1.4970986843,
-0.3549405932,
-0.1173655018,
-0.6614219546,
-0.1930857152,
0.0295196529,
-0.0081842029,
0.0089435689,
0.1385831386,
-0.680877924,
0.904615283,
0.1416730583,
0.1811906844,
0.7084639668,
-0.1196113378,
0.3724950254,
-0.7669635415,
0.3378909826,
0.1809889376,
0.0673298761,
-0.6280383468,
0.1304226816,
0.5932743549,
-0.143546313,
-0.3217947781,
0.643906951,
-0.4729472697,
-0.4076759219,
-0.1339815408,
0.3602784872,
0.3302541077,
0.4330097139,
0.0553523526,
0.8133304715,
-0.1619769931,
-0.3501913249,
-0.2026524842,
0.1121056303,
-0.3446179628,
0.4887754321,
-0.5052542686,
-0.0004273329,
-0.3075746894,
0.1099290028,
-0.9336774945,
-0.3156905174,
-0.0750227943,
-0.0563539639,
0.4050724208,
-0.1108505651,
-0.4206499159,
-0.2565070689,
-0.4827666283,
0.2966719866,
0.3505001366,
-0.5685279965,
0.717962265,
0.2674815953,
0.0031055382,
-0.6079605222,
-0.4552877843,
-0.3016634881,
-0.2580001056,
-0.7664195299,
0.5009070039,
0.2742932737,
-0.3366609514,
0.0444512442,
-0.4543154836,
-0.1915966868,
0.2338026315,
0.5190219879,
0.1561173201,
-0.1402025819,
0.2837701738,
-0.1838276237,
0.0136000281,
-0.1233726144,
0.2025674731,
0.3690731227,
0.1557699889,
-0.6976616383,
-0.5189157128,
0.2878439128,
0.8345554471,
-0.220236972,
0.6479558945,
0.4593167007,
-0.3256702423,
0.2131425142,
-0.936846137,
0.1787347049,
-0.3749033511,
0.5975144506,
-0.3972047567,
-0.3549193144,
0.4841486812,
-0.111033231,
0.3111795783,
0.529188931,
0.0921934769,
-0.1183037609,
0.6811092496,
0.4956958592,
-0.1394983083,
0.5743576884,
-0.2167262435,
-0.0520228706,
-1.0173429251,
-0.2799817026,
-0.8118953705,
-0.2487913072,
-0.5557237864,
-0.4981267452,
0.2252683043,
0.3726614118,
0.2001548707,
0.3349696398,
-0.4457044899,
0.3943909705,
0.8273257017,
-0.2369334549,
0.2137105018,
0.2572714984,
0.0036345469,
-0.2689858973,
-0.5525387526,
-0.5073019266,
1.2841114998,
0.3242659867,
0.7067203522,
-0.0015441047,
0.7904023528,
0.3209581077,
0.5423167944,
-0.3352510035,
0.1672274172,
-0.2418052405,
-0.4328982234,
-0.2379847616,
-0.4060821831,
-0.836784482,
0.6963436604,
-0.1405675858,
-0.8976938128,
0.7021781206,
-0.1502634287,
0.1327100694,
-0.0079218158,
-1.1028000116,
0.9265385866,
0.1095699444,
-0.5159944892,
0.0358719453,
-0.3924016058,
0.1424487978,
-0.2229472846,
0.3165722787,
0.1172954366,
0.2409223765,
0.8743742704,
-0.4122556746,
0.4374245107,
-0.2438688576,
0.1189368069,
0.0216730833,
-0.2104659975,
0.8574857116,
-0.0672313944,
-0.297727704,
0.263355583,
-0.0591315031,
-0.392909646,
-0.8081680536,
0.5068096519,
-0.9421547651,
-0.7895162702,
-0.3425195813,
-0.4125182033,
-0.2149223685,
0.33764413,
0.4916496873,
0.4170106053,
-0.1886968464,
0.4502443671,
0.5990378857,
0.0225475375,
0.1132054627,
0.5876458883,
0.3957985938,
-0.380558461,
0.8144888878,
0.4418720305,
0.2244831175,
0.3214399517,
-0.0021536264,
-0.266090095,
-0.6366667151,
0.0407304876,
0.3043350577,
-0.8983815908,
0.1069415882,
-0.878015995,
-0.2987276316,
-0.5906659961,
-0.0316670872,
-0.4336426556,
-0.4403755367,
-0.2425311804,
-0.1471936405,
-0.3961287141,
0.7327300906,
0.2110873163,
0.1925204098,
-0.674570024,
0.4888731241,
0.0647841245,
0.2774130404,
0.0248389374,
-0.3372000158,
-0.0562414564,
-0.0760517493,
-0.4622321725,
-0.8643341064,
-0.0259137508,
-0.3167106211,
0.9120331407,
0.1892473698,
-0.0118948016,
0.8213634491,
-0.1630882323,
0.5749752522,
0.0684105307,
-0.4676047564,
0.4535822868,
-0.0705675557,
0.3323378861,
0.8860117793,
0.4375881553,
-0.4977003634,
-0.3053661883,
-0.8587695956,
-0.8541693687,
0.909301877,
0.4164895117,
-0.367536664,
0.0171077233,
0.2857706249,
0.2258736789,
0.2653858066,
-0.7340525985,
-0.0323523171,
-0.2830672562,
-0.2811170816,
0.2830762565,
-0.4072546959,
-0.2089181989,
0.1822370589,
0.4642034471,
0.2174040675,
0.1508631259,
0.465431422,
-0.2761830091,
0.0967504531,
0.437756747,
0.6730682254,
0.8410312533,
-0.4455669224,
-0.0049868361,
-0.0135524431,
-0.8026160002,
-0.00608443,
0.2417885214,
-0.4232090116,
0.0827268213,
0.7147914171,
0.9147071242,
0.2654913068,
-0.5593574643,
0.5981353521,
-0.3667551577,
-0.3193198144,
-0.0947717205,
0.3172141016,
-0.1701763719,
0.1022712439,
0.3903731406,
0.1431806237,
-0.0416290089,
-0.2767609954,
0.0734995976,
0.3902108371,
-0.3756519854,
-0.2299059927,
0.5994997025,
0.2323138416,
-0.3702353537,
0.6974523664,
-0.0128722591,
-0.2106969804,
0.7494086027,
0.3554717004,
0.8523349762,
0.2085020542,
0.0365935154,
0.2985331714,
0.3315250278,
-0.2254445702,
-0.1835515946,
-0.2394400835,
-0.4351035655,
0.0572721064,
-0.6465813518,
-0.3086876869,
0.479468286,
-0.8468952775,
0.4154127538,
-0.1584731638,
-0.0982146785,
0.1540297121,
-0.0113446899,
-0.8547555208,
0.2456851006,
-0.1012333035,
1.2458435297,
-0.7879455686,
0.7567117214,
0.4588990211,
-0.4723707139,
-0.6165120006,
0.2504589856,
-0.0877320319,
-0.4551704824,
0.9440295696,
0.2747835517,
0.2919704616,
-0.328076005,
-0.1117222235,
-0.8698279858,
1.2994930744,
0.2703651488,
-0.7273013592,
-0.3533370197,
0.165201351,
0.4833907187,
-0.3365395367,
0.4294657409,
0.5447221398,
0.6244786978,
-0.0532209016,
-0.7440993786,
-0.1290914118,
-0.2670127451,
0.0835352018,
0.3212587237,
-0.7076212168,
0.8759562373,
0.2045003325,
-0.5609281659,
-0.2522590756,
0.2478330135,
0.2370674461,
0.4000170529,
0.5079023242,
0.7496284842,
0.8325550556,
-0.1002591699,
1.187948823,
0.1461904198,
0.2721022069,
1.4878953695,
-0.3431121409,
0.7034909129,
0.4624832869,
-0.1632643491,
0.2515318096,
0.2063353509,
-0.3112729788,
0.5658388138,
-0.128519401,
0.1221274212,
0.0557526611,
0.0750652775,
-0.4859135747,
0.3203332424,
0.0315178037,
-0.5758975744,
-0.3690565825,
-0.1590916216,
-0.3402240574,
-0.0785570592,
0.137174949,
0.7505249977,
-0.2948232293,
-0.8430235982,
0.3565127254,
0.0745746568,
0.2492051125,
-0.6289379597,
-0.0270121861,
-0.4380154014,
0.0361049585,
-0.1324951798,
-0.5052168369,
0.102411218,
-0.0628632009,
-0.5429916978,
0.031838987,
0.8661245108,
-0.0194583647,
-0.3172084689,
0.2781810462,
0.1714840084,
-0.058285594,
-0.0629868954,
-0.4148787558,
0.2231539786,
0.2311912924,
-0.3515290618,
0.5792791843,
0.3435468376,
-0.3998793662,
0.4162302315,
0.497287333,
0.0321098305,
0.2840005457,
0.2326077819,
0.8690862656,
-0.7654851675,
-0.4370498955,
-0.655174613,
0.4608029127,
-0.6961641312,
-0.2938910723,
0.8974555731,
0.759357512,
0.9453780055,
-0.1467541307,
1.0218865871,
0.1940174848,
0.4810752869,
-0.3322648704,
0.5426773429,
-0.5018283129,
0.2701148689,
-0.2447040826,
-1.1632883549,
0.1538927555,
0.3864739537,
-0.3987606764,
-0.1881829947,
0.5958779454,
0.6981496811,
-0.4687708616,
0.2677507102,
0.1398797184,
-0.0800698996,
0.5380927324,
0.1877602935,
0.6036797762,
-0.6459171772,
0.4582904279,
-0.2973797023,
-0.145061627,
-0.4186118245,
-0.7059611082,
-0.6419358253,
-0.5077779293,
-0.4251856804,
-0.1367834955,
0.0489934199,
0.4300488234,
0.7700156569,
-0.6791048646,
0.131029591,
-0.152502045,
0.358283788,
0.0360598788,
-0.3204578757,
0.4992652535,
-0.1985075474,
-0.6235717535,
0.1559445858,
0.305804491,
0.2466559857,
0.092152901,
0.1973587871,
-0.2204761505,
-0.0082739294,
0.1273183078,
0.3862214386,
-0.7038189769,
-0.3781350255,
-0.3840003908,
-0.2580073476,
0.2623032629,
0.7949798703,
-0.563480556,
0.6311381459,
0.6469581127,
0.6266300678,
0.7466030717,
0.5341864824,
0.4555678964,
-0.8034505844,
0.2379327863,
-0.1228425205,
0.27355057,
0.2017510682,
-0.030593222,
0.7979187965,
0.5936502814,
-0.3678222001,
-1.0011014938,
0.0840811878,
-0.6869217753,
-0.2739770114,
0.9987089038,
-0.2369545996,
-0.5555806756,
-0.0113676153,
-0.0931885242,
0.202798605,
-0.1749299467,
0.8576177955,
0.9792459607,
0.1054995507,
-0.0030461133,
-0.4952790141,
0.3284029961,
0.2005853951,
-0.7248086333,
0.4068616331,
0.4381006658,
0.3878888786,
0.7262256145,
0.6617567539,
-0.1976448745,
0.4595604539,
0.2464186847,
0.0420380011,
-0.229090929,
-0.3619306386,
-0.1016386673,
0.6137605309,
-0.0985126048,
-0.1283997893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14933v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14933v2 | An Empirical Study of Multimodal Model Merging | 2023-04-28T15:43:21 | 2023-10-11T15:08:51 | Yi-Lin Sung, Linjie Li, Kevin Lin, Zhe Gan, Mohit Bansal, Lijuan Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Model merging (e.g., via interpolation or task arithmetic) fuses multiple
models trained on different tasks to generate a multi-task solution. The
technique has been proven successful in previous studies, where the models are
trained on similar tasks and with the same initialization. In this paper, we
expand on this concept to a multimodal setup by merging transformers trained on
different modalities. Furthermore, we conduct our study for a novel goal where
we can merge vision, language, and cross-modal transformers of a
modality-specific architecture to create a parameter-efficient
modality-agnostic architecture. Through comprehensive experiments, we
systematically investigate the key factors impacting model performance after
merging, including initialization, merging mechanisms, and model architectures.
We also propose two metrics that assess the distance between weights to be
merged and can serve as an indicator of the merging outcomes. Our analysis
leads to an effective training recipe for matching the performance of the
modality-agnostic baseline (i.e., pre-trained from scratch) via model merging.
Our method also outperforms naive merging significantly on various tasks, with
improvements of 3% on VQA, 7% on COCO retrieval, 25% on NLVR2, 14% on Flickr30k
and 3% on ADE20k. Our code is available at https://github.com/ylsung/vl-merging | [
-0.7783318758,
-0.3594098985,
0.3673038781,
0.0427508764,
-0.1602351218,
0.0506442748,
-0.1690873802,
-0.6708629131,
-0.0884816796,
0.1050466299,
-0.5318621397,
0.0566154085,
-0.6435253024,
-0.2562745214,
-0.6049591899,
0.7040044069,
-0.0529127792,
0.1678661108,
-0.4556649029,
-0.3693651259,
-0.5782072544,
-0.3780123889,
-0.1569662541,
-0.0662625358,
0.6049236655,
0.0528537892,
0.6774136424,
0.5445692539,
0.5745870471,
0.3902014196,
0.3092937171,
0.7520956993,
-0.1931473017,
0.0459934957,
-0.1819677055,
-0.2351547331,
-0.5485560894,
0.2947782576,
0.4587605894,
0.5756604075,
-0.0007789104,
0.1813241243,
0.1659595072,
0.1058124229,
-0.7812111378,
-0.073022753,
-0.4488267601,
0.1668509096,
-0.0774009749,
-0.4421341419,
-0.3828524053,
-0.1159159988,
-0.0862584934,
-0.3811458945,
0.1943999678,
-0.0272503663,
0.9868986011,
0.3999415934,
-0.9623421431,
0.1538088024,
-0.8984684944,
0.8450254798,
-0.6033068299,
0.7117997408,
-0.0974532813,
0.4786856472,
0.3678379953,
-0.4058304727,
-0.9116254449,
-0.1125301197,
-0.2761187553,
0.1023210809,
-0.4487838447,
-0.0132076843,
0.1224812642,
0.3983273208,
-0.5016419888,
-0.0832341611,
-0.8488917351,
-0.1255201548,
0.4919817746,
0.1529385895,
0.3743415177,
-0.1298199892,
-0.7558020949,
-0.458888799,
-0.1877421588,
0.1484673917,
0.4938285947,
0.3358002603,
-0.197807923,
0.7740623355,
-0.0691781119,
0.956517458,
0.1550927162,
-0.1614652872,
0.4523027241,
-1.0983123779,
-0.1933750063,
-0.2033665776,
0.6704638004,
0.6947731376,
0.0152268615,
-0.251416415,
-0.3462252617,
0.3935159147,
0.74841851,
-0.4018694758,
-0.0936263949,
-0.0392258912,
-0.5415792465,
-0.3159730732,
-0.2554511726,
-0.1119445711,
0.0707856342,
-0.8321430087,
0.7946420908,
-0.6059062481,
-0.440272063,
0.020300135,
-0.1136752591,
0.3526203334,
0.4056335986,
-0.6575142145,
-0.0285971891,
0.6063792109,
0.6701307893,
-0.1856951863,
-0.4779438376,
-0.4992251694,
0.0332047828,
-0.1922907531,
0.5779272318,
-0.2333295494,
-0.3183678389,
-0.0506118871,
-0.0314960517,
-0.373832494,
-0.2796638906,
0.1230278537,
-0.5389211178,
0.6561752558,
-0.1367140561,
-0.2229479551,
-0.4693677425,
0.5253628492,
-0.8291321993,
0.9138821363,
0.2540080249,
-0.2984347343,
0.7115986347,
-0.4899945557,
-0.3585999608,
-0.071635671,
-0.2308049649,
-0.1395204961,
0.3548377156,
0.0950286016,
0.5988693237,
-0.5042817593,
0.0479827709,
-0.2579041421,
-0.1305163652,
0.1511687785,
-0.5683309436,
0.4430344105,
0.3869316876,
0.0227483548,
0.3390852213,
-0.4829643071,
0.1757826954,
-0.290697515,
-0.3748014867,
-0.2023763359,
-0.4421919882,
0.6010767221,
0.578291595,
0.3181898296,
-0.1563775837,
0.4372643232,
0.023106847,
0.3438554406,
0.4159184694,
-0.451487273,
0.7907901406,
-0.7388005257,
0.4285722375,
0.3258284628,
0.2421542704,
-0.361954689,
-0.3614619672,
-0.7293912172,
-0.4785488546,
0.2901565135,
0.2801600397,
-0.8693517447,
0.1551925689,
-0.4968254268,
-0.5742308497,
-0.5514543056,
0.1056295484,
0.5581951141,
0.4130097926,
0.4382076561,
-0.588914454,
-0.3652825058,
-1.1442410946,
-0.0273479521,
-0.0937903002,
0.0554670691,
0.2978875041,
0.1353881955,
-0.2320189327,
0.9257853031,
-0.0930319577,
-0.3551852703,
-0.0627487153,
0.3066474199,
0.0347769298,
0.7819579244,
0.8810533285,
-1.1419663429,
-0.5048924685,
0.3084928095,
-0.7690294981,
0.2352500856,
-0.117211014,
0.1649175435,
-0.0478805676,
0.5733049512,
-0.6940283179,
0.1575183868,
0.7607123256,
-0.0550576001,
0.4191202521,
-0.2117073387,
0.9551082253,
-1.4048056602,
-0.0384116732,
0.0919091478,
-0.1186649352,
-0.7189900875,
0.0811141878,
0.2624830902,
-0.076161541,
-0.8019222021,
0.3806005418,
-0.627761066,
-0.0013855097,
-0.1294394732,
-0.1688112319,
-0.0347593687,
0.5766516924,
-0.4407270551,
0.6014329195,
0.5072701573,
-0.444375366,
0.3775971532,
0.0593673661,
-0.1918785125,
0.6734247208,
-0.1938243806,
-0.171417594,
-0.2026401907,
-0.0954448953,
-1.4502738714,
-0.3165877759,
0.0801324621,
-0.2615230083,
0.3110499084,
-0.1532435864,
-0.3049316406,
-0.1465536207,
-0.1408423483,
1.1039403677,
0.3936389983,
-0.3382540941,
1.3104060888,
-0.0817698389,
0.1743752509,
-0.5532121658,
-0.6117863655,
0.0906539857,
-0.3097893596,
-0.8586377501,
0.7491158247,
-0.1497720182,
0.1142202467,
0.3480105698,
0.0632850826,
-0.1060414091,
-0.3301876485,
0.237069279,
0.6124169827,
-0.3221138418,
0.0578702912,
0.2102666944,
0.1522680819,
-0.5650330782,
0.0545488223,
0.5551239848,
-0.0724269673,
-0.7382479906,
-0.3918811083,
0.4251895845,
1.1530075073,
-0.4603242278,
0.6471395493,
0.8687874079,
-0.229507193,
0.2272289991,
-0.9487649202,
-0.0111267613,
-0.3882843554,
0.3678578436,
-0.6563524604,
-0.7068893909,
0.406003803,
-0.0262011979,
0.3098089695,
0.1302426308,
0.5054373741,
0.0432079025,
1.1194583178,
0.8497812152,
0.2329728603,
0.5902810097,
-0.2532666028,
0.3750877082,
-0.7934706807,
-0.5444234014,
0.0233491287,
-0.7530310154,
-0.4312404692,
-1.0070520639,
0.4514083564,
0.0198195819,
0.2158220559,
0.6841086149,
-0.3456112742,
0.3017277122,
0.3578269482,
0.0647974014,
0.418836683,
0.1134795025,
0.0078058061,
-0.058879707,
-0.8650049567,
-0.0145275882,
1.0043662786,
-0.0245174654,
0.5075575113,
0.2190233469,
0.4982027411,
0.2016101778,
0.2328192592,
-0.8301097751,
0.6124389172,
-0.247622326,
-0.4214034677,
0.0312814638,
-0.2990962863,
-0.6886307597,
0.7476039529,
-0.7824174762,
-0.3654631674,
0.5195826888,
0.1923056692,
-0.2821572721,
0.034339346,
-0.7344119549,
0.7310724854,
-0.4796425998,
-0.3003549278,
-0.5346280932,
-0.4841261208,
0.7672903538,
-0.2351066619,
0.188567996,
-0.0798348635,
0.0632689148,
0.2432037443,
-0.0446263142,
0.3369360566,
0.303712666,
0.0014160678,
-0.1999064386,
0.074593775,
-0.0167309791,
-0.4177808166,
0.4687185884,
0.4011569321,
-0.0868330598,
-0.1748733521,
-0.7545650005,
0.6717051864,
-0.5864305496,
-0.3333690763,
-0.1686310768,
-1.0094890594,
-0.3070835173,
0.1276263744,
0.0434608981,
0.8871029019,
0.1082965359,
0.368562907,
0.3253542483,
0.2080207467,
0.4054158032,
0.541164279,
-0.3198384643,
-0.4413314164,
0.6936750412,
-0.0140408194,
0.4471379519,
0.3414941132,
-0.2493630052,
-0.2185144722,
-0.2050644755,
-0.5379279256,
0.0599818826,
-0.6426289678,
-0.2219004184,
-0.5894533396,
-0.237243399,
-0.3536102474,
-0.2969504297,
-0.5632247925,
-0.2127517313,
0.0859807879,
0.2707537711,
-0.0346388407,
0.4096786082,
-0.2335124761,
0.3096476495,
-1.0857553482,
0.2316371799,
0.3913769722,
-0.0315901749,
0.0952985436,
-0.3107047081,
-0.2904144526,
0.0970758349,
-0.1444606036,
-0.7989512086,
0.3683486879,
0.13314192,
0.6645902991,
0.3795303106,
-0.348156631,
1.046359539,
-0.3783220649,
0.5832136869,
0.8506757021,
-0.7423166037,
0.1490531862,
-0.2857236862,
0.3507857621,
0.4197654426,
0.5653311014,
-0.2878514528,
-0.190766871,
-0.2627510726,
-1.0007148981,
0.6793992519,
0.1344580352,
0.0284874793,
0.2455435246,
-0.066496484,
-0.0851090923,
0.3733441532,
-0.4794224501,
-0.1950824559,
-0.1192772016,
-0.3552138209,
-0.2614013851,
0.1296831965,
-0.6374281049,
-0.5697216988,
0.0943102539,
-0.0930501074,
0.0021429968,
-0.4328680336,
-0.3907601833,
0.0666265488,
0.0035835842,
0.4519286156,
0.5711846352,
0.112125963,
0.2615205944,
0.0025962749,
-0.0777799636,
0.1586503834,
0.110377714,
0.1844638288,
-0.2447391897,
0.5025059581,
0.8356124759,
0.556325078,
-0.6333949566,
0.5781891346,
-0.2377117872,
-0.4259552956,
0.3110635579,
0.1390156746,
-0.1373183578,
0.7539544702,
0.2795000672,
0.6776255965,
0.1024729311,
-0.6749466658,
0.3622020483,
0.737298727,
-0.2701670825,
-0.4038249552,
0.8229529858,
0.2361485511,
-0.01425716,
0.5757697821,
0.0413726568,
-0.4117628634,
0.2351086289,
0.2719032466,
0.7826037407,
-0.1000643149,
0.0069596162,
0.1366485059,
0.2167464197,
-0.0616974011,
-0.0911526382,
-0.5419185758,
-0.7306326032,
-0.7786619663,
-0.6828843355,
-0.0060541513,
-0.2266686857,
-0.6196401119,
0.5026381612,
0.2064063251,
-0.4554247856,
0.0542574637,
-0.4489534497,
-0.9252369404,
0.2155755162,
0.2519212961,
0.4844196737,
-1.1053748131,
0.645185709,
0.9710872769,
-0.6133238673,
-0.9885229468,
-0.2654325664,
0.0201434083,
-0.6596211195,
0.7801203728,
0.1530480087,
-0.1045434624,
-0.1790134162,
0.0636606216,
-1.0040752888,
1.2793314457,
0.3247803152,
-0.3719926178,
-0.2934420705,
0.1213320121,
0.119850941,
-0.5425780416,
0.2745738924,
0.234644115,
0.3054186404,
0.4155604839,
-1.4772740602,
0.0181399584,
-0.5487502217,
0.0703003407,
0.401858896,
-0.4535450041,
1.3209369183,
-0.0427677743,
-0.2243115008,
0.0033877143,
0.4860017896,
-0.178783372,
0.1814613789,
0.9131512046,
0.6848409176,
0.2718678117,
-0.1040192991,
0.7215591073,
-0.7627613544,
0.3868286312,
0.7318415642,
0.0263634138,
0.4948782921,
0.6519613266,
0.1874947697,
0.1266297251,
0.2320466489,
0.0535487235,
0.7542741895,
-0.6344481707,
-0.1846595258,
-0.6346082687,
-0.139830485,
-0.5470830798,
0.9264560342,
-0.1799622625,
-0.3279775083,
-0.4743063152,
0.5016999841,
-0.2940570712,
-0.0753909573,
-0.0579934828,
0.5237787366,
-0.3537065983,
-0.7175205946,
0.4649821222,
-0.1737006605,
0.8615770936,
-0.6623235941,
-0.0353617482,
0.1053495854,
0.1619451344,
-0.169557929,
-0.4694761336,
0.2799251974,
-0.534147501,
-0.400491178,
-0.5364283323,
0.5979039073,
-0.8418843746,
-0.2246249318,
0.1378872842,
0.8637741804,
-0.2153034955,
0.0788280219,
-0.4281763136,
0.442515105,
-0.0594494306,
0.0736598372,
0.5612350702,
0.0842356384,
-0.0403790809,
0.466848731,
0.8324927092,
-0.160767436,
0.174800083,
-0.1205883995,
1.0168991089,
-0.230781585,
-0.3636995554,
-0.6295760274,
0.8733964562,
-0.0146789849,
-0.3335757554,
0.8644530177,
0.6577554345,
0.9537966847,
-0.2265919149,
0.6160815358,
-0.2529337108,
-0.1628260314,
-0.4673627615,
0.6175379753,
-1.3616501093,
0.0240500886,
0.0431826897,
-1.2060883045,
0.1241733059,
0.2409868389,
-0.0973336101,
0.0692789033,
0.4480055869,
0.8098622561,
-0.5446949005,
-0.5339751244,
0.5623244643,
-0.3178570569,
0.3324038684,
0.5361332893,
0.7627437711,
-0.4996390343,
0.5032635927,
-0.290301621,
-0.2274593413,
-0.3655648828,
-0.6278092861,
-0.5039109588,
-1.0033326149,
-0.2296274006,
-0.1703078747,
-0.1997799277,
0.6979131103,
0.9173582196,
-0.1920659244,
-0.1780443788,
0.3997011483,
-0.4198719859,
-0.4364995062,
-0.1835351586,
-0.0459455214,
-0.2984666228,
-1.1850231886,
0.4692716599,
0.4646618664,
-0.0915694684,
-0.4752245247,
0.0579108931,
-0.1732939482,
0.2992618978,
0.817792356,
0.1040127575,
-0.7895050645,
-0.1765258312,
0.0614944547,
-0.1725642085,
-0.1629657745,
1.0077598095,
-0.9129060507,
0.8732668161,
0.6036124229,
0.5424102545,
0.3871533573,
0.1817880422,
0.7148551941,
-0.752374649,
0.232528463,
-0.0467667654,
0.4854876697,
0.2663422525,
0.1250445992,
0.4254328012,
0.1341777593,
-0.1486676335,
-1.1533200741,
0.3488665819,
-1.4437310696,
-0.0271490179,
0.9549635053,
0.4027099609,
0.1389721781,
0.2919678092,
-0.1189731807,
0.36007303,
0.0891895518,
0.6271359324,
0.602055788,
-0.2666023076,
-0.0462795012,
-0.4035733044,
0.2587369084,
0.4171111584,
-0.466005981,
-0.4420557916,
0.5742943883,
0.2106643766,
0.5631759167,
0.3406209946,
-0.0889935195,
0.5561498404,
0.1022148356,
0.2522292435,
-0.5253143907,
-0.4299149215,
-0.2295103222,
0.3679475188,
-0.2686005533,
-0.3949595094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14931v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14931v2 | HQP: A Human-Annotated Dataset for Detecting Online Propaganda | 2023-04-28T15:42:55 | 2023-05-01T08:29:51 | Abdurahman Maarouf, Dominik Bär, Dominique Geissler, Stefan Feuerriegel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online propaganda poses a severe threat to the integrity of societies.
However, existing datasets for detecting online propaganda have a key
limitation: they were annotated using weak labels that can be noisy and even
incorrect. To address this limitation, our work makes the following
contributions: (1) We present HQP: a novel dataset (N=30,000) for detecting
online propaganda with high-quality labels. To the best of our knowledge, HQP
is the first dataset for detecting online propaganda that was created through
human annotation. (2) We show empirically that state-of-the-art language models
fail in detecting online propaganda when trained with weak labels (AUC: 64.03).
In contrast, state-of-the-art language models can accurately detect online
propaganda when trained with our high-quality labels (AUC: 92.25), which is an
improvement of ~44%. (3) To address the cost of labeling, we extend our work to
few-shot learning. Specifically, we show that prompt-based learning using a
small sample of high-quality labels can still achieve a reasonable performance
(AUC: 80.27). Finally, we discuss implications for the NLP community to balance
the cost and quality of labeling. Crucially, our work highlights the importance
of high-quality labels for sensitive NLP tasks such as propaganda detection. | [
-0.4905970693,
-0.5941138864,
0.1097290739,
0.0892335102,
-0.0251736287,
-0.0301593244,
-0.2556832135,
-0.5917054415,
0.1374795586,
0.6077799201,
-0.2339877635,
-0.5529763103,
-0.9757519364,
0.2615258098,
-0.1194056422,
0.9682231545,
0.389472425,
-0.1466372758,
0.1174283549,
-0.2737776637,
-0.0482933447,
-0.6834219098,
-0.4752273858,
-0.384783566,
0.7032926679,
0.4547323585,
0.9677607417,
0.9150851965,
0.578541398,
0.2363839746,
0.0053901151,
0.3466323912,
-0.8499982357,
0.0346442126,
-0.099937506,
-0.4260401428,
-0.1520842016,
0.2554146349,
0.7300556898,
0.5710080862,
-0.0121701648,
0.2406922877,
0.3354539573,
0.5762353539,
-0.8779984713,
0.0426731668,
-0.6047436595,
0.0155613963,
-0.3692084551,
0.0384827778,
-0.6928757429,
-0.1451970786,
-0.0459427983,
-0.8721507788,
0.1400725693,
0.2914345562,
1.2371411324,
0.253339231,
-0.1614462286,
-0.1982660592,
-0.6631017327,
0.9918331504,
-0.5322007537,
0.2560776174,
0.7556488514,
0.1822562218,
-0.1589026302,
-0.7623972297,
-0.4712736011,
0.1023799777,
0.0569097996,
-0.0418429747,
-0.4527919292,
-0.0701074898,
0.517927289,
0.0759877786,
-0.582003057,
0.2522317469,
-0.2038430423,
-0.6531694531,
0.4781009555,
-0.1869268119,
0.3283191323,
-0.5593857169,
-0.6534246802,
-0.1509574205,
-0.6396358609,
-0.1495586187,
0.6489033103,
0.3785513341,
-0.0383301154,
0.5672113895,
-0.398627013,
0.7202307582,
-0.0378039703,
-0.405836314,
0.043716602,
0.0197604056,
-0.1482928693,
0.1020329073,
0.8958210349,
0.3312013745,
0.2223476321,
0.251375556,
-0.1680042148,
0.4506568015,
0.1150584221,
-0.7492125034,
-0.465247333,
-0.0425628424,
-0.5244778395,
-0.3871454895,
0.0562833659,
-0.7553748488,
-0.5387775302,
-0.12092565,
0.5876498818,
-0.1753180176,
-0.0329791345,
-0.0938376039,
-0.2095361352,
0.0251094103,
0.1788030416,
-0.8091367483,
0.040761549,
0.7949948907,
0.8308271766,
-0.156886667,
-0.2152603716,
-0.7791600823,
0.0324079022,
-0.4563173652,
1.142113924,
-0.4091789424,
0.0961224809,
0.2063481957,
-0.0970689729,
0.4606823325,
-0.70854038,
0.7168265581,
-0.5272219777,
0.2359598726,
-0.4725314081,
-0.6376789212,
0.1969907284,
0.4463877678,
-0.8537549376,
1.0629711151,
0.3735154271,
-0.9394700527,
0.4195071757,
-0.1545651257,
-0.204250291,
0.3494091034,
0.0619360544,
-0.523758769,
-0.3101167977,
0.2935660481,
0.3021003604,
-0.0680750832,
0.2676173151,
-0.3259724677,
-0.4298816919,
0.4375219941,
-0.5220355988,
1.1415604353,
0.4121299088,
-0.3035947978,
-0.0821799785,
-0.8095849752,
-0.101002425,
-0.0798973888,
-0.7008357048,
-0.3110264838,
-0.1475469321,
0.0127875172,
0.262509495,
0.0730407238,
-0.4512551725,
0.2158243209,
-0.3586675525,
0.0345417969,
0.8282083273,
-0.0500069559,
0.2605811357,
-0.4168809056,
0.4526921511,
-0.2272620946,
0.2992739081,
-0.1704324931,
-0.9091798663,
-0.7697246075,
-0.4410967827,
0.3523501754,
0.624327004,
-0.9089074731,
0.442450583,
0.0011043195,
-0.2603962421,
-0.7523226142,
0.212767601,
0.4189202487,
0.6037454605,
0.4932333529,
-0.2808960676,
-0.7442080975,
-1.017614603,
-0.5634340048,
-0.4529097676,
-0.5338035226,
-0.034715727,
0.3674768507,
-0.1597601324,
0.8569255471,
-0.609103024,
-0.7388234735,
-0.2076708525,
0.7386114001,
0.0516847745,
0.2085861564,
0.1668024808,
-0.6517144442,
-0.5416381359,
-0.551805675,
-0.7629668713,
-0.3538277447,
-0.0929049626,
-0.1607338637,
0.074189879,
0.1516653299,
-0.5493653417,
0.1301783621,
0.5099045038,
-0.3029284477,
0.465282023,
-0.0512269661,
0.3139111996,
-0.8791337609,
-0.2170335054,
0.3426311314,
-0.2809332013,
-0.5896314383,
0.0267202035,
-0.1620704979,
-0.2173679918,
-0.8704169393,
0.367942214,
-0.1313058287,
0.1227001399,
-0.5341861248,
0.1070559174,
0.2285997272,
0.4254624248,
0.0768068656,
0.3844231963,
0.4323795438,
-0.3068941236,
0.5646990538,
0.434515208,
-0.5392296314,
0.8885499239,
-0.2670878172,
0.0137511278,
-0.2464534193,
0.3850083351,
-0.833686173,
-0.7365148664,
0.5777620077,
-0.56817168,
0.2407259345,
-0.3610546887,
-0.5250412226,
0.0141795464,
-0.3236795962,
0.0670282096,
0.6748214364,
-0.6681552529,
-0.0119895758,
0.703579545,
0.1474383324,
-0.6985443234,
-0.5326858163,
0.3414167166,
-0.1992541999,
-0.2537225485,
0.071589224,
0.3056136072,
-0.2519339621,
-0.0979290977,
0.2460875511,
-0.237484172,
-0.1037630513,
0.2207571566,
0.0783726647,
-0.2839367986,
0.1936092377,
-0.4659586549,
-0.2980819643,
0.0099663651,
-0.2592772543,
0.1304241717,
-0.1510311961,
-0.1193002611,
-0.7948986292,
0.5217104554,
0.0345720276,
0.0761972591,
0.8115493655,
0.9729450345,
-0.7009925246,
-0.2249294072,
-0.4791336358,
-0.3579082787,
-0.4713196158,
0.170785144,
0.0769055262,
-0.5675650835,
-0.0428967476,
-0.1157135069,
-0.1560688019,
0.6189197302,
0.4201244116,
-0.4011689126,
1.1876938343,
0.6161990166,
-0.2341379672,
0.2485141009,
-0.1829871684,
0.0299615804,
-0.4380508363,
-0.1752280146,
-0.6842315197,
-0.3959397972,
-0.7607391477,
-0.396391809,
0.3223052621,
0.2407280654,
-0.3539952636,
0.2783240378,
-0.7188510299,
0.5297804475,
0.6622287631,
0.0706044808,
0.3571482301,
0.2563072145,
0.5042340159,
-0.4012316167,
-0.9048660398,
-0.7931221128,
0.9915779829,
0.4089894891,
0.8078162074,
-0.0958199799,
0.4658827484,
0.7363268137,
0.7232511044,
-0.6725968719,
0.496126771,
-0.0071656592,
-0.86650002,
-0.4381886721,
-0.4383779168,
-1.1008107662,
0.3477682471,
-0.6165360808,
-0.6394489408,
0.2386172414,
0.4040762186,
-0.2043470889,
0.4777236879,
-0.4915197492,
0.9226068258,
-0.1068384871,
-0.4171484411,
0.0754699484,
-0.725656569,
0.2649535239,
0.0561693199,
0.365264833,
-0.4726577699,
-0.0530994274,
0.9947296381,
-0.0400600582,
1.1236894131,
-0.0537504964,
0.1197592989,
0.5178331137,
-0.1403436214,
0.4036211073,
-0.1653135121,
0.0695394427,
0.3974292874,
-0.1984077692,
-0.7214384675,
-0.1461954117,
0.5534319282,
-0.7266154885,
-0.3933106363,
-0.6446473598,
-0.3551704586,
0.0698429868,
0.2029421031,
0.6310480237,
0.4001549482,
-0.0924249366,
0.3585542738,
0.6891005039,
-0.3559687734,
0.0835871324,
0.1385172158,
0.0720681325,
-0.6071206331,
1.1807767153,
0.2326790541,
0.1976888478,
0.3426284492,
0.4953269362,
-0.3034487665,
-0.1386633962,
-0.4968378544,
0.1505440474,
-1.0958707333,
-0.3632224798,
-0.5016396046,
0.1324778348,
-0.4207431674,
-0.0501986593,
-0.4890959561,
-0.4177659154,
-0.5345696807,
0.1716471016,
0.0052822479,
0.7097203135,
-0.3751626313,
0.5545201302,
-0.6975640655,
0.8986905217,
0.4105375409,
0.2458639145,
-0.4782887101,
-0.6466819048,
-0.3455176651,
0.2059090585,
-0.5940281749,
-1.1676267385,
0.5269864202,
0.2028549463,
0.3502773643,
0.7851324081,
0.6655638218,
0.3422457874,
-0.0943355784,
0.823156476,
0.0690080374,
-0.6494843364,
0.4082431495,
-0.3723616302,
0.2742014527,
0.4149691761,
0.9894298315,
-0.4928931296,
-0.5819323659,
-0.8334925771,
-0.663893044,
0.5772719383,
0.1811620593,
-0.0403853692,
-0.1937295496,
0.0780479163,
0.0779967085,
0.1899594665,
-0.8522742987,
-0.3358626068,
-0.2777394056,
-0.1143135577,
0.0323427282,
-0.4174831212,
-0.2104320526,
-0.118365474,
0.8446673751,
-0.2565986514,
0.0863728598,
0.1082930863,
-0.2673028111,
-0.3662791848,
0.3239794075,
0.1845426857,
0.713080287,
-0.112531364,
0.3903859854,
-0.0408699401,
-0.2538928092,
0.2140589058,
-0.21949929,
-0.5565460324,
0.1870300025,
0.7084755898,
0.7093711495,
0.277392894,
-0.6148409843,
0.7147626877,
0.3080756962,
-0.0409372263,
-0.1683959961,
-0.168236807,
-0.0302748382,
0.1044108346,
0.4392372966,
0.0806558654,
0.1785572916,
-0.6037898064,
0.4321851134,
0.4201593697,
-0.4586833417,
-0.2425539643,
0.7515485287,
0.1613989323,
-0.5502941608,
0.8092921972,
-0.3405192196,
-0.6794678569,
0.3087468743,
0.4018969536,
0.4270801544,
-0.3037672043,
0.7053115964,
0.6181084514,
0.5914441347,
-0.4106036127,
0.0189286768,
0.0677742809,
-0.7743194103,
-0.4902768731,
-0.5702566504,
-0.6546616554,
0.3860656321,
-0.6653428078,
0.3083234727,
-0.2717038989,
-0.4023880064,
0.0407126769,
-0.1195903048,
-0.536470294,
0.2560634911,
0.520359993,
0.4306437075,
-1.1478390694,
0.6767851114,
0.3194982111,
-0.2005527616,
-0.3057772219,
-0.1364426911,
0.2279656529,
-0.5083796382,
0.5956594944,
0.4372975528,
0.0315115787,
0.0262604225,
-0.8956247568,
-0.7629855871,
0.3832362592,
0.5076044202,
-0.3374227285,
0.1375505775,
0.3870924115,
0.467327863,
-0.2034333795,
-0.1657208949,
0.5778931379,
0.6670618057,
-0.2172540277,
-0.4480390847,
-0.0931140035,
0.219201386,
-0.3703154027,
0.1213945821,
-0.4288408756,
0.6629972458,
-0.1805021316,
-0.5567306876,
-0.2347547859,
0.7338657975,
0.125911504,
0.4473915696,
0.5036502481,
0.6084008813,
0.6283031106,
-0.2682995796,
0.9714929461,
0.1436195225,
0.4441889822,
0.8637611866,
-0.0354883261,
1.0170634985,
0.3092387617,
-0.1605382413,
0.2777070403,
0.7324200869,
-0.2722226977,
0.2252857238,
0.1851560324,
-0.2516769469,
-0.658965826,
-0.5710971951,
-0.0008113219,
0.3441374004,
0.3314602077,
-0.0337327123,
-0.2300421149,
0.1933419257,
-0.0313354544,
0.3008153439,
-0.1832471341,
0.7687157989,
0.1030565798,
-0.5835975409,
0.8887889981,
0.0322596058,
0.6884275079,
-0.4264430106,
-0.1417901069,
0.1430260092,
0.0922921821,
-0.2734508514,
-0.7074118257,
0.218354553,
-0.0642592013,
0.1550503671,
-0.3643606007,
0.8879559636,
-0.4723237753,
-0.2985221446,
0.0838938206,
0.3259828985,
0.2950464785,
-0.3104039431,
-0.6384475827,
0.2718165517,
-0.2368310839,
-0.4392495751,
0.5111322403,
0.153787449,
0.0643971711,
0.720936656,
0.8429778814,
0.2537722588,
-0.0814306736,
-0.1879239678,
0.5295450687,
-0.5053418279,
-0.5336655378,
-0.7032183409,
0.1670287699,
-0.2784026265,
-0.4144224226,
0.6603463888,
0.5573846102,
1.1928340197,
-0.0637512058,
0.7889750004,
0.2314107716,
0.5633615255,
-0.4139769375,
0.7288859487,
-0.3352334797,
0.0882151648,
-0.0732140243,
-0.8308694959,
-0.5424144864,
0.6440008879,
0.0513678007,
-0.4949997962,
0.6095820665,
0.7473275661,
0.0711611509,
-0.1783365458,
0.5832246542,
0.1584695429,
0.1812948287,
0.3648740053,
1.1024199724,
-0.394444257,
0.8305252194,
-0.6463877559,
-0.2823382616,
-0.3716925681,
-1.0067762136,
-0.9737884998,
-0.5154798627,
-0.5076794624,
-0.5726395845,
-0.0463436805,
1.006927371,
0.8011783361,
-0.691175878,
-0.1284687221,
0.5030224323,
0.2025171518,
-0.3904455602,
-0.228374362,
0.3720272183,
-0.1999204457,
-0.686610043,
0.3011778295,
0.2937531471,
0.046506796,
-0.3992859423,
-0.069080539,
-0.1902643591,
0.1099685952,
0.6363289952,
0.528979063,
-0.7887986898,
-0.3883534968,
-0.3932303786,
-0.3324030936,
0.3609265983,
0.7591168284,
-0.7249575853,
0.5496748686,
0.6715840101,
0.6656683683,
0.293830961,
0.212678507,
0.2414700836,
-0.9606240392,
0.2867437303,
0.4885182381,
0.1512599736,
0.742982924,
-0.4194716513,
0.204039067,
0.5219060779,
-0.6685193777,
-0.9168395996,
0.4370502532,
-0.6904664636,
-0.3401441574,
1.1686118841,
-0.2948944271,
-0.2179257423,
-0.5594722033,
-0.2705540359,
0.3659431636,
-0.3397846818,
1.1830832958,
0.6237171888,
0.0127341049,
-0.0390871279,
-0.6927040815,
0.7384209633,
0.0705478415,
-1.0009129047,
-0.0096824002,
0.7120633125,
-0.0247859731,
0.240954414,
0.5547668934,
0.3389171958,
0.172129944,
0.1984203756,
0.0466033146,
0.0888532475,
-0.545886755,
-0.1484437734,
0.5368298292,
0.0641671717,
-0.1698166877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14827v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14827v3 | ChatGPT Evaluation on Sentence Level Relations: A Focus on Temporal, Causal, and Discourse Relations | 2023-04-28T13:14:36 | 2024-01-26T10:33:08 | Chunkit Chan, Jiayang Cheng, Weiqi Wang, Yuxin Jiang, Tianqing Fang, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper aims to quantitatively evaluate the performance of ChatGPT, an
interactive large language model, on inter-sentential relations such as
temporal relations, causal relations, and discourse relations. Given ChatGPT's
promising performance across various tasks, we proceed to carry out thorough
evaluations on the whole test sets of 11 datasets, including temporal and
causal relations, PDTB2.0-based, and dialogue-based discourse relations. To
ensure the reliability of our findings, we employ three tailored prompt
templates for each task, including the zero-shot prompt template, zero-shot
prompt engineering (PE) template, and in-context learning (ICL) prompt
template, to establish the initial baseline scores for all popular
sentence-pair relation classification tasks for the first time. Through our
study, we discover that ChatGPT exhibits exceptional proficiency in detecting
and reasoning about causal relations, albeit it may not possess the same level
of expertise in identifying the temporal order between two events. While it is
capable of identifying the majority of discourse relations with existing
explicit discourse connectives, the implicit discourse relation remains a
formidable challenge. Concurrently, ChatGPT demonstrates subpar performance in
the dialogue discourse parsing task that requires structural understanding in a
dialogue before being aware of the discourse relation. | [
-0.1474525779,
-1.1470975876,
0.7678381801,
0.8606776595,
-0.0158985313,
0.0538545139,
-0.099377647,
-0.2577211261,
-0.3584987223,
0.0210830513,
-0.4253431261,
-0.2600463927,
-0.5027115941,
-0.1643481106,
-0.3733815849,
1.0719652176,
0.162675783,
0.0729392767,
-0.1602324694,
0.082845062,
-0.6532096863,
-0.6639254689,
-0.9536699653,
-0.162069872,
0.6062026024,
0.0449483208,
0.5875372291,
0.1875319034,
0.5886055827,
0.2571062744,
-0.4355698824,
-0.2860387564,
-0.5982983708,
0.2305725664,
-0.2829011083,
-0.0879474208,
-0.3034670651,
0.0533969142,
0.7134766579,
0.7831813693,
0.0778180659,
0.1382579058,
0.1239012331,
0.2014163733,
-0.3912812769,
0.9733209014,
-0.5649343133,
0.0381499454,
-0.2246553749,
-0.3612748682,
-0.7371624708,
-0.3069005013,
0.2930410802,
-0.5085474849,
-0.068403922,
0.4002036452,
0.8955796361,
0.2064604014,
-0.9394679666,
-0.2096941769,
-0.6278407574,
0.2124053836,
-0.579225421,
0.2346973717,
0.1365225315,
0.2984043062,
-0.3785990179,
-0.8215276599,
-0.5653957725,
-0.6787247062,
-0.2475584298,
0.5951002836,
-0.1606894583,
0.3203011155,
0.6504526138,
0.2747187614,
-0.8302782178,
0.0520111807,
-0.2368006557,
-0.0263616703,
0.2529099584,
0.3571369648,
0.540268898,
-0.6211279035,
-0.5430732965,
0.1885221452,
-0.6837721467,
0.1508098245,
0.2905379832,
0.2576613426,
-0.0918437392,
0.7795885205,
-0.0441306531,
0.5599178672,
-0.0739051029,
0.1716112345,
-0.1562161595,
-0.5989307165,
-0.124792628,
0.0212388802,
1.0385092497,
0.1815121323,
0.3331659436,
-0.0685034469,
0.2620894909,
0.1335213482,
-0.0145977344,
-0.7639157772,
-0.2143625766,
-0.0348263048,
-0.292216897,
-0.0909840986,
-0.1381704062,
-0.4499585629,
-0.152032882,
-0.2939988375,
0.3903683126,
-0.7588319182,
-0.0049967943,
-0.0425905623,
0.0497066081,
0.4908470213,
0.2887978554,
-0.4661952555,
0.4089466631,
0.8615587354,
0.9246323705,
0.0617949367,
-0.4382016957,
-0.6690750718,
0.0662300587,
-0.0583244599,
0.9037008286,
-0.6903883815,
-0.2458629012,
-0.1311073303,
-0.1494705677,
-0.5376756191,
0.034913484,
0.6761651039,
-0.444290936,
0.6817322373,
-0.1244746223,
-0.8311046958,
0.045648247,
0.2453244328,
-0.4215538204,
0.9595167041,
0.1044329405,
-1.0348969698,
0.2361955941,
-0.5818434358,
-0.4838200808,
0.0528701767,
-0.1762978137,
-0.1079680547,
-0.3031944335,
0.1888459325,
0.454954952,
-0.2946908772,
0.6351314187,
-0.3017054796,
-0.4570479989,
0.2155478001,
-0.4837014973,
0.8817254901,
0.0054287137,
-0.0768583268,
0.1570281237,
-0.6932329535,
-0.2807687521,
-0.1225007996,
0.0002440189,
-0.0768413916,
0.014095746,
-0.0544237122,
0.4344484508,
0.0382415988,
-0.6141953468,
0.343260169,
-0.4011797607,
0.6378472447,
0.568680346,
0.5428025723,
0.1321302503,
0.0424933285,
0.5533702374,
0.0653761178,
0.0969902501,
-0.5625993609,
-0.5433220863,
-0.7203419209,
0.1512151062,
0.3371809125,
0.8685314655,
-0.8182941079,
0.2667948604,
-0.3492067158,
-0.397675544,
0.0349389277,
-0.6274066567,
0.6489568353,
0.7703014612,
0.1709870696,
-0.1005990803,
-0.2550137639,
-0.8236160278,
-0.3317659497,
-0.7453476191,
0.0267199781,
0.30837363,
0.3994735181,
0.3133245409,
0.8992776275,
-0.6112794876,
0.0630732402,
-0.0317004398,
0.6407875419,
0.1225772053,
0.2627848387,
0.5583390594,
-0.2552452385,
-0.5359529257,
-0.0083046509,
-0.6572771072,
-0.2522765696,
-0.0860783011,
0.002184534,
-0.038733054,
0.7449305654,
-0.6320059299,
0.2991344929,
0.4295712113,
-0.7767190337,
0.5860646963,
0.0290246587,
0.2742294073,
-0.9864937663,
0.0726885572,
0.086810492,
-0.1259753704,
-0.5510842204,
-0.311437875,
-0.1003803834,
-0.534240365,
-0.4444868863,
0.605735898,
-0.1925712973,
0.0029750902,
0.2124658376,
0.326725781,
-0.2706594765,
0.7510836124,
0.0000908924,
0.8171758652,
0.3160941601,
-0.2593918443,
0.1607812047,
0.4548870027,
-0.2889010906,
0.7872408032,
-0.8830941319,
0.1072808579,
-0.0772778243,
0.2823698819,
-1.2178351879,
-0.0947076902,
0.363147676,
-0.5910844803,
0.166684106,
-0.4924009144,
-0.661687851,
0.005251186,
0.1000469625,
0.4664898515,
0.3845528066,
-0.0964765325,
0.129511714,
0.1079376563,
-0.667290926,
-0.3623459339,
-0.1842596084,
0.1291314512,
-0.1144592017,
-0.6831100583,
0.0447723344,
0.1504133493,
-0.4260464907,
0.0819909647,
0.0189988874,
-0.1758976728,
-0.0981816947,
0.2715109289,
0.150338769,
-0.2019048631,
0.4739026129,
0.0708029121,
-0.3162956238,
0.1241540909,
0.1393244267,
0.4952767491,
-0.2379862666,
-0.3688959479,
-0.2248321325,
0.1668940634,
0.3608664274,
-0.2006587386,
0.8166029453,
0.5003591776,
-0.1554627866,
0.2956335843,
-0.4114947617,
0.1291944981,
-0.2984014153,
0.2892357111,
-0.4545615613,
-0.9930077791,
0.4831296206,
0.0652173758,
-0.102816619,
0.4237123132,
0.3022758067,
0.0142893279,
0.8107231259,
0.1596506983,
-0.1262689084,
0.4467678368,
0.2041868567,
0.4418253303,
-0.8971120715,
-0.2177278697,
-0.49362728,
0.2248026282,
-0.6166334152,
-0.057179451,
0.5108495355,
0.0561246723,
-0.7282876372,
0.4096824229,
0.0362215601,
0.2119542211,
0.287997216,
0.119855091,
0.5225688219,
-0.5347021818,
0.0333299227,
-0.1162548885,
-0.7288907766,
-0.5071502924,
0.4395415187,
0.2625724375,
0.4013063312,
0.0445361398,
0.1261411905,
0.0837406814,
0.079266645,
-0.7682272792,
0.6888154149,
0.1324945241,
-0.2677203715,
-0.2967036664,
-0.6644876599,
-1.1281131506,
0.2776021361,
0.0663022622,
-0.9938255548,
-0.1619607657,
-0.0194324981,
-0.2706586421,
-0.1517986059,
-0.9711875916,
1.0357834101,
0.0102503076,
-0.4237715602,
-0.0834118873,
-0.8691838384,
0.4311915934,
0.377685219,
-0.0402824469,
-0.3114476204,
0.1034392715,
0.6655344367,
-0.3063794672,
0.8390966058,
-0.001082657,
0.0301747769,
0.1149004251,
0.2858017683,
0.2987361848,
0.3378143013,
0.0899882987,
-0.0125142355,
0.2765668333,
-0.3409471512,
-0.8128374219,
0.6163113117,
-0.524477303,
-0.5522279739,
-0.6568754911,
-0.6640923023,
-0.479735136,
0.1695431471,
0.13985008,
0.6817007065,
-0.629899025,
0.0417184271,
0.3970859945,
-0.4178272188,
0.4850666523,
0.5727815032,
-0.2889505923,
-0.2024194449,
0.7045423388,
0.1577937603,
0.3111327589,
0.5854917765,
0.1108563021,
-0.1645704061,
-0.181615606,
-0.1986430734,
0.2204288542,
-0.3917260468,
-0.022076197,
-0.7761846185,
-0.5644198656,
-0.2932999134,
0.1443727016,
-0.0982029065,
-0.6833598614,
-0.0523486137,
-0.0771073774,
0.2514488101,
0.6601273417,
0.334348321,
0.3712871671,
-0.5616819263,
0.0682661682,
0.1506989896,
0.2394244671,
-0.0930271819,
-0.4388684332,
0.2298325151,
-0.3294453919,
-0.3235603571,
-0.9550380111,
0.1805027872,
0.0900635049,
0.3062616587,
0.214164108,
-0.0605336651,
0.6772794127,
-0.7622374296,
1.0304918289,
-0.0114974519,
-1.177585721,
0.6358776689,
-0.7737859488,
0.5259265304,
0.2264497429,
0.365827173,
-0.8415234089,
-0.5850977302,
-0.879917264,
-0.7950183153,
0.6911935806,
0.7776193023,
-0.090397805,
-0.2448601574,
0.226654917,
-0.2002594471,
0.2103569508,
-0.7631667256,
-0.1609852165,
0.0558196455,
-0.0311817508,
-0.0357492268,
-0.4300380647,
0.184368521,
-0.1019564867,
0.4651816785,
0.0693580508,
0.4753555954,
0.1061765328,
-0.1753532737,
0.3537404239,
0.5711460114,
0.4004853964,
0.7521198988,
-0.2298392653,
0.1689018011,
0.0562423393,
-0.1666984856,
0.0898701698,
0.4536629021,
-0.0847233832,
-0.145314157,
0.7786015272,
0.8113493323,
0.6624060869,
-0.385827601,
0.7116160989,
-0.2059411705,
0.2576467693,
-0.0854674578,
-0.2159050852,
0.0578898825,
0.2797507048,
-0.0434917435,
-0.1840229779,
0.3000450432,
-0.6727936864,
0.1562802941,
0.251712352,
-0.6126731038,
-0.3626084328,
0.5293465853,
0.1373250186,
-0.2457020283,
0.7404110432,
-0.3745106757,
-0.6544810534,
0.5310690403,
0.4519539177,
0.7145211697,
-0.2056159973,
0.3186478615,
0.574434936,
0.3583468497,
0.2209493965,
0.1104216203,
-0.0506861135,
-0.4904057086,
-0.7447347641,
-0.2214310616,
-0.521009624,
-0.0016759277,
-0.6659111381,
0.3098660409,
-0.186049059,
-0.0051895143,
-0.0563466214,
-0.0478207245,
-0.4995137453,
-0.1558225602,
-0.2772041261,
0.6114818454,
-0.7337989211,
0.5590079427,
0.3062905371,
-0.7673210502,
-0.7790164351,
0.1790953279,
-0.0543294065,
-0.5608030558,
0.9028810263,
0.0581241138,
0.1541928351,
0.062296737,
-0.2260010242,
-0.6184458733,
0.8536211848,
0.5875741839,
-0.5295131803,
-0.1071799397,
0.0489901491,
0.7563946843,
0.1567583829,
0.8185176253,
0.4460499287,
0.2845619023,
0.1109896898,
-1.3602895737,
0.1348008513,
-0.2164935321,
0.0339492597,
0.335650146,
-0.9617164731,
0.6851027012,
0.222390607,
-0.5228249431,
-0.0206451379,
0.6989735961,
0.0834003687,
0.2573649287,
0.2972366512,
0.3862947226,
0.4768336713,
-0.3675468564,
0.9827495217,
-0.3657930195,
0.3988945782,
1.4459915161,
-0.4013659656,
0.6283432245,
0.2988601327,
-0.3107730448,
0.3833330572,
0.6009502411,
0.2353833318,
0.3111665547,
0.2391024977,
-0.3132106066,
0.0181924887,
-0.240489766,
-0.4847351015,
0.2900733352,
0.3555310667,
-0.0991148055,
-0.4210218191,
-0.0250505395,
0.3057418168,
-0.1876862794,
-0.1441621482,
0.8609484434,
0.2080377638,
-0.816445291,
-0.0249967948,
-0.3497226834,
-0.0373222157,
-0.549281776,
-0.1565844119,
-0.1761680841,
-0.1055728048,
0.0411690697,
-1.1244388819,
0.2554522753,
-0.0550819337,
0.1266490519,
-0.1753469408,
0.7128831744,
-0.4582330883,
-0.3773759007,
0.1695464849,
0.5633296371,
0.0612523742,
0.0206485279,
-0.3512421846,
-0.0846699327,
-0.3466089368,
-0.2945996225,
0.1972066313,
0.8236467838,
-0.0179212838,
0.5795552135,
0.2704351246,
-0.067050457,
-0.0336189754,
0.2222889513,
0.7673538327,
-0.6720049977,
-0.3223847449,
-0.8806685209,
0.3442040086,
-0.1254709065,
-0.4280171096,
0.8729907274,
0.5686437488,
0.5685835481,
0.1127149314,
0.6197951436,
-0.1611232609,
0.3822703958,
-0.7693853378,
0.1624526381,
0.279420048,
0.1691894978,
-0.5780761242,
-0.9301526546,
-0.3878986239,
0.4274991155,
-0.7372532487,
-0.1391136944,
1.1260846853,
0.5537169576,
-0.1044299826,
0.1951464564,
0.2970455289,
0.4066874385,
0.4742564559,
0.8383510113,
1.3582098484,
-0.3606157601,
0.5610250235,
-0.1092225164,
-0.2831563056,
0.28748402,
-1.0013090372,
-1.0104409456,
-0.7348254323,
-0.3057919741,
-0.1849059761,
0.324118644,
0.7878648639,
0.3483121693,
-0.4238279164,
-0.2050104886,
-0.1193699986,
-0.0470497124,
-0.1183666363,
-0.3466425836,
0.5044645667,
-0.6067805886,
-0.6383380294,
0.2750941217,
0.5442559719,
-0.2216550261,
-0.1268259585,
0.3376822472,
-0.3067061901,
0.0089354105,
1.174677372,
0.0661164075,
-0.5058535933,
-0.5767763257,
-0.0566765666,
0.0404770225,
-0.0165935252,
1.1045029163,
-0.6181598306,
0.2394555509,
0.6812829375,
0.3626167774,
0.6462150812,
0.1201717481,
0.7975593209,
-0.8097628951,
0.2317999452,
0.2397827208,
0.5701804161,
0.0263076313,
-0.3654522002,
0.7346419692,
0.1359830648,
-0.8706146479,
-0.6190519333,
0.3392847776,
-1.3039479256,
-0.0907995626,
1.1767982244,
-0.4158402085,
0.2260883152,
-0.2911122143,
-0.5941298008,
0.3525720239,
-0.3969343305,
0.6235486865,
0.9094341993,
-0.5124236941,
-0.2044422626,
-0.6542324424,
0.2185224891,
0.3254923224,
-0.9089187384,
0.0121747795,
0.6210103035,
-0.0471139438,
-0.0078685852,
0.6974821091,
-0.1786360741,
-0.0247797314,
-0.0873029456,
-0.3804980814,
0.1462550014,
-0.1378946602,
-0.0932464898,
0.2821278274,
0.0135377878,
0.0500548966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14803v1 | SemEval-2023 Task 11: Learning With Disagreements (LeWiDi) | 2023-04-28T12:20:35 | 2023-04-28T12:20:35 | Elisa Leonardelli, Alexandra Uma, Gavin Abercrombie, Dina Almanea, Valerio Basile, Tommaso Fornaciari, Barbara Plank, Verena Rieser, Massimo Poesio | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP datasets annotated with human judgments are rife with disagreements
between the judges. This is especially true for tasks depending on subjective
judgments such as sentiment analysis or offensive language detection.
Particularly in these latter cases, the NLP community has come to realize that
the approach of 'reconciling' these different subjective interpretations is
inappropriate. Many NLP researchers have therefore concluded that rather than
eliminating disagreements from annotated corpora, we should preserve
them-indeed, some argue that corpora should aim to preserve all annotator
judgments. But this approach to corpus creation for NLP has not yet been widely
accepted. The objective of the LeWiDi series of shared tasks is to promote this
approach to developing NLP models by providing a unified framework for training
and evaluating with such datasets. We report on the second LeWiDi shared task,
which differs from the first edition in three crucial respects: (i) it focuses
entirely on NLP, instead of both NLP and computer vision tasks in its first
edition; (ii) it focuses on subjective tasks, instead of covering different
types of disagreements-as training with aggregated labels for subjective NLP
tasks is a particularly obvious misrepresentation of the data; and (iii) for
the evaluation, we concentrate on soft approaches to evaluation. This second
edition of LeWiDi attracted a wide array of participants resulting in 13 shared
task submission papers. | [
-0.7142495513,
-0.1043971479,
0.2975988686,
0.3333940208,
-0.2083827704,
-0.2343340516,
-0.1842555553,
-0.7264750004,
0.1922684014,
0.3465984762,
-0.352219224,
-0.5130061507,
-0.9818866849,
0.2018980682,
-0.0649615377,
1.3608398438,
-0.1438200474,
0.0366808474,
-0.364782244,
-0.489796102,
-0.4844795763,
-0.5175442696,
-0.7951481342,
-0.4138272107,
0.8095443249,
0.4016441107,
0.4909960926,
0.1406834573,
0.521967113,
0.3153534234,
-0.04842012,
0.165648967,
-0.2637977302,
0.2535318732,
-0.542545855,
-0.1319197565,
-0.3999750614,
0.0118975956,
0.1437807977,
0.9194242954,
-0.0181799605,
0.1643945724,
0.0932775363,
0.9519392848,
-0.6650344133,
0.1172145531,
-0.5559375882,
0.2866097093,
-0.0820926726,
0.0733989775,
-0.2129558027,
-0.0233595893,
0.2597702444,
-0.2975035012,
0.1972959042,
-0.2638806403,
0.7963811159,
0.4936446249,
-0.5334771872,
-0.4645848572,
-0.3615459502,
0.8856807351,
-0.5678012967,
0.1257702261,
0.5337080956,
-0.0013882009,
0.2159284651,
-0.6930480599,
-0.2036430985,
0.3021664619,
0.1790994853,
0.3500890732,
-0.3047432303,
-0.3063026071,
0.2925851047,
-0.0348867513,
-0.0961688757,
0.1083527207,
-0.6752058864,
-0.1531265527,
0.9203478098,
-0.0838786885,
0.0078832591,
-0.469748795,
-0.3099254966,
0.0636501461,
-0.3723191917,
-0.0395953767,
0.6611400843,
0.0983775929,
0.0522953197,
0.4099101722,
-0.1419444829,
0.2224197835,
-0.0276039988,
0.380195111,
0.5022044182,
-0.1422750801,
-0.0765136406,
0.0548018776,
0.6881057024,
0.7400597334,
0.1201488152,
-0.1714829206,
-0.2858992815,
0.4269034266,
0.5925455093,
-0.4038443267,
-0.2069516033,
0.2904527783,
-0.5557153225,
-0.5560304523,
-0.1154913455,
-0.9685181975,
-0.4229788482,
-0.7613844872,
0.4978571534,
-0.2367905825,
-0.0867607892,
0.1905718148,
0.0226629451,
0.236887902,
0.52865237,
-0.9932023883,
0.5119790435,
1.0053735971,
0.4591190815,
-0.4895982444,
-0.390877068,
-0.4290645719,
-0.1331746131,
-0.2038493901,
0.8188422918,
-0.5556313992,
-0.3260170221,
-0.0045811497,
0.0561530143,
-0.0115449717,
-0.567261219,
0.9122991562,
-0.3436533511,
0.2251270562,
-0.5845258832,
-0.4463587403,
-0.3719634116,
0.2099835724,
-0.5365542173,
1.128593564,
-0.0365916751,
-1.0005937815,
0.4792148471,
-0.5105736256,
-0.3738973141,
-0.1235503629,
-0.4031736553,
-0.4460018277,
0.0328982361,
0.0705645829,
0.3294615448,
-0.1195479855,
0.5741376281,
-0.2422243357,
-0.2698707879,
-0.1202678829,
-0.167673856,
0.7842723131,
0.2403964102,
-0.4784552455,
0.1436689943,
-0.5954955816,
-0.0618634559,
-0.1372259855,
-0.1263934821,
-0.4453372955,
0.0812733397,
0.0429317206,
0.1411456913,
0.323141396,
-0.6048001647,
0.0149064064,
-0.4252410829,
0.3037145138,
1.0440765619,
-0.00542058,
0.3961536288,
-0.503983736,
0.2756901681,
0.0598588772,
0.1586028188,
0.3222816885,
-0.5801340342,
-1.0090023279,
0.2717084587,
0.3987964988,
0.4309172928,
-0.5176877379,
0.2117311656,
-0.0373986028,
-0.6249987483,
-0.2971636653,
-0.0320036635,
0.4556602836,
0.1600475907,
0.3592470288,
-0.6378419399,
-0.8179267645,
-0.9558441043,
-0.1746983081,
-0.1148379222,
0.4240787327,
0.3465122581,
0.9046558142,
-0.3892466724,
0.5980195403,
-0.201990068,
-0.2717579603,
-0.0840875581,
0.4655290842,
0.171208486,
0.7495056987,
0.5833317041,
-0.6537433863,
-0.4332344234,
-0.0549957901,
-0.7019494772,
-0.2983315289,
0.1615731269,
-0.4208703041,
0.4792480469,
0.3943119049,
0.0593322143,
0.3920976818,
0.6113359928,
-0.3941898346,
0.4272257388,
-0.0009695718,
0.2232965678,
-1.0551637411,
-0.1725756377,
-0.1474562734,
-0.3499708772,
-0.5140023828,
-0.1420371681,
-0.3918694556,
-0.0173913836,
-0.485227108,
0.3550253212,
-0.0282939281,
-0.228263706,
-0.2337563336,
-0.0121436138,
-0.0884765759,
0.715475738,
0.1631849706,
0.4959546924,
0.5462564826,
-0.4951753914,
0.1386904716,
0.4430907369,
-0.0852451548,
0.7526108027,
-0.8539754152,
0.4813097417,
-0.1994698942,
-0.2896314561,
-0.6605219245,
-0.1877729595,
0.5677723885,
-0.4377666712,
0.2538971007,
-0.1341678351,
-0.0324595571,
-0.0501737222,
-0.5238388777,
0.4563993216,
0.1716031432,
-0.5346029997,
0.4877419472,
0.7409074903,
-0.2441570163,
-0.9146906137,
-0.6144180894,
0.0711598396,
-0.2380753011,
-0.5100187659,
0.3656071424,
0.1586836576,
-0.3515702486,
0.2580823302,
-0.2957208753,
-0.1957809776,
-0.0404199064,
0.5825266242,
0.1652293801,
0.1898781806,
-0.0725598037,
0.0525732785,
-0.3194025755,
0.2136791497,
-0.0349203199,
0.401063174,
-0.5103347898,
-0.53482306,
-0.2526459396,
0.5734990835,
-0.0662899837,
-0.0935215577,
0.5286223292,
0.7132762074,
-0.4265502393,
-0.087139301,
-0.6225354075,
0.2494321615,
-0.3918458521,
0.2828734815,
-0.4871425927,
-1.0303875208,
0.1700239927,
-0.2485810369,
0.2319235355,
0.5876489878,
0.5292265415,
-0.4123901427,
0.584862113,
0.5816722512,
-0.0622994266,
0.1540832967,
-0.2479455769,
0.0022487862,
-0.9068017602,
-0.4505010545,
-0.6258645058,
-0.6213633418,
-0.5522111058,
-0.4350687861,
0.0967473239,
0.0896323025,
-0.2533508241,
0.4798211157,
-0.5122819543,
0.3592067361,
0.807920754,
0.279029429,
0.0548344553,
0.1475047916,
0.1737863421,
-0.4456552565,
-0.3178145885,
-0.6037831306,
1.1842253208,
0.1540935785,
0.3292018473,
0.1986907125,
1.200981617,
0.4863528907,
-0.0856902227,
-0.720703423,
0.6157291532,
-0.3158233762,
-0.2395019233,
-0.1400098652,
-0.3108009696,
-1.0149850845,
0.3356005847,
0.0131673552,
-0.6292285919,
0.6455270052,
-0.2550325096,
-0.0967272744,
0.1190923825,
-0.4864114821,
1.1862556934,
-0.0269910544,
-0.4809169173,
-0.3753979504,
-0.6844513416,
0.2494740784,
-0.0323898718,
0.1288060248,
-0.357680589,
-0.1499917805,
1.1904624701,
-0.3827218115,
0.9255979657,
-0.3562081456,
-0.0543911718,
0.4040267766,
0.0186976194,
0.2070817947,
0.2637764215,
-0.2489583343,
0.1782268882,
0.3458990157,
-0.3423087597,
-0.3893809915,
0.4564920366,
-0.9188197255,
-0.4820822477,
-0.8891811967,
-0.2699199915,
-0.201707378,
0.0298317689,
0.0349575207,
0.6154517531,
-0.1763048619,
0.2457879633,
0.4917083681,
-0.2298646122,
0.3948643208,
0.1730448753,
-0.04717049,
-0.3892400265,
0.8107848763,
-0.1587955952,
-0.0967091322,
-0.0633755252,
-0.070395425,
-0.10617356,
-0.437799722,
-0.0680993795,
0.1476385146,
-0.8069259524,
-0.1897012144,
-0.5963981152,
-0.0216477681,
-0.393702209,
-0.2811563611,
-0.3772196472,
-0.5472760797,
-0.1869699061,
0.1354400665,
0.1257766336,
0.7956350446,
-0.6180135012,
-0.2152722031,
-0.6787918806,
0.2677309215,
0.4082865417,
-0.0234861542,
-0.3074479699,
-0.6715058684,
-0.0190068204,
-0.2225171775,
-0.2459218651,
-0.8412041068,
0.3259347975,
0.1009552926,
0.2641134262,
0.0824665576,
0.136678949,
0.5717272162,
-0.5522773862,
0.6772655249,
0.1675087661,
-1.0455771685,
0.8562816381,
-0.2468020022,
-0.048313152,
1.0721102953,
0.5789381862,
-0.6953559518,
-0.1575719863,
-0.6867203116,
-0.756044507,
0.9043530822,
0.1478123069,
0.2180144489,
-0.1237511039,
0.3335202932,
0.2470183223,
0.3845242262,
-0.7635624409,
-0.1529543847,
-0.0713478997,
-0.2242384851,
0.3075277209,
-0.5882923007,
-0.4121664762,
-0.4033386409,
0.8373359442,
0.0414741486,
0.2957454324,
0.3023287058,
-0.0143433847,
0.2178257853,
0.4151912332,
0.222786203,
0.6757317185,
-0.0207378976,
0.3636868596,
0.2464991212,
-0.3102508187,
0.0350171737,
-0.0104108872,
-0.3465988636,
0.0786614344,
0.2496204972,
0.9731606841,
0.2538630962,
-0.619061172,
0.8593131304,
0.0029192523,
-0.4856090546,
-0.4263997972,
-0.1279973984,
-0.1036090627,
0.5325603485,
-0.371632874,
0.8715599775,
0.3666334152,
-0.5850820541,
0.499315232,
0.0811717808,
-0.619224906,
-0.3413443565,
0.5641699433,
0.120863162,
-0.0248480085,
0.2825782597,
-0.7834497094,
-0.7878215909,
0.4611352682,
0.2538131773,
0.7046888471,
0.0231940057,
0.5930324793,
0.519970715,
0.1969859153,
-0.106103152,
0.6419349313,
-0.1108498499,
-0.9729084969,
-0.3779408932,
-0.6311333179,
-0.4937430918,
-0.2174712867,
-0.9370182753,
0.4141357541,
-0.308796674,
-0.1366535276,
-0.147245422,
0.1691635847,
-0.5980602503,
0.1439976543,
0.1329916716,
0.4058510661,
-0.7488592863,
0.5889379382,
0.7787228823,
-0.4775286019,
-0.6666445732,
-0.2511794865,
0.0252431929,
-0.5951471329,
0.7886152267,
0.1146686375,
0.0576875955,
-0.2226428092,
-0.4919481575,
-0.4279817641,
0.7378385663,
0.1664291769,
-0.4254398942,
0.0336793698,
0.0050477586,
0.4015184343,
0.0342032574,
-0.0718590468,
0.4917874932,
0.4201006591,
0.0526513234,
-0.6405104995,
-0.1460808218,
-0.4189195931,
-0.0966362506,
0.0809617862,
-0.5600100756,
0.6646179557,
-0.0268025361,
-0.1453206092,
-0.0039892364,
0.7983472943,
0.0720214993,
0.470772028,
0.678191781,
0.9176247716,
0.8116466999,
-0.2964279056,
0.7053551078,
0.0207917467,
0.3874032795,
1.5402189493,
-0.4283859432,
0.9581648707,
0.5023796558,
-0.4194876552,
0.2479500622,
0.6440229416,
-0.3326884508,
0.5417309403,
0.1491202116,
-0.3922269642,
-0.145030871,
-0.4393883049,
-0.4009745121,
0.6255805492,
0.1241020411,
0.0232607946,
-0.122430183,
0.0852488428,
0.0913579538,
0.313282609,
-0.3071067929,
0.8127831221,
0.0445804186,
-0.7460782528,
0.0573113412,
0.2023388147,
0.7404204607,
-0.1568549275,
0.15408957,
-0.048685912,
0.0314868875,
-0.4119459689,
-0.7703977823,
0.9601104856,
0.2006575018,
0.04237324,
-0.3238372803,
0.8839812875,
-0.3320857584,
-0.3755357563,
0.3024545014,
0.5489859581,
0.5030652881,
0.0286521539,
-0.7679145336,
0.2817415297,
0.2036921382,
0.0295590349,
0.137798056,
0.5159754157,
0.1567422301,
0.0135820638,
0.15381293,
0.0643860623,
-0.0237030294,
0.6234677434,
0.7617425323,
-0.3881779313,
0.0202905815,
-0.5921933055,
0.212533161,
-0.1593453437,
-0.3980976343,
0.5529304147,
0.5365851521,
0.9800146222,
-0.0930858478,
0.6163852811,
-0.3337477148,
0.488858968,
-0.5136572123,
0.3031691611,
-0.5683495998,
-0.0463521071,
-0.4388913214,
-0.9922101498,
-0.2713574469,
0.8779945374,
-0.3750754893,
-0.1013413891,
0.8913753033,
0.4314814806,
0.2194665372,
0.4348454773,
0.0886597186,
-0.1509862691,
0.0181980859,
0.9022135735,
0.965942204,
-0.8304738402,
0.3201223016,
-0.5712752938,
0.090458557,
0.209964782,
-0.7562071681,
-0.9173847437,
-0.726798594,
-0.6092869043,
-0.2250102758,
0.2112084627,
1.0893716812,
0.3346215487,
-1.1056495905,
-0.1831432432,
-0.2610943913,
-0.1238049641,
-0.0574513562,
-0.1526274085,
0.4103564918,
-0.564984858,
-1.118052125,
0.1691011935,
0.1825547069,
-0.324991405,
0.0369185843,
-0.1274064928,
-0.2885578573,
-0.2662205994,
0.531648159,
0.1248424873,
-0.5202370286,
-0.6341372132,
-0.3600336611,
0.0239387583,
0.070310697,
0.6596848369,
-0.6420571208,
0.2798182368,
0.4948508143,
1.0006155968,
0.5794103742,
-0.0808400661,
0.3932496905,
-0.5691720247,
0.2346515208,
0.3768646419,
0.5241464972,
0.2257918864,
0.0187651496,
1.1785316467,
0.4543275237,
-0.7736008167,
-0.7558140159,
0.2576903403,
-1.0919743776,
-0.1414299011,
0.9552522302,
-0.2077372968,
-0.0428050794,
-0.1687460691,
-0.4209209085,
0.3117974401,
-0.2846007347,
0.6790040731,
0.9154621363,
-0.191153273,
0.1474547684,
-0.6752047539,
0.548858285,
0.8824798465,
-0.9397110939,
-0.3413208723,
0.5442820191,
-0.0762245208,
0.2948034406,
0.7173376083,
-0.2211552113,
0.2196909934,
-0.0008353682,
-0.0284235626,
0.1409217268,
-0.5499072075,
-0.3518941998,
0.1942437589,
-0.0793047547,
-0.0775132254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14802v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14802v1 | ResiDual: Transformer with Dual Residual Connections | 2023-04-28T12:19:47 | 2023-04-28T12:19:47 | Shufang Xie, Huishuai Zhang, Junliang Guo, Xu Tan, Jiang Bian, Hany Hassan Awadalla, Arul Menezes, Tao Qin, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Transformer networks have become the preferred architecture for many tasks
due to their state-of-the-art performance. However, the optimal way to
implement residual connections in Transformer, which are essential for
effective training, is still debated. Two widely used variants are the
Post-Layer-Normalization (Post-LN) and Pre-Layer-Normalization (Pre-LN)
Transformers, which apply layer normalization after each residual block's
output or before each residual block's input, respectively. While both variants
enjoy their advantages, they also suffer from severe limitations: Post-LN
causes gradient vanishing issue that hinders training deep Transformers, and
Pre-LN causes representation collapse issue that limits model capacity. In this
paper, we propose ResiDual, a novel Transformer architecture with Pre-Post-LN
(PPLN), which fuses the connections in Post-LN and Pre-LN together and inherits
their advantages while avoids their limitations. We conduct both theoretical
analyses and empirical experiments to verify the effectiveness of ResiDual.
Theoretically, we prove that ResiDual has a lower bound on the gradient to
avoid the vanishing issue due to the residual connection from Pre-LN. Moreover,
ResiDual also has diverse model representations to avoid the collapse issue due
to the residual connection from Post-LN. Empirically, ResiDual outperforms both
Post-LN and Pre-LN on several machine translation benchmarks across different
network depths and data sizes. Thanks to the good theoretical and empirical
performance, ResiDual Transformer can serve as a foundation architecture for
different AI models (e.g., large language models). Our code is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/ResiDual. | [
-0.6264587045,
-0.3944539428,
0.1158538833,
-0.0676748306,
-0.2827104032,
0.1330549717,
-0.2740490735,
-0.1540800035,
0.111385189,
0.6558225155,
-0.5220127702,
-0.0546484441,
-0.5598905087,
-0.0429686718,
-0.4512266517,
1.0838327408,
-0.0869988054,
-0.0373157933,
-0.2977897227,
-0.3777514398,
-0.6662546396,
-0.5266909599,
-0.8268306851,
-0.7101490498,
0.75010252,
0.1684769243,
0.8769643307,
0.4806303978,
0.459403038,
0.3536128402,
0.2246962488,
-0.1225730479,
-0.7720727921,
-0.0984567851,
-0.0266412981,
-0.3886219263,
-0.4673034251,
-0.3023146391,
0.8475527167,
0.729830265,
0.0549729019,
0.2709856629,
0.2002861798,
0.861092031,
-0.4695889056,
-0.2231024057,
-0.3664767444,
-0.045291964,
0.0355617702,
0.0203367304,
-0.3246685565,
-0.2238399684,
0.0629344806,
-0.0776615962,
0.3211018443,
-0.2854211032,
1.349178195,
0.458337605,
-0.4929583371,
0.4074142873,
-1.3177828789,
0.501083076,
-0.5492616296,
0.5298118591,
0.1103414893,
0.8667252064,
0.4660804868,
-1.1722664833,
-0.3598274589,
-0.29388538,
-0.3704907596,
0.3945346475,
-0.4238995612,
-0.0837394148,
0.1377024055,
0.6896816492,
-0.454905808,
0.4351724982,
-0.5685971975,
-0.1644944251,
0.1917885691,
-0.0449592769,
0.2141788304,
0.243947193,
-0.6737865806,
0.0444189608,
-1.0090376139,
0.2051615566,
0.5417984724,
-0.0819953457,
-0.1179587245,
0.3296466172,
-0.0032672696,
0.5973414779,
-0.0509575717,
0.1882630736,
0.1460351497,
-0.1467977166,
-0.066679731,
-0.2432368994,
0.6894767284,
0.2526095212,
-0.0374155343,
-0.3701661825,
-0.3885717392,
0.1081933826,
0.4763057828,
-0.8216761947,
-0.3917752206,
0.1100985631,
-0.6798422337,
-0.2254438698,
0.0559582785,
-0.3877932131,
-0.0780205727,
-0.6295551658,
0.6176208854,
-0.4744256735,
-0.5508943796,
0.0539962538,
0.0853069574,
0.3226072788,
0.1242069975,
-0.3875752091,
0.4574122429,
0.4950881898,
0.565787673,
0.0129309827,
-0.2509362996,
-0.3052869141,
-0.1158599406,
-0.0925601348,
0.5861768126,
-0.2060907334,
-0.0636242852,
0.0017159085,
0.1314218193,
0.0748904869,
-0.5697574615,
0.7232083082,
-0.7239509225,
0.4286057353,
-0.0762160718,
-0.2460914105,
-0.429877907,
0.1169384271,
-0.9442051053,
0.8673343658,
0.2363335192,
-0.6319813132,
0.0403858572,
-0.4028013349,
-0.3331602216,
0.1296097636,
-0.0734512806,
-0.6417162418,
0.0983770862,
-0.1209641472,
0.1947360635,
-0.4963357747,
0.5518808365,
-0.0620908514,
-0.6081469655,
0.1071996018,
-0.8057276607,
0.6019366384,
0.0390695445,
-0.4095807374,
0.4343310893,
-0.885479033,
-0.5598587394,
0.083287634,
-0.0137632219,
-0.0737258494,
-0.0466292985,
-0.1671866626,
0.3369277418,
0.1447042227,
-0.4992212355,
0.0205559507,
-0.4620834887,
0.5203710198,
0.7087426782,
-0.3547069728,
0.6753407717,
-0.43952021,
0.626837492,
-0.1266418248,
0.1091245785,
-0.2394053787,
-0.0590758212,
-1.1178553104,
-0.2616805732,
0.4524328709,
0.6099802256,
-0.9182019234,
0.7764725089,
-0.5617005229,
-0.5741522908,
-0.3810119629,
-0.2667480409,
0.3463190198,
0.8144954443,
0.5956242681,
0.1586528867,
-0.6187122464,
-1.1462811232,
-0.1266934723,
0.2455375195,
-0.4072518945,
0.2983066142,
0.3137576878,
-0.3371362388,
1.0013455153,
-0.4174466431,
-0.3947578371,
-0.4437436163,
-0.1606850922,
0.5062429905,
0.4467494488,
0.5235424638,
-0.835383594,
-0.4699136913,
0.1553845704,
-0.5380257368,
0.1779222041,
-0.4179487824,
-0.0857384428,
-0.081263043,
0.3525746465,
-0.4605197012,
0.60846138,
0.5798491836,
0.052986335,
0.5865550637,
-0.3112820685,
-0.116022177,
-1.0375609398,
0.5012125969,
-0.2877699733,
-0.3742995262,
-0.6995478272,
-0.2431362271,
0.0388256125,
-0.573787272,
-0.3611077368,
0.3511909842,
-0.4382617176,
0.115313217,
-0.4398894608,
-0.1503537148,
0.203070879,
0.5155326724,
-0.1222072616,
0.5763440728,
0.5503165722,
-0.4405512512,
0.5142111182,
-0.1034638435,
0.2305947244,
0.051503621,
-0.9925830364,
0.0329487175,
-0.340864718,
0.5738918781,
-1.1208795309,
0.1711229682,
0.1718792915,
-0.3370401263,
0.4316226542,
-0.0066453377,
0.004609752,
-0.7336703539,
-0.3672952056,
0.5937585235,
0.8882998824,
-0.5377552509,
1.0354839563,
-0.1036784798,
0.2063186765,
-0.8304531574,
-0.5916265845,
0.2290955037,
-0.3458771706,
-0.7632629871,
0.5300135612,
0.1866157055,
0.3163481355,
0.2652443051,
-0.1958086491,
-0.0882152766,
-0.0026125934,
0.3481374681,
0.3470205963,
-0.6339520812,
-0.0450043641,
0.1491398364,
-0.7034284472,
-0.1472969353,
-0.3638066053,
0.8112956285,
-0.355545789,
-0.2738821805,
-0.6021915674,
0.3430535495,
0.7281019092,
-0.4900121689,
1.1286805868,
0.8695260286,
-0.350817591,
-0.0299354382,
-0.8959568143,
-0.2469466031,
-0.5349107385,
0.3746567369,
-0.4780651331,
-0.8707770109,
0.6478533149,
-0.3620894551,
-0.0293478128,
0.6598032713,
0.1985315681,
-0.2995638847,
0.3914088905,
0.7172586322,
-0.1428125948,
0.3602506518,
-0.4847089946,
0.516397059,
-0.7749970555,
-0.0707842484,
-0.3948456049,
-0.595227778,
-0.2658373117,
-0.0268654786,
0.1792717725,
0.5140987635,
-0.3580532968,
0.6737538576,
-0.3488355279,
0.3425696194,
0.5568380356,
0.2446716577,
0.0365817472,
-0.003070974,
0.1468651444,
0.1197884753,
-0.7185087204,
-0.5216715336,
0.6139445305,
0.5807971954,
0.3214144409,
0.094988659,
0.6208043098,
0.0440939851,
0.5457009077,
-0.7579020262,
0.3792974651,
-0.3765005469,
-0.2011753172,
-0.259981066,
-0.4729799926,
-0.9712051749,
0.2659095824,
-0.2007187158,
-0.4295975566,
0.1206017584,
0.4473210573,
-0.1985882074,
0.7077180147,
-0.6482474804,
0.9704117775,
-0.1989176571,
-0.2764640749,
-0.1157941818,
-1.1164913177,
0.2444553673,
-0.0621824674,
-0.2231758833,
0.2834385633,
0.1374823749,
0.4512751698,
-0.5777637362,
0.6970059872,
-0.1288197637,
0.0238921344,
0.3487057388,
-0.0419872217,
0.5410606265,
0.021294605,
0.1331616491,
0.4379954338,
-0.3443375528,
-0.3113614619,
-0.6332045197,
0.3874762058,
-0.8435678482,
-0.5253455639,
-0.0124352062,
-0.2195182592,
-0.0474232212,
0.6306972504,
0.5776947141,
0.7625890374,
-0.0791212022,
0.671734035,
0.404546231,
-0.4096152186,
0.6587379575,
0.2632766068,
-0.0279432684,
-0.4945515394,
1.1117509604,
0.0114854928,
0.2740320265,
0.5675911903,
0.3038203716,
-0.3907827735,
-0.5649353266,
-0.3275873661,
0.4086555243,
-0.4233534336,
-0.4022090137,
-0.4080847204,
-0.672324121,
-0.1275320202,
-0.1741730422,
-0.7730793357,
-0.2089514285,
-0.209147498,
-0.1312287003,
-0.2362398505,
0.3612126112,
0.110522151,
0.4145930409,
-1.1060335636,
0.5815892816,
0.2051222473,
0.6000081301,
0.1302734017,
-0.5057179332,
-0.1794022173,
0.0637977645,
-0.1892733574,
-0.4480417073,
0.0799223185,
0.119347021,
0.5000562668,
0.6868439317,
0.0956297666,
0.4870776236,
-0.8257415891,
0.6399611235,
0.4840402901,
-0.7314273119,
0.0709894672,
-0.386549741,
0.2069029063,
0.5380532146,
0.4548605978,
-0.4454183877,
-0.1601360142,
-0.4576931596,
-0.9371919632,
0.4158086777,
0.438839376,
0.182123825,
0.4844292402,
0.2693150342,
0.3033956885,
0.0618257336,
-0.7673276663,
-0.7322012782,
-0.5820449591,
0.0902438164,
-0.1883019954,
-0.4901316464,
-0.1314027905,
-0.2347379625,
0.4478135705,
0.2934750915,
0.1976626515,
-0.1229383349,
-0.135196954,
0.3398400545,
-0.0552043431,
0.5348839164,
0.7968352437,
-0.1154086515,
0.2394514233,
0.0868399888,
-0.3793781996,
0.3024434447,
0.1598464996,
-0.1966077685,
-0.081842564,
0.5378430486,
0.9725958705,
-0.0989454463,
-0.1114328355,
0.4647137821,
-0.2735192776,
-0.1680506915,
-0.4558081627,
-0.3831860125,
0.2553572059,
0.0541734919,
0.4860392809,
0.7617809772,
-0.0735349655,
-0.0106284516,
0.5526624918,
0.0483337268,
-0.4841901958,
-0.5299369693,
0.579235971,
0.4314610064,
-0.5083343387,
0.6277013421,
0.2961212695,
-0.5656033754,
0.5598291755,
0.5998548865,
0.9217303395,
-0.2438353151,
0.122099936,
0.2904550433,
0.3224792182,
0.1447569579,
-0.3754321635,
-0.1395517588,
-0.7174305916,
-0.6865964532,
-0.427390337,
0.1762022972,
0.189129144,
-0.8106453419,
0.4292807877,
-0.0924846008,
-0.1202145442,
-0.6228384376,
-0.5268132091,
-0.6932789683,
0.2514534593,
0.2167028636,
0.644749999,
-0.8108542562,
0.7974017262,
0.4390088916,
-0.4462518394,
-0.8582063913,
-0.096565716,
-0.4128136635,
-0.4820328951,
0.5652168989,
0.3083257973,
-0.4174153507,
0.0671472996,
0.1148501411,
-0.9033458233,
1.0714763403,
0.5922756195,
-0.4696429968,
-0.038197618,
0.2522340715,
0.4575713873,
0.0656333342,
0.3833701611,
0.2257131487,
0.3153760135,
0.1768879294,
-0.6448790431,
0.1107138544,
-0.2222923934,
0.1544001997,
0.340200603,
-0.7028310299,
0.7537510395,
0.3144494593,
-0.387072295,
0.0440781079,
0.8621800542,
-0.2507750988,
-0.0589494295,
0.6296308637,
0.6249569058,
0.279548049,
-0.2090331465,
1.0007059574,
-0.3490127921,
0.5354164839,
1.197693944,
-0.0272500385,
0.5097552538,
0.276620537,
-0.2619970143,
0.4501765668,
0.4155148566,
-0.0405428298,
0.3301180899,
0.1999895126,
-0.1824129373,
-0.0348583236,
-0.1132963821,
-0.88873595,
0.2725031376,
-0.0321828723,
-0.1799583286,
-0.3807566464,
0.0548570305,
-0.0317799225,
-0.062637344,
-0.0448797233,
0.4364597797,
0.0099903839,
-0.3725825548,
0.7303019762,
-0.0541713685,
0.5475718975,
-0.7047075629,
-0.0704270974,
-0.5883140564,
0.2696177363,
-0.3435028195,
-0.3380637765,
0.5547887683,
-0.5232824087,
-0.1469935924,
-0.4001350105,
0.9974175096,
-0.4405914545,
-0.4923870265,
0.4303031266,
0.2570204139,
-0.183415696,
-0.0828822553,
-0.3827650547,
0.0413433835,
-0.0639578551,
-0.3104549944,
0.2073744237,
0.3124369085,
0.2525663972,
0.6963672042,
0.5204677582,
0.0600458644,
0.0768599212,
0.3332460821,
1.1726022959,
-0.3378827572,
-0.2822479606,
-0.827231586,
1.0927388668,
-0.0463207066,
-0.0467670783,
0.7356395721,
0.7129735351,
0.5866114497,
-0.2332289368,
0.383454144,
0.2771027982,
0.2089871019,
-0.2613607347,
0.7610936761,
-0.5592697859,
0.3079690635,
-0.1012967676,
-1.1536487341,
-0.549890101,
0.2820935249,
-0.1394034326,
0.0464007072,
0.8341475725,
0.6053054929,
-0.4240836501,
-0.208989948,
0.4661588073,
0.0314328894,
0.5914739966,
0.5032677054,
0.9481819868,
-0.5929095149,
0.7102159858,
-0.2789147198,
-0.378628701,
-0.0392865352,
-0.6964938045,
-0.764072597,
-0.4426663816,
-0.2095104605,
-0.360226512,
-0.4257277846,
0.1493518651,
0.6278387308,
-0.6143919826,
-0.1450240761,
-0.2624462545,
0.0823117495,
-0.1809376329,
-0.2188169062,
0.6545728445,
-0.1630824804,
-0.2958823144,
0.2801886201,
0.3553901315,
-0.1122206077,
-0.1782270521,
-0.0650042146,
-0.0497836471,
-0.3860629201,
0.577521503,
0.3203118443,
-0.6668703556,
-0.4595815539,
-0.1764040291,
0.180836603,
0.1670894772,
1.0794892311,
-0.8955142498,
0.2027768046,
0.4970580637,
1.1395893097,
0.6614346504,
0.2641790211,
0.8217693567,
-0.5922906399,
0.3566634357,
0.5199018121,
0.4818891883,
0.0530055799,
-0.302485615,
0.2481536418,
0.1951520741,
-0.3610214591,
-0.7269596457,
0.4646800756,
-0.7047216296,
-0.2199607939,
0.7973889709,
-0.2841313779,
0.0544672906,
-0.0088217957,
-0.3111492693,
0.5244839787,
0.0524151102,
0.3147937953,
0.3098803461,
-0.0670260191,
-0.2818062007,
-0.212425977,
0.137667343,
0.6176548004,
-0.3921380937,
-0.2223578542,
0.2618463933,
0.1368995011,
0.2536264956,
0.3141360581,
-0.0923894942,
-0.0833365917,
-0.0194706023,
-0.0069348514,
-0.5077516437,
-0.708548367,
-0.5101299286,
0.3730471432,
-0.2621925473,
-0.5118900537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14796v1 | Are the Best Multilingual Document Embeddings simply Based on Sentence Embeddings? | 2023-04-28T12:11:21 | 2023-04-28T12:11:21 | Sonal Sannigrahi, Josef van Genabith, Cristina Espana-Bonet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Dense vector representations for textual data are crucial in modern NLP. Word
embeddings and sentence embeddings estimated from raw texts are key in
achieving state-of-the-art results in various tasks requiring semantic
understanding. However, obtaining embeddings at the document level is
challenging due to computational requirements and lack of appropriate data.
Instead, most approaches fall back on computing document embeddings based on
sentence representations. Although there exist architectures and models to
encode documents fully, they are in general limited to English and few other
high-resourced languages. In this work, we provide a systematic comparison of
methods to produce document-level representations from sentences based on
LASER, LaBSE, and Sentence BERT pre-trained multilingual models. We compare
input token number truncation, sentence averaging as well as some simple
windowing and in some cases new augmented and learnable approaches, on 3 multi-
and cross-lingual tasks in 8 languages belonging to 3 different language
families. Our task-based extrinsic evaluations show that, independently of the
language, a clever combination of sentence embeddings is usually better than
encoding the full document as a single unit, even when this is possible. We
demonstrate that while a simple sentence average results in a strong baseline
for classification tasks, more complex combinations are necessary for semantic
tasks. | [
-0.3105804026,
-0.6394342184,
0.510392487,
0.3372344971,
-0.0883063525,
0.0067262296,
-0.4655395746,
-0.3995612264,
0.1776412427,
0.1925819516,
-0.178291887,
-0.4649484158,
-0.6566289067,
0.1638555378,
-0.2607281208,
0.6674114466,
-0.166355446,
0.4174735248,
-0.3972857296,
-0.1692800373,
-0.4591124952,
-0.8445665836,
-0.2202581316,
-0.3121854067,
0.4571940899,
-0.0644774958,
0.5296036005,
0.400767833,
0.4337044656,
0.2287589908,
0.0719377473,
0.2976829112,
-0.28080827,
0.0690879747,
0.1322614253,
-0.3051056266,
0.2036660165,
0.014000209,
0.4496990442,
0.8545523286,
-0.0860839784,
-0.3760609329,
0.1599185914,
0.3166098893,
-0.5806239843,
0.1991512924,
-0.3483559489,
0.5502189398,
0.0308472607,
-0.181534946,
-0.6534458399,
0.0623916537,
0.1973006278,
-0.6375578046,
0.0017034044,
0.0168554541,
0.7870231271,
0.0739321262,
-0.5172810555,
-0.8105961084,
-0.6360064745,
0.8319982886,
-0.5319507122,
0.8047490716,
0.1285339147,
-0.0855879784,
0.0129791815,
-0.606402874,
-0.2639168799,
-0.3143208623,
-0.1679760516,
0.2981361151,
-0.0938656181,
0.151591152,
0.1956795752,
0.1505941451,
-0.5528540611,
0.2655076385,
-0.0593067072,
-0.205046609,
0.2616813183,
-0.2222034484,
0.3728625774,
-0.549094677,
-0.5915016532,
-0.4936861396,
-0.5178601742,
-0.2228230238,
0.2078906,
0.1886998713,
-0.1530071199,
0.8095884323,
0.1568282992,
0.614892602,
-0.445286274,
-0.0041487068,
0.3433814645,
-0.6161926985,
-0.149403125,
-0.0023164381,
0.8589968085,
0.1924498379,
0.4041046202,
-0.6412580609,
-0.2694866061,
0.0894074515,
0.2336031795,
-0.3830223978,
0.265227288,
0.1802888662,
-0.4490173161,
0.1893649399,
0.2442192286,
-0.4853800237,
-0.2779307067,
-0.1587860286,
0.2076915503,
-0.7566643953,
0.1354154348,
0.2189923227,
-0.4019358456,
0.3723593652,
0.2517777383,
-0.8352565765,
0.0166098103,
0.6114463806,
0.8488401175,
0.080749929,
-0.4287635088,
-0.4042704999,
0.2330857813,
-0.6196801662,
0.6516633034,
-0.452575177,
-0.4559221864,
0.4072816968,
-0.3482148349,
-0.1568050981,
-0.3380769193,
0.8540077209,
-0.2790943682,
0.4345404506,
-0.3066715002,
-0.917852819,
-0.0378937833,
0.1671272963,
-0.6790210009,
1.0285589695,
0.0277736075,
-0.7068675756,
0.5726358294,
-0.5308133364,
-0.5358831286,
0.0213292241,
-0.2079938501,
-0.1054078043,
0.1865875721,
0.4100717306,
0.8955364823,
-0.0314450487,
0.1839550883,
-0.1757275909,
-0.1961936951,
0.0742503256,
-0.5229414701,
0.6193047762,
0.1876645684,
-0.1821615249,
-0.1167446971,
-0.5749436021,
0.1057035923,
0.0808968246,
-0.4612118602,
-0.5134593248,
-0.0596292689,
0.3596076667,
0.205549106,
0.2439203411,
-0.7823102474,
0.1335449219,
-0.5720123053,
0.5438626409,
0.4639001489,
-0.2007926852,
0.6753471494,
-0.2445616275,
0.219367519,
-0.1328664124,
-0.1704436839,
-0.4349712431,
-0.4023121595,
-0.4841894507,
-0.305206567,
0.2889745235,
0.6386603117,
-0.8607392907,
0.3624275923,
-0.3072034717,
-0.3838249445,
-0.5678976178,
0.2842905819,
0.431669414,
0.0497476347,
0.303106308,
0.0580149926,
-0.3867554367,
-0.8325827122,
-0.1420810819,
-0.0072759157,
0.0424294807,
0.0568134524,
0.3645713925,
0.0319669694,
0.5771514177,
-0.3672384918,
-0.4482724965,
-0.5144248009,
0.3012010753,
-0.0139924502,
0.34585464,
0.8461209536,
-0.8143410087,
-0.5686752796,
0.0193190463,
-1.0977178812,
0.2518128157,
-0.4682203531,
-0.0574521236,
0.533485651,
0.4690965414,
-0.8010451198,
0.2308385968,
0.4922079444,
-0.2696820498,
0.1647210419,
-0.7892886996,
0.0675226524,
-0.9591171741,
-0.2592708766,
0.0224759951,
-0.3816883266,
-0.7199448347,
0.3511966467,
0.3304252326,
-0.2161757201,
-0.582325995,
0.3445747793,
-0.6700677276,
-0.2953996658,
0.1363276243,
0.3066003919,
0.2549148798,
0.6835951805,
0.1097584665,
0.5533649921,
0.4029586017,
-0.2383611798,
0.3958523571,
0.2457176,
-0.5893457532,
0.2655011415,
-0.6264867783,
0.0579004101,
-0.2556574345,
0.223255381,
-0.7525106072,
0.0791393742,
-0.0430121273,
-0.3300607502,
0.4167005718,
0.315341264,
-0.9191853404,
-0.2039825171,
-0.4669216573,
-0.0882163048,
0.3631552458,
-0.4194347262,
0.6791050434,
0.2753293216,
0.0009023443,
-0.5884540081,
-0.9495478868,
0.2571462691,
0.0729922205,
-0.7471873164,
0.5714505315,
0.1936681122,
0.0044741551,
0.2010398209,
0.2394194603,
-0.06593398,
-0.0545211136,
-0.0022474423,
0.1845524907,
-0.1255249232,
0.470974654,
-0.0889716148,
-0.0364442803,
-0.3153352737,
-0.281804949,
0.6811048388,
-0.0558837987,
-0.5525587201,
-0.1430586278,
0.9467239976,
0.4957601428,
-0.4397018254,
0.9468455315,
0.8131972551,
-0.447311908,
-0.3498472571,
-0.4833985269,
0.0004917743,
-0.3320057988,
0.3948416412,
-0.470220983,
-0.9078791142,
0.3291908205,
0.1869841963,
0.3353742361,
0.5079882145,
0.4429048896,
-0.4643420577,
0.8767133951,
0.6396498084,
0.1279460192,
0.4157505929,
-0.341560632,
0.2257414758,
-0.574390769,
-0.2775567472,
-0.5849843025,
-0.0017513477,
-0.5032252073,
-0.5020891428,
0.3283837736,
0.0967368707,
0.2295632064,
0.2729793787,
-0.3742162585,
0.2034755498,
0.593644321,
-0.1096303686,
-0.0860786214,
0.1407638341,
-0.3879079223,
-0.2019705325,
-1.053599,
-0.4404521286,
0.9736219645,
0.1428642571,
0.609346807,
0.024632575,
0.7645491958,
0.2474742681,
-0.1295223385,
-0.8644092679,
0.2608584762,
-0.7469195127,
-0.2252109945,
-0.3063815236,
-0.3755408227,
-1.0617377758,
0.6096431017,
-0.6357175112,
-0.3510499597,
0.0961622745,
-0.3895552158,
-0.1593478918,
0.1948896199,
-1.0424607992,
1.0205477476,
-0.3350461423,
-0.0500465408,
-0.1792439967,
-0.3336178958,
-0.1910971701,
-0.020466039,
0.3344543278,
0.1311815828,
-0.1101101711,
0.8367878795,
-0.4864242375,
0.6470009685,
-0.214742437,
-0.0973667949,
0.1985856444,
-0.3279031813,
0.4231176674,
-0.2380535901,
-0.1509967595,
0.0832113624,
0.0708974749,
-0.4544448256,
-0.8769213557,
0.5990660191,
-0.8778694868,
-0.4680132866,
-0.3661509156,
-0.4138763249,
-0.2202933878,
0.1293565631,
0.3067394495,
0.9300372005,
-0.3493849337,
0.5340265632,
0.6562778354,
-0.4883390963,
0.6731895208,
0.1343336999,
-0.0222042501,
-0.1410561353,
0.8175086975,
0.4025907516,
0.0258166883,
0.8461296558,
0.1048295349,
-0.3627251685,
-0.4390442073,
-0.5105707049,
0.2469520271,
-1.0305874348,
0.0487839952,
-0.9854130149,
-0.0746458396,
-0.5934798717,
-0.6000664234,
-0.2540740073,
-0.5632830262,
-0.1975280195,
-0.2976983786,
0.0269637201,
0.8025867939,
-0.037079528,
-0.0246273465,
-1.0278513432,
0.3655493259,
0.0507652797,
0.0898989066,
-0.04930491,
0.0808583945,
-0.4010805786,
-0.0530428365,
0.0316921622,
-0.9746400118,
0.3288368285,
0.4419917166,
0.8701446056,
0.0463550389,
-0.0273027774,
0.501201272,
-0.6490513086,
0.8661376238,
0.2496876866,
-0.8829950094,
0.3973534703,
-0.0673986599,
0.3728678524,
0.2761600316,
0.4249659479,
-0.6864476204,
-0.502176404,
-0.3651244044,
-0.9769530892,
0.5742222071,
0.0582653098,
0.4381864965,
-0.1497695148,
0.1471520066,
0.1033027992,
0.0142859519,
-0.5967447758,
-0.0230954066,
-0.3812507689,
-0.472325474,
-0.1985995471,
-0.1705454439,
0.1900322139,
0.2050369978,
0.2492202371,
-0.0045994874,
0.517560482,
0.3408406973,
-0.5366126895,
0.489664793,
0.3162481189,
0.3370525241,
0.475015372,
-0.1076757684,
0.1284147501,
0.1104213372,
-0.2672263682,
0.0552500188,
0.0150851049,
-0.0903943032,
0.5227297544,
0.9401564598,
0.8485989571,
0.5634846091,
-0.725677073,
0.8518528342,
0.02517597,
-0.1761541814,
-0.2457486838,
-0.2897815704,
0.1871955395,
-0.0493085794,
0.2828361392,
-0.1146535948,
-0.0204312224,
-0.6405563354,
0.1872300804,
0.5359874964,
-0.2780695558,
0.1285779625,
0.3398733437,
0.1847076565,
0.0648634136,
0.6249831915,
-0.0773885623,
-0.374387145,
0.453799665,
0.3503007889,
0.6779695153,
0.0716143623,
0.4800800681,
0.2257596701,
0.3793470562,
0.0256344359,
0.2276813388,
-0.0263252705,
-0.9394686818,
-0.6552935243,
-0.5987740159,
-0.3145540953,
-0.3934949934,
-0.5389643908,
0.0586414225,
-0.3338693082,
-0.0103748962,
0.2090404183,
-0.0543426685,
-0.8858364224,
0.0445272699,
0.1892254502,
0.9866874814,
-0.5809586048,
0.8667110205,
0.7773296237,
-0.4509045482,
-0.6673665643,
-0.3403864205,
-0.3180705905,
-0.6680916548,
0.7242771387,
0.1113014966,
0.027147159,
-0.1885454357,
-0.1134800091,
-0.576403141,
0.763063848,
0.5131822824,
-0.4616961479,
-0.337021172,
0.2250561863,
0.6172725558,
-0.4451623559,
0.197737202,
-0.1213325933,
0.4280698597,
0.0366549268,
-0.5704254508,
-0.1697630137,
-0.1437626332,
0.2619537115,
0.0819095746,
-0.2562449872,
0.6750482917,
0.0975908116,
-0.4249862134,
-0.1878099889,
0.6795343757,
-0.1066900119,
-0.0423964895,
0.3789123297,
0.6157333255,
0.8574712276,
-0.3341773152,
1.5608053207,
-0.4233149886,
0.151951015,
0.9116861224,
-0.2675653994,
0.9709866047,
0.2538540363,
-0.0271430053,
0.422557652,
0.5273061991,
-0.1189558804,
0.5302996635,
-0.0238285325,
0.0616208799,
-0.0960832536,
-0.1833330989,
-0.1958827823,
0.51286906,
0.306851685,
-0.2202239335,
-0.2702139318,
0.5931338668,
0.1584859043,
0.1789920628,
-0.124026753,
0.9588614702,
0.0944594666,
-0.6400942206,
0.5437229872,
0.3595719039,
0.9850335121,
-0.8691071272,
0.1038342193,
-0.0963852927,
-0.0187101178,
-0.0760536343,
-0.8229489923,
0.2900760472,
0.1452139765,
-0.0182911791,
-0.8623462915,
0.8303232193,
-0.571129024,
-0.4362595975,
0.601536274,
0.7938880324,
0.0341318771,
0.1609925181,
-0.5558126569,
0.0430765934,
-0.189993456,
-0.3083354533,
0.2312695533,
0.527243495,
0.1786124557,
0.4206961691,
0.5398691893,
0.1540541649,
0.3434096873,
0.3910163045,
0.691624105,
-0.5180583,
-0.5606435537,
-0.5773178935,
0.2867781222,
0.0186517444,
-0.2417074144,
0.900967896,
0.4805676639,
0.9667913318,
-0.1277660578,
0.8343906999,
0.1062916592,
0.0939873084,
-0.937872231,
0.5481784344,
-0.6497408748,
-0.2274814546,
-0.1404029131,
-1.1453720331,
-0.3851265013,
0.754561007,
-0.0091751711,
-0.0069882856,
0.8860340714,
0.3289006054,
0.0866823122,
-0.0182024278,
0.4218790233,
0.0446362607,
0.2874549031,
0.6674715877,
0.6717247963,
-0.1759199649,
0.5392454267,
-0.1341686845,
-0.0416172706,
-0.0650074109,
-0.6518245935,
-0.7191703916,
-0.7093521953,
-0.1341636777,
0.0328413174,
0.026344914,
0.9521799684,
0.5336433053,
-0.5461956263,
-0.0872096345,
0.0788014159,
0.1050588712,
-0.2650497258,
-0.1754466891,
0.5012959838,
-0.7470390797,
-0.8266557455,
0.4466546476,
0.4687587619,
0.1334661394,
-0.4896473587,
-0.04555998,
-0.44290483,
0.0694886893,
0.8504401445,
-0.1351810694,
-0.6308732033,
-0.2791145742,
0.2100796551,
-0.4844699204,
0.0628270656,
0.8303369284,
-0.6317382455,
0.5988284349,
0.7266104221,
0.8802397847,
0.5085557103,
-0.5229815245,
0.5937036872,
-0.9431300759,
0.2822968066,
0.173012346,
0.6942726374,
0.6241492033,
-0.1972520053,
0.5511386395,
0.0637516305,
-0.0782108381,
-0.5999903083,
0.0755928382,
-0.8810274005,
-0.6211713552,
1.017537117,
-0.6153686047,
-0.2202840745,
-0.0808579102,
-0.116982311,
0.2867205441,
-0.2414025962,
0.2352677733,
1.1812080145,
-0.017198218,
-0.2404446751,
-0.4566757381,
0.2211557627,
0.4097430706,
-0.6361108422,
-0.1625724584,
0.4381200373,
-0.3949068487,
0.5064525008,
0.4407426417,
-0.0884600282,
0.0401306264,
0.1311169863,
-0.0150728934,
-0.2108847648,
-0.2835330367,
-0.1867559403,
0.6403836012,
-0.2095148712,
0.1172446981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14780v1 | Training and Evaluation of a Multilingual Tokenizer for GPT-SW3 | 2023-04-28T11:40:48 | 2023-04-28T11:40:48 | Felix Stollenwerk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper provides a detailed discussion of the multilingual tokenizer used
for GPT-SW3. It was trained on the Nordic Pile using the SentencePiece library
and the BPE algorithm. We outline the tokenizer's most important features and
share details on its learned vocabulary. In addition, we systematically analyze
the properties and evaluate the performance of the tokenizer with regard to the
different languages present in the data. | [
-0.5767257214,
-0.5000779033,
0.3239665329,
0.237775743,
-0.6024598479,
0.0812407732,
-0.0188700594,
-0.5150763392,
0.0604258776,
0.2013526857,
-0.3557294011,
-0.5331373215,
-0.6777610183,
0.2527214587,
-0.1235455349,
1.4020009041,
-0.2566365302,
0.5666178465,
0.348364085,
-0.0326047204,
-0.5660843849,
-0.9196301699,
-0.7075491548,
-0.1680891663,
0.4038124084,
0.0074113826,
0.4700168371,
0.5622760057,
0.402987957,
0.4183474183,
-0.2200003713,
-0.5023015738,
-0.2130899876,
-0.2396864891,
-0.1384332776,
-0.4017044604,
-0.4185075164,
-0.1619852632,
0.7344533801,
0.3684885204,
0.0522551909,
0.1278169602,
-0.0222819708,
0.3739718795,
-0.2627237439,
0.1570101827,
-0.6190606952,
0.2490344048,
-0.479578197,
-0.0911917388,
-0.3438315392,
-0.1471627802,
-0.0116781918,
-0.3459499776,
0.7240805626,
0.1199564338,
0.7241117358,
-0.1292707622,
-0.5844329596,
-0.3378545642,
-0.3838867247,
0.790843308,
-0.4140861332,
0.3239872456,
0.1997264326,
0.3719853163,
0.1397912502,
-0.7323445678,
-0.5049436092,
0.0445210822,
-0.1852729917,
0.3261887133,
0.4295947552,
0.2364713103,
0.0397597626,
0.6333893538,
-0.9006897807,
0.098452881,
-0.6878249645,
-0.4152058661,
0.403676182,
-0.091271542,
0.4223246276,
-0.5551774502,
-0.6332970262,
0.047346808,
-0.3411981463,
-0.2955075502,
0.5480191112,
0.2696099579,
0.0038951472,
0.6825807691,
0.096266225,
0.796728611,
-0.5038216114,
-0.0747469738,
0.6311782002,
-0.4412132502,
-0.0245905295,
-0.0484226197,
0.6527163982,
0.3418660462,
-0.0553908609,
-0.2991217375,
-0.4964149892,
-0.0364361443,
0.2326075286,
-0.8508454561,
0.0241867732,
0.3912991881,
-0.5854166746,
-0.003510776,
0.4549328685,
-0.5508645177,
-0.042430494,
-0.1452350616,
0.2081830502,
-0.4937591553,
-0.3559319079,
0.3051548302,
-0.6834558249,
0.2902127504,
0.0993311629,
-1.0665485859,
0.285277158,
1.1860201359,
1.0308846235,
-0.3663703799,
-0.8331965208,
-0.67271173,
0.1053919718,
-0.0703481808,
0.9168918729,
-0.1387661844,
-0.3468311131,
0.1470436305,
0.1323859245,
-0.2226080894,
-0.2458233535,
0.5645935535,
-0.45400244,
0.5930547714,
-0.0810397714,
-0.6611144543,
-0.3149170876,
0.3079522252,
-0.846095562,
0.997228682,
0.4006379843,
-0.997220695,
0.8482288122,
-0.8621372581,
-0.3242097497,
0.5562826395,
0.0474668071,
-0.2133403718,
0.2742727697,
0.2994682789,
0.5558947325,
0.2295892537,
0.3921218514,
0.0618556663,
-0.7176628709,
-0.1279467195,
-0.3016135693,
0.7967159152,
0.0081359809,
-0.3344190419,
0.2959160805,
-0.6174877882,
-0.1408566535,
-0.1727762669,
-0.5871561766,
-0.0695196837,
-0.2469713092,
0.6572992802,
0.2509559691,
0.2886549532,
-0.891895771,
0.2687816024,
-0.5108855367,
0.288836807,
0.8005471826,
0.1475038677,
0.1184501797,
-0.2093663812,
0.7107056379,
-0.1886894852,
0.2008528858,
0.0812741593,
-0.5878426433,
-0.4401100576,
-0.4956456125,
0.4355326593,
0.781131804,
-0.9635849595,
0.3704805076,
-0.3076880872,
-0.3530156314,
-0.3717758656,
0.1010621339,
0.4932362139,
-0.1627377868,
0.389516294,
-0.2490632385,
-0.6537146568,
-0.8072212934,
-0.2227654308,
-0.2307186425,
-0.145969227,
-0.176058948,
0.7339822054,
-0.0494851358,
0.7104671597,
-0.2093954384,
-0.2439170778,
-0.500436008,
0.4527596533,
0.3886384666,
0.5817924142,
0.7072877884,
-0.7283397317,
-0.6489034295,
0.1652209461,
-0.4037866294,
0.1451707184,
0.0440735444,
-0.1088961139,
0.3288242519,
0.4576217532,
-0.4772386253,
0.1928220242,
0.8032413125,
-0.7124174833,
0.7373275161,
-0.1180997193,
0.0466613434,
-1.168261528,
0.0995499119,
-0.1980729699,
-0.1032965556,
-0.7217917442,
0.0980185196,
0.0129923522,
-0.2043490559,
-0.8223147988,
0.7690853477,
-0.4848886132,
-0.2800224125,
-0.0570375472,
0.3119656444,
-0.18907547,
0.6158207655,
0.307331562,
0.8765747547,
0.4150449932,
-0.2817353606,
0.4159671962,
0.3631868064,
-0.5164626241,
0.8668307662,
-0.4924327135,
0.2526642382,
-0.273612082,
0.1025372446,
-0.8980044723,
-0.0259525888,
0.0407550037,
-0.2695300579,
0.2127868533,
-0.5371853113,
-0.6227011085,
-0.7583208084,
-0.5430089831,
0.1754321903,
-0.0070375213,
-0.5883854032,
0.530542016,
0.3355473578,
-0.3411779404,
-0.7925031185,
-0.6476172209,
0.0359938368,
-0.3870480359,
-0.394266516,
0.2465202063,
-0.1243921742,
0.1272062808,
-0.173805058,
-0.0612923689,
-0.2382376194,
-0.0389174521,
-0.1166747734,
0.3662754595,
-0.0404413827,
0.098254472,
-0.217628926,
-0.3614732325,
-0.1439792812,
-0.2591038048,
0.9145774245,
-0.538973093,
-0.3412395716,
-0.2595184147,
0.253260076,
0.2565064728,
-0.0514779836,
0.6059020758,
1.3438305855,
-0.1656996906,
0.4038731754,
-0.6446945667,
0.1284250766,
-0.4716653228,
0.7706439495,
-0.8391216993,
-1.1193085909,
0.5083163381,
0.1749306023,
0.2332542986,
0.5704590082,
0.3916294277,
0.205265522,
1.0529756546,
0.3817595243,
-0.2403416336,
0.3966791332,
-0.1699929535,
-0.0138517618,
-1.009439826,
-0.0812291205,
-0.6509177089,
-0.1312188804,
-0.6081106663,
-0.3182874024,
0.1249637455,
0.2216989398,
-0.4052777588,
0.3247276247,
-0.5929426551,
0.5749310255,
0.2535540164,
-0.280980885,
0.0637160242,
-0.0783165619,
-0.3220145106,
-0.0274328981,
-0.5975373387,
-0.6285068393,
0.7758643627,
0.4584243894,
0.1330981255,
0.1715883464,
0.7602264881,
0.089707613,
0.5758005977,
-0.9532266259,
0.4411666393,
-0.2964630127,
-0.8708115816,
-0.4186906517,
-0.3430280089,
-1.0495364666,
0.8707242608,
-0.0198231954,
-0.8024441004,
-0.1315281987,
-0.1405771673,
0.1733703613,
0.4635580778,
-0.8157423735,
1.2750742435,
-0.358740896,
0.2690886557,
-0.2003092766,
-0.4602642655,
0.1990723908,
-0.1092683002,
0.4270415306,
0.0349915549,
-0.1880183965,
0.91483742,
-0.3339841068,
0.7008443475,
-0.7890198231,
-0.0373608395,
-0.0329773277,
-0.0180143546,
0.3832221925,
0.1318255216,
-0.1106937379,
0.3812159598,
0.1054156125,
-0.5031193495,
-0.3642950654,
0.2594134212,
-0.8063315153,
-0.4005177915,
-0.3737663329,
-0.1184948459,
-0.3176635802,
0.5519446731,
0.1721668392,
0.3797947466,
-0.6815021038,
0.095981583,
0.0061061257,
-0.200694859,
0.684173286,
0.4402537644,
-0.5239040852,
-0.7449051738,
0.9832267165,
-0.0538916774,
-0.0319276117,
0.4808108807,
0.2922802866,
-0.3680952489,
-0.749702692,
-0.7696157098,
0.4525920451,
-0.9066272378,
-0.0759592429,
-0.5425430536,
-0.0983672589,
0.0273132492,
-0.3166157007,
-0.1828487515,
-0.514767468,
0.0355628803,
-0.5524402261,
0.270934701,
1.1898263693,
0.0553608201,
0.6856507063,
-0.7947789431,
0.1843190193,
0.2278303504,
0.6247277856,
-0.3959797323,
-0.1942202002,
-0.4680766165,
-0.2864682376,
0.1220092401,
-0.5514014363,
0.1065931618,
-0.0085004205,
0.6459879279,
0.1584549993,
-0.7207778692,
0.5135677457,
-0.5799043775,
1.1533491611,
0.1931261569,
-1.2918287516,
0.2372089326,
-0.2974258065,
0.3829999864,
0.6005637646,
0.2416882813,
-0.8972226977,
-0.3536374867,
-0.6098792553,
-1.0276372433,
0.731654048,
-0.1881686896,
0.1422128379,
-0.2717325091,
0.1642545015,
0.4326848984,
0.4180495143,
-0.8808851242,
-0.0165381357,
-0.5461022258,
-0.0217701402,
-0.1834352016,
-0.4845601022,
0.1014068946,
-0.1910026819,
0.7585183978,
-0.2432623953,
0.3588291705,
-0.3115496635,
-0.3272603154,
0.4706190526,
0.3934459388,
0.547785759,
0.7170876265,
-0.2550220788,
-0.0250438061,
0.3699807525,
-0.8814843297,
0.0089222267,
0.1210236996,
0.070153743,
0.3301423192,
0.3789093196,
1.1490641832,
0.1190655753,
-0.2884228528,
0.8532589078,
-0.1798239052,
-0.5279461741,
-0.3159466982,
-0.3841607273,
-0.1088430658,
-0.1738804579,
0.2925799787,
0.0288958717,
0.2114918977,
-0.188483417,
0.2224149108,
0.4166133404,
-0.5123249888,
-0.2272605598,
0.3511975408,
0.2338508517,
-0.0628028437,
0.6827984452,
-0.2340479344,
-0.9544507265,
0.2585966587,
0.6646299362,
0.9195358753,
-0.315032661,
0.4421302676,
0.3668302596,
0.3910858035,
-0.0245278254,
0.6016193032,
-0.0218672212,
-0.8019884825,
-0.7481028438,
-0.6452408433,
-0.2968203425,
0.0315996557,
-0.7109799981,
0.2658852041,
-0.2158622742,
-0.2113806009,
-0.2885373235,
0.0919809639,
-0.8838769794,
0.1585169286,
-0.0893052295,
0.9337374568,
-0.902336061,
0.6953163743,
0.8450046778,
-0.1857988685,
-0.5112498999,
-0.1343917549,
-0.1796620637,
-0.9681996703,
0.6806002259,
0.3805938363,
-0.0280386228,
-0.0699130669,
-0.041291561,
-0.7527529001,
0.8712022901,
0.0113018742,
-0.0691053122,
0.2258675992,
0.1325057298,
0.5300753117,
-0.1376603246,
0.3874216974,
0.5409899354,
0.6776679158,
-0.143381685,
-1.1081821918,
-0.1769771725,
-0.5550363064,
0.4686052501,
0.2178915441,
-0.5100554824,
0.6106518507,
0.3648614883,
-0.3150554895,
-0.0992459804,
0.5156759024,
0.1929043531,
-0.4333333075,
0.5971323252,
0.3928259313,
0.8169254065,
-0.3060715199,
1.1209322214,
-0.3495465517,
0.4038848579,
0.9151514769,
-0.2123117894,
0.9556953907,
0.4708400071,
-0.2643311918,
0.4695065916,
0.5350043774,
-0.2400094867,
0.3089358509,
0.3518041968,
-0.3278278112,
0.4185346067,
0.3339022398,
-0.3013187647,
0.4542911947,
0.3595601022,
-0.0077707004,
-0.1773594022,
0.3451394141,
0.3057648242,
-0.4289091527,
-0.3659203053,
0.9749610424,
-0.3027687669,
-0.5406293273,
0.560061574,
0.2378601581,
0.968711853,
-0.5764724016,
0.2327784598,
-0.0336509831,
0.0859942734,
-0.1481429487,
-0.824721694,
0.4482448995,
-0.0348565094,
0.199005127,
-0.4004983306,
0.45723629,
-0.2972705364,
-0.4163113832,
0.1532366276,
0.5890251994,
0.4989802837,
-0.0173638742,
-0.8090570569,
0.0643408298,
-0.0572131537,
-0.4794305861,
0.249109745,
0.5644646883,
0.1442844272,
0.2519958019,
0.4481150806,
0.2225488126,
0.0275210924,
0.5935711861,
0.5659734607,
-0.7024841309,
-0.6720281839,
-0.8040266037,
0.7234200239,
-0.1991779059,
-0.4609045982,
0.8143236637,
1.0452874899,
1.0232071877,
-0.4507085681,
0.9884584546,
-0.1868162006,
0.6204791665,
-0.6568017602,
0.4363809228,
-0.1069046855,
-0.2132567316,
-0.315571934,
-1.2078197002,
-0.5894854665,
0.892418921,
-0.1348963827,
0.1498226821,
1.21588552,
0.3066088557,
0.1856824458,
0.2624438703,
0.1109542698,
0.0158179104,
0.2963222265,
0.2129369974,
0.720246613,
-0.4112484753,
0.5068801045,
-0.2023631185,
-0.2395159304,
0.2010499835,
-0.994926095,
-1.172862649,
-0.6878290176,
-0.0153528769,
-0.2273776531,
-0.0507000573,
0.7299841642,
0.5528303981,
-0.829690814,
-0.5567228198,
-0.0897632167,
0.1029132977,
-0.4893457294,
-0.2207882553,
0.6458050013,
-0.5257361531,
-0.8632971048,
0.4550169408,
0.3085786998,
0.2926638722,
-0.4089875519,
-0.0481030904,
0.0440944918,
-0.4489397109,
0.6873635054,
-0.1808646917,
-0.4779545665,
-0.4753171802,
-0.3535989523,
0.1074802503,
0.2291096747,
1.0981456041,
-0.3838586807,
0.4134802818,
0.4530279934,
0.2637164891,
1.0119438171,
0.1032325849,
0.7324410081,
-1.0271573067,
0.5623669028,
0.073769778,
0.6397371292,
0.4621597826,
-0.2498799711,
0.6863205433,
0.3162305653,
-0.5099405646,
-0.5291416049,
0.1067152321,
-0.6613398194,
-0.2754629552,
1.0847398043,
-0.094135806,
-0.1083917171,
-0.6839626431,
-0.5732362866,
0.1069067791,
-0.1238269657,
0.517269969,
1.1842217445,
0.0462757722,
-0.1639559716,
-0.8653174639,
0.7004546523,
0.1587618738,
-0.596508801,
-0.1100722924,
0.4671918154,
0.2253358364,
0.12664406,
0.8963437676,
-0.3813258111,
0.1205597818,
0.07437516,
0.3883028626,
0.1611174047,
-0.1058293432,
-0.4392902553,
0.2389831543,
0.2414882928,
-0.0354357511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14770v2 | RexUIE: A Recursive Method with Explicit Schema Instructor for Universal Information Extraction | 2023-04-28T11:28:56 | 2023-10-18T02:30:55 | Chengyuan Liu, Fubang Zhao, Yangyang Kang, Jingyuan Zhang, Xiang Zhou, Changlong Sun, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Universal Information Extraction (UIE) is an area of interest due to the
challenges posed by varying targets, heterogeneous structures, and
demand-specific schemas. However, previous works have only achieved limited
success by unifying a few tasks, such as Named Entity Recognition (NER) and
Relation Extraction (RE), which fall short of being authentic UIE models
particularly when extracting other general schemas such as quadruples and
quintuples. Additionally, these models used an implicit structural schema
instructor, which could lead to incorrect links between types, hindering the
model's generalization and performance in low-resource scenarios. In this
paper, we redefine the authentic UIE with a formal formulation that encompasses
almost all extraction schemas. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first
to introduce UIE for any kind of schemas. In addition, we propose RexUIE, which
is a Recursive Method with Explicit Schema Instructor for UIE. To avoid
interference between different types, we reset the position ids and attention
mask matrices. RexUIE shows strong performance under both full-shot and
few-shot settings and achieves State-of-the-Art results on the tasks of
extracting complex schemas. | [
-0.1479074359,
-0.5856035948,
0.2826054394,
-0.0943278819,
-0.2602600455,
0.138763696,
-0.0400604419,
-0.5268062353,
0.1930317879,
0.1214598417,
-0.3345074356,
-0.6238517761,
-0.5079433322,
0.1719253659,
-0.4235087931,
0.6230365634,
0.0074294205,
-0.1333874613,
0.0502023362,
-0.3055177927,
-0.3253912628,
-0.0128616849,
-0.2806612849,
-0.2734235227,
0.5153491497,
0.6383585334,
0.1762416214,
0.7747348547,
0.1799108684,
0.3147139549,
0.2301062644,
0.1329291761,
-0.6046714783,
0.2661247253,
-0.7562277317,
-0.2662271857,
-0.0856557116,
0.1826077551,
0.7634958625,
0.6556791067,
-0.3836534917,
0.4728086889,
-0.0276741795,
0.3637977242,
-0.8574430943,
0.446813941,
-0.7901693583,
-0.0592223108,
0.0385429263,
-0.2118055224,
-0.7004442215,
-0.4532441497,
0.441655606,
-1.0699762106,
-0.1015091315,
-0.0207110811,
1.3102977276,
-0.1014468968,
-0.506508708,
-0.0009932468,
-0.7205883861,
0.7987170815,
-0.2128999382,
0.5352197886,
-0.3065577745,
0.212275967,
-0.2608426809,
-1.0969369411,
-0.5080341101,
-0.0648324117,
-0.02032171,
0.1658562124,
-0.3177765608,
0.204199478,
0.5326805711,
0.2877087891,
0.0009657604,
0.1850164086,
-0.2131539881,
-0.1387465447,
0.2974840105,
-0.1195928752,
0.3619553149,
-0.4715341032,
-0.6750251651,
0.1146877408,
-0.6007941961,
-0.048648946,
-0.1749841571,
0.0998158157,
0.3059142828,
0.5805132389,
-0.3024958372,
0.1699434072,
0.135626018,
-0.4835601449,
0.008036647,
0.0038458749,
-0.4089563489,
-0.3091594279,
0.885035336,
0.1652878821,
0.5153301954,
-0.6297390461,
0.1672895402,
-0.2402493358,
0.1838249564,
-0.8923251629,
0.1879533976,
0.0971163735,
-0.471493125,
-0.4760462344,
0.3846750855,
-1.2337013483,
-0.0155698434,
-0.6810407043,
0.2846380472,
-0.7979006171,
-0.4357020259,
-0.4467763901,
-0.1353869289,
0.480683893,
0.33273983,
-0.8781470656,
0.4891009033,
0.5462821722,
0.4704122841,
-0.3687115908,
-0.3101617992,
-0.7455712557,
0.5076104403,
0.0338815898,
0.7548750043,
-0.6294736266,
-0.6378405094,
-0.0238352399,
0.1960888356,
-0.4060451686,
-0.2093845606,
0.4368265569,
-0.4728338122,
0.2946744263,
-0.0008580027,
-0.7942439914,
-0.3699446917,
-0.1929038465,
-0.5621505976,
1.1896736622,
0.685914278,
-0.7787138224,
0.3217242956,
-0.8994629383,
-0.3427584469,
0.3622793853,
-0.5756086707,
-0.1337928772,
-0.0152941123,
-0.2804590464,
0.172947377,
-0.4956316054,
0.1957996935,
0.0210868586,
-0.4200491607,
-0.0913731605,
-0.2502769828,
1.1619364023,
0.3192969561,
-0.5966114402,
-0.1577683836,
-0.9670871496,
0.3914017975,
0.0754059181,
-0.1964956522,
-0.5505517721,
-0.2675417364,
-0.2774470448,
-0.1275945157,
0.0142264031,
-0.5870252252,
0.7127232552,
-0.1763717383,
0.4442816973,
0.7283468246,
0.0286744833,
0.8796941042,
0.2560407519,
0.5232270956,
-0.3361046016,
-0.0668888688,
-0.308843255,
-0.0371834971,
-0.5443225503,
-0.7789492011,
1.0113672018,
1.0493489504,
-0.5808416009,
0.2723837197,
-0.5824447274,
-0.3689437807,
-0.4961488545,
0.0267286561,
0.347668916,
0.6438583136,
0.3179077506,
-0.1964857578,
-0.6637300253,
-0.8256396651,
-0.1558256596,
-0.2237878591,
-0.2916828096,
0.5447846055,
0.534519136,
-0.5103189349,
1.2355777025,
-0.6240648627,
0.0317574628,
-0.0301444381,
0.5799930692,
-0.1101884544,
0.4968628287,
0.3104986846,
-0.6008659601,
-0.3055790961,
0.2846195102,
-1.1568388939,
0.0124139972,
-0.1210727617,
-0.264914304,
0.213409692,
0.2801321149,
-1.1233658791,
0.6048300266,
-0.4369184077,
0.1073581949,
0.6457112432,
0.1350732297,
0.2386672497,
-1.2158337831,
0.2665778399,
0.0540240072,
-0.0469763093,
-0.3430835605,
0.6656315923,
0.1046066731,
-0.2051359862,
-0.1433145106,
0.4181754589,
-0.6406408548,
-0.154731214,
0.2604619265,
0.1883031428,
0.184783563,
0.2836970687,
0.0864596665,
0.4855034053,
0.5501039028,
-0.4356232285,
0.4608461559,
-0.0023182735,
-0.1242239326,
0.8191403151,
-0.3527252972,
0.2732251287,
-0.0881007016,
-0.0852422416,
-0.669713676,
-0.3977408409,
0.3178862035,
-0.3122218251,
0.8131077886,
-0.4542390108,
-0.2646311522,
-0.3279966116,
-0.2041748166,
0.0171789154,
0.2608420849,
-0.7038959861,
1.2850147486,
0.1692765802,
-0.2180130333,
-1.0045508146,
-0.0445006229,
0.0243521743,
-0.3425398767,
-0.6350858808,
0.4457879066,
0.0202264953,
-0.3419970274,
-0.0946723223,
-0.2714363337,
-0.5286862254,
0.2724875212,
0.2424006164,
0.5222824812,
-0.3619672656,
0.2576480806,
0.1426876783,
-0.1737096906,
-0.0590166487,
-0.1885927767,
0.0707280561,
-0.0724619105,
0.0912918448,
-0.853751123,
0.600892961,
0.7260519862,
0.0010948948,
0.1878103316,
0.4645891488,
-0.5530451536,
-0.0349658169,
-0.637589097,
-0.3010942936,
-0.4173351526,
0.4096387327,
-0.6563111544,
-0.4242113829,
0.2207073569,
-0.6515989304,
0.310041666,
0.2751464248,
-0.2804605961,
-0.1475628465,
0.5430796146,
0.7407521605,
-0.3501692116,
0.4215668738,
-0.5198300481,
-0.0006239355,
-0.6310639381,
-0.4710642695,
-0.6369922161,
0.186737746,
-0.6321585774,
0.0407324284,
-0.2203208208,
0.2881066799,
-0.2912474573,
0.3783756793,
-0.6544881463,
0.6565502286,
0.6182844639,
-0.3572359681,
0.4406023026,
0.5949354172,
-0.1668917388,
-0.1114120856,
-0.3889336586,
-0.5079460144,
0.9054358602,
0.0405405127,
0.742420733,
-0.1780157387,
0.9857326746,
0.187799871,
0.4635731876,
-0.8547542095,
0.639631629,
0.0712993369,
-0.4761696458,
-0.4869304895,
-0.5569699407,
-1.0847196579,
0.5320860744,
-0.2816753387,
-1.0732033253,
0.4778862,
-0.1813165545,
-0.248118937,
0.2491870821,
-1.0094598532,
0.7578055859,
0.0481450185,
-0.4703915417,
-0.0470781922,
-0.6711831093,
0.3101016283,
0.2684856653,
0.2806024849,
0.0039631813,
0.0353462063,
0.4130678773,
-0.1995199025,
0.5595549941,
-0.3049398661,
0.1492234319,
0.4517661333,
0.3418919742,
0.5916836858,
0.4117489457,
-0.0843711793,
0.321788013,
0.200144276,
-0.27269122,
-0.5792585015,
0.6725893021,
-0.7278143167,
-0.6380523443,
-0.6548628211,
-0.3117217422,
0.0624235235,
0.7614197135,
0.5486646891,
0.4156511128,
-0.3719599843,
0.0698862523,
0.6872988939,
0.2684741318,
0.2487643659,
1.0193436146,
-0.0034767874,
-0.4110674262,
1.0746358633,
0.3389755785,
-0.0189059153,
0.4312006831,
-0.0339005031,
-0.0449428558,
-0.1578019261,
-0.3051862419,
0.1381936967,
-0.4770712256,
-0.3901184797,
-0.3583570421,
-0.4492155612,
-0.4109709561,
0.0422677398,
-0.2292755693,
-0.7102661133,
-0.4725017846,
-0.2916441858,
0.1709579378,
0.4342260361,
-0.2559089661,
0.1057103425,
-0.5578774214,
0.6231592894,
0.6580408216,
0.1886977702,
-0.2740166187,
-0.3130277991,
0.2843156159,
0.0153274229,
-0.3771060109,
-0.7782787085,
-0.1788690537,
0.3415576816,
0.7151069641,
0.6039140821,
-0.0758815631,
0.6362386346,
-0.4780310094,
0.3281612396,
0.2335382253,
-0.7834678888,
0.491678834,
-0.131453082,
-0.2547535002,
0.5632632375,
0.5000771284,
-0.2846857607,
0.0331424139,
-0.775033772,
-0.7857993841,
0.6333252788,
0.2211678773,
-0.0917954147,
-0.1247879267,
0.9662102461,
0.3069500625,
0.0456228815,
-1.0099470615,
-0.4295543134,
-0.3516881764,
-0.1176492274,
0.9626760483,
-0.4934197366,
0.0174017046,
-0.2652334869,
0.5711228848,
-0.0163655132,
0.250469178,
0.2762658,
-0.2597548366,
-0.2522232234,
0.5502061248,
0.002105118,
0.783164084,
-0.3527937531,
-0.1405613273,
0.0907012448,
-0.3749247789,
0.077458173,
0.5007618666,
-0.6387057304,
0.113521941,
0.3210840523,
0.202844739,
0.6726438999,
-0.3030326366,
0.4646880925,
-0.0497814007,
-0.1591886431,
-0.4591791928,
0.1221159548,
-0.2344747484,
0.0044639707,
0.4873506129,
-0.1719036698,
0.3124473989,
-0.4973283112,
0.2322110534,
0.4457684159,
-0.1265512258,
-0.242393136,
0.5401241183,
0.3838565052,
-0.1916704178,
0.8381118774,
-0.2070997506,
0.034181837,
0.3929656446,
0.5543057919,
0.8599278331,
-0.6841757894,
0.4499876797,
0.7024327517,
0.1725820154,
0.1947482228,
0.1966304183,
-0.1985295117,
-0.5418131351,
-0.4404581189,
-0.2867051661,
-0.300252825,
0.111087963,
-1.0863215923,
0.2225082219,
-0.1604923755,
0.0913565531,
0.2523714602,
0.0247799903,
-0.4323481023,
0.1112853661,
-0.1640511006,
0.9457418919,
-0.3621423542,
0.9267479181,
0.4203431308,
-0.7043951154,
-0.8374444246,
-0.4461055398,
-0.1057371646,
-0.7308052778,
0.6860458255,
0.1088421494,
-0.3125823438,
0.2800987065,
-0.7638909817,
-0.866351366,
1.4463120699,
0.5421937108,
-0.5858592987,
-0.5292221904,
-0.1025761142,
0.118573755,
-0.6666116118,
0.2365190536,
0.6814103127,
0.3947412074,
0.0151350489,
-0.408949554,
-0.0940886438,
-0.1072059199,
-0.1207792759,
-0.044053074,
-0.4822473526,
0.4850589037,
-0.538443625,
-0.6959705353,
0.4513672292,
0.6827585697,
0.0632760823,
0.2560597956,
0.589643538,
0.5475595593,
1.157060504,
-0.0337230973,
0.9155060053,
-0.168595925,
0.2797620296,
1.3691757917,
-0.400314182,
0.7197498679,
0.2861031294,
-0.1997057796,
1.2367572784,
0.3135620654,
-0.1195199415,
0.3496221602,
-0.120506607,
-0.2898987532,
-0.1562346816,
-0.2094817907,
-0.5246242285,
0.4732727408,
0.3608235717,
-0.306280762,
-0.1652625501,
-0.3025820851,
0.1671289504,
-0.0026225215,
-0.1246735007,
0.7895615697,
0.0945068747,
-0.5489739776,
0.4427216351,
-0.2322138101,
-0.0511116832,
-0.6227267981,
-0.3535534143,
-0.3092997074,
-0.1619701087,
-0.2527229786,
-0.3860799968,
-0.3567866087,
-0.1373377889,
-0.3937977552,
0.2344861031,
0.8637462854,
-0.3533017635,
-0.2336478382,
0.3494241238,
0.1884826273,
0.0686670467,
0.1582195163,
-0.5456127524,
-0.3913352489,
0.150857091,
-0.1441968977,
0.2455151528,
0.78739959,
0.0966920778,
0.6528093815,
0.5266731977,
-0.2111209184,
-0.1045691296,
-0.0801471248,
0.8008221984,
-0.8881047368,
-0.2244394571,
-0.6024790406,
0.5875690579,
-0.7274243236,
-0.119523041,
0.5261290073,
0.6771397591,
0.340919137,
0.0715379715,
0.8275850415,
-0.06862735,
0.7108715177,
-0.168669343,
0.169479385,
-0.3323833346,
0.2674378753,
-0.4238221943,
-1.0563153028,
0.0985220745,
0.7394113541,
0.2280096859,
-0.4290205836,
0.9038348198,
0.3117161095,
-0.0414467044,
0.1784119606,
-0.0523864031,
0.492416501,
0.152939871,
0.3476890922,
0.6083891392,
-0.4211207628,
0.914160192,
-0.3540937603,
-0.4192284346,
-0.077446945,
-0.8248884082,
-0.5287616849,
-0.2479045242,
-0.4770363867,
-0.3585361838,
-0.0643897429,
0.6827886701,
0.7120582461,
-0.7392008305,
0.0484560691,
0.0460349582,
0.625538826,
-0.0832721218,
-0.3351998031,
0.468855679,
-0.1860529184,
-0.6551401615,
0.392947942,
0.4729465544,
0.1135329157,
0.1659307331,
0.1255937368,
-0.1150775105,
-0.0711718425,
0.6909731627,
0.9495145679,
-0.8022625446,
-0.5730562806,
-0.04781688,
-0.1249946058,
0.0698271543,
0.7647313476,
-0.7125301957,
0.5426931977,
0.1222892627,
0.3154527545,
0.4496825635,
0.1486994326,
0.440792948,
-0.588760078,
0.152323395,
-0.0028792981,
0.6008458138,
-0.1532377154,
-0.3313319385,
0.9866718054,
0.5430294871,
-0.5037356615,
-0.8883469105,
0.3038207889,
-1.093089819,
-0.2393687218,
1.0656603575,
-0.3840698004,
-0.2637919486,
-0.2762551308,
-0.3977668285,
0.2482626587,
-0.42715922,
1.0590136051,
0.4720497727,
0.1098384261,
0.1134103313,
-0.1962775737,
0.1122041196,
-0.0222464763,
-0.8386012912,
0.1449300051,
0.6738610268,
0.675552845,
0.323500067,
0.4590418637,
-0.1409792453,
0.5265248418,
-0.1050395891,
0.3268831074,
0.0511752702,
-0.358299613,
0.2522978187,
0.3038529158,
-0.0995963141,
-0.1154410169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14767v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14767v3 | Dissecting Recall of Factual Associations in Auto-Regressive Language Models | 2023-04-28T11:26:17 | 2023-10-13T19:01:20 | Mor Geva, Jasmijn Bastings, Katja Filippova, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models (LMs) are known to capture factual
knowledge in their parameters. While previous work looked into where factual
associations are stored, only little is known about how they are retrieved
internally during inference. We investigate this question through the lens of
information flow. Given a subject-relation query, we study how the model
aggregates information about the subject and relation to predict the correct
attribute. With interventions on attention edges, we first identify two
critical points where information propagates to the prediction: one from the
relation positions followed by another from the subject positions. Next, by
analyzing the information at these points, we unveil a three-step internal
mechanism for attribute extraction. First, the representation at the
last-subject position goes through an enrichment process, driven by the early
MLP sublayers, to encode many subject-related attributes. Second, information
from the relation propagates to the prediction. Third, the prediction
representation "queries" the enriched subject to extract the attribute. Perhaps
surprisingly, this extraction is typically done via attention heads, which
often encode subject-attribute mappings in their parameters. Overall, our
findings introduce a comprehensive view of how factual associations are stored
and extracted internally in LMs, facilitating future research on knowledge
localization and editing. | [
-0.2945630252,
-0.6781529784,
0.8454051018,
-0.301471889,
0.1970734298,
-0.1186521277,
-0.112649858,
-0.5627688169,
-0.0885134935,
0.6675362587,
-0.6399620771,
-0.1799913347,
-0.5915802717,
-0.0541322902,
-0.4719938636,
1.0540995598,
0.0222293045,
-0.4195772409,
-0.3457678854,
-0.1678337306,
-0.6310724616,
-0.6635876298,
-0.3444848359,
-0.1895111352,
0.6968863606,
0.2140842974,
0.6705706716,
0.9615051746,
0.4556405544,
0.2745766044,
-0.0910932794,
0.0603570193,
-0.4777652025,
0.4066738486,
-0.3645273149,
-0.7439465523,
-0.1908385456,
0.1108972207,
0.84267205,
0.5745842457,
-0.133751601,
0.386248678,
0.0175038818,
0.5663358569,
-0.7832038999,
0.3768619299,
-0.8124750257,
-0.0560986809,
-0.2019664794,
-0.1823069751,
-0.6992989779,
-0.2853063643,
0.2864152789,
-0.0685841739,
0.4024346471,
0.077377066,
1.0377243757,
0.3350852728,
-0.4233337939,
-0.3202399015,
-1.089348197,
0.3479122519,
-0.4665071368,
0.5874136686,
0.6124784946,
0.2013030797,
0.0138838151,
-0.6672338843,
-0.5264722705,
-0.0759080723,
-0.672260344,
-0.1402002722,
-0.3168911934,
-0.1354460418,
0.2347088754,
0.4827635586,
-0.337064296,
-0.1049194187,
-0.5872215033,
-0.186890915,
0.6286051869,
0.0272019301,
0.0639754385,
-0.1938273162,
-0.1984338015,
-0.0458675548,
-0.7830453515,
-0.0164877921,
-0.145650655,
0.3893787563,
0.0430238396,
0.6264436245,
-0.0789729357,
0.673022449,
0.428651005,
-0.0820581019,
0.1460234523,
-0.2877954841,
-0.2984426618,
0.0531910062,
0.9251871705,
-0.3446337879,
0.0978397429,
-0.3098045886,
-0.1683279574,
-0.370901376,
0.4159448743,
-0.5115963221,
-0.3457568586,
0.1723356694,
-0.3809114099,
-0.033051163,
0.1740329713,
-0.5735498071,
-0.2793046832,
-0.4942132831,
0.4290667176,
-0.4205366671,
-0.2935423255,
-0.2829686403,
0.2143300623,
0.2688239813,
-0.0835121721,
-0.8195599914,
0.26964131,
0.6502684355,
0.6716412902,
-0.2084635347,
-0.173071757,
-0.4938644171,
0.3724221289,
-0.1025391296,
0.7604045272,
-0.4924751222,
-0.0357594714,
0.149890542,
0.1503305733,
-0.1335442811,
-0.4737182856,
0.3547258079,
-0.8441871405,
0.3360278308,
-0.5091406703,
-0.8034152985,
-0.4353706837,
0.0478674062,
-0.8240360022,
1.0871919394,
-0.1621933877,
-0.7215629816,
0.3202225864,
-0.2724603713,
-0.2645119131,
-0.306486547,
-0.0815648958,
-0.4139749408,
0.2131833434,
0.1103883907,
0.7077701688,
-0.2312146127,
0.3183285594,
-0.267113328,
0.0210399311,
0.4960610271,
-0.3861313462,
0.5012487769,
0.0506859049,
-0.1306076348,
-0.1587673724,
-0.7810009122,
-0.510807991,
0.1055522859,
0.0216680281,
-0.3489504457,
0.0006265464,
-0.778252244,
0.4983394146,
0.0903118178,
-0.3850643933,
0.0757136494,
-0.0739429742,
0.0085615218,
0.6490843892,
0.4556041658,
0.6215097308,
-0.000435589,
0.1279918104,
0.3253970742,
-0.0818883255,
-0.4232597649,
-0.2839050591,
-0.9590135813,
-0.101048477,
0.1320601553,
0.3941476345,
-0.2884229422,
0.3531082273,
-0.1544186026,
-0.4971424341,
-0.6353339553,
0.1436674297,
0.2887511253,
0.7226938009,
0.3764012754,
0.0665917173,
-0.237551704,
-1.0324920416,
-0.1757184565,
-0.3198372722,
0.1652495265,
0.1116146669,
0.2894977629,
-0.0872718468,
1.1364383698,
-0.8922786713,
-0.3799025416,
-0.1681970507,
0.5328150392,
0.247635439,
0.3399144411,
0.5678727627,
-0.66652143,
-0.3985112011,
-0.21783939,
-0.7443663478,
-0.044488024,
-0.2966389954,
-0.5428476334,
0.2743665278,
0.3777326345,
-0.9482305646,
0.4843367934,
0.2102811784,
-0.4478324354,
0.4899885952,
-0.1267181486,
-0.035434477,
-0.7911775112,
0.1487352997,
0.059398368,
-0.3221339583,
-0.5698592663,
-0.1509214938,
0.2176932693,
0.2723628879,
0.1202310547,
0.3455122113,
-0.8780369163,
-0.3472291827,
-0.2353124321,
0.1896132529,
0.0783681422,
0.7166252732,
0.3212137222,
0.588126123,
0.5587850809,
-0.853271842,
0.1361490637,
0.1428276747,
0.0270785801,
0.4205708802,
-0.2743346691,
0.2735599577,
-0.5782730579,
0.004499618,
-1.0817583799,
-0.0382030345,
0.1957108974,
-0.3518297374,
0.7128238678,
-0.2613722682,
-0.4800108671,
-0.156727165,
0.2493781149,
0.1141598523,
0.4582015574,
-0.2834672034,
0.8642326593,
0.7835738659,
-0.2865711451,
-0.4790865779,
-0.5985219479,
-0.1944127679,
-0.1191489398,
-0.1414526254,
0.2373265028,
0.21256724,
-0.209380284,
0.296007663,
-0.0770660192,
-0.2871690094,
-0.064923279,
0.1829784811,
0.4565051496,
-0.3282129765,
0.3768581152,
-0.1565697938,
0.0901401266,
0.4198534787,
-0.0315058306,
0.2645083368,
0.0486535057,
-0.2089699954,
-0.4999240339,
0.264716655,
0.5372970104,
-0.3862494528,
1.0815981627,
0.5075088739,
-0.4879148304,
-0.0356655531,
-0.8359505534,
-0.2385417968,
-0.3753919303,
0.328232646,
-0.4587947428,
-0.4180167019,
0.7854236364,
0.2987515032,
0.2245190293,
0.6626409888,
0.441594243,
-0.247178331,
0.7574483752,
0.7698992491,
-0.2283727825,
0.332731992,
-0.35034585,
0.1202833056,
-0.819383502,
-0.4562155008,
-0.3606309593,
-0.1373580247,
-0.4612057805,
-0.4275667965,
0.2945444584,
0.1311122179,
-0.10374704,
0.5231142044,
-0.1045969799,
0.2777748108,
0.4645169973,
0.0498057045,
0.4105829895,
-0.2413688153,
0.1008748785,
-0.2059351057,
-0.7238959074,
-0.2262641639,
0.9366118908,
0.5601879358,
0.6272391081,
0.0465554371,
0.5490837097,
0.0613620803,
0.7984164953,
-0.6872640252,
0.3528319597,
0.057228554,
-0.5599164963,
-0.1009324566,
-0.3352932334,
-0.5449182391,
0.1333004832,
-0.2059236914,
-0.7198738456,
0.6366651654,
0.3966447413,
-0.4001930952,
0.2799503505,
-0.5374514461,
0.7093076706,
-0.0287322346,
-0.6325880289,
-0.2094480842,
-0.7975628376,
0.4930906296,
0.0258969534,
0.1600933969,
0.0688820556,
0.3224419653,
0.4566069245,
-0.049694445,
0.8732831478,
-0.0863117501,
-0.3140527606,
0.3930753767,
0.5578889847,
0.6386438608,
-0.2945582867,
0.0512396768,
-0.001158457,
-0.2339233607,
0.1093459204,
-0.8826915026,
0.4134745598,
-0.6345193982,
-0.5253099799,
-0.4461376369,
-0.382034719,
-0.3755834997,
-0.0579069406,
-0.0048397426,
0.5367078185,
-0.0999643877,
0.0882745683,
0.8678632975,
0.0540239327,
0.3950701952,
0.8181683421,
-0.1670396924,
0.0197683964,
0.8749006391,
0.259013325,
0.4258791804,
0.6664404869,
0.1155565679,
-0.4495359361,
-0.1491753906,
-0.1135876328,
0.7658361793,
-0.8977276087,
-0.4487825632,
-0.9053521752,
-0.4753564596,
-0.4739357829,
0.495446682,
-0.5545789599,
-0.2610425651,
-0.4000759423,
-0.3846799731,
0.2944804132,
0.9714852571,
-0.1927939057,
0.0404827558,
-0.940348208,
0.3126484454,
0.2272644937,
0.1451921463,
0.1472240686,
-0.7557486892,
-0.4050659239,
-0.1186907068,
-0.2695506215,
-1.1173050404,
0.5228831172,
0.3114889562,
0.5615295768,
0.5630975366,
-0.0218137037,
0.7713233829,
-0.5778552294,
0.6218011379,
-0.282875061,
-0.6962997913,
0.5083922148,
0.142654717,
0.1704040617,
0.4985353351,
0.5275195241,
-0.551621139,
-0.7396135926,
-0.6022980809,
-0.6057544947,
0.8459065557,
0.0230524298,
-0.059660472,
-0.1113996059,
0.5800665021,
0.2175762504,
0.1477532387,
-0.8245931864,
-0.4796505868,
0.0358770341,
-0.184574917,
0.1368258148,
-0.5887541175,
-0.0124056358,
-0.1434264183,
0.6273016334,
0.1018979773,
0.4158355296,
0.2966215312,
-0.3467513323,
0.0404208377,
-0.0986585021,
0.3710213602,
0.4941586256,
-0.3402276635,
0.3087664545,
-0.2028809935,
-0.3338645995,
-0.1254511327,
0.028509723,
-0.1341971755,
0.1579402387,
0.5599298477,
1.0059771538,
0.2887561619,
-0.264940083,
0.4154792726,
0.1543197036,
0.3032914996,
-0.380061239,
-0.0673107058,
-0.0406313837,
0.2883237004,
0.5176356435,
0.0335169472,
0.4014123976,
-0.8258165121,
0.4341945946,
0.3242084086,
-0.4980272353,
-0.7238650322,
0.5177150965,
-0.1548913866,
0.0068687862,
0.6008129716,
-0.01354763,
-0.4644607306,
0.2144910991,
0.5286022425,
1.1981240511,
-0.2670016289,
0.2400505543,
0.7260997891,
0.2080342621,
-0.0117149148,
-0.1683484614,
-0.2595538497,
-0.8642739058,
-0.5001644492,
-0.5191231966,
-0.0239022318,
0.0160512161,
-0.8624569178,
0.097183615,
0.0549633168,
-0.0936582386,
-0.1905726343,
-0.3451186717,
-0.8442179561,
0.2486297041,
0.5702981353,
0.6670658588,
-0.9593072534,
0.7636609674,
0.199850291,
-0.550734818,
-0.8935800195,
0.2301421165,
-0.0472109914,
-0.8339722157,
1.0696936846,
-0.0564220212,
-0.1028678417,
-0.2338385284,
-0.4194191694,
-1.4233275652,
1.0369012356,
0.2754408717,
-0.4263167083,
-0.3431813717,
0.1536479145,
0.4635224938,
-0.3978074491,
0.3422371149,
0.7620046139,
0.2310655713,
0.1917958856,
-0.7497125864,
0.2765526474,
0.0842839554,
-0.2127442956,
0.1472602338,
-0.446426332,
0.8329791427,
-0.2143844366,
-0.5581642985,
-0.3832277656,
1.0240682364,
-0.0616134256,
-0.2167793363,
0.2737930715,
0.3881573975,
0.7748917937,
0.0781962648,
1.2222340107,
-0.3675653636,
0.3613334596,
1.4187318087,
-0.1732415408,
1.0098259449,
0.3982488811,
0.0076223398,
0.7998677492,
0.4149393141,
0.340696156,
0.7569882274,
-0.4122802615,
0.0624051876,
-0.1222244799,
-0.0599857643,
0.0419121683,
0.6148187518,
0.4636131525,
-0.7590794563,
-0.0623391308,
-0.1825418919,
0.0430755094,
-0.2404787093,
-0.2126632184,
1.2458866835,
0.0420785137,
-1.0119173527,
0.2726387382,
-0.2797672749,
0.0365222767,
-0.5831196904,
-0.1904713511,
-0.3398421705,
0.0313913561,
0.0166676231,
-1.0616019964,
0.5155205727,
-0.1942806095,
-0.4024736285,
-0.2289514393,
0.7747209668,
-0.963827908,
-0.3720855117,
0.112744458,
0.4570967257,
-0.0105962595,
-0.0760232881,
-0.4567019939,
-0.0962373242,
-0.0591927245,
-0.4755851626,
0.1686108261,
0.766038835,
0.1640783399,
0.7161658406,
0.3755432367,
0.3005289435,
0.1969130784,
-0.1033989042,
0.7555218339,
-0.6790220737,
-0.3091733754,
-0.9591740966,
0.7237482667,
-0.1055024117,
-0.1906445473,
0.5296394229,
0.3838934302,
0.5345157981,
0.0138724661,
0.4172128737,
0.0795436054,
0.6747580767,
-0.6760742068,
0.4970447421,
-0.3238584399,
0.0872022063,
-0.0436257124,
-0.8596590757,
-0.0895797834,
0.3599961698,
-0.1969156563,
-0.2939805388,
0.6724145412,
0.6731737256,
-0.1545611173,
-0.1670514494,
-0.0040948484,
0.7034367323,
0.1688908786,
0.295358628,
0.6119692326,
-0.3784642518,
0.3396930695,
-0.4664469659,
-0.1089276671,
-0.1153440401,
-0.7900844812,
-0.5643666983,
-0.86319381,
-0.4004883766,
-0.2747130394,
-0.3387182057,
0.800971806,
0.608397007,
-0.8264774084,
-0.2402574569,
0.0474102907,
0.1896850467,
-0.2046023607,
-0.3448957503,
0.5360622406,
-0.4149285853,
-0.5078364015,
0.1591330022,
0.3326820433,
-0.0170975551,
-0.5269445777,
0.3178142011,
-0.2889693975,
0.0444057733,
0.4952696562,
0.41455248,
-0.6423419714,
-0.3977745175,
-0.0115640266,
-0.2033603638,
0.158519879,
0.914822042,
-1.0600239038,
0.4428118765,
0.5193257332,
0.6040645838,
0.5265831351,
0.1136338487,
1.0993988514,
-0.9393802285,
0.0572886579,
0.1143827662,
0.4117369652,
0.4348472953,
-0.6274599433,
0.3478874266,
0.255975008,
-0.491240859,
-0.87289536,
0.1838670969,
-0.5796073675,
-0.0939960331,
1.1374741793,
-0.1641356945,
-0.2659992576,
0.0300352629,
-0.0402354226,
0.3312199414,
-0.1892309934,
0.7989253998,
0.6729305983,
-0.3183581531,
-0.471467942,
-0.4210016131,
0.7672610283,
0.0550623089,
-0.567450881,
0.4207063913,
0.573892653,
0.2015257925,
0.3656931221,
0.5212446451,
-0.0171621758,
-0.0753704533,
-0.3157139719,
-0.1138837263,
0.1341000497,
-0.5540980101,
-0.1706014872,
0.123952575,
-0.0976868048,
-0.1838440001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14746v1 | FlowTransformer: A Transformer Framework for Flow-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems | 2023-04-28T10:40:34 | 2023-04-28T10:40:34 | Liam Daly Manocchio, Siamak Layeghy, Wai Weng Lo, Gayan K. Kulatilleke, Mohanad Sarhan, Marius Portmann | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE, cs.NI | This paper presents the FlowTransformer framework, a novel approach for
implementing transformer-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDSs).
FlowTransformer leverages the strengths of transformer models in identifying
the long-term behaviour and characteristics of networks, which are often
overlooked by most existing NIDSs. By capturing these complex patterns in
network traffic, FlowTransformer offers a flexible and efficient tool for
researchers and practitioners in the cybersecurity community who are seeking to
implement NIDSs using transformer-based models. FlowTransformer allows the
direct substitution of various transformer components, including the input
encoding, transformer, classification head, and the evaluation of these across
any flow-based network dataset. To demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency
of the FlowTransformer framework, we utilise it to provide an extensive
evaluation of various common transformer architectures, such as GPT 2.0 and
BERT, on three commonly used public NIDS benchmark datasets. We provide results
for accuracy, model size and speed. A key finding of our evaluation is that the
choice of classification head has the most significant impact on the model
performance. Surprisingly, Global Average Pooling, which is commonly used in
text classification, performs very poorly in the context of NIDS. In addition,
we show that model size can be reduced by over 50\%, and inference and training
times improved, with no loss of accuracy, by making specific choices of input
encoding and classification head instead of other commonly used alternatives. | [
-0.2356247157,
-0.0512649529,
0.0062280898,
0.1854399741,
-0.178479895,
0.2497283965,
0.4321101308,
-0.3629797697,
0.3891835809,
0.4468617141,
-0.5230968595,
-0.0983004197,
-0.9161300659,
0.0792768598,
-0.8248434663,
0.8365525007,
-0.3892650902,
-0.1338695884,
-0.0184744019,
0.0634957552,
-0.3901161253,
-0.2716103196,
-0.7302322388,
-0.4182459712,
0.2536086142,
0.0188453328,
0.3683596551,
0.4162505567,
0.8908392787,
0.3093050122,
-0.2200012207,
0.0011139828,
-0.4386498332,
0.2894072235,
-0.3300327659,
-0.3742544055,
-0.1681671441,
-0.2739244103,
0.5048859715,
0.5603263378,
-0.1760355085,
0.1409171075,
-0.0471138731,
0.7427024245,
-0.7683746815,
0.0104124341,
-0.2753725052,
0.2371049076,
-0.4536620975,
-0.1328061521,
-0.6557508111,
-0.1135156229,
0.2636862695,
-0.2609653175,
0.1300250441,
-0.0199327376,
0.6401267052,
0.4653148949,
-0.4239830375,
-0.2011580318,
-1.1760047674,
0.2810092866,
-0.4550465941,
0.5032295585,
-0.324192822,
0.9716181755,
-0.0818356723,
-1.2071028948,
-0.5767703056,
0.4472488761,
-0.3788704574,
0.0478355736,
-0.6605502367,
-0.1905567795,
0.2845562398,
0.358673811,
-0.8444927335,
-0.0601143464,
-0.5357009172,
-0.2514593303,
0.5200941563,
0.3228469491,
0.1137361899,
0.1943230629,
-0.3234752119,
-0.0702956244,
-0.53826195,
0.4201584458,
0.4082605541,
0.3759928346,
-0.3459718525,
0.1650583297,
-0.4385590553,
0.757574141,
0.2767515182,
-0.1709250212,
0.3120181859,
0.094105646,
-0.3051715493,
-0.1665552557,
0.7508769035,
0.0342783965,
-0.0948724002,
-0.4513977468,
-0.3065882921,
-0.1291614771,
0.4316192269,
-1.3900545835,
-0.3199271262,
0.2030177265,
-0.7805373669,
-0.5506026149,
0.5441513062,
-0.8046182394,
-0.4980871081,
-0.2288547158,
0.3119588494,
-0.378102541,
-0.5926733613,
0.0178523827,
-0.6710962653,
0.5160826445,
0.3467012644,
-0.4232319891,
0.4795196056,
0.7215946913,
1.3364993334,
-0.6993576288,
-0.0009885218,
-0.6719251275,
-0.0773521885,
-0.0692106411,
0.9261038899,
-0.4688575268,
-0.3494698703,
-0.3409284055,
0.2895351052,
-0.2995947003,
-0.692008853,
0.327707082,
-0.7641693354,
0.059157107,
0.2092237175,
-0.5524138808,
-0.2479429096,
0.1804784983,
-1.0072263479,
0.4343793392,
0.3690168858,
-0.8235358596,
0.067624934,
-1.3498833179,
-0.3832299113,
0.4305210412,
0.1701898426,
-0.4126725495,
-0.1574104577,
-0.208714813,
0.5125492811,
-0.2377331406,
0.392832756,
-0.1144822091,
-0.5262977481,
0.0719271153,
-0.6530093551,
1.1048185825,
0.2345039994,
-0.5552332401,
-0.0304085631,
-0.6217481494,
-0.1602058858,
0.0904276595,
-0.0451938361,
0.0499645621,
0.0311796013,
0.2359575927,
0.1102135181,
-0.408803463,
-0.7484104633,
-0.224016279,
-0.2801663876,
0.5191685557,
0.6006202698,
-0.0018478535,
0.4679096341,
-0.2612113059,
0.761049211,
0.3137509823,
0.2240953743,
-0.0941102207,
-0.5112639666,
-0.5275020003,
-0.3338548839,
0.5382747054,
0.8276979327,
-0.990639329,
0.362567246,
-0.6864647865,
-0.738768816,
-0.1063964516,
-0.2002477795,
-0.0910899043,
0.5263239741,
0.2646117508,
-0.0414114669,
-0.3290878832,
-0.8638934493,
-0.204596296,
0.07297308,
-0.153924942,
-0.2761786282,
0.5199494958,
-0.414865762,
1.0167787075,
-0.4373512268,
0.060147509,
-0.3912254572,
0.1820888072,
0.1038727015,
0.4643014073,
0.6740350723,
-0.9180725217,
-0.5640239716,
-0.0166454688,
-0.3896685243,
0.0737028793,
0.1762222648,
-0.0621154569,
-0.2203823775,
0.5956653357,
-0.1965340674,
0.9023330808,
0.7368347049,
-0.6385963559,
0.467520833,
0.4915543199,
-0.1181428954,
-0.7726482153,
0.2438727468,
-0.1476541758,
-0.4217692912,
-1.106410861,
0.1535255313,
0.2085498869,
-0.323294878,
-0.6110643744,
0.5850813389,
-0.0314386375,
0.3384915888,
-0.2369311452,
-0.4849901795,
0.1116821095,
0.2655287981,
-0.0023943167,
0.9946735501,
0.5941994786,
-0.6630378962,
0.4531938732,
-0.147262305,
-0.1335887015,
0.9384867549,
-0.7388541102,
0.0344975814,
-0.3787832558,
0.5268509984,
-0.8071199656,
-0.0897473842,
0.4284878373,
-0.0766267031,
0.5365493298,
-0.4437274635,
0.0309888534,
-0.6205909252,
-0.1516764462,
0.4822044671,
0.2523482144,
-0.7955310345,
1.2194530964,
0.1879067123,
0.1781020015,
-0.4583645463,
-0.8764424324,
0.2753452659,
-0.3192911744,
-0.74609828,
0.5418244004,
-0.2390538454,
-0.0155993644,
-0.0668972284,
-0.1660487801,
-0.3549882174,
0.3471020162,
0.3609663546,
0.1786903441,
-0.371714294,
-0.3407096267,
-0.0455150083,
-0.3391699791,
0.2100661844,
-0.607011795,
0.4682600796,
0.0208938792,
-0.5327455401,
-0.8399187326,
0.4911488593,
0.8061151505,
-0.2292008996,
0.7155017257,
0.6443131566,
-0.306745708,
-0.4922922552,
-0.1470014602,
-0.0342224129,
-0.5311081409,
0.1545328647,
-0.4081678689,
-0.744426012,
0.496440202,
-0.3318257034,
-0.0421941392,
0.5114883184,
-0.0051912772,
-0.182725966,
0.3519804776,
0.6810983419,
0.0529821813,
0.4253766835,
-0.725766778,
0.6792883873,
-0.871863544,
-0.0974003375,
-0.355795145,
-0.7041971087,
-0.5966918468,
-0.2210571021,
0.3064346313,
-0.2628463209,
-0.1455231458,
0.3748126924,
-0.5793709159,
0.4702426195,
0.3200986683,
0.0089289136,
0.0311478227,
-0.2003417909,
0.2624106705,
0.3223296106,
-0.5504339933,
-0.4289546311,
1.2306449413,
0.385184586,
0.3997851908,
0.5069107413,
0.5273730159,
0.3894259632,
0.5888410211,
-0.8245152831,
0.1905778497,
-0.3742511272,
-0.5148931146,
-0.3412972987,
-0.2947874963,
-0.8124981523,
0.0468777567,
0.2582344711,
-0.7088546753,
0.6349048018,
0.0082947565,
-0.3924801052,
0.8429074287,
-0.6818631887,
0.7748985887,
0.2023012042,
0.1662582904,
0.3892590106,
-0.4506047964,
0.6294180155,
0.0792657286,
-0.150632143,
0.1195835844,
0.2086879462,
0.7594859004,
-0.7450754642,
0.5763257146,
-0.4715253711,
0.0936413184,
0.2829261124,
0.1903755367,
0.5125573874,
-0.1082643643,
-0.0817098841,
0.588321805,
-0.1443686485,
-0.1515747011,
-0.7520628572,
0.2360806763,
-0.3977771401,
-0.2280577421,
-0.2696700394,
-0.107144326,
0.1514084935,
0.1826740056,
0.4151650369,
0.8571580648,
-0.0433990061,
0.4189032316,
0.8969957829,
0.3019478023,
0.8378806114,
0.2077605277,
-0.0660056397,
-0.2898938656,
0.8716868758,
0.1108901724,
0.3815817833,
0.7259971499,
0.0491776653,
-0.1292599738,
-0.5940498114,
-0.6906903386,
-0.0589441769,
-0.5143406987,
-0.736987114,
-0.66145432,
-0.9610792398,
-0.258624047,
0.1152152643,
-0.2612517774,
-0.3369639814,
-0.1377516985,
0.0374793112,
0.3347411752,
0.8026251197,
0.0863701403,
0.9338404536,
-0.3072159588,
0.2805422246,
0.4366858602,
0.9641728401,
0.0832819045,
-0.6283629537,
-0.0026557725,
-0.3053206205,
-0.4380120635,
-0.8901091814,
0.2564741969,
0.0702234954,
0.4966328144,
0.7021169066,
0.0402280837,
0.3356935084,
-0.5347088575,
0.7682020664,
-0.0005650627,
-1.0155160427,
0.3390651047,
0.1373513937,
0.1652210802,
0.3791569173,
0.2430064678,
-0.7894886732,
-0.0005777359,
-0.4335390031,
-0.558264792,
0.8042731881,
0.4537207782,
-0.1097240746,
0.4457580447,
0.1872962117,
0.0245164223,
-0.0550711229,
-0.4304565489,
-0.6801587343,
-0.4908336997,
-0.2342073768,
0.1985586584,
0.0290490929,
0.0822892115,
-0.0441952683,
0.7478574514,
-0.2007482797,
0.5612853169,
0.067134209,
-0.0355879776,
0.2683705091,
-0.0812736303,
0.6530950069,
0.459915489,
0.0347408913,
-0.0366324186,
0.0651522651,
-0.9505618811,
0.2852413952,
0.1129593998,
-0.5790668726,
0.4720803797,
0.2894816101,
0.9282304645,
-0.4393300414,
-0.4314574301,
0.9265288115,
-0.5310010314,
-0.3147395849,
-0.1412394941,
0.3769426346,
0.0921594873,
0.1375355124,
0.3886531591,
0.6079586744,
0.5659269094,
0.1170969009,
-0.0653640851,
0.4891197085,
-0.5287927389,
-0.3556463122,
0.4136702418,
0.2045728564,
-0.7785935998,
0.2108929604,
-0.6244198084,
-0.5846098661,
0.5014511943,
0.4433166981,
1.3868557215,
-0.4797888994,
0.171044305,
0.1298310757,
0.31425035,
0.0129549708,
0.0608710796,
-0.0024969927,
-0.7099848986,
-0.4184017479,
-0.5233433247,
-0.3377762139,
0.4860946536,
-0.5054956079,
0.4896846116,
-0.4983243644,
-0.033669658,
0.0732200071,
-0.6424455643,
-0.8980599642,
-0.0409953743,
0.2168320417,
1.2822540998,
-0.8262624145,
0.2476427704,
0.5293258429,
0.2906875014,
-0.7847406864,
0.0830741376,
0.3190634251,
-0.2013606578,
0.5785021186,
0.2525839806,
-0.3848332763,
-0.1563930959,
-0.4259483218,
-1.0912547112,
1.2982392311,
0.2744581103,
-0.3628225029,
0.0987816453,
0.2344259024,
0.0730568394,
-0.2668406963,
0.6014084816,
0.5293633938,
0.4243071973,
0.2334811836,
-0.8401623368,
-0.1272733808,
-0.5809749961,
0.2316552252,
0.3004676998,
-0.3848482072,
0.6392899752,
0.3374263942,
-0.4403931201,
-0.3600831926,
0.5885030031,
-0.204509899,
0.260179311,
0.7181325555,
0.3936497867,
0.7739392519,
-0.1994733959,
0.6630225778,
-0.2143962979,
-0.0458621904,
0.9862082601,
-0.1255934089,
0.7125139832,
0.3106977344,
-0.3453769386,
1.1085698605,
0.133526206,
0.1714473218,
0.4376174808,
0.2199631482,
-0.0325944945,
0.2233492285,
0.2380910665,
-0.1083512977,
0.6476333737,
0.2376707643,
-0.1507244706,
-0.4535364807,
0.1535717696,
-0.1616989523,
-0.2694018781,
-0.2253030837,
0.6829422712,
-0.35358271,
-0.1602322757,
0.2441385984,
0.2279631197,
0.9893769622,
-0.4926170707,
0.1846344173,
-0.2625050545,
0.0638682395,
-0.2479469031,
-0.7464903593,
0.8354035616,
0.2344490588,
-0.3831681311,
-0.3348204792,
0.6814507842,
0.2019297183,
-0.6028051376,
0.0021211798,
0.1848624498,
0.1209678501,
-0.2875861228,
-0.3625575602,
-0.0759990439,
-0.0763691589,
0.0239704754,
-0.116642125,
0.645149529,
0.090225324,
0.7134400606,
0.5737784505,
0.2277359664,
-0.0351676159,
0.065397881,
0.706253469,
-0.4741522372,
-0.8702017069,
-0.5990131497,
0.7203822136,
-0.540515244,
-0.2598204315,
0.1112609878,
0.5564911962,
0.7425947785,
0.0424484499,
0.8023078442,
-0.0991708785,
0.6923663616,
-0.1851728112,
0.6887695193,
0.0329164006,
0.3317736685,
0.0125534767,
-0.6391776204,
-0.1734402031,
0.2647072375,
-0.0442507826,
-0.1869425774,
0.6310793757,
0.7226258516,
-0.519998312,
0.4742130935,
-0.0193512589,
-0.1310971677,
0.7407227755,
0.1859083027,
0.6339929104,
-0.7784438133,
0.3920055926,
-0.379171133,
-0.2728050053,
-0.1590258628,
-0.9890479445,
-0.7198283076,
-0.4709620774,
-0.4257689416,
-0.1593714207,
-0.172347337,
0.7105318308,
0.9434332252,
-1.1388045549,
-0.1458078325,
-0.1114643589,
0.1796227992,
-0.2990902662,
-0.3335863352,
0.0255314391,
-0.1902436316,
-0.4899585843,
0.2932726145,
0.3870639205,
0.2596404552,
-0.4181381762,
-0.0001874084,
0.2837654054,
-0.0783917531,
0.4775567949,
0.0457658097,
-0.3587595522,
-0.0497950874,
0.0291298591,
0.1185681894,
0.0113326441,
0.8729934692,
-0.9252745509,
0.0524546169,
0.5809553266,
0.8844133615,
0.243780762,
-0.1773706675,
0.4299022555,
-0.4130178988,
0.0738061443,
0.2068971843,
0.3469502628,
0.3316465616,
-0.4849104583,
0.441647917,
0.437038362,
-0.1438980699,
-0.924225688,
0.0835187435,
-0.6026759744,
-0.2328738123,
0.7994493246,
-0.089527972,
-0.3329027295,
-0.3180699944,
0.2228574455,
-0.1414205581,
-0.0840957835,
0.2694200575,
0.3995245695,
-0.1226564348,
0.153039068,
-0.2635279,
0.4070805311,
-0.3748553395,
-0.7734677196,
0.0483716018,
-0.068701379,
0.4473654628,
0.4377509356,
0.2522502542,
0.1291617304,
0.1208016723,
-0.1289079189,
-0.0252559371,
-0.0574987382,
-0.5853685737,
-0.5473651886,
0.195366472,
-0.6232248545,
-0.2356787324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14745v1 | Made of Steel? Learning Plausible Materials for Components in the Vehicle Repair Domain | 2023-04-28T10:39:44 | 2023-04-28T10:39:44 | Annerose Eichel, Helena Schlipf, Sabine Schulte im Walde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | We propose a novel approach to learn domain-specific plausible materials for
components in the vehicle repair domain by probing Pretrained Language Models
(PLMs) in a cloze task style setting to overcome the lack of annotated
datasets. We devise a new method to aggregate salient predictions from a set of
cloze query templates and show that domain-adaptation using either a small,
high-quality or a customized Wikipedia corpus boosts performance. When
exploring resource-lean alternatives, we find a distilled PLM clearly
outperforming a classic pattern-based algorithm. Further, given that 98% of our
domain-specific components are multiword expressions, we successfully exploit
the compositionality assumption as a way to address data sparsity. | [
-0.4125896692,
-0.7615166306,
0.6414337158,
-0.1703014523,
-0.2176882327,
0.2789618969,
-0.1885963976,
-0.1901855022,
0.110841997,
0.2316104025,
-0.828707695,
-0.2725172937,
-0.157243371,
-0.156142503,
0.0239061564,
1.0806823969,
-0.0094662579,
0.0002564549,
-0.228614524,
-0.0051455125,
-0.6180166006,
-0.2925289869,
-0.365388006,
-0.1252103597,
0.5655401349,
0.268679589,
0.850276351,
0.7851917148,
0.3765201867,
0.3491891325,
0.3378352523,
0.4130246341,
-0.410590291,
0.0565925762,
-0.7747711539,
-0.4215524793,
-0.5137588382,
0.1891675591,
0.0349089988,
0.6881052256,
0.1332898736,
-0.1079687998,
0.3960189521,
0.5599781871,
-0.8236988783,
0.1322547942,
-0.9154239297,
-0.2326356322,
-0.1957987696,
-0.1684223264,
-0.5033894181,
0.0523909703,
0.0753647536,
-0.8098964095,
0.5027455091,
0.2276569456,
0.7414146066,
0.4138783813,
-0.2031716406,
-0.4541915953,
-0.5245935917,
0.8786116242,
-0.4861088097,
0.5888516903,
0.4555653036,
0.0546048135,
-0.3732904792,
-1.0023851395,
-0.8226073384,
0.0246618986,
-0.1171208844,
0.1451830268,
0.380856365,
0.1069119796,
0.0076545905,
0.4456091523,
-0.8212983012,
-0.0605566874,
-0.3027724028,
-0.3236897588,
0.7318950891,
0.1201567724,
0.4434786141,
0.099731043,
-0.6922592521,
-0.2765226662,
-0.4654167891,
-0.2157132328,
-0.1009024456,
0.3877239525,
-0.0948315412,
0.3222037554,
-0.0932839438,
0.7688035965,
0.0148156909,
-0.4293397069,
0.3298587799,
-0.4657026827,
-0.4433999062,
0.0593622848,
0.5428194404,
0.4324756563,
-0.0749411881,
-0.5918439031,
-0.1228799149,
0.0211580079,
0.3946096599,
-0.5584713817,
-0.537394464,
0.3346307874,
-0.346755892,
0.0101544317,
0.1957932562,
-0.6301268935,
-0.6157823205,
-0.6031460166,
0.2987275422,
-0.5048884153,
-0.2784679234,
0.2704486549,
-0.2956300676,
0.1597121954,
0.1251559556,
-0.6907281876,
-0.1724003702,
0.6280047894,
0.9266084433,
-0.0315557346,
-0.4674830735,
-0.5485084057,
0.1487271041,
-0.2586817145,
1.1298689842,
-0.3046314418,
-0.4380028248,
0.1025863662,
0.3146124482,
-0.1652605832,
-0.5462172031,
0.4717140198,
-0.5722222328,
0.2563923597,
-0.4535985887,
-0.5477787256,
-0.3360410929,
-0.0005075155,
-0.9038827419,
0.8581232429,
0.6998382211,
-0.6347955465,
0.6905217767,
-0.3926522136,
-0.8707927465,
0.0312671922,
0.1502487212,
-0.5064789653,
0.2625815272,
-0.2227359116,
0.6978075504,
-0.2048081756,
0.017395759,
-0.7670291662,
0.0748126209,
0.5309156179,
-0.1326204985,
0.4331489801,
0.3753246963,
-0.4013193846,
-0.0959694758,
-0.8011460304,
0.071313329,
-0.206404537,
-0.0951245129,
-0.5498543382,
-0.0885605589,
0.0934066549,
0.1866173446,
0.4876941741,
-0.4890536964,
-0.0322623588,
-0.7291167974,
0.3075323105,
0.8891058564,
-0.1264755577,
0.7039594054,
-0.5420454144,
0.3363361657,
-0.0445866622,
-0.1522518843,
-0.1307269484,
-0.0282320473,
-0.8836246133,
-0.4768407643,
0.1827652752,
0.3599327803,
-1.0760723352,
0.1156263128,
0.1619210988,
-0.5746625662,
-0.2723994255,
0.2448010594,
0.3643936515,
0.5100441575,
0.2988216579,
-0.4774703681,
-0.545225203,
-0.7287101746,
-0.1901354492,
-0.0605989397,
-0.0044011828,
0.0716076195,
0.3596642017,
-0.0352922082,
1.1156176329,
-0.8622649312,
-0.3562390804,
-0.1645557731,
0.2160743475,
0.040069703,
0.3307789862,
0.7261568308,
-0.8877863288,
-0.820995748,
0.2037052512,
-0.7813846469,
0.2175887525,
0.0268526766,
-0.1166881621,
0.1185880899,
0.495418936,
-0.6649080515,
0.2398839742,
0.3395678103,
-0.2974914908,
0.4773463011,
-0.1580387801,
0.1630953699,
-1.2818881273,
-0.0573859997,
0.056405656,
-0.348713398,
-0.8338344693,
-0.2859768569,
-0.099157244,
-0.3246161342,
-0.5492987633,
0.7025322914,
-0.5790183544,
-0.0905744731,
-0.7132645249,
0.0674543679,
0.2949698865,
0.573399961,
-0.0093490761,
1.1072247028,
0.4401700199,
-0.787876904,
0.37398386,
0.2073373944,
-0.3554151356,
0.4689948559,
-0.6828058958,
0.1571760774,
-0.3990379274,
-0.2809237242,
-1.0223059654,
-0.4274283648,
0.0072453916,
-0.1411681026,
0.551051259,
0.0431174338,
-0.3794718385,
0.0934292674,
-0.1529022455,
0.2454242855,
0.1625111848,
-0.3949632049,
0.8042538762,
0.5853741169,
-0.6493864059,
-0.5092728734,
-0.2373881638,
-0.3632090688,
-0.3038940132,
-0.7394703627,
0.6438071728,
-0.4984913766,
-0.2919763923,
0.0217027795,
-0.2220804542,
-0.7208209038,
0.636500001,
0.2054681629,
0.1814529002,
-0.2867341638,
0.2472125441,
-0.2486829609,
0.1680656821,
-0.2050256133,
-0.0617604926,
0.7889438272,
-0.137935698,
-0.0236346275,
-0.0977551192,
0.1302973479,
0.6440683603,
-0.354963094,
0.6149360538,
0.53355515,
-0.2733083665,
-0.8365618587,
-0.4114400148,
-0.4229660332,
-0.5823708177,
0.6760520339,
-0.385376513,
-0.5520721078,
0.4038443863,
-0.2996772528,
0.0225983784,
0.3470664024,
0.4956022799,
-0.4390065968,
0.6243724227,
0.859583497,
-0.2150409371,
0.3554849625,
-0.108722046,
0.2967376411,
-0.3033662438,
-0.1348585486,
-0.4318707585,
-0.1336385757,
-0.4859728813,
-0.5079829693,
0.3019209802,
0.1803438663,
-0.0873466283,
0.5096370578,
-0.3367789984,
0.6072669625,
0.395729363,
0.4145802259,
0.0741824657,
0.0754212663,
0.1142668799,
0.0918236747,
-0.9394800663,
-0.3801231384,
0.8177552223,
0.2211773247,
0.5752904415,
-0.1743635684,
0.2589014173,
0.6404107809,
0.360435605,
-0.7132737637,
0.2689027488,
-0.3787727356,
-0.8218604922,
-0.2085821927,
-0.1284630895,
-0.8248189688,
0.0091217766,
-0.1553096771,
-0.0905559137,
0.359534204,
0.1600539386,
-0.4240826964,
0.1357514113,
-0.621627748,
1.0181796551,
-0.547068119,
-0.4673614502,
-0.1596013904,
-0.2588750124,
0.178305909,
-0.1429640055,
0.4940683544,
-0.1086777523,
0.2244805247,
0.5523040891,
-0.5470163822,
0.9113875031,
-0.1021996439,
-0.0273614489,
0.3385790586,
-0.0746043772,
0.3271916509,
-0.0356689952,
-0.1681718081,
-0.193701759,
-0.3743973076,
-0.3601236939,
-0.9016307592,
0.3864345253,
-0.5184256434,
-0.3685084879,
-0.5339887738,
-0.7190349698,
-0.4584964514,
0.35926193,
0.3555645049,
0.6379979253,
-0.2611121833,
0.2002873123,
0.9048961997,
-0.0873162597,
0.7028023601,
0.6757813096,
0.5821300149,
-0.3868804276,
1.0880151987,
0.0904562771,
-0.0053549069,
0.3955412209,
-0.2106218189,
-0.3152249157,
-0.5556551814,
-0.3191570938,
0.4258091152,
-0.6830582023,
-0.3607599735,
-0.0217366945,
-0.0508089624,
-0.1753649116,
-0.5868592262,
-0.6479227543,
-0.2832163572,
-0.4965762198,
-0.2392971963,
0.1296728998,
0.7375978827,
0.2510543168,
0.5453683734,
-0.8466754556,
-0.0107171815,
0.1164238378,
0.5944223404,
-0.2235857993,
-0.3513638377,
-0.7590375543,
0.1442856193,
-0.3840151131,
-0.6309382319,
0.3486163616,
0.5028574467,
0.7452190518,
0.292471379,
0.4260872602,
0.4344436228,
-0.609141767,
0.8363498449,
0.5087787509,
-0.7599983811,
0.3622907698,
-0.2468459606,
-0.2595230639,
0.584692657,
0.799895525,
0.0781710595,
-0.1546445191,
-0.5547983646,
-0.6979340911,
0.3408956826,
-0.3239145577,
-0.044816833,
-0.0782059208,
0.2352316678,
0.1915772259,
0.2904093266,
-0.5954431295,
-0.3121282756,
-0.4710968435,
-0.5723566413,
-0.0622179843,
-0.2746162415,
-0.0230213702,
0.4739518762,
0.9063425064,
-0.2629832327,
0.1304012835,
0.2887122929,
-0.5464134812,
0.4443206787,
0.2400534898,
0.7796552777,
0.8395098448,
-0.1055458635,
0.0477944985,
-0.0719138905,
-0.3317451179,
0.089227654,
0.0239935648,
0.0529978238,
0.347353518,
0.3343867958,
0.9015715718,
0.1116846874,
-0.7543349266,
0.2865620852,
0.2844176292,
-0.1206402257,
-0.3005833328,
0.1139632463,
-0.2201632857,
0.3488866985,
0.3324364126,
-0.0378714949,
0.1772521883,
-0.8307671547,
0.6230821609,
0.4107026458,
-0.5182029605,
-0.6539931297,
0.6625561118,
0.3542841971,
0.0050891461,
0.224135533,
-0.3067499697,
-0.6487793922,
0.2988460362,
0.1826868206,
0.7239971757,
-0.3299522102,
0.1907872707,
0.2610806227,
0.230122149,
-0.1307213157,
0.1280570775,
0.234933272,
-1.0254878998,
-0.4692732394,
-0.5274884701,
-0.0985980704,
0.3279044032,
-0.3177339733,
0.2341242433,
-0.7086715698,
-0.3782043457,
-0.0946322381,
-0.0104352832,
-0.6441797018,
0.6353735328,
-0.250426054,
0.7222137451,
-0.9717943072,
0.6361792088,
0.6736443043,
-0.7897959948,
-0.7204371691,
-0.2039600164,
-0.273268491,
-0.6058955789,
0.8820305467,
-0.1581950039,
0.0340067632,
-0.2804725468,
-0.2036684901,
-0.7411048412,
0.8271996975,
0.5055205226,
-0.2758508623,
-0.2953122258,
0.2990059853,
-0.154224515,
-0.2396408319,
-0.0123468051,
0.381338954,
0.2404786497,
-0.4704667926,
-1.0508590937,
0.055492904,
-0.2644052804,
-0.2260448933,
-0.0160222296,
-0.8359801769,
0.8736789823,
0.1931425184,
-0.1593192369,
-0.0364280827,
0.9191142321,
0.0869878754,
0.6964630485,
0.4554842114,
0.5189483762,
1.0537090302,
-0.0272027124,
1.0026984215,
-0.4830399454,
0.2534512281,
1.2910411358,
-0.4598410726,
0.4169398844,
0.1444195956,
-0.0146984998,
0.6904675961,
0.5502381325,
0.0989934802,
0.9759565592,
-0.2006126642,
-0.4936511815,
-0.3013355434,
-0.2203064859,
-0.3856397569,
0.6395588517,
0.3075736165,
-0.3629274666,
-0.1166152954,
0.2031501234,
0.0619061701,
0.3149505854,
-0.3852019608,
0.8580169082,
0.1608786136,
-0.449739635,
0.5975709558,
0.0128260171,
0.3577603102,
-0.5728397369,
0.0324494801,
-0.2613274455,
0.2609665096,
-0.279094696,
-0.4324331582,
0.3668566942,
-0.3954939842,
-0.8145879507,
-0.2023563534,
0.9874925613,
-0.4796915352,
-0.3669889271,
-0.2387434691,
0.3605877757,
-0.2583329976,
-0.0671259612,
-0.4103995562,
0.0469505079,
0.151373744,
-0.1015592963,
0.6565659642,
0.6128866673,
0.2283411622,
0.6041843295,
0.5117197037,
0.00490171,
-0.0954715461,
-0.4637077153,
0.927842617,
-0.3560925722,
-0.3254223764,
-0.5388495922,
1.0526272058,
-0.2535544038,
-0.1176051125,
0.9398386478,
0.776448071,
1.0092190504,
-0.4979568422,
1.3193298578,
0.124281995,
0.6808086038,
-0.885002315,
0.6045299172,
-0.5489341617,
0.0962048098,
-0.1371081322,
-0.6866530776,
0.070275858,
0.8592925668,
0.0641446188,
-0.0569428839,
0.7976109982,
0.8202081919,
-0.2032031417,
-0.001635069,
0.2563616335,
0.2154080421,
0.0397686958,
0.1747023314,
0.4834730029,
-0.4283011556,
0.3325214684,
-0.1864261478,
-0.1705154777,
0.0361925326,
-0.9458385706,
-0.7577757835,
-0.7232595682,
-0.5719922185,
-0.4688885808,
-0.0666574612,
0.7631707191,
0.8969119787,
-0.818833828,
-0.1691577435,
0.0438660011,
0.1702219099,
-0.139593184,
-0.1719927937,
0.4580702186,
-0.787471056,
-0.6280439496,
0.8724709153,
0.0005730314,
-0.1243564039,
0.1417020857,
0.0269404203,
0.2524652183,
-0.0766929761,
0.841468811,
0.2081493735,
-0.1974914521,
-0.360927552,
0.301771611,
0.2176072747,
-0.1458457857,
1.0855172873,
-0.475884378,
0.240994826,
0.4778912663,
0.9170357585,
0.2678644061,
0.0568441451,
1.0347710848,
-0.9323942661,
0.2893593907,
0.0899868608,
0.6213971376,
0.3783315122,
-0.25977844,
0.4022469521,
0.6175747514,
-0.6040745974,
-0.7405649424,
0.4730427861,
-0.8468443155,
-0.7761266828,
0.9039370418,
-0.2842030525,
-0.3352769613,
-0.5512073636,
0.1263625771,
0.3620231152,
-0.1046349928,
0.7513304353,
0.5880420208,
0.3211616576,
-0.0068357363,
-0.2982378304,
0.772416234,
0.2275592387,
-0.5966555476,
0.0726938322,
0.5406666994,
0.5583488345,
0.2421325594,
0.5111643076,
0.3768358529,
0.342610687,
-0.1240817755,
-0.0718605816,
-0.1556490511,
-0.4786931872,
0.3140151203,
0.4949414134,
0.2938245833,
0.0800950676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14738v1 | Cost-Sensitive Self-Training for Optimizing Non-Decomposable Metrics | 2023-04-28T10:31:12 | 2023-04-28T10:31:12 | Harsh Rangwani, Shrinivas Ramasubramanian, Sho Takemori, Kato Takashi, Yuhei Umeda, Venkatesh Babu Radhakrishnan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Self-training based semi-supervised learning algorithms have enabled the
learning of highly accurate deep neural networks, using only a fraction of
labeled data. However, the majority of work on self-training has focused on the
objective of improving accuracy, whereas practical machine learning systems can
have complex goals (e.g. maximizing the minimum of recall across classes, etc.)
that are non-decomposable in nature. In this work, we introduce the
Cost-Sensitive Self-Training (CSST) framework which generalizes the
self-training-based methods for optimizing non-decomposable metrics. We prove
that our framework can better optimize the desired non-decomposable metric
utilizing unlabeled data, under similar data distribution assumptions made for
the analysis of self-training. Using the proposed CSST framework, we obtain
practical self-training methods (for both vision and NLP tasks) for optimizing
different non-decomposable metrics using deep neural networks. Our results
demonstrate that CSST achieves an improvement over the state-of-the-art in
majority of the cases across datasets and objectives. | [
0.044077117,
-0.1900532097,
0.0379884951,
0.1273327619,
-0.0425729677,
0.0788042322,
-0.1896465868,
-0.2715049386,
0.0633915737,
0.1012781709,
-0.6349210143,
-0.3784576654,
-0.1854238808,
-0.1112132445,
-0.2939173281,
0.8961312771,
0.1642465442,
-0.0084971441,
-0.2279154062,
-0.4287002981,
-0.2500161529,
-0.7005237937,
-0.5202448368,
0.1315502971,
0.4914784431,
0.3909146488,
0.2799680233,
0.7584620118,
0.6065412164,
0.253444761,
0.226864785,
0.1264233291,
-0.3856267333,
-0.0119908676,
-0.3065714836,
-0.3949702084,
-0.249459058,
-0.0113530252,
0.3128147721,
0.6192122102,
-0.1199206561,
0.6674932837,
0.4347297549,
1.0021833181,
-1.1860837936,
0.2487512976,
-0.4499469101,
0.5693680644,
0.1080522835,
-0.1803619564,
-0.1909402013,
-0.0936835259,
0.0245944317,
-0.4683988392,
0.6657523513,
-0.4831420481,
0.517234385,
0.7879233956,
-0.2095790505,
0.0058715423,
-0.5360088348,
0.9222152829,
-0.4765728414,
0.5436053276,
0.1971265525,
0.1705269516,
0.3026206493,
-0.4515305758,
0.1406407654,
-0.126836583,
0.0656797513,
0.5872120857,
-0.3863733113,
0.0151694259,
0.2334993333,
0.3128432035,
-0.5859085321,
0.3491089046,
-0.1395549774,
-0.4233130515,
0.5564303994,
0.230585888,
-0.1901231259,
-0.0692298263,
-0.7786466479,
-0.0282485876,
-0.2102446109,
0.0362000577,
0.1537191719,
0.4467190206,
-0.1943279803,
0.3105323613,
-0.5339332819,
0.4089416862,
0.320956856,
-0.0672733933,
0.4466281235,
-0.2766112387,
-0.1807824671,
0.0315189064,
0.4424293637,
0.4447250962,
0.181231916,
-0.4099436998,
-0.2323875129,
0.1893310249,
0.1517386585,
-0.6742566824,
-0.6700083017,
0.0373039395,
-0.5462425351,
-0.4080789089,
-0.5933155417,
-0.5370618701,
-0.0264006946,
-0.4532365501,
0.26671803,
-0.0800267607,
-0.2443784326,
0.0308541469,
0.0984847769,
0.0104949242,
0.1851476878,
-1.03490448,
0.1176918074,
0.0707606971,
1.011792779,
-0.2584996819,
-0.1671281308,
-0.2281743437,
0.1601516306,
-0.4994167387,
0.6442532539,
0.0882297605,
-0.2098355591,
-0.2561835051,
-0.3523370326,
-0.0885539353,
-0.4635889232,
0.2755853236,
-0.1591691673,
-0.2309075743,
-0.1934518516,
-0.5112497211,
0.0317553245,
0.502147913,
-0.5478594303,
1.0930060148,
0.3709961474,
-0.7776376009,
0.4002090693,
-0.8423270583,
-0.4204218984,
0.090103969,
0.1332298517,
-0.8077206612,
0.311624229,
0.2148124278,
0.6119791865,
0.0490728207,
0.1250973344,
-0.5477519035,
0.0482940041,
0.1342944354,
-0.8061637282,
0.6021715403,
0.454131335,
-0.5393943787,
-0.1434253752,
-0.9642007351,
0.3646996021,
0.1494542658,
-0.4443318248,
-0.1964739859,
-0.1184577495,
-0.1107808426,
0.121515438,
0.4186362326,
-0.5574583411,
-0.219544515,
-0.4113281369,
0.4890412688,
0.9423397183,
-0.1341578811,
0.5004807711,
0.0189179741,
0.4509698749,
-0.1114767939,
0.4620570838,
0.2161993533,
0.3708277345,
-0.8617928028,
-0.4603768289,
0.3119896054,
0.4951922894,
-0.4818394482,
0.4292998314,
0.1368821561,
-0.605024159,
-0.2735945284,
0.0945785269,
0.5289937258,
0.9675770998,
0.6379919648,
-0.1699059308,
-0.2855801582,
-0.9228630066,
-0.4547589123,
0.0054848325,
0.1766661704,
0.3508711457,
0.2910918891,
0.2561246157,
1.0678089857,
-0.535430491,
-0.7281051874,
0.1150950044,
0.0247960873,
-0.1759477705,
0.6604725718,
0.6457015276,
-0.6298685074,
-0.4814530909,
-0.2549209595,
-0.7470768094,
-0.0552621298,
-0.4304626882,
0.1690503806,
0.3075093925,
0.5040333867,
0.0557705201,
0.6833956242,
0.617972374,
0.035885945,
0.4799976051,
-0.5437422395,
-0.2677767873,
-0.7807005644,
0.255124867,
0.2671562135,
-0.334036231,
-0.4106552303,
-0.2095771283,
0.3398929834,
-0.1859255284,
-0.6499748826,
0.2082840055,
-0.5082856417,
-0.2895849049,
-0.2452818155,
-0.2992679179,
-0.063819319,
0.8056670427,
0.2894791663,
0.874247551,
0.510809958,
-0.7644047737,
0.1743835807,
0.1943270117,
-0.305775851,
0.6387488842,
-0.5698513389,
0.0441409051,
0.0990313143,
-0.0404893905,
-0.6363319159,
0.3300586045,
0.2387353033,
-0.3817164302,
0.1888255179,
-0.2519139051,
-0.2713862062,
-0.1950965524,
-0.1009074152,
0.5140163302,
0.2554174066,
-0.8682457209,
0.3026492596,
0.2480563074,
0.5065761805,
-0.7916834354,
-0.8454775214,
-0.0994793624,
-0.3106074333,
0.0119646415,
0.1244645193,
-0.1245430037,
0.4997453392,
-0.0322380364,
-0.4636902809,
-0.1242597848,
0.4671600461,
0.0512718931,
0.1618212909,
-0.1571577489,
0.3807408512,
-0.0946796536,
-0.6565420032,
0.2071277648,
-0.704711318,
0.0214657821,
-0.3316487074,
-0.4176996648,
-0.5851271152,
0.1585238874,
-0.1343794018,
-0.520093441,
0.3032220006,
0.5121968985,
-0.2206833959,
-0.3366847038,
-0.3946807086,
-0.0559368134,
-0.5226314664,
0.5302856565,
-0.5460750461,
-0.8485378027,
0.1393749416,
-0.4153183699,
0.1578047574,
0.5022552013,
0.531147182,
-0.444026053,
0.8639370203,
0.5507608056,
-0.0116712414,
0.3682555556,
-0.5814119577,
0.1651792079,
-0.7651027441,
-0.1309160888,
-0.5360656381,
-0.6272024512,
-0.5509707332,
-0.1610537618,
0.2920349538,
-0.267647624,
-0.4127816558,
0.3932926357,
-0.9955486655,
0.6694911718,
0.7415784597,
0.3233444691,
-0.0049401936,
0.0525324531,
0.2270512283,
-0.1485436559,
-0.926956296,
-0.0056716064,
1.0218799114,
0.2837531865,
0.8813170791,
-0.2787857354,
0.7159834504,
0.4866630137,
-0.2101160735,
-0.7094703317,
0.3439571261,
-0.4215556979,
-0.6662876606,
-0.3821425438,
-0.7974742055,
-0.8228079677,
0.1276548803,
-0.0383709706,
-0.4334669113,
0.7865607142,
0.7858485579,
-0.2708703279,
0.5325305462,
-0.6293087006,
0.915133357,
-0.7175927162,
-0.2237889171,
-0.1322074682,
-0.727140069,
-0.2232972533,
-0.2667593658,
-0.1302289218,
-0.5126596093,
-0.2580824196,
0.7060366273,
-0.1573323011,
1.2141768932,
-0.5071049333,
0.2689835429,
0.2297446132,
0.296095103,
0.2446875125,
-0.1258333921,
0.0743129775,
0.5500297546,
0.0482789651,
-0.6832133532,
-0.5630981922,
0.4019648731,
-0.7643218637,
-0.1628763676,
-0.5209922791,
-0.5306355953,
-0.3695714772,
0.1145927235,
0.3098568022,
0.4835006893,
-0.2018633634,
0.1716977507,
0.70265764,
0.0660096407,
0.6041824222,
0.4014793038,
0.6981142163,
-0.4875859916,
1.1162064075,
0.1783364415,
0.5792160034,
0.5683293343,
0.4825644195,
-0.6420072913,
-0.5551853776,
-0.1702707261,
-0.1798018515,
-0.7827910185,
-0.6008796692,
-0.4511471391,
-0.1081560254,
-0.2564299107,
-0.4428944886,
-0.8753294945,
-0.6109319925,
-0.6060708165,
-0.3246248066,
0.0981506854,
0.0332825594,
-0.8276138306,
0.2316949219,
-0.4042983055,
0.0362799428,
0.2536291182,
0.3523026109,
-0.0262068044,
-0.5304580927,
-0.4557040036,
0.1364925802,
-0.1365415305,
-0.2779147327,
0.3662624061,
0.3099393845,
0.4318839312,
0.3808312416,
0.6089417338,
0.6966196895,
-0.0542016067,
0.3553269804,
0.656488061,
-0.9263887405,
0.5502445698,
-0.0685100183,
0.3368225098,
0.9117237926,
0.0838802904,
-0.3284013569,
-0.1116977185,
-0.5482760072,
-0.6933429241,
0.7022787929,
0.124370873,
0.5160661936,
0.2041745782,
0.3176356554,
0.0488094278,
-0.0869071111,
-0.7854221463,
-0.2406506836,
-0.6991426349,
-0.3160709739,
-0.0271377191,
-0.0826684013,
-0.0579553954,
-0.2764049172,
0.5719008446,
-0.6541557312,
0.2097627521,
0.3591364324,
-0.2548732758,
0.3714165986,
-0.0128720934,
0.1339202225,
0.4126908779,
-0.145280093,
0.2295984626,
0.5081837177,
-0.4238508344,
0.2934996784,
-0.3524542451,
-0.2134971172,
-0.3232856393,
0.0605994277,
0.6864414811,
0.2129351199,
-0.2821364403,
0.5707303882,
-0.0494046658,
-0.5515645146,
-0.5258752108,
0.0341343097,
-0.0648970827,
0.3098158836,
-0.0106152054,
0.4332348704,
0.3715780079,
0.1740419865,
0.2122866064,
0.4278227389,
-0.677636981,
0.0128053622,
0.7193555832,
0.340215534,
-0.0847815573,
0.6972426772,
-0.0037060264,
-0.3611053228,
0.7095574737,
0.7031136155,
1.070933342,
-0.1367173642,
0.3743277788,
0.478302151,
0.2678180039,
0.2404317558,
0.0579647496,
-0.5624619126,
-0.5594626665,
-0.1584354192,
-0.4178514183,
-0.2355640382,
-0.2388769984,
-0.7641647458,
0.0996755585,
-0.6897847056,
-0.0842700154,
-0.0586762913,
-0.0271098353,
-0.7809752822,
0.6269901395,
-0.1422134489,
0.7498966455,
-0.6826694608,
0.4009591043,
0.23433505,
-0.2666695118,
-0.9062986374,
-0.3422658741,
-0.2096245289,
-1.006657362,
0.5164412856,
0.0496554561,
-0.3966712058,
0.2202168852,
-0.4158299267,
-0.9707003832,
0.9188925624,
0.7032828927,
-0.638114512,
0.0353075378,
0.3315345645,
0.3535534143,
-0.0744682178,
-0.0216504,
0.3555082381,
0.174070254,
0.0785708353,
-0.5732626915,
-0.1471007019,
0.0121654784,
-0.0257798191,
0.2770634592,
-0.9317055345,
0.225883618,
-0.2817751169,
-0.1634294689,
-0.1968043,
0.5526539683,
-0.2685000598,
0.5090773106,
0.6428655982,
0.6348219514,
0.5842579603,
0.116500929,
0.5942585468,
-0.2077223063,
0.7298279405,
1.2258911133,
0.1136791706,
0.4596406221,
0.0984500647,
-0.2894355655,
-0.0592055172,
0.869337678,
-0.5268999338,
0.7619416714,
0.1863701791,
-0.2144776583,
-0.635402143,
-0.0098242052,
-0.279217273,
0.660243392,
-0.0132962381,
-0.2979513407,
-0.4385347664,
0.1473166645,
-0.0702639371,
-0.0376684852,
-0.245380491,
1.018337369,
0.0702616423,
-0.0585702695,
0.5824375749,
-0.2078919858,
0.3896146715,
-0.5625766516,
0.3398932219,
-0.3081633449,
0.5381860137,
-0.4181816578,
-0.4100877643,
0.395028919,
-0.0720344707,
-0.2140264064,
-0.3431901634,
0.845731616,
0.0668145493,
-0.6297600865,
0.2408391833,
0.4274851978,
0.255166471,
-0.1728937924,
-1.1665519476,
-0.5750147104,
0.0976908579,
-0.0544720441,
0.4269440472,
0.1328570992,
0.1716946959,
0.7153494954,
0.7684345245,
-0.1391329765,
-0.022604363,
-0.0329768099,
0.6467764378,
-0.5896103978,
-0.7960012555,
-0.7285960317,
0.3961045742,
-0.0711810812,
-0.4398826063,
0.5651137829,
0.8537064195,
0.9579014778,
-0.0255578663,
0.6988366842,
0.2741088271,
0.6314083934,
-0.3605709076,
0.6488018632,
-0.7649378777,
-0.0882416815,
-0.2006443888,
-0.8415799141,
-0.4288884997,
0.5925372243,
-0.1092083529,
0.1321301758,
0.480334729,
0.6477085948,
-0.1705962718,
-0.0173612852,
0.4515895545,
-0.5207060575,
0.1479409635,
0.7504623532,
0.7808266282,
-0.0756748244,
0.7179458141,
-0.7266301513,
-0.3181875646,
0.0719400793,
-0.8589910269,
-0.8231801987,
-0.4597557485,
-0.7917085886,
-0.1091759428,
0.2845445573,
0.5589002371,
1.0051778555,
-0.7024579644,
-0.0904598087,
-0.2069419771,
-0.26137802,
-0.4993709028,
-0.0918042511,
0.8527200222,
-0.6455766559,
-0.4090698957,
0.1969030499,
0.4309764504,
0.2063177228,
-0.2724511027,
0.0421312526,
0.1534105837,
-0.1089834347,
0.5172057748,
0.6396507025,
-0.1285132319,
-0.2944732904,
0.1472024918,
0.0187309552,
0.3491135836,
0.6974391937,
-0.8699139953,
0.3920847774,
0.020690212,
0.8892908692,
0.7027773857,
0.0424254127,
0.0059078368,
-0.8525389433,
-0.0650392398,
0.4471000731,
0.0996858552,
0.3383212686,
-0.6865150332,
0.8862028718,
0.3627112508,
-0.6192635894,
-0.7048367262,
0.2483481765,
-0.7860030532,
-0.2359778285,
0.5600551367,
-0.3597289026,
-0.1945181042,
-0.004588448,
0.1473602355,
0.3254878819,
-0.1651916355,
0.8859598637,
0.0174018666,
-0.4232881665,
-0.07337372,
-0.1674487442,
0.4071050882,
0.7478542924,
-0.8372007608,
0.3282491863,
0.5274991989,
0.4679104686,
-0.1136484295,
0.5499660373,
0.0112474924,
0.2705285847,
-0.0157884359,
0.2202400267,
-0.2062124461,
-0.275452435,
-0.3557670116,
0.1877952665,
-0.1465599537,
-0.9281815886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14732v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14732v7 | Search-in-the-Chain: Interactively Enhancing Large Language Models with Search for Knowledge-intensive Tasks | 2023-04-28T10:15:25 | 2024-02-24T16:54:29 | Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Making the content generated by Large Language Model (LLM), accurate,
credible and traceable is crucial, especially in complex knowledge-intensive
tasks that require multi-step reasoning and each step needs knowledge to solve.
Retrieval-augmented generation is good potential to solve this problem.
However, where and how to introduce Information Retrieval (IR) to LLM is a big
challenge. Previous work has the problems that wrong knowledge retrieved by IR
misleads the LLM and interaction between IR and LLM breaks the reasoning chain
of LLM. This paper proposes a novel framework named
\textbf{Search-in-the-Chain} (SearChain) for the interaction between LLM and IR
to solve the challenges. First, LLM generates the reasoning chain named
Chain-of-Query (CoQ) where each node consists of an IR-oriented query-answer
pair. Second, IR verifies the answer of each node of CoQ. It corrects the
answer that is not consistent with the retrieved information when IR gives high
confidence, which improves the credibility. Third, LLM can indicate its missing
knowledge in CoQ and rely on IR to provide this knowledge to LLM. These
operations improve the accuracy in terms of reasoning and knowledge. Finally,
SearChain generates the reasoning process and marks references to supporting
documents for each reasoning step, which improves traceability. Interaction
with IR in SearChain forms a novel reasoning path based on a tree, which
enables LLM to dynamically modify the direction of reasoning. Experiments show
that SearChain outperforms state-of-the-art baselines on complex
knowledge-intensive tasks including multi-hop Q\&A, slot filling, fact
checking, and long-form Q\&A. | [
-0.2977183461,
-0.9165771604,
0.7577863932,
-0.0510796718,
0.0832431391,
0.5903022289,
-0.1818185151,
-0.687173605,
0.3489502966,
0.5272226334,
-0.4359576404,
-0.1477310658,
-0.2786310017,
-0.0612258315,
-0.4436578453,
0.7026029229,
-0.2705334425,
-0.2233716547,
-0.2166118473,
-0.052190505,
-0.1836237609,
-0.7945996523,
-0.6801651716,
-0.2891617417,
0.7375778556,
0.4981832206,
0.6039214134,
0.5222327709,
0.5341035724,
0.2294676602,
-0.2614560127,
0.638995111,
-0.7140034437,
0.5461339951,
-0.5243934989,
-0.2471958697,
-0.4005228877,
-0.4105871618,
0.524790287,
0.6024983525,
-0.072578989,
0.0998117775,
0.0438888147,
0.7051557302,
-0.7297080755,
0.0211815443,
-0.886097312,
-0.4803293049,
-0.4656418264,
-0.6055517197,
-0.3505222201,
-0.2501752377,
0.2139604092,
-0.5956730843,
-0.1668350846,
0.4418871999,
0.77622962,
-0.2063023001,
-0.5164208412,
-0.5660917163,
-0.7751336098,
0.6034264565,
-0.6232768893,
0.3055251837,
0.3193108141,
0.277507931,
-0.6118569374,
-0.8198390007,
-0.7345404625,
-0.1882120222,
0.1160132363,
-0.0976368412,
0.0658618733,
0.1672462672,
0.2523743212,
0.4642180204,
-0.3195973635,
-0.1597075015,
-0.0080617666,
0.0074707028,
0.5062925816,
0.0289621968,
0.5209844708,
-0.1721333414,
-0.2406003028,
-0.0704321563,
-0.9236812592,
-0.0782932863,
0.4381864965,
0.365560919,
0.3911609352,
0.664034009,
-0.4173916578,
0.6211569309,
0.0798681229,
-0.1861599535,
0.0794480368,
-0.4871438444,
-0.0077250008,
0.1494902819,
0.5045974851,
-0.0191519707,
0.2443837076,
0.0201217253,
-0.4547809362,
-0.2661834061,
0.0915687457,
-0.7912358046,
-0.0363606326,
-0.0347644389,
-0.2794669569,
-0.1402619034,
0.0891850442,
-0.4519473016,
-0.2078350633,
-0.2218375355,
0.7709699273,
-0.3926985264,
-0.3656759858,
0.0476217009,
-0.0098687178,
0.0487261601,
0.4755602479,
-0.5747263432,
0.4254559577,
0.5193439126,
0.6063402295,
-0.0729800016,
-0.1199126393,
-0.8269914389,
0.6317558289,
-0.1649480462,
0.5332707763,
-0.7825971842,
0.1276436001,
0.1117707416,
-0.2443262935,
-0.1535546184,
-0.5623136163,
0.226798296,
-1.0945379734,
0.0520474985,
-0.1931721866,
-0.5553469062,
-0.4111574888,
0.5478774905,
-0.797753334,
1.2414596081,
0.1084998846,
-0.9763367772,
-0.0257752798,
-0.6406024694,
-0.5736071467,
0.1828154325,
-0.1457376778,
-0.0849065408,
-0.2143917233,
0.2514390349,
0.169345364,
-0.5366328359,
0.4943449795,
-0.2402643561,
-0.5553055406,
0.2315680385,
-0.1652844101,
0.6140428185,
0.0317718871,
-0.3880084753,
-0.1106372699,
-0.7819994688,
0.135080412,
0.0760435835,
-0.5383393168,
-0.6572383046,
0.1674181372,
-0.1855842471,
0.2515768409,
0.3717606068,
-0.4056034088,
0.3389261365,
-0.3035208881,
0.2828617692,
0.5803642273,
0.3757836223,
0.3535121083,
-0.2095471621,
0.4516547024,
-0.1405895799,
0.1711530983,
-0.2292023301,
-0.2114830613,
-0.7968900204,
0.021027511,
0.2649284303,
0.5857075453,
-1.0968285799,
0.158845529,
-0.160960272,
-0.3479948044,
-0.3383234143,
0.1328138709,
0.3550076485,
0.4733527005,
0.4546889961,
-0.147181958,
-0.6964071989,
-0.5098594427,
-0.337451905,
-0.3748227656,
0.2267216593,
0.3906621635,
0.4210679233,
-0.2967608869,
0.632350862,
-0.2816303372,
-0.0820165128,
-0.4427220523,
0.0393969491,
0.4799342453,
0.4156274498,
-0.0011398684,
-0.9141770601,
-0.4781230092,
0.271281898,
-0.7105564475,
-0.0367223285,
0.0405986793,
-0.4724312723,
0.0268455297,
0.4795606136,
-0.5870676041,
0.3577082157,
0.3348484635,
-0.0843790993,
0.3872386813,
-0.2135675251,
0.238259837,
-0.8841471076,
0.3263270855,
-0.183014065,
-0.2011814266,
-0.4863139987,
0.5104615688,
-0.0842839926,
-0.0477698781,
-0.1793240607,
0.5801020265,
-0.4786361456,
0.0105887745,
-0.1736498475,
0.3483937383,
0.1967066973,
0.5138970613,
-0.2292672694,
0.7711920142,
0.3359061778,
-0.7496179342,
0.2484830171,
0.2532027662,
-0.2949919999,
0.4501947463,
-0.3068305552,
0.2571847737,
-0.1168060228,
0.3216086328,
-0.6835525036,
-0.2457329929,
0.0900620818,
-0.2310339361,
0.2537719607,
-0.0730589628,
-1.0276089907,
-0.316898793,
-0.1948898286,
0.7087674737,
0.2239519358,
-0.8683732152,
0.8089311719,
0.308465749,
-0.0705707967,
-0.5817486048,
-0.3290899098,
0.2629114687,
-0.0677081943,
-0.7012180686,
0.4426899552,
-0.160393849,
-0.249913305,
-0.0169289839,
-0.2455123067,
-0.1431825012,
-0.0459480397,
-0.1654366553,
0.2560364008,
-0.0012562539,
0.361122936,
0.1306232363,
0.1968147606,
-0.0155179491,
-0.3431513906,
0.6052568555,
0.1290239394,
-0.3152027428,
-0.2830708027,
0.4337484241,
0.695509553,
-0.437941432,
0.5347945094,
0.103653729,
-0.3558988869,
-0.249056071,
-0.7709529996,
-0.2256329805,
-0.4829643071,
0.2312193066,
-0.5188959837,
-1.0173357725,
0.3591926396,
-0.4549185336,
-0.2858145237,
0.3740071952,
0.2176108509,
-0.216967836,
1.1734136343,
0.5100907087,
0.1257380247,
0.4378447533,
-0.2535108328,
0.532681644,
-1.0096520185,
-0.4410099387,
-0.4834087193,
-0.1964367181,
-0.6389778852,
-0.3988316953,
0.5654155612,
0.4302854538,
-0.528872788,
0.3039196432,
-0.3372453153,
0.1868824661,
0.6001235843,
0.2377240956,
0.5159249306,
0.1214764714,
-0.4387832582,
0.0797467455,
-0.9253456593,
-0.1920375079,
0.7716112733,
0.1663106978,
0.9890120625,
0.075112015,
0.6675688624,
0.1540351212,
0.0112765245,
-0.5670303702,
0.6942499876,
-0.0067705037,
-0.4475968182,
-0.1522979587,
-0.5811113715,
-0.7204009891,
0.0308181699,
-0.1553388834,
-0.7328009605,
0.1032625735,
0.1918237656,
0.0898869932,
0.561111629,
-0.3403787315,
0.333521992,
-0.4984674156,
-0.6292462349,
-0.3956834972,
-0.6451771259,
0.3177307844,
-0.0639763996,
0.2395825237,
0.2057473063,
0.2333831638,
0.5433083773,
-0.6352844238,
0.5743939877,
-0.0939048752,
-0.1023625433,
0.4941340983,
0.4625303745,
1.2041299343,
-0.1007804051,
-0.2856272757,
-0.3370662332,
-0.1915752143,
-0.0843128338,
-0.8347504139,
0.8019416332,
-0.3350500464,
-0.6915439963,
-0.4013691545,
-0.6531894207,
-0.2290428281,
0.2770833969,
-0.2098408937,
0.5136729479,
0.1471659839,
0.0977876037,
0.8009421825,
-0.2450748533,
0.1645875275,
0.4273821115,
-0.4706934988,
-0.2986745834,
0.9685670733,
0.0903667212,
0.3308701217,
0.8770857453,
0.1938097179,
-0.2070331275,
-0.2598775625,
-0.3076631129,
0.2684188783,
-0.6832190752,
-0.3452911079,
-0.7369065881,
-0.5162426233,
0.1388850361,
0.0942364335,
-0.1515829861,
-0.3514209986,
0.0306527913,
-0.0700171292,
0.5708312392,
0.7055248618,
0.0594988838,
0.0444471538,
-0.5466939211,
0.2113428712,
0.3745250702,
0.3947371244,
0.4829188883,
-0.2460609078,
-0.4232580066,
-0.0750849098,
-0.1896695197,
-0.6265361309,
0.0583584309,
-0.0288150273,
0.4496131241,
0.1311645508,
-0.0296542123,
1.0177108049,
-0.3890600502,
0.4410079718,
0.0619378537,
-1.0697723627,
0.5608975887,
-0.3304165602,
0.1385684758,
0.596559763,
0.2429376245,
-0.5030165911,
-0.5921235681,
-0.5763680935,
-1.1891887188,
0.5355536342,
0.3266715705,
-0.1580665708,
-0.123949267,
0.3902353644,
0.0149244871,
0.3840361536,
-0.5417994261,
-0.0394772626,
0.2752425671,
-0.0945870727,
0.6519771218,
-0.4412587285,
0.123537913,
-0.3438014984,
0.9742626548,
-0.079325363,
0.0767239258,
0.3269044161,
-0.1776001006,
-0.3237954974,
0.126185596,
0.0760372356,
0.9879460335,
-0.3523036242,
0.5032852292,
-0.0425421,
-0.2028413713,
0.0142855011,
-0.0510430373,
-0.255757004,
-0.1524028033,
0.3819155097,
0.6639901996,
0.244373247,
-0.9704067707,
0.4667007625,
0.1786897629,
0.1279484034,
-0.3695054948,
0.1316636801,
0.0353938118,
0.4391571581,
0.6676757932,
-0.0740089715,
0.2874442935,
-0.7236192822,
0.2649989724,
0.4784169793,
-0.2180390209,
-0.0635715723,
0.5638805032,
0.1418694258,
-0.326138258,
0.8251564503,
-0.2871735394,
-0.7205837369,
0.3779681921,
0.6996156573,
0.534553349,
-0.2107149363,
0.1012775227,
0.4455936849,
0.2689930499,
-0.1997110695,
0.5400076509,
-0.0869168565,
-0.5852416158,
-0.8359056711,
-0.4213632047,
-0.3679678738,
0.2812425792,
-0.4837600887,
0.0714037567,
-0.1865610778,
0.137822479,
-0.5183315873,
-0.0216648411,
-0.5541434288,
0.2522387803,
-0.1785171479,
1.0075781345,
-0.2358301729,
0.8478085399,
0.5950908065,
-0.3887832463,
-1.0324180126,
0.2794500291,
-0.4223257601,
-0.7357869744,
0.8325092793,
0.1764634103,
-0.3701527119,
0.0529138297,
-0.6874383092,
-1.1462036371,
1.1424373388,
0.2735173702,
-0.8276138902,
-0.1052929088,
-0.1109584644,
0.4268525541,
-0.4741106629,
0.2671380043,
0.2871366143,
0.5516204238,
0.3577881753,
-0.8340438008,
0.3038178384,
-0.3176419735,
0.1415392756,
0.4576255977,
-0.4765505195,
0.7666435838,
-0.1565467119,
-0.2882723212,
0.2018342912,
0.376629591,
0.5414890051,
0.3212487698,
0.5069474578,
0.4541557431,
0.8835839033,
0.251662761,
1.0781726837,
-0.3184431195,
0.1875830889,
1.2272728682,
-0.4938046336,
0.9622942209,
0.7376625538,
0.0650920346,
0.8296125531,
0.3621269166,
0.2309938371,
0.3987396955,
0.5718500614,
-0.4889741838,
-0.3328287601,
-0.4645661414,
-0.1075505763,
0.175455302,
0.4134939313,
-0.2353577465,
-0.1069176346,
-0.1493278891,
0.0732047334,
0.2164363414,
-0.3721657395,
0.5684763193,
-0.0429755524,
-0.6760329008,
0.4541264772,
-0.0010968836,
0.3717397153,
-0.6664672494,
-0.4765772223,
-0.092648156,
0.0282102898,
-0.1881546527,
-0.7685343027,
-0.0918246806,
-0.1135758981,
-0.2128368467,
-0.0802851319,
0.972031951,
-0.6349261999,
-0.3210936189,
0.8812887669,
0.667875886,
-0.0733856931,
-0.2133087069,
-0.421230942,
0.1862270534,
-0.0787214264,
-0.2487697452,
0.2195993662,
0.7228024602,
-0.2902822793,
0.7568661571,
0.6952408552,
0.1012907773,
-0.1491877437,
0.1678297967,
1.1464692354,
-0.6621260047,
-0.36157462,
-0.6405647993,
0.2697568238,
-0.1525973678,
0.2575874627,
0.4849888086,
0.6564299464,
0.8359675407,
0.2560784221,
0.8472549319,
-0.2978715003,
0.5975781083,
-0.5501858592,
0.4199615717,
-0.7275183201,
0.2781742811,
-0.2516945899,
-1.0523381233,
-0.2038199008,
0.3338348567,
0.0270625912,
0.1138738319,
0.920388937,
0.7819282413,
-0.1957356036,
-0.2518668771,
0.0387784392,
0.4193415046,
0.3811012805,
0.6031548977,
0.9436924458,
-0.3883252144,
0.6771166325,
-0.0500866584,
-0.1667985022,
-0.2338993698,
-0.7405828238,
-0.8253014088,
-0.5463331342,
-0.0638099536,
-0.4351770282,
0.3384029865,
0.8633235097,
0.5421997905,
-0.5199522972,
-0.5260424018,
-0.3641903996,
0.3730515242,
-0.3180219829,
-0.2987632155,
0.3972558081,
-0.2714726627,
-0.5067923665,
0.6018751264,
0.5521034598,
-0.2079639137,
-0.2538148463,
-0.1769283563,
-0.7756166458,
0.0377638713,
0.7101413608,
0.2714576423,
-0.5200202465,
-0.3640858829,
-0.0265683513,
0.0847268328,
0.0233455598,
0.9779839516,
-0.8789566755,
0.677531302,
0.5352433324,
0.8691798449,
0.8134774566,
-0.1039069816,
0.6806625724,
-0.6185485721,
-0.2327161431,
0.233346045,
0.1824422479,
0.3558918238,
-0.6594930887,
0.6186349392,
0.1286635995,
-0.5911357403,
-0.7374898195,
0.4432319701,
-0.92691046,
-0.0749998465,
1.0260798931,
0.0795667544,
-0.1552876681,
-0.0553414747,
-0.1934880167,
0.3430719078,
-0.5079241991,
0.6059690714,
0.5026965737,
-0.2155351639,
-0.1021319702,
-0.5137381554,
0.3227700889,
0.2353990525,
-0.787692368,
-0.1060752943,
0.172168836,
0.0530117676,
0.1903982759,
0.4776543677,
-0.1520557255,
0.0555548444,
-0.552852869,
0.0337402485,
-0.022721123,
-0.5656197071,
0.3144636154,
0.1795034707,
0.2950928211,
0.0862585753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14721v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14721v4 | Towards autonomous system: flexible modular production system enhanced with large language model agents | 2023-04-28T09:42:18 | 2023-07-24T09:49:55 | Yuchen Xia, Manthan Shenoy, Nasser Jazdi, Michael Weyrich | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.SE, cs.SY, eess.SY | In this paper, we present a novel framework that combines large language
models (LLMs), digital twins and industrial automation system to enable
intelligent planning and control of production processes. We retrofit the
automation system for a modular production facility and create executable
control interfaces of fine-granular functionalities and coarse-granular skills.
Low-level functionalities are executed by automation components, and high-level
skills are performed by automation modules. Subsequently, a digital twin system
is developed, registering these interfaces and containing additional
descriptive information about the production system. Based on the retrofitted
automation system and the created digital twins, LLM-agents are designed to
interpret descriptive information in the digital twins and control the physical
system through service interfaces. These LLM-agents serve as intelligent agents
on different levels within an automation system, enabling autonomous planning
and control of flexible production. Given a task instruction as input, the
LLM-agents orchestrate a sequence of atomic functionalities and skills to
accomplish the task. We demonstrate how our implemented prototype can handle
un-predefined tasks, plan a production process, and execute the operations.
This research highlights the potential of integrating LLMs into industrial
automation systems in the context of smart factory for more agile, flexible,
and adaptive production processes, while it also underscores the critical
insights and limitations for future work. Demos at:
https://github.com/YuchenXia/GPT4IndustrialAutomation | [
-0.3022347391,
-0.7323856354,
0.9193775654,
-0.0398393273,
0.1560945362,
0.0545136295,
-0.1387227476,
-0.5242653489,
0.3348299861,
0.7043679357,
-0.9761858582,
-0.2963658273,
-0.2184950411,
0.1340864599,
-0.6393235922,
0.6752360463,
-0.1913371086,
-0.1262071431,
0.0601335615,
0.1633327156,
-0.2504571974,
-0.414758116,
-0.5262822509,
-0.5369799733,
0.2743236125,
0.3747310936,
1.0046862364,
0.8016625047,
0.2922507524,
0.5918658376,
0.4820105731,
0.1377074867,
-0.0679714456,
0.1518289894,
-0.4675854146,
-0.3285350204,
-1.1267434359,
-0.2909230888,
0.467476964,
0.3924399614,
0.039863959,
0.252599448,
-0.1827251315,
0.3681301773,
-0.1726683229,
0.4163138568,
-0.4894631803,
-0.0177663788,
0.1334799826,
0.0699471235,
-0.2003770769,
-0.2143595666,
-0.4297018051,
-0.3352668881,
-0.1864757985,
-0.2611257434,
0.4108657837,
0.5088416934,
-0.2981131673,
-0.1108811423,
-1.2086244822,
0.6975642443,
-0.8374233246,
-0.0734684914,
0.1216064915,
0.5429308414,
-0.3949730396,
-0.8790994883,
-0.971829474,
0.1980024725,
-0.0919912606,
0.145914793,
0.2530426085,
0.2883142829,
-0.0256999061,
0.1662717909,
-0.3716507554,
0.5503637791,
-0.201450631,
0.0316624232,
0.8884416223,
0.6520163417,
0.1699571759,
0.1887555867,
-0.3600496352,
0.1369847357,
-0.0756571516,
-0.2202318907,
0.5233057141,
0.338522017,
-0.0015369107,
0.5874733329,
-0.6569328308,
0.4153672159,
-0.0397029854,
-0.2312551886,
0.139750421,
-0.3313734531,
-0.5616446733,
-0.2763543725,
0.8500202298,
-0.1048617214,
0.2941315174,
-0.1329583228,
-0.8378457427,
0.1974104941,
0.3905301094,
-0.228124544,
-0.0092998622,
0.467906028,
-0.1633705795,
-0.0644904897,
0.127379626,
-0.4234893918,
-0.2691597939,
-0.5988140702,
0.7002309561,
0.0648093745,
-0.434196949,
0.1789517552,
-0.010463736,
0.5150600672,
0.3654100895,
-1.0427753925,
0.3164595664,
1.0129356384,
0.5183594823,
-0.0569578558,
-0.3624508679,
-0.3497515917,
0.7144266367,
-0.2768753171,
0.749255538,
-0.2512226999,
-0.2985009253,
-0.022239387,
0.181725353,
-0.0049739773,
-0.661057651,
0.0300269648,
-0.5306642652,
-0.1311264485,
0.4136409461,
-0.0065727206,
-0.4592981339,
0.2752349377,
-0.6109105945,
0.3646964133,
-0.0348644033,
-0.043392729,
0.2734057009,
-0.5918857455,
-0.4029414356,
0.4423226416,
-0.686003387,
-0.2534540296,
-0.3597081304,
-0.3238759637,
0.7858014107,
0.0039224764,
0.4324144721,
-0.463029027,
0.038872622,
0.0675279871,
-0.2939504385,
0.4198626876,
0.0749961361,
-0.6969224811,
0.724891305,
-0.7972798347,
0.1621218026,
0.0004548719,
-0.4737980068,
0.434725076,
0.0111141568,
0.1825881004,
0.4191977084,
0.6146811247,
-0.2062100768,
0.3600000441,
-0.034804929,
0.1811275035,
0.8509385586,
-0.2070924789,
0.4731213152,
-0.6015402675,
0.3887915313,
-0.269440949,
0.4409517646,
0.0836093426,
-0.1797542423,
-0.9539970756,
-0.3833595812,
-0.379314363,
0.7546589375,
-0.8838407993,
0.7314910889,
-0.1279255152,
-0.1148332059,
-0.1155438572,
0.3241554797,
0.0582565591,
-0.0347541943,
0.0913628712,
-0.4829521179,
-0.5765640736,
-1.2818931341,
0.3896669149,
-0.0532394499,
-0.2026352733,
-0.3534718156,
0.4692667723,
-0.6782928705,
1.0292282104,
-0.1094032824,
-0.4544229507,
-0.383048147,
0.1961342245,
0.6233825684,
0.4517254531,
0.1695043147,
-0.8044483066,
-0.2629872859,
0.34253034,
-0.7883162498,
0.097965844,
-0.2602465749,
0.0270969048,
0.6286303401,
0.5148355365,
-0.8848987222,
0.3881846964,
0.3745649457,
-0.1242639795,
0.8741279244,
-0.3349494338,
-0.303475678,
-1.2113445997,
0.0433514155,
-0.2401672006,
-0.3609670699,
-0.5582996607,
0.0865025818,
-0.1915587485,
0.3580233753,
-0.5987326503,
0.2751129568,
-0.3412680328,
-0.5998227,
-0.6534736753,
-0.2298492789,
-0.0196196046,
0.750284493,
0.1442551911,
0.72343117,
0.399953723,
-0.5349778533,
0.8762422204,
0.019738378,
-0.3909173012,
0.3254736066,
-0.2667940855,
-0.0321779475,
0.0216188319,
0.3625904322,
-0.5182730556,
-0.4009678066,
0.3544828594,
-0.1019100994,
0.2435053885,
0.2723695338,
-1.0670059919,
-0.5090513825,
0.007486253,
-0.0325393118,
0.4982423782,
-0.0671087205,
1.1912552118,
0.3186154366,
-0.4674555957,
-0.1794787645,
-0.9956973791,
0.0479902253,
-0.0343397111,
-0.6470333934,
-0.1054769382,
-0.1845827252,
-0.6355720162,
-0.0253398865,
-0.1086743996,
-0.300699681,
-0.1024088785,
0.2068108171,
0.2413417995,
-0.2984860241,
0.0951702371,
0.0089207906,
-0.2584854662,
0.1846013516,
-0.4689629376,
0.570572257,
-0.3052529395,
-0.2979314923,
-1.0197584629,
0.430393368,
1.1058351994,
0.0416815206,
0.7541478276,
0.3920990527,
-0.3824359477,
-0.4928103983,
-0.5888518095,
-0.3449311852,
-0.6566237211,
0.4112291336,
-0.3048428297,
-0.1631963998,
0.5854385495,
-0.1319905818,
0.3724108934,
0.4808376729,
0.8209400177,
0.0250488743,
1.0948480368,
0.8418082595,
0.1211449951,
0.2063913494,
-0.5198416114,
0.1427512765,
-0.4547305405,
-0.2925129533,
-0.2175171524,
-0.4930196702,
-0.318389982,
-0.5591235757,
0.2992393672,
-0.3647780418,
-0.6492744088,
0.1770742387,
-0.3088547885,
0.3388122916,
0.512513876,
-0.2148509026,
0.7441274524,
-0.6528792381,
0.028106723,
0.7169231772,
-0.6641049981,
-1.0019692183,
0.5584844351,
0.3368664384,
0.6398685575,
0.0424920693,
0.4423722029,
0.2094346732,
0.0232964866,
-0.8983613849,
0.923020184,
-0.1233079061,
-0.5643490553,
-0.4116272628,
0.0336264707,
-0.4785532355,
-0.087586455,
-0.3077449203,
-0.8180004358,
0.2133185416,
-0.261852324,
-0.593506217,
0.6587401628,
-1.0440529585,
0.3443939984,
-0.7267878056,
-0.2275958061,
-0.327559799,
-0.457133472,
0.1459394544,
-0.4612888396,
0.4778149724,
-0.1632952839,
-0.3056252301,
0.4187698364,
-0.3863965273,
1.1284375191,
0.273981303,
-0.264347136,
0.2481607646,
0.0445041694,
0.5813708901,
-0.0808950663,
-0.4470482469,
0.0771906897,
-0.2109669,
-0.1596211195,
-0.4727749825,
0.8510700464,
-0.7663757205,
-0.7939600348,
-0.2540453076,
-0.9443743825,
0.0177471675,
0.5124619603,
-0.2847755253,
0.1135975793,
0.2783033252,
0.048910208,
0.2430793941,
-0.0496731289,
0.9938343167,
0.5074232221,
-0.2570999861,
-0.1964494884,
0.3668815494,
0.2651019394,
0.43993783,
0.3391487896,
-0.2237752527,
0.0228385981,
-0.5181889534,
-0.5251120925,
0.0246477928,
-0.7161080241,
-0.3249541223,
-0.7678371668,
-0.5128919482,
-0.4796108902,
-0.5106338859,
-0.5019853711,
-0.3993037343,
-0.2373164445,
-0.1803053916,
0.2519206107,
1.4456443787,
-0.0043608281,
0.2037133276,
-0.6145144105,
0.3765117228,
0.780955255,
0.5779018402,
-0.0389887765,
0.1528187692,
-0.4101548493,
0.1697016656,
-0.4034227431,
-0.4303769469,
0.4571920931,
-0.3747313619,
0.6102669835,
0.4658263922,
0.1001158729,
0.182675451,
-0.3787755072,
0.4848848581,
-0.0127322404,
-0.856215179,
0.0037291299,
-0.7273722887,
0.4031187296,
0.196437791,
0.250382036,
-0.0979823843,
-0.3307346106,
-0.4998238981,
-1.2045606375,
0.8442102075,
-0.1175493151,
-0.1484652907,
0.3441747427,
0.0574800633,
0.4774623811,
0.2296347022,
-0.7372696996,
0.0478542782,
0.2632580996,
-0.2710260749,
-0.0720165446,
0.1405373365,
-0.1312602311,
-0.1203256696,
0.949084878,
-0.2522425652,
0.1996103376,
-0.1810528189,
0.2918498218,
-0.3157477677,
0.1377111822,
0.4000349045,
0.6740219593,
-0.0154677266,
-0.2293786854,
0.3133794069,
-0.2148249596,
0.0858310163,
-0.1380795389,
0.0267690159,
-0.460452497,
0.1598618776,
0.4522717595,
-0.2410011739,
-0.6867448688,
0.0123159727,
0.2807475626,
-0.2870598137,
-0.8637734652,
0.394043684,
0.2167574316,
1.1081243753,
0.5924926996,
0.0404203571,
-0.049192328,
-0.6854339838,
0.296770364,
0.3682211637,
-0.1178654283,
-0.2263357937,
0.392143935,
0.2868928909,
-0.6004683375,
0.1630597562,
-0.0184767731,
-0.4354836047,
0.9991473556,
0.3286395371,
0.9623724818,
0.1667944342,
0.1977671236,
-0.17571567,
0.4414964616,
-0.1934744716,
0.2625071704,
0.1411436498,
-0.616029501,
-0.4510194361,
-0.6206427217,
-0.4739664793,
0.1397905499,
0.0350484587,
0.5501376987,
-0.8881270885,
-0.0029176746,
-0.2457958609,
0.082880877,
-0.5773067474,
0.2339600623,
0.3845482171,
0.7132517695,
-0.6585687995,
1.0415980816,
0.9847586155,
-0.367890358,
-0.8145574331,
-0.0082977517,
0.1211112291,
-0.6405344009,
0.5216584206,
0.1458486617,
-0.3821686506,
0.0687004104,
-0.1526303887,
-0.7731430531,
1.5297002792,
0.0018137369,
-0.5486305356,
0.0266879778,
0.3859538734,
0.6099658608,
-0.5429118872,
0.0787984729,
0.6976439357,
0.7962124944,
0.1657005996,
-1.1066082716,
-0.0741503835,
-0.2026933581,
-0.3491759598,
0.2934069932,
-0.7546064854,
0.8254401088,
-0.0875305235,
-0.3389120996,
0.3662965298,
0.4211533368,
-0.0297511704,
0.4965259731,
0.401226908,
0.3629076183,
0.2343127131,
0.1030030772,
0.7955037355,
-0.0920501426,
-0.01147692,
0.9890969992,
-0.3980962336,
0.8083313704,
0.4692599177,
0.0164174791,
0.7305669188,
0.0700209662,
0.1846488863,
0.202872023,
0.0229418073,
-0.3748853803,
-0.1788126081,
-0.0875107944,
-0.1073132753,
0.3808056116,
0.509611845,
-0.0144361528,
-0.0097361999,
0.103398554,
-0.1218365058,
0.3216538727,
-0.3538113832,
1.0567406416,
-0.1010727435,
-0.3880820572,
0.2712640166,
0.0360035412,
0.8358843923,
-0.7495930195,
0.3431460261,
-0.055172883,
0.4183885455,
-0.2950446308,
-0.9073671699,
0.7071239948,
-0.3236422837,
-0.3027139008,
-0.7002034187,
0.4455007315,
-0.2808645666,
-0.4450939596,
0.3142253757,
0.4039991498,
-0.2411256433,
0.225626111,
-0.3922897875,
-0.0476428643,
-0.2818892002,
-0.1618605554,
0.0785167888,
0.6074908972,
-0.2504258752,
0.7811629176,
0.4194394946,
0.0976915956,
0.0286934897,
-0.2381369174,
0.8469305038,
-0.802495718,
-0.4825796783,
-0.3990280032,
0.7126294971,
0.150167346,
0.348343581,
0.1308597326,
0.3373683989,
0.9976216555,
-0.2585937679,
0.821316123,
-0.1250865757,
0.0292053409,
-0.3864054978,
0.8157709837,
-0.5376890898,
0.3157042861,
-0.0770726353,
-0.9460234642,
-0.2430223823,
0.0989044011,
-0.5083864927,
0.0849728435,
0.4567966163,
0.9736804366,
-0.1323172599,
-0.095928587,
0.524987638,
0.480848372,
0.3343227804,
0.6628150344,
0.6421794891,
-0.0581458025,
0.3780476451,
-0.2693069577,
-0.2629176378,
-0.1248124018,
-0.8364136219,
-0.3807630539,
-0.6410401464,
-0.0659672245,
0.3656917512,
-0.1351825446,
1.1698671579,
0.7215582728,
-0.674865365,
-0.6867711544,
-0.147003144,
0.0785284564,
-0.2576765716,
-0.1974096894,
-0.1849195212,
-0.1076680198,
-1.0592616796,
0.453476429,
0.716797471,
0.252930671,
-0.5472798347,
-0.1691832989,
-0.5148004293,
0.2198968232,
0.4423181415,
0.2649047077,
-0.5428375006,
-0.1415038109,
-0.3468160629,
-0.0918455049,
-0.2465263009,
0.5801380873,
-0.8509607315,
0.2205177993,
0.7093307376,
0.4917639792,
0.0743266046,
-0.1821627468,
0.8361744881,
-0.3747543991,
0.4493452013,
0.3384046853,
0.2763126791,
0.2247901112,
-0.6432657838,
0.2706048489,
-0.0013458628,
-0.5149979591,
-0.2103549391,
0.6261652708,
-0.9520519376,
-0.3618699014,
1.0091707706,
0.3494451642,
-0.2477102876,
-0.4105446339,
-0.0281901453,
0.3805255294,
-0.2261237651,
0.9445289969,
0.3253748417,
-0.1405835152,
0.2269786149,
-0.4796018898,
-0.172439158,
0.3248084486,
-0.9732276797,
-0.0815124959,
0.4953925312,
-0.126853928,
0.2787849307,
0.484197408,
-0.023170976,
0.2504400313,
-0.1519484967,
0.5057376623,
-0.2673535049,
-0.643230319,
-0.2191083878,
0.0311025269,
-0.0199543834,
-0.1744613647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14662v1 | CED: Catalog Extraction from Documents | 2023-04-28T07:32:00 | 2023-04-28T07:32:00 | Tong Zhu, Guoliang Zhang, Zechang Li, Zijian Yu, Junfei Ren, Mengsong Wu, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai, Pingfu Chao, Wenliang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentence-by-sentence information extraction from long documents is an
exhausting and error-prone task. As the indicator of document skeleton,
catalogs naturally chunk documents into segments and provide informative
cascade semantics, which can help to reduce the search space. Despite their
usefulness, catalogs are hard to be extracted without the assist from external
knowledge. For documents that adhere to a specific template, regular
expressions are practical to extract catalogs. However, handcrafted heuristics
are not applicable when processing documents from different sources with
diverse formats. To address this problem, we build a large manually annotated
corpus, which is the first dataset for the Catalog Extraction from Documents
(CED) task. Based on this corpus, we propose a transition-based framework for
parsing documents into catalog trees. The experimental results demonstrate that
our proposed method outperforms baseline systems and shows a good ability to
transfer. We believe the CED task could fill the gap between raw text segments
and information extraction tasks on extremely long documents. Data and code are
available at \url{https://github.com/Spico197/CatalogExtraction} | [
-0.1405728757,
-0.5674926043,
0.4326500595,
0.2204191685,
-0.4226658046,
-0.0191689283,
-0.228155002,
-0.4701752365,
-0.1672180444,
0.5179696083,
-0.6510025263,
-0.7073474526,
-0.3078722358,
0.2831088603,
-0.6964144111,
0.9959315062,
0.2369743437,
-0.5407577753,
0.0267188828,
0.2049567103,
-0.218722418,
-0.2835052609,
-0.4042677879,
0.1425124109,
0.5085331798,
0.4667415321,
0.4807617068,
0.9518769383,
0.3523759544,
0.1868952662,
-0.2056099474,
0.1499342471,
-0.2761165202,
0.2601599097,
-0.3855299354,
-0.3253138959,
-0.2097304016,
-0.0908812955,
0.5882237554,
0.5488497019,
-0.1296812743,
0.0390670188,
0.2985222042,
0.6689878702,
-0.5682953,
0.3422295749,
-0.587323904,
0.0721965358,
-0.8292492032,
-0.1290929914,
-0.6852288246,
-0.0637560114,
0.2434479594,
-1.0847922564,
0.4910669029,
-0.0421317145,
1.1724002361,
0.1622985303,
-0.3593973815,
-0.4155070484,
-0.6414362192,
0.5329057574,
-0.5044146776,
0.6573545933,
0.1305331439,
0.136850968,
-0.2034442276,
-1.1652028561,
-0.4566589296,
0.1075980142,
-0.0222357661,
0.2001116276,
0.1223723888,
0.010499334,
0.2533062994,
0.5331401229,
-0.558355093,
-0.0721387938,
-0.5016475916,
-0.0580780134,
0.5152999163,
-0.066555053,
0.1394412518,
-0.5941562057,
-0.447699517,
-0.5274746418,
-0.4237253368,
-0.0568500087,
0.2803139985,
0.3495089412,
0.2441032976,
0.3664018214,
-0.0828761309,
0.4888027906,
0.1792757213,
0.0008002413,
0.1619885415,
-0.2577493787,
-0.4998062551,
0.1529674977,
0.4609918296,
0.3292161822,
-0.0806236342,
-0.3515487909,
-0.091102235,
-0.0031820119,
0.3247951269,
-0.6426458955,
-0.2131086439,
0.0689621493,
-0.7394161224,
-0.3066183627,
0.2386435568,
-1.1918779612,
-0.2550152838,
-0.2118653953,
-0.0882839113,
-0.4279301465,
0.1235150993,
0.1866790354,
-0.2561341822,
0.1525957882,
0.4805407822,
-0.6861788034,
0.4540189505,
0.795373559,
0.9003311992,
-0.5115604401,
0.2471256405,
-0.582862258,
0.2600592077,
-0.1997120678,
0.7077774405,
-0.5734190941,
-0.6784430742,
0.0861405134,
0.5179246068,
-0.1793314964,
-0.4551245272,
1.243483901,
-0.7172745466,
0.1045599729,
0.0781237558,
-0.7314556241,
-0.0611844398,
0.3622827828,
-0.8872652054,
1.2888311148,
0.2476951182,
-0.8971707225,
0.1380202919,
-0.7202832103,
-0.4284285307,
0.1871737987,
0.0179770514,
-0.0267122313,
-0.124390766,
0.2771506608,
0.1936554909,
-0.4301434159,
0.1342879087,
-0.0559971221,
0.0658531561,
-0.1925604641,
-0.3857648075,
0.9685820341,
0.5335469842,
-0.0936054885,
-0.3759012818,
-1.0587507486,
-0.1915965676,
-0.067033574,
-0.6033913493,
-0.5229277611,
0.1293810159,
0.4555542469,
0.2844857275,
0.4864287674,
-0.7080444098,
0.5625119209,
-0.567053318,
-0.0162545554,
0.8324113488,
0.0819099322,
0.5311008692,
-0.188481316,
0.6203585863,
0.0123543879,
0.1390818208,
-0.4494897127,
-0.1971701086,
-0.8016487956,
-0.100720413,
0.5382015705,
0.6444729567,
-0.679864645,
0.8181948662,
-0.2081786692,
-0.4476691782,
-0.2538355887,
0.1743968427,
0.0685075596,
0.6378631592,
0.4007672071,
-0.4185566306,
-0.5297576189,
-0.7124868035,
-0.0243264604,
-0.1715606004,
-0.0903259516,
-0.0117013687,
0.1612405479,
-0.047088474,
1.1220440865,
-0.645565629,
-0.4873431325,
0.1249609366,
0.2458822727,
0.4246549308,
0.5175766945,
-0.0771208033,
-0.9751676917,
-0.3382084668,
0.3005731702,
-0.572909236,
-0.339468509,
-0.5863370299,
-0.3623553514,
-0.0315380171,
1.0481274128,
-0.6222093105,
0.5519375801,
0.1390488148,
-0.266280055,
0.4677824676,
-0.2089310437,
-0.2983132005,
-1.0520046949,
0.2413523197,
0.0556330457,
-0.0879795179,
-0.2717775702,
-0.0760843083,
0.2657197416,
0.0096427947,
-0.4625953734,
0.4732909799,
-0.5376796722,
-0.2032316625,
0.0439239107,
0.1684551239,
0.2775150836,
0.1780754924,
0.2221676558,
0.3104227781,
0.2081253976,
-0.5905089378,
-0.061071869,
0.5532841682,
-0.2768469751,
0.5364358425,
-0.2517243922,
-0.0509385318,
-0.2106232345,
0.4963978231,
-0.6269463301,
0.1379589438,
0.2212714106,
0.1104586348,
0.3711732626,
-0.3202658594,
-0.7227292061,
-0.3244163394,
-0.2179735005,
0.0860826299,
0.219943881,
-0.570395112,
0.5487666726,
0.1157220826,
-0.2396885604,
-0.2899587452,
-0.2477648705,
0.3454960883,
-0.082213439,
-0.7444775701,
0.8765621185,
-0.3336645067,
0.0681448206,
-0.0932743847,
-0.0646794885,
-0.1063329279,
0.285777092,
0.2050549984,
0.3559868932,
-0.174527213,
0.3670750558,
0.2166719735,
-0.2185719609,
-0.2317531258,
-0.4701909125,
0.4143326283,
0.1644879431,
-0.2584289014,
-0.4132003486,
0.3415385187,
0.7410651445,
-0.3160485625,
0.0830561295,
0.4855455756,
-0.381832093,
-0.2414773703,
-0.1540607214,
0.1820569187,
-0.4358782172,
0.0871108547,
-0.4036358893,
-0.3260104656,
0.2647125721,
-0.3446529806,
0.4862077832,
0.866828084,
0.1861691922,
0.1730888039,
0.8183031082,
0.6714013815,
0.2700436711,
0.5884266496,
-0.2136226743,
-0.1053826213,
-0.9864941239,
-0.2687264979,
-0.8873718977,
-0.1743474305,
-0.3508035243,
-0.4216330349,
0.1572214365,
0.361088872,
0.0525148809,
0.3998394608,
-0.7348900437,
0.290164113,
0.2705948949,
-0.1085858643,
0.5490429997,
-0.1153177842,
-0.0851325318,
0.010004255,
-0.4329164326,
-0.6457971931,
0.7943653464,
0.3476648629,
0.6547443271,
-0.1720610559,
0.8117523193,
0.3889257014,
0.375579983,
-0.8533786535,
0.4228377044,
-0.6244075894,
-0.3975145221,
-0.2446324676,
0.1786283404,
-1.1699656248,
0.1657017022,
0.0413711965,
-0.8453184366,
0.7510999441,
-0.4765966237,
-0.201571241,
-0.0898246914,
-0.4286598861,
0.9252343178,
-0.1058479622,
-0.1614906788,
0.3695025742,
-0.9515115023,
0.0560049489,
-0.4547317624,
0.4578473866,
0.0025706466,
0.0142804207,
1.0763187408,
-0.6035006046,
0.742557168,
0.0044898209,
-0.1584527194,
0.2728635967,
0.3106940091,
0.6437799931,
-0.1096473709,
-0.3519489467,
-0.1111720204,
0.3679735065,
-0.1440537274,
-0.5300305486,
0.3026966751,
-0.4029147029,
-0.3483103812,
-0.3880169988,
-0.4170603752,
-0.0368988216,
0.4196038544,
0.272802949,
0.229637906,
-0.3841338754,
0.3217809796,
0.4121346176,
0.0851650685,
0.616566956,
0.4436690211,
-0.1312087178,
-0.1226989254,
0.5845189095,
0.2129831016,
-0.1221990734,
0.4811953902,
0.270735085,
-0.4278287888,
-0.3076787293,
-0.6128121018,
-0.0826294348,
-0.8536420465,
-0.1681941301,
-0.8067647219,
-0.2892800272,
-0.4321289062,
-0.3425478041,
-0.2423899323,
-0.4519407153,
-0.8155083656,
-0.0929628909,
-0.0346602276,
0.6073899865,
-0.0092261499,
0.2557356954,
-1.3478009701,
0.1515343636,
0.1129026338,
-0.2351977676,
-0.0682880431,
-0.3126164377,
-0.1557260603,
-0.3047023416,
-0.3960061371,
-0.7842530012,
0.5279185176,
0.4417496324,
0.3938658237,
0.6372956038,
0.4378594458,
0.7149098516,
-0.5308393836,
0.8114796281,
0.0326977968,
-0.7733858228,
0.4915299416,
-0.2876584828,
0.1765303463,
0.7399590015,
0.1993480772,
-0.7155026793,
-0.3232629597,
-1.0377312899,
-1.0017137527,
0.7197021246,
0.2911427915,
-0.1514127403,
-0.4289861023,
0.3172520697,
0.3845681548,
-0.1352889687,
-0.2393634468,
0.1239975989,
-0.0378550328,
-0.5133880973,
0.1814235598,
0.0684112161,
0.005916887,
0.0784878284,
0.5423102379,
-0.1358066648,
-0.3324844241,
0.6428504586,
-0.3918497562,
0.0384072214,
0.3710826039,
0.1095805019,
0.4436026514,
-0.1751567274,
0.0679222271,
-0.2580772638,
-0.5082953572,
-0.1868599653,
0.3069694042,
-0.1711150855,
0.2130328268,
0.1062410623,
0.1260099709,
0.2191433311,
-0.7153754234,
0.6882222295,
-0.0236849599,
-0.0213326458,
-0.2355770171,
-0.2294668406,
-0.1145342514,
0.3322526217,
0.6400435567,
-0.1676466465,
0.4066874087,
-0.3959539831,
0.6233897805,
0.0252001379,
-0.3429056108,
-0.2627701759,
0.5269125104,
0.2623682618,
-0.2932074666,
0.628549993,
-0.1143598631,
-0.3487306237,
0.7229520082,
0.7239044905,
0.8910399079,
0.17342861,
0.3829969168,
0.127284199,
0.1730414033,
-0.4714329839,
-0.3165549338,
-0.3224852383,
-0.49437958,
-0.2256412655,
-0.974165678,
-0.1142721176,
-0.1770712733,
-0.7292020917,
0.5726138353,
-0.4097674787,
0.1113200411,
0.1336398125,
-0.0910276398,
-0.6562315822,
0.2736400366,
0.0939467549,
1.3497178555,
-0.7054445148,
0.8337977529,
0.2062255293,
-0.2819697559,
-0.4919774234,
-0.0036507947,
-0.2314262986,
-0.3586273193,
0.9615056515,
0.1539490223,
0.3380737603,
0.0633703247,
-0.3529226482,
-0.6325060725,
1.0476756096,
0.1268110573,
-0.9925503731,
-0.5910181999,
-0.2959216833,
0.4355757236,
-0.4736510813,
0.0083377054,
0.6465030313,
0.7005235553,
0.3105030954,
-0.7862548828,
0.0861081555,
-0.2798007727,
-0.1058041751,
0.1959582567,
-0.2511886358,
1.1323977709,
0.4049920142,
-0.6673066616,
0.5052075982,
0.506256938,
-0.0988510475,
0.3814759552,
0.823124826,
0.7439056635,
1.1481411457,
0.2807841301,
0.9081058502,
-0.4142248631,
0.5200521946,
1.1592371464,
-0.416865766,
0.8401629329,
0.2906703055,
-0.0086664567,
0.7655438185,
0.8692051172,
-0.0497058593,
0.3998095989,
0.0299369711,
-0.3323236406,
-0.3330388963,
-0.096692279,
-0.2220558375,
0.4238229394,
0.6157479882,
-0.6608208418,
-0.791611433,
-0.0848532543,
0.0485178642,
-0.1405388266,
-0.0973983705,
0.7468116283,
-0.0360098891,
-0.5039246678,
0.2084832191,
0.0963497385,
0.3285286427,
-0.3657049239,
-0.2266822308,
0.0721134394,
-0.1683594286,
-0.3770358562,
-0.5751001239,
0.2492693365,
-0.1067149788,
-0.2040257007,
-0.3305564523,
0.8289768696,
-0.3044237494,
-0.5324069262,
0.0635246336,
0.4864425659,
0.3603926301,
-0.0212491043,
-0.680200696,
-0.0574259795,
0.0494347326,
-0.2019762248,
0.1888237894,
0.7226457,
-0.4702138305,
-0.006869772,
1.1134104729,
-0.0348908789,
0.0389969163,
-0.1542962193,
0.9571002126,
-0.6471764445,
-0.8360300064,
-0.5323796272,
0.6028094292,
-0.4009891748,
-0.3861035705,
0.3347366154,
0.7656471729,
0.4902543426,
0.1529066563,
0.7280323505,
-0.1871041358,
0.3816865087,
-0.6033334136,
0.5290057063,
-0.4050010145,
0.2622621655,
-0.2042114735,
-1.1154091358,
-0.4829562008,
0.4418226779,
-0.0146567533,
-0.6330603361,
1.071382761,
0.6713525057,
-0.1171154827,
0.1538355201,
0.1973967105,
0.2580450177,
0.6620556712,
0.2410962284,
0.451577574,
-0.509996593,
0.9069224596,
-0.023847444,
-0.1614804864,
-0.3819908202,
-1.1182461977,
-0.3266806901,
-0.7801815271,
-0.3739649355,
-0.47890082,
-0.0084874053,
0.6492675543,
0.5159373879,
-0.3578592837,
-0.0308052693,
-0.373273313,
0.1936649829,
0.066685535,
-0.3146642447,
0.7843186855,
-0.5849728584,
-0.7796626091,
0.5946790576,
0.3817097247,
-0.03394242,
-0.0655821636,
0.0989440978,
-0.3795287907,
-0.0639766827,
0.535790503,
0.5239254236,
-0.332907021,
-0.4907463193,
0.0561308078,
-0.098589845,
0.3609583676,
0.8655464649,
-0.8676012754,
0.5594313145,
0.59764117,
0.8008580208,
0.7866629958,
0.2885719538,
0.3903368413,
-0.7821382284,
0.0389224812,
0.095243752,
0.1813983917,
0.2496437728,
-0.4056297243,
0.6248933077,
0.4241494238,
-0.3812040687,
-0.5990429521,
0.0736865401,
-1.4977267981,
-0.3109232485,
1.130988121,
-0.2901597619,
-0.6865776777,
-0.503179729,
-0.5787121654,
0.2421270162,
-0.5724074244,
0.6051512957,
0.6679422259,
0.166639924,
0.0925614908,
-0.2864499092,
0.376899451,
0.0349462405,
-0.9693206549,
0.3589909077,
0.5331872702,
0.0390164182,
0.6714484692,
0.6072905064,
-0.4795917273,
0.2375500053,
-0.1296868771,
0.0170876719,
0.2427861243,
-0.2592255771,
-0.1957525611,
0.6319599748,
-0.1538638622,
-0.2241027057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14599v1 | Antisemitic Messages? A Guide to High-Quality Annotation and a Labeled Dataset of Tweets | 2023-04-28T02:52:38 | 2023-04-28T02:52:38 | Gunther Jikeli, Sameer Karali, Daniel Miehling, Katharina Soemer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | One of the major challenges in automatic hate speech detection is the lack of
datasets that cover a wide range of biased and unbiased messages and that are
consistently labeled. We propose a labeling procedure that addresses some of
the common weaknesses of labeled datasets. We focus on antisemitic speech on
Twitter and create a labeled dataset of 6,941 tweets that cover a wide range of
topics common in conversations about Jews, Israel, and antisemitism between
January 2019 and December 2021 by drawing from representative samples with
relevant keywords. Our annotation process aims to strictly apply a commonly
used definition of antisemitism by forcing annotators to specify which part of
the definition applies, and by giving them the option to personally disagree
with the definition on a case-by-case basis. Labeling tweets that call out
antisemitism, report antisemitism, or are otherwise related to antisemitism
(such as the Holocaust) but are not actually antisemitic can help reduce false
positives in automated detection. The dataset includes 1,250 tweets (18%) that
are antisemitic according to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance
(IHRA) definition of antisemitism. It is important to note, however, that the
dataset is not comprehensive. Many topics are still not covered, and it only
includes tweets collected from Twitter between January 2019 and December 2021.
Additionally, the dataset only includes tweets that were written in English.
Despite these limitations, we hope that this is a meaningful contribution to
improving the automated detection of antisemitic speech. | [
-0.5804525018,
-0.7412754893,
0.0838588178,
0.0265865065,
-0.5363751054,
0.3553009927,
-0.1977908462,
-0.6361922622,
0.7227213979,
0.5869050622,
-0.3842604458,
-0.6841294765,
-0.9444795251,
-0.0625761151,
-0.841389358,
1.2984617949,
-0.093254827,
-0.1022818759,
0.5696189404,
-0.3625863791,
0.1278361082,
-0.2453685403,
-0.5512754917,
-0.1434931606,
0.7412241697,
0.3838983178,
0.8794779778,
0.8898163438,
0.4292096198,
0.1610417068,
-0.0735033378,
-0.276725322,
-0.3130527139,
0.1565557569,
-0.3077189922,
0.0033819899,
-0.3231869638,
0.2279063761,
0.4084179997,
0.4126605093,
0.3372313082,
0.3641006649,
-0.2931396663,
0.2853306234,
-0.4813572168,
-0.0846929178,
-0.3982211649,
0.1205088124,
-0.7611215711,
0.0406215824,
-0.2265009433,
-0.6629242301,
0.0753787756,
-0.4196522832,
0.3417235613,
0.1647797525,
0.6940561533,
0.226492703,
-0.384421587,
-0.4149718881,
-0.5934340358,
0.7292869091,
-0.571942389,
0.3585285246,
0.6611245275,
0.2698806822,
0.2231228203,
-0.1657101959,
-0.4252336323,
-0.0511823408,
0.0971330255,
-0.04465314,
-0.567072928,
-0.1953266561,
0.2571367025,
0.1149371639,
-0.4654370248,
0.3065492809,
-0.4752073288,
-0.4353334904,
0.6569994688,
-0.096312277,
0.2463479191,
-0.0746029094,
-0.3469096124,
0.0064728535,
-0.5132417679,
-0.2147416174,
0.7838332057,
0.4104656279,
0.0129437195,
0.5599150062,
-0.0660666898,
0.4436870515,
-0.199396804,
0.1011323854,
0.5725352168,
-0.0100439712,
0.03296455,
0.2088185102,
0.770498395,
0.575391233,
0.6207914352,
-0.3595376909,
-0.3099749982,
0.2338563204,
0.3815581501,
-0.908711791,
-0.454636544,
0.1376797557,
-0.3286407888,
-0.3082299232,
-0.1288950741,
-0.892385006,
-0.820101738,
-0.089760609,
0.2955676019,
-0.2342057228,
-0.1607501805,
-0.3384735882,
-0.4082270563,
-0.3090624213,
0.3668751717,
-0.5873138905,
0.263980031,
0.2844104171,
0.5421882868,
0.0721630901,
0.1892668307,
-0.6486693621,
0.0207873806,
-0.478230685,
0.8060598373,
-0.7431480289,
-0.0807356983,
0.2685492635,
-0.0019681726,
0.5027827621,
-0.4304584563,
0.7188593149,
-0.5984079838,
0.0392815061,
-0.3784476817,
-0.6443356872,
-0.1156961247,
0.0599454716,
-0.5013741255,
0.7151619792,
0.1452467591,
-0.9832606912,
0.1563032866,
-0.7016373277,
-0.5525561571,
0.258551091,
-0.1279699951,
-0.5737074614,
-0.1169128641,
0.0307897236,
0.2205228657,
-0.3310433626,
0.2030617893,
-0.2713874876,
-0.3050448596,
0.2109409422,
-0.0440170169,
1.098315835,
0.2864937484,
-0.7384033799,
0.3111751974,
-0.5896089077,
-0.2175950706,
0.2602609694,
0.0963333473,
-0.3793558478,
0.1201455221,
0.4747528136,
0.0578644276,
-0.064376533,
-1.0450183153,
-0.0725455433,
-0.29744789,
0.2373018563,
1.0005061626,
-0.1410523951,
0.1405145675,
-0.2487841398,
0.5644794106,
0.2573278844,
0.4125659168,
0.1731692851,
-0.5291689038,
-0.7079703808,
0.1698506325,
0.1144399047,
0.8818072677,
-0.7213224769,
0.686766088,
-0.0652926341,
-0.6365415454,
-0.4197216928,
0.0090612359,
0.5754035115,
0.6093181968,
0.8218686581,
-0.0756918415,
-0.8346056938,
-1.3088878393,
-0.2895540595,
-0.3936002553,
0.217821613,
-0.1354889274,
0.7230914235,
-0.1722184569,
0.7670227289,
-0.4384235442,
-0.3886631429,
0.0022543718,
0.526845336,
-0.1901261955,
0.2927072048,
0.6113917828,
-0.8577882648,
-0.7421269417,
-0.3618561625,
-0.2697156668,
-0.3133795857,
0.3095250726,
-0.1549819857,
0.0690852404,
0.2092719376,
0.3486156166,
0.6925496459,
0.3974658251,
-0.3161772788,
0.0429791547,
0.6094519496,
0.222169742,
-1.0654290915,
-0.355722487,
0.3931057751,
-0.169315502,
-0.8653483391,
-0.4768776596,
0.0010347604,
0.4360976815,
-0.6671053171,
0.5722251534,
0.1391745657,
0.369481802,
-0.385096401,
0.1000195518,
-0.5177241564,
-0.0396034531,
-0.1188638583,
0.584508419,
0.4530371428,
-0.2213139385,
0.9075988531,
0.554694891,
-0.2426933944,
0.5118941069,
-0.2238047421,
-0.0453558341,
-0.2923898697,
0.4201110601,
-0.9152477384,
-0.1607027203,
0.9753800631,
-0.6388348937,
-0.0243874248,
-0.2562057972,
-0.6534013152,
-0.5475886464,
-0.4415578246,
0.3177444637,
0.4166327119,
-0.3119215071,
0.1012832299,
0.7212660909,
0.1331889927,
-0.4407120943,
-0.9498351812,
0.2911668122,
-0.3014756143,
-0.3048334718,
0.2990689278,
-0.0405434966,
-0.3477981687,
0.2113098204,
0.0096072052,
-0.2121632546,
0.1040221602,
0.3350311518,
-0.0711224303,
0.0064027347,
0.3222509623,
-0.0164280944,
-0.0723535791,
-0.0176668223,
-0.2434860766,
0.4213895798,
0.026681425,
-0.1848371476,
-0.3600013554,
0.5926856995,
-0.0083984667,
-0.0530006438,
0.767120719,
1.057557106,
-0.647110939,
-0.0638485998,
-0.5210363865,
-0.2720412314,
-0.3551434278,
0.1389671415,
0.0790258497,
-0.884167254,
0.6713516712,
0.3982879817,
0.2301732898,
0.7146323919,
0.5457083583,
-0.2786117196,
0.7908036113,
0.3035127819,
-0.06278418,
0.6814441085,
0.1068441346,
0.3822045028,
-0.3848136067,
-0.0076381844,
-0.8958956003,
-0.2912553549,
-0.7017539144,
-0.1299282461,
0.0315500349,
-0.4181556106,
-0.3731133044,
0.4681541622,
-0.6359487772,
0.4353849292,
0.604829967,
-0.0279402491,
-0.2228715569,
0.199737668,
0.4752079248,
-0.2459563613,
-0.1254741549,
-0.5527223945,
0.9689620137,
0.3616968095,
0.4914205968,
0.2458005399,
0.750054121,
0.8669852614,
0.8218076825,
-0.555921495,
0.4615226388,
-0.5008667707,
-0.9026859999,
-0.2380469292,
-0.5397385359,
-0.7546630502,
-0.3151055574,
-0.0095984777,
-1.0461455584,
-0.1393066347,
0.2025095522,
-0.2613631487,
0.5961207747,
-0.4885132611,
0.7431178689,
0.0092471382,
-0.0164023992,
0.0715818405,
-0.7750685811,
0.1023296639,
-0.3786553144,
0.58777529,
-0.5942627788,
-0.0398133919,
1.5016866922,
-0.246952042,
1.0449972153,
-0.2883855402,
-0.119592011,
0.2850465178,
-0.1418796927,
0.1861568093,
-0.4901708066,
-0.0985036269,
0.1186517626,
-0.1112883165,
-0.5426927209,
-0.0242871605,
0.5075220466,
-0.6370691061,
-0.4110271931,
-0.2463684231,
-0.3484434187,
-0.1956777275,
0.2599012852,
0.3945224881,
0.6061028242,
-0.1042243391,
0.0700145289,
0.748303473,
-0.1536080986,
0.3296523094,
0.1908604354,
-0.2397444248,
-0.7542808652,
1.0679994822,
0.6498995423,
-0.058379665,
0.1917519271,
0.2144153714,
-0.414283365,
-0.6502537131,
-0.6644994617,
0.0214202777,
-0.8923912048,
-0.2032857239,
-0.6969178915,
-0.0859760866,
-0.8418977261,
-0.2725649178,
-0.3252565861,
-0.4516381025,
-0.3548995852,
-0.0080046579,
0.5713226795,
0.9766904712,
-0.1497607827,
0.7138928175,
-0.7993735671,
0.6329391003,
-0.3113577366,
0.4860602915,
-0.3547578156,
-0.7279044986,
-0.4343990982,
0.2288169712,
-0.2216236293,
-1.3263306618,
0.1074783579,
-0.1643945426,
0.4647942781,
0.3915189505,
0.6744384766,
0.5360618234,
-0.4408470988,
0.8355363011,
0.2175510675,
-1.0035611391,
0.9201464653,
-0.3911615312,
-0.03225201,
0.4338242412,
0.7888420224,
-0.627569139,
-0.9337670803,
-0.7423736453,
-0.7861205935,
0.7888035774,
0.2375333607,
0.0626263097,
-0.2245751917,
-0.0700878724,
0.0279017966,
0.1429182589,
-0.656113863,
-0.7228477597,
-0.3389395475,
-0.5467658043,
0.0348401964,
-0.4000937939,
-0.5331268311,
-0.2045814544,
0.9872229695,
0.1945996135,
-0.109982118,
-0.1865785867,
-0.120792672,
-0.4621356428,
0.2330301255,
0.4385939837,
0.7218304873,
-0.2293365598,
0.2673899233,
-0.3088337481,
-0.4904399812,
0.2064494789,
0.4062934518,
-0.4418701231,
0.1742685735,
0.2916800678,
0.7080408335,
-0.3805580735,
-0.4927299321,
0.4984261394,
0.2351006418,
-0.2286407948,
-0.5079196692,
-0.1555726081,
-0.1236586422,
0.2874748409,
0.5120501518,
-0.1830027848,
0.0542764962,
-0.2823341489,
0.4619827569,
0.0949247554,
-0.4980909526,
-0.3759014606,
0.701538384,
0.1684169918,
-0.4284460545,
0.4809873402,
-0.3328903913,
-0.8644327521,
0.5220521688,
0.2325731963,
0.7844654918,
-0.4893472493,
0.4150545001,
0.4762775898,
0.6625857949,
0.291527003,
0.2551437318,
0.1118481979,
-0.770686686,
-0.0704903901,
-0.5064196587,
-0.433234781,
0.0238843113,
-0.5607764125,
-0.0331006534,
-0.6020671129,
-0.451504916,
0.6111954451,
0.0723020136,
-0.3123779595,
0.4767897427,
0.3818349242,
0.8286631703,
-1.397444129,
0.7446880937,
0.7443886399,
-0.490911454,
-0.112652123,
0.0385358334,
0.3336708546,
-0.6450558305,
0.5739198923,
0.177190721,
-0.075919427,
-0.0829532817,
-0.7171677351,
-0.5886147022,
0.2342924625,
0.0401878692,
-0.3242716193,
0.4283287823,
0.3665547669,
0.3556136787,
-0.2417947501,
-0.0255539939,
0.5175951719,
0.7419340014,
0.1515792012,
-0.7601975203,
0.1102420539,
-0.1692360491,
-0.3935685158,
0.6187713146,
-0.4931977093,
0.5740436316,
0.2120669037,
-0.1944706887,
-0.3044488132,
0.4828965068,
-0.485221535,
0.3961479664,
0.7452970147,
0.6549232602,
0.5114685297,
-0.3638373017,
0.6014308929,
0.2234154791,
0.1546265334,
1.0769579411,
0.0911289454,
0.4368812144,
0.3376282156,
-0.0402151868,
-0.1282402128,
0.7798276544,
-0.2386167794,
0.3106948137,
0.4806135893,
-0.4323600531,
-0.3111976087,
-0.6472295523,
-0.2901913822,
-0.0396213308,
0.4670806527,
-0.4423653483,
-0.6389750242,
0.3896624446,
0.3020814061,
0.1817193031,
-0.3317905068,
0.6900559664,
-0.2501243949,
-0.1850522757,
0.3888373673,
0.1155029759,
0.5313819051,
-0.1047258303,
0.1923348904,
0.1363355219,
0.1046005711,
-0.3415603638,
-1.120955348,
0.7414367199,
0.3839630485,
-0.0611970387,
-0.5461845994,
0.4158437252,
-0.4277876019,
-0.2784336507,
0.3868552446,
0.2458118796,
0.4948798716,
-0.006058536,
-0.6845896244,
0.5355011225,
0.4261928201,
-0.1691324264,
0.0704485178,
0.0820114985,
-0.3034781516,
0.450322032,
0.3749982715,
0.0577402078,
0.2335100919,
0.3246622384,
0.865468204,
-0.7584987283,
-0.1736210734,
-0.8754737973,
0.3443204761,
-0.131893903,
-0.4894244075,
0.6723436117,
0.7093558311,
0.9857974648,
0.4001625776,
0.9006495476,
-0.0946771502,
1.0968263149,
-0.0335833952,
0.4505578578,
-0.6192937493,
-0.1366123557,
-0.0931538716,
-0.770222187,
-0.6915326118,
0.6597543955,
-0.6692777872,
-0.2193567753,
0.3631092012,
0.5720658898,
-0.0843155235,
0.3951462805,
0.1854502261,
0.4841787815,
0.7668256164,
0.1241569817,
0.641972959,
-0.5558471084,
0.5419901609,
-0.6307897568,
-0.1645762771,
-0.3272393942,
-0.6539160013,
-0.8506593704,
-0.8077772856,
-0.8003038168,
-0.6630556583,
0.278387785,
1.0753042698,
0.3976195157,
-0.9624913931,
0.0590482466,
0.248072207,
0.0164668877,
0.2964754105,
-0.2181801498,
0.2604864538,
-0.0535387062,
-0.7994975448,
0.1128409505,
0.1152546927,
0.2719381452,
0.0213407092,
0.4046097994,
-0.2481516153,
0.1909872591,
0.2548062801,
0.2397329062,
-0.6711197495,
-0.5006108284,
-0.5288093686,
-0.2143110484,
0.03388872,
0.34640944,
-0.3885878325,
0.2398850024,
0.139456585,
0.6712714434,
0.3756870627,
-0.0855481327,
-0.1431716979,
-0.6874153018,
0.1486940682,
0.6899847388,
0.1667026132,
0.3021016717,
0.075788781,
0.4152855277,
0.3132793605,
-0.2746558487,
-0.8813176155,
0.5168190002,
-0.8819476962,
-0.160319373,
1.189835906,
-0.0003280854,
-0.2759192586,
-0.623771131,
-0.0495635718,
0.4244195521,
-0.661640048,
0.576344192,
0.8183835149,
0.1579898596,
-0.0156276189,
-0.6580488682,
0.4157371819,
0.11903961,
-0.6115532517,
0.1804769933,
0.6126255989,
0.106363602,
0.2359125614,
0.7589001656,
0.1981171221,
0.129705295,
-0.1731286645,
0.1454315037,
0.0251914486,
-0.3772884905,
0.0869916975,
0.0375747792,
-0.440102756,
-0.4538735151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14590v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14590v2 | A logical word embedding for learning grammar | 2023-04-28T01:53:54 | 2023-06-06T00:46:49 | Sean Deyo, Veit Elser | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the logical grammar emdebbing (LGE), a model inspired by
pregroup grammars and categorial grammars to enable unsupervised inference of
lexical categories and syntactic rules from a corpus of text. LGE produces
comprehensible output summarizing its inferences, has a completely transparent
process for producing novel sentences, and can learn from as few as a hundred
sentences. | [
-0.1889586896,
-1.1920559406,
0.9496253729,
-0.2337531,
-0.1304736584,
-0.052883815,
0.1306459308,
-0.1706731021,
0.4463984072,
0.6128361225,
-0.7935809493,
-0.6035100222,
-0.3783679605,
0.1081317812,
-0.5504080057,
0.7195329666,
0.1918644458,
0.0115305986,
-0.3942970335,
0.2910751104,
-0.3222120702,
-0.4568288624,
-0.2694087625,
-0.3297176659,
0.2262995839,
0.379101336,
0.5533974171,
0.6823644042,
-0.0298028179,
0.4442160726,
0.1081816033,
0.0538601205,
-0.2144771367,
0.0477743112,
-0.4894495904,
-0.7359167337,
-0.2556892037,
0.1523866504,
0.4216050208,
0.9296765924,
-0.4597183168,
0.1079415679,
-0.0634187087,
0.4965277612,
-0.6116290689,
0.4371243715,
-0.459982127,
0.4155639708,
0.0235641785,
0.0738911629,
-0.6854500175,
-0.6871333718,
-0.0340362079,
-0.8144854903,
-0.0858545303,
0.2258378565,
0.6391131878,
0.1597721875,
-0.348210007,
-0.4127314091,
-0.2613650262,
0.6683931947,
-0.6533338428,
0.6221475601,
0.5439901352,
0.1581983119,
-0.2259771824,
-1.4152323008,
-0.505875349,
0.0299977884,
-0.2443278581,
0.2637422979,
-0.2438531965,
0.476780206,
0.409272939,
0.3330571353,
-0.417224288,
-0.2238621861,
-0.0938016772,
-0.0543089509,
0.3566368222,
-0.0939137116,
0.3809117675,
-0.1182657853,
-0.3127729893,
0.1503965557,
-0.477650702,
-0.0425957516,
0.2391169965,
0.0424564518,
0.2891326547,
0.881981194,
-0.1342227459,
0.9391242862,
0.1389802396,
-0.3610181212,
0.3333896697,
-0.0767639652,
-0.671744585,
0.2955387533,
0.3171231747,
0.2423887104,
0.4292066395,
-0.304053843,
-0.2197844982,
0.7658137679,
0.0617921352,
-0.6145255566,
-0.1794708371,
-0.2156480998,
-0.5719499588,
-0.2275480479,
0.2455076724,
-0.7688513994,
-0.3189151883,
-0.2606167197,
0.5914139748,
-0.3226057887,
-0.0734478608,
0.5450232625,
-0.3704443276,
0.2447087765,
0.2576146722,
-0.6905838251,
0.4250047207,
0.6794235706,
0.2952533066,
0.5920909643,
-0.2108148485,
-0.6725919843,
0.2095814347,
-0.3538500369,
0.8751380444,
-0.6695162058,
-0.1823227108,
0.1327342838,
0.1760174483,
-0.1465398073,
-0.2064068466,
0.5259307027,
-0.455373019,
0.5085451603,
-0.0575954169,
-1.3016941547,
-0.7755238414,
0.0775535628,
-0.5393118858,
0.5158907175,
0.0460074469,
-0.5266670585,
0.6331124902,
-0.1272723079,
-0.2387716323,
0.2109404206,
-0.5148506761,
-0.0013699641,
0.3133313954,
0.0687190294,
0.6296912432,
-0.2031251937,
0.4579431713,
-0.3715210855,
-0.0028564718,
-0.254637599,
0.2149136066,
0.6734784245,
0.2832388878,
-0.2317005396,
0.2084338963,
-0.7449133992,
0.4743594825,
0.0875962377,
-0.0968684182,
-0.6481943727,
0.3543780446,
-0.4842022359,
0.163599208,
-0.1769548953,
-0.7183908224,
0.1770312488,
-0.4402096272,
0.4003147185,
0.6498565078,
-0.0042531528,
0.5774539113,
-0.3863594532,
0.3372297585,
-0.2395351231,
-0.2198258191,
-0.4029309452,
-0.4378673136,
-0.7717209458,
-0.4813950956,
0.3069766164,
0.6990063787,
-0.7015871406,
0.8809936047,
0.1753999293,
-0.2377079427,
-0.4250561595,
0.3758065999,
0.3192349374,
0.3673510253,
0.0250886623,
-0.1544365138,
-0.6406101584,
-0.9743132591,
-0.4528937936,
-0.0782388449,
0.1703605205,
-0.1593980789,
0.4033592641,
-0.3639926612,
0.812595129,
-0.6835380197,
-0.382873565,
-0.7944869995,
-0.0448194928,
0.2087872922,
0.0833858401,
0.4516602755,
-0.3561555445,
-0.3401281536,
-0.3385709524,
-0.9904847145,
-0.3198438883,
-0.0516995266,
-0.2693243325,
0.1416720152,
1.2414186001,
-0.5405356884,
0.6855906248,
0.4572761953,
-0.9527747631,
0.0350820944,
0.0082210042,
-0.3134509027,
-1.0986362696,
-0.5426225662,
-0.3186426461,
-0.8663324714,
-0.4205047786,
0.2449017763,
0.1990086287,
-0.0224127378,
-0.4203546345,
0.1914782971,
-0.5910493731,
0.0209841784,
-0.0942399949,
0.2213596553,
0.1801869124,
0.4106293619,
0.0209429897,
0.2597197592,
0.5491729379,
-0.4695618749,
0.3426743448,
0.2661645114,
-0.7656743526,
0.1452114284,
-0.4321696162,
-0.1046356559,
-0.5484783053,
0.3251517117,
-0.7649439573,
-0.1175520569,
0.0878694504,
-0.0938110054,
0.1557501405,
0.2466058284,
-0.5155003667,
-0.0587582476,
-0.3154987693,
0.2171981931,
0.6280805469,
-0.6609291434,
0.8645579815,
0.5185979605,
0.2512111962,
-0.3418996632,
-0.6984727979,
-0.3455416262,
0.0317945406,
-0.5309402943,
0.1054555923,
0.3924399018,
-0.6383293867,
0.4974536598,
-0.0758494288,
0.1865064204,
0.0851302817,
0.3109661341,
-0.0942816734,
-0.2643738687,
0.4558150768,
-0.1461785138,
0.0820578933,
0.3166853786,
-0.2975702286,
0.580170691,
-0.4046847224,
-0.4952184856,
-0.1708857715,
0.448936224,
0.2371847183,
-0.2220065892,
0.6900296211,
0.2939331532,
-0.6733065844,
-0.9011157155,
-0.4128241241,
-0.2459026575,
-0.4787239134,
0.3899710476,
-0.3041889668,
-0.9941471815,
0.3031950891,
-0.2450749129,
-0.0465214886,
0.4483993948,
0.095023565,
-0.0326185189,
0.7404870987,
0.8413367271,
0.2997346818,
0.3003033102,
0.0484320857,
0.424831152,
-0.0773043633,
-0.3400111794,
-0.1616304368,
-0.0437324345,
-0.7333135605,
-0.4335576296,
-0.1115339622,
0.3219938576,
-0.467741251,
-0.0788433626,
-0.0766608119,
0.7581527233,
0.8374934196,
0.2251220495,
0.1687541902,
0.1456201524,
-0.4227088094,
0.013716883,
-0.848846674,
-0.3623093069,
0.7212521434,
0.3200565279,
1.3496387005,
0.2997516394,
1.0281450748,
0.3156556487,
-0.087486513,
-1.0914754868,
0.8704151511,
-0.2842308879,
-0.5214366317,
-0.0332450084,
-0.0803835765,
-0.6905760765,
0.3137909174,
-0.5940656066,
-0.7074130177,
-0.0476083718,
0.0296198595,
-0.3003362417,
0.695872426,
-0.7955079079,
0.7836694717,
-0.1078695357,
-0.3794196248,
-0.3419664204,
-0.4339833558,
0.5469143391,
-0.0299209263,
0.3087678552,
0.0467736274,
0.0598207302,
0.8536791205,
-0.4517930448,
1.2811475992,
-0.0657905936,
-0.0404411033,
0.8298925161,
0.4155835509,
0.2658088207,
-0.1111950278,
0.3053936362,
-0.1245783567,
0.0047126524,
-0.0705311447,
-0.5689750314,
0.5134623051,
-0.5147474408,
-0.9271113276,
-0.7914982438,
-0.1625432223,
-0.2634647191,
0.477873832,
-0.0241329763,
0.2502767146,
-0.3193714619,
0.2634395361,
0.6881833076,
-0.5443024635,
0.465605408,
0.1873754412,
-0.9200526476,
-0.3935538232,
0.5083091855,
-0.1326646358,
0.3173267543,
0.4944061637,
0.3899991214,
-0.507525444,
0.1208038107,
0.0206257906,
0.3332341313,
-1.1452300549,
-0.1817621291,
-0.6544975638,
-0.3667777777,
-0.4415795505,
-0.4556631744,
-0.1337744594,
-0.6679725647,
-0.1053618342,
-0.6152190566,
0.2584891319,
1.2424175739,
-0.1275147945,
0.3391595483,
-0.8834759593,
0.2928911448,
0.5532898307,
0.3191064596,
-0.3919113576,
-0.345382601,
0.2403970063,
-0.2770494223,
-0.1660564244,
-1.105389595,
0.3230813444,
0.6049785018,
0.8941278458,
0.7260432243,
-0.1978792399,
0.5736698508,
-0.6975876093,
0.6159300804,
0.381382525,
-1.3089507818,
0.6671181321,
-0.2580335736,
0.1215452254,
0.3690125942,
0.1457733959,
-0.405049026,
-0.1051376313,
-0.7446221113,
-0.6627032757,
0.5337567925,
-0.4801803827,
-0.1934472322,
-0.4770497382,
0.2813292444,
0.0601879917,
0.3241451085,
-0.8981575966,
-0.0396378152,
-0.2319651842,
-0.3779456615,
-0.3275934756,
-0.4779295325,
-0.1036665961,
-0.3643860221,
0.3991972208,
-0.0524325855,
0.288588047,
0.1394641846,
-0.4858537018,
-0.0293695293,
0.3197510242,
0.3691581488,
0.4984181821,
-0.1832820326,
0.6135861278,
0.0749875754,
-0.2192455977,
0.2229405195,
-0.3297546804,
-0.0285977069,
0.0052620149,
0.6998077035,
0.6124942303,
0.1752593219,
-0.7285629511,
0.5310018063,
0.0638786703,
-0.6300817132,
-0.522326529,
0.1242104918,
0.226484105,
0.4353734255,
-0.1251477599,
-0.1871605963,
-0.0212283004,
-0.8102246523,
0.6134446263,
0.4212319255,
-0.0995160714,
-0.1203299165,
0.488732785,
0.0845237449,
-0.0224072561,
0.5330450535,
-0.2398762554,
-0.601996839,
0.4399512112,
1.0017592907,
0.9273524284,
-0.2567387521,
0.3371525705,
0.4445377588,
0.6034386158,
-0.3549469113,
0.5013119578,
0.1233591065,
-0.921328783,
-0.5276278257,
-0.8727721572,
-0.0352976844,
0.005238309,
-0.6070038676,
0.209796831,
-0.7796813846,
0.1230613962,
-0.0330825113,
-0.4858383536,
-0.6522866488,
0.355281353,
0.4445498288,
1.191677928,
-1.0731002092,
0.6931260824,
0.9526059031,
-0.1871692687,
-0.9063921571,
-0.1945765316,
0.1780027896,
-1.0374418497,
0.8747317791,
0.3163425326,
-0.2415631413,
0.1596301198,
-0.4851650298,
-0.8825602531,
0.9855320454,
0.222557947,
-0.7155828476,
-0.0897109956,
0.005946422,
0.1796631962,
-0.3777647316,
0.0629957244,
0.3340319395,
0.402962625,
-0.3062694073,
-0.40733096,
0.2312884033,
0.0540877953,
-0.3025924265,
0.304818511,
-0.3868507445,
0.8924059272,
-0.2503976226,
-0.4698258638,
-0.2712693512,
0.7593743205,
-0.1312299967,
0.1222512797,
0.7378692627,
1.2389881611,
0.882358551,
-0.0905907676,
0.9247045517,
-0.0415458307,
0.2532512248,
1.1536706686,
-0.1858207881,
0.6472455263,
0.3630254269,
0.0329861604,
0.6764018536,
0.4906244576,
0.2323490381,
0.7873510122,
0.3237864673,
-0.4087354839,
-0.6155450344,
-0.0363843776,
-0.1695580631,
0.6914658546,
0.733024776,
-0.7433154583,
-0.6140294075,
-0.1452464163,
0.014929235,
0.3760293424,
-0.76752913,
1.0051432848,
0.2178102732,
-0.8179409504,
0.3316467106,
0.0400360227,
0.421581924,
-0.673412919,
-0.3508140445,
-0.0524988659,
0.5475151539,
-0.4040490091,
-0.6979022622,
0.3076268137,
-0.3434691131,
0.1047594696,
-0.3121722639,
1.0540837049,
-0.5625166297,
-0.6689538956,
0.5887230635,
0.9644960165,
-0.0899835229,
0.3424691558,
-0.3308547139,
-0.2993310392,
0.189525649,
-0.4736972451,
0.1085809693,
0.5829766989,
-0.1813190579,
0.4936333895,
0.339992553,
-0.128517285,
0.2908068001,
0.1279354841,
0.7446458936,
-0.9345678091,
-0.6520838737,
-1.0358866453,
0.233233884,
0.2686015666,
0.2377852648,
0.8110717535,
0.297314316,
1.0560796261,
-0.238371253,
0.9669388533,
-0.2237484604,
0.30117926,
-0.6974161863,
0.524754703,
-0.5106006265,
-0.1903551817,
-0.2741315663,
-0.8484924436,
-0.4345562458,
1.1996514797,
-0.0382329524,
-0.1242442727,
1.0451004505,
0.5875113606,
-0.1799272448,
0.1819578111,
0.6763564944,
0.2204807997,
0.0068337652,
0.5627549887,
0.8924044371,
-0.0036592216,
-0.1085597724,
-0.1171279997,
-0.4251289666,
0.2074264586,
-1.0870828629,
-1.1886531115,
-0.3465393484,
-0.1198294088,
-0.4242668152,
0.0120633179,
1.2080475092,
0.2274627239,
-0.6425853968,
-0.0291219819,
-0.5441459417,
0.0733271837,
0.0422578342,
-0.1946635693,
0.3022376001,
-0.5017169714,
-0.4389736354,
0.3933272958,
0.0394092314,
-0.0692157671,
0.1190539747,
0.1970816702,
-0.543920815,
0.2821497321,
0.9005886912,
0.0972734019,
-0.7373713851,
-0.4345933497,
-0.1231387481,
0.0549162924,
-0.597723484,
0.6287817359,
-0.7859413624,
0.4193738401,
0.624394536,
0.8562435508,
0.1887641847,
0.0008641566,
0.506758213,
-0.612840116,
0.4172497094,
0.0640310347,
0.7209689021,
-0.1845243573,
-0.0512512363,
0.5430257916,
0.4518871307,
-0.3616320491,
-0.5558202267,
0.3281948268,
-0.600797236,
-0.567030549,
1.2097634077,
-0.2488996089,
-0.4501945972,
0.1682197601,
0.0528416038,
0.2916166484,
-0.0236768872,
0.2842491567,
0.7535076737,
-0.0520884842,
-0.2273155451,
-0.4879668951,
0.5590143204,
0.5875520706,
-0.9136961102,
-0.2618710399,
0.8028656244,
0.3614501059,
-0.0599842891,
0.3908436894,
-0.0104865991,
0.0731151477,
0.3482384086,
0.3670888543,
-0.0602977276,
-0.3426828086,
-0.0408411175,
0.3218416572,
0.0333228894,
-0.2258351445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14585v1 | Improving Knowledge Graph Entity Alignment with Graph Augmentation | 2023-04-28T01:22:47 | 2023-04-28T01:22:47 | Feng Xie, Xiang Zeng, Bin Zhou, Yusong Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Entity alignment (EA) which links equivalent entities across different
knowledge graphs (KGs) plays a crucial role in knowledge fusion. In recent
years, graph neural networks (GNNs) have been successfully applied in many
embedding-based EA methods. However, existing GNN-based methods either suffer
from the structural heterogeneity issue that especially appears in the real KG
distributions or ignore the heterogeneous representation learning for unseen
(unlabeled) entities, which would lead the model to overfit on few alignment
seeds (i.e., training data) and thus cause unsatisfactory alignment
performance. To enhance the EA ability, we propose GAEA, a novel EA approach
based on graph augmentation. In this model, we design a simple Entity-Relation
(ER) Encoder to generate latent representations for entities via jointly
modeling comprehensive structural information and rich relation semantics.
Moreover, we use graph augmentation to create two graph views for margin-based
alignment learning and contrastive entity representation learning, thus
mitigating structural heterogeneity and further improving the model's alignment
performance. Extensive experiments conducted on benchmark datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of our method. | [
-0.4166077077,
-0.7267126441,
0.4915313125,
-0.2742491364,
-0.1499539167,
0.2619132698,
0.054487396,
-0.6690226197,
0.5769866705,
0.2809612453,
-0.3954652548,
-0.68689996,
-0.43032673,
-0.0958264545,
0.0764427781,
0.8710843325,
-0.2046416551,
-0.0613513514,
-0.5077465773,
-0.5921426415,
-0.4155307412,
-0.0950839892,
-0.5239229202,
-0.4014060497,
0.3543478549,
0.2023128122,
0.8515965343,
0.9196981788,
0.1944472641,
0.2494852096,
0.0221256148,
0.8069329858,
-0.3971139193,
-0.1126895472,
-0.091211319,
-0.2740755975,
-0.7539637685,
-0.3215374649,
0.6686986089,
0.9826827645,
-0.0193894301,
0.0068952381,
0.2612738013,
0.3976750076,
-0.5503786802,
0.3609541953,
-0.4526385367,
-0.0929859132,
-0.0536286086,
0.0348469727,
-0.2801047266,
-0.2923984826,
0.1678733379,
-1.1626565456,
0.1927084327,
0.2675794363,
1.4109733105,
0.2767353356,
-0.6046833396,
-0.0720379278,
-0.6021806002,
0.2833595574,
-0.5847286582,
0.7757852674,
-0.1010201499,
0.1900191456,
-0.0613357574,
-0.783639729,
-0.6289743185,
0.1836717427,
-0.3358836472,
0.0886322707,
-0.2516242862,
0.0641179308,
0.0337381549,
0.306963414,
-0.4984329641,
0.1467404515,
-0.0989906713,
-0.3395540714,
0.4710097015,
0.1500679106,
0.5974903703,
0.1386552751,
-0.45851928,
-0.1259100586,
-0.7716298103,
-0.292419076,
0.8208428621,
0.3575650156,
0.121205382,
0.5055300593,
-0.1049761474,
0.6823529601,
0.2340830415,
0.1922466755,
0.737482667,
-0.2114335448,
-0.2512850165,
0.165285334,
0.5577308536,
0.4804565907,
-0.1820344627,
-0.673039794,
0.0228756368,
0.2349558175,
0.2163725495,
-0.677904129,
-0.4112098515,
0.0965088308,
-0.1967859715,
-0.1284141392,
0.079071179,
-0.8048457503,
-0.3197408915,
-0.2620400488,
0.3702015579,
-0.6445086598,
-0.2051544785,
-0.2583120763,
-0.0985596552,
0.0681471378,
0.1393767595,
-0.7836339474,
0.3898874521,
0.4907669723,
0.6318565011,
0.1139178798,
-0.3630481064,
-0.5285435319,
0.8227253556,
-0.3082668483,
0.521373868,
-0.6166152954,
-0.0989030302,
-0.1080105975,
0.0574033633,
-0.0473362841,
-0.2818068564,
0.392483741,
-0.7008495927,
0.1329943836,
-0.2986283898,
-0.9741593599,
-0.51179111,
0.2004164159,
-0.8720981479,
0.7612608671,
0.1327478886,
-0.7426242232,
0.5318729281,
-0.6112824082,
-0.382974565,
0.0198206417,
-0.4771507382,
-0.5550439358,
-0.1912675798,
0.7621248364,
0.0730967075,
0.046813678,
-0.0346264765,
-0.4792850912,
-0.1003192663,
-0.2717048228,
-0.1320965141,
0.5291892886,
-0.0861547738,
-0.1076681241,
0.1067963168,
-0.7302986383,
0.0847135112,
0.1250894219,
0.0944516808,
-0.6088079214,
-0.1668861955,
-0.5499619246,
0.0471645594,
0.2665910423,
-0.4929327965,
0.3704646826,
-0.6564375758,
0.0897848159,
0.5780537128,
0.3079510629,
0.9316111803,
0.0388205126,
0.218722403,
0.1794783324,
-0.1673774868,
0.1919903606,
-0.4217686057,
-0.5530977845,
-0.0405334905,
0.5165101886,
0.4324906468,
-0.7940655351,
0.4838504791,
-0.7167597413,
-0.4069452286,
-0.7184802294,
0.3232515454,
0.2243481576,
1.0491943359,
0.651874423,
-0.4475795627,
-0.4439540207,
-0.9301288128,
-0.0328517593,
-0.0009437174,
0.0683693811,
0.5524032712,
0.1638340205,
-0.3567388058,
0.8123973608,
-0.6990986466,
-0.5260512829,
0.0780852586,
0.0776473284,
-0.2158217281,
0.5356951952,
0.7624582648,
-0.7979300022,
-0.3045653999,
0.3935758471,
-0.8933383226,
0.1532800943,
0.1823836863,
-0.4546179771,
0.0985501409,
0.3040526509,
-0.4809783101,
0.2832306623,
0.3780471981,
-0.320002526,
0.0070419712,
-0.1550930887,
0.107122764,
-1.1811594963,
-0.0821436197,
0.0319345668,
-0.2033605427,
-0.5380568504,
0.058487758,
0.1850009263,
-0.188967362,
-0.1049742922,
0.2912999392,
-0.823441267,
-0.1854433119,
-0.0250078719,
0.4497321844,
0.3912083507,
0.4629446566,
-0.1313997507,
0.5846626759,
0.4660080969,
-0.4504872262,
0.2822970748,
0.6116503477,
0.1044552997,
0.5921135545,
-0.4112003744,
0.4591238201,
-0.2931371927,
0.3670931458,
-0.7872707248,
-0.2450672835,
0.4955549538,
-0.3390561342,
0.7736122012,
-0.403051883,
-0.077102676,
-0.2741585076,
-0.0799048021,
0.3219503462,
0.2399578393,
-0.5916088223,
1.2588791847,
0.4036675096,
0.0810835287,
-0.7863461971,
-0.7289004326,
-0.0100316107,
-0.1761699468,
-1.0337411165,
0.7303475738,
0.4321948886,
0.1081314385,
0.7783426642,
-0.4158633649,
0.102374211,
-0.0328638032,
0.1850482523,
0.5617209673,
-0.4215907454,
0.3279033601,
0.1956760734,
-0.1629693359,
-0.1514050066,
-0.7075348496,
0.5138592124,
-0.0210742,
-0.5662090182,
-0.1983399093,
0.2425939739,
0.0600757636,
-0.5159255266,
1.0082439184,
0.5227099657,
-0.6896902323,
0.072661072,
-0.4117034674,
-0.0766049623,
-0.4253517687,
0.6046652198,
-0.3540572822,
-0.6041261554,
0.7812025547,
-0.1898733228,
-0.0324848816,
0.5848267078,
0.0903677642,
0.0033125677,
1.0555245876,
0.6164865494,
-0.3136405051,
0.2920604348,
-0.4704046249,
0.3905735612,
-1.0544155836,
-0.3137460053,
-0.3057595789,
-0.4226706326,
-0.3927337527,
-0.2523230016,
0.1625774205,
0.1881800145,
-0.2117557675,
0.3310557902,
-0.4347994924,
0.4792605042,
0.025245484,
0.2970318794,
0.1859293431,
0.1599834412,
-0.1754904985,
-0.0142606208,
-0.7199466228,
-0.511628747,
1.0501629114,
0.2458013147,
0.4911518991,
0.2403003871,
0.9395356774,
-0.0995334983,
0.4381504953,
-0.3673113286,
0.2077399045,
-0.1268425882,
-0.2173983455,
-0.5738483071,
-0.6380237341,
-0.6726395488,
0.161895141,
-0.2627415061,
-1.0227985382,
0.4703425169,
0.3832276464,
-0.2760600746,
0.5502289534,
-0.7679229975,
0.9883214831,
-0.0822210908,
-0.4204060435,
0.1330666989,
-0.5898008943,
0.1129850522,
0.3262424767,
-0.0198267903,
0.1232598722,
-0.1430514157,
0.5330862999,
-0.4812858701,
0.4623325467,
-0.4088789523,
-0.1154533774,
0.2584697902,
-0.2063757032,
1.0032116175,
0.0449080989,
-0.0161303338,
-0.0755357593,
-0.6763749719,
-0.444781363,
-1.0482604504,
0.7823694348,
-0.8207437396,
-0.4901249409,
0.1483479887,
-0.6891538501,
-0.6505810022,
0.1482257843,
0.3231044412,
0.4539747834,
-0.3167076111,
-0.0458471552,
0.5808659792,
0.1997823566,
0.0329550207,
0.0130960001,
-0.1799080521,
-0.6123372912,
1.1311126947,
0.4728907943,
0.29048419,
0.1761696488,
-0.3455244601,
-0.5006335378,
-0.5085402131,
-0.7976998687,
0.1412954479,
-0.797690928,
-0.3045542538,
-0.9227918983,
-0.0332846083,
-0.6769011617,
-0.1696729958,
-0.1525678635,
-0.2292605042,
-0.295673579,
-0.4069132507,
0.1862057745,
0.4045467079,
0.1080863178,
0.1159121245,
-0.6852900982,
0.1324964017,
0.2688544095,
0.2585545182,
0.2304253727,
-0.2052517235,
-0.161675781,
0.197535798,
-0.2960474491,
-1.1139628887,
0.1281085908,
0.2298617363,
0.7810678482,
0.3803091347,
-0.1410295367,
0.8621157408,
-0.2814226151,
0.4147513211,
0.171464473,
-0.7417680621,
0.257709384,
0.0245988816,
-0.320902735,
0.4636092782,
0.4245982468,
-0.177951619,
-0.2089482248,
-0.7915245295,
-1.0950651169,
0.2823617756,
0.1615107805,
0.1043847799,
0.2163050026,
0.2139480412,
-0.0655704439,
0.0740377903,
-0.4013287425,
-0.3731172979,
-0.2724208534,
-0.4913892448,
0.1362680644,
0.0537508652,
-0.3047477603,
-0.0259514581,
1.0479743481,
-0.4915085137,
0.1042882726,
0.2250747681,
-0.3082125783,
-0.2301163971,
0.0654462725,
0.0328177586,
0.47204265,
0.0268392228,
0.0209698044,
0.6042435765,
-0.2770615518,
0.2199920416,
0.6596950889,
-0.434395045,
-0.0992919058,
0.2339002341,
1.0450431108,
0.0750586167,
0.2194598913,
0.3591347933,
0.2140483856,
-0.0186649561,
0.3049983382,
-0.0411137901,
0.4937546551,
0.267480582,
0.2801908255,
0.0256813429,
0.0928815678,
-0.4424243569,
0.2288155407,
0.3697229028,
-0.4516156018,
-0.0902110562,
0.7629592419,
0.2702380121,
-0.0640366673,
0.7139029503,
-0.4085517824,
-0.5652456284,
0.6263237,
0.6924520731,
0.6223951578,
-0.027456332,
0.1529656798,
0.182806015,
0.2251283675,
0.3831361532,
0.1201517433,
0.258731693,
-1.0374119282,
-0.3540344834,
-0.3083792627,
-0.1392485052,
-0.1136045977,
-0.5805035233,
0.1685503125,
-0.0595674813,
0.0189445391,
0.1294784546,
0.1692390889,
-0.8803488612,
0.2489009798,
0.0434346683,
0.7555860281,
-1.0245729685,
0.6102636456,
1.0118323565,
-0.8747512102,
-1.3854700327,
0.0647454858,
-0.0869106427,
-0.4907408953,
0.0926258639,
0.1228322014,
0.1426374614,
0.2868131101,
-0.2994573712,
-0.6957729459,
1.5004900694,
0.6265518069,
-0.6395082474,
-0.397022754,
0.1148646995,
0.3976935148,
-0.6947826147,
0.0223597735,
0.223296389,
0.4928634465,
-0.0054526664,
-0.2794244885,
0.1727398187,
-0.2455978096,
-0.0979357138,
0.5294698477,
-0.652110815,
0.492181778,
-0.0396500602,
-0.3812143803,
-0.2496010512,
1.1883604527,
0.0833212286,
0.4107557833,
0.5569482446,
1.1167602539,
1.2855995893,
-0.1899284422,
0.8710924387,
-0.298186928,
0.306089133,
1.3272328377,
-0.5803512335,
0.2499615848,
0.4137634933,
0.0849170014,
0.6838225126,
0.3497506082,
-0.1790712625,
0.4743007421,
-0.2400877625,
-0.0664555207,
-0.1581307501,
-0.2323310524,
-0.4864682555,
0.0011543606,
0.158002466,
-0.4024142623,
-0.2980924249,
-0.1243556216,
-0.0517139733,
0.1285455376,
-0.3066462874,
0.7653256059,
-0.1345108002,
-0.190660134,
-0.1045377105,
-0.3492615819,
0.2001905441,
-0.4149715602,
-0.2201389372,
-0.0640496239,
-0.0846742392,
-0.4265324771,
-0.6406735182,
0.2331499159,
-0.3955673873,
-0.1911730021,
0.3622824848,
1.0709459782,
-0.5895136595,
-0.2179815471,
0.4528004229,
0.5753873587,
-0.2917361259,
0.2597396672,
-0.2855927944,
-0.1914361119,
-0.088982299,
-0.1517697573,
0.2277215272,
0.6504432559,
-0.1818688661,
0.3102004826,
0.6019200683,
-0.0139711285,
-0.0801304951,
0.1222528368,
1.0247834921,
-0.1732671559,
-0.6402621865,
-0.6822817326,
0.4665389955,
-0.5351471305,
-0.1760312319,
0.6581783295,
0.6976638436,
0.9279056191,
0.2390696555,
0.5910388231,
-0.043751698,
-0.0866634026,
-0.5469529629,
0.6472008824,
-0.4424164593,
0.0872956142,
-0.4598920345,
-1.1948295832,
-0.1406314075,
0.2390328795,
-0.3370793462,
-0.0438706465,
0.3240337074,
0.8310254812,
-0.3099116087,
0.1098307818,
0.0951266065,
0.0793591365,
0.35608688,
0.5324887037,
0.4583731294,
-0.5363134146,
0.6789320707,
-0.2680879235,
0.0534689389,
0.0106996614,
-0.8063248992,
-0.4888013303,
-0.3945065439,
-0.4224826396,
-0.5007407069,
0.2818481922,
0.7681255937,
0.4588631392,
-0.5567502975,
0.6335796714,
-0.165673703,
0.109414272,
-0.2318410426,
-0.1928672493,
0.6940733194,
-0.0668279305,
-0.6539554596,
0.3732942939,
0.2708799839,
0.2951470017,
-0.0403936319,
-0.3674747348,
-0.214826569,
-0.1893607378,
-0.0621850081,
0.2142048925,
-0.3682302833,
-0.8379432559,
-0.0420566835,
-0.1540625095,
0.2814672589,
0.2825952768,
-0.5977116227,
0.3737084866,
0.480266124,
1.0880440474,
0.4081758857,
0.2731016874,
0.6374208927,
-0.9733418226,
-0.0242819935,
0.1476489604,
0.6269645691,
0.5135529637,
-0.6492663622,
0.76933676,
0.1846393496,
-0.3474397063,
-0.715667367,
0.2119458318,
-0.7511002421,
0.1490753889,
0.7217160463,
-0.3834111392,
-0.4785254598,
0.1092014834,
-0.1265509576,
0.8801298738,
-0.3216023445,
0.3556341529,
0.6759656668,
-0.0649119392,
0.2504553199,
-0.0621988364,
0.2019911259,
0.2990905344,
-0.8359075189,
-0.2117354274,
0.599024117,
0.2778666317,
0.5986794829,
0.2857734859,
-0.0133854467,
0.2596652508,
0.2360330671,
0.1374457777,
-0.5024138093,
-0.3318486512,
-0.1445663869,
0.3262455463,
-0.1370140463,
-0.2943875492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14553v1 | Appropriateness is all you need! | 2023-04-27T22:21:52 | 2023-04-27T22:21:52 | Hendrik Kempt, Alon Lavie, Saskia K. Nagel | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | The strive to make AI applications "safe" has led to the development of
safety-measures as the main or even sole normative requirement of their
permissible use. Similar can be attested to the latest version of chatbots,
such as chatGPT. In this view, if they are "safe", they are supposed to be
permissible to deploy. This approach, which we call "safety-normativity", is
rather limited in solving the emerging issues that chatGPT and other chatbots
have caused thus far. In answering this limitation, in this paper we argue for
limiting chatbots in the range of topics they can chat about according to the
normative concept of appropriateness. We argue that rather than looking for
"safety" in a chatbot's utterances to determine what they may and may not say,
we ought to assess those utterances according to three forms of
appropriateness: technical-discursive, social, and moral. We then spell out
what requirements for chatbots follow from these forms of appropriateness to
avoid the limits of previous accounts: positionality, acceptability, and value
alignment (PAVA). With these in mind, we may be able to determine what a
chatbot may and may not say. Lastly, one initial suggestion is to use challenge
sets, specifically designed for appropriateness, as a validation method. | [
-0.2840062678,
-0.8488973975,
0.2517427802,
0.4343200028,
-0.1310379803,
-0.1715529114,
-0.1756574064,
-0.4489921927,
-0.3273586631,
0.4489040971,
-0.1870462447,
-0.2329400331,
-0.508893013,
0.0042824573,
-0.4405272901,
1.236420393,
0.1387807429,
-0.5834726691,
-0.4609563351,
-0.4177232087,
-0.7527940869,
-0.4837276936,
-0.563939631,
0.1400598884,
0.4931377172,
0.6512031555,
1.073800087,
0.7034705281,
0.7248564363,
0.3345310092,
-0.0726644397,
-0.1150122955,
-0.331717521,
0.4257382452,
-0.0404567942,
-0.5016396046,
-0.60611552,
0.1935690939,
0.3308232427,
0.1924931258,
-0.2386730462,
-0.0007287666,
0.005481258,
0.4793972075,
-0.6610856056,
0.0057465085,
-0.6322588325,
0.0008861786,
0.0321955159,
-0.1694668978,
-0.2865995765,
-0.6541640759,
0.2176300734,
-0.5343667269,
-0.0672025234,
0.0657275245,
0.8209373951,
0.4512951374,
-0.2667229474,
-0.4533150196,
-0.7139434814,
0.5546030998,
-0.4109014571,
0.2105276883,
0.6153997183,
0.6428758502,
-0.133082509,
-0.5383566022,
-0.5933880806,
-0.424262166,
0.1432298571,
0.0188020263,
-0.4718736708,
0.275762409,
0.3837395906,
-0.0867294371,
-0.5000567436,
0.0597552508,
-0.4416960478,
-0.1764844656,
0.5804840326,
0.0255591441,
0.638964653,
-0.0131301209,
-0.3353775144,
-0.1333769113,
-0.3753326535,
0.2000678182,
0.5374020338,
0.3103252351,
-0.3089132309,
0.5651590228,
0.007670687,
0.1960167736,
0.0435911752,
0.155801475,
0.0075960034,
-0.3891810477,
-0.1303870231,
-0.2102112472,
0.6861586571,
0.6257963777,
0.6403737068,
0.1128333136,
0.2516238689,
0.0760711655,
0.9176845551,
-0.2990884781,
-0.0809814036,
0.6204690337,
-0.377687484,
-0.5709336996,
-0.3595496416,
-0.500983119,
-0.4994231164,
0.0795616955,
0.2324105203,
-0.5217408538,
-0.4046103954,
-0.2390308082,
0.0000543017,
0.461861372,
0.2008517832,
-0.9359809756,
0.0645940006,
0.7619224191,
0.7122722268,
0.1197681651,
-0.2900250852,
-0.0862985402,
0.0040332545,
-0.3847285211,
0.6440876126,
-0.3877460063,
-0.5803140402,
-0.0443670899,
-0.0989045277,
-0.0622732602,
-0.1827151179,
0.8267500401,
-0.4223998487,
0.1999941468,
0.1346651018,
-0.4499777257,
-0.341279,
0.3546935916,
-0.265012145,
0.4475307465,
-0.0969321132,
-0.5764144063,
0.4989151657,
-1.0418972969,
-0.6565686464,
0.0753345415,
-0.1196805462,
-0.4066121578,
-0.2859148085,
-0.0952220783,
0.4536518753,
0.1481455714,
0.2831664383,
-0.3445380032,
-0.0784360617,
0.2449761033,
-0.6526055932,
0.8948553205,
0.4444305599,
-0.3390866518,
0.3405180573,
-0.4546244442,
0.3907370269,
-0.3079206347,
-0.275624752,
-0.1042453349,
0.2719043791,
-0.0909927934,
0.2423928827,
0.1280150563,
-0.151176855,
-0.5542725921,
-0.3737960458,
0.5944933891,
1.0631790161,
-0.4778483212,
0.7161282301,
-0.716748178,
0.6606757045,
-0.4270010889,
0.5877662897,
0.082780242,
-0.3935805559,
-0.6410599947,
-0.3338943124,
-0.0028983795,
1.0854809284,
-0.2326708287,
0.9881381989,
0.0251725707,
-0.7575393319,
-0.1120893508,
-0.3009747267,
0.3577332497,
0.2994566262,
-0.0597858913,
-0.263551265,
-0.4464505315,
-0.9970654845,
-0.0864892527,
-0.6323028207,
-0.0721836388,
0.5814831853,
0.1661309898,
-0.0962353796,
1.0642883778,
0.1066817939,
0.1703229696,
0.0452923626,
-0.3437701166,
-0.0182131529,
0.7940793633,
0.5777211785,
-1.1765929461,
-0.4666866958,
0.0660818368,
-0.8696192503,
0.0590532124,
-0.0668695122,
-0.2515349388,
0.1033089161,
0.2956864834,
-0.7382932305,
0.5785119534,
0.371991843,
-0.1675401777,
-0.0576390065,
-0.3265842199,
0.0866337046,
-0.9776276946,
0.2453029901,
-0.0640123859,
-0.5182922482,
-0.8096370101,
0.1214598268,
-0.1492324024,
-0.4344757497,
-0.6855575442,
0.4484520555,
0.3002560735,
0.3396289945,
-0.3573651612,
0.4225098789,
-0.1800355166,
-0.1138242781,
-0.1858303547,
0.7117462754,
0.6034438014,
-0.8007282019,
0.5099461675,
0.4015378058,
-0.1057520807,
0.9539433122,
-0.90587008,
0.1655741036,
-0.31214872,
0.2046028972,
-0.808835566,
-0.3503911197,
0.6988708377,
-0.8646005988,
-0.2275197357,
0.1707874537,
-0.028634293,
-0.2233753949,
-0.1581406146,
0.2589120567,
0.8360108733,
-0.124125272,
0.4938615859,
0.6650308967,
-0.3042374551,
-0.747975409,
-0.1696368903,
0.0137358345,
-0.5777902603,
-0.7351372838,
-0.1766635925,
-0.2451008558,
-0.3890285492,
-0.1451603472,
-0.0952127948,
-0.3448393047,
0.5018857718,
0.5445333123,
0.0601174757,
0.2321271151,
-0.0335246995,
-0.3476572633,
-0.3792057633,
-0.0696336553,
0.1348701864,
0.3601329327,
-0.5001897216,
-0.2313144654,
-0.4791862071,
0.4100687206,
0.5459239483,
0.0940877944,
0.3602159321,
0.632784903,
-0.3941142261,
0.3751178384,
-0.5555084348,
-0.0715909973,
-0.5377323627,
0.2598485649,
0.0164141674,
-0.9789521694,
0.3461506963,
0.3695088625,
0.5179866552,
0.4474923313,
0.4825722575,
-0.4307457507,
0.9472626448,
0.6328015327,
0.0736375973,
0.3288608491,
0.5022141933,
0.5089800954,
-0.3286369443,
-0.2327534705,
-0.8865780234,
-0.0088998461,
-0.9563037753,
-0.032240469,
0.251041919,
-0.1504068077,
-0.5141800642,
0.6119343638,
-0.6993051767,
0.6916857958,
0.6820704341,
0.0345179886,
-0.0776151568,
-0.2312252671,
0.5288847089,
0.125145942,
-0.6260969043,
-0.950212121,
0.6766032577,
0.4997314513,
0.5049897432,
0.1573427022,
0.2958138585,
0.4714515507,
0.1334987581,
-0.6987489462,
0.6245908141,
-0.0302125234,
-1.2454997301,
-0.5640209317,
-0.3160620034,
-1.2800486088,
-0.1004464105,
-0.0777463913,
-0.8399053216,
-0.0840187445,
0.2353442609,
-0.4929365814,
-0.0292007923,
-0.6992477775,
0.8019887805,
-0.392734319,
0.0573266,
-0.3722630143,
-1.1752339602,
0.1840247065,
0.0079536038,
0.3271396458,
-0.6825147271,
-0.1404244602,
0.5118430257,
-0.2527764738,
1.0328185558,
-0.003233972,
-0.009579299,
0.6638499498,
0.0745765194,
0.0398868024,
0.0308575016,
0.1157054305,
0.1067340896,
0.5028250813,
-0.6008598804,
-0.377021879,
0.2950844169,
-0.836071372,
-0.9012262821,
-0.5492908955,
-0.4979995489,
-0.1176405624,
0.38693735,
0.1880149692,
-0.1192064956,
-0.4047954679,
0.4477369487,
0.4819829464,
-0.3407034874,
0.3038309813,
0.1809715182,
0.2803170979,
-0.141865626,
0.8610975742,
-0.2359024882,
0.3088012636,
0.0671123713,
0.2655079067,
-0.2397886068,
-0.4843282998,
-0.3431149721,
-0.4127890468,
-0.7742307186,
0.0363253504,
-0.4203906953,
-0.2928314507,
-0.3928112984,
-0.492726326,
-0.2159649283,
-0.3718434572,
-0.2661518455,
0.1331219226,
0.4963811934,
0.2915046811,
-0.4881706238,
0.2416087091,
-1.0447640419,
0.2398400605,
0.4167218208,
0.368129909,
-0.4278867543,
-0.3559668362,
0.2228361368,
0.1522634625,
-0.4769634604,
-0.2533947527,
-0.1312921792,
0.2874330878,
0.7425910234,
0.4754862487,
0.4506826401,
0.2730760574,
-0.5985041857,
0.7627561688,
0.2164691389,
-0.7985095382,
0.9590258002,
-0.6167589426,
-0.4153348804,
0.7118654251,
0.6570037603,
-0.6817292571,
-0.3376248479,
-1.0442435741,
-0.9465661645,
0.4147672951,
0.9285773039,
1.0572689772,
-0.1774804145,
0.4568518996,
0.0860557556,
0.1257976145,
-0.7289404273,
0.1265722513,
-0.3740819991,
-0.1935093999,
0.1190181002,
-0.0261045601,
-0.4943028986,
0.342556864,
0.4385292232,
0.1016243398,
0.4361081421,
-0.2587100863,
0.2868946195,
0.3640175164,
0.509681046,
0.4819801152,
0.7133612633,
-0.2082253098,
-0.0291287601,
0.2351340652,
-0.4807776809,
0.3428375125,
-0.064519994,
-0.0926402435,
-0.4364934862,
0.0904537216,
0.4311933517,
-0.2996897101,
-0.8320071101,
0.6422225237,
-0.1312752068,
0.1412479877,
-0.3978016973,
0.7191960216,
-0.3083881438,
0.2965078354,
-0.3185973465,
0.350224793,
-0.1303408146,
-0.5047509074,
0.2931621969,
0.4944849908,
-0.5252536535,
-0.0339561515,
0.7644897699,
0.6985635757,
-0.8329557776,
0.6435381174,
0.0869850218,
-0.1563252658,
0.8974784613,
0.4607773125,
0.9702140093,
-0.2627582252,
0.3346850872,
0.2127097696,
0.4241426885,
-0.0896408036,
0.2669762373,
-0.1084506288,
-0.9809676409,
0.0405334271,
0.0226702318,
-0.8318540454,
-0.3413264155,
-0.4437668622,
0.2814525664,
-0.8791814446,
-0.5323628187,
-0.0988943949,
-0.6768463254,
-0.2720533907,
0.2218120396,
-0.1905408353,
0.5820350051,
-0.4304169714,
0.1558801979,
0.4601990879,
-0.3271202743,
-0.3942203522,
0.0249619633,
0.0919174775,
-0.9612190127,
0.0770715252,
0.0740736499,
0.0377977043,
-0.356333524,
-0.7617990375,
-0.5347691774,
0.717694521,
0.2326307893,
-0.2195632458,
-0.0929909423,
0.091541186,
0.3961769938,
0.0473642498,
0.1728216708,
0.4427134097,
0.4580797553,
-0.0214606952,
-1.1232187748,
-0.0821468458,
-0.4893990457,
0.1152820885,
-0.143526122,
-0.7253090143,
0.3659991324,
-0.1513638198,
-0.3667870164,
0.3054717481,
0.2083915323,
0.2265260369,
0.425642252,
0.7390036583,
-0.0175426919,
0.8979610801,
-0.095729962,
1.1430544853,
-0.2027030885,
-0.0587782599,
0.6347234845,
-0.1110648811,
0.5918364525,
0.0812752619,
-0.2545803487,
-0.1001308262,
0.834033668,
0.0526442789,
0.2645176351,
0.2099657059,
-0.2321975678,
-0.3056272268,
-0.3559381664,
-0.3212937713,
0.7145731449,
0.4299406707,
-0.1065049693,
0.0737591758,
0.1030957326,
0.3275026977,
0.1065608189,
0.1232271567,
0.723364234,
0.0442467555,
-0.5473546982,
0.5013216734,
0.0043440592,
0.5317800045,
-0.4063496292,
0.2675774693,
0.0588131025,
-0.1443128884,
-0.10207095,
-1.0093514919,
0.5148853064,
0.2399594784,
0.0471690781,
-0.0608869903,
0.9461627007,
0.2105702162,
-0.3251368999,
-0.1407018453,
0.5594626069,
0.3767555058,
0.2254659534,
-0.4909684658,
-0.159274295,
-0.2001111954,
0.1605239064,
0.012957518,
0.3075893521,
-0.154111445,
0.8684100509,
0.5033988953,
-0.1310933679,
-0.23834984,
-0.2613353133,
0.5670663714,
-0.501880765,
-0.7072097063,
-0.9625862837,
0.5664776564,
-0.0084842872,
-0.4632308185,
0.6478682756,
0.1319319904,
0.412358284,
0.3317486942,
1.1096955538,
-0.6277549863,
0.1830153614,
-0.2808009088,
0.8096717,
-0.3574430048,
0.0622286536,
-0.3840767443,
-0.8558216095,
-0.5235809684,
1.1028767824,
-0.189668417,
0.2861426771,
0.2266617417,
0.6166312099,
0.2404445112,
0.4935271144,
0.3680619895,
-0.3014875054,
0.4216647446,
0.5717206001,
1.1110805273,
-0.0809156895,
0.9517168999,
-0.1813098043,
-0.48970595,
-0.1691451073,
-1.1093147993,
-0.862475574,
-0.64310956,
-0.3607490659,
-0.5713646412,
0.3094839454,
0.9597462416,
0.9316774607,
-0.5463122725,
-0.1054841951,
-0.108794257,
0.2637455463,
-0.102096878,
-0.1188720316,
0.1057417914,
-0.4833222926,
-0.6239873767,
0.240495488,
0.0608638041,
0.3777707219,
0.1515753269,
0.0431799181,
0.0520002544,
0.2030976266,
0.6258122921,
0.7766601443,
-0.4095273018,
-1.0649625063,
-0.0919818804,
-0.0495082475,
0.1742596775,
0.4696184099,
-0.0300256051,
0.5022576451,
0.5785067081,
0.6978681684,
-0.2784270644,
-0.0247708596,
0.6870699525,
-0.6164743304,
0.3232462108,
0.6872679591,
-0.0577194467,
0.1946633011,
-0.4733271003,
0.6780363321,
-0.2731153965,
-0.8734297752,
-0.6222887039,
0.4376662374,
-0.812848866,
0.1678814739,
0.9877184629,
-0.1813531816,
0.1786427349,
-0.4105632007,
-0.5291349292,
0.2850856185,
-0.4042822123,
1.1374276876,
0.7687368989,
-0.4691179097,
-0.2371296734,
-0.6463007927,
0.443020463,
0.3419623077,
-0.9518374801,
0.1804482341,
0.4019175768,
0.0852338821,
0.2617115676,
0.8657647967,
-0.1675429046,
0.4518390894,
0.0768719837,
-0.2503511012,
0.2346606553,
-0.3318016231,
-0.0259949341,
0.0381935649,
0.3035251498,
-0.463227272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14543v1 | Discourse over Discourse: The Need for an Expanded Pragmatic Focus in Conversational AI | 2023-04-27T21:51:42 | 2023-04-27T21:51:42 | S. M. Seals, Valerie L. Shalin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The summarization of conversation, that is, discourse over discourse,
elevates pragmatic considerations as a pervasive limitation of both
summarization and other applications of contemporary conversational AI.
Building on impressive progress in both semantics and syntax, pragmatics
concerns meaning in the practical sense. In this paper, we discuss several
challenges in both summarization of conversations and other conversational AI
applications, drawing on relevant theoretical work. We illustrate the
importance of pragmatics with so-called star sentences, syntactically
acceptable propositions that are pragmatically inappropriate in conversation or
its summary. Because the baseline for quality of AI is indistinguishability
from human behavior, we draw heavily on the psycho-linguistics literature, and
label our complaints as "Turing Test Triggers" (TTTs). We discuss implications
for the design and evaluation of conversation summarization methods and
conversational AI applications like voice assistants and chatbots | [
-0.3098686039,
-1.0227663517,
0.4444374144,
0.0821715891,
-0.1901734918,
0.2806830108,
-0.2960736156,
-0.4952363372,
0.2448269129,
0.396433264,
-0.1871669441,
0.0393091924,
-0.6175723672,
-0.0442860201,
-0.5444611311,
1.1384409666,
0.0776709467,
-0.302187562,
-0.488568753,
-0.1133531034,
-0.5553224683,
-0.6458435059,
-0.3245989382,
-0.284686327,
0.271415621,
0.5353595614,
0.9738771915,
0.170174852,
0.8101776838,
0.4018738568,
0.2083122283,
0.1112364829,
-0.3378989995,
0.479881227,
0.0969022512,
-0.6181416512,
-0.1954936981,
-0.0908945277,
0.8309282064,
0.968776226,
0.1105505303,
0.1053175852,
0.0436120071,
0.5075002909,
-0.4846286178,
0.4358302653,
-0.3504000604,
0.0568600073,
-0.0565525293,
-0.0346279852,
-0.240919441,
-0.5552145839,
0.2513996661,
-0.3818473816,
-0.3259073794,
-0.1619120836,
0.9631190896,
0.3153253794,
-0.4078952968,
-0.3085336387,
-1.0814527273,
0.8005497456,
-0.5473429561,
0.0903987139,
0.3276974559,
0.2434690595,
0.0745225474,
-0.7889054418,
-0.5789088607,
-0.559446156,
-0.3169929981,
0.1853741258,
-0.4529871643,
0.3730160296,
0.2643309236,
0.3017182648,
-0.4873542786,
-0.0138908476,
-0.5965681076,
-0.1068077236,
0.6186631322,
0.2430273145,
0.3585535884,
0.1143920049,
0.0513225757,
0.4186190963,
-0.6141661406,
-0.0616943873,
0.1971979588,
0.1618140787,
0.1594979614,
0.577835083,
0.0002531966,
0.7325042486,
-0.2114758641,
0.0202711076,
0.0405760668,
-0.4630417526,
-0.0820443705,
-0.103426069,
0.6128751636,
0.5066355467,
0.6461610198,
-0.07239528,
0.3838323355,
0.2852077186,
0.3993292451,
-0.5791618228,
0.0663719699,
0.4267437756,
-0.1753397733,
0.0144689688,
0.0329825617,
-0.320399344,
-0.2840501666,
-0.3959922194,
-0.0559603237,
-0.3075310588,
-0.352332592,
-0.1730294973,
-0.1706159115,
0.5312301517,
0.2232277095,
-0.6331725717,
0.2173523307,
1.0428733826,
0.8009379506,
0.0040705982,
-0.4455326796,
0.0747430548,
0.0648012981,
-0.4639845192,
0.9014286399,
-0.586022079,
-0.9015514255,
0.0821775794,
-0.2627925277,
-0.3374238014,
-0.512504518,
0.4586803317,
0.124173224,
0.5248814821,
-0.1354932487,
-0.5683435202,
-0.2814646661,
0.3216759861,
-0.062208496,
0.59825629,
-0.0714142546,
-0.5098251104,
0.1726806611,
-0.8928625584,
-1.1216794252,
0.3568736911,
-0.4620096087,
-0.0883943811,
0.251876533,
-0.3864079118,
0.2820161581,
-0.2960639596,
0.6410602331,
0.2292115986,
-0.5076007247,
0.5724688172,
-0.17952317,
0.6296893954,
0.0686851591,
-0.2895208001,
0.4348941743,
-0.3806239963,
0.1936720759,
-0.0933161378,
0.108257018,
-0.1400580555,
0.1682560444,
-0.2708381116,
0.0923465267,
0.1624308378,
-0.3218087852,
-0.2422204763,
-0.6903076172,
0.8859153986,
0.5198420882,
-0.033990059,
0.3873367906,
-0.6987757683,
0.6579307318,
-0.0266823359,
0.1634706557,
-0.6007145643,
-0.7425683141,
-0.8646057844,
-0.1902323216,
0.1329901516,
0.8886097074,
-0.5886597037,
0.5374776721,
-0.1990601718,
-0.5790581107,
-0.6239798069,
-0.4619646966,
0.599165082,
0.6364879608,
-0.0109874289,
-0.3152436316,
-0.391107142,
-1.0914930105,
-0.456694454,
-0.7046868205,
-0.0991998464,
0.3866822422,
0.3969773054,
0.1879185438,
1.0792663097,
-0.5730410218,
-0.3694721162,
-0.4564430118,
0.3272427022,
-0.0636879802,
0.4039567709,
0.328461349,
-0.8439302444,
-0.3903361261,
0.043201495,
-0.7331227064,
0.074275732,
-0.4440850019,
0.3044754565,
0.0446228385,
0.5081503391,
-0.9130033851,
0.4456230104,
0.0509812199,
-0.3075321317,
0.5498354435,
-0.0928155929,
0.2483835369,
-0.8174844384,
0.2471831143,
-0.0631257445,
-0.1093183532,
-0.9625808597,
0.1530537456,
-0.4747631848,
-0.4082606435,
-0.5066939592,
0.2563574016,
-0.087062411,
-0.0934589207,
-0.486456424,
0.3871528804,
0.0036275932,
0.2685670853,
0.1030846462,
0.7869265676,
0.5421974659,
-0.6919514537,
0.4544629157,
0.2723528445,
-0.049123764,
0.786608398,
-0.8449607491,
-0.0627149194,
-0.2705042064,
0.2909116447,
-0.9610668421,
-0.1150974482,
0.3718221486,
-0.7110549212,
0.1142896637,
0.4556512535,
-0.1891940832,
-0.3027264476,
-0.3942113519,
0.398009479,
0.6664739847,
0.0665462613,
0.4168438911,
0.7064571381,
-0.3733609617,
-0.2932268381,
-0.7552886009,
0.376519531,
-0.3860082626,
-0.5563314557,
0.2649286687,
0.1464095712,
-0.830898881,
-0.2107892781,
0.2187026143,
-0.1833315641,
0.1640953422,
0.3999039829,
0.0089721167,
-0.1525025964,
0.1883496046,
-0.2492551655,
-0.4042581618,
0.1157651693,
-0.1152905449,
0.269122839,
-0.3213911355,
-0.2751018405,
-0.5064111948,
0.6782312989,
0.4379944205,
0.0163218826,
0.3849914372,
0.3171041012,
-0.1876543313,
0.2329767644,
-0.2466675192,
-0.2408213466,
-0.3738441169,
0.434833765,
-0.096782513,
-1.0570774078,
0.330862999,
0.00431475,
0.2831505537,
0.2714841664,
0.4742141366,
-0.3786257505,
0.8073397279,
0.4360651374,
0.0854072943,
0.5409239531,
0.045406688,
0.6773255467,
-0.5447729826,
-0.066318363,
-0.7883502841,
-0.2616261244,
-0.6263673306,
-0.2582895756,
0.1801578254,
-0.62509799,
-0.0969040766,
0.408331126,
-0.6398479342,
0.4536516368,
0.6260547638,
-0.2465142161,
0.3255494237,
-0.5096809268,
0.5741715431,
-0.4006801844,
-0.5732919574,
-0.5328796506,
0.5628874302,
0.3250361383,
0.480618,
0.0191843957,
0.3088903725,
0.323684752,
0.0326071419,
-0.9351028204,
0.7204952836,
0.1837924868,
-0.6696769595,
-0.1984322071,
-0.264557302,
-1.0564577579,
0.3832945824,
0.1044711024,
-0.9116322398,
0.0699459314,
0.086602889,
-0.4348925948,
-0.1753298491,
-1.0268737078,
0.9127649069,
-0.3792860806,
-0.0203210711,
-0.2819514871,
-0.811057806,
0.5623945594,
0.2542067468,
0.1700276136,
-0.2300304472,
-0.06674622,
0.6565839648,
-0.3852375746,
1.0316913128,
0.1149016246,
0.1222229004,
0.6658627391,
-0.20375368,
-0.0216575582,
-0.1776334494,
0.3631580472,
0.2544988096,
0.0622428656,
-0.4089672863,
-0.5538542867,
0.399462074,
-0.5365076661,
-0.9985049367,
-0.5411787629,
-0.4689076543,
-0.1641318947,
0.1833419651,
0.2176693678,
0.1927501708,
-0.4327647984,
-0.0263521448,
0.3616402745,
-0.17295748,
0.4217447042,
0.2307003587,
-0.1319128424,
0.0480701514,
1.3348728418,
0.1888398528,
0.3498809636,
0.2198577374,
0.1603209078,
-0.187271744,
-0.6489624977,
-0.2656059265,
0.2186647952,
-0.7187052369,
-0.017654635,
-0.5482202768,
-0.2453388572,
-0.4160628319,
-0.4132045805,
-0.0466542654,
-0.8029106855,
-0.4233756363,
-0.0846342966,
0.1368477494,
0.6055473089,
0.290105015,
0.3965084255,
-0.7408771515,
0.2715440691,
0.0437352546,
-0.0408396348,
-0.3408645093,
-0.4382025003,
0.0805971026,
-0.0302211754,
-0.59099859,
-0.7161028385,
0.1726230532,
0.3661232293,
0.4491364062,
0.3446127176,
0.1080438867,
0.7559102774,
-0.2641988099,
1.1254708767,
0.2915112972,
-0.919093132,
0.680172503,
-0.3356120884,
0.4524827302,
0.5427196026,
0.3349704146,
-0.7514849305,
-0.9417087436,
-1.0024387836,
-0.8995074034,
0.2722902,
0.4156965315,
0.3944016099,
-0.0595925637,
0.1922115088,
-0.161954537,
0.4634302855,
-0.3775822222,
-0.0914613307,
-0.1140649095,
-0.0467406921,
-0.0800736323,
-0.0359588079,
-0.2779749334,
-0.1632981896,
0.3799618185,
-0.1055459678,
0.3300539851,
0.0358634405,
-0.1432293653,
0.2285826504,
0.4123728871,
0.8132132888,
1.0337283611,
0.3845767379,
0.0002960251,
-0.0202668384,
-0.3565285802,
-0.1047971994,
0.0548093654,
-0.4276782572,
0.0906230658,
0.6053641438,
0.6550063491,
0.4202845097,
-0.7728830576,
0.3321461678,
-0.0042181299,
-0.0372423381,
-0.3196178079,
0.1413012296,
-0.1151921675,
0.0310172625,
0.1702270806,
0.0442364588,
0.1901889741,
-0.9889571071,
0.4284986556,
0.475979954,
-0.4265225828,
-0.2246911526,
0.3313762844,
0.4786811769,
-0.7077352405,
0.3881728351,
-0.0538903177,
-0.553742826,
0.7685666084,
0.4054736495,
0.8859478235,
-0.1417547017,
0.4241004288,
0.0016172256,
0.296291858,
0.1513746679,
0.197855249,
-0.2572847605,
-0.5877415538,
-0.3974751234,
0.004398061,
-0.8499607444,
-0.4451922774,
-0.3928181231,
0.1618739367,
-0.5655513406,
-0.254112035,
0.1181413159,
-0.1963070333,
0.0571014024,
-0.0909195319,
-0.0872111842,
0.4671586752,
-0.5854158998,
0.4379577041,
0.6609534025,
-0.5071387887,
-0.2397483438,
0.0579431914,
0.0084956987,
-0.7537677884,
0.1339118779,
0.0384598598,
0.1095859036,
0.0693793297,
-0.1983394921,
-0.3709430397,
0.6720853448,
0.3431996107,
-0.2312063426,
-0.1964379847,
0.3471942842,
0.7171845436,
-0.3518949449,
0.507198751,
0.9822129607,
0.5841184258,
0.2680762112,
-1.1136343479,
-0.1163862869,
-0.0484278053,
-0.1646170169,
0.3105334938,
-0.6942754984,
0.4610202014,
-0.2623060048,
-0.3703995347,
-0.1106476858,
0.6454713345,
-0.0753032044,
0.2608771324,
0.017971931,
0.0163122155,
0.4566485584,
-0.4075839221,
0.9753611088,
-0.0660257861,
-0.069191359,
0.9943499565,
-0.3670204878,
0.4749509096,
0.3180916905,
-0.4388408363,
0.1057869196,
0.5236640573,
0.1724327654,
-0.0809898004,
0.3480626047,
-0.1794109344,
0.1418007463,
-0.5433437824,
-0.330676198,
0.6194037795,
0.8021011949,
-0.071522437,
-0.4103039801,
0.1223682985,
0.1367854625,
0.4763450325,
-0.147642836,
0.9982720613,
0.2557439804,
-1.1056164503,
0.490948379,
-0.2198591083,
0.4183271229,
-0.3574633002,
0.0232274886,
-0.0518274382,
0.0331411324,
-0.2130447775,
-0.8550710082,
0.9116908312,
-0.0837552771,
0.305185467,
-0.3759278655,
0.90560776,
-0.2252796143,
-0.4250303507,
-0.1093479767,
0.570536077,
0.4268327951,
-0.0746675134,
-0.9059864879,
0.19723472,
-0.1548577398,
0.01869734,
0.1391258985,
0.176988855,
-0.1019063592,
0.6248571277,
0.4190516174,
0.0754508153,
-0.1501076221,
-0.0805159062,
0.7637311816,
-0.7652528286,
-0.7832295299,
-0.9399719238,
0.6469551921,
-0.0427098684,
-0.5386591554,
0.6628804207,
0.3324628472,
0.4299299419,
0.4249503016,
0.8535457253,
-0.3400477469,
0.2932089269,
-0.1235139444,
0.4455355406,
0.0418993942,
0.0097632976,
-0.2266373783,
-0.628626287,
-0.5195879936,
0.7332043648,
-0.5537425876,
0.1836593151,
0.7480333447,
0.2783519328,
0.3942367435,
0.437371999,
0.6206184626,
0.1242760718,
0.2591917515,
0.7332164049,
1.1623228788,
-0.1087565348,
0.454393059,
0.1147679016,
-0.3525817394,
-0.2898038924,
-0.6578710079,
-0.8386577964,
-0.8590454459,
-0.6889721751,
-0.2639986277,
0.1443686783,
0.4102138579,
0.5070588589,
-0.6757691503,
-0.3095885515,
-0.2839909196,
0.5770674944,
-0.2667470872,
-0.2605860829,
0.0410352051,
-0.4825288951,
-0.7366813421,
0.2310531884,
0.420589298,
0.0762266293,
-0.3647161722,
0.2225217372,
-0.2541795075,
0.0386003926,
0.6489961147,
0.819930315,
-0.6640665531,
-0.4740891159,
-0.1842826307,
0.1509159505,
0.1271629632,
1.1502729654,
-0.6544188261,
0.1189856604,
0.4600251913,
0.5681675076,
0.0577145778,
0.3099984229,
0.8325147033,
-0.7071718574,
0.4193919897,
0.8471451402,
-0.0624874867,
0.2243216634,
-0.3304032087,
0.2357443571,
0.2788806558,
-0.5213294625,
-1.1125159264,
0.7208445072,
-0.658360064,
-0.3874472082,
0.8530164361,
-0.288356632,
-0.0529222339,
-0.4427731335,
-0.3204456866,
0.0581446923,
-0.3149445653,
0.6467202306,
0.7756386399,
-0.5660904646,
-0.2942044139,
-0.5774902701,
0.6358203292,
0.550909996,
-1.0674687624,
0.2569631338,
0.5937854052,
-0.4623595476,
0.57166785,
0.8645972013,
-0.062812157,
0.4850207865,
0.0979394093,
-0.3295019865,
0.1360058933,
-0.3460027874,
-0.2691921592,
0.3092003465,
0.3158483207,
-0.3341608942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14535v2 | Deep Transfer Learning for Automatic Speech Recognition: Towards Better Generalization | 2023-04-27T21:08:05 | 2023-07-31T11:58:18 | Hamza Kheddar, Yassine Himeur, Somaya Al-Maadeed, Abbes Amira, Faycal Bensaali | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) has recently become an important challenge
when using deep learning (DL). It requires large-scale training datasets and
high computational and storage resources. Moreover, DL techniques and machine
learning (ML) approaches in general, hypothesize that training and testing data
come from the same domain, with the same input feature space and data
distribution characteristics. This assumption, however, is not applicable in
some real-world artificial intelligence (AI) applications. Moreover, there are
situations where gathering real data is challenging, expensive, or rarely
occurring, which can not meet the data requirements of DL models. deep transfer
learning (DTL) has been introduced to overcome these issues, which helps
develop high-performing models using real datasets that are small or slightly
different but related to the training data. This paper presents a comprehensive
survey of DTL-based ASR frameworks to shed light on the latest developments and
helps academics and professionals understand current challenges. Specifically,
after presenting the DTL background, a well-designed taxonomy is adopted to
inform the state-of-the-art. A critical analysis is then conducted to identify
the limitations and advantages of each framework. Moving on, a comparative
study is introduced to highlight the current challenges before deriving
opportunities for future research. | [
-0.3822543621,
-0.5445469022,
0.1112565994,
-0.0119214598,
-0.0293459017,
0.4942013323,
-0.276178807,
-0.6126341224,
-0.5029822588,
0.2327198386,
-0.4046834707,
-0.2838281989,
-0.9242545962,
0.0945378318,
-0.7233095765,
0.4307664335,
-0.1517096609,
0.0737243965,
0.0718809292,
-0.3627568185,
-0.6500465274,
-0.6448222399,
-0.911092937,
-0.6024416685,
0.0171931889,
0.3174621463,
0.2079267502,
0.5245047212,
0.6860185862,
0.2619659305,
-0.0639180243,
0.0063112066,
-0.1492278427,
0.0856051818,
0.1131891161,
-0.086259611,
-0.206205681,
-0.1672326177,
0.826703012,
0.9043845534,
-0.05359824,
0.2679223716,
0.0301134754,
0.7884867191,
-0.5028926134,
0.1531374007,
-0.5001209974,
0.3854782581,
-0.068155311,
0.196297437,
-0.0792451128,
-0.2808529735,
0.6321327686,
-0.3128247559,
0.2514775693,
-0.3430600464,
0.6564629078,
0.5048471689,
-0.6000031233,
-0.4798325002,
-1.2252887487,
0.7018799782,
-0.5858585238,
0.7797908783,
0.2377528697,
0.8141262531,
0.4170032144,
-0.7308725119,
-0.4666019678,
-0.3020151854,
0.1102079451,
-0.3410044611,
-0.3259741664,
-0.225126937,
0.0757695287,
0.4316964149,
-0.7371628284,
0.2434934825,
-0.3997378051,
-0.1934968531,
0.7197927237,
0.0841683224,
0.0628981292,
0.6084845066,
-0.1637064666,
-0.3046838641,
-0.560379982,
0.1067094952,
-0.2097933888,
0.4208538234,
-0.362873733,
0.0545518845,
-0.0007308295,
0.6148304939,
0.3307293952,
0.2737911046,
0.5077809095,
-0.3392867148,
-0.303070277,
0.1439941823,
0.6744799018,
-0.0462459624,
0.6424267292,
-0.1624162793,
-0.0541994795,
-0.1436151564,
0.0343398638,
-0.6083270907,
-0.1358480901,
0.0814823061,
-0.2783438861,
-0.1304000914,
0.1445408016,
-0.4855603278,
-0.4112536907,
-0.708910346,
0.0832269639,
-0.1451083273,
-0.3456274569,
0.0631592274,
0.2007452697,
0.4055475891,
0.3860916197,
-0.6269982457,
0.3403333426,
0.5301030278,
0.7257415056,
-0.4704148173,
0.1090380996,
-0.6604465842,
0.1840651631,
-0.250880599,
0.6075633168,
-0.450338155,
-0.5460211039,
0.0286552683,
-0.221198976,
-0.2565144897,
-0.8160838485,
0.4515062571,
-0.3747394979,
0.0123520726,
0.0705168322,
-0.4559990466,
-0.1369938552,
0.1913608909,
-0.5386019945,
0.6107665896,
-0.1025523096,
-0.3046880662,
0.4352952838,
-0.6002826095,
-0.7391500473,
-0.0394159816,
-0.4171408713,
-0.461133033,
-0.0301992912,
0.2087532729,
0.4749960303,
-0.4947136939,
0.4608231187,
-0.0218934938,
-0.2711403966,
0.3685568273,
-0.5489642024,
0.6827227473,
0.6980071068,
-0.4842309952,
0.0205738842,
-0.9302943349,
-0.0034216233,
-0.3110846579,
-0.3823707104,
-0.0253095627,
-0.1990158856,
0.1218489632,
0.1689745784,
-0.1908847541,
-0.3539444208,
-0.0308578778,
-0.2846059501,
0.6567966938,
0.4800626636,
-0.2450160533,
0.6260688305,
-0.066842109,
0.3876879811,
0.137198016,
0.1438972056,
0.2903499901,
-0.1558788717,
-0.6658747196,
-0.025025174,
0.5917301178,
0.69613415,
-0.468706429,
0.5508210659,
-0.4166920781,
-0.281653136,
-0.7991710901,
0.0197029039,
0.3611236215,
0.5697351098,
0.4374687672,
-0.2015378177,
-0.7095085979,
-0.5678188205,
-0.0554422028,
0.0273441393,
-0.1942336708,
0.515503943,
0.2136525512,
-0.4047149718,
0.8675595522,
-0.2105681598,
-0.7358675003,
-0.3252060413,
-0.041160915,
0.0829730257,
0.6122566462,
0.3736191094,
-0.9846308231,
-0.7924138904,
0.2822808325,
-0.6876593232,
0.1432215422,
-0.0777565315,
0.5043672919,
0.2293726653,
0.5022608638,
-0.3600645661,
0.4323893785,
0.3137429655,
-0.185972169,
0.167229414,
-0.0414572954,
0.0866709277,
-0.7586763501,
0.2881946862,
-0.0323879644,
-0.0479414612,
-1.0603448153,
-0.2684586346,
-0.1373424381,
-0.3472086489,
-0.4593784511,
0.6376906037,
-0.2974293828,
-0.1797111779,
-0.2009713203,
-0.2391303927,
-0.1706802696,
-0.0401821248,
0.0229070634,
0.7736799121,
0.8572771549,
-0.8137010932,
0.5382598042,
0.4478776157,
0.1139931604,
0.2964824438,
-0.6391189694,
0.497141093,
0.0589901619,
0.3275517225,
-0.7399637699,
0.077429384,
0.2523854375,
-0.6335322261,
0.7685579658,
-0.1831948608,
-0.1201942787,
-0.4774223864,
-0.0321248472,
0.4104144573,
0.7346987724,
-0.3324237466,
0.7024499774,
0.3979416192,
0.0732989982,
-0.639975667,
-1.0286722183,
0.159011513,
-0.4311520457,
-0.4432058036,
0.2184101045,
-0.1130643636,
-0.3219290972,
-0.1777089536,
-0.2585202157,
-0.4720847309,
0.092025429,
0.0475017466,
-0.2120246589,
-0.3372092545,
-0.0317900963,
-0.2070204169,
-0.326523602,
-0.0405406356,
-0.3006749153,
0.4156454206,
-0.1741452366,
-0.1950646341,
-0.9003152251,
0.4050483704,
0.3219569325,
-0.2438571602,
0.0532889143,
0.8366050124,
-0.2628567219,
-0.2838191092,
-0.4926159084,
-0.0584700219,
-0.4702393115,
0.1816241294,
-0.5673925281,
-0.8258933425,
0.3081557155,
-0.1497175545,
0.0746800676,
0.3416499197,
0.4580286443,
-0.1946045458,
0.6739065051,
0.6268036366,
-0.507715106,
0.3754166663,
-0.5539656281,
0.0833863914,
-0.6573139429,
-0.1230547279,
-0.6812916398,
-0.331266433,
-0.2883361876,
-0.2770031691,
-0.051455792,
-0.4113985896,
-0.3966244161,
0.2197019607,
-0.6655751467,
0.1754846275,
0.4570064545,
-0.3155956566,
0.2376634628,
0.187944755,
0.301400125,
0.2273206413,
-0.3821111023,
-0.1982521266,
1.2235469818,
0.4350832105,
0.7030086517,
0.0242638793,
0.540124774,
0.7447497249,
-0.2300416976,
-0.7830474377,
0.3644476831,
-0.5939719081,
-0.2503953576,
-0.5076046586,
-0.5506782532,
-1.037271142,
-0.0562243909,
0.1056448296,
-0.2931646407,
0.5614157319,
0.1586370021,
-0.5150920153,
0.1762175262,
-0.6543174982,
0.3986801803,
-0.2449094802,
0.0817409232,
-0.0995953307,
-1.0320668221,
-0.1882723868,
-0.1609714925,
0.1072893217,
-0.0928832367,
0.1648260802,
0.6966000795,
0.145683378,
0.7208328247,
-0.4684106112,
-0.1376773268,
0.3140496314,
-0.0666036233,
0.1571281254,
-0.2983670235,
-0.1830997616,
0.3429665565,
-0.032171376,
0.0132011529,
-0.393961817,
0.5197852254,
-0.8707022667,
-0.2746091783,
-0.3599532247,
-0.4329906702,
-0.631452322,
-0.1345162392,
0.2094619572,
0.491232425,
-0.0143005028,
0.4132129848,
0.8787273169,
-0.1152121723,
0.4908668697,
0.4270860255,
0.2078034133,
-0.3408772647,
0.9929995537,
0.3068640232,
0.0505806953,
0.4202181697,
0.2444845587,
-0.3991542161,
-0.9415166378,
-0.7548877597,
-0.2196082324,
-0.3809140623,
-0.0588542111,
-0.54324615,
-0.5699682832,
-0.7457157373,
-0.0576436594,
-0.4225400388,
-0.3859899044,
-0.6436350942,
0.0398522504,
0.1997698694,
0.4913313985,
-0.1379009485,
0.1375308037,
-0.7689332366,
0.4777456224,
0.553571701,
0.2959346175,
0.1893064827,
-0.8382843733,
-0.1106647551,
0.1439420581,
-0.0772534385,
-0.3045869172,
0.380889982,
0.7460582852,
0.5183870196,
0.3595282435,
0.1999403983,
0.6150937676,
-0.4377686679,
0.6115015149,
0.1314227432,
-0.7315717936,
0.5849133134,
0.1063776687,
0.005862711,
0.6712417603,
0.2206465602,
-0.4662878811,
0.0362472571,
-0.4741783738,
-0.8018873334,
0.5033397675,
0.1933906525,
0.1483749598,
0.6847767234,
0.3464632332,
0.3884895444,
0.1654715091,
-0.3077523112,
-0.4522493184,
-0.183140099,
-0.4614005983,
-0.1623965651,
0.1095581576,
-0.0572363921,
-0.4888292849,
0.4265326858,
0.0015631953,
0.2308897525,
0.1077336073,
-0.4328971207,
-0.0432150811,
0.3987130523,
0.6458206177,
0.4713482857,
-0.2371243387,
0.1473905593,
0.3071345687,
-0.5746235251,
0.5532249808,
0.4118390679,
-0.1516400576,
-0.0850211382,
0.373180002,
0.8518760204,
-0.269625783,
-0.6106241345,
0.5145631433,
-0.086208038,
-0.4270979464,
-0.5990366936,
0.1727503985,
-0.2166200131,
0.3982390761,
0.6210718751,
-0.0013094362,
0.5968796611,
-0.5379363298,
0.4544479251,
0.3277321756,
-0.6928852797,
-0.2945984006,
0.4756437242,
0.4703762531,
-0.4516536593,
0.6766593456,
0.1867067665,
-0.239669472,
0.7450197935,
0.3172011375,
1.1235435009,
-0.4285276234,
-0.051093474,
-0.0338441096,
-0.0445874818,
0.2335403413,
0.1213477105,
-0.2192229331,
-0.6136630177,
-0.3363365531,
-0.506336987,
-0.4476677179,
0.309058249,
-0.6037714481,
0.0243406799,
-0.475204736,
-0.1862547398,
-0.1749417335,
0.0908764899,
-0.7083033919,
0.3485608697,
0.5070072412,
0.7310308218,
-0.6724436879,
1.1022741795,
0.6766421199,
-0.0394978747,
-0.6085913181,
-0.0407026559,
0.0683036447,
-0.835734427,
0.9235684276,
0.1400026977,
-0.1334338933,
0.1071200147,
-0.1696552932,
-0.795307219,
0.9872230291,
0.3549107015,
-0.7844822407,
-0.2530470192,
0.5583866239,
0.5896700025,
-0.4206677377,
-0.3371255398,
0.7842922807,
0.4780277908,
0.3953216076,
-1.1730163097,
-0.182407096,
-0.142045632,
0.016924819,
-0.1877662539,
-0.3072329164,
0.4944490492,
-0.13016361,
-0.2469713837,
-0.1669912636,
0.5166409016,
0.0253854115,
0.7786559463,
0.581479609,
0.3530944288,
0.5065790415,
-0.1470242441,
0.5561785698,
0.0831289291,
0.19403404,
1.1992300749,
-0.5719331503,
0.6737726927,
0.1647150666,
-0.3504877985,
-0.0541600212,
0.4600425065,
-0.3347756863,
0.5944907665,
0.3697439134,
-0.2115659416,
0.0585366264,
-0.0226016026,
-0.6428255439,
0.4311142266,
0.3572081923,
-0.2366520911,
-0.1846272498,
0.4823367,
-0.4899268746,
-0.0005387253,
-0.39887923,
1.1964831352,
0.3565095365,
0.1304597557,
0.5813819766,
-0.5648320317,
0.779997766,
-0.4663391709,
-0.1082182154,
-0.2077384144,
0.3947885036,
-0.1448753327,
-0.6640735269,
0.602751255,
0.0889778957,
-0.0842497945,
-0.4322190881,
0.8223587275,
-0.3030262291,
-0.2403926849,
0.1785555035,
0.5319882631,
0.1641103178,
-0.0501574427,
-0.7660580873,
0.0728138834,
0.0320113413,
0.0165822245,
0.3787852824,
0.386289686,
0.1180740222,
0.9746457338,
0.5437493324,
0.1219466999,
0.0759729892,
0.2206430584,
0.6357190609,
-0.5236831903,
-0.4005499482,
-0.6628960967,
0.3643398881,
0.0876616463,
-0.0299275257,
0.3363013268,
0.3964883387,
0.6005238891,
-0.0517299883,
0.876465261,
0.0372397229,
0.7481960654,
-0.2612796724,
0.8673219681,
-0.2812697291,
0.2847557664,
0.0479504019,
-0.4687968194,
-0.4977472126,
0.5808666348,
-0.1379571706,
0.05529866,
0.3235548735,
0.2375624925,
0.0378253125,
-0.0686079189,
0.3929129839,
0.0863404498,
0.5807706714,
0.6129223108,
0.9390779734,
-0.3503369689,
0.5973380804,
-0.1298613548,
0.0829884186,
-0.2126743644,
-0.5422222614,
-0.6428008676,
-0.7472087741,
-0.5716207027,
-0.0038556957,
0.2056331635,
0.9763761163,
0.9277619123,
-1.0679622889,
-0.3765559494,
-0.2275123745,
-0.1648862213,
-0.2248252481,
-0.1661185324,
0.690990448,
-0.0707657188,
-0.4428485036,
0.4328670204,
-0.123673737,
0.4188960791,
0.03384047,
-0.1960347146,
0.0220699422,
-0.2756483555,
0.5569041371,
0.4951548576,
-0.485750705,
-0.3850951791,
-0.201917544,
0.0898977369,
0.2025360465,
0.7636907101,
-1.0717079639,
0.1504230648,
0.2381017208,
1.1464864016,
0.5176852942,
-0.2822592258,
0.5607823133,
-0.6867967248,
-0.0730167553,
0.5901908875,
-0.054428488,
0.4624944329,
-0.3233953416,
0.7111833692,
0.1612533182,
-0.3841863275,
-1.0075042248,
0.1577445716,
-1.0359739065,
-0.0667888224,
1.053661108,
-0.0137492651,
0.348015368,
-0.3032239676,
0.0298675057,
0.4963736534,
-0.435079217,
0.6833272576,
0.280040741,
-0.3553817272,
-0.2998259962,
-0.5769878626,
0.5960691571,
-0.0573019981,
-0.7516413927,
0.3077304661,
0.3813612759,
0.3825783432,
0.0232865717,
0.4609072208,
-0.0251987465,
0.1543547213,
-0.4009771943,
-0.1949959248,
-0.2663086951,
-0.2963726819,
-0.8483714461,
0.3336127698,
-0.0419148952,
-0.3220631182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14522v1 | Multivariate Representation Learning for Information Retrieval | 2023-04-27T20:30:46 | 2023-04-27T20:30:46 | Hamed Zamani, Michael Bendersky | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Dense retrieval models use bi-encoder network architectures for learning
query and document representations. These representations are often in the form
of a vector representation and their similarities are often computed using the
dot product function. In this paper, we propose a new representation learning
framework for dense retrieval. Instead of learning a vector for each query and
document, our framework learns a multivariate distribution and uses negative
multivariate KL divergence to compute the similarity between distributions. For
simplicity and efficiency reasons, we assume that the distributions are
multivariate normals and then train large language models to produce mean and
variance vectors for these distributions. We provide a theoretical foundation
for the proposed framework and show that it can be seamlessly integrated into
the existing approximate nearest neighbor algorithms to perform retrieval
efficiently. We conduct an extensive suite of experiments on a wide range of
datasets, and demonstrate significant improvements compared to competitive
dense retrieval models. | [
-0.4559501708,
-0.3783316016,
0.5277454257,
-0.0189987328,
-0.1611540765,
-0.1048142761,
-0.0432126708,
-0.1176008433,
0.3577027917,
0.1961347461,
-0.130384028,
-0.7349181771,
-0.406622231,
-0.0292404555,
-0.2945728302,
0.3071990907,
0.2838465869,
0.5701596141,
-0.2612658143,
-0.4865479171,
-0.4608837068,
-0.7941756845,
-0.1465890557,
-0.3210209608,
0.7640398145,
0.3844558895,
0.4989466667,
0.3038497269,
0.4202537835,
0.1989022493,
0.2032071501,
0.1009735987,
-0.863860786,
0.2852308452,
-0.0602419563,
-0.7525444627,
0.2163962871,
-0.249105081,
0.7240844965,
0.967548728,
-0.244898811,
-0.1520355493,
0.0645001084,
0.7853247523,
-0.9963078499,
0.2776074409,
-0.4639620483,
0.3881669939,
-0.1877286136,
-0.2999907136,
-0.727345407,
-0.5649600029,
-0.0599506944,
-0.7987749577,
0.3859988451,
0.3190129399,
0.5979276896,
-0.1963800788,
-0.7661787271,
-0.324885875,
-0.6844158173,
0.9539428353,
-0.114939481,
0.9800670147,
0.4492067695,
0.7358540297,
0.1109966412,
-0.3983542025,
-0.4845586419,
-0.0137403002,
0.0184204672,
-0.0917008296,
-0.0314682834,
-0.1273478866,
-0.0336197093,
0.3102013767,
-0.7247844338,
-0.1337587386,
-0.4651892483,
0.0287513454,
0.3905032575,
0.2169457078,
-0.2065851688,
-0.2641352117,
-0.6077662706,
-0.5921568274,
-0.6988332868,
-0.3245034218,
0.4079639316,
0.5405108929,
0.2903782427,
0.7398716807,
0.0016626882,
0.5020576715,
-0.1328442693,
0.1965551525,
0.8053157926,
-0.0550964847,
-0.2765983641,
-0.0690634847,
0.45377931,
0.1144480333,
-0.0046647689,
-0.1281464696,
-0.3011209667,
-0.4691970348,
0.3630447388,
-0.8428190351,
-0.2489922941,
-0.108246915,
-1.0768709183,
-0.0329572447,
0.272864908,
-0.7808144093,
-0.5345056057,
-0.668427527,
0.5842161775,
-0.8016303778,
-0.3773792684,
0.3366049528,
-0.2633460462,
0.3304634392,
0.1248730943,
-0.7901434302,
0.395701915,
0.3502168059,
0.7211511135,
0.0779230893,
-0.0661833733,
-0.7449855208,
0.1693001986,
-0.5339002609,
0.6451572776,
-0.8419154882,
-0.3796407282,
0.2237506807,
-0.3041999638,
0.0747404695,
-0.8315499425,
0.2250384241,
-1.1096842289,
-0.126018703,
-0.6711990237,
-0.6710835099,
-0.4851918221,
0.3048068881,
-0.9655727148,
0.8290616274,
0.1897488385,
-0.8239215016,
0.5225023627,
-0.2922925651,
-0.0655708835,
-0.075420931,
-0.355777353,
-0.5509623885,
0.036719773,
0.0171409957,
0.7338121533,
-0.1596614271,
-0.2170580477,
-0.9595667124,
-0.6097317934,
-0.2584491074,
-0.1612943411,
0.6981720328,
0.2673058212,
0.3191649914,
-0.2192961872,
-0.8805910945,
-0.1192741618,
0.0101288063,
-0.4806904495,
-0.7754617333,
-0.0836385489,
0.1117541939,
-0.0551262572,
0.0768313035,
-0.5277496576,
0.3166754544,
-0.1307871342,
-0.1010755077,
0.4384613931,
0.2367332429,
0.7807384133,
0.0371299759,
0.318453759,
0.4729957879,
-0.0427599736,
0.1603653729,
-0.1735541373,
-0.3487794697,
-0.2758498192,
0.3115346432,
0.2379518896,
-0.9662842155,
0.0207122453,
-0.4319012761,
-0.4083675444,
-0.3662696779,
0.3266203701,
0.1945048273,
0.3313167989,
0.7134410143,
-0.1243240908,
-0.5224523544,
-0.8185395002,
0.1391999125,
-0.1814068407,
-0.1452732533,
0.4423855543,
0.3108225167,
-0.3498884737,
0.6275336742,
-0.6692841649,
-0.5398894548,
0.0593627207,
0.4307376444,
0.2474069744,
0.149969995,
0.7881519794,
-1.2922741175,
-0.6692256331,
0.0480222069,
-0.7877910733,
0.4352308512,
0.2714294493,
-0.2865488827,
-0.3107802868,
0.7331227064,
-0.5196163654,
0.2710121274,
-0.0427972227,
-0.1990958154,
0.4614925981,
-0.3301083148,
0.0362925939,
-1.0406284332,
0.0354171544,
-0.0107649677,
-0.2846103013,
-0.346849829,
-0.0792243257,
0.4393994808,
-0.2409940958,
-0.3271838725,
0.2181332707,
-0.6616897583,
-0.3440487683,
0.1161345616,
-0.081271939,
0.2016548812,
0.2962776124,
-0.2103668749,
0.7085224986,
0.536046505,
-0.8629040122,
0.3504372537,
0.4640034139,
-0.2303918302,
0.8895260692,
-0.411464721,
-0.2115965784,
-0.9036538005,
0.0350095108,
-0.6746395826,
0.0124522243,
-0.1427546889,
-0.2762836218,
0.5270885825,
-0.2136084586,
-0.7212814093,
-0.3033977449,
-0.3453740776,
0.4345875382,
0.165900588,
-0.9452186823,
0.7385145426,
0.2576772869,
0.1260950565,
-0.887580812,
-0.6589980125,
-0.3142074645,
-0.1768802404,
-0.3712964654,
0.2351340503,
0.0277802497,
-0.0682292432,
0.1585078239,
0.3721212149,
-0.247227937,
-0.2785675824,
-0.3186540902,
-0.1369826198,
-0.4119546711,
0.9106884003,
-0.2209454179,
0.1302227378,
-0.2653169632,
-0.3270100951,
0.5996027589,
0.1418445855,
-0.6306908131,
0.2557587624,
0.861414969,
0.181415081,
-0.3717823923,
0.785391748,
0.7706488967,
-0.401306808,
-0.2843792737,
-0.4341366887,
-0.2221795171,
-0.4295138419,
0.5650777817,
-0.6504320502,
-0.5379291177,
0.5121452212,
0.1506471932,
-0.2608678639,
0.2172444314,
0.5266718268,
-0.0939261615,
1.0216634274,
0.8584755063,
0.0328732952,
0.6278101206,
-0.5136377215,
0.1689583659,
-0.6451426744,
-0.6760416627,
-0.4432583451,
-0.3139320016,
-0.1967199594,
-0.7581950426,
0.2650743127,
0.4424028695,
-0.520720005,
0.1539918929,
-0.149304539,
0.3519555628,
0.5451911688,
0.1976985931,
0.0734283328,
0.3985190988,
-0.672175467,
-0.1464915872,
-0.4836017191,
-0.01175455,
1.2756168842,
0.0629706159,
1.0244181156,
0.4476148784,
0.9203976393,
0.372300297,
0.1668607146,
-0.734026432,
0.027428899,
-0.4004069567,
-0.3076041043,
0.0193460751,
-0.8290906549,
-1.0877612829,
0.5362101793,
-0.2583427131,
-0.423135668,
1.1482700109,
-0.2854947746,
-0.1006519943,
0.2724527121,
-0.9938607812,
0.479414016,
0.0965393484,
-0.1411250532,
-0.1945310235,
-0.4404668212,
0.1362885684,
0.0752191618,
-0.0966997147,
0.1851448417,
-0.0189240668,
0.3800922632,
-0.1361632645,
0.6513930559,
-0.4893099964,
0.265145123,
0.2448893338,
0.1637931168,
0.2546219528,
0.1874860227,
-0.623277545,
-0.2061676532,
-0.0831557214,
-0.662750721,
-0.9456763268,
0.5667853355,
-0.9075872898,
-0.0313077085,
-0.1445447654,
-0.2437242121,
-0.0936592817,
0.5123306513,
0.016500622,
0.4463284016,
-0.2899444401,
0.7183026075,
0.9933594465,
-0.1145210341,
0.0726189539,
0.5263530016,
-0.3661239445,
-0.3745118678,
1.163282156,
0.3864140213,
-0.0269953292,
0.9499940872,
-0.0667393506,
-0.6022669077,
-0.2413209379,
-0.049745027,
0.156255126,
-1.1974749565,
-0.6601062417,
-0.8445325494,
-0.0724497512,
-0.2494937032,
0.2644394338,
-0.2081194222,
-0.1136859879,
-0.6182569265,
-0.2503705621,
0.2413029373,
1.0677289963,
-0.1539873332,
-0.2205800265,
-0.5447104573,
0.3145327866,
0.3522158861,
0.5144872665,
0.3299348056,
0.0660482794,
-0.4067661166,
-0.0165482257,
-0.4462518692,
-0.9282519221,
0.4001728296,
0.4781551957,
0.6420984268,
0.508556664,
0.1720205843,
0.5272670388,
-0.5413089991,
0.4288965464,
0.2947103679,
-0.3551864624,
0.0328642987,
-0.0508332811,
-0.0130465301,
0.5448774099,
0.9249361753,
-0.245632723,
0.229447037,
-0.1528128237,
-0.5841373801,
0.2886020541,
-0.0409322977,
0.2279047221,
-0.3074098229,
0.4538453221,
0.3398503661,
0.1191533059,
-0.4934051335,
-0.3678741455,
-0.3939982057,
-0.3621914387,
-0.1577504277,
-0.39776209,
0.1929135472,
-0.0673046783,
0.4657371342,
-0.3700559139,
0.8129701614,
0.1804320216,
-0.1784697026,
0.0939362943,
0.1003945321,
-0.0011122521,
0.4386494458,
-0.4055657983,
0.424816221,
-0.0138590094,
-0.3209500313,
0.1745767444,
0.3053929508,
0.1489951611,
0.2520610094,
0.034626279,
0.5159205794,
0.2594304979,
-0.3732821345,
0.9868151546,
-0.2844446003,
-0.4366884828,
-0.3297130466,
-0.3448665738,
0.3107762337,
0.4824259579,
0.6793961525,
0.0820005536,
0.5819739103,
-0.3620409369,
0.5290111899,
0.4954334795,
-0.5776122808,
-0.1580512524,
0.4624060392,
-0.3545496762,
0.1408371031,
0.7461513281,
-0.5409641862,
-0.3081182539,
0.2607855797,
0.343695879,
0.5073881745,
-0.0103240898,
0.3403920531,
0.4801264405,
-0.1147045866,
-0.1191336811,
0.65958184,
-0.1558264494,
-0.6469141245,
-0.0658474937,
-0.7175290585,
-0.0382636897,
-0.0934632123,
-0.7093738914,
0.5975494981,
-0.2001318783,
-0.0119786253,
-0.1226132363,
0.1726012081,
-1.0242884159,
-0.054974556,
0.2078943998,
0.8637072444,
-0.6427075267,
0.7858991623,
0.5133983493,
-0.921856761,
-0.6254115701,
-0.1301362067,
-0.298035413,
-0.6821734309,
1.0328899622,
0.2278044969,
0.148033753,
-0.3052765429,
-0.2871977389,
-1.06533885,
1.2184978724,
0.6360170841,
-0.4217460752,
-0.0650621057,
0.0426150635,
0.5202214718,
-0.500392139,
0.4536118507,
-0.1579287946,
0.1496611089,
0.0042135688,
-0.0853573903,
-0.2471940368,
-0.2909987271,
0.4400871992,
0.0603215732,
-0.5051839352,
1.0993200541,
-0.0235111937,
-0.3517434001,
-0.1443291754,
0.8524984717,
0.1538435519,
0.103511326,
0.2958387434,
0.5561306477,
0.9562887549,
0.3250780404,
1.226064086,
-0.0004984986,
0.6689453125,
0.9212388396,
-0.2039712667,
1.2542030811,
0.4779063761,
-0.0446957164,
0.6921184659,
0.3901056051,
-0.0277483929,
0.7287595868,
0.2383065224,
-0.218703106,
-0.3225618005,
0.0634037405,
-0.4582331479,
0.1683371365,
0.4631220102,
-0.620267272,
-0.6550944448,
0.2829369307,
-0.6623542905,
0.1869241446,
-0.0603115149,
0.7261276841,
0.1529189199,
0.0644606352,
0.8234761953,
0.0142926946,
0.4652246237,
-0.3823024035,
-0.4642085731,
-0.1215234548,
0.3126923144,
-0.1623509228,
-0.5381002426,
0.0870314315,
-0.7148475051,
-0.6456329823,
0.0558660552,
0.7352882624,
-0.6235102415,
-0.5447360277,
0.8147932291,
0.4055808187,
0.0553434752,
-0.0286189988,
-0.649523139,
-0.1065229401,
-0.2133883387,
-0.2459778935,
0.2830448449,
0.8410221338,
-0.0023891674,
0.7140188217,
0.5097766519,
-0.1252952069,
0.5689008832,
0.4806424975,
0.9916505814,
-0.5036692023,
-0.4944953024,
-0.3206882775,
-0.0054385304,
-0.1598305404,
0.1695951074,
0.4771039188,
0.8182296157,
0.8643629551,
-0.1641481668,
0.7173241973,
0.0868010595,
0.6426362991,
-0.438985914,
0.6240290999,
-0.763273716,
0.1406550258,
0.154523626,
-1.3446400166,
-0.4525761604,
0.606421113,
-0.307258755,
0.2029192299,
0.4205564559,
0.8910481334,
-0.6956648827,
-0.121149905,
0.6146035194,
0.2349746972,
0.386793226,
0.3689331114,
0.5102484226,
-0.6023284197,
0.7523082495,
-0.1917626113,
0.0786781237,
-0.4979686439,
-0.504935503,
-0.7983095646,
-0.7749817967,
0.2932744026,
-0.1560890675,
0.075836055,
0.9529211521,
0.8954594135,
-0.598498404,
-0.0258635413,
0.0806477666,
0.0835719183,
-0.1303986758,
-0.3254091442,
0.5228475332,
-0.6763705015,
-0.4941800237,
0.2718635201,
0.1216913983,
-0.1046605185,
-0.5601891875,
-0.3493873477,
-0.5807621479,
-0.1395661086,
0.7599367499,
0.0811627954,
-0.0465139933,
-0.350359261,
0.0465891473,
-0.3209565282,
0.500705421,
0.7027211785,
-0.8366787434,
0.8000437021,
0.8451327085,
0.9851662517,
0.8156967163,
-0.1091582105,
0.6518091559,
-1.0674467087,
0.0320801325,
0.4566361606,
0.451004982,
0.6994174123,
-0.4319942892,
0.0191747881,
0.0123931849,
-0.2631330192,
-0.4407608211,
0.2656472325,
-0.5713895559,
-0.2506343722,
1.0298684835,
-0.0277288202,
-0.4162430763,
-0.4277690947,
0.0712671578,
0.0567404479,
-0.6037233472,
0.4452863932,
0.4408645332,
0.2118862569,
-0.1911046207,
-0.4694922268,
0.1006620154,
0.3492167294,
0.0574418344,
-0.082444489,
0.2363323271,
0.4115524292,
0.2889472842,
0.5906444788,
-0.4677990675,
0.0859164223,
0.0160218645,
0.2479124516,
0.1180192158,
-0.2706719935,
-0.3659268022,
0.4906098545,
-0.0494368114,
-0.0073909899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14514v1 | Understanding Shared Speech-Text Representations | 2023-04-27T20:05:36 | 2023-04-27T20:05:36 | Gary Wang, Kyle Kastner, Ankur Bapna, Zhehuai Chen, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran, Yu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, a number of approaches to train speech models by incorpo-rating
text into end-to-end models have been developed, with Mae-stro advancing
state-of-the-art automatic speech recognition (ASR)and Speech Translation (ST)
performance. In this paper, we expandour understanding of the resulting shared
speech-text representationswith two types of analyses. First we examine the
limits of speech-free domain adaptation, finding that a corpus-specific
duration modelfor speech-text alignment is the most important component for
learn-ing a shared speech-text representation. Second, we inspect the
sim-ilarities between activations of unimodal (speech or text) encodersas
compared to the activations of a shared encoder. We find that theshared encoder
learns a more compact and overlapping speech-textrepresentation than the
uni-modal encoders. We hypothesize that thispartially explains the
effectiveness of the Maestro shared speech-textrepresentations. | [
-0.3632624149,
-0.1971667856,
0.3029552102,
0.2478581816,
-0.3732086718,
0.2399666607,
-0.4910281599,
-0.6708474755,
0.0727521852,
0.2417750359,
-0.2372728437,
-0.1830127537,
-0.9143291116,
0.1039418355,
-0.5768610239,
0.9452462792,
-0.3120857179,
0.2323009074,
-0.5005898476,
-0.3939401805,
-0.4742866158,
-0.8692290187,
-0.393332541,
-0.6785498857,
0.2422120273,
0.1395693868,
0.6344069242,
0.4137118161,
0.31761989,
0.2450425327,
-0.0980826691,
-0.1332404763,
-0.5334745049,
0.1192985401,
-0.0214906894,
-0.1675570905,
-0.1103333309,
-0.029245317,
0.7568205595,
0.7687363029,
-0.0994784236,
-0.095985584,
0.5126186609,
0.3675151169,
-0.3175316453,
0.1875011623,
-0.453337878,
0.1103370637,
-0.1403927654,
-0.2419470996,
-0.5870184302,
-0.1136246398,
0.4142672718,
-0.6032848358,
0.0511722378,
-0.1168894246,
0.8066422343,
0.3691899776,
-0.6825006604,
-0.5540543199,
-0.8278949857,
0.8166145086,
-0.0726469234,
0.5666040778,
0.1574848592,
0.4177699685,
0.1864792258,
-0.607390523,
-0.5097071528,
-0.056451764,
-0.310483247,
0.2480825186,
-0.2926669419,
0.2449076921,
-0.0832030922,
0.4586285055,
-0.4120757282,
0.2598440349,
-0.5741734505,
-0.1562983543,
0.7571903467,
-0.1847637892,
0.3680137992,
-0.1449865848,
-0.7069447637,
-0.1706292331,
-0.4047986865,
0.1378971487,
0.1121978685,
0.0414706282,
-0.237581417,
0.5020107627,
0.2733400464,
0.4069576263,
0.1762857884,
0.4346809983,
0.3722784519,
-0.0884302855,
-0.4457417428,
0.4279101789,
1.0058473349,
0.1679857075,
0.7018738389,
-0.4557098746,
-0.0979431719,
0.1972202808,
0.3038644791,
-0.399063915,
0.2768197358,
-0.1473390162,
-0.4371506572,
0.0421224311,
0.1806501895,
-0.4714626968,
-0.1555857509,
-0.5169988275,
0.9174847603,
-0.4185540378,
-0.1496875584,
0.3088462651,
-0.2459989488,
0.1104962304,
0.1826683283,
-0.9868100882,
0.6681364775,
0.5399793386,
0.6196389794,
-0.5349662304,
-0.4889941216,
-0.3181141317,
0.3026724458,
-0.2520681918,
0.615328908,
-0.6735203862,
-0.5419780016,
-0.1129345447,
-0.1388024986,
-0.6674961448,
-0.6109150052,
0.5963072181,
-0.5132226944,
0.1752853692,
-0.0515281968,
-0.8461497426,
-0.4536907673,
-0.3954438865,
-0.8871346712,
0.8911461234,
-0.1591768563,
-0.6728378534,
0.2164782435,
-0.7562497854,
-0.1954367906,
-0.2279811651,
-0.3734735847,
-0.1646544039,
0.4996440709,
0.24673374,
0.7117848992,
-0.1528901905,
0.3270884156,
0.359751761,
-0.495610863,
0.6683686972,
-0.6297445297,
0.5829563141,
0.0927966014,
-0.068585895,
0.2634364963,
-0.5843629837,
-0.2405127734,
-0.0625834092,
-0.2671850622,
-0.5977174044,
-0.1366782933,
0.0589828268,
-0.1153723747,
0.3879133761,
-0.4704871178,
-0.2448214144,
-0.2478469461,
0.4019239545,
0.5002310872,
0.1142050102,
0.6966932416,
-0.2875171304,
0.507959187,
0.2357115448,
-0.039306473,
-0.2148874551,
-0.298530668,
-0.6028336883,
-0.1743964404,
0.4040892422,
0.3470284641,
-0.4861074984,
-0.0522311069,
-0.4939263165,
-0.2037841231,
-0.8977405429,
-0.1418586522,
0.6001640558,
0.0375115946,
0.4770203233,
-0.4534733593,
-0.6306275725,
-0.8541194201,
-0.372079432,
0.0414496735,
-0.0007190747,
0.0388657264,
0.405773133,
-0.3754653931,
0.8851968646,
-0.0824486017,
-0.0202584006,
-0.4076352119,
0.1997637749,
-0.1009762287,
0.510248065,
0.5663172603,
-0.869623363,
-0.8787993193,
0.1687389761,
-0.7297199965,
-0.2765449882,
-0.256911099,
0.237800315,
0.1616478264,
0.4714977741,
-0.3247310817,
0.535844624,
0.8252910376,
-0.1968081445,
0.3937870562,
-0.3525041044,
0.3467938602,
-0.8329892755,
-0.1161016002,
-0.2491428107,
-0.4177455604,
-1.0217876434,
-0.0484926775,
-0.0132222986,
-0.2716338336,
-0.1515636742,
0.2688643932,
-0.5796623826,
-0.4886244237,
-0.0767521411,
0.3549480438,
-0.0335862376,
0.5617328882,
0.0981157571,
1.1572524309,
0.7012049556,
-0.6981574297,
-0.0339544825,
0.1914549917,
-0.1751963049,
0.3565386832,
-0.9645425677,
0.2200771421,
-0.3018537462,
-0.1911840737,
-0.8805418015,
-0.062443234,
-0.0319488719,
-0.7505704165,
0.5699985623,
0.0254020784,
-0.4780195653,
0.0932245404,
-0.1365482509,
0.6182681322,
0.4162513316,
-0.7853412628,
0.583455205,
0.7478098273,
0.0229247231,
-0.4317848682,
-0.617036283,
-0.0325870104,
-0.1607707441,
-0.635376811,
0.7251371741,
0.1282639205,
-0.2457799613,
0.1156296059,
-0.1268080026,
-0.1225980893,
-0.0099583417,
0.506844461,
0.0334440432,
-0.1332444698,
0.0523033552,
0.3338498771,
-0.2674494684,
-0.1102530137,
0.0136525407,
0.6599702835,
-0.0883899927,
-0.2933189571,
-0.6987524033,
0.7227608562,
0.5141226649,
-0.2683727443,
0.8807188869,
0.2406484038,
-0.3071624935,
0.1485250741,
-0.1405953318,
0.1425030977,
-0.434691608,
0.1080762371,
-0.4526785314,
-1.1191927195,
0.6072770357,
0.0796721354,
-0.186853677,
0.6116629839,
0.3191047311,
-0.2257968932,
0.7210091352,
0.7319756746,
0.0068958127,
0.5231029987,
-0.1577800065,
-0.187700361,
-0.9469868541,
-0.5443361998,
-0.4295834601,
-0.1281050891,
-0.4332078397,
-0.7492827773,
0.2014067918,
0.2540008426,
-0.0803069696,
0.6541321874,
-0.3648750186,
0.4693041742,
0.4615392387,
-0.1967787445,
0.2920814455,
0.384068042,
-0.259306252,
-0.3666915298,
-0.5293930769,
-0.512227118,
0.8462774158,
0.4438745677,
0.5619267821,
0.0991467834,
0.8310219646,
0.3745175302,
-0.1968942732,
-0.7520956397,
0.3805102408,
-0.6104620099,
-0.2162219584,
-0.0290988777,
-0.3247177303,
-0.9331017733,
0.3383741975,
-0.1777741164,
-0.6989649534,
0.3332834244,
-0.1486985683,
-0.0595452078,
-0.0451503992,
-0.8293225169,
0.6911531091,
-0.089161925,
-0.0115549266,
-0.5579909086,
-0.5471314788,
-0.2440212965,
0.0200898945,
0.0719696358,
0.3656161726,
0.0075344434,
1.1178346872,
-0.0132180499,
0.8185177445,
-0.156638056,
0.0440680981,
0.4547335804,
-0.2168540061,
0.0627595186,
-0.5061689615,
-0.0800845474,
0.387316972,
-0.0654827878,
0.0277997684,
-0.6302320361,
0.3961521983,
-1.0672290325,
-0.4185702801,
-0.511533916,
-0.4626779556,
-0.1616737545,
-0.179885298,
0.2128453255,
0.6811145544,
-0.4950315654,
0.382747978,
0.8429533839,
-0.3335995674,
0.3832738101,
0.3032080531,
-0.3185855448,
-0.5264363885,
0.5021945834,
0.222769469,
0.4859626591,
0.6705399752,
0.0204428341,
-0.3808443248,
-0.4286696017,
-0.4215606153,
0.3200135827,
-0.6547446251,
0.134761706,
-0.7381682992,
-0.5478495359,
-0.2585103214,
-0.2432591617,
-0.1725912839,
-0.7665014267,
-0.6754153967,
-0.2877065837,
0.4916121066,
0.8181738853,
-0.3302991688,
0.8193408251,
-0.7757155299,
0.2174270898,
0.3443281949,
0.1005809754,
0.1167560965,
-0.8598685861,
-0.3999921978,
-0.0701317713,
-0.0577168986,
-1.1727421284,
0.2581887841,
0.5057943463,
0.8034890294,
0.3763329089,
-0.101350747,
0.8734738231,
-0.5991924405,
0.7237854004,
0.2733135819,
-1.3079189062,
0.3009287715,
-0.0856538191,
0.0874489397,
0.5762090087,
0.555863142,
-0.8563091159,
-0.2883380353,
-0.3415878415,
-0.6135008931,
0.7075022459,
0.3715361953,
0.238819316,
0.3191712797,
0.3200897872,
0.4107367992,
0.1123592705,
-0.728191793,
-0.1981475651,
-0.346773684,
-0.4165199697,
-0.2072774619,
-0.6031498909,
0.0518218055,
-0.1286103576,
0.3270186782,
0.2626209855,
0.7086466551,
0.1191714332,
-0.4450716674,
0.1070703641,
0.5424712896,
0.4589249194,
0.2039227486,
-0.0290394984,
0.364567697,
0.0724745616,
-0.51018399,
0.0359023549,
0.1712867469,
0.1059020683,
0.3367624581,
0.5218010545,
1.1773070097,
0.4564947188,
-0.5110437274,
0.6247133613,
-0.0344280489,
0.1148194075,
-0.19607988,
0.1387681961,
-0.0372767374,
0.2398253679,
0.4861156642,
0.1756257117,
0.1321991831,
-0.6674461961,
0.4083120525,
0.1595555544,
-0.7073055506,
-0.4518988431,
0.7042576671,
0.1926503181,
-0.2618528008,
-0.0556834936,
-0.0882653147,
-0.9638755918,
0.4869860709,
0.7376548052,
0.8771752119,
-0.4907205403,
0.2486801147,
0.115009129,
0.0618686751,
-0.0486287363,
0.167268008,
-0.5637080073,
-0.6577964425,
-0.3649173677,
-0.4768505991,
-0.3254547715,
-0.4647474289,
-1.1310719252,
-0.029156724,
-0.069843553,
0.0201078448,
-0.1621459872,
0.0072022015,
-0.4793819785,
0.0199242327,
-0.091386281,
0.6658468246,
-0.8250867724,
0.9466413856,
0.600224793,
-0.2533991635,
-0.8627094626,
0.1674927175,
-0.0908209458,
-0.9506490827,
0.7559646368,
0.316888839,
-0.360147953,
-0.0055631218,
-0.1278802305,
-0.7138738632,
1.1561683416,
0.2970450222,
-0.7788920403,
0.0367131904,
0.3333583474,
0.7949399948,
-0.5984297991,
-0.0330653861,
0.3761847615,
-0.1052438095,
0.0319981501,
-1.3993426561,
-0.1619061083,
0.0313769393,
0.1000284627,
0.1145700961,
-0.3101906478,
0.6754342318,
0.0560849644,
-0.6220317483,
-0.0261035096,
0.7212659717,
0.0704283044,
0.52923733,
0.2754068077,
0.3153818548,
0.6953518987,
0.0986651108,
0.9991323352,
-0.1547356993,
0.3886030614,
1.2892506123,
0.0062322072,
1.0407403708,
0.4816124141,
-0.1034810618,
0.4555039406,
0.268279314,
0.2877292633,
0.7438037992,
-0.2241227627,
-0.51592803,
0.004057039,
-0.2435824871,
-0.4595362842,
0.5765413642,
0.5164524913,
-0.6043168306,
0.0466234088,
0.4266104698,
0.0143724596,
0.4193117023,
-0.493359983,
0.9051626921,
0.3264894485,
-0.4437804222,
0.4532889426,
-0.0711351633,
0.799061656,
-0.4856787026,
0.3345360756,
0.1489181519,
0.0290828533,
-0.0433892533,
-0.7837647796,
0.6200854182,
0.3202496171,
-0.2806000412,
-0.5307203531,
0.7697750926,
-0.6676115394,
0.001351042,
0.8136337996,
0.2789828181,
0.2971417308,
0.098594822,
-0.3725410104,
0.3653972745,
0.1292643994,
0.2833116651,
0.1490418166,
0.5758137703,
0.0465919562,
0.3664936423,
0.1495178044,
0.0351763107,
0.3158665597,
0.2919418514,
0.6927136183,
-0.499632448,
-0.3637818396,
-0.8225666881,
0.433128804,
-0.0629492179,
0.0403296612,
0.7766753435,
0.5271030664,
0.8385421038,
-0.1257101595,
0.6249269843,
0.2031319886,
0.4006806016,
-0.5654402971,
0.8925577998,
-0.4761597216,
0.1610764712,
-0.1850266904,
-0.545604229,
-0.261788547,
0.8345948458,
-0.2796461284,
-0.280523628,
0.671244204,
0.4492532611,
-0.0145376241,
0.3076876104,
0.3991188407,
0.1072350219,
0.0990575925,
0.5269060731,
1.0848497152,
-0.6523436308,
0.5603234768,
0.0954573974,
-0.1140771955,
-0.0955995843,
-0.4523102641,
-0.9063981175,
-0.9072963595,
-0.2775745094,
-0.0272577703,
0.0496923737,
0.9772242308,
0.4253348708,
-0.6769065857,
-0.3675776124,
0.1070125103,
-0.1241402701,
-0.2849889398,
-0.1581698954,
0.3769775033,
-0.070956476,
-0.7661203742,
0.2894427776,
0.2991998494,
0.3393120766,
0.0379087888,
-0.3916298449,
0.1901825219,
0.3018524647,
0.6680131555,
0.1124135777,
-0.3766247332,
-0.3154495358,
-0.0544806905,
-0.0655571967,
0.2485783994,
0.9940481186,
-0.8634591699,
0.45183447,
0.4671389163,
0.6153435111,
0.6396819353,
-0.1741892099,
0.6536131501,
-0.8653846383,
0.0976368338,
0.07181108,
0.349792093,
0.3511948884,
-0.0585831329,
0.2294039577,
0.0029563499,
-0.6428633928,
-0.7180842161,
0.3486586213,
-1.243650198,
-0.0085894931,
0.9692046046,
-0.180807367,
0.039353136,
-0.1995089203,
-0.2397109419,
0.637981236,
-0.6423529983,
0.5408302546,
0.5935996175,
-0.2573139369,
-0.2184238136,
-0.3302899897,
0.3658306897,
0.225181073,
-0.4275067747,
0.0513192751,
0.2073551863,
0.1564993858,
0.2932281494,
0.6495374441,
-0.2533103526,
0.0220224708,
-0.0481243655,
-0.294622153,
-0.0267635286,
-0.4910507798,
-0.7160699964,
0.125755474,
-0.1443441659,
-0.5785522461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14511v1 | Visual Referential Games Further the Emergence of Disentangled Representations | 2023-04-27T20:00:51 | 2023-04-27T20:00:51 | Kevin Denamganaï, Sondess Missaoui, James Alfred Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural languages are powerful tools wielded by human beings to communicate
information. Among their desirable properties, compositionality has been the
main focus in the context of referential games and variants, as it promises to
enable greater systematicity to the agents which would wield it. The concept of
disentanglement has been shown to be of paramount importance to learned
representations that generalise well in deep learning, and is thought to be a
necessary condition to enable systematicity. Thus, this paper investigates how
do compositionality at the level of the emerging languages, disentanglement at
the level of the learned representations, and systematicity relate to each
other in the context of visual referential games. Firstly, we find that visual
referential games that are based on the Obverter architecture outperforms
state-of-the-art unsupervised learning approach in terms of many major
disentanglement metrics. Secondly, we expand the previously proposed Positional
Disentanglement (PosDis) metric for compositionality to (re-)incorporate some
concerns pertaining to informativeness and completeness features found in the
Mutual Information Gap (MIG) disentanglement metric it stems from. This
extension allows for further discrimination between the different kind of
compositional languages that emerge in the context of Obverter-based
referential games, in a way that neither the referential game accuracy nor
previous metrics were able to capture. Finally we investigate whether the
resulting (emergent) systematicity, as measured by zero-shot compositional
learning tests, correlates with any of the disentanglement and compositionality
metrics proposed so far. Throughout the training process, statically
significant correlation coefficients can be found both positive and negative
depending on the moment of the measure. | [
-0.3644380569,
-0.5191422701,
0.5393313766,
0.1688997447,
-0.2177028954,
0.2208181024,
-0.2961922288,
-0.5704579949,
0.1914598644,
0.1002287418,
-0.3273474276,
-0.3747815192,
-0.5637974739,
0.0721948817,
-0.179901734,
0.7561525702,
-0.3631411195,
0.1339524984,
-0.3543165922,
-0.2558663189,
-0.4402306974,
-0.4023166895,
-0.2589963675,
-0.5408262014,
0.498780936,
0.0078201508,
0.5418590903,
0.7259800434,
0.9363104105,
0.4886615872,
-0.0756864771,
-0.1288460344,
-0.7243004441,
0.4419420063,
-0.3515663743,
-1.093126297,
0.1836603135,
0.0744280517,
0.752969861,
0.7570791841,
-0.2739905715,
0.2113475502,
0.2814084589,
0.9059236646,
-0.6626024842,
0.3080638945,
-0.3603748083,
0.4690495431,
-0.1618038267,
-0.0136876209,
-0.2301561534,
-0.0549787059,
0.2038727999,
-0.8557809591,
0.1864888966,
-0.190253675,
0.9049665332,
0.4263708889,
-0.122111246,
-0.3674845994,
-1.041965723,
0.7764373422,
-0.4532350898,
0.3166297078,
-0.0133887157,
0.5672523975,
-0.0636151135,
-0.5262545943,
-0.543014586,
-0.1305960119,
0.015707979,
0.5132243633,
-0.4712469876,
-0.0661035404,
0.4167059958,
0.4977670014,
-0.4210200608,
-0.0605910495,
-0.3022435308,
0.1722079664,
0.5613542199,
0.2945463359,
0.379209131,
0.1300087422,
-0.3686294556,
0.0720397606,
-0.585686028,
0.001562801,
0.4250910282,
-0.2149689347,
-0.2880555093,
0.5662240386,
-0.0925652087,
0.8093646169,
0.5572495461,
-0.3086946309,
0.1302824467,
-0.5802764893,
0.1455346793,
0.1253855228,
0.9842036366,
0.2582393289,
0.3247895539,
-0.3571053445,
-0.1130878553,
0.5629810095,
0.1503648758,
-0.4547836483,
-0.3121212125,
-0.1463952363,
-0.5156167746,
-0.2880981863,
0.5211227536,
-0.1972275227,
-0.3182708919,
-0.599655211,
0.2952410877,
-0.4891769588,
-0.5032784939,
0.2340357751,
-0.356589973,
0.5075594783,
0.1008020118,
-0.9478821754,
0.1350778341,
0.5532938242,
0.69008255,
-0.2367949635,
-0.3929829299,
0.2185984105,
0.2103186846,
-0.4583208263,
0.4731121361,
-0.5074349642,
-0.3060977757,
-0.0539685674,
-0.1645818055,
0.0142380046,
-0.780048728,
-0.1556517631,
-0.5036244392,
0.3150272965,
-0.2991069853,
-0.4629049897,
-0.118046023,
0.5189235806,
-0.7368363738,
0.6431618929,
-0.0863951221,
-0.670091629,
0.6157280207,
-0.324000597,
-0.424113214,
0.0729953572,
-0.3884353936,
-0.1548952162,
0.5613647103,
-0.2852715552,
0.085994564,
-0.2978181541,
-0.0514942408,
-0.2750199139,
-0.5620983243,
0.4158676565,
-0.0889164135,
0.4723503292,
0.0600092411,
-0.5935053825,
-0.1871993393,
-0.5556684136,
-0.2457946092,
0.244242534,
-0.2398387343,
-0.5221365094,
0.2726837993,
-0.6857780218,
0.3720040917,
0.1525290608,
-0.492157191,
-0.1601849049,
-0.3515211344,
0.4277739823,
0.4453045726,
0.3185355961,
0.7528578043,
-0.3097033203,
0.3405086398,
0.6520106792,
0.3041085303,
0.0200205408,
-0.3309637904,
-0.821921587,
-0.1369550228,
0.2816133201,
0.4907691777,
-0.9454243183,
0.6041330695,
-0.3737113178,
-0.4879367352,
-0.465179652,
-0.0603155643,
0.4665161669,
0.2946793139,
-0.0333805084,
-0.6522017121,
-0.3850994408,
-0.6733531356,
0.0168110002,
-0.2261001319,
0.0308178179,
0.130526498,
0.3126980364,
-0.1477560699,
0.8278760314,
-0.4678084552,
-0.3682622313,
0.0008671392,
0.1178780496,
0.2318881452,
0.3297176361,
0.6752243638,
-0.7133030295,
-0.6528949142,
0.0262284186,
-1.1485714912,
0.2240992039,
-0.1185721159,
-0.118459262,
-0.2131362408,
0.4556427896,
-0.3317700028,
0.1774447411,
0.3624517322,
-0.2054301798,
0.344632715,
-0.13400428,
0.1054333448,
-0.8976415396,
-0.049570743,
0.0075598485,
0.0011584765,
-0.4383517504,
0.3275260329,
-0.3660791516,
0.1800049543,
-0.454823941,
-0.0388716161,
-0.8429681063,
0.144202292,
-0.1162627861,
0.3013305962,
-0.1080311164,
0.4252411425,
0.2957214117,
0.3763190806,
1.0854876041,
-0.813231051,
0.3659828007,
0.1099770814,
-0.1395415068,
0.8795539737,
-0.7122084498,
-0.3859243095,
-0.5478836298,
-0.1252714097,
-0.9749143124,
0.2280834764,
0.1789309233,
-0.4528707266,
0.2034406215,
0.1449352205,
-0.3490977585,
-0.2088774443,
-0.3228364885,
0.4341600239,
0.7028103471,
-0.242503345,
0.3447299004,
0.3437806666,
0.3684662879,
-0.6792889237,
-0.8598566651,
-0.2459255308,
-0.1862544566,
-0.3680586517,
0.1598259509,
-0.1584369987,
-0.2581830621,
0.1215887666,
-0.2351995856,
0.1782442182,
0.0410140865,
0.3098018765,
0.125154078,
-0.4591795504,
-0.2732705474,
-0.2514063716,
-0.1323110163,
0.2934445441,
-0.2045514137,
0.4716926515,
-0.0805380121,
-0.5933661461,
-0.1066602394,
0.1668912172,
0.4115455449,
-0.311150223,
0.5660462976,
0.4927729666,
-0.1636686027,
-0.0564775988,
-0.409293592,
-0.009805684,
-0.4885875285,
0.3046951294,
-0.3228098154,
-0.7727066875,
0.8453570604,
-0.0996146575,
-0.0938950777,
0.2358344197,
0.2746617496,
-0.2209518105,
0.777161479,
0.4691563547,
-0.0407967307,
0.7627049685,
-0.5084848404,
0.0719375685,
-0.8159182072,
-0.4715726376,
-0.1841904819,
-0.6647239327,
-0.8198341727,
-0.50982517,
0.0807042792,
0.2619189918,
-0.4484426677,
0.3760706484,
-0.4655995071,
0.9650606513,
0.3712787032,
0.2113545835,
0.3016253114,
0.0635920614,
-0.2561564744,
-0.3930053413,
-0.6181601286,
-0.1420348883,
0.8153690696,
0.1517607123,
0.9649227262,
0.6028669477,
1.3724877834,
0.0014321626,
0.1764702648,
-0.7948480844,
0.4170754254,
-0.0411143415,
-0.3339350224,
-0.1779085398,
-0.4528671503,
-0.9968910217,
0.0715437904,
-0.2322633713,
-0.443533659,
0.524653852,
-0.2109155506,
-0.1102116257,
0.0670065656,
-0.4896563292,
0.6615703106,
-0.2103517503,
-0.6028114557,
0.0444914922,
-0.6842358708,
0.4451521933,
0.2543816864,
-0.1009687409,
0.2185974568,
-0.2173543721,
0.5352337956,
-0.0667506978,
0.7765953541,
-0.0992440581,
-0.1875906587,
0.5182794333,
0.4223826528,
-0.0556199402,
0.109179087,
0.4359659553,
0.3389126658,
-0.1166006103,
-0.346806258,
-0.6375011802,
0.6770256758,
-0.8109343052,
-0.5344035029,
-0.6184181571,
-0.0973239839,
-0.1111495867,
0.4136897326,
0.2451489121,
0.186483413,
-0.5245214701,
0.0796379671,
1.0675107241,
0.0649441108,
0.532566011,
0.7546377778,
-0.0410381891,
-0.3259066343,
1.2427480221,
-0.2306252569,
0.4692836404,
0.8498083353,
0.017859837,
-0.3629669249,
-0.5872685313,
-0.0786416754,
0.5015858412,
-0.4951942861,
-0.2101960629,
0.2375712693,
-0.3179252446,
0.0719457641,
-0.1461051702,
-0.1996155381,
-0.0054008937,
-0.3320069313,
-0.0934866816,
-0.3926629126,
0.9909926653,
-0.3028453588,
0.1392316073,
-0.6537703872,
0.3105806708,
0.2538052797,
0.4578531384,
0.1833147705,
-0.2391224205,
-0.1312511414,
0.1796762943,
-0.3361967802,
-0.882149756,
-0.3167062104,
0.1602699012,
0.7592561245,
0.9010865092,
-0.2077312917,
0.8559975028,
-0.5819580555,
0.9099239707,
0.725074172,
-0.7425174713,
0.1372061074,
-0.3215024173,
0.4848968983,
0.7721350193,
0.520770967,
-0.6477457285,
-0.5105628967,
-0.6109521985,
-0.5170226693,
0.6827687025,
0.0433719754,
0.092420809,
-0.3047381341,
0.103492327,
-0.0105522396,
0.1841208041,
-0.7857310772,
-0.6722870469,
-0.0621886142,
-0.1465986222,
-0.0252935179,
-0.1366263777,
-0.2215326279,
-0.1380874664,
0.2252832949,
0.3223565519,
0.3832361698,
0.1758285016,
-0.1705686301,
-0.0179980434,
-0.0957107544,
0.4133853912,
0.5927224159,
0.1582729369,
0.1395985335,
-0.4202004373,
-0.5844906569,
0.6023816466,
-0.0697472841,
-0.2918238044,
0.2040684819,
0.577871263,
0.7075392008,
0.3451836705,
-0.5462696552,
0.5910760164,
-0.0538094267,
-0.2879625261,
-0.1487680525,
0.1511441767,
0.0588390231,
0.1922780573,
0.1020622849,
0.1539732665,
0.1612079293,
-0.6638845205,
0.1568697393,
0.5160778761,
-0.7990495563,
-0.4566368759,
0.5849336982,
0.2120563537,
-0.0330525786,
0.2458032668,
-0.4051895142,
-0.1550669223,
0.3886562884,
0.5245451927,
0.6475977302,
-0.3960965276,
0.4716419876,
0.5969541669,
0.3177023828,
-0.0470500737,
0.2823249102,
-0.3370619714,
-0.7793987989,
-0.2830685973,
-0.387060225,
0.0351480916,
-0.1511448473,
-0.7248353362,
-0.1460151225,
-0.3381038904,
-0.1832915992,
-0.1046526283,
-0.2055180371,
-0.5558704138,
-0.2072019875,
0.4854053855,
0.4466686249,
-0.8105849028,
0.1281269938,
0.8243739605,
-0.8574720025,
-0.648570776,
-0.0332976244,
-0.1654421687,
-0.5148702264,
0.6580076814,
-0.1568381786,
-0.0685971081,
-0.0681650415,
-0.2636230886,
-0.9375249743,
1.1426727772,
0.4521909058,
-0.6662767529,
-0.0783344731,
0.6595917344,
0.8037232757,
-0.0711264983,
0.3294836581,
0.4662435651,
0.2711687684,
0.295848012,
-0.6198788285,
0.0160254929,
-0.0623914897,
0.1244531646,
0.4375676513,
-0.5905687213,
0.5930040479,
-0.0484014191,
-0.6143312454,
-0.0793959349,
0.5867439508,
0.0681053177,
-0.1014019549,
0.0612056851,
0.7187421918,
0.2835932672,
-0.3603980243,
0.7095560431,
-0.3201194108,
0.224922061,
0.7870491743,
-0.3766727448,
0.5439013243,
0.5576511025,
-0.3616055846,
0.6500649452,
0.284812957,
0.1017290652,
0.6420427561,
0.5161778927,
-0.2718118727,
-0.0967907012,
0.0110458834,
-0.4532137513,
0.500447154,
0.1545292884,
-0.443603605,
-0.6938797235,
-0.0831592977,
-0.3064506948,
0.4469051659,
-0.1625473052,
1.2607849836,
0.0568700694,
-0.6269341111,
0.5063413978,
-0.1795391589,
0.8015838265,
-0.9792820811,
-0.1296926737,
-0.478096664,
0.4734751582,
-0.1162411273,
-0.8057782054,
0.0985698998,
-0.3572777808,
-0.3065510988,
0.0713155568,
0.3541603386,
-0.6894071698,
-0.276488781,
0.2821375728,
0.6792966127,
-0.0387437977,
0.062096227,
-0.8635346889,
0.021273138,
-0.0261659548,
0.1965979785,
0.4123518169,
0.7389966846,
0.1632634103,
0.2165713012,
0.331496805,
0.2399029583,
0.0903815031,
-0.1005590931,
0.7606360912,
-0.5915949345,
-0.4404051304,
-1.0032805204,
0.4876486361,
-0.1557079256,
-0.1477365643,
0.9301247001,
0.7121557593,
0.9536665678,
-0.523021102,
0.5756415129,
-0.1731580496,
-0.1376696825,
-0.2803703845,
0.6348527074,
-0.2301110625,
-0.1279885471,
-0.2459388822,
-1.2012501955,
-0.1956934333,
0.5587007403,
-0.1319402754,
-0.2745534778,
0.7291434407,
0.5491400957,
-0.2673137486,
-0.3031202853,
0.3752336204,
-0.1619271636,
0.1836641431,
0.8179572821,
1.0107878447,
-0.5783421397,
0.2339186221,
-0.2288363874,
-0.4169804454,
0.0896395743,
-0.5963673592,
-0.9125545621,
-0.8535857201,
-0.4922643602,
-0.124387525,
-0.0728549883,
0.2037528157,
0.4677420259,
-0.6471549273,
-0.4308034182,
-0.3167339563,
0.1425176859,
-0.5714491606,
-0.2804744542,
-0.1731473505,
-0.2610469162,
-0.7425628304,
-0.0314961933,
0.3146227002,
0.2789848149,
-0.5530738235,
-0.1843350232,
-0.2332238555,
0.1369703412,
0.6681616306,
0.5773440003,
-0.4575432837,
0.0979728922,
0.0393095724,
-0.1082735956,
-0.0237468909,
0.9627303481,
-0.6844888926,
0.6494829059,
0.5545544028,
0.3415198624,
0.3821953833,
-0.0248228982,
0.4965415299,
-0.7621481419,
0.5522103906,
0.1602743417,
0.312964648,
0.314935863,
-0.0470875055,
0.3442103863,
0.3010092974,
-0.0299226586,
-0.587074101,
0.5803658962,
-0.842045486,
0.1023660377,
1.0143828392,
-0.0857319757,
-0.5105443001,
0.1251375377,
-0.0635786951,
0.0850592405,
-0.0126817757,
0.7358542085,
0.8524512649,
-0.210805878,
0.3004925251,
0.1789720356,
0.52811414,
0.03445483,
-0.4226925373,
-0.2386285663,
0.6931728721,
0.2596605122,
0.6881443858,
0.3014775813,
-0.3134233952,
0.333262831,
0.3109381199,
0.0027312741,
-0.1813222319,
-0.1285525411,
-0.1531974226,
0.0053802812,
0.0883969069,
-0.6458061934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14456v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14456v1 | Framing the News:From Human Perception to Large Language Model Inferences | 2023-04-27T18:30:18 | 2023-04-27T18:30:18 | David Alonso del Barrio, Daniel Gatica-Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Identifying the frames of news is important to understand the articles'
vision, intention, message to be conveyed, and which aspects of the news are
emphasized. Framing is a widely studied concept in journalism, and has emerged
as a new topic in computing, with the potential to automate processes and
facilitate the work of journalism professionals. In this paper, we study this
issue with articles related to the Covid-19 anti-vaccine movement. First, to
understand the perspectives used to treat this theme, we developed a protocol
for human labeling of frames for 1786 headlines of No-Vax movement articles of
European newspapers from 5 countries. Headlines are key units in the written
press, and worth of analysis as many people only read headlines (or use them to
guide their decision for further reading.) Second, considering advances in
Natural Language Processing (NLP) with large language models, we investigated
two approaches for frame inference of news headlines: first with a GPT-3.5
fine-tuning approach, and second with GPT-3.5 prompt-engineering. Our work
contributes to the study and analysis of the performance that these models have
to facilitate journalistic tasks like classification of frames, while
understanding whether the models are able to replicate human perception in the
identification of these frames. | [
-0.5922550559,
-1.0883675814,
0.6799322963,
0.041435644,
-0.1791704893,
-0.1175487489,
-0.0083964868,
-0.6753999591,
0.1396163255,
0.2370525151,
-0.2571253479,
-0.2787027359,
-0.5968128443,
0.0064370446,
-0.737282455,
0.913915813,
-0.1053363234,
0.2405072302,
0.0362167396,
0.1912026256,
-0.2136348933,
-0.5125405788,
-0.5544443727,
-0.2494767308,
0.1932955384,
-0.1132463887,
0.6937389374,
0.743026197,
0.2350051701,
0.2125765085,
-0.4480037093,
-0.223040998,
-0.1157588661,
-0.3454379439,
-0.4312134683,
-0.4048118889,
-0.3284550309,
0.3713867664,
0.5051519275,
0.464107573,
0.249190405,
0.2880755365,
-0.0082734618,
0.5618110299,
-0.313144058,
-0.0848466232,
-0.1552051902,
0.2936928868,
-0.3342382312,
-0.1998662949,
-0.4268478751,
0.0934552476,
-0.0207214672,
-0.5614655018,
0.4591482282,
0.2838255167,
1.1193761826,
-0.0747292563,
-0.627980113,
-0.2041518539,
-0.4322235584,
0.4278457165,
-0.4742439091,
0.296481818,
0.5006180406,
0.0645475984,
-0.301446408,
-0.3469848931,
-0.4412923753,
-0.0663794503,
0.0423511378,
-0.2136494666,
-0.508128047,
-0.0231409501,
0.3486274481,
0.3804731667,
-0.807061553,
0.1344180107,
-0.3863038123,
-0.2488611341,
0.6317119598,
0.0026514283,
0.5120896101,
-0.4717563689,
-0.5399364829,
0.1892902255,
-0.4595689774,
0.1736165881,
0.2388128787,
-0.0127728833,
-0.5433077216,
0.4936097264,
-0.5533023477,
1.025262475,
0.4091132283,
-0.0247855801,
0.1840142757,
-0.4371329844,
-0.4327209592,
0.1431575269,
0.5959532857,
0.5601359606,
-0.012219104,
-0.134315908,
0.0536974482,
0.2868240178,
0.4599000514,
-0.6537100077,
-0.0000670243,
-0.2021844983,
-0.5107827783,
-0.34534958,
0.1119404882,
-0.8728706241,
-0.2741419673,
-0.4407010972,
0.6044943333,
-0.0172482189,
-0.0821370482,
0.4642193615,
-0.3862863183,
0.4587159753,
0.5004928112,
-0.8327258229,
0.0169599317,
0.8989937305,
0.623129189,
-0.1446752548,
0.203237921,
-0.6191219091,
-0.0333829261,
-0.4751954377,
0.8668391705,
-0.6110696197,
0.0655796975,
-0.3632842898,
0.08884985,
0.0050927391,
-0.0766428337,
0.5337626338,
-0.7775352001,
0.5287560225,
-0.2099066228,
-0.5955069661,
-0.3776570857,
0.4116480947,
-0.5714295506,
0.4529000819,
-0.1393015087,
-0.9410257936,
0.2801299989,
-0.5390553474,
-0.412658155,
-0.2422126532,
-0.2152321637,
-0.4195944369,
0.4885673225,
0.537267983,
0.3203369379,
-0.2412912101,
0.4865708947,
-0.182136178,
-0.1355808675,
0.0395356491,
-0.6570532918,
0.641045928,
0.2865000963,
-0.3175962865,
0.1696311831,
-0.6088896394,
-0.4321958721,
-0.1825298518,
-0.1979121864,
-0.3300142288,
-0.0237317588,
0.1093463451,
0.1530634463,
-0.2351501882,
-0.513348341,
0.1926278472,
-0.3373783231,
0.6125387549,
0.2161319107,
0.2625772953,
0.7278385162,
-0.3310441971,
0.5865077972,
-0.0371075049,
0.1051660031,
-0.5136767626,
-0.7497159839,
-0.192402631,
-0.1906760633,
0.2364313155,
0.5447558165,
-0.6756463051,
-0.0433812626,
0.11867515,
-0.2655619979,
-0.0892053396,
-0.3138302565,
0.2147404402,
0.6154056191,
0.1987483203,
-0.31362167,
-0.659324944,
-0.6825756431,
-0.6451637149,
0.0061602681,
0.008734474,
-0.3054289222,
0.3440245688,
-0.0284748115,
1.1288411617,
-0.4517917633,
0.1862591803,
-0.1419711709,
0.6014631987,
0.2604340613,
0.3657662272,
0.6064914465,
-1.248716712,
-0.1866118014,
-0.2858023047,
-0.6860842109,
-0.1795979291,
-0.3260215819,
0.0788098797,
0.227261737,
0.7897129655,
-0.6060495377,
0.6602056623,
0.4239647686,
-0.7587201595,
0.7063801885,
0.0450004674,
0.3089749515,
-1.1062041521,
-0.12176577,
0.4642380774,
-0.5592931509,
-0.6698094606,
0.1271322817,
-0.0821632892,
-0.4364317656,
-0.5437938571,
0.8143563867,
-0.4880760908,
-0.1455165297,
-0.3700378537,
-0.0414944105,
0.4143366516,
0.0427798517,
0.1270540804,
0.7361904383,
0.4467929304,
-0.2461675853,
0.2335480899,
0.1993679255,
-0.7727469206,
0.6238310337,
-0.3061395288,
-0.1276225001,
-0.5713348389,
0.463956058,
-0.8804668188,
-0.4974456728,
0.4448479116,
-0.6325216889,
0.0575544275,
0.0617394112,
-0.2793888748,
-0.4140032828,
-0.1223683134,
0.3494918346,
0.1085010767,
-0.2638786435,
0.1781163216,
0.5394362211,
-0.0374487564,
-0.2647180855,
-0.8680676222,
0.5311151743,
-0.3566798568,
-0.5337674618,
0.2408599257,
0.1959852427,
-0.5410805941,
0.1126807854,
-0.3782638311,
-0.2985642552,
0.2736083567,
0.1106179208,
0.0443526022,
-0.5265455246,
0.2238632888,
-0.0883989558,
-0.4264665246,
-0.0763198733,
-0.0984193534,
0.2488674372,
-0.0784563571,
-0.2109325677,
-0.823102057,
0.6265960932,
0.4902868867,
-0.5807781816,
0.5972194672,
0.7109887004,
-0.3415030539,
0.1398973018,
-0.4430910349,
-0.1084445715,
-0.3248617649,
0.3772145808,
-0.1805665493,
-0.9397824407,
0.0946809426,
0.19928886,
-0.4178161025,
0.5883140564,
0.5243648887,
0.0716355443,
0.8892077208,
0.7078947425,
-0.186958462,
0.6652767658,
0.0923907906,
0.2908530235,
-0.5661064982,
0.1494435072,
-0.4816175103,
-0.3042978048,
-0.1325065196,
-0.5859273672,
0.4153240919,
0.4111218154,
-0.1196159795,
0.4363338947,
-0.3969196081,
0.5048961639,
0.509329319,
-0.0570053346,
0.6136940122,
0.0293071419,
0.2985768914,
0.2978049517,
-0.5497348905,
-0.531011641,
0.5750818849,
0.3368963003,
0.7822831869,
-0.1292183995,
0.4301322103,
0.4426763952,
0.3008772135,
-0.6534872651,
0.4645531476,
0.0404544212,
-0.9091948271,
-0.0276712663,
-0.1305792481,
-0.9099484086,
0.2777448297,
-0.3535275459,
-0.9638702273,
0.4105886221,
0.0147400657,
-0.773760736,
0.3205814064,
-0.6347083449,
0.8762154579,
-0.0910811126,
-0.1249687746,
-0.5710082054,
-0.5702363253,
0.2295214981,
-0.1110580564,
0.5142037272,
-0.4154509902,
0.023839891,
0.572994113,
0.1022241116,
0.9113445878,
0.2092931867,
0.0767040402,
0.2979958951,
-0.3859535456,
0.1888247877,
0.3290014863,
-0.2313372344,
0.1866107583,
0.0808130354,
-0.1856827438,
-0.1037835181,
0.2028047591,
-0.5040207505,
-0.9210268259,
-0.6175963283,
-0.5579978824,
0.1863959432,
0.1615525633,
0.3448538482,
0.7568522096,
-0.317742914,
0.3399446011,
0.5285131931,
-0.2656370699,
0.7667489648,
0.5834316611,
-0.4075607955,
-0.2164998353,
0.3884039819,
0.2117642164,
-0.0321700387,
0.7874539495,
0.2256344259,
-0.0239140391,
-0.5733628869,
-0.7111613154,
-0.1673830152,
-0.2077844441,
-0.142369926,
-0.5425649285,
-0.1606154144,
-0.2822872102,
-0.3274647892,
-0.1466580182,
-0.2577166855,
-0.4483892322,
-0.0716007203,
0.0979001448,
0.5543642044,
-0.0089287497,
0.3213833272,
-0.818667531,
0.7491592765,
0.228530854,
0.2520182133,
-0.3047913611,
-0.3017045856,
-0.5112596154,
0.2151038796,
-0.4729369581,
-1.0113112926,
0.2688453496,
-0.180379048,
0.4843598604,
0.3730288446,
0.3026099801,
0.3262844682,
-0.5250588059,
0.9260484576,
0.0453947745,
-0.9852544665,
0.3546602726,
-0.7026531696,
0.2441452891,
0.1791971773,
0.3541777134,
-0.5266593695,
-0.1654342413,
-0.4697652757,
-0.5746769309,
0.4323737621,
-0.188818112,
0.1432180852,
-0.3771343231,
0.3562912345,
-0.0147686722,
0.2979950905,
-0.5386225581,
0.3411776423,
0.0792938694,
-0.0024962868,
-0.1463726163,
-0.3148381412,
-0.1373164803,
-0.2511264682,
0.387175262,
-0.1088240966,
0.2528020144,
0.4213095903,
-0.3119662106,
-0.1539754868,
0.4332195818,
0.7312015295,
0.9577642083,
0.1912956089,
0.0951386169,
-0.2157870382,
-0.2761272192,
0.2979056537,
0.0900364071,
-0.3054853976,
0.032977853,
0.3773467839,
1.1346569061,
0.2216964513,
-0.4238410592,
0.7660962939,
0.1248515099,
-0.1180026457,
-0.1588969231,
0.1432687193,
0.0389630571,
0.8197597265,
0.4761203825,
0.2622399926,
0.1575293094,
-0.79883039,
0.5050358772,
0.4080517292,
-0.2846338451,
-0.5981436968,
1.1075235605,
0.2036246657,
-0.4396463335,
0.2033207864,
-0.239392519,
-0.2247909755,
0.6741194129,
0.492974788,
0.8960405588,
-0.1397313625,
0.4981887341,
0.2513205111,
0.0837722048,
-0.6417385936,
-0.2315370888,
0.0401933305,
-0.6768481135,
-0.7968635559,
-0.6203292012,
-0.1607832462,
-0.0650442243,
-0.864030242,
0.20153822,
-0.0095847016,
-0.3451529145,
0.4567990005,
-0.0925534144,
-0.3481461704,
0.17861031,
0.8679103255,
1.3416385651,
-1.1013947725,
0.9147843122,
0.6977379918,
-0.0951256901,
-0.2861961126,
0.4467055798,
0.5132104754,
-0.5763928294,
0.3485577106,
0.4782164395,
0.3680241108,
-0.1033076867,
-0.4230441749,
-0.767036736,
0.681261003,
0.5236440301,
-0.5042731762,
-0.4266659915,
-0.1032816321,
0.3766202927,
-0.4555850625,
-0.0925467014,
0.3064094186,
0.5323611498,
-0.0426683798,
-1.0369862318,
-0.2080403268,
-0.0833351389,
0.0201728735,
0.2609901726,
-0.6422488689,
0.6794464588,
-0.1430769116,
-0.1339673251,
0.0249190964,
0.598598361,
-0.2457706034,
0.6973952651,
0.2568125427,
0.6592636704,
0.5603889823,
-0.0010087967,
1.1989859343,
-0.2803308666,
0.4243382215,
0.9362124801,
0.2703948319,
0.8695625067,
0.3143649697,
-0.0299226698,
0.2918623984,
0.5976375341,
-0.0535491407,
0.3773300052,
0.0043130992,
-0.2033917159,
-0.3265319765,
0.1298794001,
-0.3040035069,
0.7547025681,
0.2847967148,
-0.4316368699,
-0.7162400484,
0.5458362699,
0.2789037228,
0.0006551133,
-0.7044405341,
0.7040050626,
0.1662406474,
-0.7063195705,
0.2768004537,
0.3514635861,
0.4042920768,
-0.3112863004,
0.240290612,
0.1363456994,
0.0296369903,
0.0068310518,
-0.7435289621,
0.8680076599,
-0.0123085119,
-0.6361474991,
-0.4450570643,
0.639011085,
-0.4082669914,
-0.3464457095,
-0.0798942298,
0.3804309368,
-0.0641905889,
-0.4766521454,
-0.430608958,
0.2960163355,
-0.0852280259,
-0.6736313701,
0.5109555721,
0.2411327213,
-0.497127831,
0.1668730825,
0.3063644469,
-0.1591317803,
-0.0796427578,
-0.4826798141,
0.5336766243,
-0.7902765274,
-0.7622175217,
-1.0759266615,
0.2591021061,
-0.018153755,
-0.2430663556,
0.7694506645,
0.6567589045,
0.4800037444,
0.0036953574,
0.5281508565,
-0.0350181647,
0.3254086077,
-0.6123357415,
0.8129991293,
-0.2906715572,
-0.1828356385,
-0.0163190793,
-0.5707514286,
-0.5853493214,
0.4863247871,
-0.6862312555,
-0.4993360639,
0.4142368138,
0.6852838397,
0.0686607063,
0.399518311,
0.1888282001,
0.3139388561,
0.2071370929,
0.2663165033,
0.4068426192,
-0.1667030007,
0.127843827,
0.2884247005,
-0.1943944395,
-0.3622661531,
-1.0160472393,
-0.7748574018,
-0.6277089715,
-0.3517303467,
-0.2199268788,
0.3755620718,
0.9704045057,
0.844248414,
-0.6166349053,
0.2009892762,
-0.0610511079,
0.265525341,
-0.3208493888,
-0.1410065442,
0.4100922048,
-0.3274468184,
-0.6627539992,
0.3802640736,
0.5090916157,
-0.1201923788,
-0.059366338,
0.4147806466,
-0.2901195288,
0.189483881,
0.6865042448,
0.4758241475,
-0.6586090922,
-0.5527736545,
-0.4329084158,
-0.094599925,
0.3533341587,
0.7093356848,
-1.0349456072,
0.5286533237,
0.7892276049,
0.7965008616,
0.6917009354,
0.2822470367,
0.7378819585,
-0.4574530125,
0.475857079,
-0.1875952631,
0.1368145645,
0.2696519196,
-0.1748499423,
0.3071217239,
0.4826079309,
-0.3902089298,
-0.7372890115,
0.2336439639,
-0.758652389,
-0.3611699939,
1.1288386583,
0.2006565481,
-0.5808482766,
-0.3160688579,
-0.232586652,
0.1315700561,
-0.152564913,
0.6048203111,
0.8296111822,
-0.1046337336,
-0.4484218657,
-1.0591267347,
0.4745672047,
-0.0401148386,
-0.6682053208,
-0.3085115254,
0.3716317713,
0.2624102533,
0.112357527,
0.7310765982,
-0.029069474,
0.2383578271,
-0.0481447317,
-0.1919807643,
0.003693366,
-0.3247647583,
-0.4505095482,
0.4772520959,
-0.4774640799,
-0.2512597144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14454v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14454v3 | PMC-LLaMA: Towards Building Open-source Language Models for Medicine | 2023-04-27T18:29:05 | 2023-08-25T14:08:38 | Chaoyi Wu, Weixiong Lin, Xiaoman Zhang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable capabilities
in natural language understanding. While demonstrating proficiency in everyday
conversations and question-answering situations, these models frequently
struggle in domains that require precision, such as medical applications, due
to their lack of domain-specific knowledge. In this paper, we describe the
procedure for building a powerful, open-source language model specifically
designed for medicine applications, termed as PMC-LLaMA. Our contributions are
threefold: (i) we systematically investigate the process of adapting a
general-purpose foundation language model towards medical domain, this involves
data-centric knowledge injection through the integration of 4.8M biomedical
academic papers and 30K medical textbooks, as well as comprehensive fine-tuning
for alignment with domain-specific instructions; (ii) we contribute a
large-scale, comprehensive dataset for instruction tuning. This dataset
encompasses medical question-answering (QA), rationale for reasoning, and
conversational dialogues, comprising a total of 202M tokens; (iii) we conduct
thorough ablation studies to demonstrate the effectiveness of each proposed
component. While evaluating on various public medical question-answering
benchmarks, our lightweight PMCLLaMA, which consists of only 13 billion
parameters, exhibits superior performance, even surpassing ChatGPT. All models,
codes, datasets can be found in https://github.com/chaoyi-wu/PMC-LLaMA. | [
-0.0476816259,
-0.8525158763,
0.8515184522,
0.0019313926,
-0.375126332,
-0.0424553044,
-0.2053412497,
-0.2915588915,
0.0391964763,
0.6503157616,
-0.2714858651,
-0.8531207442,
-0.5798848271,
0.1035672873,
-0.196543768,
0.9967374802,
-0.1857979894,
0.282907337,
-0.381244421,
-0.1355527192,
-0.359641403,
-0.5749059319,
-0.2002801448,
-0.3404357433,
0.4079792798,
0.4675093889,
0.6005259752,
0.8820773363,
0.4957803786,
0.2333225459,
-0.0148443924,
0.2420556843,
-0.2726410329,
-0.082047753,
-0.3058876991,
-0.5214204192,
-0.6549250484,
-0.0138479033,
0.5095652938,
0.8048573136,
-0.4771991372,
0.0200377442,
-0.2397218198,
0.6303565502,
-0.4658977389,
0.1624681503,
-0.5661467314,
-0.1883931607,
-0.2567570806,
-0.1015108004,
-0.2433773875,
-0.3163000345,
0.0827219784,
-0.4317826927,
-0.1627544016,
-0.0469291657,
0.6927176118,
0.3707839251,
-0.3441679478,
-0.5159630775,
-0.5579074025,
0.6472930312,
-1.0022032261,
0.2403038591,
0.5667842031,
0.236366421,
-0.1575260758,
-0.6497260332,
-0.4390476942,
-0.3282619715,
0.1358350515,
-0.0396529064,
-0.2024804205,
0.2614539564,
-0.1234046668,
0.5454098582,
-0.5293779969,
0.1671368033,
-0.4487815797,
0.1807092875,
0.3336676061,
0.3888673484,
0.3924002647,
0.0623484068,
-0.0477018766,
0.4438244402,
-0.8847107291,
-0.3089897335,
0.0375442803,
0.0936373398,
-0.3781638145,
1.0341966152,
-0.3113369048,
0.8121192455,
-0.1412161887,
-0.4246672094,
-0.0209433585,
-0.5135956407,
-0.3508842587,
-0.0811847299,
0.6498163342,
0.1844559163,
0.1051181704,
-0.1723021418,
0.0847827196,
0.1320618391,
0.5020036101,
-0.9393051863,
-0.317455411,
0.505556047,
-0.4662705064,
-0.3741228282,
-0.2991776466,
-0.4586752355,
-0.3957805336,
-0.4040509164,
0.2106732577,
-0.4244066179,
-0.0269370805,
0.5166261196,
0.5355949402,
0.1858322471,
0.317127049,
-0.8026275039,
0.3600286543,
0.7470965385,
0.8228022456,
-0.1847993731,
-0.0198257081,
-0.2042278796,
0.1111698598,
-0.3200729191,
0.874986589,
-0.6704876423,
-0.4302619994,
-0.1582839191,
-0.1664121002,
-0.1164140552,
-0.7437149286,
0.4899502397,
-0.3282850385,
0.2251608819,
0.0632058159,
-0.5504863858,
-0.0765984282,
0.1539935917,
-0.3493224084,
0.5033844113,
0.164499715,
-0.6971827745,
-0.286690414,
-0.8042056561,
-0.4326682985,
0.0172180906,
-0.1734176427,
-0.3253050745,
0.1736186445,
0.4527054131,
0.4073501229,
-0.8981977105,
0.5613090992,
-0.0920646712,
-0.2712705433,
0.5956714153,
-0.2049320787,
0.7785508037,
0.2866673768,
-0.0724287406,
0.0995200798,
-0.818795681,
-0.1927491724,
0.0835911557,
-0.398673594,
-0.2050179839,
0.0094346832,
-0.3304575682,
0.0040666247,
0.2918090224,
-0.4474192858,
0.3645131588,
-0.6179151535,
0.6005458236,
0.6212381124,
0.1210482195,
0.3401710093,
-0.4699991345,
0.5725841522,
0.0628900379,
0.3471787274,
-0.2491491586,
-0.7679557204,
-0.5365158319,
-0.4134123623,
0.2555069625,
0.6437410712,
-0.6009250283,
0.2250339836,
-0.0336619653,
-0.5891241431,
-0.8481758237,
0.2430418432,
0.3635954261,
0.8487007618,
0.3674068451,
-0.2590121329,
-0.4953933358,
-0.8710007071,
0.1341966093,
-0.4882301986,
-0.1393039525,
0.5447668433,
0.4383789003,
-0.5957205296,
0.7216885686,
-0.7405133843,
-0.1354355514,
0.0343321413,
-0.2372985631,
0.3697903752,
0.3766445816,
0.2446859479,
-0.4880637228,
-0.1647568494,
0.1932362467,
-0.7589305043,
-0.6273711324,
0.0866793692,
-0.2963056266,
-0.0343405418,
0.1800518781,
-0.5134200454,
0.0305797514,
0.9217918515,
-0.2245071381,
0.7642461658,
-0.0670256466,
0.2064121515,
-1.3281461,
0.4859965444,
-0.1676412672,
0.1139014065,
-0.7007707357,
0.1714938134,
0.0012740564,
-0.1530689895,
-0.5362032056,
0.5596133471,
-0.112218231,
0.2669492364,
-0.462415874,
-0.0132410098,
-0.1330231577,
0.3707635403,
-0.0739344656,
0.8680781126,
0.4852821231,
-0.5348780751,
0.2930064797,
0.4059689343,
-0.2464308739,
0.6925047636,
-0.7975776792,
0.1956885308,
0.1943544,
-0.0376106761,
-0.4952593148,
-0.2896618843,
0.5633082986,
-0.3410967886,
0.009162752,
-0.1156717688,
-0.461355269,
-0.1286596358,
0.081039004,
0.3878211081,
0.463096112,
-0.3165152967,
0.4353486598,
0.6755388975,
-0.4092214704,
-0.4898630381,
-0.46287328,
0.1648538411,
0.157463342,
-0.5184772611,
0.4378068447,
-0.4226555228,
-0.3847531676,
0.0730641708,
-0.0937857479,
-0.270624429,
0.1199502796,
0.4585743248,
0.427200377,
-0.4508843422,
0.2211384177,
0.304625541,
-0.2081048191,
-0.0808007345,
-0.3812578917,
0.4218880832,
-0.1178493798,
-0.658480525,
-0.5070003867,
0.3290093541,
0.6877313256,
-0.3003112972,
0.7693018317,
-0.0367447436,
-0.339050889,
0.0603030436,
-0.4799260497,
-0.0828629285,
-0.4422427118,
0.2668286264,
-0.0751714632,
-1.0424958467,
0.2216722816,
-0.2784912586,
0.0967474654,
0.050735943,
1.0548011065,
-0.0043680677,
0.749568224,
0.6582902074,
-0.0211748127,
0.1394799948,
0.1455424577,
0.0432883836,
-0.6964385509,
-0.1934190989,
-0.5572582483,
0.0345608257,
-0.1730053425,
-0.8716128469,
0.461571753,
0.0727491528,
-0.1229473725,
0.1527456343,
-0.3956721127,
0.4157956839,
0.2715462446,
0.2752975523,
0.5102681518,
-0.2742083967,
-0.2726607323,
0.2014526129,
-0.5658839941,
-0.684869945,
1.3314350843,
0.3874390125,
0.8557026386,
-0.1503877491,
0.3910253346,
-0.0717374459,
0.5127120018,
-0.6989414096,
0.4935333431,
-0.2894877493,
-0.4028860033,
0.1731476337,
-0.3375245035,
-0.6935935616,
0.0499618948,
-0.1407695115,
-0.3861646354,
-0.2012060285,
0.0711835623,
-0.2838062048,
0.2853302062,
-0.4844205379,
0.7486357689,
-0.3287668526,
-0.1006142721,
-0.2221382856,
-0.6194742322,
0.4611436129,
-0.3040030897,
0.1177461594,
-0.2992340624,
-0.3060355783,
0.4029237926,
-0.3164168596,
1.0117707253,
0.082204096,
-0.4500729442,
0.2450793684,
-0.0992092267,
0.1834209561,
0.1290089041,
-0.1799791455,
0.4175144434,
-0.0580951236,
-0.4823284447,
-0.3551790416,
0.5906866789,
-0.7047945261,
-0.5613280535,
-0.0893932059,
-0.6924631,
-0.2836672962,
0.0165635906,
-0.1914326698,
0.2884283066,
-0.3546547592,
0.025972046,
0.6165545583,
-0.5490607023,
-0.2805404067,
0.883703351,
-0.1957723796,
-0.5429826975,
0.6935472488,
-0.1796677262,
0.1708152741,
0.5803053379,
0.2670187354,
0.0532187186,
-0.9783583879,
-0.5397049785,
0.7003309131,
-0.6146643162,
-0.2998852134,
-0.6618632674,
-0.2033183575,
-0.3696244657,
-0.1686566621,
-0.3256169856,
-0.26555112,
-0.5101786256,
0.0592207238,
0.3272113502,
0.8018872738,
0.1866387874,
0.432348758,
-0.8800797462,
0.3928462565,
0.2065259516,
0.4752277732,
-0.2722070515,
-0.3329297304,
-0.4538821578,
0.0586820878,
-0.265291363,
-1.0473906994,
0.3108759522,
0.1421363801,
0.5629578829,
0.3957761526,
-0.0873712525,
0.5697244406,
-0.6265565157,
0.6884359717,
0.0140456939,
-0.9185253978,
0.7112365365,
-0.2614163458,
0.3334270716,
0.3800793886,
0.2855036259,
-0.623783648,
-0.5651425123,
-0.2063009739,
-0.5879817009,
0.4455074966,
0.0652875155,
-0.0078841085,
-0.0156467129,
0.5608164668,
0.2760347128,
0.2373591065,
-0.2210288942,
-0.1442468315,
0.1063313633,
-0.5331677794,
-0.0022534954,
-0.166476503,
-0.4181353748,
-0.1612686366,
0.662830472,
-0.3918220997,
0.2356720418,
0.0549152195,
-0.1674219966,
-0.0599930473,
0.3878137767,
0.7430032492,
0.6770118475,
0.0119049642,
0.0688453987,
0.1136336625,
-0.7008689642,
0.1445831805,
0.1568058282,
-0.0604716316,
-0.3334920704,
0.1713035554,
0.4474848807,
0.2718462944,
-1.2351615429,
0.3452332616,
-0.0242041145,
0.0184471048,
0.1392881274,
0.0453423224,
0.4113596678,
0.278981328,
0.060302414,
-0.1493073255,
-0.0793469697,
-0.2062222064,
0.2612476349,
0.243623361,
-0.1162123308,
-0.4645965099,
0.7340211272,
0.2290647924,
-0.0629321188,
0.5834003091,
0.3108201623,
-0.2726684511,
0.4494270384,
0.7248251438,
0.51231426,
-0.3692699969,
0.2592359483,
0.2602835596,
0.2218188494,
0.0537524968,
0.3182318211,
-0.0292330012,
-0.4462760389,
-0.6403495669,
-0.7304913998,
-0.78126055,
-0.1215018481,
-0.3085034788,
0.233902514,
-0.4773652554,
0.0444412716,
-0.0194788221,
-0.0179570671,
-0.3632696569,
-0.0639783144,
0.1171677485,
0.8193367124,
-0.7162103057,
1.2122416496,
0.7169275284,
-0.378118366,
-0.4980840087,
-0.1986922175,
0.0657826886,
-1.0709511042,
0.3613368273,
-0.0472474508,
0.0668646917,
-0.1464412361,
-0.7113678455,
-0.6475313306,
1.1390135288,
0.6512194276,
-0.6013346314,
-0.1626117826,
0.3016782999,
0.6152880788,
-0.514259994,
-0.0761997253,
0.5206671357,
0.1506873369,
-0.0234754086,
-1.1042691469,
0.0996106043,
-0.3018880188,
-0.193381831,
0.0361483507,
-0.3586531878,
0.8822509646,
-0.4494471252,
-0.1651689559,
0.4922322929,
0.3829245567,
0.4409161508,
0.3173689842,
-0.0230414681,
0.6879881024,
0.8589121699,
0.0773233399,
0.9508017302,
-0.4941098094,
0.0057354416,
0.8160194755,
-0.4529535472,
0.7911008,
0.4706683755,
-0.2737478018,
0.5191609859,
0.3435170054,
0.0770249069,
0.3894223571,
0.2526002228,
-0.4466792643,
-0.0506926216,
-0.2205949128,
-0.3687734306,
0.3299117982,
0.5789811015,
-0.5658841729,
-0.0082702544,
0.0575034395,
0.1604722589,
0.0938652083,
-0.1954758614,
0.8760818243,
0.2763271034,
-0.4800281823,
0.5738250613,
0.1859160066,
0.4677332342,
-0.7006406188,
-0.1738601774,
-0.1918416023,
0.067179136,
-0.0681001544,
-0.5782567263,
0.3706949353,
0.2265535444,
-0.1611669809,
0.0554396622,
0.6308433414,
-0.400583595,
-0.308996588,
-0.0453740694,
0.6719784737,
0.317062676,
0.0805436075,
-0.7486996651,
0.1592067629,
-0.1804932505,
0.111871995,
0.3929791152,
0.2187923938,
0.198437497,
0.7303117514,
0.823461473,
0.3141251802,
-0.1373735964,
-0.1446914673,
1.0289574862,
-0.5471693277,
-0.2343899161,
-0.8011516333,
0.2960841656,
0.3808178902,
-0.2269429564,
0.3180499971,
0.4502621889,
0.5483705401,
-0.0278725307,
0.6137453914,
0.0403702669,
0.4019645154,
-0.5426723361,
0.8123713136,
-0.4477589428,
0.3610184491,
0.004211165,
-0.4372457862,
-0.6001650095,
0.4908006787,
-0.1932291538,
-0.2623974383,
0.6209908128,
0.9859364629,
0.1815874428,
0.1065458134,
0.3771475255,
0.369535923,
0.3556349277,
0.7637345195,
0.6620844007,
-0.1620054543,
0.4703121185,
-0.3132799864,
-0.3074262738,
-0.2645658851,
-0.8429672122,
-0.7736541033,
-0.4979967177,
-0.3221152723,
-0.2669157386,
0.294765383,
1.0437082052,
0.6724039912,
-0.8268245459,
-0.229990989,
0.0221643597,
0.1451277584,
-0.3244023919,
-0.0642125607,
0.3347970545,
-0.0965944827,
-0.6790733337,
0.5864605308,
0.450902313,
0.0457396619,
-0.2697749436,
-0.1782709509,
-0.1207549572,
0.2294222414,
0.5281717777,
0.3236361146,
-0.7307039499,
0.0638536885,
0.2003656924,
-0.3078704774,
0.315882057,
1.0418881178,
-0.6598972082,
0.4500607848,
0.1186530441,
0.8629555106,
0.011562082,
0.0166199747,
0.6980822086,
-0.4481404722,
-0.2137712687,
0.4528387785,
0.2757211924,
0.3676032424,
-0.1453263015,
0.5522204041,
0.183550328,
-0.7552603483,
-0.802090764,
0.1380285621,
-1.0618005991,
-0.5124902725,
1.0711932182,
-0.0759777203,
-0.324313283,
-0.2579628229,
-0.5972827077,
0.3668566346,
-0.1881003529,
0.8910847306,
0.4622416198,
-0.2177872658,
-0.0873854682,
-0.6606524587,
0.0575460866,
0.2900196016,
-1.1777960062,
0.1702901125,
0.4778372347,
0.3755933642,
-0.0795005038,
0.9819438457,
-0.5150191188,
0.3387801647,
-0.1322730482,
0.0844226331,
-0.1978256851,
-0.2010183483,
-0.4309360981,
0.2441081256,
0.2308259755,
-0.0565859862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14447v1 | Analyzing Vietnamese Legal Questions Using Deep Neural Networks with Biaffine Classifiers | 2023-04-27T18:19:24 | 2023-04-27T18:19:24 | Nguyen Anh Tu, Hoang Thi Thu Uyen, Tu Minh Phuong, Ngo Xuan Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose using deep neural networks to extract important
information from Vietnamese legal questions, a fundamental task towards
building a question answering system in the legal domain. Given a legal
question in natural language, the goal is to extract all the segments that
contain the needed information to answer the question. We introduce a deep
model that solves the task in three stages. First, our model leverages recent
advanced autoencoding language models to produce contextual word embeddings,
which are then combined with character-level and POS-tag information to form
word representations. Next, bidirectional long short-term memory networks are
employed to capture the relations among words and generate sentence-level
representations. At the third stage, borrowing ideas from graph-based
dependency parsing methods which provide a global view on the input sentence,
we use biaffine classifiers to estimate the probability of each pair of
start-end words to be an important segment. Experimental results on a public
Vietnamese legal dataset show that our model outperforms the previous work by a
large margin, achieving 94.79% in the F1 score. The results also prove the
effectiveness of using contextual features extracted from pre-trained language
models combined with other types of features such as character-level and
POS-tag features when training on a limited dataset. | [
-0.3349865079,
-1.0757313967,
0.7017587423,
-0.050000038,
-0.5876920819,
-0.2737466395,
-0.1756477505,
-0.385874331,
-0.2714205384,
0.8684125543,
0.0787880644,
-0.4148605764,
-0.5413407087,
-0.0019541353,
-0.2967177629,
0.9063380361,
-0.0727477297,
0.1262527406,
-0.0226827953,
-0.2457059473,
-0.6889843941,
-0.5756021142,
-0.5641335845,
-0.1194805726,
0.6812239885,
0.5203483105,
0.5679796338,
0.7451357841,
0.4721717536,
0.3227525055,
-0.0804193243,
-0.1139435172,
-0.3067583442,
0.0452815145,
-0.2216842473,
-0.5150610209,
-0.1021982431,
0.0932220593,
0.3758103251,
0.6330237985,
0.0894317478,
0.1394364685,
-0.334030509,
0.4637088478,
-0.4234680831,
0.1447222531,
-0.5351117253,
-0.0325303227,
0.061203789,
-0.115716368,
0.0033773596,
-0.336448282,
0.4679180086,
-0.116024591,
0.1821369678,
-0.3325518072,
1.1737017632,
0.1695608944,
-0.8336043358,
-0.3555745482,
-0.6477031708,
0.1946670115,
-0.7958735824,
0.2069211155,
0.4061890841,
0.5500577092,
0.0744993091,
-0.898848176,
-0.6629632115,
-0.4236630499,
-0.1176712736,
0.1265828013,
-0.0946691483,
0.2966865003,
0.0476182811,
0.2375811338,
-0.7291151285,
0.1305638552,
-0.7475748062,
-0.150269106,
0.9788540602,
-0.0725599304,
0.2523903549,
-0.5283059478,
-0.4029826522,
0.0894501284,
-0.5200217366,
0.4113186896,
0.4927789271,
0.3490403891,
0.0331209078,
0.6894744039,
-0.0230634399,
0.5369694829,
-0.1424428672,
0.2500907183,
0.1095406115,
-0.3289749622,
-0.4343084097,
0.0208152011,
0.7940981984,
0.2840628028,
0.5653373599,
-0.0723734573,
-0.2863985896,
-0.3556945622,
0.1744887382,
-0.7238875031,
-0.1379048377,
0.4811322093,
-0.6443063617,
-0.1239759177,
0.5253808498,
-0.7769669294,
-0.2351828068,
-0.7074970603,
0.2851060927,
-0.3354388475,
-0.2636178732,
0.3505883813,
-0.2052658796,
0.6743321419,
0.1817948669,
-0.2821559608,
-0.1551707536,
0.7164876461,
0.42719841,
0.222142756,
-0.1320820898,
-0.8424434066,
0.1475043148,
-0.2099772543,
0.646116972,
-0.5790849924,
-0.2295106053,
0.4115051329,
0.3574911356,
0.0400714651,
-0.6956833601,
0.4507603049,
-0.8075454235,
0.1342821717,
-0.117267713,
-0.6792792082,
-0.3963234425,
0.4559365511,
-0.7282146215,
0.7695605755,
0.171479702,
-0.4976923466,
0.2829972208,
-0.5637680888,
-0.6609017253,
0.3185131252,
-0.291628629,
-0.3590266407,
0.1457692534,
0.1028951854,
0.6497452855,
-0.31551525,
0.5501790643,
-0.1821683496,
-0.1603119075,
0.2586997151,
-0.374179095,
1.1259696484,
0.2655109167,
-0.3289903104,
0.0469159111,
-0.6584377885,
-0.2343481034,
0.068230167,
-0.6669112444,
-0.3783448637,
-0.4194996655,
0.077947408,
0.4755166471,
0.0960657075,
-0.6269773841,
-0.0549604222,
-0.3236349225,
0.3995647132,
0.4813813567,
0.4502518773,
0.310456425,
0.0922774598,
0.6857852936,
0.2099967301,
-0.0181090366,
-0.2444773763,
-0.5545517802,
-0.8641993403,
-0.035530962,
0.6216499805,
0.8482741117,
-0.5482572317,
0.4477670789,
-0.1516458839,
-0.2659839392,
-0.7504429221,
0.2266122848,
0.3527304232,
0.5735057592,
0.3464203477,
0.108255662,
-0.5214821696,
-1.1628849506,
-0.4303335547,
-0.3862482905,
-0.0385912769,
0.3721789718,
0.7659579515,
-0.2584483325,
0.8837956786,
-0.4440720081,
-0.1591396332,
-0.1024343222,
0.3941708803,
0.1332094967,
0.2722199261,
0.6200093627,
-1.2012001276,
-0.4109643102,
0.3268414438,
-0.7188509107,
-0.1027957126,
-0.0943159461,
-0.0830487907,
-0.1990269721,
0.6876447201,
-0.5506186485,
0.6337433457,
-0.3476970792,
-0.6765642166,
0.2970395088,
-0.3112454712,
-0.1686656326,
-1.0564461946,
0.0955824926,
-0.0520643033,
-0.3212126791,
-0.7700685263,
0.1320723593,
-0.0272654593,
-0.2363613546,
-0.6490911245,
0.3500442803,
-0.3448602855,
0.1695308685,
-0.4859283268,
-0.0063474723,
0.2725219131,
0.3607552648,
0.0291117765,
0.3933149576,
0.2588598132,
-0.5533041358,
0.6826905608,
0.0633868054,
-0.1711512357,
0.52301687,
-0.7697789669,
0.2461505383,
-0.5968958735,
-0.255613625,
-0.9464054704,
-0.0834336951,
0.2569803596,
-0.2795724869,
0.2349231988,
-0.5454277396,
-0.4392986894,
-0.4479993284,
0.1460338682,
0.2879413068,
0.2352781445,
-0.1552657336,
0.5100606084,
0.6657261848,
-0.3112920523,
-0.4386545122,
-0.6980081201,
0.1365798712,
-0.3240293264,
-0.5224407315,
0.0199899077,
0.4038232565,
-0.38035658,
0.280813396,
0.4091032743,
-0.4347296655,
0.1303227544,
0.0758299753,
0.0822299048,
-0.5411113501,
0.2600880265,
0.1651753038,
-0.0157244075,
0.6348564625,
-0.527592063,
0.4788922966,
-0.3142535985,
0.0587000176,
-0.4428209066,
0.8193204403,
0.5228908658,
-0.729352057,
0.2284680903,
0.4794594347,
-0.5230097771,
0.1601044685,
-0.5838522315,
0.2223156691,
-0.418387413,
0.5131036043,
-0.3855153918,
-0.930565834,
0.4280382097,
-0.0120282155,
0.0338058919,
0.4800236821,
0.8575313687,
-0.3019015789,
0.7134512663,
0.6195311546,
-0.0785434097,
0.2531660795,
-0.4310308695,
0.1554504782,
-0.2750317454,
-0.4389416277,
-0.5778023005,
-0.2900076509,
-0.6471303701,
-0.5908645391,
0.0354903638,
0.1364387274,
-0.2457335442,
0.5337349176,
-0.1100884899,
0.4041512609,
0.666492641,
-0.1082716361,
-0.0583757199,
-0.0409317352,
-0.323307693,
0.4362366498,
-0.387407124,
-0.6861476302,
0.8967142701,
0.4329960048,
0.2554666996,
-0.0880077481,
0.7090973258,
0.1447943151,
0.0213856287,
-0.8036395907,
0.4043135047,
-0.2081473172,
-0.6861774325,
-0.4770733118,
-0.4592479169,
-1.1646145582,
0.265378952,
0.0113334376,
-0.325306803,
0.6424418092,
-0.4860702753,
-0.7377257943,
-0.0004490959,
-0.5752503872,
1.0013742447,
-0.5667742491,
-0.2721182406,
0.1000078693,
-0.9782470465,
0.1764585525,
0.1294790059,
-0.0088037942,
-0.2821018994,
0.1339521706,
0.8465391994,
-0.4600974023,
0.5085180402,
-0.4466540515,
-0.1556239575,
0.8123387098,
-0.3339470029,
0.0280115753,
0.5893141031,
-0.0389323495,
-0.0702551976,
0.3724863529,
-0.3751694858,
-0.6921572685,
0.2309536785,
-0.6839191914,
-0.6917747855,
-0.3266087174,
-0.4956401289,
0.0564822964,
0.4131891429,
0.1464978456,
0.0827164352,
-0.2020420879,
0.2190629095,
0.4738739729,
-0.0291090701,
0.517380774,
0.491691947,
-0.2369310856,
-0.5915677547,
0.8221340775,
0.3764206171,
-0.3877449334,
0.4095111191,
0.3563779891,
-0.4911359847,
-0.4797074199,
-0.5053514242,
0.4418441653,
-0.7283461094,
-0.3235015571,
-0.638112545,
-0.5416762233,
-0.467330128,
0.2788517177,
-0.0302458815,
-0.2711814344,
-0.4162321687,
-0.4111468494,
0.1298429072,
0.6587843895,
0.1720524728,
0.217041105,
-0.8878058791,
0.513649106,
0.6548434496,
0.1347366273,
-0.3441537917,
-0.5709413886,
-0.117341578,
0.0850036517,
-0.0535493419,
-1.0147615671,
0.159914881,
-0.0408474393,
0.5025615692,
0.7728652954,
0.0248002987,
0.6779237986,
-0.4860022068,
0.4936140776,
-0.1212305725,
-0.6305908561,
0.7721428275,
-0.2613017559,
-0.016162321,
0.9506812692,
0.3858673573,
-0.4015491903,
-0.2033926398,
-0.4540152252,
-0.6790540814,
0.4305793047,
0.2529218793,
0.4813799262,
0.0376540162,
0.9059001803,
0.0103792194,
0.3128882349,
-0.5351614952,
0.0779890195,
-0.2449625283,
-0.1737749428,
0.1080804914,
-0.4856226444,
-0.0415216722,
-0.5752882957,
0.1637143642,
0.0087033967,
0.104663901,
0.2777415812,
-0.1597263962,
0.2694746852,
0.2606229186,
0.5574375987,
0.615839541,
-0.1472869813,
0.3167869449,
-0.0395669304,
-0.409596771,
0.4445783198,
0.5733203888,
-0.2412465066,
0.2536715865,
0.3908052146,
0.7825502157,
-0.2665542364,
-0.7467592955,
0.7823247313,
-0.203002587,
-0.3442049325,
-0.5322807431,
-0.1981392354,
0.005696726,
0.490881741,
0.2842962742,
-0.4864431918,
0.2487420738,
-0.7693291306,
0.5695384145,
0.2642861307,
-0.7470383048,
-0.2451390624,
0.5279478431,
0.1289447993,
-0.4933170676,
0.6740720868,
-0.0048455102,
-0.7430682778,
0.8879693151,
0.250987947,
0.9289407134,
-0.2151479423,
0.3941417933,
0.1604883075,
0.3708002567,
0.2938250005,
0.7284918427,
0.0300107077,
-0.3709962368,
-0.1860134453,
-0.5435525179,
0.1160867438,
0.3978814781,
-0.6354244947,
0.3177808225,
-0.474668771,
-0.1112037823,
-0.1797251999,
0.1787425727,
-0.8604049087,
0.4957400858,
0.2665266097,
0.9247944951,
-0.6909726262,
0.8879545331,
0.7500417829,
-0.7675076127,
-0.756822288,
-0.0837570354,
-0.3596913815,
-0.4596106112,
0.7050840855,
0.5037719011,
0.3085262775,
-0.2941215634,
-0.5495288372,
-0.3942776322,
0.9194327593,
0.4961916804,
-0.3877354264,
-0.3460817337,
0.9321250916,
0.6540869474,
-0.5575165153,
0.0252078623,
0.8644930124,
0.5121254325,
0.0105497148,
-0.3759251237,
0.0267453417,
-0.5150204897,
0.0937665179,
-0.0619534217,
-0.3886964917,
0.8964028955,
0.0490732752,
-0.1131354421,
-0.1741476208,
0.9309698939,
-0.0534074008,
0.4248993099,
0.634775281,
0.4526234269,
0.9520423412,
0.0779521987,
0.7782711983,
-0.2890292704,
0.1894492507,
1.1156504154,
-0.3579771817,
0.72450912,
0.5144021511,
0.2671200931,
0.3933195472,
0.6241703629,
-0.3353245258,
0.3081288934,
0.5092336535,
-0.0563279651,
-0.3154504895,
-0.160452351,
-0.1719621867,
1.0018117428,
0.1478054523,
-0.5670576096,
-0.3262625337,
0.375268966,
-0.0170688238,
0.0254423898,
-0.1647465378,
0.9607012272,
0.2183295339,
-0.6983558536,
0.2413871288,
0.3048261106,
-0.0902995467,
-0.2977586687,
-0.2635239661,
-0.3717590272,
0.0612523332,
0.1453596354,
-0.8950468302,
0.2584661245,
0.163737908,
-0.0118581904,
-0.0026386685,
0.7070669532,
-0.7069607973,
-0.7643352151,
0.5036101937,
0.4614261985,
0.1872354895,
-0.2725189924,
-0.8202821016,
-0.4843539,
-0.4004542232,
-0.0627633333,
-0.1044886187,
0.8942114115,
-0.0469076559,
0.2636224329,
0.6744592786,
0.0333322063,
0.3791615963,
-0.0507656187,
1.0202671289,
-0.7544409037,
-0.6561099887,
-0.8757202029,
0.6356238127,
-0.3059122264,
-0.4589571655,
0.4343129992,
0.774279356,
0.8021796346,
0.1744048744,
0.7953265905,
0.1101939306,
0.2218690068,
-0.6632156372,
0.919776082,
-0.4908750355,
0.1154062226,
-0.0266949199,
-0.8055640459,
-0.2746492326,
0.4526373446,
-0.3130492568,
-0.0997903422,
0.3902947307,
0.5515853167,
-0.131962046,
-0.0576262847,
0.4135583341,
-0.0169578269,
0.48123914,
0.6825307608,
0.9320591688,
-0.5718772411,
0.705155313,
-0.4816256464,
0.0672035441,
-0.3654668033,
-0.4059537947,
-1.1418688297,
-0.5685912967,
-0.2125512362,
-0.4055312276,
-0.0751259178,
0.743881166,
0.5642311573,
-0.9785282612,
-0.3593677282,
-0.0217288192,
0.0249643959,
0.1172995865,
-0.2464066893,
0.681237936,
-0.3538146019,
-0.5421221852,
0.1748427451,
0.3222982883,
0.0763437524,
-0.2094860226,
0.073953554,
-0.8245465755,
0.0894925818,
0.6453614235,
0.172444433,
-0.5893803239,
-0.4616933763,
0.0539482459,
-0.3078568578,
0.2164900601,
1.1803703308,
-0.6141275764,
0.5190101266,
0.6933726072,
1.0914911032,
0.4222719371,
0.1490821391,
0.6805865169,
-0.4214092195,
0.2836672366,
0.5964257717,
0.5538471341,
0.049796734,
-0.3649828434,
0.4142161012,
0.1576954722,
-0.3855566978,
-0.6562974453,
0.3186977208,
-0.7189180255,
-0.5307993889,
1.0820521116,
-0.4714174569,
-0.4966316223,
-0.5835953951,
-0.2228292972,
0.6801884174,
0.1152840182,
0.5379017591,
0.6964634061,
0.1074940041,
-0.330819279,
-0.6101726294,
0.2206009775,
0.266477257,
-0.7696519494,
0.0101991035,
0.3987839818,
0.2645450532,
0.1569340974,
0.3436456919,
-0.1926525086,
0.3614902794,
-0.4243339598,
-0.3919445276,
-0.2069337815,
-0.4496270716,
-0.6612206697,
0.5152324438,
-0.3145110011,
-0.2033167481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14405v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14405v1 | ViMQ: A Vietnamese Medical Question Dataset for Healthcare Dialogue System Development | 2023-04-27T17:59:53 | 2023-04-27T17:59:53 | Ta Duc Huy, Nguyen Anh Tu, Tran Hoang Vu, Nguyen Phuc Minh, Nguyen Phan, Trung H. Bui, Steven Q. H. Truong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing medical text datasets usually take the form of question and answer
pairs that support the task of natural language generation, but lacking the
composite annotations of the medical terms. In this study, we publish a
Vietnamese dataset of medical questions from patients with sentence-level and
entity-level annotations for the Intent Classification and Named Entity
Recognition tasks. The tag sets for two tasks are in medical domain and can
facilitate the development of task-oriented healthcare chatbots with better
comprehension of queries from patients. We train baseline models for the two
tasks and propose a simple self-supervised training strategy with span-noise
modelling that substantially improves the performance. Dataset and code will be
published at https://github.com/tadeephuy/ViMQ | [
-0.086560525,
-0.8201897144,
0.5228963494,
-0.0982271656,
-0.2268743515,
-0.2127507478,
0.2350859791,
-0.2408117503,
0.2065052986,
1.0635625124,
-0.5791243911,
-0.6792571545,
-0.2603433728,
0.0761611089,
-0.1417160332,
0.8904640675,
0.0261339787,
0.2831177711,
-0.4656323195,
-0.2308595777,
-0.5139021277,
-0.650524497,
-0.9123291969,
0.0117417974,
0.3751544654,
0.5141431689,
0.407492578,
0.5069805384,
0.5530745983,
0.2209495157,
0.3116990328,
0.5543564558,
-0.3575829566,
0.6192127466,
0.1466408074,
-0.435644269,
-0.2828398347,
-0.1971009821,
0.3683052361,
0.4128096104,
0.0973210782,
0.2062180042,
-0.2647907436,
0.3638445735,
-0.2516769767,
0.1862029582,
-0.4998606741,
0.0231465157,
0.1268400103,
-0.3132012486,
-0.141515106,
-0.1802225709,
0.2419955432,
-0.5871039629,
0.1099599972,
0.0225460846,
0.8985257149,
0.6349824667,
-0.5776482224,
-0.1861373633,
-0.5736790895,
0.5054839849,
-0.5856950283,
0.2515918911,
0.5300227404,
0.1443763673,
-0.0115694124,
-0.7457380295,
-0.1887426376,
0.0186236352,
-0.2531558275,
0.3202430606,
-0.0093081407,
0.2170413136,
0.216559425,
0.3210588098,
-0.7507863045,
0.0144099593,
-0.6055516005,
-0.0674670488,
0.773198247,
0.3646411002,
0.5061485767,
-0.5985672474,
-0.3622256517,
0.3426504135,
-0.5634761453,
0.0614248477,
-0.2076452821,
0.232496202,
-0.1269201338,
0.6103141308,
-0.4519685507,
0.6264217496,
-0.1938673109,
-0.4163018763,
0.3067198396,
-0.5039870739,
-0.3347581327,
-0.0593874864,
0.7612671852,
0.5560362935,
0.2516210973,
0.0630485117,
-0.1526575834,
0.1133378521,
0.4574232697,
-0.6061048508,
-0.4099175632,
0.798196733,
-0.456247896,
-0.3029198945,
-0.1047020704,
-0.2210142761,
-0.1892448366,
-0.4693869352,
0.4293148816,
-0.3575718999,
-0.2707142532,
0.3545294106,
-0.1285487115,
0.2726052701,
0.4692892432,
-0.6165245771,
0.3150729835,
0.481325686,
0.4518806636,
-0.2174834609,
0.2578025162,
-0.5564852357,
0.0376927853,
-0.0879562423,
0.7104395032,
-0.3437194228,
-0.6091934443,
0.1695803851,
0.2474984378,
-0.2963060141,
-0.8208859563,
0.6220960021,
-0.2272237688,
0.4963846207,
0.0364288129,
-0.6061886549,
0.0697422028,
0.273540616,
-0.5311562419,
1.1711142063,
0.4049066305,
-0.9351194501,
0.1744873971,
-0.581987679,
-0.4643910527,
0.5259609818,
-0.4665629268,
-0.4690592885,
-0.1454089135,
0.4773929715,
0.704133451,
-0.2531190813,
0.2143689841,
0.1460803002,
-0.1372750252,
0.3117891848,
-0.0980597362,
0.7327540517,
0.2636031806,
-0.082424283,
0.0524449162,
-0.8225113153,
0.1261209399,
0.0782104582,
-0.4043732882,
-0.4288485348,
-0.074781552,
-0.1205327734,
0.402628094,
0.0545499958,
-0.3825131655,
0.2755489051,
-0.3265073001,
0.4218047559,
0.1028635725,
0.6641430855,
0.1628972143,
-0.4437615871,
0.6410791278,
0.4047742486,
0.4398836792,
-0.388405323,
-0.739577651,
-0.9728030562,
-0.3316410482,
0.2845737934,
0.7989102006,
-1.1941953897,
0.2919948995,
-0.1326996237,
-0.2961415648,
-0.9774307609,
-0.0376946516,
0.2638501823,
0.8696632385,
0.5610389113,
-0.0977270156,
-0.6278733015,
-0.9799320102,
0.1506108791,
-0.5778136849,
-0.1670366824,
0.6786617041,
0.3964245617,
-0.4991731346,
0.7959347367,
-0.5305747986,
-0.1219087541,
-0.0499611646,
0.0901681855,
-0.185196057,
0.6285092831,
0.2680898607,
-1.0164251328,
-0.1669797897,
-0.1991766095,
-0.7816464901,
-0.2528699934,
-0.078410916,
-0.238452062,
-0.0218059085,
0.5383441448,
-0.5326744914,
0.2864300013,
0.3279016018,
-0.086004369,
0.3348341286,
0.1616377681,
0.1721977741,
-1.5342860222,
0.1046103016,
0.0452306643,
-0.4443287849,
-0.8561228514,
-0.3669880927,
-0.1517646313,
-0.074938111,
-0.4358025193,
0.5121971369,
-0.1488477439,
0.4359320104,
0.0093704956,
-0.0493857265,
0.2168935537,
0.3253144622,
0.2240933627,
0.5771026015,
0.5003961325,
-0.7715772986,
0.4367401898,
0.5523107648,
0.0758559182,
0.9001088142,
-0.8604352474,
-0.0380377471,
-0.1790397018,
-0.0985875279,
-0.9164012074,
-0.4166944325,
0.5936575532,
-0.6114937663,
0.0311433468,
-0.4035531282,
-0.2466883361,
-0.388302207,
0.0837487057,
0.3407610655,
0.4675958157,
-0.1025571227,
-0.0335851163,
0.8292861581,
-0.3199431598,
-0.4029594064,
-0.564948678,
-0.1930452138,
-0.3149476349,
-0.4401833117,
0.0409209803,
0.0753550157,
-0.2788926065,
-0.1246554032,
0.0015539373,
-0.4356311858,
-0.0056276512,
0.5140489936,
0.257345885,
-0.4848538935,
0.9687549472,
0.1240081042,
0.1357532889,
0.2339227498,
-0.4636425376,
0.2222288102,
0.1671698391,
-0.0611011498,
-0.3172175884,
0.5573969483,
0.1640502363,
-0.3960411847,
0.3176667094,
0.382837534,
-0.5075246096,
-0.0656581521,
-0.4783533514,
-0.1482052803,
-0.4143041968,
0.1666169018,
-0.3382069767,
-1.1606429815,
0.0776655897,
-0.0443311185,
0.1656338573,
0.6138185263,
0.7257381678,
-0.2729542851,
0.8897780776,
0.2000618577,
0.0011492593,
0.1405451745,
-0.1148297116,
-0.2771714032,
-0.4953233004,
-0.1852458417,
-0.3924159408,
0.150285989,
-0.8015709519,
-0.8378894329,
0.4986394346,
-0.2338710725,
-0.2066254467,
0.2125627548,
-0.6747877002,
-0.1277788877,
0.6343867779,
0.2468850464,
0.4002679586,
-0.1048814207,
0.0468842685,
0.0408604369,
-0.7740299106,
-0.7120521665,
0.9312208891,
0.2411817312,
0.7768619061,
-0.3814203739,
0.8073163629,
0.2090258598,
-0.0467347726,
-0.686532259,
0.2791410983,
0.1611377895,
-0.5912291408,
-0.4606158137,
-0.6245971918,
-1.2154214382,
0.0291480385,
-0.2673294842,
-0.4193294048,
0.0687100738,
0.004108008,
-0.5439243913,
-0.1394858509,
-0.6210448146,
0.9617902637,
-0.1328244954,
0.1986044943,
0.3662311733,
-1.033120513,
0.1184203476,
0.127468124,
-0.165913254,
-0.3473367393,
-0.0413038321,
0.6747305393,
-0.3972075582,
0.6392620802,
-0.118873179,
-0.0790781528,
0.7931532264,
-0.3193861544,
-0.074260518,
0.7402592897,
0.2739332616,
-0.2266934365,
0.3109722435,
-0.4365992844,
-0.431417495,
0.3198742568,
-0.6930587292,
-0.554053247,
-0.060255006,
-0.3749170005,
-0.3596942723,
0.0718294606,
0.2403123677,
0.5038965344,
-0.2865195274,
-0.0412582494,
0.9476822615,
-0.1773865223,
-0.1182825714,
0.3933438659,
-0.1508481652,
-0.1293267161,
0.6172305942,
0.0577401742,
0.1100799441,
0.660793066,
-0.1804655492,
-0.0493031107,
-0.1465631872,
-0.4262320399,
0.3091094196,
-0.5289485455,
-0.3963301778,
-0.9614498615,
-0.6655011773,
-0.4965093136,
0.4493752718,
-0.1525346637,
-0.5035590529,
-0.4581033885,
-0.0829565823,
0.5542086363,
0.8619914055,
0.4560283422,
0.2890434861,
-0.9129516482,
0.5294141769,
0.5475998521,
0.1388123184,
-0.6882948279,
-0.2359305173,
-0.3953381777,
0.1400169581,
-0.1704744846,
-0.9282972217,
0.2745142281,
0.0129830949,
0.3381491303,
0.2977990806,
0.358494997,
0.2076258808,
-0.4159497917,
0.7899288535,
-0.1143415272,
-0.4959379435,
0.9500238299,
-0.3263103664,
0.350643307,
0.5946564674,
0.6193153262,
-0.8810925484,
-0.487934649,
-0.7838323116,
-0.5348848104,
0.4314279556,
0.3995301127,
0.0176979601,
-0.0017946202,
0.4576423764,
0.0402935855,
0.1994896829,
-0.3478324115,
-0.240452081,
-0.0206158366,
-0.4240114987,
-0.0043828948,
-0.1839357615,
-0.2313333601,
-0.2459075898,
0.3944996893,
-0.2927413583,
0.5830851793,
0.633836925,
-0.0487051569,
0.0896735936,
0.298147887,
0.2686088383,
0.3368832171,
-0.0310247391,
-0.0464707613,
0.0799408704,
-0.4726967812,
0.1158662438,
0.0734028369,
-0.0632607937,
0.3739284277,
0.1303033531,
0.8215236068,
-0.0842385888,
-0.7644193769,
0.4432496428,
-0.388005197,
-0.3569415212,
-0.2399068624,
0.312874496,
0.2390485853,
0.1749561578,
-0.0849863142,
-0.3237576187,
0.4534818232,
-0.1281048357,
0.3879556656,
0.0146366777,
-0.7086626291,
-0.100799039,
0.5358222127,
0.3696277738,
-0.1874926686,
0.6999794841,
0.1434882879,
-0.4088676274,
0.4684254527,
0.0940504223,
0.4656215906,
-0.3221536577,
0.5359569192,
0.3173983991,
0.2033191323,
0.1875340492,
0.7933503985,
0.0203287452,
-0.5946504474,
-0.2571153045,
-0.2152799815,
-0.5718311667,
0.1811261624,
-0.6379196644,
0.3066607118,
-0.0042469963,
-0.3314424753,
0.0735239759,
-0.0011433704,
-0.716273427,
0.7486994863,
0.1020397618,
0.5438457727,
-0.6342622042,
0.7881857753,
0.8653029203,
-0.4663921297,
-0.6635683179,
-0.2141618133,
-0.2526215911,
-0.843526423,
0.3022330105,
0.1857916713,
0.5102046132,
-0.1961379945,
-0.7006925941,
-0.6737912297,
0.8274344206,
0.0728583336,
-0.240498051,
-0.2384181917,
0.4821788669,
0.6298351288,
-0.5773286819,
-0.0354112126,
0.5575387478,
0.1164068952,
-0.0613397099,
-0.9705386758,
-0.0144499084,
-0.486335218,
-0.1325773299,
0.1149420142,
-0.5889021158,
0.7619965672,
-0.0390893891,
-0.1314634234,
0.0787279978,
0.4549795091,
0.0352810845,
0.2444643676,
0.4576068223,
0.365519017,
0.9107180238,
-0.1875441223,
0.7652192116,
-0.2859850526,
0.1192153245,
1.0732946396,
-0.1037442014,
0.6559848189,
0.3582502604,
0.0248182137,
0.1417570859,
0.7898442745,
-0.0311434995,
0.0669835657,
0.4521173239,
-0.3436008096,
-0.3016128242,
-0.4163327813,
-0.4440106153,
0.4707317352,
0.6270957589,
-0.5062698722,
0.325345546,
0.227265209,
0.1069392413,
-0.3320747912,
-0.197777018,
1.1322945356,
0.29657951,
-0.6849765182,
0.5089043975,
-0.2340014279,
0.2121504247,
-0.294973284,
-0.115873456,
-0.1749770194,
-0.1778487265,
-0.1190796569,
-0.654604733,
0.0006957299,
-0.096375905,
-0.0705154687,
0.0172022656,
0.9501320124,
-0.7762997746,
-0.4991075695,
-0.1627468616,
0.9768927693,
0.3481525183,
-0.1520714164,
-0.8642286658,
-0.4241006374,
-0.2442220151,
-0.0078592012,
-0.1837501377,
0.6385651827,
-0.0671004578,
0.6222827435,
0.2085062563,
0.0406700969,
0.0308223404,
0.0471681282,
0.9867182374,
-0.5439747572,
-0.3485699594,
-0.3874061704,
0.5109832883,
-0.1901556402,
-0.573646307,
0.5112708807,
0.6112879515,
0.7152827382,
-0.1004595533,
1.0019630194,
0.2276527584,
0.9399380684,
-0.476141274,
0.596758604,
-0.6673779488,
-0.1327365041,
-0.1521190703,
-0.2461700886,
-0.3115865588,
0.3187351227,
0.022969868,
0.0046522222,
0.4667643011,
0.6554324031,
0.3111537695,
0.078881979,
0.5109420419,
0.0380646512,
0.1584970951,
0.5570076704,
0.8921135664,
-0.6504829526,
0.3762361407,
-0.2047204524,
0.1897810549,
-0.4056102931,
-0.103450194,
-1.0022627115,
-0.7329021096,
-0.5620930791,
-0.380061388,
0.2510737181,
1.0720040798,
0.843357563,
-0.8095835447,
-0.0656784922,
0.3335704803,
-0.1168233827,
0.0666431785,
-0.2098583579,
0.2925649881,
-0.5306841731,
-0.6396314502,
0.0967665315,
0.2522352338,
0.3225587904,
-0.0838630348,
0.0646141469,
-0.2559204102,
0.0329006687,
0.4231083393,
0.2169894129,
-0.3861048222,
-0.0973135456,
0.2369406074,
-0.5511007905,
0.5069568753,
0.8958007097,
-0.8204371929,
0.583445847,
0.2487208396,
0.6648055315,
0.272118181,
0.1388127506,
0.5117168427,
-0.8133555651,
0.0437791236,
0.5136383772,
0.3252308071,
0.3330942392,
-0.5000134706,
0.6426591873,
0.1652829498,
-0.7097459435,
-0.5083858967,
0.0913255215,
-1.067158699,
-0.0835524052,
1.1780390739,
-0.2386505604,
-0.1257107258,
-0.6538442969,
-0.7691896558,
0.4506554306,
-0.332290858,
0.3807983696,
0.2738023996,
-0.1690115184,
-0.2368123084,
-0.7741921544,
0.8110306263,
0.4220432937,
-1.1319066286,
-0.1559042186,
0.3729412854,
-0.0448936038,
-0.1895761341,
0.9533037543,
-0.0372566506,
0.2933037579,
-0.1641205698,
-0.0038797269,
0.3893947005,
-0.1188903823,
-0.1444092244,
-0.0209101569,
0.041191373,
-0.4320603609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14402v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14402v3 | LaMini-LM: A Diverse Herd of Distilled Models from Large-Scale Instructions | 2023-04-27T17:58:49 | 2024-01-29T02:58:23 | Minghao Wu, Abdul Waheed, Chiyu Zhang, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) with instruction fine-tuning demonstrate
superior generative capabilities. However, these models are resource-intensive.
To alleviate this issue, we explore distilling knowledge from instruction-tuned
LLMs into much smaller ones. To this end, we carefully develop a large set of
2.58M instructions based on both existing and newly-generated instructions. In
addition to being sizable, we design our instructions to cover a broad set of
topics to ensure diversity. Extensive analysis of our instruction dataset
confirms its diversity, and we generate responses for these instructions using
gpt-3.5-turbo. Leveraging these instructions, we fine-tune a diverse herd of
models, collectively referred to as LaMini-LM, which includes models from both
the encoder-decoder and decoder-only families, with varying sizes. We evaluate
the performance of our models using automatic metrics on 15 different natural
language processing (NLP) benchmarks, as well as through human assessment. The
results demonstrate that our proposed LaMini-LM models are comparable to
competitive baselines, while being much smaller in size. | [
-0.556994915,
-0.701689899,
0.3056533933,
0.2184628397,
-0.351352334,
0.0446525291,
-0.5409277081,
-0.3831487298,
-0.1604308933,
0.7211585045,
-0.6829508543,
-0.3087365329,
-0.7787689567,
0.1246571913,
-0.3328268826,
1.067743659,
0.0966647938,
0.0886746943,
0.1183241829,
-0.0804671571,
-0.5228680372,
-0.1962312609,
-0.6394025683,
-0.4678865075,
0.431686312,
0.3815553784,
0.5378417373,
0.9113368392,
0.4733189046,
0.2683489025,
-0.341997683,
0.5850310922,
-0.7847646475,
-0.0185663886,
-0.2947456539,
-0.4595752656,
-0.3488146663,
0.0583343133,
0.6977234483,
0.802955687,
-0.3118117452,
0.3952152729,
0.1595297605,
0.9686611295,
-0.5537753105,
0.035817448,
-0.8158584237,
0.0244227108,
-0.1927227676,
-0.0522530936,
-0.7232431173,
-0.3674294055,
0.0846057013,
-0.2797261775,
0.2068140656,
0.0842309296,
0.608972311,
0.3486570716,
-0.2566285729,
-0.4812878072,
-1.0279362202,
0.954733789,
-0.7774618268,
0.0251401551,
0.3245660663,
0.2784573436,
-0.1917564422,
-0.6678465605,
-0.3637567461,
-0.0528684333,
0.0368214548,
-0.0046778419,
-0.2384033501,
0.0119466968,
0.2719637752,
0.6691545844,
-0.4876931608,
0.6171213388,
-0.5042397976,
0.2283782959,
0.679735899,
0.4427850842,
0.2776455581,
0.2916566133,
-0.2686157227,
-0.0119676646,
-0.6252560019,
-0.2778885663,
0.3641279638,
0.3359558582,
-0.2184106857,
0.5124599338,
-0.272736758,
0.9798803926,
0.307284385,
-0.2770854533,
-0.1006215885,
-0.2731745243,
-0.405513227,
0.0033562896,
0.8216599822,
0.2702493966,
0.286041975,
-0.1575462073,
-0.1942449361,
-0.3886961937,
0.2157924324,
-1.0706704855,
-0.0934990495,
0.0596287996,
-0.5821498036,
-0.0587277934,
-0.1080013812,
-0.7399027348,
-0.4856277406,
-0.4967913628,
0.1361307204,
-0.6827592254,
0.0532625802,
0.3244131505,
-0.1589903235,
0.367683202,
0.420722574,
-1.2914158106,
0.194854036,
0.8211465478,
0.7393089533,
-0.1856244206,
-0.1643903702,
-0.4694374502,
0.0595745817,
-0.0278023444,
0.472646594,
-0.6120768785,
-0.5789301991,
-0.2276863903,
-0.1551470459,
-0.1028325334,
-0.821972847,
0.4398831725,
-0.4968499541,
0.3166911006,
-0.2896935642,
-0.8130401969,
-0.2588306367,
-0.0186579321,
-0.9211222529,
0.6818335056,
0.2263085693,
-0.5608080029,
0.073267661,
-0.7210469842,
-0.4345860481,
0.142599538,
0.1547037512,
-0.194087103,
0.4719220698,
0.130606994,
0.3428505957,
-0.8443481922,
0.2168667018,
-0.076854609,
-0.4138273299,
0.2606216371,
-0.7220531702,
0.9037243128,
0.2815942466,
-0.3536430597,
-0.0284588262,
-0.8828665018,
-0.0438789427,
-0.1800982952,
-0.5345001817,
-0.0958936363,
-0.0862795636,
-0.2768619955,
-0.0073933196,
0.218117401,
-0.1515891701,
0.3125387132,
-0.1990501732,
0.582816422,
0.7889980674,
-0.2218942195,
0.4664517045,
-0.3918247819,
0.2975909114,
-0.1286187917,
0.1899516582,
-0.1248788759,
-0.44084391,
-1.0639363527,
-0.3991310894,
0.2447973341,
0.4861963093,
-0.4258726239,
0.5102745295,
-0.3494230509,
-0.3825166821,
-0.6787478924,
0.4487589896,
0.2955059707,
0.2185557634,
0.3972383738,
-0.2294804007,
-0.3001520038,
-1.0535984039,
0.0143732345,
0.0608730838,
-0.1747908145,
0.1952944249,
0.444355756,
-0.3558596373,
0.6930246353,
-0.546233058,
-0.0362513773,
-0.3261029124,
0.4364488423,
0.2168087363,
0.3113161027,
0.3712107837,
-0.5108601451,
-0.6775012016,
0.08538495,
-0.6701794267,
-0.2142311186,
-0.0317526683,
-0.1002230123,
-0.1802361757,
0.3013991117,
-0.4752159715,
-0.0266276076,
0.4927353561,
0.0973204896,
0.4465338886,
-0.2672525942,
-0.1426763088,
-1.2239195108,
-0.0874397755,
-0.0376762263,
-0.0643558726,
-0.7448179722,
0.2011219114,
-0.1772229671,
0.0431843325,
-0.5061635375,
0.3833895922,
-0.6125074625,
0.1818534732,
-0.4139604568,
-0.0287453942,
0.1733033955,
0.4661777616,
-0.0653168783,
0.8180341125,
0.2189125866,
-0.5518686771,
0.4432064295,
-0.1401505768,
-0.519785285,
0.4643824399,
-0.6322028041,
0.1743817031,
-0.2230435759,
0.0620135069,
-0.3786814511,
-0.2805687785,
-0.10189455,
0.2109992057,
0.538130343,
-0.0481915846,
-0.3311745524,
-0.3325929642,
-0.1613176316,
0.3127076626,
0.7717767954,
-0.6085296273,
0.5862883925,
0.3488594294,
-0.1489874274,
-0.49017784,
-0.6276925802,
-0.054973267,
-0.3624767363,
-0.4566268921,
0.3502666652,
-0.2035369277,
-0.4750552773,
-0.0868790075,
0.17223759,
-0.2810471654,
0.0993763283,
0.2083919048,
0.0980462953,
-0.3948505521,
0.0481105596,
-0.0702114329,
0.1921941787,
-0.1053897887,
-0.4840429723,
0.7469103932,
-0.2466744483,
-0.2693383396,
-0.5680446625,
0.265781194,
0.6598629951,
-0.3536176383,
0.9429287314,
0.7931599021,
-0.1406573951,
-0.612995863,
-0.5954278708,
-0.0254031308,
-0.4961923361,
0.3422095478,
-0.2131788135,
-1.0934678316,
0.4879858494,
-0.1875217855,
0.0933963731,
0.3104589581,
0.7367024422,
-0.0246349201,
0.659314096,
0.6432487965,
-0.2390077114,
0.3688112795,
-0.4387531281,
0.0108907949,
-0.8902418613,
-0.1732546091,
-0.3311922252,
-0.614538312,
-0.5252892971,
-0.6981165409,
0.0397357568,
0.3171942234,
-0.2686161399,
0.2277554572,
-0.6190683246,
0.7920145392,
0.647313416,
0.0927268341,
0.2393295765,
0.0167560633,
0.0722073689,
0.2249316275,
-0.76113379,
-0.6207895279,
1.0769128799,
0.3752570748,
0.862649262,
0.1441992968,
0.7519223094,
0.2220322788,
0.4900903702,
-0.6581693888,
0.5263743997,
-0.9340391159,
-0.5032699108,
-0.2476438284,
-0.6284852028,
-0.7765558958,
0.216968298,
-0.0116975959,
-0.7049695849,
0.04786174,
-0.0634475872,
-0.5717284679,
0.5460990667,
-0.6313829422,
0.7790187001,
-0.5563639402,
-0.3885018528,
-0.2245758772,
-0.3673303723,
0.8027517796,
-0.2846762836,
0.0484826304,
-0.4135696292,
0.1548254341,
0.3958991766,
-0.4983945787,
1.0625053644,
0.1073451713,
-0.329937309,
0.513574779,
-0.0519788973,
0.2494285703,
-0.0545911789,
-0.3527677357,
0.0276386905,
-0.403557837,
-0.2122705132,
-0.5447782874,
0.7806686759,
-0.9090970755,
-0.7403538227,
0.1107971072,
-0.7290815711,
0.1963935643,
0.0265795905,
0.3821107149,
0.4097789228,
-0.455927521,
0.5141571164,
0.8502512574,
-0.3380569518,
0.4583341479,
0.6719819307,
-0.0024781872,
-0.2379259765,
0.9428892732,
-0.0215498656,
0.4548553824,
0.6069554687,
0.1777337939,
-0.1360747814,
-0.6909399033,
-0.5270249248,
0.0587808676,
-0.5880666971,
-0.1696899235,
-0.2723252475,
-0.3357564807,
0.1567867696,
0.0706677958,
-0.4599545002,
-0.2864843607,
-0.5262847543,
0.066501081,
0.2746412158,
0.8223665357,
0.1308724135,
0.5123229623,
-0.9440121055,
0.2672821581,
0.6285784245,
0.2977181375,
0.0396171063,
-0.6826067567,
-0.3639917672,
0.457882911,
-0.2364943177,
-0.6476530433,
0.4831057191,
0.5424027443,
0.4472340047,
0.4134329259,
-0.0154658463,
0.6295326948,
-0.6662482023,
0.7984322309,
0.1574722081,
-0.9124037027,
0.4564995468,
-0.2015173882,
0.4519996047,
0.6595961452,
0.3289766312,
-0.2630343735,
-0.356213361,
-0.2229203582,
-0.6494420767,
0.7228668332,
0.0818655789,
0.269868046,
0.0181671437,
0.4116041362,
0.3954206407,
0.0719885379,
-0.6288961768,
-0.0691033006,
-0.1116313189,
-0.3593296409,
0.0308717396,
-0.2885957956,
-0.3061489165,
-0.0983052179,
0.4184231758,
-0.0175058171,
-0.0979764685,
-0.333878547,
-0.2033578902,
0.0551233515,
0.4814578891,
0.8336897492,
0.5647864342,
-0.1824346036,
0.229284063,
0.3401554823,
-0.4243559241,
0.2298508435,
0.0539969206,
-0.2955900729,
-0.0476598814,
0.4441809654,
1.3549400568,
0.1157039106,
-0.5942054987,
0.0456305034,
-0.1812115759,
-0.1041902676,
-0.0268249009,
0.4336855114,
0.3091685474,
0.2069390267,
0.1556459665,
-0.0784521997,
-0.0310265403,
-0.6285400391,
0.1304062605,
0.3461973667,
-0.183520779,
-0.3450864553,
0.5470397472,
0.450733453,
-0.3126952648,
0.8146201968,
-0.485522747,
-0.3348028064,
0.6538253427,
0.474247843,
0.9782910347,
-0.137242496,
0.4048511684,
0.3624365926,
0.3073408008,
-0.5354263783,
-0.0444202274,
0.2123930156,
-0.8092832565,
-0.3921168447,
-1.0008360147,
-0.2873214781,
0.5130972862,
-0.7671981454,
0.0226270817,
-0.5614702702,
-0.292845577,
0.0852591619,
-0.1239010692,
-0.7061011195,
0.0704790279,
0.3486537933,
0.7328492403,
-0.6072760224,
0.9617530704,
0.3330107927,
-0.4158132374,
-0.7971737385,
0.039992664,
-0.0694161803,
-0.8191584349,
0.9856447577,
0.1845000684,
-0.0283873267,
-0.0513070785,
-0.336443156,
-0.5824124217,
1.0860078335,
0.4539362192,
-0.8885505199,
-0.0284174737,
0.4814036489,
0.614248395,
-0.5570526719,
0.1575477868,
0.7406944633,
0.3215119839,
-0.0240254011,
-0.9154509902,
-0.1527362168,
-0.1795529425,
0.180992499,
0.067404069,
-0.8776439428,
1.1289687157,
-0.0845363364,
-0.3605802953,
0.1180924624,
0.5363903642,
0.1286811084,
-0.1433516741,
0.2086626589,
0.6737888455,
0.8798135519,
-0.1103839278,
1.0792658329,
-0.5550893545,
0.0191125143,
1.4140719175,
-0.3622090518,
0.8488309979,
0.26667431,
-0.1132576615,
0.5684425235,
0.4168975949,
-0.241266191,
0.3885220885,
0.4109712541,
-0.4190049767,
-0.2268286496,
-0.2691360116,
-0.3083454669,
0.6694342494,
0.4375275373,
-0.5845819712,
-0.0904944092,
-0.1691408157,
-0.2217393816,
0.0905398503,
-0.4091305435,
0.9032739997,
0.2910372019,
-0.7400904298,
0.8957882524,
0.2155403048,
0.7795522213,
-0.530903995,
0.1812698543,
-0.4849502444,
0.2476844192,
0.0427590497,
-0.6203220487,
0.1504081339,
0.1986942738,
-0.5328231454,
-0.2353043854,
0.5076658726,
-0.7168166637,
-0.5902702808,
0.1967180967,
0.4908182919,
0.0172146596,
0.2187351733,
-0.5651438832,
0.2151148021,
0.2216791362,
-0.012356285,
0.2472337931,
0.5276523829,
0.0203728639,
0.7474230528,
0.4432875216,
0.119294107,
0.2697865665,
0.3345532417,
0.783431232,
-0.4140146375,
-0.0539422147,
-1.1134915352,
0.4219640493,
-0.299364388,
-0.2705644965,
0.6044015884,
0.4930419922,
0.7092000842,
-0.3216283321,
0.7327015996,
0.2273032963,
0.0872129276,
-0.6881082058,
0.4859800935,
-0.3664952517,
0.653854847,
0.4032892883,
-1.0864661932,
0.0330525935,
0.378441453,
-0.2302041948,
-0.049075935,
0.4205334485,
0.728128016,
-0.12190184,
0.2494703978,
0.0561877191,
0.1453241557,
0.2126761675,
0.8265571594,
0.9213962555,
-0.0883101076,
0.3701305687,
-0.1582440436,
-0.18150796,
-0.2748996913,
-0.8779611588,
-1.0719501972,
-0.2105257511,
-0.2525869906,
0.1595180035,
0.1655712724,
0.749601841,
0.6411428452,
-0.7685098648,
-0.533688128,
-0.0938950256,
0.0276540592,
-0.1465078145,
-0.1694760174,
0.1320326775,
-0.4163329303,
-0.7838000655,
0.512984097,
0.4049648643,
0.1056856513,
-0.4207542241,
-0.18853122,
0.0055996641,
0.2172426134,
0.7302238941,
0.1835734397,
-0.7190432549,
-0.0922840312,
-0.0320101902,
-0.3019637167,
-0.0745401904,
0.7580803633,
-0.173671633,
0.4342789352,
0.5630668402,
0.6116513014,
0.6431363225,
-0.007638142,
0.9783272147,
-0.9171644449,
0.1727784723,
0.1353703886,
0.3370244503,
0.4684593976,
-0.0692672431,
0.4957414865,
-0.1211902052,
-0.4064164758,
-0.698910892,
0.3421794772,
-0.7379587293,
-0.5364170074,
1.1871445179,
-0.1696858555,
-0.1450434476,
0.2268690616,
-0.1099272594,
0.2206088603,
-0.101098448,
0.870038271,
0.6779665947,
-0.0196579695,
-0.2837026417,
-0.4489020109,
0.5532444715,
0.2452454418,
-0.8744840026,
0.1212215647,
0.4307524562,
0.1609607041,
0.230562523,
0.3397956491,
0.065905869,
-0.056298241,
0.0195304528,
-0.056860745,
-0.2070964426,
-0.1790533215,
-0.2066840082,
0.3110652864,
0.1584694088,
0.035151802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14399v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14399v2 | We're Afraid Language Models Aren't Modeling Ambiguity | 2023-04-27T17:57:58 | 2023-10-20T05:46:14 | Alisa Liu, Zhaofeng Wu, Julian Michael, Alane Suhr, Peter West, Alexander Koller, Swabha Swayamdipta, Noah A. Smith, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ambiguity is an intrinsic feature of natural language. Managing ambiguity is
a key part of human language understanding, allowing us to anticipate
misunderstanding as communicators and revise our interpretations as listeners.
As language models (LMs) are increasingly employed as dialogue interfaces and
writing aids, handling ambiguous language is critical to their success. We
characterize ambiguity in a sentence by its effect on entailment relations with
another sentence, and collect AmbiEnt, a linguist-annotated benchmark of 1,645
examples with diverse kinds of ambiguity. We design a suite of tests based on
AmbiEnt, presenting the first evaluation of pretrained LMs to recognize
ambiguity and disentangle possible meanings. We find that the task remains
extremely challenging, including for GPT-4, whose generated disambiguations are
considered correct only 32% of the time in human evaluation, compared to 90%
for disambiguations in our dataset. Finally, to illustrate the value of
ambiguity-sensitive tools, we show that a multilabel NLI model can flag
political claims in the wild that are misleading due to ambiguity. We encourage
the field to rediscover the importance of ambiguity for NLP. | [
-0.2593729794,
-1.0128312111,
0.6292731166,
0.2824562788,
-0.3153958619,
0.2881814837,
-0.0782175511,
-0.7798623443,
-0.5128525496,
0.0961479545,
-0.7201223373,
0.0032602376,
-0.9382256866,
0.2030960917,
-0.3385307491,
0.459404856,
-0.1293277442,
-0.4478884339,
-0.0859511569,
-0.3001021743,
-0.4128656387,
-0.4871048629,
-0.3166002929,
-0.4390095174,
0.3839204013,
0.0632212311,
1.2419900894,
0.4239028394,
0.4209463,
0.3614025414,
-0.4204450548,
-0.0231933296,
-0.2135458291,
-0.0429930687,
0.1119241342,
-0.3423178196,
-0.093548581,
0.229365617,
0.5306389928,
1.0000597239,
-0.2342623472,
-0.1287840009,
-0.2219495922,
0.5703999996,
-0.7384966016,
-0.1199662536,
-0.8334113359,
0.0452516973,
-0.4028730989,
0.369963944,
-0.1902288049,
-0.0761989206,
0.244113937,
-0.5530343652,
-0.0428462029,
0.2351050228,
1.3027341366,
0.5908876657,
-0.6257219315,
-0.5469332933,
-0.8435749412,
0.4567627609,
-0.7992781997,
0.5719236135,
0.4803265035,
0.1680518687,
-0.1993040591,
-0.5378944278,
-0.8561657667,
-0.1867627054,
-0.0748702437,
0.0127163939,
-0.417221576,
0.1710064709,
0.3369447589,
0.2514907122,
-0.5484575033,
0.1623831689,
-0.3520186543,
-0.126942724,
0.3425217569,
-0.0415791124,
0.3081929088,
-0.2649976015,
-0.4406998754,
0.2079856843,
-0.6468020082,
0.0449349172,
0.6120137572,
0.1749059111,
-0.0436885804,
0.6268908978,
0.0866701305,
0.9699600935,
-0.1513302922,
0.5481247306,
0.1864173859,
-0.2647379041,
-0.4421040714,
-0.2045428604,
0.6817604303,
0.0654544085,
0.0199928153,
-0.1885908544,
-0.124157384,
0.3611653447,
0.4032817781,
-0.3322334588,
-0.0920798555,
0.3749292195,
-0.0195537973,
0.0800764859,
-0.0743070245,
-0.6218956113,
-0.3026311696,
-0.3264727294,
0.5386692882,
-0.426352948,
-0.3357398212,
0.5090152621,
-0.101496987,
0.0283066407,
0.0329242796,
-0.6849171519,
0.3917137384,
0.6161484718,
0.4890260398,
0.0913780779,
-0.2417516261,
-0.1206358075,
-0.0651497543,
-0.3623535633,
0.4027812779,
-0.8079881668,
-0.4583639503,
-0.1583849192,
-0.2560633421,
-0.2150676399,
-0.5190466046,
0.6041449904,
-0.4500950277,
0.3360711336,
-0.1660017222,
-0.5783621073,
-0.0756498128,
0.0773122758,
-0.6656517982,
1.120177269,
0.321701318,
-0.6003657579,
0.3019379675,
-0.6873756051,
-0.0215838552,
0.1618568003,
-0.0510428883,
-0.4346238673,
0.1843437403,
0.0659437925,
-0.120430924,
0.0048684711,
0.7088596225,
-0.1135831103,
-0.3765747547,
0.4957493544,
-0.4671058059,
0.771034956,
0.2821186185,
-0.3403088748,
0.0169416871,
-0.4606142938,
0.0022746357,
-0.2032590955,
-0.1999133229,
-0.4696093798,
-0.0093387906,
-0.0204496216,
0.4553232491,
0.1897277534,
-0.3531163931,
0.0121498993,
-0.5077773333,
0.3897022307,
0.6203746796,
-0.3052932322,
0.443084687,
-0.2814552486,
0.6346817017,
0.0841108561,
0.2094853073,
0.1830500215,
-0.6806582808,
-0.6839135289,
0.1369227022,
0.232783258,
0.53630656,
-0.4807528257,
0.4931170642,
-0.0308936145,
-0.4802089036,
-0.7595286965,
0.0946787819,
0.2531811893,
0.3724970818,
0.3097488582,
0.1130920202,
-0.6376376152,
-0.8828256726,
-0.7729907632,
-0.2912857234,
0.0567719638,
0.0117083369,
0.4350011945,
-0.6024264693,
1.2623449564,
-0.2112227827,
0.1867232919,
0.0031887018,
0.606009841,
0.0235751793,
0.3190414011,
0.4741663635,
-1.126670599,
-0.2019387931,
-0.1978326738,
-0.5808984041,
-0.2823343575,
-0.167404592,
-0.1752124578,
0.0821509063,
0.3565757871,
-0.9128641486,
0.4674817324,
0.658377409,
-0.1957467049,
0.3133037686,
-0.1843950301,
-0.0679675341,
-0.6568351388,
-0.0132734487,
-0.0237267427,
-0.1176514104,
-0.7268083096,
0.0790690854,
0.2023112625,
-0.0178204607,
-0.4143033028,
0.5783097744,
-0.5570821166,
0.3570981026,
-0.1567186564,
0.422768414,
0.008490962,
0.1485510916,
-0.1167652383,
0.2563917637,
0.5718044639,
-0.6415330172,
0.061317578,
0.1135311425,
-0.514277339,
0.293400377,
-0.3955404162,
0.27865237,
-0.3800748885,
-0.026999006,
-0.7913976312,
-0.1668361425,
0.5233704448,
-0.2111593783,
0.2800817192,
0.2253318578,
-0.3147809207,
-0.5290421247,
0.3130558431,
0.4406305552,
0.4303450584,
-0.2116042227,
0.6029064059,
0.3301742971,
-0.1051141322,
-0.7722182274,
-0.588512361,
0.1432761997,
-0.4912893176,
-0.3920856416,
0.2525945902,
-0.1833752841,
-0.5899916887,
0.3208950162,
-0.4391744435,
-0.4164437056,
0.4054744542,
0.4669695795,
0.0556500033,
0.0713499859,
0.4692091942,
-0.346901536,
-0.0299426392,
0.0339019187,
-0.0206997581,
0.1066421494,
-0.3125263155,
-0.576793015,
-0.1810293794,
0.3937745392,
0.220978111,
-0.1317189336,
0.4330258369,
0.5578883886,
-0.7748218179,
0.2179619819,
-0.5093777776,
0.0344988368,
-0.5038752556,
0.3491655588,
-0.4809718728,
-0.9182351232,
0.5868367553,
-0.1481639743,
0.0032623014,
0.4982924461,
0.0775642693,
-0.0106631424,
0.9082459807,
0.6687043905,
0.1845716387,
0.2495075613,
0.3131241798,
0.6036191583,
-0.5916947722,
-0.0588622093,
-0.6027101874,
-0.183877036,
-0.5716106892,
-0.2907855213,
0.0568040647,
0.3779236972,
-0.149177283,
0.1956627667,
-0.4249482453,
0.5192930698,
0.1809578091,
-0.2110981941,
0.1389977783,
-0.3523204029,
0.1930998266,
-0.3450040221,
-0.5651458502,
-0.6737692356,
0.6403206587,
0.3851102889,
0.6924281716,
0.4429890811,
0.3942039013,
0.0540379696,
0.3939935267,
-0.5344689488,
0.2790981531,
0.1059085801,
-0.8034692407,
-0.317079097,
-0.5808281302,
-1.0686020851,
0.553224802,
-0.1808757037,
-0.8451867104,
0.2170324177,
0.0438528247,
-0.4262126982,
0.2628875673,
-0.7570691705,
0.9641134143,
-0.4481233954,
-0.208840102,
0.2737754583,
-0.8424939513,
0.5345730186,
-0.2327959538,
0.6404954195,
-0.3561382294,
0.0468723364,
0.2595149577,
-0.1355759948,
0.8252186775,
0.0828038678,
-0.2340542078,
0.3074166775,
0.2556810677,
0.1980292797,
-0.1095280647,
-0.4245890677,
0.1901892275,
-0.0821700171,
-0.2981810868,
-0.5491683483,
0.2436761111,
-0.6213850379,
-0.7879723907,
-0.5172300339,
-0.5902971029,
-0.0673127621,
0.1573300511,
0.3241086602,
0.1321105361,
-0.3020815253,
-0.1349868774,
0.3358007073,
-0.00873328,
0.3531760275,
0.4275224209,
-0.2344454527,
0.3621793985,
0.5634276867,
0.0152054168,
0.4751467705,
0.2090187669,
0.2822495997,
-0.5693510771,
-0.4086642265,
-0.2263739854,
-0.0947793573,
-0.7944746017,
0.1681766212,
-0.7667332292,
-0.213858068,
-0.2843918502,
-0.0880175158,
-0.168201834,
-0.1780225039,
-0.3071465492,
-0.185396567,
0.2061684877,
0.9925236702,
-0.2179484665,
0.5565807819,
-0.5903611183,
0.4459537864,
0.1445721835,
0.2601568699,
-0.5627069473,
-0.4173719883,
0.1227770448,
0.4611517787,
-0.2829943299,
-1.1834498644,
0.350654453,
0.3325538635,
0.7479240894,
0.2390965372,
0.1877015978,
0.7796800733,
-0.3705156147,
0.7531504631,
-0.1367544383,
-1.331212163,
0.4339141548,
-0.1254637837,
0.4559594393,
0.3631715775,
0.4081769884,
-0.767262876,
-0.882470727,
-0.8974726796,
-1.1880902052,
0.5057036281,
0.2848398089,
0.2846463621,
-0.163717255,
0.4984962046,
0.0419884846,
0.4400716424,
-1.2252570391,
-0.2675055265,
0.0112620844,
-0.1619243622,
-0.0777893811,
-0.2408659905,
-0.1329605132,
-0.0861433893,
0.3742339611,
0.1426944137,
-0.0247656796,
0.1153366417,
-0.241464749,
-0.1865791976,
0.6021873355,
0.7501912117,
0.6973077655,
-0.3959307075,
0.4513541162,
0.0968883634,
-0.1501700878,
0.0786363184,
0.2276754677,
0.1059626266,
0.2288269401,
0.1469282806,
0.9306450486,
0.3538173437,
-0.6118913293,
0.3179758191,
0.0403837673,
0.019388862,
-0.2125594914,
-0.1736762077,
0.266800791,
-0.1357391328,
0.2107717842,
0.4092608392,
0.1888211668,
-0.5931481719,
0.2182657123,
0.3961232603,
-0.4817472994,
-0.1658441871,
0.7295587063,
0.1312357336,
-0.4154977202,
0.7650644779,
-0.5161653161,
-0.6452679038,
0.7284627557,
0.4201468527,
0.5685556531,
-0.4774821997,
0.0933596268,
0.05148926,
0.9020232558,
0.0170271974,
0.177864641,
0.3544331193,
-0.8640110493,
-0.2447698116,
-0.2918427587,
-0.4695036709,
0.1241957173,
-0.6360510588,
0.0260531325,
-0.0209493786,
-0.3152600527,
0.0182421356,
-0.281964004,
-0.6547586918,
0.14197734,
-0.0482032448,
0.7341793776,
-1.0612671375,
0.5119360685,
0.4391273856,
-0.0602657422,
-0.5558305383,
-0.0025249929,
0.151105389,
-0.3742972314,
0.4935663939,
0.4425976872,
-0.1285942197,
-0.2120319158,
-0.4943361282,
-0.5643308163,
0.429843992,
0.5991770625,
-0.6666844487,
-0.0014360442,
0.2814643681,
0.4962123632,
-0.2281479537,
0.3452129662,
0.567121923,
0.8284432292,
-0.0959525779,
-0.8928162456,
-0.119626686,
-0.2919197083,
-0.0490483679,
0.325432688,
-0.1923475564,
1.2283887863,
-0.2671239674,
-0.6696829796,
-0.0679132789,
0.1683878899,
-0.0038216359,
0.3439259827,
0.5452493429,
0.5067947507,
1.0396175385,
-0.4762101769,
1.1674807072,
0.0685915127,
0.2054289877,
1.4250112772,
-0.5158567429,
0.7703173757,
0.5514799953,
-0.0173434541,
0.3881485164,
1.0016536713,
0.2978463173,
0.2404962927,
0.5304980278,
-0.4593812525,
-0.4579279423,
0.0615545548,
-0.4173273444,
0.3849588633,
0.8455253243,
0.0652066544,
-0.3665674627,
-0.1400441527,
-0.1640691608,
0.4043663442,
0.2535327375,
0.5575976968,
0.0581901148,
-0.5440475345,
0.4249882996,
0.0639694408,
0.5941922665,
-0.6442761421,
0.0732985809,
0.1518725157,
-0.1613260657,
-0.0831034034,
-0.7538121939,
0.4790701866,
-0.3664238453,
0.0830069408,
-0.2528656423,
0.4300642014,
-0.6847117543,
-0.3555768728,
0.268127501,
0.6310774088,
0.3079743087,
-0.1758434474,
-0.8270446062,
0.1562633514,
-0.0711600482,
-0.1018983424,
-0.2110968828,
0.5316523314,
-0.0188681241,
0.7946842313,
0.3760038018,
-0.0947237015,
0.3644688129,
-0.0409923717,
0.5894880891,
-0.5250654817,
-0.1797033101,
-0.9781168699,
0.6790603995,
0.0395809934,
-0.5215414762,
0.420905143,
0.4242234826,
0.5982342362,
0.1693199575,
0.8057147264,
-0.0538295172,
0.1549194753,
-0.5024151802,
0.4753825963,
-0.4831484854,
0.3346006274,
-0.0018451298,
-0.68650949,
-0.3745420277,
0.7532941103,
-0.3782198429,
0.2707131207,
0.6729165912,
0.6660144925,
-0.0585874952,
0.2220029682,
0.2143782675,
0.2402219772,
0.1884876639,
0.6559167504,
1.1700861454,
-0.5140809417,
0.388130635,
-0.1800485402,
0.0568475239,
-0.097449623,
-1.2409228086,
-0.5340551734,
-0.6508355737,
-0.4974394143,
-0.0569877326,
0.1520004272,
0.5745006204,
0.7335387468,
-0.3815661371,
-0.0694049746,
-0.2953874171,
0.3894041181,
-0.1980154514,
-0.1947043985,
0.0591998808,
-0.2746376693,
-0.9439873099,
0.3848354518,
0.0700049847,
0.4373104572,
-0.0470852777,
-0.0780649781,
-0.5016182661,
0.0761321262,
0.1358653605,
0.2564432323,
-0.9964315891,
-0.4458081722,
-0.0726860464,
-0.2633751631,
-0.0408262908,
0.4591606855,
-0.5599461794,
0.8145211935,
0.026709538,
0.5300214291,
0.1405602545,
0.1022175327,
0.6426616311,
-1.0296272039,
0.3448346257,
0.2268951386,
0.2078892738,
0.4884116352,
-0.4320127368,
0.4462070763,
-0.0457820408,
-0.4320452213,
-0.8857637048,
0.5711354017,
-0.7114316821,
-0.3682674766,
0.8729839921,
-0.0451196544,
0.0018932198,
-0.3791060448,
-0.142721504,
0.2886554003,
-0.101245895,
0.7829836607,
1.0940798521,
-0.0662264749,
-0.2501657009,
-0.943205893,
0.6997644901,
0.6155768037,
-0.6974214315,
0.1155255884,
0.3678377569,
0.0940492973,
0.3109119534,
0.5834546685,
0.117505677,
-0.0000622857,
0.0750540346,
0.094983466,
0.2241511792,
0.0875509754,
-0.4371697903,
-0.1409212351,
0.237399444,
-0.1080202013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14395v1 | string2string: A Modern Python Library for String-to-String Algorithms | 2023-04-27T17:57:19 | 2023-04-27T17:57:19 | Mirac Suzgun, Stuart M. Shieber, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | We introduce string2string, an open-source library that offers a
comprehensive suite of efficient algorithms for a broad range of
string-to-string problems. It includes traditional algorithmic solutions as
well as recent advanced neural approaches to tackle various problems in string
alignment, distance measurement, lexical and semantic search, and similarity
analysis -- along with several helpful visualization tools and metrics to
facilitate the interpretation and analysis of these methods. Notable algorithms
featured in the library include the Smith-Waterman algorithm for pairwise local
alignment, the Hirschberg algorithm for global alignment, the Wagner-Fisher
algorithm for edit distance, BARTScore and BERTScore for similarity analysis,
the Knuth-Morris-Pratt algorithm for lexical search, and Faiss for semantic
search. Besides, it wraps existing efficient and widely-used implementations of
certain frameworks and metrics, such as sacreBLEU and ROUGE, whenever it is
appropriate and suitable. Overall, the library aims to provide extensive
coverage and increased flexibility in comparison to existing libraries for
strings. It can be used for many downstream applications, tasks, and problems
in natural-language processing, bioinformatics, and computational social
sciences. It is implemented in Python, easily installable via pip, and
accessible through a simple API. Source code, documentation, and tutorials are
all available on our GitHub page: https://github.com/stanfordnlp/string2string. | [
0.1473276764,
-0.9195001125,
0.3084666729,
0.2734934688,
-0.0709157586,
0.128477633,
-0.5154337883,
-0.8728218675,
0.083670713,
0.1379973888,
-0.2108857334,
-0.3877045214,
-0.2936097682,
0.0052800514,
-0.4970903397,
0.9785146713,
-0.0793456063,
0.0367374346,
-0.045777861,
-0.2473878413,
-0.125707224,
-0.0015365871,
-0.5172672868,
-0.1629625708,
0.8780178428,
0.4707167745,
0.3924469352,
0.6938870549,
0.836658895,
0.17730923,
-0.4464567602,
0.0755039081,
-0.3933612108,
0.2715882957,
-0.3596748114,
-0.3581617475,
-0.1688620448,
0.0318152234,
0.5769242048,
0.4052024484,
-0.0491716824,
0.5347102284,
-0.081052117,
0.8908028603,
-0.3329790533,
-0.2146598101,
-0.6140270233,
-0.1107464358,
-0.5335403681,
-0.0574496388,
0.0818430036,
-1.0029599667,
0.2734353244,
-0.6890824437,
0.0839124247,
0.2193636149,
0.5464422107,
0.0568410419,
-0.3177753687,
-0.8057370782,
-0.2991574407,
0.6221320629,
-0.4698052406,
0.23001872,
0.242694214,
0.2942369282,
-0.3709654212,
-0.8248565793,
-0.1505262703,
0.0726598129,
0.0889503583,
-0.0422333553,
0.0577094853,
0.0696066692,
0.1784555912,
0.4192041755,
-0.904512167,
0.1870708913,
-0.5582121611,
-0.0314198025,
0.4690902829,
-0.2586603463,
0.4222968221,
-0.0489763357,
-0.2978532314,
0.2987265587,
-0.4722599983,
0.3306258917,
0.7155502439,
0.0958200842,
0.1778177619,
0.7755577564,
0.2364767641,
0.7517474294,
-0.2399035543,
0.285309732,
-0.2109355927,
-0.4751809239,
0.3451196849,
0.4817813039,
0.6981809139,
0.3170874417,
0.1978338361,
-0.0067716832,
-0.0730259195,
0.032103505,
0.1911221147,
-0.6788620353,
-0.543977499,
0.2793376744,
-0.6060529947,
-0.2079620361,
0.0685599744,
-0.8561951518,
-0.4765996933,
-0.360324502,
0.3083271682,
-0.5856544375,
-0.385777384,
-0.2460330874,
-0.576812923,
0.1821510941,
0.048253689,
-1.1439197063,
0.5578608513,
1.2225731611,
1.1597434282,
-0.1330021918,
-0.1980342418,
-0.2947538197,
0.1305887848,
-0.4539100826,
0.7574534416,
-0.668689847,
0.2413487583,
-0.1299836338,
-0.1274093091,
0.2760151327,
-0.3551624417,
0.5080344081,
-0.350710541,
0.2689647675,
-0.3138805926,
-0.7647109032,
-0.6652169228,
-0.1546993107,
-0.6275955439,
1.2861322165,
0.4472552836,
-0.9152905941,
-0.099404186,
-0.8112078309,
-0.5163026452,
0.1046188623,
0.0904134139,
-0.4752984047,
0.573887229,
-0.2993702888,
-0.3418835402,
-0.4860401154,
0.0401664339,
-0.4141607881,
-1.0798902512,
0.1422655433,
-0.1191941798,
0.8984835148,
0.3404454887,
-0.2084909678,
0.3697937429,
-0.5815889835,
0.2712940276,
0.1849013418,
-0.2532679141,
-0.85099262,
0.1512953043,
0.4895740151,
-0.3173516691,
0.6878593564,
-0.5175030828,
0.3983085454,
-0.7398595214,
0.8626351953,
0.771533668,
-0.5898779631,
0.4492357075,
0.1431609988,
-0.0078980606,
-0.3445544839,
-0.2049177438,
-0.2279132009,
-0.7699195147,
-0.1842009872,
0.1095045805,
0.3707642257,
0.6099027395,
-0.2443268001,
0.4957888722,
0.0519607775,
-0.5149063468,
-0.5182026625,
0.1661398858,
0.2524414062,
0.1526013166,
0.2405385226,
-0.3347968757,
-0.9115953445,
-0.4949281812,
-0.7466855645,
-0.2237846255,
-0.0082019018,
0.1838359833,
0.4105284512,
-0.0015012593,
1.0368130207,
-0.3027384579,
-0.1409002244,
0.2965307832,
0.0828670412,
0.3788066208,
0.746416986,
0.3697420359,
-0.6999240518,
-0.4247359037,
0.3766723871,
-0.7060809731,
0.114419587,
0.3217830062,
-0.0536811762,
0.5058038235,
-0.0508370213,
-0.1932495981,
0.0913853869,
0.6941527128,
-0.6474206448,
0.7990528941,
-0.3241157532,
-0.0546837635,
-0.9909490347,
0.5020727515,
0.1226872802,
-0.0626541823,
-0.5435494184,
0.2070411146,
0.1355813295,
-0.0957941562,
-0.3702535331,
0.5009804368,
-0.2174266726,
-0.6965665221,
-0.1964713335,
-0.0355315208,
-0.1248025894,
0.1753689945,
-0.0387393907,
1.2517491579,
0.450659126,
-0.4095234871,
0.8696201444,
0.2875455916,
-0.5814561844,
0.4568681419,
-0.6212638617,
0.2815099955,
0.2060736567,
0.1591361463,
-0.8729261756,
-0.2566484213,
0.4219946265,
-0.5734593272,
-0.0140949404,
-0.0134801557,
-0.4807965457,
-0.4480598271,
-0.5065108538,
0.8254457116,
0.5849039555,
-0.7843149304,
-0.0482554212,
0.2716856003,
-0.1441336423,
-0.2528421879,
-0.6288868189,
0.3292779326,
-0.4133177102,
-0.601837337,
0.3261958659,
0.0573278293,
-0.1563458145,
0.2686548233,
-0.3324343264,
-0.3544272184,
0.3322321475,
-0.1182567105,
-0.0315077938,
-0.269012183,
0.0172478426,
0.1668909043,
-0.2797400653,
-0.040056441,
-1.1064059734,
0.2181279957,
-0.4506550729,
-0.1167014092,
-0.4736996889,
0.4990153015,
-0.0866973475,
-0.293430537,
-0.0707280859,
0.8381770849,
-0.4663384259,
0.1430655271,
-0.2266799659,
-0.1486103833,
-0.4428088963,
0.3857454956,
-0.0301061329,
-1.0914846659,
0.2990471125,
-0.3824677765,
0.244420886,
0.0382343829,
0.3825043142,
-0.6690926552,
0.8602641821,
0.3488687575,
0.2716110647,
0.626639843,
0.1808872819,
0.1775508374,
-0.8352780938,
-0.3555125892,
-0.7096284628,
-0.6737841964,
-0.791683495,
-0.467988044,
-0.0885617808,
0.5669554472,
-0.5267145038,
0.8229382038,
-1.0758377314,
0.8074982166,
0.7585391402,
-0.4277679026,
-0.1024462208,
0.5282028913,
0.0169161912,
-0.1719565541,
-0.5255866051,
-0.1937101185,
0.8681513071,
0.35320732,
0.6819292903,
0.2906541824,
0.5940220356,
0.2812483907,
-0.408061415,
-0.9808613658,
0.2453402728,
-0.4327670336,
-0.366776973,
-0.2456226945,
-0.4796365499,
-1.0925688744,
-0.0375329778,
0.1954368353,
-1.2806119919,
-0.2658232152,
-0.0017241868,
-0.0819633156,
0.3639210761,
-0.3764497638,
0.8008791208,
-0.4238213599,
-0.5375700593,
-0.3013373911,
-0.7264666557,
0.4618964195,
0.0791188106,
-0.0081903124,
-0.043394722,
-0.009184869,
1.0339115858,
0.0163685158,
0.2477676868,
-0.0932375416,
-0.4882550836,
0.5456100106,
0.1717232168,
0.4636421502,
0.1615095586,
-0.1734830737,
0.51249367,
0.6242437959,
-0.353582412,
-0.5687583685,
0.866199553,
-0.4577395916,
-0.1848201007,
-0.6353180408,
-0.4729269147,
0.4387457669,
0.1066931486,
-0.100625962,
0.5335283875,
0.1149271056,
0.1410184205,
0.6449806094,
-0.3226667941,
0.4063807428,
0.2514863312,
-0.531511426,
-0.8327476978,
1.5118910074,
0.0291817244,
-0.2672300041,
0.1931519359,
0.3779424727,
-0.666303277,
-0.2950671613,
-0.4512810707,
0.2518926859,
-0.3396258354,
0.0551101081,
0.012396954,
-0.002193281,
-0.3571526408,
-0.0438938774,
-0.2595840991,
-0.7469335794,
-0.3566344082,
0.2353281677,
0.647202611,
0.6248328686,
-0.1363942176,
0.0908907354,
-0.6810253263,
0.2550637424,
-0.1038135514,
0.7238646746,
-0.1965884119,
-0.0289555751,
-0.4451769888,
-0.1677644849,
-0.3081776202,
-0.7475469708,
-0.1570478082,
0.3858150244,
0.0652777478,
0.442284435,
-0.2256157547,
0.6681880951,
-0.4918130934,
0.8519054055,
0.4835192263,
-0.9077735543,
0.5613217354,
-0.3806936741,
0.0930760503,
0.4400348961,
0.0392892919,
-1.1804410219,
-0.1316851974,
-0.1740513742,
-0.7619607449,
0.9197131991,
0.4168226421,
-0.3012413979,
0.2140758336,
0.5080003738,
0.2609190643,
0.0786647275,
-0.245620966,
-0.3286024928,
-0.264105469,
-0.6472414732,
0.0405042768,
-0.2917855382,
-0.0884950534,
-0.3016038239,
0.5030301213,
-0.441647917,
0.5812719464,
-0.0422097594,
0.0321475938,
-0.1391929835,
0.0821468011,
0.7371522188,
0.5610286593,
-0.3545950651,
0.25629583,
0.015299337,
-0.4313283861,
0.2236822993,
0.1311805844,
-0.4109618962,
-0.101776734,
0.2411357611,
0.5825347304,
0.2484615147,
-0.6886854172,
0.3501920402,
0.0562795587,
-0.2491686642,
-0.4740944803,
-0.1063239127,
0.2505759001,
0.2040032297,
0.2606569827,
0.1473792493,
0.4269067347,
-0.4216415882,
0.352686435,
0.3812235594,
-1.0219438076,
-0.5889670253,
0.6852200627,
0.1695691943,
-0.764472425,
0.6059035063,
-0.0387267806,
-0.5507611036,
0.6570628881,
0.753988266,
0.8062641025,
0.0083555738,
0.1310882419,
0.437741071,
-0.0219507124,
-0.3099631965,
0.5579372644,
-0.2778753936,
0.0533827506,
-0.2381471843,
-0.7227005363,
-0.1634887904,
-0.3244962394,
-0.4298358858,
0.1750050932,
-0.4213693738,
0.1108767018,
-0.4390596151,
0.2665071189,
-0.0477241352,
-0.2753584087,
0.1031088307,
1.0827711821,
-0.152013123,
0.9156152606,
0.8889704347,
-0.0437992737,
-0.3473680019,
-0.2739751041,
0.3033255637,
-0.3505754173,
0.3850749135,
0.7319700122,
0.2255124748,
0.1784204841,
-0.393550694,
-1.0711491108,
0.9659010172,
0.0996954069,
-0.7533115149,
-0.3720552027,
0.1235693023,
0.4533343911,
0.1402280182,
0.5111714602,
0.9515221715,
0.8185830116,
-0.0804024041,
-0.7249704003,
-0.1031331792,
-0.2320074737,
0.2564170957,
0.4694545269,
-0.4676111937,
0.5643798709,
-0.0181857776,
-0.2334292531,
0.6596838832,
0.8518181443,
0.3864467144,
0.5923010707,
0.1595282704,
0.5076741576,
0.975135088,
-0.3928417861,
0.6305660605,
-0.3454214036,
0.6113721132,
0.9288475513,
-0.1031706706,
0.672388792,
0.7184425592,
-0.2956184745,
0.3271532357,
0.9156201482,
-0.4123575091,
0.3911485672,
0.6322226524,
-0.1017477661,
-0.0441593602,
-0.1511809826,
-0.3165804744,
0.1620888561,
0.2533464134,
0.0691556931,
-0.3282044232,
-0.2571900487,
-0.4440174401,
0.3201449811,
-0.1968155652,
0.9276856184,
0.2930119038,
-0.5582231283,
0.4848815203,
0.0863931999,
0.9163586497,
-0.6769095063,
-0.18943654,
0.1603027135,
0.1790164858,
-0.3768989444,
-0.9523841739,
0.3995685875,
-0.1763973236,
0.0758743361,
0.0428853072,
0.762182951,
-0.6081826091,
-0.4796118736,
0.3988663852,
-0.1839440167,
0.3910324574,
0.1256661713,
-0.9801567197,
-0.0305686686,
-0.2274148017,
-0.0980762467,
0.2533129752,
0.1521459371,
-0.238749668,
0.3586679399,
0.7516914606,
0.1789445132,
0.0054064016,
-0.2370072156,
0.374579668,
-0.8944766521,
-0.4348836243,
-0.7029423118,
0.1201044023,
-0.0395811833,
-0.1237384826,
0.791041851,
0.9944483638,
0.7530872226,
0.1552123725,
0.6594192386,
-0.2021548003,
0.3888697922,
-0.4232721925,
0.8384301066,
-0.739664793,
-0.0104390569,
-0.3068959713,
-1.2918531895,
-0.2102950215,
0.6534596682,
0.3317352533,
-0.3032949865,
0.6968359351,
0.7661852241,
0.0351563245,
0.377052635,
-0.2037389874,
-0.269866854,
0.4778191745,
0.8740983009,
0.876454711,
-0.6181614399,
0.4790811241,
0.1304705441,
0.0055538276,
-0.2639067173,
-0.5694503784,
-0.4830848873,
-0.7264951468,
-0.1183763295,
-0.3448920846,
0.2947416902,
1.2428190708,
0.3488900959,
-0.8390179276,
-0.5570361614,
-0.4712706804,
0.4064511061,
-0.8115420341,
-0.2124585509,
0.5272004604,
-0.3612306118,
-0.7881283164,
0.6088539362,
0.287804395,
-0.0435057096,
-0.0543087423,
-0.3178960085,
-0.2049669772,
-0.1309042424,
0.3613579273,
0.3440862596,
-0.9717713594,
-0.446680814,
-0.3269284368,
-0.1349975765,
0.1049202383,
0.869954586,
-0.5246132016,
0.3704467118,
0.8749009371,
0.7680525184,
0.1035945788,
0.266926527,
0.447332412,
-0.3585059047,
-0.0586696304,
0.1759530455,
0.0033768076,
0.1879672855,
-0.1300606728,
0.666446507,
0.4362199605,
-0.5228532553,
-0.7837308645,
0.4282628894,
-0.990424335,
-0.5878507495,
1.2554411888,
-0.2285746634,
-0.6414313316,
0.007192729,
-0.5621207356,
0.4093176425,
-0.551450789,
0.5107795596,
0.5107940435,
0.1675821394,
-0.072058104,
-0.117039226,
0.7127871513,
0.3212153912,
-0.5568141937,
0.2817044556,
0.3105516434,
0.3901353478,
0.0573171303,
-0.0054500387,
0.0225338228,
0.4526986182,
-0.12411578,
-0.0343990214,
-0.4073976576,
-0.455203414,
-0.6889114976,
0.1880698353,
-0.2387920022,
0.1992399991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14391v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14391v4 | Energy-based Models are Zero-Shot Planners for Compositional Scene Rearrangement | 2023-04-27T17:55:13 | 2024-01-23T15:52:28 | Nikolaos Gkanatsios, Ayush Jain, Zhou Xian, Yunchu Zhang, Christopher Atkeson, Katerina Fragkiadaki | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Language is compositional; an instruction can express multiple relation
constraints to hold among objects in a scene that a robot is tasked to
rearrange. Our focus in this work is an instructable scene-rearranging
framework that generalizes to longer instructions and to spatial concept
compositions never seen at training time. We propose to represent
language-instructed spatial concepts with energy functions over relative object
arrangements. A language parser maps instructions to corresponding energy
functions and an open-vocabulary visual-language model grounds their arguments
to relevant objects in the scene. We generate goal scene configurations by
gradient descent on the sum of energy functions, one per language predicate in
the instruction. Local vision-based policies then re-locate objects to the
inferred goal locations. We test our model on established instruction-guided
manipulation benchmarks, as well as benchmarks of compositional instructions we
introduce. We show our model can execute highly compositional instructions
zero-shot in simulation and in the real world. It outperforms
language-to-action reactive policies and Large Language Model planners by a
large margin, especially for long instructions that involve compositions of
multiple spatial concepts. Simulation and real-world robot execution videos, as
well as our code and datasets are publicly available on our website:
https://ebmplanner.github.io. | [
0.1978096515,
-0.6883806586,
0.8184558749,
0.1124625802,
0.3250471652,
-0.0239076577,
-0.2210972756,
-0.1737045497,
0.1795902103,
0.6619574428,
-0.6895820498,
-0.6419227123,
-0.2737236023,
-0.2564797699,
-0.257471472,
0.5854302049,
-0.1325417012,
-0.0634462535,
-0.1758818179,
-0.0765515268,
-0.6415620446,
-0.1291905642,
0.206486702,
-0.4804680049,
0.5805850029,
0.4320694208,
0.6329315901,
0.8876312375,
0.5318808556,
0.3220999539,
0.1961149573,
-0.1223663688,
-0.4077478349,
0.0604467541,
-0.4633622169,
-0.4930236638,
-0.1101560742,
-0.0438678972,
0.5624845624,
0.8894802332,
-0.5166953802,
-0.1929565966,
-0.5288882256,
0.5207383037,
-1.2037962675,
0.2111004889,
-0.6380431652,
0.361313194,
0.3851590753,
-0.0675507486,
-0.5276690125,
-0.0031089725,
-0.0785557851,
-0.6463674307,
0.0717628226,
-0.2066147327,
0.8933488727,
0.3304159939,
-0.1910615861,
0.0447115786,
-0.9487528801,
0.9874077439,
-0.3145923018,
0.4433971643,
0.1168339849,
0.4997710586,
-0.0958720595,
-0.387937665,
-0.6846259832,
0.131160602,
-0.1548521519,
0.301387161,
-0.1643944234,
0.3014172614,
0.3491954505,
-0.1728557646,
-0.6567664742,
0.0493512936,
-0.2862381041,
0.2195609808,
0.4503810704,
0.4618094265,
0.4974030554,
-0.1292998642,
-0.5173822045,
-0.3041912913,
-0.6373887658,
-0.1806230098,
0.2344461679,
0.4384789467,
-0.2995126843,
0.8254696727,
-0.4437817633,
0.8210387826,
0.1093268469,
-0.0169999432,
0.0308155008,
-0.0753404945,
-0.3817864358,
0.1429692805,
0.3980236053,
0.6590189934,
0.0275052357,
-0.2175666243,
-0.1127425954,
0.1708472818,
0.3366412222,
-1.0729587078,
-0.506934166,
0.2558884621,
-0.0674363598,
0.1381612271,
-0.1115695834,
-0.5577346087,
0.0762675181,
-0.451433748,
0.5391771793,
-0.4536120594,
-0.0040809228,
0.5949303508,
-0.1498183906,
0.3547147214,
0.2800858319,
-1.0669199228,
0.0460903831,
0.7326780558,
0.7116935849,
0.3381234705,
-0.4399504364,
-0.1709068865,
0.8333528042,
-0.3226521015,
0.8177417517,
-1.1056393385,
-0.3895161748,
0.1980877221,
0.1843608469,
-0.5309709907,
-0.1389604211,
-0.2383534759,
-0.3481723666,
0.5760005713,
-0.1555178165,
-0.6609118581,
-0.2720333338,
0.1309146583,
-0.4328562021,
0.6079208255,
0.11010243,
-0.2860544622,
0.1901197881,
-0.9435232878,
-0.6042041183,
-0.018044088,
-0.19674851,
-0.1268354654,
-0.0157109983,
-0.0506362729,
0.4055186212,
0.2426030189,
0.1106091216,
-0.0365677327,
-0.1999742836,
-0.0868867934,
-0.1255581826,
0.2730890214,
0.1783175021,
-0.1725776494,
0.4142415524,
-0.8291066289,
-0.0138777709,
0.0687564835,
-0.1001696736,
-0.1127170697,
0.2259684652,
-0.4269195199,
0.1670458913,
0.3867157996,
-0.6326318979,
0.1736574322,
-0.559646368,
0.0779634342,
0.4527479112,
0.1026322246,
1.1143488884,
-0.3131076992,
0.7089218497,
-0.3077251613,
0.1258901358,
-0.608114779,
-0.1139701381,
-0.6097576618,
-0.1977442652,
-0.4582960904,
0.8062109351,
-0.7855674624,
0.5166164041,
-0.2380048484,
-0.4371688068,
0.0390018113,
-0.3010828197,
0.553486228,
0.6266909242,
0.3675686419,
0.1993068159,
-0.2281574607,
-0.8679519296,
0.057066109,
0.0732982233,
0.0399555005,
0.0434895009,
0.5067923665,
0.1818043292,
0.8036683798,
-0.9515353441,
0.1363951415,
-0.1137906238,
-0.0356802531,
0.0090020867,
0.5333932042,
0.679638207,
-0.551599443,
-0.4176608026,
0.1458578259,
-0.8615798354,
0.0534397028,
-0.3475796878,
-0.647126019,
-0.0948298275,
0.2984156013,
-0.8073240519,
0.4782647192,
0.3078798652,
-0.1400441378,
0.3876619935,
-0.1468084604,
-0.0162871834,
-0.9717783332,
-0.1304233372,
-0.1335656792,
-0.0475622974,
-0.668432653,
0.4231524169,
-0.265932709,
-0.4968925416,
-0.7112849355,
0.3218074739,
-0.370788157,
-0.247653529,
-0.3489188254,
-0.0792259946,
0.2386217713,
0.7956489921,
0.4288567901,
0.4302572012,
0.5382396579,
-0.652990222,
0.172954917,
0.34062168,
-0.3921210766,
0.5584689379,
-0.4080832601,
0.1705948263,
-0.2454448789,
0.2289056778,
-0.7296933532,
-0.3790621758,
0.48896873,
0.0041873688,
0.4361892641,
-0.2400834262,
-0.224127695,
0.1337025166,
0.0557964481,
0.2648661137,
0.3349976242,
-0.2991799712,
0.6991897225,
0.3132429123,
0.121777758,
-0.6741473079,
-0.5894932747,
-0.2313355953,
-0.0868484303,
-0.5611800551,
0.3867375553,
-0.0370909795,
-0.4198256433,
0.3043929338,
-0.0738385022,
0.0030823946,
-0.1829231232,
0.2876341343,
0.0970117226,
0.0678684115,
0.1167550236,
0.0275922287,
0.1200342402,
0.0399931595,
-0.3958276808,
0.6929444075,
0.1380114108,
-0.4555693567,
-0.3155709207,
0.5642458797,
0.3970267773,
-0.0178569406,
0.857811749,
0.2791543603,
-0.4357252121,
-0.1519089788,
-0.0290892478,
-0.1225093827,
-0.4948642254,
0.6543022394,
-0.3517549038,
-0.6356179714,
0.4446806014,
-0.0301840734,
0.6047773957,
0.0672186241,
0.4076665342,
-0.2772773206,
0.7888192534,
0.667634964,
0.4425863326,
1.0506228209,
-0.6449070573,
0.2201852202,
-0.6690357924,
-0.4717956185,
-0.2970851362,
-0.6965343356,
-0.3468225598,
-0.8200312257,
0.38204211,
-0.0896354988,
-0.558927834,
0.6280796528,
-0.4607419968,
0.9735863209,
0.0210996065,
0.1836470217,
-0.4312090576,
0.1185215861,
0.0668343008,
0.0574200116,
-0.8619466424,
-0.3550987244,
0.5971651077,
-0.1084627062,
0.6892022491,
0.0306308866,
0.7665305138,
-0.0470669791,
0.038050998,
-0.9222825766,
0.8384525776,
-0.1674373597,
-0.4759152532,
-0.4333588779,
-0.3228706419,
-0.9990639687,
0.4190063775,
0.0201203674,
-0.9009557962,
0.26829198,
0.0036761118,
-0.4436884224,
0.5722518563,
-0.9059233069,
0.9017034173,
-0.4272768199,
-0.6161727905,
-0.5828713179,
-0.5678613782,
0.016406687,
0.3804053068,
0.1590021551,
-0.4539989233,
0.1339858919,
0.2508989871,
-0.7198203802,
0.9682452679,
-0.4948805869,
-0.2242945433,
0.4518974721,
0.4933195114,
0.4831241071,
-0.6013599634,
-0.0837866664,
0.1398098767,
-0.1970175505,
-0.5025733113,
-0.9676983356,
0.6328293681,
-0.4277451038,
-0.6777176261,
-0.144724384,
-0.6959228516,
0.0590407029,
0.0264533125,
0.0508744866,
0.4079999328,
-0.188793838,
-0.0728843957,
0.2692322433,
-0.5078040957,
0.6908931136,
0.7351122499,
-0.2364186496,
-0.1414637268,
1.1703696251,
-0.0329046696,
0.5513916016,
1.1572364569,
0.2250588238,
-0.1767427325,
0.0163466409,
-0.5268825889,
-0.2410868555,
-0.7513168454,
-0.1823940575,
-0.3877283037,
-0.0158852283,
0.0082703214,
-0.8033551574,
-0.5340480804,
-0.624433279,
-0.159884572,
-0.343318224,
0.2291087657,
0.5159347653,
-0.318181932,
0.5112044811,
-0.5134956837,
0.0695641786,
0.1528998166,
0.1174944714,
-0.1407672167,
-0.3412477076,
-0.6040297747,
0.1576755941,
-0.1957289577,
-0.6915189624,
0.4546457529,
0.1799240857,
0.1854859442,
0.3274628818,
-0.1736610383,
0.7083157301,
-0.7021071911,
0.6293110847,
0.668189764,
-0.6814906001,
0.7474105358,
-0.6268617511,
0.6354898214,
0.2962016761,
0.1190767884,
-0.4066232443,
-0.0231750384,
-0.3159959614,
-0.7257318497,
0.6054064631,
0.0008621991,
0.4582617879,
-0.1549717933,
0.3366078436,
-0.02743892,
0.2660487592,
-0.7024915218,
0.0659658015,
-0.3087121248,
-0.1174479797,
0.3257739246,
0.0810289755,
-0.1061042547,
-0.1563843936,
0.4926394522,
-0.2361313254,
0.4104384184,
-0.0504377298,
0.0331654064,
-0.4191939533,
0.2383494675,
0.8139908314,
0.5571559668,
-0.2279065102,
-0.1137860566,
-0.0831389874,
-0.0101095792,
0.3071145713,
-0.212885052,
-0.3511288166,
-0.1853527129,
0.3556827009,
0.8025094867,
0.8522664905,
-0.5105409026,
0.2703837752,
0.2383372188,
-0.1086198539,
-0.2165755033,
0.3703788519,
-0.1109361649,
0.2636069059,
-0.2854346335,
0.2387764007,
-0.0054009524,
-0.6234220862,
0.1661289781,
0.3055124879,
-0.302615881,
-0.7153804898,
0.544911027,
0.2290374935,
-0.2647132277,
0.4435646534,
-0.4033700526,
-0.4010716081,
0.5789787769,
0.5510124564,
0.9307559133,
-0.1150198281,
0.5225892663,
0.462590307,
0.0706003085,
0.1414923072,
0.6518216133,
-0.1839761436,
-1.0917742252,
-0.6543090343,
-0.6633391976,
-0.4251135588,
-0.3237510026,
-0.5195156932,
0.0508189499,
-0.7836657763,
0.1792129129,
-0.0694886073,
-0.3707047403,
-0.5657324195,
-0.0073613939,
0.1637564749,
0.4753188789,
-0.6168857217,
0.6482980847,
0.8291460276,
-0.3724987507,
-0.8038911819,
-0.0280306097,
-0.1928265244,
-1.0092382431,
0.7531898022,
0.1293528527,
-0.5879091024,
-0.249403581,
-0.9722551703,
-0.8101911545,
0.9913384914,
0.6776884198,
-0.9859340191,
-0.1445131153,
0.1445264965,
0.3376590014,
-0.3162789047,
-0.0624282323,
0.1115410626,
0.4499725103,
0.5165369511,
-0.4431498051,
-0.3257912397,
0.0433502868,
-0.187635541,
0.6037192941,
-1.0417119265,
0.6791319251,
-0.3700658679,
-0.4556455016,
0.2726908028,
0.5800842643,
0.0349502489,
0.3721323907,
0.2843651175,
0.8965576887,
0.4742649198,
0.0263876934,
1.1635648012,
-0.6644695997,
0.1615198255,
1.250197053,
-0.7172261477,
0.8305490613,
0.1850743741,
-0.0747209936,
0.8797553182,
0.0825685933,
0.0783640817,
0.8885466456,
0.1992069185,
-0.4645872414,
-0.3897776604,
-0.4711921513,
-0.0779956579,
0.8193315268,
0.480038017,
-0.0934113041,
-0.34032318,
-0.0378543213,
-0.0013424235,
0.3488470018,
-0.2118349969,
0.5630146265,
-0.1222784147,
-0.6627590656,
0.1829387844,
0.1773236543,
0.0940306261,
-0.6368285418,
-0.3229970038,
0.0377550088,
0.2292574495,
-0.1777932793,
-0.8680630922,
0.4361593127,
-0.2172640264,
-0.3130832613,
-0.5432075262,
0.6596439481,
-0.59281528,
-0.4323222637,
0.0911456794,
0.3836123049,
0.2127370536,
0.1516857147,
-0.5453309417,
-0.1806110889,
0.0057936613,
0.0717336535,
0.2901922762,
0.4459178746,
0.083789818,
0.4675705433,
0.4512276351,
-0.1766652763,
-0.0151837571,
0.3154608309,
0.5609289408,
-0.6819754839,
-0.4970396757,
-0.6242662072,
0.3934780359,
0.2863770127,
0.0885792226,
0.450846523,
0.5721072555,
1.1136015654,
-0.2119825929,
0.3778939843,
0.1032376662,
-0.1302467734,
-0.8624178767,
0.4199556112,
-0.4332052469,
0.0153996767,
-0.2124846131,
-1.0494431257,
-0.2891998291,
0.9080883265,
-0.5795968175,
-0.0407422483,
0.3559984863,
0.8225498796,
0.1032563075,
-0.0421108715,
0.6664566994,
-0.1350861192,
0.3213279247,
0.6836861372,
1.0146394968,
-0.0699330866,
0.1761461347,
-0.4981010556,
0.3082464635,
0.0984001458,
-0.6905705333,
-0.5513691306,
-0.3809242845,
-0.539224565,
0.2459554672,
0.1344226301,
0.9966028333,
1.1318503618,
-0.5420354009,
-0.3429015875,
-0.2555663884,
0.1151895747,
-0.1682031751,
-0.2717244625,
0.1552021503,
-0.0114693353,
-0.8039001822,
0.9479285479,
0.8643692136,
-0.0466823429,
-0.1566957235,
-0.1808200628,
-0.4290226996,
0.1493331045,
0.8955931067,
0.4321745634,
-0.4178160429,
-0.5276371241,
0.0223833788,
0.1454903632,
0.0726379603,
0.8954220414,
-0.6603432894,
0.5841732621,
0.4048223794,
0.2559291124,
0.3986585438,
0.092400454,
0.6085399389,
-1.2620807886,
0.4410227835,
0.1273908317,
0.581066668,
0.275203526,
-0.3878489435,
0.5110049248,
0.2640483677,
-0.3105814159,
-0.4437266886,
0.6543488503,
-0.8406919837,
-0.4670894742,
1.0284764767,
-0.1563257128,
-0.4677141309,
0.537350893,
0.044956699,
0.115313068,
-0.4910660088,
0.5522425175,
0.4478757083,
-0.630971849,
-0.2307188064,
-0.2115288377,
-0.1018009484,
0.4493772089,
-0.7804573178,
0.01433188,
0.9882026911,
0.0464081578,
0.4091963172,
0.2099628448,
0.0626799166,
0.047723867,
0.2097247839,
0.4340184629,
-0.0746414736,
-0.7641456723,
-0.2202960551,
0.1957189441,
-0.5731683969,
-0.6071461439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14364v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14364v2 | CONSCENDI: A Contrastive and Scenario-Guided Distillation Approach to Guardrail Models for Virtual Assistants | 2023-04-27T17:39:11 | 2024-04-03T23:57:12 | Albert Yu Sun, Varun Nair, Elliot Schumacher, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A wave of new task-based virtual assistants has been fueled by increasingly
powerful large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4 (OpenAI, 2023). A major
challenge in deploying LLM-based virtual conversational assistants in real
world settings is ensuring they operate within what is admissible for the task.
To overcome this challenge, the designers of these virtual assistants rely on
an independent guardrail system that verifies the virtual assistant's output
aligns with the constraints required for the task. However, relying on commonly
used, prompt-based guardrails can be difficult to engineer correctly and
comprehensively. To address these challenges, we propose CONSCENDI. We use
CONSCENDI to exhaustively generate training data with two key LLM-powered
components: scenario-augmented generation and contrastive training examples.
When generating conversational data, we generate a set of rule-breaking
scenarios, which enumerate a diverse set of high-level ways a rule can be
violated. This scenario-guided approach produces a diverse training set and
provides chatbot designers greater control. To generate contrastive examples,
we prompt the LLM to alter conversations with violations into acceptable
conversations to enable fine-grained distinctions. We then use this data,
generated by CONSCENDI, to train a smaller model. We find that CONSCENDI
results in guardrail models that improve over baselines in multiple dialogue
domains. | [
-0.5490041971,
-0.7107095718,
0.6499649286,
0.1697398722,
-0.390265733,
0.2124893814,
0.0295245387,
-0.2906166017,
0.0839145109,
0.5080550909,
-0.7981668115,
-0.291672945,
-0.5671417117,
0.0066880886,
-0.2559164464,
0.8819141388,
0.025053516,
0.0856795534,
-0.1291640401,
0.0536928177,
-0.812753737,
-0.6318744421,
-0.8075634241,
-0.4372343719,
0.2064429224,
0.451528728,
0.3294360936,
0.2954256535,
0.415730685,
0.4055580795,
-0.3328826129,
0.3770689964,
-0.4704861343,
0.1287645251,
-0.1534465998,
-0.4561370611,
-0.3342126906,
-0.1271990389,
0.055455599,
0.4564678371,
-0.254522413,
-0.3460752964,
0.4070201516,
0.1500724703,
-0.5109527111,
0.2094595134,
-0.692751348,
-0.0590477698,
-0.0319787078,
-0.1033641174,
-0.420797199,
-0.1872050911,
0.4402839541,
-0.7710989714,
0.2230858058,
0.0819510594,
0.7453666925,
0.2144297957,
-0.5725101233,
-0.4101047218,
-0.9879394174,
0.7536523342,
-0.7188949585,
0.0668353289,
0.0963039845,
0.553465724,
-0.4392669499,
-0.7134690285,
-0.8754357696,
-0.4537631273,
-0.2618365884,
0.2867414951,
-0.3698386848,
0.2383485287,
0.2034190446,
0.2169424593,
-0.400136441,
0.3428153396,
-0.2754155397,
-0.0368987322,
0.1900727898,
0.489990145,
-0.1581496,
0.0134299686,
-0.2523750067,
-0.3914586902,
-0.6080771685,
-0.0270085763,
0.4343463182,
0.3908036053,
-0.3969400823,
0.1759473383,
-0.2912787795,
0.307684809,
0.457234472,
-0.0486343801,
0.1444729269,
-0.3331410289,
-0.157559827,
-0.0802115574,
0.7114803791,
0.5523656011,
0.2212449014,
-0.0763587952,
0.0778022707,
0.3823716342,
0.4969987273,
-0.8717292547,
-0.4564245045,
0.344733566,
-0.0589357428,
-0.5103330612,
-0.3072320223,
-0.941888392,
-0.6312840581,
-0.5872427225,
0.252433449,
-0.4819641113,
-0.2200583965,
0.0769433379,
-0.2831396759,
0.1808908433,
0.5178753734,
-0.9404084086,
0.5168380141,
0.841137588,
0.9010791183,
-0.1829143316,
-0.139635548,
-0.490098685,
-0.0377629362,
-0.1901142895,
0.6227533817,
-0.6117922068,
-0.9190249443,
0.2551036179,
-0.0486981198,
0.2342208773,
-0.4967598021,
0.7819654942,
-0.2643688917,
0.3777606487,
-0.005681227,
-0.2459911555,
0.1647335738,
0.6306650639,
-0.4512137175,
0.3521997631,
-0.170464769,
-0.7123884559,
0.3343833685,
-0.4352386296,
-0.1342552751,
-0.234503746,
-0.3441289365,
-0.6298478246,
0.0165017471,
0.2422488779,
0.1464472115,
-0.1468451619,
0.3121766746,
-0.4499408901,
-0.0469836406,
0.0134093538,
-0.6732729673,
0.6145207882,
0.3167221248,
-0.0133301504,
0.2042654753,
-0.6054677367,
-0.1873048842,
-0.2327321917,
0.042030476,
-0.4914152026,
0.0534976274,
-0.0963481888,
0.2422474027,
0.1701316386,
-0.6440597773,
0.0939788967,
-0.3734693825,
0.2221360356,
1.1031466722,
0.2222374678,
0.3187022507,
-0.3024259508,
0.4788764119,
0.3305535913,
0.4951181114,
0.0023868924,
-0.1234315932,
-0.8934932947,
-0.277597338,
-0.0659385473,
0.4211388826,
-0.9804952145,
0.2774476707,
-0.2649637163,
-0.8280569315,
-0.2070384473,
-0.2400180101,
0.6461716294,
0.8205204606,
0.1900081187,
-0.160109058,
-0.8217226267,
-0.9331144691,
0.3065439761,
-0.333740145,
0.0360521749,
0.1013152897,
0.4534417987,
-0.0362648144,
0.7107790112,
-0.5788112283,
-0.2144215852,
-0.3270689249,
0.1603209525,
0.3266738951,
0.5606386065,
0.4278311133,
-0.9150645733,
-0.2935906053,
0.1023269594,
-0.6434327364,
-0.136654377,
-0.1599566191,
-0.3399159014,
-0.4884783328,
0.4482246339,
-0.5092504025,
0.3152468801,
0.4439641237,
-0.1454312503,
0.6348263025,
-0.374552995,
0.2531438172,
-1.5383782387,
-0.0847631693,
0.3248139024,
-0.0452114902,
-0.9860717058,
-0.1579742134,
-0.3965318799,
0.0035635841,
-0.6305885911,
0.52159971,
-0.2364559025,
0.4252583385,
-0.4261538386,
0.1526893228,
-0.0091514857,
0.7533447742,
0.312060684,
0.5797529817,
0.4577881992,
-0.8712725639,
0.2234820724,
0.694203794,
-0.0310737975,
1.129820466,
-0.8611064553,
-0.0351484939,
0.0536804982,
0.3825461268,
-0.890773356,
-0.1537038982,
0.2160359919,
-0.0253428221,
0.0604421943,
-0.366030246,
-0.1422607154,
-0.1666650772,
-0.318415314,
0.0593521744,
0.5826579332,
-0.6972174644,
0.6204996109,
0.5927304626,
-0.0721808299,
-0.5547801852,
-0.3816414475,
0.0034259399,
-0.6651086211,
-0.2696100771,
0.5629454851,
-0.0495165326,
-0.4508780241,
-0.4792973697,
-0.243764177,
-0.1071785614,
0.2639884353,
0.6277185678,
0.4523573518,
0.2566477954,
-0.2709126472,
0.0404657722,
-0.0637134686,
0.0158989243,
0.135770902,
0.744646728,
0.0718794093,
-0.5262369514,
-0.577132225,
0.426692307,
0.3650098741,
-0.1704025269,
0.4817306101,
0.0873801187,
-0.2163080424,
-0.2376648337,
-0.2995563149,
-0.2048641592,
-0.5982306004,
0.3058210611,
-0.6425743103,
-0.7356538773,
0.560572505,
-0.4556787312,
0.5802933574,
-0.0664439797,
0.4705542922,
-0.0705853552,
0.9239073992,
0.8393725753,
-0.0186815821,
0.9508025646,
-0.2381126136,
0.1238247231,
-0.8506170511,
-0.4663071632,
-0.6857272387,
-0.1645131856,
-0.7650740743,
0.0657234937,
0.5706059337,
-0.186478585,
-0.2320375293,
0.5265519023,
-0.4496177435,
0.3094776273,
0.5536788702,
0.2257101685,
0.1990697831,
-0.2142443359,
0.0288324617,
0.0431351662,
-0.4281174839,
-0.8850223422,
0.8585169315,
0.0832172856,
0.9472352266,
0.2635329962,
0.7743036747,
0.438293159,
0.1984646171,
-0.4777669013,
0.7320266962,
-0.2450307161,
-0.2601598203,
0.0098566301,
-0.2363475114,
-1.0503307581,
0.3464963734,
-0.1610806286,
-0.799163878,
0.3838885427,
0.5203993917,
-0.2975253761,
0.028285902,
-0.9435190558,
0.9716197252,
-0.1574677527,
-0.3585846722,
-0.3255042732,
-0.5326097608,
0.4588385522,
0.0677845329,
-0.192536518,
0.114545837,
0.2931537628,
0.2130645961,
-0.6268013716,
1.1103537083,
-0.2153451294,
-0.0311904941,
0.1941732019,
0.2412050813,
0.6800320745,
-0.1261603683,
-0.0756320357,
-0.1165322587,
0.1118896082,
-0.0467627048,
-0.7550284863,
0.7406789064,
-0.6213043928,
-0.780346632,
-0.4096713364,
0.0150127783,
-0.4408494532,
-0.1358717233,
0.0816727579,
0.5904464126,
-0.7632989287,
-0.1686632335,
0.6501618028,
0.0295679066,
0.2717933953,
0.5726084113,
0.100049004,
-0.1001313329,
0.6332282424,
-0.2848361135,
0.2677623034,
0.4111891091,
-0.0457127392,
-0.435795635,
-0.6999895573,
-0.2285579741,
-0.0652800798,
-0.602955997,
0.1067201272,
-0.4434094727,
-0.0974192992,
-0.2543580532,
-0.2163715065,
-0.0684129745,
-0.205477342,
-0.3257145584,
-0.0900843218,
0.4074692726,
0.4919064641,
0.1060766429,
0.7837218642,
-0.2605853081,
0.2735673785,
0.2932099998,
-0.0019396596,
-0.2613981664,
-0.7291888595,
-0.1144848466,
0.0394758843,
-0.6182047725,
-0.5892461538,
0.4218993783,
0.0343054011,
0.723808229,
0.2954340875,
0.2630257905,
0.9527021646,
-0.7244705558,
0.7452317476,
0.1980606019,
-0.7336983085,
0.7191283703,
-0.1273145974,
-0.1059982255,
0.6663871408,
0.1557196677,
-0.5430215001,
-0.5804029107,
-0.6537213326,
-0.5863744617,
0.6407579184,
0.3142161965,
0.332408607,
-0.0195952151,
0.1581498682,
0.1291573048,
0.0697123185,
-0.3909355998,
0.1552355886,
-0.2676438987,
-0.4779011607,
-0.0488418713,
0.0554486401,
-0.2503362298,
0.4365909398,
0.6739685535,
-0.08408124,
-0.000543016,
0.0165137053,
0.1065631583,
0.5174602866,
0.4298655093,
0.5298566222,
0.3730877936,
-0.1260237098,
0.3265616298,
0.4435719848,
-0.2988381088,
0.2505087256,
0.0644746944,
0.0745421946,
0.0157481078,
0.2127723694,
0.7921248078,
-0.225682199,
-0.5967277884,
0.4144203663,
-0.3264806569,
0.0444196388,
-0.5220257044,
0.4060472548,
-0.2688300312,
0.4511517584,
-0.2593536973,
0.0385875776,
0.1810207367,
-0.5897343755,
0.1914290488,
0.57225734,
-0.2172159851,
-0.3701482713,
0.7090585828,
0.6077736616,
-0.3832410276,
0.2389356196,
-0.0587140396,
-0.2236951441,
0.453273356,
0.265198946,
0.9085522294,
-0.1449909508,
0.1344930083,
0.2335120142,
-0.0301858261,
-0.222654447,
-0.0694480985,
-0.1783593148,
-0.5944592953,
-0.1128936633,
-0.3087719977,
-0.9750089645,
0.3346047103,
-0.5057731271,
0.4662174284,
-0.5146429539,
-0.2599437237,
0.1776356697,
-0.1578682959,
-0.6348330975,
0.2197703272,
0.0010278255,
0.6548246741,
-0.9841755033,
0.7243030667,
0.1628717929,
-0.4791521728,
-0.5352718234,
0.0684290379,
0.075405255,
-0.3579204679,
0.3611218035,
-0.1053970382,
-0.3582540154,
-0.4745509326,
-0.5255609751,
-0.1963054538,
0.9581014514,
0.2864615619,
-0.8764334917,
-0.1112022847,
0.1344064176,
1.015203476,
-0.2407913953,
0.4052550197,
0.5687440634,
0.0285540819,
0.1904373616,
-0.9919133186,
-0.0970145166,
-0.4068463445,
0.0792694241,
-0.2032272071,
-0.7973347902,
0.5949331522,
0.3386576772,
-0.1613122523,
0.1964650154,
0.5137957931,
0.4939326644,
0.2277754098,
0.5544828176,
0.2425660491,
0.4915640056,
-0.1515716463,
0.8139445186,
-0.2011367679,
-0.2585552037,
1.576402545,
-0.568405211,
0.6535701156,
0.6915325522,
0.0957747325,
0.5047223568,
0.4644917846,
0.2165009826,
0.8947539926,
0.1890755147,
-0.5411128402,
-0.1706602275,
-0.304153055,
0.0721014142,
0.5105729103,
0.2754679024,
-0.1111816317,
-0.2879814506,
0.1474243999,
0.1581787318,
0.2896102369,
-0.0037270656,
0.9860904813,
0.055971276,
-1.0388491154,
0.4438069761,
-0.1116237491,
0.6844973564,
-0.7850477099,
-0.2240109295,
-0.4659558535,
0.5345752835,
0.1594958007,
-0.8594907522,
0.3259854913,
0.6281312704,
0.1421002746,
-0.3218963146,
0.2542021275,
-0.3171546161,
-0.2884228826,
-0.1178542599,
0.427444756,
0.2035682499,
0.3104292452,
-0.4983557463,
0.0944657624,
0.0792996809,
0.0784650147,
0.2717993557,
0.71169734,
-0.2917574644,
0.8538421988,
0.3971794546,
-0.0517032854,
-0.2775455713,
0.1801425368,
1.2091494799,
-0.1420348138,
-0.6369464993,
-0.9768670201,
0.742241323,
-0.5066049695,
-0.6257482767,
0.7149670124,
0.6204420924,
0.6067185998,
0.0132931927,
0.8885578513,
0.0271842405,
0.4613251984,
-0.5883240104,
0.173342362,
-0.2189986706,
0.5133473277,
-0.3469216526,
-0.445014149,
0.0260662157,
0.3089209497,
-0.3849437535,
-0.197697252,
0.1865656078,
1.139826417,
-0.2777632773,
-0.1498891413,
0.2464505285,
-0.0687875673,
1.0927004814,
0.6403693557,
1.0481315851,
-0.1903188676,
0.8529785872,
-0.1771453321,
-0.0875829086,
-0.1069396138,
-0.7308755517,
-1.0199326277,
-0.5742606521,
-0.3326802552,
-0.2732067108,
0.2368059903,
0.7773216963,
0.8718063831,
-0.7031572461,
-0.1498722732,
-0.4526640773,
-0.1375384331,
-0.0468541794,
-0.1050451621,
0.1085591614,
-0.0196629446,
-1.1258467436,
0.4517019093,
-0.0451130308,
0.4301748276,
-0.350086391,
-0.1794420332,
0.1839721501,
0.3231756687,
0.2936726809,
0.2834002972,
-0.4765217006,
-0.4142721891,
-0.2687329352,
-0.1419788152,
0.0652678758,
0.5863890052,
-0.7631782293,
0.5872860551,
0.3036020994,
0.2789742053,
0.784974575,
0.1382389367,
0.707990706,
-1.034409523,
0.4524278939,
0.1454177499,
0.4465810955,
0.3203809857,
-0.1183045357,
0.4821120799,
-0.1513304263,
-0.3748010695,
-0.7946521044,
0.5578304529,
-1.1473152637,
-0.0898865908,
0.8618674874,
-0.271220088,
-0.0714501068,
-0.1840855032,
-0.7533745766,
0.2390077263,
-0.3793355823,
0.9854946733,
0.4868419468,
-0.1547109783,
-0.2081033438,
-0.1806399077,
0.7097243667,
0.1290930063,
-1.1632035971,
0.2485414892,
0.7483233809,
0.1167199686,
0.1755246818,
0.4709127247,
0.1271935999,
0.0177894831,
0.269808203,
-0.0479114056,
-0.0778781325,
-0.1620288044,
-0.3227132559,
0.0693539158,
-0.0163232721,
-0.6586403251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14354v1 | Industrial Engineering with Large Language Models: A case study of ChatGPT's performance on Oil & Gas problems | 2023-04-27T17:33:49 | 2023-04-27T17:33:49 | Oluwatosin Ogundare, Srinath Madasu, Nathanial Wiggins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great potential in solving complex
problems in various fields, including oil and gas engineering and other
industrial engineering disciplines like factory automation, PLC programming
etc. However, automatic identification of strong and weak solutions to
fundamental physics equations governing several industrial processes remain a
challenging task. This paper identifies the limitation of current LLM
approaches, particularly ChatGPT in selected practical problems native to oil
and gas engineering but not exclusively. The performance of ChatGPT in solving
complex problems in oil and gas engineering is discussed and the areas where
LLMs are most effective are presented. | [
-0.285608381,
-0.9431521893,
0.9476496577,
0.4802632928,
0.0861567929,
0.4044699967,
-0.3519265056,
-0.5877827406,
-0.2750894129,
0.2886793315,
-0.2496028692,
-0.3368270099,
-0.7520158291,
-0.1309748739,
-0.6964850426,
0.6434889436,
-0.4964145124,
0.002813261,
0.2488108873,
0.1590549797,
-0.0858805254,
-0.6450152397,
-0.9237642884,
-0.2840402126,
0.1649299413,
0.1553273201,
0.5142230988,
0.0832999945,
0.8667494655,
0.3902195096,
-0.2826378942,
-0.0706206486,
-0.5670412183,
0.15515019,
0.105370149,
-0.1181486845,
0.0823126882,
-0.0956959352,
0.6462618709,
1.0722856522,
-0.2785556316,
-0.1628482342,
0.1175657883,
0.5711969137,
-0.1576395631,
0.6372777224,
-0.5130096078,
0.1512805521,
0.1012562811,
0.1193004772,
-0.1026949659,
-0.3733579218,
0.3569755256,
-0.4060266614,
-0.0022177878,
0.3474631011,
0.8497533202,
0.1629478037,
-0.3928122818,
-0.353456229,
-1.3186399937,
1.1876164675,
-0.7948276401,
0.2591807544,
-0.1901545972,
0.5386038423,
-0.6181259751,
-0.4332654774,
-0.2838851213,
-0.299842149,
0.121662356,
0.2162263393,
0.2460499853,
0.3792935908,
0.2124458998,
0.3269579411,
-0.5477916002,
0.4428832233,
-0.6885242462,
-0.1629675031,
0.6100337505,
0.202657029,
0.210550949,
0.2166125625,
-0.3372742534,
0.0520562381,
-0.6819518209,
-0.1774978638,
0.3206832707,
0.3208661079,
0.0931147486,
0.5000851154,
-0.2371398509,
0.4272246659,
-0.768897593,
-0.1725336015,
-0.2457752824,
0.3137837946,
-0.4522006214,
0.0189162325,
0.8932359219,
-0.3361932039,
0.3885159492,
-0.0830048025,
-0.4673062265,
-0.1442310959,
-0.2198362499,
-0.536298871,
-0.0852418095,
0.2893610597,
-0.2511686385,
-0.2147087753,
-0.1836828291,
-0.3972218931,
-0.4289715588,
-0.2960292101,
0.5141509175,
-0.0355403684,
-0.3963543475,
0.1607412398,
0.0375385471,
0.5336993337,
0.3200909197,
-0.6111943126,
0.0651945323,
0.9159833789,
0.9304289222,
0.2255554199,
-0.0813449398,
-0.1332918108,
0.2394527942,
-0.2493066639,
0.887525022,
-0.6151371002,
-0.4910445511,
0.032052543,
-0.1319223046,
0.1696281135,
-0.8087739348,
0.4988491535,
-0.458458811,
-0.0651748404,
-0.1234468669,
-0.7051378489,
-0.2237959653,
0.1098196879,
-0.5294374228,
0.7472993135,
0.0610340014,
-0.2615588009,
-0.054784257,
-0.7286183834,
-0.315625757,
-0.0359056294,
-0.4293904305,
-0.4744883776,
0.2273391187,
-0.4189538062,
0.5211982131,
-0.5547091961,
0.1470390111,
-0.385068208,
-0.0305219833,
0.3002104461,
-0.5485005975,
0.5661979318,
0.4192182124,
0.121130392,
0.0130286273,
-0.6322389245,
-0.0641395599,
0.0840742365,
-0.3352888525,
0.1570482403,
0.3601161838,
0.3056454062,
0.1341415793,
0.3304771185,
-0.4737612307,
0.2786676288,
-0.2695422769,
0.7101821899,
0.685149014,
-0.094420284,
-0.0816526413,
-0.1384047717,
0.5753493905,
-0.0928054228,
-0.18818371,
0.3041062653,
-0.6293283701,
-0.955671072,
-0.1345454007,
0.1687517315,
0.7231011391,
-0.458291918,
-0.2078226209,
0.0138742877,
-0.5351474285,
-0.0242305975,
0.2699485421,
0.1724288315,
0.1783976704,
0.1579121649,
-0.2319175899,
-0.5406916738,
-1.1568052769,
-0.3936319649,
-0.2690590322,
-0.4127165675,
0.3070921302,
0.1325907856,
-0.049377609,
0.7020798922,
-0.568277061,
-0.1812157333,
-0.1823839396,
0.4719780982,
0.6856436133,
0.3399955034,
0.2288537323,
-0.5686576962,
-0.7241362333,
0.4308575988,
-0.8361054659,
-0.2757786512,
0.1075748876,
0.0871773586,
-0.0517696626,
0.8426399231,
-0.6486743093,
-0.1400677264,
0.7136372328,
0.0319112837,
0.7648031712,
0.0460371152,
-0.0936053395,
-0.7712413669,
0.1333303601,
0.5255408883,
-0.5711395741,
-0.4748320878,
0.088653475,
-0.4782642424,
-0.6880336404,
-0.7187250853,
0.2076518238,
-0.6523411274,
-0.0567927361,
-0.2293124646,
-0.0361578278,
-0.5951480865,
0.3708636761,
0.2136291116,
0.8679088354,
0.6298693419,
-0.5886681676,
0.7582075596,
-0.0621876903,
-0.6089054346,
0.0220531765,
-0.7836521268,
0.0584528893,
-0.0673992559,
-0.115777567,
-1.0812193155,
-0.238573581,
-0.1673315614,
0.1933661252,
0.579641521,
-0.4531960189,
-0.4714405537,
-0.3676528931,
0.0969523266,
0.2001384795,
0.7342948318,
-0.1745608896,
0.4484371543,
0.2418726534,
-0.5959485769,
-0.3459627926,
-0.1908240169,
-0.0168050397,
-0.3273037076,
-0.5372952819,
-0.2176390886,
0.0140402364,
-0.3565416336,
-0.2245609909,
-0.4470390081,
-0.5914486051,
0.1625066102,
-0.1502835751,
0.0794484913,
-0.3776492774,
0.036189504,
-0.266762048,
-0.3171759546,
0.2080492377,
-0.0406504422,
0.5636531115,
-0.4201725721,
-0.3311323225,
-0.3158271015,
0.7144227624,
0.7605009675,
0.2079341561,
0.8530396223,
0.4725572765,
-0.2064019442,
-0.1245044619,
-0.5051729679,
-0.1151848659,
-0.5552129745,
0.6822969913,
-0.1895688623,
-0.7907122374,
0.6474696398,
-0.6991530657,
0.1531203091,
0.396386683,
0.7190636396,
-0.3247250617,
1.0801841021,
0.6005242467,
-0.4738849998,
0.3036383092,
-0.2565565109,
0.7241157293,
-0.7055440545,
0.1203379706,
-0.6535887122,
-0.4845089912,
-0.6333174109,
0.0982796848,
0.6847400069,
0.0927868932,
-0.3725842535,
0.1942349225,
-0.3346706033,
0.6761288643,
0.1845104545,
-0.1151525453,
0.5148810744,
-0.1480594426,
0.0013977289,
0.2210635543,
-0.6610807776,
-0.722974956,
0.669763267,
0.4834200442,
1.0423595905,
0.4441561699,
0.3250577152,
-0.0754060224,
0.355134517,
-1.1657053232,
0.4810967147,
-0.0496953391,
-0.8467081785,
-0.4478263855,
-0.5039108992,
-1.007938385,
0.0829920322,
0.0738663301,
-0.823792696,
-0.1876770258,
0.0833330974,
-0.28693524,
0.4363515377,
-1.1753587723,
0.7664183974,
-0.3279112279,
0.0257200934,
-0.0941546559,
-0.3452346623,
0.3616203666,
-0.2125961483,
0.3165020943,
-0.4466596544,
0.001163452,
0.5758526325,
-0.4912717044,
0.7623236179,
-0.017767271,
-0.6030631065,
0.3994699419,
-0.0196523946,
0.5990626216,
-0.0800902173,
-0.064751856,
0.0932375267,
0.0597973131,
-0.4131555557,
-0.4069891274,
1.0065203905,
-0.734811902,
-0.9195173979,
-0.5017421842,
-0.3404351473,
-0.4657809734,
0.3165558577,
0.1444680393,
0.2680273354,
-0.1441005617,
0.344379425,
0.7996851802,
-0.3722494543,
0.914675653,
0.4724048674,
-0.2451079935,
0.2388838083,
0.9597546458,
0.4798807502,
0.2465347499,
0.2473267764,
0.0014043102,
0.0549444743,
-0.7278302908,
-0.1706371158,
0.1824210733,
-0.7663844228,
-0.131062597,
-0.4322816133,
-0.7545226812,
0.2307629585,
-0.170353815,
-0.6853051782,
-0.5266587138,
0.0085106697,
0.2445532084,
0.2287415713,
0.752422452,
0.2757523954,
0.2712864578,
-0.8005819917,
0.2197633982,
0.7482412457,
0.7897633314,
-0.103545025,
-0.0287268497,
-0.261431247,
-0.0533971414,
-0.6170346737,
-0.7125609517,
0.2916034758,
0.2903409004,
0.509575665,
0.3685701489,
-0.1343561858,
0.2647423148,
-0.5278866291,
0.6809393764,
-0.0735167786,
-0.8208075762,
0.1016082317,
-0.6391945481,
0.2001070976,
-0.2139848322,
0.743498981,
-0.6624693274,
-0.3617418408,
-0.3792786002,
-1.1787986755,
0.1754560173,
0.5387325883,
0.1507096142,
0.352475673,
0.2946897745,
0.0165623073,
0.0972892866,
-0.725010097,
-0.2810214162,
0.4521901309,
-0.1243725792,
0.1543607563,
-0.2019869536,
-0.0191408787,
-0.0405376516,
0.9664594531,
0.1355913132,
0.5769007802,
0.1997403502,
-0.0799053907,
-0.0794382915,
0.6220155358,
0.695432961,
0.7771868706,
-0.2721059918,
-0.2594279647,
0.2976346612,
-0.4844142795,
0.2933227718,
-0.1297370046,
0.405115515,
-0.1364897639,
0.4155710042,
0.4109938443,
-0.0609033406,
-0.8182224631,
0.0097079584,
0.1552784145,
-0.121190168,
-0.7066197395,
0.2653471231,
0.1452280432,
0.4410756528,
0.7825779915,
-0.183566466,
0.3350372314,
-0.6925134063,
-0.4737221003,
0.594358623,
-0.3461326659,
-0.0765094385,
0.4656823277,
0.3130291402,
-0.2574877739,
0.4659736454,
0.0590516217,
-0.8548012376,
0.8782792687,
0.2706408799,
0.7618198395,
-0.0474307537,
-0.256681025,
0.0744483918,
0.4031558037,
-0.0072322092,
0.2270821631,
0.4334134758,
-0.7167604566,
-0.9149323702,
-0.5062192678,
-0.9475718737,
0.6118776798,
-0.1838752031,
0.3568526804,
-0.7482995987,
-0.0169177968,
0.1359941512,
0.050745409,
-0.5730473399,
0.0899920315,
0.2117854655,
0.412081182,
-0.8222846389,
0.4699267447,
0.6682610512,
-0.2119096518,
-0.9858308434,
-0.3118216395,
-0.0234273747,
-0.6518341899,
0.7308447957,
-0.2114800662,
-0.1641498804,
0.1379717737,
-0.6384332776,
-0.9529338479,
0.6938787699,
0.5337628126,
-1.0074714422,
0.2722775042,
0.2644673884,
0.4657849669,
0.1848270744,
0.3861554265,
0.6327890158,
0.5856814384,
-0.0850979015,
-1.5352349281,
-0.4225756824,
-0.0748090148,
0.0418587923,
0.6791824102,
-1.2902346849,
0.5865070224,
0.3076369464,
-0.1557961851,
-0.0190560408,
0.5178700089,
0.1343006343,
-0.1152024865,
0.1864078194,
0.3038558662,
0.3547031879,
-0.3016873896,
0.8420085311,
-0.1858546287,
0.8421613574,
0.4928939044,
-0.350423187,
0.7144300342,
0.4297755957,
-0.6789579988,
0.308591187,
0.4603770077,
0.2706274986,
0.192324385,
0.4344448149,
-0.6342551112,
-0.3153721988,
0.052120883,
-0.725782454,
0.5201491117,
0.6212953329,
-0.0604249313,
-0.2067178637,
-0.2488711178,
-0.0745236576,
-0.3331866562,
-0.1143172085,
0.7303810716,
0.4534837008,
0.040274363,
0.5336821079,
0.0509901568,
0.3443973064,
-0.6350929141,
-0.0465950482,
-0.049782645,
0.0010968279,
-0.1132873595,
-0.7466374636,
0.4150740504,
-0.1431409121,
-0.0743425563,
-0.2555809617,
0.5921108723,
-0.2950732112,
-0.7974062562,
-0.1417251378,
0.2118743211,
0.23359707,
0.1082243323,
-0.3950765133,
0.0528481193,
-0.187349081,
-0.3536438346,
0.0493996553,
0.5844008923,
0.1850224137,
1.1405801773,
0.2808119059,
0.1244406626,
-0.0811690688,
-0.0494371541,
0.6982693672,
-0.7738229632,
-0.125083372,
-0.6837004423,
0.0556290448,
0.0423502028,
0.2142727822,
0.5348107815,
0.650316,
0.5036309361,
-0.2756506205,
1.159312129,
0.0753451362,
0.7361056805,
-0.8849195838,
0.6283474565,
-0.2500394881,
0.6108136177,
-0.4164865911,
-1.2482333183,
-0.2476458549,
0.7475033402,
-0.3637931645,
0.2249983698,
0.8792852759,
0.6395642161,
-0.388433218,
-0.0959165841,
0.4591910243,
0.7585363388,
0.6477563381,
1.0563943386,
1.1057857275,
-0.3103968799,
0.4709956348,
-0.0278601032,
-0.0230872314,
-0.2438802272,
-1.2099288702,
-0.4199798703,
-0.2577890456,
-0.3784608841,
-0.0218944345,
-0.3314940333,
0.9690483212,
0.684679687,
-1.0990784168,
-0.7409517765,
-0.1357816011,
0.0805995464,
-0.1160396263,
-0.184317112,
0.1971438229,
-0.2616156638,
-0.9141324759,
0.5243458748,
0.3629854321,
0.1686885357,
-0.6074720025,
0.1606276333,
-0.0323251039,
0.2579357624,
0.6841885448,
0.5360842943,
-0.3506303132,
-0.4598503113,
-0.3713178635,
0.2447754741,
0.1004795805,
0.993817091,
-0.4268653393,
0.0780306384,
0.3630840182,
0.5871803164,
0.7173820138,
-0.2694565058,
0.9183213115,
-0.6558824182,
0.5187139511,
0.3974933326,
0.4964548051,
0.2742976248,
-0.3251793385,
0.4588079751,
0.2303772569,
-0.8577112556,
-0.4417353868,
0.3629000485,
-1.0287948847,
-0.2612299323,
1.0731936693,
0.1645053923,
-0.0662073866,
-0.3479475975,
-0.4722208381,
0.151891157,
-0.3157601058,
0.9090887904,
1.2724398375,
-0.1514536291,
-0.2212849557,
-0.9355204701,
0.1873432398,
0.5478616953,
-0.638541162,
-0.1786876172,
0.2712427676,
0.3073121607,
-0.04258224,
0.0551392883,
0.1211071163,
-0.267444551,
-0.3115223646,
-0.1617937982,
0.4004972875,
-0.1312143654,
-0.0325958766,
0.1357082874,
0.7428671122,
0.3428828716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14333v1 | Idioms, Probing and Dangerous Things: Towards Structural Probing for Idiomaticity in Vector Space | 2023-04-27T17:06:20 | 2023-04-27T17:06:20 | Filip Klubička, Vasudevan Nedumpozhimana, John D. Kelleher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50 | The goal of this paper is to learn more about how idiomatic information is
structurally encoded in embeddings, using a structural probing method. We
repurpose an existing English verbal multi-word expression (MWE) dataset to
suit the probing framework and perform a comparative probing study of static
(GloVe) and contextual (BERT) embeddings. Our experiments indicate that both
encode some idiomatic information to varying degrees, but yield conflicting
evidence as to whether idiomaticity is encoded in the vector norm, leaving this
an open question. We also identify some limitations of the used dataset and
highlight important directions for future work in improving its suitability for
a probing analysis. | [
-0.4374116063,
-0.9665558338,
0.2862822711,
0.058388222,
-0.4703529179,
0.2091979533,
0.2519797087,
-0.296202302,
0.1952335536,
-0.033784464,
-0.1655922085,
-0.557056725,
-0.6778161526,
-0.1370436996,
-0.4268708527,
0.7270433307,
-0.0697684661,
0.2388191223,
-0.270322293,
-0.7104387879,
-0.4773403406,
-0.8411858082,
-0.0513612702,
0.0295793843,
0.4335126281,
0.1111503541,
0.6474317908,
0.6775776744,
0.6616675854,
0.2432305664,
-0.336786747,
0.1121938974,
-0.4801146686,
0.3974448442,
-0.3568829,
-0.1956353933,
0.102107279,
0.1366718262,
0.3889495134,
0.7368392944,
0.1457278728,
0.2576185465,
0.308888793,
0.4456410408,
-0.5017850995,
0.3519067168,
-0.6298438907,
0.0528124385,
-0.2348496318,
-0.3428719342,
-0.2193281651,
-0.2374020517,
0.2401114255,
-0.1111886576,
-0.1567819864,
0.1469190717,
1.062705636,
0.1310357153,
-0.7818867564,
-0.4143309295,
-0.174948141,
0.6545433402,
-0.5009123683,
0.3643456101,
0.1354144067,
0.0689265579,
-0.1195752993,
-0.5334272385,
-0.3895695806,
-0.2952579856,
-0.2313308716,
-0.1310436428,
-0.2226587683,
-0.0054871975,
0.0982626006,
0.1573509872,
-0.3374350071,
-0.1757530868,
-0.4564751387,
-0.1944006681,
0.73612988,
0.149247095,
0.144072935,
-0.4816271067,
-0.7320287228,
-0.495416373,
-0.7811700702,
0.2752602398,
0.3485400677,
0.2444437295,
-0.2304570526,
0.703055799,
0.4096591175,
0.2796737552,
-0.3513607085,
0.4068450034,
0.3085955977,
-0.2570820451,
0.0839392915,
-0.1393669695,
0.5481703281,
0.6892323494,
0.1213611364,
-0.3773269653,
0.110072121,
0.2998620868,
0.4021494389,
-0.5899247527,
-0.0352644958,
0.4811524153,
-0.3140828609,
-0.50729388,
0.5730149746,
-0.6664205194,
-0.1406988353,
-0.2069496959,
0.3492327332,
-0.7022604346,
-0.1159165651,
0.1575172991,
-0.6667507291,
0.8299303651,
-0.2110599875,
-0.3443511128,
0.0899189189,
0.9394468665,
0.7065310478,
0.1673530191,
-0.1505472511,
-0.4880273938,
0.1280896068,
-0.4504485726,
0.5921089649,
-0.5141972899,
-0.7064369917,
0.2054932564,
0.0868776515,
0.4296239614,
-0.472438544,
0.6774511933,
-0.3705727756,
-0.1481978446,
-0.5837672353,
-0.6982464194,
-0.4689349532,
0.6560768485,
-0.2644548714,
1.3153400421,
-0.0285168979,
-0.8952565193,
0.4619707167,
-0.7376900911,
-0.5540760756,
-0.0592784993,
-0.6469822526,
-0.3967987299,
0.3328749239,
0.0461106263,
0.8785758615,
-0.0946524441,
0.1022291854,
-0.7049063444,
-0.3804347217,
0.626465261,
-0.0405092686,
0.8696020842,
0.12807329,
-0.3209779859,
-0.0766252056,
-0.515515089,
0.164856419,
0.2545014322,
-0.1308237612,
-0.7708542347,
0.3409796059,
-0.1255290508,
0.0901122466,
-0.0540300459,
-0.9910364151,
0.1951123476,
-0.4006592333,
0.6199336648,
0.7066078186,
0.4377214313,
0.1843336225,
-0.5535256267,
0.2972239852,
0.3436077833,
-0.0209118091,
0.0789628029,
-0.3920866251,
-0.1567855924,
-0.0070881378,
-0.0390243307,
0.6654732227,
-0.6234269142,
0.2496073693,
-0.1640838236,
-0.6458330154,
-0.4905201197,
-0.3002921939,
0.4328488708,
0.469481498,
0.2314436436,
-0.1078497246,
-0.3564469516,
-0.9888362288,
-0.6430106163,
-0.1975723356,
-0.0021520185,
0.5144436955,
0.5771490932,
-0.2644796968,
0.6839649081,
-0.5255833864,
-0.1689364016,
0.3831300139,
0.4332540631,
0.1869280338,
0.47981745,
1.0463118553,
-0.8671848774,
-0.1998859495,
-0.1336758137,
-0.7661606073,
0.4280484915,
0.1628727615,
-0.0949037597,
-0.4610171318,
0.8753010631,
-0.3042089939,
0.3305509686,
0.5608801246,
-0.2809146643,
0.2597468793,
-0.0247605313,
0.0637859479,
-1.1515309811,
-0.2590098381,
-0.1017458811,
0.0898141712,
-0.4160212874,
0.7440055013,
0.3155857027,
-0.1493982524,
-0.6971504688,
0.4000269771,
-0.717793107,
0.1814488024,
0.1255172044,
0.307482928,
0.0411421433,
0.2767032683,
-0.5992041826,
0.9099444747,
0.749966681,
-0.7206550241,
0.2781888545,
0.4203419089,
-0.5343352556,
0.4198635519,
-0.7635979056,
0.4043662846,
-0.5806221366,
-0.2454573512,
-1.4191248417,
0.0242582448,
0.0883835107,
-0.6062489152,
0.2962013185,
-0.0877713934,
-0.5893452764,
-0.2041704357,
-0.947329998,
0.5008641481,
0.3635573387,
-0.5128908157,
0.3752195835,
0.7623785138,
0.1347340345,
-0.819396615,
-0.7322853804,
0.0726406276,
-0.6758182645,
-0.562963903,
0.318244189,
-0.0458517298,
-0.7482412457,
0.1459615231,
-0.0467576049,
0.1233378351,
0.4218365252,
0.351179719,
0.1275290549,
-0.3655293584,
0.4346238971,
0.3009391427,
0.3105346859,
0.532104671,
0.0194948483,
0.3913094103,
-0.4799971282,
-0.3334158361,
0.1698305309,
0.8398820162,
0.6179767251,
-0.3141023517,
0.5315218568,
0.3892302513,
-0.359710753,
-0.2320834845,
-0.0801409781,
-0.3694451153,
-0.5304327011,
0.4058645368,
-0.5317070484,
-0.8362882733,
0.5363950729,
-0.2551706731,
0.291967988,
0.3368332684,
0.3563408256,
-0.751493156,
0.8393431902,
0.4172216356,
-0.0222406983,
0.0791893154,
-0.2678521872,
0.3496345282,
-0.9380076528,
-0.1751508415,
-0.536241293,
-0.4442802966,
-0.6976334453,
-0.4785549939,
0.868733108,
-0.1520488262,
-0.0876549482,
0.4327239096,
-0.5716500878,
0.3178361058,
0.2770417333,
0.0560398325,
-0.2650097013,
-0.293392092,
-0.4059551656,
-0.2243036479,
-0.5375944972,
-0.6140417457,
0.9309402108,
0.4569022954,
0.6326625347,
0.5391603112,
0.4321940839,
0.2389917672,
0.2716979384,
-1.2267068624,
0.5475738049,
-0.1470767707,
-0.9426900148,
-0.1301107109,
-0.0248855669,
-1.0596442223,
0.2096723765,
-0.1699377149,
-0.7586396337,
0.4868830144,
0.030223649,
-0.0229881033,
0.2452120483,
-0.4368797541,
0.5272563696,
-0.2533106506,
-0.1697352082,
-0.0078395447,
-0.8022409081,
0.1872787476,
0.3084653914,
0.2773478031,
-0.1232744157,
-0.1250207424,
0.5478217602,
-0.1286312491,
0.8862150311,
-0.0335895307,
-0.4187533557,
0.3301948309,
0.3646662235,
0.3883655965,
0.1919429451,
-0.1210110039,
0.3431686759,
0.3111668527,
-0.5147446394,
-0.4615057409,
0.3758486211,
-0.3281345367,
-0.6215356588,
-0.6600536704,
-0.5301550627,
-0.4809259474,
-0.1918659061,
0.3874589503,
0.7046306729,
-0.4435030818,
0.7364079356,
0.7901585102,
0.0222776998,
0.2681289315,
0.1463490129,
0.2981616259,
0.2028618753,
0.5726724267,
0.2991590798,
0.0037681984,
0.7658246756,
0.3269935846,
-0.2199311107,
-0.5523389578,
-0.1475514472,
0.2795838714,
-0.8128982186,
-0.2913478315,
-0.407715112,
-0.0238941088,
-0.2511481643,
-0.3828660846,
-0.2373793125,
-0.1224644929,
-0.0328692868,
-0.4674674273,
0.5761211514,
0.585729301,
-0.0810457766,
-0.078836441,
-0.9334819913,
0.0556919053,
0.1603188962,
0.0012298019,
-0.3901835084,
-0.1422615796,
-0.0416768603,
0.0178433564,
-0.1057452708,
-1.440367341,
0.0247603338,
0.0616087578,
0.5895709395,
0.6100218892,
0.4200393856,
0.4677322209,
-0.5480897427,
0.7369695306,
-0.3577008247,
-0.9447877407,
0.4392824471,
-0.5848153234,
-0.0382059216,
0.4296056628,
0.6952050328,
-0.4475537241,
-0.4795251787,
-0.5868256688,
-1.0167666674,
-0.125188455,
-0.2994328141,
0.7356943488,
-0.3869549036,
0.4283187091,
0.0596616343,
0.1896989644,
-0.4522598088,
-0.2794343531,
-0.0300135929,
-0.1003115922,
0.236131534,
-0.4476519823,
-0.9090746641,
-0.2399369627,
0.2610864043,
-0.2856348157,
0.5766364932,
0.2280961424,
0.0374488384,
0.5126190186,
0.2421095371,
0.4813993573,
0.4203177989,
-0.2280282527,
0.2845562696,
0.2290787399,
-0.4180158377,
0.3166322112,
0.119738929,
0.2038113922,
0.1557943225,
0.4322651327,
0.3315322101,
0.3981801867,
-0.8079541922,
0.7634291053,
0.1024800539,
-0.4182773232,
-0.4239331782,
-0.1010629982,
-0.0822877139,
0.2317925841,
0.0795104206,
-0.2490575314,
0.2474880219,
-0.768055439,
0.2699559033,
0.6624798775,
-0.501077354,
-0.2584039271,
0.5396004915,
-0.0834022611,
-0.0224612188,
0.5392611027,
-0.2504600883,
-0.4436142743,
0.3391334713,
0.0931038484,
0.7730642557,
-0.0337322466,
0.1084227711,
0.3069987893,
0.6682579517,
0.6118895411,
0.829672575,
-0.1724536568,
-0.9682736397,
-0.05135189,
0.0380385518,
-0.4524028003,
0.0875198171,
-1.0194176435,
0.1366282851,
-0.4835855365,
-0.1425721645,
-0.1507946104,
-0.3175274432,
-0.6286099553,
0.0379270129,
-0.3225071728,
1.0324130058,
-0.719650805,
0.7593535185,
1.00898242,
-0.3858708739,
-0.7462249398,
0.1917211264,
0.1274495423,
-0.8401582241,
0.6462309957,
0.0067622145,
-0.3871759772,
-0.3869227469,
-0.8335788846,
-0.9147526622,
0.9455630779,
0.0024548296,
-0.1273446679,
-0.0745751485,
-0.1188070104,
0.2549999952,
0.0378388613,
-0.4648557603,
0.2231912911,
0.4365767539,
-0.5362221003,
-0.3773103058,
0.2016864419,
-0.4399943948,
-0.1980174482,
0.3776946068,
-0.5488576293,
0.926902771,
-0.0288056228,
-0.5716803074,
-0.0482706316,
0.6420029402,
-0.0608124621,
0.0510090254,
0.4575650394,
0.3142443001,
0.5482558012,
-0.3665477633,
1.2495522499,
-0.4260995984,
0.172397539,
0.8321647644,
-0.2307346165,
0.8630535007,
0.7706285119,
-0.0559287779,
0.3607580662,
0.3812939823,
0.0489335172,
0.4518235922,
0.4998784959,
-0.0853552148,
0.4286681712,
0.0356787853,
-0.4444707632,
0.9745243192,
0.8124245405,
-0.2047855109,
-0.25485605,
0.1501496732,
0.4207734466,
0.2053359896,
0.2339280248,
0.8230300546,
0.0023135687,
-0.2082317919,
0.4209895134,
0.1169526652,
0.5460441113,
-0.7247090936,
-0.0377054289,
-0.04328385,
0.0819807053,
0.1949300468,
-1.0992006063,
0.5256448984,
-0.3346906602,
0.3545334637,
-0.3800204098,
0.5481021404,
-0.1341589987,
0.0199737586,
0.4381513298,
0.6215795279,
0.1669424176,
0.1433260441,
-0.469309926,
0.0396007821,
-0.2629442215,
-0.2035069317,
0.1844252646,
0.692527771,
0.1092279255,
0.303532958,
0.4186965227,
-0.033895202,
0.1547147036,
-0.3534390628,
1.0299777985,
-0.7918738127,
-0.487578094,
-0.6965909004,
0.8862977624,
-0.1848005205,
-0.7352431417,
1.0170558691,
0.4618983865,
0.9435096383,
-0.0480785966,
0.530100584,
0.0778537169,
0.5893782377,
-0.5879947543,
0.6610738039,
-0.4601137936,
0.0049447301,
-0.4171567261,
-0.6428501606,
-0.1944056302,
0.7169187665,
0.0736866891,
-0.4049044251,
0.6169964671,
0.7974176407,
-0.2265276611,
-0.0074571269,
0.23097983,
0.5048909783,
0.4235198796,
0.0323281251,
0.8818641305,
-0.5837763548,
0.1622611433,
-0.4389835596,
-0.2986594737,
-0.112628378,
-1.1357009411,
-0.8030406833,
-1.1734448671,
-0.2868152857,
-0.4696109593,
-0.1219653487,
0.7209323049,
0.5457013845,
-0.5157831311,
-0.2421893626,
0.2214359194,
-0.2391745597,
-0.5087149739,
-0.2771390676,
0.4444361329,
-0.1971619725,
-0.6000657678,
0.9016836882,
0.193971768,
0.21363388,
-0.2661604881,
0.5149461031,
-0.2735365331,
0.4792394936,
0.9228699803,
0.2493755817,
-0.3429842889,
-0.9058668613,
-0.0036067511,
0.0453888029,
-0.0345138237,
0.9800699949,
-0.3631471097,
0.3312360346,
0.6300383806,
1.0940829515,
0.134317562,
-0.209522754,
0.6399655938,
-1.3324590921,
0.4260929525,
0.5522860885,
0.6419354677,
0.1009134874,
-0.4817405343,
0.612195015,
0.009495697,
-0.1990132928,
-0.9945469499,
0.7019200325,
-0.9655588865,
-0.5571215749,
0.9907286167,
-0.1006811187,
-0.2053154111,
-0.1290547401,
-0.2961003482,
0.0300821159,
0.1101902723,
0.7690469027,
0.9773797989,
-0.1463105977,
0.206643343,
-0.3722927868,
0.2425207794,
0.4808177352,
-0.5902522206,
-0.1552724391,
0.2519366145,
0.0909195617,
0.266208142,
0.0420383811,
-0.4592549503,
0.1983532757,
0.2113054544,
-0.3894761801,
-0.1603867114,
-0.1499762833,
-0.1849426478,
0.4794545174,
-0.1708841473,
-0.82870996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14318v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14318v2 | q2d: Turning Questions into Dialogs to Teach Models How to Search | 2023-04-27T16:39:15 | 2023-12-26T16:00:48 | Yonatan Bitton, Shlomi Cohen-Ganor, Ido Hakimi, Yoad Lewenberg, Roee Aharoni, Enav Weinreb | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the exciting capabilities of recent language models for dialog is
their ability to independently search for relevant information to ground a
given dialog response. However, obtaining training data to teach models how to
issue search queries is time and resource consuming. In this work, we propose
q2d: an automatic data generation pipeline that generates information-seeking
dialogs from questions. We prompt a large language model (PaLM) to create
conversational versions of question answering datasets, and use it to improve
query generation models that communicate with external search APIs to ground
dialog responses. Unlike previous approaches which relied on human written
dialogs with search queries, our method allows to automatically generate
query-based grounded dialogs with better control and scale. Our experiments
demonstrate that: (1) For query generation on the QReCC dataset, models trained
on our synthetically-generated data achieve 90%--97% of the performance of
models trained on the human-generated data; (2) We can successfully generate
data for training dialog models in new domains without any existing dialog data
as demonstrated on the multi-hop MuSiQue and Bamboogle QA datasets. (3) We
perform a thorough analysis of the generated dialogs showing that humans find
them of high quality and struggle to distinguish them from human-written
dialogs. | [
-0.3049701154,
-0.8498635888,
0.7055505514,
-0.3484393358,
-0.137601316,
-0.0414215662,
0.2533480823,
-0.1883745939,
-0.1278819889,
0.8737008572,
-0.8285843134,
-0.3912676573,
-0.0149013661,
-0.1749197543,
-0.3504431844,
0.780657053,
0.2651498318,
0.1311521232,
-0.3604336381,
0.0844266862,
-0.4840898216,
-0.5518075824,
-0.876167357,
0.106912069,
0.2224512249,
0.5649523735,
0.8470586538,
0.4472979605,
0.0214964505,
0.1170505211,
0.1888001859,
0.4666969776,
-0.7118040919,
0.4065120518,
-0.0549542569,
-0.8757820129,
0.0120085906,
0.2633862793,
0.3773183525,
0.6403511167,
-0.1265673637,
0.1892566681,
-0.162386626,
0.7113198042,
-0.1680513918,
0.2014120817,
-0.8887925148,
0.0112934662,
0.0432424657,
-0.6557612419,
-0.4419639111,
-0.6259482503,
0.3203440905,
-0.722876966,
0.5888987184,
0.3022691011,
0.7286337614,
0.0948084742,
-0.7209767699,
-0.7262073159,
-0.4196450412,
0.3653535843,
-0.5905609131,
0.4101364911,
0.795904696,
0.499035418,
-0.3851791918,
-0.7571722269,
-0.5444105268,
0.0741576329,
0.1204706654,
0.0794107616,
0.0306419916,
-0.0518232696,
0.3686201572,
0.1822392792,
-0.7568285465,
-0.3757474124,
-0.5758364797,
-0.1081075445,
0.7254303694,
0.3868990839,
0.4291450083,
-0.2652083635,
0.1242272705,
-0.1924317628,
-0.9633446336,
0.3243199885,
0.5238528848,
0.1650670767,
0.1716211736,
0.5668389201,
-0.3628466725,
0.599437952,
0.2713140249,
0.0694369525,
-0.3078313768,
-0.4463303983,
0.1899148375,
-0.2087586522,
0.476852268,
0.6476198435,
0.235812664,
-0.1966335028,
-0.2959282398,
-0.2865711451,
0.2947609723,
-0.9277011752,
-0.5951582789,
0.4688593149,
-0.2261326015,
-0.4999663532,
-0.0390649736,
-0.4970036149,
-0.365678221,
-0.4444108307,
0.2837651372,
-0.1547632515,
-0.3178918064,
-0.0006434633,
-0.261068821,
0.2142863423,
0.3806217611,
-0.7681552768,
0.2643591464,
0.2722981572,
0.4103336036,
0.2337152213,
0.2745056152,
-0.8571978807,
0.0344926342,
-0.6520096064,
0.6781047583,
-0.5763041377,
-0.5502609015,
0.1794202775,
0.1077830717,
-0.0091124605,
-0.8678644896,
0.2551532388,
-0.9715442657,
0.7588242888,
-0.4514242411,
-0.5421908498,
-0.2012206465,
0.0775390342,
-0.4061074257,
1.2756078243,
0.4726200998,
-0.8212154508,
0.1939868927,
-0.633767426,
-0.1331535727,
0.1288048029,
-0.3522290885,
-0.1271271408,
-0.0520620756,
0.4133720398,
0.1420605779,
-0.854922533,
0.4758934677,
-0.1665210873,
-0.1587157845,
0.3388530314,
-0.1324418187,
0.8399032354,
0.1363572478,
-0.3877130151,
-0.1383596361,
-0.5531427264,
0.5699495077,
0.4386284351,
-0.2597367167,
-0.0842643678,
0.1577758044,
-0.1260693073,
0.343085736,
-0.0644422174,
-0.3633660078,
0.2921801507,
-0.5570226908,
0.5796394348,
0.3524249494,
0.3497744203,
0.3409413993,
-0.3367938399,
0.7152820826,
0.0348226577,
-0.0353175364,
-0.4590197504,
-0.4764924049,
-0.8781926036,
0.4220328331,
0.2055618614,
0.4993245602,
-0.9017592072,
0.2172636092,
-0.0312876739,
-0.322583437,
-0.7736945748,
0.2202706188,
0.0315733775,
0.6249630451,
0.0760543793,
-0.1566113979,
-0.5125145316,
-0.7273138762,
0.107815817,
-0.548632443,
-0.2669749558,
0.8279730678,
0.1560585648,
-0.1275618672,
1.3006689548,
-0.7417095304,
0.0569241233,
-0.1770565957,
0.2672345042,
-0.1205317229,
0.4240735471,
0.4630292058,
-1.0075926781,
-0.3443288505,
-0.3927875161,
-0.8275657892,
-0.1808039397,
-0.0125847133,
-0.4184512198,
-0.1622831523,
0.477057457,
-0.7740835547,
0.2684008479,
0.1370390207,
-0.1699388325,
0.4527573287,
0.0544715151,
0.0623461381,
-1.0247019529,
0.1383105069,
-0.3436146379,
-0.3411881924,
-0.4564652741,
0.1049015895,
-0.0937008262,
-0.8355131745,
-0.3363295197,
0.7737330794,
-0.4959996939,
-0.2181581557,
-0.2528942823,
0.3814392984,
0.2604591846,
0.4888582826,
0.1175773814,
1.1673500538,
0.6042795777,
-0.8603864312,
0.4355073571,
0.5395846963,
-0.1831040382,
0.2520981729,
-0.8916257024,
0.6640434861,
-0.330098629,
0.5241706371,
-1.1113872528,
-0.5127409697,
0.1506903917,
-0.6335313916,
0.006340764,
-0.4469696283,
-0.6590092182,
-0.4305033386,
-0.1195627153,
0.4915452302,
0.6967282891,
-0.7076092362,
0.2282582074,
0.6892895103,
-0.5260356665,
0.1223608255,
-0.1142592281,
0.0296305735,
-0.1322428733,
-0.9055313468,
-0.1955032051,
-0.1561876088,
0.0089572277,
-0.2893528342,
-0.0308994651,
-0.2820506096,
0.0854140967,
0.2928350866,
0.0120550394,
-0.234245792,
0.3532127738,
0.1925243884,
0.126049161,
0.3379582763,
-0.5440446734,
0.7210639715,
0.3461529613,
-0.3077640533,
-0.655495882,
0.4578448236,
0.551869154,
-0.3892381191,
0.1695401967,
0.2731607556,
-0.2508393526,
-0.267880708,
-0.5411177278,
-0.6164957285,
-0.4905857444,
0.024912741,
-0.4198090732,
-0.7475563288,
0.245204106,
-0.22380732,
0.1407279521,
0.2518488765,
0.440482378,
-0.4591570795,
1.5747312307,
0.5028284192,
0.2772054076,
0.1994593292,
-0.511836648,
0.2057646215,
-0.6984445453,
-0.1445181221,
-0.3833782375,
0.1888415813,
-0.3956745267,
-0.7324103117,
0.6485568881,
0.227445066,
-0.0471157283,
0.1470902413,
-0.3611079454,
0.2659205794,
0.6166856885,
-0.021572005,
-0.0167230405,
0.1137213558,
-0.1299101561,
-0.2423557639,
-0.8102872968,
-0.6195119619,
1.4230856895,
0.3051327765,
0.575596869,
0.0036522513,
0.5717433095,
0.365854919,
-0.1194313765,
-0.7565969229,
0.378559798,
0.4403679371,
-0.7250567079,
-0.2919592857,
-0.4035985768,
-0.9299433231,
0.1546356082,
0.1129184142,
-0.5685947537,
0.0302854478,
0.252435267,
-0.4179238677,
0.0051238905,
-0.6079186797,
0.6416478753,
-0.2972165644,
-0.4835239351,
-0.0920713469,
-0.6850454807,
0.3922413886,
0.0510275029,
0.1025182083,
-0.1610374004,
0.5124480128,
0.8096340299,
-0.483361721,
0.7809115648,
-0.5691214204,
-0.332621485,
1.0267658234,
0.3811880052,
0.7703629136,
0.4662456214,
-0.0809628218,
-0.5787758827,
0.1737572402,
-0.4390788376,
-0.7250260711,
0.2227577269,
-0.5538173914,
-0.7847483158,
-0.054249879,
-0.4563067555,
-0.4807664156,
0.1049743369,
0.1521174759,
0.7880169749,
-0.1274735183,
0.0828060359,
0.7109424472,
-0.3392939866,
-0.157036528,
0.6896842718,
-0.3838980496,
-0.1116353348,
0.8555909395,
0.0262813978,
0.264388144,
0.1262741089,
-0.1312459707,
-0.7185583711,
-0.1296682805,
-0.746653378,
0.0929242447,
-0.5301664472,
-0.2567383945,
-0.9124059081,
-0.2814071774,
-0.5977423191,
0.2337957919,
-0.1880971193,
-0.4343629777,
-0.3871962428,
-0.0438508168,
0.236023888,
0.5966981649,
0.1930287778,
0.3596524298,
-0.8783506751,
0.5055230856,
0.7154621482,
-0.2049624473,
-0.1075075418,
-0.5615643859,
-0.0042550554,
0.635966301,
-0.5555986762,
-0.7670432329,
0.4474928975,
0.274053067,
0.0784307718,
0.3526552618,
0.3165336251,
0.3592431247,
-0.3274046481,
0.8844380379,
-0.0732128322,
-0.5534307361,
1.0095375776,
-0.7328678966,
0.1211380959,
0.55103302,
0.33114326,
-0.6610273123,
-0.2801634371,
-0.6967122555,
-0.7183035612,
0.9263085723,
0.2018562406,
0.2412834316,
-0.0927476659,
0.4576503634,
0.2188454121,
0.3824470043,
-0.1329580545,
0.1586039215,
-0.0687547103,
-0.0334858187,
0.4360463619,
-0.30089885,
-0.2379653454,
-0.1548033804,
0.548155427,
-0.5607609153,
0.4214781225,
0.2195285559,
-0.0035352877,
-0.3188964128,
0.1067954674,
0.1299286783,
0.5130701661,
-0.2564947009,
-0.0600661971,
-0.1911754906,
-0.0666002631,
0.1734565794,
-0.2280347347,
-0.3779199123,
-0.021527838,
-0.2252177447,
0.8807072043,
-0.0252535809,
-1.1815453768,
0.5387461185,
-0.1956429929,
-0.1753506958,
-0.4145350456,
0.3868915141,
0.2628872693,
0.1633811444,
0.4003182054,
-0.4242872,
0.3635731936,
-0.8294846416,
0.3473108709,
0.4332936406,
-0.2036001384,
-0.4319096208,
0.9178848267,
0.4376887381,
-0.1721013486,
1.133918643,
-0.3114715815,
-0.5915759802,
0.6262470484,
0.4965826571,
0.6406846046,
0.1351255476,
0.5528851151,
0.4204540849,
-0.0506221987,
-0.0034242505,
0.4830416143,
-0.374266386,
-0.5947242975,
0.1004890054,
-0.3299780786,
-0.6455129981,
0.3700677156,
-0.6861869693,
0.2177094221,
-0.4111508727,
-0.2451366335,
-0.1123784557,
0.0248371549,
-0.8336923122,
0.4317448735,
-0.1995776892,
0.6561288834,
-0.5918201804,
0.6749376059,
0.5603246093,
-0.5079489946,
-0.8935554028,
0.1487013102,
-0.0181495026,
-0.7847705483,
0.8785008788,
0.1646030396,
0.15294379,
0.2075971067,
-0.9549010396,
-0.9038236737,
1.0322018862,
0.2445122004,
-0.3948121071,
-0.5223125815,
0.2976994514,
0.5215062499,
-0.4809789062,
0.388307333,
0.5854501724,
0.1213327125,
0.0834309086,
-0.7316899896,
-0.1973314136,
-0.4797890186,
-0.1437198073,
-0.0296826605,
-0.6913588643,
0.6958503127,
-0.3620404005,
-0.5607033968,
0.1007666439,
0.488858223,
0.2629509568,
0.3866269588,
0.3178994656,
0.3273425102,
0.8968223333,
-0.1089580134,
0.9135764837,
-0.4585267603,
0.176762864,
1.1681126356,
-0.4591966867,
0.6619347334,
0.1652659923,
-0.078259483,
0.0429302193,
0.8903852105,
0.1039455533,
0.5115401745,
0.3871616721,
-0.1929452717,
-0.3300629556,
-0.2978629172,
-0.3075541854,
0.3596507013,
0.396197468,
-0.1625019014,
-0.1780942827,
-0.1549209505,
-0.2431303412,
0.0284343623,
0.2675223649,
1.0073510408,
-0.1296411753,
-0.879760623,
0.852432251,
0.0295741428,
0.1439439952,
-0.3599175215,
-0.2316149324,
-0.4173335433,
-0.3549640179,
-0.0932982713,
-0.5408651829,
-0.0896579996,
0.0135135679,
-0.2049732357,
-0.0495060496,
0.481108427,
-0.6116915345,
-0.2255754769,
-0.0639884099,
0.6390522718,
0.5099588633,
-0.228364706,
-0.5833764672,
-0.3532427847,
0.2944643199,
-0.0707879066,
0.2292142957,
0.5050539374,
-0.125174433,
0.7848435044,
0.8152847886,
-0.0693536103,
0.3066821396,
0.0082630478,
1.0659195185,
-0.6598711014,
-0.6265933514,
0.2223471999,
0.4121614397,
-0.0718042254,
-0.2095148712,
0.2709445655,
0.7713739276,
0.6677899361,
0.0422564596,
1.1567574739,
0.0049748411,
0.991723597,
-0.7102424502,
0.5955749154,
-0.5304939747,
0.250290215,
0.3290345967,
-0.9136835933,
0.5369672179,
0.5158574581,
-0.1229811534,
-0.0418611132,
0.4121500254,
1.0561853647,
-0.121808283,
0.2102463692,
0.0764452815,
-0.0324320421,
0.6598420143,
0.324806273,
0.9169935584,
-0.7260676026,
0.3761426508,
-0.0933232978,
0.1531353295,
-0.3088606894,
-0.1749147028,
-0.9745630026,
-0.7162432671,
-0.250834316,
-0.3112950623,
0.0768682063,
0.892303586,
0.7934102416,
-0.7054094672,
-0.2379586846,
-0.2946799099,
-0.1898560971,
0.4295205474,
-0.3695856929,
0.3290554285,
-0.57304281,
-0.704028368,
0.7446801066,
0.0614649653,
0.2043150812,
-0.2784382999,
-0.0280274786,
0.0685564652,
0.2031133026,
0.4085021317,
0.39792943,
-0.6028898954,
-0.1804032624,
0.1381460428,
-0.2320215553,
0.035850808,
1.152421236,
-0.8516376019,
0.7513062954,
0.3445325494,
0.8208045363,
0.6072068214,
0.3647484779,
0.948808372,
-0.6415317655,
0.037010543,
0.4040685594,
-0.2693045437,
0.3938832879,
-0.4985715449,
0.5766570568,
0.0657057762,
-0.4123016894,
-0.8220795989,
0.1863770187,
-0.5866837502,
0.0694929808,
1.1192229986,
0.0274112392,
0.1376123875,
-0.2384528965,
-0.7969779968,
0.1764331609,
-0.5137912631,
0.7251958847,
0.4490196705,
-0.1631702036,
-0.1075832546,
-0.9359135032,
0.7980143428,
0.520617187,
-0.8658245206,
0.4447986484,
0.6790202856,
0.4003824592,
-0.2245801538,
0.8201186657,
-0.2172480375,
0.4744723141,
0.039934095,
-0.1618276536,
0.2215660512,
-0.3029121459,
0.1737756878,
0.2948614061,
0.2719201446,
0.0630955845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14317v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14317v2 | ICE-Score: Instructing Large Language Models to Evaluate Code | 2023-04-27T16:38:17 | 2024-01-22T17:06:50 | Terry Yue Zhuo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Recent advancements in the field of natural language generation have
facilitated the use of large language models to assess the quality of generated
text. Although these models have shown promising results in tasks such as
machine translation and summarization, their applicability in code intelligence
tasks remains limited without human involvement. The complexity of programming
concepts required for such tasks makes it difficult to develop evaluation
metrics that align with human judgment. Token-matching-based metrics, such as
BLEU, have demonstrated weak correlations with human practitioners in code
intelligence tasks. Moreover, utilizing human-written test suites to evaluate
functional correctness can be challenging in domains with low resources. To
overcome these obstacles, we propose \texttt{ICE-Score}, a new evaluation
metric via instructing large language models (LLMs) for code assessments. Our
metric addresses the limitations of existing approaches by achieving superior
correlations with functional correctness and human preferences, without the
need for test oracles or references. We evaluate the efficacy of our metric on
two different aspects (\textit{human preference} and \textit{execution
success}) and four programming languages. Our results demonstrate that our
metric surpasses state-of-the-art metrics for code generation, delivering high
levels of accuracy and consistency across various programming languages and
tasks. We also make our evaluation metric and datasets available to the
public\footnote{\url{https://github.com/terryyz/ice-score}}, encouraging
further research in evaluating code intelligence tasks. | [
-0.19453758,
-0.4898245633,
0.2256971002,
0.3368271887,
-0.1526532322,
0.4303866625,
-0.5643748641,
-0.3714478612,
-0.0132458946,
0.2619489133,
-0.0605448298,
-0.7779183388,
-0.3010426462,
-0.0942903087,
-0.2717643678,
1.157340169,
-0.0150292395,
0.1562443525,
-0.7194116712,
-0.1032962427,
-0.547533989,
-0.5052015781,
-0.2244142294,
-0.4498159587,
0.310621351,
0.6470840573,
0.7022271156,
0.5047790408,
0.8528264165,
0.1951924413,
0.3465248942,
0.223451376,
-0.5485554934,
-0.1634969711,
0.0436520837,
-0.3790737987,
-0.6290701032,
0.2133065462,
0.5531588197,
0.5750415325,
-0.0981384069,
0.6007365584,
-0.0359635986,
0.5888437629,
-0.5901391506,
0.1210620776,
-0.6570270061,
-0.1701837927,
0.0379795581,
-0.1734749824,
-0.6422518492,
-0.3841471374,
-0.2621997595,
-0.1167838275,
-0.0497578979,
0.3608039618,
0.8048826456,
0.3010694385,
-0.2725040019,
-0.2844252586,
-0.497880131,
0.9375784993,
-0.7743869424,
0.1788724214,
0.4425274432,
0.084659256,
0.1008422375,
-0.3562027514,
-0.4896663725,
-0.7988595963,
0.1268147975,
0.0615662299,
-0.1848131567,
-0.1016862839,
0.283935219,
0.384709388,
-0.5693717003,
0.3620619774,
-0.384257257,
-0.1507582068,
1.0103366375,
0.4335893989,
0.4693865776,
-0.04680527,
-0.15243949,
0.2122040987,
-0.6097640395,
0.0011199113,
0.4056254029,
0.2131293565,
-0.2862438858,
0.5461705327,
-0.1350010931,
0.6728622913,
-0.072989732,
-0.1796863973,
0.474096179,
-0.1692989767,
-0.2096665353,
-0.2538136244,
0.8270736337,
0.6841214895,
0.2600936294,
-0.3487905264,
-0.4057061076,
0.2990448475,
0.3997409642,
-0.8480704427,
-0.2462941259,
0.0926009789,
-0.5189527869,
-0.3645863831,
0.1338780671,
-0.6135403514,
-0.3208358884,
-0.4202038944,
0.1525646001,
-0.4301896989,
-0.2038032115,
-0.0419661142,
0.1153890342,
0.3128186762,
0.2016138285,
-0.6627787948,
0.442351371,
0.8414655924,
0.7130768299,
-0.4691269398,
-0.3898437023,
-0.7186406255,
-0.3927131295,
-0.5603580475,
0.6395888329,
-0.67543751,
-0.1967364401,
-0.1294848919,
-0.7138514519,
0.0800403729,
-0.7783206105,
0.378498435,
-0.5208582282,
-0.0989988148,
0.2843920588,
-0.8476233482,
-0.1000861228,
0.2298009992,
-0.2293297797,
1.1246863604,
0.3582019806,
-0.3847475648,
0.5101225376,
-0.6995073557,
-0.5621874928,
0.4436843395,
-0.1482646167,
-0.3814489245,
0.2214939892,
-0.0513792112,
0.4421384931,
-0.8108718395,
0.3739448786,
-0.391744107,
-0.4715895355,
0.5191944242,
-0.145139426,
0.4981040657,
0.3299650252,
-0.3796038032,
0.2583892941,
-0.5619854331,
0.5174809098,
-0.2890785635,
-0.5327109694,
-0.1228982508,
-0.0931181684,
0.0810252577,
0.0719185546,
0.1937718987,
-0.3929585218,
0.0379290394,
-0.1419848651,
0.3126043379,
0.6552764177,
-0.1528407633,
0.3562672436,
-0.501470685,
0.674821794,
-0.3055779338,
0.1798277944,
-0.0007604079,
-0.4115374386,
-0.7050801516,
-0.577472806,
0.4162296057,
0.7277915478,
-0.3809990287,
0.7848782539,
-0.4676294923,
-0.9252043962,
-0.64704144,
0.52921772,
0.6544064879,
0.2848512232,
0.1753018647,
-0.403989017,
-0.2361633033,
-0.7006519437,
-0.2775416672,
-0.1648178846,
-0.156651929,
0.4106000364,
0.6917711496,
-0.178335771,
0.8228046894,
-0.6756546497,
-0.056436792,
-0.3451792896,
0.2320272774,
0.3461667001,
0.6085570455,
0.5728116035,
-0.636865139,
-0.5817795396,
-0.0736661628,
-0.6515489817,
-0.1086896285,
0.1497967392,
-0.0010547205,
0.2381789237,
0.2850140631,
-0.3600440323,
0.1601715833,
0.6823521256,
-0.420502305,
0.72114712,
-0.1099191457,
0.5060433745,
-0.8116771579,
0.4166455865,
-0.0346723087,
-0.1519067883,
-0.3868913949,
0.4525050223,
-0.0072014695,
-0.4031458497,
-0.3027429879,
0.5254122019,
-0.3538310528,
-0.0720162541,
-0.0231492501,
0.1585881114,
-0.1595042348,
0.4814377725,
-0.4389875829,
0.7800071239,
0.6113941669,
-0.5329552889,
0.4699922502,
-0.0098543316,
-0.8464125991,
0.6905551553,
-0.5168579221,
0.6530758739,
0.1612545252,
-0.1664578319,
-0.7639254332,
-0.2163769603,
-0.1125614643,
-0.8252356052,
0.2043269724,
-0.0528269224,
-0.7019714713,
-0.200680241,
-0.2748646736,
0.5118557811,
0.9189466238,
-0.2699359059,
0.3346796632,
0.5544149876,
0.0452551171,
-0.5025662184,
-0.6235014796,
0.2113405168,
-0.1399586499,
-0.7666169405,
0.1302988529,
-0.6278867722,
-0.4655603468,
-0.0487611592,
0.0871871561,
-0.2794231474,
0.2128495723,
0.2829268575,
0.5084245801,
-0.3525630534,
0.1296326965,
-0.367469281,
0.0005752354,
0.0594430342,
-0.2174378633,
0.4390565455,
-0.3913508654,
-0.3931667507,
-0.3393954933,
0.2292610407,
0.8041996956,
-0.5906940103,
0.4867500067,
0.4273622334,
-0.4323165417,
-0.1801737845,
-0.658611238,
0.1127200723,
-0.3691845834,
0.3854608536,
-0.1769925058,
-0.8709771633,
0.3032943606,
0.0652881041,
-0.0373527631,
0.1516837329,
0.679525733,
-0.0624445304,
1.1117720604,
0.4134674072,
-0.4603264034,
0.2446120232,
-0.1748880297,
0.477265507,
-0.6365508437,
-0.0360215046,
-0.6796595454,
-0.152428776,
-0.2752538621,
-0.5124306679,
0.2629679143,
0.1439210773,
-0.2648156881,
0.0341597944,
-0.2212591618,
0.630135119,
0.3208876252,
0.1671689302,
0.0451576747,
-0.0815255567,
0.0270273145,
0.0132236173,
-0.5447103977,
-0.5120619535,
0.9840223193,
0.2231256664,
0.6886321306,
0.0125155393,
0.7606360316,
0.7490550876,
0.7283260226,
-0.8960186839,
0.5581684709,
-0.2791484892,
-0.4249327779,
-0.2104383111,
-0.7671434879,
-0.530570507,
-0.1750890315,
-0.3196037114,
-0.8313238025,
-0.5017163754,
0.3035984337,
-0.3555273712,
0.0923862085,
-0.8037499785,
0.9900385737,
-0.5003510714,
-0.4084658623,
-0.5697617531,
-0.2200837582,
0.3674538732,
0.0005484205,
0.4376753867,
-0.3934077322,
0.0172098037,
0.690297246,
-0.2051974237,
0.6930101514,
-0.1518591642,
0.1746407896,
0.4361480772,
0.4050268829,
0.1483557522,
0.080383867,
-0.4853426814,
0.1983742416,
-0.2969908416,
-0.3905549347,
-0.6627007127,
0.7632213235,
-0.5945248604,
-0.4918765128,
-0.2581041157,
-0.7084545493,
-0.0460987948,
0.3303511739,
-0.0474509597,
0.599849999,
-0.1868624538,
0.1418621987,
0.3807469308,
-0.2998954058,
0.0494595617,
0.5207766891,
-0.2713156044,
-0.5390716791,
1.2043566704,
-0.2442444712,
0.31888327,
0.4614603817,
0.1039002165,
0.0330833122,
-0.7032260895,
-0.3603638709,
0.1408058107,
-0.6445379257,
-0.6758050919,
-0.1242188737,
-0.091686286,
-0.2601858974,
-0.3622546494,
-0.2582605183,
-0.0185985286,
-0.1273660362,
-0.0853795484,
0.2120901793,
0.6551041603,
0.0403385796,
-0.1597375423,
-0.9572758675,
0.1556797326,
-0.0554399192,
0.6259080172,
0.0230295192,
-0.5533102155,
-0.490788281,
-0.0727364123,
-0.0124127464,
-0.3770959675,
0.2595365047,
0.2226799875,
0.4456791878,
0.1170223504,
0.1642786115,
0.5536139011,
-0.2473560423,
0.7985026836,
0.3791123331,
-1.3192173243,
0.3865174651,
-0.1096745804,
0.4470728636,
0.743986845,
0.1622902006,
-0.4628452063,
-0.5442969203,
-0.3150051236,
-0.668882966,
0.5674756765,
0.088150315,
0.3436855972,
-0.1401207149,
0.3486329317,
0.0653610155,
0.1820480973,
-0.6083407998,
-0.0804474205,
0.1408150643,
-0.4364650846,
-0.1308837831,
-0.1269404143,
0.0673344955,
-0.1861957014,
0.5773980618,
-0.2986239195,
0.2308182716,
-0.1187304854,
-0.2970457673,
-0.1759827584,
0.1311750412,
0.6330254078,
1.033054471,
-0.1578728557,
0.0157305896,
0.2965742052,
-0.3983139396,
-0.0570340008,
-0.2611535788,
-0.1776970327,
-0.3906004131,
0.6686115861,
0.5818096995,
0.1306889206,
-1.0256435871,
0.6985629797,
-0.076801531,
-0.065078266,
-0.3591536582,
0.2733334601,
-0.0969331935,
-0.0368210226,
0.2346915752,
0.3042334914,
-0.0368950926,
-0.5813884139,
0.3399196267,
0.2997448742,
-0.6987782121,
-0.2699116468,
0.3280520439,
0.4146793187,
-0.6120340824,
1.1669478416,
-0.5232210159,
-0.5457238555,
0.7732487321,
0.4815715551,
0.9076926708,
-0.1801844984,
0.2120216191,
0.4581541717,
0.317057699,
0.2394992709,
0.4010902047,
0.1481336355,
-0.7074151635,
-0.5043792725,
-0.7124626637,
-0.2322031707,
-0.0783587247,
-0.6443387866,
0.4970368743,
-0.4983982444,
-0.0136976503,
-0.1633366644,
-0.066335462,
-0.7730562091,
0.2446546555,
0.27709198,
1.1532907486,
-0.691275239,
0.7344732285,
0.7319819331,
-0.4756934345,
-0.7238160372,
-0.0006096695,
-0.1739728004,
-0.6556309462,
0.6984901428,
0.2507786155,
-0.2604165673,
-0.1070559844,
-0.5428826809,
-0.6373899579,
0.9055762887,
0.5189176798,
-0.270735532,
0.1877572536,
-0.0182920713,
0.7445046306,
-0.7914124727,
0.4579865336,
0.5261515379,
0.4383685589,
-0.2783190906,
-1.0137828588,
0.1484934986,
-0.4824211299,
-0.2431780547,
0.3005780876,
-0.7082440257,
0.4538035095,
-0.643704772,
-0.1478282511,
0.1473632157,
0.5511908531,
0.1944322288,
0.3853448927,
0.5961808562,
0.4183558524,
0.7680469751,
0.0532563999,
1.1793175936,
-0.5677289367,
0.4186802804,
0.9248531461,
-0.4371898174,
0.9652884603,
0.2313464284,
-0.2001712471,
0.4386828244,
0.3202978075,
-0.3219938576,
0.2781791985,
0.7490252256,
-0.0320608243,
-0.4765307903,
-0.2255648524,
0.1162536144,
0.7371752858,
0.2488182336,
-0.1213552728,
0.2971685231,
-0.26096645,
0.2027120888,
0.4320702851,
-0.2588609159,
0.5803918839,
0.1469573528,
-0.9937006235,
0.7009897828,
0.0379144959,
0.5615186095,
-0.5802924633,
-0.2104230672,
-0.2528539896,
0.251283437,
-0.4406566322,
-0.7406067848,
0.2371319383,
0.3363359869,
-0.2431810796,
-0.009678442,
0.2400620729,
-0.2194818705,
-0.576335907,
0.3831518888,
0.2551499009,
0.2509428859,
0.2092671692,
-0.6120319963,
0.1073797941,
0.0484732278,
0.1551996619,
0.3353459239,
0.1192657799,
0.1152580231,
0.7963333726,
0.5246558189,
-0.0913933143,
-0.214361459,
0.1703073233,
0.6416630745,
-0.5580259562,
-0.363543123,
-0.8092396259,
0.5011156201,
-0.126814723,
-0.610614121,
0.5092943311,
0.9465147257,
0.8103166223,
-0.2285479754,
0.8852732182,
-0.4181392193,
0.3082458079,
-0.5330317616,
0.6433959007,
-0.4245504737,
0.2474662066,
-0.4806269407,
-0.9305086732,
-0.5528684855,
0.2390907556,
-0.3136557639,
0.045782242,
0.8238018751,
0.8266358376,
0.0698542669,
-0.4467116892,
0.4708767831,
-0.0024284506,
0.2689594924,
0.5835456848,
0.9435450435,
-0.1560546607,
0.5898399949,
-0.0200203471,
-0.5804210305,
-0.2790272534,
-0.9480916262,
-1.0293742418,
-0.5335308313,
-0.5478572249,
-0.2464458048,
0.0399641916,
1.1528197527,
0.7414604425,
-0.8399686813,
-0.6840206981,
0.2764630616,
0.2287786305,
-0.4463932812,
-0.2571009696,
0.3041625917,
-0.4897489548,
-0.4773329198,
0.2557712495,
0.3005751073,
-0.4116461873,
-0.2327950001,
-0.4224420786,
0.0431070775,
-0.0399486646,
0.5120510459,
-0.059094429,
-0.5363912582,
-0.4619463384,
0.2159770131,
-0.2596341372,
0.1021357924,
0.9657752514,
-0.3450199664,
0.2790291607,
0.4921494126,
0.7502038479,
0.1657187194,
-0.1115368232,
0.7368494868,
-0.5179597735,
-0.3214770257,
0.3564842045,
0.3466140628,
0.4986950457,
-0.354762882,
0.5291338563,
0.0014324267,
-0.7443417907,
-0.9146015644,
0.2909632921,
-0.7124981284,
0.0458786935,
1.0425728559,
-0.4741236866,
-0.0942716449,
0.1546785086,
-0.1424975544,
-0.0575165264,
-0.5505242348,
1.0306165218,
0.5679598451,
-0.2003228813,
-0.0138159059,
-0.3895334005,
0.361455977,
0.266680181,
-0.9966368675,
0.1987228841,
0.4934849143,
0.348688215,
0.2230324,
0.5172096491,
-0.0043886793,
0.5091481209,
-0.0062739421,
0.3784775138,
0.0535146073,
-0.2209946811,
-0.1024325266,
0.0858055577,
0.5889439583,
0.1477061361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14293v2 | Controlled Text Generation with Natural Language Instructions | 2023-04-27T15:56:34 | 2023-06-08T06:33:23 | Wangchunshu Zhou, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Ethan Wilcox, Ryan Cotterell, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models generate fluent texts and can follow natural language
instructions to solve a wide range of tasks without task-specific training.
Nevertheless, it is notoriously difficult to control their generation to
satisfy the various constraints required by different applications. In this
work, we present InstructCTG, a controlled text generation framework that
incorporates different constraints by conditioning on natural language
descriptions and demonstrations of the constraints. In particular, we first
extract the underlying constraints of natural texts through a combination of
off-the-shelf NLP tools and simple heuristics. We then verbalize the
constraints into natural language instructions to form weakly supervised
training data. By prepending natural language descriptions of the constraints
and a few demonstrations, we fine-tune a pre-trained language model to
incorporate various types of constraints. Compared to existing search-based or
score-based methods, InstructCTG is more flexible to different constraint types
and has a much smaller impact on the generation quality and speed because it
does not modify the decoding procedure. Additionally, InstructCTG allows the
model to adapt to new constraints without re-training through the use of
few-shot task generalization and in-context learning abilities of
instruction-tuned language models. | [
-0.1451829523,
-0.8920278549,
0.3598048389,
0.2993103862,
-0.4374816418,
-0.0798611119,
-0.612470746,
-0.2443966269,
-0.207277447,
0.9080504775,
-0.8483726382,
-0.6320558786,
-0.3868991435,
0.388320148,
-0.2779149711,
1.331651926,
-0.2314728796,
-0.1362320483,
-0.3328861594,
0.3913766146,
-0.4949217141,
-0.3831847906,
-0.2977512479,
-0.5278995633,
-0.2320150137,
0.6590087414,
0.6967398524,
0.685434103,
0.3739806116,
0.242632091,
0.1129802987,
0.5965710878,
-0.4280370176,
-0.0169250015,
-0.2334634513,
-0.2095619887,
0.267868638,
0.1046004966,
0.6042248607,
0.5480900407,
-0.0510099828,
-0.1623787135,
0.4149539173,
0.2394364178,
-0.5541396737,
0.0952755362,
-0.6066784263,
0.0030845813,
0.0160991102,
-0.3019491136,
-0.7483543754,
-0.6703251004,
0.1862774044,
-0.5806885958,
0.4047631919,
0.0749833658,
1.0172570944,
0.4676858783,
-0.6640844941,
-0.6757313609,
-0.9013359547,
0.8188856244,
-0.9225326777,
-0.0169903673,
0.4299229681,
-0.0043494767,
-0.6469464898,
-0.7617779374,
-0.3569509685,
-0.649625957,
-0.4498929679,
0.1909652501,
0.2116269171,
0.4682339728,
0.3170499504,
0.2716067731,
-0.2993125618,
0.2074598819,
-0.0476750843,
-0.1767024547,
0.5370705128,
0.1187171042,
0.2257765234,
-0.4960195422,
-0.4977166057,
-0.0747553259,
-0.7712723613,
-0.0659845248,
0.4547584653,
0.3778727651,
-0.2466011643,
0.7090396285,
-0.3144293427,
0.7807243466,
0.3741169274,
-0.1057163402,
-0.1772014499,
-0.3795445263,
-0.2845689356,
0.2237557173,
0.9166222811,
0.2332941592,
0.1615712792,
-0.1371483058,
-0.1451523751,
0.0672561303,
0.3629912138,
-0.961771965,
-0.106134966,
-0.1987854838,
-0.2179954201,
-0.3954990804,
0.0083950423,
-0.4759893715,
-0.1182265282,
-0.5818813443,
0.3808835149,
-0.6864767671,
0.2969483137,
0.1807486117,
-0.0385171734,
0.1659964621,
0.1983761191,
-1.0838736296,
0.4753505588,
0.3879001439,
0.424167186,
-0.1998593062,
0.07599096,
-0.8067190051,
0.371481061,
-0.2368942648,
0.3048837781,
-0.7127799988,
-0.3414373696,
0.2776746154,
-0.1256570965,
0.0182343088,
-0.3323011398,
0.5860590339,
-0.2084034532,
0.5879359245,
0.1814977527,
-0.9155742526,
0.0575510673,
0.1119116545,
-0.3497522175,
1.0316212177,
0.2690568268,
-0.8677248955,
0.5027403831,
-0.3186951578,
-0.8783345222,
0.2603223324,
-0.3585256338,
-0.5129001141,
0.0453895777,
0.3496679962,
0.5991986394,
-0.4350287318,
0.5501980186,
0.1485681087,
-0.1701201797,
0.0090197083,
-0.1672195196,
0.6040421724,
0.0258438773,
-0.537609458,
0.2129374892,
-0.8739295602,
0.3130145371,
-0.2494329512,
-0.7235820889,
-0.0962497294,
0.1640260667,
0.0177078135,
-0.022225704,
0.2444448024,
-0.4320933819,
0.3770581186,
-0.6383028626,
0.5885807872,
0.2725694478,
0.4596898854,
0.8197046518,
-0.1334607452,
0.5683047175,
-0.5929911733,
0.1435842514,
-0.160621047,
-0.3024784625,
-0.6060212255,
-0.0717415437,
0.109825626,
0.664255023,
-1.0360165834,
0.5075129867,
0.1470581442,
-0.3215389252,
-0.2414252758,
0.3180478811,
0.6434053779,
0.5681847334,
0.3114656806,
0.201432392,
-0.4788566232,
-0.9877631664,
0.0155962594,
0.0972235575,
-0.191640079,
0.2004319429,
0.4955054522,
-0.1673134416,
0.6946083903,
-0.5495974422,
-0.2207832038,
-0.4206720591,
0.61169523,
0.0049007842,
0.824465394,
0.356826365,
-0.6246882081,
-0.5949209929,
0.1679792404,
-0.4759057462,
-0.3750520945,
-0.5629172921,
-0.1848729849,
0.1949515045,
0.8517030478,
-0.6106515527,
0.4839840531,
0.4841712713,
-0.0122407814,
0.6619124413,
-0.5532773137,
0.0463117734,
-1.0500382185,
-0.3537133336,
-0.0673677623,
-0.2185345143,
-0.5193511844,
0.2106137574,
0.2380271256,
-0.0855542794,
-0.2636674643,
0.1906060129,
-0.4094073176,
0.7364721298,
-0.3348922431,
-0.1595781893,
0.1183699071,
0.6254227757,
0.27791664,
0.2672416568,
0.4324173033,
-0.8445385098,
0.2289440036,
0.4050317109,
-0.3848167062,
0.3225276768,
-0.6252164245,
0.2752436399,
-0.1091036424,
0.0818087012,
-0.5439383388,
-0.6248366237,
0.1369709969,
-0.0764518082,
0.6035960913,
-0.1871350855,
-0.7689462304,
-0.2009800822,
0.058178138,
-0.0540081374,
0.4616612196,
-0.5975031853,
0.373503685,
-0.2187036276,
0.1314898282,
-0.2470620275,
-0.6739551425,
-0.0641941801,
-0.1402339041,
-0.2796918452,
0.8316996694,
-0.1878578961,
-0.0296462271,
0.0303365681,
0.1860022545,
-0.1164585277,
-0.1002062783,
0.4097301364,
0.0344975889,
0.1384140104,
0.2374907136,
0.632299602,
0.10512086,
-0.0753008649,
-0.3471601307,
0.2851516008,
0.3580109477,
-0.2668029964,
-0.4952875674,
0.6154593229,
0.1444778591,
-0.2958589196,
0.5543188453,
0.3902089,
-0.4106554389,
-0.8803756833,
-0.1141084209,
-0.3616517484,
-0.5390833616,
0.2897652686,
-0.0786929652,
-0.9602795243,
-0.090052709,
-0.1462546587,
0.3543722332,
0.0193262473,
0.5564963818,
0.0309989061,
1.1950162649,
0.9183737636,
0.2675488591,
0.4659188092,
0.1772806495,
0.0090665631,
-0.2441848665,
-0.1826848984,
-0.5108939409,
-0.0295758415,
-0.7396638989,
-0.127859503,
0.1728451699,
0.449790597,
-0.190027833,
0.5154808164,
-0.9287416935,
0.4693767428,
0.8245152235,
0.2967946827,
-0.0508612841,
-0.2479865551,
-0.1626286954,
-0.2311871797,
-0.903223455,
-0.5936308503,
0.8119421005,
-0.164196223,
0.9350953102,
-0.2615712583,
1.0558022261,
0.0879914388,
0.6094042063,
-0.6535646915,
0.3733944595,
-0.3572331965,
-0.6529768705,
-0.1518749297,
-0.5257024169,
-0.6735106707,
-0.3604879677,
-0.6413962841,
-0.5827774405,
-0.3038770258,
0.4734392762,
-0.3248620927,
-0.0825017691,
-1.0260895491,
0.5734545588,
-0.3395553529,
-0.4273432493,
-0.040212743,
-0.4770296812,
0.4775367677,
0.0455791056,
0.011451032,
0.180528149,
0.3140128553,
0.5163338184,
-0.6550294757,
1.0217803717,
-0.0057711345,
-0.0074951211,
0.6379445195,
0.2383861393,
0.8855196834,
0.1441814452,
-0.0003565781,
-0.7339880466,
-0.1693866998,
-0.1151268482,
-0.4279929996,
0.6982925534,
-0.4381677806,
-0.6240392923,
0.1033192649,
-0.6418038607,
-0.2355998904,
0.3986335695,
0.9469646811,
0.5656732917,
-0.3046250045,
0.3158790171,
0.6543640494,
-0.559674859,
0.5028173923,
0.1013611481,
-0.0033978284,
-0.4934827983,
0.5818531513,
-0.174288094,
0.5980688334,
0.8176648617,
0.4211409986,
-0.268973738,
-0.6269429326,
-0.4144307375,
-0.0504972227,
-0.5326017141,
-0.3950936496,
-0.2181837559,
-0.1835177839,
-0.3932019174,
-0.5560162663,
-0.1721160114,
-0.125158146,
-0.6720924973,
-0.1869128346,
0.4564891756,
0.9501495957,
0.295681864,
0.7971324325,
-0.7052881718,
0.44953686,
0.4210843444,
0.4305906892,
-0.4656564593,
-0.3045771122,
-0.4686988294,
0.0177179333,
-0.2400641739,
-0.9435073733,
0.4573947489,
0.4004582167,
0.3329000771,
0.5818195343,
0.4498057365,
0.2975139022,
-0.6152426004,
0.6333118677,
0.2558619678,
-0.9760478139,
0.6642697453,
-0.426327467,
0.5965265632,
0.5517270565,
0.1942505985,
-0.0180720128,
-0.8332113624,
-0.396391511,
-0.6477020383,
0.7713077664,
0.3839645684,
0.3724265695,
-0.217368558,
0.6823251843,
0.2290253341,
0.1739633828,
-0.9085661173,
0.2323390841,
-0.3542940617,
-0.3900114596,
0.0902586654,
-0.1963869929,
-0.1920032352,
-0.1434960216,
0.61538589,
-0.1951660216,
-0.2507086694,
0.1734520495,
-0.2171399146,
-0.0599746481,
0.3461386263,
0.6252139807,
0.1239542812,
-0.2051474452,
0.1734326482,
0.0101073263,
-0.3037504554,
0.0390158333,
0.146487087,
-0.6125625968,
-0.0010015173,
0.5608689785,
0.8742037416,
0.3824040592,
-0.598972857,
0.2728965878,
0.0314717777,
-0.6537876129,
-0.0357725061,
0.3689510524,
0.036458835,
-0.0090083359,
0.0079321507,
-0.2017666698,
-0.2351072133,
-0.0217581987,
0.1130901501,
0.4336105287,
-0.4543506503,
-0.1109243706,
1.0618804693,
0.3583378792,
-0.3440764844,
0.5335437655,
-0.5342678428,
-0.4257366061,
0.5311271548,
0.8300790787,
0.8748869896,
0.1071012095,
0.3447664678,
0.4896568358,
0.7592499852,
-0.1548469365,
0.2072007209,
-0.1209371984,
-0.7461743355,
-0.7224653959,
-0.5523239374,
-0.4404332936,
0.2889330387,
-0.5056729317,
0.3668970168,
-0.8522409797,
-0.0617031194,
-0.0939630195,
-0.0670368075,
-0.6233862042,
0.3231474161,
0.0084089842,
0.702408731,
-0.7401980758,
0.7761966586,
0.4892509282,
-0.3013704419,
-0.8763009906,
-0.1546082199,
-0.2165222913,
-0.1338171065,
0.4792904854,
0.2733246088,
-0.2088989317,
0.1693952382,
-1.1501853466,
-0.3392265141,
0.5949961543,
0.5725382566,
-0.3667376339,
0.0303706061,
0.2892792225,
0.5006436706,
-0.4378576875,
-0.3077172935,
0.3081653416,
0.4708140194,
-0.0657236204,
-0.6847780347,
0.1885683835,
-0.0341966115,
-0.2790441215,
0.3751945198,
-0.2505976856,
0.5163000226,
-0.1946527809,
-0.4445565939,
0.0975824744,
0.698564589,
-0.0651415437,
-0.1020019352,
0.3149677515,
0.4593657553,
0.5296214819,
-0.0412211493,
1.0612778664,
-0.1809955686,
0.014986095,
1.3238654137,
-0.157893613,
0.4460433424,
0.5028964877,
0.2769230306,
0.4671339691,
0.4084672928,
0.0477040261,
0.5353159308,
0.2973160446,
-0.3604443073,
-0.3812022805,
-0.288184911,
0.0491982996,
0.483463794,
0.3234992325,
-0.4441143572,
-0.3242150843,
0.0552223735,
0.0397319123,
0.7781188488,
-0.2694742084,
0.7220544815,
-0.0813754946,
-0.9402700067,
0.6652639508,
0.2296150774,
0.7163590193,
-0.835550189,
-0.3089748621,
0.0021780697,
0.050101582,
-0.232329756,
-0.4584070742,
0.1204663739,
0.1015608832,
-0.1991697699,
-0.6480875611,
0.6920621991,
-0.6902888417,
-0.4395359159,
-0.1011221632,
0.0287694298,
-0.1941515356,
0.1031965986,
-0.1267873645,
-0.515022099,
0.3269107342,
-0.2120547295,
0.0416425616,
0.6044631004,
-0.2684034407,
0.5687529445,
0.4184967279,
0.0042564985,
0.2580895722,
0.0125370612,
0.6241184473,
-0.4998166859,
-0.5172796845,
-0.6678827405,
0.3388652802,
-0.0281680189,
-0.4761616588,
0.5948504806,
0.3808787465,
0.6961363554,
-0.2330552042,
0.8943603039,
-0.1490189284,
0.3143030703,
-0.9002596736,
0.5815228224,
-0.1353586167,
-0.0424183868,
-0.1571933925,
-0.5951708555,
-0.4688672423,
0.2747594416,
-0.129680112,
-0.3364292085,
0.6530351639,
0.8192826509,
-0.0088188956,
-0.1707774997,
-0.0789324492,
-0.1389444321,
0.4019083083,
0.676448822,
0.7243929505,
0.2600827217,
0.6948298216,
-0.6179208159,
-0.2506444752,
-0.0432639457,
-1.2696042061,
-1.2605122328,
-0.3919074535,
-0.5378388762,
-0.1591845751,
-0.4320490062,
1.1103187799,
0.7758886814,
-0.7687413692,
-0.0303660389,
-0.6435055733,
0.1636293679,
-0.2462486774,
-0.2548319101,
0.3569529057,
-0.4618086517,
-0.9360200763,
0.5782618523,
0.1315894425,
0.3748829961,
-0.0470525175,
-0.1813915074,
-0.2056283504,
0.2627515793,
0.463880986,
0.2364454567,
-0.2485587746,
-0.497954607,
-0.1719473749,
-0.4144616723,
-0.2826954722,
1.0063031912,
-0.6733466387,
0.542365253,
0.4938330054,
0.5561730862,
0.6371198297,
0.0352257937,
0.9136089683,
-1.3365354538,
0.3373613358,
0.2867343128,
-0.0257651061,
0.324560672,
-0.4752507508,
0.0000807495,
-0.2386059612,
-0.4516164958,
-0.6211842299,
0.5934137106,
-0.7473748922,
-0.372926116,
1.1850552559,
0.1305553168,
0.0084799677,
0.066683732,
-0.4792088568,
0.5619009733,
-0.2464820594,
0.724241972,
0.5605894327,
-0.163580969,
-0.1491596103,
-0.49838081,
0.9771419764,
0.257078737,
-0.9927549362,
-0.0220937356,
0.7086187601,
-0.0440483242,
-0.304875493,
0.1953944713,
0.2074744701,
0.0498316102,
-0.1360910088,
0.3313769996,
-0.06824141,
-0.1752202064,
-0.0445104241,
0.232425645,
-0.0503402613,
-0.17377837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14286v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14286v1 | Semantic Frame Induction with Deep Metric Learning | 2023-04-27T15:46:09 | 2023-04-27T15:46:09 | Kosuke Yamada, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have demonstrated the usefulness of contextualized word
embeddings in unsupervised semantic frame induction. However, they have also
revealed that generic contextualized embeddings are not always consistent with
human intuitions about semantic frames, which causes unsatisfactory performance
for frame induction based on contextualized embeddings. In this paper, we
address supervised semantic frame induction, which assumes the existence of
frame-annotated data for a subset of predicates in a corpus and aims to build a
frame induction model that leverages the annotated data. We propose a model
that uses deep metric learning to fine-tune a contextualized embedding model,
and we apply the fine-tuned contextualized embeddings to perform semantic frame
induction. Our experiments on FrameNet show that fine-tuning with deep metric
learning considerably improves the clustering evaluation scores, namely, the
B-cubed F-score and Purity F-score, by about 8 points or more. We also
demonstrate that our approach is effective even when the number of training
instances is small. | [
-0.600904882,
-0.7033174038,
0.6781489253,
-0.2591599822,
-0.5554246902,
-0.1357527971,
-0.4117520154,
-0.2958120406,
0.186549738,
0.4100998044,
-0.6762951612,
-0.9033730626,
-0.7114049196,
-0.0285332184,
-0.4011813998,
0.975764811,
-0.0609465726,
0.2053000331,
-0.1764452606,
-0.1999052167,
-0.8902890682,
-0.1700555682,
-0.2144618034,
-0.2789767087,
0.1422217637,
0.5723062158,
0.5732557178,
0.7513736486,
0.5468972325,
0.1860825419,
0.0280254725,
0.552578032,
-0.4922519326,
-0.1186871454,
-0.3758043349,
-0.5620920062,
-0.3512145877,
-0.026722854,
0.9116769433,
0.9326654673,
0.1204520315,
0.5052083731,
0.0459214747,
0.7142267227,
-0.7837728262,
0.3096494377,
-0.9817871451,
0.3650989234,
-0.1624864638,
-0.1605100036,
-0.2388391197,
-0.1253205836,
-0.1152685806,
-0.8266996145,
0.4093578458,
0.2093495727,
0.6438769102,
0.8540912271,
-0.2480644286,
-0.0261926334,
-0.5886896253,
0.5603160262,
-0.4566787183,
0.3072448075,
0.2612155676,
0.1694354564,
-0.3902608752,
-0.5564422011,
-0.5680265427,
0.0158600882,
-0.4595713019,
-0.0815591887,
0.1788975149,
-0.0465891361,
0.3632085621,
0.2500142157,
-0.5734211802,
0.4809308946,
-0.3311297297,
0.0853493586,
0.4958767891,
0.4190713763,
0.0683489293,
-0.2479773164,
-0.4163686633,
-0.0623795725,
-0.5435928702,
0.007877253,
-0.0686664283,
0.4621855319,
0.0857512057,
0.6413396597,
-0.6726764441,
0.5187203288,
0.3843249977,
0.2728503048,
0.6342998743,
-0.33643049,
-0.1671935469,
0.4574794769,
0.6088497639,
0.7324755788,
0.4301987588,
-0.3662283421,
-0.1549194902,
0.6191653609,
0.2292897999,
-1.0341426134,
-0.0121485181,
0.0275178496,
-0.3353290856,
-0.024191713,
0.5193996429,
-0.4913997948,
0.0222413708,
-0.546053946,
0.4438411295,
-0.3550634682,
-0.1803539991,
0.3307652175,
-0.1816746891,
0.2540491819,
0.1186841801,
-1.0014055967,
0.084320344,
0.9680691957,
0.663718164,
-0.2309202403,
-0.3779168725,
-0.8187837601,
0.0160809793,
-0.7238840461,
0.563790679,
-0.7356869578,
-0.1518224925,
0.0563385077,
0.4931851923,
-0.0116291968,
-0.5690870285,
0.254486531,
-0.3955168724,
-0.0622559227,
0.1690289229,
-0.9045488834,
0.1387178004,
0.0787758827,
-0.2436752021,
0.8459137678,
0.0601969659,
-0.571516335,
1.1205061674,
-0.7843449116,
-0.4794628918,
-0.0648189485,
-0.1066476554,
-0.3461781442,
0.5408119559,
0.6686086655,
1.0759308338,
0.2102025449,
0.6683722734,
-0.542739749,
-0.6422141194,
-0.0041218325,
0.0356906317,
0.1124453172,
0.2345411479,
-0.4655437768,
-0.0350919999,
-0.7209017277,
0.0916399136,
-0.1238684356,
0.1939094067,
-0.4204590917,
-0.225679487,
-0.2293883711,
-0.0595242567,
-0.1432530582,
-0.6846663952,
-0.1949096769,
-0.8424346447,
0.2933649123,
0.4480795562,
-0.0361883342,
0.9195067286,
0.0446975827,
-0.0537774526,
0.3458861709,
-0.3126871288,
-0.3812183738,
-0.1093305647,
-0.5779902935,
-0.0973815024,
0.4387644827,
0.2790063024,
-0.4479842484,
0.9730514288,
-0.5498697162,
-0.3633510768,
-0.5308825374,
0.2632542253,
0.4017136395,
0.5043128133,
0.6011762619,
-0.6904104948,
-0.1720474809,
-0.7260941863,
-0.1424211264,
0.5252019167,
-0.1315591633,
0.1381622851,
0.6180529594,
-0.3093301952,
0.9410162568,
-0.6545894146,
-0.6924838424,
0.272557199,
0.0481606498,
0.0159236509,
0.9586287141,
0.4673187733,
-0.6148149371,
-0.1511945426,
-0.1276431233,
-0.8256024718,
0.2058405876,
0.1475777775,
-0.2901331186,
0.0063817985,
0.7868732214,
-0.3753935099,
0.5959670544,
0.292458415,
-0.4916414022,
0.1919239908,
-0.1569645554,
-0.0247134864,
-1.2397867441,
-0.1355722845,
-0.0496995598,
-0.4469151199,
-0.1046300456,
0.0233283937,
0.0025151942,
-0.3666060269,
-0.4036521316,
0.5368227959,
-0.1452960074,
-0.2574212849,
-0.2758151293,
0.484313637,
0.2252502739,
0.4639177918,
0.3113735616,
0.4303768575,
0.505194068,
-0.6756894588,
0.249892205,
0.5157268047,
-0.7088733912,
0.607853353,
-0.3148294091,
-0.0964386389,
-0.2839525938,
0.5761252046,
-0.7576465011,
-0.29570961,
-0.0083820494,
-0.6294718385,
0.4211606085,
0.0024265076,
-0.3141124845,
-0.0127805918,
-0.0962561741,
0.4007251263,
0.3039109409,
-0.9879876375,
-0.0609208085,
0.3752907515,
0.4100313485,
-0.3024869561,
-0.6817302704,
-0.2040741742,
-0.2351591289,
-0.3965049684,
0.7220982313,
0.2961863577,
0.0318526253,
0.5084978938,
-0.0866575912,
0.1154808179,
0.4305022061,
0.5623189807,
-0.257303983,
-0.6449387074,
0.5343883038,
0.3634138107,
-0.7091432214,
-0.0577454381,
-0.6460808516,
0.3249492943,
-0.2417283952,
-0.4760617316,
-0.9101846814,
0.3681705892,
0.2889040112,
-0.513887167,
0.6855354309,
1.359708786,
-0.4502316117,
-0.2296627313,
-0.3826864958,
-0.4749673009,
-0.3530006707,
0.5091937184,
-0.3619536161,
-1.3991994858,
0.2182479799,
-0.5480828285,
-0.3385648429,
0.5518554449,
0.5466530919,
-0.1954896003,
1.0068068504,
0.6993675232,
0.0482781976,
0.5606802702,
-0.357560724,
0.0119179059,
-0.960660398,
0.0043482026,
-0.4159677625,
-0.606125474,
-0.8149935603,
-0.3317711949,
0.1588269323,
0.1726604253,
-0.5038999319,
0.2039563656,
-0.5362343192,
0.6423075199,
0.4746420085,
0.3694199324,
0.1139106452,
-0.2023634017,
-0.2252332121,
0.1551442146,
-0.7285544276,
-0.3712567389,
1.0052347183,
0.2572733164,
0.4909689426,
-0.1258275658,
0.839150846,
0.0214853846,
0.0878684148,
-0.6167379022,
0.06911318,
-0.5220835209,
-0.6005740166,
-0.4763192832,
-0.2644167542,
-0.7165477276,
0.0899823457,
-0.7152550817,
-0.9468172789,
0.2230962068,
0.1003912464,
-0.5911794305,
0.0321930721,
-0.6960300207,
1.3415694237,
-0.0472683832,
-0.2719265819,
-0.64270401,
-0.526268065,
0.4532212317,
-0.0678137094,
-0.0097464491,
-0.6891367435,
0.2921791375,
0.5687858462,
-0.3594946265,
1.0380519629,
-0.4990898073,
0.5395841599,
-0.0128428927,
-0.0049153292,
0.2503224909,
0.6643277407,
0.05988409,
0.1810591966,
0.1662614346,
-0.3938069046,
-0.6871500015,
0.5825903416,
-0.5021772385,
-0.5703291893,
0.187343806,
-0.3087885976,
-0.4547251761,
0.0758110881,
0.3171655238,
0.6532569528,
-0.25992015,
0.6227359176,
0.4743469954,
0.0618958063,
0.4171826243,
0.1407102942,
-0.2506681681,
-0.1796671003,
0.6586834788,
-0.1769597828,
0.0245572478,
0.5798458457,
0.1719269156,
-0.1793039441,
-0.3547511995,
-0.6963226795,
-0.1255193204,
-0.5223432183,
-0.2154053599,
-0.2865298688,
-0.0174865555,
-0.2391182631,
-0.4335741103,
-0.6088838577,
-0.2729228139,
-0.4091530144,
-0.4642057419,
0.1854167283,
0.3528621495,
0.0773707032,
0.5536516905,
-0.6897287965,
0.2963324785,
0.0633334219,
0.6149830222,
-0.0816788301,
-0.5019848943,
-0.3443228304,
-0.015880812,
0.0469811186,
-0.0164320264,
0.1441794336,
0.3442346752,
0.4725084901,
0.6033053398,
0.2414118797,
0.8388792872,
-0.8499034047,
0.6636462212,
0.3160175085,
-0.8880438805,
0.7264852524,
-0.0064908089,
0.2311643809,
0.7171999216,
0.4195387363,
-0.2109326422,
-0.4411160648,
-0.5410686135,
-0.5508890152,
0.4607491195,
-0.3674016297,
0.4568425417,
-0.0976709649,
0.4628841877,
0.2693275511,
-0.0429344811,
-0.2286645174,
0.2193609327,
-0.2616251409,
-0.2854912281,
-0.5289758444,
-0.2482274324,
-0.0075289598,
-0.5229356289,
0.251758188,
-0.5426391363,
0.0286130551,
0.1946745515,
-0.4595013857,
0.0874650031,
-0.0150883952,
0.5297395587,
0.7264744043,
-0.0985500813,
0.1147447228,
0.5096184611,
0.0585091673,
-0.0526723675,
-0.0446698405,
-0.0244904775,
0.1403886825,
0.3505603373,
1.1722463369,
0.609022975,
-0.22000058,
0.6828286052,
-0.2362179309,
-0.1407648623,
-0.4108541608,
0.3951919377,
-0.0595176406,
0.376779139,
-0.0645893738,
0.0399200767,
-0.2794644535,
-0.2183523029,
0.4936896265,
0.6778388023,
-0.6470442414,
-0.1159535423,
0.7803297043,
0.2254751027,
-0.2541973889,
0.5334538221,
-0.3261451423,
-0.3893377781,
0.3140370846,
0.5974519849,
0.8539853096,
0.2110642046,
0.0591704063,
0.5134603977,
0.0759735703,
0.1205178201,
-0.373803407,
-0.4562838376,
-1.1382956505,
-0.6049816012,
-1.0911414623,
-0.1669070572,
-0.3790808618,
-0.6417409778,
0.2314414233,
-0.5131635666,
-0.120789364,
0.2511630654,
0.0487143733,
-1.0485885143,
0.3422009349,
0.3664700389,
0.8236805201,
-0.9753015637,
0.8787936568,
0.4253291488,
-0.2565747797,
-0.8404054046,
-0.0500557199,
-0.0055089984,
-0.7499431968,
0.802878201,
0.6124021411,
-0.0697423145,
0.1062776744,
-0.2513759136,
-0.6831886768,
1.105576396,
0.1653984487,
-0.4585401416,
0.3324687779,
0.1469656229,
0.4728142321,
-0.9653973579,
-0.0790520832,
0.6326034665,
0.347401917,
-0.1204648167,
-0.672990799,
0.1819677949,
0.12225651,
0.0466651917,
0.0780228376,
-0.2803923786,
0.3015077412,
-0.0446747653,
-0.0552652255,
-0.0856447294,
0.9285222292,
-0.2773245573,
0.4850772321,
0.532714963,
0.8989691734,
0.7621381283,
-0.1908162385,
0.645126164,
-0.4436768591,
0.1655573249,
1.1001056433,
-0.1746931374,
1.0042433739,
0.3107250035,
0.1497239023,
0.5228411555,
0.5725026131,
-0.0754093975,
0.4387621582,
-0.0165577549,
0.1001266465,
-0.4360265732,
-0.1776780784,
-0.2007602304,
0.9677552581,
0.652877748,
-0.4502283335,
-0.3474037349,
0.1310749799,
-0.1057918891,
0.3729141355,
-0.5786104202,
0.9659553766,
0.2165330946,
-0.6330158114,
0.3686058521,
0.0849297568,
0.611813128,
-0.1283501983,
0.1647272557,
-0.2418220639,
0.4535274804,
-0.4009455442,
-0.6658988595,
0.7042915821,
-0.1645894796,
-0.3665613234,
-0.010262385,
0.6102575064,
-0.2772273421,
-0.5447168946,
0.2538382709,
0.3619231582,
0.0166882183,
-0.0339933634,
-0.154001683,
-0.2930198908,
-0.4109897017,
0.042309422,
0.6053384542,
0.6675675511,
-0.0884478316,
0.165460974,
0.956802547,
-0.137396574,
-0.1479914486,
-0.0757830888,
0.657728374,
-0.7305431962,
-0.498367697,
-0.9312639832,
0.4581146836,
-0.030471433,
-0.4728716314,
0.3297211826,
0.3737739623,
1.2339018583,
-0.081623286,
0.2915178835,
0.2796035707,
0.4029527307,
-0.9408246279,
0.6420004964,
-0.6052785516,
-0.0919706747,
-0.1301284134,
-1.0150055885,
-0.6950034499,
0.5436224937,
-0.5355870724,
-0.4019366801,
0.7764887214,
0.9663419724,
-0.2361051291,
0.1443105489,
0.5271919966,
-0.1103744507,
0.0521233864,
0.5386995673,
0.6430004835,
-0.0121532567,
0.0464360677,
-0.3322139084,
-0.2085535079,
-0.3384255767,
-1.0163803101,
-0.9251281619,
-0.7149138451,
-0.1573321819,
-0.1006504446,
-0.0379186124,
0.9118682146,
0.9602189064,
-0.8795176148,
0.3315426707,
-0.0338130668,
0.2769588828,
-0.1655520201,
-0.1870566756,
0.5253970027,
-0.9779047966,
-0.6655378342,
0.3615871966,
0.1267403513,
-0.4560474753,
-0.2358194441,
0.2102319002,
0.1942553818,
-0.541087389,
0.5163809657,
-0.1347953379,
-0.4779234827,
-0.8096927404,
-0.4026291072,
0.0546967871,
0.0636322796,
0.5016981363,
-1.0125538111,
0.1942817271,
0.204907313,
1.0641541481,
0.7290776968,
0.0943609476,
0.4766586125,
-0.9451807141,
0.4530116022,
-0.0663929582,
0.4637832642,
0.2681552768,
-0.3906100094,
0.5534849763,
0.2496280223,
-0.4718186259,
-0.6929008365,
0.1838169992,
-0.5954213142,
-0.3043013811,
0.9063472748,
-0.1037574485,
-0.4961802065,
0.3470465243,
0.1731657386,
0.1571712196,
-0.0575840957,
0.4645040631,
0.2487013936,
-0.0180105902,
0.3384223878,
-0.4679736793,
0.4763849974,
0.5280149579,
-0.2963893116,
0.0508765355,
0.4219333529,
0.3449935019,
0.231942609,
0.1372917145,
-0.0509076454,
0.228212297,
0.0822347403,
-0.2096339613,
-0.2611081004,
-0.4010190666,
-0.3777595162,
0.1726659834,
0.0829277337,
-0.5847663879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14241v1 | Entity-Level Sentiment Analysis (ELSA): An exploratory task survey | 2023-04-27T15:01:20 | 2023-04-27T15:01:20 | Egil Rønningstad, Erik Velldal, Lilja Øvrelid | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the task of identifying the overall sentiment expressed
towards volitional entities (persons and organizations) in a document -- what
we refer to as Entity-Level Sentiment Analysis (ELSA). While identifying
sentiment conveyed towards an entity is well researched for shorter texts like
tweets, we find little to no research on this specific task for longer texts
with multiple mentions and opinions towards the same entity. This lack of
research would be understandable if ELSA can be derived from existing tasks and
models. To assess this, we annotate a set of professional reviews for their
overall sentiment towards each volitional entity in the text. We sample from
data already annotated for document-level, sentence-level, and target-level
sentiment in a multi-domain review corpus, and our results indicate that there
is no single proxy task that provides this overall sentiment we seek for the
entities at a satisfactory level of performance. We present a suite of
experiments aiming to assess the contribution towards ELSA provided by
document-, sentence-, and target-level sentiment analysis, and provide a
discussion of their shortcomings. We show that sentiment in our dataset is
expressed not only with an entity mention as target, but also towards targets
with a sentiment-relevant relation to a volitional entity. In our data, these
relations extend beyond anaphoric coreference resolution, and our findings call
for further research of the topic. Finally, we also present a survey of
previous relevant work. | [
-0.5664916039,
-0.3992295563,
0.3977935612,
0.1509383321,
-0.4477100968,
0.307854414,
0.0743466243,
-0.5402564406,
0.5823618174,
0.0870726481,
-0.5058928132,
-0.7319297194,
-0.6581808329,
0.2716459334,
-0.395229876,
1.222250104,
-0.1826465279,
0.3945955634,
-0.4748097658,
-0.1292847693,
-0.2539424896,
-0.4573046565,
-0.7667883635,
-0.0517391972,
0.6996192932,
0.3394772112,
0.3404354751,
-0.0725589916,
0.3613340557,
0.1050268859,
-0.1996278465,
-0.1550185829,
-0.4131495357,
0.3321885765,
-0.2918929458,
-0.2753518224,
-0.6775516272,
0.1915522367,
0.6314155459,
0.6853214502,
-0.1123172939,
0.4172767103,
0.2406125665,
0.6436603665,
-0.7248634696,
0.3174986243,
-0.4517453015,
0.1578751653,
-0.2062652409,
0.2012631893,
-0.2519949973,
0.0704911724,
0.3435824811,
-0.4382810891,
0.2426066846,
0.3634256423,
0.9242566228,
0.0455257036,
-0.7055710554,
-0.6544396877,
-0.5768495202,
1.1755460501,
-0.2331451774,
0.5600485206,
-0.0986165628,
-0.3785156906,
0.5070870519,
-0.4680690169,
-0.553527534,
-0.1835936904,
0.0151930749,
0.4754793048,
-0.4159380198,
0.0064167269,
0.1667656153,
0.3296720982,
-0.1168516278,
-0.0085032955,
-0.2722681165,
-0.0716271549,
0.3763354421,
0.1083341539,
0.3665208519,
-0.4857020378,
-0.4548589885,
0.221123904,
-0.615922749,
0.2266092002,
0.5924421549,
-0.0564431064,
0.2187947929,
0.5972075462,
0.0361636728,
0.1714494526,
0.1891852468,
0.1593622565,
0.4866124392,
-0.0724425614,
-0.1788810045,
0.1823901832,
0.7773893476,
0.6292285919,
0.0849540308,
-0.2222982049,
-0.6366772056,
0.0696748123,
0.8061097264,
-0.6655828953,
0.2304493934,
0.2933900356,
-0.4974084198,
-0.3467711508,
0.1473593116,
-1.0344702005,
-0.4715107679,
-0.4770349562,
-0.0180342402,
-0.3567131162,
-0.594768405,
-0.4098195434,
-0.2164482474,
0.1398833245,
0.3817228377,
-0.576485157,
0.532495141,
0.9503355622,
0.8876197934,
-0.3935807049,
-0.2426775396,
-0.3030836284,
-0.0449124537,
-0.685056746,
1.0377289057,
-0.80348593,
-0.7252332568,
0.1907758415,
-0.3040724993,
-0.0726212338,
-0.5162230134,
1.0363295078,
-0.5739983916,
0.0660695806,
-0.7132329941,
-0.6052733064,
-0.1071953326,
0.3440702856,
-0.7281659842,
0.9615321159,
0.3408743143,
-1.0327222347,
0.649843514,
-0.6980291605,
-0.4908449054,
0.0164469071,
-0.3304128647,
-0.1984669417,
0.5193215609,
0.1593369395,
0.4518251419,
-0.732323885,
-0.069029808,
-0.2449413985,
0.1568870842,
0.0333888754,
0.2675887942,
0.4348340631,
0.1109613329,
-0.2155754715,
-0.0354579836,
-0.4722129703,
-0.2177860588,
-0.227655068,
-0.0847769752,
-0.7641944289,
0.1042677388,
0.003097458,
0.3069797456,
0.2703266442,
-0.7779532075,
0.3545829654,
-0.2015907168,
0.3097165227,
0.694806993,
0.4405918419,
0.9023566842,
-0.043524012,
0.9519641995,
0.2982001007,
0.1171574146,
0.2693154812,
-0.3473960161,
-0.5839300752,
-0.2038214207,
0.3480807543,
0.1452585757,
-0.8558660746,
-0.0388753228,
-0.6364148259,
-0.5170699358,
-0.89769274,
-0.0316935927,
0.3146808445,
0.9120909572,
0.3671526611,
-0.2482607663,
-0.1582043618,
-1.2921711206,
-0.6325845122,
-0.4654548764,
0.1194989905,
0.2236915231,
0.7324854136,
0.0825176761,
0.5301631093,
-0.439635545,
-0.6394047141,
0.0158798601,
0.4539574683,
-0.1248552576,
0.1131043732,
0.7432380319,
-0.9410741329,
-0.5825377107,
-0.2511960268,
-0.4612590969,
0.0817377642,
0.1083020046,
-0.1695112884,
0.2475394011,
0.1857402623,
-0.9308569431,
-0.0277815647,
0.1345042437,
-0.1246857941,
0.2481636852,
0.371409744,
0.4013325572,
-0.9409627914,
-0.0652415007,
0.2959627211,
0.2391290516,
-0.7543104887,
0.0276659839,
0.0669171438,
0.2578987181,
-0.4175077081,
0.4122460186,
-0.6636026502,
0.0611216389,
0.1239460111,
-0.0085998885,
-0.0161650795,
0.273358494,
0.209555909,
0.5873162746,
0.9381330609,
-0.4220236242,
0.0988500714,
0.2080741525,
-0.2285696864,
1.3204776049,
-0.486002773,
0.260732621,
-0.493011862,
-0.0561392941,
-0.9306562543,
-0.1312111914,
0.3417841196,
-0.6604231,
0.4158245921,
-0.2766772509,
-0.6056889892,
-0.1087481305,
-0.6249392033,
0.1301816702,
0.4708586931,
-0.0561729819,
1.1090466976,
0.6561762691,
-0.2382523268,
-0.6309726834,
-0.4809605479,
0.1576578617,
-0.4078475237,
-0.4131334126,
0.3918334842,
0.1049158275,
-0.5790685415,
0.222112298,
-0.3992727399,
-0.1286581755,
-0.1855126917,
0.4027604163,
0.190376386,
-0.0886838883,
0.321297586,
0.3785903752,
0.2271019965,
0.5599709153,
-0.3192048967,
0.2867327332,
-0.1570955664,
-0.0029578093,
-0.0448118038,
0.5735762119,
0.6590598226,
-0.3593926132,
0.9412293434,
0.4343984127,
-0.6999610066,
-0.3018231094,
-0.5258553624,
0.2066597939,
-0.2501047254,
0.1271373183,
-0.5117163062,
-0.5086237192,
0.4194532931,
0.3095099628,
0.164176017,
0.9425500631,
0.5873297453,
-0.1766786575,
1.0623573065,
0.2944005728,
-0.2951262891,
0.3270928264,
-0.370851934,
0.3630914986,
-1.1490654945,
-0.3657575548,
-0.7247004509,
-0.2526074946,
-0.3422904611,
0.1374679804,
0.3807987273,
0.0683852211,
0.0943635181,
0.1013329923,
-0.4227394462,
-0.1909120828,
0.2191612571,
-0.2793083191,
-0.0509801097,
-0.0803290009,
-0.1075726748,
-0.135169521,
-0.2310624719,
-0.746560216,
0.7249521017,
0.3335932493,
0.4787383378,
0.0967797861,
0.9449018836,
0.447586149,
0.7698610425,
-0.9671626091,
0.5192500353,
0.2153955251,
-0.6377478242,
-0.245079577,
-0.2976291776,
-0.8138877749,
0.1588437706,
-0.117489852,
-0.7388004065,
0.2976312339,
-0.1007618457,
-0.2240337729,
-0.0425716005,
-0.5102247596,
0.7829710841,
0.1183234006,
-0.2234262377,
-0.1548948139,
-0.238769874,
0.1591839492,
-0.3093588948,
0.4382765591,
-0.1245621443,
-0.5610111356,
0.9755502343,
-0.1922303736,
0.5596921444,
-0.375628829,
-0.3498035967,
0.5143674016,
0.211855635,
0.2070989907,
0.1955282539,
-0.2478077114,
0.1090356708,
0.132874459,
-0.1373938173,
-0.5127702355,
1.0040018559,
-0.8165437579,
-0.5455085635,
-0.5669910312,
-0.2007274479,
-0.2765194476,
0.3322426379,
0.2527799606,
0.323500663,
-0.1160968095,
0.0681032687,
0.5711647868,
0.3097254038,
0.2449722737,
0.3664186597,
0.021171594,
-0.429962337,
0.8318652511,
0.6075527668,
-0.0081411581,
0.590734005,
-0.083057031,
-0.3514699042,
-0.5672501922,
-0.4590971768,
0.1038454995,
-0.8726180792,
-0.2982626259,
-0.9744335413,
0.3349066377,
-0.7056692839,
0.1494750082,
-0.3678795099,
-0.2897597849,
-0.6785290837,
-0.3057096004,
-0.0294542834,
0.8460694551,
0.3342458606,
-0.0519251041,
-0.7809734344,
0.3361305594,
0.0007950279,
0.0775966197,
0.2383669913,
-0.2623497248,
0.0214333162,
-0.1206556186,
-0.2187616825,
-1.2947818041,
0.3885148764,
0.0871050581,
0.4970594943,
0.3856090009,
0.1766631752,
0.4527251422,
-0.4407885075,
1.2439484596,
0.2199151665,
-1.1784780025,
0.3178731203,
-0.1095512882,
-0.2054087967,
0.4677213728,
0.9833273292,
-0.4579277635,
-0.3821254969,
-0.7996336818,
-0.9863144159,
0.487416774,
0.3064509034,
0.3256123662,
-0.2871489227,
0.5883848071,
-0.0811520815,
0.7754969597,
-0.3546141982,
-0.3047755361,
-0.0413955711,
-0.2578498125,
0.0915239453,
-0.3629619181,
0.0460718237,
0.1109292507,
0.8472985625,
-0.0064055845,
0.3827617168,
0.4238488376,
-0.1643728763,
-0.4218458235,
0.3568250835,
0.2546177208,
0.687143445,
0.1000393704,
0.1512487978,
0.2285194844,
-0.4703356624,
-0.0367696099,
0.0466285534,
-0.3577780426,
0.1548259258,
0.6293298006,
0.4947544932,
0.0827598199,
-0.2979048491,
0.7152643204,
-0.0620656572,
-0.0042739087,
-0.5367919207,
-0.2205398232,
0.1984284371,
0.1083755717,
0.4283528924,
-0.0443038382,
0.5456092954,
-0.7378151417,
-0.2683267593,
0.6345731616,
-0.8909493089,
-0.6172779799,
0.5635092854,
0.0383421369,
-0.2511529028,
0.5450741649,
-0.3551450372,
-0.519269824,
0.5099695921,
-0.2276746035,
1.0712836981,
-0.1559414268,
0.2747945189,
0.2182413489,
0.2429774553,
-0.0938285291,
0.4476124346,
0.0753022954,
-0.6007866263,
-0.0673196316,
-0.8104553223,
-0.292400986,
-0.1299976707,
-1.1709449291,
0.3788239658,
-0.2202161402,
-0.5451306701,
0.4735292792,
-0.128470242,
-0.8971893787,
0.3796821535,
-0.0544108637,
0.8705069423,
-0.5641759634,
0.4209637344,
1.2381072044,
-0.9377307296,
-0.6911391616,
0.200277701,
-0.07653559,
-0.3532186449,
0.7646590471,
0.0725163743,
-0.3088691831,
-0.0444428511,
-0.6152718663,
-0.5800945163,
0.9637493491,
-0.0120855467,
-0.4411156178,
-0.567769289,
0.0411884263,
0.9511212707,
-0.7994278669,
0.1670265347,
0.3878062367,
0.2926018536,
-0.2552297711,
-0.6874076128,
0.0425349735,
-0.3509386778,
-0.1356910467,
0.3142297864,
-0.7581686974,
0.984341383,
0.2646387219,
-0.2285159081,
-0.2389804274,
0.9975281954,
-0.433688879,
0.3437645435,
0.8811150789,
0.4789810181,
0.6197012663,
0.0215023886,
1.2229861021,
-0.516944468,
0.5644954443,
0.760263741,
-0.4729589224,
0.8060923815,
0.7377735376,
0.1065958142,
0.5126358271,
0.5342569351,
0.0747476518,
0.497690618,
0.3052969277,
-0.3084012568,
-0.1599539816,
-0.6093424559,
0.0342488028,
0.0233660024,
0.5095589757,
-0.4586038589,
-0.0298987404,
0.1480147541,
0.0307492781,
-0.1771114469,
-0.654168129,
0.7447078228,
0.4168814719,
-0.9358684421,
-0.0665292963,
0.04871393,
0.2082591653,
-0.1866215318,
-0.1012266129,
0.0803314447,
-0.1605802178,
-0.3757799268,
-1.0311260223,
0.2201439887,
0.2213876694,
-0.2020223439,
-0.3342249095,
0.6667913198,
-0.1450118572,
-0.3587027788,
0.3321519792,
0.6262800694,
0.093801409,
-0.2236823291,
-0.6298165917,
-0.0347042158,
-0.2064979225,
-0.6195654273,
0.0883565843,
0.7827305198,
-0.0194260236,
0.3124998212,
0.1361165941,
0.0805919766,
-0.1739046872,
0.3132144213,
1.010442853,
-0.4648290575,
-0.3480890989,
-0.7327963114,
0.4571874142,
-0.1948694736,
-0.5785578489,
0.6899756193,
0.6304333806,
0.9458001256,
-0.2350358367,
0.8560971618,
-0.1844687015,
0.7940353751,
-0.4138359427,
0.3184230328,
-0.650372684,
0.2039836943,
-0.598002553,
-1.162312746,
0.0241024997,
0.3691301346,
-0.4997744858,
0.0845984891,
0.7636393905,
0.4207597971,
0.0032468482,
-0.0001910419,
0.0833239257,
0.2488551289,
0.3315128982,
0.2076022923,
1.1995503902,
-0.0715547502,
0.2879805863,
-0.2843281329,
0.0473281704,
0.1272881627,
-0.8472749591,
-1.0106115341,
-0.7214255929,
-0.6371851563,
-0.4566543102,
-0.0643390715,
1.0332432985,
0.1795446277,
-0.575907588,
0.2200552076,
0.0649782419,
0.1268575937,
-0.0679487288,
-0.2651814818,
0.3425880075,
-0.3545750976,
-1.0791444778,
-0.2043806612,
0.1293969005,
-0.2673155367,
-0.3760899603,
0.1927728951,
0.1431658417,
0.2549222112,
0.499694258,
-0.2952198982,
-0.6016628146,
-0.4282008708,
0.2416823655,
-0.0395518206,
0.0879395753,
1.0026487112,
-0.2245542258,
0.2260600179,
0.4798263907,
0.3371692598,
0.1725809872,
-0.0511488356,
0.1562313437,
-0.6034504175,
-0.637601912,
0.6684387326,
0.6075715423,
0.3946589828,
-0.5613143444,
0.2448805869,
0.077008307,
-0.3442004323,
-0.7783026695,
0.2118169069,
-0.9579712152,
-0.0230900701,
1.2197146416,
-0.3051510751,
-0.263323158,
0.1546087712,
-0.2910495102,
0.131438002,
-0.9838459492,
0.6880232692,
1.0948523283,
-0.2785445452,
-0.0133188283,
-0.551851511,
0.5272800326,
0.1408342123,
-0.777043283,
-0.2509511113,
0.5696725249,
0.2797652483,
0.6626446843,
0.6998038888,
-0.0368003286,
0.0052753082,
-0.099108994,
0.0326283835,
0.3539249003,
-0.5005922914,
-0.3980750442,
0.607150197,
0.2412607968,
0.0585810803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14238v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14238v2 | The Intended Uses of Automated Fact-Checking Artefacts: Why, How and Who | 2023-04-27T14:55:23 | 2023-11-08T12:10:49 | Michael Schlichtkrull, Nedjma Ousidhoum, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated fact-checking is often presented as an epistemic tool that
fact-checkers, social media consumers, and other stakeholders can use to fight
misinformation. Nevertheless, few papers thoroughly discuss how. We document
this by analysing 100 highly-cited papers, and annotating epistemic elements
related to intended use, i.e., means, ends, and stakeholders. We find that
narratives leaving out some of these aspects are common, that many papers
propose inconsistent means and ends, and that the feasibility of suggested
strategies rarely has empirical backing. We argue that this vagueness actively
hinders the technology from reaching its goals, as it encourages overclaiming,
limits criticism, and prevents stakeholder feedback. Accordingly, we provide
several recommendations for thinking and writing about the use of fact-checking
artefacts. | [
-0.9394623041,
-0.7010213733,
1.1240715981,
-0.1019899324,
-0.6258519888,
0.1203691065,
0.2038762718,
-0.7083081603,
0.4092023671,
0.2317808419,
-0.4090938866,
-0.2209560573,
-0.906572938,
0.405510813,
-0.7673279047,
1.0978705883,
-0.4186423123,
-0.5856742263,
-0.0914856568,
-0.2690560222,
0.063299112,
-0.5252682567,
-0.0783281699,
-0.1402248293,
0.7561894655,
0.6792080998,
1.0196285248,
0.5320365429,
0.3848605156,
0.2574472129,
-0.0476754196,
0.6099838614,
-0.3867606819,
-0.2329069227,
-0.1601011902,
-0.4342168272,
0.0178716928,
0.5707125068,
0.2701294124,
0.6462715864,
0.3457983136,
0.5865856409,
-0.0070059937,
0.1348066926,
-1.0180420876,
0.0646702275,
-0.188582018,
0.1169290617,
-0.378536582,
-0.3998137116,
-0.1041900367,
-0.4552313685,
0.0539356507,
-0.9276944399,
0.1358397156,
0.2794539928,
0.9408676624,
0.501482904,
-0.5398308039,
-0.8962065578,
-0.8526214361,
0.7134572864,
-0.3062343001,
0.0508391112,
0.9812572598,
-0.0127971498,
0.0926824361,
-0.6206677556,
-0.7219859362,
0.1798077077,
-0.6195386648,
0.1136435419,
-0.0588262752,
-0.0808874741,
0.4916205108,
0.1342802793,
-0.1798737943,
-0.2717297375,
-0.5299462676,
-0.3071364164,
0.4979623258,
-0.2184356898,
0.057777565,
-0.2220514864,
-0.474437803,
0.386302352,
-0.5779479742,
-0.0910099819,
0.3425352871,
-0.2748549283,
0.3590382636,
0.79098171,
-0.1671067178,
0.4084817469,
0.1510393173,
0.1281974316,
-0.0596140549,
-0.3080834746,
-0.1696286201,
0.1525239646,
0.3885028064,
0.4632073939,
-0.0407800525,
-0.3015780747,
-0.2758863568,
0.0236427505,
0.2923127711,
-0.5332562327,
0.0487351343,
0.5483617187,
-0.2632377446,
-0.237845391,
0.447946012,
-0.2992352247,
-0.5099532008,
-0.346359551,
0.5975471735,
-0.1003594249,
0.0730005056,
-0.04546367,
-0.6800175905,
-0.1242383644,
0.6104067564,
-0.6297726631,
0.2065086812,
0.6940946579,
0.7632029653,
0.1142838299,
-0.2559520006,
-0.4920811951,
0.2357243598,
-0.6101750731,
1.0470743179,
-0.2488808483,
-0.297179848,
0.1516142786,
0.0102367532,
0.319290489,
-0.1722195894,
0.8750342131,
-0.4078166187,
0.4270837903,
-1.0136830807,
-0.5980060101,
-0.5149154067,
0.1924248785,
-0.8258897066,
0.6825664639,
-0.3209801912,
-0.7235298157,
1.1061959267,
-0.5589532256,
-0.4582495391,
0.0754385591,
-0.1972240657,
-0.4690574408,
0.441693753,
0.1665448546,
0.515573442,
-0.334122628,
0.3953062296,
-0.025793625,
-0.6561994553,
0.4035143554,
-0.1307585239,
0.6567308307,
0.5205634236,
-0.571385026,
-0.1307593733,
-0.6528125405,
-0.323182404,
-0.2608765662,
-0.4041665494,
-0.5422273874,
0.2419432998,
0.1046153605,
0.059034165,
0.161221683,
-0.6053961515,
-0.327572912,
0.3394528031,
0.214887172,
0.5133770108,
0.0750657097,
-0.0185627285,
-0.9092894793,
-0.0287831724,
-0.1486924738,
0.2952581942,
-0.3127148747,
-0.4928916693,
-0.8072122931,
-0.1719879061,
0.3226129711,
0.1481309831,
-0.6042644382,
0.2782044113,
0.2795854509,
-0.5841822028,
-0.5790050626,
0.0134171601,
0.139802888,
0.0846357793,
0.1915840656,
-0.3733976483,
-0.4717466831,
-0.8161811233,
-0.5760302544,
-0.5418307185,
0.0729591101,
0.0011571508,
0.4905857444,
0.0689657331,
1.1860101223,
-0.1322112679,
-0.0646409541,
0.1472148746,
0.6746460795,
-0.0762042254,
0.003831496,
0.3634647727,
-1.1076481342,
-0.190916568,
-0.1616003513,
-1.1248100996,
-0.2339345217,
-0.5847148895,
0.2626979947,
0.2401070297,
0.4388701916,
-0.6891259551,
0.5944337249,
0.1092204452,
-0.5330789089,
0.4452936649,
-0.0915956721,
0.7146598101,
-0.5360193849,
0.2541774809,
0.2163461149,
-0.3162225187,
-0.520519495,
0.1391852647,
0.1686745882,
0.2124435604,
-0.5371757746,
0.2794329822,
-0.4358496666,
0.1525719166,
-0.4745007157,
0.0498880446,
0.1869636774,
0.1473496854,
-0.0081069758,
0.4112926424,
-0.0830506533,
-0.6262685061,
0.1299286783,
0.2685525715,
-0.4297177196,
0.9411394,
-0.5306369662,
-0.0760788694,
-0.0027171536,
0.0082569588,
-0.825209558,
-0.3757888377,
0.2687068582,
-0.4552840292,
-0.1026438922,
0.1963891983,
-0.6892619133,
-0.2202451974,
-0.4706072807,
0.0001197128,
0.3692623675,
-0.5389732718,
0.8130196929,
0.6535493135,
0.0241850093,
-0.4499303699,
-0.7741317153,
0.4849527478,
-0.5508354306,
-0.5039123297,
0.0228805151,
0.1716809273,
-0.6993462443,
0.085591048,
-0.3092626631,
-0.2423976213,
0.2586625814,
0.378251493,
-0.3129826486,
0.059213277,
0.278205663,
-0.0799276531,
-0.1729349792,
0.3139263093,
-0.024788307,
-0.1114777923,
0.135572657,
-0.7886686921,
-0.4745913744,
0.5083214641,
0.6474991441,
0.2005843222,
0.6293337941,
0.6703243852,
-0.293117553,
0.2157229185,
-1.0591387749,
-0.1752205342,
-0.4054254293,
0.1553324163,
0.059732724,
-0.676264286,
0.453099072,
-0.5175482631,
0.5297285914,
0.6143347025,
0.2900692821,
-0.5029121041,
0.3134840131,
0.5592563152,
0.2573597729,
-0.0123802768,
0.2452972531,
0.297763437,
-0.3964257538,
-0.1599829644,
-0.5896707773,
-0.0712342858,
-0.3156426251,
-0.1843871027,
0.3428784907,
-0.155568853,
0.0055254614,
0.2091614157,
-0.2761707902,
0.3358325958,
0.7461464405,
-0.0474157184,
0.7428637147,
-0.2006019354,
0.3059301674,
0.1293615103,
-0.5356919169,
-0.8283377886,
0.8651835322,
0.3696499467,
0.7355448604,
-0.2031489164,
0.5951193571,
0.7998857498,
0.2389404625,
-0.668260932,
0.3867572844,
0.2909554243,
-1.0247209072,
-0.2867597938,
0.0652166456,
-0.6514385939,
0.1234453544,
-0.1402246654,
-0.3158459365,
0.5977371335,
0.1336121559,
-0.3435405493,
0.3011089265,
-0.804942131,
0.334931314,
-0.3335855603,
-0.2638623714,
-0.2086582929,
-0.5309824347,
0.2752361298,
-0.5390822887,
0.4465385079,
0.2920110822,
-0.0358509757,
0.8659681082,
-0.4965914488,
0.9454357624,
0.0146935889,
0.0569535494,
0.7976224422,
-0.0906879976,
0.4411281645,
-0.1034965292,
0.2038865983,
0.4434617758,
0.0502032451,
-0.2106967419,
-0.2011842132,
0.1236459091,
-0.6619557738,
-1.0345127583,
-0.7304233909,
-0.2955695987,
0.0829323977,
0.1416350156,
0.2846682072,
0.2495672852,
-0.3977910578,
0.3229846656,
0.600532949,
0.2175233811,
0.4113914669,
0.4726127982,
0.040595483,
0.0638922006,
0.8479729891,
0.6758508086,
0.1718684733,
0.028332077,
0.1879210174,
-0.0553858392,
-0.37799263,
-0.5159704685,
-0.040522445,
-0.7701271176,
0.2948210835,
-0.5792247057,
0.1300367415,
0.101123102,
-0.3028754294,
-0.0519612283,
-0.6861547828,
-0.2947466373,
-0.2028208673,
0.2352010012,
1.1813496351,
-0.3136101067,
0.1239406317,
-0.3475525975,
0.445165664,
0.3675200343,
0.036315836,
-0.3655239642,
-0.1083014011,
-0.4437914193,
-0.0655471012,
-0.2005353272,
-0.6911908984,
-0.2144224793,
-0.1005508751,
0.6591289639,
0.4881666005,
0.2775588632,
0.4228873253,
-0.1752526313,
0.5989438295,
-0.0918271095,
-0.7669253349,
0.3353912234,
-0.1771625876,
0.1156893,
0.4784052968,
0.8765725493,
-0.5481011271,
-0.630807817,
-0.5023236275,
-0.7772003412,
0.6054919958,
0.4175644219,
-0.2934496105,
-0.0399152115,
-0.0530063137,
0.3753162622,
0.3155446649,
-0.497751087,
-0.2404219061,
-0.3245494962,
0.1157912239,
0.3726039529,
-0.4506288469,
-0.7135087848,
0.2377508879,
0.6362662315,
-0.076438427,
0.0030370345,
0.4394186139,
-0.3001528978,
-0.5831074715,
0.2211899459,
0.3544284701,
0.8861019611,
-0.0071163517,
0.2729186714,
0.0818710774,
-0.4692258537,
-0.0137344673,
0.2989068925,
-0.7573739886,
0.171053037,
0.2884811759,
0.3212933838,
0.1715201437,
-0.3116790354,
0.1432160288,
0.0100687165,
-0.4217894375,
-0.4905232489,
-0.1056086645,
0.115186058,
0.1511587501,
0.8017172813,
0.2683268785,
0.2192632705,
-0.8725436926,
0.2469061166,
0.3113339841,
-0.3400360346,
-0.1062711924,
0.4331611693,
0.2481709868,
-0.2136808485,
0.0280113798,
-0.1484774649,
-0.3583707213,
0.4370125234,
-0.186321035,
0.49862203,
0.0690027028,
0.3752751648,
-0.0565161072,
0.8390122652,
-0.1620858461,
0.0645818114,
-0.2489558607,
-0.3791685402,
-0.3814821541,
-0.1994396746,
-0.5973098278,
-0.0944481194,
-0.3313524723,
0.4183171093,
-0.4595361948,
-0.3575492799,
0.220678255,
-0.1098362058,
-0.6054231524,
0.2233524472,
-0.0187734179,
0.7999227643,
-0.888029933,
0.0280676987,
0.4806102812,
-0.666449666,
-0.2907425463,
0.2575658262,
0.6547322273,
-0.5196365714,
0.2526449859,
-0.0875093043,
-0.1036840156,
-0.5279985666,
-0.7407533526,
-0.937980473,
0.7415428162,
-0.0362688191,
-0.2498988211,
0.1825450659,
0.2497353256,
0.2413436025,
0.0678726956,
0.2612476647,
0.4111540616,
0.883010447,
0.2688143253,
-0.9036029577,
0.244969517,
-0.2088141292,
-0.6580919623,
-0.0104451431,
-0.796413064,
0.6594574451,
-0.0758189857,
-0.477499485,
-0.1655159891,
0.4579038024,
-0.0654429048,
0.6381226182,
0.4172849953,
0.3662799895,
0.7527933717,
-0.2073543072,
0.9193882346,
0.029207319,
0.1497629583,
0.6071130037,
-0.1824343801,
0.227337867,
0.6145265698,
0.0049876319,
0.221562773,
0.7837635875,
-0.0764579549,
0.3977961838,
-0.2874535322,
-0.023795737,
-0.3259648085,
-0.2748661935,
-0.067746833,
0.2750914991,
0.6636203527,
-0.2501275241,
-0.2047993839,
-0.4098864198,
0.1007678956,
-0.0737801194,
-0.0225598123,
0.8106848598,
-0.0772869587,
-0.7413415313,
0.2474385053,
-0.1996394992,
0.4223283529,
-0.3092705011,
-0.0247953907,
0.1672013253,
-0.3409387171,
-0.4941624999,
-0.9036054611,
0.5094778538,
0.0786651224,
0.0635989457,
-0.1551545411,
0.6895689964,
0.0610038042,
-0.2708455026,
-0.1600890309,
0.9007933736,
0.0995401666,
-0.1731925607,
-0.2636293173,
0.0291682798,
-0.2518797219,
-0.3909089863,
0.0654439554,
0.8687272072,
-0.1292391717,
0.346306026,
0.5491472483,
-0.0447148271,
-0.3113595545,
-0.1043527722,
0.8044048548,
-0.5140022039,
-0.3239182532,
-0.7301383018,
0.5770978928,
-0.3887683749,
-0.5324705243,
1.0472222567,
0.502587676,
0.8679669499,
0.3457277119,
1.0861283541,
-0.2371653169,
0.4285112023,
-0.2674105465,
0.7966716886,
-0.475336045,
0.0396218784,
-0.2412769496,
-0.767793417,
-0.2203098834,
0.5150849223,
-0.1118578687,
0.085123539,
0.9458201528,
0.2093747705,
-0.0971535966,
0.5954890847,
0.3970312774,
0.2464589626,
0.2038516253,
-0.1126162857,
0.8887699246,
-0.1996220052,
0.3855918646,
-0.0285026003,
-0.4022919834,
-0.4577213228,
-0.8321171403,
-1.0585985184,
-0.7274190784,
-0.3830749094,
-0.0954169407,
0.2758817673,
0.7613228559,
0.6759737134,
-0.7688006759,
0.0117886811,
0.2126909643,
0.245433718,
0.0407914445,
-0.057581421,
0.3514678478,
-0.1639437079,
-0.3639847338,
-0.1798272878,
0.3307459652,
-0.2578907013,
-0.4423024058,
0.2607528269,
-0.4612649083,
0.35110116,
0.3384987116,
0.4474489689,
-0.779571116,
-0.4032407701,
-0.1164289787,
0.0215685274,
-0.2117052823,
0.9390079379,
-0.5814294815,
0.5711043477,
0.1038632616,
0.5891253948,
0.3593867421,
0.0637963563,
0.4398754835,
-0.3470726609,
-0.1372279972,
0.1501324922,
0.5249982476,
0.3562369347,
-0.6151573062,
0.5386434197,
0.2821826935,
-0.6919921041,
-0.4221113026,
-0.013070534,
-0.4921011925,
-0.4182342291,
1.0243213177,
-0.120948419,
-0.4471734762,
-1.0045484304,
-0.1401414275,
0.1159778163,
-0.4039225876,
1.3692677021,
1.0903881788,
-0.0008054868,
0.315471679,
-0.4273495674,
0.60043329,
0.1521524787,
-0.7159101963,
-0.006556679,
0.5854429603,
0.0343907997,
0.5583882332,
0.5961489081,
-0.0301101189,
0.6265311241,
0.1054179296,
-0.154019013,
-0.1315160692,
-0.3672317863,
0.2363913655,
0.2175108641,
0.1637627929,
0.1504013985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14233v2 | Large Language Models are Strong Zero-Shot Retriever | 2023-04-27T14:45:55 | 2023-08-02T02:06:28 | Tao Shen, Guodong Long, Xiubo Geng, Chongyang Tao, Tianyi Zhou, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | In this work, we propose a simple method that applies a large language model
(LLM) to large-scale retrieval in zero-shot scenarios. Our method, the Language
language model as Retriever (LameR), is built upon no other neural models but
an LLM, while breaking brute-force combinations of retrievers with LLMs and
lifting the performance of zero-shot retrieval to be very competitive on
benchmark datasets. Essentially, we propose to augment a query with its
potential answers by prompting LLMs with a composition of the query and the
query's in-domain candidates. The candidates, regardless of correct or wrong,
are obtained by a vanilla retrieval procedure on the target collection. As a
part of the prompts, they are likely to help LLM generate more precise answers
by pattern imitation or candidate summarization. Even if all the candidates are
wrong, the prompts at least make LLM aware of in-collection patterns and
genres. Moreover, due to the low performance of a self-supervised retriever,
the LLM-based query augmentation becomes less effective as the retriever
bottlenecks the whole pipeline. Therefore, we propose to leverage a
non-parametric lexicon-based method (e.g., BM25) as the retrieval module to
capture query-document overlap in a literal fashion. As such, LameR makes the
retrieval procedure transparent to the LLM, thus circumventing the performance
bottleneck. | [
-0.0431474969,
-0.7780669928,
0.7074735165,
-0.0305808429,
-0.2247466296,
0.1221419498,
-0.4765787721,
-0.4010815918,
0.2973893285,
0.6944333315,
-0.1779964566,
-0.6014739275,
-0.5594329238,
0.0421380587,
-0.483977586,
0.8167507648,
0.2495802641,
-0.2566874027,
-0.0287701972,
-0.2061698884,
-0.4946604967,
-0.4879331887,
-0.4307760894,
-0.3624331057,
0.8050409555,
0.3646533191,
0.4506253302,
0.7987214327,
0.280720681,
0.2449751049,
-0.1734134555,
-0.0424534418,
-0.7366413474,
0.4783210158,
-0.4943487048,
-0.6597798467,
-0.243299678,
-0.3266727924,
0.701977551,
0.6360390186,
-0.1427924186,
0.0825878531,
-0.2363687307,
0.2974217236,
-1.0213637352,
0.034302406,
-1.0636925697,
-0.054720033,
-0.5037077665,
-0.3661191761,
-0.585560441,
-0.0463163592,
-0.1063861027,
-0.2220130861,
0.2554194629,
-0.0349859595,
0.8380337358,
-0.1118443161,
-0.4451504052,
-0.0316417851,
-0.8543437719,
0.8955177665,
-0.8433334827,
0.2101860195,
0.3382286429,
0.5003330112,
-0.0347147621,
-0.4004361928,
-0.7041134834,
-0.3443380594,
0.0713496506,
0.0171621796,
-0.1545623988,
0.0279376544,
0.2854024768,
0.4288731813,
-0.6374049783,
0.2067989111,
-0.3756570518,
-0.0466606058,
0.6153365374,
0.2906692624,
0.1022699252,
-0.1508098841,
-0.1300681978,
0.0082707116,
-0.7771027088,
-0.2060669065,
0.2296643704,
0.5563480258,
0.2742332518,
0.9121388197,
-0.5524060726,
1.065464139,
0.047093153,
0.0370123275,
0.176638186,
-0.1971289068,
-0.0783691406,
0.1435612142,
0.8510956764,
0.0874574929,
0.1212256178,
-0.3808107376,
-0.492233336,
-0.3229700923,
0.2111100703,
-0.9232211113,
0.1413410902,
0.167382136,
-0.1298016012,
-0.1558349431,
-0.1357805133,
-0.8379160762,
-0.261646688,
-0.1928027719,
0.802865684,
-0.445486486,
-0.0276322588,
0.2089770883,
-0.0931416601,
0.665828824,
0.1199426129,
-0.7599164844,
0.0982215106,
0.8596349359,
0.8872103691,
0.1569148302,
-0.0769494399,
-0.9973227382,
0.3019979,
-0.5163831711,
0.6710000634,
-0.7790094614,
-0.3623247743,
0.1547636688,
-0.0734788105,
0.0532633923,
-0.6036227942,
0.4524362087,
-0.9647914171,
0.1173590049,
-0.121697776,
-0.6870673895,
-0.0008263489,
0.4979875088,
-0.6091762185,
0.9207105637,
0.01732466,
-0.4550072551,
0.0592777766,
-0.3509545624,
-0.417496562,
0.4427263141,
-0.3246163428,
-0.0586268753,
0.2803495526,
0.1445056349,
0.3397236168,
-0.407045126,
0.1681403965,
-0.3437255025,
-0.7086828351,
-0.0789600909,
-0.3580283225,
0.6221196651,
0.077199012,
-0.2345037013,
-0.1714987755,
-0.5923606157,
0.0127035314,
0.2127523273,
-0.4250680208,
-0.4618422985,
-0.2449292243,
-0.0548026115,
0.2985821366,
0.4236500859,
-0.8658978939,
0.3075816631,
-0.638332665,
0.0622463785,
0.3797697723,
-0.0668666139,
0.4784146249,
-0.1820986271,
0.5535649061,
-0.2160756439,
-0.2484159321,
-0.6107398868,
-0.0161563549,
-0.7039683461,
-0.3053400815,
0.423368901,
0.5543363094,
-0.8143933415,
0.4418367147,
-0.4769945145,
-0.4397371411,
-0.7299922705,
0.2844581604,
0.5158007145,
0.6832786202,
0.3950538039,
-0.1307386607,
-0.3399657309,
-0.7915990353,
-0.2730858624,
-0.0405526757,
-0.3021799922,
0.5951095223,
0.2437047958,
0.3186958134,
0.8408980966,
-0.7459533215,
-0.3518987298,
-0.3974080384,
0.1810691208,
0.6229214668,
0.1670806557,
0.291351974,
-0.5222115517,
-0.5906250477,
0.0211105067,
-0.9648061395,
-0.1413349658,
0.0537554212,
-0.068813622,
0.2882464826,
0.6124668717,
-0.9338287115,
0.1382268965,
-0.0048937681,
-0.1291549057,
0.5060389638,
-0.2756163478,
-0.0380933508,
-0.9997071028,
0.2859590054,
0.0286933426,
-0.1407321841,
-0.6115474105,
0.4349886775,
0.3510338068,
-0.146901682,
-0.4465613365,
0.8722190857,
-0.5470328331,
0.0928002968,
-0.4442837834,
0.2377405167,
0.0536811016,
0.1996068209,
0.0497623347,
0.6966356635,
0.6850441694,
-0.2994965017,
0.3230694532,
0.1599180102,
-0.2022491544,
0.8172732592,
-0.826654613,
0.251873821,
-0.6767544746,
0.2159574926,
-0.8319074512,
-0.1081138104,
-0.2020864338,
-0.3839550912,
0.6649823189,
-0.4532857835,
-0.5983521938,
-0.3358120024,
-0.4087878466,
0.3103402853,
0.4386240244,
-0.532279551,
0.5118764043,
0.0667211488,
-0.2435448766,
-0.7651138306,
-0.5260819793,
0.4861570001,
-0.129322648,
-0.3924690783,
0.327280879,
-0.0153813912,
-0.06214647,
-0.2206900865,
-0.1364577711,
0.0391463004,
-0.2691428065,
-0.1783956885,
0.4556925595,
-0.4466013014,
0.0532728583,
-0.3621058762,
0.0806427971,
-0.2456871271,
-0.254545182,
0.7254546285,
0.0922212154,
-0.3331237137,
-0.036707703,
0.4094519019,
0.6187726855,
-0.5530933738,
0.7477355003,
0.3424106538,
-0.1305264533,
-0.1405650675,
-0.9165334702,
-0.3044679761,
-0.4425113201,
0.3234396279,
-0.4265197217,
-1.1089962721,
0.3965090513,
0.2844253778,
-0.1241555959,
0.1796399504,
0.4727548361,
0.1770754158,
0.8121526837,
0.5471256971,
-0.3691178262,
0.3282943964,
-0.3275207579,
0.2226089835,
-0.9384523034,
-0.3908114135,
-0.638566494,
-0.2505135238,
-0.3310685754,
-0.561956346,
0.1577987373,
0.291385442,
-0.2008074969,
0.5645137429,
-0.2297290713,
0.7377374172,
0.4763211906,
-0.0394283421,
0.3750503957,
-0.0109858075,
-0.1480852365,
0.0251685809,
-0.6456099153,
-0.1173111275,
1.0878403187,
0.0642410219,
0.824247539,
0.2779791951,
0.8014802337,
-0.1718222946,
0.1167273819,
-1.0097680092,
0.5483111143,
-0.2130581737,
-0.7749201655,
-0.3450680673,
-0.5568466187,
-1.153088212,
0.5441923738,
0.0452392548,
-0.922639668,
0.2387942523,
-0.2515822649,
-0.4416097701,
0.2327026278,
-0.2748289406,
0.6316799521,
-0.2308127731,
-0.6490917802,
0.0009119709,
-0.6369392872,
0.4011169672,
-0.3443653286,
-0.1044885814,
-0.1379251778,
-0.2314283997,
0.2069589049,
-0.2388642579,
0.5451511741,
-0.0820097476,
-0.0273636952,
0.1877074391,
0.4473724961,
0.6596262455,
-0.2629790604,
-0.5955731273,
0.0780102387,
-0.2382071465,
-0.4726121426,
-0.7771066427,
0.9049297571,
-0.3586221635,
-0.7891991138,
-0.3711516559,
-0.768365562,
-0.1733574867,
0.4151551723,
-0.0569143705,
0.4954200089,
-0.0426241271,
0.6075916886,
0.5851176977,
-0.2083127499,
0.6637247801,
1.1761221886,
-0.0515397526,
-0.1233375743,
0.9247128367,
0.2168771923,
0.1289524883,
0.7172856331,
0.1287225485,
-0.5807935596,
-0.6592431664,
-0.3863674104,
0.4085075557,
-0.3381234407,
-0.5188682675,
-0.8170220256,
-0.364144206,
-0.3329090476,
0.0538838916,
-0.1484639347,
-0.1782999486,
-0.1689453423,
0.0956782997,
0.4528398216,
0.3225738704,
0.0370939001,
0.3462017775,
-0.8641093969,
0.2304638475,
0.0999469906,
0.4642488956,
0.1525389552,
-0.8525096178,
-0.0895173922,
-0.1733701229,
-0.2179145217,
-0.712982595,
0.6831563115,
0.3269537091,
0.5444487929,
0.3204174638,
0.1759071797,
0.6685955524,
-0.7113360167,
0.6312878728,
0.1045395732,
-0.5912370086,
0.55737257,
-0.7056335807,
0.5718291998,
0.7000243664,
0.483830601,
-0.4860727787,
-0.3925284445,
-0.403749913,
-1.1355073452,
0.7439473867,
0.1139932796,
0.5281866193,
-0.3284531236,
0.4420805573,
-0.2562508881,
0.2908587456,
-0.4330670536,
-0.0653773025,
0.1254020631,
-0.118220225,
-0.1109765768,
-0.2278327346,
-0.0475727692,
-0.0855862796,
0.5319079161,
-0.2780007422,
-0.0613709837,
0.1039690748,
-0.0914881006,
-0.1868301481,
0.4677481949,
0.1346189678,
0.5809283257,
-0.5406470895,
0.1666559428,
0.0172788668,
0.0045138546,
0.0406739786,
0.3168742657,
-0.2851634026,
0.1169697344,
0.2704878747,
0.6042460799,
0.2563763261,
-0.8892673254,
0.7556291819,
0.2582220733,
-0.1330709755,
-0.0535470992,
-0.0969195291,
0.0937157273,
0.31104213,
0.6230812073,
-0.572508812,
0.1609339118,
-0.6782923341,
0.4583450556,
0.7759299278,
-0.3916473985,
-0.0873673335,
0.6806671023,
-0.2531066835,
-0.4030991793,
0.747585237,
-0.1840111315,
-0.2506093681,
0.42827335,
0.8803759813,
0.6194689274,
-0.1638717502,
0.201968506,
0.3186686039,
-0.0082879681,
-0.2806151807,
0.210732013,
-0.0418730602,
-0.510479331,
-0.9043397903,
-0.8669496775,
-0.0714122206,
0.4512218535,
-0.5511186719,
0.4516127706,
-0.393389672,
0.2244013101,
0.1433861107,
0.0048398818,
-0.3489511609,
-0.0161057618,
0.167224437,
1.0916597843,
-0.4105328023,
0.8919084072,
0.4428191781,
-0.7754297853,
-0.7949485183,
0.0354223214,
-0.0050662099,
-0.8574747443,
0.6222600341,
-0.030802371,
0.0811228156,
0.0060196249,
-0.468559742,
-0.9499165416,
1.0261271,
0.5571720004,
-0.873795867,
-0.1124982759,
0.0597881153,
0.7553790808,
-0.2445399314,
0.5343619585,
0.4001882076,
0.1664699316,
0.8033933043,
-0.9098119736,
0.1736743003,
-0.0501735359,
0.1531986594,
0.4924256802,
-0.6928822994,
0.7610945702,
-0.132948339,
0.0138071356,
0.3036988378,
0.4567959905,
0.4735193253,
0.1836770475,
0.1389250159,
0.7179536223,
0.4829521179,
0.2723257542,
1.2503330708,
-0.3716246486,
0.3740293086,
1.301908493,
-0.6356147528,
1.205529809,
0.3944488764,
0.0819711536,
0.2281422466,
0.1645789593,
-0.1527093202,
0.4861930907,
0.3947622776,
-0.654597342,
-0.3691038787,
-0.4603895843,
-0.1680740714,
0.6360195875,
0.2133259624,
-0.3106440604,
-0.7407846451,
-0.2989953458,
0.1832511425,
0.1101332605,
-0.3253783286,
0.7718153596,
0.1109805033,
-0.6194628477,
0.7600200772,
0.173930347,
0.7692059875,
-0.6020495892,
-0.0830666572,
-0.5040547252,
0.1823808253,
0.0409178473,
-0.7893513441,
0.2918340266,
-0.0654440299,
-0.074778676,
-0.0225308165,
0.8868646026,
-0.7368835211,
-0.5744290352,
0.4630663693,
0.6253051758,
0.2888149023,
-0.410682857,
-0.4815109372,
-0.0604680516,
-0.2578085661,
-0.0332864225,
0.6186001301,
0.5656544566,
-0.1308252066,
0.5516706109,
0.7624364495,
0.3056043088,
-0.06361036,
0.2340536118,
0.9081993103,
-0.7829597592,
-0.0846535116,
-0.9709553719,
0.160019353,
-0.0903636217,
0.2459754795,
0.7929945588,
0.8408595324,
0.6465317607,
0.1010603607,
0.5285147429,
-0.0745770112,
0.4519308209,
-0.150977999,
0.7784667611,
-0.6846932173,
0.2990187407,
-0.0799324811,
-1.0770263672,
-0.4394886196,
0.369569242,
-0.3872745037,
-0.0598389059,
0.3630896509,
1.1683433056,
-0.2209720612,
-0.4002071619,
0.7082981467,
0.3701928556,
0.1837848872,
0.5921549797,
0.6712034941,
-0.3790002465,
0.8430126309,
0.0487204529,
-0.1128498837,
-0.2842393219,
-0.878534019,
-0.7067329884,
-0.0993172675,
-0.0687766969,
-0.3901131749,
0.2663343847,
0.6960875988,
0.7118447423,
-0.6405345201,
-0.3561142981,
0.1209738627,
0.0478611961,
0.2194512635,
-0.2832369208,
0.1377465278,
-0.4829899967,
-0.8099272847,
0.7336692214,
0.3913633823,
-0.2897841036,
-0.1713421196,
0.1639957875,
-0.5520433784,
0.1907379329,
0.8063728213,
0.5272040367,
-0.5811491013,
-0.1891924143,
0.3217378557,
-0.0657634214,
0.1209785789,
0.6881196499,
-0.9953522682,
0.5390115976,
0.5514333844,
0.828430593,
0.8528977633,
-0.0209651608,
0.6142044663,
-1.0227208138,
0.0504756421,
0.4591502845,
0.1609556824,
0.3933867216,
-0.4353659153,
0.3589166999,
0.0540742949,
-0.3872351944,
-0.7701321244,
0.0611580312,
-0.8380163908,
-0.3775624037,
1.2723302841,
-0.0234196428,
-0.2017757446,
-0.112162292,
0.0403122902,
-0.0875922814,
-0.5018991828,
0.8695765734,
0.5274681449,
0.0110365283,
-0.3318473995,
-0.6973503232,
-0.1418350041,
0.5063507557,
-0.4182234704,
0.0614816584,
0.5666669607,
0.5150612593,
0.1924077421,
0.6498923302,
-0.4719379544,
-0.0752460733,
-0.2099014372,
0.0447132103,
-0.1071595997,
-0.3117019534,
-0.595878005,
0.3627983034,
0.1274465024,
0.0351749137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14221v1 | A Modular Approach for Multilingual Timex Detection and Normalization using Deep Learning and Grammar-based methods | 2023-04-27T14:32:23 | 2023-04-27T14:32:23 | Nayla Escribano, German Rigau, Rodrigo Agerri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting and normalizing temporal expressions is an essential step for many
NLP tasks. While a variety of methods have been proposed for detection, best
normalization approaches rely on hand-crafted rules. Furthermore, most of them
have been designed only for English. In this paper we present a modular
multilingual temporal processing system combining a fine-tuned Masked Language
Model for detection, and a grammar-based normalizer. We experiment in Spanish
and English and compare with HeidelTime, the state-of-the-art in multilingual
temporal processing. We obtain best results in gold timex normalization, timex
detection and type recognition, and competitive performance in the combined
TempEval-3 relaxed value metric. A detailed error analysis shows that detecting
only those timexes for which it is feasible to provide a normalization is
highly beneficial in this last metric. This raises the question of which is the
best strategy for timex processing, namely, leaving undetected those timexes
for which is not easy to provide normalization rules or aiming for high
coverage. | [
-0.1082844809,
-0.5610283017,
0.47372365,
0.6171367168,
-0.294365257,
0.3541271389,
-0.500122726,
-0.5427132249,
0.0085164458,
0.0328608043,
-0.6094192266,
-0.760320127,
-0.4545208514,
0.252525121,
-0.0497229137,
0.5271092653,
-0.0105239265,
-0.09599711,
0.3604628742,
-0.260423094,
-0.2986217737,
-0.7171942592,
-0.7922658324,
-0.6991676688,
0.3262161016,
0.2823715806,
0.7196165323,
0.6924747229,
0.1242883503,
0.2615654767,
-0.3701759875,
0.2124144286,
0.2241067141,
0.0764537379,
-0.1827839762,
-0.4477746785,
-0.8464573026,
-0.2792167664,
0.6532889009,
0.7922843099,
-0.2821037769,
0.3088006377,
-0.4368336499,
0.3097187281,
-0.7522217631,
0.3188417554,
-0.3562866747,
0.7166698575,
-0.3992381692,
-0.1638457328,
-0.356577903,
-0.1151635945,
-0.4986456335,
-0.2239956856,
0.0657126456,
-0.0842158049,
0.6177333593,
0.0827201605,
-0.6150343418,
0.3143338859,
-0.7759994268,
1.0764360428,
-1.2016398907,
0.4352650642,
0.2397024632,
0.5667432547,
0.2969048619,
-0.558265388,
-0.6527994275,
0.2512440979,
-0.2535253167,
0.0216286462,
-0.4941015244,
-0.1664686352,
0.2023770809,
0.4562704265,
-0.8310939074,
0.4929457605,
-0.1187011003,
-0.3550640643,
0.490639627,
0.2778525352,
0.3118856847,
-0.2903527319,
0.0286204722,
0.2044617236,
-0.3521480262,
0.2505875826,
0.350135535,
0.3758482635,
-0.0563141108,
0.3703007698,
-0.7250493169,
0.4864233136,
-0.0860330462,
-0.3684022427,
0.4008207023,
-0.425210923,
-0.1906557232,
-0.0843956694,
0.7106435895,
0.3445388377,
0.3714084923,
-0.4834524989,
-0.4110515714,
0.3200305998,
-0.3336530924,
-0.7479065061,
0.2943870723,
0.2288618386,
-0.6962494254,
-0.1199306548,
-0.238536343,
-0.4693917334,
0.3267933726,
-0.5396242738,
0.2242558151,
-0.2232150882,
-0.5564405918,
0.7358080149,
0.0886835977,
-0.0329428241,
0.003667667,
-0.7775027752,
0.6247725487,
0.5916332603,
0.5479515791,
-0.1562388241,
-0.2456468642,
-0.764926374,
0.1326961219,
-0.3387435079,
0.7200613618,
-0.5237540007,
-0.102420114,
-0.1315872073,
0.2609456182,
-0.1322969794,
-0.4828358591,
0.2717412114,
-0.6236160398,
0.540774703,
0.3626264632,
-0.2682236731,
-0.194133684,
0.3475550115,
-0.5225812793,
0.99760288,
-0.0642509386,
-0.2212416083,
0.5003119111,
-0.5342968106,
-0.6212366819,
0.1167597398,
0.2573865652,
-0.4791609943,
0.0152577935,
0.7043083906,
0.6898881793,
0.1409092098,
0.5501226187,
-0.1295545399,
-0.2401624024,
0.2115386128,
-0.5208573937,
0.6921677589,
0.2856458724,
-0.7531129122,
0.1206497252,
-0.9426785707,
0.4798211753,
-0.2123041898,
-0.5150033832,
-0.195758909,
0.1741708368,
0.3171380162,
0.5727826357,
0.1504614502,
-0.6157449484,
-0.0015475069,
-0.3018948734,
0.5303401351,
0.6058449745,
-0.0454972424,
0.4147944748,
0.0182765424,
0.3372659087,
0.1751068532,
0.5442841053,
-0.3549050689,
-0.2227742672,
-0.7465399504,
-0.177217111,
-0.005251253,
0.7136363387,
-0.5683855414,
0.4281161129,
-0.2904929817,
-0.2220297158,
-0.085412465,
0.1022309363,
0.6106625199,
0.2733746171,
0.6164935231,
-0.0345342383,
-0.4598793983,
-1.0451419353,
-0.3331641257,
0.1442807764,
-0.1756084412,
0.0372490287,
0.1978554279,
-0.5328749418,
0.5570619702,
-0.4458457828,
-0.1839602888,
-0.1022583768,
0.2145788372,
0.5259752274,
0.3853082061,
0.7416684628,
-0.6377306581,
-0.4970988929,
0.2998100221,
-0.6379905343,
-0.1803175658,
0.119999215,
0.4773080647,
0.4820394516,
0.7204452753,
0.0229952559,
0.402528435,
0.3302046955,
-0.5199552774,
0.1970159709,
-0.023357708,
0.3966446817,
-1.1111943722,
-0.0425096713,
-0.204626739,
-0.8105590343,
-0.6733946204,
0.1914910674,
0.3836983442,
-0.1760217547,
-0.6257683635,
0.6246829629,
-0.3126702607,
0.0446141958,
-0.000101975,
-0.2467332929,
0.1327272654,
0.700664103,
0.2149136364,
0.450389415,
0.2790369987,
-0.4824796915,
0.405893594,
-0.3234257698,
-0.2385728508,
0.584235847,
-0.5343607068,
0.2410895377,
-0.1664239615,
-0.1401280314,
-0.6077424884,
0.0150707839,
-0.0599733554,
-0.4093939662,
0.3419491649,
-0.1826542914,
-0.7547469139,
-0.1376319379,
-0.2730596662,
0.6478702426,
0.3131000996,
-0.5409703851,
0.6182233095,
0.146669656,
-0.2649966776,
-0.7056381106,
-0.7709836364,
0.4459096491,
-0.1872317195,
-0.6805938482,
0.5901712775,
-0.0809278563,
-0.4947416782,
0.0086541558,
-0.2981528342,
-0.4169231355,
0.1759395301,
-0.1048856899,
0.1131744683,
-0.4630533755,
-0.0623178035,
0.1692132056,
-0.3704732656,
-0.1979252398,
-0.5007432699,
0.6086950302,
-0.3584471941,
-0.251126498,
-0.7605565786,
0.7752947211,
0.4964278936,
-0.2997483611,
0.3577045798,
1.0998917818,
-0.7989522815,
-0.1023481488,
-0.8107535243,
-0.0883881524,
-0.4188114703,
0.1082243994,
-0.2381189466,
-1.1084164381,
0.4885554016,
0.3414188325,
0.0153036267,
0.4076314867,
0.554276824,
0.1966042668,
1.1699047089,
0.6648939252,
-0.0479244888,
0.4203479886,
-0.0426546372,
0.31577757,
-0.4867737889,
-0.2898958921,
-0.4167673588,
-0.4325359464,
-0.2667213678,
-0.3122926652,
0.2401611209,
-0.2286769897,
-0.1386127919,
0.3769029379,
-0.1478129774,
0.7000243068,
0.4378628731,
0.1496087909,
0.5614522696,
-0.0634578094,
0.0166072734,
-0.2417888641,
-0.5870960951,
-0.3785077333,
0.8317456841,
0.1141799986,
0.599021852,
0.4700771868,
0.4965598583,
0.3129478395,
-0.1724050641,
-0.8044701815,
0.486616075,
-0.453720808,
-0.4323357046,
-0.1181897074,
-0.388435334,
-0.7785067558,
0.1148175523,
-0.2585732043,
-0.6926333904,
0.3573718071,
-0.1802043468,
-0.5534788966,
0.398822546,
-0.6803207994,
0.8306691647,
0.0206203666,
-0.241509214,
-0.438384831,
-0.5943744779,
0.0910815522,
0.2301077992,
0.4652738273,
-0.3328819573,
-0.176529184,
0.5403877497,
-0.1315995902,
0.9512879252,
0.0900234729,
0.2111742347,
-0.265586406,
0.3561133146,
0.0475589037,
0.5351848006,
0.0950154662,
0.2442216277,
0.1889008284,
-0.6813985109,
-0.3616420627,
0.5373210311,
-0.6760994792,
-0.3620660007,
-0.4334904552,
-0.6439284682,
0.03464498,
0.3301411271,
-0.0595662557,
0.6622614264,
0.0383767448,
0.1992156357,
0.6462016106,
-0.0845182166,
1.1821193695,
0.8637453318,
-0.1700458229,
-0.2880191505,
0.6631852984,
-0.01516701,
0.221099183,
0.8560777903,
0.2781719565,
-0.0378577076,
-0.4993632734,
-0.0599552728,
0.1423153579,
-0.7208259702,
-0.1639661044,
-0.7467293143,
-0.0597948693,
-0.7229244709,
-0.0649312288,
-0.2530796528,
-0.8914555311,
-0.240591079,
-0.1056593433,
-0.0816156119,
0.2280578613,
-0.1909997761,
0.2671775222,
-0.9027894139,
0.3889936805,
0.7392471433,
0.173065275,
-0.478818506,
-0.1458561718,
-0.0897220299,
-0.450434655,
0.0926014408,
-0.4491305947,
0.4966151714,
0.4474371374,
0.511297226,
0.3957076371,
-0.3521268964,
0.6575291753,
-0.6189301014,
0.7213811874,
-0.1778877527,
-1.219831109,
0.497656256,
-0.1936617643,
0.5361714363,
0.1265586913,
-0.0688558593,
-1.2356805801,
-0.2476294339,
-0.5483418703,
-0.8785184622,
0.5808472037,
0.004605032,
-0.0490234382,
-0.0162684247,
0.4306247532,
0.1573368013,
0.3057631552,
-0.943574667,
0.0561356731,
-0.0189215168,
0.0734992102,
-0.1834142953,
-0.3332004845,
-0.1068528593,
-0.0207023676,
0.3334821761,
-0.2615278363,
0.0274786465,
-0.0577487946,
-0.5265806317,
-0.0547720045,
0.7194766998,
0.6584905982,
0.759894371,
-0.1184788197,
0.3323650956,
0.0654030144,
-0.2718245685,
0.0583386235,
0.106278494,
0.0022073628,
0.2426007837,
0.8259340525,
0.5675657392,
0.3208901584,
-0.4962828159,
0.4855214953,
-0.2216967791,
0.1460906565,
-0.344689399,
-0.0232511628,
-0.1973452866,
0.5038399696,
0.2809306681,
0.2588717043,
0.2167324424,
-0.5249233246,
0.1186613366,
0.1622663587,
-0.1631723642,
-0.6071651578,
0.5597136617,
-0.0271492917,
-0.3978584409,
0.3362330496,
-0.4011099935,
-0.7103993893,
0.608929038,
0.5096374154,
0.7989572287,
-0.5129082799,
0.1679904908,
0.375816524,
0.5402079225,
0.0108747305,
0.4804369509,
-0.30453825,
-0.6448302865,
-0.7988843918,
-0.4209933877,
-0.1299074441,
-0.0183502492,
-0.6662170291,
0.2721043527,
-0.4214201272,
0.0082860384,
0.0252695736,
-0.1084251553,
-0.6338680983,
0.1862460524,
0.3248164654,
0.8150921464,
-0.9814193845,
0.6113461256,
0.5481442809,
0.1599571109,
-0.485035181,
-0.2150745988,
0.3458489478,
-0.7989240289,
0.7479702234,
0.1473474652,
-0.0169012845,
-0.2472296655,
-0.0829582512,
-0.7172605395,
1.1196894646,
0.1816491038,
-0.4768588841,
-0.0698809102,
-0.0606754571,
0.4836904705,
-0.1272979826,
0.0502979979,
0.6132487655,
0.520187676,
-0.3158282638,
-1.1148929596,
-0.0430736952,
-0.4782704413,
0.0479609482,
0.389811039,
-0.3701259196,
1.1534963846,
0.1601771861,
-0.4272806048,
-0.207379207,
0.2338698059,
-0.2437407225,
0.3771015406,
0.488130331,
0.6440607309,
0.4965461195,
-0.2163178772,
0.7379859686,
-0.0312556587,
0.2530755103,
0.8981177211,
-0.1188267395,
0.5832538605,
0.4119403958,
-0.1656208932,
0.3138241172,
0.7426425219,
0.3580071032,
0.3394805491,
-0.2899993658,
-0.5916130543,
-0.5475252271,
-0.1072125286,
-0.2389848232,
0.2207196057,
0.3948019743,
0.0636829361,
-0.6060381532,
0.2475376278,
0.5765592456,
0.242178157,
-0.4936076701,
0.6949623227,
-0.2050460577,
-0.6471689939,
0.2825544477,
0.3064765334,
0.8626029491,
-0.5633010268,
0.2147653848,
-0.4698137641,
0.4877947271,
-0.4944289923,
-0.5718876719,
0.5819679499,
-0.1300457418,
-0.3381245136,
-0.4281598926,
0.5125422478,
-0.5301376581,
-0.5411630869,
0.3813132644,
0.5939052701,
-0.2541797161,
-0.0869301707,
-0.4721917808,
-0.2313221991,
-0.3196034133,
-0.1444363743,
0.1175273433,
0.4493637085,
-0.3860017657,
0.4701109827,
0.6027168036,
0.1281581223,
0.2907042503,
0.4278076887,
0.6177344918,
-0.6103029847,
-0.6245681643,
-1.0345495939,
0.4617009461,
-0.1788288355,
-0.1844683141,
0.4334969223,
0.5915340185,
0.7819696069,
-0.0170980711,
0.2720937729,
0.1643998921,
0.3048993945,
-0.8218491673,
0.3454529941,
-0.5797870755,
0.1956007779,
-0.0553885363,
-0.9682525992,
-1.0249116421,
0.259396106,
-0.070139043,
-0.3173203766,
1.0817667246,
0.7405248284,
-0.3094931841,
-0.2602960765,
0.4369621873,
0.0803535059,
0.6273344159,
0.9057524204,
0.5386654139,
-0.2785240114,
0.5715397,
-0.6033446193,
-0.4432273805,
-0.043101348,
-1.118013382,
-1.1535724401,
-0.4724642336,
-0.3288410008,
-0.0805221498,
0.0322439969,
0.8886582851,
0.7895521522,
-0.7921005487,
-0.3756654263,
0.5548501015,
0.2415398955,
-0.6780593991,
-0.2197448164,
0.2588798702,
-0.6204836369,
-0.9369103312,
0.6985564828,
0.8210274577,
-0.1234063506,
0.0498500764,
0.2802035511,
-0.2306824327,
-0.2898610234,
0.9326221347,
0.2274031788,
-0.5064324737,
-0.3674457669,
0.5377729535,
0.0797794387,
0.0749381483,
1.0340636969,
-0.7025079727,
0.5271691084,
0.4205792844,
0.442666322,
0.7014930248,
-0.6630417109,
0.3931302726,
-1.0993732214,
0.6175170541,
0.4643666744,
0.6030353308,
0.335342586,
-0.31595245,
0.646270752,
0.5354062319,
-0.357401371,
-0.6540394425,
0.4468636215,
-0.8016226888,
-0.5128046274,
0.9718346,
0.0408419035,
-0.2150111943,
-0.3263875544,
0.0474905446,
0.0472666398,
-0.2263785899,
0.8139603734,
0.7252224088,
-0.0605722368,
-0.0057863048,
-0.3402297199,
0.1405051798,
0.2217766047,
-0.8039516211,
-0.2787179947,
0.4002326131,
0.4353795052,
0.428799361,
0.5008342862,
-0.4004670084,
0.6324810386,
-0.5903493762,
0.0319739059,
-0.2214536965,
-0.2316078097,
-0.5026826859,
0.19895567,
-0.3794399202,
-0.0144733461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14189v1 | UIO at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Multilingual fine-tuning for sentiment classification in low-resource languages | 2023-04-27T13:51:18 | 2023-04-27T13:51:18 | Egil Rønningstad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our contribution to the 2023 AfriSenti-SemEval shared task 12: Sentiment
Analysis for African Languages, provides insight into how a multilingual large
language model can be a resource for sentiment analysis in languages not seen
during pretraining. The shared task provides datasets of a variety of African
languages from different language families. The languages are to various
degrees related to languages used during pretraining, and the language data
contain various degrees of code-switching. We experiment with both monolingual
and multilingual datasets for the final fine-tuning, and find that with the
provided datasets that contain samples in the thousands, monolingual
fine-tuning yields the best results. | [
-0.8449937701,
-0.1666707546,
0.0320996344,
0.4502954185,
-0.2263445556,
-0.0835044906,
-0.4434237778,
-0.6126723886,
0.3049882948,
0.5679054856,
-0.7572589517,
-0.3530780077,
-0.7083250284,
0.3754858971,
0.1729463488,
1.1515463591,
-0.2001461685,
0.1771986783,
-0.0381728448,
-0.8356958628,
-0.1639377177,
-0.8280031085,
-0.6526547074,
-0.2896425128,
0.7546644211,
0.8213214278,
0.5686698556,
0.0097672138,
0.4936740696,
0.2601519823,
0.0860016048,
0.2612429857,
-0.3731463552,
-0.1061497256,
-0.3141562343,
-0.2520070076,
-0.4703724086,
0.1415036917,
0.1095143706,
1.0032544136,
0.0966645256,
0.2795812786,
0.2674497664,
0.6933495402,
-0.7664391994,
0.2812841237,
-0.4210737348,
-0.0808912739,
-0.3056182265,
-0.1004102826,
-0.1670694202,
-0.3182499111,
-0.0311310627,
-0.2243718058,
0.0137060871,
-0.2409624457,
0.8472887874,
0.3310712874,
-0.5719491839,
-0.2911885679,
-0.2032395303,
1.1127798557,
-0.5770748258,
0.2046116292,
0.5818359852,
-0.0528892577,
0.4481498301,
-0.4390615523,
-0.3845530748,
0.1125011742,
0.0362565182,
0.1396911591,
0.1975526214,
0.1351751536,
0.1062861159,
0.5097426176,
-0.092792742,
0.0545675978,
-0.2182525396,
-0.3420564532,
0.8215740323,
-0.120861575,
0.1495796293,
-0.181626305,
-0.225479275,
0.0265024155,
-0.5792959929,
0.0791908428,
0.5121247172,
0.6160674691,
-0.2978035212,
0.3022144139,
-0.5060383081,
0.547848165,
-0.4108554125,
0.0270137377,
0.7006918192,
-0.3276722729,
-0.2086766958,
0.0368071869,
0.8047680259,
0.4452143908,
0.5108285546,
0.1835896373,
-0.3878245652,
0.3139415681,
0.1197335869,
-0.688611567,
-0.2528135478,
-0.1219420508,
-0.6253989935,
-0.3588472307,
-0.2337720096,
-0.8995943069,
-0.4556786418,
-0.564842999,
0.4598327577,
-0.235437572,
-0.1337931454,
0.1120627448,
0.2137159258,
-0.037203677,
0.4461886883,
-0.9298826456,
0.1175493449,
0.1525311321,
0.5962781906,
-0.1378352791,
-0.5707855225,
-0.4132183492,
-0.4491764307,
-0.0171606559,
0.6170198321,
-0.5568307638,
-0.5080788136,
0.1029465273,
0.243709743,
-0.1573036611,
-0.5878536105,
0.6119990945,
-0.2972584069,
0.063692607,
-0.4946868718,
-0.1310634017,
-0.4532006681,
0.3895342052,
-0.6528549194,
1.1652839184,
0.3749757409,
-0.528287828,
0.3929008543,
-0.7018587589,
-0.8528876901,
-0.1961544603,
-0.1163420677,
-0.3860551119,
0.3322117031,
0.2118995637,
0.4240514934,
-0.3737852871,
-0.2613377273,
-0.390871942,
-0.054755833,
-0.0207784846,
-0.3588961363,
0.8591352105,
0.5483824015,
-0.5847434402,
-0.1900720596,
-0.9177629352,
0.1350494921,
-0.1450301111,
-0.2801563442,
-0.447758913,
-0.1460980922,
0.2109441757,
0.4165052772,
0.6795134544,
-0.5693488121,
0.3026034236,
-0.1363377869,
0.2109193206,
0.5988251567,
0.0297242291,
0.428553462,
0.0772915408,
0.7592324615,
0.2498801947,
0.2546882331,
-0.1535400748,
-0.3029150367,
-1.0695039034,
0.0122222425,
0.3586781621,
0.5858524442,
-0.8110328317,
0.089071542,
-0.0620140545,
-0.206368953,
-0.8416226506,
0.3982748091,
0.2736143172,
0.1948125511,
0.4372806251,
-0.341732353,
-0.6354150772,
-1.0259170532,
-0.2226818055,
0.0812806636,
0.4866227806,
0.2087377459,
0.4310319126,
-0.7418210506,
0.3411333263,
-0.3242856264,
-0.2914344072,
-0.3233885169,
0.580384016,
0.2429102808,
0.4436557293,
0.8497130871,
-0.7653146982,
-0.5940567255,
0.3161364496,
-0.7060585618,
-0.2719555497,
0.1010927409,
-0.1023143381,
0.4044755101,
0.6953773499,
0.1375518888,
0.3241635561,
0.7772967219,
-0.2378647774,
0.2113463134,
-0.0065385178,
0.6013963223,
-1.0944240093,
-0.1664931476,
-0.1852358282,
-0.2025460601,
-0.4696361721,
0.0245744791,
-0.0475206748,
-0.1692427248,
-0.4050304592,
0.5177904963,
-0.4989790916,
0.1498538107,
-0.4083913863,
-0.3787189424,
-0.1731883585,
0.4637363255,
0.0221900698,
0.850709796,
0.5070424676,
-0.5870187283,
0.1211807355,
0.1875663102,
-0.4484192133,
0.6192421317,
-0.3449035585,
0.1719741672,
0.0513435528,
-0.6229670048,
-0.7101930976,
-0.158837989,
-0.1415249407,
-0.4702289104,
0.191148892,
-0.1056618616,
-0.3389987648,
-0.2928452492,
-0.1778142899,
0.4655767083,
0.1098588258,
-0.6215323806,
0.4170405865,
0.607086122,
-0.4556412399,
-0.720475018,
-0.8609281778,
-0.045222614,
-0.1556293964,
-0.4095774889,
-0.1572186053,
-0.1084109247,
-0.1393382996,
-0.2493858337,
0.0374621898,
-0.1736654639,
0.2699406743,
0.3183803856,
0.1861500889,
-0.1182907671,
-0.0939930007,
0.190235272,
-0.0752119943,
-0.0298030488,
-0.0534901395,
0.6113417149,
-0.4370639622,
-0.0934958979,
0.0393155217,
0.4571486712,
0.6485539675,
-0.2938857377,
0.9978380203,
0.6803052425,
-0.2673805654,
-0.1218690649,
-0.3896922171,
0.2111542672,
-0.4717856944,
0.249510482,
-0.6662424803,
-1.1015796661,
0.6211040616,
-0.2851244509,
0.0060290666,
0.4079758525,
0.6445112824,
-0.2252628803,
1.1115093231,
0.7852552533,
-0.6251138449,
0.5438871384,
-0.3893537223,
0.1165636405,
-0.6031978726,
-0.0642122105,
-0.7216226459,
-0.5061821938,
-0.7827813625,
-0.1464741975,
0.2942945361,
0.1864801049,
-0.1875537187,
0.2613407373,
-0.1193935275,
0.4076040983,
0.5430238247,
-0.1675817519,
-0.1028056219,
0.2658783793,
-0.2865490913,
-0.0335060842,
-0.4638136923,
-0.4613512158,
0.788003087,
-0.071460411,
0.8553569913,
-0.1075816453,
1.0048031807,
0.3032644689,
0.1512962133,
-0.8232434392,
0.4825676382,
-0.5288362503,
-0.3655997217,
-0.2616143525,
-0.4186455607,
-0.9592676163,
0.1978724301,
0.0261848979,
-0.5503419638,
0.5392789841,
0.0927802771,
-0.1146291718,
-0.0172390584,
-0.6886549592,
1.1211494207,
-0.1641526669,
-0.1535519511,
-0.3074741364,
-0.5116737485,
0.0398135111,
-0.0929951891,
0.5520079136,
-0.2360012978,
0.1163609624,
0.5405620933,
-0.6252663136,
0.7927431464,
-0.352620095,
-0.1361586303,
0.3336569667,
-0.0555357561,
0.1949779987,
0.1504329592,
-0.4766757786,
0.3259239197,
0.0321264006,
-0.5138989091,
-0.1299546659,
0.8219700456,
-1.1905514002,
-0.0829875097,
-0.4928149879,
-0.2581025362,
-0.4788532257,
0.2504181862,
0.6757708788,
0.4413639307,
-0.2476192564,
0.342497915,
0.3672385216,
-0.2776859999,
0.4027355611,
0.3826760054,
0.0616878644,
-0.3352873921,
1.0473757982,
0.1562254727,
0.1408635378,
0.3390714526,
0.0148915909,
-0.1890936345,
-0.366070807,
-0.2923614681,
-0.0012275438,
-0.7112603784,
-0.4378155172,
-0.5345908999,
-0.0851047859,
-0.5019183755,
-0.2910289168,
-0.4661641717,
-0.6051118374,
-0.3765839934,
-0.006912359,
0.2700334191,
0.5241379142,
-0.3661293089,
0.528876543,
-1.0748195648,
0.3776825368,
0.2101113498,
0.294098556,
-0.3408151269,
-0.4465177655,
-0.6191729903,
0.1070469618,
-0.1770889908,
-0.5788009763,
0.4360828102,
0.5452632904,
0.50492239,
0.336366117,
0.0173381064,
0.6749843955,
-0.2889913321,
0.82194525,
0.3010924459,
-1.0115417242,
0.8662931919,
-0.2248869538,
0.5209745765,
1.3737081289,
0.5462575555,
-0.6964594126,
-0.0544271134,
-0.3658626974,
-0.8174237013,
0.9000352621,
-0.0693870336,
0.0984924212,
-0.2211217731,
0.2455679476,
0.3034665883,
0.4632641077,
-0.7948772311,
-0.3745982051,
-0.3207260072,
-0.4247204661,
-0.3410005271,
-0.2633817494,
0.0209399275,
-0.3274186254,
0.7209312916,
-0.3916117549,
0.2040783167,
-0.1662162244,
-0.4283312559,
-0.127821669,
0.4642115831,
0.2549378574,
0.3385638297,
0.0863795206,
0.0923659429,
0.3291589916,
-0.5639439821,
0.2255510241,
0.1763391346,
-0.1967386603,
-0.1465703994,
0.3129131794,
1.1786062717,
0.2179570794,
-0.3740947247,
0.3984005153,
-0.0876613185,
-0.2458766848,
-0.1418524235,
-0.048722323,
-0.1970032156,
-0.0362913273,
0.004259862,
0.4468615651,
0.3513713181,
-0.8100684285,
-0.0203682017,
0.1679274589,
-0.5448805094,
-0.4872170389,
0.4246099591,
0.5260673165,
0.3246771693,
0.6380437016,
-0.3439610004,
-0.6928331852,
0.4289101064,
0.0346216187,
0.7982057333,
-0.4768251479,
0.2451459765,
0.5085484982,
0.379745394,
-0.0537407957,
0.8702493906,
-0.0100478856,
-0.9972737432,
-0.3420425355,
-0.9620192647,
-0.2259507477,
0.1108973846,
-1.0942333937,
0.4128548801,
-0.1563515812,
-0.1650968492,
-0.145879969,
0.1472778916,
-1.0028876066,
0.7088562846,
0.2947019637,
0.7554899454,
-0.8807080388,
0.9793910384,
1.1356261969,
-0.3500829339,
-0.6582586169,
-0.3483440578,
0.0275205672,
-0.871769309,
0.6100338101,
0.1618315279,
-0.3640301228,
-0.056865748,
-0.5336514115,
-0.6195350289,
0.6860102415,
0.3232112825,
-0.533769846,
0.2170926034,
0.3757716417,
0.412897855,
-0.2548696697,
-0.0542140491,
0.7206965685,
0.4583853781,
-0.1006623432,
-0.8764342666,
-0.5065843463,
-0.3870079219,
-0.2965089083,
0.4492759705,
-0.8634603024,
0.8152731061,
0.0024167439,
0.0018810367,
0.1079597026,
0.781432569,
-0.2294880152,
0.2719970644,
0.6410929561,
0.6518037319,
0.8125399351,
-0.3308135569,
1.0972579718,
-0.4639253914,
0.3675753474,
1.1835302114,
-0.2509194314,
0.7872178555,
0.3946727514,
-0.1835260391,
0.3259188235,
0.7890209556,
0.3061940968,
0.70591259,
-0.1567014605,
-0.4486194551,
-0.2907257974,
-0.3122938871,
-0.5372985601,
0.5951365829,
0.3720248044,
-0.0970372707,
0.0007310253,
0.4965266287,
0.0464527681,
0.0234571025,
-0.7272578478,
0.7158122063,
0.2688514888,
-0.642021358,
0.522969842,
-0.1594077647,
0.9631943107,
-0.5774632692,
0.3958515823,
-0.4746143818,
0.4495893121,
-0.2589820325,
-0.8243764639,
0.3716475666,
-0.0384537391,
-0.1842686236,
-0.4595531523,
0.6595596671,
-0.4818104208,
-0.5616845489,
0.6241215467,
0.4232369363,
0.0003321413,
-0.1375833452,
-0.758218646,
0.1853380501,
0.334063977,
-0.1906540692,
0.4229016006,
0.7892163396,
0.0197199583,
0.3141839802,
0.2277699858,
0.3251932263,
0.0052646282,
0.6566070318,
0.7004163861,
-0.6533288956,
-0.6203562021,
-0.5720296502,
0.2648584247,
0.0469218865,
-0.6766473055,
0.8188091516,
0.5276489854,
1.0763572454,
-0.4495289922,
1.0289512873,
-0.1103319824,
0.5209565163,
-0.4433331192,
0.5701617599,
-0.8995559812,
-0.25900653,
-0.367180258,
-0.9282673597,
-0.0496886149,
0.8140555024,
-0.121435672,
-0.0583150536,
0.6409753561,
0.5815354586,
0.028659232,
0.1626437157,
0.348441869,
0.0240222551,
-0.0904585496,
0.3316908181,
0.958781302,
-0.4898714125,
0.3750070632,
-0.3622180223,
-0.146192193,
-0.1866371483,
-0.7466755509,
-0.8548616171,
-0.6408548951,
-0.4127461314,
-0.2065493166,
-0.1351258904,
0.9824153185,
0.6304300427,
-1.2778865099,
-0.4424910843,
0.091108419,
-0.2655638754,
-0.0954030752,
-0.2351867259,
-0.1763758808,
-0.6656442285,
-0.7727528811,
0.3129132986,
0.3669104576,
0.0748219714,
0.0831589177,
-0.097740829,
-0.3165292144,
-0.0614464879,
0.9278563857,
0.3601378202,
-0.1708212495,
-0.3645114899,
-0.1388357878,
-0.1419976205,
-0.0278858729,
1.0171817541,
-0.4460290372,
0.4948597252,
0.4637531936,
0.7191582322,
0.4507110119,
-0.2593818605,
0.5574400425,
-0.9311047196,
0.5369178653,
0.1490097195,
0.7174413204,
0.3755093813,
-0.2471896708,
0.8728612065,
0.1110387817,
-0.7025310397,
-0.5621548295,
0.0769388825,
-1.0370516777,
-0.0850003138,
1.0211894512,
-0.0751695633,
-0.0729403421,
-0.0541652851,
-0.3694357276,
0.0938618556,
-0.3279559612,
0.5245690346,
0.990865767,
-0.1558890492,
-0.1938452423,
-0.412358135,
0.7045020461,
0.5193447471,
-1.0715979338,
-0.200238958,
0.45247522,
-0.1036194339,
0.2216265947,
0.6830822229,
-0.0157403983,
0.3281642497,
-0.1809703261,
0.1820449978,
0.4206871092,
-0.4265559316,
-0.4708128572,
-0.0143711511,
0.2715471089,
-0.2229764163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14179v1 | NAP at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Is Less Really More? (Back-)Translation as Data Augmentation Strategies for Detecting Persuasion Techniques | 2023-04-27T13:33:08 | 2023-04-27T13:33:08 | Neele Falk, Annerose Eichel, Prisca Piccirilli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Persuasion techniques detection in news in a multi-lingual setup is
non-trivial and comes with challenges, including little training data. Our
system successfully leverages (back-)translation as data augmentation
strategies with multi-lingual transformer models for the task of detecting
persuasion techniques. The automatic and human evaluation of our augmented data
allows us to explore whether (back-)translation aid or hinder performance. Our
in-depth analyses indicate that both data augmentation strategies boost
performance; however, balancing human-produced and machine-generated data seems
to be crucial. | [
-0.4526668787,
-0.7714260817,
0.4669724405,
0.5574311614,
-0.3660106361,
0.0571078099,
-0.1311772913,
-0.4806248248,
0.2149041146,
0.6070640683,
-0.6863864064,
-0.5507551432,
-0.5592369437,
0.2929835618,
-0.3868825138,
0.890609026,
0.1498945802,
0.3911222517,
-0.1815558374,
-0.0278643668,
-0.4079557657,
-0.5820295215,
-0.6019589305,
-0.5568031073,
0.1884530038,
0.8709368706,
0.3779332638,
0.0284321774,
0.2549521327,
0.1765840501,
-0.0487247705,
-0.0628790855,
-0.3406983316,
0.0023412481,
-0.068375431,
-0.5373156071,
-0.3515287042,
0.092303738,
0.5243910551,
0.4227526486,
0.1182309836,
0.1767571121,
0.1315005869,
0.7554218173,
-0.4899133146,
-0.2674381733,
-0.5587744713,
0.0740876943,
-0.1559990793,
-0.2286704928,
-0.5686906576,
-0.1475446373,
-0.2429898679,
-0.4099355042,
0.3520982265,
0.1471128613,
0.8688357472,
0.2358403355,
-0.793577373,
0.057704255,
-0.5471388102,
0.7955402732,
-0.4827364087,
0.3601130545,
0.4778074324,
0.2463953942,
-0.0835162774,
-0.5221799016,
-0.6853737831,
0.0716970563,
0.0792083219,
0.2949615717,
-0.5118969679,
-0.3023591638,
0.2129298747,
0.1356823295,
-0.4957180023,
0.0736561939,
-0.4199723601,
-0.3380499184,
0.8885633349,
0.0249989908,
0.2588073015,
-0.5003710389,
-0.5736761689,
-0.2981631756,
-0.9585213065,
-0.195273757,
0.5785562992,
0.2056142092,
-0.1032122746,
0.6417378187,
-0.3468648493,
0.4852123857,
0.1366903633,
0.1255536377,
0.4143654704,
-0.9076116085,
-0.0494841114,
0.227627188,
0.6778572798,
0.4720523357,
-0.2744285464,
0.219552055,
-0.282453239,
-0.1398119628,
0.2141660303,
-0.7487297058,
-0.2663709521,
-0.0621973723,
-0.613163352,
-0.7490508556,
-0.3232218027,
-1.0607784986,
-0.6488069892,
-0.2343029827,
0.8547375798,
-0.2158293724,
-0.314977169,
0.273893863,
-0.4495253563,
0.5038639307,
0.4738867879,
-0.4726139605,
0.4510648549,
0.6726032495,
0.766012907,
-0.3981322646,
-0.2194916457,
-0.6236541867,
0.0565239564,
-0.4098072648,
1.0230498314,
-0.6467431784,
-0.4326423407,
-0.3115880191,
0.3539735973,
-0.1923327148,
-0.4549589157,
0.9759635329,
-0.3435153365,
0.6215708256,
-0.4270449877,
-0.4291377366,
-0.282569021,
0.306055069,
-0.9175288081,
0.9256972671,
-0.0099090301,
-0.291803062,
0.4174363017,
-0.749388814,
-0.7427944541,
-0.2041997612,
-0.0093859555,
-0.5518513322,
0.0250933226,
0.5145835876,
0.3707290292,
-0.2368497401,
-0.1384197921,
0.1858351082,
-0.2125265151,
0.1955316961,
-0.5864493251,
0.5795436502,
0.231628567,
-0.5271346569,
0.2077889442,
-0.78801018,
-0.3298302591,
0.007618485,
-0.2748479247,
-0.2250287086,
-0.014047523,
0.0728590786,
0.4045409262,
0.2893464267,
-0.8466012478,
0.1053695902,
-0.3220153451,
0.2318246812,
0.4196736515,
0.3139872849,
0.5670489669,
-0.2383007556,
0.7667878866,
-0.038268622,
0.0602697395,
-0.1209426746,
-0.7235481143,
-0.6249638796,
0.0535902679,
0.2621742487,
0.654957056,
-0.8478394747,
0.1343049407,
-0.3799429834,
-0.5231067538,
-0.2750842571,
0.1015220135,
0.1952026635,
0.5342572927,
0.5978039503,
0.1734598428,
-0.7121144533,
-0.8623359203,
-0.5845817327,
0.0739368722,
0.1267571896,
-0.0348062105,
0.7309866548,
0.0266781822,
0.3020393848,
-0.22869578,
-0.3891364634,
-0.5570193529,
0.3888290226,
-0.0003632395,
0.5927252173,
0.4676318169,
-1.0605335236,
-0.3903421462,
0.0939211845,
-0.303353101,
-0.2521871626,
-0.1673281044,
0.1039196998,
0.3549537361,
0.6005061269,
-0.2109105885,
0.5320256352,
0.6331728697,
-0.3267176747,
0.5025418401,
0.3969288766,
0.7260268927,
-1.1002504826,
-0.1603413224,
-0.1554003656,
-0.3123897016,
-0.8789132237,
-0.1926741153,
0.094438687,
-0.4587191343,
-0.5123999715,
0.4739408493,
-0.3209133744,
0.0742689893,
-0.407545656,
0.1329729706,
0.5140064955,
0.2340208292,
0.3376563191,
0.9319402575,
0.359226495,
-0.6287966371,
0.3340671659,
0.3486757874,
-0.2780213952,
0.840120852,
-0.7057164311,
0.055294957,
0.274081409,
0.3177908659,
-1.2378947735,
-0.4065157473,
0.4359891713,
-0.760004878,
0.1842875928,
-0.3929160237,
-0.3459937572,
-0.2797197104,
-0.5008013248,
0.1759740263,
0.3313039541,
-0.666652441,
0.6209166646,
0.3545133173,
-0.353669405,
-0.4089408815,
-0.9752355218,
0.4352998734,
-0.3784897327,
-0.8326639533,
0.5170922875,
0.4067632556,
0.0155441537,
-0.0731955692,
-0.0441369005,
-0.0047503863,
-0.0596771948,
-0.0700168759,
0.2914169431,
-0.2126060426,
0.1676186472,
0.1199237108,
-0.0512340516,
0.1392488629,
-0.0861810297,
0.5443077087,
-0.1730239093,
-0.5945165753,
-0.4985968173,
0.4702966809,
0.4298969805,
0.0426367,
0.6400867105,
0.8697043657,
-0.2186016589,
0.3114870191,
-0.7309717536,
-0.3294303417,
-0.4372712672,
0.282741189,
-0.3861703575,
-0.6349316835,
0.3482557237,
-0.2756636739,
-0.1453760713,
0.4535329044,
0.3349049687,
0.0783363506,
1.6720278263,
0.4301720858,
0.0163761619,
0.4883356392,
-0.1592211425,
0.1580430865,
-0.8500970602,
-0.4571588635,
-0.6998503804,
-0.5292438269,
-0.4470314085,
-0.487383604,
0.3375624716,
0.0959678367,
0.183707878,
0.5323114395,
-0.544326365,
0.2840955257,
0.377397418,
-0.1489526182,
0.3520198464,
0.1195902824,
0.434032768,
0.0096245045,
-0.6459440589,
-0.5165385604,
0.893281281,
0.2926343977,
0.793762207,
0.2103915662,
0.7897254825,
0.2849127352,
-0.0947771072,
-0.8473883271,
0.6378662586,
0.1639978588,
-0.4320625961,
-0.29539451,
-0.3098621368,
-1.2518786192,
0.3984627426,
-0.2800548673,
-0.4053183198,
0.6774929762,
0.0481381305,
-0.1236961782,
0.0865417346,
-0.8197419643,
0.9917779565,
-0.3356296718,
-0.3887090981,
-0.5156444311,
-0.4804365039,
0.3156920969,
0.0346552022,
0.1392121911,
-0.0416834652,
-0.5028542876,
0.9388810992,
-0.1703355759,
0.6629369259,
-0.3466602266,
-0.0887031034,
0.1507155597,
-0.1704341471,
0.9622330666,
-0.1169373021,
-0.1926828623,
-0.1662383825,
0.0586468615,
-0.5186728835,
-0.5771474242,
0.5078725815,
-0.4401271641,
-0.6023804545,
-0.3181900084,
-0.0296580736,
-0.2845610678,
0.036637444,
0.5766307712,
0.2379716188,
-0.5036970377,
0.5563440919,
0.4834451377,
-0.2116580009,
0.2681261599,
0.7264086008,
-0.1691021323,
-0.651616931,
1.3387823105,
-0.1703785658,
0.1133901477,
0.3132306337,
0.3287652433,
-0.5479103923,
-0.6481024027,
-0.6271675825,
-0.0709457025,
-0.5582638979,
-0.1805067956,
-0.6155138016,
-0.009999075,
-0.6994691491,
0.0324026085,
-0.3011547327,
-0.9807693362,
-0.2116144896,
-0.2042712718,
0.2071027309,
0.6577429175,
-0.261496067,
0.6197413206,
-0.890427351,
0.2419106215,
0.1544309855,
-0.3581507504,
-0.6409083605,
-0.5117589235,
-0.2934006751,
0.0147652309,
-0.5460391641,
-1.0889172554,
0.510702312,
0.2227080166,
0.4806859195,
0.2580870092,
-0.0348519646,
0.5515316129,
-0.2718634307,
1.2148020267,
0.1761459708,
-0.8681625128,
0.9926305413,
-0.2723228633,
0.0173681378,
0.5890240669,
0.4268018603,
-0.373362869,
-0.027414225,
-0.81378901,
-0.7739787102,
0.6436078548,
0.1444538683,
0.2164248526,
0.1383581012,
-0.2924480438,
0.0769866407,
0.4784141481,
-0.6758886576,
0.0998126939,
-0.3561104834,
0.2244006097,
0.2168434709,
-0.0813173875,
-0.3060176671,
-0.2878636122,
0.914172709,
-0.1174502522,
0.0885375366,
0.0203280672,
-0.2250932306,
-0.0023916201,
0.7195552588,
0.771597147,
0.2989400625,
0.2043643147,
-0.0377880521,
0.3502526879,
-0.4686408341,
0.2548868954,
0.3022876978,
-0.2412886322,
0.1160493642,
0.2901343405,
0.9099085331,
0.2181956172,
-0.4227513969,
0.8896540403,
0.0329714715,
-0.3003031611,
-0.2816642821,
0.0255551487,
-0.267573148,
0.1717083156,
0.4064556956,
0.4694877863,
0.4510933161,
-0.4464432001,
0.2950012386,
0.376172632,
-0.5432206988,
-0.4581715763,
0.2929324508,
0.6710451841,
-0.0629304051,
0.055476848,
-0.2166877091,
-0.8039711118,
0.3209284842,
0.6003439426,
0.6773083806,
-0.3537330329,
0.3660213351,
0.4308036566,
0.3822561204,
-0.1270024627,
0.5206134915,
-0.2550084293,
-0.651479423,
-0.6365271211,
-0.1500205547,
-0.3346558213,
0.433498472,
-0.8491975665,
0.5605865121,
0.2631537318,
-0.1291968077,
-0.2732681036,
0.0846200734,
-0.3756039143,
0.1179925129,
-0.0056904256,
0.9942210913,
-1.0501382351,
0.4651199579,
0.7950619459,
-0.2854869664,
-0.5010272861,
-0.0266314447,
0.3049834967,
-0.7042092085,
0.4031314552,
0.0842772201,
-0.3861317039,
0.150575161,
-0.7557091117,
-0.5260869265,
0.8728380799,
0.176573962,
-0.3748037815,
0.212797001,
-0.0432707146,
0.2234644592,
-0.2161812484,
-0.1645114273,
0.7795980573,
0.8054484129,
0.1472554505,
-0.6253108382,
-0.0980338827,
-0.4033074677,
-0.5946740508,
0.2087011635,
-0.4923842251,
0.4704749584,
0.0256610941,
-0.3982463479,
-0.0638635457,
0.5723643303,
0.0678493753,
0.6454002857,
0.5945406556,
0.4966476858,
0.6610760689,
-0.1686264873,
1.138861537,
-0.2081359178,
-0.2343551069,
1.1174200773,
-0.2332899421,
0.8683761358,
0.4708498716,
0.0235438216,
0.6240984797,
0.5773418546,
-0.2038895339,
0.4132764637,
-0.2914507687,
-0.2967008948,
-0.5484077334,
-0.4040521085,
-0.5724793673,
0.6012429595,
0.6123971343,
-0.2553083897,
-0.1042905003,
0.5269801021,
0.0749450922,
0.1811691076,
-0.1869117469,
0.9770132899,
-0.0061553419,
-0.8907530904,
0.4317620397,
0.0388173424,
0.4817412794,
-0.4663823247,
-0.2357507497,
0.1574092805,
-0.0946080387,
-0.2781902552,
-1.0729079247,
0.3793603182,
-0.1547942609,
-0.0046047294,
-0.3836997151,
1.154471755,
-0.3742292225,
-0.3957590759,
0.0361104943,
0.678055048,
0.2354980111,
-0.374956876,
-0.6706616879,
0.0586724691,
0.085046716,
-0.2640131116,
0.305459857,
0.3141847551,
-0.0278581902,
0.5225507617,
0.7359424829,
0.356791079,
-0.0681604445,
0.512416482,
0.759133637,
-0.598647058,
-0.4732586741,
-0.7559227943,
0.163903147,
-0.5463318229,
-0.1494985968,
1.2665691376,
0.7601040602,
0.5288469791,
-0.008815459,
0.7650672793,
0.0163602307,
0.4550471902,
-0.5788773298,
0.4027639031,
-0.6501544714,
0.2735333145,
-0.3125794828,
-0.6310207844,
0.1799947917,
0.4327219129,
-0.5956398249,
-0.2864325047,
0.6128157973,
0.920879364,
0.087158598,
0.6116858125,
0.2874538302,
-0.0611398816,
0.2497801334,
0.3611747026,
1.3264838457,
-0.5725699067,
0.9477427602,
-0.2460724562,
-0.0594595149,
-0.3380936682,
-0.8505593538,
-0.7456864715,
-0.6353758574,
-0.3813783228,
-0.3045895398,
-0.0536180846,
0.7229581475,
0.7345104814,
-0.9322977662,
0.0699912459,
-0.2407376617,
0.3468691409,
-0.3889584243,
-0.2825512588,
0.1350373179,
-0.3453193605,
-0.8001867533,
0.9798119068,
0.2091912031,
0.097643286,
-0.1422944516,
0.007270386,
-0.3419556618,
-0.0037667851,
0.739156127,
0.1567396075,
-0.4484786391,
-0.2954822183,
0.1744506508,
0.1030019447,
0.057898093,
0.920815587,
-0.9480640888,
0.3057399094,
0.9828840494,
0.5994467139,
0.6181898117,
0.5452951789,
0.732979238,
-0.889621377,
0.0799480304,
0.4533680081,
0.1334612221,
0.5189245343,
-0.399050802,
0.8187010288,
0.3428405523,
-0.6594241261,
-0.9390420318,
0.2870876491,
-0.6107692122,
-0.2156671137,
1.2498662472,
0.269546926,
-0.2688257396,
-0.5295737386,
-0.4591045082,
0.0242996402,
-0.4881312251,
0.3406069875,
0.8423278928,
-0.5333983898,
-0.2477847636,
-0.5923417211,
0.7124762535,
0.6140035391,
-0.8042990565,
-0.2549270988,
0.5229941607,
0.017667409,
0.3625076413,
0.4677523375,
-0.1773157865,
0.574606359,
0.0883361846,
-0.3157041967,
0.0499123,
-0.3471771181,
-0.4182808101,
-0.0596919172,
-0.2452569306,
-0.3674491644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14178v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14178v3 | mPLUG-Owl: Modularization Empowers Large Language Models with Multimodality | 2023-04-27T13:27:01 | 2024-03-29T08:13:38 | Qinghao Ye, Haiyang Xu, Guohai Xu, Jiabo Ye, Ming Yan, Yiyang Zhou, Junyang Wang, Anwen Hu, Pengcheng Shi, Yaya Shi, Chenliang Li, Yuanhong Xu, Hehong Chen, Junfeng Tian, Qi Qian, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive zero-shot abilities
on a variety of open-ended tasks, while recent research has also explored the
use of LLMs for multi-modal generation. In this study, we introduce mPLUG-Owl,
a novel training paradigm that equips LLMs with multi-modal abilities through
modularized learning of foundation LLM, a visual knowledge module, and a visual
abstractor module. This approach can support multiple modalities and facilitate
diverse unimodal and multimodal abilities through modality collaboration. The
training paradigm of mPLUG-Owl involves a two-stage method for aligning image
and text, which learns visual knowledge with the assistance of LLM while
maintaining and even improving the generation abilities of LLM. In the first
stage, the visual knowledge module and abstractor module are trained with a
frozen LLM module to align the image and text. In the second stage,
language-only and multi-modal supervised datasets are used to jointly fine-tune
a low-rank adaption (LoRA) module on LLM and the abstractor module by freezing
the visual knowledge module. We carefully build a visually-related instruction
evaluation set OwlEval. Experimental results show that our model outperforms
existing multi-modal models, demonstrating mPLUG-Owl's impressive instruction
and visual understanding ability, multi-turn conversation ability, and
knowledge reasoning ability. Besides, we observe some unexpected and exciting
abilities such as multi-image correlation and scene text understanding, which
makes it possible to leverage it for harder real scenarios, such as vision-only
document comprehension. Our code, pre-trained model, instruction-tuned models,
and evaluation set are available at https://github.com/X-PLUG/mPLUG-Owl. The
online demo is available at https://www.modelscope.cn/studios/damo/mPLUG-Owl. | [
-0.2354446948,
-0.9507575035,
0.5270394683,
0.0277183559,
-0.2546389699,
-0.1401017904,
-0.339122057,
-0.4693984389,
-0.1299187392,
0.1489844918,
-0.569789052,
-0.6059920788,
-0.6014714837,
0.1587798595,
0.0221751928,
0.8157170415,
0.3325579464,
0.1575701535,
-0.2935703397,
-0.0726038218,
-0.3531321287,
-0.2187057137,
-0.432620883,
-0.3617126048,
0.7036645412,
0.1521852762,
0.568567276,
0.893702805,
0.2388211638,
0.385568589,
0.0352698863,
0.2803815305,
-0.3160155118,
-0.277867943,
0.0508976802,
-0.5275241137,
-0.8090416789,
-0.0957736671,
0.7488657832,
0.4147335887,
-0.0238576811,
0.1492267549,
-0.0967026055,
0.38472417,
-0.5323596597,
0.6614398956,
-0.9046251774,
0.1275871247,
0.0516756736,
-0.122901924,
-0.7057300806,
0.1948555708,
0.0480237231,
-0.8307532668,
-0.2085884064,
0.0640054122,
0.6027146578,
0.3045486808,
-0.7855879664,
-0.0483731292,
-0.2585192025,
0.9958884716,
-0.7526331544,
0.2605902255,
0.2330183387,
0.215609014,
0.0158546921,
-0.5335673094,
-0.6528155208,
-0.1565463394,
-0.1365597099,
0.422487855,
0.0845700055,
0.2973376513,
0.1971247494,
0.3380182683,
-0.5361394882,
0.2024622709,
-0.3311316669,
-0.1823407859,
0.4498718679,
0.1796541512,
0.4275829494,
-0.3847063184,
-0.7305396199,
-0.0410437249,
-0.2675207853,
0.2307983488,
0.258651197,
0.1700947583,
-0.0763304234,
0.6636037827,
-0.1366262138,
0.9877892733,
-0.0015744722,
-0.7624807954,
0.3401387036,
-0.2046108246,
-0.2210153341,
-0.1556239575,
0.8349328637,
0.0948068276,
-0.1638882756,
-0.1065758243,
-0.2245488316,
0.0680043474,
0.0351696387,
-0.5056684017,
0.0971963033,
0.082274504,
-0.6274087429,
-0.3686377108,
0.006260985,
-0.5916430354,
-0.0647837371,
-0.5501765013,
0.8425101638,
-0.5844903588,
-0.3969392776,
0.1913066655,
0.1054091752,
0.3953418732,
0.5753457546,
-0.9042540193,
-0.1156866401,
0.7657128572,
0.6548956037,
-0.2080672532,
-0.8034282327,
-0.6546061635,
0.4337454736,
-0.0844588801,
0.8016828299,
-0.9645372629,
0.1236524582,
0.0537790656,
0.0220136251,
-0.4656407833,
-0.148899883,
0.2104257196,
-0.2392410636,
0.4435380101,
0.0844957232,
-0.3567224443,
-0.4507644773,
0.5369158983,
-0.480773896,
0.7697908878,
-0.0995913446,
-0.8796617389,
0.4224175513,
-0.6614717841,
-0.3198105991,
-0.0075004878,
-0.3173612058,
-0.2715949416,
0.1051308736,
0.1901593357,
0.6200416684,
-0.0642580688,
0.0970824137,
-0.2853432298,
-0.1385829896,
0.1545453817,
-0.4037998319,
0.4430827498,
0.0812147707,
-0.1781502813,
0.5324522853,
-0.9627869725,
0.1365761608,
-0.0485853888,
-0.8986880183,
-0.1076030955,
-0.0405547619,
0.1944192648,
0.3822433949,
0.3904680014,
-0.4177941382,
0.5274893641,
-0.1586973071,
0.4395400286,
0.7118060589,
-0.5229392648,
0.5447213054,
-0.38176772,
0.374915421,
0.094026126,
0.3919931948,
-0.7891839743,
-0.6527140141,
-0.8494343162,
-0.4749934971,
0.0370182358,
0.6347035766,
-1.0283768177,
0.4239106774,
-0.1087078974,
-0.1982018054,
-0.3879273236,
0.197822988,
0.5280682445,
0.4112457037,
0.1788172424,
0.0084159439,
-0.1736352891,
-0.8458046913,
0.3285932243,
-0.1493188143,
0.0392944142,
0.2805763483,
0.4123857021,
-0.3786574006,
0.5821344852,
-0.2749665082,
-0.4123763144,
-0.3359404802,
0.4057734013,
0.0664291456,
0.3427677155,
0.2697153091,
-0.7326737046,
-0.2333978266,
0.3069209456,
-0.7975768447,
0.0610192083,
-0.0617626496,
0.0801520571,
0.3787995577,
0.3353811502,
-0.5886713862,
0.0685643107,
0.8528459072,
-0.1703853309,
0.5987836719,
-0.3726545572,
0.0001129419,
-1.4912108183,
0.0051185763,
-0.2815407217,
-0.2346826792,
-0.524297595,
0.2439440936,
0.065819636,
-0.3675770164,
-0.45310691,
0.3041653037,
-0.6131412983,
0.015095029,
-0.4407767951,
0.0336223468,
-0.0099582085,
0.7046502829,
0.2973012924,
0.5991939306,
0.8854729533,
-0.1608703732,
0.4085005224,
0.0872213617,
-0.2173002511,
0.3239500225,
-0.281686306,
0.1926693618,
-0.201325804,
0.2117531747,
-0.8709298968,
-0.3176401556,
-0.0078677535,
-0.0966440514,
0.3172698021,
-0.2070193291,
-0.4503036141,
-0.0525993332,
-0.3252865076,
0.4528332651,
0.289214462,
-0.4799951911,
1.1484165192,
0.1709650606,
0.0598421544,
-0.8691537976,
-0.5488979816,
0.1550863087,
-0.1355964839,
-0.918155849,
0.0185377877,
-0.2692653537,
0.0300106965,
-0.1122514978,
0.2538155019,
-0.0747260749,
-0.2515608966,
0.082842432,
0.2396002859,
-0.409009099,
0.386059761,
-0.039040301,
-0.2974567711,
-0.2096078843,
-0.3576690555,
0.5810118914,
-0.4408675432,
-0.4020706415,
-0.4098230302,
0.3010520637,
0.7626377344,
-0.4361953139,
0.6922250986,
1.0770394802,
-0.1481868476,
-0.2466150075,
-0.6162167192,
-0.1765799969,
-0.4390477836,
0.499099791,
-0.3220603466,
-0.897369504,
0.2896579504,
-0.2055442482,
0.0397144705,
0.0423957705,
0.5796747208,
0.1940348446,
1.0123901367,
0.8485301733,
0.1573030949,
0.6335604191,
-0.2554845214,
0.0985368416,
-0.8927465677,
-0.4055208862,
0.2369041145,
-0.2731018364,
-0.2412745804,
-0.5587829947,
0.4119546711,
0.1389818937,
0.4014791846,
0.0900205597,
-0.3567827344,
0.5304819942,
0.4102992117,
0.3173900843,
0.5487667918,
-0.0939893872,
-0.0934820771,
0.1619727314,
-0.9318472147,
-0.3973328769,
1.1047507524,
0.2414341718,
0.9271891117,
-0.0613588616,
0.4305613339,
0.0114733484,
0.1158147901,
-1.0966293812,
0.7358914614,
-0.2210731208,
-0.3283268213,
-0.2839886248,
-0.3182133138,
-0.6514673233,
0.5573003888,
-0.7154007554,
-0.6338164806,
-0.0771016181,
0.2320002168,
-0.1258243918,
0.4028173387,
-0.9452195168,
0.8808657527,
-0.3457614183,
-0.4288382232,
-0.3698184192,
-0.4359782636,
0.6508852839,
-0.1072432026,
0.1428210139,
-0.0799632221,
-0.3034707308,
0.226974085,
-0.1046094075,
0.9476938248,
0.1972591132,
-0.0983542204,
0.0815114155,
-0.0872545391,
0.4012577236,
0.169035241,
0.0528695881,
0.0759956166,
-0.0415982753,
-0.3602643311,
-0.4686336219,
0.693600893,
-0.7703824043,
-0.6953852773,
-0.4172356129,
-1.026481986,
0.021830162,
0.2444073707,
0.0502625704,
0.7221835256,
0.0352726392,
0.3889688551,
0.6708014607,
-0.2791210711,
0.6525272131,
0.5765300989,
-0.4640724659,
-0.5007035732,
0.9604874849,
0.0010204398,
0.4841704667,
0.5967997909,
0.4809589982,
0.0090646511,
-0.4705869257,
-0.4122742116,
0.1098276004,
-0.7098495364,
-0.1187826619,
-0.7143885493,
-0.1357733756,
-0.2167063355,
-0.0942796394,
-0.2584854364,
-0.2866678536,
-0.1696070284,
0.1005738974,
0.1482786387,
0.7344852686,
-0.0240976941,
0.1736798882,
-0.5555304885,
0.1110038087,
0.8919808269,
0.0450098813,
0.0280560162,
-0.1905231029,
-0.1984759569,
-0.1234262958,
-0.2257617712,
-0.5107250214,
0.0131047741,
0.3944665194,
0.4363704622,
0.6674312949,
-0.258911401,
0.4914064705,
-0.4493277371,
0.6608701944,
0.4164316952,
-0.8155406713,
0.4271307588,
-0.7681738138,
0.6693959236,
0.1354601085,
0.0479114428,
-0.176840052,
-0.2004116476,
-0.201915279,
-0.6726939678,
0.8788015246,
0.0297132544,
0.1156936884,
0.1492075771,
0.134996444,
0.319660455,
0.1296797246,
-1.1905804873,
0.1692789048,
-0.378133595,
-0.0795672759,
0.1974565536,
-0.3255344629,
-0.2971848249,
-0.3386277854,
0.422419101,
-0.5915614963,
0.1186535507,
-0.0216338225,
-0.1975530833,
0.1875431687,
0.5137463808,
0.807995677,
0.9814995527,
-0.0193587281,
0.2751396596,
0.3162487447,
-0.3058184683,
-0.0805732235,
-0.0431669429,
-0.0461410843,
-0.2843375802,
0.5688896179,
0.7826059461,
0.3596776724,
-0.6748275757,
0.6808248162,
-0.1078164801,
-0.1174749061,
-0.2637579143,
0.1242240295,
0.1661941707,
0.3878046274,
0.3679254949,
0.0225060526,
-0.1632716507,
-0.7970288992,
0.0075260904,
0.4986928105,
-0.1865800917,
-0.5461523533,
0.4975367785,
0.2039938122,
-0.2768508792,
0.1193588153,
-0.1121065393,
-0.2766229212,
0.3430390656,
0.8215005994,
0.6893707514,
-0.1067105085,
0.3329305351,
0.2359666973,
0.3757029176,
0.0120307151,
0.1671119779,
-0.2436791807,
-0.6732814312,
-0.6278879046,
-0.6863739491,
-0.1674517691,
0.2978465855,
-0.3880742788,
0.3752937317,
-0.5373883247,
-0.0795205757,
-0.2219821066,
-0.3687313795,
-0.4500525892,
-0.0672783554,
0.2417787015,
0.7235740423,
-0.8165723681,
1.1141239405,
1.0186527967,
-0.4553812742,
-0.6380381584,
-0.0540048368,
0.0967467949,
-0.9387757182,
0.6674835086,
0.3389130831,
-0.1600803137,
-0.0513982959,
-0.3632356226,
-0.5809262991,
1.415415287,
0.4182477593,
-0.5124105811,
-0.165531531,
0.165227592,
0.4283383489,
-0.720721364,
0.3881532252,
0.0279760342,
0.3972565234,
0.1922277212,
-1.076218009,
-0.1951539367,
-0.2265006006,
-0.027925143,
-0.0593700074,
-1.0138324499,
1.0926829576,
-0.1431347579,
-0.0781799853,
0.0131197218,
0.4151729941,
0.0559886023,
0.1807130575,
0.5634585619,
0.7404002547,
0.3754311502,
-0.0771469548,
0.8500843048,
-0.4602818191,
0.1903105229,
0.8572950363,
-0.0248178728,
0.9298588634,
0.467199266,
0.3401827812,
0.3851343989,
0.1332347989,
0.1001828685,
0.2865795493,
-0.3664688468,
-0.5499796271,
-0.6973756552,
-0.182525456,
-0.3092287183,
0.7301014662,
0.1176369265,
-0.3273366094,
-0.3251355886,
0.3813062906,
0.0260390043,
0.0302216839,
-0.2709871829,
0.9928321838,
-0.0173059851,
-0.2767404914,
0.4458710253,
-0.1215710863,
0.9145818353,
-1.033798933,
-0.0859768093,
0.0592508577,
0.2783334553,
-0.2750636339,
-0.6056725979,
0.0018401662,
-0.3476186991,
-0.3503213823,
-0.2067646533,
0.6309831738,
-0.6644271016,
-0.7033784986,
0.3690313995,
0.3948510587,
-0.0836386308,
0.1323381215,
-0.6143863201,
0.2621553242,
-0.2194495499,
-0.1675364673,
0.5336531401,
0.5292557478,
0.1743770093,
0.7396667004,
0.6697294116,
-0.0939057395,
0.2517946064,
0.0192240942,
0.9386176467,
-0.3092968464,
-0.2216115147,
-0.6326726079,
0.6439343095,
0.0727008283,
-0.3276418746,
0.6390423179,
0.5894064903,
0.7547411919,
-0.3086888194,
0.5612983704,
-0.0344662331,
-0.2447630465,
-0.8721123338,
0.6766743064,
-0.754873395,
0.0021920246,
-0.1753397733,
-1.1352959871,
-0.2284197211,
0.5828995705,
-0.2882078588,
-0.2018985003,
0.8397123814,
0.8445054889,
-0.3182964623,
-0.2301843464,
0.7312577367,
0.2130487412,
0.2586951554,
0.7095338106,
0.8682991266,
-0.3920673728,
0.816208601,
-0.0756014362,
-0.5276793838,
0.0504075922,
-0.9223840833,
-1.3654434681,
-0.7413745522,
-0.0824126825,
0.2011280954,
-0.108327128,
0.8514198661,
0.971696198,
-0.3625416756,
-0.2411561757,
0.2369091213,
0.013858634,
-0.1342273653,
-0.2293888032,
0.1809624434,
-0.5426820517,
-0.7429193854,
0.5527155399,
0.6782789826,
-0.1478737742,
-0.4576475024,
-0.017603226,
-0.4221203625,
-0.0492569394,
1.0422720909,
-0.0062283739,
-0.9894732237,
-0.3769294322,
-0.0680362806,
0.0670282617,
0.1573488712,
0.7694994807,
-0.6300626397,
0.7120310664,
0.5847533345,
0.4200065434,
0.2546367049,
0.0211862493,
0.4464093149,
-0.4934291244,
0.6192758679,
-0.2120706439,
0.5669621825,
0.257247746,
-0.2674939334,
0.1098291427,
0.1710091233,
-0.5486428738,
-0.5165935159,
0.4450455904,
-1.2609335184,
-0.2634542286,
1.2446960211,
-0.071488075,
-0.3730817735,
0.07302019,
-0.5941078663,
-0.0568275265,
-0.3355588317,
1.0676746368,
0.6603585482,
-0.1292499453,
-0.6076254249,
-0.2772441208,
0.1557892263,
0.1370566785,
-0.9334980845,
-0.0662552118,
0.4884926975,
0.2832691967,
0.3118019402,
0.3129329085,
-0.0612282343,
0.1723518074,
-0.0003737933,
0.0875582919,
-0.6841151714,
-0.3532271087,
-0.3101381958,
0.2709044218,
-0.0128896153,
-0.0638403967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14177v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14177v2 | ChatGPT vs State-of-the-Art Models: A Benchmarking Study in Keyphrase Generation Task | 2023-04-27T13:25:43 | 2023-06-29T13:40:42 | Roberto Martínez-Cruz, Alvaro J. López-López, José Portela | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformer-based language models, including ChatGPT, have demonstrated
exceptional performance in various natural language generation tasks. However,
there has been limited research evaluating ChatGPT's keyphrase generation
ability, which involves identifying informative phrases that accurately reflect
a document's content. This study seeks to address this gap by comparing
ChatGPT's keyphrase generation performance with state-of-the-art models, while
also testing its potential as a solution for two significant challenges in the
field: domain adaptation and keyphrase generation from long documents. We
conducted experiments on six publicly available datasets from scientific
articles and news domains, analyzing performance on both short and long
documents. Our results show that ChatGPT outperforms current state-of-the-art
models in all tested datasets and environments, generating high-quality
keyphrases that adapt well to diverse domains and document lengths. | [
-0.0669950992,
-0.6690410972,
0.4444129169,
0.0951928049,
-0.3990858197,
0.1643270105,
-0.2204266638,
-0.3001426756,
-0.3113828599,
0.3430326879,
-0.4648864269,
-0.2686343789,
-0.7052718401,
0.2911082506,
-0.584020555,
1.2259676456,
-0.0348926745,
-0.0395267233,
-0.1844834387,
0.2268249691,
-0.4181070924,
-0.4745234251,
-0.5808278322,
-0.1583104283,
0.0286240615,
0.1165297553,
0.9225853682,
0.3989153504,
1.0779399872,
0.100434579,
-0.1941474825,
0.1214098185,
-0.5226303339,
0.4415811598,
-0.281793803,
-0.0740142986,
-0.331291914,
-0.1424610466,
0.5025832057,
0.416523993,
0.0304478388,
-0.0327598862,
0.0296700019,
0.816791594,
-0.4907684326,
0.2823417485,
-1.0804121494,
0.01199173,
-0.3687000573,
-0.0665730312,
-0.2684618533,
-0.660777092,
0.4563459456,
-0.4480619133,
0.6055804491,
0.2321121991,
0.8277491331,
-0.059143886,
-0.4124248922,
-0.7099286914,
-0.6080110669,
0.3654855788,
-0.8512706161,
0.5630925894,
-0.0737544671,
0.3756649494,
-0.4818661511,
-1.1291435957,
-0.5646951199,
-0.3716803491,
0.2362280637,
0.2523843348,
-0.3041685224,
-0.1558190435,
0.3338353038,
0.4151459932,
-1.0018360615,
-0.1076639816,
-0.6268641353,
0.0921210498,
0.5366985202,
-0.1310637742,
0.1172850877,
-0.5058752298,
-0.1841455549,
-0.4554922581,
-0.8425757885,
-0.1111374646,
0.1570262164,
0.2954786718,
0.2303306758,
0.427229166,
-0.3177820146,
0.2801004946,
-0.0743081197,
-0.0686747208,
0.124361597,
-0.3710478544,
-0.0544978678,
0.0250400566,
0.8207209706,
0.7091199756,
0.2240435332,
-0.5585480928,
-0.1625443995,
0.0471670553,
0.3379021883,
-1.1985683441,
-0.53795892,
0.0759432986,
-0.3442892134,
-0.4136919677,
0.0272707269,
-0.9990153909,
-0.2964243889,
0.1806309223,
0.5164773464,
-0.7222229838,
-0.1729706824,
0.1260407269,
-0.5251088142,
0.1665361822,
0.167870149,
-0.7321379781,
0.3825310171,
0.8457645774,
1.1231482029,
-0.7804731727,
-0.1344418526,
-0.1129034683,
-0.2205547094,
-0.3916774988,
0.8891608715,
-0.5263775587,
-0.6473651528,
0.0763364285,
-0.2631474733,
-0.4675204754,
-0.6172374487,
0.9945512414,
-0.6078210473,
0.33734864,
-0.210278064,
-0.7773239017,
0.000779604,
0.057704296,
-0.6166037917,
1.1304398775,
0.1968766749,
-0.8686179519,
0.5781937242,
-1.1141431332,
-0.5738766789,
0.0978534967,
-0.0576209612,
-0.759749651,
0.3372039497,
0.2088705748,
0.2959847152,
-0.4244424701,
0.2511042356,
-0.0379940942,
0.0075334222,
0.5676732659,
-0.5530701876,
0.1732087433,
0.5278149843,
-0.3346928358,
-0.2934858799,
-0.7601459622,
0.0279109161,
0.5220344067,
-0.2481419891,
0.0102020828,
0.2578366697,
0.305968225,
0.2287485301,
-0.0176906604,
-0.6852097511,
0.2455495149,
-0.2315538526,
0.937813282,
0.2408079505,
0.415032506,
0.1677441895,
-0.401152581,
0.4048093259,
-0.1515732855,
0.056613069,
-0.2835195661,
-0.6318962574,
-0.4414612651,
-0.0231156126,
0.5636678338,
0.1880233884,
-0.5689054728,
0.1069286913,
-0.687628448,
-0.7194685936,
-0.2351997495,
-0.2359345406,
0.2438676953,
0.5483756661,
0.2931556702,
-0.5299027562,
-0.2360724211,
-0.7769742012,
-0.4986076355,
-0.107071951,
-0.0157880187,
0.4034889638,
0.7265014648,
0.1577535272,
0.9964718819,
-0.5422651768,
0.1321470737,
-0.2352102697,
0.3268122077,
0.1703025103,
0.2701610625,
0.4012392163,
-1.1638765335,
-0.6002123952,
-0.1783436984,
-0.4453606606,
0.1007758081,
-0.0548738502,
-0.0380094349,
-0.1082800254,
0.3456950188,
-0.8570064306,
0.1785125732,
0.4308489561,
-0.0496376194,
0.5259963274,
-0.1696816385,
0.34802109,
-1.2168245316,
0.3181324601,
-0.2740964592,
-0.0606967621,
-0.9897913933,
0.0408771746,
0.3194760084,
-0.8027912974,
-0.4029481411,
0.4606818557,
-0.3214473426,
-0.0007720854,
-0.5243928432,
0.2566291392,
0.0914550424,
0.2404991835,
0.3331588805,
0.9202905297,
0.3807993531,
-0.4432380497,
0.0486857705,
0.420194298,
-0.3788325489,
0.2263302058,
-0.8653082848,
0.1979340017,
0.1458564103,
0.337990731,
-0.9760966897,
-0.4013467431,
-0.1187118664,
-0.4540439844,
0.1244775429,
-0.1378096342,
-0.5517577529,
-0.4845057726,
-0.1847056299,
0.2108227462,
0.8847156167,
-0.3494037986,
0.0778343752,
0.1142324209,
-0.5298073292,
-0.0435786881,
-0.1143550873,
0.2935304046,
-0.1477404833,
-0.7812321782,
0.570674479,
0.0445686541,
0.1079051197,
-0.2199937105,
-0.2821486592,
-0.1208392009,
0.159360379,
0.2037195563,
0.0284841843,
-0.2491947412,
0.0674283803,
0.0482458621,
0.0864555761,
-0.0415326729,
-0.2547086775,
0.5628422499,
-0.0261301547,
-0.4770870507,
0.0443704054,
0.2823013067,
0.8164157271,
-0.599811852,
0.4239770174,
0.2686352432,
-0.103167735,
-0.2155722827,
-0.3258032799,
-0.3500364125,
-0.4307085872,
0.5059668422,
-0.2375060022,
-0.6471053958,
0.1020479947,
-0.3391914964,
0.4607729018,
0.4872994423,
0.469414562,
0.2501423955,
0.8273162246,
0.3362605274,
0.0387985036,
0.3384716511,
0.0509318188,
0.6454293728,
-0.7070860863,
0.1117909476,
-0.6163988709,
-0.0552815758,
-0.7681730986,
-0.314948827,
0.4711763859,
0.0393732451,
0.1453789771,
0.5172219872,
-0.70320189,
0.0231883768,
0.745323956,
0.0387918986,
0.2351349294,
0.0284032151,
0.0926158801,
-0.0262412615,
-0.7142111063,
-0.6266099215,
1.4024840593,
0.1035698205,
0.6722256541,
-0.0024443325,
0.5256103873,
0.3226849139,
0.041495245,
-0.4592531919,
0.3018663824,
-0.1562205255,
-0.6534058452,
-0.2229463458,
-0.1666728258,
-1.1105520725,
0.4137914479,
-0.2249280214,
-0.4478746355,
-0.0816483945,
-0.0354678258,
-0.1023977399,
0.051779855,
-0.4945873618,
1.0068408251,
-0.1656395942,
-0.0468681455,
0.1194916293,
-0.5086097121,
0.1298082471,
-0.4300975502,
0.0111349998,
-0.2214956433,
0.2896723151,
0.8919665217,
-0.1697201431,
0.3618628681,
0.0069498178,
0.159971416,
0.2269471437,
-0.0319547579,
0.7857607007,
-0.1430856436,
-0.1642944217,
-0.1376562864,
-0.0032200818,
-0.0078389393,
-0.4410403371,
0.4256852269,
-0.3697990775,
-0.4037129283,
-0.1850451529,
-0.636474967,
-0.2626958489,
0.3839089274,
0.6541957259,
0.3858041465,
-0.5507481694,
0.5126147866,
0.7282299995,
0.0060092532,
0.4318780005,
0.4722156823,
-0.0571249574,
-0.1623237878,
0.8380529881,
0.070566453,
0.495623827,
0.4553999901,
0.2419994473,
-0.255915612,
-0.9183522463,
-0.3735500872,
-0.0580385439,
-0.4656962752,
-0.0909869075,
-0.7747992873,
-0.5524263382,
-0.8028037548,
-0.0491660349,
-0.4761989415,
-0.5454524755,
0.3228630126,
0.0966437161,
0.3981875181,
0.417603761,
0.2665108144,
0.4115109742,
-0.8078396916,
0.3695323467,
0.2073953599,
-0.0852611586,
-0.3067470193,
-0.4446125329,
-0.1508105695,
0.0057320381,
-0.8586739302,
-0.9332599044,
0.2796415389,
0.5687866807,
0.4597555995,
0.0959325135,
0.1909830719,
0.1186129749,
-0.8755261898,
0.972751677,
-0.0834705979,
-0.562215209,
0.7058275342,
-0.3797307909,
0.3642835319,
0.4633972943,
0.3034358025,
-0.8070814013,
-0.5444366336,
-0.8230626583,
-0.8117835522,
0.2454437762,
0.8867288232,
0.1703717411,
-0.0607896745,
0.1464456767,
0.3791930079,
0.3327245116,
-0.5519439578,
0.1155315787,
-0.3826680779,
-0.2319600433,
0.0945080295,
0.0468745306,
0.1120447144,
0.4697435498,
0.7316401005,
-0.1012803912,
0.3909462392,
0.211349383,
-0.2853069007,
0.1933271885,
0.5300814509,
0.6520445943,
0.6413736939,
-0.2472938448,
-0.1056363359,
-0.0435337834,
-0.782555759,
-0.1089847684,
0.347353518,
-0.5025929213,
0.4229358435,
0.349275887,
0.9249138236,
0.2695529163,
-0.6620886326,
0.8030815125,
-0.1262647808,
-0.520501852,
0.273640871,
0.2974418998,
0.0760720447,
0.1071587354,
0.5564661026,
-0.0155228982,
0.2837792635,
-0.3355062902,
0.327570498,
0.5556128621,
-0.0425057933,
-0.3283448815,
0.7882736921,
0.1395377666,
-0.4505299926,
0.5652136803,
0.065606609,
-0.5906587839,
0.4675518274,
0.5772256851,
0.9992874265,
0.0627939329,
0.1543599367,
0.2203469872,
0.1479589492,
-0.219418183,
0.1815012395,
-0.2250870019,
-0.4654098451,
0.0695104599,
-0.5348858237,
-0.7081823349,
0.1358104199,
-0.5940869451,
-0.1193160489,
0.0096170632,
-0.3460151851,
0.2450632602,
0.0203652345,
-0.6790654659,
0.1113683209,
-0.1049172357,
1.0321854353,
-0.8088244796,
0.7036625147,
0.4845305383,
-0.2385176122,
-0.4914254844,
0.23123914,
-0.3620474935,
-0.763045907,
0.4514873326,
0.0631434321,
0.2584839463,
-0.0644258335,
-0.2919344306,
-0.9898072481,
1.266633749,
0.189443782,
-0.4401009083,
-0.264723897,
0.4365394115,
0.5784581304,
-0.1937295794,
-0.0167914741,
0.4044135511,
0.2434954345,
0.0671917051,
-1.0538078547,
-0.1690719128,
-0.1823323816,
0.1649088264,
0.2488375604,
-0.585209012,
0.7751979232,
0.1261266023,
-0.3208706081,
0.0975411087,
0.6451786757,
0.3014408946,
0.1477173865,
0.27391541,
0.2837623656,
0.7493470311,
-0.1237087399,
0.8459246755,
-0.7339577675,
0.3826684654,
1.0647150278,
-0.4994068742,
0.9203237891,
0.4129474163,
-0.0759837851,
0.1524950117,
0.5718002915,
-0.2226301432,
0.9006927013,
0.1301933825,
-0.1475219131,
0.1194326058,
0.0678757429,
-0.5588947535,
0.3194025755,
0.0239788759,
-0.6313791871,
-0.5717726946,
0.0862735733,
0.0959953815,
-0.1978169382,
0.0620704703,
0.9166177511,
0.0445006713,
-1.0250403881,
0.3477956951,
0.0004902954,
0.3231328428,
-0.6317681074,
0.1312097311,
-0.2693314552,
0.2276805341,
0.1746586859,
-0.7368652821,
-0.1530511677,
0.2862360477,
-0.0834262148,
-0.1245600879,
0.9636639357,
-0.1142034605,
-0.5107953548,
-0.2860973179,
0.5542137027,
0.2751213908,
-0.2273406684,
-0.726722002,
-0.1462104917,
-0.0470713675,
-0.4510199428,
0.4081417918,
0.3922264576,
-0.0400522649,
0.5663022995,
0.576697588,
0.0495379604,
0.3367041945,
-0.1655944288,
0.7998561263,
-0.3899747133,
-0.3427581787,
-0.8301461339,
0.1392772198,
-0.358853966,
-0.6268294454,
0.8619515896,
0.8518593907,
0.6428372264,
-0.2462994158,
1.0372093916,
-0.1185239181,
0.6731054783,
-0.587197423,
0.7353276014,
-0.1746871769,
-0.2784042358,
-0.2806080878,
-0.9412696362,
-0.0618457347,
0.3460249305,
-0.207894966,
-0.0460819118,
0.8794377446,
0.8851581812,
-0.1885869503,
0.2692541182,
0.1586787552,
-0.1899546832,
0.7123797536,
0.4814907312,
0.6459351778,
-0.7194343209,
0.6675038338,
-0.1786586791,
0.0106529128,
-0.3613012433,
-0.9864207506,
-0.7630844116,
-0.6101903319,
-0.2588547766,
-0.0828647166,
0.4273483455,
0.6353080273,
0.766482532,
-0.6100192666,
0.099095203,
-0.351516217,
-0.2516500354,
-0.2167124897,
-0.189772293,
0.7133535147,
-0.5379799604,
-0.5947470069,
0.4196795225,
0.1781749725,
-0.0223955065,
0.0625308529,
0.0130741177,
0.2939628661,
0.3033780456,
0.4075435698,
0.1600214392,
-0.390293926,
-0.1988458633,
0.3135868311,
-0.3495696187,
0.2966691852,
0.9746139646,
-0.2667886615,
0.2060557157,
0.5181601644,
0.6643060446,
0.6652397513,
0.0121566448,
0.6531468034,
-0.4096052051,
-0.4978393018,
0.2048719674,
0.222320497,
0.3732240796,
-0.0592661798,
0.6288901567,
0.1561568081,
-0.8969296217,
-0.8204344511,
0.0883844495,
-0.8511314988,
-0.2072423249,
1.1456086636,
-0.1105563864,
-0.1699764729,
0.1112691313,
-0.3079554737,
0.1998011172,
-0.4124883711,
0.8084911108,
0.5763946176,
-0.0978907645,
0.1372416317,
-0.6003026366,
0.7009322047,
0.1488435268,
-0.7566053867,
0.3799882233,
0.1855502576,
0.4190555513,
0.1350517422,
0.4404718876,
-0.2238700986,
0.5410451293,
0.1609828919,
-0.0048734713,
-0.0393289626,
-0.006212526,
0.0955485031,
0.3465946019,
0.2977263629,
-0.1214331016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14108v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14108v5 | DataComp: In search of the next generation of multimodal datasets | 2023-04-27T11:37:18 | 2023-10-20T17:01:44 | Samir Yitzhak Gadre, Gabriel Ilharco, Alex Fang, Jonathan Hayase, Georgios Smyrnis, Thao Nguyen, Ryan Marten, Mitchell Wortsman, Dhruba Ghosh, Jieyu Zhang, Eyal Orgad, Rahim Entezari, Giannis Daras, Sarah Pratt, Vivek Ramanujan, Yonatan Bitton, Kalyani Marathe, Stephen Mussmann, Richard Vencu, Mehdi Cherti, Ranjay Krishna, Pang Wei Koh, Olga Saukh, Alexander Ratner, Shuran Song, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Ali Farhadi, Romain Beaumont, Sewoong Oh, Alex Dimakis, Jenia Jitsev, Yair Carmon, Vaishaal Shankar, Ludwig Schmidt | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Multimodal datasets are a critical component in recent breakthroughs such as
Stable Diffusion and GPT-4, yet their design does not receive the same research
attention as model architectures or training algorithms. To address this
shortcoming in the ML ecosystem, we introduce DataComp, a testbed for dataset
experiments centered around a new candidate pool of 12.8 billion image-text
pairs from Common Crawl. Participants in our benchmark design new filtering
techniques or curate new data sources and then evaluate their new dataset by
running our standardized CLIP training code and testing the resulting model on
38 downstream test sets. Our benchmark consists of multiple compute scales
spanning four orders of magnitude, which enables the study of scaling trends
and makes the benchmark accessible to researchers with varying resources. Our
baseline experiments show that the DataComp workflow leads to better training
sets. In particular, our best baseline, DataComp-1B, enables training a CLIP
ViT-L/14 from scratch to 79.2% zero-shot accuracy on ImageNet, outperforming
OpenAI's CLIP ViT-L/14 by 3.7 percentage points while using the same training
procedure and compute. We release DataComp and all accompanying code at
www.datacomp.ai. | [
-0.6833346486,
-0.4148023427,
0.2988155782,
0.1811305135,
-0.1734981984,
0.028859511,
-0.1961863637,
-0.0816376805,
0.0551382154,
0.1675337851,
-0.7334712744,
-0.4249457419,
-0.7027945518,
0.110985212,
-0.5789052248,
0.7745335698,
-0.2048018575,
0.0862655491,
-0.4227945805,
-0.4158656597,
-0.5922200084,
-0.3451507986,
-0.5981370807,
-0.0559124649,
0.6652057171,
0.4925679266,
0.8399567008,
0.585642457,
0.8371611834,
0.2079145908,
0.2139392644,
0.2355541587,
-0.5474157929,
-0.0078435326,
0.0133339986,
-0.3401189148,
-0.0825764388,
0.3955875933,
0.6933727264,
0.6261380911,
0.0289502814,
0.1489763111,
-0.0449980758,
0.7865409255,
-0.8998053074,
0.1647892892,
-0.4907035232,
0.2689970434,
-0.3422905207,
-0.4017771184,
-0.45296067,
-0.1923819482,
-0.0478335135,
-0.6095039845,
0.5316358805,
-0.0484892167,
0.5961999297,
0.4171335101,
-0.510043025,
0.1296800524,
-0.373406738,
0.840264976,
-0.3872861564,
0.4846332371,
0.2352783084,
0.5076718926,
-0.1732075214,
-1.0123337507,
-0.5648037195,
0.147253871,
0.2694402337,
0.0039195479,
-0.25797984,
-0.1427109689,
0.286903888,
0.2216995806,
-0.8292735219,
-0.1546156406,
-0.0925321802,
0.0431824476,
0.4914281666,
0.2842059731,
0.0132869016,
0.0932280794,
-0.5237432718,
-0.5896634459,
-0.5787546039,
-0.1774533391,
0.0690916628,
0.192778796,
-0.1188465655,
0.3779183626,
-0.0013533604,
0.7162681222,
-0.2360288799,
0.0924910977,
0.5930549502,
-0.5710411668,
-0.169887498,
-0.2211982012,
0.6654003263,
0.6899001002,
0.1695407927,
0.0533500127,
-0.0103257652,
0.1864343286,
0.2542847097,
-1.0470688343,
-0.5002692938,
0.0897367746,
-0.5850192904,
-0.4153710306,
-0.0554364808,
-0.9109891057,
-0.4434645474,
-0.4363841414,
0.5289836526,
-0.2356360704,
-0.2350282073,
0.1016653106,
-0.5090212822,
-0.0603355914,
0.3216886222,
-0.7773582935,
0.3565848768,
0.4470423162,
1.1260530949,
-0.6357753277,
-0.4624772072,
-0.4729218185,
-0.1975531578,
-0.4664363563,
0.8787772655,
-0.8821166158,
-0.3320553005,
-0.0174699221,
0.1347676367,
-0.3092218339,
-0.7293198705,
0.5096384287,
-0.3808477521,
0.0434391834,
-0.3306127787,
-0.653268218,
-0.2329548448,
0.3689487278,
-0.8886972666,
0.9016729593,
0.1758226156,
-0.8397806883,
0.6451342106,
-0.8009875417,
0.0048000487,
-0.0873187333,
-0.3003633022,
-0.3869709373,
-0.1943945587,
0.4875027239,
0.5647924542,
-0.2619026303,
0.1041472852,
-0.9376659393,
-0.5054224133,
0.2256541699,
-0.7544981241,
0.5317134261,
0.1509153694,
-0.090466328,
-0.2309646606,
-0.7544992566,
0.2051690817,
0.0104248282,
-0.10958419,
-0.0356506631,
-0.1310186684,
0.5334082246,
0.320001483,
-0.1783966422,
-0.5769192576,
0.4050231576,
0.4193786383,
0.5397784114,
0.8586719036,
-0.0583300218,
0.3269931078,
-0.5509548783,
0.507564187,
0.1547374874,
0.3825373352,
-0.4935509562,
-0.4990136027,
-0.3954323232,
-0.5393481255,
0.3466935158,
0.1583578438,
-0.9307187796,
-0.0807750672,
-0.3068629503,
-0.5222124457,
-0.4050500393,
0.1519843787,
-0.015484564,
0.3592382073,
0.5298494697,
-0.4750209749,
-0.6595149636,
-0.9554633498,
0.1250798255,
0.2340970933,
0.0372666605,
0.2211194932,
0.4703490436,
-0.4660979211,
1.0602763891,
-0.6037467718,
-0.4171239436,
-0.0589393154,
0.2401205152,
0.2126310617,
0.3144435585,
0.6336874366,
-1.1601330042,
-0.3776765168,
-0.5091218948,
-0.8331251144,
-0.0096447505,
-0.0237469971,
-0.0276636183,
-0.161650002,
0.3475898504,
-0.3371270299,
0.2584692538,
0.913852036,
-0.012740205,
0.3242132366,
-0.0567347817,
0.4063722789,
-1.0339764357,
0.1979451627,
0.1885507256,
-0.316911757,
-0.3841023445,
-0.141157195,
0.2206428498,
-0.3690909743,
-0.3839938343,
0.3069051206,
-0.1554514021,
-0.1922648102,
-0.3161839843,
-0.1860467196,
0.1976241916,
0.4979873598,
0.0893664733,
0.9340833426,
0.6728778481,
-0.5528283715,
0.6085653901,
0.3751086593,
-0.26743716,
0.6448196173,
-0.4644620121,
0.1071501151,
-0.1117996126,
0.7484348416,
-1.055331707,
-0.1777220666,
-0.1890095025,
-0.1707738787,
0.1949068159,
-0.298873812,
-0.5815563202,
-0.3211812675,
-0.6521338224,
0.6268666983,
0.2743346393,
-0.7391175032,
0.2941411436,
0.4586259723,
-0.060378179,
-0.5104678869,
-0.6761603951,
0.2546141744,
-0.110699825,
-0.718226254,
0.3690821826,
-0.3481321633,
0.1771873534,
-0.2121906281,
0.131338954,
-0.4778122902,
-0.1137376726,
0.3865391314,
0.3201231062,
-0.036342483,
0.2609743178,
-0.3162902594,
-0.2685977519,
-0.0581918173,
-0.0661181137,
0.4616705775,
0.0494555458,
-0.4992928505,
-0.4449133575,
0.3015644848,
0.5552524328,
0.0087905098,
0.1461106986,
0.7326411605,
-0.1020831317,
-0.1214747652,
-0.3059184849,
-0.0810329542,
-0.4708223045,
0.234784469,
-0.181274578,
-0.568584919,
0.2139942348,
-0.3325632513,
0.2621113658,
0.227860868,
0.5355819464,
-0.1397898346,
1.0216493607,
0.5507739186,
-0.1798683405,
0.5879118443,
-0.5148993134,
-0.1208334193,
-0.6886466742,
-0.1092519239,
-0.1934319884,
-0.7446611524,
-0.6510754824,
-0.6853521466,
0.622769177,
-0.6262410283,
0.1337500215,
0.3774785399,
-0.3104569018,
0.3952476978,
0.5830200911,
0.3592428267,
0.2964510024,
-0.0674288943,
0.2448350638,
-0.2302456945,
-0.7801302671,
-0.1384823769,
1.4802039862,
0.2218795866,
1.080466032,
-0.2184979916,
0.3644634485,
0.7043662071,
-0.0408728458,
-0.4885323942,
0.471899271,
-0.3698882163,
-0.5333673954,
0.0194717161,
-0.3981514573,
-0.9373391867,
0.1518314332,
-0.2018163353,
-0.0524940901,
0.4336867929,
0.2705431879,
0.0111430036,
0.3279790282,
-0.7492209673,
0.9993661046,
0.1993996501,
-0.5139248371,
-0.1265098602,
-0.5894146562,
0.2156746089,
-0.1565152854,
0.1922611743,
-0.1045474112,
-0.110433735,
0.5233412385,
-0.221001476,
0.5570291877,
-0.2377655208,
0.073971957,
0.1046916693,
-0.0417100638,
0.2507313788,
-0.0052279197,
0.1300907731,
0.1995298266,
-0.004882033,
-0.4559844434,
-0.5347887278,
0.6234685779,
-0.5412032008,
0.1875808388,
-0.1423906088,
-0.6948011518,
-0.1541128457,
-0.0971387997,
0.3224464953,
0.8530631661,
-0.1004600823,
0.551028192,
0.6754587889,
0.0774276033,
0.5030303597,
0.2431279719,
-0.0124678351,
-0.3541435599,
0.9992208481,
-0.0055192243,
0.2215941548,
0.3417575657,
-0.06970869,
-0.2789427042,
-0.4219222069,
-0.4890830219,
-0.2838968337,
-0.6303999424,
-0.2934939563,
-0.5352293253,
-0.0934026167,
-0.2390628457,
-0.0831912756,
-0.7266204357,
-0.3961938322,
-0.0426039807,
0.2300750911,
0.2349522859,
0.5139403939,
-0.3503051102,
-0.0280350465,
-0.6937220097,
0.3535257876,
0.3870145082,
0.2281262726,
-0.2794552445,
-0.4152624309,
-0.3410302103,
0.0664028078,
-0.5054910779,
-0.3535971642,
0.148342222,
0.4008571804,
0.34081617,
0.349879235,
-0.1035547927,
0.6419054866,
-0.5409651995,
0.781070292,
0.1102579683,
-0.5890683532,
0.4712072015,
-0.233381927,
0.3639355302,
0.7612474561,
0.6075838804,
-0.6290967464,
-0.1421570927,
-0.580434978,
-0.6193259358,
0.4539941847,
0.305903554,
0.0424762778,
0.2040423602,
0.0663881004,
0.3215743005,
0.3572803438,
-0.3503539264,
-0.2812172174,
-0.2252768725,
-0.2190687656,
-0.2394068241,
0.0917905197,
-0.1928438544,
-0.1685617715,
0.4842698872,
-0.3397109509,
0.3136564493,
0.032297425,
-0.0547954328,
0.1175608486,
-0.1998493373,
0.2885997891,
0.5849554539,
-0.3064639866,
0.3063281178,
-0.185392648,
-0.8678972721,
0.3050658107,
0.2613172531,
0.0043530385,
0.1545914114,
0.4795947969,
0.7038828135,
0.2852808237,
-0.6548367739,
0.8889873028,
-0.3268897533,
-0.4803242683,
-0.1107010469,
0.2535509467,
-0.3585205078,
0.3124974668,
0.2447970808,
0.285174787,
0.5053101778,
-0.4250453115,
0.6638855338,
0.2635663748,
-0.3272004426,
-0.249876678,
0.5812038779,
0.1815325618,
0.3092151582,
0.7594832182,
0.0200105682,
-0.2175145298,
0.6037500501,
0.0751742721,
0.6332876682,
0.1298304796,
0.4134764373,
0.3642375767,
0.0939579308,
-0.2034725547,
0.1555811316,
-0.0484303683,
-0.722171247,
-0.3097950518,
-0.0473223999,
-0.7455507517,
0.126483649,
-0.680238843,
0.53763026,
-0.3741214871,
-0.1462645978,
0.1387714446,
-0.0295534059,
-0.7838251591,
0.2251190394,
0.3334398568,
1.0878180265,
-1.0122895241,
0.6930215955,
0.4864211082,
-0.2798106968,
-0.2807032466,
-0.2495387346,
0.1680826098,
-0.8291550279,
0.5261291862,
0.3632614613,
0.3420125246,
0.0441861153,
-0.9254980683,
-0.7230477333,
1.1988847256,
0.4063493311,
-0.3358940184,
0.167298764,
0.1029146016,
0.1418217272,
-0.2841906846,
0.5393766165,
0.4278032184,
0.419208169,
0.3269901574,
-0.5737924576,
-0.1460260302,
-0.3925371468,
0.0869764462,
0.1791522354,
-0.7899160981,
1.0175021887,
-0.175093472,
0.0358738787,
-0.1429665983,
0.2862980664,
0.2208708376,
0.3944325149,
0.6703509092,
0.8926054835,
0.4960324466,
-0.0025724762,
0.8557110429,
0.0440207534,
0.4102278352,
1.1079890728,
-0.3266331851,
0.7923613787,
0.5089044571,
-0.1852011234,
0.4153123796,
0.8727210164,
-0.528755784,
0.8580405116,
0.0314144343,
-0.2197797745,
-0.2826143801,
-0.2768645287,
-0.3826347291,
0.4156336784,
0.0076871389,
-0.35171929,
-0.4767662287,
0.3991619051,
-0.0860210285,
-0.2771728337,
0.0799556002,
0.4426435828,
-0.2065389305,
-0.2592923939,
0.4644846618,
-0.3382664025,
0.6280663013,
-0.6753799915,
-0.2869037688,
-0.4266122878,
0.2990355194,
-0.0870292857,
-1.0026260614,
-0.0612291247,
-0.0878056064,
-0.1552004367,
-0.3640214503,
0.5644903779,
-0.3194333315,
-0.2242032737,
0.1774197072,
0.1780652404,
0.3534105122,
-0.3125032187,
-0.8412041068,
0.375025928,
-0.116198495,
-0.3873493075,
0.3954895437,
0.4059093893,
0.3273791671,
0.7617684007,
0.7406049967,
-0.1191277429,
0.0807341263,
0.1108855903,
1.2080544233,
-0.4555169046,
-0.1374187469,
-0.624653995,
0.3067311943,
-0.1681295931,
-0.4757380784,
0.4130759835,
0.833853364,
0.8641359806,
0.046564512,
0.8341074586,
-0.105211325,
0.3101388514,
-0.5095690489,
0.1995044947,
-0.70776999,
-0.1719362736,
-0.2819848061,
-0.9899938703,
-0.1866210997,
0.2759749293,
0.3041928709,
0.1451930255,
0.8031177521,
0.8791692853,
-0.3227750063,
0.2449453175,
0.334289819,
-0.0576312579,
0.5685696006,
0.8105155826,
0.6344799995,
-0.7766737938,
0.6614292264,
-0.4776410758,
-0.3856025636,
-0.1997867823,
-0.9722711444,
-0.9001194835,
-0.722805202,
-0.2879447043,
0.0467489846,
-0.1417151242,
0.7736384273,
1.0797237158,
-0.4223315716,
-0.0568505377,
-0.1766716838,
-0.2670978308,
-0.3277620077,
-0.2001137882,
0.1898141652,
-0.418676734,
-0.8124041557,
0.3045515418,
0.2463606447,
0.0570253655,
-0.3831468225,
0.1153957248,
-0.2305091918,
-0.3772093952,
0.46085307,
0.0748991892,
0.1261591464,
-0.0072798813,
-0.0742433369,
-0.0556591898,
0.1702092886,
0.9251598716,
-0.848331809,
0.776622057,
0.3890616894,
0.8943464756,
0.6920823455,
-0.2360882461,
0.6300464272,
-0.76258111,
0.2571133375,
0.113243714,
0.2699100375,
0.3566769361,
0.0111787552,
0.8622033,
0.5810724497,
-0.7224829793,
-0.7811333537,
-0.0015450011,
-1.0535707474,
-0.1190294549,
1.0998301506,
-0.1123050302,
0.0217230637,
0.0248707496,
-0.2294787914,
-0.0643873662,
-0.4183397293,
0.6593515277,
0.7344423532,
-0.0591451451,
-0.2819080949,
-0.8809438944,
0.3963340223,
0.2152185738,
-0.9438911676,
0.0979866609,
0.4911826551,
0.0116749275,
0.0111451577,
0.5454902053,
-0.0693838745,
0.3108514845,
0.3062518239,
0.0872465596,
-0.0817862675,
-0.5634971261,
-0.0916860327,
0.1364722699,
-0.3379839957,
-0.6334767342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14106v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14106v2 | ChatLog: Carefully Evaluating the Evolution of ChatGPT Across Time | 2023-04-27T11:33:48 | 2024-06-18T00:33:25 | Shangqing Tu, Chunyang Li, Jifan Yu, Xiaozhi Wang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | ChatGPT has achieved great success and can be considered to have acquired an
infrastructural status. There are abundant works for evaluating ChatGPT on
benchmarks. However, existing benchmarks encounter two challenges: (1)
Disregard for periodical evaluation and (2) Lack of fine-grained features. In
this paper, we construct ChatLog, an ever-updating dataset with large-scale
records of diverse long-form ChatGPT responses for 21 NLP benchmarks from
March, 2023 to now. We conduct a comprehensive performance evaluation to find
that most capabilities of ChatGPT improve over time except for some abilities,
and there exists a step-wise evolving pattern of ChatGPT. We further analyze
the inherent characteristics of ChatGPT by extracting the knowledge and
linguistic features. We find some stable features that stay unchanged and apply
them on the detection of ChatGPT-generated texts to improve the robustness of
cross-version detection. We will continuously maintain our project at
\url{https://github.com/THU-KEG/ChatLog/}. | [
-0.2551707923,
-0.8203578591,
0.256169796,
0.4355495572,
-0.302198112,
0.3245642185,
-0.381023854,
-0.7887123227,
-0.0755036026,
0.3431408107,
-0.4824505746,
-0.3088038266,
-0.7068386674,
-0.0355992615,
-0.5122437477,
1.4594063759,
0.2272413671,
-0.3150860667,
0.1195898429,
-0.2128210515,
-0.6780814528,
-0.577916503,
-0.9225207567,
-0.4193339646,
0.0803105161,
0.0641603544,
0.4439804852,
0.5581868291,
0.50925982,
0.2031082958,
-0.450270623,
0.0827563107,
-0.5273913741,
0.2556967735,
0.0164542254,
-0.2422429025,
-0.5809976459,
-0.4242911637,
0.8650270104,
0.3368190825,
-0.3146237731,
0.3032223582,
0.3598579168,
0.5302750468,
-0.1769880801,
0.3301227987,
-0.8552296758,
0.0484819114,
-0.4442979097,
-0.2534900904,
-0.3670884967,
-0.2499648184,
0.4051081836,
-0.1337783933,
0.3914866745,
0.1748171449,
0.8573566079,
0.0555292293,
-0.1151017919,
-0.3694649339,
-0.7044199705,
0.6614730358,
-0.7216392756,
0.4155275226,
0.1125409156,
0.7180364728,
-0.527434051,
-1.0673834085,
-0.2111638188,
-0.4032422006,
0.0031180528,
0.020353755,
-0.1503263116,
-0.4593808651,
-0.0380083174,
0.5601119995,
-0.6914535761,
0.0818603188,
-0.148594752,
-0.1506092548,
0.5893434882,
0.223993063,
0.256041646,
-0.200165689,
-0.5106166601,
-0.0821684077,
-0.3388537169,
-0.0354119614,
0.1984182894,
0.2116876841,
-0.0547645465,
0.3347308338,
-0.351636529,
0.3050600588,
-0.0865055546,
-0.0136774303,
0.420163244,
-0.4430024922,
-0.0620083027,
0.0711392239,
1.0243599415,
0.2381464541,
0.2569387257,
-0.3036838174,
-0.0416034833,
-0.2074951828,
0.2313778698,
-0.5761167407,
-0.4406707585,
0.0302384682,
-0.6663738489,
-0.3776803613,
-0.4621454179,
-1.0950809717,
-0.5815942287,
0.2058170885,
0.1089200377,
-0.6579642296,
-0.3660980463,
0.231014058,
-0.2059518248,
0.2799866498,
0.3186065853,
-0.9098337293,
0.363150239,
1.0939363241,
0.9487718344,
-0.3595190644,
-0.253649056,
-0.4179441035,
-0.1522957236,
0.0574380569,
0.9870460629,
-0.6673609614,
-0.2064245939,
-0.1744315028,
0.0578006059,
-0.0449957475,
-0.5882591605,
0.7159531116,
-0.3067224324,
0.4838063121,
0.0650721788,
-0.6185367703,
0.0520726033,
0.5506391525,
-0.273211509,
1.2797363997,
-0.0106147295,
-0.9808015823,
0.5937348604,
-0.8024748564,
-0.1403255761,
0.2631611526,
0.058675658,
-0.7139322162,
-0.1313066036,
0.282527864,
0.1879535168,
-0.1786244214,
0.3425673246,
-0.3064272106,
-0.2202912569,
0.1781027168,
-0.7140914202,
0.8401210308,
0.0288623702,
-0.3058867157,
-0.2904262245,
-0.9269041419,
0.0856686234,
0.0617794096,
-0.4126361907,
0.0469467752,
0.3952015042,
0.0616423152,
-0.0824178979,
0.338045001,
-0.5862222314,
0.386985749,
-0.1112203375,
0.5448206663,
0.5031540394,
0.313995719,
-0.0605497733,
-0.3514065444,
0.4784974158,
-0.1807378232,
0.5091593862,
-0.2587793469,
-0.8154808283,
-0.715703249,
-0.0023954862,
0.3059846163,
0.746040225,
-0.2119197249,
0.5339491963,
-0.550881505,
-0.7663792968,
-0.0177731328,
0.1586722732,
0.2243782431,
0.060321033,
0.487136662,
-0.6587074399,
-0.3479124606,
-0.6723096371,
-0.6100017428,
-0.5336199999,
-0.2521669865,
0.1775247753,
0.2661932409,
-0.1781096905,
0.7901921272,
-0.2872806489,
-0.0492602102,
-0.1216287017,
0.2393496186,
0.2308739126,
0.5014783144,
0.5232290626,
-0.5504893064,
-0.3696930408,
0.4556136131,
-0.5859978199,
-0.2096078396,
-0.2430212945,
-0.0173136797,
-0.0428632349,
0.6640613675,
-0.6255809069,
0.1519544274,
0.6275781989,
-0.3834815621,
0.473913908,
0.1410629451,
-0.0637982488,
-0.8182126284,
0.0874637067,
-0.1133707091,
-0.3828254938,
-0.4254749715,
-0.2262613624,
-0.0518984236,
-0.1591590494,
-0.0704473481,
0.5165202618,
-0.2852480114,
0.0258885678,
0.1525674909,
0.2839859724,
-0.225744471,
0.3417614698,
-0.1501158774,
0.3241098225,
0.3679226935,
-0.3203691542,
0.5326951742,
0.1120036766,
-0.3308580816,
0.3861929476,
-0.6426875591,
0.2562245429,
0.0020578015,
0.2067401111,
-0.9689810872,
0.095187217,
0.560641706,
-0.578973949,
0.4874336123,
-0.5271056294,
-0.3576009274,
-0.2103456259,
-0.1636117101,
-0.0196371842,
0.5833955407,
-0.2190245092,
0.5251785517,
0.147365585,
-0.3792127669,
-0.5325306058,
-0.210382849,
0.4119777977,
-0.3849141598,
-0.5017665625,
-0.0201655775,
0.0255186521,
-0.0771138445,
-0.013504927,
-0.4195975065,
0.0849526823,
-0.1437525451,
0.0958703384,
-0.1427405924,
-0.3531405926,
0.2159854323,
-0.3269513547,
-0.1394483745,
-0.0412387587,
-0.4522893429,
0.7527442575,
-0.2197657824,
-0.2205740213,
-0.1096419543,
-0.0176611319,
0.5337971449,
-0.2336140573,
0.4918667674,
0.819663167,
0.0816531479,
-0.2714136541,
-0.6592743397,
0.1208913997,
-0.4643369615,
0.4629797339,
-0.115724206,
-0.8412758112,
0.6659452319,
-0.2251036614,
0.2913576961,
0.5051107407,
0.3873648345,
0.0670474172,
0.4773411751,
0.5284500122,
0.0624514557,
0.6575318575,
0.2289561629,
0.2744375467,
-0.764600575,
-0.3980116546,
-0.6628101468,
-0.0584083609,
-1.0136983395,
-0.175922066,
0.0456192233,
0.2477553636,
-0.0333550796,
0.5440241694,
-0.5061772466,
0.3395385444,
0.0666598901,
0.1016827226,
0.4665853083,
-0.2318823338,
0.2915900052,
0.0871210843,
-0.6203739643,
-0.4528594315,
1.0658724308,
0.4965752661,
0.5936389565,
0.0312654153,
0.5649836063,
0.5326893926,
0.1740391701,
-0.462665379,
0.5201209784,
-0.1020108983,
-0.5147547722,
-0.3590902686,
-0.5094870925,
-1.0907137394,
0.1715047061,
-0.1004608944,
-0.9678658843,
-0.1805133224,
0.1460915357,
0.1166239977,
0.1649621725,
-0.7558988929,
1.2663136721,
-0.2520238459,
-0.1038397774,
-0.0760338604,
-0.6671242118,
0.1563033015,
-0.2498267144,
-0.1383698881,
-0.361294359,
0.0343960561,
0.5202990174,
-0.2824801803,
0.7960499525,
0.0835030898,
-0.0168670826,
0.242765829,
-0.023947563,
0.5053065419,
0.3229588568,
0.1074987054,
0.1954253167,
0.1226564497,
-0.5713605881,
-0.5179761648,
0.5534345508,
-0.3827224076,
-0.3863852322,
-0.3825830519,
-0.1412338018,
-0.2270577252,
0.2130579203,
0.1737720072,
0.5519539118,
-0.4470227361,
0.3260289133,
0.4257150292,
-0.4005225897,
0.619556129,
0.2019052058,
-0.3808427155,
-0.07733877,
0.6448527575,
-0.1361748278,
0.3800593019,
0.2955206037,
0.3657269478,
-0.0907333866,
-0.8818998337,
-0.3677313328,
0.0286606736,
-0.5813491344,
-0.0537617244,
-0.7590043545,
-0.2573834956,
-0.0533909425,
0.3495970368,
-0.5262553692,
-0.4023513496,
0.2766378522,
0.4106439352,
0.5689160228,
0.6378606558,
0.2616788447,
0.308240056,
-1.0289984941,
0.1097288504,
0.3437525928,
0.5684214234,
0.0145123433,
-0.4250364602,
-0.1619444937,
-0.087906085,
-0.4392877221,
-0.4249999225,
0.1336020827,
0.3923504055,
0.5443859696,
0.1059702858,
-0.1203956082,
0.4656466544,
-0.5991508365,
1.1189186573,
-0.1140364632,
-0.8280768394,
0.4792398214,
-0.5265616775,
0.5823945999,
0.3939542472,
0.028128786,
-0.8795023561,
-0.6072356701,
-0.8300797343,
-0.7360489368,
0.4202911556,
0.4740901589,
0.2687973976,
0.1365836859,
0.1655259877,
0.2711175382,
0.1699192375,
-0.5569957495,
0.0756013244,
-0.2977868319,
0.1127750054,
0.1924209595,
-0.0433423817,
0.1857773513,
0.0015075812,
0.4564775527,
0.077444382,
0.1755272299,
-0.0922389925,
0.0601669103,
0.3501721621,
0.4603455663,
0.3522537053,
0.8741759062,
-0.4648481309,
-0.1929334998,
0.3979132175,
-0.7860251069,
-0.337287724,
0.2065634876,
0.064100489,
0.3240355253,
0.6601222157,
0.7032883167,
0.1831519306,
-0.5859143138,
0.4240908325,
-0.2294704616,
0.2312500328,
-0.4121680856,
0.1642946601,
0.0167074315,
0.5074014664,
0.3873611093,
0.2210063338,
0.1106370762,
-0.6612647176,
0.2527737916,
0.2817887962,
-0.3859138787,
-0.2269349694,
0.4839240611,
0.117621094,
-0.475092411,
0.5263130665,
-0.3421696424,
-0.7099041343,
0.412453711,
0.3783528805,
1.0427545309,
-0.1132239774,
0.063167192,
0.2538199723,
0.3888595402,
-0.2628789246,
-0.1705749631,
-0.2054249346,
-0.5511797071,
-0.5569748878,
-0.6055710316,
-0.4968007803,
0.2007464319,
-0.40411672,
0.4247594178,
-0.2468471825,
-0.2384007722,
0.3239155114,
-0.0700976923,
-0.5018951297,
-0.0365684889,
0.0459112823,
0.701367557,
-0.5975650549,
0.6840320826,
0.4001686573,
0.0821365938,
-0.1566238999,
0.142668277,
0.0981093422,
-0.8344528675,
0.4049599469,
0.0207255818,
0.1099220887,
-0.3311110139,
-0.4984536767,
-0.6210586429,
0.7925550342,
-0.0433287844,
-0.5760305524,
-0.0590159073,
0.0686266199,
0.8272188902,
-0.0193851963,
0.2072547525,
0.6265783906,
0.2823393643,
-0.1562374234,
-1.3805626631,
-0.1952290237,
-0.4231661558,
-0.0677533597,
0.6761241555,
-0.7556613088,
0.5788543224,
0.2952212989,
-0.351018548,
-0.094456628,
0.3383692801,
-0.0902069286,
0.3390517533,
0.3804900348,
0.6024915576,
0.5031661987,
-0.2134051919,
0.7758337259,
-0.0653251186,
0.6649159789,
1.2568776608,
-0.0810445696,
0.8141288161,
0.2802528739,
-0.3171095848,
0.41019696,
0.3566672504,
-0.4756731093,
0.3625977933,
0.2092770785,
-0.215330556,
-0.1230378672,
0.0866814107,
-0.575725615,
0.6529273987,
0.2776069343,
-0.2716848552,
-0.5287293196,
-0.2681739628,
0.2572392821,
-0.2953537405,
-0.0237629134,
0.8148798943,
-0.0139993606,
-0.5540501475,
0.5380061865,
-0.4743889868,
0.6601403952,
-0.8142672777,
-0.0782734007,
-0.233823806,
0.3095536828,
-0.0920456573,
-0.9903168082,
0.2825272381,
0.0262143724,
0.2564295232,
-0.2020146996,
0.7646345496,
-0.1878475398,
-0.1047701314,
0.2765634954,
0.3962835073,
0.2855677903,
0.0797629058,
-0.6048930883,
0.2601651549,
0.084162876,
-0.3253784776,
0.4464642406,
0.9207313657,
-0.1065827981,
0.7120965719,
0.5671142936,
0.0679920912,
0.273768872,
-0.0650300384,
0.7641452551,
-0.5578531623,
-0.3228628337,
-1.0375026464,
0.401820004,
-0.5365377665,
-0.8282263279,
0.7578161359,
0.5142496228,
0.793682158,
0.2025116831,
0.7160382271,
-0.2934263349,
0.4230625629,
-0.4050768912,
0.5673030019,
-0.1893450618,
0.3572336435,
-0.346619308,
-1.1923809052,
-0.1997458041,
0.1581820995,
0.0009838011,
-0.0782877803,
0.8177167177,
0.4154983759,
-0.1165852994,
0.4192080796,
-0.1003291756,
-0.0615552217,
0.6608772874,
0.4338088334,
0.8654986024,
-0.6171752214,
0.9702073932,
-0.0649364069,
-0.1887388229,
-0.2672174275,
-1.253318429,
-0.9258756042,
-0.5014560819,
-0.535032928,
-0.29821679,
0.1941415071,
0.529617548,
0.5565998554,
-0.7027311325,
-0.0426023789,
0.0039169281,
-0.1463258117,
-0.4386052787,
-0.2417455018,
0.3132398129,
-0.4791976511,
-0.4130365551,
0.1773723811,
0.4204773307,
-0.0206888616,
-0.0075521371,
0.2166022509,
-0.0860055834,
-0.2460385263,
0.6353623271,
0.5455546379,
-0.3009057939,
-0.5875157714,
-0.0602828525,
0.1556795537,
0.2728457749,
0.7265821099,
-0.412307173,
0.5292294621,
0.5236135721,
0.7832947969,
0.9306359291,
-0.0872989818,
0.489053309,
-0.6209383607,
-0.0050468221,
0.3198437989,
0.1288322955,
0.426392138,
-0.0587650947,
0.7900074124,
0.1261268258,
-0.9784213305,
-0.8701914549,
0.0496478006,
-1.144356966,
-0.0089655174,
0.9430814981,
-0.0799314305,
0.0227603205,
-0.5167341232,
-0.2511169016,
0.2671873868,
-0.480820626,
0.9601125121,
0.9833441377,
-0.3627879918,
-0.3815879822,
-0.8391241431,
0.6516509056,
0.1798680425,
-0.8861009479,
0.3698146045,
0.1900841743,
0.3817628324,
0.4186715782,
0.4505543113,
-0.3524016738,
0.0137335071,
0.3092555106,
-0.2139965892,
0.3286830783,
0.0040444075,
-0.1042700261,
0.1457057744,
0.2245641351,
-0.2487943619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14104v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14104v4 | Learning Human-Human Interactions in Images from Weak Textual Supervision | 2023-04-27T11:32:48 | 2023-09-18T17:50:31 | Morris Alper, Hadar Averbuch-Elor | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Interactions between humans are diverse and context-dependent, but previous
works have treated them as categorical, disregarding the heavy tail of possible
interactions. We propose a new paradigm of learning human-human interactions as
free text from a single still image, allowing for flexibility in modeling the
unlimited space of situations and relationships between people. To overcome the
absence of data labelled specifically for this task, we use knowledge
distillation applied to synthetic caption data produced by a large language
model without explicit supervision. We show that the pseudo-labels produced by
this procedure can be used to train a captioning model to effectively
understand human-human interactions in images, as measured by a variety of
metrics that measure textual and semantic faithfulness and factual groundedness
of our predictions. We further show that our approach outperforms SOTA image
captioning and situation recognition models on this task. We will release our
code and pseudo-labels along with Waldo and Wenda, a manually-curated test set
for still image human-human interaction understanding. | [
-0.4034645855,
-0.6235477924,
0.5739848614,
0.0813421607,
-0.4123772979,
-0.0290398318,
-0.1059494764,
-0.9324750304,
0.2528076172,
0.3903291523,
-0.69972682,
-0.460049659,
-0.457668364,
0.1882918626,
-0.1270023882,
1.0284926891,
-0.0258728713,
0.4000297785,
-0.5604601502,
-0.2221958488,
-0.3150930107,
-0.8182675242,
-0.4275688529,
-0.3376894295,
0.5334914923,
0.3541496396,
0.6343989968,
0.2943301797,
0.3826749325,
0.4009466767,
0.1014659554,
0.396094799,
-0.6467493176,
-0.1642724127,
-0.290551573,
-0.29273507,
-0.1472412497,
0.4514161944,
0.3001628518,
0.5532055497,
-0.005562379,
-0.1499998719,
-0.0840428248,
0.5864030719,
-0.2072869092,
0.4434217215,
-0.3988663554,
0.219962135,
-0.0874026269,
-0.0274083167,
-0.4153255224,
0.0160159282,
0.3738784194,
-0.9176651835,
0.2150555551,
0.2719093561,
1.0466917753,
0.4809655547,
-0.3562485576,
-0.243219018,
-0.5634498596,
0.7256357074,
-0.2520769238,
0.0637718663,
0.6991679072,
0.3350085318,
-0.1760750562,
-0.8430629373,
-0.8949335217,
-0.1537175328,
-0.5218244195,
0.1270714998,
-0.1453167051,
0.1852729172,
0.2316292524,
-0.0218995307,
-0.0474383719,
-0.1124361828,
-0.8374705911,
-0.1314873397,
0.786021173,
0.010589282,
0.5798382163,
-0.3249205649,
-0.6870480776,
-0.2517196536,
-0.4591611922,
-0.0196198784,
0.1100926623,
-0.0447622724,
-0.3960864544,
0.5276566744,
0.2230930477,
0.2982065678,
0.1025685295,
0.0551594943,
0.0504207686,
-0.1831223816,
-0.1998725235,
-0.1183946803,
0.8294470906,
0.6766733527,
0.3921860456,
-0.1228116304,
0.031852819,
0.1033910587,
0.352812469,
-0.7755724788,
-0.7040252686,
-0.2121375054,
-0.3732980788,
-0.3363462389,
0.208431378,
-0.8760486245,
-0.7311047912,
-0.6402007341,
0.398629427,
-0.2824528217,
-0.2894779444,
-0.0296437647,
-0.2549784482,
0.3199263215,
0.387766242,
-0.6161924601,
0.3327724934,
0.1413321048,
0.5771329999,
-0.0549329929,
-0.6551537514,
-0.5928781629,
0.0075945649,
-0.3131063879,
0.6591115594,
-0.0815416873,
-0.2281985879,
-0.3457419276,
0.1522684991,
0.0072286217,
-0.4422597289,
0.318662405,
-0.6119025946,
0.0520643853,
-0.1605832577,
-0.3094675839,
-0.1049584895,
0.2121411711,
-0.9780779481,
0.5701262951,
0.006821706,
-0.8895108104,
0.3364097178,
-0.6714986563,
-0.4275670052,
0.1561364233,
-0.2660278976,
-0.662325263,
-0.1295524389,
0.0340845101,
0.3933054507,
0.1095138192,
0.630633831,
-0.3138169646,
-0.3387845457,
0.4876811504,
-0.0882365555,
0.6272226572,
0.1229678839,
-0.0330289043,
0.289319247,
-0.6045170426,
-0.2501013577,
0.2098294199,
-0.1530261636,
-0.5446605086,
0.0561564341,
0.0592328869,
0.4070170522,
0.055762697,
-0.4108552337,
0.1741988063,
-0.0857308805,
0.4313913584,
0.4248536527,
0.1233383715,
0.659758687,
-0.2099635005,
0.2051285207,
0.2081644386,
0.1315533221,
-0.1521043628,
-0.4542808533,
-0.5848549604,
-0.5431386232,
0.064798139,
0.1942710429,
-1.2926573753,
0.2354091853,
-0.1525271386,
-0.2584788799,
-0.4126767814,
0.3452626169,
0.7207815647,
0.609814465,
0.4689529836,
-0.2264503539,
-0.9413537979,
-0.8283346891,
-0.1280276328,
-0.2670247853,
-0.20410721,
0.2420399338,
0.5656195283,
-0.3957787454,
1.1917659044,
-0.3963158727,
-0.4978192449,
-0.3227951825,
0.6937327981,
-0.2684327662,
0.550186038,
0.6544961333,
-1.1579190493,
-0.4106184542,
-0.2225986868,
-1.0692361593,
0.1963659078,
-0.1930672377,
-0.3118044734,
0.1367067844,
0.6961821318,
-0.5394868255,
0.5892726779,
0.375208497,
-0.0836370885,
0.4162139297,
-0.337900877,
0.111324802,
-0.8989444375,
-0.0085439011,
0.4740231633,
-0.2505480647,
-0.906862855,
-0.195738703,
0.1525049657,
-0.1347093284,
-0.8442212939,
0.5676451325,
-0.5927376747,
0.0938847288,
-0.132962361,
-0.1456746757,
0.0881907865,
0.7867860198,
0.7826402187,
0.5788010955,
0.4529267848,
-0.3247249126,
0.1639122814,
0.6921186447,
-0.3990405798,
0.735062778,
-0.5038725734,
0.3981191516,
-0.5033262968,
0.444652617,
-1.069491148,
-0.6517514586,
0.2807948589,
-0.2241780013,
0.2311097085,
-0.3753671348,
-0.6208028793,
-0.2647417486,
-0.3683312833,
0.4379505515,
0.4776406586,
-0.6010378599,
0.4807291925,
0.4137492776,
0.1522653997,
-0.2754923701,
-0.7554097176,
0.314270407,
-0.3290504515,
-0.3110642731,
-0.004299738,
0.2148898691,
-0.2588385642,
-0.1324062645,
0.0018907341,
-0.7158617973,
-0.0215082727,
0.5210567117,
0.7214873433,
0.3382663429,
0.242065236,
0.0606143661,
-0.0633131042,
-0.0476124249,
0.0553005598,
-0.0640453324,
-0.1431073695,
-0.162644133,
-0.9121436477,
0.1846784055,
0.5752610564,
0.0230406504,
0.937310636,
0.3874224722,
-0.4325021803,
0.2773212194,
-0.0227482803,
-0.3914058208,
-0.5017043352,
0.3042133451,
-0.2772193551,
-0.7172808051,
0.2438608706,
-0.3107232749,
-0.2349812537,
0.0017112244,
0.0485618412,
-0.7851231098,
0.5159308314,
0.8648183942,
-0.0061203893,
0.2991701961,
-0.167505458,
0.1418992877,
-0.4673210382,
-0.4240778983,
-0.0533215292,
-0.5802198052,
-0.4151437283,
-0.3402491808,
0.4472289979,
0.2937314808,
0.0641519502,
0.6046431661,
-0.2754683495,
0.5818828344,
0.2992919981,
0.4939011633,
0.282084316,
-0.0699418038,
0.2159808278,
-0.3803639412,
-0.4974513054,
-0.4758555293,
0.7250878811,
0.2267941684,
1.0353429317,
-0.1401264668,
0.6601433754,
0.3939806819,
0.7876490951,
-0.7062098384,
0.4886887968,
0.1031112298,
-0.6928811073,
-0.3154338598,
-0.5278807282,
-1.1822631359,
0.2335746735,
-0.5445894599,
-0.78252244,
0.140263021,
0.3811270297,
-0.2600718141,
0.2001705617,
-1.1392403841,
0.9829446673,
-0.2646612823,
-0.3301597536,
-0.0028287021,
-1.1761136055,
0.5507799387,
-0.1063992083,
0.4571402669,
0.1974585801,
0.2290489525,
0.678453505,
-0.2046034485,
1.4798732996,
-0.2898677886,
-0.0867621675,
0.4688967764,
0.0880282596,
0.2242241353,
-0.1815273613,
0.3873810768,
0.2457002252,
0.2577680349,
-0.4245091975,
-0.3447493613,
0.2864216268,
-0.8996145129,
-0.2395427376,
-0.2446154207,
-0.5042384863,
-0.0699528977,
0.1814281791,
0.1259500384,
0.2441335917,
-0.3261608779,
0.0846578926,
0.5057430267,
-0.244169727,
0.2836864591,
0.3049427271,
-0.1813086122,
-0.4029214382,
0.7745910883,
-0.1030477807,
0.1478897929,
0.2898963094,
0.0996328667,
-0.5231218934,
0.0062497184,
-0.3920835257,
0.2537115514,
-0.764008522,
-0.0397556275,
-0.4667288363,
0.0065469169,
0.1290576011,
-0.1461761296,
-0.1338920146,
-0.1033420041,
-0.5564271808,
-0.1598714292,
0.3504680991,
0.7629213333,
0.1096222475,
0.3946757913,
-1.0048297644,
0.7132543325,
0.5910893679,
0.2118278295,
0.0666676015,
-0.073510319,
-0.2174481899,
0.13424474,
-0.373303324,
-1.0040802956,
0.3220154047,
0.3938131034,
0.2946857214,
0.3742912412,
0.4708200693,
0.6259253621,
-0.3197416961,
0.5386912823,
0.512704134,
-0.9228392243,
0.300365448,
-0.1982446462,
-0.0177752059,
0.6050562263,
0.4475704134,
-0.4803702831,
-0.0006799208,
-0.5880596638,
-0.5196646452,
0.9968063831,
0.2154188007,
0.2770710886,
0.0921566337,
0.3965559602,
0.0482516401,
0.339138329,
-0.9943547249,
0.0186437387,
-0.3674502671,
-0.3320145607,
0.111359857,
-0.099944897,
-0.3748763204,
-0.5255737901,
0.1212383956,
-0.1643102169,
-0.0429518446,
0.2928278744,
-0.4702719748,
-0.2163015753,
0.0078633018,
0.389237076,
0.4871211648,
-0.0064861537,
0.6275401711,
0.2006187141,
-0.356469661,
0.312725544,
-0.0033559441,
0.2542675734,
-0.1672033817,
0.4056288898,
0.6865743995,
0.4107376039,
-0.8808550239,
0.6522232294,
-0.2257636487,
-0.5239187479,
-0.0292842686,
-0.1583421528,
0.2331790179,
0.2428302467,
0.3199642897,
0.2057290524,
-0.1047881544,
-0.6042495966,
0.4894106984,
0.1324366629,
-0.5068596601,
-0.5254099965,
0.5619410276,
0.3189815283,
-0.0400221869,
0.5892143846,
-0.4241229594,
-0.4994193912,
0.6330041885,
0.1881887466,
0.5075990558,
0.1568422019,
0.288603127,
0.4022371471,
0.1584789902,
-0.2255579829,
0.0263790824,
-0.4008883834,
-0.8198516965,
-0.4234911203,
-0.2394563854,
-0.6019715667,
0.1492537707,
-0.7371481061,
0.2861725688,
-0.3938339353,
0.0258113723,
0.1957773715,
-0.2446989715,
-0.6232699752,
0.1505772471,
0.1023619249,
0.3320857882,
-0.9884557128,
0.9940575361,
1.0839182138,
-0.5208599567,
-0.6560327411,
0.040134985,
-0.1598017663,
-0.3899774849,
0.6664398313,
0.4613570571,
-0.1015227214,
-0.0133127645,
-1.0366482735,
-0.1719760597,
0.930244565,
0.497369349,
-0.3980429173,
0.2480335981,
-0.0524777323,
0.7344369888,
0.0454254746,
-0.1305450499,
0.4729099274,
0.475851357,
0.2134774327,
-0.6284365058,
-0.0328599699,
-0.2961107492,
0.0170884114,
-0.0927398503,
-0.552015245,
0.4722011089,
-0.170650512,
-0.5854941607,
0.2330758125,
0.7033414245,
0.2046721727,
0.689165473,
0.6358970404,
0.2152909189,
0.5354616642,
-0.0430547111,
0.9077355862,
0.311642915,
0.4284664094,
1.2148140669,
-0.360026896,
0.5408998728,
0.6820986867,
-0.2538685799,
0.3388561606,
0.4999424815,
0.0917337239,
0.6454863548,
0.2063136995,
-0.142129764,
-0.3178672194,
0.0274785757,
0.1748109311,
0.3150884509,
0.1834777445,
-0.029161891,
-0.3258566558,
0.2209930718,
-0.1346540302,
0.3667521775,
0.0175528936,
1.0803341866,
0.218798846,
-0.6122530699,
0.6918594241,
-0.3301740885,
0.7742413878,
-0.3389422596,
-0.2942871153,
0.1178061217,
-0.1859207302,
-0.3496404886,
-0.855701983,
0.4167815447,
0.2385560274,
-0.3432971537,
-0.2625546455,
0.8070877194,
-0.7180965543,
-0.2831594646,
0.2776654065,
0.4029679,
0.4925018251,
0.0594435036,
-0.2976939678,
-0.1230129749,
-0.1640994698,
0.0222907215,
0.6343773603,
0.2837585807,
-0.2780495584,
0.3447212875,
0.5696116686,
-0.4796497226,
-0.071749188,
0.1143971905,
0.8944448233,
-0.3594985902,
-0.2810724676,
-0.7378078699,
0.5120161772,
-0.1727052331,
0.0494142808,
0.199014768,
0.1394590884,
0.5679063797,
-0.3544019461,
0.7367898822,
-0.1590352505,
-0.0779444575,
-0.3049744368,
0.7820990682,
-0.3795716763,
-0.1327500939,
-0.2986280918,
-0.5916702151,
-0.2931311727,
0.5723091364,
-0.3053023517,
-0.2412554175,
0.4885499775,
0.5297702551,
-0.3160185516,
0.0143325049,
0.4623678327,
-0.1254154742,
0.1488562077,
0.3757022619,
1.1908426285,
-0.1092600748,
0.6396058798,
-0.2276656479,
-0.3842039704,
0.1913274527,
-1.0136852264,
-1.1292726994,
-0.8293825984,
-0.2305933833,
0.0072941454,
-0.0631421283,
0.9346805215,
0.9781478643,
-0.5167011619,
0.0144906482,
-0.2372316867,
-0.0971939936,
-0.1989428103,
-0.1629721969,
0.2921922803,
-0.09209124,
-0.8436021209,
0.2039263844,
0.0232817773,
0.4818960428,
-0.14601399,
-0.4052049816,
-0.1468145251,
-0.0959453359,
0.4656794369,
0.3669762909,
-0.4626855254,
-0.0535186231,
-0.3560371101,
-0.1573842615,
0.1263808459,
0.676828146,
-0.5842984915,
0.58181566,
0.1050154939,
0.5965636373,
0.7686101794,
0.2840136588,
0.2271504849,
-1.2844135761,
0.5637480021,
-0.1215442494,
0.2240605205,
0.5393324494,
-0.4554711282,
0.3612808287,
0.298266381,
-0.1381449252,
-0.5086625218,
0.1360904276,
-0.9281184077,
-0.335845381,
0.8188591599,
-0.5416894555,
-0.2114724368,
-0.1283424348,
-0.7306808233,
0.3932450712,
-0.1920588911,
0.9873178005,
0.5202879906,
-0.0646695718,
-0.503002286,
-0.3223894238,
0.4816505313,
0.080808796,
-1.0495142937,
-0.1589725614,
0.764642179,
0.1358671486,
0.184774518,
0.576954484,
-0.0941366479,
0.2783623636,
-0.337970674,
0.4635038674,
-0.1050298586,
-0.3726332486,
-0.0048648166,
-0.1825732142,
-0.1450033635,
-0.4792432487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14072v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14072v1 | Origin Tracing and Detecting of LLMs | 2023-04-27T10:05:57 | 2023-04-27T10:05:57 | Linyang Li, Pengyu Wang, Ke Ren, Tianxiang Sun, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The extraordinary performance of large language models (LLMs) heightens the
importance of detecting whether the context is generated by an AI system. More
importantly, while more and more companies and institutions release their LLMs,
the origin can be hard to trace. Since LLMs are heading towards the time of
AGI, similar to the origin tracing in anthropology, it is of great importance
to trace the origin of LLMs. In this paper, we first raise the concern of the
origin tracing of LLMs and propose an effective method to trace and detect
AI-generated contexts. We introduce a novel algorithm that leverages the
contrastive features between LLMs and extracts model-wise features to trace the
text origins. Our proposed method works under both white-box and black-box
settings therefore can be widely generalized to detect various LLMs.(e.g. can
be generalized to detect GPT-3 models without the GPT-3 models). Also, our
proposed method requires only limited data compared with the supervised
learning methods and can be extended to trace new-coming model origins. We
construct extensive experiments to examine whether we can trace the origins of
given texts. We provide valuable observations based on the experimental
results, such as the difficulty level of AI origin tracing, and the AI origin
similarities, and call for ethical concerns of LLM providers. We are releasing
all codes and data as a toolkit and benchmark for future AI origin tracing and
detecting studies. \footnote{We are releasing all available resource at
\url{https://github.com/OpenLMLab/}.} | [
-0.2298756689,
-1.0293381214,
0.6021095514,
-0.0816582143,
-0.2074416727,
0.0125140212,
-0.1471446007,
-0.7941708565,
-0.1809148192,
0.6767890453,
-0.6325642467,
-0.526915431,
-0.6706863046,
0.0227361321,
-0.5351278186,
0.9267399311,
-0.0558645017,
-0.1197268516,
-0.2632390559,
-0.3579894602,
-0.0023284338,
-0.5902253389,
-0.7560381293,
-0.3867138326,
0.2624791265,
0.1141233221,
0.3363236189,
0.9809001088,
0.2883279622,
0.2983390987,
-0.3964631259,
0.3290324211,
-0.6765173674,
0.1844708622,
0.1460539401,
-0.6885183454,
-0.371386379,
0.0853945091,
0.6358018517,
0.1332209408,
0.0797563046,
0.2992365062,
0.1251872927,
0.4473978281,
-0.5702551603,
-0.1302172393,
-0.7261680365,
-0.0375995897,
-0.6139538884,
-0.6226378083,
-0.4837881029,
-0.0623715259,
0.1107783392,
-0.1581951231,
0.4444196224,
0.1054956019,
0.8395934701,
0.1002479792,
-0.481880337,
-0.5717935562,
-0.8936873674,
0.8022933602,
-0.6263588667,
0.1835495979,
0.0688600764,
0.2379927039,
-0.2909476161,
-0.6783398986,
-0.7726532221,
-0.3156102598,
-0.1906331331,
-0.1785865128,
-0.3038010597,
-0.4151677787,
0.1279245168,
0.3836753666,
-0.4627914727,
0.2938809395,
-0.1651961356,
-0.2667681575,
0.5876557231,
0.0645139888,
0.4918245077,
0.1376088411,
-0.4001392126,
0.1011625379,
-1.086363554,
-0.0438109487,
0.4683565795,
0.2272523344,
-0.5148023367,
0.5097050667,
-0.0471556075,
0.469914943,
-0.2749453783,
-0.2893103063,
0.0992073789,
-0.4873037338,
-0.0011539825,
-0.0672359094,
0.6844097376,
0.0755713955,
0.3622745275,
-0.1652217954,
-0.2775412202,
0.0487758592,
-0.0355468281,
-0.8388717771,
-0.0428810157,
-0.1534522623,
-0.4776138365,
-0.2440021038,
-0.1061745957,
-0.524967134,
-0.5654818416,
-0.211053893,
0.185097605,
-0.1958972663,
-0.1812192798,
-0.4557489157,
0.2738421559,
0.7736666203,
0.2089463025,
-0.715780437,
0.1609349847,
0.7874121666,
0.8970679641,
-0.3933210373,
-0.09509103,
-0.5339875221,
0.1623242944,
-0.3938706815,
0.679220736,
-0.4275313914,
-0.1948474944,
-0.0350375064,
-0.0886392742,
0.4407661259,
-0.4576964378,
0.4178157151,
-0.5181218386,
0.2570747137,
0.0504611805,
-0.6772753,
-0.1405749172,
0.3187088668,
-0.6226503253,
1.0530112982,
-0.0322838463,
-0.7233977318,
0.1253396571,
-0.7990195751,
-0.4751347303,
0.2487149686,
-0.5198725462,
-0.3561237454,
0.1048878282,
0.4268073142,
0.4283229113,
-0.3740486503,
0.2939631343,
-0.1679187864,
-0.4462583959,
0.2048823237,
-0.7118725181,
1.1876477003,
0.151245147,
-0.5880630612,
0.0411546677,
-0.9381619692,
-0.2929984331,
0.3687475622,
-0.0811402723,
-0.465734899,
0.332680583,
-0.2986910641,
-0.1517996043,
0.3186723292,
-0.3672053218,
0.0056735068,
-0.093709223,
0.4113165736,
0.8718181849,
-0.1317745447,
0.3758561015,
-0.0439387821,
0.5620750189,
-0.0004191084,
-0.0985612348,
-0.5240596533,
-0.5730244517,
-0.6886392236,
-0.2858075798,
-0.0046180589,
0.4895810783,
-0.5981772542,
0.4431595802,
-0.0730922222,
-0.3836762607,
-0.5549290776,
0.0778504834,
0.2978480458,
0.5241901875,
0.2773762047,
-0.0073795384,
-0.3993713558,
-0.8341543078,
-0.169521302,
-0.2943409383,
-0.1984272897,
0.608779192,
0.4805388451,
-0.4583234787,
1.089579463,
-0.394657135,
-0.0698922798,
-0.0398521759,
0.0538221784,
-0.0104456209,
0.4541483819,
0.6536881924,
-0.7777133584,
-0.2691018879,
0.0566569604,
-0.7513222694,
-0.4178883433,
0.1305646449,
-0.1605507582,
0.3832618892,
0.8790379167,
-0.3335890174,
0.2563628256,
0.7111985683,
-0.3831895292,
0.4500523508,
-0.0246511381,
-0.0926599801,
-1.1714177132,
0.4058572054,
-0.0599517599,
-0.1930660903,
-0.5499403477,
0.2092338502,
0.0317399651,
0.1815493554,
-0.385684222,
0.8856785893,
-0.6508080959,
-0.0353647768,
-0.3853121102,
0.1468936056,
-0.104581885,
0.2320997864,
-0.1211525276,
0.9929866195,
0.4286471605,
-0.6132087111,
0.2057179362,
0.0066376049,
-0.2988699079,
0.6342875361,
-0.276571542,
0.2749247551,
-0.2538704276,
0.2232461721,
-1.0173410177,
0.1655090451,
0.4582598209,
-0.5666784048,
0.2278739959,
-0.22989057,
-0.351998806,
0.0410193987,
-0.1192641929,
0.5182653666,
0.5794932246,
-0.6522752643,
0.7056434155,
0.3361897469,
-0.2256614268,
-0.7124573588,
-0.4727067351,
0.1256738454,
-0.405751586,
-0.5291159749,
0.2752973437,
-0.113864474,
-0.4332765341,
0.07559973,
-0.0725506172,
-0.0128795849,
0.5734907985,
0.1607347131,
0.2818776667,
-0.5641391873,
-0.083627142,
-0.0511715747,
-0.1186273918,
0.2428322881,
-0.1896299571,
0.5141244531,
0.0432358906,
-0.2113873363,
-0.2796815932,
0.2176258862,
0.5379601121,
-0.2936055362,
0.6782243848,
0.6978865862,
-0.3874262571,
-0.3672966361,
-0.6062526107,
-0.2163331807,
-0.4799718857,
0.3631234765,
-0.1168453768,
-1.0241806507,
0.6986327767,
-0.0300064832,
-0.0541153923,
0.6248397827,
0.5533006191,
0.2850030959,
1.0142774582,
1.0172719955,
-0.4296759665,
0.4038110673,
0.0083364593,
0.2292742282,
-0.8468501568,
-0.1776285321,
-0.7661795616,
-0.1615476459,
-0.7824456692,
-0.2574954033,
0.2367285937,
0.1600827277,
-0.0048854807,
-0.0065000406,
-0.291575402,
0.7121963501,
0.5214352012,
-0.1802410483,
0.4605599344,
0.000708769,
-0.1257482171,
0.304590255,
-0.265874058,
-0.6346407533,
1.2152018547,
0.3319975138,
0.537350595,
0.0889477953,
0.6468229294,
0.4534364045,
0.7866235971,
-0.503670454,
0.5764119625,
-0.0184482634,
-0.3605599999,
-0.1382010132,
-0.4244776964,
-0.9670622945,
0.1038500369,
-0.1441179365,
-0.9350933433,
-0.2143971175,
0.0473687127,
-0.124748297,
0.2744687498,
-0.3111084104,
0.6482375264,
-0.2837673128,
-0.4695477784,
0.0941404626,
-0.6355714202,
0.5104067922,
0.0207291804,
0.1727275848,
-0.2724201083,
-0.1106751487,
0.7293393016,
-0.1615198553,
0.7428961992,
-0.0557121858,
-0.670594275,
0.4613335431,
0.0622643605,
0.6116520166,
0.0663074479,
0.025668554,
0.3385345638,
-0.4715767801,
-0.3414290249,
-0.1963044405,
0.8199208975,
-0.7351338267,
-0.5725149512,
-0.264500618,
-0.5230335593,
0.1007399559,
0.3265264034,
0.3516937196,
0.2996260226,
-0.2543329895,
0.1311601698,
0.4893601239,
-0.1525712162,
0.5427717566,
0.8058229685,
-0.106912367,
-0.003365065,
0.8463721275,
-0.2047422081,
-0.1211607531,
0.2478758395,
0.2920047939,
-0.3878435791,
-1.0437591076,
-0.5698203444,
0.3061646819,
-0.6450543404,
-0.1354106516,
-0.2745796144,
-0.372600764,
-0.1787941605,
-0.177630797,
-0.2242772579,
0.2502913773,
-0.6128905416,
0.1322195381,
0.2917308509,
0.6551380157,
0.316232115,
0.4054835737,
-0.8079252839,
0.1725090593,
0.1070922092,
0.394162029,
0.0292977802,
-0.4304434657,
-0.0395873711,
0.0768395066,
-0.2702521384,
-0.6020851731,
0.3755267859,
-0.0108987717,
0.6793787479,
0.7130101323,
0.0753548071,
0.4961947799,
-0.5189893842,
0.9446541071,
-0.2409801781,
-0.966121614,
0.3486992419,
-0.2507657707,
0.156502679,
0.2304160148,
0.3325108588,
-0.389321208,
-0.5903549194,
-0.5051252842,
-0.931230247,
0.8033964038,
0.2652384937,
0.2410736829,
-0.0460037179,
0.612822175,
0.158904478,
0.1270313859,
-0.929879427,
-0.4408885539,
0.3819642961,
-0.1338591874,
-0.3389932811,
-0.3681363761,
-0.1530214995,
0.2771733105,
0.4711773992,
-0.2173353732,
0.1678998023,
0.1677099466,
-0.3784695566,
-0.120656386,
0.0810337216,
0.8413135409,
0.7446628213,
0.0391113609,
0.3156356812,
-0.1010288298,
-0.3096047342,
0.1292788386,
0.1750467271,
-0.5444683433,
-0.1496136189,
0.5935031176,
0.7041504979,
-0.390243113,
-0.800124526,
0.4965858757,
0.141584605,
0.1578949094,
-0.4672846198,
0.1445966214,
0.1786120683,
0.5250102282,
0.6032001972,
-0.3067209125,
0.2603590786,
-0.5822005868,
0.2747413814,
0.7175947428,
-0.2031786591,
-0.3937361538,
0.550127089,
0.3417581618,
-0.6606089473,
0.5166887045,
-0.1744632274,
-0.6013810635,
0.7856206298,
0.7366488576,
0.8885478973,
-0.3551329672,
-0.0419802479,
-0.0180117581,
0.2211616635,
0.0604327992,
-0.0477636158,
-0.1372210234,
-0.8359165788,
-0.4939655066,
-0.4410646558,
-0.3870654404,
0.4980838895,
-0.4957023263,
0.2780125737,
-0.1217121109,
0.2407801151,
-0.1494756341,
-0.0675058588,
-0.4974181056,
-0.1182923838,
0.7407472134,
0.6175166368,
-0.8315158486,
0.6791745424,
0.4524046779,
0.3205171525,
-0.3270151913,
0.1752708405,
0.2373491973,
-1.0943876505,
0.4867115617,
0.580524087,
-0.4298543036,
0.2144024819,
-0.9212765694,
-0.7941029668,
1.172726512,
0.1943967938,
-0.4538043737,
0.1129704118,
-0.0072331387,
0.5521671176,
-0.5390321612,
0.3290776312,
0.78665483,
0.2561130226,
-0.1515237838,
-0.4576984644,
0.2259587497,
-0.2956955433,
-0.1321631968,
0.2976948619,
-0.3625636697,
0.9792581201,
-0.1190465167,
-0.4712786376,
0.3242102265,
0.6039150357,
0.2345170528,
0.5979253054,
0.2671318948,
0.2383465916,
0.6943219304,
0.0104406457,
0.9540843964,
-0.4041971266,
0.2462370843,
0.8589179516,
-0.4387413263,
0.5979506969,
0.5297265053,
-0.0963212773,
0.4867246747,
0.3556005061,
-0.1814181805,
0.1489334106,
0.5400156975,
-0.2186058611,
0.2642967105,
-0.1871904284,
-0.2404881418,
0.5961744785,
0.3750376999,
-0.4518834949,
-0.3514777124,
-0.208948791,
0.178786695,
0.003160526,
-0.2749141753,
0.7950164676,
-0.1449920535,
-0.6872832179,
0.4889845252,
0.1909356117,
0.8487739563,
-0.6819785833,
-0.028265411,
-0.5467476845,
0.1229526997,
0.1294274628,
-0.4291391969,
0.0558510125,
0.1177141592,
0.0283888616,
0.0180928651,
0.6015409827,
-0.5183314085,
-0.2608135641,
0.5720857978,
0.7819944024,
0.1024181396,
0.0107332543,
-0.4599717855,
0.1306348294,
-0.0082636895,
-0.4405740201,
0.2483914047,
0.5244545341,
-0.3422732055,
0.6355661154,
0.7286531329,
0.0663961545,
-0.0644453391,
-0.3862609863,
0.5779224038,
-0.683886528,
-0.6189380884,
-1.5046240091,
0.188070789,
-0.0104904175,
-0.2489144653,
0.5649114251,
0.4360383749,
0.7911494374,
0.2310578227,
0.7673205733,
0.0777914003,
0.3048453033,
-0.6484755278,
0.7689454556,
-0.5896726847,
0.5303475857,
-0.1887916028,
-1.0830167532,
-0.3076119125,
0.309292078,
0.0176870748,
-0.093982935,
0.5938612223,
0.7305359244,
-0.0157521572,
-0.1247015372,
0.007951837,
0.2445854694,
0.6067823172,
0.2532867789,
0.8769324422,
-0.0835320428,
0.6651899219,
-0.0280837044,
-0.2758227289,
-0.4985295236,
-1.1910153627,
-0.6766517162,
-0.2715415657,
-0.2580235898,
-0.2698751092,
-0.0281719435,
0.4697758257,
0.4810931087,
-0.802504003,
-0.2961468101,
-0.2062505037,
0.2848647535,
-0.1392261982,
-0.2433421016,
0.5624732971,
-0.0704858601,
-0.8381347656,
0.4878219366,
0.1569716483,
0.5127152205,
-0.279420197,
-0.2698940933,
-0.1190148294,
0.1713233739,
0.5905280113,
0.2981184721,
-0.8283258677,
-0.4490505755,
-0.0666978881,
-0.1845651865,
0.1142815277,
0.9744671583,
-0.5694176555,
0.2549353838,
0.3447586894,
0.7729355693,
0.31293419,
-0.0360285453,
0.6637827754,
-0.7405350804,
0.2119730413,
0.2483187318,
0.3376709819,
0.4025847614,
-0.380960077,
0.6161875129,
0.3494028151,
-0.3994520009,
-1.0835310221,
0.2643684149,
-0.8157696724,
-0.2867198288,
1.1277163029,
-0.2496551871,
-0.1661061645,
-0.0070207599,
-0.1881045252,
0.3421245813,
-0.1703917533,
0.724021256,
0.5871764421,
-0.0581433736,
-0.2004010528,
-0.4381875098,
0.4992310703,
0.2797195911,
-0.7984648347,
0.0807535127,
0.4683633447,
0.225698635,
0.2825903594,
0.613309443,
-0.1515824646,
0.0143081248,
-0.0475722067,
0.129402563,
-0.1850234866,
-0.3371270895,
-0.4074048698,
0.2620498836,
0.0065910826,
-0.2377701551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13994v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13994v3 | SweCTRL-Mini: a data-transparent Transformer-based large language model for controllable text generation in Swedish | 2023-04-27T07:32:37 | 2023-06-22T13:02:23 | Dmytro Kalpakchi, Johan Boye | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present SweCTRL-Mini, a large Swedish language model that can be used for
inference and fine-tuning on a single consumer-grade GPU. The model is based on
the CTRL architecture by Keskar, McCann, Varshney, Xiong, and Socher (2019),
which means that users of the SweCTRL-Mini model can control the genre of the
generated text by inserting special tokens in the generation prompts.
SweCTRL-Mini is trained on a subset of the Swedish part of the mC4 corpus and a
set of Swedish novels. In this article, we provide (1) a detailed account of
the utilized training data and text pre-processing steps, to the extent that it
is possible to check whether a specific phrase/source was a part of the
training data, and (2) an evaluation of the model on both discriminative tasks,
using automatic evaluation methods, and generative tasks, using human referees.
We also compare the generative capabilities of the model with those of GPT-3.
SweCTRL-Mini is fully open and available for download. | [
-0.3985567987,
-0.8450094461,
0.3539675772,
-0.08971861,
-0.510640204,
-0.0035550413,
-0.3094089031,
-0.3814889491,
-0.1393290758,
0.6122815609,
-0.7448669672,
-0.4939620793,
-0.2924460471,
0.1923281699,
-0.3942113519,
1.2190845013,
0.1442684382,
0.2271459103,
-0.2693823576,
0.072310403,
-0.2423170209,
-0.5121458173,
-0.5090274811,
-0.1664225608,
0.6587913632,
0.3848944604,
0.7821452022,
0.6360689402,
0.3676437736,
0.2868665755,
-0.1957650632,
-0.2883502245,
-0.5259383917,
0.231307447,
-0.4584849179,
-0.4534666836,
-0.2378900796,
-0.2596154213,
0.4260054827,
0.305410713,
0.0325122923,
0.3196585774,
0.3598376811,
0.3810992539,
-0.2693216503,
-0.0464605503,
-0.7865290642,
-0.1425486803,
-0.3458080888,
0.2945033908,
-0.571788609,
-0.5183717012,
0.0459182747,
-0.1211532205,
0.9011351466,
0.2278488129,
0.7060027719,
0.1296063811,
-0.4012387991,
-0.5700260401,
-0.8919336796,
0.8430687189,
-0.4984515607,
0.2133763134,
0.0775008872,
0.543487072,
0.2496076077,
-0.7524673939,
-0.6681938767,
-0.2208125591,
-0.1635486931,
-0.0701654404,
-0.2337914854,
0.4240410924,
0.2839173973,
0.3026674688,
-0.6149200797,
0.1724005193,
-0.4391411245,
-0.1887876391,
0.4607351422,
0.2716871202,
0.2572270334,
-0.4595010281,
-0.2890766859,
-0.0204052217,
-0.97180444,
-0.3140375614,
0.4879148006,
0.4497258663,
-0.1928002834,
0.7712086439,
0.3397724032,
0.5379391909,
0.0614805035,
-0.020008469,
-0.0423692726,
-0.5618653297,
-0.2473534048,
-0.0973605514,
0.8422052264,
-0.0592776649,
0.0586994328,
0.228629142,
-0.5505953431,
0.2400417179,
0.3119458258,
-0.7409437895,
-0.4441294074,
0.1531132758,
-0.5023639202,
-0.4269675314,
-0.3856986463,
-0.7015160322,
-0.4471160769,
-0.3495075405,
0.305732578,
-0.3917568028,
-0.2388281673,
-0.2696858644,
-0.1502572447,
0.0567013472,
0.18766886,
-0.9141564965,
0.153179571,
0.4488388896,
0.6140583158,
-0.4408509135,
-0.0949657857,
0.0149269514,
-0.0182060972,
-0.2151632607,
0.7232744694,
-0.3510954678,
-0.5253629684,
0.1801604033,
-0.2413796037,
-0.133556053,
-0.472592622,
0.5707948804,
-0.3687425852,
0.2822178304,
-0.0947546512,
-0.3501687944,
0.3203243315,
0.0201116782,
-0.9045857787,
0.973474741,
0.2234388888,
-1.212056756,
0.4774697125,
-0.643306613,
-0.5848523378,
0.2971734107,
-0.4099430442,
-0.3552269936,
0.2986337841,
0.1613331586,
0.3719038367,
-0.4049340785,
0.245064795,
-0.0789909735,
-0.2499966174,
0.1300967187,
-0.5813694596,
0.6597225666,
0.2787911296,
-0.3729253411,
0.3948886693,
-0.6529273987,
-0.1568376869,
-0.0520158336,
-0.3539125025,
-0.4052452147,
-0.2589633763,
0.4772261679,
0.4379698634,
0.3372053504,
-0.6758158803,
0.1252024323,
-0.2162840664,
0.475445509,
0.703317821,
-0.0111898314,
0.5300400853,
-0.0899405554,
0.919247508,
-0.0778905302,
0.4199892282,
-0.1335139871,
-0.2237431407,
-0.8163975477,
-0.5868819952,
0.7225486636,
0.259367466,
-1.468231678,
0.2875798941,
-0.2678666711,
-0.4359909594,
-0.7875779271,
-0.110207215,
0.5267996788,
0.2443039417,
0.1121312678,
0.5243194699,
-0.7700476646,
-1.0050874949,
-0.0897917375,
0.0023939295,
-0.2025291473,
0.3425941467,
0.6470575333,
-0.170919463,
0.9806336761,
-0.3003108501,
-0.2191421688,
-0.9542224407,
0.2853128016,
0.1402712911,
0.4694655538,
0.5602912307,
-0.856870234,
-0.6053965688,
0.0109981392,
-0.4502507746,
-0.1295707822,
-0.1244898513,
0.0590175353,
0.4186396003,
0.5095371604,
-0.6502318382,
0.2309450358,
0.8447952271,
-0.3797942102,
0.9289830923,
-0.3495691419,
-0.1025991216,
-0.8980029821,
0.2305650413,
-0.3283490241,
-0.2084809542,
-0.5219213367,
0.1885838211,
0.1678788066,
-0.0648964792,
-0.7036685944,
0.7068329453,
-0.4743411243,
-0.0352988243,
-0.2737596631,
-0.0180810895,
-0.1287233233,
0.4679762721,
0.0878845826,
0.934466064,
0.2342566699,
-0.4912246466,
-0.0245341584,
0.1118225828,
-0.6407840252,
0.5909016728,
-0.7024123669,
0.2011802346,
-0.2479867041,
-0.0702652559,
-1.0789977312,
-0.1847148538,
-0.202684626,
-0.2681744099,
0.1533417106,
-0.3928441703,
-0.7161756158,
-0.7319194674,
0.0208367724,
0.1788170636,
0.725900948,
-0.6095266938,
0.8655745983,
0.2913880646,
-0.5918856263,
-0.3018272519,
-0.777647078,
-0.2483250499,
-0.0347452424,
-0.4222691655,
0.137410149,
-0.1382347792,
-0.1211333349,
-0.1195172891,
0.1011099815,
-0.0886448994,
-0.3169675767,
0.2511196434,
0.5035305619,
-0.1101955026,
-0.033696454,
0.7564849257,
0.0885727108,
-0.2143945098,
0.008797165,
0.7667250633,
-0.0112043815,
-0.1439327449,
-0.0772656873,
0.3581550717,
0.6288871765,
0.0788841248,
0.5080453753,
0.3984198868,
0.0038408157,
-0.4430990219,
-0.3264373243,
-0.1265394986,
-0.5468316674,
0.2241979539,
-0.6652501822,
-1.0547858477,
0.4172998667,
0.1215560585,
0.1996374428,
0.6045621634,
0.581253767,
-0.3180367053,
1.3610829115,
0.9657292962,
0.2898582816,
0.4528441727,
-0.2698120773,
-0.1060916111,
-0.5482046604,
-0.1416804343,
-0.7980023623,
-0.2738738954,
-0.4236526787,
-0.3626562953,
0.230308637,
0.0603096262,
-0.4056433141,
0.4265905917,
-0.5017022491,
0.5589161515,
0.4073100388,
-0.2160468251,
0.3764183521,
-0.04208377,
-0.7139068246,
-0.330058068,
-0.9914938807,
-0.4734634757,
0.7421067357,
0.3084332049,
0.9670562744,
-0.1058281958,
0.5855462551,
0.5482559204,
0.5038093328,
-0.5971111059,
0.6031031013,
-0.3782740235,
-0.8724505305,
-0.1624370217,
-0.3547253907,
-0.8384583592,
0.5565711856,
-0.2517812252,
-0.2388151884,
0.0680040419,
0.3735338449,
-0.1780890971,
0.1354177445,
-0.7508014441,
0.862513423,
-0.1784456074,
-0.0738377944,
-0.0950440466,
-0.4102745652,
0.2956797183,
-0.1276207417,
0.3713315427,
0.1231995001,
0.033259958,
0.6536633968,
-0.2632283866,
1.0294376612,
-0.3999931812,
-0.1486804038,
0.3283289373,
0.3604776561,
0.6453406215,
-0.2785355449,
-0.0386709794,
0.1447870135,
0.010911731,
-0.2366088927,
-0.4171103239,
0.6336898804,
-0.5378438234,
-0.2209966332,
-0.2026221454,
-0.2648890018,
0.0207907204,
0.6266631484,
0.7731682062,
0.2780632973,
-0.6029919982,
0.0983157456,
0.6769590974,
-0.16952236,
0.4633879364,
0.3972138166,
-0.5689277053,
-0.5666039586,
0.6817872524,
-0.0751188248,
0.2580347359,
0.297703445,
0.2468412519,
-0.5351079106,
-0.8104590178,
-0.7386274934,
0.2940856814,
-0.5869785547,
-0.2365079075,
-0.7346459031,
-0.1444431841,
-0.2605618834,
-0.3442860246,
-0.4525792003,
-0.2885379493,
-0.2752026618,
-0.2898794115,
-0.0098613324,
1.0003530979,
0.2344625145,
0.5775150657,
-0.5619720817,
0.2476304919,
0.0014236502,
0.1023376361,
-0.1694939435,
-0.3786476552,
-0.2667694688,
0.1439402699,
0.0893056765,
-0.3177663386,
0.4024577439,
-0.032644812,
0.3521113396,
0.3636498749,
0.1621460617,
0.138636291,
-0.7308400869,
1.0861437321,
0.3287122548,
-0.8755971789,
0.4446240067,
-0.5710525513,
0.6236211061,
0.6219041348,
0.1807557642,
-0.3126931489,
-0.5801753998,
-0.7627723217,
-0.7004623413,
0.4602999985,
0.1458493769,
0.2856952548,
-0.0613106713,
-0.053972654,
0.5447651148,
0.4383053184,
-0.581536293,
0.017294202,
-0.1162934378,
-0.4701491594,
-0.1060723513,
-0.4967157841,
-0.0141558247,
-0.2987087965,
0.3303877711,
-0.211802274,
0.3175804615,
-0.1895417571,
-0.3366138637,
0.212379083,
0.3334038854,
0.6307281852,
0.4074164629,
0.1084641218,
0.1872521788,
-0.0686440393,
-0.8532981277,
-0.0420011058,
-0.1793421358,
-0.5749854445,
0.3397827148,
0.2826628685,
0.8536006212,
0.290355593,
-0.6258810163,
0.6930353642,
-0.1012148708,
-0.397349596,
-0.1881572008,
-0.0252363775,
-0.0370759852,
0.0933547691,
0.2281257212,
0.2076673657,
-0.0666861907,
-0.1362840235,
0.1931870431,
0.2442728728,
-0.4773013592,
-0.3935337663,
0.7595963478,
0.3744223118,
-0.0632348731,
0.533973515,
0.1080573574,
-0.4952784777,
0.3705926538,
0.7015414238,
0.8450101018,
-0.0908323824,
0.4018542767,
0.2546624243,
0.3986510634,
-0.0169207994,
0.5292049646,
-0.1275349408,
-0.6084637642,
-0.4884802103,
-0.8219953775,
-0.2700932622,
0.0323951542,
-0.6326321363,
0.2434896529,
-0.4609227479,
-0.2508583069,
0.037849471,
-0.2544997334,
-0.8989648223,
0.0291776992,
-0.0507958345,
1.1294455528,
-0.9795553088,
1.2576942444,
0.4217787087,
-0.2608821392,
-0.4346827269,
-0.1714562774,
-0.1947436482,
-0.472193867,
0.5575964451,
-0.2318682522,
-0.2931894064,
0.0126724597,
-0.7589729428,
-0.6588707566,
0.8362389803,
0.3419874609,
-0.7048923969,
-0.2333886176,
0.1382495016,
0.9109518528,
-0.4041461647,
0.052959729,
0.7203638554,
0.2797889411,
0.2887153625,
-0.7943758965,
-0.1107696742,
-0.1426873356,
0.3336986899,
0.1551335752,
-0.2288645208,
0.9030387402,
-0.1900921911,
-0.4036718011,
0.2832259536,
0.7144366503,
0.2538518012,
-0.159257248,
0.3994334638,
0.0598453432,
0.7455174327,
-0.0386728607,
1.2457331419,
-0.0020731378,
0.2736949325,
1.3261560202,
-0.2300824523,
0.861651063,
0.4102604985,
-0.0591201894,
0.5340589285,
0.3523018062,
-0.0288953166,
0.7819008827,
0.1151011288,
-0.2415478826,
0.0356602445,
0.1109540164,
-0.0815981552,
0.177309379,
0.4569970965,
-0.5755465627,
-0.0896740183,
0.651440084,
0.0241963435,
-0.0467794612,
-0.4686604738,
0.7524966002,
-0.0551757887,
-0.5734618902,
0.5286087394,
-0.0110804467,
0.9899121523,
-0.58021909,
0.1525120735,
-0.3409787118,
0.371063441,
0.1066997796,
-0.7229694724,
0.2290537357,
0.2417954504,
-0.3117712438,
-0.3669056594,
0.9925724864,
-0.6260399222,
-0.5456448197,
-0.0923976228,
0.3465361297,
0.095017992,
0.0170224719,
-0.7542097569,
0.3009287417,
0.2878086567,
-0.0905998647,
0.281558156,
0.2682632208,
-0.0889943317,
0.4953586459,
0.47126773,
0.1922401637,
0.1756473631,
0.188767314,
0.6802612543,
-0.5994459391,
-0.731600523,
-0.6374390721,
0.5089293122,
-0.1477121711,
-0.3260048032,
0.8680849671,
0.7492565513,
0.7556807995,
-0.5143565536,
1.254645586,
-0.2692010999,
0.7593470216,
-0.4350416958,
1.0757178068,
-0.1175153553,
-0.0405198559,
-0.1365011781,
-0.8877221346,
-0.0947232172,
0.3291285038,
-0.2447630614,
-0.015097701,
0.7312883139,
0.5961291194,
-0.0931944624,
0.1575655788,
0.4373125434,
0.3753957748,
0.2070091963,
0.0521798059,
0.7293872237,
-0.0637677088,
0.7357852459,
-0.1766881347,
-0.0574047044,
-0.1398877949,
-0.7187044024,
-1.1125199795,
-0.5716494322,
-0.0736899674,
-0.3584927619,
-0.016092144,
0.6977866888,
0.3938552737,
-0.7651383877,
-0.0591784418,
-0.0363324061,
0.0978578553,
-0.3257520497,
-0.195578143,
0.4623105526,
-0.0710416138,
-0.755143404,
0.2527240515,
-0.0790411234,
0.3020941019,
-0.5474375486,
0.1004929617,
0.3001378179,
0.2382634133,
0.7743016481,
0.0656234249,
-0.4914903045,
-0.1775324196,
-0.0808674544,
-0.5308520794,
-0.1086169556,
1.2971863747,
-0.5741033554,
0.2934582829,
0.6408527493,
0.1930263937,
0.819889009,
-0.145183742,
0.6571992636,
-0.8941072822,
0.1266016513,
0.4256520569,
0.1359830648,
0.2808037996,
-0.2708204985,
0.1964712888,
0.0146972425,
-0.3750241101,
-0.7347533703,
0.2986224592,
-0.7153524756,
-0.5101420283,
1.3401831388,
0.0882717296,
-0.3928706646,
-0.4147608876,
-0.5529904962,
-0.0973600671,
-0.2651047707,
0.2961213589,
0.4635826647,
-0.0493144691,
-0.2811662853,
-0.4418853223,
0.7879755497,
-0.0859039202,
-0.5364203453,
0.4313970208,
0.7019295096,
0.4287899733,
-0.1291860044,
0.7168934941,
-0.2725881934,
0.0696033761,
0.3998833299,
0.4883087873,
-0.0603267513,
-0.6084709764,
-0.4388073981,
0.2621111572,
-0.1011193395,
0.0038826026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13989v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13989v1 | Cross-Domain Evaluation of POS Taggers: From Wall Street Journal to Fandom Wiki | 2023-04-27T07:24:29 | 2023-04-27T07:24:29 | Kia Kirstein Hansen, Rob van der Goot | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Wall Street Journal section of the Penn Treebank has been the de-facto
standard for evaluating POS taggers for a long time, and accuracies over 97\%
have been reported. However, less is known about out-of-domain tagger
performance, especially with fine-grained label sets. Using data from Elder
Scrolls Fandom, a wiki about the \textit{Elder Scrolls} video game universe, we
create a modest dataset for qualitatively evaluating the cross-domain
performance of two POS taggers: the Stanford tagger (Toutanova et al. 2003) and
Bilty (Plank et al. 2016), both trained on WSJ. Our analyses show that
performance on tokens seen during training is almost as good as in-domain
performance, but accuracy on unknown tokens decreases from 90.37% to 78.37%
(Stanford) and 87.84\% to 80.41\% (Bilty) across domains. Both taggers struggle
with proper nouns and inconsistent capitalization. | [
-0.5502722859,
-0.7455233335,
0.0984342545,
0.0967169181,
-0.1198057532,
0.2252877951,
-0.3716489673,
-0.9289376736,
0.2460026145,
0.0123266848,
-0.4451049566,
-0.6084415913,
-0.6221426725,
0.1909219027,
-0.0398436934,
1.3422029018,
-0.0616414249,
-0.099303171,
-0.3310464025,
-0.1053983644,
-0.3442341387,
-0.7585681081,
-0.5225449204,
-0.0602779575,
0.3990278244,
0.0215463117,
0.648265183,
0.4764593244,
1.0053952932,
0.2156986892,
0.057437215,
0.2702527642,
-0.6514020562,
-0.0017484542,
-0.6884165406,
-0.0110213021,
-0.7706716061,
0.1552114785,
0.4018357694,
0.5593650341,
0.0304052345,
0.2962768376,
-0.0430880077,
0.5349188447,
-0.6244357228,
0.0077870218,
-0.6239672899,
0.2533949912,
-0.501916647,
-0.2116459757,
-0.4101375937,
-0.0794379637,
0.4623095095,
-1.1330347061,
0.6162861586,
0.4593821466,
1.3567961454,
-0.009805534,
0.1126307547,
-0.2737723291,
-0.9351094365,
0.7582804561,
-0.3619787991,
0.5624551773,
0.6753956079,
0.1518689543,
-0.1624337584,
-0.7645699978,
-0.3985844851,
-0.0541808493,
0.0563745461,
0.1186589152,
-0.8727464676,
-0.0904991552,
0.4628872871,
0.2673351467,
-0.6110469699,
0.0190220531,
-0.2572679222,
-0.0932776853,
0.7724582553,
0.0352059193,
0.156069532,
0.0886054412,
-0.7186264396,
-0.0894873813,
-0.6112447977,
0.1665958166,
0.4933844507,
0.1915303171,
0.3695033193,
0.5778263807,
-0.0627536327,
0.5332271457,
0.5051127076,
-0.5123357177,
0.3559233844,
-0.4539253414,
-0.3788079917,
-0.0887653977,
0.623737812,
0.6523252726,
0.3280347288,
-0.57207793,
-0.2368834764,
0.1297063828,
0.3972353935,
-0.7166844606,
-0.4236890376,
-0.0545223989,
-0.7927059531,
0.3369818926,
0.268155396,
-0.4776070118,
-0.4772483408,
-0.1164624989,
0.4232816696,
-0.4413886666,
-0.3102177382,
0.0771111101,
-0.5641095638,
-0.0002489271,
0.2002739757,
-0.7244960666,
0.2200122774,
0.9281631112,
0.7153747082,
-0.622864306,
-0.504912734,
-0.3871435523,
0.2629531324,
-0.2594732046,
0.9025332332,
-0.5738462806,
-0.5680909753,
-0.0307282861,
-0.0044336822,
-0.1769923419,
-0.7217980027,
0.5364106297,
-0.666092217,
-0.077932179,
-0.3821312487,
-0.650539875,
0.0625823885,
0.3637286425,
-0.5506934524,
0.8440175653,
0.0121411793,
-0.8947582841,
0.7643218637,
-0.4424260855,
-0.5346660614,
0.2160504758,
0.1097946987,
-0.184479177,
0.0942462832,
-0.1151885018,
0.3160202205,
-0.2748984098,
0.1766920388,
-0.4315996468,
-0.5720689893,
0.30465886,
-0.447034657,
0.6187827587,
0.0852947161,
-0.2131936699,
-0.2652005553,
-0.3732313216,
-0.1252516657,
-0.1086855382,
-0.2152196467,
-0.7179991603,
0.0330586992,
-0.2128915638,
0.023062164,
0.2589615583,
-0.8045448065,
0.3056480885,
-0.1163753495,
-0.0551934913,
0.2949308753,
0.0851716921,
0.355976522,
-0.4343031943,
0.5566810966,
-0.3576362133,
0.4594166875,
0.0967536643,
-0.7761529088,
-0.3793623447,
-0.5120534897,
0.4135836959,
0.4546719193,
-0.5984047055,
0.651188314,
-0.3030099869,
-0.8218365908,
-0.2263862789,
-0.2202648669,
0.6360801458,
0.474958092,
0.4117515385,
-0.7263771892,
-0.3495329022,
-0.6703055501,
-0.6608430743,
-0.4946241379,
-0.1544464231,
0.416228801,
0.4232628942,
-0.1437799186,
1.1536128521,
-0.3345745206,
-0.6565136909,
0.2399915755,
0.4001168609,
-0.0125708757,
0.3424060047,
0.5081094503,
-0.6423909068,
-0.5356448889,
0.1544966251,
-0.359841764,
-0.2138521224,
0.238335669,
-0.0528237112,
0.2756316364,
0.3601810634,
-0.5462955236,
0.8271989226,
0.5368795395,
-0.4848530591,
0.7089694738,
-0.1162588522,
0.3089951575,
-0.5472326875,
0.3102981746,
0.1507912576,
0.0495846272,
-0.4683899581,
-0.2178473473,
-0.2311674505,
0.1033004671,
-0.5178276896,
0.5110611916,
-0.5952479839,
-0.2850424647,
-0.012818411,
0.3373568952,
0.3139675856,
0.4936844409,
0.1183968186,
0.8715834618,
0.5015288591,
-0.548550427,
0.3492106497,
0.2031493634,
-0.4798109531,
0.9770979285,
-0.6568803191,
0.0146916844,
0.1539869159,
0.3209922612,
-1.0505918264,
0.0648995042,
0.5471064448,
-0.5829413533,
0.2549459338,
-0.4194922149,
-0.536965251,
-0.3167670071,
-0.3662796319,
0.2418904752,
0.3435541391,
-0.5887460113,
0.5426877141,
0.7932150364,
0.0993437916,
-0.7562751174,
-0.6929659843,
-0.0355903916,
-0.190155834,
-0.4828903675,
0.7252511382,
-0.0987794474,
-0.3105497658,
0.2962932885,
-0.3151012063,
-0.2196933031,
-0.0204639714,
0.3788570166,
0.1649065316,
-0.3414265215,
0.0348096676,
-0.2991050482,
0.0053269588,
0.1616373211,
-0.2134125978,
0.2662781477,
-0.1811186075,
-0.6020489931,
-0.4225013256,
0.1613485217,
0.0070825084,
-0.3194925189,
0.4187413454,
0.3989785016,
-0.3543754816,
-0.2950356305,
-0.2864141464,
0.1622029394,
-0.4618722796,
0.2746983469,
-0.5694431067,
-0.5868625641,
0.5083019137,
-0.0636548921,
0.1304831803,
0.7005150318,
0.1976282001,
-0.2400698066,
1.021723628,
0.6097739339,
0.2142560333,
0.5048915148,
-0.2084346116,
0.3874662817,
-0.6421278119,
-0.4728596509,
-0.6135978103,
-0.3636551201,
-0.5319532752,
-0.5539495349,
0.052562546,
0.468706727,
0.0288088229,
0.5930195451,
-0.5165193081,
0.7231541872,
0.3947244585,
-0.3377867639,
0.408058852,
0.4220989048,
0.1438389122,
-0.0848989561,
-0.6538164616,
-0.413603574,
0.8764233589,
0.5177500844,
0.8524497151,
0.1261710078,
0.3258427382,
0.6356998086,
0.6131568551,
-0.7542973161,
0.2690915465,
-0.6298196912,
-0.8285686374,
-0.3362828195,
-0.1955845058,
-1.0323069096,
-0.0285008382,
-0.04085337,
-0.870870173,
0.4875416756,
-0.0090679387,
-0.4282177687,
0.5347403288,
-0.6917996407,
0.7935391068,
-0.099052608,
-0.1928980649,
0.144062832,
-0.4764069319,
0.1212512106,
-0.2054164559,
0.0399721265,
-0.419942081,
-0.1618534625,
1.2767022848,
-0.2328383625,
0.7605625987,
-0.3436821401,
-0.1995519996,
0.4769654274,
0.0657981485,
0.1232553124,
0.0596099719,
0.1716906875,
0.8008422256,
0.2150178999,
-0.225123629,
-0.3433397412,
0.6407295465,
-0.7552119493,
-0.3916209042,
-0.6810005903,
-0.215057373,
-0.582667768,
0.1978112906,
0.4742661417,
0.298394382,
-0.6868031621,
0.2198872566,
0.8111926913,
0.0607754625,
0.3621565104,
0.6072216034,
-0.2317753136,
-0.3953608572,
0.934612155,
0.188806951,
-0.0884552673,
0.2781379819,
0.0795732588,
-0.3480428755,
-0.3922744393,
-0.6394232512,
0.2755934894,
-0.5402088761,
-0.5216528773,
-0.4690971673,
-0.158525005,
-0.385400176,
-0.0438761748,
-0.2783499956,
-0.2829938233,
-0.1650903374,
0.1861859709,
0.3093581796,
0.999248147,
0.0071330476,
0.3869076967,
-0.7724480033,
0.1497105658,
0.0463400222,
0.6534359455,
-0.1534160674,
-0.771951139,
-0.2876995206,
0.0492033139,
-0.0115092797,
-0.6525249481,
-0.0329129994,
0.2297735363,
0.5855418444,
0.6330561042,
-0.0621865951,
0.9806296229,
-0.4653036594,
0.970266521,
0.3385179639,
-0.9464734793,
0.1239912212,
-0.1946804523,
-0.042162165,
0.7196701765,
0.7078096271,
-0.7592794895,
-0.0878668353,
-0.6837168932,
-0.7428902984,
0.9736037254,
-0.0939218849,
0.1009842455,
0.0217728186,
0.0645388737,
0.5264160037,
0.1420593262,
-0.0831492841,
-0.4171108603,
-0.0482448749,
0.2710873783,
-0.0414361842,
-0.1041120067,
-0.1517017037,
-0.164177224,
0.7100009918,
0.0483930409,
0.3162499368,
0.2080580294,
0.0489521399,
-0.3579277694,
-0.2946937084,
0.2939850092,
1.1094572544,
-0.2514829934,
0.0339095294,
-0.0912801176,
-0.7783315182,
-0.3345499039,
0.1721905768,
-0.1278995425,
0.3846637011,
0.5281814337,
0.7360284328,
-0.1446497589,
-0.6858405471,
1.0037039518,
-0.3050810099,
-0.3157991767,
-0.0964640006,
-0.0923509896,
-0.2086953223,
0.0922834054,
0.5136802197,
0.4386849999,
0.1335463375,
-0.4004868865,
0.3490876257,
0.3740451038,
-0.2975295782,
-0.4992534518,
0.4694051445,
0.2923822105,
-0.4102007747,
0.1182783991,
-0.4327038825,
-0.5276612043,
0.4682221413,
0.6650742292,
0.9074570537,
0.0193788484,
0.2766807079,
0.200868085,
0.2423869967,
0.1333418787,
0.1573937982,
-0.2010317743,
-0.5911252499,
-0.3695650697,
-0.5672742724,
-0.6527651548,
0.0073924689,
-0.5876137614,
0.0984579027,
-0.5494527817,
-0.5398344994,
0.1845337152,
0.3220304549,
-0.7747721672,
0.2743342817,
0.1361721158,
1.1256991625,
-0.8059862256,
0.8002208471,
0.8718962669,
-0.3501649797,
-0.5575592518,
0.2516837716,
-0.393014431,
-0.605529964,
0.7127101421,
-0.1580052823,
-0.3618216515,
-0.2529162467,
-0.2743930817,
-0.9956654906,
0.7541119456,
-0.2145794183,
-0.7251135707,
0.0349813178,
0.1742164344,
0.8120179176,
-0.3245915473,
0.0740841776,
0.4877150655,
0.4357656538,
-0.1096294671,
-1.1519293785,
-0.4336310923,
-0.2947790623,
-0.1210436448,
0.1012706161,
-0.6642968655,
0.7872404456,
0.1810130924,
-0.488358438,
-0.1055202112,
0.6546615958,
0.2057892531,
0.7829290032,
0.6200323105,
0.547375083,
0.8896837234,
-0.1948121041,
0.8128462434,
-0.3641321361,
0.3651897013,
0.9716970921,
-0.5039356351,
0.9753654003,
0.4085614681,
-0.3618087769,
0.371522516,
0.607935667,
-0.2754897773,
0.4549838603,
0.1997186542,
0.087372601,
0.0295145623,
-0.5343732834,
-0.4785529971,
0.4049496651,
0.3772237599,
-0.1943128705,
-0.0834634379,
-0.0141195767,
0.3000122309,
-0.0539432466,
-0.234078005,
0.6261460185,
-0.2902124524,
-0.8172769547,
0.4577021003,
0.290905267,
0.9672458768,
-0.6738091707,
0.1181342825,
-0.3391270936,
0.2522104383,
-0.1671554595,
-0.9857705832,
0.3329149783,
0.4191741943,
-0.2036643624,
-0.3851619661,
1.0656831264,
-0.3656545281,
0.0365880765,
0.3555927575,
0.5940572619,
0.454438597,
0.049269598,
-0.6827561855,
0.2413990349,
-0.3373658955,
-0.2195054293,
0.1710666716,
0.6860976815,
-0.2611769736,
0.0809773952,
0.7274782658,
0.2159723639,
0.0833339244,
-0.0617929809,
0.8238422871,
-0.2676616013,
-0.3647289276,
-0.5006688833,
-0.0741772503,
-0.257206291,
-0.9918039441,
1.2934374809,
0.861692965,
1.4714651108,
-0.1127458662,
0.6689318419,
-0.3865267336,
0.4993304908,
-0.034678299,
0.7303949594,
-0.4914444983,
-0.054399956,
-0.2618173361,
-1.0815041065,
-0.2956048548,
0.377920866,
-0.4349769056,
0.0054457174,
0.6939361095,
0.5079782605,
-0.0840133652,
0.0496791489,
0.2967792749,
-0.1967167556,
0.0984294638,
0.3449104428,
1.1410726309,
-0.2947902679,
0.5260030627,
-0.5115711689,
-0.2819540203,
-0.2942456007,
-0.9166808128,
-1.0807291269,
-0.4507811666,
-0.3353720307,
-0.3906684518,
0.2457886487,
0.507789135,
0.7832545042,
-0.9206772447,
-0.1451694816,
0.4891486168,
-0.1695027947,
-0.3021020889,
-0.1868166029,
0.4560024142,
0.0465215109,
-0.7723116875,
0.2765529752,
0.2260087132,
-0.2816744149,
-0.2364035249,
-0.1898444146,
0.002512577,
0.2443767786,
0.5077841282,
0.3749906123,
-0.6154395342,
-0.2961875498,
0.2419211864,
-0.434577018,
-0.0159412082,
1.0112506151,
-0.6235860586,
0.2922080755,
0.8057267666,
0.7049913406,
0.1708574891,
0.4722876847,
-0.0030176977,
-0.7649211884,
-0.3065330684,
0.3366608322,
0.1164250448,
0.29975757,
-0.1375602037,
0.4543915987,
0.7221942544,
-0.5734885335,
-0.7054273486,
-0.1616093367,
-0.7180895805,
-0.4924423099,
1.2467772961,
-0.4851361811,
-0.478464365,
-0.3014683425,
-0.2006141841,
0.2665995061,
-0.4069884419,
0.5539781451,
0.7691938281,
-0.3418056965,
0.8296734095,
-0.1423569322,
0.7818431258,
0.3639273345,
-0.6726952195,
0.2697403431,
0.5315941572,
0.2552164793,
0.5635688901,
0.6961992979,
0.0249440484,
0.2952446938,
0.2394423634,
0.1035583243,
-0.1509698778,
-0.7593192458,
-0.1241377667,
0.1221573427,
-0.1081186533,
-0.4092683494
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.