id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.04836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.04836v1 | Understanding the Impact of Culture in Assessing Helpfulness of Online Reviews | 2023-04-27T07:20:55 | 2023-04-27T07:20:55 | Khaled Alanezi, Nuha Albadi, Omar Hammad, Maram Kurdi, Shivakant Mishra | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CY | Online reviews have become essential for users to make informed decisions in
everyday tasks ranging from planning summer vacations to purchasing groceries
and making financial investments. A key problem in using online reviews is the
overabundance of online that overwhelms the users. As a result, recommendation
systems for providing helpfulness of reviews are being developed. This paper
argues that cultural background is an important feature that impacts the nature
of a review written by the user, and must be considered as a feature in
assessing the helpfulness of online reviews. The paper provides an in-depth
study of differences in online reviews written by users from different cultural
backgrounds and how incorporating culture as a feature can lead to better
review helpfulness recommendations. In particular, we analyze online reviews
originating from two distinct cultural spheres, namely Arabic and Western
cultures, for two different products, hotels and books. Our analysis
demonstrates that the nature of reviews written by users differs based on their
cultural backgrounds and that this difference varies based on the specific
product being reviewed. Finally, we have developed six different review
helpfulness recommendation models that demonstrate that taking culture into
account leads to better recommendations. | [
-0.6539642215,
-0.1552937031,
0.2319744527,
0.5085458755,
-0.507422626,
0.077279076,
-0.237157464,
-1.1988478899,
0.4992181957,
0.2183078974,
-0.3833622932,
-0.1052609012,
-0.3940091729,
0.3417884409,
0.3071312606,
1.4941267967,
-0.1108053774,
0.5224878788,
-0.2001103014,
-0.4727573097,
-0.7078565359,
-0.5346798897,
-0.0690945834,
-0.296461165,
0.266820848,
0.2147358507,
0.604247272,
-0.245259434,
0.6433308721,
0.2089686692,
-0.1195460856,
0.4056825936,
-0.5896493793,
0.0401987582,
-0.2748840153,
-0.3324428499,
-0.1233345792,
-0.0063104532,
-0.116568163,
0.3615073562,
-0.058832638,
0.4357809722,
0.1557631642,
0.7223351598,
-0.8261030316,
0.001411041,
0.0535814129,
0.2008533627,
0.2169741988,
-0.0201096181,
0.266697526,
-0.8929972649,
0.566339314,
-0.6648772955,
0.0598755479,
-0.2468561977,
0.5271741748,
-0.1638020724,
-0.6728546619,
-0.8222033381,
-1.2556387186,
0.5650065541,
-0.2265916467,
0.4983438551,
0.6727769971,
0.220528543,
0.0754212886,
-0.1622413993,
-0.5474404097,
-0.3228851557,
-0.3035060465,
0.1569351107,
0.0643735155,
-0.4228422046,
0.2523731291,
0.5010436773,
-0.0540006831,
-0.5470796824,
-0.5463393927,
-0.1151382402,
0.5212267637,
-0.1809862256,
0.4948012829,
-0.0783963278,
-0.1742248386,
-0.1309093535,
-0.4211852551,
0.6295182705,
0.4128005505,
-0.1134311855,
-0.0138136391,
0.0345840305,
-0.5386484265,
0.1570586711,
-0.0407053344,
-0.4872417748,
0.1163672879,
-0.5931073427,
0.2154958546,
0.0633897111,
0.1352543086,
1.1584330797,
0.7211105824,
0.2092193365,
-0.0478232466,
-0.0865098685,
0.1376013756,
-0.904964447,
-0.0226019621,
0.0919827893,
-0.9145872593,
0.0508081056,
0.6992961168,
-0.4076990783,
-0.6479510665,
0.0901181996,
0.1151906699,
0.1128055677,
-0.3117471933,
-0.4936268926,
-0.3794790506,
0.0340322629,
0.4824041724,
-0.684638381,
0.2281817496,
0.3691683412,
0.6847037673,
0.015062361,
-0.0150534268,
-0.160685733,
-0.1660296321,
-0.179658547,
0.8412729502,
-0.4582713544,
-0.7731158733,
0.3063062429,
0.0169200506,
0.5888623595,
-0.3595075905,
0.6896002293,
-0.7291026115,
0.1158575118,
-0.8600051403,
-0.2330974936,
-0.7571284771,
0.2942711711,
-0.6072101593,
0.615111053,
0.2150750607,
-0.5952864885,
0.8085590005,
-0.4758011699,
-0.695397675,
0.1882167906,
0.2031573057,
-0.1686803848,
0.4396224916,
0.468619287,
0.1275021285,
-0.1423323154,
-0.3232434094,
-0.4793415666,
-0.6358298063,
0.6657673717,
0.1364230812,
0.9794929624,
0.606893003,
-0.3559590876,
-0.1301588714,
-0.5160537362,
0.0668525994,
-0.0171673167,
-0.3986776173,
-0.6358895302,
0.2772628665,
0.3634176552,
0.1707615256,
0.1560422182,
-0.4379983544,
0.1296346933,
-0.2500860989,
0.3417620063,
0.3237344325,
0.3205493987,
0.1191735864,
-0.4545284212,
0.7266898155,
-0.2066702843,
0.4556038082,
-0.2182067931,
-0.5302987099,
-0.4106841683,
0.1281460673,
0.2832156718,
0.5047181845,
-0.3429062963,
0.0311450195,
0.162919566,
-0.6794580221,
-0.3549151421,
0.3245351613,
0.3514459729,
-0.0775922686,
0.1463383138,
-0.8835708499,
-0.2538707554,
-0.5043992996,
-0.3517533839,
-0.3204011023,
-0.1420658976,
0.3036293983,
0.2341979295,
-0.1958011091,
0.8973670602,
-0.6105752587,
-0.6588018537,
-0.3122622669,
-0.5646877885,
-0.0494209789,
0.0719730407,
0.6960352063,
-0.6695099473,
-0.6393271685,
0.0932520926,
-0.3923754692,
-0.2383220345,
0.0246688537,
-0.003847199,
0.2833975852,
-0.1284777522,
-0.0899064913,
0.3764726818,
0.3238525987,
-0.3061897457,
0.1521023959,
-0.4156063199,
0.6290012598,
-0.8424949646,
-0.252138406,
0.2938169539,
0.1269220859,
-0.5256204605,
0.2991823852,
0.1491807848,
-0.011587929,
-0.184516713,
0.2824703753,
-0.2651674151,
-0.0530663207,
-0.3225538731,
-0.4052999616,
0.3750416338,
0.1258228123,
0.1355579346,
0.294421196,
0.0661430433,
-0.5533677936,
0.1370671093,
0.199834004,
-0.7225521803,
0.9751894474,
-0.3990979493,
0.1030909196,
0.037421342,
0.7633774877,
-0.8484734297,
0.073031418,
0.2742534578,
-0.260813266,
-0.3237193525,
-0.1287084967,
-0.3158444464,
-0.084160313,
-0.4945558012,
0.3622884154,
0.4410061836,
-0.215588361,
0.4401139319,
0.5015429258,
-0.200373888,
-0.300961107,
-0.3632105291,
-0.2503285408,
-0.2148835063,
-0.5779960155,
0.2042738795,
-0.2150086612,
-0.8114228249,
-0.2403426021,
-0.0704374164,
-0.0383720882,
0.3153272271,
0.3211963177,
0.1091636941,
-0.1102497131,
0.1175580695,
-0.2635258734,
0.1107883826,
0.2026925236,
-0.0987774655,
0.2744722962,
-0.392658174,
-0.1505066901,
-0.3503829837,
0.6145379543,
0.4390711188,
-0.4361548722,
0.7940279841,
0.8546512723,
-0.2535515726,
-0.0662885085,
-0.7929840684,
-0.4560578465,
-0.4015699625,
0.288494736,
-0.1830153465,
-0.3366068304,
0.6320220828,
0.4552182555,
-0.0610302798,
0.4769794643,
0.4978238642,
-0.4256275892,
0.81046772,
1.000056982,
0.2067263275,
0.5127791762,
-0.0255655665,
0.5212885737,
-0.4131968915,
-0.3680402935,
-0.4180138111,
-0.5601853728,
-1.01866436,
-0.0564007089,
0.2492814064,
0.1268139631,
0.2017759085,
-0.1130653098,
-0.4170246124,
0.6757108569,
0.4973608851,
0.0009918981,
0.532787025,
0.239018023,
-0.2389005572,
-0.0530465432,
-0.3116306365,
-0.3480494022,
0.6466538906,
0.2756382227,
0.6874984503,
0.3098542392,
0.0510106981,
0.5540248156,
0.4757978022,
-0.781614244,
0.090472728,
-0.0430519953,
-0.5362665057,
0.1749058366,
0.1285736412,
-0.46333763,
0.0154083641,
-0.3983064294,
-0.298959285,
0.1670962423,
0.046197176,
-0.6674212217,
0.1637527347,
-0.8388330936,
0.4208405316,
-0.497723639,
-0.3674355149,
-0.4461141825,
-0.539342761,
0.0458055325,
-0.0192678627,
0.6072378755,
-0.1027171165,
0.4834836721,
0.7279202342,
-0.4336151779,
0.7228045464,
-0.2566018701,
-0.113305524,
0.3487861753,
0.4020443857,
-0.0514225625,
0.1562486589,
0.1923326254,
0.6297876239,
0.3007653356,
-0.0967618227,
-0.2517797351,
0.9001954794,
-1.1587812901,
-0.811657548,
-0.5936792493,
-0.29857409,
-0.2329902202,
-0.0431978963,
-0.0279356483,
0.450158149,
-0.034825664,
0.2057603598,
0.170185104,
-0.2354257107,
0.346845448,
0.5284263492,
-0.3756648004,
-0.5961427689,
0.9191364646,
0.3899007738,
0.010123237,
0.0229378045,
0.408241719,
-0.3981615007,
-0.3475861549,
-0.6320564747,
0.0589380264,
-1.2229137421,
0.2481876165,
-0.4601005018,
0.2088606358,
-0.4035057724,
-0.2687179148,
0.1245605275,
-0.3309654295,
0.1271164864,
-0.0170661788,
0.5321003795,
1.3599104881,
0.1189963594,
0.1807583123,
-0.8582803011,
-0.0374558009,
0.4613725245,
0.5508462191,
0.3146759272,
-0.224383384,
-0.6448355317,
-0.3118860126,
-0.5943431258,
-1.0652871132,
0.0732629821,
0.1546936333,
0.4359181523,
0.9687934518,
0.1727143824,
0.5628349781,
0.0493614785,
0.9150587916,
-0.163514331,
-0.6898983717,
0.4018346965,
-0.2394722402,
0.4377248883,
0.6931299567,
0.7422844172,
-0.895496428,
-0.0569150411,
-0.1666269153,
-0.8121157289,
0.4469132721,
0.0864013359,
0.3220805526,
0.2920337617,
-0.0773235112,
0.4201966524,
0.2724223733,
-0.9674528241,
-0.1814917475,
-0.5712532997,
0.7196976542,
0.0779516622,
-0.3951515853,
-0.1903455853,
-0.110694468,
0.4905742109,
0.3048178554,
-0.0784220919,
0.3702180386,
-0.309905529,
-0.4327441752,
0.3621856868,
0.847704947,
1.0985764265,
-0.3304090202,
-0.3913300931,
0.4362170398,
-0.4517441392,
-0.1357631981,
-0.2873517573,
-0.189447552,
-0.2661756873,
0.2933909595,
0.3881489336,
-0.1223884001,
-0.2215894759,
0.056105379,
-0.3476444185,
0.4134631157,
-0.5181456208,
-0.0521000586,
0.0277979299,
-0.0218390096,
0.670427978,
0.1694582403,
0.2473833859,
-0.9420651197,
-0.1933544576,
0.5095564723,
-0.5586933494,
-0.1923926324,
0.0946460143,
0.808450222,
-0.5691432953,
0.6207054257,
-0.1700246632,
-0.8201310635,
0.6059119701,
0.408626467,
0.9247864485,
-0.1414116323,
0.158327803,
0.3878197968,
0.167819649,
0.2824953198,
0.0506551415,
-0.3932253122,
-0.7544430494,
-0.2009238452,
-0.8448579311,
-0.5264633298,
-0.1748698503,
-0.5656479001,
0.3200247884,
-0.5993178487,
-0.2670176923,
-0.313519299,
0.194411695,
-0.6623439789,
0.5894595385,
0.2504656613,
0.3058605194,
-0.6733670235,
0.3631280065,
0.7469815016,
-0.5567574501,
-0.5583327413,
0.5271142125,
0.1635689288,
-0.4344927371,
0.6436548233,
0.6261806488,
-0.6631497145,
-0.7365611792,
0.3661826551,
-0.5927395821,
0.5101872087,
-0.2325293571,
-0.3093746305,
0.5555502176,
-0.322445482,
0.8026430607,
-0.4934096038,
1.041181922,
0.238777414,
0.2722503841,
-0.0177718718,
-1.0113130808,
-0.0299965832,
-0.5248487592,
0.0591001473,
-0.1326822788,
-0.6311667562,
0.4974401593,
-0.4007308483,
-0.1063552499,
-0.2346090376,
0.3226419985,
0.2110480964,
0.3176546395,
0.638610661,
-0.0144732483,
0.3922155499,
-0.0389507264,
1.3220285177,
-0.4978946745,
0.0936429277,
0.6718654037,
-0.332023263,
0.98870188,
0.3176077902,
-0.2570271492,
1.0240211487,
0.9020196795,
-0.1695229709,
0.4173795283,
0.2639508843,
-0.0598864295,
0.0423629507,
-0.5968101025,
-0.7905738354,
0.4774135649,
0.1797801405,
-0.3906405866,
-0.0465276241,
-0.0804759711,
0.0492554344,
-0.0540700778,
-0.5686336756,
0.774261117,
0.0860305354,
-1.0940464735,
0.2541240156,
0.3881332278,
0.6776564717,
-0.636189878,
-0.1598915309,
-0.3615123034,
0.1966091692,
-0.7410628796,
-0.6872784495,
0.1954650581,
0.1691946238,
-0.3838089406,
-0.3324775994,
0.6648293734,
0.0945703536,
-0.7013001442,
0.4502224028,
0.5685971975,
-0.0678692162,
0.0494398288,
-0.1352996826,
0.0254960414,
0.0437450483,
-0.1261022687,
0.2520917356,
-0.1535447538,
-0.5824181437,
0.2768963277,
0.8265159726,
0.1705819219,
-0.4372970462,
0.150753513,
0.211281687,
-0.6200513244,
-1.1636039019,
-0.9352118373,
0.3000895977,
-0.0221927557,
-0.6939725876,
0.8276039958,
0.2063050419,
1.2536467314,
-0.366858691,
0.7504442334,
-0.1143997386,
0.1203352138,
-0.191115126,
1.2323856354,
-0.4350008368,
0.4179652929,
-0.2444467396,
-1.2728228569,
-0.0367610902,
0.8864754438,
-0.5304095149,
0.5518164039,
0.8319302201,
0.4411275089,
0.1093962789,
0.4297827482,
0.053450007,
-0.0499772653,
0.1151141748,
-0.1389853954,
1.032081008,
0.0629453287,
0.7025666237,
-0.6342222095,
-0.0266391691,
-0.4982924759,
-0.9373102784,
-0.7847152352,
-0.343486011,
-0.3793940842,
-0.4816398323,
-0.2684214413,
1.3809002638,
0.6010819674,
-1.3088283539,
-0.4342470765,
0.7774897218,
0.0421056375,
-0.4121624827,
-0.2107236832,
0.1802580506,
0.1892820448,
-0.5595026612,
-0.0364007391,
0.1965203732,
-0.0698855594,
-0.6053398252,
-0.0008335014,
0.3192929626,
0.1052663028,
0.4365617037,
0.0538726784,
-0.91922158,
-0.0985497534,
-0.1014794409,
0.066674754,
0.1161526442,
1.1036736965,
-0.5243640542,
0.9091210365,
0.6185500622,
0.2471073121,
0.2988461256,
-0.2322724015,
0.776730597,
-0.1374361217,
-0.1932962239,
-0.0631637126,
0.4170748591,
0.5452782512,
-0.5781975985,
0.2696815431,
0.1733747125,
-0.4983593524,
-0.3393913507,
0.1752879024,
-0.6699613929,
-0.1412870586,
1.0845674276,
-0.4083682001,
0.2093403488,
-0.3844417334,
-0.4809215963,
0.0310137644,
-0.4461639524,
1.5328794718,
1.2088974714,
-0.0527165309,
0.4459573627,
-0.4518330991,
0.6626603007,
0.3233374357,
-0.5151888728,
-0.5344637036,
0.364923507,
0.5384110212,
0.3591605127,
0.2937936485,
0.3279873729,
0.6361516118,
-0.5289558172,
-0.1551268846,
-0.0320352279,
-0.153602168,
-0.4999699891,
0.676302731,
0.2324209511,
0.1406864226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.07468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.07468v1 | BactInt: A domain driven transfer learning approach and a corpus for extracting inter-bacterial interactions from biomedical text | 2023-04-27T06:14:25 | 2023-04-27T06:14:25 | Krishanu Das Baksi, Vatsala Pokhrel, Kuntal Kumar Bhusan, Sharmila Mande | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | The community of different types of microbes present in a biological niche
plays a very important role in functioning of the system. The crosstalk or
interactions among the different microbes contributes to the building blocks of
such microbial community structures. Evidence reported in biomedical text
serves as a reliable source for predicting such interactions. However, going
through the vast and ever-increasing volume of biomedical literature is an
intimidating and time consuming process. This necessitates development of
automated methods capable of accurately extracting bacterial relations reported
in biomedical literature. In this paper, we introduce a method for automated
extraction of microbial interactions (specifically between bacteria) from
biomedical literature along with ways of using transfer learning to improve its
accuracy. We also describe a pipeline using which relations among specific
bacteria groups can be mined. Additionally, we introduce the first publicly
available dataset which can be used to develop bacterial interaction extraction
methods. | [
-0.1993913502,
-0.7239431143,
0.691490829,
-0.158714518,
-0.2832283676,
0.3971515,
0.1263593137,
-0.6462464333,
0.4499237239,
0.1422383338,
-0.3452815413,
-0.2923708558,
-0.6323655844,
0.2470965087,
-0.1309760064,
0.9913647175,
0.2970240712,
0.0717382655,
-0.4496410191,
-0.284465909,
-0.1832637936,
-0.5259940028,
-0.4709032178,
-0.1487496495,
0.6441878676,
0.2696438432,
0.321374774,
0.1530908197,
0.8280355334,
0.310951978,
-0.0367958769,
0.5300902724,
-0.4420934319,
-0.0203712396,
-0.8983915448,
0.0287449714,
-0.3948739767,
0.0630537122,
0.5969682336,
1.001715064,
0.4264108539,
0.2767008841,
-0.0454234965,
0.3739717007,
-0.3328480721,
0.2098620385,
-0.217910707,
-0.0264023039,
-0.1943329871,
-0.3191189766,
-0.6024458408,
-0.2438697964,
0.224358961,
-0.5844039321,
-0.0623389557,
-0.1797160357,
0.6955572963,
-0.1185150892,
-0.5242853165,
-0.3485474885,
-0.308906883,
0.5459439158,
-0.6020806432,
0.3148176372,
0.2171917558,
0.0242834873,
-0.3976855874,
-0.8402949572,
-0.2533409894,
-0.0475734845,
-0.5512883663,
0.1926068068,
-0.2497919351,
-0.2112412602,
0.0355797745,
0.1833225638,
-0.2901979089,
-0.2594142258,
-0.9843275547,
-0.1707937717,
0.4740388393,
-0.019762205,
0.6098183393,
-0.1790467203,
-0.2443578392,
0.0190623645,
-0.2882832289,
0.3543936014,
-0.0491600186,
0.2192551047,
0.019182425,
0.1860778034,
0.3471249044,
0.3747189641,
0.0913750902,
0.03149876,
0.4221251607,
-0.5243623257,
-0.1709856987,
0.0520885102,
0.7718542218,
0.1976826787,
-0.043921046,
-0.0689490139,
0.2612610757,
-0.2248790115,
0.4670794606,
-0.830873847,
-0.2788100243,
0.1362080574,
-0.7477232814,
-0.5487075448,
0.1285824925,
-1.0561490059,
-0.2272029221,
-0.1317046881,
0.2919158638,
-0.7699508071,
-0.382738471,
-0.3816330135,
-0.3512090147,
0.1528967768,
0.4392065704,
-0.6796104312,
0.6155920625,
0.543225348,
0.9686073661,
-0.6867005229,
0.0101778051,
-1.1107065678,
0.4734098613,
0.0161080509,
0.7748040557,
-0.699444294,
-0.8326115608,
-0.229741618,
0.3155399859,
-0.1542504877,
-0.567317903,
0.1082744971,
-0.2983701825,
-0.3202847838,
-0.0233764388,
-0.6983144283,
-0.3150973916,
-0.3480553329,
-0.7761690021,
0.432867229,
0.5841032863,
-0.8773613572,
-0.0223620459,
-0.5918866992,
-0.966068387,
0.5319772363,
-0.1799760163,
-0.2880310118,
-0.0225141067,
-0.0384139009,
0.4326988459,
0.0082901362,
0.1112823412,
-0.7105065584,
-0.10679131,
0.5913453102,
0.355682224,
1.3968575001,
0.3374924958,
0.0332084782,
0.0185105912,
-0.6491007209,
-0.3501507342,
-0.3924097419,
-0.0525091104,
-0.6632089019,
-0.0938699841,
-0.2123747766,
-0.3105948865,
-0.070077464,
-0.7499584556,
0.4939644039,
-0.2925765216,
0.8773353696,
0.6556405425,
0.4606837928,
0.4999749064,
-0.2472953796,
0.3537599444,
0.1076518297,
0.002718274,
-0.0155900968,
-0.4946513474,
-0.0491363369,
-0.6596964598,
0.4839558303,
0.3645801842,
-0.4614373446,
0.4668104351,
-0.1886654645,
-0.6265341043,
-0.4730617702,
0.1186506599,
0.1573756933,
0.8560963273,
0.6526321769,
-0.5892235637,
-0.279938519,
-0.529584229,
0.0677810907,
-0.2242141068,
0.3073121309,
0.4015069306,
0.3575541377,
-0.8907097578,
1.1830846071,
-0.5788796544,
-0.1118528694,
-0.2494333237,
0.4386516511,
0.1781738549,
0.752951622,
0.8550984859,
-0.6297697425,
-0.3696958423,
0.7400859594,
-0.6469323039,
-0.4245004654,
0.0560650937,
-0.2687410712,
0.0396484919,
0.7453367114,
-0.2019982338,
0.6972301006,
0.3242265284,
0.066977635,
0.5341970325,
-0.053435944,
0.2590216398,
-1.1177284718,
0.4564328194,
0.0641561523,
-0.4608522058,
-0.6355143785,
-0.1786963344,
0.3148130178,
-0.0597236939,
-0.4914218783,
0.935341835,
-0.3985565603,
0.0510097966,
0.0059157661,
-0.1287481785,
0.2443030328,
0.1029482707,
0.3392065763,
0.6331907511,
0.3975219727,
-0.6923737526,
0.504085362,
0.5806268454,
-0.2113885581,
0.2964848578,
-0.392101258,
-0.0799788833,
0.3724305928,
0.2946433425,
-1.0181460381,
-0.040388301,
0.4728732109,
-0.8008491397,
0.1346267909,
-0.4705529511,
-0.2009007633,
-0.21888493,
-0.0852372199,
0.7418988943,
0.3862999678,
-0.4335626364,
0.6303815842,
0.5984598398,
-0.6484146118,
-0.475741744,
-0.6834816337,
-0.2148405463,
0.0222559702,
-0.2482093275,
0.1824803054,
-0.1478102654,
-0.3317582607,
0.1756149828,
-0.1453314275,
-0.5087578893,
0.0138843507,
0.3399426937,
0.7096983194,
0.1355474144,
0.2392269969,
0.613158226,
0.0350644663,
0.0282262582,
0.1204397306,
-0.0444891416,
0.0446916819,
-0.1583371907,
-0.3608396649,
0.2955732048,
0.6307764649,
-0.221251294,
0.267333895,
0.5530425906,
-0.4273455739,
-0.1115231439,
-0.1585999876,
-0.1685891449,
-0.4876813293,
0.3858292699,
-0.4180389643,
-0.513969481,
0.4615287781,
-0.553306818,
-0.3857481182,
0.2837392688,
0.4519988298,
-0.3183011413,
0.0799177587,
0.7679842114,
-0.1759885997,
0.1613494158,
0.0007894431,
0.2435911596,
-0.7096546888,
-0.3681151569,
-0.3689014018,
0.0069151116,
-0.2485440671,
-0.3452951014,
0.4549881518,
-0.0950525701,
0.1135235578,
0.7159192562,
-0.2031151354,
-0.0859762207,
0.4587424397,
0.1402982473,
0.3064858019,
0.1739254147,
-0.5943123698,
0.307549715,
-0.5227599144,
0.0037994946,
0.8388831019,
0.2014716566,
0.7800652385,
0.2892695963,
0.5907897949,
0.901340425,
0.4548463821,
-0.8423044682,
0.3955004811,
-0.1818577796,
-0.2780827284,
-0.032735616,
-0.6448907852,
-1.1076455116,
-0.3043329716,
-0.4220769107,
-0.7857615948,
0.8122522235,
-0.3450275958,
-0.5337643027,
0.248821035,
-0.6948577762,
0.5920789242,
-0.065831691,
-0.488247931,
-0.3569672108,
-1.0291353464,
0.0247826055,
-0.3324668407,
0.5863984823,
0.290189445,
0.1795383841,
0.627915442,
-0.5602664948,
0.8959613442,
0.2071079612,
0.0026698785,
0.3731105626,
0.5249834061,
-0.2294232994,
0.4242319167,
-0.1991021633,
0.437746346,
0.5428083539,
-0.3611669242,
-0.0852848664,
0.5307842493,
-0.8371683359,
-0.1994474083,
-0.6748422384,
-0.4665951729,
-0.2234366387,
0.4188166559,
0.0888377652,
0.6787390113,
-0.507674396,
0.0295347441,
0.6448581815,
-0.4042881131,
0.5435798764,
0.4238084853,
-0.2041469365,
-0.8379076719,
0.882229507,
-0.2095593214,
0.2532222271,
0.5594395399,
0.0967253521,
-0.1137451306,
-0.1769807637,
-0.3783107698,
0.384313643,
-0.4328552186,
-0.5932965279,
-0.8363768458,
-0.4700213373,
-1.226564765,
-0.3962347507,
0.2078625858,
-0.2644225955,
-0.5036075115,
-0.2143446803,
0.4705961943,
0.7149153352,
-0.5778082013,
0.280803144,
-1.5053225756,
0.2363411933,
0.1431798041,
0.1032507271,
-0.1516709626,
-0.3914946616,
-0.5005349517,
-0.2337780595,
-0.0356950052,
-1.2050808668,
0.6484888196,
0.1310933679,
0.5934491754,
0.7418791652,
-0.1277343482,
0.2383113503,
-0.3128731549,
0.4344007373,
0.2096672803,
-1.0519227982,
0.563329041,
-0.2965312004,
-0.212471351,
0.5480836034,
0.8637180328,
-0.5705863833,
-0.0831945613,
-0.7029238343,
-0.5519353151,
0.635643363,
0.0110841077,
-0.405649215,
-0.0759537965,
0.4906408489,
0.6183460951,
-0.0646477714,
-0.4756461084,
-0.0497676395,
0.0938934535,
-0.233008936,
0.274918586,
0.0718382075,
-0.2879139185,
-0.5010966063,
0.6337263584,
0.0214139167,
0.1060660928,
0.5268208981,
-0.5211102962,
-0.2529303432,
-0.1966080666,
0.2011855543,
0.6963435411,
-0.5459188819,
0.2777677774,
-0.2133382708,
-0.7714913487,
0.128881976,
0.3066217303,
0.0835367069,
-0.089507699,
0.5229415894,
0.0537624843,
-0.362901628,
-0.9223140478,
0.6300433278,
0.0584884435,
-0.1614847481,
0.0021537896,
0.0655774772,
-0.049554117,
0.3831923902,
0.3859581649,
0.3748424649,
0.420895189,
-0.7541325092,
0.685479939,
0.1480818689,
-0.6077452302,
-0.3851606548,
0.3341256082,
0.5176167488,
-0.0960385427,
0.5591464043,
-0.1548541486,
-0.3868165016,
0.8758830428,
0.4699164629,
0.5384725332,
-0.3052588999,
0.4530390501,
0.7245652676,
-0.0477477349,
0.7112613916,
-0.4921295643,
-0.193650797,
-0.6657776833,
-0.4715882242,
-0.6570912004,
-0.6260422468,
0.0984203443,
-0.5761680603,
0.5604093075,
-0.4866943359,
-0.0753670037,
0.3659266531,
0.1935674101,
-0.0993229523,
0.2622309625,
0.2104183584,
0.5971546173,
-0.9514208436,
1.0117690563,
0.8470418453,
-0.8143613935,
-0.2743754387,
-0.2011896223,
-0.1271708608,
-0.6238423586,
0.8621634245,
0.0376290046,
-0.2705535889,
-0.1397423297,
-0.3491413891,
-0.5776532888,
0.7936658263,
-0.1117103696,
-0.4811604619,
0.3229765296,
0.1106346995,
0.3829078972,
-0.4904434383,
0.4184472561,
0.2303446084,
0.4260198474,
-0.1462711096,
-0.519520402,
0.3286916614,
-0.6851516366,
-0.3982509971,
-0.1103199571,
-0.8513378501,
0.5103880763,
-0.1710821539,
0.0380868614,
0.1150891334,
0.7624368072,
-0.0911886096,
0.5704965591,
0.4122102261,
0.2467762828,
0.8713175058,
0.3810391426,
0.5082333088,
-0.1272690147,
0.1173415333,
0.9689477086,
-0.4691618383,
0.5033552051,
0.3185453415,
-0.2069772333,
0.704779923,
0.9717521071,
-0.2885362804,
0.4450393617,
0.1274211109,
-0.5044855475,
-0.07668221,
0.1905453056,
-0.6228292584,
-0.0186388735,
0.8692882061,
-0.3051386774,
0.2290723771,
0.1657508612,
-0.1124707609,
-0.1428934187,
-0.4032007456,
0.9276397824,
0.1765988469,
-0.4527809322,
-0.0179014802,
-0.4502285123,
0.2880364358,
-0.5017005205,
-0.2390051335,
-0.2278790623,
0.093267478,
-0.3553619683,
-0.588311851,
0.3184549212,
-0.3616783917,
-0.3911230266,
0.1586510241,
1.1171579361,
-0.3372614682,
-0.4571384788,
0.7054274678,
0.7522794604,
0.2902162969,
0.6396359205,
-0.2666730583,
-0.2051512897,
0.0763607994,
0.2455361187,
0.408787936,
0.6455920935,
0.0030994066,
0.4032013714,
0.7511398196,
0.4489255548,
-0.3133648336,
-0.1874509752,
0.9326894283,
-0.5332609415,
-0.143463403,
-0.6056295037,
0.0833172947,
-0.2513909936,
0.0607506409,
0.0205631722,
0.5317701101,
0.6277191639,
-0.2357679456,
1.305775404,
-0.254421562,
0.7826048136,
0.1008625403,
0.8196817636,
-0.5439394712,
-0.0758142918,
-0.3847896159,
-0.5509134531,
-0.1329717785,
0.4367359579,
-0.0973153859,
-0.4196666777,
1.1676917076,
0.4971587062,
-0.4990416467,
-0.0098331347,
-0.0359962732,
0.4482010305,
0.2437229007,
0.2307651043,
0.3914373815,
-0.046641849,
0.5853070617,
-0.1846080124,
-0.8231511712,
-0.2833398283,
-0.8632268906,
-0.8071559668,
-0.5145321488,
-0.4838490188,
-0.6021834016,
0.3250507414,
0.7891851664,
0.4225558341,
-0.9457302094,
-0.404825151,
0.1892638952,
-0.0587211661,
-0.4733379781,
-0.2314389348,
0.481012702,
-0.6239103079,
-0.6850209832,
0.3597748876,
0.3310227394,
-0.0944025367,
0.1471299529,
0.232517302,
-0.625287354,
0.2730242908,
0.5685626268,
0.6338976622,
0.1848164499,
-0.1555897295,
-0.2268197984,
-0.2503898442,
0.0938380957,
0.8563880324,
-0.9139018059,
0.3335113525,
0.6518639922,
1.1909096241,
0.5523167849,
0.054998409,
0.5929906964,
-0.3350239396,
-0.0807492062,
0.0481037088,
0.2986463904,
-0.0092875063,
-0.5856449604,
0.8754449487,
0.9006524682,
-0.6527200937,
-0.5613866448,
0.0845599696,
-1.6091423035,
-0.7551463842,
1.0999112129,
-0.4162751734,
-0.5158249736,
-0.2198808342,
-0.2831371725,
0.5657245517,
-0.4226091504,
0.5432906151,
0.4555808306,
-0.3094679713,
0.2350082844,
-0.0771722123,
0.4153305292,
0.3946643472,
-0.8963937759,
-0.0397667363,
0.4572945535,
0.3334644139,
0.1774685979,
0.6977533102,
-0.2106140405,
0.2334754169,
-0.3166542351,
0.1185408309,
0.2528383136,
-0.1703164876,
0.1846139729,
-0.0428014882,
-0.5539660454,
0.0311974399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13958v1 | Learning and Reasoning Multifaceted and Longitudinal Data for Poverty Estimates and Livelihood Capabilities of Lagged Regions in Rural India | 2023-04-27T05:33:08 | 2023-04-27T05:33:08 | Atharva Kulkarni, Raya Das, Ravi S. Srivastava, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Poverty is a multifaceted phenomenon linked to the lack of capabilities of
households to earn a sustainable livelihood, increasingly being assessed using
multidimensional indicators. Its spatial pattern depends on social, economic,
political, and regional variables. Artificial intelligence has shown immense
scope in analyzing the complexities and nuances of poverty. The proposed
project aims to examine the poverty situation of rural India for the period of
1990-2022 based on the quality of life and livelihood indicators. The districts
will be classified into `advanced', `catching up', `falling behind', and
`lagged' regions. The project proposes to integrate multiple data sources,
including conventional national-level large sample household surveys, census
surveys, and proxy variables like daytime, and nighttime data from satellite
images, and communication networks, to name a few, to provide a comprehensive
view of poverty at the district level. The project also intends to examine
causation and longitudinal analysis to examine the reasons for poverty. Poverty
and inequality could be widening in developing countries due to demographic and
growth-agglomerating policies. Therefore, targeting the lagging regions and the
vulnerable population is essential to eradicate poverty and improve the quality
of life to achieve the goal of `zero poverty'. Thus, the study also focuses on
the districts with a higher share of the marginal section of the population
compared to the national average to trace the performance of development
indicators and their association with poverty in these regions. | [
-0.241332069,
-0.679497838,
0.3573751152,
0.3200433552,
-0.0190309808,
0.2280200273,
0.1925714612,
-0.1377349794,
0.1613577157,
0.3183588386,
-0.5905919671,
-0.2096558064,
-0.6422114968,
-0.2832072377,
-0.3207385838,
0.68636024,
0.549890995,
0.1082502827,
-0.3623853028,
-0.1624177545,
-0.8950794935,
-0.2802428603,
-0.7397313118,
0.1237671524,
0.1430002898,
0.633174181,
0.4542382061,
0.4957759678,
0.5861108899,
0.2950476408,
0.1625665277,
0.1837969869,
-0.3214370012,
0.0414669625,
0.2036662251,
-0.398912698,
-0.4698271751,
-0.0434863754,
0.2973430753,
0.8659291863,
-0.12484999,
0.3690457344,
0.4400179088,
0.7597988844,
-0.787828505,
0.1248560846,
-0.0101328306,
0.1090164557,
-0.5939545035,
-0.23266761,
0.1339505166,
-0.7115851045,
-0.0122925639,
-0.211238414,
0.495195955,
0.0548398085,
0.528310895,
0.2880719304,
-0.5550838113,
-0.4710158706,
-1.036740303,
1.0088005066,
-0.422863394,
0.0361371599,
0.7141472101,
0.4589577317,
0.0617492422,
-0.4862492085,
-0.2594483793,
0.0373870246,
-0.1202698275,
0.3904078901,
0.5529528856,
-0.5266469717,
-0.1188390329,
0.5333156586,
-0.4507389069,
-0.1321805418,
-0.8283330202,
-0.1277314872,
0.4999982417,
0.4789377451,
0.2055398673,
-0.3053314984,
-0.6173459291,
0.0548362806,
-0.520740211,
0.4405002296,
0.5835076571,
0.3927908838,
-0.3533160985,
0.4493068755,
-0.2060583234,
0.7555828691,
-0.1534193307,
-0.1399665028,
0.2243604362,
-0.7250239253,
0.257792294,
-0.1105609015,
0.225322932,
0.417371273,
-0.1340449452,
0.2224259377,
-0.2242909968,
0.0817248672,
-0.0816925839,
-0.0585603155,
0.0767002031,
0.2803384066,
-0.6245952845,
-0.0923637524,
0.0089289639,
-1.6301603317,
-0.6849153042,
-0.3333615363,
-0.1131642684,
-0.2223214805,
-0.5414030552,
-0.0298787896,
0.0328359269,
0.6220772862,
0.0875938982,
-0.9351636171,
0.2667067647,
0.674628377,
0.9738771319,
0.1122793257,
-0.1556984037,
-0.4265578091,
-0.2309414148,
0.0915847868,
1.1082816124,
-0.7939357758,
-0.6272067428,
0.0695422888,
-0.090237394,
-0.2427560538,
-0.5766748786,
0.5610037446,
-0.2157722116,
-0.1054677069,
-0.3403553069,
-0.0479322523,
0.1320797205,
0.2778022289,
-0.5510363579,
0.9280430675,
0.3103999197,
-0.2482585162,
0.4963769317,
-0.5950880051,
-0.3840713203,
-0.0422648937,
0.0744275749,
-0.4240051806,
0.0872375444,
0.2535424232,
0.5226511359,
-0.5458452106,
0.6063284278,
-0.4623977542,
-0.0892639607,
-0.0871103704,
-0.6140660644,
0.9857987761,
0.297178179,
0.0071269814,
0.0510249659,
-0.8603950739,
0.0845934227,
-0.0874647871,
0.0945981443,
-0.3139616847,
0.0437232181,
0.0765150487,
0.0647047982,
0.3230734169,
-0.4220846593,
0.0545194,
-0.1767033339,
0.368101716,
0.4952632785,
0.0800504759,
0.3737168014,
-0.3305180967,
0.5373269916,
0.023669444,
0.8501867056,
-0.0452228226,
-0.4365622401,
-0.6473445296,
-0.1433983445,
0.7103157043,
0.8192636371,
-0.2789319158,
0.086867094,
0.1735109836,
-0.1226016581,
-0.3565786183,
-0.2759510875,
0.1357966065,
0.6547419429,
0.2184867561,
-0.274009645,
-0.6086819172,
-0.4935628176,
0.3402636051,
0.3501151204,
0.2212104648,
-0.0959098712,
0.5819584727,
0.1811902225,
0.9638389945,
-0.6715766191,
-0.711288631,
-0.1119900644,
-0.0311937295,
-0.1555758417,
0.6994129419,
0.3548194468,
-1.5173448324,
-0.5091996193,
-0.2769275606,
-0.7423722744,
-0.2452147007,
-0.0220733564,
-0.0702840984,
-0.3213362992,
0.4586029947,
-0.4682718813,
0.8919505477,
0.454587996,
-0.5034946203,
0.6853509545,
-0.2145854682,
0.2363686413,
-0.841993928,
-0.0048338785,
0.0530460663,
0.1570171416,
-0.5771632195,
-0.2847323716,
-0.2641515732,
-0.4136976004,
-0.0866084173,
0.5193371773,
-0.4570980966,
-0.2156609744,
0.1319511384,
0.3629232943,
-0.2433577031,
0.1782647371,
-0.522135973,
0.7410574555,
0.6516823769,
-0.2339191735,
0.4607125521,
0.0516329072,
-0.030813029,
0.8503944278,
-0.5599257946,
-0.4595519006,
-0.053285107,
-0.1940080374,
-0.755228281,
-0.3166285455,
0.2517647445,
-0.7090480328,
0.1328542233,
0.3514294922,
-0.0303874966,
-0.165142104,
-0.3040187061,
0.4762913287,
0.3201421797,
0.0923565552,
0.5801131725,
0.5455957055,
-0.1311445981,
-0.6746753454,
-0.4127220511,
-0.1562904716,
-0.6234815121,
-0.266854316,
-0.1207395419,
0.1264012903,
-0.4252527654,
0.4154451489,
0.0632892922,
-0.449871242,
-0.1535332948,
0.4699388146,
0.0753995106,
0.0132545112,
-0.0813111812,
-0.1625779122,
-0.4642569423,
-0.2074895948,
0.128494978,
0.5779694915,
-0.0761090145,
-0.471682936,
-0.057943821,
0.5910180211,
0.4311472476,
-0.5767586827,
0.6826813221,
0.4683151543,
-0.5407035947,
0.0020258415,
-0.2752223313,
0.2004056871,
-0.3550871611,
-0.1060260385,
-0.0097544016,
-0.5814630985,
0.7815082073,
-0.5973632336,
-0.4595943391,
0.3799632788,
0.1542572677,
0.2283581942,
0.4399642646,
0.8295185566,
0.0228116382,
0.1151592433,
-0.4764147699,
0.4665541053,
-0.9414779544,
-0.6083179116,
-0.5270965099,
-0.0930426791,
-0.5112637281,
-0.5495867729,
0.5182740092,
0.2026000917,
0.022711115,
-0.3910065293,
-0.3394057453,
0.4412978292,
0.3329667151,
0.0252872445,
0.1185605004,
-0.3193045557,
0.0266098455,
-0.0888580456,
-0.5184780359,
-0.466450721,
1.0362040997,
0.0305077024,
0.3106216788,
0.0747502744,
0.5932793617,
0.8844792247,
0.2004480511,
-0.5545614362,
0.2032886744,
-0.2406995445,
-0.5695721507,
-0.2721029818,
-0.0560799986,
-1.0403467417,
-0.0832221732,
-0.3179858625,
-0.6243370175,
0.5909153223,
0.0975788161,
-0.686604321,
0.1515492201,
-0.7251001596,
0.5099533796,
-0.2277647406,
-0.5283213854,
-0.3539633155,
-0.7426791787,
0.6011695266,
-0.0906090438,
0.6471719146,
-0.1159807816,
0.2079508156,
0.1639996022,
-0.4516102076,
1.1258199215,
-0.5866687298,
0.5141841769,
0.563878119,
-0.5564079881,
-0.1111061722,
0.1073281392,
-0.2703043222,
-0.1009119079,
-0.1757369936,
-0.9213783145,
-0.3782582581,
0.8326404095,
-0.721137464,
-0.3698070943,
-0.7259987593,
-0.5240800381,
-0.2542970181,
0.1682453454,
-0.0834519267,
1.041413188,
0.0148737561,
0.0322440118,
0.6450318098,
-0.1815669835,
0.4516069591,
-0.4106992781,
0.0110406419,
-0.4151345789,
1.0329717398,
0.3223547041,
0.1559607834,
0.1345696598,
0.3166491389,
-0.2658509314,
-0.430377394,
-0.1956533641,
0.123713322,
-0.4623140991,
-0.502091229,
-0.0461132303,
-0.2759628296,
-0.154529199,
-0.2816013992,
-0.2585544288,
-0.1593253165,
0.0963411033,
0.3409526944,
-0.0891104564,
0.9273480177,
-0.4249403775,
0.1747757196,
-0.7170444131,
0.2574755847,
0.2835847139,
0.2971925735,
0.2909127474,
-0.0603356138,
-0.3474057615,
0.0291293003,
-0.4112248123,
-0.6101830602,
0.5422808528,
0.1509493738,
0.4496981204,
0.2158549428,
0.169020921,
1.1204971075,
-0.0505002812,
0.8034309745,
0.0366058499,
-0.5359553099,
0.6050659418,
-0.2243174016,
0.263171643,
0.462803781,
0.4226639867,
-0.1678472012,
0.0963961631,
-0.213192001,
-1.0979046822,
0.2421569824,
-0.0710506961,
-0.2253888845,
0.3009266555,
0.4988334179,
0.3911603987,
0.1705293804,
-0.3363372386,
-0.3580719829,
-0.1367955655,
-0.1343438476,
0.1875350773,
-0.2435674816,
-0.0746401846,
-0.3183832169,
0.3114031553,
0.0473916084,
0.3083173037,
0.2471881211,
0.3010354638,
0.0865379497,
0.1915975213,
0.7866446376,
1.0623636246,
-0.0072829677,
-0.0636113212,
0.0583100319,
-0.5719680786,
0.1430789679,
0.1198726371,
-0.2283863127,
-0.3883168399,
0.5022158623,
0.5126665235,
-0.2406519353,
-0.3100344241,
0.3147398233,
-0.1094448641,
-0.0660279691,
-0.8556702733,
-0.1998350173,
0.0846661255,
0.4330356121,
0.5845001936,
0.3907805085,
0.0203738287,
-0.4106669128,
0.0025882199,
0.1826260388,
-0.4217360616,
-0.2153777778,
0.4949036539,
0.4519229829,
-0.3870278001,
0.7099201679,
-0.3967419863,
-0.1154236048,
0.852006793,
0.2809028327,
0.3979272544,
-0.437466681,
0.3068536818,
0.5042142272,
0.1372305453,
0.0333690457,
0.3658151031,
-0.0856185183,
-0.2822006345,
-0.440212965,
-0.8889629245,
-0.0063396445,
0.1868794858,
-0.808127284,
0.3065944016,
-0.2220705599,
-0.1487247497,
-0.3412088454,
0.0162220653,
-0.5031450391,
0.5406723022,
-0.0654698685,
0.4710690379,
-0.9394975901,
0.5225867629,
0.3369152546,
-0.2875438333,
-0.5044844151,
0.311507076,
-0.0649386123,
-0.9384877086,
0.7477456331,
-0.0126158763,
-0.4504674375,
-0.0299736932,
-0.2604537606,
-1.0059763193,
1.1699999571,
-0.1491560191,
-0.3744018078,
0.1619837731,
0.2986849248,
0.4883878231,
-0.4512072504,
0.0444732122,
0.3843644261,
0.6564884186,
0.0003140964,
-0.6931485534,
-0.314773947,
-0.2919685245,
0.1248689815,
0.5050862432,
-0.9779254198,
0.9157765508,
-0.3871062398,
-0.2792343199,
0.0575701594,
0.4954169393,
0.1533869207,
0.8158053756,
0.4626291394,
0.5095877647,
0.5608551502,
-0.2876904309,
0.8600597382,
-0.5706977844,
0.6487505436,
0.695679903,
-0.3544557691,
0.5561823845,
0.3213805556,
-0.4167086184,
0.3114017546,
0.7336491942,
0.1296494007,
0.7853079438,
0.1374621987,
-0.4055758119,
-0.0848014578,
-0.3797638714,
-0.3959935308,
0.8154126406,
0.7912695408,
0.2835302949,
-0.3829667866,
0.1992909908,
-0.0972588882,
0.2650589645,
-0.4491021931,
0.0467712842,
0.0618515275,
-0.300437212,
0.2161752582,
-0.1060459465,
0.4502281547,
-0.7870725989,
-0.480327785,
-0.5039817095,
0.3363465071,
-0.3434600234,
-0.6702008247,
0.9961496592,
-0.1189381778,
-0.1564353704,
-0.0240040477,
1.097074151,
-0.1682100743,
-0.5626832843,
0.2300521135,
0.9145478606,
-0.0192448441,
0.4970411062,
-0.4581318796,
0.0611158833,
-0.1694087833,
0.1388779432,
0.5238274336,
0.5373860002,
-0.3120649159,
0.5746648908,
0.4139155447,
0.3785355687,
0.1476136446,
-0.1662569046,
0.546245575,
-0.8898996711,
-0.3002584875,
-0.7775618434,
0.6107732654,
-0.3500508964,
-0.6265729666,
0.8813980222,
0.3988412917,
0.6413484812,
-0.0250284057,
0.7464782,
-0.7298637033,
0.4107849002,
-0.288753897,
0.3034103513,
-0.5949051976,
0.1069957465,
0.4566968083,
-0.6857381463,
-0.4422656,
0.3908531666,
-0.4872199297,
0.322506845,
0.5535693169,
0.6555050611,
-0.1630618721,
-0.0627129823,
0.4298219681,
-0.2530278563,
-0.0103375195,
0.2047540098,
0.7932091355,
-0.1579850018,
0.2076812685,
-0.3603937924,
-0.4792289138,
-0.0492504612,
-0.7744265795,
-0.2027069926,
-0.702986598,
0.0314275958,
-0.0090470668,
0.0613796972,
0.3850675523,
0.6191107035,
-0.8111618757,
-0.5671067834,
0.1390342563,
0.0990737155,
-0.4078422785,
-0.340156287,
0.6879196167,
-0.1992900074,
-0.51822716,
0.0825907961,
0.4581707716,
-0.5782845616,
-0.7187626958,
0.128446281,
-0.5422386527,
-0.211689204,
0.6387583613,
0.432687819,
-0.3212366402,
-0.0182826538,
-0.1654239744,
0.2206576169,
-0.0153987063,
0.962266922,
-0.6711672544,
0.4818329215,
0.3181627095,
0.3932644427,
0.0568336956,
0.2359648645,
0.0847561881,
-0.5396446586,
0.1640075743,
0.1831678897,
-0.1260324419,
0.5876299739,
-0.6500328183,
0.5135321021,
0.6286203265,
-1.110147953,
-0.6533617973,
0.2663438618,
-0.6208336949,
0.0343746133,
0.7404310703,
-0.2329129726,
-0.3341554403,
-0.4809592962,
-0.1697384417,
0.4251674116,
-0.462223202,
0.9669155478,
0.467564851,
-0.8655225039,
-0.1629681885,
-1.1864118576,
0.3416517973,
0.2705333829,
-0.8247609138,
-0.0148767289,
0.5342947245,
-0.1113638952,
0.2917002439,
0.8424349427,
-0.2128378749,
0.0857636034,
0.4084830582,
-0.1959178448,
0.2081559449,
-0.3938270211,
-0.3336283863,
0.5112400651,
-0.2454734445,
-0.3471882641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13923v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13923v2 | Retrieval-based Knowledge Augmented Vision Language Pre-training | 2023-04-27T02:23:47 | 2023-08-06T08:06:43 | Jiahua Rao, Zifei Shan, Longpo Liu, Yao Zhou, Yuedong Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | With the recent progress in large-scale vision and language representation
learning, Vision Language Pre-training (VLP) models have achieved promising
improvements on various multi-modal downstream tasks. Albeit powerful, these
models have not fully leveraged world knowledge to their advantage. A key
challenge of knowledge-augmented VLP is the lack of clear connections between
knowledge and multi-modal data. Moreover, not all knowledge present in
images/texts is useful, therefore prior approaches often struggle to
effectively integrate knowledge, visual, and textual information. In this
study, we propose REtrieval-based knowledge Augmented Vision Language (REAVL),
a novel knowledge-augmented pre-training framework to address the above issues.
For the first time, we introduce a knowledge-aware self-supervised learning
scheme that efficiently establishes the correspondence between knowledge and
multi-modal data and identifies informative knowledge to improve the modeling
of alignment and interactions between visual and textual modalities. By
adaptively integrating informative knowledge with visual and textual
information, REAVL achieves new state-of-the-art performance uniformly on
knowledge-based vision-language understanding and multi-modal entity linking
tasks, as well as competitive results on general vision-language tasks while
only using 0.2% pre-training data of the best models. Our model shows strong
sample efficiency and effective knowledge utilization. | [
-0.2066684663,
-0.4407212436,
0.6255508661,
-0.1527888179,
-0.4746833742,
0.1221663505,
0.0264959168,
-0.5672786236,
0.4370728731,
0.5395497084,
-0.3025210798,
-0.5006249547,
-0.5839635134,
-0.1109331846,
-0.1598807871,
0.4289862514,
-0.1260679215,
0.1003876701,
-0.2862378657,
-0.164661482,
-0.4042635262,
-0.5719636083,
-0.1537129432,
0.0399446674,
0.4939877093,
0.1034777462,
0.2970588505,
0.5105256438,
0.7027028799,
0.3013575673,
0.4285521507,
0.4278454781,
-0.1993720382,
0.0435594432,
-0.3051624,
-0.4340701997,
-0.3087249994,
-0.0900239125,
0.5205956101,
0.239632532,
-0.165267095,
0.2190964371,
-0.0730313137,
0.7738619447,
-1.0456604958,
0.3953230083,
-0.7209802866,
0.0312121231,
-0.2786472142,
-0.340739578,
-0.3042771816,
-0.0117089534,
0.4037027359,
-1.1742042303,
-0.0166678671,
0.277802527,
0.7115656734,
0.5996003151,
-0.2765286267,
-0.0481215678,
-0.1976619512,
0.7219070792,
-0.2719804943,
1.0340491533,
0.4896274805,
0.5178841352,
0.2676003277,
-0.9584251642,
-0.6990725398,
0.0284338295,
-0.1512699723,
0.1434120834,
0.1160091311,
-0.0488237813,
-0.2087686658,
0.237563923,
-0.2699837685,
-0.4695520401,
-0.3533481359,
-0.257689923,
0.312068671,
-0.0269918367,
0.0549662597,
-0.2821326256,
-0.7625057697,
-0.1474599987,
-0.388640821,
-0.0656694472,
-0.1309002638,
0.2348456681,
0.0393010639,
0.493896693,
-0.3559655249,
1.1434601545,
0.1342580765,
-0.2898176908,
0.6369119287,
-0.6758258343,
-0.38994959,
-0.195745945,
0.555375278,
0.366186291,
0.1966206133,
-0.0184762441,
-0.2835908234,
-0.2918789387,
0.5443886518,
-0.3125259876,
-0.3084365726,
-0.4474786818,
-0.3953246474,
-0.2538322508,
-0.1793350428,
-0.5436401367,
-0.2675351799,
-0.5590022802,
0.9108723402,
-0.5069435835,
-0.1788533628,
0.1503232419,
0.1850349009,
0.5001728535,
0.7429064512,
-0.7581951618,
-0.1647373289,
0.2059573531,
0.4542035758,
-0.1270062178,
-0.4143924713,
-0.414452374,
0.4213977456,
-0.2723580003,
0.7146191597,
-0.581974864,
0.0691428035,
-0.031504564,
-0.0787853822,
-0.1486105472,
-0.3893702626,
0.06514626,
-0.9648303986,
0.3059494793,
-0.2885421216,
-0.3705052137,
-0.3751963675,
0.5455983281,
-0.5139769316,
0.6765759587,
0.1217095405,
-1.048232317,
0.8768868446,
-0.3525670171,
-0.3296739459,
0.2749519646,
-0.5089712739,
-0.2861907482,
-0.1233368218,
0.3802956641,
0.3438778818,
-0.1179416776,
0.2084557712,
-0.1329881251,
-0.0875348449,
-0.3898436427,
-0.2022559792,
0.2679660022,
0.2410901189,
-0.0697759688,
0.1101086959,
-0.7021176815,
0.2189121246,
-0.0363720357,
-0.525011301,
-0.5721464753,
-0.1739621758,
-0.1805069447,
0.1729052663,
0.6211156845,
-0.3992109001,
0.1662371159,
-0.2336201668,
-0.1695525497,
0.5783696771,
-0.0902624726,
0.5629082322,
0.0879511535,
0.3895467222,
0.2326135635,
0.4384126961,
-0.2059953511,
-0.195321992,
-0.7490398884,
-0.3256626427,
0.1184818149,
0.733907342,
-1.6693345308,
0.1201570928,
-0.1765402257,
-0.3562503159,
-0.66710186,
0.4446566105,
0.6906426549,
0.8677282333,
0.573780477,
-0.4307417572,
-0.7106595635,
-0.770604372,
-0.3810996711,
-0.2677834928,
0.3366025686,
0.45129022,
0.2287412584,
-0.3035989106,
0.977032721,
-0.4433438182,
-0.7375995517,
-0.1385203451,
-0.0176050775,
-0.1533192247,
0.4178723991,
0.4692397714,
-1.1444035769,
-0.4550511837,
0.0241637547,
-1.0168004036,
0.1688676625,
0.2596723735,
-0.1533737481,
0.2754994035,
0.6544161439,
-0.1719141603,
0.6152893305,
0.2139914483,
-0.3299300671,
0.6410850286,
-0.5027810335,
0.4503275752,
-0.9876559377,
-0.0118418513,
-0.2227532119,
-0.4556724727,
-0.4134461582,
-0.0099647064,
0.2643042207,
0.1545930207,
-0.8146955967,
0.6702085137,
-0.5460597873,
-0.1171893403,
-0.094024986,
0.0118436879,
0.0974270925,
0.4055019319,
0.4838611186,
0.794749856,
0.8687266111,
-0.5968368053,
0.4511839747,
0.426589638,
-0.5060910583,
0.5446959734,
-0.2113126367,
-0.1792236865,
-0.1964204609,
-0.2490965873,
-0.5686588883,
-0.1434511542,
0.3236419261,
-0.4572342038,
0.3619901538,
-0.2013780177,
-0.3283520639,
-0.0622682646,
0.1744312048,
0.7601246834,
0.1682783961,
-0.6410466433,
1.0120954514,
0.2780128419,
0.1990047395,
-1.0047113895,
-0.5584697723,
-0.1382733881,
0.0456094071,
-0.5088152289,
0.1387643516,
0.1191092283,
0.1308386326,
0.0870489478,
-0.0159160532,
-0.3160327971,
-0.2446265519,
-0.0732244328,
0.1833062768,
-0.0998381451,
0.495236814,
-0.3456715643,
-0.1668020934,
-0.1955047846,
-0.6052663326,
0.2548023164,
-0.3452658653,
-0.4456757605,
-0.407212317,
0.0600882694,
0.3904868364,
-0.7267487645,
0.6928254366,
0.6438661218,
-0.1012738124,
0.3283338547,
-0.9278506637,
-0.0449008755,
-0.4509353042,
0.5349626541,
-0.5853158236,
-0.8507533073,
0.2139629275,
-0.0748812556,
-0.239728108,
0.0881590918,
0.228402406,
-0.2900955379,
0.5236626267,
0.9661371112,
0.257802844,
0.943302393,
-0.0593879856,
0.0965366364,
-0.7052724361,
-0.7771026492,
0.2921327949,
0.0804804787,
-0.0098182671,
-0.7153539658,
0.2114371359,
0.1194349155,
-0.267023176,
0.1165985689,
-0.3123161793,
0.3877498209,
0.7405456901,
0.3412744403,
0.4735150039,
0.1996800154,
-0.190638423,
-0.1804351509,
-0.7247545719,
-0.0802132189,
1.2019994259,
-0.0093527352,
1.0671288967,
-0.1543533504,
0.7222520709,
0.2868255377,
-0.049556125,
-0.3742543161,
0.400187403,
-0.1263422966,
-0.3600076437,
-0.1917865127,
-0.3852027953,
-0.6013119817,
0.2956931591,
-0.5740819573,
-0.2297506481,
0.4030337036,
0.5005909204,
-0.2170932144,
0.39315781,
-0.866410315,
0.9535965323,
-0.6237643361,
-0.4323471189,
-0.025595583,
-0.8841713071,
0.2422831655,
-0.3687411845,
0.2037582695,
0.3963603973,
-0.2072960734,
0.6803281307,
-0.2384857833,
0.6264412999,
-0.3096095622,
0.1433551908,
0.3752033412,
-0.0852159411,
0.1794374436,
0.003280001,
0.3654069304,
-0.0210300572,
-0.0130859548,
-0.4719084203,
-0.7716700435,
0.1949225813,
-0.6729053259,
-0.7197349072,
-0.3412760794,
-0.306658119,
-0.1593720168,
0.496160388,
0.2059024125,
0.4120695293,
0.180308491,
0.2353363037,
0.7710441351,
-0.2562873662,
-0.0147019168,
0.8028291464,
-0.7212632298,
-0.573125422,
1.0210496187,
0.0440616421,
0.3485617638,
0.6783129573,
-0.2463152707,
-0.4631349742,
-0.2949635983,
-0.3806158304,
0.1438435614,
-0.7115662098,
-0.273181349,
-0.6547851562,
-0.0383224823,
-0.5288954377,
-0.0748041496,
-0.6018751264,
-0.0719874799,
-0.2627230287,
-0.0149833709,
0.237653777,
0.4707522094,
-0.1887824088,
0.1357506812,
-0.5875589252,
0.5184240937,
0.7827031016,
0.6295471191,
-0.1278179884,
-0.5094518065,
-0.3345264792,
-0.2238398194,
0.1090251431,
-0.7117062807,
0.4818291366,
0.2497971058,
0.7013537884,
0.2545047104,
-0.0392468534,
0.6716994643,
-0.4921710789,
0.4172076285,
0.4228453338,
-0.5595522523,
0.7301788926,
0.0109965019,
0.1892404407,
0.7709118724,
0.2459078729,
-0.0899719968,
0.0922243446,
-0.4365539253,
-0.7585110664,
0.395644635,
-0.1474692076,
-0.235921979,
0.1268537194,
0.483694762,
-0.0397846177,
0.5533855557,
-0.7422448993,
-0.1743468195,
-0.6968182325,
-0.2874336839,
0.0571235977,
-0.2385443002,
0.1050293967,
-0.4148002863,
0.4896168113,
-0.2697601616,
0.1225529015,
0.5643627644,
-0.647921741,
0.3418268561,
0.0293510351,
0.3346512318,
0.7668397427,
-0.1905931383,
0.3407128751,
0.14191477,
-0.6202406287,
0.1284346879,
0.0257366579,
-0.1136248931,
-0.4010002613,
0.3453222215,
0.6409049034,
0.309297204,
-0.762904644,
0.8170251846,
-0.2716316283,
-0.1560673416,
-0.4617255628,
-0.072638534,
-0.2714647949,
0.6085221767,
0.510094583,
0.1438418776,
0.0865109712,
-0.2781464756,
0.561991632,
0.3968533278,
-0.6426436901,
-0.0649895817,
0.536824882,
0.1748033762,
0.0238716248,
0.5870829821,
-0.196998626,
-0.6958030462,
-0.0943200961,
0.3499107957,
0.1546638608,
-0.215723604,
0.128309533,
0.2674170136,
0.2947390974,
0.1783461124,
0.6630194187,
-0.2110242099,
-0.7648199201,
-0.5389800072,
-0.7488703728,
0.0478294566,
-0.2036316842,
-0.4749075174,
0.0639619455,
-0.3957642615,
0.0825771764,
-0.6182929873,
-0.0458845459,
-0.923422873,
0.5145152211,
-0.0032633806,
0.9997060299,
-0.8320767879,
0.9539777637,
0.8711122274,
-0.7235198021,
-0.7965872288,
-0.32042858,
-0.3781617284,
-1.0098903179,
1.1289098263,
-0.1350147128,
-0.2802114189,
0.1765577942,
-0.481624037,
-1.0124038458,
1.2419016361,
0.4695254862,
-0.3123608232,
-0.1647246778,
-0.1144833565,
0.3808807135,
-0.4730933607,
-0.0029603217,
0.1180999056,
0.4363892972,
0.3188203275,
-0.8738207221,
-0.2827143967,
-0.2902593911,
-0.1317666322,
0.142993167,
-0.5996823907,
0.5615311265,
-0.2827756107,
-0.101670593,
-0.3159442842,
1.0582021475,
0.1578721106,
0.4119411409,
0.5909674168,
0.8073816299,
0.6051231623,
0.2367887497,
0.9268384576,
-0.3584630787,
0.2207392752,
1.2314958572,
-0.029025251,
0.9427126646,
0.6541786194,
0.2069302201,
0.4089997411,
0.2990416884,
0.1724589467,
0.966078341,
-0.3760171235,
-0.2241080254,
-0.930924952,
-0.1206881925,
-0.5170524716,
0.5156260729,
0.1192425266,
-0.4082824588,
-0.1950037032,
0.3121962845,
-0.6709709167,
0.0065337578,
-0.4306154549,
0.9126640558,
-0.0495899655,
-0.341126442,
0.3862866461,
-0.6278295517,
0.7734048367,
-0.6111541986,
-0.2165216357,
0.0996204689,
0.1247356907,
-0.1048013493,
-0.8308159709,
0.1936717331,
-0.3418018222,
-0.4689278305,
-0.0465442725,
1.0660893917,
-0.6894556284,
-0.4526027739,
0.3514660001,
0.8000344634,
0.0797132626,
-0.1814672947,
-0.6116853356,
-0.2603952885,
0.150592491,
0.051031854,
0.333951056,
0.4000032246,
0.1319254935,
1.0010777712,
0.5260888338,
-0.0157674775,
0.4243839681,
-0.1121084839,
0.8608528376,
-0.6038721204,
-0.4611411989,
-0.3261965215,
0.3876589835,
0.0477162004,
0.0047819656,
0.4720644653,
0.5105842352,
1.0062582493,
-0.2534230947,
0.6703389883,
-0.0786118209,
0.5798093081,
-0.675503552,
0.8134926558,
-1.0109558105,
0.0554535389,
-0.2182242423,
-0.805339694,
-0.3413621187,
0.7304100394,
-0.5581638813,
0.1043032482,
0.389121592,
0.6767587662,
-0.0843242034,
-0.4371485412,
0.639968574,
-0.0218923371,
0.1348435432,
0.5843402147,
0.7946392894,
-0.3921922445,
0.6697001457,
-0.0867684558,
-0.1637737006,
-0.2569967508,
-0.8072237372,
-0.6246069074,
-0.9269130826,
-0.0541776158,
0.1595226526,
0.2408870012,
0.5810729265,
0.7710097432,
-0.2419947982,
0.3962498605,
0.1537026614,
0.0771206394,
0.0822412446,
-0.1441007555,
0.4830747545,
-0.495649159,
-0.2264427245,
0.3562993407,
0.3084871769,
0.0612392686,
-0.1292424202,
-0.2545723915,
-0.5192198157,
-0.4133688509,
0.6751744747,
0.41706267,
-0.7587042451,
-0.4453269243,
0.0615443103,
-0.0433587022,
0.1435146779,
0.5750511289,
-1.369541049,
1.0527443886,
0.4552851319,
0.7851427197,
0.4353069365,
0.1230275854,
0.5371420979,
-0.776240766,
0.1128059328,
0.0220109895,
0.439252615,
0.4485246241,
-0.2255843431,
0.3834160268,
0.3446390331,
-0.4301425219,
-0.3089131117,
0.3984699845,
-0.9652637243,
-0.0424178652,
0.6919842958,
-0.3370837271,
-0.2966121435,
-0.17540811,
-0.2463915646,
0.3526036143,
-0.1323651075,
0.5792918205,
0.2020556927,
0.0818536282,
-0.6315937042,
-0.2676995099,
0.511721909,
0.4138020277,
-0.6282297373,
-0.0909744874,
0.448464036,
0.4077824354,
0.2580265403,
0.7476357818,
-0.1229839623,
0.355245173,
-0.1599154323,
0.2540831566,
-0.4804006219,
-0.5993970037,
0.0177891459,
0.0892774239,
0.0531842895,
-0.2702517211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13902v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13902v2 | Controllable Data Augmentation for Context-Dependent Text-to-SQL | 2023-04-27T01:00:10 | 2023-04-28T02:45:31 | Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | The limited scale of annotated data constraints existing context-dependent
text-to-SQL models because of the complexity of labeling. The data augmentation
method is a commonly used method to solve this problem. However, the data
generated by current augmentation methods often lack diversity. In this paper,
we introduce ConDA, which generates interactive questions and corresponding SQL
results. We designed the SQL dialogue state to enhance the data diversity
through the state transition. Meanwhile, we also present a filter method to
ensure the data quality by a grounding model. Additionally, we utilize a
grounding model to identify and filter low-quality questions that mismatch the
state information. Experimental results on the SParC and CoSQL datasets show
that ConDA boosts the baseline model to achieve an average improvement of
$3.3\%$ on complex questions. Moreover, we analyze the augmented data, which
reveals that the data generated by ConDA are of high quality in both SQL
template hardness and types, turns, and question consistency. | [
-0.7556582093,
-1.1760175228,
0.1564010531,
0.0867856815,
-0.2914812565,
0.117516771,
-0.1996998638,
-0.5097647309,
0.3262138367,
0.6183238626,
-0.7123050094,
-0.5032079816,
-0.3275432289,
0.2558240891,
-0.43371889,
1.0923987627,
0.0785102174,
0.023700919,
-0.3295041919,
-0.3781259656,
-0.8198269606,
-0.584243536,
-0.4077381194,
-0.1572874635,
0.0221029148,
0.5056955218,
0.9712218046,
0.4241339266,
0.2403345555,
0.1891449392,
-0.4033127129,
0.6680063605,
-0.4907245934,
0.4258564115,
-0.391448319,
-0.6743605137,
-0.2023283094,
-0.1540088505,
0.3773406148,
0.9760386348,
-0.0265148021,
-0.2687362134,
0.02300651,
0.5662541986,
-0.490932256,
-0.1069518775,
-0.7532035708,
-0.0702332631,
-0.0589154139,
-0.2016593218,
-0.3494699299,
-0.4370829463,
0.0215398353,
-0.7349347472,
0.0456708446,
0.1519940346,
0.6026147008,
0.5102808475,
-0.6724729538,
-0.3745459318,
-0.8005625606,
0.5132594109,
-0.4278339446,
0.3569248319,
0.234921813,
0.1051106676,
-0.3814921379,
-0.4846577942,
-0.8594386578,
-0.2440181524,
-0.4790634811,
-0.0375125781,
0.0492267236,
0.1624477059,
0.4226889908,
0.3997591138,
-0.3002548814,
0.1091462076,
-0.1229525432,
-0.1223789379,
0.5693807006,
0.4016964436,
0.366392225,
-0.2019451857,
-0.1752435118,
0.0768671036,
-0.6631077528,
0.2795876265,
0.1211594045,
0.3329126537,
0.1743888855,
0.8336114287,
-0.5063623786,
1.2301011086,
0.3160240352,
0.2903892994,
0.1010285765,
-0.7130807042,
-0.2959316969,
0.0005604525,
0.3656954765,
0.387994051,
-0.1882071346,
-0.0819910541,
-0.0529116318,
0.106724821,
0.0019202201,
-0.7614469528,
-0.0560704097,
0.5107895136,
0.0400040001,
-0.0560439937,
0.0712325945,
-0.5978391171,
-0.5804535747,
-0.5947381854,
0.4004112184,
-0.4349240661,
-0.192234531,
-0.1728461981,
0.0252606943,
-0.0003932558,
0.4876186848,
-0.8098769784,
0.4744708836,
0.5505190492,
0.5568031669,
-0.6764950752,
0.3136731088,
-0.5322242379,
0.0571960658,
-0.6648668051,
0.498031348,
-0.8012019396,
-0.4968879223,
-0.2346917391,
0.1530872136,
0.1813266426,
-0.600112915,
0.3418581784,
-0.6948984861,
0.363430053,
-0.5202109814,
-0.7838349342,
-0.0330746993,
0.413811028,
-0.6589144468,
0.9523084164,
0.2888767421,
-0.731795609,
0.7178912163,
-0.5153511763,
-0.3379412293,
0.2219479084,
-0.5589298606,
-0.2486376315,
-0.2554762065,
0.4113122225,
0.0532361791,
-0.2023783922,
0.6232431531,
-0.0493279174,
-0.4719316661,
0.2999906242,
-0.2045836896,
0.6901939511,
0.2257027179,
-0.1279639155,
0.1986113489,
-1.0492295027,
0.0925101712,
-0.4926765859,
-0.399102509,
-0.542863965,
-0.047545027,
-0.1317991167,
0.1159416139,
0.1509044915,
-0.5888563991,
0.0960761309,
-0.4941986203,
0.1452468187,
0.3177549243,
0.5319356322,
0.6347491741,
-0.1858667135,
0.3892138302,
0.4732639194,
0.0541491657,
-0.1622144729,
-0.3601048589,
-0.7527836561,
-0.210155651,
0.3100862801,
0.6667938232,
-1.0170570612,
0.7119995952,
-0.0279171783,
-0.487395972,
-0.4353783727,
-0.0850103125,
-0.0957200155,
0.8413808942,
0.6681830287,
-0.0959787518,
-0.5451467633,
-0.881795764,
-0.111887008,
0.317517668,
-0.0271000043,
0.4727453291,
0.1304527074,
0.0079271533,
1.4151978493,
-0.5013097525,
-0.2298925668,
-0.0346591361,
-0.0351721346,
0.454156965,
0.9322503209,
0.1029270664,
-0.9510306716,
-0.339854151,
-0.0214729607,
-0.6161919236,
0.0502939075,
-0.2518493235,
-0.2155774832,
0.1456486285,
0.4352723956,
-0.5880439878,
0.4506821334,
0.3391057253,
-0.3930152357,
0.2141212374,
-0.2767448723,
0.5635416508,
-1.1480480433,
-0.0818498358,
-0.0327084772,
-0.0522053279,
-0.7096322179,
-0.3452414274,
0.095645003,
-0.3361333609,
-0.2089386582,
0.2016890645,
-0.372690022,
0.1646390706,
-0.0751618668,
-0.114815928,
0.1245067343,
0.3247067332,
0.0802508593,
0.9495165348,
0.3556775451,
-0.8451907635,
0.2850089371,
0.650159359,
-0.4383591413,
0.8535737395,
-0.7975399494,
0.0895868167,
-0.2628100514,
0.4273589253,
-1.2713793516,
-0.3144434094,
0.0487741344,
-0.2824565172,
0.045964472,
-0.2950730026,
-0.3523052931,
0.0995736718,
-0.0064299544,
0.0787078291,
0.2294588685,
-0.6366023421,
0.405761987,
0.4028487504,
-0.1795892566,
-0.5917565227,
-0.8353770971,
0.0856358185,
0.0279004555,
-0.6007125378,
0.5032511353,
-0.0499759279,
-0.1638777256,
-0.1074011847,
-0.0447275378,
-0.371729672,
-0.1572074294,
0.2193820328,
0.3811191618,
0.0158483721,
0.4220338762,
0.8600175381,
0.1641235054,
-0.1105077788,
-0.0890530869,
0.4958563447,
0.4315733314,
-0.2057342529,
-0.2508067191,
0.5836361051,
0.3577212393,
-0.3265351355,
0.9252437353,
0.1339711547,
-0.4920225739,
-0.2331593484,
-0.1974300593,
-0.3456549942,
-0.4664467871,
0.1674490273,
-0.5377125144,
-1.1515352726,
0.4213640988,
-0.0724753886,
0.0401870906,
0.3210657239,
0.2478251159,
-0.195922792,
1.0156219006,
0.388120681,
0.4558411241,
0.4932915568,
-0.2018480897,
-0.0483966693,
-0.5296732783,
-0.4263551831,
-0.4440176487,
-0.3856790066,
-0.7214226723,
-0.2697347701,
0.662305057,
0.0624317415,
-0.2605228722,
0.1229649112,
-0.9726740122,
0.4739514291,
0.2287965119,
0.4787579477,
0.5826612115,
0.0064122393,
0.3541119695,
-0.5021546483,
-0.5919910669,
-0.0785053298,
0.9611893892,
-0.002965844,
1.1441847086,
-0.0040081879,
0.3562186658,
0.4062100351,
0.2619095147,
-0.326565057,
0.4604313076,
-0.0799619555,
-0.7844634056,
-0.4665590525,
-0.4482686818,
-0.7161678076,
0.2886333764,
-0.6493652463,
-0.4685429335,
0.8091391921,
0.1438548565,
-0.2587027848,
-0.0509560853,
-0.8102961779,
0.4495986104,
0.1349638104,
-0.4262062609,
0.0474678203,
-0.6584741473,
0.4036796689,
-0.0564087108,
-0.1582209468,
0.1058716103,
-0.187636748,
0.6776754856,
-0.7216002345,
0.581266582,
-0.3560139239,
-0.0638371632,
0.442247957,
0.0356794894,
0.7823997736,
0.305328846,
-0.1421648562,
-0.1955866516,
-0.0920703933,
-0.14245601,
-0.8637019396,
0.8268384933,
-0.3350563347,
-0.4990388751,
-0.1266405582,
-0.7473785877,
-0.5025978088,
0.1148102209,
0.2073155642,
0.5333409309,
0.0424005874,
0.4058690071,
0.7845773697,
-0.2131557614,
0.121338442,
0.4226095676,
-0.0401370898,
-0.5022391677,
0.6552543044,
0.6147300601,
0.2359306961,
0.2603681386,
-0.286886245,
-0.6707159877,
-0.4023503065,
-0.572573483,
-0.0916131139,
-0.6287462115,
-0.1449444443,
-0.7707425952,
-0.1437227726,
-0.1556992829,
-0.0129896598,
-0.1321441233,
-0.8118482828,
-0.3756153286,
-0.3653398454,
0.6905249953,
0.4493413568,
0.2515588403,
0.3860752285,
-0.3715466857,
0.2788142562,
0.3262814283,
0.4226779044,
-0.4779047072,
-0.3721705079,
-0.0256365184,
0.11576996,
0.0295139682,
-1.0380989313,
0.0910369307,
0.1139599755,
0.3258476257,
-0.2069523484,
0.4122291803,
0.5979970098,
-0.0368552953,
0.8203870654,
0.006426448,
-0.9007738233,
0.8459403515,
-0.2090374082,
0.026250245,
0.8711987138,
0.3160946965,
-0.1494023949,
-0.4328397512,
-0.5273340344,
-0.8597359657,
0.5756748319,
0.1477220505,
0.2558379769,
0.1278103143,
0.5604998469,
0.248811394,
0.3913705349,
-0.3475210369,
-0.3700095415,
-0.0610259995,
-0.197873801,
0.1476223916,
-0.0465872437,
-0.1777825505,
-0.4300846159,
0.1059677228,
-0.0983658656,
-0.199319005,
0.4464096129,
-0.1681566834,
0.1212809458,
0.481028527,
0.3659901917,
0.6984448433,
-0.2334641218,
0.0227331985,
0.3753575981,
-0.369969815,
0.3680904508,
0.186231643,
-0.6896830797,
0.2523275614,
-0.2770588398,
0.7755750418,
-0.2647547722,
-0.4305559695,
0.1862713695,
0.1055008173,
0.1656991988,
0.0659752488,
0.4826378524,
-0.1690614969,
-0.1187611297,
0.4332176447,
0.1241017878,
0.3691362739,
-0.2829605341,
0.4796925783,
0.378646642,
-0.4584721029,
0.2200885266,
0.7993041873,
0.4086183012,
-0.1526518017,
0.4348950982,
-0.1046409458,
-0.0408352539,
0.5406467915,
0.5259643793,
-0.0303124301,
-0.262308985,
0.0579950549,
0.4987523854,
0.3966789842,
0.1274056584,
0.7559835911,
-0.1488864571,
-0.551913321,
-0.4642762244,
-0.0049414514,
-0.8210982084,
0.1092799008,
-0.7090950608,
0.4222956896,
-0.5472243428,
-0.2000470608,
-0.1326594204,
0.1418618113,
-0.328774035,
0.8903641105,
-0.512616694,
1.133500576,
-0.8820337057,
0.6916188002,
0.4338152707,
-0.5539198518,
-0.6503119469,
-0.3071331978,
-0.5874323249,
-0.1417577416,
0.296382159,
0.0622162186,
0.2603857815,
0.320831418,
-0.8438153267,
-0.6297568679,
0.9390660524,
0.4460535645,
-0.4758636057,
0.2213925123,
0.2367824763,
0.5348274112,
-0.4270621836,
0.1794226021,
0.8902065158,
0.4581804872,
0.0947246477,
-0.4382072687,
0.1576109082,
-0.2845478952,
0.0300582685,
0.180114314,
-0.161735028,
0.8354117274,
-0.0105072958,
-0.1851917803,
-0.3538627028,
0.8605645895,
0.3366945088,
0.3807252645,
0.672694087,
0.3875331581,
0.9326586127,
-0.3489251137,
0.8956807256,
-0.2485218048,
0.2514992058,
1.2218528986,
-0.1719615608,
0.5030846,
0.4757115245,
-0.1450559348,
0.4239245057,
0.6588768959,
-0.0171493255,
0.363440156,
0.1722206026,
-0.2910446823,
-0.1883006841,
-0.5071612597,
-0.504314661,
0.0744431913,
0.6931475997,
-0.1435176432,
-0.0820417553,
0.0690612569,
-0.1169480309,
0.2481749803,
-0.0713133588,
0.7817400694,
-0.3300304413,
-0.8321522474,
0.6966998577,
-0.2482098341,
0.7321743965,
-0.4503201544,
-0.2610872388,
-0.7084704638,
-0.2170125097,
-0.5029005408,
-1.0924112797,
0.4857476652,
-0.0496740602,
-0.3075875044,
0.3112244904,
0.5788621902,
-1.0113383532,
-0.2332574278,
-0.1831132621,
0.4070607126,
-0.008380264,
0.0277764332,
-0.4644012451,
0.1347515583,
-0.049736768,
-0.0543405041,
0.0514115132,
0.1971027404,
-0.2765881121,
0.6319788098,
0.6307314038,
0.0313822739,
0.0977462828,
-0.055718448,
1.0539833307,
-0.3961945176,
-0.8042830229,
-0.472139895,
0.6543747783,
-0.590827167,
-0.1615323871,
0.5323287845,
0.6918793321,
0.4945943654,
0.105239667,
0.7029075623,
-0.2665810287,
0.7347803116,
-0.5173642635,
0.7286805511,
-0.428291291,
0.3060328066,
0.0011754334,
-0.8157659173,
-0.1520351321,
0.1302298307,
-0.185061276,
-0.0737792552,
0.473951906,
1.1139879227,
-0.0611858368,
0.1035555825,
0.1400105804,
0.1019003317,
0.449305892,
0.3859740198,
0.688795507,
-0.3974860907,
0.4231821299,
-0.1227887943,
-0.3257931471,
0.081195347,
-0.460904628,
-0.5900890827,
-0.6662402749,
-0.3260002136,
-0.6443132162,
-0.1864796728,
0.8810337782,
0.8133254647,
-1.0201954842,
0.1546897292,
-0.3173488677,
0.3338130414,
0.1213481948,
-0.2619803548,
0.3685065508,
-0.3298987746,
-0.7293405533,
0.4812326729,
0.1380871832,
0.2261140049,
-0.1199763417,
0.1823598593,
-0.1157066077,
0.2799204588,
0.3411212862,
0.0914573669,
-0.2442824095,
-0.0812854618,
-0.0149845555,
-0.2117455751,
0.1759148985,
0.6437911987,
-0.6930437088,
0.6873559356,
0.5404130816,
0.8218963146,
0.4432128668,
0.5359198451,
0.4903222322,
-0.9963157773,
0.2960415184,
0.2442503422,
-0.0831745565,
0.3737172782,
-0.7610403895,
0.507412076,
0.1461593509,
-0.3238627911,
-0.708933115,
0.1462519169,
-1.0478179455,
-0.0512886979,
0.9149972796,
0.105252862,
0.0016330261,
-0.3722051084,
-0.534668386,
0.1773220897,
-0.3481229246,
0.5278614759,
0.5256983042,
-0.3155249655,
-0.2391335368,
-0.1302939653,
0.7599300146,
0.3775518239,
-1.2945674658,
-0.120525524,
0.8207814693,
0.2123447657,
-0.0096952356,
0.5456268787,
-0.0362991132,
0.2010031193,
-0.1608659178,
-0.2402230948,
-0.1338069588,
-0.1692611277,
-0.3394707739,
0.4315855205,
-0.2825181186,
-0.4002464712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13883v1 | Neural Keyphrase Generation: Analysis and Evaluation | 2023-04-27T00:10:21 | 2023-04-27T00:10:21 | Tuhin Kundu, Jishnu Ray Chowdhury, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Keyphrase generation aims at generating topical phrases from a given text
either by copying from the original text (present keyphrases) or by producing
new keyphrases (absent keyphrases) that capture the semantic meaning of the
text. Encoder-decoder models are most widely used for this task because of
their capabilities for absent keyphrase generation. However, there has been
little to no analysis on the performance and behavior of such models for
keyphrase generation. In this paper, we study various tendencies exhibited by
three strong models: T5 (based on a pre-trained transformer),
CatSeq-Transformer (a non-pretrained Transformer), and ExHiRD (based on a
recurrent neural network). We analyze prediction confidence scores, model
calibration, and the effect of token position on keyphrases generation.
Moreover, we motivate and propose a novel metric framework, SoftKeyScore, to
evaluate the similarity between two sets of keyphrases by using softscores to
account for partial matching and semantic similarity. We find that SoftKeyScore
is more suitable than the standard F1 metric for evaluating two sets of given
keyphrases. | [
0.037982069,
-0.456032455,
0.4202803671,
-0.0872314647,
-0.4355537295,
-0.1354965121,
-0.2236576527,
0.0004022221,
-0.0542014651,
0.3709627092,
-0.3235982358,
-0.665361464,
-0.4653402567,
0.3045137823,
-0.6139375567,
1.1447278261,
0.1123794317,
0.0614822954,
0.0032929394,
-0.0338992588,
-0.5133405924,
-0.41105178,
-0.321133256,
-0.2240787745,
0.3771781325,
0.2500485182,
0.577683568,
0.2750320137,
0.9211468697,
0.2770492435,
-0.4428630769,
-0.113484256,
-0.3114165366,
0.592692256,
-0.2782925963,
-0.4192008972,
-0.1692726612,
-0.2692838609,
0.3609414697,
0.5282924175,
0.1749763787,
0.2411134094,
0.0591270737,
0.4547529221,
-0.5312940478,
-0.0518069118,
-1.1101456881,
0.3048548698,
-0.291133225,
-0.1517768651,
-0.1000313535,
-0.671551168,
0.3499922454,
-0.1916636825,
0.671846509,
-0.0584252104,
0.6442861557,
0.0503472164,
-0.4837131798,
-0.735421598,
-0.3881215453,
0.4843797684,
-0.9470508695,
0.1698375791,
-0.1290405095,
0.1811254472,
-0.1612714976,
-1.1339526176,
-0.6728615165,
-0.314838022,
0.2750983238,
0.1534753591,
0.2595160306,
0.1166405454,
0.0102659557,
0.4064917266,
-0.4607725441,
-0.2102891952,
-0.3837974072,
0.1193821132,
0.3920271397,
0.1952899396,
0.0229721703,
-0.6544317007,
-0.0947449282,
-0.3422828019,
-0.6243413091,
-0.0096342899,
0.2151848972,
0.4178350866,
0.1982132345,
0.5795785785,
0.0574918762,
0.1500708759,
0.0485407598,
-0.232078582,
0.3915993869,
-0.7537772655,
-0.0228021964,
0.0639057532,
0.8202904463,
0.4340583682,
0.360747546,
-0.6928640008,
-0.3899037242,
0.0980031639,
0.4430235028,
-0.8808910251,
-0.1147654876,
0.1505577713,
-0.8513646722,
-0.8873255253,
0.1740542203,
-0.742882669,
-0.1442311853,
-0.0104054697,
0.6371221542,
-0.5157335997,
-0.2282919586,
0.0018054864,
-0.6536316872,
0.2964755893,
-0.2214088142,
-0.658624053,
0.3246037066,
0.81688416,
0.9537518024,
-0.4854852855,
-0.1714122146,
-0.1190415695,
-0.2041981369,
-0.3713338375,
0.3968990743,
-0.4714739025,
-0.5388857722,
0.1716527939,
-0.0564945675,
-0.2662834227,
-0.513920784,
0.7889524102,
-0.5616374016,
0.0486644097,
0.0372032002,
-0.6762784719,
-0.1586333066,
0.1761868894,
-0.6891560555,
0.8225674033,
0.0691468567,
-0.6694363952,
0.5059663653,
-0.8135159016,
-0.6853836179,
-0.0016192638,
-0.1637492627,
-0.5949482918,
0.5395969152,
-0.1919715554,
0.4213180244,
-0.5278933048,
0.286003083,
-0.239376694,
-0.2668160796,
0.6958742142,
-0.3709029853,
0.4906072617,
0.327319622,
-0.7133705616,
-0.0960478559,
-0.6587417722,
0.3357059062,
0.2306628227,
-0.1059386879,
-0.1430592984,
0.014428393,
0.3457690775,
0.3529694974,
0.1957501024,
-0.6417461038,
-0.0849869177,
-0.6666039824,
0.7612419724,
0.5453570485,
0.5767064691,
0.3686276376,
-0.0648722798,
0.4823434055,
0.1075175852,
0.0949262977,
-0.2891856134,
-0.4462874532,
-0.4389730692,
0.2859800756,
0.7190135717,
0.2577627897,
-0.5312013626,
0.2698410749,
-0.6283529401,
-0.4815415442,
-0.3788658082,
0.1954896301,
0.4151147306,
0.3246871829,
0.1384294182,
-0.3613677025,
-0.2262269557,
-0.701168716,
-0.4097496569,
0.1148533225,
0.0613116771,
0.1771800965,
0.8609045744,
0.2112533003,
0.7320415974,
-0.384958595,
-0.1484518945,
-0.2776279151,
0.1956006289,
0.2848396897,
0.4377028942,
0.3921250701,
-1.0101919174,
-0.3385380208,
-0.2044672221,
-0.6392253637,
0.1857116818,
-0.0848629028,
0.0723107085,
-0.2258798331,
0.5418241024,
-0.8187608719,
0.3315594792,
0.0877454951,
-0.1666065007,
0.2534997761,
-0.048868876,
0.1042602882,
-1.2687948942,
0.5008164048,
-0.2527678609,
0.1708437651,
-0.6990677118,
0.5083711147,
0.0427146442,
-0.5263029933,
-0.4928714335,
0.2659937739,
-0.2624223828,
0.0206257924,
-0.2006513923,
0.1960751265,
0.0382011645,
0.3709298968,
0.0062444122,
0.4820227027,
0.0878561586,
-0.5586266518,
0.1404906809,
0.2394004166,
-0.3926226795,
0.0008623453,
-1.0259037018,
0.3911488652,
0.1308523118,
-0.0815817863,
-1.1267955303,
-0.0145235313,
-0.081315279,
-0.6673719883,
0.1405998766,
0.0966787636,
-0.5464907885,
-0.4623818696,
-0.5107030869,
0.498401314,
0.6193498373,
-0.1200889796,
0.2336451262,
0.1047622338,
-0.1728806347,
-0.1334638149,
-0.5082784891,
0.0454070717,
-0.2796129584,
-0.5867046118,
0.4856945574,
0.3003769219,
0.0060106474,
0.0129290279,
-0.0074978983,
0.0282756723,
0.3403645754,
0.4007208645,
-0.0072912881,
-0.3902430832,
0.0892148986,
0.0819786191,
-0.0461600348,
0.0297877528,
-0.2483717203,
0.4052670002,
-0.0139813516,
-0.3168108761,
0.0039127599,
0.3485936821,
0.8839480877,
-0.3711678982,
0.6568319798,
0.3720186055,
-0.2535204887,
0.0393109359,
-0.1551482528,
-0.3990071118,
-0.4711445272,
0.4168047607,
-0.4504062831,
-0.457113117,
0.2882868052,
-0.1002352387,
0.2601790726,
0.394908458,
0.6500507593,
0.2866450548,
1.1153782606,
0.2993323803,
0.1910620034,
0.1242943406,
-0.1576821655,
0.4056130052,
-0.6072235703,
-0.2618166208,
-0.57959342,
-0.4446113408,
-0.8259540796,
-0.1777381301,
0.4422158897,
-0.084432289,
-0.0890984088,
0.3054868281,
-0.6876996756,
0.1147406623,
0.8100782037,
-0.1632290781,
-0.1621036083,
0.048224587,
-0.5626051426,
-0.2423351556,
-0.6115635633,
-0.4264656305,
1.5168222189,
0.1943563521,
0.4227925539,
0.0288982987,
0.6885265708,
0.270950973,
-0.0323481597,
-0.7163335681,
0.4761514962,
-0.2605737746,
-0.5668309331,
0.0133539708,
-0.2146811783,
-1.0032851696,
0.2229740918,
-0.2432190031,
-0.2727885544,
-0.1547580659,
-0.2409041375,
-0.4472947419,
-0.062598221,
-0.518125236,
0.9790232778,
-0.2942393422,
-0.1671602428,
0.0442573056,
-0.6897966862,
0.3117335439,
-0.2660661638,
-0.2121687084,
0.1803138107,
-0.0010466023,
0.8848136663,
-0.1990328878,
0.3138342202,
-0.2396395653,
0.1630937308,
0.304605633,
-0.0466430373,
0.3012436628,
-0.2179860473,
-0.3178009689,
-0.0495851785,
-0.0594708286,
0.1966765076,
-0.538351655,
0.4766821265,
-0.4671938717,
-0.3339973688,
-0.0644169822,
-0.2826224864,
-0.0320717618,
0.3215406239,
0.6606867909,
0.4704905748,
-0.2539003789,
0.6458659172,
0.4899984598,
-0.1959310919,
0.3922198713,
0.2131009549,
0.0360816494,
-0.5046138763,
0.8643474579,
0.0402041897,
0.2360230684,
0.4236864448,
0.0874653384,
-0.3744835854,
-0.6470002532,
-0.0543215126,
0.0055759363,
-0.5770231485,
-0.5152854919,
-0.4844191372,
-0.4698914886,
-0.8046317697,
-0.076934725,
-0.2476465553,
-0.6552345157,
-0.1685549617,
-0.0256664287,
0.2427569628,
0.5923153162,
0.2352133393,
0.3701750636,
-0.8277409077,
0.4088432193,
-0.0440721288,
-0.1160039753,
0.1154570207,
-0.5115566254,
-0.1652880758,
-0.0177630074,
-0.7022935152,
-1.1449549198,
0.4639206827,
0.4078217447,
0.3597036898,
0.3730841279,
0.0378286541,
0.1853570044,
-0.7744665146,
0.9752603173,
0.1734060049,
-0.8943122029,
0.6424980164,
-0.0575303361,
0.4062677026,
0.7435762286,
0.1165304258,
-0.4878975153,
-0.6644836068,
-0.7616631389,
-1.0191937685,
0.368195504,
0.6830861568,
0.3721937835,
-0.3151918054,
0.5400415063,
0.1573328674,
0.3990620971,
-0.5401622057,
-0.1374797523,
-0.4876053333,
-0.6604595184,
0.149452731,
-0.0355167277,
0.2741300464,
0.0847098157,
0.4047826529,
0.0150317168,
0.4547398686,
0.0389299616,
-0.144705683,
0.1919056475,
0.3427993059,
0.5444438457,
0.1879729629,
-0.2275941074,
-0.0077735246,
0.0873572156,
-0.5802305341,
0.1595703512,
-0.1972813755,
-0.3276998699,
0.4290126264,
0.3750165403,
0.6426796317,
0.5851820707,
-0.5644942522,
0.8869324327,
-0.1416510344,
-0.3974148333,
-0.1147637963,
0.1813176274,
0.1009975299,
0.0212621875,
0.5093547106,
0.0600995757,
0.251847446,
-0.3631548285,
0.3913624585,
0.5316674709,
-0.1792381704,
-0.5658541322,
0.6873752475,
0.250672847,
-0.4166644514,
0.7560899258,
-0.0404626057,
-0.9500826597,
0.7477660179,
0.5904824138,
1.1313370466,
-0.0334415846,
-0.0023877393,
0.2995165288,
0.3327997029,
0.2023487687,
0.3302434981,
-0.3169969916,
-0.5889502764,
0.0582912304,
-0.6722251177,
-0.0908524171,
0.2895365059,
-0.7481613159,
0.060968183,
-0.3264304399,
-0.5331227183,
0.130535394,
-0.0315425359,
-0.7949703932,
0.2708981037,
-0.0271061733,
0.8913143873,
-0.6768780351,
0.4667882621,
0.5315092206,
-0.5006539822,
-0.6948594451,
0.2035236359,
-0.2883996069,
-0.5943362713,
0.9011816978,
0.3450233638,
0.1046031788,
-0.1015017107,
-0.2330763787,
-0.7106266618,
1.2470234632,
-0.0259405505,
-0.3125987947,
-0.4888345003,
0.3756112754,
0.5099564791,
-0.4263822734,
0.2430683821,
0.451092124,
0.1707773805,
-0.0701052621,
-0.7651106119,
0.0376151688,
-0.4476671219,
0.3653435409,
0.1148903742,
-0.2806273401,
0.8959999084,
0.0156759974,
-0.1689760685,
0.4707371891,
0.5678158998,
0.1819645166,
0.077805452,
0.2165125012,
0.2473428249,
0.4208348989,
0.2068321705,
0.8329369426,
-0.7639328241,
0.2937179506,
1.0318493843,
-0.4026298523,
0.9878094196,
0.4642162919,
0.2420795411,
0.2621046305,
0.3682746589,
-0.1364574581,
0.9375828505,
0.0728808343,
-0.0585563369,
0.0936187357,
0.2145434171,
-0.4418038428,
0.5639486909,
0.2675266266,
-1.0368111134,
-0.3437421918,
0.0913698822,
-0.243443355,
-0.1644184291,
-0.1612562388,
0.8058740497,
0.286931783,
-0.9000957608,
0.3125373125,
0.3819333613,
0.5851687193,
-0.5136017799,
0.0543505587,
-0.1617380977,
0.5014227629,
0.1408057064,
-0.6240172386,
0.0785929412,
0.1760063618,
-0.0760807693,
-0.0673015416,
0.9345613718,
-0.0307037625,
-0.3936001062,
0.0600811429,
0.4349140525,
0.1787746698,
-0.0077426145,
-0.9037925601,
-0.2758188546,
-0.0792555958,
-0.3813141882,
0.1823679358,
0.5466424823,
0.3147932887,
0.2745345533,
0.5188549161,
0.0653480291,
0.1975276619,
0.1239549443,
0.4964858294,
-0.6987891793,
-0.2763103843,
-0.946716249,
0.1524146199,
-0.045974955,
-0.7353253365,
0.9416677952,
0.528598249,
0.2923352718,
-0.2563262582,
0.7153456211,
0.0872300267,
0.4139829576,
-0.5582518578,
0.8679885864,
-0.5494527221,
-0.1249494553,
-0.4735118449,
-1.0086702108,
0.0233238656,
0.5432184935,
-0.0953685343,
0.0839717761,
0.817535162,
0.9069923759,
-0.0821085721,
0.2042836696,
0.1358024925,
-0.0918911919,
0.2401518971,
0.5888376832,
0.6883611083,
-0.7922068834,
0.6396094561,
-0.0132768722,
0.3280062377,
-0.270250082,
-0.6854388118,
-0.7119179964,
-0.6613833308,
-0.0489872023,
-0.3872356415,
0.0601052977,
0.7268449664,
0.36232391,
-0.6734680533,
0.0395582393,
-0.5763146281,
0.0009749144,
0.0743682683,
-0.323895514,
0.410776943,
-0.5678351521,
-0.4452300072,
0.0497160666,
0.0766195506,
-0.0325140022,
-0.1781426072,
-0.0156856813,
0.0515909567,
0.2297755182,
0.3624480963,
-0.0396220535,
-0.5087620616,
-0.0824208483,
0.4871232212,
-0.3789693415,
-0.0912906528,
0.9874631763,
-0.5322839022,
0.0223860517,
0.6303374171,
0.6533303857,
0.3135066628,
-0.2045099586,
0.6258453131,
-0.6259681582,
-0.2391781807,
0.3969291449,
0.074625738,
0.3647998273,
-0.056929484,
0.4079544544,
0.1849358231,
-0.4601487517,
-0.8784558177,
-0.02326365,
-0.4774751961,
-0.315767765,
1.2223520279,
-0.1226140186,
-0.5595113039,
0.0140316729,
0.0632709339,
0.4017385542,
-0.1568778455,
0.5736087561,
0.5285295248,
0.3341521025,
0.2990455627,
-0.2649709582,
0.4188782871,
0.5415402055,
-0.3931360245,
-0.2110530436,
0.0254025832,
0.4928738475,
0.4035922587,
0.3870543838,
-0.2400562614,
0.5765175819,
0.265702486,
-0.0416045971,
0.1060650572,
-0.1026934758,
-0.2021117359,
0.6977678537,
0.0910831541,
-0.3618555069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13875v1 | MasonNLP+ at SemEval-2023 Task 8: Extracting Medical Questions, Experiences and Claims from Social Media using Knowledge-Augmented Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-04-26T23:45:11 | 2023-04-26T23:45:11 | Giridhar Kaushik Ramachandran, Haritha Gangavarapu, Kevin Lybarger, Ozlem Uzuner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In online forums like Reddit, users share their experiences with medical
conditions and treatments, including making claims, asking questions, and
discussing the effects of treatments on their health. Building systems to
understand this information can effectively monitor the spread of
misinformation and verify user claims. The Task-8 of the 2023 International
Workshop on Semantic Evaluation focused on medical applications, specifically
extracting patient experience- and medical condition-related entities from user
posts on social media. The Reddit Health Online Talk (RedHot) corpus contains
posts from medical condition-related subreddits with annotations characterizing
the patient experience and medical conditions. In Subtask-1, patient experience
is characterized by personal experience, questions, and claims. In Subtask-2,
medical conditions are characterized by population, intervention, and outcome.
For the automatic extraction of patient experiences and medical condition
information, as a part of the challenge, we proposed language-model-based
extraction systems that ranked $3^{rd}$ on both subtasks' leaderboards. In this
work, we describe our approach and, in addition, explore the automatic
extraction of this information using domain-specific language models and the
inclusion of external knowledge. | [
-0.2761219144,
-0.8900464773,
0.8567175865,
0.1846012026,
-0.1682956219,
-0.0906581581,
-0.2105723321,
-0.8885368109,
0.5529203415,
0.4658548832,
-0.4491432607,
-0.6340330243,
-1.0163232088,
0.1393567026,
-0.170622021,
0.9379902482,
-0.1333015114,
0.1595666409,
-0.4069544971,
0.1484213769,
-0.4246599972,
-0.4575428069,
-0.580657959,
-0.245758757,
0.4375100136,
0.3727041781,
0.2698790133,
0.1016120091,
0.7959345579,
0.2531729937,
0.2080449611,
0.2829991281,
-0.2122099847,
0.0558606461,
-0.385225296,
0.110021688,
-0.5177258849,
0.0631809756,
0.1675444841,
0.5858091712,
-0.0923836827,
0.2914390266,
-0.017432332,
0.2411648631,
-0.574667871,
0.3126883507,
-0.453042984,
0.0644200817,
0.0168797951,
-0.4855155647,
-0.1407740116,
-0.3631096482,
0.2492497712,
-0.5782659054,
0.0103774993,
-0.2426602542,
1.1667292118,
0.1567362249,
-0.3932714462,
-0.4371983409,
-0.3740085959,
0.645190835,
-0.6607403159,
0.3223027587,
0.7076243162,
0.5523297787,
0.0343137868,
-0.9540873766,
-0.3205469847,
0.1783810854,
-0.4165665507,
0.1068077162,
-0.1938609332,
-0.0556731448,
0.0319450125,
0.2946076691,
-0.424279213,
-0.0667259544,
-0.682631135,
-0.1273009926,
0.7071387768,
0.0049202051,
0.5397899151,
-0.3650730848,
-0.2681997716,
0.408719629,
-0.6809275746,
-0.2396926582,
-0.1120057851,
0.0725904256,
-0.1709545553,
0.6134120822,
-0.2895853221,
0.5573340058,
-0.109478429,
-0.1020533219,
0.3537066281,
-0.3784631491,
-0.1633067578,
-0.2347270399,
0.7658526897,
0.5730176568,
0.0873432159,
-0.2319567055,
-0.120935671,
0.1391008794,
0.3868639767,
-0.6436644793,
-0.3792894483,
0.280824542,
-0.7059270144,
-0.3349625468,
-0.0456324182,
-0.9811938405,
-0.6550633907,
-0.1983278394,
0.6490053535,
-0.3142789006,
-0.479234457,
0.1378270984,
-0.0621406883,
-0.0820759609,
0.5976232886,
-0.6599071026,
0.49168244,
0.7435927391,
0.4734981954,
-0.4508711994,
0.0348653235,
-0.4323187768,
-0.1165238768,
0.057312917,
0.9803693891,
-0.5232796669,
-0.1086740121,
0.130533427,
0.3273497522,
-0.1925278902,
-0.7827959061,
0.3316511214,
-0.4755485952,
0.2971900702,
-0.1791518629,
-0.7076764107,
-0.0319405496,
0.4005329907,
-0.4997197092,
0.7001556158,
0.1755366772,
-0.8016337752,
0.3244466186,
-0.8881224394,
-0.4481555521,
0.3999353945,
-0.462441206,
-0.1334707588,
-0.0209907219,
0.3467575908,
0.662745595,
-0.4734967947,
0.1407318413,
-0.1470337659,
-0.0582988411,
0.0904465839,
0.0590707622,
0.5306955576,
0.3241825998,
-0.2571001947,
0.1967718303,
-0.5915465951,
0.0722250566,
0.3020450771,
-0.3960889876,
-0.5071635246,
-0.0593159124,
-0.1467399448,
0.4013289213,
0.3791413903,
-0.6396613121,
-0.0953677297,
-0.4479884803,
0.3944058716,
0.4528756142,
0.6434094906,
0.1151133329,
-0.2481393963,
0.7165677547,
0.0131579209,
0.3665086627,
-0.0481699817,
-0.4608354568,
-0.4443762898,
-0.2129137218,
0.2787162364,
0.3270414472,
-0.8117778301,
0.1064242572,
-0.3649223447,
-0.4560986161,
-0.7215133309,
-0.0131521393,
0.2311765552,
0.635629952,
0.6496803761,
-0.0179175679,
-0.6291265488,
-0.8429127336,
-0.3392282128,
-0.1178934202,
0.0951487646,
0.3652636111,
0.4685645103,
-0.3924910426,
0.6584832072,
-0.6416829228,
-0.2673428059,
-0.4729021192,
0.2455292046,
-0.0691415891,
0.4313150048,
0.2295241654,
-0.8514214754,
-0.3146695495,
0.129463464,
-0.9074482322,
-0.2894589603,
0.1076528579,
-0.1343852878,
0.1486029625,
0.3907305002,
-0.514048636,
0.444401145,
0.5536652207,
-0.4614666998,
0.412484467,
-0.0484253466,
0.4803761244,
-1.1743869781,
0.0294854082,
0.1257700622,
-0.4303192794,
-0.3673768044,
0.0929730162,
-0.074003011,
-0.1010512486,
-0.571969986,
0.6400521398,
-0.334688127,
-0.1293907166,
-0.139283821,
0.1140716746,
-0.0328264982,
0.2627471387,
0.3377872407,
0.2232621908,
0.3463668823,
-0.4850508273,
0.1904701144,
-0.000145645,
-0.4984086454,
0.3432996571,
-0.5858246684,
0.0205524452,
0.0977152362,
-0.1538349241,
-0.6240014434,
-0.274451226,
0.2305350304,
-0.7455657721,
-0.1325523406,
-0.1672932357,
-0.4046771526,
-0.2130462676,
0.0681179687,
0.2410990894,
0.3554424047,
-0.2381931543,
0.5897442698,
1.1522318125,
-0.4993971586,
-0.3152044713,
-0.4171723723,
-0.0220508985,
-0.1803935915,
-0.4397058189,
0.2506858408,
0.2130783498,
-0.4157204032,
0.3144928813,
0.0879361331,
-0.3904154301,
0.120684132,
0.3691584766,
0.3166863024,
-0.0094292881,
0.1895486116,
0.1018271744,
-0.0936266258,
0.2615112364,
0.0732116178,
0.513934195,
-0.0719889924,
-0.449714452,
-0.4737661481,
0.7135985494,
0.3624908328,
-0.2630251348,
0.5522115231,
0.2655543387,
-0.9355673194,
0.1157149747,
-0.7246986032,
-0.3660852909,
-0.3707869649,
0.3608018458,
-0.2355658859,
-1.0445797443,
0.3817583025,
-0.22340855,
0.2584626377,
0.6653921604,
0.6375125051,
-0.2192584127,
1.0768742561,
0.5651015639,
0.4286943972,
0.138299346,
-0.0514530949,
0.0570840649,
-0.3783188164,
-0.2866223454,
-0.3478097618,
0.0362023376,
-0.3618682921,
-0.3960648775,
0.4306900203,
-0.136087805,
0.1437908709,
0.4529025853,
-0.2909699976,
0.0356242657,
0.2083780617,
0.2322472036,
0.292519629,
-0.0790398121,
-0.0152307153,
-0.307149291,
-0.6204069853,
-0.3742752969,
0.7412563562,
0.5960046649,
0.6325032115,
-0.0604840815,
0.9055833817,
0.4369616508,
0.4530451596,
-0.6482284665,
0.4533093572,
-0.0376265272,
-0.4856711328,
-0.0516970083,
-0.4669949114,
-0.8339778781,
0.1784787923,
-0.4193207026,
-0.5755617619,
0.1533144414,
0.1423627287,
-0.6247782111,
-0.1530092955,
-0.7421616316,
1.0937305689,
-0.1452989727,
-0.0135874506,
-0.264724046,
-0.7142506242,
0.1654382199,
-0.0896054357,
0.4990385771,
-0.1331513524,
0.248054564,
0.8576171994,
-0.3865630925,
0.660174191,
-0.3590539694,
0.0665533468,
0.2032654881,
0.0346098281,
0.3021070361,
0.0698881522,
0.2766983807,
0.1510611176,
0.4901405573,
-0.0980388597,
-0.6767135262,
0.6056130528,
-0.5844262838,
-0.3781683445,
-0.2956570089,
-0.0997405872,
-0.4387716055,
0.1399210989,
0.1298451424,
0.3511141241,
-0.1369010955,
0.0333271362,
0.2964663506,
-0.499913156,
0.04873164,
0.6371404529,
-0.3786815405,
-0.3395790458,
0.7412006259,
0.0820265412,
0.1476636529,
0.282273531,
0.2552092671,
-0.3080218732,
-0.443789959,
-0.080299668,
0.4105059505,
-0.8547119498,
-0.2236184627,
-0.9363789558,
-0.4246296585,
-0.7733818889,
0.1048384458,
-0.4124366939,
-0.6074336767,
-0.2592282593,
-0.2447265238,
0.0909666941,
0.7945426106,
-0.1007006094,
-0.0446625017,
-1.1235872507,
0.3571204245,
0.1906463057,
0.0190026369,
-0.2647382617,
-0.3952235281,
-0.5191911459,
-0.3262172043,
0.0708895847,
-0.8883233666,
0.4725025892,
-0.0734440386,
0.6476582289,
0.2123576105,
-0.0183734354,
0.7983887792,
-0.491271317,
0.7184486389,
0.1915726066,
-0.4455150366,
0.8585050702,
-0.1167231053,
0.0912578702,
0.8380640745,
0.692232728,
-0.7892951369,
-0.3735353649,
-0.7263057232,
-0.8149806261,
0.3926718831,
-0.0633753985,
-0.1414975077,
-0.4065337479,
0.3624109924,
0.1399912089,
-0.0210712254,
-0.6891195774,
-0.0011015179,
0.0502083302,
-0.4609427452,
0.3616227508,
-0.5080431104,
-0.2898095548,
-0.0897308215,
0.6999335289,
-0.0127096241,
0.3896808028,
0.3453227282,
-0.3743882179,
-0.0250867065,
0.2466632724,
0.4741265178,
1.0054886341,
-0.0642916262,
0.4179005623,
-0.0723707154,
-0.3253521621,
-0.4023085535,
0.274984628,
0.1791469753,
-0.0419377647,
0.516025722,
0.3813263476,
0.1919985265,
-0.871543467,
0.8314778209,
-0.4121225774,
-0.0973204374,
-0.5369396806,
-0.1771372557,
0.0606130362,
0.2628255785,
0.1698109955,
-0.0843757913,
0.3283240199,
-0.3654715121,
0.5150260925,
0.1888639778,
-0.6512825489,
-0.4905788302,
0.4558841288,
0.3869702518,
-0.1837631464,
0.1707827151,
0.0325494036,
-0.2649907768,
0.2484618127,
0.4232939482,
0.5163189769,
-0.0967403948,
0.1672781259,
0.4928114414,
0.0599535406,
-0.0204353835,
0.50437361,
0.0626585111,
-0.6072887182,
-0.5741350055,
-0.5789777637,
-0.0438013598,
0.2552433908,
-0.6262899041,
0.4535885453,
-0.2866950035,
-0.2493254691,
0.1636691391,
-0.047016155,
-0.6086816192,
0.3593962193,
0.0257238336,
0.7923564315,
-0.8941432834,
0.728469789,
0.8532652259,
-0.3896529377,
-0.6850691438,
-0.3047603369,
0.0775335655,
-0.7448174953,
0.6514692307,
0.044924695,
-0.0126670087,
-0.1941014975,
-0.3639110923,
-0.577912271,
0.8810648918,
0.204349786,
-0.2742345333,
-0.1470721513,
-0.0031731466,
0.4640386701,
-0.633800745,
0.1014704481,
0.3933178484,
0.1680619568,
0.010429862,
-1.0114631653,
0.0622959398,
-0.4779980183,
-0.3769018948,
0.0041574645,
-0.0362948477,
0.6197601557,
-0.2182951272,
-0.4315794706,
-0.2067838609,
0.4869594574,
0.2424911112,
0.0937593505,
0.5439165831,
0.5182315111,
0.6117517352,
0.0962330848,
1.2045593262,
-0.3965030015,
0.4248999953,
1.3018037081,
-0.0807199702,
0.7631821036,
0.5190218687,
0.1044497192,
0.4616410732,
0.8677083254,
0.4407722354,
0.71466887,
-0.1011936963,
-0.3237174451,
-0.4370951056,
-0.2423104048,
-0.5236339569,
0.4208474755,
0.4986001849,
-0.7490973473,
-0.2902636826,
-0.0229572151,
0.1385698318,
-0.0308728665,
-0.0652659833,
1.1188292503,
0.1297013611,
-0.7801960111,
0.2804991901,
0.1160385162,
0.3737719953,
-0.4862557948,
-0.4828084707,
0.0590645485,
-0.0086755175,
-0.2741085589,
-0.5630643368,
0.5556406975,
0.0411237404,
-0.0464923978,
-0.2302531451,
1.2534456253,
-0.4284745455,
-0.4858131111,
0.3202353716,
0.7574168444,
0.4865554869,
-0.1131776273,
-0.7726140618,
0.0613186061,
-0.2347389311,
-0.1051933318,
0.3123677671,
0.4163816869,
0.0050983713,
0.3893871009,
0.43849352,
0.4833948612,
-0.1495637894,
0.267901361,
0.8134500384,
-0.4524839222,
-0.4618673623,
-0.742266953,
0.4312638938,
-0.3049358726,
-0.2196791023,
0.4896611571,
0.3109879196,
0.518317163,
0.0878964588,
0.8764888644,
-0.2463266402,
1.1027084589,
-0.4348532259,
0.8773944378,
-0.8081508279,
0.1440475881,
-0.3031069338,
-0.274684757,
-0.2095302492,
0.6813697815,
-0.4848068953,
-0.1332152039,
0.8944533467,
0.6151910424,
0.1895106882,
-0.009989081,
0.2304390371,
0.1023336947,
0.3724452257,
0.4678326249,
0.8695598841,
-0.3709295392,
0.2109373063,
-0.1439810693,
-0.2496710122,
-0.1083378196,
-0.6667845845,
-0.685857892,
-0.7041682601,
-0.4375181794,
-0.2917793095,
0.1485891938,
1.2001202106,
0.7513433099,
-0.7448820472,
0.1307931244,
0.1752931625,
0.1589005142,
-0.1037008017,
-0.3087313771,
0.3328504562,
-0.1636977941,
-0.4288778603,
0.4532665312,
0.3205599189,
-0.1345421523,
-0.1070395485,
0.0263035353,
-0.4083541036,
-0.2260352969,
0.6220614314,
0.1889277399,
-0.4207294583,
-0.3981333077,
0.0581722073,
-0.1576680392,
0.1210805625,
0.7959569693,
-0.6884852648,
0.350142628,
0.4346009791,
0.8717390895,
0.3709076047,
0.2183218896,
0.5319891572,
-0.4267565608,
-0.3287830651,
0.4341552556,
0.315474093,
0.3202894628,
-0.3988117874,
0.5229766369,
0.4454701841,
-0.4706894755,
-0.6068130136,
-0.0156888328,
-0.6698366404,
-0.493594557,
1.3275961876,
-0.3855932355,
-0.1918848157,
-0.3511175513,
-0.0253387615,
0.1561175734,
-0.1619171053,
0.9232293367,
0.7214294076,
-0.4427092075,
-0.302713424,
-0.9986855984,
0.6954692006,
0.1515295953,
-1.2461454868,
-0.1850041598,
0.4634448588,
0.5157807469,
0.1081391722,
1.1970733404,
-0.6747692823,
0.360057503,
-0.386883229,
0.1177145913,
0.0781070068,
-0.3488306999,
-0.0961231291,
0.4181132615,
-0.130743295,
-0.1132583097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13867v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13867v3 | Transferring Procedural Knowledge across Commonsense Tasks | 2023-04-26T23:24:50 | 2023-11-20T04:09:25 | Yifan Jiang, Filip Ilievski, Kaixin Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stories about everyday situations are an essential part of human
communication, motivating the need to develop AI agents that can reliably
understand these stories. Despite the long list of supervised methods for story
completion and procedural understanding, current AI has no mechanisms to
automatically track and explain procedures in unseen stories. To bridge this
gap, we study the ability of AI models to transfer procedural knowledge to
novel narrative tasks in a transparent manner. We design LEAP: a comprehensive
framework that integrates state-of-the-art modeling architectures, training
regimes, and augmentation strategies based on both natural and synthetic
stories. To address the lack of densely annotated training data, we devise a
robust automatic labeler based on few-shot prompting to enhance the augmented
data. Our experiments with in- and out-of-domain tasks reveal insights into the
interplay of different architectures, training regimes, and augmentation
strategies. LEAP's labeler has a clear positive impact on out-of-domain
datasets, while the resulting dense annotation provides native explainability. | [
-0.1122214198,
-0.662152648,
0.6011490822,
0.1614509821,
0.0741805211,
0.1023496911,
0.1839289069,
-0.7297293544,
-0.1446861178,
0.4268750846,
-0.5866842866,
-0.4086676836,
-0.5792913437,
-0.0967459828,
-0.3107380867,
1.2421107292,
-0.1490135491,
-0.569627285,
-0.39976722,
0.0070022247,
-0.3708072603,
-0.1929196566,
-0.3898344636,
-0.4851413965,
0.3219624758,
0.3436342478,
0.713807106,
0.8642925024,
0.1590081155,
0.2627645433,
0.0940951928,
0.5148630738,
-0.4153408706,
-0.0092331721,
-0.1401417851,
-0.5998583436,
-0.3097016513,
-0.0969521478,
0.3636099398,
0.8514463305,
0.2270716578,
-0.0036536825,
0.1388153583,
0.5104781389,
-0.5036138296,
0.587195456,
-0.1118953153,
0.1681656241,
0.0760701671,
-0.1253660023,
-0.2986899316,
-0.3483930826,
0.2913202643,
-1.3217184544,
0.3167282939,
-0.1440418959,
0.6821575165,
0.2403491586,
-0.5151865482,
-0.380833298,
-0.7508187294,
0.3976674378,
-0.3477232456,
0.0731237307,
0.5297589302,
0.2403089255,
0.1414684504,
-0.7152332067,
-0.6615888476,
-0.5181826353,
-0.2394344658,
-0.0414575115,
-0.0970137864,
0.1041955203,
0.0808244646,
0.1390074193,
-0.2766177058,
0.0935884565,
-0.4358488321,
-0.2933496535,
0.7255965471,
0.4431663752,
0.4349723458,
0.0495415404,
-0.520614326,
-0.2514909804,
-0.3799138665,
0.3255470097,
0.1062745526,
0.2783068419,
-0.4343829155,
0.4396449029,
-0.1997196078,
0.9895787835,
0.2041555792,
-0.2187989354,
0.2079813629,
-0.5074721575,
-0.0629527047,
-0.0983486846,
0.5141980648,
0.3725310266,
0.1998633891,
-0.2642925382,
-0.0838091671,
-0.1756908,
0.4180742204,
-0.5979377031,
-0.1700972468,
-0.0184513498,
-0.086012654,
-0.3223401606,
-0.1755134463,
-0.5717104077,
-0.9165249467,
-0.512958765,
0.3582184017,
-0.6419155002,
-0.0757882744,
0.0812770501,
-0.4172703326,
0.0136372149,
0.8848454952,
-1.0015015602,
0.2099608332,
1.0140908957,
0.9795415998,
-0.3471612334,
-0.343889147,
-0.5539969802,
0.4255135059,
-0.4406823516,
0.8187685013,
-0.461270839,
-0.3033771813,
0.1728410721,
-0.0775614157,
-0.4508562088,
-0.3103379905,
0.2565300465,
-0.270480752,
-0.1338631362,
0.1958725452,
-0.6333886981,
-0.378803432,
0.5215560794,
-0.4717437327,
0.6194967031,
0.1379619539,
-0.3013764918,
0.3115261793,
-0.8957872987,
-0.5722950697,
0.2252324522,
-0.0619748458,
0.087499477,
0.0546565466,
0.3198587596,
0.2574842572,
0.2115166932,
0.014994774,
0.190817371,
-0.2745008171,
0.164235726,
-0.6084064841,
0.8640573025,
0.1577102393,
-0.0452988632,
0.0187121946,
-0.6427859664,
-0.2851401269,
-0.2625977099,
-0.1801484972,
-0.2315331995,
-0.5548154116,
-0.1071427688,
-0.0092527997,
0.1505925804,
-0.3257303238,
0.6022850275,
-0.448880136,
0.4524095953,
0.4212881029,
0.3619372547,
0.9872497916,
-0.7577434182,
0.8451818824,
0.1703827083,
0.0498523302,
-0.8038901687,
-0.7278952003,
-0.5632129908,
-0.3431366682,
-0.1209952831,
0.6489165425,
-0.8158653975,
0.0127623174,
-0.3737210035,
-0.4920325577,
-0.5701647997,
0.1152863204,
0.2838430405,
0.8736300468,
0.3144133985,
-0.2427612543,
-0.0220664293,
-0.5037383437,
-0.3729609549,
-0.5069638491,
-0.1180561259,
0.3288722634,
0.4553529322,
-0.1634754241,
1.1543200016,
-0.3176192939,
-0.4219475389,
-0.2749583125,
0.7363251448,
0.0997326821,
0.6374835968,
0.0525533445,
-0.7469914556,
-0.3058590889,
0.2381498069,
-0.7319476604,
0.1526619941,
-0.9016140103,
0.1341950297,
0.0778840333,
0.2808217108,
-1.1180849075,
0.706122458,
0.0781805217,
-0.1861318052,
0.5389365554,
-0.3296148479,
0.3096587062,
-0.6522120833,
-0.2130766809,
0.019367544,
-0.2123530656,
-0.7900417447,
-0.000501953,
-0.0364047997,
-0.0050779097,
-0.7020311356,
1.0655289888,
-0.4651142359,
0.2159576565,
-0.0199825782,
-0.0224901214,
0.2839299142,
0.7317137718,
0.2856821716,
0.5386722088,
0.5941547155,
-0.7810631394,
0.2733025849,
0.6708678007,
-0.2569096982,
0.6708650589,
-0.2713284791,
0.2777993381,
-0.08119452,
0.4981147647,
-0.8299422264,
-0.2922713757,
0.4398451149,
-0.7205051184,
0.1737107933,
-0.8141388893,
-0.3729643226,
-0.1565672606,
0.0260313991,
0.2549608648,
0.4471558928,
-0.4950658977,
0.7010045052,
0.130617857,
-0.1672893614,
-0.2349974215,
-0.880118072,
0.2086840719,
-0.3730504513,
-0.6277219057,
0.2014073431,
-0.0060923067,
-0.2743434608,
-0.1608186364,
-0.2399880141,
-0.7457116246,
-0.1845984608,
0.4427452385,
0.3208218813,
-0.2484102398,
0.2385439724,
0.0120363319,
-0.117083855,
0.1434541941,
-0.3831574023,
-0.1986808926,
-0.1260042936,
-0.5984646678,
-0.5633109212,
0.113152653,
0.5663388968,
-0.0343903042,
0.6138057113,
0.4685899913,
-0.2421749681,
-0.293708533,
-0.1632356495,
-0.1182112619,
-0.4364408255,
0.1827295721,
-0.3906116188,
-0.7338376045,
0.145622924,
-0.2000038922,
0.4059709013,
0.21939224,
0.1782738715,
-0.3946441412,
0.6354082227,
0.7717613578,
0.1090187877,
0.3145536184,
-0.3207378685,
0.1529417336,
-0.4296583831,
-0.272669822,
-0.1730494499,
-0.0500331186,
-0.1476017386,
-0.8126941323,
0.3163357973,
0.1106239781,
-0.2244918942,
0.3346055448,
-0.4367968738,
0.6434341073,
0.4656422436,
-0.1479609162,
0.6702451706,
-0.0070386552,
0.3905628324,
0.0487175249,
-0.7949065566,
-0.5875958204,
0.7223349214,
0.470882833,
0.7508073449,
-0.187431708,
0.8014128208,
0.643953681,
0.1911566108,
-0.8931992054,
0.3891609013,
0.200473398,
-0.4827262163,
-0.5889455676,
-0.0335015133,
-1.0990353823,
0.2028694898,
-0.0799209177,
-0.786036849,
0.4215221703,
0.1494996548,
-0.7904199958,
0.1387205422,
-0.7338584661,
0.7501924634,
-0.2332378328,
-0.4039087296,
-0.0755239651,
-0.7885953188,
0.4906139374,
0.0785463005,
0.2252424955,
-0.0016590698,
-0.2418715954,
0.469330579,
-0.4639037848,
1.3131465912,
-0.0708869919,
-0.1347848773,
0.618393302,
0.4580123723,
0.6016783714,
0.09896826,
0.1021588519,
0.1795722544,
-0.2249958217,
-0.1998522133,
-0.8746966124,
0.3637777865,
-0.5521862507,
-0.6052315831,
-0.4121066928,
-0.9762644768,
-0.3699647486,
0.0555609688,
-0.0779057816,
0.316026181,
-0.1798879206,
-0.2556473315,
0.6602929235,
0.0750242323,
0.4730769992,
0.6238920093,
0.3995127976,
0.2090905011,
1.0231389999,
-0.1084000543,
0.1611535996,
0.5305240154,
0.0009000963,
-0.4113075435,
-0.5676391125,
-0.7750214338,
-0.0335174724,
-0.6534311771,
-0.136501357,
-0.7763973475,
-0.5423430204,
-0.3446695805,
-0.6312915683,
-0.2465213686,
-0.6615205407,
-0.5246119499,
-0.3937846124,
0.5242158175,
0.8532088399,
-0.3564013243,
0.197549656,
-1.1192773581,
0.5794879794,
0.4390007854,
-0.1286579072,
-0.0010574416,
-0.7627669573,
-0.2902112901,
0.289370209,
-0.2745375335,
-0.6765143871,
0.5971964598,
0.1981753111,
0.5038999319,
0.4194942117,
0.2622425258,
0.8749762177,
-0.385494411,
0.818459928,
0.2651501,
-0.7723284364,
0.5678026676,
-0.6171959639,
0.3448019922,
0.4994932711,
0.422016263,
-0.4718622565,
-0.4291850626,
-0.734483242,
-0.8153406978,
0.8368428349,
0.3683156371,
0.3193408549,
0.2125810832,
0.0754077956,
0.4092583954,
0.1116998866,
-0.3989827037,
0.1020748094,
-0.2178420275,
-0.0477092378,
0.0007090002,
0.3838764131,
-0.4172621965,
-0.2254186422,
0.3235700428,
-0.1635543853,
0.0785094947,
0.1710349768,
-0.6356633306,
0.1198301539,
0.1707879007,
0.4751960933,
0.7936996818,
0.173617959,
0.0993641913,
0.0954161808,
-0.4437154233,
0.1767461896,
0.373331815,
-0.1518701911,
-0.1407779157,
0.8761708736,
0.9613432288,
0.0180296581,
-0.7299616933,
0.5459653139,
0.3720803857,
-0.2359105796,
0.050725244,
0.4000984132,
0.1166513935,
0.3488769233,
0.2451710254,
0.3836248815,
0.3077136576,
-0.5322057605,
0.3465529382,
0.0162218679,
-0.4337773323,
-0.3630226254,
0.4797394574,
0.4280605316,
-0.5483680964,
0.7789518833,
-0.0636355281,
-0.0774836987,
0.9829007387,
0.4105011523,
0.6311159134,
0.1205453947,
0.830176115,
0.2080275118,
0.312256068,
-0.0608039908,
-0.5150432587,
-0.6878123879,
-0.601770103,
-0.3275689483,
-0.3046237528,
-0.6208892465,
-0.0391808338,
-0.5567013025,
-0.1496055126,
-0.1607744694,
0.3400565684,
-0.0519361123,
-0.2287877649,
-0.7245694995,
0.1640063375,
0.4802076817,
0.8963797688,
-0.925838232,
0.5817809701,
0.5793147683,
-0.6850474477,
-0.5226463079,
0.0021739751,
0.1868035793,
-1.1437731981,
0.5247486234,
0.1756936312,
-0.0386890359,
-0.1806001663,
-0.4058208764,
-0.5635040998,
1.0208795071,
0.2638099492,
-0.4899328053,
-0.2187183052,
0.4266692102,
0.8160696626,
-0.5324491858,
0.3663591444,
0.6154925227,
0.6001297832,
0.5010618567,
-0.9276522994,
-0.2473507524,
-0.2451622784,
-0.2324750274,
-0.3819767535,
-0.3672515452,
0.4946393967,
-0.6585947275,
-0.1866128296,
0.1633994132,
0.7401568294,
0.5127013326,
0.8118950725,
0.444218874,
0.3088660836,
0.9107983112,
0.3046265244,
1.0046161413,
-0.0449766554,
-0.2965879738,
1.3948420286,
-0.0496383123,
0.4177471995,
0.2210450023,
0.0537685752,
0.5615265965,
0.6313854456,
0.0659614503,
0.2996739447,
0.2834734917,
-0.272459954,
-0.3195121884,
-0.331827879,
-0.1705332547,
0.3051160276,
0.3747468591,
-0.0507527441,
-0.2380340546,
0.1705921292,
-0.165533185,
0.0332997628,
-0.4185285866,
0.9377887845,
0.0057592518,
-0.9376299381,
0.4596380591,
-0.4916677475,
0.3351580799,
-0.6058989763,
-0.5212497711,
-0.4852725267,
-0.0804199502,
-0.091680415,
-1.0693353415,
0.2746775746,
0.0002238267,
-0.0521320738,
-0.7947499156,
0.7135016322,
-0.4990170896,
-0.2977066934,
-0.3636811972,
0.8168992996,
0.3841255605,
-0.0683578476,
-0.6701349616,
-0.3336756229,
-0.0994435698,
-0.0798354298,
0.3181267679,
0.7186240554,
-0.3960622847,
0.9116212726,
0.5388538837,
-0.1430294663,
0.1539517194,
0.0320673697,
0.7719572186,
-0.5750160813,
-0.955601573,
-0.385468483,
0.8667291999,
-0.0038077212,
-0.2651818991,
0.7566274405,
0.4618020058,
0.4150964916,
-0.2591667771,
0.8733293414,
0.155064851,
0.1858010888,
-0.3377137482,
0.7126006484,
-0.2226809561,
0.25063622,
0.1923809797,
-0.5257052183,
0.0496424064,
0.5155540705,
0.023376327,
-0.1720707864,
0.5229344368,
0.6239862442,
-0.1727459878,
0.0685982108,
0.2918355465,
0.263628453,
0.1974146217,
0.7156675458,
1.142862916,
-0.0601882003,
0.5948826075,
-0.09956792,
-0.2729983032,
0.0488774106,
-0.8591287732,
-0.9122194648,
-0.6571190357,
-0.6864844561,
-0.0359147713,
0.3671451509,
0.3882692754,
1.195240736,
-0.5005409122,
-0.178756997,
-0.4592494071,
0.2555574477,
-0.4894362092,
-0.2746011019,
0.1221775934,
-0.5290946364,
-0.7065109611,
0.8340616822,
0.1890592128,
0.129069522,
-0.0572508574,
-0.1576035321,
0.0164008383,
0.2430041134,
0.2911036909,
0.7768350244,
-0.5799017549,
0.0601636842,
-0.2477797568,
-0.0327976048,
0.1554192007,
0.9457691312,
-1.1447501183,
0.5685844421,
0.4351255298,
0.865829289,
0.8159825206,
0.1292280704,
0.6341756582,
-0.7109975815,
0.0431268737,
0.5186434388,
-0.189683184,
0.2141735703,
-0.6893982887,
0.6158288717,
0.141615212,
-0.1811883599,
-0.5662414432,
0.0374922045,
-0.9990617037,
-0.2146281749,
1.2462757826,
-0.4701265991,
-0.1339915544,
-0.667583704,
-0.2009992152,
0.0983241275,
-0.4734811187,
0.7333972454,
0.5668162704,
-0.6495400071,
-0.3218057156,
-0.5079627633,
0.7090790272,
0.1023442522,
-1.0313382149,
0.2621876001,
0.6726867557,
0.0656696633,
0.2637013197,
0.8404577374,
0.2463983446,
0.3815220892,
0.2781416178,
-0.3130161762,
-0.7212812901,
-0.5508166552,
-0.3277161419,
0.1405794322,
-0.4341825247,
-0.3727942109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13861v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13861v2 | The Parrot Dilemma: Human-Labeled vs. LLM-augmented Data in Classification Tasks | 2023-04-26T23:09:02 | 2024-02-05T14:41:35 | Anders Giovanni Møller, Jacob Aarup Dalsgaard, Arianna Pera, Luca Maria Aiello | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, physics.soc-ph | In the realm of Computational Social Science (CSS), practitioners often
navigate complex, low-resource domains and face the costly and time-intensive
challenges of acquiring and annotating data. We aim to establish a set of
guidelines to address such challenges, comparing the use of human-labeled data
with synthetically generated data from GPT-4 and Llama-2 in ten distinct CSS
classification tasks of varying complexity. Additionally, we examine the impact
of training data sizes on performance. Our findings reveal that models trained
on human-labeled data consistently exhibit superior or comparable performance
compared to their synthetically augmented counterparts. Nevertheless, synthetic
augmentation proves beneficial, particularly in improving performance on rare
classes within multi-class tasks. Furthermore, we leverage GPT-4 and Llama-2
for zero-shot classification and find that, while they generally display strong
performance, they often fall short when compared to specialized classifiers
trained on moderately sized training sets. | [
-0.2950438261,
-0.5755113959,
0.146986872,
0.2568562627,
-0.0495293774,
0.7618597746,
-0.2978298366,
-0.9507293701,
0.0201811884,
-0.0234136861,
-0.2950637341,
0.1033193544,
-0.7414039969,
0.4560096264,
-0.2643723786,
0.8853429556,
0.294752568,
-0.0864492357,
-0.404469341,
0.0807069913,
-0.3255594969,
-1.0772048235,
-0.6234240532,
-0.4636418223,
0.855381012,
0.5098749995,
0.8807145953,
0.6282934546,
0.4236468971,
0.3935532868,
-0.2276246846,
0.5329837203,
-0.4619158804,
-0.2397074401,
-0.1973252892,
-0.339081496,
-0.2858940959,
0.4897701144,
0.2495153099,
0.7706254721,
0.1004036814,
0.2473989576,
0.2019111365,
0.5378710032,
-0.8119463325,
0.2340487093,
-0.374589026,
0.3889348209,
-0.4089065492,
-0.2869448066,
-0.101675503,
-0.1181668192,
0.2157140225,
-1.0564547777,
0.4536546767,
-0.0174773559,
0.6305623055,
0.1828466952,
-0.4893093705,
-0.0403731465,
-0.6775163412,
0.9823631644,
-0.1072052717,
0.0875665769,
0.6423915625,
0.5064767599,
-0.203194201,
-0.7287793159,
-0.5540242195,
0.0199329779,
0.1606228054,
-0.0458553135,
-0.1095477045,
0.0603097416,
0.3064813614,
0.2652795911,
-0.3309525549,
0.1554141045,
-0.7940052748,
-0.4641443491,
1.0686317682,
0.1348757297,
0.0882107094,
-0.2399038225,
-0.0745323151,
-0.2066449225,
-0.5616389513,
0.1690439582,
0.3781105578,
0.5027945042,
-0.0617217757,
0.7394974232,
-0.4786474705,
0.6184031963,
0.286452204,
-0.0098463474,
0.4145009816,
-0.3359225988,
-0.1100261733,
0.2092262954,
0.6402615905,
0.2085051388,
0.3487503231,
-0.1696877331,
0.0968909413,
0.4052363336,
0.367690742,
-0.4742974639,
-0.2844054699,
0.0199607853,
-0.0352803953,
-0.8681429029,
-0.150870353,
-0.3223954737,
-0.6755109429,
-0.6553798318,
0.2648735046,
0.0616893768,
-0.0444235615,
0.0234073848,
-0.3027149141,
0.2978824675,
0.7036443949,
-0.9363831282,
0.152523607,
0.8660854101,
0.8068062067,
-0.104602851,
-0.096192129,
-0.4604766667,
0.2023531348,
-0.784316361,
0.7712117434,
-0.6396946907,
-0.5138396025,
-0.1759279072,
0.1322932243,
0.0976976752,
-0.4447169006,
0.4238500297,
-0.137436375,
0.0249933098,
-0.7778172493,
-0.4548541605,
-0.1000807285,
0.4468230605,
-0.3449565172,
1.0168228149,
0.1860260814,
-0.7471554279,
0.3980845511,
-0.4346067011,
-0.4993177652,
0.2527949512,
-0.5383508801,
-0.3134329319,
-0.199758485,
-0.0331822708,
0.6185851097,
-0.341930598,
0.0944855958,
-0.6100420356,
-0.7167778015,
0.2944541574,
-0.3211177588,
0.7522538304,
0.3256741166,
-0.0852600783,
-0.0720354244,
-0.7340323925,
-0.0518178493,
0.1574779898,
-0.6728559136,
-0.0117581747,
0.2407497913,
-0.0109014688,
0.0521595441,
0.1314692944,
-0.7634996176,
0.3453081548,
0.0253919419,
0.8480591774,
0.9410544038,
-0.2659835219,
0.4230620861,
-0.5173780918,
0.4551500678,
-0.2155489624,
0.2894353867,
0.3931742609,
-0.688942194,
-0.5658935905,
-0.0969826579,
0.2626784742,
0.5407384634,
-0.8917303681,
0.1775886267,
-0.0240924694,
-0.7547895908,
-0.2807179987,
0.0084057664,
0.2102499455,
0.4478311837,
0.3246641159,
-0.1231389344,
-0.5898550153,
-0.8722887039,
-0.2133064121,
-0.1902316064,
0.0069123446,
0.4948389828,
0.3228684664,
-0.3587501049,
0.9096405506,
-0.337942034,
-0.235690251,
-0.0766749978,
0.4231665432,
-0.2650099099,
0.5896667838,
0.4546235502,
-0.6583366394,
-0.2460671514,
0.162497282,
-0.9176614285,
0.013760305,
-0.0998246819,
0.0329253525,
0.1715558022,
0.1051400527,
-0.364066273,
0.6371609569,
0.0925867334,
0.1648353487,
0.6387505531,
-0.07082849,
0.24382478,
-0.3260405958,
-0.1657322049,
0.1607886553,
-0.1680411696,
-0.779458344,
-0.2808028162,
0.1696770489,
-0.2522763908,
-0.632589519,
0.1504829228,
-0.2576082051,
-0.2297139168,
-0.0327686593,
-0.1919809133,
-0.0640530437,
0.5552364588,
0.2151039839,
1.155672431,
0.3375176191,
-0.5015140176,
0.4640526772,
0.3337583542,
-0.2030784637,
0.4491650164,
-0.7451376319,
0.5711513758,
-0.0173678175,
0.480492115,
-0.6893174052,
-0.5285585523,
0.352153182,
-0.5602630973,
0.3348812461,
0.0141750555,
-0.646507144,
-0.5420728326,
-0.6535592675,
0.7337409258,
0.4081686735,
-0.5093741417,
0.1564197838,
0.4060685933,
0.018658448,
-0.8021155,
-0.7966601253,
0.1798033118,
-0.237483561,
-0.4426155388,
0.3627366722,
0.1694437116,
0.029846346,
-0.271230787,
-0.0300956704,
0.0419211276,
0.0986878276,
0.3056367338,
0.0368441194,
0.0971944183,
0.1373900622,
-0.0530235507,
0.0084642349,
-0.0997506082,
0.1540538669,
0.0970826745,
-0.2305173278,
-0.3336154819,
-0.5160069466,
0.0903367847,
0.3058956265,
-0.0326592065,
0.3566294312,
0.5227336287,
-0.2227470279,
0.1284664869,
-0.5518304706,
0.1087925285,
-0.5542303324,
0.0923166126,
-0.2294635922,
-0.6536014676,
0.2523861825,
-0.0581114292,
-0.1278420389,
0.2766120434,
0.2695813775,
-0.4216681421,
1.165915966,
0.4241188467,
-0.2368965,
0.4381486177,
-0.4151436985,
-0.1635980904,
-0.8604729772,
-0.4032518864,
-0.4352617264,
-0.3776038885,
-0.6096880436,
-0.5732710958,
0.6052258611,
0.0434901156,
-0.6937286258,
0.0985151827,
-1.0979993343,
0.5694862604,
0.53963238,
0.340370357,
0.0884189531,
0.2081181705,
0.6158854365,
0.1557989568,
-0.8352389336,
-0.4122628272,
1.4212471247,
0.1038870588,
0.4849274755,
-0.0147794476,
0.5438712835,
0.6237857342,
0.0916203856,
-0.7430334687,
0.4837412238,
-0.1958389431,
-0.5189353824,
-0.2630265057,
-0.2290214747,
-1.2579529285,
0.4287192523,
-0.3571071029,
-0.4212000668,
0.5291927457,
0.2500997484,
-0.3061119914,
0.1707463264,
-0.5330899358,
0.5373630524,
-0.4812546968,
-0.5083652139,
-0.2104647607,
-0.7188156843,
0.3324643672,
-0.2377239913,
0.2996564806,
-0.1062544659,
-0.1999218315,
0.88430655,
-0.7657206655,
1.0275764465,
-0.0494480543,
0.1331807375,
0.5203480721,
-0.2315981537,
0.4163430631,
-0.3401075304,
-0.1158482805,
0.3643250763,
0.1943600625,
-0.7540166974,
-0.3772667944,
0.2744594812,
-1.2073769569,
-0.6576049924,
-0.9661934376,
-0.4331201613,
-0.3012008071,
-0.2753556073,
0.3330666721,
0.263576746,
0.1261703819,
0.2504150271,
0.2101959884,
-0.4064686,
0.1086687371,
0.2121553421,
0.1577409804,
-0.2996723354,
1.1332850456,
0.5923708081,
0.2492219806,
-0.03537824,
0.282866627,
-0.3458158076,
-0.3059874475,
-0.4115566611,
0.1046243832,
-0.6142927408,
-0.2751767933,
-0.2588512301,
-0.2809675038,
-0.3938973248,
-0.3804577887,
-0.1084891111,
-0.8611145616,
-0.6799917817,
-0.0558078513,
0.5130805969,
0.8867356181,
-0.5421406627,
0.2189648747,
-0.4474196136,
0.2721558809,
0.4832991362,
0.0044730725,
0.0606973618,
-0.3454030454,
-0.0185170285,
0.3409692049,
-0.5796076059,
-0.8483597636,
0.0373728797,
0.2121205479,
0.3901420236,
0.4013398588,
0.1927167326,
1.0323529243,
-0.3157034516,
0.8874938488,
0.2199860364,
-0.7654492855,
0.4865514338,
-0.5958003998,
-0.1157163456,
0.2850272357,
0.3570934534,
-0.5453873277,
-0.0766207352,
-0.3707458377,
-0.7269873023,
0.9873094559,
0.3224604428,
0.0433618166,
-0.1641342044,
0.4637171328,
-0.0859571323,
0.3019949794,
-0.421657145,
0.0638737157,
-0.4332294166,
0.0515456535,
-0.2316222638,
-0.2244842798,
-0.0372050479,
-0.802790463,
0.4850252569,
-0.0325699486,
0.1100329012,
0.2256126255,
0.0148564233,
-0.2532940805,
0.1159896106,
0.4521613121,
0.4558976293,
-0.0838240758,
0.050818935,
0.3017217815,
-0.3861160576,
0.4163483679,
-0.2196847945,
0.0980539471,
-0.563215673,
0.5332357883,
0.4057337642,
0.2195263952,
-0.6610694528,
0.4558932483,
0.2694931328,
-0.4418193996,
-0.409262985,
0.2854534388,
-0.1639098823,
0.2613115013,
0.4352810085,
0.0498187803,
0.218760848,
-0.636510849,
-0.2169857621,
0.377894491,
0.1546609998,
-0.1896096319,
0.4930884242,
0.3551037312,
-0.4481355846,
0.6706003547,
-0.311418891,
-0.5862542987,
0.9129564762,
0.2768718898,
0.5000376105,
-0.1553768516,
0.4538414478,
0.0671265647,
0.0573349819,
-0.113477461,
0.2401789427,
-0.5152493119,
-0.5321254134,
-0.3244059682,
-0.3000335395,
-0.6818685532,
0.0759780928,
-0.7148835063,
0.0821561292,
-0.6954992414,
-0.2484468818,
0.3097033799,
0.2322780341,
-0.7016374469,
0.0899449363,
0.1413907707,
0.5251704454,
-0.8015634418,
0.6559812427,
0.6746765375,
-0.3388028145,
-0.7848241925,
-0.6931402683,
0.4714249074,
-0.6217608452,
0.8548902273,
0.0693399534,
-0.2231429964,
-0.2369282693,
-0.7076399326,
-0.7649743557,
1.1767237186,
0.156049341,
-0.6705521941,
0.2033240199,
0.602527082,
0.7329172492,
0.0101340022,
-0.0372032672,
0.5431388617,
0.5028873086,
0.2721526623,
-1.021646142,
-0.2363791764,
-0.2406395823,
0.0125709418,
-0.2923016548,
-0.8544412851,
1.0824545622,
-0.190655157,
-0.2201081812,
-0.0330613479,
0.3788783252,
0.4154378176,
0.4781377017,
0.474447459,
0.2246029973,
1.0006139278,
-0.0562395379,
1.1041346788,
0.1821059436,
0.2710522115,
0.7474043965,
-0.3392420709,
0.7170031071,
0.1862765551,
-0.7819445729,
0.0167953279,
1.4095380306,
-0.1056830212,
0.2575362027,
0.3750188351,
-0.243485257,
-0.4198879004,
-0.138686195,
-0.5914845467,
0.554908216,
0.4114183187,
0.2266651541,
0.1316429377,
0.0416167527,
-0.1933797747,
-0.0500015654,
-0.4682254195,
0.7480986714,
-0.1576458961,
-0.2562450767,
0.956818521,
-0.1765701473,
0.8361602426,
-0.1820662469,
-0.0771210939,
-0.0979517177,
-0.0011234956,
-0.6111078262,
-0.709748745,
0.2171562463,
0.1186122075,
-0.0503408872,
0.0876997784,
0.6867192984,
-0.1688128859,
-0.6708024144,
-0.0303003024,
0.1999723911,
0.4497234523,
-0.0076097483,
-0.6607958674,
0.1683361381,
-0.193976596,
-0.1291398555,
0.4943702221,
0.2184250504,
-0.4440113902,
0.9478569627,
0.805631578,
0.1149153039,
0.1153419092,
-0.1588659436,
0.9067339897,
-0.493524164,
-0.4284788668,
-0.5647704005,
-0.0529260486,
-0.2222344428,
0.0187298357,
0.6312730312,
0.5814674497,
0.8380150795,
0.0040411996,
0.9471256733,
0.1102620736,
0.582175374,
-0.0227654632,
0.5503035784,
-0.6645002961,
0.3829315603,
-0.2238165736,
-0.558108747,
-0.2282501906,
0.7883067727,
-0.4876839221,
-0.0316858143,
0.1210091114,
0.6159494519,
-0.0957065746,
0.2565853,
0.0037256451,
-0.2417327315,
0.4115700424,
0.6079372168,
1.2972302437,
-0.134293437,
0.4231626689,
-0.5079734325,
-0.1359811276,
-0.2486028075,
-0.6976804137,
-0.7878988385,
-0.3423019946,
-0.4888724387,
-0.052899424,
0.1220693663,
0.9981541634,
1.0495784283,
-0.557474196,
-0.241257742,
0.1039914712,
-0.0445772633,
-0.2052343637,
-0.229067564,
0.3408242762,
-0.4166205823,
-0.5473439693,
0.339309305,
0.0680819303,
0.3524826169,
-0.0735429972,
-0.2452228069,
-0.0510056019,
0.1624385566,
0.8855196238,
0.7545796037,
-0.9105878472,
-0.6244707704,
-0.3966816068,
0.0919548869,
-0.0470233299,
0.7454842925,
-1.0485643148,
0.4494615495,
0.311880976,
0.8184314966,
0.6389337778,
0.3005018532,
0.2196121067,
-0.9091760516,
0.2813055515,
0.1610331386,
0.0764591694,
0.3773486912,
-0.613235414,
0.9488694668,
0.3322557509,
-0.6865017414,
-1.1152139902,
-0.0757821947,
-1.0873998404,
-0.5276332498,
1.0750417709,
0.0578275323,
-0.0110173821,
-0.3334808946,
-0.4362294078,
0.2755317092,
-0.240938127,
0.8475686908,
0.5438898206,
-0.643345356,
0.0011407329,
-0.4915550947,
0.7425615191,
0.1798367202,
-0.7200387716,
-0.0212764461,
0.6227936149,
0.3204016685,
0.184590742,
0.6698920727,
0.1416520923,
0.4307516813,
-0.0900144503,
-0.1801725328,
-0.5598940849,
-0.2293779254,
-0.1239409298,
0.1543186307,
-0.1389374286,
-0.4846777916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13846v1 | Extracting Structured Seed-Mediated Gold Nanorod Growth Procedures from Literature with GPT-3 | 2023-04-26T22:21:33 | 2023-04-26T22:21:33 | Nicholas Walker, John Dagdelen, Kevin Cruse, Sanghoon Lee, Samuel Gleason, Alexander Dunn, Gerbrand Ceder, A. Paul Alivisatos, Kristin A. Persson, Anubhav Jain | physics.app-ph | physics.app-ph, cs.CL, cs.IR | Although gold nanorods have been the subject of much research, the pathways
for controlling their shape and thereby their optical properties remain largely
heuristically understood. Although it is apparent that the simultaneous
presence of and interaction between various reagents during synthesis control
these properties, computational and experimental approaches for exploring the
synthesis space can be either intractable or too time-consuming in practice.
This motivates an alternative approach leveraging the wealth of synthesis
information already embedded in the body of scientific literature by developing
tools to extract relevant structured data in an automated, high-throughput
manner. To that end, we present an approach using the powerful GPT-3 language
model to extract structured multi-step seed-mediated growth procedures and
outcomes for gold nanorods from unstructured scientific text. GPT-3 prompt
completions are fine-tuned to predict synthesis templates in the form of JSON
documents from unstructured text input with an overall accuracy of $86\%$. The
performance is notable, considering the model is performing simultaneous entity
recognition and relation extraction. We present a dataset of 11,644 entities
extracted from 1,137 papers, resulting in 268 papers with at least one complete
seed-mediated gold nanorod growth procedure and outcome for a total of 332
complete procedures. | [
-0.0566969253,
-1.0935144424,
0.7505757809,
0.4645028412,
-0.241852954,
-0.1112954766,
-0.2204348147,
-0.3340173662,
0.1195460558,
0.4094238281,
-0.3884607553,
-0.5837156177,
-0.507884264,
0.712433815,
-0.3001823425,
1.3038160801,
-0.3899534941,
-0.2589632869,
0.4003234506,
0.5457300544,
-0.3190306425,
0.1034699604,
-0.1888430417,
-0.0652644485,
0.4958388507,
0.387452215,
0.4216147661,
0.9841221571,
0.6068150401,
0.3404922187,
-0.1529110521,
0.4209584892,
0.1229523644,
0.0882399455,
0.0650525466,
0.2119799256,
-0.4861977398,
0.2710776627,
0.627512157,
0.5787979364,
-0.0736816972,
0.2852481306,
0.3178647459,
0.4934684634,
-0.3134427965,
0.1737538874,
-0.8539712429,
0.2734772563,
-0.4255067408,
-0.867276907,
-0.2603079975,
-0.0659101605,
0.089078106,
-1.0903052092,
0.6827123165,
0.0029267825,
0.625392735,
-0.1652048975,
-0.1809125245,
-0.5383217931,
-0.6708135009,
0.6273782849,
-0.7908195853,
-0.0469283499,
0.0880712941,
-0.0005800181,
-0.3915095627,
-1.0255507231,
-0.4423444867,
-0.3574263155,
-0.3592097461,
0.091800727,
0.2087976336,
0.2275428921,
0.2908278406,
0.4142296314,
-0.9991022944,
-0.4847799838,
-0.7152451277,
0.0379203632,
0.3199217319,
-0.1213683262,
0.1594325155,
-0.6248304248,
-0.1821794063,
-0.0957783088,
-0.6206515431,
-0.6455046535,
0.2497010678,
0.6772729158,
0.3744348884,
0.9527906179,
-0.0477987528,
0.6494912505,
-0.1647857726,
-0.0720298514,
0.0926304311,
-0.7198454738,
-0.2731428444,
0.1193781793,
1.0037583113,
0.0090478733,
-0.0373491757,
-0.3015540838,
-0.0427667387,
0.0180173256,
0.2550991774,
-0.8424102068,
-0.1453510225,
0.4682686627,
-0.4616558552,
-0.3202575743,
0.2839540243,
-0.6913166642,
-0.1545568109,
0.027568141,
0.3834205568,
-0.1734594107,
-0.0980162993,
0.0126565499,
-0.3502781689,
-0.3113208413,
0.305634588,
-0.8794930577,
0.4771131873,
0.5880348682,
1.3010748625,
-0.0920844972,
-0.4176102579,
-0.4988812804,
0.5167745948,
-0.6009386778,
0.43759951,
-0.1399808675,
-0.3806233406,
-0.2801704705,
0.0366069712,
0.0683255717,
-0.4494304359,
0.2978469431,
-0.5976746678,
0.0824682787,
0.0179510694,
-0.4092877209,
0.0765027627,
0.1834265292,
-0.8201209903,
0.6865499616,
0.3881680369,
-0.8650819063,
0.5658938885,
-0.8776627183,
-0.5145843625,
0.2202363461,
-0.1408768594,
-0.4149465561,
0.1684890091,
0.5042937398,
0.3338935375,
-0.2288117856,
0.1891791224,
-0.1413846314,
-0.312242955,
0.0647044778,
-0.2796445787,
0.3400896788,
0.1861725748,
-0.3899842799,
0.2160515487,
-0.9420250654,
-0.1259648949,
-0.0451309495,
-0.2790614367,
-0.2825750411,
-0.276240766,
0.0822445676,
-0.102550745,
0.070539318,
-0.7686972022,
0.3649582565,
-0.3467889726,
0.5742160082,
0.4468332827,
0.6503320932,
0.2404386103,
0.1384039074,
0.3370186687,
-0.0372555107,
0.2824742198,
-0.0794172734,
-0.4123630226,
-0.3972422481,
0.0030353316,
0.3100673854,
0.3154409826,
-0.5647849441,
0.1699532717,
-0.0164681915,
-0.31647861,
-0.4268864095,
0.513777554,
0.1489067674,
0.7089727521,
0.4491610527,
-0.058570087,
-0.700365901,
-0.4697229862,
-0.3159146309,
-0.0773246288,
0.0047672447,
0.019300431,
0.6674838066,
0.0088065844,
0.814036727,
-0.6288658381,
-0.5386559963,
0.0793905407,
0.6533722281,
0.7049890757,
0.7014015913,
0.2780241072,
-0.9996118546,
-0.5218085051,
0.5059446096,
-0.7980201244,
0.0345777161,
-0.2674588263,
-0.087183632,
-0.1903761923,
0.5816547275,
-0.9184134603,
0.4941865504,
0.2405409068,
-0.1949926615,
0.7644000649,
-0.4075594246,
0.3933272362,
-0.7922629118,
0.2474430054,
0.2753001451,
-0.0868303552,
-0.5878772736,
0.1360214353,
0.0252099112,
0.1325290501,
-0.455524981,
0.3128348887,
-0.8295787573,
-0.3576719463,
-0.2281845808,
0.1390129924,
0.2208259255,
0.2859376669,
0.2509943843,
1.1625078917,
-0.0552677065,
-0.4118408263,
0.1297528893,
0.3546535075,
-0.2984429598,
-0.0046977089,
-1.0070611238,
-0.1609452516,
0.4468550086,
0.084195517,
-0.422490716,
-0.1161009222,
0.3672085106,
-0.4134573936,
0.0050065694,
-0.3511759341,
-0.8597677946,
-0.3974290192,
-0.1751137525,
0.1941056699,
0.0499857627,
-0.05747189,
0.445412308,
-0.124711059,
-0.6825584173,
-0.0439052507,
-0.6323637962,
0.1731376797,
-0.385987699,
-0.1555682123,
0.5848816633,
-0.0389257632,
-0.1642895043,
0.1138814613,
0.1673863977,
0.0326841734,
-0.0708130822,
-0.0346866548,
0.2837010622,
-0.1039539725,
-0.3010542393,
0.2751091123,
-0.0762611255,
-0.2155768126,
-0.7155428529,
0.156306386,
-0.1769113541,
-0.2628697157,
-0.3122889698,
0.4691734314,
0.5969482064,
-0.0374108925,
0.4309798181,
0.6449628472,
-0.2204915434,
-0.0623012148,
-0.15501827,
-0.21966438,
-0.4753160179,
0.3414196968,
-0.2575469315,
-0.7690110803,
0.3336176276,
-0.042124249,
0.2376308441,
0.6532694697,
0.5181711316,
0.0368622765,
1.2231156826,
0.5012266636,
0.6510400176,
0.3453459144,
-0.1968971342,
0.0488353185,
-1.1065047979,
-0.2057467997,
-0.4582403302,
0.0647713766,
-0.5571670532,
-0.3145366311,
0.7469009161,
0.3027458489,
-0.2208260596,
0.3294422925,
-0.7963335514,
0.3005168736,
0.4876127839,
0.033617191,
0.7260921597,
0.2154255956,
0.1105264798,
-0.042581331,
-0.3690565825,
-0.5332484245,
1.0998934507,
0.1027029231,
0.3058407307,
-0.129806906,
0.5267310143,
0.2241108865,
0.4284372032,
-0.4093865156,
0.2318283916,
0.0098406253,
-0.3960807025,
-0.3609915674,
-0.73675102,
-0.8456819654,
0.3339982331,
-0.0562036112,
-0.4676560462,
-0.0185247958,
0.2093941867,
-0.5561653972,
0.1584329307,
-0.6386270523,
0.6567544341,
-0.2222040445,
-0.2689341605,
0.2898950577,
-0.68966645,
0.3005364537,
-0.4490049779,
0.4798905551,
0.3536063433,
0.0647675022,
0.9805437922,
-0.6636969447,
0.433353126,
-0.0669576749,
-0.0803021863,
0.4035857916,
0.254892379,
0.4707598686,
0.3369850218,
0.1165832281,
-0.0507546775,
0.0037793287,
-0.0824858397,
-0.7380087376,
0.6385353208,
-0.579668045,
-0.4305156469,
-0.3944349587,
-0.7698882222,
-0.0826013908,
0.5764821172,
0.1265777647,
0.3666098118,
0.1815193892,
-0.0793671384,
0.1196879074,
0.0236264244,
0.4301008582,
0.3688515127,
-0.2090916932,
-0.9118791223,
0.9161109924,
0.2199477851,
0.0810462087,
0.1485708058,
0.3924081624,
-0.1691695005,
-0.9725982547,
-0.5245574117,
0.4196076989,
-0.2089221328,
-0.2642615438,
-0.5292030573,
0.0364765227,
-0.7013623714,
-0.0777418762,
-0.1748750061,
-0.5316348076,
-0.6551731229,
-0.2985873222,
0.6220192313,
1.1102496386,
-0.3170993626,
0.418084681,
-0.8946444392,
0.328011632,
0.2126231939,
0.1389277726,
-0.0941799879,
-0.0076469397,
-0.2131329626,
-0.1269229203,
-0.4163012207,
-0.8764278889,
0.7801480889,
0.3690870702,
-0.0211458132,
0.3383399844,
-0.2245408744,
1.1125206947,
-0.8155753016,
0.6867397428,
0.1019809768,
-0.6777051687,
0.9745008945,
-0.6101114154,
-0.1078361422,
0.4889032245,
0.1627792567,
-0.096448265,
-0.4577893019,
-0.6656057835,
-1.1142753363,
0.3443973362,
0.4587412775,
-0.5003321767,
-0.2033177167,
0.5675295591,
0.2999746799,
0.5060096979,
-0.7232531309,
0.0829339325,
-0.0716610029,
-0.0517879613,
0.0766257197,
0.0062234523,
-0.4587994814,
-0.1590012461,
0.6826255918,
-0.0882348195,
0.0812014639,
0.6260436773,
0.0420952588,
-0.1232897118,
0.199757129,
0.4587901235,
0.8127020001,
-0.6046682596,
0.1234721914,
-0.5057967305,
-0.6657555103,
-0.0161266942,
0.4388547242,
-0.3777216375,
0.1251668185,
0.5223600864,
0.3621125221,
-0.0812344402,
-0.3168199062,
0.3313746452,
-0.0326137617,
-0.4845435023,
-0.0938314125,
-0.4196248949,
-0.5168008208,
0.3996995389,
0.7595675588,
-0.0093059642,
0.5364412069,
-0.389641881,
0.4294871688,
0.2621942461,
-0.1951852441,
-0.3646321893,
0.5597670674,
-0.1086961627,
-0.0188641604,
0.4908391833,
-0.2162541151,
-0.3043033183,
0.2600999475,
0.8173957467,
0.6804593801,
0.3788475394,
0.5078012943,
0.1667267531,
0.2954748869,
-0.2132870704,
0.2969599664,
-0.1370387822,
-0.3297393918,
-0.596490562,
-0.8118771315,
-0.1141818017,
0.0903971493,
-0.5020790696,
-0.3710441589,
-0.5404213667,
-0.2508581281,
-0.2059546709,
0.5935660005,
-0.3517469168,
-0.0381593518,
-0.4522028267,
0.9921262264,
-1.0951898098,
0.3356671929,
0.4689131081,
-0.5411695838,
-0.9319735765,
-0.3059611619,
-0.1055684686,
-0.1139123738,
0.5431988835,
-0.0233328529,
0.0270097833,
0.1846273839,
-0.5088922977,
-0.6839646101,
1.1238107681,
0.1037759632,
-0.1962092966,
-0.2753019035,
-0.1050575972,
0.3747190237,
-0.2399071455,
0.2671558559,
0.6054430008,
0.5964816809,
0.3396634758,
-0.7818431258,
-0.0555136837,
-0.4488456845,
0.2976180315,
0.0590347759,
-0.0350661911,
0.9976324439,
0.0734120682,
-0.2564717829,
0.4380029738,
1.0589002371,
0.8983698487,
0.0640226901,
0.1539031267,
0.299167186,
0.6739019156,
0.0558694638,
0.7936011553,
-0.2244077325,
0.5115061998,
0.6151793599,
-0.3432371616,
0.6609701514,
0.8979135752,
-0.1311008185,
0.3900550902,
0.7495228052,
-0.2360045165,
0.7337487936,
0.0297005437,
0.0533385053,
0.280615598,
-0.2032182664,
-0.4557587504,
0.0917548016,
0.4085736573,
-0.3019065559,
-0.0789649114,
0.002147594,
0.0969156846,
-0.2387773246,
-0.3271235228,
0.4617254734,
0.0485400483,
-0.6631647944,
-0.0122758057,
-0.109749563,
0.6939134598,
-0.6853466034,
-0.5821706653,
-0.0086120525,
0.0154213635,
-0.3140384853,
-0.6072908044,
0.2198994309,
0.1363588423,
-0.2739556134,
-0.2618410289,
0.45936203,
-0.4031736851,
-0.8740959764,
-0.079181321,
0.4632826746,
0.1541008353,
0.0290480703,
-0.5058325529,
0.1917789727,
-0.4238708615,
-0.4227623045,
0.1470762044,
0.7601892948,
-0.0206423681,
0.138273254,
0.9266596437,
1.0445296764,
-0.1285716891,
-0.051657442,
0.9011949301,
-0.4161786437,
-0.4799942672,
-0.7785788178,
0.284663409,
-0.19876571,
-0.3487602472,
0.9156411886,
0.4402796924,
0.6820463538,
-0.0319624133,
0.7993193269,
-0.1316396296,
0.5071750283,
-0.6851284504,
0.6153182983,
-0.5776405334,
0.2588537335,
-0.8975988626,
-0.8538790941,
-0.7298967242,
0.7599675655,
0.0053383703,
0.1411110759,
0.7461654544,
0.6432626247,
-0.0627760813,
0.057092566,
-0.2535597086,
0.3518335223,
0.687731266,
-0.0065751323,
0.2648086548,
-0.4138078094,
0.4275035858,
-0.1472403705,
-0.5009744763,
0.100376673,
-1.050973177,
-0.3371882439,
-0.4245473444,
-0.208018288,
-0.1778561473,
0.0213170908,
0.7560806274,
0.6002411246,
-0.6543173194,
-0.1970854402,
-0.6611753702,
-0.1344386935,
-0.4809308052,
-0.2551702857,
0.7862865925,
-0.1334401965,
-0.2642627954,
0.6809183359,
0.3896332383,
0.1988878697,
-0.1964886785,
0.0573935471,
-0.1935298294,
-0.4228144586,
0.5283749104,
0.4943811893,
-0.4746818542,
-0.0285268221,
-0.0211415179,
0.2963499129,
-0.1622037739,
0.9124962091,
-0.8162558079,
0.2723737359,
0.2402217537,
0.2522888184,
0.4143949747,
0.2673820555,
0.8266506791,
-1.056681633,
-0.0317401402,
0.0501676351,
0.0716399997,
0.351998806,
-0.5329185128,
0.4677182734,
0.3793859482,
-0.5981326103,
-0.9642732739,
-0.0834764615,
-0.7921554446,
-0.4058418274,
0.98299402,
0.1223350465,
-0.5542597771,
0.0984387025,
-0.0845275819,
0.4351867437,
-0.2883440256,
0.544208467,
0.1757187992,
-0.3045687973,
-0.0754948705,
-0.6294943094,
0.5238346457,
-0.1862003207,
-0.7387759089,
0.1729843169,
0.3678823113,
-0.0030504151,
0.4872877598,
0.7217190862,
-0.4295888841,
0.1401871443,
-0.0603100769,
-0.254765749,
-0.4584959745,
-0.7785543203,
-0.0344775803,
0.5112332702,
-0.1426737309,
-0.0069822771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13835v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13835v3 | Multi-Party Chat: Conversational Agents in Group Settings with Humans and Models | 2023-04-26T21:41:17 | 2023-06-08T21:45:46 | Jimmy Wei, Kurt Shuster, Arthur Szlam, Jason Weston, Jack Urbanek, Mojtaba Komeili | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Current dialogue research primarily studies pairwise (two-party)
conversations, and does not address the everyday setting where more than two
speakers converse together. In this work, we both collect and evaluate
multi-party conversations to study this more general case. We use the LIGHT
environment to construct grounded conversations, where each participant has an
assigned character to role-play. We thus evaluate the ability of language
models to act as one or more characters in such conversations. Models require
two skills that pairwise-trained models appear to lack: (1) being able to
decide when to talk; (2) producing coherent utterances grounded on multiple
characters. We compare models trained on our new dataset to existing
pairwise-trained dialogue models, as well as large language models with
few-shot prompting. We find that our new dataset, MultiLIGHT, which we will
publicly release, can help bring significant improvements in the group setting. | [
-0.263481617,
-0.6504400373,
0.6489701867,
0.2627551258,
-0.0558334291,
0.2801829875,
-0.2000641078,
-0.5697843432,
0.1623360217,
0.6132178903,
-0.4096009731,
-0.4476059377,
-0.1419585645,
0.0241851788,
-0.2046128809,
0.6366128325,
0.6630077362,
0.4358305931,
-0.059161555,
-0.5787340403,
-0.733653903,
-0.6879557967,
-0.648373127,
-0.4147963822,
0.6269360781,
0.7605251074,
0.9290886521,
0.0622346252,
0.2574497759,
0.2906493247,
0.1263592094,
0.077118136,
-0.6470116377,
0.2556843162,
0.0843650922,
-0.3904210329,
-0.4009940326,
0.2298001647,
0.3829639256,
0.8595202565,
-0.3514945805,
-0.1577942669,
-0.1818336248,
0.459847182,
-0.2579590082,
0.3991580307,
-0.6808805466,
-0.0458226353,
0.3087195456,
-0.0666472018,
-0.5897815824,
-0.1603910625,
0.121015653,
-0.5980261564,
0.2682595849,
0.2742279768,
0.3783206344,
-0.0516761355,
-0.7733472586,
-0.053891886,
-0.6981016994,
0.5939185023,
-0.6935059428,
0.2591605186,
0.6167961359,
0.3615892529,
-0.1132577211,
-0.4444409311,
-0.5682011247,
-0.3027690053,
-0.106811665,
0.2006995678,
0.2319651544,
0.3388959169,
0.1551930159,
0.0958064273,
-0.2160126865,
-0.0493235588,
-0.4416270554,
0.2519780099,
0.7100456953,
0.2138535082,
0.1860083938,
-0.0997673646,
-0.2634491026,
-0.1342725903,
-0.3561761677,
0.1194126979,
0.5554936528,
0.3720750809,
-0.0230151918,
0.3768012226,
-0.0893292576,
0.5642697811,
-0.0302953068,
-0.1354123354,
0.0044686096,
-0.7180320621,
0.1115794778,
0.0011574242,
0.6131640673,
1.0081375837,
0.2478865981,
-0.1421937793,
0.0638914257,
0.1657770723,
-0.0427521914,
-0.7950937152,
-0.692456305,
0.0539105013,
-0.685177505,
-0.3240829408,
0.1346620619,
-0.9172194004,
-0.8699493408,
-0.2011761963,
0.1300961375,
-0.1468363851,
-0.5008277297,
-0.0958602801,
-0.514497757,
0.2893907726,
0.3933464289,
-0.917088449,
0.4598912299,
0.4692148566,
0.5379927158,
0.1569545269,
-0.3648279309,
-0.7048984766,
0.2033881396,
-0.5163941979,
0.6919135451,
-0.6572700143,
-0.6679314971,
-0.0673017278,
-0.1538141668,
-0.0538035147,
-0.1423186809,
0.3735564947,
-0.271027714,
0.5281309485,
-0.4515350759,
-0.4330710173,
0.0616153479,
0.2084784955,
-0.4342059195,
0.3419467509,
-0.085391216,
-0.6017659307,
0.4851263762,
-0.5305565,
-0.3844588995,
0.322832793,
-0.5890749097,
-0.1117082536,
0.2928310037,
0.2028164566,
0.3721601963,
-0.0995117202,
0.2548872232,
-0.5140678287,
-0.4060130417,
0.540068388,
-0.3882277906,
0.5374422669,
0.0629603714,
0.2283131778,
0.4397957623,
-0.6078418493,
0.1722449809,
0.0439870656,
0.0534097366,
-0.2999067903,
0.4108608365,
0.074291274,
0.2911420465,
-0.1930407882,
-0.4502758384,
0.3158760965,
-0.2865102887,
0.6518427134,
0.5774552822,
0.2532998323,
0.4765177071,
-0.3754061759,
0.3823309541,
-0.1162408069,
0.3129983544,
-0.5942446589,
-0.854845047,
-0.8036319017,
-0.1843550652,
-0.2052487135,
0.4183852673,
-0.916444242,
0.3472292423,
0.0580855943,
-0.3838847578,
-0.2882168293,
-0.2932054102,
0.4815028012,
0.406915158,
0.1923198104,
-0.2012469769,
-0.1421797723,
-0.8091252446,
-0.2544232309,
-0.5978611112,
0.1970837414,
0.5421828628,
0.0471978933,
0.1445054561,
1.0068656206,
-0.335263133,
-0.0011931729,
-0.4314642549,
0.2856853306,
-0.0807608962,
0.3747130334,
0.4196391106,
-0.7991470695,
-0.5846313834,
-0.1805787086,
-0.6372554302,
0.1535910815,
-0.0218350086,
0.1370466948,
0.1468966901,
0.471573621,
-0.3488648534,
0.499204278,
0.8428808451,
-0.6684551239,
0.2260886133,
-0.2316956669,
0.6505647898,
-1.1535241604,
-0.3501745462,
-0.2089443207,
-0.2360740453,
-1.0878413916,
-0.2954958081,
-0.1626784056,
-0.5173268318,
-0.4465498924,
0.5089938045,
-0.7410392165,
-0.3042378128,
-0.2481147796,
0.0224887114,
0.1856062263,
0.6699015498,
0.0556037053,
0.9202544689,
0.5343689322,
-0.626265645,
0.4402573705,
0.4824645519,
-0.3279434144,
0.6968091726,
-0.7009392381,
0.6129254699,
-0.0299980752,
0.4932070374,
-1.2198334932,
-0.5190117359,
0.22047171,
-0.1971838176,
0.0294075198,
-0.2749218643,
-0.5892630219,
-0.1592716873,
-0.1493093967,
0.4653762877,
0.2695440054,
-0.4225500822,
0.44325158,
0.5007134676,
-0.2105619907,
-0.1315969974,
-0.5519146919,
0.3952772021,
-0.4669809639,
-1.0432319641,
0.0669646785,
-0.1543822736,
-0.5904575586,
-0.3104456663,
0.1756287068,
-0.4512985945,
-0.0315969288,
0.3206212223,
0.0900738388,
0.1017421111,
0.3935389519,
-0.2832242846,
-0.1502050906,
-0.2524827719,
0.1874922365,
0.6588375568,
-0.4754344821,
-0.5882347822,
-0.542746067,
0.8058342338,
0.3108886778,
-0.266125977,
0.9361187816,
0.3806068599,
-0.0196755715,
0.168210417,
-0.804876864,
-0.5529615879,
-0.4396250546,
0.3078279495,
-0.3610506654,
-0.9041679502,
0.8629000783,
0.2073296458,
0.0503442213,
-0.1645051241,
0.2088731676,
-0.0406307653,
1.249119997,
0.6395193338,
0.2515423,
0.6382462978,
0.3290803432,
0.4143733382,
-0.4093542695,
-0.259498477,
-0.4794752598,
-0.2185351104,
-0.3486415744,
-0.4097830057,
0.4535906613,
0.1798123717,
0.0937103406,
0.348780334,
-0.3046724796,
0.7593781352,
0.4651466906,
0.0815129429,
0.519921422,
-0.2909504473,
0.3883299232,
-0.0003900782,
-0.7110997438,
-0.5030508041,
0.8864738345,
0.2179425359,
0.6935011744,
0.1908031106,
0.4700320363,
-0.1130604595,
0.0449745432,
-0.65601933,
0.6192260981,
0.3827095926,
-0.8787454963,
-0.4169307351,
-0.5909548998,
-0.9045056105,
0.5280995965,
-0.2801136971,
-0.8320760727,
0.283090502,
0.0421443209,
-0.4305470884,
0.0191341024,
-1.0389105082,
0.9473749399,
-0.166076079,
-0.2140809745,
-0.3548555374,
-1.0381816626,
0.6290934086,
0.2738397419,
0.2800728679,
-0.4730401337,
0.247302562,
0.4626489878,
-0.0755703226,
0.7402063608,
-0.1470503658,
0.1288185269,
0.3714178801,
-0.0236565415,
0.1619552821,
0.3566348255,
-0.0979638398,
0.18648386,
0.1575150937,
-0.3314108253,
-0.5787442923,
0.3214072287,
-0.7358263135,
-0.5159407258,
-0.2891435325,
-0.5489988923,
-0.4124715924,
-0.0870299041,
0.2021003067,
0.6610992551,
-0.638130188,
0.4255547225,
0.2759819925,
-0.1927620322,
0.7069367766,
0.4304924309,
-0.6816174388,
-0.5579241514,
0.6759326458,
-0.1564689428,
0.7257607579,
-0.2250742912,
0.1998534948,
-0.1862538457,
-0.0497113019,
-0.2832586467,
-0.0045387652,
-0.7993519902,
0.1207228005,
-0.654427886,
0.0732318088,
-0.4841002524,
0.0000993875,
-0.2642859519,
-0.6689478755,
-0.1504374593,
0.0019746842,
0.1633268297,
0.7221662998,
0.1974171698,
0.5930318832,
-0.8810461164,
0.2522240877,
0.7435228229,
0.0607919656,
-0.3128136694,
-0.1796538681,
0.0819868147,
-0.1005690768,
-0.1828878224,
-1.3007179499,
0.3040447831,
0.3184202611,
0.5585424304,
0.439991802,
0.1331268847,
0.6018742919,
-0.5157188773,
0.9363700151,
0.540827632,
-0.8601125479,
0.4455705285,
-0.5168517232,
0.039901562,
0.970430553,
-0.3052991629,
-0.9219207764,
-0.2576962411,
-0.8034588099,
-0.3603734672,
1.0080928802,
0.392850399,
0.2823261321,
0.181831345,
0.0534321964,
-0.0514606424,
0.6580957174,
-0.6138739586,
-0.1893563569,
-0.2397913039,
0.1508939564,
-0.3468649387,
-0.1979417205,
-0.5862142444,
-0.27538535,
0.1067657247,
-0.3638920188,
0.2714593112,
-0.11294505,
0.3022192717,
-0.2423823178,
0.541751802,
0.630928278,
0.9506918788,
-0.0564933233,
0.3653986454,
0.1243331805,
0.1513015926,
0.1779899448,
0.005255064,
0.3550357223,
-0.2037176043,
0.3411493301,
0.9181492925,
0.2969470024,
-0.3452857137,
0.7532370687,
-0.5389466286,
-0.2016967386,
-0.1376422793,
0.2188859135,
0.2061570734,
0.285805732,
0.1901937276,
0.3293728828,
0.1714831889,
-0.9816006422,
0.1124629602,
0.3862311542,
-0.4612167776,
-0.327072829,
0.3134096861,
0.655518055,
-0.6753248572,
0.7470344901,
-0.3275319934,
-0.5305339098,
0.5187824368,
0.286342144,
0.778010428,
-0.2602078319,
0.2483612597,
0.0125711393,
0.15843606,
0.011883351,
0.1998735517,
-0.0280440859,
-1.0220900774,
-0.1267481446,
0.056457717,
-0.8090501428,
-0.0837321356,
-0.4637756646,
0.291002512,
-0.2330881953,
-0.1458257139,
-0.1828916818,
-0.0082201771,
-0.5092374682,
-0.400721401,
0.1517867148,
0.1842628121,
-0.9910185337,
0.8247458339,
0.4091433585,
-0.5529637337,
-0.8007510304,
0.0320285521,
-0.0503742434,
-0.5738537908,
0.2052093744,
0.53311342,
-0.0883182511,
0.0935059935,
-0.8900678754,
-0.4775068164,
0.9885651469,
0.2493691742,
-0.3249279559,
-0.1557452381,
-0.140255034,
0.5562187433,
-0.5676618814,
0.4457377791,
0.2186448127,
0.497102499,
0.4751280844,
-1.0471169949,
-0.3909826279,
-0.1489697993,
-0.0365652032,
-0.2756604254,
-1.0171792507,
1.023816824,
0.0506512895,
-0.2935703993,
-0.0081509529,
0.7568081617,
0.4982864857,
0.4392447472,
0.8655135632,
-0.0160144027,
0.8285270929,
-0.0064194198,
0.8355489969,
-0.4656163454,
0.1262098998,
1.3179110289,
-0.8757458925,
0.4773351848,
0.4272230864,
0.1903532743,
0.1973847747,
0.346054405,
0.2500823438,
0.4288102686,
0.0056702383,
-0.4625974298,
-0.6448042393,
-0.2876337171,
-0.4671705663,
0.4857111275,
0.2021988779,
0.0385414883,
0.1255177408,
0.1093653142,
-0.2073206753,
0.1395747364,
0.053132765,
1.0417176485,
0.1886150986,
-0.8492685556,
-0.1657534242,
0.0178874359,
0.2872998118,
-0.2279601097,
-0.2720180154,
-0.1790863276,
0.2690446675,
-0.1875041872,
-0.6299329996,
-0.0050124209,
-0.2661134601,
0.1605882347,
-0.3807018101,
0.8876226544,
-0.7437891364,
-0.3548842669,
0.290025115,
0.6459853649,
0.3555552363,
-0.2026387006,
-0.5722948313,
0.0847940817,
-0.1740212739,
-0.0950376466,
0.0660728216,
0.4593276083,
0.0197780188,
0.5677493215,
0.5386142731,
-0.3680013418,
0.2429031581,
0.548799336,
0.8630716801,
-0.5365642905,
-0.763733983,
-0.4733636975,
0.6882626414,
-0.4071604311,
-0.4710932076,
0.8674519062,
0.3879401386,
0.2695767283,
0.1986501664,
0.470398128,
0.163761586,
0.3307133019,
-0.4111904502,
0.6250239611,
-0.1741635501,
0.0217399225,
-0.3006052077,
-0.9904863834,
-0.0775565282,
0.9310682416,
0.037103001,
0.2524059117,
0.6592226028,
0.7839798331,
-0.0516811609,
0.6685938835,
0.6584993601,
-0.252425462,
0.8176699877,
0.4152697623,
1.524834156,
-0.2429695576,
0.3369354308,
-0.0302737299,
-0.238496691,
-0.281199187,
-0.8518462181,
-1.2627294064,
-0.6235334277,
-0.3220947683,
-0.1954283416,
-0.0270909499,
0.9649570584,
0.926120162,
-0.5184848309,
-0.4153699279,
-0.236642614,
-0.0837202743,
-0.0717471614,
-0.1476379931,
-0.1600150913,
-0.4079502523,
-0.586673975,
1.0740064383,
0.1922090799,
-0.091412805,
-0.3459858,
-0.206502974,
-0.2796120346,
0.0830727071,
0.3165493309,
0.022603482,
-0.6447433829,
-0.4466178119,
-0.0275637954,
-0.207064569,
0.3365260959,
0.9682751894,
-0.4018395245,
0.67512995,
0.4403047562,
0.1900312454,
0.5532289743,
0.2985571027,
0.7395364642,
-0.9387027025,
0.5570140481,
0.3719027042,
0.1964957416,
0.3591605723,
-0.1346227378,
0.5152539611,
0.3296173811,
-0.9721834064,
-0.6281049252,
0.4212121964,
-0.9793528914,
-0.192490384,
1.1521718502,
-0.129161492,
0.2151187509,
-0.3816326261,
-0.4924759865,
0.2523413599,
-0.7038840652,
0.2047638446,
1.0057605505,
-0.3631530702,
-0.4533002079,
-0.498878479,
0.3925896883,
0.3224720061,
-0.9455048442,
0.0915564746,
0.8541978002,
-0.1928949505,
0.2179762721,
1.1046118736,
0.2966533303,
-0.1347827315,
0.2080901563,
0.1097685769,
-0.0527783334,
-0.8078263998,
-0.5165804625,
0.3200890422,
-0.0362856351,
-0.1680909693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13803v1 | Translate to Disambiguate: Zero-shot Multilingual Word Sense Disambiguation with Pretrained Language Models | 2023-04-26T19:55:52 | 2023-04-26T19:55:52 | Haoqiang Kang, Terra Blevins, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) learn rich cross-lingual knowledge and can
be finetuned to perform well on diverse tasks such as translation and
multilingual word sense disambiguation (WSD). However, they often struggle at
disambiguating word sense in a zero-shot setting. To better understand this
contrast, we present a new study investigating how well PLMs capture
cross-lingual word sense with Contextual Word-Level Translation (C-WLT), an
extension of word-level translation that prompts the model to translate a given
word in context. We find that as the model size increases, PLMs encode more
cross-lingual word sense knowledge and better use context to improve WLT
performance. Building on C-WLT, we introduce a zero-shot approach for WSD,
tested on 18 languages from the XL-WSD dataset. Our method outperforms fully
supervised baselines on recall for many evaluation languages without additional
training or finetuning. This study presents a first step towards understanding
how to best leverage the cross-lingual knowledge inside PLMs for robust
zero-shot reasoning in any language. | [
-0.4501859844,
-0.5012285113,
0.7594726086,
-0.1474998891,
-0.5271056294,
-0.0331002213,
-0.2024517059,
-0.2693641484,
-0.1338526905,
0.0909833536,
-0.4158629179,
-0.6557892561,
-0.7471238971,
0.068684347,
-0.2878242731,
0.8422907591,
-0.1616269201,
0.1337319911,
-0.0874258876,
-0.4783960283,
-0.4089772999,
-0.4706000388,
-0.2259160131,
-0.3870035708,
0.6796239018,
0.3465722799,
0.3665959239,
0.2863056958,
0.1290677339,
0.1598495692,
0.0408523493,
-0.0211694967,
-0.4488753676,
-0.2333812863,
-0.3476476669,
-0.3183298409,
-0.192119211,
0.0873939767,
0.2778966129,
1.0572346449,
-0.1185536683,
0.1660066396,
-0.0036579079,
0.3064107895,
-0.8774197102,
-0.0626095831,
-0.7777235508,
0.080655925,
-0.1972689033,
-0.2824134231,
-0.499638319,
0.3052086532,
-0.0308171902,
-0.9142517447,
0.0627694279,
0.0357352756,
0.7666888833,
0.3312272131,
-0.6423960328,
0.0304749142,
-0.5412313938,
0.8233473897,
-0.6435881853,
0.6966621876,
0.2618511021,
0.1263775826,
0.1949466318,
-0.4832675457,
-0.9286546707,
-0.1651754528,
0.0545935296,
0.2187217921,
-0.1014492735,
0.1107252315,
0.4296688437,
0.3167042136,
-0.7336027622,
0.0365469158,
-0.2311822325,
-0.2257087827,
0.3551793993,
-0.1552884728,
0.1767950654,
0.049441658,
-0.4686891735,
-0.3559819758,
-0.6994711757,
0.0085974503,
0.0501359329,
0.214618668,
-0.1117194071,
0.5415607691,
-0.2014604658,
1.1063936949,
-0.0599794053,
-0.254039228,
0.2560100257,
-0.4561132491,
-0.2036599666,
0.1450019032,
0.5234367251,
0.3914709985,
0.405187875,
-0.2360783517,
-0.0920270309,
0.2045394331,
0.0121472869,
-0.8175525665,
-0.0006940913,
0.0336335599,
-0.1191188842,
0.0666816458,
-0.0037316075,
-0.2861227393,
-0.0592017472,
-0.4023739398,
0.6498914957,
-0.4744897485,
-0.4069729745,
0.433832407,
-0.3011036515,
0.4262502491,
0.1468357742,
-0.4735416472,
-0.1280309111,
0.4222398102,
0.6643660665,
-0.1986644566,
-0.6426002979,
-0.7110737562,
0.2258348912,
-0.6094781756,
0.5923024416,
-0.21128802,
-0.3420867622,
-0.1109614745,
-0.0500724912,
-0.0571256615,
-0.2996908128,
0.1492916197,
-0.367334336,
0.34327811,
-0.4714704156,
-0.5260449648,
-0.093899712,
0.5075486302,
-0.138763994,
0.639898777,
0.2451440245,
-0.565585196,
0.8260166645,
-0.4867194295,
-0.5083165765,
0.2470883429,
-0.0431988947,
0.2104512602,
0.443831712,
0.1932749599,
0.3947137296,
0.1444578916,
0.1534964144,
-0.4843696952,
-0.2833328843,
-0.1356151402,
-0.3637599945,
0.8147124648,
0.188539356,
-0.0781217366,
0.0428186581,
-0.7285242081,
-0.0237534922,
0.1560534686,
-0.1092404276,
-0.7990669608,
-0.397682935,
-0.1298624575,
0.5964018703,
0.2987053692,
-0.7973453999,
-0.0277638603,
-0.487821579,
0.2624980807,
0.2321456522,
-0.1495826691,
0.6068290472,
0.0719047859,
0.5411564708,
0.4533902705,
0.0162054524,
-0.4186703265,
-0.1208855659,
-0.5765724182,
-0.0539906323,
0.257835716,
0.5782394409,
-1.2200267315,
0.2801347971,
-0.0947635025,
-0.389328748,
-0.4638117552,
0.194394812,
0.4620135725,
0.8601133227,
0.6181817055,
-0.33758986,
-0.0640453398,
-0.5321536064,
-0.2695685029,
-0.05303967,
-0.1580305099,
0.105088219,
0.3826320469,
-0.0447885506,
0.7481360435,
-0.418384701,
-0.2580272257,
-0.4854902029,
0.1736456752,
-0.0293997508,
0.1661394984,
0.7451549172,
-0.6283429265,
-0.4928956628,
0.0566581674,
-0.5736036301,
-0.2139117122,
0.0070489538,
-0.2416332662,
0.213333413,
0.5525942445,
-0.5285266638,
0.4724087119,
0.700745523,
-0.6280894876,
0.487023592,
-0.3178744912,
0.0351760648,
-1.0714621544,
0.3219034374,
-0.0710731596,
-0.3700307906,
-0.6299663186,
0.1970317066,
0.2313467562,
-0.3636997938,
-0.79462713,
0.9863320589,
-0.5755727887,
-0.2041000128,
-0.2463168055,
0.4465045929,
0.3897766769,
0.4297731519,
0.255559653,
0.6019149423,
0.5889191628,
-0.7175316811,
0.1854052395,
0.2371094376,
-0.4194809794,
0.9168278575,
-0.5585599542,
-0.0907688811,
-0.2104688287,
-0.007665501,
-0.774415195,
0.0495015942,
0.1000731438,
-0.486364007,
0.3888508677,
0.0924458131,
-0.3719159067,
-0.330478102,
-0.0719757825,
0.5625675321,
0.1759475023,
-0.5965648293,
0.2568927407,
0.2078195959,
0.0610025339,
-0.6792786121,
-0.7676895857,
-0.0158644281,
-0.1344415694,
-0.1269703805,
0.3605118096,
-0.1670394987,
-0.1220791414,
-0.0660694018,
-0.3422064185,
-0.124857299,
0.3160921335,
-0.2484461516,
0.2456203848,
-0.036553394,
0.085514009,
0.1273055375,
-0.2190817446,
-0.1380340755,
-0.3941920698,
0.6178544164,
0.0849060789,
-0.7071308494,
0.0010594809,
0.4685169458,
0.5816264749,
-0.5013709664,
0.7119008303,
0.8057314157,
-0.2858400047,
-0.1772767752,
-0.3243334889,
-0.2868050635,
-0.3403326869,
0.3463308215,
-0.6049614549,
-0.9061965942,
0.3958183527,
-0.0559752472,
0.0260268804,
0.243176043,
0.2808315754,
0.0035911438,
1.0046242476,
0.7890517116,
-0.0678213909,
0.2685135305,
-0.1142467633,
0.3841077387,
-0.7269467711,
0.0325288475,
-0.2147369236,
-0.26402542,
-0.2155791223,
-0.5834214091,
0.2877525687,
0.5718057156,
-0.2171436399,
0.3960774839,
-0.1812660545,
0.4498530626,
0.4998691082,
-0.2173680067,
0.4957279265,
-0.0771515593,
-0.428550899,
0.0346681401,
-0.8594827652,
-0.1443366706,
0.8120341301,
0.0276850984,
0.3414283395,
0.0350815319,
0.6941114068,
-0.2227814049,
0.1634734571,
-1.0521717072,
0.4330973625,
-0.2064666301,
-0.5149857402,
-0.3162755966,
-0.4732577205,
-0.9331895113,
0.4153446853,
0.0545902885,
-0.4652741551,
0.2084211856,
0.1511777192,
-0.4281300902,
0.2109707743,
-0.5943741202,
1.2222303152,
-0.4646193981,
-0.231673032,
-0.1050459519,
-0.5092637539,
0.3303411901,
-0.1814365834,
0.147749275,
-0.2011160702,
-0.1167148426,
0.1800447851,
-0.2874091566,
0.5668684244,
-0.4941382408,
-0.4038052261,
0.14665474,
0.3112220168,
-0.0958953723,
-0.0531530567,
-0.0419302471,
0.6303172112,
0.3886996508,
-0.5083773136,
-0.389383316,
0.4164278507,
-0.3494390845,
-0.3936368227,
-0.5819473267,
-0.7212377191,
-0.3833802342,
0.4016702771,
0.3942211568,
0.2705248594,
-0.3956710398,
0.1399662346,
0.4684216678,
-0.4240809083,
0.549449265,
1.0034226179,
-0.2612166703,
0.0929633975,
0.7741839886,
0.1662901938,
0.3786676228,
0.4926384687,
0.0648897812,
-0.6690812707,
-0.4426465034,
-0.8161572218,
0.058542639,
-0.3196568191,
-0.3408854306,
-0.3288370073,
-0.0155757936,
-0.4148765802,
-0.2364872545,
-0.3010116518,
-0.1509383619,
-0.0241250247,
-0.1376379579,
0.1110308245,
0.2860956192,
-0.2440409362,
0.2479709238,
-0.8331852555,
0.4416005313,
0.1577768028,
0.360597223,
-0.2914562225,
-0.7210071683,
-0.1906170845,
0.168285206,
-0.1256799102,
-0.9635952711,
0.6507471204,
0.3450461924,
0.5809646249,
0.4163534939,
0.1664520949,
1.0446557999,
-0.5497485399,
0.7344655395,
0.4725186825,
-1.219204545,
0.4821902812,
-0.27701208,
0.8574489951,
0.6335849166,
0.5782511234,
-0.8248187304,
-0.1705379188,
-0.3827631772,
-0.7001074553,
0.55161798,
-0.458995223,
0.2823473215,
-0.18261832,
0.1771460027,
0.1416638792,
0.4520481229,
-0.7308852077,
0.0425001197,
-0.3478161693,
-0.3089891076,
-0.4404437542,
-0.114432469,
-0.1174002513,
-0.4318817258,
0.2890395224,
-0.5273042917,
-0.1714150608,
0.126996249,
-0.6864245534,
0.1564304978,
0.3273284435,
0.560534656,
0.7991269827,
0.0511096828,
0.1914794147,
0.3194004893,
-0.1599261463,
0.0479602255,
0.108352229,
-0.1895889342,
0.0915314481,
0.2983426154,
0.9283685088,
0.3959122896,
-0.7830798626,
0.9068336487,
0.0789766908,
-0.3265836239,
-0.0586702451,
-0.2564615607,
-0.0042955172,
-0.0530081578,
0.2058109492,
-0.2649987042,
-0.0456465371,
-0.5853568912,
0.1846866161,
0.4922733009,
-0.4048040211,
-0.376894176,
0.5534607768,
0.0611818321,
0.2282865494,
0.3350184262,
-0.6224373579,
-0.4616331458,
0.0815400705,
0.5938199759,
0.4493628442,
-0.3040860593,
0.2762964964,
0.4503084421,
0.2084987164,
-0.0604982711,
0.3129756153,
-0.4754767418,
-1.0984025002,
-0.7312033176,
-0.8316819668,
-0.2308536768,
0.1833020598,
-0.739097774,
0.1910701543,
-0.2980170548,
0.1965110004,
-0.4291599095,
-0.0076300497,
-0.8132244945,
0.1815925092,
0.4655347466,
1.0088243484,
-0.8998723626,
1.1493052244,
0.6968455911,
-0.5438206196,
-1.0017352104,
0.005655732,
-0.0354301669,
-0.8849291801,
0.4812672436,
0.1718170196,
-0.0175957885,
0.3387719989,
-0.2630934417,
-0.5576874018,
1.0697127581,
0.5740435719,
-0.790471673,
0.2054043263,
0.2658686042,
0.47637707,
-0.1865976453,
0.14773646,
0.5748169422,
0.4456682205,
0.2733534873,
-1.1026749611,
-0.2759038806,
-0.0323295631,
0.024747422,
0.23750633,
-0.2482947111,
0.7670348287,
-0.2504509985,
-0.2865526974,
-0.3014239073,
0.470947206,
0.3426796794,
0.5810028315,
0.6143520474,
1.0481094122,
0.6255726814,
-0.04504399,
0.9166352749,
-0.6374312043,
0.163089335,
1.2642458677,
-0.6730966568,
1.013954401,
0.7297252417,
0.2217805982,
0.2977069914,
0.5316715837,
0.2734655738,
0.5754814744,
0.0096924743,
-0.4636593163,
-0.4212767482,
-0.2535810173,
-0.3529926538,
0.768617332,
0.2414241433,
0.0764880404,
-0.5417231321,
0.367646277,
0.0373095945,
0.1282232255,
-0.4682948291,
0.8080019355,
0.3115073442,
-0.6727083325,
0.5392221808,
0.0021674316,
0.8815116882,
-0.7230465412,
0.0308708549,
-0.3475832045,
0.1818898022,
0.1273571551,
-0.6917085052,
0.4967319071,
0.1149785072,
-0.0670272931,
-0.489923656,
0.82681036,
-0.8988426924,
-0.4073922634,
0.5993320942,
1.0499100685,
0.35805884,
-0.3947670758,
-0.6947357655,
-0.1407643408,
-0.1420869827,
-0.08611238,
0.5663627982,
0.7090678811,
-0.06269297,
0.1953132898,
0.7327375412,
0.3001571596,
0.1845339388,
0.3132785261,
0.5441379547,
-0.5426604152,
-0.370601058,
-0.7305089235,
0.4379757941,
-0.0313215107,
-0.429518193,
0.7481299639,
0.4292339385,
1.574708581,
-0.1133472174,
0.6642566919,
-0.0747108907,
0.4128525853,
-0.2657171786,
0.8728717566,
-0.989633739,
-0.1620348096,
0.0081576314,
-0.8253577948,
-0.3267312944,
0.8230606318,
-0.418127507,
-0.1557150334,
0.6410056949,
0.7632212043,
-0.2595537305,
-0.6088375449,
0.917501092,
0.0108997449,
0.052715607,
0.6708787084,
0.4743060768,
-0.3327064216,
0.6069003344,
-0.3121955097,
-0.1089373529,
0.05281692,
-1.1464185715,
-0.6632306576,
-0.600687325,
-0.2092392296,
0.0963751078,
-0.1904478967,
0.5420499444,
0.8579804301,
-0.6988463998,
-0.1361199617,
-0.1098736003,
-0.0711291581,
-0.1599460393,
-0.1686684787,
-0.0874220282,
-0.5434876084,
-0.7395752668,
0.7026361823,
0.409488678,
-0.0124816336,
-0.3095802963,
-0.275432229,
-0.1863981485,
-0.0225131437,
0.9771274328,
0.4283017814,
-0.6286313534,
-0.2976799011,
0.022714328,
-0.0744310841,
-0.2582472265,
0.6836725473,
-0.8529946804,
0.4985492826,
0.5904538631,
0.6038597226,
0.4778248072,
-0.0856746659,
0.6211004257,
-1.0059176683,
0.6862515211,
0.0360303931,
0.467996031,
0.4142200649,
0.1189500466,
0.302308321,
0.4314513206,
-0.0463645458,
-0.9435921907,
0.3475749493,
-0.862862885,
-0.5357867479,
1.0907582045,
-0.3798001707,
-0.1608330607,
-0.0299688261,
0.0145880226,
0.4159175754,
0.0582074709,
0.4724027812,
0.768874526,
0.167247653,
-0.373031944,
-0.4996404648,
0.2293055058,
0.7095131278,
-0.6166380048,
-0.0965420455,
0.5859818459,
0.4427159727,
0.0626250654,
0.6552576423,
-0.1455765963,
0.1494956315,
-0.0060072741,
0.2237998992,
-0.2587248385,
-0.5170362592,
-0.4541382492,
0.0667661205,
0.1527160704,
-0.2766229808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13783v1 | Fine Tuning with Abnormal Examples | 2023-04-26T18:59:48 | 2023-04-26T18:59:48 | Will Rieger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given the prevalence of crowd sourced labor in creating Natural Language
processing datasets, these aforementioned sets have become increasingly large.
For instance, the SQUAD dataset currently sits at over 80,000 records. However,
because the English language is rather repetitive in structure, the
distribution of word frequencies in the SQUAD dataset's contexts are relatively
unchanged. By measuring each sentences distance from the co-variate distance of
frequencies of all sentences in the dataset, we identify 10,500 examples that
create a more uniform distribution for training. While fine-tuning ELECTRA [4]
on this subset of examples reaches better performance to a model trained on all
87,000 examples. Herein we introduce a methodology for systematically pruning
datasets for fine tuning reaching better out of sample performance. | [
-0.7118268609,
-0.8452885747,
0.1765803546,
-0.0604798011,
-0.3180799484,
-0.1202406958,
-0.3638117909,
-0.4332601726,
0.0902167931,
0.5295055509,
-0.8698524833,
-0.4171823263,
-0.3204109371,
0.2793374062,
-0.5878058076,
1.1421077251,
0.1449078768,
-0.3173210025,
0.1833688766,
-0.4049057961,
-0.6326776743,
-0.2637906075,
-0.653367579,
-0.0070320298,
0.3650235534,
0.9718956947,
0.6470294595,
1.0873156786,
0.4837402105,
0.3057641089,
0.2275357544,
0.7801257372,
-1.0123186111,
0.1973977387,
-0.0995002389,
-0.5973041654,
0.088338539,
0.1777977496,
0.5209678411,
0.6302089691,
-0.2018133402,
0.1927693635,
-0.2107740194,
0.7867665887,
-0.2997117043,
-0.1448457837,
-0.8709950447,
-0.2460602522,
-0.5307824016,
-0.2725969255,
-0.2561154068,
-0.3601043522,
-0.1481525004,
-0.7201958895,
0.8465742469,
0.1957353354,
1.0884848833,
0.3354872167,
0.0175375622,
-0.1784163266,
-0.7494972348,
0.86460042,
-0.4449441433,
0.0912783295,
0.6518698931,
0.2510287166,
-0.2330430895,
-0.4423445761,
-0.4971708655,
-0.0039013566,
0.2102185488,
-0.1316433847,
-0.2589123845,
0.1082263887,
0.1676649004,
0.3492051959,
-0.3300791383,
0.3221897781,
-0.5980178714,
-0.0975283682,
1.0629329681,
0.3509451151,
0.1642962247,
0.2215512693,
0.1950673908,
-0.2981711328,
-0.7252959013,
-0.1185770929,
0.8574290276,
0.4115968645,
0.2020619363,
0.6386811733,
-0.5468225479,
1.1092121601,
0.146819666,
0.2759832442,
0.3164410293,
-0.4909193516,
-0.2535623312,
-0.0888143107,
0.4377462566,
0.7117716074,
0.6905923486,
-0.1989204735,
-0.2275462151,
0.2474656105,
0.5147702098,
-0.5777864456,
-0.5878990293,
0.0715097412,
-0.2940121591,
-0.251493752,
0.1090195179,
-0.7479227185,
-0.3152135015,
-0.6074361801,
0.086480543,
-0.8297486901,
0.0608312823,
0.1323357522,
-0.3616488278,
-0.0193417259,
-0.0013241897,
-0.8114006519,
0.2974372208,
0.7727966309,
0.8665028811,
-0.1095748544,
-0.4073122442,
-0.6917392015,
-0.0499505363,
-0.4233606756,
1.19460392,
-0.6643220186,
-0.176020205,
0.0128576234,
0.2119722068,
-0.1494215727,
-0.8451806307,
0.5893456936,
-0.1462784559,
-0.2333429009,
-0.1705277264,
-0.8086366653,
-0.2164888531,
-0.1120338663,
-0.533575058,
0.9780007005,
0.2151430696,
-0.2603664994,
0.8278130293,
-0.5408217907,
-0.5939942598,
0.0097677689,
0.0062366421,
-0.4658102989,
0.4353362024,
0.2107312232,
0.7225234509,
0.0796082541,
0.1187308207,
-0.3279453516,
-0.519667387,
-0.2109909952,
-0.1659909636,
0.4571686685,
0.5044022799,
0.0178018082,
-0.0160164889,
-1.0095237494,
-0.0725835115,
-0.1937562376,
-0.0633868724,
-0.6423555017,
0.1630948037,
0.2904476225,
0.0194104575,
-0.1916994005,
-0.2681439221,
0.2558126748,
-0.7869864106,
0.7404427528,
0.6448728442,
0.3637549579,
0.3620815873,
-0.8093618155,
0.38023597,
-0.0421749502,
-0.0097611882,
-0.1022697613,
-0.2910833359,
-0.6385795474,
-0.4294841588,
-0.0579920784,
0.3036285043,
-0.5164769888,
0.6912834644,
0.0461213775,
-0.7059528232,
-0.8315441608,
0.5193152428,
0.0270229355,
0.3863171041,
0.4534065127,
-0.0619910583,
-0.6438838243,
-1.2021335363,
-0.5909349918,
0.2155754119,
0.0221628603,
0.1129588261,
0.2968887985,
-0.0045703202,
1.1417845488,
-0.4656013548,
-0.4754920006,
-0.2224480957,
0.3239003122,
0.3935163915,
0.6245816946,
0.5181075931,
-0.7314373851,
-0.2686005831,
-0.1201466694,
-0.1010562703,
-0.127712369,
-0.3270211816,
-0.2051210999,
0.0286625028,
0.7609545588,
-0.2510846555,
0.3444506824,
0.242713213,
-0.2581910193,
0.2467080057,
-0.2526485622,
-0.0237743463,
-1.0529558659,
-0.1741857678,
0.4126970172,
-0.354683131,
-0.6239401698,
0.0769086033,
-0.132245332,
0.2368625253,
-0.3273925185,
0.0425800458,
-0.5139721036,
0.3965782225,
-0.1426202953,
0.0421191454,
-0.268686235,
0.2409034371,
-0.227359131,
0.8357000947,
0.3318246901,
-0.8903602958,
0.4001446068,
0.1286174953,
-0.7425214648,
0.6113144159,
-0.7037069201,
0.0250117239,
-0.2746780813,
-0.0960110798,
-1.103173852,
-0.5238124132,
-0.3106866181,
0.0691623688,
0.170581013,
-0.0005830419,
-0.5373564363,
-0.3691294491,
-0.3701873124,
0.1165920049,
0.5157476068,
-0.4068001807,
-0.1689860374,
0.7209937572,
-0.0212275609,
-0.0571292341,
-0.4788855016,
-0.144634068,
-0.565875411,
-0.4631326497,
0.3860358298,
0.0284077059,
-0.4089422524,
-0.1941891462,
-0.0009988603,
-0.3760111332,
0.1749558747,
0.1233837828,
-0.1027926356,
0.0345701203,
0.3873556256,
0.0711516365,
0.1696200371,
-0.4269069135,
0.0871422663,
0.6884099841,
-0.0514862575,
-0.1526458263,
-0.3491474688,
0.2911999822,
0.3919654787,
-0.0282256342,
0.6281241775,
0.546434164,
-0.3668367863,
-0.4425622821,
-0.6673179865,
-0.2013993114,
-0.5169699788,
0.6993416548,
-0.2139049023,
-0.6555261016,
0.4252690673,
0.0842760652,
0.4320904911,
0.4228556454,
0.5003097653,
-0.121392034,
1.0850535631,
0.711593926,
-0.5273355246,
0.6360577941,
-0.3310866356,
0.2810992002,
-0.4166913331,
0.1334791481,
-0.6728283167,
-0.6319670081,
-0.5313282013,
-0.3729597032,
0.1224052906,
0.2823028564,
-0.1777539253,
0.5494664311,
-0.7858552337,
0.911534965,
0.5969673395,
0.2403783202,
0.2372506857,
0.1531410962,
0.1679357439,
-0.0588431284,
-0.7087706327,
-0.4758304954,
0.8267449737,
0.1509351432,
0.5498287678,
-0.1694631726,
0.6869091392,
0.1434048712,
0.2461295128,
-0.7021280527,
0.2740096152,
-0.4461842775,
-0.6092909575,
-0.5038240552,
-0.3562600613,
-1.1044470072,
-0.2771148682,
0.083603248,
-0.704869926,
0.3009982407,
0.3390942216,
-0.4895519614,
-0.00669266,
-1.03733325,
0.6252277493,
0.3104847968,
-0.171717003,
-0.3847297728,
-0.3620538414,
0.3224408329,
-0.0707115382,
0.2188385129,
-0.4150844812,
-0.0007155918,
0.7556312084,
-0.7738025784,
0.7488859296,
-0.045534797,
0.1349521875,
0.3462641239,
-0.0059060492,
0.5830767751,
0.0494632199,
-0.3241734207,
-0.0929600969,
-0.0378582291,
-0.5654156208,
-0.1085408926,
0.6629353166,
-0.6574047804,
-0.2792533636,
0.1857047528,
-0.8038192391,
-0.4990861416,
-0.0053839441,
0.6814971566,
0.456473738,
-0.1206147745,
0.3652046025,
0.3958219588,
-0.0542336367,
0.625797689,
0.443222791,
0.3809648156,
-0.1131227463,
0.9085195065,
0.5350500941,
0.0247771312,
0.0447821543,
-0.0568609312,
-0.2539520264,
-0.7434444427,
-0.4408405721,
0.059843488,
-0.204488039,
-0.3919692338,
-0.4404340982,
0.1495892555,
-0.2954601943,
-0.2882941663,
-0.2679715455,
-0.3016334474,
-0.3699580431,
-0.242471993,
1.0083187819,
0.7313779593,
0.0241565499,
0.4732252359,
-0.6067039967,
0.3963884115,
0.095825322,
0.6048429608,
-0.1896853149,
-0.6223855019,
-0.3612706959,
0.1973845214,
-0.1529664546,
-0.8320441246,
0.7095268369,
0.6803911328,
0.5579727292,
0.5273715854,
0.0968154669,
1.3037637472,
-0.6258016229,
0.6710740328,
-0.0795897171,
-0.6254948974,
0.6029152274,
-0.6732696891,
0.0451628603,
1.2278174162,
0.2297795266,
-0.4239704609,
-0.738173306,
-0.7916673422,
-1.069861412,
0.7590574026,
0.1116031185,
0.1691778451,
-0.346849829,
0.4466612935,
0.2494353354,
0.1645324677,
-0.1461963505,
-0.2571954131,
0.0557473414,
-0.5935046673,
-0.4613417983,
0.2046191245,
-0.2190894336,
-0.7029765248,
0.6774471998,
-0.1441350877,
-0.07799761,
0.1362500936,
-0.276270479,
-0.1633941531,
-0.1039933264,
0.6994005442,
0.6335480213,
-0.0140404338,
-0.0402826816,
0.2753608823,
-0.6981065869,
-0.0223644935,
0.0924662724,
-0.0861931071,
0.115034692,
0.132781446,
0.5384919643,
0.1036398783,
-0.773987174,
0.0680386275,
0.1931062043,
-0.2749301493,
-0.1405227333,
0.4360059798,
-0.0061916513,
-0.0501614437,
0.4017348588,
0.2121193856,
0.1560148746,
-0.5602077842,
0.6330959797,
0.3064087629,
-0.5026928186,
-0.1969435811,
0.2907817662,
0.2425513417,
-0.5023866296,
0.7248504758,
-0.2356726378,
-0.2044220865,
0.893887341,
0.2642558813,
0.5623781085,
-0.0008478787,
0.1715860367,
0.3851060569,
0.3880118728,
-0.5940700769,
0.2502916157,
0.1722729206,
-0.7848997116,
-0.486207515,
-0.5363516808,
-0.0727694854,
0.3227199912,
-0.7703619599,
0.4471594989,
-0.261850208,
0.2322955579,
0.2046387494,
0.1310464591,
-0.9152479768,
0.0807573572,
-0.2909467816,
1.0234702826,
-1.1302297115,
0.9119073153,
0.726511538,
-0.48043859,
-1.0216081142,
-0.2764753401,
-0.2111119628,
-0.9841686487,
0.2663347125,
0.1927982867,
0.3748930097,
0.2243383676,
-0.6522328258,
-0.4285282791,
0.643237412,
0.2647120357,
-1.122045517,
0.282217443,
0.01743415,
0.6582337618,
-0.3264727294,
-0.0365469828,
1.1094588041,
0.3959855735,
-0.5289165974,
-0.7120708823,
-0.2653793097,
-0.3374734819,
-0.2377877533,
0.473549813,
-0.7835001945,
0.6437986493,
0.0884490311,
-0.0277510379,
0.0989656001,
0.3049510121,
0.1507398933,
0.4266103804,
0.7159611583,
0.6367411613,
1.108348012,
-0.1997710019,
0.9759994149,
-0.2623938918,
0.2629315853,
1.0419914722,
-0.1208097488,
0.7193409801,
0.5375786424,
-0.1897436976,
0.1817511767,
0.8538969159,
-0.4194096029,
0.583899796,
0.3580473363,
-0.0634070337,
-0.2979569733,
-0.0547024943,
-0.2223366648,
0.4072559774,
0.3151012063,
-0.4070731103,
-0.3108628392,
0.0547753684,
-0.0294100605,
0.3859940469,
-0.579417944,
0.8649329543,
-0.1722305417,
-0.7718352079,
0.6067504287,
-0.0877656788,
0.7495152354,
-0.1733939946,
-0.0915377885,
-0.3857611716,
0.1439408064,
-0.279276967,
-0.5688869953,
0.6077313423,
0.0667174235,
-0.3831233382,
-0.2714859843,
0.6410386562,
-0.3652265668,
-0.6674456596,
-0.3786340356,
0.387531966,
0.3424746394,
-0.0857034773,
-0.3683866858,
-0.2727214992,
0.0899859294,
-0.1493282616,
0.3027667105,
0.7128252983,
-0.0838683918,
0.5147876143,
0.6179418564,
0.3174940646,
0.2458001822,
0.2120431662,
0.7706766725,
-0.6416091919,
-0.5911102295,
-0.9454373121,
0.2335741967,
-0.4416670203,
-0.8932756186,
0.7452847958,
0.6729697585,
0.8793894649,
-0.123294875,
0.707876265,
-0.002676971,
0.7334659696,
-0.2338242978,
0.597951889,
-0.2830311656,
0.1807534248,
-0.2899318039,
-0.7796866298,
-0.2196969241,
1.016289711,
-0.2088924497,
-0.307721585,
0.320810169,
1.0205632448,
-0.0820316747,
0.2266490161,
0.3360687792,
0.275256604,
0.1183250472,
0.3518595397,
0.624420166,
-0.2598313093,
0.6304184198,
-0.5159186125,
-0.0063928841,
-0.2668633461,
-0.8579576015,
-0.7368335724,
-0.6132121682,
-0.245244652,
-0.0414722264,
0.1848364472,
0.9608605504,
1.0786243677,
-0.9670790434,
-0.1172552109,
-0.7055901885,
-0.018320784,
-0.6824548841,
-0.3255019486,
-0.0497619286,
-0.6478611827,
-0.7967156768,
0.474824965,
-0.00047202,
-0.2738720179,
0.0914704725,
0.2449440807,
-0.2606251836,
-0.0920574144,
0.3526436388,
0.2831811011,
-0.194431141,
-0.5652166605,
-0.1708087176,
0.2646238506,
-0.0065628993,
0.8172470331,
-0.7542812228,
0.1944120973,
0.389636308,
0.5232255459,
0.3515525162,
0.2272941172,
0.8502774239,
-1.1426694393,
0.3673952818,
0.3347499371,
0.18797566,
0.1782074273,
-0.412114054,
0.7129118443,
0.114983663,
-0.5691354871,
-1.2120500803,
0.0860431641,
-0.7982723713,
-0.2395498902,
1.089443326,
0.1986361146,
0.0562969707,
-0.6710134149,
-0.2628182471,
0.4080173671,
-0.5778900981,
0.9781161547,
0.8883306384,
-0.2734002173,
0.0895693526,
-0.7662411332,
0.7318518758,
0.4456914067,
-0.6438438892,
0.2417283803,
0.5686284304,
0.4337940514,
-0.0164035279,
0.3648176789,
0.2490092069,
0.2115273923,
-0.139914453,
-0.2607334256,
-0.1697288007,
-0.2383184135,
-0.3555378616,
0.3409789205,
-0.1026672795,
-0.2617250681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13714v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13714v3 | Evaluation of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 for supporting real-world information needs in healthcare delivery | 2023-04-26T17:54:28 | 2023-05-01T00:41:37 | Debadutta Dash, Rahul Thapa, Juan M. Banda, Akshay Swaminathan, Morgan Cheatham, Mehr Kashyap, Nikesh Kotecha, Jonathan H. Chen, Saurabh Gombar, Lance Downing, Rachel Pedreira, Ethan Goh, Angel Arnaout, Garret Kenn Morris, Honor Magon, Matthew P Lungren, Eric Horvitz, Nigam H. Shah | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Despite growing interest in using large language models (LLMs) in healthcare,
current explorations do not assess the real-world utility and safety of LLMs in
clinical settings. Our objective was to determine whether two LLMs can serve
information needs submitted by physicians as questions to an informatics
consultation service in a safe and concordant manner. Sixty six questions from
an informatics consult service were submitted to GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 via simple
prompts. 12 physicians assessed the LLM responses' possibility of patient harm
and concordance with existing reports from an informatics consultation service.
Physician assessments were summarized based on majority vote. For no questions
did a majority of physicians deem either LLM response as harmful. For GPT-3.5,
responses to 8 questions were concordant with the informatics consult report,
20 discordant, and 9 were unable to be assessed. There were 29 responses with
no majority on "Agree", "Disagree", and "Unable to assess". For GPT-4,
responses to 13 questions were concordant, 15 discordant, and 3 were unable to
be assessed. There were 35 responses with no majority. Responses from both LLMs
were largely devoid of overt harm, but less than 20% of the responses agreed
with an answer from an informatics consultation service, responses contained
hallucinated references, and physicians were divided on what constitutes harm.
These results suggest that while general purpose LLMs are able to provide safe
and credible responses, they often do not meet the specific information need of
a given question. A definitive evaluation of the usefulness of LLMs in
healthcare settings will likely require additional research on prompt
engineering, calibration, and custom-tailoring of general purpose models. | [
-0.3010106087,
-0.730330348,
1.1445297003,
0.252230823,
-0.2682688832,
-0.4715854526,
-0.0746328831,
-0.9622970819,
-0.0481917523,
0.4600359201,
-0.396282047,
-0.4475788772,
-0.5875200629,
0.4149440527,
-0.3422619402,
0.9095118046,
-0.1611826569,
0.3762997687,
-0.0866616294,
0.2575338483,
-0.6070048213,
-0.7904621959,
-0.5841674805,
0.0114267701,
0.6630607247,
0.3444761038,
0.8396280408,
0.2273353785,
0.9973042011,
0.1796371788,
0.0763494,
-0.1614979655,
-0.2359220684,
0.2595677674,
-0.0578765869,
-0.2848767936,
-0.4253186285,
0.1770189106,
0.5058805346,
0.7173413634,
-0.164993301,
0.1795448214,
0.0032322581,
0.5682197809,
-0.4715057015,
0.0551825799,
-0.1850560308,
0.2463365644,
0.007982295,
-0.2721867263,
-0.4594185948,
-0.7489873767,
0.5344585776,
-0.767600894,
-0.107250005,
0.3038365245,
0.8970728517,
0.2630724311,
-0.4816333354,
-0.5935188532,
-0.9010030627,
0.4172538817,
-0.76483953,
0.389813602,
0.4409463704,
0.332247287,
-0.0889006704,
-0.662853837,
-0.4192600548,
-0.383094877,
-0.1758828908,
0.3191012442,
-0.1885246634,
0.3386795819,
0.6295035481,
0.2669387758,
-0.7289714813,
0.1835702062,
-0.3779976964,
-0.2467149198,
0.487519592,
0.454844892,
0.3045500517,
-0.1123076081,
-0.5289192796,
0.091454424,
-0.9817313552,
-0.2219581157,
0.2161097527,
-0.008741674,
-0.1378180087,
0.6242819428,
0.0922043398,
0.6985762715,
0.0260464456,
-0.3718070388,
0.0232432559,
-0.3882622421,
-0.2477182895,
-0.0801527202,
0.92412889,
0.8404841423,
0.2336778641,
-0.1189479679,
-0.084375158,
-0.0772321969,
0.4604266286,
-0.854414463,
0.0616829954,
0.414303422,
-0.4855948985,
-0.0883039236,
0.0615568832,
-0.5754951835,
-0.6507900953,
-0.3767737448,
0.3014478981,
-0.3316210508,
-0.1979417801,
0.1376888901,
0.0687954351,
0.3860193193,
0.5043958426,
-0.6835147738,
0.4151748717,
0.5038384795,
0.7461082339,
-0.3255317807,
0.0837894678,
-0.0569039509,
0.1632447094,
-0.4548892081,
0.8972471356,
-0.2495006621,
-0.6995513439,
0.1858847439,
0.2374559343,
-0.0730375573,
-0.7192249894,
0.7815656066,
-0.4305078983,
0.2084289342,
-0.6149527431,
-0.529445529,
-0.1614888608,
0.5040493608,
-0.6924230456,
0.4503574669,
0.1470845491,
-0.9932851791,
0.4963648319,
-0.522276938,
-0.2868344784,
0.233576864,
-0.4731357992,
-0.1778657585,
-0.2560229301,
-0.108038567,
0.4104732871,
-0.7372297049,
0.3925045133,
-0.3342143297,
-0.5623629689,
0.2754382789,
-0.5599256754,
0.3176223338,
0.2033094913,
-0.3369441926,
-0.0042291866,
-0.5743159652,
0.2077843398,
0.0559522063,
-0.6231545806,
-0.1198578104,
-0.1046247929,
-0.0301858,
0.2137152553,
0.0612317473,
-0.6301626563,
0.176273495,
-0.3445638418,
0.0302863438,
0.5712510943,
0.3590304852,
0.0518062413,
-0.6613248587,
0.6784558296,
0.0640066788,
0.4964137077,
0.2258945554,
-0.7327126265,
-0.3702724278,
0.0395122692,
0.0357567221,
0.6525270939,
-0.7214542031,
0.1296180934,
-0.4333241284,
-0.4165796041,
-0.2701465189,
-0.4318814874,
0.3964540064,
0.9124265909,
0.3000886738,
-0.1318386197,
-0.3698984087,
-1.2122751474,
-0.3016182482,
-0.4647789598,
-0.2087439448,
0.6381458044,
0.1538801491,
-0.369697243,
0.7075873017,
-0.3794949651,
-0.079900533,
0.1213168949,
-0.0373573638,
0.2920612991,
0.0886901915,
0.3527577817,
-0.7948505878,
-0.4350195825,
-0.1705756038,
-0.9083573222,
-0.220335111,
0.1313625723,
0.2638451755,
0.0359699912,
-0.1130928695,
-0.4946395457,
0.2859782875,
0.5118706226,
-0.1008395106,
0.6349009275,
-0.2779000998,
0.5226349235,
-0.9261642098,
0.345698148,
0.1207892522,
0.0400039032,
-0.9544868469,
-0.2307654768,
0.1007293612,
-0.0345285162,
-0.4233587086,
0.5411507487,
-0.2820744812,
-0.0481307246,
-0.0704034194,
0.1845539957,
-0.1137591377,
-0.0414599106,
0.0185914058,
0.9092459083,
0.3197669387,
-0.7104510069,
0.3782758713,
0.2424004078,
-0.2986738086,
0.7889425755,
-0.7128433585,
0.189259991,
0.0408590585,
0.1711184084,
-0.6997452974,
-0.609139502,
0.5298237801,
-0.1399704963,
0.1746089309,
-0.1687757075,
-0.661215961,
-0.5323063135,
-0.273740679,
0.430331707,
0.4374275804,
-0.1224484593,
0.3425799608,
0.4255517125,
-0.5148278475,
-0.3706580997,
-0.9305950403,
0.1953250319,
-0.2796833217,
-0.7192550898,
-0.0764152631,
-0.2000874728,
-0.3737277091,
-0.1132791787,
-0.1130755171,
-0.2708815634,
-0.0139684491,
0.480877459,
0.48023808,
-0.061452128,
0.3015893996,
-0.2441717088,
-0.1025940999,
0.3148274422,
-0.0533406809,
0.2700319588,
-0.083392933,
-0.8440628052,
-0.4514038861,
0.6359935403,
0.4477392435,
0.1974250227,
0.4295765758,
0.3704477847,
-0.4033315778,
0.4462354779,
-0.9168316722,
-0.1339568049,
-0.4218624234,
0.2041758895,
-0.0837410763,
-1.0956341028,
0.2058711797,
-0.0399419777,
0.1091317981,
0.4878698289,
0.6144518256,
-0.037847288,
0.8745394349,
0.1523682773,
0.1316099763,
0.0083970632,
0.0982892886,
0.4163785875,
-0.7590420842,
-0.4623224139,
-0.512984097,
0.0966008231,
-0.6166527271,
-0.0776434168,
0.9327661991,
-0.2934035957,
-0.304079473,
-0.0512235537,
-0.6441398263,
-0.0449532643,
0.2876270413,
0.243696481,
0.3528064191,
-0.0526284464,
-0.0813053548,
-0.038823802,
-0.4894964993,
-0.8357126117,
1.065310359,
0.4420979321,
1.3480755091,
0.3143845797,
0.3779942393,
0.1026636362,
0.4635178745,
-0.8600142002,
0.5103832483,
0.0370178595,
-0.6964223981,
-0.1528225094,
-0.5206434727,
-1.0116497278,
0.0936221257,
-0.0768831521,
-0.7580549717,
0.0727887675,
0.2066311538,
-0.5351989865,
0.0673801675,
-0.9209166765,
0.4952886701,
-0.4337659478,
-0.1764110476,
0.2083916068,
-0.8503359556,
0.34204036,
-0.3563606739,
0.4604336023,
0.0082025556,
-0.2871094644,
0.7571127415,
-0.3257178664,
0.7654006481,
-0.1439766735,
-0.3474054635,
0.2345217019,
-0.0496024266,
0.3392541409,
0.139490664,
-0.1403834373,
-0.0010127095,
0.5959081054,
0.0815528408,
-0.5809898973,
0.7570801377,
-0.762348175,
-0.9498922229,
-0.6429226398,
-0.3849568963,
-0.620813787,
0.3846512139,
0.2398291528,
0.5170398355,
-0.1009088084,
0.0789168254,
0.7079137564,
-0.1348343939,
0.0966128483,
0.8761359453,
0.0216928367,
-0.2249467969,
0.4694875479,
0.2164598554,
0.4057379961,
0.1039546728,
0.2288488001,
-0.3143809438,
-0.651931107,
-0.3084678352,
0.2992892563,
-0.8484926224,
-0.0718472973,
-0.6358035207,
-0.3735024035,
-0.280472517,
0.2568607628,
0.1344330013,
-0.0220742244,
-0.2896169722,
0.0248297527,
0.1037726998,
1.1840108633,
0.2198908776,
0.0240205284,
-1.115403533,
0.138770178,
0.1436339617,
0.5611786246,
-0.4118766189,
-0.3391082585,
-0.164156422,
-0.0299737193,
-0.1685859561,
-1.1704483032,
-0.0820602551,
-0.153759107,
0.6370075941,
0.3323194087,
0.0948861986,
0.5463398099,
-0.5951328874,
1.0449260473,
0.3116087019,
-0.4528725147,
0.4039928913,
-0.4614484608,
0.257755965,
0.5211347342,
0.8018916845,
-0.7554489374,
-0.0945772901,
-0.4077854156,
-0.7195804119,
0.5526863933,
-0.060971126,
-0.0082503334,
-0.23878555,
0.6193793416,
-0.1448439956,
0.1086486056,
-0.6800352931,
-0.087776944,
0.1206526086,
-0.124926798,
0.2890913188,
-0.499871999,
-0.461579144,
0.284884274,
0.3996587694,
-0.0326628014,
0.562548995,
0.5786643028,
0.3003672063,
-0.2362459004,
0.6676414013,
0.5104755163,
0.7611819506,
-0.0567838512,
0.2671197653,
0.1284007728,
-0.7920770049,
0.3275783956,
0.1718677133,
-0.1453968138,
-0.2500125468,
0.3810251653,
0.3807629347,
0.1649665684,
-0.652643621,
0.809637785,
-0.2973574698,
-0.3269615173,
-0.2910898328,
0.1418150812,
0.0275628567,
-0.0278818924,
0.0473727323,
-0.1294424832,
0.3149990737,
-0.3079140186,
0.0594682768,
0.3793181479,
-0.5489817262,
-0.174295634,
0.4352117479,
0.0467775203,
-0.0787424371,
0.3473526835,
0.0568963066,
-0.0714162737,
0.3357595503,
0.7457183003,
0.5855392218,
-0.388240993,
-0.0380433463,
0.26881212,
0.3149164021,
-0.1684374809,
0.6201065779,
0.4394849241,
-0.432346642,
-0.1699418128,
-0.1893424243,
-0.7626158595,
0.2679457664,
-0.6945623755,
0.0435306951,
-0.6638802886,
-0.6175530553,
-0.2765836418,
-0.2450288981,
-0.6854498982,
0.4234364331,
-0.0224819183,
0.8757659793,
-0.5272622108,
0.339637816,
0.7619656324,
-0.5307058096,
-1.3285648823,
0.1830113977,
0.1747812182,
-0.5815793872,
0.4515973628,
0.0126073807,
-0.097896412,
-0.3239842355,
-0.5398501158,
-1.0416533947,
1.203769207,
0.4126391411,
-0.6021311879,
-0.3052979708,
0.309483856,
0.6071256995,
-0.0360553376,
0.4854531586,
0.2902781069,
0.6172606945,
0.1576102972,
-1.2899155617,
0.390063554,
-0.1466308981,
-0.0776511878,
0.061134778,
-0.5427451134,
0.7159034014,
0.0748644546,
-0.3784547448,
0.0933227465,
-0.1549934894,
0.215888232,
0.082504198,
0.3715132177,
0.336425215,
0.7956748009,
-0.2124804854,
1.487285018,
-0.4402300715,
0.1791440099,
0.8341536522,
-0.4586397111,
0.6485720873,
0.4083434045,
-0.4018964469,
0.206445083,
0.7127124667,
-0.0449493602,
0.3363966942,
0.2128414512,
-0.4852378368,
0.0674989074,
-0.2405236512,
-0.6802369952,
-0.2008831203,
0.4406651855,
-0.2787363529,
-0.0694169551,
-0.0674549639,
0.1725090593,
-0.4887323678,
0.0238120817,
0.8337025046,
0.1610023528,
-0.8675833344,
0.5666581392,
-0.0633267686,
0.1807104647,
-0.8368009925,
-0.1348158866,
0.0997623056,
-0.1123383567,
-0.5217375159,
-0.9887107611,
0.1781429648,
0.2387333214,
0.0063706632,
0.0323237963,
0.7238665223,
0.0529411398,
-0.2723931372,
0.1820247173,
0.2977550626,
0.3412961364,
0.1339319199,
-0.4523693621,
0.123291418,
-0.1684921682,
-0.2722133398,
0.2769898772,
0.1679716408,
-0.0667878017,
0.7098440528,
0.4577034414,
0.3377783298,
-0.0683329031,
0.2243129462,
1.1936347485,
-0.4801368117,
-0.1542657316,
-0.5576062799,
0.1883307844,
0.0802255869,
-0.16060853,
0.6285974979,
0.4743832648,
0.3754816353,
0.0947058946,
1.1197140217,
0.0107179154,
0.6455565691,
-0.682213068,
0.3678559363,
-0.2707389891,
0.4189025462,
-0.3261418939,
-0.7859737277,
-0.5217922926,
0.3376371264,
-0.748067379,
0.3405062556,
0.903039217,
0.5520811677,
0.1638621688,
0.3729279637,
0.3491392732,
0.3560011685,
0.661055088,
0.5000323653,
1.001413703,
-0.2219855785,
0.4932892621,
0.0416355878,
-0.4957617521,
-0.0593817085,
-0.710863173,
-0.7719934583,
-0.1692128479,
0.0284555256,
-0.316950947,
0.1612722427,
0.9559813142,
0.6282787323,
-0.5856509805,
0.1362800151,
0.2436347157,
-0.3281530738,
0.42628479,
-0.1432174593,
0.4178236127,
-0.1692472398,
-0.2927823961,
0.3701182008,
0.4986594021,
0.2876152694,
-0.2594295442,
0.0511030816,
0.1968774647,
-0.1808646321,
0.3209224939,
0.0994238481,
-0.9141054153,
-0.613804698,
0.1850693077,
-0.5047190785,
0.1589420736,
0.7001262903,
-0.3493597806,
0.5176033378,
0.1955831945,
0.6995220184,
0.2578176558,
0.2305217534,
0.4651602209,
-0.2278016657,
-0.1648762673,
0.4822437465,
0.3755438626,
0.2768051326,
-0.7973164916,
0.4074975252,
0.1406277418,
-0.958910346,
-0.1941899508,
0.2454895824,
-0.8793242574,
0.2264053822,
1.5091203451,
-0.4122695029,
0.0659279153,
-0.4422602654,
-0.4584002197,
-0.1158792078,
-0.2449643165,
0.4597255588,
0.7872223258,
-0.4199222028,
0.0022480807,
-0.9984884858,
0.4260682464,
0.0645240396,
-1.1106253862,
-0.238447696,
0.634475112,
0.5242065191,
0.1638986319,
0.9935228229,
-0.4313269258,
0.3924128413,
-0.2191264033,
-0.3213965893,
0.0745147914,
0.0457561426,
-0.2314002216,
0.1376870275,
0.4899624288,
0.2124507874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13712v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13712v2 | Harnessing the Power of LLMs in Practice: A Survey on ChatGPT and Beyond | 2023-04-26T17:52:30 | 2023-04-27T17:56:11 | Jingfeng Yang, Hongye Jin, Ruixiang Tang, Xiaotian Han, Qizhang Feng, Haoming Jiang, Bing Yin, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper presents a comprehensive and practical guide for practitioners and
end-users working with Large Language Models (LLMs) in their downstream natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. We provide discussions and insights into the
usage of LLMs from the perspectives of models, data, and downstream tasks.
Firstly, we offer an introduction and brief summary of current GPT- and
BERT-style LLMs. Then, we discuss the influence of pre-training data, training
data, and test data. Most importantly, we provide a detailed discussion about
the use and non-use cases of large language models for various natural language
processing tasks, such as knowledge-intensive tasks, traditional natural
language understanding tasks, natural language generation tasks, emergent
abilities, and considerations for specific tasks.We present various use cases
and non-use cases to illustrate the practical applications and limitations of
LLMs in real-world scenarios. We also try to understand the importance of data
and the specific challenges associated with each NLP task. Furthermore, we
explore the impact of spurious biases on LLMs and delve into other essential
considerations, such as efficiency, cost, and latency, to ensure a
comprehensive understanding of deploying LLMs in practice. This comprehensive
guide aims to provide researchers and practitioners with valuable insights and
best practices for working with LLMs, thereby enabling the successful
implementation of these models in a wide range of NLP tasks. A curated list of
practical guide resources of LLMs, regularly updated, can be found at
\url{https://github.com/Mooler0410/LLMsPracticalGuide}. | [
-0.3195283413,
-0.6873312593,
0.6261082888,
0.2247947901,
-0.4357409775,
0.0335734822,
-0.3896618783,
-0.4925801158,
-0.1064734757,
0.8974626064,
-0.573205471,
-0.5747499466,
-0.6489174366,
0.044117827,
-0.5730124712,
1.0040347576,
-0.0512597859,
0.1315309852,
-0.1311291456,
0.2592133582,
-0.4666506648,
-0.8751885295,
-0.7983471751,
-0.3999087214,
0.6177877188,
0.2499505579,
0.608453393,
0.2117466033,
0.6664734483,
0.1601906717,
-0.3927536011,
0.1163622811,
-0.6252228618,
0.370233953,
-0.1809812337,
-0.4118003547,
-0.4467273951,
0.1269165576,
0.6302065253,
0.8171799183,
-0.4525945485,
0.1644350141,
0.1999424547,
0.5299885869,
-0.2611418962,
0.1855819672,
-0.810549736,
0.1135353222,
-0.2946441472,
-0.3434042633,
-0.3710737526,
-0.3317909241,
0.208886236,
-0.2625989318,
0.0645615384,
0.2215195596,
0.5040274262,
0.1295637786,
-0.5281183124,
-0.6025594473,
-0.7752031684,
0.8128302693,
-0.9657657146,
0.3251419961,
0.2015534788,
0.3838802576,
-0.3599788249,
-0.8728637695,
-0.4001196325,
-0.3841584623,
0.0108322212,
-0.0008196933,
-0.0643334538,
0.2343666255,
0.4331533313,
0.5493792892,
-0.4256481528,
0.2215732187,
-0.2686154246,
0.146306783,
0.5114071965,
0.1962071955,
0.2515923083,
0.0486187078,
-0.3513948619,
0.2200627178,
-0.9961938262,
-0.245881781,
0.3504949212,
0.3787785172,
0.0103434371,
0.6990525723,
0.047361657,
0.8144264221,
-0.4182895422,
-0.2242836058,
-0.1477927566,
-0.4496067464,
-0.2867794931,
-0.2639481127,
0.789152205,
0.228503719,
0.5174620748,
-0.3743394613,
-0.2385222018,
-0.4902454615,
0.5368382931,
-0.5825117826,
0.00981561,
-0.0633702204,
-0.2493353635,
-0.2170711011,
-0.4683285952,
-0.7572407126,
-0.4537338614,
-0.5973544121,
0.064821288,
-0.3395963013,
-0.2674500048,
0.1422737837,
-0.0086539416,
0.5183593035,
0.2166915089,
-1.0583178997,
0.5552787781,
0.7787469625,
1.0040988922,
-0.1763809621,
-0.0792520046,
-0.2214336991,
0.1610550582,
-0.2214455903,
0.6898198128,
-0.2232697457,
-0.419439733,
0.4319294095,
-0.0871661827,
-0.1598029584,
-0.617975235,
0.9794127345,
-0.5406169295,
0.0112098623,
-0.2612238824,
-0.7735443711,
-0.1655871421,
0.3785654902,
-0.5192492008,
0.9309347868,
-0.2200208604,
-0.6226441264,
0.1744508445,
-0.6744825244,
-0.4809184074,
0.1275919825,
-0.0318742171,
-0.0539418682,
0.1677678972,
0.1054715589,
0.8485845327,
-0.3962930739,
0.3688133061,
-0.0649444163,
-0.0389427878,
0.1205945909,
-0.4692007005,
0.7519388199,
0.173534885,
0.0657857731,
0.0151875848,
-0.4265076518,
-0.1112987176,
0.1977333277,
-0.4355484545,
-0.1370639056,
0.3333109319,
0.1893958896,
0.0866061002,
0.0964229703,
-0.2927976549,
0.3722171485,
-0.2267478257,
0.5902684927,
0.5524976254,
-0.0226869695,
0.3409406245,
-0.2971785069,
0.5529084206,
-0.4664364159,
0.1383650899,
-0.1824385971,
-0.5347698927,
-0.6706383228,
-0.1127055585,
0.2248769104,
0.5472416282,
-0.6260429025,
0.373267293,
-0.2034662664,
-0.714613378,
-0.3109912872,
0.3305944502,
-0.0180567615,
0.4689075649,
0.25799492,
-0.1578405797,
-0.5784361959,
-0.606117487,
-0.3024984002,
-0.0695174485,
-0.1430415958,
0.2759902477,
0.3846331239,
-0.1494711637,
1.0205823183,
-0.4070152044,
-0.3931975365,
-0.6915166974,
0.0871489346,
0.4256232679,
0.1625011116,
0.2229077369,
-0.7248042226,
-0.2914103866,
-0.2111879587,
-0.7245918512,
-0.2673001587,
-0.0977188796,
-0.1479010731,
0.1378453076,
0.5939742327,
-0.7332701087,
-0.0716337636,
0.7792695165,
-0.2028112411,
0.6548252106,
-0.1537012011,
-0.3146596551,
-1.1192443371,
0.0631236956,
0.1780357361,
-0.4917999208,
-0.8224984407,
0.1798349917,
-0.2218755186,
-0.0370921493,
-0.4145987332,
0.4980868995,
-0.508167088,
-0.0515024625,
-0.2343047708,
0.1008570641,
-0.3283990622,
0.2628656924,
0.2366826981,
0.8652364612,
0.3476444781,
-0.6379767656,
0.4875949919,
0.124405846,
-0.4602856338,
0.2984336317,
-0.6551538706,
0.1768747866,
0.0271368921,
0.2218186259,
-0.7822406888,
-0.0235217363,
0.160743773,
-0.1125498936,
0.3790231645,
-0.4103546441,
-0.9295879006,
-0.126296103,
-0.0506488048,
0.0020475306,
0.7649095058,
-0.4369960129,
0.5050410032,
0.6573730707,
-0.4354134202,
-0.2479813546,
-0.7880784273,
0.4695444703,
-0.3722292185,
-0.5347795486,
0.40399912,
-0.0211111829,
-0.2574350238,
-0.3501507938,
0.1314586699,
-0.068206422,
0.0678313747,
0.0591517873,
0.1081476063,
-0.0334949121,
0.241648227,
-0.3163393438,
-0.0472080335,
0.1973762363,
-0.1116260737,
0.6945505142,
0.029266417,
-0.5347316861,
-0.0775781795,
0.4462544918,
0.3025651872,
0.1073435992,
0.6552970409,
0.6314331889,
-0.2519727647,
-0.1595991254,
-0.7576408982,
-0.2064271271,
-0.4139385223,
0.4456860423,
0.1774479598,
-0.9390084147,
0.3037846684,
-0.3119051754,
0.4901795387,
0.2054071724,
0.8160809278,
-0.3395548761,
0.6613770723,
0.880740881,
-0.2123989165,
0.627171278,
-0.1215860173,
0.5886836648,
-1.05919981,
-0.1390829086,
-0.4766094387,
-0.0392794237,
-0.4672433138,
-0.6404067874,
0.1931400001,
0.1963729262,
0.0588399358,
0.1311900765,
-0.2483374476,
0.2989488542,
0.4986712635,
-0.1461982578,
0.5952137709,
-0.0544676371,
0.0741354898,
-0.1435429007,
-0.822437048,
-0.9499220252,
1.1053316593,
0.5810893178,
0.8747476339,
0.058764644,
0.5032609701,
0.2408958673,
0.3310669661,
-1.1329234838,
0.6528725624,
-0.0916934311,
-0.5634053946,
-0.2622526288,
-0.2570973933,
-0.9200083613,
0.3171355426,
0.044258628,
-0.7020658255,
-0.4483715296,
0.0681674629,
-0.0598027036,
0.485906899,
-0.7697604895,
0.6707789898,
-0.350353092,
-0.1343944669,
-0.1377236992,
-0.4192414284,
0.4697868228,
0.0683432147,
0.2880872488,
-0.1896469593,
-0.2326726019,
0.7965316176,
-0.2213386744,
1.1373974085,
0.0219257493,
-0.4100690186,
0.3209088445,
-0.2804267406,
0.5938456655,
-0.0786806718,
-0.0075169848,
0.3520666957,
-0.0282020569,
-0.1221288294,
-0.3269000351,
0.4527338445,
-0.4223883152,
-0.5753199458,
-0.5251344442,
-0.5768313408,
-0.4663646519,
0.1021507233,
-0.0076234001,
0.2625550926,
-0.2053665221,
0.249048382,
0.7804989219,
-0.1386642009,
0.4093547165,
0.4515617192,
-0.3168744743,
-0.1055211723,
0.6600550413,
0.2600241005,
0.4477486312,
0.3778371215,
0.0592329204,
-0.4563918114,
-0.9236240983,
-0.0826045573,
0.3179396391,
-0.6960251927,
0.0238306336,
-0.5086010695,
-0.5162888169,
-0.4011704326,
-0.0451468937,
-0.1782937348,
-0.0916147754,
-0.2325538397,
0.0247404203,
0.3977578282,
0.7639915347,
0.1474699378,
0.5459946394,
-0.7370746732,
0.2785831988,
0.4052837193,
0.2910099924,
-0.0249315202,
-0.5673353672,
-0.2428524792,
0.0261598341,
-0.2785043418,
-0.7834382057,
0.6555480361,
0.0461215414,
0.762413919,
-0.0043574893,
-0.1419999152,
0.3605608046,
-0.6158234477,
0.9320075512,
0.0302700531,
-0.6064478755,
0.3640891612,
-0.6804392934,
0.3075772822,
0.4179656506,
0.5430753231,
-0.9968616366,
-0.3309475183,
-0.4332006872,
-1.1682810783,
0.5489510298,
0.3567127883,
0.4200158715,
0.1528749764,
0.2905147076,
-0.0519478545,
0.3744381368,
-0.7898933887,
-0.1125069186,
0.3609850705,
-0.1738922149,
-0.0976077169,
-0.5375321507,
-0.139488399,
-0.0816717222,
0.8028011918,
-0.1464957595,
0.3604987562,
0.0771646425,
-0.2101489305,
0.3909741342,
0.4448153377,
0.2966377437,
0.7123352885,
-0.2128260136,
0.0452306829,
0.3728664219,
-0.6794961691,
-0.3357622027,
-0.0001484142,
-0.0604088157,
0.0769042447,
0.4239831567,
0.5554105639,
0.4781001508,
-0.8504994512,
0.3280151486,
-0.1006578356,
-0.1476422846,
-0.4759884179,
0.0177073963,
0.4227406383,
0.2563326359,
0.3345205188,
-0.342233181,
0.0658063516,
-0.4908834398,
-0.1465337574,
0.6228148937,
-0.3217414618,
-0.0351069495,
0.2005370855,
0.2789728642,
-0.3565656245,
0.6057394147,
0.0620627962,
-0.3658417165,
0.3934731483,
0.5390940905,
0.8057465553,
0.0440017879,
0.0038293716,
0.0029303948,
0.4278457761,
-0.1490366161,
0.1651746631,
-0.0710295513,
-0.7095358372,
-0.7251223326,
-0.6592252851,
-0.8051603436,
0.3118195534,
-0.4655710161,
0.3297130466,
-0.307641536,
-0.1392801404,
-0.1893807948,
0.077893652,
-0.6037397981,
-0.1574328542,
0.3632310629,
1.1145689487,
-0.5434994102,
0.7457000613,
0.5952011347,
-0.1856930554,
-0.6963855028,
0.0034907982,
0.0689235553,
-0.8555934429,
0.3786261082,
-0.1734130979,
0.1083793864,
0.0582876168,
-0.5619447827,
-0.7122135758,
1.1286654472,
0.3199993968,
-0.6767109036,
-0.1845361739,
0.2789204121,
0.5641500354,
-0.1678968519,
0.3874992132,
0.6980721354,
0.2522306144,
0.2680975795,
-0.9506636262,
-0.1311090291,
0.0472625121,
0.0144382995,
0.0442287326,
-0.4349993169,
0.4723846316,
0.0716797411,
-0.0849887878,
-0.0560238548,
0.3482128382,
0.4253425002,
-0.0030090488,
0.3870666623,
0.3227978945,
0.7159968615,
-0.0873992518,
1.0963667631,
-0.2284227461,
0.3209697902,
1.0462403297,
-0.3078922331,
0.9474616647,
0.796908319,
-0.4556876421,
0.0723436922,
0.5593470335,
0.0064675822,
0.2681899667,
0.3745055199,
-0.3781751692,
-0.1414473057,
-0.3774957657,
-0.3361135423,
0.2372622192,
0.5077400804,
-0.4060533047,
-0.4530395865,
-0.2452265024,
0.2529944181,
-0.1470017284,
-0.3230497539,
0.8814138174,
0.5626909733,
-0.5515999198,
0.2670410275,
-0.0108439252,
0.8862116337,
-0.9271749258,
-0.0046639605,
-0.0325405039,
0.0308243129,
-0.1129919216,
-1.0790144205,
0.4604561031,
0.37204355,
-0.0620050877,
-0.8463848233,
0.8941970468,
-0.2574567497,
-0.5334321856,
0.261454314,
0.6621300578,
0.2050647438,
-0.2575875819,
-0.4529069662,
-0.1222975999,
-0.1414762139,
-0.4822208881,
0.5849137306,
0.3520869315,
0.2119259238,
0.9309686422,
0.6918529272,
0.4871096313,
0.2039519399,
0.4542450011,
0.8799734712,
-0.7993984818,
-0.1708131582,
-0.9599921703,
0.3495326042,
-0.1633375585,
-0.2621926069,
0.6878682375,
0.3543345034,
0.6952646971,
0.1440484375,
0.909254849,
0.005750054,
0.707963407,
-0.8319342136,
0.6746575832,
-0.1766467094,
0.3767537177,
-0.0528204143,
-0.8318884969,
-0.305863142,
0.4403792322,
-0.5569394827,
0.0495199263,
0.5279209018,
0.6428471804,
0.0799125433,
0.1807103455,
0.3147438467,
0.1126189232,
0.6269333959,
0.4514925778,
0.9261776209,
-0.170303449,
0.6017596722,
-0.1656049341,
-0.0702851787,
-0.1717567742,
-1.108866334,
-0.9509528279,
-0.411328733,
-0.1866808236,
0.2150725275,
0.0434378162,
0.8758767843,
0.8725441098,
-0.5533178449,
-0.4819809496,
-0.2885940671,
0.2299485058,
0.0487973876,
-0.2146023065,
-0.0157393776,
-0.7984394431,
-0.7805328369,
0.283290565,
0.1839567274,
0.071647428,
-0.485103935,
0.0349930897,
-0.4270705283,
-0.1477777064,
0.8125327826,
0.0881192312,
-0.5643755198,
0.1695630103,
-0.0692064911,
-0.0763704553,
-0.1592456102,
1.0708509684,
-0.656848371,
0.1466553658,
0.4217866659,
0.6448803544,
0.4228999615,
-0.3357484341,
0.8085321784,
-0.7666087151,
-0.1017387807,
0.5439134836,
0.4684648812,
0.4144096076,
-0.2756603956,
0.7198722959,
0.0820055902,
-0.7327395082,
-0.8726101518,
0.129210636,
-1.0502252579,
0.0858949125,
1.515392065,
-0.051494319,
0.1217483506,
-0.2915653288,
-0.3905678988,
0.1517411768,
-0.340967834,
0.5696352124,
0.9121031165,
-0.0989277512,
-0.3810538948,
-1.2640157938,
0.4689975977,
0.1670943499,
-0.9105198383,
0.3612030447,
0.0551322512,
0.0879049227,
-0.1672144681,
0.6555543542,
-0.0814867914,
-0.4718208611,
-0.2957058549,
0.0010888011,
0.1442878991,
0.0733973011,
-0.391628325,
0.017814856,
0.3631336987,
0.0768711865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13689v2 | HeySQuAD: A Spoken Question Answering Dataset | 2023-04-26T17:15:39 | 2024-02-27T13:57:08 | Yijing Wu, SaiKrishna Rallabandi, Ravisutha Srinivasamurthy, Parag Pravin Dakle, Alolika Gon, Preethi Raghavan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spoken question answering (SQA) systems are critical for digital assistants
and other real-world use cases, but evaluating their performance is a challenge
due to the importance of human-spoken questions. This study presents a new
large-scale community-shared SQA dataset called HeySQuAD, which includes 76k
human-spoken questions, 97k machine-generated questions, and their
corresponding textual answers from the SQuAD QA dataset. Our goal is to measure
the ability of machines to accurately understand noisy spoken questions and
provide reliable answers. Through extensive testing, we demonstrate that
training with transcribed human-spoken and original SQuAD questions leads to a
significant improvement (12.51%) in answering human-spoken questions compared
to training with only the original SQuAD textual questions. Moreover,
evaluating with a higher-quality transcription can lead to a further
improvement of 2.03%. This research has significant implications for the
development of SQA systems and their ability to meet the needs of users in
real-world scenarios. | [
-0.6498570442,
-0.9583147168,
0.3413958848,
0.1369840652,
-0.0775522962,
0.1491863877,
-0.0099086156,
-0.6319375038,
0.2841675282,
0.3777591586,
-0.8323537707,
-0.1745072901,
-0.2342822105,
0.3229890764,
-0.3542504907,
0.6372384429,
0.2851450145,
0.3456522524,
-0.407011807,
-0.3162130713,
-0.7818632126,
-0.7476667762,
-0.7092720866,
0.1498167515,
0.3069210649,
0.618963778,
0.7713389397,
0.1108521745,
0.343806684,
0.366659373,
0.0630188063,
0.2776198685,
-0.767337203,
0.579118669,
0.1718678623,
-0.5050368309,
-0.3112257123,
-0.1571579278,
0.5441087484,
0.5332091451,
-0.1913192421,
0.4708281755,
0.0020112148,
0.3792012632,
-0.3539472818,
0.1994942427,
-0.4720362425,
-0.1098598242,
0.1513417661,
0.0537769347,
0.0494617745,
-0.5514836311,
0.4228500724,
-1.0727161169,
0.2109920382,
-0.1156727225,
0.7625561953,
0.1594260484,
-0.0168158226,
-0.3709719777,
-0.7031177878,
0.6559898257,
-0.5132729411,
0.2716495097,
0.4623621702,
0.5188226104,
-0.1046086401,
-0.3801240921,
-0.8153302073,
0.2864434123,
0.1535858512,
0.2118987739,
-0.419367969,
-0.1963313222,
0.199230209,
0.1670493931,
-0.8229105473,
-0.0531985164,
-0.6136958599,
-0.1871620417,
1.0715807676,
0.1952348053,
0.3476971388,
-0.1814764291,
-0.228105098,
-0.1422336996,
-0.2991786599,
0.1166010946,
0.0880915821,
0.064085342,
-0.0787426233,
0.3708515167,
-0.5501546264,
0.37257424,
-0.0246720985,
0.1887752861,
0.2269299477,
-0.2209113389,
-0.1660176516,
-0.129591316,
0.894841671,
0.3923671246,
0.6374317408,
-0.2645334899,
-0.0785024613,
-0.2675525546,
0.3017987609,
-0.6875976324,
-0.0984354764,
0.3386130631,
-0.0320264101,
-0.09129747,
0.1200411096,
-0.6886875629,
-0.3147669733,
-0.3620988131,
0.5965087414,
-0.4302916825,
-0.2486893833,
0.0733326375,
-0.3277626336,
0.3648693562,
0.4773789644,
-0.6639547944,
0.3791306317,
0.6609475017,
0.5653737783,
-0.0591199733,
-0.271400243,
-0.7890740037,
-0.2531552315,
-0.3829868436,
0.827632308,
-0.1093545631,
-0.4566849768,
0.0101996874,
-0.1386677772,
-0.3387745619,
-0.8938894868,
0.2676607668,
-0.7481360435,
0.4150836766,
-0.3505223095,
-0.4028122723,
0.0254343823,
0.2743031681,
-0.6135182977,
1.2375471592,
0.267675072,
-0.3692650795,
0.2264670283,
-0.6281004548,
-0.3534474969,
0.2438194305,
-0.1664990038,
-0.3562215269,
-0.1629565507,
0.5229747891,
0.4891486168,
-0.3024602234,
0.2534887791,
-0.2055549622,
-0.5403116345,
0.5623366833,
-0.3572179675,
0.8248766661,
0.2804250717,
-0.2093198597,
-0.0275374576,
-0.5957171917,
0.3650017083,
0.0253767185,
-0.1257726848,
-0.0568963327,
-0.2981755137,
-0.0113006579,
0.2516458929,
0.1595885158,
-0.6569026709,
-0.0186488349,
-0.1681319177,
0.3169959784,
0.5994005799,
0.2937666178,
0.104129754,
-0.5138219595,
0.8571125865,
-0.0551690832,
0.2717110813,
0.0944817513,
-0.8492848277,
-0.4492977262,
-0.4306322038,
0.0960101113,
0.574631691,
-0.6753001809,
0.3883431256,
-0.2694070637,
-0.4940857291,
-0.8403232098,
0.1747788936,
0.4089356959,
0.3827658594,
0.3461490571,
-0.3529379964,
-0.708191216,
-0.7827595472,
-0.0457508974,
-0.5890437365,
-0.2886934876,
0.5494874716,
0.249655962,
-0.1681562662,
1.1618624926,
-0.6037323475,
0.0250231307,
-0.2753720582,
0.1564317942,
-0.219756797,
0.0992904752,
0.1156404912,
-0.6586524844,
-0.2705571651,
-0.4947150648,
-0.9188768864,
-0.199252218,
-0.0047095264,
-0.1591040343,
-0.2213667333,
0.3563353419,
-0.9447708726,
0.3612499833,
0.4493553638,
-0.1740090251,
0.7841389775,
0.025142381,
0.4515183866,
-1.0629355907,
-0.0577324741,
-0.2254616469,
-0.2867738307,
-0.5755642056,
0.0440461896,
-0.1601506472,
-0.6060499549,
-0.4394860566,
0.2611638606,
-0.1368047297,
-0.3632421494,
0.0921832621,
0.5033404827,
0.1385324746,
0.4981350303,
-0.2000472993,
1.2873886824,
0.4557897449,
-0.5522990227,
0.5780845881,
0.8020960689,
-0.2460084856,
0.813967526,
-1.1182790995,
0.5300142765,
-0.099070482,
0.2562606037,
-1.048406601,
-0.2672102451,
-0.0827998668,
-0.6271778941,
-0.052164115,
0.0924197584,
-0.4840696454,
-0.4048808217,
-0.011800128,
0.4068213105,
0.346039027,
-0.3500863016,
0.1038394719,
0.7664651275,
-0.4132290184,
-0.16393058,
-0.2637608051,
0.2410549372,
-0.0504088253,
-1.010502696,
-0.2164376229,
-0.2673567235,
-0.3690569401,
-0.4169677794,
0.0382854901,
-0.4357244372,
0.2323919237,
0.5253038406,
0.1637151986,
-0.5565546155,
0.410250783,
-0.234882012,
0.0676196665,
0.1746100783,
0.008700314,
0.7070832253,
-0.4047384262,
-0.2056308836,
-0.9124026299,
0.6688672304,
0.5539237857,
-0.3557365835,
0.4889617264,
0.5335094333,
-0.3016895652,
0.0333008915,
-0.4264703095,
-0.3272100389,
-0.4737208784,
0.3392120004,
-0.4037459195,
-0.9544841051,
0.389787972,
0.2838462591,
0.1358189136,
0.510777235,
0.3131192327,
-1.0110930204,
0.9476917386,
0.1042545885,
-0.3563366234,
0.14667961,
-0.2571635246,
-0.0878010392,
-0.3420413733,
-0.2308630645,
-0.8171741366,
-0.3750053942,
-0.3759173751,
-0.3486384451,
0.5437630415,
0.0623542257,
-0.1303336024,
0.4357286096,
-0.1647404581,
0.2629756629,
0.6772168279,
0.165377602,
0.3114817739,
-0.3033798635,
0.608533144,
0.1940343827,
-0.7789247036,
-0.6294219494,
1.0313830376,
0.2982904613,
0.4738200009,
0.2266093045,
0.8308290243,
0.5114207864,
-0.0308853202,
-0.6316963434,
0.6413514614,
0.3129114807,
-0.717841208,
-0.9890598655,
-0.4976585805,
-1.2580983639,
0.1480796188,
-0.2287852466,
-0.563811481,
0.1735925078,
0.0728414208,
-0.613149941,
-0.1702989638,
-0.9457286596,
0.7998504639,
0.1072571054,
0.0800504982,
-0.2382829934,
-0.6700206399,
0.1367388219,
-0.0310529359,
0.0700430945,
-0.0266317371,
0.3269961476,
1.1554652452,
-0.4490239024,
0.6896685958,
-0.2388471663,
-0.2011750638,
0.7414535284,
-0.2051384151,
0.2297216207,
0.2826623023,
-0.3391040564,
0.1966720074,
0.5892680883,
-0.6916641593,
-0.6829330921,
0.449062109,
-1.0795394182,
-0.4928211272,
-0.3220920265,
-0.6692706943,
-0.7162951231,
0.1126999557,
0.0351159386,
0.6577450633,
-0.6984935403,
0.2385590971,
0.9009242058,
-0.1365632415,
0.1466381401,
0.3023473918,
-0.0140295336,
-0.2332283705,
0.6280741692,
0.0243531242,
0.3844367862,
0.096479319,
0.0746465251,
-0.2938138247,
-0.2549339831,
-0.9737406969,
0.0620199442,
-0.2922329903,
-0.2036594152,
-0.5904031396,
-0.2084141225,
-0.7601462007,
0.2748152912,
-0.1708613187,
-0.5573477745,
-0.4535979927,
-0.0539149009,
0.2804928422,
0.7386464477,
0.2570111752,
0.3726013601,
-0.9370958805,
0.8563555479,
0.8501902223,
0.0693077147,
-0.4112910926,
-0.5499953628,
-0.3156792223,
0.4755770564,
-0.3166944683,
-1.0546550751,
0.1352477074,
0.4401454628,
0.4323010743,
0.1761654913,
0.2144029886,
0.8090028167,
-0.1117459312,
0.8669107556,
-0.0316297226,
-0.6100828648,
0.4147125185,
-0.4144597352,
0.5943164229,
0.9327869415,
0.3336932957,
-0.6364175677,
-0.2852032781,
-0.7674508691,
-0.2152333707,
0.5528723598,
0.2812412977,
0.1966095269,
0.0080014775,
0.2279673219,
-0.0827017203,
0.1704822481,
0.1775362641,
-0.0559272841,
-0.1213903949,
-0.2801504731,
-0.0625788644,
-0.0187971443,
-0.0645706579,
-0.1044857502,
0.6034857035,
-0.146411255,
0.4023900926,
0.3043020964,
-0.3215718865,
-0.2591519058,
0.3359753191,
0.2964797914,
0.6662117839,
-0.1996488571,
-0.2111487389,
0.2983553112,
-0.7050170898,
-0.0032447842,
0.0568256676,
-0.2019842565,
0.0528940596,
0.3218536675,
0.5362549424,
0.0858345404,
-1.0857210159,
0.7234233022,
-0.2958561182,
-0.4044192731,
-0.1601860374,
0.3525450826,
0.0739481077,
0.176484704,
0.5817080736,
0.075357385,
0.1943937093,
-0.7314617634,
0.4981651902,
0.3997024298,
-0.6365977526,
-0.2287515551,
0.1442240179,
0.2318651378,
-0.6196334362,
0.6872077584,
-0.0869755596,
-0.6357470155,
0.648001194,
0.2665679455,
0.7142840624,
-0.3152324259,
0.5474569798,
0.2542230785,
0.2076236755,
0.3738588691,
0.7688836455,
-0.1365166605,
-0.5102759004,
-0.0153779807,
-0.4050020576,
-0.5840634108,
0.0064936769,
-0.9882668257,
-0.0328258015,
-0.3373464048,
-0.1569412351,
-0.0739260092,
0.1468498111,
-0.898037076,
0.5396950245,
-0.2227189243,
0.6157588363,
-0.61760813,
0.4478323758,
0.3999711275,
-0.2793053091,
-0.8638619184,
0.0379204489,
-0.2642524242,
-0.7913281322,
0.297190845,
-0.0074711745,
-0.073096849,
0.0275699422,
-0.5737396479,
-0.6094010472,
1.021438241,
0.204581961,
-0.5546565056,
0.1678830534,
0.4799730778,
0.7451908588,
0.0109995482,
0.3367997706,
0.6374821067,
0.2141362727,
-0.1665219367,
-1.1624825001,
-0.2822242081,
-0.2566245198,
-0.5965852737,
-0.1661905199,
-0.7469521165,
0.1841789186,
-0.359955579,
-0.2256420106,
0.1967763901,
1.0293358564,
0.3288626075,
0.6790511608,
0.7068312764,
0.3113717735,
1.0930784941,
-0.0176554937,
0.6366507411,
0.1238987222,
-0.1246869639,
1.0677556992,
-0.186272338,
1.1736599207,
0.4330564737,
-0.286210835,
0.3452341557,
0.4212987721,
0.4459887743,
0.0653628558,
0.4349296093,
-0.3563316464,
-0.3219403923,
0.0305245556,
-0.2587326169,
0.6762779355,
0.1309599131,
0.1565209478,
0.137916863,
0.089033559,
-0.3109093308,
0.1523867995,
0.0488703102,
1.1867601871,
-0.061084006,
-0.7652238607,
0.7529835105,
-0.2564840019,
0.2456971705,
-0.3378169537,
0.1026953608,
-0.4578310251,
-0.32535851,
-0.0566220693,
-0.8116841316,
0.2210201174,
0.2767029107,
-0.1372475624,
-0.097038582,
0.4354830086,
-0.3873321414,
-0.2318747193,
-0.3858312666,
0.6644372344,
0.4441610575,
-0.3550863564,
-0.5927488208,
-0.1214629933,
-0.1868997663,
0.0448871665,
0.1235904843,
0.4642188251,
-0.1001304835,
0.7128996849,
0.6573019624,
-0.0435527861,
0.2970656455,
0.1524534374,
0.8218454719,
-0.435364306,
-0.6225678325,
-0.0880016536,
0.2786639333,
-0.3424801826,
-0.756521821,
0.7981162667,
0.8258505464,
0.4679623246,
-0.0702034235,
0.7841793895,
0.1924830973,
0.825538218,
-0.2102079391,
0.7742776275,
-0.1869705915,
0.1139853224,
-0.2366640866,
-0.5538113117,
0.1032553986,
0.3589860201,
-0.1542627364,
-0.2038767934,
0.2619593143,
0.9598540664,
-0.0057027694,
0.7154035568,
0.379408896,
-0.0170208495,
0.3334202468,
0.4184721708,
0.9842559099,
-0.8330703974,
0.755643785,
-0.0897330791,
-0.1177954748,
-0.1244035065,
-0.0820005536,
-0.7331674099,
-0.7250798941,
-0.3719104826,
-0.2508136928,
0.3513998389,
0.7901288271,
0.8813239336,
-0.9464653134,
-0.2266400307,
0.3195689321,
-0.1616438627,
-0.3974585533,
-0.2098883986,
0.4363238811,
-0.1427195519,
-0.5831539631,
0.6586766243,
-0.1008981541,
-0.2043758631,
-0.352560997,
-0.2627488673,
-0.1162369773,
0.1554563791,
0.5621753931,
0.5438408852,
-0.1847904623,
-0.2638576329,
0.557798326,
-0.3175031841,
-0.0402941145,
0.6429297924,
-0.8197852373,
0.5042096972,
0.6219949126,
0.9385703206,
0.6312394738,
0.3613895178,
0.7903851271,
-0.7020300627,
-0.3134649992,
0.4838341773,
-0.0398218818,
0.2100832611,
-0.2671129704,
0.1484747827,
0.15747042,
-0.5357832313,
-0.6003707647,
-0.1217597574,
-1.0513051748,
0.1355962902,
1.1441891193,
-0.1958975196,
-0.0043277293,
-0.7969689369,
-0.5862394571,
0.429400146,
-0.4974814951,
0.8892034292,
0.4150721431,
-0.0338554718,
-0.1268870384,
-0.6086901426,
0.376806289,
0.6140765548,
-1.2024056911,
-0.0127653321,
0.7412489653,
0.0608059093,
-0.0936607197,
0.7144099474,
0.122001633,
0.7636846304,
-0.3015737832,
-0.1421713531,
0.0182396919,
-0.2521835864,
-0.1946649402,
0.3427699506,
-0.0963786617,
-0.6119395494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13664v1 | Using Implicit Feedback to Improve Question Generation | 2023-04-26T16:37:47 | 2023-04-26T16:37:47 | Hugo Rodrigues, Eric Nyberg, Luisa Coheur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Question Generation (QG) is a task of Natural Language Processing (NLP) that
aims at automatically generating questions from text. Many applications can
benefit from automatically generated questions, but often it is necessary to
curate those questions, either by selecting or editing them. This task is
informative on its own, but it is typically done post-generation, and, thus,
the effort is wasted. In addition, most existing systems cannot incorporate
this feedback back into them easily. In this work, we present a system, GEN,
that learns from such (implicit) feedback. Following a pattern-based approach,
it takes as input a small set of sentence/question pairs and creates patterns
which are then applied to new unseen sentences. Each generated question, after
being corrected by the user, is used as a new seed in the next iteration, so
more patterns are created each time. We also take advantage of the corrections
made by the user to score the patterns and therefore rank the generated
questions. Results show that GEN is able to improve by learning from both
levels of implicit feedback when compared to the version with no learning,
considering the top 5, 10, and 20 questions. Improvements go up from 10%,
depending on the metric and strategy used. | [
-0.4165768921,
-0.862225771,
0.6310513616,
0.3605913222,
-0.1891597956,
-0.1119298264,
-0.1276694685,
-0.3104805648,
-0.086555019,
0.2751841545,
-0.654096365,
-0.5523705482,
-0.3556691408,
0.4903427362,
-0.3930405676,
1.1284441948,
0.2801369429,
0.1221962124,
-0.4133306146,
0.0668971464,
-0.5612344742,
-0.2613783777,
-1.2470895052,
-0.0643248335,
0.5090644956,
0.5796197653,
0.1693754047,
0.2461649925,
0.029073419,
0.3260349035,
-0.0907122716,
0.4521709681,
-0.691541791,
0.5662477612,
-0.0655636638,
-0.5720892549,
0.0981334746,
-0.0828578696,
0.6154197454,
0.5981139541,
-0.0862653106,
0.3030314744,
0.4062369168,
0.597725153,
-0.3981367946,
0.2060029656,
-0.5256592035,
0.1991390586,
0.2552069724,
-0.4741341472,
-0.4206256866,
-0.9475055337,
-0.0152412821,
-0.7170311809,
0.4923429191,
-0.0995792225,
0.4628660679,
0.2919172943,
-0.2216042876,
-0.4242351353,
-0.9580048323,
0.5497756004,
-0.593623817,
0.1991189122,
0.1919574291,
0.0830839872,
-0.3673114777,
-0.6717221737,
-0.5296072364,
-0.1659862101,
-0.24704355,
0.2871107459,
0.0811746195,
-0.3836830854,
0.4863828123,
0.1225588396,
-0.5897868276,
-0.3234646916,
-0.2535390556,
0.0226528998,
0.7949374318,
0.1626885235,
0.2439638227,
-0.3164319098,
-0.1546577513,
-0.3018573821,
-0.6288502812,
0.4273803532,
0.3710805774,
0.2407316715,
0.4977016449,
0.3443238735,
-0.3979221284,
0.598277688,
0.6524690986,
0.1703763604,
0.1885014921,
-0.2414909899,
0.1626216322,
-0.0628450662,
0.7784103155,
0.2782429755,
0.1279747784,
-0.1024592221,
-0.1296415776,
-0.2057774961,
0.1783107221,
-0.7369459271,
-0.2637763917,
0.2953412533,
-0.2098037452,
-0.3346717954,
0.3549124599,
-0.821270287,
-0.3768417835,
-0.0927421674,
0.3662475944,
-0.4466524422,
-0.1598424762,
-0.0089437719,
-0.3573076725,
0.3882338703,
0.4966977835,
-0.9006730318,
0.0636219233,
0.4336750507,
0.5253445506,
0.266649574,
0.0292433705,
-0.8437777758,
0.2316045165,
-0.338701874,
1.038954258,
-0.6140976548,
-0.7257057428,
-0.1088425666,
-0.0519152209,
-0.0599448495,
-0.4973569214,
0.2963541448,
-0.4430265129,
0.9537944794,
-0.5421219468,
-0.5857051015,
0.0459109433,
0.3201241195,
-0.3444669843,
1.4431592226,
-0.0232899878,
-0.6756070256,
0.6519508958,
-0.660538435,
-0.3389142752,
0.5832132697,
-0.3281514645,
-0.3294502795,
0.0341112576,
0.5270491838,
0.2210258842,
0.08394593,
0.0095591061,
0.0628043562,
-0.4289780259,
-0.0797521099,
0.0211104099,
0.5471636057,
-0.0424563773,
-0.6708239913,
0.2460238934,
-0.9331634045,
0.6244344115,
0.0492449626,
-0.5562856793,
-0.4632896483,
0.0550247692,
-0.506170094,
0.1444660723,
-0.0086634755,
-0.6092937589,
0.2607873678,
-0.4853885472,
0.1816723049,
0.7861841917,
0.4844605327,
0.4734435081,
-0.2465273291,
0.6603757143,
-0.2741153836,
0.3007909358,
-0.0753667876,
-0.7366732359,
-0.9533114433,
0.3571923971,
0.4167363942,
0.595285058,
-1.0922919512,
0.3501915932,
0.0922153145,
-0.3230327666,
-0.4861915112,
0.4074709713,
0.3317514956,
0.4585561752,
0.4149755239,
-0.0905520096,
-0.4487052858,
-0.3145673871,
-0.0832273141,
-0.6380510926,
-0.2676401138,
0.4490046501,
0.2928802073,
0.1788249612,
0.9268001318,
-0.8213291764,
-0.0118850367,
-0.3222168386,
0.6101143956,
-0.1799334437,
0.5885902643,
0.3017409444,
-0.6760649085,
-0.3918354213,
-0.2371647805,
-0.6579856873,
-0.363340497,
-0.1868576854,
-0.4094665349,
-0.0160438847,
0.8296388984,
-0.5146573186,
0.0864918754,
0.2780364156,
-0.3665442169,
0.3679359555,
-0.2564251125,
0.1167047694,
-1.2017514706,
-0.0187041704,
-0.201752767,
-0.1233093515,
-0.4026037455,
0.1313346177,
-0.0491541103,
0.0150032192,
-0.3341760337,
0.3826481402,
-0.460634321,
0.2464173138,
-0.0685276017,
-0.0812957957,
0.0119289206,
0.5224580765,
-0.296408534,
0.8063539267,
0.1038229987,
-0.8331491351,
0.3569972813,
0.3633886576,
-0.2265714109,
0.3607281148,
-0.94628793,
0.6542983055,
-0.5797994733,
0.1619872451,
-1.0711278915,
-0.0755393878,
0.3465287685,
-0.656221211,
0.0284364559,
-0.1323777139,
-0.396746397,
-0.458399564,
-0.5450582504,
0.1135047674,
0.698810935,
-0.5696202517,
0.3129515946,
-0.0832575187,
-0.4965241849,
-0.3767331839,
-0.0990401357,
-0.1933595836,
0.2126052678,
-0.5763953328,
-0.0332658179,
-0.2467866987,
-0.1188522428,
0.2729593813,
0.1985316575,
0.2331407368,
0.0276477449,
0.2308366001,
-0.2024002969,
-0.2268358022,
0.5851518512,
0.2658801079,
0.0025371877,
0.1301295757,
-0.5530784726,
0.6521239281,
-0.0011061878,
-0.0650060475,
0.0233446192,
0.6142574549,
0.2451128364,
-0.4110449851,
0.4593515992,
0.5306853056,
0.0106505314,
-0.9260072708,
-0.3016703427,
-0.3557105064,
-0.4900485575,
0.0820062757,
-0.1632008255,
-1.1639091969,
0.306578517,
-0.0284368619,
0.0752713159,
0.4679726958,
0.3758381605,
-0.375333637,
1.5421388149,
0.7949137688,
0.3118248284,
0.4948395789,
-0.2866883278,
0.0006422091,
-0.6323553324,
-0.516197741,
-0.5210180879,
-0.2233388424,
-0.452441901,
-0.29195261,
0.3456967473,
0.2420470417,
-0.0307003725,
-0.0369035862,
-0.5571332574,
0.4818924367,
1.0980567932,
0.213885352,
0.2644623816,
-0.1779910475,
-0.1532677859,
0.1779364198,
-0.8498094082,
-0.4840786755,
1.0654058456,
-0.1749683172,
0.4839514792,
-0.0347523578,
1.0049937963,
0.2127870619,
0.3688730896,
-0.5124505162,
0.8098810315,
-0.0646817982,
-0.2250769883,
-0.7049088478,
-0.7311953306,
-1.1563762426,
0.1959366947,
-0.4351883531,
-0.1428353935,
0.110225372,
0.2770336568,
-0.9031205177,
0.0267094038,
-0.7122082114,
0.4721287787,
-0.1651113778,
-0.4946347773,
0.2488123029,
-0.4931544662,
0.1623558402,
0.2154244184,
-0.2144162655,
0.2181143612,
0.4372231066,
0.6817366481,
-0.6339048743,
0.6505723596,
-0.4613293707,
-0.3146859705,
0.4392858148,
-0.1890375912,
0.4818806052,
0.4517730474,
0.1603019387,
-0.4264002144,
-0.2846331298,
-0.3088243008,
-1.0355049372,
0.5376199484,
-0.5362089276,
-0.9392871857,
-0.2706560791,
-0.4388347864,
-0.4152261019,
0.1089294627,
0.3225692511,
0.2832689285,
-0.204039067,
0.0919550434,
0.8686286211,
-0.4536800683,
0.4427193701,
0.6056706309,
-0.3283965886,
-0.3488513529,
0.5781669021,
-0.1294567585,
0.1272625327,
0.1970375925,
0.2051587701,
-0.3502025902,
-0.4508248866,
-0.7430787683,
0.0712306947,
-0.31132254,
-0.1118931323,
-0.803666234,
-0.2310943902,
-0.7856753469,
0.1544140726,
0.239342317,
-0.3510708511,
-0.2272926122,
-0.3298983872,
0.3691841364,
1.0279717445,
0.0235367361,
0.1472313851,
-0.7496805191,
0.3739011884,
1.0171890259,
0.4020000696,
-0.1832084954,
-0.1810185462,
0.1009337083,
0.1153469831,
-0.2583294511,
-0.8159051538,
0.2891159058,
0.1768134832,
0.4039989114,
0.1988379657,
-0.0058748908,
0.601667285,
-0.555314064,
0.9427803159,
-0.090798445,
-0.8432617784,
1.023445487,
-0.270052582,
0.6937998533,
0.7804561853,
0.1835389137,
-0.5243322849,
-0.8427730203,
-0.5050720572,
-0.9025858641,
0.4857150614,
0.1839682162,
0.291370362,
-0.2302140146,
0.69340837,
0.2264017761,
0.3316657543,
-0.5381831527,
-0.0391016454,
-0.3014165759,
-0.2160617709,
0.0020265034,
-0.258372277,
0.0339407288,
-0.3881956339,
0.7180873156,
-0.3158438206,
0.1751639098,
0.3448911607,
-0.0707048252,
-0.3601968586,
0.3532409072,
0.5936388373,
0.4117014408,
-0.2163906395,
-0.0181658119,
0.1334713697,
-0.4570398331,
0.1918979883,
0.0195765272,
-1.0003334284,
0.1272033155,
0.1718635857,
0.6763881445,
-0.0489087664,
-0.3798019588,
0.3620578349,
-0.3567875624,
-0.5127598047,
-0.1611225456,
0.3922370374,
-0.2053044289,
0.3371182084,
0.4429929256,
-0.1067685261,
0.0327153169,
-0.6431962848,
0.401134938,
0.4021141827,
-0.4679794908,
-0.1697382331,
0.8328329921,
0.4318091273,
-0.2829463184,
0.6847648621,
-0.5036159754,
-0.6635776162,
0.5801869631,
0.4297876954,
0.9211608171,
-0.3472211361,
0.8722205758,
0.5869836211,
0.2713595927,
-0.1522752345,
0.8407326937,
-0.2166780829,
-0.6802091599,
-0.6362752914,
-0.4894592464,
-0.3526559472,
0.3511033356,
-0.5688772202,
0.0288179405,
-0.7458562255,
-0.0707030222,
-0.3790100813,
-0.0989226848,
-0.3812086284,
0.4337932467,
-0.0180811435,
0.4470668435,
-0.7909832001,
0.3973527849,
0.9308419824,
-0.7079706192,
-1.0089021921,
0.2838643491,
-0.5089610219,
-0.6072776914,
0.7537149787,
0.2486881614,
-0.1036586016,
0.2731102705,
-0.8381285667,
-0.910256803,
0.9280213118,
0.1574312449,
-0.2061832994,
-0.0229505654,
0.1722910106,
0.7945625782,
-0.0376774333,
0.2589452863,
0.1415876448,
0.4208664298,
0.0678809285,
-0.3633733988,
0.0726004392,
-0.7462258935,
-0.0371852517,
0.4603204727,
-0.4488472939,
0.8311065435,
-0.3771582246,
-0.5247348547,
0.1011320576,
0.7536020279,
0.1180675998,
0.237830326,
0.8665634394,
0.5852711797,
0.854444623,
-0.110963501,
1.1007010937,
-0.2640900016,
0.1095705554,
1.1734950542,
-0.1543847024,
0.7425279617,
0.3980917633,
0.1915427446,
0.8681316972,
0.4333901107,
-0.0674510747,
0.5547534823,
0.5266069174,
-0.2560553849,
-0.1626737416,
-0.0219494347,
-0.4565531909,
0.1835002899,
-0.0423780344,
-0.2656105161,
-0.08436957,
-0.1377629489,
-0.1358757913,
0.2164909393,
-0.3791980743,
1.3246372938,
-0.2000147849,
-0.9914222956,
0.2843423486,
-0.1909825057,
0.4500872195,
-0.6064001918,
-0.5646327138,
-0.7294313908,
-0.0695879906,
-0.2567381859,
-0.5573238134,
-0.0768205971,
0.1923819631,
-0.3647351265,
-0.5014504194,
0.4891902208,
-0.720072031,
-0.7564729452,
0.1500128061,
0.761148572,
-0.2164015025,
0.0207757968,
-0.3811369538,
-0.5762519836,
0.0333982185,
-0.1762889624,
-0.0237367973,
0.4986813664,
-0.067980051,
0.5168575048,
0.9426389933,
0.2399826646,
0.382650435,
0.3845958412,
0.7230958939,
-0.7316718102,
-0.6130501032,
-0.4765675366,
0.5248872042,
-0.3873932064,
-0.5486560464,
1.0269768238,
0.3902782798,
1.064455986,
0.0595609732,
1.0513471365,
-0.0439760238,
0.6908771396,
-0.5948010087,
0.4257703125,
-0.4195047915,
0.3992860913,
-0.3571748137,
-0.9773073196,
-0.1792771369,
0.4997772574,
-0.2624416649,
0.0507777445,
0.7572080493,
0.7533689737,
0.4783806205,
0.1705571264,
0.0220889058,
0.1742634177,
0.3102304041,
0.5710952878,
1.2566541433,
-0.3465558589,
0.6781619787,
-0.2438973933,
-0.0855424404,
0.1203844547,
-0.420645833,
-0.7032991052,
-0.518306613,
-0.2743887603,
-0.3010724187,
0.2493640929,
0.7567490935,
0.4760420322,
-0.9378175735,
0.0696705654,
-0.3510240614,
0.0435227454,
-0.2595701516,
-0.2666303515,
0.2172996849,
-0.6453480124,
-0.7320317626,
0.4077456892,
0.2034766376,
-0.0179436784,
-0.1363778561,
0.1422296315,
-0.1094298959,
0.1235824004,
0.8305209279,
0.2465399802,
-0.2230119407,
-0.620002687,
0.2662444711,
-0.0065640267,
-0.1363805383,
0.9788033366,
-0.9157950282,
0.3436176479,
0.6435181499,
0.5755454898,
0.2950912714,
0.5273711681,
0.8679907322,
-0.8849220276,
-0.2723430991,
0.3028937578,
0.0110969897,
0.3142315447,
-0.6599897146,
0.4998870492,
0.1997025162,
-0.2990757227,
-0.5291709304,
0.2279616892,
-0.5287324786,
-0.4204130471,
1.4042389393,
0.049084764,
-0.0307086688,
-0.1562585831,
-0.4680506289,
0.1656369269,
-0.4503960311,
1.0484662056,
0.5544298291,
-0.200574562,
-0.2335221618,
-0.2263356745,
0.7410607338,
0.9085815549,
-1.0392956734,
-0.4036265612,
0.5859301686,
0.1955888271,
-0.0049965815,
0.6164981723,
-0.1222073883,
0.333519429,
-0.299323678,
0.1302064657,
0.0457275398,
-0.2083045989,
-0.3784341216,
0.7098638415,
-0.0067296866,
-0.3117151856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13649v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13649v1 | A Symmetric Dual Encoding Dense Retrieval Framework for Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering | 2023-04-26T16:14:39 | 2023-04-26T16:14:39 | Alireza Salemi, Juan Altmayer Pizzorno, Hamed Zamani | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR | Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering (KI-VQA) refers to answering a
question about an image whose answer does not lie in the image. This paper
presents a new pipeline for KI-VQA tasks, consisting of a retriever and a
reader. First, we introduce DEDR, a symmetric dual encoding dense retrieval
framework in which documents and queries are encoded into a shared embedding
space using uni-modal (textual) and multi-modal encoders. We introduce an
iterative knowledge distillation approach that bridges the gap between the
representation spaces in these two encoders. Extensive evaluation on two
well-established KI-VQA datasets, i.e., OK-VQA and FVQA, suggests that DEDR
outperforms state-of-the-art baselines by 11.6% and 30.9% on OK-VQA and FVQA,
respectively. Utilizing the passages retrieved by DEDR, we further introduce
MM-FiD, an encoder-decoder multi-modal fusion-in-decoder model, for generating
a textual answer for KI-VQA tasks. MM-FiD encodes the question, the image, and
each retrieved passage separately and uses all passages jointly in its decoder.
Compared to competitive baselines in the literature, this approach leads to
5.5% and 8.5% improvements in terms of question answering accuracy on OK-VQA
and FVQA, respectively. | [
-0.3440720439,
-0.9593175054,
0.6355339885,
-0.1545844525,
-0.5708826184,
0.2285232097,
0.1322944909,
-0.119685106,
-0.0332998261,
0.5313059092,
-0.4985867143,
-0.3108175397,
-0.7906329036,
-0.0246105809,
-0.2056547403,
0.398896873,
-0.2703178227,
0.5086657405,
-0.576191783,
-0.3136116862,
-0.7041522264,
-0.4336389601,
-0.250508666,
-0.0807825327,
0.5608831644,
0.4284420609,
0.5521935225,
0.3024460673,
0.6723299026,
0.3019878566,
-0.0488180891,
0.133733809,
-0.6261557937,
0.5554505587,
0.0381968431,
-0.5203477144,
0.3391853571,
-0.3623544574,
0.5220306516,
0.3369700611,
-0.06031188,
0.1726023704,
-0.0198305901,
0.8585062027,
-0.9562727809,
0.0253855493,
-0.6463829875,
-0.0052453051,
-0.0554472394,
-0.2594827712,
-0.1928481311,
-0.0128081543,
0.1061419174,
-0.5932013392,
-0.0409982018,
-0.366499573,
0.7689096928,
0.6647536755,
-0.9244959354,
-0.202924639,
-0.6602221131,
0.5229824781,
-0.1243425682,
0.6853276491,
0.3023912013,
0.7863715291,
0.1683071256,
-0.8708804846,
-0.8599800467,
0.2205102146,
0.0664613843,
0.4524857402,
0.0116759967,
0.1160353422,
0.2566374838,
0.4549201429,
-0.5458338261,
-0.3443677425,
-0.6214246154,
-0.0014511909,
0.4576978087,
0.3246755302,
0.1460345536,
-0.2935141325,
-0.7035775781,
-0.3329682648,
-0.2423351556,
0.2216999233,
-0.0300530624,
-0.3269378841,
0.2173298448,
0.8580937386,
-0.4741602242,
0.7154375315,
-0.0372859426,
-0.1598826796,
0.1621751189,
-0.469099164,
-0.2306694835,
-0.1770314425,
0.659003377,
0.4873615503,
-0.0644698143,
0.0236700382,
-0.1694241166,
0.210176006,
0.220978111,
-0.821428299,
-0.1520096958,
0.0782174021,
-0.5210188627,
0.0509630032,
-0.1142555401,
-0.9391553402,
-0.3769970238,
-0.4738876522,
1.0580933094,
-0.4478603005,
-0.2682061493,
0.3633001447,
-0.7677938342,
0.5051087737,
0.4444887042,
-0.4390122294,
0.0984791443,
0.4348040223,
0.4564709961,
0.1087151766,
0.0243056249,
-0.5395437479,
0.1296737343,
-0.0654911697,
0.4483977258,
-0.7730790973,
-0.1836631298,
-0.2374129146,
-0.199691534,
-0.1818373352,
-0.3728784025,
0.5033373833,
-1.1304929256,
0.0066296756,
-0.859377861,
-0.3848907053,
-0.3126671314,
0.5329788327,
-0.6934082508,
0.9841441512,
0.2233572602,
-0.9780452847,
0.3483846188,
-0.3860094547,
-0.0515044443,
0.0157430936,
-0.5019929409,
0.1267148554,
0.0821093321,
0.4762113988,
0.2145268768,
-0.6018535495,
0.1810365468,
-0.1090144515,
-0.3975483179,
0.2116959095,
-0.58173877,
0.7593808174,
0.3498485982,
-0.2922153473,
-0.3733240366,
-0.6448640823,
0.1793910265,
0.0998775139,
-0.2615410984,
-0.6801477075,
-0.2897669971,
-0.0856033638,
0.2943733633,
0.1679876596,
-0.9128351808,
0.1512036473,
0.0692040324,
0.4021762908,
0.6225354075,
0.2114311308,
0.4458268583,
-0.1474146545,
0.5116704106,
0.4998859763,
0.1048772857,
-0.1145663261,
-0.3845557868,
-0.7752118707,
-0.5608864427,
0.2611427903,
0.600800395,
-1.4892994165,
-0.113400355,
-0.1582296193,
-0.5788346529,
-0.8945034742,
0.1519091129,
0.4857185185,
0.6748234034,
0.4606892765,
-0.1766713262,
-0.1661762148,
-0.8528181911,
-0.083997786,
-0.140808776,
0.238134563,
0.3484788835,
0.599380374,
-0.206338346,
0.5916935802,
-0.6886215806,
-0.4427834153,
-0.0240306854,
0.001830117,
0.0089480877,
0.2673152983,
0.3713573813,
-1.4158645868,
-0.672219038,
-0.1420426071,
-0.9436004758,
0.3961950839,
0.0637625754,
-0.4462231994,
-0.0225902926,
0.4144529402,
-0.7379856706,
0.5870025158,
0.05744645,
-0.4638635814,
0.1647232175,
-0.1952572763,
0.6818386912,
-1.1038104296,
0.0447105989,
-0.3389148116,
0.0029843093,
-0.4252108335,
0.2774572074,
0.3067409098,
0.0197565667,
-0.204570055,
0.4424434304,
-0.5371637344,
0.1167115867,
0.1517644674,
-0.0903088674,
0.4330447316,
0.4773128927,
0.1004735231,
0.4393393099,
0.6154033542,
-0.2540355921,
0.5210720897,
0.4695923626,
-0.5186229348,
0.6498124003,
-0.7474042773,
0.1847553849,
-0.9189038277,
0.0208873842,
-1.4885157347,
-0.0168539472,
0.0723374188,
-0.4297198653,
0.4024291337,
-0.2447548807,
-0.4362923801,
-0.5140759945,
-0.1463677585,
0.6755129099,
0.580568552,
-0.5553240776,
0.707015276,
0.1639739275,
0.0214095581,
-1.069183588,
-0.8134765625,
-0.13037166,
-0.0061437148,
-0.8731769323,
0.2435415238,
-0.13491714,
-0.2229623795,
0.2870027125,
-0.3060248792,
-0.5128132105,
0.0295530967,
0.0991983935,
0.1800877899,
-0.2898868918,
0.0086649368,
0.2473765761,
-0.0331254937,
-0.1434293687,
-0.1289955527,
0.2585329711,
0.2420808375,
-0.5374304056,
-0.4393190145,
0.8248705864,
0.8063704967,
-0.4769760072,
0.6700789332,
0.6794580221,
-0.2339598387,
0.0790253431,
-0.7998459935,
-0.1648478955,
-0.4767248929,
0.214492321,
-0.8079053164,
-0.9790000319,
0.4710844457,
0.3607057929,
-0.0801776871,
0.2619011104,
0.4532711506,
-0.3900294304,
0.9759972692,
0.5861641765,
0.3243363798,
0.2267989218,
-0.5167378783,
0.0036362051,
-0.6257435083,
-0.6867566109,
-0.4127334654,
-0.6969797015,
0.0184609275,
-0.7541280985,
0.8109602928,
0.3598363996,
-0.1554907858,
-0.004911188,
-0.6364185214,
0.542624712,
0.8262207508,
0.3176644444,
0.5578547716,
0.1476657987,
-0.3518969119,
-0.3287727535,
-0.6584423184,
0.0797465891,
1.0967612267,
-0.0706528202,
1.0994079113,
0.193442896,
0.6556213498,
0.0950564444,
-0.3262513578,
-0.5969405174,
0.336001873,
-0.1152714118,
-0.7191915512,
-0.2353332639,
-0.5276550651,
-0.5738243461,
0.6060950756,
-0.1016477719,
-0.4261383116,
0.5321426988,
-0.1684682816,
-0.2389781028,
0.1928808689,
-0.7293847799,
0.9674226046,
-0.3818926513,
-0.2812917829,
-0.2849414945,
-0.8116661906,
0.438116312,
0.1685749292,
-0.2412155271,
0.2386322021,
-0.2719338834,
0.5234008431,
-0.2249123752,
0.4141398966,
-0.635655582,
0.1557219774,
0.4452979863,
0.0633490831,
0.1527374685,
0.3667203188,
-0.0814766437,
0.000782937,
0.6802547574,
-0.3499658704,
-0.9501938224,
0.5244128108,
-0.8944118619,
-0.5920693278,
-0.334487021,
-0.481577605,
-0.0687852204,
0.2010962665,
0.3440620601,
0.8593335152,
-0.050332021,
0.5658530593,
0.9084014893,
-0.1258511245,
0.1996243,
0.4755370319,
0.2952389419,
-0.6670614481,
0.5762406588,
0.2494056374,
0.2486387938,
0.8807535768,
-0.1036220565,
-0.6616588831,
-0.4295128286,
-0.9583722353,
0.0586984642,
-1.0523846149,
-0.4645927846,
-1.1420892477,
-0.272564739,
-0.1985357106,
-0.0560307465,
-0.188713029,
-0.4153497219,
-0.096660018,
0.2046682239,
0.4308713377,
0.3577884138,
0.0775306299,
-0.1109571978,
-0.9286081791,
1.0355026722,
0.5892230272,
0.1581653506,
-0.144778803,
-0.3684532046,
0.1945299059,
0.4380241036,
-0.1763581038,
-0.9393456578,
0.1654719859,
0.1894048899,
0.5411953926,
0.113406308,
0.5875054002,
1.039319396,
-0.2440548539,
0.7141789198,
0.2642703652,
-0.4576914608,
0.2925765812,
-0.0790610537,
0.5189239979,
1.0717338324,
0.7368859053,
-0.6439086199,
-0.0423613191,
-0.082680136,
-0.6516357064,
0.5293027759,
-0.0241572428,
0.1512206197,
-0.0213668253,
0.3047296703,
0.3247374892,
0.2750748396,
-0.2822934389,
-0.2124603391,
-0.31879282,
-0.4327968955,
0.2045039982,
-0.4599235356,
-0.210962683,
-0.4775190055,
0.3484174013,
-0.158334434,
0.4112298191,
0.7112756968,
-0.479126066,
0.0952980295,
0.1905433685,
-0.1928815693,
0.4936366975,
-0.087964274,
0.2787309885,
-0.2775589526,
-0.5195145011,
0.2620195448,
0.2775257528,
-0.3508684039,
0.0034593306,
-0.0697489232,
0.6188688278,
-0.1585662663,
-0.846808672,
0.8783246875,
-0.4143944085,
-0.4491274953,
-0.2633977234,
-0.1519226879,
0.0785840675,
0.5916875601,
0.5213748813,
0.0589452311,
0.4256030321,
-0.37208125,
0.1243678257,
0.6077005267,
-0.4315059483,
-0.0148812402,
0.7755883336,
0.1117846072,
0.271671325,
0.8824538589,
-0.0383746773,
-0.3774042726,
0.5744577646,
0.2608997524,
0.6468685269,
0.2476281822,
0.385181129,
0.4225612581,
0.1772641987,
0.172864601,
0.9937313795,
-0.5771541595,
-0.6428721547,
-0.2256205082,
-0.6991791129,
0.063567996,
0.0625697449,
-0.8179669976,
0.170979619,
-0.1861305982,
0.1065184996,
0.0377038941,
-0.0640820712,
-0.8517099619,
-0.0165992733,
0.0659392551,
0.9005789161,
-0.4603560567,
0.6663357615,
0.6842934489,
-0.4550204575,
-0.6001419425,
-0.2597138584,
0.0714159682,
-0.6433109045,
0.6814181209,
0.0718707591,
0.0808262751,
0.1931343228,
-0.2404280007,
-0.8308430314,
1.4339243174,
0.3988988698,
-0.3965398669,
-0.1094157547,
0.3267762959,
0.310768038,
0.1509791613,
0.434871614,
0.2691186965,
0.4079522491,
0.5706180334,
-0.6092643142,
-0.0447503626,
-0.4501654506,
0.0359700061,
0.2268837392,
-0.662411809,
0.5695159435,
-0.2089283466,
-0.3921177685,
0.3127776384,
0.3903302252,
-0.0842851996,
0.3275182545,
0.4556757808,
0.8534436822,
0.5617653728,
-0.1271044761,
0.7566398382,
-0.0504345037,
-0.0994047895,
0.9002889991,
-0.1153422073,
0.8059019446,
0.7460996509,
0.159004882,
0.327080667,
0.2706603408,
0.1571163088,
0.8601583838,
-0.1542465091,
-0.3725206554,
-0.5363892913,
-0.0359010324,
-0.476138711,
0.726746738,
0.209978804,
-0.3041451573,
-0.4497425258,
0.2542386651,
-0.5745694041,
0.2042663097,
-0.1522986442,
1.022400856,
0.0648457929,
-0.7644264698,
0.8582940698,
-0.095792748,
0.5719419122,
-0.6280839443,
-0.1938708574,
-0.2158110738,
0.2663257122,
0.1430999786,
-1.0125137568,
0.1933190674,
-0.1578407735,
-0.366825223,
-0.3421224356,
1.0078310966,
-0.6958202124,
-0.4448688924,
0.2277596444,
0.8602688909,
-0.2284758836,
-0.158095032,
-0.7198235393,
-0.04948489,
0.0161723904,
-0.1873565763,
0.2383490652,
0.6381748915,
0.0177193228,
0.5910592675,
0.330442667,
-0.6030448079,
0.2770965695,
0.0033455591,
1.1507028341,
-0.5243725777,
-0.4231370389,
-0.5763065219,
0.7684813142,
0.0431513228,
-0.193111226,
0.5450699329,
0.4300284982,
0.6829614043,
-0.1632327884,
0.6362720728,
-0.4701420665,
0.0610379539,
-0.4578053653,
0.6971641779,
-0.9351777434,
-0.1007484421,
-0.28054896,
-0.8896195292,
-0.0082554165,
0.2093864083,
-0.0142353578,
-0.4007451236,
0.4736990631,
1.049425602,
-0.1993214637,
0.1043262109,
0.2651381493,
-0.0099572781,
0.0357168242,
0.808827281,
1.1764119864,
-0.7293100953,
0.7998319864,
-0.4435552657,
-0.0434561893,
0.1116696224,
-0.2668045759,
-0.7900819778,
-1.038136363,
-0.1957161725,
-0.2029464394,
0.1321276724,
0.3683458269,
0.4678860307,
-0.2169872075,
0.2840552926,
0.1650508195,
0.0717204437,
-0.2511992157,
-0.2180742472,
0.1501266509,
-0.1088597104,
-0.5872352123,
0.1783200353,
0.2441227585,
-0.1575419307,
-0.0714105144,
0.0076019662,
-0.3440882564,
-0.1804838777,
0.4296248555,
0.00921073,
-0.460303396,
-0.1981107295,
0.4533933997,
-0.1732954085,
0.0937374458,
0.648594439,
-0.9539331198,
0.9278404117,
1.1105048656,
1.1363942623,
0.8809697032,
0.0029265007,
0.4348962009,
-0.5273415446,
0.1040450409,
0.4137134552,
0.0465173796,
0.1716328263,
-0.3413310349,
0.3715470731,
0.336607486,
-0.3359065652,
-0.683016181,
0.2156859934,
-1.2286022902,
-0.2797953188,
1.1389584541,
0.0412665009,
-0.2613222599,
-0.2477708459,
-0.347879082,
0.101018846,
-0.1795608401,
0.3612550497,
0.4502735138,
0.2401070446,
-0.3681410253,
-0.5591629744,
0.239596203,
0.3129208386,
-0.2527069747,
-0.1102647632,
0.7537466288,
0.3518989384,
-0.0329392888,
0.9095316529,
-0.4310270846,
0.5298879147,
0.229049772,
-0.2663617432,
-0.3732245266,
-0.310878247,
-0.1349770874,
0.2259284854,
-0.1725544184,
-0.3671684861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13634v1 | HausaNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Leveraging African Low Resource TweetData for Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-26T15:47:50 | 2023-04-26T15:47:50 | Saheed Abdullahi Salahudeen, Falalu Ibrahim Lawan, Ahmad Mustapha Wali, Amina Abubakar Imam, Aliyu Rabiu Shuaibu, Aliyu Yusuf, Nur Bala Rabiu, Musa Bello, Shamsuddeen Umaru Adamu, Saminu Mohammad Aliyu, Murja Sani Gadanya, Sanah Abdullahi Muaz, Mahmoud Said Ahmad, Abdulkadir Abdullahi, Abdulmalik Yusuf Jamoh | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the findings of SemEval-2023 Task 12, a shared task on sentiment
analysis for low-resource African languages using Twitter dataset. The task
featured three subtasks; subtask A is monolingual sentiment classification with
12 tracks which are all monolingual languages, subtask B is multilingual
sentiment classification using the tracks in subtask A and subtask C is a
zero-shot sentiment classification. We present the results and findings of
subtask A, subtask B and subtask C. We also release the code on github. Our
goal is to leverage low-resource tweet data using pre-trained Afro-xlmr-large,
AfriBERTa-Large, Bert-base-arabic-camelbert-da-sentiment (Arabic-camelbert),
Multilingual-BERT (mBERT) and BERT models for sentiment analysis of 14 African
languages. The datasets for these subtasks consists of a gold standard
multi-class labeled Twitter datasets from these languages. Our results
demonstrate that Afro-xlmr-large model performed better compared to the other
models in most of the languages datasets. Similarly, Nigerian languages: Hausa,
Igbo, and Yoruba achieved better performance compared to other languages and
this can be attributed to the higher volume of data present in the languages. | [
-0.5536829233,
-0.3683283031,
0.0506420434,
0.6437399983,
-0.476677388,
0.2517417669,
-0.3789731264,
-0.6837592721,
0.8197311163,
0.5665823817,
-0.7083870173,
-0.6225904822,
-0.7842375636,
0.117638506,
-0.0650844574,
0.8408900499,
-0.124709554,
-0.1980587989,
0.0962667093,
-0.6135084629,
-0.3060936332,
-0.5847637057,
-0.8664758205,
-0.2203091979,
0.7911410928,
0.6351489425,
0.5357156396,
-0.1892639995,
0.3179484904,
0.2230618149,
-0.0139099499,
0.2108038217,
-0.37802279,
0.0107752299,
-0.2532147169,
0.0840417296,
-0.614326179,
0.0938360244,
-0.0847858563,
0.6305968761,
0.0092269862,
0.3994499147,
0.3244758546,
0.430490315,
-0.7176219225,
0.1955795288,
-0.3216611743,
-0.0722216591,
-0.5180401206,
-0.008687526,
0.0020544254,
-0.4018216729,
-0.0037006382,
-0.1338899285,
-0.1533742249,
-0.1409081519,
0.9348287582,
0.2723123431,
-0.4395360947,
-0.2987689674,
-0.1194390059,
1.0875453949,
-0.7767520547,
-0.0117576197,
0.6030952334,
0.3392425478,
0.4853972495,
-0.4105561674,
-0.2681798339,
0.3106256723,
0.0882802904,
0.2524886727,
-0.1660459191,
-0.231185019,
0.0058287885,
0.2497595251,
0.016665766,
0.0115230978,
-0.2909268737,
-0.2766672969,
0.8363813758,
-0.1213358417,
0.0191554017,
-0.6232270598,
-0.2095122933,
0.1476334184,
-0.5540707707,
-0.1082195342,
0.3997211754,
0.6063789725,
-0.4498515129,
0.4952972531,
-0.1511282921,
0.2552329898,
-0.5351525545,
-0.0167611409,
0.6597678065,
-0.2516499162,
-0.1141511723,
-0.0301724654,
1.0031963587,
0.1739320606,
0.3847526908,
0.1872036159,
-0.4846193194,
0.0100503005,
0.3776862323,
-0.546512723,
0.0110251289,
-0.0637944415,
-0.7072711587,
-0.4541291893,
-0.352825731,
-1.0980632305,
-0.5859077573,
-0.1493719071,
0.7724505067,
-0.2293668836,
-0.138278231,
-0.3027999103,
0.303684622,
-0.0353314169,
0.6547173858,
-0.7665780187,
0.2115478814,
0.3824217618,
0.8386663198,
-0.2447593361,
-0.2410117239,
-0.0986674204,
-0.3432811797,
-0.1639434546,
0.49939695,
-0.3774498105,
-0.4167814553,
0.2169925869,
0.1188231856,
-0.0368658006,
-0.4861073494,
0.8943151236,
-0.3745342791,
-0.2064994574,
-0.669505775,
-0.1317303628,
-0.4760610759,
0.4367338717,
-0.7552697659,
1.0539507866,
0.5055536032,
-0.7064512968,
0.1653284729,
-0.9108958244,
-0.9504512548,
-0.0576355867,
-0.1699516922,
-0.364985615,
0.2244927138,
0.4256021976,
0.5664609075,
-0.4154405296,
-0.288376689,
-0.332776159,
-0.1425254941,
-0.0356480516,
-0.2897526026,
1.0409671068,
0.4355455339,
-0.6619228125,
-0.3100559413,
-0.6015924215,
-0.1566376686,
0.0711958781,
-0.2789912522,
-0.2370059788,
-0.2053310126,
0.2851242423,
0.3330481052,
0.4990856349,
-0.8626846075,
-0.0635537729,
-0.0398825668,
0.1952273548,
0.6489505768,
0.3095707595,
0.2546233535,
0.0675241724,
0.844024837,
0.0595204309,
0.0597662553,
0.0760459006,
-0.383287847,
-1.0362770557,
-0.0576036982,
0.4730669856,
0.5572793484,
-0.8616736531,
0.1145555004,
-0.1994680613,
-0.3687003851,
-0.8225581646,
0.2058453858,
-0.1333082318,
0.3418072462,
0.4296836257,
-0.0839818045,
-0.9534488916,
-1.0544034243,
-0.0375581458,
-0.1624255329,
0.3776505589,
0.3450273573,
0.6715595126,
-0.5710127354,
0.4189551771,
-0.23517479,
-0.410227716,
-0.5406352282,
0.4996370673,
0.2813702226,
0.304300487,
0.7729974985,
-0.4399595559,
-0.5336806178,
0.0722412765,
-0.8474115133,
-0.3335311115,
0.2334756553,
-0.2377745509,
0.6462309361,
0.3490778804,
-0.0381229557,
0.5216929913,
0.7125046849,
-0.1093848497,
0.0257004127,
0.4918795824,
0.4858063459,
-1.4166603088,
-0.0820656344,
-0.1582324505,
-0.3401936293,
-0.2732951343,
-0.3156399429,
-0.2031946331,
-0.2732777297,
-0.5158644319,
0.536028564,
-0.1784784049,
0.0423431583,
-0.4619045854,
-0.3610283136,
-0.339263767,
0.3959762156,
0.1612110138,
0.7627748847,
0.2392593622,
-0.2733924091,
0.3305398822,
0.203279525,
-0.473860532,
0.3222542405,
-0.5944618583,
-0.0103888754,
0.2902175486,
-0.3565319777,
-0.6800661683,
-0.1964128762,
-0.0325871669,
-0.6484191418,
0.1314380765,
-0.0883261189,
-0.546348691,
-0.4596366286,
-0.1020065621,
0.2088351697,
0.4663313925,
-0.4869255722,
0.6618843675,
0.8454583287,
-0.4718272388,
-0.7913810611,
-1.0353566408,
0.2610443532,
-0.1177522689,
-0.5756905079,
-0.1075772792,
0.4953463078,
-0.130709514,
0.08114665,
-0.0365048796,
0.0589044169,
0.2106090784,
0.3434059918,
0.1141320691,
0.0731103495,
-0.0997371525,
0.0222113319,
0.1024084911,
0.0301698167,
-0.1730194241,
0.7035378814,
-0.2542372942,
-0.0739748403,
0.0417440198,
0.512732923,
0.2033558637,
-0.1388293356,
1.0961377621,
0.9812313318,
-0.5561940074,
-0.1479398608,
-0.5801913142,
0.2382119298,
-0.3729996383,
0.1133261099,
-0.3472435474,
-1.140434742,
0.6211267114,
0.0822186247,
0.0882680789,
0.3340930641,
0.7945387959,
-0.4882113338,
0.8007876277,
0.7277885079,
-0.518012464,
0.3264988661,
-0.6109821796,
0.2481780499,
-0.5393400788,
-0.0254981164,
-0.6043017507,
-0.554792881,
-0.8743642569,
-0.4154265225,
0.2798149884,
-0.2675856054,
0.0294247344,
0.5220693946,
0.3378544152,
0.1242876425,
0.5199502707,
0.0628238395,
-0.369613111,
0.3386166692,
-0.1371218264,
-0.0822879821,
-0.6175802946,
-0.6609047055,
0.8388729692,
0.3425378203,
0.9643951654,
0.0916962475,
1.2448880672,
0.5865357518,
0.2601695359,
-0.9136567712,
0.6236748099,
-0.4246950746,
-0.5175542235,
-0.219717443,
-0.3420128524,
-0.8729736805,
0.0120624304,
-0.0528266393,
-0.52706182,
0.4763934314,
-0.115498893,
-0.1642919332,
0.0985683799,
-0.3467000127,
1.0001075268,
0.0554278754,
-0.3393919766,
-0.2773638368,
-0.3990012705,
0.1052273735,
-0.2583140433,
0.5062827468,
-0.2420559675,
-0.1788155735,
1.0237648487,
-0.6536915302,
0.9016128778,
-0.4189425111,
-0.1633056104,
0.5460035205,
0.0081778588,
0.2815252244,
0.0686836094,
-0.4403354824,
0.3936730027,
-0.2232989967,
-0.776011169,
-0.0482421778,
0.7187928557,
-1.0192793608,
-0.2015913725,
-0.4609546065,
-0.3139758408,
-0.4782004058,
0.054681886,
0.4855530262,
0.3569965065,
-0.1910996437,
0.4917887449,
0.1348640025,
-0.2275763601,
0.6775583029,
0.1311107278,
0.0903587937,
-0.5738059282,
0.8757945895,
0.2053285986,
-0.0054087033,
0.2399978191,
-0.0582998246,
-0.3247992992,
-0.3241429329,
-0.1299307644,
0.1511429101,
-0.7368103266,
-0.5090835094,
-0.7614902258,
-0.2049494088,
-0.6107004285,
-0.1785013825,
-0.4675979614,
-0.7503306866,
-0.1339445263,
-0.1017211378,
0.1391173303,
0.4223277271,
-0.5217387676,
0.5641840696,
-1.0443696976,
0.1499276161,
0.1525045037,
-0.1151268631,
-0.0702580661,
-0.6012037396,
-0.7895719409,
-0.0469373837,
-0.3062840104,
-0.7663518786,
0.7348155975,
0.1440151334,
0.3979639709,
0.1677680016,
0.0836733431,
0.6064682603,
-0.198127076,
0.8881677389,
-0.0185559373,
-0.9577308297,
0.9151661396,
-0.419289887,
0.3740544915,
1.0856237411,
0.6529781222,
-0.590914011,
-0.292881012,
-0.5211578012,
-0.7359515429,
0.9168733954,
0.491671294,
0.1977158636,
-0.2324973494,
-0.0798356012,
0.2055097669,
0.5215732455,
-0.6379941702,
-0.1695689261,
-0.4508442879,
-0.3690572679,
-0.272475481,
-0.3973386884,
0.0247642379,
-0.0838877335,
0.9337189198,
-0.0959550142,
0.393056035,
-0.126205951,
-0.32089746,
-0.1916975379,
0.5565195084,
0.0788303539,
0.5179612637,
-0.3182986379,
0.0457595102,
0.2273714989,
-0.4862987101,
0.1668570489,
0.1935954094,
-0.3846775293,
0.0749449208,
0.6680830717,
0.9943847656,
0.0236470588,
-0.2225786597,
0.4676321447,
-0.0689809993,
-0.1942078322,
-0.3710878789,
-0.3173685074,
0.0590404421,
0.1064508632,
0.2219821662,
0.3152063489,
0.127610445,
-0.6650714278,
-0.028660303,
0.072504513,
-0.5887559652,
-0.4980623126,
0.2968407869,
0.6681470275,
0.2411609143,
0.4977845848,
-0.2732449174,
-0.8235796094,
0.3717318773,
0.182026878,
1.0242235661,
-0.2881345153,
0.4654050767,
0.4744604528,
0.5920882821,
0.2463406473,
0.882845521,
-0.1021470428,
-0.9095124006,
-0.4347769916,
-1.0013881922,
-0.3144101501,
0.2422178239,
-0.7264155746,
0.3483201563,
-0.3323103487,
-0.3728528917,
-0.1727445126,
0.3800317645,
-0.7758685946,
0.5121718645,
0.2317534387,
0.9048083425,
-0.9522846341,
0.8952314258,
1.2002846003,
-0.418735683,
-0.6688324213,
-0.1524104178,
0.2319357842,
-0.7931227088,
0.7201619744,
0.1917896867,
-0.0320801958,
-0.1627928466,
-0.4782387316,
-0.5511575937,
0.8300930858,
0.1087034419,
-0.2397075146,
0.3286107183,
0.3598078489,
0.4940259457,
-0.4656062424,
-0.0703963339,
0.6273236275,
0.3678361475,
0.2498522699,
-0.7422031164,
-0.2106414437,
-0.3254536092,
-0.1255455315,
0.3260261118,
-0.7131385207,
0.6422576904,
-0.0017531295,
-0.125361219,
-0.0448829085,
1.0221097469,
-0.0679667816,
0.1275417954,
0.6416443586,
0.8275105953,
0.5007107854,
-0.2938089371,
0.9326065779,
-0.1377656013,
0.320648253,
0.9968733191,
-0.2108912617,
0.9184322953,
0.4423733354,
-0.2178381979,
0.3595322371,
0.8047242761,
0.3472775221,
0.5295698047,
-0.201068297,
-0.4011584222,
-0.3710673749,
-0.5402551293,
-0.1988689154,
0.6366570592,
0.449064225,
-0.0643662587,
-0.3316369355,
0.2885172367,
0.1575354338,
-0.0779066905,
-0.5287586451,
0.5748835802,
0.4140708447,
-0.4709618986,
0.4273296297,
-0.0651152655,
0.8029978871,
-0.4784646332,
0.3420601487,
-0.3972854614,
0.2230383903,
-0.1654735804,
-0.9084650278,
0.6023014188,
0.2313253731,
0.1071584076,
-0.2056293935,
0.9218446612,
-0.253787756,
-0.6200771332,
0.5823441744,
0.5275265574,
0.0328026824,
0.0208210219,
-0.8002755642,
0.3068418205,
0.1939631552,
-0.1596857607,
0.0977350622,
0.6177640557,
-0.090769656,
0.2859710753,
0.0507500991,
0.3606534898,
-0.054577224,
0.7098180056,
0.6877411604,
-0.7641148567,
-0.498265624,
-0.5824325085,
0.1311712563,
-0.2236034572,
-0.1301716417,
0.9550351501,
0.4243168533,
0.8540974855,
-0.2077478021,
1.125366807,
-0.4440464079,
0.9380242825,
-0.353440702,
0.5124199986,
-0.854737103,
0.1302194148,
-0.3902612031,
-1.0055972338,
0.1287876517,
0.6083629131,
-0.2810725272,
0.0987625644,
0.7143835425,
0.5537636876,
0.0022501952,
0.2172427624,
0.2150995284,
0.1885373741,
0.1063737273,
0.3243103325,
0.947712183,
-0.571900785,
0.4302329421,
-0.707634151,
-0.0885424688,
-0.195493117,
-0.8081588745,
-1.0699247122,
-0.4681327045,
-0.3005243242,
-0.495873183,
-0.1428026259,
1.2240204811,
0.5726645589,
-1.1924766302,
-0.4758095145,
0.3239620924,
-0.116071485,
0.0900262073,
-0.2494310737,
0.2284723073,
-0.5325657129,
-0.7485513687,
0.214606449,
0.2875396013,
0.1397286505,
0.1535730362,
0.0008994443,
-0.5432541966,
0.0947269276,
0.979754746,
0.1809316725,
-0.265096724,
-0.1822468936,
0.0018129108,
-0.1296532601,
-0.224133119,
0.6971853971,
-0.536187768,
0.0738189444,
0.6558081508,
0.7906731963,
0.5964443088,
-0.005665808,
0.3972707391,
-0.9864528179,
0.2203054279,
0.3531321883,
0.6714248657,
0.5110848546,
0.02654895,
1.0551860332,
0.2203648984,
-0.4925771654,
-0.5265833139,
-0.0627408251,
-1.1302593946,
0.0145961195,
1.0711177588,
-0.1879895777,
-0.4991444349,
-0.0003781692,
-0.1336966157,
0.2140364051,
-0.6681134105,
0.5328873992,
0.8358564973,
-0.0572192632,
-0.3784626722,
-0.5886702538,
0.394554615,
0.4729927182,
-1.0827414989,
-0.2751610577,
0.2478781044,
-0.2099790871,
0.1748272479,
0.767855227,
-0.2123299092,
0.2398357391,
-0.2263955474,
0.1260857582,
0.2635120451,
-0.1488083005,
-0.2047256976,
0.0542820506,
-0.1586576104,
-0.2822393477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13620v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13620v3 | ChartSumm: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Automatic Chart Summarization of Long and Short Summaries | 2023-04-26T15:25:24 | 2023-06-11T04:07:27 | Raian Rahman, Rizvi Hasan, Abdullah Al Farhad, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Md. Hamjajul Ashmafee, Abu Raihan Mostofa Kamal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Automatic chart to text summarization is an effective tool for the visually
impaired people along with providing precise insights of tabular data in
natural language to the user. A large and well-structured dataset is always a
key part for data driven models. In this paper, we propose ChartSumm: a
large-scale benchmark dataset consisting of a total of 84,363 charts along with
their metadata and descriptions covering a wide range of topics and chart types
to generate short and long summaries. Extensive experiments with strong
baseline models show that even though these models generate fluent and
informative summaries by achieving decent scores in various automatic
evaluation metrics, they often face issues like suffering from hallucination,
missing out important data points, in addition to incorrect explanation of
complex trends in the charts. We also investigated the potential of expanding
ChartSumm to other languages using automated translation tools. These make our
dataset a challenging benchmark for future research. | [
-0.4340178967,
-0.4957695901,
0.3647010326,
0.1168249622,
-0.462025255,
0.0404677689,
-0.1539193094,
-0.4830362201,
0.0238262247,
0.6486589909,
-0.1859844923,
-0.9746621847,
-0.8445167542,
0.2550621629,
-0.7518948913,
0.8368922472,
-0.3732794523,
-0.1285190731,
-0.0201134328,
-0.3782748878,
-0.7019963861,
-0.3971642554,
-0.1243149042,
0.0530981869,
0.3914730847,
0.8857713938,
0.6930800676,
0.8598152399,
0.8741803765,
0.2935737073,
0.4289215803,
0.4655455947,
-0.6210310459,
0.213050589,
0.0533541068,
-0.3160712719,
-0.7649438977,
-0.1383171976,
0.6579070091,
0.8674280047,
0.2169846594,
0.4142493606,
0.0974973217,
1.2172265053,
-0.4128286541,
0.5864378214,
-0.1514960974,
-0.0363832563,
-0.2696997225,
-0.3104387224,
-0.3128967285,
-0.5749856234,
0.1392923743,
-0.5604635477,
0.0605576783,
0.2736738324,
0.7843410373,
0.3234643042,
-0.7547610402,
-0.4504161477,
-0.5278227329,
0.5899779797,
-0.6876572371,
0.264710784,
0.3573981822,
0.8790940046,
0.1549566984,
-0.8883682489,
0.0707360804,
-0.1423742473,
-0.275773108,
0.3584037721,
-0.2370656431,
-0.3573952913,
0.1137163192,
0.265742898,
-0.7855629921,
0.0419487432,
-0.3400247395,
0.1450473964,
0.8619471192,
0.6893340349,
0.2722353041,
-0.31574139,
-0.1790267974,
-0.2173420191,
-0.2885956168,
-0.4480816424,
0.1910620183,
0.4961951077,
-0.6219258308,
0.685677886,
-0.4466329813,
0.7039403915,
-0.4660362601,
-0.0828745961,
0.3545180559,
-0.2556197941,
-0.1689089835,
0.0363554917,
0.6493920088,
0.7719078064,
0.7379056811,
-0.1250653863,
-0.2982739508,
0.0259056929,
-0.0461319573,
-0.7830350399,
-0.3530126512,
0.0975029618,
-0.4093779325,
0.039110817,
0.1567589194,
-0.8819339871,
-0.5201852918,
-0.6247954965,
0.155367136,
-0.4458873868,
0.0335052125,
0.1089565605,
-0.1688941866,
-0.3608537018,
0.509337306,
-0.5127131939,
0.5541093946,
0.6924743652,
1.0412788391,
-0.4999729395,
-0.2687945068,
-0.443140626,
0.4285077155,
-0.5429335237,
0.7970193028,
-0.2032509595,
-0.3533864319,
-0.2708198726,
0.1124622822,
-0.1987789124,
-0.6643041372,
0.2491802126,
-0.1927153766,
-0.1027196646,
-0.1375681311,
-0.7333077788,
-0.5069517493,
0.1574261039,
-0.8057883978,
0.7880354524,
0.2281971276,
-0.5231383443,
0.4294174612,
-0.6270478964,
-0.62053442,
0.1831514239,
-0.4036937356,
-0.6936457157,
-0.1199238226,
0.3083295226,
0.5031200647,
-0.3907657862,
0.208037138,
-0.0889800787,
-0.3672805429,
0.2127597183,
-0.0951372385,
0.2531562448,
0.1891685873,
-0.4732756019,
0.2955117524,
-0.6472952962,
-0.1092655361,
0.1781244874,
0.1697421223,
-0.1881683618,
0.0538974404,
0.4498259127,
0.0523829572,
0.0275508817,
0.3349761665,
-0.1462090313,
-0.0884595662,
0.2722668648,
0.4447437823,
0.2111272961,
0.0743774101,
-0.4916121662,
0.5635582209,
-0.0340630971,
-0.0783343539,
-0.3730442822,
-0.3649301231,
-0.7122243047,
-0.5646897554,
0.2422005236,
0.4283083677,
-0.3110447228,
0.6654106379,
-0.7687898278,
-0.7927359939,
-0.0796158537,
0.2385752797,
0.1800267398,
0.7671922445,
0.2994935215,
-0.4260679185,
-0.3705178201,
-0.9538852572,
-0.0636578426,
0.1045883447,
-0.1478212178,
0.2247777432,
0.7335675955,
-0.1499428153,
0.7708497047,
-0.571261704,
-0.6021226645,
-0.395947963,
0.3748241365,
0.0357821099,
0.282531321,
0.8655974865,
-0.659712553,
-0.6592977047,
-0.0970026851,
-0.9598914385,
-0.0855694637,
-0.1850419939,
-0.2318011671,
0.0326311849,
0.4485407174,
-0.3306957781,
0.6719987392,
0.2457415164,
-0.3828824162,
0.5328092575,
-0.2870796919,
0.4883506596,
-0.8858916163,
0.4464150071,
-0.1085321978,
-0.4537760615,
-0.1984018385,
-0.1716650724,
0.3607730567,
-0.3370433152,
-0.0645418987,
0.4282145798,
-0.6644337773,
-0.3671147525,
-0.2714797258,
0.5803698897,
-0.0095717721,
0.298448205,
0.0029789445,
0.5898682475,
0.4513647556,
-0.5730040669,
0.4663985372,
0.4540781379,
-0.5524611473,
0.6807509661,
-0.5819764137,
-0.3113387823,
-0.0472448319,
0.2162590325,
-1.1823935509,
-0.2993664443,
0.092885077,
-0.2974227071,
0.1030563489,
0.13415429,
-0.7640382051,
-0.3616380394,
-0.2469460219,
0.2229550928,
0.3482696116,
-0.2973262966,
0.365031451,
0.5123944879,
-0.3530340195,
-0.0261577833,
-0.7695442438,
0.5594852567,
-0.4492813945,
-0.5962173939,
-0.1110810637,
-0.0864437371,
-0.3279744983,
-0.1720848829,
-0.0162850209,
0.2755424976,
0.1382766068,
0.4162890613,
0.3371333778,
-0.1961153746,
0.190993607,
-0.3094634414,
-0.5677541494,
-0.1752403378,
0.1900492758,
0.3252481818,
-0.1257197857,
-0.5748111606,
-0.3343340158,
0.3678734899,
0.7232819796,
-0.2478237599,
0.1264667064,
0.1464361846,
-0.3377881944,
-0.0323826186,
-0.2180891931,
0.1447228044,
-0.3610605896,
0.7685651183,
-0.1515309215,
-0.2693793774,
0.5714477897,
0.0111324582,
0.1886002868,
0.5283655524,
0.582439661,
0.0691961944,
1.2029350996,
0.3371946514,
-0.3112101853,
0.1883348376,
-0.1764390618,
-0.0265844315,
-0.1420102119,
0.04667335,
-0.5384854674,
-0.4185799658,
-0.4304592907,
-0.414919138,
0.4165921509,
-0.115036577,
-0.038996473,
0.2393323332,
-0.4999082983,
0.1462331265,
0.1118575558,
-0.0654724017,
0.5769531131,
-0.1821694076,
0.2949092388,
-0.2043753117,
-0.5067597032,
-0.9311159849,
1.1989982128,
0.2037887573,
0.6945816875,
0.0074984911,
0.2412456423,
0.628828764,
0.5087746978,
-0.8118289709,
0.5367134809,
-0.0891577899,
-0.4525412321,
-0.3773863614,
-0.5129334927,
-1.0035122633,
-0.0039324649,
-0.0674741417,
-0.4510349631,
-0.101414673,
0.1479257345,
0.0904313549,
0.0592453517,
-0.8993193507,
0.959939301,
-0.6417910457,
0.0167799518,
-0.2808877528,
-0.8093805313,
0.2951355577,
-0.2324761301,
0.4808224738,
-0.5388172865,
-0.2486383766,
0.995868504,
-0.5770098567,
0.4900136292,
0.1177323535,
0.0196773689,
0.0418473035,
-0.0170633867,
0.3819668293,
-0.0612107851,
0.0538693517,
-0.0186315961,
-0.2038625777,
-0.6145354509,
-0.3745167255,
0.4938500822,
-0.5934423208,
-0.0787764788,
-0.409802705,
-0.7689726949,
-0.4370944202,
0.2848344147,
0.0784433335,
0.6668960452,
-0.2393052727,
-0.0047435155,
0.0270839948,
-0.0418571718,
0.2034933716,
0.6322938204,
-0.2324507684,
-0.5643193722,
0.8727108836,
0.3963891566,
0.2192758173,
0.2095659971,
-0.2443983406,
-0.042845659,
-0.673394382,
-0.5949879289,
0.2794816196,
-0.9406629205,
-0.2415710986,
-0.2914908528,
0.0580392405,
-0.2089831829,
-0.2582266927,
-0.1796819866,
-0.5047661662,
-0.0800742209,
-0.2845986187,
0.4817512035,
0.6896805167,
0.051262375,
0.168835178,
-0.7526510954,
0.8300718069,
0.2253211588,
0.3874686062,
0.1580694318,
-0.2875416875,
-0.6826959252,
-0.1251759082,
-0.2603228092,
-0.7466771603,
0.501265347,
0.1012552008,
0.3752106428,
0.7098106146,
0.1106778532,
0.8277074099,
-0.3665646315,
0.4421964586,
0.3129114807,
-0.6855174899,
0.3757590055,
-0.3092886508,
0.6148788333,
0.6274513006,
0.2734817266,
-0.6514003873,
-0.6898248792,
-0.2609508038,
-1.0918726921,
0.4298867285,
0.317618072,
-0.3369881511,
0.1936043203,
-0.187075749,
0.5009152293,
0.1144783422,
-0.0383608341,
-0.4634876251,
-0.2649648786,
-0.5102494955,
-0.6902202964,
-0.0435412638,
-0.2496230602,
-0.3153295517,
0.570348978,
-0.1181807294,
-0.3731401563,
-0.0484168492,
-0.5424615741,
-0.2586542964,
0.0025499081,
0.5376524329,
1.292252183,
-0.3537921011,
0.3211975098,
0.135165751,
-0.4965439141,
-0.1861434132,
0.4901308119,
-0.007990432,
0.2436956912,
0.6284843683,
0.7971591949,
0.4143408537,
-1.1998645067,
0.2027283013,
-0.1367415637,
0.0069238613,
-0.1795542836,
-0.1297819763,
0.2570266724,
-0.0372381769,
0.7321817875,
-0.187293753,
0.2048808038,
-0.3599029481,
0.380215764,
0.0627540126,
-0.4047880173,
-0.1586601138,
0.8101406693,
0.2207415253,
-0.0908890367,
0.3509531319,
0.3613441586,
-0.2326965481,
0.7877936959,
-0.0311504193,
0.6491116881,
0.2067766786,
0.0823261589,
0.3901181519,
0.392845124,
0.1059061214,
0.0908723325,
-0.0943991989,
0.0464702062,
-0.078365013,
0.030719908,
-0.6350857019,
-0.1265900433,
-0.6821751595,
0.442139715,
0.0237282161,
-0.2092357278,
0.0621359609,
0.0900451839,
-0.5126698613,
0.4375694096,
0.1650638729,
0.8549319506,
-0.8568149209,
0.3176238835,
0.2686495483,
-0.4702455699,
-0.3605923951,
-0.4039266706,
0.002115286,
-0.7011884451,
0.2857768238,
0.2474797219,
0.0305909626,
-0.1512606889,
-0.4239903688,
-0.5059006214,
1.0728642941,
0.3236997426,
-0.6155732274,
0.0667145476,
0.6197541952,
0.4631058276,
-0.3131205738,
0.2774894536,
0.7465349436,
0.814486444,
-0.3252089322,
-0.8017178774,
0.1678827107,
-0.4016493559,
-0.1866875589,
0.1996314079,
-0.5903910995,
0.5773827434,
-0.092951566,
-0.3433493376,
0.2470375448,
0.5701239705,
0.2560275793,
0.6803533435,
0.3008196354,
0.2315669954,
0.6277230978,
-0.1148179397,
0.748251617,
-0.5336414576,
0.2319334596,
1.2486991882,
-0.1745091677,
0.5243241787,
0.2153562903,
0.1103848219,
0.1530461311,
0.7685379982,
-0.2231171429,
0.3172909915,
0.0757329389,
0.4448549449,
-0.2000457942,
0.2392596751,
-0.6773319244,
0.0840286538,
0.3357875943,
-0.4358898401,
-0.5334590077,
-0.063065052,
-0.1539076418,
0.409037292,
-0.2217983454,
0.648665309,
0.2290968299,
-0.311874181,
0.7229198217,
-0.1949245632,
0.1555497348,
-0.6897090673,
0.0857241079,
-0.2756521106,
0.0203379989,
-0.1480731815,
-0.6350159049,
0.0701126754,
0.1175292432,
0.1354417801,
-0.2275981158,
0.375505805,
-0.2082904726,
-0.6072216034,
0.2448262572,
0.6236807704,
0.3117247522,
0.0544642024,
-0.5514653921,
-0.0777833834,
-0.3925015628,
-0.1774412543,
0.0856399983,
0.751259923,
-0.2421512157,
0.8746452928,
0.1282376051,
0.025238229,
-0.1341481656,
0.2673105597,
0.6115234494,
-0.8826331496,
-0.970567286,
-0.5893022418,
0.5227714181,
-0.2706854343,
-0.3416161537,
1.2272760868,
1.2715249062,
0.2554805577,
-0.1104514822,
0.8634735942,
0.3987600803,
0.7567802668,
-0.3162822723,
1.1217212677,
-0.5856456757,
0.0062425896,
-0.5482367873,
-0.7224557996,
-0.3559800982,
-0.0593595654,
-0.5360019803,
-0.0610325672,
0.5582365394,
0.4149677753,
-0.1747575253,
-0.0513821132,
0.2784717977,
0.0375133194,
0.1229590103,
0.5746390224,
0.5249695182,
-0.3798632026,
0.8943782449,
-0.0500085987,
-0.1652341634,
-0.7380614281,
-0.5588096976,
-0.7732660174,
-0.6932499409,
-0.5127327442,
0.0258218106,
-0.0705518723,
0.4054948986,
0.761480391,
-0.9382321239,
-0.7740017176,
0.0938780531,
0.1433987916,
-0.4179184735,
-0.2074745744,
0.8081963658,
-0.0279267374,
-0.6516491771,
0.0038545229,
0.4336444438,
0.338940233,
-0.0532217771,
-0.3659878075,
0.1975486875,
-0.0276672747,
0.3740258217,
0.2331709415,
-0.0645792931,
-0.0533258803,
-0.294431597,
-0.3423250616,
0.3636370599,
0.719823122,
-0.4882667363,
0.6015717983,
0.4248047471,
0.2075044066,
0.7793188095,
0.1444170475,
0.6026114225,
-0.2854067683,
0.1888678074,
0.168545723,
0.4133813083,
0.5249278545,
0.0842697769,
0.7113665938,
0.0563070811,
-0.1898835748,
-1.023240447,
-0.0200369209,
-1.1284894943,
-0.2221280932,
0.6619579196,
0.1636656821,
-0.1275951415,
-0.2219452411,
-0.2753995955,
0.5061699152,
-0.236695677,
1.1168751717,
0.4607155025,
-0.1144066826,
0.0739372373,
-0.6584467292,
0.3079890013,
0.2448751032,
-1.2813725471,
0.4001978934,
0.7443150282,
0.0851574317,
-0.1519607157,
0.3943761289,
-0.102635622,
0.4636389315,
-0.0132157989,
-0.1722195894,
-0.1452186406,
-0.097984843,
0.0651735291,
0.2701156437,
0.0827407762,
-0.1434849352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13597v1 | Shades of meaning: Uncovering the geometry of ambiguous word representations through contextualised language models | 2023-04-26T14:47:38 | 2023-04-26T14:47:38 | Benedetta Cevoli, Chris Watkins, Yang Gao, Kathleen Rastle | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexical ambiguity presents a profound and enduring challenge to the language
sciences. Researchers for decades have grappled with the problem of how
language users learn, represent and process words with more than one meaning.
Our work offers new insight into psychological understanding of lexical
ambiguity through a series of simulations that capitalise on recent advances in
contextual language models. These models have no grounded understanding of the
meanings of words at all; they simply learn to predict words based on the
surrounding context provided by other words. Yet, our analyses show that their
representations capture fine-grained meaningful distinctions between
unambiguous, homonymous, and polysemous words that align with lexicographic
classifications and psychological theorising. These findings provide
quantitative support for modern psychological conceptualisations of lexical
ambiguity and raise new challenges for understanding of the way that contextual
information shapes the meanings of words across different timescales. | [
-0.4717538357,
-0.8058486581,
0.9565274119,
0.4190367162,
-0.2280409038,
0.0750098005,
-0.2707411647,
-0.6232658029,
0.1133027971,
0.182188049,
-0.8505597115,
-0.1236910522,
-0.9633498192,
0.0773229972,
-0.3852549493,
0.6154152155,
-0.1038190275,
0.1666222811,
-0.1692153215,
-0.4311186075,
-0.3929320872,
-0.2926804423,
-0.1519412398,
-0.3513704836,
0.7279997468,
-0.0340460613,
1.4449532032,
0.439872086,
0.4337831736,
0.2587297559,
-0.3645909131,
-0.1101719663,
-0.5142768621,
0.2447316796,
-0.3453103006,
-0.5914652944,
0.1301235557,
0.1357807368,
0.6082857847,
1.6006125212,
-0.0545147732,
0.0917033553,
0.0778666586,
0.7837764025,
-0.9743132591,
0.1668966711,
-0.7236619592,
0.2367451489,
-0.3436661065,
-0.115912497,
-0.2380984426,
0.0667951405,
0.2429270446,
-0.7961106896,
0.1468204409,
0.0765603334,
0.9276917577,
0.0695365071,
-0.5128037333,
-0.4580155313,
-0.687015295,
0.8506066203,
-0.3204184473,
0.5255336165,
0.2912748754,
0.3529584408,
-0.3214038014,
-0.5029543638,
-0.6457004547,
0.2210291475,
-0.0774252191,
0.0995178595,
-0.1671424657,
0.1123519912,
0.1696404964,
0.1533241868,
-0.1918090582,
-0.219198212,
-0.4005157948,
-0.1680226028,
0.511064887,
0.2675569355,
0.2487008274,
-0.3900769651,
-0.397641927,
0.0116120661,
-0.4338943064,
-0.024331037,
0.3192191422,
0.3612504601,
-0.0711506307,
0.534666419,
0.1041167006,
0.665441215,
-0.2673175633,
0.1201680228,
0.0612166151,
-0.038420666,
-0.1062146723,
0.1113868207,
0.5768662095,
0.1645890474,
0.1244489402,
-0.358933866,
0.0445069969,
0.2976248264,
0.1400876939,
-0.2626262903,
0.061097078,
0.0924972296,
-0.0997660011,
-0.1751066595,
0.1070773154,
-0.6858734488,
-0.59438169,
-0.3507374227,
0.2934393287,
-0.6014623642,
-0.542642355,
0.6735435128,
-0.4644854665,
0.163934499,
0.340580374,
-0.8265731335,
0.2679703236,
0.5650715828,
0.4852359891,
0.0951287895,
-0.4582924545,
0.4067909718,
0.2775368989,
-0.5592330098,
0.2394260615,
-0.7645689845,
-0.3475334942,
0.0039607226,
0.025408702,
-0.0229795761,
-0.0486116409,
0.0824204311,
-0.6242491007,
0.3183021247,
-0.6999629736,
-0.2945975959,
-0.3313288093,
0.1108616441,
-0.5879602432,
1.0222499371,
0.2772005796,
-0.7109403014,
0.3696568608,
-0.2089932859,
0.0833381638,
0.2724149227,
-0.5537700653,
0.2529919744,
0.7052193284,
-0.1789555252,
0.0929306298,
-0.3530896306,
0.2092958987,
-0.3643415868,
-0.1335062236,
0.3982066214,
-0.2594614327,
0.7746872306,
0.336702019,
-0.620336771,
-0.2860418856,
-0.4402732551,
0.0319026597,
0.2483836263,
0.2008775771,
-0.5341590643,
0.1030828059,
0.3476101756,
0.2821270823,
0.3142853677,
-0.6540512443,
-0.2390544266,
-0.3615133464,
0.3601432741,
0.5759746432,
-0.6432557702,
0.7534704208,
-0.0768755823,
0.6774399281,
0.1010022983,
0.0699911416,
0.2680718899,
-0.4550669789,
-0.4909875691,
-0.0131159211,
0.0353634097,
0.2605332434,
-0.6353646517,
0.2049903423,
-0.1221641675,
-0.2778717279,
-0.4021784067,
0.1028884649,
0.2374157608,
0.1465672702,
0.0053531369,
-0.2128120959,
-0.5239648819,
-0.8352053165,
-0.3333244324,
-0.2454655021,
0.2039855421,
0.5800535679,
0.519356668,
-0.3047240376,
1.3502091169,
-0.6851779222,
0.0125067681,
0.1262782514,
0.4547990859,
-0.2673248351,
0.0194374043,
0.7241860628,
-1.0523540974,
0.0382673852,
0.0690999627,
-0.8778415918,
-0.0524682663,
0.027520448,
-0.2613478601,
-0.2066205889,
0.6067091227,
-0.1707091033,
0.4680823088,
0.6756371856,
-0.4867998958,
0.6753023267,
-0.0560662597,
0.019067714,
-0.6682971716,
-0.1085868776,
-0.37156564,
-0.0641330779,
-0.4322166145,
0.2541788816,
0.0886871144,
-0.0773383826,
-0.4082976878,
0.7027997375,
-0.7381513119,
0.1225869879,
-0.2889267206,
0.5919802189,
0.1649781466,
0.065361172,
0.0113305785,
0.5138536096,
0.7228187919,
-0.2740050852,
0.2769761384,
-0.008314576,
-0.2946176827,
0.2843430638,
-0.2498515844,
-0.1943054199,
-0.6508059502,
-0.0535633862,
-1.4653129578,
-0.2945097983,
0.060598854,
-0.2335854024,
-0.1847028881,
0.1739602387,
-0.4567718804,
-0.2210796773,
0.0599100739,
1.2858417034,
0.1852082014,
-0.2102420926,
0.5945984721,
0.5459909439,
0.060209915,
-0.5507366061,
-0.8313888907,
0.0881393105,
-0.2705578506,
-0.5819921494,
0.3941545486,
0.3462073803,
-0.646694541,
0.1692477465,
-0.098130554,
-0.2101726532,
0.1653864235,
0.4418013096,
0.1125287563,
-0.1563760787,
0.2907226384,
-0.1359269321,
0.2391648591,
0.3829735518,
-0.3283857107,
0.4505662024,
-0.3463152647,
-0.4560782909,
0.3386095166,
0.5231288075,
0.6002815962,
0.0877498761,
0.8060988784,
0.6584682465,
-0.6912454367,
-0.0322095789,
-0.4311617017,
0.106397137,
-0.4680785239,
0.2380198836,
-0.5568381548,
-0.902559936,
1.0261415243,
0.0019705987,
-0.4192269146,
0.2987728715,
0.1790293008,
-0.1011249796,
1.1500514746,
0.860937953,
0.3364557028,
0.5116568804,
-0.0070652305,
0.3268539011,
-0.7208381891,
-0.4044390321,
-0.2667262256,
-0.151600495,
-0.6133342981,
-0.5248770118,
0.4053031206,
0.2891407907,
-0.0810605213,
0.0869020522,
-0.4392130673,
0.6067697406,
-0.0694313124,
0.1707277596,
-0.0957707316,
0.0644857362,
-0.1816055626,
-0.3448649347,
-0.5255500674,
-0.4222974479,
0.7027258277,
0.263217181,
0.8027253151,
0.44082582,
0.2454872131,
0.09382952,
-0.2098225057,
-0.7490717769,
0.3736688495,
0.1572130919,
-0.8643525243,
-0.1503576934,
-0.2652504146,
-1.2371044159,
0.4697241485,
-0.290820837,
-1.0262234211,
0.5174837112,
-0.253885746,
-0.3438324034,
0.3533239961,
-0.4944573343,
0.6726590395,
-0.2818374634,
-0.584008038,
-0.2543797195,
-0.6715367436,
0.4072802663,
0.1281516552,
0.6091476083,
-0.3172816038,
-0.1445367485,
0.6270642281,
-0.2265555561,
0.6688374281,
0.1166077256,
-0.3710419536,
0.2101367563,
0.4323399961,
-0.2378681302,
-0.1544772387,
-0.1835876107,
0.2317665219,
0.6251545548,
-0.9618057609,
-0.700955987,
0.3378283679,
-0.693970561,
-0.5587661862,
-0.61101228,
-0.9581796527,
-0.2858324647,
0.2623623013,
0.3587190509,
0.5960949063,
-0.2724018395,
-0.2484913468,
0.4867262244,
-0.2342736721,
0.1069332734,
0.0287604146,
-0.5286886096,
0.017771557,
0.4665382802,
-0.0676235035,
0.4447106123,
0.0711094886,
0.1548206657,
-0.392398566,
-0.1787391454,
-0.1181029156,
0.304143846,
-0.8568872809,
0.277297318,
-0.2699969411,
-0.1446091235,
-0.4667167962,
-0.5015990138,
-0.1442536563,
-0.2100353092,
-0.1571937948,
0.1775774062,
0.4876865447,
1.2605842352,
0.0761365741,
0.7113138437,
-0.2829512656,
0.0787863955,
-0.1178539768,
0.413438201,
-0.018888576,
-0.3110001087,
-0.1125792116,
0.1816841215,
-0.0201198552,
-1.5553915501,
0.2636701465,
-0.0315753147,
0.4195389748,
0.6457332373,
-0.2244754434,
0.8533971906,
-0.4995674789,
0.8109124899,
0.332461834,
-1.0726013184,
0.3130346537,
-0.5248611569,
0.4206095338,
0.666511178,
0.4006253481,
-0.8031918406,
-0.3784104288,
-0.6248283982,
-1.0333137512,
0.6006070375,
0.0541917197,
0.2405581027,
-0.166406557,
0.6536449194,
0.1594834328,
0.1990505457,
-0.680809021,
-0.3866276443,
0.007268711,
-0.2946766913,
-0.1254773289,
-0.4700623453,
-0.2627308071,
-0.4182332754,
0.1250604093,
-0.0855976343,
0.2514281273,
0.1300138533,
-0.3120209575,
-0.102999039,
0.3064178228,
0.3166412115,
0.8235602975,
-0.16739133,
0.6554276943,
0.1692422479,
-0.4526718855,
-0.0229296684,
-0.0506676398,
0.1980955452,
0.1520189047,
0.2872270942,
0.7156166434,
0.5210169554,
-0.6418981552,
0.4652125537,
0.0360082015,
-0.1307641715,
-0.2887092531,
-0.3582750857,
0.0276416354,
-0.0288765877,
0.269964397,
0.0471373536,
0.3615718186,
-0.8550035954,
0.0285942797,
0.6131165624,
-0.684463203,
-0.1970416158,
0.4581252038,
-0.2461583763,
0.0762071982,
0.3600729406,
-0.472145319,
-0.7379328609,
0.5187308788,
0.5098673105,
0.6275240183,
0.1399401277,
0.2825660408,
0.0926944837,
0.1866221428,
0.1529597044,
0.3695755005,
-0.168166995,
-1.0436854362,
0.0266341083,
-0.8021255136,
-0.3003849089,
-0.1860372275,
-0.9100958109,
0.0525064841,
-0.3084176779,
-0.2140435874,
0.256042093,
-0.3553668559,
-0.5138547421,
0.031144388,
0.5641306639,
0.7074181437,
-1.2123476267,
0.37025702,
0.7604691982,
-0.2021501511,
-0.8882238269,
-0.196435526,
0.3918919265,
-0.6956574917,
0.645249486,
0.2385526747,
-0.6657397747,
-0.2035290748,
-0.3852854371,
-0.9734380841,
0.6184864044,
0.5871651769,
-0.1938543171,
-0.2609550059,
0.6330074072,
0.5603958368,
-0.277002871,
0.5011094809,
0.6967694163,
0.5613343716,
0.1716860831,
-0.7921062708,
0.0978533477,
-0.183553651,
0.1633579135,
0.3014219403,
-0.0265419278,
1.0422415733,
0.0052181566,
-0.7261955142,
-0.0160720646,
0.5227882266,
-0.0747529492,
0.0866332799,
0.4802633226,
0.2861142755,
0.6707786322,
-0.4203886688,
1.0418469906,
-0.2116618007,
0.4519135058,
0.7205140591,
0.0264495108,
0.4309470952,
0.754349649,
-0.3152250648,
0.6678621769,
0.7293779254,
0.4577135146,
0.3190188408,
0.3081145585,
-0.5615738034,
-0.3678364456,
-0.2759648263,
-0.2677932978,
0.6426404715,
0.7493838072,
-0.2180033177,
-0.7449174523,
0.2764008045,
-0.1289802343,
0.5594001412,
-0.1852774471,
0.4847021103,
0.1337269396,
-0.5497436523,
0.6145112514,
-0.0299795475,
0.574218154,
-0.6872159839,
0.2005399168,
0.3103354871,
0.3037636578,
-0.3371793926,
-1.1337326765,
0.3446949422,
-0.528352499,
-0.1322404146,
-0.3840284348,
0.4289450645,
-0.6053782701,
-0.5886176229,
0.8272730708,
0.5189067125,
0.2921536267,
-0.03015453,
-0.8451911807,
0.0764205977,
-0.2070069313,
0.3011187613,
-0.0252900589,
0.8476148844,
-0.0517676696,
0.4619505107,
0.1213448793,
0.305252552,
0.490504384,
0.0294403341,
0.5091319084,
-0.7781578898,
-0.4522637427,
-0.894595325,
0.1447535604,
0.3011434674,
-0.5650840998,
0.7359814048,
0.1889959872,
0.8121108413,
0.1974839866,
0.3266340494,
-0.2650707364,
-0.2465317249,
-0.262295723,
0.5642745495,
-0.9509737492,
0.0957394242,
-0.4143356383,
-0.3614372015,
-0.454813391,
0.7599444985,
-0.8253475428,
-0.0029670224,
0.661162734,
0.6470955014,
-0.179594323,
0.4057208598,
0.202529341,
0.0767536685,
-0.1041080356,
0.4874368906,
1.1194936037,
-0.3776741326,
0.0588199794,
-0.2092164606,
-0.2606636584,
-0.0198440123,
-0.6737598181,
-0.4536434114,
-0.9658392668,
0.0911000296,
-0.4312954843,
0.0626568571,
0.7385089993,
0.6232713461,
-0.4674933851,
-0.4964296222,
-0.3199806511,
0.2024975419,
-0.2564291656,
-0.3130467236,
0.1482106,
-0.592230022,
-0.6592999697,
-0.1501673758,
0.2474893183,
-0.0865502506,
-0.4218673706,
0.0256163199,
-0.2177397311,
0.2154195011,
0.6170076132,
0.0540589616,
-0.993702054,
-0.3515229225,
-0.082744129,
-0.2573226392,
-0.0233090259,
0.6488617063,
-0.607937634,
0.5509419441,
0.5011641979,
0.5110349655,
0.326064527,
-0.2979370058,
0.6075834036,
-0.5737584829,
0.5510463119,
0.1589282006,
0.5219153166,
0.3437618613,
-0.4089714885,
0.24613069,
0.1510539502,
0.1000492945,
-0.8742209673,
0.8536388278,
-1.0653061867,
-0.6506488323,
1.075479269,
0.1516774744,
-0.5650646091,
-0.0698509663,
-0.0602316856,
0.175635457,
0.0869519487,
0.7321235538,
1.0648481846,
-0.1420944184,
-0.0372262709,
-0.4769064188,
0.5328871012,
1.0437560081,
-0.2622200251,
0.2212250531,
0.5466633439,
0.2763158977,
0.4584807456,
0.2798847854,
-0.4624071419,
0.192354247,
0.0093037654,
-0.0526447445,
0.3866448998,
-0.2238164842,
-0.3985499144,
0.2539710104,
0.0968966782,
-0.0019489975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13568v1 | Toxic comments reduce the activity of volunteer editors on Wikipedia | 2023-04-26T13:59:25 | 2023-04-26T13:59:25 | Ivan Smirnov, Camelia Oprea, Markus Strohmaier | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Wikipedia is one of the most successful collaborative projects in history. It
is the largest encyclopedia ever created, with millions of users worldwide
relying on it as the first source of information as well as for fact-checking
and in-depth research. As Wikipedia relies solely on the efforts of its
volunteer-editors, its success might be particularly affected by toxic speech.
In this paper, we analyze all 57 million comments made on user talk pages of
8.5 million editors across the six most active language editions of Wikipedia
to study the potential impact of toxicity on editors' behaviour. We find that
toxic comments consistently reduce the activity of editors, leading to an
estimated loss of 0.5-2 active days per user in the short term. This amounts to
multiple human-years of lost productivity when considering the number of active
contributors to Wikipedia. The effects of toxic comments are even greater in
the long term, as they significantly increase the risk of editors leaving the
project altogether. Using an agent-based model, we demonstrate that toxicity
attacks on Wikipedia have the potential to impede the progress of the entire
project. Our results underscore the importance of mitigating toxic speech on
collaborative platforms such as Wikipedia to ensure their continued success. | [
-0.3778125346,
-0.5096357465,
0.6228964329,
0.0640522838,
-0.3843957782,
-0.0977556854,
-0.3197784126,
-0.4273046255,
0.2662963867,
0.6643550992,
-0.424200058,
-0.2124084681,
-0.4123971462,
0.3648151457,
-0.5899072289,
1.3246763945,
0.3069010079,
-0.0479821227,
-0.346645236,
-0.1457763314,
-0.0296065379,
-0.2288441062,
-0.8678144217,
0.0246200785,
1.2060167789,
0.4625057578,
0.7154226303,
0.4090338051,
0.130161643,
0.3825280368,
-0.4566981792,
0.0256729145,
-0.9493243098,
0.3984893262,
-0.614700973,
-0.3748806119,
-0.2295498103,
-0.0874286592,
0.2190215737,
0.3182218671,
0.0058134212,
0.1970449239,
-0.0171730109,
0.4932558537,
-0.6481250525,
0.2197203487,
-0.1243496314,
-0.0938648209,
-0.3199524581,
-0.0822617486,
-0.6095325947,
-0.1400693804,
-0.0963484496,
-0.7700673938,
0.0097393878,
-0.7221102118,
0.2295795232,
0.1644883454,
-0.4626515508,
-0.0802349597,
-0.789691627,
0.5595827103,
-0.6926350594,
0.1537819803,
0.1266582012,
-0.2966618538,
-0.5166876912,
-0.4032705128,
-0.9741091728,
-0.453869909,
0.1270727962,
0.214519769,
-0.0562384501,
0.034430854,
0.2942564487,
-0.2450541705,
-0.1081162989,
0.129061684,
-0.4887529612,
-0.1181844622,
0.6902288795,
0.0672776252,
0.5763189197,
-0.4571011662,
-0.0606917441,
-0.024473466,
-0.5429692268,
-0.1277487725,
0.4110703468,
-0.1838606894,
0.3391009569,
0.535245955,
-0.1684051752,
0.1716093719,
-0.2360551208,
0.0725392997,
-0.00566313,
-0.3712328076,
0.3924803734,
-0.304728955,
0.9141113758,
0.86804533,
0.5049648881,
-0.5230517983,
0.2430524677,
0.2196586281,
0.3730871379,
-0.8251006603,
-0.3650524616,
-0.0558199249,
-0.3337732852,
-0.712708056,
-0.0039646653,
-0.797031045,
-1.0724717379,
0.1923775524,
0.1323362142,
0.1190922186,
-0.5047535896,
-0.6142309308,
-0.4780631065,
-0.5211774111,
0.5840477347,
-0.3164997697,
0.2454889864,
0.4735108316,
0.7011854649,
-0.154144451,
-0.3604150712,
-0.7556560636,
0.4888106287,
-0.3524082601,
0.6427617073,
-0.3184760511,
-0.6125907302,
-0.1033726856,
-0.0632650778,
0.42707026,
-0.4399403334,
0.7265034914,
-0.6157051325,
0.1028596684,
-0.5796351433,
-0.2792972624,
-0.1075794399,
-0.0996226743,
-0.6630800962,
0.5478050113,
-0.1278574467,
-0.8904020786,
0.2211491764,
-0.6071839333,
-0.3073641956,
0.0355903171,
0.0968589559,
-0.0335919149,
0.2209101319,
-0.2770793736,
0.0363427252,
-0.1989260912,
-0.2954666913,
-0.5149096847,
-0.1807358861,
0.5363993049,
-0.1030729115,
0.8371706605,
0.095088616,
-0.5044468045,
0.0891382992,
-0.4527687728,
-0.1487933546,
-0.2984764874,
-0.5934247375,
-0.4665104747,
0.4202573895,
0.2264908701,
0.6760960221,
0.0296600834,
-0.7179679275,
-0.0907021761,
-0.5051322579,
0.1757667959,
1.0852525234,
0.5151794553,
0.1986137033,
-0.2941815853,
0.3019122183,
0.1694621593,
0.4762001634,
0.2599138916,
-0.583830297,
-0.9332678318,
0.1811975241,
-0.0863669738,
0.2728954852,
-0.6441656351,
0.0105954837,
-0.3067873716,
-0.7932118773,
-0.1453604698,
0.3967873454,
0.1779802144,
0.5800510645,
0.1939979941,
-0.5467922688,
-0.1252965331,
-0.6547805071,
-0.359412998,
-0.6846263409,
-0.1716092229,
0.275305897,
0.410518378,
-0.3732098639,
0.9047913551,
-0.2281590402,
-0.2996307611,
0.3670103252,
-0.0155849624,
-0.1583331823,
0.1273081303,
0.3641239405,
-0.8675897717,
-1.0096287727,
-0.108211644,
-0.49137941,
-0.392883122,
-0.1004792824,
-0.3829140067,
0.1892704666,
0.361628741,
-0.9533137083,
0.2037334144,
0.2904759943,
-0.3790670931,
0.4022141993,
-0.126883477,
0.1893386841,
-0.7218869328,
0.1981386989,
-0.1585498005,
-0.0892100334,
-0.5256490707,
0.0597947128,
-0.0539775863,
-0.1674687415,
-0.3830324709,
0.3086849749,
-0.1547071487,
0.5875060558,
-0.3426328599,
0.3817607164,
-0.120978348,
0.446495682,
-0.1067798585,
0.574423492,
0.28780514,
-0.397274971,
0.4563110471,
0.347240746,
0.0404579602,
0.4083167911,
-0.3191288412,
0.3661007881,
-0.1143945754,
0.4541746974,
-0.8323948383,
-0.1046262234,
0.3571551144,
-0.4924865663,
0.0337571427,
0.2666176558,
-0.4969316423,
-0.247142598,
-0.8017526865,
-0.4726106226,
0.0208452418,
0.0035294401,
0.3021252155,
0.8188712597,
-0.5158379078,
-0.5181482434,
-0.4901942313,
0.6231677532,
0.0154935708,
-0.7428128123,
0.1121087,
-0.4963561893,
-0.3591656685,
0.3319251537,
-0.2818142176,
-0.2902307808,
0.0154998982,
0.4492923617,
-0.1305086613,
0.2611755431,
0.2576362193,
-0.2461699247,
-0.0636439696,
0.64351964,
0.372402668,
0.2717656791,
0.1575092673,
0.0607881993,
-0.425643146,
0.5755152106,
1.2548617125,
-0.1067064703,
1.2058050632,
0.2477901429,
0.0866527036,
-0.2588717043,
-0.4760536849,
0.0067140083,
-0.5036786199,
0.6858619452,
0.5074532032,
-0.4033893645,
0.5845236182,
0.0597868003,
0.0964818299,
0.7974259257,
0.6220317483,
-0.3249056637,
0.9503266215,
0.4168581367,
-0.3241811395,
0.7209005952,
-0.1076749936,
-0.0529586934,
-0.4438651204,
-0.2630086243,
-0.4814350903,
-0.082110554,
-0.6759104133,
-0.3194389939,
0.5307658315,
-0.4150401354,
-0.1169454902,
0.0379120559,
-0.5602958798,
0.4399734139,
0.3335607648,
0.3046586514,
0.1928681284,
-0.2027469426,
0.1269041449,
0.0912903175,
-0.5071263909,
-0.4011250734,
0.9566002488,
0.100424163,
0.4286634028,
0.3337239027,
0.7309500575,
0.7146784663,
0.6275955439,
-0.3873943985,
0.7440416813,
-0.0526471771,
-0.8070670366,
-0.562153399,
-0.4902901053,
-0.5220255256,
-0.0188374892,
-0.155995056,
-0.2814164162,
0.1498550177,
0.0341275074,
0.0103862667,
0.2072121054,
-0.8057678342,
0.7706273794,
0.1234478727,
-0.6060362458,
-0.870816648,
-0.5773419142,
-0.0422654785,
-0.3394409716,
0.6704391241,
-0.008797436,
-0.2156016082,
1.0679694414,
-0.7659212947,
0.9644295573,
-0.37635535,
-0.1298120767,
0.3611587882,
-0.0259088203,
0.6422445774,
-0.0088012153,
-0.2221263796,
0.0227720439,
-0.1823174208,
-0.0132051939,
-0.1483822167,
1.0410890579,
-1.0366977453,
-0.6743813157,
-0.1492235363,
-0.1892013252,
-0.198684901,
0.3061244786,
0.409384191,
-0.0670523718,
-0.2285427302,
0.1066214442,
0.4801565111,
-0.1407402158,
0.3429293931,
0.5990731716,
0.1957861781,
-0.6831818223,
0.8721929789,
0.5140227675,
0.2342094034,
-0.0902835056,
0.1645902395,
-0.0729146972,
-0.3151385784,
-0.2198668718,
0.4729848504,
-1.0080299377,
-0.2155319154,
-0.587579608,
0.123094894,
-0.2783301771,
0.0905610919,
-0.1799889803,
-0.4759485424,
-0.4746854901,
-0.0389247723,
0.2628984153,
0.8646560907,
-0.0347673222,
0.0333294943,
-0.6819648147,
0.2862815559,
0.6607159972,
0.5821796656,
0.1351327896,
-0.1593893319,
-0.4903051555,
0.158356607,
-0.3838361502,
-1.5382716656,
0.0106275519,
0.3853236139,
0.5136211514,
0.4317390919,
0.4354667068,
0.3765758872,
-0.4263058305,
0.8031555414,
0.2158128619,
-0.6452538371,
0.249011308,
-0.4641773999,
0.0905999765,
0.529366374,
0.1019360721,
-0.9619281888,
-1.1165491343,
-0.4809487164,
-0.766789794,
0.6750487089,
0.4039242566,
0.3704865575,
-0.3075619042,
0.0877243131,
-0.1306483299,
0.1944282949,
-0.7707112432,
-0.4746069312,
-0.0892192423,
0.2834903598,
0.0468715429,
-0.7204954028,
-0.2702261806,
-0.2853399217,
0.9190438986,
0.3679579496,
-0.188200444,
-0.0351861529,
-0.1451225579,
-0.7605583668,
0.3646506667,
0.3540499806,
0.6799284816,
0.0350628793,
0.0361059457,
0.1623945087,
-0.5352030396,
0.0249925647,
-0.1389783919,
-0.3477682769,
0.2798517644,
0.3098776042,
0.3049870729,
0.3147069514,
-0.7215358615,
0.5445610285,
-0.0183625761,
0.338747412,
-0.3151979446,
0.5195259452,
0.4490427077,
0.1856557578,
0.3403542936,
0.463024199,
0.1699757874,
-0.563424468,
0.138325572,
0.1888031214,
-0.2236850709,
-0.2785414755,
0.8555868864,
0.7431913614,
-0.1964244395,
0.3335832357,
0.151883617,
-0.6166490316,
0.5130645037,
0.0024385115,
0.7172526121,
-0.2856994271,
0.3956842721,
0.3194631338,
0.281196028,
0.2376759946,
-0.2160561681,
-0.2558938563,
-0.1912311763,
-0.4275892079,
-0.4700306356,
-0.5595676899,
0.0293175131,
-0.260010004,
0.1705207378,
-0.2745989263,
-0.4085772932,
0.3629933,
0.1346887648,
-0.2411620766,
-0.0557808802,
0.2808330357,
0.863191247,
-0.872305572,
0.5078699589,
0.6376396418,
-0.6461803913,
-0.2577713728,
0.0844040364,
-0.1495310515,
0.13895455,
0.564866364,
0.1054479107,
-0.1735438257,
-0.0890283436,
-0.5484323502,
-0.58669734,
0.3355145454,
0.6599368453,
-0.1820575297,
0.0214099679,
0.1806582212,
1.0121359825,
0.4735194445,
0.003655243,
-0.0007168461,
0.4909327328,
-0.2772586346,
-1.1412767172,
-0.0612870716,
-0.5376343131,
-0.2223234326,
0.2181866765,
-0.789588213,
0.6282999516,
0.0327657089,
-0.198729977,
-0.0915107876,
0.453068018,
-0.2921863198,
0.0214313213,
0.8835378885,
0.1043121219,
0.5578588843,
0.4879069626,
0.7806274891,
-0.2221358567,
0.3661574125,
0.7272971869,
0.0797362104,
0.8083457947,
0.6063879728,
-0.0348399207,
0.7996844649,
-0.0365843363,
0.0863941982,
0.5325562954,
0.1664136052,
-0.8644399643,
-0.3503785729,
-0.427115798,
-0.2474122494,
0.2038695663,
0.2597592771,
-0.4456657171,
-0.2586063743,
0.1644462347,
0.3794417977,
0.1182148829,
-0.3269341886,
0.7696821094,
-0.1397489905,
-0.945135355,
0.2009561807,
-0.1172072738,
0.3222988546,
-0.4337014556,
-0.1165168881,
-0.0779686272,
0.1394800097,
-0.312685132,
-0.7176653147,
0.2498030066,
0.3175080419,
-0.3882704675,
-0.2332789451,
0.6222044826,
-0.3775706589,
-0.0300032552,
0.3408299983,
0.1289531589,
0.0521593802,
-0.3593132198,
-0.3936851621,
-0.0223931894,
-0.0631903931,
-0.5398883224,
0.2419278026,
0.4742412567,
-0.0100844074,
0.4449386299,
0.7246235013,
0.3065194488,
-0.0555352531,
-0.367805928,
1.5253144503,
-0.2406748384,
-0.6045140624,
-0.8129090667,
0.4374819398,
-0.5252462029,
-0.0606746338,
0.9293110967,
0.5003778934,
0.6722878218,
-0.2076537758,
0.7328747511,
-0.2390563637,
0.4753808677,
0.2370689809,
1.3983398676,
-0.4282666743,
0.0479232855,
-0.5783654451,
-0.6473060846,
-0.0900843441,
0.4052290618,
0.0252696741,
-0.2132801414,
0.3308009803,
0.6980403066,
0.3047548234,
-0.2701975405,
0.1810120791,
0.7786348462,
0.5712650418,
0.0767344609,
0.7468090653,
0.1214690208,
1.0540628433,
-0.5414943099,
-0.2171022892,
-0.2860862017,
-0.6635786295,
-0.7991943359,
-0.4610607028,
-0.3344194591,
-0.4027746618,
0.0835936964,
0.367739886,
0.2235361785,
-0.6914998293,
-0.0509105176,
0.0363205858,
0.1995179504,
0.0152023723,
-0.2005168498,
0.2972072363,
0.1679645032,
-0.5710971951,
0.1267862618,
0.2148256749,
-0.7086418867,
-0.2859420776,
-0.3044835031,
-0.1012323424,
0.1256888062,
0.517283082,
0.4606110752,
-0.5300552845,
-0.4961391091,
-0.0132084042,
-0.2903324962,
-0.3527672887,
0.3678615093,
-0.685393095,
1.0557496548,
0.6128341556,
-0.0229823664,
0.4200445414,
-0.2105795592,
0.3454450369,
-0.5469203591,
0.0497840159,
0.3608781397,
0.0466479845,
0.171602577,
-0.5210226774,
0.3373109102,
0.4511689246,
-0.7047429085,
-0.8754795194,
-0.245256573,
-0.7336190939,
-0.1457574219,
1.0551841259,
-0.068771787,
0.0049885917,
-0.101774089,
-0.4415495694,
0.6673380733,
-0.5441427231,
1.2165014744,
1.0075463057,
-0.1318246275,
0.0185627379,
-0.695515275,
0.5715541244,
0.1878792942,
-0.7903019786,
0.3629024625,
1.0119028091,
0.4911677241,
0.3837901652,
0.7897049785,
0.2892089188,
0.7830525637,
-0.133655861,
-0.1245637611,
-0.1468496621,
-0.2969892919,
0.314178586,
0.3692007959,
0.1159508303,
0.0707116425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13567v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13567v4 | Technical Report: Impact of Position Bias on Language Models in Token Classification | 2023-04-26T13:57:25 | 2024-04-11T08:10:11 | Mehdi Ben Amor, Michael Granitzer, Jelena Mitrović | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language Models (LMs) have shown state-of-the-art performance in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Downstream tasks such as Named Entity
Recognition (NER) or Part-of-Speech (POS) tagging are known to suffer from data
imbalance issues, particularly regarding the ratio of positive to negative
examples and class disparities. This paper investigates an often-overlooked
issue of encoder models, specifically the position bias of positive examples in
token classification tasks. For completeness, we also include decoders in the
evaluation. We evaluate the impact of position bias using different position
embedding techniques, focusing on BERT with Absolute Position Embedding (APE),
Relative Position Embedding (RPE), and Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE).
Therefore, we conduct an in-depth evaluation of the impact of position bias on
the performance of LMs when fine-tuned on token classification benchmarks. Our
study includes CoNLL03 and OntoNote5.0 for NER, English Tree Bank UD\_en, and
TweeBank for POS tagging. We propose an evaluation approach to investigate
position bias in transformer models. We show that LMs can suffer from this bias
with an average drop ranging from 3\% to 9\% in their performance. To mitigate
this effect, we propose two methods: Random Position Shifting and Context
Perturbation, that we apply on batches during the training process. The results
show an improvement of $\approx$ 2\% in the performance of the model on
CoNLL03, UD\_en, and TweeBank. | [
-0.4027816653,
-0.5170710683,
0.1233278736,
0.0398218036,
-0.2561952472,
-0.0390314981,
-0.1045164466,
-0.6833477616,
0.198828429,
0.3817098439,
0.0752838701,
-0.5613843203,
-0.8279693723,
-0.0584488474,
-0.4667626619,
0.8580223918,
-0.009317995,
0.2437284589,
-0.0022557967,
-0.1865988523,
-0.9475775957,
-1.0980528593,
-0.5582138896,
-0.3295450807,
0.2348149568,
0.1321546435,
0.6504166126,
0.5160810947,
0.3999382257,
0.2020802498,
-0.3747476637,
-0.3156787455,
0.0726251975,
0.1445630044,
-0.3402766287,
-0.7055794597,
-0.3529582322,
0.0804219618,
0.7933528423,
0.5546305776,
-0.1007343382,
0.0321440063,
-0.0264773294,
0.1232837364,
-0.6181361079,
-0.0620673411,
-0.7815133333,
0.2565171421,
-0.4404821694,
-0.0397838689,
-0.6590815783,
0.042831704,
0.3410441875,
-0.0765663758,
0.5952063203,
0.2466615885,
1.0933673382,
0.3792532384,
-0.3865900636,
-0.2146519721,
-0.5648536086,
0.8870360255,
-0.8725606799,
0.6197934747,
0.2878105044,
-0.019865673,
0.048665449,
-0.2946874499,
-0.5173454285,
0.0786844045,
-0.240137279,
-0.2000532746,
0.0148569709,
0.1630721986,
0.5359447598,
0.1319888234,
0.0864924043,
0.3985978365,
-0.0877995938,
-0.2518001497,
0.2418826222,
-0.1731864363,
0.1387066096,
-0.3775990605,
-0.266335398,
-0.2572484016,
-0.6258442402,
0.1490529776,
0.5399776697,
0.5011459589,
0.0514550582,
0.6583300829,
0.3755337,
0.7281677127,
0.3743733466,
-0.0059310328,
0.4224399328,
-0.1947295517,
-0.2443800718,
0.477052182,
0.3595104516,
0.149887383,
-0.0455831215,
-0.1255554408,
-0.418531239,
-0.0688649043,
0.4676207304,
-0.5946602821,
0.1493024826,
0.0716794357,
-0.451080054,
-0.2108821273,
0.3697866499,
-0.5809352994,
-0.5425256491,
-0.2817959785,
0.3094145954,
-0.2809557617,
-0.2059276104,
0.109951891,
-0.3230484426,
0.6051162481,
-0.0165334642,
-0.9913498163,
0.2135977,
0.8900129795,
0.7348245382,
-0.2225531936,
-0.1088830978,
-0.3608465195,
0.1413443834,
0.0271910075,
0.5515408516,
-0.64152807,
-0.3176319599,
0.1421429068,
0.0113680325,
-0.3081914485,
-0.5888451338,
0.8019510508,
-0.4257680476,
0.3494696617,
-0.2988286018,
-0.641735673,
0.0620576702,
0.1860426366,
-0.6537984014,
0.9310327172,
-0.0871101469,
-1.2024335861,
0.7448887229,
-0.5487971306,
-0.5922503471,
-0.3081663251,
-0.27730003,
-0.5339183807,
0.1486159265,
0.3260083795,
0.4354571402,
-0.0330749303,
0.301548034,
-0.0218198299,
-0.6232771277,
0.3683986068,
-0.5616787076,
0.5291013122,
-0.0944291577,
-0.6662330627,
0.1096511409,
-0.4472353756,
-0.3253838122,
-0.0794206485,
-0.2391075939,
-0.6515756845,
0.1837492585,
-0.005895616,
0.3286801875,
-0.0020535442,
-0.7241099477,
0.3151730895,
-0.5705256462,
0.435546875,
0.7693046927,
-0.1304484606,
0.783215344,
0.0412369706,
0.4745424092,
0.2252431363,
0.2001904249,
-0.0218655206,
-0.4991723299,
-0.8631435633,
-0.1156508327,
0.7749294639,
0.4376259148,
-0.5051199794,
0.5470307469,
-0.2510227859,
-0.1468705535,
-0.7874248624,
-0.3115255833,
0.3251693249,
0.5107288361,
0.4200980961,
-0.3486196399,
-0.5637019277,
-1.0081670284,
-0.2590807974,
-0.0683026016,
-0.0721638948,
-0.0116878124,
0.1730310917,
-0.1722618937,
1.0752129555,
-0.2217578292,
-0.3601177037,
-0.1836913228,
0.127206862,
0.3158996999,
0.6322063804,
0.4749003947,
-0.6863701344,
-0.1692689806,
-0.3670870066,
-0.3379777372,
-0.1231750026,
0.0067514433,
-0.0827382132,
0.6144176722,
0.4921065867,
-0.9020978808,
0.6258252859,
0.3439054787,
-0.4268679321,
0.1718889028,
-0.0027487772,
-0.126809001,
-0.8925632834,
-0.0348349214,
0.2060302347,
-0.1483852565,
-0.6288925409,
-0.107092768,
0.1271405369,
0.132922411,
-0.4341897964,
0.5070944428,
-0.3621508479,
-0.2213294506,
-0.207099691,
0.0278409794,
-0.0424846709,
0.4240453541,
0.1328447163,
0.5466874242,
0.3625352383,
-0.4713650644,
-0.3358225524,
0.127178818,
-0.4233312905,
0.401325196,
-0.5827928185,
0.2533005178,
-0.1516928524,
0.3060112596,
-0.8697929978,
0.2205715925,
0.4350728989,
-0.325760752,
0.9759004712,
-0.3523419499,
-0.4487213492,
-0.348777324,
-0.2357432842,
0.410143882,
0.3491053581,
-0.5376297832,
0.425417006,
0.5209192634,
0.2177947313,
-1.1265839338,
-0.6675417423,
-0.0995331928,
-0.4383425415,
-0.179001987,
0.7597339153,
0.5396622419,
-0.1556214541,
0.0423614047,
-0.4780794084,
0.3534976542,
0.1157807037,
0.25722754,
0.0877556428,
0.0616780296,
0.2945913076,
-0.163567096,
-0.1678107679,
0.0297630802,
-0.4717483222,
0.8330102563,
0.0024501556,
-0.6161840558,
-0.3654873967,
-0.081319496,
0.4144594073,
-0.215805158,
1.0096668005,
0.6166577339,
-0.4660792649,
-0.1316037625,
-0.6285083294,
-0.1128742322,
-0.4442295134,
0.3867899776,
-0.1629300863,
-0.6946064234,
0.4667154253,
0.3344641328,
0.0968992263,
0.415780127,
0.2908190191,
-0.0126772067,
1.1217569113,
0.6593781114,
-0.4847521484,
0.9484652281,
-0.2168674171,
0.5454069376,
-0.8300409913,
-0.2599608898,
-0.6817840338,
-0.5848689675,
-0.7084307075,
-0.5431239605,
-0.0088787433,
0.230613485,
-0.2556566596,
0.4276075959,
-0.6788249612,
0.3057262599,
0.5591199994,
-0.1652986407,
-0.0877042189,
-0.0127719035,
-0.3184115291,
-0.2001722753,
-0.7840970159,
-0.5120757222,
0.878796041,
0.714549005,
0.6252364516,
-0.1223016828,
0.5735695958,
0.3522660136,
0.3914209902,
-0.8875257373,
0.2471176088,
-0.0910073444,
-0.6160275936,
-0.3748891354,
0.0100692622,
-0.7682830691,
0.3490384221,
-0.0363782607,
-0.6650714278,
0.3836126626,
0.0801995546,
-0.0312954299,
0.5519430041,
-0.7265025973,
0.729621768,
-0.2864872217,
-0.1984882951,
0.0659784451,
-0.6769951582,
-0.1048181579,
0.0972883254,
0.1989663541,
-0.0497309379,
0.1468659937,
0.8344420791,
-0.4445730448,
0.839561522,
-0.8532226682,
-0.2887440622,
0.2739912868,
-0.1936521679,
0.6004101634,
-0.2467736453,
-0.3512696028,
0.5455741882,
-0.1802958548,
-0.4153101146,
-0.4314824045,
0.5288901925,
-0.7477155328,
-0.6355320215,
-0.5018389821,
-0.2288274914,
-0.2344113588,
-0.0558129773,
0.40095824,
0.3375011683,
0.1820822954,
0.1046343148,
0.5342887044,
-0.4871804416,
0.5830703974,
0.1601627916,
-0.1118815318,
-0.2484856099,
0.6859340668,
0.2596153021,
0.0753257275,
0.596331656,
-0.0510531291,
-0.478092134,
-0.5879901648,
-0.2446847558,
0.2059200406,
-0.8290416598,
-0.3165464997,
-0.5259384513,
-0.276099354,
-0.3658860922,
-0.1413137913,
-0.3594630361,
-0.5955933928,
-0.1609101146,
-0.4126133919,
0.0172978137,
0.5733971,
0.390991807,
0.6355109811,
-0.4020742476,
-0.2259244472,
-0.1329996437,
0.5856749415,
0.1986605376,
-0.6226959229,
-0.3704412878,
-0.0201772526,
-0.262609005,
-0.6808154583,
0.3389500678,
-0.1616539359,
0.8100691438,
0.2881708741,
-0.1557521969,
0.6130015254,
-0.4559848607,
0.837168932,
0.0643055737,
-1.2063945532,
0.3362343907,
-0.0024064935,
0.1902314574,
0.4125136435,
0.1135560572,
-0.5558106303,
-0.2899484038,
-0.5601251125,
-1.0634460449,
0.9350235462,
0.0994586274,
0.0615570396,
-0.3196401,
0.3161940575,
0.0722354203,
0.2463572025,
-0.744152844,
-0.2973847389,
-0.3025963604,
-0.2255040854,
0.048587732,
-0.3054140806,
0.2890702486,
-0.368450582,
0.6322692037,
0.1402643323,
0.577480495,
0.2250010967,
-0.2858891785,
-0.0318972282,
0.3196977973,
0.464142859,
0.5115473866,
-0.212701261,
0.245331198,
0.3596051037,
-0.2494354248,
0.0198693406,
-0.06812042,
-0.3699697554,
0.4086711705,
0.2578601241,
0.9085150957,
0.3496724367,
-0.3832895458,
0.6546305418,
0.0403648093,
0.2586414516,
-0.245139122,
-0.1893593967,
-0.202980265,
-0.0108065503,
0.4542336464,
0.2166357487,
-0.055047553,
-0.2808903754,
0.031892363,
0.5040662885,
-0.6055518985,
-0.4293250442,
0.5696800947,
0.1099235564,
-0.5144098997,
0.6324924827,
0.0185159389,
-0.8136079907,
0.6090692282,
0.7732978463,
0.867688179,
-0.3649517,
-0.0220301468,
0.2783094049,
0.3819534779,
-0.0971739963,
0.0059478567,
-0.031303335,
-0.9371358752,
-0.3854183555,
-0.695394814,
-0.3495866954,
-0.0530942418,
-0.5975918174,
0.6625868082,
-0.3613789082,
-0.5818174481,
-0.0673918799,
-0.276963383,
-0.8275471926,
-0.0618248731,
0.428391546,
0.8888378739,
-0.5986430049,
0.9290707111,
0.7728092074,
-0.2036554813,
-0.6318201423,
0.1873406172,
-0.4446280003,
-0.5936647058,
0.6120305657,
0.5247194767,
0.026593361,
-0.2816529274,
-0.5011946559,
-0.9267007709,
0.95999825,
0.2777567506,
-0.5394287109,
-0.1880592555,
0.3820192516,
0.6778451204,
-0.164615646,
0.3298031092,
0.5263460875,
0.2094006389,
-0.1601733714,
-1.0844011307,
-0.0254501365,
-0.0117664514,
0.0703280717,
0.598890245,
-0.6888588071,
0.769961834,
0.2228749245,
-0.2416908443,
-0.2923084497,
0.3498552442,
0.1201515868,
0.1106101647,
0.5811098218,
0.5937171578,
0.8116503954,
-0.1771327406,
1.1066859961,
-0.3696750402,
0.3862279058,
0.9360308051,
-0.3718999326,
0.8568104506,
0.7520598769,
-0.0678014234,
0.4370693564,
0.480652988,
0.0087581454,
0.6028527617,
0.3506211042,
0.0884052068,
0.1449409723,
-0.2989892662,
-0.3529237211,
0.3852235675,
0.4411982,
-0.6256055832,
0.0592381172,
0.0362854451,
0.019382799,
-0.2849445343,
-0.3092781305,
0.3801189661,
0.0763174072,
-0.5811035633,
0.2909088731,
0.4612417221,
1.1834979057,
-0.351970315,
0.0950445011,
-0.1709320396,
0.3269121051,
-0.1878746301,
-0.6067730188,
0.3502246141,
0.0285711624,
-0.150161162,
-0.4543068111,
0.92081815,
-0.2220606059,
-0.2103728801,
0.3702667356,
0.1352255344,
-0.0840030089,
0.1043195873,
-0.4212815166,
-0.0192835778,
-0.1389123499,
-0.174309358,
0.3794497252,
0.3227733374,
-0.3087972105,
0.4205336571,
0.3182843328,
-0.0954115912,
0.2633654475,
0.3172179163,
0.5535109043,
-0.7507795095,
-0.3289108276,
-0.9720945358,
0.2635530829,
-0.0943251029,
-0.1257748306,
0.8793466687,
0.4376881719,
1.2013239861,
-0.0016196128,
0.6459416151,
-0.09862791,
0.323880583,
-0.3715922236,
0.5443360209,
-0.0448207892,
0.5011043549,
-0.408949852,
-1.1306886673,
-0.3725667894,
0.6800914407,
-0.5315275788,
-0.0809494182,
0.4475874007,
0.3243123889,
0.0760758743,
-0.0250349529,
0.0990380421,
0.0368020646,
0.4409942925,
0.1830480546,
1.0899719,
-0.6021929979,
0.2226697803,
-0.3067435324,
0.3007313013,
-0.195987761,
-0.8710740209,
-0.7937755585,
-0.253145963,
-0.2862014472,
-0.1878231168,
-0.135663271,
1.1233177185,
0.694601953,
-1.0457220078,
-0.1119498089,
-0.0145793725,
0.3435373008,
0.0098842541,
-0.2715427876,
0.3875568509,
-0.2418450117,
-0.8444211483,
0.0667523369,
0.1098540053,
0.1655955017,
-0.0524581037,
0.0032848099,
-0.255366981,
-0.1760964245,
0.5203673244,
-0.0341574512,
-0.8545674086,
-0.5566493273,
0.1311890483,
-0.0942245796,
0.1822810769,
0.8514179587,
-0.8071438074,
0.2447892576,
0.3813169599,
0.6344636083,
0.3949038386,
0.4335846305,
0.5480163693,
-1.192559123,
0.3750926554,
0.2360321283,
0.5810258985,
0.4598912597,
-0.3815812469,
0.4174118042,
0.1578763425,
-0.3675099313,
-0.9400719404,
-0.1826770604,
-0.6932294369,
-0.2557298541,
1.255767107,
0.1168849692,
0.0470805094,
-0.0821581334,
-0.3397395015,
0.5725405812,
-0.3134305179,
0.7151243091,
0.9374117851,
-0.0452074036,
0.1540678442,
-0.3739305437,
0.3305042386,
0.6661049128,
-0.1739202887,
-0.1215737462,
0.2729475498,
0.2669710517,
0.2513370514,
0.2200801969,
-0.1641162485,
-0.4363555014,
-0.2062375098,
0.4065885842,
0.1271618158,
-0.2814840674,
-0.6714314222,
0.2124599814,
0.2230998874,
-0.4027229548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13559v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13559v2 | Towards Multi-Modal DBMSs for Seamless Querying of Texts and Tables | 2023-04-26T13:31:04 | 2023-04-28T14:55:48 | Matthias Urban, Carsten Binnig | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | In this paper, we propose Multi-Modal Databases (MMDBs), which is a new class
of database systems that can seamlessly query text and tables using SQL. To
enable seamless querying of textual data using SQL in an MMDB, we propose to
extend relational databases with so-called multi-modal operators (MMOps) which
are based on the advances of recent large language models such as GPT-3. The
main idea of MMOps is that they allow text collections to be treated as tables
without the need to manually transform the data. As we show in our evaluation,
our MMDB prototype can not only outperform state-of-the-art approaches such as
text-to-table in terms of accuracy and performance but it also requires
significantly less training data to fine-tune the model for an unseen text
collection. | [
-0.4141349494,
-1.0891753435,
0.8253611922,
-0.0591992065,
-0.3895699978,
0.0540844016,
0.0351593122,
-0.527356863,
0.4166653454,
0.7315645218,
-0.7949790359,
-0.6297094226,
-0.281787008,
0.2529579699,
-0.6153830886,
0.719635725,
0.318038851,
0.1537273526,
-0.2238956094,
-0.1444974095,
-0.4869567454,
-0.6325975657,
0.0901854038,
0.1858872175,
0.3345223367,
0.3373326957,
1.0799890757,
0.5228832364,
0.3471706212,
0.3273311853,
0.342048049,
0.4316383004,
0.0100947749,
0.5453624725,
0.0884151161,
-0.6452266574,
-0.7053043842,
-0.2600443661,
0.6486402154,
0.9652300477,
-0.1754011661,
-0.3249287903,
-0.0527835973,
0.9761940837,
-0.6106821299,
0.4247299433,
-0.5779275894,
0.158378914,
-0.4569087923,
-0.2978538275,
-0.4821389914,
-0.5596850514,
0.0282386206,
-0.5338686109,
-0.0827139243,
0.3160963953,
0.4818589985,
-0.1194089279,
-0.9937573075,
-0.4656556249,
-0.6596730947,
0.6039662957,
-0.3723651171,
0.926802814,
0.421947211,
0.4230216146,
-0.0400305539,
-0.4064855874,
-0.7910162807,
-0.3754527867,
-0.3341598511,
-0.0026360843,
0.4401246607,
0.0480333641,
0.0170783922,
0.4446381927,
-0.554903388,
-0.2133585662,
0.0985558257,
0.0686487556,
0.283377856,
0.4848842323,
0.1692322791,
-0.5335176587,
-0.4668267071,
0.2007640749,
-0.5322263837,
-0.207279101,
0.135736838,
0.4419563711,
0.0782742649,
0.7831898928,
-0.1491591334,
1.1041078568,
-0.394849062,
-0.2832517028,
0.0005073801,
-0.7784884572,
-0.4493089616,
-0.4375683069,
0.9580623507,
0.2111111581,
-0.1752614379,
-0.3954143226,
-0.2746514976,
-0.100916937,
-0.045081716,
-0.5413491726,
-0.0590599813,
0.1999861151,
-0.5290448666,
-0.2806879878,
0.0933684111,
-1.018663764,
-0.3777984381,
-0.5880529881,
0.5456482172,
-0.5453894138,
-0.3412702084,
-0.0195266083,
0.2095327973,
-0.0990943983,
0.5169193745,
-1.0526109934,
0.2774637938,
0.5216688514,
0.9153086543,
-0.0380868427,
-0.1393626779,
-0.0779139251,
0.6804967523,
-0.3118131161,
0.7789744139,
-0.6786614656,
-0.7955790162,
0.0447079465,
0.0404932424,
-0.1555202305,
-0.3535195291,
0.4288937151,
-0.6258937716,
0.7155000567,
-0.4897325635,
-0.3209646046,
-0.2415929139,
0.4099419117,
-0.8889865875,
0.945525229,
0.1186879277,
-0.3784568608,
0.5617359281,
-0.6967502832,
-0.6025637984,
-0.2335447818,
-0.3475483358,
-0.2661320269,
-0.0148421768,
0.4101193547,
0.4805538058,
-0.744063139,
0.1685019135,
-0.3419623971,
-0.1561699957,
0.3877115846,
-0.4037729502,
0.501406312,
0.2340025902,
-0.1710911691,
0.0085319122,
-0.761433959,
0.0092989169,
-0.2853315175,
-0.5492370129,
-0.4987760186,
0.4664456844,
0.364199698,
0.3469188809,
0.1037629694,
-0.226574719,
0.6143479347,
-0.3234341145,
0.2571226358,
0.4196759164,
-0.2413537204,
0.559066236,
-0.2187636644,
0.248425737,
0.1391302049,
0.326369077,
-0.539052844,
-0.1875894964,
-0.7065453529,
-0.529927671,
0.3229556978,
0.6392701864,
-1.0807716846,
0.4074486792,
-0.3321565986,
-0.2119157761,
-0.0838319287,
-0.0337056778,
0.0395459421,
0.2825739682,
0.4922971725,
-0.4574486613,
-0.2856990099,
-0.9098387361,
-0.3171870112,
0.101890564,
-0.1397872716,
0.6099359393,
0.3405399621,
-0.0924730673,
0.7667659521,
-0.3087406754,
-0.574354887,
0.1466588676,
0.0004505061,
0.0445313081,
0.457497716,
0.3419979215,
-0.8153338432,
-0.5170181394,
0.2260777801,
-1.1248919964,
0.2977956533,
-0.0546627827,
-0.0845979899,
0.5010179877,
0.5776486397,
-0.6782299876,
-0.090637289,
0.3351559937,
-0.507638514,
0.4400326312,
0.1062881276,
0.6697738767,
-1.2582011223,
-0.0127678774,
-0.3479771316,
-0.5168311596,
-0.439009279,
-0.0912711993,
0.2245716602,
-0.3981981874,
-0.011653576,
-0.1048271656,
-1.055252552,
-0.2360019535,
0.1696661115,
0.1941757947,
0.1048241183,
0.4582095742,
-0.1213211119,
0.709272325,
0.7204899192,
-0.6114072204,
0.4053497314,
0.2024191022,
-0.2868237793,
1.2626103163,
-0.1644490659,
-0.0577685349,
-0.2688738108,
0.1967951059,
-0.9937426448,
-0.1323492974,
-0.0229767412,
-0.1896047592,
0.3913901448,
-0.2981135547,
-0.6038178205,
-0.2222629637,
-0.4889067709,
-0.0228102114,
-0.0872570202,
-0.3823280036,
1.0006816387,
0.552313149,
-0.0873560235,
-0.6794828773,
-0.7875473499,
0.2964211106,
0.0391068272,
-0.7125430703,
0.2085505277,
0.182245791,
0.0982862711,
0.1388813108,
-0.1950795501,
-0.5951982141,
-0.1994830072,
0.143348068,
0.4309876263,
-0.2983418703,
0.2157297879,
0.3524812758,
0.080837965,
-0.0988979265,
-0.1781193167,
0.4920719266,
0.1227720156,
-0.4399806559,
-0.4504667222,
0.6812056303,
0.8816492558,
-0.3939715028,
0.8174877763,
0.2689629495,
-0.3213158548,
0.026174074,
-0.6494876742,
-0.1781514287,
-0.4855972826,
0.3754745722,
-0.5839672685,
-1.0210067034,
0.2358517051,
-0.073719345,
-0.0544972606,
0.2702767253,
0.5327342749,
-0.1140377969,
1.0029809475,
0.6026581526,
0.1363604665,
0.573222816,
0.051486969,
-0.06732741,
-0.507609129,
-0.7253274918,
-0.7258113623,
0.0605297685,
-0.3548088372,
-0.6298807859,
0.6328953505,
0.0824945047,
-0.0147757353,
0.338771373,
-0.4015441537,
0.515766263,
0.2373752147,
0.2325880378,
0.8120310307,
0.0221936032,
-0.0274969749,
-0.0793869644,
-0.2284059227,
-0.4057871103,
1.1471830606,
-0.1983433813,
0.9087496996,
0.5662106276,
0.3494489491,
0.2014202923,
0.1286178678,
-0.8228657842,
0.4587832689,
0.1515371054,
-1.1123547554,
-0.3313405216,
-0.430395335,
-0.9158691168,
0.8596189022,
-0.5195998549,
-0.5303746462,
0.455948323,
-0.1800624877,
-0.0773798525,
0.2834031582,
-0.8377681375,
0.7663301229,
-0.2329160422,
-0.5322777033,
-0.2517276108,
-0.6346335411,
0.6098346114,
-0.1552618891,
0.4497834742,
-0.2864005864,
-0.4678775668,
0.3945438862,
-0.5663604736,
0.382617414,
-0.2747429311,
-0.0106279785,
0.2089248747,
0.4928889573,
0.3222011626,
0.3213870525,
-0.1577577591,
-0.1136947274,
0.3102506995,
-0.1897379607,
-0.5614645481,
0.8995097876,
-0.3146744668,
-0.2520961761,
-0.4895147681,
-0.6938898563,
-0.4789010882,
0.5500558615,
-0.4423079491,
0.6998544931,
-0.2692370713,
0.407160759,
0.4828126431,
0.1149172038,
0.7006546855,
0.7396724224,
-0.311088115,
-0.2580883503,
0.675190568,
0.438392669,
0.0732411519,
0.8080357313,
-0.3747338355,
-0.7795621753,
-0.3380258977,
-0.7699962854,
0.000301308,
-0.2776887119,
-0.4130630791,
-0.8487398028,
0.6371958852,
-0.215658471,
-0.0809614733,
-0.3183472455,
-0.5412828326,
-0.1143414378,
0.3196203113,
0.322324276,
0.7313229442,
0.2243105173,
0.190197885,
-1.0206084251,
0.3983972073,
0.5666586161,
0.829158783,
-0.0704669952,
0.2010341287,
-0.2386053205,
-0.2912989259,
-0.4003193378,
-1.4100865126,
0.3178433776,
0.270471096,
0.3625317514,
0.2346295565,
-0.2362793088,
0.4631614983,
-0.6407489181,
0.6825293303,
0.2578598559,
-1.1245090961,
0.3827928603,
-0.871348381,
0.0232275575,
0.7017505765,
0.5654860735,
-0.569036603,
0.1689015329,
-0.0218184777,
-0.8055020571,
0.9005794525,
0.0973945558,
-0.0544992164,
0.1568250358,
0.0937926769,
0.24729155,
0.7278200984,
-0.7503247857,
-0.3923721611,
-0.2893593609,
-0.1030876487,
0.1116938815,
-0.3326867819,
-0.160732612,
-0.1051982716,
0.360288322,
-0.3113138378,
0.5200849175,
0.0720972866,
-0.371176362,
0.0811284482,
0.6907440424,
0.2722456157,
0.8449428082,
-0.3652891517,
0.0239449665,
0.0957480744,
-0.4050118923,
0.148929134,
0.388928324,
-0.0348160714,
0.1029856205,
-0.1841589957,
0.6419272423,
0.28647241,
-0.4669447243,
0.5166098475,
-0.0945443586,
-0.0899377614,
-0.0140565364,
-0.3889359832,
0.2678582072,
0.12854141,
0.3726668358,
0.0454672687,
0.5874935389,
-0.7873278856,
0.1554020643,
0.7497500181,
-0.442956388,
-0.2509011328,
0.9404441714,
0.2810345888,
-0.1547987908,
0.3041781485,
0.1840210408,
-0.0226589367,
0.020011479,
0.3709056675,
0.440181762,
-0.2472313643,
0.0936065912,
0.0360380523,
0.5588023663,
-0.0534437597,
0.6184379458,
-0.2267458886,
-0.2780270278,
-0.4962517023,
-0.5284693241,
-0.6237667203,
-0.3098865449,
-0.5247361064,
0.3582980633,
-0.4215230644,
-0.0246686004,
-0.0621662885,
-0.304576695,
-0.3682124913,
0.1905549169,
-0.1855989099,
0.6565343738,
-0.4957132638,
1.037913084,
0.4738068283,
-0.6045721769,
-0.3912279904,
-0.4289689958,
0.1004923508,
-0.5654982924,
-0.1078762561,
-0.1093439087,
-0.0048571397,
-0.1297471076,
-0.1380931735,
-0.7723437548,
1.0712387562,
0.4154051244,
-0.6281145215,
-0.2190991491,
0.5065068007,
0.2642528415,
0.0745573714,
0.4946406782,
0.6791302562,
0.5554852486,
-0.3848467469,
-1.069535017,
0.0677749738,
0.004386228,
-0.0692805499,
0.712346375,
-0.6246884465,
1.1455636024,
0.2224196792,
-0.0924748629,
-0.1439734697,
0.6099190712,
-0.2540370524,
0.0489923842,
0.4458121955,
0.4160781205,
0.7081384063,
-0.5128430724,
1.2684582472,
-0.2301290631,
0.5627189279,
0.7614142299,
-0.1190964133,
0.6941004992,
0.4963174164,
-0.5281966329,
0.6059679389,
0.2246427387,
0.2533905208,
0.3881021142,
-0.4017054141,
-0.4330282509,
-0.1961895972,
0.0235630237,
-0.6834205985,
0.2834270298,
0.5191816092,
-0.1322236508,
-0.3182331026,
-0.0706802011,
0.0591195859,
0.0938659757,
-0.1945839971,
0.7263679504,
-0.163969636,
-0.1087125465,
0.4419696331,
0.1113931239,
0.836892724,
-0.7321709991,
0.1803233474,
-0.2078338712,
-0.2123547494,
-0.3481742442,
-0.6365115047,
0.3074947298,
-0.5262106657,
-0.3220789135,
0.0189844165,
0.6026159525,
-0.6551368237,
-0.3328814805,
-0.1370837688,
0.9729176164,
-0.1267635226,
-0.1632594913,
-0.7439643145,
-0.0473643392,
-0.2153723538,
-0.2470668405,
0.3009301126,
0.7770785093,
-0.0035186852,
0.4525207877,
0.8244205117,
-0.3284740448,
0.2288983166,
-0.0172244012,
0.9064612389,
-0.9392399788,
-0.647518158,
-0.8064604998,
0.4292954803,
-0.0302450266,
0.1046639904,
0.9147815108,
0.9841863513,
0.3908903301,
-0.3121493757,
0.6626536846,
-0.3004005849,
0.7981603742,
-0.5192239881,
0.6444983482,
-0.8133683801,
0.1973804981,
-0.6293229461,
-1.2799671888,
-0.4373389482,
0.3859561682,
0.071011886,
0.1080215722,
1.0629532337,
0.9053459167,
-0.0581249073,
0.1982250065,
0.3275328279,
0.0745335594,
0.4111723006,
0.3037583828,
0.734496057,
-0.5698016286,
0.5740825534,
-0.0218640584,
-0.0859837085,
-0.2151624858,
-0.6439023018,
-0.6611595154,
-0.7705098391,
0.2939854562,
-0.3179504275,
0.1215392798,
0.6859486699,
0.6894240379,
-0.7555103898,
-0.5281583071,
0.1622273475,
0.3035889566,
0.0481321961,
-0.2137326598,
0.5714476109,
-0.3216018975,
-1.0735234022,
0.529925704,
0.5762372017,
0.0452463925,
-0.3592730761,
0.3552571833,
-0.4381626546,
-0.0179220252,
1.0606791973,
0.0449780263,
-0.2686295509,
-0.0144402478,
0.0135169784,
-0.2958059013,
0.1728090346,
0.891810894,
-0.8110857606,
0.5408248901,
0.3731271923,
0.4674043655,
0.5985961556,
-0.1866024137,
0.3236498833,
-0.5581963062,
0.3664957881,
0.2843980789,
0.2077976912,
0.2332330942,
-0.2150383741,
0.369294554,
0.4329984188,
-0.4659353197,
-0.7481095195,
0.2213526368,
-1.1942895651,
-0.3092365265,
0.7877447605,
0.6709980369,
-0.1235163584,
-0.5716593862,
-0.3226463497,
-0.15110147,
-0.5010299087,
0.4872066975,
0.53784132,
-0.2543796301,
-0.0185846966,
-0.8853283525,
0.7047685385,
0.4607558846,
-1.0723600388,
-0.0252443571,
1.0016924143,
0.114716731,
-0.0655861944,
0.9159772992,
-0.6115348935,
0.1142476127,
-0.0200424567,
-0.0542589687,
-0.101049304,
-0.4695770442,
0.0419554524,
0.6752030253,
-0.0126648815,
-0.0273112785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13462v1 | Multidimensional Evaluation for Text Style Transfer Using ChatGPT | 2023-04-26T11:33:35 | 2023-04-26T11:33:35 | Huiyuan Lai, Antonio Toral, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate the potential of ChatGPT as a multidimensional evaluator for
the task of \emph{Text Style Transfer}, alongside, and in comparison to,
existing automatic metrics as well as human judgements. We focus on a zero-shot
setting, i.e. prompting ChatGPT with specific task instructions, and test its
performance on three commonly-used dimensions of text style transfer
evaluation: style strength, content preservation, and fluency. We perform a
comprehensive correlation analysis for two transfer directions (and overall) at
different levels. Compared to existing automatic metrics, ChatGPT achieves
competitive correlations with human judgments. These preliminary results are
expected to provide a first glimpse into the role of large language models in
the multidimensional evaluation of stylized text generation. | [
-0.3209581673,
-0.9658486247,
0.400556922,
0.641658783,
-0.1771506667,
0.1890326291,
-0.3520312905,
-0.3963133693,
0.1994892359,
0.2538377643,
-0.4981051981,
-0.4492943585,
-0.608424902,
-0.0811705515,
-0.3749575317,
1.2335596085,
-0.2373244315,
-0.2490374893,
0.0472043827,
0.2555161715,
-0.6288229227,
-0.5875813961,
-0.8578354716,
-0.1583367586,
0.5257406235,
0.59113729,
0.5434157848,
0.1463239193,
0.8891422153,
0.2003958225,
0.3809639513,
-0.1935658604,
-0.418654114,
0.2462614179,
-0.0067815296,
-0.128539145,
-0.6692207456,
0.167908594,
0.654405117,
0.2423305064,
-0.0743193924,
0.1538644433,
0.115852423,
0.6324693561,
-0.6530534625,
0.3222294152,
-0.3589743674,
0.3036083877,
-0.2387635261,
-0.5644164085,
-0.4505802095,
-0.5830947161,
0.2785843909,
-0.395999521,
0.2103013098,
0.108657673,
0.5866243243,
-0.0285712276,
-0.653575182,
-0.2468953133,
-0.9506180882,
0.5804113746,
-0.1727151573,
0.4261254668,
0.19004336,
0.5173394084,
0.3122594655,
-0.8431549072,
-0.6984638572,
-0.3126474321,
0.0614333302,
0.7623317838,
-0.1762405932,
-0.0177851897,
-0.0006007666,
0.3233273029,
-0.6603469849,
-0.1639107615,
-0.3960611522,
-0.1197603866,
0.6799805164,
0.1488508433,
0.4988708198,
-0.188345924,
-0.5209721327,
-0.5353212953,
-0.1958762556,
0.0120868906,
0.4592797756,
0.1913666874,
-0.0652648211,
0.4555452466,
-0.0806939304,
0.4309147894,
-0.1876666397,
-0.2161441743,
0.1449398696,
-0.8549649715,
0.0297478475,
-0.0820008367,
1.0474754572,
0.7913243175,
0.4116918445,
-0.1059973463,
-0.0852596983,
-0.2608667016,
0.4861286581,
-1.0816254616,
-0.4999040663,
-0.3113040924,
-0.5955178738,
-0.3731839955,
0.0994754955,
-1.3192083836,
-0.3114554584,
-0.3838397563,
0.6680572033,
-0.5769971013,
-0.1327037662,
0.2146984488,
-0.4172700047,
0.4153420627,
0.5145276785,
-1.0517383814,
0.1194469556,
0.4910445511,
1.0951018333,
-0.4587114453,
-0.3114154041,
-0.0021410552,
-0.1426717639,
-0.2874516547,
1.057880044,
-0.5930846334,
-0.5036102533,
-0.0081084557,
-0.3545761704,
-0.3168263733,
0.1017629728,
0.7458345294,
-0.0178519804,
0.1647977084,
-0.1793354899,
-0.2929973304,
-0.0208239369,
0.2341763973,
-0.3495961726,
0.9582192302,
0.2141135931,
-0.6899893284,
0.5194624066,
-0.8995597959,
-0.4690468609,
-0.0157390293,
0.1226440817,
-0.546831727,
-0.1105393395,
0.0813255534,
0.4123589993,
-0.0562518165,
-0.4193310738,
-0.4945743978,
-0.410929054,
0.4331582189,
-0.7531093359,
0.4586122632,
0.2310180664,
-0.1074012816,
0.011862156,
-0.7665926218,
0.1448651999,
0.0951143354,
-0.2184071988,
-0.2545264959,
-0.4641573131,
0.5204764605,
0.263138175,
0.380643189,
-0.6511818767,
0.5070034266,
0.2972445786,
0.3071119189,
0.5755637288,
0.3816351593,
0.397354424,
-0.3761634827,
0.6592085958,
-0.4471322298,
0.2931686938,
-0.0699005425,
-0.5469065309,
-0.6703240871,
-0.2668653429,
0.3320933878,
0.7518752813,
-0.5757461786,
0.2734062672,
-0.18543455,
-0.8098096251,
-0.0348239131,
-0.3306403458,
0.1704325527,
0.0995824262,
0.1687323153,
-0.6507585049,
-0.0385452881,
-0.8477155566,
-0.2372408211,
-0.1996927857,
-0.0817751959,
0.3123963475,
0.369720459,
0.1949045211,
0.6760821342,
-0.674057126,
-0.2059697807,
-0.1600700319,
0.6997029781,
-0.1530528516,
0.4820536375,
0.9702429771,
-0.5265996456,
-0.923150897,
0.1873193234,
-0.3201819956,
-0.3739134669,
-0.3443276584,
-0.3707764745,
-0.244010672,
0.391935885,
-0.5080736279,
0.4430604875,
0.7098686099,
-0.5224426985,
0.8434954882,
-0.2832258046,
0.7277421355,
-1.0929988623,
0.1752203554,
0.1116831824,
-0.0193604287,
-0.8168873191,
-0.1713979542,
0.1404998451,
-0.2226569355,
-0.1631864607,
0.5235233307,
-0.1734640747,
-0.1107086465,
-0.1024899185,
0.2803103328,
0.2758577466,
0.6164777279,
-0.1351534575,
0.9599448442,
0.334385246,
-0.1395875365,
0.4519789219,
0.2439564019,
-0.1395784616,
1.3441002369,
-0.6440017819,
0.5172597766,
0.0489289574,
0.2600017488,
-1.4684017897,
0.0705431625,
0.304933399,
-0.297326982,
0.4894388914,
-0.2904294431,
-0.6909789443,
-0.1669844985,
-0.4266913831,
0.2563304305,
0.442976445,
-0.1823293269,
0.1007091627,
0.0768199414,
-0.4761366248,
-0.1662325561,
-0.3298942149,
0.1940391809,
-0.4722259939,
-0.5195611715,
0.4280094504,
-0.3587863743,
-0.0983907729,
-0.46659109,
0.0381652229,
-0.4171116948,
-0.0151655553,
0.0417570174,
0.4442995787,
-0.0782544315,
0.0546882562,
-0.0424320325,
0.0996278673,
0.0138208447,
-0.1592422724,
0.5703247786,
-0.2837076485,
-0.6204480529,
-0.5967850685,
0.1034239084,
0.6338847876,
-0.3770281374,
0.5630761385,
1.1216266155,
0.1006166711,
0.0464533195,
-0.2845310271,
0.0332392864,
-0.3773884177,
0.3787401319,
-0.3661577106,
-0.5187808871,
0.4240005612,
0.2279009223,
0.1323782653,
0.5754155517,
0.5403835773,
0.1017218828,
0.9847128987,
0.6172923446,
0.1646887064,
0.8293027282,
0.0594803132,
0.2974518836,
-0.6761853695,
-0.1541729122,
-0.5923914909,
-0.4162088931,
-0.7409945726,
-0.2324543446,
0.3499649167,
-0.0165542904,
-0.2575787902,
0.4535484612,
-0.4104161561,
0.4209759235,
0.4508685768,
0.1275469363,
0.3409872651,
0.0143990172,
0.0912621245,
-0.0920428261,
-0.2381819636,
-0.3952572346,
1.1584059,
0.4176113605,
0.8326509595,
0.1634061635,
0.4864516556,
0.3401615322,
0.2919471264,
-1.1862530708,
0.2339218706,
-0.379294306,
-0.1029751897,
-0.4372060597,
-0.3526605666,
-0.8432910442,
0.2961487472,
-0.4254499376,
-0.8707915545,
-0.0632414371,
-0.0884725004,
-0.4009942114,
0.2098372132,
-0.817758441,
0.7897217274,
-0.1444503963,
-0.2403948903,
0.056305062,
-0.3267760873,
0.2615253627,
-0.3683685064,
-0.1726012975,
-0.190735206,
0.0124173937,
0.7147641778,
0.1628331989,
0.6205096841,
0.1801492274,
-0.2290276587,
0.0662178174,
0.3783124387,
0.0972849578,
-0.0691117644,
-0.0040305788,
0.2815223634,
0.3113021255,
0.0178988222,
-0.9565657973,
0.4570954442,
-0.7014346123,
-0.0199747309,
-0.1527455747,
-0.7335036993,
-0.3291555643,
0.2487369031,
0.1407067329,
0.5538033247,
-0.448131144,
0.3359620273,
0.2059849948,
-0.1812819839,
0.396003902,
0.2913951278,
-0.4946900308,
-0.2304361314,
1.0254015923,
0.1557703167,
0.3727339506,
0.3879406154,
0.4903540015,
-0.4710852802,
-0.4079741538,
-0.5918444395,
-0.1885450482,
-0.6404290199,
-0.0447666869,
-0.4040496349,
-0.4905232191,
-0.3526526988,
-0.2182604522,
-0.4307381213,
-0.6554108262,
0.011094979,
0.3315050304,
0.3697220981,
0.9040928483,
0.1619140655,
0.4779793322,
-0.7916013002,
-0.033743158,
0.5160852671,
0.4724186361,
-0.303750217,
-0.6317680478,
0.1115325317,
-0.1245779842,
-0.6698818207,
-0.8682305813,
0.4720921814,
0.2414948493,
0.3449875116,
0.3979952633,
-0.1196572259,
0.4620766342,
-0.547097683,
0.7877401114,
0.2702366114,
-0.8368282318,
0.3486486673,
-0.6020957828,
0.2464721352,
0.5171172023,
0.2186719775,
-0.9684117436,
-0.2398248315,
-0.7520959377,
-0.4321400523,
0.4682768881,
0.6210636497,
0.1636336148,
0.2454460859,
0.3008637726,
0.0131550049,
0.1697764695,
-0.3572249115,
-0.2160196602,
-0.4405979216,
-0.0504210889,
0.0177027695,
0.0195732526,
0.0017572031,
-0.0419391803,
0.1404219419,
-0.1440750211,
0.6458521485,
-0.0102548376,
0.1652704179,
0.1297501624,
0.5674307346,
0.7924004197,
0.6793467402,
-0.2654958665,
0.1425380707,
0.1944588721,
-0.6278345585,
-0.0536854342,
0.0488965809,
0.0338540412,
-0.0499648042,
0.3074716628,
0.8211318254,
0.1773676872,
0.0163565613,
0.8352198005,
-0.4670898914,
-0.2412406653,
-0.129269585,
0.0082031097,
-0.412352711,
0.0462790728,
0.0499523245,
0.2275166512,
0.3563019037,
-0.5349566936,
0.3532363474,
0.4690188169,
-0.4691623449,
-0.5269635916,
0.4175798297,
0.1026590988,
-0.3262068927,
0.5104237199,
-0.1149482206,
-0.5606616735,
0.524386704,
0.7009666562,
0.8672837019,
-0.1914612204,
0.4568180442,
0.4991482496,
0.1181223392,
0.0526154675,
0.0032326854,
-0.0686330944,
-0.7194032073,
-0.3190506399,
-0.7140802741,
-0.737598896,
0.050206285,
-0.6363136768,
0.4084766805,
-0.4822148383,
-0.182592243,
0.2366250306,
-0.0552433692,
-0.7324784398,
-0.1815915555,
0.1529606581,
0.6616423726,
-0.8891848326,
0.5261057019,
0.4614400566,
-0.5727517605,
-0.5954485536,
0.4323072135,
0.2314133793,
-0.8731178641,
0.6598348022,
0.1962141544,
-0.3228055835,
0.094816722,
-0.208816275,
-0.8009717464,
0.9439971447,
0.1784893423,
-0.2509132624,
0.229994148,
0.0772102252,
0.7830251455,
-0.0539023429,
0.6289602518,
0.789491117,
0.6328846216,
0.2453276366,
-1.3109365702,
-0.137329191,
-0.1877204329,
0.0229152292,
0.2823862731,
-0.7888180017,
0.8712064028,
0.1174352914,
-0.3298225701,
-0.0223464686,
0.3634494543,
-0.1755069196,
-0.0530659258,
0.3762658834,
0.3023890257,
0.4911254644,
-0.068034932,
1.1594222784,
-0.4118236601,
0.6312041283,
0.7437598705,
-0.0816620961,
0.9765345454,
0.2368305027,
-0.3730898798,
0.3847814798,
0.324106127,
-0.0698576793,
0.3623024523,
0.1022895128,
-0.253908664,
0.0867845938,
-0.2438759506,
-0.2377085984,
1.0902198553,
0.0770154148,
-0.1298039407,
-0.2730866671,
-0.0951384827,
0.2740242481,
-0.2438459098,
-0.0912000537,
0.8266375065,
-0.2269852608,
-0.7526388168,
0.0737185925,
-0.0360659733,
0.5353655815,
-0.5036337972,
-0.318772763,
-0.2008307576,
0.1998614371,
0.0510051921,
-1.415702343,
0.3690294921,
-0.2940482795,
0.2203761786,
-0.702600956,
0.9228715301,
-0.5225142837,
-0.4698157012,
-0.0043122713,
0.52843225,
0.2312100679,
-0.2519795299,
-0.7394493222,
-0.2510892153,
-0.1608413458,
-0.1158818454,
0.4820038974,
0.6970241666,
0.0821191892,
0.3863426745,
0.6849646568,
0.0535090193,
-0.0077462918,
0.4590665102,
0.4048191011,
-0.4082299173,
-0.3922653496,
-0.9395554662,
0.0717942417,
-0.0997831076,
-0.489865154,
1.0223599672,
0.3614500761,
0.5595303774,
-0.1253017187,
0.8317198753,
-0.0952311009,
0.0367510729,
-0.6050427556,
1.0147857666,
-0.2638960779,
-0.3124253154,
-0.6670899391,
-1.0875169039,
-0.4084264338,
0.7613675594,
-0.2381610721,
0.1723773777,
0.8860679269,
0.4718684554,
-0.043271102,
0.1504280865,
0.473377645,
-0.2985033691,
0.3975118697,
0.3217731416,
0.9003925323,
-0.2407831103,
0.7625620961,
-0.527197957,
-0.4199999273,
-0.1727983057,
-1.1368587017,
-0.8584663272,
-0.7066614628,
-0.2340346128,
-0.0621536411,
-0.2423578799,
0.6931766868,
0.6741982102,
-0.4166156054,
-0.224007085,
0.2555375993,
-0.3551594019,
-0.3644231856,
-0.2941273153,
0.4486707151,
-0.4633950293,
-0.8349054456,
0.0126209753,
0.4867416918,
0.1175241396,
-0.4132356942,
0.2951417267,
0.1631118208,
0.1132903546,
1.002415061,
-0.0516419299,
-0.2015900761,
-0.7360521555,
-0.0721569732,
-0.2661800683,
0.2678319216,
1.0435897112,
-0.0473240092,
0.4806979299,
0.7289608121,
0.4779837132,
0.4158040583,
0.1502121687,
0.5344113708,
-0.9645309448,
-0.1431045383,
-0.2486000061,
0.2551036477,
0.2299806029,
-0.3355732262,
0.401127249,
0.228935197,
-0.8016527891,
-0.1867657751,
0.0145614827,
-1.1885038614,
0.1424484104,
1.2431902885,
-0.1112724468,
0.2281270027,
0.0150017943,
-0.6308867931,
0.3467887938,
-0.4819363356,
0.7835751772,
0.9179306626,
-0.5286248922,
-0.3536169529,
-0.9873151183,
0.5367072225,
0.0406833775,
-1.1402839422,
0.0851109475,
0.3562588096,
0.285801053,
0.3561944962,
0.6016782522,
-0.1747935265,
0.127210781,
0.1882763058,
0.1750170439,
0.2040552348,
-0.4659297764,
-0.1577278078,
0.1545317769,
-0.0239297803,
-0.1967391819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13343v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13343v2 | Enhancing Large Language Model with Self-Controlled Memory Framework | 2023-04-26T07:25:31 | 2024-02-15T16:01:39 | Bing Wang, Xinnian Liang, Jian Yang, Hui Huang, Shuangzhi Wu, Peihao Wu, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are constrained by their inability to process
lengthy inputs, resulting in the loss of critical historical information. To
address this limitation, in this paper, we propose the Self-Controlled Memory
(SCM) framework to enhance the ability of LLMs to maintain long-term memory and
recall relevant information. Our SCM framework comprises three key components:
an LLM-based agent serving as the backbone of the framework, a memory stream
storing agent memories, and a memory controller updating memories and
determining when and how to utilize memories from memory stream. Additionally,
the proposed SCM is able to process ultra-long texts without any modification
or fine-tuning, which can integrate with any instruction following LLMs in a
plug-and-play paradigm. Furthermore, we annotate a dataset to evaluate the
effectiveness of SCM for handling lengthy inputs. The annotated dataset covers
three tasks: long-term dialogues, book summarization, and meeting
summarization. Experimental results demonstrate that our method achieves better
retrieval recall and generates more informative responses compared to
competitive baselines in long-term dialogues.
(https://github.com/wbbeyourself/SCM4LLMs) | [
-0.1747050434,
-0.7546143532,
0.7081744671,
0.2807037532,
-0.1845085919,
0.1099607199,
-0.6021702886,
-0.3624406457,
0.4069823623,
0.9134399295,
-0.1660803556,
-0.4284454584,
-0.1578931212,
0.0119533446,
-0.3212539554,
0.8382932544,
-0.2107309252,
-0.1844590455,
-0.2418088168,
-0.218760848,
-0.4792645872,
-0.7464882731,
-0.5941416025,
-0.5619394183,
0.5731315017,
0.3280686736,
0.5623167753,
0.9409171343,
0.2455185801,
0.2844217122,
-0.1527642906,
0.1593884081,
-0.5606594086,
0.3904354274,
-0.4723465443,
-0.3280407488,
-0.7752669454,
-0.4463507831,
0.9020367265,
0.284355253,
-0.3673714995,
-0.0164598245,
0.1546813399,
0.711235702,
-0.4834062159,
0.4359326661,
-0.4997642636,
-0.0935184211,
-0.1261800826,
-0.4237298965,
-0.5481772423,
0.1431370825,
-0.0841337517,
-0.2397916615,
-0.1475262046,
-0.1405803114,
0.3465330899,
0.0604570657,
-0.3073145151,
-0.3425881267,
-0.9835706949,
0.6307589412,
-0.8802406192,
0.162435025,
0.5876338482,
0.1677155346,
-0.4295703173,
-0.5057007074,
-0.4624122381,
-0.3248599768,
0.0460653864,
0.1063132957,
0.083363317,
0.20891729,
0.1330541819,
0.1176742241,
-0.4217558801,
0.3112063408,
-0.2793887854,
-0.2957722545,
0.5839557052,
0.4115596414,
0.1837416738,
-0.1363095939,
-0.3925521374,
0.2314575911,
-0.5887182355,
-0.3363879025,
0.0872281939,
0.4086753428,
0.1425505579,
0.5251433849,
-0.3337344825,
0.4940181077,
-0.1564297229,
-0.2355857939,
0.1836230606,
-0.1273783594,
-0.1212865859,
0.0853927657,
0.7264006138,
0.4092985988,
0.3536121249,
-0.1060542837,
-0.3785309792,
-0.2709874809,
0.0770782307,
-0.8963216543,
-0.0402941257,
0.2463300079,
-0.3761297166,
0.0988470018,
-0.380076617,
-0.7307454944,
-0.2575217187,
-0.2669965625,
0.2972774804,
-0.4268793166,
-0.1721024364,
0.2341190428,
0.3029079139,
0.1542093605,
0.352909863,
-0.9957157969,
0.4097474813,
0.3486973941,
0.8165454865,
-0.6362072229,
-0.342907548,
-0.4098191261,
0.9073401093,
-0.28297472,
0.5915343761,
-0.5183643699,
-0.4371423125,
0.1137931645,
0.023326572,
0.0739770159,
-0.5428736806,
0.0613986328,
-0.6846707463,
0.1915145814,
0.0826618075,
-0.7710005641,
0.0174337104,
0.2720017135,
-0.6269330382,
1.086376071,
-0.0664427355,
-0.404820323,
-0.2408605069,
-0.4777251482,
-0.5067326427,
0.2882948518,
-0.3832613826,
-0.2162985057,
-0.0761005953,
0.1446764469,
0.7350566387,
-0.1543702185,
0.4739979804,
-0.2651981711,
-0.4286861122,
0.1591515839,
-0.3606894314,
0.1775741428,
0.1175444275,
-0.1393621415,
0.1934570968,
-0.7586328983,
0.0126074404,
0.1962281764,
-0.6095206738,
-0.3096314073,
0.079897441,
-0.1041845754,
0.2721910179,
0.6153071523,
-0.2643568516,
0.3528695107,
-0.2533697188,
0.5693049431,
0.8097913861,
0.1137909815,
0.5573244691,
-0.2724232674,
0.4681574404,
-0.0232980307,
-0.0193191022,
-0.747815311,
0.3107067645,
-0.9162253141,
-0.2868910134,
0.0683309436,
0.533922255,
-0.6154894233,
0.5987548232,
-0.2786959112,
-0.1847473681,
0.0179996025,
0.5238129497,
0.1583973765,
0.2202404737,
0.4826173484,
-0.2058964521,
-0.3818649054,
-0.7891991138,
0.0729104504,
-0.2061775625,
-0.0074850288,
0.3936446309,
0.3862612247,
-0.3535807431,
0.8972633481,
-0.3329559863,
-0.6231820583,
-0.5772447586,
-0.0440104157,
0.0356037989,
0.4924458563,
0.207885012,
-0.2849313915,
-0.1217565313,
-0.2994247079,
-0.6484744549,
-0.0308437273,
-0.5433601141,
0.0006309149,
0.5126984119,
0.8564221859,
-0.8168703318,
0.3933998346,
0.2679961026,
-0.2071704715,
0.464641571,
-0.5997903943,
-0.1581815034,
-1.1805583239,
-0.0195987336,
-0.3141432703,
-0.3941626251,
-0.237492606,
-0.09481626,
0.3708254099,
0.1578985155,
-0.3743741512,
0.7806222439,
-0.6932700872,
0.1175486445,
-0.7256903648,
0.302164048,
-0.1576183289,
0.6961986423,
0.0733177066,
0.6930909157,
0.3303789198,
-0.6402692795,
0.4138856232,
0.0071417303,
-0.1694861948,
0.2521046102,
-0.4252491891,
0.1512151957,
-0.2336106896,
0.5190093517,
-0.7778155804,
-0.1578332931,
0.0815563127,
-0.0390897505,
0.5810319185,
0.0666607842,
-0.7012620568,
-0.2697952688,
-0.130255878,
0.074442178,
0.2923224568,
-0.4463577569,
1.0331537724,
0.244320333,
-0.5556664467,
-0.3436169028,
-0.715362668,
0.354341507,
-0.2026827186,
-0.036425788,
0.1152645499,
-0.3473625481,
0.1566823423,
-0.1963269562,
-0.1168651879,
0.1277900338,
-0.1422172785,
0.2512277365,
0.2930443585,
-0.120912455,
0.7119150758,
0.122821264,
-0.2474915683,
0.13090536,
-0.2429483086,
0.7816711664,
-0.0483254977,
-0.1549540609,
-0.4724283814,
0.3822026849,
0.5506116152,
-0.3132277727,
0.5373656154,
0.2410074472,
-0.2045723945,
-0.4163089991,
-0.778106153,
-0.2394695431,
-0.4940975606,
0.6871006489,
-0.3236544132,
-1.3149449825,
0.6704106331,
-0.3130176365,
-0.1805967987,
0.2750299871,
0.7367254496,
-0.1544984132,
0.7877727151,
0.4555229843,
-0.6749640107,
0.5713240504,
-0.1016910374,
-0.0601428188,
-0.8283669949,
-0.0666325539,
-0.1786000133,
-0.0920392871,
-0.2420584559,
-0.5820427537,
-0.1513874531,
0.1900539249,
-0.3355351388,
0.0551732294,
-0.1263106614,
0.6792269945,
0.2012474835,
-0.0892133787,
0.3015673757,
-0.172917515,
-0.2508319318,
0.0414092951,
-0.6404806972,
-0.6398994923,
0.8596137762,
0.6357230544,
1.1222131252,
-0.0654747188,
0.7064034343,
0.3603518903,
0.143443197,
-0.5997891426,
0.8495509624,
0.2291596383,
-0.5967200398,
-0.5808126926,
-0.4523655176,
-0.7659662366,
0.2161187381,
0.0249338299,
-0.883726716,
-0.180572331,
0.1723367125,
-0.4463761151,
0.2894813418,
-0.3223150074,
0.5113364458,
-0.5947024226,
-0.5763281584,
-0.4146153331,
-0.6014555097,
0.0040070009,
-0.137258783,
0.0275848918,
-0.2102842331,
-0.1580218673,
0.7121694088,
-0.0492919572,
1.0139400959,
0.1030503362,
-0.0877051726,
0.3834899962,
0.2860105634,
0.6299484372,
-0.0038867644,
-0.1223814934,
0.0168638919,
-0.0152284661,
-0.3958270848,
-0.6555928588,
0.9964126348,
-0.5268925428,
-0.7647086978,
-0.5208628774,
-0.6505271792,
-0.192562893,
0.4804116189,
-0.3936186731,
0.348934561,
-0.2843172848,
0.3736218214,
0.6887146235,
-0.1969516873,
0.866528213,
0.8937139511,
-0.6352924109,
-0.4710630178,
0.7603830695,
0.1868052334,
0.3203637898,
0.3111383021,
0.1419390887,
-0.3014434874,
-0.6525040269,
-0.3350910544,
0.4117729962,
-0.6340508461,
-0.3993420005,
-0.7394654751,
-0.3857782781,
-0.3448297679,
0.140024662,
-0.4751750529,
-0.2839523554,
-0.4818363488,
-0.2767221034,
0.3617750108,
0.6418836117,
0.060500171,
0.4778123498,
-0.704731226,
0.2135557085,
0.2220246941,
0.5550348163,
0.2145721614,
-0.5231190324,
-0.5819662213,
-0.2032168657,
-0.1322413087,
-0.5853155255,
0.5005230308,
0.1045799032,
0.4588476419,
0.3761564195,
-0.0165500231,
0.7221673131,
-0.557703793,
0.6163013577,
0.029771423,
-0.7245198488,
0.4412484169,
-0.5391257405,
0.7310022712,
0.4941589236,
0.0515446775,
-0.421533972,
-0.4859674871,
-0.3042443693,
-0.9492256641,
0.5910772085,
-0.0878150314,
0.4319910705,
-0.1483911425,
0.7098193169,
-0.1688708961,
0.1297719777,
-0.6502816677,
-0.0936161354,
0.1645640284,
-0.2692955136,
-0.2431289107,
-0.739880383,
0.0126624145,
-0.0776578635,
0.6750864983,
-0.2713228464,
-0.0703840256,
0.1394913793,
-0.0932542682,
-0.1077674851,
0.4799534678,
0.4913339317,
0.8028364182,
-0.2198109478,
0.1928073019,
0.417468369,
-0.3798076808,
-0.0573993176,
0.1011159644,
-0.087168552,
-0.3082233071,
0.2973768711,
0.5581379533,
0.309943676,
-0.7941703796,
0.2917410731,
-0.0264133308,
0.0694589466,
-0.6067024469,
0.2325612754,
0.4378308654,
0.4082052112,
0.4669233561,
-0.5248436332,
-0.0704419911,
-0.4354214966,
0.2286918759,
0.2498007715,
-0.3234919608,
-0.0717283115,
0.4500802457,
0.1776159108,
-0.2100862265,
0.5294252634,
0.0830500945,
-0.4165585637,
0.1925501078,
0.9300786257,
0.5119405389,
-0.5412883162,
0.0606078319,
0.1084820852,
0.2875965834,
-0.2514106631,
0.2976544797,
-0.2593954206,
-0.5615848899,
-0.5058797598,
-0.5584338903,
-0.1868467182,
0.4973182082,
-0.5804573894,
0.0321084447,
-0.5296792984,
-0.0907324776,
-0.5525057912,
0.2065913379,
-0.3463029861,
0.2334388196,
0.0920596123,
1.0495140553,
-0.5243384242,
1.2403104305,
0.2142773271,
-0.2723870277,
-0.629196465,
-0.2894649804,
-0.2773037851,
-0.5576403737,
0.3264751434,
0.1522677988,
-0.3427332938,
-0.0539166443,
-0.5026071072,
-0.9847248793,
1.201970458,
0.2629221082,
-0.884955585,
-0.0950973332,
0.2000790238,
0.7665784359,
-0.6104717851,
0.0888017938,
0.5192609429,
0.1896467358,
0.2450830489,
-0.771637857,
0.0548687167,
-0.0459531695,
0.2079809457,
0.2436586469,
-0.8353413343,
0.3990359306,
-0.2377796918,
-0.0283154305,
0.3081262112,
1.1611310244,
0.2987579405,
0.2029789835,
0.2373929471,
0.3306628764,
0.5654405355,
0.4448007941,
0.6951926351,
-0.4639509916,
0.1526531875,
1.8091264963,
-0.6105445623,
1.0703451633,
0.4644745886,
0.313357383,
0.3294440508,
0.2725358009,
0.077592738,
0.2662867904,
0.3699650466,
-0.2125569731,
-0.5358095765,
0.0338628218,
-0.3051032424,
0.5652196407,
0.5093670487,
-0.5895107985,
-0.1183325723,
0.1152940542,
0.1912357807,
0.2089456171,
-0.2663698792,
0.8681726456,
0.2139682323,
-0.3557731211,
0.224856928,
0.0269812662,
0.4005616903,
-0.8352710605,
-0.0572834313,
-0.2763115168,
0.385637939,
0.0652766973,
-0.6580203772,
-0.0264150035,
-0.1970657408,
-0.2557885051,
-0.3680955172,
0.862832129,
-0.8235366344,
-0.3688341677,
0.6770533919,
0.5081644058,
0.1043975502,
0.0120909857,
-0.5288011432,
0.3358926177,
-0.2276791781,
-0.5661044121,
0.3497074246,
0.4302648902,
-0.2736077309,
0.9705770016,
0.395908922,
0.3478571475,
-0.2176347524,
0.0841385052,
0.977883637,
-1.089184165,
-0.6238674521,
-0.8982458115,
0.0077360584,
-0.1020058841,
-0.1205129623,
0.7778909802,
0.860470593,
0.6563251019,
0.1496117711,
0.6994637251,
0.3978150189,
0.6461191773,
-0.4874824882,
0.9238997698,
-0.2599817216,
0.3178842366,
0.014555824,
-0.7831459045,
-0.3094589114,
0.5045945644,
-0.2504133582,
0.1966905892,
0.4936411679,
0.7913072109,
0.1018762663,
-0.091520153,
0.4876162112,
0.5470614433,
0.3763763309,
0.5446607471,
0.8247764707,
0.0442769974,
0.478618443,
0.1295918226,
-0.1557274461,
-0.2574849427,
-0.9477900863,
-1.2105611563,
-0.4584005177,
-0.1364713609,
-0.3633633554,
0.0932572111,
0.9871335626,
0.5532210469,
-0.7097679377,
-0.5538178682,
0.2616369426,
-0.0915073678,
0.215579316,
-0.1456312388,
0.4116577804,
-0.3621632159,
-0.382122606,
0.5200246572,
0.7430648804,
0.1888308376,
-0.5908025503,
-0.2215871215,
-0.1865317225,
0.2982749641,
0.6848151088,
0.4395073652,
-0.5895303488,
-0.3597538173,
-0.1023524478,
-0.3393107355,
0.0881285891,
0.719843924,
-0.7953580618,
0.6446392536,
0.0844731927,
0.6051436663,
0.7528269887,
-0.2095653564,
0.6544544697,
-0.2849982381,
0.027362559,
0.2668264806,
0.3443625867,
0.3446487188,
-0.4045339227,
0.1759162247,
-0.2281547189,
-0.6748983264,
-0.5097661614,
0.1258526444,
-1.0566099882,
-0.3663550317,
1.3045333624,
-0.0480563678,
-0.3694678843,
-0.0504516475,
-0.3701882362,
0.190914467,
-0.5690948963,
0.9827144742,
0.8276002407,
-0.2229046077,
-0.2326912582,
-0.3420381248,
0.3840921819,
0.3568660617,
-0.7191349268,
0.3642529249,
0.7314688563,
0.2920759022,
0.0055532688,
0.9686081409,
-0.1812900007,
-0.0324299186,
-0.6089023948,
0.2987335026,
-0.2760784924,
-0.5893484354,
-0.4936372042,
0.1490910798,
-0.0731837973,
0.1504239291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13337v2 | Nominal Topology for Data Languages | 2023-04-26T07:11:44 | 2023-05-10T06:50:37 | Fabian Birkmann, Stefan Milius, Henning Urbat | cs.CL | cs.CL, F.4.3 | We propose a novel topological perspective on data languages recognizable by
orbit-finite nominal monoids. For this purpose, we introduce pro-orbit-finite
nominal topological spaces. Assuming globally bounded support sizes, they
coincide with nominal Stone spaces and are shown to be dually equivalent to a
subcategory of nominal boolean algebras. Recognizable data languages are
characterized as topologically clopen sets of pro-orbit-finite words. In
addition, we explore the expressive power of pro-orbit-finite equations by
establishing a nominal version of Reiterman's pseudovariety theorem. | [
-0.4038212299,
-0.6060518622,
0.6937333941,
-0.3382171094,
-0.3006460071,
0.4736389816,
-0.1871520281,
-0.25991413,
0.5713762045,
0.5166559815,
-0.4990571141,
-0.4825928807,
-0.0240656119,
0.1398345828,
-0.3315223455,
0.7878600955,
-0.108754836,
-0.3015078008,
-0.4936225414,
-0.5161488056,
-0.073686108,
-0.7643595338,
-0.0859692618,
0.2194497585,
0.4410977662,
0.7623414397,
1.2452899218,
0.4704774916,
0.6936644316,
0.4914351106,
0.1696668118,
0.1284234077,
-0.1011060551,
-0.2460055649,
0.0186000746,
-0.3198114038,
-0.5224292278,
0.1538381428,
1.2776857615,
1.0993241072,
-0.1875972003,
0.1017760932,
-0.2261252701,
0.9053396583,
0.0077340803,
0.3348525465,
-0.3524642885,
-0.1008474156,
-0.7276506424,
0.129492864,
-0.0053200996,
-0.891054213,
0.0321552977,
-1.0902619362,
0.1064464003,
0.4733348489,
0.6419994831,
0.1697488427,
-0.2504300475,
-0.3046816289,
-1.0182828903,
0.4993480742,
-0.3492988348,
0.6741655469,
0.2678286433,
0.7266309261,
-0.3400925994,
-0.6833840609,
-0.8179641366,
-0.0334898531,
-0.6423521042,
0.0201433711,
-0.0516021401,
0.3554158211,
0.1599302441,
0.9589464068,
-0.9046082497,
-0.4385017753,
-0.5014083982,
-0.0545876473,
0.5975765586,
0.0229306072,
0.284935534,
-0.0550514311,
-0.0741536543,
0.3293409348,
-0.8420585394,
-0.1791207343,
0.5048745275,
0.4025838077,
-0.2252980471,
0.3766320944,
0.0076748561,
0.8078847528,
-0.0849588215,
0.0834650844,
0.1065755263,
-0.4609664381,
-0.1369594783,
-0.2687177062,
0.3951051533,
-0.4888765812,
0.5923784971,
-0.4581460655,
-0.028930787,
0.1992512494,
0.3282217979,
-0.157491222,
-0.6006882191,
0.2371267676,
-0.4048358798,
-0.0122600654,
0.1946186572,
-0.6030096412,
-0.2947216928,
-0.5004840493,
0.2463480234,
-0.3496252894,
-0.5972306132,
0.4301054776,
0.3928121328,
0.0337239951,
-0.1313615739,
-0.6343206763,
0.9981175065,
0.8018701077,
0.6953456998,
0.2294710129,
0.180944398,
-0.0718069598,
-0.0671174899,
-0.7475749254,
0.6600644588,
-0.6980632544,
-0.2745110393,
0.1590215117,
-0.1823625714,
-0.0898185894,
-0.830455184,
0.4951182306,
-0.6558790207,
0.3695460856,
-0.3734516203,
-0.7011423707,
-0.1872052848,
0.0090630725,
-0.5272666216,
0.9467077851,
0.4454491138,
-0.8219910264,
0.3166746795,
-0.4224223197,
-0.2272675037,
0.5540465117,
-0.4948371053,
-0.2137476206,
0.189337492,
-0.780482769,
-0.1055081189,
-0.181147486,
0.2734523416,
-0.2489150912,
-0.1869296879,
-0.1041178256,
0.3238880336,
0.3350640833,
0.3667398095,
0.2177648693,
0.1271492541,
-0.8249844313,
0.0105247321,
0.0271754246,
-0.165809691,
-0.8319364786,
0.2554849982,
-0.2092146873,
-0.0004807863,
0.1970242262,
-0.716278553,
0.7863963246,
-0.4634039998,
0.091065675,
0.7328674197,
-0.4258361757,
0.611539185,
-0.1925951242,
0.5738527775,
-0.1028383523,
0.0872277245,
0.4480160475,
-0.3393919766,
-0.7638782859,
-0.6385117173,
0.2646071911,
0.3850914538,
-1.0386052132,
0.476562798,
-0.4776495993,
-0.4324044883,
0.0504821502,
-0.2431309223,
0.3601643145,
0.4066792727,
0.1642391086,
-0.1500538439,
-0.6803138852,
-1.095489502,
0.015571747,
-0.7016767263,
0.4297123551,
0.7615544796,
0.5089068413,
0.0498180166,
1.057367444,
-0.5718684793,
-0.3221572936,
0.0694729239,
0.1652953625,
0.7897670865,
0.4849823713,
0.6688607335,
-0.8657637239,
-0.4887237549,
-0.1484044939,
-0.8250942826,
0.0195635166,
-0.1035206839,
-0.1769911796,
-0.1850567311,
0.3306531012,
-0.6715640426,
0.1153004616,
0.348669678,
-0.7051462531,
0.7545401454,
-0.1107965857,
-0.0402324721,
-0.736949861,
0.1097118407,
-0.590842545,
-0.6712704301,
-0.9288653135,
0.0061439658,
-0.2770394981,
-0.0287243798,
-0.2117073387,
0.8026348948,
-0.5444133282,
-0.6744308472,
-0.0432868339,
-0.0156825576,
-0.7330506444,
0.1389385462,
0.4268350005,
0.8302313089,
0.9655745029,
-0.6708112955,
0.2534332871,
0.5018203855,
-0.3030644655,
0.5578914881,
-0.4148220122,
-0.0697313249,
-0.0808701292,
0.2349665463,
-1.0564194918,
-0.1761647761,
0.1868214309,
-0.3758909404,
0.4292680323,
-0.2407708913,
-0.658485949,
-0.4428990185,
-0.2302445322,
0.8993264437,
0.4323521852,
-0.3594794273,
0.1592490226,
0.4804500937,
-0.0637348443,
-0.2691390514,
-0.1918286383,
-0.0662682503,
-0.3615875244,
-0.6000234485,
0.2101163268,
-0.0967607647,
-0.5397484303,
0.1644831598,
-0.2448826879,
-0.2173019648,
-0.0725592077,
0.0812969729,
0.2794151008,
-0.2564809024,
0.1856748313,
-0.3049599528,
-0.3290790319,
-0.3707535863,
-0.9155396819,
0.4719060063,
-0.6243823171,
-0.0394639298,
-0.1452341974,
0.2401816994,
0.5751817822,
0.1622314751,
0.7435139418,
0.0578104146,
-0.7541649342,
0.2240783572,
0.0206133313,
-0.0578937009,
-0.558188498,
-0.1694758236,
-0.4710311294,
-1.0338513851,
0.5203304291,
-0.1940149218,
0.1540533453,
0.2083985358,
0.1966187805,
-0.4195333421,
0.4235425591,
0.7254437208,
-0.0789555088,
0.3272701204,
-0.3659524322,
0.4315415025,
-0.6447646022,
0.078216292,
-0.5409733653,
-0.1675005853,
-0.8812602162,
-0.4029791057,
0.6436171532,
0.3873494267,
-0.506911993,
0.5059834719,
-0.221337378,
0.3305258155,
0.3406465054,
-0.5926924944,
-0.0450828634,
0.0640477464,
-0.293641746,
-0.218208164,
-0.6797010303,
-0.7060313821,
0.5583637357,
0.1086896062,
0.5846773386,
0.5074634552,
0.7130197883,
0.5038895011,
0.1098221764,
-0.4697965682,
0.4283708632,
-0.6822331548,
-0.8286498189,
-0.0214761198,
-0.383584559,
-0.7529210448,
-0.1992293447,
0.0180668607,
-1.0764154196,
0.5784137249,
0.2496613115,
-0.1308188885,
0.5035127401,
-0.2943465412,
0.7198547125,
-0.0700273216,
-0.088176623,
-0.093050614,
-0.5513529181,
0.3445317447,
0.1066941246,
0.6789183617,
0.0707928613,
0.1244348139,
0.7208727598,
-0.5538327694,
0.6136496067,
-0.3013194799,
0.1275328696,
0.439041853,
0.6596518755,
0.2587730289,
0.2300831676,
0.2501297891,
0.3149186969,
0.2642057538,
-0.4056868553,
-0.4383988082,
0.397633791,
-0.5613997579,
-0.4218314886,
-0.6769693494,
-0.3769286275,
-0.4542319775,
0.4557936788,
-0.0466600507,
0.7846933603,
-0.1051325873,
0.1252014786,
0.6642330289,
-0.2625707686,
-0.0050445786,
0.5007852316,
-0.5484258533,
-0.1839303821,
0.9867989421,
0.1928812265,
0.2037988156,
0.4564767182,
0.0433348604,
-0.5704493523,
-0.3468837142,
-0.440410167,
0.5157185793,
-0.2959743738,
-0.1531340331,
-0.2977716029,
-0.2004478276,
-0.1447913945,
-0.4046265483,
-0.4996211529,
-1.0806607008,
0.1860997379,
-0.1800475717,
0.3495684862,
0.7646104097,
-0.5816763639,
0.3388880491,
-0.671865344,
0.5399202704,
0.117673263,
0.6758704782,
-0.6468997598,
-0.3125002384,
-0.0883498713,
-0.3812019527,
0.3004069328,
-0.6828709245,
-0.0114791561,
0.5685218573,
0.629889667,
0.4231818318,
0.0259867087,
0.5054909587,
-0.6566191316,
0.7636684179,
0.0045154821,
-0.8995514512,
0.1956827492,
-0.7988806963,
-0.205606997,
0.41128093,
0.5566019416,
-0.8622349501,
-0.3901797533,
-0.6976071596,
-0.4711320698,
0.7711493373,
0.5696578026,
-0.1042800173,
-0.1211653128,
0.852920711,
0.0730637312,
0.521556437,
-0.4145390391,
-0.8355746269,
-0.2746689916,
-0.3927592635,
-0.0003073292,
-0.3675221205,
-0.1751967072,
-0.1200597137,
0.3008777201,
-0.1830262989,
0.7875047326,
0.1069139168,
0.2350381017,
0.0916212723,
0.2729993761,
0.4134207964,
0.7311654091,
-0.257999599,
0.6618955731,
-0.2270798981,
-0.4772582054,
0.1842961907,
-0.0449598171,
-0.1070967093,
-0.0256011728,
0.5297403336,
0.2049742639,
-0.1137501672,
-0.0763419643,
0.035836082,
-0.0813603848,
0.0879871398,
-0.5084918737,
-0.2163722515,
-0.0897303149,
-0.0178690832,
-0.0157575477,
-0.0971440151,
0.2984635532,
-0.913594842,
0.4053426981,
0.5839604735,
-0.4608685374,
-0.9017654061,
0.5124510527,
-0.1943941265,
-0.1448455453,
0.575235486,
-0.4624426365,
-0.9076909423,
0.4623329937,
0.4944300354,
0.7763620019,
-0.0760232136,
0.3767084181,
0.5822364688,
0.3461787105,
0.3634834588,
0.7615362406,
-0.1918235868,
-0.9623984694,
0.4079558849,
-0.7902493477,
-0.1329112202,
-0.2823128402,
-0.3485488296,
0.0764477029,
-0.8070431948,
0.0527269319,
0.0691685602,
0.0624276623,
-0.2998716533,
0.2086254209,
0.3972912133,
0.9366242886,
-0.7147354484,
0.9509550929,
1.092725873,
-0.184191376,
-0.4438942373,
-0.260565877,
0.3496474028,
-0.3480800986,
0.6129238009,
-0.3233371675,
-0.2907077074,
-0.1164222956,
-0.3053448498,
-1.1907150745,
0.6566190124,
0.1904628426,
-0.3750234842,
0.2055745125,
0.4570239186,
0.8387203813,
-0.2638751566,
0.0113757867,
0.4250661731,
0.7134833932,
-0.0544740371,
-0.7768447399,
-0.2024638355,
-0.1630695164,
-0.2200934738,
0.6287866831,
-0.7616770267,
0.8268853426,
0.2887001336,
-0.8204743266,
0.2604119778,
0.6608124971,
0.0655003637,
-0.0373002626,
0.6140338778,
0.4986906946,
0.9205240011,
-0.4028692245,
1.1218150854,
-0.4236020446,
0.4690967202,
0.7735538483,
-0.178503722,
0.2533918321,
0.1669696271,
-0.5716326833,
0.5301917195,
0.604169786,
0.5891751647,
0.5418958664,
0.3708704412,
-0.3256415129,
-0.4324777722,
-0.1297648251,
-0.2597595155,
0.1631799638,
0.6557269692,
0.3684782386,
-0.0659369752,
-0.5086558461,
0.0239584092,
0.1850340813,
-0.0831229314,
0.5977647901,
0.1397170126,
-0.1862961352,
0.613163352,
-0.1377233863,
0.2287665009,
-0.5911152363,
-0.0503360219,
-0.4103405178,
0.0152437268,
-0.4676889181,
-0.8339470625,
0.901802063,
-0.1359545588,
-0.0814907923,
-0.1008835062,
0.5349668264,
-0.2619020641,
-0.6185832024,
0.130192861,
0.3588584065,
0.4086585641,
0.4956607521,
-0.4417135417,
-0.540884316,
-0.4310680032,
0.0204836726,
-0.1206318811,
0.2333340794,
-0.4183512032,
0.4876296818,
0.4340747595,
0.2151708007,
0.3089996874,
-0.3481151164,
0.8845145106,
-0.4933327138,
-0.4556368291,
-0.2565961182,
0.1202316582,
0.2410187721,
-0.1645418108,
0.5243311524,
0.7806733251,
0.669378221,
-0.0270961989,
0.5217534304,
-0.6349895,
0.7402566671,
-0.4848004878,
0.4259223044,
-0.671167016,
0.0394517891,
-0.3560464382,
-1.0012197495,
-0.5297435522,
0.6044395566,
-0.3525860012,
-0.1209341586,
0.7265805602,
0.5820992589,
-0.491448462,
-0.1714087278,
0.4356195033,
0.456035167,
0.2160256952,
0.4042565823,
1.0394330025,
-0.2018232048,
-0.0607335605,
-0.1541308165,
-0.4449646473,
0.2253377289,
-0.4004924893,
-0.4148206711,
-1.0219813585,
-0.294147253,
-0.0439483114,
-0.0087729376,
0.5819215775,
0.9213473797,
-0.841463685,
-0.286803335,
-0.2343901098,
0.3272049427,
0.0255660582,
-0.2582214475,
0.5170413852,
-0.0777798444,
-0.4354704618,
0.3760226369,
0.5362166762,
-0.2409837842,
-0.0414168201,
-0.0605166443,
-0.1993782073,
0.4418235421,
0.2238496393,
0.6790949702,
-0.2296728045,
-0.718409121,
-0.0947036743,
0.0848526135,
0.1192954332,
1.2477498055,
-0.764667213,
0.4218333364,
0.6531400084,
0.2289884537,
0.0918338746,
0.1528529674,
0.2870162427,
-0.9025871158,
0.4281381369,
0.1325817108,
0.6411092877,
0.1570100039,
-0.4128851295,
0.7587527037,
0.5633487701,
-0.4422127604,
-0.4852631092,
0.7713520527,
-0.823481977,
-0.0291224867,
0.8838860989,
-0.3478365242,
0.0797178671,
-0.4450179935,
0.108377628,
0.0582690649,
0.1625046432,
0.5406332016,
0.5697027445,
-0.2599065304,
0.1315350085,
-0.4141242802,
0.9537355304,
0.1006329954,
-0.8716354966,
0.236608237,
0.6944002509,
-0.0291826855,
0.5742427707,
0.9908176064,
-0.5205488205,
0.1444593221,
-0.1152182296,
-0.1857399344,
0.1853022426,
-0.9649892449,
-0.1188010946,
-0.4135777056,
0.106291689,
-0.1649631858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13301v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13301v2 | Prompting GPT-3.5 for Text-to-SQL with De-semanticization and Skeleton Retrieval | 2023-04-26T06:02:01 | 2023-08-31T15:24:36 | Chunxi Guo, Zhiliang Tian, Jintao Tang, Pancheng Wang, Zhihua Wen, Kang Yang, Ting Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text-to-SQL is a task that converts a natural language question into a
structured query language (SQL) to retrieve information from a database. Large
language models (LLMs) work well in natural language generation tasks, but they
are not specifically pre-trained to understand the syntax and semantics of SQL
commands. In this paper, we propose an LLM-based framework for Text-to-SQL
which retrieves helpful demonstration examples to prompt LLMs. However,
questions with different database schemes can vary widely, even if the
intentions behind them are similar and the corresponding SQL queries exhibit
similarities. Consequently, it becomes crucial to identify the appropriate SQL
demonstrations that align with our requirements. We design a de-semanticization
mechanism that extracts question skeletons, allowing us to retrieve similar
examples based on their structural similarity. We also model the relationships
between question tokens and database schema items (i.e., tables and columns) to
filter out scheme-related information. Our framework adapts the range of the
database schema in prompts to balance length and valuable information. A
fallback mechanism allows for a more detailed schema to be provided if the
generated SQL query fails. Ours outperforms state-of-the-art models and
demonstrates strong generalization ability on three cross-domain Text-to-SQL
benchmarks. | [
-0.2680115402,
-1.083345294,
0.8356972933,
0.1651209146,
-0.6391820908,
-0.3035794497,
-0.1303371936,
-0.2696199715,
0.1025883928,
0.6034319401,
-0.7848377824,
-0.7583779693,
-0.2634412348,
0.4613928497,
-0.6336079836,
1.1841832399,
-0.0380703509,
0.0548556894,
-0.3306649923,
0.1623287052,
-0.6453266144,
-0.372099191,
-0.5638972521,
-0.2003424913,
0.4506462216,
0.2160340399,
0.4040417969,
0.5085536242,
0.1352271885,
0.147588253,
-0.0705616474,
-0.1162149236,
-0.3259493113,
0.4721013606,
-0.3611045182,
-0.551423192,
-0.3969462514,
-0.2853901386,
0.5584436059,
0.7224960327,
-0.1560790688,
-0.1036845669,
0.0988740698,
0.5237115026,
-0.3232870102,
0.2326599658,
-1.0398176908,
-0.2114594281,
0.0056720828,
-0.2508695424,
-0.4316782951,
-0.4444046021,
0.0974491388,
-0.5484924912,
0.4001202285,
0.0266149286,
0.729716301,
0.0764155015,
-0.5964333415,
-0.4542192221,
-0.4202457666,
0.2986086011,
-0.5922346711,
0.2967393994,
0.4311115742,
0.402042836,
-0.2732816935,
-0.8159841895,
-0.6728888154,
-0.4845176935,
-0.368416369,
-0.0840265155,
0.1738402843,
0.0624153279,
0.3200751543,
0.2864067554,
-0.8728932142,
-0.0806975067,
-0.0469508618,
-0.1129980311,
0.3503209054,
0.1855514199,
0.3018139601,
-0.3798389435,
-0.5090414882,
0.0392214134,
-1.1064736843,
-0.3742496371,
0.1925041974,
0.5457239747,
0.0929995552,
0.8176292181,
-0.4922193885,
0.9595904946,
0.0860436037,
0.4077129066,
-0.203624472,
-0.4581764042,
-0.1994196475,
0.1195463762,
0.661190033,
0.469242394,
0.2290681005,
-0.3477447629,
-0.2206864506,
0.0516297519,
0.1031703651,
-0.8932120204,
-0.192312479,
0.3382371962,
-0.3488309681,
-0.135318473,
-0.1555000842,
-0.8221721649,
-0.5657019019,
-0.2689138949,
0.5825282931,
-0.3775169253,
-0.3425969779,
0.1744323671,
-0.3130837679,
0.6484027505,
0.4199346602,
-1.1714277267,
0.2917790413,
0.6333127618,
0.6364669204,
-0.4346936941,
0.0530010983,
-0.4165932536,
0.6358314753,
-0.2544157803,
0.8259344697,
-0.506936729,
-0.6672441959,
0.1225271001,
0.2409360111,
-0.1225645542,
-0.4290161729,
0.2843821943,
-0.5194815397,
0.588375628,
-0.4054234922,
-0.6638269424,
0.0901027694,
0.6148974895,
-0.5648700595,
1.1961160898,
0.1122713536,
-0.8129072189,
0.6329548359,
-0.6165795922,
-0.4187375009,
0.2282022387,
-0.624792397,
-0.2000604123,
0.0108146565,
0.3245749772,
0.6179170012,
-0.5512526631,
0.3536808789,
-0.2500964999,
-0.39707762,
-0.2357928306,
-0.1795401424,
0.5445840955,
-0.0271436144,
-0.3536853194,
0.0544671379,
-0.8411945105,
0.1796000749,
0.3752673864,
-0.3924456239,
-0.3258551359,
-0.0304280575,
-0.1828366667,
0.0930428058,
0.1794095337,
-0.2412198782,
0.3799451888,
-0.7261430621,
0.5038291216,
0.4594177306,
0.3648028076,
0.3392229676,
-0.0986790061,
0.4746929705,
-0.1456627697,
-0.2450596541,
-0.2819201648,
-0.4385205209,
-0.449791491,
-0.0947736651,
0.0897183418,
0.6638175249,
-0.9649204612,
0.2944258153,
-0.3409500122,
-0.1084599197,
0.0359795243,
-0.1380526572,
0.0890695229,
0.5902823806,
0.531383276,
-0.0324749984,
-0.3928077817,
-0.7585327029,
-0.5239768028,
-0.4311262965,
-0.2873953879,
0.2757788002,
0.5768740773,
0.1889614761,
1.2410796881,
-0.5235309601,
-0.226121515,
-0.4148429334,
0.0469450839,
0.2636097372,
0.5367898345,
0.5144646168,
-0.7394266725,
-0.3396688402,
0.01657423,
-0.5935028195,
0.068161428,
-0.0762540624,
-0.1734894514,
0.2861145437,
0.6005558372,
-0.9844213128,
0.3466968238,
0.0021951064,
-0.2753210068,
0.4762440026,
-0.0667280778,
0.140875265,
-1.5680174828,
0.0147583038,
-0.3307193816,
-0.0489619821,
-0.5031741261,
-0.1287196279,
0.0344478153,
-0.2450387627,
-0.3319825232,
0.7090905309,
-0.4892579615,
-0.0504256077,
0.0679730996,
0.3485925198,
0.0202593729,
0.2677449286,
0.2500537932,
0.8077660203,
0.5732616782,
-0.8686466813,
0.4043553174,
0.4363825023,
-0.0537959002,
0.9528972507,
-0.9083001614,
0.2866690159,
-0.1841902882,
0.4096777141,
-1.3277564049,
-0.526324451,
0.3664033413,
-0.4366369843,
0.3292785287,
-0.6992890239,
-0.5391058922,
-0.2874793708,
-0.405269593,
0.0421720855,
0.3394811749,
-0.4682650864,
0.6891748905,
-0.0330072269,
-0.3794219494,
-0.6176797748,
-0.7911260128,
0.282241255,
-0.3031637669,
-0.5953028202,
0.4599014819,
0.0878625363,
0.0639219955,
-0.1572286189,
-0.1804377288,
-0.3008464575,
-0.1040614471,
-0.0638168231,
0.3817927837,
-0.3372868299,
0.5175337195,
0.4627010524,
0.1427768916,
0.3103345037,
-0.6474978924,
0.5665764809,
0.1891013384,
-0.4304785132,
-0.1667299718,
0.5343607664,
0.1323871613,
-0.0654526055,
0.6032629013,
0.4214273989,
-0.4337668419,
-0.144439429,
-0.5158106089,
-0.5512923598,
-0.4444850385,
0.4442732334,
-0.5992812514,
-0.9138824344,
0.3483397365,
-0.1959858537,
0.043543268,
0.4851458967,
0.6205015779,
0.0606583171,
1.1289414167,
0.4300071895,
0.2232176363,
0.3202553988,
-0.0085666422,
-0.0688494667,
-0.349652946,
-0.2548714578,
-0.7970020175,
0.2291649878,
-0.3460994065,
-0.3926740587,
0.0976057574,
0.0941304117,
-0.1449254155,
0.4421511889,
-0.5497173667,
0.5855542421,
-0.0034099,
-0.0626578107,
0.3911583424,
0.1973863244,
-0.3235286772,
0.1326987147,
-0.4971012473,
-0.5426819921,
0.8624033928,
-0.0896461606,
0.873232007,
0.0897666439,
0.9114781022,
0.2047046572,
0.1327920854,
-0.6099580526,
0.7643352151,
0.1548804492,
-0.7899880409,
-0.1875671297,
-0.3883835375,
-0.9280098677,
0.1731342673,
-0.0497754142,
-0.6839932799,
0.0398202054,
0.3266400993,
-0.006672814,
-0.0012879334,
-0.7410739064,
1.0526403189,
-0.0228922553,
-0.3705477417,
-0.0344342329,
-0.7326712608,
0.202711165,
0.1372128427,
-0.1378063858,
-0.063542217,
-0.3074609339,
0.4172615707,
-0.1860529631,
0.9058985114,
-0.4359853268,
-0.4198144972,
0.2485766411,
0.1792051941,
0.8657345772,
0.3577646613,
-0.2254569232,
-0.4796880782,
0.1378166527,
-0.1363312751,
-0.7484019995,
0.7187358141,
-0.0619711652,
-0.7507677674,
-0.0472219028,
-0.3302104175,
-0.5388266444,
0.240694508,
0.2045947611,
0.4340519905,
-0.3066305518,
0.0881132707,
0.7477194667,
-0.1104047075,
0.2436811179,
0.3800306618,
-0.3097817898,
-0.0995039344,
0.8001345396,
-0.2182341814,
0.3170572221,
0.5960332155,
0.0080053415,
-0.969424963,
-0.652769506,
-0.9233078361,
0.2307825536,
-0.822928071,
-0.2794029117,
-0.7378908396,
0.2227697968,
-0.4711834192,
0.049480211,
0.2180160582,
-0.7337830663,
-0.4117887914,
-0.2182354927,
0.6982483864,
0.652991116,
0.582008779,
0.1366499066,
-0.718531847,
0.1609824151,
0.3212997317,
0.3724654615,
-0.2873645425,
-0.423161,
0.1724075526,
-0.1613897532,
-0.0762274191,
-1.2232223749,
-0.0320105515,
0.3031443059,
0.5609753728,
-0.0425862297,
0.2359695733,
0.4819673598,
-0.5520855188,
0.9419166446,
0.0848219022,
-0.7964986563,
1.0085468292,
-0.665453136,
0.0132770706,
0.5814669728,
0.5353114605,
-0.3339588642,
-0.3510279059,
-0.3290998936,
-0.9301589727,
0.6222481132,
0.1247984692,
0.3375719786,
-0.4626347125,
0.6552670002,
0.1822467893,
0.2843905985,
-0.8102513552,
0.0262886565,
-0.2120165974,
-0.2658390999,
0.4405317903,
-0.1027547345,
-0.1102798432,
0.1116660684,
0.3863223195,
-0.6179568172,
0.2046673745,
0.3089122772,
-0.2564401329,
0.2724773586,
0.6468968987,
0.3498255908,
0.6907151341,
-0.1362812966,
-0.015661668,
0.5160167217,
-0.3623060584,
0.0804486796,
0.2465680093,
-0.1212200522,
-0.0218161717,
-0.059111733,
0.630366981,
0.0152183715,
-0.5093798637,
0.5250367522,
-0.1011402681,
-0.3888318241,
0.0935789123,
-0.0385428146,
0.256236583,
-0.0770052746,
0.3519999981,
-0.5352084041,
0.2351879478,
-0.4419687688,
0.3084595203,
0.6314157248,
-0.4518378973,
-0.1318109185,
0.7296729684,
0.2311266661,
-0.0494158976,
0.4818961322,
-0.1188901439,
-0.2812372446,
0.4163899422,
0.7244343758,
0.7133100629,
0.0108423335,
0.1982533485,
0.2752965391,
0.2105697691,
-0.1169947386,
0.6286116242,
-0.3383123875,
-0.2238251269,
-0.5096655488,
-0.403254956,
-0.2410199642,
-0.0079464242,
-0.5995714068,
0.5271418095,
-0.2960394025,
-0.0495045967,
-0.2721731961,
-0.2378526032,
-0.2565262318,
0.2257395834,
-0.2592222691,
1.0474985838,
-0.7226375341,
0.8583174944,
0.7334150672,
-0.4944735765,
-0.8044504523,
0.0263472814,
-0.1853616089,
-0.6551454663,
0.5190475583,
0.1443100572,
-0.0194397867,
0.2020224482,
-0.5175392032,
-0.3912231922,
1.1796412468,
0.5906972289,
-0.3995878398,
-0.4308332205,
0.3197134733,
0.4127677977,
-0.365632683,
0.1598044187,
0.6277306676,
0.3797568977,
0.2782621682,
-0.6585500836,
0.4650346339,
0.0872517228,
0.072341606,
0.3451271355,
-0.0129428841,
0.6105052829,
-0.2572207749,
-0.2139332741,
0.25174582,
0.5727502108,
0.3527944386,
0.2067308277,
0.6327171326,
0.1773242056,
0.555526495,
-0.1769831628,
1.0925450325,
-0.1903847307,
0.1608901173,
1.022690773,
-0.6179397702,
0.8246003985,
0.6523684859,
-0.1446392387,
0.529577136,
0.637560606,
0.1223121807,
0.4159771204,
0.4155149758,
-0.3683794141,
-0.2068400979,
-0.0702333003,
-0.6943442225,
0.0596897528,
0.5664131641,
-0.3883135617,
-0.5501187444,
-0.1978121996,
-0.1953980476,
0.0112814736,
-0.1366074979,
0.9619199634,
-0.0581280664,
-0.7029867768,
0.5929587483,
-0.1845938861,
0.3543913364,
-0.9008405805,
-0.3162802458,
-0.2958158255,
-0.2252958119,
-0.1564846188,
-0.7888302207,
0.3593517244,
-0.0776701272,
-0.1959111989,
-0.1046693474,
0.9768365026,
-0.6544985771,
-0.0684755817,
0.119619675,
0.6653056145,
0.3062995076,
-0.2669947445,
-0.708782196,
-0.1338499635,
-0.0539851487,
-0.1540665478,
0.5104165673,
0.6585280299,
-0.3069397509,
0.4182864428,
0.5653079152,
-0.0309858546,
-0.0858063027,
0.4226180017,
1.0312387943,
-0.6630240679,
-0.5053613186,
-0.9023060799,
0.2774695754,
-0.212118417,
-0.1185224056,
0.5898723602,
0.5606718659,
0.4878985286,
-0.2314283997,
0.5846402049,
-0.1647791862,
0.6245126724,
-0.8338544965,
0.7166162133,
-0.5301405787,
0.535502553,
-0.3062972724,
-1.0965316296,
-0.2073887587,
0.4528532922,
-0.0856970996,
0.2446953058,
0.7122839093,
1.0492260456,
0.2002636939,
0.1796065718,
0.1069644615,
-0.0177413505,
0.3737436831,
0.4606385231,
0.9368479848,
-0.2069731206,
1.0269912481,
0.4054247737,
0.0398387834,
0.0371354669,
-1.1038073301,
-0.9891378284,
-0.6270505786,
-0.1800258309,
-0.4000946283,
0.3880995214,
0.9097682834,
0.5639463067,
-0.6314482689,
-0.01957893,
-0.3854369521,
0.1773122251,
0.1222900376,
-0.2565346658,
0.502464056,
-0.4118737578,
-0.526607573,
0.4734419286,
0.2317434847,
0.3567508161,
-0.1364398599,
0.1945010275,
-0.2237785608,
-0.0087589454,
0.5024853945,
0.0716635063,
-0.6137770414,
-0.2997675836,
0.0219795387,
-0.1367760003,
-0.081261389,
1.0087931156,
-1.0053141117,
0.0129095651,
0.5037617683,
0.8003286719,
0.5433003306,
-0.0809301883,
0.7979661226,
-1.1137571335,
-0.0499892458,
0.3492870033,
0.0850337222,
0.3705430031,
-0.5403498411,
0.5940305591,
0.2293788791,
-0.3294140995,
-0.7922826409,
0.3787748814,
-0.9057697058,
-0.1389866173,
1.1530536413,
-0.0380133726,
-0.0543375351,
-0.4287535548,
-0.4428086877,
-0.0260500275,
-0.3435665667,
0.5127335191,
0.6668483615,
-0.0056327302,
-0.0960838422,
-0.4148638546,
0.8866324425,
0.4394253194,
-1.0737266541,
0.4979123771,
0.5154283047,
0.4430836141,
-0.2389163375,
0.8064074516,
-0.316821605,
0.2939977348,
-0.1911033392,
-0.3152467906,
0.1813428998,
0.0087636458,
-0.3063438535,
0.1533230245,
0.0476020947,
0.0069523114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13292v1 | Zero-Shot Slot and Intent Detection in Low-Resource Languages | 2023-04-26T05:10:12 | 2023-04-26T05:10:12 | Sang Yun Kwon, Gagan Bhatia, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Alcides Alcoba Inciarte, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intent detection and slot filling are critical tasks in spoken and natural
language understanding for task-oriented dialog systems. In this work we
describe our participation in the slot and intent detection for low-resource
language varieties (SID4LR; Aepli et al. (2023)). We investigate the slot and
intent detection (SID) tasks using a wide range of models and settings. Given
the recent success of multitask-prompted finetuning of large language models,
we also test the generalization capability of the recent encoder-decoder model
mT0 (Muennighoff et al., 2022) on new tasks (i.e., SID) in languages they have
never intentionally seen. We show that our best model outperforms the baseline
by a large margin (up to +30 F1 points) in both SID tasks | [
-0.2389956564,
-0.8380463123,
0.8906943202,
-0.0078722565,
-0.2820960581,
-0.430909425,
-0.2782819271,
-0.3120357692,
0.0255965069,
0.588208735,
-0.6328004003,
-0.4730891883,
-0.3916967213,
0.1505269259,
-0.0201123171,
0.8336316347,
-0.1801571101,
-0.2034371346,
-0.1887610406,
-0.1788752526,
-0.8213076591,
-0.3971189857,
-0.7889436483,
-0.1103763506,
0.4167698324,
0.5895802379,
0.3275093436,
0.3914598525,
0.3660137355,
0.1943275034,
0.0688984469,
-0.0493628234,
-0.3919686675,
0.4426059425,
-0.0067110672,
-0.4331083,
-0.5799245834,
0.1890184134,
0.6999390125,
0.6862611175,
0.0176429208,
0.0546124354,
0.0119565763,
0.2929276526,
-0.8630799651,
0.2327941358,
-0.6581249237,
0.0507142916,
-0.4769657552,
-0.2732260823,
-0.7762960792,
0.0944025442,
-0.0589570142,
-0.5841363072,
0.3633059263,
0.0069785831,
0.4403126538,
0.3048444986,
-0.3345237672,
-0.4867700338,
-0.9348233938,
1.192632556,
-0.5125328302,
0.4375092387,
0.6101011038,
0.1645326465,
-0.0360992216,
-0.2310138047,
-0.8400782943,
-0.0849318504,
-0.0836739242,
-0.0702432841,
-0.4450253844,
0.4004377723,
0.3109265268,
0.2898164988,
-0.7308971882,
0.1156100333,
-0.1908816844,
-0.0669933707,
0.191721186,
0.1212005615,
0.2453425825,
-0.3950669765,
-0.1702699512,
0.1847756505,
-0.7361482382,
0.2490582913,
0.135339886,
0.3385756612,
-0.3044304252,
0.6611411572,
-0.0869170129,
1.2886618376,
0.0805247277,
0.0783594847,
-0.0743286908,
-0.7238883376,
-0.4866249859,
0.0341493189,
0.5951015353,
0.0797341093,
0.1706823856,
0.0189919658,
-0.298378408,
0.0400175937,
0.1897714138,
-0.5276051164,
0.1146159545,
0.3327602148,
-0.383289814,
-0.2999265194,
-0.5002683997,
-0.0564034916,
-0.1626689136,
-0.1556307375,
0.3042446375,
-0.7184252739,
-0.3195158839,
0.3193610311,
-0.1764326543,
0.5217861533,
0.5437371135,
-0.9403810501,
0.0819923729,
0.8188868761,
0.8437297344,
-0.1228535548,
-0.1347631514,
-0.9291645885,
0.2981906831,
-0.3562424481,
1.0027433634,
-0.6850424409,
-0.4200922847,
-0.0419289097,
0.1014746204,
-0.4113794267,
-0.3818509579,
0.8047792912,
-0.4738381505,
0.2546069026,
-0.3276945949,
-0.5315931439,
-0.2762599289,
0.437341243,
-0.6412563324,
0.7539627552,
0.2716776729,
-0.3658497036,
0.4002061486,
-1.1580033302,
-0.5377589464,
0.4771660268,
-0.2059570849,
-0.0755622312,
0.369715184,
-0.0050394381,
0.6102645397,
-0.0600774325,
0.0994433761,
-0.2045691013,
-0.6289642453,
0.3398967385,
-0.7557590008,
0.7259588838,
0.0649979338,
-0.1725074649,
0.1542843133,
-0.2931032479,
-0.1560556591,
0.081561856,
-0.3315275908,
-0.5861730576,
-0.1864925772,
-0.0589387268,
0.1791674793,
0.0853955373,
-0.7593740821,
0.2287741154,
-0.0647000149,
0.5691767335,
0.6013059616,
-0.0122840367,
0.5597733855,
-0.1594836712,
0.7299506068,
0.1660076529,
0.3045040369,
-0.5185661912,
-0.7986029983,
-0.5646814108,
-0.3449447453,
0.3451901674,
0.3385690749,
-1.0549362898,
0.4640949368,
-0.0563835837,
0.0589117408,
-0.6344642043,
-0.1390692592,
0.4147286415,
0.3572957516,
0.0703483671,
-0.5635524392,
-0.0727678463,
-0.6438895464,
0.0112910522,
-0.1024309695,
-0.0210371111,
0.6066075563,
0.1256187707,
-0.1576015353,
0.8555215001,
-0.3329448402,
-0.48839432,
-0.6934453249,
0.2184730619,
0.3096062839,
0.441316843,
0.8449985981,
-0.5987529755,
-0.6842384338,
-0.2296980023,
-0.661480546,
0.1183800921,
-0.124548465,
0.0549559891,
0.4829339385,
0.2487094998,
-0.7756000161,
0.390054673,
0.5360202193,
-0.3044766486,
0.2353120893,
-0.2053487897,
0.1707802266,
-0.7077224255,
0.0522291958,
0.0196828935,
-0.3667179346,
-1.2106240988,
-0.1231065318,
0.1678563207,
-0.1995597333,
-0.7295898795,
0.5785684586,
-0.4804148078,
-0.3415793478,
-0.3010379374,
0.1264978647,
0.0098639941,
0.5477383137,
0.2229680419,
0.891441524,
0.5448096991,
-0.6463836432,
0.0197291728,
0.1433238387,
-0.3962486684,
0.668846786,
-0.5675569177,
0.2552799284,
-0.3519420326,
0.1681296527,
-1.2095532417,
-0.2966575921,
0.4742878079,
-0.4686769545,
0.3979251683,
-0.6695886254,
-0.1711709797,
-0.2735336423,
-0.3732108176,
0.7291790843,
0.2935344875,
-0.2677540481,
0.442807138,
0.4509528279,
-0.2151895612,
-0.6429451704,
-0.6114141345,
-0.1985639185,
0.1095112041,
-0.4984017313,
0.1372083873,
-0.0224088933,
-0.0149064809,
0.1920333058,
0.0760191604,
-0.2201655358,
0.0433794223,
0.2280669361,
0.4158422649,
-0.4377934933,
-0.070635058,
-0.0015215215,
-0.2020178586,
-0.460909903,
-0.3493848443,
1.0307348967,
-0.0563295446,
-0.6077846885,
-0.8517720103,
0.3862349391,
0.7580521107,
-0.288759768,
0.66965729,
0.5491526127,
-0.2697809935,
0.2485727966,
-0.5455373526,
0.0217417777,
-0.4809606075,
0.0052540246,
-0.4608736932,
-1.1488953829,
0.2550877035,
0.3452123702,
0.1361233443,
0.3421884775,
0.3722693622,
-0.1988407224,
0.8355810046,
0.7540428638,
-0.0218735207,
0.6085686088,
-0.4106613398,
0.4944139719,
-1.1374615431,
0.2582923472,
-0.322381258,
-0.3774761558,
-0.3854089379,
-0.8405658007,
0.3990063071,
-0.0324748829,
0.3044575155,
0.5784008503,
-0.4423668981,
0.7405633926,
0.5690892339,
-0.3853437603,
0.2957065701,
-0.1414310932,
0.0642957166,
-0.0440798663,
-0.689912498,
-0.3547985256,
1.1660813093,
0.2622427344,
0.5499048233,
0.1445610225,
0.7943290472,
0.3693960607,
0.0085447216,
-1.0315703154,
0.5129868984,
-0.3419600129,
-0.6489955187,
-0.6559287906,
-0.2210038751,
-1.0936374664,
0.1875588596,
0.1502408832,
-0.5757930279,
0.5383328795,
0.2780030966,
-0.865206182,
0.2392206341,
-0.8626132607,
1.0926734209,
-0.0432318524,
-0.1528012156,
-0.3516091406,
-0.1470334828,
0.5212572217,
0.1885273308,
0.1356875002,
-0.4975830913,
0.1569449604,
0.4508055747,
0.3009390831,
0.8368801475,
-0.5905618668,
-0.1121743619,
0.4071365595,
0.1813023537,
0.5799084306,
-0.1004409567,
-0.1609245837,
0.0784793422,
-0.1477901191,
-0.4302334785,
-0.2379455566,
0.6491160393,
-0.379350245,
-0.3380869627,
-0.4448347688,
-0.578666389,
0.1825764775,
0.2277203351,
0.2366777807,
0.6612523794,
-0.42209813,
0.0508726314,
0.8090340495,
-0.2653732002,
0.7474443316,
0.8660687208,
0.1000725999,
0.2793811262,
0.9717655778,
-0.0960922465,
0.3183075488,
0.2444423586,
-0.2482046634,
-0.244747445,
-0.6027212739,
-0.7302699685,
0.2659510076,
-0.3324400187,
-0.1637876332,
-0.8052650094,
-0.2528007925,
-0.5648779273,
-0.2461022139,
-0.3167123497,
-0.5895962119,
-0.2072500736,
0.2232352495,
0.0391320661,
0.9107482433,
-0.0896436647,
0.444488883,
-0.7936008573,
0.3775595725,
0.3019810617,
0.4534913301,
-0.1631279737,
-0.4394460618,
-0.0572225079,
0.0133174332,
-0.1470956355,
-0.5579324961,
0.2558948994,
0.1746183932,
0.5979058146,
0.7336048484,
0.0904912204,
0.3014848232,
-0.663528204,
0.8663653731,
0.1401188225,
-0.8054040074,
0.5977926254,
-0.4618239999,
0.4517606795,
0.5150880218,
0.2877331674,
-1.1348274946,
-0.2831055522,
-0.5098212361,
-0.3487302065,
1.349237442,
0.2302099317,
0.1041427031,
-0.0688595846,
0.1930346787,
0.1446308047,
0.1013568714,
-0.6318218708,
0.0508645587,
0.0949034318,
-0.1005940363,
-0.0636482015,
-0.5884125829,
0.0039322828,
-0.0168581139,
0.4292213619,
-0.1084563062,
0.8236941099,
-0.1329460144,
-0.3562076688,
-0.3192093074,
0.7404278517,
1.0458086729,
0.2115177065,
-0.38187024,
0.129461512,
-0.1725780964,
-0.5186544657,
0.1936857998,
0.0174969453,
-0.4587984383,
0.2167833596,
0.3248690367,
0.9908760786,
0.3112701476,
-0.4980485439,
0.8104745746,
-0.4390659034,
0.0609487109,
-0.3380213082,
0.2613844275,
-0.1836424619,
-0.0306950305,
-0.0674027205,
0.2194453031,
0.2959387302,
-0.66838485,
-0.0386255421,
0.6476981044,
-0.5795930028,
-0.6112414002,
0.2993227243,
0.5333873034,
-0.1963834167,
0.5285962224,
-0.9803440571,
-0.4792825282,
0.3700268567,
0.5124897957,
0.9055848718,
-0.3717790842,
0.4244180322,
0.2418567836,
0.2923463881,
0.2400917113,
0.5870529413,
-0.5030439496,
-1.0875995159,
-0.5563244224,
-0.5132036209,
-0.4882676899,
0.3236362636,
-0.496479243,
0.1374452114,
-0.1918417364,
-0.1285686493,
0.2915057838,
-0.1960098594,
-0.7569031119,
-0.4292832315,
0.203027159,
0.5875797272,
-0.7204549313,
1.1477093697,
0.6306834817,
-0.0874280334,
-0.307199955,
0.1939071864,
0.1905083805,
-1.0021978617,
0.5379471183,
0.2621870637,
-0.0991038904,
0.0282046571,
-0.2629335225,
-0.8766667843,
0.9009751678,
0.0560117625,
-0.383289665,
-0.1768692881,
0.2054004669,
0.1471448094,
-0.356642127,
0.145209536,
0.7471661568,
0.374037385,
0.1550661474,
-0.9072602391,
-0.234098658,
0.035267923,
-0.01031275,
0.5017341971,
-0.3674424291,
0.9446393251,
-0.0922812298,
-0.4978037179,
-0.0721193403,
0.2616565824,
0.1857202351,
0.3686590493,
0.7481341958,
0.4436574876,
0.6499320269,
-0.2359149605,
1.1340485811,
-0.3267417252,
0.0493433923,
0.9359387159,
-0.7062274218,
0.8488391042,
0.2713650465,
0.011873519,
0.2332863063,
0.3594749272,
0.371006161,
0.6956192851,
-0.3013996482,
-0.6060006022,
-0.394238174,
-0.5360383987,
-0.0852180719,
0.6086521745,
0.7346032262,
0.1002471894,
-0.2540464699,
0.3283076882,
-0.1609058976,
-0.4429216683,
-0.2509388924,
0.7568107843,
-0.1758594513,
-0.8102004528,
0.4846289754,
0.2150469273,
0.9303097725,
-0.4124896228,
-0.0123217888,
-0.123880282,
0.1591235399,
0.191255942,
-1.0177813768,
0.4163928032,
0.2614205182,
-0.249394998,
-0.397584796,
1.035249114,
-0.531437099,
-0.1214369237,
0.0877269879,
0.4489374459,
0.3203095496,
-0.2668233514,
-0.4192695618,
0.0969334692,
0.0372553468,
0.2812116444,
0.2485166043,
0.5151605606,
-0.0248488728,
0.2541535497,
0.6203799844,
-0.1127384454,
0.1064456552,
0.1532661021,
0.5511780381,
-0.5655322671,
-0.5308963656,
-0.6684324145,
0.205591321,
-0.072234787,
-0.1121198088,
0.4923104942,
0.5264669061,
0.8696922064,
-0.2448527962,
0.7695054412,
-0.2431354076,
0.5023841262,
-0.3985662162,
0.5992779136,
-0.2920628488,
0.0229325928,
0.1567597091,
-0.6927418113,
-0.0551259965,
0.6302833557,
-0.4597123265,
-0.2627935708,
0.5234017968,
0.4972312152,
-0.3172980845,
0.0026504532,
0.7412822247,
-0.0690758973,
0.1919781566,
0.7565839887,
0.9207088351,
-0.2504814565,
0.3935930431,
-0.2179463208,
-0.3851228356,
-0.4922376573,
-0.579806447,
-0.9180616736,
-0.5896852612,
-0.2069691122,
0.1971089393,
-0.1612592936,
0.8665901423,
0.7947170138,
-1.1052421331,
-0.3295688629,
0.0767339468,
0.4096915424,
-0.2263268828,
-0.2275909483,
-0.0138380658,
-0.6357697248,
-0.7450905442,
0.6743186116,
0.7994500995,
0.2034990788,
-0.1243290827,
-0.1079213768,
-0.2601601481,
0.1662181914,
0.8103449345,
0.4123699367,
-0.7879015207,
-0.2543082237,
0.2342323214,
-0.1405882537,
0.0468493439,
1.2176642418,
-0.557305038,
0.3230935633,
0.380484432,
0.3854210973,
0.416495055,
-0.3468908668,
0.582896769,
-1.1115680933,
0.3538905084,
0.2792804539,
0.4423187077,
0.3271959424,
-0.3709580302,
0.4895291328,
0.206656456,
-0.4402008951,
-0.8738054037,
0.4131641686,
-1.0347397327,
-0.1436977386,
0.9425421953,
-0.1243724301,
-0.242476806,
-0.4921771586,
-0.0706744194,
0.0503818244,
-0.5451664329,
0.3560472429,
0.6435540915,
-0.4404165447,
-0.2379415333,
-0.7668844461,
0.7707790732,
0.2747465372,
-0.6321052909,
0.3017886281,
0.4679294229,
-0.0170259271,
0.3058021665,
1.3334438801,
0.0717469528,
0.5441198945,
-0.3936834931,
0.0529331639,
0.0561245494,
-0.4405649006,
-0.5726644397,
-0.0308074523,
0.1556265354,
-0.5610150695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13276v1 | The Closeness of In-Context Learning and Weight Shifting for Softmax Regression | 2023-04-26T04:33:41 | 2023-04-26T04:33:41 | Shuai Li, Zhao Song, Yu Xia, Tong Yu, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are known for their exceptional performance in
natural language processing, making them highly effective in many human
life-related or even job-related tasks. The attention mechanism in the
Transformer architecture is a critical component of LLMs, as it allows the
model to selectively focus on specific input parts. The softmax unit, which is
a key part of the attention mechanism, normalizes the attention scores. Hence,
the performance of LLMs in various NLP tasks depends significantly on the
crucial role played by the attention mechanism with the softmax unit.
In-context learning, as one of the celebrated abilities of recent LLMs, is an
important concept in querying LLMs such as ChatGPT. Without further parameter
updates, Transformers can learn to predict based on few in-context examples.
However, the reason why Transformers becomes in-context learners is not well
understood. Recently, several works [ASA+22,GTLV22,ONR+22] have studied the
in-context learning from a mathematical perspective based on a linear
regression formulation $\min_x\| Ax - b \|_2$, which show Transformers'
capability of learning linear functions in context.
In this work, we study the in-context learning based on a softmax regression
formulation $\min_{x} \| \langle \exp(Ax), {\bf 1}_n \rangle^{-1} \exp(Ax) - b
\|_2$ of Transformer's attention mechanism. We show the upper bounds of the
data transformations induced by a single self-attention layer and by
gradient-descent on a $\ell_2$ regression loss for softmax prediction function,
which imply that when training self-attention-only Transformers for fundamental
regression tasks, the models learned by gradient-descent and Transformers show
great similarity. | [
-0.3409623802,
-0.6183483005,
0.4578356147,
0.1389688104,
0.193827197,
-0.423168838,
-0.4787504971,
-0.2279133648,
-0.4591108561,
0.4024174213,
-0.7394474745,
-0.0704595968,
-0.5595300198,
0.0847181082,
-0.4183938205,
1.1541414261,
-0.13964127,
0.0388106145,
-0.2442018539,
-0.3349470198,
-0.4977902472,
-0.3606932461,
-0.4688732028,
-0.4999364614,
0.4410054982,
0.1472615153,
0.5903869271,
0.3455688953,
0.5387277007,
0.326344341,
-0.0882266238,
-0.3352408409,
-0.7974792719,
0.2648023963,
-0.1433620602,
-0.8923849463,
-0.2654652596,
-0.0266287643,
0.7719621658,
0.9095580578,
0.0432661362,
0.4160281122,
0.5748627186,
0.7149208188,
-0.4268948436,
0.2629637718,
-0.8001573086,
0.1767400801,
0.1372826248,
-0.0267282687,
-0.5208223462,
-0.0682173893,
0.2257507145,
-0.2730434239,
0.4329694211,
-0.1215249598,
0.8445210457,
0.6720222831,
-0.6880588531,
0.0342309959,
-0.8884116411,
1.0251560211,
-0.4192459583,
0.5247237682,
0.1094539538,
0.27028355,
0.0807549432,
-0.5872780681,
-0.2847297788,
-0.0818001851,
-0.2304129899,
0.0109855076,
-0.1294715852,
0.0811153054,
0.5322670937,
0.0783656538,
-0.1350736171,
-0.0095556658,
-0.3401177227,
-0.0749477148,
0.448355943,
0.2073127776,
-0.3676456809,
-0.1665068716,
-0.7943662405,
-0.1660895646,
-0.8270823359,
0.1278970093,
-0.1288659424,
0.4070324004,
-0.2803426385,
0.3961794674,
0.1470159441,
0.6009478569,
0.316708684,
-0.4271411002,
0.4003787935,
-0.2133237422,
-0.4427776039,
-0.0841475129,
0.4668588638,
0.1264359653,
0.3791337907,
-0.2629855275,
-0.4473327994,
-0.2471712828,
0.2722091377,
-0.6484135985,
0.5032836795,
-0.1285959482,
-0.691470921,
-0.0322113335,
-0.0628750771,
-0.5220546722,
-0.0542967208,
-0.7009057403,
0.8211487532,
-0.1948750466,
-0.0605904125,
-0.0610922165,
0.3955075145,
0.6590465307,
0.16804865,
-0.7694075704,
0.5207086205,
0.6341629028,
0.7810168862,
-0.2461009622,
-0.1678118706,
-0.4910028875,
0.129802838,
-0.0382590257,
0.3944809139,
-0.332749337,
-0.1175283566,
0.2347783297,
0.0487687662,
-0.4690369666,
-0.533736527,
0.5002042651,
-0.4624504745,
0.2809869647,
-0.1419698596,
-0.4961239994,
-0.0512826107,
0.0869630426,
-0.4637593925,
1.1040942669,
0.4747052193,
-0.6029688716,
0.3856176138,
-0.4638442695,
-0.5764549971,
-0.1099433452,
-0.034658324,
-0.4607276022,
0.3524159789,
0.0574183017,
0.8201928735,
-0.2724313438,
0.1573984772,
-0.2179743499,
-0.364055723,
0.4355682731,
-0.4885335267,
0.5756291747,
0.0445265621,
-0.6440097094,
0.0594481751,
-0.4416187406,
-0.201789394,
0.0531766005,
-0.2254662216,
-0.2140785754,
-0.130226776,
0.1525437832,
0.4657339156,
0.1495134681,
-0.4039583802,
0.3006614149,
-0.5892447233,
0.3636642396,
0.9007680416,
-0.2839690745,
0.8049843907,
-0.0498579405,
0.559450686,
-0.2709746957,
0.3696086407,
-0.0424183868,
-0.1718258709,
-0.635917604,
-0.004521071,
0.2752687931,
0.5099598169,
-0.4037044346,
0.2260750532,
-0.3233736455,
-0.107467331,
-0.4019091427,
0.4165307283,
0.4284431934,
0.798451364,
0.4341557324,
0.1061355248,
-0.3468084335,
-1.0083346367,
-0.1825213134,
0.2129152566,
-0.325291872,
0.4636905491,
0.3358796537,
-0.3645202219,
1.1040781736,
-0.5699934959,
-0.8884899616,
-0.5352029204,
-0.2768268585,
0.4874202311,
0.2279578596,
0.5764880776,
-1.0378690958,
-0.6861860752,
-0.1134454608,
-0.6706015468,
-0.0886624083,
-0.2171391845,
-0.0259721223,
0.0861073211,
0.8145866394,
-0.6476259828,
0.3892863691,
0.4527522922,
-0.1250248104,
0.1515298784,
-0.0329506658,
-0.4738548994,
-1.0985900164,
-0.0991886407,
0.3814468682,
-0.3222902715,
-0.7374408245,
-0.0775668249,
0.2251494229,
0.1364794523,
-0.5356007814,
0.691618979,
-0.4113960862,
-0.1247715279,
-0.2438263744,
0.0793544799,
-0.1302176267,
0.724460423,
-0.2176820785,
0.599963367,
0.6942266226,
-0.5662114024,
0.0883846879,
0.2596257925,
-0.0107630808,
0.5493457913,
-0.6107230783,
0.0156590566,
-0.3108403981,
0.2981984615,
-0.9895807505,
0.1334960461,
-0.040931195,
-0.19484514,
0.6939813495,
-0.1721387953,
-0.4108155668,
-0.1763155758,
-0.1886824369,
0.3876055181,
0.5027109981,
-0.5336465836,
0.8138155937,
0.2615143955,
0.1059150472,
-0.6776019931,
-0.7116574645,
-0.2508226931,
-0.4162490666,
-0.5036130548,
0.3877938986,
0.0393026546,
-0.2753149569,
-0.0995127559,
-0.2518891394,
0.1955522597,
-0.0839124173,
0.2444924861,
0.2727336586,
-0.3008993268,
0.3827946484,
-0.1590200067,
-0.3172754049,
0.2440182269,
-0.2221371084,
0.455119282,
-0.3480537236,
-0.0477795042,
-0.0989479497,
0.0934007168,
0.3884710371,
0.0143409083,
0.8759064078,
0.9344620705,
-0.3066556752,
-0.2894114852,
-0.6110030413,
-0.4294277728,
-0.5426783562,
0.4781012535,
-0.3931296766,
-0.8953882456,
0.4850562513,
-0.035594441,
-0.1138260886,
0.5921834111,
0.7284879684,
0.0060567656,
1.2472144365,
0.9469718337,
-0.2600509524,
0.6049008965,
-0.4109112322,
0.0889132693,
-1.2287191153,
-0.3539560139,
-0.4263071716,
-0.6058138013,
-0.4909555614,
-0.2469856739,
0.5619038343,
-0.2970938683,
-0.2576879263,
0.4292117357,
-0.4271934032,
0.4047829509,
0.1738138199,
0.1041202098,
-0.0920826718,
0.033013951,
0.025452897,
-0.2386333942,
-0.7827011943,
-0.011898838,
1.1985641718,
0.5310760736,
1.0978386402,
-0.0290343203,
0.2782514691,
0.1522427052,
0.6104527712,
-0.8746345639,
0.5035159588,
0.0029317206,
-0.4515578151,
-0.3262465298,
-0.5468857884,
-1.1242820024,
0.4127655923,
-0.0237535052,
-0.7671014667,
0.1319542974,
0.0046321084,
-0.2565277219,
0.1688719094,
-0.8512427211,
0.7681886554,
-0.1982293129,
-0.740939796,
-0.165211916,
-0.9710928202,
0.0723278597,
-0.0433894806,
0.234106496,
-0.0402070358,
-0.2975053787,
0.5041772723,
-0.0014803511,
0.8946959376,
-0.2704361975,
-0.221422717,
0.0580785088,
0.1449198127,
0.5867054462,
0.130877763,
-0.0276901573,
0.0258019157,
-0.5046414137,
-0.2885535657,
-0.5394138098,
0.626603663,
-0.718426764,
-0.6962302923,
-0.3008484244,
-0.694383204,
-0.3792774677,
-0.0487189516,
0.1983035952,
0.698861897,
0.2507329285,
0.5884277225,
0.9369997978,
0.0975673944,
0.5643978715,
0.3204058111,
-0.0848976076,
0.1357670128,
0.5553037524,
0.0761963129,
0.414031893,
0.709606111,
0.4488943815,
-0.5345329642,
-0.2387199998,
-0.0569161847,
0.4155261219,
-0.79817307,
-0.4958219826,
-0.5240481496,
-0.270716548,
-0.3488408923,
-0.2928644717,
-0.2504977286,
-0.0763461813,
-0.3358586133,
-0.0651887953,
0.0866608769,
0.6878733635,
0.1318269819,
0.1753327847,
-0.5071710944,
0.1177505478,
0.4076220691,
0.3076934516,
0.0303836409,
-0.9491171837,
-0.4727802873,
-0.2590630352,
-0.2125162035,
-0.7285403609,
0.4630219638,
0.4848546982,
0.6031882167,
0.5701258779,
-0.1304433048,
0.4736601412,
-0.3845951557,
0.3626015782,
0.0025884009,
-0.9739774466,
0.1941021979,
-0.2411447763,
0.5948752761,
0.5738269091,
0.3801971078,
-0.4929127991,
-0.209247157,
-0.5298886895,
-0.8724401593,
0.8989016414,
0.2138822377,
0.584931016,
0.4094415903,
0.625747323,
0.2822554111,
0.2638243437,
-0.9892799854,
-0.2950562835,
-0.0073595205,
-0.1645869613,
-0.1364157051,
-0.1928903759,
-0.0075026737,
-0.456546694,
0.3708893359,
-0.5175530314,
0.3753555417,
0.1383423358,
-0.3095260262,
-0.2349378616,
0.0579446405,
0.5546566248,
0.5467355251,
-0.1961206645,
0.1642281711,
0.6899549365,
-0.3217746913,
0.0088904677,
-0.0359256417,
-0.1107461378,
-0.3377476037,
0.4311317205,
0.8785535693,
0.6517685652,
-0.4561646879,
0.7800680995,
-0.0479341187,
-0.1484414339,
-0.3295169175,
0.0167125724,
-0.1438263804,
0.2940719426,
0.7730623484,
0.3344300687,
0.10443113,
-0.3941695988,
0.2320795208,
0.5811933279,
-0.7032206059,
-0.4263869822,
0.8566275239,
0.0376697071,
-0.2220975906,
0.4314576983,
0.0466486812,
-0.6812403202,
0.5801124573,
0.7319041491,
0.8259376884,
-0.3542335331,
-0.0089518186,
0.4010086954,
0.1959285438,
-0.02987835,
-0.3496261537,
-0.3173759878,
-0.6678035855,
-0.5577293634,
-0.6853771806,
-0.0759224594,
0.155280903,
-0.7280555964,
0.3726805747,
-0.1656965613,
-0.1229060888,
-0.3736165464,
-0.2021997869,
-0.9199091196,
0.2103596777,
0.4832855761,
0.542304635,
-0.8324046135,
0.6871987581,
0.4042600095,
0.0351489484,
-0.7989371419,
0.2868203223,
-0.1812687069,
-0.8199992776,
0.7827994227,
0.4714716673,
-0.119809784,
0.0153953331,
-0.6280272603,
-1.2407283783,
1.014567852,
0.5879228711,
-0.4606388509,
-0.2176132202,
0.2644757628,
0.6390315294,
-0.403683871,
0.3674044609,
0.421769619,
0.3757908344,
-0.0827383697,
-0.8986027837,
0.1466209739,
0.1796999127,
0.0334012769,
0.3071675599,
-0.9921705127,
0.9338933229,
-0.1311293393,
-0.0832603127,
-0.359403491,
0.7215573788,
-0.2310774177,
0.0699659064,
0.6612385511,
0.1815359443,
0.148949042,
-0.089095369,
1.2065169811,
-0.2185088992,
0.7745565772,
0.6978598833,
-0.3400064409,
0.6465278268,
0.4938804805,
-0.3355088234,
0.3739636838,
0.2007561475,
-0.0741707906,
0.4615138769,
0.0348622575,
0.0170664582,
-0.2289562672,
-0.0167908575,
-0.2971458137,
0.5101687908,
0.389919579,
-0.4120198786,
-0.2585475147,
0.3490046263,
0.1942308545,
-0.0577805564,
-0.5171192288,
0.7202193737,
0.279510349,
-0.6761119366,
0.620414257,
-0.2106789947,
0.7586830258,
-0.8040885329,
0.1936145574,
-0.1815428436,
0.5765978098,
-0.2039208412,
-0.69554919,
0.2491621673,
-0.3724986911,
-0.0835240334,
-0.6587377787,
0.9076341987,
-0.3698408306,
-0.5357242823,
0.6419896483,
0.4347901344,
-0.2843730152,
-0.1742605716,
-0.8505913019,
-0.0842126757,
-0.017281197,
-0.7669691443,
0.6223354936,
0.1405127048,
0.1824972779,
0.7817391157,
0.3266467154,
-0.2265137583,
0.1125115007,
0.1762869954,
0.7594931126,
-0.3467586339,
-0.1947108656,
-0.8909049034,
0.1802587956,
0.2206009626,
-0.2786103785,
0.9058957696,
0.5376107693,
0.8428146839,
-0.1525024921,
0.4352432191,
-0.019417569,
0.3119005561,
-0.4713295698,
0.4096593857,
-0.7795376778,
-0.0266969316,
-0.243642211,
-1.3589195013,
-0.2962856591,
0.4275924861,
-0.4447641075,
0.2248203009,
0.7710051537,
0.6537970304,
-0.0654235035,
-0.4744393229,
0.4381043911,
0.3214148581,
0.0829953849,
0.6546763778,
0.3999587595,
-0.4216690958,
0.8367136717,
-0.2239619792,
-0.0656593814,
-0.409909904,
-0.5732802749,
-0.9436457753,
-0.8282623887,
-0.0876872316,
-0.4684288502,
-0.3677661121,
0.9429986477,
0.802379787,
-0.604919076,
-0.2112719268,
0.0953057855,
-0.014973524,
-0.3709898293,
-0.3074365556,
0.4539376199,
-0.5675198436,
-0.7433385849,
0.279517293,
0.2634547055,
-0.1798300743,
-0.525242269,
-0.0955048576,
0.0078022629,
0.0908318385,
0.7983894944,
0.1601924002,
-0.4479764104,
-0.2182244509,
0.1438552588,
-0.2353045642,
0.41042009,
0.8996798992,
-1.0866508484,
0.1188700497,
0.3690333664,
0.5243093967,
0.9257751703,
0.0600059107,
0.4115977883,
-1.0244414806,
0.3634421825,
0.2093496323,
0.3869004846,
0.4776855707,
-0.4826761484,
0.5485463738,
0.1397210658,
-0.718159914,
-0.8631814718,
0.309409976,
-0.9484813213,
0.000996337,
1.4783107042,
0.2995043695,
-0.5577480793,
-0.0282746069,
-0.2120946944,
0.1850521415,
-0.2999140918,
0.8048313856,
0.2603133917,
-0.2182072848,
-0.1831632406,
-0.5611242056,
0.5230334997,
0.7407902479,
-0.5146537423,
0.0659741387,
-0.0885557085,
0.3335023224,
0.0370422304,
0.0455453806,
0.1234745011,
-0.010173209,
-0.3118055463,
-0.103173025,
0.2184983194,
-0.1722845137,
-0.5646007657,
0.4481201172,
-0.2679247856,
0.1232124418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13273v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13273v3 | From Association to Generation: Text-only Captioning by Unsupervised Cross-modal Mapping | 2023-04-26T04:06:20 | 2023-05-08T02:29:28 | Junyang Wang, Ming Yan, Yi Zhang, Jitao Sang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the development of Vision-Language Pre-training Models (VLPMs)
represented by CLIP and ALIGN, significant breakthroughs have been achieved for
association-based visual tasks such as image classification and image-text
retrieval by the zero-shot capability of CLIP without fine-tuning. However,
CLIP is hard to apply to generation-based tasks. This is due to the lack of
decoder architecture and pre-training tasks for generation. Although previous
works have created generation capacity for CLIP through additional language
models, a modality gap between the CLIP representations of different modalities
and the inability of CLIP to model the offset of this gap, which fails the
concept to transfer across modalities. To solve the problem, we try to map
images/videos to the language modality and generate captions from the language
modality. In this paper, we propose the K-nearest-neighbor Cross-modality
Mapping (Knight), a zero-shot method from association to generation. With
text-only unsupervised training, Knight achieves State-of-the-Art performance
in zero-shot methods for image captioning and video captioning. Our code is
available at https://github.com/junyangwang0410/Knight. | [
-0.4033554792,
-0.4990642071,
0.5670965314,
-0.1053737327,
-0.5571772456,
0.1849939525,
0.0539328158,
-0.240050301,
0.5121068358,
0.6318861842,
-0.4271793365,
-0.3992139697,
-0.5134084225,
-0.0571295545,
-0.1670980304,
0.6960813999,
-0.2975860536,
0.0856095925,
-0.4293991625,
-0.1967362165,
-0.5729376674,
-0.4394639134,
-0.117419444,
0.0516921058,
0.0300563779,
0.5043541789,
0.6977496743,
0.9081588984,
0.3627457917,
0.1998725832,
0.5394335389,
0.1579917669,
-0.3100022972,
-0.0448997654,
-0.1804562807,
-0.4528547227,
-0.3006244004,
-0.1002921909,
0.6995684505,
0.6640303135,
0.3062956631,
0.0152559588,
-0.4397400618,
0.6559914947,
-0.8586070538,
0.3102977872,
-0.7594511509,
0.2714699805,
-0.2449666411,
-0.7237941623,
-0.15032354,
0.2689105272,
-0.049650494,
-0.8443300724,
0.428468883,
0.3039016128,
0.9853787422,
0.0967142507,
-0.3351353705,
-0.1646077931,
-0.541194737,
0.880353272,
-0.4319941103,
0.4457384646,
0.3007938564,
0.4062356353,
0.1287123859,
-0.3578448892,
-0.797308147,
0.1399100721,
0.1277858764,
0.2541825175,
-0.1184424981,
-0.0763438493,
-0.0270094965,
0.39865309,
-0.1527047604,
-0.1590324044,
-0.4267050326,
-0.1821462065,
0.7178822756,
0.216095373,
0.5463792086,
-0.4456555843,
-0.5497151613,
-0.2978660762,
-0.7292870879,
0.1705605537,
0.1113446206,
0.321079582,
-0.2467238903,
0.7407180071,
-0.1498823911,
0.5579563379,
0.2713114619,
-0.0121390885,
0.2332750708,
-0.4611181319,
-0.2869795263,
0.0989538655,
1.0999557972,
0.8371987939,
0.2530501485,
-0.3305879533,
-0.0045866389,
0.201953277,
0.0882601365,
-0.7534586191,
-0.2721089423,
-0.336927861,
-0.4184645414,
-0.4983415902,
0.1245201454,
-0.9412885904,
-0.0723015815,
-0.1091741696,
0.765332818,
-0.112633504,
-0.2196152508,
0.071600616,
0.1416120231,
0.308298558,
-0.1145459488,
-0.8651102781,
0.299960047,
0.0792666897,
0.8613349795,
-0.366174221,
-0.3467838466,
-0.8162420988,
0.5059895515,
-0.6493855119,
0.5682566166,
-0.6067794561,
-0.2566728294,
0.4735025465,
0.2578561306,
-0.0610057302,
-0.4100904167,
0.1258186996,
-0.4657935798,
0.1742487401,
-0.2630289197,
-0.3429778814,
-0.4169643223,
0.0261920858,
-0.568369627,
0.7785494924,
0.1308470517,
-0.4333795011,
0.3993754983,
-0.6772854924,
-0.5263710618,
0.0454344898,
-0.5041521192,
-0.5095694065,
0.1898439378,
0.6232485175,
0.6591650248,
-0.3711381555,
0.1224177629,
-0.2638136744,
-0.2069129497,
0.2558164001,
-0.0427767001,
0.2995686829,
-0.2015331537,
-0.3720088601,
0.1092052087,
-0.5281445384,
-0.0562163852,
0.2225471735,
0.2371837199,
-0.3997328877,
-0.1121359989,
0.1946956515,
0.460809499,
-0.0299945232,
-0.6311413646,
0.1943126023,
-0.1863953322,
0.4937932789,
0.4766845703,
0.1770257503,
0.7542235851,
-0.5173681974,
0.8303692937,
0.1541511416,
0.0604387037,
-0.7114375234,
-0.2562922239,
-0.7328592539,
-0.3910785615,
0.299297601,
0.3562149704,
-1.196742177,
0.2863708735,
-0.4450590909,
-0.1897872984,
-0.6748401523,
0.1075374931,
0.5669908524,
0.386834532,
0.3192633986,
-0.8231418133,
-0.386189878,
-0.940723002,
0.1981121302,
-0.0550357178,
0.1528027207,
0.4013065696,
0.2923375964,
-0.0237566698,
0.8989853263,
-0.3759177923,
-0.745049417,
-0.2380228788,
0.0467374139,
-0.189450562,
0.2627733052,
0.6092910171,
-0.6374903917,
-0.6159166694,
0.0215155128,
-0.6408739686,
-0.2962238789,
-0.4167165756,
-0.1939967871,
0.3641991913,
0.579921484,
-0.4632121921,
0.4600085616,
0.4949148297,
0.0022804749,
0.3597631156,
0.0839624554,
0.4073389173,
-1.1089190245,
0.1801905036,
-0.3171552718,
-0.412125349,
-0.4675307572,
0.1330045313,
-0.2338110507,
-0.4126487076,
-0.464532584,
0.4135713875,
-0.755178988,
-0.4525343776,
-0.4090872109,
0.2525843382,
-0.0550988093,
0.8244029284,
0.4169384837,
0.6586512923,
1.0452792645,
-0.316917181,
0.0593858175,
0.4604084492,
-0.113962166,
0.4448510706,
-0.3752290308,
-0.0809063315,
-0.117210336,
-0.1497877091,
-0.8089462519,
-0.2314535826,
0.4395765364,
-0.5481226444,
0.3281613886,
0.0172878671,
-0.3447601497,
0.1628604382,
-0.5798190832,
0.6969764233,
0.5847679973,
-0.4881317914,
0.6253280044,
0.34535864,
-0.0214284863,
-0.3134798408,
-0.5681703091,
0.0417807885,
0.1621140242,
-0.4515247643,
0.454934597,
-0.062587291,
0.3104897439,
0.2127554268,
-0.2364530563,
-0.2025069445,
-0.5123845339,
0.494091332,
0.3558346331,
-0.1528279632,
-0.0984103456,
0.2052900195,
-0.0615716688,
-0.081945397,
0.3882492185,
0.3950802386,
0.1259124279,
-0.3494166136,
-0.2491718531,
0.8613898158,
0.768666327,
-0.3595268428,
0.296556592,
0.2534518242,
-0.092493996,
-0.2614017129,
-0.2044656426,
-0.031336762,
-0.4131881595,
0.4144337177,
-0.2911039889,
-0.9571123719,
0.3571771085,
-0.2159940153,
-0.1623038352,
0.2523856759,
0.4428960979,
-0.0178726595,
0.8264779449,
0.9269325137,
-0.0406554751,
0.4073354006,
-0.3878438473,
0.4254946709,
-0.7596756816,
-0.1505360454,
0.0721082613,
-0.2399559766,
-0.2910885215,
-0.7735909224,
0.351157397,
0.5838044882,
0.0801906064,
0.2362262756,
-0.486279428,
0.4949560761,
0.4448030591,
-0.2825773954,
0.3338506222,
0.356300801,
0.0518252626,
-0.4783709645,
-0.9495541453,
-0.0325101838,
1.1021277905,
-0.0742127076,
0.4266223311,
-0.0576882921,
0.7210184336,
0.2654415667,
0.1057472154,
-0.9713131785,
0.854272306,
-0.1059065163,
-0.3840348721,
-0.1421930343,
-0.2381307632,
-0.7770974636,
0.0603483282,
-0.4811292589,
-0.3442099094,
0.1673036963,
0.0897175446,
-0.0277940929,
0.3749603033,
-0.0841156691,
0.82244277,
-0.1814634204,
-0.2753058076,
0.1855380535,
-0.7459827662,
0.5092336535,
-0.2882895172,
0.3001850247,
0.1501841098,
-0.1821106672,
0.4823976159,
-0.4565315247,
0.8415917754,
0.0423410311,
0.2726271152,
0.3987895548,
0.4389706552,
0.1877210289,
-0.2627039254,
0.710672915,
0.1206607893,
0.1011872292,
-0.3849096,
-0.6815181971,
0.4259093106,
-0.6726076603,
-0.23005566,
-0.5777699947,
-0.653955996,
-0.2520547211,
0.2690118551,
0.3954133391,
0.4660044312,
0.0786924735,
0.1431989521,
0.5213246942,
-0.074261263,
0.8291580081,
0.744761467,
-0.5320596695,
-0.7607796192,
1.1509592533,
-0.0508309491,
0.2899922132,
0.6258794069,
0.0530725345,
-0.2417838424,
-0.4816406667,
-0.7058134675,
0.2538455129,
-0.4472240508,
-0.4479487538,
-0.2007266879,
-0.2187776864,
-0.3117293715,
-0.6903623939,
-0.4466693401,
-0.2974408567,
-0.1558956802,
0.124416247,
0.2837383151,
0.2561076581,
-0.2046208084,
0.370826602,
-0.9190939069,
0.4967399538,
0.4216023386,
0.1287562549,
0.0900679678,
-0.2837037444,
-0.1198878437,
-0.3073670566,
-0.4382457733,
-1.1039302349,
0.3417112529,
0.4844059348,
0.3090347052,
0.5116897225,
0.1005898267,
0.6959704757,
-0.5836360455,
0.9834424257,
0.7671952248,
-1.1126688719,
0.315944463,
-0.4886049628,
0.2624437213,
0.5166065097,
0.4851711988,
-0.4652371407,
-0.1287506968,
-0.3702593446,
-0.8681471348,
0.5275018215,
0.1296117604,
0.251883775,
-0.0325399153,
0.1504210234,
0.1325448304,
0.2943588197,
-0.9068821073,
-0.1513083428,
-0.4482764304,
-0.1060637981,
0.1249814779,
0.0697837472,
-0.0979347527,
-0.3338361382,
0.7093868852,
-0.3550270498,
0.2382618189,
0.4185441136,
-0.2172599435,
-0.5900746584,
0.1512416452,
0.581235528,
0.4324954152,
0.1394810528,
0.0069442387,
-0.2931287289,
-0.3146319687,
0.1995965391,
0.020032065,
-0.6371070743,
0.257619679,
0.5194478035,
0.8331140876,
0.385792017,
-0.8930689692,
1.1005438566,
0.6399948001,
-0.5314056873,
-0.0541491024,
-0.2554209232,
-0.2743493617,
0.1118571609,
0.2742903233,
-0.1737142801,
-0.0345693417,
-0.837523222,
0.276738584,
0.5058764219,
-0.6678108573,
-0.3534833491,
0.7600696683,
0.1370360106,
-0.3206012249,
0.0833085105,
-0.2601906657,
-0.5713953972,
0.0971444547,
0.5704655051,
0.9576927423,
-0.0556810349,
0.5184431672,
0.2245492339,
0.2675735354,
0.1895150095,
0.3803379238,
-0.3303475976,
-0.6224213839,
-0.6385936141,
-0.5908266306,
-0.1079636961,
0.23470819,
-0.6438981891,
0.1449561715,
-0.3993261158,
0.16374816,
-0.2109170258,
-0.1682785302,
-0.4567849636,
-0.0185392257,
-0.1879800856,
0.456068486,
-1.1696896553,
0.5940491557,
0.853300035,
-0.7276685238,
-0.6848680377,
-0.1427208334,
-0.4455421269,
-0.6777377129,
0.4743427634,
0.0338313915,
-0.1169219911,
-0.3010291159,
-0.4902383685,
-0.5262690783,
1.0438714027,
0.1810888499,
-0.7184759974,
0.0092324903,
0.5191584826,
0.2024465352,
-0.8337973952,
-0.2327004224,
0.078241311,
0.1071282923,
0.2538484633,
-0.7873043418,
0.1270458847,
-0.2003620863,
0.1461126357,
0.5368334055,
-0.6480103731,
0.6130640507,
-0.0154531011,
-0.2388732135,
0.2299024016,
0.5129751563,
0.1493909657,
0.4184402525,
0.3635827005,
0.7300259471,
-0.213004753,
0.3249104619,
0.7431778908,
-0.3004536331,
0.0556634627,
1.1343575716,
-0.2595520616,
0.8974526525,
0.8716629148,
0.1066198722,
0.3255009353,
0.2367105931,
-0.2378851622,
0.917941153,
0.067260325,
-0.2001542449,
-0.68742764,
-0.4994159639,
-0.1636019796,
0.4653985798,
-0.2299202383,
-0.6871035695,
-0.3920230269,
0.1770024449,
-0.1400683671,
0.571598351,
-0.5346473455,
0.5813736916,
0.019867409,
-0.3298670352,
0.4184503853,
-0.0869313553,
0.5385123491,
-0.6180411577,
-0.3666795194,
-0.0077735358,
-0.4210065007,
-0.0037120988,
-0.5073772669,
0.0838079304,
-0.0510437749,
-0.4877359867,
-0.1142302081,
0.6555998325,
-0.7472305298,
-0.5633611083,
0.0703903437,
0.5579203963,
0.3230549395,
0.0947280601,
-0.3499379754,
0.2305861861,
-0.0364142694,
0.292429477,
0.2874755263,
0.2719904482,
-0.2341755629,
0.1947869658,
0.5900329947,
0.0963774025,
0.276910603,
-0.1672961265,
0.700473845,
-0.5481356978,
-0.3531114161,
-0.5321359634,
0.3680050671,
0.1538101882,
-0.349697262,
0.6559548378,
0.8344694376,
0.8784389496,
-0.4762963653,
0.7020540237,
-0.0862730369,
0.1574572176,
-0.5422514081,
0.5162221789,
-0.7399861217,
-0.364703387,
-0.4186939001,
-1.1670389175,
-0.295589447,
0.3682872355,
0.0171005167,
-0.3403181136,
0.6960574389,
0.8156868219,
-0.3242977858,
-0.3636422455,
0.5753105283,
-0.1563599706,
0.0637113675,
0.9432066679,
0.5413342714,
-0.7713004351,
0.8245373964,
-0.3326043487,
-0.2056645602,
-0.0153337987,
-1.06065166,
-1.1553035975,
-0.8061412573,
-0.4400750101,
0.2012128383,
-0.106477946,
0.5161067843,
0.8305954337,
-0.4366982281,
-0.0957043543,
-0.1070418656,
-0.3862946928,
-0.1029673293,
-0.245826751,
0.397061795,
-0.053759791,
-0.5703055859,
0.420258373,
0.6005880237,
0.081523627,
-0.4408126771,
-0.1901316047,
-0.0034355612,
0.2912273109,
0.5408771634,
0.5761423111,
-0.7069784999,
-0.3278647363,
0.0256379005,
0.2581833005,
0.258433044,
0.9859890938,
-0.7449182272,
0.8394591212,
0.5180028081,
0.8857012391,
0.6807214022,
-0.1368833631,
0.5828629732,
-0.7662373185,
-0.0583283603,
0.0416550934,
0.072586894,
0.4893808663,
0.105538018,
0.3024429381,
0.4269398749,
-0.3115577102,
-0.849103868,
0.5040009022,
-1.4898495674,
-0.097475782,
0.7690466046,
0.1453277469,
-0.3786478639,
0.1779184788,
-0.2807191908,
0.3023121357,
-0.2410575747,
0.8071265817,
0.5731119514,
0.0463449806,
-0.5870484114,
-0.6303812861,
0.4568248391,
0.588480413,
-0.6310955286,
-0.1050276086,
0.4825961292,
0.1887468845,
0.3250518441,
0.7962982655,
-0.2894489765,
0.5549747944,
-0.0987905487,
0.2793830931,
-0.6130931973,
-0.4453288317,
-0.2559515834,
0.2413285822,
-0.3237656653,
-0.7028993964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13734v2 | The Internal State of an LLM Knows When It's Lying | 2023-04-26T02:49:38 | 2023-10-17T09:34:30 | Amos Azaria, Tom Mitchell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance in
various tasks, one of their most prominent drawbacks is generating inaccurate
or false information with a confident tone. In this paper, we provide evidence
that the LLM's internal state can be used to reveal the truthfulness of
statements. This includes both statements provided to the LLM, and statements
that the LLM itself generates. Our approach is to train a classifier that
outputs the probability that a statement is truthful, based on the hidden layer
activations of the LLM as it reads or generates the statement. Experiments
demonstrate that given a set of test sentences, of which half are true and half
false, our trained classifier achieves an average of 71\% to 83\% accuracy
labeling which sentences are true versus false, depending on the LLM base
model. Furthermore, we explore the relationship between our classifier's
performance and approaches based on the probability assigned to the sentence by
the LLM. We show that while LLM-assigned sentence probability is related to
sentence truthfulness, this probability is also dependent on sentence length
and the frequencies of words in the sentence, resulting in our trained
classifier providing a more reliable approach to detecting truthfulness,
highlighting its potential to enhance the reliability of LLM-generated content
and its practical applicability in real-world scenarios. | [
0.2813703716,
-0.4840860367,
0.929703176,
-0.0722872391,
-0.1147315502,
0.0893342793,
-0.5356078744,
-0.403677702,
-0.2404029071,
0.2583153844,
-0.2809909284,
-0.4950415194,
-0.4429869354,
-0.0451853648,
-0.2784342766,
0.8303178549,
0.0004763504,
0.0898720399,
-0.4022022784,
0.0133426599,
-0.4115635455,
-0.6804027557,
-0.1969863176,
-0.7314888835,
0.2613072991,
0.1781575382,
0.4498242736,
0.654838264,
0.3824917674,
0.3132022619,
0.1012382358,
0.1259498894,
-0.5703383684,
0.1827421784,
-0.1789966226,
-1.0794414282,
-0.0027610096,
0.325842917,
0.6346870065,
0.2675882876,
-0.1927528977,
0.2276245803,
0.0914491117,
0.5472507477,
-0.6431063414,
0.5388665795,
-0.8969738483,
0.1319114566,
-0.0804625601,
-0.1799648404,
-0.6809459925,
-0.83596766,
-0.0189315826,
-0.2419019789,
0.1292503923,
-0.1052106321,
0.9212309718,
0.5254229307,
-0.5199926496,
-0.624697268,
-0.6507313251,
0.6676380634,
-0.8370682597,
0.3549235463,
0.2651854753,
0.2820684612,
0.0367261991,
-0.4035563767,
-0.9481433034,
-0.6651551127,
-0.2365031242,
0.2998069823,
-0.0058376426,
0.0360277258,
0.2050590217,
0.4584074616,
-0.3164205551,
0.1083355844,
0.0490252525,
-0.3575597405,
0.5201787949,
0.0137493294,
0.1081320196,
-0.1172866449,
-0.4475290477,
-0.1021813005,
-0.6987496018,
0.2320280075,
0.6427039504,
0.1687624156,
0.0271726456,
0.9375936985,
-0.1371396184,
0.5114200711,
0.1619529724,
-0.9838200808,
0.2941554189,
-0.2960372567,
-0.0648288727,
0.5868711472,
0.6651647091,
0.4982322156,
0.1604086757,
-0.1450632364,
-0.6247995496,
0.6373331547,
0.2876626253,
-0.7857532501,
0.06608098,
0.1675974727,
-0.3127256632,
-0.5715478063,
0.2733844519,
-0.0525901839,
-0.5060681105,
-0.2896058261,
0.6703059673,
-0.6182866693,
-0.0604045801,
0.1616913229,
0.0178576205,
0.1283202469,
0.0424042307,
-0.3475627303,
0.18110919,
0.6573898792,
0.5354529619,
-0.1002013981,
0.0636002347,
-0.5604092479,
0.2417085916,
-0.6267701387,
0.4213332236,
-0.3470693827,
0.0237377714,
-0.002457506,
-0.1715938151,
-0.0020089415,
-0.6305391192,
0.7961518764,
-0.4236629009,
0.117228061,
-0.0902152881,
-0.9839065075,
-0.2597137988,
0.3858029246,
-0.5679075718,
0.7800267935,
-0.2216553986,
-0.6855566502,
0.2372355461,
-0.4004978538,
-0.3415575624,
-0.2312539667,
-0.3584773242,
-0.4687758684,
0.4462091625,
-0.1734321117,
0.5270973444,
0.2750351429,
0.5381157398,
0.0321357064,
-0.451531738,
1.0680545568,
-0.7183190584,
0.5961412787,
0.1161866859,
-0.3401234746,
-0.2929062247,
-0.7375012636,
-0.0355775356,
0.0622119829,
-0.7610400319,
0.004076221,
-0.067576699,
-0.5397238135,
0.0892094225,
0.4397348762,
-1.0690411329,
0.0308250394,
-0.5387897491,
-0.0450063609,
0.9231573939,
0.1022193506,
0.0575028732,
-0.5418255925,
0.1551958919,
0.3173511326,
-0.0934065208,
-0.2217961997,
-0.3297550976,
-0.9977533817,
-0.1203552336,
0.3490793109,
0.6589968204,
-0.5736215115,
0.7095329762,
-0.2553648651,
-0.3691204786,
-0.7398129106,
0.044492662,
0.5791758895,
0.964818716,
0.1254740804,
0.0331194028,
-0.2947906256,
-1.0842707157,
-0.4741197228,
-0.4631865919,
0.282140404,
-0.0057564136,
0.4339638948,
0.0690490082,
1.0405943394,
-0.3592942655,
-0.2432977408,
-0.1452325433,
0.192501381,
0.4368821383,
0.207673043,
0.2110909671,
-0.5760797262,
-0.3006578982,
-0.2198924571,
-1.0173313618,
-0.1348150074,
-0.2479926795,
0.3045659661,
0.5393107533,
-0.0171229839,
-0.5224783421,
0.6380401254,
0.5905869603,
-0.1751548499,
0.5971247554,
-0.3357560337,
-0.1446782798,
-0.7898690104,
-0.3776637316,
0.1705800146,
-0.3599934578,
-0.3656159937,
-0.0441181175,
0.087189123,
0.3013768196,
-0.3523666561,
0.2136021703,
-0.5418996215,
-0.0649580956,
-0.4080209732,
0.0544079952,
-0.0056969463,
0.387603581,
-0.0334687084,
0.8966674805,
0.4108611643,
-0.6051077247,
0.5398222208,
0.0152157564,
-0.7986741066,
0.5532724857,
-0.3419697881,
0.0258236695,
-0.3987630606,
0.3864961267,
-0.8951030374,
-0.0490614884,
0.0732011348,
-0.5144803524,
0.2974817455,
0.0014586275,
-0.7873002291,
-0.1948812455,
-0.1429953724,
-0.2877393365,
0.6822259426,
-0.6538879871,
0.6155208945,
0.2148544192,
0.3551348448,
-0.7789802551,
-1.1225630045,
0.0042347824,
0.0093086278,
-0.5424239039,
0.0656946525,
-0.2817417383,
-0.532613039,
0.0353310928,
-0.3328763247,
0.1456607133,
0.1401731521,
0.7185325623,
0.2932161093,
-0.2643203437,
0.4342297018,
-0.3751021922,
-0.0485643521,
0.3417132795,
-0.1944624633,
0.4026935697,
-0.61062783,
-0.4883845747,
-0.8477609158,
-0.1660976112,
-0.0022781573,
0.0263423901,
1.0307238102,
0.4755657017,
-0.1697237343,
-0.230045557,
-0.6621873975,
-0.1712339371,
-0.4912536442,
0.0586471111,
-0.5226266384,
-0.6263857484,
0.0531749129,
0.0126724727,
-0.0492079109,
0.2852232754,
0.5054206848,
-0.243140012,
0.810750246,
0.6805743575,
-0.0240200926,
0.0452057943,
-0.1214300767,
0.3953207731,
-0.574837923,
-0.2349975854,
-0.2571786642,
-0.1717212796,
-0.6943486929,
-0.3701986074,
0.5383670926,
0.0040538991,
0.0124168778,
-0.0965824127,
-0.4249244928,
0.6288882494,
0.4984817505,
0.4519616663,
0.5884559155,
-0.1060255766,
-0.2514424026,
-0.1244198233,
-0.4052018225,
-0.9013338089,
1.0804084539,
0.4650419056,
0.9219679236,
0.3021811247,
0.7185992002,
0.0927117243,
0.5854613781,
-0.9147148132,
0.7289801836,
0.0408954285,
-0.6572975516,
-0.0661574304,
-0.6335703731,
-0.3750659227,
-0.0182067733,
-0.2935462594,
-0.5098534226,
-0.1813028753,
0.1778839976,
-0.2160961628,
0.5365570188,
-0.6006662846,
0.3161090314,
-0.662784338,
-0.1099806353,
-0.1993329376,
-0.672617197,
0.489312917,
-0.2226177305,
-0.0184526257,
-0.2631630898,
-0.2223697305,
0.563546896,
-0.1188626289,
1.210739851,
-0.0245072618,
-0.2778262496,
0.2732645571,
0.2022812963,
0.6945441365,
-0.0247548912,
-0.3907697797,
0.1017909721,
-0.4710424244,
0.0667852536,
-0.5118123293,
0.584903121,
-0.7252526879,
-0.6497099996,
-0.6335773468,
-0.5714418888,
-0.3392795026,
0.0849134997,
0.3484897017,
0.4608345628,
-0.2413629889,
0.1859279722,
1.1416413784,
-0.3296611905,
0.5161341429,
0.6006715298,
-0.2369421273,
-0.0013383453,
1.0824445486,
0.20430547,
0.3277540207,
0.5824338794,
0.4399032891,
-0.584232688,
-0.4070307016,
-0.0545459054,
0.3913939297,
-1.0425131321,
-0.243206054,
-0.4680398405,
-0.42725721,
-0.2372605503,
0.1196586043,
-0.2723446488,
-0.4485278726,
-0.1383215785,
-0.5389602184,
0.0875393823,
0.8616836667,
-0.0740549192,
0.2463536561,
-0.4452973902,
0.3185828626,
0.5869162083,
0.1728848815,
-0.4214743376,
-0.6116416454,
0.0424400494,
0.1928535998,
-0.2934349477,
-0.7769385576,
0.1142498404,
0.2464103699,
0.7096773982,
0.4758712053,
0.2402816564,
0.1630411595,
-0.3827750087,
0.8446370363,
0.2975099981,
-0.8763847351,
0.613361001,
0.0646646619,
0.0826711655,
0.4440464377,
0.3968816996,
-0.2429705709,
-0.6698456407,
-0.6434970498,
-0.0619227141,
0.4206169844,
0.0689094067,
0.2593919337,
0.1096691787,
0.2247602195,
0.2907504439,
0.4986738563,
-1.0237649679,
-0.4918819964,
-0.2293364704,
-0.5233405828,
-0.0025162755,
-0.442558825,
-0.358538568,
0.0919657052,
0.919316411,
-0.3743201494,
0.3864202201,
0.1254675984,
-0.299050957,
-0.1379438043,
0.4079252183,
0.4828834534,
0.9909058809,
-0.2671483755,
0.5597140789,
0.0233298019,
-0.3260684609,
0.3198680282,
-0.1325064451,
-0.4272623062,
0.2398925126,
0.4643201828,
0.8674588203,
-0.2604773939,
-0.5963585377,
1.0242466927,
-0.0555132031,
0.0072556371,
-0.4445320368,
0.3912302256,
0.1698742658,
0.2682863474,
0.2448076159,
0.1267262399,
-0.1480377316,
-0.9370504022,
0.1006711945,
0.4023246467,
-0.4243549407,
-0.228086099,
0.4336913526,
-0.1300601214,
-0.1141537726,
0.5861989856,
-0.1087768748,
-0.8006986976,
0.3045770824,
0.6803409457,
0.5584385395,
-0.1147713661,
0.3659026325,
0.2288012207,
0.4713154435,
-0.0694644451,
0.1945272833,
0.2240367532,
-1.1501835585,
-0.6016663313,
-0.6935408115,
-0.3584654033,
0.2183387876,
-0.5285233259,
-0.2087628543,
-0.3479213119,
-0.2324333936,
-0.3062817156,
0.1309953779,
-0.3228502572,
0.5172511935,
0.6259992123,
0.7833693027,
-0.6916508079,
0.8465765715,
0.3700647652,
-0.41676718,
-0.9522686005,
0.1778852493,
0.0939507633,
-1.0866646767,
0.8289911747,
0.426033318,
-0.3319345117,
-0.4544309378,
-0.9171635509,
-0.5970051885,
0.9624321461,
0.6193255186,
-0.7670263648,
0.1899220943,
0.3525235355,
0.5615363717,
-0.3871229887,
0.0051135514,
0.2913655043,
0.5377309322,
0.0384641998,
-0.8004768491,
0.16787076,
0.0652658418,
-0.0453765653,
-0.2099714279,
-0.7277681828,
0.8265917897,
-0.4259089828,
-0.3559443653,
-0.0932638422,
1.0205783844,
0.4508671165,
0.1893337369,
0.5664143562,
0.6825010777,
1.2534931898,
-0.2871185541,
1.1912180185,
-0.3094739914,
0.0630103499,
1.2287971973,
-0.3869656324,
0.6658550501,
0.1659752578,
0.2539130151,
0.7275803685,
0.2190193534,
-0.0357620306,
0.5473160148,
0.3357025981,
-0.528660655,
-0.2720608115,
-0.3345760107,
-0.0806604922,
0.3389992118,
0.2867484093,
-0.4074119925,
-0.0064179581,
0.0695152134,
0.1580173224,
0.2819129229,
-0.2545641363,
0.6846859455,
0.2117003947,
-0.6186962128,
0.3911952972,
-0.0550572127,
0.7666979432,
-0.4075415432,
-0.1371686161,
-0.1518341154,
0.3677449226,
-0.2669316232,
-1.2777838707,
0.024863027,
0.0472280458,
-0.1751402318,
-0.3247547746,
0.7545535564,
-0.4617210031,
-0.4450297356,
-0.1191705838,
0.35528633,
0.2513209879,
-0.0535302609,
-0.4691207707,
0.107315138,
0.0304350778,
-0.1689402759,
0.121343188,
0.627352953,
0.3363375068,
0.9014596939,
0.5729510784,
0.3870705962,
0.2175646573,
-0.0746050254,
0.6315876842,
-0.5088200569,
-0.4758119583,
-0.7834132314,
0.2963649333,
-0.1745434403,
-0.1413156986,
0.8035365343,
0.7320334911,
0.8509625793,
0.2051040381,
1.0562062263,
0.2450876236,
0.6603761911,
-0.9216382504,
0.470197469,
-0.2462891191,
0.3525948524,
0.409504354,
-0.715967536,
0.1308921576,
0.7365118861,
-0.3572078645,
-0.3030042946,
0.8185806274,
0.8650365472,
0.1644552052,
0.1096550077,
0.3765583932,
0.6162886024,
0.1343484819,
0.4966417551,
1.1879843473,
-0.2898176312,
0.5111687779,
-0.5837671757,
-0.0346781127,
-0.0456714965,
-0.8873512745,
-0.8497050405,
-0.3907605112,
-0.338790834,
-0.59327209,
-0.0036146385,
0.5604644418,
0.392739892,
-0.5142763853,
-0.2168615609,
0.1607095301,
0.092675209,
-0.0668883175,
-0.2601830661,
0.1119896173,
-0.3430181742,
-0.2789182663,
0.6699936986,
0.1636625677,
0.0835921243,
-0.2960934043,
-0.025655793,
-0.0304993261,
0.3160041571,
0.3488104641,
-0.2580418289,
-0.7083086967,
-0.4780884981,
-0.3116004765,
-0.5764119625,
0.3705304563,
0.5663894415,
-0.8185005188,
0.2861022651,
0.2009026408,
0.536397934,
0.5456105471,
0.0799531564,
0.4431083202,
-1.0520737171,
-0.2345532775,
0.3881590366,
0.3170217276,
0.518928647,
-0.6329028606,
0.6557844877,
0.2384988964,
-0.4342676401,
-0.7792818546,
0.2242594063,
-0.932356298,
-0.3575316966,
1.1572518349,
-0.0961958244,
-0.5801204443,
0.1550856978,
-0.0028624178,
0.4194883406,
-0.4246775508,
0.5748904943,
0.7580048442,
-0.2201229334,
-0.0429263934,
-0.590436101,
0.3834632635,
0.052961193,
-0.6485478878,
-0.1040940583,
0.5476548672,
0.5614988804,
0.4683090448,
0.5031613708,
0.1634037793,
-0.1557814181,
-0.0673219562,
0.1363687366,
-0.1639319509,
-0.3046291173,
-0.2740579844,
0.2819714844,
-0.0707627013,
-0.1565491557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13250v1 | Exploring the Curious Case of Code Prompts | 2023-04-26T02:37:52 | 2023-04-26T02:37:52 | Li Zhang, Liam Dugan, Hainiu Xu, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has shown that prompting language models with code-like
representations of natural language leads to performance improvements on
structured reasoning tasks. However, such tasks comprise only a small subset of
all natural language tasks. In our work, we seek to answer whether or not
code-prompting is the preferred way of interacting with language models in
general. We compare code and text prompts across three popular GPT models
(davinci, code-davinci-002, and text-davinci-002) on a broader selection of
tasks (e.g., QA, sentiment, summarization) and find that with few exceptions,
code prompts do not consistently outperform text prompts. Furthermore, we show
that the style of code prompt has a large effect on performance for some but
not all tasks and that fine-tuning on text instructions leads to better
relative performance of code prompts. | [
-0.319484055,
-0.9450255632,
1.0247348547,
0.246883139,
-0.1372772902,
0.0337190591,
-0.277859807,
-0.350175947,
-0.1204940975,
0.0929972157,
-0.6596608758,
-0.3050645888,
-0.235721454,
0.5281988978,
-0.2087480277,
1.1407389641,
-0.0658224374,
0.0801853165,
-0.2632906735,
0.3465445638,
-0.9163933992,
-0.6975443363,
-0.5765610933,
-0.1721026301,
0.7237121463,
0.1647079438,
0.8396538496,
0.5024626255,
0.4039776921,
0.2447510213,
-0.1401935518,
0.2205623537,
0.043685291,
0.3419255614,
-0.1256888509,
-0.5472742915,
-0.157241255,
0.0985226184,
0.028093949,
0.5017507672,
0.1539916247,
-0.0666008666,
0.038873326,
0.7282536626,
-0.3150100112,
0.4000074267,
-0.1432932466,
-0.0769670829,
0.0839326903,
-0.2775299251,
-0.5141434073,
-0.6578233242,
0.0753493682,
-0.4979055524,
0.1461700797,
-0.0103302943,
0.5704405904,
0.3173762858,
-0.2265209109,
-0.6802095771,
-0.7020535469,
0.5637689829,
-0.4893231392,
-0.0568658374,
0.3074139655,
0.1273887604,
-0.0302499291,
-0.5443001986,
-0.5164580345,
-0.6611815691,
-0.3713788092,
-0.0249022488,
-0.4775781035,
0.300743103,
0.8714569807,
0.2624247968,
-0.7868229747,
0.0311359651,
-0.1372438967,
-0.0335393213,
0.3622839153,
0.3134085536,
0.7535575032,
-0.2961344421,
-0.1447647363,
-0.1272143275,
-0.7737460136,
0.5592524409,
0.4252208173,
0.3497405946,
-0.2535054982,
0.4192866683,
-0.1588409245,
1.1305776834,
-0.1118345633,
0.119483687,
-0.2865941226,
-0.49696666,
-0.1504291445,
-0.1339215338,
0.6515911222,
0.4456825554,
0.8251823187,
-0.0616382323,
-0.2712598145,
0.4665854573,
0.4100322127,
-0.7012965083,
-0.6030103564,
0.1113629341,
-0.2711084485,
-0.0241104998,
0.2400633395,
-0.4441206753,
-0.318099767,
-0.6010422707,
0.1536031663,
-0.3182456493,
0.0420527905,
0.1704404205,
-0.3321546018,
0.0383529179,
0.6007015705,
-1.134594202,
-0.0634890944,
0.6394228935,
0.76405406,
-0.2008383721,
0.138830021,
-0.6439461112,
-0.4495743215,
-0.5500062704,
0.9866610765,
-0.9792101979,
-0.717872262,
0.0296794809,
-0.045405779,
-0.2218954563,
-0.3712129593,
0.4732569754,
-0.439653337,
0.3173088729,
-0.7281041741,
-0.4042428732,
0.0390343443,
0.0750822946,
-0.6415419579,
0.9983847737,
0.0817888081,
-0.5983788967,
0.5235742927,
-0.8570107222,
-0.3929066956,
0.1381433308,
-0.5582319498,
0.1667368561,
0.0692663118,
0.3652796745,
0.4118156135,
-0.0674359798,
0.3129324317,
-0.0225071777,
-0.8302367926,
0.3908833861,
-0.3051635623,
0.5375925303,
0.4155315161,
-0.4254836142,
-0.0263668485,
-0.4239039123,
0.2061638087,
0.006463632,
-0.3837859035,
-0.3195714653,
-0.1719073206,
-0.2860183418,
0.0560456589,
0.0104967775,
-0.2140076011,
0.9394754767,
-0.2536526322,
0.6188819408,
0.7137586474,
0.0290840939,
0.5000740886,
-0.592408061,
0.932466507,
-0.2002749294,
-0.071915932,
-0.6402707696,
-1.0082166195,
-0.2854132652,
-0.3315183222,
0.1798616052,
0.5895112753,
-0.9536902905,
-0.1684973091,
0.1315690577,
-0.2759081721,
-0.1385102719,
-0.0872981623,
0.5756182671,
0.3155312836,
0.3148330152,
0.1526066959,
-0.242699489,
-0.7012515068,
-0.6580857635,
-0.5244490504,
-0.1128496975,
0.3303735852,
0.3448274136,
-0.0125975367,
1.1046110392,
-0.6094139814,
0.4065999985,
-0.2294164002,
0.2426769584,
0.6156939268,
0.4606215954,
0.7426376939,
-0.848351419,
-0.6224247217,
-0.1243387088,
-0.5718708634,
-0.2699083388,
-0.3284138143,
0.2290980667,
0.2371637523,
0.4412483275,
-0.5238443613,
0.4375662804,
0.4437387288,
-0.5913364291,
0.7365937233,
-0.2395380288,
0.6770637631,
-0.5668216944,
0.059131436,
-0.0773342773,
-0.1382974684,
-0.8011661768,
0.1426288933,
0.3410388529,
-0.1657409817,
-0.2897813916,
0.5057034492,
-0.464389503,
0.0685221031,
-0.2757987678,
0.0627833605,
0.3541301191,
0.4647010863,
0.2190804183,
1.5373200178,
0.5963822603,
-0.8239604235,
0.1657959372,
0.2312906832,
-0.3227558434,
0.27948156,
-1.0615839958,
0.5426235199,
-0.0264433008,
-0.0207800344,
-1.1750744581,
-0.109464854,
0.2562930882,
-0.5478858352,
0.2427568138,
-0.2294303328,
-0.5052264929,
-0.4503584504,
-0.2880219817,
0.3992388546,
0.7392235398,
-0.5658171177,
0.0888461173,
-0.2784070969,
-0.3337158263,
-0.2627018094,
-0.6929365396,
0.1501671076,
-0.0660513192,
-0.5552267432,
0.2574881911,
-0.3720588982,
-0.525703609,
-0.295132339,
-0.0474246293,
-0.0083508017,
0.0896974355,
0.3193867207,
0.4163762033,
-0.3407264054,
0.2355020344,
-0.036784865,
-0.1205430925,
0.0841830447,
-0.2941047549,
0.3830963075,
-0.228160128,
-0.4789859056,
-0.3749179244,
0.5787878036,
0.173410818,
-0.2536090016,
0.4455525279,
0.058249563,
-0.163111493,
0.0398022644,
-0.4153070748,
-0.199261412,
-0.5152968168,
-0.1581014842,
-0.3782206178,
-1.0932182074,
0.3356564939,
0.2107306272,
-0.0559562668,
0.1926506609,
0.5175274014,
-0.1696089506,
1.2454966307,
0.7345943451,
0.0081045711,
0.6775226593,
0.1159809008,
0.3879603446,
-0.2211295813,
0.0274783578,
-1.0154408216,
0.1138141528,
-0.4971145093,
-0.3699383736,
0.3072627485,
0.1890784204,
-0.022504421,
0.5459939837,
-0.8330413699,
0.6646023393,
0.5278502703,
-0.0349490941,
0.4622214735,
-0.197335422,
-0.1390460134,
-0.044686947,
-0.7734162211,
-0.9200092554,
0.4365121722,
-0.067717135,
0.7299809456,
0.065115571,
0.6027462482,
0.4044446051,
-0.1192483529,
-0.4617579877,
0.3317429423,
0.0914478078,
-0.4192549586,
-0.1125022322,
-0.3824703097,
-0.9306793809,
-0.2922547758,
0.130221054,
-0.7507174015,
0.3198675215,
0.3139241636,
-0.788097024,
0.0428277925,
-0.9860060215,
0.8572179675,
0.0902680606,
0.012103186,
0.1522643417,
-0.3650996983,
0.0189050045,
0.3137565851,
0.2410746664,
0.1515066326,
-0.0454979688,
0.4797789454,
-0.1986569762,
0.7954629064,
-0.123628512,
-0.2732060254,
0.4454469979,
0.3752369285,
0.7819821239,
0.2966721058,
-0.083968468,
-0.2082415819,
0.1267264187,
-0.3524134755,
-0.9132555127,
0.5763167739,
-0.3426846564,
-0.7579905987,
-0.3480543494,
-0.4135605395,
-0.230330348,
-0.0914861634,
0.4122238457,
0.8611289859,
0.2217307985,
-0.2171330601,
0.8659912348,
-0.3706335723,
0.7626730204,
0.2903434038,
-0.0288727544,
0.1428944618,
0.5846483707,
-0.1763681918,
0.537676394,
0.3827333748,
0.1150623038,
-0.1661795229,
-0.4784526229,
-0.8144604564,
-0.0340180956,
-0.8263870478,
-0.1693117172,
-0.757666409,
0.2510937452,
-0.3644194305,
-0.4683620334,
0.1141090095,
-0.3957325816,
-0.4419103861,
-0.2249067426,
0.8784570098,
1.023758769,
0.2795787454,
-0.0043047783,
-0.9737023115,
0.4109742045,
0.4786311984,
0.2693743706,
-0.2118856907,
-0.3220294118,
-0.0409113839,
0.010675176,
0.0246265344,
-1.0043689013,
0.0234622415,
-0.1473037153,
0.4428178072,
0.1256319433,
0.171480149,
0.524268806,
-0.4977139533,
1.3636428118,
0.0809069723,
-0.8810640574,
0.7104876637,
-0.7335983515,
0.5940286517,
0.5893253684,
0.3211919665,
-0.6915481091,
-0.5578822494,
-0.3972987235,
-0.3780899346,
0.6635956764,
0.2283169478,
0.4691230059,
-0.4771493077,
0.4883395433,
0.1247051209,
0.2949944437,
-0.7439107299,
-0.2819411457,
-0.1181710064,
0.0260961391,
0.2071678191,
-0.2347506434,
0.0644101351,
-0.0835897923,
0.1574449837,
-0.44456774,
0.5960671306,
0.544187963,
0.0347235687,
-0.0555459931,
0.4536681473,
0.8017575145,
0.8775797486,
0.2410750538,
-0.0223088171,
-0.1321987063,
-0.3762698472,
0.1040711924,
-0.2606522143,
-0.2100075334,
0.0977539644,
0.5859439373,
0.7934852242,
0.3001434207,
-0.6723983288,
0.5084193349,
-0.2981983721,
-0.2263750881,
0.2908056378,
0.560600996,
-0.1013258547,
0.2861514091,
0.38232705,
0.1809242964,
0.2703527212,
-0.7069169879,
0.0266058724,
0.2968987823,
-0.4126870632,
-0.1158885285,
0.6834270954,
0.1153799966,
-0.6066405177,
0.4085204303,
-0.3510526121,
-0.6373668909,
0.7636926174,
0.3108442724,
0.7537036538,
0.2009494454,
0.4822302759,
0.4395285547,
0.1787384599,
-0.1385466754,
0.5160482526,
-0.359185487,
-0.2340094596,
-0.6980769038,
-0.3140282631,
-0.5102925301,
-0.4950886965,
-0.6639693975,
0.2288926691,
-0.272079587,
-0.0583530031,
-0.2839683294,
-0.0970212966,
-0.6154410243,
0.1210201085,
0.1218294948,
0.9385125041,
-0.4854720235,
0.7969568372,
0.8108277917,
-0.5219709873,
-1.2248306274,
-0.0313746743,
-0.0945195928,
-0.6573551297,
0.5446746945,
0.2978402078,
-0.048665002,
-0.0174364951,
-0.5216647387,
-0.3665500879,
0.7223708034,
0.3907601237,
-0.6358946562,
-0.3626851439,
-0.1597356796,
0.6265189648,
-0.24909091,
0.4565137029,
0.4939641654,
0.5826915503,
-0.242489025,
-0.8878440857,
0.1706728935,
-0.4305067658,
0.176119253,
0.1708270013,
-0.2303340882,
1.0192751884,
-0.4473674297,
-0.3834214509,
0.3069244325,
0.3896443546,
0.2621972859,
0.3724752665,
0.4477944374,
-0.2214309126,
0.7904247046,
-0.3911798,
1.47935009,
-0.3087925017,
0.1304333508,
0.5860537887,
-0.0621985793,
0.3498069942,
0.4484636784,
-0.520571053,
0.7759824991,
0.7719651461,
0.0949900895,
0.4168552756,
0.11955975,
-0.0434899144,
-0.3701812029,
0.0763740018,
-0.6837462783,
-0.1372703314,
-0.1307720244,
-0.1680870056,
-0.0941035897,
0.1018405408,
0.0019903011,
0.4411615729,
-0.2691865563,
0.890687108,
0.1149247363,
-1.0997693539,
0.5339292884,
-0.2045329511,
0.6274505854,
-0.5571085811,
-0.3585140109,
-0.3571991026,
-0.3971604705,
-0.1085619926,
-0.7457129955,
0.0988896415,
0.3849015832,
-0.503906846,
-0.5336056352,
0.610517323,
-0.2406718284,
-0.0571104996,
0.1257999688,
0.4395594597,
0.0404275022,
-0.3957751989,
-0.6021660566,
-0.0606239513,
0.0463170968,
-0.2929694057,
0.2696311474,
0.6467412114,
-0.0734203085,
0.5387541056,
0.8133172989,
-0.2082383782,
-0.0235816557,
0.252577275,
1.0053659678,
-0.8521025777,
-0.7099654675,
-1.1454185247,
0.6655707955,
0.1504754126,
-0.3706153333,
0.8971369863,
0.1564378887,
0.5262643099,
-0.3112850785,
0.6964389682,
-0.1007713974,
0.3287962973,
-0.9090416431,
0.3063614368,
-0.235423252,
0.3273875713,
-0.6647806168,
-0.8072622418,
-0.0891295224,
0.5369200706,
-0.3180606663,
0.3225779831,
0.8258677721,
0.8656513095,
0.4026073217,
0.5524650216,
0.3983548582,
-0.3492275178,
0.3702412546,
0.5625540614,
1.1603595018,
-0.0374849327,
0.296413511,
0.0178793594,
-0.1630595773,
-0.1481685042,
-1.0550522804,
-1.0624773502,
-0.5215389729,
-0.3608542383,
-0.1571329236,
0.1134261787,
1.0411355495,
0.4297882915,
-0.7454056144,
0.119655475,
-0.3045557737,
0.1518391967,
-0.3741932511,
-0.201279074,
0.0405942984,
-0.6696594357,
-0.7309595346,
0.5562109947,
0.293558538,
0.149086237,
0.0480762273,
-0.0643899962,
0.1615862399,
0.0945730582,
0.3448655009,
0.1650241911,
-0.5838863254,
-0.4092286825,
0.4525266886,
-0.3617802858,
0.1042990088,
1.4403520823,
-0.9159101248,
0.3469747007,
0.5161070824,
0.5452903509,
0.0375728272,
0.0905149803,
0.8738848567,
-0.5801655054,
-0.0727085918,
0.252248615,
0.2916524112,
0.0781057328,
-0.6609796882,
0.3783739507,
0.0555057637,
-0.7226532698,
-0.7974795699,
0.2690013349,
-0.8402817845,
-0.412148118,
1.2570207119,
-0.2494113892,
-0.0827057958,
-0.3910678923,
-0.6872073412,
-0.1403670907,
-0.5548448563,
0.3778018355,
0.8978617191,
-0.358151406,
-0.0795271322,
-0.7074950933,
0.845040679,
0.4339318275,
-0.6854891181,
0.2603456676,
0.5452565551,
-0.1260730177,
0.1098321453,
0.8040898442,
0.0659072101,
0.6702048182,
-0.2144508511,
-0.2796810567,
-0.2980305552,
-0.5712356567,
-0.6750147343,
-0.04147752,
0.279404819,
0.1924346685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13191v1 | Towards Explainable and Safe Conversational Agents for Mental Health: A Survey | 2023-04-25T23:12:13 | 2023-04-25T23:12:13 | Surjodeep Sarkar, Manas Gaur, L. Chen, Muskan Garg, Biplav Srivastava, Bhaktee Dongaonkar | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Virtual Mental Health Assistants (VMHAs) are seeing continual advancements to
support the overburdened global healthcare system that gets 60 million primary
care visits, and 6 million Emergency Room (ER) visits annually. These systems
are built by clinical psychologists, psychiatrists, and Artificial Intelligence
(AI) researchers for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). At present, the role
of VMHAs is to provide emotional support through information, focusing less on
developing a reflective conversation with the patient. A more comprehensive,
safe and explainable approach is required to build responsible VMHAs to ask
follow-up questions or provide a well-informed response. This survey offers a
systematic critical review of the existing conversational agents in mental
health, followed by new insights into the improvements of VMHAs with contextual
knowledge, datasets, and their emerging role in clinical decision support. We
also provide new directions toward enriching the user experience of VMHAs with
explainability, safety, and wholesome trustworthiness. Finally, we provide
evaluation metrics and practical considerations for VMHAs beyond the current
literature to build trust between VMHAs and patients in active communications. | [
-0.6324699521,
-0.8291457891,
1.1286622286,
0.0714626238,
-0.1224868745,
0.1344907731,
-0.0461246073,
-0.8126193881,
0.37767452,
0.4683945775,
-0.7320398092,
-0.3308489621,
-0.5392382145,
-0.058186166,
-0.1868180037,
0.8867066503,
0.1757559329,
0.1004772857,
-0.1652795225,
-0.0269756,
-0.5934425592,
-0.7445867658,
-0.8988045454,
-0.3631715477,
0.4145556986,
0.1720188558,
0.8977651,
0.1715059578,
0.2644439042,
0.2835116982,
0.053495083,
0.3860558271,
-0.2927353084,
0.2357746661,
-0.1035826057,
-0.3863579929,
-0.8359421492,
-0.405841291,
-0.1064559072,
0.5366002917,
-0.6183828712,
0.0510945357,
-0.1565923393,
0.4894841313,
-0.4000538588,
0.2678007185,
-0.4098569155,
0.16066508,
0.113614127,
-0.2301537991,
-0.3389074504,
-0.3811400235,
0.2563478053,
-0.7785388231,
-0.0192113537,
-0.0039953468,
0.376668036,
0.274471879,
-0.5439996719,
-0.0976912603,
-1.0635012388,
0.3094959259,
-0.4926382899,
0.1684484482,
0.6326287985,
0.5074930787,
-0.089094691,
-0.814584136,
-0.6847700477,
-0.2556843162,
0.0285900123,
0.3197647333,
-0.5288393497,
0.4111419022,
0.2281515449,
0.2226616442,
-0.4508593082,
-0.2385958582,
-0.1497265548,
-0.1822279692,
0.5929587483,
0.6574599743,
0.4982847273,
0.2866512239,
-0.1163190603,
0.1019362211,
-0.1187708974,
0.0174445901,
-0.3243282139,
-0.2039369047,
-0.0463316031,
0.4732768238,
-0.1258057803,
0.2424356043,
-0.0266354457,
-0.0721708164,
0.0063888724,
-0.2529469728,
-0.2521638274,
0.3158788383,
0.5949432254,
0.8141887188,
0.2998805046,
-0.0653473511,
0.2854039073,
0.3804613948,
0.9640019536,
-0.7828754783,
-0.1533985138,
0.3237024844,
-0.5442152023,
-0.2272250354,
0.076736033,
-0.5716432929,
-0.5354579687,
-0.588139534,
0.3004870415,
-0.4725424051,
-0.7431025505,
0.3597654402,
0.0055240034,
0.2726929784,
0.5981467366,
-0.3970562816,
0.5819362998,
0.6418524384,
0.7475745082,
0.0196016096,
0.0066565219,
-0.033815641,
0.0637072176,
-0.3727410734,
0.6689938903,
-0.3487637043,
-0.7920107245,
0.3210656941,
0.1337841004,
0.0042227325,
-0.479228586,
0.4032551944,
-0.2266487777,
0.288238883,
-0.6071450114,
0.0455168523,
-0.2377528697,
0.5095569491,
-0.2226262838,
0.5549331903,
0.0586050563,
-0.6158412695,
0.1480300874,
-0.7422161698,
-0.4208937585,
0.0966634154,
-0.2162207514,
-0.1358813345,
0.1804103106,
0.3878052235,
0.1802430004,
-0.3065883517,
0.0398666561,
-0.4824767411,
-0.3285951912,
0.5339689851,
-0.4160230756,
0.8049336076,
0.4263423383,
-0.4220980108,
0.4648936391,
-0.5228056908,
0.2859577537,
0.1778000146,
0.1995714456,
-0.2775019407,
-0.0092315227,
0.0154620958,
0.194601506,
-0.0197847523,
-0.2969298661,
-0.2643573582,
-0.0351341926,
0.2295904458,
0.8387543559,
0.2801709473,
-0.082713671,
-0.5642522573,
0.6585944891,
0.0763678253,
0.7820785642,
-0.0704741776,
-0.612714231,
-0.447992146,
-0.5558975935,
-0.4078755379,
0.4613695443,
-0.8039697409,
0.3611258864,
0.0136614293,
-0.5707867146,
-0.6303784251,
-0.3161371648,
0.2819050252,
0.6079773903,
0.2864310145,
-0.5092619658,
-0.3839124441,
-0.7392263412,
-0.0227439813,
-0.5407131314,
-0.0016443434,
0.1730481088,
-0.0229746215,
-0.8050286174,
0.7912734747,
-0.4039480984,
-0.0981263965,
-0.2109906524,
-0.2105203867,
-0.2874416113,
0.0644964427,
0.3663505018,
-0.5354246497,
-0.3521095216,
0.1792044193,
-0.8986809254,
-0.1590510011,
0.2265843302,
-0.1753907353,
-0.1176298857,
0.3665141761,
-0.8443645239,
0.2778080106,
0.2111794055,
-0.4203460813,
0.2738444507,
-0.2253617793,
0.2684578896,
-1.0061506033,
-0.0478602163,
-0.1917357743,
-0.399711132,
-0.8813768625,
-0.1624109149,
-0.4807034433,
-0.2657363117,
-0.2557543814,
0.2951267362,
-0.3265693188,
0.1978007555,
-0.3563916385,
0.0814317837,
-0.3889021873,
0.3665072322,
-0.0121773575,
0.4628480375,
0.6325700283,
-0.5034940839,
0.272908628,
0.31295982,
0.2192049921,
1.0931524038,
-0.6532485485,
0.2966341078,
-0.2826166451,
0.3864233792,
-0.8709790707,
-0.190626055,
0.6593120694,
-0.5531835556,
-0.0919053033,
0.4069276452,
-0.1222772151,
-0.2961767316,
-0.2484098375,
0.1897957772,
0.6015149951,
-0.1384802312,
0.327059716,
0.8254148364,
-0.2967195213,
-0.3515923023,
-0.3652910888,
0.2070163786,
-0.1827200204,
-0.4274187386,
0.0573679544,
-0.2334563881,
-0.7812302709,
0.1515258551,
-0.1999597996,
-0.1693731844,
0.2233003825,
0.5454605222,
0.1530482918,
-0.3430589736,
0.2840389609,
0.0092926938,
-0.4270232618,
0.491584301,
-0.0128351049,
0.513109386,
-0.6227591634,
-0.5185317993,
-0.6572166085,
0.7258961201,
0.7094675303,
-0.1130059958,
0.8476675749,
0.7576450706,
-0.6869710684,
0.1430781782,
-0.4110317528,
-0.3291930258,
-0.3744638562,
0.1165290996,
-0.1377836466,
-0.7549567819,
0.2714888453,
-0.0481557772,
0.0945114046,
0.2154085934,
0.7922949791,
-0.0985465273,
1.4095717669,
0.625145793,
0.2077250034,
0.3726330101,
0.2064344287,
0.4245314598,
-0.3458075225,
-0.2661830783,
-0.2193177789,
0.1910370737,
-0.563282907,
-0.3842438161,
0.5359684825,
-0.4549395144,
-0.0911905915,
-0.0647071749,
-0.6518753171,
-0.2025544941,
0.2458828986,
0.4277317226,
0.3612620234,
-0.2041903585,
0.259547472,
-0.0527316593,
-0.2184410691,
-0.6966981292,
0.8344911933,
0.4331783056,
0.5186292529,
0.3304220438,
0.4827286899,
0.4583574235,
0.4563049674,
-0.8922373652,
0.5535567999,
0.736641407,
-0.7457607388,
-0.4086870253,
-0.189259693,
-1.0680059195,
0.4600557983,
-0.1395041198,
-0.770601809,
-0.0930678248,
0.0996510461,
-0.4438470602,
-0.1381688267,
-0.5420199037,
0.5725108385,
-0.2142695189,
-0.1378087848,
-0.4998906553,
-0.786190927,
0.3602226079,
0.0366587043,
0.2955924571,
-0.2024027258,
-0.0094227884,
0.4844937325,
-0.5970463753,
0.6423573494,
-0.1451378763,
0.1142670214,
0.3932124674,
-0.1319862902,
0.0642643869,
0.2176375687,
0.0824820623,
0.1163624078,
0.4844512939,
-0.415174067,
-0.7451868057,
0.4409138262,
-0.8484043479,
-0.8961069584,
-0.4157526493,
-0.1823371053,
-0.6540011168,
0.1233776659,
-0.0936619863,
0.359267056,
-0.5106506348,
0.0775874034,
0.917809844,
-0.1096420735,
-0.0113983275,
0.6122349501,
-0.3257939816,
-0.2789871097,
0.710042119,
-0.0181828942,
-0.0492673479,
0.0915544629,
0.1392936707,
0.0044556987,
-0.4251120985,
-0.0398998186,
0.1812462509,
-0.4050925374,
0.2546130121,
-0.9804484248,
-0.3914683759,
-0.4105779529,
-0.2347479016,
-0.3624714315,
-0.146334216,
0.0590169951,
-0.5348468423,
0.282148838,
0.8354344368,
-0.0896579176,
0.4504726231,
-0.602297008,
0.4060808122,
0.558916986,
0.0210995264,
0.1790834814,
0.2170108855,
-0.2156509608,
-0.094269298,
-0.454508096,
-1.2318502665,
0.2659049928,
-0.3757587969,
0.7626526952,
0.6551032662,
0.3958031833,
0.699658215,
-0.2174701542,
0.878888905,
0.308393538,
-0.7041431069,
0.4973374605,
-0.3990720809,
-0.0174588747,
0.6697513461,
0.3662729561,
-0.6300680041,
-0.1911358982,
-0.7462274432,
-0.8332244754,
0.5390701294,
0.454798311,
0.2188689858,
-0.1546883732,
-0.1160841584,
0.1333238035,
0.2748591602,
-0.285815984,
-0.4333156943,
-0.1212907434,
-0.350505054,
-0.16382505,
-0.3486188352,
-0.6056680679,
0.0105007626,
0.6060838699,
-0.0964211375,
0.6950152516,
0.535357058,
0.1232004836,
-0.3196607828,
0.3680980504,
0.5484061837,
0.9083567262,
-0.1913916916,
0.356828481,
0.25002262,
-0.6154556274,
0.1355917454,
0.1117623001,
0.4017660022,
0.1230277568,
0.0730130151,
0.6192236543,
-0.1052221954,
-0.7964884043,
0.4111134708,
-0.5314151645,
-0.0851609856,
-0.608481288,
0.0987564996,
-0.036025092,
0.2980134189,
-0.0272562075,
-0.1803680509,
0.3120304346,
-0.7896550298,
0.2016272098,
0.30309093,
-0.9625965953,
-0.4185132682,
0.5676611662,
0.2804755569,
-0.7285820246,
0.3321737051,
0.3569774628,
-0.1260549873,
0.3583544791,
0.4803004265,
0.8758231401,
-0.3142346442,
0.5172578096,
-0.0423057936,
0.4704436064,
-0.0081527745,
0.3388106227,
-0.2944775522,
-0.4167976975,
0.4225644767,
0.2511337996,
-0.966670692,
0.2272546738,
-0.8282700777,
-0.1043397412,
-0.60414958,
-0.6140179038,
-0.0741145238,
-0.1592063457,
-0.7516952753,
0.1626304388,
0.236632362,
0.4674267471,
-0.5262359977,
0.4997124374,
0.9246731997,
-0.2295752913,
-0.495818764,
0.1788042784,
0.3147257864,
-0.8291596174,
-0.4769144356,
0.0967361629,
-0.2198377103,
-0.3993595541,
-0.4592592418,
-0.428057909,
1.1492372751,
0.3588247001,
-0.2197114229,
-0.1102761254,
0.0365389138,
0.9084103107,
-0.0877306908,
0.6134188175,
0.372404784,
0.5001462102,
-0.1958810687,
-0.869109273,
0.3038586676,
-0.4895679057,
0.0872901902,
-0.1147937402,
-0.6127330065,
0.1868028343,
-0.1800336987,
-0.1470548213,
-0.0921967998,
0.5442530513,
0.3923531175,
0.8614695668,
0.5396897793,
0.1629273444,
0.9195924997,
0.2473375201,
1.1006906033,
-0.1296016276,
-0.0822111592,
1.0146837234,
-0.280808866,
0.3903836012,
0.5403935313,
-0.1919970065,
0.2596525252,
0.654374063,
0.6264907122,
0.261695683,
0.1844905615,
-0.5441781878,
-0.3700932562,
-0.4164494574,
-0.70259583,
0.0949979946,
0.5694262981,
-0.3146364987,
0.0954246819,
0.1827253252,
0.3843069673,
-0.0079163602,
-0.0698210746,
0.7917318344,
0.6247404814,
-0.5437157154,
0.0750773624,
-0.235048905,
0.0946483016,
-0.7492444515,
0.0622148961,
-0.0284401514,
0.1768673658,
-0.1442944109,
-0.6919777393,
0.2943992317,
-0.0055526663,
-0.1287874728,
-0.2442960888,
0.8037885427,
-0.0120167369,
-0.1316805631,
0.2438497096,
0.784881413,
0.2491260916,
-0.2364031374,
-0.6539339423,
-0.0623233914,
-0.3243563771,
-0.266267091,
0.2720378041,
0.5058530569,
-0.1852540374,
0.7284799814,
0.7049580216,
-0.0518627837,
-0.1089227647,
-0.113884829,
0.6398562789,
-0.6153624058,
-0.459518522,
-0.5685260892,
0.7114578485,
-0.2429954261,
-0.3267219663,
0.6946853399,
-0.0449419878,
0.2909290493,
0.0024220489,
0.9259157777,
0.039901983,
0.3486109674,
-0.1884229779,
0.8035558462,
-0.4923557639,
-0.2617926896,
-0.2172928602,
-0.6979097128,
-0.0352116078,
0.435873419,
-0.0499065667,
-0.1467154622,
0.6277521253,
0.649158597,
0.3369448781,
0.2456188649,
0.6148598194,
0.2878516912,
0.7131823897,
0.3599238694,
1.1669012308,
-0.1274811924,
0.3595121205,
-0.1832347065,
-0.2038742602,
-0.239954412,
-0.348976016,
-0.7609181404,
-0.5066058636,
-0.4649150074,
-0.2384758741,
0.2455357164,
1.1540710926,
0.6415913701,
-0.5612733364,
0.0473019034,
0.119630143,
0.1993007809,
-0.5148037076,
-0.2564770877,
-0.1718006432,
0.06761197,
-0.3273561299,
0.2949724793,
0.3062376678,
-0.1700789779,
-0.1770207733,
-0.0350660905,
0.4043299854,
0.4407305121,
0.782458365,
0.4520899951,
-0.7820338607,
-0.0906525552,
-0.0578588545,
-0.3802149296,
0.0395950042,
0.6377147436,
-0.404669255,
0.7058111429,
0.3209344745,
0.6806665063,
0.2692082226,
-0.0783639178,
0.870747745,
0.3630590737,
-0.1817620695,
0.2140439749,
0.2674713433,
0.0363041274,
-0.6869464517,
0.5444034934,
-0.0256662406,
-0.4075781107,
-0.9566347599,
0.0021704512,
-1.3881152868,
-0.0087307664,
1.0224422216,
-0.1215881705,
-0.0489343926,
-0.5141384602,
-0.9410625696,
0.3180504739,
-0.4339647591,
0.8980425,
0.3552410901,
-0.406509012,
-0.2928474844,
-0.7119554877,
0.4276520908,
0.1198446006,
-1.2335834503,
-0.0657525584,
0.4298864603,
0.1583090574,
-0.0604926944,
1.2281019688,
-0.2618329823,
0.3881880045,
0.0293816682,
0.0948205218,
-0.2167322189,
-0.1371330917,
-0.2481528372,
0.1466857493,
0.3109743595,
-0.3639625609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13188v1 | TABLET: Learning From Instructions For Tabular Data | 2023-04-25T23:07:20 | 2023-04-25T23:07:20 | Dylan Slack, Sameer Singh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Acquiring high-quality data is often a significant challenge in training
machine learning (ML) models for tabular prediction, particularly in
privacy-sensitive and costly domains like medicine and finance. Providing
natural language instructions to large language models (LLMs) offers an
alternative solution. However, it is unclear how effectively instructions
leverage the knowledge in LLMs for solving tabular prediction problems. To
address this gap, we introduce TABLET, a benchmark of 20 diverse tabular
datasets annotated with instructions that vary in their phrasing, granularity,
and technicality. Additionally, TABLET includes the instructions' logic and
structured modifications to the instructions. We find in-context instructions
increase zero-shot F1 performance for Flan-T5 11b by 44% on average and 13% for
ChatGPT on TABLET. Also, we explore the limitations of using LLMs for tabular
prediction in our benchmark by evaluating instruction faithfulness. We find
LLMs often ignore instructions and fail to predict specific instances
correctly, even with examples. Our analysis on TABLET shows that, while
instructions help LLM performance, learning from instructions for tabular data
requires new capabilities. | [
0.0552566648,
-0.9305559397,
0.7389833927,
0.1159147322,
-0.1001742408,
0.0861284062,
-0.4213266075,
-0.2476689816,
-0.291685611,
0.8260635734,
-0.3994967937,
-0.8748746514,
-0.5571322441,
-0.1983281225,
-0.2385808229,
1.26818645,
-0.3231032193,
0.1638280153,
-0.2583021224,
0.1288108528,
-0.5608603358,
-0.0734090656,
-0.2900315523,
-0.2732005417,
0.4820985198,
0.9417920113,
0.4645379484,
1.0981377363,
0.6664499044,
0.2080077678,
0.2948683202,
0.3132274449,
-0.4390096664,
0.16678074,
0.1195208505,
-0.5159988403,
-0.4606671929,
0.1286957264,
0.4885354936,
0.637116611,
-0.3648593724,
0.3084189892,
0.1607423723,
0.9680644274,
-0.4431088865,
0.6278285384,
-0.8122614026,
0.28102988,
-0.2029928267,
-0.2097712755,
-0.7898008823,
-0.6844418645,
0.2023849636,
-0.5940137506,
0.37558797,
0.3181595504,
0.6958791018,
-0.0083275018,
-0.1673899889,
-0.4523563385,
-0.8073093295,
0.4460290074,
-0.4913202822,
0.3916222751,
0.3863582611,
0.6147096157,
-0.5733003616,
-0.9996955991,
-0.477833569,
-0.5757474899,
-0.0043583801,
-0.1422587484,
0.2460229248,
0.3813407123,
0.3966470957,
0.2123384327,
-0.649843514,
-0.0459270664,
-0.5997995734,
0.1017638147,
0.4110237658,
0.2597348988,
0.2839100659,
0.0671093911,
-0.4673492908,
-0.217450887,
-0.8169869781,
0.148058027,
0.1059943363,
0.4656575024,
-0.2740901709,
0.5384892821,
-0.2832356095,
0.844034791,
0.0962471887,
-0.2410677671,
0.2401919812,
0.1633882076,
-0.4922432303,
0.314715445,
0.6959232092,
0.158638835,
0.1178515628,
-0.5293388963,
-0.208457008,
-0.3828299642,
0.5718163848,
-0.7752327919,
-0.3724929988,
0.1047309116,
-0.2319506258,
-0.0299724545,
0.0619393587,
-0.9124397039,
-0.8299726248,
-0.4908571243,
0.58258605,
-0.326518774,
0.5042675138,
-0.2629518509,
0.1049651504,
0.1974429339,
0.4452824891,
-1.1767383814,
0.6097185612,
0.9828135967,
0.6583015919,
-0.1894637495,
-0.5723807812,
-0.9006685019,
0.2157117873,
-0.6617544889,
0.892147541,
-0.5901684165,
-0.2547015846,
-0.1020770818,
0.1128465012,
-0.3809797466,
-0.7967419624,
0.4575420916,
-0.0401870273,
-0.0480958261,
-0.384093374,
-0.6859246492,
-0.1901201606,
0.1298636496,
-0.9488399625,
0.8229026794,
0.2194849998,
-0.3098501265,
0.8881476521,
-0.8098246455,
-0.5371208191,
0.0382617787,
-0.2462365776,
-0.5015557408,
0.2538378239,
0.1315990537,
0.7259998322,
-0.2064272165,
0.1681369096,
-0.3567735255,
-0.4204142094,
0.2696964443,
-0.4003869295,
0.06949009,
-0.0773327649,
-0.5950447917,
0.1782100499,
-0.6641123295,
-0.1590010375,
-0.1885445416,
-0.4152452946,
0.429220289,
-0.03289368,
-0.239159286,
-0.1382579505,
-0.172582984,
-0.4390636981,
0.2420833409,
-0.1954165697,
0.1694257408,
0.7198435664,
-0.1008062586,
0.4881761968,
-0.306810081,
0.3260406852,
-0.1807393879,
0.1673454791,
0.0435266532,
-0.5103556514,
-0.3939587176,
-0.011567248,
0.3702868819,
0.5989000797,
-0.5897163153,
-0.2992094159,
-0.4157564342,
-0.4800616503,
-0.2971161008,
0.5768101215,
0.5354931951,
0.7706509233,
0.4348922968,
0.0494809672,
-0.3219608366,
-0.7826228142,
-0.4872160554,
0.0010330123,
0.007171771,
0.4370886385,
0.3095122278,
0.1308094859,
0.4054044187,
-0.2249349952,
-0.391585052,
-0.7347385883,
0.2401408404,
0.2412546128,
0.2287875414,
0.0547918454,
-0.620022893,
-0.8681587577,
0.3556696773,
-0.7904401422,
0.0218026452,
-0.1673077196,
-0.026479803,
0.3625589311,
0.4383285046,
-0.7359464169,
0.5911772847,
0.3888901174,
-0.1358330995,
0.4486448467,
-0.4543454945,
0.1452852041,
-0.7448305488,
-0.1331168711,
0.1605047584,
-0.1628548503,
-0.8457366824,
-0.2640929818,
0.3216592371,
-0.0750635862,
-0.5220698118,
0.6600427628,
-0.5034002662,
-0.1735030711,
-0.1937161535,
0.1035823002,
0.1416816562,
0.4446907341,
-0.0311645772,
0.8957925439,
0.1098600477,
-0.5139316916,
0.3881361783,
0.0892914832,
-0.5209488273,
0.2667346001,
-0.3112538755,
-0.0334728397,
-0.0419296585,
0.1586574316,
-0.844042778,
-0.5234050155,
0.1975749284,
-0.2430119663,
0.8351275325,
-0.0818880498,
-0.3149990737,
-0.2783454061,
-0.2982387245,
-0.019297557,
0.3103968501,
-0.5729737282,
0.684628129,
0.4812820256,
-0.0108103584,
-0.8272484541,
-0.6274911761,
0.03097599,
-0.2148602605,
-0.2226593792,
0.4990867972,
0.4085083008,
-0.1857382208,
-0.0581441522,
-0.2147381604,
-0.0505349636,
-0.142723009,
0.5534670949,
0.1449842006,
-0.0601511523,
0.1920040697,
-0.0398274511,
-0.0000581245,
0.1065572649,
-0.2809649706,
0.5563754439,
-0.1060002521,
-0.0364407711,
-0.579646647,
-0.1336391419,
0.3921685219,
0.1028692722,
0.8764218688,
0.6620423794,
-0.4421181679,
-0.5103898644,
-0.6002513766,
-0.1203932688,
-0.5105468631,
0.2458252013,
-0.2757974267,
-0.1144929379,
0.405349195,
0.0850705057,
0.2017173022,
0.1212339625,
0.4350017607,
-0.3541098237,
0.5095846057,
0.4812152982,
-0.0272112899,
0.4400829673,
-0.3449987173,
0.1527797431,
-0.6835756302,
-0.5637775064,
-0.3794074357,
-0.4798360467,
-0.5927351117,
-0.3682405651,
0.3503917754,
-0.3145231903,
-0.21702604,
0.308981508,
-0.3167073727,
0.6894868612,
0.6663883924,
0.5859591961,
0.0758472979,
0.3087635934,
-0.0813833103,
0.0612472147,
-0.5934406519,
-0.5538657904,
1.3987767696,
0.3957842588,
0.896938026,
-0.3638314903,
0.709536612,
0.5991033912,
0.6171705723,
-0.3993583918,
0.5388580561,
-0.5779982209,
-0.482014358,
-0.2702283263,
-0.7362377048,
-0.939219296,
-0.1718076169,
-0.123981677,
-1.1639441252,
-0.319380492,
0.3998710811,
-0.3640173376,
0.3609408736,
-1.0429265499,
1.4002629519,
-0.2594983876,
-0.719260335,
0.1561253071,
-0.4645322561,
0.1539337784,
0.2084463984,
0.1022909805,
-0.0996878669,
0.1965262592,
0.8221305013,
-0.3558879793,
0.7301741838,
-0.3947475255,
0.1762756705,
0.3744878769,
0.1095904931,
0.42621243,
-0.0817777216,
0.0432503223,
-0.1940781325,
-0.098824203,
-0.3633534014,
-0.7144012451,
0.7468613386,
-0.5581103563,
-0.6049417257,
-0.0587598383,
-0.6526516676,
-0.4610268176,
-0.1440732181,
0.256071806,
0.6290404797,
-0.0590600632,
0.283062309,
0.7209857106,
-0.3088545203,
0.4361503422,
0.044257082,
-0.1548653096,
-0.4689981639,
0.9655669928,
0.3384416401,
0.17062518,
0.7491505742,
0.2863574624,
-0.5381159782,
-0.6160125136,
-0.9624225497,
0.0065253265,
-0.758240521,
-0.2010849416,
-0.3751000166,
-0.0433148518,
-0.1875816435,
0.103123486,
-0.2064082325,
-0.2972100079,
-0.001253848,
-0.5529028773,
0.3922867775,
0.8333182335,
0.3045153022,
0.4533810318,
-0.8605895042,
0.434523195,
0.1534218639,
0.5672844648,
-0.0757169276,
-0.3617296517,
-0.3690838218,
0.125158608,
-0.3929195404,
-1.0761413574,
0.3670914769,
0.2909246385,
0.7034780979,
0.2623453438,
-0.0907040015,
0.6789965034,
-0.5380114913,
0.4670331776,
-0.3145608008,
-0.7255561948,
0.3715450466,
-0.2123711854,
0.1921118945,
0.7751988173,
0.2354561538,
-0.2843694687,
-0.1960453242,
-0.3496259153,
-0.6159790158,
0.8074786663,
-0.1754630357,
0.0550180376,
0.3986739516,
0.5514473915,
0.5799149871,
0.4355635047,
-0.7789905667,
0.0217002239,
0.2100705504,
-0.6423180699,
-0.0205383133,
-0.1387562305,
-0.0246041324,
-0.1499829292,
0.4499242008,
0.0299638323,
0.3077450693,
0.0263978429,
-0.2875347435,
-0.1727162004,
0.1817657501,
0.678000927,
0.6893676519,
-0.2635890543,
0.0544776395,
0.3146633506,
-0.9089156389,
-0.1059443727,
0.1122361869,
-0.06673491,
0.0062269238,
0.272765249,
1.0021883249,
0.1463426501,
-0.6540632248,
0.2608020306,
-0.1212807968,
-0.2490679622,
-0.1225003749,
0.2675147951,
-0.1272441745,
0.0951990709,
0.2281742841,
-0.393645376,
0.1987780333,
-0.8026079535,
0.3657806218,
0.3058187366,
-0.4672231376,
-0.065924488,
0.5558137894,
-0.1705113202,
-0.3452249467,
0.5396336317,
-0.3080933988,
-0.3593915105,
0.6735194325,
0.4603870511,
0.6777077317,
-0.102002807,
0.5733624101,
0.0965837985,
0.2249415219,
-0.1416541636,
0.3623047471,
-0.0111392969,
-0.1664533615,
-0.1249088719,
-0.6176583767,
-0.7912668586,
0.2080344856,
-0.3642566204,
0.1705645323,
-0.7092280388,
0.0012272611,
0.0589680597,
0.346653074,
-0.6673786044,
0.1231729612,
0.1670719087,
0.8848697543,
-0.5329329967,
0.7072144747,
0.3431495428,
-0.0462859645,
-1.1206184626,
-0.0738424882,
-0.1253408641,
-0.5044116378,
0.3151286542,
0.5859490037,
0.3406385183,
-0.4835151136,
-0.3599853814,
-0.2112325281,
0.9876561761,
0.3911391497,
-0.4336346388,
-0.0166348964,
0.7577041984,
0.477776587,
-0.4363234341,
0.2128386945,
0.7536474466,
0.3760188222,
-0.092311874,
-0.9810672402,
0.0633815676,
-0.0091211963,
-0.4637743235,
0.2845387459,
-0.1835497469,
0.9791288972,
-0.3632519841,
-0.0697767735,
-0.2403375655,
0.4363517165,
0.1433393806,
0.9080506563,
-0.02726404,
0.3902616501,
0.8710003495,
-0.1491111219,
1.1341751814,
-0.1843786985,
-0.0839803591,
1.2949286699,
-0.3271501958,
1.0256487131,
0.284311384,
0.0121170422,
0.6365719438,
0.6047745943,
-0.1043273434,
0.3969023526,
0.1163180172,
-0.1587482989,
0.2582733333,
0.1460077465,
-0.1534104347,
0.3890524805,
0.6666713357,
-0.5953312516,
-0.2205003202,
-0.0565568916,
0.0099841757,
0.0961433128,
-0.4841269851,
0.9752672315,
-0.011807383,
-0.7252415419,
0.5189065933,
-0.1852182746,
-0.1442029923,
-0.3087040186,
-0.2428686321,
-0.2282999009,
0.324206531,
-0.3140647411,
-0.6495124698,
-0.0724044368,
0.0594080314,
0.0261831861,
-0.0453986973,
0.5125285387,
-0.4092959762,
-0.6028946638,
-0.0936691761,
0.4839358926,
0.1810408086,
-0.0853451416,
-0.4429261386,
-0.1864775717,
-0.1336050183,
-0.2478422523,
0.4125698209,
0.5271317363,
-0.051433783,
0.9817739129,
0.4112581313,
0.170566842,
0.3632332087,
-0.1582408845,
0.7701708078,
-0.5762727857,
-0.3148573339,
-1.0227072239,
0.2027444392,
-0.2028502524,
-0.1437786222,
0.4479209185,
0.6432965398,
0.7727353573,
-0.2225219756,
0.5383011699,
0.2793090343,
0.3995909989,
-0.9033693075,
0.7267491221,
-0.2676476836,
0.4613465369,
0.0268952586,
-1.0050451756,
-0.3723902404,
0.3727402687,
-0.7323019505,
0.0125364494,
0.7513743639,
0.8157085776,
-0.1647251695,
0.2987673879,
0.207609728,
0.0065227812,
0.1270933598,
0.531001091,
0.5386943817,
-0.2396781594,
0.7123548388,
-0.546363771,
-0.0259847566,
-0.1885693967,
-0.6191462874,
-1.028516531,
-0.4255245626,
0.0032386847,
-0.2025462538,
0.4705225527,
1.1347676516,
0.6307606101,
-0.7980904579,
-0.4445976317,
-0.3843009472,
0.3048767745,
-0.2556619346,
-0.1678256541,
0.4883659482,
-0.5410326719,
-0.413619101,
0.2781079412,
0.2372490019,
0.000532494,
0.0443341061,
-0.0599537529,
0.2390795052,
-0.1717201024,
0.3412337899,
0.3012530208,
-0.5231195092,
0.1038464084,
0.1770687252,
-0.1851409972,
0.3334176838,
0.8790681958,
-0.6640628576,
0.434354037,
0.3750965893,
0.6358607411,
0.6342706084,
0.1261468977,
0.7216850519,
-0.6752233505,
-0.1305594891,
0.1475582272,
0.2776093185,
0.3787240088,
-0.3677455485,
0.3696759939,
-0.246918723,
-0.6162013412,
-0.9362567067,
-0.2315187752,
-0.8557788134,
-0.126519382,
1.2125817537,
-0.3780642152,
-0.8000223637,
0.0148189906,
-0.2609670162,
0.2211940885,
-0.670928359,
1.2971836329,
0.3019517362,
-0.2770929337,
-0.4238750041,
-1.0635483265,
0.8224930763,
-0.0207532272,
-1.0708185434,
0.4763298929,
0.2945721745,
0.0280161183,
-0.0911790431,
0.3004672825,
-0.0252980646,
0.4778339863,
0.1964588761,
-0.1516170055,
-0.2788724899,
-0.8860398531,
-0.0137839299,
0.3723685145,
0.1660024822,
-0.281394124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13180v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13180v2 | Sebis at SemEval-2023 Task 7: A Joint System for Natural Language Inference and Evidence Retrieval from Clinical Trial Reports | 2023-04-25T22:22:42 | 2023-05-02T16:46:33 | Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing number of clinical trial reports generated every day, it
is becoming hard to keep up with novel discoveries that inform evidence-based
healthcare recommendations. To help automate this process and assist medical
experts, NLP solutions are being developed. This motivated the SemEval-2023
Task 7, where the goal was to develop an NLP system for two tasks: evidence
retrieval and natural language inference from clinical trial data. In this
paper, we describe our two developed systems. The first one is a pipeline
system that models the two tasks separately, while the second one is a joint
system that learns the two tasks simultaneously with a shared representation
and a multi-task learning approach. The final system combines their outputs in
an ensemble system. We formalize the models, present their characteristics and
challenges, and provide an analysis of achieved results. Our system ranked 3rd
out of 40 participants with a final submission. | [
0.0634169802,
-0.4675418139,
0.8819274902,
0.3557369113,
-0.2976284325,
-0.0954648629,
0.0745034814,
-0.7290440798,
0.4708675444,
0.8634086251,
-0.294486165,
-0.4396690726,
-0.9236679673,
0.2676786482,
-0.3603495955,
0.9707320333,
-0.0576574579,
0.4880269468,
-0.2561350465,
-0.2752972841,
-0.5470314622,
-0.4990676045,
-0.5477529764,
-0.4040001333,
0.4166199267,
0.3583977222,
0.2077965587,
0.1670499146,
0.7992699742,
0.2894559205,
0.309438318,
-0.0229771677,
0.0215275418,
0.5006415844,
-0.2381331772,
-0.3961027563,
-0.405834645,
-0.2318076193,
-0.0188593585,
0.843775332,
-0.1771479994,
0.0641125962,
0.2000773251,
0.3562205136,
-0.6843817234,
0.2265896946,
-0.328750819,
0.0733747631,
-0.0506087318,
-0.3651445508,
-0.4561229646,
-0.1949896961,
0.4848747551,
-0.6344903111,
0.268078655,
0.1571661085,
0.4821856916,
0.1348680854,
-0.5697228909,
-0.6537507176,
-0.2392091304,
0.793376565,
-1.0339949131,
-0.0649280101,
0.3058964908,
0.3089810014,
-0.2212672383,
-0.889352262,
-0.0825631842,
-0.003693644,
-0.2368963361,
0.2159144878,
-0.0201398376,
0.1488448381,
-0.0380131602,
0.228190586,
-0.6978557706,
0.0800383389,
-0.4556722343,
-0.4030410647,
0.7512069941,
-0.0919557884,
0.4121675193,
-0.2779630721,
-0.4054040611,
0.0722365454,
-0.5683372021,
-0.4131120741,
-0.2431183606,
0.4791598618,
0.1486672163,
0.5729795098,
-0.4182533324,
0.4111568332,
-0.3045457602,
0.0191887449,
0.5500670075,
-0.1800241023,
-0.5193099976,
0.5161161423,
0.8374643922,
0.2308119386,
-0.4418753386,
-0.4083559215,
-0.1743935794,
0.5305339694,
0.3004841506,
-0.241246894,
-0.0534981601,
0.3659473062,
-0.63346982,
-0.3561106026,
-0.3073511422,
-0.8281850219,
-0.6154896021,
-0.4369532466,
1.0802943707,
-0.363165617,
-0.222856909,
0.2888285518,
-0.4005376399,
-0.085544914,
0.6473508477,
-0.7081317902,
0.6548560262,
0.6819493175,
0.509581089,
-0.4352504313,
-0.1634230167,
-0.7876395583,
0.116618827,
-0.0124105783,
0.917480886,
-0.529825747,
-0.2742414176,
0.0315596461,
0.3680287004,
-0.1256491244,
-0.5427820086,
0.935565412,
-0.3618681431,
0.4921227396,
-0.4593835175,
-0.6542034745,
-0.2239928842,
0.0359203033,
-0.4535515308,
0.7572596669,
-0.3417707086,
-0.7492733002,
0.5564739704,
-0.5343075395,
-0.5532222986,
0.3128784895,
-0.2680409551,
-0.2527493238,
0.1793493479,
0.1939173043,
0.571174562,
-0.3616528809,
0.3908049762,
-0.5151248574,
-0.1825459003,
-0.4627716243,
-0.1483294815,
0.7188897133,
0.329667896,
-0.544829011,
-0.058480747,
-0.5923871398,
-0.1856727451,
0.0326872692,
-0.2735039294,
-0.4578405619,
0.0618263334,
-0.0870413929,
0.0546580218,
0.241526857,
-0.6800810099,
0.142723158,
-0.3549047112,
0.2236198783,
0.346639961,
0.2517998219,
0.413516432,
-0.3327759504,
0.3870407939,
0.0090415664,
-0.0680477992,
-0.1657786816,
-0.5812698007,
-0.6736559868,
0.1129986793,
0.3275988996,
0.4788529277,
-0.8170000315,
0.158021003,
-0.0406271592,
-0.1248636842,
-0.4326978624,
-0.1804228425,
0.1810752898,
0.360619843,
0.6598696113,
-0.4624489844,
-0.7188977003,
-0.8871612549,
-0.2923166752,
-0.0068763113,
-0.2184198201,
-0.0149779459,
0.7557735443,
0.0603589229,
0.3995255828,
-0.1872978061,
-0.4005264342,
-0.3727534413,
0.5101264119,
0.2986240685,
0.6023012996,
0.2057790458,
-0.5202775598,
-0.067508541,
0.0053506913,
-0.9530146122,
-0.4741822779,
-0.1013306603,
-0.1277962327,
0.0940296948,
0.4947696626,
-0.2511947751,
0.5961927176,
0.3401911855,
-0.2941733897,
0.3127543926,
-0.3296664953,
0.3400678933,
-1.0704923868,
0.0312810987,
-0.2219685763,
-0.3365150392,
-0.576167047,
-0.1986207068,
-0.1347681582,
0.1331044585,
-0.056998603,
0.3585042953,
-0.5057441592,
-0.1825739443,
-0.2353088558,
-0.1120202169,
0.1854423583,
0.519790709,
0.2669831812,
0.2042624801,
0.491513133,
-0.5817824602,
0.1173671708,
0.2008804381,
-0.260486424,
0.4881834984,
-0.7465456724,
-0.0792247579,
-0.0475623608,
0.0445322841,
-0.6115575433,
-0.6494269371,
0.1753846258,
-0.3856777847,
0.1392063946,
-0.0907219574,
-0.3225000799,
-0.3177147806,
0.053600274,
-0.152866438,
0.3199668825,
-0.2855130732,
0.5313811302,
0.8746222258,
-0.6368517876,
-0.5242732167,
-0.6889482141,
0.2097491771,
-0.145171538,
-0.2697541714,
0.4074299037,
0.4927916229,
-0.1626255065,
0.1026936024,
-0.1960948557,
-0.1378780156,
-0.0927707627,
0.3516346812,
0.2619691789,
-0.2142671347,
0.4721232057,
0.3120855987,
0.0088324239,
0.2306742072,
-0.0973347574,
0.2605800033,
-0.1036453247,
-0.8480984569,
-0.2559610307,
0.7259368896,
0.4601083696,
-0.1491435617,
0.4299966991,
0.4590725601,
-0.652205348,
-0.0605860911,
-0.7570217252,
-0.1656880677,
-0.3648197651,
0.0017380537,
-0.0477522351,
-0.8436287045,
0.2896645069,
-0.2246925831,
0.3906773329,
0.8145153522,
0.7067533731,
-0.1073187962,
1.2258942127,
0.2500746846,
0.3209497929,
0.0406978428,
-0.0728723705,
0.039521955,
-0.668733418,
-0.4017860293,
-0.5271881223,
-0.2256450057,
-0.1168492138,
-0.4538806081,
0.559374094,
-0.0174374934,
-0.1484928876,
0.3631565273,
-0.6860557199,
-0.1321213394,
0.8264137506,
0.2632982135,
0.4669094086,
-0.0420119837,
-0.4681095779,
0.0469106287,
-0.6795725822,
-0.6037814617,
1.1365720034,
0.0596411042,
0.477524817,
0.1743482202,
0.9556667805,
0.4461261332,
0.2019371092,
-0.3546310365,
0.5128362179,
0.008633377,
-0.7650344968,
-0.1101480722,
-0.0968647972,
-1.1519879103,
0.3796911538,
-0.497417897,
-0.7752114534,
0.2869596779,
-0.0884927064,
-0.5783948898,
-0.1315765828,
-0.889210999,
0.8638007641,
-0.1487469226,
-0.5123190284,
-0.3377387524,
-0.945684135,
0.2323760986,
0.1675117463,
0.2052123696,
-0.3760129809,
0.17904374,
0.8808752894,
-0.573533535,
0.7581261992,
-0.3162575364,
0.4513173699,
0.3234618008,
-0.0498389751,
0.3954434097,
0.2423442304,
-0.1691399515,
-0.354300648,
0.5897051692,
-0.4620719552,
-0.5253512263,
0.5911054015,
-0.4310316741,
-0.4673981965,
-0.7925519347,
-0.2097321153,
-0.209935382,
0.3466710448,
0.0214454029,
0.7387393117,
-0.2742094994,
0.3136844933,
0.2238565534,
-0.4218485057,
0.3685618043,
0.4985671341,
-0.0980972424,
-0.1811692417,
0.5402435064,
-0.1698688567,
0.0710992962,
0.4173899293,
0.0414506756,
-0.4180421829,
-0.7184801698,
-0.1711213291,
0.0954274982,
-0.5021787882,
-0.1873937696,
-0.8710814714,
-0.0843861103,
-0.9003491998,
-0.0046917582,
-0.2338151336,
-0.5084043145,
-0.1824129522,
0.0992542803,
0.0657368079,
0.9785738587,
-0.1494405717,
0.0183608383,
-0.9609934092,
0.2508842051,
0.2544966936,
0.0174458139,
-0.3464696407,
-0.3347127736,
-0.0914432183,
-0.1044340432,
-0.3104475737,
-0.9755131006,
0.6822211742,
0.0000055994,
0.7029429078,
0.1545638889,
0.2538716197,
0.4794357419,
-0.4323717654,
0.6549756527,
0.2522047162,
-0.5870349407,
0.7490807772,
-0.3244087696,
0.2951407135,
0.9649240375,
0.2319345027,
-0.5272287726,
-0.266251415,
-0.7297725677,
-0.6968214512,
0.6872996688,
0.338208735,
-0.4462419748,
0.0547081344,
0.0207918864,
0.3791084588,
0.3707119823,
-0.2764477432,
0.2236469239,
0.1311729997,
-0.444432348,
0.1390240937,
-0.128513366,
-0.3710997403,
0.0372043923,
0.7379660606,
-0.329960227,
0.5348734856,
0.6074557304,
-0.2839458883,
0.181312412,
0.5329036713,
0.1876924485,
0.4964287281,
-0.2081565112,
0.1652104557,
0.4368680418,
-0.4718782306,
-0.0718080327,
0.210428223,
0.2270462364,
0.1499226093,
0.6954978108,
0.9152528048,
0.3001604676,
-0.7537680268,
0.6174779534,
-0.1038449332,
-0.4001963735,
-0.3235006034,
-0.1135483682,
0.116100274,
0.313934356,
0.3632001281,
0.5613696575,
0.7676222324,
-0.4897524416,
0.4434198737,
0.1616000086,
-0.5358811021,
-0.2943195999,
0.7552258968,
0.3933300674,
-0.1437771767,
-0.0106752729,
-0.3264804184,
-0.395363152,
0.6815315485,
0.3560843468,
0.5851077437,
0.0778737962,
0.3693754971,
0.3422234356,
-0.058884643,
-0.4103794694,
0.435153842,
0.1068687961,
-0.5383168459,
-0.6311557889,
-0.5866838098,
-0.4967021644,
0.0366092734,
-0.7812386155,
0.4204603732,
0.0497630872,
-0.0993547216,
0.1756193489,
0.1519858837,
-0.6230160594,
0.2206617296,
0.2226617932,
0.6436709762,
-0.8773686886,
0.581342876,
0.8220591545,
-0.1406553388,
-0.7107219696,
-0.5735515356,
0.3789149821,
-0.7467484474,
0.4031431675,
0.1797367483,
0.1074533165,
-0.3387157917,
-0.2863204181,
-0.7846392989,
1.1307854652,
0.1643829942,
-0.3813055158,
-0.2332561761,
-0.0657683313,
0.6489413977,
-0.4341916144,
0.3891000748,
0.5438704491,
0.1545878798,
0.3717088401,
-1.0908231735,
-0.0357031077,
-0.3125027716,
-0.5286490917,
0.0792663619,
-0.2328118086,
0.3094697893,
-0.1660337299,
-0.2531762719,
0.1127248704,
0.5886462927,
0.4970856309,
0.7400315404,
0.6035460234,
0.6544363499,
0.7335035801,
-0.1171354204,
0.8910550475,
-0.1575602889,
0.3797774911,
1.3506265879,
-0.5955310464,
0.8110954762,
0.60507375,
-0.2881071866,
0.3603171706,
0.6005573869,
0.2788223326,
0.5770410299,
-0.1678922027,
-0.4015798569,
-0.4133440852,
-0.3523540497,
-0.4860961437,
0.3922076523,
0.5818314552,
-0.5378103852,
-0.3002471328,
0.0051509743,
-0.1804295182,
-0.3276999891,
0.0192547683,
0.8035701513,
0.2575310469,
-1.1466242075,
-0.1051416919,
-0.3988845348,
0.2622517347,
-0.489913404,
-0.1790549159,
0.2207261026,
0.2503513396,
-0.1084885672,
-0.5477206707,
0.3791078329,
-0.2187345922,
0.3175888062,
-0.2725114524,
0.9804180264,
-0.3598766327,
-0.5492520928,
0.2760358453,
0.5542176366,
0.1529175043,
0.0944661424,
-0.7038593292,
0.0740580559,
-0.0244053975,
-0.3200006485,
0.2262152284,
0.3469836116,
0.1073033065,
0.4637408555,
0.3314124346,
0.3884845972,
0.1213364601,
0.2904322445,
0.6034353971,
-0.2811831236,
-0.3982276022,
-0.4880842865,
0.2072230428,
-0.4170418382,
-0.2093991041,
0.4710395336,
0.4272416532,
0.2527977228,
0.2048800588,
0.9432612062,
-0.2566320896,
1.1515477896,
-0.5256705284,
0.2613645792,
-0.7709322572,
0.3191236258,
-0.1915144473,
-0.5538409948,
-0.3818238974,
0.3591672778,
-0.4120336771,
-0.2729021907,
0.9722281098,
0.5153431296,
0.1562754214,
0.6001211405,
0.0409165062,
0.1328225136,
0.2878083885,
0.7807145715,
0.4798256457,
-0.6799789667,
0.2788138986,
-0.2227410823,
-0.0933137834,
-0.2971080244,
-0.5263265967,
-0.5257058144,
-0.6080866456,
-0.1489928365,
-0.1809305251,
0.263884902,
1.1333463192,
0.7152332664,
-1.1671094894,
0.0426128507,
-0.3122048378,
-0.195953548,
-0.189152509,
-0.1538993865,
0.4083021581,
-0.5409681797,
-0.7017365098,
0.4994901121,
0.6277891994,
-0.302868396,
0.1155391335,
0.0113781914,
-0.6295593977,
-0.2784486115,
0.425891906,
0.145114392,
-0.5819052458,
-0.2626619339,
0.1404413432,
-0.2731242478,
-0.1544517428,
0.7642516494,
-1.0277528763,
0.6539316177,
0.9214977026,
0.8212556243,
0.6282013059,
-0.1630535275,
0.9603930712,
-0.170238331,
-0.0319512822,
0.5460498333,
0.5797427893,
0.0782296509,
-0.0680517927,
0.8386455774,
0.3778540492,
-0.910272181,
-0.79424721,
-0.1385609806,
-0.9317066073,
-0.3014855683,
0.8830760717,
-0.1710258573,
-0.1085929126,
-0.6241164207,
-0.2018787116,
0.3901029527,
-0.3427675962,
0.5854758024,
0.7078186274,
-0.2636811137,
0.1043025479,
-1.0635248423,
0.4602131844,
0.917948544,
-0.904268384,
-0.5193460584,
0.3012361825,
0.0273672193,
0.2474837303,
0.8236583471,
-0.125380829,
0.2882064283,
0.0540935844,
0.1530164182,
0.5648844838,
-0.1635101587,
-0.1919481903,
0.2903368175,
-0.3580844402,
-0.1524290293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13149v1 | Modeling Spoken Information Queries for Virtual Assistants: Open Problems, Challenges and Opportunities | 2023-04-25T20:52:40 | 2023-04-25T20:52:40 | Christophe Van Gysel | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Virtual assistants are becoming increasingly important speech-driven
Information Retrieval platforms that assist users with various tasks.
We discuss open problems and challenges with respect to modeling spoken
information queries for virtual assistants, and list opportunities where
Information Retrieval methods and research can be applied to improve the
quality of virtual assistant speech recognition.
We discuss how query domain classification, knowledge graphs and user
interaction data, and query personalization can be helpful to improve the
accurate recognition of spoken information domain queries. Finally, we also
provide a brief overview of current problems and challenges in speech
recognition. | [
-0.2533841431,
-1.0699584484,
0.5106927156,
-0.0300280582,
0.3112887442,
-0.0028990498,
0.1219809353,
-0.8443965316,
0.2937125266,
0.955760181,
-0.4146696031,
-0.0395125374,
-0.3933938742,
-0.0905365199,
-0.5420876145,
0.1767474264,
0.2098630667,
0.4255564511,
-0.7581711411,
-0.132284537,
-0.7330344915,
-1.0985938311,
-1.0184770823,
0.1399023384,
-0.0071315691,
0.3482685983,
0.5159757137,
0.3095097244,
0.6018525958,
0.4735764265,
-0.1853846908,
0.2585431337,
-0.3023351133,
0.6844221354,
0.037297003,
-0.6893621683,
-0.2272912562,
-0.1072352231,
0.357347697,
0.8426752687,
-0.2888479233,
-0.0662964359,
-0.2406480014,
0.4383959174,
-0.2713590264,
0.1586158723,
-0.7238845229,
0.044389464,
-0.509375751,
-0.3943219781,
-0.2375909686,
-0.4342336655,
0.3288167417,
-0.7482088208,
0.1795498878,
0.0979112014,
0.8665949106,
0.2121657133,
-0.3472456634,
-0.5804283023,
-1.2963542938,
0.4505703449,
-0.4397628009,
0.5711707473,
0.728190124,
0.7690807581,
-0.173989743,
-0.8357648253,
-0.7459570765,
-0.4442159235,
0.2907807827,
-0.1695501953,
-0.7011122704,
-0.0054645999,
0.316236347,
0.3359972835,
-0.3884219527,
0.0236911848,
-0.5193754435,
-0.1691607386,
0.3759461641,
0.3076204062,
0.5195731521,
0.1388325542,
0.0083111981,
-0.1127935275,
-0.4303262532,
0.1161332205,
0.4675553143,
0.294375807,
0.2893931568,
0.6703897715,
-0.4665662348,
1.1310561895,
-0.1246874183,
0.1432244331,
0.1438540965,
-0.328354001,
-0.0361254029,
-0.0640836582,
0.1490428895,
0.0604430847,
0.45262447,
-0.1218415201,
0.0279941838,
-0.48278898,
0.4330002666,
-0.2430862635,
0.1056131944,
0.373092711,
-0.1379583776,
-0.0547223166,
0.1943994015,
-0.5681014657,
-0.6258561611,
-0.7292339802,
0.4892508984,
-0.2079914659,
-0.5427018404,
0.0323488899,
-0.3497153223,
0.3326369226,
0.4821368158,
-0.5698507428,
0.7160135508,
0.4875339568,
0.6206615567,
-0.0539751276,
0.1919790953,
-0.7144021392,
0.0701400861,
0.1331176758,
0.6098171473,
-0.6719527245,
-0.7253634334,
0.1685460955,
0.0227011777,
-0.2335523218,
-1.0436896086,
0.3820646703,
-0.4907233119,
0.1742250621,
-0.4382482767,
-0.5210826993,
0.1042945758,
0.1853453219,
-0.7890877128,
0.7329044938,
0.1384580582,
-0.6429885626,
-0.1870888323,
-0.6158055663,
-0.2505862415,
0.0000869141,
-0.0668571964,
-0.0337041952,
0.077595219,
-0.0112270275,
-0.0408784486,
-0.2864263654,
-0.2859125435,
-0.081113413,
-0.0567989275,
0.2816553712,
-0.1276821494,
0.81540519,
0.1989634037,
0.0552397594,
0.223393932,
-0.9060963988,
0.1805497706,
0.2800878882,
-0.1431912333,
-0.6269610524,
0.0689921975,
-0.0284284763,
-0.1269714683,
0.2990989387,
-0.5707255602,
0.4205288589,
-0.3204205334,
0.2482264489,
0.5061211586,
0.1539451331,
0.0361893252,
0.101279445,
0.580440402,
0.2145920098,
0.487618804,
0.2187672704,
-0.8066771626,
-0.7376589179,
0.2145121247,
0.4108877182,
0.9446434975,
-0.9010968208,
-0.0625189021,
0.0821180791,
-0.3617731631,
-0.7032826543,
-0.0755696371,
0.320866257,
0.9222938418,
0.2835033834,
-0.194552809,
-0.6283597946,
-0.697581768,
-0.2873520255,
-0.4709891677,
0.1161894053,
0.8037259579,
-0.1356297135,
-0.0901929289,
0.985127151,
-0.6020248532,
-0.4806850255,
0.001437099,
0.0872325078,
0.1279667467,
0.3031625748,
0.3712382615,
-1.5137588978,
-0.295196414,
0.2494702637,
-0.5644627213,
-0.2635729909,
0.4126401246,
0.2114879787,
-0.1184424907,
0.4972138405,
-0.8538373709,
0.4761211872,
0.0995366946,
-0.1211015582,
0.4919406176,
-0.0595126711,
0.3450142145,
-0.8480486274,
-0.2582781315,
-0.0277612656,
-0.1861972362,
-0.9811505675,
-0.2139824927,
-0.3600591123,
-0.4767907858,
-0.5482456684,
0.6986656785,
-0.3603802025,
-0.3943171799,
-0.3749621511,
0.1310597509,
-0.1332794279,
0.0193263832,
0.0460064448,
0.8095135689,
0.776594162,
-1.089325428,
0.656855166,
0.3728871942,
-0.1427549124,
0.6535557508,
-0.8031457663,
0.4166232646,
-0.1243902817,
-0.3256786764,
-0.8730800152,
-0.3942475617,
0.0179153103,
-0.6570941806,
0.3706553876,
-0.0262574852,
-0.4294445515,
-0.4123575985,
0.1911786348,
0.3563805223,
0.2544285059,
-0.5574575067,
0.5663257241,
0.8167338967,
-0.3804399967,
-0.5472999215,
-0.2318533063,
-0.0610427223,
-0.0209567007,
-0.6843534708,
0.4931795001,
-0.0818013623,
-0.6155624986,
0.0914314464,
-0.0159738753,
-0.4593664408,
0.0295023732,
0.2879266441,
-0.2210642546,
-0.2166366875,
0.2515932322,
-0.2057292759,
0.0935577676,
-0.2339179814,
-0.1372561753,
0.6705164909,
-0.0882327482,
-0.5627223849,
-0.4760981202,
0.662080884,
0.2924975455,
-0.4315562248,
0.4135188162,
0.6090250015,
-0.629632175,
0.2919813693,
-0.767254591,
-0.2609421611,
-0.4627005756,
0.2765081525,
-0.563206017,
-0.7221024632,
0.5423269868,
-0.0372232236,
-0.2035465389,
0.1119753048,
0.4255591035,
-0.3631570041,
1.2626923323,
0.8582978845,
0.0659795478,
0.6215978861,
-0.1127953753,
-0.0771007016,
-0.5650800467,
-0.5775692463,
-0.8620826006,
0.2538184524,
-0.490997225,
-0.2168863267,
0.5523427129,
0.1375403255,
0.2934130728,
0.4722753167,
-0.3181866109,
0.035687726,
0.9277193546,
0.0546222404,
0.3271792829,
-0.0881121978,
0.1486539245,
0.0161339492,
-0.322969079,
-0.3386018872,
0.5868291259,
0.101268135,
0.8394349813,
0.4000208676,
0.2902333438,
0.5240635276,
-0.5192061067,
-0.6170002222,
0.5286380649,
0.1148592904,
-0.516179204,
-0.4374102354,
-0.5448824763,
-1.1185473204,
0.0664487109,
-0.0851860344,
-1.0831750631,
0.3580448329,
0.4213203192,
-0.0234276373,
0.0691376328,
-0.9311155081,
0.7433553338,
-0.3338250518,
-0.0303639434,
0.0586128309,
-0.5751920342,
-0.0561718307,
0.2594597042,
-0.0756948814,
0.0381761752,
0.1845175326,
0.6064245105,
-0.4448370039,
0.7939658761,
-0.3575101793,
0.3500711918,
0.559263587,
-0.2237170935,
0.3074885011,
-0.2461079061,
-0.3733103871,
0.0028422687,
0.3263487816,
-0.3411276639,
-0.6135110855,
0.6616247892,
-0.7043806911,
-1.1459206343,
-0.2902770042,
-0.2564034164,
-0.7162546515,
0.1928072572,
0.112676248,
0.3758975565,
-0.2474045008,
0.1377143562,
0.7820892334,
-0.3261859715,
0.0800783411,
0.7198666334,
-0.1087115631,
-0.0056535122,
1.0895354748,
0.3240415454,
0.1228416264,
0.5907967687,
-0.0206468012,
-0.4103452861,
-0.5565072894,
-0.2101192325,
0.1295182854,
-0.606667459,
0.0224350784,
-0.6990354061,
-0.3688475788,
-0.8350160718,
0.6552890539,
-0.1711811423,
-0.5689151883,
-0.5993406773,
-0.1222948804,
0.3208169043,
0.7542262077,
0.0264699534,
0.4852401316,
-0.6174343228,
0.3317962289,
0.5163471103,
0.1802175194,
-0.3398967385,
-0.483746618,
-0.1000975296,
-0.1496784538,
-0.4423474967,
-1.1511298418,
0.3793579638,
0.0932312459,
0.8531247973,
0.3917364776,
-0.0897830352,
0.6106415987,
-0.3709004521,
0.9420930147,
-0.1327511966,
-0.7621338367,
0.8525653481,
0.048720099,
-0.0572938249,
0.3010366261,
0.6377820373,
-0.3789209127,
0.0614020415,
-0.4697769582,
-0.6942380071,
0.6269986033,
0.420918256,
0.1917033195,
0.1629227996,
0.3892022669,
-0.1286183149,
0.2198418379,
-0.2369979322,
-0.1502960771,
-0.2217917889,
0.221068874,
0.3189853132,
-0.2975446582,
0.041390162,
-0.2729689777,
0.6137908101,
0.2277033627,
0.5091038346,
0.1280483454,
0.2057728767,
-0.1287953258,
0.048185546,
0.6660307646,
0.591683805,
-0.3168727458,
-0.340704143,
0.0185890216,
-0.2929757237,
-0.0613034181,
0.3892940879,
0.2349983603,
0.317517817,
0.0395445861,
1.0426170826,
-0.1504418999,
-0.7928555012,
0.5287057757,
-0.5535704494,
0.0116703343,
-0.7825191021,
0.2691370249,
0.0157114044,
0.1905968636,
0.4043183029,
-0.2735848129,
0.4396510124,
-0.6952350736,
0.1428894252,
0.5867981911,
-0.7227531075,
-0.1126024798,
0.7543074489,
0.1622067094,
-0.8100466728,
0.6848574877,
0.3381865025,
-0.2270041257,
0.6311483383,
0.5221293569,
0.4511072338,
-0.9186542034,
0.052308742,
-0.0047290833,
-0.0130319549,
0.1099613681,
0.6620881557,
-0.2220579237,
-0.4331525266,
0.1287502348,
-0.3070294261,
-1.125418663,
0.3546136618,
-0.7351090908,
0.4106414318,
-0.1266634613,
-0.7207477689,
0.3045036197,
-0.2804059088,
-0.6756051779,
0.1584765166,
-0.1217233688,
0.7832665443,
-0.3162076771,
0.7752633095,
0.8430377841,
-0.6094374657,
-0.3925118744,
-0.2725531161,
-0.0397850834,
-0.6224102378,
0.6187084317,
-0.2120951116,
-0.0941665545,
-0.0736151934,
-0.4183558524,
-0.9770962,
0.8227878809,
0.3288125396,
-0.3959061503,
-0.3862031996,
0.288695991,
0.60312289,
-0.2155442834,
0.363717258,
0.2579481006,
0.3527909517,
0.0278273243,
-1.3279349804,
-0.5515062213,
-0.3837025762,
-0.0080626365,
-0.0624092296,
-0.4917516708,
0.9294572473,
-0.1756908149,
-0.128306821,
0.2790317833,
0.8393212557,
0.0286345351,
0.6939485669,
0.5852862,
0.1537435651,
0.8189067245,
-0.2046598643,
1.1445298195,
0.069985956,
-0.1576073468,
1.1370798349,
-0.4334625006,
0.877399981,
0.4718033373,
-0.1180871502,
0.0739186853,
0.5906611085,
0.4719499052,
0.3670312464,
0.3231396675,
-0.4315457642,
-0.1052216068,
-0.449047327,
-0.6260814071,
0.6819397807,
0.8274402022,
-0.2484038323,
0.0998366773,
0.5820859075,
-0.5284873843,
-0.0202210862,
-0.2316504866,
1.0411937237,
0.1128076911,
-0.4573516846,
0.2552408278,
-0.0668821856,
0.0323098935,
-0.5751188993,
-0.4319630265,
0.140498817,
-0.0536851883,
-0.1342798918,
-0.4873495102,
0.1904193759,
-0.0273790583,
-0.1356894076,
-0.0018333901,
1.0181267262,
-0.2703361809,
-0.0499892607,
0.1421886533,
0.5752895474,
0.5273156166,
-0.3619332314,
-0.7257803679,
0.2506251931,
-0.092791535,
-0.0474518649,
0.1763960719,
0.2758405209,
-0.1296429783,
0.8470090032,
0.5684374571,
0.3204456866,
0.5988618135,
0.340975374,
0.7583355904,
-0.7076784372,
-0.4235469699,
-0.1330003589,
0.2145983428,
-0.4234630764,
-0.2702369988,
0.5654137731,
0.4218859971,
0.8535898924,
-0.3105077744,
0.7806484103,
0.1146849021,
1.1067498922,
-0.6168207526,
0.3962470293,
-0.6113402843,
0.2528083324,
-0.0808915794,
-0.6354966164,
0.1351222843,
0.2271512598,
-0.3390895128,
0.1027926505,
-0.0074883071,
0.6903681159,
-0.2474599779,
0.0947848037,
0.6085851789,
0.1471142769,
0.4514769316,
-0.0164907034,
1.0009367466,
-0.2749493718,
0.6948440671,
-0.3379376233,
0.0402135253,
-0.6555649042,
-0.2278669029,
-0.387821734,
-1.2538186312,
-0.279546231,
-0.3266867101,
0.3434752226,
0.625068903,
0.9847627878,
-0.7805169821,
-0.1886737794,
0.0463675596,
0.3294048011,
-0.0946723446,
-0.3575158715,
-0.0341618396,
-0.1321196109,
-1.1893951893,
0.6562972665,
-0.0571132489,
0.4515827894,
-0.0854531229,
0.2262642533,
-0.0650697201,
0.1717192829,
0.6414361,
1.030328393,
-0.6453869343,
-0.1133672148,
0.0217280295,
-0.1082714722,
-0.0821943507,
0.8656519055,
-0.6669436693,
0.8396841884,
0.4449467361,
0.8639074564,
0.7134584785,
0.3919931352,
0.5363599658,
-0.8992696404,
-0.0298473109,
0.4895812571,
0.2324426919,
0.4661688805,
-0.6175780892,
0.4402570426,
0.102495715,
-0.2674854398,
-1.0785477161,
0.3120189607,
-1.3814297915,
0.0423079804,
1.0047556162,
0.104594402,
-0.0387551598,
-0.4710002244,
-0.5790478587,
0.3204574585,
-0.1305160522,
0.3911897838,
0.5772614479,
-0.8008838892,
-0.294688642,
-0.9542024732,
0.6503921747,
0.1763026863,
-1.0504798889,
-0.1974336058,
0.4662234485,
0.071932584,
0.324300617,
0.866479218,
-0.1718583852,
0.2268706858,
-0.0912097394,
-0.1974458396,
-0.1367363781,
-0.4248076975,
-0.028317241,
0.3023475111,
0.2914184034,
-0.5436433554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13134v1 | LAST: Scalable Lattice-Based Speech Modelling in JAX | 2023-04-25T20:25:37 | 2023-04-25T20:25:37 | Ke Wu, Ehsan Variani, Tom Bagby, Michael Riley | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce LAST, a LAttice-based Speech Transducer library in JAX. With an
emphasis on flexibility, ease-of-use, and scalability, LAST implements
differentiable weighted finite state automaton (WFSA) algorithms needed for
training \& inference that scale to a large WFSA such as a recognition lattice
over the entire utterance. Despite these WFSA algorithms being well-known in
the literature, new challenges arise from performance characteristics of modern
architectures, and from nuances in automatic differentiation. We describe a
suite of generally applicable techniques employed in LAST to address these
challenges, and demonstrate their effectiveness with benchmarks on TPUv3 and
V100 GPU. | [
-0.1693956256,
-0.2935700715,
0.6674652696,
0.1589892507,
-0.1894148737,
0.2455376536,
0.3580714166,
-0.7387186885,
0.0365116373,
0.301156044,
-0.4646524191,
-0.2836318016,
-0.0856824741,
-0.1768649817,
-0.2901130915,
0.2340431511,
0.1620234251,
0.1763363332,
-0.2684348524,
-0.2391649187,
-0.1419389397,
-0.4953613281,
-1.0780558586,
-0.4243499935,
0.1210621148,
0.2994427979,
1.1862951517,
0.6703757048,
0.2560326159,
0.407283783,
-0.3020044267,
-0.3301076889,
-0.2083786875,
-0.0611013509,
-0.0724499896,
-0.4427298903,
-0.7054117322,
-0.1297302544,
0.7838147879,
0.6948749423,
-0.2562609613,
0.2217513919,
-0.5562800765,
0.5074226856,
-0.7232054472,
0.078813307,
-0.3720763028,
0.4406346977,
-0.6793338656,
0.0426710658,
-0.4303800762,
-0.059289109,
0.2806166112,
-0.711907804,
-0.2724129856,
0.0958908722,
0.7844492197,
0.3601219356,
-0.4468537271,
0.0121505698,
-1.1406850815,
0.983291924,
-0.7478921413,
0.7833628058,
0.3140491247,
0.6405684352,
-0.2334355414,
-1.1063849926,
-0.3186563253,
-0.3482739925,
0.3473335803,
0.2143555135,
-0.2077780515,
0.2435521781,
0.4990309775,
0.6001251936,
-0.6930013299,
0.1064605489,
0.0163432136,
-0.2219951898,
0.6935197115,
0.3882930875,
0.2346429676,
0.3137800992,
0.0884909332,
-0.3999706805,
-0.6079910994,
0.0351955928,
0.0856163725,
-0.0240489133,
-0.3155085444,
0.0772224069,
-0.1476060748,
1.0198507309,
-0.2178302556,
-0.3949635029,
0.5052719116,
0.329924196,
-0.4408629835,
-0.0674830824,
0.7187823653,
-0.3774548173,
-0.0284542851,
-0.0350572951,
-0.1096547395,
-0.120462589,
0.275677681,
-0.6484504938,
-0.2027416527,
0.2265169173,
-0.6945025921,
-0.2657376528,
-0.6548725367,
-0.595505476,
-0.2628045082,
-0.3151819706,
0.3189509809,
-0.220395267,
-0.5591698885,
-0.1266212165,
-0.2289627343,
0.4984791279,
0.1156042367,
-1.0785300732,
0.8246090412,
0.6209257841,
1.0085169077,
-0.0345101915,
0.013139152,
-0.6835361123,
0.1762657166,
-0.594158411,
0.5666252971,
-0.6930189729,
-0.6640345454,
-0.2435428053,
-0.1948395818,
0.3155705929,
-0.3313181102,
0.7743617892,
-0.5356696248,
0.0459230393,
-0.2326099575,
-0.5369791985,
-0.0449176021,
-0.2414494306,
-0.7323533297,
0.9807279706,
0.6376229525,
-0.309348911,
0.2128562182,
-0.5013464093,
-0.5896298289,
0.4605484009,
-0.3604393899,
-0.6021695733,
0.5271757841,
-0.1405003816,
0.1223362163,
-0.6968995333,
-0.2281244248,
-0.4293270707,
-0.4932499528,
0.0429578833,
-0.4678154588,
0.7638034821,
0.5393975377,
-0.2052998096,
-0.0524146482,
-1.1374261379,
0.3054079711,
-0.1182056144,
0.1258543432,
-0.3437766731,
0.2643544078,
0.2819454074,
0.1143422797,
0.1104272902,
-0.763599515,
-0.0014363008,
-0.5554344654,
0.8067964911,
0.3464123607,
-0.3268282115,
0.5147891045,
-0.4651489258,
0.5122863054,
-0.3872461319,
0.6210228801,
0.5875389576,
-0.6588311195,
0.0526381396,
-0.4639886618,
0.1744047701,
0.4526297748,
-0.55301404,
-0.3374114037,
-0.1916720718,
-0.9790316224,
-0.1569289416,
-0.2673418224,
0.3882913888,
0.1198780909,
0.2931950986,
-0.3059536219,
-0.7643530965,
-0.7361957431,
-0.2905033529,
-0.4268002808,
-0.1195910051,
0.29074651,
0.0773755983,
-0.0812883154,
0.8783068061,
-0.3307420909,
-0.2651042044,
-0.1532366425,
0.2660143375,
0.3744492829,
0.5229873657,
0.535114944,
-1.1990759373,
-0.5608068705,
0.1881607473,
-0.4173280895,
0.0323419534,
-0.227743119,
-0.0131499041,
-0.090391092,
0.5789855123,
-0.5523945093,
0.2055585235,
0.6221132874,
0.2364648581,
0.2781114578,
0.1447691172,
-0.212798059,
-1.2183763981,
-0.2550225258,
-0.3283675611,
-0.6023381948,
-0.569539547,
-0.2047756165,
-0.0490615293,
-0.2081920803,
-0.4077835083,
0.5437016487,
-0.4878061414,
-1.0477074385,
-0.2241211683,
-0.0530038923,
-0.2582603395,
0.3736128509,
0.3063000143,
0.8161725402,
0.533167541,
-0.7414750457,
0.5928496122,
0.1027310118,
-0.0690872371,
0.7139168978,
-0.6755519509,
0.0714515001,
0.3763722181,
0.1975849271,
-0.9712722301,
-0.2860119343,
-0.2822782993,
-0.5738198161,
0.4165092111,
-0.4997928739,
-0.0825472996,
-0.5398871303,
-0.107411176,
0.5126855969,
0.7893986106,
-0.4552863836,
1.329164505,
0.757401526,
0.0856619254,
-0.5662130117,
-0.8727988005,
0.0011065525,
0.1212532222,
-0.3637449145,
0.7759565115,
-0.21404019,
-0.3080701828,
0.0189145003,
0.0513683371,
-0.3370296061,
0.3302537203,
0.7134756446,
-0.0804059133,
-0.2913595736,
-0.1500486434,
0.0977154747,
-0.2294457704,
-0.1581691653,
-0.6277474761,
0.5287615061,
-0.5384972095,
-0.3293389976,
-0.7086256146,
0.0585692078,
0.7879223824,
-0.0583073869,
0.520529449,
0.7328197956,
-0.534358561,
-0.1877892017,
-0.292476207,
0.3424951136,
-0.5505217314,
0.3882606924,
-0.7554398775,
-0.7947387099,
0.5441652536,
-0.3573057353,
0.5299277306,
0.2848279476,
0.6420617104,
-0.1309986264,
1.298538208,
0.553039968,
-0.2544193268,
0.635174334,
-0.0224016681,
-0.0433484204,
-0.7128525972,
0.172160238,
-0.482820183,
-0.1562024504,
-0.6899349689,
0.0340201035,
0.2625340521,
-0.18127428,
-0.1981101483,
0.2969744205,
-0.446140945,
0.4968581796,
0.2507169843,
-0.5040476322,
0.0900750905,
-0.0856858641,
-0.1323783994,
-0.0790209621,
-0.4352340698,
0.0827535689,
0.8378708363,
0.2356919199,
0.6393939853,
0.3492234051,
0.6567699909,
0.4587000608,
0.5180342793,
-0.749366343,
0.5417607427,
-0.1491428912,
-0.4295182526,
-0.5475721359,
-0.5841888785,
-0.4505579174,
0.3451570272,
-0.1090350673,
-0.6723988652,
0.2671041191,
0.1258610189,
-0.5038474202,
0.3523416221,
-0.3320080042,
0.5245780945,
0.1770686656,
-0.319134742,
-0.0335414633,
-0.2865380645,
0.1412791163,
0.1674932539,
0.3533086479,
0.1183368638,
0.0027736472,
0.4775030017,
-0.7328714728,
0.3838303685,
-0.3737934232,
0.0098575614,
0.1586879194,
0.1783641428,
0.5500649214,
0.0785548314,
0.0784825906,
-0.0864297599,
0.4453237355,
-0.3281375468,
-0.4512446523,
0.6158780456,
-1.0380527973,
-0.3365299702,
-0.5684554577,
-0.5146023631,
-0.7315323949,
0.1719280034,
0.2478686273,
0.9710116982,
-0.2646443248,
0.2162370533,
0.6367272139,
0.1459617317,
0.6501367688,
0.7459480762,
-0.141898334,
-0.6634963751,
1.137090683,
0.212937817,
0.0793326646,
0.6380272508,
0.2528884411,
-0.3802182674,
-0.8864611387,
-0.6868337989,
0.1868543476,
-0.2402648628,
-0.2656321526,
-0.4930793047,
-0.430449158,
-0.4055538774,
-0.3506730497,
-0.8481671214,
-0.6416470408,
-0.1350552887,
-0.0713040307,
0.2820002139,
0.8379513621,
-0.4754679203,
0.5468040705,
-0.8286369443,
0.2362028658,
0.4565286636,
0.2170095742,
-0.0905687809,
-0.6999135613,
-0.3611069322,
-0.1638035178,
-0.0378582403,
-0.6380942464,
0.3388120532,
0.4135932028,
0.4838874042,
0.2137102336,
-0.1186611354,
0.7222343683,
-0.3111461103,
0.9367147684,
-0.0678446889,
-1.3722723722,
-0.0521183275,
-0.1798989922,
0.5000393391,
0.3983832896,
0.4879085124,
-0.6699323654,
-0.1932103932,
-0.6094011664,
-0.55812639,
0.6385760903,
0.1848588735,
0.0428005122,
0.3959027231,
0.5794975162,
-0.5074687004,
-0.1228372306,
-0.4592295587,
-0.1030789316,
-0.1303290427,
-0.4547424912,
0.3341930807,
-0.531069994,
0.0003770162,
0.1137018055,
1.0060119629,
-0.1389211714,
0.0629163831,
0.296066612,
-0.2500396967,
-0.2143078893,
0.0583017878,
0.6681633592,
0.8350889683,
-0.1891095787,
-0.2469873726,
0.5693445802,
-0.8352303505,
0.195652619,
-0.078843005,
-0.2352684885,
0.0549491271,
0.5192994475,
0.6739311814,
0.5004554987,
-0.4090295434,
0.5880559087,
-0.5761104226,
-0.4941223562,
-0.9071460366,
-0.0880697891,
0.1678439528,
0.4109967649,
0.4683715999,
-0.1505640745,
0.3313677311,
-0.3279705942,
0.2475995719,
0.4622690678,
-0.5464411378,
-0.2001889199,
0.7661228776,
-0.2434024066,
-0.2034664899,
0.3531114459,
-0.3231368363,
-0.141853258,
0.3796968758,
0.4320525527,
0.927790761,
-0.6714388132,
0.2142403275,
0.2528734207,
0.1606941819,
-0.1269527078,
0.6286411881,
-0.5731984973,
-0.5053073764,
-0.5511426926,
-0.6721730232,
-1.0247850418,
0.0837555304,
-0.8884518147,
0.0089636622,
-1.0246375799,
-0.4799505472,
0.1595965475,
0.1567343473,
-0.2126468122,
0.3496631384,
0.4956124425,
0.7889543176,
-0.7357970476,
0.7639189959,
0.5928103924,
-0.1274268627,
-0.8870312572,
-0.5784156919,
0.262709856,
-0.370100975,
0.3524523675,
-0.4693609476,
-0.4312083721,
0.2258655429,
-0.5941252708,
-1.4029878378,
1.3675570488,
0.2306826264,
-0.7443515062,
-0.0208188575,
0.2794294357,
0.5929103494,
-0.1529349089,
0.7969017029,
0.6062272787,
0.1075564027,
0.4934948087,
-0.9152010679,
-0.2755521238,
-0.0787321627,
0.5891547203,
-0.0254510045,
-0.8843180537,
1.0831346512,
0.2160682231,
-0.181685999,
0.2546775043,
1.3813687563,
0.1096791849,
0.1980052292,
0.7720953822,
0.7539281249,
0.9237407446,
0.0074379337,
0.8858793378,
-0.1738684475,
0.197822541,
1.22805655,
-0.5136017203,
0.9198880792,
-0.1966324151,
-0.521507144,
0.5748025179,
0.7117789984,
0.2936225832,
0.4409022033,
0.1409850866,
-0.406368196,
-0.3152914643,
-0.0253865905,
-0.359329015,
0.636588335,
0.6688239574,
0.0139171369,
-0.0769735202,
0.2050852627,
0.0708567575,
-0.1790739894,
-0.6258311272,
0.8150342703,
0.2722142637,
-0.0364995748,
0.725793004,
-0.050168667,
0.2433469743,
-0.8832185268,
-0.1099610403,
-0.2525846064,
0.1746602952,
-0.4846121967,
-0.1935625672,
0.3712814748,
-0.2816027999,
-0.166205436,
-0.0273939166,
0.4624745846,
-0.0872348323,
-0.1565870345,
0.1994327754,
-0.0426869653,
0.2699169219,
0.0500950515,
-0.7475761175,
0.5407086611,
-0.1629493237,
-0.1720644683,
0.201971218,
0.3161690831,
-0.3045522571,
0.7175256014,
0.6357371807,
0.123889327,
0.1387469321,
0.4054122865,
0.7148030996,
-0.5058090687,
-0.6676166058,
-0.5895956755,
-0.1021313146,
-0.1913565099,
-0.2603515387,
0.5914580226,
0.655549407,
0.7404174805,
0.1740109473,
0.6656012535,
-0.0273380559,
0.62041682,
-0.4825907052,
0.4769077599,
-0.6940395832,
-0.1535303891,
-0.4300449789,
-0.8204278946,
-0.1989834905,
0.5153957009,
-0.130410701,
-0.0276174955,
0.5013830066,
0.7583320737,
0.1663478017,
0.6910178661,
0.8857435584,
0.5870747566,
0.5996935368,
0.7456696033,
0.7510050535,
-0.462275207,
0.2730784118,
-0.2292502075,
-0.2493401617,
-0.01505474,
-0.5492763519,
-0.4753358066,
-0.9196122289,
-0.2010951638,
-0.2635288537,
0.0687694028,
0.8766208291,
0.9332797527,
-0.7684358954,
-0.4180911183,
-0.32628268,
-0.0136529272,
-0.3763987124,
-0.143309772,
0.1641741097,
-0.2628999352,
-0.8330449462,
0.686283946,
0.4144897461,
0.0644741356,
-0.3475853503,
0.0525545217,
0.1218811125,
0.0934430882,
0.476767391,
0.9132508039,
-0.1061484814,
-0.1895807534,
-0.5628382564,
-0.2099424899,
-0.2805607915,
0.8061778545,
-0.8733237982,
0.2231921703,
0.660757184,
0.8367553353,
0.9611887932,
-0.1945576966,
0.7276511192,
-0.4309524894,
0.3400356472,
0.5296288133,
0.3070714474,
0.324028194,
-0.2875224054,
0.5192169547,
0.4350856543,
-0.5037533641,
-0.9084523916,
0.2959379256,
-0.8692936301,
0.0808973238,
0.7557535768,
-0.0428034067,
-0.8146150708,
-0.4402859211,
0.091712296,
0.0375773311,
-0.1089907587,
-0.0672195628,
0.5332616568,
-0.146266982,
-0.3138273656,
-0.4611692429,
1.185613513,
0.4909961224,
-0.7316616774,
-0.1609721184,
0.40798226,
0.2201236933,
0.1739599258,
1.0314186811,
-0.3991039693,
0.5830026865,
0.331255883,
0.0009498712,
-0.2280380428,
-0.3543803096,
-0.218561992,
0.0888612792,
0.1820339859,
0.007151226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13060v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13060v2 | Injecting structural hints: Using language models to study inductive biases in language learning | 2023-04-25T18:00:08 | 2023-10-29T17:14:06 | Isabel Papadimitriou, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Both humans and large language models are able to learn language without
explicit structural supervision. What inductive biases make this learning
possible? We address this fundamental cognitive question by leveraging
transformer language models: we inject inductive bias into language models by
pretraining on formally-structured data, and then evaluate the biased learners'
ability to learn typologically-diverse natural languages. Our experimental
setup creates a testbed for hypotheses about inductive bias in human language
learning. We investigate the effect of injecting models with three types of
inductive bias: 1) recursive, hierarchical processing, 2) crossing token-token
relationships that can't be modeled by context-free grammars, and 3) a Zipfian
power-law vocabulary distribution. We show that non-context-free relationships
form the best inductive biases. Our study leverages the capabilities of
transformer models to run controlled language learning experiments that are not
possible to run on humans, and surfaces hypotheses about the structures that
facilitate language learning in both humans and machines. | [
-0.0836665481,
-0.6715611815,
0.3698942065,
0.2178784758,
-0.0760432333,
0.1593802273,
-0.2397907674,
-0.3467458189,
-0.186127916,
0.3018385768,
-0.4459024668,
-0.2429918796,
-0.4743298888,
0.0905572847,
-0.4646053016,
1.0984454155,
0.1926109195,
0.531093955,
-0.2259943783,
0.1717014909,
-0.196901843,
-0.3964907229,
-0.2107181549,
-0.840479672,
0.2603231966,
0.2826177478,
0.6802618504,
0.563693881,
0.2007357478,
0.1895793825,
-0.294105351,
-0.1890179068,
-0.1986809671,
-0.1200255603,
-0.3860320747,
-0.8867729902,
0.0008066199,
0.019908987,
0.526720345,
1.1640888453,
0.0572721548,
0.0429939963,
0.1642674953,
0.58853966,
-0.5962710381,
0.2894833386,
-0.6919617057,
0.0420653895,
-0.3190428913,
-0.0602565669,
-0.6035941243,
-0.4561804831,
0.1912352145,
-0.3193556666,
0.6099165678,
0.0417832918,
0.841961503,
0.4684136212,
-0.504044652,
-0.3453847468,
-0.7659188509,
0.5143741965,
-0.4459819496,
0.5831891894,
0.6048657894,
0.1561145782,
-0.3502885699,
-0.4100075662,
-0.2109593451,
-0.5958834887,
-0.4023419619,
-0.1310348511,
0.1688800901,
0.2941844463,
0.3660822213,
0.3933984339,
-0.4009979069,
0.0442690141,
-0.5213394165,
0.0079295179,
0.1983649135,
-0.3425398767,
0.5128718615,
-0.3414186835,
-0.0685544685,
-0.1320230067,
-1.0240960121,
0.0455880947,
0.6485375762,
0.6755251288,
-0.1336514205,
0.6137088537,
-0.0303929374,
0.3847134709,
0.2961398363,
0.1094724163,
0.1627273858,
-0.136654526,
-0.0837776884,
0.1123356968,
0.625222981,
-0.1104431897,
0.5714530349,
-0.6465114355,
-0.0305611286,
0.2717956901,
0.2959603667,
-0.5218431354,
-0.4291902781,
0.0007965681,
-0.1878536791,
-0.3637537062,
0.1143720075,
-0.625662446,
-0.2826649845,
0.1040893123,
0.2530137599,
-0.501770556,
-0.3550047576,
0.0614251457,
-0.3804079294,
0.2374068797,
-0.3111209571,
-1.2065776587,
0.5042632818,
0.4112254381,
0.4558294117,
-0.0252298545,
-0.2665723562,
-0.3264266849,
0.0760381445,
-0.2643249035,
0.7667377591,
-0.755730927,
-0.1828547716,
0.2367207557,
0.0427669287,
-0.0159167685,
-0.6737081409,
0.3969845176,
-0.2894212604,
0.4279794097,
-0.2156855315,
-0.4338907897,
0.0420003198,
-0.1940431744,
-0.7543239594,
1.0419989824,
0.2995460927,
-0.9417464733,
0.6340265274,
-0.7596048117,
-0.8608396649,
0.2188545465,
-0.3572762609,
-0.3831433058,
0.2612388432,
0.1700130254,
0.1513617039,
-0.0959348008,
0.4572810233,
-0.1515043378,
-0.0880821347,
0.1203936413,
-0.1299365312,
0.9275695086,
-0.052353844,
-0.8007466197,
0.1837341487,
-0.6700494289,
-0.445658952,
0.1810319424,
-0.4053981304,
-0.5445258021,
0.0960657969,
-0.0120550152,
0.2847607732,
-0.1899980754,
-0.5219507813,
0.2437403351,
-0.6707732081,
0.6217252016,
0.484954983,
-0.1108726189,
1.0020940304,
-0.0660622641,
0.4589085877,
0.1427233815,
-0.0593316182,
-0.0938029364,
-0.2983097732,
-0.7207232118,
0.0403145216,
0.2516449392,
0.195488438,
-0.7993998528,
0.1763644367,
-0.0419833101,
-0.1697858125,
-0.5940487981,
0.2892801464,
0.6487256885,
0.3240703046,
0.3685064912,
0.0243803393,
-0.427788645,
-0.971111536,
-0.4954628646,
-0.1813478619,
-0.3205617368,
0.0302876662,
0.6180107594,
-0.0842414871,
0.9170791507,
-0.1967011243,
-0.1043184847,
-0.4991405904,
0.1297303736,
-0.191061601,
0.3545857072,
0.3513071239,
-0.6683612466,
-0.1825727969,
-0.0893293098,
-0.4819650352,
-0.0280345585,
-0.0627990514,
0.0358652547,
0.1277780831,
0.5008614063,
-0.6795915961,
0.2411748171,
0.4033276141,
-0.3030023873,
0.4698341787,
0.1260192841,
-0.6737017632,
-1.0478206873,
-0.256777823,
0.1864253432,
-0.0099021662,
-0.6464673877,
0.0637107417,
0.2628794909,
0.3370862007,
-0.2020132393,
0.4245298803,
-0.4956255555,
0.0428782962,
-0.0833498612,
-0.1042576879,
-0.0143892802,
0.5937894583,
0.1502354294,
0.5900506377,
0.4730685949,
-0.6646410227,
-0.2308716178,
0.0658989102,
-0.447478801,
0.1698496342,
-0.6547666192,
0.0140472846,
-0.3666521013,
0.2223330587,
-0.9753234386,
-0.3569610715,
0.296281904,
-0.3776396215,
0.430760622,
-0.2630223036,
-0.3129895031,
-0.1723783314,
-0.1376151294,
0.402041465,
0.2479071468,
-0.6767649055,
0.6119624972,
0.2491427958,
0.157068342,
-0.5336200595,
-0.6911305189,
-0.2967722118,
-0.1845500618,
-0.2057310343,
0.3660160303,
0.0945704728,
-0.4009680748,
0.0769246742,
-0.1851019561,
-0.0375360325,
0.1084763184,
0.5484013557,
0.1643441468,
-0.0398879983,
0.4338985682,
0.0695152804,
0.0904055163,
0.2858449221,
-0.5471524596,
0.6472300887,
-0.0912253261,
-0.3073231578,
-0.1132062823,
0.0831037238,
0.6096574068,
-0.2728035152,
0.5862986445,
0.2379887849,
-0.3340576291,
-0.4574985206,
-0.5189215541,
-0.5531315804,
-0.4326266944,
0.4115284979,
-0.3149957657,
-0.8874510527,
0.1602775902,
-0.0255254526,
0.0217679348,
0.2945609689,
0.5785466433,
-0.0401945189,
0.9199220538,
0.8609935045,
-0.0677949861,
0.7362048626,
-0.2807335854,
0.2788952291,
-0.7521885633,
-0.2549036443,
-0.5865975618,
0.0438227989,
-0.6933485866,
-0.0867964327,
0.0415871888,
-0.0264170114,
-0.1969283521,
0.3932322562,
-0.3600194752,
0.4689718783,
0.6406424046,
0.0579384565,
0.1667313278,
-0.0104296049,
-0.5394984484,
0.1949244291,
-0.6901421547,
-0.2850421071,
1.0034821033,
0.349340409,
0.9187014103,
-0.3298504055,
0.2997583449,
-0.0301540941,
0.3585886359,
-0.8687326312,
0.0044722143,
0.2137441784,
-0.8491358757,
-0.1211607382,
-0.4432677627,
-0.7332357764,
0.1674139798,
-0.0529148169,
-0.5011053681,
0.1785949767,
0.132509023,
-0.0508984737,
0.391625762,
-0.7974481583,
0.607726872,
-0.1967892051,
-0.3132647872,
0.1363176107,
-0.7193136811,
0.4185937047,
0.1815178394,
0.2598708868,
0.2101858407,
0.4721211493,
0.5233370066,
-0.075275436,
1.0223345757,
-0.1149814129,
-0.1944100559,
0.0248313304,
0.1341755092,
0.4573728144,
-0.1504891813,
0.1168736219,
0.0665191561,
-0.3147418201,
-0.405867219,
-0.5333399773,
0.1075846925,
-0.8296685219,
-0.3596066236,
-0.1844795793,
-0.7427178621,
-0.1300433874,
0.0650926158,
0.7474973202,
0.3910846412,
-0.1178923845,
0.0477622822,
0.5551786423,
0.0731094182,
0.3138162792,
0.3724341393,
-0.1183818728,
0.0332125388,
0.6684759259,
0.0083645964,
0.5525721312,
0.7069948912,
0.3563270867,
-0.2501660287,
-0.5567696095,
-0.2252697498,
0.5520637035,
-0.5839121938,
0.0493465438,
-0.6683245301,
-0.2030865252,
-0.3782297373,
0.0256775506,
-0.3609541953,
-0.5389059782,
0.0632392839,
-0.6491553187,
0.07421574,
1.2528444529,
0.2729872465,
0.4292824864,
-0.1504389793,
0.1347875148,
0.3100391924,
0.3357705772,
-0.0790697113,
-0.3744724095,
-0.2752572596,
0.048859179,
-0.1992451847,
-0.8293934464,
0.2151544392,
0.1261093169,
0.43302688,
0.6134108901,
-0.0888775587,
0.2403773516,
-0.6215143204,
0.6636345387,
-0.0611175708,
-0.8872796297,
0.5667892098,
-0.2852762938,
0.32807073,
0.3924070895,
0.5939707756,
-0.2904310226,
-0.7752628326,
-0.5444142222,
-0.6529565454,
0.4764013886,
0.0307337958,
0.0110891834,
-0.3268927932,
0.5023812056,
0.0402469933,
0.2103778273,
-0.9850717187,
-0.1676856875,
-0.468953073,
-0.0498468056,
0.0662064105,
-0.2836812437,
-0.1573725641,
-0.2258935571,
0.5630465746,
-0.3752731681,
-0.0196078625,
0.0683820546,
-0.5234801769,
-0.2784959078,
0.444693476,
0.4835418165,
0.5633893609,
-0.2508631051,
0.3537285626,
-0.0156631451,
-0.3667152226,
0.0447110794,
-0.2162002921,
-0.3511419594,
0.0085882535,
0.3769869804,
0.7361414433,
0.3863288164,
-0.3663650751,
0.3759700358,
-0.1643546522,
-0.1576964557,
-0.1844764948,
-0.0653332621,
0.142612204,
0.1673269123,
0.370314151,
-0.0463791415,
0.0120526738,
-0.5611063838,
0.1511894166,
0.6779261827,
-0.6703829169,
-0.7547351718,
0.6581203938,
0.0016998954,
-0.4345894158,
0.5630102158,
-0.18462421,
-0.6849440932,
0.3265512288,
0.9609652758,
1.0675797462,
-0.4082742035,
0.3144137859,
0.2818045318,
0.5933986902,
-0.1430525184,
-0.0726125911,
-0.3257270753,
-0.8165826797,
-0.4678730667,
-0.7045928836,
-0.4228641689,
0.0523961298,
-0.7507405877,
0.1099186689,
-0.3246665895,
0.1133860648,
0.096866712,
-0.2156077921,
-0.577173233,
-0.096816197,
0.1027895361,
0.9333481789,
-1.117738843,
1.1176695824,
0.6920239329,
-0.6520803571,
-0.8464511633,
0.0011162719,
-0.0947138444,
-0.6225236654,
0.9530060887,
0.208079949,
-0.2817300856,
-0.1533723176,
-0.8065828681,
-0.6332227588,
0.6106829047,
0.4062384069,
-0.1392521411,
-0.6665568352,
0.2883605063,
0.3008058369,
-0.3798206747,
0.4269805551,
0.7021328211,
0.2280226946,
0.1133946553,
-0.6694104075,
0.0935080126,
-0.3715526164,
-0.0682195053,
0.2449452728,
-0.1989966631,
1.0146670341,
-0.2247329205,
-0.4167258143,
-0.3336197436,
0.5614910722,
-0.1497810632,
-0.2093988061,
0.4413034022,
0.4951531291,
0.6480872631,
0.0239698328,
1.1034963131,
-0.2998878062,
0.1586914957,
1.2149637938,
-0.1277130097,
0.5324183702,
0.5607560277,
-0.1269548833,
1.0730134249,
0.2714598775,
0.2901517749,
0.5135028362,
0.1557321995,
-0.1338345408,
0.0416232273,
-0.2921409309,
-0.1272387505,
0.27003178,
0.5966912508,
-0.31317541,
-0.4383409321,
-0.0189285465,
0.2904208302,
-0.0285026263,
-0.0161383245,
0.7610056996,
0.0738795549,
-0.7718906403,
0.3856252432,
-0.1927364916,
0.8269197345,
-0.7698636055,
0.0963343456,
-0.252427876,
0.229260087,
-0.4034471512,
-0.2553129196,
0.282913059,
-0.1551438868,
-0.3137857616,
-0.1909065247,
0.4806639552,
-0.6906275749,
-0.3289957643,
0.4914472699,
0.3375058174,
-0.0777834281,
-0.2472795993,
-0.1826199442,
-0.3846984208,
-0.1356445253,
-0.1169191524,
0.4572929442,
0.2082404494,
-0.1724926978,
0.6880689859,
0.620241642,
0.1852297038,
0.4060111046,
0.3057435155,
0.907313168,
-0.5433319211,
-0.2454728484,
-0.9673399925,
0.3683049381,
0.2259709388,
-0.0901441053,
0.9861268997,
0.4271177649,
1.1639670134,
-0.0433722474,
0.86348629,
0.1457016766,
0.1555274725,
-0.3373288512,
0.6297945976,
-0.1897214502,
-0.0554770567,
-0.2832520008,
-0.7404041886,
-0.3767186701,
0.6491402984,
-0.4577341974,
-0.0370478965,
0.9404914379,
0.8619910479,
-0.0024974751,
0.1257939637,
0.0642988831,
0.2802549005,
0.5064550638,
0.439745605,
0.9216023088,
-0.2408210635,
0.4362327158,
-0.4694325626,
-0.2494190037,
-0.0972458795,
-0.7387247682,
-1.3554325104,
-0.5954829454,
-0.0453862213,
-0.4032292664,
0.0728530735,
1.24036479,
0.7944484949,
-0.8278217912,
-0.4709441662,
-0.5368847251,
0.497278899,
-0.1596836746,
-0.315836966,
0.2974494398,
-0.7948047519,
-0.7037169337,
0.522382319,
0.2633645535,
0.010131387,
-0.4145146906,
0.0913218558,
-0.2906149328,
-0.061103791,
0.4850971401,
0.3551821709,
-0.7272670269,
-0.1772939861,
0.0911947861,
-0.1019814238,
0.1336935461,
1.1211749315,
-0.8559169769,
0.2818034589,
0.4960633814,
0.582649529,
0.3377054632,
-0.1382738501,
0.7044278383,
-0.97086519,
0.316622436,
0.0457405224,
0.3094420433,
0.454731673,
-0.3811899722,
0.356820792,
0.0998458564,
-0.3958479762,
-0.7778754234,
0.5803865194,
-0.3764975667,
-0.2906689942,
1.1212310791,
0.2249369025,
-0.4167887866,
-0.3216137886,
0.1475884318,
0.449878633,
-0.1925842762,
0.9066435099,
0.592379272,
0.091243811,
-0.0961337984,
-0.4612267911,
0.8619321585,
0.4149680436,
-0.5839054585,
0.0466807,
0.083941251,
0.4911383688,
0.3141263425,
0.1670822501,
-0.1533497721,
0.0518746451,
-0.1404720098,
0.2990167439,
0.0534693301,
-0.7143488526,
-0.5032789707,
0.0836168453,
0.1051955596,
-0.0402149484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13010v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13010v2 | Unstructured and structured data: Can we have the best of both worlds with large language models? | 2023-04-25T17:30:05 | 2023-07-05T21:33:33 | Wang-Chiew Tan | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | This paper presents an opinion on the potential of using large language
models to query on both unstructured and structured data. It also outlines some
research challenges related to the topic of building question-answering systems
for both types of data. | [
-0.0552148409,
-1.3114904165,
0.8782575727,
0.2053673565,
-0.1857763082,
0.358284831,
-0.3170186579,
-0.6553138494,
0.0525588579,
0.6911669374,
-0.1713147014,
-0.3496644497,
-0.3128433228,
0.0284715537,
-0.6838574409,
0.5973833203,
0.091552332,
0.3966655433,
-0.5221875906,
-0.1330023706,
-0.51691401,
-0.9748130441,
-0.5650356412,
-0.3575511277,
0.1917950213,
0.0947687253,
1.0385450125,
0.2607476413,
0.2860102952,
0.351452142,
-0.3173967004,
0.178785935,
-0.3183078468,
0.4861168265,
-0.308655113,
-0.1713612825,
-0.1728532165,
-0.1046466157,
0.4631380141,
1.2937202454,
-0.4682681262,
0.0256811362,
-0.1844357401,
0.5532178879,
-0.2561262846,
0.1257865578,
-0.546815753,
0.0828678682,
-0.1488524824,
-0.1943077594,
-0.2258143425,
-0.1580689996,
0.0251476597,
-0.2755011022,
-0.2973203957,
0.3273384571,
0.6902949214,
0.0391124822,
-0.8295357823,
-0.3452541828,
-1.0270558596,
0.7661536336,
-0.4793718755,
0.6272525787,
0.4886188209,
0.4130418897,
-0.5038808584,
-0.7282547355,
-0.5122436285,
-0.1016355604,
-0.0555017665,
0.032710012,
0.0892915204,
-0.0943473354,
0.151887536,
0.7104979753,
-0.7866700292,
0.4296157062,
-0.5949648023,
0.0810763836,
0.9442649484,
0.2293040007,
0.3300495446,
-0.2993293107,
-0.2826654315,
0.146810919,
-0.7079761624,
0.0701272637,
0.4726782441,
0.52666682,
0.3453365564,
0.887250185,
-0.6240005493,
0.9598764777,
-0.330478251,
0.116679512,
-0.1516768038,
-0.2496055067,
-0.3254860044,
-0.3460680842,
0.7816949487,
0.4944352508,
0.3924610317,
-0.5499645472,
-0.3685241044,
-0.2591482103,
-0.1571757495,
-0.5996375084,
-0.0713394657,
0.5023844242,
-0.5627943277,
-0.0116079058,
0.366076827,
-0.9129938483,
-0.3205550015,
-0.3946869969,
0.1049070209,
0.3220357597,
-0.3422555327,
0.4294950366,
-0.1654863656,
0.1569812894,
0.1641351134,
-0.8135285974,
0.3860702217,
0.6281061172,
0.6139824986,
0.1078340039,
0.2232511938,
-0.2695214152,
0.0105137276,
-0.469363004,
0.9677387476,
-0.6423538923,
-0.485646069,
0.1648066193,
0.0579620041,
-0.0403731205,
-0.6153174043,
0.3818788528,
-0.8408052921,
0.7174586654,
-0.2688842416,
-0.8382843733,
0.0352555923,
0.1596435457,
-0.5717750192,
1.3830083609,
0.4561777115,
-0.6826781631,
0.2897822559,
-0.6513970494,
-0.4557709992,
0.1769674867,
-0.0761840418,
0.1034462973,
0.12637721,
0.111738272,
0.3425582051,
-0.5849038959,
0.9327343702,
-0.4725551307,
-0.0732902214,
0.6046258211,
-0.1131678969,
0.6643207073,
0.5557918549,
0.2099079192,
-0.2135588229,
-0.8340936303,
0.4350784719,
0.2051341683,
-0.7088022232,
-0.5158450603,
0.5700760484,
0.4255624115,
0.3435494006,
0.3453609049,
-0.9510586262,
0.4850538075,
-0.3322588205,
0.8255249262,
0.3026179373,
-0.1202510372,
0.4175642729,
-0.0980429053,
0.4151181877,
-0.1608846635,
-0.1569198966,
0.2833625972,
-0.385376811,
-0.2204330266,
0.3804425299,
0.4800219238,
0.5843145251,
-0.8171500564,
0.2091787159,
-0.0491186716,
-0.2360312194,
-0.4303639829,
0.0636352152,
0.3917747736,
0.5553067923,
0.3298169374,
-0.257496506,
-0.7863155007,
-0.7882267237,
-0.0976244658,
-0.2626951337,
-0.2155099362,
0.6519172192,
0.439722538,
0.1911181659,
0.9237041473,
-0.9348289371,
0.2064713538,
-0.3405572176,
0.0155631425,
0.3933902085,
0.2967634797,
0.467494458,
-1.2907283306,
-0.4808391035,
-0.0769517571,
-0.6221506596,
0.0040028044,
0.3253802955,
0.164851591,
0.145628944,
0.6317818165,
-0.8395984173,
0.213542372,
0.3636028469,
-0.5679584742,
0.3293365538,
-0.3067552745,
0.2617582381,
-1.2059470415,
0.1542982608,
-0.3687861562,
-0.2997431457,
-0.8637034297,
0.0787808225,
-0.0772809833,
-0.1856373549,
-0.288441509,
0.5960360765,
-0.3111435771,
-0.3552076221,
-0.2369671166,
-0.1326024681,
0.257805258,
0.2393546402,
0.322124511,
0.6827622652,
0.6781385541,
-0.4112941325,
0.7723921537,
0.5874483585,
-0.7603160739,
0.5095994473,
-1.1043058634,
0.2740936279,
-0.3889361024,
0.3969051242,
-0.9305034876,
-0.6922489405,
-0.4051641524,
-0.4695357084,
0.2885760963,
-0.0557260886,
-0.7981542945,
-0.6724098325,
-0.1651614904,
0.2770665288,
0.3998841643,
-0.3228752613,
0.0883376375,
0.7281637788,
-0.276686281,
-0.4566525817,
-0.6299341321,
0.1594126821,
-0.2683666646,
-0.7238288522,
0.1379081756,
-0.2902484238,
-0.6351664066,
0.0929138735,
0.0537972115,
-0.5717378259,
-0.0313754939,
0.2491572797,
0.3794131577,
-0.4972545803,
0.3393283784,
-0.2509808838,
0.27275455,
-0.1784061193,
-0.3301595747,
0.6459429264,
0.1440485418,
-0.1047978848,
0.1979372948,
1.0460463762,
0.643971324,
-0.2929388285,
0.9027118087,
-0.1563816667,
-0.3399784267,
-0.0241263397,
-0.3158390522,
0.2008236051,
-0.4522854388,
0.3996659517,
-0.1760916859,
-1.2406390905,
0.4706534743,
0.0705782101,
-0.1171005219,
0.3100471497,
0.6292850375,
-0.6410424709,
1.2209720612,
0.6775932908,
-0.1701160371,
0.1720228344,
0.09177614,
0.3447073102,
-0.5849273205,
-0.5130152106,
-0.9548505545,
-0.1186626554,
-0.4075210392,
0.1605565697,
0.2608689964,
0.1717680991,
-0.2719766498,
0.2073294669,
-0.4843870103,
0.5410189033,
0.4607799947,
-0.0654156059,
0.2941559851,
-0.2907322049,
0.1247609705,
0.3188976347,
-0.4121177793,
-0.385323137,
0.9799486399,
0.0122831697,
0.8312569261,
0.025738053,
-0.1543210298,
0.0444945656,
-0.4738814235,
-0.7584419847,
0.3528318107,
-0.1534616798,
-1.1133826971,
-0.4146428406,
-0.3360346556,
-1.3021247387,
0.2439616919,
-0.1408683062,
-0.799084425,
0.1949261427,
-0.1067686602,
-0.2400819212,
0.5296879411,
-0.7043175697,
0.7462971807,
-0.2308788002,
0.2210984528,
0.2779598832,
-0.8541831374,
0.1413608193,
0.0194766391,
0.2788104415,
0.0194360372,
0.1581550837,
0.7046055794,
-0.3832394183,
0.2587603629,
-0.0863559395,
0.0552759692,
0.5121992826,
-0.0490956306,
0.1828808933,
0.0464011133,
-0.2765325606,
-0.0892165899,
0.4837040603,
-0.3385194838,
-0.7909467816,
0.4968815744,
-0.7031493783,
-0.5593661666,
-0.4222015738,
-0.9375301003,
-0.5202152729,
0.1379998028,
0.2030650675,
0.7533646822,
-0.1722277999,
0.6829319,
0.5151430368,
-0.1454900056,
0.6172404289,
0.5951093435,
-0.3401306868,
0.1291843802,
0.2612220049,
0.2976585031,
0.3285023868,
0.5588672757,
0.2074559033,
-0.7293073535,
-0.7412688732,
-0.3924321234,
0.1442056447,
-0.3569057286,
-0.2724387944,
-0.6612428427,
-0.4442703128,
-0.3883682489,
0.0295134075,
-0.4226412475,
-0.6418904066,
0.0584917292,
-0.2376154959,
0.2394109517,
0.9526798129,
0.2301066518,
0.0447916165,
-0.6794656515,
0.2132101655,
0.2019868642,
0.4976952672,
-0.2973653972,
-0.1797677428,
0.0396634936,
0.1851775199,
0.0919127241,
-0.7820578814,
0.2906378508,
0.0665226579,
0.2286355644,
0.254755199,
0.2158865631,
0.4665786028,
-0.3909820318,
0.9300968051,
-0.1935604513,
-0.4016447365,
0.4303231239,
-0.5784807205,
0.002868128,
0.5724202991,
0.5182201266,
-0.6827018857,
-0.1031427085,
-0.6251384616,
-0.7632479668,
0.5685184002,
-0.0435408391,
0.2142244428,
0.1964360625,
0.3023799956,
0.0738099739,
0.5074307919,
-0.578525126,
-0.0115423147,
-0.0631479472,
-0.0759478062,
-0.1013422683,
-0.2238673121,
-0.0672584996,
-0.2921859026,
0.1011316255,
0.1550700814,
0.152458936,
-0.0672177821,
0.1070296392,
-0.2789818347,
0.5771604776,
0.1660896242,
0.8968310952,
-0.2713424265,
0.078736417,
0.0190749317,
-0.2692238092,
-0.068194665,
-0.1204720661,
-0.2209956944,
-0.3070161939,
0.2697795928,
0.5811142325,
0.0555064008,
-1.019887805,
0.3100633025,
-0.0055801473,
-0.2574847639,
-0.1636729985,
-0.0669740066,
0.3786138892,
0.1341516674,
0.2641299069,
-0.5796108246,
0.0238635857,
-1.0863763094,
-0.0682793558,
0.6093941927,
-0.1759374291,
-0.2827457488,
0.6556380987,
-0.1319208592,
-0.2795225084,
1.0549324751,
0.2290846407,
-0.467469424,
0.6029828787,
0.6619359851,
0.1396427453,
-0.2087729424,
0.3099647164,
-0.0025161081,
-0.0412096158,
-0.2167110592,
0.7137079835,
-0.0358107053,
-0.597594738,
-0.3435744345,
-0.9213940501,
-0.3768946826,
0.5686132312,
-0.6335132718,
-0.055306945,
-0.3290990591,
0.2179612517,
0.2528998852,
0.1387766451,
-0.2578476071,
0.3578463495,
-0.2626032531,
0.8806884289,
-0.7145802379,
0.7788530588,
1.0319283009,
-0.3524524868,
-0.9942278862,
-0.6630046964,
-0.2198592424,
-0.6331458688,
0.4914907813,
-0.3060610592,
0.2028231472,
-0.3139140308,
-0.860876739,
-1.0125995874,
0.9105145335,
0.0106128855,
-0.1574283093,
-0.2360554039,
0.2802496552,
0.7002209425,
-0.2732403576,
0.0798079222,
0.6324395537,
0.4859800935,
0.4988096058,
-1.0973430872,
-0.3406756818,
-0.274009794,
-0.0352373198,
0.5936107039,
-0.6223316193,
1.245821476,
0.134660691,
-0.2963019013,
0.1764880121,
0.6725255847,
-0.3643623888,
0.3196433783,
0.2923675776,
0.5001006722,
0.6840164661,
-0.1361143887,
1.1747721434,
-0.0460304394,
0.5302263498,
0.9106798768,
-0.4430890977,
0.8353273869,
0.1845484078,
-0.5663096309,
0.3767649233,
1.0145212412,
0.0504832901,
0.4008890688,
0.0041488926,
0.0765047893,
-0.2879160345,
-0.2218729109,
-0.4526437521,
0.7689619064,
0.3145647049,
0.2275063097,
-0.3856503069,
-0.1556699127,
0.1178602427,
0.3580519259,
-0.1690040082,
0.714594841,
-0.0291491859,
-0.8119327426,
0.0381651968,
0.2765065134,
0.3407264352,
-0.5325163007,
0.0893439725,
-0.3290758431,
-0.276874423,
-0.2415878177,
-1.1717128754,
0.56643188,
0.1330296993,
-0.1789214909,
-0.2321425229,
0.8478783965,
-0.6405480504,
-0.3639606833,
-0.0871194601,
0.7146022916,
0.1423269212,
-0.0658869818,
-0.6053323746,
-0.4170208275,
-0.4238942862,
-0.4338104725,
0.4097119868,
0.3981889486,
-0.3677412271,
0.754866004,
0.7532249093,
0.1602590829,
0.0598640293,
0.0954378843,
0.9205179811,
-0.7949919701,
-0.5625810027,
-0.5069800019,
0.3262941539,
-0.2527680397,
-0.0800659209,
0.6130618453,
0.8814607859,
0.6522129178,
0.2184254229,
0.5368280411,
-0.4055758119,
0.8480277658,
-0.5697578192,
0.511433363,
-0.6491078734,
-0.1971482337,
-0.251173377,
-1.0946273804,
-0.1939163804,
0.2791837156,
-0.1002134308,
0.1235886067,
0.8429381847,
0.6692303419,
-0.1142228842,
0.217179209,
0.2285560668,
0.2334829718,
0.238142103,
0.8215842247,
1.2502479553,
-0.039643053,
0.1419185698,
0.1217985004,
-0.0597616471,
-0.0375486314,
-0.4827898145,
-0.9298484921,
-0.9752595425,
0.0172261447,
-0.2329647243,
-0.2249629796,
0.5437764525,
0.4375214577,
-0.7991890907,
-0.2361167073,
0.259547621,
0.2734640241,
0.3710885644,
-0.1607439369,
0.53606534,
0.1111300364,
-0.8402768373,
0.5767878294,
0.4284145534,
0.2044535577,
-0.2529760003,
0.2146641612,
-0.3674725592,
0.3582766652,
0.7255666852,
0.5156782866,
-0.1919683963,
-0.3859392703,
0.2533061802,
-0.0971635506,
0.0293330252,
1.0368987322,
-0.587955296,
0.1956058741,
0.6499328613,
0.4819443822,
0.3955967724,
0.504191041,
0.3427909017,
-0.5571033955,
0.1063803509,
0.1902607679,
0.3160943687,
0.3741950989,
-0.5356636047,
0.590955019,
0.0391350836,
-0.7315872312,
-0.8849233985,
0.3839639723,
-1.0795235634,
-0.6316882968,
1.3188217878,
0.2142012864,
-0.0576965474,
-0.7111371756,
-0.0748047233,
-0.1006824374,
-0.1058409587,
0.5151868463,
1.0142828226,
-0.3759976029,
0.2400803715,
-0.8431050181,
0.2318967134,
0.1739691347,
-0.8806743622,
-0.0333783925,
0.7308448553,
0.1162079126,
-0.1672543287,
0.7295697927,
-0.2330395281,
-0.0520776808,
-0.1373609304,
-0.4562330544,
-0.3220143318,
-0.5548440218,
-0.0098906476,
0.428473264,
-0.0053739538,
0.0335425511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13007v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13007v3 | Answering Questions by Meta-Reasoning over Multiple Chains of Thought | 2023-04-25T17:27:37 | 2023-10-17T19:18:05 | Ori Yoran, Tomer Wolfson, Ben Bogin, Uri Katz, Daniel Deutch, Jonathan Berant | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modern systems for multi-hop question answering (QA) typically break
questions into a sequence of reasoning steps, termed chain-of-thought (CoT),
before arriving at a final answer. Often, multiple chains are sampled and
aggregated through a voting mechanism over the final answers, but the
intermediate steps themselves are discarded. While such approaches improve
performance, they do not consider the relations between intermediate steps
across chains and do not provide a unified explanation for the predicted
answer. We introduce Multi-Chain Reasoning (MCR), an approach which prompts
large language models to meta-reason over multiple chains of thought, rather
than aggregating their answers. MCR examines different reasoning chains, mixes
information between them and selects the most relevant facts in generating an
explanation and predicting the answer. MCR outperforms strong baselines on 7
multi-hop QA datasets. Moreover, our analysis reveals that MCR explanations
exhibit high quality, enabling humans to verify its answers. | [
-0.8333932161,
-0.9095805287,
1.0121276379,
-0.1061678007,
-0.1833077818,
0.5217276216,
0.1136762723,
-0.4489629865,
0.195074141,
0.4865950346,
-0.8122080564,
-0.0520527661,
-0.2962669134,
0.2937464118,
0.0585100278,
1.0931962729,
-0.1889811754,
-0.1678623706,
-0.2615711987,
-0.2811588943,
-0.4109621346,
-0.7700458169,
-0.5753499269,
-0.3893682659,
1.0083048344,
0.6214433908,
0.8424473405,
0.4488901496,
0.5776174068,
0.2063385844,
-0.0588304438,
0.6411417723,
0.054706227,
0.0633085594,
-0.4701277614,
-0.3269518316,
-0.488129884,
-0.2309274524,
0.3165128827,
0.70385921,
-0.0054660309,
0.6301439404,
-0.1757886559,
0.9239777923,
-1.0740228891,
-0.318457365,
-0.4558970928,
-0.2582377791,
0.0443600304,
-0.3247564435,
-0.4082278311,
-0.4434381425,
-0.0278379191,
-0.1336235851,
0.0076326886,
-0.0035328695,
0.4830899239,
0.026790509,
-0.767364502,
-0.4210306704,
-1.0531482697,
0.4528835416,
-0.2321923375,
0.449590981,
0.1322351545,
0.4179869294,
-0.0205683298,
-0.6565434337,
-0.7046508789,
0.2602003217,
-0.1172024831,
0.0994747132,
0.133865878,
0.2206876725,
0.2005304098,
0.172503531,
-0.4968448579,
-0.6750507355,
-0.4619205892,
-0.0766842514,
0.4577947259,
0.137847513,
0.2522448003,
0.0746582299,
-0.3613420129,
-0.1874661148,
-0.4582200646,
0.3456885517,
0.1456281692,
0.091073446,
0.5802410245,
0.5556944013,
-0.204438448,
0.8547261357,
0.1342535168,
-0.0946891233,
0.0621308908,
-0.5276244879,
-0.0823551714,
-0.1309997588,
0.7652794123,
0.1214370355,
0.2671346366,
-0.1162303165,
0.0193369221,
-0.0142272934,
0.1868650466,
-0.4573224783,
-0.0842486396,
0.6436761618,
-0.4108973145,
0.0407588035,
0.2270244807,
-0.9116277695,
0.1679052114,
-0.2055736184,
0.5294917226,
-0.0624296926,
-0.3110281229,
0.1022226214,
-0.406232059,
0.1645041704,
0.1014120281,
-0.5232156515,
0.6099187732,
0.494130671,
0.6718571186,
0.3634653091,
-0.4780006111,
-0.712949276,
0.3656498492,
-0.5480149984,
0.990552187,
-0.5990703106,
0.13577874,
-0.3654274642,
-0.0344963782,
-0.1830727011,
-0.202903077,
0.3218242228,
-0.8402945399,
0.1070691943,
-0.7788043618,
-0.105052039,
-0.3635725379,
0.6621981859,
-0.6887122989,
0.828600347,
-0.4658744335,
-0.9896564484,
0.2422574759,
-0.6960701346,
-0.443330735,
-0.3820281327,
0.0111503443,
0.0480988994,
0.0663506836,
0.5670360327,
0.2031739354,
-0.2185926884,
0.3847359121,
-0.5136454105,
-0.1680645943,
0.4724225104,
-0.3225009441,
0.5271020532,
0.3564536572,
-0.0576036014,
-0.0261257011,
-0.6232936382,
0.3553088307,
-0.1781876534,
-0.2898998857,
-0.3824324012,
0.2261925787,
-0.538480401,
0.8110863566,
-0.090818949,
-0.4223776758,
0.2753292322,
0.0349487774,
0.3824467957,
0.7084652185,
0.2622779012,
0.18250449,
-0.4999585748,
0.653639853,
0.1271204054,
0.1675767303,
-0.2821710408,
-0.7303394079,
-0.5221566558,
0.1781203449,
0.0705081224,
0.4533953071,
-0.8299061656,
0.0041113258,
-0.1002093554,
-0.2857080996,
-0.6233614683,
-0.0618771836,
0.358623296,
0.3134634197,
0.7137580514,
-0.000890037,
-0.6197754145,
-0.4750648141,
-0.6949592233,
-0.2531202435,
0.123490788,
0.136076048,
0.7015959024,
-0.229553774,
0.9994867444,
-0.5660631657,
0.451533258,
-0.2019015551,
0.2803916931,
0.2916056216,
0.1961610317,
-0.1690015346,
-0.7297777534,
-0.2246637642,
-0.0389457792,
-0.5730551481,
0.2604687512,
-0.2669909298,
-0.433059752,
-0.4598727226,
0.4282305837,
-0.591421783,
0.1309449375,
0.4697315693,
-0.2191690952,
0.8322613835,
-0.0789413005,
0.2681536376,
-0.9607077241,
0.2060767412,
-0.4116817713,
-0.2961380184,
-0.4876094759,
0.3157379925,
-0.1292269826,
-0.0308469981,
-0.1446505934,
0.3688763678,
-0.5709154606,
-0.2439338714,
-0.144592911,
0.1804892421,
0.2545492649,
0.527520597,
0.0495002531,
0.6188095808,
0.3752857149,
-0.9856715798,
0.3170877993,
0.1282580495,
0.1296573877,
0.2128240466,
-0.7651712894,
0.5467818379,
-0.3620315194,
0.6433821321,
-1.1773215532,
-0.0782542825,
0.1579021513,
-0.4476325512,
-0.4305361509,
-0.2502657473,
-0.4377449155,
-0.8339355588,
-0.0801555663,
0.6992493868,
0.054728929,
-0.7366240025,
0.8560349345,
0.0494887307,
0.2865319848,
-0.860345304,
-0.5913165212,
-0.0961946845,
-0.0101106027,
-0.6186586618,
0.0833311155,
-0.296620369,
-0.3329337239,
0.0192110706,
-0.4178856909,
-0.3442175686,
-0.176717788,
-0.1615719348,
-0.0293852687,
-0.1587293148,
0.4531644583,
0.1328698844,
-0.2941966355,
0.3087671101,
-0.5711706877,
0.5002496839,
-0.2991625965,
-0.3626198173,
-0.2138200998,
0.4350337386,
0.9669875503,
-0.5052258372,
0.7900086641,
0.5541168451,
-0.2262840271,
0.0787201077,
-0.5465430617,
-0.1602635533,
-0.3590066135,
-0.3173597157,
-0.9638680816,
-0.5779035091,
0.5659809113,
-0.4170782864,
0.1670775265,
0.508045733,
0.4276997745,
-0.2558835149,
1.2314653397,
0.2101498991,
0.3144283593,
-0.0701559186,
-0.2463173568,
0.3908480406,
-1.0312957764,
-0.3426988423,
-0.5549656153,
-0.3136050701,
-0.4883015156,
-0.6622520685,
0.5224222541,
0.3870715201,
-0.4661178589,
0.197578907,
-0.36133793,
0.7668902874,
0.5484972,
0.251835227,
0.6062476635,
-0.5047131777,
-0.4641816914,
0.7380486131,
-0.79652071,
-0.5417507291,
0.8875347972,
0.0994679257,
0.7194395661,
0.1424291581,
0.6973195672,
-0.091247119,
-0.0761269704,
-0.4870626926,
0.4193106592,
0.1495343596,
-1.062738061,
-0.3149566054,
-0.5395613313,
-0.7809242606,
0.6743787527,
-0.0531743839,
-0.6412297487,
0.1914091259,
0.2852014005,
-0.5365888476,
0.6569436789,
-0.4581088424,
0.6684336066,
-0.2243148834,
-0.1585422009,
-0.1513362378,
-1.0407440662,
0.7831678391,
0.1916192919,
0.625700295,
0.1309373528,
0.1798793972,
0.7312247157,
-0.6509352326,
0.384532541,
0.1405079216,
0.0072648879,
0.8288420439,
0.1170283034,
0.5449662805,
0.0315644108,
0.0668545365,
-0.2687957883,
0.3392997384,
-0.478132844,
-0.8249414563,
0.2431880832,
-0.5391551256,
-0.3662712574,
-0.3780601025,
-0.2541646361,
-0.3492849767,
-0.0194340292,
0.2894648015,
0.4785238504,
0.0689048097,
-0.2097483873,
0.4678590298,
0.0138600981,
0.5289760232,
0.0104211327,
-0.3808472157,
-0.7859220505,
0.4956736267,
-0.0036668787,
0.5890859962,
0.5559154153,
0.5340246558,
-0.5533103347,
0.1002688706,
-0.6597766876,
0.2127604485,
-0.7799019814,
-0.0609979667,
-1.1056218147,
-0.145034492,
-0.1577425599,
-0.0377032086,
-0.3296562135,
-0.4017546177,
0.2749530375,
-0.133365497,
0.1848371774,
0.6033604741,
-0.299426347,
0.0720125139,
-1.0948511362,
0.9433906674,
0.9329042435,
0.3565997779,
0.4253833592,
0.1006468982,
-0.0794297755,
0.3286660612,
-0.4991005361,
-1.2013043165,
-0.2620470822,
0.0195302758,
0.3814413846,
0.3924746513,
0.0812875405,
1.2552338839,
-0.6707342863,
0.6140203476,
0.4448585212,
-1.1113977432,
0.8334561586,
-0.102883786,
0.3767710626,
0.7193421721,
0.6621762514,
-0.7374068499,
-0.4221203625,
-0.6656071544,
-0.6243009567,
0.1286749542,
-0.0180263389,
-0.1561499089,
-0.3972821832,
0.3456069231,
0.0082478616,
0.0530944727,
-0.7500014305,
-0.2257575989,
0.0715391412,
0.2403156757,
0.0385614932,
-0.0739459023,
-0.1019250974,
-0.2441727221,
0.4554283619,
-0.4112100601,
0.2224070728,
0.5395981669,
-0.175058797,
-0.4103584588,
0.5477182269,
0.3843798041,
1.1231096983,
-0.126564458,
0.6968595982,
0.2301623821,
-0.2324946523,
0.5629107952,
-0.7173891068,
0.1983125061,
-0.0431541353,
0.5536327362,
0.3802957535,
-0.2147949636,
-0.4351940453,
0.3735310733,
-0.0770588294,
-0.2252363712,
0.2151518911,
-0.0553242639,
0.0597373061,
0.267046243,
0.3315841556,
0.4120212495,
0.268699348,
-1.0475654602,
0.3494423926,
0.1987638623,
-0.2849317789,
-0.3723989129,
0.4507215321,
-0.0150850005,
-0.2680543661,
0.6108180285,
0.0078408672,
-0.7440735698,
0.5652868152,
0.5013135076,
0.8040185571,
-0.1904382259,
0.4524360895,
0.6663894057,
0.5311744213,
-0.2729620934,
0.6286647916,
-0.1414528936,
-0.7690674067,
-0.9108186364,
-0.3836605847,
-0.6076512933,
-0.1374783069,
-0.7777173519,
-0.0387941375,
-0.3675135374,
-0.2025313824,
-0.2316167206,
-0.2522028089,
-0.574164927,
0.4609696865,
-0.070020251,
0.690836668,
-1.0122463703,
0.3763321936,
0.4774549305,
-0.7274993658,
-0.8514305949,
0.4681459367,
-0.309417069,
-0.4678250849,
0.331540525,
0.192592591,
-0.5794400573,
-0.1719826162,
-0.4446561635,
-0.9907240868,
0.8146548867,
0.0322359614,
-0.5306549072,
0.0257122796,
-0.2030744702,
0.3269123137,
-0.1834159642,
0.6769715548,
0.5415775776,
0.5166654587,
0.3948785365,
-0.7113255262,
0.0885722041,
0.061765831,
-0.3330498338,
0.4056759775,
-0.6084201336,
0.8398313522,
-0.8230348229,
-0.0423310176,
-0.3504821062,
0.4933881462,
0.6832130551,
0.5231705904,
0.7085900307,
0.5696129799,
1.1360675097,
0.1699837297,
0.9374002218,
-0.1581213474,
0.2821610868,
1.2570650578,
-0.0599321872,
0.8804365396,
0.6356996298,
-0.3738589585,
1.2710449696,
0.8543067575,
0.5882886052,
0.4179376364,
0.3985553682,
-0.0964325517,
-0.5697698593,
0.2474699765,
-0.2938189209,
0.4281981587,
-0.0182355158,
0.0140537955,
-0.1287938207,
0.0030431775,
-0.244145751,
-0.2568382919,
-0.417295903,
0.9033263922,
-0.0105245486,
-1.0068674088,
0.5228946209,
-0.1416600496,
-0.007792742,
-0.3251782954,
-0.0861483887,
-0.0296760052,
0.0290932562,
-0.1589186788,
-0.946048975,
0.4672368765,
0.2237782031,
-0.4559510052,
-0.1339347959,
0.5358105898,
-0.2923318744,
-0.5855979323,
0.336127758,
0.9824699163,
0.2952815592,
-0.2034718841,
-0.6266771555,
-0.313539654,
-0.5621913671,
0.0095332647,
-0.1487138122,
0.9021610618,
-0.0448896587,
0.9188890457,
0.9021688104,
-0.1131880656,
0.1401549578,
0.0205439143,
0.8595089316,
-0.7899686098,
-0.6440605521,
-1.1458685398,
0.6746799946,
0.0281429887,
-0.092601046,
0.3370918036,
0.4976698458,
0.5621833205,
0.1000440493,
0.6687896848,
-0.0192152802,
0.4120939672,
-0.4984422922,
0.0386427604,
-0.4600017965,
0.1202908829,
-0.5470998287,
-0.8047198057,
-0.1327277422,
0.4227042496,
-0.0783920288,
0.1825153232,
1.3162252903,
0.2789991796,
-0.2315572351,
0.0445693955,
0.0827714652,
-0.0118530346,
0.304278791,
0.7657628655,
1.0619313717,
-0.5232474804,
0.8133509159,
-0.0404048935,
-0.165963158,
0.1392226517,
-0.8394443393,
-0.7502301931,
-0.3794751763,
-0.1799650639,
-0.3736572266,
-0.010157465,
0.6822094321,
0.7904771566,
-0.7510011196,
-0.2677141428,
-0.3616162241,
0.8554852009,
-0.998383522,
-0.1764813811,
0.2927844822,
-0.5723375678,
-0.0575199164,
0.2126476318,
0.1641301513,
-0.439656198,
-0.1212026626,
0.0137330564,
-0.6270610094,
0.3957142532,
0.7549986243,
-0.014101035,
-0.8655605316,
-0.3133127987,
0.1869710684,
0.3622613847,
0.1818322539,
1.1329522133,
-0.8176804185,
0.5960531831,
0.8126121759,
0.5836517215,
0.4430336654,
0.3779296875,
0.5477513671,
-0.5680382848,
-0.660494864,
0.0117614316,
0.119904235,
-0.1882257015,
-0.2553727627,
0.4866814613,
0.1231586784,
-0.6792714,
-0.4707561731,
0.4267009199,
-0.8010332584,
-0.5623726249,
1.0512491465,
0.011169184,
-0.2088574618,
-0.353485465,
-0.0556709655,
0.2412075996,
-0.02719496,
0.483733952,
0.8711595535,
-0.4297052622,
-0.4130196571,
-0.3990200162,
0.1953269541,
-0.1064931676,
-1.0432345867,
0.2847847044,
0.2655488253,
0.3132276237,
0.3597532511,
1.096129179,
0.0618063398,
0.4570768178,
-0.1211152747,
-0.2432764322,
0.2968367636,
-1.0098377466,
-0.0129839508,
0.4050953388,
-0.120510377,
-0.4929469526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13005v2 | Evaluating Inter-Bilingual Semantic Parsing for Indian Languages | 2023-04-25T17:24:32 | 2023-06-05T15:55:47 | Divyanshu Aggarwal, Vivek Gupta, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite significant progress in Natural Language Generation for Indian
languages (IndicNLP), there is a lack of datasets around complex structured
tasks such as semantic parsing. One reason for this imminent gap is the
complexity of the logical form, which makes English to multilingual translation
difficult. The process involves alignment of logical forms, intents and slots
with translated unstructured utterance. To address this, we propose an
Inter-bilingual Seq2seq Semantic parsing dataset IE-SEMPARSE for 11 distinct
Indian languages. We highlight the proposed task's practicality, and evaluate
existing multilingual seq2seq models across several train-test strategies. Our
experiment reveals a high correlation across performance of original
multilingual semantic parsing datasets (such as mTOP, multilingual TOP and
multiATIS++) and our proposed IE-SEMPARSE suite. | [
-0.247999236,
-0.3904974461,
0.1554276794,
0.9423113465,
-0.3317308128,
-0.1902379245,
-0.1952655017,
-0.550170064,
0.2284772247,
0.2932943404,
-0.5188221335,
-0.2595676482,
-0.5303225517,
0.4918117821,
-0.2846283317,
0.4692465663,
0.0117083313,
0.2895686626,
-0.3825691342,
-0.4537531137,
-0.7416468859,
-0.1236477867,
-0.3327097297,
-0.1199639142,
0.1083818525,
0.4753905535,
0.3643213511,
0.3736096919,
0.4416381121,
0.3151432574,
0.1600236893,
0.4695462286,
0.0690901503,
0.3104820549,
-0.5843448043,
-0.3189383149,
-0.271790415,
-0.2570796609,
0.7270799875,
0.986415267,
-0.0841811299,
0.2193190902,
0.0480911583,
0.5303356647,
-0.6124920845,
0.2842619121,
-0.6625912189,
0.1114769652,
-0.5230641961,
-0.1695513874,
-0.4874474406,
-0.1216689199,
-0.2391771674,
-0.364535898,
-0.3173439503,
0.0182593539,
0.5068179369,
0.1399761587,
-0.5570697188,
-0.2610604167,
-0.5001664758,
0.6168519855,
-0.882357955,
0.5987184048,
0.4387393892,
0.3907790482,
0.0669782981,
-0.4803213179,
-0.5383751392,
0.1179860905,
-0.0352998525,
0.2690667212,
0.1891532391,
-0.3805253208,
0.2262170762,
0.214519456,
-0.7646375895,
0.1807946414,
-0.3184195757,
-0.0521910936,
0.5000396967,
0.2549842298,
0.875526607,
-0.2772346437,
-0.6517663002,
0.0153160226,
-0.5605831742,
0.4330736399,
0.3980053961,
0.4691462815,
0.0212572385,
1.1446038485,
-0.5749054551,
0.6976473927,
-0.3678312004,
0.0266851131,
0.3061183989,
-0.5214124322,
0.0205785707,
0.2836866081,
0.4606775641,
0.4225457907,
0.1456611603,
-0.0977480114,
-0.1056895182,
0.3014752865,
-0.1912550777,
-0.5210083723,
0.3309834599,
0.115094617,
-0.083464697,
0.2341500074,
-0.1312237531,
-0.6609101892,
-0.1015661433,
-0.7318791151,
0.2985126376,
-0.7008113265,
-0.3110364974,
0.4600081742,
-0.0973325372,
0.8732860684,
0.2990313768,
-0.9427230358,
0.3282120228,
0.7836555243,
0.4876297712,
-0.1190035418,
-0.7411820889,
-0.6766896248,
0.2861348987,
-0.11770311,
1.1320579052,
-0.8965557814,
-0.2303186357,
-0.2070841342,
-0.1236399859,
-0.5558813214,
-0.3863450289,
0.7452251911,
-0.2899636328,
0.3078454733,
-0.3824187517,
-0.4747230113,
0.030815281,
0.5573430061,
-0.2649435699,
0.9057384729,
-0.1417296082,
-0.6743495464,
0.4021897018,
-0.3549586535,
-0.5762304068,
0.0920475423,
-0.4196506739,
-0.0060629393,
0.0954091251,
0.5311704874,
0.2179360986,
-0.6539146304,
0.320548296,
-0.2779099345,
-0.0004077768,
-0.1801809669,
-0.2455120236,
1.105388999,
0.2605093122,
-0.271232307,
-0.0727381557,
-0.890081048,
0.3300793469,
-0.0695361346,
0.0172558576,
-0.5293677449,
-0.059121076,
-0.0598305501,
0.7328840494,
0.2495091856,
-0.8123586178,
-0.0316974223,
-0.6208714247,
0.2668608427,
0.4778106809,
-0.1857245564,
0.2776858807,
0.0289402064,
0.3791542053,
0.297849834,
0.1524670571,
-0.1362414211,
-0.5270729661,
-0.7385243177,
-0.1052967235,
0.2642332315,
0.9455503821,
-0.5169435143,
0.3420596421,
-0.4090908468,
-0.4274135232,
-0.4633721411,
0.0748328343,
0.4278222919,
0.6264172792,
0.3963449001,
-0.1411125213,
-0.3801612854,
-1.3156003952,
-0.6907165051,
0.0258360822,
0.2626659274,
-0.2740175426,
0.2569077313,
-0.4443379641,
0.9206004143,
-0.0264479592,
-0.1082409322,
-0.1109788492,
0.0402682461,
0.0082822256,
0.5967590809,
0.2888406515,
-0.6533169746,
-0.6725412011,
0.1034042388,
-0.7166636586,
-0.3864859045,
0.164257437,
-0.2804591656,
0.1336617917,
0.5338330269,
-0.7156996131,
0.293728888,
0.2974807322,
-0.5006909966,
0.0694699511,
-0.1521300673,
0.2507485449,
-1.198788166,
-0.0007015169,
-0.4718925953,
-0.0774694979,
-0.4088520706,
0.0247170664,
0.2529148161,
-0.4243154228,
-0.4551906586,
0.5312936306,
-0.340482831,
-0.2952014804,
0.2356742471,
0.0379303247,
0.1322659701,
0.3898868561,
0.0246119574,
0.6561564803,
0.3664135635,
-0.219238013,
-0.019149363,
0.4981516004,
-0.1714609861,
0.7178669572,
-0.6659405231,
-0.1455308497,
-0.3742161095,
-0.2105637789,
-1.0650945902,
-0.1678717732,
-0.0120754382,
-0.4269549847,
0.3520967364,
0.0537740961,
-0.5983917117,
0.1772506088,
-0.3560627699,
0.6151124835,
0.1298307925,
-0.5604764819,
0.6238955855,
0.4417575598,
-0.3925661445,
-0.5187188983,
-0.771348238,
0.228358224,
-0.2019248605,
-1.1771492958,
0.000376097,
0.1914869696,
-0.2949693799,
-0.0812557191,
-0.0940374359,
0.0291552655,
-0.1145220548,
0.0672376528,
-0.044225011,
-0.360984832,
0.0320816375,
0.295376718,
-0.3174919784,
-0.0048535634,
-0.1134215519,
0.6150694489,
-0.505910337,
-0.7797967792,
-0.1500143111,
0.7599748373,
0.475841701,
-0.8888887167,
0.5001718998,
0.5473583341,
-0.4800852537,
-0.1660568565,
-0.5846693516,
0.2831941545,
-0.3552053869,
0.063776657,
-0.5519628525,
-0.5308586359,
0.5685452223,
-0.1925117522,
-0.0487898067,
0.7922644615,
0.562443316,
0.1759939641,
1.1663899422,
0.2078941911,
0.2916487455,
-0.1251635998,
0.1173067987,
0.4951516092,
-0.6590770483,
-0.4416032434,
-0.6208036542,
-0.0053815856,
-0.5601616502,
-0.3528722525,
0.3420780301,
0.2526477575,
0.0011411739,
0.2564966083,
-0.119977951,
0.5599250197,
0.4416000247,
-0.3777604997,
0.3714455366,
0.1783819646,
-0.3455231488,
-0.3087558746,
-0.581813097,
-0.4936982095,
0.6186268926,
-0.0118489815,
0.453458786,
0.4664081931,
0.4714765549,
0.0266377255,
-0.3984720111,
-0.4811067283,
0.5346798897,
-0.2540113628,
-0.1796268672,
-0.2509241104,
-0.0302150249,
-0.9065210223,
0.559641242,
-0.1231773347,
-0.3975689709,
0.2512327135,
-0.2183134854,
-0.0658332333,
-0.0875935256,
-0.9511590004,
0.9570409656,
-0.2834335566,
-0.2920873165,
-0.1431371868,
-0.966732502,
0.5271913409,
0.1255667061,
0.1883814782,
-0.5181315541,
-0.0413633734,
0.4153141379,
-0.6805984378,
0.5017896891,
-0.1470655203,
0.073332414,
0.1970550567,
0.0363389701,
0.2658534646,
0.3315746784,
-0.0080799963,
0.1408782899,
0.2397020012,
-0.6258429885,
-0.4017790258,
0.7997258902,
-0.6734127998,
-0.2601684332,
-0.5690147281,
-0.3770601749,
-0.793436408,
0.3247689903,
0.2208580226,
0.6239762306,
0.1786199212,
0.0411532894,
0.3677008748,
-0.2846377194,
0.4251624942,
0.4563001692,
-0.1674787849,
-0.2962757051,
0.8385090828,
0.0840268135,
0.1775620878,
0.4597118795,
0.203653276,
-0.5946929455,
-0.3270128667,
-0.723901391,
0.2540091574,
-0.7028998733,
-0.188230738,
-0.7515103221,
-0.2401091456,
-0.7706230283,
0.0315731391,
-0.5265476108,
-0.862026751,
0.2709922791,
0.1751646996,
0.0226447675,
0.3586022556,
-0.1297218651,
-0.2086242437,
-0.8727023602,
0.3141878247,
0.541646719,
0.2895251513,
-0.4140618145,
-0.2632089257,
0.2831834257,
0.0859414563,
0.155181706,
-0.5597658753,
0.2341940701,
0.3554755449,
0.503218472,
-0.0181648657,
-0.0299082156,
0.912548542,
-0.757397294,
0.6860304475,
0.1105989814,
-0.8730728626,
0.6787256002,
-0.3616595566,
0.421213448,
0.8218715191,
0.1799003929,
-0.5889032483,
-0.1423450261,
-0.315738529,
-0.9312517047,
0.6223286986,
0.2217603326,
0.0262213089,
-0.2371413857,
-0.0433344319,
0.2512076497,
-0.0042547751,
-0.3905975223,
0.1577376872,
-0.1267233044,
-0.2034749538,
0.069036901,
-0.3214167058,
0.1048386395,
-0.3870013058,
0.4919419587,
0.1152995005,
0.0462063514,
0.2504215539,
-0.4933119118,
0.2481132448,
0.5989858508,
0.6805612445,
0.6781869531,
0.0117973713,
0.292398572,
0.0691958815,
-0.2754497528,
0.0526231378,
0.3579778373,
-0.0253092162,
-0.143008545,
0.4540869892,
0.6634063721,
0.0461822115,
-1.0324565172,
0.6774671674,
-0.2124898285,
0.1272005588,
-0.5439094305,
-0.0994455889,
0.171223253,
0.2460542619,
-0.2554016411,
0.2439964712,
0.3296892643,
-0.4463360608,
-0.0404021293,
0.2772226632,
-0.1665817052,
-0.3525652289,
0.6696050763,
0.167936042,
-0.0911859497,
0.8394021392,
-0.2385949343,
-0.3622975051,
0.3383164108,
0.722566843,
0.6007076502,
-0.3468729258,
-0.0206442233,
0.3537097275,
0.4810131788,
-0.0302288476,
0.5682492256,
-0.1149096861,
-0.5920248628,
-0.649276793,
-0.7968777418,
-0.1335619092,
-0.2890691459,
-0.5962534547,
0.6014540195,
-0.0062618507,
0.3674891293,
-0.1302809864,
-0.3222025037,
-0.6424505115,
0.0141002489,
0.2493582517,
0.9966413379,
-1.0368990898,
0.7431133986,
0.8822678924,
-0.3267523944,
-0.6926853657,
-0.5101490021,
-0.1274703443,
-0.9767093062,
0.7060319781,
0.282571137,
-0.206225127,
-0.0982367694,
0.1173309237,
-0.75628829,
0.78545928,
0.4397410154,
-0.2397529185,
0.1250357777,
0.9408608079,
0.5190933943,
-0.1745724529,
0.1588650197,
0.4886580706,
0.3989616334,
-0.0735129267,
-0.8456282616,
-0.3104709089,
-0.8101186156,
0.1605162472,
0.4915952981,
-0.5946685672,
0.9087571502,
0.2283490747,
-0.1447783709,
-0.2581199408,
0.4559594691,
0.1366659701,
0.3094298542,
0.5998893976,
1.1061309576,
0.4238071442,
0.2031361014,
0.9063069224,
-0.242071107,
0.0519928373,
1.4009414911,
-0.6175239682,
0.9622609615,
0.7610348463,
-0.1712634712,
0.0523375943,
0.3536717594,
0.4960740805,
0.2904313207,
-0.2309240401,
-0.1475402415,
-0.4143244624,
-0.3400022089,
-0.5514808893,
0.9421545267,
0.4565187097,
0.2306862324,
-0.8366919756,
0.0480579659,
-0.1809598804,
0.3543740809,
-0.0090122065,
0.6010096073,
-0.1491544396,
-0.8102820516,
0.2679888606,
0.1134255603,
0.1935506612,
-0.7319096923,
-0.1309568286,
-0.2749396265,
0.0971669033,
-0.2087866813,
-0.7119819522,
0.7663094997,
-0.1037041098,
0.0262129959,
-0.3647617698,
0.7383141518,
-0.7089686394,
-0.4816343784,
0.247115612,
0.6915413141,
-0.0131905936,
0.0244159196,
-0.4933776855,
-0.1346099526,
-0.1013427526,
0.0219149962,
0.3749824464,
0.5780399442,
-0.3150039613,
0.1606500596,
0.5084404349,
-0.113150999,
0.6679028273,
-0.0436130986,
0.5631449819,
-0.5471913815,
-0.4739113152,
-0.6961010098,
0.6058390141,
-0.2152372003,
-0.5446564555,
1.044421196,
0.8981512189,
1.085688591,
-0.1097734049,
0.3062061071,
-0.1213513464,
0.7078811526,
-0.5986955762,
0.0963728875,
-0.5813438296,
0.3538764119,
0.1407904178,
-0.943659842,
-0.4227203727,
0.4501942098,
-0.2307663709,
-0.4714916945,
0.6240427494,
0.671726048,
-0.4205933511,
0.3262792826,
0.1762490124,
-0.0990661234,
0.2694222629,
0.5763320923,
1.0253341198,
-0.4771414101,
0.138269186,
-0.5246079564,
-0.020084314,
0.1460273564,
-0.7750657797,
-0.67979002,
-0.7048067451,
-0.0082609793,
-0.1142898351,
-0.4204599857,
1.1869096756,
0.1878964603,
-0.8263832331,
-0.2528203726,
-0.0397569612,
-0.3127069175,
0.2067392021,
-0.1374916583,
0.267565161,
-0.8357712626,
-0.6613473296,
0.487475127,
0.7582168579,
-0.304412961,
0.1250786185,
0.1930812448,
-0.6334763765,
-0.115685612,
0.9616477489,
0.3800990283,
-0.6170508862,
-0.0653332546,
-0.0168268103,
-0.1143638194,
0.0317177996,
0.8424276114,
-0.4200807214,
0.7260802984,
0.8010649085,
1.1293925047,
0.3765537143,
-0.1728943884,
0.3000658751,
-0.6189094782,
0.4374184012,
0.2512943745,
0.5871447921,
0.3118244112,
0.029040603,
0.6528308988,
0.1738758087,
-0.4286600351,
-0.7648879886,
0.0984591544,
-1.073892951,
-0.1141205877,
1.061527729,
0.1650648564,
-0.2761484087,
-0.1329867989,
-0.2373023927,
0.0028017729,
0.046876885,
0.1910888553,
0.5364345312,
-0.3285183311,
0.1933322549,
-0.5559861064,
0.1232620329,
0.8670715094,
-0.9371231794,
-0.0431523137,
0.4738445282,
0.0582197011,
0.0695182532,
0.6991372705,
-0.4546603262,
0.169145301,
0.002184347,
-0.1849329174,
0.1289669275,
-0.3191320002,
-0.3459946513,
0.0248285811,
0.1352593303,
-0.0875581577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12995v1 | AudioGPT: Understanding and Generating Speech, Music, Sound, and Talking Head | 2023-04-25T17:05:38 | 2023-04-25T17:05:38 | Rongjie Huang, Mingze Li, Dongchao Yang, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Zhenhui Ye, Yuning Wu, Zhiqing Hong, Jiawei Huang, Jinglin Liu, Yi Ren, Zhou Zhao, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities across a
variety of domains and tasks, challenging our understanding of learning and
cognition. Despite the recent success, current LLMs are not capable of
processing complex audio information or conducting spoken conversations (like
Siri or Alexa). In this work, we propose a multi-modal AI system named
AudioGPT, which complements LLMs (i.e., ChatGPT) with 1) foundation models to
process complex audio information and solve numerous understanding and
generation tasks; and 2) the input/output interface (ASR, TTS) to support
spoken dialogue. With an increasing demand to evaluate multi-modal LLMs of
human intention understanding and cooperation with foundation models, we
outline the principles and processes and test AudioGPT in terms of consistency,
capability, and robustness. Experimental results demonstrate the capabilities
of AudioGPT in solving AI tasks with speech, music, sound, and talking head
understanding and generation in multi-round dialogues, which empower humans to
create rich and diverse audio content with unprecedented ease. Our system is
publicly available at \url{https://github.com/AIGC-Audio/AudioGPT}. | [
-0.5884336233,
-1.0807949305,
0.6100008488,
0.30614838,
-0.1076230705,
0.0810864121,
-0.5525886416,
-0.4665113986,
-0.0344814062,
0.1960336268,
-0.7609813213,
-0.242576316,
-0.5982809663,
-0.0662978515,
-0.4398974776,
0.9448828697,
0.1818401068,
0.198059544,
0.0270930529,
-0.0466635413,
-0.8642818332,
-0.4034463465,
-1.1098278761,
-0.7039052844,
0.156269908,
0.4335029721,
0.6743627787,
0.2756008208,
0.4953109622,
0.3395465612,
0.1553100348,
0.1279770881,
-0.1861793846,
0.2463322729,
0.1444536895,
-0.1943960637,
-0.6679614186,
-0.0122514814,
0.5679587722,
0.5580701232,
-0.2814431787,
-0.0282360092,
0.0454606302,
0.1939044893,
-0.026654426,
0.5301603079,
-0.5671132207,
-0.0278939754,
0.2209160179,
-0.3405773342,
-0.1645168811,
-0.0164146479,
0.2681597769,
-0.5315225124,
-0.033605691,
0.0240711272,
0.3950677812,
0.5812585354,
-0.285818398,
-0.3714959919,
-0.8913314939,
0.607595861,
-0.6132335067,
0.7939829826,
0.3519281447,
0.5623681545,
-0.036875654,
-0.6039752364,
-0.9330474138,
-0.4626586139,
0.2493866086,
0.1470744759,
-0.0780474693,
0.1982133836,
0.0592405908,
0.311588496,
-0.7064697742,
-0.2225200832,
-0.1443131864,
-0.186832577,
0.4487110376,
0.0518148094,
0.5611342788,
-0.2496465743,
-0.2480806112,
-0.1346007288,
-0.6122274399,
-0.0768747851,
0.1387506872,
0.3442044258,
-0.248799324,
0.6389549971,
-0.0608064458,
0.648357749,
0.008433166,
-0.495236963,
0.172345981,
-0.4508182406,
-0.2599811554,
0.1980308294,
0.8720901608,
0.0608572699,
0.1883387715,
-0.1578481942,
-0.2208555192,
0.0816212595,
0.1696630567,
-0.5446791053,
-0.100543797,
0.2822071016,
-0.208959192,
-0.0820999891,
-0.1568025798,
-0.3161361814,
-0.1497035474,
-0.6608485579,
0.6134849191,
-0.7933381796,
-0.4167319834,
0.2577691972,
-0.0614717752,
0.2928363085,
0.4405606687,
-0.8052922487,
0.1447955221,
0.6534991264,
0.8616497517,
-0.2941571772,
-0.4910749793,
-0.4808760881,
0.411338985,
0.0408849008,
0.6976739168,
-0.5827109218,
-0.4805828035,
-0.4474240541,
-0.3268727064,
-0.1257675439,
-0.3017140329,
0.6171730161,
-0.236993432,
0.1406965852,
0.0375727713,
-0.3133455813,
-0.3099861741,
0.3906300366,
-0.4196125567,
0.5700138211,
-0.2098977566,
-0.4572244585,
0.1111397892,
-1.0367277861,
-0.4877310097,
0.0089113638,
-0.4894074798,
-0.2083902955,
-0.1907214969,
0.2915153801,
0.4459759891,
-0.4447819889,
0.5889812112,
-0.021398386,
-0.3401445448,
0.1899809837,
-0.8042548299,
0.4318807423,
0.2316279858,
-0.6844934225,
0.3179959655,
-0.6796050072,
-0.1168072671,
0.1008792073,
-0.6909689307,
0.246775493,
0.182502389,
0.5569012165,
0.0662332103,
0.0390238687,
-0.4541194439,
0.1082506701,
0.1416847706,
0.9907361865,
0.6604321599,
-0.2254523933,
0.0851445645,
-0.4731298387,
0.4555440843,
-0.3341694772,
-0.0782997608,
-0.44555825,
-0.5730636716,
-0.6953604817,
-0.3540259898,
0.1240752786,
0.771093905,
-0.5162973404,
0.4208140075,
-0.4960829616,
-0.2273537815,
-0.251291275,
-0.1638904959,
0.3507763147,
0.3813536763,
0.2048935294,
-0.2936879992,
-0.4059722126,
-0.7192279696,
0.0007924585,
-0.3551417291,
-0.3217092156,
0.6859002113,
0.2093446702,
-0.4058688879,
0.9717437029,
-0.0511201695,
-0.1431025714,
-0.3226238191,
0.5068722963,
0.0863330811,
0.5990026593,
0.2666289806,
-0.981914103,
-0.116374068,
0.0850294828,
-0.6831589937,
-0.1653356105,
-0.1815442294,
0.1779302508,
-0.3652867675,
0.3924069107,
-0.9517337084,
-0.0092541333,
0.5707120895,
-0.21663028,
0.5005154014,
0.2323566824,
0.4170950055,
-0.9974398613,
-0.0072671445,
-0.1989109069,
-0.5224512815,
-0.592418611,
-0.1823031902,
-0.4470189214,
-0.5369856954,
-0.3910010755,
0.2768924236,
-0.2819708884,
-0.3200929761,
-0.4417898655,
0.1960893869,
-0.0575650334,
0.6682583094,
0.1933217794,
1.1456243992,
0.6437487602,
-0.5219128728,
0.6322826147,
0.3590168059,
-0.287637651,
0.7283649445,
-0.8117174506,
0.3758070469,
0.0574765615,
0.3038859367,
-1.0061032772,
-0.4182601571,
0.2537537813,
-0.6195369959,
0.2433865517,
-0.0205418151,
-0.3943107128,
0.0792499334,
0.191002965,
0.701695919,
0.3721404076,
-0.4978665113,
0.9510868788,
0.5639842153,
-0.6467988491,
-0.1776531041,
-0.5384615064,
0.2917710543,
-0.2906123698,
-0.9150182009,
0.2731235921,
-0.3570172787,
-0.2611006498,
-0.1271674633,
-0.0875009075,
-0.1207142323,
-0.2615270913,
0.3110311925,
-0.0612833686,
-0.3709995449,
0.1453187764,
-0.1445997655,
-0.0515011512,
0.0427325889,
-0.4482844174,
0.6998915076,
-0.4939185083,
-0.8102303147,
-0.6634418368,
0.5153494477,
0.9332279563,
-0.3302113414,
-0.0116467625,
0.8344752789,
-0.2649378181,
0.1151863933,
-0.5822245479,
-0.2261155993,
-0.4553341866,
0.4446184039,
-0.4666866958,
-0.9458583593,
0.3296810985,
-0.1208638102,
0.0306561161,
0.1735450625,
0.7955604196,
0.0545150638,
1.0708568096,
0.4039965868,
-0.1725265682,
0.6095129251,
-0.0959138051,
0.259441644,
-0.8042437434,
-0.2035223544,
-0.2649316192,
-0.2213679254,
-0.254614383,
-0.3705177903,
0.7483308315,
-0.0124634691,
-0.3021226525,
0.1684189588,
-0.3908353448,
0.3654641807,
0.7787427306,
0.186081484,
0.4990569949,
-0.1166633666,
0.1575189978,
0.2914537191,
-0.5167818666,
-0.508166194,
0.8976415992,
0.4223043025,
0.8667289615,
0.2513708472,
0.2155060619,
0.2981855571,
-0.1104849875,
-0.9551905394,
0.3792456686,
0.2615901828,
-0.4566909969,
-0.5454360843,
-0.2310306728,
-0.5331960917,
0.3096683025,
-0.1366358548,
-0.7729505897,
-0.1226059794,
0.0333036333,
-0.3628713489,
0.1036004052,
-0.7066945434,
0.6813994646,
-0.3431503773,
-0.0421672314,
-0.3784649074,
-0.5962699056,
0.3496124148,
0.0874392018,
0.253199935,
-0.2229970396,
0.2056790143,
0.5876960754,
0.088728331,
0.7349930406,
0.0450670198,
-0.0351151228,
0.3811200857,
0.1079106182,
0.2287080735,
0.4979733825,
0.0592936091,
0.1531199366,
-0.2314314544,
-0.0265159681,
-0.505032599,
0.6659986377,
-0.7527636886,
-0.6295215487,
-0.1328378767,
-0.9795933962,
-0.3378559649,
0.3394301534,
-0.0307801254,
0.5066396594,
-0.2643834651,
0.2821577191,
0.6416160464,
-0.0361746103,
0.4630670846,
0.293723613,
-0.1647745073,
-0.3627793491,
0.9645487666,
-0.3513107896,
0.1002392396,
0.2730208039,
0.1304164678,
-0.1542167217,
-0.5838583708,
-0.7788577676,
-0.0239504501,
-0.561837554,
0.0372241214,
-0.6357480884,
-0.1688676178,
-0.3736064136,
0.1046438143,
-0.3880800009,
-0.389257431,
-0.052065134,
-0.126778841,
0.2293600738,
0.8457756042,
-0.1074622497,
0.5449079871,
-0.7608404756,
0.5472664833,
0.8181368709,
0.2012028247,
-0.1893853992,
-0.2468216717,
-0.005030253,
0.1677297205,
-0.5265752077,
-0.8239637017,
0.083715938,
0.3239349723,
0.4772596359,
0.3900866508,
-0.4271580279,
0.4827350378,
-0.7230110765,
0.8285501003,
0.1469670236,
-1.220499754,
0.4194251001,
-0.7466475368,
0.2227912694,
0.3010857403,
-0.0926419348,
-0.7324845195,
-0.2066262364,
-0.4116152525,
-0.6835765839,
0.6984891891,
0.5237993598,
0.0158473924,
0.2682431042,
0.1611627638,
-0.0171356853,
0.4386868477,
-0.7271319032,
-0.1114124581,
-0.4710056484,
-0.1077813134,
-0.0858611017,
0.065089874,
-0.2372456938,
-0.1551478952,
0.6724078059,
-0.1883392632,
0.5267707705,
0.2376418114,
0.0553199537,
0.0267945044,
0.4646912217,
0.6941995621,
0.6421961188,
-0.0261096973,
0.0783900246,
-0.0465841852,
-0.2959817946,
0.165089637,
0.1628754884,
0.2185715288,
-0.1301944256,
0.3682754636,
1.0902647972,
0.2230863869,
-0.8989106417,
0.5502080917,
-0.224913016,
-0.0637472942,
-0.599250257,
0.1583790034,
0.3653982282,
0.4053780138,
0.2469863594,
0.1470948011,
0.3120107353,
-0.6572164893,
0.4038394094,
0.5827184916,
-0.4117546976,
-0.2610844672,
0.7562394738,
0.2447176129,
-0.5670539737,
0.6334233284,
0.0707976744,
-0.4484339654,
0.4407918155,
0.5346516967,
0.8349526525,
-0.247107625,
0.0180196706,
-0.1007352993,
0.1926364452,
0.1811199635,
0.3781704903,
-0.33294788,
-0.7236253619,
-0.5843271017,
-0.5496362448,
-0.5997287035,
0.3186716437,
-0.2214767784,
0.1461693347,
-0.2691437006,
-0.1281950027,
-0.0179700144,
-0.5073814392,
-0.5444691777,
0.161519289,
0.1829895526,
0.5059693456,
-0.7007120252,
0.7011977434,
0.6336789131,
-0.4510202706,
-0.9609862566,
0.0851021633,
0.0023306143,
-0.8395355344,
0.5303407311,
0.096685335,
-0.4749113917,
0.1015680656,
-0.5032744408,
-0.6927238107,
1.0949300528,
0.5326126218,
-0.4355744123,
-0.1149799824,
0.1913453788,
0.1743575782,
-0.3829447925,
0.3780198991,
0.6539498568,
0.8409020901,
0.1676146388,
-1.3687285185,
-0.3155031204,
-0.2282164246,
-0.3307761848,
0.0106195826,
-0.6173968911,
0.9893231988,
-0.0813048333,
-0.0733836293,
-0.0812687203,
0.4120191932,
0.339053005,
0.1386412382,
0.7554876804,
0.5123883486,
0.4667983353,
-0.2519298494,
0.8386191726,
-0.2594181001,
0.1679147333,
0.9468027949,
0.0366673954,
0.5352955461,
0.4444491863,
-0.0717215985,
0.049219355,
0.6125911474,
0.2756632268,
0.4123507142,
0.1240356266,
-0.580258131,
-0.5089274049,
-0.2170211375,
-0.396453917,
0.9383341074,
0.3515912294,
-0.0291349404,
0.0546668768,
0.2829223871,
-0.2462309897,
-0.3810150921,
-0.0574455298,
0.9091345072,
0.1387577802,
-0.4853052199,
0.3628020883,
-0.0455757007,
0.6329696774,
-0.5997748375,
-0.329489857,
0.1787673831,
-0.1309669316,
-0.0953373313,
-0.5504749417,
0.204799369,
-0.1138227358,
-0.2233943194,
-0.1085756347,
0.4823613465,
-0.583114028,
-0.3440002799,
0.1765078455,
0.7443451881,
0.2803677022,
-0.2510969639,
-0.6447033286,
0.2833643854,
-0.0841163993,
-0.3807211816,
0.0708671436,
0.3479946554,
0.1292749345,
0.7565302849,
0.6981084943,
0.0828989819,
0.0622949377,
0.2349900901,
0.6399527192,
-0.4428529441,
-0.6518495083,
-0.7410753369,
0.2343521714,
0.2206922919,
-0.0730481222,
0.2929255664,
0.4631813467,
0.8601497412,
0.0625490323,
1.1794446707,
-0.1536191553,
0.3390390575,
-0.6769577861,
0.6192684174,
-0.4909596145,
0.1797441393,
-0.3678639829,
-0.9521434307,
-0.2270126194,
0.8669056892,
0.068080388,
0.2244158238,
0.6248829365,
0.5555390716,
-0.4076430202,
0.582762897,
0.3640193045,
0.0063110078,
0.6962043047,
0.5166356564,
0.8657899499,
-0.1837465912,
0.6873247027,
-0.073451899,
-0.3054817319,
0.0893989801,
-0.7054594755,
-0.6987307072,
-0.6867918372,
-0.0005876696,
0.0897776634,
0.190554738,
1.0269683599,
1.1197961569,
-0.6573607922,
-0.448633194,
-0.2814069986,
-0.0407339036,
-0.2100939304,
-0.23966977,
0.2744468153,
-0.2466038316,
-1.1377378702,
1.0097777843,
0.364256084,
0.0032813991,
-0.4258136153,
-0.3632562757,
0.0835883915,
-0.1308288574,
0.6044643521,
0.1443870813,
-0.9061003923,
-0.5970951319,
-0.2281469107,
0.2424200177,
0.2701556683,
1.1917550564,
-0.552413702,
0.3575130403,
0.4032942653,
0.8881272674,
0.4390205443,
0.0541027412,
0.8471506238,
-0.429577291,
0.0650892183,
0.3168918192,
0.5307964087,
0.4810888469,
-0.2206273973,
0.3537042141,
0.1087957099,
-0.7694987655,
-0.5269309878,
0.4360387325,
-1.2223960161,
-0.1077479422,
1.0971133709,
0.0423698276,
0.1965572536,
-0.2084246725,
-0.5788760781,
0.5188542604,
-0.6894962192,
0.5207067728,
0.7325235009,
-0.6904528737,
-0.3319553137,
-0.7566326261,
0.3338650763,
0.3563865721,
-0.6853575706,
0.0541498996,
0.5612211227,
0.2231580019,
0.3246313035,
0.7992560863,
0.0179329943,
0.3350236416,
-0.2195305973,
0.117687203,
-0.2200654894,
-0.5586329699,
-0.1888514757,
0.2492168099,
0.0764897242,
-0.2886050344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12986v2 | Measuring Massive Multitask Chinese Understanding | 2023-04-25T16:51:53 | 2023-05-15T16:41:08 | Hui Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | The development of large-scale Chinese language models is flourishing, yet
there is a lack of corresponding capability assessments. Therefore, we propose
a test to measure the multitask accuracy of large Chinese language models. This
test encompasses four major domains, including medicine, law, psychology, and
education, with 15 subtasks in medicine and 8 subtasks in education. We found
that the best-performing models in the zero-shot setting outperformed the
worst-performing models by nearly 18.6 percentage points on average. Across the
four major domains, the highest average zero-shot accuracy of all models is
0.512. In the subdomains, only the GPT-3.5-turbo model achieved a zero-shot
accuracy of 0.693 in clinical medicine, which was the highest accuracy among
all models across all subtasks. All models performed poorly in the legal
domain, with the highest zero-shot accuracy reaching only 0.239. By
comprehensively evaluating the breadth and depth of knowledge across multiple
disciplines, this test can more accurately identify the shortcomings of the
models. | [
-0.0682267845,
-0.7869099379,
0.6877118945,
0.3317216635,
-0.0593161695,
-0.0646222979,
-0.4315856993,
-0.4860213697,
0.1068297103,
0.1193153784,
-0.4295733869,
-0.5487415195,
-0.6975477338,
-0.1583149284,
-0.1947352439,
0.9210158587,
-0.1100946963,
0.3129184246,
0.1573055089,
-0.1347930878,
-0.7791868448,
-0.36094594,
-0.6935408115,
-0.3349212408,
0.5773863196,
0.0870585591,
0.5739037991,
0.4883006513,
0.5377879739,
0.1475982666,
-0.0439265668,
0.0149912648,
-0.2272607833,
-0.3592703044,
-0.1922747493,
-0.1984094083,
-0.9366503954,
0.1654525101,
0.608320415,
0.7553229332,
-0.0217538606,
0.2202205807,
0.0917895585,
0.3159503341,
-0.5715864897,
0.3474166989,
-0.3884368837,
0.1213013828,
-0.208730638,
-0.0176783595,
-0.4405640364,
0.1649872214,
0.1272602975,
-0.633230567,
0.3101684451,
-0.2134683877,
0.8146474957,
0.00665252,
-0.8310139775,
0.056095425,
-0.5348585844,
0.8905075192,
-0.9456601143,
0.4156487584,
0.3064081371,
0.3254933953,
0.0304206535,
-0.4360199869,
-0.6813339591,
-0.6054045558,
0.0144873289,
0.5374974608,
0.2582286298,
0.4851609468,
0.3470427096,
0.4205189347,
-1.0571165085,
0.1735761911,
-0.2840666175,
-0.1292691827,
0.7801119089,
0.4653610289,
0.5488241911,
-0.0846049264,
-0.1455113441,
-0.0884603336,
-0.3655822277,
0.2493299544,
-0.0210585762,
0.336835742,
-0.0197708327,
0.5762616992,
-0.3509352803,
0.9220147133,
-0.2184682786,
-0.4706735313,
0.1013135612,
-1.0785831213,
-0.4377462268,
-0.2701454759,
0.739471674,
0.4101037383,
0.1735512316,
0.0156568009,
-0.1329583824,
-0.0805890635,
0.2849405408,
-0.6809216142,
-0.2588873804,
0.5203251243,
-0.397326827,
0.115198724,
0.0854675844,
-0.1703779548,
-0.4379087389,
-0.2776128054,
0.3752239943,
-0.6339295506,
-0.5498562455,
0.3136125207,
-0.0622583777,
0.4753776491,
0.3803173602,
-0.9295101166,
-0.127502054,
0.9293414354,
1.0962054729,
-0.1987801641,
-0.8461242914,
-0.1439656764,
-0.0569775365,
-0.8182724714,
0.696066916,
-0.1247517765,
-0.0669692382,
-0.2031175196,
0.0599535629,
-0.4778428674,
-0.326602906,
0.4138087034,
-0.0231424123,
-0.2664912343,
-0.4476689696,
-0.5681869388,
-0.4645607471,
0.690657258,
-0.4664220512,
0.6743398309,
0.2625883222,
-0.3867567778,
0.7321720123,
-0.9666833282,
-0.4314583838,
0.1551469266,
-0.0076398891,
-0.1091696993,
-0.0723181069,
0.1151721776,
0.8283821344,
-0.321629256,
0.6049645543,
-0.4203980565,
-0.5502502918,
-0.0384832136,
-0.483394891,
1.104978919,
-0.1163590029,
-0.4363276958,
0.3178984225,
-0.3840720952,
0.0920766369,
0.139065966,
-0.2632649541,
-0.3623806834,
-0.3710237145,
0.166397199,
0.5200334191,
0.1276712716,
-0.6753744483,
0.3604947925,
-0.3431152701,
0.2863413692,
0.4639553428,
-0.1024890468,
-0.1447610706,
-0.4302225113,
0.4050098062,
0.1566151232,
0.3283738196,
-0.3929598331,
-0.6674726009,
-0.646685183,
-0.2313719094,
0.2517620027,
0.4821459353,
-0.6082092524,
0.4245434403,
-0.3504103422,
-0.9362658858,
-0.3518396318,
0.0497030504,
0.5328255892,
0.2426516414,
0.269212395,
-0.5034025311,
0.1653613001,
-0.819580853,
-0.4329344928,
-0.1195825487,
-0.1500978023,
0.1814283282,
0.9021512866,
-0.0717084482,
0.0898162425,
-0.4683510959,
-0.4219872653,
-0.3458759785,
0.4131019413,
0.1481346786,
0.451913923,
0.6897889376,
-0.5585488677,
-0.6658251286,
0.3476879597,
-0.6305572391,
0.3842692673,
-0.1846229881,
0.1150298342,
-0.0150130279,
-0.2650035322,
-0.6569609642,
0.444119215,
0.5230778456,
-0.4737969637,
1.0380728245,
-0.2522512078,
0.4784399867,
-0.8389953971,
0.3696632385,
0.1954032779,
0.0326232389,
-0.8717039227,
0.3870090544,
0.6167780757,
0.043276716,
-0.5492364168,
0.3874221146,
-0.5728931427,
0.0084848711,
-0.1976811141,
0.0736978278,
-0.0301139001,
0.5162859559,
0.0236830432,
0.7484680414,
0.6379799843,
-0.6435039639,
0.7667034864,
-0.2295790911,
-0.5496253371,
0.6634406447,
-0.7615433335,
0.0300097223,
0.1398347318,
0.2557882369,
-1.0457416773,
-0.5238143802,
-0.2225249708,
-0.479859978,
-0.0661801621,
0.1323268265,
-0.4559243321,
-0.4580443799,
-0.3615022302,
0.3839335144,
0.1246473864,
-0.1715741307,
0.5656846762,
0.2187300175,
-0.0693654045,
-0.9841418862,
-0.6945925951,
0.0105313826,
0.1250399053,
-0.7465411425,
0.1224709079,
-0.1986933798,
0.0905063599,
-0.2125752121,
0.0296539925,
-0.5046318173,
0.2228070349,
0.1150838062,
0.4132647216,
-0.5465788841,
-0.0224137064,
-0.2033169121,
0.1608914733,
0.1042160392,
-0.1296405643,
0.500434339,
0.0234557204,
-0.7792044878,
-0.5546042323,
0.0651147142,
0.9828162789,
-0.4824971259,
0.6557068825,
0.4573301375,
-0.5620895624,
-0.1146810502,
-0.4314479232,
-0.0261543579,
-0.3609974086,
0.7952009439,
-0.4520696998,
-0.606413722,
0.5948084593,
0.4091646075,
0.6534392238,
0.5570385456,
0.6939422488,
0.4097795188,
1.1403442621,
0.4963687062,
-0.0299210697,
0.0403812788,
-0.2399463356,
0.4160645604,
-0.6821402907,
0.0022514719,
-0.1933413893,
-0.1067386493,
-0.1600165963,
-0.3342608213,
0.41773054,
-0.2831651866,
-0.2227030396,
0.4247641861,
-0.2331336439,
0.4471584857,
0.5060908794,
0.0828303322,
0.3368816376,
-0.5022150874,
-0.0819958001,
0.0115143284,
-0.3744855523,
-0.1477379948,
1.1246203184,
0.3566685915,
0.3727082312,
0.1708730459,
0.0303549375,
-0.1873616874,
0.4164976776,
-1.1717120409,
0.1390904933,
-0.4986482263,
-1.0005013943,
-0.5972402096,
-0.2127664983,
-0.5805936456,
0.4557367861,
0.1121946871,
-0.4590390921,
-0.3426808417,
0.1613518298,
-1.0860528946,
0.4527725279,
-0.6801701784,
1.3698550463,
-0.3674533963,
-0.0646075457,
-0.1345126629,
-0.3324756026,
0.9793252349,
-0.4401247203,
0.0564490929,
-0.2848861217,
0.177555874,
0.7897915244,
0.1919756085,
0.690731883,
-0.1237169132,
-0.1242566258,
0.1758635342,
0.0787601918,
0.0331714638,
-0.2224605232,
-0.0180458445,
0.2156559229,
0.4330517352,
-0.620428741,
-0.6507643461,
0.4789327681,
-0.5471843481,
-0.5014611483,
-0.5239509344,
-0.8018391132,
-0.1801582426,
0.3477865458,
-0.0498886965,
0.4112461209,
-0.229298979,
0.1805955172,
0.2812494636,
-0.4263896644,
0.300538063,
0.9645202756,
-0.0975507125,
0.1541790813,
0.9593300223,
0.5461046696,
0.4839186072,
0.0221000239,
0.3666196465,
-0.3513695896,
-0.6382524371,
-0.7273109555,
0.2856150568,
-0.4892957509,
0.0740877166,
-0.6897143722,
-0.5204349756,
-0.9519013762,
0.1803045869,
-0.6535747051,
0.1849289238,
0.1329856515,
-0.0904380828,
-0.1439943016,
0.9252135158,
0.0499034151,
0.1883385777,
-0.9437853098,
0.1998319924,
0.170346275,
0.3289991021,
0.2942759395,
-0.8509738445,
-0.4078635573,
0.0635977909,
-0.4572460055,
-0.6274192929,
0.4149383008,
0.1112727001,
0.439855963,
0.7067924142,
-0.1212491691,
1.0974909067,
-0.4178988039,
1.3699514866,
0.2097243816,
-1.0842118263,
0.3198060989,
-0.5037582517,
0.4308102727,
0.324865371,
0.3332213163,
-1.0135422945,
-0.435867995,
-0.4460682273,
-0.4540019929,
0.7108374834,
-0.2546856105,
0.2198628783,
0.4170776606,
0.4303655922,
0.0642779768,
-0.179775849,
-0.7330877185,
-0.3033794463,
-0.0031177832,
-0.0399348028,
-0.3400714397,
-0.0264046472,
0.0745856836,
-0.4555312991,
0.593285501,
-0.2331318855,
-0.030208271,
0.0090426439,
0.2005456388,
0.0532563403,
0.265679419,
0.928144455,
1.2147245407,
-0.004538835,
0.170858413,
0.2516786456,
-0.8530943394,
0.1383269131,
-0.1997109056,
0.0280296803,
-0.0887236372,
0.7850099802,
0.4646286368,
-0.1042534187,
-0.7449418902,
0.9435648322,
-0.0263411067,
-0.321448952,
-0.3727199435,
0.1212200597,
0.2707155347,
-0.1706163138,
0.1251796484,
-0.1659211665,
0.1745876372,
-0.565191865,
0.3204779923,
0.3901379704,
-0.4234760404,
-0.4545293152,
0.534897089,
-0.0637435839,
0.1478267312,
0.6336599588,
-0.3221271038,
-0.4982888997,
0.930531919,
0.3096807301,
0.5437746644,
-0.5047490597,
0.2657707036,
0.7215070128,
0.6158340573,
-0.5448766947,
0.2819386125,
0.2858973145,
-0.8077957034,
-0.866309464,
-0.2824255824,
-0.5350248218,
0.6392834187,
-0.5685914755,
0.1700433195,
-0.3704593182,
-0.0301978346,
0.3990703225,
0.2317748666,
-0.4968740642,
0.4102235734,
-0.1484621316,
0.7342916727,
-0.9248020649,
1.1030282974,
0.6931089759,
-0.5979326367,
-1.148982048,
0.0065987245,
0.2789823711,
-0.9092543125,
0.7173955441,
0.4576081932,
0.1607191414,
-0.2226252407,
-0.3132281899,
-0.7009359598,
1.000918746,
0.3258733451,
-0.5425642729,
0.1011834964,
0.0904563963,
0.5974809527,
-0.0368124768,
0.6428618431,
0.74386096,
0.5104839802,
-0.1779136062,
-1.5796169043,
-0.0190169606,
-0.1290953457,
-0.3523434997,
0.0175639261,
-0.811897099,
1.3120090961,
-0.2606974244,
-0.2936781645,
-0.1335484236,
0.3670518696,
0.2865625918,
0.4634916484,
0.629783392,
0.3486478627,
0.5679808259,
-0.040654026,
0.9911822677,
-0.389937222,
0.5611966848,
0.8454654813,
-0.4199510813,
0.6631190777,
0.0702433586,
-0.1451423913,
-0.0749930814,
0.8331241012,
-0.0318008028,
0.0107058249,
0.2650101781,
-0.1868667603,
-0.3903137743,
-0.282448858,
-0.1812408119,
0.5705196857,
0.2878730297,
-0.1134277061,
-0.0858262032,
0.131440863,
0.127911225,
-0.3841333687,
-0.1870626211,
0.4244849682,
0.0074513415,
-0.9663290977,
0.6406795382,
0.1858519912,
0.7929027081,
-0.6070095301,
-0.1368038505,
-0.1765744388,
0.2042752355,
-0.0826498047,
-1.0429768562,
0.3175647259,
-0.0365551412,
0.1516725272,
0.118841514,
0.4879736006,
-0.4736525416,
-0.4307181835,
0.4765242934,
0.6205724478,
0.5174995661,
-0.5143042803,
-0.8601791263,
-0.2844673991,
-0.1214759797,
-0.1999004781,
0.2360758334,
0.3561092913,
0.1107638478,
0.4490133524,
0.5890731215,
0.3004377484,
0.1315572262,
0.1311371475,
0.3301921487,
-0.8594448566,
-0.3978370726,
-1.0859771967,
0.320179522,
-0.0286277868,
-0.7806600928,
0.8268824816,
0.4942265153,
0.9549762607,
-0.1017329246,
0.8743329048,
-0.0532787628,
0.3037325144,
-0.2749467194,
1.0003908873,
-0.849170804,
-0.326611191,
-0.1754152328,
-0.5620449185,
-0.5246524215,
0.5546238422,
-0.2411464602,
0.0494989045,
0.9561195374,
0.6719280481,
-0.1586794257,
0.003541389,
0.9721534848,
0.1349392831,
0.3997840881,
1.0188136101,
0.7817451358,
-0.3914495111,
0.143852666,
-0.6460672617,
-0.5459088683,
0.1095299497,
-0.5349324346,
-1.1293070316,
-0.4782575369,
-0.154692784,
-0.075083442,
-0.2270944864,
0.6444957256,
0.8257402778,
-0.9711509943,
-0.3693274856,
0.4720177948,
-0.2252708524,
-0.8913960457,
-0.2166484147,
0.6297928095,
-0.3017876148,
-0.7424978614,
0.3221211135,
0.31422773,
-0.202165857,
-0.5501506925,
0.2182245255,
-0.1470020264,
-0.1496587843,
0.7903016806,
-0.0359668061,
-0.9079723954,
-0.4640030265,
0.4046574831,
-0.3225915134,
-0.0965304077,
1.0269242525,
0.1272359937,
0.5182439089,
0.4260056317,
0.7134588957,
-0.0161317904,
-0.0114635648,
0.4037704468,
-0.3068043292,
-0.1471368819,
0.0571879558,
0.3887433708,
0.1658733934,
-0.4429766834,
0.4767905176,
0.3842408061,
-0.6100087762,
-0.6701393127,
-0.0875773504,
-0.9335327744,
-0.466635257,
0.9967009425,
-0.6412656307,
-0.1624796838,
-0.5475543737,
-0.0849802941,
0.3620381951,
-0.0626534075,
0.7366339564,
1.0481885672,
-0.3561395109,
-0.0169715509,
-1.2196147442,
0.2136846036,
0.6733461618,
-0.72755301,
0.4662925005,
0.2964149415,
0.5025826097,
0.3508337736,
0.8808206916,
-0.0067290622,
0.5114789009,
0.0522824153,
0.220601052,
0.0284653492,
-0.3377909362,
-0.2180345654,
0.1969428211,
0.026966041,
-0.190884158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12982v1 | Intent Induction from Conversations for Task-Oriented Dialogue Track at DSTC 11 | 2023-04-25T16:45:50 | 2023-04-25T16:45:50 | James Gung, Raphael Shu, Emily Moeng, Wesley Rose, Salvatore Romeo, Yassine Benajiba, Arshit Gupta, Saab Mansour, Yi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With increasing demand for and adoption of virtual assistants, recent work
has investigated ways to accelerate bot schema design through the automatic
induction of intents or the induction of slots and dialogue states. However, a
lack of dedicated benchmarks and standardized evaluation has made progress
difficult to track and comparisons between systems difficult to make. This
challenge track, held as part of the Eleventh Dialog Systems Technology
Challenge, introduces a benchmark that aims to evaluate methods for the
automatic induction of customer intents in a realistic setting of customer
service interactions between human agents and customers. We propose two
subtasks for progressively tackling the automatic induction of intents and
corresponding evaluation methodologies. We then present three datasets suitable
for evaluating the tasks and propose simple baselines. Finally, we summarize
the submissions and results of the challenge track, for which we received
submissions from 34 teams. | [
-0.2516695261,
-0.5781578422,
0.8026615977,
0.0377332121,
0.1056413874,
0.0129676592,
-0.0016345087,
-0.3479801714,
0.1429092735,
0.6204066277,
-0.992189765,
-0.4443983436,
-0.2246746421,
0.3315442801,
-0.3493820727,
0.8544396758,
-0.2352818549,
-0.0515462533,
-0.4879066944,
-0.0897298306,
-0.8435733318,
-0.346996516,
-0.6035978198,
-0.3058778346,
0.0659034476,
0.5089202523,
0.2126194388,
0.3515263498,
0.5898830891,
0.4503685534,
0.0578477755,
0.4883645177,
-0.2426396459,
0.5412604809,
-0.1497281939,
-0.2422877699,
-0.5195888877,
0.2417231053,
0.2600272894,
0.5894609094,
-0.3612589836,
0.3365299702,
-0.0514768399,
0.5013414025,
-0.5000383854,
0.5494065285,
-0.5706851482,
-0.0266925655,
0.174401328,
-0.1996581703,
-0.5537117124,
-0.2929182649,
0.5386054516,
-0.8280866146,
0.1595971733,
0.1281389743,
0.4253281057,
0.245646432,
-0.1146480739,
-0.8329834938,
-0.8200052977,
0.6523909569,
-0.285364747,
0.1128429398,
0.1160786673,
0.5289099216,
-0.1944024712,
-0.5564967394,
-0.5562556982,
-0.2866533399,
-0.1101367772,
0.1804793775,
-0.2369244993,
0.2614612281,
0.452144742,
0.2715948522,
-0.4475540817,
-0.1388114691,
-0.1497890204,
-0.07608594,
0.6705156565,
0.8205917478,
0.0113802208,
-0.0536324456,
-0.1858126521,
-0.0464031957,
-0.167051062,
0.0957830101,
0.2927112579,
0.2433712035,
0.0703930929,
0.702491045,
-0.7521315813,
0.4311056733,
0.3903703094,
-0.0475129969,
0.3170478642,
-0.6993234754,
-0.1342108995,
0.2701530755,
0.7243676186,
0.5057415366,
0.1768810004,
-0.1895981878,
-0.2637780905,
0.2235913128,
0.354167968,
-0.246229589,
0.1526058018,
0.3875040114,
-0.2247850895,
-0.2585534453,
-0.0986182094,
-0.2134111971,
-0.4559471607,
-0.621245563,
0.2528331578,
-0.1961544305,
-0.1223762333,
0.0404441804,
-0.3907391131,
0.419229418,
0.7750614882,
-0.7585594654,
0.7770310044,
0.930541575,
0.3507757783,
-0.3390078843,
-0.2099797875,
-0.4652089179,
0.0928766727,
-0.1527640522,
0.9528692961,
-0.6138397455,
-0.4568192363,
0.240263164,
0.1001251936,
-0.10859029,
-0.6982530951,
0.5856234431,
-0.1095945761,
0.4618170857,
-0.2342738062,
-0.4591818154,
0.1210343838,
0.3634029329,
-0.2030091584,
1.204105854,
0.4003293514,
-0.2256541848,
0.4014033973,
-1.1094597578,
-0.4319955409,
0.2810405195,
-0.2994738817,
-0.0704700202,
0.1183233187,
0.0222800989,
0.0402508751,
-0.4110832214,
0.1168292463,
0.0177256707,
-0.343077451,
0.2203724533,
-0.1035380289,
0.8433247805,
-0.0008944135,
-0.5494968891,
0.3276022375,
-0.4771657884,
0.0190135371,
0.1286207885,
0.1699675322,
0.0266394969,
-0.352327019,
-0.2970534563,
0.2631699741,
0.0805549845,
-0.5754575133,
0.4811625779,
-0.1812518239,
0.2698655427,
0.7499028444,
0.0514995568,
0.6080745459,
-0.18695952,
0.4803908169,
0.0493113101,
0.5672988296,
-0.259435147,
-0.7042839527,
-0.8214266896,
0.1697543263,
-0.0071625779,
0.5481669903,
-0.8684664965,
0.5540213585,
-0.4363279641,
-0.6094514728,
-0.5464362502,
0.0839351788,
0.6254815459,
0.4903806448,
0.0777774081,
-0.8322614431,
-0.3153763115,
-0.8669318557,
-0.0723716468,
-0.2232393324,
-0.0564207025,
0.8115212917,
0.1096927822,
-0.0627281591,
0.8809276223,
-0.4811311364,
-0.4558184147,
-0.4622521996,
0.4282583594,
0.0192773361,
0.4021959007,
0.4393390417,
-0.4683922529,
-0.8482330441,
-0.0499462113,
-0.8144612908,
-0.2643131912,
-0.0224128775,
-0.2153800577,
0.309969157,
0.3849312365,
-0.7439706922,
0.7942442298,
0.1448072642,
-0.1810500771,
0.6312764883,
0.1814725846,
0.4579712451,
-0.6603969336,
-0.2397063375,
0.055745136,
-0.2313211113,
-0.8658126593,
-0.7987149954,
-0.2402450591,
-0.3074195683,
-0.5187026858,
0.4802916944,
-0.3172172606,
-0.37999475,
-0.1903917044,
0.0941412896,
-0.0499232784,
0.7036640644,
0.1936726272,
0.8038948178,
0.358101964,
-0.6749418378,
0.5324009061,
0.7258742452,
-0.4223428071,
0.7559506893,
-0.542098105,
0.4340509474,
0.1182576865,
0.4836510122,
-1.041192174,
-0.1649590731,
0.575250864,
-0.4799654484,
-0.1108263806,
-0.0365651697,
-0.5111685395,
-0.3489711583,
0.0142673971,
0.3124561012,
0.4894165397,
-0.1553744525,
0.6152175665,
0.370926857,
-0.2501452863,
-0.2916028202,
-0.1776522547,
0.2256234884,
-0.0854766518,
-0.5742272735,
0.3035405278,
-0.0521679781,
-0.4533955157,
-0.1250463575,
-0.1163815781,
0.0607397221,
0.049994424,
0.4555798471,
-0.0050007752,
-0.0534247607,
-0.2900977433,
0.011654269,
-0.3794667423,
0.1571192145,
-0.3132265508,
0.6649085879,
-0.0193871912,
-0.6009304523,
-1.4114868641,
0.5119813085,
0.6253628731,
0.1156720594,
0.3361145556,
0.1246506125,
-0.0336718597,
0.0419285148,
-0.7921729684,
-0.2653748691,
-0.532091558,
-0.0045739361,
-0.5201382041,
-0.3317701519,
0.443231523,
-0.3658636808,
0.2469412386,
0.2666504383,
0.6064997911,
-0.1736608744,
1.0923844576,
0.5886896849,
0.2741147578,
0.7314809561,
-0.1379951388,
0.260846585,
-0.738219142,
-0.3034436405,
-0.5750855803,
-0.1417067945,
-0.3926397562,
-0.2815311551,
0.4367707968,
-0.5771213174,
0.1672009826,
0.7910401821,
-0.4601517916,
0.1476333588,
0.6203771234,
0.1011367068,
0.256208241,
-0.1488879025,
0.1392866969,
0.1024293602,
-0.5160298944,
-0.4948406816,
1.0005016327,
0.104051128,
0.3832759559,
0.0172166526,
0.7565352321,
0.5352393389,
0.377466619,
-0.9055832028,
0.7301896214,
0.2509202957,
-0.6081341505,
-0.5243817568,
0.0143462857,
-0.8139744997,
-0.3603118062,
0.2030168623,
-0.9729472995,
0.2279326171,
0.1012896821,
-0.3520510197,
-0.5730461478,
-0.8822334409,
0.7583608627,
-0.0608282275,
-0.1688756198,
-0.1693469584,
-0.458222717,
0.1234302223,
0.4322732091,
-0.1725272089,
-0.2834224999,
0.2949080169,
0.6466073394,
-0.3005496264,
0.6532223225,
-0.4348176718,
-0.1715754867,
0.6628798246,
-0.1082689986,
0.8088008165,
-0.1289473474,
-0.1814296097,
-0.0622378998,
-0.291850239,
-0.3542070389,
-0.7795469761,
0.2870626152,
-0.3839965165,
-0.7725515366,
-0.1954805255,
-0.6685804725,
-0.5973845124,
0.2329319865,
-0.0536416471,
0.525899291,
-0.310351789,
0.0547568426,
0.5311875939,
0.0655695349,
0.2543602288,
0.3566322625,
0.0996207818,
-0.1050482467,
0.5693941712,
-0.2439586967,
0.5832943916,
0.0110084824,
-0.1319956332,
-0.4230262041,
-0.4190974534,
-0.5409837961,
-0.1324106902,
-0.7876239419,
-0.0194682144,
-0.7881652117,
-0.1363514513,
-0.9862573743,
-0.0847524032,
-0.50499928,
-0.4370546043,
0.1648508012,
0.2602726221,
-0.0705852434,
0.9082199931,
0.2783788443,
0.4880459011,
-0.5115039349,
0.2242055833,
0.2956714332,
0.2057572156,
-0.276029557,
-0.3321175277,
-0.1856548637,
-0.0375362001,
-0.4117601514,
-0.2629725635,
0.0321271047,
-0.1020225659,
1.00076437,
0.5391567945,
0.0726802275,
0.6257948875,
-0.4787703753,
0.8685179353,
0.2281124294,
-0.8342818618,
0.7574483156,
-0.438626498,
0.1848866642,
0.8910887241,
0.3658137321,
-0.6091564894,
-0.3076733053,
-0.7746292949,
-0.4926334918,
1.1153723001,
0.5313739777,
0.1168318093,
0.0801643059,
0.3427014053,
0.2883176804,
0.2560316324,
-0.1273840666,
-0.4140598774,
0.0288336948,
-0.2960858941,
0.1266738027,
-0.1531901509,
-0.2912271023,
-0.0651288256,
0.3325228989,
-0.212714389,
0.6563455462,
0.1680434197,
-0.2362596989,
0.0261893123,
0.056355726,
0.6494791508,
0.6982508898,
-0.0467423797,
-0.486612618,
0.1715385169,
-0.372019887,
0.0539234243,
-0.1964255124,
0.0440557078,
0.1222938374,
0.0574890152,
0.7082119584,
0.0469527505,
-0.5552068353,
0.5051625967,
-0.5429977179,
-0.416175127,
-0.3749856353,
0.4599303305,
-0.3809004128,
0.1885039061,
0.2141902298,
-0.3021725714,
0.3553079665,
-0.7291004658,
0.0348925404,
0.2826583683,
-0.7287713289,
-0.2435976863,
0.0961059406,
0.5724790692,
-0.8820562363,
0.6178882122,
-0.5555375218,
-0.5404566526,
0.4839870334,
0.2894586325,
1.2587357759,
-0.2068947107,
0.112045452,
0.1953380406,
0.1197334826,
0.2365683466,
0.3867699802,
-0.582044363,
-0.5220776796,
-0.1017778665,
-0.0813294053,
-0.8370879292,
0.0722875819,
-0.6441345811,
0.5961863995,
-0.1683004946,
-0.0018271747,
0.3837338984,
-0.0038885481,
-0.9172536731,
-0.0904186219,
0.1428694725,
0.7399157286,
-0.8212751746,
0.5758132935,
0.7182754278,
0.0075062239,
-0.3571014702,
0.0218865573,
0.3575077355,
-0.8329345584,
0.7301667929,
0.2064238936,
-0.1861506402,
-0.1395513266,
-0.3247435987,
-0.4839569032,
1.0043144226,
-0.3416597843,
-0.3482334018,
-0.0959959552,
0.6300151944,
0.3325440884,
-0.6548740864,
0.4379609823,
0.7222673297,
0.4133612514,
-0.0741136894,
-1.2910736799,
-0.0418356583,
-0.2958195806,
-0.2770079374,
-0.0370523296,
-0.5865994096,
0.3103981316,
0.2886022031,
-0.2491551489,
0.3922467828,
0.4508599937,
0.0538338944,
0.6007122397,
0.891967237,
0.4125305116,
0.3412226737,
-0.192592293,
0.8123455048,
-0.2217220068,
-0.0039457935,
1.1650230885,
-0.6112296581,
0.1435604692,
0.4874825776,
-0.3007195294,
0.4889055789,
0.4165691137,
0.2256846428,
0.5297890306,
0.1980774701,
-0.240132764,
-0.1522469521,
-0.7162992954,
-0.0702015683,
0.78717345,
0.760849297,
-0.0742489621,
-0.2416143715,
0.0257356409,
-0.481316179,
-0.1520608962,
-0.0863922909,
1.4584302902,
-0.2077234387,
-1.1313567162,
0.2109446079,
-0.4711567163,
0.1200992912,
-0.2826668024,
-0.1288817823,
-0.1988363713,
0.2059709281,
0.0079430668,
-0.6892165542,
0.0710784942,
0.1732513756,
-0.0807087719,
-0.5561377406,
0.5886600018,
0.0933942199,
-0.056209974,
-0.1087778881,
0.3561031222,
0.34404549,
-0.0621165745,
-0.8297722936,
0.0971653461,
-0.1495648474,
-0.2521623373,
0.1408537477,
0.684658885,
-0.2933761179,
0.5523662567,
0.4979804456,
-0.4266380966,
0.0033394981,
0.2408523113,
0.8756617308,
-0.6157826185,
-0.3748499751,
-0.2416970879,
0.5878981948,
-0.3700994849,
-0.5253977776,
0.7624611259,
0.6500015259,
0.8178517222,
0.0497442335,
0.9462654591,
-0.1200640127,
0.6297920346,
-0.1304156184,
0.0403966196,
-0.1504529715,
0.1263277829,
-0.4468431473,
-0.9005618691,
0.3162722886,
0.1604131609,
-0.5085862875,
-0.2558059692,
0.6994953156,
0.4771258831,
0.0706827343,
0.2425094843,
0.0475410558,
-0.2639276981,
0.564250052,
0.3359505236,
1.1611714363,
-0.4162715673,
0.5796195865,
-0.6492648721,
-0.3119563758,
-0.542576611,
-0.5289791822,
-0.8432573676,
-0.7063083053,
-0.408798933,
-0.3946871161,
0.0462005325,
0.879763782,
0.6422459483,
-0.9147720933,
-0.3239072263,
-0.3443743587,
-0.0629047006,
-0.3932376206,
-0.2365311682,
0.0120766386,
-0.7017654181,
-1.1954733133,
0.4033035636,
0.4909243882,
0.0432674475,
-0.2106205523,
0.0966032445,
-0.0208015479,
0.0059869993,
0.5994791985,
0.1251744479,
-0.7454873919,
-0.342969954,
0.316457212,
-0.2368088216,
0.1734290719,
1.0567151308,
-0.7321377993,
0.3357428014,
0.439186424,
0.6057049632,
0.4130026698,
0.1936757118,
0.7213744521,
-0.4688155651,
0.2330650538,
0.4329416454,
-0.0179372001,
-0.0458263196,
-0.4542799294,
0.655837357,
0.0968053117,
-0.4754703045,
-1.1351664066,
0.2556551099,
-1.1757001877,
0.1042545289,
1.0344887972,
-0.2155711502,
-0.2732375562,
-0.6406649351,
-0.3836166263,
0.1965389401,
-0.5072239637,
0.726424098,
0.6285458207,
-0.7101737857,
0.1673195213,
-0.5199947953,
0.7382470369,
0.53145504,
-1.0219731331,
0.3647851944,
0.3205422759,
-0.2268420309,
0.387827754,
0.7474283576,
0.0018854104,
0.5658132434,
0.2111725062,
-0.055655621,
0.117846258,
-0.5422247052,
0.1012942865,
-0.1915268004,
-0.1060633734,
-0.3535538018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12979v1 | GMNLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Sentiment Analysis with Phylogeny-Based Adapters | 2023-04-25T16:39:51 | 2023-04-25T16:39:51 | Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Ruoyu Xie, Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This report describes GMU's sentiment analysis system for the SemEval-2023
shared task AfriSenti-SemEval. We participated in all three sub-tasks:
Monolingual, Multilingual, and Zero-Shot. Our approach uses models initialized
with AfroXLMR-large, a pre-trained multilingual language model trained on
African languages and fine-tuned correspondingly. We also introduce augmented
training data along with original training data. Alongside finetuning, we
perform phylogeny-based adapter tuning to create several models and ensemble
the best models for the final submission. Our system achieves the best F1-score
on track 5: Amharic, with 6.2 points higher F1-score than the second-best
performing system on this track. Overall, our system ranks 5th among the 10
systems participating in all 15 tracks. | [
-0.7501275539,
-0.2307669371,
0.3060043752,
0.4005596638,
-0.5057691336,
0.011341759,
-0.1047196463,
-0.7258952856,
0.6330692172,
0.2745503485,
-0.6363568306,
-0.4974869192,
-0.5876345038,
0.3646880984,
0.1512935013,
1.2195284367,
0.2650850117,
0.0904891193,
0.0976786017,
-0.5395933986,
-0.2389928997,
-0.7579510212,
-0.6896252632,
-0.2846658528,
0.7781493664,
0.4501351714,
0.6212202907,
-0.0143219,
0.4113007188,
0.2326634973,
-0.2594953477,
-0.0289436877,
-0.3155835569,
0.0970399082,
-0.3250827491,
-0.1235755458,
-0.8947079778,
0.0429876894,
0.1056270748,
0.6594789624,
-0.1046449244,
0.2607633173,
0.3651599288,
0.4132484794,
-0.5557979345,
0.1256823838,
-0.5561582446,
0.2760037482,
-0.0153345475,
-0.1316217631,
-0.1929851323,
-0.2606078684,
0.2367410362,
-0.4066529274,
0.0006582882,
-0.1043558866,
0.6587176323,
0.0348693542,
-0.3323846459,
-0.1796657294,
-0.1413030773,
0.8426445723,
-0.9770221114,
-0.0425945297,
-0.0177747626,
0.1271905303,
0.1214935556,
-0.3259309828,
-0.3371847868,
0.2346146554,
0.0451572984,
0.5321409106,
0.0697049648,
0.2400497943,
-0.0080799013,
0.5916652083,
-0.4827575684,
-0.140667066,
-0.2565842271,
-0.2728719115,
0.9005869031,
-0.0948281884,
0.1363838017,
-0.3706265688,
-0.207920745,
0.0242127329,
-0.3709895313,
-0.0415410995,
0.4854870737,
0.4737840593,
-0.0287182797,
0.6575631499,
-0.2610227168,
0.697586,
-0.1712964773,
0.2509184778,
0.5386298299,
-0.2240973115,
-0.4593670368,
0.0338955484,
0.8676732779,
0.5527828336,
0.2834513187,
0.1907367557,
-0.5017094612,
0.0703940839,
0.1598730236,
-0.6216765642,
-0.3387910128,
-0.01888128,
-0.6331838965,
-0.67055583,
-0.0990338176,
-1.2435606718,
-0.5815819502,
-0.1957910061,
0.8900021315,
-0.3245981932,
-0.2982387543,
-0.1775173098,
-0.0726525933,
0.2807202041,
0.4954031706,
-1.0293836594,
0.1718754321,
0.5709283352,
1.0156584978,
-0.2755364478,
-0.3524821103,
-0.3327160478,
-0.2641251981,
0.0773840472,
0.6532387137,
-0.6170026064,
-0.734431982,
-0.1157543808,
0.4363688231,
-0.2843142152,
-0.5510260463,
0.7972759008,
-0.1351315379,
0.1967632473,
-0.4637457728,
-0.4642514586,
-0.5245937705,
0.4841746092,
-0.3396940529,
0.8129192591,
0.187907666,
-0.6348177791,
0.2088045329,
-0.9066352248,
-0.4485061169,
-0.0233333278,
0.1083871052,
-0.2364554703,
0.2546769679,
0.2797846794,
0.5675099492,
-0.0150215467,
0.0828093737,
-0.5461834073,
-0.1036988571,
-0.1774774045,
-0.2422124296,
0.7218783498,
0.3179694712,
-0.4408723414,
0.2253284603,
-0.8748313189,
-0.0529584624,
0.052720014,
-0.3647784293,
-0.2432568371,
-0.1533581465,
0.1578276902,
0.349730283,
0.2752558589,
-0.8133199811,
0.4144725204,
-0.5368412733,
0.3506019115,
0.7841632366,
0.2630186379,
0.4057783186,
0.0146195078,
0.7635605931,
-0.0444973633,
0.1999624819,
-0.1649251431,
-0.6496322155,
-0.8342779875,
0.1695326269,
0.2882057428,
0.6381314993,
-0.4842215478,
0.1438012421,
0.1399086565,
-0.4789921045,
-0.2909531593,
-0.2138583362,
-0.0561361164,
0.3624344468,
0.3970286548,
-0.5893936157,
-0.6661722064,
-0.8844542503,
-0.119808197,
-0.1298025548,
0.1712545604,
0.3443150222,
0.6767804623,
-0.2742440701,
0.2471701652,
-0.3842181861,
-0.2503437698,
-0.2104098797,
0.4259761572,
0.4235772192,
0.5577620268,
0.7949926257,
-0.3984771669,
-0.2521883845,
0.2154658586,
-0.7992756963,
-0.3827927113,
0.2958242595,
-0.0788528323,
0.2933080494,
0.4067820609,
-0.1543596536,
0.2438397706,
0.9617302418,
-0.436635226,
0.3979498148,
0.1275575608,
0.2929603159,
-1.2245173454,
0.1296848208,
-0.0052999407,
-0.2423142791,
-0.5644873381,
-0.0622162186,
-0.4635916054,
-0.4652143717,
-0.1853478849,
0.4476375282,
-0.2255830467,
-0.1799684167,
-0.4697312713,
-0.2117648423,
-0.1528011113,
0.5170199275,
0.1865759492,
0.6483760476,
0.4187462032,
-0.3463603258,
0.3164260983,
0.1232744604,
-0.0370421447,
0.5972160697,
-0.711415112,
0.1108134761,
0.0511329249,
-0.0907002762,
-0.9000884295,
-0.2321354896,
0.3340453506,
-0.6249126792,
0.1158369109,
-0.142738089,
0.1220695004,
-0.3353767693,
-0.308054179,
0.2620513737,
0.177763626,
-0.4189476073,
0.8525961041,
0.6401464939,
-0.5534385443,
-0.6246477962,
-0.5526153445,
0.072071068,
-0.2700344324,
-0.4941813648,
0.014372915,
0.0707852989,
-0.0396892577,
-0.0654490516,
-0.1061529666,
0.1382004619,
0.232521981,
0.4169606566,
0.2534384727,
-0.3249935508,
-0.2579628527,
-0.111529246,
0.0053301831,
0.2002260387,
-0.4130273163,
0.6574082375,
-0.2850198448,
-0.0168492738,
0.0783411115,
0.2439077497,
0.6809483767,
-0.1628002375,
0.7451927662,
0.6116707921,
-0.1833340526,
-0.0276657809,
-0.215909645,
0.0641190037,
-0.4155990481,
0.2620085478,
-0.4053898454,
-1.0096698999,
0.5454181433,
-0.0832905322,
0.201020062,
0.6756604314,
0.4978635907,
-0.1414238214,
1.2353944778,
0.753246963,
-0.4327879846,
0.257925421,
-0.1841664016,
-0.0155278435,
-0.8577497005,
-0.2760434449,
-0.471347183,
-0.5128961802,
-0.7427607179,
-0.2615460157,
0.3418204188,
-0.0270314496,
-0.1632936001,
0.2031550854,
-0.384228915,
0.1541097164,
0.5779747367,
-0.2545114458,
-0.1019149125,
-0.1242807657,
-0.4116772413,
0.054794997,
-0.5230309367,
-0.3757397234,
0.9850353003,
0.1786276251,
0.5724188089,
0.1132701039,
0.7626351714,
0.2959852815,
0.3675994277,
-1.0275530815,
0.7394808531,
-0.355705142,
-0.3283640444,
-0.2057155073,
-0.1845413446,
-0.6240039468,
0.4399341941,
-0.1535177529,
-0.6130402088,
0.5674479604,
0.120647572,
-0.2563304305,
0.0911036059,
-0.3272872567,
1.0736943483,
-0.1059575677,
-0.1364843994,
-0.0646161586,
-0.7437019944,
0.3805773556,
-0.0254496355,
0.2997541428,
-0.4385168552,
0.1053997725,
0.7135796547,
-0.5767578483,
0.6369236112,
-0.7320094705,
-0.0896584764,
0.1123165861,
-0.039973665,
0.3308035731,
0.1383189559,
-0.5089034438,
-0.0196757298,
-0.0233007651,
-0.211210236,
-0.1882328093,
0.7695202231,
-0.9591748714,
-0.3675377369,
-0.9012964964,
-0.3528329134,
-0.524574995,
-0.0078566568,
0.2997532487,
0.3043430746,
-0.4336039126,
0.2238295078,
0.2039758265,
-0.3481718302,
0.6113313437,
0.3055381179,
-0.5244247913,
-0.7578982115,
0.9691284895,
0.0051334924,
0.1514829099,
0.1776450127,
0.1693430394,
-0.2415081114,
-0.5140548944,
-0.5030809641,
0.0857337266,
-0.6661031842,
-0.3255540431,
-0.6563137174,
-0.3787112534,
-0.4627543688,
-0.0971428156,
-0.0403756015,
-0.6679665446,
-0.3044832647,
-0.0756883472,
0.0996271372,
0.6414168477,
-0.4004432261,
0.4329020083,
-0.864577949,
0.0448802002,
0.4267371595,
-0.0378940441,
-0.3073672652,
-0.7654851675,
-0.1363665313,
-0.1461996287,
-0.262794286,
-0.8705250025,
0.7148040533,
0.6429706216,
0.4821747839,
0.2722709775,
-0.3467405736,
0.7092968225,
-0.3801021874,
0.9836968184,
0.0548465699,
-1.0653722286,
0.9292433858,
-0.5205913782,
0.5592030287,
0.8848898411,
0.4355584979,
-0.6253072023,
-0.3829210103,
-0.4281895757,
-0.8285349011,
0.7754899263,
-0.0890694559,
0.0680745542,
-0.0243471526,
0.376288712,
0.1024695188,
0.3329336047,
-0.8521495461,
-0.1619337499,
-0.6206612587,
-0.365080744,
-0.3444800973,
-0.3663061857,
0.1584542692,
-0.3153770864,
1.0920643806,
-0.4396811128,
0.1490724087,
0.1821038574,
-0.1000007913,
-0.1126171574,
0.4225396216,
0.5827642679,
0.4713308811,
-0.3714154363,
0.0775702,
0.3501291275,
-0.6038244367,
0.1836308837,
0.2749547064,
-0.3134538829,
0.0342605151,
0.2132674903,
0.9067414403,
0.014643183,
-0.2596240938,
0.4202425182,
0.0290471707,
-0.2972163856,
-0.0661717355,
-0.0470847115,
-0.076122269,
0.1966475397,
0.2710023522,
0.5588839054,
0.4797757268,
-0.6828399897,
0.0977517813,
0.4135224521,
-0.8067139387,
-0.8205593228,
0.61572963,
0.5926708579,
0.2741068006,
0.1259916425,
-0.3399839699,
-0.7048227787,
0.514343679,
0.5123031139,
0.8236712217,
-0.8634471893,
0.4322645366,
0.6329190135,
0.3896124661,
0.046558477,
0.8069102168,
0.3117405176,
-0.850278914,
-0.532597959,
-1.1306881905,
-0.4497607052,
0.3139739633,
-0.7671999335,
0.386300981,
-0.4552800059,
-0.1583887786,
0.1400743723,
-0.0167467166,
-0.2929266095,
0.6762212515,
0.407785356,
0.9583620429,
-1.0551273823,
0.7424808145,
1.2040989399,
-0.0847693309,
-0.8429599404,
-0.1756992042,
0.4032447934,
-0.8710852265,
0.394782722,
0.2847581208,
-0.1531099081,
0.125986129,
-0.3782477975,
-0.6545404196,
1.0744239092,
0.0943848863,
-0.6422124505,
0.2603169084,
0.0279023871,
0.4243812561,
-0.3954167366,
0.0840856656,
0.5569898486,
0.4663048387,
0.287034899,
-0.8364243507,
-0.287119478,
-0.4429702461,
-0.2680076957,
0.3630758822,
-0.5953902602,
0.8267403841,
0.1391717941,
0.0507355109,
0.1838337481,
0.8520517945,
0.0790503249,
0.2517124712,
0.6819078922,
0.7533588409,
0.6965918541,
-0.2627196312,
0.8216592669,
-0.3020431101,
0.4981986582,
1.0893200636,
-0.4449292421,
0.8462569118,
0.4212771058,
-0.2308620661,
0.3041855991,
0.7246506214,
0.0117238034,
0.545832634,
0.1439693272,
-0.5658527613,
-0.1738941669,
-0.4431523383,
-0.4221913517,
0.6511178613,
0.4130711257,
-0.3662042022,
-0.0819834173,
0.2976106703,
-0.0367895663,
-0.2970230579,
-0.7576062083,
0.9019275904,
0.2445866466,
-0.7368254662,
0.0915574282,
-0.058337111,
0.9004380107,
-0.4861858785,
0.205159381,
-0.3087459803,
0.189748913,
-0.2937710285,
-0.9724322557,
0.4831201136,
-0.1096224934,
-0.0508240461,
0.0168061722,
0.9527118206,
-0.4014029503,
-0.7152133584,
0.3919363022,
0.5365065932,
0.0375082009,
-0.1233666167,
-0.7949776053,
0.0716858581,
0.1950561404,
-0.3019338548,
0.2034872472,
0.5697968602,
0.1191420332,
0.159092322,
0.3074360192,
0.3119566441,
-0.1288585514,
0.5165586472,
0.6931067109,
-0.7639766335,
-0.2873452306,
-0.9377926588,
0.2632125616,
-0.1154939756,
-0.3638834655,
0.8945142031,
0.6412709355,
0.6024314165,
-0.2056634277,
0.9765021801,
-0.236794427,
0.5132148266,
-0.3322315812,
0.4828502238,
-0.7172079086,
-0.0175693147,
-0.4587067664,
-1.2968181372,
-0.3745742738,
0.6942328215,
-0.3009451628,
-0.1840455532,
0.5728724003,
0.5872333646,
-0.1070254073,
0.4548499584,
0.3648476601,
0.1717344373,
0.105752863,
0.4320023954,
1.0918658972,
-0.286544174,
0.2926155031,
-0.2681376636,
-0.0663586855,
-0.2874011099,
-0.9010379314,
-0.628031671,
-0.2993611693,
-0.2494312823,
-0.2531171143,
0.029642975,
0.9899846315,
0.4327965379,
-1.2901306152,
-0.3431159556,
-0.048646722,
-0.3471668959,
0.0700823069,
-0.3036601841,
-0.015106665,
-0.3696385324,
-0.6506934762,
0.4656790197,
0.7649582028,
0.1665943116,
0.0199569594,
0.0345174745,
-0.3547720909,
0.0452090614,
0.8835309148,
0.2333472669,
-0.5251297355,
-0.6749277711,
0.0590468757,
0.2062138617,
0.0885295868,
0.7267618179,
-0.6164426804,
0.3285786808,
0.5327330828,
0.4598291218,
0.2536608577,
0.1640702337,
0.8746321797,
-0.654902339,
0.1678109169,
0.3987972438,
0.6839798093,
0.3800073266,
-0.0279229823,
0.8681519032,
0.3518268764,
-0.9773360491,
-0.576892972,
-0.074587442,
-1.1303284168,
-0.0588090904,
1.0002598763,
-0.2350178659,
-0.2067608088,
-0.0525318533,
-0.3855312169,
0.0201985724,
-0.3057396114,
0.4327041209,
0.8888781071,
-0.1470032036,
-0.3172091246,
-0.5937812328,
0.5421116948,
0.5762120485,
-1.0846540928,
-0.4402351677,
0.5631406307,
0.10638313,
0.2686065733,
0.6372904181,
-0.0849026889,
0.1923272759,
-0.3689707816,
0.1208617538,
0.4071487188,
-0.267788887,
-0.6794006824,
0.3103608489,
0.1497228444,
-0.1626898348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12959v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12959v2 | Escaping the sentence-level paradigm in machine translation | 2023-04-25T16:09:02 | 2024-05-16T13:32:14 | Matt Post, Marcin Junczys-Dowmunt | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is well-known that document context is vital for resolving a range of
translation ambiguities, and in fact the document setting is the most natural
setting for nearly all translation. It is therefore unfortunate that machine
translation -- both research and production -- largely remains stuck in a
decades-old sentence-level translation paradigm. It is also an increasingly
glaring problem in light of competitive pressure from large language models,
which are natively document-based. Much work in document-context machine
translation exists, but for various reasons has been unable to catch hold. This
paper suggests a path out of this rut by addressing three impediments at once:
what architectures should we use? where do we get document-level information
for training them? and how do we know whether they are any good? In contrast to
work on specialized architectures, we show that the standard Transformer
architecture is sufficient, provided it has enough capacity. Next, we address
the training data issue by taking document samples from back-translated data
only, where the data is not only more readily available, but is also of higher
quality compared to parallel document data, which may contain machine
translation output. Finally, we propose generative variants of existing
contrastive metrics that are better able to discriminate among document
systems. Results in four large-data language pairs (DE$\rightarrow$EN,
EN$\rightarrow$DE, EN$\rightarrow$FR, and EN$\rightarrow$RU) establish the
success of these three pieces together in improving document-level performance. | [
-0.4210639596,
-0.7142800093,
0.6291304231,
0.2772112489,
-0.184030652,
0.0200354308,
-0.2121526301,
-0.287238121,
-0.2454937398,
0.4404368699,
-0.2970075011,
-0.4848254621,
-0.8519309759,
0.2327786237,
-0.7800841331,
0.9725853205,
-0.3633186817,
-0.0616653226,
-0.3894082308,
-0.2503214478,
-0.4964106977,
-0.4936260283,
-0.4545786977,
-0.3723965287,
0.4211495221,
0.2876993418,
0.6313335896,
0.890601337,
0.6168658137,
0.2634397447,
0.0245022308,
0.0713007376,
-0.2714067698,
0.397790134,
-0.0172836576,
-0.6144338846,
-0.2353139669,
-0.0109637678,
0.7169091702,
0.8354708552,
0.1953458488,
-0.2338966727,
0.1397224516,
0.7379596233,
-0.5068553686,
0.2102926522,
-0.421038866,
0.3813033104,
-0.3102945387,
-0.2677662969,
-0.665995419,
-0.0005332508,
-0.1419246346,
-0.6239985824,
0.358461678,
0.136820063,
1.0109876394,
0.4299215972,
-0.5739445686,
-0.263101995,
-0.9864481688,
0.6484755278,
-0.5009718537,
0.4019149542,
0.2618931532,
0.1757739633,
-0.0496490262,
-0.6780765653,
-0.380133301,
-0.0034858603,
-0.2650694251,
0.3516415358,
-0.3359207213,
-0.2601224184,
0.3562352061,
0.5278406143,
-0.6103359461,
0.2297945023,
-0.3854863644,
0.1927457154,
0.2153009623,
0.0934832841,
0.2410154045,
-0.0574058145,
-0.4734273255,
-0.2804238796,
-0.6146618724,
-0.1268226206,
0.1954235584,
0.1644157022,
-0.0704443753,
0.3251355588,
-0.0922014713,
0.607090354,
0.1043592915,
0.2775141597,
0.4180966616,
-0.2120153755,
-0.1831031442,
-0.2426877469,
0.8053446412,
0.1916683465,
-0.1242576391,
-0.4755163193,
-0.5707809329,
0.057407923,
0.6757083535,
-0.7030549049,
0.0827064961,
0.2054924667,
-0.3755749166,
-0.1887349039,
0.0708302483,
-0.8130460978,
-0.2121879607,
-0.2070451379,
0.2446030974,
-0.6425625682,
0.0785414055,
-0.142603606,
-0.3058467805,
0.5250843167,
0.2604834139,
-1.0109460354,
0.4117832184,
0.7433142066,
0.9669284225,
-0.1851279885,
-0.2309527397,
-0.6219914556,
0.1456887871,
-0.7636886835,
0.6153911948,
-0.6190170646,
-0.5204251409,
0.2103261203,
-0.0406006798,
-0.2809014916,
-0.5786949992,
0.8051970005,
-0.4414046407,
0.6864255071,
-0.2016185075,
-0.5621846914,
0.1175315231,
0.2106948048,
-0.5825841427,
1.0423030853,
0.1970388889,
-0.6722027063,
0.3389776945,
-0.6681841016,
-0.7393099666,
0.0022946275,
-0.2446619421,
-0.1944441497,
0.3533476889,
0.340390265,
0.3716949224,
-0.3950870633,
0.0933422819,
-0.0066240286,
-0.5563035011,
0.0807352066,
-0.5213940144,
0.6006639004,
0.5533992052,
-0.3549022079,
-0.1668217927,
-0.6598631144,
-0.4182942212,
0.1929080784,
-0.5073185563,
-0.4321034253,
-0.1014372185,
0.0175320152,
0.3730476499,
0.3238573372,
-0.4737398922,
0.1081343889,
-0.4350661337,
0.6362413168,
0.5098489523,
-0.2512507141,
0.8698176742,
-0.2914199233,
0.6034480333,
0.132541731,
-0.0183976833,
-0.3178666532,
-0.2557502389,
-0.8832380772,
-0.0399732701,
0.1072610617,
0.6039250493,
-0.7331242561,
0.5472262502,
-0.4426300228,
-0.3865300119,
-0.7839924693,
-0.022431355,
0.407225877,
0.7589656115,
0.5723608732,
-0.1101706177,
-0.1881886274,
-0.9480159283,
-0.3185811639,
0.0996235386,
-0.220241338,
-0.0203400459,
0.5231000781,
-0.1013124213,
0.8135729432,
-0.4899839163,
-0.320659101,
-0.2604081035,
0.2011460662,
0.3093827665,
0.7163468599,
0.3049313128,
-1.1170756817,
-0.2627171874,
0.1461395174,
-0.9757786989,
-0.0613283701,
-0.2946491241,
0.0136661176,
0.3519258499,
0.7971218824,
-0.6950261593,
0.1999218911,
0.3797442019,
0.0322046801,
0.0126322918,
-0.5981666446,
0.0666609034,
-1.2124032974,
0.2597308159,
0.0875539258,
-0.0584590696,
-0.7578601837,
0.3738971651,
0.2923867106,
-0.3243174851,
-0.1411041915,
0.4767509103,
-0.3695648611,
-0.1680844873,
-0.1241600141,
0.4611794055,
0.4084052444,
0.383782655,
-0.1006090119,
0.6407085061,
0.312343061,
-0.2104440033,
0.1086082011,
0.5190557241,
-0.073403798,
0.8742612004,
-0.4965933561,
0.3250736594,
-0.3931856453,
0.6309970021,
-0.7104115486,
-0.2168519199,
0.4357359707,
-0.3977756202,
0.5741832256,
0.0076451264,
-0.4893136322,
-0.4435670674,
-0.1289595366,
0.1715379506,
0.5670729876,
-0.3750349581,
0.4937429428,
0.0686355829,
0.0287135281,
-0.613017261,
-0.9451231956,
0.4928665161,
-0.3744519651,
-0.6656216979,
0.5229028463,
0.0866978243,
-0.0595343597,
-0.0535771735,
-0.2894900143,
-0.1722391248,
0.1039161906,
0.0904496908,
0.1668234915,
-0.2909824252,
0.1610481739,
0.0765850842,
-0.3447836041,
-0.059233956,
-0.5376486778,
0.5114201903,
-0.2694536746,
-0.1083921194,
-0.2425582409,
0.6136840582,
0.7057872415,
-0.4857043326,
0.7240763307,
0.7500529885,
-0.3827157319,
-0.2302380651,
-0.3206132948,
0.2126954794,
-0.4165734351,
0.3916867971,
-0.6889015436,
-0.5429557562,
0.3246450722,
0.0203187764,
0.1437014937,
0.4289347827,
0.3174633086,
-0.295889765,
0.8334951997,
0.625837326,
-0.0145695983,
0.4581472576,
-0.1686631143,
0.4067926407,
-0.8658896089,
-0.1601558328,
-0.8179265261,
-0.2665886879,
-0.596752882,
-0.2493882775,
0.4881291986,
0.1325329989,
-0.0107064322,
0.6784679294,
-0.3366974592,
0.1381440461,
0.5873066187,
-0.1361602992,
0.237341091,
-0.3338387609,
0.1033645347,
0.0949358642,
-0.8225522637,
-0.5765138268,
0.7995797396,
0.3454810977,
0.4444439411,
-0.1079885662,
0.9605932236,
0.195794642,
0.0808868408,
-0.6120852232,
0.3753512502,
-0.5810323954,
-0.342662245,
-0.2123570442,
-0.4856465161,
-1.0978910923,
0.5537115932,
0.021510249,
-0.3773542643,
0.2575730979,
-0.0031704789,
0.150494501,
0.0112394448,
-0.6411417723,
1.2903338671,
0.0464626513,
-0.1441509724,
-0.0324437208,
-0.9219930768,
-0.0134759778,
-0.2391029894,
0.4731137455,
0.2078012973,
-0.1743036807,
0.3745923936,
-0.3908134103,
0.5668682456,
-0.0135453036,
-0.3001357019,
-0.2267447114,
0.1299169809,
0.6159208417,
-0.4514520466,
-0.0457404591,
0.0696818307,
-0.089097552,
-0.5504382849,
-0.6669485569,
0.5701273084,
-0.6960939765,
-0.6489880681,
-0.0383906141,
-0.7387038469,
-0.2927312255,
0.3319970071,
0.6552941799,
0.5761494637,
-0.2961753905,
0.5599212646,
0.7217934728,
-0.1904637069,
0.4145174325,
0.2211514711,
0.2149680406,
-0.124856934,
0.9602326751,
0.0110605462,
0.3012234867,
0.8127664328,
0.2257799655,
-0.2098776698,
-0.5914157033,
-0.6402558684,
-0.186284408,
-0.8386221528,
0.0186462067,
-0.8420411944,
-0.2275548428,
-0.4025447071,
-0.4583581388,
-0.2758108377,
-0.3115503788,
-0.3267423511,
-0.0308913495,
-0.3506516814,
0.555100143,
0.2460586578,
0.2025582343,
-0.8802495599,
0.2193231881,
-0.2120249122,
-0.1370048076,
-0.3242361248,
-0.6428500414,
-0.2975080609,
-0.2598077357,
-0.1933813542,
-0.7717134356,
0.280882597,
0.0625801682,
0.4291626215,
0.2453363389,
0.1913911253,
0.3071241081,
-0.5946860909,
0.644421041,
0.0494504161,
-0.8930091858,
0.5239608884,
-0.5559099317,
0.3901518881,
0.4503843188,
0.3333298862,
-0.9418731332,
-0.9373449683,
-0.5315275192,
-1.0554301739,
0.6185290217,
0.2850755155,
0.302891165,
-0.0995208621,
0.1503659487,
0.2134624571,
0.2647995651,
-0.7340687513,
0.0661616772,
-0.3769875169,
-0.400377661,
-0.1687006801,
0.3589028418,
-0.2692398727,
0.0946303606,
0.2395680547,
-0.1096263453,
0.0728873909,
0.104305014,
-0.3110278547,
-0.014599449,
0.4586442411,
0.3829136491,
0.5373232961,
-0.0050296225,
0.2709922194,
-0.0565681793,
-0.1031188965,
0.0664568767,
0.1870038956,
-0.4971922934,
0.0186700206,
0.5920357108,
0.7818599939,
0.2206053585,
-0.246849224,
0.6726328135,
0.3588869274,
-0.1666597128,
-0.1444229335,
0.0106446398,
-0.0206604823,
0.1296101362,
0.2461574823,
0.2357444018,
-0.0278749,
-0.5752372742,
0.1267691851,
0.3013542891,
-0.4737704694,
-0.09897165,
0.7845005989,
0.4069829583,
-0.3675501645,
0.5202527046,
0.0324585922,
-0.3478782475,
0.5633898973,
0.6828536987,
0.9539749026,
0.0560263544,
0.2189579606,
0.0830691084,
0.4889731407,
-0.2528459728,
-0.3824179769,
-0.1514088064,
-0.6044778824,
-0.0172848739,
-0.5914732218,
-0.1497557312,
-0.0143409651,
-0.7934892178,
0.0265869778,
-0.2798767388,
0.2264580131,
-0.0411082059,
-0.161628589,
-0.5919014812,
0.1326782256,
0.2017736882,
1.1436146498,
-0.7407591939,
0.9304563999,
0.4169162214,
-0.7284289598,
-0.1521119177,
0.2429704666,
-0.1236234307,
-0.7149390578,
0.5065820813,
0.2168891579,
-0.2074151337,
0.0417614765,
-0.3365332782,
-0.5425004959,
1.1085919142,
0.1883631945,
-0.502671361,
-0.3756552637,
0.1369553804,
0.7021611333,
-0.5181952119,
-0.2570663393,
0.6646715999,
0.6405771971,
-0.0520975851,
-0.4016079903,
0.1430664957,
-0.2639636099,
0.2996625602,
0.323165834,
-0.570315361,
0.7326535583,
0.2264271379,
-0.362030983,
0.1732261181,
0.4502588212,
-0.4212059975,
0.2297362834,
0.4516327977,
0.5926582217,
0.6421139836,
-0.1390018761,
1.1594130993,
-0.2618359923,
0.1280593425,
1.0372897387,
-0.2842384577,
0.8960235119,
0.5375167727,
0.0352976061,
0.4564655721,
0.5368596315,
-0.2784945965,
0.4177050591,
-0.0316817686,
-0.1259059012,
-0.1288443953,
0.169357717,
-0.3341967762,
0.4505064189,
0.3293660879,
-0.4672758281,
-0.3320464492,
0.0104621965,
0.2542572021,
0.3211495876,
0.2431192696,
0.6798375845,
0.1794669032,
-0.8699533343,
0.5861480832,
0.2009661496,
0.3340709507,
-0.5127734542,
0.1978470981,
-0.678976655,
0.0933717415,
-0.0578676499,
-0.6140221953,
0.3690777421,
0.0003883892,
-0.2769488394,
-0.7812234759,
0.5590276718,
-0.3389041126,
-0.2620505989,
0.3109973371,
0.743283391,
0.1619224995,
0.0719786286,
-0.4594894648,
0.0408342332,
-0.3708147407,
-0.1499697566,
0.404622823,
0.7484178543,
0.1192610934,
0.3838581741,
0.4404126108,
-0.0722282082,
-0.1997769773,
-0.0850089863,
0.7836325765,
-0.6676366925,
-0.529458344,
-0.6828787923,
0.2835125923,
-0.1773884296,
-0.523901999,
0.5702134371,
0.5780916214,
0.9443883896,
0.0925062522,
0.7741876245,
-0.1428628564,
-0.0054146615,
-0.4913868308,
0.5149437189,
-0.618471384,
0.2275490612,
-0.1829773039,
-1.0434494019,
-0.3682591021,
0.3232191503,
-0.2563758492,
-0.1456225663,
0.9852578044,
0.6166484952,
-0.1273406893,
-0.032264702,
0.3996424377,
0.2555237412,
0.4383726418,
0.7138314247,
0.8400955796,
-0.5087436438,
0.9265716672,
0.0568905547,
-0.4313599765,
-0.2096519172,
-0.6332542896,
-0.468182236,
-0.6846684217,
-0.1015850902,
-0.3193282485,
0.0532051362,
0.5457609892,
0.5412535071,
-0.4090460539,
-0.1485358775,
-0.2718619704,
-0.0185289383,
-0.2708182335,
-0.1645958722,
0.2368598133,
-0.8736894131,
-0.9575471282,
0.6992864609,
0.4258600473,
-0.1234607846,
-0.1512836665,
-0.0540040396,
0.0557488129,
0.03313547,
0.3898193836,
0.3036955893,
-0.6284143329,
-0.3802865744,
-0.0528289936,
-0.5719462633,
0.3679094613,
0.9580591917,
-0.5309904218,
0.439992398,
0.3665331006,
0.9102381468,
0.5688906312,
-0.1773575693,
0.9445647001,
-0.7803828716,
0.1083141938,
0.2064680457,
0.4063128233,
0.3372389376,
-0.1846191734,
0.7033367753,
0.3247764409,
-0.3062001169,
-0.6787611842,
0.3331210613,
-0.6817860603,
-0.5659398437,
0.93772012,
-0.3749050796,
-0.2685929835,
-0.071994029,
0.0754028335,
0.281537503,
-0.1673785299,
0.7129181027,
0.8842053413,
0.0551354289,
0.075149551,
-0.7484911084,
0.2725245655,
0.4856341779,
-0.9101374149,
0.129622817,
0.5732387304,
-0.065585658,
0.3094981313,
0.5611736774,
-0.3252644241,
0.0370716341,
0.3000455797,
-0.2636536658,
0.0562212653,
-0.4995521009,
-0.5451136827,
0.3141266704,
-0.2137153298,
-0.4792695045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12955v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12955v2 | Nondeterministic Stacks in Neural Networks | 2023-04-25T16:00:40 | 2023-05-18T01:56:21 | Brian DuSell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human language is full of compositional syntactic structures, and although
neural networks have contributed to groundbreaking improvements in computer
systems that process language, widely-used neural network architectures still
exhibit limitations in their ability to process syntax. To address this issue,
prior work has proposed adding stack data structures to neural networks,
drawing inspiration from theoretical connections between syntax and stacks.
However, these methods employ deterministic stacks that are designed to track
one parse at a time, whereas syntactic ambiguity, which requires a
nondeterministic stack to parse, is extremely common in language. In this
dissertation, we remedy this discrepancy by proposing a method of incorporating
nondeterministic stacks into neural networks. We develop a differentiable data
structure that efficiently simulates a nondeterministic pushdown automaton,
representing an exponential number of computations with a dynamic programming
algorithm. We incorporate this module into two predominant architectures:
recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and transformers. We show that this raises
their formal recognition power to arbitrary context-free languages, and also
aids training, even on deterministic context-free languages. Empirically,
neural networks with nondeterministic stacks learn context-free languages much
more effectively than prior stack-augmented models, including a language with
theoretically maximal parsing difficulty. We also show that an RNN augmented
with a nondeterministic stack is capable of surprisingly powerful behavior,
such as learning cross-serial dependencies, a well-known non-context-free
pattern. We demonstrate improvements on natural language modeling and provide
analysis on a syntactic generalization benchmark. This work represents an
important step toward building systems that learn to use syntax in more
human-like fashion. | [
-0.0647534207,
-0.6237581968,
0.2471850663,
0.4637422264,
0.207701847,
0.2141731977,
-0.1575229913,
-0.5654824376,
0.2901573479,
0.1908318996,
-0.1718915701,
-0.1558833569,
-0.5421429276,
0.2455109209,
-0.5755386353,
0.7656547427,
-0.0294720586,
-0.2167837471,
-0.0852136239,
-0.0755025297,
-0.2346570939,
-0.6024745107,
-0.3688474596,
-0.4664640129,
0.3333002627,
-0.1278519183,
0.5031662583,
0.6356769204,
0.1694248319,
0.3961895406,
-0.1521480381,
-0.0147498995,
-0.0294098835,
0.3008016646,
-0.0621763282,
-0.6763983965,
-0.2563538253,
-0.2152973861,
0.8304458261,
1.0838719606,
-0.2254344374,
-0.0150975995,
-0.2510972917,
0.7269336581,
-0.4800128937,
0.4246960878,
-0.5353309512,
0.2714784443,
-0.1827676445,
-0.203716293,
-0.5050795078,
-0.385094732,
0.1168405488,
-0.2237220556,
0.1482671052,
-0.1886107624,
0.4272468984,
0.3472268581,
-0.3385160565,
-0.1047062501,
-0.6588786244,
0.8778554797,
-0.612834394,
0.4939946532,
0.1796862334,
0.1473634392,
-0.4524338543,
-0.6889695525,
-0.3534708619,
-0.5114524364,
-0.0680188611,
-0.1186751574,
-0.4629516304,
0.16694507,
0.3831861317,
0.2980082035,
-0.5166364312,
0.179101035,
-0.0285881665,
-0.0120707843,
0.3414110839,
0.1519643962,
0.3366668224,
-0.4159852862,
-0.562351346,
-0.0314591825,
-0.3494564295,
-0.0260349866,
0.4824534059,
0.2701664567,
-0.1084533259,
0.270252198,
-0.183463797,
0.856579721,
-0.011520463,
0.3482857347,
0.158097446,
-0.1994198412,
-0.2352376282,
-0.0949797481,
0.6027976871,
0.0018364352,
0.3468665183,
-0.4253225625,
-0.3477840126,
0.2372396141,
0.2840559185,
-0.4661212265,
-0.4255349934,
0.2111184001,
-0.5045328736,
-0.5484525561,
-0.1972936392,
-0.6552758217,
-0.0316737667,
-0.2886953652,
0.1340873539,
-0.4694530368,
-0.269708395,
0.1202534735,
-0.2579939067,
0.0476993248,
0.0318270102,
-1.0969570875,
0.682085216,
0.373387903,
0.8149597645,
0.1802314222,
-0.268252492,
-0.3712037206,
-0.0559716411,
-0.4911329448,
0.6196887493,
-0.3472768962,
-0.085318096,
-0.2228304297,
-0.1714110076,
-0.4873283207,
-0.7046554685,
0.0607613623,
-0.6164896488,
0.1081991568,
0.2057626396,
-0.4355221391,
-0.1866661459,
0.1858493835,
-0.7741847634,
0.9731652141,
0.1775098741,
-0.634275794,
-0.32375139,
-0.6168736815,
-0.7499943376,
-0.0414451584,
-0.1324325353,
-0.2764431238,
0.3929077387,
-0.1164558902,
0.0813789815,
-0.1705034822,
0.4748540521,
-0.0867599249,
-0.2186908871,
0.3132223189,
-0.5750159025,
1.006701231,
-0.0676647574,
-0.5499384999,
0.0429566018,
-0.8430856466,
0.2257338166,
0.0709015578,
-0.436264962,
-0.2399704158,
0.0569690056,
-0.0153640499,
0.3631192744,
0.2208614647,
-0.3489596546,
0.3631220758,
-0.5450431108,
0.8722478151,
0.6989824772,
-0.1268238574,
0.3442144692,
-0.4186514914,
0.3943733275,
-0.0093190568,
-0.0969437808,
-0.2284966111,
-0.3855597377,
-0.6533474326,
0.1920990795,
0.2270608544,
0.6690912843,
-0.8161564469,
0.4303271174,
-0.0079427753,
-0.0519282855,
0.1071971208,
-0.0343992673,
0.4938060045,
0.6183431149,
0.469602406,
-0.3474439383,
-0.9075860977,
-0.9145889878,
-0.1263012439,
-0.459153235,
0.0879122764,
0.2053818256,
0.4204781651,
-0.0619115569,
0.7317575812,
-0.2724769711,
0.0813159868,
-0.260122776,
0.452824533,
0.3466257453,
0.5075002909,
0.3592817783,
-0.4784617722,
0.0107695125,
-0.2691137493,
-0.6950330734,
-0.2095426768,
-0.1838541031,
0.2571989596,
0.2890008688,
0.4120656848,
-0.6268388629,
0.2147025019,
0.4377164543,
0.1294590831,
0.6189838052,
-0.2400365472,
-0.2788266838,
-1.0490721464,
0.1929450482,
-0.1491460353,
-0.1484002322,
-0.8302670717,
-0.2312256843,
0.0449492335,
-0.0013313203,
-0.4950775802,
0.4195761681,
-0.5191549063,
-0.4795343876,
-0.2522994578,
-0.1461723447,
0.0428964831,
0.6188730001,
0.0725711063,
0.6046410203,
0.4719450176,
-0.6641400456,
0.3233544528,
0.2442531437,
-0.4803082347,
0.2479735017,
-0.5944164395,
0.0338030607,
-0.3513692319,
0.513505578,
-0.870939672,
-0.0163444094,
-0.0262080207,
-0.3483816385,
0.0898054168,
-0.2138292044,
-0.483138293,
-0.2194260359,
-0.1346696466,
0.6646565199,
0.3053288758,
-0.4863668978,
0.2409094274,
0.1535305083,
0.3633458614,
-0.7199015021,
-0.90167135,
0.4077067077,
0.1169283316,
-0.5947406292,
0.5736576915,
0.2615941465,
-0.3054596186,
-0.0955035761,
-0.0825742483,
-0.1172744632,
0.4212163389,
0.0869777203,
0.2145798951,
-0.3736583591,
0.327863723,
-0.3444594443,
-0.3391575217,
0.0045133866,
-0.8475158215,
0.6234323382,
-0.3843948841,
-0.1606213748,
-0.6086747646,
0.3488956392,
0.5691908598,
-0.1094150469,
0.4906376004,
0.2427450269,
-0.4698589742,
-0.5703121424,
-0.1991789192,
-0.2935581505,
-0.4340050817,
0.2864604592,
-0.1763307154,
-0.6774786115,
0.4329991639,
0.0485447496,
-0.076588586,
0.3590190411,
0.5626729131,
0.0033143079,
0.658898592,
0.3644754291,
-0.0557176098,
0.7128437757,
-0.2567594647,
0.0857250839,
-0.8219773173,
-0.0506569482,
-0.355515182,
-0.8740699887,
-0.6190402508,
-0.4955277443,
-0.0530767813,
0.095009014,
-0.1186534911,
0.7955493927,
-0.3895737827,
0.4638285935,
0.3905538321,
-0.3031689525,
0.1856652349,
-0.0699509904,
-0.4849995375,
0.2535457611,
-0.6405553818,
-0.1395550668,
0.5390239954,
0.2933541834,
0.8762485385,
0.1894148886,
0.4678014517,
0.2091334164,
-0.0434295721,
-0.8387135863,
0.5846228004,
-0.4984164238,
-0.322814852,
0.0357218534,
-0.6096426845,
-0.9617677927,
0.147840932,
0.0961657837,
-0.8492651582,
0.5044846535,
0.055633992,
-0.3405598998,
0.7185545564,
-0.8708987832,
0.507361412,
-0.4293505251,
-0.1737574339,
0.2587931454,
-0.8485596776,
0.0814719796,
0.4014210403,
-0.2217364758,
0.0878729671,
-0.0342498831,
0.5184383988,
-0.3098560274,
1.1808797121,
-0.0978702456,
-0.049197942,
0.2459606677,
0.3390480876,
0.4796700478,
-0.0393796526,
-0.2265500128,
0.3443749845,
-0.1996786445,
-0.3531112373,
-0.7192019224,
0.5265891552,
-0.6524776816,
-0.3094264865,
-0.2799527645,
-0.8002195954,
-0.1957834363,
0.2402614951,
0.0720717758,
0.7297799587,
-0.0533129685,
0.0454467759,
0.4900022447,
-0.0688769892,
0.829703927,
0.1908746064,
-0.0032229866,
-0.2968833447,
0.7302933335,
0.2422358245,
0.3362922966,
0.8879173398,
0.2186294496,
-0.4242196977,
-0.4998112321,
-0.4848538935,
-0.1124422848,
-0.5438990593,
-0.0088480515,
-0.8056439757,
-0.5374640822,
-0.2332477719,
0.0084339809,
-0.2768225372,
-1.104147315,
-0.0808748305,
-0.0847803727,
0.2684029937,
0.709610045,
-0.0133744702,
0.0094031123,
-0.648687005,
0.1698766053,
0.3095381558,
0.55775702,
0.3238118887,
-0.1518432349,
-0.055843927,
-0.1552656293,
-0.1478563249,
-0.7792490125,
0.2688215375,
0.0394542217,
0.4922979474,
0.1447651088,
-0.0605096966,
0.4942657948,
-0.4930754006,
0.5056032538,
0.1040099636,
-0.933730185,
0.2998883128,
-0.4541877806,
0.2938055694,
0.4178915322,
0.065839462,
-0.7516731024,
-0.0455764905,
-0.5680873394,
-0.6533238888,
0.5741737485,
0.2987363636,
0.2753790319,
-0.4762391448,
0.3720331192,
-0.1460327655,
0.4068613648,
-0.5901409388,
-0.1589618176,
-0.3107632399,
-0.2570712864,
0.3119004667,
0.0829731449,
0.1016198322,
-0.0131860161,
0.2076564878,
-0.0439939015,
0.466081351,
0.1597237289,
-0.3048827052,
0.0767663121,
0.3791126311,
0.8291285634,
0.4547905326,
-0.1268917918,
0.6145220399,
0.0303532649,
-0.2447834164,
0.2391773909,
-0.0035234871,
-0.0999084041,
0.0113403657,
0.307923615,
0.9030078053,
0.5386892557,
-0.4521572888,
0.1666275561,
0.042177666,
-0.2324266285,
-0.2967318892,
-0.1121643782,
0.0912086368,
0.2454342097,
0.1594195515,
0.4009711742,
-0.1615210772,
-0.3942403793,
0.6632633209,
0.4509081841,
-0.4164262414,
-0.5450021029,
0.4765630364,
0.0871054307,
-0.5750210285,
0.6375362873,
0.019994026,
-0.5881478786,
0.9467763305,
1.0392934084,
0.982195437,
-0.1627447605,
0.3095508814,
0.2084236145,
0.1989294142,
-0.1477407217,
0.1191996783,
-0.3064127564,
-0.7460322976,
-0.4521526098,
-0.6159332395,
-0.4365357757,
-0.1250087619,
-0.2099849135,
0.111907877,
-0.8987692595,
-0.1246288717,
0.0316955186,
-0.2281025946,
-0.1142888442,
0.0240498353,
0.0571381301,
0.7669953704,
-0.602455914,
0.7884556651,
0.7028461695,
-0.378785938,
-0.666728735,
-0.0354589336,
-0.0513735898,
-0.8426189423,
0.9263986349,
0.3376737535,
-0.3228837848,
0.0928078964,
-0.157121107,
-0.8034939766,
0.7748710513,
0.2917653918,
-0.2359721065,
-0.4047656357,
-0.0713828057,
0.6695550084,
-0.2835883498,
0.3697643876,
0.175911665,
0.2228558213,
0.199622333,
-0.5990229249,
0.1288913935,
-0.4207042456,
0.2344065607,
0.7608055472,
-0.6096229553,
1.3176134825,
-0.0855101869,
-0.4284381866,
0.1963517219,
0.1924904585,
-0.1205677614,
-0.0434341989,
0.4280201793,
0.8555470705,
0.7510848045,
-0.0012918495,
1.1508673429,
-0.284876138,
0.1930469871,
1.0076599121,
-0.2302313894,
0.7853608727,
0.3653146327,
-0.2085086405,
0.9919980764,
0.1677960008,
-0.1206331849,
0.2100881189,
0.5443876982,
-0.4304952919,
-0.1808212399,
-0.1670447737,
-0.2013574392,
0.3708358407,
0.1987820566,
-0.5204891562,
-0.6484981179,
-0.2189601809,
-0.3096088469,
0.0712828189,
0.1032011285,
0.6453999877,
0.1909422725,
-0.5142270327,
0.7972878814,
0.1872648597,
0.6190856099,
-0.4643219411,
0.0626738295,
-0.0405713469,
0.0913028196,
-0.4829191566,
-0.4584583938,
0.7624741197,
-0.230847463,
-0.4258152246,
-0.431391567,
0.6825904846,
-0.2745662034,
-0.2672630548,
0.3723489344,
0.5558174849,
0.0710794553,
0.3076716363,
-0.482082814,
-0.354719311,
-0.3414956629,
0.0567666255,
0.3379440606,
0.0409046337,
-0.3778522611,
0.5854145885,
0.844886601,
0.0148117738,
0.2039444447,
0.2776177526,
0.6824983954,
-0.8417128325,
-0.6366044879,
-0.8692750931,
0.3032121062,
0.2400500625,
-0.1016251817,
0.3335897624,
0.2448787987,
0.639816463,
0.08963117,
0.5521944761,
-0.1596691906,
0.0413548984,
-0.392976284,
0.5618050098,
-0.3290949464,
0.2795211673,
-0.0066421246,
-0.7658806443,
-0.6158956289,
0.8083951473,
-0.4457531571,
0.0315411203,
0.7000303864,
0.5479004383,
0.1027566642,
0.3492604494,
0.2103090137,
0.1808394194,
0.2167497575,
0.9789113402,
0.9671273828,
-0.4368527234,
0.4290777445,
-0.1810345203,
-0.1203340963,
-0.0183875579,
-0.9966067076,
-0.6975810528,
-0.4913377166,
-0.1314752996,
-0.2265641838,
-0.0162431896,
0.9033999443,
0.672098577,
-0.741817534,
-0.5035556555,
-0.5800276995,
0.5797596574,
-0.3722364008,
-0.2464191914,
0.0748033971,
-0.5849471092,
-0.605848074,
0.7090510726,
0.5968319178,
0.1835280508,
-0.1676024497,
0.3603487313,
-0.4527585804,
0.0082631512,
0.6193575263,
0.6373823285,
-0.4149102271,
-0.1592289209,
0.3325861692,
-0.0849315524,
0.3139477372,
0.9477649331,
-1.0241429806,
0.3320626915,
0.8419247866,
1.0034228563,
0.1844504029,
-0.0203934517,
0.5023331642,
-1.0347970724,
0.1850247383,
0.4256585836,
0.302603811,
0.2568134964,
-0.2401013821,
0.1778179705,
0.3692412674,
-0.3572872579,
-0.5939718485,
0.7100359797,
-0.7515369058,
-0.1911456138,
0.7548642755,
0.1496726274,
-0.3669930398,
-0.3825636208,
0.3796981573,
0.1860023886,
-0.2001075745,
0.7973143458,
0.5864283442,
-0.5313147306,
-0.1055253893,
-0.4905305505,
0.2843861878,
0.7097048759,
-0.7503135204,
0.1789803207,
0.2583651841,
0.2946324646,
0.4011383057,
0.5898125768,
-0.3457486928,
0.1789262742,
-0.1746823937,
-0.125354141,
-0.226868242,
-0.3738683462,
-0.5789293051,
0.3864257336,
-0.2863430977,
-0.2897787392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12888v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12888v2 | Out-of-distribution Evidence-aware Fake News Detection via Dual Adversarial Debiasing | 2023-04-25T14:59:25 | 2024-04-15T14:17:30 | Qiang Liu, Junfei Wu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evidence-aware fake news detection aims to conduct reasoning between news and
evidence, which is retrieved based on news content, to find uniformity or
inconsistency. However, we find evidence-aware detection models suffer from
biases, i.e., spurious correlations between news/evidence contents and
true/fake news labels, and are hard to be generalized to Out-Of-Distribution
(OOD) situations. To deal with this, we propose a novel Dual Adversarial
Learning (DAL) approach. We incorporate news-aspect and evidence-aspect
debiasing discriminators, whose targets are both true/fake news labels, in DAL.
Then, DAL reversely optimizes news-aspect and evidence-aspect debiasing
discriminators to mitigate the impact of news and evidence content biases. At
the same time, DAL also optimizes the main fake news predictor, so that the
news-evidence interaction module can be learned. This process allows us to
teach evidence-aware fake news detection models to better conduct news-evidence
reasoning, and minimize the impact of content biases. To be noted, our proposed
DAL approach is a plug-and-play module that works well with existing backbones.
We conduct comprehensive experiments under two OOD settings, and plug DAL in
four evidence-aware fake news detection backbones. Results demonstrate that,
DAL significantly and stably outperforms the original backbones and some
competitive debiasing methods. | [
-0.365722388,
-1.0125542879,
0.6141968966,
-0.0035736745,
-0.426687628,
0.0746406242,
0.1302660257,
-0.2137250751,
0.260358125,
0.4252860248,
-0.2945695519,
-0.4128480554,
-0.5646148324,
-0.3284796178,
-0.2481077164,
1.0150142908,
-0.0059791799,
0.3880079389,
-0.0725860596,
-0.526736021,
-0.1169115826,
-0.4303338528,
-0.6957538128,
-0.2524937093,
0.3790424168,
0.1267959774,
0.7628877163,
0.3947015703,
-0.0207493063,
0.0723181069,
-0.0572663248,
0.505808115,
-0.3172016442,
-0.2048685402,
-0.427573055,
-0.3767579496,
-0.3506659567,
0.2351344675,
0.4374555051,
0.2875491679,
0.0095685311,
-0.1395464838,
-0.1539906263,
0.7011193633,
-0.8608945012,
-0.2219768614,
-0.727779448,
0.0074993046,
-0.124877274,
-0.1410288215,
-0.5742775798,
-0.357798934,
-0.1170944199,
-0.6870399117,
0.4675326645,
-0.0436462462,
0.8255556822,
0.0963836908,
-0.8864291906,
-0.4293556213,
-0.6354560852,
0.5385833979,
-0.5291848183,
0.3135685921,
0.1653387398,
0.3511269987,
-0.2874640822,
-0.369343698,
-0.8993408084,
0.0225121193,
0.0107848551,
0.2987380624,
-0.0909988731,
-0.2924142778,
-0.0824719444,
0.5212118626,
-0.6458661556,
0.0781321824,
-0.0797289684,
-0.1967631429,
0.5767934918,
-0.406717062,
0.294642508,
0.1382265985,
-0.8115435243,
-0.3198583126,
-0.91970402,
-0.2517940998,
0.8546029925,
0.057301946,
-0.1300081164,
0.2970855236,
-0.0474358238,
0.154720068,
0.470661521,
0.0328674652,
0.2753690183,
-0.2499757707,
-0.1948120296,
0.2516742349,
0.6695454121,
0.0709273964,
-0.6195796728,
-0.040408276,
-0.2482800335,
0.4359521866,
0.5180246234,
-0.4722256362,
-0.5094114542,
0.0576142184,
-0.3379464746,
-0.7365761399,
0.0400265567,
-1.0544369221,
-1.0592768192,
-0.206165731,
1.0308516026,
-0.3077166677,
-0.6105533242,
0.0850002319,
-0.3516602814,
-0.2921235263,
0.3107929826,
-0.2814317942,
0.1452323496,
0.4938666224,
0.7046028972,
-0.0944732875,
0.1031096503,
-0.8475440145,
0.0197905842,
-0.3864017725,
0.7673317194,
-0.1830163151,
0.006332255,
-0.0916081369,
-0.0877673551,
0.2113829106,
-0.5636831522,
0.7618964314,
-0.9125839472,
0.4406886697,
-0.2797054946,
-0.3296126723,
-0.4699820578,
0.4590561986,
-0.8456533551,
0.8028724194,
0.0644072518,
-0.8820636272,
0.7659394145,
-0.3906586766,
-0.5838410854,
-0.3614710867,
-0.0267145708,
-0.8044500947,
0.1587397903,
0.5301583409,
-0.0211705342,
0.1423252225,
0.3055330217,
-0.68207407,
-0.0665350556,
0.0493988618,
-0.9238612056,
0.8468160033,
0.106584616,
-0.5492174029,
0.1206831709,
-0.8130506277,
-0.3551822305,
0.1554480493,
-0.1552892774,
-0.8022806644,
-0.0655945614,
-0.1918860972,
0.3052768409,
-0.0802096575,
-0.6036828756,
0.3668683469,
-0.3745523691,
-0.0371556431,
0.6202324033,
-0.0041674469,
0.7747049928,
-0.32971102,
0.1498880982,
0.6752349138,
0.3508925438,
-0.0074069095,
-0.2255411446,
-0.6456463933,
-0.3894177973,
0.2285205722,
0.3684929609,
-1.3124486208,
0.5895591378,
0.0368901193,
-0.2343925536,
-0.3760149777,
-0.0307664983,
0.5718328953,
0.473785311,
0.6618482471,
-0.3381205797,
-0.5002936125,
-0.6914483905,
-0.4074793756,
-0.2392452806,
0.3228851557,
-0.2510800958,
0.666311264,
-0.0090561798,
0.8513861299,
-0.3562550247,
-0.4087404311,
-0.1687569767,
0.260640204,
0.0493353158,
0.2273203731,
0.5811321735,
-1.5048743486,
-0.2860521972,
-0.3136137426,
-0.6746496558,
0.0868494511,
-0.2365179658,
-0.1321329623,
0.6363722086,
-0.1292240769,
-0.6416950822,
0.8812836409,
0.3942192197,
-0.5414975882,
0.7018975019,
-0.2886558771,
0.1429355592,
-0.9407934546,
-0.2723412216,
0.0537281223,
-0.3263566196,
-0.538775444,
0.0069010956,
0.3460891843,
0.2149721533,
-0.4418550134,
0.6387745738,
-0.4099362493,
0.0369294025,
-0.5564188361,
-0.0398044363,
0.6260762811,
0.2473831177,
0.2360035628,
0.4475764334,
0.5003890991,
-0.6349903345,
0.4465598166,
-0.1621821523,
-0.2818428278,
0.802057147,
-0.2896974087,
-0.1627730131,
-0.2955596447,
0.8761033416,
-0.8659798503,
-0.1241008565,
0.6655771136,
-0.442227602,
0.4563463032,
-0.3863987923,
-0.486975193,
-0.3392201066,
-0.6146855354,
0.307393223,
0.3854456842,
-1.2967931032,
0.4261045456,
0.4170594215,
0.4069626629,
-0.6041837931,
-0.5814223289,
-0.0014230538,
-0.4869194031,
-0.5806492567,
0.42072469,
0.0760357305,
-0.2517156601,
0.3676330745,
-0.5198110342,
-0.1675061435,
-0.2067834735,
0.0024453849,
0.144378379,
-0.1523984522,
0.078068316,
0.2147672623,
0.1452915668,
0.03474731,
-0.5329378247,
0.2153729945,
0.0896516219,
-0.6912739873,
-0.4884727001,
0.363281101,
0.5696469545,
0.113547951,
1.0548939705,
0.8560376167,
-0.3357132077,
-0.5225912929,
-0.680752039,
-0.3136960864,
-0.3751335144,
0.220011875,
-0.1466447413,
0.0338844024,
0.2123038918,
0.0660794154,
-0.0472007021,
0.2140711397,
0.3701246083,
0.3957493305,
1.1934227943,
0.2183149308,
-0.0918852836,
0.2492021322,
-0.5271244645,
0.2753391862,
-0.6085000634,
-0.0133995609,
0.2724382579,
-0.1123787537,
0.1076666713,
-0.480669558,
0.4018506706,
0.3735693395,
0.0129402056,
0.0942309946,
-0.3392981589,
0.302213639,
0.7653049827,
0.5906131268,
0.3355587721,
0.097791478,
0.0851454958,
0.2473644614,
-0.6275855303,
-0.3178876936,
1.308352828,
0.2567591667,
0.6843616962,
0.4005512893,
0.4096733332,
0.6653113961,
0.3309893906,
-0.3623596728,
0.1691782027,
-0.1960815191,
-0.6440712214,
0.1423199028,
-0.4623859525,
-0.2187829763,
0.5988397002,
-0.144098416,
-0.0362955891,
0.397146374,
0.2500148416,
-0.1459073126,
0.8401268721,
-0.7499580383,
0.6687306762,
-0.2510919869,
-0.4052065015,
-0.5496923923,
-0.4282899797,
0.6923983097,
-0.0410233736,
0.4761458635,
0.3565993011,
0.0886068717,
0.2509980202,
-0.279166311,
0.8640224934,
-0.534013927,
-0.2028186023,
0.4040636718,
0.0914283097,
0.6939445138,
0.6246097684,
0.1444054544,
0.1320329756,
-0.2987252176,
-0.3773404658,
-0.6396386623,
0.8754971027,
-0.5944401026,
-0.6379242539,
-0.8139514327,
-0.54664433,
0.0080576632,
0.0929676369,
0.4430604875,
0.603230536,
-0.313413471,
-0.1129507199,
0.8540688753,
-0.1871145666,
0.3111434281,
0.8638606071,
0.0296150334,
-0.609259963,
0.9130491018,
0.0322597139,
0.2505362034,
0.2406803966,
0.3825112283,
-0.6687569022,
-0.5632365346,
-0.9137602448,
0.0065941093,
-0.5071755052,
-0.0393211804,
-0.5294182897,
-0.1123559326,
-0.6538618207,
-0.0312481169,
-0.5591145754,
-0.2942199111,
-0.2531366348,
0.0862148255,
0.0038405117,
0.5610030293,
-0.4611974061,
0.0232287198,
-0.4207703471,
0.8290688992,
0.4330433607,
0.0539029501,
-0.1634391248,
-0.7341663241,
-0.0828944892,
0.6965736747,
-0.7115088105,
-0.8942732215,
0.3563556969,
-0.0855212957,
0.4317553639,
0.8443882465,
0.6693735123,
0.3614499271,
-0.1186541766,
0.6521421075,
0.2460478544,
-0.5846228004,
0.4034371674,
-0.2968026698,
-0.2559841871,
0.2221605927,
0.4444739223,
0.149887085,
-0.1975594163,
-0.6944012642,
-0.6457663178,
0.8399575353,
0.2558661699,
-0.1012421101,
0.0142288236,
0.0193083715,
0.532265842,
0.1584315747,
-0.8604695201,
-0.3286485374,
-0.4024553001,
-0.1112140268,
0.2351988405,
-0.3438716829,
-0.4365867376,
-0.077032879,
1.1520437002,
-0.0087498808,
-0.0433500893,
0.2283868939,
-0.2371176332,
0.047664959,
0.2500554621,
0.5670540929,
0.5268951058,
-0.1490283459,
0.4190360308,
-0.0104511082,
-0.6200836897,
0.2177539468,
0.236240238,
-0.3929157555,
0.1491726637,
0.0144869918,
0.6715706587,
-0.2130640596,
-0.3121144772,
0.9370455146,
-0.0911527202,
-0.0765561089,
-0.6018170714,
-0.1574074328,
-0.2391388863,
0.4170779288,
0.4773037434,
0.5024972558,
0.1723930538,
-0.6828715205,
0.2415599674,
0.624666214,
-0.4610424936,
-0.6271330714,
0.7641692758,
0.2812814116,
0.1977531314,
0.0466417968,
-0.7852505445,
-0.6758636832,
0.7062482238,
0.6626218557,
0.7027319074,
-0.0696926191,
0.507933259,
-0.1250581741,
0.0514818281,
-0.5414887071,
0.0157397762,
0.1029562131,
-0.812302649,
-0.0343333147,
-0.4237588644,
-0.1438769996,
0.4484609663,
-0.5169013739,
0.4425046146,
-0.1704565287,
0.0347433314,
-0.0439820848,
0.1386680305,
-0.2098487318,
0.3421725333,
0.2741253972,
0.6486724019,
-0.9704646468,
0.9660742283,
0.8614544868,
-0.3064000607,
-0.0708525926,
0.3108358979,
0.5590361953,
-0.465324223,
0.4672040641,
0.2029491067,
0.0145606026,
-0.3128706813,
-0.0418995731,
-0.5159721375,
0.8296397328,
0.3882003427,
-0.1363836229,
0.1821619272,
-0.0989004746,
0.237726599,
-0.3436712325,
0.3725067675,
0.1027316526,
0.3263500333,
0.1907078028,
-0.3270024061,
0.0799918398,
-0.0469528325,
-0.3300278485,
0.3775918484,
-0.7584943175,
0.8511827588,
-0.1830461174,
-0.3498764336,
-0.2454162091,
0.6951360703,
0.2185117304,
1.071067214,
0.7675357461,
0.9368886948,
0.4990664423,
0.1597943604,
0.8212533593,
0.0224386621,
0.2472131401,
1.0776177645,
-0.5173248649,
0.3214633167,
0.2880645692,
-0.1181029081,
0.6379137039,
0.4123838544,
0.1552692354,
0.958311677,
-0.1263383478,
-0.7396181822,
-0.2079163045,
-0.062631622,
-0.5358288884,
0.0501067825,
0.416026473,
-0.2394660562,
-0.2920165956,
0.3067698181,
0.2804961801,
0.2639375031,
-0.2935168445,
0.4269729853,
-0.1253709942,
-0.4511632919,
0.4042754769,
-0.0281841345,
0.7731152177,
-0.4576993585,
-0.0263071507,
-0.2606211603,
0.6335948706,
-0.1634085625,
-0.6075671315,
0.3753902018,
-0.1891541928,
-0.4762562811,
-0.1121774614,
0.8045383692,
-0.5516783595,
-0.2448248118,
0.3386877477,
0.1047094762,
-0.2624342144,
-0.5911593437,
-0.4383693337,
-0.2134212554,
-0.2491923869,
-0.5061229467,
0.630315125,
0.3979670107,
-0.1272125095,
0.4349015355,
0.8754103184,
0.2712215483,
-0.0412536748,
0.0103391958,
0.9780645967,
-0.169175908,
-0.7570784688,
-0.7634750009,
0.1991827637,
-0.5553103685,
-0.1538762599,
0.8240138888,
0.8221378922,
0.7775150537,
-0.1330299228,
0.8429782987,
-0.2049284428,
0.5121946335,
-0.5764506459,
0.8180140853,
-0.6770590544,
0.318992734,
0.0722515136,
-0.622969687,
-0.1269245297,
0.0700837597,
-0.3525887728,
-0.2362441272,
0.7783555984,
0.8448834419,
-0.4938315153,
0.1843430102,
0.1504807174,
0.1681197137,
0.3960074484,
0.5184316039,
0.7203679681,
-0.6314948201,
0.7300778627,
-0.6272236705,
-0.2900112867,
-0.2366138846,
-0.7451788783,
-1.1252946854,
-0.3767447472,
-0.604850769,
-0.7205020189,
0.3442960978,
0.4641047418,
0.80769521,
-0.8727054596,
0.565233171,
-0.3957395554,
0.415727824,
-0.4454299808,
-0.3384969831,
0.7499027848,
-0.1245752051,
-0.5040543079,
0.7340375185,
0.1297179759,
-0.1192297265,
-0.3394528627,
-0.0577790961,
-0.3989582658,
0.2106398642,
0.404894352,
0.2247911692,
-0.6093275547,
-0.3839032352,
-0.4534769952,
-0.0922826305,
-0.1087262779,
0.7513364553,
-1.2118992805,
0.4645906985,
0.4949860573,
0.2931951582,
0.2735049725,
0.4004081786,
0.454236418,
-0.9556387067,
0.5305185318,
0.0515417233,
0.1559218615,
0.2082639188,
-0.5842315555,
0.3520117998,
0.7350228429,
-0.4696789682,
-1.0802356005,
0.4502986968,
-0.6859122515,
-0.542722702,
1.1483454704,
-0.2803924978,
-0.1567984074,
-0.4176614285,
-0.2260208577,
0.4502840936,
-0.4011407793,
1.1377799511,
0.2103310227,
0.1889918894,
0.1389706135,
-0.2833452523,
0.4612323046,
0.1993269175,
-0.520097971,
-0.1533518285,
0.4030891359,
0.2890939713,
0.1389240921,
0.3109585345,
0.0487307943,
0.3352984786,
0.3976496756,
-0.1033168882,
-0.4314597845,
-0.4370059073,
-0.3109044731,
0.0820035785,
-0.6733469367,
-0.53652215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12847v1 | NLP-LTU at SemEval-2023 Task 10: The Impact of Data Augmentation and Semi-Supervised Learning Techniques on Text Classification Performance on an Imbalanced Dataset | 2023-04-25T14:19:46 | 2023-04-25T14:19:46 | Sana Sabah Al-Azzawi, György Kovács, Filip Nilsson, Tosin Adewumi, Marcus Liwicki | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a methodology for task 10 of SemEval23, focusing on
detecting and classifying online sexism in social media posts. The task is
tackling a serious issue, as detecting harmful content on social media
platforms is crucial for mitigating the harm of these posts on users. Our
solution for this task is based on an ensemble of fine-tuned transformer-based
models (BERTweet, RoBERTa, and DeBERTa). To alleviate problems related to class
imbalance, and to improve the generalization capability of our model, we also
experiment with data augmentation and semi-supervised learning. In particular,
for data augmentation, we use back-translation, either on all classes, or on
the underrepresented classes only. We analyze the impact of these strategies on
the overall performance of the pipeline through extensive experiments. while
for semi-supervised learning, we found that with a substantial amount of
unlabelled, in-domain data available, semi-supervised learning can enhance the
performance of certain models. Our proposed method (for which the source code
is available on Github attains an F1-score of 0.8613 for sub-taskA, which
ranked us 10th in the competition | [
-0.1988681853,
-0.9821254015,
0.2137935609,
0.3199010789,
-0.2616783082,
0.2266063094,
-0.0483554788,
-0.64001894,
0.0218385383,
0.6069126725,
-0.373750031,
-0.3829734921,
-0.6025376916,
0.3643276095,
-0.6861338019,
0.8975916505,
0.2011880875,
0.1417054981,
-0.3670670688,
-0.1397370845,
-0.5224588513,
-0.5801971555,
-0.4874903858,
-0.3086804748,
0.1881280988,
0.2221654207,
0.4126215577,
0.2464927584,
0.4033242166,
0.2580168247,
-0.2480043918,
0.330819279,
-0.6291575432,
0.0869436711,
-0.3848548532,
-0.3847689629,
-0.4516536593,
-0.0847640261,
0.5279968381,
0.5018351078,
0.0802547336,
0.3258312345,
0.4649599493,
0.3635114431,
-0.5402317047,
-0.1725473702,
-0.5292773843,
0.1412477046,
-0.1894041598,
-0.5272516608,
-0.5412837863,
-0.0626094341,
0.0867571682,
-0.2786785364,
0.3775256276,
0.156655699,
0.6610607505,
0.4460200071,
-0.6588140726,
-0.0606356002,
-0.7834783792,
1.0976287127,
-0.7613927126,
0.3151786327,
0.2554606795,
0.0052490397,
0.1453874111,
-0.5934642553,
-0.2611528933,
0.276063323,
-0.1048731878,
0.0852548555,
-0.2432754189,
-0.0962186158,
0.4654859602,
0.3948639929,
-0.4856045246,
0.2585088313,
-0.6212954521,
-0.1956607997,
0.8556183577,
0.0728305951,
0.3790883124,
-0.1475837082,
-0.2226921618,
0.0784607157,
-0.4565331638,
-0.0638433322,
0.6746750474,
0.4695578218,
-0.0499470755,
0.77204144,
-0.0119334869,
0.3631862104,
-0.1817030907,
0.2233946919,
0.5474325418,
-0.3331703842,
-0.198412478,
0.0573012866,
0.6319785714,
0.4227303267,
-0.0650249496,
0.0432709157,
-0.3171706796,
0.3068406582,
0.5683466196,
-0.6624148488,
-0.1373798698,
0.0669993684,
-0.4686841369,
-0.8277068138,
-0.2716421783,
-1.0247303247,
-0.4398004413,
-0.4082831144,
0.702816844,
-0.1704567075,
-0.1269842088,
-0.1616176665,
-0.1089570969,
0.1452681869,
0.5826486349,
-0.6245132685,
0.1802595407,
0.5758683681,
0.7047216892,
-0.4638490081,
0.0539982133,
-0.3712721765,
-0.1778604686,
0.0994677916,
0.5282409191,
-0.8195825815,
-0.2311728895,
0.1333893239,
0.4085585475,
-0.0237759799,
-0.3105516434,
1.1174106598,
-0.2813880146,
0.6019648314,
-0.0983565599,
-0.7497624755,
-0.2872140706,
0.2186319232,
-0.618024528,
1.4162174463,
0.0241181292,
-0.8728532791,
0.2115347683,
-0.5815624595,
-0.6637494564,
0.1396949142,
-0.066406779,
-0.7855558395,
0.0051067355,
0.4149846137,
0.748917222,
-0.1392217427,
0.2353550345,
-0.3228988945,
-0.5010375381,
-0.1578812599,
-0.4336876273,
0.7991265059,
0.1007322297,
-0.5143729448,
0.1318439543,
-0.61443156,
-0.1607028693,
0.1818011999,
-0.1882324368,
-0.5150550008,
-0.0284068696,
0.2709513009,
0.1425476819,
0.081170775,
-0.5777089596,
0.0007691983,
-0.5109314919,
0.3776396811,
0.7828615308,
-0.0770905167,
0.6299852133,
-0.1572912037,
0.440087676,
-0.0124420701,
0.0901662633,
-0.1003818661,
-0.5342401266,
-0.7757251859,
0.1003001481,
0.4517016113,
0.5396088958,
-0.9623326659,
0.368345201,
-0.2553106844,
-0.5206640959,
-0.5300685763,
0.0528112948,
0.1137035638,
0.3777238131,
0.7480551004,
0.1143398285,
-0.6884143353,
-0.7630695105,
-0.3685911,
0.1846558452,
0.0219532363,
0.1994380504,
0.7088549137,
-0.4343338609,
0.358931303,
-0.1961621195,
-0.3247956336,
-0.2673043907,
0.2787210941,
0.0435771868,
0.5889812708,
0.5208625793,
-0.8656566143,
-0.1457080841,
-0.1612565368,
-0.905356288,
-0.3746587634,
0.0837445781,
0.0318015888,
0.3781825006,
0.5586321354,
0.1516411453,
0.5067257881,
0.5665252209,
-0.374358207,
0.1543092728,
-0.02884336,
0.2439277619,
-1.2197026014,
-0.1863668412,
0.3473959863,
-0.381524086,
-0.7564444542,
-0.1163515002,
0.1179735512,
-0.1879271716,
-0.5011854172,
0.312466681,
-0.0794605091,
0.1053956375,
-0.3956757486,
-0.2335763723,
-0.1480752081,
0.3096836209,
-0.0396609083,
0.6111277342,
0.2271321118,
-0.5633039474,
0.1352738142,
0.1003529951,
0.1495283544,
0.354937762,
-0.7580195069,
0.1657656282,
-0.1280647367,
0.1548181623,
-0.7769365907,
-0.1052745804,
0.039831765,
-0.5799497962,
0.2517781258,
-0.1673463285,
-0.463797003,
-0.3648625016,
-0.3721678257,
0.4536508024,
0.3461708426,
-0.6293385029,
0.8525828719,
0.7100890279,
0.1019191518,
-0.6846243739,
-0.6626273394,
-0.1435717046,
-0.3831754029,
-0.7045109272,
0.4494975507,
0.332077086,
0.125249505,
-0.0905776247,
-0.0179861654,
0.318115145,
0.2557404041,
0.1627822965,
0.3663622141,
0.2177108526,
0.2664918005,
0.2995550036,
0.1341866255,
0.1552681476,
-0.1277092844,
0.7239968181,
-0.3088023365,
-0.2054561377,
-0.1885196269,
0.0513937883,
0.2204742432,
-0.0454740599,
0.8760988116,
0.9379665852,
-0.5218831897,
-0.508918941,
-0.4763700664,
-0.3520926237,
-0.4383124411,
0.219336763,
0.00135624,
-1.2556635141,
0.3898173869,
-0.1812407523,
0.0798002481,
0.6451967359,
0.542920053,
-0.4209644794,
1.1983947754,
0.7048381567,
-0.0334433764,
0.3728685081,
-0.4492879808,
0.1518970281,
-0.5172999501,
-0.2687959671,
-0.5590088367,
-0.4921125472,
-1.0180473328,
-0.465572238,
0.2396364808,
-0.2926407456,
-0.071133405,
0.4807547331,
-0.7053739429,
0.238846913,
0.4630359411,
0.2788540423,
0.2256168723,
0.0659810379,
0.2364411056,
-0.2423833758,
-0.550922811,
-0.4734583199,
1.1444314718,
0.6406577826,
0.7942716479,
0.0562008247,
0.5188361406,
0.870223701,
-0.0619361848,
-0.5346343517,
0.5297247767,
-0.3575899899,
-0.4788827598,
-0.2186188251,
-0.5864682198,
-0.916960001,
0.2697007954,
-0.5409150124,
-0.5485013127,
0.2046267092,
0.0400683805,
0.1279516667,
0.3078627884,
-0.5225405097,
0.8781235814,
-0.2412603199,
-0.6352419853,
-0.1406464428,
-0.6190906763,
0.3460857272,
-0.2896048725,
0.3135629892,
-0.0664723814,
0.0148760742,
0.88939327,
-0.2691129148,
0.9098890424,
-0.2381634861,
-0.1413479298,
-0.0679446012,
-0.3978336453,
0.6109094024,
-0.0580401905,
-0.0254647546,
0.2675537765,
0.1167374179,
-0.4731226265,
-0.2950704694,
0.4484101236,
-0.8331282735,
-0.1653352529,
-0.5042831302,
-0.3035442829,
-0.1264381409,
0.10137932,
0.321210444,
0.4061399102,
-0.0088899899,
0.5991738439,
0.6908577681,
-0.4326309264,
0.3062384427,
0.230360195,
-0.3739227355,
-0.2677655816,
0.994222939,
0.1249847934,
-0.0044314275,
0.359819591,
0.105092749,
-0.5125028491,
-0.4902333319,
-0.249862954,
-0.0114950454,
-0.5955713391,
-0.2896641493,
-0.9597327709,
-0.346008569,
-0.499035269,
-0.0643738285,
-0.3434285223,
-0.4474601448,
-0.354422003,
-0.0611300617,
0.035169296,
0.3218688667,
0.2485989928,
0.4039955735,
-0.7278902531,
0.1023243517,
0.0664941072,
-0.1852250099,
-0.3501600027,
-0.9159519076,
-0.1088645831,
0.087577641,
-0.408939451,
-0.6627303958,
0.5727926493,
0.0723624453,
0.4874086976,
0.0846591368,
0.3385906518,
0.4068829417,
-0.0857406631,
0.6649585366,
-0.0889400691,
-0.8924586773,
0.9987686872,
-0.433784008,
0.1026514471,
0.4693095982,
0.2904021144,
-0.2478206158,
-0.6215135455,
-0.8369743824,
-0.9996008873,
0.7575706244,
0.766741097,
0.4345442057,
0.2720253468,
0.1224371567,
0.0406401232,
0.2631369233,
-0.9582441449,
-0.3105072677,
-0.0751410499,
-0.1918074191,
0.1658833027,
-0.2992979288,
0.0489818789,
-0.4137975276,
1.018589139,
-0.2016937733,
0.2248280346,
-0.1145604178,
-0.261795193,
-0.1169366091,
0.4310043156,
0.4256668687,
0.4212613702,
-0.2129720002,
0.2334374338,
0.5923365355,
-0.4666165709,
0.0070108315,
0.3337756395,
-0.5187922716,
0.0161638036,
0.4146957397,
0.8531911373,
0.0857541189,
-0.5620090961,
0.6415664554,
-0.1411502361,
-0.1983129531,
-0.3406192958,
-0.0260481015,
-0.3169251382,
0.329064101,
0.4538842142,
0.3005029559,
0.3602287173,
-0.453795135,
0.2664361596,
0.2242743373,
-0.4102527797,
-0.3525311649,
0.713773787,
0.3825860322,
-0.0225145053,
0.2870540023,
-0.1974433661,
-0.695972085,
0.4741267562,
0.522873044,
0.7174115181,
-0.3448013067,
0.3259383738,
0.5585308075,
0.54551965,
-0.1120486856,
0.3759708405,
0.1953863353,
-0.9085855484,
-0.595330596,
-0.7206122875,
-0.2612841725,
0.2984636128,
-0.5638321042,
0.7129372358,
-0.0485557951,
-0.1424919963,
0.1439946294,
-0.0025018491,
-0.5328361392,
0.2269797325,
0.1883407831,
0.5409573317,
-1.1564804316,
0.604613483,
1.0244427919,
-0.1902831793,
-0.6580330133,
-0.134221971,
0.1111632138,
-0.6004812121,
0.3372040689,
0.4367087185,
0.0902406275,
0.1011701226,
-0.6243789792,
-0.3431985676,
0.9408821464,
0.1830960512,
-0.4722842872,
0.0338524207,
0.4127925336,
0.7427939177,
-0.1830667555,
0.356877178,
0.4000404179,
0.1812278181,
0.0859817117,
-0.8411309123,
-0.0936822668,
-0.5181446671,
0.0026459589,
0.3913876712,
-0.390820086,
0.3890142143,
0.2494483739,
-0.1810098886,
-0.3444233537,
0.702247858,
0.0747459456,
0.6473757029,
0.6650993228,
0.811904788,
0.662987709,
-0.3694444597,
0.7306833863,
0.0638358817,
0.7118319273,
1.0545729399,
0.0649604276,
0.6855562925,
0.3443463445,
-0.3513465524,
0.0457920395,
0.6660001874,
-0.3565531075,
0.2933374643,
-0.1026002467,
-0.1002845019,
-0.3155578375,
-0.5680735111,
-0.4672521353,
0.5355073214,
0.3643249571,
-0.6811429262,
-0.1818689108,
0.4262818098,
-0.0705652088,
0.1160975993,
-0.3078923523,
0.6990787387,
0.0808494687,
-0.2543312013,
0.2387790084,
0.0345949754,
0.8984624147,
-0.0499320589,
-0.0375093073,
0.0295341704,
0.3549749255,
-0.4198886156,
-0.9630627036,
0.4223039746,
-0.0182976592,
0.0224507395,
-0.4170523584,
1.2661069632,
-0.5078234673,
-0.8196955919,
0.3999575078,
0.6310276985,
-0.0125197014,
-0.1237601489,
-0.7587568164,
0.0850166455,
0.2374615371,
0.0849711075,
0.2425459474,
0.2767530084,
-0.1671020091,
0.4762535989,
0.6582964659,
-0.2732095122,
-0.0157416817,
0.3532872498,
0.929704845,
-0.3373229802,
-0.3353244364,
-0.938123405,
0.3641846776,
-0.3914654851,
-0.0788550675,
0.9170106649,
0.7997919917,
1.0619450808,
0.0278878566,
0.6997286081,
-0.144950822,
0.7716723084,
-0.3313621283,
0.415302366,
-0.8441460133,
0.6391765475,
-0.5600087047,
-1.0263600349,
-0.0877561867,
0.32115978,
-0.4350823462,
-0.0115736211,
0.3424908519,
0.7121645212,
-0.1238641962,
0.5869481564,
0.2708383203,
-0.0539729632,
0.3494178951,
0.0741765052,
1.112157464,
-0.7893496156,
0.4647706747,
-0.6101019382,
0.0339210741,
-0.1823745221,
-0.6187818646,
-1.1971414089,
-0.5214801431,
-0.4313723147,
-0.4775114655,
0.0587907247,
0.8535705209,
0.3879345655,
-0.9524691701,
0.1749249995,
-0.2249615788,
-0.0328368545,
0.0290831644,
-0.3415065706,
0.2648786604,
-0.3244810998,
-0.9744181633,
0.1375452429,
0.1435030997,
0.0067335838,
0.0374513678,
0.0465102345,
-0.3581932783,
-0.3393565118,
0.7833894491,
-0.2050193548,
-0.4218893647,
-0.1663806885,
0.1646588445,
0.1817908883,
-0.2155508399,
0.4900003076,
-0.529017508,
0.4929943383,
0.7601159811,
0.9501760006,
0.5957072377,
0.3142210841,
0.5609582663,
-0.9584100246,
-0.1124277413,
0.5921341181,
0.4143958986,
0.2390962243,
-0.438542515,
1.0254126787,
0.5113132596,
-0.7759628892,
-1.0425300598,
-0.3305587471,
-0.955465734,
-0.1980338842,
1.1143103838,
0.2150017023,
-0.0409864634,
-0.2053730488,
-0.2470016778,
0.349229008,
-0.494066447,
0.6411124468,
0.5557591915,
0.0007260048,
-0.4921182692,
-0.7992277145,
0.3565064669,
0.6121029854,
-1.1318063736,
-0.3559394777,
0.3507397771,
-0.1289116144,
0.1758905202,
0.126862824,
-0.0699415877,
0.0078721596,
-0.523265481,
-0.1316653937,
0.2201871872,
-0.1176887825,
-0.2563900054,
0.1706289351,
-0.6178152561,
-0.0347903036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12836v1 | Lessons Learned from a Citizen Science Project for Natural Language Processing | 2023-04-25T14:08:53 | 2023-04-25T14:08:53 | Jan-Christoph Klie, Ji-Ung Lee, Kevin Stowe, Gözde Gül Şahin, Nafise Sadat Moosavi, Luke Bates, Dominic Petrak, Richard Eckart de Castilho, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many Natural Language Processing (NLP) systems use annotated corpora for
training and evaluation. However, labeled data is often costly to obtain and
scaling annotation projects is difficult, which is why annotation tasks are
often outsourced to paid crowdworkers. Citizen Science is an alternative to
crowdsourcing that is relatively unexplored in the context of NLP. To
investigate whether and how well Citizen Science can be applied in this
setting, we conduct an exploratory study into engaging different groups of
volunteers in Citizen Science for NLP by re-annotating parts of a pre-existing
crowdsourced dataset. Our results show that this can yield high-quality
annotations and attract motivated volunteers, but also requires considering
factors such as scalability, participation over time, and legal and ethical
issues. We summarize lessons learned in the form of guidelines and provide our
code and data to aid future work on Citizen Science. | [
-0.2414830625,
-0.0673706532,
0.5746333003,
0.2048639953,
-0.3283641338,
0.3343648911,
-0.2929054499,
-0.8821888566,
0.4969938695,
0.8399018049,
-0.3568572998,
-0.3454186916,
-0.5241273642,
0.5273458362,
-0.3015702963,
1.0867527723,
-0.029755,
-0.1515075266,
-0.4427993894,
-0.1437100023,
-0.011187152,
-0.7440686226,
-0.6387956738,
-0.073832117,
0.5935080051,
0.8003998399,
0.6371191144,
0.4905478656,
0.5104151964,
0.2441502959,
-0.0318609066,
0.1492463052,
-0.2781224549,
-0.044352252,
-0.1784094125,
-0.4787274003,
0.1697721332,
0.7293619514,
0.1929851919,
0.7756051421,
-0.118914023,
0.5702514052,
-0.0378603414,
0.7989742756,
-0.4086245894,
0.5018066168,
-0.3392140269,
0.0130660115,
-0.4778544605,
0.0418284647,
-0.2894749641,
-0.7073037624,
0.2136795372,
-0.9150574803,
0.5206820369,
0.0645145029,
0.3204207718,
0.3707207441,
0.172540769,
-0.4872196317,
-0.511308372,
0.7894269824,
-0.6651464701,
-0.0430824347,
0.8658308387,
0.3274098337,
-0.0697658584,
-0.6454470754,
-0.6136690974,
-0.1117738038,
-0.0424609147,
0.093225874,
0.2484478801,
-0.2798129618,
0.1539754122,
0.1646980196,
-0.3507080078,
0.0531209446,
-0.6913935542,
-0.3117620349,
0.6392080784,
-0.2743021846,
0.0852417499,
-0.6430972219,
0.0073019373,
-0.1947990656,
-0.2945464551,
0.4219448566,
0.4899055362,
0.7001280189,
0.0531472974,
0.8395962715,
-0.4272601902,
0.3361718953,
-0.1826879531,
0.4007299244,
0.5713048577,
-0.4240459204,
0.0069776801,
-0.0033745805,
0.4599002004,
0.1536828578,
0.4307808876,
-0.1261513382,
0.1207724214,
-0.2032119185,
0.1381548345,
-0.475235641,
-0.4056167006,
0.1645559669,
-0.5732169151,
-0.3977138996,
0.2002743036,
-0.5648862123,
-0.5763144493,
-0.7725025415,
0.001008187,
0.0216156449,
-0.3258629143,
0.0571845397,
-0.5018163323,
-0.0683184788,
0.3002405763,
-0.9332700968,
0.145862475,
0.8549110889,
1.1559611559,
0.1349070519,
-0.1190844476,
-0.6994125247,
-0.1682072282,
-0.0522723645,
0.8775224686,
-0.6279039979,
-0.4435659647,
-0.0999453589,
0.168066889,
0.2615807354,
-0.5945420265,
0.3803533614,
-0.3243235052,
0.2175441384,
-0.4981927574,
-0.213826701,
0.0007125955,
0.1170133948,
-0.8651924133,
1.0810501575,
0.0599292964,
-0.6514254212,
0.7176110148,
-0.7929748893,
-0.2299032211,
0.2463068962,
0.0017627346,
-0.1951054186,
0.38233459,
0.56059587,
0.4246964157,
0.0258617122,
0.2856824696,
-0.1721244752,
-0.12683478,
0.1854249835,
-0.0591705814,
1.0884349346,
-0.1154879853,
-0.0452646129,
0.1138035357,
-0.731582284,
-0.0710255355,
-0.0976990536,
-0.5879376531,
-0.4254544973,
0.1979235709,
0.3378210366,
0.1067221612,
0.0446966253,
-0.8376954198,
0.2160470337,
-0.7273967862,
0.5147876143,
0.5280866027,
0.0238385592,
0.4303311408,
-0.1233091801,
0.2624164522,
-0.6374104619,
0.3026968539,
0.0699242428,
-0.7589483857,
-0.452321738,
-0.269947499,
0.1808860153,
0.2287774533,
-0.9375610948,
0.154045403,
0.1050674692,
-0.5777247548,
-0.8254799247,
0.0558048487,
-0.1857496947,
0.4409926534,
0.6224271655,
-0.2053656727,
-0.8029732704,
-0.9166685939,
-0.310236007,
-0.4687210917,
-0.2929266691,
0.0244004298,
0.6846274137,
0.0361944288,
1.4211504459,
-0.3220030069,
-0.2672261,
0.0718292743,
0.7454674244,
0.182630524,
0.4528994858,
-0.0252780318,
-0.6679228544,
-0.192092672,
-0.0916772708,
-0.4408391416,
-0.2578741014,
0.1068676189,
0.112967588,
0.1304993182,
0.4503208399,
-0.2102563232,
0.4186391234,
0.6404460669,
-0.1047197729,
0.6749817133,
-0.2051607668,
0.2695474923,
-0.7622346282,
0.2481750101,
-0.1356916279,
-0.5197123289,
-0.2787564695,
-0.2234504372,
-0.1040308252,
-0.412707448,
-0.4266023636,
0.1638998985,
-0.4006433189,
-0.0103005748,
-0.6405561566,
0.0859919488,
-0.1296953261,
-0.0204132237,
0.5268285871,
0.4994617403,
0.197052896,
-0.2780430317,
0.4717684686,
0.1627993733,
-0.4444441497,
0.5107557178,
-0.6039845347,
0.3326833248,
-0.3182932436,
0.2236884832,
-0.4262331724,
-0.3358519077,
0.2956071198,
-0.5503980517,
-0.3483543694,
-0.2161987573,
-0.8553509116,
-0.4204331636,
-0.2915626168,
-0.0367241986,
0.116150476,
-0.7643200159,
0.1465361714,
0.6833644509,
-0.2176210433,
-0.09515021,
-0.7957698703,
0.3420425355,
-0.0664293841,
-0.1851075888,
-0.1557677239,
0.2256418616,
-0.2135345191,
0.2496259063,
0.2436800301,
-0.1634433568,
0.1637581885,
0.4996807277,
-0.1660972834,
0.1452502012,
0.3244540095,
-0.2062188238,
-0.426210463,
0.3101032674,
0.0000613774,
0.1879124641,
-0.0481666774,
-0.4119738042,
-0.3029755354,
0.5605884194,
0.1592363715,
-0.3732296228,
0.6355574727,
0.4429382682,
-0.5647184849,
0.0680391863,
-0.4485689998,
-0.1078817919,
-0.4210318923,
0.193082273,
0.4911904931,
-1.0426687002,
0.0986193642,
-0.106151998,
0.4457282722,
0.3501436412,
0.0917690247,
-0.3773106039,
0.3357828557,
0.8264339566,
-0.2093441635,
0.3289512992,
0.1342882514,
0.1323787719,
-0.6182352901,
-0.3676665723,
-0.8604589105,
-0.1391076893,
-0.4082964361,
-0.9929594994,
0.2020585686,
-0.0175161734,
0.0472616032,
0.4391948283,
-0.8011363745,
0.4606355727,
0.7012552023,
-0.1163252294,
0.5887019038,
-0.136680156,
0.7462279201,
-0.2071932852,
-0.1285083294,
-0.8359501958,
0.8887141943,
0.0443490595,
0.159278363,
-0.0302410927,
0.9613682628,
0.3019921482,
0.8988886476,
-0.5882381201,
0.4374331236,
0.0660706908,
-0.6861032844,
-0.8367627859,
-0.3554163277,
-0.8708963394,
0.1114941388,
-0.414280355,
-0.5677127838,
0.3224115074,
0.0087022902,
-0.2076110542,
0.0281802453,
-0.6491054296,
0.4959311485,
0.0429620482,
0.1894800663,
-0.322147727,
-0.4963906109,
-0.0984071121,
-0.1356209964,
0.526820004,
-0.2984935641,
0.1753554493,
0.9889037013,
-0.4521008134,
1.1229169369,
-0.5345579386,
0.2800089419,
0.6115723252,
-0.3868197203,
0.3676767647,
0.4987846911,
-0.273653686,
0.1249816939,
0.0485746637,
-0.2798247039,
-0.2910850048,
0.483936727,
-0.3882282376,
-0.6748337746,
-0.4091944993,
-0.3172843456,
-0.1795009673,
-0.0071520498,
-0.108019039,
-0.12133798,
-0.1757684797,
0.2898163795,
0.1886565536,
-0.0433452353,
0.6920273304,
0.3735201955,
-0.2661949694,
-0.3854118884,
0.8021786213,
0.30125314,
0.094912827,
0.1681585908,
0.383061558,
0.0346568748,
-0.2330285609,
-0.3223993778,
0.0990788862,
-0.532692194,
0.0121652931,
-0.5039514303,
0.3378201127,
-0.5361506939,
-0.2189716101,
-0.4393962622,
-0.5125089288,
-0.5357604027,
-0.4085160494,
0.5819840431,
0.6398220062,
-0.5150281191,
-0.1646546125,
-0.6020435095,
0.2704024017,
0.3353011608,
0.2995353341,
-0.1582235992,
-0.0015519458,
-0.3891510963,
0.0212841351,
0.3427912891,
-0.81978935,
0.26788041,
-0.0377216861,
0.5277901292,
-0.1206931919,
0.0965963304,
0.6139919162,
-0.3541811705,
0.7384238839,
0.0237148069,
-0.9715539217,
0.5691493154,
-0.0611665733,
0.3735271394,
1.0692641735,
0.2306272537,
-0.8996201754,
-0.5501097441,
-0.4102919102,
-0.9473949075,
0.4836417139,
0.1903480887,
0.1103205979,
-0.1337713152,
0.34869048,
0.4931233823,
0.2728908062,
-0.6653851271,
0.1334485263,
-0.6061518788,
0.1038726345,
-0.2805465758,
-0.0074616368,
0.0115858512,
-0.2349090874,
0.465859592,
-0.1384948343,
-0.2816797793,
0.6035890579,
-0.0273149181,
-0.0761025101,
0.2657135129,
0.0274505652,
0.4328829348,
-0.0924905315,
0.3083527386,
0.014433003,
-0.4310916066,
-0.2467522472,
0.242957592,
-0.0740309283,
0.0325171836,
0.4366365373,
0.1539094597,
0.0863894671,
-0.7847706676,
0.3043268919,
0.0920430571,
-0.2169747651,
-0.3300226331,
-0.3154054582,
0.4973151088,
0.1269247681,
0.5978394747,
0.0988250375,
0.2632006705,
-0.5046221614,
-0.1238385588,
0.2886427939,
-0.3093436062,
-0.2878804505,
0.2537257373,
0.4873976707,
-0.4313470721,
0.6521509886,
-0.2953956127,
-0.157971099,
0.520909667,
0.0720190182,
0.6160681248,
0.0654368773,
0.6835587025,
0.3996398449,
0.7801721096,
-0.39540115,
0.0612781607,
-0.223344937,
-0.3613816798,
-0.884459734,
-0.3895890713,
-0.7741034627,
-0.1030413061,
-0.7722687721,
-0.0593417771,
-0.4705799222,
-0.0710930079,
0.0027423252,
-0.0531891994,
-0.6992762089,
0.1873348504,
0.1790996492,
0.5709859133,
-1.188349247,
0.2983895242,
0.5925267339,
-0.3135393858,
-0.5460804701,
-0.2716648877,
0.0698149949,
-0.4279037416,
0.684460938,
0.387421757,
-0.0961650833,
-0.3739135861,
-0.9203789234,
-1.0633351803,
0.6856902838,
0.0302933492,
-0.4151965082,
0.342768997,
0.3389934301,
0.7870603204,
0.0004093944,
-0.1672505289,
0.2732648253,
0.734212935,
-0.3534323275,
-0.9199258089,
0.0719453469,
-0.1775837541,
-0.397382319,
-0.0675329715,
-0.3720176816,
0.4332233667,
-0.1419737339,
-0.3277905583,
-0.0997612774,
1.0485416651,
0.1782339215,
0.5210107565,
0.6139195561,
0.1825688034,
1.0906559229,
0.0583743975,
0.6670152545,
0.5539574027,
0.2179335058,
1.0637007952,
-0.2878705561,
0.8229876757,
0.9077637792,
-0.0775077492,
0.3071094751,
0.3946557641,
-0.1864982098,
0.3149603605,
0.5062394142,
-0.0277810022,
-0.2870457768,
-0.3791668117,
-0.0512829423,
0.2294960916,
0.0690490603,
-0.1706296504,
-0.1254033595,
0.4372446835,
-0.1317785382,
0.4327777922,
-0.3289970458,
0.5472435951,
0.0342501998,
-0.4104971886,
-0.4425500035,
-0.1791556627,
0.6181721091,
-0.0055224993,
-0.2595881522,
0.1802391112,
-0.420440644,
-0.4772782624,
-0.8967834115,
0.8238526583,
0.2474534065,
-0.4366423786,
-0.5266050696,
0.4493487775,
0.011898255,
-0.5858388543,
-0.0451857187,
0.3147479296,
0.4695741534,
-0.4971371591,
-0.1696284562,
-0.268648386,
-0.0306767821,
-0.4979871511,
0.0590617135,
0.3376484513,
-0.2634118795,
0.4141281247,
1.133990407,
0.2363083959,
-0.141394943,
0.3256837726,
0.7615083456,
-0.6772739887,
-0.2328854203,
-0.5476867557,
0.5183331966,
-0.4866368473,
-0.4598672688,
0.7087135315,
0.726733923,
0.8821578026,
-0.0161529947,
0.9380273223,
-0.2044537216,
0.7878544331,
-0.2342695743,
0.5176662207,
0.0662066713,
-0.0318591036,
0.0342548341,
-0.5436531901,
-0.5416954756,
0.5275635719,
-0.4010532498,
-0.5031113625,
0.3704743683,
0.3727956414,
0.4914920926,
0.3915603161,
-0.0965052694,
-0.4194868207,
0.7405307889,
0.045440957,
0.7708762884,
0.3270198703,
0.5139398575,
-0.4935262203,
-0.3271070123,
0.0082126744,
-1.0644905567,
-0.9160260558,
-0.5965787768,
-0.4448047876,
0.0520599224,
-0.1685179621,
1.0419193506,
0.5870469213,
-0.6663796306,
0.0910773724,
-0.0728510842,
-0.1110679582,
-0.3388446271,
-0.242648825,
0.3200637102,
-0.1297412813,
-0.7622885704,
0.4959206879,
0.2861367762,
-0.390861392,
-0.300557375,
0.3668527603,
-0.2576328218,
-0.1301612556,
0.3147793412,
0.715520978,
-0.4342615008,
-0.4948688745,
-0.0958003029,
0.084550865,
-0.0643797815,
1.1450484991,
-0.9304955602,
0.6224844456,
0.3359282017,
0.6019769907,
0.5975240469,
0.0978686661,
0.2269547135,
-0.7721730471,
0.0576377846,
0.646145761,
0.1624263376,
0.7058294415,
-0.3077352643,
0.5023620725,
0.0524024814,
-0.7491796017,
-0.5840303898,
-0.0480587594,
-0.8283298612,
-0.2530189455,
1.0497151613,
-0.0239896197,
-0.2181828767,
-0.6297069788,
-0.467256546,
0.361358285,
-0.4956673384,
0.9896185994,
0.7538870573,
-0.1165766492,
-0.0783758909,
-0.5154050589,
0.4144322574,
0.1819705665,
-1.0883235931,
0.4213657975,
0.3764764965,
0.0191469565,
0.5670270324,
0.725912869,
-0.0540420376,
0.0367674939,
-0.298458606,
0.4456286132,
-0.4128887653,
0.0798418149,
-0.0739943311,
0.1966688186,
0.0774545595,
-0.1293575317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12833v1 | A New Information Theory of Certainty for Machine Learning | 2023-04-25T14:03:57 | 2023-04-25T14:03:57 | Arthur Jun Zhang | cs.IT | cs.IT, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, math.IT | Claude Shannon coined entropy to quantify the uncertainty of a random
distribution for communication coding theory. We observe that the uncertainty
nature of entropy also limits its direct usage in mathematical modeling.
Therefore we propose a new concept troenpy,as the canonical dual of entropy, to
quantify the certainty of the underlying distribution. We demonstrate two
applications in machine learning. The first is for the classical document
classification, we develop a troenpy based weighting scheme to leverage the
document class label. The second is a self-troenpy weighting scheme for
sequential data and show that it can be easily included in neural network based
language models and achieve dramatic perplexity reduction. We also define
quantum troenpy as the dual of the Von Neumann entropy to quantify the
certainty of quantum systems. | [
-0.0418327115,
-0.4158944488,
0.5022563338,
-0.0419949144,
-0.1012840569,
0.1594017595,
-0.1105435789,
-0.3476082385,
0.4105642736,
0.2541516721,
-0.1866389364,
-0.3923786879,
-0.7500114441,
-0.268740952,
-0.4395098388,
0.5718799233,
0.0356561616,
0.0572179779,
-0.0783604458,
0.0334479697,
-0.0054315887,
-0.8470802903,
-0.6059470773,
-0.3172128797,
0.7989161611,
0.2218897343,
0.8566481471,
0.4328475595,
0.9119408131,
0.3446969986,
0.3925302625,
-0.3599525988,
-0.0408676937,
0.2520655692,
-0.0152370865,
-1.0193465948,
-0.0689820945,
-0.0075594834,
0.8329731226,
0.7886172533,
-0.3508114815,
-0.1143281087,
0.0654368252,
0.7440820336,
-0.8790011406,
0.0462435037,
-0.4941475987,
0.4582898319,
0.024417825,
-0.3297922611,
-0.3218825459,
-0.4289548099,
0.2758046687,
-0.660697937,
0.2315291017,
-0.1815416813,
0.5997191668,
0.3600834608,
-0.6659487486,
-0.465639323,
-0.7292712331,
0.9788963199,
-0.2318919599,
0.6472950578,
0.2670451701,
0.2496004552,
-0.2010181844,
-0.6915516257,
-0.6378512383,
-0.2694258392,
0.2720482349,
0.0421653986,
-0.3187843263,
0.3142074943,
-0.1328907609,
0.2502394617,
-0.4778013825,
0.0500128977,
-0.4682216644,
-0.3923531175,
0.5633596778,
-0.3115615249,
0.0548055507,
-0.0342258029,
-0.460518986,
-0.2099986374,
0.1676465124,
-0.0370236225,
0.7349417806,
-0.0117802555,
0.1038290262,
0.4714739025,
0.0985441804,
0.6170684099,
-0.1642598063,
-0.2092482746,
0.2715713084,
0.2717870474,
-0.4012759328,
0.3177785575,
0.7874464989,
0.1309070289,
-0.1276166141,
-0.2053859085,
0.049486272,
0.1076832265,
0.463296175,
-0.4100109935,
-0.4945764244,
0.3669444621,
-0.3132642508,
-0.7855437994,
0.2955942452,
-0.3237032294,
-0.4946189523,
-0.2766215801,
0.3752293289,
-0.5579388738,
-0.3799157143,
0.0448256321,
-0.4560870528,
-0.1130910963,
0.392814517,
-0.7342613935,
0.015916016,
0.6969670653,
0.7889550924,
-0.2393524349,
-0.2492377013,
0.0298115946,
0.2779755294,
-0.7291517258,
0.276214987,
-0.5934696198,
0.0427914448,
-0.1431114972,
-0.2962350249,
0.0399130322,
-0.0732155964,
0.5378859043,
-0.6666244864,
0.0998145938,
0.2594820261,
-0.5736492276,
-0.4030202627,
0.0664438382,
-0.7628534436,
0.7050249577,
0.2442102581,
-1.0824992657,
0.4532998204,
-0.2093703449,
-0.2678903937,
-0.0317386314,
0.0641928241,
-0.24977687,
0.252484113,
-0.8253061175,
0.2513998449,
-0.0211227294,
0.4687399566,
-1.0212216377,
-0.1331075132,
0.4721134305,
-0.568340838,
0.7982666492,
0.6113168001,
0.016318731,
-0.422183454,
-0.9447447658,
0.508670032,
-0.4027752876,
-0.2617782056,
-0.4950936735,
-0.144786343,
-0.3020386398,
0.2275706232,
0.4054962397,
-0.3508650362,
0.2965449095,
-0.0707929805,
0.6055829525,
0.7675797939,
-0.105323568,
0.5839985609,
-0.1287953854,
0.3280416131,
0.186359033,
-0.1644593626,
0.435945183,
-0.613255918,
-0.5832306743,
-0.2072655559,
0.7403338552,
1.0146974325,
-0.6995370984,
0.6871279478,
-0.0297030732,
-0.4630986154,
-0.2785454988,
0.0884444863,
0.2095972002,
0.3694210649,
0.0776913688,
-0.3753232062,
-0.8094745278,
-0.9749577045,
-0.233425647,
-0.6389989257,
-0.2979533076,
-0.0284491293,
0.4263468385,
-0.3344475627,
0.7055730224,
-0.1570523679,
0.3096060455,
0.376260221,
0.6578839421,
0.1069498435,
0.7913426757,
0.0169022828,
-0.9445158839,
-0.0857675448,
0.010881139,
-1.2261066437,
0.3939558268,
0.0733347535,
-0.3154282272,
0.3622988462,
0.1313480884,
-0.5211126208,
0.5873582959,
0.40596053,
-0.0456211604,
0.2967644632,
-0.481800139,
0.0282073319,
-1.0416735411,
-0.1101170555,
-0.0013270278,
-0.2480466068,
-0.698492229,
0.116594702,
0.2224231362,
-0.0012353411,
-0.3306104541,
0.247904256,
-0.089785628,
0.0523988307,
-0.1028147563,
-0.2745731473,
-0.1688113958,
0.3240723312,
0.2478469163,
0.2366256714,
0.8339873552,
-0.9688498378,
0.7008355856,
-0.1808334291,
-0.0559584387,
0.7512325048,
-0.5370733738,
-0.149274841,
-0.3041810989,
0.2891559601,
-0.7735844254,
-0.1352302879,
0.2852589488,
-0.6512800455,
0.5439457893,
0.0345655084,
-0.37535429,
-0.6354331374,
-0.2274898887,
0.4660965502,
0.3110377491,
-0.2192632407,
0.1628110409,
0.3742475212,
0.4343158901,
-0.8699491024,
-1.1698031425,
0.10860686,
-0.3480763137,
-0.6658577919,
0.1107299253,
-0.0798073933,
-0.4900356233,
-0.1377765238,
-0.2185421288,
-0.4190531969,
0.2073489875,
0.1102988198,
0.1038377136,
0.0058595319,
0.6236504316,
-0.2035615891,
-0.226240173,
-0.0468602218,
-1.4245935678,
0.0441444702,
-0.1259005815,
-0.0634663403,
-0.6928678155,
0.2547682226,
0.0161059517,
0.4215490222,
0.841290772,
0.7977365255,
-0.3952113688,
-0.1372841895,
-0.2786830664,
-0.2217592597,
-0.4128260016,
0.0729763061,
-0.5009308457,
-0.6540840268,
0.2428524941,
0.1590931714,
-0.4168173671,
0.5446590781,
0.3381663561,
-0.4354020357,
0.5936656594,
0.8919912577,
0.0688198134,
0.5028991103,
-0.406288892,
0.281737566,
-0.3525906503,
-0.0498272441,
-0.4764843583,
-0.4881809652,
-1.0903978348,
-0.3767662346,
0.3208727241,
0.4674287438,
-0.1864949465,
0.1965635419,
-0.6909252405,
-0.1537322402,
1.2401098013,
0.2948531806,
0.1535766423,
0.1604794413,
0.0193082187,
0.2535181642,
-0.717772305,
-0.4761127234,
1.3061336279,
0.2908499539,
0.8616685867,
0.1271541119,
1.0743216276,
0.639678359,
-0.1609740406,
-0.6104221344,
0.1952489018,
0.1368554235,
-0.6524190903,
-0.6193215847,
-0.8231146336,
-1.0801641941,
-0.0382359102,
-0.1665753275,
-0.9627166986,
0.4743605554,
0.4480425417,
-0.0223512501,
0.6105802655,
-1.0302197933,
0.5645334721,
-0.1266408563,
-0.2887199819,
-0.1169448942,
-1.0010584593,
0.5417009592,
-0.1591573209,
0.1420871913,
0.0891666189,
-0.3598217964,
1.0061681271,
-0.693526566,
0.6542717218,
-0.0237231702,
-0.2679822147,
0.6269164085,
0.3184817135,
0.4079184234,
0.2034865171,
-0.3432488739,
0.3562282324,
0.3419495523,
-0.6702395082,
-0.7190252542,
0.4315861166,
-0.7225825787,
-0.339910239,
-0.6127712727,
-0.6393550038,
-0.0645248517,
0.335740447,
0.7830242515,
0.2783367038,
0.2110968381,
0.2763906121,
1.102850914,
0.1623660028,
0.413628459,
0.0652639493,
0.3329945207,
-0.4190048873,
1.1025691032,
0.2793346643,
0.1544454396,
1.0272296667,
0.2135346681,
-0.163596496,
-0.2278476357,
0.0896496624,
-0.1412028074,
-0.6680203676,
-0.134793818,
-0.5919741392,
-0.1367894411,
-0.5456854105,
-0.175318405,
-0.0668198243,
-1.2016739845,
-0.1552787125,
-0.1426909864,
0.0797514245,
0.5781575441,
-0.5636187792,
0.2512399256,
-0.4565006196,
0.2068596333,
0.4503523111,
0.3645035625,
-0.28144449,
-0.3920820951,
-0.312427938,
0.2868292034,
-0.4356852174,
-1.0328724384,
0.2148335129,
0.082685627,
0.458465457,
0.4883972704,
0.1970045567,
0.0086401748,
-0.1315843016,
0.5675159693,
0.600782752,
-0.9915620685,
0.5614614487,
-0.2549423277,
-0.2669499516,
0.2186411321,
0.5748544335,
-0.4248422682,
-0.562879622,
-1.1098796129,
-0.4183050692,
0.4221128821,
0.248056218,
-0.0889732391,
0.3411721885,
0.2828182578,
0.1751769185,
0.7140361667,
-0.4776669443,
-0.3893713951,
-0.3325314522,
-0.4380059242,
-0.1869811118,
-0.2120093703,
-0.1883374006,
-0.149765417,
0.8236676455,
-0.0971592814,
0.7524785399,
0.1730970591,
-0.0465789102,
-0.0952388123,
0.266514957,
0.5866906047,
0.7202398777,
-0.4830180705,
0.6607969403,
-0.0378452316,
-0.5509231687,
0.5859976411,
-0.1434914321,
-0.1978621781,
0.132077381,
0.5640571713,
0.6215005517,
0.0767312124,
-0.0427408144,
0.2288450599,
0.1006889343,
-0.566527009,
-0.433516562,
0.2249817103,
-0.3784395456,
0.131440863,
0.4054164588,
0.306948483,
0.4028318524,
-0.5750089288,
0.4670817554,
0.638510704,
-0.5926194191,
-0.2009578049,
0.4798637331,
-0.275855571,
-0.3206843734,
0.311304003,
-0.3489840329,
-0.3805034757,
0.6233121157,
0.3728365302,
0.8217837214,
-0.3987521231,
0.4438301027,
0.2496953756,
0.3946332932,
-0.1730065048,
0.2569685578,
-0.2955204248,
-0.8441050053,
0.3140724301,
-0.5586121678,
-0.5428327322,
-0.3047849536,
-0.5825400949,
0.1343555301,
-0.3962855637,
-0.3654063642,
0.1133584902,
0.2479288578,
-0.5270559192,
0.3909656405,
0.2219596654,
0.7525736094,
-0.4423172772,
1.0052652359,
0.6170138717,
-0.1468956023,
-0.7474659681,
-0.2690736651,
-0.1364392936,
-0.8856486082,
0.6705426574,
-0.0131835556,
0.0172635484,
-0.1017686576,
-0.7798022032,
-1.1071259975,
1.1227164268,
0.4669330716,
-0.3681287467,
-0.1817839891,
-0.0466189794,
0.4061432779,
-0.055177182,
0.2705702782,
0.354331702,
0.6132022142,
0.4291626215,
-0.5723920465,
-0.310613364,
-0.1802479774,
0.1572686583,
0.4025614262,
-0.5794926286,
0.9689031243,
-0.2669455111,
-0.0530601777,
-0.3718633056,
0.8666505218,
0.0462919362,
0.6465699077,
0.2659380436,
0.8641000986,
1.5043795109,
-0.00982928,
1.0418564081,
-0.4425378144,
0.563300848,
0.7495062351,
0.1407277137,
0.541351676,
0.4011953771,
-0.5011837482,
0.8585550785,
0.7161001563,
0.2255628556,
0.3496387899,
0.5223448277,
-0.4006651044,
-0.1962491274,
0.1371677965,
-0.3662919104,
0.059180256,
0.4711508453,
-0.3346562386,
0.1637681723,
0.263833195,
-0.1332584769,
-0.407604605,
-0.3643324375,
0.47919783,
0.3007616997,
-0.371134758,
0.6927135587,
0.1045066193,
0.5059049129,
-0.5381600857,
0.1690987349,
0.3229543567,
0.1167435944,
-0.305521071,
-0.7468777895,
0.1054792106,
-0.6657105088,
-0.1573095322,
0.0310514048,
0.7386965156,
-0.5127357244,
-0.7532128096,
0.0119255483,
0.0403805934,
0.3256542981,
0.0319668539,
-0.642611742,
-0.2278263271,
-0.1915247291,
-0.0848101601,
-0.1510777175,
1.0326123238,
-0.0583235249,
0.9962654114,
0.1235534027,
0.086921908,
0.4015299678,
-0.6859582067,
0.3331424594,
-0.5528507829,
-0.9260246158,
-0.6940316558,
0.0990733579,
0.0413681194,
-0.0108890943,
0.646282196,
0.4497098625,
0.6076180935,
0.0724914521,
1.2207437754,
-0.1382564753,
0.1363996863,
-0.5553552508,
0.2989582121,
-0.4793613553,
0.006676977,
-0.251681298,
-0.5015596747,
-0.4266000092,
0.4872990549,
-0.2746893764,
0.0729680657,
1.0987255573,
0.5440525413,
-0.074356176,
0.1876143962,
0.5298364758,
-0.0343551598,
-0.1170690209,
0.8610463142,
0.5752866268,
-0.5080055594,
0.5320717692,
-0.5788125992,
-0.4367714524,
-0.3540354967,
-0.7779759765,
-0.6717939377,
-0.8880618811,
-0.2535677254,
-0.6925494671,
0.0116693322,
0.6205025315,
1.092902422,
-0.9126557708,
-0.1761373878,
-0.5622088909,
0.7645177245,
-0.2021733075,
-0.2261905819,
0.1948740482,
-0.4838765264,
-0.3004359305,
-0.0847878084,
0.0318460949,
0.3583789766,
-0.1642781794,
-0.2149180621,
0.0084815333,
0.0956735313,
0.3025302291,
0.4597988129,
-0.3807542324,
-0.2883599401,
-0.3724557459,
-0.4326101243,
0.192557916,
0.9536288977,
-0.6777481437,
0.4744493365,
0.6658473015,
0.402092725,
0.3101888597,
-0.1748552471,
0.71917665,
-0.7128190994,
0.4339085519,
0.2135217041,
0.132782653,
0.0894998983,
-0.7762488127,
0.5806285143,
0.6975402236,
-0.4459572434,
-0.7777658701,
0.3562954962,
-1.0570380688,
-0.2000208795,
0.661305964,
0.0550577454,
-0.542555511,
0.0338372178,
0.4013095796,
0.380812794,
-0.5913438797,
0.6735072136,
0.7617637515,
-0.0185122099,
-0.2297900021,
-0.6913745999,
0.4299641848,
0.1925483942,
-0.5298426151,
-0.3382041752,
0.0535089001,
-0.1126069948,
0.5626966953,
0.4943118095,
0.4461245537,
0.1170212328,
0.3068420589,
0.3696556985,
0.1697827429,
-0.5212184191,
-0.3699353337,
0.3939827383,
-0.10407345,
-0.332259655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12814v1 | A Novel Dual of Shannon Information and Weighting Scheme | 2023-04-25T13:40:50 | 2023-04-25T13:40:50 | Arthur Jun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT | Shannon Information theory has achieved great success in not only
communication technology where it was originally developed for but also many
other science and engineering fields such as machine learning and artificial
intelligence. Inspired by the famous weighting scheme TF-IDF, we discovered
that information entropy has a natural dual. We complement the classical
Shannon information theory by proposing a novel quantity, namely troenpy.
Troenpy measures the certainty, commonness and similarity of the underlying
distribution. To demonstrate its usefulness, we propose a troenpy based
weighting scheme for document with class labels, namely positive class
frequency (PCF). On a collection of public datasets we show the PCF based
weighting scheme outperforms the classical TF-IDF and a popular Optimal
Transportation based word moving distance algorithm in a kNN setting. We
further developed a new odds-ratio type feature, namely Expected Class
Information Bias(ECIB), which can be regarded as the expected odds ratio of the
information quantity entropy and troenpy. In the experiments we observe that
including the new ECIB features and simple binary term features in a simple
logistic regression model can further significantly improve the performance.
The simple new weighting scheme and ECIB features are very effective and can be
computed with linear order complexity. | [
-0.390011996,
-0.158468619,
0.1733172238,
0.0043310928,
-0.5123007894,
0.1887755841,
-0.078100726,
-0.7063820958,
0.5867431164,
0.302974999,
-0.1876464933,
-0.4739345312,
-0.6254901886,
-0.3930570781,
-0.3603113592,
0.8608893156,
0.1774109453,
0.2777478695,
0.1117425263,
-0.3970708847,
-0.2105816305,
-0.7823256254,
-0.5558244586,
-0.3646392524,
0.7880827188,
0.2226716727,
0.5938591361,
0.3562494516,
0.8578910232,
0.168300733,
0.2246156931,
-0.171348691,
-0.1721641123,
-0.2423641831,
-0.0870141909,
-0.7192724943,
-0.3009709716,
-0.1636438966,
0.8036705852,
0.6249486804,
-0.41536659,
0.0854639187,
-0.1377595067,
0.8641342521,
-0.7524911761,
0.0027884683,
-0.3687715232,
0.3180285394,
-0.3811670542,
-0.5800662637,
-0.2817060351,
-0.2029623091,
0.2795986533,
-0.6357189417,
0.4030033946,
0.2408544868,
0.7348280549,
-0.0617234521,
-0.6520217061,
-0.6302492619,
-0.6283058524,
0.7795186639,
-0.322135061,
0.5235614777,
0.1176057309,
0.1327546388,
0.0244191065,
-0.2300953567,
-0.4493087232,
-0.2547285855,
0.1413008273,
0.0692257062,
-0.0786279067,
0.3465021849,
-0.0339449085,
0.4584548771,
-0.5822169185,
0.0332032666,
-0.4959633648,
-0.3686289191,
0.5197876692,
-0.2784482539,
0.1339099258,
-0.0737197548,
-0.6800667644,
-0.3216913939,
-0.0455083884,
0.0136450203,
0.8246104717,
0.1896501184,
-0.0972843543,
0.6222971082,
-0.0626921281,
0.6944410801,
-0.1445013881,
-0.2385162264,
0.4026905894,
-0.1185114533,
-0.1385297179,
0.773021996,
0.5023888946,
0.4344933629,
-0.1115824953,
-0.2201985121,
-0.0895787477,
0.3094884753,
0.2861091793,
-0.6109101176,
0.058960326,
0.0386148207,
-0.5297998786,
-0.8289139271,
0.3129323721,
-0.7614296079,
-0.3185575008,
-0.1704650074,
0.5259768367,
-0.4972414672,
-0.5021721125,
0.0407526791,
-0.5818440914,
0.3866096437,
0.369905442,
-0.7773657441,
0.0423574001,
0.7050866485,
0.97522825,
-0.1137941405,
0.1788857579,
-0.1649719626,
0.3235752881,
-0.2541717887,
0.6506676078,
-0.7931225896,
-0.1574897617,
-0.1720591635,
-0.3878634274,
0.2146767974,
-0.0981347933,
0.4842797518,
-0.6558027267,
0.2389885187,
-0.0004077097,
-0.3692345023,
-0.0101380227,
0.1633017361,
-0.8534820676,
1.0257828236,
0.047057841,
-1.2913613319,
0.7227249146,
-0.4750734568,
-0.4314104617,
0.1227015555,
0.1162212342,
-0.4001740813,
0.1396457851,
-0.664529264,
0.0576327406,
-0.1062131077,
0.3597555757,
-0.7372834682,
-0.4741819501,
0.0305126309,
-0.4762587845,
0.6192318201,
0.3845928609,
-0.1957486123,
-0.4493000805,
-1.2098404169,
0.2102389783,
-0.3435943425,
-0.641823709,
-0.7911307216,
-0.1357289702,
0.0878705159,
0.0853062645,
0.2429641932,
-0.582773447,
0.2639000714,
-0.1175276637,
0.3473447561,
0.6414750218,
-0.187696442,
0.597037375,
-0.4407968521,
0.1242515892,
0.0781550109,
-0.2312359065,
0.5183960795,
-0.4332661927,
-0.3090645671,
-0.1289586276,
0.5368667245,
0.6730146408,
-0.7195950747,
0.3819850385,
-0.175045833,
-0.2706497312,
-0.3872830868,
-0.0566278659,
0.2770859301,
0.4358208776,
0.1795565635,
-0.6821359396,
-0.7948428988,
-0.7123662233,
-0.2695166767,
-0.5867226124,
-0.1117376611,
0.1396634281,
0.0970244929,
0.0422858447,
0.4956533015,
-0.2104987204,
-0.0149107417,
-0.0963845327,
0.7874954939,
0.062774688,
0.5268191099,
0.3897509277,
-1.0677310228,
-0.005593637,
-0.1160330549,
-0.4388670921,
0.0648805574,
-0.0318671167,
-0.5578481555,
0.403509289,
-0.2144123614,
-0.5067555308,
0.5626237988,
0.1237429678,
-0.5295085907,
0.1831635088,
-0.3333212733,
0.1753985584,
-0.77482903,
-0.0216550995,
0.2604311407,
-0.3505936265,
-0.6647761464,
-0.134301573,
0.2300565392,
0.0683353022,
-0.2418809235,
0.4130683541,
-0.174800694,
-0.0713180155,
-0.2638124824,
0.0237283818,
-0.0294915009,
0.6252963543,
0.2885618806,
0.2808998525,
0.3011050522,
-0.7370689511,
0.492339313,
-0.1487580091,
-0.3659712374,
1.063724041,
-0.1836592257,
-0.2904324532,
-0.6597626209,
0.1684064418,
-0.6798336506,
0.0427250341,
0.1630968302,
-0.3568868637,
0.7990483642,
0.0841890126,
-0.3141945601,
-0.6119081974,
-0.5209311247,
0.4115499854,
0.2175186574,
-0.3512002528,
0.3353108168,
0.4318704307,
0.3007121086,
-0.8730083108,
-0.9043576121,
0.1710867435,
-0.3327817619,
-0.629353106,
0.5453096628,
-0.0853680819,
-0.2708380818,
-0.015942838,
-0.4578823447,
-0.1674531549,
-0.1045569554,
-0.1362236738,
0.375692606,
-0.0183047112,
0.569853127,
-0.4222333431,
0.0836372748,
-0.1664872319,
-1.0347015858,
0.3703582585,
-0.1471543312,
0.1448477656,
-0.4050759077,
0.2988473475,
0.1251414418,
0.1349057257,
0.9546536803,
0.9717829823,
-0.2277271599,
-0.0675781295,
-0.668628037,
-0.0579868406,
-0.3542356491,
0.328338027,
-0.2313228399,
-0.497695595,
0.1277382076,
0.3126775622,
-0.1163362041,
0.3781978488,
0.2386588007,
-0.256542027,
0.7239636779,
0.9962263107,
0.0203558058,
0.9309329391,
-0.2799057662,
0.1472695768,
-0.4718314409,
-0.4626745582,
-0.5279198885,
-0.7336041927,
-0.862924695,
-0.1035159677,
0.3394803405,
0.1482037604,
-0.147317335,
0.2943903506,
-0.5558864474,
-0.0754018873,
1.127417922,
0.5259357095,
0.2802067697,
0.2134821117,
0.0144583909,
0.4420397282,
-0.6702753305,
-0.3040829301,
1.1373176575,
0.0788311958,
0.8008490205,
0.1524796933,
0.876090169,
0.6781393886,
0.2919924557,
-0.6979365349,
0.3060604036,
-0.1657964438,
-0.681206584,
-0.4213782847,
-0.9310091734,
-0.6486153603,
0.0801132247,
-0.2032458335,
-0.7041850686,
0.5288361907,
0.2933387756,
0.0345239975,
0.6283230782,
-0.921280086,
0.4003964365,
-0.2598980367,
-0.4091086388,
-0.2717428207,
-0.8114404082,
0.3071569502,
-0.0619116016,
0.1808792949,
-0.151975587,
-0.3933908641,
1.1580877304,
-0.78541255,
0.4262914956,
-0.3610780537,
-0.0535264947,
0.4682970345,
-0.2066083401,
0.4842270017,
0.0284093879,
-0.5322954059,
0.2542828023,
0.2582826018,
-0.6219206452,
-0.5650056005,
0.3945931494,
-0.6574801207,
-0.3862075508,
-0.5386013985,
-0.5166807175,
-0.0244295225,
0.2946109176,
0.5528642535,
0.5933738351,
0.1249346733,
0.2585303485,
0.9371740222,
-0.0148543837,
0.4907175004,
0.472440511,
0.602953136,
-0.4182836711,
1.0413076878,
0.3847334385,
0.2541033626,
1.2373118401,
0.2172711641,
-0.1542084813,
-0.1800518036,
-0.2681487799,
0.072168611,
-0.4798579514,
-0.2990159392,
-0.4751856923,
-0.1353170723,
-0.3961753249,
-0.0559049994,
-0.0328793488,
-0.9766514897,
0.0049046925,
-0.081212014,
0.0688071996,
0.5137599707,
-0.1782960445,
0.0949734971,
-0.4045419395,
0.1999205649,
0.2811180353,
0.6151779294,
0.0501785576,
-0.2849384546,
-0.2587021291,
0.1383173317,
-0.409584105,
-0.9284457564,
0.1210713387,
0.1883720756,
0.4947296381,
0.4784784019,
0.2800854743,
0.2167888284,
-0.1166947335,
0.2917142808,
0.5506142378,
-0.6550240517,
0.2278245091,
0.0143306125,
-0.0181475244,
0.3675301969,
0.3501341641,
-0.4501364827,
-0.3633090556,
-0.7424181104,
-0.5297175646,
0.8354891539,
0.3167099953,
-0.1064245999,
0.4013003409,
0.146075964,
0.0252223928,
0.6200916767,
-0.8219202757,
-0.3106413782,
-0.4234403372,
-0.7452152967,
0.2448129952,
-0.3593151867,
0.0057861558,
0.0357404724,
0.8479557037,
0.1397818029,
0.6150089502,
0.3448210657,
0.0667946488,
-0.1073171422,
0.6004174352,
0.6144738793,
0.3507479131,
-0.6883292198,
0.5795533061,
-0.0308264289,
-0.887514472,
0.5779411197,
-0.0342744812,
-0.0390775949,
0.0744292513,
0.42213732,
0.7312019467,
0.2562536001,
-0.2242496759,
0.501711905,
-0.0325938649,
-0.4271303117,
-0.1300193518,
0.2303633392,
-0.3763813972,
-0.0068225795,
0.4495031536,
0.3182164431,
0.2404325157,
-0.7713842988,
0.2164825946,
0.6970958114,
-0.4666416645,
-0.21422638,
0.3746474385,
0.0053740395,
-0.2996860743,
0.0645264536,
-0.4928972721,
-0.2987695336,
0.7695930004,
0.3539040685,
0.5418084264,
-0.1701919287,
0.5045899153,
0.1855956316,
0.3557066917,
-0.4178240895,
0.4697490335,
-0.6570584178,
-0.6707582474,
0.423497051,
-0.8416267633,
-0.238057062,
-0.2514883876,
-0.6132276058,
0.4892021418,
-0.4264380932,
-0.174715206,
0.0683079138,
0.4103552401,
-0.750808537,
0.2711560726,
0.3976456821,
0.8564745784,
-0.2411907017,
0.8355452418,
0.6587726474,
-0.0499554388,
-0.6829521656,
-0.2308235615,
-0.1018291563,
-0.8946074247,
0.6340476274,
0.2998363972,
0.0595538728,
-0.1300522387,
-0.4194161296,
-1.1938744783,
1.2941492796,
0.1515462399,
-0.7282815576,
-0.4911929369,
0.0935966969,
0.3846031427,
-0.1923220158,
0.422241807,
0.2656225264,
0.6259676218,
0.6250221729,
-0.4355908632,
-0.2435241789,
-0.3805788457,
0.1781780571,
0.6352028251,
-0.9099828601,
0.3670276403,
-0.1525020599,
-0.2691951096,
-0.3177833855,
0.4965336919,
-0.1249496713,
0.7616025805,
0.5171153545,
0.9206010103,
1.2644213438,
0.0141934827,
0.8715897799,
-0.4596120417,
0.2058224231,
0.6560417414,
-0.1026834771,
0.4340578914,
0.1889468431,
-0.3268868923,
0.7264540195,
0.5850545168,
-0.0571223684,
0.7136238217,
0.3471526504,
-0.4499081969,
0.0289037731,
-0.1145484447,
-0.3776818514,
0.1997096539,
0.2608672678,
-0.2958808243,
-0.1318974495,
0.3858004212,
-0.2713552415,
-0.6799169779,
-0.7240748405,
0.6368134618,
0.1925914586,
-0.3478751481,
0.2809046805,
0.2794525921,
0.8531989455,
-0.5864270329,
0.0950803384,
0.1428892761,
-0.1255404353,
-0.2346936166,
-0.5475863218,
0.100734584,
-0.2928090692,
-0.1817343682,
-0.0317471363,
0.8569489121,
-0.6127921939,
-0.6917083859,
0.0602647774,
-0.340993464,
0.0553082153,
0.2789832652,
-0.3802555501,
-0.1645476222,
-0.1525097191,
-0.0743497089,
-0.0072740712,
0.7577478886,
0.0041859122,
0.6026889682,
0.0167247225,
0.4187342227,
0.1980488747,
-0.1112462357,
0.4648131132,
-0.7233740687,
-0.9737547636,
-0.5801959634,
0.0385081582,
-0.1633538008,
-0.0257501975,
0.2915900946,
0.4783469439,
0.8550301194,
0.3805872798,
0.8620237708,
-0.1336375177,
0.1579257399,
-0.630276382,
0.3241443038,
-0.4681447446,
0.3534164429,
-0.3919519186,
-0.8210318089,
-0.1857280731,
0.1592616737,
-0.2739753723,
0.0275764521,
0.7805933952,
0.6994022131,
-0.0555605404,
0.3300758302,
0.2729798555,
-0.0987234265,
0.0009657254,
0.8167875409,
0.3542702496,
-0.3534559309,
0.8796866536,
-0.3676978946,
-0.5748147964,
-0.402916193,
-0.6720107198,
-0.8214505911,
-0.5664998293,
-0.2254307866,
-0.3535671234,
0.0717629939,
0.9317362905,
1.027880311,
-0.6804371476,
0.0192973539,
-0.3714926839,
0.5397973657,
0.0094935186,
-0.3038769364,
0.1743151993,
-0.2288530022,
-0.1662669033,
-0.2687037885,
0.2660335302,
0.3238757253,
-0.0237981565,
-0.0680014491,
-0.0629009157,
0.2116808891,
0.3261223435,
0.2025402784,
-0.1021374315,
-0.2431558967,
-0.4862356186,
-0.4116181731,
0.3336821795,
1.1399301291,
-0.618083179,
0.4683240354,
0.6076578498,
0.3261032999,
0.5359768867,
0.0076228813,
0.4667776525,
-0.7132346034,
0.4726599455,
0.1434776038,
0.1497651935,
0.1549586803,
-0.8867818117,
0.4063214958,
0.6837356091,
-0.2376270741,
-0.8085434437,
0.084779337,
-1.0626312494,
-0.1655957252,
0.6060701013,
0.3751294613,
-0.5123225451,
-0.019432893,
0.119144313,
0.3514737189,
-0.6642359495,
0.9377510548,
0.9071204066,
0.0241053663,
-0.1756554395,
-0.3224310875,
0.3541077673,
0.2014015913,
-0.4832322598,
-0.4893251061,
0.0007013559,
0.0704823285,
0.3392347395,
0.5900419354,
-0.0244793389,
0.0804237574,
0.0928905755,
0.3299646676,
-0.0466724075,
-0.4447085261,
-0.112797983,
0.4740333855,
-0.2621081471,
-0.08246544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12776v1 | State Spaces Aren't Enough: Machine Translation Needs Attention | 2023-04-25T12:54:20 | 2023-04-25T12:54:20 | Ali Vardasbi, Telmo Pessoa Pires, Robin M. Schmidt, Stephan Peitz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Structured State Spaces for Sequences (S4) is a recently proposed sequence
model with successful applications in various tasks, e.g. vision, language
modeling, and audio. Thanks to its mathematical formulation, it compresses its
input to a single hidden state, and is able to capture long range dependencies
while avoiding the need for an attention mechanism. In this work, we apply S4
to Machine Translation (MT), and evaluate several encoder-decoder variants on
WMT'14 and WMT'16. In contrast with the success in language modeling, we find
that S4 lags behind the Transformer by approximately 4 BLEU points, and that it
counter-intuitively struggles with long sentences. Finally, we show that this
gap is caused by S4's inability to summarize the full source sentence in a
single hidden state, and show that we can close the gap by introducing an
attention mechanism. | [
-0.0931977257,
-0.3888298869,
0.9336972833,
0.2824198604,
-0.4217746556,
-0.1173695177,
0.004596042,
-0.1220918223,
0.1122482941,
0.3219750226,
-0.6641929746,
-0.1279804409,
-0.739672482,
0.663911283,
-0.6870381832,
0.886551559,
-0.3701814115,
-0.4499398172,
-0.2177404612,
-0.105798997,
-0.4474987686,
-0.3806353509,
0.065465644,
-0.0191243049,
0.3337135911,
0.0559159704,
0.7757202983,
0.8841823339,
0.697101593,
0.3440452814,
-0.2133426368,
0.2039594799,
-0.3820760548,
0.1044540629,
0.1512206197,
-0.4279410541,
-0.4327107668,
-0.2871343195,
1.03145051,
0.7063550353,
-0.021994831,
0.1068065837,
0.0500541665,
0.7890662551,
-0.444904685,
0.2973974645,
-0.3596121371,
0.4551816285,
-0.2962074578,
-0.1498016417,
-0.329895556,
-0.4018756747,
0.0064774528,
-0.6401891708,
0.0799055025,
0.0638614148,
1.0031377077,
0.9162145257,
-0.5923571587,
0.0814070702,
-0.7630011439,
0.6505480409,
-0.7013611197,
0.548314333,
0.1784604043,
0.1020025238,
-0.3282569051,
-0.5566872954,
-0.6356488466,
0.2502326667,
-0.0155983949,
0.1786502153,
-0.4908717573,
-0.0208676085,
0.7064846158,
0.3857828379,
-0.448438853,
-0.1563266814,
-0.8234423399,
-0.1689035594,
0.1293193847,
0.2574103475,
0.0975972414,
-0.2823441923,
-0.5152732134,
0.1935745329,
-0.670367837,
0.1983585507,
0.1752581447,
0.1305038035,
0.0200890042,
0.7718250155,
0.0562300272,
0.8202039599,
0.121985659,
0.2521661818,
0.2651263475,
-0.4001612663,
-0.353230834,
-0.2624250948,
1.070417881,
0.3199627101,
-0.1030946374,
-0.1385171562,
-0.1869925261,
0.4207911789,
0.5897279382,
-0.8871189952,
0.1283610761,
0.3235473931,
-0.0841302574,
0.0428092927,
-0.1386815012,
-0.4061845243,
0.043618232,
0.0068732542,
0.1271403581,
-0.468008101,
0.1227473542,
0.2092650235,
-0.2178950161,
0.1058901325,
0.072021611,
-0.8369417191,
0.5309742689,
0.4166065156,
1.0172451735,
-0.4133606255,
-0.1044453755,
-0.121124208,
0.1182438061,
-0.5920580626,
0.6675655842,
-0.4369055331,
-0.2669434845,
-0.1385424882,
0.1545973867,
-0.2606300116,
-0.3663010597,
0.4016166031,
-0.413505584,
0.1843975782,
-0.3486120701,
-0.5868989825,
-0.1073330492,
0.0709961057,
-0.8535925746,
1.0734888315,
0.1888790578,
-0.5892288089,
0.1398104131,
-0.9034947157,
-0.5519451499,
0.1521916538,
-0.1846115589,
-0.4220452905,
0.40078035,
-0.0111879995,
0.3383983672,
0.3664634526,
0.3692768216,
-0.0512524359,
-0.7184699774,
0.5190953612,
-0.1417869478,
0.2866043448,
0.3372625709,
-0.168315798,
0.2009056956,
-0.4941036701,
-0.2540572882,
0.1028973982,
-0.7237261534,
-0.0683189183,
0.1541659832,
-0.2876119316,
0.4849559665,
0.3180578947,
-0.5963303447,
0.2049273103,
-0.72545892,
1.0377310514,
0.5306839347,
-0.2270025015,
0.743242085,
-0.0383818001,
0.7328048944,
0.3428530991,
-0.1899416298,
-0.4007187784,
-0.3227302432,
-0.5867660046,
-0.0423813947,
0.2112514675,
0.5568876863,
-0.8890528083,
0.5186570287,
-0.5025264025,
0.0542869233,
-0.6910938621,
-0.139263317,
0.3189559579,
0.308542937,
0.4009657204,
-0.2805351615,
-0.4904612601,
-1.0705502033,
-0.3815045059,
0.4864293039,
0.021049913,
-0.0846050233,
0.583466351,
-0.3014766276,
0.8024039268,
-0.4223606884,
-0.1849321127,
-0.4247450829,
-0.7125517726,
0.4123291671,
0.2101108134,
0.1146728173,
-0.5893716216,
0.0135774659,
-0.2509150505,
-0.7535621524,
0.2979361713,
0.1485318393,
-0.0868164748,
0.1867214292,
0.42366907,
-0.9753610492,
0.5931496024,
0.8045633435,
-0.2192398459,
-0.0173962489,
-0.174169153,
0.0353353918,
-1.1985682249,
0.1725272536,
0.0646759421,
-0.4006479084,
-0.6797830462,
0.2575430572,
0.4836208224,
-0.6014031768,
-0.4256126285,
0.0822267756,
-0.4092663229,
-0.4149735272,
-0.1859407872,
0.4434922636,
0.1761544496,
0.7560731769,
-0.2117371559,
0.5716205239,
0.0332462974,
-0.6004306674,
-0.0201874264,
0.6184222698,
-0.2444984019,
0.042949602,
-0.5854198337,
0.1874165237,
0.0728154555,
0.660941422,
-0.8662133217,
-0.2602365911,
0.309586823,
-0.272205323,
0.3677674532,
0.0543611869,
-0.5139191151,
-0.5626043081,
-0.1911751479,
0.6738702059,
0.3751583695,
0.0228699408,
0.268987447,
0.2499229908,
-0.0520811565,
-0.482814908,
-0.8563812971,
0.1459219754,
-0.1038934663,
-0.5007505417,
0.1457947344,
-0.0081859576,
0.2803031802,
0.1943619847,
-0.6100468636,
0.0544424467,
0.1375811845,
0.3854641616,
0.0221466944,
0.0136879822,
-0.0092608389,
0.2357144356,
-0.2337834835,
0.0053413231,
-0.4877272844,
0.3024147153,
-0.3090467155,
-0.1150486395,
-0.5227387547,
0.4850818515,
0.6465147138,
-0.3726953864,
0.4591834545,
-0.0421412438,
-0.5462172627,
-0.1556088626,
0.1111134663,
-0.0778287724,
-0.4563196599,
0.5403393507,
-0.3925948441,
-1.1748503447,
0.3320865035,
-0.0484785438,
0.1805059165,
0.6066461205,
0.2941999137,
-0.2341610789,
0.9430587888,
0.640448153,
0.1935748905,
0.4327041805,
-0.2471692115,
0.6320297718,
-1.0162549019,
-0.1507786214,
-0.3674902022,
-0.5555860996,
-0.5582023263,
-0.4637045264,
0.3848969042,
-0.2312874049,
0.0304834284,
0.8007826209,
-0.5206816792,
0.403455615,
0.2229046822,
-0.051936727,
0.0512597673,
-0.1358875185,
-0.1395853609,
-0.3886036277,
-1.014334321,
-0.4063647389,
0.6191613674,
0.3826885521,
0.5092223287,
0.1210609898,
0.6138464808,
-0.0616565868,
-0.2790772021,
-0.9853349328,
0.6291530728,
-0.3754012883,
-0.3941275179,
-0.4870536327,
-0.5533458591,
-1.1876444817,
0.3311675191,
0.1553941071,
-0.3168925643,
-0.0649604499,
0.3000618219,
-0.4725785255,
-0.0209239665,
-0.3480345905,
1.0463225842,
0.2094740123,
-0.0088952314,
0.1456897557,
-0.8744595051,
0.3512963355,
-0.0228194669,
0.3959671259,
-0.0068767164,
0.0562770627,
0.5364804864,
-0.6284373403,
0.6977104545,
0.1423376054,
-0.2308569402,
-0.0139565067,
0.2754022777,
0.3500367701,
-0.6326401234,
0.2883165181,
0.1373198032,
0.0168242957,
-0.4552121758,
-0.6356160045,
0.4289321601,
-0.4019797146,
-0.3972530961,
-0.4110480249,
-0.6660702229,
-0.0389561579,
0.2855265439,
0.5510673523,
0.5069358349,
0.1993253231,
0.1667472571,
0.6345764399,
-0.0827834383,
0.5783928037,
0.1232919618,
-0.0905961692,
-0.1617706567,
0.5845791101,
0.2434118241,
0.2212292105,
0.3130274713,
0.0194508284,
-0.4724004567,
-0.3597064018,
-0.6952232122,
0.2417166531,
-0.6278504729,
-0.2681072652,
-0.6431583166,
-0.2974037528,
-0.3724138141,
0.0565717444,
-0.4128823876,
-0.6760163903,
-0.1286257654,
-0.3494738638,
0.0811402202,
0.965243876,
0.4130138457,
0.2607855201,
-0.8604827523,
0.3809044361,
-0.2443983704,
0.33292678,
-0.4219079912,
-0.8678712249,
-0.5953179002,
-0.3286136687,
-0.5438181758,
-1.0306420326,
0.4770129323,
0.1920810789,
0.3182137907,
0.1823174208,
-0.0584112704,
0.8475269079,
-1.1568523645,
0.7705155611,
0.2115277499,
-1.0945874453,
0.7459668517,
-0.221511215,
0.8117587566,
-0.0011751428,
0.276954025,
-0.5190063119,
-0.8373468518,
-0.5665850639,
-0.8928951621,
0.6014267802,
0.3321301043,
0.0886784047,
-0.1505417079,
0.2705409527,
-0.1332388371,
0.3685368598,
-0.8153144717,
-0.0083628278,
-0.3508017361,
-0.418150425,
-0.1106240973,
-0.0706549361,
-0.1414639205,
0.1273463666,
0.2471256107,
-0.1270783693,
0.4154842794,
0.234065026,
-0.2161848396,
-0.241090402,
0.4274484515,
0.8976359963,
0.4845274687,
0.0421995521,
0.1730722934,
0.0916711986,
-0.1876710802,
0.0742172822,
0.0510730408,
-0.317489773,
0.1380461305,
0.2036779672,
0.9674294591,
0.7687450051,
-0.2199316174,
0.6038107276,
0.0798275471,
-0.3223953545,
-0.0718183741,
-0.1014751643,
0.1835612208,
0.2976690829,
0.0765811726,
0.5016643405,
0.3907322586,
-0.43581146,
0.0387715213,
-0.0027670918,
-0.5437648892,
-0.6347952485,
0.8994417191,
0.2009909004,
-0.3195198178,
0.373916626,
-0.0320915766,
-0.6720138788,
0.3572519124,
0.5997462869,
0.6069867611,
-0.242562592,
-0.2803161442,
0.2425884306,
0.5517181754,
-0.4408279955,
0.4461401701,
-0.1396124661,
-0.574156642,
-0.8294262886,
-0.5316357017,
-0.1844461113,
-0.1268332005,
-0.794844985,
-0.1449695528,
-0.3414017558,
-0.3974730074,
-0.266846925,
-0.3124995232,
-0.6506784558,
-0.0479511246,
-0.0645491108,
0.9321395755,
-0.8407760859,
0.7229539752,
0.4100010395,
-0.0943171084,
-0.7315998077,
-0.1888613403,
-0.0708031654,
-0.306594938,
0.3815473616,
0.4306491315,
-0.2836378813,
-0.000027441,
-0.5996362567,
-0.962035656,
0.9055355191,
0.4158901274,
-0.7946839929,
-0.1439924985,
-0.1517368257,
0.5071930289,
-0.0400927328,
-0.5219463706,
0.5775805116,
0.2035810947,
-0.2351555079,
-0.8318032622,
0.2687316239,
-0.3120769262,
0.2259946615,
0.6945149899,
-0.570753932,
0.6157118678,
-0.2429262996,
-0.6314442158,
0.0961707383,
0.5108233094,
0.2500075102,
0.0766759589,
0.2782621682,
0.7238802314,
0.4582195282,
-0.2359917611,
1.201795578,
-0.1220568419,
0.2439938635,
0.9175277352,
-0.3462719917,
1.0773005486,
0.6101875305,
-0.232421726,
0.4534962475,
0.5397534966,
0.0485186018,
0.578273654,
0.2619160116,
0.1913211942,
-0.1391722262,
0.4689132869,
-0.1889298409,
0.1717493981,
0.670932591,
-0.2321419567,
0.0019601283,
-0.090597406,
-0.1062755883,
0.121722877,
-0.0290907398,
0.596671164,
0.4830188453,
-0.6985655427,
0.3126806617,
0.0104644131,
0.1735657901,
-0.5384261012,
-0.0620929003,
-0.3343311548,
0.0639031529,
-0.2864474654,
-0.6701305509,
0.467533201,
0.127076596,
-0.2006721348,
-0.5997538567,
0.3614107966,
-0.4759416878,
-0.2199639827,
0.1471506357,
0.1788268387,
0.5684882998,
0.0316501707,
-0.2849607766,
0.1140766591,
-0.1191263422,
-0.2604060471,
0.0484335758,
0.8598693013,
-0.1521402299,
0.5219488144,
0.5881083012,
-0.0267999768,
0.4061479568,
-0.0641453639,
0.7750099301,
-0.9518755078,
-0.8496544957,
-1.0137399435,
0.4887955487,
0.1363522708,
-0.2337244004,
0.8114677668,
0.7154532671,
0.6388426423,
-0.2136095315,
0.7307965755,
0.2092932314,
0.317645371,
-0.5116646886,
0.3408271968,
-0.4644806087,
0.119211711,
-0.0219682287,
-0.9589595199,
-0.3478028178,
0.6335452795,
0.0506630354,
-0.2421482652,
1.0682727098,
0.433536768,
-0.0031472885,
-0.2421936244,
0.6703058481,
0.351950258,
0.017985452,
0.9866293073,
1.0346052647,
-0.705547452,
0.7986557484,
0.395352453,
0.0025390664,
-0.3098262846,
-0.7903981209,
-0.4874724448,
-0.6599532962,
-0.1927593201,
-0.4759049416,
-0.2558156252,
0.4986440241,
0.6765636802,
-0.5257138014,
0.0212426204,
0.1500418037,
-0.0373320654,
-0.1185946465,
-0.0772907957,
0.15994744,
-0.242157042,
-0.5819010735,
0.8536762595,
0.7624454498,
0.0547143333,
-0.0718108341,
0.0007515623,
0.176134631,
0.0927235857,
0.5632381439,
0.2374212295,
-1.0438324213,
-0.3148989081,
0.2562051713,
-0.3169477582,
0.2367096394,
0.9562036395,
-0.4930904806,
0.323115617,
0.2826774716,
0.6702282429,
0.7563787699,
-0.0683046058,
0.756750226,
-0.9935515523,
0.0428732634,
0.1076736078,
0.6599028707,
0.3498977423,
-0.2716673911,
0.3724107742,
0.2591515481,
-0.6395866275,
-0.6296595335,
0.5417011976,
-1.177918911,
-0.1799629778,
0.9412711859,
-0.1776934862,
-0.561342001,
0.0609949715,
0.0455081202,
0.397670716,
-0.4100888968,
0.5399631262,
0.8121660948,
-0.1204617694,
-0.1083555073,
-0.9073771834,
0.5321968198,
0.3162752688,
-0.5832914114,
-0.134613812,
0.525619626,
0.3222270012,
0.2116250545,
0.6934645176,
-0.2528828681,
0.2306689024,
-0.0440972745,
-0.0316986926,
-0.0867010057,
-0.4143224955,
-0.8687503338,
0.0328835249,
-0.2880517542,
-0.5515018106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14275v1 | What's in a Name? Evaluating Assembly-Part Semantic Knowledge in Language Models through User-Provided Names in CAD Files | 2023-04-25T12:30:01 | 2023-04-25T12:30:01 | Peter Meltzer, Joseph G. Lambourne, Daniele Grandi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cc:68T50, I.2.7; J.6 | Semantic knowledge of part-part and part-whole relationships in assemblies is
useful for a variety of tasks from searching design repositories to the
construction of engineering knowledge bases. In this work we propose that the
natural language names designers use in Computer Aided Design (CAD) software
are a valuable source of such knowledge, and that Large Language Models (LLMs)
contain useful domain-specific information for working with this data as well
as other CAD and engineering-related tasks.
In particular we extract and clean a large corpus of natural language part,
feature and document names and use this to quantitatively demonstrate that a
pre-trained language model can outperform numerous benchmarks on three
self-supervised tasks, without ever having seen this data before. Moreover, we
show that fine-tuning on the text data corpus further boosts the performance on
all tasks, thus demonstrating the value of the text data which until now has
been largely ignored. We also identify key limitations to using LLMs with text
data alone, and our findings provide a strong motivation for further work into
multi-modal text-geometry models.
To aid and encourage further work in this area we make all our data and code
publicly available. | [
-0.4202133417,
-0.5795443058,
0.8734849095,
0.2188029736,
-0.3018377423,
-0.0419762358,
-0.0414397381,
-0.665959537,
-0.0639798641,
0.6124122739,
-0.4584830999,
-0.6783006787,
-0.6410443187,
0.2608624697,
-0.6814354062,
0.6016334295,
-0.1747511923,
0.1059293449,
-0.4391449988,
0.0041304748,
-0.3651313186,
-0.6424825788,
-0.3103692532,
-0.044176843,
0.7770959735,
0.1977392733,
0.7093070149,
0.8466124535,
0.5362017155,
0.3502370119,
-0.0835530162,
0.2008240223,
-0.1697908342,
-0.0513017774,
-0.0970459059,
-0.1803011745,
-0.493637383,
-0.0972802863,
0.4609734118,
0.9115928411,
0.2757253051,
0.1455913335,
0.1697643846,
0.5499787331,
-0.5731763244,
0.6592198014,
-0.3272527158,
-0.0775574818,
-0.4518024027,
-0.0812978074,
-0.3440786898,
-0.2714511156,
0.1230672672,
-0.6962286234,
0.1087634936,
0.2280297428,
0.9436378479,
0.156414941,
-0.2920844853,
-0.4047404826,
-0.7407927513,
1.0069947243,
-0.7376769781,
0.7489706278,
0.5295168161,
0.2789417207,
-0.4394437373,
-0.5321053863,
-0.5927592516,
-0.2142070532,
-0.236841172,
-0.1343458593,
-0.2229843438,
0.4811969399,
0.1145807654,
0.384901017,
-0.4795390964,
-0.0303277541,
-0.5499556661,
-0.4364757836,
0.6525800824,
-0.0290465616,
0.6729813814,
-0.1037886217,
-0.534244597,
-0.1167549342,
-0.807464242,
-0.2608882785,
0.4161362052,
0.4939617217,
-0.0599054024,
0.6762855053,
-0.2687550485,
1.0088704824,
-0.3954048157,
-0.1238766983,
0.2496545613,
-0.1325772107,
-0.4543949366,
-0.0226683952,
0.6827406883,
-0.0458443835,
0.2173566967,
-0.6637467742,
-0.2187915295,
-0.1621908098,
0.1083165333,
-0.8134713173,
-0.4801400006,
-0.0518012419,
-0.4282429218,
0.1550516337,
0.0483884327,
-0.3061894774,
-0.5656678081,
-0.9256807566,
0.4232165813,
-0.2344813347,
-0.1024617702,
0.2222462445,
-0.3094124794,
0.1989753991,
0.4510479271,
-0.6510317326,
0.0300406069,
0.8908464909,
0.4984301925,
-0.4389333427,
-0.2598386407,
-0.3754006624,
0.1516876221,
-0.4788444638,
1.0452513695,
-0.6040462255,
-0.5886442661,
-0.2524973452,
0.2515581846,
0.0592604354,
-0.685793221,
0.4084241092,
-0.4833456576,
0.189071998,
-0.4225873947,
-0.6315637827,
-0.1932230741,
-0.0384583622,
-0.925868988,
0.7642440796,
-0.034243159,
-0.8354386687,
0.4297366142,
-0.3704469204,
-0.497289896,
-0.049928464,
-0.6580238342,
-0.0512582585,
0.2780821025,
-0.1590438187,
0.4647056758,
-0.4080623686,
0.0740750507,
-0.4292441607,
0.0219310988,
0.2271374911,
-0.0736143216,
0.5757418871,
0.2346105576,
0.1715697944,
0.0221906696,
-0.7511344552,
0.0084212674,
-0.1638295054,
-0.4302794337,
-0.4083888233,
0.0484613739,
0.1623235196,
0.1648966372,
0.3344449401,
-0.8762016296,
-0.0172502473,
-0.3650102615,
0.0724104568,
0.6086985469,
-0.3289975226,
0.3463385403,
-0.328114897,
0.6119288206,
0.0071220649,
-0.0071406732,
0.0029516758,
-0.5946936011,
-0.7624722719,
-0.2568771541,
0.5094073415,
0.0706206337,
-0.8954017162,
0.0224900525,
-0.0278865136,
-0.524640739,
-0.1944401413,
0.1899501532,
0.2528582513,
0.5178001523,
0.1990694106,
-0.3946115077,
-0.5830464363,
-1.1603964567,
-0.2416723669,
-0.2604246438,
-0.4374938011,
0.4374983311,
0.1849833876,
-0.1795486659,
1.1932410002,
-0.6150375009,
-0.3829918206,
-0.246415332,
0.4857703745,
0.0106249163,
0.1878947616,
0.4627050757,
-0.6627395749,
-0.176831007,
-0.038245216,
-0.6230431795,
-0.1445496082,
0.0168820843,
-0.4249446094,
0.0958979353,
0.5436804295,
-0.614305079,
0.5163286924,
0.5793344378,
-0.3550446033,
0.716897428,
-0.37111938,
-0.2431933731,
-1.123262763,
0.0952610672,
-0.1596731246,
0.0420917124,
-0.3256316483,
-0.1277540177,
0.0788643509,
-0.0454986095,
-0.6639460325,
0.9948689342,
-0.94718647,
-0.1338345557,
-0.5703961849,
0.3037237823,
0.0611660592,
0.3146626949,
0.2677859664,
0.7401528358,
0.5208619237,
-0.7139684558,
0.3721362948,
0.4156474769,
-0.5664529204,
0.3352231383,
-0.55634588,
0.1167726368,
-0.2848808467,
-0.2021145374,
-0.7353355289,
-0.2859447598,
-0.3030649126,
-0.2787844539,
0.1291155517,
0.0008138606,
-0.7954499125,
-0.2550886273,
0.0383375771,
0.5017248392,
-0.0445450097,
-0.6291838288,
0.7237861753,
0.9022957683,
-0.2596368194,
-0.2321160883,
-0.6463165283,
0.1718192697,
0.0234242175,
-0.6522622108,
0.6774955988,
-0.2688010931,
-0.1754215211,
-0.0320876762,
-0.3487779498,
-0.7368516326,
0.2037267685,
0.3617426753,
0.1939452887,
-0.2580738366,
0.7009910345,
-0.1668919176,
-0.2614674568,
0.169702664,
0.187324971,
0.2533717752,
0.1771659404,
-0.2252792418,
-0.3498409986,
0.3338705599,
0.4705310464,
-0.1248627827,
0.4213707149,
0.1297790557,
-0.5582001209,
-0.4747051299,
-0.1100190356,
-0.0970141292,
-0.47360906,
0.5092759728,
-0.4785359204,
-0.7212100029,
0.2916474342,
-0.1505758464,
0.1108862683,
0.4111348391,
0.2801768482,
-0.0181425884,
0.9559087753,
1.3325561285,
-0.3231081963,
0.2532878816,
0.1537390649,
0.5748910308,
-0.6381555796,
-0.0440005697,
-0.7668896914,
-0.3604304492,
-0.3309276402,
-0.529032886,
-0.005824721,
0.0907703862,
-0.1192427054,
0.8028929234,
-0.3993929029,
0.5075436831,
0.2186893672,
-0.0976492912,
0.6105290651,
-0.3443057835,
-0.0879658014,
0.0610258766,
-0.2935305834,
-0.6918681264,
0.8066159487,
0.2043994963,
1.0909079313,
0.0145891374,
0.4620178044,
0.2028821856,
0.2310139686,
-0.8755757809,
0.4665057361,
-0.3514415622,
-0.4433798492,
-0.1630480736,
-0.3131801784,
-1.2354303598,
-0.0572658293,
0.0003520568,
-0.5930235386,
0.1976110041,
-0.0591517724,
-0.4571966231,
0.1158475131,
-0.4666612744,
1.0075206757,
-0.5670242906,
0.2276556343,
-0.0999887809,
-0.1291667968,
0.1902151406,
-0.2145643085,
0.3036913574,
-0.426933974,
-0.1123286858,
0.8081419468,
-0.49336496,
0.6418347955,
0.2073689252,
-0.3224225938,
0.1015656516,
0.1018143445,
0.2261261046,
-0.2423685938,
-0.1065843105,
0.1969857812,
0.2324902862,
-0.0755406171,
-0.5892028809,
0.7444018722,
-0.4707212448,
-0.4557583332,
-0.0748600513,
-0.5534006953,
-0.4092544615,
0.4074531496,
0.0357555375,
0.620157063,
-0.1092851833,
0.4678470492,
0.4853375554,
-0.5376058817,
0.3110900521,
0.4967069626,
-0.451562494,
0.1313382238,
0.9536702037,
0.0542017259,
0.0372392684,
0.4484895766,
0.0125011634,
-0.1681749672,
-0.3228985071,
-0.599737823,
0.3114159107,
-0.5923428535,
-0.3439522088,
-0.6153751612,
-0.4478802681,
0.0187201891,
0.0956241488,
-0.4670979083,
-0.5011823773,
-0.3435644209,
-0.1057513207,
0.1844001412,
1.0759956837,
0.4272019267,
0.2424249351,
-0.8015012741,
0.2199712992,
0.2942471504,
0.6242679954,
-0.0733450055,
-0.0563107654,
-0.2624335587,
-0.0763896853,
-0.4348545074,
-0.7581124902,
0.3814681768,
0.1420125514,
0.8137560487,
0.1363077462,
0.1960475296,
0.4947159886,
-0.3026436865,
0.5232614875,
-0.0753787234,
-0.5816764832,
0.2288814634,
-0.1847056746,
0.4523245692,
0.3258064389,
0.267529428,
-0.3828072548,
-0.3426633477,
-0.3504934907,
-0.7789942026,
0.6863428354,
0.2890533209,
0.1213898063,
0.0156050054,
-0.0821568221,
0.1233958751,
0.2479989231,
-0.2833155692,
-0.2673232853,
0.3547716141,
-0.4094490707,
0.3767430484,
-0.1886025369,
0.0883952379,
-0.013750447,
0.5948994756,
-0.1581536084,
0.4278647006,
-0.0470139757,
-0.2567752302,
0.1893139631,
0.1195017099,
0.4483853877,
0.7355012894,
0.1274338663,
0.1601286232,
0.0212176368,
-0.3164420426,
-0.4479578137,
0.2292322218,
0.2225801498,
0.3127891719,
0.1585914642,
0.5105985403,
0.547257781,
-0.8035593629,
0.4581625164,
-0.3903914392,
-0.0005083553,
-0.2328404039,
-0.1549820751,
0.2479957342,
0.0845544115,
0.2230656594,
-0.2065248489,
0.2032229304,
-0.4113162458,
0.3239627182,
0.3841737509,
-0.3323377073,
-0.4931324422,
0.668882668,
0.1908212602,
-0.1797047108,
0.3633016646,
-0.0345247947,
-0.3479679227,
0.7965153456,
0.3352349102,
0.9659297466,
0.2295705676,
0.2204578072,
0.2260364145,
-0.092777364,
0.0677665472,
0.2357067764,
-0.2703638971,
-0.6470109224,
-0.5531100035,
-1.1209317446,
-0.4946253598,
0.1396358907,
-0.1967360228,
0.5947250724,
-0.4421143532,
-0.183348015,
0.2441138327,
-0.2122263759,
-0.8370357156,
0.167523995,
0.5392457247,
1.1117258072,
-0.442850858,
1.0423561335,
0.7420725226,
-0.3694534004,
-0.9013844132,
-0.1230833605,
0.0314976238,
-0.4881700277,
1.1333075762,
0.1176717207,
-0.1984934658,
-0.2555296421,
-0.1873322129,
-1.3873177767,
0.8054149747,
0.5975603461,
-0.2631604671,
-0.3505343199,
0.5391803384,
0.4397238791,
-0.2398647368,
0.3544954062,
0.2034234405,
0.6037035584,
0.1895715743,
-1.1096379757,
-0.2490248084,
-0.2627918422,
0.0673348382,
0.2391676903,
-0.3223212361,
0.8993671536,
0.1251299381,
-0.6431446671,
0.377933979,
0.8671824336,
0.137005657,
0.053354729,
0.3060213625,
0.3276436925,
0.8040072322,
-0.1662592888,
0.9508515596,
-0.629326582,
0.2958112955,
1.1957881451,
-0.0154591575,
0.7587694526,
0.2834909856,
-0.1250825524,
0.4911760688,
0.4715466499,
0.2376042306,
0.2888844311,
0.2697200179,
-0.0819861069,
-0.4663901329,
-0.1124715284,
-0.2265926152,
0.5716677308,
0.1948068142,
-0.4070764184,
-0.6751933694,
-0.0388420299,
0.0944628492,
-0.016742276,
0.0468341224,
0.6867147684,
0.3072887361,
-0.2005681992,
0.2352134436,
-0.0998901576,
0.3923467696,
-0.3818645477,
-0.1279123724,
-0.1536094695,
0.4139041901,
-0.1176142022,
-0.8498661518,
0.5430975556,
-0.1125263348,
-0.3352213502,
-0.3324266076,
0.4311254323,
-0.4416372478,
-0.7222675681,
0.365809828,
0.3979904652,
0.2625954449,
-0.3203695118,
-0.3512187004,
-0.0606159195,
-0.3105991483,
-0.0515696593,
0.4527454674,
0.664020896,
-0.1630312055,
0.6292698383,
0.3603321016,
0.141413033,
-0.0630493462,
0.0431318656,
0.8901740313,
-0.7237068415,
-0.1322220266,
-0.5349222422,
0.3927085102,
-0.1409751475,
-0.322278589,
0.9360415936,
0.8651821613,
1.0410009623,
-0.0985852033,
0.7838616371,
-0.0355169065,
0.6195762753,
-0.3893072903,
1.0805579424,
-0.5162608027,
0.205651015,
-0.1511532664,
-0.8547863364,
-0.419778496,
0.2032786161,
-0.3486094475,
-0.0441137627,
0.5827659369,
0.8950756192,
-0.1460912675,
0.2227988243,
0.4718057215,
0.2344867438,
0.3842994869,
0.351871103,
0.6413934827,
-0.2608125806,
0.4817733169,
-0.3111504316,
-0.1666024625,
-0.0340566486,
-0.9799854159,
-0.7688877583,
-0.7701450586,
-0.2735533416,
0.2416190207,
-0.1133376807,
0.6429065466,
0.8763315082,
-0.9157825708,
-0.2686553895,
0.0232753269,
0.1889457256,
0.1426181048,
-0.1186267734,
0.5640906096,
-0.459982425,
-0.7070037723,
0.586833775,
0.1567275524,
-0.0293844752,
-0.1837434769,
-0.0101439413,
0.2124466896,
0.1040036753,
0.7487971783,
0.3473961055,
-0.6956809759,
-0.1437808424,
0.1372366697,
-0.2700929046,
-0.0349872261,
0.815310955,
-0.8898730278,
0.7306802273,
0.7971445322,
0.7710048556,
-0.026361363,
0.2044703811,
0.8628978729,
-0.6616296768,
-0.0899385586,
0.0028196285,
0.6676797271,
0.3463579118,
-0.2667670548,
0.1926918626,
-0.0623457916,
-0.6628753543,
-0.4480606318,
0.067047447,
-0.893849194,
-0.4433753192,
1.1854759455,
0.0049829734,
-0.4981281161,
-0.2460810095,
-0.4978792667,
0.1106769294,
-0.2206003517,
1.0429550409,
0.6213904619,
-0.2253939062,
0.0861528143,
-0.75949049,
0.7594984174,
0.0050674262,
-0.8208811879,
0.3343785703,
0.4757253826,
0.1366992295,
0.1438958049,
0.1573532373,
-0.3110837936,
0.174536109,
-0.4766940773,
0.3295981586,
-0.1025024056,
-0.432403177,
0.1547702104,
-0.0672129989,
0.2887989879,
-0.1491808146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12764v1 | Test-Time Adaptation with Perturbation Consistency Learning | 2023-04-25T12:29:22 | 2023-04-25T12:29:22 | Yi Su, Yixin Ji, Juntao Li, Hai Ye, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Currently, pre-trained language models (PLMs) do not cope well with the
distribution shift problem, resulting in models trained on the training set
failing in real test scenarios. To address this problem, the test-time
adaptation (TTA) shows great potential, which updates model parameters to suit
the test data at the testing time. Existing TTA methods rely on well-designed
auxiliary tasks or self-training strategies based on pseudo-label. However,
these methods do not achieve good trade-offs regarding performance gains and
computational costs. To obtain some insights into such a dilemma, we take two
representative TTA methods, i.e., Tent and OIL, for exploration and find that
stable prediction is the key to achieving a good balance. Accordingly, in this
paper, we propose perturbation consistency learning (PCL), a simple test-time
adaptation method to promote the model to make stable predictions for samples
with distribution shifts. Extensive experiments on adversarial robustness and
cross-lingual transferring demonstrate that our method can achieve higher or
comparable performance with less inference time over strong PLM backbones and
previous state-of-the-art TTA methods. | [
-0.1753604263,
-0.7398257852,
0.4822885394,
0.4266991019,
-0.2902385294,
0.2592607737,
-0.1694820076,
-0.1265755892,
-0.2735772729,
0.3947656155,
-0.4597894847,
-0.3205567002,
-0.6627149582,
-0.0501282252,
-0.2163692266,
0.7856805921,
-0.2552209496,
-0.2760274112,
0.3371476233,
-0.0478768162,
-0.703627646,
-0.5142335892,
-0.6100907922,
-0.0143027343,
0.1151335537,
0.2535554767,
0.8235153556,
0.4819642901,
0.1636842191,
0.2092244923,
0.0067110481,
0.1224710718,
-0.761877358,
0.0915018022,
-0.0623451918,
-0.6581403613,
0.0492069274,
0.1529288292,
0.8927938342,
0.4519997835,
-0.1953422278,
-0.0479049236,
0.0254557859,
0.2399404347,
-0.8376453519,
0.1844144762,
-0.9043247104,
0.2410648912,
-0.0700829476,
-0.3585169017,
-0.508495748,
-0.2174678594,
0.336940527,
-0.9739688635,
0.0006463958,
-0.1350446343,
0.8690821528,
0.3474269509,
-0.337539494,
0.1823436022,
-0.916435957,
1.0332410336,
-0.6457169056,
0.4791671932,
0.3856901526,
0.3619427085,
-0.319214493,
-0.4885108173,
-0.7227914333,
-0.2234977037,
0.1524789333,
0.1955061257,
0.3952756226,
-0.1615077108,
0.1007046327,
-0.0244380943,
-0.2970886827,
0.2570590079,
-0.0118856365,
-0.1320007592,
0.5055631399,
-0.0815317929,
0.1156890392,
0.118797034,
-0.6709135175,
-0.7073481679,
-0.8657128811,
0.4103240669,
0.3607240915,
0.3768185377,
-0.2488618791,
0.2372546792,
0.5072325468,
0.5197059512,
0.2514475882,
-0.010148976,
0.0896826163,
-0.2573338151,
-0.3057145476,
0.1814785749,
0.6668293476,
-0.1086010337,
0.1219799668,
-0.0530097075,
-0.1874608994,
0.0539113171,
0.1752905697,
-0.5825362206,
-0.3851168156,
0.0336925872,
-0.2668203115,
-0.3198174238,
0.1990220398,
-0.8483983874,
-0.4010512829,
-0.0505752712,
0.724514246,
-0.2843710184,
-0.3138899207,
0.3133828044,
0.1735111773,
0.4401981533,
0.1268044412,
-0.7574065924,
0.2555799484,
0.3878964782,
0.7314255834,
-0.2750153542,
-0.4563829601,
-0.8617943525,
0.0864330828,
-0.5930158496,
0.7904757261,
-0.4067227244,
-0.6002424955,
-0.2349421531,
0.2327881157,
-0.2170567811,
-0.4538994133,
0.140664652,
-0.4413270652,
0.3169813156,
-0.2419415861,
-0.2851122022,
0.0600311048,
0.1415895969,
-0.4891563058,
1.1468700171,
0.3580234945,
-0.5491163731,
0.3985461891,
-0.6401329041,
-0.3367966413,
-0.2556221485,
-0.0434692279,
-0.7663727403,
-0.0055549336,
0.2199663371,
0.0483977944,
-0.0087713031,
-0.0146333184,
-0.4106683135,
-0.580801487,
0.4804096818,
-0.3227374852,
0.8862282634,
0.1447423697,
-0.680388093,
0.0015470589,
-0.4342175722,
-0.1111675799,
0.0010518291,
-0.3341535926,
-0.3611910045,
0.407998085,
-0.0516701229,
0.1700613499,
-0.0387499258,
-0.3220334947,
0.3074285388,
-0.5279833674,
0.1596052796,
1.2778042555,
-0.0605295263,
0.3016753197,
-0.1497631818,
0.6227498055,
0.2181848884,
0.2402637154,
0.2549009323,
-0.1309654266,
-0.5484730601,
0.0695465505,
0.6838942766,
0.6434592009,
-0.6114753485,
0.3885670304,
-0.1499049813,
-0.2475837022,
-0.4977307916,
0.2372558564,
0.249854818,
0.4594702721,
0.5738905668,
-0.3931107521,
-0.7721824646,
-0.2347572744,
-0.3504446745,
-0.4724063277,
-0.1184397116,
0.1563802212,
0.0355320461,
-0.2628269792,
0.8126847148,
-0.3124068379,
-0.2562821805,
-0.0868201032,
0.1472809911,
0.0789060444,
0.3720912039,
0.8172690868,
-0.8965419531,
-0.7996873856,
-0.0097647011,
-0.3108469546,
-0.2088479996,
-0.2590031922,
0.0119509157,
0.2280455381,
0.4574181736,
-0.0791066661,
0.2867613435,
1.0472121239,
-0.5951141119,
0.609900713,
-0.0534633286,
-0.0879341736,
-1.0180616379,
-0.1744579524,
-0.1011235937,
-0.4772352874,
-0.4187791348,
-0.356064111,
-0.0081803435,
0.0103866328,
-0.5630716085,
0.6151192784,
-0.2581829727,
-0.0148247369,
-0.3216318786,
-0.1408441067,
-0.24997814,
0.028081445,
0.0515279695,
1.0390014648,
0.6337127686,
-0.6543030143,
-0.1743774861,
0.2795774043,
0.2216729522,
0.1031318232,
-0.4607019722,
0.3956677318,
0.0865117833,
0.1962669343,
-1.2170863152,
0.2807730436,
0.1389003694,
-0.1174607575,
0.4664687812,
-0.1425443441,
-0.1213525981,
0.0507210307,
-0.4179578424,
0.4593233168,
0.741828382,
-0.7025553584,
0.7103135586,
0.2854143381,
-0.0386852212,
-0.7868919373,
-0.5718542337,
-0.1725639403,
-0.2031960785,
-0.0652214661,
0.6204391122,
-0.1774185598,
-0.0309127588,
-0.1324491352,
-0.5306779742,
0.0390190445,
0.3155019581,
0.1973499209,
0.1993500143,
-0.122424975,
0.029052617,
-0.2088408023,
-0.1127296984,
-0.1110028476,
-0.4305791259,
0.4756147265,
-0.062935546,
0.1427646577,
-0.4102357626,
-0.1367451251,
0.3374529183,
0.059441939,
0.7810195088,
0.6197045445,
-0.0717960149,
-0.3414016962,
-0.3098578453,
-0.3661113977,
-0.4852464795,
0.2060743868,
-0.5800681114,
-0.5564348698,
0.4895460308,
-0.3146724999,
-0.0149741992,
0.4733780921,
0.3136161566,
-0.3146213591,
0.7914072275,
0.9173102975,
-0.2368859798,
0.6920390129,
-0.2769292295,
0.0643128604,
-0.4773590863,
0.2083390653,
-0.4390771985,
-0.4033471048,
-0.6547101736,
-0.3440341949,
0.3686803281,
0.0875172839,
-0.2522140443,
0.2752040923,
-0.1280958503,
0.3594363034,
0.2154531479,
0.0315013267,
0.0639923066,
0.1157047376,
0.0298903305,
-0.1012478918,
-0.5550575256,
-0.216229558,
1.3189053535,
0.2896083891,
0.7080279589,
0.0270010568,
0.3228499293,
0.3302102983,
0.3693713546,
-0.3180947304,
0.2497211248,
-0.5962228775,
-0.2583557963,
-0.5049434304,
-0.465572685,
-0.980822742,
0.0378868468,
-0.2029977292,
-0.4732905626,
0.556825757,
0.1935846508,
-0.4000134766,
0.3775314093,
-0.6523933411,
0.8835197687,
-0.4220990241,
-0.1546108425,
0.1184399948,
-0.7004445195,
-0.0348057225,
-0.1999622881,
0.0580247752,
-0.0031959785,
-0.1771898717,
0.4991891384,
-0.0789086446,
0.7714540958,
-0.4586367309,
-0.1950443834,
0.1613131613,
0.2695293427,
0.7797575593,
0.1096057445,
-0.054564707,
0.0116449269,
0.1657306105,
-0.7102137208,
-0.6377800107,
0.515755415,
-1.2722001076,
-0.4770817757,
-0.4610762298,
-0.6452195644,
-0.4578515887,
0.0273479745,
0.1735949814,
-0.1687363088,
-0.0488779917,
0.1254642457,
0.8452750444,
-0.1845131665,
0.5128781796,
0.4801472723,
-0.169356674,
-0.1629531384,
0.7353729606,
0.2147584856,
0.4463268518,
0.4460126162,
0.4182608426,
-0.6693766117,
-0.8634443879,
0.0678819641,
0.140175283,
-0.3203178346,
-0.0139079075,
-0.2927182317,
-0.1406458914,
-0.368252188,
-0.134936139,
-0.6367229223,
-0.2696914971,
-0.2694796026,
0.0764945075,
0.0926307589,
0.3094574511,
0.2423337698,
0.5209708214,
-0.4143199921,
0.4369985163,
0.4316165447,
0.3122371733,
-0.6809896231,
-0.7051451802,
0.1472588927,
-0.0389641672,
-0.5109738708,
-1.0113190413,
0.2169520408,
0.4234978855,
0.2549321353,
0.2549413145,
0.3072663546,
0.6516308784,
-0.0404341668,
0.6860563755,
-0.1139704213,
-1.1533918381,
0.4748702049,
-0.079599157,
0.2136973143,
0.3788380325,
0.4367304146,
-0.3185516,
-0.1518671364,
-0.5398947001,
-0.64722085,
0.373488903,
0.0726463795,
-0.0854434595,
0.3527917862,
0.4632773399,
0.4329394102,
-0.0092761703,
-0.8066935539,
-0.1471558064,
-0.6563275456,
-0.1081536487,
-0.5572654605,
-0.2496535182,
-0.0082835769,
-0.064814426,
0.6140105724,
-0.4897926152,
0.0917685032,
0.3593212068,
-0.1886008531,
-0.2329022735,
0.3673945367,
0.5514947772,
0.7996368408,
-0.508698523,
0.2763759494,
0.3437924683,
-0.5708284378,
0.6999613047,
0.4510888457,
-0.176939249,
-0.1467707902,
-0.0453469008,
0.7662197948,
0.0953668281,
-0.6055836082,
0.305351913,
-0.1366470754,
-0.1833446175,
-0.1592635512,
0.0861437619,
-0.2819711566,
0.163224414,
0.5690100193,
-0.0055394149,
-0.3252230287,
-0.5081475377,
0.124355562,
0.2854588926,
-0.3057105243,
-0.5795152187,
0.6573180556,
-0.1767818779,
-0.1854406595,
0.4507149756,
-0.1102701798,
-0.4935396016,
0.4684283435,
0.7518690228,
0.8711026907,
-0.7261812687,
0.4098619223,
-0.1127851009,
0.3707617819,
-0.1512420177,
0.4886599481,
0.3238948286,
-0.75032866,
-0.7673776746,
-0.4316346645,
-0.3185709119,
0.4150797427,
-0.1250410974,
0.2144916058,
-0.760997355,
-0.0790261775,
-0.3793928623,
0.1811101735,
-0.6182308793,
0.161078468,
-0.1878117621,
0.7083175182,
-0.9569319487,
0.9351703525,
0.7450425625,
0.1119064391,
-0.9101837277,
0.294470191,
-0.2476891279,
-0.3545471132,
0.3242330849,
-0.1232057437,
0.1126048788,
0.1517011821,
-0.3046576679,
-0.7971891761,
0.9957922101,
0.9579417706,
-0.8387258053,
0.0255727004,
0.0503478833,
0.4669217765,
-0.26736027,
-0.0457416661,
0.5440867543,
0.5223410726,
-0.291010499,
-0.9826414585,
0.1719674319,
0.2150727212,
0.2042191476,
0.1467847377,
-0.6851078272,
0.915322423,
-0.022249857,
-0.3943467438,
-0.1893842518,
0.6572020054,
0.4151719213,
0.0539494567,
1.0223405361,
0.484624505,
0.6317471266,
-0.2233904153,
1.1769824028,
-0.0623715259,
0.7234048247,
0.9839781523,
-0.3717571795,
0.8456367254,
0.7115817666,
-0.6548188925,
0.5021691918,
0.8040575385,
0.1564767957,
0.7883893251,
0.093962118,
-0.0942329168,
-0.3039250374,
0.0217347052,
-0.5567132831,
0.4220323563,
0.2344703525,
-0.1718195975,
-0.1043074057,
-0.0781112239,
-0.3171546161,
0.0329430588,
-0.0880041346,
0.5621103644,
-0.1259204,
-0.6077737212,
0.8769161105,
-0.2317958027,
0.4942201972,
-0.6315931678,
0.0230400991,
-0.0703054816,
0.3271876574,
0.0988118947,
-0.4261628389,
0.0326358378,
-0.6302497983,
-0.0180646293,
-0.1491871178,
0.5752035379,
-0.4840528071,
-0.3066810668,
0.3884404302,
0.2051969469,
-0.2669104636,
0.0282413252,
-0.7788030505,
0.2436954677,
-0.07585302,
-0.1450380683,
0.4189839065,
0.0774385259,
0.0059229084,
0.5443127155,
0.6584332585,
0.3811697066,
0.487863481,
-0.2420496494,
0.5846209526,
-0.4979726672,
-0.5694985986,
-0.6663613319,
0.3145175874,
0.3775295019,
-0.1077399179,
0.5784412026,
0.203637138,
0.8824022412,
-0.1707616895,
0.9154414535,
0.2104426771,
0.185871169,
-0.7281557918,
0.3504839242,
-0.2220319211,
0.4272692204,
-0.1798543632,
-1.0382336378,
-0.2048390061,
0.5173267722,
-0.3057494462,
0.0580056906,
0.7236707807,
0.5892957449,
-0.2674506903,
-0.2768048644,
0.0695633143,
0.7099986672,
0.6307860017,
0.7624367476,
0.7598224878,
-0.6738558412,
0.4059391916,
-0.3185555041,
-0.0951314792,
-0.1016782001,
-1.0867578983,
-0.6055814028,
-0.4453398883,
-0.4524333179,
-0.59853369,
0.5769920349,
0.7395777106,
0.9321405292,
-1.1013798714,
-0.2822445035,
-0.4220457375,
0.0476713143,
-0.7272152305,
-0.2792096436,
0.6098582745,
-0.6100791097,
-0.7696062326,
0.6208562851,
0.1056910753,
0.4792286158,
-0.3603775799,
-0.2086024731,
-0.427351892,
0.0209663119,
0.2073291093,
0.5668333769,
-0.4649852812,
-0.4160847962,
-0.135537684,
0.3498446047,
0.2071638852,
0.8009847999,
-0.9132328629,
0.7542694211,
0.3777053654,
1.0976699591,
0.6591930389,
0.2015178651,
0.8880503178,
-0.822191298,
0.3297325075,
0.162391156,
0.0208035186,
0.1079802737,
-0.4448134899,
0.415997684,
0.4231835306,
-0.5211662054,
-1.034860611,
0.0472058244,
-0.798012495,
-0.3575960994,
0.9479326606,
-0.3357584476,
-0.2013517022,
-0.2144900113,
-0.1301071346,
0.2892811,
-0.1515705138,
1.3266413212,
0.6824249625,
-0.0021425174,
-0.3414293826,
-0.2132391036,
0.7533193231,
0.7745737433,
-0.8203564882,
-0.1007107645,
-0.0996847525,
0.6470884085,
0.0838060677,
0.3998631239,
-0.0450786129,
0.384860903,
-0.3532499671,
-0.3867326975,
0.065646179,
-0.5137857795,
-0.3885930181,
0.3125540316,
0.2896376252,
-0.3321167231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12730v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12730v2 | CitePrompt: Using Prompts to Identify Citation Intent in Scientific Papers | 2023-04-25T11:19:52 | 2023-05-03T11:47:55 | Avishek Lahiri, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal, Imon Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Citations in scientific papers not only help us trace the intellectual
lineage but also are a useful indicator of the scientific significance of the
work. Citation intents prove beneficial as they specify the role of the
citation in a given context. In this paper, we present CitePrompt, a framework
which uses the hitherto unexplored approach of prompt-based learning for
citation intent classification. We argue that with the proper choice of the
pretrained language model, the prompt template, and the prompt verbalizer, we
can not only get results that are better than or comparable to those obtained
with the state-of-the-art methods but also do it with much less exterior
information about the scientific document. We report state-of-the-art results
on the ACL-ARC dataset, and also show significant improvement on the SciCite
dataset over all baseline models except one. As suitably large labelled
datasets for citation intent classification can be quite hard to find, in a
first, we propose the conversion of this task to the few-shot and zero-shot
settings. For the ACL-ARC dataset, we report a 53.86% F1 score for the
zero-shot setting, which improves to 63.61% and 66.99% for the 5-shot and
10-shot settings, respectively. | [
-0.1658076644,
-0.3210563362,
0.9977933168,
0.2823610008,
-0.2277910411,
-0.3180531263,
0.0414551906,
-0.121911563,
0.0719056726,
-0.3087271452,
-0.3019309342,
-0.4471592903,
-0.6954771876,
0.5619914532,
-0.106173642,
0.9965181947,
0.1332988292,
0.208918646,
-0.3892565072,
-0.0690083802,
-0.3655311167,
-0.2156466097,
-0.4039750993,
-0.2015907615,
0.9848923087,
0.4414363503,
0.1707754284,
0.3252184987,
0.3746855557,
0.0925526395,
-0.0673300102,
0.0540296845,
-0.2205620706,
0.4775990844,
-0.4482145905,
-0.2860417068,
0.0896928683,
0.3965940475,
0.4736321867,
0.6738102436,
0.4689715207,
0.2656549215,
-0.078547731,
0.2924178243,
-0.7362514138,
0.1943681091,
-0.3614639938,
-0.2987301052,
-0.31035918,
-0.7248575687,
-0.9858071804,
-0.3587051928,
0.0059552491,
-0.7042201161,
0.2082942575,
0.311478883,
0.5791432858,
0.081473209,
-0.3949385285,
-0.2850185931,
-0.3002121747,
0.7699020505,
-0.2898224592,
0.1586877853,
0.290389806,
0.1281550676,
-0.2593764365,
-0.9053652287,
-0.3950702548,
-0.3186117411,
-0.355045408,
-0.0483232923,
-0.330806762,
-0.0848708153,
0.5816342831,
-0.2276325822,
-0.862190485,
-0.1993756741,
-0.3779938221,
-0.2544127107,
0.4309966564,
-0.1365331858,
0.1610979438,
-0.3415935636,
-0.3234109879,
-0.0586790331,
-0.7364640236,
0.2976191044,
-0.0477601252,
0.6860170364,
0.3773151636,
0.6342597604,
0.0392549075,
0.661088109,
0.2661252916,
0.0544094294,
0.0061853882,
-0.2159053534,
0.0317647755,
0.5122249722,
0.7422765493,
-0.0332416929,
0.3600516021,
-0.0486194268,
0.2013871223,
-0.3212340176,
-0.0268811043,
-0.9108960629,
-0.3101454973,
0.2349411696,
-0.4630943239,
0.0076202094,
0.1956101507,
-0.2755405307,
-0.4984237552,
-0.4319342673,
0.1466084123,
-0.5344914794,
0.0513533689,
-0.4275229871,
-0.2857638896,
0.1293448657,
0.773070991,
-0.6381546855,
-0.2426082939,
0.5278455019,
1.135915041,
-0.1435253918,
-0.444147706,
-0.8726351857,
-0.028367253,
-0.1045857966,
1.2055448294,
-0.8223485947,
-0.521330595,
-0.188750878,
-0.1134647056,
-0.4814695418,
-0.1315235794,
0.6882867217,
-0.4881113768,
0.3960018158,
-0.6613143086,
-0.6143214107,
-0.1364836842,
0.1923454851,
-0.4624759555,
0.7345366478,
0.2734721005,
-0.9725049138,
0.6207793951,
-0.9493210912,
-0.391304642,
0.5121666789,
-0.0061634006,
0.005487612,
0.1352128237,
-0.1705386937,
0.4257458746,
0.045364473,
0.6574887633,
-0.3448505402,
-0.2644986212,
0.3702728152,
-0.1673050076,
0.9880393744,
0.4491882324,
-0.2091524303,
0.2386978716,
-0.5931920409,
-0.0846381038,
-0.1295548677,
0.1200975105,
-0.7046167254,
-0.2263783216,
-0.0511631295,
0.243342042,
0.0576235093,
-0.6779548526,
0.4983285666,
0.0908054933,
0.1561529487,
0.4591706693,
0.348896265,
0.4247525334,
-0.2329348326,
0.5705797076,
-0.2370662838,
0.0897647738,
-0.455770582,
-0.7944114208,
-0.1661904007,
-0.4606480598,
0.2530876398,
0.4037132561,
-0.4557380378,
0.2843909264,
-0.1913431287,
-0.3658267558,
-0.1484690905,
-0.1491356194,
0.1714437008,
0.7877981067,
0.5954180956,
0.1397732794,
-0.5029928684,
-0.2976160049,
-0.3416207433,
-0.6025515199,
-0.0217263643,
0.4045291841,
0.703319788,
0.2862989604,
1.2400301695,
-0.4212347567,
-0.1353128403,
-0.2115697563,
0.5801498294,
0.2874243259,
0.4785699248,
0.712915659,
-0.8101641536,
-0.6187482476,
-0.2401941717,
-0.8456971645,
-0.4761931002,
-0.1665293574,
0.0886234343,
-0.2188395411,
0.5245934129,
-0.6461846232,
0.3078821003,
-0.1762879789,
-0.7975491881,
0.882948935,
0.1119816005,
0.2334060073,
-0.5522393584,
0.6677219868,
0.132274583,
-0.0120917419,
-0.7138015032,
-0.2054024488,
0.1617271155,
-0.2671913207,
-0.6641420126,
0.8565397859,
-0.3604515791,
0.3692239225,
-0.3764656484,
-0.2872128487,
0.2079007924,
0.0724710971,
0.3700238168,
0.8153548241,
0.4767870009,
-0.717954576,
-0.0066888807,
0.4047209322,
0.0064014019,
0.868334651,
-0.6914098263,
-0.0110828429,
-0.3018178344,
0.3786790669,
-0.7275486588,
-0.2328358889,
0.3186197281,
-0.6195157766,
0.4501018524,
-0.3200564086,
-0.2409079522,
-0.0922084376,
-0.3716033697,
0.3875836432,
0.0970432684,
-0.5936427712,
0.4156175852,
-0.3768059015,
-0.454346329,
-0.6618583798,
-0.1350764036,
0.0148923583,
-0.2703094482,
-0.2628706396,
0.2929090559,
-0.2049429864,
-0.3381235301,
-0.0606566072,
0.0708311126,
0.1089029387,
-0.0233826227,
0.46313712,
0.308252573,
-0.1610733718,
0.3546357155,
0.1359361857,
-0.1513007581,
0.1232315153,
-0.2366644591,
0.3832494318,
-0.0059433943,
-0.3118827939,
-0.4676324725,
0.576987505,
0.6246492267,
0.001467834,
0.5999383926,
0.3119289279,
0.0427434295,
-0.036285691,
-0.1824633479,
-0.2049628049,
-0.4088609517,
-0.2074242383,
-0.3694768846,
-0.5586797595,
0.3566067517,
-0.311350137,
0.1097351983,
0.3481968939,
0.1072960198,
-0.2934571505,
0.6837381124,
0.4186327755,
0.235803619,
0.5907220244,
-0.0795757174,
0.2001692355,
-0.8111920357,
-0.5317154527,
-0.9343908429,
-0.1672764868,
-0.1945836246,
0.0241806749,
0.3024897277,
0.1369811445,
-0.4967533946,
0.265876621,
-0.6075353622,
0.3686186373,
0.6365293264,
-0.16834189,
0.1766454279,
-0.1224455386,
-0.1889227927,
-0.0976758599,
-0.6730567813,
-0.6743778586,
0.9251411557,
0.0010358758,
0.4522376359,
-0.2027768791,
0.8335677385,
0.4349170029,
0.2966465354,
-1.0506967306,
0.4264854193,
0.3127347827,
-0.5578705072,
-0.2749361992,
-0.2195742726,
-1.1616613865,
0.1391983479,
0.0247974247,
-0.5140389204,
0.8810602427,
0.2230786681,
-0.4746752679,
-0.2642934024,
-0.7930274606,
0.9183573723,
-0.3078397214,
-0.4925539196,
0.3810628951,
-0.5945526361,
0.2668482363,
0.1666473001,
0.0549163297,
-0.1125880703,
0.1632803828,
0.8866868019,
-0.1562602669,
0.6132218242,
-0.7812568545,
0.4414644539,
0.3584916294,
0.0372961387,
0.6578758359,
0.1731735915,
-0.2370443791,
-0.0898229256,
-0.0897219032,
-0.358001709,
-0.6715858579,
0.6598703265,
-0.3209860623,
-0.5331072211,
-0.9079388976,
-0.4737191498,
-0.0961897671,
0.3736557961,
0.6011421084,
0.3123683035,
-0.1830981821,
0.1692127734,
0.6529029608,
0.1278729439,
0.6028195024,
0.7113898993,
0.134376049,
0.0836811736,
0.7178428769,
0.056919992,
-0.1683165431,
0.1400996447,
0.2914834321,
-0.6088070273,
-0.7774487734,
-0.3035879135,
0.2536620498,
-0.921566844,
-0.5523833036,
-0.6499986649,
0.007649235,
-0.6901376843,
-0.2447085381,
0.264801383,
-0.5194583535,
-0.7851820588,
-0.0186003223,
0.4486502707,
0.3076295555,
-0.0056408835,
0.1489817351,
-0.4951117337,
-0.107944876,
0.1517204195,
-0.031587597,
-0.2477053702,
-0.7282950878,
0.1885650307,
-0.387470156,
-0.1496192515,
-0.9300014377,
0.4580676854,
0.5400043726,
0.7919542193,
0.6455219984,
0.5577428341,
0.3258410394,
-0.4242783785,
0.8728093505,
0.2324041128,
-0.5626128316,
1.1141668558,
-0.2113830447,
0.2815481424,
1.1736800671,
1.069791913,
-0.1983110458,
-0.1276311278,
-0.7287170291,
-0.7032278776,
0.6326873302,
-0.1205861121,
-0.2845330536,
-0.1964109689,
0.332570672,
0.3128239512,
-0.1117946357,
-0.7482864261,
-0.2140952945,
-0.6301674247,
-0.3171797097,
0.0788398683,
-0.1152988896,
-0.2243743837,
-0.3822892308,
0.6506086588,
-0.4696700573,
0.2902240753,
0.4995936751,
-0.3507345617,
0.095421426,
0.5355386734,
0.8510658741,
0.8497181535,
-0.2251375616,
0.4904455543,
-0.437654376,
-0.5784319639,
0.2358671278,
0.1882014722,
-0.6687548161,
0.3225044906,
0.5444592834,
0.6742790341,
-0.0096870037,
-0.522131443,
0.7304006815,
-0.0174829084,
-0.1667250991,
-0.0821715593,
0.166032061,
-0.3837490082,
0.0198033378,
0.8294817209,
0.2486530691,
0.4647812247,
-0.4877775908,
0.0626118034,
0.4340232909,
-0.3324289918,
-0.5196012259,
0.4208926558,
0.0999541655,
-0.1484965682,
0.3962974846,
-0.6443043947,
-0.4707682133,
0.2270831168,
0.6652356386,
0.7746360302,
-0.309114188,
0.5493021607,
0.7951325178,
-0.0231983364,
-0.0827210024,
0.1646155566,
-0.4960105121,
-0.2793008387,
-0.2743718028,
-0.6320520639,
-0.3522492945,
0.0665748045,
-0.6002609134,
0.2814797461,
-0.4464336336,
-0.100280188,
0.4198504984,
0.0654227659,
-0.3723926246,
-0.0461131521,
-0.1686710268,
1.0481450558,
-1.3300127983,
0.8338643312,
0.8114927411,
-0.4588038325,
-0.6332982183,
-0.1909302622,
0.1197484136,
-0.3688715398,
1.0866959095,
0.3486601412,
-0.0580100231,
0.2004299164,
-0.9264960885,
-0.8224696517,
1.0171767473,
0.4792765379,
-0.2644527853,
0.2486447394,
-0.4240584373,
0.2990219593,
-0.5531750917,
0.4903201759,
0.2869896293,
0.8662897944,
0.56001091,
-0.583656311,
0.2467847764,
-0.6189436316,
-0.3204322159,
-0.1318184584,
-0.0679486543,
0.5750547051,
-0.546739161,
-0.4364315569,
-0.1796386242,
0.6385672092,
0.7657122612,
1.0574526787,
0.285441041,
0.0068626204,
1.0491002798,
-0.2224489152,
0.9067794681,
0.0194085836,
0.0071465019,
1.00928092,
-0.516938746,
0.6967042685,
0.802539587,
-0.1373661309,
0.7891013026,
0.729290843,
-0.1524776071,
0.7752516866,
-0.1658602655,
-0.3212525547,
-0.1698489189,
-0.5154487491,
-0.4330657721,
0.2029671371,
0.4951310456,
-0.5523163676,
-0.2899624407,
0.3780907989,
0.0927112326,
0.0459696501,
-0.3558998406,
0.5636206269,
0.0980157629,
-0.9086846709,
0.4850269556,
-0.5759102106,
0.5184400082,
-0.5665627718,
-0.0385317095,
-0.1095869839,
-0.310338974,
-0.5406148434,
-0.7328927517,
0.1459370553,
0.2115451545,
-0.4951187968,
-0.4395529628,
0.8020398617,
-0.012697082,
-0.2719346881,
-0.1944490671,
0.2787830234,
0.4043830931,
-0.1616833061,
-0.4591858387,
-0.1367699504,
-0.334415555,
-0.3120867312,
0.4948733747,
0.3822989762,
-0.1430587173,
0.4000842273,
0.8239716291,
0.0976695195,
0.0244833156,
0.0970487595,
0.6048138738,
-0.5403141975,
-0.4372545779,
-0.6140159369,
0.2480242997,
-0.3224163651,
-0.4857935905,
0.8607273698,
0.6206293702,
0.2573534548,
0.0085461289,
0.746075511,
-0.4130603671,
0.4351343215,
-0.2841887176,
0.4287186861,
-0.0791190118,
0.211730659,
-0.1398724616,
-0.6462880373,
-0.6515879631,
0.6671312451,
-0.551794529,
0.1372848153,
0.9541471004,
0.4080762267,
0.1169715151,
0.1548893899,
-0.0271722879,
-0.2536694705,
0.2688307166,
0.2634005547,
0.8340395689,
-0.0479306541,
0.3302143812,
-0.098734729,
-0.4999906123,
-0.4127494395,
-1.066647172,
-0.5811398625,
-0.5521308184,
-0.5287747383,
-0.1954352707,
-0.1466640085,
0.8742791414,
0.5146484375,
-0.9999377131,
0.3279816508,
-0.2532291412,
0.0485171676,
-0.3776087463,
-0.267931968,
0.6916381717,
-0.755961597,
-0.4657476544,
0.6682309508,
0.2988874614,
0.0982576013,
0.1701408774,
-0.1765897721,
-0.4816563725,
-0.0765611753,
0.6748518348,
0.8576349616,
-0.4378960133,
-0.3503615856,
0.5433371067,
-0.10566888,
-0.032239981,
1.196762085,
-0.9705067873,
0.4147922397,
0.6910077333,
0.1744425744,
0.348338604,
0.232947126,
0.2419743836,
-0.6996754408,
-0.0230398327,
0.7008658648,
0.4415366352,
0.3431257904,
-0.545263648,
0.3426995873,
0.2976576984,
-0.6996244788,
-0.9777310491,
-0.0267868675,
-1.3100808859,
-0.4473261535,
1.1362961531,
-0.5306870341,
-0.2309041321,
-0.6643542051,
-0.0852853507,
0.0775199607,
-0.5434314609,
0.6016398668,
0.4293988049,
-0.6948229671,
-0.3407489061,
-0.0381379016,
0.5005810261,
0.1742168814,
-0.6662209034,
0.1762844026,
0.6221465468,
0.0758945718,
0.6097394228,
0.5565752387,
-0.0122902524,
0.7709928751,
-0.1874941736,
-0.1824977398,
-0.531621933,
-0.6348181367,
-0.2620334625,
0.6247977614,
0.2933285236,
0.060127072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12706v1 | What does BERT learn about prosody? | 2023-04-25T10:34:56 | 2023-04-25T10:34:56 | Sofoklis Kakouros, Johannah O'Mahony | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models have become nearly ubiquitous in natural language processing
applications achieving state-of-the-art results in many tasks including
prosody. As the model design does not define predetermined linguistic targets
during training but rather aims at learning generalized representations of the
language, analyzing and interpreting the representations that models implicitly
capture is important in bridging the gap between interpretability and model
performance. Several studies have explored the linguistic information that
models capture providing some insights on their representational capacity.
However, the current studies have not explored whether prosody is part of the
structural information of the language that models learn. In this work, we
perform a series of experiments on BERT probing the representations captured at
different layers. Our results show that information about prosodic prominence
spans across many layers but is mostly focused in middle layers suggesting that
BERT relies mostly on syntactic and semantic information. | [
-0.2965613604,
-0.7936190367,
0.6336066127,
0.292626828,
-0.2838760316,
-0.460847795,
-0.1497816443,
-0.6594734192,
0.2428236902,
0.2225347012,
-0.3391852081,
-0.4637010098,
-0.70829916,
-0.2306072563,
-0.236346975,
1.1742717028,
0.3370877206,
0.2268552035,
0.0436807349,
0.3066029251,
0.0471160263,
-0.8160399795,
-0.4573872983,
-0.0506077632,
0.4791837037,
0.2384563088,
0.8512781262,
0.1227388158,
0.3358163238,
0.2494774014,
-0.2741711736,
-0.199761644,
-0.2741600871,
0.4729178548,
-0.0124151632,
-0.532674551,
-0.3509933949,
0.1674228907,
1.2223250866,
0.96728158,
0.2614820302,
0.0708239824,
0.3230678737,
0.4890165031,
-0.3961739838,
0.5390058756,
-0.5079295039,
-0.1772735864,
-0.3151014149,
-0.0110700633,
-0.4823955297,
-0.2691893876,
0.5786781907,
-0.2330285907,
0.5886938572,
-0.1008976549,
0.7508223653,
-0.1513766497,
-0.3291721642,
-0.4761401117,
-0.6777479649,
0.7747747302,
-0.5744881034,
0.5463857651,
0.5453243256,
0.2214491963,
-0.164435938,
-0.4259930253,
-0.5401815772,
-0.5876739621,
-0.2398211956,
-0.1139603853,
-0.1845842749,
0.2542949021,
-0.0537525192,
0.0363767669,
-0.2448130399,
-0.0890707672,
-0.3567804396,
-0.1063483581,
0.6069533825,
-0.420842886,
0.2318349183,
-0.5320695639,
-0.3942354918,
-0.1883165091,
-0.3363706768,
0.4247773588,
0.5273417234,
0.5700810552,
0.0920673385,
0.358836174,
0.4882196486,
0.5797482729,
-0.2541160882,
0.0928815603,
0.0890420377,
0.0653802902,
-0.1800951213,
0.2717802227,
0.485317409,
-0.2714909911,
0.4619560838,
-0.3376499414,
-0.3185137808,
-0.5167789459,
0.4324054122,
-0.3928819299,
-0.5026420951,
0.1587115079,
-0.3353977799,
-0.0580412261,
0.2259397507,
-0.1067688763,
-0.1209606156,
-0.1851207763,
0.473192364,
-0.774433136,
-0.5235068798,
-0.1291533113,
-0.3123459518,
0.3291068971,
0.0369696356,
-1.2079238892,
0.3811264336,
0.6460625529,
0.7243036628,
0.367560178,
-0.16871804,
-0.12742275,
0.051805187,
-0.4781970382,
0.6379473805,
-0.8108401299,
-0.3596236706,
0.0165475085,
0.1933153719,
-0.3837786019,
-0.3988020122,
0.4377447069,
-0.5115443468,
-0.2981323302,
-0.6293590665,
-0.7319180965,
-0.3431458771,
-0.0920444354,
-0.8380252123,
0.7353131175,
-0.0843251646,
-0.7028543949,
0.1675234139,
-0.2176643312,
-0.3128702044,
-0.0669190064,
-0.1463743299,
-0.3485391736,
0.8002020717,
-0.1490871459,
0.6832199693,
0.2236412019,
0.2282060832,
-0.1051779687,
-0.4209027886,
0.3718158305,
-0.0436717942,
0.5643553734,
-0.1112333834,
-0.1065456048,
-0.0241438951,
-0.8130173683,
-0.0819768831,
0.0264069866,
-0.3136892319,
-0.5908725262,
0.1307235807,
0.0707766414,
-0.2692496479,
0.1643698812,
-0.7429358363,
0.1558806449,
-0.171351701,
0.5020042658,
0.7156860232,
0.1376253963,
0.3938995004,
0.0679936036,
0.1797635108,
-0.1937497258,
-0.1012118682,
0.1502985805,
-0.6880785227,
-0.6089516878,
-0.2898150384,
0.5255835652,
0.0965066925,
-0.0491002761,
0.1944616437,
0.2168766558,
-0.3790097833,
-0.864580512,
0.0703627318,
0.4534166157,
0.2849194109,
0.2978728414,
-0.2639037371,
-0.4387619495,
-1.2353593111,
-0.1425697953,
-0.3982652426,
0.0267472211,
0.2743614614,
0.4615221918,
0.2129125595,
0.8899382949,
-0.1261562407,
-0.3757664859,
-0.6123037338,
0.6727669239,
0.3153367639,
0.4926118851,
0.9315590262,
-0.5031483173,
-0.1801252663,
-0.2942189574,
-0.5221530199,
-0.0665755197,
-0.0572075211,
-0.2904666662,
-0.0268417541,
0.2958720922,
-0.6946053505,
-0.0222923029,
0.6276765466,
-0.2047335058,
0.9030133486,
-0.4670282602,
-0.3951121867,
-0.3762205839,
0.1769265234,
-0.0430106409,
-0.0069626393,
-0.8206212521,
-0.2336357981,
0.0944759026,
-0.1079232246,
-0.3417904079,
0.2345241755,
-0.6441677809,
-0.6748711467,
-0.1754317582,
-0.0064757848,
0.0069874581,
0.5530798435,
0.3638118505,
0.7061017752,
0.6107882857,
-0.6373661757,
-0.210040763,
-0.030160727,
-0.4701305628,
0.0864632204,
-0.8731268048,
0.2708034515,
-0.3077156544,
-0.058709953,
-1.4104075432,
-0.1751248986,
-0.2972733676,
-0.585949719,
0.4788718522,
-0.1833649129,
-0.7942509651,
0.1301333755,
-0.0700227544,
-0.1438046694,
0.5747759342,
-0.0775939599,
0.4725235701,
0.5994613767,
-0.3236599565,
-0.4134400487,
-0.4056322873,
-0.3595066369,
0.4212899208,
-0.447059989,
0.2643856704,
0.4729558527,
-0.3113983274,
0.1408237517,
-0.2119010687,
-0.145950675,
0.2332766354,
0.1982054561,
0.0383543298,
-0.1540533006,
0.5155633688,
0.0546302088,
-0.0103101833,
0.4759563506,
-0.1407074779,
0.6452571154,
-0.3377090096,
-0.2046889514,
-0.6278169751,
0.374296248,
0.4828117788,
-0.0000096017,
0.9886078238,
0.6818553805,
-0.1756295562,
-0.2333135456,
-0.2170255482,
-0.2948137224,
-0.3372900784,
0.6312419772,
-0.4916577339,
-0.4484272599,
0.6696526408,
0.2456968576,
0.1375620365,
0.3606607318,
0.2235016972,
-1.0151957273,
1.2252874374,
0.8816300035,
0.0507155471,
0.570264101,
-0.5728496313,
0.039041061,
-0.7885727882,
-0.325954169,
-0.5358333588,
-0.6211876869,
-0.356802851,
-0.1065110415,
0.4595007896,
0.4572632313,
-0.1073236093,
0.2294510603,
-0.2065495104,
0.2626287341,
0.7489024997,
0.1451540887,
-0.1432591528,
-0.1542669833,
-0.1253135949,
-0.3503952026,
-0.5143707395,
-0.5269950032,
0.6768346429,
0.5816294551,
0.556908071,
0.2847544253,
0.5856642723,
0.1303779781,
-0.0597215779,
-0.5944577456,
0.6005331278,
-0.3965921104,
-0.5178028941,
-0.2046451718,
0.1913058162,
-0.9397857785,
0.3239905834,
-0.1109152883,
-0.5370511413,
0.460688442,
0.2979848087,
-0.20132792,
0.1467902362,
-0.9213074446,
0.7065019011,
-0.2643348575,
-0.1725132912,
-0.3158622086,
-0.7269818187,
0.0283527076,
0.3442798257,
0.108830303,
-0.0842337385,
0.2900258899,
0.8575041294,
-0.2267036438,
1.299431324,
-0.6817904115,
-0.2864751518,
0.3060658276,
0.4051908553,
0.4085118473,
-0.1923905164,
0.1471246481,
0.312648803,
-0.2942334414,
-0.4153511822,
-0.5278779864,
0.3066405356,
-1.0206357241,
-0.4989411831,
-0.1026708409,
-0.6139424443,
-0.2716677785,
-0.2683676183,
0.0708510652,
0.488752991,
-0.1321566403,
0.4614805877,
0.7977709174,
-0.0636041686,
0.2790529728,
0.3419461548,
0.0234507248,
0.2588326037,
0.8526960611,
0.5114411712,
0.413901031,
0.3892402947,
0.0141118467,
-0.2713293135,
-0.5268723965,
-0.0683950707,
0.5844882131,
-0.7042412162,
0.4081868231,
-0.6362046599,
-0.4506337345,
-0.5107358694,
-0.003732207,
-0.3145921826,
-0.5503308773,
-0.2653529644,
-0.229521662,
0.1697696447,
0.7555143237,
-0.1002249047,
0.437780261,
-0.9247985482,
0.0482519232,
0.5688212514,
-0.0165807046,
0.180572778,
-0.3353580236,
-0.2145426869,
-0.3086010516,
0.0118463105,
-1.2722760439,
0.4146360457,
0.6468501091,
1.0670568943,
0.3084868193,
-0.1947557181,
0.3180173635,
-0.3989039958,
0.9913598299,
-0.1374671012,
-1.0943088531,
0.9829008579,
-0.116560474,
0.2579272687,
0.2395971417,
0.7630553842,
-0.2070122212,
-0.7646509409,
-0.8434439898,
-0.8180877566,
0.6516039371,
0.2081262916,
0.2077760845,
-0.251927942,
0.2284242362,
0.3360652328,
0.3008345664,
-0.567629993,
0.2573495209,
-0.0979506671,
-0.1080038473,
-0.0265572686,
-0.7576211691,
0.0357569978,
-0.1985646188,
0.2400435656,
0.1082062721,
0.5438927412,
0.3167062998,
-0.5974255204,
0.2970169187,
0.2705335319,
0.2456036061,
0.4763824642,
-0.7069453597,
0.6367166638,
-0.2529762387,
-0.8167307973,
-0.2694569826,
-0.1555147171,
0.0691520572,
0.5559580326,
1.0707131624,
1.0305947065,
0.6024721265,
-0.4835645854,
0.3296353519,
0.3832950592,
-0.3461765945,
-0.2553462684,
0.2345801294,
-0.0421135575,
0.4907223284,
0.4385012686,
-0.0945880935,
0.1092351377,
-0.9306442738,
0.0984552354,
0.3954315186,
-0.5812231302,
-1.048384428,
0.4014129937,
0.0969708189,
-0.0137480684,
0.8673089147,
-0.0024508142,
-0.6701790094,
0.5361717343,
0.5540527105,
0.8365330696,
-0.4099787176,
0.3093835413,
0.2369086593,
0.1624095887,
0.3708863556,
0.7070372105,
-0.6758652329,
-0.8821588755,
-0.2399344444,
-0.606210053,
-0.4647219181,
0.0540289134,
-0.8293213248,
-0.0719345436,
-0.5662446022,
-0.3973530829,
0.2003787011,
-0.1045333818,
-0.4805532098,
0.0151286833,
0.4201173782,
0.763476193,
-1.0875233412,
1.0631507635,
0.7841743827,
-0.5791180134,
-0.6313130856,
0.0584855415,
-0.2015973032,
-0.9644315243,
1.4945733547,
0.2412591428,
-0.2749412656,
0.1083595306,
-0.770827055,
-0.7021127343,
0.5633485317,
0.427654773,
-0.4888360202,
-0.2406547517,
-0.0082383687,
0.7136391401,
-0.368727386,
0.3085982502,
0.7337914705,
0.2743295431,
-0.0962023288,
-1.0287692547,
-0.2890585363,
-0.2356835008,
0.1263082027,
-0.1796418875,
-0.3258828521,
1.3214998245,
-0.3976876736,
-0.390969485,
-0.4016141593,
0.4711589515,
0.3488116264,
-0.3881971538,
0.5400035381,
0.1771196574,
0.7607781887,
0.0165310651,
1.1049537659,
-0.2372875512,
0.3056466877,
0.7309675217,
-0.1656989902,
1.0175782442,
0.3195006847,
-0.2002059221,
0.7197367549,
0.5543248653,
0.3160658479,
0.8954501152,
0.0193801727,
0.0594979748,
-0.4180960655,
-0.0443862341,
-0.1710624844,
0.3588959277,
0.6313415766,
-0.6163398027,
-0.1845720708,
0.1355406493,
0.022477027,
-0.2316957116,
-0.1487800628,
0.791126132,
0.0003536605,
-0.2440728098,
0.6192991138,
-0.360673815,
0.1462227106,
-0.8053022027,
-0.1995397359,
0.0014836504,
0.2875131071,
0.1071961224,
-1.084005475,
0.2818055749,
-0.2991464734,
-0.3539607525,
-0.4221707284,
0.7499426007,
-0.4141366482,
-0.0572049581,
0.4212380946,
0.337043047,
0.6315646172,
-0.1284356266,
-0.4252615571,
0.0766692385,
-0.1663250327,
-0.2953056097,
0.2085197419,
0.4318571687,
-0.0139223933,
0.3448534012,
0.3742984235,
0.4913717508,
0.2053670287,
0.5491480231,
0.7006797791,
-0.7309381366,
-0.6044636369,
-0.6225681901,
0.5445930362,
-0.0858107582,
-0.1836590171,
0.679132998,
0.11143177,
0.7613397241,
-0.1919568181,
0.6948196292,
0.108329609,
0.5547620058,
-0.7120663524,
0.5381720066,
-0.163164705,
0.0981464162,
-0.0801833346,
-1.1277297735,
0.0073415446,
0.9256436825,
-0.5271548033,
-0.2707306445,
0.4979812801,
0.2401936501,
0.1175194457,
0.3524537981,
0.0887044445,
0.6110826135,
0.29001683,
0.2491317391,
0.7911807299,
-0.0702698156,
0.1173489466,
-0.0275461003,
-0.2422173321,
-0.3863788545,
-0.3831526637,
-0.6926093698,
-0.8902439475,
0.10891518,
0.0292208791,
0.2314936668,
0.5961872935,
0.8365384936,
-0.8657795787,
-0.300552398,
-0.0661591589,
-0.1050748155,
-0.4457131028,
-0.1982083172,
0.7094897628,
-0.9670236707,
-0.781229794,
0.3687112033,
-0.0783004984,
0.2166676223,
-0.4592740238,
0.1995480508,
-0.2068736553,
-0.003112342,
0.4932923019,
0.0055289306,
-0.6417349577,
-0.4055654407,
0.1399641931,
0.0224686358,
-0.1472779363,
0.952193141,
-0.7312112451,
0.503115952,
0.7303177118,
0.2770934403,
0.357955724,
-0.13140589,
0.6087117791,
-1.6215361357,
0.3580011129,
0.2536099553,
0.3388542831,
0.1622173935,
-0.3103316128,
-0.0762120038,
0.2976215482,
-0.2889078557,
-0.8486534953,
0.1394590884,
-0.8085721731,
-0.5537576675,
0.9796439409,
-0.2184255272,
-0.4152108133,
-0.1772056073,
-0.218611598,
0.2108976245,
-0.240186885,
0.4232475162,
0.9536668658,
-0.5157214999,
-0.3694426119,
-0.8944284916,
0.4989338219,
0.4521567822,
0.180713892,
0.0910868794,
0.1579979807,
0.0699306354,
0.4375784695,
0.6403556466,
0.0504971854,
0.0630205646,
0.0129812229,
0.2085906267,
0.0268681031,
-0.7311649919,
-0.0387101434,
0.3350153565,
0.0784973875,
-0.4864224195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12674v1 | Compressing Sentence Representation with maximum Coding Rate Reduction | 2023-04-25T09:23:43 | 2023-04-25T09:23:43 | Domagoj Ševerdija, Tomislav Prusina, Antonio Jovanović, Luka Borozan, Jurica Maltar, Domagoj Matijević | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, 62M45, I.2.7; I.2.0; I.5.3 | In most natural language inference problems, sentence representation is
needed for semantic retrieval tasks. In recent years, pre-trained large
language models have been quite effective for computing such representations.
These models produce high-dimensional sentence embeddings. An evident
performance gap between large and small models exists in practice. Hence, due
to space and time hardware limitations, there is a need to attain comparable
results when using the smaller model, which is usually a distilled version of
the large language model. In this paper, we assess the model distillation of
the sentence representation model Sentence-BERT by augmenting the pre-trained
distilled model with a projection layer additionally learned on the Maximum
Coding Rate Reduction (MCR2)objective, a novel approach developed for
general-purpose manifold clustering. We demonstrate that the new language model
with reduced complexity and sentence embedding size can achieve comparable
results on semantic retrieval benchmarks. | [
-0.4617717266,
-0.7249126434,
0.6934916377,
0.0683173239,
-0.5048888326,
-0.1540876031,
-0.2788622975,
-0.1736358702,
0.1524783969,
0.2724716365,
-0.329756856,
-0.3628644943,
-0.9728312492,
0.0055442494,
-0.4610987306,
0.6628726125,
0.1762131006,
0.0382559188,
-0.4411567152,
0.1370223463,
-0.4283518791,
-0.7914355993,
-0.1915933192,
-0.1999233961,
0.362411499,
-0.0104716206,
0.4121799767,
0.4640831947,
0.8428121209,
0.3582689762,
-0.1901917905,
0.0737824813,
-0.5602679849,
-0.0717074275,
0.1412706226,
-0.4831073582,
-0.1070482209,
0.1359137297,
0.7411622405,
0.7968111634,
-0.3767220974,
-0.0025159121,
0.124366127,
0.6339107752,
-0.6418915987,
0.2554510236,
-0.8256873488,
0.0296645742,
0.144003123,
-0.2032866031,
-0.7403435707,
-0.2368554324,
-0.0078375787,
-0.2830227911,
0.3091309071,
0.0599866919,
0.610332787,
0.5176554322,
-0.6715254188,
-0.2893849313,
-0.6717732549,
0.8855664134,
-0.6273071766,
0.2220849693,
0.1662767529,
0.4203505218,
-0.1850295067,
-0.7168791294,
-0.6735640764,
-0.2649059892,
-0.2828601003,
-0.1600067914,
-0.5146331191,
0.1489428878,
0.2847837508,
0.2653425634,
-0.5455797911,
-0.0237722993,
-0.4837828279,
-0.0727879182,
0.3333003223,
-0.227840811,
0.0359411426,
-0.4386758208,
-0.3715505898,
-0.281637907,
-0.4650884569,
-0.2605430186,
0.3007101119,
0.1908106506,
0.3610098362,
0.7139463425,
0.0488138311,
0.7679840922,
-0.0896943212,
0.1490301788,
0.3074349761,
0.1032472849,
-0.2819262147,
0.1906042844,
0.5370621085,
0.5765714049,
0.1181722805,
-0.1734306067,
-0.0014461013,
0.4854204953,
0.5123812556,
-0.9033536315,
-0.0693231225,
0.0460379012,
-0.643017292,
0.016593175,
0.2473526448,
-0.559276998,
-0.0753043517,
-0.2963024974,
0.1839880943,
-0.4516731799,
-0.058884237,
0.2274499685,
-0.2958363593,
-0.01311222,
0.0983973518,
-0.5595602393,
0.3958068192,
0.6295542121,
0.9186366796,
0.0926285684,
0.122500889,
-0.7114933133,
0.2535172999,
-0.1851506531,
0.6943301558,
-0.6873409152,
-0.4530476928,
-0.0766645744,
-0.2109846324,
0.0503423735,
-0.6462291479,
0.7496216893,
-0.4646635354,
0.1156603098,
-0.0553398095,
-0.9207804799,
-0.1714146584,
0.0582018942,
-0.7338690162,
0.6779319048,
0.1847762316,
-0.7326827645,
0.4170619249,
-0.3259199262,
-0.3639900982,
-0.127355054,
-0.0029476422,
-0.3539502323,
0.5884133577,
0.4479793906,
0.5858688951,
-0.1585197151,
0.302197814,
-0.2687830329,
-0.564273417,
-0.0605372116,
-0.2973238528,
0.4331043959,
0.5648893118,
-0.0015355698,
-0.3191188872,
-0.6997441053,
-0.0139068617,
-0.062213745,
-0.4367682338,
-0.5848922133,
0.2080052644,
0.075400427,
0.1641478539,
0.214422375,
-0.7062958479,
0.3165034652,
-0.3334419131,
0.7484126091,
0.3938458264,
-0.2122562528,
0.4882033467,
-0.1090664268,
0.09485659,
0.2323106676,
-0.1231248453,
-0.0360331573,
-0.3534429669,
-0.7100530863,
-0.3268360198,
0.2058436424,
0.2839652598,
-0.6943504214,
0.7030605674,
-0.5597776771,
-0.2515183389,
-0.7263467312,
0.0106052933,
0.326707691,
0.2103398591,
0.6435452104,
-0.1740870178,
-0.7121323347,
-0.9773262143,
-0.1356144249,
-0.2799091637,
-0.2556452155,
0.0638051927,
0.3271543086,
-0.1163292825,
0.9058129191,
-0.6481066346,
-0.4255805612,
-0.4815528989,
0.3858214915,
0.4099349082,
0.7575772405,
0.5575416088,
-0.9598956108,
-0.4912380576,
-0.2809534669,
-0.4751276374,
-0.0603027567,
0.2247935534,
-0.1046705246,
0.3162248731,
0.6016080976,
-0.7196599841,
0.6602402329,
0.7796811461,
-0.2007261664,
0.2020618916,
-0.6773031354,
0.2282353044,
-1.0979669094,
0.0286476109,
0.0710151196,
-0.4863193333,
-0.4423833191,
0.1059247777,
0.0626494214,
-0.1158935726,
-0.2707063556,
-0.0157027319,
-0.6151487827,
-0.0534353629,
-0.3201954961,
0.0861220211,
0.0984181687,
0.4483466744,
0.12182758,
0.6054158211,
0.1911605746,
-0.6112871766,
0.2612394989,
0.3511399925,
-0.7427887321,
0.4002839029,
-0.9044784307,
0.1686229855,
-0.3539061248,
0.4849400818,
-0.9265645146,
0.0082810018,
-0.4290950596,
-0.3204651773,
0.3403279483,
-0.277566582,
-0.7501746416,
-0.6213610768,
-0.2008841187,
0.2996461093,
1.0680189133,
-0.4772019386,
0.2968683243,
0.3047227263,
-0.0487200581,
-0.3379509747,
-1.1897583008,
0.0699545369,
-0.088161625,
-0.5049284101,
0.6694641113,
0.0997756794,
-0.024499597,
0.1054413915,
0.0692391768,
-0.1045137718,
-0.2513000071,
0.0140486723,
0.1543795764,
0.0336176492,
0.2454005033,
0.3196820617,
-0.1661311686,
-0.0919843912,
-0.3506588042,
0.6907433271,
0.1390935481,
-0.3854438663,
-0.4698571563,
0.7539530993,
0.332729429,
-0.1118988097,
1.1217530966,
0.5280075669,
-0.2054926604,
0.099144794,
-0.7538399696,
-0.0289325323,
-0.4007744193,
0.4689189196,
-0.3681254387,
-1.1374567747,
0.2003891468,
-0.1005515978,
-0.3391802311,
0.4488266408,
0.451905489,
-0.0893894657,
1.1926846504,
0.6533439755,
-0.2381348312,
0.4073420167,
-0.3207992315,
0.3869949579,
-0.8045966625,
-0.1802569926,
-0.7514188886,
-0.4056929052,
-0.6169794798,
-0.7365052104,
0.5328240991,
0.2819013894,
-0.1490528286,
0.4051651657,
-0.7112308145,
0.4449685216,
0.6662032008,
0.2927204072,
0.244086355,
0.3709757328,
-0.1849404573,
-0.037332762,
-0.708404243,
-0.4642445445,
0.8119630218,
0.151994884,
0.5917703509,
0.3345049024,
0.7094048262,
0.3473328948,
-0.1484872699,
-0.4294089079,
0.4845797718,
-0.7111611366,
-0.4838004112,
-0.0524859242,
-0.741253078,
-0.7963252068,
0.2300072461,
-0.1261942834,
-0.8515369296,
0.1427132338,
0.0517145023,
0.034220431,
0.2798170149,
-0.9040039778,
0.680131495,
0.4082177281,
-0.0346317366,
-0.4747928977,
-0.653824985,
0.1262816042,
0.2600471079,
0.1507893056,
0.0251609217,
0.1638492197,
0.4434466958,
-0.8159003854,
0.5108551383,
-0.5905324221,
0.1355971545,
0.4352317452,
0.034982942,
0.6866347194,
-0.3058653474,
-0.226363197,
-0.1184097081,
0.0815188661,
-0.5765944123,
-0.7205725908,
0.6828733683,
-0.600541234,
-0.514128387,
-0.264845401,
-0.4477005899,
-0.1059684753,
-0.1159439832,
0.3129547834,
0.5251345038,
-0.2143842876,
0.4592189193,
0.4466614425,
-0.360622406,
0.4734375179,
-0.0057014097,
-0.2888732553,
-0.1301641017,
0.5372028351,
-0.0706748217,
0.2198574692,
0.6927177906,
-0.0234311111,
-0.5430247188,
-0.7117801309,
0.05509758,
0.0754556954,
-0.653529942,
-0.1067559049,
-0.8112688661,
-0.1354411989,
-0.7231944799,
-0.0386882462,
-0.1609224528,
-0.5195629597,
-0.1826555431,
-0.1297674924,
0.1984537244,
0.5681530237,
-0.1009163931,
0.5266325474,
-0.9778895378,
0.1956400424,
0.120886378,
0.2069317251,
-0.0893226191,
-0.4179165661,
-0.1497615129,
0.0385148115,
0.0011881434,
-0.4723665118,
0.5443757176,
0.4320921004,
0.4558873773,
0.0810495615,
0.1897016168,
0.8630308509,
-0.7714254856,
0.7643632889,
0.409550488,
-0.9369001985,
0.6836537123,
-0.0196450688,
0.3697739542,
0.5357334614,
0.4022560418,
-0.240067929,
-0.3007026315,
-0.3194117546,
-0.7274015546,
0.4488594234,
0.4056690037,
0.3465910554,
-0.3747580051,
0.3346596062,
0.0341337919,
0.2909452915,
-0.4689557254,
0.0622856319,
-0.0242855567,
-0.3437557518,
-0.47936064,
-0.6640828252,
0.3134327233,
-0.3535533845,
0.4352557957,
0.0531197116,
0.7444804311,
0.3509262204,
-0.4505566061,
0.2886824012,
0.3272053003,
0.2368344814,
0.2505250871,
-0.4464705586,
0.3178041875,
-0.1210292652,
-0.4198960662,
0.1667699665,
0.2101804614,
0.151619792,
0.2287528366,
0.5250456333,
0.8445866108,
0.0405046754,
-0.4783852398,
0.6499577761,
-0.0459278487,
-0.1314272434,
0.0111313453,
-0.0973891169,
-0.0366220102,
0.2254159451,
0.4004370868,
0.012224555,
0.4225808382,
-0.5653312206,
0.2618964612,
0.2776865363,
-0.2954041958,
0.0675285831,
0.5551390052,
0.0943119004,
0.1168884709,
0.8817001581,
-0.2094884515,
-0.5177695751,
0.3744083643,
0.4389304221,
0.599219799,
-0.0502027608,
0.2873516381,
0.4411592484,
0.1846130192,
-0.1402856261,
0.053437639,
-0.1667300314,
-0.4465763569,
-0.7533880472,
-0.7961697578,
0.12904419,
-0.3746648431,
-0.8943728209,
-0.0402251147,
-0.101447247,
-0.3430149555,
-0.1566143334,
-0.0101096677,
-0.5253127813,
0.0611799508,
0.1016113982,
0.844931066,
-0.3657670915,
0.9672648907,
0.4827297628,
-0.3668674231,
-0.6736754775,
-0.1653346866,
-0.2671751976,
-0.4632256925,
0.9311969876,
0.3610831499,
0.0865633786,
0.0371935442,
-0.4839937687,
-0.5186423659,
0.9378272295,
0.7348962426,
-0.9271453023,
-0.1653602719,
0.3274256885,
0.5856969953,
-0.5059589148,
0.1405985355,
0.4780987203,
0.2071151286,
0.4442916512,
-0.887422502,
-0.0474696867,
-0.2450736016,
0.5967220068,
0.2367282808,
-0.2196434736,
0.9340949655,
0.0885643065,
-0.2311020643,
0.2393116355,
0.6380251646,
0.1366712749,
0.0802930444,
0.4816678762,
0.8594614863,
0.6280285716,
-0.2063235641,
1.3110803366,
-0.1533723921,
0.6811057925,
1.0337455273,
-0.3344961703,
1.0938147306,
0.7793000937,
-0.4006543159,
0.6882764101,
0.3049519658,
0.2235593647,
0.9195060134,
0.444229126,
-0.1668980271,
-0.2178761214,
-0.0615082085,
-0.3424549401,
0.2712317109,
0.0750327855,
-0.4538626373,
-0.1674319059,
0.1989317387,
-0.1091231033,
0.369841516,
-0.2752053142,
0.7528284192,
0.0180537067,
-0.5582219958,
0.5365424752,
-0.0768479332,
0.6658194661,
-0.4321858883,
-0.130227387,
-0.0833127648,
0.3827315569,
0.0012937218,
-0.363026619,
0.452568233,
0.2058551162,
-0.263441354,
-0.200267747,
0.6517148018,
-0.5489481688,
-0.8444955945,
0.4259119034,
0.2493159771,
0.30286026,
-0.277539283,
-0.3409081697,
0.2348231524,
-0.1467943341,
-0.082945779,
0.2172127664,
0.489602834,
0.4890155196,
0.5086911321,
0.5281122923,
0.1590801626,
0.211347118,
0.146405533,
0.9970287085,
-0.4519274533,
-0.6139855385,
-0.8260735273,
0.4856491089,
-0.3281088173,
0.2658124268,
0.3847875893,
0.529430747,
0.7441909313,
-0.2261866927,
0.6937702894,
-0.2888613939,
0.6267530918,
-0.8276622295,
0.5204980373,
-0.5840207338,
0.3047614396,
-0.3716066778,
-1.3163100481,
-0.3761705458,
0.8844561577,
-0.2598601878,
0.1149729043,
0.8723933101,
0.6344327927,
-0.0832285956,
-0.2338771671,
0.4314434826,
0.2621777058,
0.4584787786,
0.7867571115,
0.6283250451,
-0.4270698428,
0.4346398115,
-0.2465034574,
-0.1650625318,
-0.222357437,
-1.0458142757,
-0.8707238436,
-0.8048051596,
-0.2021607608,
-0.0948374271,
0.1320398748,
0.8254923224,
0.7629827857,
-0.5913595557,
-0.013611394,
-0.3899045289,
-0.3210730255,
-0.0557937138,
-0.1658186466,
0.3853437901,
-0.4991570413,
-0.8349872828,
0.1676432937,
0.1020807028,
-0.0469061397,
-0.2186647505,
0.0455473885,
-0.4901191592,
-0.0420817472,
0.6945843697,
-0.4286301732,
-0.5299008489,
-0.3676795959,
-0.3207539022,
-0.1168814003,
0.0086213043,
0.9494212866,
-0.8543581963,
0.3711354733,
0.4231575131,
0.4967796504,
0.8295019865,
0.0067639737,
0.6494133472,
-0.9166056514,
0.5834255219,
0.0684121773,
0.4995056391,
0.2454644442,
-0.2357897162,
0.4474871159,
0.0445533954,
-0.5405104756,
-0.7333623171,
0.1113201454,
-1.1208000183,
-0.5063024163,
1.0576925278,
-0.3916920125,
-0.3076197803,
0.310908407,
-0.2657017708,
0.4131811261,
-0.3966592252,
0.6231261492,
0.7730971575,
0.1080757678,
-0.1925287694,
-0.1985126287,
0.1506234407,
0.2839157283,
-0.5135356188,
-0.1499999464,
0.7152603865,
-0.1826952547,
0.272669971,
0.3126799464,
-0.0713584498,
-0.1698232293,
0.1047859788,
0.0367094986,
-0.2003386319,
-0.2565560639,
-0.2132338285,
0.3511088192,
-0.0717502832,
-0.1934602708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12633v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12633v2 | PUNR: Pre-training with User Behavior Modeling for News Recommendation | 2023-04-25T08:03:52 | 2023-10-30T08:13:42 | Guangyuan Ma, Hongtao Liu, Xing Wu, Wanhui Qian, Zhepeng Lv, Qing Yang, Songlin Hu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | News recommendation aims to predict click behaviors based on user behaviors.
How to effectively model the user representations is the key to recommending
preferred news. Existing works are mostly focused on improvements in the
supervised fine-tuning stage. However, there is still a lack of PLM-based
unsupervised pre-training methods optimized for user representations. In this
work, we propose an unsupervised pre-training paradigm with two tasks, i.e.
user behavior masking and user behavior generation, both towards effective user
behavior modeling. Firstly, we introduce the user behavior masking pre-training
task to recover the masked user behaviors based on their contextual behaviors.
In this way, the model could capture a much stronger and more comprehensive
user news reading pattern. Besides, we incorporate a novel auxiliary user
behavior generation pre-training task to enhance the user representation vector
derived from the user encoder. We use the above pre-trained user modeling
encoder to obtain news and user representations in downstream fine-tuning.
Evaluations on the real-world news benchmark show significant performance
improvements over existing baselines. | [
-0.5156932473,
-0.4771172702,
0.3883886039,
0.2126972675,
-0.5973485708,
-0.0266539957,
-0.1066824719,
-0.1441292465,
0.4186423719,
0.7461958528,
-0.7576869726,
-0.473408401,
-0.2947496772,
-0.1713464856,
-0.1633662134,
1.2709300518,
0.1546785682,
0.0983025804,
-0.4333919883,
0.2448371351,
-0.5868494511,
-0.7523542643,
-0.4894596934,
-0.3353354335,
0.3834128082,
0.4469075799,
0.4164430797,
0.2481325567,
0.1822650433,
0.2228587717,
0.1804586351,
0.2933396995,
-0.5271484852,
-0.3426784575,
-0.0690103844,
-0.1565712243,
-0.3435971737,
0.4579936862,
0.2467898428,
0.5027736425,
-0.2877663076,
0.1084661931,
0.1867396981,
0.7776666284,
-0.4292980134,
-0.2019845396,
-0.3743147254,
-0.0113360472,
-0.1719900668,
-0.2912682593,
-0.3047867715,
-0.2180289477,
0.1871114969,
-0.8007890582,
0.2277752608,
0.4635874629,
0.7680008411,
-0.006751027,
-0.725908041,
0.0279385019,
-0.7381467819,
0.4677564502,
-0.4662828445,
0.6201825142,
0.6223219633,
0.038141869,
-0.3496635854,
-0.6173295975,
-0.630223155,
-0.1630975902,
-0.3454186022,
0.0819250494,
-0.1462855041,
-0.0293013733,
0.1546182036,
0.1973541081,
-0.4736686945,
-0.0833052322,
-0.3045220375,
-0.2212646008,
0.4349985719,
-0.0582792088,
0.0372401997,
-0.208519578,
-0.5254971385,
-0.0063409079,
-0.4179736078,
0.3884377778,
0.6448283195,
0.055498939,
-0.095408231,
0.4023910463,
-0.4412072003,
0.6969524026,
0.3116066456,
0.0238347035,
0.5527810454,
-0.3772368431,
0.0385713913,
0.0448970608,
0.6299133301,
0.6031907201,
0.5074974895,
-0.0173918363,
-0.111447148,
-0.0260355566,
0.6482869387,
-0.7279879451,
-0.3676460683,
-0.2622287571,
-0.6287787557,
-0.381953001,
0.605851233,
-0.6020476818,
-0.5162041783,
-0.5964590311,
0.5268371701,
-0.2258969843,
-0.3685224652,
0.6097712517,
0.2170231044,
-0.2468212992,
0.244655475,
-0.7481870055,
0.2961268723,
0.5669329762,
0.5235709548,
-0.3749913573,
-0.3178224266,
-0.7757283449,
0.2606829405,
-0.0797598064,
0.8379502892,
-0.6782673597,
-0.2148205936,
0.1385506243,
0.0376836024,
-0.021508351,
-0.2347142696,
0.5201020241,
-0.7040644884,
0.2279882431,
-0.3803535998,
-0.5236142278,
-0.2390173823,
0.1725428849,
-0.4632901847,
0.8428617716,
0.168728739,
-0.8388652802,
0.6474493742,
-0.9252440333,
-0.6814903021,
-0.2316987813,
0.3106194735,
-0.4908520281,
0.1537419409,
0.6566174626,
0.5277220011,
0.3065057397,
0.2256736308,
-0.1923737824,
-0.5719839931,
0.0780454874,
0.0163846482,
0.3991187513,
0.2877133191,
0.2196520567,
0.4412521422,
-0.6775222421,
-0.423604995,
-0.1373221278,
-0.3927810192,
-0.3895868063,
-0.0768246874,
0.1488550305,
0.139617309,
0.1838445216,
-0.7079488635,
0.210151419,
-0.3321495652,
0.3721428812,
0.5661447644,
0.1576434672,
0.5677555799,
-0.368157655,
0.3467817605,
0.3905186653,
0.182474494,
-0.4945816994,
-0.1144014969,
-0.471390903,
0.0435857363,
0.2538946569,
0.3084831536,
-0.5364606977,
0.4833830595,
0.0433652401,
-0.0778133124,
-0.2599415481,
0.318757683,
0.2574570477,
0.4882976413,
0.3444998264,
-0.5608423948,
-0.9056244493,
-0.4103190601,
-0.6187899709,
-0.0000019971,
-0.0637091622,
0.1986950785,
0.0593374223,
-0.4574555457,
1.0500751734,
-0.5034765601,
-0.720985055,
-0.3284471333,
0.3556909859,
0.2525553405,
0.5348315835,
0.3417894542,
-0.8937405944,
-0.2436723411,
-0.4469587207,
-0.1863912046,
-0.0589403063,
-0.0326854177,
-0.1196058244,
0.1362108439,
0.6589210033,
-0.4313367605,
0.611884594,
0.2569095194,
-0.4808433354,
0.4590927064,
-0.3475032747,
0.2722282708,
-1.1253798008,
-0.1569965035,
0.2706644237,
-0.5691428185,
-0.5199360847,
-0.368740052,
-0.0356059298,
-0.3374245763,
-0.5709523559,
0.4652299285,
-0.4039123058,
-0.3041678369,
-0.4239677489,
-0.4568890929,
-0.0227251761,
0.639220953,
0.2415774465,
0.7381032705,
0.456171304,
-0.7491024137,
0.0287727043,
0.3107454181,
-0.5689884424,
0.2533954084,
-0.552942872,
0.2232533246,
-0.19679223,
0.3974322677,
-0.9089192748,
-0.1123345941,
0.1952898353,
-0.1625067294,
0.1162797436,
-0.2210152745,
-0.6707408428,
-0.507409513,
-0.4250758886,
0.2471625507,
0.5673289299,
-0.6476876736,
0.5477285385,
0.2965072691,
0.0773820505,
-0.0690053776,
-0.0682912096,
-0.2907122076,
-0.1354410946,
-0.369720459,
0.4935816526,
-0.1591533422,
0.4074508548,
-0.1141626835,
-0.1797739416,
0.124734357,
-0.0564746708,
0.3122653961,
0.1428910494,
-0.0885916874,
-0.0551909171,
-0.2070676684,
-0.3733651042,
-0.1741810888,
-0.3491349816,
0.6977648139,
-0.1593546718,
-0.3404934406,
-0.5307408571,
0.2020665258,
0.2495711595,
-0.5942636728,
0.4389612377,
1.0246466398,
-0.0542624742,
0.1361380965,
-0.6602519751,
-0.4709907472,
-0.5259133577,
0.3359458148,
-0.0461406559,
-0.9521630406,
0.1378893554,
-0.3825191855,
-0.2123462409,
-0.0888697058,
0.2962248325,
-0.5220653415,
1.2944767475,
0.9626801014,
-0.160840854,
0.8865113854,
0.0539393313,
0.1313980371,
-0.5453149676,
-0.3827567697,
-0.1179118231,
-0.4124856293,
-0.1741163135,
-0.0183768477,
0.4091720283,
0.3041005135,
-0.4390487969,
0.2462091297,
-0.3435611129,
0.5609614849,
1.0411912203,
0.2918828726,
0.3750993609,
0.3812661469,
-0.0076544029,
-0.228595987,
-0.3986492753,
-0.300627023,
1.0133026838,
0.1324296892,
0.9972921014,
-0.3482854366,
0.4816579223,
0.4882093072,
-0.008893704,
-0.5176762938,
0.3909383118,
-0.4312795103,
-0.1449394822,
-0.0567422844,
-0.0187308565,
-0.8446584344,
-0.0480216369,
-0.5596622229,
-0.8204929233,
0.114818193,
0.4218449593,
-0.4547329545,
0.1735513657,
-0.5654161572,
0.8469660282,
-0.1745302826,
-0.056636069,
-0.3177431226,
-0.4857322276,
0.1748918742,
0.0062643746,
0.0955237225,
0.1317739189,
0.2161665708,
0.9674534202,
-0.1983353198,
0.9345730543,
-0.3892873526,
0.3282299936,
0.1772206575,
-0.0284682754,
0.6210572124,
0.2698298395,
0.0115082553,
0.1894367635,
-0.2096172869,
-0.1181442589,
-0.286624372,
0.4317251146,
-0.9091860652,
-0.8334646821,
-0.4776546061,
-0.4794812799,
-0.418962419,
0.3667457104,
0.3637161553,
0.3995845318,
-0.0990889892,
0.2435445487,
0.5608360767,
0.0434768908,
0.4624752998,
0.9370411634,
-0.3603575826,
-0.3137499094,
0.9859120846,
-0.2948982418,
-0.6414337158,
0.3580780029,
0.1428016424,
-0.4292185009,
-0.7610986829,
-0.1405249387,
0.150869742,
-0.1666094214,
-0.0064926273,
-0.7783451676,
-0.0533513762,
-0.3923839331,
-0.1756299138,
-0.1898594648,
0.2148462683,
-0.6409701109,
-0.0049910322,
0.2612188458,
0.6980850101,
0.1139295846,
0.824653089,
-0.6333940625,
0.6861346364,
0.34749192,
0.6110608578,
-0.3857592046,
-0.4058475494,
-0.4043234885,
0.0026732679,
-0.4536410272,
-0.5182742476,
0.3491554558,
0.1392700374,
0.5998606682,
0.6709313393,
0.4126453698,
0.5403786302,
-0.5491012931,
0.5611376166,
0.3894971907,
-0.714641571,
0.7670574784,
-0.2966878712,
0.1869790703,
0.7143784761,
0.5048260689,
-0.3655580878,
0.09683723,
-0.2204358876,
-0.4277693927,
0.9914303422,
-0.1462462693,
0.3604254127,
0.172876671,
0.3624607325,
0.3208862543,
0.4482567012,
-0.4886365831,
0.0217985231,
-0.6880438924,
0.1447191238,
-0.411986798,
-0.5163767338,
0.2454619408,
-0.5519985557,
0.4388634562,
-0.0604358092,
0.0294500627,
-0.0131305521,
-0.3491007388,
-0.2551255822,
-0.0414582342,
0.4525445998,
0.6902778745,
-0.4538038075,
-0.2399107963,
-0.3394971192,
-0.5548103452,
0.0971146971,
0.2619671226,
-0.1088917255,
-0.1479716003,
-0.0276545715,
1.0465946198,
0.4601514637,
-0.4144101441,
0.8817696571,
-0.1235473379,
-0.2143711597,
-0.3578824103,
0.2231294513,
0.0469009094,
0.1614865214,
0.3744145632,
0.4186933935,
0.1512239575,
-0.5440747142,
0.3950252831,
0.3019393981,
-0.4286671579,
-0.4765254557,
0.7105640173,
0.4632385671,
-0.2520285845,
0.5485036969,
-0.0522671379,
-0.5564658046,
0.092476815,
0.6913097501,
0.5151943564,
-0.1982992887,
0.3886766434,
0.2785497606,
-0.0641430244,
-0.2399320304,
0.3505817652,
-0.1983428597,
-0.7621027827,
-0.1990103722,
-0.8259031177,
0.0061492831,
0.3701058328,
-0.7437723279,
0.7030513883,
-0.3467798531,
-0.0516265444,
0.0211977661,
0.3346078396,
-0.7632421255,
0.1953794956,
0.0802118108,
0.7709844112,
-0.8160713315,
0.8279049993,
1.1892749071,
-0.2189329416,
-0.4312908351,
0.3037025928,
-0.0751658157,
-0.6067444682,
0.3577034473,
0.3803204596,
0.0920938402,
0.2287437916,
-0.3886587322,
-0.6249588132,
0.7437545657,
0.4410740137,
-0.7191146016,
0.1172926128,
-0.0722783059,
0.3787414134,
-0.7697241306,
0.0515156724,
0.258308053,
0.3785155416,
0.2062746584,
-0.6435133219,
-0.0567742996,
-0.1427067518,
0.1419540942,
-0.0703689009,
-0.4083345532,
0.8970649242,
-0.412343204,
-0.0753178522,
-0.2319524437,
0.8911032081,
0.0221028309,
0.6100698113,
0.8332467079,
0.4130591154,
0.4650824368,
0.278588891,
1.0191899538,
-0.2438099384,
-0.0798624977,
1.0710626841,
-0.2433584481,
0.6811156869,
0.2363198698,
-0.0708496422,
0.6840792298,
0.792846024,
-0.053272292,
0.8941995502,
0.0087917503,
-0.0076462175,
-0.6022399068,
-0.2434135973,
-0.3637592196,
0.4840210378,
0.0828574747,
-0.1485179812,
-0.1630192101,
0.5135754943,
-0.1353695095,
0.2461593002,
-0.5281718969,
1.1749004126,
-0.0874179155,
-0.7165189385,
0.2425299883,
0.1127787456,
1.0617002249,
-0.6986474395,
0.0681393817,
-0.2256533504,
0.092142947,
-0.2798649371,
-0.6251961589,
0.0114959963,
-0.1353062391,
-0.5648989081,
-0.3498692214,
1.2081160545,
-0.5112370849,
-0.4117046595,
0.1153859869,
0.5038359761,
0.0896105692,
-0.4834839404,
-0.3601112664,
-0.0709808841,
0.0036954537,
-0.5031129718,
0.5203886032,
-0.0834166259,
-0.3588598073,
0.4894440472,
1.0827736855,
-0.0574305691,
-0.2099306136,
0.3649732769,
0.9533084631,
-0.6471660733,
-1.1126714945,
-0.5560631156,
0.2123813033,
0.1134632081,
-0.3200878203,
0.5914494991,
0.4821383357,
0.9603734612,
-0.2597833574,
0.5542686582,
0.3036958575,
0.5937675238,
-0.4198240936,
0.6903555989,
-0.5683785081,
0.2708602846,
-0.1768494248,
-1.0020024776,
-0.0157154482,
0.2949261367,
-0.2634541094,
0.2000691295,
0.3148513436,
0.5976684093,
-0.5203085542,
0.1622491181,
0.211951673,
-0.1106189862,
-0.0996890292,
0.2284339368,
0.7807358503,
0.0501919761,
0.5303695202,
-0.2834645212,
-0.0875835493,
-0.6210212708,
-1.0217300653,
-1.2336724997,
-0.6526249647,
-0.2082298547,
-0.0718261153,
0.2248542756,
0.849716723,
1.1567305326,
-0.8684638143,
-0.0183868054,
-0.1280244887,
-0.0554554015,
-0.3546005785,
-0.1714082658,
0.3079552054,
-0.2436987013,
-0.4309505224,
0.3873577416,
-0.077470772,
0.0718614608,
-0.1295218468,
-0.3558240831,
-0.0444290265,
-0.1931717694,
0.5241075158,
0.2623186707,
-0.5229539275,
-0.181752786,
-0.1485218853,
0.1575795412,
-0.0597677566,
1.2615512609,
-1.274875164,
0.3773292005,
0.3157447278,
0.3670556843,
0.8396915197,
0.5529547334,
0.6991540194,
-1.1300375462,
0.2206488997,
-0.0601532795,
0.1763040572,
0.2494128495,
-0.5850291252,
0.1419544369,
0.2124227583,
-0.1836451888,
-0.6951162219,
0.0585018471,
-0.9760602713,
-0.2579031885,
0.9898610115,
-0.0663178116,
-0.0393300876,
-0.3069409728,
-0.4784361422,
0.2494621724,
-0.7478632331,
0.640006125,
0.3296615183,
-0.1212868243,
-0.4026086628,
-0.268412441,
0.6423267126,
0.2329052538,
-0.5255482197,
-0.1907015741,
0.2517045736,
0.3273566961,
-0.2071322203,
0.7760284543,
0.1902573705,
0.3635085523,
-0.4380978644,
-0.0534438156,
-1.0417487621,
-0.5945469737,
-0.070290409,
0.0112343933,
-0.310002774,
-0.3283079267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12631v1 | Explain like I am BM25: Interpreting a Dense Model's Ranked-List with a Sparse Approximation | 2023-04-25T07:58:38 | 2023-04-25T07:58:38 | Michael Llordes, Debasis Ganguly, Sumit Bhatia, Chirag Agarwal | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Neural retrieval models (NRMs) have been shown to outperform their
statistical counterparts owing to their ability to capture semantic meaning via
dense document representations. These models, however, suffer from poor
interpretability as they do not rely on explicit term matching. As a form of
local per-query explanations, we introduce the notion of equivalent queries
that are generated by maximizing the similarity between the NRM's results and
the result set of a sparse retrieval system with the equivalent query. We then
compare this approach with existing methods such as RM3-based query expansion
and contrast differences in retrieval effectiveness and in the terms generated
by each approach. | [
-0.4216624796,
-0.6926208138,
0.7100282907,
0.215428099,
-0.2793878317,
-0.2324455678,
-0.2789547443,
-0.1803796142,
0.288856864,
0.6942512989,
-0.762375772,
-0.3849684596,
-0.40242365,
0.2808109224,
-0.7082862854,
0.735781312,
0.3971710205,
0.4437075555,
-0.2849936485,
-0.305770725,
-0.5180213451,
-0.4432131052,
-0.6635374427,
-0.63521415,
0.5843113065,
0.2806594372,
0.99948138,
0.4160415232,
0.8226246238,
0.3166657388,
-0.0536517911,
0.0194498096,
-0.684589386,
0.09756466,
-0.3854171336,
-0.8128852844,
-0.1496853679,
-0.0212495904,
0.918607533,
1.1663968563,
-0.2151434869,
-0.0045357291,
0.1839812398,
0.4855965078,
-0.6167442203,
-0.4172883034,
-1.0134570599,
0.2657473087,
0.2829698622,
-0.4312931895,
-0.5456339121,
-0.3590637445,
0.0821683705,
-0.5851291418,
0.4675110281,
0.1487350464,
1.0710264444,
0.1616291702,
-0.2728227675,
-0.232147336,
-0.7615856528,
0.9939137697,
-0.7911451459,
0.1782509834,
0.4874750972,
0.7259202003,
-0.1306736469,
-0.8589716554,
-0.675098896,
-0.069231458,
-0.3936497867,
0.2732018828,
-0.1258538663,
0.1522529572,
0.3096701503,
0.4184720516,
-0.9112431407,
0.1071078032,
-0.2455337942,
0.0487021208,
0.5973881483,
0.3391473293,
0.2032276392,
-0.3860542774,
-0.5904372931,
0.2352312058,
-0.8506258726,
-0.4266707301,
0.2408502698,
0.2648528218,
0.2498613447,
0.6308866739,
-0.340525955,
0.9917900562,
-0.1255637705,
0.3894013166,
-0.0903735533,
-0.5476588011,
-0.5107512474,
-0.1459227353,
0.5302764773,
0.5459735394,
0.3997934163,
-0.5092785954,
-0.2449219078,
-0.3934358656,
0.5192046762,
-0.9340808392,
-0.0377215557,
0.0431702957,
-1.1283712387,
-0.1919765472,
0.1760730296,
-0.7573692203,
-0.3300708234,
-0.51163131,
0.8590057492,
-0.2741303742,
-0.1142915413,
0.1303573698,
-0.2860054672,
0.4109552801,
0.2806953788,
-0.8923538327,
0.9408601522,
0.7494547963,
0.8569931984,
-0.0688736066,
-0.0687657669,
-0.2801541388,
-0.1182851046,
-0.5104902387,
0.7970180511,
-0.6007369161,
-0.4072173238,
-0.2721944451,
0.0088191843,
-0.2497203797,
-1.1228824854,
0.2724501491,
-0.7208319306,
0.1332829744,
-0.5653233528,
-0.4565353394,
-0.4156391919,
0.2792532444,
-0.387491107,
0.8677229881,
-0.11661838,
-0.3933142722,
0.3872492015,
-0.5031329989,
0.1182917431,
0.121752739,
0.0980452076,
0.1704335064,
0.3314412832,
-0.0557781011,
0.6324537396,
-0.3616577387,
-0.1271064728,
-0.6943590045,
-0.9777083397,
0.4823562205,
-0.3208581507,
0.5584853888,
0.5345752239,
-0.1337991059,
0.1158928871,
-0.565076232,
0.2903318405,
0.0182992704,
-0.0351286419,
-0.4192721546,
0.1673507392,
-0.2914739847,
-0.0788649917,
0.3140453398,
-0.4156583846,
0.0458167791,
-0.4501233399,
0.3225998878,
0.5765783191,
0.2101710439,
0.7735215425,
-0.5218093991,
0.5845547915,
-0.0913767517,
-0.1046811938,
0.031167049,
-0.2768827677,
-0.4483257532,
-0.1778207868,
0.5324425101,
0.4015856087,
-0.3396428227,
-0.0985386148,
-0.4853205383,
-0.4210880697,
-0.5696195364,
0.2700133622,
0.2555089891,
0.2834090292,
0.3553520143,
-0.1628146619,
-0.7125232816,
-1.0752848387,
-0.574881196,
0.1092427373,
-0.2126877904,
0.6873315573,
0.2889528275,
-0.2174503356,
0.5963923931,
-0.5869657397,
-0.0609560125,
-0.1631082445,
0.0023922913,
0.5815976262,
0.4758844972,
0.3793625534,
-0.9684610963,
-0.4359219074,
-0.0866235569,
-0.9764691591,
0.0803209245,
-0.0809988081,
-0.3777986467,
-0.1713965535,
0.8064981699,
-0.4352191687,
0.3913723826,
0.0753614306,
-0.3542623818,
0.3191078007,
-0.3029040396,
0.1506098956,
-1.0595555305,
0.064801693,
-0.0482127853,
-0.2876556218,
-0.2661157548,
0.4105826914,
-0.190388903,
-0.3417795599,
-0.0752372742,
0.4982254505,
-0.6104194522,
-0.7107889056,
-0.2925915718,
0.4085520804,
0.1506791413,
0.0146129886,
-0.2536303401,
0.643084228,
0.2922465503,
-0.5331845284,
0.3176244795,
0.169417575,
-0.3282941878,
0.6646373868,
-0.804675281,
-0.1898898184,
-0.5380821824,
0.1478620768,
-1.2491871119,
-0.1283621043,
-0.0767910704,
-0.4524862766,
0.403306663,
-0.43941769,
-0.5177543759,
-0.2090851665,
-0.165639922,
0.2428581864,
0.7393344641,
-0.8508727551,
0.5263599753,
-0.1248595342,
-0.0834144652,
-0.7954829335,
-0.8826012611,
0.0211013444,
-0.4206548333,
-0.4424017966,
0.4353576601,
-0.1824597567,
-0.7351624966,
0.4064954221,
-0.0819218978,
-0.3327276111,
0.3791814446,
0.3706762791,
0.0446009077,
-0.7706122398,
0.1076230034,
-0.1084214374,
0.1505817175,
0.1735216975,
0.020120142,
0.4716441631,
-0.0273388084,
-0.1583381444,
-0.2319974899,
0.2321120501,
0.111330092,
0.0021820194,
0.8395370245,
0.480424732,
-0.4332465231,
-0.462130785,
-0.326662153,
-0.6147350669,
-0.4922497869,
0.1553716958,
-0.8137729764,
-0.388643831,
0.6923256516,
0.2982164323,
-0.2532786429,
0.4699411988,
0.4520956278,
-0.4153737724,
1.0006033182,
0.0660150796,
0.5852264762,
0.3092395365,
-0.3499268889,
-0.0322506987,
-0.8077247143,
-0.4477119446,
-0.6529399157,
-0.6824703217,
-0.6238942146,
-0.4654399455,
-0.1096134931,
0.3574129045,
-0.1824400872,
0.3582653403,
-0.6108174324,
0.5633194447,
0.4047829807,
0.2470477074,
0.1999472976,
0.0398164354,
-0.0696370751,
-0.2921656668,
-0.8371272683,
-0.4757141769,
1.1352066994,
-0.0327137113,
0.8622748852,
0.4005275965,
0.657651484,
0.3321827352,
0.4854857922,
-0.7529893517,
0.5640182495,
-0.2336693853,
-0.9458719492,
-0.1684124768,
-0.6205368042,
-1.2711613178,
0.7614910007,
-0.4948159754,
-0.7402386069,
0.2438488454,
-0.2586525977,
-0.3307363689,
0.0280350447,
-0.8391887546,
0.9976837039,
0.0611391552,
-0.2864019871,
-0.45200634,
-0.3703432083,
0.4285526872,
0.104044199,
0.0292947739,
-0.4207822382,
-0.3208664954,
0.624230206,
-0.4640912414,
0.3983770609,
-0.2579088211,
0.7183358073,
0.2998273373,
0.2695639431,
-0.053754393,
0.1515571177,
-0.7172002792,
-0.0771619156,
0.3066962957,
-0.7525110245,
-1.2223780155,
1.1618102789,
-0.5639272928,
-0.5575495362,
-0.2441936731,
-0.7122682333,
0.0224050507,
0.2692779601,
0.0957958251,
0.8912695646,
-0.1099849716,
0.459649533,
0.5253044963,
-0.08553949,
0.457899183,
0.6573207974,
-0.427526325,
-0.1782523841,
0.9993117452,
0.4904279113,
0.0863630176,
0.646707058,
0.0015329636,
-0.5797635317,
-0.8506773114,
-0.2737497389,
0.193415612,
-0.878364861,
-0.0864639282,
-0.6039468646,
0.0039018306,
-0.1310760379,
-0.1491343379,
0.3030970991,
-0.3947900236,
-0.404548049,
-0.03152797,
0.1836249679,
1.1179214716,
-0.1295527369,
0.3625018597,
-0.4125543833,
0.4483755529,
0.1894809455,
0.3666174114,
0.2536745965,
-0.7090732455,
-0.090737693,
0.0367830545,
-0.109786287,
-0.9957763553,
0.5033144951,
0.3330236375,
0.6655576825,
0.4632332325,
-0.0349612534,
1.0143184662,
-0.4177162051,
0.579624474,
-0.1812103391,
-0.6241083741,
0.1779430211,
-0.2254190892,
0.0577128194,
0.773003757,
0.7706358433,
-0.0111646531,
0.0147382114,
-0.822906673,
-0.5888180733,
0.5169067383,
0.1419668347,
0.3690300882,
-0.0897172242,
0.8672693968,
0.0655812472,
0.0507825725,
-0.5277424455,
-0.2746045291,
-0.152357012,
-0.3243932128,
-0.2688047886,
-0.4173698127,
0.2792409658,
0.0228729416,
0.6401677132,
-0.1803857237,
0.5234879851,
0.3628119528,
-0.1691614091,
-0.0144291976,
-0.0600060113,
0.3834004402,
0.8830273151,
-0.5708970428,
0.5640231371,
0.5046375394,
-0.0297660641,
-0.1281944513,
0.0969287381,
0.0094382185,
0.2936251163,
0.2797059119,
0.3602618575,
0.7323386669,
-0.6356676817,
0.4288116693,
-0.1580736637,
-0.0828510448,
-0.1948683113,
0.0261489432,
0.3029247224,
0.0567670874,
0.5610508323,
-0.1355967224,
0.5738248825,
-0.861541748,
0.4246555269,
0.8192479014,
-0.8323733807,
-0.2366047949,
0.7145882845,
-0.1203775778,
-0.3767215014,
0.6727104187,
-0.1074116006,
-0.299885124,
0.7921045423,
0.6181794405,
0.4148029089,
0.246155262,
0.1066043973,
0.5229274631,
0.2726275921,
0.0523397066,
0.5298754573,
-0.2014909536,
-0.5831157565,
-0.6506211162,
-0.7960852385,
-0.3761627078,
0.0349998586,
-1.1296466589,
0.1668895781,
-0.5718185306,
0.0103282211,
0.5043463707,
0.2549784184,
-0.5600819588,
0.4908777475,
-0.2407283485,
0.960719049,
-0.5124840736,
0.5060420632,
0.748485744,
-0.639061451,
-0.9084020853,
-0.0392007194,
-0.3306033909,
-1.0002934933,
0.5599230528,
0.0478933491,
0.4092764258,
0.1201139987,
-0.4742334783,
-0.7744444609,
0.8795532584,
0.3677567542,
-0.1255147308,
-0.133318305,
-0.1292252243,
0.5971983075,
-0.3254059255,
0.6859324574,
0.2574684024,
0.4395647943,
-0.0325422622,
-0.4899746776,
0.3625653088,
-0.09324646,
-0.1003439799,
0.1741091609,
-0.3918273449,
0.496545583,
-0.0676538274,
0.0488536544,
0.5579873323,
0.6480839849,
0.0062393649,
0.5057795048,
0.2073471546,
0.5465893149,
0.4788602591,
-0.0906187072,
1.4152393341,
-0.0806532651,
0.398023963,
1.0436644554,
-0.0390960276,
0.982164681,
0.2051619589,
-0.0267691854,
0.5766118765,
0.8430902362,
-0.1988707781,
0.3819896877,
0.2529101372,
-0.0635328591,
-0.5404451489,
-0.1016629338,
-0.2528042495,
0.2772844136,
0.2953826487,
-0.6024695039,
-0.5381712914,
-0.3446348906,
-0.3273693919,
0.4740329683,
-0.4972762167,
0.9997938871,
0.5031161904,
-0.66689533,
0.8148657084,
-0.0283466484,
0.3988677263,
-0.2975217998,
-0.1856329739,
-0.2097970843,
0.1013271585,
-0.5697623491,
-0.7372309566,
0.7337008715,
-0.3057700694,
-0.578802824,
-0.2727693617,
0.829831779,
-0.2780290246,
-0.2644954026,
0.2568643987,
0.5926101208,
0.7679813504,
-0.0972217992,
-1.0276768208,
-0.1451049596,
-0.1933984309,
-0.0172948111,
0.4963315725,
0.4718922675,
0.0850541145,
0.7295382619,
0.6054326892,
-0.0412438214,
0.2811384797,
-0.1538105756,
0.2813509107,
-0.8070487976,
0.0156916808,
-0.8563429117,
-0.0636769831,
-0.0649345517,
-0.0798718631,
1.028804183,
0.7308736444,
0.4845734537,
0.0435314626,
0.3263716102,
0.266150713,
0.6274808049,
-0.4253433645,
0.9859886169,
-0.7688320279,
0.2205209732,
-0.0770108551,
-1.3602814674,
-0.1222220957,
0.6601359844,
-0.4306381643,
0.054156471,
0.5532326698,
0.9215121269,
-0.3352186382,
-0.1037140116,
0.7475637794,
0.5101081729,
-0.3756808341,
0.1144696176,
1.0126270056,
-0.3760555685,
0.5560867786,
-0.1112120375,
0.2768461108,
-0.3852037489,
-0.5872520208,
-0.7940767407,
-0.3153041601,
-0.1149404272,
-0.7731993794,
0.1512820572,
0.632660687,
0.9821912646,
-0.6502801776,
-0.1950709522,
-0.0724684447,
0.5403428674,
-0.0596222766,
-0.294919759,
0.0496439636,
-0.3438999057,
-0.7864584923,
0.5789211392,
-0.1408498734,
-0.161126107,
-0.1476599276,
-0.0479623824,
-0.1403501481,
0.4945961833,
0.3752586544,
0.0543924756,
-0.5619280934,
-0.2000785321,
0.0507146977,
-0.1026949808,
0.0372153632,
0.4663560688,
-0.9298091531,
0.5578758121,
0.5838754773,
0.6007009745,
0.8041883707,
0.4082200527,
0.7133586407,
-0.2480383962,
-0.0507932454,
0.4049879014,
0.2577065825,
0.344512403,
-0.1748923808,
0.7505787611,
0.0847167745,
-0.510612309,
-1.1923829317,
0.1297191083,
-1.1340478659,
-0.4072591066,
1.2274589539,
-0.2185562998,
-0.3749872148,
-0.0389041454,
0.0862902775,
-0.0713369325,
0.0148352357,
0.3763735294,
0.3434305489,
-0.0078757619,
0.1000506505,
-0.7204838991,
0.294177562,
0.7723551989,
-0.3130476475,
-0.5199415088,
0.1375235319,
0.644777,
-0.1061710566,
0.3833993971,
-0.1097568944,
0.2971309423,
0.0680840164,
-0.2048899531,
0.2542513311,
-0.0424371958,
-0.6031472087,
0.3893840015,
0.328202337,
0.0368144885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12569v1 | KINLP at SemEval-2023 Task 12: Kinyarwanda Tweet Sentiment Analysis | 2023-04-25T04:30:03 | 2023-04-25T04:30:03 | Antoine Nzeyimana | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This paper describes the system entered by the author to the SemEval-2023
Task 12: Sentiment analysis for African languages. The system focuses on the
Kinyarwanda language and uses a language-specific model. Kinyarwanda morphology
is modeled in a two tier transformer architecture and the transformer model is
pre-trained on a large text corpus using multi-task masked morphology
prediction. The model is deployed on an experimental platform that allows users
to experiment with the pre-trained language model fine-tuning without the need
to write machine learning code. Our final submission to the shared task
achieves second ranking out of 34 teams in the competition, achieving 72.50%
weighted F1 score. Our analysis of the evaluation results highlights challenges
in achieving high accuracy on the task and identifies areas for improvement. | [
-0.528847754,
-0.3616427481,
0.2774897814,
0.692492187,
-0.3527147472,
0.3054387271,
0.110480994,
-0.5057367086,
0.5161862373,
0.4288369119,
-0.5434426069,
-0.552262485,
-0.975864172,
0.1225356311,
-0.1575310826,
0.9262835383,
-0.2148729265,
0.1382482797,
0.0527358912,
-0.3911080062,
-0.3057137728,
-0.4708092213,
-0.3981991708,
-0.3231919706,
0.6141802669,
0.5558193922,
0.6125211716,
-0.0903488249,
0.575011313,
0.2439558953,
-0.1308883727,
-0.1964260191,
-0.0512459166,
0.2256101221,
-0.264092207,
-0.2217190862,
-0.8240077496,
-0.04892819,
0.0772519335,
1.0617692471,
-0.0510112718,
0.2955887318,
0.3511873484,
0.6572753191,
-0.4365711808,
0.4249401987,
-0.367826879,
0.0145107536,
-0.2484630644,
-0.0033789389,
0.22741732,
-0.418615967,
0.2347142994,
0.0921026692,
0.1401286721,
-0.1425715089,
0.8944820762,
-0.0644485876,
-0.2952529788,
-0.2597903013,
-0.2403541356,
0.6856348515,
-0.6672046185,
0.1303170472,
0.5705977082,
0.2998396754,
0.3723142147,
-0.4864825308,
-0.3879976869,
0.2885763347,
0.1452914476,
0.1202298999,
-0.2467789501,
0.1659415811,
-0.2547709048,
0.3364377916,
-0.2867575288,
-0.0508134887,
-0.6462913752,
-0.2911299467,
0.7636216283,
0.0260254219,
0.1159493625,
-0.4233502746,
-0.1299562603,
0.2152451128,
-0.3242835402,
-0.0138245635,
0.8385943174,
0.3370268941,
-0.0320020281,
0.7268956304,
-0.3950353265,
0.3050211668,
-0.1101160794,
0.1667299271,
0.6789323688,
0.1016442999,
-0.3426006436,
0.1209054142,
0.9144087434,
0.5273442268,
0.1429773122,
-0.1874972731,
-0.6037020087,
0.2211938947,
0.470696032,
-0.4855443239,
-0.1664127856,
0.2526149154,
-0.6861037016,
-0.8546406627,
-0.2300460041,
-1.4683582783,
-0.615252912,
-0.1102665737,
0.8909778595,
-0.2389914095,
-0.5403622389,
0.0124904783,
0.1104678363,
0.2689966559,
0.3935408294,
-0.9157224298,
0.2463606745,
0.7215610743,
0.937482655,
-0.4072911441,
-0.4959395826,
-0.1385305971,
-0.283775717,
-0.2116735876,
0.7685812712,
-0.5209648609,
-0.5034329295,
0.0884366408,
0.0799335614,
-0.1814589202,
-0.4467422366,
0.7343405485,
-0.4096118808,
-0.0659682974,
-0.2614841759,
-0.3176575899,
-0.4384040534,
0.3975764215,
-0.580288589,
1.0455209017,
0.4703896046,
-0.7636505365,
0.1003716439,
-0.9198029637,
-0.6875709295,
-0.0023423717,
0.0460413769,
-0.4826188385,
0.3110048473,
0.1731455624,
0.7124240994,
-0.0823399797,
0.3324260414,
-0.2168531716,
-0.0270875227,
-0.2167312205,
-0.1554045081,
0.7885361314,
0.2670589983,
-0.9024422169,
0.1017330065,
-0.6410469413,
-0.1605892032,
0.001584053,
-0.1441402286,
0.0428462811,
-0.332120508,
0.0771524981,
0.1825964451,
0.1709297895,
-0.7760976553,
0.2439336032,
-0.3898607492,
0.395303756,
0.6938285828,
0.0778084695,
0.6800422072,
-0.1216545552,
0.8933097124,
0.0801965222,
0.2971225083,
0.2132702023,
-0.8287346959,
-1.0224530697,
0.3360917866,
0.3391391337,
0.3916282058,
-0.6166356206,
0.2878339589,
-0.3719930351,
-0.7715486884,
-0.720893085,
0.0152576575,
-0.0055578076,
0.3557764888,
0.2397100031,
-0.1746250391,
-0.7777888179,
-1.0797762871,
-0.1073502004,
-0.3004062176,
0.3304561973,
-0.0578175113,
0.7498038411,
-0.5176261663,
0.4654316604,
-0.2233141959,
-0.3563335836,
-0.5650007725,
0.5616771579,
0.1303666085,
0.4108348191,
0.5274310112,
-0.6938584447,
-0.3263092637,
-0.0127371941,
-0.5684720278,
-0.4598450959,
0.6086142063,
-0.2052885294,
0.562045455,
0.4655292332,
-0.4683401287,
0.7298585773,
1.0333143473,
-0.3577319682,
0.5377553701,
0.212184146,
0.4416771829,
-1.1647225618,
0.1091607809,
-0.3311365843,
-0.1926749945,
-0.6973259449,
0.0030531832,
-0.1302977651,
-0.3240835965,
-0.274802655,
0.2483605444,
-0.0962461308,
-0.1387936771,
-0.4038040042,
-0.3786294758,
0.0056494419,
0.5673456788,
0.0860218704,
0.6667186618,
0.4234974682,
-0.3964596987,
0.2920131385,
0.0667853579,
-0.5396390557,
0.3326798379,
-0.709133029,
0.0385013185,
0.071569711,
-0.3415189683,
-1.0793447495,
-0.2476101816,
0.2223475426,
-0.6117088795,
0.2149050385,
-0.0020214252,
-0.3459631503,
-0.4573079646,
-0.3601469696,
0.1630063206,
0.460375309,
-0.3048508465,
0.8747150898,
0.8007797599,
-0.4007238448,
-0.4784028828,
-0.8547127247,
0.1726155132,
-0.3202035129,
-0.6086462736,
0.1481572539,
0.3125170469,
-0.1777555943,
-0.1554232687,
-0.0451256149,
-0.0239833351,
0.0974007547,
0.4931280911,
0.178039059,
-0.0476654582,
-0.1031070054,
0.0062028239,
0.0354189426,
0.3082143366,
-0.1114626303,
1.0089918375,
-0.2559777498,
-0.0906540826,
-0.0359321237,
0.4918605387,
0.6882694364,
-0.1033718213,
0.9297254682,
0.7387951016,
-0.3535087109,
0.0871139914,
-0.6930868626,
0.3219162524,
-0.4339318871,
0.2491992265,
-0.5019948483,
-0.8690927625,
0.6798286438,
-0.0940816924,
-0.1998915821,
0.6376461387,
0.6669892073,
-0.4801798761,
1.042979598,
0.6893672347,
-0.3295330107,
0.0960527286,
-0.4401266575,
0.2929357588,
-0.7712911963,
-0.6796513796,
-0.6514743567,
-0.5681661367,
-0.7064219713,
-0.3177860975,
0.1643420905,
0.2169657499,
-0.1754397452,
0.4472579062,
-0.2764024138,
-0.0494525805,
0.5247701406,
0.0830500573,
-0.2252962887,
0.1374302208,
-0.3202005327,
0.0678527206,
-0.4000091851,
-0.6340999007,
0.8415849805,
0.3342276514,
0.7047054768,
0.0775218233,
0.8973793387,
0.4489362538,
-0.046750661,
-0.8651648164,
0.6345320344,
0.1306329668,
-0.375159651,
-0.191177994,
-0.1405304372,
-0.9453773499,
-0.0114241056,
0.252986908,
-0.8370077014,
0.3762574494,
-0.2612339556,
-0.1654567569,
0.4671424627,
-0.5342725515,
0.8802877665,
0.1698439568,
-0.0158127304,
0.0213981494,
-0.6641887426,
0.1555128545,
-0.1187769324,
0.280298382,
-0.3171426356,
-0.2299629003,
0.8727694154,
-0.5400308967,
0.8717775345,
-0.482001394,
-0.2310556322,
0.2411605567,
0.2838434279,
0.311884582,
-0.0326995812,
-0.3700639904,
0.422110945,
-0.0638130158,
-0.5524126291,
-0.3385369778,
0.5910542011,
-1.0455815792,
-0.4962240756,
-0.4767695963,
-0.173839286,
-0.477638483,
-0.1057765633,
0.5307782292,
0.3843261003,
-0.1161969602,
0.0762512013,
0.2907841504,
-0.3024606705,
0.7657335401,
0.0214940868,
-0.4275840819,
-0.545889318,
0.7787789106,
0.0378953591,
0.1551986337,
0.248107329,
0.2284302413,
-0.3415134847,
-0.4998001456,
-0.289244175,
-0.1105145663,
-0.7190360427,
-0.5678989291,
-1.1596941948,
-0.3974263668,
-0.7207418084,
-0.0350572914,
-0.3760513663,
-0.6528413296,
-0.1361346096,
-0.1719276756,
0.1619865447,
0.901687026,
-0.2019596249,
0.3465866446,
-0.8287793994,
0.0000256822,
0.3638920188,
0.2733048797,
-0.1094114333,
-0.5778403878,
-0.0162557233,
-0.0845316723,
-0.3574747145,
-0.791008532,
0.5050279498,
0.1672053784,
0.5017848015,
0.0823258609,
-0.2256658226,
0.540543437,
-0.3753105104,
1.0530081987,
0.1849899292,
-1.0961107016,
1.0737549067,
-0.2241851538,
0.4255195558,
0.810462594,
0.5117542148,
-0.421317935,
-0.3412494957,
-0.6663040519,
-0.5565994382,
0.5543106198,
0.3098218441,
0.32713449,
0.0573019758,
0.0794465169,
0.3858371079,
0.4010225832,
-0.4328622818,
-0.2655862868,
-0.3598673344,
-0.3339841962,
-0.0344717503,
-0.6806428432,
0.2064940631,
-0.4561865628,
0.784545064,
0.0088113528,
0.6086102128,
-0.0613775104,
-0.2223951966,
-0.0790292174,
0.3083216548,
0.6125574112,
0.612084806,
-0.1879296601,
0.1057791635,
0.2064523995,
-0.8543884158,
0.2395377308,
0.1278860718,
-0.024554031,
0.2485035658,
0.5656254888,
0.8662833571,
0.0693634748,
-0.194507286,
0.8209273219,
0.0463878103,
-0.5963310599,
-0.0461777933,
-0.2975406647,
0.1382519305,
0.2623541653,
0.4679758549,
0.6297284961,
0.2766270936,
-0.5220438242,
0.0104598086,
0.0230667312,
-0.6996967793,
-0.7172868252,
0.466203928,
0.4235245883,
-0.1798595488,
0.1829844117,
-0.5000028014,
-1.1952464581,
0.5098344088,
0.1124751717,
1.0203802586,
-0.5427166224,
0.4915832579,
0.3357850611,
0.3048766255,
0.0278411042,
0.8601959348,
0.2309690267,
-0.8024812341,
-0.3997902572,
-1.153575182,
-0.2224872112,
0.2123595774,
-0.6816651821,
0.4914162159,
-0.1312976927,
-0.1430186033,
-0.0971125141,
0.2878628075,
-0.7215713263,
0.3803081512,
0.1519691497,
0.829829514,
-0.8162602782,
0.9247370362,
1.0170440674,
-0.4418917596,
-0.8806852698,
-0.149011001,
-0.0960649624,
-0.9159725904,
0.735673964,
0.3275493681,
-0.0452117026,
-0.0928706005,
-0.3471127152,
-0.529386878,
1.0269577503,
0.2465937436,
-0.3873941898,
-0.0254878514,
0.4165292978,
0.3653731942,
-0.2533451021,
0.0600202419,
0.717888236,
0.3255108297,
0.2225967199,
-1.0205477476,
-0.3306998909,
-0.289211452,
-0.1014079303,
0.2389672101,
-0.5563541055,
0.7658385634,
0.0441004112,
-0.0039278241,
0.0310229938,
0.8104783893,
-0.1088332236,
0.1640256494,
0.7124168873,
0.5847262144,
0.5226216316,
-0.1474470198,
0.8933091164,
-0.1054141372,
0.4747385681,
0.9471613169,
-0.2391245216,
0.7912530303,
0.4586775601,
-0.3891683221,
0.4665976763,
0.5938484669,
0.2686834335,
0.7981770039,
-0.0129160788,
-0.4284576476,
-0.0702766031,
-0.3750026524,
-0.3530176878,
0.9140053391,
0.1863851547,
-0.2699584663,
-0.3046448231,
0.5098820329,
0.0402172431,
-0.0779740959,
-0.7135420442,
0.5649136901,
0.168489635,
-0.6127631068,
0.0172046125,
-0.1333387196,
0.9829878807,
-0.3206810653,
0.117188625,
-0.4185453951,
0.20748353,
-0.257511735,
-1.1117889881,
0.7005276084,
0.0386262052,
0.0451210439,
-0.3024461865,
1.0188392401,
-0.382189244,
-0.821028769,
0.513840735,
0.5297436714,
0.147713691,
-0.4179944694,
-0.7189984322,
0.3934418559,
0.0487354621,
-0.3129272163,
0.2347992361,
0.628303349,
0.143754974,
0.4991354346,
-0.0569538623,
0.2523781657,
0.0649720058,
0.4940117896,
0.8549179435,
-0.4708951414,
-0.3499527276,
-0.9505895376,
0.1105242968,
-0.1121765971,
-0.3015541136,
0.7212386131,
0.5538515449,
0.6193217635,
-0.1562858373,
0.8159577847,
-0.3936460018,
0.5028026104,
-0.1643844247,
0.8621559739,
-0.5220350623,
-0.0809577703,
-0.4714414775,
-1.048203826,
-0.0852580592,
0.5671303272,
-0.1803151667,
-0.0277715269,
0.7328289747,
0.7997034192,
0.0067665544,
0.4879794419,
0.5420801044,
-0.2077267021,
0.1172892153,
0.3224543035,
0.9805908203,
-0.7600848079,
0.59736377,
-0.707577765,
0.2029945403,
-0.0799601451,
-0.820594728,
-1.0268031359,
-0.8218873739,
-0.3459115624,
-0.4964049757,
-0.0528284088,
0.8388472199,
0.4162412882,
-1.1785155535,
-0.2090678811,
-0.1001170576,
-0.3405557573,
0.1311469227,
-0.3168925047,
0.3737139404,
-0.5928416252,
-0.7634251118,
-0.0104688071,
0.4606382251,
0.0081607103,
-0.2718687356,
-0.0266714897,
-0.5170335174,
-0.22213462,
0.7740130424,
-0.3073531389,
-0.4927170277,
-0.5191068053,
0.0295982752,
-0.3401165307,
0.0393618569,
0.764836669,
-0.5980243683,
0.18583031,
0.6516469121,
0.7217164636,
0.3949655592,
-0.1887374818,
0.7492230535,
-0.5387881994,
-0.0249995571,
0.4050544202,
0.4904174507,
0.4012483358,
-0.1372228861,
0.9864673615,
0.2212064564,
-0.5899054408,
-0.601937294,
-0.2937244773,
-0.9135670662,
-0.036792241,
1.2868409157,
-0.1418837011,
-0.4256592989,
-0.2444904894,
-0.2252745926,
0.3044654131,
-0.2731066048,
0.5286372304,
0.8900129199,
0.1916604191,
-0.269803077,
-0.6762562394,
0.411801815,
0.3882208765,
-0.7475480437,
-0.4470646977,
-0.1487341523,
0.133841753,
0.1517939419,
0.6217855215,
-0.1295930594,
0.0915835425,
-0.0611871146,
0.1452405602,
0.2536464036,
-0.1830824167,
-0.3972129524,
0.2630600333,
-0.1346694678,
-0.3640893102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12519v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12519v2 | GlyphDiffusion: Text Generation as Image Generation | 2023-04-25T02:14:44 | 2023-05-08T07:44:48 | Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jian-Yun Nie, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Diffusion models have become a new generative paradigm for text generation.
Considering the discrete categorical nature of text, in this paper, we propose
GlyphDiffusion, a novel diffusion approach for text generation via text-guided
image generation. Our key idea is to render the target text as a glyph image
containing visual language content. In this way, conditional text generation
can be cast as a glyph image generation task, and it is then natural to apply
continuous diffusion models to discrete texts. Specially, we utilize a cascaded
architecture (ie a base and a super-resolution diffusion model) to generate
high-fidelity glyph images, conditioned on the input text. Furthermore, we
design a text grounding module to transform and refine the visual language
content from generated glyph images into the final texts. In experiments over
four conditional text generation tasks and two classes of metrics (ie quality
and diversity), GlyphDiffusion can achieve comparable or even better results
than several baselines, including pretrained language models. Our model also
makes significant improvements compared to the recent diffusion model. | [
-0.0752949491,
-0.828050673,
0.7136579752,
0.262365222,
-0.4494933486,
0.1046689376,
0.101624243,
-0.177083984,
-0.1687030643,
0.74806422,
-0.3948505223,
-0.4898681343,
-0.7825313807,
0.1178311408,
-0.7564282417,
0.9724020958,
-0.0694520995,
-0.0813223943,
-0.2227235585,
0.1441564262,
-0.3868576288,
-0.2344021052,
-0.7185962796,
-0.5088335276,
0.20643498,
0.1369894892,
0.6961401105,
0.4630615711,
0.4250112772,
0.3327912092,
-0.1114578545,
-0.0187230408,
-0.4470697045,
0.0879811198,
-0.2904629409,
-0.1159366295,
-0.030438032,
-0.1691840291,
0.5943070054,
0.4714611173,
-0.3314703405,
-0.322309643,
0.1868655831,
0.6999288797,
-0.5408525467,
-0.0992320627,
-0.4646260142,
0.1457847506,
-0.1495947987,
-0.0948020667,
-0.5801948905,
-0.3887426555,
0.0518208034,
-0.579215169,
0.2098600417,
-0.0983855352,
0.6247677803,
0.2635378242,
-0.5650223494,
-0.7065523267,
-0.5358421803,
0.6266746521,
-0.3937466741,
0.2468942106,
0.0946409479,
0.1745500714,
-0.1945258677,
-1.0889029503,
-0.4746514261,
0.1261944175,
0.0572198071,
0.4101468921,
-0.1214425787,
-0.0831189826,
0.1425280422,
0.5554941297,
-0.6141241193,
-0.2925420403,
-0.1685085148,
0.0122851497,
0.4481316209,
-0.0952488631,
0.7352216244,
-0.3108501434,
-0.5582069159,
-0.0462267362,
-0.4661006033,
-0.3642171323,
0.0806732327,
-0.1488687992,
-0.3155549169,
0.2592155039,
0.1042585671,
0.5265795588,
0.1207914129,
-0.4948159456,
0.1525148898,
-0.4972312748,
-0.248350665,
0.0733371004,
0.8058195114,
0.4872953296,
0.3536440134,
-0.0708747581,
-0.2073208541,
0.2930208147,
0.1312945634,
-1.1307666302,
-0.5224641562,
-0.0712625384,
-0.5179389119,
-0.362801671,
-0.4527526498,
-0.9575576186,
-0.5038359761,
0.1487642676,
0.3301932812,
-0.5067229271,
-0.2242574841,
0.2951756716,
-0.5150045753,
-0.4213212729,
0.335233748,
-1.1831841469,
0.0841289237,
0.0877128243,
0.8244802952,
-0.4514445662,
0.1650252789,
-0.2114785314,
0.4445862174,
-0.6083283424,
0.8554573059,
-0.6690262556,
-0.6637881398,
0.2930197418,
-0.4584057927,
0.3864040077,
-0.3597774208,
0.5830482244,
-0.6188361645,
0.3517072499,
0.0218273755,
-0.4457396865,
-0.1961220652,
-0.1413259208,
-0.6477196217,
0.8886280656,
0.2301297188,
-0.7467660308,
0.6522201896,
-0.3756616414,
-0.4800879061,
0.3751685917,
-0.4510175288,
-0.4742467105,
0.071259737,
0.102454029,
0.4662265778,
-0.2134969532,
0.4572585523,
0.0120006828,
0.0609410889,
-0.1165001392,
-0.4578833282,
0.4167272151,
0.2787941992,
-0.1841292679,
-0.304815203,
-0.664801836,
-0.0869359374,
0.0505865663,
-0.3468787968,
-0.6343070865,
0.276658237,
0.2273957282,
0.3628122211,
0.1003308892,
-0.5288316011,
0.329641223,
-0.1388991773,
0.4729248285,
0.5374004245,
0.3640394211,
0.8640834689,
-0.1409690976,
0.2276145518,
0.1608048379,
0.1367546171,
-0.6532097459,
-1.0141762495,
-0.4073805511,
-0.4763721526,
0.1719776541,
0.3877925575,
-1.342091918,
-0.1059780121,
-0.1779945046,
0.049737636,
0.1383690983,
0.2135065496,
0.2218350619,
0.5509266853,
0.2613286376,
-0.4101510048,
-0.2549146116,
-0.7046559453,
0.1471873373,
-0.1110665426,
0.0467102788,
-0.003527022,
0.4943684936,
-0.2715657949,
0.6095458269,
-0.6384623051,
-0.2937297523,
0.0391031168,
0.7286305428,
0.0745414346,
0.4627087712,
0.7809498906,
-0.9798946381,
-0.8171964288,
0.0645633638,
-0.771922648,
-0.1492569596,
-0.4264181852,
-0.3962083459,
0.2125752568,
0.582310617,
-0.487300694,
0.5609285235,
0.9107816815,
-0.3477545083,
0.2287858725,
-0.5042641163,
0.3671132922,
-0.9577591419,
-0.3515699804,
0.2830626369,
-0.372004658,
-0.779509604,
0.2747965753,
0.1807377338,
-0.0447242483,
-0.3220693469,
0.6251324415,
-0.5922060013,
0.2707945108,
-0.6142596006,
0.1196236461,
0.118558228,
0.1429643482,
0.3344136178,
0.711661458,
0.7878708243,
-0.7131296992,
0.0285558067,
0.1908599883,
-0.3839301765,
0.868085444,
-0.3196238875,
-0.0637807623,
-0.3890480399,
0.4630569518,
-1.3502348661,
-0.1645955443,
0.3459762931,
-0.207774505,
0.2626821995,
-0.0267569758,
-0.6198109984,
-0.3181951642,
-0.1291130632,
0.7268564701,
1.0173616409,
-0.700967133,
0.3886089027,
0.1442286372,
-0.3627409339,
0.0944980606,
-0.9637827873,
0.21406883,
-0.1179480627,
-0.8203926682,
0.8682960868,
-0.2474530488,
0.0983680785,
-0.0082167424,
0.2594720423,
-0.2470570952,
-0.2533089221,
0.0849470869,
0.0558260791,
0.0023489094,
0.0764207169,
0.3159343004,
-0.0397991687,
-0.1089025363,
-0.3242003322,
0.3658766747,
0.8052245378,
-0.2993776798,
-0.3261878192,
0.7657186985,
0.2064447552,
0.1086654216,
0.4571120143,
0.5112993717,
-0.3655615151,
-0.2786465585,
-0.1415697485,
0.1005440652,
-0.5356180072,
0.079160586,
-0.2365905941,
-0.6354074478,
0.3814857304,
-0.2183671594,
0.2725714147,
0.4605937004,
0.5963876247,
-0.188802734,
1.2356318235,
0.9641506672,
0.4487511218,
0.7222134471,
-0.199082464,
-0.0228989888,
-0.3321271837,
-0.1181244254,
-0.3797359169,
-0.0935687944,
-0.6657711864,
-0.8580607176,
0.3117351532,
0.1856767386,
0.0326963589,
-0.2960749567,
-0.5879248381,
0.3847204745,
0.2787999213,
0.0890811235,
0.3757947087,
0.5185347795,
-0.31871292,
-0.0720750988,
-0.5906864405,
-0.5488376617,
0.7972266674,
0.0009125348,
0.7175996304,
0.0821630582,
0.9678398371,
0.4718950391,
0.6293330789,
-0.2436839491,
0.3392599821,
-0.5666571259,
-0.5782223344,
-0.0882478952,
-0.3598471284,
-0.6990427971,
0.0996466056,
-0.2450936735,
-0.6488357186,
0.0380196348,
0.1616268456,
0.0270101819,
0.1171260998,
-0.5965360999,
0.5613331199,
0.1711046547,
-0.2340378016,
-0.2595460713,
-0.2345964611,
0.6911551356,
-0.3486963809,
0.5579992533,
0.3025274873,
-0.0946796313,
0.4888526201,
-0.1490078568,
0.7440921068,
-0.0118382387,
-0.4945622385,
0.4292318225,
0.0632910654,
0.4718124568,
-0.1427053362,
-0.2145837843,
0.0732902661,
-0.4393240809,
-0.3732317388,
-0.6761437058,
0.4949518442,
-0.3272731006,
-0.4583558738,
-0.1810084134,
-0.1133544743,
0.3287096322,
0.2374939919,
0.6535998583,
0.4252195358,
-0.1076323614,
-0.2069880664,
0.7465763092,
-0.3688712716,
0.8058063388,
-0.1112752184,
-0.6731275916,
-0.7847911716,
1.0578819513,
-0.0643502921,
0.5963494778,
0.3955205679,
0.3364582062,
-0.5280566216,
-0.6713987589,
-0.7031399608,
0.1337524354,
-0.867428124,
-0.0118037919,
-0.3651375473,
-0.2410191149,
-0.2064263374,
-0.4330615401,
0.0722335577,
-0.1789242476,
-0.6327040792,
0.2623144686,
0.3071505725,
0.9754328728,
-0.0196120944,
0.5487208366,
-0.6407805085,
0.8762366772,
0.4269720316,
0.1679718792,
0.0070153656,
-0.5105414391,
-0.0432858281,
-0.0509576052,
-0.7215862274,
-0.9974666834,
0.2422602475,
0.4309337139,
0.5711467266,
0.3888694048,
-0.0857425779,
0.5705347061,
-0.9968450665,
0.9452033639,
0.9262766838,
-0.9097901583,
0.4568997324,
-0.3227449059,
0.5137765408,
0.0592606179,
0.4345290363,
-0.6953185797,
-0.7732540369,
-0.5923749208,
-0.7809134126,
0.2325731516,
0.5894014835,
0.5141236186,
-0.230044201,
0.5420531631,
0.2405804247,
0.0590233281,
-0.9313423634,
-0.3306235671,
-0.4510603249,
-0.3557690084,
-0.1961893141,
-0.4338735938,
0.0842821524,
-0.0183449648,
0.3746034205,
-0.1100848913,
0.1896398664,
0.2031072676,
-0.1325658858,
-0.106011875,
0.0801921338,
0.6509276628,
0.2667855024,
0.3667755723,
0.2686756253,
-0.1344788074,
-0.607204318,
0.4672143757,
-0.4349155128,
-0.6953191757,
0.2067402303,
0.3095677197,
0.5746760368,
0.0257925298,
-0.0915538296,
0.446662426,
-0.0820586979,
-0.639844358,
0.3134480715,
0.0473331846,
0.1756365597,
0.0638723001,
0.6102478504,
0.012038039,
0.4763885736,
-0.4429161847,
0.4753917754,
0.3377740085,
0.0069069024,
-0.1194733754,
0.8386909962,
0.3639017045,
-0.2461610883,
0.2391720563,
-0.4463585615,
-0.3512014747,
0.4088013172,
0.8349906802,
0.8195366263,
-0.3615676463,
0.6985405087,
0.2582905293,
0.003506938,
-0.2495435476,
0.3694824874,
-0.111099124,
-0.4030408561,
-0.4943195581,
-0.6375932693,
-0.141612947,
-0.1178155467,
-0.0626517236,
0.1919288933,
-0.6093908548,
-0.3576927483,
0.0412644818,
-0.5379912853,
-0.0931787938,
0.612901926,
0.5400127172,
0.6727690101,
-1.0166476965,
0.5726933479,
0.6738929749,
-0.1181464121,
-0.2849422395,
0.3286953866,
-0.3871807456,
-0.449564755,
0.7862238884,
0.0975593626,
-0.0525431558,
0.2326392978,
-0.5329963565,
-0.7800809741,
0.778093636,
0.3968815506,
-0.1903208494,
-0.0602448322,
0.187290594,
0.4823830128,
-0.4003958106,
0.2556713521,
0.122309342,
0.3415672481,
0.7168622017,
-0.2095301449,
0.0800695047,
-0.1490590274,
0.6411146522,
0.0674024075,
-0.5190063715,
0.8683282733,
0.0099601299,
-0.5939747691,
0.2193609178,
0.9572794437,
0.2705110908,
0.0836146101,
0.3343347609,
0.5482624769,
0.5989210606,
0.0241107065,
0.9703652859,
-0.1018902585,
0.2614319026,
0.6103847027,
-0.0209280588,
0.6242189407,
0.4109375477,
0.1525509953,
0.8558758497,
0.6216135025,
0.126456216,
1.0645968914,
0.3279460669,
-0.4953150153,
-0.3520773649,
-0.0870260894,
-0.3798397779,
0.0049914564,
0.1408094019,
-0.5586700439,
-0.6026835442,
0.2112587243,
-0.3564904034,
0.2988922596,
-0.3280045688,
0.449499011,
0.1719014198,
-0.6532772183,
0.6217507124,
0.3012732565,
0.842640996,
-0.2669399679,
-0.3786228597,
-0.2697305381,
-0.0536597297,
-0.2417394221,
-1.0392587185,
0.2198221833,
0.0651955679,
-0.322319001,
-0.9239647985,
0.7131721377,
-0.2628296316,
-0.7498170137,
0.2302680165,
0.0591350086,
0.2363347113,
0.1558780521,
-0.7179101706,
0.0754433945,
0.0008294196,
-0.1367139518,
0.1867392957,
0.6728228331,
-0.1048556268,
0.576143384,
0.4449011981,
-0.1484549791,
0.3172412515,
0.3599899411,
0.6654675603,
-0.4432703555,
-0.7307006121,
-1.1114842892,
0.8545443416,
-0.0038963926,
-0.1561289877,
0.5572736859,
0.429605633,
0.2311979383,
-0.0748048872,
0.8040971756,
0.1199223399,
-0.0987343341,
-0.9121060967,
0.8495625854,
-0.7878525853,
-0.2569478154,
-0.7928295135,
-0.6130985022,
-0.3253518343,
0.7468976974,
-0.1001388207,
0.1744192094,
0.856228292,
0.4350310862,
-0.1303370446,
-0.007059379,
0.5428849459,
-0.0941588134,
0.3811480999,
0.4647818208,
0.9018902779,
-0.60798949,
0.521504581,
0.0551596917,
-0.4652166665,
-0.0535106249,
-1.2968243361,
-0.9402870536,
-0.6761649847,
-0.7102686167,
-0.0398564637,
-0.0584898107,
-0.1760476232,
0.8586828113,
-0.3486123085,
0.0329379141,
-0.6635354757,
0.2125521153,
0.2625000477,
-0.1830193251,
-0.0957307965,
-0.2846116126,
-0.7256934643,
-0.1392502636,
0.4516512752,
0.4717237651,
-0.5693253279,
-0.051342085,
-0.0445379242,
0.2260856479,
0.7451975942,
-0.1903983802,
-0.5054574609,
-0.1740321815,
-0.2603756785,
-0.5818806291,
0.222674638,
0.4791258574,
-0.6363979578,
0.1979706287,
0.4453643858,
0.2447073907,
0.6692808867,
-0.0769911557,
0.4052881598,
-0.7177379727,
0.1763257533,
-0.286609441,
0.021205226,
0.4003482759,
-0.4149499238,
-0.0290153362,
0.466170162,
-0.3599275947,
-0.5312123895,
0.4097728729,
-0.6742880344,
-0.4211537242,
1.0681777,
-0.0354982726,
-0.3948924839,
0.0926454291,
-0.4103810787,
0.1884722859,
-0.3472865522,
0.6460465789,
0.8230256438,
0.0653085485,
-0.3975764215,
-0.3482878804,
0.4764479101,
0.1423729807,
-0.9795515537,
-0.1213732511,
0.7597994208,
0.2219538093,
0.4412277639,
1.0348623991,
0.0807216987,
0.434556663,
0.3826697767,
0.2424015999,
0.557356894,
-0.3844587207,
-0.0082872752,
0.4065959752,
-0.1412965059,
-0.0632280484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12443v1 | Understanding and Predicting Human Label Variation in Natural Language Inference through Explanation | 2023-04-24T20:45:09 | 2023-04-24T20:45:09 | Nan-Jiang Jiang, Chenhao Tan, Marie-Catherine de Marneffe | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human label variation (Plank 2022), or annotation disagreement, exists in
many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. To be robust and trusted, NLP
models need to identify such variation and be able to explain it. To this end,
we created the first ecologically valid explanation dataset with diverse
reasoning, LiveNLI. LiveNLI contains annotators' highlights and free-text
explanations for the label(s) of their choice for 122 English Natural Language
Inference items, each with at least 10 annotations. We used its explanations
for chain-of-thought prompting, and found there is still room for improvement
in GPT-3's ability to predict label distribution with in-context learning. | [
-0.8446452022,
-0.6864631772,
0.3541400433,
0.394436568,
-0.2754479647,
-0.0941011384,
0.0215783212,
-1.0862662792,
0.082428284,
0.2008268386,
-0.8410337567,
-0.5534311533,
-0.4553760886,
0.2925380468,
0.1258044094,
1.1540699005,
-0.0441587791,
-0.0833231136,
0.1877793223,
-0.4330460131,
-0.5267228484,
-0.1915061623,
-0.5070493817,
-0.5740737319,
1.0439990759,
0.2293681949,
0.9035822153,
0.8553367853,
0.1091973558,
0.1712720096,
-0.3883751333,
0.0830458403,
-0.0891472176,
0.003432825,
-0.2895916104,
-0.4700726867,
-0.3159869909,
0.1322994679,
0.4247741699,
0.9607622623,
0.1252817065,
-0.1100269854,
-0.1052594483,
0.4308944345,
-0.5441871285,
-0.1325848401,
-0.4251156747,
0.3308082223,
-0.1497481912,
0.1572860777,
-0.4040647149,
-0.3433493078,
0.4827606678,
-0.7956086993,
0.3329495788,
0.1401539743,
1.0221441984,
0.3034084737,
-0.4113512933,
-0.1793326586,
-0.6249575019,
0.7951530814,
-0.8562323451,
0.317296505,
0.551849246,
0.3493427336,
-0.0674095154,
-0.5845937133,
-0.4966049194,
0.1761554182,
-0.1481173187,
0.2801826596,
0.1272553951,
0.0477647558,
0.0418002345,
0.4345496297,
-0.6303036213,
0.4758608341,
-0.2580390573,
-0.2480614334,
0.6671777964,
-0.2650739253,
0.3481999636,
-0.2244563252,
-0.4430348277,
-0.0627949685,
-0.5416271091,
-0.1000083983,
0.422478646,
-0.0691820979,
-0.1267177314,
0.2600884438,
-0.0149958236,
0.8789231181,
-0.4327253699,
0.1506918669,
0.2227945626,
-0.1656102091,
-0.3167481124,
0.128589347,
0.6197487116,
0.4970566332,
0.0827833414,
-0.0647146627,
-0.1941566616,
0.0280726347,
-0.0004568232,
-0.3094096184,
-0.324308157,
0.3343963921,
-0.4315496385,
-0.2999988794,
-0.0378308557,
-0.9778149128,
-0.5852723122,
-0.1334382594,
0.2660235763,
-0.2787613571,
-0.29803285,
0.1420942843,
-0.3957025111,
0.0349338129,
0.4634011984,
-1.0488642454,
0.0681232139,
0.6568410397,
0.6753973365,
-0.473290205,
-0.3332783878,
-0.0684601068,
0.1272879839,
-0.1794977784,
0.9764119983,
-0.5247918963,
-0.2081763893,
-0.173634842,
-0.0461244509,
-0.0157821234,
-0.6158456802,
0.5921046734,
-0.4158478677,
0.4668603539,
-0.3939840794,
-0.669059515,
-0.472181648,
0.0958510339,
-0.822959125,
1.0740478039,
-0.0262537878,
-1.1747300625,
0.8601353168,
-0.949647963,
-0.1056068018,
0.3848364353,
0.1185083762,
-0.3739693761,
0.0093269199,
0.4333408177,
0.3064895868,
0.0453596078,
0.4087250531,
-0.4532334507,
-0.1672435999,
0.5619411469,
-0.6791980267,
0.8956457973,
0.4759756327,
-0.2379746884,
0.0623284094,
-0.8556050658,
-0.0890007988,
-0.1302053928,
-0.4578526914,
-0.2062460333,
0.227635622,
0.0190307647,
-0.1764003485,
-0.039805036,
-0.5751591325,
0.0568850227,
-0.3121961355,
0.4858800173,
0.6902747154,
0.2767202854,
0.1656028032,
-0.4588509798,
0.4021392167,
-0.1152433008,
0.2158432454,
-0.2808610499,
-1.0939052105,
-0.3323482573,
-0.3273749352,
0.2247876078,
0.4555128515,
-0.2412491739,
0.2575440109,
-0.1098180413,
-0.3970630765,
-0.4652157128,
-0.1043219417,
0.1678515226,
0.3711512387,
0.5086275339,
0.0247624554,
-0.6805855036,
-1.0232857466,
-0.5155754685,
-0.0125381825,
-0.5030891299,
0.2793035507,
0.5455912948,
-0.5906739235,
1.1742619276,
-0.3133715391,
0.3571370542,
-0.2170431465,
0.7361732721,
0.2626460791,
0.4141322374,
0.2507556081,
-0.9362360239,
-0.322691083,
0.1235186607,
-0.5204860568,
-0.2837797701,
-0.3049155772,
-0.1991339326,
0.0657372773,
0.1815218329,
-0.289383918,
0.5819541812,
0.4747399688,
-0.1552304476,
0.3888537288,
-0.289878577,
-0.4157587886,
-0.8146751523,
-0.2216377258,
0.1211742088,
-0.2368495017,
-0.53027004,
-0.2322228551,
-0.2575750649,
0.130319491,
-0.1819571406,
0.5321422815,
-0.2894874215,
-0.0565833114,
0.1094897836,
0.3042995334,
0.1398332715,
0.2414012104,
0.1889537871,
0.472081244,
0.2681730688,
-0.5791720748,
0.1916462034,
0.1642519534,
-0.3107517362,
0.3016192913,
-0.5256305337,
-0.0323013254,
-0.2852281332,
0.5481178761,
-1.2352238894,
-0.7858154774,
0.2774918079,
-0.2828413248,
0.0693516284,
-0.032088466,
-0.174902752,
-0.5176481009,
-0.158944577,
0.3239409626,
0.2597337365,
-0.7726557255,
0.3820125461,
0.1780923009,
0.0443846583,
-0.4712090492,
-0.8197582364,
-0.0442962945,
-0.3939321339,
-0.416313678,
0.1882526129,
-0.2413589656,
-0.3430685401,
-0.1824326664,
-0.3940817118,
-0.2593846023,
0.3486702144,
0.1851933748,
0.1843027174,
-0.3228651285,
0.2964307964,
0.0091779353,
-0.2386758327,
0.2243606895,
-0.4362482727,
0.0667964593,
-0.2032438815,
-0.1819933057,
-0.4589235187,
0.3552359045,
0.2229029834,
0.1032968983,
0.666226387,
0.5709528327,
-0.4271627367,
-0.0890587196,
-0.4322167039,
0.0537402369,
-0.3839040697,
0.1444026232,
-0.1663958728,
-0.7547807693,
0.6723425984,
-0.0727856606,
0.1725299656,
0.5601807833,
0.2902957201,
-0.2604358792,
0.9862165451,
0.2650237381,
0.4413518012,
0.2605390847,
0.1724704802,
0.1629657745,
-0.6263873577,
-0.3318974376,
-0.3791785538,
-0.3888090849,
-0.8828590512,
-0.4524649382,
-0.0127481082,
0.2836045325,
-0.2547771037,
-0.0065473332,
-0.7043820024,
0.8550564051,
0.5859159827,
0.1741397381,
0.0601240098,
-0.1635778993,
-0.2403603941,
-0.0775742084,
-0.5468106866,
-0.7663804293,
0.6521722674,
0.6546011567,
0.4844731987,
0.0460496955,
0.7219453454,
0.3309883177,
0.8009553552,
-0.4277620316,
0.2449996769,
-0.0087654982,
-1.0810539722,
-0.5042532086,
-0.1070687324,
-0.9745485187,
0.4508800805,
-0.0806825086,
-1.3550879955,
0.2130849659,
0.3816651702,
-0.1824745983,
0.2883106172,
-0.7342244983,
1.0328497887,
-0.2454100996,
-0.2019874752,
0.3022615314,
-1.0446341038,
0.4144550264,
-0.1307807565,
0.4499029517,
-0.2860090137,
-0.017365234,
0.7947842479,
-0.4094974995,
1.1260546446,
-0.1766041964,
-0.3109418452,
0.3434936404,
-0.0710864961,
0.3370704651,
0.256531924,
-0.3033261597,
0.0101363603,
-0.1500789374,
-0.4876082838,
-0.4853000343,
0.2889122069,
-0.7646029592,
-0.4058920145,
-0.0930108875,
-0.4950355589,
-0.1119852811,
-0.0039414656,
0.6518749595,
0.050085336,
-0.0398108885,
0.175982818,
0.8569301963,
-0.4969654679,
0.434114784,
0.068872191,
-0.4326438606,
-0.5735586882,
0.8596433997,
0.0358446054,
0.2697301507,
0.4798665345,
0.6452718973,
-0.2664447427,
-0.3725383282,
-0.2756372094,
0.0900073871,
-1.0116536617,
0.1578429341,
-0.6112102866,
0.2488728911,
0.1518187821,
-0.4447525144,
-0.0688599795,
-0.3576588631,
-0.3380421698,
-0.4776830375,
0.3071419597,
1.2515603304,
-0.3078778982,
0.4735895097,
-0.5613549352,
0.3526797295,
0.5624255538,
0.4113303423,
-0.1539857537,
-0.3309371173,
-0.0655453801,
0.4022642672,
-0.1322604716,
-1.4917014837,
0.197569117,
0.2342936099,
0.5730118752,
0.5709810853,
-0.0934961215,
0.4308413565,
0.0220121052,
1.0666488409,
0.0224034041,
-0.9727509618,
0.6739284992,
-0.5501239896,
0.4496567249,
0.2281848192,
0.5823034048,
-0.6738758683,
-0.5184201598,
-0.6644318104,
-1.1299048662,
0.6356934905,
0.097063899,
-0.3344919086,
-0.0371638536,
0.3746503294,
0.7343811989,
-0.0908971429,
-1.1464072466,
-0.2606701851,
-0.5464802384,
-0.058978755,
-0.0558201186,
-0.3280761242,
-0.2425959259,
-0.2741096318,
0.616073072,
-0.2210247964,
0.2650422156,
0.155525282,
-0.011552779,
-0.1437971592,
0.440063566,
0.8734395504,
0.9368084073,
-0.3720060587,
0.5798428059,
0.4849916101,
-0.3894196451,
-0.0259450283,
0.108388409,
-0.1732915491,
0.2466925681,
0.6792248487,
1.2165590525,
0.1440767795,
-0.3622033596,
0.162391156,
0.0084089441,
-0.338994652,
-0.0930370688,
0.1110100672,
0.25332883,
-0.047441151,
0.4119741023,
0.0166459028,
0.0146702984,
-0.2231787741,
0.1221299544,
-0.0117218066,
-0.5171614289,
-0.3646930456,
0.9621415138,
-0.0148901474,
-0.3528910875,
0.4882187247,
-0.1658830941,
-0.4931320846,
0.6640677452,
0.5178381801,
0.7805554867,
-0.1244136468,
0.6521558166,
0.2080541104,
0.2028648108,
0.1866260618,
0.2584281862,
-0.2902648449,
-0.8222247362,
-0.5396044254,
-0.4978071451,
-0.7454625964,
0.2593674362,
-0.8518648744,
-0.0452436209,
-0.2466118038,
-0.0021864015,
0.5647527575,
-0.5209556818,
-0.5686880946,
0.4717233181,
0.5042327642,
0.9967411757,
-1.1733628511,
0.5663328767,
0.8406081796,
-0.2876345813,
-0.7890280485,
0.2372548431,
-0.040559411,
-0.5741186738,
0.8622470498,
0.5433174372,
0.1961963922,
-0.2302715033,
-0.902376771,
-0.5892236233,
0.7948231101,
0.0525753461,
-0.3622640967,
0.398753643,
0.2320892066,
0.6537472606,
-0.258217752,
0.4508013129,
0.5351737142,
0.8781419992,
0.0152352387,
-0.5364559889,
-0.1082404107,
-0.061956089,
0.1759202927,
0.0207936969,
-0.1288167089,
0.6903746128,
-0.2198694199,
-0.169976294,
-0.3574377298,
0.6488411427,
0.405282855,
0.6256154776,
0.6531909108,
0.2924159765,
1.2057135105,
-0.2996466458,
1.1445567608,
0.1962028295,
0.3729878664,
1.2089486122,
-0.0800617784,
0.7250929475,
0.4086916745,
-0.3997892737,
0.6908893585,
1.3376612663,
0.0223782249,
0.3592393696,
0.3819012642,
-0.4614086449,
-0.3455434144,
-0.1176059023,
-0.2735354304,
0.2443634272,
0.5247170925,
-0.2531138659,
-0.1672089398,
0.143971011,
0.0891848505,
-0.389287442,
0.0780556425,
0.8427547812,
-0.2238248885,
-0.9404894114,
0.7792499065,
-0.2933944464,
0.3218790591,
-0.3823294938,
-0.001112524,
-0.3268373311,
0.0682105869,
-0.3151113987,
-0.9607055187,
0.1125347614,
-0.3540027738,
-0.1780566573,
-0.4325345159,
0.3552843928,
-0.3523969948,
-0.1143264621,
0.1456069946,
0.1490436345,
0.4650772214,
0.2194263488,
-0.5812080503,
-0.0828360766,
0.3156369328,
-0.5496460795,
0.0268765874,
0.6628362536,
-0.2766654789,
0.7133914232,
0.4607533216,
-0.178704828,
0.4750811756,
-0.0178748891,
0.6395020485,
-0.3984825313,
-0.4471679926,
-0.7751247883,
0.6440823674,
-0.2430025339,
-0.4884007871,
0.4438444376,
0.5200586319,
0.6027273536,
-0.2448122948,
0.9198801517,
0.1214579046,
0.5823633671,
-0.467214942,
0.322040081,
-0.3946960866,
0.3354952931,
-0.0407619253,
-0.9462080002,
-0.5720590949,
0.770620048,
-0.2255560011,
0.0158273671,
0.9156282544,
0.4942090511,
0.0248792414,
0.6191812754,
0.0448616929,
0.361379385,
0.278973341,
0.2569411397,
0.8093687892,
-0.0836600438,
0.2651649117,
-0.2386144847,
-0.1356057227,
-0.1913481802,
-1.3710627556,
-0.5281522274,
-0.2531609237,
-0.5224843621,
-0.284488827,
0.0611441918,
0.7205482721,
0.6880806684,
-1.0793857574,
0.1248977408,
-0.6072105765,
0.3730560839,
-0.3036071062,
-0.234725371,
0.2888730764,
-0.2112700343,
-0.522968173,
0.3372323513,
0.2902410328,
0.3990215957,
-0.1934842169,
-0.2085393965,
-0.4214116335,
0.0340845846,
0.2021631747,
0.4604469836,
-1.1322271824,
-0.5230102539,
-0.4264554977,
0.2691175044,
0.2590267062,
0.6306710243,
-0.5574370623,
0.6968064308,
0.5243442059,
0.4993927479,
0.4368158877,
0.1044103205,
0.6850569248,
-0.8593125343,
0.0391209945,
0.1486173123,
0.1871337891,
0.4535860419,
-0.2693454325,
0.6826242208,
0.3526882529,
-0.6717838645,
-0.670656383,
0.3641593456,
-0.7764078975,
-0.3484417796,
1.0643532276,
-0.4286331534,
-0.1915726811,
-0.5602136254,
-0.2730522454,
0.3004635274,
-0.1791217625,
0.6574806571,
0.9457350373,
-0.2524251044,
-0.3345795274,
-0.8631237149,
0.593593061,
0.4328936338,
-1.1136975288,
0.2593317926,
0.3495272696,
0.0695458725,
0.3137910962,
0.2624973357,
0.3200859725,
0.0984726176,
-0.0545113645,
0.0165960267,
0.3753511012,
-0.0346831754,
-0.0489464961,
-0.0044129468,
0.0116271256,
-0.2284392864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12425v1 | TIGTEC : Token Importance Guided TExt Counterfactuals | 2023-04-24T20:11:58 | 2023-04-24T20:11:58 | Milan Bhan, Jean-Noel Vittaut, Nicolas Chesneau, Marie-Jeanne Lesot | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ME | Counterfactual examples explain a prediction by highlighting changes of
instance that flip the outcome of a classifier. This paper proposes TIGTEC, an
efficient and modular method for generating sparse, plausible and diverse
counterfactual explanations for textual data. TIGTEC is a text editing
heuristic that targets and modifies words with high contribution using local
feature importance. A new attention-based local feature importance is proposed.
Counterfactual candidates are generated and assessed with a cost function
integrating semantic distance, while the solution space is efficiently explored
in a beam search fashion. The conducted experiments show the relevance of
TIGTEC in terms of success rate, sparsity, diversity and plausibility. This
method can be used in both model-specific or model-agnostic way, which makes it
very convenient for generating counterfactual explanations. | [
-0.4320800602,
-1.1603462696,
0.9155191779,
-0.1866174191,
-0.2767770588,
-0.2455656081,
-0.0096683158,
-0.0042073489,
0.3649232388,
0.2063380778,
-0.4333534539,
-0.6183005571,
-0.6423385739,
-0.1831473708,
-0.6826661229,
1.3005083799,
-0.0851668417,
-0.1854315102,
-0.0049263015,
-0.2279403955,
-0.5790171027,
-0.2859094441,
-0.5483353734,
-0.042379614,
0.6394972801,
0.4855590761,
0.7675454021,
0.5785801411,
0.2893466055,
0.3973279595,
-0.1549103856,
-0.0143471733,
-0.6102641225,
-0.0286477599,
-0.809622705,
-0.4560638368,
-0.4978681803,
0.1484214216,
0.3386203349,
0.3676207066,
0.1262421161,
0.280847311,
-0.1530658901,
0.2457025498,
-0.5277238488,
-0.1417107284,
-0.8011773229,
-0.1419877708,
-0.2903880477,
-0.3250797987,
-0.3199554384,
-0.4889953136,
0.1770518571,
-0.5242432356,
0.7551219463,
-0.0534026287,
0.8131363988,
0.4677082896,
-0.3703412414,
-0.1290429533,
-0.3259284794,
0.7853636146,
-0.4993613362,
0.174409017,
0.1540990323,
-0.064222835,
-0.0742587745,
-0.8877262473,
-0.5642349124,
0.2661582232,
-0.2417849153,
0.0942248181,
-0.2209379226,
0.2427873611,
0.1368476003,
0.3172815144,
-0.6043306589,
-0.078431569,
-0.0402144417,
-0.3626165986,
0.3013187647,
0.1292419583,
0.6084254384,
-0.206160292,
-0.3627888858,
0.0892657414,
-0.8061099052,
0.1545139253,
0.1045951471,
-0.0138369054,
0.0357187949,
0.5140500069,
-0.0787066892,
0.3559274971,
0.3158982694,
0.0687808245,
0.004045181,
-0.5249915123,
-0.2268383056,
0.4223803282,
0.4955718517,
0.3238075972,
0.0383443683,
-0.3757141531,
0.010411053,
0.2947866917,
0.380905956,
-1.0803624392,
0.2145940661,
0.491689384,
-0.4688007832,
-0.5375259519,
0.0277526751,
-1.0781713724,
-0.1994535029,
-0.13486664,
0.6564756632,
-0.2770510316,
-0.0664107874,
-0.1769372076,
-0.2112813294,
-0.3381007016,
0.3027031124,
-1.056571722,
-0.1682751328,
0.5982486606,
0.9634833336,
-0.1522250623,
-0.3524763584,
-0.9793772697,
-0.0212320331,
-0.319049567,
0.983536005,
-0.7718514204,
-0.461440295,
-0.260083735,
0.026658982,
-0.0145912664,
-0.070414342,
0.4125870466,
-0.2151698172,
0.2794564366,
-0.3453870416,
-0.4834379256,
-0.3196707666,
-0.0355572775,
-0.5789877176,
1.3011057377,
0.1667585373,
-1.0990979671,
0.6745375395,
-0.9123004079,
-0.6177331805,
0.0272832811,
-0.0369592719,
-0.6717430353,
0.3787472844,
0.4861615002,
0.5288877487,
0.0059258379,
0.6580600739,
-0.1172015145,
-0.6397398114,
0.1130748615,
-0.3592157066,
0.5734565854,
-0.0046475506,
-0.8392782807,
0.553052783,
-0.3265252411,
-0.0746258423,
-0.2550950944,
-0.0102168778,
-0.5129253268,
-0.1870633066,
-0.1619627476,
-0.0472975075,
0.1882570684,
-0.4845682383,
0.1276330799,
-0.4699522555,
0.5665841103,
0.493388176,
0.4422760904,
0.4196780324,
-0.0919658765,
0.4845524728,
-0.1247372329,
0.2780264914,
-0.0977372155,
-0.7484343052,
-0.4686501622,
-0.4460144043,
0.4431027174,
0.4976203144,
-1.1378554106,
0.1430640966,
-0.1203011721,
-0.429782331,
-0.2308904082,
-0.2068125308,
0.3836598098,
0.6038730145,
0.200946629,
0.0850622058,
-0.6949601769,
-0.7566575408,
-0.4270390868,
-0.2444557995,
0.2089768946,
0.1022690386,
0.6162489653,
-0.3143661022,
1.2017546892,
-0.3868584335,
0.0120965047,
-0.2755411267,
0.5737184286,
0.1307078451,
0.1540914923,
1.0050379038,
-0.8769827485,
-0.2058353573,
0.022964444,
-0.6194387674,
-0.3646769822,
-0.4956216216,
-0.1836565435,
0.2445291728,
0.6287100315,
-0.6001495719,
0.7903513312,
0.33748734,
-0.5970786214,
0.2563941479,
-0.2493223548,
0.6441605687,
-0.9390922785,
0.0484933034,
-0.1066886261,
-0.2489545047,
-0.6867324114,
-0.0149405804,
-0.1172698736,
-0.0083014667,
-0.2496836036,
0.8892524242,
-0.0718627647,
0.0015290893,
0.054270748,
0.5435780287,
-0.0796301439,
0.6190645695,
-0.0506835915,
1.0726450682,
0.2710754573,
-0.3319347501,
0.056745775,
0.1154176146,
-0.0829922259,
0.5735752583,
-0.4869645536,
-0.0045302617,
-0.1074581221,
-0.5276943445,
-1.292622447,
0.0444089398,
-0.1186467782,
-0.6458242536,
0.1905523837,
-0.1863021851,
-0.1489214748,
-0.0926485136,
-0.6837925911,
0.3288507462,
0.0655808896,
-0.7003466487,
0.7203665972,
0.3325423598,
-0.3501270413,
-0.6479115486,
-0.6905408502,
0.2904720306,
-0.3356512189,
-0.3152343035,
0.2354108244,
0.0466032885,
-0.25224787,
0.1305508912,
-0.0641957372,
0.1103667393,
0.2840203941,
0.4313682616,
0.2118293643,
-0.1600265056,
0.4876769781,
0.3051321208,
-0.1375829875,
-0.1644043773,
-0.2634533048,
0.2232170552,
-0.2447477579,
-0.0518979579,
-0.0603936352,
0.6414172053,
0.4359506965,
0.0373810269,
0.5039154887,
0.867490828,
-0.3092420399,
-0.1477992684,
-0.4431129396,
-0.0753323138,
-0.4169856608,
0.7635734677,
-0.0550713055,
-0.6615028977,
0.5531283021,
0.1539292186,
0.0077401763,
0.6032627821,
0.8212009072,
0.1115687788,
0.8130100965,
0.5237343311,
0.235022068,
0.8934760094,
-0.0310552455,
0.3760392666,
-0.1733593196,
0.1434725821,
-0.5612933636,
-0.1280967146,
-0.6874750257,
-0.3723108172,
0.5500982404,
-0.1245150417,
-0.189538762,
0.41044873,
-0.7630410194,
0.5160087347,
0.6160471439,
0.1219571158,
0.3161439002,
0.0176112968,
-0.0511604548,
-0.4492370188,
-0.733920157,
-0.5371438265,
0.9916324019,
0.0651547164,
0.3819659352,
0.1036124527,
0.5644621253,
0.6598691344,
0.7061172724,
-0.7297833562,
0.4200859666,
-0.4104656577,
-0.679107666,
-0.6545351744,
-0.3461308479,
-0.7340664268,
-0.0125278765,
-0.4461867511,
-0.9188537002,
0.3268302083,
0.2262685001,
-0.2519915998,
0.4253003895,
-1.2153836489,
1.0394831896,
0.011406865,
-0.4964643717,
-0.3777431548,
-0.2636061907,
0.0804516003,
0.0293014683,
0.0850260854,
0.406216532,
-0.0908881798,
0.6708666086,
-0.561175108,
0.866594255,
-0.246764645,
0.132937789,
0.4132855237,
0.2515049875,
0.6274904609,
0.3702637255,
-0.1522997618,
0.1935755014,
-0.0609594174,
-0.2687526345,
-0.6165853739,
0.7583572268,
-0.5011712313,
-0.7171193361,
-0.0731680319,
-0.4604514241,
-0.1923882812,
0.2851636708,
0.4735001326,
0.7826231122,
-0.2959045768,
0.1016465649,
0.7433222532,
-0.128391549,
0.8001439571,
0.0489507169,
0.0800901502,
-0.6141989231,
1.0263305902,
0.1770460159,
-0.0553691573,
0.505566597,
0.3828811347,
-0.2194342315,
-0.7721962929,
-0.6890312433,
-0.0957450122,
-0.7498936057,
-0.2714800239,
-0.5806811452,
0.072085917,
-0.1423208117,
-0.6792749763,
-0.051872354,
-0.4908683002,
-0.374800384,
-0.2536164224,
0.6457984447,
0.7853147388,
0.0702377483,
0.4159637988,
-0.5017066002,
0.5809498429,
0.644327879,
0.4855369925,
-0.0612143204,
-0.2697829902,
-0.2836790085,
-0.1571843475,
-0.004819179,
-0.9498748183,
0.3170810342,
0.0245137345,
0.7402549982,
0.2942008972,
0.1263934672,
0.3978570998,
-0.0683799684,
0.7412883639,
0.0224214289,
-1.3607048988,
0.6458996534,
-0.5224657655,
0.2427575439,
0.4794566929,
0.1046447754,
-0.3825975657,
-0.5468044877,
-0.8580379486,
-0.7894601822,
0.7035873532,
0.34371683,
-0.2676927149,
-0.1348642558,
0.5097293854,
0.1873651594,
0.2319877595,
-0.5660318732,
-0.0152820479,
-0.692337513,
-0.5209803581,
0.3821274936,
-0.550553441,
0.0339778699,
0.1441714466,
0.8594652414,
-0.2943868637,
0.0862077847,
0.690587163,
-0.1776786894,
-0.0541792773,
0.5178508759,
0.7889667749,
0.4784739614,
-0.1449446678,
0.1307371408,
0.5143049359,
-0.7334825397,
-0.2043952197,
-0.0517420657,
-0.4189213216,
0.2547124326,
0.5523694158,
0.5803224444,
0.2097332776,
-0.3270919025,
0.4855882823,
-0.0494025014,
-0.0969082415,
0.3741454184,
0.0327298678,
-0.1005401239,
0.178140685,
0.2595410645,
0.1116152704,
0.3993668258,
-0.6190564036,
0.2785480022,
0.1692742705,
-0.3640378118,
-0.2375447303,
0.8083100319,
0.4210319817,
-0.1781177223,
-0.109560959,
-0.341904819,
-0.6895694733,
0.8146431446,
0.0518580265,
1.0528997183,
-0.0996799245,
0.4428474307,
0.4930157065,
0.2920700014,
0.0820817351,
0.236647889,
-0.1417466253,
-0.3012979329,
-0.4775625169,
-0.0219522007,
-0.3985581696,
-0.3347207606,
-0.2251183242,
0.4592095912,
-0.452780664,
-0.3111402094,
0.3028407097,
-0.0672789961,
-0.3775172234,
0.1201327592,
-0.2387951165,
0.5140524507,
-0.9119054079,
0.6641867161,
0.5768241882,
-0.3413138092,
-0.529925704,
0.0513138138,
-0.0872476473,
-0.7284413576,
0.6672901511,
-0.0409436189,
-0.3815897107,
-0.2764196992,
-0.4421521425,
-0.6357287765,
0.8721616864,
0.4831001163,
-0.4434393048,
-0.1115527451,
-0.0279109497,
0.8114384413,
-0.2752347589,
0.6004529595,
0.3755874932,
0.499279052,
-0.0173326563,
-0.7900532484,
0.3528703451,
0.0567929111,
0.0997755378,
0.3219096959,
-0.5362427235,
0.6252031326,
-0.4702523649,
-0.3489413261,
-0.1226750016,
0.1627522558,
-0.2758346498,
0.5095927119,
0.4589297175,
0.408159703,
0.5426689386,
-0.3652344644,
0.8489459157,
0.0043947091,
0.6914695501,
1.0087928772,
0.1714289933,
0.4906308949,
0.456171453,
-0.0050207614,
0.4809745848,
0.5662225485,
0.0730573386,
0.4558662772,
-0.3560388684,
0.0606290288,
-0.5113698244,
-0.2537947893,
-0.0669365674,
0.3634653687,
0.4259510636,
-0.340590626,
-0.54006809,
-0.0926121622,
0.2245789021,
0.2884131074,
-0.4450039864,
0.6544677615,
-0.3166350424,
-0.586790204,
0.3093797863,
-0.2547870874,
0.5446797609,
-0.285115689,
-0.312651813,
-0.3598347306,
0.0885182768,
-0.3569144607,
-0.8904411793,
0.4264811873,
0.1228367612,
-0.4420845807,
-0.3155196011,
0.4888699651,
-0.2394330204,
-0.3749325573,
-0.0748646036,
0.3117546737,
-0.0911981985,
-0.123509191,
-0.3393450975,
-0.410361141,
0.2422124147,
-0.2684075534,
0.0349218324,
0.8199436069,
-0.5451651812,
0.3844783306,
0.4403789639,
0.0955781564,
-0.2883114815,
0.150220111,
0.6187772155,
-0.8719340563,
-0.7094814777,
-0.8119817972,
0.3974138498,
-0.1604130417,
-0.4654647112,
0.4622930884,
0.2918308377,
0.3613658249,
0.0572988838,
0.5411205888,
-0.0298582427,
0.4682982862,
-0.5729679465,
0.5913819671,
-0.4958393276,
0.3159067929,
-0.3752114177,
-0.4347990453,
-0.3155213892,
0.1402705014,
-0.5045151114,
0.0128858471,
0.9014610052,
0.7930114865,
0.167193532,
0.142764166,
0.3768899739,
0.3897499442,
0.2444928586,
0.4924838543,
0.4142257869,
-0.5218957067,
0.7872052789,
0.0799776614,
-0.0697202608,
-0.2875274122,
-1.0388240814,
-1.301956892,
-0.5778449774,
-0.5470514297,
-0.0664092004,
0.0803502649,
0.7330784202,
0.6949573755,
-0.9577801824,
0.7398383617,
-0.0844924524,
0.6526412368,
-0.1655642837,
-0.2951693535,
0.696852386,
-0.2470434308,
-0.7800676227,
-0.0714636445,
0.5920240879,
0.0948053673,
0.1098170578,
0.4764147997,
-0.182814613,
0.1056731939,
0.497197926,
0.0131615344,
-0.8358035088,
-0.7671986818,
-0.072967723,
-0.0751188397,
0.0105243055,
1.1292755604,
-0.9702792764,
0.5403757095,
0.7749422193,
0.5779401064,
0.4301969111,
-0.0647024661,
0.5204665065,
-0.9495515227,
0.3567355573,
-0.1586107463,
0.5648640394,
0.2112629563,
-0.8889608979,
0.5956232548,
0.3926245868,
-0.362449348,
-0.6732735038,
-0.1249857396,
-0.9683041573,
-0.4578441978,
0.977375567,
-0.1935968846,
-0.1797598004,
-0.448654592,
-0.5389254689,
0.2776079178,
-0.5394843817,
1.0538598299,
0.6090199947,
0.0777192563,
-0.0544799902,
-0.3925712407,
0.4547139406,
0.5612899065,
-0.9775083661,
0.2134121507,
0.2906248569,
0.2721923888,
0.0641350672,
0.2453383952,
0.0161390211,
0.5084469914,
0.3049304187,
0.1805187762,
-0.2124679834,
-0.0893693641,
-0.1671204865,
0.218898654,
-0.202596873,
-0.1313262731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12410v2 | PEFT-Ref: A Modular Reference Architecture and Typology for Parameter-Efficient Finetuning Techniques | 2023-04-24T19:43:11 | 2023-10-19T15:08:05 | Mohammed Sabry, Anya Belz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) techniques aim to improve over
the considerable cost of fully finetuning large pretrained language models
(PLM). As different PEFT techniques proliferate, it is becoming difficult to
compare them, in particular in terms of (i) the structure and functionality
they add to the PLM, (ii) the different types and degrees of efficiency
improvements achieved, (iii) performance at different downstream tasks, and
(iv) how differences in structure and functionality relate to efficiency and
task performance. To facilitate such comparisons, this paper presents a
reference architecture which standardises aspects shared by different PEFT
techniques, while isolating differences to specific locations and interactions
with the standard components. Through this process of standardising and
isolating differences, a modular view of PEFT techniques emerges, supporting
not only direct comparison of different techniques and their efficiency and
task performance, but also systematic exploration of reusability and
composability of the different types of finetuned modules. We demonstrate how
the reference architecture can be applied to understand properties and relative
advantages of PEFT techniques, hence to inform selection of techniques for
specific tasks, and design choices for new PEFT techniques. | [
-0.5441807508,
-0.7892743945,
0.4545045197,
0.2394245416,
-0.4233013093,
-0.0132073835,
-0.4758866429,
-0.1396386027,
-0.1410663575,
0.3854518533,
-0.2280659825,
-0.2343196869,
-0.0164205823,
0.2759392858,
-0.3546132147,
0.5987355709,
-0.190444991,
-0.0037461864,
-0.2868008316,
-0.095246613,
-0.0260193329,
-0.7590834498,
-0.5926072001,
-0.5078447461,
0.3741983771,
0.5036262274,
0.5377219915,
0.3484548032,
0.7480697632,
0.3929672241,
-0.156566292,
0.0276538935,
-0.150770694,
-0.1944679469,
-0.4823212326,
-0.4465381205,
-0.742425561,
0.0194781162,
0.6662679911,
0.6250319481,
-0.1998102665,
0.3803593814,
0.2690751851,
0.8406324387,
-0.5846578479,
0.2261419445,
-0.4159055054,
-0.0467698388,
-0.6298252344,
-0.1453596801,
-0.3159798682,
-0.2843297422,
0.3952130377,
-0.4611890018,
0.2013344765,
-0.2084050626,
0.5958977938,
0.2819534838,
-0.1718162447,
0.1889389902,
-0.6153535843,
0.6307479143,
-0.7583860755,
0.5695550442,
0.2792916298,
0.4834326804,
0.3574333489,
-0.9613861442,
-0.220685333,
-0.2144456804,
-0.301615864,
-0.1874138564,
0.0971915424,
0.3492055535,
0.0134158237,
0.5989502668,
-0.3770042658,
-0.1911970079,
-0.4901026487,
-0.3418213725,
0.3906680942,
-0.2022482306,
-0.0223895591,
-0.2151105851,
-0.2660437226,
0.1347933412,
-0.6946851015,
-0.1652667671,
0.5452105999,
0.3194439709,
-0.1259525567,
0.2756023109,
-0.4084210992,
0.8714308143,
0.6394936442,
-0.3046023548,
0.4709784985,
-0.4251500964,
-0.35019207,
-0.3123513162,
0.5250695348,
0.0286321696,
0.240498662,
-0.2692190111,
-0.3148839176,
-0.6788891554,
0.4295647144,
-0.6172350645,
-0.4921446443,
-0.0456561036,
-0.6500018239,
-0.1599753946,
0.0766907483,
-0.4353582859,
0.2386336923,
-0.6113064289,
0.6012765169,
-0.4899550378,
-0.3065728545,
0.0517328568,
-0.1793387234,
0.4223408401,
0.3599658608,
-0.7753899693,
0.6030295491,
0.742372334,
0.6405594349,
-0.2157475352,
-0.1199636534,
-0.289219588,
0.0288339108,
0.0175580177,
1.0791306496,
-0.6547475457,
-0.1311701089,
-0.1364564002,
-0.0150414351,
-0.1851607412,
-0.9407069683,
0.6924893856,
-0.3342598081,
0.0352342166,
-0.0105308611,
-0.370219022,
-0.5588721633,
0.1892600656,
-0.8053526282,
0.9025427699,
0.3453684449,
-0.3464321196,
0.1643989384,
-0.4845076501,
-0.3018017709,
0.0777725205,
-0.1270205826,
-0.3386956751,
0.3923862278,
-0.3324815631,
0.5035656691,
-0.5163475871,
0.281783551,
-0.1986705512,
-0.2896084487,
-0.0435045101,
-0.3080837429,
0.4413359463,
0.5723195672,
-0.2890243828,
0.0970190391,
-1.0037460327,
0.13333112,
-0.3618029356,
-0.6864644885,
-0.4106269777,
0.1131529808,
0.0684145242,
-0.1385846138,
0.39664343,
-0.223705247,
-0.0314434841,
-0.1935247183,
0.592042923,
0.3969388008,
-0.2690579593,
0.4909933209,
-0.5094521642,
0.1447899193,
-0.1394324899,
0.3076654673,
0.0005804162,
0.0134556051,
-0.6526139379,
-0.2679710686,
0.5157675743,
0.2948545516,
-0.5418220162,
0.366032958,
0.2471227497,
-0.658315599,
-0.1330009848,
0.1423243284,
0.6744941473,
0.5056663156,
0.2718838155,
-0.4112072289,
-0.4179459512,
-1.2228991985,
-0.1474018693,
-0.1996091604,
0.1133943498,
0.218917042,
0.0180717669,
0.2933882773,
0.6644684076,
-0.0615394525,
0.3317228258,
-0.2156933844,
0.253429085,
0.2528212965,
0.8043929935,
0.8260544538,
-0.8519318104,
-0.7024068832,
0.0754386932,
-0.1084818095,
-0.5078211427,
-0.0103750117,
-0.1314321309,
0.169601351,
0.4662122428,
-0.3476653397,
-0.2575916052,
0.3551707268,
-0.4164009094,
0.8352121711,
-0.0294958577,
0.2887628078,
-0.6235163212,
0.2778679132,
-0.007670356,
-0.3747115433,
-0.6988469958,
0.399279356,
0.3415904045,
0.0689845234,
-0.674990654,
0.1452785879,
-0.3264922202,
0.118451938,
0.0328643918,
-0.0805441067,
0.1701880991,
0.5911991596,
0.1025416926,
0.9196944237,
0.4099406004,
-0.4386132956,
0.2448985577,
-0.037741337,
-0.3328712881,
0.7525878549,
-0.6620697379,
0.2839247584,
0.080635123,
-0.2542873621,
-0.9259368777,
0.0201043375,
0.2659516931,
-0.0132280756,
0.5050430894,
-0.1870530546,
-0.579213798,
0.018830372,
-0.3903909028,
0.7978953719,
0.4873232543,
-0.3012902141,
0.6669047475,
0.1741095781,
-0.3985930681,
-0.2823058069,
-0.4760603905,
-0.4158023596,
-0.4083821774,
-0.5555687547,
0.5867579579,
-0.2046267837,
-0.392462939,
-0.1566049308,
-0.5693946481,
-0.4089738429,
0.12835899,
-0.1561448127,
0.0189749431,
-0.4807223082,
0.2435834259,
0.0147782778,
-0.15425542,
-0.1376315504,
-0.4217249155,
0.5184919238,
-0.2740882039,
-0.2336200774,
-0.475284487,
0.3259836435,
0.5155758262,
-0.3325833678,
0.2381008267,
0.3651789427,
-0.133354634,
0.0196114872,
-1.1175652742,
0.2808941901,
-0.5464578271,
0.2070124745,
-0.5529338121,
-0.5914547443,
0.3865080476,
-0.2730092108,
0.101019226,
0.4564283192,
0.4378924072,
0.0445307381,
0.4621284902,
0.8025380373,
0.352402389,
0.7369145155,
0.0168732125,
-0.2575488091,
-0.671405673,
-0.2625527382,
-0.8523746133,
-0.4550342858,
-0.1248586997,
-0.5309538245,
-0.1107011139,
0.4899416566,
-0.5921397209,
0.5063580871,
-0.4238865972,
0.5516684651,
0.648599565,
0.0132529456,
0.4684797525,
0.007778083,
-0.3765273392,
0.2572330534,
-0.6583355665,
-0.7644840479,
1.0657178164,
0.1832626015,
0.7522878051,
0.0320220776,
0.630838871,
0.0645151287,
0.1885859966,
-0.7816570401,
0.6107923388,
-0.5595393777,
-0.4816705287,
0.0054017282,
-0.2292855978,
-0.3521327972,
-0.0023332094,
-0.0744410902,
-0.5113087296,
0.519405067,
0.3462339342,
-0.6978048682,
0.3485420346,
-1.119320035,
0.9002305865,
-0.1678521037,
-0.3130413592,
-0.3694720864,
-0.3367880583,
-0.0414868146,
-0.4258691967,
-0.1803749502,
-0.1250357181,
-0.1985988766,
0.6760792136,
-0.3837173283,
0.6786714792,
-0.1308997124,
-0.0283974055,
0.3827492893,
-0.0291630831,
0.2573837638,
-0.1659679413,
-0.5266593099,
0.0077307713,
0.4556181729,
-0.2628486454,
-0.4482193291,
0.5296425223,
-0.7523938417,
-0.7019254565,
0.2061819136,
-0.5455437899,
-0.3437387347,
0.280882746,
0.0358807072,
0.7857052088,
-0.166214481,
0.4557659626,
0.5619891286,
-0.0659040138,
0.3982362747,
0.6338948011,
0.1251119375,
-0.2289295197,
0.7352519035,
0.2311215848,
0.4612314105,
0.7487159967,
0.1068045422,
-0.2264303118,
-0.9388807416,
0.1748573482,
0.1317180097,
-0.5065439343,
-0.3047092557,
0.0113918697,
-0.0770700574,
-0.1736132205,
-0.1850660443,
-0.3886548281,
-0.6769165993,
-0.0027509048,
-0.0084042102,
0.2145695835,
0.3231652677,
-0.0445241481,
0.4216522872,
-0.7262743115,
0.1767174155,
0.6424605846,
0.7497062683,
-0.1900063008,
-0.173917383,
-0.1688181907,
-0.4198528528,
-0.4990452826,
-0.6504483223,
-0.1146637052,
0.4084232748,
0.9076792598,
0.4794722497,
0.0908914208,
0.6831593513,
-0.658088088,
0.5702825785,
0.0351230949,
-0.9716104269,
0.3029170036,
-0.2693070471,
0.1417293996,
0.7431244254,
0.1659038365,
-0.2489558011,
-0.081637159,
-0.75031358,
-0.8080380559,
0.4670896232,
0.0038254757,
-0.0542601682,
0.1129432321,
0.8255403638,
0.4939629436,
0.290558219,
-0.3764880598,
-0.2917493582,
-0.1042140424,
-0.2022682577,
0.0586269908,
-0.3764180243,
-0.2907387018,
-0.3642591238,
0.4788905084,
-0.2139373422,
0.4679841995,
0.2625029087,
-0.1996310204,
0.0083167451,
0.4657524526,
0.3022606671,
0.9030708671,
-0.2342256159,
0.3595064282,
0.1947609335,
-0.3921726048,
0.1002247334,
0.2945256233,
0.0224545076,
0.038533546,
0.1688019037,
0.4840166867,
0.4417689145,
-0.6084449291,
0.0775467604,
0.2875041664,
-0.4298048019,
-0.1661806405,
0.3245719373,
-0.0377844423,
0.7472339869,
0.2844373286,
0.2187123746,
0.2721314728,
-0.5711381435,
0.5028266907,
0.1772724241,
-0.2228395045,
-0.6139739156,
0.2512450814,
0.555272162,
-0.6650208831,
0.1489619911,
-0.0045319507,
-0.0256487839,
0.420137614,
0.4530846775,
0.861348927,
-0.1296115518,
0.2033411562,
0.1215606034,
-0.0037785023,
0.0192450173,
0.3161622882,
-0.4498848319,
-0.4126214385,
-0.6049780846,
-0.5712288022,
-0.2645465434,
0.1862324327,
-0.7109543681,
0.1522292942,
-0.5492691398,
-0.2286310792,
0.0060649514,
0.1352429688,
-0.6305168867,
-0.1428875625,
0.2985011041,
1.4678475857,
-0.37523368,
0.9220035672,
1.0551196337,
-0.0660442114,
-0.9217554331,
0.0895829499,
0.0876269713,
-0.5177072883,
0.5159290433,
-0.251963824,
-0.0899216458,
0.0221537892,
-0.2888781428,
-0.8491620421,
1.1115041971,
0.6064383388,
-0.671227932,
-0.1482160836,
-0.122420378,
0.299595803,
-0.2139238268,
-0.0646109879,
0.9067983627,
0.5325847864,
-0.0668426305,
-1.4323017597,
-0.0174993128,
-0.4021118283,
-0.1496798247,
0.391656667,
-0.7589033842,
0.8971038461,
0.3302796781,
-0.1605109274,
0.399151504,
0.2486235052,
0.1114782989,
-0.0361544453,
0.5448807478,
0.2762595117,
0.5105422139,
-0.3065323532,
0.6493617892,
-0.5174789429,
0.5137652755,
0.9019473791,
0.2106312364,
0.9849327803,
0.6809766889,
-0.2869278789,
0.3918304741,
0.4349097311,
0.0738704279,
0.6900313497,
0.0497956574,
-0.2177690119,
-0.4708081186,
0.2106862664,
-0.3462175727,
0.1200495213,
0.2418816686,
-0.3120706975,
-0.6295413971,
-0.1434192657,
-0.2054416537,
0.0222782306,
-0.6449343562,
0.6801356673,
0.059852723,
-0.5827589631,
0.519053936,
-0.0735039636,
0.6821006536,
-0.7780305743,
0.105284974,
-0.0975166336,
0.2704657316,
-0.2157148123,
-0.5921698213,
0.6402388215,
-0.1166177839,
-0.2073028684,
-0.3984736502,
0.7080814838,
-0.2744619846,
-0.1615113914,
-0.1330520064,
0.6592810154,
0.0783074647,
-0.0394301713,
-0.7776734829,
-0.0540286638,
-0.1417789161,
-0.1988461912,
0.154235214,
0.400731653,
0.1523716152,
0.3677640259,
0.2238552421,
0.0752668604,
-0.0732006058,
0.0252179615,
0.7367511392,
-0.5763041377,
-0.2849396467,
-0.6947019696,
0.5639992356,
0.0284246337,
-0.3261352479,
0.3400678337,
0.400493294,
1.0274814367,
-0.0835149735,
0.4559316635,
-0.2234888375,
0.403288573,
-0.6229575276,
0.47807917,
-0.4795787036,
0.2977159917,
-0.3838913441,
-0.958756566,
-0.3691647649,
0.8117015362,
-0.3889406919,
-0.0351434052,
0.8399221301,
0.5683816671,
-0.4044028819,
-0.116734229,
0.1569992453,
0.1948857754,
0.005386807,
0.4754676521,
0.6235451102,
-0.0034682385,
0.594445169,
-0.5058115125,
-0.0762175545,
-0.0766012967,
-0.8556868434,
-0.6478763223,
-0.7164122462,
-0.4587056935,
0.414175421,
0.0658809841,
0.9331920743,
1.0421372652,
-0.7835276723,
-0.39069736,
-0.067456983,
-0.0244851038,
-0.4386155605,
-0.1697482914,
0.4021953344,
-0.5982201695,
-0.8369678259,
0.2199614346,
0.3750179112,
0.0497864857,
-0.099601157,
0.1266400963,
-0.0186671112,
0.195824191,
0.648576498,
0.3258993328,
-0.6474676728,
-0.5720492601,
-0.1511860937,
0.0712807775,
0.1557927579,
1.1181317568,
-0.7925475836,
0.1037416309,
0.8422793746,
0.6028646827,
0.2145055979,
-0.0230448712,
0.919149816,
-0.7040064931,
0.1298861802,
0.1092761233,
0.5908403397,
-0.0267110337,
-0.0410711244,
0.5571039319,
0.2322152257,
-0.4719485044,
-0.4825688601,
0.2879467905,
-1.1925942898,
-0.3513880372,
0.8676965237,
-0.3009692729,
-0.0882713497,
-0.3081762791,
-0.5360924602,
0.1035136059,
-0.1749072224,
0.7112223506,
0.7374597788,
-0.2743799984,
-0.1600058526,
-0.2434531152,
0.6677792668,
0.385135144,
-0.743478179,
-0.0682471469,
0.3825674355,
0.5804846287,
0.3506774902,
0.586412847,
-0.3700682223,
0.3993782401,
-0.260804981,
-0.1836948544,
-0.3338950574,
-0.399094522,
-0.2547360063,
0.5393680334,
0.3354936838,
-0.0292366762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12404v1 | Semantic Tokenizer for Enhanced Natural Language Processing | 2023-04-24T19:33:41 | 2023-04-24T19:33:41 | Sandeep Mehta, Darpan Shah, Ravindra Kulkarni, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditionally, NLP performance improvement has been focused on improving
models and increasing the number of model parameters. NLP vocabulary
construction has remained focused on maximizing the number of words represented
through subword regularization. We present a novel tokenizer that uses
semantics to drive vocabulary construction. The tokenizer includes a trainer
that uses stemming to enhance subword formation. Further optimizations and
adaptations are implemented to minimize the number of words that cannot be
encoded. The encoder is updated to integrate with the trainer. The tokenizer is
implemented as a drop-in replacement for the SentencePiece tokenizer. The new
tokenizer more than doubles the number of wordforms represented in the
vocabulary. The enhanced vocabulary significantly improves NLP model
convergence, and improves quality of word and sentence embeddings. Our
experimental results show top performance on two Glue tasks using BERT-base,
improving on models more than 50X in size. | [
-0.542000711,
-0.7316301465,
-0.1201737523,
0.2555657327,
-0.5444577932,
0.2348839492,
-0.3923320174,
-0.4739667773,
0.6513978839,
0.3161306679,
-0.3930540979,
-0.4102154374,
-0.8889228106,
0.2812224925,
-0.3558138907,
1.0527807474,
0.3519310951,
0.1675105095,
-0.1287939996,
0.0544507019,
-0.846552074,
-0.5208755732,
-0.647336185,
-0.3474196196,
0.3773550391,
-0.0645989925,
0.8904086351,
0.8374503851,
0.6176204681,
0.3382893205,
-0.4402038157,
0.306466639,
-0.2551476359,
0.0011921325,
-0.1488738209,
-0.3706701398,
-0.5892221332,
-0.2007794529,
0.5695225,
0.8697960377,
0.1059094742,
-0.0618460402,
-0.0827843845,
0.3239204288,
-0.6879977584,
-0.0822176263,
-0.9570389986,
0.0632006973,
-0.2348110676,
-0.3537350893,
-0.3242065609,
-0.0674205795,
0.1055228859,
-0.6871420145,
0.3563860059,
-0.022801809,
0.8949788213,
0.3546532393,
-0.2426719815,
-0.107314907,
-0.3041882813,
0.6813379526,
-0.8326086998,
0.6004419923,
0.0309101809,
-0.097406663,
-0.42214939,
-1.0522571802,
-0.459810555,
-0.125642851,
-0.0429764688,
0.0805065408,
0.0025120005,
0.4194028378,
0.2050899863,
0.3304429054,
-0.256420821,
0.2720096111,
-0.3621022999,
-0.3454118669,
0.1844433844,
0.0905910954,
0.4194306731,
-0.2562348247,
-0.4403686523,
0.2026034892,
-0.4000097215,
-0.1422785819,
0.1168754324,
0.5102263689,
0.4679344594,
0.7341868877,
-0.3025810421,
0.7506377101,
-0.0731814802,
-0.0870517567,
0.2459810823,
-0.3886936307,
0.0238034893,
0.2383068055,
0.2768104374,
0.5876223445,
0.0122987051,
-0.3758585155,
-0.2174325287,
0.2729230225,
0.2988817394,
-0.9833368659,
-0.2226331979,
0.1879718006,
-0.3127262592,
-0.0899592414,
0.2783021033,
-0.3110274374,
-0.2002743781,
-0.3587481976,
0.1840807647,
-0.684818387,
-0.1092758477,
0.4900382161,
-0.755758822,
0.2176280469,
0.0244501755,
-1.019665122,
0.6097415686,
1.0981373787,
1.0563769341,
-0.4121064544,
-0.1432350427,
-0.8610389233,
0.1684563607,
-0.5396495461,
0.6234967709,
-0.5675233603,
-0.191367358,
0.071556285,
-0.287786305,
0.0456391163,
-0.5114400387,
0.6892598867,
-0.6636550426,
0.1159347147,
0.1637924016,
-1.1507198811,
0.0413270071,
0.2275275141,
-0.471635133,
1.3822239637,
-0.0226954985,
-0.8653780818,
0.9417886138,
-0.9222496748,
-0.3024107516,
0.503452599,
0.2359569371,
0.076507315,
0.5194497705,
0.2933877409,
0.2731935978,
0.173511982,
0.2241788507,
0.078584969,
-0.519743681,
-0.0453718305,
-0.0390886888,
0.396809876,
-0.1604091525,
-0.0177019425,
0.3132621348,
-0.755630672,
0.0845200717,
-0.2149970084,
-0.5851112604,
-0.4623131752,
-0.2338216156,
0.3191112578,
0.1069850624,
0.5371266603,
-0.9471277595,
0.1923914254,
-1.0985621214,
0.2344362587,
0.58247298,
0.0283300746,
0.4658195078,
-0.0542058088,
0.287298888,
-0.017687168,
-0.0188774336,
0.0118383933,
-0.7064012289,
-1.1757719517,
-0.6438681483,
0.6676210165,
0.2955877483,
-0.6284191012,
0.8299401402,
-0.575075984,
-0.3364751935,
-0.5460503697,
0.1777050793,
0.0966417417,
0.3605494499,
0.588513732,
-0.6243636608,
-0.7791171074,
-0.7830813527,
-0.4544561803,
0.1955456883,
-0.2716636956,
-0.1778078824,
0.573533833,
-0.1586812139,
1.4365078211,
-0.4597091973,
-0.5354275107,
-0.390345037,
0.1999214888,
0.3451525867,
0.6924821734,
0.4550226331,
-0.6500889659,
-0.2826019526,
-0.1956050694,
-0.0503519475,
0.0026703868,
0.0098696547,
-0.2402626127,
0.2408488989,
0.4284113646,
-0.7285885215,
0.456605494,
0.213047564,
-0.5599047542,
0.2508427799,
-0.3756757081,
-0.459312439,
-1.0400643349,
-0.0530707985,
-0.3599721193,
-0.0959040076,
-0.7928084135,
0.1909142137,
-0.1514309049,
0.0180218574,
-0.4727251828,
0.4876950085,
-0.1592262089,
0.0337079093,
-0.4511102736,
0.3422089517,
-0.105472587,
0.2453176826,
0.3717192113,
0.516291976,
0.367831111,
-0.5503603816,
0.4178817868,
0.4864011705,
-0.0960968286,
0.2648174167,
-0.9319753051,
0.1047233641,
-0.1559180617,
0.273925066,
-0.7280524969,
-0.2866358757,
-0.132233873,
-0.5761449337,
0.254609704,
-0.1118651703,
-0.6745150089,
-0.2597029805,
-0.5992364287,
-0.1848193407,
0.407958746,
-0.567920506,
0.6110373139,
0.1853350252,
0.1324197501,
-0.4436515868,
-0.8072603345,
0.5942710042,
-0.0016623575,
-0.7081680894,
0.7697880268,
0.1100228131,
0.2204199731,
0.065469332,
-0.067942284,
-0.138023898,
0.2345509827,
-0.0045276647,
0.3441494107,
-0.0537424125,
0.6076545715,
0.1741078198,
-0.3326889575,
-0.1182455048,
-0.5456357002,
0.8594112396,
-0.0009135978,
0.0755028576,
-0.5047798753,
0.3415749967,
0.1408921927,
-0.4699852467,
1.0977617502,
1.0261632204,
-0.46736601,
-0.1407439858,
-0.4768743217,
-0.4206482172,
-0.4707042277,
0.5932147503,
-0.6262063384,
-1.1161206961,
0.2126185745,
-0.018807197,
0.3262357116,
0.4318468869,
0.3619260192,
0.4179590344,
1.0038542747,
0.7421429157,
0.0041737384,
0.4948380291,
-0.1265092343,
0.2452672273,
-0.8734963536,
-0.0618287921,
-0.3768664598,
-0.2728039026,
-0.6069736481,
-0.5599983335,
0.0393425673,
0.1250846535,
0.0131829875,
0.614025116,
-0.7457395792,
0.2451970726,
0.7346237898,
-0.0946549028,
0.2883343995,
-0.2246040404,
-0.3152847886,
-0.4136522412,
-0.9595828056,
-0.5911979675,
0.7705318332,
0.3421165943,
0.2999513745,
0.0768621266,
0.9263229966,
0.0744841993,
0.1103045344,
-0.968147397,
0.6534724832,
-0.282468617,
-0.547170639,
-0.188200593,
-0.1249824762,
-0.8486030698,
0.3346036673,
-0.6251289248,
-0.5414288044,
-0.1510503292,
-0.0248356014,
-0.1170598343,
0.0985356271,
-0.5430612564,
0.8747338653,
0.0885102153,
-0.012109871,
-0.3333982825,
-0.4548797905,
0.0101742661,
0.0789119974,
-0.090307638,
-0.1236771122,
-0.6735221744,
0.7665356398,
-0.828727603,
0.69087708,
-0.3251955807,
0.1743896008,
0.0014708431,
-0.0866355374,
0.4457161129,
-0.169309631,
0.1126726493,
0.0081119277,
-0.0217871647,
-0.3781749308,
-0.8523453474,
0.4599817395,
-0.2545773685,
-0.5079112649,
0.0141382366,
-0.5098176599,
-0.2343111932,
0.3319481313,
0.0850792155,
0.5169457793,
-0.0017457502,
0.4907105267,
0.3311895728,
-0.1398879588,
0.4272381067,
-0.0197100099,
-0.1454150081,
-0.3919766247,
0.7687280178,
0.163807109,
0.1807056814,
0.4007009268,
0.2766740322,
-0.339817971,
-0.7108690143,
-0.241071865,
0.0508294217,
-0.68474859,
-0.137301594,
-0.7919482589,
-0.1953131258,
-0.4937579334,
-0.2287388146,
-0.4177464247,
-0.8628270626,
-0.1545785815,
-0.2513693869,
0.5515776277,
0.430318594,
0.0072288588,
0.2650647461,
-0.7600730062,
0.1226711795,
0.1768971235,
0.3744574487,
-0.1508547515,
-0.5562809706,
-0.2348625362,
-0.3752465844,
0.2072420716,
-0.3847016394,
0.4072915614,
0.5574518442,
0.3445570469,
0.2143875211,
0.0449890271,
0.7855069041,
-0.6120538116,
0.9825837016,
0.2087850571,
-1.0474500656,
0.5847333074,
-0.2291553915,
0.4462511837,
0.419249773,
0.0018893857,
-0.5535424352,
-0.7246174216,
-0.4827357531,
-1.1244372129,
0.3625718355,
0.2151943296,
0.5590392351,
-0.4604251087,
0.2892605066,
-0.0016114378,
0.1388534904,
-0.3492133617,
-0.0640799105,
-0.362383157,
-0.3284263313,
0.2140985727,
-0.4218398929,
0.1828697473,
-0.3126950562,
0.7497172952,
-0.2953369319,
0.1695145071,
0.0512114502,
-0.118766211,
0.4554125667,
0.0960318148,
0.3173612952,
0.4296156466,
-0.1575433314,
0.1439255476,
0.5545317531,
-0.6503134966,
-0.332744658,
0.0158708077,
-0.2706434131,
0.5741089582,
0.5065491199,
0.6268336773,
0.4196072519,
-0.6407726407,
0.5109807253,
0.0330761969,
-0.118639417,
-0.2117371261,
0.1476433873,
0.1753350645,
-0.1282104105,
0.2170795649,
0.1754757017,
0.3172492385,
-0.1837230325,
0.3687740862,
0.410428375,
-0.5239020586,
0.0332587101,
0.7258528471,
0.3420389891,
-0.3622306883,
0.5765662193,
-0.045893278,
-0.7114216089,
0.2596963644,
0.5784513354,
0.6924854517,
0.3184812069,
0.0162209049,
0.4161310792,
0.2294796556,
0.2191215008,
0.1942062229,
-0.2339396924,
-0.8968700171,
-0.6746939421,
-0.7548276186,
-0.1734132916,
-0.4615455568,
-0.6556239724,
0.3548903465,
-0.3883044124,
-0.4926475883,
-0.0041952534,
0.0612462386,
-0.4592621028,
0.2162172794,
-0.0685950294,
1.2598713636,
-0.3648177981,
0.6883060932,
0.7173653841,
-0.3394903839,
-0.4832717776,
-0.2803037167,
-0.3359354436,
-0.3409137726,
0.9420745373,
0.4602743685,
-0.1260684878,
0.0132460706,
-0.1250177473,
-0.86571908,
0.8403426409,
0.1793086529,
-0.0551666357,
-0.0614986382,
0.2488590926,
0.745365262,
-0.3672170639,
0.0332449824,
0.5858504772,
0.3681000173,
0.1210461333,
-0.8213995099,
0.0109837344,
-0.2747964561,
0.5660794377,
0.2955581248,
-0.1413443983,
0.445664525,
0.1537026316,
-0.2606293857,
0.4005100131,
1.0733104944,
-0.0791139826,
-0.2602657378,
0.4284230769,
0.6455492377,
0.6773679852,
-0.1973328143,
0.8725963831,
-0.626132071,
0.1168306544,
1.2631275654,
0.2037784755,
1.0414470434,
0.7542765141,
0.1205101982,
0.5230286121,
0.3861453235,
-0.0520417467,
0.1920199245,
0.3906082511,
-0.3211643398,
-0.254278481,
-0.6924607158,
-0.0429104604,
0.7082411051,
0.2788684368,
-0.3640479147,
-0.1292359978,
0.0282587633,
0.0429788269,
0.2205072939,
-0.2958905101,
0.7812178135,
-0.2085520625,
-0.4456965923,
0.3259407282,
0.3926522732,
1.2083812952,
-0.5802094936,
0.0322008282,
0.0743345618,
0.2506440878,
-0.2196960896,
-0.3725762367,
0.5215836763,
0.0400181785,
0.243210569,
-0.194308877,
0.9729391336,
-0.3714042902,
-0.3924871683,
0.1515829116,
0.2629659772,
0.1327237934,
0.1203745306,
-0.4014470279,
-0.0920321941,
-0.5673226714,
-0.2067242563,
0.0903641805,
0.2395994812,
0.1911679059,
0.4798161387,
0.7188729644,
0.2558113039,
0.5493841767,
0.3253522813,
0.9625247121,
-0.4383041263,
-0.5904661417,
-0.7207915187,
0.569322288,
-0.5143629313,
-0.6657301188,
0.8149089217,
0.7296789885,
0.841617465,
-0.1209843904,
0.2829749286,
-0.2329263091,
0.5392205119,
-0.5196983814,
0.4103778303,
-0.2221861929,
-0.0564908236,
-0.2314706147,
-0.9294605851,
-0.7480576038,
0.6113334894,
-0.0207300484,
-0.2457975298,
0.4904994667,
0.7285977006,
0.2877422571,
-0.0754416585,
0.2510693371,
-0.0839888901,
0.3297421634,
0.1383208781,
0.5375480652,
-0.4422115684,
0.3778770864,
-0.2587414384,
-0.0807065293,
0.0480826683,
-0.7972949147,
-1.1183362007,
-0.3474989831,
-0.3061200976,
-0.0679573491,
-0.0667028949,
1.2397598028,
0.7295052409,
-0.6218605638,
0.0347888619,
-0.468868643,
-0.1098422483,
-0.1786116809,
-0.2778634727,
0.3459224403,
-0.9941891432,
-0.8084569573,
0.3308461607,
0.4053139091,
-0.186494261,
-0.1885909587,
-0.0182840433,
-0.2655125856,
0.2522499859,
0.6376390457,
-0.3526754379,
-0.7111971974,
-0.5183623433,
0.0014860729,
0.1665715873,
0.0166770611,
0.6605525613,
-0.8030765653,
0.6648101211,
0.5862181783,
0.9429933429,
0.4939962327,
-0.0880485103,
0.6855415106,
-0.9504341483,
0.3601576388,
0.2927593887,
0.360848546,
0.4059327543,
-0.1384016871,
0.5940500498,
0.3720008135,
0.0100208391,
-0.5581206679,
0.2320158929,
-0.641987741,
-0.2311950475,
0.7970351577,
-0.0266842265,
-0.1401532292,
-0.2002556622,
-0.3546824753,
0.3130890429,
-0.4090611637,
0.4587145448,
0.6980552673,
-0.1005579978,
0.1174883246,
-0.3457781672,
0.5484079719,
0.5609472394,
-0.5092936158,
-0.2553236485,
0.3976099193,
0.0625500083,
0.347227782,
0.274956584,
-0.0922228992,
0.2634103,
0.2541949153,
0.1004686281,
-0.2041467428,
-0.0896012858,
-0.1594534814,
0.234194383,
0.0655490085,
-0.3668411672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12397v1 | On the Challenges of Using Black-Box APIs for Toxicity Evaluation in Research | 2023-04-24T19:11:51 | 2023-04-24T19:11:51 | Luiza Pozzobon, Beyza Ermis, Patrick Lewis, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Perception of toxicity evolves over time and often differs between
geographies and cultural backgrounds. Similarly, black-box commercially
available APIs for detecting toxicity, such as the Perspective API, are not
static, but frequently retrained to address any unattended weaknesses and
biases. We evaluate the implications of these changes on the reproducibility of
findings that compare the relative merits of models and methods that aim to
curb toxicity. Our findings suggest that research that relied on inherited
automatic toxicity scores to compare models and techniques may have resulted in
inaccurate findings. Rescoring all models from HELM, a widely respected living
benchmark, for toxicity with the recent version of the API led to a different
ranking of widely used foundation models. We suggest caution in applying
apples-to-apples comparisons between studies and lay recommendations for a more
structured approach to evaluating toxicity over time. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/for-ai/black-box-api-challenges. | [
0.0270423256,
-0.4206891954,
0.801841855,
0.5146121383,
-0.0537681766,
-0.0176917333,
0.1860314459,
-0.9491323829,
-0.1251856685,
0.3537862301,
-0.4650005996,
-0.5035543442,
-0.4250135422,
0.186774984,
-0.0571302697,
1.0421423912,
-0.0288357902,
0.0662220493,
-0.3708101809,
-0.4682621658,
-0.9809086919,
-0.4319777191,
-0.5235327482,
-0.4198361039,
0.8797174692,
0.040410202,
0.500272572,
0.4239111841,
0.4117468297,
0.2093778998,
-0.444195956,
-0.2366091609,
-0.3869048059,
0.1791727394,
-0.4484058619,
-0.5315721631,
-0.2882574201,
0.2073717266,
-0.1453000307,
0.5957814455,
0.0657652318,
0.3508842885,
-0.052524846,
0.4473274946,
-0.9982993007,
0.1236450076,
-0.5507231951,
0.3993666172,
0.1782524884,
-0.3309996426,
-0.6441357136,
-0.2607403696,
0.6499121189,
-0.6307355762,
-0.1603440195,
0.093337141,
0.5018228889,
0.7185413837,
-0.4516689479,
-0.4572222233,
-0.8705414534,
0.9822621942,
-0.6832868457,
0.1734318733,
-0.0446799919,
0.4500241876,
0.2172022313,
-0.7595787048,
0.013516915,
-0.5455158949,
-0.0646198317,
-0.0710587874,
-0.0890279412,
-0.2848983109,
0.2147713304,
0.2205487937,
-0.2492320091,
0.0099631138,
-0.5006649494,
-0.3653349876,
0.7172583938,
0.3401020467,
0.3040851951,
-0.2981109619,
-0.4887085557,
-0.0312267225,
-0.7102510929,
0.0227829739,
0.3091293275,
0.2726367414,
-0.1297605187,
0.431558162,
-0.1944870204,
0.3475202024,
-0.1132861972,
0.2772027552,
0.5885983706,
-0.3198067546,
0.0155124171,
0.0385060124,
0.6514159441,
0.8879465461,
0.0839065313,
-0.3530900478,
0.1328346729,
0.2121819258,
0.9443514347,
-0.6827715635,
-0.4068109393,
0.563675344,
-0.546728909,
-0.6339101791,
-0.3713253736,
-0.9381284714,
-0.5979816914,
-0.0242640227,
0.7312431931,
-0.1233886629,
-0.4462912679,
0.0154183768,
-0.5225574374,
0.036245808,
0.3549256623,
-0.2943080962,
0.027108429,
0.6523141265,
0.9598973989,
-0.5167496204,
-0.2354207039,
-0.0758143365,
-0.3177790046,
-0.5059127212,
0.9232902527,
-0.6140911579,
-0.6227937937,
-0.2142340541,
0.0394650474,
0.4705878198,
-1.038613081,
0.6707500219,
-0.0835220218,
-0.0942484885,
-0.7424746752,
0.0087228324,
0.0214242246,
0.3021947742,
-0.4217702448,
0.8968827724,
0.4286692739,
-0.8717404008,
0.7314505577,
-0.6859921813,
-0.1811595857,
-0.1219891086,
0.1551360339,
-0.5292297006,
0.1367964,
-0.2287013084,
-0.1970326304,
0.1480908096,
-0.111505039,
-0.7312134504,
-0.3869849443,
0.0929145962,
-0.1470034868,
1.1774190664,
0.4205205142,
-0.5965701342,
0.1858176589,
-0.74304533,
-0.0793971196,
-0.0029360962,
-0.2066270113,
-0.78654778,
0.2337625176,
0.0193547588,
0.2327903211,
-0.0700057819,
-0.819714129,
-0.2481126636,
-0.0756796375,
0.5016406178,
0.849955678,
0.3521761298,
0.2710134387,
-0.6179401278,
0.161016345,
0.1316681802,
0.5401375294,
0.1490764469,
-0.4537724853,
-0.2340519875,
0.3574625254,
0.0792632028,
0.4916653633,
-0.3351145089,
0.3200650513,
-0.0824780911,
-0.7382110357,
-0.3684791327,
-0.2123541087,
0.4318957329,
0.7383517623,
0.6059265137,
-0.815092206,
-0.2626955211,
-0.8730790615,
-0.2912789583,
-0.115550153,
0.0058332146,
0.9407343864,
0.6972852945,
-0.376686126,
0.9468314648,
-0.5966899395,
-0.1480397582,
0.6332779527,
0.1913585514,
-0.3838898838,
0.7231391072,
0.9051546454,
-0.5450731516,
-0.2690706253,
0.0747333765,
-1.0915398598,
-0.4597405493,
0.4392615557,
-0.4292203188,
-0.1273864359,
0.3308863938,
-0.4281341732,
0.2946531177,
0.3361005485,
-0.2294230759,
0.871701479,
0.1575766802,
0.3248827457,
-0.380487591,
0.2349519134,
0.2053706348,
0.1915574819,
-0.5375787616,
0.2964828908,
0.1064071655,
-0.2100974321,
-0.7503197789,
0.5916303396,
-0.1048180908,
0.0378426649,
-0.1944853067,
-0.4054231644,
0.144132182,
0.2745625675,
0.0726460814,
0.8139724135,
0.1900817603,
-0.5015330315,
0.3650329113,
0.1367820799,
-0.1208345369,
1.0325539112,
-0.7599591613,
0.0896302834,
-0.0578128994,
0.3874932528,
-0.6257476807,
0.177673772,
0.5930927992,
-0.4308065474,
0.0768904388,
-0.2337215692,
-0.0715027675,
-0.5202544928,
-0.5444877744,
0.6252406836,
0.4225718081,
-0.2480419278,
0.3583012819,
0.3231417537,
-0.1701136529,
-0.8997189999,
-0.9775666595,
-0.0117837721,
-0.5628271103,
-0.1534403265,
-0.0358531736,
-0.4078105092,
-0.4838449061,
0.2844424546,
-0.4518565834,
0.1348778903,
0.2284805775,
0.2981662154,
-0.0405290909,
-0.095641844,
-0.0197022278,
0.1327005327,
-0.1305958629,
0.7326862216,
-0.0984953195,
-0.018165404,
0.141593352,
-0.2739810646,
-0.1287725121,
0.2313997447,
0.7506041527,
-0.3253644705,
0.4080816507,
0.0092303092,
-0.2647567093,
-0.3960738182,
-0.3371835649,
0.0545683578,
-0.4431878924,
0.1547315121,
0.1520984322,
-0.3738409877,
0.7596285343,
-0.2453004867,
0.2703234255,
0.3860937357,
0.5775384903,
-0.0031090067,
0.7117424011,
0.4091497064,
-0.003765017,
0.3064099252,
-0.2606702745,
-0.0356562771,
-1.0277701616,
-0.1305418611,
-0.5526465774,
-0.2243007123,
-0.3723340034,
-0.2404507548,
0.578566432,
-0.6828063726,
-0.6675605178,
-0.0778821334,
-0.9291847348,
0.2860482931,
0.33409217,
0.5512298346,
0.4113723338,
-0.0220112372,
0.0048797335,
0.0149762137,
-0.3362261057,
-0.2502693832,
1.3911882639,
0.5207744837,
0.744836688,
-0.2447370142,
0.4654836357,
0.5520663857,
0.8971512914,
-0.6255776286,
0.0138231525,
0.1471942514,
-1.247728467,
-0.0172063187,
-0.5110909939,
-0.7995967865,
0.2541431189,
-0.1341208518,
-0.6609638333,
0.6024682522,
0.0855481774,
-0.4935596883,
0.1069432944,
-1.166757822,
1.0942623615,
-0.3706968129,
-0.7348483205,
0.1467449516,
-0.6451635957,
0.3166047931,
-0.1804908812,
0.2301836014,
-0.0520041436,
0.1429633051,
0.4409340024,
-0.4551489353,
0.8037444949,
-0.4163793623,
-0.1358749419,
0.3561673164,
0.1363092065,
0.0272907428,
0.0991018638,
-0.1876434535,
0.3204196393,
0.2578431964,
-0.5700410008,
-0.2814621329,
0.8502499461,
-0.9178019762,
-0.5063819885,
-0.6510581374,
-0.69680053,
-0.1882694513,
0.2271848768,
0.3135350943,
0.2246630788,
0.023791749,
0.1670600474,
0.543451786,
-0.8911144137,
-0.1396063715,
0.5289972425,
-0.0406933948,
-0.1234664395,
0.7183557749,
0.337877959,
0.4525744319,
-0.1946457773,
0.3396416306,
-0.1839286238,
-0.794757843,
-0.3650796413,
-0.0913251266,
-0.6510096788,
-0.2489335537,
-0.5084559917,
-0.0528647453,
-0.1714740247,
-0.0724994019,
-0.4687256813,
0.2957015038,
0.065234147,
-0.2957462072,
0.3299559057,
0.7778320909,
-0.2521505952,
-0.0481956564,
-0.2950080037,
0.0750867799,
0.3356777132,
0.8412622809,
0.2357572764,
0.1825618297,
0.1239394471,
0.1251808554,
-0.5174256563,
-1.0583925247,
0.1600789428,
-0.478846103,
0.6651033759,
0.0130339749,
0.3878594637,
0.425568223,
-0.4375185966,
0.7211943269,
-0.3691034615,
-0.6638718247,
0.5192967057,
-0.4719854593,
0.0483299121,
0.7266433239,
0.4092128575,
-0.2820031047,
-0.792208612,
-0.3740670085,
-0.7765848637,
0.5994085073,
0.1847147942,
0.0420350768,
0.0859885886,
0.4836740494,
0.3024811745,
0.2267448455,
-0.7924796343,
-0.4835048914,
-0.4449882805,
-0.0682456195,
-0.1409973353,
-0.2493515909,
-0.4634754658,
-0.1758285612,
0.2296679467,
0.3500464559,
0.0108837541,
0.3107046485,
-0.1861618757,
-0.591950953,
0.3107835054,
0.1620683372,
0.9549722075,
-0.7357851267,
-0.0680974498,
0.2226669639,
-0.5397087336,
0.5005195737,
0.247622326,
-0.5393861532,
-0.2458979487,
0.3346627355,
0.2655731738,
0.5372161269,
-0.6911056638,
0.2752548456,
0.0320057832,
-0.1974479258,
-0.2272560447,
-0.119680956,
-0.0383478887,
0.2582426667,
0.542226851,
0.273919642,
0.4124902189,
-0.9052178264,
0.2273112833,
0.2578899562,
-0.5172887444,
0.1182292253,
0.747849822,
0.3855473697,
-0.3423489034,
0.2694256604,
-0.2287404984,
-0.1070302576,
0.6303625107,
0.1549482346,
0.4645097852,
-0.1741195172,
0.2404473424,
0.2850275636,
0.44406268,
0.1000874564,
-0.1104724482,
0.1079089195,
-0.4820201397,
-0.3626584411,
-0.6577759385,
-0.6684892178,
0.2758136988,
-0.734914422,
-0.1603933871,
-0.6431840658,
-0.2791317999,
0.2814805806,
0.0062873648,
-0.3577071726,
0.0622739382,
-0.0285328384,
0.9803348184,
-1.2373613119,
0.0184519123,
0.7952022552,
-0.5454680324,
-0.5284450054,
-0.1886918545,
0.2734339535,
-0.3256033659,
0.2844377756,
0.1634218097,
0.1028181911,
-0.249893561,
-0.6880905628,
-0.5288450122,
1.1151055098,
0.1592894942,
-0.0905009434,
-0.0587616563,
-0.1783088297,
0.9814034104,
-0.1041386053,
0.3582661152,
0.7276552916,
0.3694152534,
-0.0913715512,
-1.0296230316,
0.0587622747,
-0.3532451391,
-0.0342022516,
-0.0983173102,
-0.5532951951,
0.9096006155,
-0.0192089994,
-0.200332135,
-0.0111623155,
0.1971404552,
0.5354932547,
0.9922193885,
0.575196147,
0.7459212542,
0.2207217962,
-0.0439506173,
0.9711822271,
0.0540488884,
0.42225191,
0.8140534759,
-0.5022278428,
0.6677187681,
0.2030809373,
-0.413962245,
0.8146709204,
0.7438164353,
-0.1428362578,
0.5895959735,
0.2314065397,
-0.0484230705,
0.1919211,
-0.1156226546,
-0.65054667,
0.0274163168,
0.235542804,
-0.2147269696,
-0.5432440639,
0.0874076188,
-0.0739527568,
0.0680343211,
-0.3656615019,
0.5966887474,
0.1472459882,
-0.6038537025,
0.4035823643,
-0.4801142514,
0.8764206171,
-0.3550445139,
-0.0585218035,
-0.1593526155,
0.2420615405,
-0.2944280505,
-0.8405106068,
0.5383481979,
-0.0225938559,
0.1520074457,
0.1132389754,
0.6071944833,
0.1478981823,
-0.2884173393,
0.8132987618,
0.6850969195,
-0.0393750221,
-0.1389701664,
-0.8700171113,
0.3127075732,
-0.4239592552,
-0.0680312216,
0.3743513227,
0.477391392,
-0.0152721554,
0.9973698258,
0.5923618674,
0.2438238114,
0.230941385,
-0.1722632051,
0.7694410682,
-0.5352641344,
-0.4166385829,
-0.441460073,
0.4850274324,
0.0791441947,
-0.327619344,
0.4467363656,
0.4563312829,
0.9105904698,
-0.1624450386,
0.8094819784,
-0.0598113686,
0.4919378757,
-0.0991867483,
0.7023266554,
-0.6835814118,
0.193978712,
-0.4805708826,
-0.8218833208,
-0.1610503942,
0.4526365995,
-0.4743972719,
0.3014775217,
0.8231246471,
0.6426186562,
-0.0394095108,
-0.238723889,
-0.3326570094,
0.5061516762,
0.3415190578,
0.5459981561,
1.0068846941,
-0.1342670768,
0.6137879491,
-0.6394037604,
-0.3753796816,
-0.3316364586,
-0.8024684191,
-0.4947652519,
-0.3954041004,
-0.2291633189,
-0.6616390944,
0.4105989933,
0.4388385117,
0.6777656078,
-0.8741573691,
0.0216757283,
0.1975477785,
0.4323573709,
-0.5589909554,
-0.2925303876,
0.0260383803,
-0.1437441558,
-0.4904133976,
-0.1398270279,
0.325161159,
-0.1798177063,
-0.2992784381,
0.0589619167,
-0.0271225534,
-0.119093284,
0.7545400262,
0.615183115,
-0.590773046,
-0.8750373721,
-0.2082665116,
-0.2076366246,
0.1110524684,
0.6701416373,
-0.7521978021,
0.573563695,
0.3216733336,
0.4508053064,
0.1730748862,
0.1157278791,
0.642981112,
-0.3006724119,
0.0301222727,
0.2822957933,
0.1652362496,
0.3105808198,
-0.4652515948,
0.6520388126,
0.1856788695,
-0.6740838885,
-1.1613776684,
0.1139707714,
-1.0125178099,
-0.5450857878,
1.0220711231,
-0.1801195741,
-0.3247936964,
-0.3783602118,
-0.3227961361,
-0.0490551963,
-0.2773447335,
1.0794448853,
0.7548841834,
-0.1586615443,
-0.1740330011,
-0.8765119314,
0.5466947556,
0.113108933,
-0.797159493,
0.181044355,
0.5228280425,
0.8432387114,
0.6360823512,
0.4775490463,
-0.5067591667,
0.5050485134,
0.248373583,
-0.0517814532,
-0.0572215691,
-0.2354359329,
-0.3145054579,
0.056494765,
0.1783444583,
0.0643053278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12395v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12395v2 | Extreme Classification for Answer Type Prediction in Question Answering | 2023-04-24T19:08:51 | 2023-04-26T19:52:57 | Vinay Setty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Semantic answer type prediction (SMART) is known to be a useful step towards
effective question answering (QA) systems. The SMART task involves predicting
the top-$k$ knowledge graph (KG) types for a given natural language question.
This is challenging due to the large number of types in KGs. In this paper, we
propose use of extreme multi-label classification using Transformer models
(XBERT) by clustering KG types using structural and semantic features based on
question text. We specifically improve the clustering stage of the XBERT
pipeline using textual and structural features derived from KGs. We show that
these features can improve end-to-end performance for the SMART task, and yield
state-of-the-art results. | [
-0.5597264767,
-0.7123708129,
0.3629263043,
-0.2297374159,
-0.0139596621,
0.4359484911,
0.2817383707,
-0.540628612,
0.3158869743,
0.7350672483,
-0.5798050761,
-0.6164649129,
-0.6595156789,
0.0380953252,
-0.6801333427,
1.4320623875,
0.0492529087,
-0.1896068305,
-0.2350997031,
-0.3259106278,
-0.2432304472,
-0.7634810209,
-0.2516601682,
-0.3269901574,
0.6046546698,
0.4434851408,
0.9528615475,
0.5270220041,
0.188482374,
0.3429936469,
-0.2157118022,
0.0840852931,
-0.2427957952,
0.2793086171,
-0.0446252823,
-0.8461204171,
-0.3181052804,
-0.1726962924,
0.4260477722,
0.4625175893,
0.1417466849,
0.404987216,
-0.4833849669,
0.3044041693,
-0.2509940863,
0.2445003986,
-0.7634220719,
0.2261163741,
0.0901277885,
-0.0519393235,
-0.3332491219,
-0.454385221,
0.4088236094,
-0.4409488738,
0.2689292729,
0.3961540461,
0.7653747201,
0.2805672288,
-0.7534439564,
-0.2394293994,
-0.6820144057,
0.5417535901,
-0.4462174177,
0.3804094195,
0.2729980648,
0.5981872082,
0.0967908576,
-0.6684933901,
-0.7559762597,
0.0903388634,
-0.3763269782,
0.2514279485,
-0.0485875756,
0.2274606824,
0.0387773141,
0.2839194238,
-0.6174673438,
0.1769784838,
-0.2141776979,
-0.2191501111,
0.4914375544,
0.2769305408,
0.1740510613,
-0.4263068736,
-0.1958331913,
-0.1897899657,
-0.2390600592,
0.3969224989,
0.1408802122,
0.1175811514,
0.3624821603,
0.6424071789,
-0.3923269808,
0.8112179041,
-0.2648376524,
-0.2696343064,
0.4398185313,
0.0198367257,
0.0596687607,
0.0574081615,
0.4271706641,
0.2145120651,
0.2636349201,
-0.4789921939,
-0.0181962401,
0.0912014395,
0.2083623707,
-0.5428739786,
-0.3041908741,
0.5072511435,
-0.2411511987,
-0.4011713266,
-0.037227232,
-0.5245907903,
-0.3636351824,
-0.1412250996,
0.3690151274,
-0.3102063835,
-0.1287188977,
-0.1348427534,
-0.3372767568,
0.1746122092,
0.1369204372,
-0.4890900552,
0.2374017388,
0.4244159758,
0.3400264978,
0.0852701515,
-0.0743359551,
-0.5856948495,
0.311539501,
-0.0762460753,
1.2781894207,
-0.756288588,
-0.1340966523,
-0.0013542442,
0.0651402697,
-0.2201948464,
-0.4794209301,
0.8283874393,
-1.0642580986,
0.1294662803,
0.0410031453,
-0.6041738987,
-0.5568842292,
0.606423974,
-0.6109546423,
1.198970437,
0.4421770573,
-0.9542804956,
0.303799957,
-0.7469158173,
-0.2654812932,
0.2112078518,
0.0186360776,
-0.5131449699,
-0.1635937542,
0.171674341,
0.652959466,
-0.2355967462,
0.3572256565,
-0.3124968112,
-0.0484729335,
0.7692400813,
0.0924334303,
0.200728327,
-0.0454550162,
-0.217494756,
0.4565986097,
-1.1651579142,
0.6006824374,
-0.1683893353,
-0.1015860513,
-0.4259251654,
-0.0409425162,
-0.0798985362,
0.715986371,
0.03266,
-0.9921793342,
0.1361596882,
-0.218013525,
0.4495048821,
0.7500077486,
-0.2276476324,
0.225559786,
-0.2429704666,
0.6158988476,
0.0788604096,
0.2314247042,
0.1824899018,
-0.9165298939,
-0.7521563768,
-0.3233920038,
0.455044955,
1.0068831444,
-1.0012624264,
0.4802215695,
-0.4669557512,
-0.9052279592,
-0.5748974085,
-0.0282584429,
0.679452002,
0.6873450279,
0.6729930639,
0.3621413708,
-0.4576969445,
-0.9808965921,
-0.0928375199,
-0.279428184,
-0.0054822816,
0.3326392472,
0.4609821737,
-0.2858520448,
1.28236413,
-1.175904274,
-0.3118245006,
-0.4622980058,
0.2589995265,
0.2322481275,
-0.1296326965,
0.2072108984,
-1.2703220844,
-0.7666466832,
0.0904330239,
-0.5301055908,
0.1773246676,
0.4487468302,
-0.1401946545,
0.0361869931,
0.3764152825,
-0.4209515452,
0.2316689789,
0.3320278227,
-0.4652569592,
0.4866214395,
0.082866393,
-0.0656726062,
-0.8778839111,
-0.1130910739,
0.0180411879,
-0.2015860379,
-0.9726689458,
-0.112147741,
0.2855567336,
0.014231991,
-0.3637083173,
0.4555608034,
0.2058231533,
0.1053211167,
-0.0849973038,
0.143923074,
-0.0516443439,
0.5451157689,
0.1945302784,
0.3066391945,
0.5631034374,
-0.4496740401,
0.5746853948,
0.5809472799,
-0.2008531243,
0.2393530309,
-0.6273578405,
0.0990355909,
-0.5566213131,
0.4667330086,
-1.3954335451,
-0.1812376678,
-0.1928467155,
-0.8006100059,
0.1968501359,
0.0086131869,
-0.7120860815,
-0.8686364293,
-0.3405366838,
0.0510612056,
0.4995774329,
-0.3056646585,
0.7469935417,
0.2254451215,
-0.2111286074,
-0.4900897443,
-0.5133101344,
-0.3129428327,
-0.1876152307,
-0.8864067793,
0.4699780941,
-0.0585596375,
0.2198089212,
0.2405907363,
0.0477692112,
-0.286136061,
-0.1279539913,
0.2150532007,
0.3906689882,
0.0143851833,
0.3408624828,
0.2403326631,
-0.3518194854,
-0.1793030947,
-0.3615958095,
0.3638622761,
-0.1576271802,
0.195859462,
0.0448040888,
0.5462250113,
0.7613834739,
-0.345998019,
1.0710306168,
0.6204071641,
-0.163279444,
-0.1882747859,
-0.5095183849,
-0.101619646,
-0.4322645664,
0.6258224249,
-0.4100469351,
-1.2089041471,
0.7534886599,
0.0754451007,
0.0817487836,
0.4054688513,
0.2440752089,
-0.0943006352,
1.4674652815,
0.8402709961,
0.1722739935,
0.088757582,
-0.4157378376,
0.5645734668,
-0.8278005123,
-0.6671635509,
-0.6560178995,
-0.2994852066,
-0.5607025027,
-0.1386962086,
0.8666613102,
0.0177595876,
-0.082481429,
0.4479112327,
-0.7463202477,
0.0637096465,
0.5695071816,
0.039382536,
0.2133960128,
-0.1336627305,
-0.1023705304,
0.0279313624,
-0.8457994461,
-0.3468651772,
0.9966753125,
0.2184292525,
0.4835481346,
-0.1103024185,
0.3993301988,
0.2132141888,
0.6038703918,
-0.8128302097,
0.6482579708,
-0.2700644732,
-0.8213611841,
-0.5732027292,
-0.4151903689,
-0.6901214719,
0.4108134806,
-0.3047586381,
-0.6849178672,
-0.2395355105,
0.0165577643,
-0.4438549578,
0.3817054331,
-0.6968086362,
0.697290957,
-0.0660691336,
0.4613760114,
0.3005294502,
-1.0858819485,
0.1787165105,
-0.2674177289,
0.3252120018,
0.0838936493,
-0.0478011668,
1.055077076,
-0.2426828891,
0.7445375323,
-0.0813050345,
-0.0295680258,
0.5275720358,
-0.441762656,
0.6552062631,
-0.1619996428,
-0.2239232063,
-0.3948373199,
0.1549962908,
-0.3782538176,
-1.0332856178,
0.3097821474,
-1.0510767698,
-0.5181627274,
-0.1369476467,
-0.7426854372,
-0.6718751788,
0.0129436087,
0.4226458669,
0.6967696548,
0.4386774004,
0.0710083023,
0.9498088956,
0.0198793877,
0.2740549445,
0.5699195862,
-0.2328869849,
-0.4855818748,
1.1440538168,
0.7648426294,
0.2106877416,
0.9276189208,
0.3930027187,
-0.7059383392,
-0.5331077576,
-0.5183449984,
0.074472867,
-1.0304231644,
-0.4465335011,
-1.3844058514,
-0.4776283503,
-0.6483992338,
-0.1086789742,
0.0105639221,
-0.7550739646,
0.0351010486,
-0.4602052271,
0.6043047309,
0.7065146565,
0.5558946729,
0.2920310497,
-1.2438559532,
0.3603926897,
0.6815850139,
0.2722741365,
-0.0442398898,
-0.6448566914,
-0.1728633642,
-0.2935934961,
-0.4088541865,
-0.7913863063,
0.1601654887,
0.2400326878,
0.700453043,
0.2673920393,
0.6281237602,
0.2373393774,
-0.295909375,
0.5958800912,
0.2133948952,
-0.6603823304,
0.5286458731,
-0.145770058,
0.2052855343,
0.3634543717,
0.9817485809,
-0.6259894371,
-0.5537342429,
-0.6323127151,
-1.0367679596,
0.4926868677,
0.0572907813,
0.0462417416,
-0.1223645061,
0.2004766017,
0.4099897444,
0.2902005613,
-0.8078520298,
-0.5551626086,
-0.2984568775,
-0.2542636395,
0.1223097593,
-0.2200569957,
0.0259055533,
-0.4282505214,
0.7834281921,
-0.467649281,
0.2460867912,
0.1472398788,
0.1179089993,
0.1481286585,
0.6180432439,
0.2923650444,
0.4500472844,
-0.207833901,
0.2181657553,
0.3725119531,
-0.2695972621,
0.3456014097,
0.1525958478,
-0.2172684222,
-0.1033467948,
0.2098176181,
0.6984440684,
-0.1491206437,
-0.7960085869,
0.3527361155,
0.0965633392,
-0.1570757776,
-0.3161388338,
0.1732393056,
-0.0280591473,
0.1801666617,
0.4718685746,
0.0286609959,
0.2212172151,
-0.513733089,
0.0841929391,
0.1790177673,
-0.7838588953,
-0.1911990941,
0.2755497694,
0.0663209409,
-0.1263241768,
0.6666609645,
-0.3655443192,
-1.2529172897,
0.7200818658,
0.581576705,
0.6330717802,
-0.2415703535,
0.5325457454,
-0.0409900136,
-0.0170153659,
0.452283293,
0.4147562683,
0.1556127369,
-0.729785502,
-0.5180850625,
-0.6545680165,
-0.4409385324,
-0.1661221534,
-0.5518273711,
0.2042430192,
-0.0971808061,
0.0015378161,
0.1162706912,
-0.2119585127,
-0.3212427199,
0.6719481945,
0.046154052,
0.8404194117,
-0.9751122594,
0.8421391845,
1.2337517738,
-0.0242270418,
-0.7873684168,
-0.5322295427,
-0.4235688746,
-0.6769701242,
0.7654343247,
0.3864175677,
-0.0216997266,
0.1024292037,
-0.4453833103,
-1.086869359,
1.0746541023,
-0.1209265664,
-0.0141988778,
-0.2386530489,
0.4707867503,
0.5591359138,
-0.2196541131,
0.5255222917,
0.4159297943,
0.5065672398,
0.5055392385,
-0.7872677445,
-0.0072843865,
-0.402137816,
-0.056329105,
0.607493341,
-0.6477118134,
0.5599284768,
-0.1808568537,
0.2381022125,
-0.0831387267,
0.839389801,
0.1220963299,
0.2384856343,
0.6393657327,
0.6888062954,
0.7947383523,
-0.1230665445,
0.9793077707,
-0.1806872189,
0.4628713429,
0.7299641967,
-0.0868772939,
0.7208963633,
-0.0220312085,
-0.205425337,
0.8224254847,
0.6011309624,
0.1163955852,
0.5733513236,
0.4299379885,
-0.2117515206,
-0.4081160128,
-0.276755631,
-0.3875420094,
0.4371999502,
0.4936608672,
-0.20827806,
-0.1270867288,
0.4334014654,
0.1125207022,
-0.1406975389,
-0.5288392305,
0.6484149694,
-0.2743433714,
-0.8624691963,
0.4953296185,
-0.003316954,
0.7077556849,
-0.6618885398,
0.0384962261,
0.1780163199,
0.1653104573,
-0.4544806182,
-1.1873381138,
0.3172604442,
-0.3305960596,
-0.6058492064,
-0.063846387,
0.845854938,
-0.2955617011,
-0.5996311903,
0.4185025096,
0.3061083257,
-0.0607341155,
-0.3183942139,
-0.5173084736,
-0.5530334115,
-0.079499796,
-0.2506625652,
0.3494895399,
0.4650519192,
-0.349183917,
1.0965602398,
0.3340784907,
-0.5894711614,
0.6057585478,
-0.2068728358,
1.2519233227,
-0.5801177621,
-0.7398472428,
-0.3056219816,
0.6173796058,
-0.0615947545,
-0.3850232959,
0.5088887811,
0.4499433935,
0.553230226,
-0.0306250025,
0.956345439,
-0.2828416526,
0.7451056242,
-0.1744783223,
0.4500572383,
-0.2619690597,
-0.2875150144,
-0.4379571378,
-0.8546146154,
-0.3660809994,
-0.1353211254,
-0.2995355725,
-0.1368016005,
0.9029815793,
0.5910771489,
0.1343564391,
0.3987584114,
0.5086606145,
0.1071518809,
0.3478856385,
0.5085877776,
0.8253023028,
-0.3214716613,
1.2603183985,
-0.4305156469,
-0.536829412,
-0.0198013019,
-0.4434081018,
-0.9084148407,
-0.6785915494,
-0.5007699728,
-0.4217176139,
-0.3546397388,
0.5973873734,
0.7716376185,
-0.8789927959,
0.2671717703,
0.1201056987,
0.1801727712,
-0.151625067,
-0.2632698119,
0.5901473165,
-0.278773278,
-0.3204162419,
-0.0633784607,
0.3247955441,
-0.0914624259,
-0.0676184893,
0.2906556726,
-0.2192925215,
0.0179941244,
0.9218398333,
0.1663225889,
-0.463337481,
-0.411503464,
0.5536186099,
0.2572568953,
0.0202447828,
0.7216578722,
-1.0164293051,
0.2077308297,
0.5894616842,
0.690644443,
0.3725899756,
-0.1247033328,
0.0763335004,
-0.4308415651,
-0.4076273739,
0.3636946976,
0.1800045222,
0.1074826047,
-0.4360369444,
0.4147233665,
0.1408924758,
-0.5953405499,
-0.4143586159,
0.2906641662,
-0.9409406185,
-0.2103661895,
1.0654207468,
-0.3697086871,
-0.3105400503,
-0.862249136,
-0.2545432448,
0.2629829645,
-0.2484353334,
0.6109016538,
0.6212885976,
-0.7361612916,
-0.1075790823,
-0.4042535722,
-0.0540610366,
0.4379039705,
-0.9713032246,
-0.2311671972,
-0.0899577364,
0.1545239985,
0.7063778639,
0.2315312028,
-0.1240532473,
0.0869804025,
-0.3829616308,
-0.0757817477,
-0.0129660349,
-0.4252857566,
0.3831353188,
0.6935744882,
-0.0254611205,
-0.0283281263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12370v1 | Better Question-Answering Models on a Budget | 2023-04-24T18:06:27 | 2023-04-24T18:06:27 | Yudhanjaya Wijeratne, Ishan Marikar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) and question-answer datasets from large language
models have made it much easier for much smaller models to be finetuned to the
point where they display sophisticated conversational abilities. In this paper,
we present Eluwa, a family of LoRA models that use the Stanford Alpaca dataset
and massively improve the capabilities of Facebook's OPT 1.3B, 2.7B and 6.7B
models. We benchmark these models in multiple ways, including letting GPT-4
judge their answers to prompts that span general knowledge, writing,
programming and other tasks. We show that smaller models here can be fine-tuned
to be as performant as models 3x larger - all for as little as 40 USD in
compute. | [
-0.6269136667,
-1.1469825506,
0.5083210468,
-0.0122534893,
-0.0888944566,
-0.2415014058,
0.1556681246,
-0.9137172103,
0.4127192497,
0.6904476285,
-0.6232660413,
-0.05993421,
-0.3364579082,
0.118792668,
-0.3272892237,
0.9039576054,
0.3447037041,
-0.538356483,
-0.1807924062,
-0.4018737376,
-0.507735014,
-0.0860202834,
-0.7695757747,
-0.1929724067,
0.9164773822,
0.677801609,
0.9040055275,
0.358424753,
0.693916142,
0.1844885945,
0.0141049707,
0.2095338255,
-0.5366467834,
-0.1614927649,
-0.1610328555,
-0.4924460053,
-0.7327914834,
-0.1472356319,
0.0299612284,
0.7868149281,
-0.2678364217,
0.6129384637,
-0.2480764985,
0.7798839211,
-0.5068275332,
0.1275149137,
-0.952003479,
-0.5220304728,
0.3505245149,
0.0128342798,
-0.2933546007,
-0.5510268211,
0.4361003041,
-0.9756996632,
0.0067101861,
0.1033643708,
0.9668782353,
0.5622558594,
-0.3451928198,
-0.3296758831,
-0.685601294,
0.4520221949,
-0.9356426597,
0.1017486304,
0.5890223384,
0.4023895264,
-0.0607697926,
-0.3566185236,
-0.3800131679,
0.1051651239,
0.0491786003,
0.2270361632,
-0.4994532168,
-0.0247104224,
0.1781272441,
0.17951563,
-0.5101285577,
0.3100110292,
-0.68637079,
0.3111417592,
0.6081782579,
-0.007418029,
-0.0926977172,
-0.3317531645,
0.3271022141,
-0.1969264895,
-0.6294265389,
0.1855276525,
0.3372311592,
0.5030206442,
-0.0553860627,
0.5382899046,
-0.7463262081,
0.9875882268,
-0.0259125009,
0.0210777242,
0.0398649611,
0.0281129945,
-0.3890789747,
-0.3043580651,
0.1606110781,
0.3351162672,
0.2653936446,
0.0643095449,
0.1137553379,
0.1454315782,
0.1037203074,
-0.9404733181,
-0.3382141292,
0.3380396962,
-0.3453311622,
-0.2415202409,
-0.190393582,
-0.5396296382,
-0.3588443995,
-0.1051635519,
0.7381824851,
-0.1011876836,
0.0866947994,
0.2883332372,
-0.0084860772,
0.6441443563,
0.6669769883,
-1.013168931,
0.3985829055,
0.4160618484,
0.6952438951,
0.0956735387,
0.0346897766,
-0.7254235744,
-0.0951211154,
-0.491648078,
1.1194727421,
-0.4619012773,
-0.1714380682,
-0.0538369045,
-0.0543227345,
-0.1095749363,
-0.5165905356,
0.4054315388,
-0.8701386452,
0.3103746772,
-0.61407125,
-0.2833915651,
-0.3776806593,
0.3488149941,
-0.9661096931,
0.9856843948,
0.3816972673,
-0.5238806009,
0.0843880251,
-0.9288420677,
-0.2986434996,
-0.0623401552,
0.2739804685,
-0.0317701437,
0.160840258,
0.8540293574,
0.2802532911,
-0.4370541275,
-0.2921357155,
-0.4096221626,
-0.3091053665,
0.0091701513,
-0.1317539811,
0.5706108212,
0.1818676889,
0.1685994565,
-0.0401177146,
-1.0374081135,
0.0710940659,
0.2327055633,
-0.4635467231,
-0.4503182769,
-0.0962753221,
-0.2418825477,
0.2334596217,
0.2727320492,
-0.4796682894,
0.0786180571,
-0.7061191201,
0.7399946451,
0.7609810233,
0.0070105148,
0.3713196516,
-0.4744684994,
0.5722748637,
-0.1404722184,
0.1912232488,
-0.2074683458,
-0.7965953946,
-1.0105279684,
0.0109822303,
0.163652271,
0.6684921384,
-0.7443038821,
0.1102683917,
-0.3700759709,
-0.5627231002,
-0.8609221578,
0.3604277968,
-0.1035178229,
0.6377552748,
0.4366606772,
-0.0478362143,
-0.2318238616,
-1.0383534431,
-0.0827044919,
-0.4986418784,
-0.1962386966,
0.6946056485,
0.5628093481,
-0.0649316832,
1.0823813677,
-0.6696636081,
-0.0259330552,
-0.1493120641,
-0.0247537643,
0.380658716,
0.031523481,
0.697688818,
-0.6774540544,
-0.4490896761,
0.1771342605,
-0.362560451,
-0.2485710829,
0.2788960636,
-0.135897398,
-0.022974493,
0.3977798522,
-0.5123376846,
0.2992923558,
0.7908662558,
-0.3386442065,
0.0601566657,
-0.2201943099,
0.0004676778,
-1.2782226801,
0.0401390493,
-0.2379521281,
-0.4750757515,
-0.4527034461,
0.0627247319,
-0.0485424884,
-0.2240932882,
-0.3911771178,
0.5654685497,
-0.0848563015,
-0.2606340349,
-0.2810827196,
0.4729357958,
0.2643996477,
0.584584713,
-0.3512998223,
0.8198501468,
0.0254046842,
-0.52793926,
0.4575652182,
0.6678630114,
-0.4944760501,
0.5045437217,
-1.2235938311,
0.5693671107,
-0.2979559898,
0.237412408,
-0.829244554,
-0.5087787509,
-0.2316083759,
-0.2197420895,
-0.4076896608,
-0.0127218934,
-0.252728492,
-0.6197918057,
-0.3636143804,
0.1981921494,
0.640663445,
-0.8296786547,
0.8220781684,
0.2374522835,
-0.6406148672,
-0.4062696099,
-0.4565469623,
-0.2194657028,
-0.1543338299,
-0.6599802375,
0.1986237466,
-0.3407867849,
-0.1594256759,
0.0334281921,
0.3285482228,
-0.0746903941,
0.1303956062,
0.1030121744,
0.3189605474,
-0.5100438595,
0.2409958988,
0.298753798,
0.1235788912,
-0.2539459467,
0.0600249991,
0.5566705465,
-0.273727119,
-0.2223218381,
-0.0885927156,
0.2020052969,
0.5336617827,
-0.3458348811,
0.7430098653,
0.09807612,
-0.5297932029,
-0.1785893887,
-0.6749914289,
-0.2196141183,
-0.4727736115,
0.4898611903,
-0.3281296492,
-0.9004437923,
0.7479375005,
0.1971906126,
0.4640883505,
0.5267299414,
0.4791315198,
-0.0604269132,
0.8737707734,
0.6482291818,
-0.1598853916,
0.4217257798,
-0.0162330922,
0.1858669519,
-0.5931274295,
0.1226695776,
-0.7472597957,
-0.3297547698,
-0.4113577902,
-0.5022408962,
0.2276807874,
-0.0470635891,
-0.2852376401,
0.4780425131,
-0.3347724676,
0.7234597206,
0.5611152649,
0.1822118163,
0.3711672425,
-0.1334965378,
0.6196404099,
0.429846555,
-0.7630669475,
-0.5279673338,
1.1197285652,
0.4103471637,
0.831343174,
0.150166437,
0.2700317204,
0.2693374455,
0.450391382,
-0.5847492814,
0.3578509986,
-0.3557614088,
-0.662369132,
-0.5508046746,
-0.3102088869,
-0.7108023167,
0.3356154263,
-0.2889013588,
-0.8444516659,
0.4573119283,
0.3246025145,
-0.9451673627,
0.0083767399,
-0.8743262291,
0.7469046116,
0.1187946051,
0.0784584656,
-0.2758977115,
-0.3409965932,
0.1475794315,
-0.2645778358,
0.2879728377,
-0.5063704848,
0.106690906,
1.0391002893,
-0.2411333323,
0.6618070602,
-0.1047796905,
-0.3608603477,
0.4567426741,
-0.2474675328,
0.651140511,
0.0237705037,
-0.3597326577,
-0.3923290968,
0.3685138524,
-0.5808026791,
-0.7531809211,
0.6624517441,
-1.0994302034,
-0.5254517198,
0.2275418192,
-0.7956101298,
-0.7183596492,
0.0193662345,
0.1331038326,
0.4409811795,
-0.4098828733,
0.4362647533,
0.4995478392,
-0.377004087,
0.3039375246,
0.5204780698,
-0.3574509919,
-0.3755932748,
0.6592957973,
0.2229980379,
0.4006453156,
0.4195319414,
0.2676333785,
-0.2030739039,
-0.1644077003,
-0.611392796,
0.1934472919,
-0.944450438,
-0.2387551814,
-0.6659002304,
-0.0524425395,
-0.499761045,
-0.2562504709,
-0.3362102807,
-0.9352834225,
-0.1437560618,
-0.3982799351,
0.738905549,
0.7509381771,
0.1332433522,
0.7067742944,
-0.4092626274,
0.5400102139,
0.9361949563,
-0.0472823419,
0.0007508466,
-0.8188690543,
-0.2110963464,
0.0392589197,
-0.3108374476,
-0.6573355198,
0.1412661374,
0.5477454662,
0.0527936928,
0.2706751525,
0.2058290392,
0.8106669784,
-0.3847611845,
0.5591483712,
-0.0821836367,
-0.7435045242,
0.6198490262,
-0.4922527075,
0.3206183314,
0.7193139791,
0.0009843963,
-0.3856374621,
-0.1347679794,
-0.3649041951,
-0.6929571033,
0.5286560059,
0.0601852387,
0.4871239364,
0.0698497593,
0.559240222,
0.3295711279,
0.127423659,
-0.6850808859,
0.2408671975,
-0.2007668018,
-0.380485177,
-0.0754724368,
-0.0718025863,
0.0201193728,
-0.3984097242,
0.870960474,
-0.5263615251,
0.0999908149,
-0.0026152022,
-0.1259039938,
-0.1334383935,
0.3678326011,
0.2985375226,
0.8127325177,
-0.3685408235,
-0.288916111,
0.6113471389,
-0.2099925429,
-0.0390166305,
0.2841288149,
-0.3326082528,
-0.188270703,
0.2175191343,
1.0162312984,
0.147210151,
-0.7020059824,
0.2891651988,
0.0194589011,
-0.142822668,
0.0732730478,
0.2570025325,
0.4021939933,
0.2579725981,
0.3398811817,
-0.3319676816,
-0.0287669562,
-0.6158667207,
-0.3440842927,
0.2945162654,
-0.1712210923,
-0.262601316,
0.6528816223,
0.4984378815,
-0.3435540795,
0.5822448134,
0.2199670225,
-0.2404247969,
0.7431232333,
0.5351827741,
0.4555479884,
-0.2551907897,
0.5174021125,
0.2999149263,
0.526804626,
0.0077132699,
0.4218759835,
0.0844940469,
-0.8303951621,
-0.2434446216,
-0.5436124802,
-0.8644129634,
0.1742976308,
-0.8760051131,
0.094799228,
-0.4304427207,
-0.1479857713,
0.2775813341,
0.0108217532,
-0.8760505319,
0.2985683382,
-0.2118498832,
0.9680547714,
-0.872699976,
0.6683388352,
0.5242396593,
-0.327555716,
-0.7373611927,
-0.4871376455,
-0.6259179115,
-0.7739334106,
0.2088621259,
0.219697684,
-0.11045973,
0.2144997567,
-0.6236850023,
-0.9435513616,
1.1354578733,
0.6695878506,
-0.593737781,
-0.4141673148,
0.1399299502,
0.507266283,
-0.4143800139,
0.1912797689,
0.8386520743,
0.1942092329,
-0.0682868734,
-0.9436047673,
-0.2676186562,
-0.2007092088,
-0.2144611925,
-0.0766408965,
-0.7692533135,
0.9214906096,
-0.4237484634,
0.1810321808,
0.3326660395,
0.766109705,
0.1679461449,
0.2003327757,
0.580257237,
0.3927886486,
1.0783523321,
0.0132003147,
0.9287316799,
-0.1259686947,
0.2017122358,
1.1922047138,
-0.3866120577,
1.3980518579,
0.4131852984,
-0.1733872443,
0.7696820498,
0.6770297885,
0.247727111,
0.4921218455,
-0.1382572204,
0.2451243252,
-0.4762686789,
-0.1275044978,
-0.2968721688,
0.3426020443,
0.2888259888,
0.0077906991,
-0.0078235874,
0.1797035336,
-0.306034565,
-0.1245145574,
-0.4068628252,
0.7895454764,
0.1964106411,
-0.6781800985,
0.4362389743,
0.0292424206,
0.4978993833,
-0.6060931683,
0.1402112991,
-0.4360366762,
0.1669196039,
-0.120913431,
-0.2299805135,
-0.0020562082,
0.0590513013,
-0.2973329723,
0.4473836124,
0.7138614058,
-0.1270920783,
-0.7943230271,
0.3196416795,
0.7003023028,
-0.0626597106,
-0.124486424,
-0.6023485661,
-0.156799376,
-0.4270004332,
-0.3868886828,
-0.1009072587,
0.0203855652,
-0.2670244575,
0.834854126,
0.6814556718,
-0.1206513122,
0.1880520433,
0.1787260473,
0.808296144,
-0.5329924226,
-0.88226372,
-0.3578368425,
-0.0113873668,
-0.0955484733,
-0.4283078313,
0.5453824997,
0.3128763139,
0.6160421968,
-0.0137253264,
0.6603150368,
0.0771355405,
0.8079349399,
-0.3944941163,
0.5552068949,
-0.6603760123,
0.0702676699,
-0.4895253778,
-1.0513848066,
0.0102845943,
0.765229702,
-0.5535668731,
0.0522026792,
0.29431656,
0.7298646569,
-0.1224619821,
0.3113502264,
0.4001649022,
0.1647183597,
0.4421724677,
0.7876790762,
0.7758644223,
-0.6914815903,
0.6491297483,
-0.1757957488,
-0.2104838192,
-0.3300599158,
-0.7320100665,
-1.011010766,
-0.2644980252,
-0.2943118215,
-0.1288107336,
0.0693945587,
0.965418458,
0.9171186686,
-0.8582601547,
0.0936411247,
0.2661787868,
-0.0208694283,
-0.2502130568,
-0.1097626239,
0.5922157168,
0.1209152341,
-0.5835907459,
0.4188481271,
0.2163264304,
0.0027794158,
-0.1642036885,
-0.0934513435,
0.0679827183,
0.9411305189,
0.9744372964,
0.4925419092,
-0.519490242,
-0.5363247991,
0.2091767937,
0.1459020525,
0.0678054243,
0.451438427,
-0.8143857121,
0.1043618023,
0.3695411682,
0.9915269613,
0.4681154788,
0.3853522837,
0.2929616868,
-0.2436627299,
0.0895704105,
0.0144696031,
0.2699767351,
0.5176970959,
-0.1734488457,
0.60801965,
-0.2120511681,
-0.5297115445,
-0.8447061777,
0.1717025936,
-1.0320827961,
-0.2043880671,
0.9523660541,
0.1386838555,
-0.3683915138,
-0.1862218976,
-0.3277222514,
-0.3043513596,
-0.3021063209,
0.9367352724,
0.775180459,
-0.1255771071,
-0.1867371947,
-0.8025202155,
0.2131280303,
0.4030021727,
-1.4035197496,
0.0697561726,
0.3541278243,
0.2841520011,
0.0704646856,
0.8559499383,
0.1716182083,
0.5070514083,
-0.2211657465,
-0.5355277658,
0.0546382517,
-0.309486866,
-0.0716880113,
0.2515463829,
0.4072681665,
-0.0317468382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12272v1 | AMR Parsing with Instruction Fine-tuned Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-04-24T17:12:17 | 2023-04-24T17:12:17 | Young-Suk Lee, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo, Radu Florian, Tahira Naseem, Salim Roukos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction fine-tuned language models on a collection of instruction
annotated datasets (FLAN) have shown highly effective to improve model
performance and generalization to unseen tasks. However, a majority of standard
parsing tasks including abstract meaning representation (AMR), universal
dependency (UD), semantic role labeling (SRL) has been excluded from the FLAN
collections for both model training and evaluations. In this paper, we take one
of such instruction fine-tuned pre-trained language models, i.e. FLAN-T5, and
fine-tune them for AMR parsing. Our extensive experiments on various AMR
parsing tasks including AMR2.0, AMR3.0 and BioAMR indicate that FLAN-T5
fine-tuned models out-perform previous state-of-the-art models across all
tasks. In addition, full fine-tuning followed by the parameter efficient
fine-tuning, LoRA, further improves the model performances, setting new
state-of-the-arts in Smatch on AMR2.0 (86.4), AMR3.0 (84.9) and BioAMR (82.3). | [
-0.3852243125,
-0.7092221379,
0.3116315901,
-0.1646829695,
-0.3145719767,
-0.167802617,
-0.4128744304,
-0.6762329936,
-0.0595104732,
0.7307517529,
-0.499022156,
-0.7112183571,
-0.6888226867,
0.1534913331,
-0.1850148141,
0.8908025622,
-0.0524639376,
0.0273671467,
-0.0275336821,
-0.3080941439,
-0.4475834668,
-0.4274687469,
-0.4846681952,
-0.4661318362,
0.4566966593,
0.6867640615,
0.5212193727,
0.9923878908,
0.4346973002,
0.2566538751,
0.0464236848,
0.3796955645,
-0.2754945457,
-0.02604964,
-0.3171522021,
-0.277367413,
-0.7181113362,
-0.0156338084,
0.5342236757,
0.7196546197,
0.0365272649,
0.4276896417,
-0.0867665634,
0.6176391244,
-0.8838991523,
0.2891333401,
-0.5687450171,
-0.0212324038,
-0.2885326743,
-0.1584694088,
-0.4587926865,
-0.053236153,
0.0286096465,
-0.5638446212,
0.4588864744,
-0.1062822491,
0.9357818961,
0.3064450324,
-0.2498618066,
-0.203207165,
-0.9004634023,
1.0446586609,
-0.759170115,
0.4987269044,
0.2789849639,
0.4000637531,
0.0159776062,
-0.7498099208,
-0.384491235,
-0.1426270753,
-0.0487782732,
-0.1788396537,
-0.1992696375,
0.4249367118,
0.3401464224,
0.4643330276,
-0.189117074,
0.2679775357,
-0.5186505318,
0.0469939299,
0.5637899637,
0.1263448745,
0.1389946938,
-0.065956898,
-0.1815793216,
-0.2619823217,
-0.5043736696,
0.1550256461,
0.1559156924,
0.5293134451,
-0.0798360035,
0.6428967714,
-0.3416050673,
1.0588274002,
-0.0311160944,
0.0445190333,
0.0572994277,
-0.1439969093,
-0.2999403775,
-0.0399286188,
0.6719943881,
0.0144041358,
0.6716361046,
0.0672362447,
-0.455701232,
0.1764557213,
0.2325720936,
-0.7538496852,
-0.3641305268,
-0.005005267,
-0.4366455078,
-0.3539687395,
0.1891056895,
-0.586838007,
-0.0992660075,
-0.5579760671,
0.3677953482,
-0.3641417325,
0.0641844794,
0.3851967454,
0.2611662149,
0.262465626,
0.5428434014,
-1.1532254219,
0.5337525606,
0.7900624275,
0.6367412806,
0.1205790117,
-0.2779836953,
-1.0182226896,
0.2357089967,
0.0403361581,
0.9291862845,
-1.0107502937,
-0.2206448466,
-0.1337729692,
0.1089107692,
-0.5114995837,
-0.6657220125,
0.5150732398,
-0.3123529255,
0.0965143517,
-0.3123649359,
-0.6934042573,
-0.3064698279,
0.1476841122,
-0.743575573,
0.5795102715,
0.0844679549,
-0.4392253757,
0.1750300527,
-1.1239689589,
-0.6181803346,
-0.3216662109,
-0.1409035772,
-0.1643648893,
0.2427729964,
0.4655607045,
0.4684127569,
-0.3331320882,
-0.093406111,
-0.2356145084,
-0.4639256001,
0.0171131305,
-0.3796386123,
0.4526487887,
0.1809829324,
-0.3383330405,
0.4209213257,
-0.8861957788,
0.1797035336,
-0.1976260692,
-0.3428326845,
-0.1540793329,
0.0424927287,
-0.1211044267,
0.1914004236,
0.2826321125,
-0.6066774726,
0.1399120688,
-0.5663259625,
0.4012491107,
0.6665578485,
-0.0683425814,
0.241808638,
-0.1364817023,
0.4579302371,
0.3310112953,
-0.0880599543,
-0.1963759065,
-0.1150105819,
-1.193754673,
-0.1089248359,
0.5054653287,
0.6840341091,
-0.1493014544,
0.4026597738,
-0.362354219,
-0.1588957757,
-0.8429906368,
0.2414596975,
0.6260905862,
0.5423902869,
0.7588006854,
-0.1315422505,
-0.5320067406,
-0.896905899,
-0.4732398689,
0.1713045537,
0.0348619968,
0.1227918863,
0.4335336089,
-0.246095404,
0.7665662766,
-0.5791880488,
-0.5829276443,
-0.4886200726,
0.1869634241,
0.041269578,
0.6037716866,
0.2749090195,
-0.3925466835,
-0.3821187913,
0.2129908949,
-0.4842195213,
-0.2492741942,
0.2492998987,
0.0774199069,
0.38096416,
0.5171123743,
-0.5579913855,
0.6144970655,
0.2846933603,
-0.3462123275,
0.4377340972,
-0.3397546411,
0.174891606,
-0.9533076286,
0.2567608654,
-0.1239693612,
-0.3070913851,
-0.6562411785,
0.0441971272,
0.1060497612,
-0.1511484385,
-0.4565061927,
0.7777220011,
-0.4672292173,
-0.194701463,
-0.4135670662,
-0.1559173465,
0.3206434548,
0.4011157155,
0.104751952,
0.6896709204,
0.1914146394,
-0.6431668997,
0.0094902255,
0.1230022311,
-0.2828651071,
-0.1219336763,
-0.8318054676,
0.1234768033,
0.0206933841,
0.0068253339,
-0.5505920053,
-0.3991672993,
0.2643208802,
0.0373163633,
0.3439770937,
-0.182654351,
-0.4643223882,
-0.0680408478,
-0.1239385828,
0.3216008246,
0.3743474185,
-0.5799013972,
0.5863078833,
0.0049628811,
0.3619233966,
-0.644636035,
-0.6029364467,
-0.4261389673,
-0.1161916032,
-0.6500253677,
0.2601598501,
0.2848026156,
-0.2194381505,
-0.0675241426,
-0.2195071727,
-0.0284315571,
0.0359915011,
0.0196062941,
-0.1573480517,
-0.7105006576,
-0.3352797925,
0.1650261879,
-0.3792948425,
-0.1295550317,
-0.0041484414,
0.5763292909,
-0.5148457289,
-0.5210902691,
-0.4810561538,
0.2220601439,
0.528585434,
-0.8518904448,
0.9182619452,
0.6104221344,
-0.2966832817,
-0.1545581818,
-0.5756598115,
-0.1403337419,
-0.490670085,
0.2581486702,
-0.4250225127,
-0.9207322001,
0.6071593761,
0.1531679183,
0.2175934911,
0.2699841857,
0.0120589919,
0.0039150608,
1.0357495546,
0.4245304763,
0.1156765148,
0.5394995809,
-0.2218109816,
0.2294061184,
-0.700003624,
0.0515100248,
-0.3696286678,
-0.4077186584,
-0.4022683799,
-0.4443819523,
0.2475518286,
0.1115101948,
-0.1712835431,
0.090874061,
-0.0815028101,
0.8228888512,
0.6109983325,
0.2469479591,
0.289203465,
0.0972857624,
0.0662995726,
0.1448820531,
-0.3841953874,
-0.7254859209,
0.72854352,
0.3981537819,
0.7478668094,
0.0238469969,
0.7019439936,
0.2140898556,
-0.1182407215,
-0.7703374028,
0.6977767944,
-0.9924122691,
-0.2798607647,
-0.1409584433,
-0.1427431256,
-0.9305324554,
0.4480441213,
-0.0472304784,
-0.7124490142,
0.0266676042,
0.5557471514,
-0.4042782485,
0.3629714251,
-0.9659763575,
1.4065791368,
-0.1682202667,
-0.1391976625,
-0.3299850523,
-0.8589431643,
0.3881208897,
0.2912012637,
0.0242952686,
-0.1977537572,
0.2045259327,
0.5224701166,
-0.5603545308,
0.9097793102,
-0.4039627314,
-0.0049622706,
0.1550481319,
-0.13955082,
0.4014671445,
-0.2934189737,
-0.1083681732,
-0.0383747444,
0.2507858574,
-0.4417231381,
-0.6282289028,
0.5083430409,
-0.7353656292,
-0.5985483527,
-0.2655621767,
-0.400872916,
-0.243621856,
0.3593542874,
0.2343085706,
0.7434424758,
-0.24671112,
0.2331202775,
0.8842536807,
-0.1432034373,
0.230276376,
0.4411146045,
-0.1071897671,
-0.2083491981,
0.8187164068,
-0.0151196765,
0.3878590167,
0.6071723104,
0.2386099845,
-0.1697751135,
-0.3299500346,
-0.4308798909,
0.2414146066,
-0.8242326379,
-0.274435252,
-0.7405381203,
-0.3221222758,
-0.4742955267,
-0.014037624,
-0.4616474807,
-0.4880047441,
-0.6647307277,
0.0550079942,
0.2254415005,
0.796790421,
0.1687301993,
0.6247555017,
-1.0187497139,
0.4122732878,
0.1131187826,
0.4950025976,
-0.0326739177,
-0.5032347441,
-0.3467725217,
0.2626510561,
-0.1706195474,
-0.6064481735,
0.1343588382,
0.6552900076,
0.3227846324,
0.4469926357,
0.0325854942,
1.0913324356,
-0.6116191745,
0.4715984762,
-0.3260484338,
-0.9319123626,
0.7835267782,
-0.4205929935,
0.609175086,
0.6801250577,
-0.1862411201,
-0.1585509032,
-0.3309516013,
-0.5349125862,
-0.7052036524,
0.9914335012,
-0.1118385568,
0.0640044734,
0.0535400026,
0.2013078928,
0.1842832565,
0.0508797839,
-0.6910881996,
-0.0456806608,
-0.2431986481,
-0.5111291409,
-0.0295567084,
-0.3695445955,
0.1382644475,
-0.3044170737,
0.562104404,
0.0673380047,
0.0959801003,
-0.1978892833,
-0.3505873978,
-0.336491853,
0.6157937646,
0.7094228864,
0.5694117546,
-0.3280860782,
0.3179067671,
0.093571417,
-0.5287907124,
0.0019916436,
0.1978886873,
0.0503210239,
-0.2128769308,
0.6161209941,
1.0815794468,
0.5096964836,
-0.7258574367,
0.4032074213,
-0.0977414474,
-0.0786643773,
-0.2876538038,
0.7934677005,
-0.1885743886,
0.1677379012,
-0.1274962574,
0.2646785378,
-0.030058939,
-0.1464384794,
0.1752762347,
0.2368828952,
-0.1622778922,
-0.5241286159,
0.6070151329,
0.078051649,
0.013679591,
0.4801232517,
0.0656268224,
-0.4270072579,
0.2657113969,
0.6687172055,
0.7043864131,
-0.4024364352,
-0.0140147554,
0.3305739164,
0.3185519874,
-0.0605658889,
0.4070269167,
-0.0377150066,
-0.6124534607,
-0.317777276,
-0.9365867972,
-0.1969751418,
0.365408659,
-0.8920013309,
0.4598852694,
-0.5534391403,
0.2477722764,
-0.0038145885,
0.1236295775,
-0.6564277411,
0.4842181206,
0.0682624727,
0.8325193524,
-0.99484092,
0.9685738683,
1.0258222818,
-0.3204143941,
-0.8602374792,
0.0907574371,
-0.249742955,
-0.5230308175,
0.4450612068,
0.4924800396,
-0.3039590716,
0.210113734,
-0.2723251283,
-0.8549989462,
0.8684065938,
0.6013087034,
-0.4796848297,
-0.0098880511,
0.3955879509,
0.6165020466,
-0.6039766073,
-0.0276854839,
0.6738425493,
0.2579950988,
0.0448941961,
-0.804453373,
-0.0777782947,
-0.2808026671,
-0.1047739238,
0.3289172649,
-0.5170817971,
0.8017710447,
-0.1659028381,
0.0201760679,
0.0934466049,
1.0418299437,
0.3993777633,
0.1718993485,
0.5949466825,
0.454575479,
0.651789844,
0.1880284548,
0.8468216062,
-0.1254543364,
-0.0322664715,
1.3023409843,
-0.1114491671,
1.0789228678,
0.3176119924,
0.1111681312,
0.5300358534,
0.4453760386,
0.1264498532,
0.4682640135,
-0.1684547663,
-0.3485021591,
-0.5082193017,
-0.0314845927,
-0.1847970188,
0.7575970292,
0.5805510879,
-0.4236645699,
-0.3801127374,
0.0939943716,
0.0402524658,
0.0906516537,
-0.2508434057,
0.6664335728,
0.0336618088,
-0.6289739013,
0.7825718522,
0.2470882088,
0.3405186236,
-0.5952106714,
-0.2553107738,
-0.1954823732,
0.4901411831,
-0.250017643,
-0.417175293,
0.3013270199,
0.2557013929,
-0.431402564,
-0.093583107,
0.9400450587,
-0.6102609038,
-0.5230153799,
0.2301211506,
0.3581264913,
0.0614256561,
0.192579627,
-0.6248546243,
0.1930212975,
0.1371250451,
-0.2979806364,
0.2567663193,
0.4068185091,
-0.1681395173,
0.5925564766,
0.3213402927,
-0.0823783278,
0.3063498437,
0.3184413314,
0.7871554494,
-0.7602298856,
-0.4419626594,
-0.8044832349,
0.5591734052,
0.2028836757,
-0.2267343104,
0.4002900422,
0.4995733202,
0.9341213107,
-0.3710444272,
0.7072939277,
-0.0942836925,
0.780820787,
-0.9065797925,
0.530551672,
-0.6809418797,
0.5299443603,
-0.160050109,
-0.9066407681,
-0.3466120362,
0.8366584778,
-0.547018528,
0.2565969527,
0.5346559882,
0.7654434443,
-0.8337859511,
0.189576149,
0.2267827392,
0.1014690995,
0.3392772675,
0.3132106066,
0.6968888044,
-0.3452443182,
0.1811591536,
-0.4960187972,
-0.0398924202,
-0.1500253677,
-0.8153563738,
-1.1064912081,
-0.3231259286,
-0.306873858,
-0.0065335971,
0.0880441889,
1.2063701153,
0.5668234229,
-1.2319403887,
-0.3702869415,
-0.1109849364,
-0.1879293025,
-0.0207243506,
-0.1788623035,
0.3722558916,
-0.7223190665,
-0.5553334951,
0.5928421617,
-0.0995575488,
0.0997293591,
0.1459187865,
0.0550267808,
-0.3120112121,
-0.176076591,
0.5021831989,
0.3648532033,
-0.9500133395,
-0.4751605988,
-0.0423001833,
0.1747684479,
0.1297010481,
0.7227199078,
-0.558336854,
0.3045866787,
0.2645203471,
0.5538557768,
0.2706004083,
0.4603614509,
0.7839648128,
-1.0338519812,
0.0592203885,
0.0758320913,
0.27598086,
0.2808653712,
-0.1523601562,
0.538489759,
-0.064993687,
-0.4658530354,
-0.854316771,
0.2325440049,
-0.8705587387,
-0.0928540155,
1.0233830214,
-0.1605794728,
-0.3963200152,
0.0513117202,
-0.0750800073,
0.5352753997,
-0.214469865,
0.4383027852,
0.4975329638,
-0.406237632,
-0.288685143,
-0.6346458793,
0.5120357871,
0.6019127965,
-0.7509899139,
0.4246147573,
0.6346344948,
0.2042060643,
-0.1758777499,
0.4288006425,
0.0518518202,
0.2725104988,
-0.4018793106,
-0.1800711602,
-0.3869237304,
-0.5064796805,
-0.3547964394,
0.0317785554,
0.3463134766,
-0.4035079181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12269v1 | Enriching Source Code with Contextual Data for Code Completion Models: An Empirical Study | 2023-04-24T17:09:14 | 2023-04-24T17:09:14 | Tim van Dam, Maliheh Izadi, Arie van Deursen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based pre-trained models have recently achieved great results in
solving many software engineering tasks including automatic code completion
which is a staple in a developer's toolkit. While many have striven to improve
the code-understanding abilities of such models, the opposite -- making the
code easier to understand -- has not been properly investigated. In this study,
we aim to answer whether making code easier to understand through using
contextual data improves the performance of pre-trained code language models
for the task of code completion. We consider type annotations and comments as
two common forms of additional contextual information that often help
developers understand code better. For the experiments, we study code
completion in two granularity levels; token and line completion and take three
recent and large-scale language models for source code: UniXcoder, CodeGPT, and
InCoder with five evaluation metrics. Finally, we perform the Wilcoxon Signed
Rank test to gauge significance and measure the effect size. Contrary to our
expectations, all models perform better if type annotations are removed (albeit
the effect sizes are small). For comments, we find that the models perform
better in the presence of multi-line comments (again with small effect sizes).
Based on our observations, we recommend making proper design choices when
training, fine-tuning, or simply selecting such models given the intended data
and application. Better evaluations and multi-modal techniques can also be
further investigated to improve the practicality and accuracy of
auto-completions. | [
-0.4406261742,
-0.3239399791,
0.5100640655,
0.2536092699,
-0.4694606662,
0.0761251897,
-0.4904934466,
-0.6207162142,
0.0622453131,
0.5086315274,
-0.0921919718,
-0.3636092842,
-0.5883953571,
0.104303129,
-0.5687387586,
1.192945838,
-0.135599643,
0.1303027123,
-0.5393803716,
0.0470128059,
-0.599609673,
-0.5548319817,
-0.1671462655,
-0.2198165953,
0.3600329161,
0.2477610707,
0.6877878904,
0.8153522015,
0.788482368,
0.2136199176,
-0.0163142234,
-0.09452077,
-0.4018214047,
-0.0898405463,
0.190323174,
-0.5553854704,
-0.5352641344,
-0.0337560251,
0.1952432543,
0.8336821198,
0.1556107849,
0.3812937737,
0.2199217081,
0.4770478904,
-0.5964396596,
0.3111121953,
-0.2919858992,
0.1335734725,
0.0527932048,
-0.4128218293,
-0.5860760212,
-0.3839839697,
0.2215044647,
-0.5717613101,
0.207882002,
-0.0424559936,
0.5975425839,
0.5446349978,
-0.5624864697,
-0.4325275123,
-0.6944294572,
0.476703614,
-0.9815707207,
0.3568963706,
0.4866625071,
-0.0819210559,
0.3312058747,
-0.6843016148,
-0.2437941581,
-0.6527478099,
-0.6550965905,
0.0357345529,
0.3187348247,
0.0832384825,
0.6676763892,
0.5752195716,
-0.4291602075,
-0.2391310334,
-0.4716223478,
-0.0280709453,
0.3729388416,
-0.2061004192,
0.3361761868,
-0.4470996857,
0.0064659491,
0.0358810611,
-0.7225143909,
0.2052746266,
0.0803191885,
0.1526276916,
-0.2320905179,
0.4279998839,
-0.2641691267,
1.054543376,
-0.1134804562,
0.1156710237,
0.4278416932,
-0.4212492406,
-0.1689644158,
-0.4083760977,
0.2938975692,
0.1975553483,
0.3883500099,
-0.4288725853,
-0.1537774801,
-0.1790854335,
0.6172340512,
-0.7669857144,
-0.5000047684,
0.1166861057,
-0.6812455058,
-0.2543597221,
0.4234047532,
-0.2167075574,
-0.3029067814,
-0.8680272698,
0.3601516485,
-0.3456626236,
-0.2693353593,
-0.2286773622,
-0.294223994,
0.1935844123,
0.5315461755,
-0.5197239518,
-0.1856191605,
0.6243546605,
0.702902019,
0.0259867217,
-0.2512144446,
-0.5992802978,
-0.0123938331,
-0.4529541731,
0.6461685896,
-0.8377048969,
-0.3871625662,
-0.1096557006,
-0.3001846969,
0.1305478364,
-0.4812201262,
0.217935726,
-0.5923615098,
0.1768909246,
-0.4117957056,
-0.5545129776,
-0.1633088738,
0.0422755703,
-0.6438100338,
0.9091570973,
0.2000981122,
-0.8259965181,
0.6973964572,
-0.8352949619,
-0.5860171318,
-0.012505441,
-0.2781540453,
-0.1484369636,
0.3698783517,
0.0012755233,
0.4970768094,
-0.0136780087,
0.3969851136,
-0.2960566878,
-0.5723540783,
0.2288638204,
-0.0104123838,
0.2706257701,
0.3499749005,
-0.5854665637,
0.032996729,
-0.6410496235,
0.0259998366,
-0.1770567,
-0.4353639185,
-0.3674955368,
0.1006739438,
0.2214594781,
0.3512022197,
0.0631131232,
-0.2455086261,
0.3152219355,
-0.0615840368,
0.3009284139,
0.5189167857,
-0.1764738262,
0.6747869849,
-0.059628211,
0.4462966323,
0.0005999975,
0.2077469677,
-0.4740338326,
-0.1711692214,
-0.8492289782,
-0.1771189421,
0.4928306937,
0.2891210914,
-0.7890641093,
0.2705804408,
-0.2914775014,
-0.1423914284,
-0.2095296383,
0.2406640053,
0.6020354033,
0.5719940066,
0.4230761528,
-0.4295546114,
-0.7078854442,
-0.7179346085,
-0.3040666878,
-0.0451165773,
-0.2449083179,
0.5908147693,
0.4471130371,
-0.3616236448,
1.3835989237,
-0.7562400699,
0.1718242466,
-0.1444239169,
0.1334769875,
-0.0327428579,
0.6526834369,
0.5228099823,
-0.9679607153,
-0.570795536,
-0.0824586228,
-0.8010628819,
-0.1965980381,
0.0679014623,
0.090355292,
-0.1262384206,
0.6253548265,
-0.1258883923,
0.5075702071,
0.4269811511,
-0.2130977809,
0.2922341228,
-0.2071532458,
0.38695243,
-0.8803402781,
0.3467705548,
-0.1505228728,
-0.3913229704,
-0.8641858697,
0.173159197,
0.4766209126,
-0.2336820513,
-0.1932104081,
0.2454525977,
-0.4395163953,
-0.1315005869,
-0.3277827203,
-0.0212073512,
0.0115519427,
0.4402657747,
0.288362056,
1.0491929054,
0.3263934851,
-0.5575373769,
-0.2168076783,
-0.0549544245,
-0.3552543521,
0.1199103519,
-0.7692939043,
0.2442403436,
-0.295173496,
0.2893093824,
-0.8803097606,
-0.4210399985,
-0.1316855401,
-0.3170745075,
0.3005512357,
-0.2957366705,
-0.350135088,
-0.2203470618,
-0.0856498852,
0.5387744308,
0.5014327168,
-0.5782507062,
0.4429064691,
0.2311702371,
0.0660998523,
-0.4223449826,
-0.6754854918,
0.0387879908,
-0.1825273037,
-0.3578134179,
0.1753547192,
-0.2893106639,
-0.1458068937,
-0.2017400414,
-0.1771024019,
-0.3202919066,
0.2012158483,
0.3593188822,
0.2699648738,
-0.1059507579,
0.277181536,
-0.2333846092,
-0.084437497,
0.0644501522,
-0.0803432614,
0.4252467752,
-0.1695699841,
-0.3361338973,
-0.1196249872,
0.2007425725,
0.3544945121,
-0.3681615293,
0.4510705769,
0.4489290118,
-0.1220269874,
-0.0491693132,
-0.7164205313,
-0.1956175417,
-0.4033431709,
0.2163329571,
-0.3748018146,
-1.1338750124,
0.520997107,
0.0088275345,
-0.0565430112,
0.3173629045,
0.0079491613,
-0.0431893915,
0.8645482659,
0.8816351295,
-0.0554483682,
0.8359192014,
-0.3811563253,
0.2380212396,
-0.8791869879,
-0.1091588587,
-0.4338213801,
0.0859146491,
-0.3580338061,
-0.4753713906,
0.3398817778,
0.3030656874,
0.0496083647,
0.6298038363,
-0.6088137031,
0.5127373934,
0.3418357074,
0.2830251157,
0.3964958489,
-0.2579711676,
0.2248838395,
0.1196685731,
-0.5249800682,
-0.4079301357,
1.2486085892,
0.3882151246,
0.5802499056,
-0.0384502746,
0.695535779,
0.4164846838,
0.5822663307,
-0.4573343694,
0.0692690387,
-0.0270114169,
-0.4893583655,
-0.0044442457,
-0.6006256938,
-0.3030765653,
0.1852740645,
0.0725670084,
-0.3944114149,
0.2593301535,
0.4791405797,
-0.4686505497,
-0.2433738559,
-1.0901232958,
0.9134116173,
0.0493956357,
-0.1311827451,
-0.1869337708,
-0.6460531354,
0.3587968349,
-0.0976370275,
0.3303414583,
0.2646167278,
0.0522446223,
0.6179702878,
-0.6397035718,
0.7449322939,
-0.2379998267,
-0.1761517078,
0.1902767718,
-0.1235769317,
0.4861507714,
0.3189209998,
0.0286892615,
0.0746055245,
-0.0500469692,
-0.3636346757,
-0.7803416848,
0.4314915836,
-0.6209354997,
-0.4447674751,
0.1123186648,
-0.4601251781,
-0.0368363075,
0.0239176378,
0.3841577768,
0.9595449567,
0.2454637587,
0.4319249988,
0.6490290761,
-0.0214072186,
0.5902644992,
0.4728357494,
-0.2273240387,
-0.2768364847,
0.6162726283,
0.2023816109,
0.3076858819,
0.2891209722,
-0.2507480681,
0.0285868272,
-0.4372216165,
-0.3870650232,
-0.0399635099,
-0.8907096386,
-0.1992542893,
-0.7975493073,
-0.1199990809,
-0.4038052857,
-0.1882808506,
-0.2713423371,
-0.379584223,
-0.1473206729,
-0.0255560745,
0.315654099,
0.9740110636,
0.1924189329,
0.3747776151,
-0.6369771361,
0.2083509415,
0.2107033283,
0.5963190794,
0.1559036672,
-0.4974981248,
-0.6771453023,
0.0214515738,
0.1258878261,
-0.712023139,
-0.0458585583,
-0.0957308337,
0.3139390051,
0.2429085821,
-0.0667674989,
0.8019561172,
-0.3923681378,
0.7601255774,
-0.1040783897,
-1.2403299809,
0.8303328753,
-0.325802803,
0.4635852575,
0.752758801,
0.0373194888,
-0.4561361074,
-0.5068204403,
-0.4624826908,
-0.7240601778,
0.6904960871,
0.3237461448,
0.1881716102,
0.015051337,
0.6450248361,
0.1359073222,
0.431769222,
-1.0469652414,
-0.2452551275,
-0.4466404915,
-0.0124590434,
-0.1124417111,
-0.2825465798,
0.09388116,
-0.4084940255,
0.3709238172,
-0.2772315741,
0.2932756841,
0.2943466008,
-0.6514590383,
0.1481346041,
0.2043158412,
0.7979980707,
1.0847229958,
-0.1873752773,
0.1902606338,
0.2152372599,
-0.4246914685,
-0.2387014031,
-0.0288409144,
-0.0431296714,
-0.0081182513,
0.6780401468,
0.7008137107,
0.2336528003,
-0.5135478377,
0.6253342032,
-0.0722450241,
0.2287360132,
-0.256616652,
0.3070243001,
-0.2601096332,
-0.086114049,
0.5040348768,
0.3304502964,
0.4641527534,
-0.4596699476,
0.2605751455,
0.3383724988,
-0.3482032418,
-0.1733084321,
0.4031767249,
0.2935096323,
-0.0663508177,
0.2934955657,
-0.0635899976,
-0.5633721352,
0.7968757749,
0.3967298269,
0.7108807564,
0.1063856855,
0.1088094413,
0.2452159673,
0.1297251433,
-0.0875522122,
-0.0133859068,
-0.5989077687,
-0.2176401168,
-0.8392487764,
-0.5199359655,
-0.3276982307,
-0.1922028363,
-0.6467477679,
0.1566279233,
-0.3202408552,
-0.1217262298,
-0.2591501772,
-0.1199253649,
-0.768021822,
0.3810040951,
0.0228903499,
0.8471128941,
-0.8016068339,
0.8695464134,
0.7322425246,
-0.7954633236,
-0.9854115844,
0.316904366,
-0.3943045735,
-0.2799254358,
0.8388496637,
0.3865511417,
0.074849315,
-0.0023398271,
-0.4842004776,
-1.1438394785,
0.8769473433,
0.1782055497,
-0.2204061151,
-0.0523501188,
0.1195455864,
0.5868150592,
-0.6154894829,
0.8667938709,
0.4695444703,
0.4538033903,
-0.0724908635,
-1.0767079592,
0.0384820215,
-0.5533505678,
0.4916974604,
0.2626101971,
-0.3852284849,
0.7567577958,
-0.09067671,
0.1225167364,
-0.2973184288,
0.5516799688,
-0.1261833906,
0.1628954411,
0.5371995568,
0.2280249149,
0.4395388961,
-0.0075754812,
1.1631355286,
-0.6168944836,
0.5652114749,
1.1929107904,
0.0630779713,
0.7929185629,
0.3594871163,
-0.0100089926,
0.6687156558,
0.5425776243,
0.1978807896,
0.4049978852,
-0.0217835158,
0.2269450724,
-0.217445001,
-0.0329586938,
-0.7841730714,
0.3376135528,
-0.142141819,
-0.572945416,
0.0944582075,
0.1685135812,
0.0736169517,
-0.0618819036,
-0.1231094748,
0.8264091015,
0.0502669662,
-0.7772701383,
0.4399811625,
-0.1729970723,
0.6596556306,
-0.3856931329,
0.0808987021,
-0.4189731181,
-0.0894517899,
-0.5420362949,
-0.4387378395,
0.4981899559,
0.1824990809,
-0.5454030633,
-0.249163568,
0.4800274968,
-0.4933677018,
-0.2066479623,
0.2397554517,
0.3037362099,
-0.1214959398,
-0.1767403781,
-0.2362238318,
0.1326776147,
-0.0030066173,
-0.2902497649,
0.0954287797,
0.1343503743,
0.1915422678,
0.4401814938,
0.5635883808,
-0.198203966,
-0.0274370592,
0.1804356426,
1.1136541367,
-0.6181998849,
-0.5350723863,
-0.7373802066,
0.8257466555,
-0.4342511296,
-0.0968680456,
0.8666602373,
0.7144165635,
0.9286357164,
-0.3943809867,
0.7693622112,
-0.3408927917,
0.4348608255,
-0.6308681965,
0.5870260596,
-0.5313619971,
0.5059381723,
-0.5518333912,
-1.0510479212,
-0.3593093753,
0.5713728666,
-0.6725167036,
0.4450369179,
0.8116964698,
0.6239314079,
-0.3083323538,
0.0055105393,
0.1059115678,
-0.0829621628,
0.3005115092,
0.260302335,
0.8507584333,
-0.3912158906,
0.4074287117,
-0.3426393569,
-0.3723796308,
-0.3048552275,
-0.8200652003,
-0.9820804596,
-0.5386068821,
-0.3401008844,
-0.1990541071,
-0.2129109204,
1.0153634548,
0.9891788363,
-0.7718135118,
-0.1967731714,
-0.1868366748,
0.0448599569,
0.1608896852,
-0.2256207913,
0.2039497644,
-0.8387007117,
-0.3920106888,
0.1404364109,
0.2926836908,
-0.1274611503,
-0.0054578497,
-0.1650547385,
0.2110265344,
-0.101318568,
0.8114539981,
0.0183741245,
-0.7438850403,
-0.4190865159,
0.0447007269,
-0.2040497959,
0.2228476554,
1.3199567795,
-0.9157987237,
0.438986361,
0.5822933316,
0.4685603678,
0.3427682221,
0.2933564782,
0.5803819299,
-0.7248467207,
0.1692001373,
-0.1122748926,
0.3989769816,
0.2583880723,
-0.5978921652,
0.6947731376,
-0.06523256,
-0.4965354204,
-0.7198156118,
0.1523365676,
-0.5853303671,
-0.4278971851,
1.2238621712,
-0.1426921934,
0.0348683558,
-0.0784290433,
-0.3431898057,
0.2124874592,
-0.2322897315,
0.7010519505,
0.5634010434,
-0.2079932541,
-0.1659900695,
-0.6588306427,
0.8668254018,
0.5595708489,
-0.8498016,
0.1511728019,
0.6124819517,
0.2739145756,
0.2992044091,
0.6985229254,
0.016423719,
0.427223891,
-0.3541323841,
0.0336995721,
-0.1217947826,
-0.4599498212,
-0.4984283447,
0.2702311873,
0.2992511988,
0.3405022025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12244v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12244v2 | WizardLM: Empowering Large Language Models to Follow Complex Instructions | 2023-04-24T16:31:06 | 2023-06-10T13:18:25 | Can Xu, Qingfeng Sun, Kai Zheng, Xiubo Geng, Pu Zhao, Jiazhan Feng, Chongyang Tao, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training large language models (LLMs) with open-domain instruction following
data brings colossal success. However, manually creating such instruction data
is very time-consuming and labor-intensive. Moreover, humans may struggle to
produce high-complexity instructions. In this paper, we show an avenue for
creating large amounts of instruction data with varying levels of complexity
using LLM instead of humans. Starting with an initial set of instructions, we
use our proposed Evol-Instruct to rewrite them step by step into more complex
instructions. Then, we mix all generated instruction data to fine-tune LLaMA.
We call the resulting model WizardLM. Human evaluations on a
complexity-balanced test bed and Vicuna's testset show that instructions from
Evol-Instruct are superior to human-created ones. By analyzing the human
evaluation results of the high complexity part, we demonstrate that outputs
from our WizardLM are preferred to outputs from OpenAI ChatGPT. In GPT-4
automatic evaluation, WizardLM achieves more than 90\% capacity of ChatGPT on
17 out of 29 skills. Even though WizardLM still lags behind ChatGPT in some
aspects, our findings suggest that fine-tuning with AI-evolved instructions is
a promising direction for enhancing LLMs. Our code and data are public at
https://github.com/nlpxucan/WizardLM | [
-0.2649787664,
-0.8685657978,
0.2179737985,
0.2038825005,
0.0694777742,
0.2569824755,
-0.385294944,
-0.3341782093,
-0.2117700279,
0.7225330472,
-0.4544338584,
-0.6402631998,
-0.462087214,
0.0353005156,
-0.133870393,
1.0535609722,
-0.1136189178,
0.0573165454,
-0.1536802202,
0.2565252781,
-0.535384953,
-0.5091837645,
-0.5996363759,
-0.5369939804,
0.3772818744,
0.6138730049,
0.6773144007,
0.5214319825,
0.0579575449,
0.2813996971,
0.1316175312,
0.9935454726,
-0.8401314616,
0.1504354477,
0.0237533692,
-0.5132564306,
-0.719601512,
-0.1456080228,
0.4471482337,
0.649708271,
-0.3361911178,
0.084431529,
0.1717535406,
0.8233579397,
-0.3712096214,
0.4159579873,
-0.6116500497,
0.0423308574,
-0.1535739601,
-0.4432692528,
-0.5594013929,
-0.3160196841,
0.1611712128,
-0.512568295,
0.1161976159,
0.499219805,
0.5532016158,
0.1628068537,
-0.2252023071,
-0.4666786492,
-1.0215069056,
0.607830584,
-0.7072535753,
0.246052444,
0.523609519,
0.3789076507,
-0.7984368205,
-0.418207705,
-0.5107918382,
-0.3883941472,
0.1870869845,
-0.1074774936,
0.000192806,
0.1627280563,
0.2480477244,
0.1312253028,
-0.4655597806,
0.2477571964,
-0.4373203814,
-0.0715681165,
0.7258322835,
0.554893434,
0.4504343271,
0.3894689977,
0.0648155585,
-0.1121911332,
-0.9665281773,
-0.1645104587,
0.553314209,
0.37665838,
0.10508091,
0.8374091983,
-0.3402678967,
0.7575708628,
0.253975749,
-0.180567801,
0.1703670621,
0.1450814456,
-0.2835784554,
0.2855195701,
0.6070725322,
0.1535504013,
0.3626460433,
-0.3032710254,
-0.3608314693,
-0.4304755032,
0.3645677269,
-0.9461042285,
-0.2900308967,
0.1957264841,
-0.2346310616,
0.0461617336,
-0.0144799966,
-0.6218096018,
-0.5047198534,
-0.5671707392,
0.4499255717,
-0.5465413332,
-0.0393007472,
0.4358274341,
0.2809515595,
0.6024060249,
0.724838078,
-1.0864440203,
0.2856815159,
0.89511621,
0.6879644394,
-0.1616501212,
-0.4580121338,
-0.6892884374,
0.1984404773,
-0.586601615,
0.6580800414,
-0.6428279281,
-0.3214831054,
-0.1026495993,
-0.2881315053,
-0.1209036335,
-0.5937362313,
0.2733164728,
-0.602367878,
0.370115608,
0.2170526534,
-0.8702717423,
-0.2127615511,
0.1807892621,
-0.4954701066,
0.966068387,
0.1421933472,
-0.4987112284,
-0.0541322641,
-0.7895517945,
-0.5380603671,
-0.0177701581,
-0.0093415221,
-0.3607888818,
-0.0535767041,
0.1808632165,
0.4941589534,
-0.496841222,
0.03984534,
-0.1013185009,
-0.4384697676,
0.0815898702,
-0.7699506283,
0.6766738892,
0.0559034124,
-0.392617166,
0.1676932126,
-0.8885748982,
-0.01051581,
0.102420561,
-0.6562769413,
-0.1289698631,
-0.0030306517,
-0.373103857,
-0.0798945278,
0.2564570904,
-0.2563057542,
0.4156843424,
-0.5302014351,
0.1663790941,
0.8286784291,
-0.2233192921,
0.4643563926,
-0.2019900978,
0.4818738997,
-0.4002967179,
0.2690280676,
-0.1191528514,
-0.627545774,
-0.8833503127,
-0.2253822833,
0.0475795716,
0.70975703,
-0.4589579105,
0.5976598263,
-0.2650888264,
-0.6477368474,
-0.7701687217,
0.3477146029,
0.3465977013,
0.4799464643,
0.3936202526,
-0.1080682948,
-0.3746421635,
-0.717615664,
0.0329298973,
-0.0386731327,
-0.2606586516,
0.1510027796,
0.2834199965,
-0.359143436,
0.7208112478,
-0.4760864973,
-0.0469733067,
-0.0772057921,
0.0595286004,
0.1980323046,
0.4490181804,
0.0653441623,
-0.4387963712,
-0.5614759922,
0.3719951212,
-0.6822615862,
-0.1118530408,
0.0628003329,
-0.3789067268,
0.1441818178,
0.3844968379,
-0.8525626659,
0.3841061294,
0.3180187643,
-0.2315837145,
0.5820644498,
-0.6757364273,
0.1184293926,
-0.7083027959,
-0.3212993741,
-0.457031101,
-0.2657832801,
-0.8782784343,
-0.1031862944,
-0.0708911195,
0.0288561657,
-0.3612219691,
0.4401963353,
-0.6526370049,
-0.0107831508,
-0.3201493919,
-0.1805857718,
-0.0924603492,
0.7566831708,
-0.1533507258,
0.6081994176,
0.5841853023,
-0.5263545513,
0.535374701,
0.1769686043,
-0.3263063729,
0.1980877966,
-0.5904818177,
0.4596824646,
-0.124920316,
0.2979490161,
-0.8741973042,
-0.435280025,
0.4772565961,
-0.1741133779,
0.6700911522,
-0.0399382338,
-0.6640574336,
-0.2203494012,
-0.1839800179,
-0.0653972849,
0.8006198406,
-0.6766952872,
0.8432112932,
0.1591630131,
0.0190229248,
-0.5387638211,
-0.348513037,
0.1841523349,
-0.164777562,
-0.5758099556,
0.1164629906,
-0.0942905918,
-0.1486969739,
-0.2091837972,
0.0220879763,
0.2071865946,
-0.0609582216,
0.4197984934,
0.2826186717,
-0.1926843673,
0.1108367592,
0.1022290364,
0.1025406271,
-0.0839635804,
-0.3916065991,
0.7815306187,
-0.1055347621,
-0.6336254478,
-0.5185666084,
0.2512468398,
0.647893548,
-0.1905276626,
0.6733072996,
0.503534615,
-0.2073404789,
-0.4808912575,
-0.435649842,
-0.0518393479,
-0.4635094106,
0.4214386046,
-0.2665002644,
-0.7800858021,
0.2372244447,
-0.2409941554,
0.5021421909,
0.2138326168,
0.8183190227,
-0.1046824083,
1.1683200598,
0.4367724955,
0.1174485013,
0.3215530515,
-0.1511586457,
0.0781793818,
-0.720477283,
-0.4050085843,
-0.2499936521,
-0.1475462168,
-0.2957386374,
-0.7484813333,
0.1707195938,
0.2974546254,
-0.653840065,
0.06223258,
-0.524028182,
0.4813817739,
0.4974023998,
0.2683834434,
0.2339085788,
0.1760584265,
0.2194692641,
0.3298107982,
-0.820012033,
-0.7851058841,
1.1495871544,
0.3747650683,
1.1881639957,
-0.0176080801,
0.7179156542,
0.3357064128,
0.3979245126,
-0.6417776942,
0.4895364642,
-0.0707305148,
-0.1864498556,
-0.5447164774,
-0.2677881122,
-1.108107686,
0.2927135527,
-0.1746569276,
-0.5517778397,
-0.3443157673,
0.2139565498,
-0.2163735777,
0.2317770571,
-0.8896021843,
0.5042940974,
-0.3581099212,
-0.2069535255,
-0.2718113363,
-0.4737391472,
0.4114908576,
-0.1609231085,
0.0310319047,
-0.1545276642,
-0.1762414873,
0.5610032678,
-0.8115865588,
1.1860928535,
-0.0351381451,
-0.566342473,
0.3565463126,
0.0249174479,
0.7729639411,
-0.3057970405,
-0.1127030626,
0.0062108906,
-0.5746609569,
-0.4037753642,
-0.8262777925,
0.6734773517,
-1.0179131031,
-0.9673470259,
0.0849250183,
-0.629442811,
-0.2327898294,
-0.0137182483,
0.0082234014,
0.4453403354,
-0.0548105203,
-0.1462329924,
0.8362088203,
-0.3803174198,
0.1466297507,
0.4679082036,
-0.2925540507,
-0.2561935484,
0.9491199255,
0.1715480387,
0.3315341175,
0.4543222785,
0.2724606693,
-0.0563440099,
-0.5944746137,
-0.8655593991,
0.0769406185,
-0.7262859344,
-0.201475203,
-0.5793793201,
-0.2597016692,
-0.1320014596,
-0.1233816147,
-0.4450270534,
-0.2645434439,
-0.3714044094,
0.1311624944,
0.615860641,
0.9085873961,
0.2587835193,
0.2145175934,
-0.7755681872,
0.1951305717,
0.5749284625,
0.1412014067,
0.4410037696,
-0.6777751446,
-0.3302412927,
0.2546303868,
-0.2074193209,
-0.5852614045,
0.3443094194,
0.3835603297,
0.6026962996,
0.2158641666,
-0.0253404435,
0.8275237083,
-0.9788307548,
0.6188252568,
0.1172528267,
-0.7696039081,
0.4201348424,
-0.1462558359,
0.2223066539,
-0.0164451655,
0.2131376117,
-0.2115168422,
-0.5599001646,
-0.3748966753,
-0.7834182978,
0.6933656335,
0.1351982951,
0.4004443288,
0.1490651965,
0.4127265215,
0.418030709,
-0.0586238876,
-0.0505128577,
-0.1263108999,
-0.0358208865,
-0.2462740242,
0.179445684,
0.0072285063,
-0.1658691913,
-0.2346953899,
0.5701905489,
0.0018460454,
0.0970995501,
0.0149805117,
-0.1230861768,
-0.187882185,
0.1369304657,
0.6821101904,
0.729144156,
0.0588500984,
0.030129943,
0.418361485,
-0.5009262562,
0.158466801,
-0.0565998591,
-0.0259155054,
-0.3283979297,
0.7654110193,
1.0465613604,
-0.0335177593,
-0.8738647103,
0.2747552991,
-0.0595744997,
-0.1288171709,
-0.2999265492,
0.6226041317,
0.2703879774,
0.4070776999,
0.4172682464,
0.0788557157,
-0.1143634692,
-0.424995333,
-0.0197023526,
0.2992540002,
-0.0920287073,
-0.3622941673,
0.5904026031,
0.1895412058,
-0.5866791606,
0.6771577597,
-0.2057307661,
-0.4692969024,
0.4356288314,
0.6283016205,
0.6999916434,
-0.3807263076,
0.0329500623,
0.1076553091,
0.1547737867,
-0.2620809674,
0.1377398819,
0.0879294202,
-0.4996336997,
-0.7717204094,
-0.6557771564,
-0.5123044252,
-0.0617089048,
-0.2689048052,
0.4356138706,
-0.4941952527,
0.4413282573,
-0.1902052313,
-0.1012673751,
-0.8050457239,
-0.0953803509,
0.196842894,
0.7816460133,
-0.4585339129,
1.0560578108,
0.3580922186,
-0.1246577799,
-0.8731932044,
-0.1549620181,
-0.1601651013,
-0.9313777685,
0.8223898411,
0.1331361681,
-0.2645561397,
-0.004939069,
-0.7867161036,
-0.5165548921,
1.1803935766,
0.4884449244,
-0.9004830122,
-0.0973909646,
0.1375006288,
0.7142789364,
-0.6202802658,
0.1877200752,
0.5573660135,
0.4474294782,
0.2563481629,
-0.9163456559,
-0.0364274681,
-0.0378395021,
-0.0869248658,
0.1277994961,
-0.5105726719,
0.8411473036,
-0.4598395824,
-0.1889054328,
-0.0421096124,
0.8565890193,
0.174667418,
0.1059549451,
0.5171265602,
0.3253601193,
1.1068201065,
0.3935212195,
1.0824545622,
0.0287954602,
0.0101215178,
1.308983326,
-0.3192350864,
0.8758584857,
0.1560896784,
-0.2914057672,
0.3864619136,
0.6908296347,
0.1020399109,
0.2559154034,
0.6827747226,
-0.2242471725,
-0.2560459077,
0.1874680966,
-0.0908085331,
0.4830183685,
0.4815298915,
-0.0655859709,
-0.18012546,
0.1633236408,
0.1107800826,
-0.0438030437,
-0.5083623528,
0.8268171549,
-0.0429246239,
-0.5669767261,
1.0232696533,
-0.2038932741,
0.7072355151,
-0.5682137609,
-0.4963180721,
-0.1330393404,
0.0189853255,
-0.2480098605,
-0.735799253,
-0.0257150903,
0.1448432356,
-0.0896159708,
0.0631851181,
0.7237508893,
-0.733379066,
-0.3561374545,
0.1523656398,
0.5247536302,
0.4572535157,
0.1122569367,
-0.3963393271,
-0.0665875599,
0.127192691,
-0.4997458458,
0.4128165841,
0.6974888444,
-0.3370656967,
0.9081884027,
0.627446115,
0.1500074863,
0.3592024148,
0.1264320165,
0.8639315963,
-0.3696564734,
0.0396034494,
-0.975397706,
0.2744373679,
-0.0865936577,
-0.2189749479,
0.7242120504,
0.3981577158,
0.7180455327,
-0.1890707016,
0.7878541946,
0.0102209309,
0.1563073546,
-0.5797153711,
0.5494523644,
-0.2656323612,
0.4303395748,
0.077207081,
-1.0202630758,
-0.3352987766,
0.3014740944,
-0.2343874872,
-0.1595344841,
0.1521485597,
1.1025989056,
-0.116051659,
-0.0381701514,
0.4321433306,
0.1145179048,
0.5667920709,
0.5514100194,
0.9999399781,
-0.0668288171,
0.7635763884,
0.094648093,
-0.3280096352,
-0.3615500033,
-0.6556518674,
-1.2852013111,
-0.3884012103,
-0.2160151899,
-0.2421856523,
0.0871896744,
1.3219941854,
0.6382070184,
-0.6265577078,
-0.1904764771,
-0.0670436993,
0.1632304639,
-0.3419310749,
-0.1216495931,
0.6425188184,
-0.5128603578,
-0.9848011136,
0.4309471846,
0.3765605986,
0.1243557781,
-0.5731143951,
-0.5984395146,
0.1055906564,
0.1399987191,
0.8963878155,
0.1934087723,
-0.7590066195,
-0.4121504724,
-0.0421302393,
-0.239376232,
0.0144288931,
0.6224591136,
-0.362836957,
0.5403399467,
0.4758040309,
0.812582612,
0.478554666,
-0.2241113037,
0.8844327927,
-0.4365410209,
-0.2890483141,
0.102132313,
0.237046212,
0.4277138114,
-0.4286087453,
0.5428829789,
-0.2877510786,
-0.7124948502,
-0.5784454942,
-0.0514172576,
-0.720672667,
-0.2289089113,
1.2822401524,
-0.1860225201,
-0.4922718108,
-0.2176917046,
-0.7513546944,
0.3338215649,
-0.4360496402,
0.847322762,
0.5592560768,
-0.4396335483,
-0.0670472011,
-0.6937812567,
0.3341147602,
-0.0350323617,
-0.8921383619,
0.397375077,
0.4612863362,
0.1830277294,
0.0075978492,
0.4508604407,
0.0249436647,
0.1415906698,
0.11295975,
0.2283125818,
-0.2912921011,
-0.2386963218,
-0.1314538568,
0.1400334835,
0.2518086433,
-0.1229459718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12206v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12206v2 | PAXQA: Generating Cross-lingual Question Answering Examples at Training Scale | 2023-04-24T15:46:26 | 2023-10-17T15:46:54 | Bryan Li, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing question answering (QA) systems owe much of their success to large,
high-quality training data. Such annotation efforts are costly, and the
difficulty compounds in the cross-lingual setting. Therefore, prior
cross-lingual QA work has focused on releasing evaluation datasets, and then
applying zero-shot methods as baselines. This work proposes a synthetic data
generation method for cross-lingual QA which leverages indirect supervision
from existing parallel corpora. Our method termed PAXQA (Projecting annotations
for cross-lingual (x) QA) decomposes cross-lingual QA into two stages. First,
we apply a question generation (QG) model to the English side. Second, we apply
annotation projection to translate both the questions and answers. To better
translate questions, we propose a novel use of lexically-constrained machine
translation, in which constrained entities are extracted from the parallel
bitexts.
We apply PAXQA to generate cross-lingual QA examples in 4 languages (662K
examples total), and perform human evaluation on a subset to create validation
and test splits. We then show that models fine-tuned on these datasets
outperform prior synthetic data generation models over several extractive QA
datasets. The largest performance gains are for directions with non-English
questions and English contexts. Ablation studies show that our dataset
generation method is relatively robust to noise from automatic word alignments,
showing the sufficient quality of our generations. To facilitate follow-up
work, we release our code and datasets at https://github.com/manestay/paxqa . | [
-0.4912479818,
-0.7860381007,
0.4219435155,
0.232264936,
-0.152772516,
-0.0320957676,
0.1373161674,
-0.2567736804,
0.1620394439,
0.6929574013,
-0.6570504904,
-0.3467868865,
-0.0515340716,
0.3925538659,
-0.3794651926,
0.7130028009,
-0.1816390306,
0.257116735,
-0.3803214431,
-0.1578402221,
-0.4380830228,
-0.5716771483,
-0.8880600333,
-0.0593411997,
0.4871824384,
0.5278186202,
0.6825692654,
0.5776159167,
-0.1505491138,
0.1934398115,
0.1735809892,
0.3731984496,
-0.2690360844,
-0.1956324726,
-0.2681098878,
-0.638843298,
-0.1392151415,
-0.0571256913,
0.8214352131,
0.9650691748,
0.0010848881,
0.155458197,
-0.2960244119,
0.1996020228,
-0.5092113614,
0.0749952272,
-0.6087886691,
0.1522617787,
0.037309546,
-0.1552286595,
-0.2488186508,
-0.4403728247,
0.0581225157,
-0.931666851,
-0.0582250468,
0.2457670718,
0.869895637,
0.1446442753,
-0.6430692673,
-0.3613905013,
-0.4010204673,
0.7502446175,
-0.7164296508,
0.4546094537,
0.3387658,
0.5151341558,
0.1234965175,
-0.8346700668,
-0.832221806,
0.1114726514,
0.0340941958,
0.1299272478,
-0.1337136328,
-0.2947896123,
0.1383954436,
0.3787901998,
-0.7575061321,
-0.1042935178,
-0.5284226537,
-0.0842948779,
0.6060045958,
0.1924479008,
0.6452034712,
-0.1628084183,
-0.3465032578,
-0.4585878253,
-1.0343548059,
0.0776881352,
0.4150659144,
0.2775828838,
0.1082763746,
0.4878008664,
-0.4361782968,
0.3781917989,
0.2746891677,
0.0779078528,
0.372598052,
-0.5101443529,
-0.1548616737,
0.0260554999,
0.6378451586,
0.313328445,
0.256126523,
-0.3217874467,
-0.0315276235,
-0.2430210114,
0.1640233696,
-0.6828895211,
-0.0779466107,
0.2323069572,
-0.0369081013,
-0.1249187514,
-0.2207979858,
-0.697050035,
-0.0574712679,
-0.4171321392,
0.5159743428,
-0.309271127,
-0.3469506204,
0.2061149031,
0.0414074175,
0.6349915266,
-0.061540056,
-0.5845544934,
0.3248077929,
0.4624561965,
0.1504797041,
-0.0846270844,
-0.4109933376,
-0.8575721979,
-0.0616441444,
-0.6982386708,
0.4349928796,
-0.3505092561,
-0.2529191077,
0.3081457019,
0.1939923465,
-0.1507789046,
-0.7425305247,
0.5230945945,
-0.6813465953,
0.6495064497,
-0.3447954059,
-0.405626446,
-0.0940035433,
0.4345104396,
-0.3420863748,
1.0114998817,
0.2472650409,
-0.6575958729,
0.1821387261,
-0.3118421435,
-0.2824057937,
-0.0027810261,
-0.1530559957,
-0.2501728833,
-0.1189394817,
0.7460306883,
0.0714884847,
-0.4587690234,
0.1819304526,
0.1619442552,
-0.1427045912,
0.2551653683,
-0.239193514,
0.9820683599,
0.0879192799,
-0.3918227851,
0.0369895026,
-0.7991108894,
0.4292026758,
0.0292328242,
-0.0803539306,
-0.4316653013,
-0.4484057426,
-0.0312993564,
0.5534877181,
0.0183272194,
-0.7214505672,
-0.0719178617,
-0.5687582493,
0.0227704979,
0.2823290825,
0.3981665075,
0.3592785001,
-0.2554083169,
0.990198195,
0.0298516881,
0.1035467908,
-0.0427660011,
-0.4122281969,
-0.7417915463,
0.0582716428,
0.4813639522,
0.7272268534,
-1.452650547,
-0.0951711237,
-0.2581093907,
-0.4820674062,
-0.519741416,
0.1793791056,
0.8052409887,
0.6325321794,
0.4255675375,
0.0279210713,
-0.3899255097,
-0.9701573253,
-0.0543419719,
-0.29178074,
-0.1651738435,
0.3246077299,
0.1579388529,
0.0961038843,
0.6782214642,
-0.3306556642,
0.2086417824,
-0.1718455255,
0.3133853078,
-0.2628903389,
0.4484234452,
0.5642513633,
-1.0129300356,
-0.4494872987,
-0.1326415837,
-0.5912125111,
-0.4711062908,
-0.3747530878,
-0.451646775,
0.152965799,
0.6346998215,
-0.3599664569,
0.0529842675,
0.5461058021,
-0.3429210782,
0.6185455918,
0.0461267829,
0.1962470114,
-1.308768034,
-0.0057559926,
-0.2389670759,
-0.2023411095,
-0.5328465104,
0.3227247894,
0.1206863001,
-0.3541362286,
-0.7436037064,
0.7707332373,
-0.4379837215,
0.0869005322,
-0.064187333,
0.2022239566,
0.103033416,
0.6379326582,
0.2681863308,
0.7827213407,
0.4067587256,
-0.3653482497,
0.2964639068,
0.4971178472,
-0.2418364882,
0.4727900326,
-0.815730691,
0.1694591343,
-0.0109999012,
0.0367723629,
-0.8926825523,
-0.1273699105,
0.4377254248,
-0.5007349253,
0.0630402938,
0.0170277748,
-0.6225634217,
-0.066497691,
-0.0170842502,
0.656404078,
0.5937579274,
-0.7666845918,
0.3024176955,
0.2560728192,
-0.4605581164,
-0.5204556584,
-0.5966643691,
0.1496882737,
-0.2064945847,
-0.6512297988,
0.2406014502,
0.0100240353,
-0.2390598208,
-0.0382229462,
0.0334087014,
-0.2356734574,
-0.2572589517,
0.109026283,
0.2239355594,
-0.3023203313,
0.1107104346,
0.4448322356,
0.1950456649,
0.4380201399,
-0.3511270583,
0.3523362279,
0.1752324998,
-0.1812227368,
-0.153600499,
0.7692601085,
0.4783127904,
-0.488619864,
0.4050076306,
0.5428549647,
-0.352853924,
-0.4184525907,
-0.3370151222,
-0.1043983698,
-0.4153285921,
0.173635006,
-0.6040542126,
-0.6174128652,
0.3957211971,
0.1318672895,
0.129539907,
0.1676032841,
0.5355125666,
0.3068574965,
1.1535099745,
0.4423771799,
0.4145205915,
0.0196845997,
-0.1345337629,
0.1235213801,
-0.5657809973,
-0.0226584636,
-0.2718058228,
0.1660905778,
-0.6479174495,
-0.6698913574,
0.6353906393,
0.0121234618,
-0.0255183373,
0.171427682,
-0.2250903398,
0.2709985375,
0.8042719364,
-0.1949550658,
0.1172428504,
-0.0028755788,
-0.2566525638,
0.1022704467,
-0.8228418827,
-0.2904744148,
1.1400109529,
0.1348331422,
0.2748327553,
-0.0686612576,
0.770082593,
-0.280063808,
0.1323252916,
-0.3544244766,
0.4542786777,
0.0279521737,
-0.7820138335,
-0.3538659513,
-0.6125784516,
-0.7888265252,
0.1922878176,
-0.0872588977,
-0.3456391096,
0.4535732865,
-0.008105739,
-0.4066447914,
0.0890874192,
-0.7716782093,
1.0035687685,
-0.0966368988,
-0.3975732327,
0.1287406832,
-0.6316199899,
0.5307016969,
-0.2559267581,
-0.0160287656,
0.1464980245,
-0.0289626811,
0.6149868965,
-0.5750992298,
0.7609077096,
-0.2550549507,
-0.4354304969,
0.5202302933,
-0.0503920354,
0.2509395778,
0.3707429171,
0.0106268022,
-0.0632834285,
0.5967319608,
-0.6218545437,
-0.7875543237,
0.4854234755,
-0.6714939475,
-0.6216275096,
-0.2527750134,
-0.9476197958,
-0.7739617229,
-0.0546499602,
0.1796368808,
0.4301090539,
0.1039992943,
-0.0133408355,
0.5315879583,
-0.6129791141,
-0.0267319269,
0.4406297803,
-0.4488684535,
-0.5843957067,
1.0470467806,
0.1653050184,
0.3657688797,
0.4517023861,
-0.0371984728,
-0.5064808726,
-0.3811903894,
-0.7908312082,
0.3401416242,
-0.4905400872,
-0.0342664085,
-0.4478433132,
-0.1548334658,
-0.7059438229,
-0.0446999893,
-0.2180438787,
-0.6566210985,
0.2235628963,
0.0939157382,
-0.0761834532,
0.2662617862,
-0.1214416698,
0.1086600646,
-0.700686276,
0.5309856534,
0.5844008923,
-0.1246779338,
-0.214352414,
-0.265594542,
-0.2017871439,
0.211531505,
-0.0253203399,
-0.7309510112,
0.607516706,
0.0192094184,
0.2780451477,
-0.0369691178,
0.3898158371,
0.4875919223,
-0.4011641741,
0.7429575324,
-0.1215431318,
-0.8281860948,
0.3811361194,
-0.2983877063,
0.5191370249,
0.4193111956,
0.6503039002,
-0.7105951309,
-0.3355291188,
-0.4183575213,
-0.862432003,
0.488257587,
0.1626100838,
0.1624411345,
-0.2408452928,
0.478307724,
0.3243083358,
0.1111528799,
-0.4842639267,
-0.1364423633,
-0.2041637301,
-0.1438496411,
0.0298413634,
-0.1628905386,
-0.1149154902,
-0.0720503628,
0.8702026606,
-0.3696910143,
-0.0947858542,
0.392529875,
0.057588391,
-0.0153432442,
0.2942477763,
0.1492191255,
0.8128578663,
0.0009186588,
-0.076986447,
0.2587670982,
-0.1692287475,
0.1880636513,
0.4235028327,
-0.5606705546,
0.0690009445,
0.1519486159,
0.4804514349,
-0.0351244695,
-1.0301840305,
0.3549432755,
-0.2790993452,
-0.3690198064,
-0.5185816288,
-0.2501117885,
0.0544488132,
0.2086732686,
0.2450634688,
-0.6286588311,
0.1258807033,
-0.6254765987,
0.2610761225,
0.1751192063,
-0.1786101013,
-0.2596831918,
0.711375773,
0.1233830824,
0.1285576671,
0.7368998528,
-0.3788528144,
-0.4300791323,
0.5481206179,
0.5357774496,
0.737167418,
-0.0602426343,
0.4787041545,
0.3607958555,
0.1544112116,
0.3511060774,
0.6126291156,
-0.1714443415,
-0.5522402525,
-0.6288727522,
-0.6448663473,
-0.6302914023,
0.0549972057,
-0.708920598,
0.0619861968,
-0.1980639994,
0.3149679005,
-0.0003787263,
0.0816785917,
-0.4055038691,
0.5709397793,
0.395901531,
0.9854325056,
-0.879148066,
0.850763917,
0.9360791445,
-0.5749582052,
-1.1182912588,
0.2006342411,
-0.2130731046,
-0.8013459444,
0.7762438059,
-0.1805725247,
0.1981493831,
-0.0343095809,
-0.2727435827,
-0.6826713681,
0.8800141811,
0.3687076569,
-0.1946526468,
-0.4286607206,
0.7950578332,
0.5165059566,
-0.3926775753,
-0.0352913439,
0.3705896735,
0.2947793603,
0.1142572463,
-0.8899797201,
0.1801124066,
-0.5535091758,
-0.1299037784,
0.0329401344,
-0.4595500827,
0.7873802781,
0.0614534989,
-0.167343244,
0.2630690336,
0.4812702239,
0.3001181483,
0.3472109139,
0.6469978094,
0.5613268018,
0.4135756493,
-0.023160059,
1.1191601753,
-0.3209480941,
-0.2607933879,
1.2133443356,
-0.2805683017,
0.779827714,
0.6653052568,
0.1194528043,
0.2666477859,
0.635643363,
0.3259670734,
0.2234419286,
0.3705081344,
-0.1248701364,
-0.3891362548,
-0.4062732458,
-0.2268654257,
0.5158081651,
0.139487952,
-0.2915455401,
-0.3048051,
0.1941167116,
-0.0187848434,
0.242509976,
-0.1955219805,
0.5065762997,
-0.0932540447,
-1.0269732475,
0.940705955,
-0.1217364818,
0.2335700244,
-0.4906713068,
-0.2403409779,
-0.5231686234,
-0.059082482,
0.0870928094,
-0.5921953321,
0.4106582403,
0.0288234912,
0.0521065891,
-0.3565852046,
0.2044381201,
-0.7935332656,
-0.757129848,
0.04772247,
0.8583939075,
0.2937696576,
-0.1731493622,
-0.4810688198,
-0.234703213,
0.1147985384,
-0.0017538737,
0.2367257327,
0.665278852,
-0.3514834046,
0.3970566988,
0.4778035581,
0.1122571379,
0.5324823856,
-0.0703740343,
0.7478513718,
-0.3223869801,
-0.2962379754,
-0.0052104918,
0.3581861556,
-0.0282185748,
-0.6509500742,
0.7913994789,
0.6221870184,
1.2040885687,
-0.0627379045,
0.712695539,
0.0248404648,
0.8087595701,
-0.5209295154,
0.5418999791,
-0.7837962508,
0.0705984235,
0.0815851316,
-0.6953753829,
-0.1315642893,
-0.1011518687,
-0.505889535,
-0.2664874792,
0.5572040081,
1.0426402092,
-0.0580687597,
-0.2121770531,
0.4841995835,
-0.0574317612,
0.2097814232,
0.8192315698,
0.855784297,
-0.8006670475,
1.0497299433,
-0.7550044656,
0.0537006184,
0.3219387531,
-0.3403812647,
-0.8197280765,
-0.8372800946,
-0.5653802156,
-0.197329253,
0.2355514914,
0.6366918683,
0.7904235125,
-0.8391756415,
-0.1414041221,
-0.0192184411,
-0.0617946982,
-0.2218624204,
-0.2997375131,
0.4993515313,
-0.5227246881,
-1.1581397057,
0.4434258044,
-0.1813690215,
-0.1222812831,
-0.3272771835,
0.038341146,
-0.3705946803,
0.2853685915,
0.3971486688,
0.6115369797,
-0.4559049308,
-0.2510928214,
0.3398900628,
0.0565516949,
-0.1243566349,
0.4879015088,
-0.8850483894,
0.3837180734,
0.4802490175,
1.049733758,
0.3881690502,
0.1081167459,
0.9040859938,
-0.941740334,
-0.0748062581,
0.2997697294,
0.1999276131,
0.389906466,
-0.1481700689,
0.5158991814,
-0.0679148212,
-0.3176689148,
-0.8826083541,
0.1354139596,
-0.7197583318,
-0.2312990725,
1.1601843834,
-0.4051271975,
-0.4590247571,
-0.0386104733,
-0.3250155151,
0.2362530082,
0.1269874722,
0.6935358047,
0.4744796157,
-0.1439893097,
-0.4195919931,
-0.3959302902,
0.3673224449,
0.927157104,
-0.9821459055,
0.0951506346,
0.5009524226,
0.2199254036,
0.2889454961,
0.2239490002,
-0.4008128643,
0.6757038236,
0.2887872458,
0.1613132209,
-0.0031536804,
0.0413646474,
-0.1324886978,
0.4131392837,
-0.0882432982,
-0.3815201521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12102v1 | Unlocking Context Constraints of LLMs: Enhancing Context Efficiency of LLMs with Self-Information-Based Content Filtering | 2023-04-24T13:55:47 | 2023-04-24T13:55:47 | Yucheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have received significant attention by achieving
remarkable performance across various tasks. However, their fixed context
length poses challenges when processing long documents or maintaining extended
conversations. This paper proposes a method called \textit{Selective Context}
that employs self-information to filter out less informative content, thereby
enhancing the efficiency of the fixed context length. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach on tasks of summarisation and question answering
across different data sources, including academic papers, news articles, and
conversation transcripts. | [
-0.5266588926,
-0.6709672809,
0.7676871419,
0.1273692697,
-0.467096597,
0.0502950735,
-0.2975492179,
-0.5199494362,
0.3801361024,
0.8016065359,
-0.8445176482,
-0.4592458904,
-0.3658807874,
0.3335685432,
-0.5267635584,
0.8502859473,
-0.1344680935,
-0.2472504824,
-0.5611793399,
-0.3386911154,
-0.4332987666,
-0.6279691458,
-0.3933858871,
-0.1981233209,
0.5176510215,
0.5003726482,
0.292342186,
0.6470680833,
0.4995130002,
0.2262318879,
-0.2575899959,
0.4767611027,
-0.711889267,
0.5535215139,
-0.4066176713,
-0.3337378204,
-0.1921783388,
-0.1731023937,
0.910440743,
0.3860426843,
-0.0706456527,
0.0875137746,
0.3480660915,
0.7527230978,
-0.7115988731,
-0.0375141576,
-0.5919718146,
0.0590857901,
-0.1259621084,
-0.3361701369,
-0.3011901975,
0.1638564467,
0.0148673169,
-0.4661759138,
0.0335868783,
-0.0853815973,
0.6461277604,
0.5193610787,
-0.5684878826,
-0.4100911617,
-0.7477574348,
0.9368760586,
-0.5868365765,
0.399816066,
0.5902563334,
0.0716814175,
-0.0582580045,
-0.6721998453,
-0.3685445786,
0.1799051762,
-0.4914421439,
0.1491441727,
0.084086597,
0.0884154812,
0.1991114169,
0.3365358114,
-0.5195527077,
0.0169373807,
-0.5178853869,
-0.1657595485,
0.6134600639,
0.2655268013,
0.043675404,
-0.535153091,
-0.0944872648,
0.3551442027,
-0.8393198848,
-0.1534055769,
0.0398392268,
0.0987969562,
-0.0185378026,
0.6072410941,
-0.7784574032,
0.8403502703,
-0.0331693105,
-0.3199500144,
-0.1520161033,
-0.4781274796,
-0.1470400095,
-0.3163591623,
0.4272989631,
0.2915251553,
-0.1647303104,
-0.0251658149,
-0.2558093071,
-0.3302664459,
-0.0079517625,
-1.0079472065,
0.1465248764,
0.3003153205,
-0.4412644506,
0.1747430414,
-0.0683028251,
-0.5791418552,
-0.1843863875,
-0.2212428898,
0.0458995774,
-0.0793057829,
0.0598641187,
-0.1321446896,
0.0248257238,
0.2841066122,
0.3908886611,
-0.8185539246,
0.2055309564,
0.4578511715,
0.9485394359,
-0.4942470789,
-0.0308899879,
-0.6111570001,
0.5002017617,
-0.1003106758,
0.7167158723,
-0.6835578084,
-0.5373590589,
-0.0986673683,
0.060726583,
0.0122794248,
-0.4691197276,
0.4527644813,
-0.7814347148,
0.3206105232,
-0.4167370796,
-0.746435523,
0.017250089,
0.1893869787,
-0.5972156525,
0.9035092592,
0.209476918,
-0.6616356373,
0.2145545781,
-0.5045339465,
-0.7126992941,
0.1093149409,
-0.3304402828,
-0.0447767414,
0.0098042702,
0.4418458939,
0.454359293,
-0.1752476692,
0.5218403935,
-0.1859190762,
-0.3442419767,
0.1332175285,
-0.3673933744,
0.3861361146,
0.5832882524,
-0.002852526,
0.3014111817,
-0.6021342278,
-0.3009211123,
-0.0531731099,
-0.6643651128,
-0.4203686118,
0.2358376682,
-0.2112677395,
0.2267415524,
0.5266344547,
-0.4596176147,
0.1691946685,
-0.0671498179,
0.5817101598,
0.5134762526,
0.1748355627,
0.481279999,
-0.4422115982,
0.5309174657,
-0.0760877058,
0.0588895641,
-0.3833105266,
-0.121532999,
-0.6920489073,
-0.3363465667,
0.3303537369,
0.4402596354,
-1.0031026602,
0.4478755891,
-0.171350047,
-0.0439965464,
-0.3068053722,
0.5745542049,
0.2022614181,
0.5765002966,
0.3539614379,
-0.213244155,
-0.6723760366,
-0.9469745159,
-0.3110765219,
0.0911226943,
-0.1954648793,
0.6099516749,
0.202086553,
-0.2483152598,
1.219596982,
-0.5437713861,
-0.4507796764,
-0.5194402933,
-0.0647698492,
0.4327856302,
0.3389153183,
0.2995664477,
-0.8965535164,
-0.4852280617,
-0.5081988573,
-0.7814155817,
-0.5015702248,
-0.2955975533,
0.0752650201,
0.1916537732,
0.8280261755,
-0.3864576221,
0.3590270877,
0.6477599144,
-0.3362869024,
0.2185902745,
-0.1709647775,
-0.0416295342,
-0.9307829738,
-0.0161287244,
-0.0044667823,
-0.7406730056,
-0.5222317576,
-0.0414148569,
0.2039876878,
0.0504892953,
-0.4810760021,
0.8703397512,
-0.7561673522,
0.0740683675,
-0.6053614616,
0.5268734694,
0.1388007253,
0.3593079746,
0.3174042106,
0.8984373808,
0.250762105,
-0.8860857487,
-0.0632082298,
0.357835263,
-0.5377719402,
0.5818498135,
-0.3813338578,
0.0029959078,
-0.3806559443,
0.4517183602,
-0.8707276583,
-0.3677812219,
0.0317356512,
-0.0005971909,
0.210325256,
-0.2397237271,
-0.3671898544,
-0.2110636681,
-0.2808491588,
0.4533613324,
0.2154358476,
-0.5356464982,
0.5800216794,
0.6276110411,
-0.2883156538,
-0.6002668738,
-0.6154851317,
0.3159945309,
-0.2441974282,
-0.4642539918,
0.5364775658,
-0.4281899035,
-0.1330370754,
0.0119889667,
-0.2863101661,
-0.1822816432,
0.2104793489,
0.1083711609,
0.0921534076,
-0.0091963522,
0.2715515792,
0.334125638,
0.1932796836,
-0.1032772139,
-0.0527925491,
0.5001145601,
0.1446618587,
-0.2415138781,
-0.3887951076,
0.6448419094,
0.4214397967,
-0.0304311924,
0.7560955882,
0.3924302757,
-0.1868496686,
-0.3266861141,
-0.7828791738,
-0.3997151852,
-0.5406156182,
0.3267084658,
-0.459015727,
-1.5207183361,
0.5735408664,
0.1289787441,
-0.0137323523,
0.3534366786,
0.3952180743,
0.0361806974,
0.8346967101,
0.4973037243,
-0.3431206942,
0.8317045569,
-0.0170948897,
0.0737626702,
-1.1259068251,
0.1327279955,
-0.1665110439,
-0.1871839017,
-0.4262773693,
-0.1622143984,
0.4042876065,
0.0060895775,
0.2406347245,
0.1882570535,
-0.4421267509,
0.6731925607,
0.6552644968,
0.2834870517,
0.4400312304,
-0.3086466491,
0.1300185323,
0.0294989385,
-0.8936843872,
-0.3590580225,
0.9914272428,
0.2822840512,
0.8955316544,
0.1101390868,
0.6299422979,
0.2867736518,
0.4142919183,
-0.5282026529,
0.6476985216,
-0.083865881,
-0.8697256446,
-0.4815310538,
-0.6160586476,
-0.8664829135,
0.417439729,
-0.0316269509,
-0.8204728961,
0.1641570926,
-0.06295643,
-0.46411708,
0.1012921706,
-0.3984921277,
0.4615214765,
-0.1608070284,
-0.4620710015,
-0.252216965,
-0.483137995,
0.2861020565,
-0.196672231,
0.2974702716,
-0.3125194013,
-0.0107014393,
0.7811434269,
-0.2012300789,
0.967368722,
0.007022291,
-0.0681306869,
0.6228553057,
0.0271896832,
0.5005449653,
0.2128740698,
-0.0605243109,
0.0550899059,
0.2134202868,
-0.2966468632,
-0.481965214,
0.7279390693,
-0.4407680631,
-1.0900148153,
-0.2342564613,
-0.7030383945,
-0.1398759633,
0.3735630512,
0.204852879,
0.4162096977,
-0.0931614265,
0.6847345829,
0.495259434,
-0.0170687754,
0.7542344332,
0.7680400014,
-0.1591506302,
-0.3419552743,
0.5370051861,
0.4036745727,
0.0857372135,
0.5159804821,
0.2015302777,
-0.5345488787,
-0.6573186517,
-0.2623660266,
0.3484357893,
-0.9379718304,
-0.2424868941,
-0.7063189149,
-0.462163806,
-0.5472795367,
-0.0105226096,
-0.029782474,
-0.478998512,
-0.5753359199,
0.0306659229,
-0.0844213516,
0.6833286285,
-0.0713078231,
0.5105780959,
-0.6959275603,
0.4578825831,
0.46405375,
0.4341471493,
-0.2800348699,
-0.7086782455,
-0.4094823897,
-0.2307257652,
-0.1817433834,
-0.8072633147,
0.3715326786,
0.1539612412,
0.6479002237,
0.4199546278,
0.418751359,
0.482321173,
-0.2805928886,
0.7224212289,
-0.2237029374,
-0.8541591167,
0.6609110236,
-0.397726059,
0.5413050652,
0.8321721554,
0.2260451317,
-0.5838826299,
-0.4289307296,
-0.293677181,
-1.0296219587,
0.5922186971,
0.3370277286,
0.170244813,
-0.070472233,
0.7153406143,
-0.1156548113,
0.3134488463,
-0.9372532964,
-0.1382489204,
0.1031353772,
-0.1977026165,
-0.0312089473,
-0.8013492227,
-0.2487509549,
-0.2287123203,
0.6895615458,
-0.1886539161,
-0.1422482133,
0.8312369585,
-0.4844005704,
0.0213397164,
0.3298626244,
0.734267354,
0.8497216702,
-0.1180463508,
0.1968413889,
0.4175112247,
-0.2367554158,
0.0099317785,
-0.2114919126,
-0.4037964046,
-0.0076425211,
0.1976352334,
0.5874346495,
0.1490594745,
-0.7206086516,
0.3268201649,
-0.2074726969,
-0.0199092831,
-0.3016834557,
0.3610090911,
-0.025197953,
0.1847088188,
0.3979011178,
-0.7244412899,
0.3418696225,
-0.4489388764,
0.3640437126,
0.478774488,
-0.3736911416,
0.0239511412,
0.593737185,
0.3336547911,
-0.1335989237,
0.3087793291,
-0.0257572159,
-0.3006936312,
0.3971252441,
0.6145983338,
0.7389580607,
-0.215638876,
0.0277386624,
0.1964478195,
0.1971982867,
-0.1003052965,
0.2329332381,
-0.5882015228,
-0.7639701962,
-0.66656214,
-0.6333724856,
-0.6361816525,
0.3627558649,
-0.5041422844,
0.0857766494,
-0.3775446117,
-0.120667018,
-0.2878620327,
0.0411803462,
-0.363670826,
0.2941767275,
0.0606942326,
0.942779541,
-0.4925492406,
0.9397459626,
0.3226615191,
0.0513439626,
-0.3841668367,
-0.0515390821,
-0.1037833467,
-0.5623463392,
0.4612423778,
0.2976990342,
-0.2682270408,
-0.1067148373,
-0.4615781307,
-1.1124836206,
0.994811058,
0.205456987,
-0.792419076,
0.0102428738,
0.0825628266,
0.443829298,
-0.5487374067,
0.0563770868,
0.5988072157,
0.6312372088,
0.1687405258,
-0.7165827155,
0.1603521556,
-0.2412852943,
-0.2162804306,
-0.0155433761,
-0.9222277999,
0.600738287,
0.2118396461,
-0.2763436139,
-0.1032135487,
0.7682132125,
0.0358778462,
0.3041677475,
0.5875261426,
0.2161193043,
0.7577571869,
0.1246751174,
1.0295023918,
-0.6564016342,
0.3407040536,
1.4012285471,
-0.283755213,
0.7183527946,
0.4521896839,
0.1631804556,
0.5029584169,
0.8083057404,
0.0683658123,
0.6182359457,
0.0402871408,
-0.4266086519,
-0.272973597,
-0.2586567998,
-0.0696175694,
0.489826262,
0.4231309891,
-0.2615632415,
-0.0713443607,
-0.1530423015,
-0.0105698714,
-0.0218401942,
-0.2889860868,
0.9895261526,
0.1618992984,
-0.9476425052,
0.3031269908,
0.0875919163,
0.6731231809,
-0.4924776554,
0.3122032285,
-0.3489872217,
-0.1785069108,
-0.261549443,
-0.7640015483,
0.6547757983,
-0.1300976425,
-0.268189162,
-0.3443918228,
1.1267594099,
-0.4709917009,
-0.1920446008,
0.3164791465,
0.7580180764,
-0.0279333107,
-0.3493533432,
-0.3271049559,
-0.0101281218,
-0.0341785103,
-0.5275101662,
0.3459041417,
0.3399676681,
0.0179814603,
0.8285948038,
0.4967601001,
0.1202485412,
-0.3028181493,
-0.0527820513,
0.9555003047,
-0.8711046576,
-0.8865122199,
-0.9143624902,
0.0501896627,
-0.3719500303,
-0.0778869316,
0.7119014263,
0.718306303,
0.7758865356,
0.2522473335,
0.8056676984,
0.1083492562,
0.6255538464,
-0.6601356268,
0.7386705875,
-0.5849143267,
0.5586445928,
0.0518365279,
-0.8514808416,
-0.2615503967,
0.503395617,
-0.4602888227,
-0.0508968607,
0.6021039486,
0.5983154178,
-0.0680335388,
-0.1038656533,
0.5160763264,
0.1032132208,
0.2464182973,
0.2753832936,
0.8686140776,
0.1930821985,
0.6059454083,
-0.2251252979,
-0.1110062376,
-0.3490180373,
-0.9334719777,
-1.2624783516,
-0.6359370351,
-0.1464960128,
-0.1818338186,
-0.0857267976,
0.7200757265,
1.1532539129,
-0.7691045403,
-0.3000164628,
0.0227837004,
0.6105293632,
0.3229483962,
-0.2390834242,
0.1716408432,
-0.3418951035,
-0.5733737946,
0.6987216473,
0.4767619371,
0.0074834265,
-0.4010381699,
0.0789092407,
-0.0792025551,
0.2945152223,
0.6621343493,
0.2442289144,
-0.4921494722,
-0.4227473438,
-0.1587857753,
-0.0597967952,
0.3082953095,
0.9891719222,
-0.7200590968,
0.1654106081,
0.4477004409,
0.5803539753,
0.9170850515,
0.3091540337,
0.4103305042,
-0.9958617091,
0.1037957668,
0.1531041116,
0.5279027224,
0.4119267166,
-0.7058778405,
0.6771611571,
0.1511501074,
-0.6017170548,
-0.7234121561,
0.4214129448,
-0.8769792318,
-0.7150325775,
1.3463921547,
-0.073181659,
-0.2835972011,
-0.2196611613,
-0.151851669,
0.1241228804,
-0.4733918309,
0.8588423729,
0.7387212515,
-0.2799733281,
-0.414542377,
-0.5795892477,
0.4820979238,
0.426304251,
-0.8914635181,
0.0470456779,
0.5753352046,
0.4523927569,
-0.038817659,
0.883667171,
0.1323066354,
-0.1736187935,
-0.6072144508,
-0.4159966111,
-0.0283735339,
-0.624360621,
-0.2933427095,
0.3819813132,
-0.1224780083,
0.1623463184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.14276v1 | AI, write an essay for me: A large-scale comparison of human-written versus ChatGPT-generated essays | 2023-04-24T12:58:28 | 2023-04-24T12:58:28 | Steffen Herbold, Annette Hautli-Janisz, Ute Heuer, Zlata Kikteva, Alexander Trautsch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Background: Recently, ChatGPT and similar generative AI models have attracted
hundreds of millions of users and become part of the public discourse. Many
believe that such models will disrupt society and will result in a significant
change in the education system and information generation in the future. So
far, this belief is based on either colloquial evidence or benchmarks from the
owners of the models -- both lack scientific rigour.
Objective: Through a large-scale study comparing human-written versus
ChatGPT-generated argumentative student essays, we systematically assess the
quality of the AI-generated content.
Methods: A large corpus of essays was rated using standard criteria by a
large number of human experts (teachers). We augment the analysis with a
consideration of the linguistic characteristics of the generated essays.
Results: Our results demonstrate that ChatGPT generates essays that are rated
higher for quality than human-written essays. The writing style of the AI
models exhibits linguistic characteristics that are different from those of the
human-written essays, e.g., it is characterized by fewer discourse and
epistemic markers, but more nominalizations and greater lexical diversity.
Conclusions: Our results clearly demonstrate that models like ChatGPT
outperform humans in generating argumentative essays. Since the technology is
readily available for anyone to use, educators must act immediately. We must
re-invent homework and develop teaching concepts that utilize these AI models
in the same way as math utilized the calculator: teach the general concepts
first and then use AI tools to free up time for other learning objectives. | [
-0.4131411314,
-0.9161251783,
0.3798127174,
-0.0603855141,
0.1531815678,
0.307730794,
-0.0871631205,
-0.3097107112,
-0.1192987114,
0.2931759059,
-0.2489942461,
-0.2721862197,
-0.4693787992,
0.2285362333,
-0.5487605333,
1.117782712,
-0.0825332627,
0.1189187393,
-0.4517989457,
0.3984889984,
-0.1445181817,
-0.6335884333,
-0.9889178872,
-0.2108079493,
0.364818871,
0.4417930543,
0.5708719492,
0.1799522191,
0.7780393362,
0.3899857402,
0.1755392551,
-0.0279960074,
-0.3285888731,
-0.2104940861,
-0.0934270844,
-0.2313460261,
-0.2209360003,
0.3367015123,
0.60143435,
0.6669173837,
-0.1365755349,
0.3082687557,
0.1854420751,
0.4246936738,
-0.3641780913,
0.1764794439,
-0.5649375916,
0.1451301128,
-0.0264210645,
0.1146070138,
-0.6489177346,
-0.6670074463,
0.3560111523,
-0.6636190414,
0.1926967502,
-0.0206450485,
0.9082306027,
0.1487603039,
-0.2464010119,
-0.506413579,
-0.8652837276,
0.5571123362,
-0.6827685237,
-0.2013725489,
0.0600397736,
0.1216787323,
-0.2075638026,
-0.8288075924,
-0.9248241782,
-0.3476437628,
0.0326917358,
0.5186265707,
-0.0997415707,
0.2145204395,
0.3369040489,
0.2850784063,
-0.6313230991,
-0.0120269665,
-0.6568574905,
-0.1914443523,
0.6466038823,
0.3657726943,
0.4987423122,
-0.281085819,
-0.3286570013,
-0.2666369379,
-0.37842834,
0.3059933484,
0.7394030094,
-0.1178613231,
0.2238427103,
0.7209593058,
0.160898298,
0.1419986486,
-0.1455674618,
-0.1436185986,
-0.3091497123,
-0.130391106,
-0.0246557016,
0.0552036613,
1.0503811836,
0.4282288551,
0.5470670462,
-0.0228833351,
0.049012471,
0.301325053,
0.3752216399,
-0.923055768,
-0.3623635471,
-0.0195624642,
-0.5796608925,
-0.4260015786,
0.1701219082,
-0.9320181012,
-0.3551575243,
-0.4508137703,
0.5255935788,
-0.4301715195,
-0.0929361433,
-0.1036834493,
-0.2461601943,
0.4059276283,
0.3964610398,
-0.8102258444,
0.3574362397,
0.6914750934,
0.8579753637,
-0.2507724464,
-0.4997225404,
0.1269698292,
-0.062214762,
-0.5021635294,
1.047118783,
-0.7341833711,
-0.6773850918,
0.1773582995,
-0.2643626332,
-0.3821047843,
-0.4971231818,
0.7474043965,
-0.0565115921,
0.7565864921,
-0.0598843135,
-0.8802121878,
-0.2074105889,
0.0745986924,
-0.3670225739,
0.9692959189,
0.0823408812,
-0.6301043034,
0.1998009831,
-0.9878861308,
-0.4069030285,
-0.0227900986,
-0.3006771505,
-0.6003992558,
-0.1461220831,
-0.0246367529,
0.4067639112,
-0.3501165211,
0.4062881768,
0.0742605329,
-0.4499736726,
0.4103107154,
-0.7112782598,
0.648082912,
0.1437796652,
-0.5806640983,
-0.1900195628,
-0.6744417548,
-0.099574402,
0.2011424005,
-0.6209496856,
0.036860805,
0.2758896351,
0.047903154,
0.0135343447,
0.01930576,
-0.6894898415,
0.2102849931,
-0.3655382395,
0.5667949319,
0.8286451101,
-0.0260115024,
0.0438265949,
-0.6267712116,
0.6350724101,
-0.1722898036,
-0.179625228,
-0.4224641025,
-0.6267145276,
-0.7533215284,
0.0068824375,
0.1439369768,
0.6016011834,
-0.3293591738,
0.1024972126,
-0.1507445723,
-0.6311890483,
-0.6515249014,
-0.2088346928,
0.3524717689,
0.637327075,
0.2654686272,
-0.2099155188,
-0.3337505162,
-0.7709194422,
-0.3970530331,
-0.4693535268,
-0.1501723528,
0.5411109328,
0.5527668595,
0.0193152782,
0.8252094984,
-0.527693212,
-0.0233242121,
-0.20464921,
0.5786809325,
-0.3175582588,
0.5621519089,
0.4424180388,
-0.3677153587,
-0.8293554783,
-0.1833708137,
-0.6791570187,
-0.1014063731,
-0.4201368392,
-0.1411036104,
0.3152072132,
0.3734302819,
-0.7012252212,
0.5692011118,
0.1708679199,
-0.4510815144,
0.8601086736,
-0.1088308543,
0.5035834908,
-1.1344190836,
0.1803505421,
-0.0703675002,
0.1978879124,
-0.4484294653,
-0.2220002562,
-0.3280584514,
-0.6694657803,
-0.1297564358,
0.4547843933,
0.0081370696,
0.2986462414,
-0.2736079693,
0.0270330124,
0.1855164319,
0.3665162325,
-0.170603469,
1.1154624224,
0.1059073731,
-0.0955343693,
0.0269169789,
0.211886391,
-0.2654738426,
0.5513079762,
-0.8809283972,
0.1561413556,
-0.1148745939,
0.4015480876,
-1.1818591356,
-0.4080467224,
0.0139568392,
-0.6462196708,
0.0589629784,
0.1244755313,
-0.1248023435,
-0.4303517044,
-0.2553806305,
-0.0528862961,
0.7023340464,
-0.3909309804,
0.6456010342,
0.1691494137,
-0.4455792606,
-0.2634232938,
-0.4131907225,
0.4182839394,
-0.2682193518,
-0.7244181037,
0.2401653826,
-0.1965018213,
-0.5536108613,
0.0259984657,
0.4098774195,
-0.2070218921,
0.1246822253,
0.3444767296,
0.2800442278,
-0.3894869387,
0.3129161596,
0.0671953335,
-0.0031857968,
0.4029925168,
-0.1704472601,
0.4107627869,
-0.0974485949,
-0.3599345386,
-0.61725384,
0.803160727,
0.7237315178,
-0.1240071133,
0.7447391152,
0.5926563144,
-0.1162693799,
-0.0636232421,
-0.5812416077,
-0.2538180947,
-0.4318128228,
0.3069984913,
0.0426286384,
-0.7919945121,
0.2308593541,
-0.0800616816,
0.3411200643,
0.5558531284,
0.4340826571,
-0.2726486623,
0.9565914273,
0.3399232924,
-0.079571791,
0.3652576506,
-0.2785260975,
0.546890676,
-0.4582587779,
-0.0643926337,
-0.7648884058,
-0.2154336125,
-0.6451340318,
-0.107312113,
0.2232718319,
-0.3586891592,
-0.4282985926,
-0.1645831019,
-0.816375196,
0.5408517718,
0.7254781723,
-0.1976698935,
-0.0009775617,
0.0875884071,
0.0487433635,
-0.1501353085,
-0.494838506,
-1.1718921661,
1.2777266502,
0.0865875483,
0.3882820606,
-0.0148616061,
0.4988401532,
0.6229003072,
0.4788458645,
-0.6170639396,
0.7718517184,
-0.4380765557,
-0.6068861485,
-0.1700413525,
-0.1873232573,
-0.942974329,
0.1766655445,
-0.3010350466,
-0.6705619693,
-0.1949944347,
0.129329741,
-0.3286648393,
0.5189449787,
-1.1256064177,
0.8464481235,
0.0044193058,
-0.5265796781,
-0.2333061248,
-0.3398856223,
0.176030457,
0.0482537858,
-0.0002560241,
-0.0942795351,
0.3297412694,
0.9428409338,
-0.4542380869,
0.8876205087,
-0.0737094879,
0.1559323668,
0.9590819478,
-0.0103063211,
0.2360937446,
-0.0607424676,
-0.1994193792,
0.0541478917,
-0.0398053564,
-0.3530278206,
-0.3118316233,
0.4586420357,
-1.0608196259,
-0.8298162222,
-0.3433416486,
-0.2391988188,
0.1871404052,
0.0163225159,
0.3170439899,
0.5819425583,
-0.4937420785,
0.0900048167,
0.3964545727,
-0.2937319875,
0.6620563269,
0.1920923591,
0.1344465315,
-0.2975414097,
1.2895560265,
0.3298908472,
0.1069236696,
0.0033081195,
0.4527076781,
0.0018160212,
-0.2527739108,
-0.4957593977,
-0.0180137828,
-0.5636817813,
0.1328615546,
-0.7188125253,
-0.3607825339,
-0.520095706,
-0.5582047105,
-0.3004023433,
-0.3934032619,
-0.3140706122,
0.1158118322,
0.0546108223,
0.7954321504,
0.0631029084,
0.4371816814,
-0.4514849782,
0.0014462353,
0.4645887911,
0.0503018685,
0.0725669861,
-0.3464797139,
0.0677448735,
0.0390661694,
-0.8034331799,
-0.5505474806,
0.2276466489,
0.3576296866,
0.2550966144,
0.507427454,
-0.1276227981,
0.3741712272,
-0.4359483421,
1.2769024372,
-0.0598442778,
-0.8653756976,
0.3136903048,
-0.3596699238,
0.0804490075,
0.3491459787,
0.4061259925,
-0.5376245975,
-0.4208733439,
-0.6838312149,
-0.7977510691,
0.4965091944,
0.1632395685,
0.5599700809,
-0.0823627189,
0.4814296961,
0.3012494743,
0.2287931591,
-0.68200773,
0.055700656,
-0.492487967,
-0.4105732143,
0.0176360141,
-0.2977929115,
0.1721987575,
-0.2966890037,
0.566119194,
-0.087316893,
0.4937408268,
0.3067744374,
0.3985844851,
0.1332104206,
0.3959588408,
0.724422276,
0.5407271385,
0.2033545673,
0.0324116908,
0.1063008085,
-0.8341004848,
0.1495054066,
0.0791245326,
-0.5236484408,
-0.0501078069,
0.4417099059,
0.5111098886,
-0.0611284487,
-0.832452178,
0.4133505821,
-0.3529761732,
-0.6088052392,
-0.5392227769,
0.3689965308,
-0.0123542072,
-0.0145389177,
0.2255451083,
0.1850042343,
0.1681448072,
-0.5218674541,
-0.120331876,
0.4344715774,
-0.1353220344,
-0.3201673329,
0.7065429091,
0.3590339124,
-0.5983630419,
0.6547422409,
-0.0332958214,
-0.470859617,
0.7855551243,
0.4862370193,
1.0053213835,
-0.1172988489,
0.5716347694,
0.6239345074,
0.2656589448,
0.0130653018,
0.0213958696,
0.0767975971,
-0.5471887589,
-0.1942693144,
-0.3794658482,
-0.6799779534,
0.1948367059,
-0.1988807023,
0.073449105,
-0.5128507614,
-0.0042609223,
0.1777091324,
0.0740426332,
-0.3131019771,
0.2990111113,
-0.1519006193,
0.282630533,
-0.8215562701,
0.2515381277,
1.0313277245,
-0.5035151839,
-1.0092529058,
0.3225516379,
-0.0878306255,
-0.2672663033,
0.2079261243,
0.3021224737,
0.0100255413,
0.1540173888,
-0.853538692,
-0.5485445857,
0.8422191739,
0.1615878195,
-0.0880054906,
0.0627794638,
0.4701311886,
0.8311324716,
-0.4154143631,
0.5028732419,
0.3114656508,
0.3809651732,
0.040462099,
-0.5257719159,
-0.3894194663,
-0.3482550085,
-0.1888911277,
-0.1164542586,
-0.7563945651,
0.970952332,
-0.2066715211,
-0.3002671897,
-0.0473779067,
0.4912831485,
-0.2968235314,
0.4903919399,
-0.0152885998,
0.4435143173,
0.7621167898,
-0.1356765181,
0.929202795,
-0.2506576777,
0.0549319834,
0.8567661643,
-0.1023887247,
0.8070412278,
0.2697182,
-0.2713425457,
0.5457164645,
0.5265764594,
-0.2190428823,
-0.1013697386,
0.2913816571,
-0.5662874579,
-0.1289032251,
-0.2530391216,
-0.3093932867,
0.8140613437,
0.235351786,
-0.2655743361,
-0.0197796077,
0.0172117539,
0.3009568453,
0.5843204856,
-0.1672221869,
1.0346832275,
-0.2350662798,
-1.2368980646,
0.1758676469,
0.0265007261,
0.3221038878,
-0.1124942377,
-0.1693692356,
-0.3276844025,
0.0779930949,
-0.1014347523,
-0.7381829619,
0.2198751122,
0.3518100977,
-0.0274331812,
-0.057320971,
0.7132359147,
-0.1995249689,
-0.7805420756,
-0.3164863884,
0.3639827669,
0.2123785168,
0.3361420929,
-0.4123103917,
-0.3614472151,
-0.0488524884,
-0.3448877335,
0.2001404166,
0.3890930116,
0.093362011,
0.5601652265,
0.6333387494,
-0.0574200526,
0.0508470684,
-0.1218528524,
0.7514517307,
-0.4047510028,
-0.1688737422,
-0.8078677058,
0.5572945476,
-0.2344436795,
-0.6014444828,
0.5624033213,
0.5904595852,
0.7756897807,
-0.0338257514,
1.1607323885,
-0.0893744081,
0.6608247757,
-0.2217467576,
0.8175922036,
-0.1677773446,
-0.0086842068,
-0.5410770178,
-0.7607601285,
0.0154842725,
0.7609570622,
-0.3774164915,
0.1051743552,
0.626611948,
0.4785338938,
0.2033277154,
0.2861147821,
0.2160930634,
-0.0170067288,
0.6513367295,
0.2936249077,
0.9985802174,
-0.3697770238,
0.5691295266,
-0.194313243,
-0.1435891986,
-0.023605274,
-0.6696226597,
-1.0722740889,
-0.6048279405,
-0.4354235232,
-0.1537248492,
0.0689888895,
0.8047376871,
0.0657938048,
-0.5645855665,
-0.183132261,
-0.1459245831,
-0.0260644015,
0.1748375297,
-0.2872442305,
0.4388810396,
-0.4174394011,
-0.8418439031,
-0.1134307981,
0.1321168691,
0.1611466557,
-0.3555423021,
0.0791236386,
-0.0653595477,
0.684630096,
0.528763175,
0.1513707638,
-0.5709670186,
-0.4572350383,
0.0076661054,
-0.3159362376,
0.1189167202,
0.8351954818,
-0.3174498677,
0.4936535954,
0.3870517015,
0.6018224359,
-0.0549758747,
0.3073568046,
0.4424456358,
-0.090891175,
-0.1209699288,
0.2384869307,
0.2287643403,
0.2224755138,
-0.2921100855,
0.4161406159,
0.3197105825,
-1.0608901978,
-0.6311842203,
-0.2502753139,
-0.5480219126,
-0.3221774101,
0.8368942142,
-0.4735596776,
0.0558052845,
-0.0552607477,
-0.7978058457,
0.1175491959,
-0.4247676134,
1.4943377972,
0.9715815783,
-0.1721804887,
0.0536861755,
-0.5933386087,
0.6049144864,
0.4464326501,
-0.9980403185,
-0.0786750391,
0.4604719877,
-0.1449438632,
0.1112317517,
0.3301769793,
0.0390522815,
0.3329595625,
0.3121204674,
0.3259243965,
0.0813402832,
-0.1591394842,
0.2324731052,
0.5121911168,
0.1278394461,
0.1349833459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12036v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12036v3 | Generating Post-hoc Explanations for Skip-gram-based Node Embeddings by Identifying Important Nodes with Bridgeness | 2023-04-24T12:25:35 | 2023-05-15T09:31:29 | Hogun Park, Jennifer Neville | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI | Node representation learning in a network is an important machine learning
technique for encoding relational information in a continuous vector space
while preserving the inherent properties and structures of the network.
Recently, unsupervised node embedding methods such as DeepWalk, LINE,
struc2vec, PTE, UserItem2vec, and RWJBG have emerged from the Skip-gram model
and perform better performance in several downstream tasks such as node
classification and link prediction than the existing relational models.
However, providing post-hoc explanations of Skip-gram-based embeddings remains
a challenging problem because of the lack of explanation methods and
theoretical studies applicable for embeddings. In this paper, we first show
that global explanations to the Skip-gram-based embeddings can be found by
computing bridgeness under a spectral cluster-aware local perturbation.
Moreover, a novel gradient-based explanation method, which we call GRAPH-wGD,
is proposed that allows the top-q global explanations about learned graph
embedding vectors more efficiently. Experiments show that the ranking of nodes
by scores using GRAPH-wGD is highly correlated with true bridgeness scores. We
also observe that the top-q node-level explanations selected by GRAPH-wGD have
higher importance scores and produce more changes in class label prediction
when perturbed, compared with the nodes selected by recent alternatives, using
five real-world graphs. | [
-0.7407408357,
-0.8936026096,
0.4879382253,
-0.2124619931,
-0.4427817166,
0.2958375514,
0.0850446373,
-0.2615058422,
0.3958525956,
0.0512791499,
-0.2927624583,
-0.7785761356,
-0.8035631776,
-0.1756398678,
-0.0388023071,
0.7973588705,
-0.2767895758,
0.0397245623,
-0.4166073501,
0.0036537275,
-0.465913713,
0.084544234,
-0.6520278454,
-0.4500392973,
0.8580719829,
0.4656100273,
0.8670175076,
1.0044980049,
0.1824538559,
0.211636126,
-0.3869352937,
0.0656970143,
-0.4472817779,
-0.1847027391,
-0.3868899941,
-0.1048935726,
-0.5834938884,
0.0826838091,
0.7269804478,
1.3331230879,
0.209269926,
-0.1818247288,
0.3666840494,
0.6719689369,
-0.5266664028,
0.1165639311,
-0.5070172548,
0.2500825822,
-0.1302803904,
-0.3721548915,
-0.2910437286,
-0.1799511015,
0.0315046832,
-0.6406847239,
0.4129000604,
0.1458008587,
0.8603547812,
0.0174840279,
-0.4861368537,
-0.1153862029,
-0.6373898387,
0.2678985,
-0.2330880314,
0.5240132213,
0.4742490649,
0.4003458023,
-0.1739350557,
-0.6722701788,
-0.2692507505,
0.2193389535,
-0.2357871234,
0.3366146982,
0.0149456216,
0.5035656691,
0.3692396879,
0.3922831416,
-0.6107584238,
0.0933558121,
-0.2131415606,
-0.3338697255,
0.3652334809,
-0.2158410102,
0.0222722311,
0.0284920875,
-0.484330833,
0.0332962126,
-0.9901206493,
0.2667722702,
0.4023022056,
0.1881733388,
0.0991395041,
0.3494073749,
-0.034839239,
0.7475055456,
0.050810799,
0.4573997557,
0.3791196942,
-0.2090763599,
0.0581691787,
0.1587152481,
0.5175346136,
0.2331873626,
0.3472874463,
-0.4541579783,
0.0063817478,
0.1727116257,
0.1377181113,
-0.6360272169,
-0.1516100168,
0.1630702466,
-0.8138108253,
-0.152194649,
0.1279513389,
-0.9092863798,
-0.3564165533,
-0.0533238053,
0.1901631951,
-0.0576996356,
-0.6098312736,
-0.0266940389,
-0.2950066328,
0.1494909525,
0.3375465572,
-0.439664185,
0.3310237527,
0.4835490286,
0.9300855398,
-0.1394464821,
-0.3602255583,
-0.7762656212,
0.0062173484,
-0.5065012574,
0.6031144857,
-0.7921354175,
-0.4836037457,
0.04822772,
0.2173779905,
-0.1361364126,
-0.3209408224,
0.2263727635,
-0.5714982152,
-0.2077143341,
-0.4963158369,
-0.4961516559,
-0.2943089902,
0.1583089679,
-0.5575374961,
0.8936679959,
0.0741420612,
-1.2443990707,
0.1198047027,
-0.4563196003,
-0.5919277668,
-0.0374001898,
-0.0001136773,
-0.3607921302,
0.1851142347,
0.3441698551,
0.6499944925,
-0.1179937571,
0.0356869549,
-0.5025388598,
-0.5551277995,
0.0475432985,
-0.004510581,
0.5298075676,
0.0597926565,
-0.2042234242,
0.1410795301,
-0.5042288303,
-0.0987367555,
0.2127151936,
-0.0910482407,
-0.2986812294,
0.1850288361,
-0.4610491991,
0.319845885,
-0.1297459304,
-0.5301111937,
-0.219869405,
-0.264044553,
0.4052356482,
0.8813942671,
0.101211533,
0.4302128553,
-0.264387548,
0.874217391,
0.1295774579,
0.0097387256,
-0.4151036143,
-0.7469130158,
-0.1676995754,
-0.0135453129,
0.5170236826,
0.457936883,
-0.7098785043,
-0.0275970418,
-0.2344081253,
-0.3217502832,
-0.5023562908,
-0.0314357989,
0.5361388922,
0.7879682183,
0.5145971775,
-0.2898871899,
-0.4026010931,
-0.701685369,
-0.456122458,
-0.0005606008,
0.0997342169,
0.6047887802,
0.4322176874,
-0.22281003,
0.9920441508,
-0.4114227891,
0.1203243732,
-0.1710060537,
0.1099783629,
0.0964510366,
0.3270572126,
0.1574287564,
-0.7199180126,
-0.2875533402,
0.0692631006,
-0.4832424223,
-0.1256807446,
0.0540341772,
-0.3181456327,
-0.3180251122,
0.7064439058,
-0.4814389348,
0.4928378761,
0.5523504615,
-0.3487392962,
0.6387933493,
-0.1127725989,
-0.1871563494,
-0.8203008771,
-0.0261230804,
-0.0417322889,
-0.5869702697,
-0.1953283846,
0.0413761735,
-0.2022268474,
-0.3292106092,
-0.0827056766,
0.4096587598,
-0.7300907373,
-0.4637005627,
-0.0780982301,
0.6416902542,
-0.0677856877,
0.5899781585,
-0.231670633,
0.103058055,
0.9997512698,
-0.7146294713,
0.3574209809,
0.0334160812,
0.2123136669,
0.2473495305,
-0.9473413229,
0.1533154845,
-0.4080484509,
0.3820187449,
-1.3977624178,
0.1401941478,
0.2452384084,
-0.7906531692,
0.534303546,
-0.8007596731,
-0.2207077593,
-0.4694271386,
-0.2862065732,
0.5056087971,
0.4746176898,
-0.8312041163,
0.4882715642,
0.3475148678,
0.1482985616,
-0.4582089782,
-0.4499900639,
-0.260219574,
-0.1091879159,
-0.7167350054,
0.5951196551,
-0.0006333274,
0.1055369601,
0.358697474,
-0.3329012394,
0.3431219757,
0.3977921009,
0.4729226232,
-0.0312839858,
-0.1459981352,
0.385086447,
0.2543652952,
-0.6830118299,
0.1882599443,
-0.5063815713,
0.3717948496,
-0.0935658813,
-0.4994077981,
-0.1806144118,
0.4566997886,
0.2444273978,
-0.3781525791,
0.5917118192,
0.7971540093,
-0.3905112147,
-0.2983919382,
0.0371876471,
-0.2699808776,
-0.4119023085,
0.2100919932,
-0.3798629344,
-1.1562286615,
0.6314585209,
-0.7746349573,
-0.1430472732,
0.4728761017,
0.0035782433,
-0.3960748017,
1.1426746845,
0.2264387608,
0.2352409065,
0.3709929883,
-0.2312610447,
0.1675991714,
-0.8608059883,
-0.0825353116,
-0.5547806025,
-0.5357022882,
-1.0589139462,
-0.6099486947,
0.1378344297,
0.6152173281,
-0.1180943996,
-0.0590482205,
-0.3098393977,
0.5084248185,
0.2383674383,
-0.1257393509,
0.0742451474,
0.34317559,
-0.6650781035,
0.14920187,
-0.7955217957,
-0.180377692,
0.7364641428,
0.4465923309,
0.5549319983,
-0.1311688572,
0.7181599736,
0.3898209035,
0.0851586163,
-0.7841684222,
0.4318199158,
0.0215016622,
-0.1088900492,
-0.2290475219,
-0.7090892196,
-1.2767080069,
0.5082079172,
-0.2552803159,
-0.6196466088,
0.0503369272,
0.6600068212,
0.1196631342,
0.4224382043,
-0.3947973847,
1.0396118164,
0.2797112763,
-0.2244874984,
-0.339407891,
-0.7015656829,
0.1692881435,
0.4222195745,
0.6875231266,
0.1788692027,
0.0873332545,
0.6772189736,
-0.6037479639,
0.712099731,
-0.656208694,
0.2260559648,
0.4171025157,
0.1770441532,
0.9567941427,
-0.120417349,
0.1691221148,
0.3818972707,
-0.6468328834,
-0.5625695586,
-0.6416296959,
0.688154757,
-0.4534024596,
-0.7013307214,
-0.0148203466,
0.0897809938,
-0.4220900536,
-0.0251825638,
0.3167260885,
0.6194519997,
-0.0627114922,
0.0508313477,
0.9253095388,
-0.3471038342,
0.4949454367,
-0.0650450811,
-0.4575395882,
-0.3239345849,
1.0731245279,
0.1401614845,
0.1255218238,
0.3967296481,
0.6013467312,
-0.3328155577,
-0.8015697598,
-0.5518152118,
0.4150006473,
-0.6768212914,
0.1914706379,
-0.8457393646,
-0.1478934884,
-0.2175614536,
-0.3567010462,
-0.1324660331,
-0.4290829897,
-0.111769326,
-0.7394687533,
0.1783605963,
0.7667467594,
-0.3059309125,
0.3914627433,
-0.7734864354,
0.2370703667,
0.2702576816,
0.6445052028,
0.4999991953,
-0.3801577687,
-0.4645084441,
-0.1784465462,
-0.0249681212,
-1.4491779804,
-0.2618725002,
0.1710508317,
0.7859350443,
0.6509567499,
-0.1836613715,
0.5221621394,
-0.4471697509,
0.4440498352,
0.1451508254,
-0.9997596741,
0.724216342,
-0.5044868588,
-0.0641317964,
0.0229937155,
0.7551930547,
-0.7614579201,
-0.1172264889,
-0.7018201351,
-1.1195625067,
0.6074975133,
-0.0741936266,
-0.149359867,
-0.1522237509,
0.4715250134,
-0.0303419679,
-0.1634121686,
-0.6286661029,
-0.4098808169,
-0.3385137618,
0.2447243631,
0.0338372812,
-0.4177951515,
0.1289043278,
-0.0107061388,
0.7045263648,
-0.1978837997,
0.2709775567,
0.2780002952,
-0.2946971357,
-0.1370283663,
0.0238806102,
0.0965249613,
0.8222129345,
0.2232384682,
0.5361232758,
0.0808410496,
-0.176488027,
-0.1416031718,
0.0871822089,
0.0167849585,
0.3563001752,
0.7782965899,
0.8343116045,
-0.1059057862,
-0.1819688976,
0.7731692791,
0.0380752496,
-0.1294570416,
0.1107123047,
-0.1880599111,
0.4884550273,
0.0760085657,
0.136673063,
-0.0912137106,
0.0977732018,
-0.2742010951,
0.1187092438,
0.4920383394,
-0.7292581201,
-0.4427136183,
0.5527414083,
0.1406847388,
-0.2807409465,
0.276838392,
-0.6048190594,
-0.6030803919,
0.6740075946,
0.5133442879,
0.7351275086,
-0.5411201119,
0.6057613492,
0.6959624887,
0.3683713377,
0.1157371178,
0.3452795744,
-0.3598977327,
-0.6687104702,
-0.4373151958,
-0.5176570415,
-0.0071288319,
-0.3267252445,
-0.7073959112,
-0.1298409104,
-0.6053506732,
-0.0100933928,
-0.0852543339,
-0.3672614098,
-0.7515668273,
0.1832394004,
-0.1837028563,
0.7023796439,
-1.1198310852,
0.4404262602,
0.8218313456,
-0.1826258153,
-0.7932770252,
-0.0182253364,
-0.0634105131,
-0.6759138703,
0.4552209675,
0.1757720113,
-0.3340153098,
0.1233132854,
-0.3311511874,
-0.7976023555,
1.0025638342,
0.1307734251,
-0.6165816784,
0.2462391108,
-0.1500727832,
0.3105092645,
-0.2325665057,
0.2843275964,
-0.0332798958,
0.469761014,
0.2744179964,
-0.3129350543,
0.4381221533,
-0.2467824668,
0.3493460715,
0.2816983163,
-0.2407510132,
0.7475955486,
-0.4110101759,
-0.4099080265,
-0.7168505788,
0.5167148113,
0.0733955801,
0.2893457711,
0.8780863881,
0.5814883113,
0.9242776036,
-0.0715071037,
1.1815184355,
-0.0759008527,
0.2244766504,
0.9377147555,
0.2019041479,
0.504791677,
0.1911312789,
-0.2171243429,
0.7560766339,
1.1424674988,
0.4083887935,
0.3607918322,
0.7099207044,
0.1542693526,
-0.5395027995,
-0.1448796839,
-0.6370257139,
0.3370608687,
0.4684005082,
-0.6226787567,
-0.3346220255,
-0.1059488282,
0.06690301,
-0.1447059661,
-0.6191376448,
0.594945848,
0.1156239286,
-0.5282150507,
0.4786145985,
0.0910616368,
0.205943197,
-0.292529434,
-0.2218670249,
-0.401850611,
-0.0789587721,
-0.4531413615,
-0.5567775369,
0.4073654711,
-0.210032329,
-0.4025965333,
-0.4884827435,
0.729862988,
-0.3205509484,
-0.1977283806,
0.8132596016,
0.6159536839,
0.477977246,
-0.0787430257,
-0.5203630924,
-0.1079058051,
-0.215291366,
-0.1911824346,
0.3225323558,
0.6264200807,
-0.2558716536,
0.2586135566,
0.6751116514,
0.0953976437,
-0.1257077456,
0.1001578569,
0.7735772729,
-0.6989575624,
-0.720184207,
-0.8774581552,
0.4403370917,
0.0534224771,
-0.0730473548,
0.5892136097,
0.3558599055,
0.859174192,
0.2932716906,
0.7407360673,
0.2717391253,
0.3445547819,
-0.6648302674,
0.4105271101,
-0.7638872266,
0.2390443534,
-0.5214650631,
-0.8992381692,
-0.0837085545,
0.6054888964,
-0.0760996342,
0.4005208611,
0.9090410471,
0.8593894243,
-0.1439521164,
0.0596911125,
0.1947649866,
0.514156878,
0.1001141295,
0.4678261876,
0.7703236938,
-0.0514457487,
0.6113916636,
0.2640995681,
-0.4034585059,
-0.2600602508,
-1.0772564411,
-0.9527247548,
-0.6143331528,
-0.6045824885,
-0.5618187189,
0.0578382872,
0.438336432,
0.6982783079,
-0.3985145986,
0.1722290367,
-0.327827245,
0.8594569564,
-0.4140700996,
-0.2199969888,
0.7113149166,
-0.1725571752,
-0.170231387,
0.4270257354,
0.3383902609,
-0.0088048317,
-0.1700298786,
-0.1168146953,
-0.0256792549,
-0.1997650713,
0.4888706803,
0.1964806467,
-0.5205504298,
-0.2670640945,
-0.3187383115,
0.2963691652,
0.1477378309,
1.0434479713,
-0.7689843774,
0.484366715,
0.7875753045,
0.7587013245,
0.6456739902,
0.1018875241,
0.3800219595,
-0.9512237906,
-0.3165938854,
-0.1281352341,
0.5877228379,
0.4643793404,
-0.3294899762,
0.3565605283,
0.7471699715,
-0.1476009786,
-0.4518072307,
0.6201125383,
-0.7526641488,
-0.4414673746,
1.2583634853,
-0.5775828362,
-0.2845311165,
-0.5164324045,
0.1108112261,
0.4911051691,
-0.0673844665,
0.3583000004,
0.6101831198,
0.0702582225,
-0.3307648301,
-0.3118405044,
0.5470517278,
0.1683523357,
-0.6419751644,
0.109765172,
0.3592095673,
0.1798520684,
-0.1127842069,
0.8223890066,
-0.119651936,
0.1855426431,
0.1619362086,
-0.1907133609,
-0.4676719904,
-0.4849254191,
-0.2664041817,
0.3312425911,
-0.0540786982,
-0.499170512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12026v1 | SocialDial: A Benchmark for Socially-Aware Dialogue Systems | 2023-04-24T11:55:22 | 2023-04-24T11:55:22 | Haolan Zhan, Zhuang Li, Yufei Wang, Linhao Luo, Tao Feng, Xiaoxi Kang, Yuncheng Hua, Lizhen Qu, Lay-Ki Soon, Suraj Sharma, Ingrid Zukerman, Zhaleh Semnani-Azad, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have been widely applied in many scenarios and are now more
powerful and ubiquitous than ever before. With large neural models and massive
available data, current dialogue systems have access to more knowledge than any
people in their life. However, current dialogue systems still do not perform at
a human level. One major gap between conversational agents and humans lies in
their abilities to be aware of social norms. The development of socially-aware
dialogue systems is impeded due to the lack of resources. In this paper, we
present the first socially-aware dialogue corpus - SocialDial, based on Chinese
social culture. SocialDial consists of two parts: 1,563 multi-turn dialogues
between two human speakers with fine-grained labels, and 4,870 synthetic
conversations generated by ChatGPT. The human corpus covers five categories of
social norms, which have 14 sub-categories in total. Specifically, it contains
social factor annotations including social relation, context, social distance,
and social norms. However, collecting sufficient socially-aware dialogues is
costly. Thus, we harness the power of ChatGPT and devise an ontology-based
synthetic data generation framework. This framework is able to generate
synthetic data at scale. To ensure the quality of synthetic dialogues, we
design several mechanisms for quality control during data collection. Finally,
we evaluate our dataset using several pre-trained models, such as BERT and
RoBERTa. Comprehensive empirical results based on state-of-the-art neural
models demonstrate that modeling of social norms for dialogue systems is a
promising research direction. To the best of our knowledge, SocialDial is the
first socially-aware dialogue dataset that covers multiple social factors and
has fine-grained labels. | [
-0.2708675563,
-0.9063296914,
0.3440487981,
0.3343143463,
-0.1570570469,
0.2367090434,
-0.1377423853,
-0.3808249235,
0.1958954781,
0.3160417974,
-0.6679002047,
-0.4486637414,
-0.4152965248,
0.054018341,
-0.3785008788,
0.8469803929,
0.7590777278,
0.1838512719,
0.1484282911,
-0.2474495769,
0.0343257226,
-0.4957565069,
-0.6978620291,
-0.154956013,
0.2433695197,
0.197037518,
0.8491959572,
0.1456552297,
-0.0586154535,
0.3433307409,
-0.2464746684,
0.6529451609,
-0.6563756466,
-0.1028439626,
0.1580177397,
-0.0759963691,
-0.6078680754,
-0.0075283987,
0.6581303477,
0.4258337319,
0.1079396829,
0.2796423435,
0.2528783977,
0.343293637,
-0.1117966175,
0.4773364663,
-0.7893733978,
0.0784776807,
-0.1472725272,
-0.1950550824,
-0.2100166231,
-0.733758688,
0.2008346021,
-0.6835166812,
0.1555582732,
0.0957880095,
0.5303441882,
0.0962485522,
-0.3332848251,
0.0131847421,
-0.6051161289,
0.4706216156,
-0.6705726981,
0.2882417738,
0.3407239318,
0.3174054027,
-0.252330184,
-0.5331554413,
-0.749325037,
-0.1556631774,
0.1262775213,
0.1309361309,
0.2631123364,
-0.1020310372,
0.032605961,
0.0623042472,
-0.3408989012,
-0.4371519983,
-0.4775975645,
-0.4532358348,
0.6275943518,
0.2532503903,
0.3986861408,
-0.535856843,
-0.3014920652,
0.2093362212,
-0.6598861814,
0.1015914157,
0.1277523786,
0.458301872,
-0.3091408312,
0.2827052176,
-0.3138666153,
0.1541968137,
0.0381635949,
-0.1117314547,
0.0002299985,
-0.8525622487,
0.1742226034,
0.3145686984,
0.9580510855,
0.7502336502,
0.6020154953,
0.0870736614,
0.1051541269,
0.3134536743,
0.1016272008,
-0.7710884213,
0.1046212018,
-0.0133526428,
-0.4045014381,
-0.7170080543,
-0.366702199,
-0.5655572414,
-0.5593500733,
-0.2257208526,
0.0468249395,
-0.4361002147,
-0.4561831653,
-0.1221707091,
0.0722098872,
0.3943019807,
0.538589716,
-0.7004492879,
0.4701836705,
0.9375227094,
0.9861578345,
0.2233956158,
0.0522596203,
-0.473490864,
-0.1208915636,
-0.2516522706,
0.5495614409,
-0.4025897682,
-0.4615072012,
0.2691726983,
0.0262275208,
0.2595828474,
-0.3269944787,
0.4022221863,
-0.330163151,
-0.1760511398,
-0.0645319596,
-0.3640652895,
0.1248517931,
0.2137919217,
-0.1000318974,
0.9451684356,
-0.054119207,
-0.5091540217,
0.3302295506,
-0.4229913354,
-0.3617402315,
0.3818721473,
-0.4065996706,
-0.0825041309,
-0.2594040036,
-0.0879248753,
0.2621214092,
-0.5525684357,
0.5745710135,
-0.5884601474,
-0.3560852706,
0.3573718071,
-0.6159944534,
0.9870197773,
0.2724201977,
-0.287274003,
0.0362576917,
-0.6969457269,
0.1471643746,
-0.034463454,
0.044819884,
-0.2055319548,
-0.0346731581,
0.2238111347,
0.266651839,
0.2183959633,
-1.0429201126,
-0.267449528,
-0.0541277938,
0.8605112433,
1.0123462677,
-0.105921194,
0.2338858247,
-0.3870967627,
0.0265925694,
-0.1102688536,
0.5058405399,
0.0941149071,
-0.5225832462,
-0.5873407125,
0.0017246251,
0.0822954029,
0.6557631493,
-0.5662593246,
0.3956488073,
-0.2376868874,
-0.7332898974,
-0.3674452305,
0.1948717535,
0.392141521,
0.0489644594,
-0.0743745491,
-0.157368511,
-0.2898463309,
-0.7002571225,
0.0536990389,
-0.4560725093,
0.0244914405,
0.7524074912,
0.0264258031,
-0.2701435685,
0.9294085503,
-0.2430405021,
-0.3182359934,
-0.3159432411,
-0.1732486486,
0.0066630021,
0.3853923082,
0.1668808758,
-0.6066343784,
-0.4306810796,
0.0301546399,
-0.7475436926,
-0.2640691996,
0.0283247624,
-0.5459315777,
0.1752783507,
0.5414299369,
-0.6238008142,
0.4234646857,
0.5071928501,
-0.2082322091,
0.6045731306,
-0.1482387036,
-0.0226329379,
-1.1125522852,
-0.2190296203,
0.2067748904,
-0.3035111725,
-0.6318340302,
-0.6447527409,
-0.082514897,
-0.5187551379,
-0.4597776234,
0.723194778,
-0.0080992617,
-0.0470644422,
0.2082751244,
0.4344324768,
-0.1254837662,
0.831561923,
0.0625228658,
0.6470419168,
0.2774078548,
-0.5530042052,
0.2116854638,
0.5120450854,
-0.4268308878,
0.6040911674,
-0.9744732976,
0.3071430624,
0.0913798138,
0.4757449925,
-1.0598703623,
-0.1210075617,
0.2324966341,
-0.6423162818,
-0.3168360889,
-0.1494027972,
-0.5032131672,
0.1328634471,
-0.204367131,
0.3541926444,
0.5104342103,
-0.2873829305,
0.57808882,
0.7957533002,
-0.6136750579,
-0.0472887978,
0.140765056,
-0.0613096878,
0.0746549815,
-1.0129170418,
0.1317204684,
0.0340991206,
-0.1468800157,
-0.3382415175,
-0.2561844289,
-0.0651720092,
-0.0899503678,
0.3742187619,
0.475959897,
-0.0308234673,
0.0962588117,
0.1005228832,
-0.1243466064,
0.1283697337,
-0.1440224051,
0.6882305741,
-0.356318146,
-0.1512170881,
-0.4812423885,
0.2046840489,
0.77078408,
-0.0719614103,
0.250628829,
0.6737285256,
-0.3489556313,
-0.0219960921,
-0.6146902442,
-0.2234114558,
-0.5262459517,
0.1948744804,
-0.1110787094,
-0.8841294646,
0.41397506,
-0.0490564406,
0.362932235,
0.0341309234,
0.4129326642,
0.1863019913,
1.2049090862,
0.2312435359,
0.0331737548,
0.6766944528,
0.0668389648,
0.3420485258,
-0.7205596566,
0.0443708859,
-0.4045799971,
0.1449972689,
-0.7900611162,
-0.4348483086,
0.70170331,
-0.4192260504,
-0.4725930691,
0.2975338995,
-0.4110038579,
0.0118084038,
0.5819656849,
0.2871406674,
0.3687306345,
-0.2119781822,
0.0046109506,
0.2993148565,
-0.688508153,
-0.8262376785,
0.8403845429,
0.1508104056,
0.657294333,
0.0814861208,
0.4379993081,
0.5823730826,
0.0611762032,
-0.3633897305,
1.0068795681,
-0.2039822638,
-0.7299298048,
-0.5540557504,
-0.5300373435,
-0.6749871373,
0.135180667,
-0.2301869541,
-0.7566217184,
0.08042714,
-0.0094232457,
-0.8469824791,
-0.0587615445,
-0.6445764899,
0.7508820295,
-0.0625867248,
-0.7153897285,
-0.3598837256,
-0.6635380387,
0.1579060405,
0.0556529909,
0.3050285876,
-0.6716372967,
0.6282789707,
0.4756601751,
-0.6010038853,
1.2093659639,
-0.3081094921,
0.1022477597,
0.560444355,
0.1617431939,
0.4130772948,
0.5164172649,
0.1723059118,
0.3652759194,
0.4985057414,
-0.2643708289,
-0.4562943876,
0.431615293,
-0.7983078957,
-0.6006038785,
-0.2286641747,
-0.2038937062,
-0.2190203369,
0.1805486977,
-0.0642549247,
0.9964079857,
-0.544031322,
0.3451232612,
0.4869648814,
-0.6168625951,
-0.0527638942,
0.5143135786,
-0.3038538098,
-0.1718857437,
0.9591493607,
0.2811408043,
0.4103356004,
-0.043942973,
0.2013813704,
-0.3799758255,
0.103498593,
-0.5317294002,
-0.0190762747,
-0.2936542034,
0.0379781239,
-0.8375445604,
-0.5882099271,
-0.8071020842,
-0.1304720044,
-0.4344006181,
-0.3653563559,
0.2636888027,
0.1018924266,
0.4392392039,
0.3608752787,
-0.2321060151,
-0.0699384063,
-0.9251354933,
0.3733215332,
0.4911687374,
0.3501181304,
0.0438801907,
-0.2273592651,
0.0597831123,
0.3201284111,
-0.1684916914,
-0.3064076304,
0.3391097188,
0.310816139,
0.3752612472,
0.4557444155,
0.4855664968,
0.4015084803,
-0.6155005097,
0.6817602515,
-0.0014520764,
-0.8186523914,
0.4860868156,
-0.6017223597,
0.1461630464,
0.4064662755,
-0.1959132403,
-0.9423944354,
-0.4947790205,
-0.7805254459,
-0.712775588,
0.6422095895,
0.3918189406,
0.3458135724,
-0.2486971617,
0.1001746953,
0.1515793204,
0.0292962492,
-0.3277757466,
-0.087840803,
-0.4322523475,
-0.1426016092,
-0.0391409621,
-0.1313470304,
-0.0731356665,
-0.1692357063,
0.5871986747,
-0.1886151284,
0.2913176417,
0.3254829943,
-0.0153447026,
0.1533236653,
0.3185380399,
0.4053193331,
0.2067691535,
-0.3673391342,
-0.1161434501,
0.2521177828,
-0.4132204056,
0.1585474163,
-0.0285645388,
-0.335763067,
-0.1109130383,
-0.1823452711,
0.570052743,
0.3416356146,
-0.6604276896,
0.34862414,
-0.299847573,
0.126488924,
-0.9285442233,
0.2437384725,
-0.0159586351,
0.2296203226,
0.1612338126,
0.0256519374,
0.227076754,
-0.6714420915,
0.1206028089,
0.4794818461,
-0.76359272,
-0.3737466931,
0.5317257047,
0.8485569954,
-0.5504501462,
0.4560860693,
-0.2933602929,
-0.5118878484,
0.409852773,
0.2837877572,
0.8396054506,
0.2622466981,
0.6260411739,
0.5378878117,
0.0602486767,
0.1996500939,
0.1131332144,
-0.4702959657,
-1.2697336674,
-0.0812966451,
-0.6133692265,
-0.7046341896,
-0.1387945265,
-0.4202077389,
0.0281314868,
-0.798505187,
-0.4663433135,
0.3178340197,
0.1240030304,
-0.5580968857,
-0.2283836007,
0.0826043487,
0.7574077249,
-0.5282405019,
0.6620516777,
0.2656236291,
-0.0503560379,
-0.5672473907,
-0.4211457968,
0.4035428762,
-1.0042595863,
0.6284105182,
0.2949030995,
-0.5523845553,
-0.0482939221,
-0.5172422528,
-0.4214491248,
0.7393510938,
-0.1584556252,
-0.3213600516,
0.0454967879,
0.1859342605,
0.5392308831,
-0.3466545641,
0.2706125379,
0.5727471709,
0.3726437688,
-0.0361857414,
-0.897905767,
0.1682306677,
-0.8665881753,
0.1957351714,
-0.1368854493,
-1.1152902842,
0.4480963051,
-0.0005012447,
-0.4098976552,
0.229558304,
0.2150579989,
0.3415803015,
0.408727318,
0.7055178881,
-0.2225317508,
0.5020474195,
-0.2677057385,
0.7876477242,
-0.6089490056,
-0.0283375047,
0.8577302098,
-0.8032443523,
0.4111955464,
-0.0880239606,
-0.134307608,
0.1663726419,
0.5232055187,
0.3480766416,
0.1700892895,
0.1962686777,
-0.572958529,
-0.6709134579,
-0.6684610844,
-0.3021381199,
0.4954640865,
0.5148208737,
0.0443630442,
0.0671981871,
-0.4750659466,
-0.1145110428,
-0.0861932263,
-0.0696970522,
1.0953222513,
0.1100170836,
-0.6069603562,
0.3350843787,
-0.3881626427,
0.6403873563,
-0.6754865646,
-0.1184716523,
-0.3125251234,
0.2270782143,
0.0421687067,
-0.5513948798,
-0.0894374773,
-0.0349939875,
0.0990281329,
-0.1832285821,
0.9352314472,
-0.4627451897,
-0.4309063256,
0.2069488019,
0.4324992299,
0.2415909171,
-0.0147774536,
-0.4161913693,
0.0427799746,
0.0054848529,
0.1541221887,
0.3279511034,
0.8449851274,
-0.1394098103,
0.7203611732,
1.0143845081,
0.0832284465,
0.0161829069,
0.2851230502,
0.6749739051,
-0.6965800524,
-0.4728010893,
-0.4965746403,
0.281786859,
-0.4473210275,
-0.4521570802,
0.5557676554,
0.223155126,
0.552036643,
0.3136211634,
0.9873168468,
-0.0798917934,
0.60062325,
-0.0903659686,
0.8357857466,
-0.2260798812,
0.0180147495,
-0.5043773055,
-0.8479167223,
0.2560221255,
0.7307552099,
-0.0778951645,
-0.0982065052,
0.1151573136,
1.2688628435,
0.2375102788,
0.5387240052,
0.4287977815,
0.2059923708,
0.418941468,
0.2276459187,
1.036408186,
-0.2873245776,
0.7142084241,
-0.0751665458,
-0.3742913008,
-0.2704741657,
-0.5175979137,
-0.7390786409,
-0.5188860893,
-0.148794964,
-0.5188739896,
0.2519147992,
1.402613759,
0.874473393,
-0.6328967214,
-0.2395795286,
0.0993991271,
0.0134783322,
-0.1170833632,
-0.2239578664,
0.0532079861,
-0.3882724941,
-0.6914243102,
0.07351657,
0.501257062,
-0.1017890275,
-0.3307135105,
-0.1674996167,
0.0163066555,
0.3507503569,
0.8825432062,
0.206281811,
-0.5851005912,
-0.5298502445,
0.1998984963,
-0.2548664212,
-0.1053826064,
0.6573844552,
-0.2583511472,
0.3384467065,
0.2936636508,
0.4699920714,
0.2874758542,
-0.0784258842,
0.8480122685,
-0.4205821157,
0.0477269478,
-0.0230174288,
0.3804335892,
0.2980629206,
-0.2616090178,
0.5764742494,
0.1624311507,
-0.6333169937,
-0.6166577339,
0.1674144417,
-1.0868401527,
0.1537200958,
1.2718731165,
-0.0776720792,
-0.0988733396,
-0.579456389,
-0.582660675,
0.4655139446,
-0.8818113804,
1.0077221394,
0.6665373445,
0.1932132244,
0.0368968844,
-0.4811796248,
0.4702081382,
0.3860266209,
-0.5657018423,
0.4836310446,
0.5041613579,
0.1353904903,
0.2692528963,
1.1254149675,
-0.4397224784,
0.3486326933,
0.2048001289,
-0.1597417444,
0.1816539615,
-0.102446869,
0.5184485912,
-0.1124590486,
-0.2589576244,
0.0779991373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12008v2 | CHEAT: A Large-scale Dataset for Detecting ChatGPT-writtEn AbsTracts | 2023-04-24T11:19:33 | 2024-02-24T05:52:28 | Peipeng Yu, Jiahan Chen, Xuan Feng, Zhihua Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL | The powerful ability of ChatGPT has caused widespread concern in the academic
community. Malicious users could synthesize dummy academic content through
ChatGPT, which is extremely harmful to academic rigor and originality. The need
to develop ChatGPT-written content detection algorithms call for large-scale
datasets. In this paper, we initially investigate the possible negative impact
of ChatGPT on academia,and present a large-scale CHatGPT-writtEn AbsTract
dataset (CHEAT) to support the development of detection algorithms. In
particular, the ChatGPT-written abstract dataset contains 35,304 synthetic
abstracts, with Generation, Polish, and Mix as prominent representatives. Based
on these data, we perform a thorough analysis of the existing text synthesis
detection algorithms. We show that ChatGPT-written abstracts are detectable,
while the detection difficulty increases with human involvement.Our dataset is
available in https://github.com/botianzhe/CHEAT. | [
-0.4312356114,
-0.6565371752,
0.4722394049,
0.1610036045,
0.0570538566,
0.3232186139,
-0.2568679452,
-0.5075193048,
0.3901112974,
0.5557030439,
-0.3990684748,
-0.6011447906,
-0.5824925303,
0.1857167184,
-0.8145909905,
1.5601623058,
-0.0979953706,
0.0323684327,
-0.2062818557,
0.3155843019,
-0.2116108537,
-0.4339798987,
-0.9526680708,
-0.0884535983,
0.4887465239,
0.3230724931,
0.3050273657,
0.290024817,
0.4401409626,
0.2865931392,
0.1472634524,
0.1559505314,
-0.8248863816,
0.1648936719,
-0.0865315869,
-0.1767694801,
-0.6244718432,
-0.083950378,
0.6507613659,
0.2643074989,
-0.0337406918,
0.096787639,
-0.0190566629,
0.6388955712,
-0.5720880032,
0.3958843946,
-0.7465049028,
0.0550572909,
-0.5820393562,
-0.1554715931,
-0.7148216963,
-0.2138148248,
-0.1287383139,
-0.5885118246,
0.4052874148,
0.0641855299,
0.4826595187,
-0.0184924006,
-0.1795316637,
-0.4533802271,
-0.5444871187,
0.6435351372,
-0.6866157055,
-0.1849563867,
0.0981846452,
0.2522481978,
-0.5883757472,
-0.7636396885,
-0.6882440448,
0.0054140221,
0.002623925,
0.2513500452,
-0.2595945895,
0.0426176041,
0.1565040797,
0.3093328774,
-0.591268301,
-0.1559448242,
-0.7811332345,
-0.4240032136,
0.774662137,
0.2666522264,
0.7687056065,
-0.1406202018,
-0.0097677056,
0.0516692623,
-0.8488134146,
-0.5616042614,
0.6797383428,
0.1124833822,
0.2356333882,
0.4223046899,
-0.1097571626,
0.296374619,
-0.4157064557,
0.1838877499,
0.0629199296,
-0.4481443465,
0.3066849113,
0.4029580355,
1.1027677059,
0.4116209447,
0.4355968535,
-0.1275220513,
-0.1908152401,
0.3241557181,
0.201802209,
-0.9487546682,
-0.6950026751,
0.2732849121,
-0.0717623308,
-0.3901900053,
-0.1144383177,
-0.7898009419,
-0.6726459265,
-0.2404955626,
0.4152730405,
-0.6615481377,
-0.1065138057,
0.1853632331,
-0.3426842988,
0.1630170941,
0.3562901616,
-0.6312930584,
0.4885832667,
0.8715692163,
0.9520046115,
-0.4222966433,
-0.3615007997,
-0.4476046562,
0.1735535711,
-0.1884389073,
0.9699832797,
-0.3740291297,
-0.3635085225,
-0.1862919778,
-0.2151643634,
0.0544580147,
-0.2176460177,
0.6688444018,
-0.417293936,
0.4304739237,
0.0119970571,
-0.6939147711,
0.0641024038,
0.1202927679,
-0.6182383895,
0.75717628,
-0.0819139406,
-1.0456550121,
0.31536147,
-0.6418546438,
-0.5689979792,
-0.0314249359,
-0.0085970499,
-0.6254084706,
-0.2556013465,
0.2678845525,
0.2240147442,
0.2715882957,
0.1876344979,
0.0421290547,
-0.6033468843,
0.5907940865,
-0.4786539972,
0.4893270433,
-0.0333881862,
-0.2268048078,
-0.270073384,
-0.6778294444,
-0.0908592269,
-0.1193243638,
-0.289093852,
-0.3450484574,
0.3954056203,
0.3263942599,
0.0867486671,
0.2121336758,
-0.9272934198,
0.2260316312,
-0.0910734013,
0.462787807,
0.6981310248,
0.3278771937,
-0.1222503707,
-0.5162473321,
0.5342674255,
-0.1658551991,
-0.1506648064,
-0.2896511853,
-0.6735551953,
-0.3553577662,
-0.4132375419,
0.5585922003,
0.4871758223,
-0.6149998903,
0.2894957364,
-0.3938808739,
-0.475076586,
-0.4795741439,
-0.1419080198,
0.5442065597,
0.2281296402,
0.3153501153,
-0.2567156255,
-0.6910849214,
-0.8442463279,
-0.7129539847,
0.0924216211,
-0.424510777,
0.0685112178,
0.8591405153,
-0.0092222299,
0.6863743663,
-0.739546001,
-0.561275363,
0.0466106273,
0.1929198503,
0.2032242864,
0.5890475512,
0.0988167226,
-0.4626395404,
-0.6899337173,
-0.12190523,
-0.4998416007,
-0.2586926222,
-0.2339239717,
-0.1248296648,
-0.0177428685,
0.8705670834,
-0.4854805768,
0.1093842164,
0.4804843366,
-0.3839739263,
0.9058624506,
-0.1533425748,
0.3157226741,
-0.8478065133,
0.2067740858,
-0.1315844059,
-0.2023134083,
-0.5134273767,
-0.1263943315,
-0.1023438647,
-0.109363921,
-0.2619163692,
0.3316386938,
-0.2669642866,
0.1678204685,
-0.2615247369,
0.330419004,
-0.110173136,
0.3871385157,
0.0498139448,
0.9726927876,
0.311111331,
-0.2777557373,
-0.017897293,
0.6313073635,
-0.5398685336,
0.4391828179,
-0.8517262936,
0.0750469416,
-0.1957931221,
0.8513833284,
-1.1040353775,
-0.7137317657,
0.2701005042,
-0.6589785814,
0.1889681667,
-0.3923290372,
-0.5396824479,
0.082736738,
-0.5770298243,
0.4291628897,
0.5229263306,
-0.2341772318,
0.3005257249,
0.6262204051,
-0.3694600165,
-0.4250120521,
-0.7891752124,
0.4920535982,
0.1293691844,
-0.6987072229,
0.3326469064,
0.0914733186,
0.0083905403,
-0.0680556595,
0.07560388,
0.0818569437,
-0.454513073,
0.3094034791,
0.253474623,
-0.0924032703,
-0.0702539682,
0.1784589291,
-0.174145937,
0.2960212827,
-0.1675668359,
0.5230928063,
-0.1292593032,
-0.3522591591,
-0.1713286191,
0.2908904254,
0.7197852135,
-0.0854019523,
0.6684348583,
0.5892599821,
-0.0332632586,
-0.5218298435,
-0.1760790348,
-0.2053182423,
-0.5170513988,
0.4024280608,
0.2499532104,
-0.5544534326,
0.5603416562,
0.0455583259,
0.3051111996,
0.4345526397,
0.5356484056,
0.1466170251,
1.0237123966,
-0.1894286573,
-0.014103123,
0.2343863845,
-0.1996566057,
0.2857372463,
-0.9357494116,
-0.2400970459,
-0.5378860831,
-0.4510259926,
-0.8166411519,
-0.2584151626,
0.5466960073,
-0.7723782659,
-0.1408063024,
0.1986835748,
-0.7682342529,
0.9859524369,
0.3635649383,
0.3822566271,
0.54050982,
-0.0382048786,
0.3454283178,
0.0063640983,
-0.4423900843,
-0.5393511653,
1.3144035339,
0.1272448301,
0.6261240244,
-0.0368562266,
0.5999876261,
0.6457546353,
0.209508732,
-0.7137037516,
0.637324214,
-0.302752614,
-0.7662075162,
-0.1895480603,
-0.47196576,
-1.0025113821,
0.1365428865,
-0.0497922376,
-0.5712774396,
-0.12050163,
0.0659742653,
0.1468821764,
0.4248710275,
-0.8138926029,
0.7139012218,
0.4297014177,
-0.3800966442,
-0.1814970672,
-0.4276609719,
0.6371605396,
-0.3035698235,
0.3724447489,
-0.0942891613,
0.0747569352,
1.0201317072,
-0.3531051874,
0.8339412808,
-0.0917889774,
-0.1730907708,
0.2816810906,
0.3156784177,
0.5420657992,
0.3194580674,
0.0190569498,
0.1488954425,
0.0452061743,
-0.641525805,
0.0147545664,
0.8467518091,
-0.4756115973,
-0.3246178031,
-0.5411912799,
-0.5314332247,
-0.1973591,
0.331282407,
0.6767241955,
0.6026132703,
-0.5187145472,
0.0699008703,
0.8448416591,
-0.2619521618,
0.1988763362,
0.3531803489,
-0.1643159539,
-0.1471400112,
1.2295329571,
-0.0121660242,
0.100834161,
0.0780493245,
-0.0083578601,
0.0822151601,
-0.8982086182,
-0.4090929031,
0.1209489331,
-0.4969874322,
-0.142908439,
-0.6391629577,
-0.3343726695,
-0.0513041168,
-0.3012563586,
-0.4114472866,
-0.5042154193,
0.0923103094,
0.2010394037,
0.3435252905,
0.6164334416,
0.0027777804,
0.2884271443,
-0.6656545997,
0.2716794908,
-0.0298203249,
0.4364836514,
-0.1229153797,
-0.264634937,
-0.0876011103,
0.211502552,
-0.2819474339,
-0.4773689806,
0.1869428903,
0.2252170742,
0.1026331186,
0.2696642876,
0.1210892498,
-0.0935783908,
-0.6674954891,
0.8300204277,
-0.1734530926,
-0.9287499785,
0.247680977,
-0.9098656178,
0.3968011141,
0.8044918776,
0.2625070512,
-0.7837801576,
-0.916782558,
-0.5756568313,
-0.909321785,
0.699806571,
0.5215554237,
0.4316617548,
0.0374007821,
-0.084991239,
0.3589145839,
0.0237128884,
-0.6439105272,
0.0120270746,
0.0458984934,
-0.0502651446,
0.3004668057,
0.0592984743,
-0.2086812258,
-0.1088474318,
1.0018870831,
0.1706551313,
0.3188129365,
0.163847968,
0.129719004,
0.1842269003,
0.2809740007,
0.424310118,
0.574649334,
-0.2469732612,
0.0645489097,
-0.1450411975,
-0.9299596548,
-0.0820526779,
-0.0302660391,
-0.4281082451,
0.2681352496,
0.5209881067,
0.1785290241,
0.1337055117,
-0.9958391786,
0.6418046951,
-0.1521293521,
-0.5427527428,
-0.5591389537,
0.3838403225,
0.0452777147,
-0.3337168694,
0.2409399152,
0.2865205109,
0.5081228018,
-0.4080246687,
0.4126983881,
0.3206588328,
-0.262119472,
-0.3454455435,
0.5698283315,
0.0022857254,
0.0953535736,
0.6388686299,
-0.2081507593,
-0.689144969,
0.6336601377,
0.3239476681,
0.621129334,
-0.1855770797,
0.4941499233,
0.4397355914,
0.1737416536,
-0.1526972055,
0.203276515,
0.2442520857,
-0.5010587573,
-0.601970017,
-0.5557299852,
-0.6208804846,
0.2747940719,
-0.2701410353,
0.4357708693,
-0.2849633098,
0.1882265359,
0.559869945,
-0.3812119961,
-0.1197807416,
-0.189560324,
-0.1259200573,
0.5398620963,
-0.8245500922,
0.3372720778,
0.3557617366,
-0.0237725284,
-0.4247013628,
0.016281588,
0.1192225516,
-0.4900582731,
0.1348803639,
0.1088510379,
-0.1272633672,
-0.0992848948,
-0.809448123,
-0.3598628342,
0.5173312426,
0.0099983923,
-0.3325123191,
0.0526442826,
0.2253086865,
0.7960140705,
0.0823924541,
0.1059452891,
0.6663829684,
0.633626163,
0.1375302225,
-0.7239223123,
0.1250410378,
-0.3641512096,
-0.5714253187,
0.7493343353,
-0.4340421557,
0.8930523992,
0.2202698588,
-0.2660565674,
-0.2053445727,
0.1379673928,
0.2245526463,
0.4165625572,
-0.0373706259,
0.2367404848,
0.5865269303,
-0.1246267632,
0.8593104482,
-0.0581507348,
0.0438391455,
0.9240088463,
-0.0632606447,
0.6211630702,
0.3742175698,
-0.2933419049,
0.645737946,
0.3517046571,
-0.4473440945,
0.3113003075,
0.5945781469,
-0.6706249714,
0.0488665774,
0.0718690827,
-0.4061585665,
0.5592066646,
0.715207994,
-0.2710818648,
-0.4138639569,
-0.0108929789,
0.5877982378,
-0.0300721154,
-0.2222873569,
0.8154576421,
-0.0262002423,
-0.7425098419,
0.5310981274,
-0.0092216041,
0.6710866094,
-0.5838626027,
-0.0521147028,
-0.0870790929,
0.2777560055,
-0.5657477975,
-1.001665473,
0.2717341483,
0.0160544813,
0.1669227183,
0.0896202475,
0.8560884595,
-0.5191957355,
-0.3128198981,
-0.3464503288,
0.32364586,
0.4109442532,
-0.3941152096,
-0.1442525685,
-0.208553955,
0.0147782043,
-0.3410712481,
0.5528874993,
0.4323548377,
-0.0614461415,
0.4366496503,
0.7945017815,
0.1823742688,
-0.2875283062,
-0.5637449026,
0.8927414417,
-0.1727256477,
-0.5064732432,
-0.8635947108,
0.153468594,
-0.3861369491,
-0.294968605,
0.8962067962,
0.8741592169,
0.6528490186,
-0.357868433,
1.1881108284,
-0.2440048605,
0.2604680061,
-0.6030459404,
1.0585187674,
-0.0572352745,
0.2997547388,
-0.4300609529,
-0.6606792212,
-0.2494499981,
0.0328552276,
-0.3019274771,
-0.2098729908,
0.5676446557,
0.8008916378,
-0.3172336519,
0.2929380536,
-0.0460488982,
0.1470547616,
0.5482026935,
0.5148643851,
0.66432482,
-0.4579823315,
0.8112291694,
0.1312305182,
-0.3333932757,
-0.1214985251,
-1.0368793011,
-1.0070407391,
-0.5239115357,
-0.468344599,
-0.6080847383,
0.0787253603,
0.4072737396,
0.1371281445,
-1.1758824587,
0.1022886932,
-0.3531518877,
0.0767842829,
0.0175186284,
-0.277849257,
0.7611975074,
-0.1984087527,
-0.7312176824,
0.2535719275,
-0.0225600097,
-0.2103888839,
-0.2565392256,
0.2717023194,
-0.0117724771,
0.3907932639,
0.4843402803,
0.4517139792,
-0.0300988611,
-0.1105313152,
-0.2090158314,
-0.120416902,
0.0472961031,
1.0446517467,
-0.5014615059,
0.33587116,
0.7002025247,
0.5328142643,
0.6810312271,
-0.1471917778,
0.7379725575,
-0.9376811385,
-0.0854497999,
0.3663135469,
0.2990131974,
0.2143431008,
-0.4305035174,
0.5175743699,
0.0894475654,
-0.9446427822,
-0.6913103461,
-0.007771818,
-0.9096480608,
-0.6243441105,
1.1316264868,
-0.0555164516,
-0.23256284,
-0.4624694586,
-0.6846778393,
-0.0046008979,
-0.6954188943,
1.2717860937,
0.9335336089,
-0.1679579467,
0.4768048227,
-0.83800596,
0.9497942328,
0.1336037219,
-1.0045292377,
0.3330694437,
0.7977001071,
0.3599349558,
0.1380628943,
0.6356731653,
-0.433083415,
0.4631544948,
0.4340099394,
0.1017459184,
-0.2560396194,
0.0786244124,
0.2001102269,
0.1756728292,
-0.3562661409,
0.0536770225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12940v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12940v2 | Topological properties and organizing principles of semantic networks | 2023-04-24T11:12:21 | 2023-08-17T14:51:25 | Gabriel Budel, Ying Jin, Piet Van Mieghem, Maksim Kitsak | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | Interpreting natural language is an increasingly important task in computer
algorithms due to the growing availability of unstructured textual data.
Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications rely on semantic networks for
structured knowledge representation. The fundamental properties of semantic
networks must be taken into account when designing NLP algorithms, yet they
remain to be structurally investigated. We study the properties of semantic
networks from ConceptNet, defined by 7 semantic relations from 11 different
languages. We find that semantic networks have universal basic properties: they
are sparse, highly clustered, and many exhibit power-law degree distributions.
Our findings show that the majority of the considered networks are scale-free.
Some networks exhibit language-specific properties determined by grammatical
rules, for example networks from highly inflected languages, such as e.g.
Latin, German, French and Spanish, show peaks in the degree distribution that
deviate from a power law. We find that depending on the semantic relation type
and the language, the link formation in semantic networks is guided by
different principles. In some networks the connections are similarity-based,
while in others the connections are more complementarity-based. Finally, we
demonstrate how knowledge of similarity and complementarity in semantic
networks can improve NLP algorithms in missing link inference. | [
-0.3323861957,
-0.533454299,
0.5611354709,
0.241373077,
-0.2256813049,
-0.2484376729,
-0.2382229269,
-0.6409560442,
0.7833121419,
0.8409764171,
-0.3781568706,
-0.5066207051,
-0.5406598449,
0.1834522635,
-0.5814126134,
0.9357455373,
0.3778857887,
0.0565229468,
-0.118034862,
-0.553811729,
-0.173004061,
-0.2859469354,
-0.4077276587,
-0.4799044728,
0.4921341836,
0.086412549,
1.1214720011,
0.873375535,
0.7383373976,
0.4435811639,
-0.5339474678,
-0.0699641109,
-0.1944561601,
0.0367307365,
-0.4988363683,
-0.4688388705,
-0.3487421572,
-0.1738364398,
0.8409122229,
1.4107972383,
0.1173841953,
-0.2330105454,
0.0903407931,
1.038476944,
-0.1693746895,
0.33543998,
-0.6316928267,
0.1183409691,
-0.2163252532,
-0.31471017,
-0.0309078321,
-0.2755681276,
0.318212986,
-0.7550823689,
0.5584442019,
0.3780879378,
0.9885365963,
0.2200700343,
-0.5390299559,
-0.4556080699,
-0.59387362,
0.5114141107,
-0.4899772704,
0.3934220374,
0.5441942215,
0.2379486561,
-0.4813914001,
-0.5626341701,
-0.5168874264,
-0.2899471223,
-0.3204490542,
-0.1559204757,
-0.052742172,
0.415396899,
-0.0483839698,
0.5547268987,
-0.6042386889,
0.1508398354,
-0.3549114168,
0.090091981,
0.6812732816,
0.014344654,
0.5982041359,
-0.42541942,
-0.1648327708,
-0.1236046702,
-0.4582157433,
-0.1813463569,
0.3581694365,
0.531173408,
-0.0168053638,
0.7445613742,
-0.5096142888,
0.8366086483,
-0.5343227983,
0.0103108436,
0.1606392115,
-0.6537982821,
-0.2911321521,
0.1809867769,
0.8638467193,
0.088466011,
0.584487617,
-0.7246013284,
0.2517869174,
-0.0192703661,
0.2484561801,
-0.2089153826,
-0.3366627395,
0.0965699106,
-0.4249155819,
-0.3130379021,
0.2718268037,
-0.1500736922,
-0.2202800214,
-0.5176261663,
0.3657003939,
-0.5055896044,
-0.4313599169,
0.3840375245,
-0.5370601416,
0.491447717,
0.0162242688,
-0.9100532532,
1.123033762,
0.9319511652,
0.8598008156,
-0.0495267473,
-0.2940048575,
0.0387972966,
0.0152152963,
-0.1486533433,
0.4377111197,
-0.3332992792,
0.0754008144,
-0.3078018725,
0.1688058674,
-0.1446006447,
-0.357360065,
0.5195002556,
-0.7843821049,
-0.133894816,
-0.1179183275,
-0.7241269946,
-0.321849376,
-0.0171787068,
-0.9166644216,
0.3759799004,
-0.2369402349,
-1.0848196745,
0.2469466627,
-0.7668841481,
-0.6032961607,
-0.0223206654,
0.0424205884,
0.1827073991,
0.0858669057,
-0.3371717334,
0.3477755785,
-0.3126066923,
0.1874888688,
-0.2654113173,
-0.0436620601,
0.1327462643,
-0.0473528951,
1.1119868755,
0.2050530463,
-0.0664795041,
0.0368597917,
-1.1213767529,
0.0332561508,
0.1423517317,
-0.0236892328,
-0.6372217536,
0.2364099622,
-0.0358969383,
0.1122048348,
0.0138505651,
-0.6012498736,
0.0302506499,
-0.8902426362,
0.3103221357,
0.4809269905,
0.1471377164,
0.7092546225,
0.0987548903,
0.0453656502,
-0.0616423935,
-0.182566449,
0.4588729441,
-0.7381968498,
-0.8466830254,
0.2808294296,
0.1592316478,
0.4906207621,
-0.5907914639,
0.6642392278,
-0.4594651759,
-0.2077511251,
0.0604964569,
0.1869160533,
0.3825802803,
0.4401661158,
0.3869987726,
-0.3736144602,
-0.3150040209,
-0.9036245942,
-0.2802515626,
-0.2146586627,
-0.2125316411,
0.2115636915,
0.4017783403,
0.023338059,
1.1278355122,
-0.5397229791,
-0.124566704,
-0.2492517382,
-0.124724403,
0.5426480174,
0.3444192111,
0.2570863068,
-0.9001628757,
0.0876249,
0.2842280269,
-0.9386529922,
-0.0746316165,
0.2073803097,
-0.1594261825,
-0.2053161561,
0.1822406203,
-0.4185188711,
0.1938049346,
0.3545506001,
-0.6237323284,
0.3567123115,
-0.3896674514,
-0.5460165143,
-1.0902816057,
-0.1371164769,
0.0670436919,
-0.1106426492,
-0.7964531183,
0.2409067899,
-0.507117033,
0.0141642885,
-0.0725116134,
0.4055677056,
-0.3187204599,
-0.3667508364,
-0.1025815979,
0.4287057817,
0.2916237116,
0.4943870008,
0.2315684408,
-0.071948804,
0.5143063068,
-0.8506830931,
0.8343962431,
0.415502131,
-0.0391979143,
0.5984953642,
-0.9063013196,
-0.2080080956,
-0.0205751844,
-0.215370819,
-0.8501616716,
-0.1984911859,
0.1334431618,
-0.3901437521,
0.2748575807,
-0.1568869203,
-0.6027314067,
-0.0582527332,
0.0989241302,
0.2430867553,
-0.005630394,
-0.2429423928,
0.2321532667,
0.271709621,
0.3422724009,
-0.3453121483,
-0.7200669646,
0.2392191589,
-0.0718170032,
-1.0079753399,
0.1778515577,
0.3206214309,
-0.5635514855,
0.3062520623,
0.0652528554,
-0.5526683331,
0.3557364047,
0.2962302566,
-0.2490003407,
-0.3498262465,
0.4628962576,
-0.0976336822,
-0.2877463102,
0.2199226171,
-0.7864018083,
0.3664102256,
-0.38067469,
-0.2136018872,
-0.2861492336,
0.2304160148,
0.4532878101,
-0.055701647,
0.9234811664,
0.2300280929,
-0.2880578637,
-0.0197510105,
-0.0482208729,
-0.1437344551,
-0.4125997722,
0.2613131702,
-0.3792498708,
-0.7405619025,
0.5331892967,
0.160528332,
-0.1945927888,
0.6241599917,
0.225707233,
-0.2264092416,
0.1628708541,
0.9051815271,
-0.158531189,
0.0640214533,
-0.3361672163,
0.291439712,
-0.6193031669,
-0.1285171509,
-0.803907752,
-0.3691281676,
-1.2300676107,
-0.0180264302,
0.2793877721,
0.1802509874,
-0.1169596836,
0.6963566542,
-0.2406956404,
0.3825254738,
0.5279055834,
0.0209857319,
0.4262672365,
0.1971705407,
-0.4348630607,
0.1368362606,
-0.8778237104,
-0.360034883,
0.5011855364,
0.1504713893,
0.5211473107,
0.2028788179,
0.689653039,
0.0799987316,
-0.5000838637,
-0.8987487555,
0.5085721612,
-0.0228068102,
-0.4022241235,
-0.8345968127,
-0.7410742044,
-1.2053151131,
0.1869172901,
-0.3862640262,
-0.9289086461,
0.402285099,
-0.1789566875,
0.3171772957,
0.5713737607,
-0.5160478354,
0.6193985343,
0.0981438383,
-0.0273096804,
-0.2015591264,
-1.0961046219,
0.1549012661,
0.1627577096,
0.0670737252,
-0.07425154,
0.0969791114,
0.7426284552,
-0.8344739676,
0.6281865835,
0.3290753663,
0.1893613786,
0.1858296543,
0.227506265,
0.2212294638,
-0.1410494745,
-0.1301258057,
0.3578708768,
0.1043128893,
-0.5100304484,
-0.7993772626,
0.5500630736,
-0.8316676617,
-0.2282417566,
-0.0853463039,
-0.4547915459,
-0.1581639946,
0.4643999934,
0.2053503394,
0.8324676156,
-0.2006396204,
0.2581190467,
0.5930443406,
-0.0038829516,
0.5236738324,
0.0590921938,
-0.0392431207,
0.0393260047,
1.08022964,
0.3308992088,
0.5526803136,
0.6783792377,
0.4403448403,
-0.178591758,
-0.5299718976,
-0.0970844403,
0.2723127902,
-0.7232531309,
0.1629926115,
-0.8630327582,
-0.4633751512,
-0.2021009475,
-0.0294748023,
-0.1931995153,
-1.0647491217,
-0.0263494067,
-0.0989571884,
0.6207330227,
0.9422348142,
-0.0480661541,
0.1434037387,
-0.5627758503,
0.4532722533,
0.3244413137,
0.6319670081,
-0.0571888499,
-0.1868699342,
-0.1112312078,
-0.1589794755,
0.0412576534,
-0.9754499197,
0.0489043109,
0.4424002171,
0.2307240814,
0.461268574,
0.0925819278,
0.1545902193,
-0.361856401,
0.4144211113,
0.1607089788,
-0.6803930402,
0.4331811666,
-0.4108667374,
-0.0221344326,
0.3413748741,
0.2943312526,
-0.7619338036,
-0.41111812,
-1.0009794235,
-0.6670014262,
0.5400610566,
0.8942469954,
0.248176083,
0.0009397453,
0.3987120092,
-0.5008465052,
0.1458209455,
-0.6041036844,
-0.4693824947,
-0.3552191854,
-0.1153348908,
0.2224532813,
-0.1317088902,
-0.1226591095,
-0.173245728,
0.1879675537,
-0.1294619143,
0.0993644893,
0.1963100731,
0.1451254338,
0.3459532857,
0.3204729259,
0.544782877,
0.8777570128,
-0.3304745555,
0.4068997204,
0.106928736,
-0.549294889,
0.234323591,
-0.2161606997,
-0.0251328293,
0.0869450867,
0.6381912231,
0.6117368937,
0.1885876805,
0.0467814356,
0.2920917273,
-0.1249861568,
-0.0033491361,
-0.1589421779,
0.2402808666,
0.2019396424,
-0.0240978114,
0.1013169289,
0.0857684389,
0.3177862167,
-0.4375105798,
0.2037666589,
0.345312953,
-0.5548765659,
-0.4157244265,
0.0273860861,
-0.0418164693,
-0.3847822547,
0.606063664,
-0.2869137824,
-0.3581096232,
0.805277884,
0.4377865791,
0.8724313974,
0.2222116441,
0.2011101544,
0.1949730664,
0.4859855771,
0.2511371672,
-0.1065197513,
-0.2744568586,
-1.1873488426,
-0.1103283837,
-0.8795816302,
-0.4129600525,
-0.5621926188,
-0.5983844399,
0.0321740247,
-0.7093121409,
0.1800238937,
0.109918043,
0.1797713935,
-0.5615967512,
0.4206267595,
-0.3396167457,
0.7864021063,
-0.7480590343,
0.7790206075,
0.4850702584,
-0.3434950411,
-0.7953669429,
-0.3787819147,
0.1701996326,
-0.641767025,
0.8557187915,
-0.1691629887,
-0.2295001149,
-0.0551279187,
-0.4305129945,
-1.0006084442,
0.8265597224,
0.010292612,
-0.0739241093,
-0.1255414039,
0.4041569233,
0.8276261687,
-0.3233494759,
0.0720108151,
0.3745508194,
0.2970099151,
0.3491232693,
-0.8780437112,
-0.0655344427,
-0.2746935189,
0.1943082213,
0.3296286166,
-0.2573899329,
0.4801575243,
0.0024589158,
-0.3633222282,
-0.1794730574,
0.6015740633,
-0.1200211644,
0.0672159195,
0.2450909317,
0.6808917522,
0.8283867836,
-0.1114656851,
1.307190299,
-0.347997278,
0.203858301,
0.9318427444,
0.0043450925,
0.5557070971,
0.3437611759,
0.0076571973,
0.6131897569,
0.1976650804,
0.1969433874,
0.130476743,
0.4960553944,
0.1083610803,
0.0743367001,
-0.3254817724,
-0.2276390195,
0.5198999643,
0.3202704191,
-0.4095406234,
-0.3290346563,
-0.4435454607,
0.201085493,
-0.0109911682,
-0.1785143167,
0.9218121171,
0.2821753919,
-0.0082596652,
0.3901267946,
0.0400035009,
0.1094569489,
-0.5955469608,
0.047860954,
-0.0976921543,
-0.1454238296,
-0.4223639965,
-0.8989871144,
0.6806511879,
-0.5162717104,
-0.4015480578,
0.0990991965,
0.7356444001,
-0.0254662987,
-0.4409232736,
0.4568837285,
0.3890210986,
0.4316933453,
0.1895100772,
-0.4195190072,
-0.4168656468,
-0.5679932833,
0.0251925159,
0.1154156253,
0.8409815431,
-0.0624855906,
0.676632762,
0.6953181624,
0.470570147,
0.2466401458,
-0.006983364,
0.8420028687,
-0.8571791649,
-0.3707439899,
-0.668287158,
0.049223382,
-0.2681866884,
-0.3235351741,
0.6931766868,
-0.0781749561,
0.6518391967,
0.3802387416,
0.1105166823,
-0.0305301938,
-0.0356413461,
-0.7511042356,
0.7192098498,
-0.3193465471,
0.0095192632,
-0.4499082267,
-1.1823436022,
-0.5799596906,
0.5410034657,
-0.0618358254,
-0.1566666812,
0.8706197143,
0.793854475,
-0.1987546086,
0.17047216,
0.3885472715,
0.124036856,
0.1956280917,
0.226400584,
0.3257629275,
-0.3636521697,
0.1777803749,
-0.2753015161,
-0.1536125541,
0.0882946923,
-0.9133790731,
-0.6968225241,
-0.6232262254,
-0.0869852751,
-0.3921256959,
-0.1615731269,
0.8307260275,
0.6571410894,
-0.6465365291,
-0.4872125089,
-0.5472217798,
0.8166484237,
-0.2128899246,
-0.2190173566,
0.4652966559,
-0.4802798331,
-0.0310537983,
0.1789220273,
0.6469292641,
-0.0579828173,
-0.2846000493,
-0.1684828103,
-0.4313076735,
-0.0210286286,
0.5750598907,
0.4184756875,
-0.6212190986,
-0.2212729752,
-0.0520732552,
-0.2025733143,
0.1457878947,
0.7085964084,
-0.354786545,
0.5596373677,
0.9070290923,
0.5649539232,
0.0812689066,
-0.2852327228,
0.6075377464,
-0.78575629,
0.2895796001,
0.0279112346,
0.5929257274,
0.2257286161,
-0.2394998819,
0.6307080984,
0.5889214277,
-0.3402739167,
-0.1839559823,
0.4387303591,
-0.9379110932,
-0.1650424898,
1.0918208361,
-0.0033508288,
-0.52120471,
-0.580527842,
0.2107353956,
0.1205987111,
0.2037208974,
0.1579944342,
0.5965415835,
-0.2051406354,
0.0004030626,
-0.4461644292,
0.5233457088,
0.203065604,
-0.5293613076,
-0.3259393573,
0.1739156693,
0.1481671631,
0.6081398129,
0.4459975064,
-0.0573415346,
-0.2032302618,
-0.1813142598,
-0.0765810087,
0.2632086575,
-0.5521021485,
-0.2813251913,
0.1511930674,
-0.0379393771,
0.055407159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11960v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11960v2 | ThreatCrawl: A BERT-based Focused Crawler for the Cybersecurity Domain | 2023-04-24T09:53:33 | 2023-04-26T13:25:45 | Philipp Kuehn, Mike Schmidt, Markus Bayer, Christian Reuter | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Publicly available information contains valuable information for Cyber Threat
Intelligence (CTI). This can be used to prevent attacks that have already taken
place on other systems. Ideally, only the initial attack succeeds and all
subsequent ones are detected and stopped. But while there are different
standards to exchange this information, a lot of it is shared in articles or
blog posts in non-standardized ways. Manually scanning through multiple online
portals and news pages to discover new threats and extracting them is a
time-consuming task. To automize parts of this scanning process, multiple
papers propose extractors that use Natural Language Processing (NLP) to extract
Indicators of Compromise (IOCs) from documents. However, while this already
solves the problem of extracting the information out of documents, the search
for these documents is rarely considered. In this paper, a new focused crawler
is proposed called ThreatCrawl, which uses Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT)-based models to classify documents and
adapt its crawling path dynamically. While ThreatCrawl has difficulties to
classify the specific type of Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) named in texts,
e.g., IOC content, it can successfully find relevant documents and modify its
path accordingly. It yields harvest rates of up to 52%, which are, to the best
of our knowledge, better than the current state of the art. | [
-0.4210712314,
-0.7853364944,
0.2587171495,
0.0371048003,
-0.3557344973,
0.4312285483,
-0.018510662,
-0.7999264598,
0.5614920259,
0.129477933,
-0.499473542,
-0.6120202541,
-0.6464236379,
0.00052812,
-0.5997127295,
0.97517097,
0.2950644195,
-0.6301892996,
0.0256101713,
0.2863377631,
-0.3304518163,
-0.4818244576,
-0.4386228621,
0.2591659129,
0.5388068557,
0.0550940111,
0.7008139491,
0.4232215881,
1.0285574198,
0.2743202448,
-0.2018178552,
-0.0327619314,
-0.2132575959,
0.4142231345,
-0.4642252028,
-0.27264148,
-0.1250255257,
0.0043206434,
0.1444024295,
0.2476552576,
-0.1111460105,
-0.0909459293,
0.1734757125,
0.4260085821,
-0.826936841,
-0.0777026042,
-0.8790482879,
-0.0813693404,
-0.4791231155,
-0.2122176737,
-0.6302203536,
-0.3262161016,
0.6359978914,
-0.3875826001,
0.3201991916,
-0.2303947508,
0.9518805146,
0.0877799988,
-0.2604534924,
-0.437739104,
-0.4465388358,
0.7176335454,
-0.5602285266,
0.5215200186,
0.0936114639,
0.3175135553,
-0.1272043139,
-0.853217423,
-0.1100790948,
0.1310953051,
0.1161298826,
0.0141462507,
-0.5329055786,
-0.0967309624,
-0.0007662585,
-0.0542665161,
-0.6374160051,
-0.0602824576,
-0.4894155264,
-0.3990732431,
0.7594082952,
-0.0596496984,
0.1368957311,
-0.2225522101,
-0.7906212211,
-0.2910557985,
-0.1288645267,
0.1544637382,
0.3546913266,
0.4641730785,
0.0944577679,
0.0931110978,
0.114482455,
0.4577999413,
0.239171192,
-0.2061548382,
0.4428904355,
0.0022914272,
0.1334643364,
0.3344224095,
0.522852242,
0.2373534143,
-0.1127276048,
-0.3347427249,
-0.1955055296,
0.0502877422,
1.1278128624,
-0.6862989664,
-0.0845951065,
0.334367305,
-0.6953721642,
-0.6083879471,
0.3853825331,
-1.0839112997,
-0.4337404072,
0.1071972996,
0.1948981434,
-0.8701939583,
-0.0243430156,
0.0053448286,
-0.5151463151,
0.5477833748,
0.3630504012,
-0.1611649394,
0.1696082503,
0.6060544252,
1.1291155815,
-0.4875515401,
0.1557815224,
-0.3859519064,
0.2694334388,
-0.0107144462,
0.7586970925,
-0.5330355167,
-0.399446547,
0.2318390757,
-0.1457510591,
-0.1992197037,
-0.1816725731,
0.6439044476,
-0.9082615376,
0.0050400305,
0.2830300331,
-0.2095371932,
-0.5313513875,
0.7958028316,
-0.7501809001,
0.8397403955,
0.0342067368,
-1.1429520845,
-0.0199355278,
-0.8175118566,
-0.8162466884,
0.3795927465,
0.304017663,
-0.2149375677,
-0.0224360246,
0.1364408731,
0.2303463519,
-0.2380616665,
0.2426426411,
-0.3162156641,
-0.2759238183,
0.0204053409,
-0.2006738037,
0.890950501,
0.3261452317,
-0.6032785177,
-0.0085479505,
-0.4561508298,
0.1380325705,
0.1863485724,
-0.3919446468,
-0.5114645362,
0.4453112483,
0.1226630658,
0.0560877062,
0.6196700931,
-0.8918555975,
0.0254250858,
-0.4639403224,
0.3217237294,
0.858858943,
0.1020368785,
0.0968079492,
-0.4496588409,
0.3689473867,
-0.0577951074,
0.4661360085,
-0.0606666915,
-0.5004705787,
-0.6113914251,
-0.4260579348,
0.321388036,
0.7408652306,
-0.5465296507,
0.517152369,
-0.2390283048,
-0.8161042929,
-0.513030827,
-0.3758305311,
0.0500102602,
0.1655023694,
0.5266569853,
-0.4263239205,
-0.701931417,
-0.9013864994,
-0.2850529253,
-0.1236518621,
-0.1596599072,
0.2568459809,
0.1774535924,
-0.7097296715,
0.9821617007,
-0.5934270024,
-0.4531083703,
-0.3912220001,
0.3980593085,
0.3627716005,
0.2302763015,
0.4430883527,
-1.1050560474,
-0.5468264222,
-0.1873128414,
-0.5714975595,
0.0321707204,
-0.1270572245,
-0.1719506383,
0.1347354352,
0.4053946435,
-0.5255684853,
0.4739438295,
0.149342984,
0.020515142,
0.3558627069,
0.0784084126,
-0.1446130574,
-0.8996323347,
0.1947909296,
-0.0154493116,
-0.1533142775,
-0.715290606,
0.7569124103,
-0.013591853,
-0.3404956758,
-0.5118138194,
0.0144777093,
-0.0822593495,
0.2386591434,
-0.0834434628,
0.4046047628,
-0.3051407635,
0.4444511533,
0.0002638688,
0.6356490254,
0.6108399034,
-0.5543624759,
0.129964143,
0.2832659185,
0.0042187106,
0.2067900896,
-0.6976900697,
0.4796516299,
0.0028407441,
0.0933358148,
-0.4831864834,
-0.0133339046,
0.1929395944,
-0.5033005476,
0.3451230228,
-0.1092610657,
-0.306347847,
-0.5919278264,
-0.9217336774,
0.0791645125,
0.5261570811,
-0.4845051169,
0.965190649,
0.634776175,
-0.1242018491,
-0.6073967218,
-0.439866066,
0.3028156757,
0.0661527961,
-0.732093215,
0.500434339,
-0.2524902821,
-0.1489252448,
-0.0768348426,
-0.2519410849,
-0.3919766247,
0.3536895812,
0.4541081488,
0.3838136494,
0.0267264433,
-0.1485253423,
-0.201791361,
-0.0678379238,
0.2473356724,
-0.4313153028,
0.7240685225,
-0.1406690329,
-0.2915323973,
-0.4741074443,
0.5109343529,
0.655747354,
-0.6875232458,
0.5283445716,
0.5233253837,
-0.377312094,
-0.142321676,
-0.3930668533,
-0.0671811849,
-0.5690968037,
0.2111655623,
-0.1168603674,
-0.619581759,
0.1554353386,
-0.1183171198,
0.2300194949,
0.6571526527,
0.1622730345,
-0.2616998255,
0.9029237032,
0.8212019205,
-0.3873822689,
0.3593524396,
-0.3424871564,
0.6269985437,
-0.5796526074,
-0.3600527644,
-0.5733007193,
-0.5080779195,
-0.8576296568,
-0.1161946207,
0.4179846942,
-0.3467052281,
0.0465161838,
0.8047799468,
-0.7819318771,
0.0400281064,
0.9484746456,
0.4206980169,
-0.2151686102,
-0.0582006462,
-0.0858886465,
0.259673208,
-0.532482028,
-0.5013746023,
0.9426736832,
0.2959164977,
0.691163063,
0.1653061211,
1.0130681992,
0.7261742949,
-0.0879544318,
-0.8319732547,
0.6781489849,
-0.2125616223,
-0.8202821016,
-0.2351562232,
-0.0743723437,
-1.0932286978,
-0.0213680267,
-0.0259565227,
-0.7145332098,
0.3700289726,
-0.3477121592,
-0.1375816017,
0.5271423459,
-0.1732100993,
0.3641501069,
-0.0868562758,
-0.2747493684,
-0.5104454756,
-0.8827353716,
-0.0969642252,
-0.2300542444,
0.3174830079,
0.1283969879,
0.1499105543,
0.7399200201,
-0.0679885969,
0.8211272359,
-0.2184522003,
0.0309592988,
0.5658741593,
0.5489247441,
0.6381462216,
-0.0553760827,
-0.1139227897,
0.4016318321,
-0.1466274261,
-0.1851991266,
-0.1662531942,
0.281187892,
-0.5041039586,
-0.7498972416,
-0.7309905291,
-0.5671731234,
0.1026230454,
0.5163800716,
0.1484426856,
0.3537955284,
-0.1659201831,
0.4948218763,
0.843690455,
-0.1272829324,
0.7388810515,
0.4720861912,
0.5047531128,
-0.0642383099,
0.8325325847,
-0.0553075597,
-0.2493851185,
0.6977749467,
0.0196452048,
-0.0696892962,
-0.7264160514,
0.1454294324,
-0.0941458568,
-0.4357819557,
-0.7204192281,
-0.7943882346,
-0.6915536523,
-0.2942473292,
-0.6191482544,
-0.1264320612,
-0.0589576326,
-0.1328115165,
0.0672368184,
0.1466486156,
0.4705821574,
-0.0613133535,
0.1481978595,
-0.9361207485,
0.2917741239,
0.2300280333,
0.3189812601,
-0.1088951528,
-0.1597150266,
-0.1473563462,
0.0298841298,
-0.5560255051,
-1.0295097828,
0.5068228245,
0.0916765034,
0.4215816855,
0.5701254606,
0.504974246,
0.2704859376,
-0.3655713201,
0.7621219158,
-0.0391028747,
-0.8776797056,
0.8623315692,
-0.3825024366,
0.1390116066,
0.6392136216,
0.6633207798,
-0.3957052827,
-0.5385307074,
-0.5109098554,
-0.9518076181,
0.6785604358,
0.2159635872,
0.0604014434,
-0.2471112758,
-0.1853641421,
-0.0394023955,
0.0432404988,
-0.4639037549,
0.2006144077,
-0.2932811379,
-0.2428431213,
0.5032923818,
-0.3915207088,
-0.0035793553,
0.1640436053,
0.8206818104,
0.0192363951,
0.5258779526,
0.3481701612,
-0.3983299434,
-0.0046214047,
0.231783554,
0.0388498567,
0.2270828038,
-0.6249808669,
0.2739627361,
0.0293364879,
-0.8839389086,
-0.0767015368,
0.3041203618,
-0.3324858546,
0.204226926,
0.5523850322,
0.1109947264,
0.1092751995,
-0.9384012222,
0.9018326998,
0.0546784364,
-0.0716537535,
-0.2856148183,
0.225119561,
-0.451554358,
0.4112866819,
0.5630056262,
0.2164028138,
0.4775159061,
-0.4435683191,
0.5014667511,
0.4537234604,
-0.5777495503,
-0.1514068246,
0.4937274754,
0.3304424584,
-0.5935628414,
0.927677393,
-0.1403523237,
-0.8832823634,
0.6132542491,
0.5674659014,
1.1863920689,
-0.4249597788,
0.1679223478,
0.1631302088,
0.6760833263,
0.438889116,
0.2962902188,
-0.0373066701,
-0.4570508897,
0.0304336194,
-0.6235323548,
-0.2972001135,
0.0682439432,
-0.7788410187,
0.376085341,
-0.5554197431,
-0.1002511606,
0.0996489748,
-0.1331238449,
-0.6571292281,
0.0272179712,
0.0908511728,
1.3323028088,
-0.1221966371,
0.5549666882,
0.5033823252,
-0.1631306559,
-0.2019557357,
0.3490252495,
-0.0398886204,
-0.5516859889,
0.3937987685,
0.5620128512,
-0.1439265013,
-0.3046246469,
-0.6169952154,
-1.019937396,
0.841840446,
-0.0484438874,
-0.5761874914,
-0.4276204705,
0.0548269935,
0.421684593,
-0.0039486131,
-0.0026415747,
0.1168061569,
0.576832056,
-0.2468052506,
-0.5018607378,
0.0618598983,
-0.496863395,
-0.2015463263,
0.457533747,
-0.4263277948,
0.6640117764,
-0.0629429296,
-0.2960269153,
-0.2941325605,
0.3073781729,
-0.1861794293,
0.4769054949,
0.5624822378,
0.4961234629,
0.447935611,
0.0196486991,
1.004075408,
-0.5482662916,
0.2018225342,
0.8531975746,
-0.1667100638,
0.8998320699,
0.1705538481,
-0.0700743869,
0.896762073,
0.4587564468,
-0.3895309269,
0.8032788634,
-0.2087902874,
-0.084851563,
-0.2068350315,
-0.1470999271,
-0.111444138,
0.6982553601,
0.3174384534,
-0.4245244265,
-0.4809163511,
0.043994274,
-0.1083738655,
-0.1051825359,
-0.1068211198,
0.8435686827,
-0.3514414132,
-0.1829121411,
0.2279327661,
0.3113417327,
0.6467902064,
-0.8563597202,
0.193316415,
0.1589630246,
-0.011980325,
-0.032886412,
-0.8377323151,
0.503015697,
0.082558915,
-0.2836556137,
-0.1447754353,
1.1189240217,
0.0456132479,
-0.0718110055,
0.5262235999,
0.0067246235,
0.0761638582,
-0.2716291547,
-0.5187299252,
-0.0237299632,
0.0243642349,
-0.141050294,
0.1667575389,
0.1314812303,
0.0283014085,
0.6270961165,
0.8235572577,
-0.2254396379,
-0.0374291353,
-0.506957531,
1.1700963974,
-0.4802907407,
-0.738220036,
-0.5978158712,
0.3945449889,
-0.3291836977,
0.0052493121,
0.5399130583,
0.6994128227,
0.7096371055,
0.0385756381,
0.7628081441,
-0.3771706223,
0.5638420582,
-0.0400605388,
0.6176272035,
-0.2213587761,
-0.0236467198,
-0.1952822208,
-0.7302343845,
-0.0761966631,
0.4797834158,
0.1155497953,
-0.5243321061,
0.6207339168,
0.5493678451,
-0.1437738091,
0.1213647425,
-0.0899977461,
0.1359719485,
0.3980623782,
0.3007858396,
0.4255665243,
-0.3369293213,
0.7547491789,
-0.2591582537,
-0.2321234494,
-0.5148833394,
-0.724445045,
-0.8321096897,
-0.4123105705,
-0.2241595685,
-0.1808571368,
0.4871088266,
0.7643867135,
0.7799703479,
-0.8451854587,
0.1871178597,
0.0301843528,
0.1710720062,
-0.2534714937,
-0.3023730814,
0.3113761246,
-0.6959385872,
-0.2776364088,
0.6049426794,
0.4041769803,
-0.1848709285,
0.105965063,
0.3147945404,
-0.5084272027,
0.5749432445,
0.5003806949,
-0.048638802,
-0.4037473202,
-0.3877127767,
0.0962295309,
-0.1109262705,
-0.0051965164,
0.7360877395,
-0.8726496696,
0.5032326579,
0.4699977934,
0.8893427849,
0.3474588692,
-0.233816877,
0.3439031541,
-0.8070480824,
0.0362691544,
0.5508809686,
0.1954445392,
-0.0008733898,
-0.646576643,
0.6144266129,
0.2432370633,
-0.099473618,
-0.7758194804,
0.1573896706,
-0.9053629637,
-0.6227224469,
0.6915709376,
-0.0278088879,
-0.2748258114,
-0.1605276316,
-0.1341416687,
0.2830796242,
-0.4929023087,
0.9774743915,
0.3037511706,
0.2616075575,
0.2802426219,
-0.1986911744,
0.2166578323,
-0.1119688079,
-0.6524227858,
-0.070552513,
-0.0109248394,
-0.0592420213,
0.697614789,
-0.0815959945,
-0.1652930975,
0.2498434782,
-0.0899708048,
0.196325317,
0.0270442776,
-0.7484968901,
-0.0092748469,
0.5532340407,
-0.4507585764,
-0.4608432353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11957v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11957v4 | Benchmarking ChatGPT-4 on ACR Radiation Oncology In-Training (TXIT) Exam and Red Journal Gray Zone Cases: Potentials and Challenges for AI-Assisted Medical Education and Decision Making in Radiation Oncology | 2023-04-24T09:50:39 | 2023-08-21T09:20:48 | Yixing Huang, Ahmed Gomaa, Sabine Semrau, Marlen Haderlein, Sebastian Lettmaier, Thomas Weissmann, Johanna Grigo, Hassen Ben Tkhayat, Benjamin Frey, Udo S. Gaipl, Luitpold V. Distel, Andreas Maier, Rainer Fietkau, Christoph Bert, Florian Putz | physics.med-ph | physics.med-ph, cs.CL | The potential of large language models in medicine for education and decision
making purposes has been demonstrated as they achieve decent scores on medical
exams such as the United States Medical Licensing Exam (USMLE) and the MedQA
exam. In this work, we evaluate the performance of ChatGPT-4 in the specialized
field of radiation oncology using the 38th American College of Radiology (ACR)
radiation oncology in-training (TXIT) exam and the 2022 Red Journal Gray Zone
cases. For the TXIT exam, ChatGPT-3.5 and ChatGPT-4 have achieved the scores of
63.65% and 74.57%, respectively, highlighting the advantage of the latest
ChatGPT-4 model. Based on the TXIT exam, ChatGPT-4's strong and weak areas in
radiation oncology are identified to some extent. Specifically, ChatGPT-4
demonstrates better knowledge of statistics, CNS & eye, pediatrics, biology,
and physics than knowledge of bone & soft tissue and gynecology, as per the ACR
knowledge domain. Regarding clinical care paths, ChatGPT-4 performs better in
diagnosis, prognosis, and toxicity than brachytherapy and dosimetry. It lacks
proficiency in in-depth details of clinical trials. For the Gray Zone cases,
ChatGPT-4 is able to suggest a personalized treatment approach to each case
with high correctness and comprehensiveness. Importantly, it provides novel
treatment aspects for many cases, which are not suggested by any human experts.
Both evaluations demonstrate the potential of ChatGPT-4 in medical education
for the general public and cancer patients, as well as the potential to aid
clinical decision-making, while acknowledging its limitations in certain
domains. Because of the risk of hallucination, facts provided by ChatGPT always
need to be verified. | [
-0.2465626746,
-0.7351950407,
0.6573126912,
-0.1390675157,
-0.0735238642,
0.2887412012,
-0.1458770782,
-0.2309326231,
-0.281915158,
0.2052638978,
-0.3955941796,
-0.3666095734,
-0.5693233013,
0.0214783866,
0.0015085492,
0.907551527,
0.0137389675,
0.5258883834,
0.1021682024,
-0.0357332639,
-0.7606850266,
-0.4900664091,
-1.0411063433,
-0.50073421,
0.2887972891,
0.3764590919,
0.5510596037,
0.4170546532,
0.9857562184,
0.3042502403,
0.0770305991,
-0.2648229301,
-0.572971046,
-0.1509597003,
0.1431666315,
-0.3908972144,
-0.3850069642,
0.1190204844,
0.4147877097,
0.4266570508,
-0.2859517634,
-0.3545634747,
-0.2285592258,
0.5532929301,
-0.2047323585,
0.1356369257,
-0.5939472318,
0.5093842745,
-0.060915757,
-0.5456798077,
-0.0234476104,
-0.6828370094,
0.5716065168,
-0.3744140267,
0.2684807181,
-0.0595392399,
0.9512349367,
0.2260710597,
-0.5464466214,
-0.2377750129,
-0.5758945942,
0.770591855,
-0.5533015132,
0.5029675961,
0.211055994,
0.8106486201,
-0.0913403258,
-1.0206532478,
-0.0995321199,
-0.2986816764,
0.0409811847,
0.5948494673,
-0.3212125599,
0.5076515675,
0.4018346071,
0.4480536282,
-0.6007848978,
-0.1724597067,
-0.5314697623,
-0.4576307237,
0.273688674,
0.2316446006,
0.2625568807,
-0.0693182424,
-0.5145365,
-0.0751642585,
-0.6852189898,
-0.1025851071,
-0.1429467499,
0.0776065961,
0.0670777634,
0.3051580489,
-0.2557662427,
0.5395497084,
-0.1452142149,
0.0907515734,
0.1939830929,
-0.3938630223,
-0.1749288291,
0.0064688888,
0.8417708874,
0.4608714581,
0.0320692435,
-0.1446065903,
0.2428898513,
0.2480145693,
0.2707647383,
-0.92299366,
-0.2586624622,
0.2008755058,
-0.4731158018,
-0.2033743113,
-0.1894160807,
-0.8289853334,
-0.136511147,
0.0652885959,
0.6151901484,
-0.6633377671,
-0.1027751639,
0.3371267617,
-0.0764000863,
0.3211585879,
0.3138307035,
-0.6512941718,
0.5833021402,
0.4667181373,
0.9019325376,
-0.0516965091,
0.0011961175,
-0.0723949745,
-0.1911333501,
-0.0745325908,
0.9172201157,
-0.6816473603,
-0.3404864073,
-0.3064985573,
-0.3331693411,
-0.4556989074,
-0.2070498317,
0.6092506647,
-0.3139451146,
0.4904280603,
-0.4442017972,
-0.6261384487,
-0.4443877637,
0.6547048092,
-0.2183252722,
0.6772672534,
0.3050276935,
-0.655359745,
0.2436833829,
-0.9660328031,
0.033493802,
0.2359002382,
-0.4795970917,
-0.5251968503,
-0.5675124526,
0.0087352684,
0.3499979675,
-0.3279001117,
-0.0029657607,
0.1240757108,
-0.4237377644,
0.1452034712,
-0.3863348365,
0.4924951494,
0.520355165,
-0.3866705894,
-0.1774153709,
-0.4308306575,
0.378790319,
0.0071667456,
-0.3246763349,
0.1174204946,
-0.2415905148,
-0.2717944384,
0.2811810076,
-0.1593105793,
-0.6830760241,
0.0486091673,
-0.2694483697,
0.5529116988,
0.2513712645,
0.4576295316,
-0.1391866654,
-0.5503863692,
0.8329866529,
-0.1801800877,
0.4190512896,
-0.0193565153,
-0.7774448991,
-0.6951081157,
0.0290829279,
0.5779563785,
0.5279687643,
-0.651996851,
-0.2031892091,
0.1148236394,
-0.6931820512,
-0.3433737159,
-0.5067816973,
0.8141565323,
0.7360477448,
0.3119237125,
-0.591157198,
-0.3875761628,
-0.562554121,
-0.0211500358,
0.0304926969,
0.2506904006,
0.5536128879,
0.3991246521,
-0.1165835336,
0.5828732252,
-0.5519813895,
-0.5716257095,
0.0144836335,
0.056408219,
0.1264190972,
0.3573739231,
0.3817113638,
-0.7913515568,
-0.5536162853,
0.4926293194,
-0.7143104672,
-0.0641915649,
0.0736638829,
-0.2678025663,
-0.2538192272,
0.370719105,
-0.2752275169,
0.2219067514,
0.394335568,
-0.5114425421,
0.1116947308,
-0.581695199,
0.7598885298,
-0.5385327935,
0.2243251204,
-0.047667373,
-0.2850678563,
-0.8207125664,
-0.0889088735,
-0.0570014119,
-0.1077174395,
-0.3318411112,
0.3293268979,
-0.4121965766,
-0.0883454233,
0.0587807782,
0.0941938236,
-0.2585490942,
0.5312430859,
0.0943071768,
0.5429707766,
0.2786206305,
-0.2233474404,
0.0959431529,
0.3261059821,
-0.2235945761,
0.2715238631,
-0.5662727952,
0.1538643092,
0.3739066422,
0.0033345497,
-0.395216763,
-0.0820246413,
0.1578749567,
-0.4971418679,
0.316204071,
-0.1497546285,
0.102047801,
-0.3683941364,
-0.0734656528,
0.330183655,
0.6358286738,
0.2037833035,
0.5115969777,
0.3990836143,
-0.14385432,
-0.7668046355,
-0.5224660039,
0.006832201,
-0.0831043348,
-0.3780686259,
0.2406894565,
-0.2006793469,
-0.1174448878,
-0.0273215752,
0.1131512076,
-0.2285523117,
-0.022765791,
0.186973244,
0.0705212578,
-0.3563775122,
-0.0279493798,
-0.1484757215,
-0.2724836767,
-0.0670553148,
0.3079126477,
0.6343715191,
-0.4627778828,
-0.5635563135,
-0.2581461072,
0.2124523371,
0.288847357,
-0.1498117596,
0.1206623241,
0.3361621201,
-0.4222640693,
0.2340768576,
-0.6199094057,
-0.4593961835,
-0.410885632,
0.5181638002,
-0.2528762519,
-0.9211116433,
0.4837563634,
-0.0003696278,
0.0193191096,
0.3246000409,
0.911701262,
0.2895723879,
0.8582603335,
0.2876704931,
0.2746715844,
0.445412457,
-0.4449603558,
0.2287059128,
-0.5552539825,
-0.3385582566,
-0.3701370656,
0.0504575372,
-0.6579785943,
-0.5461066961,
0.7801107764,
-0.59178859,
-0.5135161877,
-0.1127557009,
-0.7946177125,
0.5145388246,
0.547197938,
0.4382367134,
0.4855438173,
-0.2573410869,
-0.0795408711,
-0.1073152125,
-1.0171073675,
-0.2672539055,
1.233540535,
0.5341145396,
0.2187394202,
0.0488357469,
0.4016023278,
0.2749422789,
0.236223042,
-0.6823318005,
0.3654580116,
-0.0243742354,
-0.8636847734,
-0.0817279667,
-0.5444040298,
-1.1522153616,
0.3219094872,
-0.3588218391,
-0.4068237841,
-0.0772943869,
0.0530677997,
-0.4267044365,
0.0329119898,
-0.7969600558,
1.0422586203,
-0.2634451687,
-0.153877154,
-0.0999077708,
-0.7334814072,
0.1278364658,
-0.0983113423,
0.1541631967,
-0.2402247787,
-0.0705161244,
0.6516666412,
-0.1796043813,
0.451872915,
-0.2243548036,
0.561999619,
0.1485485435,
-0.1203707084,
-0.0190700311,
-0.0850163698,
-0.2174969316,
0.2280988693,
0.1185520962,
-0.1890894473,
-0.2739488184,
0.4871391356,
-1.0119923353,
-0.3453062773,
-0.748984158,
-0.4557643533,
-0.4629180729,
0.4791543186,
0.6751821637,
0.7460432649,
-0.3965960145,
-0.0484104678,
0.468257159,
-0.2053097188,
0.0855698586,
0.6034825444,
0.0092954142,
-0.2229380757,
0.7358367443,
0.196887508,
0.3232907057,
0.3425761759,
0.4106488228,
-0.1336387098,
-0.9131487608,
-0.1692180187,
0.1559666246,
-0.821521759,
-0.4139673114,
-0.8249979019,
-0.6381774545,
-0.0844182894,
-0.1985591501,
-0.3452092111,
-0.2151233107,
0.2416185588,
0.0222517699,
0.5250895023,
0.6869934201,
0.0498407967,
0.3410608768,
-0.5556266904,
-0.1612541378,
0.2537764311,
0.3861545622,
-0.2870432734,
-0.4873246849,
-0.090195246,
-0.0289206877,
-0.6990495324,
-0.6408065557,
0.2148453295,
0.2153900862,
0.5676269531,
0.431720376,
-0.1674274355,
0.4426271915,
-0.4625105858,
0.5112086535,
0.2215651274,
-0.6025691032,
0.4512099028,
-0.7015573382,
0.178775236,
0.4665727913,
0.3129712045,
-0.6059172153,
-0.6283024549,
-0.7561131716,
-0.4030372202,
0.8870665431,
0.6319633126,
-0.0074991966,
0.0592455417,
0.3112204075,
0.0214714743,
-0.018636914,
-0.7789812088,
-0.2220008373,
-0.3154973388,
-0.1132124886,
0.3080150485,
-0.1794797331,
-0.3275029361,
-0.0296292733,
0.7160164714,
0.0674877688,
0.7804445624,
0.2062158585,
0.4264966249,
-0.0663783625,
0.3387424648,
0.3879330456,
0.6264979839,
-0.5843358636,
-0.1374246329,
0.463003844,
-0.8187888861,
-0.0794390365,
0.1826433092,
0.1970198154,
-0.2639723718,
0.4659687281,
0.4705447555,
0.1346478462,
-0.5501389503,
0.6885490417,
-0.526609242,
-0.2826793492,
-0.1646315753,
0.2598052621,
-0.2337620705,
0.3030458987,
0.1314120442,
0.2405061424,
0.4825063646,
-0.4102246463,
0.1281937361,
0.3070211709,
-0.5704866648,
-0.072229661,
0.5267388821,
0.1675361097,
-0.0140994145,
0.3715626597,
0.0680376738,
-0.6347239017,
0.6690211296,
0.4739902914,
0.2418465912,
-0.3547490835,
0.0343278311,
0.6878118515,
0.1179262772,
-0.2414309531,
0.3625538647,
0.2143441737,
-0.8516817689,
-0.0815311372,
-0.2030629963,
-0.8715615273,
-0.1517332196,
-0.3948418498,
0.4614217877,
-0.6652556062,
-0.3758024573,
-0.0624577962,
0.379468292,
-0.4837587178,
0.5666605234,
-0.0650379211,
0.5936280489,
-0.5084071159,
0.7980363965,
0.5802935958,
-0.3450579643,
-1.0349568129,
-0.2996867597,
0.1827195138,
-0.8344566226,
0.2075229436,
0.1223997548,
-0.0679263994,
0.0972553939,
0.0524886437,
-0.8852635026,
1.3507319689,
0.2742598653,
-0.320789367,
0.1209393069,
-0.0267487783,
0.6812314391,
-0.1261872947,
0.9262627959,
0.6954741478,
0.3240130842,
0.3004541397,
-1.0447126627,
-0.0043229689,
-0.1744038016,
-0.1474876404,
0.1592803299,
-0.894923389,
0.8699839711,
-0.2279317528,
-0.3664947748,
-0.0668063164,
-0.0018173716,
0.1998197734,
0.4092325866,
0.2342296243,
0.4324528873,
0.7341284156,
-0.5193322897,
1.2110364437,
-0.2630403936,
0.4905013144,
0.4266518354,
-0.0011704655,
0.5439058542,
0.1177236959,
-0.4606207609,
0.2504635453,
0.6021448374,
-0.1314470023,
0.6600590348,
-0.2713804543,
-0.3145032525,
-0.0842666775,
0.0438564755,
-0.7833180428,
0.5888329148,
0.3386454284,
-0.0574015938,
-0.2055017948,
0.0078830766,
0.3282061815,
-0.0345267951,
-0.2430691868,
0.635032475,
0.1754263192,
-0.6909176707,
0.3921546638,
-0.103478387,
0.3917842507,
-0.8786761165,
-0.1186017543,
-0.2896611094,
0.4502676427,
-0.2562378645,
-0.6416828036,
0.3088710904,
0.0469733775,
0.2742790282,
-0.075907588,
0.6369624734,
-0.1489323527,
-0.4020724595,
0.202058807,
0.4129186571,
0.4034424126,
0.3852404952,
-0.78616786,
0.035936214,
0.2202747315,
-0.2827821374,
0.2627032101,
0.414939791,
0.1423660815,
0.8450418711,
0.3967098296,
0.2785047591,
-0.26348719,
-0.0583017543,
0.759834528,
-0.5364344716,
-0.4586038589,
-0.7228975296,
-0.0181788076,
-0.1225735992,
-0.5755413771,
0.6485417485,
0.412706852,
0.5417476296,
0.3450464904,
0.7066158056,
-0.0941495448,
0.5937910676,
-0.7303268313,
0.8345607519,
-0.2601873577,
0.3466044366,
-0.3617510498,
-0.6576359272,
-0.6173685789,
0.8338565826,
-0.5774985552,
0.5288407803,
0.902629137,
0.6472341418,
0.1128038019,
0.1892127395,
0.5408502221,
0.3405680358,
0.4323794842,
0.9238396287,
0.6535759568,
-0.5125430822,
0.6447086334,
-0.3101193011,
-0.4877289534,
-0.1906099916,
-0.7048060894,
-0.8754919767,
-0.3831465244,
-0.2747554779,
-0.160357222,
0.1636979282,
0.8542354703,
0.8491029143,
-0.6707400084,
-0.100446336,
0.0188345984,
-0.1958850771,
-0.1795191914,
-0.1216840744,
0.4952938259,
-0.0659388825,
-0.4150002599,
0.1541834176,
0.3136617839,
0.0092817061,
0.2212431431,
-0.1429766268,
-0.0759414732,
-0.0768420324,
0.3074881136,
0.2694817781,
-0.4301226437,
-0.2462999374,
-0.0809913725,
-0.2150535136,
0.4469812512,
0.6514531374,
-0.6561276317,
0.5716207623,
0.1113113761,
0.430739224,
0.5988495946,
-0.1376694739,
0.6147920489,
-0.2683662176,
0.0338177904,
0.6297078729,
0.4387993813,
0.3175192773,
-0.3885940015,
0.6955547333,
0.1434884667,
-1.090642333,
-0.5052153468,
-0.0634846836,
-1.1218922138,
-0.2361757159,
1.1130415201,
-0.2963237464,
0.2382256091,
-0.5302382708,
-0.4468738139,
0.3881461918,
-0.4501902461,
0.8072293997,
0.3836315572,
-0.5034649372,
-0.3164336085,
-1.0011667013,
0.7409182191,
0.4096847773,
-0.8754409552,
-0.1921272427,
0.392664969,
0.3659308255,
-0.1500570029,
1.2100893259,
-0.3793831766,
0.6172230244,
0.177009955,
0.118979834,
-0.282645613,
0.1941730827,
-0.1989287287,
0.0730674118,
0.1716825664,
-0.1720488816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11943v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11943v1 | Constructing Tree-based Index for Efficient and Effective Dense Retrieval | 2023-04-24T09:25:39 | 2023-04-24T09:25:39 | Haitao Li, Qingyao Ai, Jingtao Zhan, Jiaxin Mao, Yiqun Liu, Zheng Liu, Zhao Cao | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recent studies have shown that Dense Retrieval (DR) techniques can
significantly improve the performance of first-stage retrieval in IR systems.
Despite its empirical effectiveness, the application of DR is still limited. In
contrast to statistic retrieval models that rely on highly efficient inverted
index solutions, DR models build dense embeddings that are difficult to be
pre-processed with most existing search indexing systems. To avoid the
expensive cost of brute-force search, the Approximate Nearest Neighbor (ANN)
algorithm and corresponding indexes are widely applied to speed up the
inference process of DR models. Unfortunately, while ANN can improve the
efficiency of DR models, it usually comes with a significant price on retrieval
performance.
To solve this issue, we propose JTR, which stands for Joint optimization of
TRee-based index and query encoding. Specifically, we design a new unified
contrastive learning loss to train tree-based index and query encoder in an
end-to-end manner. The tree-based negative sampling strategy is applied to make
the tree have the maximum heap property, which supports the effectiveness of
beam search well. Moreover, we treat the cluster assignment as an optimization
problem to update the tree-based index that allows overlapped clustering. We
evaluate JTR on numerous popular retrieval benchmarks. Experimental results
show that JTR achieves better retrieval performance while retaining high system
efficiency compared with widely-adopted baselines. It provides a potential
solution to balance efficiency and effectiveness in neural retrieval system
designs. | [
-0.1661321074,
-0.7296857834,
0.307834059,
-0.1958442479,
-0.3401635587,
0.0630778745,
-0.16311571,
-0.4952832162,
0.2948549688,
-0.0069752824,
-0.0565638021,
-0.4663783312,
-0.4058280289,
0.0992736146,
-0.3696779311,
0.6652688384,
0.2687505782,
-0.0945083573,
0.0516391061,
-0.5049688816,
-0.2762731612,
-0.4247277677,
-0.6891028285,
-0.0470110811,
0.8269432783,
0.1791277677,
0.7859814167,
0.6447275281,
0.7582463622,
0.3742122054,
-0.430760622,
0.004470712,
-0.6543747187,
0.1152419671,
-0.0628636405,
-0.6827297211,
0.0263342895,
-0.4836659133,
0.773358047,
0.7945892215,
-0.3767612875,
-0.0238431562,
-0.0289499965,
0.9619444013,
-0.9135094285,
-0.123803094,
-0.7395638824,
0.4888478816,
-0.4541404545,
-0.6718111038,
-0.5302817822,
-0.4311327636,
0.2298470736,
-0.5833293796,
0.242508918,
0.2207527459,
0.8320078254,
0.2642764151,
-0.3905479312,
0.1113554463,
-0.4551197588,
0.7459871173,
-0.5056819916,
0.5840231776,
0.1262159497,
0.4385097027,
-0.0765010566,
-0.5822187066,
-0.1277607381,
-0.1625054181,
-0.3661823869,
0.0757788047,
-0.3439675272,
0.3518249393,
0.0871950239,
0.1605856121,
-0.7771181464,
-0.0035618143,
-0.0017941736,
0.0302868076,
0.1416036785,
0.2819747329,
0.0309487991,
-0.2871219814,
-0.1182166785,
-0.5312339664,
-0.3901023269,
-0.1860821098,
0.0465934575,
0.5324095488,
0.342918098,
0.6146358848,
-0.3786238432,
0.6257576942,
-0.050044544,
-0.0554416887,
0.0943803638,
-0.3937131464,
-0.1628835797,
0.1338997334,
0.3649035692,
0.3227312267,
-0.0784678459,
-0.2585511208,
-0.4442901611,
-0.003903772,
0.1461852789,
-1.0344268084,
-0.1530451477,
-0.2623924017,
-0.7701157331,
-0.1094906107,
0.1086733788,
-0.7296890616,
0.09185303,
-0.13111718,
0.7190945745,
-0.4474245012,
-0.3762172759,
-0.0059225145,
-0.1633023918,
0.1566170603,
0.1438425928,
-0.5778388977,
0.4445644617,
0.3540528417,
0.8706847429,
0.1428704262,
0.2615913153,
-0.4949577153,
0.0754564703,
-0.4044662714,
0.4857615232,
-0.8873172998,
-0.3887212574,
-0.2033161074,
-0.4367025197,
-0.1095365733,
-0.7595224977,
0.2662344873,
-0.9436826706,
0.1503083557,
-0.0630431995,
-0.2859067321,
-0.18701379,
0.2607960999,
-0.60352844,
1.0632213354,
0.3433692753,
-1.0514823198,
0.3385820091,
-0.8040623665,
-0.3589078486,
0.2307485342,
-0.1666268706,
-0.5139992237,
0.3547314107,
0.3625089526,
0.0072078584,
-0.2129755616,
0.1496762782,
-0.1008690372,
-0.8011459112,
-0.2272548974,
-0.3705785573,
0.5986352563,
0.5998646617,
-0.1444730461,
-0.1043045074,
-0.3368749619,
0.4162487984,
0.2475733608,
-0.2058712542,
-0.9347724915,
-0.0528504513,
-0.0815547556,
-0.4456855953,
0.1646664441,
-0.4612947404,
0.1965416074,
-0.3564573824,
0.0395822264,
0.5541753769,
-0.1342992932,
0.288258791,
-0.1621910036,
0.523527503,
0.1220874563,
0.1799398065,
-0.1452624053,
-0.1153431535,
-0.5737540722,
0.1070549637,
0.6146124005,
0.2563395798,
-0.6403480172,
0.4241369069,
-0.4013184011,
-0.4115490019,
-0.7374559045,
-0.3069580495,
0.6045852304,
0.5878712535,
0.4686169922,
-0.5540626645,
-0.7754584551,
-0.9298615456,
-0.0395769663,
-0.1296418756,
0.2358718812,
0.6330053806,
0.2926971912,
-0.0036771682,
0.8851463795,
-0.6192523837,
-0.3212656975,
-0.155267626,
0.1088913679,
0.5112025142,
0.5027503967,
0.3164771795,
-1.0674064159,
-0.7009920478,
0.2239971012,
-0.6268879175,
0.1063927412,
0.0693744943,
-0.0121321967,
0.1512865275,
0.4113371372,
-0.3938140869,
0.4509698749,
0.142793864,
-0.1294296831,
0.1054729,
-0.3215419054,
0.3415802121,
-0.8346060514,
0.4338723421,
-0.0073765614,
-0.1154202148,
-0.1512923241,
0.3401933312,
0.0706261769,
-0.0423763506,
-0.2136824578,
0.1723768413,
-0.5304450989,
-0.4367850125,
0.002032503,
0.0208262652,
0.0511350594,
0.416338712,
-0.3796131611,
1.0200414658,
0.2060779482,
-0.4739491045,
-0.2926174402,
0.2484902143,
-0.5258683562,
0.6939275265,
-0.5802121758,
0.1061278656,
-0.6178246737,
0.3123557568,
-0.6110016704,
0.1621328294,
-0.1370055974,
-0.2601325214,
0.6303024888,
-0.4712659419,
-0.4316693246,
-0.5110569,
-0.3230265081,
0.5792235136,
0.5500041842,
-0.8541867137,
0.4076534212,
0.2484729439,
0.134215489,
-0.9100077152,
-0.5640565157,
0.1216907352,
-0.3222691715,
-0.5085036755,
0.7994476557,
-0.024985427,
0.1091659516,
0.4766232967,
-0.3478984833,
-0.0481358469,
0.1243697107,
-0.2711459696,
-0.14567931,
-0.4927119613,
0.0808728039,
0.0678625181,
-0.2863518,
-0.2815837264,
-0.1237929091,
0.327919811,
-0.1552051157,
-0.4442366958,
-0.5188382268,
0.4028282464,
0.1874920726,
-0.2123498768,
0.3792569339,
0.3969260752,
-0.1741334498,
-0.1167033315,
-0.6108385324,
-0.2969293892,
-0.5146741271,
0.8708692789,
-0.6994473338,
-0.9084659815,
0.2781554163,
-0.1458434612,
-0.4155374467,
0.41427809,
-0.0910751969,
-0.0837788358,
1.491953373,
0.5551496148,
-0.1009262726,
0.6670578122,
-0.4513611197,
0.1706305891,
-0.9406585693,
-0.3646540046,
-0.8433853388,
-0.6652500033,
-0.5847764015,
-0.2692634463,
0.7953009605,
0.165073961,
-0.2559131384,
0.3387039602,
-1.0489135981,
0.8780795932,
0.6766488552,
0.2781983912,
0.2922575474,
0.2246378511,
-0.3720391691,
-0.3096602261,
-1.0919736624,
0.1443576664,
0.8841374516,
-0.010381218,
0.7771689296,
0.0946297422,
0.8007570505,
0.1446474195,
0.2366958559,
-0.4353370965,
0.5905057192,
-0.3435438871,
-0.4864253998,
-0.1339155734,
-0.7682273984,
-1.1829069853,
0.4744458497,
0.0657480657,
-0.4636133909,
0.1774297208,
-0.1497924328,
-0.1819967628,
0.5791277289,
-0.8046752214,
0.7563453317,
-0.2467500269,
-0.432647258,
-0.5503104925,
-0.8368718028,
0.1030253917,
0.1576487422,
-0.3040093184,
0.1926977783,
-0.0312151946,
0.789290607,
-0.4102677703,
0.4395881891,
-0.5001648068,
0.8043316007,
0.2664287388,
0.2179281861,
0.5909765959,
-0.1801151335,
-0.4122047722,
-0.2759144008,
0.0669232681,
-0.3109387755,
-0.779058814,
0.7246118188,
-0.8156061172,
-0.5866638422,
-0.4632193148,
-0.2995401025,
0.2493202686,
0.3044006228,
-0.2198181599,
0.5845313072,
-0.1473638415,
0.6230949163,
0.4282007515,
-0.156036675,
0.4619643092,
0.4880593121,
-0.0596753024,
-0.3973554075,
0.9282006025,
0.2149798423,
-0.1956637651,
0.9129016399,
0.5120637417,
-0.4544306993,
-0.992397964,
-0.1922393888,
0.0053771315,
-0.4946771562,
-0.6854314804,
-0.6373544931,
-0.3179245889,
0.2173390239,
-0.2826559842,
-0.3623384535,
-0.1636979431,
0.013907386,
0.0908886567,
0.3823426962,
0.5833389163,
-0.2220867574,
0.2092955261,
-0.6393333673,
0.0478917994,
0.1321632564,
0.707642138,
0.3826963603,
-0.3256624341,
-0.4591486752,
-0.1686950922,
-0.1903486252,
-0.2833405137,
0.5417456627,
0.2113772184,
0.5285928845,
0.1985983104,
0.2174786478,
1.3237234354,
-0.2252282649,
0.2194571495,
-0.0026029763,
-0.4292942286,
0.453597337,
0.0409619734,
0.4327981174,
1.0863752365,
0.391104877,
-0.3501748741,
0.0204245429,
-0.4474301636,
-0.8719393015,
0.8669807911,
0.1362218261,
0.1027834937,
-0.1426271051,
0.2706139386,
0.0472340472,
-0.0770519227,
-0.4879944921,
-0.192021668,
0.0544871241,
-0.3025981486,
0.4346743226,
-0.248820737,
0.0748105198,
-0.3762384355,
0.5119839907,
-0.1199071109,
0.3201255202,
0.5600388646,
-0.1068985462,
-0.441806078,
0.0756030753,
-0.0864494592,
0.2300521135,
-0.8476381302,
0.198009029,
0.1744011492,
-0.168978408,
-0.0052554114,
0.2150453627,
-0.389895618,
0.0153018674,
0.0295390338,
0.458955884,
0.288095057,
-0.5002504587,
0.4818190038,
-0.0679288283,
-0.0433987081,
-0.0938787907,
-0.0275180023,
-0.1882384866,
0.213287428,
0.7121795416,
0.1414855421,
0.4560101032,
-0.3139246106,
0.4594772458,
0.8090108633,
-0.3070624471,
-0.101524137,
0.6130293012,
0.1326264441,
-0.2973602712,
0.917829752,
-0.1657208651,
-0.4304250479,
0.5764766335,
0.6162801385,
0.7891073823,
-0.1031791195,
-0.0795594156,
0.7131518126,
0.0751050115,
0.0964944214,
0.150426358,
-0.3017815948,
-0.3003242016,
-0.4888957441,
-0.6576613784,
-0.2876162231,
-0.1576371193,
-0.4561881423,
0.106299445,
-0.187210083,
-0.0153603461,
-0.2498124838,
0.274964571,
-0.6169986129,
0.1330888271,
-0.2199487537,
0.8600530028,
-0.2939061224,
0.6788288951,
0.3099042475,
-0.4243927002,
-0.6175419092,
-0.2903566062,
-0.3232358694,
-0.642790854,
0.6846250296,
0.4665938318,
0.0328084193,
0.179430142,
-0.2543633282,
-1.1497710943,
1.2534633875,
0.0998247787,
-0.7414603829,
-0.207465589,
-0.1144272834,
0.5906425118,
-0.267101258,
1.1559787989,
0.1707590669,
0.5487290621,
0.1140486449,
-0.5952931046,
-0.017875405,
-0.310190767,
0.4590360522,
0.6404106021,
-0.6133392453,
0.3489982486,
-0.189922452,
-0.4900721908,
0.3276466131,
0.4869751036,
0.0206529368,
0.4901080728,
0.714030087,
0.8842019439,
0.5035845637,
0.0790508986,
1.1956663132,
-0.36013183,
0.2134007663,
0.893221736,
-0.0630826205,
0.9191439748,
0.4533216059,
-0.3489626348,
0.2906138897,
0.4323437214,
0.0845765918,
0.8522666693,
0.3385409415,
-0.1976870894,
-0.0141224321,
-0.5359498858,
-0.564212203,
0.3040396273,
0.2602125704,
-0.3719561696,
-0.466116786,
-0.4828095436,
-0.3034279943,
0.25558272,
-0.0414976142,
0.7338261008,
-0.1282488704,
-0.5332427025,
0.5744637847,
-0.0165444594,
0.8725948334,
-0.7162996531,
-0.1256691068,
-0.4100398421,
0.0968164355,
-0.2072161734,
-0.4263681769,
0.3420945704,
-0.3792376518,
0.0950700566,
-0.1466858685,
0.4680718184,
-0.3586215079,
-0.3986025453,
0.4722122252,
0.543849051,
0.2168022841,
0.1286406964,
-0.8646140099,
0.1121579334,
0.0283749364,
-0.4408645034,
0.5666709542,
0.4228567779,
0.0236923806,
0.4930213094,
0.6201991439,
-0.0777283907,
-0.2350910753,
0.248231858,
1.0263992548,
-0.9007021189,
-0.1980725974,
-0.415576458,
0.3387630284,
0.0056265122,
-0.0623619705,
0.3060490787,
0.8635058999,
0.8878823519,
0.3494926095,
0.2525464594,
-0.2940837443,
0.5313901901,
-0.2617569566,
0.5185911059,
-0.9213654399,
0.1889107972,
-0.2560638487,
-1.2864969969,
-0.6596847177,
0.6081845164,
0.1126536354,
0.4346249998,
0.7555023432,
1.2401605844,
-0.3918784857,
-0.0827025548,
0.5160075426,
0.4328228235,
0.2893067002,
0.7505845428,
0.5628095269,
-0.5792683363,
0.8784796,
-0.4879936874,
0.0310240407,
-0.5271834731,
-0.6981509328,
-0.3946253061,
-0.4563986957,
-0.2199760228,
-0.0311181713,
0.6086494923,
0.8468769789,
0.8168850541,
-0.455519855,
-0.0608186536,
-0.2628715038,
0.0777973756,
-0.1251170337,
-0.2956662774,
0.7129696608,
-0.3424430788,
-0.5810213089,
0.6330033541,
0.2953268588,
-0.1486200988,
0.0866876915,
-0.1285615414,
-0.3826776445,
-0.4818507135,
0.4018959701,
0.1739428192,
-0.5179834962,
-0.557149291,
0.0593472198,
-0.1351051033,
0.3979656696,
0.5690758824,
-1.3155198097,
0.8268470168,
0.4671947956,
0.9456296563,
0.8433230519,
0.1644727886,
0.2800545394,
-0.5480683446,
0.0627451092,
0.6352921724,
0.1648761779,
0.4674974084,
-0.1749266535,
0.9115807414,
0.0806185603,
-0.5454189181,
-0.8561455607,
-0.1801903993,
-0.9787351489,
-0.1529510319,
0.6138499379,
0.3488317132,
-0.4360577464,
-0.01754543,
-0.2527728975,
0.2389943749,
-0.6787773967,
0.7666076422,
-0.0124575356,
-0.023376625,
-0.1486366093,
-0.1537173688,
0.1585267037,
1.082567811,
-0.1354543418,
-0.1969028115,
0.1884461194,
-0.0440499038,
0.0772110447,
0.5338164568,
-0.3211784959,
0.1271093786,
0.0785016567,
-0.0467285663,
-0.2768591642,
-0.323494643,
-0.1900309175,
0.4548304379,
0.1969982535,
-0.0869189948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12331v1 | USTEP: Structuration des logs en flux gr{â}ce {à} un arbre de recherche {é}volutif | 2023-04-24T09:12:00 | 2023-04-24T09:12:00 | Arthur Vervaet, Raja Chiky, Mar Callau-Zori | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Logs record valuable system information at runtime. They are widely used by
data-driven approaches for development and monitoring purposes. Parsing log
messages to structure their format is a classic preliminary step for log-mining
tasks. As they appear upstream, parsing operations can become a processing time
bottleneck for downstream applications. The quality of parsing also has a
direct influence on their efficiency. Here, we propose USTEP, an online log
parsing method based on an evolving tree structure. Evaluation results on a
wide panel of datasets coming from different real-world systems demonstrate
USTEP superiority in terms of both effectiveness and robustness when compared
to other online methods. | [
-0.0121801486,
-0.5891574621,
0.3837620914,
0.4294745028,
-0.4857623279,
0.5035994649,
0.0108016683,
-0.8408020139,
0.34236449,
-0.0261761304,
-0.4858087003,
-0.5491802096,
-0.2767006159,
0.0335418656,
-0.3491615355,
0.785998702,
0.1593980491,
-0.1554706991,
-0.0412436314,
-0.0385279842,
-0.4543143809,
-0.6071835756,
-0.9460048676,
-0.1991369426,
0.1212064549,
0.1440540701,
0.5692682862,
0.7259842157,
0.3464067876,
0.4299545884,
-0.2702405453,
0.0047382726,
-0.3787088692,
0.670575738,
-0.180674389,
-0.6005859375,
-0.5683827996,
-0.561384201,
0.3642171025,
0.6607866287,
-0.5401301384,
0.3276644051,
0.1375394315,
0.7008433342,
-0.5853737593,
0.1048392132,
-0.741209209,
0.2817045748,
-0.1893704981,
-0.4647753537,
-0.541279614,
-0.1783069521,
-0.1002631783,
-0.2577460706,
0.4635791481,
-0.1409897208,
1.1255780458,
0.1370996982,
-0.0009262373,
-0.3360643387,
-0.3427780271,
0.5857998729,
-0.8661146164,
0.6048170924,
0.3543800414,
0.3891801238,
-0.4224651456,
-1.1468675137,
0.2467801422,
0.1931622028,
-0.3375046551,
-0.1215458959,
-0.1328840107,
-0.1139270812,
0.1506580561,
0.4613452554,
-0.5723438263,
0.175887689,
-0.2286763787,
-0.361163646,
0.6611239314,
0.1478110403,
0.2954477072,
-0.1291095316,
-0.3617328405,
-0.3019223213,
-0.366785109,
0.3484338522,
0.1790642738,
0.2807192504,
0.0813381523,
0.2330958843,
-0.4880920351,
0.7000290155,
0.1157595664,
-0.1049331874,
-0.0613014102,
0.1021752432,
-0.5396820307,
0.108795099,
0.4339473844,
0.5165135264,
-0.3448159993,
-0.1408448517,
-0.375199914,
0.0380490758,
0.1406294256,
-0.7672436237,
-0.5370611548,
0.3308391869,
-0.589717567,
-0.3862632811,
0.0306405481,
-1.0684708357,
-0.0797732845,
0.1841389835,
0.1104308888,
-0.1490379572,
-0.320412904,
0.1637320668,
-0.1131257638,
-0.000854042,
0.1805574894,
-1.0621920824,
0.3874275684,
0.5971527696,
1.1112170219,
0.0457410887,
0.1274514645,
-1.0984318256,
-0.0693808421,
-0.0588124879,
1.0075296164,
-0.5910218358,
-0.2266998291,
-0.2319364846,
-0.2457404882,
-0.0744995922,
-0.4725199044,
0.8762853146,
-0.7713514566,
-0.0117804063,
0.0790650994,
-0.5198889971,
-0.2064703703,
0.0723582804,
-0.6971532106,
1.2619862556,
0.4483387768,
-0.7820416689,
0.5682252049,
-0.7078502774,
-0.0933781043,
0.3086409569,
-0.0042899777,
-0.4149270356,
0.5143156648,
0.4507910311,
0.6478537321,
0.0461422056,
0.5322734714,
-0.1063707694,
0.2035012692,
-0.2686448991,
-0.102380909,
1.0789967775,
0.7446869612,
-0.2728015184,
-0.0793842971,
-0.6315336227,
0.486946702,
0.1983537972,
-0.3124009967,
-0.3702198565,
0.4238286316,
0.0803431645,
0.1200192645,
0.2066548467,
-0.7562624812,
0.2527575791,
-0.3624230623,
0.6672127843,
0.6083639264,
-0.0237552058,
0.0638459325,
-0.00659033,
0.275775969,
-0.1340079606,
0.2567141652,
-0.4645965695,
-0.4356376231,
-0.7633085251,
-0.1987546086,
0.239036262,
0.5362282395,
0.094005689,
0.4813425541,
-0.3603661358,
-0.4937907159,
-0.0645412207,
0.180793941,
0.1306127608,
0.1323986799,
0.5314925313,
-0.3184165955,
-0.6077541113,
-0.713960588,
-0.5635017753,
-0.3229187131,
-0.3320858181,
0.0334275961,
0.0190478023,
-0.3370119035,
0.9004797339,
-0.755207479,
-0.0497146174,
-0.3703706264,
0.0763453543,
0.2006044686,
0.3481720388,
0.3853575885,
-0.4922696352,
-0.7223264575,
0.2645822763,
-0.6201975942,
-0.4334292114,
-0.4094229639,
-0.0414362699,
0.1255290508,
0.44014588,
-0.4190312922,
0.3707972467,
0.5793135166,
-1.0181826353,
-0.2160408944,
-0.0921351835,
0.1228599995,
-0.748169899,
-0.1834921092,
-0.3012607694,
-0.8791902661,
-0.4885933399,
0.4274334311,
0.0528255738,
0.028284803,
-0.3594037592,
0.0329586715,
-0.3936247826,
-0.4070455134,
0.3512049913,
0.0309483353,
0.3370985687,
0.4457732737,
-0.0438181087,
0.0492787175,
0.3532532752,
-0.5477702022,
0.5194467902,
-0.0122609474,
-0.1321038753,
0.5599864721,
-0.4077278674,
0.2377112061,
0.0251852088,
-0.0078853955,
-0.8100199103,
-0.0336262211,
-0.220778048,
-0.3906854093,
0.5376247764,
-0.1915317923,
-0.3104529083,
-0.071885027,
-0.4946576357,
0.3272334933,
0.1981351078,
-0.756088078,
0.5455377102,
0.3379918337,
-0.0277934074,
0.0633594394,
-0.3567779064,
0.1540925801,
-0.6237465739,
-1.09433043,
0.3211374581,
0.1761687696,
-0.2000413388,
-0.2492561787,
-0.5352967381,
-0.3318988979,
0.2625772059,
-0.046581205,
-0.0521726422,
-0.4109463096,
-0.201023683,
-0.0856435224,
-0.1443869919,
-0.2270614207,
-0.2021641433,
0.6107501984,
-0.3846444488,
-0.0779711455,
-0.7228111625,
0.5526487827,
0.2602919042,
0.023497019,
0.3107219934,
0.109322153,
-0.3745996356,
-0.3404686153,
-0.4287513196,
-0.1914856583,
-0.5183398724,
0.0801697448,
-0.4431785941,
-0.8102237582,
0.3319986165,
-0.3004589677,
0.5335424542,
0.7587097287,
-0.1022905707,
-0.2978951931,
1.1085022688,
0.7012340426,
0.0349664763,
0.2599005699,
-0.1620692462,
0.1965777278,
-0.2894687057,
-0.4090795517,
-0.7431331873,
-0.5662472844,
-0.3478663862,
-0.1833087206,
-0.1664705127,
0.7974358797,
0.0657544881,
0.6829962134,
-0.7199975252,
0.4096982479,
0.1106618345,
-0.0923594385,
0.6611863375,
0.2808644474,
0.0358332507,
-0.2706558704,
-0.8071106076,
-0.5139295459,
0.7114711404,
0.6538594961,
0.6003673673,
0.0085950224,
0.5999266505,
0.5307598114,
0.2536704242,
-0.4538696408,
0.3888180852,
0.193773672,
-0.409319967,
-0.310328573,
-0.2863570154,
-0.8738946319,
0.4521019757,
-0.008251776,
-1.085848093,
-0.1123612598,
0.4741361141,
-0.1178766116,
0.6346439123,
-0.9583401084,
0.9633489251,
-0.5016207695,
-0.0660435706,
-0.3158904612,
-0.5016073585,
0.0913164839,
0.0834004954,
0.3463728428,
-0.1276022345,
-0.0755381659,
0.7304114103,
-0.628010571,
0.841742456,
-0.3717666268,
0.0367328599,
0.5141489506,
0.4141447246,
0.857074976,
0.329837352,
0.1473276317,
0.445872128,
0.4281146824,
-0.4610111117,
-0.3697253466,
0.7098160386,
-0.4291790128,
-0.2064142078,
-0.7073019743,
0.1660779566,
0.0195299536,
-0.0933893844,
0.2526295483,
0.4904899597,
-0.1771072894,
0.317653954,
-0.0008569588,
0.0577695295,
0.8606567383,
0.2376671135,
-0.3216689527,
-0.1500947773,
0.6311041117,
-0.1693653762,
0.1807578653,
0.6495191455,
0.3133304715,
-0.4191742837,
-0.4786955416,
-0.466822803,
-0.1526565552,
-0.5494928956,
-0.8092830777,
-0.7960812449,
-0.123169817,
0.1861917228,
-0.327875644,
-0.5442165732,
-0.8087704182,
-0.0817189962,
-0.3442046344,
0.4997484982,
0.6972463131,
-0.0872482657,
0.4876455963,
-1.0540909767,
0.0838889629,
0.2937727571,
0.7263855338,
-0.2032093704,
-0.2067982852,
-0.1274791658,
0.019558575,
-0.6545699835,
-0.91858989,
0.4163006842,
0.6579708457,
0.5023242235,
0.5048432946,
0.0427905247,
0.8549435139,
-0.2805181444,
0.6445736289,
0.1565866023,
-0.9792445302,
0.8616653681,
-0.0462040193,
-0.0466480143,
0.4689526856,
0.1579758078,
-0.552159369,
-0.4285138249,
-1.0939860344,
-0.9124727249,
0.8015120625,
0.4662297368,
-0.211617589,
0.1060674191,
0.2003659904,
0.1772754937,
-0.0118108429,
-0.7293350101,
-0.0570498742,
-0.3923044503,
0.0714384168,
0.1774358898,
-0.2134727091,
0.3011479676,
-0.102277495,
0.2930749655,
0.1142910197,
0.0295304582,
0.2823893726,
-0.3741363883,
-0.1253225058,
0.2961583138,
0.3284358382,
0.7511174083,
-0.2788401544,
0.4508853257,
0.3949623704,
-0.6210318804,
-0.0174107458,
-0.5498725176,
-0.2123109102,
0.1739318669,
0.5965556502,
0.5722324848,
0.0904591531,
-0.7714393139,
0.265350163,
-0.1036732644,
0.0673394576,
0.0074525736,
0.1649324298,
0.0394712687,
0.3592653573,
0.3088839054,
-0.0579475686,
0.2751350105,
-0.3863222897,
0.2457798868,
0.3501029611,
-0.1802005023,
-0.6907168031,
0.526833117,
0.3984470069,
-0.6306622624,
0.3982780576,
-0.1486285776,
-0.4058671892,
0.270667702,
0.8198078871,
1.07835567,
-0.5310504436,
0.3472721577,
0.5915958881,
0.2678351104,
-0.0995949209,
0.1943909079,
-0.4217758179,
-0.3815862238,
-0.4988179803,
-1.185613513,
0.0721439272,
0.3767265677,
-0.5291838646,
0.3851953745,
-0.590254724,
0.0107722953,
-0.2791745067,
-0.2605733573,
-0.5044851899,
0.35546121,
-0.2090089917,
0.8350681067,
-1.003133297,
0.2948915958,
0.6052853465,
0.1211773828,
-0.4131101668,
-0.3183107972,
-0.2204104513,
-0.5065872073,
0.5008618832,
0.3913087845,
0.1277253926,
0.114411734,
-0.2680219412,
-0.8248887062,
0.9409867525,
0.1779491007,
-0.6612122655,
0.0224075038,
-0.1230613515,
0.5751997232,
-0.5009297729,
0.401516825,
0.631704092,
0.1798062921,
0.0730694607,
-0.7677301764,
0.0655171424,
-0.1239589676,
-0.0572516769,
0.6993142366,
-0.389239043,
0.5482061505,
0.0036711972,
-0.8979863524,
-0.722659409,
0.6482760906,
-0.2259341478,
0.3412539661,
0.8538281322,
0.8740722537,
0.7727801204,
0.1426436156,
0.5413656831,
0.0201976821,
0.4846494198,
0.921754539,
0.119668141,
1.2183586359,
0.452046752,
-0.618119657,
0.8305259347,
0.8920804262,
0.3278951049,
0.469881922,
0.1110202372,
-0.3356570601,
-0.4313082993,
0.1281435639,
-0.303684622,
0.3184596002,
0.5578563213,
-0.0306629408,
-0.9365575314,
-0.6504212022,
0.0483180843,
0.2505436242,
-0.3566239774,
0.7794141173,
-0.0006656236,
-0.5878318548,
0.731323123,
0.2867619097,
0.3741013706,
-0.5951609612,
-0.015942622,
-0.2453198582,
0.0393331572,
-0.7822540998,
-0.4570481181,
0.9130467772,
0.2689125836,
0.254614532,
-0.5298213959,
0.5349777341,
0.1913320422,
-0.3393091857,
0.4710094631,
0.3943104148,
0.4107922614,
-0.09863168,
-0.5234116316,
0.0222449247,
0.4827315509,
-0.3027097583,
0.2707673609,
0.2596150637,
-0.429910332,
0.4734048247,
0.8237668276,
-0.0272188969,
0.2794862986,
-0.2539199889,
1.1077593565,
-0.8725953698,
-0.8962111473,
-1.1366503239,
0.9743852615,
-0.4504797459,
-0.2064844966,
0.3654925227,
0.9420330524,
0.8700886369,
0.2705817819,
0.367643863,
-0.3577055633,
0.3551453054,
-0.5786982775,
0.3118312657,
-0.3463907242,
0.4425635338,
-0.0388782844,
-1.3452978134,
-0.267029494,
0.8236002922,
0.4855464399,
-0.441108942,
1.0598366261,
0.4196327329,
-0.3928669989,
0.290034622,
0.1679200679,
0.0789933205,
0.4918578267,
0.5829374194,
0.5773712397,
-0.3034614623,
0.5856335163,
-0.2676892281,
-0.461019367,
-0.2648308575,
-1.3643066883,
-1.1390037537,
-0.515360117,
-0.1355123669,
-0.0116333766,
-0.3114362061,
0.8434386253,
0.5180066228,
-1.0485417843,
-0.2771163881,
-0.5474562645,
-0.0791567191,
-0.1857932061,
-0.1738878638,
0.4447866976,
-0.7814998627,
-0.2556778193,
0.5932883024,
0.6191790104,
-0.1250318587,
0.0206057113,
-0.0242187548,
-0.2301232666,
-0.3369964659,
0.613275528,
0.3063336909,
-0.4662714303,
-0.4077967107,
0.0357796624,
0.1697016954,
0.2807347476,
0.7639380693,
-0.5770030022,
0.5958126187,
0.9703304768,
0.6772024632,
0.971113205,
0.2180736065,
0.5649111867,
-0.8593788743,
0.0872236118,
0.2782311738,
0.2809724212,
0.5121867061,
-0.4372494817,
0.615629673,
0.342952013,
-0.4910376072,
-0.9071612954,
0.2305282354,
-0.5984273553,
-0.0038931791,
0.5820439458,
-0.1819992661,
0.1235471144,
-0.342843771,
-0.2626435459,
-0.1440463662,
-0.6541541815,
0.5821403265,
0.7195948362,
-0.6372882724,
0.0022489561,
-0.6176406145,
0.8915431499,
0.147902742,
-1.0086482763,
0.0508819483,
0.3828163743,
0.1006679758,
0.4207974672,
0.8147454858,
0.0941106156,
-0.0888014659,
0.0817656592,
-0.2551696301,
0.3617552817,
-0.3139251173,
-0.1649693847,
0.2602100074,
0.1788518429,
-0.0643274114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11924v1 | KInITVeraAI at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Simple yet Powerful Multilingual Fine-Tuning for Persuasion Techniques Detection | 2023-04-24T09:06:43 | 2023-04-24T09:06:43 | Timo Hromadka, Timotej Smolen, Tomas Remis, Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents the best-performing solution to the SemEval 2023 Task 3
on the subtask 3 dedicated to persuasion techniques detection. Due to a high
multilingual character of the input data and a large number of 23 predicted
labels (causing a lack of labelled data for some language-label combinations),
we opted for fine-tuning pre-trained transformer-based language models.
Conducting multiple experiments, we find the best configuration, which consists
of large multilingual model (XLM-RoBERTa large) trained jointly on all input
data, with carefully calibrated confidence thresholds for seen and surprise
languages separately. Our final system performed the best on 6 out of 9
languages (including two surprise languages) and achieved highly competitive
results on the remaining three languages. | [
-0.6394683719,
-0.5923104286,
0.4203898013,
0.3855632544,
-0.3589802384,
-0.073157087,
-0.2192790955,
-0.3278639317,
0.150451079,
0.5588516593,
-0.6315490007,
-0.7124464512,
-0.679823041,
0.3838657737,
0.0733122751,
0.894254148,
0.0132920919,
0.4652021527,
0.1057172194,
-0.3413234353,
-0.459128648,
-0.501519084,
-0.7350261807,
-0.704462707,
0.5887156129,
0.9391738772,
0.4331949651,
0.0958154127,
0.2059916854,
0.3042155504,
-0.1241933331,
0.0340430476,
-0.3541056216,
0.2018416673,
-0.3628898561,
-0.7200251818,
-0.410522908,
0.0071002869,
0.3788338006,
0.4695656002,
0.1376894116,
0.0286214147,
0.2004068047,
0.6709313989,
-0.4734300077,
0.1171831638,
-0.5235734582,
-0.1214934662,
-0.3642114699,
-0.1736342162,
-0.5398609638,
-0.3554864824,
-0.2427615523,
-0.2827863991,
0.1478047073,
0.012004124,
0.8966581225,
0.0545724593,
-0.7286993861,
-0.0791756064,
-0.5420831442,
0.7651666403,
-0.5026459098,
0.6292622685,
0.6135113835,
0.3399069309,
-0.1349173784,
-0.3637724519,
-0.4903313816,
0.1280986071,
0.0857334882,
0.1638521403,
-0.6354414225,
-0.0225077812,
0.0698511302,
-0.0898558944,
-0.6200031042,
0.3717837632,
-0.3399178386,
-0.3620244861,
0.5871547461,
-0.1720377058,
-0.0763247162,
-0.3621701002,
0.0264896266,
-0.2483849078,
-0.8651011586,
-0.0806554183,
0.9459394217,
0.2374301553,
0.0590779968,
0.5315723419,
-0.6035947204,
0.5803930759,
0.1815305352,
-0.0284569394,
0.1721464247,
-0.4259607494,
-0.1384990364,
0.0897320285,
0.9293516278,
0.3940479755,
0.1784798354,
0.1805428118,
-0.0769853815,
-0.0197220929,
-0.0213048849,
-0.7029479742,
-0.557677269,
0.1934014857,
-0.5024287701,
-0.5074933171,
-0.3576709032,
-0.9192063808,
-0.5628230572,
-0.3017389774,
0.6696354747,
-0.5926923156,
-0.453809768,
0.3186941743,
0.1238093823,
0.2298159897,
0.0860369578,
-0.8095786572,
-0.0595321953,
0.7337762713,
0.4363660216,
-0.2000662535,
-0.3649717271,
-0.7268308997,
-0.0270660352,
-0.258030206,
1.0011042356,
-0.7120662332,
-0.3248668909,
-0.0273056291,
0.559215486,
-0.1458229721,
-0.4920194745,
0.9787433743,
-0.4059692323,
0.2725281715,
-0.2655863464,
-0.3820893466,
-0.4592524171,
0.5625298023,
-0.8734976053,
0.7878087163,
-0.2394188344,
-0.5401430726,
0.4230895638,
-0.694247663,
-0.7032582164,
0.033060126,
0.1445441097,
-0.6695300937,
-0.1063391194,
0.3024167717,
0.7933042645,
-0.0705611557,
0.3703110516,
-0.0291157234,
0.0329854414,
0.0531668812,
-0.5471680164,
0.6220582724,
0.3438140452,
-0.6234977245,
0.3980301023,
-0.7517513037,
-0.0989255384,
0.0674187914,
-0.1445259452,
-0.3276452124,
-0.2333656996,
-0.2402711958,
0.1269950271,
0.2182726711,
-0.7792842388,
-0.0208595861,
-0.3998524249,
0.2025685608,
0.5289264917,
0.0743655115,
0.3584994376,
-0.0965049937,
0.8435757756,
0.1064047441,
0.2823360264,
-0.1631736308,
-0.7877349854,
-1.1018271446,
0.1859977543,
0.4083044827,
0.4220517874,
-1.0571737289,
0.1196960136,
-0.3685391247,
-0.7194610238,
-0.3056667149,
-0.0196372923,
0.3621787727,
0.1868271828,
0.2557578981,
0.4273475707,
-0.6824536324,
-1.3802160025,
-0.6318199635,
-0.0494656116,
0.2591845095,
-0.1939145774,
0.7868730426,
-0.0405166633,
0.2872183621,
-0.2483991534,
-0.2816470265,
-0.512953341,
0.4720919132,
0.2746178806,
0.4405547082,
0.4670048356,
-0.9993730783,
-0.6601250172,
0.3341630101,
-0.2792681754,
-0.1267644763,
0.1441698968,
-0.2055148184,
0.4219807386,
0.4711049497,
-0.1045416147,
0.3172580898,
0.6742786169,
-0.3238660693,
0.427954644,
-0.0040054298,
0.6382867694,
-1.3092573881,
-0.2476426065,
0.0853264034,
-0.2857313752,
-0.9817236066,
0.0288634095,
0.318582803,
0.0061750091,
-0.6023944616,
0.3352820873,
-0.3346521556,
0.7259648442,
-0.3641425967,
-0.106829077,
0.1158805266,
0.5610699654,
0.203493014,
0.4302232862,
0.4803055823,
-0.6441036463,
0.3031535745,
0.1277752519,
-0.3085912764,
0.9998493791,
-0.5523807406,
0.1915710568,
-0.0492105111,
-0.1214592308,
-1.1451780796,
-0.4242895842,
0.4254661202,
-0.4152262807,
0.3130268753,
-0.3232976794,
-0.4271606207,
-0.53446877,
-0.3219041824,
0.1663857549,
0.223480925,
-0.6452900767,
0.8633854985,
0.3257033825,
-0.2474342734,
-0.3235961795,
-0.5548901558,
0.1180621609,
-0.5758747458,
-0.6224414706,
0.0871747136,
0.0688650757,
0.0950737819,
-0.5289716125,
0.185729444,
0.2863037288,
-0.1269424409,
0.1608227491,
-0.0040546213,
0.0654615536,
-0.0495401807,
0.2161958069,
-0.2952645719,
0.0815707892,
-0.0764300525,
0.6469038129,
-0.3201506734,
-0.5654191375,
-0.3755172491,
0.4392337501,
0.5798185468,
-0.0540299788,
0.6145145893,
0.8054068089,
-0.2479648441,
0.351365298,
-0.9472786784,
0.0137547981,
-0.489662677,
0.4154453874,
-0.772136569,
-0.9229556918,
0.4215939343,
-0.3900732994,
-0.1390634179,
0.5130818486,
0.5344928503,
0.209123984,
1.6379717588,
0.5517525077,
-0.1680637449,
0.1967726648,
-0.2511657774,
0.3307587802,
-0.5538234115,
-0.7610191703,
-0.8758249879,
-0.4045775235,
-0.7099990249,
-0.2934484184,
0.4703444541,
0.0306729302,
-0.0930196494,
0.5982860327,
-0.4433916509,
0.5493070483,
0.7328566909,
-0.0190336052,
0.1980974376,
0.0948172733,
-0.1620187908,
-0.1484752297,
-0.6758580208,
-0.4748884737,
0.8014873266,
0.3163340986,
0.6388360262,
0.3824678659,
0.6374804974,
-0.0747818872,
-0.0281008109,
-0.7277252674,
0.7317530513,
0.008230418,
-0.3417472541,
-0.3226846755,
-0.0911268815,
-1.3267821074,
0.34672153,
-0.0450184271,
-0.7202885151,
0.5200099349,
-0.086694248,
-0.0760262311,
0.359539032,
-0.8066751361,
0.8824473619,
-0.0460877791,
-0.4748849273,
-0.2419822216,
-0.4772114158,
0.2134076208,
-0.1331609637,
0.3690068126,
-0.2268664241,
0.1228703335,
0.98058182,
-0.1618806869,
0.839035213,
-0.3041554391,
-0.4997798204,
-0.0565092526,
0.2194283158,
0.9402644634,
-0.0919125378,
-0.2685811818,
0.0446862355,
0.2182718515,
-0.3547894061,
-0.384817183,
0.7406110764,
-0.5098538399,
-0.7508690953,
-0.2750355005,
-0.070211336,
-0.3460475504,
0.3344946206,
0.6777005792,
0.3051318228,
-0.4040520787,
0.4331278503,
0.6316264272,
-0.0800506249,
0.4667187333,
0.8567952514,
-0.1295775473,
-0.616738081,
1.1632472277,
-0.1712568849,
0.0028606218,
0.277884841,
0.3801834881,
-0.5055238605,
-0.5326490402,
-0.3926250637,
0.1987325996,
-0.8495110869,
-0.4817120135,
-0.8529056311,
0.099955231,
-0.5933980942,
0.1388301998,
-0.3469290733,
-0.4759049714,
-0.2183359265,
-0.1587409079,
0.2311047018,
0.8872916698,
-0.2390102446,
0.5059691668,
-0.7124307156,
0.1594835669,
0.3355304003,
0.1685274988,
-0.4424078763,
-0.4156482518,
-0.2936585248,
0.2559975386,
-0.4523712099,
-0.9445232153,
0.4031644762,
0.1936965585,
0.6548780203,
0.4426319897,
-0.0643396974,
0.4341466725,
-0.2817740142,
0.8720347285,
0.1981008798,
-0.7667651176,
1.0631011724,
-0.4871261716,
0.6188915372,
0.6434195042,
0.73276788,
-0.4076872468,
-0.3852434456,
-0.6549262404,
-0.4929870963,
0.7932909131,
0.3633768559,
0.0699818954,
-0.0336559527,
-0.0517851822,
0.4563891888,
0.083601743,
-0.8549776673,
-0.2733620405,
-0.1900439262,
-0.0903855637,
-0.0285022613,
-0.412735939,
-0.2693313658,
-0.4789794087,
1.1417902708,
-0.3438360691,
-0.022330571,
-0.2673477232,
-0.0285165086,
-0.0042644921,
0.6323701143,
0.894056201,
0.3985339701,
0.2134421766,
0.2523082197,
0.3543024063,
-0.5374996066,
0.4729690552,
0.2394522578,
-0.0677206665,
0.0869712234,
0.2436033487,
1.1394281387,
0.2039163262,
-0.2814064026,
0.5916882157,
-0.1712610871,
-0.687379241,
-0.0337672532,
-0.0133410357,
-0.0311276019,
0.3535399139,
0.2224083543,
0.2396542132,
0.3451052904,
-0.1838139296,
-0.0018073013,
0.3878332078,
-0.5571948886,
-0.6132537127,
0.6637791991,
0.4197717607,
-0.3186813593,
-0.0222179741,
-0.2919167578,
-0.9787320495,
0.3338220119,
0.3775745928,
0.8687079549,
-0.6854575276,
0.4950417578,
0.4864486456,
0.3685819209,
-0.1020796299,
0.6380767226,
-0.1013545543,
-0.7372035384,
-0.3868335187,
-0.3937258422,
-0.2682057321,
0.5326260924,
-0.656940639,
0.5727925897,
0.3770594001,
-0.0937457681,
0.0275683943,
0.0704412386,
-0.7493469715,
0.1235588267,
0.0518000573,
0.7297797799,
-0.9778318405,
0.7948990464,
0.9288336635,
0.0822489783,
-0.8193084002,
-0.3806220293,
0.0139008211,
-0.6553782821,
0.492942065,
0.2442965955,
-0.3733625114,
0.1043975875,
-0.5701224208,
-0.6400259733,
0.7732947469,
0.4465911984,
-0.6061810255,
0.4934529066,
0.3894937932,
0.3233462572,
-0.0753395334,
0.1075904593,
0.9433318377,
0.8522206545,
0.2291561216,
-0.8849005103,
-0.1195773855,
-0.4677790105,
-0.3418236375,
0.2696397901,
-0.7017726898,
0.3686274886,
0.1491715461,
-0.0064153043,
0.1718855351,
0.6999276876,
0.2019444704,
0.3365424275,
0.700058639,
0.3344916105,
0.7759663463,
-0.3595100343,
0.8066378236,
-0.3219718635,
0.0349061601,
0.9177315831,
-0.1400765479,
0.6737528443,
0.3534954786,
-0.0244493615,
0.4984055758,
0.8511807919,
0.1334715337,
0.5953157544,
-0.0887280107,
-0.2921718359,
-0.5621775389,
-0.2399732918,
-0.3369183838,
0.642501235,
0.3285980225,
-0.0742920414,
-0.1221980825,
0.7464642525,
0.2929257751,
-0.0636982247,
-0.1955741346,
0.8150828481,
-0.2159978449,
-1.058791995,
0.5771462917,
0.0686009899,
0.7302911282,
-0.5673546791,
0.0063666636,
-0.2203675359,
0.1537404358,
-0.1015457064,
-0.8425608277,
0.006329298,
-0.3769260645,
0.2040899694,
-0.3256218731,
0.9523780346,
-0.6291437745,
-0.6551848054,
0.1215472668,
0.3623991013,
0.2340964228,
-0.3488146067,
-0.5689985752,
0.1006043777,
0.1706836671,
-0.2891727984,
0.1455368698,
0.7127813697,
0.0375262611,
0.6306097507,
0.4014189541,
-0.0488274843,
-0.1397672296,
0.6447284818,
0.740179956,
-0.4565713108,
-0.5639868975,
-0.8783101439,
0.2220077962,
-0.3003186584,
-0.2165396959,
1.1058751345,
0.7157729864,
0.6848828197,
-0.166761741,
0.6060657501,
0.2493011504,
0.3429402709,
-0.5535216331,
0.504334569,
-0.5973386168,
0.0458163433,
-0.4512142837,
-0.807697773,
-0.2409675419,
0.3496602774,
-0.3425650597,
0.0041318275,
0.7928342223,
0.9600283504,
0.0062767724,
0.6400958896,
0.5641557574,
0.1109843999,
0.3225509524,
0.495701462,
0.9068664908,
-0.5856665373,
0.8324066401,
-0.4896629155,
-0.0201903265,
-0.2296511382,
-0.8653922081,
-1.1561057568,
-0.9022915959,
-0.5115094781,
-0.2223140746,
-0.144437924,
0.4964724183,
0.7542939782,
-1.0220878124,
0.0385273211,
-0.0632599741,
0.0799858943,
-0.151594013,
-0.2056513131,
0.1971430182,
-0.0163355004,
-1.0869621038,
0.6555855274,
0.2099603266,
0.1693571508,
-0.2870903909,
-0.1128985733,
-0.4659220874,
-0.1111573055,
0.7169564962,
0.0169188511,
-0.591338098,
-0.4192886055,
0.0956991017,
0.2701201439,
-0.1185006574,
0.9497305155,
-0.6195442677,
0.5004953742,
0.5595821142,
0.1627981216,
0.5105547905,
-0.1326767653,
0.6771837473,
-0.6337634921,
0.2424953878,
0.2028063536,
0.4686008692,
0.3958012462,
-0.5009262562,
0.7934507728,
-0.030646624,
-0.5639919043,
-0.6380143166,
0.2552403212,
-0.6088432074,
-0.2715301216,
1.3520501852,
0.1931517422,
-0.2590053082,
-0.556522131,
-0.4604830146,
0.1434290111,
-0.196692124,
0.2475194484,
0.9748369455,
-0.1817531735,
-0.1828241646,
-0.3406321406,
0.5584309697,
0.7910535336,
-0.5823729038,
-0.2289385051,
0.1657800525,
0.105870828,
0.2490763068,
0.4474646747,
0.0686018467,
0.2184690237,
-0.3325752318,
-0.147978127,
0.0501525328,
-0.4431394041,
-0.4545382559,
0.226889044,
-0.0786424577,
-0.2066536844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11922v1 | Generating Topic Pages for Scientific Concepts Using Scientific Publications | 2023-04-24T09:03:14 | 2023-04-24T09:03:14 | Hosein Azarbonyad, Zubair Afzal, George Tsatsaronis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR | In this paper, we describe Topic Pages, an inventory of scientific concepts
and information around them extracted from a large collection of scientific
books and journals. The main aim of Topic Pages is to provide all the necessary
information to the readers to understand scientific concepts they come across
while reading scholarly content in any scientific domain. Topic Pages are a
collection of automatically generated information pages using NLP and ML, each
corresponding to a scientific concept. Each page contains three pieces of
information: a definition, related concepts, and the most relevant snippets,
all extracted from scientific peer-reviewed publications. In this paper, we
discuss the details of different components to extract each of these elements.
The collection of pages in production contains over 360,000 Topic Pages across
20 different scientific domains with an average of 23 million unique visits per
month, constituting it a popular source for scientific information. | [
-0.569144845,
-0.463085264,
0.6545159221,
0.2608092725,
-0.4084949493,
0.03248851,
0.1084142029,
-0.3109361827,
0.7395086884,
0.6323278546,
-0.3163147867,
-0.4319406152,
-0.3406756222,
0.3458171189,
-0.5302997828,
1.2402524948,
0.1001449376,
0.0335482992,
-0.4528846443,
0.215350017,
0.0421079583,
-0.078579627,
-0.2606956959,
0.0076868632,
0.8869966269,
0.1752387434,
0.245431751,
0.8709340096,
0.6765200496,
0.1923229545,
-0.2788945436,
0.2297044545,
-0.325574398,
0.1090880036,
-0.6780707836,
-0.426743716,
-0.2904390991,
0.246429652,
0.8238199353,
0.7662394643,
0.2433071882,
0.144271329,
-0.1639487594,
0.7118057013,
-0.5740492344,
0.0232055411,
-0.4630943239,
0.3360612392,
-0.4349891543,
-0.7708066106,
-0.2681286037,
-0.336802274,
0.1606516391,
-0.8924313188,
0.7249447107,
0.0694612712,
0.8263623118,
-0.1203939319,
-0.1549261361,
-0.6375626922,
-0.3864960074,
0.500657022,
-0.4131742418,
0.2454250604,
0.5235022902,
-0.1899860948,
-0.2953002453,
-0.7845897675,
-0.8238106966,
-0.2181227356,
0.1794429421,
0.2618724406,
-0.0549610555,
-0.2403505296,
0.3364764154,
0.2591592371,
-0.7446442246,
-0.2138518095,
-0.5145097971,
0.0705881342,
0.8732129335,
0.0972123966,
0.3048717082,
-0.5228161812,
-0.070491828,
-0.1275841743,
-0.8308253884,
-0.2205992788,
0.5632563233,
0.0657944828,
0.3558343053,
0.923165977,
-0.2713083625,
0.7435093522,
0.2293436825,
-0.2939512134,
0.1296014041,
-0.6425018907,
0.2972335517,
0.1857661307,
0.61255759,
0.5225785971,
-0.3312399387,
-0.3292863369,
0.1456595212,
-0.448977977,
0.5496042967,
-0.8210483789,
-0.2469768673,
0.5030484796,
-0.5953521132,
-0.3347632885,
0.1896676719,
-0.9975450635,
-0.4051279724,
-0.2699635327,
0.1393696517,
-0.2547909021,
-0.3032962382,
-0.2374385595,
-0.5776363611,
-0.1667837799,
0.5630483031,
-0.7157511115,
-0.0503743403,
0.90021348,
1.1532957554,
-0.8079312444,
-0.2832960486,
-0.008466159,
0.3496761918,
-0.3379569948,
0.9690296054,
-0.3981578648,
-0.8022840619,
-0.1907730103,
0.1297347993,
0.2239614278,
-0.3232852519,
0.0705972388,
-0.9596452117,
-0.0586942621,
-0.5182924271,
-0.8858588338,
-0.1477185637,
0.0585651807,
-0.7465455532,
0.4552593231,
-0.2728024125,
-1.0504931211,
0.4373815954,
-0.9054519534,
-0.2856467962,
0.4572708011,
-0.0284345597,
0.2304127216,
0.1367250383,
-0.4358326197,
0.3143518567,
-0.2238427252,
0.0956661329,
-0.0067772735,
0.3471660614,
0.5650968552,
0.0242877696,
0.4303026795,
0.6987406015,
0.1053070053,
-0.0551295504,
-0.8904719353,
-0.0390120931,
0.1266132593,
-0.3354034722,
-0.4073653817,
0.1534512341,
0.1493528187,
-0.0152893495,
0.5644920468,
-0.545751214,
0.3724306226,
-0.1890227497,
0.4391599894,
0.3981453478,
0.7002100945,
0.3025472462,
-0.2992549241,
0.2861559689,
0.0133780483,
-0.2966565788,
-0.4021691382,
-0.8402613997,
-0.6408977509,
0.0799759701,
0.4389653504,
0.2648242116,
-0.3385309875,
0.5703055263,
0.1224183962,
-0.7659305334,
-0.0583810546,
0.1165084839,
0.3661885858,
0.6690754294,
0.2198348939,
-0.3637658656,
-0.0688998029,
-0.6696485281,
0.0619928688,
-0.0668699741,
-0.1393079758,
0.1125411987,
0.7121165395,
-0.0392542258,
1.0074431896,
-0.9343060255,
0.1195003688,
0.2865642607,
0.3720724881,
0.0907400101,
0.3122890294,
0.2268134803,
-1.2919071913,
-0.5319489837,
-0.0373940542,
-0.7370871305,
0.0547895394,
-0.1651788503,
-0.3747417033,
0.1265704632,
0.3954576552,
-0.5097159743,
0.2523522973,
-0.0521225557,
-0.2298676819,
0.6516876221,
-0.177379176,
0.079119049,
-1.2817817926,
0.1738487929,
0.3437252939,
0.2277556956,
-0.3638620377,
0.1231076196,
-0.2093984932,
-0.3982887864,
-0.5056675076,
0.5506051779,
-0.211560443,
-0.1273412257,
-0.5333589911,
0.3391337693,
0.4211476147,
0.0577069037,
0.5154269934,
0.6657066345,
0.3021397889,
-0.7895587087,
0.4012136161,
0.4075504541,
0.076391466,
0.3076904416,
-0.5815589428,
0.0717963427,
-0.1162330657,
0.3237208724,
-0.8533434868,
-0.3135035634,
0.1615806073,
-0.3623012602,
0.2559201121,
0.1532431245,
-0.3545436561,
-0.3431501091,
-0.0609883592,
-0.1651352793,
0.0572647415,
-0.0506961495,
0.0557997487,
0.7725599408,
-0.7323545814,
-0.4597059488,
-0.0734666958,
0.094454959,
-0.1222995445,
-0.3182434142,
0.6904350519,
-0.0540008806,
-0.3407984078,
0.4735876024,
-0.2321742326,
-0.0619684719,
-0.2661395669,
0.3213807046,
-0.0109798508,
-0.0205073692,
0.4513364136,
-0.1691812277,
-0.1817005128,
-0.046849668,
-0.5442433953,
0.6855954528,
-0.2740362287,
-0.4652711153,
-0.3905538917,
0.7928977609,
0.4784019291,
-0.0500238873,
0.5984142423,
0.4015975595,
-0.4036261141,
0.1624460965,
-0.4017022252,
-0.2465171814,
-0.3666663468,
0.5282657743,
-0.1967928112,
-0.3671071231,
0.477155298,
-0.0509050302,
0.1904961467,
1.0694587231,
0.4681759477,
-0.6023008227,
0.5685738921,
0.6164634824,
0.193526566,
0.1621871889,
-0.4331482351,
0.1337365657,
-0.649366498,
-0.6148109436,
-0.8375643492,
-0.1185295805,
-0.7819112539,
-0.657584548,
0.1187981293,
0.4116572738,
-0.0757456645,
0.3704592288,
-0.8669799566,
0.2763027847,
0.7363106608,
0.035680566,
0.3123147786,
0.152882576,
0.0655873343,
-0.0148866475,
-0.4890359342,
-0.9879704714,
1.1678931713,
0.0559575222,
0.3551179767,
-0.201718837,
0.7874886394,
0.5201871395,
0.1960754395,
-0.7896456122,
0.5538910031,
-0.1584462821,
-0.5340876579,
-0.4429160953,
-0.239885509,
-0.7084724903,
-0.0832386538,
-0.2711801827,
-0.5097919106,
0.3540202081,
0.0074757091,
-0.0228310451,
0.1941699237,
-0.3055337965,
0.566893816,
-0.4646039009,
-0.4057986736,
-0.481236726,
-0.5682038665,
0.0590840094,
-0.5933619738,
-0.0949992388,
0.0316045284,
0.059091121,
1.2676420212,
-0.2806331813,
0.6043836474,
-0.0657186955,
-0.109602198,
0.602114141,
-0.3444166481,
0.0647312179,
0.3127562106,
-0.0874831155,
0.3082754314,
0.2949817181,
-0.312125206,
-0.3255588412,
0.4799556136,
-0.7645098567,
-0.7264399529,
-0.6017522216,
-0.490976125,
-0.0149968285,
0.3527802825,
0.4115188718,
0.1882999092,
-0.108132869,
0.3584726155,
0.7703905106,
-0.427952826,
0.2864204049,
0.6634857655,
-0.2617278695,
-0.1763294935,
1.4326688051,
0.1207766533,
0.081650719,
0.7251519561,
0.208390519,
-0.4088998437,
-0.8197163343,
-0.1375182122,
0.1272081286,
-0.5845546126,
-0.1613937318,
-1.0418602228,
-0.4698920548,
-0.2652148008,
-0.1867132634,
-0.2245678008,
-0.5951011777,
-0.5266513228,
0.0919487923,
0.5802056193,
0.5496646762,
-0.3753426671,
0.1951251328,
-0.9480496049,
0.7856071591,
0.2581001222,
-0.2398203611,
-0.1398933679,
-0.256608367,
-0.2414708138,
0.0835000128,
-0.7881370783,
-0.969061017,
0.6908850074,
0.1454342455,
0.7120773792,
0.8757802844,
-0.0991659835,
0.4297973514,
-0.7187915444,
0.8892137408,
0.5258165598,
-0.469940275,
1.0020077229,
-0.539159596,
-0.2625305951,
0.4167557061,
1.0505520105,
-0.3975560069,
-0.3139254451,
-0.9562431574,
-0.8963941336,
0.3750484586,
-0.0443774872,
0.0673871264,
-0.1930017173,
0.6329637766,
0.2702255845,
0.6012161374,
-0.4094899893,
-0.1778206974,
-0.4960380793,
0.1328891367,
0.0678450689,
-0.1742154509,
-0.5072808266,
-0.0262962449,
0.6486747861,
-0.1210835949,
0.3713034093,
0.1322820038,
0.1512846798,
-0.2576920986,
-0.0619924143,
0.726757586,
1.1790034771,
-0.4952293634,
-0.0895325765,
-0.3922106028,
-0.7886943221,
-0.0605477244,
0.1520400345,
-0.4185169935,
0.1020427495,
0.1523371786,
0.6498978734,
-0.2338169813,
-0.5658313632,
0.0085666068,
0.1866847277,
-0.0602826178,
-0.2688184083,
0.3594050109,
0.4240747392,
0.23935996,
0.8812926412,
-0.0042895577,
0.1545024365,
-0.5103361011,
0.6565121412,
0.3352997303,
0.0797630176,
-0.2560001016,
0.442790091,
0.1718046814,
-0.3957264721,
0.3538620472,
-0.3366028368,
-0.3514654636,
0.8736838102,
0.6618509889,
0.4768646955,
0.3295388818,
0.7152733207,
0.4870132506,
-0.4261824191,
0.0580632351,
-0.0137135098,
-0.0858329758,
-0.7390760183,
-0.2130568624,
-1.2698630095,
-1.0190720558,
0.3411357701,
-0.6245559454,
0.0553191267,
-0.2541182637,
-0.183275044,
0.6660373807,
0.5147902369,
-0.1487108171,
0.2606227696,
-0.0452963039,
1.0283392668,
-0.7765982151,
0.4639652967,
0.8053964972,
-0.7906726599,
-0.3808933496,
0.047996942,
-0.0800986812,
-0.5375305414,
1.1712962389,
-0.285513103,
0.1461254656,
-0.0023773785,
-0.5541307926,
-0.7997454405,
0.6769484878,
-0.3674136102,
-0.619879961,
-0.030267626,
0.0680639595,
0.4801283181,
-0.5139268041,
-0.2445446104,
-0.1058375388,
0.509932518,
0.4551421404,
-0.2597950697,
-0.3372879922,
-0.427100271,
-0.182914421,
-0.1886700243,
-0.5079628825,
0.6546720266,
0.0689693093,
0.2266499698,
-0.0753055215,
0.830304265,
0.8697836399,
0.5680372715,
0.1105577201,
0.4240797162,
1.044088006,
-0.0141501697,
0.7876303196,
-0.5345824957,
0.1531734616,
0.6578586102,
-0.2095029056,
0.8078389168,
0.5555796623,
-0.2798583806,
-0.0220692996,
1.0635170937,
-0.412388742,
0.8479543328,
0.2585095465,
-0.2952158451,
0.1761839986,
-0.2262053639,
-0.7465183735,
0.4090137482,
1.0134016275,
-0.3435127735,
-0.2562665343,
-0.0155332321,
-0.1044040248,
-0.2441369891,
-0.3691495359,
0.7215046883,
0.2206281126,
-0.7458360791,
0.1290022731,
0.143133834,
0.249666363,
-0.5807594061,
-0.1152385995,
-0.0529661179,
-0.2426083088,
-0.2812791467,
-0.9794012904,
0.4056563079,
0.2388348579,
-0.6640818715,
-0.4759824872,
0.9389663339,
-0.1877187788,
-0.4436672628,
-0.4433045387,
0.4576840401,
0.5100838542,
0.0468754992,
-0.6122099757,
-0.2487334162,
0.0901289657,
-0.3790769875,
0.5563368797,
0.4818069935,
0.0130166905,
0.3586069345,
0.9883846641,
0.600007236,
-0.0068577407,
-0.2205902934,
0.7769228816,
-0.8117346764,
-0.5756821632,
-0.3031568527,
0.2104723901,
-0.3412574232,
-0.5195240378,
0.8718720078,
0.5853956342,
0.5464509726,
-0.2495523244,
0.9279183149,
-0.2171981037,
0.4291276336,
-0.5323003531,
0.9819629788,
-0.7162306309,
-0.0806834996,
-0.1853734255,
-1.1551113129,
-0.1456440538,
0.8543589115,
-0.0732380599,
-0.252209872,
0.5941981673,
0.3476240337,
0.1025305688,
0.3842049241,
-0.1259181201,
-0.0025098491,
0.3237499297,
-0.2095011175,
0.7938340306,
0.0827442706,
-0.1394243836,
-0.2938851118,
-0.1318961829,
-0.584835887,
-1.0453628302,
-0.4199364781,
-0.9153035879,
-0.5721539259,
-0.4201435745,
-0.0322301015,
0.4197509289,
0.5773748159,
-1.0782786608,
0.0451720245,
-0.4542751312,
0.019566128,
0.1153166667,
-0.2943591475,
0.7890979648,
-0.4437284172,
-0.5293808579,
0.2729653418,
0.4160043299,
-0.1867587566,
-0.4262682199,
0.0779798478,
-0.2349192798,
-0.1607092321,
0.3560496867,
0.7778741717,
-0.3918480575,
-0.0163806006,
0.0942983404,
-0.1031953692,
0.0459409244,
0.7976201177,
-0.405066669,
0.3582337201,
0.6596457362,
0.5559599996,
0.9053018093,
0.0441602692,
0.430688113,
-0.520144403,
0.1400665343,
0.4190371633,
0.184049204,
0.1639419496,
-0.3812476099,
0.4698133171,
0.5069046617,
-0.4599686861,
-0.8668256402,
0.2080075294,
-1.2312703133,
-0.3314890862,
1.0617419481,
-0.0545482896,
-0.1515264809,
-0.0847813338,
0.0965127498,
0.4160062969,
-0.3008143306,
0.8422157168,
0.7334276438,
-0.5055523515,
0.1703057438,
-0.8139470816,
0.4255740643,
-0.1277813613,
-0.9714912772,
-0.3304714859,
0.5743435621,
0.2419830114,
1.2171126604,
0.3209403753,
-0.2274115831,
0.0558381267,
0.0776886195,
0.1187577769,
0.0777882859,
-0.5436236262,
0.4212917984,
0.5063183308,
-0.285443157,
-0.1478372216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12329v1 | Pre-trained Embeddings for Entity Resolution: An Experimental Analysis [Experiment, Analysis & Benchmark] | 2023-04-24T08:53:54 | 2023-04-24T08:53:54 | Alexandros Zeakis, George Papadakis, Dimitrios Skoutas, Manolis Koubarakis | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | Many recent works on Entity Resolution (ER) leverage Deep Learning techniques
involving language models to improve effectiveness. This is applied to both
main steps of ER, i.e., blocking and matching. Several pre-trained embeddings
have been tested, with the most popular ones being fastText and variants of the
BERT model. However, there is no detailed analysis of their pros and cons. To
cover this gap, we perform a thorough experimental analysis of 12 popular
language models over 17 established benchmark datasets. First, we assess their
vectorization overhead for converting all input entities into dense embeddings
vectors. Second, we investigate their blocking performance, performing a
detailed scalability analysis, and comparing them with the state-of-the-art
deep learning-based blocking method. Third, we conclude with their relative
performance for both supervised and unsupervised matching. Our experimental
results provide novel insights into the strengths and weaknesses of the main
language models, facilitating researchers and practitioners to select the most
suitable ones in practice. | [
-0.8065117598,
-0.8817871213,
0.70300138,
-0.0612971187,
-0.3806511164,
0.1367141902,
-0.547718823,
-0.7553178072,
0.2474063486,
0.5872864127,
-0.1196221337,
-0.429649502,
-0.721385181,
0.1328028888,
-0.7532270551,
0.7090637088,
-0.4607252777,
0.2036042511,
-0.3737005889,
-0.1807752252,
-0.5442049503,
-0.4822416604,
-0.5681208372,
-0.0843503401,
0.360848099,
0.2288119197,
0.5706610084,
0.8890919089,
0.5272619724,
0.3885878921,
0.2437388748,
-0.0778622553,
-0.4563172758,
0.1808521301,
-0.1420545429,
-0.1879305094,
-0.2204123139,
0.1321518123,
0.8840277195,
0.951295495,
-0.1160511225,
-0.2408172637,
0.0983531401,
0.3088523746,
-0.6560441256,
-0.172199145,
-0.6583127379,
0.1558447331,
-0.4034249187,
0.2470278889,
-0.5798125863,
-0.1630716473,
0.5569565892,
-0.626963079,
0.5031944513,
0.1560231298,
1.1139904261,
0.274353385,
-0.2612316012,
-0.4055767655,
-1.0052829981,
0.7366448045,
-0.6173669696,
0.6624315381,
0.3261374533,
0.0845138282,
-0.0629286766,
-1.011292696,
-0.3219922781,
-0.2012142688,
-0.124321714,
-0.2385221273,
-0.1395420134,
0.2935934961,
0.3392069042,
0.388248533,
-0.5652951598,
0.5207371712,
-0.3159631491,
-0.1627252102,
0.3226862252,
-0.2266787887,
0.0635952875,
0.2352206558,
-0.3318945169,
-0.0070658145,
-0.5906022191,
-0.3138494492,
0.193593964,
0.139427349,
0.3278028071,
0.588372767,
-0.072196357,
0.6479367018,
0.0196097009,
0.4858641624,
0.0595957525,
-0.254037708,
-0.3101539314,
0.1533063054,
0.7035556436,
0.1019784287,
0.3515032232,
-0.3659342527,
-0.4675514102,
0.0654669181,
0.4799131751,
-1.0115917921,
-0.1607525647,
0.0931583643,
-0.5915651321,
0.0847935155,
-0.1544696391,
-0.6873598695,
-0.2189093381,
-0.4392744005,
0.50062567,
-0.3891759217,
-0.2368006557,
0.1416080892,
0.2508004606,
0.0709022507,
0.3351361752,
-0.5205435157,
0.7018354535,
0.6298447847,
0.7158120871,
-0.1086852849,
-0.2880297601,
-0.4890806079,
-0.2942052186,
-0.4984410703,
0.8837304711,
-0.5858762264,
-0.2202461958,
0.1429142058,
-0.2030190676,
0.0946849883,
-0.5833157301,
0.7561645508,
-0.7848575711,
-0.0066539543,
-0.2037809342,
-1.0672786236,
-0.1306010932,
-0.0460209474,
-0.9582009315,
0.6387116313,
-0.2671932578,
-0.5070649981,
0.6086799502,
-0.2150163651,
-0.3097296655,
0.0240811072,
-0.2528475821,
-0.4837971032,
0.367303282,
0.1746753603,
0.6355139017,
-0.4118516743,
0.3705656528,
-0.3728441596,
-0.5110824108,
0.091299355,
-0.0895649493,
0.2448188514,
0.296171397,
-0.2186649442,
0.1668247283,
-0.6943314672,
-0.1091356352,
0.1415693611,
-0.0450264066,
-0.580845356,
0.2143264115,
-0.0807356462,
0.1107606962,
-0.0819226876,
-0.5611943007,
-0.0269389413,
-0.0546482913,
0.4943466485,
0.6332162619,
-0.4179901183,
0.548015058,
0.0753758177,
0.1423260123,
0.1499588192,
-0.18793118,
-0.1193025932,
-0.2847242653,
-0.7442097068,
-0.3784342706,
0.9276291728,
0.0902440473,
-0.4660852253,
0.3285907507,
-0.2838403285,
-0.5632552505,
-0.7845320106,
0.0385122597,
0.3848867416,
0.4002365172,
0.5148673654,
-0.7728888988,
-0.797542572,
-0.9760539532,
-0.3147312999,
0.1795845479,
0.0130077386,
0.3273746371,
0.5802788734,
-0.1532960981,
0.8243672252,
-0.1821945459,
-0.2985430658,
0.1031472087,
0.2781995535,
0.0135824969,
0.6895399094,
0.4641881287,
-0.7417407632,
-0.3859602213,
-0.450112313,
-0.6004445553,
0.2113865763,
0.1001536921,
-0.0716968775,
0.0027531858,
0.5067793727,
-0.678163588,
0.4626972675,
0.5451064706,
-0.2129701376,
0.4116334617,
-0.2787872851,
0.2560364306,
-0.7758360505,
-0.1494488567,
0.154365018,
-0.4399037361,
-0.6876773834,
0.1159666032,
0.0934126377,
-0.3181602061,
-0.3474353552,
0.2040331811,
-0.6683675647,
-0.460131526,
-0.128665328,
0.3207091391,
-0.0577579699,
0.2205460519,
0.3918522298,
0.6540101767,
0.4964381754,
-0.8117286563,
0.3183936477,
0.039707426,
-0.6997944117,
0.4557703435,
-0.9992492199,
0.2926477492,
-0.1679556817,
0.2380260527,
-0.8123824,
-0.0091347089,
0.0001049645,
-0.2156723738,
0.6663882136,
-0.1723269522,
-0.4384790361,
-0.2927841544,
-0.0530674756,
0.5656321645,
0.4256009758,
-0.5149473548,
0.6823222637,
0.4104494154,
-0.0214168951,
-0.578630805,
-0.6434639692,
-0.126098156,
-0.0653667003,
-0.2606922686,
0.8390344381,
0.0241085086,
-0.0945790634,
0.6148664951,
-0.0053382595,
-0.3538258076,
0.1642583609,
0.0969904214,
0.0078450022,
-0.4234110117,
0.2356584519,
-0.2100252211,
-0.0071915882,
0.0264844727,
-0.1748194098,
0.5638225079,
-0.1091459692,
-0.4322549403,
-0.2997584939,
0.5408268571,
0.2480015159,
-0.7143712044,
0.9383741021,
0.3418146372,
-0.9599280953,
0.0382833853,
-0.9433330297,
-0.208641395,
-0.3900004923,
0.571628809,
-0.5082260966,
-0.9484766722,
0.5070239902,
-0.2331524789,
0.0073857666,
0.2975809872,
0.3427200615,
-0.048160933,
0.8192532063,
0.6201118827,
-0.0140486266,
0.5114203691,
-0.1758280993,
0.1661041975,
-0.6334562898,
0.0146123972,
-0.7781316042,
-0.3089099526,
-0.6752765179,
-0.5206359029,
-0.5466476679,
0.4537884593,
-0.2286304086,
0.5537436604,
-0.3913103342,
0.468953222,
0.4372115433,
-0.1329262257,
0.1168490723,
-0.0278234221,
-0.1874691546,
-0.2529205084,
-0.443423897,
-0.4573252499,
1.1556859016,
0.4776396751,
0.6379016638,
-0.0715850964,
0.7795649767,
0.1326628923,
0.4837988019,
-0.597890377,
0.4048073292,
-0.2042921931,
-0.6874817014,
-0.4293864071,
-0.4973058403,
-1.0660526752,
0.3541511595,
-0.4552820027,
-0.6783013344,
0.3247852623,
0.040202789,
-0.2782371342,
0.5680443048,
-0.7520298362,
0.8856174946,
-0.08958783,
-0.3535978198,
-0.2966455519,
-0.1861698031,
0.1820160598,
-0.260949403,
-0.0473362543,
-0.0742776692,
0.0083012106,
0.9080706835,
-0.1162065566,
0.3697372079,
-0.0702874735,
0.0716291517,
0.2748648226,
-0.0348886624,
0.6764039397,
-0.0731607825,
0.013087946,
0.2084915191,
-0.3025822043,
-0.4788894355,
-0.438922435,
0.8976581693,
-0.6966136694,
-0.5993806124,
-0.2623862624,
-0.1619309783,
-0.0517649837,
0.4713941813,
0.2109903395,
0.3704351485,
-0.5031712055,
0.471242696,
1.0248391628,
-0.1525250375,
0.463221699,
0.6344780922,
-0.3448297083,
-0.1941519231,
0.5712293386,
0.4683449268,
-0.1448931545,
0.4314800203,
-0.3031803071,
-0.4078510404,
-0.7620078325,
-0.3817484081,
0.2635473907,
-0.5813910365,
-0.1177486926,
-0.8226509094,
-0.2419211566,
-0.4091895521,
0.0043933126,
-0.9509956241,
-0.0429235138,
-0.2981534004,
-0.2209216654,
0.0019060115,
0.8568538427,
0.0946402997,
-0.0711675435,
-0.6992353797,
0.1835169941,
0.3576619327,
0.7786812782,
0.0782350078,
-0.1850759983,
-0.3669764102,
-0.0753582418,
-0.0007075376,
-0.9802024961,
0.1559526175,
0.1502220482,
0.5711871386,
0.3627696633,
0.1398164779,
0.7278677225,
-0.8196902275,
0.4779793024,
-0.0058368943,
-1.0791000128,
0.3688513637,
0.2372084409,
-0.4525332749,
0.4587286711,
0.7127175331,
-0.1599600315,
-0.0365132689,
-0.5823965669,
-0.8313891888,
0.3085672259,
0.1468106657,
-0.082778722,
-0.096093297,
0.5486343503,
-0.0722364858,
0.273049742,
-0.403337419,
-0.2818214595,
-0.0364004113,
0.0068565127,
-0.4512380958,
-0.5064154267,
0.1423820704,
-0.0280025322,
0.4056662619,
0.2576473057,
0.5674331784,
0.2560774684,
-0.6537858248,
-0.1380991787,
0.2176544815,
0.5960598588,
0.6541007161,
-0.3107423186,
0.1229067966,
0.1946826428,
-0.3279067576,
0.2198201567,
0.5251001716,
-0.094646275,
0.2621557713,
0.3374942541,
0.9585472345,
0.2243819833,
-0.3935353756,
0.4484767318,
-0.3217483759,
-0.1232103631,
-0.3293837309,
-0.3114071488,
0.0180352964,
0.2107510418,
0.1745815724,
-0.0546595976,
0.2768526077,
-0.2601754665,
0.3518025577,
0.3921128213,
-0.4457311034,
-0.2636346817,
0.7076074481,
0.3855613172,
-0.360337019,
0.8915355802,
-0.0525485985,
-0.3419723213,
0.5129256248,
0.4202166498,
0.7332641482,
-0.2732714713,
0.0448027998,
0.2303844392,
0.3752212822,
-0.1968502253,
-0.0052456115,
0.0903721228,
-0.9468565583,
-0.8860496879,
-0.4257417023,
-0.311771661,
0.2511973381,
-0.9160401821,
0.0195924118,
-0.3889731765,
-0.4041417539,
0.0513487421,
0.2914406061,
-1.3039232492,
0.1795890182,
0.1088367775,
0.9919857979,
-0.7600421309,
0.8853715658,
0.9389410019,
-0.4672130048,
-0.673584938,
-0.2308189571,
-0.4430068731,
-0.3799496889,
0.4774795771,
0.3257059753,
0.3017706573,
0.2527416348,
-0.2456542999,
-0.8471679688,
0.9035057425,
0.3137121499,
-0.93084234,
-0.1338263005,
-0.0612200201,
0.4704835415,
-0.5098645687,
0.3503669798,
0.6368322968,
0.2816482186,
-0.4712700248,
-0.7361368537,
0.1836801469,
0.003217411,
0.2291836143,
0.3633228838,
-0.3002386987,
0.8586315513,
-0.029635733,
-0.3363021016,
0.1432560682,
1.0365946293,
0.0599761382,
0.0620189123,
0.6856768131,
1.1032731533,
0.6726973057,
-0.3053424358,
0.9605000615,
-0.2435429394,
0.4241010845,
1.1947788,
-0.5546723008,
0.9960283041,
0.4229460955,
-0.1633163393,
0.4287454784,
0.7436737418,
0.0068146968,
0.6153379679,
0.5273699164,
-0.0091831191,
-0.2612705529,
-0.4211445153,
-0.5267291665,
0.1592215896,
0.3628685474,
-0.5293137431,
-0.0162115488,
0.1353014261,
-0.1682178229,
0.0834937915,
-0.3326567411,
0.480184406,
0.0161553174,
-0.6242084503,
0.1679197252,
-0.0379165672,
0.6304421425,
-0.2399756312,
-0.0827236474,
-0.1093809232,
0.285913378,
0.04453573,
-0.6633924246,
0.0906587988,
0.0347962528,
-0.0948004872,
-0.171412617,
0.9100479484,
-0.4792985618,
-0.0231752172,
0.6272484064,
0.5097420812,
0.2028948367,
-0.0967645869,
-0.6062456965,
0.1336134523,
-0.3893341124,
-0.4040036201,
0.3056165576,
0.5371204615,
0.1659032553,
0.5927148461,
0.5003710389,
0.207161814,
0.2380016297,
0.0483790599,
0.9216238856,
-0.5699841976,
-0.1170591787,
-0.6751333475,
0.435103327,
-0.0458320342,
-0.1389722824,
0.4850722849,
0.5175632834,
1.2443245649,
-0.0272475462,
0.2702396214,
0.2020785362,
0.4534447491,
-0.5508340001,
0.475599587,
-0.4095881879,
0.1746007353,
-0.343493849,
-1.066701293,
-0.1379302144,
0.706905663,
-0.2107955664,
0.2148296237,
0.6715096831,
0.5492067933,
-0.0467789695,
-0.1820878088,
0.4149362147,
0.1662572324,
0.2930628657,
0.495498389,
0.9686157703,
-0.4509552717,
0.4919714034,
-0.595977664,
0.0008371383,
-0.38045609,
-0.9542860389,
-0.8375946879,
-0.5592163205,
-0.4053044021,
-0.3271974325,
0.1803284734,
0.8625589013,
0.8485629559,
-0.8377757072,
0.0953440219,
-0.1298063844,
0.0724315718,
-0.1589833647,
-0.1333258897,
0.4568516612,
-0.2040811032,
-0.7936607599,
0.1893911213,
-0.1178946197,
0.2250279784,
-0.2098872066,
-0.0703059733,
-0.2486320883,
0.1330032945,
0.3668702543,
0.2084327489,
-0.7009744644,
-0.3367465734,
-0.1326052994,
-0.2152148485,
-0.0867401436,
1.1248145103,
-0.7974088788,
0.4684601426,
0.3712033629,
1.0185146332,
0.6239792705,
-0.2241200805,
0.5712788105,
-0.6587474942,
0.2347811759,
0.4041472673,
0.7205510736,
0.2190057337,
-0.0934724361,
0.5133321285,
-0.0504487306,
-0.6356393099,
-0.9739535451,
0.1420426965,
-0.3809577823,
-0.190693289,
0.5173543096,
-0.5754180551,
0.0676346868,
0.0425819233,
0.1275584996,
0.6140581965,
-0.2444268763,
0.3607970476,
0.9185170531,
0.2041044235,
-0.4094917178,
-0.6263837814,
0.4797540009,
0.5689532757,
-0.4291534126,
-0.3427081108,
0.3313057721,
0.1436652094,
0.3108228445,
0.5844290257,
0.0474198125,
0.0423610397,
-0.1163305491,
0.3159170449,
-0.0106073041,
-0.4470697939,
-0.3667881191,
-0.0040331739,
0.3090522885,
-0.2297165096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11913v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11913v2 | Development of a Trust-Aware User Simulator for Statistical Proactive Dialog Modeling in Human-AI Teams | 2023-04-24T08:42:51 | 2023-06-18T18:56:01 | Matthias Kraus, Ron Riekenbrauck, Wolfgang Minker | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The concept of a Human-AI team has gained increasing attention in recent
years. For effective collaboration between humans and AI teammates, proactivity
is crucial for close coordination and effective communication. However, the
design of adequate proactivity for AI-based systems to support humans is still
an open question and a challenging topic. In this paper, we present the
development of a corpus-based user simulator for training and testing proactive
dialog policies. The simulator incorporates informed knowledge about proactive
dialog and its effect on user trust and simulates user behavior and personal
information, including socio-demographic features and personality traits. Two
different simulation approaches were compared, and a task-step-based approach
yielded better overall results due to enhanced modeling of sequential
dependencies. This research presents a promising avenue for exploring and
evaluating appropriate proactive strategies in a dialog game setting for
improving Human-AI teams. | [
-0.2233625501,
-0.974922955,
0.475161016,
0.4413470328,
0.1287789941,
0.3389592767,
0.1266193986,
-0.3519557714,
0.0176259857,
0.4154804051,
-0.7031011581,
-0.0525968373,
-0.0733320415,
0.1360928714,
-0.0560551323,
0.8717759252,
-0.1877681911,
0.1738107353,
-0.4231245518,
0.0039207498,
-0.7952253222,
-0.634775281,
-0.7756789327,
-0.1835467815,
0.1004977226,
0.3793380558,
1.0821442604,
0.1005785093,
0.4928758144,
0.3451861143,
0.190885216,
0.0600600801,
-0.379668504,
0.280898124,
-0.0049783601,
-0.5898302794,
-0.6890608072,
0.226744175,
0.4527906477,
0.0392309688,
-0.2768689096,
0.1653420925,
0.0347472765,
-0.0566301346,
-0.0982125998,
0.6029341817,
-0.3155050278,
-0.2452862859,
0.0582761355,
-0.0553848147,
-0.2131778449,
-0.2674703002,
0.3611037135,
-1.0997154713,
-0.0349914581,
0.3197842836,
0.6626886129,
0.2446115166,
-0.2146771997,
-0.0933247432,
-0.6681828499,
0.5962393284,
-0.6514676809,
0.0684498623,
0.5803717375,
0.3471549153,
-0.4420823455,
-0.3233176768,
-0.6461786628,
-0.5901809335,
-0.0165465456,
0.3627872467,
0.0799434334,
0.0720428824,
0.0496257208,
-0.372382164,
-0.4416924119,
-0.0687744245,
-0.0891230926,
-0.397878319,
0.5949029326,
0.2670317292,
0.5112916827,
0.1367366463,
-0.5554953218,
-0.0332978219,
-0.4436285794,
0.1662513763,
0.3883808255,
0.1074308902,
-0.2186591476,
0.3183183968,
0.0428706259,
0.2014789432,
0.0594150499,
-0.0815852508,
0.2560265064,
-0.5236425996,
-0.0613890849,
-0.0278284606,
0.753238976,
0.2443502992,
0.6727085114,
-0.1444717497,
0.0316112339,
0.4081389308,
0.5506367683,
-0.8097197413,
-0.1809225529,
0.2789442241,
-0.2889449298,
-0.5727701187,
-0.0858589187,
-0.3892999291,
-0.2824957073,
-0.2170275599,
0.6612338424,
-0.8062303066,
-0.5993525386,
-0.273765713,
0.153638944,
-0.1904855222,
0.6797983646,
-0.5011396408,
0.4860864878,
0.5458280444,
0.4172027409,
0.0325361416,
-0.4558455944,
-0.5742995739,
0.0870485008,
-0.2659944892,
0.434874773,
-0.6954148412,
-0.6581634879,
-0.0842231885,
-0.4066005647,
-0.2178706825,
-0.7248216271,
0.5679498911,
-0.5317060947,
0.183667317,
-0.2929441631,
-0.5874006152,
-0.0429519005,
0.445304364,
-0.3818936348,
1.0200446844,
0.3039621711,
-0.6921113133,
0.2615125775,
-1.0157953501,
-0.3183527589,
0.2257867754,
-0.4476905167,
-0.3693840206,
-0.1764071286,
-0.138567239,
0.2482684255,
-0.2166608125,
0.5146472454,
-0.2458022833,
-0.5965344906,
0.4554772973,
-0.0376511179,
0.8650193214,
0.0391192138,
-0.3450464904,
0.4783510566,
-0.2652101219,
-0.1149783507,
-0.0398246199,
-0.0321807079,
-0.4124079347,
0.0193996932,
0.0050126482,
0.2309550345,
0.0417466611,
-0.4749782681,
0.1571680456,
0.0141778132,
0.2364740372,
0.643415451,
0.1839087903,
0.5703468919,
-0.3650601208,
0.6134805083,
0.334992677,
0.5018085837,
-0.1482666433,
-0.7552915215,
-0.1717788875,
-0.6122575998,
0.3820536137,
1.0051037073,
-0.69901371,
0.5659008026,
0.1816689968,
-0.2894961238,
-0.5627673864,
0.0205099359,
0.5544983149,
0.7587410808,
0.1530464292,
-0.7878970504,
-0.4253563285,
-0.7500288486,
-0.0609572344,
-1.0318310261,
-0.0638180226,
0.4576300681,
0.7272168994,
-0.3522776961,
1.3211374283,
-0.1605559736,
-0.7242607474,
-0.3244921863,
0.5079115033,
-0.4923686385,
0.605217576,
0.5912821293,
-0.8473540545,
-0.4754207432,
-0.4691099823,
-0.879527986,
0.0481044464,
-0.3228323758,
-0.1965696067,
0.0612215251,
0.1441664994,
-0.8648570776,
0.6802943349,
0.4353325069,
-0.5984682441,
0.8053771853,
-0.2586346269,
0.2433073521,
-0.9558691382,
0.255687356,
0.046311833,
-0.3329679072,
-0.828471601,
-0.0754963309,
-0.2166444063,
-0.0640021935,
-0.447147727,
0.712202847,
-0.1163252071,
0.0260444619,
0.1171121672,
-0.2100275904,
-0.3233640194,
0.4813329875,
0.2136653662,
1.3360793591,
0.5003271699,
-0.5230451226,
-0.3413375616,
0.5181805491,
-0.2091500908,
0.6951138973,
-0.8694161773,
-0.0844304934,
0.1344600916,
0.515383184,
-0.7398945689,
-0.3585183918,
0.4454869926,
-0.6194010973,
-0.0465712771,
0.0699644387,
-0.909725666,
0.0135216638,
-0.1740405709,
0.4438914955,
0.8406022191,
0.1853051037,
0.8189477921,
0.6074551344,
-0.060960602,
-0.2045454383,
-0.0102654928,
-0.0194219649,
-0.3407179117,
-0.8288873434,
0.3138832748,
-0.233468011,
-0.6150657535,
-0.0616266802,
0.0494698435,
-0.2685226798,
0.4716910124,
0.5162158012,
0.4531634748,
0.3308447003,
-0.1415044367,
-0.3735119998,
0.0041404292,
0.2041217983,
0.203710407,
0.4849430025,
-0.316498518,
-0.1198600456,
-1.0104894638,
0.3097943664,
0.4850586057,
-0.2434258908,
0.8953440189,
0.8710241318,
-0.3431286514,
0.1970738322,
-0.508692503,
-0.6701127291,
-0.4356230199,
0.2475436777,
-0.1316587478,
-0.8781304955,
0.7592342496,
-0.4048705697,
0.2387761474,
0.0306074284,
0.5803258419,
-0.6218828559,
1.2743597031,
0.4253985286,
0.025515262,
0.4634246826,
-0.0047040889,
-0.0218646862,
-0.5213273168,
-0.1992810816,
-0.3060135245,
-0.0510984994,
-0.0906180069,
-0.6864937544,
0.4410228133,
-0.0259524547,
-0.6171745062,
0.2916897833,
0.1291875243,
-0.0043622586,
0.6131895185,
0.1527604461,
0.0275163073,
-0.3001569211,
-0.1065997779,
-0.2976088226,
-0.4749067724,
-0.5886634588,
0.7411831617,
0.3395441473,
0.4868781865,
0.1042333543,
0.8672956228,
0.7539522648,
0.5652077198,
-0.3394052684,
0.6240174174,
0.4141604304,
-0.9130613208,
-0.4961113632,
-0.4015956223,
-0.7451132536,
-0.1742935628,
-0.436227411,
-0.9658031464,
-0.2005175501,
0.5872574449,
-0.6241948605,
-0.1420269161,
-0.8461772203,
0.9603773952,
-0.2337569743,
-0.5479514003,
-0.4285909235,
-0.8186174631,
0.2524270117,
0.0114249783,
0.4217911661,
-0.2160285115,
0.3501137793,
0.6613813639,
-0.5137250423,
1.1493418217,
-0.5604179502,
0.3037027121,
0.7632423639,
0.534155786,
0.6223399639,
0.3845821917,
0.0959652513,
0.1384968758,
-0.1504587233,
-0.2692824006,
-0.507717073,
0.1651173681,
-0.9631145597,
-0.6771136522,
-0.3307265937,
-0.5856318474,
-0.5087985396,
0.2790718675,
-0.3552427888,
0.1151220575,
-0.7930378318,
-0.0887641311,
0.753035903,
-0.1941408068,
0.0024322728,
0.4537976086,
-0.2534245849,
-0.0255913623,
0.7720544338,
-0.1553999335,
-0.0138572985,
0.1705691069,
0.1559355408,
-0.1872419119,
-0.1231379509,
-0.3303061724,
0.0543989129,
0.183792755,
-0.1006456837,
-0.413951993,
-0.1360933334,
-0.3723149896,
-0.1055163518,
-0.3589815497,
-0.1768156439,
-0.3721950352,
0.0928722471,
0.2244481742,
0.4059305191,
0.0393369459,
0.5536649227,
-0.7152122259,
0.2448284626,
0.3932211101,
0.1856961548,
-0.1408196092,
-0.1815841496,
-0.0949247852,
0.0510320105,
-0.2643655539,
-0.9524320364,
0.3660336733,
-0.0940179601,
0.6658353806,
0.2817233503,
0.2029861659,
0.4062699378,
-0.3763350248,
0.7705299854,
0.2025248259,
-0.7920606136,
0.3339588046,
-0.7873120904,
-0.0545623973,
0.9186670184,
0.1407867968,
-0.3044435978,
-0.2995374799,
-0.8192693591,
-0.470380187,
0.6538456678,
0.7119333744,
-0.1382456869,
0.0900804102,
0.1848341376,
-0.0549627282,
0.0938127786,
0.0448642783,
0.0438837186,
-0.004089857,
-0.414909482,
0.1114467233,
-0.0917461067,
-0.3370911777,
0.0200029574,
0.5133154392,
0.0155831613,
0.4879920781,
0.2710570991,
-0.0761820078,
0.2560924292,
0.1623460352,
0.4926198423,
0.4083588123,
-0.4957579374,
-0.3269363046,
0.1137170717,
-0.6927855611,
0.1190328747,
0.0400523841,
-0.267133683,
-0.3156896234,
-0.0252216347,
0.5412277579,
0.3872610033,
-0.8962515593,
0.5732450485,
-0.4286029041,
-0.342159152,
-0.6442754269,
0.2902124226,
0.3885508776,
0.4111135602,
0.1128173098,
0.4602730274,
0.2547334135,
-0.7518481612,
0.382534802,
0.227915287,
-0.3935162723,
-0.5838151574,
0.984652102,
0.6545199156,
-0.7728005052,
0.7030065656,
-0.4002555609,
-0.6302800179,
0.7799313664,
0.314031601,
0.6504601836,
-0.3023390472,
0.5512219071,
0.1261243224,
0.019104084,
-0.3127484918,
0.5520371795,
-0.0297762323,
-0.84864676,
-0.0138348313,
-0.014539009,
-0.7469787598,
-0.3604317904,
-0.4593749046,
0.0696198121,
-0.3724122345,
-0.8423309922,
-0.3926914632,
0.0942211524,
-1.0586806536,
0.0290478207,
-0.146960333,
0.958535552,
-0.7435228825,
0.8195670843,
0.8714630008,
-0.4159437418,
-0.6289420724,
0.1341462731,
0.2504016161,
-0.849998951,
0.6798976064,
0.059542194,
0.0010718096,
-0.0357514098,
-0.3729525208,
-0.4550172091,
1.2698818445,
0.144699052,
-0.3818612099,
0.0122875897,
0.0529721975,
0.9737067819,
-0.5279635787,
0.4941010475,
0.3397799134,
0.4911119342,
-0.0807873532,
-1.0811966658,
-0.073249273,
-0.1544579715,
-0.1255510449,
-0.40244326,
-0.9895842671,
0.5117060542,
-0.3071393371,
-0.0474758483,
0.0013016397,
0.738681376,
0.6307857633,
0.332192868,
0.9766631722,
0.3168058395,
0.7489350438,
0.2458519191,
0.7851378918,
-0.4884704053,
-0.0348773263,
1.1812953949,
-0.869923532,
0.8378717303,
0.375015825,
0.0494951271,
0.4948765039,
0.3516772687,
0.2586348057,
0.2871024907,
0.1602066159,
-0.379303515,
-0.4909034371,
-0.3283599615,
0.00139008,
0.6726124287,
0.3454692662,
-0.1842319071,
0.255125165,
-0.5428011417,
0.6026688218,
-0.0049881996,
-0.0067426483,
0.7004945874,
-0.1785269082,
-0.9379702806,
-0.1179369465,
-0.070347935,
0.4482684135,
-0.5426954031,
-0.1430817097,
-0.0130785732,
0.2374223024,
0.0699545145,
-0.7921295166,
0.0019394767,
0.2303111851,
0.0701620877,
-0.2757647336,
0.653190434,
-0.2393680364,
-0.2143657953,
0.1328911185,
0.7060036063,
0.0535197519,
-0.0967015475,
-0.8568764925,
0.0247135218,
-0.1613408029,
-0.3389904201,
0.6307811737,
-0.0588201396,
-0.5515279174,
0.6125768423,
0.5348848104,
-0.2452082485,
-0.3164818287,
0.2116915584,
0.7584434152,
-0.071902357,
-0.5605533719,
-0.5248578787,
0.6787828803,
-0.4135212302,
-0.1987799853,
0.5930790901,
0.4514625967,
0.4398849905,
-0.0466822535,
0.9939183593,
-0.0767842308,
0.4625727236,
0.1339794695,
0.7868251801,
-0.0975769758,
0.0573704615,
-0.1817550063,
-0.5319348574,
-0.1513544172,
0.6978971362,
0.1803058386,
0.0560370386,
0.1497745812,
0.8055344224,
0.2531221211,
0.1652329713,
0.1308591068,
0.2477199137,
0.4615370631,
0.2474161536,
0.7720142603,
-0.223543331,
0.4069419503,
-0.0396082923,
-0.6857020259,
-0.1814495623,
-0.6139551401,
-1.1136757135,
-0.4818173945,
-0.2794156075,
-0.2993907332,
0.3662722111,
0.9077143073,
0.8038125634,
-0.6179671288,
-0.291751951,
-0.027791407,
-0.3369577825,
-0.3707322478,
-0.2503267229,
0.0591570139,
-0.0797968656,
-0.4556300938,
0.1475233585,
0.0931068137,
0.014150653,
-0.3543462157,
-0.3871469796,
-0.0916935429,
0.4014253318,
0.3129070103,
0.5261338353,
-0.4053202868,
-0.3205069304,
0.3357815742,
0.0330720469,
-0.1965300143,
0.9046319723,
-1.034881115,
0.3600476682,
0.3978743553,
0.4204337597,
0.158751592,
0.5878491998,
0.8606693149,
-0.5378332734,
-0.0386888906,
0.2772783935,
0.1350999326,
-0.0406210423,
-0.4465668201,
0.6177369356,
0.3580389917,
-0.6783713102,
-0.7413204312,
0.0583115555,
-1.0541403294,
0.0364976674,
1.1638640165,
-0.5325791836,
0.0241192821,
-0.4545648992,
-0.6823805571,
0.299641788,
-1.0328994989,
1.0107408762,
0.4896437526,
-0.4804956913,
0.1597190946,
-0.5147920847,
0.6608609557,
0.4266659915,
-0.9931337237,
0.1373650879,
0.3644270003,
0.2030356675,
0.0898924842,
1.1491754055,
0.0423812307,
0.2837540209,
0.1972590387,
-0.0228590854,
-0.193282783,
-0.6159027219,
0.4873751998,
-0.0409544297,
-0.0169410482,
-0.0155932484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.12998v1 | ChatLLM Network: More brains, More intelligence | 2023-04-24T08:29:14 | 2023-04-24T08:29:14 | Rui Hao, Linmei Hu, Weijian Qi, Qingliu Wu, Yirui Zhang, Liqiang Nie | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Dialogue-based language models mark a huge milestone in the field of
artificial intelligence, by their impressive ability to interact with users, as
well as a series of challenging tasks prompted by customized instructions.
However, the prevalent large-scale dialogue-based language models like ChatGPT
still have room for improvement, such as unstable responses to questions and
the inability to think cooperatively like humans. Considering the ability of
dialogue-based language models in conversation and their inherent randomness in
thinking, we propose ChatLLM network that allows multiple dialogue-based
language models to interact, provide feedback, and think together. We design
the network of ChatLLMs based on ChatGPT. Specifically, individual instances of
ChatGPT may possess distinct perspectives towards the same problem, and by
consolidating these diverse viewpoints via a separate ChatGPT, the ChatLLM
network system can conduct decision-making more objectively and
comprehensively. In addition, a language-based feedback mechanism comparable to
backpropagation is devised to update the ChatGPTs within the network.
Experiments on two datasets demonstrate that our network attains significant
improvements in problem-solving, leading to observable progress amongst each
member. | [
-0.3866527379,
-0.9108224511,
0.5001864433,
0.4152037203,
0.1612537354,
0.3735198379,
-0.5111762881,
-0.3550826013,
0.2247554213,
0.5223439336,
-0.6642767787,
-0.1251609474,
-0.5551053882,
-0.1059933752,
-0.218588993,
0.9752216935,
0.5097413659,
0.296535641,
-0.1410928518,
-0.2319929749,
-0.7941114902,
-0.6155954599,
-1.1956961155,
-0.7728266716,
0.8073536754,
0.2875422239,
0.9886527061,
0.052514974,
0.7723364234,
0.4189004302,
-0.0661194548,
0.2510508001,
-0.6449505687,
0.3125775456,
-0.2468361557,
-0.5896152854,
-0.569060266,
-0.0887232795,
0.3376250267,
0.784650147,
-0.3411095738,
-0.174503088,
0.0834454671,
0.7085363269,
-0.1302661449,
0.4618171453,
-0.6728658676,
0.0606771596,
0.3323203623,
0.009912801,
-0.4516720474,
-0.4393844008,
0.3870952427,
-0.4126888216,
-0.1043075174,
0.2652400732,
0.4573999941,
0.2161615342,
0.1256743371,
-0.0793375298,
-0.8124868274,
0.6358479261,
-0.7110927105,
0.3134587407,
0.1383829266,
0.2486887574,
-0.3437824547,
-0.5279368758,
-0.4749420881,
-0.2664728761,
0.010599914,
0.4494902194,
0.04034907,
0.0933686867,
0.0099046333,
-0.0187279824,
-0.397741735,
-0.0089425817,
-0.3087168336,
-0.1211007759,
0.7456156015,
0.2042237073,
0.3300917745,
0.1321985275,
-0.1846822053,
0.0147536797,
-0.4566539824,
-0.1975397021,
0.1587213129,
0.383918047,
0.1785157919,
0.5112203956,
-0.3101309538,
0.4979628921,
-0.1512560993,
0.2465098798,
0.1872216314,
-0.3120631874,
-0.2220450491,
-0.1602662057,
0.9003914595,
0.3626483977,
0.4408097267,
-0.2231834978,
-0.0035904427,
-0.1628544182,
0.1491221189,
-0.6449221373,
-0.7859091759,
0.227554217,
-0.4832457602,
-0.1895696074,
-0.3151710629,
-0.4167680442,
-0.6673956513,
-0.3305367827,
0.5596763492,
-0.6366865635,
-0.6691352725,
0.2166639268,
-0.1876378655,
0.0741642788,
0.7244946361,
-0.7117888927,
0.4705647826,
0.6987982988,
0.8485437632,
-0.2179226875,
-0.3423362672,
-0.0663779676,
-0.1782911122,
-0.296525538,
0.9701395631,
-0.7246375084,
-0.3094827235,
-0.41018188,
-0.215535,
-0.4811007977,
-0.5405340791,
0.0285783447,
-0.4217166603,
0.4428452253,
-0.0052684667,
-0.561157167,
-0.3898379505,
0.4872403741,
-0.5522102714,
0.7328253388,
-0.2248368412,
-0.5997040272,
-0.14594163,
-0.925462842,
-0.2054199129,
0.3166234493,
-0.3146286011,
-0.2749086916,
0.0751483813,
0.1765628606,
0.4507622123,
-0.2531795204,
0.3872525096,
-0.4207898974,
-0.1515206695,
0.6313899159,
-0.4239795208,
0.7154861093,
0.1529332548,
0.0083258711,
0.3045242131,
-0.4318039119,
0.3409792483,
0.1297209114,
-0.3490743637,
-0.0568654425,
0.1772167832,
-0.1116995737,
0.217717573,
0.1301806867,
-0.4258953929,
0.1084787101,
-0.4204868674,
0.7067245841,
0.565762639,
-0.041464489,
0.2816604078,
-0.8508361578,
0.2789681554,
0.0818812475,
0.0867578611,
-0.227255106,
-0.9937268496,
-0.9220450521,
-0.0014517744,
0.0058214478,
0.8476694226,
-0.5711596608,
0.0188576262,
-0.181231156,
-0.3304494619,
-0.5709195137,
0.022974886,
0.3769052327,
0.3241552413,
0.3579155505,
-0.7548719049,
-0.3265786767,
-0.7867108583,
-0.2136105001,
-0.3832605779,
0.0229002722,
0.4955383539,
0.3746937513,
-0.0904906392,
1.1353335381,
-0.297952801,
-0.2111411691,
-0.4650768042,
0.0786582157,
0.2873272002,
0.4916384816,
-0.0352193825,
-0.7376665473,
-0.3560679257,
0.2033389509,
-0.6610537767,
0.1245494485,
0.00300276,
-0.1439504474,
-0.250390172,
0.3050487339,
-0.6981141567,
0.114979893,
0.3316957951,
0.0200234987,
0.4642174244,
-0.2165433466,
0.068978481,
-1.2102661133,
-0.1941027641,
-0.3148683906,
-0.1021783724,
-0.6339088082,
-0.0735176429,
-0.4562971592,
-0.4092172384,
-0.2589715123,
0.5056506991,
-0.1230222359,
0.0573079921,
-0.1081209704,
0.4199666977,
-0.0257031675,
1.0631768703,
0.073379159,
0.4661689699,
0.5742414594,
-0.304726243,
0.7579908967,
0.3808244765,
-0.0611470938,
0.4899500906,
-0.7513551116,
0.3917634487,
-0.2200965732,
0.3000009954,
-0.9225696921,
-0.2051361501,
0.2335058153,
-0.6149689555,
0.0749434233,
0.1215397045,
-0.1939314604,
-0.2829461396,
-0.0512778573,
0.1583138853,
0.3202969432,
-0.2416030765,
0.6892797947,
0.475797683,
-0.5071376562,
-0.3612285256,
-0.6282867789,
0.3436568975,
0.1513470262,
-0.9693902135,
-0.1063345,
-0.293084234,
-0.4063207805,
0.1881980896,
0.2191688269,
-0.2365192324,
0.0024042383,
0.3416831195,
0.0180839673,
-0.2379372418,
0.506200254,
-0.3416912556,
0.0323772728,
0.1164659932,
-0.5930535197,
0.6867251396,
-0.4704566598,
-0.4667397738,
-0.3195813298,
0.6244899631,
0.3783177733,
-0.4413055182,
0.6264574528,
0.3894818723,
-0.2445078641,
-0.3703601658,
-0.5171411037,
-0.428832382,
-0.4331500828,
0.6522476077,
-0.3518952429,
-1.2005776167,
0.5543019176,
-0.3324495852,
0.2557648718,
-0.0252358187,
0.921400547,
-0.3015394509,
1.2351055145,
0.5362204909,
-0.0386677161,
0.4346467853,
-0.2163737714,
0.4912159741,
-0.7566463947,
-0.423709929,
-0.3333154023,
-0.2931006253,
-0.388484627,
-0.5173798203,
0.0203414448,
-0.1523425728,
-0.2353488207,
0.1514919251,
-0.5539428592,
0.4135169089,
0.55773592,
0.3781133294,
0.4050906897,
-0.2047986835,
-0.325504005,
0.3857437372,
-1.1327031851,
-0.3467069864,
0.7492460012,
0.2125328481,
0.7464959025,
0.2383980751,
0.5108207464,
0.178517431,
0.5406492352,
-0.9200434685,
0.7382057905,
0.1849113405,
-0.6076092124,
-0.3594495654,
-0.6288637519,
-0.9720096588,
0.2985347211,
-0.236535117,
-0.9857389927,
-0.2069031447,
-0.0099702254,
-0.4283959568,
0.1471305937,
-0.8938872814,
0.6057321429,
0.0162405595,
-0.223029986,
-0.6368511915,
-0.6225161552,
0.2978931963,
-0.0007039618,
0.1909736395,
-0.416993022,
0.3459613323,
0.5963897705,
-0.5033612847,
0.8632210493,
0.2316530496,
0.163542673,
0.4895162582,
-0.0371749736,
0.2504983842,
0.3062061071,
-0.0950141698,
0.0473286621,
-0.3251922429,
-0.27424559,
-0.7482884526,
0.7028255463,
-0.9340560436,
-0.8526489735,
-0.0932260677,
-0.8013816476,
-0.4018084407,
0.1689368486,
-0.0980234519,
0.6947514415,
-0.2481641918,
0.1758903116,
0.6207507253,
-0.0696815774,
0.5342558026,
0.2538506687,
-0.5668897629,
-0.3014150262,
0.9321851134,
-0.0004403028,
0.352355063,
0.2427051216,
0.1215803027,
-0.1416120976,
-0.5077985525,
-0.2366941273,
0.033833459,
-0.6035959721,
0.0283943024,
-0.7402856946,
-0.6179109216,
-0.1067928448,
0.1862144768,
-0.3762767613,
-0.5798079967,
0.1680990458,
0.1790783554,
0.5167003274,
0.8011801243,
0.0640231892,
0.4406860769,
-0.7062423229,
-0.0923707336,
0.7507296801,
0.4354701042,
0.1688072979,
-0.1270367652,
-0.4124095738,
0.2543336451,
-0.3537467122,
-0.8357099891,
0.2762188613,
0.2691141367,
0.4602112472,
0.05598801,
-0.2659818232,
0.31866768,
-0.6305758357,
0.4453907311,
0.3532186151,
-0.5756127834,
0.3922127783,
-0.3950862288,
0.4983370304,
0.2785939276,
-0.0693648905,
-0.7799086571,
-0.8686556816,
-0.6019142866,
-0.407074213,
0.6428856254,
0.5260117054,
0.2511062026,
-0.057776209,
0.0085211191,
-0.3185118437,
0.1354600936,
-0.5584657788,
0.1190246195,
-0.3192152083,
-0.1401918083,
0.3670797348,
0.3317383826,
-0.2459644973,
-0.1133017689,
0.7190981507,
-0.2883967161,
0.4841064215,
0.129084155,
0.0810162127,
0.071320422,
0.2588222921,
0.2899292409,
0.6010173559,
-0.0395033434,
0.1131337956,
0.3150203526,
-0.4481682777,
-0.0004927755,
-0.0430366695,
0.1592918485,
-0.1723934412,
0.125240624,
1.0072162151,
0.0293665435,
-0.5750809908,
0.2319670916,
-0.4938768446,
-0.0161046796,
-0.0968780145,
0.5493037701,
0.6324938536,
0.5803560019,
0.3247378767,
0.6532378793,
-0.0705935806,
-0.5311412811,
0.3260345459,
0.5169159174,
-0.623144567,
-0.1779173762,
0.48865816,
0.4198006392,
-0.9600551128,
0.6436941624,
-0.0789050758,
-0.6698854566,
0.856933713,
0.3639701903,
0.7950569391,
-0.236310184,
0.3449971974,
0.144514069,
0.2860569954,
-0.1959139854,
0.2042521089,
0.2037110031,
-1.2142816782,
-0.7132361531,
-0.3610187471,
-0.8595328331,
0.1050281674,
-0.1407019496,
0.075370729,
-0.613917172,
-0.3346938193,
-0.0421711989,
0.1002835855,
-0.556445241,
0.2852303088,
0.0573092215,
0.4444445968,
-0.3489138484,
1.0554468632,
0.6948878169,
-0.2345986664,
-0.9124917984,
-0.3884965777,
-0.1513879448,
-0.9129582047,
0.412175566,
0.3910088241,
-0.3115665615,
0.182312265,
-0.5431597829,
-0.926096797,
0.8632437587,
0.0654769391,
-0.5848557949,
0.1704632938,
-0.0438320003,
0.5380046964,
-0.5719955564,
0.5830149055,
0.314215064,
0.2598130107,
0.1820909381,
-1.0029579401,
-0.1982357502,
-0.3920005262,
-0.0041339528,
0.3148867488,
-0.9427351356,
0.803947866,
-0.399708122,
-0.1258866489,
-0.012242754,
0.6087648869,
0.2256183475,
0.0104798647,
0.3725762665,
0.5655329227,
0.9268584847,
-0.0331015401,
0.6445804834,
-0.230380103,
0.4275665879,
1.4204893112,
-0.2877005339,
0.7115414739,
0.1178544462,
-0.0046520503,
0.4219168425,
0.4769465029,
0.0695287734,
0.2546153665,
0.264770925,
-0.4054556489,
-0.3035113215,
-0.211046651,
-0.2279593349,
0.3037403822,
0.5670371056,
-0.0400439166,
-0.1021960378,
0.1126813069,
0.243384406,
-0.045431681,
-0.2923443317,
0.821241796,
0.2266043127,
-0.7292193174,
0.1361367255,
-0.2410162389,
0.3366026282,
-0.3630311787,
-0.0947158188,
-0.3223752081,
0.2331925631,
-0.2097106278,
-0.7717036009,
0.240846917,
-0.3032255173,
-0.0683004782,
-0.1831373125,
0.8272926211,
-0.6102567911,
-0.534452498,
0.3831136227,
1.0112917423,
0.2383755893,
0.1044942215,
-0.8628828526,
-0.1259179562,
-0.1213377416,
-0.2630336881,
0.2493546158,
0.5082140565,
-0.0958250836,
1.0650475025,
0.7321157455,
0.1957468987,
0.1375389546,
0.2822979689,
0.9691307545,
-0.4017675221,
-0.2808469832,
-0.8462492228,
0.224443242,
-0.5272357464,
-0.3539718986,
0.5406365395,
0.276245445,
0.641084671,
0.2755470872,
0.927869916,
-0.1047896296,
0.3753234148,
-0.2670555413,
0.9123988748,
-0.1750416756,
0.2165346444,
-0.0128295301,
-0.8617524505,
-0.3522309363,
0.7610174417,
-0.1639148891,
0.0343525484,
0.7577809095,
1.0144376755,
0.1230432242,
0.4741743207,
0.3611701429,
0.4150787294,
0.3279794753,
0.8742561936,
1.0731003284,
0.0063125268,
0.5972947478,
0.0558096208,
-0.2615024745,
-0.1060682014,
-0.6896156669,
-1.1914774179,
-0.4654226601,
-0.4000566304,
-0.0850830078,
0.1713211536,
1.009431839,
0.9324561954,
-0.7607877254,
-0.3973182738,
-0.2617111802,
0.4551781714,
-0.2351540327,
-0.2178014368,
-0.0014982919,
-0.7224807143,
-0.5547934771,
0.4287513494,
0.6869464517,
-0.3600369096,
-0.4286620319,
-0.1256156713,
-0.2563144565,
0.5359795094,
0.5318043828,
0.0366110913,
-0.4360775054,
-0.432626754,
0.0702824667,
-0.1127802506,
0.3162148893,
0.6741540432,
-0.8624254465,
0.5498391986,
0.4738197029,
0.8390954733,
0.4376794398,
-0.2952638865,
0.7584609389,
-0.3840450943,
0.1285413653,
0.4643080533,
0.3148766458,
0.4132159948,
-0.1010947824,
0.4894868135,
0.2419818789,
-0.7877035141,
-0.2457927018,
0.4325592518,
-0.8053354621,
-0.3476752937,
0.8526886702,
-0.2562674582,
-0.2460592687,
-0.3586129248,
-0.5451460481,
0.1542992145,
-0.6852073073,
0.8375447989,
0.9462295175,
-0.4955363274,
-0.5684425831,
-0.5095575452,
0.3781964183,
0.8034627438,
-0.968333602,
-0.0293476563,
0.353109479,
-0.0733833238,
0.3773001134,
0.8571761847,
0.2394090891,
0.0034133552,
-0.1359439194,
-0.1363518536,
0.1185366735,
-0.390509069,
-0.0295922495,
0.285977602,
0.0560289919,
-0.0341628753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.13731v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.13731v2 | Text-to-Audio Generation using Instruction-Tuned LLM and Latent Diffusion Model | 2023-04-24T07:45:28 | 2023-05-29T12:09:08 | Deepanway Ghosal, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Soujanya Poria | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | The immense scale of the recent large language models (LLM) allows many
interesting properties, such as, instruction- and chain-of-thought-based
fine-tuning, that has significantly improved zero- and few-shot performance in
many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Inspired by such successes, we
adopt such an instruction-tuned LLM Flan-T5 as the text encoder for
text-to-audio (TTA) generation -- a task where the goal is to generate an audio
from its textual description. The prior works on TTA either pre-trained a joint
text-audio encoder or used a non-instruction-tuned model, such as, T5.
Consequently, our latent diffusion model (LDM)-based approach TANGO outperforms
the state-of-the-art AudioLDM on most metrics and stays comparable on the rest
on AudioCaps test set, despite training the LDM on a 63 times smaller dataset
and keeping the text encoder frozen. This improvement might also be attributed
to the adoption of audio pressure level-based sound mixing for training set
augmentation, whereas the prior methods take a random mix. | [
-0.4174129665,
-0.77961272,
0.5468495488,
0.0475725569,
-0.4545746744,
0.0612875819,
-0.2615835369,
-0.4104112387,
0.110326156,
0.604483068,
-0.6163901091,
-0.8196948767,
-0.5977999568,
0.1203200892,
-0.5671052337,
1.0371315479,
0.3375706673,
-0.0492040515,
0.1111277342,
0.1126771346,
-0.6838342547,
-0.041486375,
-0.8756120801,
-0.3285894096,
0.4478802085,
0.3738906682,
0.3728715777,
0.6160057783,
0.1943285614,
0.1081871241,
-0.3708538711,
0.3035469651,
-0.4261637926,
0.0605107211,
0.1880059987,
-0.3739611506,
-0.7054142952,
-0.0061222184,
0.6611667871,
0.4652526081,
-0.2417099625,
0.2233569771,
-0.0516997688,
0.6552106738,
-0.4679821432,
-0.2643253207,
-0.7948390841,
0.2650927901,
-0.060514383,
-0.5855537653,
-0.6687303782,
-0.3327537179,
-0.0368636437,
-0.6070746779,
0.4125989377,
0.1225081086,
0.5067461133,
0.5445946455,
-0.2786064744,
-0.4330894649,
-1.1479654312,
0.7123764157,
-0.8402191997,
0.4791636765,
0.330046773,
-0.0009668709,
-0.147409901,
-0.6263253093,
-0.5528099537,
0.0687331259,
0.5418698788,
0.2032390982,
0.083662279,
0.1036231965,
0.0668034852,
0.5839256048,
-0.4148830771,
0.2308343053,
-0.2470960915,
0.1468030661,
0.4885723889,
-0.0148297548,
0.3244632483,
0.0695718676,
-0.2933686972,
-0.095447354,
-0.8273895383,
-0.2606606185,
0.4471066892,
0.3815440238,
-0.157184273,
0.5225929618,
0.1583022028,
0.77831918,
0.2597746849,
-0.3271314502,
0.2870275676,
-0.3995371163,
-0.3392843306,
0.4494127333,
0.9018902183,
0.1514407992,
0.1059461832,
-0.2406096905,
-0.5046839714,
-0.0424167514,
0.2697823942,
-0.7694448829,
-0.0005697012,
0.111729458,
-0.1272021234,
-0.4071033299,
-0.1163076982,
-0.6962085366,
-0.0827556178,
-0.1321998835,
0.6424883604,
-0.4734817743,
-0.212267682,
0.2064916492,
-0.0802562088,
0.2479074597,
0.1082093045,
-1.1635516882,
0.3030818105,
0.680762291,
0.9535284042,
-0.3132098019,
0.2073582709,
-0.8018962741,
0.3177435398,
-0.6182447076,
0.7315016389,
-0.594326973,
-0.552238822,
0.0951610804,
-0.4614579976,
0.0647863746,
-0.741212666,
0.5699294209,
-0.4493794739,
0.4225542545,
0.1561558098,
-0.8033345938,
0.0461270772,
-0.1347695142,
-0.5691912174,
1.2682932615,
-0.1139005199,
-0.473187983,
0.5937376022,
-0.6829381585,
-0.6559411287,
-0.2473318726,
0.0427413471,
-0.6478335857,
0.2526094317,
0.3689166605,
0.4302598834,
-0.6002063155,
0.250619024,
-0.0285831131,
-0.4838799834,
0.0825960413,
-0.6629442573,
0.253677994,
0.046905756,
-0.2949955761,
0.0240843035,
-0.8534691334,
-0.1972223073,
-0.0390229858,
-0.5129321814,
-0.0065296786,
0.061213132,
0.1535938829,
0.1309442371,
0.0443100929,
-0.4512501955,
-0.1437380463,
-0.8365983367,
0.4387326241,
0.5698533654,
0.2329638302,
0.5063624978,
-0.5866839886,
0.4558520317,
-0.0419946052,
-0.22280927,
-0.4059682786,
-0.5072543025,
-0.6474432349,
-0.0651733279,
0.2873955667,
0.5499712825,
-0.4856248796,
0.5901864171,
-0.0899510384,
-0.3839390576,
-0.7439908385,
0.1236040518,
0.2525298595,
0.5884994864,
0.5270732641,
-0.2344109863,
-0.2464905381,
-0.4165382981,
-0.0557886176,
0.1076966897,
-0.2699663937,
0.403228581,
0.1097275987,
-0.0211472865,
0.8360186219,
-0.4203632176,
-0.5061494112,
-0.2611294389,
0.2681584358,
0.1600330621,
0.5964277983,
0.4721560776,
-0.4008755684,
-0.2489765882,
-0.0555359684,
-0.4352682829,
-0.3215436637,
-0.1042626351,
0.0379257649,
0.3125017583,
0.4866291285,
-0.421210438,
0.1320861131,
0.4526138306,
-0.2236079872,
0.3363169432,
-0.3120307624,
0.1916257292,
-1.5423574448,
-0.1621602327,
-0.0398861021,
-0.3380488157,
-0.6503425241,
-0.3887103796,
-0.3783967495,
-0.2768461406,
-0.5226136446,
0.348954469,
-0.3899318278,
-0.3529893756,
-0.4583945274,
0.3907867074,
-0.0580995977,
0.3838397264,
0.1474626064,
0.934550643,
0.4734764993,
-0.8454592228,
0.1251604855,
0.1459804326,
-0.2813836932,
0.2331016213,
-0.6435785294,
0.5133342743,
0.002653196,
0.1359952837,
-0.8584011197,
0.000721218,
0.0177793764,
-0.3345595896,
0.5086661577,
-0.0685996413,
-0.6233816147,
0.0312514529,
-0.1284720004,
0.5220857263,
0.8268580437,
-0.6632452011,
0.6612312794,
0.2640016377,
-0.0929257497,
-0.2914438546,
-0.6370087862,
-0.0354119428,
-0.4679652452,
-0.5728330612,
0.6401460767,
-0.2150685191,
0.0342841782,
-0.2371097654,
-0.2074812055,
-0.1628914177,
-0.1401295513,
0.0834349319,
0.1445242316,
-0.6087411642,
0.241740346,
0.3817692399,
-0.0337127075,
0.0815112144,
-0.553681612,
0.4724447727,
0.3670638204,
-0.1063961238,
-0.5770584345,
0.0882184729,
0.3181812763,
-0.1185686663,
0.5174424648,
0.6185244918,
-0.0766185522,
-0.5644681454,
-0.345841378,
-0.2967481315,
-0.4686396718,
0.222224474,
-0.0400080569,
-0.8214703798,
0.2274201065,
-0.2868412733,
0.3124403059,
0.31475389,
0.4064287543,
-0.2391965687,
0.7680092454,
0.5768930316,
0.1035951823,
0.7780806422,
-0.2143191099,
-0.0787103549,
-0.8024491072,
-0.0597149916,
-0.4485422671,
-0.287102133,
-0.515545845,
-0.5714684725,
0.3390114605,
-0.0997030511,
-0.0746779442,
0.1043883562,
-0.5020309687,
0.4416513443,
0.4318073094,
0.0983536318,
0.3048508465,
0.1133325994,
-0.0648451298,
0.0588927492,
-0.7197691202,
-0.4952847958,
1.235953331,
0.2904992104,
0.5937353969,
0.0590316541,
0.9627603292,
0.4398164451,
-0.0523168594,
-0.6856043339,
0.5150989294,
-0.5535011292,
-0.2820681334,
-0.3433994055,
-0.2620990574,
-0.7808564901,
0.0723964795,
-0.5464163423,
-0.4644768834,
-0.2550350726,
0.2452861369,
-0.2198646367,
0.3255544007,
-0.5534110665,
0.5743182898,
0.0434916541,
-0.3824053407,
-0.339610815,
-0.3221519887,
0.2332532704,
-0.2350224555,
0.2074031234,
-0.1965340972,
-0.0547221862,
0.7415671945,
-0.3267160058,
0.7130363584,
-0.1192636713,
-0.5563989282,
0.3253495693,
-0.0663049817,
0.4019235373,
0.1423703432,
-0.0962545276,
-0.0760236233,
-0.3516998887,
0.018163098,
-0.64084512,
0.509078145,
-0.8053430915,
-0.5770410895,
0.0533080883,
-0.5826463699,
-0.3227577806,
0.0385552384,
0.5371413827,
0.7231215239,
-0.2953425944,
0.2047705501,
1.0083795786,
-0.4618834853,
0.6136260629,
0.409091264,
-0.2004791647,
-0.5260392427,
0.922496736,
-0.1888695657,
0.5501885414,
0.7964848876,
0.3027161658,
-0.2640800774,
-0.6766545773,
-0.4928272069,
0.1521362811,
-0.3900368512,
-0.0184203926,
-0.3191618919,
-0.2382212281,
-0.1756431311,
-0.0982305631,
-0.6727625728,
-0.33541587,
-0.8335971236,
-0.1307654083,
0.4524413049,
0.8448573351,
0.228431955,
0.5045877695,
-0.7285993099,
0.6088495255,
0.125162378,
0.1989463121,
-0.1786021441,
-1.0251203775,
-0.3149024248,
-0.002248998,
-0.2989189327,
-0.9076787233,
0.4133084416,
0.4241132736,
0.0850381702,
0.250044018,
0.0512821265,
0.3808825612,
-0.7187167406,
0.840996027,
0.1745158881,
-0.7673091888,
0.7595351338,
-0.4269491732,
0.4230002165,
0.0143263126,
-0.2328668386,
-0.1486015618,
-0.8028074503,
-0.4887903333,
-0.9343466759,
0.7486670613,
0.3780132234,
0.30210796,
0.1282619089,
0.3248743713,
0.2106388211,
0.1261532754,
-0.7278318405,
-0.2663477659,
-0.2801046073,
-0.4170078337,
-0.1916213334,
-0.2281879932,
0.0658666864,
0.0849447697,
0.8454378247,
-0.0445395149,
0.2470993847,
0.0821714997,
0.017771041,
-0.0590969585,
0.5286725163,
0.8698596954,
0.1201299727,
-0.1178599298,
0.0434774756,
0.2233036458,
-0.5308011174,
0.3027823567,
-0.1629265696,
-0.24026604,
0.0253325794,
0.3529962599,
1.2383605242,
0.3555997908,
-0.491766721,
0.2136546969,
-0.0102986339,
-0.4823995233,
-0.3666132689,
0.5149838328,
0.3059504926,
0.0218138732,
0.3951350152,
0.0591039881,
0.0138985151,
-0.197036311,
0.2711134553,
0.1595051587,
-0.4012716711,
-0.2324114293,
1.0157105923,
0.3109322786,
-0.6757011414,
0.3927973211,
0.0225642044,
0.2554044425,
0.5894751549,
0.8643663526,
1.1125141382,
-0.0946898386,
0.0592068061,
0.2369090468,
0.3615200818,
-0.075298816,
0.2548183203,
-0.2075065523,
-0.7036873102,
-0.557918191,
-0.7657781839,
-0.2141515166,
0.2782231569,
-0.6069072485,
0.3673346937,
-0.4957655668,
-0.247703582,
-0.1004164442,
-0.3266653717,
-0.3711047769,
0.4759540558,
0.075453788,
0.687728405,
-0.7779200673,
0.8402094245,
0.3556036651,
-0.2348332703,
-0.817520082,
0.4955020547,
-0.3285076916,
-0.3429281116,
0.3769762218,
0.0233608447,
-0.3815156221,
0.208325848,
-0.2617953122,
-0.63811481,
1.1978526115,
0.7360737324,
-0.8182535172,
0.0331149101,
0.2408117503,
0.6139643788,
-0.5291337967,
-0.0405374207,
0.5069603324,
0.1088248342,
0.3513199091,
-0.827316761,
-0.2694744766,
-0.0391577967,
0.0257478897,
0.2287468165,
-0.4691934586,
0.510086596,
-0.2454476207,
-0.1046685874,
-0.1669050008,
0.9244562387,
0.3361988664,
0.3606777489,
0.5826829672,
0.4604837298,
0.6946864128,
-0.0076840087,
0.7702795267,
-0.4250402451,
-0.1010867357,
1.1290384531,
-0.1269832104,
0.9926613569,
0.4168111682,
0.017036112,
0.4457881153,
0.6271662712,
0.203660965,
0.5915341377,
-0.0787118822,
-0.4680510461,
-0.1581556648,
-0.0523801185,
-0.2663798332,
0.4546705484,
0.3813228607,
-0.5514287949,
0.2518109977,
0.1516584456,
-0.3198900819,
0.1892100573,
-0.4399791956,
1.1209083796,
0.2110165954,
-0.4237212837,
0.5485048294,
-0.0208015684,
0.8336791992,
-0.3562528789,
-0.030423129,
-0.1332980096,
-0.2188149244,
-0.1065513417,
-0.6659733057,
0.3171021044,
0.2619976699,
-0.4397300184,
-0.364205122,
0.5850493908,
-0.6652684808,
-0.4123472273,
0.355014354,
0.3092007935,
0.0998082757,
0.385022074,
-0.353885591,
-0.1353786886,
-0.0041494803,
-0.2810843587,
0.1749212891,
0.5489759445,
0.3376450837,
0.4659537971,
0.6082264781,
0.2767663896,
0.2574715614,
0.4621572196,
0.4353299439,
-0.729388535,
-0.6739470959,
-0.8174751997,
0.2070101202,
0.3974572122,
-0.2798655629,
0.1726162136,
0.6864604354,
0.5319342613,
-0.164617449,
0.7119407654,
0.3252762258,
0.5468428135,
-1.1670576334,
0.6024461389,
-0.7099125385,
0.5769428015,
-0.4402308464,
-0.9190123081,
-0.0114462823,
0.3786527216,
0.0432853214,
0.2742516398,
0.6031319499,
0.787800312,
-0.0838683024,
0.1148155183,
0.4727880955,
0.0396810025,
0.2438691407,
0.5675858855,
0.4950729012,
-0.4651201367,
0.7035623193,
0.0455582142,
0.2214044333,
0.0700142011,
-0.8577929139,
-0.9343307018,
-0.4574189484,
-0.3522939086,
-0.1750658453,
-0.0167960823,
0.7717958689,
0.6287266016,
-0.5969889164,
-0.2795731425,
-0.4465639889,
0.1701860726,
-0.2152001411,
-0.1872877181,
0.1640340388,
-0.3196543455,
-1.0207805634,
0.8864819407,
0.3901925087,
0.3325283527,
-0.1977876276,
-0.2686702311,
-0.0368429236,
0.3405534029,
0.5236988664,
-0.0669278875,
-0.6318895817,
-0.2180663049,
-0.1148257703,
-0.0548520721,
0.4471673667,
0.6605340838,
-0.6577584147,
0.4189560115,
0.3786425591,
0.5691539645,
0.7684490681,
-0.2025749832,
0.9625858665,
-1.1594934464,
0.2225641906,
0.191782698,
0.0333125517,
0.4268956482,
-0.214855507,
0.3409792483,
0.1212898567,
-0.4477937818,
-0.806404233,
0.0902978703,
-0.9092858434,
-0.0559446365,
1.2439882755,
0.241802007,
-0.1017244607,
0.1467786878,
-0.1755039692,
0.6438595653,
-0.6153575778,
0.6799249649,
0.4137258232,
-0.0522352196,
-0.3593657613,
-0.5462711453,
0.6737976074,
0.4718209505,
-0.8747964501,
-0.0805484876,
0.4266584516,
0.3103841245,
-0.1192133874,
0.7310615182,
0.1047612429,
0.3130633533,
-0.0027335926,
-0.0228613354,
-0.1598551124,
-0.4396685362,
-0.2940986156,
0.3032298684,
0.2000293434,
-0.4088338315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11872v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11872v2 | Generation-driven Contrastive Self-training for Zero-shot Text Classification with Instruction-following LLM | 2023-04-24T07:35:38 | 2024-04-15T02:40:54 | Ruohong Zhang, Yau-Shian Wang, Yiming Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in zero-shot
language understanding has garnered significant attention. However, employing
LLMs for large-scale inference or domain-specific fine-tuning requires immense
computational resources due to their substantial model size. To overcome these
limitations, we introduce a novel method, namely GenCo, which leverages the
strong generative power of LLMs to assist in training a smaller and more
adaptable language model. In our method, an LLM plays an important role in the
self-training loop of a smaller model in two important ways. Firstly, the LLM
is used to augment each input instance with a variety of possible
continuations, enriching its semantic context for better understanding.
Secondly, it helps crafting additional high-quality training pairs, by
rewriting input texts conditioned on predicted labels. This ensures the
generated texts are highly relevant to the predicted labels, alleviating the
prediction error during pseudo-labeling, while reducing the dependency on large
volumes of unlabeled text. In our experiments, GenCo outperforms previous
state-of-the-art methods when only limited ($<5\%$ of original) in-domain text
data is available. Notably, our approach surpasses the performance of Alpaca-7B
with human prompts, highlighting the potential of leveraging LLM for
self-training. | [
-0.1196618825,
-0.5375011563,
0.5470333099,
-0.0299866814,
-0.4791654646,
0.2958032787,
-0.2411931157,
-0.3429783881,
0.0583874211,
0.6805643439,
-0.5287988186,
-0.8362722993,
-0.4715487659,
0.2784692943,
-0.2541565299,
1.122528553,
0.1143231019,
-0.1740673482,
-0.252284348,
-0.1519622505,
-0.3603784144,
-0.3380622864,
-0.5691536665,
-0.4289934933,
0.7151495218,
0.6485393047,
0.2082503885,
0.8492681384,
-0.1687632203,
0.2747510374,
0.0082420753,
0.191189006,
-0.5285899043,
0.3103728294,
-0.0702519789,
-0.4208321571,
-0.1288134009,
0.039220456,
0.5110899806,
0.6325804591,
-0.0218248013,
-0.0945188478,
0.3682969213,
0.350160718,
-0.7662337422,
0.1307898462,
-0.8017378449,
0.1451449096,
-0.0711292475,
-0.4039973021,
-0.7059392333,
0.0627402291,
-0.1717506945,
-0.642406702,
0.6736124158,
-0.1377562284,
0.596666038,
0.2526393235,
-0.3203853667,
-0.3288586438,
-0.6667929292,
0.8482518792,
-0.5856080055,
0.2980058491,
0.3284206092,
0.0881283581,
-0.1213256568,
-0.5787805915,
-0.6763287783,
-0.1116405874,
0.0737650171,
0.4147385061,
0.075331673,
0.1692591012,
0.0910389498,
0.4283834398,
-0.4659676254,
0.6226302385,
-0.224966675,
-0.1806981266,
0.3059051931,
0.102620706,
0.1989423782,
-0.102248162,
-0.4468368292,
-0.1588698924,
-0.8598501682,
-0.2729925811,
0.1757691652,
0.4044738412,
-0.236424908,
0.3438167274,
-0.3586865366,
0.7784128189,
0.2007465959,
-0.1822755188,
0.2619224191,
-0.1840170473,
-0.4400125742,
0.1669664234,
0.9830925465,
0.101754643,
-0.0983587727,
-0.2523503602,
0.0217512678,
-0.0918357298,
0.0898704529,
-1.1723761559,
-0.0365843512,
-0.0122904731,
-0.1379218549,
-0.5399435759,
-0.2208203673,
-1.0395091772,
-0.407656163,
-0.0517648757,
0.2860382497,
-0.264557153,
0.3008662462,
-0.0161250904,
0.1487210542,
0.4102355838,
0.3681887388,
-1.2345408201,
-0.0974097103,
0.3944580257,
0.8553565741,
-0.0667170882,
-0.3065990806,
-0.7333106399,
0.3103541136,
-0.5410394669,
0.9203423858,
-0.5096493959,
-0.524179399,
0.1311714053,
-0.030456597,
-0.0444148332,
-0.51071316,
0.4942277372,
-0.444424212,
0.52051121,
0.2037996501,
-0.6765127778,
0.0357124545,
0.188293606,
-0.3169240057,
0.8830094934,
0.1212451309,
-0.6012049317,
0.2448411137,
-0.132461518,
-0.4426338971,
0.3668000102,
-0.5337777138,
-0.6903280616,
0.0006093894,
0.2733586431,
0.7131491899,
-0.3765247166,
-0.1151647791,
-0.3911526501,
-0.3048732877,
0.0184082314,
-0.4825824201,
0.5469467044,
0.2718896568,
-0.472296685,
0.0898327604,
-0.9175501466,
-0.0987558663,
0.3377274871,
-0.2355262637,
-0.3554397523,
-0.2676153779,
-0.5674949288,
0.197236672,
0.1685210615,
-0.59858495,
0.2291433811,
-0.5504359603,
0.2194501609,
0.686842382,
-0.01778486,
0.5831781626,
-0.0664639995,
0.7443311214,
-0.2191703171,
-0.0170786642,
-0.6646918654,
-0.2851829529,
-1.0727500916,
-0.4512628317,
0.3892320693,
0.512448132,
-1.0409847498,
0.7235534191,
0.0042799218,
-0.349042505,
-0.5450288653,
0.479909569,
0.5539453626,
0.9325805306,
0.5481287241,
-0.2155695707,
-0.3299762011,
-0.5854043365,
0.294991672,
0.0273558386,
-0.2029728889,
0.3147658408,
0.1476061046,
-0.3528705239,
0.6890117526,
-0.5367429852,
-0.4814294875,
-0.5361394286,
0.3805128634,
0.1238874644,
0.3049303293,
0.4918645024,
-0.1819026619,
-0.6293303967,
0.132596761,
-0.8733381629,
-0.4989867806,
-0.5235417485,
-0.1287713647,
0.2994625866,
0.7595973015,
-0.070591338,
0.2865556777,
0.5998921394,
-0.2205508947,
0.3226619065,
-0.504357636,
0.0036703707,
-1.1129260063,
-0.2800542116,
-0.0008540846,
-0.1528348476,
-0.7111362219,
-0.0291035976,
0.2401008457,
-0.024865251,
-0.4166104794,
0.6283838749,
-0.5915237069,
0.0757989064,
-0.7003717422,
0.1376357973,
0.2045442015,
0.4907310605,
0.0993553102,
0.8659524918,
0.5490327477,
-0.6154502034,
0.0764184743,
0.1734843552,
-0.335364908,
0.4120849371,
-0.4649568498,
0.3936766386,
-0.2814271152,
0.3551467061,
-0.9637709856,
-0.1042501256,
0.4138080478,
-0.4783101678,
0.5593445897,
-0.1553653926,
-0.2785013616,
-0.1468300521,
-0.3819041848,
0.40025267,
0.6471136212,
-0.9507241845,
0.6370944381,
-0.0612915605,
-0.2361230105,
-0.5877830982,
-0.7566153407,
0.1118007675,
-0.1616287529,
-0.1034191623,
0.4036286771,
-0.191715613,
0.3453292549,
-0.35700652,
0.0714258477,
0.0773048699,
0.1253448129,
0.2160795927,
0.4077684581,
0.08741045,
0.1987671703,
0.4263947308,
-0.1380486041,
-0.149543941,
-0.254314512,
0.6130258441,
0.2082275599,
-0.0544349998,
-0.4489167929,
0.2266167402,
0.1162098795,
-0.1253436208,
0.826167345,
0.3780249953,
0.049004361,
-0.7699744105,
-0.3683549166,
-0.0796653181,
-0.4774610102,
0.1964072883,
-0.4016608894,
-1.109459877,
0.3717300892,
0.035216555,
-0.1309819669,
0.5277318358,
0.6478002667,
-0.3038953543,
0.6689484119,
0.7028635144,
-0.0900131688,
0.625443697,
-0.312007755,
-0.1210867018,
-0.7894980311,
-0.3527193069,
-0.5269123912,
0.071175456,
-0.7016644478,
-0.6089403033,
-0.0524337254,
0.0820040032,
-0.0682696551,
0.3080840707,
-0.5172097087,
0.6941457391,
0.3997680247,
0.1233370453,
0.2541479766,
0.1933099031,
-0.2359395027,
0.1437054873,
-0.8684550524,
-0.2522773445,
1.1195123196,
0.2535985708,
0.8919711709,
-0.3478458226,
1.1573586464,
0.2004045099,
0.5406599641,
-0.8319451809,
0.5244908333,
-0.390748322,
-0.1696312279,
-0.219382301,
-0.6679195762,
-1.2172396183,
0.4603781998,
-0.1775381267,
-0.2300233245,
0.2040508986,
0.2979497015,
-0.4824120998,
0.1916760057,
-0.7081755996,
0.7684015632,
-0.220736593,
-0.3905786872,
-0.0972056612,
-0.5010043979,
0.1322139949,
-0.1856212765,
0.1730434448,
-0.0242065191,
-0.1951108128,
0.5412302613,
-0.2668620646,
1.1427525282,
0.0692274496,
-0.4194486141,
0.533592701,
0.1088797674,
0.3769789636,
-0.2598920166,
0.0925314128,
0.2186613977,
-0.5390787721,
-0.4633307159,
-0.5868868232,
0.8565425873,
-0.7723437548,
-0.5345804691,
-0.5560043454,
-0.2685064971,
-0.2209778279,
0.1666511297,
0.4675233662,
0.3711092472,
-0.1664306074,
0.1948014498,
0.7342281938,
-0.5196328163,
0.4827366173,
0.6482234597,
-0.0400270782,
-0.6527714729,
1.0331845284,
-0.0493795313,
0.4075409174,
0.6060421467,
0.2720484436,
-0.3222083747,
-0.7178567052,
-0.563023448,
0.2743924558,
-0.704328537,
-0.4877129495,
-0.5729653239,
-0.1813538522,
-0.4543260634,
-0.3538369238,
-0.2201032192,
-0.0352708548,
-0.732193172,
-0.175871551,
-0.0338433199,
0.4842212498,
0.1031050086,
0.5739833713,
-0.5980706215,
0.3867644668,
0.5895539522,
0.3510570824,
-0.057386443,
-1.0742660761,
-0.2237407863,
-0.2566375136,
-0.3037461042,
-0.768140316,
0.4989843667,
0.2965064049,
0.4701955616,
0.4112195671,
0.0570591465,
0.4446709156,
-0.535353899,
0.4666873515,
0.463873744,
-0.7171087265,
0.618070364,
-0.3104701638,
0.5247243047,
0.6697419882,
0.3589885235,
-0.3946704566,
-0.4306780696,
-0.5074675679,
-0.728367269,
0.7029771209,
0.0758217126,
0.3894032538,
-0.2942870855,
0.5382835865,
0.2921027243,
-0.0182276089,
-0.8617950678,
-0.1806606352,
-0.3341413438,
-0.4520606101,
-0.2106178999,
-0.4577952921,
0.114173539,
-0.0457499027,
0.7059486508,
-0.5314680338,
0.0800636485,
0.2130882889,
-0.2052213252,
0.0372318923,
0.4296720028,
0.5771017075,
0.1949691027,
-0.1222264245,
0.3481009603,
0.3670298159,
-0.2259223908,
0.2536389828,
0.1666506529,
-0.4373522997,
-0.1866872758,
0.4056739211,
0.8701612949,
0.1568666697,
-0.496963799,
0.4307507873,
0.0035879053,
-0.3097731471,
-0.0377681293,
0.2466325909,
-0.1610509157,
0.0615381375,
0.2330244482,
-0.4420630336,
0.0287265629,
-0.5906590819,
0.1159182265,
0.2983216643,
-0.3336956501,
-0.1357161403,
0.5102006197,
0.4997388422,
-0.0407146513,
0.5024617314,
-0.4094171524,
-0.3130911291,
0.6487737894,
0.7698019743,
1.0730528831,
-0.4470610619,
0.5160488486,
0.4585828185,
0.0795631781,
0.177883029,
-0.2456544489,
-0.3293014765,
-0.9283225536,
-0.6249887943,
-0.6691969037,
-0.5324628949,
0.3494557738,
-0.4603302777,
0.1369812191,
-0.7301808596,
0.343801856,
-0.0531064644,
-0.064251706,
-0.3874653876,
0.3393096924,
0.4206504822,
0.5799106956,
-0.7608614564,
1.0717691183,
0.2716964483,
-0.3975611925,
-0.3921936452,
0.0905939639,
-0.2629882097,
-0.9597655535,
0.4229332507,
0.4580826461,
-0.4098654687,
0.0859951675,
-0.6447848082,
-0.3566803038,
1.1357949972,
0.3390517831,
-0.9221712947,
0.2527068555,
0.1242897585,
0.6809177995,
-0.6299765706,
0.3374844193,
0.3778083622,
-0.1185834259,
0.4920958877,
-0.3657910526,
-0.0683326572,
0.1508899033,
0.2186904252,
0.091780521,
-0.7467507124,
0.3302626014,
-0.337810725,
-0.3894297779,
0.1893539131,
1.0188833475,
0.2337983847,
0.3687024713,
0.5656519532,
0.5176388621,
0.6200005412,
0.2013268769,
1.0841151476,
-0.1369429529,
0.3339661062,
1.4776337147,
-0.2888991237,
0.7072672248,
0.1760048717,
-0.0111337714,
0.72073704,
0.5193358064,
-0.124927029,
0.5177012086,
0.0452472083,
-0.5973218679,
-0.3879668117,
-0.2093451619,
-0.1005196199,
0.4653940797,
0.1681884825,
-0.562328577,
-0.3203543425,
0.0606295392,
0.1047993749,
0.3077612519,
-0.4141989946,
0.9968287945,
0.0285228193,
-0.4985680878,
0.6698346138,
0.0295377802,
0.8865528703,
-0.5808978677,
-0.0125936922,
-0.6024909616,
0.0586748347,
-0.0566084348,
-0.7558073401,
-0.0299969316,
0.1923962682,
-0.0583820269,
-0.3895587027,
0.7062949538,
-0.7252221107,
-0.4206742346,
0.4427372515,
0.2543022633,
0.0396864638,
0.0285695456,
-0.6222789884,
-0.0057582664,
0.2174786925,
0.0327150635,
0.643882215,
0.4659692645,
0.2118792087,
0.6196209788,
0.4905659258,
-0.124655202,
-0.0815446526,
0.4309169054,
0.8155931234,
-0.8643826842,
-0.4072459936,
-0.8457909226,
0.0380387343,
-0.0312069934,
-0.2313006371,
0.6512409449,
0.5642040968,
0.9795297384,
-0.0721610412,
0.7653973699,
0.2331536412,
0.3832325935,
-0.5915042162,
0.4381941855,
-0.4490724206,
0.1751698703,
0.1404296011,
-0.7552320957,
-0.387321949,
0.6039142609,
-0.1991104931,
0.0736401007,
0.5860496759,
0.6662555933,
0.2360718548,
-0.3511330783,
0.6604498625,
0.1665730327,
0.2855810225,
0.4751263559,
0.8266652822,
-0.2423021942,
0.8843463063,
-0.4603381753,
-0.400490284,
-0.1027523503,
-0.9206522107,
-1.1252471209,
-0.2058170736,
-0.5009506345,
-0.1792840511,
-0.0308586974,
0.7432458401,
0.5701926947,
-0.8368064761,
-0.0816027671,
-0.2743872106,
0.032962542,
0.1532632113,
-0.1772215664,
0.1623823643,
-0.7170071006,
-0.8800289631,
0.6603096724,
0.3959222436,
0.3458548486,
-0.1995155215,
-0.1512765884,
0.0994175449,
0.1624656916,
0.7606922388,
0.5636452436,
-0.4989021719,
-0.194574669,
-0.2060437649,
-0.2854178846,
0.2799459696,
0.6702375412,
-0.9450368285,
0.739589572,
0.3931792676,
0.7465271354,
0.6717199683,
0.0420923866,
0.3493772745,
-0.8601819277,
0.1812522858,
0.2282654941,
0.2679565251,
0.4610075355,
-0.3920980394,
0.3728583455,
0.1715836078,
-0.5305243134,
-0.4318751991,
0.2071377784,
-1.0779974461,
-0.4241884947,
1.2064269781,
-0.1493693441,
-0.1707042009,
0.1310199201,
-0.1827640831,
0.3466505706,
-0.3517232835,
1.000068903,
0.3181726038,
-0.074133411,
-0.5547736287,
-0.1692801267,
0.2526247501,
0.4946695864,
-1.1208570004,
0.0668410361,
0.4566162825,
0.3142656088,
-0.0261549782,
0.5468332171,
0.0608655401,
0.0419021398,
-0.091940403,
0.3597950935,
-0.1519450098,
-0.4515404999,
-0.6871638298,
0.1475185007,
0.0417340957,
-0.3832377195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11791v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11791v1 | Directed Acyclic Transformer Pre-training for High-quality Non-autoregressive Text Generation | 2023-04-24T02:30:33 | 2023-04-24T02:30:33 | Fei Huang, Pei Ke, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Non-AutoRegressive (NAR) text generation models have drawn much attention
because of their significantly faster decoding speed and good generation
quality in machine translation. However, in a wider range of text generation
tasks, existing NAR models lack proper pre-training, making them still far
behind the pre-trained autoregressive models. In this paper, we propose
Pre-trained Directed Acyclic Transformer (PreDAT) and a novel pre-training task
to promote prediction consistency in NAR generation. Experiments on five text
generation tasks show that our PreDAT remarkably outperforms existing
pre-trained NAR models (+4.2 scores on average) and even achieves better
results than pre-trained autoregressive baselines in n-gram-based metrics,
along with 17 times speedup in throughput. Further analysis shows that PreDAT
benefits from the unbiased prediction order that alleviates the error
accumulation problem in autoregressive generation, which provides new insights
into the advantages of NAR generation. | [
-0.345653981,
-0.4023571312,
0.4419173896,
0.2925078869,
-0.2788121402,
0.1232034042,
-0.1709725708,
-0.2871080637,
0.0650752857,
0.4735973179,
-0.5662714243,
-0.2052138746,
-0.96757406,
0.329472214,
-0.7942349911,
1.1982462406,
-0.2588369846,
-0.0136977807,
0.0096836267,
0.2711406648,
-0.6039634347,
-0.3029444218,
-0.3225061893,
-0.6100812554,
0.090618059,
0.2551525533,
0.8992883563,
0.7345613837,
0.5225870609,
0.3692233562,
0.5335498452,
0.187262401,
-0.2174980342,
0.4072354138,
-0.1056229472,
-0.1207480133,
-0.5943207741,
-0.0451098196,
0.4436905682,
0.3009970486,
-0.2789655328,
0.0156835243,
0.1627821773,
0.7309942842,
-0.4332792163,
0.0565322191,
-0.5532461405,
-0.0454263836,
-0.0793266892,
-0.223799631,
-0.4403793514,
-0.7525888681,
0.0312203318,
-0.6740632653,
0.6290012002,
0.0221923422,
0.9640883207,
0.5698413253,
-0.5524020195,
-0.1622212976,
-0.8148666024,
0.5534281731,
-0.5844416618,
0.6402465105,
0.0406073108,
0.1695937812,
-0.1200284809,
-0.9877941012,
-0.8648093939,
0.0601071678,
-0.1352799088,
0.2858100832,
-0.4178214073,
0.1447543502,
-0.0049531315,
0.4520694017,
-0.6897904277,
-0.0853162706,
0.3000152409,
-0.0945857018,
0.6091668606,
0.0179424211,
-0.0518556908,
-0.0596713386,
-0.3858707249,
-0.4132260084,
-0.4674144387,
-0.2363975495,
0.300111115,
0.0678390265,
0.0009881863,
0.2820366025,
-0.3643420041,
0.5371976495,
0.8779034019,
-0.0905271247,
0.5082478523,
-0.5211763978,
-0.0764405504,
0.1516775787,
1.134299159,
-0.0226254556,
0.3443444967,
-0.1148835346,
-0.5740630627,
0.1275987029,
0.3202075064,
-0.8811776638,
-0.7591229081,
-0.3667389154,
-0.4505853355,
-0.2523853779,
0.2010352463,
-0.6745663881,
0.2378565371,
-0.27827546,
0.4789065421,
-0.286533922,
-0.3635777235,
0.0703583956,
0.289734751,
-0.1495746672,
0.2422154397,
-0.7843992114,
0.2334282398,
0.0855514929,
0.6302189827,
-0.3652682602,
-0.1832938939,
-0.6002545953,
-0.0405129157,
-0.4772035182,
1.000048399,
-0.0720940977,
-0.3639776707,
-0.0743457451,
-0.1094726101,
-0.2519514859,
-0.2336206287,
0.6702669859,
-0.6322904825,
0.1974705905,
0.091811806,
-0.2611487508,
0.024684431,
0.0549334399,
-0.5549482107,
1.0092386007,
-0.0315323398,
-0.7593352795,
0.5182899237,
-0.582785666,
-0.8395701051,
0.0178369805,
0.0389165096,
-0.671226263,
0.0683775544,
0.3717058599,
0.4640459716,
-0.2005013078,
0.5913627744,
0.475851357,
-0.0088928705,
0.1263354421,
-0.8438057899,
0.2094449699,
0.2588714659,
-0.7274644971,
0.1808940023,
-0.78706038,
0.2633079886,
0.0564214066,
-0.3026761115,
0.0305792373,
-0.398974061,
0.1660305858,
0.5102621317,
0.435311377,
-0.614446044,
0.0212021973,
-0.5110910535,
-0.0145896962,
0.7502174973,
0.0711379349,
0.5532162786,
-0.1923052371,
0.5919101834,
0.0548941754,
0.0999058411,
-0.2424147278,
-0.3031246364,
-0.998521626,
0.1615600437,
0.3620083928,
0.3391560316,
-1.2912849188,
0.5876344442,
-0.4044954777,
-0.5820679665,
-0.2488767207,
0.0668982416,
0.7629615664,
0.6377563477,
0.7241960764,
-0.3694579303,
-0.5524454713,
-0.6013157368,
-0.1905950308,
-0.1654888541,
0.1222507507,
-0.1944685578,
0.3999486566,
-0.2601959109,
0.9072506428,
-0.516690433,
-0.2740403414,
-0.3171965778,
0.5607249737,
0.3154705763,
0.6036036611,
-0.054039441,
-0.89561975,
-0.8351429701,
-0.1689112782,
-0.3355992436,
-0.2671308815,
-0.2080412805,
-0.0309170149,
0.3714105487,
0.4325616658,
-0.6365219951,
0.4343031645,
0.7551770806,
-0.3053044677,
0.5184157491,
-0.6599990129,
0.1477558315,
-1.0982832909,
-0.0087525006,
0.0193403792,
-0.348048985,
-0.7814970016,
-0.610360086,
0.2124608755,
0.1443732381,
-0.2514432967,
0.2763180435,
-0.6860366464,
0.1952350438,
-0.6602956057,
-0.1672972739,
0.0950417146,
0.0660557151,
0.312477529,
0.9399553537,
0.3728760183,
-0.8090148568,
0.0187484715,
0.7370426655,
-0.2711094022,
0.319339335,
-0.7296658158,
0.1246758625,
-0.0898468941,
0.3465698659,
-0.6517934799,
0.0489394851,
-0.0209430866,
-0.5553283095,
0.5153878331,
0.3711850047,
-0.6432428956,
-0.4193091393,
0.4097723067,
0.4440060854,
0.6861383319,
-0.7662670016,
0.4832287133,
0.0228931438,
-0.0055861021,
-0.6680799127,
-0.4532858729,
-0.0334969424,
0.2090817988,
-0.3209204376,
0.4317257404,
-0.0760662407,
0.2062163055,
-0.1598185599,
-0.046445895,
0.0379779711,
-0.0968263224,
0.2595339119,
0.1643511206,
-0.168972984,
0.1392073184,
0.0833043605,
-0.6560361385,
-0.0018062865,
-0.650596261,
0.6390381455,
0.0065784613,
-0.198406294,
-0.4309537411,
0.1197893322,
0.1521396935,
-0.552269578,
0.4546189308,
0.3922079802,
0.1521527767,
-0.2436552197,
-0.5248197913,
-0.1388485134,
-0.5451722145,
0.2338722348,
-0.2847575247,
-0.3984732032,
-0.1458730102,
0.0050524161,
-0.0357880741,
0.5860878229,
0.4825453758,
0.2142272145,
1.1171061993,
0.8349468112,
0.1836753041,
0.501080811,
-0.1170943305,
0.3898843825,
-0.2802753747,
-0.2226857096,
-0.2830603123,
-0.0572662055,
-0.5970818996,
-0.2162044346,
0.2779794335,
-0.1342745572,
-0.3695630431,
0.5409911275,
-0.7680227757,
0.3988785446,
0.5871676803,
-0.2986361086,
0.5433303118,
-0.2471600473,
0.0080776233,
0.1489938498,
-0.8382165432,
-0.4537329674,
1.0004407167,
0.0947729349,
0.7854956985,
-0.2889113426,
0.8908565044,
0.0670211539,
0.4318578243,
-0.3742141724,
0.3360824287,
-0.3854280114,
-0.3883835971,
-0.0565658435,
-0.3376070261,
-0.9523417354,
-0.1268903464,
-0.540491581,
0.0035252513,
0.4178756475,
0.4501343966,
-0.0702648014,
0.2723059058,
-0.2637702525,
0.6277083158,
-0.3232551217,
-0.1138230562,
0.3224438429,
-0.7630575299,
0.0712757483,
-0.2229302227,
0.0088327006,
0.2413661033,
0.2113864571,
0.6507929564,
-0.3325242698,
0.349034965,
-0.3972266316,
-0.1783315241,
0.2376345247,
0.0946185812,
0.6955161095,
-0.0713879988,
0.1391106397,
0.2706213892,
-0.4143815041,
-0.0309258141,
-0.4087306857,
0.4930989146,
-0.7265124917,
-0.5117114186,
-0.5894232988,
-0.5754078031,
-0.1269724071,
0.5321998,
0.9848142266,
0.2080991417,
-0.1405478567,
-0.0475107133,
0.8552337885,
0.1912704706,
0.7252787948,
0.2621441782,
0.075757809,
-0.5509782434,
0.8280393481,
-0.0263516996,
0.3794776201,
0.4969367981,
-0.1264720112,
-0.5296295881,
-0.8844001293,
-0.3569897413,
0.0063626855,
-0.4513109326,
-0.7251401544,
-0.9367277026,
-0.4218482375,
-0.476777941,
-0.1488642544,
-0.6724485159,
-0.2987746298,
-0.3758816421,
-0.1099237278,
0.2505843341,
0.9530613422,
-0.1692735106,
0.8194743395,
-0.7238518,
0.5187516212,
0.0219787303,
0.264800936,
-0.1126273274,
-0.4050721228,
-0.272239089,
0.0230493899,
-0.6002918482,
-0.6455139518,
0.8191502094,
0.3426036835,
0.3912500739,
0.3548657298,
0.2709105313,
0.5059107542,
-0.8722505569,
0.4675183296,
0.5950146914,
-1.0186275244,
0.491676718,
-0.2688651085,
0.5311309695,
0.7557956576,
0.3008742034,
-0.2639566064,
-0.46310395,
-0.6870826483,
-0.7678741813,
0.3116277158,
0.4327955544,
0.0542943925,
-0.2964917719,
0.2289718091,
0.4573819935,
0.3217993379,
-0.8791000843,
-0.3902716041,
-1.0656754971,
-0.3882898986,
-0.6940971613,
0.0848829895,
0.5620530844,
0.1453716308,
0.9133624434,
-0.1466145664,
0.1171583459,
0.5138207674,
-0.2929590344,
-0.258556217,
0.2793156803,
0.2967268527,
0.2740388215,
0.072304152,
0.0409658812,
-0.1054890305,
-0.8276091814,
0.7339138389,
0.1688862592,
-0.3796851933,
0.2523553371,
0.2066273987,
0.7038175464,
-0.0466096513,
-0.1998563707,
0.7290372252,
-0.2518814802,
-0.4347676337,
-0.5741336346,
0.0965671539,
-0.2667538524,
0.1308545023,
0.5567564368,
0.3960814178,
0.0641545206,
-0.0153737841,
0.4297521114,
0.3934233487,
-0.4000732601,
-0.3647480905,
0.8974990845,
0.1824963987,
-0.247617498,
0.5630426407,
-0.1496734023,
-0.5285217166,
0.3342754245,
0.8632111549,
0.8799648881,
-0.5324140191,
0.2526829243,
0.3659695983,
0.222891748,
-0.5163557529,
0.0924824402,
-0.0772965997,
-0.6772346497,
-0.3026436269,
-0.8634086251,
-0.0876833647,
-0.268704772,
-0.6238493323,
0.0855431408,
-0.341999799,
-0.3194345236,
-0.43320629,
0.0430144332,
-0.6574363112,
0.7197401524,
-0.1970103085,
0.5903832316,
-0.8673570752,
1.1734005213,
0.4646957517,
-0.1917974353,
-0.7879633904,
0.4197478294,
-0.4510703087,
-0.4138713479,
1.0106025934,
0.2069898397,
-0.3719137907,
0.3908751309,
-0.1267181933,
-1.1771370173,
1.1952149868,
0.22679995,
-0.5945627689,
-0.3131149709,
0.0258989967,
0.5375034809,
-0.5165426731,
0.2162332684,
0.3223380446,
0.5149537921,
0.1095606387,
-1.0108425617,
0.1331867874,
-0.2648465037,
0.1363355517,
0.5996400118,
-0.4161814749,
0.9997640848,
-0.0953340679,
-0.4749002755,
0.3544043601,
1.0649819374,
-0.0370074995,
0.1609795243,
0.5236829519,
0.3957423568,
0.5752090812,
-0.140426293,
0.9200841784,
-0.3819575012,
0.0940854624,
1.1634664536,
-0.0393565856,
0.621953249,
0.4424301386,
0.2385609001,
0.7605526447,
0.231227383,
-0.076421015,
0.7986726761,
-0.1043444574,
-0.1791933477,
-0.2887019813,
0.0222189147,
-0.5080987215,
0.4771879315,
-0.1900846064,
-0.4378754795,
-0.1202278435,
0.1702196002,
-0.2609979212,
0.524751842,
-0.3500299156,
0.7581222057,
-0.0824285671,
-0.9035405517,
0.7031595111,
-0.0119617982,
1.015109539,
-0.4944439828,
0.0291129928,
-0.0457946919,
0.4266697168,
-0.228058815,
-0.5449642539,
0.1419514865,
-0.0351132005,
-0.3371835947,
-0.7862721086,
0.750130415,
-0.3383144438,
-0.4488619268,
0.1812902391,
0.6011408567,
-0.2106134742,
0.0037142062,
-0.4185213149,
-0.4962448478,
-0.0766656846,
-0.3108069003,
0.2368855625,
0.525867641,
0.0806880072,
0.4734329283,
0.84377563,
0.084472388,
0.1505482048,
-0.3101539612,
0.6780768037,
-0.4706575572,
-0.5203363299,
-0.6632891893,
0.3458712697,
0.205159083,
-0.363244921,
0.8960641623,
0.4577645659,
0.7816146016,
-0.0778216273,
0.6146310568,
0.1112942547,
0.4556752741,
-0.5642430782,
0.947603941,
-0.2088564932,
-0.1323463917,
-0.2899906933,
-1.1392604113,
-0.1507642269,
0.6600866318,
-0.304243803,
0.1928580999,
0.8603389263,
0.4451137483,
-0.0426593125,
-0.037259791,
0.3125348091,
0.2117890269,
0.3528419137,
0.5027647018,
0.6411955953,
-0.7179989219,
0.7420319319,
-0.3661141992,
-0.1220213175,
0.218169719,
-0.9172965288,
-0.8098853827,
-0.6656759381,
-0.1637173593,
-0.266485393,
0.085823603,
0.7231222391,
0.5963729024,
-0.6459624767,
-0.0823907703,
-0.7259494066,
-0.3128057122,
-0.0442595631,
-0.1985717267,
0.1822647899,
-0.5430924296,
-0.6863783598,
0.3797739446,
-0.1571096182,
0.384345144,
0.0334977508,
-0.3084927499,
-0.2746453285,
0.0015913951,
0.1896129549,
0.1604531258,
-0.2725946903,
-0.0235355087,
0.153882429,
0.0517634079,
0.386998117,
0.7150850892,
-1.0143737793,
0.1586856246,
0.2452813983,
0.3829253316,
0.6265654564,
0.2936133742,
0.8644959331,
-0.5892076492,
0.0380930603,
0.3348357081,
0.144913286,
0.4086277187,
-0.4999360144,
0.0471786559,
-0.0675831586,
-0.8309345841,
-0.4527855217,
0.3149285913,
-0.5682324767,
0.0355560072,
0.8906046152,
-0.1857134998,
-0.0680972561,
-0.1925504059,
0.0546675548,
0.6500885487,
-0.5486650467,
0.5195382833,
0.0975317881,
-0.1538691968,
-0.0915422142,
-0.2695779502,
0.6025292277,
0.458060205,
-0.8616485596,
0.1151238531,
0.5035793781,
0.0490554273,
0.3126965463,
0.6483103633,
-0.1472571045,
0.2821783423,
-0.027881939,
0.3136965334,
-0.280049175,
-0.6641678214,
-0.3800989389,
0.1551128626,
0.0988790169,
-0.0137027344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11766v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11766v4 | NAIST-SIC-Aligned: an Aligned English-Japanese Simultaneous Interpretation Corpus | 2023-04-23T23:03:58 | 2024-04-01T01:07:54 | Jinming Zhao, Yuka Ko, Kosuke Doi, Ryo Fukuda, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | It remains a question that how simultaneous interpretation (SI) data affects
simultaneous machine translation (SiMT). Research has been limited due to the
lack of a large-scale training corpus. In this work, we aim to fill in the gap
by introducing NAIST-SIC-Aligned, which is an automatically-aligned parallel
English-Japanese SI dataset. Starting with a non-aligned corpus NAIST-SIC, we
propose a two-stage alignment approach to make the corpus parallel and thus
suitable for model training. The first stage is coarse alignment where we
perform a many-to-many mapping between source and target sentences, and the
second stage is fine-grained alignment where we perform intra- and
inter-sentence filtering to improve the quality of aligned pairs. To ensure the
quality of the corpus, each step has been validated either quantitatively or
qualitatively. This is the first open-sourced large-scale parallel SI dataset
in the literature. We also manually curated a small test set for evaluation
purposes. Our results show that models trained with SI data lead to significant
improvement in translation quality and latency over baselines. We hope our work
advances research on SI corpora construction and SiMT. Our data can be found at
https://github.com/mingzi151/AHC-SI. | [
-0.1831948161,
-0.2023360282,
0.4848855436,
0.139195621,
-0.447448194,
0.1953338981,
-0.1813581735,
-0.5074558258,
0.3344235718,
0.4601817727,
-0.6661113501,
-0.5736471415,
-0.4572228193,
0.259498328,
-0.3441939652,
1.1472158432,
-0.534558773,
0.529986918,
-0.0048161941,
-0.4691109657,
-0.7919760942,
0.003346228,
-0.6031929255,
-0.0496385731,
0.3604649007,
0.4639908373,
1.1703649759,
0.9494380951,
0.7391033173,
0.2489325702,
0.4364575148,
0.1739014238,
-0.2854152322,
0.1553771198,
-0.1557034701,
-0.5668796897,
-0.5358942747,
-0.1164982691,
0.9666529894,
0.7976391912,
0.0099599855,
0.1832453161,
0.2523311675,
0.3493049741,
-0.2447102815,
0.0474464409,
-0.5053788424,
-0.0756949484,
-0.4684644341,
-0.0834490359,
-0.4604969621,
-0.2764824033,
-0.1555089355,
-1.0005569458,
-0.0521368906,
0.441876322,
1.0520422459,
0.7635469437,
-0.6089161634,
-0.1520999223,
-0.5135042667,
1.1384284496,
-0.5873348713,
0.2596164346,
-0.2073096186,
0.4073962569,
-0.127042383,
-0.357046783,
-0.2516018152,
0.1015179977,
-0.1370199323,
0.3994716108,
0.2911819518,
-0.0418659486,
0.0785235614,
0.3741031587,
-0.9349073768,
0.3069547415,
-0.2563866377,
-0.1272939742,
0.605713129,
0.3225384355,
0.7998520732,
-0.0271924399,
-0.9033919573,
-0.0721290931,
-0.4166800976,
-0.3598672748,
0.4351241291,
0.2794210613,
-0.3029759228,
0.7364675999,
0.1502982378,
0.3578590155,
-0.027696237,
-0.1687401533,
0.310860157,
-0.6653208137,
-0.0241182521,
0.309869647,
0.9864063263,
0.2364552319,
0.2518321574,
-0.0638832897,
-0.2086326778,
0.4127391279,
0.4019913971,
-0.5936381817,
0.2185320556,
0.1543597877,
-0.3092616498,
-0.3226541281,
0.2594605386,
-0.9014084339,
-0.0760844648,
-0.7259820104,
0.3343063593,
-0.3555639088,
-0.264075309,
0.2334500998,
0.2145854831,
-0.0696970895,
0.2120601982,
-0.5219933987,
0.5556561947,
0.6400814652,
0.787609756,
-0.405716002,
-0.5291667581,
-0.4576555789,
0.3183139861,
-0.3231267929,
0.5731237531,
-0.3984176517,
0.061225757,
-0.3638774157,
-0.0024422945,
-0.3691431582,
-0.1470079124,
0.7013881207,
-0.3262962103,
0.3442293406,
-0.0622922853,
-0.5051233172,
-0.0433728956,
-0.0743543133,
-0.6796925068,
1.0022852421,
-0.1678545028,
-1.1038082838,
0.1402311027,
-0.6685566306,
-0.2488493919,
0.0273833871,
-0.4084580839,
-0.349717021,
-0.055920653,
0.5104090571,
0.0562226586,
-0.4269016087,
0.638220787,
-0.3644062579,
-0.442784667,
0.1371640712,
-0.5505948663,
0.7800517082,
0.3590340614,
-0.3817698956,
-0.1331454962,
-0.5909258127,
-0.0710732937,
0.1720910072,
0.1819652468,
-0.3239720464,
-0.0985438749,
0.0460908152,
0.2373579293,
0.421697408,
-0.735955894,
0.1960060447,
-0.4684194028,
-0.1136863604,
0.5285986662,
0.0665827394,
0.4461717606,
-0.2117207497,
0.7120441198,
0.1540905684,
0.0997168496,
-0.0725921541,
-0.5052853823,
-0.5238696337,
-0.1672531515,
0.5139172673,
0.6562703252,
-0.7608311176,
0.266230315,
-0.4261629581,
-0.3212119043,
-1.0614852905,
-0.0099485656,
0.4550560713,
0.1855763644,
0.4223588407,
-0.6066063643,
-0.5565385222,
-0.9250693917,
-0.2375175208,
0.0505751967,
0.2093800306,
-0.103790462,
0.1886678487,
0.0292135607,
0.7014266253,
-0.3982621431,
-0.1372573525,
0.174353987,
0.4904725254,
0.0125628943,
0.6791858077,
0.3179958761,
-0.7742797136,
-0.6226926446,
0.2561560869,
-1.0299905539,
-0.3409879208,
-0.4948183298,
-0.5746083856,
-0.1103345454,
0.6185996532,
-0.331913352,
0.4146801233,
0.6826426387,
0.0909839571,
0.2476010025,
-0.0367329046,
0.3176830709,
-1.4935261011,
0.1493573189,
0.0012148826,
-0.3601703942,
-0.5412668586,
0.0656165183,
0.0878448784,
-0.2081340104,
-0.3078063428,
0.2926672995,
-0.6297495365,
-0.444534421,
-0.4963513613,
0.1541610658,
0.1678089648,
0.3764672279,
0.0832647383,
1.01182127,
0.3222182989,
-0.0886308253,
-0.1306909174,
0.2938382328,
-0.3140744269,
0.680829525,
-0.3824878931,
0.2211450934,
-0.0715924501,
0.2995015383,
-0.9327808022,
-0.2866992056,
0.3489826918,
-0.4063419104,
0.4974788427,
-0.0311805476,
-0.5690066218,
-0.2097472101,
0.0335528553,
0.7293512821,
0.1321822107,
-0.5997288227,
0.2802252769,
0.3360159397,
-0.3255212009,
-0.8465753794,
-0.6711601615,
-0.0953710973,
-0.1177548021,
-0.5695478916,
0.4013946056,
-0.0032668123,
-0.0641219541,
0.1547541022,
-0.3408297896,
-0.1326288879,
0.0629885942,
0.2140195966,
0.6163032055,
-0.6063780189,
-0.1092315018,
0.3946963847,
-0.3722346127,
-0.2252830118,
-0.3032569289,
0.4534317553,
-0.0847218558,
-0.5980222821,
-0.9079423547,
0.4697160721,
0.7747327685,
-0.3057243824,
0.884544313,
0.6494122744,
-0.4646248817,
0.2138587087,
-0.3291515112,
0.2823087275,
-0.3609823585,
0.0444845855,
-0.6444933414,
-0.4987822175,
0.1739985943,
-0.1306076348,
0.428314805,
0.6348225474,
0.3697407544,
-0.0681244954,
1.4229230881,
0.3750530481,
-0.1217138246,
0.1334047019,
0.3330051005,
0.3845246434,
-0.7088208199,
0.1592123806,
-0.3809227347,
-0.3710850477,
-0.4363775551,
-0.2007925361,
0.3351981342,
0.1481571198,
-0.0286122262,
0.6247903109,
-0.4411063194,
0.4582444727,
0.0829048306,
-0.0866584405,
0.3948180079,
-0.2487467378,
-0.2369319797,
-0.2068293989,
-0.4116268754,
-0.6351473331,
1.1454129219,
0.4261059165,
0.429889977,
-0.0398764946,
0.8731679916,
-0.272267282,
-0.0058532557,
-0.3602351248,
0.4650624096,
-0.2143095136,
-0.724326551,
-0.066411972,
-0.3190066814,
-0.8495863676,
0.4275244474,
-0.0839241073,
-0.3901041746,
0.1148012727,
-0.1737886667,
-0.3663919568,
0.2939546108,
-0.8671044111,
0.9646542668,
-0.4444128275,
-0.1534595042,
-0.2186124623,
-0.8218276501,
0.4764887094,
-0.4889091849,
0.3136416674,
-0.4269848168,
-0.2075410932,
0.6016295552,
-0.2990060449,
0.7453835607,
-0.0886688232,
0.2357754111,
0.0539880842,
-0.0327025652,
0.3836044669,
0.1088217869,
-0.0846776292,
0.303934902,
0.2450226396,
-0.5578878522,
-0.4365339875,
0.723295927,
-0.7158632874,
-0.1867320538,
-0.5484556556,
-1.0169953108,
-0.0581111908,
0.2277841568,
0.1452822089,
0.3358152211,
-0.1702302992,
0.0003105957,
0.1549797356,
-0.0610153005,
-0.0290476456,
0.3093546331,
-0.273417145,
-0.3003993034,
0.8216417432,
0.035630621,
0.5582299829,
0.2892055809,
-0.0628820136,
-0.0499775223,
-0.5828127265,
-0.7788083553,
0.352447778,
-0.3919425607,
-0.2351426035,
-0.5935297012,
-0.2681195438,
-0.5143330097,
-0.2084279656,
-0.6072033644,
-0.3533254564,
-0.2174561918,
0.2902739942,
-0.0425352901,
0.7511997819,
0.0738501176,
0.3472622335,
-0.7146558762,
0.5403788686,
-0.5043519139,
0.1304271519,
-0.4390699267,
-0.4067541361,
-0.3925758004,
0.135397613,
-0.0563764423,
-0.8617123365,
0.4206729233,
-0.1543566138,
0.3488486707,
0.2670873702,
-0.0203886759,
0.963250041,
-0.5583919883,
0.4376068413,
0.245851934,
-0.7584828138,
0.4361376166,
-0.3464950919,
0.3808854818,
1.1297380924,
0.6147079468,
-0.4344867468,
-0.6856718063,
-0.4960631132,
-0.6585301161,
0.97676301,
0.3920246363,
-0.4718298912,
0.1837180257,
0.1545846164,
0.5270089507,
0.1373746544,
-0.6819540858,
-0.2164982259,
0.0682360753,
-0.8559378386,
0.0819308311,
0.1243775189,
0.0803568438,
-0.1549272686,
1.0206114054,
-0.1732359529,
0.0917651951,
-0.1211210638,
-0.3087719381,
-0.3250062168,
0.1594885886,
-0.0991443768,
0.3243631423,
-0.1518518925,
-0.1013620198,
0.1221661866,
-0.3865461648,
0.0227845106,
0.1156510487,
-0.3560937941,
0.1594191641,
-0.1253921241,
0.8692442775,
0.6696484089,
-0.3959489465,
0.6174562573,
0.0449722931,
0.0098256283,
-0.2491465211,
-0.2768035531,
-0.0476469211,
-0.0415213257,
-0.2640277743,
0.4436351359,
0.1304517388,
-0.2717706561,
0.2805864513,
0.1478625089,
-0.1178549826,
-0.2452424616,
0.7296409011,
-0.0835347846,
0.0282354522,
0.4815351665,
-0.2681927085,
-0.3243856132,
0.4375064969,
0.5248993635,
0.662982285,
-0.40250507,
0.0769010112,
0.6317694783,
0.3659846485,
-0.364810884,
-0.0030674031,
0.1910728812,
-0.6069790125,
-0.5939257145,
-0.7214529514,
-0.5466391444,
-0.3096215129,
-1.1908359528,
0.7296770215,
0.0210307874,
0.1590124965,
0.226831913,
0.0700825453,
-0.5452979803,
0.0598831624,
0.2775641978,
0.4138940573,
-1.2787632942,
1.2063851357,
0.6936468482,
-0.5197635293,
-0.8419125676,
0.2098847032,
0.3409630954,
-0.9106804729,
0.024632521,
0.436347127,
-0.0522641949,
0.1751675308,
-0.2921257019,
-1.3968478441,
1.1390109062,
0.4520567358,
-0.74168396,
-0.1499069929,
0.4037116766,
0.483015269,
-0.4334512949,
0.1842356026,
0.6749431491,
0.4258418083,
-0.0879244283,
-1.0289562941,
-0.1270888895,
-0.2249431014,
-0.0241266564,
0.6430492401,
-0.5439903736,
0.4483317137,
0.3053051233,
-0.6212834716,
0.3239376843,
0.8215287328,
0.0899576396,
0.3093436956,
0.6872107387,
0.7036633492,
0.8369213939,
0.0403952636,
0.8286829591,
-0.3708518744,
0.0697668269,
1.5314551592,
-0.5661300421,
0.7952269316,
0.5471022725,
-0.0301380362,
0.5143336058,
0.471883893,
-0.0810765922,
0.2843308449,
-0.2522588074,
-0.1114925817,
-0.1285890788,
-0.2318748385,
-0.2204014659,
0.3868163824,
0.3062420189,
-0.0862053633,
-0.2989560068,
0.3328628838,
0.0465214588,
0.3312202692,
0.0381941944,
0.5332981348,
0.1579833776,
-0.8903861642,
0.1607525051,
-0.0653658435,
0.5812346935,
-0.3688854873,
0.2856178284,
0.2259536535,
0.0931638852,
-0.1766833216,
-0.8144364953,
0.5000558496,
0.165910095,
0.0182191357,
-0.3194569349,
0.4564344585,
-0.6357100606,
-0.4626725614,
0.3523595631,
0.3959155977,
0.7257306576,
0.1525131017,
-0.8810963035,
0.1514018178,
0.1760598272,
-0.0469394177,
0.3831132352,
0.2717094421,
-0.2817324996,
-0.004784992,
0.4657087326,
-0.0178135503,
0.2593912184,
0.2284729481,
0.4297570586,
-0.4155603051,
-0.2362879664,
-0.4877810478,
0.4854374528,
-0.0804473534,
-0.2491521537,
0.5726408362,
0.771310389,
0.9123986363,
0.384927541,
0.5469760895,
0.1756799519,
0.7386242747,
-0.4553923011,
0.2827068567,
-0.6305376887,
0.1455648541,
0.037205711,
-0.9908917546,
-0.3894802332,
0.1772745401,
-0.3165025115,
-0.3533682823,
1.1863005161,
0.8795772791,
-0.3278284073,
0.5052135587,
0.2277963907,
0.2106538415,
-0.0847946182,
0.6684025526,
0.5237730145,
-0.9214183092,
0.6073001027,
-0.4624645412,
-0.1002628431,
0.1748688817,
-0.5998598933,
-0.515681684,
-0.5397828817,
-0.5559378266,
0.0044348454,
0.0992284715,
0.964725256,
0.2992702127,
-0.8694380522,
-0.2864465117,
-0.1989024282,
-0.4411722422,
-0.3574751616,
-0.1316597909,
0.1900637448,
-0.650320828,
-1.1361575127,
0.8021088839,
0.3759589195,
-0.0039969054,
0.025825629,
-0.0989774764,
-0.3812062442,
-0.1061534509,
-0.1618110538,
0.1136112884,
-0.731808722,
-0.1187973171,
-0.1527704597,
-0.4320095778,
0.4418871701,
0.4643747509,
-0.2853067815,
0.5856180191,
0.2254801393,
0.7878862619,
0.5706526637,
0.1461895108,
0.7928932905,
-0.7159056067,
0.2001533508,
0.1250382066,
0.5034887195,
0.1993959695,
-0.4240015447,
0.5541546345,
0.0138612129,
-0.5766739845,
-0.8756709099,
0.0305880234,
-1.3042651415,
-0.0767353475,
1.020435214,
-0.0781163797,
-0.2894753814,
-0.180189684,
-0.2774784267,
0.6744889021,
-0.0935472772,
0.0799433589,
0.8546670079,
0.2531796992,
0.3105263114,
-0.9835703373,
-0.1067010313,
0.9457783103,
-0.872684598,
-0.2136735469,
0.321338594,
0.0803197548,
0.0458321385,
0.4204810262,
-0.4827302396,
0.2850800157,
0.0994416997,
0.3949928284,
0.2435255051,
-0.4797388613,
-0.6705789566,
0.0311130621,
0.0684745163,
-0.5637589097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11721v1 | A Lightweight Constrained Generation Alternative for Query-focused Summarization | 2023-04-23T18:43:48 | 2023-04-23T18:43:48 | Zhichao Xu, Daniel Cohen | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Query-focused summarization (QFS) aims to provide a summary of a document
that satisfies information need of a given query and is useful in various IR
applications, such as abstractive snippet generation. Current QFS approaches
typically involve injecting additional information, e.g. query-answer relevance
or fine-grained token-level interaction between a query and document, into a
finetuned large language model. However, these approaches often require extra
parameters \& training, and generalize poorly to new dataset distributions. To
mitigate this, we propose leveraging a recently developed constrained
generation model Neurological Decoding (NLD) as an alternative to current QFS
regimes which rely on additional sub-architectures and training. We first
construct lexical constraints by identifying important tokens from the document
using a lightweight gradient attribution model, then subsequently force the
generated summary to satisfy these constraints by directly manipulating the
final vocabulary likelihood. This lightweight approach requires no additional
parameters or finetuning as it utilizes both an off-the-shelf neural retrieval
model to construct the constraints and a standard generative language model to
produce the QFS. We demonstrate the efficacy of this approach on two public QFS
collections achieving near parity with the state-of-the-art model with
substantially reduced complexity. | [
-0.2662936747,
-0.3930076659,
0.2672703266,
0.0326244943,
-0.6115249395,
-0.047608681,
-0.2151880264,
-0.2144749016,
0.5992575288,
0.649895072,
-0.7924473286,
-0.527831614,
-0.4079054296,
0.2813859284,
-0.5459210873,
1.350501895,
0.3801702857,
-0.063200362,
-0.4582896531,
-0.2822879851,
0.0731044486,
-0.3959188461,
-0.4584953785,
-0.2416509986,
0.4656080008,
0.3277977705,
0.5699980855,
0.4431485236,
0.5195983648,
0.1368210018,
-0.3531324565,
0.5186213851,
-0.6545906663,
0.1956316382,
-0.0241322927,
-0.5243917704,
-0.44722718,
-0.4136650264,
0.4632796943,
1.036521554,
-0.3144811988,
0.1899310201,
0.1843841672,
0.7649773955,
-0.9731349945,
-0.1274472773,
-0.6373851895,
0.1253018975,
-0.0741021931,
-0.3616653979,
-0.2987442613,
-0.3070198298,
0.1323350221,
-0.7788886428,
0.5187494755,
-0.0176703334,
0.871955514,
0.3031806946,
-0.6440775394,
-0.180334121,
-0.3786588907,
0.5793088675,
-0.7436804175,
0.1815752685,
0.5942549109,
0.1285746396,
0.1341382712,
-0.9989535213,
-0.397310555,
0.0587797202,
-0.179588303,
0.190921545,
-0.1181250364,
0.3457100689,
0.1045067534,
0.4505972862,
-0.6613025069,
-0.1390223354,
-0.3048411608,
-0.2303411961,
0.4255977869,
0.5827367902,
-0.2006002963,
-0.7679669261,
-0.2289283723,
0.1656336039,
-0.8598429561,
-0.0346773341,
0.1278076023,
0.4711714685,
-0.0827781707,
0.6568875313,
-0.6091932058,
0.6368016601,
0.1982134283,
-0.0925945789,
-0.0488537289,
-0.6554073691,
-0.0210633501,
-0.2303729355,
0.7804999948,
0.7090533376,
-0.1290961206,
-0.3565887809,
-0.5913861394,
-0.4276295006,
-0.0587049872,
-1.1278167963,
-0.1290041208,
0.1556198001,
-0.6739494801,
-0.2740542293,
-0.2931975722,
-0.5265848041,
-0.4647963047,
-0.0772972777,
0.1518050283,
-0.488219887,
-0.0431697071,
0.1101620048,
-0.3807193339,
0.2607461512,
0.2064670771,
-1.0602798462,
0.3583995104,
0.3766720891,
0.9548532367,
-0.1015439704,
0.1108944714,
-0.6365573406,
0.437882334,
-0.0773289055,
0.6396674514,
-0.1199457571,
-0.5955902934,
-0.0802881345,
-0.2636766434,
0.1546398699,
-0.4916062653,
0.4808749259,
-0.583127737,
0.1107027084,
-0.2227141112,
-0.3927778602,
-0.0558673963,
0.3235301375,
-0.5357717872,
0.7923095822,
0.4553668499,
-1.0193657875,
0.3295429349,
-0.2195713222,
-0.7718020678,
0.2455424219,
-0.2788703442,
-0.1921491474,
0.343162477,
0.4094456136,
0.3171745241,
-0.548386097,
0.4148955941,
-0.1689611375,
-0.2331732512,
-0.0822459087,
-0.2093833238,
0.6886885762,
0.2605091929,
-0.098175779,
0.237449646,
-0.9468711615,
0.0873527452,
0.0888216794,
-0.3762781024,
-0.3375268281,
0.1798686981,
0.2417301685,
-0.066383563,
0.3659216762,
-0.2604517937,
-0.0161683373,
-0.5859119892,
0.4946168065,
0.231814757,
0.2933780253,
0.6170325279,
-0.2458350807,
0.8351819515,
-0.2936573923,
0.0621089675,
-0.1648268998,
0.0257388465,
-0.4653886557,
-0.3893562555,
0.4882576168,
0.4043291509,
-1.1824136972,
0.3591447175,
-0.4457135201,
-0.1346878707,
-0.3149755001,
0.0386074595,
0.3652354181,
0.8421411514,
0.2662289739,
0.0123282755,
-0.5198323727,
-0.9814878702,
0.0321303941,
0.0005081343,
-0.4138397872,
0.2947734594,
0.2104605883,
0.2166222781,
0.9322277308,
-0.7469207644,
-0.4422541559,
-0.6297213435,
0.0610142238,
0.0806544274,
0.5891013741,
0.5955706239,
-0.7794350982,
-0.061474897,
-0.2651251256,
-0.7574674487,
0.0466373414,
-0.0433732495,
0.0540769696,
-0.1925936043,
0.8233525157,
-0.8384898901,
0.3130995035,
0.1818977743,
-0.3520904779,
0.3749148548,
-0.1331757754,
-0.1870788485,
-1.2216644287,
0.2802281976,
-0.2161759734,
-0.2890642583,
-0.4152195156,
0.4729010463,
0.2464297116,
-0.4921020269,
-0.2009607255,
0.2487864643,
-0.5621753931,
0.2334002852,
-0.3127870262,
0.1885845363,
0.3517274559,
0.5479692221,
0.0412175842,
0.566542089,
0.4265339673,
-0.4940440655,
-0.0920721591,
0.3942349255,
-0.101636827,
0.3031491339,
-1.042240262,
-0.1334142238,
-0.4908438623,
0.3946202993,
-0.7702198029,
-0.4241474867,
0.1118527129,
-0.4618366957,
0.3393331468,
-0.0766291097,
-0.3599511683,
0.0051829536,
-0.5412193537,
0.5854383111,
0.4288392961,
-0.3887357414,
0.8584446907,
0.3137520254,
-0.187812835,
-0.5432161093,
-0.9887675643,
0.1999728084,
-0.133948192,
-0.6841734648,
0.6471820474,
0.1921307892,
0.082185261,
0.1031475961,
-0.1853519082,
0.0763074681,
0.1319648474,
-0.0125169531,
0.0642925575,
-0.3482855856,
0.1173985824,
0.3671107292,
0.1935888231,
-0.087976262,
-0.2565074265,
0.3145913184,
0.15313375,
0.0840428993,
-0.1514424235,
0.8043792248,
0.5683374405,
-0.63971138,
0.6904949546,
0.3969794214,
-0.4635129273,
-0.4332647324,
-0.1203891039,
-0.438783735,
-0.4855116308,
0.5016109347,
-0.4047893286,
-1.0404195786,
0.7422530651,
0.0306477398,
-0.0851287544,
0.3872872293,
0.1993610412,
0.099904038,
1.0786806345,
0.7302033305,
0.2442932427,
0.5879068375,
-0.3254962564,
-0.0601511113,
-0.9393252134,
-0.3077700436,
-0.4992675781,
-0.2546451092,
-0.2828590572,
-0.197178036,
0.5669081211,
0.318805784,
0.2479619533,
0.043788068,
-0.5888881683,
0.4083951414,
0.3710527122,
0.3461811841,
0.2189435512,
-0.0931243747,
-0.0296887197,
0.0785564408,
-0.9988291264,
-0.1298121214,
1.2711066008,
-0.2247430533,
0.6785197854,
0.2160363048,
0.9238656759,
0.1462063193,
0.0983127132,
-0.7935428023,
0.6300350428,
-0.3001504242,
-0.451937288,
-0.2539337277,
-0.710332334,
-0.9399656057,
0.3786197305,
-0.3851801753,
-0.6342323422,
0.4563280344,
0.1536642015,
-0.7551767826,
-0.0708105937,
-0.8792712688,
0.5605380535,
0.1192323416,
-0.3523822725,
-0.1562061012,
-0.6907689571,
0.7182528973,
0.2112760246,
-0.1335751563,
-0.0297917537,
-0.3697462976,
0.6535570621,
-0.8371506929,
0.6735121012,
-0.261716783,
0.0611873381,
0.4366863966,
-0.0056003463,
0.6290174723,
0.2771277726,
-0.1634074301,
-0.5517776012,
0.0061604087,
-0.4851972461,
-0.6450876594,
0.5142322183,
-0.4200288951,
-0.7156456709,
-0.1611120701,
-0.7839089632,
-0.4060243666,
0.3759021759,
0.6109136939,
0.8257575631,
-0.1753604859,
0.4452186227,
0.5918654799,
0.0210804846,
0.4281004667,
0.4921837449,
-0.0277359243,
-0.5592581034,
0.9528586864,
0.0674959496,
0.1566734165,
0.5492131114,
0.0827605128,
-0.411288172,
-1.1447660923,
-0.3835557699,
0.0472410135,
-0.7943933606,
-0.6050383449,
-0.7024944425,
0.0922795907,
-0.5747292042,
-0.11860127,
-0.0764793828,
-0.9274153113,
-0.4816327691,
-0.1501524597,
0.4129437804,
0.3861125708,
0.1353855282,
0.3681972623,
-0.7680606246,
0.6605953574,
0.0816272572,
0.1685685962,
0.098891668,
-0.4023926854,
-0.36531353,
-0.2816590965,
-0.1606896222,
-0.9132171273,
0.3900007606,
0.55828619,
0.2946641743,
0.4124264717,
0.7376238108,
0.4474292994,
-0.1454401463,
0.688207984,
0.3603137732,
-0.7591212988,
0.5830731392,
-0.6196786761,
0.7480586171,
0.9362959266,
0.1183890179,
-0.1552999616,
-0.4720159173,
-0.4127488732,
-1.1963969469,
0.5571267605,
0.0622778647,
0.104701452,
-0.2272914946,
0.5571441054,
-0.0792939514,
0.3207145929,
-0.4677000344,
-0.0332586579,
-0.3304850459,
-0.3752260506,
0.1359136552,
-0.1745303422,
-0.2137247175,
-0.1703946739,
0.4675402045,
-0.5662620068,
-0.13856709,
0.3761363924,
-0.2164711207,
0.0628459305,
-0.0386145711,
0.5434567332,
0.4638194144,
-0.3738614023,
0.2211398482,
-0.0220109764,
-0.4379046857,
-0.1606501043,
0.3608490229,
-0.6886042953,
0.1676169336,
0.1966692507,
0.62542063,
0.1616799533,
-0.9214205742,
0.5989352465,
-0.1614528894,
-0.4033736289,
0.0760291666,
-0.0522704348,
0.3361212909,
0.0986009091,
0.5347226262,
0.1064351946,
0.5451484323,
-0.1230282187,
0.1843133718,
0.5221397877,
-0.1700385362,
-0.1694116294,
0.9540659189,
0.4248611927,
0.0476836748,
0.6457861662,
-0.524775207,
-0.1770906299,
0.502479732,
0.4542093277,
0.9897895455,
0.4162098169,
0.1191805378,
0.3428817689,
0.2980641723,
0.1279222965,
0.4182603657,
-0.5083139539,
-0.4669987261,
-0.4677993953,
-0.5238420367,
-0.1951645315,
-0.0921686813,
-1.0606386662,
0.0620103888,
-0.7281339765,
-0.3798858225,
-0.0761206448,
-0.2852525711,
-0.2509450614,
0.1148694977,
-0.1559513062,
0.8825686574,
-0.3382022083,
0.6964321733,
0.4563613832,
-0.658449769,
-0.7417872548,
0.1061673462,
-0.2210095227,
-0.4879778028,
0.2340290397,
-0.1734735966,
-0.3435693085,
0.1315492839,
-0.5217003822,
-0.7645747066,
1.1976205111,
0.634849906,
-0.3080723882,
-0.3703783751,
-0.2641961575,
0.382076025,
-0.1288454682,
0.0718417019,
0.3825939596,
0.0087744091,
0.093469426,
-0.4700380862,
0.454048574,
-0.4783586264,
-0.0005435743,
0.2975877523,
-0.762790978,
0.7487069964,
-0.4107635617,
-0.3662833571,
0.2409671843,
1.0229626894,
0.1912806481,
0.2744570374,
0.3551385105,
0.464589715,
0.8075075746,
0.0806526914,
1.1900168657,
-0.5192029476,
0.1715096533,
1.1517950296,
-0.1622514576,
0.7655510306,
0.6964523792,
0.0942984074,
0.115736261,
0.3827421069,
0.1481191069,
0.8160620928,
0.3898127675,
-0.4545784295,
-0.1335463524,
-0.5747338533,
-0.3742439151,
0.3125467598,
0.4769369662,
-0.2517961264,
-0.4621002078,
0.0703139901,
-0.0971028805,
0.2544925213,
-0.4554922283,
0.7513144016,
0.1023348123,
-0.743422091,
1.0082973242,
0.2430945635,
0.8887088895,
-0.8475088477,
0.2709242105,
-0.5391494632,
-0.0250847768,
-0.394923985,
-0.2864437997,
0.3147785962,
0.1102461144,
-0.4528527856,
-0.1762950122,
0.7219027877,
-0.460157007,
-0.3988429308,
-0.0606235489,
0.5729822516,
-0.2234076262,
-0.0561502352,
-0.3380129635,
-0.2929112911,
0.090427205,
-0.3600362241,
0.5379364491,
0.723110199,
0.0476925485,
0.6208241582,
0.3347957432,
0.0554683059,
0.0102056097,
0.1964772195,
1.072920084,
-0.6833834648,
-0.7976984978,
-0.2455596626,
0.2525219321,
0.0681197867,
-0.705150187,
0.5825184584,
0.5440993309,
0.3833846748,
-0.0498106256,
0.7249810696,
-0.1739596725,
0.314222455,
-0.6687682271,
0.7738791108,
-0.8482828736,
0.171600163,
0.0958336443,
-0.4928056598,
-0.3584268391,
0.2328361422,
0.1293433309,
-0.1271285266,
0.6412570477,
0.8913967609,
0.1786691099,
0.0084308172,
0.1867592037,
-0.2802767456,
0.0130121671,
0.5851893425,
0.7220771313,
-0.1869090647,
1.0310753584,
-0.2084401995,
0.0015585002,
-0.1510946006,
-0.7111641169,
-0.8912100196,
-0.328469336,
-0.3247824013,
-0.3652844429,
0.0370026603,
0.8761790991,
0.6648339033,
-0.663664341,
-0.0391663872,
-0.3130713105,
0.0828285441,
-0.1037105247,
-0.2396223992,
0.6262586117,
-0.3389207423,
-0.564632833,
0.4358947277,
0.0924752504,
0.1159515232,
-0.109161146,
-0.0796092674,
-0.0843706578,
0.0209287163,
0.572943449,
0.3672145009,
-0.4346587658,
0.0689979941,
0.2064233571,
-0.165382877,
-0.2003769577,
1.0391714573,
-0.9340763688,
0.1390495449,
0.6541667581,
0.7335454822,
0.8116015196,
0.1022128314,
0.689293623,
-1.0845530033,
0.3387490809,
0.7028284073,
0.2529170811,
0.3467332721,
-0.3999349773,
0.235996291,
0.1384620816,
-0.0281218234,
-0.9466270208,
0.2839678824,
-1.0319290161,
-0.4270755649,
0.8034847975,
-0.0157063268,
-0.2013540268,
0.0663382336,
-0.0010221601,
0.1157307029,
-0.4834356904,
0.4869999588,
0.3255253136,
-0.1776238978,
-0.3058104813,
-0.204769522,
0.6277412176,
0.73049891,
-0.504673779,
0.1920681,
0.6516259313,
-0.0200597961,
-0.1029212624,
0.8360995054,
-0.1675434262,
0.3999096751,
0.2103730589,
0.0592779666,
-0.2489908636,
-0.0945065692,
-0.4067682624,
0.7341775298,
0.0796383247,
-0.1134288535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11693v1 | Studying the Impact of Semi-Cooperative Drivers on Overall Highway Flow | 2023-04-23T16:01:36 | 2023-04-23T16:01:36 | Noam Buckman, Sertac Karaman, Daniela Rus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Semi-cooperative behaviors are intrinsic properties of human drivers and
should be considered for autonomous driving. In addition, new autonomous
planners can consider the social value orientation (SVO) of human drivers to
generate socially-compliant trajectories. Yet the overall impact on traffic
flow for this new class of planners remain to be understood. In this work, we
present study of implicit semi-cooperative driving where agents deploy a
game-theoretic version of iterative best response assuming knowledge of the
SVOs of other agents. We simulate nominal traffic flow and investigate whether
the proportion of prosocial agents on the road impact individual or system-wide
driving performance. Experiments show that the proportion of prosocial agents
has a minor impact on overall traffic flow and that benefits of
semi-cooperation disproportionally affect egoistic and high-speed drivers. | [
-0.1208593398,
-0.5784702301,
0.8093407154,
0.4547405243,
-0.18049559,
0.0191452391,
0.0946406797,
-0.7384437323,
0.193523258,
0.3827413917,
-0.4795088172,
0.1085967422,
-0.3221289814,
0.0787974149,
-0.0649983585,
0.7679619193,
0.1949444115,
0.16343458,
-0.2944913805,
-0.1602058262,
-0.2642787695,
-0.4103859663,
-0.6332997084,
0.0276578646,
0.3478373885,
0.1813262999,
1.0423601866,
0.2189675421,
0.1873630583,
0.5622757077,
0.1036491096,
-0.48688519,
-0.6315712333,
0.1715239286,
-0.2545991838,
-0.1849633753,
-0.3090745211,
0.1177644581,
0.9580962062,
0.4655862451,
-0.1808205694,
-0.0688605979,
-0.0510583632,
0.3018879294,
-0.6279746294,
0.3585809767,
-0.0651848912,
-0.2887318134,
-0.2107063234,
-0.4915452003,
-0.0658892989,
-0.6443494558,
0.5957123041,
-0.6761645675,
-0.0848416612,
0.3334924579,
0.5863178372,
0.3297337592,
-0.488150239,
-0.2948440909,
-0.8956990242,
0.5905704498,
-0.1807154417,
-0.0120633254,
-0.0698539242,
0.3380956054,
-0.3543492556,
-0.0793639943,
-0.761701405,
0.0231171586,
-0.07689666,
0.3983469009,
-0.1747841239,
0.5306141973,
-0.3426115215,
0.1518633068,
-0.2267850339,
0.0590665266,
-0.6770381331,
0.0190168247,
1.1012622118,
0.7033655643,
0.115755409,
0.3414565325,
-0.3877115548,
-0.0660897866,
-0.3148882985,
0.9422898293,
0.456949383,
0.1191990077,
-0.3043136299,
0.4552964866,
-0.0736432299,
0.5103082657,
0.1092924923,
-0.0437204763,
0.2507190704,
-0.6903704405,
-0.0456560291,
0.0651875883,
0.7343320847,
0.4574822187,
0.5250307918,
-0.350474,
-0.1625897735,
-0.0637302995,
0.062693812,
-0.3998298347,
0.0131564913,
-0.0037046587,
-0.0967970341,
-0.6289083958,
0.2967132032,
-0.4605269134,
-0.0054195663,
-0.30872944,
0.4398566484,
0.2032355666,
-0.3869046569,
0.0015834189,
-0.4739862382,
0.4947291315,
0.4595630467,
-0.5073655248,
0.4291003346,
0.4327711463,
0.9091516733,
-0.0369551405,
-0.5037770271,
-0.662340045,
0.541128397,
-0.2018105239,
0.9180566072,
-0.4982459545,
-0.6655288339,
-0.1606594771,
0.170257479,
0.2270734608,
-0.4214679897,
0.1505776495,
-0.4057180882,
-0.2281424999,
-0.4827739,
-0.2923591435,
0.124054715,
-0.2698033452,
-0.5606177449,
0.4384994209,
0.3044903278,
-0.2217053771,
0.2310803384,
-0.4040186703,
-1.0034759045,
0.3501764238,
-0.343659699,
-0.0779519603,
0.4653482735,
-0.896256566,
0.3024430275,
-0.1592683494,
0.0913723707,
-0.398187995,
-0.4104328752,
0.0547933355,
0.0317793898,
0.9367861152,
-0.3297342062,
-0.228159681,
0.3905919194,
-0.4782998562,
-0.1061410457,
-0.1722511798,
-0.1394765228,
-0.4621422291,
-0.1433020681,
-0.2428377718,
0.6028809547,
-0.057847172,
-0.6084922552,
-0.1793842167,
0.0061001554,
-0.0637249425,
1.8907445669,
0.4155218303,
0.9088590741,
-0.2883731127,
0.5347059965,
0.119410336,
0.8122113347,
1.0227798223,
-0.7939891815,
-0.3085121512,
-0.3228809834,
-0.0659186766,
0.0840111896,
-0.733377099,
-0.0612871833,
-0.0660657138,
-0.070543237,
-0.528677702,
-0.1959856153,
0.4245303273,
0.2138225585,
-0.2427904755,
-0.2522687316,
0.0026293446,
-0.653162837,
0.2129603773,
-0.4324652255,
0.1958771646,
0.5352275372,
0.3621625006,
0.1882421076,
0.8162543178,
-0.5556814671,
-0.478836894,
0.0139889605,
0.2049197257,
-0.4476670921,
0.3316920102,
0.5844744444,
-0.770258069,
-0.6017680168,
-0.4579857886,
-0.3398116231,
-0.0887316093,
0.0593740791,
-0.5294038057,
0.2916229367,
-0.1367734373,
-0.3407393694,
0.3255233765,
0.618324101,
-0.8811937571,
0.72133708,
-0.4388663173,
-0.0056508398,
-0.1393144131,
-0.2772630155,
0.2772702873,
-0.2812556326,
-0.5193270445,
-0.3625566661,
-0.4763238132,
0.3293653131,
-0.4116771519,
0.1288625151,
-0.3589615226,
-0.6777727604,
-0.1947214305,
-0.0067834631,
-0.3273418248,
0.2273503542,
0.2369467616,
1.1735161543,
0.5413509607,
-1.1053152084,
0.1062609777,
-0.101620093,
0.0497854576,
0.7743723392,
-0.815333128,
-0.0886108577,
-0.391110301,
0.3934861124,
-0.6277166605,
-0.1420239806,
0.037411239,
-0.4827677906,
-0.0938375443,
0.0908922032,
-0.6220393181,
0.2644727826,
-0.3914112747,
0.1839804202,
0.6397482157,
0.0326843895,
0.5707147717,
1.0975966454,
0.0904402658,
-0.0017483956,
-0.0361042544,
-0.1706683338,
0.1797982752,
-1.0737315416,
0.1362680793,
-0.0169164743,
-0.6479301453,
0.1486097425,
0.1656058729,
0.0388765857,
0.1884232014,
0.4616245031,
0.5258052349,
0.3172969818,
-0.2920304537,
0.0033484998,
-0.2648969591,
0.5533097386,
-0.0044928282,
0.3306537867,
-0.4348710775,
0.2852116227,
-0.4527323842,
0.5341444612,
0.3656673133,
-0.1710487902,
1.0107414722,
0.1866597831,
0.2268059254,
0.1534495205,
0.1598777324,
-0.0679414123,
-0.5483899117,
-0.0984962657,
-0.4408659339,
-0.9013577104,
0.3706738055,
-0.0229619592,
0.0878727809,
0.3029059768,
0.3257209957,
-0.5773733258,
1.2074227333,
0.7771484256,
0.2802199423,
0.2533637881,
-0.3390848041,
-0.0963005722,
-0.4768867195,
-0.5538852811,
-0.4306471646,
-0.2425022423,
-0.9841601253,
-0.3509849012,
0.6721349955,
-0.5021927357,
-0.1515093744,
-0.1405281276,
-0.150526613,
0.2635745704,
0.4709737301,
0.1229044721,
0.4248848855,
-0.7477027774,
0.2719837129,
0.3742071092,
-0.6948465109,
-0.2020809501,
0.5285311341,
-0.0851967484,
0.8309291601,
0.4229275286,
0.386004895,
0.4586121142,
0.1321666241,
-0.5136897564,
0.7207512259,
0.2155149281,
-0.4801333845,
-0.4665971994,
-0.6729223132,
-0.7677468657,
-0.3002191186,
-0.2656936646,
-0.5736200809,
0.5047025681,
0.1494717002,
-0.7024935484,
-0.2136730552,
-0.4123469889,
0.7498795986,
-0.3322436213,
-0.9152643681,
-0.4175412953,
-0.8957269788,
-0.0151897958,
0.343087405,
0.3491412997,
-0.0353090055,
-0.2668798566,
0.3355410993,
-0.4202670455,
0.6067601442,
-0.5863673687,
0.0828842446,
0.3757887185,
0.130932495,
0.7365757227,
0.0119459257,
0.2980598211,
0.350001663,
-0.2214217037,
-0.4408797026,
-0.4708031714,
0.7253698111,
-0.9745941758,
-0.7519937754,
-0.610974431,
-0.4416056573,
0.1955074221,
-0.2077343464,
0.1970479637,
0.2493518144,
-0.0267843455,
-0.419084698,
0.5553913713,
0.0112663163,
0.3184441626,
0.7390523553,
0.0957845002,
0.0281630456,
0.7355335355,
0.2165028304,
0.9027993679,
-0.1801784635,
0.3103578389,
-0.589292407,
-0.0979645625,
-0.5422329307,
0.2604815066,
-0.1349724382,
0.2914166749,
-0.5290555954,
0.1913150549,
-0.4013320506,
-0.4012974501,
-0.3741060793,
-0.4376738667,
0.0206864011,
0.1426600516,
0.0331309289,
0.7592772841,
-0.5495405197,
0.3190116584,
-0.2774010301,
-0.1441196948,
0.5527719855,
0.2040068209,
-0.0260660127,
0.0731014535,
-0.1808478236,
-0.1388595253,
-0.1494052708,
-0.7719650865,
-0.1163002625,
-0.1832215935,
0.523440659,
0.409144789,
0.5464803576,
0.6119577885,
-0.1614811867,
0.5146681666,
0.2364109755,
-0.6900514364,
0.1919193417,
-0.1492934972,
0.0808277875,
0.5550657511,
0.2711667717,
-0.1231178716,
-0.6411381364,
-0.5979596376,
-0.4770069122,
0.654304564,
0.8581174016,
-0.2184562087,
0.0976699442,
0.1273411512,
-0.1847405136,
0.2142899334,
-0.3488671482,
-0.4092614949,
-0.0464714505,
0.1064964384,
-0.1406853944,
-0.0426919125,
-0.0609478317,
-0.3107764721,
0.510332644,
0.1877806038,
0.402156204,
0.3814018369,
0.296946466,
-0.5359868407,
0.0156764258,
0.7079634666,
0.3570918441,
-0.3552808464,
0.3098702729,
-0.2100224048,
-0.2076471746,
0.5785930157,
-0.3440277576,
-0.4243195355,
0.022119537,
-0.0975161195,
0.1484837681,
0.0843056366,
-0.4438964128,
0.7598204017,
-0.3443935812,
-0.0705308095,
-0.5257604122,
0.389968425,
-0.2453312576,
0.455509901,
0.2125792652,
0.4916447103,
0.5684554577,
-0.921703577,
-0.1299678832,
0.5029969215,
-0.690461278,
-0.7735645175,
0.4762402475,
0.5982764959,
-0.4256749451,
0.2167314738,
-0.5798366666,
-0.8220234513,
0.682005167,
0.2309293449,
0.7521538734,
-0.2522211969,
0.175884366,
0.2040107101,
0.148997277,
-0.0092166383,
0.2178349048,
-0.2633453012,
-0.5215610266,
-0.3852761686,
-0.2233624905,
-0.215380162,
-0.6759803295,
-0.452039808,
0.0767925456,
-0.3921776116,
-0.3608994484,
0.0461647436,
-0.0463234037,
-0.5316013694,
-0.061814107,
-0.1442088485,
0.4621162117,
-0.7581366301,
0.4245918095,
1.1085351706,
-0.4427225888,
-0.7011805177,
0.2062257528,
0.0714877248,
-0.5227615237,
0.7111578584,
-0.0800878406,
-0.8530430794,
0.1670518667,
-0.5138468146,
-0.6574949026,
1.1192547083,
-0.1045643985,
-0.3157253563,
-0.0879912004,
0.4205941558,
0.7108857036,
-0.1929996759,
0.264357686,
0.2729378939,
0.439378202,
0.3268826604,
-0.9751253724,
0.2488164604,
-0.0530461594,
0.2731466889,
0.1156009361,
-1.225716114,
0.589368403,
-0.3899306059,
-0.3906055689,
-0.1133010462,
0.4249390364,
0.5251309872,
0.4113853574,
0.9881467819,
0.1280203909,
0.3172856867,
0.2129445076,
1.0186715126,
-0.2455613166,
0.1466727853,
0.7930084467,
-0.2639363706,
0.212451458,
0.5595827699,
-0.097702153,
0.347519666,
0.1574482024,
0.7319621444,
1.0758020878,
0.2572887838,
-0.4902233779,
-0.5975982547,
-0.4562023282,
0.0161005408,
0.7836460471,
-0.3852934837,
0.1103015393,
-0.0257830471,
-0.2389953434,
-0.1066379845,
-0.2536554039,
-0.4576916993,
0.9081534743,
-0.0875003114,
-0.5930565596,
-0.1814287156,
-0.129452005,
0.4794626236,
-0.3707075715,
-0.0203945078,
0.0503122211,
0.3204193413,
-0.1415539533,
-1.3270676136,
0.2829119861,
-0.2468503118,
0.0293067768,
-0.1565835476,
0.5247054696,
0.1539913118,
0.0776107982,
0.534930408,
0.279610306,
0.0974316373,
-0.0115424143,
-0.3287314475,
-0.199238956,
-0.1595873833,
0.0188549347,
0.3459753394,
0.6978578568,
0.0369528756,
0.5461900234,
0.6652638912,
-0.0475502722,
0.1238395721,
-0.087833941,
1.2166495323,
-0.5113873482,
-0.6944723725,
-0.8785811067,
0.5760127306,
-0.4364849627,
-0.3292479515,
0.8246930242,
0.5270254016,
0.650210917,
0.3246957064,
0.5206317902,
-0.1580776423,
-0.3035073578,
-0.0925617665,
0.4294813871,
-0.3597281873,
0.2041948885,
-0.4461172521,
-0.5344754457,
0.5527150035,
0.6101247668,
-0.2093015462,
-0.1836424917,
-0.0088825738,
0.589394331,
0.3248276711,
0.2862358391,
0.1784887016,
0.1572191864,
0.2452284992,
0.5771983266,
1.2271900177,
-0.0004987652,
0.2214773595,
-0.7277219892,
-0.8055101633,
-0.0916827023,
-0.245016858,
-0.722045064,
-0.5916330814,
-0.1874774247,
-0.2480343729,
0.4247167706,
0.5129514337,
0.7735288739,
-0.1144058108,
-0.3196000159,
-0.2533133924,
0.3298912048,
-0.097769618,
-0.3411603272,
-0.1983893663,
0.0881431177,
-0.3221319616,
-0.2069318593,
0.6412168145,
0.367199868,
-0.5134473443,
-0.7155951262,
-0.1268340498,
0.1621766537,
0.5450982451,
-0.0420239232,
0.0828907862,
-0.1608888507,
0.1772177666,
-0.2585308254,
-0.1495632231,
0.8821678162,
-0.6592439413,
0.1607230455,
0.2647975683,
-0.3049512804,
0.2844268382,
0.2157568485,
0.84343189,
-0.4191541374,
0.0593275838,
0.3670864105,
-0.2235773504,
-0.4377668202,
-0.8801125288,
0.5155006051,
0.561383903,
-0.8641163707,
-0.4452030063,
0.1008794084,
-0.9051969051,
-0.0670520291,
1.217009306,
-0.199540481,
-0.5670442581,
-0.5191358328,
0.0683014616,
0.2449780852,
-1.0238389969,
0.6693614721,
-0.014878789,
-0.5584942102,
-0.3500091434,
-0.245401293,
0.4088616371,
0.2047128826,
-0.665661931,
-0.296992749,
0.8062325716,
-0.0606093518,
-0.0803577006,
1.0390363932,
0.174306646,
0.4445491433,
0.0373887792,
-0.3244091272,
-0.1695945561,
-0.4422922432,
-0.0866792649,
-0.052309148,
-0.1540617794,
-0.0733003542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11679v2 | Domain Mastery Benchmark: An Ever-Updating Benchmark for Evaluating Holistic Domain Knowledge of Large Language Model--A Preliminary Release | 2023-04-23T15:11:49 | 2023-08-10T05:27:58 | Zhouhong Gu, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Haoning Ye, Lin Zhang, Zhuozhi Xiong, Zihan Li, Qianyu He, Sihang Jiang, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain knowledge refers to the in-depth understanding, expertise, and
familiarity with a specific subject, industry, field, or area of special
interest. The existing benchmarks are all lack of an overall design for domain
knowledge evaluation. Holding the belief that the real ability of domain
language understanding can only be fairly evaluated by an comprehensive and
in-depth benchmark, we introduces the Domma, a Domain Mastery Benchmark. DomMa
targets at testing Large Language Models (LLMs) on their domain knowledge
understanding, it features extensive domain coverage, large data volume, and a
continually updated data set based on Chinese 112 first-level subject
classifications. DomMa consist of 100,000 questions in both Chinese and English
sourced from graduate entrance examinations and undergraduate exams in Chinese
college. We have also propose designs to make benchmark and evaluation process
more suitable to LLMs. | [
-0.3922224939,
-0.9268150926,
0.4418719411,
0.4543899596,
-0.095262453,
0.1142600998,
-0.5303631425,
-0.3002910316,
-0.4383099675,
0.4967230856,
-0.3506188691,
-0.7017314434,
-0.560335815,
-0.1275831461,
-0.3292436898,
0.4882273972,
-0.2255800664,
-0.0366264246,
-0.8186804056,
-0.1551830918,
-0.5188558102,
-0.5345320702,
-0.5431259274,
-0.5486189127,
0.3118425608,
0.3550744653,
0.3144390583,
0.5215753317,
0.829216063,
0.2499152124,
-0.1398606896,
0.4057358503,
-0.4477243423,
0.0814374462,
-0.1806897968,
-0.1285462976,
-0.9362372756,
-0.0332446434,
0.8871892691,
1.10902071,
0.1459885836,
0.3694764376,
0.0087466165,
0.6421100497,
-0.820792675,
0.1060945094,
-0.6626079679,
-0.1422524005,
-0.292588532,
-0.1843061,
-0.402774781,
-0.2919663191,
0.3389236927,
-0.4111024439,
-0.0794466883,
-0.2406381816,
0.8025676012,
0.0324140638,
-0.5989643335,
0.2871446311,
-0.4146485031,
0.7899612188,
-0.5065770745,
0.3951478302,
0.4519576132,
0.6254020929,
-0.0393208116,
-0.7615836859,
-0.4567804337,
-0.1836218238,
0.2082943022,
0.044309929,
0.1789760143,
-0.1645867229,
0.0726780295,
0.6533669829,
-0.6152721047,
0.0590255596,
0.1127843261,
-0.0136511484,
0.8742316961,
0.4974360764,
0.4124034643,
0.383241415,
-0.594397366,
-0.1527712047,
-0.9672053456,
-0.0674492717,
-0.1531697512,
-0.0457966812,
-0.040180441,
0.2458853275,
-0.406281352,
0.9740281701,
-0.23041673,
-0.3080319166,
0.2804381251,
-0.3620580733,
-0.6034008861,
-0.3939421773,
0.3640444875,
0.3928846121,
0.4845214188,
-0.2412683517,
-0.0879124999,
-0.018310396,
0.2940962911,
-0.6646509767,
0.0409275331,
0.217653662,
-0.1540210545,
0.2177553922,
0.1751003712,
-0.4584775865,
-0.3420102596,
-0.475592196,
0.4043076634,
-0.3168126941,
-0.4211040735,
0.3967416286,
0.0192085672,
0.567969501,
0.6428410411,
-0.6288465261,
0.4332242608,
1.0036690235,
0.5608477592,
-0.9632194638,
-0.7410002947,
0.0349040404,
0.1802754253,
-0.158411175,
0.8895587921,
-0.448399961,
-0.4641441405,
0.0916797668,
0.0398713723,
-0.355189234,
-0.90970397,
0.4154151976,
-0.8518203497,
-0.2567660511,
-0.4293430448,
-0.8468997478,
-0.1977019757,
0.5069593191,
-0.277438432,
1.0642333031,
0.3624217212,
-0.3016765714,
0.4906508923,
-0.4157227278,
-0.4810699522,
0.2359963208,
0.0569478944,
-0.1444282234,
-0.2281705439,
-0.1497697383,
0.3837054968,
-0.4629781246,
0.4640681148,
-0.2173352987,
-0.3043445647,
0.296546489,
-0.2121225297,
0.7489343286,
0.119211413,
-0.2849541903,
-0.0262648743,
-0.706281662,
0.1436472088,
0.3144043982,
-0.1358093321,
-0.3594990075,
-0.2751460373,
0.0165971164,
0.2933842838,
0.6523374915,
-0.2398728728,
0.3244353533,
-0.1377613395,
-0.1309205741,
0.8200922608,
0.1795077324,
0.2782625556,
-0.4920417666,
0.4409151971,
0.0513075441,
0.182276845,
-0.064480193,
-0.5699666739,
-0.9257774353,
-0.0467313565,
0.2828189731,
0.2535553575,
-0.0992363915,
0.635047555,
-0.491743356,
-0.7015975118,
-0.255112797,
0.4449110925,
0.4231009185,
0.2846168578,
0.2919327915,
-0.4823717475,
-0.2547874749,
-0.7226385474,
-0.2579262555,
-0.018050205,
0.1688298583,
0.3136372268,
0.6433925033,
-0.3093654811,
0.8621423841,
-0.6428838372,
-0.4904333055,
-0.3046252728,
-0.0543389507,
0.0417152196,
0.3430517614,
0.607134223,
-0.5066042542,
-0.8742384315,
0.3378339112,
-0.880559206,
-0.1375122815,
0.1216654032,
-0.414181143,
-0.1851658672,
0.1529401392,
-0.5525202751,
0.2148082852,
0.3638101816,
-0.2971485555,
0.5377819538,
-0.1593910456,
0.1162419543,
-0.634304285,
0.1197026819,
-0.0070208628,
-0.0836077631,
-0.6059535742,
0.4751170874,
0.3471746147,
0.1551309526,
-0.4496983588,
0.9027227163,
-0.6431723237,
-0.3098962903,
-0.4202793837,
0.5015002489,
0.1996051371,
0.4706426263,
0.0103313085,
0.9022156596,
0.7197875977,
-0.9319388866,
0.4772402942,
0.2016569525,
-0.6238242388,
0.7116418481,
-0.5373151898,
0.173867628,
0.2551053762,
-0.071111396,
-0.9265648127,
-0.0502773523,
-0.3630751669,
-0.2506744266,
0.2785785794,
0.2547002137,
-0.4149101973,
-0.3564933836,
-0.1617204845,
0.4185339212,
0.4315239787,
-0.5285232067,
0.2858041525,
0.7094857097,
0.0926399007,
-0.4142128229,
-0.3651720881,
0.079760693,
0.0234004427,
-0.7760868669,
0.3371082246,
-0.3950365782,
-0.4956037402,
-0.2963003218,
-0.1137426794,
-0.3036126196,
0.4479621947,
0.1208606511,
0.0161539558,
-0.3042697012,
-0.0368396677,
-0.0936763883,
0.0180713646,
0.4251884818,
-0.0692544207,
0.4817496538,
0.0437721908,
-0.6065922379,
-0.3073453307,
-0.0251566917,
0.5669491291,
-0.1978595704,
0.3215318918,
0.1712849736,
-0.4799917638,
-0.5612280965,
-0.5407722592,
0.0819417536,
-0.4321056306,
0.3207016289,
-0.7315872312,
-0.6959790587,
0.4881331623,
-0.3258821964,
-0.0850387961,
0.6315662861,
0.8662894964,
0.244799763,
0.7250785828,
0.3779167533,
-0.3959771395,
-0.0487853251,
-0.4746772647,
-0.2132586092,
-0.9004540443,
-0.2609855533,
-0.5363993645,
-0.1857045293,
0.1686248779,
-0.5808609128,
0.157162264,
-0.1666748077,
-0.4112569392,
0.326946348,
-0.1571370959,
0.3632357717,
0.3641816676,
0.0352286138,
0.6890642643,
-0.1827519983,
-0.1852822304,
-0.1583112627,
-0.276052326,
-0.2782027423,
1.2442048788,
0.3019329607,
0.4546140432,
0.2413153052,
0.1123748794,
0.629535377,
0.4506267607,
-0.6588561535,
0.5987973213,
0.1183709651,
-0.6241232157,
-0.0725989118,
-0.1523010582,
-0.7105277777,
0.298181653,
0.2306932658,
-0.4998283088,
0.1074455231,
-0.4109124839,
-0.0118310787,
0.2974916101,
-0.3069828749,
1.1208033562,
-0.1947129667,
-0.3527611494,
-0.2746969461,
-0.2709603012,
0.5329944491,
-0.398255378,
-0.1520625651,
-0.2978672683,
-0.1887135357,
0.6553238034,
-0.4062488973,
0.6996316314,
-0.1456509531,
-0.4157463908,
0.2700746953,
0.1071068123,
0.331857264,
-0.0079638679,
-0.1163994595,
0.144730553,
-0.3497898579,
-0.4931035638,
-0.5259456038,
0.776884377,
-1.0079045296,
-0.8321638703,
-0.3408140242,
-0.2746249437,
-0.5920932293,
0.0957561508,
-0.0512255207,
0.2392608672,
-0.7077826858,
0.1280973703,
0.7636118531,
-0.0982844755,
0.0981012881,
0.8001667857,
-0.2365467846,
-0.1324137151,
0.7560444474,
-0.0079766922,
0.3775593042,
0.381482482,
-0.1076715887,
-0.258027643,
-0.7423105836,
-0.4082402885,
0.3036432266,
-0.8341772556,
-0.2192472816,
-0.9001463056,
-0.5446150899,
-0.3706494868,
0.0095643997,
-0.3923073709,
-0.0034537269,
-0.015759699,
0.0187783856,
0.2713581026,
0.6341869831,
0.2878782153,
0.2824017406,
-0.5516280532,
0.3535309732,
0.6126292348,
0.4734513164,
0.1937454641,
-0.9690138102,
-0.5443027616,
-0.0054437746,
-0.4540872872,
-0.470905453,
0.1643221527,
0.3898879886,
0.8052531481,
0.6337426305,
-0.0068582948,
0.6106973886,
-0.2514323294,
0.7959671617,
-0.3455094993,
-1.1847748756,
0.5608597994,
-0.2750268579,
0.4938153327,
0.7194122076,
0.2766990364,
-0.4553250074,
-0.4074801505,
-0.5102518201,
-0.3572981358,
0.4396972656,
-0.1795611531,
0.2489220649,
0.0512496792,
0.1750147492,
0.2417824566,
0.2425541282,
-0.2882728279,
-0.603325069,
0.2171653807,
0.2651915252,
-0.0507219993,
-0.3893104494,
-0.0748218447,
-0.7470550537,
0.6593725085,
-0.1864070147,
0.1262955815,
-0.0287080891,
-0.5290691853,
-0.1489203423,
0.1402093768,
0.7270151377,
1.3740932941,
-0.4651607871,
-0.0109664313,
0.383910358,
-0.728048265,
0.2082939148,
-0.3165077865,
-0.0312835611,
-0.1370670646,
0.3657993376,
0.5181857347,
0.1296512038,
-0.8248365521,
0.8843342662,
0.1888228953,
-0.3693335652,
-0.3589503169,
0.0491020195,
0.0956856534,
-0.2395917475,
0.5394619107,
-0.3072049618,
0.0423982441,
-0.4575936198,
0.4614154696,
0.3429483771,
-0.3926459551,
-0.3637696207,
0.6397915483,
0.1370047629,
0.186480388,
0.2764182687,
-0.142349422,
-0.5678198338,
0.757309556,
0.6237472892,
0.8597431183,
-0.2147559971,
0.1768808961,
0.2360319942,
0.1479283571,
-0.0044572204,
0.3057050705,
-0.0802343488,
-0.9614636302,
-0.505943954,
-0.4763984382,
-0.7882194519,
0.1469334364,
-0.5324680209,
0.1306322664,
-0.6094886065,
-0.1327782422,
-0.1968606561,
0.5102702379,
-0.6490936279,
0.6027479768,
0.0174342543,
1.315754056,
-0.6163144708,
1.3029677868,
0.713935554,
-0.1168196276,
-0.233847633,
-0.0716534033,
-0.1355503947,
-1.0572589636,
0.9288980961,
-0.064193733,
0.0080027152,
0.0212812405,
-0.2528078258,
-0.6375407577,
1.1568106413,
0.0560098775,
-0.1327694654,
0.4767741859,
0.3297058046,
0.6710352898,
-0.6324646473,
0.210178569,
0.9763559103,
0.8352319598,
-0.1939849406,
-0.7581100464,
-0.0786029994,
-0.6052871943,
0.0048630224,
-0.0583615191,
-0.8343799114,
1.0223864317,
0.030781284,
-0.2816864848,
-0.0625379831,
0.714756906,
0.2021381408,
0.456605047,
0.4074763954,
0.7709335089,
0.5656055212,
-0.3727541268,
0.9584272504,
-0.4176525176,
0.4196674228,
0.9253222942,
-0.7046371698,
0.7360244989,
-0.0322558135,
-0.4677417278,
0.3332007527,
0.7421504855,
-0.0893669203,
0.2751642466,
0.3107843697,
-0.300575912,
-0.4981049299,
-0.3890441656,
-0.7959414721,
0.4942083061,
0.3337315321,
-0.0767698064,
-0.0933195427,
-0.1502759904,
0.1168181002,
0.3302559555,
-0.2491054982,
0.85247612,
0.1456350833,
-0.5829637647,
0.8743126392,
0.0317441374,
0.4535951912,
-0.5931146741,
0.255453974,
-0.5158135891,
0.2548579872,
0.0886022002,
-0.7833052278,
0.0459268056,
-0.1363463551,
0.0140672289,
-0.2253909558,
0.7599784136,
-0.3773470223,
-0.0759675875,
0.7235887647,
0.8995483518,
-0.0045464211,
-0.4936473966,
-0.7214169502,
0.1604294032,
-0.4407228827,
-0.2508035302,
0.4487006366,
0.549138844,
0.103919439,
0.7697874308,
0.3774577379,
0.2568706274,
-0.0205687359,
0.3848958611,
0.8967334032,
-0.8077995777,
-0.1735336483,
-0.7387763262,
0.2208970189,
-0.1953740269,
-0.5113162398,
1.0101957321,
0.6609057784,
0.8776523471,
-0.1716426611,
0.9022091031,
0.2817987204,
0.2960237265,
-0.1898189187,
0.8193975091,
-0.9522076249,
0.1622872353,
-0.3162295222,
-1.1610965729,
-0.352273345,
0.082142055,
-0.210485056,
0.2373293936,
0.8883119226,
0.4233087301,
0.0717204213,
-0.0391204655,
0.7661259174,
0.0951500833,
-0.0120038642,
0.8865073919,
0.8948788643,
-0.592699945,
-0.0554883629,
-0.3450143337,
-0.2204600722,
-0.3680154383,
-0.5944725871,
-1.0688154697,
-0.5952957273,
-0.3919425905,
-0.2416119576,
-0.0438878313,
0.6679870486,
0.6391816735,
-0.9520230293,
-0.5751204491,
0.3705203235,
0.3126126528,
-0.6711279154,
-0.2365973145,
0.5754817724,
-0.4235951602,
-0.8214569688,
0.4955249131,
0.4698965549,
-0.1238828301,
-0.5597065091,
-0.1009763181,
-0.2884169817,
0.0220723916,
0.7106974721,
0.1242008433,
-0.3873303533,
-0.1561261714,
0.2158529609,
-0.5095575452,
0.1574108899,
0.9775445461,
-0.4390261173,
0.4003627896,
0.5561662912,
0.9945833683,
0.2890220582,
-0.083637245,
0.7110720873,
-0.5558882952,
-0.068274945,
-0.2142765969,
0.3550760746,
0.2438513935,
-0.2021482885,
0.5675747395,
0.5203492641,
-0.4765033424,
-0.6301471591,
-0.0357442573,
-1.3418192863,
-0.2552138865,
1.2288236618,
-0.3210390508,
-0.2321831137,
-0.4186436534,
0.1393147409,
-0.0328529961,
0.0000670797,
0.5700662732,
0.7455531955,
0.4519538581,
-0.0334932208,
-0.5018122792,
0.6277936697,
0.3363821507,
-1.0317460299,
0.3157157004,
0.1074138805,
0.0690009147,
-0.1891428232,
0.8471673727,
-0.2078194469,
0.5310157537,
-0.2758336663,
0.1276489198,
0.1082976833,
-0.4809236228,
-0.076975733,
0.3429273367,
0.406547159,
0.1013770849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11666v1 | Hold the Suspect! : An Analysis on Media Framing of Itaewon Halloween Crowd Crush | 2023-04-23T14:22:25 | 2023-04-23T14:22:25 | TaeYoung Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, stat.AP | Based on the 10.9K articles from top 40 news providers of South Korea, this
paper analyzed the media framing of Itaewon Halloween Crowd Crush during the
first 72 hours after the incident. By adopting word-vector embedding and
clustering, we figured out that conservative media focused on political
parties' responses and the suspect's identity while the liberal media covered
the responsibility of the government and possible unequal spillover effect on
the low-income industry workers. Although the social tragedy was not directly
connected to institutional politics, the media clearly exhibited political bias
in the coverage process. | [
-0.6784401536,
-0.6819922924,
0.4536544085,
0.1465944052,
-0.2105492949,
0.1466583759,
-0.0267274287,
0.0493720807,
0.7350256443,
0.3964426219,
-0.1149910763,
-0.0636990443,
-0.9532120824,
-0.289067775,
-0.5926547647,
0.5450334549,
0.0866121948,
0.1025320143,
0.7494655848,
-0.1988312453,
0.0443513915,
-0.467990905,
-0.4010975957,
0.2800960243,
0.2584111989,
0.2432347387,
0.4997250736,
0.5663533211,
0.2338248193,
0.317474246,
0.1165850759,
-0.4539595544,
-0.56132406,
-0.6382768154,
-0.3517716229,
-0.3674686253,
-0.005845191,
0.3612466455,
0.7560907602,
0.2528072,
-0.0530516505,
0.4407126009,
-0.1542493999,
0.2979026437,
-0.4459145367,
-0.5442606211,
-0.7553399205,
-0.0091005992,
-0.6648401618,
-0.361137718,
-0.3840232193,
-0.2703105509,
-0.2245723307,
-0.448130399,
0.3425796628,
0.0022523317,
0.8499263525,
0.1868166924,
-0.8450456858,
-0.0201289784,
-0.4621153176,
0.7102509737,
-0.430572778,
0.1444054693,
0.4350636601,
0.0687344968,
-0.3601483405,
-0.0823063254,
-0.6156832576,
0.2971290946,
0.200330466,
0.0004847707,
-0.003443527,
0.0277031548,
0.3379774094,
0.1938512474,
-0.2127884477,
-0.034712702,
-0.8416606784,
-0.0845937356,
0.8424392939,
-0.0035094188,
0.4470129907,
-0.8342440724,
-0.5730993748,
0.0962615013,
-0.3547002375,
-0.0951668546,
0.4066991806,
0.2012475729,
-0.2393511981,
0.8174085617,
-0.0769895837,
0.0817006901,
0.4515880346,
-0.092663601,
0.0981216133,
-0.1384876072,
-0.1735709459,
0.6678337455,
0.7972248197,
0.9475284815,
0.3553651273,
0.4056862593,
0.4698492885,
0.2849724591,
0.5213978291,
-0.5694417357,
0.1355420649,
0.2849431634,
-0.8285408616,
-0.4916103482,
0.1542064548,
-1.0484024286,
-0.439665556,
0.2147108763,
-0.042810902,
0.0960411653,
-0.917365551,
-0.0723390356,
-0.1613270789,
0.0825328305,
0.1138679907,
-0.2715175152,
-0.0081056589,
0.5905032158,
0.8224458098,
-0.3818904161,
0.0854505822,
-0.2782812715,
0.3178016543,
-0.6859915853,
0.7557857037,
-0.3631315529,
-0.3118304014,
0.1235645637,
0.2901234627,
-0.12686795,
-0.3264021873,
0.7679469585,
-0.6944253445,
0.2071460634,
-0.3857656717,
-0.6440368891,
-0.269243896,
0.1205246374,
-0.5495566726,
0.880910933,
0.1135081723,
-1.1434218884,
0.8888380527,
-0.0115147177,
-0.2104382962,
0.1896803826,
-0.521869719,
-0.2251700014,
0.586486578,
0.2124296427,
0.3522679806,
0.5446421504,
0.2572758794,
-0.5349163413,
-0.2672101855,
0.1516156793,
-0.1416211426,
0.8886164427,
0.1443407536,
-0.2201860547,
0.1203908324,
-0.6729977131,
-0.1453741938,
0.3392025828,
-0.4576193392,
-0.5375880599,
-0.2659145296,
0.3362168372,
0.3135669827,
-0.5899470448,
-0.606453836,
0.1995372027,
0.095273748,
0.0313914753,
0.5230414867,
0.7046134472,
0.8252620101,
-0.0506394021,
0.4698506296,
0.009605784,
0.0723154396,
-0.0311613567,
-0.2233260572,
-0.2209282964,
-0.2267619818,
-0.0220705532,
0.4663562179,
-0.7685964704,
-0.1224214062,
0.1462696344,
-0.1106506065,
-0.3124859035,
-0.4522325397,
-0.0880424082,
0.2196877599,
-0.1965973079,
0.2471404225,
-0.9040704966,
-0.6696653962,
-0.3893456757,
-0.2248986065,
0.0334235281,
-0.1747263521,
0.2641496956,
0.2735784948,
0.6926721334,
-0.302873373,
-0.7825291753,
-0.3092516661,
-0.1936403215,
0.4960851669,
0.2846831679,
0.7821085453,
-0.8830094934,
-0.428365618,
-0.4008702636,
-0.6318750381,
0.0164555777,
0.1061047986,
0.1010115221,
0.4128223062,
0.7200484276,
-0.5882691145,
0.7721287012,
0.1592688262,
-0.6018015146,
0.4459193945,
0.3923069239,
0.8234718442,
-1.2888548374,
-0.4094516933,
0.1270430088,
-0.1613895893,
-0.8142178655,
-0.0341012403,
0.0904032737,
-0.3237207532,
-0.4976429045,
0.1419979036,
-0.2018505186,
-0.1196488291,
-0.4766313732,
0.486277014,
-0.1915321052,
-0.0599045008,
0.0693732053,
0.2444856763,
0.2709652781,
-0.3308302462,
-0.128841266,
0.0463437401,
-0.7279006243,
0.5252252817,
-0.3318082094,
0.0109850382,
-0.3587472737,
0.1348789781,
-1.0985082388,
-0.7596319914,
0.3096044362,
-0.5388686061,
0.0329984352,
-0.406727463,
-0.236021474,
-0.6277726889,
-0.337993592,
0.1568424404,
0.0055224146,
-0.1823734641,
0.4989719689,
0.8776805401,
0.0406219959,
-0.3062409461,
-0.4944290519,
0.2032081783,
-1.0511559248,
-0.482935667,
0.1698422581,
0.5130957365,
-0.5538341403,
0.1895073503,
-0.2781770229,
-0.0454635546,
-0.0652626827,
-0.042063646,
0.0539088696,
-0.2269525677,
0.0055120611,
-0.0599316359,
-0.3171159029,
0.0713045299,
0.3294928372,
0.4717509151,
0.1694556773,
-0.221474424,
-0.6477373838,
0.7280479074,
0.35538131,
0.2423345745,
0.5771429539,
0.3858288527,
-0.6151328087,
-0.068488881,
-0.5565578938,
-0.3457433879,
-0.4622548223,
0.5820254683,
-0.12954624,
-0.682552278,
0.478294313,
0.0377854779,
-0.4882487953,
0.3032590747,
0.5711452961,
0.154626593,
0.8301563859,
0.4203355312,
-0.5646984577,
0.4695879519,
-0.125704661,
-0.0414350405,
-0.3407460749,
0.0148022873,
-0.3161141872,
-0.4641611576,
-0.1950033903,
-0.3870810568,
0.1994039714,
0.3131283522,
-0.0540794693,
0.2530481815,
-0.6195045114,
0.49738729,
0.0361930877,
-0.05495435,
0.4102560282,
0.1311659813,
0.4798151255,
-0.3342710137,
-0.4296048582,
-0.3566697538,
0.5797582865,
0.5370774269,
0.6261110902,
0.0967380181,
0.5475692153,
0.3223078251,
0.287702322,
-0.36324054,
0.5397868752,
0.1516115516,
-0.924321413,
-0.2056024671,
0.0851365998,
-0.6142936945,
0.3160046935,
0.128988266,
-1.2477022409,
0.8004980087,
-0.1682998985,
-0.260953337,
0.2798765302,
-0.5139572024,
0.526691854,
-0.1063664183,
0.1033214703,
-0.439296037,
-0.0697210655,
0.5980743766,
0.0968965515,
0.6214293838,
-0.4236393273,
-0.2669190466,
0.9005737901,
-0.3200239837,
0.6007533669,
-0.475832969,
0.1051767021,
0.3879723549,
0.0872440934,
0.3439561427,
0.35683617,
0.067799896,
-0.0961494148,
-0.1143580154,
-0.375159353,
-0.2571674585,
0.262327373,
-0.2559814751,
-0.6218762994,
-0.4493249357,
-0.2597469687,
0.1696686745,
-0.0364170298,
0.8980185986,
0.4824373126,
-0.1931594312,
0.306576401,
0.6701616645,
0.1367293745,
0.8682404757,
0.321482569,
-0.6951745152,
-0.5921020508,
0.170896858,
0.4346983135,
0.1028878167,
-0.304495573,
0.1794160306,
0.0833620057,
-0.4609230161,
-0.493993938,
-0.0376793779,
-0.5947583318,
0.115300484,
-0.8456564546,
0.013368763,
-0.1169198751,
-0.3026265502,
-0.6773228049,
-0.0251200385,
-0.1610579342,
-0.5519941449,
0.2674212456,
0.409614414,
0.0653161928,
0.7149161696,
-0.301736474,
0.2281103432,
-0.5229998827,
0.1531280875,
-0.2247415185,
-0.6817925572,
-0.2840875089,
-0.5432741642,
-0.1172597036,
-1.3613058329,
0.2540340424,
-0.1703633815,
0.6031517386,
0.9121273756,
0.5046452284,
0.2179555148,
-0.0289337393,
0.7390366197,
0.1357045174,
-0.4707227349,
0.6092620492,
-0.6988054514,
0.0488254465,
0.4559839666,
0.6767272949,
-0.1167319492,
-0.2480550855,
-0.7969165444,
-0.4207601547,
0.788208425,
0.0004421246,
0.1299258918,
-0.2459298074,
-0.1727361381,
-0.2741259634,
0.2258236706,
-0.6328526139,
-0.3083331287,
-0.3011777103,
0.0136905229,
0.1276039034,
-0.4327267408,
-0.4788250923,
-0.3221635222,
0.2764061689,
-0.1953865141,
0.260800153,
0.2652525008,
-0.0403765216,
-0.2839491367,
0.0502917655,
0.4591910243,
0.8149359822,
-0.1011040881,
0.1038046628,
0.0534102283,
-0.5038079619,
0.1007321775,
-0.1962179244,
-0.2009491175,
0.2296458036,
0.3835249841,
0.8748630285,
0.5265907049,
-0.4929398,
0.6140679121,
0.134031564,
-0.3217393458,
-0.4734531045,
-0.1679617912,
-0.1247250885,
0.675452292,
1.1207437515,
-0.205511868,
0.2324923277,
-0.7124569416,
0.5484640598,
0.1908544898,
-0.2503494024,
-0.238502562,
0.8906781077,
-0.0690828338,
-0.1459939182,
0.2134796828,
-0.1661803573,
-0.8697642088,
0.7331723571,
0.5618304014,
0.7434076071,
-0.687623322,
0.8482351899,
0.4457848966,
0.619269371,
-0.0489229187,
0.2859448493,
0.2620758116,
-0.8468852639,
-0.300816834,
0.0369136445,
0.3094207346,
0.1413177848,
-0.7383897305,
0.1366297603,
-0.551884234,
-0.4571489394,
-0.2328720093,
0.2365695089,
-0.0011088309,
0.1418935061,
0.0051356666,
1.1250779629,
-0.8313729763,
0.597263813,
0.4507436752,
-0.1140787229,
-0.8572258353,
0.4113831818,
0.4695462286,
-0.4389858842,
0.2774893045,
0.2173688859,
0.9002305865,
-0.203545779,
-0.3984742165,
-1.2565557957,
0.6127173901,
0.2246865928,
-0.2284378707,
0.2023983449,
-0.1182386577,
0.2108975947,
-0.701725781,
-0.1647280604,
0.7625539303,
0.3177563548,
0.0839973167,
-0.6860174537,
0.1272879243,
-0.1308493167,
-0.1192878112,
0.5509421825,
-0.8512488604,
0.4845786989,
-0.0775241554,
-0.5239735842,
-0.4806153774,
0.3845508397,
0.0854295492,
0.9413563609,
0.5341884494,
0.4895011783,
0.7129929662,
-0.0551814549,
1.0861749649,
0.240006879,
0.3121035099,
0.8447403908,
0.0234816819,
0.7090750337,
0.3476589918,
-0.3390147984,
-0.0377522595,
0.8371647,
-0.1498121619,
0.9700914621,
-0.071139507,
-0.1611753255,
0.1144762114,
-0.1747901887,
-0.4809587598,
0.6044193506,
0.5294573903,
-0.2654998004,
-0.3052744865,
0.6383592486,
0.2980649769,
0.327773422,
-0.8393984437,
0.536311388,
0.2923950553,
-0.1731698513,
0.0384316556,
-0.0838904828,
0.3652452826,
-0.1712940037,
0.5357762575,
0.1892259419,
0.162651971,
-0.3938015103,
-0.6745716929,
0.6395997405,
-0.4178373814,
-0.3036927879,
0.3592510223,
1.273291707,
-0.1316948831,
-0.2720182538,
0.5692073703,
0.1155041978,
0.0098698707,
-0.4044634402,
-0.4391298592,
0.6954600811,
-0.1314611435,
-0.7209692001,
0.4146048129,
0.2776125968,
-0.3706481159,
0.2846741378,
0.0888739675,
-0.1816994697,
0.5027613044,
-0.1361158937,
0.8642201424,
-0.5736659765,
-0.4659309089,
-0.8577015996,
0.2796972096,
-0.7241817117,
-0.3925958276,
0.9849045873,
0.4534386992,
0.63920331,
-0.0116745243,
0.4508908987,
-0.4317730069,
0.5441356301,
-0.311850816,
0.804893136,
-0.0987483412,
-0.3550952971,
-0.7087968588,
-0.8221575618,
0.1629056782,
0.408888191,
-0.4367716908,
0.0894061849,
0.5158350468,
0.5254637599,
0.217162028,
0.2233897895,
0.2333483994,
0.1304917634,
-0.2017557919,
0.1341513246,
0.63307482,
-0.2551295459,
0.5053468347,
-0.2350532413,
-0.5493798852,
-0.4670200348,
-0.8832918406,
-1.2072355747,
-0.6832271218,
-0.3679720759,
-0.472517252,
-0.3488067985,
0.7716875076,
0.7625429034,
-0.7917932868,
0.131887123,
0.4239853024,
0.2595314384,
-0.1190879121,
-0.4097571075,
0.5639777184,
0.0909270793,
-0.6582729816,
0.3708199263,
0.2305033356,
-0.2725403905,
-0.053648971,
0.3401376903,
-0.4968286157,
0.1704659909,
0.4733229578,
0.2148731053,
-0.5212193131,
-0.4143365026,
-0.2623848021,
-0.115987204,
-0.2299930304,
0.9074720144,
-0.6937503219,
0.0493645072,
0.3825054169,
0.6959108114,
0.5185137391,
0.4957824051,
0.4363166094,
-0.7700055838,
0.414267987,
-0.2683971822,
0.1944613308,
-0.0203294437,
-0.8176578283,
0.6472135782,
0.5628991723,
-0.6591544151,
-1.2067624331,
0.0837979838,
-1.0309134722,
-0.1824582964,
1.0439634323,
0.4093963206,
-0.2884765267,
-0.4765063524,
-0.3838575482,
0.2620962262,
-0.5624136925,
0.841670692,
0.7222971916,
0.2282007933,
-0.8711714149,
-0.907045126,
0.4338793755,
-0.2777708173,
-0.4074114561,
-0.505472064,
0.1738857925,
0.2835271657,
0.4342665374,
0.9303510189,
0.061673332,
0.4008921683,
0.1454597414,
-0.4209030867,
0.2072695047,
-0.1119497493,
-0.0519045368,
0.5437653661,
-0.7560583949,
-0.5197634101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11664v1 | IslamicPCQA: A Dataset for Persian Multi-hop Complex Question Answering in Islamic Text Resources | 2023-04-23T14:20:58 | 2023-04-23T14:20:58 | Arash Ghafouri, Hasan Naderi, Mohammad Aghajani asl, Mahdi Firouzmandi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, one of the main challenges for Question Answering Systems is to
answer complex questions using various sources of information. Multi-hop
questions are a type of complex questions that require multi-step reasoning to
answer. In this article, the IslamicPCQA dataset is introduced. This is the
first Persian dataset for answering complex questions based on non-structured
information sources and consists of 12,282 question-answer pairs extracted from
9 Islamic encyclopedias. This dataset has been created inspired by the HotpotQA
English dataset approach, which was customized to suit the complexities of the
Persian language. Answering questions in this dataset requires more than one
paragraph and reasoning. The questions are not limited to any prior knowledge
base or ontology, and to provide robust reasoning ability, the dataset also
includes supporting facts and key sentences. The prepared dataset covers a wide
range of Islamic topics and aims to facilitate answering complex Persian
questions within this subject matter | [
-0.5246683955,
-1.0684437752,
0.5414177179,
0.3752984107,
-0.1522932351,
0.3761499226,
0.1980558783,
-0.1188174114,
-0.1366873085,
0.5260882378,
-0.8431140184,
-0.2732532918,
-0.5444357991,
0.1678073406,
-0.2437968552,
0.8205394149,
-0.1958376169,
0.0777236372,
0.0664595738,
-0.0031302492,
-0.2809335887,
-0.4044730663,
-0.5594763756,
0.1855065972,
0.6336736083,
1.016112566,
1.089043498,
0.5059313178,
0.5713932514,
0.2143939286,
0.0746236891,
0.2940456271,
-0.2162322998,
0.1662934572,
-0.0598209463,
-0.4242190719,
-0.2545971572,
-0.1682516932,
0.6241966486,
0.8956795335,
-0.0523565821,
0.4994359612,
-0.132360816,
0.8044214249,
-0.6307993531,
-0.4426226914,
-0.2614836693,
0.0835144371,
-0.7226893902,
-0.4323238432,
-0.111989975,
-0.5860120654,
0.0594691262,
-0.5984202623,
-0.0437484905,
0.195545584,
0.4182237089,
0.1405561417,
-0.998629272,
-0.3282873333,
-0.8291702867,
0.7463445663,
-0.3694589436,
0.2223909646,
0.3601296842,
0.6196683645,
-0.5277312994,
-0.5201322436,
-0.7262256145,
0.1701114625,
0.0533910841,
0.1235118806,
0.0588619336,
-0.1417091936,
0.334643662,
0.4762888551,
-0.9179444909,
-0.6503244042,
-0.4306732118,
0.088122271,
0.5072080493,
0.2659500539,
0.470151782,
-0.1991951317,
-0.2632725239,
-0.2196869105,
-0.7064297795,
0.5489886999,
0.5112791657,
0.1375599504,
0.0457539707,
0.7951640487,
-0.4676326215,
0.913830936,
0.0613432564,
-0.216811955,
0.1646178067,
-0.4482878149,
-0.11878369,
0.1696626097,
0.5829764009,
-0.1342027038,
0.3155212402,
-0.046245221,
0.399715215,
-0.3873004615,
0.201394856,
-0.5843780637,
-0.2203647792,
0.7845349312,
-0.6197874546,
-0.0698371902,
0.2160598189,
-0.9685542583,
-0.2147828043,
-0.0540502369,
0.3362985551,
-0.4419098198,
-0.3284051716,
0.230207637,
-0.3575038612,
0.5018420815,
0.5620782971,
-0.1813510656,
0.4719238281,
0.3933897614,
0.729639411,
0.2378381044,
-0.1923709363,
-0.3999261856,
0.2944289148,
-0.3655351102,
0.9776136279,
-0.8057884574,
-0.0583237596,
-0.2588388324,
0.0088278484,
-0.002721329,
-0.1086948961,
0.9550568461,
-0.6260428429,
0.4668867886,
-0.4076328874,
-0.4966521263,
-0.4986602664,
0.3905082047,
-0.7221967578,
0.8101267219,
-0.2029059231,
-1.2435698509,
-0.2803547084,
-0.6383915544,
-0.3524106741,
0.1299684495,
-0.0197331663,
-0.2215844244,
-0.2856351435,
0.3313542604,
0.316182822,
-0.5902073383,
0.07816156,
-0.2518796027,
-0.3948179483,
0.3992718756,
-0.4048409164,
0.8854705095,
0.453425914,
-0.1388891488,
-0.2390083969,
-1.0094726086,
0.3990753293,
0.0933742374,
-0.4543686509,
-0.4074386954,
0.2319608629,
0.095706597,
0.4679640532,
0.1683295816,
-0.7552207112,
0.4627003372,
-0.1254735589,
-0.0507736802,
0.5035998821,
0.4237795472,
-0.0107849799,
-0.70383811,
0.762504518,
0.1310569346,
0.0550098866,
-0.1309606731,
-0.7144674659,
-0.38897717,
-0.1182635725,
0.0176013373,
0.8420777917,
-0.8097736835,
-0.004629307,
0.1170944422,
-0.9277045727,
-0.2538196445,
-0.1219640523,
0.2968920171,
0.3929052353,
0.5284792781,
0.1151070967,
-0.4151148498,
-0.8525403142,
-0.5604874492,
0.0712988675,
0.0135596683,
0.2848565876,
0.4099769294,
0.3505143225,
0.4529664516,
-0.5335557461,
0.0591739379,
-0.3259738684,
0.1763404161,
0.6689961553,
0.494019717,
0.3621411324,
-1.0775206089,
-0.4631224871,
-0.2494884729,
-0.3587325215,
0.099621281,
-0.5363970995,
-0.5483734012,
-0.6331568956,
0.263458401,
-0.3419587612,
0.3566051424,
0.6206496358,
-0.6219351888,
0.6260721684,
0.2809618413,
0.6415445805,
-1.3806399107,
0.3576197922,
-0.2639964819,
-0.1266435385,
-0.8411671519,
0.0461766385,
-0.0716152862,
0.1576024443,
-0.5646294951,
0.2908375263,
-0.2501434088,
0.1493277848,
-0.1054883599,
-0.3317935169,
0.1012664363,
0.7517371774,
0.1109608784,
0.9449898601,
0.5516537428,
-0.6494585276,
0.6433063149,
0.7848339081,
-0.3566591442,
0.3875798285,
-0.8029814363,
0.2396507561,
-0.2057605535,
0.3502689302,
-1.146469593,
-0.3357107937,
0.4264987707,
-0.451133877,
-0.2449219823,
-0.1961734593,
-0.3113460243,
-0.1675650775,
-0.3638601899,
0.7901847959,
-0.0949985608,
-0.2339610457,
0.4208462238,
0.1572391391,
-0.5316277146,
-0.9526246786,
-0.2939715683,
0.0763940364,
-0.0897599086,
-0.4478873014,
0.0547870919,
-0.1994376779,
-0.1531242728,
0.0077858097,
-0.1131335944,
-0.5254850984,
0.0640759617,
0.3660510182,
0.0671445727,
-0.1637059599,
0.1551451534,
0.3391161859,
0.092731379,
-0.0451341011,
-0.022147404,
0.5990154743,
-0.022463873,
-0.3576673865,
-0.4367705882,
1.0069651604,
0.5271196365,
-0.222868681,
0.8429338932,
0.238473326,
-0.4384687841,
0.2504194677,
-0.1869794726,
0.3669959009,
-0.4115181267,
0.2300538719,
-0.8371734619,
-0.6729790568,
0.2979362309,
-0.2602837384,
0.2092093527,
0.5394419432,
0.7004740834,
-0.3404010236,
0.9843580127,
0.2925040722,
0.2188334465,
-0.1287230104,
0.2518379092,
0.1236545369,
-0.6029974818,
-0.6172562242,
-1.0084648132,
-0.2932647467,
-0.715010643,
-0.3379107118,
0.5207432508,
0.2221791446,
-0.8348653316,
0.0478046536,
-0.1811856627,
0.3561441302,
0.7466671467,
0.2484036088,
0.4641536474,
-0.1361493021,
-0.0002413051,
0.3260434866,
-0.7117341757,
-0.557908833,
1.1286108494,
0.0797362998,
0.9258314371,
0.6876443028,
0.058423575,
0.3816771805,
-0.5421780944,
-0.5656685829,
0.1838542819,
0.140832141,
-0.7848577499,
-0.3703969419,
-0.4759193063,
-0.8488771915,
-0.0590723902,
-0.4133642912,
-0.2079189122,
0.3209553361,
0.0158223771,
-0.5776917338,
0.328684479,
-0.0181819163,
0.6687097549,
-0.2558132708,
-0.1090665385,
-0.0569280535,
-0.959776938,
0.5119845271,
-0.0759218931,
0.181207642,
-0.0348223411,
0.1981711686,
1.0274721384,
-0.4783002436,
0.2231304348,
0.0559943691,
0.1926514208,
0.36029917,
0.349689424,
0.1989287734,
0.0501553714,
0.018157443,
0.0142219979,
0.7239102125,
-1.0120378733,
-0.315918237,
0.3565833569,
-1.0805549622,
-0.4457713962,
-0.8963396549,
-0.4288705289,
-0.6545714736,
0.2311715931,
0.1160634384,
0.4940603077,
-0.099859938,
0.3482393622,
0.7238494158,
-0.5047408938,
0.1151091903,
0.1122735888,
-0.0266211629,
-0.3584474921,
0.3195567131,
-0.1436730474,
0.1371991485,
0.564150393,
-0.0169545244,
-0.2444559187,
-0.3267472684,
-0.7668532729,
0.073250331,
-0.4793352783,
-0.2790127099,
-0.7784245014,
-0.3610839248,
-0.2217808813,
0.1166125163,
-0.3498693109,
-0.7802693248,
0.2901028097,
0.1745451838,
0.4998359382,
0.7433572412,
0.0808784589,
0.2626342773,
-1.2409356833,
0.7583830357,
0.4984785914,
0.2590143383,
-0.1645276248,
-0.4056030512,
-0.1032323912,
0.1823588759,
-0.231809929,
-1.3926699162,
0.0050841989,
0.4760007262,
0.3549855649,
0.4088915288,
0.2523451447,
0.888651073,
-0.585968256,
0.6359550357,
-0.1613960266,
-0.8804148436,
0.7227093577,
-0.4665023386,
0.4555916488,
0.51579386,
0.9818472862,
-0.9850944877,
-0.2075429261,
-0.3707770705,
-0.5537355542,
0.6793747544,
0.3577008247,
-0.1771993488,
0.4155058861,
0.7042744756,
0.2945043743,
0.3046338856,
-0.2966497242,
-0.5556941628,
-0.4689614773,
-0.2527050972,
0.1653872132,
-0.2229324281,
-0.0827974603,
-0.0618841909,
0.7125151157,
0.0053867716,
0.261487484,
0.2722287178,
0.0743914098,
-0.3470639288,
0.5701791048,
0.2890082002,
0.7586781383,
-0.3441421092,
0.0992468968,
-0.1732773781,
-0.6960020661,
0.350823611,
-0.2362238914,
0.0791632235,
-0.2707103789,
0.3534317315,
0.1969695538,
-0.5980036855,
-0.8400546908,
0.5922589898,
-0.4053631723,
-0.196271345,
-0.5356158018,
0.0969342068,
-0.0011639198,
0.1695669144,
0.6323434711,
0.2321753353,
0.4854042828,
-0.5627496839,
0.3415198624,
0.2174559087,
-0.0274314061,
-0.0574318618,
0.3518390954,
-0.0520414859,
0.1564930826,
0.7638207674,
0.2512366474,
-0.6227453351,
0.5757703781,
0.4127064645,
0.1205916479,
-0.4008195698,
0.453509748,
0.6722761393,
0.20954822,
0.1461390406,
0.9368376732,
-0.1543175429,
-0.6614664197,
-0.5847628117,
-0.6082231998,
-0.9730618,
0.0533937551,
-0.7695837021,
0.1393504143,
-0.6507100463,
0.4297643006,
-0.1085292548,
0.3145685196,
-0.6363193393,
0.5476168394,
0.154241547,
1.1491070986,
-0.9388215542,
0.7780744433,
0.8836723566,
-0.2427037805,
-0.9659783244,
0.0621798635,
0.0513874516,
-0.5931814909,
0.2118037492,
-0.1703866571,
-0.3639759123,
-0.0668695346,
-0.8390526175,
-1.0462733507,
0.7444319129,
-0.1165011302,
-0.4518285096,
0.1679780632,
0.4383475184,
0.1478552371,
0.0004720234,
0.4082413316,
0.3633435071,
0.6038997173,
0.4660393894,
-0.6669777036,
0.0860247836,
-0.6472509503,
-0.404953599,
0.1256737411,
-0.6170418859,
1.1276482344,
0.0178955719,
-0.1008184999,
0.3124429882,
0.3415264189,
0.3074518442,
0.1250331998,
0.4096638858,
0.3938761353,
0.6430181861,
-0.0673562288,
0.7057482004,
-0.1947613657,
0.0591522567,
1.2432538271,
0.0974769667,
0.9151348472,
0.4378887415,
-0.317787677,
0.7705672383,
1.0574833155,
0.3753755987,
0.534324348,
0.0429416373,
-0.1971208304,
-0.7182416916,
-0.1202307567,
-0.5776588321,
0.7837976217,
0.4452735484,
0.2639107108,
-0.2890062332,
-0.1787344664,
0.1358320415,
-0.0862510875,
-0.3909507394,
0.7024917006,
-0.2836033404,
-0.4585989714,
0.2003694773,
0.2131999433,
-0.0698231682,
-0.6005392075,
-0.3455118537,
-0.1075979397,
-0.1508840919,
-0.3304563165,
-1.111140728,
0.4374260008,
0.1474495083,
-0.1895716488,
0.1308369339,
0.483589977,
-0.2985368669,
-0.7001345754,
-0.3774696589,
1.0609235764,
0.3567997813,
-0.3341381252,
-0.8383614421,
-0.3933136761,
-0.0456958711,
-0.3308750093,
-0.0809606314,
0.7283414006,
-0.0618598275,
0.6551012397,
0.8611971736,
0.0164866112,
0.1373878717,
-0.4345029593,
0.923207581,
-1.1066638231,
-0.4113562703,
-0.5845646262,
0.3214409947,
0.0930508599,
-0.3238820434,
0.8074686527,
0.5483849049,
0.5544952154,
0.2325552404,
1.0543705225,
-0.3533464074,
1.0456848145,
-0.3564729095,
0.3903275132,
-0.6103087664,
-0.1239926293,
-0.298455894,
-0.8887212873,
-0.3656832874,
0.5567480326,
0.0331599042,
-0.1411375552,
0.6541974545,
0.4831441343,
-0.0927508697,
0.2880723476,
0.0837852731,
0.3522503674,
0.1434795409,
0.9652611613,
1.121669054,
-0.6869795918,
0.5807112455,
-0.243812114,
-0.346170485,
0.0794976354,
-0.6376416683,
-0.7123984098,
-0.576834023,
-0.0777421668,
-0.3225359321,
0.0354457349,
1.1920641661,
0.2872697115,
-1.1394337416,
-0.1722067893,
0.0914724767,
0.1773734987,
-0.3555841446,
-0.1671375781,
0.6143573523,
-0.01940942,
-0.5699920654,
0.2471880913,
0.2301689535,
-0.2139989883,
0.0355437547,
0.1498706043,
-0.6931632757,
0.3279990554,
0.1817274243,
0.4276254475,
-0.0825412571,
-0.2071519196,
0.1608821303,
0.0049577313,
0.2871996164,
0.8395646811,
-0.6540899873,
0.2511734962,
0.4924425483,
0.705458045,
0.1461033225,
0.2014001012,
0.3827435374,
-0.3823563457,
0.0756579116,
0.2649464607,
0.178997919,
-0.0229571257,
-0.4214132726,
0.1356473267,
-0.0813759267,
-0.6372200847,
-0.1811908334,
0.4184496105,
-1.2989323139,
-0.4811054766,
0.8463177681,
-0.2562408447,
-0.149815008,
-0.8674862981,
-0.5306993723,
0.1537546962,
-0.190807566,
0.629031539,
0.8218351603,
-0.4716109633,
-0.3081448376,
-0.3676305115,
0.5760321617,
0.3067982197,
-0.984390974,
-0.2710054219,
0.4602695405,
0.2451149672,
-0.1139508113,
0.5387399793,
-0.016887404,
0.6471041441,
-0.0917888731,
-0.1451499015,
0.1480982453,
-0.5255632997,
0.1121385321,
0.6305955648,
0.0492985137,
-0.3317994475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11657v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11657v3 | Enhancing Chain-of-Thoughts Prompting with Iterative Bootstrapping in Large Language Models | 2023-04-23T13:54:39 | 2024-03-15T10:28:13 | Jiashuo Sun, Yi Luo, Yeyun Gong, Chen Lin, Yelong Shen, Jian Guo, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) can achieve highly effective performance on
various reasoning tasks by incorporating step-by-step chain-of-thought (CoT)
prompting as demonstrations. However, the reasoning chains of demonstrations
generated by LLMs are prone to errors, which can subsequently lead to incorrect
reasoning during inference. Furthermore, inappropriate exemplars (overly
simplistic or complex), can affect overall performance among varying levels of
difficulty. We introduce Iter-CoT (Iterative bootstrapping in Chain-of-Thoughts
Prompting), an iterative bootstrapping approach for selecting exemplars and
generating reasoning chains. By utilizing iterative bootstrapping, our approach
enables LLMs to autonomously rectify errors, resulting in more precise and
comprehensive reasoning chains. Simultaneously, our approach selects
challenging yet answerable questions accompanied by reasoning chains as
exemplars with a moderate level of difficulty, which enhances the LLMs'
generalizability across varying levels of difficulty. Experimental results
indicate that Iter-CoT exhibits superiority, achieving competitive performance
across three distinct reasoning tasks on ten datasets. | [
-0.2771211863,
-0.8042558432,
0.8032342792,
0.373912245,
-0.395285219,
0.4911233783,
-0.5024696589,
-0.2365644127,
0.1954954118,
0.2299744189,
-0.5469276905,
-0.3773609102,
-0.488362968,
0.1648309231,
-0.6010963917,
0.8868072629,
-0.3586068153,
-0.1067972332,
-0.09812361,
0.2010336071,
-0.4704985619,
-0.3498475254,
-0.7640711069,
-0.3022899032,
0.4942551553,
0.4958445728,
0.4235244393,
0.3683644235,
0.1644677669,
0.3510132134,
-0.0373444818,
0.175289318,
-0.3714214265,
0.4523412585,
-0.5024428964,
-0.3446859419,
-0.2066732943,
-0.3454190791,
0.6632255912,
0.674435854,
-0.320351094,
0.1663377881,
0.0319382399,
0.9282250404,
-0.8959121108,
0.0529516786,
-0.8306198716,
-0.258810401,
0.1044662222,
-0.4832829833,
-0.5520747304,
-0.4269143045,
0.0516868159,
-0.6101726294,
0.1834597588,
0.4704099298,
0.4816602767,
0.1716943234,
0.0070903241,
-0.437502116,
-0.7618417144,
0.6560000181,
-0.5962934494,
0.1999394149,
0.2395115346,
0.1919476986,
-0.2837007344,
-0.610072732,
-0.5622760653,
-0.2701591849,
0.1260118634,
-0.066741541,
-0.2997923791,
0.0053205723,
0.4275061488,
0.3640785813,
-0.2731076181,
0.0415153094,
-0.4746210277,
-0.0658438504,
0.4410085082,
0.2597379684,
-0.0663991719,
0.1611776799,
-0.2932332456,
-0.3575793207,
-0.7079688907,
0.2119683474,
0.174735114,
0.3778370619,
0.2310615927,
0.4658203721,
-0.3670987785,
0.862373054,
0.3035307527,
0.0830477253,
0.0640826449,
-0.1543453485,
-0.2394066155,
0.0562675931,
0.8314113021,
0.2269999385,
0.3487403393,
-0.0486369245,
-0.294164598,
0.0853503421,
0.2888818085,
-0.5163113475,
-0.4839329422,
0.5753631592,
0.0218916237,
-0.3079923391,
-0.1312530339,
-0.8377141953,
-0.4813467562,
-0.141110599,
0.565630734,
-0.3427824676,
-0.2782301605,
0.2367241532,
-0.2982390225,
-0.0500952266,
0.3455868661,
-0.7020945549,
0.5614345074,
0.3817025125,
0.6321680546,
-0.2232611775,
-0.3392891288,
-0.8354451656,
0.2243234962,
-0.680984199,
0.9022400379,
-0.7633985877,
-0.059106607,
-0.1551579833,
-0.1675084233,
-0.1037876755,
-0.5708407164,
0.2110015899,
-0.5026148558,
0.0416570343,
-0.6688013077,
-0.5893523693,
0.0897499621,
0.5384742618,
-0.6666600108,
1.0776486397,
-0.0645310655,
-0.6313663721,
0.3416104317,
-0.4335753322,
-0.4679573774,
-0.0557951033,
-0.4622753561,
-0.1138587147,
0.1532040238,
0.5587276816,
0.519100666,
-0.7609128356,
0.3548120558,
0.0533863232,
-0.2654613853,
0.2145249695,
-0.1805967242,
0.566087842,
0.029261874,
-0.6092110872,
0.3812164366,
-0.8164010644,
0.3786357343,
0.2775192559,
-0.0879779086,
-0.1978559047,
-0.0770529136,
-0.3136944771,
0.364392668,
-0.2514509857,
-0.3241559863,
0.3481253684,
-0.208655268,
0.3953545988,
1.0241634846,
0.2099781334,
0.4181583822,
-0.3231025934,
0.6278812885,
0.0838794932,
-0.0377201401,
-0.2811139822,
-0.4631605148,
-0.9514276981,
-0.2626998723,
0.3197262287,
0.29945153,
-1.0731594563,
0.3605129421,
0.0041369856,
-0.4069401622,
-0.6243942976,
0.2637533545,
0.3440778255,
0.4544156194,
0.4779031873,
-0.1437055171,
-0.4227906764,
-0.5145718455,
-0.2874194086,
-0.3536719978,
0.0020216892,
-0.2008101344,
0.6671741009,
0.2454684377,
0.5687649846,
-0.3238391578,
-0.0384855084,
-0.3748168051,
0.1565668732,
0.051661469,
0.5298537612,
-0.0603533983,
-0.3824058771,
-0.2233454436,
-0.1255722493,
-0.4148700833,
0.0069740154,
-0.4299313426,
-0.2039593309,
0.0228495859,
0.4610469937,
-0.4103329182,
0.2459823042,
0.289788425,
-0.2124308497,
0.7698105574,
-0.2970166206,
0.2273646146,
-0.9316671491,
0.0821250603,
-0.1722492874,
-0.2643264532,
-0.4092445672,
0.192943275,
0.1461102515,
0.4010930359,
-0.0629388392,
0.3306754231,
-0.6210379004,
-0.0413115472,
-0.2188642621,
0.3843451738,
0.1532823294,
0.3788640797,
0.1325476766,
0.8443220258,
0.7881270647,
-0.9261266589,
0.3395229876,
0.1277929395,
-0.5951415896,
0.4097107649,
-0.5494977832,
0.2581230104,
-0.1212215573,
0.4405618012,
-1.0581427813,
-0.238057375,
0.1505106837,
-0.0703702644,
0.1897456497,
0.2946419716,
-0.6677200794,
-0.6567664742,
-0.5851204991,
0.3850753307,
0.3599593937,
-0.8521804214,
0.5549585819,
-0.1077092886,
-0.0962926,
-0.7078424096,
-0.418220669,
0.1692286134,
-0.0017437802,
-0.189884603,
0.1917599142,
-0.1907864064,
-0.4244026542,
-0.24154073,
-0.2754911184,
0.1245678142,
-0.1443461329,
-0.0520152897,
0.3298471272,
0.1130929142,
0.3889625371,
0.1371644735,
-0.1476918161,
0.1115685254,
-0.5074079037,
0.7012760639,
-0.2379526496,
-0.3738533258,
-0.3095018864,
0.3425179422,
0.4088579416,
-0.1513223052,
0.5161046386,
0.1291977018,
-0.1844719946,
-0.406204164,
-0.931814909,
-0.2716648579,
-0.4926015735,
0.0141950641,
-0.5323435664,
-0.809215188,
0.371694684,
-0.3763436079,
0.0369820222,
0.1583425403,
0.6221728325,
-0.1257046163,
1.039881587,
0.5113626122,
-0.2268314958,
0.1928430647,
-0.284520179,
0.3445591629,
-0.8677555323,
-0.3225544095,
-0.4615810812,
-0.225004375,
-0.3767652512,
-0.6592854857,
0.2548692226,
0.029817909,
-0.3918651342,
0.1974807978,
-0.5571667552,
0.7870087624,
0.3762328029,
0.1287114173,
0.5712022781,
0.1191308796,
-0.4266985953,
0.2563913167,
-0.9353724122,
-0.4308638871,
0.649841547,
0.0788672641,
1.021187067,
-0.1208685637,
0.5345460773,
-0.0253500659,
0.0723672807,
-0.7239820957,
0.5343783498,
0.3361860216,
-0.5538848639,
-0.0580424778,
-0.4018152654,
-0.6144214869,
0.0072608315,
-0.1381039172,
-1.3349288702,
0.2268302888,
0.5144530535,
-0.5241926908,
0.5284852982,
-0.3540263772,
0.3578488827,
-0.1128678173,
-0.5332990289,
-0.2698125839,
-0.6513972878,
0.2809368074,
0.0408693664,
0.2076979727,
0.2046570778,
-0.1198781356,
0.707162261,
-0.3814799488,
0.6990360022,
0.0376919359,
-0.3601985276,
0.4950300455,
0.3365044296,
0.9777829051,
-0.3212305903,
-0.2019533217,
-0.3025372624,
-0.1103801727,
-0.4407831728,
-0.710285902,
0.6604765654,
-0.3108851612,
-0.8161482215,
-0.2001108527,
-0.7205920219,
-0.6060008407,
-0.074410066,
0.5662222505,
0.4187089801,
0.1817246377,
-0.0383539833,
0.5551080704,
-0.0477015264,
0.4266088903,
0.146741122,
-0.363283664,
-0.488233,
0.8864532709,
-0.0496478043,
0.7568283677,
0.2555026412,
0.3278987706,
-0.2776904404,
-0.4013810456,
-0.5591184497,
0.106206879,
-1.0098766088,
-0.2307125479,
-0.7049796581,
0.0275761075,
0.0449657328,
-0.3208007812,
-0.4815304279,
-0.5937094688,
0.2531765997,
-0.3184043765,
0.4770586491,
0.8923833966,
0.056756895,
0.1486399919,
-0.3795876801,
0.2697512507,
0.3471909761,
0.406981796,
0.3888344169,
-0.3432922363,
0.051451385,
-0.2649614513,
-0.1162472144,
-0.7726415992,
0.1023201123,
-0.1173424572,
0.2672628164,
0.3017414808,
0.2060365528,
1.0908794403,
-0.4375834763,
0.8155122995,
0.4749765694,
-1.0957593918,
0.6240552664,
-0.2480063885,
0.403788358,
0.6784240603,
0.3957784176,
-0.1879350692,
-0.7370595932,
-0.5700562596,
-1.0759161711,
0.4341419339,
0.3474355936,
-0.1362217665,
-0.2434829623,
0.1675959826,
0.3003683984,
0.4674536288,
-0.5652084947,
-0.2069632113,
0.1538535953,
-0.0665395409,
0.1798576266,
-0.1252870411,
-0.1504068673,
-0.6135561466,
0.9413071275,
-0.3798772097,
0.29200688,
0.2538347244,
-0.103677325,
-0.4860721827,
0.5066387057,
0.3959994316,
0.8660025001,
0.0479026251,
0.4023798704,
0.461866498,
-0.0664808005,
0.4247496426,
-0.252374202,
0.0121794185,
-0.1827030182,
0.2388233542,
0.7822579741,
0.0748311579,
-0.7876579762,
0.3386777341,
-0.0112894224,
-0.1360220015,
-0.1109739542,
0.1952467412,
0.1256946921,
0.4196814895,
0.4914596379,
0.045938693,
0.0605813898,
-0.6116092205,
-0.121394299,
0.3350223601,
-0.1523556411,
-0.0536725223,
0.4189703166,
-0.0109924767,
-0.2119206041,
0.4366514385,
-0.2257131785,
-0.6743503809,
0.5152110457,
0.9042030573,
0.8208559155,
-0.1178462654,
0.2547135353,
0.6275832653,
0.3984133601,
-0.5579496026,
0.4442314506,
-0.4922406077,
-0.5937165022,
-0.6574465036,
-0.1367695779,
-0.5700570345,
0.25281775,
-0.8220338225,
0.1259660423,
-0.729167223,
0.0535660945,
-0.2276992798,
-0.3374130428,
-0.6012149453,
0.3355516791,
-0.0160980467,
1.1044406891,
-0.5895007253,
0.5932641625,
0.5751844645,
-0.268340528,
-0.9981927872,
0.2905920446,
-0.107000351,
-0.6323571205,
0.3224537671,
0.2814313471,
-0.5391854644,
0.2057702541,
-0.8019765615,
-0.6801362038,
1.0838284492,
0.333727181,
-1.0739536285,
-0.0740225539,
-0.0771235451,
0.3327559829,
-0.5335075855,
0.2439654768,
0.7694894075,
0.2888471186,
0.3612338603,
-0.8388137221,
0.4639846087,
-0.2868227363,
0.0045895749,
0.2437101305,
-0.4792627692,
0.6908037066,
-0.6487686634,
-0.0625179783,
0.2105960995,
0.4034370482,
0.5891235471,
0.1018025875,
0.7396574616,
0.2261971682,
1.324811697,
0.1120074689,
1.0385155678,
-0.2728335261,
0.0709147155,
1.4383080006,
-0.3352452517,
1.08915627,
0.7205235362,
-0.0170622654,
0.9130660892,
0.4108718038,
0.2451277822,
0.3816275895,
0.4650946558,
-0.3543398976,
-0.5493955016,
0.0569202863,
-0.2203570157,
0.1291513741,
0.4135764539,
-0.36860919,
-0.1344421059,
0.0948339924,
-0.0149908522,
0.0862415731,
-0.3391941488,
0.7986565232,
-0.0158688892,
-0.9439702034,
0.7519200444,
-0.3897257447,
0.3737461269,
-0.51666677,
-0.1049183756,
0.1958515346,
0.1283571571,
-0.0019150873,
-0.7905597687,
-0.1052867323,
0.3664026856,
-0.0636982173,
-0.1792474836,
0.7714831233,
-0.3461207151,
-0.5180293322,
0.3757033944,
0.6768120527,
0.0590934455,
-0.2528076768,
-0.5229168534,
0.2575022876,
-0.1066315547,
-0.3751597106,
0.0791335627,
0.3417508602,
-0.2081610411,
0.9664116502,
0.4246137738,
0.0505545065,
-0.1792112887,
0.3229312599,
1.3661191463,
-0.894885242,
-0.4551462829,
-1.0866333246,
0.6738058329,
-0.4045261443,
-0.0731287524,
0.5204436183,
0.2596273124,
0.7152370214,
0.0042606965,
0.827699244,
-0.1244578883,
0.1920072287,
-0.5747594833,
0.2362104654,
-0.3634326458,
0.5712665319,
-0.5643519759,
-0.8912136555,
-0.0127460072,
0.7678256631,
-0.3534844816,
0.0259855762,
1.1687198877,
0.6891329885,
0.2859996557,
0.342112571,
0.2493135482,
0.3444224596,
0.2556306422,
0.6780416965,
1.1184228659,
-0.315120399,
0.362870276,
-0.3586097658,
-0.2437860817,
0.2104554325,
-1.0304505825,
-1.1235249043,
-0.684574604,
-0.4167640507,
-0.5375981331,
0.1499384642,
1.5222038031,
0.3884967566,
-0.9666927457,
-0.2902698219,
-0.560342133,
0.0516663417,
-0.4871324599,
-0.1865719259,
0.1420885473,
-0.6223436594,
-0.4146451652,
0.5062127709,
0.2475673556,
-0.2492352426,
-0.2909110188,
0.1579188257,
-0.3178628981,
0.1759440899,
0.5935334563,
0.0623238012,
-0.7198417187,
-0.163987726,
-0.0172088053,
0.2704933882,
0.1091783568,
1.0323395729,
-1.1337844133,
0.7035145164,
0.3387194574,
0.512776792,
0.5440349579,
0.0141416322,
0.8220566511,
-0.8698883057,
-0.0749795139,
0.2256182134,
0.290779233,
0.4901133776,
-0.3923211098,
0.4796918631,
-0.0806559473,
-0.3392325044,
-0.8278877735,
0.2417984158,
-0.7337195277,
-0.3411259055,
1.2875783443,
-0.0101982476,
-0.3319697082,
-0.0803035051,
-0.3829245567,
0.0440143086,
-0.465407759,
0.9766187072,
0.7631117702,
-0.0855112597,
-0.250731498,
-0.4039890468,
0.4786610305,
0.5511544943,
-0.892413795,
0.4538000822,
0.2478375137,
0.236818105,
0.232178092,
0.7976663709,
0.0900901332,
0.4075686634,
0.0194773637,
-0.2015044838,
0.1127805635,
-0.5676407218,
-0.1860103756,
0.1836597472,
0.322583288,
0.0478604287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.11633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.11633v1 | Evaluating ChatGPT's Information Extraction Capabilities: An Assessment of Performance, Explainability, Calibration, and Faithfulness | 2023-04-23T12:33:18 | 2023-04-23T12:33:18 | Bo Li, Gexiang Fang, Yang Yang, Quansen Wang, Wei Ye, Wen Zhao, Shikun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT to comprehend
user intent and provide reasonable responses has made them extremely popular
lately. In this paper, we focus on assessing the overall ability of ChatGPT
using 7 fine-grained information extraction (IE) tasks. Specially, we present
the systematically analysis by measuring ChatGPT's performance, explainability,
calibration, and faithfulness, and resulting in 15 keys from either the ChatGPT
or domain experts. Our findings reveal that ChatGPT's performance in
Standard-IE setting is poor, but it surprisingly exhibits excellent performance
in the OpenIE setting, as evidenced by human evaluation. In addition, our
research indicates that ChatGPT provides high-quality and trustworthy
explanations for its decisions. However, there is an issue of ChatGPT being
overconfident in its predictions, which resulting in low calibration.
Furthermore, ChatGPT demonstrates a high level of faithfulness to the original
text in the majority of cases. We manually annotate and release the test sets
of 7 fine-grained IE tasks contains 14 datasets to further promote the
research. The datasets and code are available at
https://github.com/pkuserc/ChatGPT_for_IE. | [
-0.5017649531,
-0.9590095878,
0.3804699183,
0.1815707237,
-0.1024881676,
-0.0003749132,
-0.6128973365,
-0.5639690757,
-0.4739839137,
0.2539991438,
-0.2437212467,
-0.3634586632,
-0.922023952,
0.0366150402,
-0.5310041904,
1.1242746115,
-0.1192647144,
-0.1461916715,
0.1773376018,
0.20120956,
-0.6003473997,
-0.1618131548,
-0.6794416308,
-0.2950922549,
0.2327367812,
0.6445324421,
0.7135535479,
0.5009699464,
0.7955312729,
0.1989346594,
0.075225383,
0.2099877596,
-0.8939270973,
-0.0429425761,
-0.3509100974,
-0.4305278063,
-0.3535875976,
0.2060388625,
0.5519269705,
0.2293250114,
-0.213159129,
0.403298378,
0.527285099,
0.5245449543,
-0.5748368502,
0.636864543,
-0.9614834785,
-0.1401832402,
-0.3132462204,
-0.242424354,
-0.4589762986,
-0.2847613394,
0.4606699944,
-0.5530322194,
0.1090002134,
0.2492162138,
1.1709896326,
-0.0178827159,
-0.0263296328,
-0.4997740686,
-0.766941309,
0.8132220507,
-0.5662884116,
0.4196367562,
0.4024532139,
0.5884364247,
-0.2234896868,
-0.947104454,
-0.5072706938,
-0.255435288,
0.1311984807,
0.4313527346,
-0.3157812953,
-0.102926448,
0.2688026428,
0.6622611284,
-0.5663571954,
0.0845555291,
-0.4326785803,
-0.2279403955,
0.3912437558,
-0.0628803223,
0.369566977,
-0.0850478485,
-0.4714923799,
-0.0489847809,
-0.5416183472,
0.2120350003,
0.201393798,
0.2977502644,
0.1569803506,
0.823445797,
-0.2618997991,
0.2470894307,
-0.0313816182,
-0.0831032693,
-0.0108076874,
-0.2999753952,
-0.3749479651,
-0.0061085215,
0.8646858931,
0.3648158312,
0.6443440318,
-0.4977864027,
-0.2075514644,
-0.1697069705,
0.2171784937,
-1.0202510357,
-0.221647203,
0.187842682,
-0.539309144,
-0.1085872203,
0.1198944226,
-0.8766932487,
-0.3118210137,
-0.2468480021,
0.5242316723,
-0.8883091807,
-0.0694521368,
0.2727558613,
-0.2080683857,
0.4407692552,
0.5969882011,
-0.7723991871,
0.3012693822,
0.9029645324,
0.7781788707,
-0.4977190495,
-0.2400386781,
-0.4270505905,
-0.1592251062,
0.1222439781,
0.9170868397,
-0.6496626735,
-0.037782494,
-0.2993276119,
-0.0144457929,
-0.4230834246,
-0.481992811,
0.8116009235,
-0.5531557202,
0.2471109629,
-0.1534638256,
-0.6023156643,
-0.2930550575,
0.4726366401,
-0.4902934432,
1.0328600407,
0.0388798676,
-0.7977126241,
0.2333092093,
-0.701038003,
0.0361048952,
0.2291995734,
-0.0362051614,
0.0390595794,
-0.0046050274,
0.3334895372,
0.5162127614,
-0.4517892003,
-0.0298297685,
-0.296195507,
-0.4416169822,
0.2386581749,
-0.9970614314,
0.4314780831,
0.3962860703,
-0.3156097531,
-0.4425189495,
-0.739522934,
0.2369437069,
0.1176663637,
-0.4411751032,
-0.0314069837,
0.1601362079,
0.0542813689,
0.0501238815,
0.3732875884,
-0.6246049404,
0.2202241272,
-0.4499857128,
0.4673115909,
0.6534850001,
-0.0292714816,
0.198619172,
-0.1474595666,
0.3523929417,
-0.2816057503,
0.0883417949,
-0.1190104336,
-0.492282778,
-0.4960893989,
-0.3193579912,
0.5757815242,
0.8342344761,
-0.5147386193,
0.1208236814,
-0.5931303501,
-0.6276674867,
-0.3907640576,
0.1021525562,
0.3787929714,
0.4039618671,
0.1235524043,
-0.5837885141,
-0.0686143413,
-0.8378841877,
-0.4498291016,
-0.2396343648,
-0.2674120963,
0.3388845026,
0.4232288301,
-0.0736156479,
1.0236365795,
-0.2639518678,
-0.1222167462,
-0.1714982837,
0.3559013903,
0.2265866101,
0.1617833078,
0.128021881,
-0.6313897371,
-0.4872238338,
0.4112634063,
-0.6181622744,
-0.119910188,
0.0731094331,
-0.1077456772,
-0.2364804745,
0.0667225569,
-0.6836202145,
0.5167176127,
0.4025961757,
-0.0391990952,
0.6270765066,
0.0594450496,
0.2631721497,
-0.8712445498,
0.260989368,
0.0486151911,
-0.4299509227,
-0.3828618228,
0.0861638263,
0.0079933507,
-0.1090587005,
-0.3364106417,
0.5264032483,
-0.3611958027,
-0.0872530863,
-0.0977261662,
0.7037766576,
0.0781015307,
0.3008220792,
-0.3278592229,
1.0090895891,
0.1948081851,
-0.3664301336,
0.2851157486,
0.2837061584,
-0.4452961683,
0.4036593139,
-0.6083964109,
0.1455418468,
-0.0612608232,
-0.0975571722,
-1.1797860861,
-0.3129831851,
0.0887995288,
-0.5996485949,
0.2912142575,
-0.2724922895,
-0.5722625256,
-0.0195964389,
-0.2075332701,
-0.1544072777,
0.5382797718,
-0.3136638105,
0.4934622645,
0.2782132626,
-0.3406618237,
-0.4361643791,
-0.3179984391,
0.0933450311,
-0.3289878666,
-0.7164062262,
0.1242069602,
0.0683562309,
-0.3371081948,
-0.2500876188,
-0.2472102344,
-0.1897723973,
0.1259343773,
0.2339628786,
-0.0020516508,
-0.3873485923,
0.1324489117,
-0.4836126864,
-0.0923995227,
-0.0794426352,
0.0564181134,
0.706592083,
-0.527720809,
-0.3988342881,
-0.343693763,
-0.0267880168,
0.3972393572,
-0.334723711,
0.3701171577,
0.9742969871,
-0.1396366507,
0.0183575097,
-0.679464817,
0.0370704345,
-0.4142943323,
0.4955356419,
-0.3917308748,
-0.7169825435,
0.6186996102,
-0.2530069649,
0.3212690055,
0.5992279649,
0.3930099607,
0.0296700429,
0.8913971186,
0.2907254994,
-0.123382695,
0.4913552403,
0.003915342,
0.22476466,
-0.7726880312,
-0.101768747,
-0.6985381842,
-0.053082142,
-0.7225943804,
-0.1061695069,
0.1227124333,
0.4347627163,
-0.0538135692,
0.2917223275,
-0.2954462469,
0.4942033291,
0.5241314173,
0.1748992056,
0.3495587409,
0.161557287,
0.2648021877,
0.0780022666,
-0.3431406915,
-1.0767066479,
0.978051424,
0.7072544098,
0.9366179109,
0.065303877,
0.4036056101,
0.2361525148,
0.184207961,
-0.9892122746,
0.3664648235,
-0.2583003044,
-0.3847322762,
-0.3279856145,
-0.3549377322,
-0.9751934409,
0.1651154906,
0.0441828184,
-1.4767431021,
-0.1559956074,
0.0022675907,
-0.2519354224,
-0.0760517195,
-1.1828469038,
0.8072572947,
-0.0305021442,
-0.3847260177,
-0.0132189672,
-0.4310436845,
0.2584324777,
-0.1715050638,
0.051246617,
-0.3883381784,
0.0997123867,
0.6766856909,
0.0055829864,
0.6331704259,
-0.0669331476,
-0.0209037941,
0.3061043024,
0.2546487153,
0.7009261847,
0.0661524013,
-0.2290291488,
0.2291441858,
0.3300390244,
-0.1448609233,
-0.7307071686,
0.5097091198,
-0.5378260612,
-0.5257759094,
-0.0755569711,
-0.2957895696,
-0.3858558238,
0.331697613,
0.2435095012,
0.4186838567,
-0.3804136515,
0.4616236687,
0.6366496682,
-0.2150643617,
0.4738428593,
0.3290614188,
-0.1430964619,
-0.1020526811,
1.0383737087,
0.0821722746,
0.3317926824,
0.2798496485,
0.3338399827,
-0.1398985982,
-0.7321544886,
-0.4137545824,
-0.2598778903,
-0.6049215794,
-0.0681846887,
-0.450584501,
-0.3826504052,
-0.2425887734,
0.4596281946,
-0.4599363208,
-0.3675076365,
-0.1186857969,
0.1905938089,
-0.0308245253,
0.7275466323,
0.420542717,
0.6549281478,
-0.917626977,
0.1047715172,
0.117464073,
0.3122505248,
-0.2541090846,
-0.5492296219,
-0.130474329,
0.1633066535,
-0.6191544533,
-0.721349597,
0.2004492432,
0.3012592494,
0.5357530713,
0.4718576074,
-0.0883211866,
0.9023292661,
-0.4640635848,
0.9508016109,
-0.2051384747,
-0.7840582728,
0.3710853159,
-0.2699110508,
0.1435716748,
0.7850669622,
0.2391943187,
-0.3186183274,
-0.402335763,
-0.6983445883,
-0.7184877396,
0.7518036366,
0.6080562472,
0.0278763399,
0.1330618858,
0.3812603056,
0.2789876759,
0.0288328044,
-0.6585499644,
0.0985004231,
0.0550163016,
-0.265558064,
0.1185396388,
-0.3297272623,
0.1642973274,
0.3229239881,
0.7505380511,
-0.0300687887,
0.5313894749,
0.2033584565,
-0.2095605433,
0.2063455433,
0.5510164499,
0.3250769675,
0.8305500746,
-0.3778197169,
0.1430416107,
0.0737557784,
-0.8384831548,
-0.5252329707,
0.396699667,
0.174303472,
-0.2091018707,
0.5642501712,
0.4749334753,
-0.0303411968,
-0.6820626855,
0.7707278728,
-0.443792522,
0.1297744513,
-0.078652285,
0.265812248,
-0.2822551131,
0.3625187278,
0.2759280801,
-0.0890285671,
0.3490861654,
-0.3489232957,
0.165432483,
0.5736985207,
-0.4602914453,
-0.3686862588,
0.2064056695,
-0.1044290736,
-0.2564198673,
0.656799078,
-0.0770973414,
-0.430586189,
0.367639631,
0.4410571158,
0.7031756639,
-0.119449541,
0.0012316041,
0.1814000309,
0.5284949541,
-0.1199104935,
0.129971087,
-0.0332672,
-0.7112951279,
-0.5404358506,
-0.5702520609,
-0.4596271515,
0.3537431955,
-0.6297309399,
0.3026393652,
0.059794616,
-0.0765314773,
0.2550902665,
0.1979465783,
-0.9214186072,
0.1900499463,
-0.1465489566,
1.042645216,
-0.4580922127,
0.6089055538,
0.3353431225,
-0.2301249355,
-0.9990646243,
0.1702001095,
-0.0905659422,
-1.3112578392,
0.5052233338,
0.3808089793,
0.0643650666,
-0.0614577718,
-0.6211639643,
-0.6981735826,
1.0899522305,
0.5145559311,
-0.5537031889,
-0.1027644575,
0.2378937304,
0.4158494771,
-0.0626762435,
0.802144587,
0.7024474144,
0.5762090683,
-0.0042302217,
-1.3436347246,
-0.1807325631,
-0.1631498784,
-0.2414217889,
0.0425902195,
-0.4657308757,
0.5716623664,
0.2399259359,
-0.5353057384,
0.0140518015,
0.1877946705,
-0.145535484,
0.1842524409,
0.3719319105,
0.3499346077,
0.6796012521,
-0.2323847413,
1.0816428661,
-0.2308603823,
0.5572496057,
1.1901522875,
-0.0631816536,
1.0802620649,
0.4929377139,
-0.1228944138,
0.0642172992,
0.645637095,
0.0476736538,
0.4183336198,
0.0353166722,
-0.1328629404,
-0.1568798721,
-0.0467144847,
-0.1285960078,
0.8806461692,
0.3848512173,
-0.4621870518,
-0.6128492355,
0.0005272259,
0.0771422833,
-0.4319781065,
-0.1663848907,
0.9623516798,
0.0094262948,
-0.8025581241,
0.2042440921,
0.0261977818,
0.2135705948,
-0.5460503101,
-0.3128807843,
-0.0010043517,
0.2735410035,
-0.1881495416,
-1.0069227219,
0.0821782053,
0.0658057779,
0.1519083828,
-0.1127183288,
1.0627145767,
-0.0865212902,
-0.0889370814,
-0.0150218206,
0.5388798118,
0.5363007784,
-0.3572087884,
-0.5935923457,
0.0458229147,
0.1828779876,
-0.6345822215,
0.2532777786,
0.7331548929,
0.0395096242,
0.5939987302,
0.4144084752,
0.1845016181,
-0.0353067704,
-0.2625146806,
0.6687494516,
-0.4038052857,
-0.0727778897,
-1.1186639071,
0.416282177,
-0.1497731507,
-0.2952192128,
0.8724484444,
0.7463467121,
0.6204797626,
0.1472505778,
0.7814467549,
-0.1663266271,
0.3928438425,
-0.6414356232,
0.3983448744,
-0.101109758,
0.3536190093,
-0.2768839896,
-1.0328929424,
0.117016457,
0.4927971363,
-0.490370214,
-0.1244434714,
0.6720721722,
0.7086181641,
-0.4654397368,
0.5034695864,
0.3272228837,
0.1329281479,
0.5132436752,
0.5336757302,
1.0079165697,
-0.5237258673,
0.7716342211,
-0.0660984218,
-0.4954744875,
0.037479233,
-1.0624966621,
-0.7937694192,
-0.3268142045,
-0.0767303482,
-0.2731885314,
-0.0172106009,
0.73688519,
0.6924115419,
-0.620126009,
0.1153131351,
0.0164851844,
-0.1624762565,
0.0501068197,
-0.324455291,
0.4356432259,
-0.5815674663,
-0.804192543,
0.2498487532,
0.2435635775,
-0.0983323231,
-0.0171754006,
0.2298034728,
0.2436242551,
-0.1009031683,
0.693144381,
0.1212633029,
-0.633615315,
-0.6951309443,
-0.1177526861,
-0.0490017571,
0.2366992682,
0.4740230143,
-0.3050242662,
0.5680621862,
0.4533725977,
0.8109537363,
0.5797659159,
0.255905658,
0.4634904861,
-0.6365501881,
-0.4188945591,
-0.0181352776,
0.3259457052,
0.0547567159,
-0.3257292807,
0.6854872108,
-0.1975699663,
-0.8591301441,
-0.5348316431,
-0.1645945907,
-1.2484339476,
0.149669081,
1.4285387993,
-0.5789582729,
-0.2515613735,
-0.1425380856,
-0.6345332861,
0.133488223,
-0.5667516589,
0.7537986636,
1.114736557,
-0.2115871906,
-0.1204381362,
-1.040563345,
0.1971551627,
-0.033627864,
-0.9146569967,
0.3340931535,
0.3310164511,
0.3937342763,
0.310537219,
0.4759018719,
-0.291762054,
0.0441623963,
-0.1836136729,
-0.1038062498,
-0.0175668094,
0.0123602143,
-0.0509800352,
0.3303786516,
0.3987361491,
-0.3088615239
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.