id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04136v1 | Knowledge-Augmented Language Model Prompting for Zero-Shot Knowledge Graph Question Answering | 2023-06-07T04:15:21 | 2023-06-07T04:15:21 | Jinheon Baek, Alham Fikri Aji, Amir Saffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are capable of performing zero-shot closed-book
question answering tasks, based on their internal knowledge stored in
parameters during pre-training. However, such internalized knowledge might be
insufficient and incorrect, which could lead LLMs to generate factually wrong
answers. Furthermore, fine-tuning LLMs to update their knowledge is expensive.
To this end, we propose to augment the knowledge directly in the input of LLMs.
Specifically, we first retrieve the relevant facts to the input question from
the knowledge graph based on semantic similarities between the question and its
associated facts. After that, we prepend the retrieved facts to the input
question in the form of the prompt, which is then forwarded to LLMs to generate
the answer. Our framework, Knowledge-Augmented language model PromptING
(KAPING), requires no model training, thus completely zero-shot. We validate
the performance of our KAPING framework on the knowledge graph question
answering task, that aims to answer the user's question based on facts over a
knowledge graph, on which ours outperforms relevant zero-shot baselines by up
to 48% in average, across multiple LLMs of various sizes. | [
-0.1563329548,
-1.1734595299,
1.0137107372,
-0.1606286019,
-0.1675765514,
0.1866187602,
-0.127115041,
-0.5148165822,
0.117747426,
0.5661174655,
-0.7206044197,
-0.5002189279,
-0.399484843,
0.1776794195,
-0.1456457973,
0.7063782811,
-0.0528440438,
0.0113258883,
-0.5857900381,
0.0038705897,
-0.727625072,
-0.3412062824,
-0.5627133846,
-0.5343402028,
0.669177413,
0.8146648407,
0.3903953433,
0.3910410404,
0.0078624487,
0.1978720427,
0.0036075138,
0.2430266142,
-0.2164028734,
0.2332527637,
0.0575848147,
-0.6116265059,
-0.4275645018,
-0.1810297519,
0.4914887249,
0.7885397673,
0.1784451008,
0.2190848291,
-0.042173855,
0.5464254022,
-0.6157764196,
0.1321657449,
-0.74996984,
0.0448482446,
0.1256381869,
-0.4924803376,
-0.3678567708,
-0.339543879,
0.0797378197,
-0.5860772133,
0.0805850998,
-0.0632447451,
0.9044527411,
0.0500617698,
-0.3949487507,
-0.1961640716,
-0.6169846654,
0.4088356495,
-0.7145442963,
0.2584654689,
0.4780270755,
0.2936899364,
-0.0886974186,
-0.3459120393,
-0.8406296968,
-0.4067081213,
-0.0072154063,
0.1550226957,
-0.0795612261,
0.3574589193,
0.3337535858,
0.2146929055,
-0.5638391376,
0.0340940915,
-0.2547470927,
-0.2196131051,
0.4022011459,
0.0953094214,
0.4612283409,
-0.125015229,
-0.3493810296,
0.0024995692,
-0.8117698431,
0.1514058262,
0.424570322,
0.410792321,
0.0966613293,
0.8978947401,
-0.6434642076,
1.2975523472,
0.1812923402,
-0.1881101876,
0.2675187886,
-0.1414381117,
-0.2333261967,
0.150743857,
0.6443852186,
0.5342652798,
0.340588212,
-0.1804084033,
-0.0666177794,
-0.1812114865,
0.0021308172,
-0.7101413608,
-0.0205781534,
0.4944626689,
0.1821114272,
-0.3943279684,
-0.4147693813,
-0.6111312509,
-0.4239703119,
-0.0167948585,
0.9249417186,
-0.5332629085,
-0.0852471888,
0.2463830262,
-0.1814129949,
0.4258272052,
0.5564894676,
-0.8006383181,
-0.0377145894,
0.4001717865,
0.7643135786,
0.2599242032,
-0.2563756704,
-0.7383884192,
0.2096833736,
-0.4002609551,
1.1456087828,
-0.6358921528,
-0.2698729336,
-0.0151013769,
-0.0576993562,
-0.0714262724,
-0.3778380752,
0.3256470859,
-0.8410283923,
0.3161375225,
-0.7662029266,
-0.971293509,
-0.3387342393,
0.8078444004,
-0.1876185238,
0.9797987938,
0.2187208831,
-0.638594985,
0.3159873188,
-0.8648195267,
-0.2498099804,
0.4392739832,
-0.2373084128,
-0.0356984399,
-0.2268925905,
0.5427840948,
0.4005146027,
-0.1336762011,
0.1861318797,
-0.3967817426,
-0.2510478795,
0.0083645349,
-0.3143330812,
0.5679196119,
0.0145591339,
0.0415286086,
0.1220588684,
-0.7376427054,
0.1205281839,
0.3007111251,
-0.2752894461,
-0.1769127399,
-0.2773968279,
-0.6176377535,
0.2146625817,
0.496955961,
-0.9709641337,
0.4257291257,
-0.4924989939,
0.0743911639,
0.6681195498,
0.35017097,
0.4249610901,
-0.514834106,
0.8157397509,
0.0483828001,
0.0064104781,
-0.5081039071,
-0.6504971385,
-0.7032029033,
0.0821852311,
0.2728338838,
0.7425552607,
-1.0788090229,
0.2387576997,
-0.1660065055,
-0.4978931248,
-0.4322233796,
0.2366828918,
0.1282879412,
1.3045698404,
0.2669028342,
0.0719253495,
-0.3331924975,
-0.5629737973,
-0.1768488586,
-0.4852257371,
-0.1070874631,
0.5560873747,
0.2451684326,
0.2487592697,
1.0925728083,
-0.6827782393,
-0.1627560258,
-0.3345368505,
-0.0333596766,
0.1607732475,
-0.0036218825,
0.5440994501,
-0.291369319,
-0.6203375459,
0.1113548279,
-0.8341811299,
-0.3184113801,
0.0654500201,
0.0413869731,
0.2195873111,
0.4891011417,
-0.7335144281,
0.1029336452,
0.5521562099,
-0.3011347055,
0.7333379984,
-0.2353549451,
0.2970279157,
-1.0203156471,
0.2121199518,
-0.3659951687,
-0.2217559814,
-0.7938440442,
0.0113963457,
0.0283249393,
-0.3465889692,
-0.441637814,
0.9133281708,
-0.2902615666,
0.1075368449,
-0.4016248584,
0.4442494214,
0.1916063428,
0.6269950271,
0.1535541266,
0.8691928387,
0.7840508223,
-0.6957743168,
0.5143187642,
0.2133750618,
-0.3748144507,
0.4834124446,
-0.8135552406,
0.2565603852,
-0.3267511129,
0.0473870113,
-1.0694539547,
-0.3619797528,
0.3484235704,
-0.6755332351,
0.1580563486,
-0.4290530086,
-0.6122239828,
-0.31674698,
-0.1969540119,
0.2082214355,
0.5291157961,
-0.4487969577,
0.5810733438,
0.0728402734,
-0.2275386453,
-0.6653935909,
-0.3884508312,
0.038498912,
0.0910871774,
-0.705421865,
-0.1355035901,
-0.1676673442,
0.1494307518,
0.1921395808,
0.0141281094,
0.0084826425,
-0.0384615585,
-0.0651878789,
0.3819095492,
-0.3077897429,
0.4230713546,
-0.0561703816,
-0.0452294387,
-0.0008159815,
-0.5671327114,
0.7581436634,
0.1221218035,
-0.6244395971,
-0.220184505,
0.1188174486,
0.3797100782,
-0.1672751307,
0.8056471944,
0.2704433501,
-0.2318050414,
0.1365554482,
-0.5880736113,
-0.1849787384,
-0.4773339331,
0.3024891019,
-0.2493548542,
-1.2192239761,
0.6242904663,
-0.0114283068,
0.0795048326,
0.2756709754,
0.5959298015,
-0.1875337809,
1.0652238131,
0.5416684747,
-0.0607123263,
0.3995122612,
0.0313644111,
0.2509313226,
-0.5466966629,
-0.3678718805,
-0.303801626,
-0.1121848002,
-0.1824346483,
-0.2912042439,
0.5489224792,
0.2708422244,
-0.1675162017,
0.0605533309,
-0.3060288429,
0.602810204,
0.6039136052,
0.1208267957,
0.3813642263,
-0.0293059107,
-0.2942897677,
0.3678913116,
-1.0496017933,
-0.2958177924,
1.1553630829,
0.1415524334,
0.6133643985,
-0.141779229,
0.5804103017,
0.0231457092,
0.0928918943,
-0.9004524946,
0.5791220665,
0.3478440344,
-0.6577772498,
-0.4660229981,
-0.4099024832,
-0.800378561,
-0.0791766271,
-0.244115591,
-0.8101696372,
0.0397070982,
0.5275092125,
-0.7479255795,
0.5331214666,
-0.7410826683,
0.7217373848,
-0.1569729149,
0.0810817182,
0.1428052038,
-0.4864046872,
0.4288035333,
0.0317574218,
-0.0277316291,
-0.0973175988,
0.0241240766,
0.5861478448,
-0.541668117,
0.8791648746,
-0.5147088766,
-0.1995122582,
0.5747714043,
0.1013028473,
0.5606169105,
-0.1602194756,
-0.0364248231,
-0.1562409401,
0.0496450737,
-0.5605034232,
-1.0112321377,
0.566798389,
-0.7279570699,
-0.7997704744,
-0.2405132651,
-0.8411415219,
-0.6464885473,
0.2516770363,
0.1908055395,
0.4638908207,
0.2338251323,
-0.0928631648,
0.7019125819,
-0.3241160214,
0.1438771337,
0.7029640079,
-0.5576165915,
-0.2252394408,
0.8326778412,
0.2247980684,
0.5816576481,
0.4565328956,
0.331248492,
-0.4982731938,
-0.4181325138,
-0.7582083941,
0.2472786456,
-0.779933989,
-0.3387681544,
-0.8263580799,
-0.3471532464,
-0.5083758235,
-0.1409296393,
-0.0341225192,
-0.4702122509,
-0.0027294622,
-0.2228088379,
0.9171008468,
0.5688237548,
0.0522402152,
0.3914377391,
-0.9658536315,
0.24924317,
0.677824378,
0.5077345967,
0.0887183771,
-0.7914276123,
-0.0827449858,
0.2446946353,
-0.1962431967,
-0.983620584,
0.043187771,
0.1498755068,
0.3606996238,
0.3484395146,
0.229033649,
0.7691286802,
-0.5774365067,
0.9391351342,
0.1425301135,
-0.6272426248,
0.7161182165,
-0.511136651,
0.5829721689,
0.5256686807,
0.2706904411,
-0.6947156787,
-0.5097557902,
-0.6078382134,
-0.5744718909,
0.7359842658,
-0.1251761913,
0.4130797386,
-0.184023127,
0.5859247446,
-0.0871902406,
0.2497807294,
-0.6465685964,
-0.2884958684,
-0.0346415639,
-0.0883842334,
0.1525766551,
-0.3257938623,
-0.0616883226,
-0.2668818533,
0.766295433,
-0.3959083557,
0.2447174639,
0.3395090401,
-0.0713513345,
-0.4087946117,
0.2978960872,
0.6002545953,
0.611759305,
-0.274335444,
-0.0426742062,
0.4577612281,
-0.2496307045,
0.0834942758,
-0.0492987782,
-0.5807182789,
-0.0631766468,
0.3145563006,
0.8799769878,
-0.0474248305,
-0.8634194732,
0.6243565083,
0.0660466924,
-0.4541765451,
-0.1458845437,
0.1881824285,
0.1625694782,
0.0707752705,
0.4187546074,
-0.1848639101,
-0.2311793864,
-0.5284142494,
0.0877202302,
0.5522999167,
-0.5149576664,
-0.1289304495,
0.3826530278,
0.0742617473,
-0.362007618,
0.5610150695,
-0.2487648726,
-0.6276634336,
0.3788280785,
0.5381134152,
0.5362923145,
-0.03708487,
0.4179621041,
0.4718486071,
0.2349675,
0.2810968459,
0.5401207209,
-0.2557469904,
-0.9498291612,
-0.846560955,
-0.5715880394,
-0.5913454294,
0.3610338569,
-0.4326722324,
0.3754199445,
-0.5285003185,
0.1977212578,
-0.3056965768,
0.092556417,
-0.4446707964,
0.2430341989,
0.1004005596,
1.104060173,
-0.9037553072,
0.7822947502,
0.8273022175,
-0.5049561858,
-0.932785213,
-0.0495719165,
-0.1917156577,
-1.1522499323,
0.4118998349,
-0.0853718743,
-0.0946121141,
0.2257426679,
-0.8735561371,
-0.6991754174,
1.1598790884,
0.6186665297,
-0.36395666,
-0.0758267492,
0.3189852536,
0.4041963518,
-0.1946619302,
0.1782839596,
0.1963033974,
0.369481951,
0.5394948721,
-0.7385601997,
-0.0999554619,
-0.118339479,
-0.4079113603,
0.14448452,
-0.4601801932,
0.5131819248,
-0.327286154,
-0.131913662,
-0.057779476,
0.5835343003,
0.5211129189,
0.1950712949,
0.5935570598,
0.5168721676,
0.8392518759,
0.1938072145,
1.1562702656,
-0.7286710739,
0.198645249,
1.1040098667,
-0.4039698541,
0.7698895335,
0.4001497924,
-0.0313058868,
0.5673109889,
0.5600654483,
0.2154031694,
0.3045398295,
-0.2658281624,
-0.5403670669,
-0.5397761464,
-0.3385136127,
-0.2936510146,
0.4550229311,
0.0633848161,
0.0551168583,
-0.6323004961,
-0.0573913939,
-0.0702224746,
-0.0281355251,
-0.3736140132,
0.8095907569,
-0.0473461226,
-0.7097635865,
0.5043286085,
-0.1288560182,
0.3620874584,
-0.944443047,
-0.1893890947,
-0.1991982311,
-0.3751490712,
-0.0857600346,
-1.071845293,
0.1604320705,
0.1630198956,
-0.2152308971,
-0.0653002858,
0.9256626964,
-0.6817151308,
-0.5423609614,
0.0962758735,
0.7296670079,
0.0748391077,
-0.1048744321,
-0.5487367511,
-0.3416006565,
-0.1800242811,
0.0083412938,
0.3706616461,
0.4653054178,
0.1394315362,
0.9025137424,
0.7071158886,
0.1724699736,
-0.0076993187,
0.1850270033,
0.8958619237,
-0.4211683571,
-0.4506321549,
-0.824765563,
0.4244305789,
-0.0151020363,
-0.013354334,
0.9067744017,
0.243753314,
0.7628507018,
-0.000857844,
0.8206176758,
-0.097011134,
0.5530951619,
-0.5940935612,
0.7800946832,
-0.5908979177,
0.109671846,
-0.2325187474,
-0.6890996099,
-0.2401539832,
0.2571309507,
-0.485965997,
0.0597908236,
0.3453903794,
0.9614319205,
0.1509773433,
-0.076094158,
0.7762853503,
0.1780827343,
0.0258139372,
0.5810167789,
0.8157149553,
-0.3409173787,
0.617446363,
-0.2645875216,
-0.0728490725,
-0.0584357828,
-0.9520340562,
-0.8165194392,
-0.4798206985,
-0.264970839,
-0.3731455505,
0.0109805306,
0.9221114516,
0.4863520265,
-0.7271741629,
-0.0340306833,
-0.0901278034,
0.2392710149,
0.1292852014,
-0.2466629148,
0.2777304053,
-0.5893663764,
-0.424832046,
0.433499068,
0.3662420809,
0.0107095828,
-0.1416905075,
-0.0188107733,
-0.3896692395,
0.1767785996,
0.6582929492,
0.4970494211,
-0.5318123698,
-0.7476677299,
0.3548355103,
0.2795750201,
0.1800247133,
0.6245704889,
-1.0032323599,
0.6853340864,
0.4863801897,
0.8376678824,
0.188503772,
0.0325130075,
0.6528823972,
-0.9495928884,
-0.007252099,
0.1118131429,
0.1672336757,
0.4170763195,
-0.5111817718,
0.0138525981,
0.2864525914,
-0.5054849982,
-0.7569097877,
0.3846503198,
-0.8180490732,
-0.1447136849,
1.0887416601,
-0.1367099583,
-0.3788930774,
-0.2159794718,
-0.211861223,
0.1380951554,
-0.234074384,
0.5718913078,
0.8286116123,
-0.2598975599,
-0.483823806,
-0.4974462092,
0.3826306462,
0.4136894643,
-0.6300187707,
0.1565583497,
0.4481472373,
0.6769868731,
-0.0170338806,
0.9393442273,
-0.0446492881,
0.4466232359,
-0.0714713112,
0.2306916714,
-0.3452729285,
-0.2659335732,
-0.5352905393,
0.1437582672,
0.5166059136,
-0.080760181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04125v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04125v2 | Multimodal Fusion Interactions: A Study of Human and Automatic Quantification | 2023-06-07T03:44:50 | 2023-10-30T18:06:46 | Paul Pu Liang, Yun Cheng, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.HC | In order to perform multimodal fusion of heterogeneous signals, we need to
understand their interactions: how each modality individually provides
information useful for a task and how this information changes in the presence
of other modalities. In this paper, we perform a comparative study of how
humans annotate two categorizations of multimodal interactions: (1) partial
labels, where different annotators annotate the label given the first, second,
and both modalities, and (2) counterfactual labels, where the same annotator
annotates the label given the first modality before asking them to explicitly
reason about how their answer changes when given the second. We further propose
an alternative taxonomy based on (3) information decomposition, where
annotators annotate the degrees of redundancy: the extent to which modalities
individually and together give the same predictions, uniqueness: the extent to
which one modality enables a prediction that the other does not, and synergy:
the extent to which both modalities enable one to make a prediction that one
would not otherwise make using individual modalities. Through experiments and
annotations, we highlight several opportunities and limitations of each
approach and propose a method to automatically convert annotations of partial
and counterfactual labels to information decomposition, yielding an accurate
and efficient method for quantifying multimodal interactions. | [
-0.89395082,
-0.6374617219,
0.2932604253,
0.0659149885,
-0.0656796023,
0.1139694676,
-0.071253337,
-0.7869263291,
0.4385316074,
0.003227276,
-0.6037278771,
0.0733011886,
-0.3275969625,
0.1648229957,
-0.1438087076,
0.7851611376,
-0.0777723417,
0.2811321318,
-0.5907992125,
-0.3735177219,
-0.4051328897,
-0.7894482613,
-0.26275298,
-0.6474145651,
0.7988806367,
-0.1332431436,
0.7559372187,
0.2760353088,
0.7794146538,
0.4759660065,
0.1441647112,
0.0081228456,
-0.1000144556,
-0.0190032516,
-0.1605032533,
-0.0963884369,
-0.3245464563,
0.3083418608,
0.3604003191,
0.8892347813,
0.2545748055,
0.4014658332,
-0.1940529197,
0.107716307,
-0.9575153589,
0.1811254472,
0.0638010502,
0.1290450096,
-0.0313654989,
-0.3219608665,
-0.2641063929,
0.1200103015,
0.1370838583,
-0.5692225099,
0.0313300081,
0.0049826824,
0.6586596966,
0.5420946479,
-0.8552783728,
0.0106468685,
-0.9517570734,
0.6496432424,
-0.2732540965,
0.5072652698,
0.5075134635,
0.3654850125,
0.1291185021,
-0.4672544897,
-0.9341532588,
-0.1178219244,
-0.5960102677,
0.2292058319,
-0.3048917055,
0.4698218107,
0.2456411719,
0.2410828769,
-0.4924483001,
-0.1134792641,
-0.4370155632,
-0.7439079881,
0.7291699052,
0.1653722525,
0.4301905334,
-0.4794719517,
-0.7491986752,
-0.3144692183,
-0.0859640539,
-0.0811397061,
0.2367521822,
-0.1622357517,
-0.0834975466,
0.7374082208,
-0.2987070382,
0.7136737108,
0.0658888444,
-0.3333299458,
0.5630800724,
-0.9734714627,
-0.2782470882,
-0.0231833793,
0.9656541348,
0.5352235436,
-0.3847305775,
-0.088596046,
-0.1820699424,
0.5587199926,
0.0506145731,
-0.1968735904,
-0.3538258374,
0.1424610913,
-0.7018072605,
-0.1521793008,
0.047221899,
-0.5961251855,
-0.4076593518,
-0.445307523,
1.0468584299,
-0.2621780634,
-0.4529752135,
-0.3147863448,
-0.5016334653,
0.0220883936,
0.2613121867,
-0.5962536335,
0.1012398824,
0.4052263796,
0.5371708274,
-0.03221412,
-0.4839040637,
-0.1958914101,
0.2430138737,
0.1558799297,
0.7781950831,
-0.616951406,
-0.3290555477,
-0.487837255,
-0.0751932338,
-0.2647562921,
-0.405015558,
0.2260218114,
-0.4606677294,
0.4704060256,
-0.4321092069,
-0.2793628871,
-0.5748152733,
0.3063721955,
-1.0438634157,
0.4888272882,
0.0839721933,
-0.8010320663,
0.6450303197,
-0.7832359076,
-0.3225131631,
0.0842650533,
-0.0472014286,
-0.0760710761,
-0.0664616004,
-0.2551158369,
0.3725126684,
-0.2346436232,
0.3565090001,
-0.4304475486,
-0.2454028726,
0.5949448943,
-0.3561525047,
0.4731499255,
0.2796816826,
-0.1349522322,
0.3842361569,
-0.7433160543,
-0.1613966674,
-0.2676120698,
-0.2101801932,
-0.4937455058,
-0.0393937677,
0.0654302016,
0.5478291512,
0.22576271,
-0.6038947701,
-0.0564025566,
-0.0042410498,
0.3857982755,
0.4810751081,
0.142568782,
0.449618578,
-0.5614532232,
0.311276406,
0.3024518788,
0.3110938072,
-0.2617702484,
-0.3685133755,
-0.7508760691,
-0.3997386396,
0.480340749,
0.4189751446,
-1.0155752897,
0.1470278203,
-0.1635191888,
-0.3697989583,
-0.6186159849,
-0.1071308851,
0.6542555094,
0.3532999456,
0.4821848273,
-0.6897101998,
-0.9037994146,
-1.1420539618,
-0.167787537,
-0.4066950381,
-0.0472096279,
-0.03826138,
0.6097462773,
-0.4791531563,
1.051846981,
-0.1254405379,
-0.1794604212,
0.074176006,
0.752096355,
-0.4972660244,
0.5045195222,
0.4395746887,
-1.2269933224,
-0.1049040034,
0.0451082774,
-0.8278305531,
0.0677765831,
-0.2246261835,
0.1414950192,
0.0592322201,
0.1676947027,
-0.4854333401,
0.6124095917,
0.4269086123,
-0.2712060511,
0.2628291547,
0.0188799333,
0.6141380668,
-0.6557568312,
0.0874742344,
0.1358577013,
0.1215709895,
-0.9436621666,
-0.153871417,
-0.1001433134,
0.1032961756,
-0.4602319002,
0.629391551,
-0.3884622455,
-0.2745627761,
-0.1226915568,
-0.1549280882,
-0.0460849889,
0.6178044081,
0.0588292442,
0.4747655094,
0.1333796233,
-0.4719497561,
0.7284272909,
0.1775877029,
-0.1191890687,
0.4810133278,
-0.4153279364,
-0.1860714108,
-0.3726303875,
0.4018776715,
-1.4868971109,
-0.5986241102,
0.5671902299,
-0.560536325,
-0.0934626237,
0.1125274971,
-0.7162055969,
-0.2886547446,
-0.5506315827,
0.7719621062,
0.3519821763,
-0.2681238651,
0.9697353244,
0.4382635951,
0.0907026678,
-0.335528791,
-0.8029913306,
-0.1073499694,
-0.3781267405,
-0.6864132285,
0.2111353725,
-0.1898837686,
-0.5625554919,
0.0147511289,
0.0159846786,
-0.2357334793,
0.0631288067,
0.5966523886,
0.3723311424,
0.126368016,
0.4571663439,
0.1104501486,
-0.3039101064,
0.0331149399,
0.4763507843,
0.4040792882,
0.0310526174,
-0.4858106375,
-0.7034058571,
0.3735452294,
0.4948296547,
-0.3537076712,
0.6290346384,
0.9648216367,
-0.3153705299,
0.7672441006,
-0.8018395901,
-0.2354073673,
-0.4391784072,
0.036120899,
-0.5077670217,
-0.4803762138,
0.6687694788,
-0.0033167016,
-0.0453635566,
0.5272039771,
0.5211420059,
-0.1646300405,
1.3384635448,
0.5225923657,
0.1995866746,
0.3910470307,
-0.0387411825,
0.02256497,
-0.8426573277,
-0.5442750454,
-0.0735305622,
-0.63357234,
-0.5189822316,
-0.3822737932,
0.5516053438,
-0.0673905164,
-0.0586028956,
0.2754277289,
-0.425342828,
0.2369828373,
0.4848920405,
0.0421093591,
0.4066394567,
-0.1474045217,
0.244068712,
0.0542158559,
-0.7180602551,
-0.1873019189,
0.7367322445,
0.2659235299,
0.6589438319,
0.3123506904,
0.5391141176,
0.329757154,
0.5575900078,
-0.7549726963,
0.5775133371,
0.291377008,
-0.6817394495,
-0.0598734878,
-0.5673396587,
-0.9107320905,
0.6201789379,
-0.6332730055,
-0.6397675276,
0.4515142441,
0.3174193501,
-0.3566803634,
-0.0507393181,
-1.1744838953,
0.7986590862,
-0.0982720852,
-0.2874818146,
-0.2909664214,
-0.9753590226,
0.4294574857,
-0.1710034609,
0.4963006973,
0.0042539518,
-0.1478464901,
1.0457330942,
-0.1095625535,
1.0074119568,
-0.0214429535,
0.0244307518,
0.1990535706,
0.1365963072,
-0.1431243271,
-0.2309711426,
0.2321322858,
0.1866773665,
0.3277150989,
-0.2275911272,
-0.4558549821,
0.5919471979,
-0.9650258422,
-0.3322685957,
-0.4995973408,
-0.6776847839,
-0.2099434286,
0.0587016344,
0.387943536,
0.5481324792,
-0.0039142091,
-0.1500617564,
0.2383229434,
0.0738576949,
0.5265972614,
0.303373754,
0.0017943452,
-0.5137579441,
1.000159502,
0.1427278966,
0.3027897775,
0.5150324106,
0.0348593779,
-0.2296690047,
0.040217936,
0.0006733887,
0.288387984,
-0.879964292,
-0.1491504312,
-0.6633372903,
0.1280389577,
-0.2389690876,
-0.0418165252,
0.0598314703,
-0.5777438283,
-0.1050550789,
0.0179271363,
0.0340639465,
0.6667434573,
-0.5200141668,
0.1295428723,
-0.8716706634,
0.3344403207,
0.5182289481,
0.1120850444,
0.0593691058,
0.1379480064,
-0.0982316211,
0.3558545709,
-0.2164686918,
-1.1381670237,
-0.0134320566,
0.1190423891,
0.5731435418,
0.2277558446,
0.1182524338,
0.8382837772,
0.1348327249,
0.814340055,
0.6321319342,
-1.0530631542,
0.3163997531,
-0.0762748346,
0.4166590571,
0.396270752,
0.7314120531,
-0.6309812665,
-0.0904336199,
-0.5694051385,
-0.7921851873,
0.6959136724,
0.1354417056,
-0.2633022368,
0.0293271337,
-0.0873360261,
0.2509557009,
0.2142786533,
-0.6666218042,
-0.2075863481,
-0.36322999,
-0.1753880382,
-0.2436532974,
-0.2720784843,
-0.6785937548,
-0.2270214111,
0.1750993878,
0.1337575316,
0.4272072017,
0.0830578133,
-0.3710722625,
-0.3206650913,
0.2205162048,
0.7235023975,
0.6659148335,
-0.1387866586,
0.6031803489,
0.2242008746,
-0.1277408749,
0.3227707744,
0.0838628262,
0.1497322321,
0.0826411396,
0.7764146328,
0.7945821881,
0.2618589103,
-0.6917123795,
0.4167068601,
-0.0859450996,
-0.1901841462,
-0.0989170969,
-0.0047894185,
-0.2067263424,
0.4714226723,
0.1981766075,
0.2132653594,
0.3437016308,
-0.7119370699,
0.1822409183,
0.288364172,
-0.3099377751,
-0.6658499241,
0.4602530599,
0.5363078117,
-0.0198475141,
0.2223193645,
-0.2553481162,
-0.4529142678,
0.3883828223,
0.0176688638,
0.5756229162,
-0.1930721402,
0.2250596285,
0.2597567737,
-0.0188050605,
0.2585540116,
0.0694710538,
-0.4296241701,
-0.7031521201,
-0.7242256403,
-0.3366039395,
-0.2399687618,
-0.0788445473,
-0.7972572446,
-0.129942745,
-0.1412016004,
-0.6817816496,
0.6879928708,
-0.196153149,
-0.7256933451,
0.1008097306,
0.3309963942,
0.3480075002,
-1.0346670151,
0.4155575037,
1.1560690403,
-0.7411937118,
-0.3586750329,
-0.1305988729,
0.3652658463,
-0.3925626278,
1.0737118721,
-0.0462888218,
-0.0972876623,
-0.3915040791,
-0.1808114648,
-0.7871103883,
1.0358300209,
0.0491765216,
-0.1594839096,
0.0910967886,
0.1233039647,
0.5260774493,
0.0059235352,
0.5272894502,
0.4502880573,
0.8759239316,
0.2352086008,
-1.5804071426,
0.0938776284,
-0.3323546052,
0.0133579262,
0.5253538489,
-0.6427756548,
0.9442433715,
-0.0467445441,
-0.6076142788,
-0.010826502,
0.3531492054,
-0.3654296398,
0.6141925454,
0.6685563922,
0.3126917183,
0.2241484672,
-0.2152423263,
0.9055032134,
-0.1088634282,
0.6126329899,
0.7248188853,
-0.1270422041,
0.4748471975,
0.6127514839,
-0.1600336134,
0.2225763202,
0.5949753523,
0.0378577784,
0.4367060363,
-0.1059841067,
-0.3467699885,
-0.4513391256,
-0.2442125827,
-0.3926357329,
0.681860745,
0.1368921399,
-0.0249567144,
-0.3024971485,
0.6820033193,
-0.2173207402,
-0.2221569419,
-0.2410636395,
1.0863509178,
-0.4247537255,
-0.5419037938,
0.6360771656,
-0.0486522578,
0.7695300579,
-0.4342191517,
-0.0033694522,
0.1128097251,
-0.0727052614,
-0.5276623964,
-0.8031833768,
0.2516158223,
-0.5586280823,
-0.2539421618,
-0.0779515505,
0.8199077249,
-0.58851403,
0.0371901691,
0.1767685115,
0.4874325395,
-0.0952293947,
0.3361459076,
-0.4054110944,
0.5248987675,
-0.081644766,
-0.1324682832,
0.5427078009,
-0.0018125734,
-0.1449256539,
0.7899034023,
0.5855174065,
-0.3544156551,
0.0569935702,
-0.2903349996,
0.9418787956,
-0.7753780484,
-0.0907042548,
-0.6593724489,
0.5406240821,
0.0223618206,
-0.2609887123,
0.7683454752,
0.2467400283,
0.9855194092,
-0.0626654252,
0.6723059416,
-0.2872141898,
0.2519914806,
-0.3278160989,
0.3111748695,
-0.6732283235,
0.0177489016,
-0.2031509131,
-0.7851914763,
-0.2634571493,
0.5653972626,
-0.4163385034,
0.1564420313,
0.5203659534,
0.4786915481,
-0.0743997023,
0.1074311733,
0.2692214251,
0.0747891068,
0.0548952594,
0.5040847659,
1.2108798027,
-0.1633658707,
0.3633544445,
-0.5683919787,
-0.3317829072,
-0.3301096857,
-0.410264194,
-0.8015114665,
-1.124676466,
-0.3970168233,
-0.0474908687,
-0.2654547393,
0.9813790917,
0.8065688014,
-0.3755570948,
-0.1239404231,
0.5830974579,
0.0148300892,
-0.2251277715,
-0.1990478635,
-0.0142506743,
0.0844133794,
-0.5860522985,
0.0920568034,
0.3004764915,
0.2060337514,
-0.4860036969,
0.0173509587,
-0.1923592687,
0.0189083293,
0.9751440287,
0.350396663,
-0.8817283511,
-0.4790490866,
-0.4147037864,
0.0858021975,
-0.1826675236,
0.801748693,
-1.0660811663,
0.8812501431,
0.8405482769,
0.3040190637,
0.2344551384,
0.1093652025,
0.3407657743,
-0.6166401505,
0.2464238107,
0.2152330428,
0.2289016545,
0.1566845328,
-0.0789814144,
0.4452931881,
0.2973042428,
-0.2676811218,
-0.9306665659,
0.5181021094,
-1.1986538172,
-0.3877490163,
1.0822474957,
0.0719363019,
-0.0889354125,
-0.1795790941,
-0.2977846563,
0.1310165077,
-0.1327596903,
0.6832544804,
0.6385421157,
-0.5646698475,
-0.1964462101,
-0.0560047813,
0.4352828264,
0.2263251841,
-0.6520645618,
-0.2718898654,
0.7625242472,
0.1310441941,
0.8212407231,
0.5134711266,
0.1580287516,
0.4656846225,
0.0841985717,
0.2220807076,
-0.2585998774,
-0.1757497042,
-0.2594678998,
0.2525060773,
-0.2502306402,
-0.3901573718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04116v1 | Unbalanced Optimal Transport for Unbalanced Word Alignment | 2023-06-07T03:03:41 | 2023-06-07T03:03:41 | Yuki Arase, Han Bao, Sho Yokoi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Monolingual word alignment is crucial to model semantic interactions between
sentences. In particular, null alignment, a phenomenon in which words have no
corresponding counterparts, is pervasive and critical in handling semantically
divergent sentences. Identification of null alignment is useful on its own to
reason about the semantic similarity of sentences by indicating there exists
information inequality. To achieve unbalanced word alignment that values both
alignment and null alignment, this study shows that the family of optimal
transport (OT), i.e., balanced, partial, and unbalanced OT, are natural and
powerful approaches even without tailor-made techniques. Our extensive
experiments covering unsupervised and supervised settings indicate that our
generic OT-based alignment methods are competitive against the
state-of-the-arts specially designed for word alignment, remarkably on
challenging datasets with high null alignment frequencies. | [
-0.1726808846,
-0.6608865261,
0.6183134913,
0.181422621,
-0.3476632535,
-0.0629888028,
-0.0545748845,
-0.4267474413,
0.4136280417,
0.3996646404,
-0.6462272406,
-0.044245448,
-0.411822468,
0.0240130499,
-0.79763484,
0.978957653,
-0.0972131416,
-0.2377032489,
-0.283842206,
-0.8448099494,
-0.7758079767,
-0.0645314306,
-0.0659622177,
-0.3839633465,
0.4379372895,
0.4926519096,
1.2049196959,
0.8053482175,
0.4663414061,
0.363324672,
-0.0714189932,
-0.1692920029,
-0.4253771901,
0.068292357,
-0.5911974311,
-0.0709522516,
-0.153601706,
-0.2929368913,
0.6182430387,
1.5212892294,
-0.1145230532,
0.1819117069,
0.1747463048,
0.6624550223,
-0.7231197357,
-0.5064409971,
-0.6519486308,
0.1458238363,
-0.5894536376,
-0.5417507887,
0.0190697778,
-0.4473738968,
0.5583902001,
-0.8984071612,
-0.0696254149,
0.3608792424,
0.9513631463,
0.4438602328,
-0.9739916921,
-0.2248877287,
-0.7137961984,
0.7207201719,
-0.3451128006,
0.3163856566,
-0.2408679426,
-0.0762895495,
-0.3319445252,
-0.1898075789,
-0.5971837044,
0.2633287013,
0.0995261669,
0.396946907,
-0.2931555212,
0.0956223831,
-0.2275697291,
0.3196897209,
-0.7438393831,
0.358569622,
-0.3624979854,
-0.0895612687,
0.5497091413,
0.2120079547,
0.6679477096,
0.0614989698,
-0.7842486501,
0.1629102528,
-0.4157935977,
-0.0867803842,
0.5795115232,
0.3752849102,
-0.049071461,
1.0770068169,
-0.0939040333,
0.960274756,
0.0828062743,
0.0915733352,
0.2997845709,
-0.4888820648,
-0.0524312481,
0.5495018959,
0.7420466542,
0.5930975676,
0.1962922066,
-0.6591208577,
-0.154553026,
0.2504432499,
0.4219539762,
-0.1916696429,
0.340367943,
0.1762145609,
-0.2044902295,
-0.3905406296,
-0.0160057992,
-1.0367717743,
-0.2298870385,
-0.4456380308,
0.8086694479,
-0.2892331481,
-0.2084883898,
0.4890519381,
-0.3994823992,
0.3238851726,
0.092882067,
-0.9410235286,
0.334338963,
0.2910603583,
0.8807578683,
-0.5692697763,
-0.2498576343,
-0.2938694954,
0.2380659878,
-0.4434399605,
1.0797177553,
-0.3145392537,
-0.0096321655,
0.2492779195,
0.0175366662,
-0.1640640795,
-0.1400883794,
0.9446727037,
-0.2681985199,
0.6273159385,
-0.292639643,
-0.7483923435,
-0.0773430914,
-0.2220025063,
-0.358132422,
0.8102585077,
0.4084415436,
-1.0353927612,
0.4209256768,
-0.7600829601,
-0.8206656575,
0.0044479906,
0.2896932364,
-0.2343976051,
0.4098151028,
-0.1187602803,
0.0234362911,
-0.0547298715,
0.1394765228,
-0.5072430968,
-0.222631976,
-0.1530639082,
-0.2708033323,
0.8305100799,
0.2749710083,
-0.3307558894,
0.106496945,
-0.732311368,
0.0434821025,
0.1965425462,
-0.2345051914,
-0.8761924505,
0.1294222474,
0.2112004906,
0.0539418273,
0.2906568646,
-0.7864875197,
0.2186488807,
-0.6697840095,
0.3279837668,
1.025873065,
-0.3013217449,
0.9310612679,
-0.2286347151,
0.3577285707,
0.0355976857,
0.2198073417,
0.3920626044,
-0.2721216977,
-0.5477446318,
0.0860095322,
0.4160946906,
0.6083811522,
-0.5642933846,
0.7010951042,
-0.5793021321,
0.0536907613,
-0.7948771715,
0.0199340172,
-0.0300058424,
0.8332911134,
0.4237463772,
-0.1563030332,
-0.2744597197,
-1.0626214743,
-0.2423909605,
0.1714535952,
0.3417281508,
-0.1493293494,
0.0815077275,
-0.1318627149,
1.0595011711,
-0.4696133137,
-0.2907893062,
-0.0352765433,
0.1131655052,
-0.1082169339,
0.4177586436,
0.6759419441,
-0.7358935475,
-0.2348265201,
0.208216086,
-0.8548265696,
-0.5950541496,
-0.1436378956,
-0.7543987632,
0.181640625,
0.3675326705,
-0.5423563123,
0.4144744873,
0.6549851298,
-0.6812399626,
0.0415392816,
-0.4208388627,
-0.1160012707,
-0.9493956566,
0.1968978494,
-0.2319644392,
-0.4210135043,
-0.7276719809,
-0.1225299463,
-0.0376859047,
-0.0430586748,
-0.3177742362,
0.6210315228,
-0.6093431711,
-0.1577167958,
-0.5933740139,
0.5836245418,
-0.3171826303,
0.3229923844,
-0.1449185908,
0.40063712,
0.5300952196,
-0.4700631499,
0.1685543209,
0.4708961546,
-0.2025294602,
1.0266582966,
-0.5258694291,
-0.1377945691,
-0.4319657981,
-0.167259261,
-1.1562584639,
0.1879661083,
0.0948104113,
-0.0094562583,
0.3135195673,
0.1164774075,
-0.3237219155,
-0.2224355489,
-0.0936933309,
0.5554767847,
0.5354539752,
-0.5648328066,
0.4936627746,
0.6985573173,
-0.0820435733,
-0.6736071706,
-0.5961688757,
-0.0949696004,
-0.4010159075,
-0.8250716329,
0.4720676839,
0.1293495148,
0.0472052172,
0.3499781489,
-0.6953397393,
0.1269074231,
0.0462614037,
0.0620263293,
0.3895660341,
-0.251867801,
0.0702687055,
0.3630698025,
-0.2349479198,
-0.2758431733,
-0.7573074698,
0.2495865375,
0.1570093334,
-0.1948166043,
-0.2045461833,
0.5850925446,
0.8069942594,
0.0355199985,
0.7719498277,
0.3907451928,
-0.2381361723,
0.1756835431,
-0.4743040502,
0.3502873778,
-0.4546484351,
0.1819265187,
0.0293091703,
-0.7351436615,
0.1556632519,
0.0319266282,
0.2262304723,
0.4746998549,
0.0574945398,
-0.143793419,
1.0478025675,
0.8900179863,
-0.3174566627,
0.2701840401,
0.4464416504,
0.2772443593,
-0.7292259336,
0.0667830333,
-0.6469478607,
-0.5550221205,
-0.8134068847,
0.0205239318,
0.248889491,
-0.0314397924,
-0.3285960555,
0.3625943065,
-0.6095437407,
0.3712312877,
0.5428349972,
-0.138686344,
0.3201834559,
0.0945251063,
-0.5093085766,
0.209301427,
-0.8734117746,
-0.4246409237,
0.9210677743,
-0.1241410896,
0.8363952637,
0.1288963407,
0.3576399088,
0.1756633073,
0.1619847119,
-0.5196003914,
0.3770079613,
-0.3370222449,
-0.4874287248,
-0.4391541481,
-0.5528081059,
-1.4901410341,
0.365790844,
-0.4802968204,
-0.7870279551,
0.2119799107,
0.1319731176,
-0.2236913741,
0.3290201128,
-0.85745579,
1.0968178511,
-0.4940795898,
-0.3163692057,
0.1697502881,
-1.0312650204,
0.2279692739,
-0.1221688688,
0.1945905238,
-0.0721614882,
-0.2994413078,
0.5432835817,
-0.4163523018,
0.2226311117,
0.0434458219,
-0.0214765016,
-0.1937922537,
0.0312575698,
0.2449774742,
-0.6711368561,
0.308293432,
0.138033241,
0.1125579402,
-0.67139709,
-0.5444648862,
0.7814676762,
-0.797778964,
-0.2507378161,
-0.5346831679,
-0.5684203506,
-0.1466698647,
0.4800429344,
0.4860804081,
0.2431159168,
-0.1826391965,
-0.0220871642,
0.5268542767,
-0.1899629682,
0.5183611512,
0.585965395,
-0.0720636994,
-0.2045807838,
0.7914537191,
0.1987254918,
0.3598075509,
0.7613284588,
0.4366357028,
-0.662741363,
-0.5318143964,
-0.3630597889,
0.1416553259,
-0.3375780582,
-0.0427997597,
-0.7283553481,
0.0231632199,
-0.1455917656,
-0.4954049885,
-0.5474640727,
-0.6907297969,
-0.1683631837,
-0.1099982038,
0.0004321407,
0.3378059566,
-0.0696880296,
0.1777165085,
-0.4428475797,
0.3678202629,
0.1464561671,
0.3436468542,
-0.3250873089,
-0.6535276771,
0.216572687,
0.0572468303,
-0.4805763662,
-0.7764282227,
0.1191482544,
-0.0403613113,
0.625086844,
0.5595359802,
0.3744423687,
1.1429473162,
-0.7054206133,
0.3551062644,
0.4260438383,
-1.0802477598,
0.3833204806,
-0.2555966377,
0.3829776645,
0.5839428306,
0.3002769053,
-0.6545696259,
-0.6513541937,
-0.5635080338,
-1.251698494,
0.5365301967,
0.7168995142,
0.122825101,
0.1590493768,
0.0710098147,
0.1416431218,
0.190445289,
-0.7554502487,
-0.2033892125,
-0.2280550003,
-0.5808634162,
-0.0479538292,
0.2204721272,
0.0108001623,
0.0100104949,
0.5914936662,
0.0286355522,
0.0293318275,
0.3240909278,
-0.2462401837,
-0.3932875395,
0.285011977,
0.8538968563,
0.4472307861,
-0.2114534974,
0.238575086,
0.0370951854,
-0.2612208128,
0.482462585,
0.0361053944,
-0.3764180839,
0.1504485458,
0.2158147246,
0.62610811,
0.2628185749,
-0.6356710196,
0.7319933772,
0.1363334954,
-0.2000270635,
-0.2197102457,
-0.207623139,
-0.0743298233,
-0.0776421279,
0.0566129088,
0.4077159762,
0.0954642296,
-0.4117029309,
0.0068618869,
0.7708263993,
-0.5642142296,
-0.1633998305,
0.875536561,
0.3610430956,
-0.1698496789,
0.7176513672,
-0.0791671723,
-0.2712223232,
0.0182166174,
0.2964746058,
0.7781763673,
-0.1048705131,
0.0208995715,
0.0545590669,
0.5543864965,
-0.3420105875,
-0.0093178879,
0.1078310162,
-1.0344150066,
-0.0112874098,
-0.4558031261,
0.0292372163,
-0.2491078228,
-0.7306393981,
0.3024654388,
0.1556779444,
-0.0866953209,
0.0574076548,
-0.3723001778,
-0.4609847367,
-0.2453519106,
0.064570114,
0.6846850514,
-1.0178877115,
0.3074840903,
0.6307510138,
-0.2159270793,
-0.4125436246,
-0.0034916503,
0.1463828683,
-0.7194845676,
0.1023283899,
-0.0674588233,
-0.1315852255,
-0.1226853579,
-0.3586377501,
-1.0781391859,
0.717064023,
0.7217418551,
-0.4451495409,
-0.0383361056,
0.3297844827,
0.5335662961,
-0.1450131685,
0.1488431245,
0.1846277118,
0.5095229745,
0.026849905,
-0.9363967776,
0.1106064767,
-0.1214332804,
0.1781634092,
0.6135053039,
-0.6687594056,
0.2049093843,
0.0651768595,
-0.4357412457,
0.2528382838,
0.579954803,
-0.3121088743,
0.2188705057,
0.623165369,
0.8616474867,
0.7024821043,
-0.0961390883,
0.8778192997,
-0.1070632711,
0.1980675459,
0.9906027317,
-0.686281085,
0.4657093883,
0.8170953989,
0.1838055402,
0.0717594922,
0.3939635754,
0.2866344452,
0.6788432002,
0.2946435511,
-0.0367652886,
-0.2303799093,
-0.0455862358,
-0.1366014481,
0.45475474,
-0.2636221945,
0.2061047852,
-0.6352351904,
0.2513938248,
-0.0113245361,
0.0891884491,
-0.2177195847,
0.7706766129,
-0.2842460573,
-0.7998458743,
0.4832982421,
-0.1494448483,
0.7028502822,
-0.5666223168,
0.4006696045,
-0.4173991978,
0.1046971306,
-0.2322336435,
-0.9376215935,
0.4579902589,
-0.2690293491,
-0.0714162961,
-0.4436865151,
0.3841445744,
-0.5680549741,
-0.4288542271,
0.3300319314,
0.3386849761,
0.0172688141,
0.2920875847,
-0.4847214222,
-0.2718779445,
-0.0512449853,
-0.0207483619,
0.4641623795,
0.7912262082,
0.0410898328,
0.6749932766,
0.4629786313,
0.2211513072,
0.3534517288,
-0.2305502594,
0.5320436358,
-0.6188767552,
-0.5290405154,
-0.6052163839,
0.5674869418,
-0.1868546009,
-0.5794317722,
0.6255987287,
0.7791104317,
0.7751752734,
0.0460524075,
0.5932748318,
0.0362843983,
0.4372165203,
-0.6946191788,
0.1331213266,
-0.9939437509,
0.0907199755,
-0.5803352594,
-0.9370182753,
-0.0653882548,
0.6715850234,
0.0754774809,
-0.2677986324,
1.0960617065,
0.6203610897,
-0.5114303231,
0.2433551997,
0.169667244,
0.0339244641,
-0.1354851276,
0.6850065589,
0.894105494,
-0.4110184014,
0.4965902865,
-0.00832457,
-0.3156993091,
-0.012355567,
-1.0361446142,
-0.5479769111,
-0.5935665369,
-0.6897011995,
-0.2184438407,
0.2559442818,
0.9204921722,
0.7808010578,
-0.4451957345,
-0.3205296993,
-0.3313908875,
0.3507247865,
-0.2603745162,
-0.2440927327,
0.2226318866,
-0.3605824709,
-0.5191939473,
-0.0115560973,
0.7398516536,
0.3224588335,
0.2254215926,
0.2933877707,
-0.3095912039,
0.2267811894,
0.5127204657,
0.3542802632,
-0.4518347383,
-0.4013389051,
-0.0331888571,
-0.1422304809,
0.0233337097,
0.7232005,
-0.1514923722,
0.4089869559,
0.5672748089,
0.7051229477,
0.1282212138,
0.264613241,
0.749980092,
-0.5924100876,
0.3448927701,
0.1477029622,
0.443782866,
0.0303833187,
-0.3130909204,
0.4660343826,
0.5062333345,
-0.6154544353,
-0.8534132838,
-0.0526280031,
-1.5290402174,
-0.3630256951,
1.0601480007,
0.3673199713,
-0.3273126185,
-0.2418688387,
-0.1152800322,
0.2073304355,
-0.255561471,
0.7917315364,
0.7535827756,
-0.0772479698,
0.1576641649,
-0.5345387459,
0.1118384674,
0.6858856678,
-0.7968706489,
-0.1616907418,
0.3514733613,
0.3240328729,
0.0456446223,
0.4320532382,
-0.1778278649,
-0.1505587101,
-0.4048709273,
0.0007459001,
0.4133661091,
-0.1418596804,
-0.2562154531,
0.1587720513,
-0.4637899101,
-0.4204343855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04101v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04101v1 | Gotta: Generative Few-shot Question Answering by Prompt-based Cloze Data Augmentation | 2023-06-07T01:44:43 | 2023-06-07T01:44:43 | Xiusi Chen, Yu Zhang, Jinliang Deng, Jyun-Yu Jiang, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Few-shot question answering (QA) aims at precisely discovering answers to a
set of questions from context passages while only a few training samples are
available. Although existing studies have made some progress and can usually
achieve proper results, they suffer from understanding deep semantics for
reasoning out the questions. In this paper, we develop Gotta, a Generative
prOmpT-based daTa Augmentation framework to mitigate the challenge above.
Inspired by the human reasoning process, we propose to integrate the cloze task
to enhance few-shot QA learning. Following the recent success of prompt-tuning,
we present the cloze task in the same format as the main QA task, allowing the
model to learn both tasks seamlessly together to fully take advantage of the
power of prompt-tuning. Extensive experiments on widely used benchmarks
demonstrate that Gotta consistently outperforms competitive baselines,
validating the effectiveness of our proposed prompt-tuning-based cloze task,
which not only fine-tunes language models but also learns to guide reasoning in
QA tasks. Further analysis shows that the prompt-based loss incorporates the
auxiliary task better than the multi-task loss, highlighting the strength of
prompt-tuning on the few-shot QA task. | [
-0.4469624162,
-0.9411430955,
0.8985580206,
-0.1395172775,
-0.4361925721,
-0.2884497941,
-0.0794588178,
-0.2110891938,
-0.0877104923,
0.373755455,
-1.2336874008,
-0.594968915,
-0.2170420736,
0.4234519899,
0.1490891725,
0.8399487734,
0.5530567765,
0.0361167155,
-0.1771033555,
0.0470540673,
-1.1800142527,
0.0662204251,
-0.6654328108,
-0.0269394387,
0.4669232666,
0.8743475676,
0.5872122645,
0.4196859598,
0.1931796968,
0.2116456628,
0.0759625733,
0.2990122437,
-0.6636012197,
0.1280381829,
-0.0938166454,
-0.82966429,
-0.1722275913,
-0.1529893428,
0.4221791625,
0.5686945915,
0.0972821563,
0.2635914683,
-0.0039778776,
0.5508240461,
-0.5157851577,
0.0791480765,
-0.7596511841,
-0.1513786465,
-0.2443508208,
-0.1640318632,
-0.20824036,
-0.3877417147,
0.1697725505,
-0.9468185306,
0.2462430447,
0.1130897254,
0.8028883934,
0.6153272986,
-0.3246149123,
-0.0142721143,
-0.2042066604,
0.4797671735,
-0.7169527411,
0.1299136281,
0.2885915041,
0.4605216086,
-0.357771039,
-0.5680669546,
-0.7798185945,
-0.2333069146,
-0.0425165854,
0.1020565256,
-0.038780205,
0.2704056203,
0.5082436204,
0.2382474989,
-0.7460067868,
0.0424121842,
-0.1680267155,
-0.2842538059,
0.4601204097,
0.2774679661,
0.5026926398,
-0.1333933026,
-0.3658561707,
0.0776034445,
-0.8042714,
0.2068631351,
0.0835344344,
0.313305527,
-0.0196127165,
0.5287483335,
-0.43996647,
1.1334757805,
0.4403614998,
-0.0551946238,
0.0441738926,
-0.4421914816,
-0.2543148398,
-0.1742325872,
0.421923995,
0.4359493554,
0.1208073497,
-0.203653425,
0.2433618307,
-0.0423038416,
0.0702164695,
-0.7479851842,
-0.3144078255,
0.2681831419,
0.1263526231,
0.1738791168,
-0.1754982919,
-0.6312831044,
-0.4529871047,
-0.5232439041,
0.5518326759,
-0.6179199815,
0.2114144713,
0.0186410248,
-0.4358749986,
0.4701194167,
0.3712706268,
-0.6612153053,
-0.1007469073,
0.7428292036,
0.694036901,
0.1857143044,
-0.3447297215,
-1.07282722,
-0.2746134996,
-0.359280169,
1.0144490004,
-0.4804649651,
-0.2769006193,
-0.216865018,
0.0047066053,
-0.0521639846,
-0.3845538199,
0.5477214456,
-0.7164907455,
0.4785995781,
-0.512947917,
-0.8734835386,
-0.1556171775,
0.4297068417,
-0.5089946985,
0.7766771913,
0.3203373253,
-0.400749892,
0.5500952601,
-0.5967386961,
-0.1425744891,
0.4787838161,
-0.0386343747,
-0.2450253814,
0.1141560376,
0.4007490873,
0.2911764383,
-0.1876666099,
0.0240783803,
-0.2961019278,
-0.5160649419,
0.0722210854,
-0.2144209445,
0.9081524611,
-0.0438100882,
-0.0752782375,
0.1578415185,
-0.589977622,
0.4582002461,
-0.0370122902,
0.0116138598,
-0.0806240961,
-0.6387252808,
-0.3346228302,
0.168823719,
0.1217300892,
-0.5318157673,
0.5508677363,
-0.8244624138,
0.2244190574,
0.4374341369,
0.3037512898,
0.7226850986,
-0.370121181,
0.6492351294,
-0.0420354716,
0.174819991,
-0.2810848653,
-0.7926028967,
-0.3350685239,
-0.3462155759,
0.2225240022,
0.8157202601,
-1.0095616579,
0.3464159966,
-0.1460995227,
-0.3375840783,
-0.7920018435,
0.5718892813,
0.094457604,
0.9137443304,
0.492390424,
-0.0137233147,
-0.4566994905,
-0.6946545839,
-0.1273946017,
-0.0590188205,
-0.3383359313,
0.1784499586,
0.2433075607,
0.0650795549,
1.4502943754,
-0.6113280654,
-0.5467727184,
-0.4864085317,
0.0201653522,
0.3322329223,
0.3748522401,
0.5433320999,
-0.60771209,
-0.4734607935,
-0.3397270441,
-0.5728521347,
-0.2591680586,
-0.3105967045,
-0.1800932884,
-0.3640405238,
0.1813794822,
-0.8633724451,
0.3248277307,
0.0255763549,
-0.2695898712,
0.760543406,
-0.0229997598,
0.1293945163,
-0.8869456649,
-0.163868472,
-0.2523101568,
-0.258430779,
-0.6974580288,
0.0817679092,
0.0362055749,
-0.3343481421,
-0.5496624112,
0.8020832539,
-0.2882311642,
0.086865671,
-0.6065462828,
0.3113875687,
0.4145647585,
0.5311101079,
0.002694902,
1.0388953686,
0.8561760783,
-0.7704238296,
0.4762046337,
0.5561718941,
-0.2507755458,
0.9574689865,
-0.762468636,
0.4766725302,
-0.4695045352,
0.2729483247,
-0.8484835029,
-0.4069831967,
0.3671394587,
-0.6151035428,
0.061831899,
-0.4675554037,
-0.4374388158,
-0.3619298637,
-0.367731899,
0.1989052147,
0.5632992983,
-0.5830448866,
0.4358126223,
-0.1215102449,
-0.0487234965,
-0.4289183319,
-0.4840131104,
0.1224746704,
-0.3681745827,
-0.869515419,
0.2421230823,
-0.3663636446,
0.0385312214,
-0.0943023562,
-0.0214356203,
-0.2847562432,
0.2831825018,
0.0633441359,
0.2161335647,
-0.4323509634,
0.5615701675,
0.0650470778,
-0.1983088255,
-0.2252480537,
-0.4410225451,
0.3493323624,
-0.0539981984,
-0.1947288364,
-0.7911219001,
0.394187212,
0.0645550638,
-0.0509679765,
0.524933219,
0.721470356,
-0.0941119865,
-0.3413650692,
-0.4726895392,
-0.640617311,
-0.4293444753,
0.0705356598,
-0.5185086727,
-0.8870405555,
0.3803665638,
-0.120024763,
0.1154194549,
0.2765637636,
0.3280612528,
-0.5309994221,
0.6704086661,
0.5718120337,
-0.1058097184,
0.323418498,
-0.2076958865,
0.1363384873,
-0.6016919613,
0.0548391566,
-0.3331490159,
-0.2762280703,
-0.2259623855,
-0.2875148952,
0.8857833147,
0.4124648273,
-0.2211643904,
0.2528933287,
-0.3351676762,
0.7605136037,
0.7421749234,
0.3796132207,
0.2683853209,
-0.3789508045,
0.3191118836,
0.2273292243,
-0.9937266707,
-0.4524420202,
0.9580803514,
-0.0364110991,
0.4173939526,
0.0154057601,
0.7917814851,
0.2626950741,
-0.0782481432,
-0.8407540917,
0.5258719921,
0.2244216055,
-0.7500286102,
-0.5486927629,
-0.1160389781,
-0.8637535572,
0.1729626209,
-0.1423588991,
-0.6978215575,
0.2545415163,
0.527723968,
-0.9320444465,
-0.088633202,
-0.8738514185,
1.0298383236,
0.0772341192,
-0.4654271305,
-0.019197559,
-0.9724983573,
0.5250740647,
0.5195017457,
-0.2391562909,
-0.0878774375,
0.1026115417,
0.3511969447,
-0.6030294299,
1.0594483614,
-0.3538535535,
0.0626975372,
0.7485182881,
-0.0884226263,
0.7113559842,
0.4975126386,
0.0366702899,
-0.070814833,
-0.0378012694,
-0.7616069913,
-0.9608446956,
0.4096051753,
-0.29934147,
-0.8109951019,
-0.1348871589,
-0.4587648213,
-0.465785563,
0.0670939982,
0.5441679955,
0.4251998067,
-0.1245159805,
-0.1912702173,
0.8234202266,
0.0534147136,
0.3365291953,
0.4166731834,
0.2225750536,
-0.1770897955,
0.6484701633,
-0.3063703477,
0.2529803514,
0.2680267394,
0.2756954134,
-0.5406558514,
-0.3828540444,
-0.981515348,
0.1380136162,
-0.7656818628,
-0.452801764,
-0.4508355558,
0.2373403907,
-0.4033465087,
-0.2082448602,
0.0168205611,
-0.1623060703,
-0.5973528624,
-0.1416270733,
0.5835694075,
0.0794748962,
-0.0895255655,
0.7985161543,
-0.883074522,
0.613179028,
0.7577311993,
0.0975187048,
-0.3208642006,
-0.6244138479,
0.1112436801,
0.1654996723,
-0.0801185519,
-1.0627889633,
0.1938097328,
0.3741079271,
0.3388134241,
0.2871854007,
0.079951942,
0.7436745167,
-0.4302778244,
0.9081757665,
0.1580257416,
-0.8247029185,
0.6221426129,
-0.1722228974,
0.6666772366,
1.0648882389,
0.0349296704,
-0.3993182182,
0.0517781749,
-0.4046220481,
-0.4438373446,
0.6199068427,
0.1061683297,
0.2279067636,
-0.0949935615,
0.3914315104,
0.4150943458,
0.2062634975,
-0.4339815676,
-0.1181685254,
-0.3058209717,
-0.2051590681,
0.2367085516,
-0.1455219686,
-0.0633379817,
-0.080154106,
0.6155347228,
-0.5733370781,
0.0717387125,
0.2769410908,
-0.5046467185,
0.1828748137,
0.7509225607,
0.3951215148,
0.3421161175,
-0.1512271613,
-0.1123050153,
0.2905291021,
-0.1676132083,
0.1129932776,
-0.0110638058,
-0.4885843992,
-0.084802337,
0.321841687,
0.9978016019,
0.0040303217,
-0.7360278368,
0.5330328345,
0.178724587,
0.0586907156,
0.0429303236,
0.3430624604,
-0.133949697,
0.1522722095,
0.4506114721,
-0.0674433857,
0.3309647143,
-0.4645474255,
0.4282307923,
0.5094364285,
-0.2522329092,
-0.4201551974,
0.4433899522,
0.3127969205,
-0.0871320888,
0.6313599348,
-0.7003994584,
-0.4670426846,
0.7536027431,
0.3942011595,
0.8621319532,
0.1539663523,
0.5064879656,
0.5647207499,
0.3716787696,
0.0812758654,
0.482873112,
-0.3479893506,
-0.5601017475,
-0.5687048435,
-0.2306093723,
-0.1889150143,
0.066868335,
-0.2533327043,
0.3357381821,
-0.2975843549,
-0.1423178166,
-0.1428341717,
-0.0518032424,
-1.0731582642,
0.1825760454,
0.0606820509,
0.7556355596,
-0.8019629121,
0.4550149441,
0.5340131521,
-0.6526563764,
-0.6434349418,
0.1225166768,
0.1197549626,
-0.7405224442,
0.6447789669,
0.1988298446,
-0.0839915797,
0.4524040222,
-0.7863450646,
-0.7033076286,
0.950894177,
0.4241330326,
-0.6250616908,
-0.1152244657,
-0.0036452811,
0.4095770419,
-0.1973857284,
0.4931074679,
0.6433976889,
0.6779407263,
0.0174941067,
-0.748916328,
-0.1305864006,
0.1157965958,
-0.2753733993,
-0.2038487792,
-0.4479002357,
0.3489251435,
-0.6710941792,
-0.6399019361,
0.2989419401,
0.7699968815,
0.3182689548,
0.7361623645,
0.5026541352,
0.4472689927,
0.8817479014,
-0.0542386696,
1.0642931461,
-0.0292767864,
0.0081057567,
1.3828072548,
-0.2968622744,
0.282423526,
0.2330811173,
-0.1663346589,
0.499127388,
0.4999063015,
0.1930299848,
0.5320330262,
0.1338840276,
-0.3526090384,
-0.6274421215,
-0.2170383334,
-0.1685885638,
0.4335491955,
0.2836197317,
0.3136992157,
-0.6084330082,
0.3488968909,
-0.2512770295,
0.133554399,
-0.3907201886,
1.0616117716,
0.0844353661,
-0.6834754348,
0.6237362623,
-0.4170283675,
0.5661582947,
-0.5955795646,
-0.1640501469,
-0.4057510197,
-0.5202934146,
-0.1641598642,
-0.6949418187,
0.0472712964,
-0.0341090299,
-0.3505222797,
0.1716021746,
0.7837581038,
-0.5467450619,
-0.2040849477,
-0.4232106209,
0.8103755116,
-0.0119611518,
-0.3857168555,
-0.656001687,
-0.3855139017,
-0.1555356383,
0.0059896121,
0.1555169374,
0.4872547984,
0.056733273,
0.7878861427,
0.5538808703,
-0.280266583,
0.2277053297,
0.1807226539,
0.7391889095,
-0.6782239079,
-0.7299265265,
-0.6957492232,
0.6241156459,
-0.1422864795,
-0.4393724799,
0.6529071331,
0.2969342768,
0.395190537,
-0.372004956,
0.6619010568,
-0.0591831356,
0.5294350386,
-0.7523331046,
0.1667409539,
-0.3290778697,
0.1810869426,
0.2205119133,
-0.6360929608,
-0.1506638825,
0.029738022,
-0.3276418447,
-0.0966060758,
0.6407113671,
0.9756703973,
0.0052496092,
-0.0692729205,
0.504804194,
-0.036537461,
0.0515222512,
0.8103117347,
0.7013832331,
-0.4264187217,
0.3522029817,
-0.2249071598,
-0.0029909092,
-0.1640574187,
-0.7665070891,
-0.8153515458,
-0.551061511,
-0.3889915645,
0.0015300332,
0.1703403443,
0.9892689586,
0.6901779175,
-0.7298080325,
0.4874593019,
-0.3050334454,
0.44799155,
-0.47350353,
-0.2986938357,
0.4209245145,
-0.7769861817,
-0.775752604,
0.921595633,
0.2541604638,
-0.1047527567,
0.0085758315,
0.161071822,
0.0085706608,
-0.1003538221,
0.553340435,
0.6205327511,
-0.730491519,
-0.2902288735,
0.2627483606,
0.0107927779,
0.1618197411,
0.7673926353,
-1.3181034327,
0.5422740579,
0.5805939436,
0.945356667,
0.0691047683,
0.3644854128,
0.4330639839,
-1.1130642891,
-0.0255040005,
0.4259341061,
0.0019370639,
0.3439018726,
-0.6193645,
0.3455178738,
0.2386557162,
-0.3697723746,
-0.5429090261,
0.3434991539,
-1.2668550014,
-0.306491673,
0.9976905584,
-0.0475112423,
-0.1838540733,
-0.4379728734,
-0.5019330978,
0.0646329597,
-0.5735263824,
0.669565022,
0.4576917589,
-0.1925047636,
-0.423689127,
-0.4303905964,
0.7395167947,
0.5494139194,
-1.0411602259,
-0.1006942168,
0.913936615,
0.3885240853,
-0.123648271,
0.7301560044,
0.4688997269,
0.9163039327,
-0.2324708104,
-0.1769317985,
-0.3062499166,
-0.1983870566,
-0.4746895432,
0.3643833697,
0.0788659379,
-0.3895256221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04085v1 | XSemPLR: Cross-Lingual Semantic Parsing in Multiple Natural Languages and Meaning Representations | 2023-06-07T01:09:37 | 2023-06-07T01:09:37 | Yusen Zhang, Jun Wang, Zhiguo Wang, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-Lingual Semantic Parsing (CLSP) aims to translate queries in multiple
natural languages (NLs) into meaning representations (MRs) such as SQL, lambda
calculus, and logic forms. However, existing CLSP models are separately
proposed and evaluated on datasets of limited tasks and applications, impeding
a comprehensive and unified evaluation of CLSP on a diverse range of NLs and
MRs. To this end, we present XSemPLR, a unified benchmark for cross-lingual
semantic parsing featured with 22 natural languages and 8 meaning
representations by examining and selecting 9 existing datasets to cover 5 tasks
and 164 domains. We use XSemPLR to conduct a comprehensive benchmark study on a
wide range of multilingual language models including encoder-based models
(mBERT, XLM-R), encoder-decoder models (mBART, mT5), and decoder-based models
(Codex, BLOOM). We design 6 experiment settings covering various lingual
combinations (monolingual, multilingual, cross-lingual) and numbers of learning
samples (full dataset, few-shot, and zero-shot). Our experiments show that
encoder-decoder models (mT5) achieve the highest performance compared with
other popular models, and multilingual training can further improve the average
performance. Notably, multilingual large language models (e.g., BLOOM) are
still inadequate to perform CLSP tasks. We also find that the performance gap
between monolingual training and cross-lingual transfer learning is still
significant for multilingual models, though it can be mitigated by
cross-lingual few-shot training. Our dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/psunlpgroup/XSemPLR. | [
-0.4019517303,
-0.1005707085,
0.1411562562,
0.2542875707,
-0.327308774,
0.0181146525,
-0.3158814013,
-0.5606670976,
-0.1296811551,
0.4256573319,
-0.4680384994,
-0.3743564487,
-0.5825320482,
0.2098258585,
-0.4007349312,
0.5393788218,
0.0644638762,
0.7091130018,
-0.0288782604,
-0.3585008383,
-0.3387625515,
-0.6284089088,
-0.6361900568,
-0.1946847439,
0.5152880549,
0.1942554712,
0.4327605963,
0.5809995532,
0.5494086146,
0.2171992958,
-0.1255766302,
0.2162273228,
-0.4620840847,
-0.0090788975,
-0.6295220852,
-0.387652874,
-0.0094762947,
-0.3666269481,
0.9939597845,
1.0199477673,
0.0974086896,
0.179959029,
0.0198783036,
0.3969396949,
-0.6605449319,
-0.0107981749,
-0.6388917565,
0.3007619083,
-0.398031503,
0.0704519451,
-0.5161037445,
0.0782881752,
0.170112133,
-0.3638009429,
0.085418798,
0.38120538,
0.6511761546,
-0.1528091431,
-0.3941314518,
-0.31161955,
-0.3479344249,
1.1101574898,
-0.6551041007,
1.0485341549,
0.0417123325,
0.5544517636,
0.1742675453,
-0.6454098821,
-0.3147711754,
-0.0683121532,
-0.1370986849,
-0.0395185873,
-0.16224204,
-0.3015384376,
0.2289539278,
0.304007709,
-0.8915278316,
-0.0178453941,
-0.1570837349,
-0.0349398144,
0.4700646698,
0.377374649,
0.3145741224,
-0.1780420691,
-0.6847694516,
-0.3722684085,
-0.6949975491,
0.2440412939,
0.0150354821,
0.5090534091,
-0.1177920997,
0.5100194216,
-0.0192566998,
0.7421249151,
-0.5437512994,
-0.1800206751,
0.2237792462,
-0.5667305589,
-0.0712834671,
0.189115867,
0.6914464235,
0.3975222707,
0.2443706542,
-0.1253584921,
-0.1455596834,
0.2543537319,
-0.2716634572,
-0.5724766254,
-0.0581733584,
-0.2216650844,
-0.2335453331,
0.2220940441,
-0.0123179238,
-0.8729789853,
-0.153881073,
-0.2865065336,
0.0139861237,
-0.5818223953,
-0.3866012692,
0.5585224032,
-0.2516628206,
0.5237750411,
-0.0991819203,
-0.6794289947,
0.6937021017,
0.6811893582,
0.6580386162,
-0.2855704427,
-0.6334655285,
-0.5162938833,
0.3247172832,
-0.2069045156,
0.7280135751,
-0.6951215267,
-0.342081964,
-0.1860499531,
0.1014698297,
-0.3889255822,
-0.5466219783,
0.7165620923,
-0.34678635,
0.0112781767,
-0.6732032299,
-0.6448252797,
-0.0394450054,
0.4719984829,
-0.703124404,
1.0650448799,
0.0256500766,
-0.7069618106,
0.4871148467,
-0.6214202046,
-0.4617395103,
0.0088335844,
-0.2158091813,
-0.0725497305,
0.0486944616,
0.0864684209,
0.2833519578,
-0.4885308146,
-0.016788803,
-0.270288527,
-0.0414451957,
0.1686470062,
-0.2384323478,
0.8482910991,
0.0380778573,
-0.3347593248,
-0.0517718233,
-0.8739880919,
0.4028306305,
0.2326980382,
-0.0443388671,
-0.4859277308,
-0.1597639769,
0.1216589734,
0.8103816509,
-0.0790988877,
-0.9909897447,
-0.2258752882,
-0.4935145974,
0.3151072264,
0.3421062529,
-0.3520976901,
0.2015998513,
-0.1045723706,
0.227851674,
0.279381901,
-0.1857977808,
-0.3891401887,
-0.4199904799,
-0.6570294499,
-0.2804861665,
0.2181008011,
0.4976121783,
-0.4239513278,
-0.0023310483,
-0.5632808208,
-0.3439091742,
-0.6757235527,
0.3267869055,
0.8597015738,
0.5570581555,
0.5286595821,
-0.2834484875,
-0.7471562028,
-0.7167707086,
-0.53929317,
0.1385174692,
0.1468335241,
0.0703796521,
0.4696232975,
-0.1196233928,
0.7820745111,
-0.2566296458,
-0.4698395431,
-0.6924467683,
-0.02741942,
-0.1774013042,
0.3227730691,
0.5899866223,
-0.7368488908,
-0.8053477407,
0.4593658149,
-0.420945704,
-0.1352469027,
0.0784487575,
-0.1875684708,
0.4673016071,
0.1183474511,
-0.501897037,
0.3083159626,
0.5855373144,
-0.4337843657,
0.5005592704,
-0.0152820898,
0.1515487581,
-0.573888123,
0.336846441,
-0.0581388846,
-0.5407412648,
-0.5929834843,
0.2587404549,
0.2396248281,
-0.2928781509,
-0.8268092871,
0.9082733989,
-0.56800282,
-0.5363000631,
-0.0496126227,
0.3665657043,
0.4636203349,
0.3922120631,
0.4600901306,
0.5758569241,
0.5065335035,
-0.2578417659,
0.2796165943,
0.2486609817,
-0.3527090847,
0.398293376,
-0.7193453312,
-0.2794989944,
0.1104619801,
-0.0248216335,
-0.8687606454,
0.1046987772,
0.1010329202,
-0.2652522027,
0.1633771956,
-0.0504453667,
-0.6827216744,
-0.2113161981,
-0.208287403,
0.4506934583,
0.3385108113,
-0.5601472259,
0.4780567884,
0.2641693354,
-0.0263376255,
-0.2916688919,
-0.986574173,
0.1603985578,
0.1232857704,
-0.8889288902,
0.3635019362,
0.1402061582,
-0.116452992,
0.1100424305,
-0.0400019623,
-0.0397183634,
-0.3359203041,
-0.2018474936,
-0.0122134574,
-0.3460955024,
-0.2824812233,
-0.0114826942,
-0.3431541026,
0.1294634193,
-0.1733003408,
0.6749523282,
-0.2352683842,
-0.7303715944,
-0.0245711766,
0.7908597589,
0.4707205594,
-0.6145364642,
0.4727668762,
0.4820422828,
-0.1725278795,
-0.2924245596,
-0.3310268223,
0.1362972111,
-0.3438894749,
0.1953199208,
-0.6199951768,
-0.8797344565,
0.580837369,
0.1144440919,
0.1238284782,
0.2330584228,
0.5819171667,
0.3366225064,
1.2390854359,
0.4497125447,
-0.0289461371,
-0.0173516348,
-0.1714868695,
0.1129639894,
-0.574669838,
-0.1211631224,
-0.3590069115,
-0.0058098077,
-0.3242835999,
-0.5536788702,
0.1151181906,
-0.184893325,
-0.1272160262,
0.4202688932,
-0.1383336931,
0.6354323626,
0.5589826107,
-0.2769165635,
0.3989714086,
-0.057359308,
-0.5421614647,
-0.2469770163,
-0.7482832074,
-0.2782020271,
0.6921417117,
0.0681984052,
0.7088341713,
0.0540575311,
0.4835231006,
-0.0040426734,
-0.2928801179,
-0.5033233762,
0.7144181728,
-0.4843331575,
-0.4755844772,
0.0335441977,
-0.4380216599,
-0.8403210044,
0.7737064958,
0.1277183741,
-0.4388187528,
0.1966546625,
-0.0463528149,
-0.1287881583,
0.5667031407,
-0.5761464238,
1.2365961075,
-0.6144998074,
-0.3565306365,
-0.174574092,
-1.059813261,
0.4311696291,
-0.0065339822,
0.2263738066,
-0.3591370285,
-0.1700322479,
0.3822216392,
-0.2750361264,
0.7675305009,
-0.1617884189,
-0.0248442739,
0.0643328056,
-0.0107701281,
0.1468716711,
-0.1635387242,
-0.2748937309,
0.4284648895,
0.4266767502,
-0.4210469723,
-0.422395587,
0.6466609836,
-0.5831274986,
-0.1663933396,
-0.4595337808,
-0.5100467801,
-0.1782257706,
0.5174683928,
0.2400096953,
0.5440929532,
-0.2070866972,
-0.0062578209,
0.6908197403,
-0.1906896234,
0.3544602692,
0.5519354343,
-0.5457664132,
-0.5016963482,
0.8957274556,
0.0985929221,
0.5087717175,
0.5950900316,
0.1815841198,
-0.3978678882,
-0.1649603993,
-0.6869133115,
0.1394072473,
-0.8817024827,
-0.188508004,
-0.6959565878,
-0.043759089,
-0.7521954179,
-0.2065483928,
-0.4903849661,
-0.4381633699,
0.0883247927,
0.2473740727,
-0.0619224757,
0.1600689143,
-0.0915618911,
0.1718910933,
-1.1218855381,
0.4859179258,
-0.1729646027,
0.4163914025,
-0.1715475023,
-0.365190804,
-0.2835567594,
0.1822735071,
0.0039029014,
-0.6699196696,
0.6520119309,
0.6187357306,
0.7574819326,
0.4409486055,
0.0624546073,
0.9830256701,
-0.7598329186,
0.6071839333,
0.243762061,
-1.1059830189,
0.3630076349,
0.0440686978,
0.5016188025,
0.4653142095,
0.5445235968,
-0.9749925137,
-0.1789943874,
-0.2032238245,
-0.5460782051,
0.70899266,
-0.1224171743,
-0.0712630227,
-0.1570668072,
-0.1668285877,
0.3051668108,
0.0038622352,
-0.7489232421,
-0.0368547589,
-0.2960431874,
-0.0102805002,
0.1143838391,
-0.2608328462,
0.0669727102,
-0.4215108454,
0.5171433687,
-0.1067521498,
0.0045653181,
0.0687992945,
-0.4950544238,
-0.0564708076,
0.2589573562,
0.570940733,
0.6320076585,
0.0232605711,
0.3226981759,
0.275162369,
-0.199171409,
0.1305368394,
0.2001219392,
0.1801904887,
0.2817382812,
0.4556181133,
0.7199746966,
0.755847156,
-1.1951802969,
0.5227283835,
-0.0414210446,
0.0545160286,
-0.0377851278,
-0.0805175602,
-0.0209853984,
0.0075382632,
0.0229626987,
-0.1886103749,
0.1956315935,
-0.3487595618,
0.3398667574,
0.3856397271,
-0.1899387091,
-0.5401714444,
0.5103122592,
-0.0733610913,
0.276689887,
0.4081219435,
-0.3473621607,
-0.8026953936,
0.129226625,
0.7198870778,
0.7109879851,
-0.3002721369,
-0.0822597295,
0.3385662138,
0.2739799023,
0.0198209826,
0.4890733957,
-0.1490398496,
-0.656462729,
-0.4874770045,
-0.7402895689,
-0.5631918311,
-0.4906195402,
-0.6968957186,
0.4508851469,
-0.1215520203,
0.2391058803,
0.0163598582,
0.093401283,
-0.5410571098,
0.1324513555,
0.4064311683,
1.334327817,
-0.8279863596,
1.0658720732,
0.8656480908,
-0.2258690447,
-0.4870826006,
-0.5785169005,
0.0765283406,
-0.8284484744,
0.9338771105,
0.2670052648,
-0.3016212285,
-0.1211345196,
0.006476,
-1.0209664106,
0.7828050852,
0.5223150849,
-0.6027383208,
-0.0665922835,
1.0890204906,
0.42956236,
-0.3721666038,
-0.0127396574,
0.6725212932,
0.3990694284,
0.2406688482,
-0.8033095598,
-0.1330185384,
-0.3829100132,
0.2620259523,
0.4179220796,
-0.3664223552,
0.798535645,
0.1182468012,
-0.3349009752,
0.0477691889,
0.5704872012,
0.3460635245,
0.2772159576,
0.350366354,
0.9861849546,
0.4414085746,
-0.0397681706,
0.9533210993,
-0.648167491,
0.2410844117,
1.2457675934,
-0.8426870704,
0.9939924479,
0.4470536411,
-0.1023710594,
0.2778816819,
0.4532035887,
-0.0016043335,
0.6236561537,
0.0820997134,
-0.2712442577,
-0.3655747473,
-0.1067060679,
-0.3681561947,
0.4001197517,
0.3866961896,
-0.3270013034,
-0.8956418037,
0.4215288162,
-0.076926209,
-0.1006991044,
-0.3430963159,
0.548971355,
0.2310029417,
-0.467237711,
0.549821794,
0.0357951224,
0.472533375,
-0.9481387138,
-0.0305874329,
-0.1628869623,
0.4463362396,
-0.0502036884,
-1.0042763948,
0.6484804749,
0.0297806058,
-0.1424371302,
-0.3755061924,
0.9541472793,
-0.5954525471,
-0.6349695325,
0.7473697662,
0.4121258557,
0.1071980819,
0.0891765505,
-0.9111827016,
0.4894778728,
-0.172122702,
-0.1247344315,
0.460960567,
0.6186211109,
-0.2203727067,
0.6789426804,
0.5924620032,
0.1051522419,
0.6462160945,
0.0551275574,
0.9741256237,
-0.823556602,
-0.492479831,
-0.8568328619,
0.4621896148,
-0.056916669,
-0.4408178627,
1.143124342,
0.8496416807,
1.3584535122,
0.0752042979,
0.5776795745,
0.0000952802,
0.7745307684,
-0.3469799757,
0.3939376771,
-0.5336580276,
0.1207601503,
-0.2220538706,
-0.6177684665,
-0.6135405302,
0.3452672362,
-0.2708544135,
-0.1865761429,
0.5304697156,
0.6387777328,
-0.3708174825,
0.1217803508,
0.7079917789,
-0.2284519523,
0.141298607,
0.5785253048,
0.8310315013,
-0.1995840371,
0.6169600487,
-0.5703502297,
0.0759929121,
-0.0103640389,
-0.8367637396,
-0.6873323321,
-0.3231682181,
-0.0964244306,
0.0842131227,
0.1476705968,
0.9485995173,
0.744505465,
-0.8767514825,
-0.5789117813,
0.0715529546,
-0.0926747993,
-0.4153404236,
-0.165600419,
0.1137874573,
-0.7316556573,
-0.559152782,
0.4446363747,
0.409968853,
-0.3020806611,
-0.4015733004,
-0.1630351841,
-0.3298377991,
-0.1264552623,
0.9268664122,
0.3772019446,
-0.7421369553,
0.0679886863,
0.2129972875,
-0.1645457,
0.2294415087,
0.8729059696,
-0.6325092912,
0.3967968225,
0.6154883504,
0.9428327084,
0.3593590856,
-0.4362654388,
0.3586556911,
-0.7141699195,
-0.1026415452,
0.110532105,
0.7469623089,
0.4388978779,
0.1342338175,
0.5512157679,
0.2615892291,
-0.2961767316,
-0.9611103535,
0.1325965673,
-0.9541318417,
-0.2248213142,
0.997918427,
-0.520801723,
-0.4202047884,
-0.1384323388,
-0.1604321152,
-0.1505950093,
0.0163154844,
-0.016423285,
0.4903859794,
-0.2134540528,
-0.5331754088,
-0.4268728495,
0.0984535515,
0.6050579548,
-0.6974281073,
0.4043742716,
0.465198338,
0.2656334043,
0.1106188968,
0.2507228851,
-0.309465915,
0.4191555977,
-0.0357682295,
0.0630953535,
0.200561747,
-0.3097948432,
-0.4044461846,
0.1585691571,
-0.1296119243,
-0.0194467437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04076v1 | Text-only Domain Adaptation using Unified Speech-Text Representation in Transducer | 2023-06-07T00:33:02 | 2023-06-07T00:33:02 | Lu Huang, Boyu Li, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Domain adaptation using text-only corpus is challenging in end-to-end(E2E)
speech recognition. Adaptation by synthesizing audio from text through TTS is
resource-consuming. We present a method to learn Unified Speech-Text
Representation in Conformer Transducer(USTR-CT) to enable fast domain
adaptation using the text-only corpus. Different from the previous textogram
method, an extra text encoder is introduced in our work to learn text
representation and is removed during inference, so there is no modification for
online deployment. To improve the efficiency of adaptation, single-step and
multi-step adaptations are also explored. The experiments on adapting
LibriSpeech to SPGISpeech show the proposed method reduces the word error
rate(WER) by relatively 44% on the target domain, which is better than those of
TTS method and textogram method. Also, it is shown the proposed method can be
combined with internal language model estimation(ILME) to further improve the
performance. | [
-0.1248102933,
-0.4874457717,
0.3836496472,
-0.1455495656,
-0.7962258458,
0.1213597432,
-0.5686427951,
-0.4515890181,
-0.0508851297,
0.4421498179,
-0.364654541,
-0.4073888659,
-0.7686678171,
0.2296919823,
-0.0493993722,
0.845156312,
0.1146460027,
0.0532545224,
0.0513776727,
-0.238381803,
-0.5638641715,
-0.6051653028,
-0.7531971931,
-0.3417285681,
-0.0660990849,
0.2136697024,
0.1446071863,
0.3918620944,
0.256693989,
0.2289506048,
-0.1443722695,
0.1237574816,
-0.4651308656,
0.2430437356,
-0.3003878891,
-0.0829088762,
-0.2560203373,
-0.4012818336,
0.747885406,
0.5443426967,
-0.1490438133,
0.0707554594,
0.2134275436,
0.4445726573,
-0.7004285455,
0.101488702,
-0.823312819,
-0.0058466243,
-0.2385727465,
-0.4552310407,
-0.9109274149,
-0.1270557791,
0.4675399065,
-0.8399453163,
0.0646131858,
-0.1766314059,
0.3302759528,
0.2640780509,
-0.6520836353,
-0.2113662958,
-0.9642318487,
0.6916674376,
-0.4303710461,
0.8998535872,
0.1406854838,
0.2619496286,
-0.0211138502,
-0.941552639,
-0.2866902947,
-0.0922136828,
0.1745349765,
0.4239052236,
-0.2329709679,
-0.0795689523,
0.0516795889,
-0.2242937088,
-0.6588215232,
-0.0903017074,
-0.5131396651,
-0.5582639575,
0.4718461931,
-0.3118667901,
-0.0121689569,
0.3090070784,
-0.6826864481,
-0.4032740593,
-0.4607650936,
-0.0449840426,
-0.3887822628,
0.5187299848,
0.0718313232,
0.0655852035,
0.5698332191,
0.5214741826,
0.1174945384,
-0.1416104287,
0.3176705837,
0.2322426289,
-0.3178966939,
0.4766188264,
0.6503939629,
-0.0177726392,
0.2428128272,
-0.1332116425,
-0.1665405035,
-0.0453029834,
0.3080010712,
-0.5575721264,
0.1836015433,
0.0103303054,
-0.0883379728,
0.5249173641,
0.177204296,
-0.8089184761,
-0.548899591,
-0.1185203493,
0.7388339043,
-0.525937736,
-0.5026444197,
0.2766596973,
-0.2813475728,
0.1917872429,
0.317750901,
-0.4885048866,
0.6675553918,
0.2931015193,
0.8392962217,
-0.4013646543,
-0.2605085075,
-0.6767804623,
0.533354342,
-0.0204148311,
1.1332216263,
-0.1164660156,
-0.9581999183,
-0.1733174622,
-0.049815923,
-0.3869930506,
-0.5451133251,
0.8513240814,
-0.3685052693,
0.094899185,
0.3334164917,
-0.9068831801,
-0.3972326517,
-0.4929609895,
-0.7045928836,
1.1046350002,
0.3002338111,
-0.4311247766,
0.0809186026,
-0.9003478289,
-0.6314630508,
0.0888747126,
0.0858243853,
-0.5004935861,
0.263682574,
0.2431166321,
0.3826328814,
-0.2862502337,
-0.1239627078,
0.2167429775,
-0.5212093592,
0.2321135998,
-0.2745051086,
0.9104286432,
0.1465804577,
-0.3986903131,
-0.1613032073,
-0.7464327812,
0.1598117203,
0.1083775759,
-0.2078021914,
-0.4573090076,
-0.1130047888,
0.4665437937,
-0.2551318705,
-0.0233571287,
-0.4469070137,
-0.0413120314,
-0.283233583,
0.2707167268,
0.7915127873,
-0.1038613692,
0.7511290312,
-0.132272318,
0.3589105606,
0.07177753,
0.0054284991,
-0.0907223746,
-0.4455635548,
-0.6118373871,
-0.4675640166,
0.5093892217,
0.5397964716,
-0.447224617,
0.3114227355,
-0.467918694,
-0.5386565328,
-0.4890025854,
-0.1965269744,
0.409049958,
0.4284023941,
0.5201143026,
-0.4785821736,
-0.7294411063,
-0.2147563696,
-0.491566956,
-0.0841362923,
-0.2473752648,
-0.035634242,
0.2220287621,
-0.1031245291,
0.7875848413,
-0.370008111,
-0.4812167585,
-0.403151691,
0.0557157584,
0.0855830386,
0.2285359651,
0.5068645477,
-0.7415733933,
-0.7202197313,
-0.0210256446,
-0.1665745378,
-0.2478967905,
-0.2223983556,
0.0748693347,
0.4358491898,
0.3043721616,
-0.260755837,
0.5106196404,
0.6936539412,
-0.4368004501,
0.1593788564,
-0.3789085448,
-0.178064093,
-1.0061603785,
-0.2760668993,
0.1993361115,
-0.6451112032,
-0.907648921,
-0.1695466191,
0.2522245049,
-0.2341451645,
-0.5311911702,
0.5903798938,
-0.5832967162,
-0.2607228756,
-0.2871914804,
0.4254934788,
0.1891554743,
0.4246708453,
0.4355457127,
1.1090241671,
0.665897429,
-0.9595885277,
0.1147831455,
0.3076339662,
0.064096272,
0.3857779503,
-0.3579022884,
0.6923619509,
-0.0473154038,
0.4378919303,
-0.7320041656,
0.2617458701,
-0.0202882905,
-0.3883979917,
0.6068624854,
0.0980198756,
0.0011994345,
-0.0126385186,
-0.3081096709,
0.1647863686,
0.5569511652,
-0.7829591036,
1.0317285061,
0.5590612888,
-0.2877197862,
0.0285372771,
-0.7076557875,
-0.023976028,
0.1122277454,
-0.3725951314,
0.7401455045,
-0.1398398429,
0.2714009583,
-0.2527710497,
-0.414727658,
-0.5005255938,
-0.1326206625,
-0.002860419,
0.0573023781,
-0.2677350044,
0.0769503936,
0.1139153317,
-0.3142294288,
-0.3665340543,
-0.5752918124,
0.3660318553,
0.2195650041,
-0.1142222881,
-0.821762383,
0.4777771235,
0.5293343663,
-0.1946496814,
0.3646540344,
0.5197876096,
-0.2630884945,
-0.4492976069,
-0.2073254734,
-0.2648846507,
-0.4312904179,
0.5558732748,
-0.4664572477,
-0.8301869035,
0.0859289616,
-0.5426792502,
-0.0649283752,
0.4793069959,
0.4514090717,
0.0174558964,
0.5719379783,
0.8192643523,
-0.0417032652,
0.471526593,
-0.1118765399,
0.0076247985,
-0.8970926404,
-0.2084091455,
-0.6646633744,
0.1684933007,
-0.426813066,
-0.4260493815,
0.5910481811,
-0.2007732242,
-0.2287074625,
0.7177461982,
-0.8195978403,
0.0935206637,
0.4622968137,
0.3000193536,
0.3001102805,
0.4471043944,
0.0187150482,
-0.3024867773,
-0.5078389049,
-0.1420482993,
1.1242154837,
0.1431716383,
0.5972446799,
0.2125967145,
0.5896570683,
0.4687904716,
0.1521383077,
-0.7905783057,
0.3975184858,
-0.3750489354,
-0.3425700963,
-0.2730882764,
-0.4389697611,
-0.6282238364,
0.3985866606,
-0.1741412878,
-0.7512805462,
-0.0105207646,
-0.1677790284,
-0.3298486173,
0.2202403545,
-0.8215029836,
0.3602637053,
-0.1674935967,
-0.0394265093,
-0.0253982097,
-0.3538433909,
-0.414719671,
-0.3877020478,
0.3378414214,
0.1265052557,
-0.1457173228,
0.9346209764,
-0.2360375375,
0.6827862859,
-0.4880479276,
-0.1446439773,
0.6062704325,
-0.1241842657,
0.5115984082,
-0.1488122493,
-0.4060616493,
0.3000464737,
0.1464937031,
-0.1779403985,
-0.5541098714,
0.0816932172,
-0.9306220412,
-0.4253186584,
-0.6356233358,
-0.2398117632,
-0.3835296631,
0.0974185839,
0.3147794604,
0.4861278236,
-0.4260405004,
0.1120488197,
0.6391732097,
0.00074938,
0.5801097155,
0.6714497805,
-0.0074103917,
-0.5235620737,
0.7054445148,
-0.0867184028,
0.1399885267,
0.4506944418,
0.3920899928,
-0.7486319542,
-0.5201147199,
-0.6151355505,
0.1112798303,
-0.5874074697,
-0.3682007194,
-0.4246941507,
-0.3168268502,
-0.5173675418,
-0.0531058386,
-0.3847377896,
-0.5892981887,
-0.503849864,
0.1178359762,
0.8312166929,
0.4771244526,
-0.0509279296,
0.6704812646,
-1.123354435,
0.2918260992,
0.2831797004,
0.0728195831,
-0.4860189259,
-1.3798905611,
-0.3058736622,
-0.0423181467,
-0.3202336133,
-0.8739947081,
0.0822080523,
1.0534197092,
0.3618575037,
0.1064359844,
0.0730577707,
0.7167941332,
-0.6739398241,
0.567768693,
0.2905480564,
-1.2962424755,
0.2277611196,
0.0454184525,
0.3718855381,
0.3513360023,
0.0824690014,
-0.602226615,
-0.1233086288,
-0.2481610328,
-0.5661956668,
0.7672098875,
0.2942728102,
0.2605679333,
0.5092000365,
0.6926972866,
0.1742213517,
-0.2747670412,
-0.6916378736,
-0.2620459199,
-0.4202546179,
-0.3778599799,
0.0862164944,
-0.2475809157,
0.1853907108,
-0.3718177676,
0.8628851771,
-0.2583829761,
0.6290511489,
0.4231145978,
-0.483456254,
-0.0799905881,
0.4432817996,
0.5022938251,
0.4855540395,
-0.0662889183,
0.0432182848,
0.4560407698,
-0.9857298732,
0.2937658429,
0.2365030646,
-0.006029251,
0.4604637921,
0.3480542302,
0.7144297361,
0.2558721602,
-0.5167673826,
0.6986978054,
-0.1792222857,
-0.1656880379,
-0.3360815048,
-0.0510708392,
0.0430427641,
0.2346599698,
0.8375781775,
-0.0161845069,
-0.0575560518,
-0.2173666656,
0.4068901241,
-0.0291404929,
-0.4487859309,
-0.4490327239,
0.6611097455,
0.2931644022,
-0.2512953579,
0.1517505795,
-0.0391438268,
-0.4649468362,
0.3460048437,
1.1222275496,
1.2269164324,
-1.0270792246,
0.1797268838,
0.2381636202,
-0.0551365577,
0.0302052051,
0.505138278,
-0.029122442,
-0.7093952894,
-0.5275461674,
-0.5423570275,
-0.4437565804,
-0.1464611143,
-0.6860697865,
0.2332845479,
-0.5357576609,
-0.2224640399,
-0.054741703,
-0.2540137768,
-0.4513364136,
0.4295850694,
0.2153716385,
0.8511788249,
-0.4563294947,
0.995872736,
0.908993721,
0.0860271007,
-0.5872466564,
0.0804489926,
-0.0004958938,
-0.711959362,
0.2992028594,
-0.0486220904,
-0.4663145542,
0.3654130995,
-0.1958637834,
-0.7031604648,
1.0114392042,
0.5448697209,
-0.756737411,
0.1989858299,
0.234084636,
0.3859296739,
-0.4322203994,
0.1521363109,
0.3881890476,
0.3958152831,
-0.0866485387,
-1.0195008516,
0.0533136539,
0.2865800858,
0.2680285275,
0.1561608613,
-0.4771593511,
0.4987696707,
0.0500467196,
-0.4381242692,
-0.0993289351,
0.8096188903,
-0.0001152286,
0.2189536542,
0.8188140392,
0.2101969123,
0.7558678389,
0.0231578629,
0.5038194656,
-0.1647874266,
0.6748802662,
1.1039763689,
-0.508564353,
0.842412889,
0.4623562098,
-0.2711329162,
0.5311764479,
0.4137138426,
0.3033953309,
0.8085016608,
-0.0084616104,
-0.6957083344,
-0.036633037,
-0.0394896492,
-0.2519601285,
0.9080964923,
0.4582100809,
-0.0588219464,
-0.3704073727,
0.1380155832,
-0.0302789286,
0.1732221991,
-0.3508940041,
1.065731883,
0.2066605538,
-0.0666440949,
0.7054485679,
-0.0251232684,
0.5239620209,
-0.7092921734,
0.0644265115,
0.1572198272,
0.2493129671,
0.0351216681,
-0.2846429944,
0.3320361674,
0.1436445862,
-0.0458438024,
-0.2242762297,
0.8125457168,
-0.3756482303,
-0.4518919289,
0.6908487082,
0.5260198712,
0.1446360797,
-0.273016274,
-0.6274650693,
0.2181364894,
0.1934753209,
-0.3312739432,
0.0813612565,
0.5614300966,
0.0589994341,
0.1792561412,
0.5365565419,
0.0348554216,
0.1317965239,
0.3202803135,
0.8440690637,
-0.7339639068,
-0.434917599,
-0.6066715717,
0.5015293956,
0.124702625,
-0.1456158459,
0.3708854318,
0.4906544387,
0.7971712947,
-0.0724223629,
1.0174156427,
0.0746751875,
0.7999857664,
-0.5265583396,
0.5329336524,
-0.5575366616,
-0.1008904725,
-0.2627139688,
-0.9014322758,
-0.5317500234,
0.6773021817,
0.3791711926,
-0.0291060638,
1.0905959606,
0.6109219193,
-0.1394462585,
0.2858846486,
0.6437245607,
0.294565469,
-0.0352991931,
0.6371995211,
0.3532773554,
-0.7417293191,
0.7569335103,
0.0026774928,
-0.3861676753,
-0.1791711152,
-0.7374370694,
-0.6818079352,
-0.8154003024,
-0.3048957586,
-0.2835395634,
0.2650099099,
0.9036861062,
0.5820961595,
-0.8317109942,
-0.2519082129,
0.1525870562,
-0.3481242061,
-0.3934993446,
-0.1118536144,
0.7034155726,
-0.1249317452,
-0.7237636447,
0.676641047,
0.4396563172,
0.0138706192,
0.118480213,
-0.0728589296,
0.0638630241,
0.0380655155,
0.6168322563,
0.2440728694,
-0.3398525119,
-0.5609050989,
0.0491769686,
0.1309912354,
0.3863838017,
1.0703424215,
-0.6787192822,
0.6986383796,
0.1227136031,
0.8590135574,
0.7703790069,
-0.3595272899,
0.4354876578,
-0.816973269,
0.5673752427,
0.2712192535,
0.3193444014,
0.4749248922,
-0.3101761639,
0.2498863041,
0.2461845875,
-0.3668831885,
-0.3783104718,
0.2368760109,
-1.0231091976,
-0.2309167534,
1.1009552479,
-0.2211270928,
-0.4719916284,
-0.4571146667,
-0.3973709345,
0.7722806334,
-0.7587162256,
0.4784787297,
0.0871157646,
-0.1864623725,
-0.2617466152,
-0.1804613173,
0.3194277883,
0.2590516806,
-0.6213589907,
0.051709868,
0.1819953918,
0.382261157,
0.1726696342,
0.8591544628,
0.0280639119,
0.3165585101,
-0.1466053426,
0.2293429226,
0.098947458,
-0.1960358471,
-0.5887026191,
-0.1053375155,
-0.0146214571,
-0.2985852957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04067v1 | An Empirical Analysis of Parameter-Efficient Methods for Debiasing Pre-Trained Language Models | 2023-06-06T23:56:18 | 2023-06-06T23:56:18 | Zhongbin Xie, Thomas Lukasiewicz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasingly large size of modern pretrained language models not only
makes them inherit more human-like biases from the training corpora, but also
makes it computationally expensive to mitigate such biases. In this paper, we
investigate recent parameter-efficient methods in combination with
counterfactual data augmentation (CDA) for bias mitigation. We conduct
extensive experiments with prefix tuning, prompt tuning, and adapter tuning on
different language models and bias types to evaluate their debiasing
performance and abilities to preserve the internal knowledge of a pre-trained
model. We find that the parameter-efficient methods (i) are effective in
mitigating gender bias, where adapter tuning is consistently the most effective
one and prompt tuning is more suitable for GPT-2 than BERT, (ii) are less
effective when it comes to racial and religious bias, which may be attributed
to the limitations of CDA, and (iii) can perform similarly to or sometimes
better than full fine-tuning with improved time and memory efficiency, as well
as maintain the internal knowledge in BERT and GPT-2, evaluated via fact
retrieval and downstream fine-tuning. | [
-0.7084471583,
-0.9493917823,
0.5172044039,
0.0512091108,
-0.3090179563,
-0.228839606,
-0.433940649,
-0.1299287081,
-0.3269335926,
0.2588641047,
-0.5691415668,
-0.1496897936,
-0.5435311198,
-0.1457369477,
-0.2119343877,
0.9710452557,
0.0848244429,
0.415278405,
-0.0484058261,
-0.0260444935,
-0.4932763278,
-0.6370416284,
-0.4362726212,
-0.1971135885,
0.2340780497,
0.2082905173,
0.6715549827,
0.3755719066,
0.2877861261,
0.2362466902,
0.0855612978,
0.1261361986,
-0.6997823119,
-0.2107163668,
-0.229040131,
-0.3106153309,
-0.1909585148,
0.447887063,
0.4358689785,
0.8083977699,
-0.0658301488,
0.2016405463,
0.1154382229,
0.6161283255,
-0.9276916385,
-0.0796275139,
-0.8183851242,
-0.3126742542,
-0.010735319,
-0.1395199895,
-0.2850007117,
-0.7646009326,
0.2907180488,
-0.7507230639,
0.1616810411,
-0.0395939313,
0.7698329687,
0.5463468432,
-0.2010147423,
-0.3061318994,
-0.7011134624,
1.0901664495,
-0.765958786,
0.6404262185,
0.7109247446,
0.0385055616,
-0.0927076787,
-0.243961364,
-0.5025838017,
-0.2665230334,
-0.1691414565,
-0.0670406222,
-0.2141366303,
0.0630290434,
0.4562959671,
0.0114748189,
-0.5063331723,
0.2144822776,
-0.3653205931,
-0.1014071479,
0.3748982549,
-0.3865634203,
0.4261458516,
0.3219286799,
-0.094138965,
-0.2261999696,
-0.9195936918,
-0.2272501886,
0.7025124431,
0.1965207309,
0.0147700328,
0.1148363501,
-0.0450985469,
0.6861706972,
0.2531403303,
0.1295444071,
0.2865290046,
-0.3945133388,
-0.1295318902,
-0.0687761009,
0.4015046954,
0.2869120836,
0.6384575963,
-0.3546203971,
0.1538631022,
0.2399464995,
0.3202066422,
-1.0132467747,
-0.2202619314,
-0.107445389,
-0.373077631,
-0.0934978053,
-0.3279983103,
-0.8722323179,
-0.2462842017,
-0.6518471837,
0.4803144336,
-0.3625154793,
-0.2990905941,
-0.0725648776,
-0.2689369917,
0.2317309231,
0.2158602476,
-1.0029665232,
0.1082258821,
0.4803386629,
0.5008198619,
0.2037586272,
-0.044315733,
-0.6369926929,
-0.1705171764,
-0.5363539457,
0.5802052021,
-0.9138827324,
-0.3632358611,
-0.1865618527,
-0.2780822814,
-0.1793745607,
-0.4978742898,
0.5803195238,
-0.681212306,
0.2107333243,
-0.7601953745,
-0.3669605255,
-0.2440153956,
0.1001734734,
-0.5569198132,
0.971468091,
0.1453659087,
-0.7927806377,
0.7819229364,
-0.4464536607,
-0.1414809227,
-0.4283440113,
-0.1925252825,
-0.387696743,
0.1726415306,
0.5555116534,
-0.0073675714,
-0.4759761989,
0.4392365813,
-0.5210908651,
-0.4972300231,
-0.0661479756,
-0.5902429223,
0.8891928792,
0.2416029423,
-0.5063794851,
-0.2521988153,
-0.7276585698,
0.0413028039,
-0.1652688682,
-0.1127540767,
-0.8602576256,
0.0573705696,
-0.3389146626,
0.3335075974,
-0.0317863673,
-0.4316933155,
-0.0203511417,
-0.4268624783,
0.1775545627,
0.7659070492,
-0.2415279001,
0.5466018915,
-0.0380140506,
0.3976621032,
0.0939236805,
0.1771539897,
0.0655316189,
-0.053920079,
-0.7919318676,
-0.4879738986,
0.4637288451,
0.3057461083,
-0.5299506783,
0.567124784,
-0.0219899137,
-0.5453718305,
-0.6270871162,
0.2765382826,
0.5115231872,
0.599916935,
0.4698067307,
-0.1959160864,
-0.6121028066,
-1.0322070122,
-0.6284422278,
-0.1036029607,
0.0673077032,
0.0646505132,
0.4202503264,
-0.1759171784,
0.9711809754,
-0.3386895955,
0.2092582732,
0.0025652382,
0.3434149027,
0.1550281048,
0.6818277836,
0.9344123602,
-0.5422713757,
-0.282052964,
-0.3047541678,
-0.4155669212,
-0.5210961699,
0.0134634376,
-0.2854029834,
0.2648026943,
0.3744391799,
-0.40712291,
0.5703753233,
0.4290630817,
-0.2565934956,
0.3802454472,
-0.2710131407,
0.1431731582,
-0.4092028141,
0.1388495415,
-0.0066308952,
-0.1131264642,
-0.7777791619,
0.0225456804,
0.1133899987,
0.3309566975,
-0.0690308884,
0.4500556588,
-0.5986638665,
0.1431095153,
-0.5030630827,
0.1136266589,
-0.2082176954,
0.4500917792,
0.1607972533,
0.9121211171,
0.4782352746,
-0.7520735264,
-0.18925713,
0.1000580639,
-0.3386462331,
0.4567893147,
-0.5801401138,
0.4025568962,
-0.6385636926,
0.1230332702,
-0.9158066511,
0.5333120823,
0.1388847381,
-0.0866077915,
0.2094863206,
-0.1562333107,
-0.2981470525,
-0.0990626067,
-0.4578862786,
0.5119003654,
0.6613446474,
-0.7609893084,
0.47679618,
0.266043216,
-0.0468590967,
-0.6058004498,
-0.5699675679,
-0.2659923732,
-0.3824620545,
-0.1972120553,
0.0742103383,
-0.3638480604,
-0.3547417819,
-0.2303081006,
-0.1602478027,
0.0286203716,
0.2323980331,
-0.0659386516,
0.1584278792,
0.028674705,
0.1611196399,
0.2652440667,
-0.1191759482,
-0.0205605756,
-0.2087658942,
0.6439967752,
0.0550646149,
-0.3193283975,
-0.0411137603,
0.2380796671,
0.1359609067,
-0.2585677803,
0.7635826468,
0.6278463006,
-0.131612435,
-0.300908953,
-0.8975018859,
-0.5450037122,
-0.4451482296,
0.4210995436,
-0.2291378677,
-0.5184245706,
0.3674365282,
-0.0174372438,
0.0880122408,
0.2342876047,
0.5689266324,
0.320692122,
0.9568190575,
0.3359389305,
-0.2093556672,
0.5107806325,
-0.0114230886,
0.3569769859,
-0.6938712597,
0.3000063896,
-0.7804673314,
-0.20304887,
-0.670755446,
-0.4796439409,
0.2671738565,
0.2028916627,
-0.4660773575,
0.1511043459,
-0.1547200829,
0.397285074,
0.8392230868,
0.0768387541,
0.1144838631,
-0.0437730812,
0.0007262931,
-0.1499959379,
-0.4939294159,
-0.4723694623,
1.286344409,
0.2947411537,
0.7079408169,
-0.0804925635,
0.3192090094,
0.0621217228,
0.3498135805,
-0.1611382067,
0.326418519,
-0.307190001,
-1.0200363398,
-0.3769858479,
-0.4125891328,
-0.3733539581,
0.5210615396,
-0.1772578806,
-0.6607671976,
0.5964080691,
0.4185619652,
-0.1568543315,
0.1460274458,
-0.8292822838,
0.6630339622,
-0.177253902,
-0.4958505034,
-0.4358777106,
-0.4575262368,
0.2309242487,
-0.4272783399,
0.2869141698,
-0.0627888814,
0.1643579453,
0.7848520279,
-0.4194539189,
0.7702893615,
-0.6024743319,
-0.3699243665,
0.1181129143,
-0.1710166633,
0.6366726756,
-0.0151889548,
-0.361420095,
0.2401339412,
-0.0250819139,
-0.3491564691,
-0.732036531,
0.573695302,
-0.8514137864,
-0.6834884882,
-0.1573204994,
-0.4725859463,
-0.5624991059,
0.1751119047,
0.0840987563,
0.3755294979,
-0.3227132559,
0.1908965111,
0.668346405,
-0.3918128014,
0.5323505402,
0.7580596805,
0.0615232587,
-0.2424227148,
0.5671981573,
0.3449366391,
0.2871030867,
0.1770067066,
0.3161154985,
-0.268094182,
-0.546130836,
-0.419890672,
0.1352170855,
-0.5906863213,
0.1314451396,
-0.6132800579,
0.1237632111,
-0.331502676,
0.0829418451,
-0.3809300661,
-0.3320364356,
-0.1866645664,
-0.3143276572,
0.2374735624,
0.1385188401,
-0.1196823865,
0.5367850661,
-0.3825029433,
0.4837271869,
0.4041287303,
0.3190748096,
-0.0510917976,
-0.6069787145,
-0.0507789403,
0.3006446362,
-0.1452369839,
-0.8265879154,
0.1777053028,
0.2565933466,
0.7903285623,
0.4783628881,
0.1585653573,
0.870818913,
-0.4543350041,
0.5555089712,
-0.1233294383,
-1.0556226969,
0.3326620162,
-0.1713016629,
0.0843346417,
0.8385543227,
0.3823933303,
-0.0534108169,
-0.2984759808,
-0.2730006278,
-0.7469260097,
0.8866394162,
0.1965976506,
0.260609597,
0.0533715487,
0.4444983602,
0.4264243841,
0.2675599754,
-0.5222496986,
-0.3475889862,
-0.3508603573,
-0.1880271584,
-0.1898845285,
-0.4514014423,
0.0319336019,
-0.5100473166,
1.0100480318,
-0.1628611237,
-0.174698621,
0.0704832152,
-0.4767630994,
-0.0101789888,
0.48481673,
0.6200259924,
0.9963819981,
-0.3527942896,
0.1589646488,
0.4781771898,
-0.4457055032,
0.1642909348,
0.3329144418,
-0.5323832035,
-0.1167319342,
0.165312469,
1.0760202408,
0.0220716782,
-0.5278599858,
0.2991366982,
0.0612839386,
-0.1164879352,
-0.0552332476,
0.0454525389,
-0.0597150587,
0.0785655752,
0.24829036,
-0.1816364527,
0.2129389197,
-0.4858670831,
0.0320388526,
0.7975987792,
-0.4567034543,
-0.3738082647,
0.513486743,
0.2041839957,
0.3521186709,
0.4465824366,
-0.0487994701,
-0.4493082762,
0.3701356351,
0.6677284241,
0.870164156,
-0.4311493337,
0.153500393,
0.4764702022,
0.5375498533,
-0.0504237525,
0.2040174603,
-0.1363727152,
-0.7574455738,
-0.4461719692,
-0.496850282,
-0.0495904796,
0.2084356546,
-0.399454385,
0.1778606325,
-0.2368202358,
-0.2595246434,
-0.0800921768,
0.0276779924,
-0.8646798134,
0.3936016262,
0.0359511189,
0.8406946659,
-0.8903103471,
0.8124358654,
0.5783833265,
-0.3429878056,
-0.5802234411,
0.0394397937,
-0.2180816531,
-0.7927082181,
0.9706124067,
-0.0330449007,
-0.2272608727,
-0.095358707,
-0.3781386316,
-0.8532586694,
0.4828351736,
0.7363983989,
-0.8588184714,
-0.0669136569,
0.1087311283,
0.4846936166,
-0.0237645805,
0.9147056341,
1.0666092634,
0.8609663248,
-0.330825448,
-0.9163067937,
0.1421063691,
-0.1705223024,
0.0822332352,
0.0684383065,
-0.4903746247,
0.6308025718,
0.0747298151,
0.0666697696,
-0.2886542082,
0.4497357309,
0.1687241346,
0.075307332,
0.9376151562,
0.4866699874,
0.6136715412,
0.0162951797,
0.7147057056,
-0.3988172412,
0.1391737014,
0.9464566708,
-0.2360496819,
0.3296747506,
0.576659441,
-0.3134159148,
0.3959329724,
0.3389231265,
0.183059603,
0.6876245737,
0.379022181,
0.1362773329,
-0.4076088965,
0.0114338957,
-0.4640257359,
0.3907432258,
0.0546369068,
-0.376303494,
-0.3583192229,
0.0075281807,
0.3195658326,
0.0563915521,
-0.1342923045,
0.8867530823,
-0.0355835892,
-0.8338963389,
0.7626205683,
-0.1715225279,
0.7048723102,
-0.6071777344,
0.1193672717,
-0.261618644,
0.221624583,
0.034332823,
0.0121371308,
0.1299168169,
0.1121375412,
-0.2389153242,
-0.012402771,
0.5451620817,
-0.6275369525,
-0.5565434694,
0.3496357501,
0.497653991,
-0.1098562479,
-0.2256549746,
-0.4206761122,
0.0497162044,
-0.0103518991,
-0.40037328,
0.1680917144,
-0.0223435014,
-0.3126396835,
0.3846543729,
0.5454138517,
0.2545770407,
0.0788061544,
0.3565428555,
1.000205636,
-0.5333812237,
-0.4812377393,
-1.0483521223,
0.1742518842,
-0.1523392051,
-0.1929177046,
0.8296785355,
0.4589287937,
0.7002748847,
-0.1610004604,
0.9384236336,
0.201600343,
0.6406764388,
-0.5323415995,
0.6533392072,
-0.3829943836,
0.3885919452,
-0.5474379659,
-1.0323596001,
-0.0594750643,
0.4501737058,
-0.7618240714,
0.5242134333,
0.3997300267,
0.9301444888,
-0.136796549,
0.194411993,
0.1299552321,
0.0968187377,
0.4051124156,
0.3197935522,
0.7611976862,
-0.307313025,
0.2272387296,
-0.2259273827,
-0.468332231,
-0.0755540282,
-1.0470784903,
-1.1791346073,
-0.3309664726,
-0.3026903868,
0.1300556809,
0.4798935652,
1.1029994488,
1.0737781525,
-1.0126764774,
0.0846461505,
-0.0722068623,
0.0548169985,
-0.1987791806,
-0.1021155193,
0.5756453872,
-0.6192984581,
-0.9363870025,
0.3763022721,
-0.1969629973,
-0.2790814042,
-0.2060898691,
-0.0821081251,
-0.1489391923,
0.3970431387,
0.5284456015,
0.0181913227,
-0.4565113783,
-0.218605563,
-0.3688302338,
0.3122007549,
-0.1374617517,
0.8730745316,
-0.8856480718,
0.4644960463,
0.6673479676,
0.5713153481,
0.2914426625,
0.3941491246,
0.9362692237,
-0.5611903667,
0.3224070668,
-0.1615622789,
0.210883528,
0.3216029108,
-0.15682666,
0.4823284745,
-0.0244072527,
-0.3911693394,
-0.8724948168,
0.0887408853,
-0.436694026,
-0.5017305017,
1.0984481573,
-0.0348798335,
0.1050753295,
-0.2251943499,
-0.3278299868,
0.3883234859,
-0.3493884504,
0.8947332501,
0.5862031579,
0.3086214662,
-0.1160099506,
-0.5463296771,
0.8273934126,
0.6823513508,
-0.9118334055,
0.2619077265,
0.5158253312,
0.2705193758,
-0.0560784005,
0.4600855112,
-0.1133896932,
0.132192865,
-0.2479134053,
-0.0148638729,
-0.1101709679,
-0.1808910668,
-0.3005078137,
-0.1037743688,
0.0296833571,
-0.1714680642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04059v1 | Augmenting Reddit Posts to Determine Wellness Dimensions impacting Mental Health | 2023-06-06T23:15:59 | 2023-06-06T23:15:59 | Chandreen Liyanage, Muskan Garg, Vijay Mago, Sunghwan Sohn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Amid ongoing health crisis, there is a growing necessity to discern possible
signs of Wellness Dimensions (WD) manifested in self-narrated text. As the
distribution of WD on social media data is intrinsically imbalanced, we
experiment the generative NLP models for data augmentation to enable further
improvement in the pre-screening task of classifying WD. To this end, we
propose a simple yet effective data augmentation approach through prompt-based
Generative NLP models, and evaluate the ROUGE scores and syntactic/semantic
similarity among existing interpretations and augmented data. Our approach with
ChatGPT model surpasses all the other methods and achieves improvement over
baselines such as Easy-Data Augmentation and Backtranslation. Introducing data
augmentation to generate more training samples and balanced dataset, results in
the improved F-score and the Matthew's Correlation Coefficient for upto 13.11%
and 15.95%, respectively. | [
-0.296417743,
-0.80176121,
0.4266876876,
0.3353001773,
-0.3439767659,
0.2874747217,
-0.0295386426,
-0.6434401274,
0.8095599413,
0.3733386993,
-0.9891510606,
-0.6547359228,
-0.6104872823,
0.1607198119,
-0.1661523134,
1.132781148,
0.3616947234,
0.0558287762,
-0.3058986962,
-0.1419035345,
-0.5776376128,
-0.3824222684,
-0.4297883511,
-0.2813823819,
0.4139369428,
0.3744182289,
0.9545810223,
0.1933119893,
0.7096135616,
0.2177449912,
0.1230411083,
0.5592798591,
-0.6321727633,
0.1770513803,
-0.2395587713,
-0.2153069973,
-0.686296165,
-0.0203677863,
0.229921639,
0.6593561172,
-0.14806889,
0.3240193129,
0.1934227347,
0.5741733909,
-0.5290882587,
0.087207973,
-0.2716157138,
0.1351448148,
0.1636292189,
-0.6183599234,
0.1048732996,
-0.3773755431,
-0.1636524796,
-0.502358377,
0.2522605658,
-0.293366611,
0.6953323483,
0.4337921739,
-0.5046440363,
0.0740532428,
-0.8895136118,
0.3848590553,
-0.5912973285,
0.3518539071,
0.6319099665,
-0.2049064487,
0.1110564768,
-0.5680475831,
-0.608240366,
-0.0253563728,
-0.446174562,
0.1646707952,
-0.4900048077,
0.0055296565,
0.5471246243,
0.8803756833,
-0.7307697535,
-0.1596612334,
-0.3082126379,
-0.0461891182,
1.0121079683,
0.4142270684,
0.7387990355,
-0.4321223199,
0.0817023367,
-0.1434912682,
-0.1332173347,
-0.0072867852,
0.1744478047,
0.2241110504,
-0.2633206546,
1.0168492794,
-0.3718956411,
0.4073672295,
0.1251551658,
-0.2234839797,
0.6610033512,
-0.7163960338,
-0.0151689826,
-0.1099523976,
0.6602825522,
0.98686409,
-0.147280544,
0.1056803688,
-0.1369464397,
-0.0504700504,
0.5579825044,
-0.7719287276,
-0.3991680741,
0.2118956745,
-0.6068587899,
-0.1497053206,
0.2005559206,
-0.8658428788,
-0.6351541281,
-0.4560044408,
0.4663453102,
-0.6987020969,
-0.2732581198,
0.2163656056,
0.0892142355,
-0.0960228294,
0.2995471954,
-0.8522738218,
0.0370261185,
0.6467564702,
1.0309240818,
-0.0514240004,
0.0598242283,
-0.3857299685,
-0.1950705051,
-0.1526218206,
0.659855783,
-0.5770422816,
-0.5943567753,
0.0275822021,
0.1579448134,
0.1102007329,
-0.3433178663,
0.7731899619,
-0.1922656745,
0.3618949652,
-0.5474331379,
-0.4734685123,
0.0232847594,
0.3993738592,
-0.6527653337,
1.1083803177,
0.6133872867,
-1.0565299988,
0.4362003803,
-0.6886370778,
-0.7170521617,
0.3149428666,
0.1604976207,
-0.3378483951,
0.2344806343,
0.7281945348,
0.2727894187,
0.0686173141,
-0.0012312977,
-0.4840104878,
-0.2851659358,
0.2940114141,
-0.5043891668,
0.7923581004,
0.2184174806,
0.1953241974,
0.1268507093,
-0.8173849583,
0.2425778061,
-0.0664556473,
-0.2050335556,
-0.4643478692,
-0.1776863933,
-0.0324944779,
0.2243791223,
0.210766986,
-0.5454785824,
0.0938711092,
-0.5752493143,
0.145910725,
0.4177024066,
0.4746156931,
0.1768462211,
-0.4132765234,
0.8238722682,
-0.0737603232,
0.2773214579,
-0.3251365721,
-0.5044391155,
-0.1207402572,
-0.5611202717,
0.0334680341,
0.7168849707,
-0.6852430701,
1.1298958063,
-0.529789567,
-0.5953581929,
-0.8871489763,
0.1791909486,
-0.1874893904,
0.3800595403,
0.7113858461,
-0.2970222831,
-0.4925980568,
-0.6546200514,
-0.2535680532,
-0.1473521441,
-0.4016338885,
-0.1106718853,
0.1915023327,
-0.6995871067,
0.7802967429,
-0.9154217839,
-0.3063205183,
-0.2150646895,
0.0512957983,
0.0438573807,
0.3958857954,
0.4604967833,
-0.6642219424,
-0.460304141,
-0.0464140736,
-0.7322593331,
-0.1989723742,
-0.0156476703,
-0.0650648549,
-0.5489251018,
0.2168561667,
-0.751365602,
0.5640179515,
0.3910377026,
-0.4158359468,
0.3038656414,
-0.1775301397,
0.5018795133,
-1.1744629145,
-0.2848218381,
0.3088477552,
-0.1957164556,
-0.5902532935,
0.0840555578,
-0.0225671772,
-0.3486124575,
0.1853030473,
0.2655101418,
-0.0984437466,
0.328512907,
-0.3630188406,
-0.1640091687,
0.1963525265,
0.0400197506,
-0.4574612677,
0.4505208433,
0.5504771471,
-0.0756691694,
0.6386948824,
0.1736297607,
-0.2568988502,
0.7591665387,
-0.5687795281,
-0.2472500056,
-0.4094088078,
0.3407492638,
-1.1420183182,
-0.5828633308,
0.1346047968,
-0.607002914,
0.1417349875,
0.4948404133,
-0.548961103,
-0.642968297,
-0.4669498205,
0.3545761406,
0.4707147181,
-0.5585404634,
0.3571309745,
0.5055081248,
-0.0826139227,
-0.3113202453,
-0.5596897006,
0.0763336346,
-0.4418312311,
-0.6389524341,
0.5149364471,
-0.0090541299,
-0.1852045655,
0.1608053148,
0.1089458764,
0.1983533055,
-0.0629981458,
0.2587391436,
0.15334405,
-0.075533472,
0.4758540094,
-0.0600814074,
-0.0225214809,
0.1871466041,
0.0639067069,
0.5365821123,
0.039240364,
-0.4601568282,
-0.6924672127,
0.5464083552,
0.414008975,
-0.3628732264,
0.9395465851,
0.8672372699,
-0.6442583203,
0.0983957499,
-0.4033073187,
-0.5588584542,
-0.4308648407,
0.3052383363,
-0.0262327939,
-0.8220006824,
0.4919640124,
0.2202515006,
-0.1365819126,
0.391689986,
0.3443439007,
-0.2292566895,
1.3240822554,
0.6284355521,
0.0017310686,
0.5182675123,
-0.0294455662,
0.8364854455,
-0.5248940587,
-0.2625520527,
-0.0196471903,
-0.3100966215,
-0.7813013196,
-0.517980814,
0.5120669603,
-0.0246153548,
0.1609993577,
-0.0120783178,
-0.7006667256,
0.19351542,
0.3067034483,
0.720924139,
0.2625792623,
0.1188098267,
0.3390564024,
-0.6342968345,
-0.2904277146,
-0.1921931654,
0.8552715182,
0.4517754912,
0.9438598752,
0.0361960307,
0.5908883214,
0.6291137934,
0.4605232179,
-0.7428606749,
0.3121146858,
-0.1562329084,
-0.2490146309,
-0.2726839781,
-0.3492919207,
-0.7446737885,
0.1125970781,
-0.6364318728,
-0.7305223346,
0.1946848482,
0.1130256802,
-0.6694228053,
0.0255462825,
-0.7382018566,
0.6043038964,
-0.1804707199,
-0.2122150511,
-0.2931400239,
-0.4742687047,
0.6805080175,
-0.1699679345,
0.1084263548,
-0.2308787704,
0.3635959923,
0.4146409035,
-0.7348441482,
0.6123915315,
0.0006754243,
-0.1529907882,
0.1274356246,
-0.5406945944,
0.2533848584,
0.2976730764,
-0.014401651,
-0.1407821178,
0.0385075025,
-0.379481107,
-1.0567338467,
0.7440375686,
-0.58268857,
-0.6074674129,
-0.2377837449,
-0.5074287057,
-0.3827567101,
-0.1542271525,
0.0904349536,
0.1839937568,
-0.1990402192,
0.2890697718,
0.3495797217,
-0.2986216843,
-0.0196317509,
0.1795618236,
-0.3312597871,
-0.4579100609,
0.8044487238,
0.1085873619,
0.1769284606,
0.3299140334,
0.1858881712,
-0.5229061246,
-0.0052476348,
0.0865885615,
0.2853559554,
-0.6201202869,
-0.3422099352,
-0.9984704256,
-0.4283617735,
-0.726472199,
-0.049666822,
-0.2288797349,
-0.3066235781,
-0.2270368636,
-0.7452095747,
0.6754491329,
0.3196997344,
-0.5975064039,
0.3613872528,
-0.8592888117,
0.5073903203,
0.3884345889,
0.1768157482,
-0.0182002075,
-0.3762966096,
-0.278788507,
0.4310908616,
-0.5552272201,
-1.0052880049,
0.4869416058,
0.0584801324,
0.4068013132,
0.6776614785,
0.2648843229,
1.0531134605,
0.0537346192,
0.7538446188,
0.3702546954,
-0.6490296721,
0.8194693923,
-0.2725476325,
0.4192947745,
0.575704217,
0.4226650894,
-0.566142261,
-0.3613785207,
-0.7333466411,
-0.7412167788,
0.237832576,
0.2012280524,
0.6244968176,
-0.3137440979,
0.4105509818,
-0.0535777807,
0.0008282235,
-0.7358260155,
-0.2860481143,
-0.4776853621,
-0.2994242609,
-0.0960366428,
-0.431095928,
-0.0097601973,
-0.7401784658,
0.5019171834,
-0.058167614,
0.17466335,
0.2500844598,
0.2992767096,
-0.1801356226,
0.1626272798,
0.3077710569,
0.4942652583,
-0.2657003701,
0.2013046294,
0.1007836983,
-0.6105887294,
0.1242093444,
0.2370236814,
-0.1497712284,
0.0297544394,
0.6252840757,
0.6828852296,
-0.0826521069,
-0.5222191215,
0.4141269624,
0.0484961383,
0.1091581285,
0.0833806694,
0.3288153708,
0.0113440249,
0.101319246,
0.3324614763,
0.0269220825,
0.2250162512,
-0.7191541195,
0.483838886,
0.4950868189,
-0.5421639681,
-0.4859196246,
0.4230294824,
0.0611373074,
-0.2967713177,
0.8017042875,
-0.3410600424,
-0.2481493503,
0.2202141732,
0.5060198307,
0.6400830746,
-0.6623570919,
0.6602813005,
0.9288381338,
0.4732625186,
-0.0487901457,
0.4983654022,
0.0213164669,
-0.8046193123,
-0.5018774867,
-0.7850405574,
0.193186298,
0.4556234777,
-0.9596071243,
0.2771848142,
-0.0591466576,
-0.4900082648,
0.01987358,
-0.0083643897,
-0.6723257303,
0.570769906,
-0.1079552248,
0.3759027123,
-1.0927470922,
0.4913285971,
0.5920064449,
-0.4156954288,
-0.6752343178,
0.5070637465,
0.0687325746,
-0.6588328481,
0.1508777887,
0.3042942882,
0.0498563573,
-0.079901807,
-0.3653077483,
-0.7397041917,
0.8726342916,
0.34559533,
-0.2282616198,
0.0080565605,
0.3510080874,
0.9099466801,
-0.3791959584,
0.1553098857,
0.5319426656,
0.428858012,
0.247254163,
-0.4811444581,
0.1465021819,
-0.4007073045,
-0.0582097434,
-0.0809317455,
-0.0953930616,
0.600340724,
-0.6239881516,
-0.5616990924,
-0.29513973,
0.6863918304,
0.1692079604,
0.251070559,
0.4559834003,
0.899595201,
1.0636757612,
0.1485852301,
1.1476242542,
-0.3630030155,
0.4293391705,
1.0711574554,
-0.0809961781,
0.4719238281,
0.174409166,
-0.3883004189,
0.3258647919,
0.9486500025,
-0.2604548931,
0.6211332083,
0.0443984456,
-0.544254601,
-0.168370977,
-0.4953944087,
-0.4584468901,
0.4029494226,
0.577149272,
-0.4886725247,
-0.3279456794,
0.4444400072,
0.0064093717,
0.226326704,
-0.2579405904,
0.7123000026,
0.0892561823,
-0.5588266253,
0.3425846398,
0.0569854304,
0.4388425648,
-0.265784502,
-0.081345737,
-0.3134326637,
-0.0046832385,
-0.5937590599,
-0.9354900718,
0.7018334866,
-0.1249492988,
-0.2940773964,
-0.1985926777,
0.9430761337,
-0.5760319829,
-0.9399258494,
0.2915503979,
0.6646457314,
-0.1131476834,
-0.2252383232,
-0.7061824799,
-0.2412967235,
0.0344392098,
0.0386600681,
0.1248635277,
0.605919838,
0.0353328362,
0.4881660044,
0.8106418252,
0.0341537558,
-0.22178258,
0.236953631,
0.8299838901,
-0.5306241512,
-0.5763866305,
-1.0657730103,
0.531688273,
-0.3971398771,
-0.0959988162,
1.0402565002,
0.3721476793,
0.5558606386,
-0.0640804619,
0.6703011394,
-0.066483207,
0.564168036,
-0.3053424358,
0.6141716242,
-0.795828402,
0.242686674,
-0.2206606865,
-0.7453088164,
-0.2288427353,
0.6245800853,
-0.3352877498,
0.0487054884,
0.4817856252,
0.9131454229,
-0.0733512044,
0.2095136493,
0.2863658071,
0.0979984924,
0.2328523844,
0.0489098132,
0.7526723742,
-0.2385418564,
-0.2371407747,
-0.4615948796,
-0.2261861116,
-0.2249240577,
-0.514447391,
-0.7029598951,
-0.7121431828,
-0.5267580748,
-0.5495225787,
-0.1778326631,
0.8619387746,
0.4622114003,
-0.4749472439,
0.463365823,
0.1055381075,
0.1951745898,
-0.4886965156,
-0.3408134878,
0.2450005859,
-0.2217398286,
-0.3257105052,
0.1222683191,
0.4221087396,
0.0661483929,
-0.4204923809,
0.1770685762,
-0.0247699656,
0.047516048,
0.8838375807,
-0.036901094,
-0.4342955053,
-0.3800229728,
0.0065173497,
-0.1712170988,
0.1677670479,
0.6857326031,
-0.4336804748,
0.4971066117,
0.4804299772,
0.5130286217,
0.1379440874,
0.704821229,
0.489490211,
-0.8416127563,
-0.17887339,
0.1592194289,
0.1671479046,
0.7388007045,
-0.8250661492,
0.4647276998,
0.3103364408,
-0.2302284092,
-0.7555232644,
-0.0799692646,
-0.8544034958,
-0.0611709692,
0.9935913682,
0.0527384318,
0.1483864337,
0.0407235436,
-0.1409412622,
0.0866989344,
-0.1522585154,
1.1771719456,
0.7676612139,
-0.3126927912,
-0.3090369999,
-0.5244917274,
0.6434858441,
0.2270301878,
-1.2711458206,
-0.0531689487,
0.5744674802,
0.1090666577,
0.2679045796,
0.8881717324,
-0.0143019464,
0.0500614531,
-0.1681378037,
-0.2173151076,
0.3554932475,
0.1714821011,
-0.1270417869,
0.09495271,
-0.3863871694,
-0.0969486237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04050v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04050v2 | LLMZip: Lossless Text Compression using Large Language Models | 2023-06-06T22:42:00 | 2023-06-26T18:03:12 | Chandra Shekhara Kaushik Valmeekam, Krishna Narayanan, Dileep Kalathil, Jean-Francois Chamberland, Srinivas Shakkottai | cs.IT | cs.IT, cs.CL, cs.LG, math.IT | We provide new estimates of an asymptotic upper bound on the entropy of
English using the large language model LLaMA-7B as a predictor for the next
token given a window of past tokens. This estimate is significantly smaller
than currently available estimates in \cite{cover1978convergent},
\cite{lutati2023focus}. A natural byproduct is an algorithm for lossless
compression of English text which combines the prediction from the large
language model with a lossless compression scheme. Preliminary results from
limited experiments suggest that our scheme outperforms state-of-the-art text
compression schemes such as BSC, ZPAQ, and paq8h. | [
-0.2150016427,
-0.320007354,
0.5130618215,
0.1867129505,
-0.4205774963,
0.0049574184,
-0.2396332622,
-0.6064454317,
0.4379471838,
0.4096877873,
-0.7740001678,
-0.3122600019,
-0.997664392,
0.2947564125,
-0.4244283438,
0.5000912547,
0.1095502377,
0.0189137068,
-0.0894117057,
0.2975588143,
-0.5133131146,
-0.6473945975,
-0.4967217445,
-0.4486019015,
0.3990285993,
0.3565090001,
0.6166989803,
0.5718992949,
0.5660249591,
0.2561816275,
-0.1897502989,
-0.1292605698,
-0.4284479916,
0.3882572949,
0.2549918592,
-0.8389007449,
-0.0666460097,
-0.2088594437,
0.8435399532,
0.5756413341,
-0.3579165637,
0.2974670231,
0.1658670604,
0.5975183845,
-0.902815938,
0.0536336713,
-0.8595747948,
0.1738891751,
-0.355430454,
-0.641056776,
-0.6631932259,
-0.1425512582,
-0.6153947115,
-0.080724299,
-0.0925619975,
0.2971999645,
0.643961966,
0.5651586056,
-0.2940299511,
-0.1758406311,
-0.3715429902,
0.8408932686,
-1.0247273445,
0.4164711535,
0.5086571574,
0.2040658295,
-0.4283088148,
-0.5576480627,
-0.6261155009,
-0.1648765653,
0.2644559741,
-0.1235862896,
-0.4176523089,
0.1786686927,
0.250477463,
0.5783327222,
-0.6802098751,
0.3971633911,
-0.4849198759,
-0.2024634182,
0.7060647607,
0.0940979868,
0.3083784282,
-0.0932620987,
-0.3938661218,
0.1656036079,
-0.9034768939,
-0.2360151708,
0.3962247372,
0.0108831981,
-0.1207371131,
0.7782635689,
-0.3376214206,
0.8269168139,
-0.298776716,
-0.4409372211,
0.2256252766,
0.0993714333,
-0.4491463304,
0.4789814055,
0.6042973399,
0.6128373146,
0.0401509367,
-0.3441462219,
-0.1187822223,
0.2039860487,
-0.2066750377,
-0.825963676,
0.2284700423,
0.1607965231,
-0.5574686527,
-0.2847916484,
0.1795887202,
-0.4818872511,
-0.4165656865,
-0.1597196311,
0.2393255234,
-0.0510541312,
0.045198869,
0.5378104448,
-0.3032667339,
0.1098899022,
0.2787666619,
-0.7918987274,
0.4047294259,
0.6356830001,
1.1681803465,
-0.3522372246,
-0.4650219679,
-0.4631877542,
0.3187915385,
-0.0908116475,
0.9281390905,
-0.5709400177,
-0.2422785014,
0.1088702157,
0.0911474377,
0.231003657,
-0.2802762687,
0.7829623222,
-0.4153980613,
0.0573849417,
0.0654696226,
-0.661382556,
-0.3841887414,
0.188252911,
-0.6188805103,
0.9272742271,
-0.0684622303,
-0.854424119,
0.1180916205,
-0.2000019699,
-0.1322457492,
-0.0917228237,
0.1928351521,
0.1532873809,
0.4427034259,
0.1949255764,
0.6859127283,
-0.7626730204,
-0.0056798486,
-0.4058620036,
-0.4941369295,
0.284994036,
-0.9014120102,
0.8516716957,
0.2550783455,
0.0099016009,
-0.1949883699,
-0.8238646984,
0.0828637704,
0.1767099947,
-0.8634780049,
-0.2167135626,
-0.1903054565,
-0.0670333579,
0.1606001258,
0.4132418334,
-0.6195192337,
0.8029729128,
-0.5101050735,
0.5250268579,
0.8599350452,
-0.0420509316,
0.3031217754,
-0.3906060159,
0.8483236432,
-0.4968554974,
0.0014203284,
-0.2027936727,
-0.553255856,
-0.6084647179,
-0.2511423528,
0.4893830717,
0.6333090067,
-0.5375490785,
0.315770179,
-0.4882589877,
-0.6204170585,
-0.348816216,
0.1419464797,
0.0786634386,
0.12253277,
0.133978039,
-0.1892840862,
-0.7935076356,
-0.7086663246,
-0.0825726315,
-0.1165485382,
-0.4965060353,
-0.1936043501,
0.3276560605,
-0.254145205,
0.1435427666,
-0.7771447897,
-0.0905841216,
-0.451497227,
0.0947460234,
0.4359253943,
0.3367158473,
0.3376664221,
-0.3886713684,
-0.3516305089,
-0.2717419565,
-0.4325261116,
-0.4368347824,
0.0181068275,
-0.0714665428,
0.4924948514,
0.4700542986,
-0.9201595783,
0.4526835382,
1.1681331396,
-0.4754494131,
0.4925720096,
-0.131923452,
0.3339674473,
-1.3145506382,
-0.2140763998,
-0.3755889237,
-0.3579775393,
-0.4283602834,
0.2415548265,
-0.1890669167,
-0.1321834773,
-0.6609736085,
0.5324196219,
-0.792349577,
-0.1066644564,
-0.3138309121,
-0.0579721481,
-0.1319801658,
0.4013238847,
-0.0637705773,
0.6604574323,
0.555524826,
-0.5511136055,
0.4596684575,
0.0573802255,
-0.4163572788,
0.0430326238,
-0.645144701,
0.1316755563,
-0.2384424657,
0.4616550505,
-0.8616278172,
-0.2323490381,
0.1274357885,
-0.6841447949,
0.5191120505,
-0.0944869667,
-0.629662931,
-0.4042829573,
-0.7419248819,
0.3438536525,
0.6362928152,
-0.3707385659,
0.4384665191,
0.3755702078,
-0.1349158436,
-0.9126045704,
-1.1566283703,
0.485542804,
-0.1453719288,
-0.661414206,
0.4501472712,
-0.3606359959,
-0.0941066593,
-0.2631438971,
-0.1467668712,
-0.1022086442,
0.0552541316,
0.4593544602,
0.1993720084,
-0.0280339681,
-0.0540973358,
-0.0106652956,
-0.0545907691,
-0.002855754,
-0.2292195708,
1.1534594297,
0.2401198894,
-0.1731489003,
-0.387681216,
0.7029187679,
0.6088469625,
0.2480705678,
0.8964425921,
0.1407359987,
-0.5376542211,
-0.1442928463,
-0.5663321018,
0.1021330804,
-0.4956100285,
0.0788151547,
-0.3134532869,
-0.9732428193,
0.6501051784,
0.2022017986,
-0.20200333,
0.5214918852,
0.7681264281,
0.242202431,
0.8706411123,
0.819670856,
-0.2243344784,
0.2877743542,
-0.1089332774,
0.0577803068,
-0.5108930469,
-0.1237815842,
-0.7461230159,
-0.2773116529,
-0.5280088186,
-0.4902233779,
0.043270167,
0.1886706203,
-0.1602940708,
0.4088567793,
-0.4858519733,
0.7190579176,
0.8400951028,
-0.1418612897,
0.468049556,
0.1088955551,
0.2597625852,
0.1411772668,
-0.7885357738,
-0.3558687568,
1.0743637085,
0.3130555153,
1.0270744562,
0.3587007821,
0.8564904332,
0.6287173033,
0.1515882313,
-1.0289179087,
0.5388972163,
0.171243459,
-0.4608707726,
-0.2268434316,
-0.282692194,
-1.1329768896,
-0.1272752136,
-0.3450483084,
-1.1818161011,
-0.0971769691,
0.0541430637,
0.0239020362,
0.4670799673,
-0.5683245659,
0.3368884623,
0.2055033743,
0.1511892527,
-0.1332506388,
-0.5434490442,
0.574929893,
-0.0741970912,
0.0257760342,
-0.0903506353,
-0.2847064137,
0.7788337469,
-0.6816017628,
0.4770665169,
0.0951489806,
-0.183559522,
0.2215589434,
0.2989684939,
0.6529344916,
-0.2213527411,
-0.1113540828,
0.6192116141,
0.2198246121,
-0.4129656553,
-0.6194344163,
0.5284751654,
-0.4004916549,
-0.6968348026,
-0.6121938825,
-0.393922627,
0.071180068,
0.1582839489,
0.7057145834,
0.3168121874,
0.2817668915,
0.3250057399,
0.2192274481,
-0.3379509449,
0.7881993651,
0.438434571,
-0.0304894187,
-0.4517687559,
0.5813295245,
0.3216256201,
0.1152600944,
0.7323852181,
0.273889482,
-0.2971752882,
-0.7995812297,
-0.1839453727,
0.2486905456,
-0.8306154013,
-0.8833774328,
-0.4239951074,
-0.30890432,
-0.5950835943,
-0.4727201164,
-0.1029896215,
-0.6693084836,
-0.0374622047,
-0.0497711599,
0.060921777,
0.775637567,
-0.155562073,
0.5331073999,
-0.9600071907,
0.1083256751,
-0.1638011634,
0.2044097185,
-0.0190461297,
-0.7605934143,
-0.1683708876,
-0.2099128366,
-0.1777249277,
-1.2673335075,
0.7458025217,
0.3512675464,
0.4415925741,
0.6073263288,
0.3023919761,
0.378400594,
-0.7845904231,
1.1145604849,
0.4201597273,
-1.0080789328,
0.5239954591,
-0.0159445964,
0.409823209,
0.2201166749,
0.4503983557,
-0.5687962174,
-0.5341747999,
-0.5754390955,
-0.7851136923,
0.2788826525,
0.1191829666,
0.1302054524,
0.0344550684,
0.2060635984,
0.1571526527,
0.3194811344,
-0.9856864214,
-0.3123800755,
0.1455714107,
-0.3872199059,
-0.2198000103,
-0.7430741191,
0.2729723454,
-0.1228032559,
0.7033241987,
0.0029139977,
0.6815963387,
0.1235808358,
-0.1687789857,
-0.0010455129,
0.434248507,
0.9116718769,
0.3867400289,
-0.2901956737,
0.4908239841,
0.2273212224,
-0.7918895483,
0.4181244671,
0.0511030816,
-0.1551143825,
0.0490735658,
0.7091379762,
0.5115248561,
-0.1305059493,
-0.8146045804,
0.5517808199,
-0.1099997312,
-0.1873294264,
-0.4236429334,
-0.0049096951,
-0.1339482963,
0.3322423995,
0.5995838642,
-0.2110169977,
0.5328522921,
-0.6200181246,
-0.065080151,
0.4267384708,
-0.0444303416,
-0.1427242905,
0.8136414886,
-0.0096588992,
-0.3362167776,
0.2359518856,
-0.1849769503,
-0.5565961003,
0.3337852657,
0.7968374491,
0.8349947929,
-0.29614079,
-0.137401849,
0.2448278815,
0.6130532026,
-0.3599046469,
0.2137957066,
-0.1429929733,
-0.6473276019,
-0.8727523088,
-0.8600885868,
-0.2517749369,
0.1596749127,
-0.4006794095,
0.4238689244,
-0.2575387359,
-0.0286250412,
-0.1496058702,
0.0739832968,
-0.4584951401,
0.1343923807,
0.4838437736,
1.4300346375,
-0.7264275551,
0.788028419,
0.2774974406,
-0.2897872329,
-0.8831783533,
0.0932391435,
0.0941491351,
-1.0435061455,
0.6363122463,
0.3162056804,
-0.2967397869,
-0.0763106197,
-0.8139528036,
-1.2661263943,
1.0746366978,
0.9807185531,
-0.5884049535,
-0.1431618184,
0.0045338315,
0.0932469666,
-0.150270924,
0.0230221599,
0.3495282829,
0.4495669901,
0.132973209,
-0.8300741315,
0.2620921731,
-0.332601428,
-0.1508599818,
0.3075964451,
-0.4977838695,
0.5624278188,
-0.0655122399,
-0.4193898141,
0.0683392212,
0.7915181518,
-0.0710224435,
0.1832351238,
0.3378372788,
0.7121658921,
0.7326648831,
0.1064949781,
1.3000234365,
-0.6550430059,
0.3438897729,
0.9539502263,
0.2784720957,
1.1958560944,
0.6365810633,
-0.4151964784,
0.2958296239,
0.7846212983,
0.1179762334,
0.3801246881,
0.4182853997,
-0.3519716859,
-0.0838288218,
-0.2666469514,
-0.4617031515,
0.5141000748,
0.1146714613,
-0.2749153674,
0.1068155169,
-0.1769039929,
0.3125530183,
-0.2753981948,
-0.6462272406,
0.3609946668,
0.1298658997,
-0.4884563982,
1.0727697611,
0.2819102108,
1.1614288092,
-0.5321305394,
0.1024315134,
-0.0896069184,
-0.2316880375,
-0.2568009794,
-0.8382733464,
0.3882677853,
-0.1095265895,
-0.1505035609,
-0.004743902,
0.9332271814,
-0.3992076814,
-0.5953091979,
0.0152649609,
0.1356189251,
0.4552617073,
-0.1236011907,
-0.3242973089,
0.3031851351,
-0.0430372246,
-0.5674372911,
0.1504448354,
0.1938169748,
0.442335844,
1.1158270836,
0.3853805363,
0.514752388,
0.2458033115,
-0.1758310497,
0.6155841351,
-0.5272182822,
-0.3833749294,
-0.9986501336,
0.3118341267,
0.0809505358,
-0.1044620499,
0.8014291525,
0.4910456538,
0.6971337199,
-0.1661801785,
0.7368694544,
-0.0635533035,
0.2544780076,
-1.025537014,
0.4544775486,
-0.7748895288,
0.1762672514,
-0.2065784633,
-1.0382889509,
-0.5771084428,
0.4221153557,
0.1612647921,
-0.3510150909,
0.9272220135,
0.7201262116,
0.1780199111,
-0.4714268744,
0.6565722227,
0.2742134631,
-0.0835955217,
0.7154293656,
0.619668901,
-0.3895785511,
0.4366227984,
-0.0007680929,
-0.0329239964,
-0.2180386484,
-1.144903183,
-0.8317483664,
-0.6644287705,
-0.1315861046,
-0.5984680653,
-0.0538865663,
1.212272644,
0.4630384743,
-0.4396026433,
-0.0222640894,
-0.1256984025,
0.1938734055,
0.0394480191,
-0.2196690142,
0.2656942308,
-0.0030318624,
-0.7765566707,
0.290664196,
0.4006261826,
0.336856395,
-0.5229756832,
-0.1369330138,
-0.0481136143,
0.5485988855,
0.6833306551,
0.1699201167,
-0.5846423507,
-0.23146981,
-0.2751065791,
0.2239242196,
0.0441774689,
0.6732322574,
-0.478659153,
-0.1367179155,
0.8287521005,
0.6188694835,
0.3578999341,
-0.1881297976,
0.7974463105,
-0.7304554582,
0.5492383242,
0.0213775393,
0.6150615215,
0.3921495378,
-0.4587928951,
0.4853899479,
0.1880014986,
-0.6721202731,
-1.2418251038,
0.355984956,
-1.2060317993,
-0.4171223938,
1.4628635645,
0.0171487015,
-0.6253492236,
0.3098606765,
-0.3496334851,
0.0833742693,
-0.6044867635,
0.7155349255,
0.8668078184,
0.1165206507,
-0.6177867651,
-0.7894088626,
0.4107491672,
0.1189275384,
-0.5681598186,
0.0198516902,
0.4563496411,
-0.0228507258,
-0.0446048267,
0.6602785587,
0.3624124229,
-0.0689587221,
0.319006741,
0.1810865849,
0.0340309404,
-0.350613147,
-0.4330197573,
0.3704689443,
0.2822824419,
-0.0789746344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04047v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04047v2 | CAVEN: An Embodied Conversational Agent for Efficient Audio-Visual Navigation in Noisy Environments | 2023-06-06T22:32:49 | 2023-12-27T02:00:30 | Xiulong Liu, Sudipta Paul, Moitreya Chatterjee, Anoop Cherian | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Audio-visual navigation of an agent towards locating an audio goal is a
challenging task especially when the audio is sporadic or the environment is
noisy. In this paper, we present CAVEN, a Conversation-based Audio-Visual
Embodied Navigation framework in which the agent may interact with a
human/oracle for solving the task of navigating to an audio goal. Specifically,
CAVEN is modeled as a budget-aware partially observable semi-Markov decision
process that implicitly learns the uncertainty in the audio-based navigation
policy to decide when and how the agent may interact with the oracle. Our CAVEN
agent can engage in fully-bidirectional natural language conversations by
producing relevant questions and interpret free-form, potentially noisy
responses from the oracle based on the audio-visual context. To enable such a
capability, CAVEN is equipped with: (i) a trajectory forecasting network that
is grounded in audio-visual cues to produce a potential trajectory to the
estimated goal, and (ii) a natural language based question generation and
reasoning network to pose an interactive question to the oracle or interpret
the oracle's response to produce navigation instructions. To train the
interactive modules, we present a large scale dataset: AVN-Instruct, based on
the Landmark-RxR dataset. To substantiate the usefulness of conversations, we
present experiments on the benchmark audio-goal task using the SoundSpaces
simulator under various noisy settings. Our results reveal that our
fully-conversational approach leads to nearly an order-of-magnitude improvement
in success rate, especially in localizing new sound sources and against methods
that only use uni-directional interaction. | [
-0.3338234723,
-0.787050426,
0.6823649406,
0.2563351095,
-0.3154538274,
-0.2271919399,
-0.3956328928,
-0.545055449,
0.4047053456,
0.5749274492,
-0.8106086254,
-0.8018650413,
-0.2620340288,
-0.1858756393,
-0.296638757,
0.3234091401,
0.4143877029,
-0.0791788772,
-0.0465012789,
-0.1012224555,
-0.9135378599,
-0.1442782134,
-1.0567506552,
-0.1631706059,
0.5362314582,
0.0575344227,
0.9303789735,
0.5077744722,
0.1446466297,
0.3397652805,
-0.3464081883,
0.2131479234,
-0.3604340255,
0.5029723644,
0.116784215,
-0.3917267621,
-0.2699237764,
-0.4176527262,
0.1474814415,
0.7126280665,
-0.5318828821,
-0.2730482817,
-0.1198482513,
0.3824976087,
-0.3494053781,
0.7438999414,
-0.1721143872,
0.2026207298,
0.3163012564,
-0.0419229418,
-0.0851173177,
0.1021215916,
0.4864633977,
-0.9490745068,
-0.1067664996,
0.0228531603,
0.5430577993,
0.9013445377,
-0.5633241534,
-0.4342847764,
-1.0972272158,
0.689969182,
-0.5522475839,
0.5297174454,
0.504424274,
0.3243362308,
-0.2606361806,
-0.3940536976,
-0.4634090662,
-0.1438273042,
0.2758373022,
0.4895586669,
-0.3421860039,
0.2741018832,
-0.0019288243,
-0.1311988235,
-0.4017107785,
-0.2348255664,
-0.1777643412,
-0.1415753961,
0.6118784547,
0.100995928,
0.3591888249,
-0.3222838342,
-0.2094126493,
-0.313858211,
-0.2466315776,
0.0707980394,
0.135472998,
0.3994823098,
-0.2040618658,
0.4291166961,
-0.2132936567,
0.8633825183,
-0.1582906246,
-0.1211122796,
0.050212428,
-0.4600612223,
0.1238329038,
0.6968623996,
0.6439635754,
0.3974732757,
0.0516652316,
-0.23698318,
-0.4994180202,
-0.1591269225,
0.398249805,
-0.4353105426,
-0.4053098559,
0.2195326984,
0.0307550859,
-0.147163257,
-0.1897638142,
-0.4622572064,
-0.3989284337,
-0.5428869128,
0.5572648644,
-0.3680137396,
-0.3551760018,
0.4243482947,
-0.0548001714,
0.2608079314,
0.707752049,
-0.5509651899,
0.2375630736,
0.4487200677,
0.8926420808,
0.1360843182,
0.1057891846,
-0.5454295278,
0.3819695413,
-0.5722121596,
0.5481445789,
-0.3917680383,
-0.7109582424,
0.000981066,
-0.2252616882,
0.0035024849,
-0.4745499194,
0.5132208467,
-0.1944151521,
-0.0634942129,
-0.1020586491,
-0.0096553052,
-0.3623169065,
0.2006466091,
-0.68111974,
0.7133473754,
-0.2548387647,
-0.2463562936,
0.2429317534,
-0.5920909643,
-0.6258974671,
0.0028298558,
-0.3634943068,
-0.2003120482,
-0.443249464,
0.4495544434,
0.2550401092,
-0.1065561399,
0.2520481348,
0.2697027922,
-0.5698208809,
0.0637648404,
-0.4390449226,
0.5513707995,
0.0854623541,
-0.8134229779,
0.1782424152,
-0.6312686801,
-0.3839188516,
-0.0394552089,
-0.4688256979,
-0.435038805,
0.201182574,
-0.0201112777,
-0.0452933088,
0.0457430333,
-0.3557827771,
0.0133022564,
-0.5565186143,
0.0447205156,
0.6392262578,
0.3208961487,
0.5373345017,
-0.2617575824,
0.5016061068,
-0.1673056036,
0.1789970249,
-0.2127990723,
-0.8008759618,
-0.6805121899,
-0.2892437875,
-0.1878047287,
0.5376537442,
-0.6983476281,
0.1543973833,
-0.2919516265,
-0.1313634962,
-0.2994224131,
0.0180335902,
0.3431933522,
0.5593103766,
0.1829329878,
-0.013127774,
-0.5367166996,
-0.4270316064,
0.1309072226,
-0.5950071216,
-0.1843473911,
0.9916979074,
0.2397353798,
-0.3662681878,
0.7297007442,
-0.2224077433,
-0.5150655508,
-0.0188249629,
0.4993984699,
0.3173887432,
0.3971400261,
0.1297632754,
-1.1148805618,
-0.2412227392,
-0.0210635085,
-0.893381536,
-0.202986598,
-0.4806173444,
-0.1790342629,
-0.1792794019,
0.5238429904,
-0.7407867908,
0.5917262435,
0.3151740134,
-0.0657476708,
0.1412653774,
-0.13787283,
0.3187207878,
-0.9088073969,
-0.3429551423,
-0.0918818563,
-0.2609987557,
-0.501730442,
-0.3915167749,
-0.7087903619,
-0.3027344644,
-0.4540682137,
0.4953319132,
-0.5405492187,
-0.1164834499,
-0.1560809612,
0.540946424,
-0.1309228539,
0.8963130713,
0.4396390617,
0.7056238651,
0.9161971807,
-0.7654618025,
0.6591655016,
0.6983055472,
-0.2706419826,
0.6138043404,
-0.7305443287,
0.2038640082,
-0.109562479,
0.2098145187,
-0.909783721,
0.0473384857,
0.4834249318,
-0.3105897307,
0.2294017971,
-0.5331194401,
-0.2014213502,
0.0880570263,
0.3051926196,
0.5173717737,
0.4646799266,
-0.5764467716,
0.9615274668,
0.2841165662,
-0.218414709,
-0.3794246614,
-0.562125802,
0.452062726,
-0.1740018278,
-0.9227052927,
-0.1267651618,
-0.1219489574,
-0.3048118949,
-0.1242396012,
-0.4954234064,
0.1289436966,
-0.2160664201,
0.7228769064,
0.4711993933,
-0.349298656,
-0.1016173214,
-0.2504071295,
-0.0698160455,
0.3371236026,
-0.7419544458,
0.1015482619,
-0.3135781884,
-0.4399514496,
-0.3555347919,
0.252422452,
0.4476917684,
-0.0669428706,
0.3794955611,
0.3517379463,
-0.1839850396,
-0.0148837715,
-0.4189125299,
-0.332231164,
-0.4351715446,
0.4567946494,
-0.2363066524,
-0.4665032327,
0.2765864134,
-0.4782438874,
0.0522573702,
-0.2750123143,
0.3628479242,
-0.2210523486,
1.1368877888,
0.2837872505,
0.3049060404,
0.4919323921,
-0.5239721537,
0.132470265,
-0.707305491,
-0.7823240161,
-0.2448347211,
-0.3052611053,
-0.0918402523,
-0.684915781,
0.7158839703,
-0.2953085601,
-0.2303730398,
0.484387815,
-0.375243783,
0.1966843754,
0.5863752961,
0.2361141741,
0.2067118287,
-0.2572557926,
-0.1653717458,
0.1199246943,
-0.787170589,
-0.2622874081,
0.6302044392,
-0.0732832924,
1.1057885885,
0.3679770529,
0.5609324574,
0.2853635848,
-0.3516590893,
-0.884690702,
0.720040977,
0.5799241066,
-0.6188188195,
-0.8990130424,
-0.557174921,
-1.2303017378,
0.2869167626,
-0.4519197643,
-0.8214956522,
0.4764540493,
-0.0099098841,
-0.2642444074,
0.0709987581,
-0.4316541553,
0.8783560991,
-0.4325039387,
-0.5114347935,
-0.2120718211,
-0.8920941949,
-0.129076004,
0.2467231303,
0.2417850941,
-0.1252015829,
-0.1322261095,
0.7977750301,
-0.0592652261,
0.7208531499,
-0.1821847111,
0.0320826098,
0.4682497978,
0.4178056121,
0.5887357593,
0.1465956718,
0.0922632143,
0.294585675,
-0.1650476605,
-0.2029871196,
-0.762114048,
0.3887679279,
-0.6348049641,
-0.4783921838,
-0.3075397313,
-0.3704625666,
-0.2946445942,
0.2968130708,
0.0517590232,
0.6681002378,
-0.410338968,
0.2197251022,
0.8568510413,
-0.2639605105,
0.3029861152,
0.5439037085,
-0.2339110672,
-0.1369335949,
0.7095860839,
-0.306593895,
-0.0273248237,
0.6107282043,
0.1726034582,
-0.5151290298,
-0.1660238057,
-0.4625403881,
0.0150016602,
-0.6281936765,
0.1148052439,
-0.489897728,
-0.0962367728,
-0.0002673978,
-0.2369729429,
-0.6491470337,
-0.2121894062,
-0.2304490358,
-0.1477584988,
0.0266086813,
0.6333118677,
-0.1899766177,
0.2446547151,
-0.271553129,
0.3918120265,
0.7088420987,
-0.0929924846,
-0.0894914716,
-0.3973427117,
-0.2749276757,
0.3353885412,
0.2278434634,
-0.8917249441,
0.2376391441,
0.102889888,
0.6609454751,
0.4378513098,
0.2917429805,
0.5394548178,
-0.1867002845,
0.5909360647,
0.2519423366,
-0.4947351217,
0.7617627978,
-0.5000043511,
0.4839212596,
0.3604875207,
-0.0014749571,
-0.5693210363,
-0.4278994501,
-0.4104988575,
-0.9989488721,
0.7375666499,
0.6810495853,
0.0905066729,
0.2420575917,
0.1680637151,
-0.4438961744,
0.3252814114,
-0.2750091255,
-0.286275506,
-0.4917059541,
0.1199764088,
-0.1177729368,
0.1686658263,
-0.2607829571,
-0.1041398719,
0.7759720087,
-0.1305316091,
0.24151209,
0.4221260846,
0.1638330668,
0.0154270148,
0.0746917501,
0.3498647809,
0.1933131665,
-0.3443748951,
0.1456855386,
0.0875036567,
-0.2556470037,
0.1101320386,
-0.0588566102,
-0.0535304621,
0.1153771654,
0.3468421698,
0.9602811337,
0.7649937272,
-0.8595082164,
0.746039927,
-0.4350405037,
-0.0675494894,
-0.5989215374,
0.2001735866,
0.2855140567,
0.4598555267,
0.1905944496,
0.4334608912,
0.3794282973,
-0.4967449009,
0.1966287047,
0.3089903891,
-1.0201673508,
0.0069225794,
1.049926877,
0.3368822038,
-0.4636367559,
0.7790415883,
0.1168110222,
-0.2078511566,
0.4657376707,
0.2279745787,
0.85100317,
0.0668701306,
0.3050146997,
0.3884130418,
0.2444587052,
0.0130777471,
0.0751257986,
-0.734406054,
-0.4859462976,
-0.2146378458,
-0.3851043284,
-0.5157513618,
-0.3731965423,
-0.4531680346,
0.0602480955,
-0.0995903686,
-0.2502138317,
-0.2986719906,
-0.4100800753,
-0.4786503911,
0.1985893697,
0.4393008351,
0.4811886549,
-0.3921950758,
0.2037449926,
0.7206201553,
-0.5190988183,
-1.0030487776,
-0.0365942717,
0.26065889,
-0.6994060278,
0.3901022971,
-0.1781496257,
-0.7781536579,
-0.2102837712,
-0.7602163553,
-0.5534415245,
1.2075868845,
0.5928113461,
-0.5314810872,
-0.0110866101,
-0.080146499,
0.3934253454,
-0.1906578243,
0.1537598968,
0.116086252,
0.6449251771,
0.9114405513,
-0.7153405547,
-0.1233031899,
-0.4133113623,
-0.1498928666,
0.1369865835,
-0.5997498631,
0.3414852619,
-0.3334984183,
-0.1261214167,
0.2392653376,
0.7259411812,
-0.0357276499,
0.3020377457,
0.7853765488,
0.0945062712,
0.7399979234,
-0.1632192135,
0.9682284594,
-0.237885505,
-0.1659921408,
0.9486678839,
0.0179215223,
0.533341825,
0.3979127109,
0.2178393006,
0.5507362485,
0.3793030679,
0.2789429128,
0.6465739012,
0.1623216271,
-0.6786028147,
-0.7351007462,
-0.2082320452,
-0.0084903147,
0.4986964166,
0.0395588353,
0.3172129393,
0.1274155676,
0.155702889,
-0.1620267779,
0.0344086438,
-0.1064949259,
1.0751322508,
0.2287612259,
-0.6357313991,
0.3161622882,
-0.3051869571,
0.2674675286,
-0.7339949012,
-0.459908247,
-0.2090771645,
-0.0692134798,
-0.0051080398,
-0.6208662987,
-0.140814811,
-0.389434129,
0.2363970429,
-0.1019376665,
0.5579538345,
-0.6329886317,
-0.115578413,
0.3203686178,
0.4331639409,
0.538074553,
-0.2656745017,
-0.5019643307,
-0.0152262179,
-0.0055492367,
-0.0933830142,
0.0019509915,
0.4994859993,
0.1269740015,
1.1058471203,
0.6559669971,
0.1824568361,
0.0203962773,
0.2354493141,
0.5480291247,
-0.5195096731,
-0.86084342,
-0.1498598307,
0.4116644561,
0.1299622357,
-0.0446504578,
0.4676552117,
0.6691507101,
0.4202182293,
0.1901233047,
0.4753880799,
0.2729326785,
-0.0363394022,
-0.6449734569,
0.5543488264,
-0.6421821117,
0.7075947523,
-0.4626559019,
-0.9839458466,
-0.1062137336,
1.0192579031,
-0.1471908391,
0.136329934,
0.3134420514,
1.1096093655,
-0.2103590816,
0.2221142352,
0.5448082685,
0.173231855,
0.2466446459,
0.5405266881,
0.9757113457,
-0.1876473427,
1.0120126009,
-0.2866958976,
-0.2291003019,
-0.0356500931,
-0.4636828005,
-0.6445914507,
-0.8373938799,
-0.4833401442,
-0.3232099712,
0.5324907899,
0.6934980154,
1.1269745827,
-0.383640945,
-0.4715595841,
-0.1227341592,
0.2422723919,
-0.333244592,
-0.1700788587,
0.1963090748,
0.2199800014,
-0.7586265206,
0.9468063116,
0.4730654061,
0.129162237,
-0.0586618744,
-0.7645406127,
-0.1662083268,
0.2094402909,
0.2273568213,
0.5078932047,
-0.523732841,
-0.2818808258,
0.08103735,
-0.1193404645,
0.1710149199,
0.660523355,
-0.7740412354,
0.9672108293,
-0.171002835,
0.3692026138,
1.1784496307,
-0.0286189783,
0.6027141809,
-0.6572118402,
0.2155103832,
0.3141158819,
0.1588084251,
0.3693208098,
-0.2866128087,
0.5202468634,
0.126181677,
-0.4658372402,
-0.2903110981,
-0.0571776666,
-1.3996812105,
-0.1359339058,
1.3083107471,
0.1367196441,
-0.301428616,
-0.4999960959,
-0.8443953991,
0.336591661,
-0.7670450807,
0.5090597868,
0.232794553,
-0.3028331399,
-0.2426951528,
-0.5844091177,
0.2994506359,
0.3551029563,
-0.2225543261,
-0.1442181766,
0.6780039668,
-0.1957475692,
0.1593361497,
0.600759685,
0.0858215243,
0.3909629285,
0.3271140158,
0.1141570881,
-0.2413156033,
-0.437769115,
-0.0128669795,
-0.2139636278,
-0.1737642437,
-0.3471989632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04043v1 | An Analysis of Reader Engagement in Literary Fiction through Eye Tracking and Linguistic Features | 2023-06-06T22:14:59 | 2023-06-06T22:14:59 | Rose Neis, Karin de Langis, Zae Myung Kim, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Capturing readers' engagement in fiction is a challenging but important
aspect of narrative understanding. In this study, we collected 23 readers'
reactions to 2 short stories through eye tracking, sentence-level annotations,
and an overall engagement scale survey. We analyzed the significance of various
qualities of the text in predicting how engaging a reader is likely to find it.
As enjoyment of fiction is highly contextual, we also investigated individual
differences in our data. Furthering our understanding of what captivates
readers in fiction will help better inform models used in creative narrative
generation and collaborative writing tools. | [
-0.4824779034,
-0.7433347702,
1.0002939701,
-0.1112944409,
-0.370539844,
0.1656287611,
-0.1239758432,
-0.9111824632,
0.4697607458,
0.3887986243,
-0.5046896338,
-0.4520468116,
-0.3948657811,
0.3142375052,
-0.2774684131,
0.5691440701,
-0.4057740271,
-0.4156318307,
-0.5205622315,
-0.310033679,
-0.4581111073,
-0.3303125203,
-0.0097603304,
0.1046103537,
1.1332598925,
0.2040208727,
0.7832171321,
0.333941251,
0.7685545683,
0.2637408972,
-0.1751779616,
-0.0346077979,
-0.5796470642,
0.0071831946,
-0.0846474543,
-0.776499331,
0.1740625799,
0.4675052762,
0.4689027667,
0.4011684656,
0.2849439085,
0.1263114214,
0.1375081241,
0.9323049784,
-0.5355021358,
-0.1611058712,
0.2409622818,
0.2083024383,
-0.7915307283,
-0.4195370078,
-0.5643467903,
-0.5936975479,
0.4041334689,
-0.7075765133,
0.4073742628,
0.4985267818,
0.4426141381,
0.0155179063,
-0.6108518839,
-0.7125482559,
-0.3976802826,
0.761598289,
-0.2716813982,
-0.0069121285,
0.2766027153,
-0.0116482722,
0.3486077487,
-0.1278789937,
-0.8853518963,
-0.3096201122,
-0.4253676236,
0.2563557625,
-0.0185806211,
-0.2089616954,
0.2756525874,
0.6067026854,
-0.6190556288,
-0.0000131916,
-0.0858412683,
0.3084492981,
0.8414515257,
0.4068074226,
0.6711008549,
-0.1408454925,
-0.2400196493,
-0.0718881115,
-0.3147304356,
0.582013309,
0.7661783695,
-0.2344592065,
-0.1377768666,
1.000656724,
-0.1000423133,
0.6019721031,
0.1073029414,
-0.0286766551,
0.280769974,
-0.5458661914,
0.0948127657,
0.0110150427,
0.740998745,
0.8778392673,
0.5336550474,
-0.0586299188,
0.0885237455,
0.2176886052,
0.3221107125,
-0.3935609758,
0.3249579966,
0.3729282022,
-0.6769511104,
-0.4898180068,
0.0056688804,
-0.5690672994,
-0.6819080114,
-0.0477692448,
0.0986356363,
-0.3592616618,
-0.2463222891,
0.2483970225,
-0.7602687478,
0.1207344234,
0.272267133,
-1.2676608562,
-0.209465608,
0.522895813,
0.8697935939,
-0.6201691031,
-0.4344578981,
-0.0025459682,
0.0057844925,
-0.5796041489,
0.9082096219,
-0.2767491341,
-0.1089390293,
0.1913421005,
-0.0924787894,
-0.4039525986,
-0.1342339963,
0.2449170351,
-0.4202809334,
0.3394870162,
-0.2579575181,
-0.5800401568,
-0.467023164,
0.1331070662,
-0.7965222597,
0.7393293381,
0.2320899367,
-0.6919901371,
0.4807799459,
-0.2330327481,
-0.1951083541,
0.2050595433,
-0.0476833954,
-0.0305052735,
0.7606264949,
-0.0598284826,
0.1842541397,
-0.1007255912,
0.0303676818,
0.0506447144,
-0.5144840479,
0.7034455538,
0.1458800584,
0.4150380194,
-0.0653241053,
-0.3133920133,
0.0254833288,
-0.1231251359,
-0.23561351,
0.1226837263,
-0.0213187765,
-0.4412309229,
0.168609485,
0.4598452747,
-0.184927687,
0.1910839081,
-0.7409361005,
0.1044507772,
-0.5155061483,
0.0510136746,
-0.1344758868,
0.5570005774,
0.3917306364,
-0.4813988507,
0.8823227286,
-0.2115803957,
0.043868646,
-0.4573147595,
-0.3782565296,
-0.5485969186,
-0.0462143011,
0.0768615007,
0.3756764233,
-0.6234519482,
-0.0207137559,
0.3211415708,
-0.6389956474,
-0.4664150476,
0.0871752948,
0.4454597831,
0.1333108842,
-0.109958984,
-0.0078711472,
0.1575267166,
-0.5756849647,
-0.7021660209,
-0.2637343705,
0.0360730588,
0.3473192751,
0.3863298297,
0.0057447609,
0.9916642904,
-0.6472289562,
-0.5668767095,
-0.6875423789,
0.2627936602,
-0.1734857857,
0.4063012004,
1.0631767511,
-0.9465184212,
-0.8675413728,
0.2743106186,
-1.0769488811,
-0.0706537142,
-0.3791984618,
-0.0656147152,
-0.0803715438,
0.5973008871,
-0.5936297178,
0.828089118,
0.219730407,
-0.5160878301,
0.3800885081,
0.3720634878,
0.7113583088,
-0.4467541277,
-0.0587588772,
0.2910549045,
0.0179631375,
-0.6378734708,
0.2218040377,
0.0065716477,
-0.0129473805,
-0.6971521378,
0.4334988594,
-0.7040585876,
0.3294779956,
-0.0875226781,
0.5307683945,
0.1988851428,
0.1790805161,
0.5037693381,
0.6208691597,
0.2531208396,
-0.0344721749,
0.2846325934,
0.5520808101,
-0.5610017776,
0.3714804649,
-0.474388063,
-0.0617468283,
-0.1747186035,
-0.3677303493,
-1.3847980499,
-0.6139591336,
-0.1868048012,
-0.5763103366,
-0.1231633797,
0.331189543,
-0.4547076225,
-0.0774173513,
-0.5004777312,
0.4566437602,
0.1722621769,
-0.3224582076,
0.7563081384,
0.2754395306,
-0.2763868272,
-0.0245423112,
-0.8249839544,
-0.0059533515,
-0.592289567,
-0.5954309702,
-0.1090265736,
-0.2126790285,
-0.4271966517,
-0.1699604541,
0.2477006912,
0.127969861,
0.046323102,
0.1431818306,
0.0081560686,
-0.1057860181,
-0.0812987387,
0.0351151899,
-0.0943390802,
-0.0513000712,
0.7791612744,
0.0154733891,
-0.1137576327,
-0.2158890963,
-0.7037613392,
0.9451270103,
0.5335355401,
-0.3261300325,
0.4559807777,
0.4900001884,
-0.1073065922,
0.1190722063,
-0.5901052952,
0.0717154369,
-0.3975635469,
0.0197955593,
-0.2624022067,
-1.075966835,
0.3768052757,
0.1977903843,
-0.196253106,
0.4587006271,
0.7012669444,
-0.6500138044,
0.7074284554,
1.0628376007,
0.4534572363,
0.6787837744,
0.3257959783,
0.373342365,
-0.7689199448,
-0.3147896826,
-0.4146464765,
-0.4724431336,
-0.1927092075,
0.0380640477,
0.2497725338,
0.3174370825,
0.5872235894,
0.3866518438,
-0.4763620496,
0.9112519026,
0.4738096297,
-0.2081236094,
0.2847659588,
-0.2530684471,
-0.0011652489,
-0.3400884569,
-0.0802228227,
-0.4613394737,
0.654430449,
0.3462028205,
0.6161909103,
0.8073989153,
0.8116939664,
0.3922845721,
0.038572289,
-0.9060301185,
0.2928798199,
0.3260457516,
-0.4646439552,
-0.4145424664,
0.1311953515,
-0.7437982559,
0.0710581467,
-0.366659075,
-1.1313704252,
0.7329449654,
-0.0213829242,
-0.5833559036,
-0.372025162,
-1.0473537445,
1.1730940342,
-0.086260654,
-0.3521516919,
-0.2987095118,
-0.5417022705,
0.3437773287,
-0.1735410392,
-0.1616091132,
-0.1794627309,
-0.0434569977,
0.6459185481,
-0.1019274741,
0.9624342918,
0.2766230106,
0.2782067955,
0.7745682597,
0.5391911864,
0.0599072315,
0.0294372793,
0.1636575609,
-0.0203024037,
0.1837636828,
-0.1604443789,
-0.3252010942,
0.4899322093,
-0.1688025743,
-0.5688012838,
-0.9118683934,
-0.8393551111,
-0.2854454815,
0.0648266077,
0.4340204895,
0.3399267495,
-0.4286646843,
0.3899116516,
0.4251916409,
0.2808594704,
1.1218247414,
0.4350152016,
-0.3038136363,
-0.1395350695,
0.2952401042,
0.0267444495,
0.538516283,
0.3216193318,
0.0579835661,
-0.5074781179,
-0.7182520032,
-0.393767029,
0.2697032094,
-0.3840504885,
0.2128156871,
-0.6868064404,
0.3772630692,
0.0520092621,
-0.8197435141,
0.1797486544,
-0.146154657,
-0.7393373847,
-0.197429195,
0.3670100868,
0.7847998738,
0.3051839769,
0.6539139748,
-0.6429331303,
0.1675935388,
-0.041095484,
0.0633016005,
-0.0574963167,
-0.0122490888,
-0.6831172109,
-0.8933818936,
-0.1091751233,
-1.167755127,
0.4543437362,
0.1162562221,
0.2082042396,
0.4252391756,
0.1334613264,
0.2998083234,
-0.1984288245,
1.2444996834,
0.3071599007,
-0.8419151306,
0.5780310631,
-0.6513886452,
0.5267927051,
0.7508662939,
0.494628489,
-0.5685389638,
-0.5988241434,
-0.2099770159,
-0.2552553415,
0.4628543854,
0.0447397828,
0.0093839224,
-0.2017258704,
0.0590027981,
0.0760458708,
0.5425572395,
-0.7808416486,
0.0871855021,
0.2138516754,
-0.4198504984,
-0.5970201492,
-0.5179803967,
-0.1118704826,
0.1433060318,
-0.1194834337,
-0.3347815573,
-0.0904029235,
0.225374341,
-0.2595527768,
-0.3052067161,
-0.0331282169,
0.4024301171,
0.7127818465,
-0.3138670921,
-0.1942885667,
-0.4421077371,
-0.8234506249,
-0.1736345142,
-0.2145553082,
-0.2609793842,
0.1745226085,
0.7033285499,
0.4980186224,
-0.0015811233,
-0.8868439794,
0.8254099488,
0.0362332687,
0.0853319764,
-0.2998137772,
0.1825598478,
0.1064163968,
0.638242662,
0.3161870241,
0.2602909505,
0.4134083092,
-0.7300994396,
-0.1531031579,
0.3099122941,
-0.5450994968,
-0.0849993452,
0.6400048137,
0.3605978787,
-0.0754644945,
0.0331588946,
-0.1116161793,
-0.311863184,
0.5800842047,
0.4292321205,
0.9580973983,
0.2518011034,
0.2714817226,
0.2581753731,
0.452049613,
0.2705604136,
0.1169378459,
-0.0912825391,
-0.4104480147,
-0.3174627721,
-0.3853635788,
-0.5572637916,
-0.6056121588,
-0.7927897573,
0.0988944322,
0.0251854695,
-0.1902444214,
0.3254935443,
-0.0814431086,
-0.3551592529,
0.0639473721,
0.1781200022,
0.6197362542,
-0.9472236633,
0.4383084774,
0.3774938881,
-0.7101815939,
-0.3415385187,
0.1884399951,
0.5268313289,
-0.0564176254,
0.1927924007,
0.4745921493,
-0.0560759194,
-0.0946025401,
-0.4123728275,
-0.6654447913,
0.8686600924,
-0.0498175956,
-0.4878848791,
0.0140539855,
0.1352262795,
0.7719065547,
-0.774535656,
0.2691858113,
0.7485954762,
0.1539481133,
-0.3190759122,
-0.6306768656,
-0.3721141815,
-0.2208480984,
0.0891895443,
0.2697601318,
-0.8265749812,
0.4587991834,
-0.2750273347,
-0.4325570166,
0.424592644,
0.7667583227,
0.0311660916,
0.9752550721,
0.2246383727,
0.1196552441,
0.3502242267,
-0.3000586629,
1.2888795137,
0.1419504881,
0.3146300316,
0.644061029,
-0.2972983122,
1.1210974455,
0.6934135556,
0.1909926087,
0.5766702294,
0.7057190537,
0.1031002551,
0.5364521742,
-0.2473579496,
-0.4732768536,
-0.2057971954,
-0.247363925,
-0.2090748549,
0.2659903169,
0.0654373318,
-0.2841835618,
0.4386249185,
0.6692880392,
-0.2186207175,
0.5494049788,
-0.2861036062,
0.8077440262,
0.0263456125,
-0.7601738572,
-0.0522978902,
-0.4042505622,
0.1991480291,
-0.5526772141,
-0.0675286651,
0.0347391963,
-0.0454098806,
-0.2987704873,
-1.3360543251,
0.1211148724,
0.2363213748,
-0.6922216415,
-0.1527301818,
0.4401515722,
-0.3740293682,
-0.2739849389,
0.2467887402,
0.3863244653,
0.2977387011,
-0.1060341522,
-0.0753818676,
0.5131368041,
0.3812069893,
-0.5444420576,
0.3224318922,
0.4625943303,
0.0595013276,
0.1708969027,
0.5815910697,
-0.3086546063,
-0.075834468,
-0.0802288651,
0.1915071309,
-0.9440847635,
-0.6948487163,
-0.4135335982,
0.8175823092,
0.0167673919,
-0.9439178705,
0.9199441671,
0.5018916726,
0.3042998314,
-0.5708918571,
0.3311268389,
-0.1395001113,
0.7413311601,
-0.5076967478,
0.6080503464,
-0.5274764299,
-0.0418710262,
-0.0962897316,
-1.0376133919,
-0.1024390459,
0.2857880592,
-0.3157239258,
-0.3435473144,
1.1314532757,
0.2738457024,
0.3569107354,
0.1787162423,
0.4711749554,
-0.151289463,
-0.2576793432,
0.3909458518,
1.0985950232,
-0.0764353871,
-0.0908475816,
-0.0369821899,
-0.4709643722,
-0.3884361684,
-0.9594454765,
-1.1766672134,
-0.6172227263,
-0.4990183413,
-0.0744308978,
-0.3306059241,
0.1499928832,
0.1221278906,
-0.506560564,
-0.0443320014,
0.2710457742,
-0.0336688869,
-0.3269639909,
-0.2366581112,
0.2140386403,
-0.3436991274,
-1.0316231251,
0.4649987519,
0.4732831419,
0.1636958271,
-0.2548647821,
0.4209248722,
-0.2470757514,
0.377484709,
0.5299023986,
0.2312415689,
-0.7607873678,
-0.302628994,
0.077162087,
-0.2612915039,
-0.1139606014,
0.7835150361,
-0.5737814903,
0.7430377007,
0.6761907339,
0.2694865465,
0.8199646473,
0.2437005788,
0.1926530451,
-0.4109268785,
0.2621767223,
0.3503174484,
0.2025080025,
0.1526892334,
-0.9155797958,
0.6019336581,
0.3954769671,
-0.7829690576,
-0.7323237062,
0.1774664223,
-1.6547393799,
0.1716039181,
0.9161827564,
0.0339071602,
-0.3303747773,
-0.0047184336,
-0.5297856927,
-0.4941496551,
-0.0598354191,
0.1383606344,
1.1907088757,
-0.4801996648,
-0.4349113107,
-0.7823671103,
0.5435537696,
0.2518056631,
-0.6601947546,
0.0118662156,
0.7882611752,
-0.1363383085,
0.4162743986,
0.4300427735,
-0.0754693896,
0.4674288929,
0.2178405374,
-0.0151457693,
0.102223523,
-0.3916736841,
-0.1382634342,
0.5165936947,
-0.0465240777,
0.0003784209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06083v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06083v1 | Improving Fairness and Robustness in End-to-End Speech Recognition through unsupervised clustering | 2023-06-06T21:13:08 | 2023-06-06T21:13:08 | Irina-Elena Veliche, Pascale Fung | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | The challenge of fairness arises when Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
systems do not perform equally well for all sub-groups of the population. In
the past few years there have been many improvements in overall speech
recognition quality, but without any particular focus on advancing Equality and
Equity for all user groups for whom systems do not perform well. ASR fairness
is therefore also a robustness issue. Meanwhile, data privacy also takes
priority in production systems. In this paper, we present a privacy preserving
approach to improve fairness and robustness of end-to-end ASR without using
metadata, zip codes, or even speaker or utterance embeddings directly in
training. We extract utterance level embeddings using a speaker ID model
trained on a public dataset, which we then use in an unsupervised fashion to
create acoustic clusters. We use cluster IDs instead of speaker utterance
embeddings as extra features during model training, which shows improvements
for all demographic groups and in particular for different accents. | [
-0.3511550426,
-0.0588037148,
0.1670310646,
-0.2237956524,
-0.3348370492,
0.21623227,
-0.4313319921,
-0.2734053135,
0.1576784551,
0.3912388682,
0.0008657665,
-0.6292026639,
-0.782417357,
-0.0722489133,
-0.6120114326,
1.0115804672,
0.7329143286,
0.0678081214,
-0.4353789687,
-0.3379101157,
0.0417242721,
-0.7394558191,
-0.6477602124,
-0.1088959724,
-0.0187095851,
0.3343349993,
0.4954614937,
0.8362422585,
0.1530803442,
0.3863225579,
-0.4876886904,
-0.1167281419,
-0.3326705992,
-0.0104009081,
-0.2058350146,
-0.354108125,
-0.3059695065,
-0.2208952159,
0.7999580503,
0.921426475,
-0.4954208434,
0.2706148922,
0.1819265634,
0.6117755175,
-0.689904213,
0.0029068519,
-0.612888217,
0.1550583243,
-0.3643798232,
-0.1734861284,
-0.1626533568,
-0.6095420718,
-0.09023197,
-0.3702116907,
0.3561905324,
-0.0568722077,
0.5645953417,
0.5453856587,
-0.3105761409,
-0.0747706667,
-0.739160955,
0.585881114,
-0.6310865879,
0.681009829,
0.4757983685,
0.4322960377,
-0.1872723997,
-0.3345859647,
-0.4903505445,
0.3741466999,
0.0626735091,
0.2135822773,
-0.4054450095,
0.1555542946,
0.2108833641,
0.3954506516,
-0.4863635004,
0.3818357289,
-0.4151006043,
-0.3422826231,
0.5389744043,
-0.3375350237,
-0.2007533163,
0.1341353357,
-0.0374901332,
-0.2593595088,
-0.5243870616,
0.7366853356,
0.5386604071,
0.4436704218,
0.0241641793,
0.5141037107,
-0.3244684637,
0.2994140983,
0.3301427066,
-0.2190716416,
0.6642643213,
0.2356450111,
-0.0773972124,
0.5612287521,
0.5778795481,
0.5156865716,
0.2821965218,
-0.4630053341,
-0.2452833354,
0.4307979941,
-0.1793416589,
-0.5300574303,
0.1497048438,
0.2366335392,
-0.7089216113,
-0.0607948937,
0.4853298664,
-0.8012285233,
-0.3091975451,
-0.2801756561,
0.1399172395,
0.05838117,
-0.2370146662,
0.0740848556,
-0.1376979202,
0.1990476847,
-0.0565406419,
-0.8992555141,
0.7223562598,
0.8056601286,
0.6124597788,
0.0090716509,
0.0350645147,
-0.8869046569,
0.4904561639,
-0.1888404489,
0.6312509179,
-0.709774673,
-0.63032341,
-0.2045608014,
0.1572805047,
0.1492889673,
-0.7963849902,
0.4038422704,
-0.1767912507,
0.3493282795,
-0.1704845279,
-0.5458179712,
-0.1724511087,
-0.1626872718,
-0.2067154646,
0.5651357174,
-0.3533151448,
-0.4935451448,
0.4697823524,
-0.6836065054,
-0.60230124,
-0.2787851989,
-0.6340476871,
-0.7525128126,
0.450412184,
0.4407261014,
0.0999652371,
0.0486986972,
0.4123200178,
-0.2132218778,
-0.433034867,
0.297428757,
-0.4323239923,
0.6891871095,
0.2459803671,
-0.3051901162,
0.1389046013,
-0.9975898266,
-0.0874127299,
-0.2059086412,
-0.3165070117,
-0.0599281117,
0.1844637096,
-0.0466006324,
-0.0385460593,
0.11345011,
-1.0453538895,
-0.642834723,
-0.5634378195,
0.3657170236,
1.0415428877,
-0.3305623531,
0.7938092947,
-0.3746496439,
0.2009325176,
0.1564445198,
0.3311305046,
0.0476439446,
-0.6819172502,
-0.6126242876,
-0.3049118817,
0.5757075548,
0.55216676,
-0.1465647817,
0.9859021902,
-0.4057218432,
0.0067495024,
-0.6268719435,
-0.3597031236,
0.455273807,
0.3417019844,
-0.0412917025,
-0.7993898988,
-0.2936287224,
-0.8573897481,
-0.2810330987,
0.036234308,
-0.462207675,
0.3887986541,
-0.1542601436,
-0.112558715,
1.2795802355,
-0.1519588977,
-0.562443912,
0.2404950857,
-0.1487510353,
0.2462218106,
0.7574241757,
0.1564867646,
-0.8485569358,
-0.2994863987,
0.2078195065,
-0.4685504436,
-0.2175492048,
0.4645089209,
0.1553173363,
0.264654547,
0.4709846377,
-0.043742694,
0.7436827421,
0.4028082192,
-0.4638209343,
-0.269602716,
-0.3077838421,
0.1829958558,
-0.8595406413,
0.1410503238,
-0.254629761,
-0.480155468,
-0.6853794456,
-0.268725276,
-0.2704749703,
-0.4439110756,
-0.2363249063,
0.1455375701,
-0.2842724323,
-0.7599621415,
-0.3266950548,
-0.1372441053,
-0.1978250593,
0.4483312964,
-0.0615607612,
0.5801219344,
0.9072864652,
-0.4726082087,
0.0760507137,
0.2421823144,
0.0067692106,
0.715870142,
-0.528672874,
0.4342571795,
-0.5243947506,
0.1780020297,
-0.5807479024,
-0.0055672037,
-0.0617579818,
-0.957313478,
0.4317319691,
-0.3345212042,
-0.3645804822,
0.0500211045,
-0.2286536843,
0.3382829428,
1.0547751188,
-0.7436836958,
0.6272539496,
0.8473784328,
-0.2129010409,
-0.4670668542,
-0.5585640073,
-0.0254232958,
-0.5082840323,
-0.4675371945,
0.3183191121,
-0.0974310637,
-0.0855166093,
-0.1081292927,
-0.3046137989,
-0.3463488817,
-0.1042453945,
0.443456471,
-0.3381952345,
0.209382683,
-0.1045478135,
0.1778529435,
-0.6486413479,
-0.1259452403,
-0.3680358827,
0.2212772071,
0.0425913371,
-0.5591564775,
-0.604062736,
0.8278803229,
0.3740857244,
-0.4446817935,
0.3318963051,
0.6795700192,
-0.6628434062,
-0.0019610487,
-0.7790455818,
-0.2107845694,
-0.5042043924,
0.0465026796,
-0.006142688,
-1.4513950348,
0.8131177425,
-0.0788054615,
0.0375649333,
-0.0804011896,
0.126764968,
-0.0284582488,
0.840757966,
0.8510232568,
-0.2822470963,
0.3940302432,
0.323130697,
0.4602798522,
-0.5686338544,
-0.537977159,
-0.6598283648,
-0.25594908,
-0.7079814076,
-0.3996347785,
0.5732253194,
-0.2116820365,
-0.3002438843,
-0.1255333722,
-0.7326479554,
0.7995812297,
0.8267963529,
0.1696431637,
0.4506044388,
0.3051355183,
0.4339579642,
0.0548053794,
-0.3578042686,
-0.2961109281,
1.0856611729,
0.306076169,
0.607917428,
0.3291822374,
0.8936617374,
0.3078237772,
-0.4017566741,
-0.3774191737,
0.3890648186,
-0.644084096,
-0.16565907,
-0.5110968351,
-0.7269450426,
-0.9625419378,
0.0749063417,
0.1046120748,
-0.9134268761,
0.9176213741,
0.1580795497,
-0.5480932593,
0.2022672594,
-0.4027156532,
0.4193442166,
0.2250679284,
0.1481316984,
-0.1188109666,
-0.8898432255,
-0.2695910335,
-0.1253011525,
0.5182740092,
-0.1702104211,
0.1693268418,
0.9098899961,
-0.5345082879,
0.6982856989,
-0.5326879621,
0.2966454029,
0.0527089052,
-0.3295359313,
0.3470312655,
-0.0875836462,
0.007438445,
0.3770217001,
-0.2383513749,
-0.2399987727,
-0.5622959733,
0.5378404856,
-0.635828793,
-0.435439527,
-0.2317160964,
-0.2763999999,
-0.224244386,
-0.072057426,
0.3997062445,
0.5809719563,
0.0317384154,
0.414562583,
0.9477543831,
-0.3095210195,
0.6044493318,
0.508218646,
0.2010464519,
-0.4879478216,
1.0597347021,
0.2609733641,
0.0213315561,
0.1059721932,
0.1582650244,
-0.7630360723,
-0.5737702847,
-0.1671199948,
-0.256426841,
-0.6165342331,
-0.2626816332,
-0.6842033267,
-0.3732663393,
-0.7619735003,
-0.2016322315,
-0.438791126,
-0.5936541557,
-0.2890811563,
-0.0858936161,
0.4647553563,
0.5602886677,
-0.8252559304,
0.4605897665,
-0.3300048411,
0.2318293303,
0.5326239467,
0.6237709522,
-0.0865406394,
-0.7745217085,
-0.0121709881,
-0.0686435252,
0.1148049384,
-0.3893193305,
0.2689067721,
0.6429773569,
0.5753595829,
0.5518514514,
0.324477762,
0.606148541,
-0.6683731675,
0.393230021,
0.3453630507,
-1.2165977955,
0.5463439822,
-0.2261273861,
-0.0061576921,
0.6132270098,
-0.1271978766,
-0.3793716729,
-0.3320723772,
-0.5084035993,
-0.8760179877,
0.5502344966,
0.252644062,
-0.0251565855,
0.2990361452,
0.0040790155,
0.056874115,
0.3905782998,
-0.7254732251,
-0.0682447404,
-0.5292422175,
-0.2945985794,
-0.0379559286,
-0.0377324261,
-0.2875670195,
-0.3472531438,
0.3078096807,
-0.0197079536,
0.1788043529,
-0.001738796,
0.1589373052,
-0.09569747,
0.5620589256,
0.1436657459,
0.3267349005,
-0.1698456407,
0.0721358806,
0.0565915518,
-0.282184571,
0.2738935351,
0.2981115282,
-0.0222733878,
-0.1050072387,
-0.3163835406,
0.3967435956,
0.0619726591,
-0.4665389955,
0.9228467941,
-0.1399233937,
-0.1200769544,
-0.4063573778,
-0.0096198041,
-0.2527172565,
0.4681789279,
0.2563505769,
0.1038472205,
0.693292439,
-0.2542014122,
0.3098909855,
0.4638105333,
-0.4245221019,
0.0005910607,
0.6897106767,
0.1776417494,
-0.5475637317,
0.3847004771,
-0.4547639191,
-0.2756202519,
0.4386458397,
0.5772781968,
0.7481723428,
-0.6483578682,
-0.0968884379,
-0.1091167852,
0.1972566992,
-0.0480346754,
0.2428525537,
-0.3629350364,
-0.5302254558,
-0.0877450183,
-0.6618793011,
-0.450900197,
-0.412641108,
-1.0114048719,
-0.0988088548,
-0.6473168135,
-0.1568367332,
-0.4688930213,
-0.4886026084,
-0.3159424365,
0.2954862416,
0.1821286082,
0.3106813431,
-0.8397253752,
0.5481542945,
0.4436095655,
0.1499819905,
-0.3778291047,
-0.1591753364,
0.1152541637,
-0.5208451152,
-0.2996921837,
0.27189219,
-0.0204638224,
0.0598500445,
-0.4182613194,
-0.9651749134,
1.0361959934,
0.448826015,
-0.772951901,
0.3986165822,
0.4947110415,
0.348598063,
-0.252376169,
-0.1293838471,
0.4486779869,
0.163095206,
0.3744940162,
-1.0599458218,
-0.1310598254,
-0.3559955955,
0.0995542929,
0.0142019587,
-0.4978320599,
0.5598178506,
-0.0972807854,
-0.3620693088,
-0.2383849621,
0.7890600562,
0.3178672791,
0.6451792717,
0.726026535,
0.8304119706,
1.040617466,
-0.242503047,
0.4762361348,
-0.0722273141,
0.1045808196,
1.0475052595,
-0.1657087952,
0.8049077988,
0.1292557567,
-0.148016423,
-0.0155632719,
0.5111801028,
0.031145528,
0.9547829032,
0.3212418854,
-0.4918551147,
-0.2130930722,
-0.4488564134,
-0.6178777814,
0.6641764641,
0.1666625589,
-0.0415100195,
-0.1150169224,
0.2220661938,
-0.0287934374,
0.4750868976,
-0.4345702529,
1.089135766,
0.1036277041,
0.0219392404,
0.0228554849,
-0.0778019354,
1.0671846867,
-0.2143877447,
0.0958857685,
-0.1770396382,
0.0171573572,
-0.4313671291,
-0.4405277967,
0.4262345731,
0.3855072558,
-0.5184305906,
0.01044566,
0.4649481773,
-0.5389772654,
-0.5501392484,
0.3614109159,
0.2978584766,
0.5054633617,
-0.1033308133,
-0.1779143363,
-0.0000318387,
-0.0347814821,
0.3678228557,
0.5956769586,
0.4499531388,
0.1288226694,
0.3452647626,
0.9407231808,
0.0041241315,
0.2223061621,
0.5893941522,
0.9263469577,
-0.451274842,
-1.1383715868,
-0.5162114501,
0.531400919,
-0.2751427591,
0.0397860073,
0.4406245351,
0.6707166433,
0.8146343827,
0.5160511136,
0.6990329027,
0.2031221241,
0.8658120036,
-0.1539375782,
1.0268260241,
-0.2435485721,
0.2216803581,
-0.3393672705,
-0.7559209466,
-0.4270755351,
0.7909106016,
0.1477915347,
0.1203506887,
0.0468090288,
0.9141401052,
-0.0622474328,
0.225234434,
0.6137049198,
0.0776858777,
0.4301840067,
0.2990356982,
0.6244091392,
-0.1795401126,
0.3652288914,
-0.0939631239,
-0.6455097198,
0.3265990317,
-0.7026970983,
-0.7730382681,
-0.4333572388,
-0.1914074421,
-0.078616485,
0.4928730428,
0.7808196545,
0.7075731754,
-0.9659326673,
-0.3621430695,
0.1492621005,
-0.1107889861,
0.0999197662,
-0.1380399168,
0.4254450202,
0.0943193361,
-0.4678169489,
0.5661236048,
0.4257355034,
0.1090474427,
0.2348785847,
-0.1801006794,
0.5732765794,
-0.0881284475,
0.3423065543,
0.4259614944,
-0.4906523228,
-0.2725193202,
-0.3723706901,
0.6783304214,
0.230333969,
0.4308084846,
-0.8192496896,
0.3753571212,
0.0149527304,
0.6556112766,
0.253277868,
0.2575992346,
0.4760965109,
-0.8584280014,
0.2371249795,
0.3100600839,
0.2976110578,
0.6320526004,
-0.4365916252,
0.2910346687,
0.1765941381,
-0.9245133996,
-1.0380686522,
0.0588191971,
-0.9008406997,
0.0592835732,
0.7980628014,
-0.2305037677,
-0.0744201988,
-0.419170022,
0.3303630054,
0.440033555,
-0.8966864944,
0.8164648414,
-0.0980146527,
-0.0724468753,
-0.1057034731,
0.0033072254,
0.3631389439,
0.2179481834,
-0.6983975768,
0.0499617346,
0.4501346052,
0.2434742302,
-0.0253753588,
0.7432029247,
-0.3709874153,
0.2401721328,
-0.1727888584,
-0.0229384303,
-0.0887425169,
-0.5124413371,
-0.8286768198,
0.1116329357,
-0.1731698364,
-0.5704420209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04009v1 | Triggering Multi-Hop Reasoning for Question Answering in Language Models using Soft Prompts and Random Walks | 2023-06-06T20:45:18 | 2023-06-06T20:45:18 | Kanishka Misra, Cicero Nogueira dos Santos, Siamak Shakeri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite readily memorizing world knowledge about entities, pre-trained
language models (LMs) struggle to compose together two or more facts to perform
multi-hop reasoning in question-answering tasks. In this work, we propose
techniques that improve upon this limitation by relying on random walks over
structured knowledge graphs. Specifically, we use soft prompts to guide LMs to
chain together their encoded knowledge by learning to map multi-hop questions
to random walk paths that lead to the answer. Applying our methods on two T5
LMs shows substantial improvements over standard tuning approaches in answering
questions that require 2-hop reasoning. | [
-0.0702817887,
-1.1917954683,
1.1603614092,
-0.2011496574,
-0.1624676734,
0.1760134846,
-0.0212355219,
-0.2987173796,
-0.0977103114,
0.5404449105,
-0.8753427267,
-0.3825822771,
-0.4032200575,
0.1226466373,
-0.1422362179,
0.8800914288,
0.0441709496,
-0.1313610226,
-0.1298960149,
-0.1700667441,
-0.5842380524,
-0.2334170043,
-0.6665427685,
-0.2293784916,
0.8666422963,
0.5641439557,
0.8706134558,
0.3657675385,
0.188262403,
0.2684497535,
-0.069001615,
0.6057043076,
-0.1309635639,
0.5629718304,
-0.0565110594,
-0.5463330746,
-0.368514508,
-0.1833453923,
0.6170220971,
1.1233053207,
0.087208882,
0.1631593853,
-0.1895827651,
0.3516754508,
-0.2358059883,
-0.1255722791,
-0.5360091329,
-0.0472273044,
-0.1167714298,
-0.5090842843,
-0.4901168942,
-0.5273915529,
0.1404708177,
-0.4911309481,
0.0692377687,
0.2454477549,
0.5247672796,
0.107919693,
-0.742113471,
-0.2126089782,
-0.7780516148,
0.5918658972,
-0.4208296537,
0.4917249382,
0.2163488418,
0.2941305041,
-0.2788847685,
-0.8554927111,
-0.4493574202,
-0.1823356003,
-0.0816878676,
-0.2298659682,
0.181812942,
0.0163088925,
0.48328197,
-0.2019985616,
-0.6606911421,
-0.2853224874,
-0.3668524325,
-0.1957538277,
0.5132868886,
0.0934951305,
0.3256696761,
0.0559932664,
-0.2476409227,
-0.2804614604,
-0.6066429019,
0.3827634454,
0.2848041058,
0.5790572166,
0.211516723,
0.4190308452,
0.034728419,
1.0915349722,
-0.0232679658,
-0.3483815193,
0.3648687899,
-0.4487773776,
0.2087257951,
-0.2944206297,
0.6566718817,
0.1496165842,
0.8689190149,
-0.4650645256,
-0.1242249385,
-0.5084499121,
-0.0053637479,
-0.5394612551,
0.0057631754,
0.6972998977,
-0.3822362423,
0.0096364468,
-0.1816614866,
-0.8074119687,
-0.3785673678,
-0.0353075862,
0.5726438761,
-0.588767767,
-0.5353109241,
0.3019405007,
-0.6141652465,
0.3337460458,
0.5446085334,
-0.7028428912,
0.2836307287,
0.4796622694,
0.7841818333,
0.4343781173,
-0.518347621,
-0.9187306166,
0.1932156682,
-0.4352295697,
1.1037715673,
-0.5265748501,
-0.1991646439,
0.1220554411,
-0.041009441,
-0.4220375121,
-0.1588658094,
0.2537381947,
-0.677231133,
0.2335968614,
-0.3989765048,
-0.5163600445,
-0.1767742187,
0.4822931886,
-0.4103863537,
1.0699908733,
0.1759519577,
-0.7783809304,
0.1535758972,
-0.5247119665,
-0.6843478084,
-0.0502306186,
-0.0038573621,
0.0281202085,
-0.1524529308,
0.3310382068,
0.4302380383,
-0.0302401055,
0.2942479253,
-0.4036270082,
-0.206177339,
0.343285203,
-0.107268557,
0.9338687062,
0.1755333245,
-0.0295931678,
0.2973768413,
-0.7825701237,
0.2860395312,
0.414945215,
-0.2586486638,
-0.453461647,
0.1972871721,
-0.4318074286,
0.4326764643,
-0.0137673561,
-0.3259520233,
0.6168645024,
-0.2238343507,
0.270455271,
0.7198830247,
0.3007283807,
0.4088415802,
-0.553442657,
0.579770267,
0.26133129,
0.0743574202,
-0.5833836198,
-0.9239068627,
-0.5222629309,
0.2133871168,
-0.0192327257,
0.6595569849,
-0.7194185853,
-0.0826992318,
-0.2003257573,
-0.362182945,
-0.6185460687,
0.2202903181,
-0.0954507515,
0.7019912004,
0.6157748103,
0.0707135946,
-0.277895838,
-0.3531701267,
-0.5156918764,
-0.2783375978,
0.0063543404,
0.4362563491,
0.4068409204,
0.0612318665,
1.0155746937,
-0.5461867452,
0.1627044827,
-0.5160464644,
0.271048516,
0.2630912066,
0.2565726042,
0.5148679018,
-0.8098840117,
-0.1807397902,
-0.5858590007,
-0.406155616,
-0.0404919386,
-0.2946020961,
-0.1209747642,
-0.3042064607,
0.7488992214,
-0.814076066,
-0.0070341169,
0.1740592271,
-0.5293023586,
0.8352051377,
-0.053628549,
0.339497745,
-1.0719950199,
-0.155589208,
-0.3053436279,
-0.4362379313,
-0.8775059581,
-0.0018408732,
-0.2005402893,
-0.054217197,
-0.4935643077,
0.7118242979,
-0.4766138196,
-0.0845170766,
0.0519925579,
0.3261038363,
0.156722486,
0.6749014854,
0.2511903644,
0.5514745116,
0.650131464,
-0.7461351752,
0.4141112268,
0.299059689,
-0.1384752691,
0.081356369,
-0.6850512028,
0.638360858,
-0.3751160204,
0.445402503,
-1.2202743292,
-0.0321081951,
0.1542923898,
-0.4583554566,
0.1722527891,
-0.6010388732,
-0.5878769755,
-0.5431824923,
-0.3161582053,
0.4402185082,
0.4589246213,
-0.3517503142,
0.7256453633,
-0.0499777049,
0.0147431483,
-0.2855531275,
-0.5226983428,
-0.2064594924,
-0.2392153442,
-0.9280110598,
-0.1568381339,
-0.3797013462,
-0.2455115616,
-0.1419046372,
0.0675831065,
-0.0556548946,
0.335095495,
-0.0720868781,
-0.0467291884,
-0.3099845648,
0.3591462076,
-0.1125430688,
0.052154772,
0.1213871762,
-0.6691474915,
0.6661505103,
-0.1776948124,
-0.5946738124,
0.0452858992,
0.5418208241,
0.5877303481,
-0.2488879263,
0.8035695553,
0.598254621,
-0.2786276639,
-0.1777928025,
-0.2752118409,
-0.3780765235,
-0.4360979497,
0.1434587538,
-0.6745898128,
-1.1136032343,
0.4136424065,
-0.4857188463,
0.1401154548,
0.1299495101,
0.3999964595,
-0.2853450775,
1.2068881989,
0.4243819118,
0.3202699125,
0.2547540665,
0.0521424152,
0.481377542,
-0.5016617179,
-0.4558730721,
-0.8133431673,
-0.2140247077,
-0.5261950493,
-0.5794222355,
0.5182161927,
0.3597901762,
-0.3786045015,
0.1623294204,
-0.175470531,
0.2196458876,
0.8752357364,
0.0095144501,
0.2703660727,
-0.1828395277,
-0.5359967351,
0.4333434105,
-1.1255506277,
-0.285407573,
0.9270998836,
0.3676799536,
0.8185271621,
0.092198655,
0.6188952327,
-0.065846473,
-0.3011360466,
-0.633292675,
0.6139509082,
0.362636447,
-0.5920174122,
-0.4661478996,
-0.4493643045,
-0.818949759,
0.0529519655,
-0.2350674123,
-1.0254547596,
-0.0476232618,
0.3488269746,
-0.6970440149,
0.4624797106,
-0.7265331149,
0.7936357856,
-0.2791616917,
-0.1672211438,
0.1928021163,
-0.9627811313,
0.2927275002,
0.3813981414,
0.427496314,
0.0261112712,
0.2925672829,
0.8001586795,
-0.329316467,
0.6639772058,
-0.2667801678,
0.0274111256,
0.7611641288,
0.2029056698,
0.6834958792,
-0.1278930753,
0.0838082582,
-0.1309310049,
-0.0510352999,
-0.394474566,
-0.7170992494,
0.1441994309,
-0.5609878898,
-0.6847988963,
-0.3985429704,
-0.6538430452,
-0.8146552444,
0.1550942063,
0.1141437218,
0.5334650874,
0.2921822965,
-0.1026960611,
0.9331933856,
-0.1118980721,
0.4210508764,
0.4377325177,
-0.3438911736,
-0.0568519533,
0.4883558452,
0.0547913387,
0.4346986711,
0.4221526384,
0.3591483533,
-0.658721745,
-0.504744947,
-0.5904117227,
0.048907835,
-0.7434861064,
-0.1622673273,
-1.0203912258,
-0.3540757596,
-0.8831135631,
0.0426443256,
0.0566189624,
-0.6377748847,
0.0384917594,
-0.2883406579,
0.6617703438,
0.5764616728,
-0.0968329683,
0.2576384246,
-1.1399986744,
0.4421723485,
0.7186970115,
0.3928038478,
0.0160583612,
-0.5541046262,
-0.0173191465,
0.0040503601,
-0.0426449887,
-1.3723760843,
-0.1584801525,
0.1732083261,
0.512517035,
0.3886309862,
0.001744242,
0.6976236105,
-0.794608593,
0.7710959315,
0.1569943875,
-0.5328290462,
0.9828638434,
-0.5067294836,
0.3515535593,
0.4357056618,
0.6191383004,
-0.7714690566,
-0.4623562396,
-0.7270290256,
-0.841177702,
0.6079332829,
-0.114658758,
0.103682898,
-0.1814360917,
0.2776785791,
-0.0658969879,
0.178994298,
-0.6492366195,
-0.2674677372,
-0.1578798145,
-0.1543079466,
0.0942931697,
-0.2643450797,
-0.1142898351,
-0.1858677566,
0.5284240842,
-0.4014050066,
0.1685182005,
0.1597345024,
-0.2354952395,
-0.3099806905,
0.5255658627,
0.3366591036,
0.6212886572,
-0.2036560178,
0.451031357,
0.1209599972,
-0.1983482689,
0.2162450999,
-0.0141243739,
-0.3313297331,
-0.1026424989,
0.6552160382,
0.7456585765,
-0.0282112472,
-0.693328023,
0.4941681027,
-0.0275609102,
-0.1476343274,
0.1282105595,
0.3978117704,
0.328365624,
0.2783039808,
0.4067104757,
0.1000971869,
0.0562379993,
-0.6287207603,
0.2674199045,
0.3330481946,
-0.2466939688,
-0.3037557304,
0.4979112446,
-0.0081303604,
-0.5361554623,
0.9108771682,
-0.1655987054,
-0.705861032,
0.5412604809,
0.6727475524,
0.6431988478,
-0.371712774,
0.2809850276,
0.5867016912,
0.5397194028,
-0.0862421319,
0.5555074811,
-0.1913591325,
-0.8597874641,
-0.5127850771,
-0.5691326857,
-0.3983973861,
0.0989855379,
-0.3577581942,
0.3481348157,
-0.387925595,
0.1336164474,
-0.2718110383,
-0.1095708385,
-0.730096817,
0.2736026347,
0.2913451195,
1.1931257248,
-1.239287734,
0.6690143347,
0.8189455867,
-0.5862492323,
-1.3043431044,
0.0349023715,
-0.2049804032,
-0.7408288121,
0.2448058277,
0.1631020159,
-0.1303569525,
0.1691506654,
-0.8044186234,
-0.8040958643,
0.8960255384,
0.0901762843,
-0.3619028926,
-0.0508011989,
0.2778676748,
0.2689886987,
-0.2024496347,
0.6841408014,
0.5703114271,
0.4876124859,
0.3081397414,
-0.5571109653,
0.0750501454,
-0.139882341,
-0.4348730743,
0.037411686,
-0.6355064511,
0.7440981865,
-0.7869696021,
0.067471981,
-0.1605192423,
0.6919900775,
0.7537962198,
0.3644308746,
0.9128477573,
0.3564687669,
1.1874524355,
0.0170489457,
0.8725019097,
-0.2325009704,
0.1491824836,
1.2764401436,
-0.3186757565,
0.518879354,
0.531160295,
-0.1444817334,
0.9489532709,
0.9501322508,
0.3355843723,
0.5340880156,
0.1403168589,
-0.1611177325,
-0.7460997105,
-0.138695091,
-0.3157928288,
0.2064193934,
0.2737551033,
0.221041441,
-0.434787035,
-0.1090863124,
0.0507265665,
-0.1436846256,
-0.2781728208,
0.6258544922,
0.115347974,
-0.9879768491,
0.0842900276,
-0.0897322744,
0.1326128989,
-0.9653864503,
-0.2174067348,
-0.3848728836,
-0.4118359089,
-0.0448084064,
-0.9607313275,
0.1381471753,
0.0861632228,
-0.1636615843,
-0.6012690067,
1.0307815075,
-0.5890761018,
-0.2704929709,
0.3748758137,
0.9335948229,
0.2584144771,
0.0722293928,
-0.7460210919,
-0.536645174,
-0.2952530682,
-0.6588392854,
0.1549731195,
0.8348832726,
-0.2448839843,
0.9001972675,
0.8636398911,
-0.0642074645,
0.3425217569,
0.5427222252,
0.8286970258,
-0.7086737156,
-0.6517845392,
-0.6573579311,
0.615650475,
0.1291111261,
-0.099571839,
0.6331965327,
0.2554946542,
0.415831238,
0.1655761749,
0.7544369698,
-0.1714362949,
0.6437846422,
-0.6776803732,
0.2674681246,
-0.5687738061,
0.1599416435,
-0.1511845589,
-0.6248193383,
-0.0410138182,
0.4562322497,
-0.0996594951,
0.375136435,
0.9795843959,
0.7447817326,
-0.1577465981,
-0.1743991673,
0.2230761945,
0.402770102,
0.1553513557,
0.7989937067,
0.9302449226,
-0.277213037,
0.816334188,
-0.0224621855,
-0.1251720786,
0.0842200294,
-0.9902541041,
-0.9423800111,
-0.6263290644,
-0.4193644822,
-0.6822679043,
-0.0262944642,
0.9289867878,
0.7513359785,
-0.7848098874,
0.0896544158,
-0.0622877255,
0.6511889696,
-0.4441494644,
-0.2225637138,
0.5152438879,
-0.7474941611,
-0.2707066834,
0.6622060537,
0.2326960564,
0.055048611,
-0.0722796172,
-0.0241805129,
-0.6804574132,
0.1395377517,
0.2863908708,
0.2164221704,
-0.2104254216,
-0.5770552754,
0.2843662202,
0.0828864723,
0.0442187712,
1.0747201443,
-0.9213779569,
0.1848409176,
0.7322641611,
0.4486700594,
0.3112155497,
0.0571538769,
0.3593500257,
-1.0727336407,
0.1126072779,
0.4167898297,
0.4424661696,
0.3123792112,
-0.2654569447,
0.3387520611,
0.4523693025,
-0.4512587786,
-0.5454802513,
0.3834087253,
-0.9605898261,
-0.5036822557,
1.4534112215,
-0.1632220447,
-0.3987976313,
-0.5335922837,
0.1019098759,
0.2365262955,
0.0085398005,
0.3321526349,
0.6979773045,
-0.325838685,
-0.2473433763,
-0.6119433045,
0.5221315622,
0.2396304458,
-0.7948430181,
-0.1019989401,
0.4153505862,
0.5686516762,
0.0698508844,
1.2704604864,
0.1971555948,
0.2888830304,
-0.0299972929,
-0.2599898577,
-0.159874171,
-0.7297900915,
-0.1485302746,
0.35153234,
0.2309500724,
-0.0925577208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03997v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03997v3 | Sentiment Analysis in Finance: From Transformers Back to eXplainable Lexicons (XLex) | 2023-06-06T20:19:33 | 2024-03-26T21:32:51 | Maryan Rizinski, Hristijan Peshov, Kostadin Mishev, Milos Jovanovik, Dimitar Trajanov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexicon-based sentiment analysis (SA) in finance leverages specialized,
manually annotated lexicons created by human experts to extract sentiment from
financial texts. Although lexicon-based methods are simple to implement and
fast to operate on textual data, they require considerable manual annotation
efforts to create, maintain, and update the lexicons. These methods are also
considered inferior to the deep learning-based approaches, such as transformer
models, which have become dominant in various NLP tasks due to their remarkable
performance. However, transformers require extensive data and computational
resources for both training and testing. Additionally, they involve significant
prediction times, making them unsuitable for real-time production environments
or systems with limited processing capabilities. In this paper, we introduce a
novel methodology named eXplainable Lexicons (XLex) that combines the
advantages of both lexicon-based methods and transformer models. We propose an
approach that utilizes transformers and SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP)
for explainability to learn financial lexicons. Our study presents four main
contributions. Firstly, we demonstrate that transformer-aided explainable
lexicons can enhance the vocabulary coverage of the benchmark Loughran-McDonald
(LM) lexicon, reducing the human involvement in annotating, maintaining, and
updating the lexicons. Secondly, we show that the resulting lexicon outperforms
the standard LM lexicon in SA of financial datasets. Thirdly, we illustrate
that the lexicon-based approach is significantly more efficient in terms of
model speed and size compared to transformers. Lastly, the XLex approach is
inherently more interpretable than transformer models as lexicon models rely on
predefined rules, allowing for better insights into the results of SA and
making the XLex approach a viable tool for financial decision-making. | [
-0.4610032737,
-0.4171072543,
0.2636863291,
0.1793163121,
-0.1141169444,
0.4913935065,
-0.1356011778,
-0.4150483012,
0.2568581402,
0.2544148862,
-0.5465051532,
-0.3508458734,
-0.6165856123,
0.0087731453,
-0.647649467,
1.2479683161,
-0.0204057153,
0.1123346984,
-0.058913134,
-0.2631403208,
0.1470910162,
-0.5399569869,
-1.0928001404,
-0.2735733688,
0.2827306986,
0.1454301924,
1.2907238007,
0.4251207113,
0.5576771498,
0.3580172658,
-0.3225262761,
-0.2530511022,
-0.0641716123,
-0.2746271789,
-0.2391370833,
-0.4908358455,
-0.3749058843,
-0.214630276,
0.0847492218,
1.176627636,
-0.1772365421,
-0.0282198247,
0.0806678683,
0.9077023864,
-0.6122188568,
0.3788437247,
-0.3405925333,
0.1593781412,
0.0986052155,
-0.050873436,
-0.1476235837,
-0.2867283225,
0.3803030252,
-0.5702241659,
0.2131199092,
0.1195070297,
0.8438255191,
0.0605383106,
-0.1721877307,
-0.6616196632,
-0.7035143971,
0.9018859267,
-0.6804982424,
0.4214444458,
-0.113211222,
0.4678424597,
0.4833271503,
-0.7421298623,
-0.5152211189,
-0.0563808158,
-0.3432711363,
0.5142330527,
-0.3962527812,
-0.0629053861,
0.0895686895,
0.5934816599,
-0.0490772091,
0.0338503867,
-0.0847468898,
-0.2133523226,
0.5063539743,
0.0156884566,
-0.0306984372,
-0.4616141915,
-0.5552287698,
-0.3496605754,
-0.3489844203,
0.5062119365,
0.5006970763,
0.3111501932,
-0.0127351377,
0.3775078952,
0.1360138059,
0.1410631239,
0.0343746953,
-0.0298029836,
0.1225001961,
-0.2709862292,
-0.2112190872,
0.1231411621,
0.4892088473,
0.2367033213,
0.2485726029,
-0.1815097779,
-0.4294287264,
-0.1163490862,
0.2926951349,
-0.5502524972,
-0.1068366095,
0.418101728,
-0.687951088,
-0.4490405917,
0.1795532405,
-1.1914045811,
-0.3430488706,
-0.4619299173,
0.5233322382,
-0.5142390728,
-0.3424827456,
0.0424258411,
-0.5075032115,
0.703635335,
-0.0504693203,
-0.9723779559,
0.6094812155,
0.9439898133,
0.7770977616,
0.0248005241,
0.1622928083,
-0.3181656301,
-0.0383086167,
-0.4230996668,
0.7872846723,
-0.5564217567,
-0.5734450817,
0.001851392,
-0.3605219722,
-0.0322583579,
-0.3896433115,
0.3670788705,
-0.3376919627,
0.1532645673,
-0.2241377085,
-0.5986979604,
-0.5055155158,
-0.0410390235,
-0.5144398808,
0.7909527421,
0.3572419584,
-0.936987102,
0.4658035636,
-1.1459560394,
-0.3370984197,
0.0007731148,
0.012577232,
-0.486009717,
0.021626845,
0.4480567873,
0.5507413149,
-0.1550165266,
0.182686165,
-0.2845739722,
-0.1701458097,
0.6001230478,
-0.3216272593,
0.5518255234,
0.249047488,
-0.64828825,
0.0440476462,
-0.6649136543,
-0.2884837687,
0.0641123205,
0.3958280087,
-0.5872423053,
0.3821299672,
0.032305371,
-0.1135440916,
0.2006470263,
-0.3910676539,
-0.2463721633,
-1.0520207882,
0.3943293095,
0.7860171199,
-0.2643943429,
0.5931221843,
-0.0315078124,
0.6656232476,
0.1817492247,
0.2129538804,
-0.2978060842,
0.0083299195,
-0.6799342036,
-0.035266839,
0.2052883208,
0.5374100208,
-0.497789681,
0.1500300467,
-0.175518617,
-0.3493362069,
-0.307577312,
0.0574634708,
0.062194366,
0.465518862,
0.4529108405,
0.0579663776,
-0.5104843974,
-1.2859460115,
-0.636097908,
-0.0287270471,
-0.1883936375,
0.2868492305,
0.296230346,
-0.041703064,
0.8914447427,
-0.7184179425,
0.1106528565,
-0.6957039833,
0.1482557952,
0.4446628094,
0.1039170921,
0.7701692581,
-0.8771920204,
-0.2806275487,
0.2433700562,
-0.413921237,
0.040015623,
-0.5136880279,
0.184720993,
0.1815983057,
0.6434817314,
-0.056725692,
0.4480298162,
0.4113201499,
-0.5216187835,
0.4358755648,
0.0546570718,
-0.1905778348,
-1.1868627071,
0.1008035913,
0.2121213377,
-0.3993901312,
-0.4206973612,
-0.0589461215,
-0.0872542784,
-0.2343358845,
-0.0794568285,
0.5691915751,
-0.134605512,
-0.1188668013,
-0.3201289177,
0.3786721528,
0.0410261154,
0.452637881,
-0.1255336553,
0.7255775332,
0.8321162462,
-0.4150455892,
0.2388587296,
0.1899237335,
-0.1587635279,
0.4070748687,
-0.6733688712,
-0.4634410739,
-0.1361225247,
-0.0426091515,
-1.1954792738,
0.1915683746,
0.1756095439,
-0.3613294065,
0.2862513959,
0.251486361,
0.0836954862,
-0.3181917667,
-0.3544190824,
0.0812869817,
0.5469397902,
-0.9010645151,
1.0838241577,
0.176191777,
-0.4859381616,
-0.7954059243,
-0.4781839848,
0.2818251848,
-0.4626474082,
-0.469320178,
0.4646445215,
0.1146179736,
-0.9413043261,
-0.0716930628,
-0.41865924,
0.0271752886,
0.2133726776,
0.2885092497,
0.6226630211,
-0.1667098552,
0.196376726,
0.0339595117,
-0.5428934097,
0.4200307131,
-0.1823719591,
0.0807451755,
-0.3233304024,
0.1367452294,
-0.2749683857,
0.5010129809,
0.4167274535,
0.0647557825,
0.9746336937,
0.4760855734,
0.014597673,
-0.3191562891,
-0.3183187842,
-0.0108266464,
-0.5254215002,
0.1737159491,
-0.2474524379,
-0.5673215389,
0.70610255,
-0.2108562589,
0.3539904058,
1.0895090103,
0.463783294,
-0.0883009583,
0.9473404884,
0.8249044418,
-0.0601282865,
0.3768528998,
-0.2402993441,
0.7486463189,
-0.2918229103,
-0.1718847752,
-0.5504800677,
-0.3064780235,
-0.5046970248,
0.1425937414,
0.150848493,
-0.0699203834,
0.1374776959,
0.5022559762,
-0.2887319922,
0.4039287567,
0.2529266477,
-0.1146330908,
0.0288289301,
-0.3004261851,
-0.2794918418,
0.1008205414,
-0.5606694221,
-0.3594035208,
0.9299624562,
0.522603631,
0.6588100791,
-0.1247592643,
0.4621916413,
0.281200856,
0.3338668942,
-1.1806291342,
0.2354347408,
-0.439132154,
-0.1219687238,
-0.0882083327,
-0.633810997,
-0.5315287709,
-0.0876922384,
-0.294029206,
-0.2528459728,
0.1326772273,
0.0895396024,
-0.7526150346,
0.4138721228,
-0.9269396663,
0.6964207888,
-0.2188184708,
-0.1193193346,
-0.1445952952,
-0.4071865976,
0.2764966488,
-0.3398570716,
0.8069190383,
0.2220797241,
-0.3070781529,
0.9695618153,
-0.7854394913,
0.7264707685,
-0.1804923266,
-0.368615061,
0.1162187979,
-0.1037718356,
0.3329277039,
0.2380324453,
-0.1584450752,
0.2587642372,
0.3998009562,
-0.3601927459,
-0.8384196758,
0.6559669375,
-0.5533794165,
-0.3611491323,
-0.2237829268,
-0.572674036,
-0.3783322573,
-0.4422455728,
-0.0197629016,
0.4931594729,
0.1106372625,
0.171512723,
0.2045552731,
-0.2915194035,
0.8237659931,
0.0983177871,
-0.2369658947,
-0.3520276845,
0.8348678946,
-0.0108213304,
0.0244610086,
0.416788131,
0.6298093796,
-0.5125750303,
-0.1990768611,
0.1373661757,
-0.0183888208,
-0.7341653705,
-0.0660793036,
-0.6278865337,
-0.189325586,
-0.5018811226,
-0.6024463177,
-0.429928571,
-0.670188427,
-0.0047691143,
-0.3006492555,
0.5639646649,
0.7461723685,
-0.3730138242,
0.4555550516,
-0.807549715,
0.5770345926,
0.4968501627,
0.6299749017,
0.2660363317,
-0.4432066977,
-0.4090294242,
-0.0370859094,
-0.0621582344,
-0.8955202699,
0.4830364287,
0.1023491845,
0.394646734,
0.8760125041,
-0.038030494,
0.6332048178,
0.073198691,
0.7880628705,
0.2858378887,
-1.3436204195,
0.2974333763,
-0.0198558718,
0.0377881639,
0.3995309472,
0.5117371678,
-0.6169797778,
-0.3406704962,
-0.7594110966,
-1.309568882,
0.621497333,
0.3458127677,
0.2421227247,
-0.139573127,
0.7732531428,
0.6404866576,
0.136925891,
-0.5859623551,
-0.3893310428,
-0.6116105914,
-0.2544863522,
-0.1887148619,
-0.3032578528,
0.0807971656,
-0.3259284794,
0.8878100514,
-0.2253907323,
-0.0697993338,
0.147739917,
0.1686812788,
0.1417402029,
0.3821443021,
0.1529555172,
0.7631902695,
-0.1472973228,
0.0335476883,
0.3119881153,
-0.2665012479,
-0.3457818329,
0.0909411162,
0.1664315611,
0.1881773025,
0.3263784647,
0.5134384632,
0.6151311398,
-0.8350611925,
0.7066616416,
-0.0425386578,
-0.4874292612,
-0.6851305962,
-0.0031912632,
0.1519608051,
0.2574805021,
0.5149227977,
0.3442352414,
0.164098978,
-0.4249029458,
0.1604422033,
0.5206477046,
-0.6616231203,
-0.3038135767,
0.6778274179,
0.1122542769,
0.1268381923,
0.3113614619,
0.060997203,
-0.5486204028,
0.6805840135,
0.1538277864,
1.0466428995,
0.1335223317,
0.2741981745,
0.3340294361,
-0.0722595602,
-0.1010954529,
0.2358371615,
-0.1369041204,
-0.6721457839,
-0.6944740415,
-0.8890421391,
-0.6895892024,
-0.0602337644,
-1.0004267693,
0.1318276823,
-0.4849619567,
0.0588347949,
0.5502892733,
-0.4019973874,
-0.4697930813,
0.3575021327,
0.1811562032,
1.0650417805,
-0.64715904,
0.1496123821,
0.3718482852,
-0.2693905234,
-0.8092824221,
-0.1608158946,
-0.0708894879,
-0.9464249015,
0.461163044,
0.1543391943,
-0.134173885,
-0.152744621,
-0.5541753769,
-0.6680560112,
0.7127919197,
0.0465051457,
-0.5821274519,
-0.1205780283,
0.1675251871,
0.4792419076,
-0.0954602659,
0.2367953062,
0.8019058108,
0.7009831667,
0.2841543555,
-0.3034320474,
-0.2997887135,
-0.24985376,
-0.1840550601,
0.5099601746,
-0.3966172636,
0.496838361,
-0.3031332791,
-0.1017032564,
-0.0221747961,
0.8859087825,
-0.3734902442,
0.3490215242,
0.7754638791,
0.4020955563,
0.4442035854,
-0.2416711599,
1.2535504103,
-0.5359992385,
0.4836708307,
0.7251572609,
0.0960414857,
0.7349985242,
0.589656353,
-0.4224275947,
0.8082457781,
0.3468499482,
-0.1011412293,
-0.0428358614,
0.1377896816,
-0.0866230279,
-0.4628436565,
0.0665259287,
0.0333151668,
0.7895980477,
0.3210739493,
-0.5530511737,
-0.3052810431,
0.1488588601,
0.1153618768,
0.2903876305,
-0.6001107097,
0.8602691889,
0.3820017874,
-0.2681879401,
-0.2310885936,
-0.1067558601,
0.6858609319,
-0.9248102307,
0.2911807597,
-0.2135688812,
0.1517225057,
-0.2580099106,
-0.9585733414,
0.9296672344,
0.0048863865,
0.0345950313,
-0.538087368,
0.44137761,
0.049671486,
-0.8771733046,
0.4060029685,
0.5399998426,
-0.071713455,
-0.2430749238,
-0.5584297776,
-0.7484208941,
0.0126216682,
-0.366284281,
0.1441139728,
0.3257057369,
0.2632271051,
0.6514691114,
0.7213070393,
-0.0266283266,
-0.5201804042,
0.314666152,
0.6821045876,
-1.1838691235,
-0.6633322835,
-0.9440735579,
0.3013351858,
-0.0029724448,
-0.1941986233,
0.6173673868,
0.5037423372,
0.3539605737,
-0.0271512009,
0.7462898493,
0.1538711339,
0.688026011,
-0.4688447714,
0.7822403908,
-0.558663249,
0.412460953,
-0.3008718193,
-0.7320603132,
-0.3020014763,
0.3762480319,
-0.2819646001,
0.0057760756,
0.7843627334,
0.4780535102,
-0.0336725377,
0.4692503214,
0.2957804799,
0.3470867276,
0.1228080168,
0.0544669144,
0.6511368155,
-0.2833556831,
0.9457600713,
-0.6940243244,
-0.1123883799,
0.0615881905,
-0.9929362535,
-0.6770235896,
-0.3931300044,
-0.5116701126,
-0.2305944413,
-0.4103743434,
0.7754564881,
0.1406603009,
-0.9370612502,
-0.1992330402,
-0.0213384554,
0.0852258056,
-0.5857033134,
-0.3829300404,
0.5254594684,
-0.592487514,
-0.6337251663,
0.2039611936,
0.6004289985,
0.1154168174,
-0.2190806717,
0.3106555939,
0.4520935416,
0.5797006488,
0.6463836432,
0.0719370469,
-0.4449321926,
-0.345800817,
0.0825662613,
0.3720517457,
0.0722851679,
0.8665242195,
-0.8251219988,
0.2151762694,
0.256996274,
0.5943001509,
0.1617691815,
0.0855162069,
0.5797860026,
-0.401938498,
-0.074389562,
0.0060295681,
0.7224782705,
0.1364578158,
-0.3746328652,
0.3754904568,
0.1258685887,
-0.1685655117,
-0.1653413773,
-0.1595266461,
-1.2199647427,
-0.6185002327,
0.982855022,
0.0748017877,
-0.4720016122,
-0.1780463308,
-0.2715098858,
0.0465998203,
-0.3841898143,
0.9355236888,
0.4234704077,
-0.0095006255,
-0.0260491595,
-0.2406438738,
0.5798900127,
0.5152796507,
-0.6893206835,
0.3594900668,
-0.0608731769,
0.0937696397,
0.2943682671,
-0.1666339338,
-0.2173639983,
0.183968544,
0.2149629742,
0.0173904859,
-0.0979689956,
0.0441543236,
-0.3674530387,
0.4952939749,
-0.2851160467,
0.1333260983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03984v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03984v2 | Toward More Accurate and Generalizable Evaluation Metrics for Task-Oriented Dialogs | 2023-06-06T19:43:29 | 2023-06-09T01:17:39 | Abishek Komma, Nagesh Panyam Chandrasekarasastry, Timothy Leffel, Anuj Goyal, Angeliki Metallinou, Spyros Matsoukas, Aram Galstyan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Measurement of interaction quality is a critical task for the improvement of
spoken dialog systems. Existing approaches to dialog quality estimation either
focus on evaluating the quality of individual turns, or collect dialog-level
quality measurements from end users immediately following an interaction. In
contrast to these approaches, we introduce a new dialog-level annotation
workflow called Dialog Quality Annotation (DQA). DQA expert annotators evaluate
the quality of dialogs as a whole, and also label dialogs for attributes such
as goal completion and user sentiment. In this contribution, we show that: (i)
while dialog quality cannot be completely decomposed into dialog-level
attributes, there is a strong relationship between some objective dialog
attributes and judgments of dialog quality; (ii) for the task of dialog-level
quality estimation, a supervised model trained on dialog-level annotations
outperforms methods based purely on aggregating turn-level features; and (iii)
the proposed evaluation model shows better domain generalization ability
compared to the baselines. On the basis of these results, we argue that having
high-quality human-annotated data is an important component of evaluating
interaction quality for large industrial-scale voice assistant platforms. | [
-0.5534125566,
-0.517252028,
0.439517796,
0.0021097451,
-0.2242322713,
0.1341941506,
0.049341701,
-0.6544762254,
0.1989120245,
0.5285722613,
-0.3397665918,
-0.516864121,
-0.4793355465,
-0.0788172856,
-0.1039400175,
0.836751163,
0.2351332158,
0.0203687754,
-0.4761156142,
-0.2525610328,
-0.5210930109,
-0.6431262493,
-0.5909649134,
-0.3585373163,
0.2108896673,
-0.0404349603,
0.9885451794,
0.3034978211,
0.3301102221,
0.3548899591,
-0.0799489692,
0.3916496933,
-0.2755815387,
0.0022660606,
0.198296845,
-0.4004274011,
-0.9756383896,
0.4801417291,
0.231152162,
1.0108778477,
-0.1393111199,
0.1696729809,
0.2301959991,
0.2792447209,
-0.325288564,
0.3043511212,
-0.147938922,
0.1217559949,
0.0996092409,
-0.3402073979,
-0.261062324,
-0.2716850042,
0.3998762369,
-0.7652518749,
-0.0180067345,
0.0100651057,
1.0676645041,
0.3101561368,
-0.3323358297,
-0.248300761,
-0.7994937897,
0.8858855367,
-0.9702963233,
0.3511835039,
0.5465031266,
0.3064392507,
-0.1306859851,
-0.2155618221,
-0.4739447832,
-0.3573776484,
-0.1275052577,
0.1542783678,
-0.1899209023,
0.5117428899,
0.092665948,
0.4927850068,
-0.0687531307,
0.1377290189,
-0.1465231031,
-0.4522148371,
0.6856374145,
0.3277177811,
0.4473895729,
-0.1007282659,
-0.1163287014,
0.1035508886,
-0.3411303163,
0.4119998217,
0.4128059149,
0.097495392,
0.1116269156,
0.1969895065,
-0.3357433677,
0.8087198138,
0.2434222847,
-0.3885125816,
0.4297873974,
-0.5898662806,
-0.3968844116,
-0.4700818062,
0.8874719143,
0.608831048,
0.0659218505,
-0.2614584863,
-0.2327720374,
-0.3453101814,
0.2069026828,
-0.5183486938,
-0.1439805478,
0.2894640565,
-0.5485275984,
-0.2750153542,
0.138103649,
-0.4434044361,
-0.168218568,
-0.6436805725,
0.4504869282,
0.0047284444,
-0.2578614056,
-0.1977661997,
0.0424840227,
-0.0967376083,
0.7316917777,
-0.6363652945,
0.2197763324,
0.8166968226,
0.59661901,
-0.063665852,
-0.1051483825,
-0.8558503985,
-0.113289237,
-0.5652212501,
0.516561389,
-0.7083745003,
-0.4157893956,
-0.0555509664,
-0.2608671188,
0.0194910951,
-0.826710701,
0.4829262793,
-0.2927629352,
0.4922101796,
-0.1634102911,
-0.4868386984,
-0.204319343,
-0.0134067172,
-0.4429879189,
0.8611018658,
0.2198600322,
-0.3061414063,
0.6947470307,
-0.653696835,
-0.3270715475,
0.0783418268,
0.1098042578,
-0.114448607,
0.2061774135,
0.2259513736,
0.6730690002,
-0.3331736326,
0.3358587325,
-0.1629645079,
-0.3442271948,
0.4404003322,
-0.2738889754,
0.6130990982,
0.0701276138,
-0.1108708382,
0.1961023062,
-0.6838394403,
0.1616445929,
-0.6869102716,
-0.3687309325,
-0.2185950577,
-0.2088654339,
-0.1770610958,
0.2657858133,
0.2763274014,
-0.7519965768,
-0.1138825342,
-0.0815561935,
0.3178132772,
0.4377283752,
0.2457619607,
0.2893210649,
-0.1462305784,
0.2730041742,
0.0630803108,
0.5138936639,
0.0638640597,
-0.4550254345,
-0.849188745,
-0.4155068398,
0.3926743269,
0.3707033396,
-0.4388721585,
0.709790647,
-0.1567645967,
-0.5006062388,
-0.7282792926,
0.2678548098,
0.6732113957,
0.3251862824,
0.2337927818,
-0.7656925917,
-0.0811058432,
-0.8486713767,
-0.0670705736,
-0.6682497263,
-0.3827877045,
0.4129079282,
0.0129219815,
-0.1566853076,
1.0540009737,
-0.1901859343,
-0.3249726295,
-0.185240984,
0.7485998273,
0.0021758054,
0.4988835156,
0.358974725,
-0.5262700915,
-0.2009899169,
0.0650448576,
-0.6410603523,
-0.3891333044,
-0.096077688,
-0.2967401147,
-0.0009809427,
0.1475798041,
-0.5532129407,
0.3948687613,
0.449925065,
-0.2042832077,
0.6642541885,
0.1346107274,
0.6851437688,
-0.6586375833,
0.0229747761,
0.2483561933,
-0.3147996962,
-1.0731021166,
-0.4689972103,
-0.442189306,
-0.0891392678,
-0.3079435229,
0.3576237857,
-0.2298817486,
-0.3137111664,
-0.1875571907,
0.1912060529,
0.3098852932,
0.7094749212,
-0.049986884,
0.9185579419,
0.2121973634,
-0.4740566611,
0.2995422781,
0.4099126756,
-0.3845031559,
1.0953046083,
-0.7054907084,
0.2610158622,
0.1146395952,
0.0977120176,
-0.8946895599,
-0.2822014689,
0.083812587,
-0.8501535654,
0.1117802635,
-0.219879359,
-0.2618374825,
0.0237185843,
-0.0423414409,
-0.0316086262,
0.5611689687,
-0.3813795149,
0.6090686917,
0.5825746655,
-0.1954611093,
-0.3308357,
-0.2869872153,
0.2333237976,
-0.1055699214,
-0.6808800101,
-0.057581909,
0.0314825028,
-0.1232949942,
-0.2706476152,
-0.2342069,
-0.516711235,
0.1112308204,
0.4290408194,
0.0738897696,
0.0950990841,
-0.09199889,
0.0195864327,
-0.2393698692,
0.1732735336,
0.0906702429,
0.2059202194,
0.1590328664,
-0.4258902669,
-1.1684061289,
0.3695885539,
0.5899930596,
-0.2084542364,
0.1920378059,
0.6733034253,
-0.3303491175,
0.3728697598,
-0.8142748475,
0.0518597923,
-0.4002902806,
0.2962476015,
-0.4692367315,
-0.9005355835,
0.4495190978,
0.0862615556,
0.3480472565,
0.3830306828,
0.0410846248,
-0.4341105819,
1.3512978554,
0.5958403349,
-0.1180590615,
0.3895272911,
-0.1572947055,
0.219395861,
-1.0762399435,
-0.2367055118,
-0.5609135628,
0.0552454628,
-0.1539469957,
-0.3581815064,
0.317563355,
0.2786610126,
-0.1407567561,
0.3432281017,
-0.2089236528,
-0.0821239576,
0.6406571865,
0.1033178791,
0.4219729304,
-0.1116948724,
0.3537739515,
-0.1547935754,
-0.240979284,
-0.845392108,
0.6368604898,
0.7624981403,
0.4859131873,
-0.0751455426,
0.8286926746,
0.4480255544,
0.3513225913,
-0.6073436141,
0.5210210681,
0.1555640697,
-0.320464015,
-0.7030909657,
-0.5953520536,
-0.6015103459,
0.1985058188,
0.099866733,
-1.154086709,
0.2866842151,
0.4057212174,
-0.3510614038,
-0.0717268437,
-0.758212626,
0.9189219475,
0.0299108382,
-0.0126864631,
-0.254899174,
-0.3181184232,
0.0134195471,
0.2263420522,
-0.0112935808,
-0.5395950675,
0.1906607002,
1.0661517382,
-0.6967530847,
0.9286689162,
-0.6459023356,
-0.1603817642,
0.5786385536,
0.1238157451,
0.2427203804,
-0.1082825661,
0.0807089582,
0.4299750626,
0.1583084613,
-0.453291744,
-0.9540176988,
0.3620610535,
-0.7732138634,
-0.6396147013,
0.0743350983,
-0.2945732176,
-0.5670418739,
-0.2350711375,
-0.0376736149,
0.7770456076,
-0.1857500523,
-0.1017667353,
0.3399550319,
-0.1312978119,
0.0942316502,
0.1133330092,
0.217260614,
-0.4875538647,
1.0677443743,
0.157763496,
0.6691877246,
0.2441862077,
-0.1645618081,
-0.1336677372,
-0.6037885547,
-0.4106758237,
-0.0627823696,
-0.6118078232,
-0.171401903,
-0.6420821548,
-0.0703722984,
-0.0151817231,
0.0425492153,
-0.2339565158,
-0.3136471212,
-0.3925196826,
-0.0890083313,
-0.0361490808,
0.5229269266,
-0.0987965167,
0.4671167135,
-0.7334305644,
0.1225943267,
0.6470423341,
0.2359915823,
0.0902033895,
-0.5439434052,
-0.3354597986,
0.3094896674,
-0.2131709456,
-0.4798767865,
0.0822241604,
0.1634912044,
0.6174871922,
0.4338565469,
-0.2620185614,
0.6516684294,
0.0377216302,
1.0891858339,
0.4299841523,
-1.1482996941,
0.3796634078,
-0.2701759934,
0.1014304087,
0.7760435939,
-0.073488988,
-0.6590636373,
-0.6146007776,
-0.4220744073,
-0.6847448945,
0.4009988904,
0.2498971373,
0.1800046265,
0.1154844835,
0.141103372,
0.1918929964,
0.4251658916,
-0.3129643202,
0.0047626891,
-0.3690739274,
-0.1789599359,
0.0322803222,
-0.3492800295,
-0.180960536,
-0.0964909494,
0.5694484115,
-0.1307831705,
0.4104328156,
0.1227984428,
-0.2459748089,
-0.0400913619,
0.3852301836,
0.2385702878,
1.0441025496,
-0.3428576887,
-0.2163580656,
0.0791129619,
-0.2843089998,
0.2713901997,
-0.1745539606,
0.0603582337,
0.0957234576,
0.4053842127,
0.8786073327,
-0.0762601271,
-0.5175409317,
0.6520619392,
0.0137950294,
0.0507828556,
-0.1178442463,
0.3264383078,
-0.3550291955,
0.0959521458,
0.4079969525,
-0.2300688177,
0.5683189631,
-0.4610769749,
0.0220608413,
0.424697876,
-0.7823211551,
-0.4218462408,
0.4069488943,
0.9584610462,
-0.2938798964,
0.3369176984,
-0.2417393625,
-0.3636513352,
0.3974600136,
-0.2568446398,
0.9368823171,
-0.2328030467,
0.4174746573,
0.3213466704,
0.1688085645,
0.3485554755,
0.0934986547,
-0.2775192857,
-0.4843912423,
-0.6798834205,
-0.4995969534,
-0.8081262112,
0.0731594265,
-0.7054485083,
-0.2983855903,
-0.2814564109,
-0.5202977061,
0.1658771485,
0.0475659333,
-0.8411214352,
0.5513198972,
-0.1911280304,
0.5299966931,
-0.7989587784,
0.1754621118,
0.4263346195,
-0.4322757721,
-0.513931334,
0.0359613746,
-0.1207199916,
-0.5102337599,
0.7504550815,
0.178056404,
-0.0973943472,
-0.2495164424,
-0.2634333968,
-0.6083354354,
0.9511888027,
-0.048118297,
-0.4393684566,
0.1891947985,
0.3166711926,
0.8323389888,
-0.5282544494,
0.6266713142,
0.80737257,
0.4285376966,
-0.3384928405,
-1.3522833586,
-0.0929266587,
-0.3212192059,
0.222213164,
0.1662675142,
-0.4990838766,
0.1499602199,
0.0473377258,
-0.2165550739,
0.2124655992,
0.8744258881,
-0.3330436945,
0.3780687153,
0.8061146736,
0.424847275,
0.5185037255,
-0.4977846146,
0.7067451477,
-0.1120996699,
0.1484838724,
0.8899281621,
-0.0464504994,
0.6188684106,
0.2597223222,
-0.2722480893,
0.1896963567,
0.5802924037,
0.2328295559,
0.1644271016,
0.1712841541,
-0.2128290087,
-0.4245401025,
-0.4531669915,
0.0339217149,
0.3902205825,
0.2625690103,
-0.1950655282,
0.2337509245,
0.0626831502,
0.0794030204,
-0.1148692816,
-0.0641438141,
1.1489623785,
-0.2970561683,
-0.6502141356,
0.5768603683,
-0.371235013,
0.490052253,
-0.0353561938,
-0.1062846035,
-0.2665396035,
-0.4966163933,
-0.3238832355,
-0.8964223862,
0.052518867,
0.0584479272,
-0.0100145135,
0.0690830424,
0.212051034,
-0.4031502008,
-0.0927195922,
0.037920326,
0.5870615244,
0.4930383563,
-0.0344528221,
-0.3331699073,
0.0970753804,
-0.0165435169,
-0.2665780187,
0.1841043681,
0.212139219,
0.1991014034,
0.5205978155,
0.5373262763,
-0.1831178963,
-0.1967107356,
0.481854111,
0.693786025,
-0.4195567966,
-0.2236841321,
-0.1414825469,
0.821377635,
-0.5247516036,
-0.4917351007,
0.1949325651,
0.2520323694,
0.7170345187,
0.328517437,
0.9427889585,
0.0715560839,
0.7166131735,
-0.3661110401,
0.4460745156,
-0.2532867193,
-0.0498721637,
-0.4620234966,
-0.9230352044,
0.0501006693,
0.5603791475,
-0.175640896,
0.2071409076,
0.24379538,
0.6520426273,
-0.0327902734,
-0.0609382242,
0.578546524,
0.0312314369,
0.6872950196,
0.2764944732,
0.9121020436,
-0.3499679565,
0.4182869792,
-0.3090617359,
-0.6149293184,
-0.245009914,
-0.515276134,
-0.9868482351,
-0.7891125679,
-0.6037822962,
-0.1679052562,
0.1860763282,
0.7902533412,
0.9791220427,
-0.6278863549,
-0.281896621,
0.2742052376,
-0.1897285283,
-0.3362565041,
-0.2826231718,
0.1278499663,
-0.3712645471,
-0.880140543,
0.1760537177,
0.4574608207,
0.0976864249,
-0.4213773906,
-0.1940868497,
0.3034312427,
0.1606322676,
0.65227139,
0.3074008822,
-0.9340085983,
-0.5560578108,
-0.3661060333,
-0.1578158587,
0.1753349006,
0.6353849769,
-0.2323113084,
0.6152819395,
0.2568129897,
0.4716397822,
0.1062949449,
0.4316332638,
0.6894519925,
-0.5621793866,
-0.1440236419,
0.2134845406,
0.2210787386,
0.5077807903,
-0.320142746,
0.4541801512,
-0.1650135666,
-0.608904779,
-0.7644534707,
0.1335784942,
-1.0649169683,
0.4819345772,
0.9551885724,
-0.6534196734,
-0.0097883577,
-0.2662185729,
-0.4894667268,
0.1877984852,
-0.7068461776,
0.8239153028,
0.6646981835,
-0.5728753209,
-0.1140967458,
-0.6998072267,
0.6151952147,
0.3671117425,
-1.224794507,
0.0720423162,
0.7847433686,
0.033751227,
0.5175821185,
0.6553342342,
-0.0806675106,
0.484107703,
-0.3029397726,
0.2154291421,
-0.2083858699,
-0.3960441351,
0.0966475382,
-0.0207591336,
0.3704401553,
-0.4492491484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03978v1 | Büyük dil modellerinin Türkçe verisetleri ile eğitilmesi ve ince ayarlanması | 2023-06-06T19:31:08 | 2023-06-06T19:31:08 | A. Taha Arslan | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Large language models have advanced enormously, gained vast attraction and
are having a phase of intensed research. Some of the developed models and
training datasets have been made open-accessible. Hence these may be further
fine-tuned with some techniques to obtain specialized models for specific
tasks. When it comes to Turkish language, open-access models do not provide
satisfactory coverage. This is also observed over published datasets. In this
work, we propose some ideas to mitigate this issue: creating large Turkish
datasets, training LLMs with these and fine-tuning pre-trained models with
Turkish inputs. We report our findings on Turkish-based trainings with the
problems encountered along the way. We conclude with outcomes of these
experiments and propose ideas for further works.
--
B\"uy\"uk dil modelleri inan{\i}lmaz \"ol\c{c}\"ude geli\c{s}mekte, b\"uy\"uk
ilgi toplayarak ve \"uzerlerinde yo\u{g}un ara\c{s}tirmalarin yapildi\u{g}i bir
d\"onemdedirler. Geli\c{s}tirilen modeller ve e\u{g}itimde kullanilan
verisetlerinden bazilari a\c{c}ik eri\c{s}imli olarak sunulmaktadir. B\"oylece
ince ayarlama teknikleri uygulayarak \"ozelle\c{s}mi\c{s} g\"orevler i\c{c}in
\c{c}ali\c{s}abilir modeller elde edilmektedir. T\"urk\c{c}e s\"oz konusu
oldu\u{g}unda bu modellerinin kapsayicili\u{g}i yeterli d\"uzeyde de\u{g}ildir.
Bu durum, yayimlanan verisetlerinde de g\"ozlemlenebilir. Bunu a\c{s}manin
yollari T\"urk\c{c}e i\c{c}erikli b\"uy\"uk verisetlerinin olu\c{s}turulmasi,
b\"uy\"uk dil modellerinin bunlarla e\u{g}itilmesi ve \"onceden
e\u{g}itilmi\c{s} modellerin T\"urk\c{c}e girdilerle ince ayarlanmalari
olabilir. Bu \c{c}ali\c{s}mada a\c{c}ik eri\c{s}imli dil modelleri ve
verisetleri \"uzerinde durulmakta ve T\"urk\c{c}e temelli bazi deneyler,
kar\c{s}ila\c{s}ilan sorunlar ve sonu\c{c}lar irdelenmektedir. | [
-0.4662263095,
-0.6088274717,
0.4273088276,
0.1616005301,
-0.3749600649,
-0.4801724255,
-0.3781495392,
-0.3673106134,
-0.0083910292,
0.5538932085,
-0.6118562818,
-0.4716202915,
-0.5596946478,
0.1004129574,
-0.2925469577,
1.0069190264,
-0.3577373326,
0.253230691,
0.3059877455,
-0.214724198,
-0.1882122606,
-0.5545285344,
-0.4592241943,
-0.1450892985,
0.5110521913,
0.3714931607,
0.5664944649,
0.5388327837,
0.5979958773,
0.3577953875,
-0.4960911572,
0.1476800442,
-0.3865632713,
0.2260823995,
-0.1015513465,
-0.5345209241,
-0.4884584248,
-0.0742825195,
0.9295849204,
0.6782647371,
-0.1316438913,
0.2094177008,
0.0366881266,
0.8445711732,
-0.764520824,
0.1193122715,
-0.2514584064,
0.0754448548,
-0.4123857915,
0.2475740612,
-0.2046575844,
-0.2184291184,
-0.0752415732,
-0.5742096305,
0.2645391226,
0.1722299904,
1.17070961,
-0.0423715264,
-0.3545532227,
-0.2148205489,
-1.0950847864,
1.2131451368,
-1.1551941633,
0.6431563497,
0.2455694675,
0.5270254612,
-0.438218683,
-0.6447265148,
-0.6293176413,
-0.3110592067,
-0.1364088356,
0.2949666977,
-0.0012291053,
-0.2333487868,
0.3666667044,
0.6861305833,
-0.4814540446,
0.1647562683,
-0.8525753021,
0.2056824267,
0.6551818252,
0.4016333222,
0.0265638251,
0.3019697666,
-0.2193305194,
-0.0941907689,
-0.815297544,
0.0180912595,
0.6934598088,
0.4087538123,
-0.1309980899,
1.1493428946,
-0.4170018733,
0.852408886,
0.2633381784,
-0.1627393663,
0.2226745337,
-0.384011507,
-0.5678360462,
-0.2239908576,
0.7005659342,
0.0301921144,
0.4060896635,
0.0841110572,
-0.3406989276,
-0.0049413405,
0.307212323,
-0.8757145405,
-0.0451024622,
0.2588863969,
-0.4290601909,
-0.2611514628,
0.2150902003,
-0.6120161414,
-0.1929527521,
-0.4161720872,
0.5390008688,
-0.1740658879,
-0.4658511281,
0.2904452085,
0.2573299706,
0.4682131112,
0.1871140748,
-0.9625385404,
0.3163848519,
0.5497726798,
0.6954383254,
0.0724223405,
-0.2721693814,
-0.0606543384,
0.2075961232,
-0.6553565264,
0.6992732286,
-0.2909223735,
-0.3698735237,
0.0715750009,
0.4728916883,
-0.2428985089,
-0.5311174989,
0.4802505076,
-0.4094002545,
0.641943574,
-0.1789605916,
-0.68840307,
-0.1579743177,
0.2861992419,
-0.774758637,
0.7505667806,
-0.1142288297,
-1.3458532095,
0.3355056345,
-0.817954421,
-0.2019364387,
-0.3003759086,
-0.2581599057,
-0.802996695,
0.2783581316,
0.2357057482,
0.5415737033,
-0.2657532394,
-0.0519594885,
-0.329269141,
-0.4392192364,
0.2647513151,
-0.1244849488,
1.0671900511,
0.5016292334,
-0.35476771,
0.2859464884,
-0.7898071408,
-0.2194163948,
0.3156657517,
-0.7889921069,
-0.1444117129,
-0.2860856354,
0.1612750739,
0.003993134,
0.1210367754,
-0.6784111857,
0.2517890036,
-0.6536347866,
0.1220633835,
0.8683977127,
0.0054137232,
0.4501191676,
-0.6557095647,
0.6799713969,
0.2663427889,
0.102096498,
0.1316257417,
-0.2147431374,
-1.2069497108,
-0.4127690494,
0.2940206826,
0.4124950767,
-0.3425732255,
0.4296672642,
-0.0790897608,
-0.7282807231,
-0.501968503,
-0.013128737,
0.1458989978,
0.3277612925,
0.0728977844,
-0.0653620437,
-0.5372898579,
-1.1186338663,
-0.5070139766,
-0.0958415717,
-0.2718672454,
0.2128639668,
0.4752991796,
-0.0438516773,
0.887367785,
-0.3256112337,
-0.4208676219,
-0.3888077736,
-0.1141692996,
0.8480123878,
0.6390222311,
0.5424137712,
-0.8492004871,
-0.761423409,
0.1854756773,
-0.7070544958,
0.0734986588,
0.2365208268,
-0.1385055482,
0.6016946435,
0.5242125988,
-0.8414518237,
0.5642834902,
0.3864285648,
-0.4537521303,
0.9369442463,
-0.2869324088,
0.1519951075,
-1.430252552,
0.3755179942,
0.0078154588,
-0.1001896188,
-0.742980957,
0.4309806228,
-0.1457717866,
0.0717096478,
-0.7478048205,
0.7971229553,
-0.6829972267,
0.1874489188,
-0.0596690476,
-0.3125469685,
-0.2077396959,
0.459387958,
0.0131627694,
0.9635942578,
0.6103945374,
-0.7077935934,
0.5029021502,
0.3916712105,
-0.6095107794,
0.4704682529,
-0.8365344405,
-0.1193154603,
-0.4554341733,
-0.0958836302,
-0.8369131088,
-0.3588859737,
0.5811746716,
-0.3477170467,
0.6150106788,
-0.3095478714,
-0.4680868685,
-0.3467009664,
-0.1595623046,
0.1847444773,
0.5485208631,
-0.5880336165,
0.7351857424,
0.2360881269,
-0.2701596618,
-0.660556376,
-0.9100142121,
-0.2809372544,
-0.656891644,
-0.8178442717,
-0.1921508014,
-0.269469738,
-0.4666360915,
0.0581003688,
-0.1794374287,
-0.2702600062,
-0.0685138404,
0.1609910578,
0.2969148159,
-0.369579494,
-0.0496642254,
-0.1252693534,
-0.0570408888,
-0.0940017477,
-0.3528467119,
0.578925252,
-0.3359458745,
-0.3982207477,
-0.3848293722,
0.4015560746,
0.8602718115,
-0.3719970584,
1.2077208757,
0.7738872766,
-0.3417644799,
0.3118084967,
-0.7569854856,
-0.0400391184,
-0.5110737085,
0.4088791013,
-0.5065569878,
-1.0218504667,
0.5763925314,
-0.0910202339,
0.5832175612,
0.6998362541,
0.980267942,
-0.1686507761,
1.1622968912,
0.8150885701,
-0.0626448542,
0.654365778,
-0.5903950334,
0.2775398493,
-0.6801267862,
-0.2051876038,
-0.6176264882,
-0.1428098679,
-0.7130086422,
-0.2554782033,
0.4626647234,
0.2473567575,
-0.596975863,
0.1517291665,
-0.1855869442,
0.3514716327,
0.6748992205,
0.0848082453,
0.212992698,
0.4420392811,
-0.2904989421,
-0.009091964,
-0.7371270061,
-0.4435017109,
1.2587394714,
0.4927907884,
1.319347024,
0.3486915231,
0.8116955757,
-0.0600796416,
-0.0679015741,
-0.7397642732,
0.3979357183,
-0.1440973282,
-1.0478239059,
-0.504385829,
-0.4305995703,
-1.0873667002,
0.1668503881,
-0.2417696565,
-0.8881844878,
0.3364388347,
0.0653788596,
-0.2885898948,
0.5085372925,
-0.4206949472,
0.949215591,
0.1463790238,
-0.504875958,
-0.2650304437,
-0.4773211181,
0.4466834068,
0.0648658797,
0.11403846,
-0.0295655336,
0.2474503368,
0.8365195394,
-0.6090260744,
0.6540465355,
-0.0688034743,
-0.2317157388,
0.4986550212,
0.0035958614,
0.596278131,
-0.1126467288,
-0.02944001,
0.1424702406,
-0.0292282011,
-0.6920288801,
-0.4075472653,
0.6744354963,
-1.06647861,
-0.7570094466,
-0.4118078649,
-0.5203354359,
0.0639357567,
0.266921252,
0.4570976496,
0.4195368886,
-0.1816018373,
0.1824133098,
0.5112521648,
-0.1277815849,
0.2378555238,
0.62516433,
-0.2430290282,
-0.3061345518,
0.7337563038,
0.1122258455,
0.1907115579,
0.0053917998,
0.2275118381,
-0.3439811468,
-0.494936347,
-0.55051893,
0.6020180583,
-0.6506863832,
-0.0273821559,
-0.7109922767,
-0.6039103866,
-0.6352518797,
-0.0050859973,
-0.5780277252,
-0.6302483082,
-0.3268399835,
-0.070385389,
0.3685571849,
0.9741002917,
-0.3246528506,
0.4873023033,
-0.5980404019,
0.1148366481,
0.3954920173,
0.4545274377,
-0.1431497037,
-0.762825489,
-0.552539587,
0.1688627452,
-0.0900742039,
-0.7748134136,
0.5768308043,
-0.1125662029,
0.5820369124,
0.6615761518,
0.0497436635,
0.492269814,
-0.4372181892,
0.5760350823,
0.1240626499,
-0.5628493428,
0.4077344835,
-0.503626287,
0.2124124169,
0.5006302595,
0.7043289542,
-0.5483148694,
-0.3643453121,
-0.4761929512,
-0.7486020327,
1.0824846029,
0.3991982937,
0.0714896545,
0.2757126987,
0.2142686844,
0.1121368036,
0.1738895923,
-0.804482758,
-0.2791639268,
0.1350307912,
-0.1060954034,
0.0188648514,
-0.6136615276,
-0.0892323032,
-0.3008385897,
1.2351025343,
0.2870378196,
0.2705861926,
0.1705774963,
-0.0325480625,
-0.4206929803,
0.4841611683,
0.6019535065,
0.8402636051,
-0.5282699466,
-0.0255928505,
0.1502762735,
-0.4384625852,
0.1750782877,
0.1907678545,
-0.3088352382,
0.0061340118,
0.1467428803,
1.0060784817,
-0.3033519685,
-0.4849598408,
0.4956846535,
-0.233242929,
-0.0665607899,
-0.8737242818,
-0.130807817,
0.0940064415,
0.6170225739,
0.0946903154,
-0.1931963414,
-0.0263262652,
-0.4103660882,
-0.086995773,
0.3333922327,
-0.3118952215,
-0.2650466561,
0.6393712759,
-0.1197683513,
-0.1751486659,
0.6824231148,
0.0274308994,
-0.501729548,
0.5328379869,
0.6704847217,
0.7498669028,
-0.6475685239,
-0.1304268837,
0.7434642911,
0.4333659708,
-0.1881523877,
0.44340083,
0.2665379345,
-0.6866031885,
-0.4614231884,
-0.805687964,
-0.3368956447,
0.5425863862,
-0.6685809493,
0.6353548765,
-0.5219765306,
-0.0485443398,
-0.2461539358,
0.1848010421,
-0.9379403591,
0.1901684552,
0.0885338485,
0.9620717168,
-1.1924420595,
0.8024653792,
1.0530097485,
-0.3677971065,
-0.6882029176,
-0.2401877642,
-0.3676432669,
-0.6605629325,
0.6369792819,
0.0611936264,
0.3513184786,
-0.0456068255,
-0.8159367442,
-1.1950929165,
0.9406647086,
0.2168943584,
-0.7430362105,
-0.112051107,
0.2203679979,
0.3683852851,
-0.2812202573,
0.2927515805,
0.5927450061,
0.6376137137,
0.1669561267,
-1.079328537,
0.0384677313,
-0.3799790442,
-0.2473492771,
0.0761540756,
-0.8261281252,
1.3066431284,
-0.2683385909,
-0.2340148091,
0.4334520102,
0.7337802649,
0.3791255355,
0.0351706557,
0.6376852989,
0.6937975883,
0.345485568,
0.2735880613,
1.0061155558,
-0.1786151528,
0.5126106739,
0.9483647346,
0.1537304372,
0.6448988318,
0.4193763435,
-0.4753944576,
0.3007380366,
0.5052945614,
-0.1774797142,
0.5445738435,
0.3890817165,
-0.5247089863,
-0.551835835,
-0.0983151644,
-0.5877138972,
0.5275215507,
0.3783482909,
-0.3358718157,
-0.4191637337,
-0.1358250231,
0.1594885439,
-0.2401408851,
-0.1538848877,
0.6319103241,
0.0940704942,
-0.1357269734,
0.7896260619,
0.2299306095,
0.4968184233,
-0.7390660048,
0.1426560283,
-0.4289257526,
0.4151421189,
-0.0069309813,
-0.2744702101,
0.2981072068,
0.0666859746,
-0.2048951834,
0.2767688632,
0.6225858331,
-0.6298504472,
-1.2845250368,
0.0746049061,
0.5365456939,
0.4842056334,
-0.1368588805,
-0.4728500843,
0.101779066,
-0.142514199,
-0.7208032608,
0.1711468399,
0.340575695,
-0.0632544309,
0.5207989812,
0.4784369171,
0.2874212563,
0.2802346945,
-0.2675945759,
1.216063261,
-0.6939104199,
-0.521731019,
-0.7184222937,
0.5829756856,
0.1486265063,
-0.0430234298,
0.6801314354,
0.6614865661,
0.9894595146,
-0.2576646507,
0.9314724207,
-0.0088083139,
0.7489749789,
-0.5340538621,
1.1046583652,
-0.8842277527,
-0.0617756955,
-0.1545333117,
-1.4634559155,
-0.2840761542,
0.9136408567,
-0.261007458,
0.0920246989,
0.3757245243,
0.8737053275,
-0.4723750353,
-0.1771044433,
0.5259099603,
0.8288779855,
0.3942428529,
0.5130437016,
1.0465955734,
-0.4171236753,
0.4402902126,
-0.4613251984,
-0.1587320864,
-0.4102255702,
-0.7315496802,
-1.3348617554,
-0.4962271452,
-0.1707887948,
-0.3314271569,
0.1029860452,
1.0739190578,
0.7213618159,
-1.2558336258,
-0.4560243785,
0.0240573473,
-0.1872041076,
-0.0542909019,
-0.2338241041,
0.5349197388,
-0.2303856909,
-0.9250418544,
0.3905416131,
-0.1602207422,
0.4252392352,
-0.3489992619,
-0.0290351231,
-0.3165642917,
0.1690758318,
0.3302277625,
0.3339298964,
-0.6721659899,
-0.1185772866,
-0.089950256,
0.0388538502,
-0.0797824934,
0.7050337791,
-0.5692014098,
0.313085109,
0.4338347912,
0.3441821933,
0.8745604753,
-0.2088999897,
0.5775521398,
-0.573946476,
0.3730612099,
0.0305734482,
0.4993846416,
0.3170524538,
-0.1316728294,
0.6381685734,
0.0689720213,
-0.562404871,
-0.8172748685,
0.2356356531,
-0.7691603303,
-0.1553331465,
1.1881421804,
-0.4239361882,
-0.4116567373,
0.0418418199,
-0.3018229008,
0.4129365981,
-0.0648620501,
0.9784265757,
0.7282467484,
0.1756337285,
-0.0859560743,
-0.4892438352,
0.1081324145,
0.464048177,
-0.604070127,
0.3254914582,
0.4283608198,
0.5244401693,
0.1099371091,
0.5724035501,
-0.2350514233,
0.0109808529,
-0.0436650142,
0.1949584782,
-0.2943766117,
-0.4836668074,
-0.4560455978,
-0.2223925442,
0.2750476301,
-0.2940834463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03975v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03975v2 | Revisiting Conversation Discourse for Dialogue Disentanglement | 2023-06-06T19:17:47 | 2023-06-10T06:42:03 | Bobo Li, Hao Fei, Fei Li, Shengqiong Wu, Lizi Liao, Yinwei Wei, Tat-Seng Chua, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue disentanglement aims to detach the chronologically ordered
utterances into several independent sessions. Conversation utterances are
essentially organized and described by the underlying discourse, and thus
dialogue disentanglement requires the full understanding and harnessing of the
intrinsic discourse attribute. In this paper, we propose enhancing dialogue
disentanglement by taking full advantage of the dialogue discourse
characteristics. First of all, in feature encoding stage, we construct the
heterogeneous graph representations to model the various dialogue-specific
discourse structural features, including the static speaker-role structures
(i.e., speaker-utterance and speaker-mentioning structure) and the dynamic
contextual structures (i.e., the utterance-distance and partial-replying
structure). We then develop a structure-aware framework to integrate the rich
structural features for better modeling the conversational semantic context.
Second, in model learning stage, we perform optimization with a hierarchical
ranking loss mechanism, which groups dialogue utterances into different
discourse levels and carries training covering pair-wise and session-wise
levels hierarchically. Third, in inference stage, we devise an easy-first
decoding algorithm, which performs utterance pairing under the easy-to-hard
manner with a global context, breaking the constraint of traditional sequential
decoding order. On two benchmark datasets, our overall system achieves new
state-of-the-art performances on all evaluations. In-depth analyses further
demonstrate the efficacy of each proposed idea and also reveal how our methods
help advance the task. Our work has great potential to facilitate broader
multi-party multi-thread dialogue applications. | [
-0.294267565,
-0.9607883692,
0.5498251915,
0.165807873,
-0.4270291328,
0.6676216125,
0.1916815937,
-0.4320581853,
0.3143513203,
0.4509327412,
-0.4835656583,
-0.5101853013,
-0.6292916536,
-0.1503020823,
-0.3717535734,
0.7976099253,
0.2674427032,
0.0707680583,
-0.1156538576,
-0.2464847416,
-0.5188319683,
-0.5528464913,
-0.526262939,
-0.5320282578,
0.3766148984,
0.0428403951,
0.5227795839,
0.3093934655,
-0.0145661179,
0.4454423189,
-0.7271670699,
0.21099177,
-0.8030773997,
0.0675441325,
-0.1687525213,
-0.2967562079,
-0.4614632726,
-0.1366849989,
0.7390235066,
0.8491621614,
-0.3745291233,
-0.2144675851,
0.4462403059,
0.3856212795,
-0.1945208758,
0.5326244235,
-0.6659314632,
0.1530145407,
0.0190364365,
-0.1727870107,
-0.521895051,
-0.1643808633,
0.3833367527,
-0.3465006351,
0.0705634281,
0.1557324529,
0.7370613217,
0.1010019258,
-0.6402902603,
-0.0513171107,
-0.8881751895,
0.5013843775,
-0.740252018,
0.3515490592,
0.2275128216,
0.2074294537,
-0.1388793886,
-0.6080896854,
-0.3323627412,
-0.0265732817,
-0.2900391519,
0.1435136795,
-0.1819096655,
0.3010070622,
0.1480235308,
0.5476973653,
-0.2347182781,
0.1684404612,
0.1032930091,
-0.3718367815,
0.2622828484,
0.363447994,
0.1501405388,
-0.4143297374,
-0.3178148866,
0.0859121233,
-0.5709063411,
0.1281421781,
0.3559628129,
0.2717324793,
-0.2788464427,
0.2002203465,
-0.1683870703,
0.2708903551,
0.4201418459,
-0.2965690792,
0.1980919838,
-0.5457596183,
0.0198748801,
0.3986053169,
0.6926412582,
0.2059790194,
-0.4574221671,
-0.1019247994,
0.2463716269,
-0.2787373364,
0.1012103185,
-0.8131002784,
-0.13990435,
0.1787399203,
-0.5213705301,
-0.3648824394,
-0.2045481056,
-0.7627044916,
-0.274479866,
-0.247113049,
0.0280795954,
-0.6135417819,
-0.5385350585,
0.0424365178,
-0.0149224792,
0.3470340371,
0.3617083728,
-1.0578297377,
0.4046022296,
0.776973784,
0.8689566255,
-0.0047177193,
0.004594448,
-0.343988955,
0.1426664293,
-0.1113215908,
0.4099345207,
-0.6687397361,
-0.5275354981,
-0.2359893769,
0.184161067,
-0.0208321922,
-0.1767265797,
0.2663305998,
-0.4176602662,
0.3513197005,
0.0420732647,
-0.4555952847,
-0.1379804015,
0.4268772006,
-0.6340153813,
0.4538336098,
0.0422841273,
-0.9383760691,
-0.0520010144,
-0.4640157521,
-0.4921280742,
-0.0142456666,
-0.2557744682,
-0.4801644981,
0.0562046021,
0.2970072329,
-0.0182965212,
-0.1633087993,
0.4258478284,
-0.2133483887,
-0.3965070546,
0.3096117675,
-0.7906589508,
0.8841168284,
0.0594399311,
-0.2800967693,
-0.1286217868,
-0.5181378722,
0.0076831062,
-0.1121466532,
-0.1186606884,
-0.2595519423,
0.0903194174,
-0.442648828,
-0.0596243478,
0.102797322,
-0.5629326701,
-0.0767436549,
-0.9541332126,
0.7784371376,
0.6996415257,
0.3314372301,
0.5593666434,
-0.0376206152,
0.3286612928,
0.5605332851,
-0.0396104492,
-0.4882495701,
-0.4044049382,
-0.520876348,
-0.3383474946,
0.5542186499,
0.7632575035,
-0.9252098799,
0.53519243,
-0.0962570384,
-0.1774969846,
-0.5581351519,
-0.2168086767,
0.866686821,
0.6555090547,
0.1296911389,
-0.630376339,
-0.3494243622,
-0.63773489,
0.0517593399,
-0.4987868369,
-0.1615019888,
0.3954512477,
0.0459377877,
-0.0005841492,
0.8777117729,
-0.630477488,
0.0727683082,
-0.3029840589,
0.3339723349,
0.008690428,
0.5199041367,
0.1750092953,
-0.8484507799,
-0.3078235388,
-0.0014625475,
-0.7060174942,
0.3179838955,
-0.0386616662,
-0.2417673469,
0.0957725048,
0.4551855028,
-0.4029518664,
0.4563255906,
0.2929036915,
-0.0374766961,
0.3772089183,
-0.0409911685,
0.2956329286,
-1.343999505,
-0.1291756034,
-0.1818111986,
-0.2656755745,
-0.7657138705,
-0.2366654277,
-0.4686106145,
-0.2807120681,
-0.4993139803,
-0.071338661,
-0.379135102,
0.1388854533,
0.0191129521,
0.2729045451,
0.3728661835,
0.9194494486,
-0.1232631952,
0.5197788477,
0.4727955759,
-0.2910096943,
0.1645370871,
0.618029654,
-0.3856559396,
0.6284945011,
-0.7378752828,
0.3642866313,
-0.224125281,
0.5535209775,
-1.4505413771,
0.0068604611,
0.4145893157,
-0.3428111374,
0.3105953932,
-0.3456258476,
-0.1969669163,
-0.118969433,
-0.1977818161,
0.3871806264,
0.2965463102,
-0.3563025594,
0.6704232097,
0.5672063828,
-0.4413916469,
-0.4525763094,
-0.5179920793,
0.243366003,
-0.3971848488,
-0.639457643,
0.7398616672,
-0.0422510616,
-0.0572193787,
-0.2270570695,
-0.2419841439,
-0.2072086036,
0.0642762408,
0.2415567189,
0.2851513326,
0.0012653592,
-0.0228182264,
0.4431048334,
-0.2911864817,
-0.083337985,
-0.0867337659,
0.5810130835,
-0.2606738508,
-0.5063406825,
-0.7172580957,
0.612287581,
0.5096333623,
-0.3307281733,
0.6081237197,
0.5020011067,
-0.0291607473,
0.2381009609,
-0.3237729371,
-0.2316346169,
-0.4808180928,
0.4212217331,
-0.5723319054,
-1.3159464598,
0.6497978568,
-0.6208795905,
0.1883451641,
-0.249382332,
0.3632393777,
-0.1658314914,
1.2772139311,
0.5473824739,
-0.2603820562,
0.5596311092,
-0.0990684927,
0.8004442453,
-0.9437400699,
-0.3379749358,
-0.2600100338,
-0.2724600136,
-0.6823333502,
-0.4263180792,
0.3495560884,
0.1357530951,
0.1098582372,
0.2689519525,
-0.4932649732,
0.4569405317,
0.1655079871,
0.3270946145,
0.509511292,
-0.0003921716,
-0.2829302251,
-0.2901138365,
-0.5764336586,
-0.3956387043,
0.5440194011,
0.4334255457,
0.6158083677,
0.2308410555,
0.8021658063,
0.1397057474,
-0.3876048326,
-0.6823667884,
0.6195760965,
0.0729140937,
-0.2640560269,
-0.3598475456,
-0.5774920583,
-1.0670973063,
0.5167770386,
-0.0035567835,
-1.0696597099,
0.1549404711,
0.0739553496,
-0.3637354374,
-0.0834477022,
-0.7127497792,
0.6736553311,
0.0693640485,
-0.2480798513,
-0.2992429733,
-0.8532245755,
0.5788455009,
0.4074503481,
-0.0017220918,
-0.0063433256,
0.5113140941,
0.3763259947,
-0.3471170068,
1.0845029354,
-0.0862565711,
-0.2238304615,
0.4010582268,
0.0213293843,
0.2711355984,
0.403007865,
0.1523977369,
0.3149074018,
0.0648344308,
-0.1094510704,
-0.7126951218,
0.523142159,
-0.5670846701,
-0.8042450547,
0.0086878948,
-0.2718488574,
-0.3444316387,
0.0260012392,
0.0103275524,
0.9118548632,
-0.7113391161,
0.071826525,
1.0494503975,
-0.0883858576,
0.4231705666,
0.5267249346,
-0.1286438107,
-0.4222250581,
1.1629503965,
-0.1443147659,
0.3372729421,
0.4930976629,
0.1449314207,
-0.3427963555,
-0.5018063188,
-0.3691737652,
0.0981201679,
-0.3707997203,
-0.1158183441,
-0.6414954662,
-0.5479720235,
-0.466014564,
0.2022531033,
-0.3328226805,
-0.4762241244,
-0.2217767984,
-0.2444055974,
-0.0254863109,
0.2065861523,
0.1975534856,
0.3778774738,
-0.693638742,
0.3975684643,
0.4163086712,
0.2469529659,
0.17756401,
-0.4311435223,
-0.1737511009,
0.2618859708,
-0.6500207782,
-0.7675123811,
0.0788731799,
0.1189982444,
0.6206806302,
0.5261108279,
0.1018930376,
0.8087779284,
-0.7198745608,
0.8143815398,
0.4003562331,
-1.0721178055,
0.5518522859,
-0.2495511174,
0.5702242255,
0.5173892379,
0.0100500602,
-0.5878623128,
-0.6790977716,
-0.6400484443,
-0.9080963731,
0.9637349248,
0.4495279491,
0.2310638875,
0.057006631,
0.1787161082,
-0.0499790497,
0.3168565929,
-0.4659933448,
-0.2730041444,
-0.3174099624,
-0.02607782,
0.2574659288,
-0.3220642507,
-0.6057010889,
-0.4062188566,
0.3430959284,
-0.1422802359,
0.4478811026,
-0.0474078767,
-0.03189959,
0.406563431,
0.5151048899,
0.4238743484,
0.4678487182,
0.0393606499,
0.0871244818,
0.177443102,
-0.0667755306,
0.3038153052,
0.1153886393,
0.202556625,
0.1097244322,
0.2042794973,
1.0423117876,
0.5636155009,
-0.1622575969,
0.3944108188,
-0.2827471793,
-0.1563919634,
0.0693842322,
0.0184441134,
0.3804322481,
0.3768366873,
0.0275505558,
-0.1727463305,
0.3199083507,
-0.6917533875,
0.3265390694,
0.3418874145,
-0.3625490963,
-0.3230294883,
0.2403845489,
0.6183071136,
-0.4209201336,
0.4690373242,
-0.3733605742,
-0.5262935758,
0.3144704401,
0.5194938779,
0.7858942151,
-0.4581732452,
0.5181438327,
0.2359398305,
0.0108095286,
0.1963616014,
-0.238647148,
-0.5647431016,
-0.7216150761,
-0.4444377422,
-0.3897187114,
-0.659256041,
-0.0439733192,
-0.6828451157,
-0.0643585548,
-0.4262478948,
-0.2083773017,
-0.0263077188,
-0.1541691422,
-0.0908337086,
-0.4393357337,
0.1995852292,
0.1937419623,
-0.4413130581,
0.6731481552,
0.0224065613,
-0.0879545957,
-0.5147457123,
0.0177958496,
0.3046656549,
-0.4570449889,
0.0966222435,
0.3201905489,
-0.4853194356,
-0.043576397,
-0.2961374819,
-0.683278501,
1.2375816107,
0.5361351967,
-0.7448781133,
-0.3364368379,
0.3457702696,
0.4195412993,
-0.4987312853,
0.3171399236,
0.7482785583,
-0.0379697308,
0.6125132442,
-0.9123581648,
0.0252756663,
-0.098746337,
0.3747070432,
0.3114787638,
-0.7513961196,
0.4833216071,
0.2605671585,
-0.512804687,
0.0216155052,
0.7130956054,
0.0663937926,
0.2915058136,
0.6651412249,
0.4338783622,
0.7101732492,
-0.1638385653,
0.2846762538,
-0.3983158767,
0.204434976,
1.3751711845,
-0.4166180789,
0.5278042555,
0.2855576575,
-0.0205267742,
0.7614172101,
0.268709749,
0.5003246069,
0.6712518334,
0.0831839666,
-0.5859425068,
-0.1964141279,
-0.1085658148,
-0.372889787,
0.7838796973,
0.5193504691,
-0.2406877279,
-0.423448354,
0.2362971604,
0.1551247239,
0.0914764702,
0.1299867481,
1.2689707279,
0.1494606435,
-0.5434470177,
0.642842412,
-0.1249749139,
0.3289453089,
-0.6447624564,
-0.237339437,
-0.1820839792,
0.0163230561,
0.0127924271,
-0.5685651302,
0.4397572279,
-0.2697410882,
-0.0473483801,
-0.4386912584,
0.5773869753,
-0.8024152517,
-0.231877327,
0.1765829027,
0.364035368,
0.0488618761,
0.189001739,
-0.7615362406,
0.3134239912,
0.1429213881,
0.1087435111,
0.4892089665,
0.5560236573,
0.2531529963,
0.301388979,
0.2970463037,
-0.5019083023,
-0.3958181143,
0.3558357954,
1.1810611486,
-0.4578633308,
-0.6857717633,
-0.8130478859,
0.7058604956,
-0.4746512175,
-0.0474019535,
0.7089982629,
0.3286557198,
0.494833082,
0.5498592257,
0.3434037268,
-0.0742950886,
0.3187710643,
-0.4447964728,
0.5131779909,
0.0231918339,
0.3328187764,
-0.5524361134,
-0.6407108307,
0.2339345515,
0.4949041307,
-0.050591331,
-0.3572364748,
0.6254572272,
0.8576222658,
0.0513962433,
0.4374417663,
0.3252730072,
0.1839848608,
0.6530178189,
0.6748592257,
0.7925221324,
-0.3461004198,
0.5599408746,
0.0572460927,
-0.4326682389,
-0.0249245241,
-0.6164734364,
-0.8365984559,
-0.6615127921,
-0.4712784588,
-0.3230092525,
0.0788711831,
0.4040905833,
0.7362493873,
-0.4400781989,
-0.1455360055,
-0.1383515,
0.4858237505,
-0.3678164184,
-0.2402580827,
-0.06324137,
-0.243895933,
-0.8386699557,
0.6277958155,
0.5110776424,
-0.0759686381,
-0.3580023348,
-0.0332596414,
-0.3547411561,
0.1823924929,
0.9001677036,
0.1748407781,
-0.6383658051,
-0.3552836478,
-0.3943110108,
0.0333754681,
0.30447945,
0.9041979909,
-0.7180700302,
0.6309384108,
0.2104715109,
0.603507936,
0.7490257621,
0.2646443844,
0.6213709116,
-0.8634986281,
0.4463080764,
0.2531201243,
0.2209357619,
0.2248703837,
-0.321927309,
0.062691845,
0.0926056877,
-0.3262289464,
-0.8179324865,
0.5507121682,
-1.0084751844,
-0.2010078281,
0.5044131875,
-0.4952296615,
-0.2803921103,
-0.4220659137,
-0.4393058419,
0.2867244184,
-0.475543201,
0.8603854775,
0.8264280558,
-0.2764871716,
-0.2418785542,
0.0780049637,
0.295884341,
0.5017732978,
-0.7189184427,
0.3022211194,
0.5503979921,
0.0112076299,
0.3961081803,
0.7634950876,
-0.3609808385,
-0.0650686547,
0.1934880316,
-0.5258952975,
0.019159982,
-0.3518987298,
-0.2484049201,
0.2535104752,
-0.0358612128,
-0.3873982131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03974v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03974v2 | TKDP: Threefold Knowledge-enriched Deep Prompt Tuning for Few-shot Named Entity Recognition | 2023-06-06T19:11:59 | 2023-06-10T06:50:35 | Jiang Liu, Hao Fei, Fei Li, Jingye Li, Bobo Li, Liang Zhao, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot named entity recognition (NER) exploits limited annotated instances
to identify named mentions. Effectively transferring the internal or external
resources thus becomes the key to few-shot NER. While the existing prompt
tuning methods have shown remarkable few-shot performances, they still fail to
make full use of knowledge. In this work, we investigate the integration of
rich knowledge to prompt tuning for stronger few-shot NER. We propose
incorporating the deep prompt tuning framework with threefold knowledge (namely
TKDP), including the internal 1) context knowledge and the external 2) label
knowledge & 3) sememe knowledge. TKDP encodes the three feature sources and
incorporates them into the soft prompt embeddings, which are further injected
into an existing pre-trained language model to facilitate predictions. On five
benchmark datasets, our knowledge-enriched model boosts by at most 11.53% F1
over the raw deep prompt method, and significantly outperforms 8
strong-performing baseline systems in 5-/10-/20-shot settings, showing great
potential in few-shot NER. Our TKDP can be broadly adapted to other few-shot
tasks without effort. | [
-0.4158422947,
-0.5307113528,
0.798761785,
0.1384900063,
-0.4630229473,
-0.0928388834,
-0.3121950924,
-0.4420594275,
-0.1655704826,
0.4487258792,
-0.5694133043,
-0.57889992,
-0.5907047987,
0.2531458735,
0.3282159567,
0.9761619568,
0.1799361557,
0.2006296068,
0.325796932,
-0.0014784916,
-0.7478863001,
0.1764940023,
-0.8757136464,
-0.2765017152,
0.6338769197,
0.841359973,
0.1724343598,
0.3746089041,
0.3388518989,
0.1065460294,
-0.1103010029,
0.319991082,
-0.4272918403,
0.1633051038,
-0.103133209,
-0.4748408496,
-0.3606932461,
-0.1882548183,
0.7404687405,
0.5573768616,
0.2469401211,
-0.0269455072,
0.314832747,
0.3620209396,
-0.832216084,
0.2049339414,
-0.6806092262,
0.0372543447,
-0.4888281524,
-0.206851393,
-0.2323128879,
-0.3444703221,
0.2133497447,
-0.7989143729,
0.1845281422,
0.0591663755,
0.729831636,
0.4931912422,
-0.4370411336,
0.0784940571,
-0.4938059747,
0.6398565173,
-0.6664161682,
0.2550628781,
0.4864945412,
0.5893040895,
-0.271591872,
-0.4318916798,
-0.7813830972,
-0.0139027443,
-0.0102915121,
-0.1205983013,
-0.1015006602,
0.2946472168,
0.4400382936,
-0.0324058011,
-0.2841875255,
0.476000905,
-0.1508119553,
-0.2563809454,
0.3084794581,
0.267220974,
0.0759893507,
-0.338247478,
-0.3332164586,
0.0518508777,
-0.8242020607,
0.0940718725,
0.1672796458,
0.808354795,
-0.1087463945,
0.7065590024,
-0.3624356389,
0.8934386373,
0.3380061984,
-0.4207784832,
0.0515468605,
-0.3700225949,
-0.1823190153,
0.3188653886,
0.6973800063,
0.4577702284,
0.2574160993,
-0.0659304112,
-0.2224771231,
-0.1442088336,
-0.1339554191,
-0.9561371207,
-0.1614493877,
-0.0294718649,
-0.2834683359,
-0.1293721646,
-0.2469596416,
-0.7441545725,
-0.8090785146,
-0.1632662714,
0.4386919737,
-0.7210761905,
-0.2277945131,
-0.0766627118,
-0.393796593,
0.3539680839,
0.5118423104,
-0.9368153214,
0.0368118919,
0.8504788876,
0.7456294298,
-0.065067701,
-0.4235897064,
-0.8350698948,
0.255872041,
-0.1888940483,
1.1340440512,
-0.6970366836,
-0.2862438858,
-0.0614253134,
-0.0387056544,
0.0994020849,
-0.3035371602,
0.5474711061,
-0.5913770199,
0.0975680277,
-0.3568169177,
-0.8415509462,
-0.0883099139,
0.3565009832,
-0.6144881248,
0.7060592771,
0.1132570654,
-0.6758983731,
0.9984405041,
-0.6257665157,
-0.4734313488,
0.5335270762,
-0.0733532608,
-0.1917869598,
0.2171803862,
0.4326964915,
0.5975671411,
-0.1241076812,
0.0900052935,
-0.6022814512,
-0.2298422456,
-0.1595631093,
-0.1191278994,
0.6171314716,
-0.1469968408,
-0.1255126297,
-0.3164917529,
-0.8006929755,
0.0693647116,
-0.0814707577,
-0.2162928432,
-0.3453636467,
-0.5310623646,
-0.0453667901,
0.0065239295,
-0.085043177,
-0.5728881955,
0.6503499746,
-0.7101911902,
0.1278403252,
0.527043283,
0.5628994107,
0.8970246911,
0.0057541458,
0.6140740514,
0.2643597424,
-0.1216708049,
-0.3493839502,
-0.5492700934,
-0.5255711675,
-0.2504913211,
0.5184198618,
0.468362242,
-0.9404703379,
0.254039675,
-0.2350600362,
-0.2961294651,
-0.6557756662,
0.2720753253,
0.1133557707,
0.9651134014,
0.5266901851,
0.1692032963,
-0.499229908,
-0.9233119488,
-0.4464001954,
-0.107669428,
-0.2324703336,
0.7035621405,
0.4114877582,
0.0412481129,
1.0399343967,
-0.4734289348,
-0.8744191527,
-0.4671257734,
0.1717583686,
0.5002779961,
0.4116664529,
0.3910791576,
-0.2365563363,
-0.4684179425,
-0.1938855499,
-0.3841453195,
-0.1499428749,
-0.0853103548,
-0.0676693395,
0.0489916056,
0.0617424883,
-0.8913784027,
0.0292299893,
-0.04902317,
-0.4085454941,
0.2319888473,
0.1366985589,
0.0499290116,
-1.1853457689,
-0.1624882817,
-0.0168937314,
-0.1343277246,
-0.4598778486,
-0.3921149373,
0.2656734586,
-0.1074650809,
-0.5655955076,
1.0014994144,
-0.3615994453,
0.0252197776,
-0.471262902,
0.2373974025,
0.077294983,
0.3461287022,
0.1446668804,
0.5575671792,
0.7627034783,
-0.9178655744,
0.2906628251,
0.2549884915,
-0.4703385234,
0.8955852389,
-0.5384367108,
0.1543509215,
-0.1073072627,
0.2832208276,
-0.550239861,
-0.4035285711,
0.4160442352,
-0.4381613731,
0.6580742598,
-0.633813262,
-0.5684515238,
-0.1196712479,
-0.1815987974,
0.4093911946,
0.3054299951,
-0.6494719982,
0.612054944,
0.1348743588,
-0.1538652331,
-0.509315908,
-0.5789878964,
0.0750529468,
-0.1896194965,
-0.5479105115,
0.6036252975,
0.2240191996,
0.1660100371,
0.0409605764,
-0.1372892559,
-0.0213945527,
0.1012212038,
0.1280260533,
0.1365917623,
-0.4756142199,
0.4589975476,
0.1815136224,
-0.3837799132,
-0.3321126103,
-0.5757954121,
0.1823539287,
0.0826838836,
0.0278371405,
-0.6866316795,
0.1741373539,
0.0658424571,
0.0202108566,
0.6665834785,
0.7792370915,
-0.4619602561,
-0.3574769795,
-0.6487828493,
-0.2860625088,
-0.3888330162,
0.0192112345,
-0.5429475307,
-1.0691380501,
0.1832243651,
-0.2608082294,
-0.2481406778,
0.4644937813,
0.2455196381,
-0.293684721,
0.8633570075,
0.8576554656,
-0.139103353,
0.4945489764,
-0.118651323,
0.0988440588,
-0.8753190041,
-0.2862233818,
-0.5498069525,
-0.530151844,
-0.5595575571,
-0.2222446054,
0.3171169162,
0.3668803871,
-0.3533596694,
0.299690336,
-0.1525728106,
0.8682379723,
0.5090556741,
0.2022134811,
0.1057307869,
-0.3380581141,
0.0181557126,
-0.1351222545,
-0.636339426,
-0.4107889235,
0.8804751039,
0.1585482657,
0.693384409,
0.0618536621,
0.8549149036,
0.0500827283,
-0.1393096,
-0.9765632153,
0.4489970803,
0.1086954623,
-0.4026586711,
-0.2210059166,
-0.2421177924,
-0.742087245,
-0.314132303,
-0.3125505149,
-0.7532212138,
0.3836095929,
0.3031578362,
-1.0588155985,
-0.0144756343,
-0.7726872563,
0.8348298669,
-0.072358042,
-0.2854510546,
0.0236038789,
-0.5569819808,
0.4127516747,
0.1648411453,
-0.4803191423,
-0.3379263282,
-0.3951876163,
0.5994587541,
-0.1546262056,
0.7726918459,
-0.5783900023,
0.0506742783,
-0.1047517583,
-0.019206224,
0.7173816562,
0.5357826948,
-0.0215807892,
0.0989509374,
-0.4105288088,
-0.3725084364,
-0.7060536742,
0.7474304438,
-0.5739189982,
-0.5147345662,
-0.1615988314,
-0.1967761368,
-0.3983811736,
0.5680238008,
0.4744226933,
0.2570676208,
-0.1168790162,
0.0911134854,
0.6907356381,
-0.1150254682,
0.6391634941,
0.6017749906,
0.1869639009,
-0.5387584567,
0.7149477601,
0.0079299929,
-0.2047475576,
0.4788201153,
0.0831921995,
-0.3268671036,
-0.4173283279,
-0.5257530212,
0.1984302998,
-0.6697849631,
-0.8954734802,
-0.8837641478,
0.1337565333,
-0.5625670552,
-0.1395709217,
-0.3444314003,
-0.53838557,
-0.7906877398,
-0.1462032646,
0.4626270235,
0.5543310046,
0.0317294039,
0.5234454274,
-0.8375580907,
0.636631608,
0.431663245,
0.6111397147,
-0.2660764754,
-0.5007150173,
-0.0474928953,
-0.2453544438,
-0.0799805671,
-1.1310441494,
0.231904164,
0.5705726147,
0.5223429203,
0.6312198639,
0.0975436345,
0.6745604873,
-0.5681160688,
0.8569627404,
-0.0383883789,
-0.7510221601,
0.9579817057,
-0.1151763052,
0.5542372465,
0.9967572093,
0.3635439277,
-0.1540534645,
-0.0068983058,
-0.4153900146,
-0.4753179848,
1.0687804222,
-0.0892381594,
-0.0401023142,
0.0415763408,
0.1969956011,
0.3154585361,
0.107579872,
-0.4798731506,
-0.1221073046,
-0.1052439287,
-0.0036069613,
-0.0132783959,
-0.3580953777,
0.0908511654,
-0.0654312372,
0.7772687674,
-0.3701591492,
0.0704779178,
-0.0718673542,
-0.3211426437,
-0.0681373477,
0.4954530001,
0.4863829315,
0.2314756215,
-0.1155732796,
0.1206787676,
0.3107697666,
-0.2259447426,
0.1166426912,
0.3679550588,
-0.2650457323,
-0.0672073811,
0.4071772695,
1.0756676197,
0.4687438011,
-0.0620998442,
0.5406188965,
-0.0538988151,
0.1633097827,
0.0333676822,
0.217760399,
-0.1758696884,
0.6612535715,
0.4333897829,
0.2449081987,
0.253688097,
0.0324391834,
-0.011188955,
0.4378157854,
-0.2616703212,
-0.3413423002,
0.3127911985,
0.3482272625,
-0.3087863028,
0.6967342496,
-0.4412263036,
-0.5014438629,
0.3231246769,
0.4526949227,
1.1285748482,
-0.0795788765,
0.1956439018,
0.6279068589,
0.3291002214,
0.0206475537,
0.3256482482,
-0.5319857001,
-0.7336859107,
-0.3700641096,
-0.6403930783,
-0.2170946151,
0.1476793587,
-0.3231647909,
0.8578410149,
-0.4720751047,
-0.2060560435,
0.1835457236,
0.2940922678,
-1.1274268627,
-0.1704593897,
0.483602792,
1.0304611921,
-0.7889532447,
0.7355595231,
0.6894302368,
-0.3818484247,
-0.7917573452,
0.1831242442,
0.0392335653,
-0.636547029,
0.7911479473,
0.4031378925,
0.1043742001,
0.3842560351,
-0.6320195198,
-0.8049184084,
1.1435649395,
0.4498845637,
-0.6060184836,
-0.0581806153,
-0.0894814506,
0.3088482618,
-0.4844581485,
0.4557570517,
0.7140575647,
0.7253350019,
0.2133108974,
-0.7903926969,
-0.0257577039,
0.0554695502,
0.0847620219,
0.1369750947,
-0.3921360075,
0.3657573164,
-0.5840975046,
-0.4709911346,
-0.0761135444,
0.7735007405,
0.4842649102,
0.4445112944,
0.420011133,
0.5508700609,
0.8389089108,
-0.0920595601,
0.882753253,
-0.1835077703,
0.0059846565,
1.3012371063,
-0.3810026944,
0.5749439597,
0.4887522459,
0.0680388287,
0.2886891961,
0.6915737987,
-0.1554151475,
0.8339343667,
-0.2276356667,
-0.4102933109,
-0.4373767078,
-0.5674411058,
-0.4830419719,
0.5748178363,
0.3760405779,
-0.2421750873,
-0.4006372392,
0.2252055705,
-0.1992856264,
-0.527618885,
-0.3849263787,
1.2560861111,
0.2460201383,
-0.7585807443,
0.265820086,
-0.1946973652,
0.6010991931,
-0.3732053339,
-0.3663626909,
-0.3001886904,
0.0046525309,
-0.198380664,
-0.8953365088,
-0.2559428513,
0.050049182,
-0.2884603739,
-0.2651020288,
1.1339813471,
-0.4319739044,
-0.2240642607,
-0.0232751369,
0.4829111397,
-0.1671048999,
-0.1795829386,
-0.454490304,
-0.3369967639,
-0.2197945416,
-0.2305081785,
0.1248281524,
0.7705321908,
0.458017379,
0.4361262918,
0.3706830442,
0.2476802021,
-0.1248695552,
0.3137047589,
0.9638258219,
-0.8148629665,
-0.588973403,
-0.8868147731,
0.5185949206,
-0.0970071182,
-0.4832583964,
0.6395031214,
0.3043450713,
0.630769074,
-0.0654994398,
0.6547892094,
0.0453135259,
0.424259603,
-0.6481935382,
0.5676076412,
-0.3633878827,
0.248211354,
-0.2959652245,
-1.0424613953,
-0.3988240361,
0.1314605176,
-0.2432913184,
-0.0128636425,
0.4558242559,
0.8141955733,
-0.0920390859,
0.0483741164,
0.3251988888,
0.1900396198,
0.0797088742,
0.6841307878,
0.8498674631,
-0.3084508777,
0.50817132,
-0.4195536375,
-0.005801897,
-0.3742858171,
-1.145858407,
-0.9041587114,
-0.2629518211,
-0.3306905627,
-0.0642238855,
-0.0377413295,
1.0256665945,
0.6518799663,
-0.7748339176,
0.5812621117,
-0.1215460896,
0.4079189897,
-0.0075006476,
-0.2134055346,
0.1387132108,
-0.5972129107,
-0.5220203996,
0.7667051554,
0.3397777975,
0.1749693155,
0.0129213193,
-0.0322162472,
0.1102720425,
-0.4600659907,
0.4935267568,
0.2613297999,
-0.6794605255,
-0.1587130129,
0.1302107275,
-0.0852439329,
-0.134236902,
0.8003147244,
-1.2496598959,
0.4873894453,
0.6128093004,
0.7662053108,
0.3792950213,
-0.1072165594,
0.5816219449,
-1.093544364,
-0.060988877,
0.6272913814,
0.2703814805,
0.4155149162,
-0.5504233241,
0.2993871868,
0.1799940616,
-0.4614998698,
-0.755551219,
0.0897651017,
-0.9423715472,
0.068944402,
1.1405352354,
0.051297307,
0.0511020161,
-0.0937355459,
-0.1996339113,
0.3076197505,
-0.820301652,
0.4245618582,
0.5000590086,
-0.1374221146,
-0.5769107342,
-0.2752952576,
0.8504450917,
0.1833563894,
-0.6675437093,
-0.2321289033,
0.6312330961,
0.0962451547,
-0.0778047666,
0.6043184996,
0.3438880742,
0.4627524018,
-0.182213977,
-0.0956171975,
-0.2249555439,
-0.5280640721,
-0.676418066,
0.2601003051,
0.108043775,
-0.0495615527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03969v2 | ECQED: Emotion-Cause Quadruple Extraction in Dialogs | 2023-06-06T19:04:30 | 2023-06-10T06:52:49 | Li Zheng, Donghong Ji, Fei Li, Hao Fei, Shengqiong Wu, Jingye Li, Bobo Li, Chong Teng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The existing emotion-cause pair extraction (ECPE) task, unfortunately,
ignores extracting the emotion type and cause type, while these fine-grained
meta-information can be practically useful in real-world applications, i.e.,
chat robots and empathic dialog generation. Also the current ECPE is limited to
the scenario of single text piece, while neglecting the studies at dialog level
that should have more realistic values. In this paper, we extend the ECPE task
with a broader definition and scenario, presenting a new task, Emotion-Cause
Quadruple Extraction in Dialogs (ECQED), which requires detecting emotion-cause
utterance pairs and emotion and cause types. We present an ECQED model based on
a structural and semantic heterogeneous graph as well as a parallel grid
tagging scheme, which advances in effectively incorporating the dialog context
structure, meanwhile solving the challenging overlapped quadruple issue. Via
experiments we show that introducing the fine-grained emotion and cause
features evidently helps better dialog generation. Also our proposed ECQED
system shows exceptional superiority over baselines on both the emotion-cause
quadruple or pair extraction tasks, meanwhile being highly efficient. | [
-0.548745513,
-0.972017467,
0.4899860919,
-0.0425802991,
-0.0780325234,
0.1642824113,
0.0758851841,
-0.5564106703,
0.1859661341,
0.4611043036,
-0.5549387932,
-0.5101823807,
-0.3433299065,
0.1748470068,
-0.0714192167,
1.1647202969,
0.0708105937,
-0.2766140401,
-0.2378980666,
-0.0870213509,
-0.1532202065,
-0.5696803331,
-0.603957355,
-0.268519789,
0.5991336703,
0.7045977712,
0.2946310043,
0.0431700237,
0.059248291,
0.3315785527,
0.1445164382,
0.3853996396,
-0.4034829438,
0.1668914258,
0.2536921799,
-0.4464765489,
-0.8174920082,
-0.0356000103,
0.2960362732,
0.2371552438,
-0.2560257912,
0.0655604601,
0.0208641794,
0.5951836109,
-0.4177215695,
0.1707964987,
-0.4533565044,
0.2394209206,
-0.0005775352,
-0.412197113,
-0.0397457108,
-0.2359162271,
0.1773571372,
-0.5700778961,
0.0356347077,
0.3645103872,
0.8308869004,
0.0275106542,
-0.5503669381,
-0.159748584,
-0.4186818898,
0.3328499496,
-0.5767418146,
0.2047864646,
0.1014491245,
0.0727693811,
-0.0370433033,
-0.7750000954,
-0.8446640372,
0.305654794,
0.0664913356,
0.2592328489,
-0.4822755754,
0.4545746148,
0.4923270643,
0.2907811105,
-0.412243098,
0.0692333654,
-0.0711445957,
-0.2901574969,
0.4839951992,
0.4603117704,
0.6985675097,
-0.4266540408,
-0.3928606212,
0.1317339987,
-0.5981296897,
0.3348253965,
0.4681382775,
-0.0237286594,
-0.2611199021,
0.3397209346,
-0.3027073145,
0.3578421772,
0.2446495146,
0.0471539907,
0.4676910639,
-0.360031873,
-0.182163164,
-0.0563529469,
0.7989916205,
0.6985478401,
0.1660251617,
0.0297133215,
0.0561507717,
-0.0647147074,
0.0412124433,
-0.9869363904,
-0.218062982,
0.7575131059,
-0.3596209884,
-0.4718836844,
-0.3565864563,
-1.1444787979,
-0.1416817158,
-0.1242295727,
0.0941230357,
-0.3889386952,
-0.2920910418,
-0.0328851789,
-0.4042649269,
0.0109336656,
0.2353436649,
-0.7324104309,
0.3744083643,
0.7001350522,
0.6233499646,
0.1828781664,
0.019655671,
-0.8825054765,
-0.0501756184,
0.1898658574,
0.9365087152,
-0.8106328249,
-0.2150064707,
0.0339358859,
0.1123099327,
0.1682441533,
-0.2410510331,
0.9183741212,
-0.2314407378,
0.6431506872,
-0.3192921281,
-0.5671734214,
-0.2660247684,
0.5491330028,
-0.4778417945,
0.9933135509,
0.0965194553,
-0.808156848,
0.0380930975,
-0.5150157809,
-0.1703207791,
0.381039083,
-0.4258466661,
-0.4960285127,
0.0460256711,
0.0794284642,
0.3977893293,
-0.5693900585,
-0.0230039638,
-0.5868730545,
0.0818653926,
-0.1291786879,
-0.2010037601,
0.6185711026,
-0.1398581713,
-0.3258718252,
-0.1055833623,
-0.752155602,
0.3841038644,
0.0130851343,
-0.1229198352,
-0.4959280789,
0.1090605184,
0.0489181615,
0.7798088789,
0.1209802181,
-0.90236938,
-0.0127152493,
-0.3044598401,
0.2901644707,
0.599250555,
0.2769418359,
0.1575937569,
-0.2398845702,
0.7291945219,
0.1101504192,
-0.0046917242,
-0.3034582734,
-0.4169650376,
-0.4964304864,
-0.5555984378,
0.1312420517,
0.5952190757,
-0.7896131873,
0.3729488552,
0.1870236993,
-0.3088939786,
-0.3408948779,
-0.1977935284,
0.7271894217,
0.601498723,
0.1067559347,
-0.0899995491,
-0.6248012185,
-0.8059936166,
-0.2732694745,
-0.056975998,
-0.0654831529,
0.7206193805,
0.1922961026,
-0.0869658738,
0.7532717586,
-0.5547926426,
0.0911352187,
0.0062555876,
0.3593262732,
-0.1140229478,
0.1933327168,
0.554197371,
-0.8472329974,
-0.6782535315,
0.0430571064,
-0.4726382196,
-0.703931272,
0.0597949624,
-0.246753186,
0.272883743,
0.2687338293,
-0.7660309672,
0.4050129056,
0.6298536658,
-0.4381412566,
0.6478332281,
0.0436319597,
0.2222693563,
-0.9582403898,
-0.2181872427,
0.182877019,
-0.3231178224,
-0.717168808,
-0.4044161737,
0.0029480017,
-0.0954023078,
-0.2167604715,
0.1888117939,
-0.4392755926,
-0.1537749022,
-0.1653527021,
0.4952682257,
0.3563708365,
0.7401348948,
-0.2463698983,
0.1608255357,
0.5113246441,
-0.2586411238,
0.5852783322,
0.3895244002,
0.1034113169,
0.9324724078,
-0.5837777257,
0.2523204684,
-0.1276707798,
0.3711960018,
-1.0189633369,
-0.1112419292,
0.2781553864,
-0.5306612849,
0.1916638315,
0.0158496257,
-0.4080664217,
-0.560642004,
-0.3040292561,
0.3807152808,
0.5405892134,
-0.5962144136,
0.9144316912,
0.4595226347,
-0.4439680576,
-0.190850243,
0.0337343477,
-0.0281150416,
-0.4678922892,
-0.7735027075,
0.4445382059,
-0.0005339827,
-0.0520301089,
-0.1605452895,
-0.1091776565,
0.0360490531,
0.0860821381,
0.3703922927,
0.1501709223,
-0.0102137858,
0.3246301115,
0.0043133753,
-0.0580914021,
0.3132172227,
0.1115940139,
0.6936128139,
-0.3277412951,
-0.1126333252,
-0.5734795928,
0.801016748,
0.6754606962,
-0.3371107578,
0.2100986987,
0.6137354374,
-0.474370271,
-0.2942204177,
-0.3333461881,
-0.0844842717,
-0.4442638159,
0.4814655483,
-0.3440266252,
-0.901483953,
0.5587980747,
-0.3739037216,
-0.0028295165,
0.2449309975,
0.6977366209,
-0.2350100577,
1.3948769569,
0.5779193044,
0.0072753737,
0.4773005843,
0.1376070529,
0.4448035955,
-1.1340502501,
-0.2249954045,
-0.5387182236,
-0.0479687862,
-0.7203931212,
-0.1845642924,
0.6702463031,
-0.0738855526,
-0.0942060798,
-0.0627418607,
-0.3186073303,
0.1547388285,
0.2486002147,
0.2359445095,
0.2057967633,
-0.1250717342,
-0.0165108833,
0.0679055825,
-0.7568055987,
-0.5108753443,
0.766014576,
0.2340444028,
-0.0446436405,
0.1021507233,
0.8136889935,
0.2396039665,
0.1250735819,
-0.6153642535,
0.3740151227,
0.1922152638,
-0.445110321,
-0.2382676899,
-0.3078874052,
-0.913300395,
0.5851508975,
-0.3645844162,
-1.3434593678,
0.1500043422,
0.2406098545,
-0.5561056137,
0.1055340394,
-0.6954038143,
0.8053243756,
-0.1201090142,
-0.3765838742,
-0.2509097159,
-0.6643167138,
0.4245163202,
-0.1685383916,
0.3837910593,
-0.3362718225,
0.2935854495,
0.4357023537,
-0.7469243407,
0.790260613,
-0.232161954,
-0.0681499019,
0.3340037167,
-0.1375475973,
0.8153348565,
-0.0317680091,
0.1163481399,
0.014589292,
0.1063035131,
-0.3345164061,
-0.6545248032,
0.3941090703,
-0.4647777677,
-0.6967126131,
-0.1685486138,
-0.504308641,
-0.2583795488,
0.0112274578,
0.142885223,
0.7363542914,
-0.3726325035,
-0.0089438884,
0.3141073287,
-0.3481437564,
0.5416406393,
0.5247117877,
0.0058161593,
-0.2242071331,
0.6936151981,
-0.2266902924,
0.3856418729,
0.0363538489,
0.3347399533,
0.1350406557,
0.019678073,
-0.2167081833,
0.011275759,
-0.3251498342,
-0.3184332848,
-1.0289667845,
0.0689874813,
-0.2620453238,
-0.064732112,
-0.2872613966,
-0.3863251209,
-0.0813131183,
-0.0942460969,
0.3276087344,
0.2210146338,
-0.2485318184,
-0.0011933228,
-1.1543548107,
0.5331954956,
0.5020152926,
-0.0315799266,
-0.0473102443,
-0.049650494,
-0.0377344154,
0.1369740963,
-0.5433296561,
-0.9718397856,
0.6067934036,
0.2637672424,
0.3713545501,
0.4287979603,
0.3147070408,
0.4615900218,
-0.637070477,
0.5857477784,
0.5244210362,
-0.960947752,
0.1046280563,
-0.5223129392,
-0.0930887312,
0.0258107763,
0.3238517344,
-0.8073136806,
-0.3330398798,
-0.9650336504,
-0.9333522916,
0.7953951955,
0.4530386329,
-0.0064758579,
-0.1347086728,
0.1390576363,
-0.0369919129,
0.1321173757,
-0.3606469035,
-0.1568796933,
0.037142355,
-0.2815362215,
0.3484618366,
-0.3589710593,
-0.2643519044,
-0.1446590722,
0.4874443114,
-0.1014310122,
0.5200887322,
0.2912290096,
0.2488213331,
-0.30899629,
0.3058542609,
0.1925150454,
-0.2428167313,
-0.1882880479,
-0.0463892519,
0.09439338,
-0.0100065954,
-0.142540589,
0.2400906235,
0.3591679037,
-0.1432996839,
0.1380507052,
0.8166205287,
0.1098825261,
-0.7510710955,
0.7804766893,
-0.0122558922,
-0.1317458749,
-0.3259701133,
-0.0362474993,
0.0724223852,
0.7241293788,
0.0647754297,
-0.3811573088,
0.6517426968,
-0.8278414011,
0.2530696094,
0.41471228,
-0.1334986836,
-0.565761447,
0.2707805634,
0.7993186712,
-0.6136149168,
0.4410621524,
-0.4290296733,
-1.3074638844,
0.9682010412,
0.5813687444,
0.894592762,
-0.1084780395,
0.3564207256,
0.3170678616,
-0.1154685318,
0.3736788332,
0.5098230839,
-0.3690097928,
-1.0889976025,
-0.1344943047,
-0.1629396081,
-0.6579369903,
-0.1938603222,
-0.7952371836,
0.3142000735,
-0.0830795541,
-0.1020152345,
0.2022194266,
-0.0743253455,
-0.766772747,
0.0861551687,
0.5320308208,
0.2676314116,
-0.8946992755,
0.4048471153,
0.4837220907,
-0.0665603429,
-0.7648819685,
-0.1091734096,
0.1775088012,
-0.676995039,
0.5288167596,
0.3768346906,
-0.061776489,
0.1686553955,
-0.5549331903,
-0.6469729543,
0.9361435175,
-0.2931922674,
-0.7074529529,
-0.18837367,
-0.058039885,
0.5693193078,
-0.6758829355,
0.5524364114,
0.6580953598,
0.4596638083,
-0.1215326861,
-0.8628364205,
0.204442203,
-0.5124545097,
-0.3387499452,
0.516923666,
-1.0688800812,
0.7139699459,
-0.059171468,
-0.311794579,
-0.2786283791,
0.143521294,
0.3611814678,
0.5735974312,
0.6648443341,
0.5834679008,
0.9441384077,
-0.0393210687,
1.0032709837,
-0.4398742616,
0.4497434795,
1.1567218304,
-0.6035217047,
0.397850275,
0.3032466471,
0.0273695551,
0.6516094208,
0.5394842029,
0.1817053109,
0.2941595018,
0.0160390567,
-0.4565995038,
-0.5253355503,
-0.096154511,
-0.0789391175,
0.6921215057,
0.6430525184,
-0.2821732759,
-0.2066773474,
-0.1458501667,
0.2193949819,
-0.3215768039,
-0.1994582266,
0.684245944,
0.10995882,
-0.433178544,
0.3544086814,
-0.3306484818,
0.3708007932,
0.0456154011,
-0.2557557225,
0.0844905749,
-0.2753414512,
-0.4213271737,
-0.3879281878,
0.0186022427,
0.1629421562,
-0.040780019,
0.0092433318,
0.6939479709,
-0.5459592342,
-0.0822937563,
0.2089677006,
0.5816461444,
0.1985013038,
-0.1517789513,
-0.579200387,
-0.1087066829,
0.0775157586,
-0.5976743102,
0.1617626697,
1.0193701982,
-0.0245818999,
0.3100916445,
0.5119518638,
-0.3398180008,
-0.2061344087,
0.002164891,
1.1377978325,
-0.7666442394,
-0.5231690407,
-0.6108518243,
0.8303125501,
-0.5995404124,
-0.3265390396,
0.5064566135,
0.3000170887,
0.2231057286,
0.4649133384,
0.9956271052,
-0.3403028846,
0.481227994,
-0.3775858879,
0.1499487013,
-0.5081994534,
0.0813850686,
-0.6466132402,
-0.6924469471,
0.0806591287,
0.1663589925,
-0.1318999827,
-0.1893376112,
0.9563833475,
0.5278229713,
0.2837252021,
0.3708412349,
0.4959159493,
0.4075974822,
0.3982235193,
0.9828723669,
0.8979139328,
-0.3812206686,
0.3537199795,
-0.0730898455,
-0.4071547091,
-0.4381902814,
-0.9094914198,
-0.9566397071,
-0.537086904,
-0.4897577167,
-0.3588944972,
-0.2179092169,
0.8775181174,
0.3841273487,
-0.2759115994,
0.5140979886,
-0.240463838,
0.2585740685,
0.2714669108,
-0.2473895103,
0.082292825,
-0.2552055418,
-0.853223443,
-0.0331817865,
0.4711994231,
-0.1639707536,
0.2855384648,
0.1395424306,
0.0805474445,
0.3234135807,
0.7129238844,
0.5408247709,
-0.4471121132,
-0.8293346763,
-0.3319942355,
0.0491536073,
0.272510618,
0.6627967358,
-0.5193740129,
0.4969318807,
0.5444555283,
0.3798488379,
0.563470006,
0.0692154616,
0.8586044312,
-0.5654373169,
0.0894432962,
0.2028738856,
0.5313847065,
0.0834484026,
-0.6014385223,
0.2866208553,
0.3100778162,
-0.7424413562,
-0.7127377987,
0.5515287519,
-1.1589554548,
0.0523332208,
1.2946500778,
-0.2942180037,
-0.1839468628,
-0.2671638727,
-0.5219168067,
0.5148450136,
-0.5309470296,
0.8208363056,
0.6344929338,
-0.4711322188,
-0.2839700878,
-0.3229469657,
0.2778231204,
0.5043483377,
-1.2002859116,
0.0846205056,
0.9542040229,
0.1559856236,
-0.0657974854,
0.5591890812,
-0.1328381747,
0.3836828172,
0.0432392582,
0.6238242388,
0.0779824853,
-0.0831387639,
-0.1491221935,
0.288559705,
-0.5287906528,
-0.176177159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03959v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03959v1 | Leveraging Explicit Procedural Instructions for Data-Efficient Action Prediction | 2023-06-06T18:42:08 | 2023-06-06T18:42:08 | Julia White, Arushi Raghuvanshi, Yada Pruksachatkun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Task-oriented dialogues often require agents to enact complex, multi-step
procedures in order to meet user requests. While large language models have
found success automating these dialogues in constrained environments, their
widespread deployment is limited by the substantial quantities of task-specific
data required for training. The following paper presents a data-efficient
solution to constructing dialogue systems, leveraging explicit instructions
derived from agent guidelines, such as company policies or customer service
manuals. Our proposed Knowledge-Augmented Dialogue System (KADS) combines a
large language model with a knowledge retrieval module that pulls documents
outlining relevant procedures from a predefined set of policies, given a
user-agent interaction. To train this system, we introduce a semi-supervised
pre-training scheme that employs dialogue-document matching and action-oriented
masked language modeling with partial parameter freezing. We evaluate the
effectiveness of our approach on prominent task-oriented dialogue datasets,
Action-Based Conversations Dataset and Schema-Guided Dialogue, for two dialogue
tasks: action state tracking and workflow discovery. Our results demonstrate
that procedural knowledge augmentation improves accuracy predicting in- and
out-of-distribution actions while preserving high performance in settings with
low or sparse data. | [
0.0957976505,
-0.7353650928,
0.7246764302,
-0.1294888705,
-0.0696476772,
0.0879027322,
-0.1532729119,
-0.0351038799,
0.0675602406,
1.044085145,
-0.7078801394,
-0.6655401587,
-0.2356467992,
-0.1882480085,
-0.2301731855,
0.7770120502,
-0.0466528088,
0.1671728641,
-0.20614627,
0.1522980928,
-0.3211258948,
-0.4806826711,
-0.410369128,
-0.4054909945,
0.1902226657,
0.3088092506,
0.6189510226,
0.6636908054,
0.0931349322,
0.4607367218,
0.1246265471,
0.6113823652,
-0.3802787364,
0.4000927806,
-0.1020618826,
-0.2561782598,
-0.1834343821,
-0.2016232759,
0.2835502625,
0.7352790833,
-0.5335658193,
-0.3708330989,
0.0441719331,
0.2418221831,
-0.3798834682,
0.8477586508,
-0.1971996278,
0.0999500901,
0.2292462438,
-0.3632300794,
-0.3812768757,
-0.2996247113,
0.5165054798,
-0.8895774484,
0.0384142175,
-0.0400725678,
0.5045199394,
0.1739330441,
-0.2140975147,
-0.6369225383,
-0.9102003574,
0.6094102263,
-0.6051031351,
0.1780288517,
0.6237779856,
0.264913559,
-0.4149316549,
-0.6523163915,
-0.5098547339,
-0.1682209373,
-0.3679928482,
0.0292511303,
-0.0444623977,
0.6787607074,
0.5395303965,
0.0600651577,
-0.1501475126,
-0.0940900445,
-0.2173950672,
-0.4281892478,
0.4899014235,
0.4802346528,
0.0517996624,
-0.025780445,
-0.183578372,
-0.1906139404,
-0.3087969124,
0.130619958,
0.3177854419,
0.4597175717,
-0.0154852485,
0.5894852281,
-0.5678611994,
0.8403883576,
0.1527799517,
-0.3522601426,
0.0056866324,
-0.4603762329,
-0.3480083644,
-0.031179022,
0.6529665589,
0.1073513329,
0.1643291116,
-0.247670427,
-0.3436300755,
-0.1059986353,
0.3311591744,
-0.7611908317,
-0.1814188063,
-0.0778705105,
0.0070638629,
-0.2555314302,
-0.1366093457,
-0.4273202121,
-0.7234951854,
-0.7294347882,
0.0642730445,
-0.4189743996,
0.1425350308,
0.0282200519,
0.0019786579,
0.173223421,
0.7545752525,
-0.69291085,
0.309867084,
0.7238787413,
0.55970788,
0.1912211776,
0.0077659455,
-0.873362124,
0.4672339261,
-0.5006324053,
0.6838376522,
-1.0926405191,
-0.3494382501,
0.4752369523,
0.1995618343,
-0.1507493407,
-0.3905065358,
0.5615557432,
-0.4050796926,
-0.0001528744,
-0.0155321974,
-0.5931559205,
-0.262853682,
0.2976605296,
-0.5224010944,
0.6244373322,
0.232030496,
-0.2372800857,
0.3699080646,
-0.9207512736,
-0.5752207041,
0.150699228,
-0.2930305302,
-0.1249998212,
-0.1925321668,
0.1318725199,
0.5697207451,
-0.3224630356,
0.2209059894,
-0.2362483144,
-0.1352685392,
0.0971331,
-0.3105745316,
0.3868043125,
0.1767718196,
-0.1563519388,
0.0385530889,
-0.3720027208,
-0.0206517093,
-0.3080603182,
-0.1972050965,
-0.1596894413,
-0.0351996906,
-0.5666484833,
0.1893592626,
0.0686057359,
-0.4452753067,
0.2500549853,
-0.3635521829,
0.1517009586,
0.7710992098,
0.13642326,
0.7767935991,
-0.0807282627,
0.6948629618,
0.0644559488,
0.1646302342,
-0.510722816,
-0.2851589918,
-0.5755701661,
-0.2746457756,
0.0309244916,
0.5906613469,
-1.1870055199,
0.3059009314,
-0.1766645759,
-0.3849938512,
-0.2596126795,
0.2547470033,
0.7098251581,
0.7243694067,
-0.0407257974,
-0.2126844823,
-0.300579071,
-0.6314756274,
-0.0672895834,
-0.3732619286,
-0.0128396535,
0.619851172,
0.1264825165,
-0.0392111689,
0.7785180211,
-0.7068948746,
-0.3230954409,
-0.1829702705,
0.4282171428,
0.0157092847,
0.3311353028,
-0.0626497567,
-0.5958827138,
-0.5149061084,
0.1979052871,
-0.8396459818,
0.0365827307,
-0.1486870199,
-0.1573333144,
0.3161752224,
0.440225631,
-0.8063658476,
0.7494750023,
0.1817211956,
-0.1739106327,
0.3136996627,
-0.4286682904,
0.1898672283,
-0.90662992,
-0.1140259802,
0.1201892123,
-0.3137970567,
-1.1635267735,
-0.4807447195,
-0.1058029234,
-0.457233876,
-0.298121959,
0.4757611454,
-0.4381274283,
-0.1865514964,
-0.1055758819,
-0.2581325173,
-0.1138804257,
1.1174430847,
0.7243897915,
0.6018388271,
0.6987097859,
-0.7799351811,
0.3575601876,
0.5656917095,
-0.480409205,
0.5319797993,
-0.3343714178,
0.2824479938,
0.0023915656,
0.3872614801,
-0.5544868708,
-0.3808273077,
0.2942144573,
-0.1260797232,
0.2269909531,
-0.6069856286,
-0.5844726562,
-0.0218183342,
0.1241613701,
0.0718190596,
0.4378288984,
-0.1972178966,
0.9594856501,
0.6074007154,
-0.4127210081,
-0.5256736279,
-0.2636864185,
-0.0795505419,
0.0134827532,
-0.4952123463,
-0.0494921766,
0.0901613161,
-0.0761357546,
-0.3800769746,
-0.1653580219,
-0.296230644,
-0.1526018232,
0.4205526412,
0.1566758007,
0.3389412463,
0.04258148,
0.1195398197,
0.0816146061,
0.0335895754,
-0.4235272408,
0.5321319103,
0.2041683942,
-0.4767716229,
-0.6843879223,
0.2517757416,
0.6887199879,
-0.1038152501,
0.3918408453,
0.2474587262,
-0.3108393848,
-0.1469303966,
-0.4248984754,
-0.3356123865,
-0.5414590836,
0.1673599333,
-0.1071746051,
-0.4189423323,
0.3397874534,
-0.2897982895,
0.391621083,
-0.266338706,
0.419958353,
-0.2456082851,
1.3420225382,
0.4225577414,
0.2256391644,
0.8176124096,
-0.3597569764,
0.3743728399,
-0.3896757066,
-0.5434954762,
-0.3333034515,
0.0655517802,
-0.3371572495,
-0.7534624338,
0.4028060138,
-0.3135378957,
-0.0656119511,
0.3804288208,
-0.1672533602,
0.2563869953,
0.4170444012,
0.0947233737,
0.1831194013,
0.1508036703,
-0.0132364593,
0.2741449773,
-0.6833071709,
-0.5379300117,
0.9878471494,
0.1264216155,
0.9280687571,
-0.2739970982,
0.5946518183,
0.6748666763,
-0.0969088227,
-0.8360710144,
0.7490092516,
0.0745070279,
-0.111569792,
-0.5926085711,
-0.370922178,
-0.9639088511,
-0.204604581,
-0.2046493739,
-0.5247068405,
0.3489379585,
0.2960608006,
-0.5213399529,
-0.0494186655,
-0.9611566663,
0.5161476135,
0.0212864149,
-0.2649902105,
-0.2050614804,
-0.530800283,
-0.0102170864,
0.0740839615,
0.0483888015,
0.0555193089,
0.1686291695,
0.6730670929,
-1.0192649364,
0.9699012637,
-0.7277984619,
-0.2173912376,
0.4282445014,
0.0178323425,
1.0603039265,
-0.1137278527,
0.0855291635,
-0.2474257946,
-0.1363084763,
-0.4425778687,
-1.0846771002,
0.3832706213,
-0.4096958339,
-0.5668052435,
-0.3673154116,
-0.7951651812,
-0.5240197182,
0.0987592563,
-0.3747220337,
0.8950983882,
-0.0951690599,
-0.0603364334,
0.8483182192,
0.06920176,
0.2973971367,
1.0313150883,
0.1656862199,
-0.096107766,
0.882458806,
0.0524525233,
0.322586596,
0.3371167481,
-0.0757038668,
-0.5529373884,
-0.5079941154,
-0.4549508989,
-0.0222405493,
-0.5699845552,
-0.3173650205,
-0.770260334,
-0.1154763252,
-0.4643637836,
-0.0314712636,
-0.1044864208,
-0.2620746791,
-0.17750673,
-0.1176696569,
0.3843288422,
0.7192752957,
0.1519898623,
0.3016121387,
-0.6321522593,
0.3182777464,
0.4752447903,
0.2386141121,
-0.3398959935,
-0.4576074481,
-0.4185528755,
0.4377706647,
-0.1141363159,
-0.6190963984,
0.401050508,
0.1898252368,
0.5466646552,
0.5702457428,
0.3601571023,
0.7528335452,
-0.333153069,
0.4207102954,
0.0777921975,
-0.5115045905,
0.6298622489,
-0.3752369583,
0.2276168317,
0.5110908747,
0.177151382,
-0.3611431718,
-0.5051380396,
-0.5793453455,
-0.3666813076,
1.3191021681,
0.3710431159,
0.2230369449,
0.1038624868,
0.1974231899,
0.0425107032,
0.3509347737,
0.1711543053,
0.0141561292,
0.0039758384,
-0.2562844157,
0.0571131147,
0.181247443,
-0.4078927338,
0.0131516252,
0.6416471004,
-0.4871013761,
0.4011389017,
0.071362026,
-0.298348546,
0.1487886906,
0.1169506833,
0.5029174089,
0.4066177905,
0.012928661,
-0.3680728078,
0.043835707,
-0.5427084565,
0.0611255243,
0.2905132174,
-0.0712652355,
0.0262786504,
0.1380334795,
0.9874525666,
0.242386654,
-0.9760228992,
0.4882433712,
-0.1365722567,
-0.1676107347,
-0.4313201308,
0.2665688396,
-0.2008450478,
0.3742981255,
0.0655880719,
0.0785589069,
0.277004987,
-0.9159163833,
0.1081451252,
0.3879275024,
-0.5715751648,
-0.2041488588,
-0.1609047949,
0.4610075653,
-0.4842009246,
0.5912179351,
-0.3569043577,
-0.3362471759,
0.4373126924,
0.2435890138,
0.6832353473,
-0.1969013959,
0.6489218473,
0.0494223535,
-0.2273226976,
-0.1488051862,
0.3908569515,
-0.5814419985,
-0.5300986171,
-0.3746882975,
-0.4904595315,
-0.624320209,
-0.0075267139,
-0.5817373395,
0.3608140647,
-0.544878006,
0.0289030764,
-0.0003188557,
0.061162699,
-0.7836430073,
0.0992090777,
-0.0337815545,
0.7032275796,
-0.78973943,
0.9160127044,
0.5211359262,
-0.1557211578,
-0.7993201017,
-0.1144996434,
-0.0688019395,
-0.8897898793,
0.2625527084,
-0.1154058725,
-0.2273740321,
-0.2055967599,
-0.4193219244,
-0.488466531,
1.1479891539,
0.5624716282,
-0.4581082165,
-0.2578752041,
0.2731597126,
0.6845396757,
-0.5844287872,
0.4363750517,
0.8001472354,
0.3261548281,
0.4738460183,
-0.7713281512,
-0.0523874871,
-0.2689276338,
-0.1884943992,
0.2542508543,
-0.3021827638,
0.1441144347,
-0.0831850618,
-0.3128450513,
0.1034034714,
0.6648072004,
0.1261793375,
0.4602312148,
0.7068772316,
0.3170444071,
0.9371390939,
-0.073692441,
1.0657507181,
-0.3565614223,
-0.1063027009,
1.0148750544,
-0.4002924562,
0.3583189249,
0.1240170747,
0.1710473597,
0.688644588,
0.4910762012,
0.2768388391,
0.7377716899,
-0.0916289166,
-0.4071286917,
-0.4571373165,
-0.6359543204,
0.2395357043,
0.5268948674,
0.5627648234,
-0.4364648163,
-0.0244916752,
0.0471201688,
0.0553081632,
0.0551960059,
-0.4078989923,
1.4646779299,
-0.2834666073,
-1.185400486,
0.4640124142,
-0.3734664321,
-0.0362120941,
-0.7458789349,
-0.5008682013,
-0.2112895846,
-0.0429867208,
-0.0969311073,
-0.8647475839,
-0.0514728539,
0.2248345017,
-0.0725293234,
-0.5516743064,
0.7231293321,
-0.8309620619,
-0.3922565877,
-0.1024824157,
0.2882401347,
0.3373817503,
0.0235992484,
-0.6435315013,
-0.3600668013,
0.0583453588,
-0.0413944721,
0.3421503007,
0.532427907,
-0.2896338105,
0.799723208,
0.6879615784,
-0.0696972683,
-0.1705128253,
0.1683456153,
1.1347507238,
-0.4134671688,
-0.7074950337,
-0.1974469572,
0.4280561805,
-0.4415217042,
0.2457480431,
0.2897435725,
0.4743793309,
0.5057016015,
0.1521113515,
0.9982585907,
-0.0111713838,
0.5212765336,
-0.6915213466,
0.3071067333,
-0.010887553,
0.3623249233,
-0.1375961304,
-0.6539082527,
0.3001896739,
0.2866647542,
-0.4854327738,
0.1305336952,
0.4334995151,
1.1913506985,
-0.087751016,
0.1984041184,
0.2811619937,
0.0599214286,
0.2589889169,
0.1760772914,
0.6850776672,
0.0722622573,
0.7394163013,
-0.4588909745,
-0.193903029,
-0.1887634695,
-0.4749024212,
-0.9348538518,
-0.683275044,
-0.3241725564,
-0.2368109375,
0.2405072898,
0.8808977008,
0.940381825,
-0.6194544435,
-0.2278830111,
-0.3427896798,
0.0698413178,
-0.2886467576,
-0.1699800491,
0.2093909234,
-0.5905709863,
-0.8600133657,
0.5744236112,
0.2766083181,
0.0506138913,
-0.1519147009,
-0.6156968474,
-0.0320176519,
0.3982063532,
0.4229800105,
0.4265645444,
-0.650372982,
0.0149272196,
0.0548712574,
0.0594673008,
-0.1820333004,
1.2496957779,
-0.7082899213,
0.869918704,
0.4116457701,
0.4465880394,
0.6348446608,
0.2931453586,
1.1766221523,
-0.7361927629,
-0.0108590322,
0.4535191655,
0.1576302648,
0.2556625009,
-0.445874095,
0.4295048118,
-0.0814756528,
-0.2786504924,
-0.7763700485,
0.2907695472,
-0.762573421,
0.0949587971,
1.1408635378,
-0.637790978,
-0.210679993,
-0.5913929343,
-0.3335041404,
0.2088748515,
-0.9046798944,
0.6018859744,
0.3718345165,
-0.2362215519,
-0.1286974698,
-0.3832460046,
0.9686062932,
0.2339188457,
-0.9665116072,
0.5683957934,
0.6403627396,
-0.216670841,
0.1415876448,
0.5776913166,
0.1229531989,
0.3894633353,
-0.2000418752,
-0.2210735083,
-0.1851361841,
-0.4622662067,
-0.1721973121,
-0.0907017142,
-0.2138227522,
-0.0968072861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03954v1 | Recognition of Handwritten Japanese Characters Using Ensemble of Convolutional Neural Networks | 2023-06-06T18:30:51 | 2023-06-06T18:30:51 | Angel I. Solis, Justin Zarkovacki, John Ly, Adham Atyabi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The Japanese writing system is complex, with three character types of
Hiragana, Katakana, and Kanji. Kanji consists of thousands of unique
characters, further adding to the complexity of character identification and
literature understanding. Being able to translate handwritten Japanese
characters into digital text is useful for data analysis, translation, learning
and cultural preservation. In this study, a machine learning approach to
analyzing and recognizing handwritten Japanese characters (Kanji) is proposed.
The study used an ensemble of three convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for
recognizing handwritten Kanji characters and utilized four datasets of MNIST,
K-MNIST, Kuzushiji-49 (K49) and the top 150 represented classes in the
Kuzushiji-Kanji (K-Kanji) dataset for its performance evaluation. The results
indicate feasibility of using proposed CNN-ensemble architecture for
recognizing handwritten characters, achieving 99.4%, 96.4%, 95.0% and 96.4%
classification accuracy on MNIST, K-MNIS, K49, and K-Kanji datasets
respectively. | [
-0.2833219469,
-0.3803322017,
0.4144437313,
-0.1252536774,
-0.4989540875,
0.4731618166,
-0.4048957527,
-0.7687956095,
-0.0461978279,
0.6683966517,
-0.5382303596,
-0.6041952372,
-0.7286999226,
0.5015276074,
-0.1456543803,
0.8720855713,
-0.1836991161,
0.3473563194,
-0.0350423157,
-0.1992175728,
-0.6186948419,
-0.42966187,
-0.7484750152,
-0.1953065991,
0.3058119714,
0.5558826923,
0.42816028,
0.3123903871,
0.8967754245,
0.4455822706,
0.3334591091,
0.453040272,
-0.1889124811,
0.1792421043,
0.5943072438,
-0.4960769415,
-0.0686956644,
-0.1829155684,
0.6817851663,
0.1423221678,
0.2544545233,
-0.2412540913,
0.0200984683,
0.5511749387,
-0.5860355496,
0.125614062,
-0.3858132064,
0.5414701104,
-0.3241585195,
-0.155426532,
-0.5436636209,
-0.4547121823,
0.1218598187,
-0.8475704193,
0.3743192255,
0.0112813851,
0.5003033876,
-0.0289664771,
-0.0195823852,
-0.588817656,
-0.6086025834,
0.6238098741,
-0.5944195986,
-0.0292170793,
0.3883609176,
0.6852471828,
-0.1829185784,
-0.4110091627,
-0.8668547273,
-0.1307957172,
-0.353007257,
0.3775697649,
0.2503694296,
-0.0692788363,
0.4293148518,
0.4199086726,
-0.7796505094,
0.5556257367,
-0.2792321444,
-0.3597721457,
0.8875082731,
0.3126760721,
0.7464991212,
0.1878546178,
-0.3100498021,
-0.3710598648,
-0.1291891485,
0.0225455035,
0.2910054028,
0.1071372926,
-0.0539972223,
0.1221067384,
-0.0812807605,
0.5717483163,
-0.0039277794,
-0.3549285233,
0.3570033014,
-0.178314358,
-0.2909932733,
0.4352002442,
1.2649906874,
0.2977387011,
0.515098989,
-0.1505623609,
-0.235714823,
-0.1755610108,
0.1800971776,
-0.835599184,
-0.152652204,
-0.2770757377,
-0.856918335,
-0.4932658672,
-0.1060905382,
-0.7800975442,
-0.8076319098,
-0.1862652153,
0.3501765132,
-0.5143255591,
-0.1400190145,
-0.2400945425,
-0.4500723779,
0.113865599,
0.5128725767,
-1.0378518105,
0.1478986442,
0.3182269931,
0.788389504,
-0.0982504264,
-0.1815789789,
-0.0134061305,
-0.1429924667,
-0.3054207861,
0.4287647903,
-0.3775110245,
-0.7039827704,
-0.2370366603,
-0.002340103,
-0.0708734766,
-0.4358984828,
0.8325127959,
-0.4051068723,
-0.0743384659,
0.0152570764,
-0.5659553409,
-0.1099470183,
0.2979003191,
-0.9553197026,
0.4692419469,
-0.1159833819,
-0.4999837577,
0.3176535368,
-0.2144472897,
-0.6308107376,
0.5687149763,
-0.0473603755,
-1.1508930922,
-0.0230112839,
0.3309667408,
0.9096064568,
-0.0593595505,
0.094930388,
-0.6965906024,
-0.829144299,
0.5698131323,
-0.8421169519,
0.8883280754,
0.4673132002,
-0.09478499,
-0.412327379,
-1.1116191149,
0.0613283478,
0.1070941165,
-0.3491571248,
-0.5239625573,
-0.3500077724,
0.2938153744,
-0.0220824126,
0.2188925147,
-0.5912870765,
0.4024938941,
0.046587076,
0.2109287977,
0.3684536815,
0.1768098325,
0.3428869247,
-0.1197170392,
0.2674800158,
0.0986520201,
-0.0443471819,
-0.2475790381,
-0.450725466,
-0.7691338062,
-0.3068760335,
0.1940538883,
0.5101947784,
-0.9890329838,
0.6676474214,
-0.1154117435,
-0.7154756784,
-0.4101691842,
-0.2969796956,
0.5185894966,
0.4392808974,
0.2685756087,
-0.2163360119,
-0.7733020782,
-0.7367101908,
-0.0789363682,
0.2217561305,
-0.0143594574,
0.1259424835,
0.382887274,
0.0717419162,
0.31048581,
-0.1919570267,
-0.3607022762,
0.0800629705,
0.2528780103,
0.145302549,
0.77021873,
0.1719536334,
-0.8303790092,
-0.7867769599,
0.4068509936,
-0.9529390335,
0.3854685724,
-0.2865324616,
-0.0210215338,
0.1776126921,
0.4536551535,
-0.293764323,
0.3363744915,
0.093984738,
-0.061228659,
0.3261126578,
-0.4427901804,
0.3526686728,
-1.2415649891,
0.1764784455,
0.0565575697,
-0.0783361271,
-0.7264740467,
-0.0389437303,
0.3532451689,
-0.5729984045,
0.0282313284,
0.1771191061,
-0.5718001723,
-0.266441077,
-0.1539781839,
-0.2787730694,
-0.0403181091,
0.8914712071,
0.3510400355,
0.4290628731,
0.1048552915,
-0.1798767149,
0.3132979572,
-0.0619014278,
-0.8435105681,
0.6190751195,
-0.1664323658,
0.4795253277,
-0.0566090345,
0.2812381685,
-0.9865338206,
-0.1335327476,
0.5731419921,
-0.4630859196,
0.667226553,
0.0220140237,
-0.3508024812,
-0.3859040439,
0.0221470986,
0.3250478506,
0.4009974301,
-0.4056776166,
0.5812618732,
0.2268832326,
0.175504908,
-0.5314932466,
-0.5795437098,
-0.0007288208,
-0.1887499392,
-0.2463457882,
0.3500936627,
0.1469184905,
0.3009961247,
-0.1699764132,
0.2893457115,
-0.0700272545,
0.5352208018,
0.1547187865,
0.4770838916,
-0.2019996643,
-0.0570288152,
0.1853619218,
-0.1795482486,
-0.2046183497,
-0.0891735405,
0.3935689628,
-0.1358561069,
-0.0050022518,
-0.6970607638,
0.1562520564,
0.9260981679,
-0.3344280422,
0.2029238641,
0.848628521,
-0.5552558303,
-0.1051175222,
-0.2831988633,
0.2949039936,
-0.3802365065,
0.2986083031,
-0.5285128355,
-0.5793597698,
0.5593443513,
0.0687572509,
-0.3711423278,
0.5831560493,
0.3912496567,
-0.3937945664,
0.9019711018,
-0.0094922893,
-0.4059059322,
0.4476516843,
-0.3407458365,
0.0651041195,
-0.7294311523,
-0.3896258175,
-0.6447253227,
-0.8000442982,
-0.8196792603,
0.0601094663,
0.2908499837,
0.0369769745,
0.0673099831,
0.4102722108,
-0.8374949694,
0.7617650032,
0.6101793051,
0.4556022286,
0.1463289559,
-0.0401411168,
-0.0765553638,
0.3227882981,
-0.1592272073,
-0.4348705709,
1.1657575369,
0.2418922782,
0.3643001616,
-0.1303931326,
0.8943760991,
0.4685902596,
0.2059213519,
-0.7876215577,
0.6762934327,
-0.5841760039,
-0.323723644,
-0.6531260014,
-0.2281731069,
-0.8132243752,
0.1760500222,
-0.6507710218,
-0.6943796277,
0.4946496785,
-0.2127992213,
-0.4426242113,
0.14087753,
-0.7602828145,
0.7653568983,
-0.3783703148,
0.1794462651,
-0.2034897804,
-0.6995774508,
0.3020729423,
0.0066148071,
-0.1237207949,
0.0522828661,
0.4673364758,
0.7086939812,
-0.325496763,
0.7119258046,
-0.3031260073,
0.2731074095,
0.334256202,
-0.1918172985,
0.5224841237,
-0.2461601794,
-0.2369073629,
0.4977763891,
-0.0801737532,
0.0686307475,
-0.8279694319,
0.449860096,
-1.0267939568,
0.0981760398,
-0.4205362797,
-0.4086604714,
0.0646082982,
0.5240311027,
0.6911566257,
0.6103633046,
-0.3434853554,
0.1803753376,
0.4269053936,
0.2151571661,
0.8753041029,
0.2397704124,
0.0549787097,
-0.7817352414,
1.1270159483,
0.4918316007,
-0.177121833,
0.5213040709,
0.3077858388,
-0.0043273089,
-0.7885998487,
-1.0593659878,
-0.4710302949,
-0.5363097787,
-0.2562859356,
-0.3382128775,
-0.2819351256,
0.0486109816,
-0.1673457026,
0.3830505908,
-0.3250032961,
-0.6609102488,
0.3495025635,
-0.07054317,
0.4410923421,
0.5777710676,
0.2893962562,
-1.0679504871,
0.0782959163,
0.0401911847,
0.2490237355,
0.3773222566,
0.0918289423,
-0.5050317049,
-0.0361179113,
-0.3151903152,
-0.7084854245,
0.3501074612,
0.0848917738,
0.4886929095,
0.5348198414,
-0.1165870205,
0.3885916173,
-0.3276208639,
0.2099406272,
0.3089891374,
-0.7618418336,
0.1445413232,
-0.3525003791,
0.1759946346,
0.7856248021,
0.4655096829,
-0.7110626101,
-0.2230615914,
-0.5180285573,
0.0123613011,
0.9245997071,
0.235322386,
-0.216822505,
0.3499935865,
0.4186145067,
0.2846599221,
0.1298991144,
-0.462215513,
0.0922372714,
-0.1909316033,
-0.9520786405,
-0.1730821878,
0.0723146051,
0.4620859921,
0.0219043549,
0.4763809741,
-0.0688755959,
0.2777974904,
0.0988635868,
-0.2786218226,
0.0419676676,
-0.0498331934,
0.8593193889,
-0.2700836062,
-0.1622286439,
-0.0153054465,
0.1952573806,
-0.8960677981,
0.4862414002,
0.0797444731,
-0.5379475355,
-0.1612624824,
0.6499625444,
1.197406888,
-0.1494670957,
-0.2536448538,
0.2568425238,
-0.2450366467,
-0.0882655159,
-0.3572933972,
0.4436837137,
-0.2718827128,
0.1926035285,
0.248752296,
0.4995974004,
0.5051596761,
-0.4390514791,
-0.1247889549,
0.4236370325,
-0.2889346182,
0.064600572,
-0.1407409906,
0.3774270117,
-0.8242647648,
1.0308829546,
-0.0592962876,
-0.5776786208,
1.1349174976,
0.7283645272,
1.1061315536,
-0.3536091745,
-0.0526362509,
0.5526579618,
0.0830258504,
-0.034146674,
-0.1066671163,
-0.5232644081,
-0.9589551687,
0.3576637506,
-0.574444294,
-0.5532854199,
0.1544888169,
-0.5501605272,
0.4862191975,
-0.7323271036,
-0.0329480097,
0.1147395447,
0.2229614705,
-0.5342876911,
0.5929048657,
0.5447586775,
0.2085260898,
-0.7745918632,
0.6564204097,
0.2678881884,
-0.3348505795,
-0.7134869099,
-0.0805199593,
-0.2000079453,
-0.9526233077,
0.4557067156,
0.808634758,
0.005311247,
0.105763413,
-0.2663365304,
-0.7417469025,
1.1051688194,
-0.2312064022,
-1.0990797281,
0.1103773341,
0.369857043,
0.8335450888,
-0.273730427,
0.4758901596,
0.366261363,
0.3947069049,
-0.0646909997,
-0.4888547361,
0.0650307089,
-0.6182819605,
0.2391276956,
0.3161670566,
-0.6619389653,
0.4606828094,
0.1674027592,
-0.3137139976,
0.2748422921,
0.5522828102,
0.1000254527,
0.6220855117,
0.3495141566,
0.670168221,
0.9772207141,
-0.1929835975,
0.7407691479,
0.2017509043,
0.1456171274,
0.7866621017,
-0.17766352,
0.6480249166,
0.0443940349,
-0.203332305,
0.6292160749,
0.6245390177,
-0.6411014199,
0.6221482158,
0.461804688,
-0.4942533672,
-0.272218138,
0.4034569561,
-0.0027906583,
0.6477423906,
0.4337182045,
-0.5803925395,
0.0335328057,
0.6210903525,
-0.1030399501,
-0.1128180102,
-0.4593780637,
1.0596637726,
0.0460233539,
-1.0628181696,
0.4810918272,
0.0871489868,
0.5275403261,
-0.3600054681,
-0.2811320126,
0.0877931044,
0.3820567131,
-0.2145803273,
-0.9263576865,
0.0336174816,
-0.2207995802,
-0.1821211725,
0.0602241755,
1.281419158,
-0.4039534926,
-0.8974843621,
-0.2597081363,
-0.5034421682,
0.1443658024,
0.3202817738,
-0.4964268208,
0.1211166307,
-0.2132443786,
0.0762125999,
0.4031464159,
0.3539901674,
-0.2098798454,
0.2725504637,
0.6886262298,
-0.4070521295,
-0.2958651781,
0.1288915128,
0.2920961976,
-0.1989658475,
-0.5306042433,
-1.0972019434,
0.4476592839,
-0.3150861859,
-0.5053024292,
0.6546897292,
0.4643020332,
0.793407619,
-0.3278367221,
0.9718717933,
0.3290248513,
0.2410231978,
-0.8320122957,
1.2676230669,
-0.2634874284,
-0.1770358533,
-0.6036576629,
-0.4480955005,
-0.5957726836,
0.7818776965,
-0.1868476868,
0.1207088605,
0.2847757936,
0.5862628222,
0.0355523154,
0.517110467,
0.3233173788,
-0.3694574535,
0.1846014708,
0.8408393264,
0.8822622299,
-0.6818217635,
0.2826464474,
-0.4032372236,
-0.1243619397,
-0.4741918743,
-0.6950618029,
-0.9580181837,
-0.7263404131,
-0.1488974392,
-0.2265602648,
-0.1342449188,
0.5964667797,
0.2910811901,
-0.6377128363,
-0.1533109993,
-0.3377878964,
0.0590257049,
-0.1803559363,
-0.1031757966,
0.5218320489,
-0.1340393573,
-0.8006380796,
0.2462145835,
0.2683503926,
0.3406896889,
-0.1347796023,
-0.1226070598,
0.0765551701,
-0.4687640667,
0.2189098746,
0.2649556398,
-0.3125691116,
-0.0446987078,
-0.0939014107,
-0.4010259509,
-0.0168907233,
0.7435560822,
-0.4476766586,
0.7865723968,
0.7270936966,
0.795193851,
0.6499249935,
-0.3500573039,
0.3124888539,
-0.4081656635,
-0.1762775183,
0.3190078139,
0.6588680744,
0.2885231376,
-0.7564443946,
0.1833701432,
0.3485180736,
-0.6452763677,
-0.469286859,
-0.170922786,
-1.1041296721,
-0.170603767,
0.4445021451,
-0.3681930006,
-0.3184891939,
-0.0994536579,
-0.3923915029,
0.6841256022,
-0.0742930993,
0.4761712849,
0.8409654498,
0.1819737554,
-0.3066291511,
0.2974996269,
0.4764342606,
0.0952444449,
-0.9226859212,
-0.180091083,
0.4707578421,
0.0818965882,
0.4333024919,
0.7886317372,
-0.0542648137,
0.4781092703,
0.0261195749,
0.2688123882,
-0.3679227829,
-0.2656317949,
-0.4267274439,
0.1272087842,
-0.3332143128,
-0.6199908257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03950v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03950v2 | MISGENDERED: Limits of Large Language Models in Understanding Pronouns | 2023-06-06T18:27:52 | 2023-07-07T05:18:34 | Tamanna Hossain, Sunipa Dev, Sameer Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Content Warning: This paper contains examples of misgendering and erasure
that could be offensive and potentially triggering.
Gender bias in language technologies has been widely studied, but research
has mostly been restricted to a binary paradigm of gender. It is essential also
to consider non-binary gender identities, as excluding them can cause further
harm to an already marginalized group. In this paper, we comprehensively
evaluate popular language models for their ability to correctly use English
gender-neutral pronouns (e.g., singular they, them) and neo-pronouns (e.g., ze,
xe, thon) that are used by individuals whose gender identity is not represented
by binary pronouns. We introduce MISGENDERED, a framework for evaluating large
language models' ability to correctly use preferred pronouns, consisting of (i)
instances declaring an individual's pronoun, followed by a sentence with a
missing pronoun, and (ii) an experimental setup for evaluating masked and
auto-regressive language models using a unified method. When prompted
out-of-the-box, language models perform poorly at correctly predicting
neo-pronouns (averaging 7.7% accuracy) and gender-neutral pronouns (averaging
34.2% accuracy). This inability to generalize results from a lack of
representation of non-binary pronouns in training data and memorized
associations. Few-shot adaptation with explicit examples in the prompt improves
performance for neo-pronouns, but only to 64.7% even with 20 shots. We release
the full dataset, code, and demo at
https://tamannahossainkay.github.io/misgendered/ | [
-0.2355222702,
-0.6489341259,
0.3848533332,
0.2250095755,
0.1095225662,
-0.1122327447,
-0.1351087391,
-0.4607060254,
-0.1355229765,
0.378579706,
-0.537546277,
-0.220412001,
-0.5808359981,
0.5138679743,
-0.2450615764,
0.6198329329,
0.2751350701,
0.0609260425,
-0.0785004497,
-0.0777455121,
-0.8957531452,
-0.297313422,
-0.0851158351,
-0.0566196218,
0.2944477201,
0.52652812,
0.8958415985,
0.6731294394,
0.200976789,
0.322563678,
-0.0223949887,
-0.1068421304,
-0.5286575556,
0.1516062468,
-0.3110931814,
-0.2414427102,
-0.3051075041,
0.1618365645,
0.7033811212,
0.9311523438,
0.2191765159,
0.1268595904,
-0.0068152421,
0.3192029297,
-0.9040805101,
-0.0459895656,
-0.6233283281,
0.1608939022,
0.0496937074,
0.211115256,
-0.4235688448,
-0.3229667544,
0.1447604299,
-0.5953670144,
0.2827166617,
0.0990090892,
0.6673886776,
-0.0745825469,
-0.3564652205,
-0.0796160102,
-1.0727416277,
0.8519922495,
-0.6009782553,
0.6464042068,
0.5067660809,
0.2499967068,
-0.0858721137,
-0.1524051577,
-0.4466712773,
-0.307720989,
0.1306519806,
0.0901396349,
-0.6826127172,
-0.0065800175,
0.4218183756,
0.0313841328,
-0.7733256221,
0.2954286933,
-0.3619444966,
-0.0176073406,
0.5171833634,
0.0100281881,
0.2270119041,
-0.3942556977,
-0.2392202467,
0.1688850373,
-0.584664464,
-0.397464633,
0.8189606667,
0.6822627187,
0.2061122954,
0.7091274858,
0.2149804533,
0.6248530149,
0.2795285285,
-0.0357401744,
0.4364572167,
-0.2707951367,
-0.2916170657,
-0.2242403626,
0.8132298589,
0.3310976326,
0.4718013406,
-0.213299036,
0.0647087321,
-0.2709103525,
0.171004951,
-0.5851143003,
0.1685880721,
0.0129669504,
-0.3394110203,
0.1051426604,
-0.0626497045,
-0.644429028,
-0.4025308192,
-0.0163745396,
0.5358039141,
-0.3855523467,
-0.5172851682,
0.3403294086,
-0.3907581866,
-0.0204367414,
0.2110091448,
-0.9079272747,
0.2913797498,
0.5731343627,
0.550083518,
0.2384372056,
-0.4363894761,
-0.3304101229,
-0.1052089706,
-0.4159464538,
0.3926600218,
-0.615673542,
-0.5424001813,
-0.0604719184,
0.1731690913,
-0.4497350454,
-0.6733936667,
0.227178365,
-0.134488374,
0.6500592232,
-0.039914947,
-0.6661804318,
-0.1150851697,
-0.0537143424,
-0.6075909138,
0.7179103494,
0.1065678969,
-0.6641684771,
0.2688414156,
-0.3243276775,
-0.0011695152,
0.093794331,
-0.0195380189,
-0.1934356838,
0.2517536283,
-0.2101730555,
0.4216898382,
-0.3022642732,
0.5369542241,
-0.2635782659,
-0.3947318494,
0.0375087783,
-0.4159585536,
0.8287833929,
-0.1614578813,
-0.2621461153,
0.0114054279,
-0.6089651585,
-0.3219689727,
0.2615272403,
0.2848064899,
-0.4581635594,
-0.2120880783,
0.0754700601,
0.3349357545,
-0.0117761455,
-0.5625660419,
-0.0512423478,
-0.3733683527,
0.2409583479,
0.7173876762,
-0.2615165114,
0.7145514488,
-0.2471544743,
0.7160490751,
-0.1860372871,
0.3208361268,
0.084713921,
-0.3950802982,
-0.4709630907,
-0.2322529554,
0.4406129718,
0.6344406009,
-0.564422071,
0.695766151,
-0.1956837922,
-0.4446653426,
-0.5189933777,
0.2239654958,
0.4143660367,
0.5104091763,
0.3458705544,
-0.0709976181,
-0.7450389266,
-1.3820525408,
-0.5435947776,
-0.6063301563,
-0.0755990967,
0.3035473228,
0.6747488976,
-0.3923927844,
0.9230211377,
-0.1758979112,
0.0914506093,
-0.377396673,
0.252869904,
-0.0153943263,
0.400847435,
0.3926696479,
-0.6295519471,
-0.155878067,
-0.274056673,
-0.5668714046,
-0.2021534741,
-0.1792544574,
0.0907030255,
-0.0321840085,
0.4189696312,
-0.4985782504,
0.2758373618,
0.6096754074,
-0.5254035592,
0.8069432378,
-0.0586731136,
-0.147871539,
-0.9181058407,
0.3609673977,
0.3203478456,
-0.5325580239,
-0.8079525232,
-0.131627813,
0.1354491711,
-0.0902793333,
-0.666077435,
0.6299649477,
-0.528568089,
-0.0889745057,
-0.393892318,
0.007208731,
-0.0035689618,
0.0520039573,
0.1354657561,
0.6796188354,
0.3893744349,
-0.5542981625,
-0.0324616171,
0.0993991643,
-0.0355188549,
0.4050785303,
-0.6960032582,
0.0852415189,
-0.4748777449,
-0.0162259117,
-0.7234560251,
-0.1208963692,
0.4477471709,
-0.3601801097,
0.277012378,
-0.1754851788,
-0.4558643699,
-0.3094193637,
-0.2824180424,
0.3118824363,
0.3796396255,
-0.0887312815,
0.6453264952,
0.3120813966,
-0.1327658892,
-0.8150760531,
-0.4998993874,
0.280374378,
-0.1906784773,
-0.3504537046,
0.0780078098,
-0.2640967965,
-0.437494874,
0.0781769156,
0.0022115291,
-0.2168910354,
0.2222596705,
0.2815313637,
0.2301381677,
-0.1073153019,
0.4561851323,
-0.1512451023,
-0.2885479629,
-0.1644324511,
0.0820900649,
0.4765789509,
-0.1043399647,
-0.144382149,
-0.3208639622,
0.582301259,
0.5094194412,
0.2477723956,
0.8489131331,
0.5034514666,
-0.5442487001,
-0.0023722474,
-0.5256316662,
-0.2130605131,
-0.3690521717,
0.5819151998,
-0.3499836326,
-1.0963820219,
0.4823900759,
0.2334219664,
0.1389116049,
0.6258022785,
0.192435652,
-0.0047729118,
0.999492228,
0.8220114708,
0.0955301523,
0.3446458578,
0.0964077562,
0.1697090566,
-0.6920388341,
0.0735460892,
-0.6768862009,
-0.078569971,
-0.9830449224,
-0.358600378,
-0.1204095483,
-0.0318189636,
-0.3601818681,
0.5400930047,
-0.0916978866,
0.7007777095,
0.5006362796,
-0.2396887392,
0.2144042552,
-0.2646698654,
0.163701579,
-0.2982770503,
-0.7273430228,
-0.6169097424,
0.8563796878,
0.5531173348,
0.5314719677,
0.0755494013,
0.4389983714,
0.2579420805,
-0.0970390663,
-0.7920101285,
0.5716178417,
-0.4074198902,
-1.0800611973,
-0.1469577104,
-0.6031160355,
-1.0510669947,
0.4324380159,
-0.2629989386,
-0.7560081482,
0.6224238276,
-0.0106193721,
-0.3622019291,
0.2644197345,
-0.7257095575,
0.9384174347,
-0.0314208418,
-0.3651095331,
0.2499279678,
-0.7491784096,
0.4378394485,
-0.2839512229,
0.3066876233,
-0.276851058,
-0.07621447,
0.5813445449,
-0.2242498398,
1.0476410389,
-0.1846194118,
0.0040402394,
0.0011866101,
0.342011869,
0.0872568637,
-0.2865570486,
-0.1767439991,
0.409794867,
-0.2807147503,
-0.2902579308,
-0.3766359687,
0.4993532598,
-0.7991026044,
-0.6767933965,
-0.450489074,
-0.4553290904,
-0.1854696721,
0.2179973125,
0.2684020996,
0.0821036622,
-0.5802989006,
0.140953064,
0.4623733759,
-0.4012776911,
0.2867563069,
0.4753720164,
-0.3044449985,
-0.1658199131,
0.7130404711,
0.2652131915,
0.3768895864,
0.1335968524,
0.3579499722,
-0.2367611527,
-0.1497969329,
-0.3449539542,
0.4866555333,
-0.5423120856,
-0.0000509074,
-0.790261507,
-0.0816015378,
-0.5563131571,
0.0392023064,
-0.5178764462,
-0.5154546499,
-0.5131231546,
-0.1949682534,
-0.1090070829,
0.6314097047,
-0.2749670446,
0.3077122271,
-0.6547966003,
0.3863388002,
0.4604824483,
0.0185807068,
-0.3151759207,
-0.7010492086,
0.0721162707,
-0.0802592263,
0.0732705817,
-1.1383525133,
0.3869073689,
0.2065426707,
0.5719572306,
0.1749923229,
-0.2287824601,
0.6555538774,
-0.6483194828,
0.6762967706,
0.2271845341,
-1.198876977,
0.4845344126,
-0.3307114244,
0.405497998,
0.6419285536,
0.5048624873,
-0.7583523393,
-0.4669025242,
-0.7514246106,
-0.8649001718,
0.6561374068,
0.2902542055,
0.3699610531,
-0.2388707846,
0.3004797697,
0.6412016153,
0.2476242483,
-0.8899182677,
-0.377412945,
-0.0137256123,
-0.1045412496,
-0.2549764216,
-0.4009593427,
0.2887410223,
-0.1257584393,
0.8089279532,
0.0102870092,
0.4252715111,
-0.0114347311,
-0.4048682749,
-0.1629725546,
0.3818072379,
0.4633889496,
0.5625991821,
-0.3071066141,
0.1421146989,
-0.0140362205,
-0.3501857817,
0.2970237136,
0.0999136865,
-0.4871369302,
0.3738240302,
0.3793705702,
0.7777013183,
0.1246804297,
-0.5603860617,
0.585778594,
-0.2070944905,
-0.2607172728,
-0.1748543382,
-0.0717372373,
-0.0339219384,
0.1642016768,
0.2382065058,
0.3339001238,
0.1857724339,
-0.5948109031,
-0.0719286352,
0.3629458249,
-0.4417953789,
-0.5734240413,
0.3549499512,
0.0163156614,
-0.2915473282,
0.3189062476,
-0.2640883625,
-0.344355613,
0.4727217257,
0.7536730766,
1.1679464579,
-0.5242154598,
0.4947651029,
0.5395645499,
0.6898466945,
-0.1969809383,
0.15493384,
0.4232095778,
-1.0553646088,
-0.274420023,
-0.0997965559,
-0.2175848633,
0.2176173776,
-0.449282378,
0.1505529284,
-0.3976941705,
-0.5232871771,
0.0250405185,
-0.3175936341,
-0.8015348911,
-0.0627295822,
0.1206983477,
0.6322005987,
-1.3306117058,
0.1179480925,
0.5999809504,
-0.2395457923,
-0.3413150609,
0.0159682706,
0.1155784279,
-0.5221034884,
0.6168341637,
0.1516917795,
-0.2109456509,
-0.0554709472,
-0.4664604962,
-0.6312817931,
0.5350476503,
0.7059428096,
-0.7585828304,
0.0660085604,
0.2619200945,
0.4117923975,
-0.3256931603,
0.5257046819,
0.3077695966,
0.4705427885,
-0.2064126283,
-1.1425421238,
-0.2153008282,
-0.1964552999,
0.0659260377,
0.0247364938,
-0.4087099433,
0.9964215159,
-0.0657499731,
-0.3124135733,
-0.0320870504,
0.339790076,
0.0650537685,
0.1624383479,
0.656230092,
0.2074566633,
0.8094556332,
0.187581405,
0.7722171545,
0.2161181569,
0.1363912672,
1.2741236687,
-0.4201570451,
0.6416668296,
0.3103836775,
0.0447097272,
0.2976077795,
0.2788735032,
0.2222201526,
0.1530267298,
0.1271450222,
-0.1123714745,
-0.4985870421,
-0.4203282595,
-0.2575327158,
0.7578424811,
0.1038586646,
-0.625913918,
-0.2405522913,
0.2977825105,
0.0702007636,
0.0625695884,
-0.0490190871,
0.7371050119,
-0.0469397642,
-0.1690446585,
0.4042564332,
0.0947629884,
0.5095145702,
-0.3626540899,
0.0897793546,
-0.1111889631,
-0.0338513218,
0.005927545,
-0.5482043624,
0.0646310449,
0.2655755281,
-0.3907049,
-0.2121983171,
1.0269889832,
-0.3769344091,
-0.7097414136,
0.3620653749,
1.1461216211,
0.1880265325,
-0.0265409015,
-0.7759252787,
-0.0512056388,
-0.0075912788,
0.1084989756,
0.1288858652,
0.2763685286,
-0.1690942943,
0.6700485945,
0.209645763,
0.071785748,
-0.0152241904,
0.2832681239,
0.4206207693,
-0.7384465337,
-0.1309236586,
-0.9384344816,
0.3717380762,
0.0575953163,
-0.3970861435,
1.0136219263,
0.6825400591,
0.7210062146,
-0.1579748988,
0.6555672288,
0.2097491473,
0.5810618401,
-0.0258459914,
0.3312410116,
-0.412017405,
-0.0198752787,
-0.3872015178,
-1.0910260677,
-0.5369929671,
0.7203637958,
-0.428173691,
0.3280109167,
0.3893724084,
0.6391842365,
-0.1340396404,
0.0605472587,
0.6728750467,
0.3193743825,
0.0080256434,
0.3805603981,
1.1331579685,
-0.7086976171,
0.103524141,
-0.2582252324,
0.0052868007,
-0.3721308708,
-0.9015444517,
-0.7384281754,
-0.4171413183,
-0.7071177959,
-0.0981795341,
0.2933810949,
1.1096456051,
0.698389709,
-0.5123377442,
-0.2802784741,
-0.0619267933,
0.1526987255,
0.0570043959,
-0.1683134288,
-0.0665768757,
0.0191145595,
-0.8938289285,
0.3782290816,
0.1353865117,
0.1614162624,
-0.2240630537,
0.0630889609,
-0.2771618366,
0.0349423885,
0.4891230166,
0.3538736999,
-0.4727179408,
-0.4171648622,
0.2301496565,
-0.0206526592,
-0.0648800582,
0.5560760498,
-0.528495729,
0.5408694744,
0.5301885009,
0.0961465165,
-0.0301511455,
0.103183724,
0.6225020289,
-0.795266211,
0.0862054378,
0.5809680223,
0.3930180371,
0.4445618093,
-0.2310543209,
0.1585177183,
0.4511585236,
-0.2707171738,
-0.7622591257,
0.263332516,
-0.501573503,
-0.646324873,
1.2907004356,
0.0883545801,
-0.2101510316,
-0.3971636891,
-0.0718822256,
0.2674260437,
-0.3931191266,
0.3380765021,
0.7210336328,
0.2495901436,
-0.2888601124,
-0.8276417255,
0.1317688078,
0.4854885936,
-0.4606606066,
0.2520625293,
0.8693527579,
0.2858005464,
0.0970185846,
0.4617354274,
-0.0490347594,
0.3008621633,
-0.0372075438,
0.3590419888,
0.0278630983,
-0.5137257576,
-0.6654316783,
0.0271174107,
0.0982978866,
-0.1004220024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05434v1 | How Good is the Model in Model-in-the-loop Event Coreference Resolution Annotation? | 2023-06-06T18:06:24 | 2023-06-06T18:06:24 | Shafiuddin Rehan Ahmed, Abhijnan Nath, Michael Regan, Adam Pollins, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James H. Martin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annotating cross-document event coreference links is a time-consuming and
cognitively demanding task that can compromise annotation quality and
efficiency. To address this, we propose a model-in-the-loop annotation approach
for event coreference resolution, where a machine learning model suggests
likely corefering event pairs only. We evaluate the effectiveness of this
approach by first simulating the annotation process and then, using a novel
annotator-centric Recall-Annotation effort trade-off metric, we compare the
results of various underlying models and datasets. We finally present a method
for obtaining 97\% recall while substantially reducing the workload required by
a fully manual annotation process. Code and data can be found at
https://github.com/ahmeshaf/model_in_coref | [
-0.4033209383,
-0.2810612023,
0.3988728821,
-0.4096618295,
-0.6046054959,
-0.0609885491,
-0.3311398029,
-0.8234723806,
0.1312601417,
0.3789631724,
-0.3963633776,
-0.4152906835,
-0.4620614648,
0.0766528025,
-0.2944300771,
0.9861704707,
-0.0376386419,
-0.1403547674,
-0.6592255235,
-0.253595978,
-0.3559607863,
-0.9487154484,
-0.5304137468,
-0.9782604575,
0.3240132034,
0.4545489848,
0.5418339372,
0.6453211904,
0.7092810273,
-0.039107725,
-0.2354293168,
0.0792229846,
-0.4205721319,
-0.0221809186,
-0.3534734547,
-0.0637273714,
-0.6010065079,
0.4747444093,
0.3707442582,
0.7417722344,
0.1863069236,
0.2299243808,
-0.0682241321,
0.2947874963,
-0.6493837833,
0.1577677131,
-0.8295199871,
-0.0728183761,
-0.2536512911,
-0.0392349884,
-0.5689842105,
0.0080372998,
0.3008463383,
-0.5885546803,
0.3598946035,
0.2157114744,
0.8548310995,
-0.0274025667,
-0.0361514799,
-0.3362481296,
-0.7106757164,
0.4965182245,
-0.6726236939,
0.1097332686,
0.740432024,
0.0524454266,
0.3983868659,
-0.5412063003,
-0.5189540386,
-0.3837659061,
-0.0770596266,
-0.0781394616,
-0.2302365899,
0.0723454505,
0.6169556975,
0.2167958021,
-0.4107139111,
0.1394238174,
-0.324896574,
-0.0671341643,
0.5907220244,
0.2082841545,
-0.0383367874,
-0.2592838109,
-0.1049211174,
0.2826255858,
-0.6954538822,
0.0356208123,
0.0186816193,
0.4329197705,
0.0789703131,
0.6781260967,
-0.1033872515,
0.5787470341,
0.5730896592,
-0.149419114,
0.0215545651,
-0.5000280142,
-0.179064557,
0.1890316755,
0.4405789673,
0.5490903854,
0.3979861736,
-0.6061208248,
-0.040834479,
0.1420443356,
0.4250211418,
-0.7399616838,
-0.3718897402,
0.1059738174,
-0.5323804021,
0.0026485506,
-0.0872392729,
-0.148657456,
-0.2783965468,
-0.5023967028,
0.4279944599,
-0.5062303543,
0.1146088615,
-0.2598750293,
-0.1477399468,
-0.2534485161,
0.3049893379,
-0.4521237016,
-0.0706123784,
0.6471200585,
0.7960125804,
-0.0961674079,
-0.2918245792,
-0.5609644055,
0.3219951093,
-0.0009461246,
0.8425778151,
-0.8977130651,
-0.7873679399,
-0.3280747235,
-0.2063309997,
-0.1531046629,
-0.520416081,
0.7396122217,
-0.300901264,
-0.2600563169,
-0.4121104777,
-1.0426300764,
-0.2498102635,
0.2732771933,
-0.8460187912,
0.9659258723,
-0.2495348305,
-0.8357542157,
0.3445643485,
-0.3477658331,
-0.3973242342,
-0.0747386664,
0.0138339205,
-0.3960209489,
-0.0129111763,
0.3038145006,
0.5050991178,
-0.3542297184,
0.0989342481,
-0.6868840456,
-0.3819487393,
0.2703623772,
0.2371486127,
0.3839516938,
-0.1396339238,
-0.2788742483,
0.110647209,
-0.8236890435,
-0.5709030032,
-0.0873227715,
-0.0285326112,
-0.5992401242,
-0.2235484272,
-0.1219146028,
0.5643612146,
0.0562969968,
-0.6041968465,
0.4221563041,
0.0324946158,
0.2435984612,
0.3228141069,
0.0892348364,
0.7221193314,
-0.4127900302,
0.3110456467,
0.0496002659,
0.2964027226,
-0.4265390635,
-0.4249191582,
-0.7062521577,
-0.1264191866,
0.2844513059,
0.3097225428,
-0.4176453948,
0.392337352,
0.0026545117,
-0.8445225954,
-0.3185806572,
0.0403677411,
0.6111205816,
0.7874755859,
0.2875321507,
-0.414113611,
-0.5957187414,
-0.6371215582,
-0.2346825898,
-0.4653820992,
0.26229617,
0.2879911959,
0.7688161731,
-0.1472572386,
0.9665936828,
0.0933747962,
-0.2434640378,
-0.225117445,
0.5357076526,
0.1778027266,
0.6089041829,
0.5581282377,
-0.6194466352,
-0.1766453683,
-0.0239315052,
-0.7497425675,
-0.2584311962,
-0.1949599385,
-0.1967517734,
0.4463504851,
0.2510969937,
-0.5007581115,
0.9367445707,
0.291500479,
-0.2628796697,
0.7541979551,
-0.2634843886,
0.1260816455,
-0.6317378879,
0.5175731182,
-0.0673677623,
-0.1003180295,
-0.5360341072,
-0.1934054196,
0.4148826301,
-0.2315332443,
-0.2017300874,
0.4300603867,
-0.4926756322,
0.0009810508,
-0.5068252683,
0.1911151409,
0.1784654409,
0.3194397688,
0.2245347053,
0.4614977837,
0.1594953835,
-0.6786379218,
0.2411364615,
0.2527053356,
0.034207467,
0.8509078026,
-0.3806586862,
0.438195914,
0.0499910712,
0.6123198271,
-0.5494531989,
-0.049536258,
0.1700528264,
-0.3975008428,
0.2425418198,
-0.2643283606,
-0.4957699478,
-0.4316059649,
-0.0810068771,
0.5279691815,
0.2209229469,
-0.7872767448,
0.9430121183,
0.4183909297,
0.2372627854,
-0.2037004679,
-0.4231162667,
0.187842831,
-0.178797245,
-0.441475153,
0.4928131998,
0.0647545904,
-0.0744886622,
0.0516228154,
-0.0241028573,
0.1991709173,
-0.0270621497,
0.7466275692,
0.4168700278,
0.1589392722,
0.3774946928,
-0.3885985017,
-0.3585842252,
-0.1038115099,
-0.5235210061,
0.1334093362,
-0.0220560357,
-0.6139994264,
-0.6436284781,
0.5996043682,
0.4992440045,
-0.4183718562,
0.5001345277,
0.5213766694,
-0.8711498976,
0.1218455732,
-0.8783529401,
-0.1867438257,
-0.2085957378,
0.0736406967,
-0.4630380869,
-0.7009525299,
0.7610248327,
0.012366672,
0.1527429372,
0.5292786956,
0.4418578744,
-0.3247537911,
0.6121876836,
0.4441110492,
-0.2013721168,
0.3912199438,
-0.2609352171,
0.2711449265,
-1.0767891407,
-0.2232846171,
-0.7538872361,
-0.2374261618,
0.2113348544,
-0.6594706774,
0.1505349576,
0.5694103241,
-0.0262752417,
0.6782726645,
-0.2239420116,
0.189664349,
0.8266122341,
0.0381977558,
0.4716169238,
-0.3026122451,
-0.1094014272,
-0.158953622,
-0.9313848019,
-0.6534960866,
0.8868768811,
-0.0089439852,
0.6752846837,
-0.4621530175,
0.8180712461,
0.2191611826,
0.3182660639,
-0.3912216127,
0.3255758286,
0.0345443487,
-0.6588833928,
-0.125161469,
-0.0676337034,
-0.4368272722,
-0.1313085109,
-0.348634541,
-0.9410288334,
0.3659782708,
0.4575449824,
-0.4662274718,
0.7235043049,
-0.3712513149,
0.8428660631,
0.1408647746,
-0.2611499727,
-0.3767019808,
-0.5446468592,
0.0948471949,
-0.2179341763,
0.0382753462,
-0.4410778284,
0.359084785,
0.9502930045,
-0.1661129296,
1.1318054199,
0.1900107563,
0.4273609221,
0.6211884022,
0.1914796233,
0.9903932214,
-0.1067783982,
-0.3583025038,
0.224557966,
-0.2555921078,
-0.2852266729,
-0.396145463,
0.5038695931,
-0.3360069692,
-0.1856939495,
-0.1563457549,
-0.5166966319,
0.1356687546,
-0.2463044822,
0.2637907565,
0.5955449343,
-0.3865518868,
-0.0641181022,
0.4111674428,
0.2471115887,
0.6182106137,
0.1986614168,
0.0364422202,
-0.3440563381,
0.6732367873,
0.3907952905,
0.1926656514,
0.1762090325,
0.0101834349,
-0.1413118988,
-0.340392977,
-0.4363588393,
0.3915484548,
-1.0396689177,
-0.2761967778,
-0.8576873541,
0.1079657599,
-0.5552787781,
-0.5646783113,
-0.3746582866,
-0.6098766327,
-0.6968705654,
-0.1144763231,
0.2800168097,
0.4105576575,
-0.1767801195,
0.2231775075,
-0.8957049251,
0.0080647459,
0.060510084,
0.1255000085,
0.131468907,
-0.5258117914,
-0.522587657,
-0.2148962021,
-0.3177354038,
-0.8605163693,
0.0585366525,
0.4489395022,
0.7192414999,
0.4624086022,
0.4712355435,
0.60768646,
0.0278449152,
0.8832756281,
0.3040121496,
-1.1621016264,
0.7692731619,
-0.042389974,
0.4045372605,
0.5172119141,
0.3387452662,
-0.7277354598,
-0.4496737123,
-0.9164414406,
-0.7568730712,
0.6276445389,
0.2676416934,
-0.484251976,
-0.1216583848,
0.6890761256,
0.323320359,
-0.1631700844,
-0.3802359104,
0.0134581095,
0.0623972714,
0.1355919838,
-0.1610735357,
-0.397539109,
-0.018931767,
-0.2257058024,
0.9517011046,
-0.2254413068,
0.1067630798,
0.3003436625,
-0.5209876299,
-0.2431295216,
-0.020793939,
0.3224333525,
0.9624676704,
-0.4135945141,
0.3151037395,
0.3798837662,
-0.2934746742,
-0.2117943913,
0.0811689943,
-0.3263309002,
0.3124415576,
0.6989218593,
0.9193280935,
0.4971872568,
-0.6070775986,
0.2071991712,
0.1315762252,
0.1203745082,
-0.0867734849,
-0.1242561564,
0.2092938274,
0.4890146554,
0.2564629614,
-0.1781141758,
0.0521771125,
-0.3009316623,
0.3660562038,
0.1461008787,
-0.5803316236,
-0.3929452598,
0.612569809,
0.5774959326,
-0.3534588814,
0.6393827796,
-0.0993076041,
-0.8309870362,
0.6002938747,
0.459800303,
0.8654639721,
0.1075106859,
-0.119990997,
0.9007949233,
0.2184664458,
-0.0995889902,
-0.0768822432,
-0.272164017,
-0.3873088658,
-0.2097003162,
-0.4404881895,
-0.8406181335,
-0.4296727777,
-0.8999100327,
0.1736915559,
-0.1345764101,
-0.6071485281,
0.0417668037,
0.0495652817,
-0.7174830437,
0.1754927933,
0.5753840208,
1.0868580341,
-0.7642284036,
1.1301440001,
0.7540871501,
-0.6164610386,
-0.4041897655,
-0.2630124986,
-0.0783051327,
-0.3961329758,
0.447427094,
0.2559187412,
0.1092857122,
-0.2506985366,
-0.1884036362,
-0.4807263017,
1.1772251129,
0.0406675451,
-0.8587887883,
-0.1157486215,
-0.0457994938,
0.2158989012,
-0.7996456623,
0.3028384745,
0.7229731679,
0.3449345827,
0.066078119,
-1.2754591703,
0.0723439381,
-0.1407787949,
0.1349797994,
0.067326434,
-0.2117516547,
0.619355619,
-0.447863549,
-0.0950974151,
-0.0582113601,
0.8584054112,
0.2310629636,
0.6760802865,
0.6265343428,
0.7498543859,
0.8380171657,
0.0640752539,
1.0210812092,
-0.3760291636,
0.6267393827,
1.4641637802,
-0.3716649115,
0.7504141927,
0.6968895793,
0.1146911383,
-0.0797731206,
0.8012497425,
0.202355355,
0.2302546054,
0.0538677312,
-0.1518924832,
-0.8120797276,
-0.3995487094,
-0.2739174664,
0.158435151,
0.2486362904,
-0.5853304267,
-0.2703287005,
0.1774840653,
0.0508152843,
-0.1219040155,
-0.4082600176,
0.5806786418,
0.1573497802,
-0.5680549741,
0.2070036978,
-0.2825550437,
0.5240141153,
-0.2298206389,
0.0768877715,
-0.1756246686,
0.2939541042,
0.1315894723,
-0.5416768193,
0.4947547317,
0.0839126408,
-0.5787715912,
0.1041264236,
0.8142938018,
-0.4601753354,
-0.5082105994,
0.6337165833,
0.1286531538,
0.0927718282,
-0.4189735055,
-0.5197696686,
0.2996841967,
-0.3836169839,
-0.0372292176,
0.1130331382,
0.1937583983,
-0.2994799316,
0.3975131512,
0.5542219877,
-0.2159904242,
0.0976547003,
0.0709865019,
0.6895029545,
-0.720736146,
-0.5020400286,
-0.7519108653,
0.1975225657,
-0.2448118925,
-0.5681363344,
0.3569819629,
0.4529502392,
1.0609459877,
0.21815525,
0.7303183079,
-0.0194746125,
0.4993618131,
-0.188299492,
0.4150749445,
-0.454293251,
-0.1130524725,
-0.3822115064,
-0.5528297424,
-0.3791986704,
0.5160318613,
-0.3914992809,
-0.2007612735,
0.6240804195,
0.6560484171,
-0.0976900682,
0.4365288913,
0.3546532989,
-0.1414520293,
0.3957867324,
0.8162878752,
0.7771584988,
-0.3119546473,
0.427881062,
-0.7299955487,
-0.1456291229,
-0.8231841922,
-1.1201938391,
-1.0861420631,
-0.8667284846,
-0.7213504314,
-0.6634851098,
0.2498870939,
1.2230316401,
0.9309604764,
-0.6351494789,
-0.2235911787,
0.5926927924,
-0.1203365624,
-0.4543532431,
0.0174174085,
0.4289008975,
-0.2187092006,
-0.4328483343,
-0.0720636919,
0.3997994363,
-0.0205964446,
0.0900099874,
-0.1668780893,
-0.4459074438,
0.0073232329,
0.5119946599,
0.2819191515,
-0.8649557233,
-0.450266093,
-0.3505123258,
-0.4463799894,
0.0374003015,
1.2222739458,
-0.5776709318,
0.6372525096,
0.4308948517,
0.6895042658,
0.7801702023,
-0.071440272,
0.3575505912,
-0.2965766788,
0.0543244965,
0.3212239444,
0.4112151265,
0.2223608941,
-0.3628418744,
0.6695267558,
0.5270576477,
-0.3751698136,
-0.6201798916,
-0.01055656,
-1.3687903881,
-0.1506438255,
1.0469251871,
-0.4613246024,
-0.3988584876,
-0.2191468179,
-0.3071745336,
0.5827902555,
-0.3058426082,
0.8705852032,
0.7698178887,
-0.4547811151,
-0.1349540353,
-0.0187931582,
0.0785510689,
0.1580152959,
-0.4769250453,
0.2592316568,
0.4057255387,
-0.0122326752,
0.3506673276,
0.6193789244,
0.1229342073,
0.4915576577,
0.0455204435,
0.6309966445,
-0.3559598029,
-0.3997408748,
-0.2416989505,
0.23226358,
-0.0836661533,
-0.0986974537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03917v1 | Turning large language models into cognitive models | 2023-06-06T18:00:01 | 2023-06-06T18:00:01 | Marcel Binz, Eric Schulz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models are powerful systems that excel at many tasks, ranging
from translation to mathematical reasoning. Yet, at the same time, these models
often show unhuman-like characteristics. In the present paper, we address this
gap and ask whether large language models can be turned into cognitive models.
We find that -- after finetuning them on data from psychological experiments --
these models offer accurate representations of human behavior, even
outperforming traditional cognitive models in two decision-making domains. In
addition, we show that their representations contain the information necessary
to model behavior on the level of individual subjects. Finally, we demonstrate
that finetuning on multiple tasks enables large language models to predict
human behavior in a previously unseen task. Taken together, these results
suggest that large, pre-trained models can be adapted to become generalist
cognitive models, thereby opening up new research directions that could
transform cognitive psychology and the behavioral sciences as a whole. | [
-0.3286353946,
-0.9640240073,
0.9928843379,
0.1185104698,
0.1260394901,
-0.1576219648,
-1.0320175886,
-0.49855721,
-0.1101551801,
0.8174724579,
-0.5381882787,
-0.1135746166,
-0.5282071233,
-0.4131185114,
-0.5074631572,
0.9263318181,
0.3874422014,
0.1915592998,
-0.0642973557,
0.0262361411,
-0.6228567362,
-0.8147287965,
-0.5881813169,
-0.6994639635,
0.1662202775,
0.179580465,
0.9979111552,
0.1658173054,
0.307282269,
0.3504321277,
0.3351499438,
0.036862988,
-0.4720109701,
-0.1279591918,
-0.5798948407,
-0.6024321914,
-0.366609931,
0.4011256099,
0.4755968153,
1.2197515965,
-0.2870849073,
0.0908654407,
0.3112787306,
0.5548860431,
-0.2890306711,
0.4803952277,
-0.5791127086,
-0.3526487052,
-0.1266192198,
0.1486762911,
-0.6999233961,
-0.0523446873,
0.2014901638,
-0.6627418995,
0.2673566341,
0.0275490154,
0.3776814938,
0.0616792366,
-0.5549718738,
-0.2990246117,
-1.2982904911,
1.1417226791,
-0.6726514101,
0.369922787,
0.5819833279,
0.3001610935,
-0.437690556,
-0.4797277451,
-0.5076738,
-0.6194261909,
-0.202121377,
-0.0710242242,
-0.4125223458,
0.0552049577,
0.3762200475,
0.0197811332,
-0.2469608486,
0.0892059803,
-0.4043675065,
-0.0750938132,
0.8518641591,
0.1871680617,
0.4331330359,
0.0950175896,
0.315274328,
-0.3036028147,
-0.1399637759,
0.1348809153,
0.0572781973,
0.4940981865,
0.1269878596,
0.6457177401,
-0.2849048078,
0.4548907876,
0.2584188282,
0.217888549,
-0.1034211218,
-0.0060828384,
-0.249655202,
-0.0554024689,
0.6841604114,
0.3079974353,
0.9696545601,
-0.2195675373,
-0.1324139535,
0.6148332953,
0.6451699734,
-0.5105020404,
-0.5463135839,
0.1492982507,
-0.4095748067,
-0.1827342361,
-0.1287628114,
-0.5371847749,
-0.4302239716,
-0.7901511788,
0.2521256506,
-0.6122919321,
-0.4121132493,
0.5998103619,
0.263191849,
0.0244484041,
0.6208594441,
-1.0947071314,
0.7468718886,
0.7884484529,
0.4996649325,
-0.0808174163,
-0.3140363395,
-0.281481266,
0.1321185231,
-0.8026509285,
0.5185844898,
-0.7575308681,
-0.3070965409,
0.0370876268,
-0.0436607264,
0.1000345349,
-0.6545701623,
0.3829824626,
-0.4391105175,
0.1326793283,
-0.2301659286,
-0.4065369964,
-0.3628379703,
0.3095514476,
-0.5671378374,
0.6471430063,
-0.0000473878,
-0.2756014466,
-0.0276851058,
-0.9079236388,
-0.3831013143,
-0.1256850511,
-0.180018723,
0.0195487738,
0.4760043025,
0.147342056,
0.7149141431,
-0.6131785512,
0.6612784863,
-0.5103303194,
-0.0746272802,
0.848326385,
-0.4022453427,
0.9072548747,
0.1589757204,
-0.1251924336,
0.0332914107,
-0.4154160321,
0.2158832252,
0.2940482795,
-0.3425443172,
-0.6133204103,
0.143555671,
0.1641505957,
0.3200336993,
0.2006061822,
-0.5303524733,
0.1757202148,
-0.2547048926,
0.8413316607,
0.5350118279,
-0.4397711754,
0.844634831,
-0.3251346648,
0.1322792619,
-0.2448466271,
0.0011263966,
0.3076709807,
-0.4562801719,
-0.7078392506,
-0.1607151031,
0.0725556165,
0.44094491,
-0.2513034046,
0.3745949268,
-0.3446347415,
-0.4556354284,
-0.343742013,
-0.005494955,
0.3177581131,
0.0408199057,
0.3933921456,
-0.268142879,
-0.2137522697,
-0.7589663267,
-0.5589431524,
-0.2069669962,
-0.3455247879,
0.1760927141,
0.6405463219,
-0.4175588191,
0.7217083573,
-0.6520861387,
-0.1856419146,
-0.0475848503,
0.2568725646,
0.0932683498,
0.7917936444,
0.469291538,
-0.6247445345,
0.1342879832,
0.1625605077,
-0.8388441801,
0.2602319717,
-0.2293643653,
-0.1673339903,
-0.1897336692,
0.6762371659,
-0.7227591276,
0.314075321,
0.3194334209,
-0.3695202172,
0.7272746563,
-0.4855296016,
0.0123365847,
-0.6163505912,
0.0429372825,
0.0192023143,
-0.1449076533,
-0.717448771,
0.0925213769,
0.0318491384,
-0.2417950332,
0.1034750715,
0.6073764563,
-0.352481544,
-0.1328841001,
-0.2191267908,
-0.2808491588,
-0.1941608489,
0.5822134614,
0.0594388433,
0.28075701,
0.6217288971,
-0.7618530989,
0.3894490898,
0.19728522,
-0.5245966315,
0.508410275,
-0.5155293941,
0.0373640433,
-0.3550329208,
0.3586978614,
-0.8089760542,
-0.5668377876,
-0.1158114299,
-0.4172776043,
0.2024149299,
0.1736167669,
-0.3966440856,
-0.43270576,
0.156048283,
0.376201719,
0.6174760461,
-0.2090089172,
0.6943932176,
0.3684942424,
-0.3123666942,
0.0856882036,
-1.04025805,
-0.0007140565,
-0.1470653415,
-0.3512592912,
0.3701431155,
-0.1599957496,
-0.4896223247,
-0.0578639433,
0.1506688893,
-0.2609848082,
0.0054053613,
0.3114206791,
0.3781432211,
-0.287201643,
0.3641766012,
-0.3124954402,
-0.0653549433,
0.1897597164,
-0.5910844803,
0.6678683162,
-0.2677727044,
-0.3535750508,
-0.3586527705,
0.4020529389,
0.945587337,
-0.5560323,
0.4863449037,
0.3302132189,
-0.7443938255,
-0.0335773081,
-0.6152812243,
-0.4261144102,
-0.3904428184,
0.565077424,
-0.2144578397,
-0.8823818564,
0.4064639211,
-0.3990830183,
0.0120723089,
0.2944292128,
0.5178784132,
-0.3069532812,
1.3979823589,
0.8341038227,
0.1758439541,
0.6496576071,
-0.2908097208,
0.1070370674,
-0.7577918768,
-0.1021520123,
-0.4249249101,
-0.1939760298,
-0.6451230645,
-0.4203296304,
0.2196691483,
0.064285472,
-0.7317317128,
0.0374333896,
-0.3834161758,
0.4490748644,
0.3780762255,
0.2589478195,
0.1293049753,
0.0779990256,
0.0055911075,
0.0270265788,
-0.2709196508,
-0.7905439138,
1.2093019485,
0.0653210655,
0.8000469208,
0.0118887722,
0.2377090901,
0.1980197281,
0.5447621346,
-0.7698218822,
0.6383526325,
-0.6050543189,
-0.903644681,
-0.6143612266,
-0.209918648,
-1.0589764118,
0.2672140896,
-0.4151751697,
-1.0550692081,
0.1722333729,
0.0362093709,
-0.4691145122,
0.188689664,
-0.6898885965,
0.8571994901,
-0.4536263049,
-0.0639860183,
-0.8483889699,
-0.3319934607,
0.6533923745,
-0.2728791535,
0.490493536,
-0.2385490388,
0.2270568609,
0.8705399632,
-0.1910562515,
1.0493355989,
-0.1008252874,
-0.1048655659,
0.174280405,
0.4117030203,
0.3155804276,
-0.0963005647,
-0.2094147205,
0.073990643,
0.1344142258,
-0.6104704738,
-0.7718389034,
0.7146006823,
-0.9528362155,
-0.6148394346,
-0.1689599454,
-0.7061868906,
-0.4611546993,
0.249846071,
-0.0144383488,
0.5105995536,
-0.562122345,
0.0962685272,
0.534858644,
-0.0137720117,
0.196315214,
0.5928736329,
-0.4290707111,
-0.0592028648,
0.7433614135,
0.2167253345,
0.2477334887,
0.1766507477,
0.1533942223,
-0.2111505121,
-0.4174803793,
-0.0343806632,
0.4523361325,
-0.5717136264,
0.3542687595,
-0.4369224012,
0.0927308798,
-0.3028507531,
-0.3004136682,
-0.6443016529,
-0.2532926798,
-0.2082618475,
0.1088030413,
0.1650881916,
1.0176542997,
-0.0522234254,
0.375374794,
-0.5916742086,
0.3724168241,
0.734598279,
0.2454209775,
0.3457966447,
-0.3754661679,
-0.1039563641,
0.5175691843,
-0.2667653561,
-0.6145222187,
0.2767917216,
0.1444288343,
0.3006682396,
0.4590365887,
0.059094999,
0.6186566949,
-0.6273290515,
0.4731392264,
0.3229307532,
-0.9767810106,
0.3507608771,
-0.539930284,
0.3324092627,
0.2468632311,
0.2676555514,
-0.685316205,
-0.2291126549,
-0.6671046019,
-0.3005577326,
0.6480728388,
0.1117156744,
0.4857744277,
-0.0076590963,
0.3171567917,
0.0679120421,
-0.1048202589,
-0.3423664272,
0.2822303176,
-0.2463957667,
-0.1542721689,
-0.6211153865,
0.0751901194,
-0.0925267562,
-0.4508845508,
0.3036421239,
-0.3259199858,
0.3430857956,
-0.0948609188,
-0.099829033,
-0.0937983096,
0.4660881758,
0.2989610136,
0.4970115423,
-0.0312799364,
0.1699593663,
0.1825186014,
-0.3446096778,
0.1858763397,
-0.0222179834,
0.2461031377,
-0.5641807914,
0.3710737228,
0.3972046375,
0.4284497499,
-0.8604824543,
0.3581509292,
-0.0241761655,
0.0195036083,
-0.3694021404,
0.1662707478,
0.3396012187,
0.4886029959,
0.2381272465,
0.3409268856,
0.0420645811,
-1.102412343,
-0.0054006255,
0.4797771871,
-0.3366639018,
-0.6418935657,
0.5610084534,
0.0664767772,
-0.120218955,
0.9249804616,
0.030039601,
-0.3668883741,
0.3856944144,
0.7109923959,
0.617584765,
-0.3943997622,
0.2069500536,
0.3241262734,
0.2542303205,
-0.5829467177,
-0.0406376496,
0.1136435717,
-1.0677441359,
-0.6051492691,
-0.5038187504,
-0.1652457118,
0.1734445244,
-0.8924236894,
-0.0771859214,
-0.5213543177,
-0.4063466191,
0.5374706984,
-0.0462206565,
-0.9091162682,
0.4305856228,
0.3566604257,
0.3209015131,
-0.8878498673,
0.9216865897,
1.0359369516,
-0.3572061956,
-0.50443542,
-0.1137033999,
-0.314763248,
-0.8031970263,
0.5726251602,
0.0859493092,
-0.0450614356,
0.0604503304,
-0.9075094461,
-0.8827536106,
0.6651265025,
0.8266788721,
-0.4992338419,
-0.280962944,
0.1478007883,
0.6237452626,
-0.5348963737,
0.0123601751,
0.9110343456,
0.5340307951,
-0.3310424089,
-1.1043249369,
0.2373171449,
-0.0223422367,
0.0970895737,
0.1283831596,
-0.5228998065,
1.1853065491,
-0.4704856575,
-0.2316269577,
0.0148573937,
0.6875008345,
-0.0225459225,
0.0134746153,
0.4607523978,
0.254349649,
1.0312885046,
0.0816857815,
1.018294096,
0.1146235913,
0.1583583951,
0.9825611711,
-0.2549680173,
0.9285489917,
0.232314527,
-0.1930573583,
0.6331032515,
0.2573685944,
0.3116627634,
0.3892447948,
0.2552739084,
0.0923714563,
-1.0269879103,
-0.0705117658,
0.1233090311,
0.6929332018,
0.8436819315,
-0.0892817453,
-0.0762941018,
0.3755984306,
0.0743225962,
0.3615907431,
-0.5984057784,
0.5460511446,
0.1743058264,
-0.836963892,
0.6278856993,
0.081759125,
0.6773167253,
-0.3837613761,
0.0344580933,
0.3233290911,
0.4768992662,
-0.058991529,
-0.8611519337,
0.2332473099,
-0.1230791584,
-0.3826500177,
-0.308519274,
0.8575126529,
-0.3457154632,
-0.5340746045,
0.3501304686,
0.6502158642,
0.25275141,
-0.4837038815,
-0.5167014599,
-0.2651465237,
-0.0119165666,
-0.0819412321,
0.4112089276,
0.3845736384,
-0.7172917724,
0.7400679588,
0.8589150906,
-0.0306933187,
-0.0936571211,
-0.2617134154,
0.7486664057,
-1.0158673525,
-0.5128998756,
-0.8285747766,
0.2719968855,
0.0659728721,
-0.1301064193,
0.1970187873,
0.1267997324,
0.9267160296,
-0.3533326983,
1.0137392282,
0.115487054,
0.1389768571,
-0.4194224775,
0.6906318069,
-0.3044109643,
-0.2372874022,
-0.0714261457,
-0.6674537659,
-0.2526561916,
0.6682614088,
-0.7230316401,
0.1742542237,
0.6388378739,
0.3837451935,
-0.2151421607,
0.1711569577,
0.5425505042,
0.4246845245,
0.326741308,
0.7253139615,
0.7128814459,
0.037051402,
0.4208351076,
-0.1080799401,
-0.3129564524,
-0.2693460584,
-0.5474801064,
-0.9754664898,
-0.6252430081,
-0.3389394283,
0.0252960604,
-0.1236427352,
0.799613297,
0.8611908555,
-0.8082281351,
-0.4125762582,
-0.0726497322,
-0.3317267597,
-0.4228795171,
-0.1409292221,
0.1930810809,
-0.2398118824,
-0.7169879675,
0.2014853358,
-0.0235362705,
0.1915951073,
-0.3950980604,
-0.0255050082,
0.0565497242,
0.3783521056,
0.7237442732,
0.2729664445,
-0.9329039454,
-0.422611177,
-0.1119673774,
-0.2081347108,
-0.2802883387,
0.9094468355,
-0.7536407113,
0.2315706164,
0.1098859981,
0.3412979245,
0.5994948745,
-0.408267647,
0.7370016575,
-0.3254745007,
0.1988434345,
0.3041327298,
0.4645638764,
0.3408827782,
-0.1182084084,
0.3688396811,
-0.2016989738,
-0.4613113701,
-0.6874347329,
0.4409902394,
-0.8586679697,
-0.5264373422,
0.9404399395,
0.0011396297,
-0.2999823987,
-0.09079431,
-0.4022940099,
0.3729010224,
-0.3720266521,
0.8534116745,
0.9096385241,
-0.2694724798,
0.1989673227,
-0.9339821935,
0.2933109701,
0.5881022215,
-0.6609652042,
0.5586348772,
0.5304032564,
0.2664021254,
0.4872989357,
0.4429085255,
-0.0506698526,
0.2123873979,
-0.2703512013,
0.2317418754,
0.2250956595,
-0.1014846787,
-0.1455128938,
-0.1055787653,
0.270381242,
0.1127008349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03907v1 | CL-UZH at SemEval-2023 Task 10: Sexism Detection through Incremental Fine-Tuning and Multi-Task Learning with Label Descriptions | 2023-06-06T17:59:49 | 2023-06-06T17:59:49 | Janis Goldzycher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The widespread popularity of social media has led to an increase in hateful,
abusive, and sexist language, motivating methods for the automatic detection of
such phenomena. The goal of the SemEval shared task \textit{Towards Explainable
Detection of Online Sexism} (EDOS 2023) is to detect sexism in English social
media posts (subtask A), and to categorize such posts into four coarse-grained
sexism categories (subtask B), and eleven fine-grained subcategories (subtask
C). In this paper, we present our submitted systems for all three subtasks,
based on a multi-task model that has been fine-tuned on a range of related
tasks and datasets before being fine-tuned on the specific EDOS subtasks. We
implement multi-task learning by formulating each task as binary pairwise text
classification, where the dataset and label descriptions are given along with
the input text. The results show clear improvements over a fine-tuned
DeBERTa-V3 serving as a baseline leading to $F_1$-scores of 85.9\% in subtask A
(rank 13/84), 64.8\% in subtask B (rank 19/69), and 44.9\% in subtask C
(26/63). | [
-0.3225863576,
-0.791189611,
0.5036594272,
0.4521105587,
-0.3155762255,
-0.2381072193,
-0.0847446918,
-0.3795477748,
-0.0382904485,
0.3671765327,
-0.7314411402,
-0.6233531833,
-0.8476303816,
0.3781482875,
-0.4707605541,
1.0554599762,
-0.1095710099,
0.1209973246,
-0.1886597574,
0.0832470208,
-0.525649488,
-0.3518850207,
-0.5086914897,
-0.1443866789,
0.4979219139,
0.5027233958,
0.0807586014,
0.4416861236,
0.4789065421,
0.2863667309,
0.0259996243,
0.487387687,
-0.4727125168,
0.3164580166,
-0.313010633,
-0.2485423386,
-0.58286798,
-0.0573671274,
0.3372400403,
0.3092509806,
0.2278848141,
0.4468550086,
0.3855087459,
0.3931040466,
-0.7280579805,
0.230415374,
-0.718616426,
0.0951235592,
-0.4476228058,
-0.3341151774,
-0.3872147501,
0.1584195793,
-0.1640893519,
-0.3735571206,
0.2368271798,
0.0172759611,
0.647328794,
0.1703408957,
-0.7629299164,
-0.4017622173,
-0.4958153963,
1.0778750181,
-0.4458552599,
0.5267612338,
0.6299360394,
-0.0589699186,
-0.0049299542,
-0.2481535375,
-0.3074761033,
-0.0093304394,
-0.1504058838,
0.0638812631,
-0.1541714817,
-0.1398696154,
0.2382424176,
0.0410937257,
-0.5500589013,
0.1086625159,
-0.3911466002,
-0.1664115638,
0.7004076242,
0.2614287734,
0.1511361301,
-0.1750988364,
-0.4788796604,
0.244093582,
-0.4393740594,
0.1044343114,
0.5673314333,
0.388815999,
-0.0704463348,
0.154189229,
-0.3284253776,
0.1705687642,
0.0668737441,
-0.2208370119,
0.4268844426,
-0.535322547,
-0.0109705245,
-0.2337998301,
0.6266077161,
0.3974103928,
-0.0960234404,
0.1942526847,
-0.2568760514,
0.4762577415,
0.5050876141,
-0.6357310414,
-0.2482425123,
0.1703278571,
-0.5189058185,
-0.4986228943,
-0.3494227827,
-0.7283625007,
-0.5566381812,
-0.5082027912,
0.3516025841,
-0.2946767211,
-0.2419688404,
-0.2151699364,
0.0678409711,
-0.1106994748,
0.6046677828,
-0.8143168092,
0.2080585361,
0.5755169392,
0.4398463368,
-0.491861403,
-0.2621003091,
-0.5074157119,
-0.0243767761,
-0.0801619589,
0.7541040182,
-0.7042463422,
0.1129660457,
0.000489835,
0.600200057,
-0.0730802566,
-0.1865001321,
0.6812998056,
-0.2022369653,
0.0283269547,
-0.4476167262,
-0.2436085641,
-0.3367933929,
0.4426310062,
-0.3671438992,
1.1184183359,
-0.2538980544,
-0.7551993728,
0.4328123331,
-0.5479525924,
-0.5692927837,
0.0855086073,
0.0758140758,
-0.5383287668,
-0.2540007532,
0.20706141,
0.8562679291,
-0.1995124668,
0.2729643285,
-0.4972563684,
-0.4018959701,
-0.1662786007,
-0.3298869729,
0.5452786684,
0.2588272095,
-0.7342728376,
0.4084284008,
-0.5307602882,
-0.1658140719,
-0.0766304806,
-0.1253779233,
-0.4326960444,
-0.0306899287,
0.0520235039,
0.1221663579,
0.3576183021,
-0.6991798878,
-0.2131896168,
-0.1629325598,
0.239398703,
0.9089136124,
-0.2543666661,
0.2124589384,
-0.2125912309,
0.4882512689,
0.2030982673,
0.3143176138,
-0.1117161289,
-0.3738179505,
-0.7477815151,
-0.1074829549,
-0.0300388131,
0.6164942384,
-0.8416014314,
0.2374742031,
0.0740186721,
-0.5908577442,
-0.0546931811,
0.2541851401,
0.6180269122,
0.020791946,
0.657702744,
-0.1371106505,
-0.6652798057,
-1.0336716175,
-0.3526355624,
0.0765550062,
0.366343379,
0.0996791124,
1.024871707,
-0.1431463659,
-0.0917089731,
-0.2661523223,
-0.5137549043,
-0.0740723908,
0.4349637032,
-0.0829549134,
0.4850788116,
0.4553551972,
-0.9271182418,
-0.5556076765,
0.0001041399,
-0.6431593299,
-0.2515085638,
0.334857434,
-0.0594048053,
0.2347396165,
0.6624785066,
0.0631164014,
0.4376971424,
0.347891748,
-0.3972525299,
0.5648354292,
0.006185533,
0.5730599761,
-1.0805184841,
-0.2930345833,
0.3356412947,
-0.2882775962,
-0.6087349057,
0.1024261191,
0.0677465424,
0.2368054241,
-0.6547527313,
0.1930021346,
-0.2953644395,
0.1515343487,
-0.419352591,
-0.0599692352,
-0.3947640359,
0.6421099305,
-0.2777973413,
0.5119047761,
0.4070396423,
-0.7183250785,
0.4559600949,
-0.0659829527,
0.1548867673,
0.7787306309,
-0.4256978631,
0.3255439401,
-0.3221059144,
0.1036476195,
-1.070915103,
-0.245701775,
0.2731773853,
-0.3718364537,
-0.122098051,
-0.1573504806,
-0.4447793067,
-0.4076598883,
-0.4662001133,
0.3720484376,
0.0409090109,
-0.347653091,
0.5014771223,
0.7624726295,
-0.1520598382,
-0.6737929583,
-0.2949907184,
-0.2998130918,
-0.1957464665,
-0.4049347639,
0.4431227446,
0.1147449315,
0.0548599809,
-0.0429607481,
-0.0824083462,
-0.042861525,
0.1630290449,
0.3312890828,
0.0794187039,
0.2554222643,
0.3724672496,
0.2954013944,
0.1524376869,
0.0286972243,
-0.176171422,
0.6681312323,
-0.3946458995,
-0.1137745827,
-0.2982802689,
0.4452854991,
0.5524361134,
-0.1057430506,
0.4663454294,
1.1107391119,
-0.6339781284,
-0.3343384266,
-0.2417755425,
-0.2257727534,
-0.440770328,
0.4634514451,
-0.5906633139,
-1.0298675299,
0.2300086021,
0.1446127743,
0.1737587154,
0.530690968,
0.6269935369,
-0.3614831567,
1.3573793173,
0.6744025946,
0.3045200706,
0.3576529324,
-0.1007018164,
-0.1257712394,
-0.569869101,
-0.2567367256,
-0.5010654926,
-0.487292707,
-0.8017978668,
-0.3632493019,
0.4680325091,
-0.2211320102,
-0.4591435194,
0.7444963455,
-0.6201204062,
0.3970488012,
0.4121310115,
0.2767814696,
0.1118630469,
0.0488717072,
-0.0276427399,
-0.2798016369,
-0.2286286652,
-0.5087742209,
0.9551958442,
0.4798250198,
0.6521680355,
0.1570565552,
0.4856003225,
0.7385213375,
0.1472901255,
-0.4989334047,
0.8653460145,
-0.8674957156,
-0.4848453999,
-0.123276256,
-0.2211981267,
-0.9448105097,
0.4938663542,
-0.2989152968,
-0.8444784284,
0.0819998235,
0.270852983,
-0.0365791246,
0.1820932925,
-0.4417476356,
0.942127645,
-0.0707948655,
-0.5227136612,
-0.3924010694,
-0.4009379447,
0.4119036496,
-0.0447754301,
0.5077400804,
-0.448761791,
-0.0333791375,
0.8445028663,
0.0555026345,
1.1248891354,
-0.2058444619,
-0.4244554937,
-0.1865953058,
-0.1283160746,
0.4631038606,
-0.1631835103,
0.046518907,
-0.1021745354,
0.4743646681,
-0.3711226583,
-0.1297263205,
0.6901733875,
-0.543556571,
-0.4054910541,
-0.3514057696,
-0.601249814,
-0.3031455874,
0.1762425005,
0.2078840286,
0.5534810424,
0.0362503678,
0.4564535916,
0.6848723292,
-0.1604422927,
0.182322681,
0.434091717,
-0.2587748468,
-0.2893919051,
1.0335105658,
0.0373817012,
-0.1286751032,
0.3128886819,
0.0365248844,
-0.3288522363,
-0.3520516753,
-0.3790144324,
-0.0405579843,
-0.8077734709,
-0.1759492457,
-1.1085830927,
0.1683449745,
-0.7298692465,
0.064291805,
-0.3388249874,
0.0616749562,
-0.1713650525,
0.2126453966,
0.0436357707,
0.7888431549,
0.1345709264,
0.1370930672,
-0.707231164,
0.4502292871,
0.2570835352,
-0.0833112374,
-0.3546906114,
-0.701089859,
-0.0440614335,
0.2017760277,
-0.5717585087,
-1.1309502125,
0.3607377112,
0.0220343918,
0.346185863,
0.1385249496,
0.145647496,
0.6298178434,
-0.2039220035,
0.6642161608,
0.0792665333,
-0.9851421118,
0.8838737607,
-0.5381248593,
0.197018072,
0.4680052996,
0.6766847968,
-0.4105405807,
-0.5935987234,
-0.4304081202,
-0.7231197953,
0.7952095866,
0.3226737976,
0.2697826028,
0.0079012746,
0.1635184735,
0.347578913,
0.4095996022,
-1.0078310966,
-0.3836533129,
0.0677074641,
-0.3566917777,
0.3098149896,
-0.2557145357,
-0.1060305536,
-0.5049438477,
1.1753277779,
-0.3575741351,
0.400565654,
-0.1969705075,
-0.1984070092,
-0.0373642556,
0.6529384851,
0.6922025681,
0.5527113676,
0.0809682831,
0.5368314385,
0.4438007474,
-0.4816995263,
0.2428387851,
0.1787388474,
-0.2551887631,
-0.1207495481,
0.2155397385,
0.9703832865,
0.0904814973,
-0.3128409982,
0.6245285273,
0.033991836,
-0.3760593832,
-0.2968688309,
0.0152950231,
-0.1538101435,
0.4431726038,
0.1757996529,
0.1732564569,
0.3660811186,
-0.7275435328,
0.3599635661,
0.3860414624,
-0.6854678988,
-0.449806273,
0.7011851072,
0.3382256329,
0.0259042699,
-0.2089560926,
-0.8282176256,
-0.8657020926,
0.604011178,
0.5704797506,
0.7285347581,
-0.1473612636,
0.5334053636,
0.524921298,
0.4774526358,
0.0253179651,
0.6743885279,
-0.0268575065,
-0.8230526447,
-0.3722980618,
-0.7357811928,
-0.2033624798,
0.4836597443,
-0.4955052137,
0.4957643449,
-0.2410263568,
-0.0664679483,
0.3409087956,
-0.0491516925,
-0.6665787101,
0.2436665148,
0.2317174971,
0.258667618,
-1.0903121233,
0.4992869794,
1.2654756308,
-0.1971640289,
-0.6594854593,
-0.0437519327,
0.304282397,
-0.637204349,
0.8352015615,
0.4612872601,
-0.3400140107,
-0.0640186071,
-0.5189496279,
-0.6369579434,
0.7784742713,
0.318560034,
-0.5060429573,
0.1300682425,
-0.0410105288,
0.5755841732,
-0.4023001194,
0.2363791466,
0.4683720469,
0.4355991781,
-0.2329410613,
-1.1884653568,
0.2069305778,
-0.4986392558,
-0.1843709797,
0.4019017816,
-0.5916013718,
0.8623033762,
0.182672143,
-0.2833358347,
-0.2511703372,
0.4805902839,
0.1339958608,
0.488306731,
0.93365556,
0.4120715261,
0.5452342629,
-0.3566412628,
0.5418345928,
0.0002782917,
0.4681996405,
1.0426006317,
0.0179023556,
0.6026082635,
0.1532748938,
-0.3510886729,
0.5106707215,
0.495552808,
-0.1037980691,
0.3671815395,
0.0975009426,
-0.183963269,
-0.6055299044,
-0.5545427203,
-0.2919644713,
0.6392453313,
0.3705075085,
-0.3941188753,
-0.3144024014,
0.5982308984,
0.0917742103,
0.1325687021,
-0.3998077512,
0.6762082577,
-0.0374743976,
-0.7182030678,
0.4520837069,
0.2042468786,
1.0475546122,
-0.2930089533,
-0.1326322109,
0.2307517976,
0.4540307224,
-0.2656515539,
-0.7030701041,
0.1644710004,
-0.031602852,
-0.1774651706,
-0.6001268625,
1.2622227669,
-0.7705757618,
-0.3977277279,
0.3356542289,
0.3655682504,
0.292655468,
-0.2082588524,
-0.7349040508,
0.0982429683,
0.0617590807,
0.1150148362,
0.2198936045,
0.2932501435,
-0.2000354081,
0.5113064051,
0.5314631462,
-0.2135705203,
-0.0890886411,
0.0316790305,
0.5739391446,
-0.4413353205,
-0.5843664408,
-0.7932878733,
0.1232554913,
-0.0931390375,
-0.3894512355,
0.7908392549,
0.3509913683,
1.0059024096,
-0.2195270061,
0.6989355087,
-0.2785906494,
0.6610856652,
-0.3675764203,
0.4027493298,
-0.9014468789,
0.1967464536,
-0.4994532168,
-0.7092278004,
0.0293241423,
0.4224159122,
-0.3431565166,
-0.0854428113,
0.8943632841,
0.7285994887,
0.0163380709,
0.3721729815,
0.3377280235,
0.0099143554,
0.1873524189,
0.4790226817,
0.8108556867,
-0.6272392869,
0.6394138336,
-0.5612002015,
-0.1460572034,
-0.0530265458,
-0.6877157092,
-0.9646584392,
-0.8749665618,
-0.5107774138,
-0.2577624023,
0.2869450748,
0.966193378,
0.7164180875,
-1.0423669815,
0.0409365892,
-0.0411901549,
0.0353152864,
-0.4939052165,
-0.2765161693,
0.0519743301,
-0.5410232544,
-1.0387216806,
0.2181185633,
0.3129571676,
-0.339925468,
-0.1503233612,
0.2668588161,
-0.4331453145,
-0.2689540684,
0.9290708899,
-0.2607025504,
-0.7166460752,
-0.515773952,
0.1062337458,
-0.0371238813,
-0.432297051,
0.6339619756,
-0.2645166516,
0.3031396866,
0.6314593554,
0.4585394561,
0.4084186852,
-0.0657341182,
0.2750855386,
-0.8482909203,
-0.1773619652,
0.1277189106,
0.3641546071,
0.1236761659,
-0.4308576584,
0.6116815805,
0.6349499822,
-0.5753477216,
-0.8394577503,
0.2458372563,
-0.7460393906,
-0.2712485194,
1.1736701727,
-0.1676651537,
-0.1536957175,
-0.6039455533,
-0.3048056364,
0.2619400024,
-0.460868001,
0.5814468861,
0.7815634608,
-0.0899771154,
-0.1505114883,
-0.670625329,
0.5086956024,
0.6806717515,
-1.1546252966,
0.0175602864,
0.4529474676,
0.277271688,
0.2393968105,
0.6287619472,
-0.0299752373,
0.4391521811,
-0.4101793468,
0.0129189137,
0.1202697754,
-0.529296279,
0.1582733542,
0.4417005777,
-0.6926659346,
-0.3310404718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03902v1 | Utterance Classification with Logical Neural Network: Explainable AI for Mental Disorder Diagnosis | 2023-06-06T17:58:44 | 2023-06-06T17:58:44 | Yeldar Toleubay, Don Joven Agravante, Daiki Kimura, Baihan Lin, Djallel Bouneffouf, Michiaki Tatsubori | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO, q-bio.NC | In response to the global challenge of mental health problems, we proposes a
Logical Neural Network (LNN) based Neuro-Symbolic AI method for the diagnosis
of mental disorders. Due to the lack of effective therapy coverage for mental
disorders, there is a need for an AI solution that can assist therapists with
the diagnosis. However, current Neural Network models lack explainability and
may not be trusted by therapists. The LNN is a Recurrent Neural Network
architecture that combines the learning capabilities of neural networks with
the reasoning capabilities of classical logic-based AI. The proposed system
uses input predicates from clinical interviews to output a mental disorder
class, and different predicate pruning techniques are used to achieve
scalability and higher scores. In addition, we provide an insight extraction
method to aid therapists with their diagnosis. The proposed system addresses
the lack of explainability of current Neural Network models and provides a more
trustworthy solution for mental disorder diagnosis. | [
-0.3114571869,
-0.8642597198,
0.7606554031,
0.0756072551,
-0.1723388284,
-0.2011722475,
-0.1054791957,
-0.6551316977,
0.4244153798,
0.2333412021,
-0.8109979033,
-0.3491818607,
-0.6733295918,
0.0856926143,
-0.6431831717,
0.8745474219,
0.3340294957,
0.2544400096,
-0.2177089155,
-0.1550108045,
-0.7033755779,
-0.5253735185,
-1.280298233,
-0.4935781062,
0.5204120874,
0.0814939365,
0.722445786,
0.4698060751,
0.5576390624,
0.4790505767,
-0.0442755222,
0.2492683977,
-0.0900137946,
0.1850182414,
-0.2142102122,
-0.3734517097,
-0.7460915446,
-0.1094145253,
0.1768336594,
0.7284064889,
-0.3284879327,
0.1733009219,
-0.2434093207,
0.4120495021,
-0.1445553601,
0.2606272995,
-0.2327975482,
0.6165269613,
0.0628537834,
-0.0458158329,
-0.3798648119,
-0.3461499214,
0.2891891599,
-0.6816419959,
0.1535092145,
-0.0457836054,
0.3311649561,
0.5185388923,
-0.1764198095,
-0.0433506295,
-0.740239203,
0.5076040626,
-0.8028864264,
0.304105401,
0.3598612249,
0.4649102986,
-0.0618183427,
-0.8159608245,
-0.6890303493,
-0.2316254824,
-0.0757657662,
0.0044934256,
-0.350990504,
0.2050146312,
0.4022879601,
0.2069911212,
-0.7833589911,
0.0579227544,
-0.3099196255,
-0.4830465317,
0.6300022602,
0.260995239,
0.6105520725,
0.026222242,
-0.0403072275,
0.4567212462,
-0.1632321924,
-0.2241655886,
-0.1541225016,
0.1139499769,
0.2633604705,
0.3667281866,
-0.1499356925,
0.7860777378,
0.0339175873,
-0.3913910687,
0.1973060817,
0.0045668827,
-0.4136050045,
0.7343431115,
0.8000568151,
0.3424016535,
0.2948198915,
-0.1578728408,
-0.1602232456,
0.385245949,
0.3376749456,
-0.6439256668,
-0.3051128387,
0.2366399616,
-0.7584915161,
-0.2471788824,
-0.4379939735,
-0.3428954482,
-0.8012650609,
-0.6644197702,
0.3446711004,
-0.6821855307,
-0.5230586529,
0.1315880418,
-0.1750031412,
0.0288213119,
0.533056438,
-0.6469185948,
0.3494006395,
0.5873633027,
0.758420527,
-0.0519819669,
0.0073572751,
-0.2205912769,
-0.3310687244,
-0.2030525506,
0.5274990797,
-0.178235054,
0.0486753061,
-0.2912965417,
-0.0573970154,
-0.1020307019,
-0.7638770342,
0.4272700548,
-0.3692756891,
0.086373806,
0.0673653558,
-0.5284691453,
-0.4553394914,
0.2939171791,
-0.6358993053,
0.5244581699,
0.3268952072,
-0.6990343332,
0.1337750256,
-0.7652394176,
-0.3117460907,
0.2684859931,
-0.2696293592,
-0.1410999596,
0.0320195332,
-0.0085899895,
0.4485640824,
-0.3841525614,
0.6427450776,
-0.4333660305,
-0.3905528784,
0.4318038821,
-0.6133998632,
1.0590347052,
0.4657360613,
-0.3089986145,
0.4547174275,
-0.9171450734,
0.2780556083,
0.2217350006,
0.0876178741,
-0.06032544,
0.2736246884,
-0.2320924103,
0.2064338028,
0.15581806,
-0.4821434617,
-0.2180549949,
-0.6234215498,
0.6177788973,
0.5604543686,
-0.0888908803,
-0.1160068512,
-0.5534883142,
0.5358635783,
0.476052314,
0.0733084381,
0.1288425624,
-0.6813313365,
-0.760638833,
-0.3301618397,
0.1808270067,
1.1725649834,
-0.4289136231,
0.880438149,
-0.1564779282,
-0.1481269747,
-0.7863487601,
-0.0163048897,
0.3100579977,
0.9527603984,
0.3446649313,
-0.1216874942,
-0.7187931538,
-1.1028826237,
-0.1599600464,
-0.0667349249,
0.0748029128,
0.0244272538,
0.3364886642,
-0.1921005547,
0.7086372375,
-0.2664760351,
-0.3421148956,
-0.3853646815,
0.0040289783,
0.4459074438,
0.497859627,
0.253102541,
-0.7004611492,
-0.0541779213,
0.1678479761,
-1.1782957315,
0.138656944,
0.0770803988,
0.2573118508,
0.0479390435,
0.6537274122,
-0.7098724842,
0.7855499983,
-0.061359819,
-0.5090807676,
0.4621150196,
-0.2705054283,
-0.1117873713,
-0.9896987677,
-0.1687291563,
-0.0306185987,
-0.5335817933,
-0.6117031574,
-0.3134765327,
-0.3704011738,
-0.2947966158,
-0.2997990847,
-0.0231910124,
0.0559985228,
0.0567458048,
-0.2247077078,
0.2731892765,
0.0475686863,
0.3641719222,
-0.0803317279,
0.1718043238,
0.7077893019,
-0.5224667788,
0.9879980683,
0.1205996946,
-0.3746863902,
0.7061111927,
-0.549292624,
0.1161629111,
-0.2859481573,
0.2146447599,
-0.717158854,
-0.1034556702,
0.5217701793,
-0.5646346211,
0.341085583,
0.328240186,
-0.2185197175,
-0.2172069401,
0.4015765786,
0.6422000527,
0.3108256757,
-0.3822010458,
0.4193150699,
0.1703555733,
-0.065291442,
-0.3950010538,
-0.7978033423,
0.0269697588,
-0.3830184937,
-0.6133805513,
0.2903452218,
-0.0193593632,
-0.4752227366,
0.1361492574,
-0.0331432037,
-0.1517758965,
0.4082312882,
0.1572594345,
0.244575128,
-0.6148763895,
0.356672287,
-0.1036083177,
-0.3515299559,
0.5639972687,
-0.3563335836,
0.3934098482,
-0.4435141385,
-0.3900534511,
-1.0235824585,
0.7570051551,
0.6812778711,
-0.2163605988,
0.7595100999,
0.5021606684,
-0.7245909572,
-0.4793839157,
-0.0402304977,
-0.1661145389,
-0.4284036458,
0.5615056157,
-0.3120080531,
-0.5144451857,
0.4883153737,
-0.1240086555,
-0.5110056996,
0.3298611641,
0.310795933,
-0.2156437337,
1.5295950174,
0.2345970273,
-0.0942241326,
0.1819151342,
-0.0465356745,
0.7150281072,
-0.4281003773,
-0.158533901,
-0.200450018,
-0.5414950848,
-0.5828368664,
0.1138258278,
0.249081552,
0.0805095583,
-0.65534693,
-0.2639517486,
-0.990382731,
0.2285954058,
0.5080615282,
0.4945806265,
0.1263173968,
-0.2369735539,
0.0683486089,
-0.1361486614,
-0.6040168405,
-0.2089442313,
0.6278143525,
0.3135095239,
0.313082099,
0.3217454255,
0.4914360642,
0.5251057148,
0.4243017733,
-1.2199137211,
0.6388806701,
-0.0193563197,
-0.5334425569,
-0.3260984123,
-0.4439473152,
-0.6974391937,
0.07091216,
-0.100760974,
-1.0490624905,
0.1577066779,
0.0820137188,
-0.6145241261,
0.2744155526,
-0.6374436617,
0.992393136,
-0.4059267342,
0.4271006286,
-0.4177255929,
-0.7454815507,
0.6333302855,
0.0522462875,
-0.0079467865,
-0.1113151982,
0.378038615,
1.0107936859,
-0.5790879726,
0.78529495,
-0.3668554723,
0.1710414141,
0.0848907605,
0.0726297498,
-0.0667668357,
0.0581056327,
-0.1307354718,
-0.0498137102,
0.0908820704,
-0.0360313877,
-1.1796309948,
0.4826882482,
-0.7671477795,
-0.7273032665,
-0.4300990403,
-0.581697762,
-0.491618365,
0.4573483765,
0.2233740389,
0.678525269,
0.1442351639,
-0.017346086,
0.8852294683,
-0.2510296404,
0.3268947899,
0.1477232575,
-0.3754864335,
-0.3827132881,
0.9595665336,
0.1360388845,
-0.1162883341,
0.054655835,
0.2646209598,
-0.102926679,
-0.7444620728,
-0.1486147195,
0.1660505831,
-0.8080049753,
-0.2977935076,
-0.1959811002,
-0.8406251669,
-0.4917402565,
0.2139731497,
-0.223163113,
-0.4233571589,
-0.3683893085,
-0.382741183,
0.5000163317,
0.6914941072,
0.0336945206,
0.2059357017,
-0.5714986324,
0.5942665935,
0.1325722337,
0.3045500517,
0.1792873591,
-0.486105442,
-0.0497448109,
0.0714295432,
-0.2892433107,
-1.0341638327,
0.4908121526,
0.2171872258,
0.592877984,
0.9268605113,
0.2394612432,
0.7532336712,
-0.2639044821,
0.4655589759,
0.4242566228,
-0.9061499238,
0.8934533,
0.0006132441,
-0.0695349649,
0.3268013299,
0.6474919915,
-0.5604149103,
-0.1320827752,
-0.7618073821,
-0.544347167,
0.8788601756,
-0.1758386344,
-0.4145253897,
-0.1792098731,
0.4398638606,
-0.150945276,
-0.0291367564,
-0.5835566521,
-0.6753412485,
-0.4252667427,
-0.7273293734,
-0.1072863638,
0.0045354161,
-0.4465662241,
-0.7271754742,
0.4815943837,
-0.1044980958,
0.7189515829,
0.6873333454,
-0.1034562588,
0.3074160516,
0.0978035629,
0.6895204782,
0.6245865226,
-0.234124288,
0.0810847133,
0.1006413624,
-0.4405232072,
0.1914889961,
0.1583158672,
0.0472440533,
0.022240052,
0.3898743987,
1.0686590672,
-0.2647344172,
-0.6169854403,
0.5461515188,
-0.2280545235,
-0.5524650216,
-0.7062273622,
0.2360888273,
0.1949891001,
0.5248458385,
-0.0996899605,
0.5199748278,
0.3133010864,
-0.4827790558,
0.1519718915,
0.2559638321,
-0.6395899653,
-0.232454434,
0.36965397,
-0.0658405945,
-0.9894218445,
1.3129885197,
-0.3054508567,
-0.5242862701,
0.7929026484,
0.9530879259,
0.8698254824,
-0.0717822239,
0.2217458189,
0.049129881,
0.1139311045,
0.1269194782,
0.4839884043,
-0.2045843005,
-1.0949976444,
-0.2502576113,
-0.4159208536,
-0.1637739092,
0.6448600292,
-0.9330791831,
-0.1057708785,
-0.8431577086,
-0.3252275288,
0.1568885595,
-0.1443487853,
-0.4215067327,
0.542683661,
0.548799932,
0.8581950665,
-0.5339329243,
0.8639546037,
0.6047579646,
-0.213599503,
-0.902089715,
-0.3951737583,
0.1779107302,
-0.555881381,
0.5962367058,
0.4043598175,
0.0123809474,
0.0305725355,
-0.3795455694,
-0.7406821847,
0.9744618535,
0.6142003536,
-0.2453158051,
-0.0092805494,
0.0131181795,
0.500472784,
-0.4812170863,
0.3321546912,
0.883430481,
0.7062797546,
-0.1705255508,
-0.9571929574,
0.1753116995,
-0.5451766253,
-0.2608804405,
0.1479112953,
-0.0478060171,
0.5446550846,
-0.2907131314,
-0.1901651919,
0.0847723112,
0.7609401345,
0.2943594754,
0.6388283968,
0.7211803794,
0.8761027455,
1.2314451933,
-0.1271135658,
0.9571599364,
-0.1153272465,
-0.1522918046,
0.9826831818,
-0.074067466,
0.7103261948,
0.0975782052,
-0.1778675467,
0.5031015873,
0.6372670531,
0.2068662643,
0.1842558533,
0.5604765415,
-0.4779040515,
-0.3120999634,
-0.2273987681,
-0.4409420192,
0.6067202687,
0.8424888253,
-0.5465823412,
-0.0781934634,
0.2044551969,
-0.1180474237,
-0.1343092173,
-0.5126312971,
0.7763431072,
0.2207537591,
-0.5940933824,
0.5177951455,
-0.1751959324,
0.2942797244,
-0.4746372104,
-0.0684760064,
0.0358672105,
0.4693710506,
-0.4507712722,
-0.3654312789,
0.6725673676,
-0.3775660098,
-0.4705542028,
-0.2938632369,
0.7389557958,
-0.1888422221,
-0.5015457869,
0.3360732794,
0.4880552292,
0.3776954412,
-0.0791877061,
-0.913827002,
-0.3946006,
-0.1067673042,
0.0838354453,
0.2671554387,
0.6059960127,
-0.2153514177,
0.82278198,
0.4520789981,
0.2621515691,
-0.0030145955,
0.1981262863,
0.369217664,
-0.9913254976,
-0.3355499506,
-0.7750252485,
0.2677031159,
-0.1248291433,
-0.3191637993,
0.2255833745,
0.0365766026,
0.3618867695,
0.1272067726,
0.7064169645,
-0.0015960914,
0.5651381016,
-0.1755742133,
1.0220942497,
-0.5864433646,
0.0738939568,
0.0243911967,
-0.4346909821,
-0.464779824,
0.8369828463,
0.0162470024,
0.0803563073,
0.9715933204,
0.6707757711,
0.0905412138,
0.5228155255,
0.3947334886,
0.4204846919,
0.1645389497,
0.6508478522,
1.050968647,
-0.1331186593,
0.1229696348,
-0.2373519689,
-0.240164578,
0.060887225,
-0.732060492,
-0.4912187457,
-0.5464092493,
-0.5047785044,
-0.3616311252,
0.0134857381,
0.8978974819,
0.861995697,
-0.8854116201,
0.176315546,
-0.3047559559,
0.4132034481,
-0.5641178489,
-0.3262097239,
0.2846283913,
-0.32338202,
-0.286506623,
0.7065215707,
0.128279224,
-0.2161290944,
-0.2513719201,
0.0446333028,
-0.012106278,
-0.128511399,
0.5093695521,
0.2412923425,
-0.8285763264,
-0.1715465486,
-0.2165684402,
0.1142500713,
0.00813819,
0.623214066,
-1.0920784473,
0.2185334861,
0.4333917201,
0.8979910612,
-0.1354223639,
-0.1781031787,
0.6692528129,
-0.0611181855,
0.0892178342,
0.5434438586,
0.5400139093,
0.1108808368,
-0.6792029738,
0.0345064476,
0.3117847443,
-0.53821522,
-0.7876061201,
0.1701328754,
-1.1793625355,
-0.2828519642,
0.5727024078,
-0.3735998273,
-0.405090183,
-0.5436371565,
-0.1718962044,
0.3489208221,
-0.0316212438,
0.5089868307,
0.4136248231,
-0.7365936637,
-0.221223861,
-0.5789133906,
0.5050276518,
0.6024338603,
-0.5744079947,
-0.3643426299,
0.3370208144,
0.162626192,
0.3058774173,
0.5122277737,
-0.0108104497,
0.5743649006,
-0.0950024948,
-0.1142319739,
-0.1614745557,
-0.339173466,
-0.3698033094,
0.2452351004,
-0.0906135142,
-0.33051157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03901v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03901v2 | ChatDB: Augmenting LLMs with Databases as Their Symbolic Memory | 2023-06-06T17:58:24 | 2023-06-07T17:22:22 | Chenxu Hu, Jie Fu, Chenzhuang Du, Simian Luo, Junbo Zhao, Hang Zhao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) with memory are computationally universal.
However, mainstream LLMs are not taking full advantage of memory, and the
designs are heavily influenced by biological brains. Due to their approximate
nature and proneness to the accumulation of errors, conventional neural memory
mechanisms cannot support LLMs to simulate complex reasoning. In this paper, we
seek inspiration from modern computer architectures to augment LLMs with
symbolic memory for complex multi-hop reasoning. Such a symbolic memory
framework is instantiated as an LLM and a set of SQL databases, where the LLM
generates SQL instructions to manipulate the SQL databases. We validate the
effectiveness of the proposed memory framework on a synthetic dataset requiring
complex reasoning. The project website is available at
https://chatdatabase.github.io/ . | [
-0.2516304255,
-1.2456425428,
0.7802235484,
0.3671751916,
0.0096145673,
0.3741513789,
-0.2929433286,
-0.5658105016,
0.416059047,
0.570117414,
-0.7073378563,
-0.3632751405,
-0.0888477638,
-0.0946952775,
-0.5301010609,
0.3588756025,
0.1622339785,
0.2604153752,
-0.2239426672,
-0.1381503642,
-0.6971205473,
-1.0335222483,
-0.4739606678,
-0.0756486505,
0.3607870638,
0.3910062909,
0.7744632363,
0.477711916,
0.3700209856,
0.3020201325,
-0.0581641123,
0.6755482554,
-0.5382820964,
0.5422853231,
-0.0408876315,
-0.6782159209,
-0.6413735747,
-0.6233198643,
0.5827808976,
0.9322703481,
-0.3443241119,
-0.2922875285,
-0.3800066411,
0.6080395579,
-0.4274995029,
0.3001437485,
-0.8998781443,
-0.1007618979,
-0.1589391679,
-0.1910990477,
-0.5597023964,
-0.4176407754,
-0.0646891445,
-0.4973419905,
-0.1567539573,
0.4065804183,
0.3815384209,
0.1710587144,
-0.2883165479,
-0.3048651218,
-1.0086489916,
0.5938876867,
-0.5095331669,
0.4757326543,
-0.019170763,
0.5704769492,
-0.7553639412,
-0.570450604,
-0.5496160388,
-0.2348157316,
0.1078027338,
-0.3733671904,
0.0210157428,
0.2954695523,
0.4661379755,
0.1189784259,
-0.4014675915,
-0.1908505261,
-0.372197181,
-0.0195559561,
0.4751036465,
0.4891910851,
0.4372694194,
0.192451179,
-0.2161740959,
0.2235585898,
-0.8991898298,
-0.3194425106,
0.2327248603,
0.3955481052,
0.1538719237,
0.7774671912,
-0.1991065592,
0.9543340802,
-0.1646793783,
0.2085736096,
0.2053706497,
-0.1600737423,
-0.2195070833,
0.3061214089,
0.6896266937,
0.1538861692,
0.5346329212,
-0.4662485719,
-0.0753437728,
0.1260336936,
0.4541701972,
-0.7165881395,
-0.1841616184,
0.6037596464,
-0.2229811996,
-0.0847060829,
-0.2861681879,
-0.5750259757,
-0.5607520938,
-0.3108049929,
0.3985335231,
-0.9239068627,
-0.202353552,
0.3205203414,
-0.1011177078,
0.104140982,
0.4076398909,
-0.6979555488,
0.3428076506,
0.7732951045,
0.6573156118,
-0.0828794166,
-0.1624876708,
-0.1097510308,
0.5372058749,
-0.5213250518,
0.9450498223,
-0.6788758636,
-0.434188664,
-0.1357126832,
-0.0304594561,
0.1801624149,
-0.515999198,
0.5351609588,
-0.5438843369,
-0.0742634162,
-0.2774299383,
-0.7767211795,
-0.1353230625,
0.1873293221,
-0.7587835193,
0.8816660643,
-0.0908837616,
-0.365185231,
0.0053510428,
-0.7433245778,
-0.6173622012,
-0.1315098405,
-0.2818196714,
-0.1228532493,
0.0124016944,
0.0658753142,
0.3113591373,
-0.5180285573,
0.5303157568,
-0.7768313289,
-0.6770704389,
0.5042473674,
-0.2897457778,
0.8556240201,
0.2498634309,
0.1111380011,
0.0131923361,
-0.8275437951,
-0.0623895042,
0.1903282255,
-0.3563610911,
-0.3001055717,
0.3523334861,
-0.3165778816,
0.0510745533,
0.0697346702,
-0.4191659391,
0.4673044682,
-0.4939247966,
0.4714026153,
0.6190574169,
0.0259286258,
0.4160832763,
-0.3280103207,
0.2588864565,
0.3658381999,
0.0937148258,
-0.3733228743,
-0.2984553874,
-0.7724161744,
-0.2976520061,
-0.0031493956,
0.5957698226,
-0.6645904183,
0.3352550566,
-0.2861200571,
-0.3549155593,
-0.1704593003,
0.0184156187,
-0.0789144784,
0.1788158566,
0.4986512959,
-0.0587091073,
-1.0522985458,
-0.7692092061,
-0.3629087508,
-0.0815374181,
-0.0995896086,
0.4663206637,
0.1164809987,
-0.1495864242,
0.7092219591,
-0.3146307468,
-0.1143291295,
-0.0609530769,
-0.4311882257,
0.5323580503,
0.4353343546,
0.3764896393,
-0.2712743878,
0.0410124995,
-0.4553868473,
-0.9826002717,
0.0948794559,
-0.4625883102,
-0.4943001568,
0.186484322,
0.5877556801,
-1.3333375454,
-0.0430538803,
0.1827434301,
-0.3913396299,
0.7575150132,
-0.0985688493,
0.1481059343,
-0.9933573008,
-0.3820285201,
-0.2550293207,
-0.0784649998,
-0.5796224475,
-0.1000461653,
0.0407387204,
-0.0238639303,
-0.3816898465,
0.5719009638,
-0.8026507497,
-0.0713601559,
-0.0122491959,
0.0915137678,
-0.1162901819,
0.4608106315,
-0.011914094,
0.6327881217,
0.8834463954,
-0.5966891646,
0.7834163904,
0.0449455306,
-0.1940144449,
0.914373219,
-0.5942541361,
-0.0539819188,
-0.2090093642,
0.4498517513,
-1.1349606514,
-0.4265235364,
0.1026334837,
-0.3595089018,
0.3581265211,
-0.0347568691,
-0.6938548088,
-0.3344079256,
-0.1713265628,
0.0148827937,
0.3823070228,
-0.6345260143,
1.0058146715,
0.4777630568,
0.1574643403,
-0.4375111163,
-0.8382707238,
0.3606207371,
-0.1770343632,
-0.6919915676,
0.1804610193,
0.041794613,
-0.411647737,
-0.0054450794,
0.060459394,
-0.1817215085,
0.000471725,
0.4438202679,
0.4875648022,
-0.475289911,
0.5245956779,
0.238582164,
0.1785754263,
0.3403433561,
-0.1570878625,
0.7378533483,
-0.1499626338,
-0.682585299,
-0.1353655905,
0.3090789914,
0.6763657928,
0.1544129848,
1.0113339424,
0.0892248303,
-0.4925803542,
-0.3337880373,
-0.6396968961,
-0.3841053545,
-0.4679100811,
0.3607490063,
-0.509032011,
-0.7953186035,
0.4520770311,
-0.4353491366,
0.1153618842,
0.1825767606,
0.6590122581,
-0.5271090269,
0.8231655359,
-0.3315904438,
0.1503432542,
0.2088003904,
-0.0708020627,
0.2288648486,
-0.6716575027,
-0.2699878812,
-0.4283058941,
-0.4221820831,
-0.2300450057,
-0.8613906503,
0.1120510846,
0.1965622902,
-0.5810658932,
0.208185643,
-0.4306390584,
0.6497056484,
0.231317088,
0.1741575152,
0.4018360078,
0.0632166043,
-0.2641987205,
0.1985153854,
-0.6604897976,
-0.4090980887,
1.0770175457,
0.2428561747,
1.1801950932,
0.1047799364,
0.3564036787,
0.1381102651,
0.1542221606,
-0.5505747199,
0.8412742615,
0.1036241874,
-0.8261954784,
-0.0656052902,
-0.383009851,
-0.9155524373,
0.2571519315,
-0.3920559585,
-0.6718969941,
0.0503099486,
0.2272657305,
-0.0945635438,
0.4068869054,
-0.8841046691,
0.5537949204,
-0.553608954,
-0.2159139067,
-0.4700554311,
-0.5106603503,
0.8195077181,
0.0101978006,
0.1508145034,
-0.17491588,
-0.0371248238,
0.3767397106,
-0.4489342272,
1.0273554325,
-0.212471053,
0.2579541802,
0.4633987546,
0.4045719504,
0.522769928,
-0.0822603405,
-0.1431573033,
0.2841673791,
0.1377753019,
-0.2957145274,
-0.5272413492,
0.9031589627,
-0.5920230746,
-0.5886436105,
-0.2451209426,
-0.8100040555,
-0.7032462358,
-0.011534485,
-0.6163568497,
0.2598100007,
-0.2439758927,
0.5313130617,
0.7218674421,
-0.3179149032,
0.1172754839,
0.2972717285,
-0.4593171179,
-0.1676760912,
0.588188827,
-0.0480975695,
0.181220293,
0.2440852374,
-0.1917742789,
-0.4998481274,
-0.3254727125,
-0.5101240873,
0.2362706959,
-0.6245697141,
-0.2776924372,
-0.840550065,
-0.3199302256,
-0.0052704434,
0.0405175127,
-0.448623836,
-0.811868906,
-0.1328362674,
-0.2097124159,
0.8464455009,
0.1844172329,
0.1344204396,
0.3677454293,
-0.9386585951,
0.3770235181,
0.0582684465,
0.4666985869,
0.2305088192,
-0.1456318498,
0.0133954482,
0.2549859583,
-0.0881581157,
-1.0221031904,
0.1929827482,
0.2266474068,
0.8115576506,
0.1384841353,
-0.1637838334,
0.8848742247,
-0.5515828729,
0.503582716,
0.1398468763,
-0.7408988476,
0.4799014628,
-0.359755218,
0.0795425549,
0.1074886844,
0.4467495978,
-0.3434498906,
-0.5080892444,
-0.5939126015,
-0.5841730237,
0.4067557752,
0.0903640464,
0.2356654853,
-0.0916558579,
0.455714345,
-0.2503454387,
0.1207168773,
-0.2638926208,
-0.4071344137,
0.1176309139,
-0.2250084579,
0.3797867,
-0.297652334,
-0.0390364081,
-0.2181303352,
0.4059563279,
-0.0473979861,
0.3705436289,
-0.142478019,
-0.0639930293,
0.0803995952,
0.1736807078,
0.1831701696,
0.6478948593,
-0.0925455689,
0.2523669899,
0.3586617708,
-0.3226639032,
0.1449328065,
-0.1366580576,
-0.0005432051,
0.1453148872,
-0.0054973876,
0.6785993576,
0.2331748307,
-1.0400170088,
0.0127644846,
-0.1040262282,
-0.0985377803,
-0.3997355998,
0.4708661735,
0.993712008,
0.3958773017,
0.1665561795,
0.1257525533,
-0.0154849496,
-0.5987439156,
0.2030219436,
0.7278462052,
-0.2134036124,
-0.0880718827,
0.6039914489,
0.0159427915,
-0.3696602285,
0.6603257656,
0.1043011397,
-0.1737594455,
0.42554456,
0.6482803822,
0.5182153583,
-0.3594142795,
-0.3285313249,
0.5826570988,
0.3096297085,
-0.1094940752,
0.6311600804,
0.1443559229,
-0.9887306094,
-0.5743115544,
-0.7071412802,
-0.5595543385,
-0.261539489,
0.0571001172,
0.4067396224,
-0.6048821807,
-0.0585534833,
-0.1176203936,
-0.408485949,
-0.3370193839,
0.0863500759,
0.0815600529,
1.0934134722,
-0.3754588068,
1.2817081213,
0.3297403753,
-0.2382763624,
-0.6930836439,
-0.5776976943,
0.1173525155,
-0.9047265053,
0.4042107165,
-0.2040019333,
-0.1251808703,
-0.2185078859,
-0.4632595479,
-0.7179426551,
0.8681676984,
0.6177169085,
-0.7629754543,
-0.0803750902,
0.2180293798,
0.5617927313,
-0.3507441878,
0.3496530354,
0.6187202334,
0.4055600762,
0.6055997014,
-0.510789752,
0.1430247575,
-0.0271738172,
-0.0038205404,
0.2118217647,
-0.2591674626,
0.7410401106,
-0.5566315055,
-0.1333358139,
-0.1586102247,
0.6758952141,
0.8816756606,
-0.3012733161,
0.5073189139,
0.4907028973,
0.8335257769,
-0.1853474081,
1.0022341013,
-0.4044292271,
-0.0037098175,
1.4274106026,
-0.4429841042,
0.8115819693,
0.6400941014,
-0.3925142586,
0.6048079133,
0.5962961316,
0.155805096,
0.096160762,
0.2713413537,
-0.214961797,
-0.4821846783,
0.0253517553,
-0.2493738681,
0.2650592327,
0.9624487162,
-0.1962109208,
-0.162087366,
-0.4630975425,
-0.0397178642,
-0.3394849598,
-0.0294000227,
0.6131868958,
0.2452795953,
-0.3776959479,
0.7446222305,
-0.1906833351,
0.4868991077,
-0.5991746783,
-0.2146039456,
-0.1637118161,
0.2888283134,
-0.2369315922,
-0.9287913442,
0.6729635596,
-0.1440237164,
0.2079972774,
-0.0474487022,
0.9684765339,
-0.4476671517,
-0.3994502425,
0.2490027994,
0.6560034156,
0.1601472199,
-0.2306699753,
-0.67751652,
0.1074511483,
-0.1844028831,
-0.2963087857,
0.3339171112,
0.8168241382,
-0.1385308355,
0.9672379494,
1.1081035137,
0.2848885953,
0.3034453988,
0.1134200543,
0.9488971233,
-0.8608644009,
-0.4117822051,
-1.1607251167,
0.1614464372,
-0.2837384939,
0.356182456,
0.6978099942,
0.7493796945,
0.3761702776,
-0.2926039398,
0.4670116007,
-0.0191596672,
0.5641621947,
-0.4298096597,
0.6228180528,
-0.4022317231,
0.5261158943,
0.0338006914,
-1.0324031115,
-0.4584542811,
0.5715524554,
0.0754359961,
-0.1308841109,
0.6800127625,
1.1873681545,
-0.1118822917,
0.3869303465,
0.2305814177,
0.6216623783,
0.3510577083,
0.7819345593,
1.0934196711,
-0.0955944583,
0.6091296077,
0.0978959873,
0.0967875421,
-0.1909456551,
-0.7992801666,
-0.8682813048,
-0.3539921939,
-0.0093482854,
-0.6051135063,
0.1273885965,
1.0203200579,
0.6662858129,
-0.7300133705,
-0.4507192671,
-0.1187816337,
0.3356181085,
-0.0428166687,
-0.2332934737,
0.115407005,
-0.5448701978,
-0.4788479507,
0.369386375,
0.5589219332,
-0.0735779405,
-0.5685485601,
-0.0718908608,
-0.3864276111,
0.3262686431,
0.8550394773,
0.1307639927,
-0.5827839375,
-0.1278718114,
0.0700226799,
-0.3517359197,
0.2744325101,
0.6594758034,
-0.834461689,
0.3396292329,
0.6016241908,
0.7753590345,
0.5220727324,
-0.2214070112,
0.6108312607,
-0.517072022,
0.1767360568,
0.291283071,
0.6999109983,
0.1492884606,
-0.3139835298,
0.4571532905,
0.2656899691,
-0.2469589114,
-0.7142045498,
0.0401662439,
-1.2275447845,
-0.5833469033,
1.0889109373,
0.2218175232,
-0.6054733992,
-0.2853150666,
-0.3661297262,
-0.1143492386,
-0.312109679,
0.6516833901,
0.6464412212,
-0.4126468897,
-0.2683548331,
-0.4677490294,
0.2869909406,
0.0513667837,
-1.0673555136,
0.2747824788,
0.9519053102,
0.1499199867,
-0.0326510519,
0.7919863462,
-0.2473578304,
0.2435985953,
0.1762804538,
0.1564383656,
-0.058042068,
-0.3198180795,
0.1426879913,
0.2546316385,
-0.0073217074,
-0.0087373964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03882v2 | Causal interventions expose implicit situation models for commonsense language understanding | 2023-06-06T17:36:43 | 2023-06-07T13:17:04 | Takateru Yamakoshi, James L. McClelland, Adele E. Goldberg, Robert D. Hawkins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Accounts of human language processing have long appealed to implicit
``situation models'' that enrich comprehension with relevant but unstated world
knowledge. Here, we apply causal intervention techniques to recent transformer
models to analyze performance on the Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC), where a
single context cue shifts interpretation of an ambiguous pronoun. We identify a
relatively small circuit of attention heads that are responsible for
propagating information from the context word that guides which of the
candidate noun phrases the pronoun ultimately attends to. We then compare how
this circuit behaves in a closely matched ``syntactic'' control where the
situation model is not strictly necessary. These analyses suggest distinct
pathways through which implicit situation models are constructed to guide
pronoun resolution. | [
-0.1157718077,
-0.7705982924,
0.8176397085,
0.0669481978,
0.1249957383,
-0.3191739321,
-0.1872676611,
-0.3692706525,
-0.4423363209,
0.5440661907,
-0.7745087743,
-0.0880385339,
-0.7635341883,
0.1130973473,
-0.2487458587,
1.0204021931,
-0.0675938204,
-0.1620757878,
-0.1727149338,
-0.0507921614,
-0.9757606983,
-0.2307762653,
-0.5874789357,
-0.2852856815,
0.7551675439,
0.4545342028,
0.8625739813,
0.2908801436,
0.6742317677,
0.4389747679,
-0.4620386362,
-0.1284428388,
-0.3402025998,
0.1594665796,
-0.6600425243,
-0.4625221789,
-0.0028616455,
0.275182873,
0.5565850735,
1.2084167004,
-0.2580297291,
0.1354814321,
-0.0214468781,
0.330806464,
-0.7588416338,
0.2340804189,
-0.5887283683,
-0.1907357424,
-0.0539890453,
-0.0772865042,
-0.6739214659,
-0.2235252857,
0.2500630021,
-0.6904383898,
0.5375341177,
0.2458266318,
0.7200623155,
0.4448699951,
-0.7755925059,
-0.0979034081,
-1.053432107,
0.5716968179,
-0.3484465182,
0.2980612218,
-0.0193550494,
0.3619585335,
-0.7079416513,
-0.8638949394,
-0.759231925,
-0.0115983095,
-0.5476713181,
0.1464396119,
-0.5517165065,
0.2105806619,
0.3582301438,
-0.1698283851,
-0.2554594278,
-0.0318739675,
-0.7962522507,
-0.2546720803,
0.2816231847,
0.2378525287,
0.0761322826,
-0.4099650681,
-0.2663486302,
-0.0933270901,
-0.622838974,
0.3011732101,
0.2337433696,
0.4113555849,
-0.0277924109,
0.6329296827,
-0.0703508332,
0.8426804543,
0.259765625,
0.1366394907,
-0.1216676012,
-0.2280702442,
-0.3443157971,
0.2599480152,
0.3831115663,
0.0565079413,
0.1800185591,
-0.0701077431,
0.1270219982,
0.2604004443,
0.5013653636,
-0.3170878291,
-0.0188860111,
0.1814259738,
-0.2398630977,
-0.3468082547,
0.1052851751,
-0.3151364625,
-0.1563513577,
-0.6435637474,
0.4909781516,
-0.0997492522,
-0.2743619084,
0.2228928059,
-0.3877538741,
0.3024865687,
0.2154526711,
-0.6413865089,
0.2152202129,
0.7360388637,
0.493816644,
0.1826770157,
-0.3818342686,
-0.5871775746,
0.4442619383,
-0.4735358655,
0.9865292907,
-0.700196743,
-0.276655525,
-0.0922066942,
0.5055884123,
-0.4934616089,
-0.2877559066,
0.5970408916,
-0.4309739172,
0.3592807055,
-0.4760015011,
-0.1580823958,
-0.0898932144,
-0.1265129596,
-0.651165247,
0.7889104486,
0.0142166503,
-1.1963803768,
0.3786866963,
-0.6728407145,
-0.4751536548,
-0.0885470137,
0.118738018,
0.1026378646,
0.5391501188,
-0.0206598956,
0.3587496281,
-0.0114510823,
0.7116085887,
0.0025482948,
-0.4894050658,
0.1740820557,
-0.462619096,
0.5409054756,
-0.1762784719,
-0.2730810642,
0.5405558944,
-0.503944695,
-0.5566374063,
0.2865388691,
0.3186836243,
-0.7394768,
0.1473259777,
-0.1368275583,
0.5675979853,
-0.1304122955,
-0.4470561445,
0.0080451462,
-0.2629845142,
0.38559255,
0.7427859902,
0.3880650699,
0.46175161,
0.1438032091,
0.2641663849,
0.0922177806,
0.443250984,
-0.0489990078,
-0.4488078356,
-0.7378013134,
0.0940847099,
0.044437401,
0.4322793484,
-0.5836474895,
-0.1653849632,
-0.1508451402,
-0.08603248,
-0.6143512726,
-0.3869817257,
0.4151036441,
0.7867860794,
0.3449293971,
0.305706799,
-0.3173745871,
-1.3033602238,
-0.4354074299,
-0.2935374081,
0.0271059591,
0.1697952002,
0.4797845781,
0.1102599055,
1.0156767368,
-0.710853219,
-0.2505788207,
-0.2947141528,
0.6173847318,
0.290879339,
0.4363276362,
0.1783716828,
-0.7974255681,
0.2890847921,
-0.2451797426,
-0.6303685308,
-0.2014897317,
-0.262265563,
-0.2812505066,
-0.0476640686,
1.0011377335,
-0.5518342853,
0.3280744255,
0.5001587868,
-0.6708722115,
0.6860114336,
-0.3850592971,
0.0414192267,
-0.6924207807,
0.2489229143,
-0.1418088377,
-0.0007599206,
-0.8105459809,
0.0772533044,
0.0551714152,
0.0382230431,
-0.8197216988,
0.3283600807,
-0.3707686961,
-0.0582128428,
0.0217435751,
0.3519272804,
-0.1592211276,
0.5759789944,
0.2439427525,
0.7711346745,
0.2238592505,
-0.6577372551,
-0.1230962649,
0.1520625204,
-0.1806756407,
0.9821761847,
-0.8361153007,
-0.058941599,
-0.6992075443,
0.1603641212,
-1.1426843405,
-0.3596538305,
0.2342525423,
0.1032332703,
0.2260981798,
-0.0461771861,
-0.3198083937,
-0.5621578693,
0.1333178729,
0.3438252211,
-0.0172698218,
-0.430427283,
0.5057636499,
0.2125006318,
-0.1521559507,
-0.5050656796,
-0.3890152574,
0.0194410253,
-0.3230057657,
-0.3209144473,
0.2829527557,
0.1246384084,
-0.5982327461,
0.1529357731,
-0.2195856869,
0.2225313485,
0.1881135404,
0.3844312727,
0.2834913433,
-0.0827874392,
0.2700622082,
0.4536131918,
-0.4507527947,
0.3513558507,
-0.0886383057,
-0.0336019471,
-0.0712463632,
-0.304179281,
-0.4909473956,
0.4939768612,
0.5003321171,
-0.0797611102,
0.8581787348,
0.2877157032,
-0.3618147969,
0.0920237452,
-0.4090473354,
-0.2359113544,
-0.4564073086,
0.1852427125,
-0.4470723867,
-0.9096589088,
0.4015572071,
-0.2028014213,
-0.0002661761,
0.5286822319,
0.084882088,
-0.2220941633,
1.0658136606,
0.4799296558,
0.1937464923,
0.1950979829,
0.1200192422,
0.3610702455,
-0.9880762696,
-0.4789353013,
-0.6053376198,
-0.2511355281,
-0.6172208786,
-0.3541785777,
0.4071507156,
0.2389538288,
-0.4047942162,
0.5141407847,
-0.2649921775,
0.5228379965,
0.1801986992,
-0.0183936115,
0.414655,
-0.5714246631,
-0.1746773124,
-0.2783271968,
-0.8252886534,
-0.2795605063,
0.4464280009,
0.147631675,
0.5689801574,
0.1894824803,
0.1341477185,
0.077351734,
0.5871679187,
-0.3673014939,
0.4392911196,
0.2629660666,
-0.5190491676,
-0.2095776349,
-0.1094088629,
-1.1492395401,
0.6330474019,
-0.0569558553,
-0.9162442088,
0.5090656281,
0.2081115693,
-0.153753534,
-0.2247892022,
-0.6629494429,
1.179661274,
0.0356015116,
-0.4326691628,
-0.1585723609,
-0.7091160417,
0.6068755388,
0.2213698477,
0.4633324146,
-0.100445129,
0.1853227764,
0.5287333131,
-0.1878398657,
0.9610081315,
-0.2503564954,
-0.2915403843,
0.1553283185,
0.318372488,
0.7794590592,
-0.0828212649,
0.3530693948,
0.0509794168,
-0.3002142012,
-0.2566920817,
-0.5319347382,
0.6435275078,
-0.2793228626,
-0.8964806199,
-0.344609797,
-0.6566170454,
-0.2720686197,
0.0954049975,
0.3302848339,
0.3421371579,
-0.4571019709,
-0.0347868763,
0.5801166296,
-0.0752440467,
0.4578111172,
0.6357246041,
0.0982585549,
0.29356879,
0.3914708197,
-0.1629299968,
0.3429677486,
0.1568084657,
0.3477155268,
-0.3309748471,
-0.0905912146,
-0.1577442586,
0.4732547998,
-0.771458447,
-0.1917852759,
-0.6337578297,
0.1078096405,
-0.1776074618,
-0.192478627,
-0.2958664596,
-0.2767034173,
-0.0755934119,
-0.2866062522,
0.2009320855,
0.8593638539,
-0.113724418,
0.5942774415,
-0.2908834219,
0.1232597455,
0.4045407772,
0.1491303444,
-0.1148883402,
-0.7087243199,
0.0252770651,
-0.3275870085,
0.0417203084,
-1.2100000381,
0.0915029794,
0.0435727462,
0.6779509783,
0.5063566566,
0.0565248393,
0.7387380004,
-0.607217133,
0.6306928992,
-0.071064949,
-1.1408495903,
0.8920657039,
-0.4811864495,
0.5979466438,
0.4770449102,
0.2776662111,
-0.8684632182,
-0.8496468663,
-0.833560884,
-0.8859272003,
0.7790717483,
0.2527221441,
-0.049340535,
-0.2731470466,
0.3419166207,
-0.1675218344,
0.1531207561,
-0.5010672212,
-0.142098695,
0.1179697514,
0.0588651672,
0.0425219312,
-0.1868688315,
-0.3068675399,
-0.0732133985,
0.3202157021,
-0.1137369722,
0.2028178424,
0.2347478718,
-0.3309671283,
-0.0561284684,
0.3902738988,
0.7313725948,
0.5157724023,
-0.0741634294,
0.433884263,
0.1672525406,
-0.1613252759,
-0.0153251812,
-0.111321561,
-0.1484668106,
0.0271024257,
0.7811667323,
0.867180407,
1.1487557888,
-0.4099503458,
0.6263998747,
-0.1390251666,
-0.1798530072,
0.02521424,
0.1505944133,
0.0855190754,
0.2697192729,
0.2372640669,
0.2294169068,
0.2774695456,
-0.3451225162,
0.0206800699,
0.2797180712,
-0.4240103364,
-0.4502718449,
0.7687485814,
-0.0377773046,
-0.1614872813,
0.5724310875,
-0.100044921,
-0.5829890966,
0.6701409817,
0.8542873859,
0.5198541284,
-0.6122972965,
0.3724954426,
0.4732055068,
0.5241420269,
-0.2569251359,
0.2077018768,
-0.062596947,
-0.7536829114,
-0.5750234723,
-0.0342698023,
-0.2159420699,
0.2219247669,
-1.0332630873,
0.0698351115,
-0.0068300669,
0.0471073762,
0.0307278596,
-0.6152229905,
-1.018904686,
0.0971434414,
-0.0802998394,
0.8075698018,
-1.3671909571,
0.4794668853,
0.3527100384,
-0.205655396,
-0.7586184144,
0.0717444122,
0.0487383716,
-0.1767783612,
0.8567872047,
0.0469874963,
-0.3624844253,
-0.0912748575,
-0.5256883502,
-0.8923735023,
0.7488406897,
0.3792449832,
-0.7404740453,
0.1814907938,
-0.1367758363,
0.5666581392,
-0.0604494251,
0.226481095,
1.0535854101,
0.7000003457,
-0.0296191163,
-0.7762658596,
0.2214075923,
-0.014490759,
0.1867448539,
0.3331030309,
-0.3568836451,
0.6234424114,
-0.574331224,
-0.4027742147,
-0.4123701155,
0.8781131506,
0.1158763245,
0.0969678238,
0.6799209714,
-0.0528621152,
0.7947382331,
-0.1788897216,
1.1449047327,
0.1761389077,
0.1797151715,
1.2780045271,
-0.1781843901,
0.9006514549,
0.8280818462,
-0.0720573068,
0.549480021,
0.518697381,
0.5010123253,
0.7391291261,
0.1534176618,
-0.0660077408,
-0.2426094115,
-0.2939147651,
-0.1699978858,
0.6949044466,
0.5438935757,
0.1075899228,
-0.1822762042,
0.2591727674,
0.1357856542,
0.0597911552,
-0.3264504373,
0.6360118389,
-0.2407404333,
-0.9641017914,
0.1604592651,
-0.010094678,
0.1458733678,
-0.4270093143,
-0.1348991096,
-0.4483781755,
0.0321182907,
0.0273070242,
-0.6504124999,
0.6022384167,
-0.1876352131,
-0.214505583,
-0.0218918826,
0.7117710114,
-0.4804675281,
-0.4698253274,
0.3714573681,
0.4237275124,
0.0278254598,
0.0584421493,
-0.3122995496,
-0.1438340098,
-0.3922824562,
-0.3083209693,
0.0761028528,
0.4849260151,
-0.5411214232,
0.3506874442,
0.5709652901,
0.0200754292,
-0.0822509453,
0.2815675139,
0.7421743274,
-0.7282882929,
-0.4783421159,
-0.5401139855,
0.4601671994,
-0.0115775755,
-0.439237088,
0.5441498756,
0.0815753639,
0.8164384961,
-0.1142090932,
0.3927197754,
0.1264275014,
0.1927568316,
-0.5008115172,
0.3544642031,
-0.3493280709,
0.1064819768,
-0.4089353681,
-0.6579968333,
-0.3676988184,
0.5957055092,
-0.4971008897,
-0.4401808679,
0.9051752687,
0.5866805911,
-0.0829200298,
0.0523842238,
0.0772421658,
0.258617878,
0.0840162262,
0.4961618781,
0.9255383015,
-0.3098562658,
0.4044213593,
-0.0372902937,
-0.1696543843,
-0.1249319986,
-1.1642975807,
-0.6229501963,
-0.6793515086,
-0.2074910849,
-0.098293215,
0.310108006,
0.6225033998,
0.5505497456,
-0.7502445579,
0.1554407179,
-0.3609817922,
0.3891937733,
-0.6856251955,
-0.2179827541,
0.6002593637,
-0.4290398955,
-0.7434579134,
0.5764197707,
0.2170791626,
-0.3030804694,
-0.1088791713,
0.1500724554,
-0.1612222195,
0.2260992229,
0.5554832816,
0.0506056547,
-0.7982649803,
-0.6786644459,
-0.0565717258,
-0.0572870374,
-0.2746276557,
1.3572330475,
-0.8836279511,
0.2748226821,
0.2975478768,
0.1189026311,
0.2719684243,
0.0156934038,
0.6359759569,
-0.9006200433,
0.5518025756,
-0.1551671922,
0.3506361246,
0.1896238178,
-0.6412863135,
0.4027930796,
0.418284595,
-0.1812541783,
-0.7443357706,
0.2284928709,
-0.5963814855,
-0.6569914222,
0.9649397135,
0.1747735441,
-0.2038278878,
-0.3081184626,
-0.2076182812,
0.3627878129,
-0.1428193897,
0.6314427257,
0.6781307459,
-0.2469949424,
-0.2919991612,
-0.788367033,
0.4650453329,
0.4787853956,
-0.7173464894,
0.2678472996,
0.5359754562,
0.0362504572,
0.0690097138,
0.2949694097,
0.144008413,
0.2731700838,
-0.1429545879,
-0.1163010746,
-0.0918033496,
-0.7959979773,
-0.4705281556,
0.1671762764,
-0.1903688312,
-0.1678493768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03872v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03872v3 | Deductive Verification of Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2023-06-06T17:18:56 | 2023-10-03T19:48:22 | Zhan Ling, Yunhao Fang, Xuanlin Li, Zhiao Huang, Mingu Lee, Roland Memisevic, Hao Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) significantly benefit from Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) prompting in performing various reasoning tasks. While CoT allows models
to produce more comprehensive reasoning processes, its emphasis on intermediate
reasoning steps can inadvertently introduce hallucinations and accumulated
errors, thereby limiting models' ability to solve complex reasoning tasks.
Inspired by how humans engage in careful and meticulous deductive logical
reasoning processes to solve tasks, we seek to enable language models to
perform explicit and rigorous deductive reasoning, and also ensure the
trustworthiness of their reasoning process through self-verification. However,
directly verifying the validity of an entire deductive reasoning process is
challenging, even with advanced models like ChatGPT. In light of this, we
propose to decompose a reasoning verification process into a series of
step-by-step subprocesses, each only receiving their necessary context and
premises. To facilitate this procedure, we propose Natural Program, a natural
language-based deductive reasoning format. Our approach enables models to
generate precise reasoning steps where subsequent steps are more rigorously
grounded on prior steps. It also empowers language models to carry out
reasoning self-verification in a step-by-step manner. By integrating this
verification process into each deductive reasoning stage, we significantly
enhance the rigor and trustfulness of generated reasoning steps. Along this
process, we also improve the answer correctness on complex reasoning tasks.
Code will be released at https://github.com/lz1oceani/verify_cot. | [
-0.3200532794,
-1.1806412935,
0.858976841,
0.0465322956,
-0.2910984457,
0.2437527478,
-0.2247634977,
-0.5569272637,
-0.1191822439,
0.8485464454,
-0.6372682452,
-0.4928924143,
-0.4473184049,
0.3169280589,
-0.5077351928,
0.8252067566,
-0.2477060258,
-0.3329614699,
-0.1143516228,
0.2644940615,
-0.3089758456,
-0.5751532316,
-0.7308331728,
-0.5822962523,
0.1715720743,
0.1203510091,
0.5619311333,
0.3648275733,
0.3693903983,
0.2457859069,
-0.1381133199,
0.6837676167,
-0.3284238577,
0.2263438255,
-0.4722186923,
-0.2285008878,
-0.7247543931,
0.0369545221,
0.271905005,
0.545360148,
-0.1209327877,
0.1287642866,
0.06074531,
0.767808497,
-0.5265717506,
0.0376033001,
-0.7875075936,
-0.2879686654,
0.3798304498,
-0.153379485,
-0.6232895255,
-0.5443615913,
-0.0369895622,
-0.0848721564,
0.0520039797,
-0.0049446803,
0.6366280913,
0.2740717828,
-0.5742912292,
-0.3270463943,
-1.042544961,
0.5306932926,
-0.7339557409,
0.2736628354,
0.6093634963,
0.2754252851,
-0.4874401689,
-0.6408951283,
-0.6918693185,
-0.61386621,
0.0364189036,
-0.3666439354,
0.0547780432,
0.2366925478,
0.4963160157,
0.5527824759,
-0.6518104076,
-0.2220658064,
-0.2259720415,
-0.1168779284,
0.7115144134,
0.1453863829,
0.2863760293,
-0.0031400181,
-0.3961359859,
0.0711868703,
-0.8129835725,
-0.130089581,
0.2197274566,
0.2325963378,
-0.1748422384,
0.5505991578,
-0.4963729382,
0.7417780757,
0.1246308833,
0.0110148331,
-0.1680789441,
-0.3914499581,
-0.4141712487,
0.2962353826,
0.7006201744,
0.1723366827,
0.4826879799,
-0.0173403341,
-0.2838473618,
0.1831193864,
0.2258811444,
-0.5630255938,
-0.3454859555,
0.6009374261,
-0.1245702505,
-0.4030946493,
-0.101230152,
-0.1929986179,
-0.3096668124,
-0.5816984773,
0.341050148,
-0.5261295438,
-0.1222868413,
0.3796294034,
0.2658592165,
0.222587958,
0.474088937,
-0.6365273595,
0.4292502403,
0.8472819328,
0.5205065608,
0.1242408976,
-0.1713497043,
-0.5442615151,
0.1495003849,
-0.4171639681,
0.7264715433,
-0.5361121297,
0.0191100985,
-0.1715714484,
-0.0620379895,
-0.0233828984,
-0.2477481216,
0.4917412102,
-0.5617613196,
-0.1772847772,
-0.4339230061,
-0.6291582584,
-0.0906178057,
0.9611362219,
-0.5706273317,
1.107332468,
-0.1469285637,
-0.781878233,
0.0663513467,
-0.6313683391,
-0.3612522185,
-0.2503813803,
-0.2695614398,
0.0682180151,
-0.1743912548,
0.4556151927,
0.3491157889,
-0.4699151516,
0.3807687163,
-0.3269805312,
-0.1581543088,
0.4172885716,
-0.5991274118,
0.976021111,
0.2063384205,
-0.424156636,
-0.0242254846,
-0.9610452056,
0.1704354137,
0.0606392175,
-0.2001049668,
-0.2282270789,
-0.1526400596,
-0.5278607607,
0.3379949033,
0.1875175685,
-0.5052661896,
0.5167404413,
-0.4889697433,
0.6052458882,
0.714800179,
0.2888876498,
0.2829652131,
-0.0316551924,
0.5047858357,
0.0970382169,
0.213109538,
-0.0433938354,
-0.414575398,
-0.66396451,
-0.1907069981,
0.214837417,
0.5446649194,
-0.7169415355,
0.6061288714,
0.0517704859,
-0.4053419232,
-0.0977784172,
0.0415282883,
0.3866131604,
0.6727384925,
0.4053169787,
-0.0034633097,
-0.6622217894,
-0.6229658127,
-0.1010010317,
-0.3191072345,
0.1145549566,
-0.120727323,
0.7984326482,
-0.474321872,
0.7802018523,
-0.4954952896,
0.2035048604,
-0.3940330744,
0.2694681287,
0.3625898361,
0.6279348135,
-0.0777671784,
-0.3442163169,
-0.1293431818,
-0.0357973576,
-0.6308820248,
-0.0552570224,
-0.2486804426,
-0.4481058419,
0.3100350201,
0.4791289568,
-0.5807627439,
0.627810061,
0.406930089,
-0.4138664007,
0.8556064963,
-0.4817484617,
0.2141399384,
-0.74015975,
0.1324055493,
-0.4822963476,
-0.5225122571,
-0.2155079097,
0.0491951518,
-0.1174313128,
0.0748595446,
-0.0806666017,
0.3367935121,
-0.3649953008,
0.1164046228,
-0.3476140201,
0.2340028882,
0.3395737112,
0.3635043204,
0.0393815637,
0.3666769564,
0.6590828896,
-0.9346321225,
0.5325597525,
0.1424456686,
-0.275475949,
0.3611932695,
-0.7871185541,
0.4547998309,
-0.2559231818,
0.6259817481,
-0.9934658408,
-0.0527960584,
0.2930887043,
-0.1919084936,
-0.1221368611,
-0.0677242056,
-0.6904265881,
-0.4723944366,
-0.1289247274,
0.353743881,
0.3655776381,
-0.6296089292,
0.5808839798,
0.0598705262,
0.4144584835,
-0.5055971146,
-0.608604908,
0.0572981574,
0.2147083133,
-0.5797239542,
0.2650519609,
-0.031701915,
-0.4071515799,
-0.2228237689,
-0.3556125462,
-0.1181261316,
0.0180080552,
0.0459920317,
0.3312707543,
0.0062739928,
0.0044691386,
0.1196239069,
-0.1701688319,
0.3296916485,
-0.5262600183,
0.5600793958,
-0.3991406858,
-0.6180292368,
-0.3872824311,
0.1967537403,
0.6835544109,
-0.3686131239,
0.4990367591,
0.4147331417,
-0.6154412627,
-0.5394015312,
-0.5821254253,
-0.2829987705,
-0.4066082835,
-0.1894923896,
-0.4837251902,
-0.6053185463,
0.6208778024,
-0.1194475964,
-0.051819697,
0.2593100369,
0.6700521111,
0.1945959777,
1.0324993134,
0.3648734689,
0.1847969443,
-0.1775519997,
-0.4345808923,
0.6403546929,
-0.8731865287,
-0.4080981612,
-0.5009334087,
-0.0776982307,
-0.4111730754,
-0.6468942165,
-0.0101157697,
0.1483767182,
-0.3605576456,
0.5066072941,
-0.6983377934,
0.7197847366,
0.4209116101,
0.3035679162,
0.6189487576,
-0.2864979506,
-0.4883356094,
0.5168494582,
-0.2770134509,
-0.9571361542,
0.6053061485,
0.3406736255,
1.0301561356,
-0.0761476979,
1.0744440556,
0.3634398282,
-0.0845274404,
-0.6319540143,
0.8066767454,
0.1321833581,
-0.6823297739,
-0.3019281626,
-0.3535041809,
-0.5755368471,
-0.118802838,
0.1990197003,
-1.0217494965,
0.0431784652,
0.4107686281,
-0.4660063386,
0.3376409113,
-0.3751408756,
0.8036801219,
-0.2878392637,
-0.4152711928,
-0.3864087164,
-0.6400980949,
0.6202581525,
0.2742022872,
0.1146301404,
-0.2888361216,
0.3306004107,
0.2895228267,
-0.7582268119,
0.961101532,
0.0197813064,
-0.5803058743,
0.7401719689,
0.7341944575,
0.8868314624,
0.2641462684,
-0.0735929832,
-0.1253001392,
0.2149102241,
-0.0529172905,
-0.6494914293,
0.6930071712,
-0.3569011986,
-0.6560578942,
-0.3660657108,
-0.3094617128,
-0.2067636549,
0.0737132132,
-0.0041099289,
0.453977406,
-0.0806643814,
-0.2538275421,
0.7339189649,
-0.0931827798,
0.2051960826,
0.0615851805,
-0.4870685637,
-0.3344179094,
0.3421001136,
-0.2373426706,
0.4860767126,
0.5059071779,
0.3012820184,
-0.4565404058,
-0.3084977567,
-0.3264956772,
0.1063848585,
-0.9935446382,
-0.1192589402,
-0.6031050086,
-0.3050042987,
-0.5167651176,
-0.0986598134,
-0.5882926583,
-0.5585162044,
0.2047010958,
-0.1904564053,
0.3636049628,
0.8093878031,
0.014212966,
-0.3255759776,
-0.7502394915,
0.6903116107,
0.4814143181,
0.3918142319,
0.1363987923,
-0.3893104196,
0.0383156538,
0.3057901263,
-0.2850152254,
-0.6392554641,
0.138434276,
-0.1792102754,
0.4675451815,
0.3853193223,
0.427541256,
0.8644225597,
-0.4462411106,
0.8050624132,
-0.0405274928,
-1.1826714277,
1.0001063347,
-0.232703194,
0.2323658168,
0.5621451139,
0.173159793,
-0.1592362076,
-0.6639116406,
-0.6701411605,
-0.7851344347,
0.4203041494,
0.4203528166,
-0.1355174184,
-0.4693320096,
0.3170844018,
0.1070330366,
-0.1828137934,
-0.7453166246,
0.069028154,
-0.0302591007,
-0.0111992201,
0.4447074831,
-0.2705801725,
-0.1127401516,
-0.409512639,
0.8051593304,
-0.1672642082,
0.1252556741,
0.7825016975,
-0.0791472122,
0.0315187313,
0.3707991838,
0.5676898956,
0.8174260855,
-0.3401616812,
0.6739714146,
0.1112117246,
-0.2185838968,
0.2127993554,
-0.396114707,
-0.0075536114,
-0.0974715054,
0.3505157232,
0.4658708572,
-0.0956245437,
-0.7546180487,
0.2942128181,
-0.0265015941,
-0.0708229244,
-0.4560052752,
0.1054259464,
0.0022131077,
0.363761723,
0.0448417626,
-0.045713786,
0.195276022,
-0.600792408,
0.1576414853,
0.2408588678,
-0.0991630331,
-0.2383315563,
0.6021566987,
0.1861034781,
-0.2178579271,
0.8050285578,
-0.4584017098,
-0.7052910328,
0.7117394805,
0.8055850863,
1.151340723,
0.1796375662,
0.2262784392,
0.7579574585,
0.4871326387,
-0.4673579037,
0.4665565193,
-0.3118386865,
-0.5975861549,
-0.6831686497,
-0.5771554112,
-0.5702511668,
0.1063723117,
-0.4001453519,
0.3699682951,
-0.5743427277,
-0.052224841,
-0.3693922758,
-0.2044920623,
-0.5363130569,
0.3325656056,
0.6421643496,
0.8720965981,
-0.7074079514,
1.0350109339,
0.5209738016,
-0.4097789228,
-0.9358799458,
0.1013615578,
-0.210296154,
-0.5484388471,
0.7697454691,
0.4576894939,
-0.5422234535,
-0.1701487899,
-0.6489441991,
-0.7459040284,
0.8743720651,
0.3643688858,
-0.5363914967,
-0.0574638247,
0.1253130883,
0.4912703633,
-0.4344241023,
0.1731063575,
0.5781971812,
0.3272662461,
0.4029929936,
-0.9516693354,
0.6992096901,
0.1048426405,
0.0284003802,
0.0984169692,
0.0108153829,
0.7935035229,
-0.5562952757,
-0.0729298815,
-0.1822804362,
0.5252212882,
0.6299853325,
0.1612793505,
0.5351715088,
0.5505757928,
1.016292572,
0.248179242,
0.9877700806,
-0.3844141662,
0.3120979071,
1.3823268414,
-0.5233784914,
0.7572737336,
0.5519633889,
-0.2913917005,
0.9625544548,
0.3736824989,
0.1907890588,
0.2846354246,
0.3798682988,
-0.2297686934,
-0.6827145219,
0.0646113008,
-0.1621895134,
0.4963761568,
0.2686524093,
-0.4209820032,
-0.2803899646,
-0.2727122009,
-0.0659065172,
0.09839046,
-0.2385923117,
0.501226306,
0.1745985448,
-1.0217994452,
0.9005361199,
-0.0247652456,
0.1472052336,
-0.4502740502,
-0.3370084763,
0.0103710173,
0.3830356896,
-0.2532573044,
-0.7278127074,
0.5770455003,
0.1477317363,
-0.0148600526,
-0.2658626735,
0.8174168468,
-0.2914441526,
-0.4922574162,
0.2404419482,
0.4166329801,
0.1583091021,
-0.2923036516,
-0.538040936,
0.0516984612,
-0.0127003351,
-0.2848185897,
-0.2088323236,
0.6518319845,
-0.2191822231,
0.8162484765,
0.7090358734,
-0.03911772,
-0.1336772144,
0.3972284794,
0.7680062056,
-0.7583225369,
-0.3893761933,
-1.3816511631,
0.5489863753,
-0.1476308852,
0.0241553541,
0.4734262228,
0.4147642255,
0.7489832044,
-0.1725752801,
0.6771199703,
-0.3970316052,
0.1089541912,
-0.6569342017,
0.3469004333,
-0.0688049495,
0.6763280034,
-0.2461292297,
-0.600384295,
-0.3403985798,
0.775533855,
-0.4038890898,
-0.0999245048,
1.0827844143,
0.8839128613,
0.02368824,
0.0419527516,
0.1832790971,
0.1851214916,
0.3616546988,
0.7723697424,
0.9903706312,
-0.4287455976,
0.4748863876,
-0.5121161342,
-0.1679605842,
0.0479119271,
-1.3715003729,
-1.1618942022,
-0.3528825045,
-0.7938094735,
-0.6432778239,
-0.1190619916,
1.3173670769,
0.4562473893,
-0.718675375,
-0.0702754408,
-0.7040415406,
0.3397481143,
-0.5667008162,
-0.2112437189,
0.3341320455,
-0.4344053566,
-0.3516212106,
0.3363608122,
0.3422434926,
-0.0896734968,
-0.4168435335,
-0.0353017859,
-0.4514640272,
0.3964242041,
0.7485297918,
0.0250356551,
-0.9656608105,
-0.3463147581,
-0.1156272516,
-0.2216117531,
-0.0837357491,
0.8939139843,
-0.9367483854,
0.2829230428,
0.7839323878,
0.4297615588,
0.3294316232,
-0.0281463396,
0.6538179517,
-0.5494937301,
-0.1858734339,
0.269215554,
0.50649786,
0.1306297332,
-0.5501691699,
0.6488085985,
-0.0613843724,
-0.6102731824,
-0.9365759492,
0.5675147176,
-1.1957697868,
-0.1997218877,
1.2277634144,
-0.268825531,
-0.4028944373,
-0.2153197229,
-0.4513598979,
0.3213600218,
-0.13870731,
0.9948549867,
0.6698542237,
-0.3436662853,
0.0259742476,
-0.181257993,
0.388174504,
0.0439658128,
-0.8569224477,
0.6585716605,
0.2848546505,
0.2424437851,
0.0994367301,
0.7256572843,
-0.371660769,
0.0700824931,
-0.0283777639,
0.0481035225,
-0.1295261383,
-0.2508483529,
-0.0388636887,
-0.0577698834,
0.239144817,
-0.1555963755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03866v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03866v1 | Correction of Errors in Preference Ratings from Automated Metrics for Text Generation | 2023-06-06T17:09:29 | 2023-06-06T17:09:29 | Jan Deriu, Pius von Däniken, Don Tuggener, Mark Cieliebak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A major challenge in the field of Text Generation is evaluation: Human
evaluations are cost-intensive, and automated metrics often display
considerable disagreement with human judgments. In this paper, we propose a
statistical model of Text Generation evaluation that accounts for the
error-proneness of automated metrics when used to generate preference rankings
between system outputs. We show that existing automated metrics are generally
over-confident in assigning significant differences between systems in this
setting. However, our model enables an efficient combination of human and
automated ratings to remedy the error-proneness of the automated metrics. We
show that using this combination, we only require about 50% of the human
annotations typically used in evaluations to arrive at robust and statistically
significant results while yielding the same evaluation outcome as the pure
human evaluation in 95% of cases. We showcase the benefits of approach for
three text generation tasks: dialogue systems, machine translation, and text
summarization. | [
-0.2065683603,
-0.3364958167,
0.6282775998,
0.3304742277,
0.0397809483,
-0.0116613954,
-0.397897929,
-0.2771625221,
0.1050553396,
0.4617596269,
-0.262827903,
-0.3418522775,
-0.5849475861,
0.3873643577,
-0.2379514873,
1.2143158913,
-0.1543637216,
0.0574653484,
-0.3412491083,
-0.0278450903,
-0.5657788515,
-0.6249707937,
-0.5859082937,
-0.4130862951,
0.2099071294,
0.7517621517,
0.9117648005,
0.4751295745,
0.826228559,
0.3736597896,
0.4109286368,
0.5376944542,
-0.1436674446,
0.237845853,
0.0117750885,
-0.295309931,
-0.9549735188,
0.1313126385,
0.6149620414,
0.6052340269,
0.1318930686,
0.1633727401,
0.2874551117,
1.0130442381,
-0.5070815682,
0.1697243303,
-0.7021359801,
-0.0286710039,
-0.016848743,
-0.5515853167,
-0.5829010606,
-0.7106301188,
0.2422608733,
-0.542840302,
0.3526625335,
0.1400335431,
0.631184876,
0.5310918093,
-0.1849507689,
-0.3892361522,
-0.8220785856,
1.0083054304,
-0.7803438902,
-0.2459884584,
0.5468420386,
0.2205337584,
-0.2241374999,
-0.0426512882,
-0.4426800013,
-0.4376556575,
-0.1397211552,
0.1335623562,
-0.3021788597,
-0.0434480086,
0.0582734905,
0.15905945,
-0.2216377854,
-0.1075010225,
-0.0766768605,
-0.1842568666,
0.9723172784,
0.3730218112,
0.3482501507,
-0.5223193765,
0.1293388903,
-0.3989949524,
-0.217116788,
-0.1409008205,
0.747615099,
0.4814617634,
0.1418079883,
0.8179942966,
-0.3083890975,
0.4170831144,
0.2001265734,
-0.1068095639,
0.4386363626,
-0.6263977289,
-0.1202644408,
0.0508481935,
1.0275058746,
0.9452553391,
0.4821784794,
-0.0233085137,
-0.4599570036,
0.3675349057,
0.5965688825,
-0.429636687,
-0.2371183932,
0.2259752601,
-0.3825154305,
-0.8273656368,
0.162827611,
-0.6320715547,
-0.280317843,
-0.1472466737,
0.5782877207,
-0.2017969638,
-0.0396803729,
0.080082193,
-0.3107025623,
-0.5592105389,
0.3431805968,
-0.9587512612,
0.247183606,
0.141130358,
0.6478225589,
-0.4082300365,
-0.208398059,
-0.2662606537,
-0.0720774382,
-0.5602896214,
0.9849865437,
-0.1236983836,
-0.6717237234,
-0.0426442586,
-0.3471849263,
0.0251080692,
-0.6129633784,
0.6728557348,
-0.1081674099,
0.4164978564,
-0.0413538553,
-0.5983448029,
0.3963377178,
-0.0218929574,
-0.7382596731,
0.9700000286,
0.1680295318,
-0.8667839766,
0.8278849125,
-0.937078476,
-0.4516689777,
-0.164877072,
0.1093721837,
-0.7881450653,
-0.1286537796,
0.1877186298,
0.3877151906,
-0.3873238862,
0.4207591712,
-0.0957953185,
-0.1860250086,
0.462420702,
-0.4200597107,
0.5164735913,
0.1161961034,
-0.7110468149,
0.2700693011,
-0.8753139377,
0.165356189,
-0.0197665151,
-0.5147868991,
-0.3745585978,
0.2045890987,
0.1189825758,
-0.2590154707,
0.2587592006,
-0.4071206152,
0.0898246691,
-0.3697427213,
0.1874654144,
0.7124127746,
-0.0290499125,
0.7790469527,
-0.5894141793,
0.2646980882,
0.0072902688,
0.0476603247,
-0.0790979788,
-0.5394402146,
-1.0047552586,
0.1699658185,
0.4022872448,
0.53973943,
-0.6040231586,
0.8828114867,
-0.2640338838,
-0.7192127109,
-0.3814423978,
0.1765466332,
0.5048763156,
0.4148997068,
0.1892983913,
-0.4199869037,
-0.4430718422,
-0.8023585081,
-0.4396189749,
-0.6522327065,
-0.1241802722,
0.3213293552,
0.3265681267,
-0.2854699492,
1.3116135597,
-0.645303905,
-0.226462841,
-0.1618123502,
0.5716712475,
-0.2111597508,
0.6591504216,
0.5089957714,
-0.4298952222,
-0.3316938281,
-0.0733180568,
-0.4879316688,
-0.4695952237,
-0.1526733339,
-0.1728884876,
0.5638508797,
0.0307271779,
-0.1450688392,
0.4912215173,
0.2314316034,
-0.2498826385,
0.853728652,
-0.5266191959,
0.632760942,
-1.0532407761,
-0.019402694,
0.3705595732,
-0.2154967338,
-0.2872584164,
-0.5048968196,
-0.1032025814,
0.0917261466,
0.0980528966,
0.4286794066,
0.0574169531,
-0.0700057596,
-0.2877378166,
0.1451925486,
0.1221245304,
0.2258333713,
-0.019562101,
0.8200034499,
-0.0493158512,
-0.5768651366,
0.3156410456,
0.219217658,
-0.1749729067,
0.598623693,
-0.5194345713,
-0.0671174526,
-0.0172375645,
0.3301434815,
-1.0846333504,
-0.6277855635,
0.140366897,
-0.7928997874,
-0.1330679208,
0.3093792796,
-0.4939149022,
-0.1931769699,
-0.372428894,
0.1401701421,
0.5083420873,
-0.3050530851,
-0.0621137358,
0.5610794425,
-0.4052242041,
-0.261910677,
-0.3766235113,
0.1755122989,
-0.2547818422,
-0.6029314995,
0.1204713881,
-0.0701794103,
-0.5349401832,
-0.0550978221,
0.3290350735,
-0.0096168248,
0.1449169666,
0.2135635614,
0.4309623837,
0.0148439268,
0.297947973,
0.0844822302,
-0.4699107707,
0.0145208407,
-0.2594169378,
0.0708880872,
-0.0809840113,
-0.2269943357,
-0.4923446774,
0.3700370193,
0.5765442252,
0.0780308843,
0.2899405062,
0.1923490912,
-0.3024453521,
-0.0497548319,
-0.4943380952,
-0.0703684688,
-0.410507977,
0.398954004,
-0.0412237309,
-0.2698402107,
0.0651880205,
0.1585765183,
0.4282391369,
0.9102447033,
0.5901264548,
-0.184760496,
1.5290702581,
0.6901296973,
0.0807506666,
0.3795605302,
0.1339617074,
-0.031825766,
-0.3597424924,
0.1319199204,
-0.9698792696,
-0.1170185804,
-0.80685395,
-0.1061785966,
0.5727878213,
-0.1901008785,
-0.2367613167,
0.3376800716,
-0.6374509335,
0.2181435376,
0.7789233923,
0.0832230672,
0.5853186846,
0.2614010274,
-0.0008843269,
-0.2764968872,
-0.5558776855,
-1.085747242,
1.3146259785,
0.1225062087,
0.4889691472,
-0.1101428866,
0.8137026429,
0.7230224609,
0.5455493331,
-0.7376965284,
0.228872776,
-0.4502043426,
-0.3956302106,
-0.6107697487,
-0.6681027412,
-0.5405566692,
-0.1437707245,
-0.5878012776,
-0.5709424615,
-0.0610598214,
0.4983259737,
-0.4777379036,
0.2068265527,
-0.9811517596,
0.7839862108,
-0.1026882976,
-0.1752558351,
-0.2549723685,
-0.4350982904,
0.2224818915,
-0.3621820509,
0.0933439657,
0.0924263746,
0.2459453493,
1.0275543928,
-0.6067256927,
0.568780303,
0.0186543949,
-0.119905211,
0.2092919648,
-0.0176044777,
0.3451266885,
-0.1864011884,
-0.4230867326,
-0.1051891074,
-0.2365362644,
-0.2453165948,
-0.5527868867,
0.3334988356,
-0.9378505349,
-0.3203230202,
-0.402749896,
-0.4204486609,
-0.3193636835,
0.0696244538,
0.6095511913,
0.5083683729,
-0.2964101732,
-0.1068398207,
0.2112603933,
-0.3411716223,
0.2092445642,
0.0338837095,
-0.0871720538,
-0.6601784825,
1.0485292673,
0.0575771891,
0.3538109362,
0.0455754064,
0.3029078245,
-0.2197281867,
-0.2592925429,
-0.9534209967,
-0.1691460162,
-0.4216783047,
-0.2009360343,
-0.6845949292,
0.0219853465,
-0.2525966465,
-0.4114761353,
-0.3992791772,
-0.8013650775,
-0.290507257,
0.0200855639,
0.3703300655,
0.9319450855,
-0.0586236939,
0.6037427187,
-0.8300067186,
0.1970063001,
0.1946017444,
0.2771806717,
-0.0273070838,
-0.3445749283,
-0.392314136,
0.1389743537,
-0.7175986171,
-0.7082129121,
0.3584041297,
-0.00113497,
0.0920014456,
0.1160205454,
0.121887885,
0.4868960381,
-0.5214321613,
0.9198476672,
0.4400304258,
-0.992190659,
0.6299268007,
-0.4192376733,
0.1106318235,
0.7362365723,
-0.0289004035,
-0.2799355686,
-0.7506740689,
-0.8568634987,
-0.8760415912,
0.7288434505,
0.4878073633,
-0.0028600013,
-0.061207585,
0.1926561445,
0.2570241392,
0.2467640191,
-0.4930891395,
-0.1150398627,
-0.1882558316,
-0.3743962049,
-0.3376113772,
-0.1191024259,
-0.0912345573,
0.0072362446,
0.9928559065,
-0.0512099862,
0.0376048274,
0.3055078983,
0.0434982814,
-0.5996282101,
0.4965334833,
0.5113222599,
0.519975245,
-0.3508427143,
-0.0989562869,
0.0005790487,
-0.3973584175,
0.4234599173,
-0.1885380447,
-0.4656025469,
0.2822345495,
0.1163445041,
0.7028645873,
0.0198150668,
-0.4642010927,
0.5038585663,
-0.3049283326,
-0.0713486746,
-0.2581136823,
0.0692826807,
-0.2944060862,
-0.3129267395,
0.4507438242,
0.6896432042,
0.2690767944,
-0.290582031,
0.3909946084,
0.336979866,
-0.3720262051,
-0.0312277488,
0.6714105606,
0.7270187736,
-0.4289223254,
0.1341986656,
-0.3375407457,
-0.4873947203,
0.6935174465,
0.3768882155,
1.1568909883,
0.05777172,
0.5800261497,
0.4866377711,
0.2802722454,
-0.4049929976,
-0.0725550205,
0.1532932073,
-0.7359284163,
-0.2287387699,
-0.6346332431,
-0.8859314322,
-0.4110428095,
-0.3951796889,
0.3758275211,
-0.2650986016,
-0.8076037169,
0.1205052584,
0.0505834967,
-0.2894270718,
0.491735518,
-0.198842898,
0.2997857332,
-0.9634661078,
0.1940264851,
0.7051009536,
-0.2984040678,
-0.8277789354,
0.2289791405,
-0.0667162016,
-0.1813806295,
0.6080938578,
-0.0530357733,
-0.3811813593,
-0.2253119498,
-0.1571221054,
-0.4618771374,
0.512039423,
0.1898364127,
-0.4010963142,
0.2187840939,
0.155734539,
0.6497001052,
-0.5793170333,
0.6105085015,
0.7040352821,
0.6087902188,
-0.454323262,
-1.2250020504,
-0.1208372191,
-0.2295022756,
-0.0901076794,
0.1990666091,
-0.5127886534,
0.5383158326,
-0.316181004,
-0.0585515834,
0.3785370886,
0.387239486,
0.2773333192,
0.4382616878,
0.788007617,
0.1535772681,
0.6970931888,
-0.1227085516,
0.9413269758,
-0.1852541119,
0.3683893085,
0.9015828967,
-0.2760975659,
0.7140190601,
0.2975989282,
-0.2693083286,
0.2316437513,
0.4487968981,
0.2098648995,
0.0715502873,
0.0563232191,
-0.0183521118,
-0.2079315484,
-0.0666303262,
-0.1729688942,
0.3872986436,
-0.0243140496,
-0.4723421037,
-0.0427633859,
-0.3763721883,
0.0299730748,
0.3342233598,
-0.0014715611,
0.9037362933,
-0.1912315339,
-1.0621275902,
0.4426597357,
0.1788208187,
0.8121221662,
-0.1926607639,
-0.0517436527,
-0.0563056357,
0.1492248923,
-0.4902302623,
-0.5912609696,
0.2879424095,
0.6389791369,
-0.573058188,
-0.2570992708,
0.6184691787,
-0.198306784,
-0.8117674589,
-0.0683588535,
0.356598258,
0.1659129262,
0.1532045901,
-0.2770427465,
-0.1619225591,
0.2385313213,
-0.0925452486,
0.0257418454,
0.1376183927,
-0.209402442,
0.353526175,
0.6309782863,
0.2652879655,
-0.1952039152,
0.1122995988,
0.4326425195,
-0.6305802464,
-0.597669065,
-0.895418942,
0.6040893197,
-0.360560149,
-0.5069671273,
0.6400911808,
0.3651232421,
0.5880053043,
-0.0138406772,
1.3582057953,
0.0533327088,
0.6257100701,
-0.2499430031,
0.8957239389,
-0.5096353292,
0.3121773303,
-0.906850934,
-1.1862136126,
-0.2588836253,
0.5142816901,
-0.3327113688,
-0.0645418316,
0.5839207172,
0.5765963197,
0.2676932812,
0.1557065696,
0.1092374921,
-0.0542639904,
0.3261383176,
0.2477802485,
0.672231257,
-0.5037484765,
0.5080501437,
-0.1280335337,
-0.741743803,
-0.3246077895,
-0.9120329618,
-0.3883644044,
-0.5902430415,
-0.2974770069,
-0.5143153071,
0.0022847471,
1.11990273,
0.4291874468,
-0.7766965032,
-0.4237985611,
-0.0442481749,
0.0232708436,
-0.0080640744,
-0.2718211412,
0.2684132457,
-0.6733044982,
-1.0033341646,
-0.1078223884,
0.199866727,
0.0615398064,
-0.4474779963,
-0.0960825682,
0.4865315557,
0.2784518898,
0.4211755395,
-0.1170224696,
-0.3819689751,
-0.442238152,
-0.1126119941,
-0.3145338297,
0.1428668201,
0.8006522059,
-0.6087456346,
0.5328995585,
0.5356744528,
0.520495832,
-0.1481520087,
0.3113815188,
1.0521036386,
-0.5634683371,
-0.1377389282,
-0.0436881594,
0.286696583,
0.7126675248,
-0.5055333376,
0.3850562871,
0.1105368137,
-0.9022793174,
-0.8200970888,
0.1422124207,
-0.8013932109,
0.1906132549,
1.0668450594,
0.0924420953,
-0.0237265509,
-0.0468848757,
-0.5630888939,
0.3104931414,
-0.7830004692,
1.2381315231,
0.8668739796,
-0.1863678545,
0.6550832391,
-0.310719341,
0.6491054296,
0.7034811974,
-0.8989688754,
0.2071671039,
0.668851018,
-0.0033738371,
0.5416208506,
0.7041403651,
-0.2232233733,
0.4088476896,
-0.0143464962,
0.1687268019,
0.4786659181,
-0.2165450007,
-0.0311060902,
-0.0898704976,
0.2658540606,
-0.0074731773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03856v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03856v2 | Iterative Translation Refinement with Large Language Models | 2023-06-06T16:51:03 | 2024-05-01T20:44:01 | Pinzhen Chen, Zhicheng Guo, Barry Haddow, Kenneth Heafield | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose iteratively prompting a large language model to self-correct a
translation, with inspiration from their strong language understanding and
translation capability as well as a human-like translation approach.
Interestingly, multi-turn querying reduces the output's string-based metric
scores, but neural metrics suggest comparable or improved quality. Human
evaluations indicate better fluency and naturalness compared to initial
translations and even human references, all while maintaining quality. Ablation
studies underscore the importance of anchoring the refinement to the source and
a reasonable seed translation for quality considerations. We also discuss the
challenges in evaluation and relation to human performance and translationese. | [
-0.2185143083,
-0.4001385272,
0.3868139088,
0.2313605547,
-0.1964383721,
0.1665602922,
-0.6787730455,
-0.4740280807,
-0.0290629342,
0.6786451936,
-0.5630000234,
-0.3253116906,
-0.2653898895,
0.462340951,
-0.6057808995,
0.821079433,
-0.0834694281,
0.3494484425,
0.0773040727,
-0.2928183377,
-0.4113838971,
-0.3313991427,
-0.8387063146,
-0.7194256783,
0.6651131511,
0.6277859211,
0.6180638075,
0.6937537193,
0.4324505031,
0.4062140584,
-0.136184752,
0.1063794792,
-0.5847349763,
0.1724885702,
-0.4018493891,
-0.4150347412,
-0.1231823787,
-0.016735116,
0.9312691092,
1.0072594881,
-0.3938159645,
0.2466308326,
-0.0195953455,
0.9775093794,
-0.1882763952,
-0.2882021666,
-0.6029627323,
-0.2359072566,
-0.2671236098,
-0.2131714821,
-0.4595757127,
-0.461589694,
0.2084640115,
-0.3846989572,
0.7586048841,
0.2806516588,
0.8589755297,
0.4034368396,
-0.2295753211,
-0.0815076903,
-0.969776392,
0.83619982,
-0.9051311016,
0.4778825343,
0.3864282966,
0.44413957,
-0.0998979211,
-0.6957530975,
-0.4596533477,
-0.3808631897,
-0.0797199756,
-0.1047547907,
0.0822169185,
0.0348137543,
0.2743646801,
0.7709028721,
-0.5426905155,
0.1972090006,
-0.7248492837,
-0.2182764858,
0.9718795419,
0.1342287958,
0.0984952077,
-0.0117434477,
0.0516717806,
-0.2565166056,
-0.8331824541,
-0.2117863446,
0.3635341525,
0.4010086656,
0.4722146988,
0.6068338156,
-0.407222718,
0.7020670772,
0.1854636818,
0.1322025806,
0.2882442176,
-0.6465889215,
0.0107144294,
-0.0236355867,
0.734659493,
0.256226778,
0.3278956711,
-0.3103075325,
-0.2563416064,
-0.1277278066,
0.7423096895,
-0.7612928748,
-0.0786481872,
0.2752000391,
-0.4683693051,
-0.0050317179,
-0.1152703017,
-0.6143602133,
-0.1705174446,
-0.5559982061,
0.3877580166,
-0.4870493114,
-0.2277468294,
0.2276012003,
0.0755449682,
0.1272034049,
0.3184351325,
-0.9968004823,
0.148596108,
0.5267956853,
0.6546077132,
-0.04148902,
-0.5317782164,
-0.4166507423,
-0.1862492561,
-0.6021949053,
0.7431126237,
-0.2670121789,
-0.4864613712,
-0.1271579117,
-0.1059167385,
0.0894273967,
-0.6744772792,
0.4868824482,
-0.4299054742,
0.2436538637,
-0.4976228774,
-0.5162258744,
-0.5198443532,
0.2357447445,
-0.6398370862,
0.8473878503,
0.1056123003,
-0.2505079806,
0.3575267494,
-0.6867620349,
-0.4978324771,
-0.1565438658,
0.2393149734,
-0.4436526299,
0.5850819349,
0.1681419462,
0.0644561052,
-0.5506914854,
0.1877126098,
-0.0331585221,
-0.203936398,
0.204662919,
-0.2436740845,
0.4904774725,
0.4612766802,
-0.030022122,
0.4108497202,
-0.6835212708,
0.1806913614,
0.0632107034,
-0.2857976556,
-0.0710342601,
-0.0743523762,
-0.1213638112,
0.1767879575,
0.0948116854,
-0.5628834367,
0.5860666633,
-0.7256695628,
0.6112421155,
0.4766202569,
-0.0203166045,
0.6155794859,
-0.1250451803,
0.2911283374,
-0.2330965996,
0.1797881573,
-0.3942104876,
-0.4215877056,
-0.7866130471,
0.1331406236,
0.7071424127,
0.1208924875,
-0.6575213075,
0.1887759417,
-0.2276507318,
-0.5351917744,
-1.2020514011,
0.4620420933,
0.4243862331,
0.5221104026,
0.5537691712,
-0.5526271462,
-0.411446929,
-0.7970199585,
-0.4071584344,
-0.1113681793,
-0.0286849812,
-0.1353103369,
0.4268310964,
-0.2405878305,
0.5509502888,
-0.3225413263,
-0.3712646663,
-0.0500125773,
0.7552126646,
0.1606575549,
0.7445808053,
0.2445633262,
-0.5899179578,
-0.4342805445,
0.1391969472,
-0.4414440691,
-0.105647482,
-0.1038017273,
-0.1670770794,
0.143674612,
0.6552687883,
-0.4383895099,
0.2902342677,
0.4034728706,
-0.2209533751,
0.6308138371,
-0.5669012666,
0.5912314057,
-0.9448430538,
0.4849685133,
-0.1079453602,
-0.1461395174,
-0.711276114,
0.3611877263,
0.0769457519,
0.0636402294,
-0.1447143704,
0.6063225865,
-0.6249531507,
-0.4592732489,
-0.3800086677,
0.1684316546,
0.1333889067,
0.0840365142,
0.0746844858,
0.9581679106,
0.0864773095,
-0.5553241968,
0.4083548486,
0.3183095157,
-0.3517504036,
0.5466946959,
-0.7018349767,
0.3090257943,
-0.1862331778,
0.1708668619,
-1.2262636423,
-0.2885827124,
-0.0745241269,
-0.7539156079,
0.5558573008,
-0.0603151992,
-0.6173445582,
-0.7089696527,
-0.0572813638,
0.5722263455,
0.4139692187,
-0.5457436442,
0.3105053902,
-0.2048092932,
-0.0535823666,
-0.3693957627,
-0.557857573,
0.3131024539,
-0.0041763131,
-0.642889142,
0.5338382721,
-0.2870172858,
-0.1893257797,
-0.0383851677,
0.0130907753,
-0.0594510883,
0.0737859532,
-0.2585288286,
0.0009469276,
-0.1712725461,
0.2841844559,
-0.2480594963,
-0.3392902911,
-0.1985518783,
-0.392320931,
0.497856468,
-0.1139556542,
-0.4106492996,
-0.4637859762,
0.5231556296,
0.6521238685,
-0.6070982218,
0.5455675721,
0.6588634253,
-0.3251205683,
0.1589598805,
-0.9160158634,
-0.5799435973,
-0.4487942159,
0.1987545043,
-0.4276595712,
-0.7756505609,
0.6593520045,
-0.0822790712,
0.2014981955,
0.7011967301,
0.7050465941,
-0.1785519272,
1.5010040998,
0.5789118409,
0.0311887488,
0.3230294585,
-0.3017924726,
0.119812049,
-1.0005652905,
-0.1526740193,
-0.9661231637,
-0.373840183,
-0.4715506136,
-0.4320875704,
0.0523737706,
0.1958724111,
-0.1733390987,
0.458129257,
-0.644225955,
0.4074398577,
0.5502534509,
-0.0628138706,
0.5497781634,
0.0491530336,
-0.2395370454,
-0.255656153,
-0.6078154445,
-0.2927243114,
0.9601505995,
0.2392580509,
0.6863994598,
0.0378943346,
0.6417679191,
0.003111972,
0.8120697141,
-0.8204086423,
0.0133855455,
-0.1570321321,
-0.8810803294,
-0.4062488079,
-0.585282445,
-1.0205097198,
0.2973338664,
-0.1340398937,
-0.755635798,
-0.0435176678,
0.28587237,
-0.4181512892,
0.0208521616,
-0.6537704468,
0.8331260681,
-0.4386300445,
-0.4261123836,
-0.6204557419,
-0.5401445031,
0.1985308677,
-0.0380425975,
0.0949518532,
-0.0224416703,
0.1112175807,
0.2975125909,
-0.3397044241,
0.5042340755,
0.0614306815,
-0.289079845,
0.2382088304,
0.2477162033,
0.2222080529,
-0.2063985914,
-0.5101089478,
0.1300740242,
-0.2406642288,
-0.4894683957,
-0.7275418639,
0.6604862213,
-0.6359916329,
-0.7882956862,
-0.1214213148,
-0.3027432859,
-0.182266295,
0.3355077505,
0.5567696691,
0.1878274977,
-0.1697467715,
0.0725227743,
0.526979208,
-0.1381652653,
0.0704912171,
0.6747544408,
-0.5064172745,
-0.5060093999,
0.862729013,
0.1799633652,
0.3766020536,
0.0804801434,
0.2519035339,
-0.6766876578,
-0.7511416078,
-0.7861092687,
0.7214681506,
-0.6542426348,
-0.1487942487,
-0.1369838119,
-0.0203774143,
-0.3372976184,
-0.1201208308,
-0.8654406071,
-0.2383161783,
-0.2859230042,
0.0616113059,
0.2680332363,
0.9315921068,
-0.0775087923,
0.3898881078,
-1.0390877724,
0.276815325,
0.1215866283,
0.517960906,
0.0641807169,
-0.8534390926,
-0.3404811025,
0.1434199512,
-0.28926,
-0.7736773491,
0.5603619814,
0.2239751369,
0.5609078407,
0.3826673925,
-0.2827138603,
0.9127810001,
-0.7162812352,
0.7946309447,
0.3330324888,
-1.0208412409,
0.5183871388,
-0.1628538668,
0.611985147,
0.9554282427,
0.3125986457,
-0.8956498504,
-0.0469414517,
-0.442804575,
-0.9106557965,
0.4701848626,
0.0680603385,
-0.0226438642,
0.0077810008,
0.8165874481,
0.0415770002,
0.2700944841,
-0.3706470728,
-0.0510746092,
-0.1609356254,
0.0313732736,
-0.3907834589,
-0.1973666549,
-0.1789904088,
-0.4237743318,
0.7573358417,
-0.3223062456,
0.1059847251,
0.3088864982,
-0.150175631,
-0.5827250481,
0.2126689404,
0.6514695883,
0.7613296509,
0.0308181494,
-0.2286929488,
0.1595672071,
0.0775946751,
0.2791540325,
-0.1654288173,
-0.0981182456,
-0.1143726185,
0.3158859909,
0.4868216217,
0.2182493806,
-0.3516489863,
0.199025318,
-0.0955564827,
-0.2861189246,
-0.0438412502,
-0.2022238374,
0.1429234296,
0.1069083586,
0.3933829367,
0.0808052197,
0.3413373232,
-0.567751646,
0.2117360681,
0.2302835584,
-0.4283221066,
-0.4342881143,
0.6127333641,
0.331727773,
-0.4526361525,
0.9936054349,
-0.1367347986,
-0.6569014192,
0.2757206857,
0.5084462762,
0.9294473529,
-0.6578204632,
-0.0216259826,
0.9707878828,
0.399438411,
-0.6355838776,
0.1298366189,
0.0020686567,
-0.6302471161,
-1.1099309921,
-0.5493094921,
-0.3462595344,
-0.0830584913,
-0.726179719,
0.1354973614,
-0.2473079711,
-0.2494142056,
-0.0532087386,
-0.0488253087,
-0.5638030171,
0.2454749793,
0.1052762792,
0.9096115232,
-0.5734237432,
0.807521224,
0.8235310912,
-0.6277990341,
-0.6838209629,
-0.0695008859,
-0.0436158404,
-0.5854062438,
0.5593543649,
0.1801025718,
-0.1560651958,
0.3003898561,
-0.5230310559,
-1.0050855875,
0.9178621769,
0.2816624641,
-0.7247468233,
-0.0630116686,
-0.0999177992,
0.9276185632,
-0.0785805359,
0.2550231814,
0.7402192354,
0.6139827371,
0.2341275215,
-1.0994690657,
-0.1157706678,
-0.133210972,
0.2232622355,
0.1807380617,
-0.7195850611,
0.6661672592,
-0.3741014898,
-0.3253583014,
0.3118158877,
0.8991187215,
-0.2087758482,
-0.0019009016,
0.2840759456,
0.6579025388,
0.7921066284,
-0.1485821456,
1.1634432077,
-0.2954905331,
0.3249847591,
0.9668186307,
-0.1076637581,
0.8073769212,
0.5567921996,
-0.1409350485,
0.3361215591,
0.6662672758,
0.1674726605,
0.2502435744,
0.4039432108,
-0.131994918,
-0.351698637,
-0.0605437607,
-0.2550725043,
0.5613059402,
0.4005092382,
-0.3324587643,
-0.2722269893,
-0.0845031962,
-0.1624382436,
0.5047613978,
-0.295659095,
0.8300859928,
0.1230675131,
-1.3871814013,
0.8463062644,
0.2012630701,
0.4625755847,
-0.4120638669,
-0.1557693183,
-0.3248499632,
0.1885146797,
-0.2931696177,
-0.6751431823,
0.5820518136,
-0.1429382712,
-0.1157864481,
-0.3396735191,
0.4045723975,
-0.6524118781,
-0.303970933,
0.3457931578,
0.3959344923,
0.1444353014,
-0.2684595287,
-0.8246207833,
0.004821931,
0.2308562845,
-0.3137644231,
0.0414622761,
0.3205257058,
0.0150738154,
0.9079863429,
0.7571366429,
0.2229952365,
-0.0487349853,
0.371007055,
0.5388208628,
-0.7654010653,
-0.1060789526,
-0.7817404866,
0.5171310306,
-0.1235108078,
-0.3003765345,
0.7426351309,
0.2673890889,
0.858874619,
0.052585151,
0.3915185928,
0.2850914598,
0.5180780888,
-0.4085505307,
0.5873885751,
-0.7098300457,
0.2719437182,
-0.1042598262,
-1.0485750437,
-0.438734293,
0.8548384309,
-0.242516607,
0.0464725569,
0.6441811323,
0.7128348947,
0.2820081711,
-0.1626639217,
0.4245640337,
0.3221229315,
0.3866648972,
0.1235593632,
0.736956656,
-0.4493458271,
0.4000293314,
-0.1631431878,
-0.0658833608,
-0.3739184737,
-0.9040964246,
-0.4652251005,
-0.7481846213,
-0.2469207346,
-0.464215368,
-0.1312166303,
1.0380247831,
0.7208322287,
-0.8676426411,
-0.4059797227,
-0.0852883905,
0.0229747146,
-0.4297737479,
-0.1648457646,
-0.0469941497,
-0.6686114073,
-0.8465624452,
0.4826416671,
0.1350706369,
-0.1252894253,
-0.661220789,
-0.0430962816,
-0.2235565186,
-0.0254818574,
0.5069913268,
0.5224917531,
-0.7961388826,
-0.3909352422,
0.0849265233,
-0.1005630866,
0.2479124665,
1.0074653625,
-0.5136640072,
0.8864251971,
0.5030667186,
0.7139973044,
0.8248062134,
0.2502028048,
1.0519299507,
-0.7743204832,
-0.1139616519,
0.2225583792,
0.2521062195,
0.8108644485,
-0.3000488281,
0.6683169603,
0.0601930358,
-0.7266826034,
-0.5754229426,
0.2933135927,
-0.4488660097,
-0.1557762921,
1.0275466442,
-0.1293315291,
-0.2825253308,
-0.0877034366,
-0.4709638357,
0.3970216811,
-0.3151714802,
0.9821593165,
0.822857976,
-0.0278337225,
-0.1236783937,
-0.4367523789,
0.5172066689,
0.675673902,
-0.5298777819,
0.292237848,
0.5777776241,
0.2356836051,
0.4896911085,
0.5517162085,
-0.4258288145,
0.2855062485,
-0.1604076773,
0.426118046,
0.2280552536,
-0.3438819349,
-0.616994977,
-0.1526626498,
0.7119653225,
0.3307322562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03853v1 | From Key Points to Key Point Hierarchy: Structured and Expressive Opinion Summarization | 2023-06-06T16:45:44 | 2023-06-06T16:45:44 | Arie Cattan, Lilach Eden, Yoav Kantor, Roy Bar-Haim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Key Point Analysis (KPA) has been recently proposed for deriving fine-grained
insights from collections of textual comments. KPA extracts the main points in
the data as a list of concise sentences or phrases, termed key points, and
quantifies their prevalence. While key points are more expressive than word
clouds and key phrases, making sense of a long, flat list of key points, which
often express related ideas in varying levels of granularity, may still be
challenging. To address this limitation of KPA, we introduce the task of
organizing a given set of key points into a hierarchy, according to their
specificity. Such hierarchies may be viewed as a novel type of Textual
Entailment Graph. We develop ThinkP, a high quality benchmark dataset of key
point hierarchies for business and product reviews, obtained by consolidating
multiple annotations. We compare different methods for predicting pairwise
relations between key points, and for inferring a hierarchy from these pairwise
predictions. In particular, for the task of computing pairwise key point
relations, we achieve significant gains over existing strong baselines by
applying directional distributional similarity methods to a novel
distributional representation of key points, and further boost performance via
weak supervision. | [
-0.3886193633,
-0.6407989264,
0.6835413575,
0.1244667992,
-0.3486557305,
0.0571198128,
-0.0368221477,
-0.5844345689,
0.5517715812,
0.4306297302,
-0.262255758,
-0.7831482887,
-0.5022434592,
-0.0712031201,
-0.0955134854,
1.1316175461,
0.1871828437,
-0.3772833049,
-0.1702054739,
-0.2926976979,
-0.1683495492,
-0.5278721452,
-0.328651309,
-0.4722738266,
0.3767204881,
0.2572992146,
0.9504600763,
0.333869338,
0.7395444512,
0.2443828285,
-0.3560205996,
0.1397337168,
-0.3556887507,
0.5467016697,
-0.021078961,
-0.4581604004,
-0.7240517139,
0.0174689777,
0.3479426205,
1.0360267162,
0.2978649139,
0.2424642146,
0.249472633,
0.9880291224,
-0.6318150759,
0.5359005928,
-0.3923072517,
0.1347977072,
0.0735682696,
-0.4097008109,
-0.2932861745,
-0.444863826,
0.3963234127,
-0.7196799517,
0.0884418488,
-0.0942840502,
0.876747787,
0.0712898821,
-0.432287246,
-0.4749150574,
-0.7625262141,
0.3041086495,
-0.7214184999,
0.1476815194,
0.1285330802,
0.2797849476,
0.0571957901,
-0.6344184875,
-0.4562569857,
0.1257576197,
-0.1941810697,
0.3032439053,
0.0927561522,
0.1581546068,
0.1333990544,
0.4465535581,
-0.3746013343,
-0.3345080018,
-0.1547202617,
0.313300848,
0.6560723186,
0.0696075931,
-0.0962367281,
-0.5966044664,
-0.0415609106,
-0.1182853281,
-0.8042315245,
0.4482703209,
0.2578692436,
0.3714695573,
-0.0091393702,
0.4411250949,
-0.5649757981,
0.3784076571,
0.2707650959,
-0.1591065228,
0.4418426454,
-0.3427071273,
-0.3029144704,
-0.2150896937,
0.8537690043,
0.8250169754,
0.357139051,
-0.1550052762,
0.0381516404,
0.0812222213,
0.141380921,
-0.7388882637,
-0.5559168458,
0.4098798335,
-0.9788133502,
-0.6110622287,
0.031546697,
-0.8145708442,
-0.5502299666,
-0.3067279756,
0.1540622562,
-0.2805759013,
-0.2900400758,
-0.0878713578,
-0.2881495953,
0.329449743,
0.287296325,
-0.8671794534,
0.2965932488,
0.9448996782,
0.8594335914,
0.1367161125,
-0.0430920534,
0.0761772618,
0.3805106878,
-0.5573610067,
0.9542580247,
-0.8682169914,
-0.4805193543,
0.1418829709,
-0.2593190074,
0.1260782927,
-0.7484561205,
0.6223736405,
-0.3548047543,
0.0648066252,
-0.5440762639,
-0.6270986199,
-0.2755403221,
0.6734269857,
-0.3444304168,
0.9223476052,
-0.1611180007,
-0.7374062538,
0.6033803225,
-0.6531677246,
-0.5411406755,
0.1499775797,
-0.3899482489,
-0.2934787273,
0.1202516034,
0.4764497578,
0.6872888207,
0.1241305545,
0.0041301651,
-0.4037509561,
0.1278640777,
0.1285977513,
0.5064000487,
0.5630411506,
-0.0278184321,
-0.1907372177,
0.2906006873,
-0.6688815951,
0.1850168705,
-0.1292290241,
-0.0256106611,
-0.6972866058,
0.2978044748,
-0.2403854579,
0.4112489522,
0.2646246254,
-0.2358908355,
0.230387494,
-0.5695253015,
0.5010929704,
0.5028080344,
0.6275174022,
0.5444315672,
-0.1320311427,
0.3500935137,
0.0769451782,
0.1785300821,
-0.1661531329,
-0.7230266929,
-0.6176977754,
0.0857650116,
-0.0771706626,
0.2280907482,
-0.3797213435,
0.587043941,
-0.4698958099,
-0.5738028288,
-0.4152061045,
-0.0153051065,
0.352331996,
0.5886693001,
0.1641284078,
-0.1497986466,
-0.2143053412,
-1.0517237186,
-0.4367324412,
-0.6929840446,
-0.1309124678,
0.1704039425,
0.4046123028,
0.2545724809,
0.7967711687,
-0.711453259,
-0.4220426977,
-0.3346968293,
0.3392446339,
0.3653515577,
0.2273204029,
0.3840266764,
-0.7819962502,
-0.5537472367,
0.0884221792,
-0.7066522837,
0.0371020697,
-0.0174566098,
-0.2104022801,
-0.2762852311,
0.5480772853,
-0.6440746784,
0.0830294117,
0.0876217633,
-0.2655400634,
0.302929312,
0.099431552,
0.2660239339,
-1.2484508753,
-0.0207011905,
0.0793004557,
-0.0594937056,
-0.5796180964,
0.184319675,
-0.0265656803,
-0.1758442074,
0.0123602301,
0.0049513341,
-0.1128001809,
-0.0700992346,
-0.1263913512,
0.3136312664,
0.0908586755,
0.8454985023,
0.1533139646,
0.0941452459,
0.2742241323,
-0.4546371102,
0.0880713612,
0.3954918981,
-0.0849058703,
0.8731366396,
-0.7623289227,
0.0693531781,
-0.2804269791,
0.3195969462,
-1.1747509241,
-0.1256425828,
0.2373109609,
-0.5848190188,
0.0832133591,
-0.2969383597,
-0.4409991801,
0.0206961799,
-0.6782137156,
0.1673195064,
0.4558216929,
-0.3027226627,
0.3249264359,
0.737413764,
-0.3602836132,
-0.3220375776,
-0.1069645584,
-0.1176498383,
-0.2383636534,
-0.6404249072,
0.5614634156,
0.2939691544,
-0.4832062423,
0.1419139504,
-0.1144824326,
0.1238824427,
-0.105792515,
0.5789865851,
0.0023994159,
-0.0318584554,
0.3534932137,
-0.0832428038,
-0.2268571556,
0.276273936,
-0.0474174172,
0.1356678605,
-0.4228510559,
0.2042713463,
-0.0766087994,
0.411855638,
0.5556853414,
-0.1502656341,
0.1522045135,
-0.1380178481,
-0.4996547699,
-0.4250491858,
0.0617151149,
0.1228821054,
-0.3946782351,
0.3220154047,
-0.6335943937,
-0.4931306541,
0.5453050733,
-0.2051342428,
0.5948351026,
0.7050510645,
0.5767675638,
-0.5093364716,
1.0760854483,
0.7993499041,
-0.2031237185,
0.3060884774,
-0.4681744874,
0.6380329132,
-0.6239734292,
-0.5019010901,
-0.6387140155,
-0.6736938953,
-0.7220636606,
-0.1905335337,
0.5733905435,
0.2118817717,
-0.0881812871,
0.2818309069,
-0.5562517643,
0.5174832344,
0.3679563105,
-0.0788963139,
0.4589334428,
-0.2559464276,
0.0451736897,
-0.0480505191,
-0.3089957833,
-0.6488540769,
1.1298899651,
0.5703186393,
0.5138142705,
0.0611837432,
0.7776926756,
0.1608694345,
0.2087709755,
-1.2416884899,
0.6599450707,
-0.0261134449,
-0.1798689663,
-0.3846107721,
-0.1331224591,
-0.6269264817,
0.4329481423,
-0.1901464611,
-0.7375186086,
0.454223901,
0.2016241699,
-0.3122142553,
0.0052549448,
-0.6794718504,
0.8166587353,
0.3775919378,
0.0055730492,
-0.3012692034,
-0.7799444199,
0.3830125332,
0.3890782297,
0.0496124215,
-0.2161808014,
0.0002221181,
0.9472799301,
-0.6656983495,
0.5920471549,
-0.236276269,
-0.1496727467,
0.1675316393,
0.1051221713,
0.4172451198,
-0.1680631489,
0.122819908,
0.0337408371,
0.1562870145,
-0.1376059204,
-1.0108363628,
0.6911303997,
-0.658159256,
-0.3323336542,
-0.2234086245,
-0.4963543117,
-0.6843630075,
0.0083590476,
0.1803362668,
0.368912071,
-0.0827359855,
0.1919891685,
0.2603512704,
0.3483068645,
0.4296812713,
-0.0208231844,
-0.0685385168,
-0.3986151814,
0.7246193886,
0.1924718469,
0.1003519073,
0.7493031025,
0.2546850145,
-0.534109354,
-0.6322286725,
-0.0371058434,
0.2384168059,
-0.950171113,
-0.1094796583,
-0.5716793537,
-0.1585968584,
-0.4996032715,
-0.4281278253,
-0.1901903152,
-0.8860298395,
0.288475126,
-0.2966094315,
0.0269801132,
0.9937723279,
0.3969483376,
0.2335619032,
-0.4680399895,
0.4583022296,
0.1497885585,
0.2986041903,
0.0003319606,
-0.1595833004,
-0.1728283465,
-0.3949957788,
-0.7083733678,
-1.0856318474,
0.4019598961,
0.2945010662,
0.1734028906,
0.7539361119,
0.2423199117,
0.8343100548,
-0.369936645,
0.7762994766,
0.1329392195,
-0.7779772878,
0.7964297533,
-0.2950883806,
0.2247306854,
0.7678745389,
0.6390658021,
-0.6340067387,
-0.8311527967,
-0.9171639681,
-0.8581392765,
0.0489403531,
0.2008351237,
-0.1604178101,
-0.0064706188,
0.2066335529,
0.0379123352,
0.3576550782,
-0.6785680056,
-0.1947089136,
-0.2376685143,
-0.4968203902,
-0.0186927803,
-0.2054698616,
-0.2227945477,
-0.1231521592,
0.6701286435,
-0.2946200967,
-0.0119602829,
0.1878824979,
0.0448277965,
-0.1101782322,
0.4997235537,
-0.0568074696,
0.9260414839,
-0.405910939,
0.5617203712,
-0.4492982924,
-0.384780407,
-0.0621358901,
-0.1732438505,
-0.4319391251,
0.0447204113,
0.5328799486,
0.2995557189,
0.2517709136,
-0.3302900791,
0.5169946551,
0.3118043244,
-0.1421841383,
0.1209150031,
-0.3005650342,
0.1394233108,
0.2529918849,
0.1561433673,
0.0016062954,
0.4260457158,
-0.9212554097,
0.0252231807,
0.359177947,
-0.3579542935,
-0.4075702429,
0.3303620815,
0.4549023509,
-0.1206802949,
0.3214792013,
-0.034341868,
-0.5863697529,
0.5198774338,
0.1462895721,
1.0901118517,
0.2125113159,
0.4526554346,
0.4918139577,
0.2826581299,
0.373534739,
0.4494688213,
-0.429980576,
-0.557518661,
-0.1924169362,
-0.4844556749,
-0.5466966629,
0.0672796741,
-0.4953737557,
0.0222168323,
-0.7245497108,
-0.0070095495,
0.4317466021,
0.2339975834,
-0.3567948639,
0.1623371989,
-0.1193365455,
0.6215977073,
-0.9521325827,
0.4323149621,
0.6079953909,
-0.4369215965,
-0.784165442,
0.3969092071,
-0.1183765754,
-0.600887835,
0.5622507334,
0.2591184378,
0.0802851394,
-0.4207399786,
-0.2468937784,
-0.4844709337,
0.80967623,
-0.1761696488,
-0.4650687277,
-0.1728073061,
0.2940827608,
0.7067394257,
-0.4364836514,
-0.0508654527,
0.572160542,
0.2151198834,
0.1785508096,
-0.5951078534,
0.2309544832,
-0.5042580962,
-0.2461852431,
0.5145713687,
-0.4169692099,
0.4469923675,
-0.1162551865,
-0.1760396659,
-0.3862574995,
0.6242707968,
0.1098567247,
0.4039852023,
0.54507339,
0.6118967533,
0.7203087211,
-0.0329956487,
0.7404770851,
-0.4489717782,
0.2839415073,
1.1293091774,
-0.1646206975,
1.2566581964,
0.5850437284,
-0.3195272684,
0.5510914326,
0.7464146018,
0.2587765157,
0.5437725186,
0.0077903592,
-0.0223775972,
-0.0285995752,
-0.0824475512,
-0.4069644511,
0.09100952,
0.4344859719,
-0.5168765783,
-0.2070973665,
-0.6025717854,
-0.1014493629,
0.0231889077,
-0.5428411365,
1.0277270079,
0.2754738331,
-0.7144194245,
0.1927889138,
-0.1453830898,
0.3022284508,
-0.4696377218,
-0.0947005823,
-0.062971577,
0.0771762133,
-0.3082333207,
-1.0867080688,
0.4046664238,
-0.1195796728,
-0.267367661,
-0.4514245093,
0.7736104131,
-0.335383743,
-0.4659604728,
0.088042222,
0.4080236256,
0.088329412,
-0.2059155703,
-0.4617120922,
-0.3927875459,
-0.4978185892,
-0.221046567,
0.0769161955,
0.5238621831,
-0.0615175888,
0.3237353861,
0.4275803566,
0.1001325026,
-0.1475709081,
0.3241731822,
0.7225165367,
-0.7483894229,
-0.9800108671,
-0.6682237387,
0.3438844979,
-0.3584486842,
-0.5861936212,
0.7057120204,
0.4978871942,
0.7728813291,
0.0538929142,
0.7245130539,
-0.11914175,
0.4469104707,
-0.3387297094,
0.5075015426,
-0.3385294974,
0.0033113705,
-0.6329860091,
-1.0422636271,
-0.3229081333,
0.4850680232,
-0.4156407714,
-0.1747249812,
0.8737655282,
0.6550606489,
0.1354009211,
0.1725412607,
0.2218669206,
0.2619975209,
0.3846981823,
0.6149427295,
0.756356895,
-0.2750009298,
0.4368602037,
-0.5110856295,
-0.2538928092,
-0.1701729298,
-0.7103618979,
-0.7740995884,
-0.8104097247,
-0.5384710431,
-0.3256436884,
-0.1407089531,
0.760212481,
0.7993711233,
-0.7158311009,
-0.2304107845,
-0.1927226931,
0.4013456106,
-0.5203763247,
-0.2836263776,
0.6357269287,
-0.4421462119,
-0.5684554577,
0.1621017903,
0.7104247212,
-0.1937395781,
-0.3569737673,
-0.010219912,
0.1255289465,
0.1276879013,
0.7891049981,
0.252046138,
-0.5925417542,
-0.3678694367,
-0.1663869619,
0.0982550606,
0.1731983572,
1.187387228,
-0.5913076401,
0.5053592324,
0.9610913992,
0.4270338118,
0.3558718562,
0.0991546884,
0.5661095977,
-0.7455233335,
-0.0285494849,
0.4145358205,
0.3490230441,
0.1372917145,
-0.2120376378,
0.4964162409,
0.2123842686,
-0.2948437929,
-0.5028264523,
0.341160804,
-1.2236472368,
-0.3340110481,
0.8384744525,
-0.2217556238,
-0.1936308444,
-0.1369217783,
-0.1106530428,
-0.1071790829,
-0.2809322774,
0.9721722007,
0.6541862488,
-0.4282250404,
-0.0890420899,
-0.1769627184,
0.796677053,
0.2076821327,
-1.1153874397,
0.1884942502,
0.5051047802,
-0.0176461879,
0.4768453836,
0.9075213075,
-0.3011897802,
0.0360287391,
0.0375532396,
-0.2933979332,
0.2412334979,
-0.5661911964,
-0.0775796473,
0.8931682706,
0.134245947,
-0.4431481659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03819v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03819v3 | LEACE: Perfect linear concept erasure in closed form | 2023-06-06T16:07:24 | 2023-10-29T21:41:46 | Nora Belrose, David Schneider-Joseph, Shauli Ravfogel, Ryan Cotterell, Edward Raff, Stella Biderman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY | Concept erasure aims to remove specified features from a representation. It
can improve fairness (e.g. preventing a classifier from using gender or race)
and interpretability (e.g. removing a concept to observe changes in model
behavior). We introduce LEAst-squares Concept Erasure (LEACE), a closed-form
method which provably prevents all linear classifiers from detecting a concept
while changing the representation as little as possible, as measured by a broad
class of norms. We apply LEACE to large language models with a novel procedure
called "concept scrubbing," which erases target concept information from every
layer in the network. We demonstrate our method on two tasks: measuring the
reliance of language models on part-of-speech information, and reducing gender
bias in BERT embeddings. Code is available at
https://github.com/EleutherAI/concept-erasure. | [
-0.3055745065,
-0.751742661,
0.3914283514,
-0.1460528374,
-0.003207006,
0.077175349,
-0.3039028943,
-0.3818305731,
0.2200957239,
0.4906524718,
-0.504784286,
-0.5396069288,
-0.2791100442,
-0.4384970665,
-0.8535198569,
1.1093913317,
0.1492720097,
0.0573613904,
-0.3702857494,
-0.042310603,
-0.4915408194,
-0.2528372407,
-0.7530531287,
-0.25450629,
0.3785214424,
0.6022633314,
0.6968289614,
0.5758364797,
0.3468723893,
0.2699826062,
-0.5234815478,
0.181228295,
-1.0765099525,
0.4347075522,
-0.0993683487,
-0.620267272,
-0.6942062974,
0.08180397,
0.8296343088,
1.1282303333,
-0.2890365422,
0.2570819557,
0.1327170432,
0.880708456,
-1.0181634426,
-0.1771753579,
-0.6223678589,
0.2089555264,
-0.154253155,
-0.0747249648,
-0.4802933931,
-0.305716157,
0.0361641236,
-0.5052982569,
0.493253082,
-0.1193422377,
1.0848878622,
0.2087752819,
0.149347648,
-0.157419607,
-1.1698026657,
0.9558433294,
-0.599881351,
0.5284970403,
0.5619626045,
-0.0153838675,
0.1000401825,
-0.6525413394,
-0.5765920877,
-0.2315345556,
0.124284178,
-0.039329242,
-0.1706433445,
0.1953459978,
0.6488417983,
0.0459793583,
-0.4354467988,
-0.0201884583,
-0.6641303301,
-0.2719888389,
0.6999247074,
-0.0803734362,
0.3852259517,
-0.0531084761,
-0.3638897836,
0.4351576865,
-0.9763537049,
-0.1284493953,
0.2689245641,
0.1625256538,
0.2918759584,
0.5301354527,
-0.0702677071,
0.1332679689,
-0.233326897,
-0.1106929109,
0.3733698726,
0.1018311903,
-0.4173054397,
0.151001662,
0.2213681489,
0.2251503021,
0.1409645975,
-0.454262048,
-0.5447794199,
-0.1027686149,
0.0847353637,
-0.5631435513,
0.0368893296,
0.2966901362,
-0.6675847173,
-0.4497269988,
0.0723369643,
-0.4630372822,
-0.5244753957,
-0.5589491129,
0.3803456426,
-0.2831416428,
-0.3300605118,
0.0224091094,
-0.2048408836,
0.3762865067,
0.5106667876,
-0.5419418216,
0.7249214053,
0.8224737048,
0.850903213,
-0.004432532,
-0.0130882226,
-0.5218949318,
0.1105152369,
-0.5012227297,
0.1736082286,
-0.4445771277,
-0.3718433082,
-0.3070758283,
-0.2371074408,
0.1570673883,
-0.5133162141,
0.5515367985,
-0.352900207,
0.0646620467,
-0.3725375831,
-1.1284662485,
0.0330605358,
-0.0851221532,
-0.6805608869,
0.7944170237,
-0.4537221193,
-0.5093803406,
0.2325290293,
-0.9532080889,
-0.1461278945,
-0.0311012696,
-0.1275452524,
-0.5952207446,
0.1867718399,
-0.1517992616,
0.2631509602,
0.0887854323,
0.2459172159,
-0.4043572247,
-0.5173003674,
0.1466457695,
-0.3914372325,
0.7866111398,
0.4497837126,
-0.5164710879,
-0.0330882035,
-0.7216277719,
-0.0010224344,
0.2393879592,
0.4266688228,
-0.5705549121,
0.2756831348,
-0.0150436386,
0.0216199532,
0.2678065002,
-1.0047459602,
-0.1067107767,
-0.3086198568,
0.3972185254,
0.9925969243,
-0.3565820456,
0.7853425145,
-0.4967634678,
0.2394543588,
-0.2781835198,
0.218116194,
0.0812393352,
-0.4718204141,
-1.1049392223,
-0.5891916156,
0.4469186366,
0.4271306098,
-0.4435223639,
0.257509321,
-0.0130720437,
-0.2169182152,
-0.4863002598,
-0.056521181,
0.42166394,
0.3508634567,
0.1173901483,
0.0177987739,
-0.6258321404,
-0.9623201489,
0.016532179,
0.2361324728,
0.0201408677,
0.1055562347,
0.5493924022,
0.0281937104,
1.0793409348,
-0.6401017308,
-0.3277184367,
-0.050742697,
0.0176956076,
-0.143117249,
0.4732608497,
0.3435727954,
-0.9063099623,
-0.1281702667,
-0.3027023971,
-0.7586411834,
-0.1080048904,
0.0250857398,
-0.107956484,
0.2184441835,
0.8269286156,
-0.2826362848,
0.8635056019,
0.1802616566,
-0.3288587332,
0.4567303061,
-0.1085254401,
-0.0634882301,
-0.561011374,
0.2826678455,
-0.0237870775,
-0.6215711832,
-1.0532419682,
0.2506935894,
0.1394719034,
-0.2310597599,
-0.4659304619,
0.4757377207,
-0.2116619945,
-0.1273809224,
-0.2415349931,
0.4740821123,
0.2266418338,
0.131392315,
-0.1048967838,
0.688218534,
0.0369563065,
-0.5600879788,
-0.1073510423,
0.1766000092,
0.0578629114,
0.3510184586,
-0.5531398058,
0.2988219559,
-0.6145982742,
-0.0985168964,
-1.1127560139,
0.4284994602,
-0.0647773817,
-0.5426087976,
0.2890900075,
0.2710446417,
-0.1256154478,
-0.0526502952,
-0.580247283,
0.1358593255,
0.4824988842,
-0.4267307222,
0.3869968951,
0.3556957841,
-0.1333916485,
-0.889944911,
-0.7291257381,
0.0491063148,
0.0281363875,
-0.3776518703,
0.4660200477,
-0.2109692991,
-0.3560013473,
0.2953315675,
-0.2912095189,
-0.3257522881,
0.2525496185,
0.2037785947,
0.2836076617,
-0.243380174,
0.5076159239,
0.0795065165,
-0.0294679515,
0.0585981943,
-0.0195492394,
0.7279465199,
-0.079091154,
-0.5834707618,
-0.4433428347,
0.3228104711,
0.4789336622,
-0.229779765,
0.6167132258,
0.5943320394,
-0.937568903,
-0.5162930489,
-0.6605917811,
-0.1755441576,
-0.4848556519,
0.534583509,
-0.4243074656,
-0.8597942591,
0.5750911236,
0.2171919346,
0.2394217551,
0.2696491778,
0.2338997722,
-0.5903933048,
0.7059500813,
0.7287371159,
-0.1117110774,
0.4037123322,
-0.5184528828,
0.5497061014,
-0.7400270104,
-0.2999954224,
-0.6320258975,
-0.3781811297,
-0.3392366469,
-0.3152012527,
-0.073088266,
0.2874228656,
-0.1942385137,
-0.0544926561,
-0.3440275192,
0.7101355791,
0.4116264284,
0.5518957376,
0.3364008665,
-0.1486885697,
0.0421426222,
-0.3812379837,
-0.325589627,
-0.559889555,
1.1705611944,
0.6543468237,
0.468741715,
0.132684797,
1.0726780891,
0.5956673026,
0.1378788203,
-0.7944003344,
0.6493276954,
-0.4176295698,
-0.5544474125,
-0.6547530293,
-0.5928396583,
-0.6273242235,
-0.0056998422,
-0.2393303365,
-0.7562369108,
0.235133931,
0.1386462897,
-0.1617595404,
0.9657694101,
-0.445189327,
0.3392042816,
0.0365930088,
-0.3439624012,
-0.3912856877,
-0.0954310521,
0.5197141767,
-0.1204140261,
0.3946601152,
-0.2612343132,
-0.1889142394,
0.7788218856,
-0.6031246185,
0.9457710981,
-0.4880144596,
-0.1328092068,
0.0059558623,
0.4133757055,
0.3333762288,
-0.2661019564,
0.1501786709,
0.1511517018,
-0.0953578651,
-0.5236390829,
-0.6573767066,
0.3722415566,
-0.7649037838,
-0.3596619964,
-0.1785481572,
-0.6106600165,
0.0467576236,
0.1558175087,
-0.0480937585,
0.2419307381,
-0.5738653541,
0.1271614581,
1.1293224096,
-0.3198335767,
0.441354692,
0.2254845649,
-0.4401182532,
-0.0294651035,
1.1743268967,
0.0763281435,
0.6187329888,
0.3410409987,
0.1451718509,
-0.1248078421,
-0.4377503991,
0.2571212351,
0.1293649226,
-0.8340883255,
-0.0235970486,
-0.4503197968,
-0.6451756954,
-0.0206474662,
-0.1187152267,
-0.6205405593,
-0.8340317607,
-0.1800668538,
0.0278583225,
0.0666217804,
0.9945725799,
-0.2036803365,
0.2215998769,
-0.3980204463,
0.4870337546,
0.3639171422,
0.2990926206,
0.035219647,
-0.4598891735,
0.1057303399,
0.2204101831,
-0.1805450916,
-0.4156700373,
0.1835308671,
0.2912914455,
0.6854457259,
0.6027934551,
-0.0957560986,
0.5080877542,
-0.5555936694,
0.6776809692,
0.3674786389,
-1.568805337,
0.4238408506,
-0.0951888412,
-0.1571140736,
0.2101060301,
0.1953132153,
-0.8993930817,
-0.5760973692,
-0.6493524909,
-0.7753064632,
0.4872914553,
0.4779823124,
0.0805327743,
0.22766608,
0.5343270898,
-0.1537694782,
0.3226466477,
-0.4276831746,
-0.5683922172,
-0.0091783367,
-0.2413524538,
0.2285489887,
-0.6460234523,
-0.0277375821,
-0.3105918169,
0.6890100837,
0.2692765594,
0.410936594,
0.245527029,
-0.3848698735,
-0.0679814667,
0.3455006182,
0.9101009369,
0.841729641,
-0.3390683532,
-0.2172106355,
0.2385520488,
-0.6396351457,
0.1976529509,
-0.2673522532,
-0.7671178579,
0.1689936072,
0.4046190381,
0.595636487,
0.135247454,
-0.4351900816,
0.6894147396,
-0.1182092354,
-0.4686419666,
-0.3049429357,
0.0196958147,
0.004819321,
-0.0151905892,
0.3815902472,
0.4017480612,
0.3305027187,
-0.2856738269,
0.6482489705,
0.4550288618,
-0.5941470861,
0.0662270561,
0.5789132118,
0.0370478295,
-0.1689938456,
0.368640244,
-0.410779506,
-0.5155512094,
0.8329338431,
0.4181463122,
0.9197884798,
-0.2352007926,
0.4922958314,
0.3442622721,
0.459861517,
0.0939129069,
0.3953597546,
0.2092633247,
-1.0703938007,
-0.6057818532,
-0.2844688594,
-0.4561700821,
0.215942502,
-0.8481244445,
0.1649434716,
-0.7179790735,
-0.0266641248,
0.3569257855,
-0.0686942413,
-0.6016907096,
-0.0108878287,
0.6123177409,
0.7772922516,
-0.8655947447,
0.7781962752,
0.3686225116,
-0.3995666206,
-0.6659564972,
-0.0177228544,
0.2062322199,
-0.6589101553,
0.8444030881,
-0.1931601167,
-0.2625591159,
-0.2565433681,
-0.8311555982,
-0.863655746,
0.8285398483,
0.482532233,
-0.9001857638,
-0.112906903,
0.0705027357,
0.134779945,
-0.1571475267,
0.2339646816,
0.7073596716,
0.384370625,
-0.1754255593,
-1.0363570452,
-0.0175122228,
-0.1308806092,
-0.0268093031,
-0.0135668973,
-0.2742473781,
1.1004664898,
-0.3374072611,
-0.1144547015,
0.2058855444,
0.6737237573,
0.1571360677,
0.2816196382,
0.878264606,
0.4803828597,
1.5333877802,
-0.1255589277,
0.436009407,
0.0216164589,
0.7312933207,
1.0832006931,
-0.5086692572,
0.6513528228,
0.2513116598,
-0.1525798291,
0.1600161642,
0.0847489983,
0.4000542462,
0.4355921149,
0.34690997,
-0.2862632871,
-0.0820394307,
-0.1489694268,
-0.1708289832,
0.6082718372,
0.5435155034,
-0.1418720633,
-0.3619014621,
0.2891927958,
0.3153186142,
0.3655162156,
-0.4894395471,
0.5608974695,
0.0702458918,
0.1760633737,
0.6623734832,
-0.0410563797,
0.5422345996,
-0.5290536284,
-0.3341212571,
-0.250267148,
0.2853682041,
-0.3958473504,
-0.5840231776,
0.1698319912,
-0.0702870265,
-0.4102291465,
-0.0797952041,
0.8355959058,
-0.6753122807,
-0.4122543633,
0.4447673857,
0.6495143771,
0.0736542568,
0.1171555296,
-0.7696326971,
0.1011150628,
0.2709850967,
-0.0315265693,
-0.0049925665,
0.3850998878,
-0.0208169855,
0.9080261588,
0.5990150571,
0.5642108917,
-0.0638244823,
0.490580231,
0.8259963393,
-0.6496565342,
-0.2798231542,
-0.8602825999,
0.2670372725,
-0.4026048183,
0.0993100405,
0.4334041178,
0.6847723722,
0.7895994186,
0.245386526,
0.869799912,
0.0414100289,
0.7178279161,
-0.452414602,
0.9307374954,
-0.5309787393,
0.3742663264,
-0.648943007,
-0.8180315495,
-0.3799586892,
0.8072136641,
-0.0947075561,
-0.0133644799,
0.8285921216,
0.8856592178,
-0.1853603721,
0.3563770354,
0.7393085957,
0.3429535925,
0.5133293271,
0.1015248448,
0.873953104,
-0.2965904474,
0.1791686565,
-0.5007411242,
-0.3408800662,
0.0648775324,
-0.7143025994,
-0.7338613272,
-0.3583481014,
-0.3366512656,
-0.4646125138,
0.338493824,
1.014852047,
0.6638723016,
-1.0177023411,
-0.2546063066,
0.156734392,
0.4235286117,
-0.1879788339,
-0.2368125021,
0.51518929,
-0.6888169646,
-0.5615046024,
0.1676776558,
0.1313341558,
-0.3585833907,
-0.4381243885,
-0.1536988914,
-0.1771110147,
-0.0444126129,
0.6816188693,
0.1224978417,
-0.6371843815,
-0.4786713123,
0.1354668438,
-0.1416983157,
-0.0092187617,
0.8709406853,
-0.360997498,
0.4650534391,
0.3249730468,
0.5153594017,
0.6020248532,
-0.1404588968,
0.4774318039,
-0.9987009764,
0.4486320913,
0.4178414047,
0.5515788198,
0.0906587765,
-0.4432702065,
0.4082944393,
0.2991216779,
-0.2876567841,
-0.9497449994,
0.1474211663,
-0.5627192855,
-0.6006772518,
0.8918287158,
-0.0572711825,
-0.3313390017,
-0.2118982524,
-0.1841239929,
0.0747861564,
-0.49569875,
0.3784678578,
0.4704953134,
0.3554669023,
-0.1560581625,
-0.9450107813,
0.3973382115,
0.5292880535,
-0.4556176662,
0.0055639152,
0.3964505196,
0.5275820494,
0.1125665531,
0.8576309681,
0.0390698276,
0.316097945,
-0.2862849236,
0.7091768384,
-0.0793469176,
-0.4692647159,
-0.2828037441,
0.0445299447,
0.0603787266,
-0.4347790182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03799v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03799v2 | Prompt Space Optimizing Few-shot Reasoning Success with Large Language Models | 2023-06-06T15:43:16 | 2024-03-28T03:23:59 | Fobo Shi, Peijun Qing, Dong Yang, Nan Wang, Youbo Lei, Haonan Lu, Xiaodong Lin, Duantengchuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt engineering is an essential technique for enhancing the abilities of
large language models (LLMs) by providing explicit and specific instructions.
It enables LLMs to excel in various tasks, such as arithmetic reasoning,
question answering, summarization, relation extraction, machine translation,
and sentiment analysis. Researchers have been actively exploring different
prompt engineering strategies, such as Chain of Thought (CoT), Zero-CoT, and
In-context learning. However, an unresolved problem arises from the fact that
current approaches lack a solid mathematical solution for determining optimal
prompts. To address this issue in prompt engineering, we propose a new and
effective approach called Prompt Space. Our methodology utilizes text
embeddings to obtain basis vectors by matrix decomposition, and then constructs
a space for representing all prompts. Prompt Space significantly outperforms
state-of-the-art prompt paradigms on ten public reasoning benchmarks. Notably,
without the help of the CoT method and the prompt "Let's think step by step",
Prompt Space shows superior performance over the few-shot method. Overall, our
approach provides a robust and effective mathematical framework for selecting
simple and effective prompts. This advancement marks a significant step towards
improving prompt engineering for a wide variety of applications in LLMs. Our
code is publicly available at
\textcolor{blue}{\url{https://github.com/YouBLEI/Prompt-Space}} | [
-0.551492691,
-0.9215555191,
1.1456530094,
0.6707683206,
-0.2306373715,
-0.0361126773,
-0.242992416,
0.2309479862,
0.0038253586,
0.1563760787,
-0.840398252,
-0.6370503902,
-0.2155239135,
0.2297747433,
0.2441479266,
0.4881869256,
-0.202388227,
0.0655599087,
-0.4597717822,
-0.0731415525,
-0.8898918033,
-0.4417645931,
-0.429333508,
-0.0074901069,
0.5938456059,
0.5367373228,
0.3647934496,
0.4561568797,
0.2528574765,
0.2164054364,
-0.4115213752,
0.3611355424,
-0.3952443898,
0.2739715278,
0.0514211319,
-0.2607658803,
-0.1941869706,
-0.089243412,
0.7198046446,
0.8772075772,
0.2311244756,
0.0005806448,
0.1199118644,
0.4532077014,
-0.9433769584,
0.1446418315,
-0.3417496979,
0.1273213923,
0.0428826511,
-0.327786684,
-0.5945490003,
-0.6340045929,
-0.1602092087,
-0.7599560022,
-0.2395651191,
0.3443303406,
0.39008075,
0.2910340726,
-0.2606912851,
-0.0462944284,
-0.4218937755,
0.988361001,
-0.5504113436,
0.3191272318,
0.1579203606,
0.3477341831,
-0.6096738577,
-0.3557882011,
-0.4584644735,
-0.3904912472,
0.058040835,
-0.0292265359,
-0.4002971351,
0.1153812706,
0.5308188796,
-0.3640226722,
-0.7660115957,
0.1698845625,
-0.0165061634,
-0.2247893959,
0.1978149414,
0.2870952189,
0.3470733762,
-0.1105816886,
-0.5512641668,
0.0884043798,
-0.8566288352,
0.1809040457,
0.0350271985,
0.5553309321,
-0.0304511376,
0.6128601432,
-0.1702013314,
0.6704718471,
0.0335782357,
0.0784039497,
-0.0660747215,
-0.2612162828,
-0.0738550127,
-0.0291441064,
0.6539984941,
0.2449414134,
0.0351729877,
0.1090453491,
-0.2865260541,
0.2684242129,
0.0041040592,
-0.850540936,
0.1232202649,
0.1345062256,
-0.3433547616,
-0.0945475921,
-0.4216248095,
-0.6687723398,
-0.7362076044,
-0.2312449813,
0.1962998658,
-0.5561981201,
0.1241351962,
-0.009898142,
-0.0100689158,
0.1341127455,
0.5981420875,
-0.5425431728,
0.1079998687,
0.8682249784,
0.9326125979,
-0.2535045445,
-0.0624038018,
-0.9370661974,
-0.4128937721,
-0.5357328057,
1.0885152817,
-0.6382309198,
-0.622018218,
0.0193465352,
-0.4945103228,
-0.0091651771,
-0.2886833549,
0.6751081944,
-0.5218166113,
0.2235040814,
-0.4883479476,
-0.7739225626,
0.1467892826,
0.4287700355,
-0.4893165231,
0.767347753,
0.0042296513,
-0.4707944691,
0.0280409139,
-0.791321516,
-0.0840339288,
0.1373203397,
-0.385854274,
-0.1440026909,
0.1851570308,
0.4980205894,
0.4251950681,
-0.2464045435,
0.1007845849,
-0.3929773271,
-0.4142853618,
0.4767900407,
-0.2648501694,
0.7580099106,
0.3396852314,
0.0236610118,
0.2055191696,
-0.6833941936,
0.0521118417,
0.0332601406,
-0.2377340198,
-0.2471645921,
-0.1970081627,
-0.0634914264,
0.1711895466,
0.2287238836,
-0.5431084037,
0.4681243896,
-0.6499983668,
0.148291111,
0.8130862713,
0.2523619533,
0.9521548748,
-0.1626149267,
0.9610196352,
-0.0963214636,
0.0213459749,
-0.5123117566,
-0.5170752406,
-0.2899139225,
-0.2962576449,
0.0321476422,
0.6241986156,
-0.7623001933,
0.352057308,
0.0934844613,
-0.1896180212,
-0.105246976,
0.1034318283,
0.2241064757,
0.6112188697,
0.3794180155,
0.3740091026,
-0.4626809657,
-0.6821201444,
-0.2981200218,
-0.1410375088,
-0.0064906063,
0.1843289882,
0.235695526,
-0.1294000894,
1.3058204651,
-0.8469257355,
-0.0912761614,
-0.5470656157,
-0.0964464098,
0.47714293,
0.5092140436,
0.6872053742,
-0.4829306304,
-0.3630780578,
-0.2570877671,
-0.7017763853,
-0.3893342316,
-0.3491165638,
-0.4453535676,
0.019399887,
0.4012567699,
-0.9942808151,
0.2849018276,
0.1075858325,
-0.5235479474,
0.524738729,
0.1046798304,
-0.0196723118,
-0.989477098,
0.0632788539,
0.2375879437,
-0.2138620168,
-0.4484078884,
0.0139288688,
0.1440605372,
-0.5067306161,
-0.5534172058,
0.9932829738,
-0.5186084509,
0.2204980999,
-0.4601233602,
0.4492548406,
0.0013272634,
0.6824348569,
-0.2611732781,
0.8682800531,
0.5637837052,
-0.4176213145,
0.0826444328,
0.3872863054,
-0.2455544174,
0.5163745284,
-0.5844743252,
0.281821698,
-0.3034581542,
0.4243920147,
-1.274230957,
0.0615201369,
0.4213131666,
-0.5605131984,
0.1968319714,
-0.2042790055,
-0.3198516965,
-0.2004934996,
-0.4924926758,
0.4197445214,
0.5824505687,
-0.4883683324,
0.6482653618,
0.2060296237,
-0.36790663,
-0.5923578143,
-0.2601390481,
-0.1678854525,
-0.1453727186,
-0.597823143,
0.0994465202,
-0.1777783185,
-0.3944793046,
-0.0895170644,
-0.3243891299,
-0.1059752479,
0.2266283333,
0.081578888,
0.537694335,
-0.3775733411,
0.1772924215,
0.2886746824,
-0.4516250193,
0.168753013,
-0.4210760891,
0.5205802917,
-0.1456100494,
-0.2847175598,
-0.3150216639,
0.5585159063,
0.3545877039,
-0.0512634329,
0.5758727193,
0.2788440585,
-0.5653281212,
-0.5821799636,
-0.3585371673,
-0.1264694184,
-0.4931618273,
0.2042348832,
-0.4247857928,
-0.9529407024,
0.3362507522,
-0.3866054714,
0.2662729621,
0.1974330544,
0.3865123689,
-0.1731191874,
1.1617295742,
0.7577791214,
0.0512277409,
0.5085711479,
-0.1036549583,
0.2202970833,
-0.7321084142,
-0.0663932264,
-0.7152609825,
-0.2484333664,
-0.164726451,
-0.5945912004,
0.6416096091,
0.259580642,
-0.2644811273,
0.2288703024,
-0.344019711,
0.7369889021,
0.2986351848,
-0.0639742836,
-0.0304696467,
-0.0373545326,
-0.5363525748,
-0.114325732,
-0.7730753422,
-0.7752169371,
0.6138861179,
0.3430785239,
0.85535115,
-0.0738265738,
0.83675313,
0.0807254389,
-0.0417715572,
-1.0213339329,
0.7873651981,
0.1793100983,
-0.1653966755,
-0.2979976833,
-0.5520825982,
-0.997386992,
0.3324080408,
-0.2233671993,
-0.83491081,
0.1720767021,
0.1573918313,
-0.8365478516,
-0.0292817131,
-0.6925443411,
0.7989842892,
-0.0065976307,
-0.3346178234,
-0.1631538868,
-0.55689466,
0.1378636807,
0.0835942477,
0.0664234087,
-0.1225437075,
-0.1635897756,
0.6436544657,
-0.555553019,
0.8642628789,
-0.4173645675,
-0.0767099708,
0.3871750236,
0.3197002411,
0.6745970845,
0.1692414731,
0.0664255992,
-0.19511953,
-0.245285973,
-0.3741263151,
-0.9405032396,
0.7969263196,
-0.655729115,
-0.4675812721,
-0.2766967714,
-0.3589097857,
-0.505038619,
0.1525341421,
0.1761038899,
0.4425069094,
-0.2497061491,
-0.046012491,
0.8389710784,
-0.5208713412,
0.6963011622,
0.1938920617,
-0.253783226,
-0.3983690143,
0.5660008788,
-0.0865603238,
-0.1442831159,
0.6553606391,
0.3968910873,
-0.5118530393,
-0.2759483457,
-0.4543809891,
0.1786455214,
-1.0038006306,
-0.3689723015,
-0.836337328,
0.0157597736,
-0.3192434609,
-0.5523997545,
-0.3335013092,
-0.644179523,
-0.5172815919,
-0.1124941707,
0.1209646687,
0.4151770473,
0.1818652004,
0.459980011,
-0.8421453834,
0.3408556581,
0.120172061,
0.1312223971,
-0.1085135862,
-0.2869100273,
-0.0149392104,
-0.1898943782,
-0.4950018227,
-0.9933045506,
0.2186339498,
-0.2628164887,
0.8568085432,
0.2049645782,
0.0874820203,
0.4649550915,
-0.6847466826,
0.7907980084,
0.4365808964,
-1.0116637945,
0.8114076257,
-0.188985616,
0.60762012,
0.5017427206,
0.2609126866,
-0.4893108904,
-0.0598766208,
-0.3445694149,
-0.8432036638,
0.5121763945,
0.3048994243,
-0.0211219154,
-0.0773201883,
0.2027276754,
0.1128407121,
0.0547195449,
-0.3938023448,
-0.155085817,
0.1705067009,
-0.2076869905,
0.19990848,
-0.2702103555,
0.0988172814,
0.0203618445,
0.552495718,
-0.4124689698,
0.532746017,
-0.0115489634,
-0.2355188578,
-0.1616823822,
0.4955674112,
0.7919220924,
0.7677769065,
0.1677552164,
0.0583933853,
0.3507891297,
-0.1858870238,
0.3460568488,
0.0045546498,
-0.1530786604,
0.1468728036,
0.3465423286,
0.7742071152,
0.1963137388,
-0.4853998721,
0.723215878,
-0.0697844476,
0.1722534448,
-0.1524030268,
0.0523597896,
-0.1359327435,
0.4864131212,
0.435516566,
0.32527408,
0.0227717776,
-0.0870135874,
0.0288571324,
0.3021552265,
-0.1437480003,
-0.2770020068,
0.6230416894,
0.3954676688,
-0.3678338528,
0.5322853327,
-0.2887885869,
-0.3761279583,
0.5879027247,
0.6040046215,
1.2599526644,
0.1698120534,
0.3073832691,
0.3979711533,
0.2230804712,
-0.062301226,
0.4211675227,
-0.0358107202,
-0.7012419701,
-0.7617262006,
-0.5889584422,
-0.4928606749,
-0.197629407,
-0.0702567548,
0.5263752341,
-0.8196398616,
-0.2427888513,
-0.202565372,
-0.0035982532,
-0.6863356829,
-0.1904520094,
0.5484030843,
1.1747816801,
-0.7375576496,
0.3405701518,
0.8580304384,
-0.2210459262,
-0.8888775706,
-0.0549027957,
0.197311908,
-0.6071859002,
0.6541506052,
0.3727133572,
-0.2447522134,
-0.0009449351,
-0.8463989496,
-0.7648366094,
0.7539039254,
0.4928737581,
-0.7413865328,
0.0342020765,
-0.2775956094,
0.2951306403,
-0.5207961798,
0.2919023633,
0.2601028979,
0.4452559948,
0.126182884,
-0.4911191761,
0.2310667783,
-0.226628378,
0.1706059128,
0.1340958774,
-0.373114109,
0.6052902341,
-0.3501200974,
-0.3624473214,
0.2658753395,
0.761472702,
0.9670340419,
0.4562920332,
0.5085783005,
0.3252493441,
0.9352856278,
-0.0977336839,
0.9885800481,
-0.1869396716,
0.2737887502,
0.8198933601,
-0.4383501112,
0.586394012,
0.5314572453,
-0.070957534,
0.443104893,
0.5046305656,
0.2905778289,
0.4805400372,
0.2715241015,
-0.2183793634,
-0.4422111511,
-0.0854975954,
-0.1555229574,
0.103478007,
0.3303171098,
0.0238378346,
-0.4519129395,
0.2789075375,
0.0374770761,
0.130551815,
-0.2425515801,
0.6776040792,
0.2955525219,
-0.5628270507,
0.5353460312,
-0.0121273808,
0.4788957536,
-0.4926364124,
-0.2148097008,
-0.4337942898,
-0.0076004192,
0.0367066674,
-0.7874664664,
-0.1216792241,
0.2499254942,
-0.0473292209,
-0.5404999852,
0.8281699419,
-0.0740070567,
-0.3527651131,
-0.0398008786,
0.6904366016,
0.0191546846,
-0.1003652662,
-0.4878388345,
0.1509302706,
-0.2461416423,
-0.3311386704,
0.0771096721,
0.7374127507,
-0.1981892437,
0.6957184672,
0.6916074753,
0.0374226868,
-0.1373382211,
0.1784581244,
1.1245778799,
-0.8581763506,
-0.9252628684,
-1.1987086535,
0.6357856989,
-0.0084694847,
-0.4910786152,
0.617777288,
0.531928122,
0.2561878264,
-0.1453237385,
0.7685728073,
0.1583473682,
0.3499249518,
-0.6596201658,
0.3906828463,
-0.2349853069,
0.4276101589,
-0.4814583361,
-1.2132152319,
-0.572327733,
0.7147310972,
-0.3186165988,
-0.0628252178,
0.890152216,
0.7971172333,
0.0771979317,
-0.0537494309,
0.3900693953,
0.0385504514,
0.3576153219,
0.7610798478,
1.4358849525,
-0.0548921898,
0.4309082031,
0.0752634555,
-0.4409750402,
-0.1651532799,
-0.9199984074,
-1.0296515226,
-0.249652952,
-0.3697839379,
-0.2380301505,
-0.2174414694,
1.6135498285,
0.4621772766,
-0.6832308769,
-0.0141776782,
-0.1835258007,
0.4476350546,
-0.0232532043,
-0.2148146778,
0.1856689751,
-0.6948142648,
-0.4710175991,
0.8103297949,
0.5094646215,
-0.0058280244,
-0.1560419202,
-0.0663350597,
-0.0903959125,
0.1978521645,
0.7675355673,
0.1850109547,
-0.6248876452,
-0.1226939335,
0.5472238064,
-0.2686440945,
0.0154896853,
1.0424253941,
-0.9720710516,
0.2038786113,
0.8862445951,
0.9787716866,
0.0893970281,
0.1092380583,
0.546210289,
-1.0473679304,
0.1122747436,
0.5079287291,
0.5595058799,
0.1973993778,
-0.5512115359,
0.2717815042,
0.2035987824,
-0.4811935723,
-0.7902134657,
0.173449561,
-1.1579834223,
-0.483935833,
1.3856265545,
-0.0229096375,
-0.3611318469,
0.202772826,
-0.6199702621,
0.086335443,
-0.6613306999,
0.5035951734,
0.633389473,
-0.2708479762,
-0.2811521292,
-0.2646232247,
0.3413563371,
0.4644913077,
-0.8452861905,
-0.0494609177,
0.8885745406,
-0.0213543605,
0.2739464641,
0.7239251733,
0.2265196592,
0.3750734627,
-0.1078488976,
-0.2405595332,
-0.0434660465,
-0.5003888607,
-0.6528058052,
0.4101366699,
-0.0029296021,
-0.3368110657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03774v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03774v3 | Exploring Hybrid Linguistic Features for Turkish Text Readability | 2023-06-06T15:32:22 | 2023-11-04T13:03:35 | Ahmet Yavuz Uluslu, Gerold Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the first comprehensive study on automatic readability
assessment of Turkish texts. We combine state-of-the-art neural network models
with linguistic features at lexical, morphosyntactic, syntactic and discourse
levels to develop an advanced readability tool. We evaluate the effectiveness
of traditional readability formulas compared to modern automated methods and
identify key linguistic features that determine the readability of Turkish
texts. | [
-0.3318050504,
-0.8851636052,
0.1406854987,
0.2171643376,
-0.6605152488,
0.241033271,
-0.1511103362,
-0.9464097619,
0.3520107269,
0.5032024384,
-0.3709742129,
-0.4169435501,
-0.6368684769,
0.3825075626,
-0.4541908205,
0.8524341583,
-0.2643235028,
-0.2273575217,
-0.0773539171,
-0.4240416288,
-0.1619912535,
-0.4669420719,
-0.3465496302,
-0.3456499577,
0.518922627,
0.0726395994,
0.7441623211,
0.6350536942,
0.6451502442,
0.3180457056,
-0.4590907991,
0.0480698459,
0.1453129649,
0.1403750926,
-0.1612639427,
-0.1571556628,
-0.430560112,
-0.2071815282,
0.9813098907,
0.5319902301,
0.2614598274,
0.2773979604,
0.2670087814,
0.6512864232,
-0.4742013514,
0.101611875,
-0.1467129439,
0.1825536489,
-0.5143426061,
-0.1490478367,
-0.2483739406,
-0.3716644347,
0.5762289166,
-0.6486014724,
0.1295519918,
0.0426308215,
0.6151062846,
0.0809457228,
-0.6989965439,
-0.3456026018,
-0.7165620923,
0.6149577498,
-0.8668479919,
0.4243465364,
0.4923115671,
0.3214918375,
-0.0252423584,
-0.5178623796,
-1.0399594307,
-0.7145690322,
-0.3792234361,
-0.0996165946,
0.0761522576,
0.0068162158,
-0.3024201095,
0.9026276469,
-0.6891193986,
-0.1943139285,
-0.2288344651,
-0.3139017224,
0.6262155771,
0.2805905044,
0.6793966889,
-0.0879613534,
-0.0808924735,
0.0315306075,
0.0129028857,
0.1423106343,
0.5665385127,
0.3380404413,
-0.0255569015,
0.9098537564,
-0.4636592865,
0.7445368767,
-0.3612762988,
-0.2768941224,
-0.0025649567,
-0.7937405705,
-0.2635855377,
-0.0642660633,
0.5695875287,
-0.2836426497,
0.0505637825,
-0.2653574646,
-0.177986145,
-0.1193260178,
0.2602277696,
-0.2000522614,
-0.1315366477,
0.2177316695,
-0.8018091321,
-0.5891807079,
-0.0205041561,
-0.656956315,
-0.8916144371,
-0.2256638557,
0.5467247367,
-0.6303313375,
-0.6253369451,
0.2619842589,
0.0798014402,
0.4783668518,
0.2147666961,
-1.135445118,
0.6440548301,
0.8629395366,
1.0439440012,
-0.2086647302,
-0.2093902677,
0.1156174466,
-0.0962361097,
0.1604974866,
0.6768246293,
-0.4383229315,
0.1136940941,
0.018236313,
-0.1884113997,
-0.4971570969,
-0.4594680071,
0.7698251605,
-0.301538229,
0.2006376535,
0.1122641563,
-0.3941401243,
-0.8300702572,
0.3979561031,
-1.1540222168,
0.9141538739,
-0.005736887,
-1.4078365564,
0.5762237906,
-0.5911828876,
-0.7651821971,
0.0989914462,
0.3120526969,
-0.3948838711,
0.0276535079,
-0.0225102585,
0.2325257063,
0.2143593878,
-0.2391044647,
0.0835571513,
-0.3775860369,
0.1708480716,
-0.4360426366,
0.8885301948,
0.164784044,
-0.5794528127,
0.4028441906,
-0.9249768257,
-0.0789252669,
-0.1697200388,
-0.7093819976,
-0.1374525577,
0.1979088783,
0.829665482,
0.1260546297,
0.3563239276,
-0.5921952128,
0.1167451367,
-0.5750026703,
0.047387477,
0.2313472629,
-0.3696688712,
0.2438750118,
-0.5220568776,
0.7059276104,
0.0952115282,
-0.3057322204,
-0.1312972903,
-0.3707089722,
-0.9609127045,
-0.4620738924,
0.1918154359,
1.2291301489,
-0.4238137007,
0.665500164,
0.3715649545,
-0.8061079979,
-0.4750646055,
0.135316968,
0.6508282423,
0.3073923588,
0.017728813,
-0.1563258767,
-0.4495842457,
-0.7820294499,
-0.7565321922,
-0.3109602332,
0.4541068971,
0.2481552362,
0.5813826919,
0.097022593,
0.4101296663,
0.2617234886,
-0.0914196745,
-0.7799687386,
0.0734283775,
0.378739208,
0.4332692623,
0.119371213,
-0.7567749619,
-0.4907058179,
0.5804783702,
-0.7194800973,
0.0338403881,
0.0855563655,
0.0234355628,
0.4324280024,
0.2108389884,
-0.3923392296,
0.6558316946,
0.3390649259,
-1.0055521727,
0.7538320422,
-0.4647776186,
0.3307278156,
-0.9792733192,
0.3387489319,
0.3472504914,
-0.4286864102,
-0.6159252524,
0.4871470034,
-0.0152999172,
0.1338354498,
-0.5232866406,
0.4893540144,
-0.4284337461,
0.0187701155,
-0.046915561,
-0.2953532934,
-0.0648255423,
-0.179007411,
0.0544513278,
0.7236139178,
0.1194062158,
-0.4861026704,
0.5614312291,
0.3022201359,
-0.7814210057,
0.3340447843,
-0.6568720937,
-0.1861110479,
-0.0990244448,
0.0465605855,
-1.0001451969,
-0.1593682021,
0.5919325948,
-0.2795704901,
0.3710074127,
0.3412465751,
-0.6997529864,
0.075436838,
0.091300942,
0.4737261236,
0.1616474539,
-0.1980881244,
0.7423765063,
0.2006771415,
-0.4166795313,
-0.6138734818,
-0.4323825836,
0.1519354135,
-0.2652843297,
-1.1160625219,
-0.0009272893,
0.4052835405,
-0.364739269,
-0.2408431023,
0.2075963467,
-0.3594163358,
0.2434779406,
-0.1069904938,
0.2007630914,
-0.4710800648,
-0.1373381466,
-0.0851686597,
-0.1754224747,
-0.2985125482,
-0.5191679001,
0.4414834082,
-0.6328975558,
0.2981419861,
-0.7491281629,
0.4638015032,
0.6405466199,
-0.6420467496,
1.1339144707,
0.7491734028,
-0.5072131157,
0.2389275283,
-0.3498448431,
0.2867508233,
-0.4373881519,
0.5005329251,
-0.397767067,
-0.7399079204,
0.7238858342,
0.107152395,
0.2469998598,
0.5935736299,
0.7731083035,
-0.3550601304,
0.6552988887,
1.0569806099,
0.2459403723,
0.3956502378,
0.1281131655,
0.2829267979,
-0.3761433065,
-0.5643609762,
-0.6545441151,
-0.4800397158,
-0.547760427,
-0.1333388239,
0.0311016142,
-0.0087483078,
0.1360014677,
0.2880577147,
-0.2978042662,
0.4442117214,
0.4173248112,
0.0129411938,
0.6380175948,
-0.1606653184,
-0.8651025891,
-0.2271664739,
-0.2493265867,
-0.8655249476,
0.5604102612,
0.471904546,
0.4288749695,
0.2099176645,
0.4415137768,
0.4822355211,
-0.2784744203,
-0.9163741469,
0.4935475886,
-0.3348062038,
-0.6277258992,
-0.465328604,
-0.2462527305,
-0.8362179399,
0.396702379,
-0.7134335041,
-0.9291169643,
-0.0367129631,
0.1828442067,
-0.2194979638,
0.575571239,
-0.6474299431,
1.1303882599,
-0.0683269575,
0.1572109312,
-0.0651557595,
-0.5010845065,
0.2586381733,
-0.0608287565,
-0.1522967219,
0.1444678903,
-0.4194239676,
0.7520842552,
-0.2198665738,
0.5594807267,
0.4162456095,
0.1154907644,
-0.0121549042,
0.3431894779,
0.111774534,
-0.1741799116,
-0.1494239122,
0.0342547782,
0.6204054952,
-0.7451674342,
-0.5895638466,
0.1886432916,
-0.8006460667,
-0.1160694137,
-0.7504560351,
-0.5540015101,
-0.0139501365,
0.4501885176,
0.161542967,
0.5465693474,
-0.5751715302,
-0.1465836167,
0.4665559232,
-0.2398458719,
0.4387788475,
0.3112692833,
-0.1649622172,
-0.5439965725,
0.7890601158,
0.0803380534,
-0.1250749975,
0.2552728951,
0.2492748499,
-0.4130478203,
-0.8530910015,
-0.615285635,
0.2751776874,
-0.3458447158,
0.8495675921,
-0.6597669125,
-0.3281722069,
-0.249735117,
-0.0593137443,
-0.2072943449,
-0.7977563739,
-0.2770512402,
-0.0147937695,
0.0732545927,
1.1342889071,
0.1903486997,
0.4089283943,
-0.8468458652,
0.092246592,
-0.1495241523,
0.4543327391,
-0.1843862385,
-0.6325096488,
-0.500132978,
-0.6218215823,
-0.1930121779,
-0.8156735301,
0.4671551883,
0.1065873206,
0.4254432917,
0.3887126446,
-0.1323805153,
-0.2675165236,
-0.2458492517,
0.6831848025,
-0.1414970011,
-0.9565556645,
0.4889036119,
-0.4850753844,
0.3250048757,
0.7990508676,
0.3589128554,
-0.8344435692,
-0.2447389215,
-0.3878295124,
-0.6595180631,
0.3301418722,
0.5070556998,
0.1164127216,
0.5476089716,
0.4580689967,
0.5825273395,
0.030796811,
-0.3830660284,
-0.2366589755,
-0.0045782812,
-0.4729756415,
-0.295072943,
-0.4479961097,
0.2422615141,
-0.4872309864,
0.6916797757,
0.2214281559,
-0.0812948644,
-0.0926946104,
-0.3100613058,
0.0961377397,
0.4660920799,
0.8608805537,
1.0392503738,
-0.4129587412,
0.0813724026,
0.0086124018,
-1.2641464472,
0.4409658909,
0.3174568117,
-0.3857348263,
0.0941950381,
0.6097243428,
0.623773396,
-0.2892014086,
-0.5181753635,
0.3016165495,
-0.3840368092,
-0.1265284717,
-0.6025941968,
-0.0730933249,
-0.1849085093,
0.2983417809,
0.1920069009,
0.0840475932,
0.3640777171,
-0.4131937027,
0.3797300756,
0.0621081926,
-0.4605782032,
-0.1633165926,
0.3062525094,
0.4012075365,
-0.4308864772,
0.5211508274,
0.1700630784,
-0.5781397223,
0.6139668822,
0.5379320979,
0.8504300714,
0.136486128,
0.4464245141,
0.1580387503,
0.7273097038,
0.3347961605,
0.5406410098,
0.0117517905,
-0.6797005534,
-0.3365748227,
-0.669451654,
-0.5341998935,
0.2020422965,
-0.6510282159,
0.2430790663,
-0.6467096806,
-0.0118092326,
0.2628010511,
0.6913097501,
-0.4003210068,
0.5117865205,
0.0889936388,
1.0424309969,
-0.7934313416,
0.5648015141,
1.1187483072,
-0.3354054391,
-0.4732788503,
-0.1081925333,
0.0838596821,
-0.3987373412,
0.2289211005,
0.3134084046,
0.1830938309,
-0.1371327937,
0.120989047,
-0.6371155381,
0.9092985988,
0.2728590071,
-0.3039431572,
0.0393803231,
0.2537307739,
0.4876707494,
-0.0511917919,
0.58112818,
1.1427259445,
0.6040214896,
-0.0640167594,
-1.4271837473,
0.0119507266,
-0.7813161016,
-0.3184411228,
0.3277839124,
-0.5020083785,
0.5477005243,
-0.0613033436,
0.0663787872,
0.193742618,
0.9797886014,
0.0607523136,
0.610437572,
0.6864443421,
0.8963243365,
0.838721931,
0.1419671029,
1.20613873,
0.0103045423,
0.1614354402,
0.7444788814,
0.3744192123,
0.9077785611,
0.3440546691,
-0.1514921635,
0.4038380384,
0.8560456634,
0.2120372057,
0.4483635724,
0.2382974625,
-0.8419238925,
-0.2154899389,
0.0188075062,
-0.2512975037,
0.7215644717,
0.058854565,
-0.6768587232,
-0.1434137374,
0.0498389266,
-0.036687497,
0.1094460115,
-0.1229664311,
0.7567722797,
0.0272039827,
-0.0908556059,
0.3246229887,
0.196615696,
0.7086806893,
-0.2526423633,
-0.0177246183,
-0.0425559096,
0.320679754,
-0.3052449226,
-0.8421724439,
0.6715496182,
-0.0949731097,
-0.4387687743,
0.3603075445,
1.0232510567,
-0.183183074,
-0.8815627098,
0.1665965766,
0.6512960792,
0.4212752879,
-0.0060892855,
-0.6149181128,
-0.1559592038,
-0.3202539384,
-0.2616877854,
0.1268078238,
0.2504844368,
0.0501434021,
0.6572595239,
0.501929462,
0.387267828,
0.3881960213,
-0.0638789609,
0.5854444504,
-0.8476068377,
-0.751994133,
-0.7801949382,
0.646307528,
0.209809795,
-0.78383255,
0.3578620851,
0.3137570918,
0.6052629948,
0.1822612733,
1.0692987442,
0.0300356299,
0.5236697197,
-0.3091892898,
1.4681993723,
-0.4240298271,
-0.1942722648,
-0.1937607378,
-1.1091768742,
-0.3902744949,
0.7339735031,
-0.1127997413,
-0.0115971183,
0.6328693628,
0.3915905952,
-0.2170443982,
0.2969638407,
0.4199491441,
-0.0031997331,
-0.0955953598,
0.3602454364,
0.8740269542,
-0.2173079252,
0.4628248215,
-0.3093144894,
-0.4635364115,
-0.1748621017,
-0.8062796593,
-1.247710228,
-0.8056653142,
-0.2821288109,
-0.8243692517,
0.2066818327,
0.7588829398,
0.3743173182,
-1.0334144831,
-0.0883489549,
0.0270223934,
-0.0449113734,
-0.2775519192,
-0.186817959,
0.4307183027,
0.0305712372,
-0.3681534231,
0.031333033,
0.2187372893,
0.0240025967,
-0.5171588063,
0.1638516039,
-0.3846113682,
0.3735475838,
0.2304456383,
0.5395623446,
-0.6916928887,
-0.0680648386,
-0.0515749864,
-0.4420763254,
-0.1852241755,
0.9569607377,
-0.6900854111,
0.8013880253,
1.0237212181,
0.9048087597,
0.2428727001,
-0.202212289,
0.671371758,
0.0483421385,
0.2761643231,
0.4589347839,
0.290630132,
0.2476991415,
-0.7038840652,
0.3528208435,
0.1316986531,
-0.4093312323,
-0.3009438515,
-0.075949721,
-1.1956982613,
0.4524759054,
0.7073270679,
-0.5062107444,
-0.4276652336,
-0.6464908123,
-0.5246526599,
0.6163954735,
0.0380165689,
0.8424052596,
0.9725014567,
-0.0683394894,
-0.6405563951,
-0.5032026768,
0.2957406342,
0.6680291295,
-0.7619983554,
-0.5083401799,
0.1640478671,
0.3059680164,
-0.1990735382,
0.3904217184,
-0.172032699,
0.4342954457,
0.1668531299,
-0.0574464947,
-0.2555707097,
-0.2981173694,
-0.669676125,
-0.2788838744,
-0.0733774975,
-0.0607474595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05432v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05432v1 | Towards End-to-end Speech-to-text Summarization | 2023-06-06T15:22:16 | 2023-06-06T15:22:16 | Raul Monteiro, Diogo Pernes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | Speech-to-text (S2T) summarization is a time-saving technique for filtering
and keeping up with the broadcast news uploaded online on a daily basis. The
rise of large language models from deep learning with impressive text
generation capabilities has placed the research focus on summarization systems
that produce paraphrased compact versions of the document content, also known
as abstractive summaries. End-to-end (E2E) modelling of S2T abstractive
summarization is a promising approach that offers the possibility of generating
rich latent representations that leverage non-verbal and acoustic information,
as opposed to the use of only linguistic information from automatically
generated transcripts in cascade systems. However, the few literature on E2E
modelling of this task fails on exploring different domains, namely broadcast
news, which is challenging domain where large and diversified volumes of data
are presented to the user every day. We model S2T summarization both with a
cascade and an E2E system for a corpus of broadcast news in French. Our novel
E2E model leverages external data by resorting to transfer learning from a
pre-trained T2T summarizer. Experiments show that both our cascade and E2E
abstractive summarizers are stronger than an extractive baseline. However, the
performance of the E2E model still lies behind the cascade one, which is object
of an extensive analysis that includes future directions to close that gap. | [
-0.1646936387,
-0.6206901073,
0.2903980017,
0.382914573,
-0.4370052218,
0.0720035806,
-0.3000965416,
-0.515188694,
0.3156360984,
0.3231880367,
-0.2272200435,
-0.2489205301,
-1.0055924654,
-0.0221628062,
-0.7396526933,
1.446770668,
0.0016218565,
-0.2543862164,
-0.2418694496,
0.0457753278,
-0.1619524062,
-0.4854763746,
-0.8988929391,
-0.190374583,
0.333815366,
0.2929320633,
0.411898762,
0.3688714206,
0.1938756853,
0.1359803379,
-0.3956544995,
-0.0195795093,
-0.9008140564,
0.1020756885,
-0.2956255972,
-0.3248692155,
-0.4188297689,
-0.1937840432,
0.4076426923,
0.6395745277,
-0.102220282,
0.2350372672,
0.340806365,
0.7975797057,
-0.3106864393,
0.3481840789,
-0.2951173782,
-0.2429364771,
0.1630175114,
-0.1740494817,
-0.3202861845,
-0.2317219228,
0.2549255192,
-0.1791972965,
0.0266351737,
-0.3790473342,
0.7769038081,
0.2760935426,
-0.7457792759,
-0.4512394369,
-0.7693482041,
0.3923138082,
-0.8091430664,
0.4034249187,
0.2224144489,
0.3743322194,
0.2208389938,
-1.045930028,
-0.28754884,
-0.0305114724,
-0.037068028,
0.6902036667,
-0.2600013316,
-0.1593559235,
-0.1221773401,
0.1714770943,
-0.6031455994,
0.0938597694,
-0.5983135104,
0.1939459294,
0.5632702112,
-0.1973921061,
0.0884343609,
-0.1432379037,
-0.3759387732,
0.4420795739,
-0.5220972896,
0.0631103963,
0.2388668358,
0.1409312934,
-0.4028392434,
0.639144659,
-0.3732596636,
0.3201772273,
-0.051411815,
0.0310106855,
-0.099848628,
-0.3037494123,
-0.0243467633,
0.1467802227,
0.5650591254,
0.837826252,
0.2707874179,
-0.3682611585,
-0.3810634017,
0.0721619055,
-0.1144373119,
-0.9093487263,
0.1009790972,
0.3808681369,
-0.5875906348,
-0.3803664148,
-0.2919025123,
-0.577008605,
0.1353347152,
-0.5987457037,
0.4166463912,
-0.2513469756,
-0.3865417242,
-0.0360846296,
-0.3764274418,
0.2328195274,
0.3673135042,
-0.7771165967,
0.5163058043,
0.5665204525,
1.1618857384,
-0.2898980677,
-0.0065399776,
-0.2312334925,
0.5473615527,
-0.2826881409,
1.1019643545,
-0.2396862358,
-0.5068188906,
-0.0683970004,
-0.1980633736,
0.0569608174,
-0.2336921841,
0.3504498005,
-0.5516692996,
0.4498016536,
-0.1010620594,
-0.7864999771,
-0.2254457325,
-0.0329792835,
-0.5391939282,
1.0125803947,
0.2725455463,
-0.7706328034,
-0.0159844253,
-0.4258817732,
-0.6424037218,
-0.3882646561,
-0.2453489453,
-0.4780362248,
0.3388023376,
0.2904917598,
0.4373472035,
-0.3317987025,
0.3539956212,
0.165002659,
-0.1637939811,
-0.1253644675,
-0.3425965309,
0.5417955518,
0.1913120598,
-0.10106913,
0.096827887,
-0.6362846494,
-0.4495802224,
0.0223541632,
-0.2640326917,
-0.1521130204,
0.1578492969,
0.410312742,
0.4751438797,
0.3076392114,
-0.3502826095,
-0.0650804564,
-0.3955487013,
0.7572886348,
0.5778284073,
0.2191079259,
0.4892546833,
-0.6103078723,
0.2324047387,
-0.0968684852,
-0.2326626331,
-0.6597732306,
-0.4885775149,
-0.2887514532,
-0.2209074348,
0.4212269187,
0.8723474145,
-0.5332242846,
0.2967066765,
-0.6362953782,
-0.3534545898,
-0.0700855404,
-0.3214101195,
0.1903693527,
0.4146943092,
0.2093574107,
-0.2073108852,
-0.5085657835,
-0.8571602106,
-0.3758690655,
0.0240947064,
-0.1029416621,
-0.0144440103,
0.5591102839,
0.0449608676,
1.0676548481,
-0.1822851896,
-0.3211813271,
-0.6069043875,
0.1748436093,
0.2059110254,
0.2045128196,
0.3901828825,
-0.7273231149,
-0.5119907856,
-0.0012316353,
-1.0752465725,
-0.2527047396,
-0.2703494728,
0.2251960784,
0.0698287636,
0.7810924053,
-0.6024188995,
0.5516535044,
0.4484927058,
-0.1531473994,
0.5562458634,
-0.1672583967,
-0.0944313332,
-1.5780385733,
-0.0429743268,
-0.0420889333,
-0.4899471402,
-0.7232515216,
-0.0085887965,
-0.0474197417,
-0.3261475861,
-0.5300101638,
0.4200776815,
-0.4919012487,
-0.331788063,
-0.5575665832,
0.2963462174,
-0.0091441525,
0.4030585289,
0.3397463858,
0.8188708425,
0.4231023192,
-0.6699057817,
0.1237525344,
0.3497582674,
-0.2269351035,
0.3636041284,
-0.9139629602,
-0.1337450594,
-0.5478820205,
0.7482281327,
-1.2914373875,
-0.2203080505,
-0.2605293393,
-0.7885320187,
0.4320965707,
-0.0744028091,
-0.2928447723,
0.1119322255,
-0.4644833803,
0.5345369577,
0.5818885565,
-0.3591549695,
0.6156389713,
0.3910327852,
-0.869815886,
-0.1990988553,
-0.7174594402,
0.4840576351,
-0.0953575969,
-0.741815567,
0.6946873069,
0.2904187143,
-0.0878026187,
0.1184181273,
-0.0428913757,
0.0687343031,
-0.4022224844,
-0.0982916802,
0.0990262777,
-0.1389550865,
0.0483159572,
0.3753815293,
-0.2216829062,
0.0414050892,
-0.3716457486,
0.3545226455,
0.2373015732,
-0.0122298151,
-0.6264364719,
0.858463943,
0.50578022,
-0.1829255819,
0.7275459766,
0.3545827568,
-0.5880493522,
-0.0589863174,
-0.3805337846,
-0.3061117828,
-0.3206684291,
0.7181475163,
-0.3288573623,
-0.5377176404,
0.7231117487,
-0.2094323933,
0.3440241218,
0.54231143,
0.6087008119,
-0.2256961912,
0.8669413924,
0.4791160226,
0.0018918933,
0.4837088287,
-0.4569008052,
0.115781568,
-0.9431583285,
-0.2460300326,
-0.2227145582,
-0.2123057246,
-0.3743169308,
-0.2678133547,
0.3857817948,
0.2612744868,
0.0847279951,
0.3576537371,
-0.2026439905,
0.4477600455,
0.2200680822,
0.0852093846,
0.3644433618,
0.2413917035,
0.3759576976,
0.1292613596,
-0.6013048291,
-0.5211607814,
1.2020748854,
0.3589652777,
0.5113658905,
0.3224152327,
0.7072998881,
0.394438833,
0.250195533,
-0.7079852819,
0.3409688771,
-0.3712967336,
-0.2255040109,
-0.3648508489,
-0.2520228028,
-0.5621083975,
0.3193280399,
0.2725298703,
-0.5714318752,
0.0649561062,
-0.1090464741,
-0.2397470623,
0.287083745,
-0.5734532475,
0.3906115294,
0.0603237413,
-0.3684290648,
-0.2247917056,
-0.7555974126,
0.2653627992,
-0.0265410487,
0.5930246711,
-0.0151495887,
-0.2869762778,
0.9693989754,
-0.4409227073,
0.9251690507,
0.0702198744,
-0.2925489545,
0.3797491789,
-0.077724956,
0.8860358596,
0.1268048137,
0.0516859554,
0.1867518574,
-0.1238177344,
-0.5847728848,
-0.4806285501,
0.5209120512,
-0.8785840273,
-0.3765317798,
-0.4013682008,
-0.3434833884,
-0.0581536964,
-0.0164659359,
0.7484083772,
0.7118901014,
-0.1692731827,
0.0538821481,
0.5016129017,
-0.141973868,
0.6183395386,
0.441244632,
-0.1792666614,
-0.5800520182,
1.0365144014,
0.4257161617,
0.4412180781,
0.6294331551,
0.058087524,
-0.4918264449,
-0.6337895393,
-0.514215529,
0.2596752048,
-0.7039425969,
0.0186940823,
-0.7794882059,
-0.5833832026,
-0.6445487738,
-0.2354160398,
-0.382455945,
-0.9571507573,
-0.3095648587,
-0.3195413351,
0.1393942386,
0.8139753938,
-0.2103188187,
0.493993789,
-0.6611411572,
0.529351294,
0.1265407056,
0.113952212,
-0.1706832051,
-1.0593826771,
-0.2358455658,
-0.0614493601,
-0.3475367129,
-1.0987945795,
0.3880542219,
0.4845445454,
0.2942509651,
0.1885871887,
-0.0514864251,
0.3244883418,
-0.54946661,
1.0274697542,
0.3339927495,
-0.7950024009,
0.5571985245,
-0.6186279655,
0.2418537587,
0.1559600383,
0.2967922986,
-0.8089625239,
-0.3945637047,
-0.4032385945,
-1.2644515038,
0.4831548929,
0.5527361035,
0.0854737014,
0.001912619,
0.2439087033,
0.3032513261,
0.2072962075,
-0.5730308294,
-0.1848139465,
-0.3719063699,
-0.2524836063,
-0.2076910287,
-0.4876677692,
0.1803071648,
0.0545386896,
0.7929523587,
0.2567931116,
0.4926539063,
0.2134568095,
-0.2328961641,
0.121734269,
0.2511017621,
0.7370731235,
0.5305265188,
-0.2070417255,
-0.0041262568,
0.1868611276,
-0.1928182244,
-0.0331556424,
0.1475456506,
-0.3636391163,
0.2371638417,
0.58830899,
0.7671840191,
0.280947715,
-0.42276752,
0.7133167386,
0.1109014004,
-0.5549448133,
-0.3997760713,
-0.66818434,
0.239369154,
0.0693883151,
0.3498242795,
0.0993054062,
0.3735642731,
-0.589645505,
0.4984134734,
0.0079581086,
-0.4139249623,
-0.4975281656,
1.0968769789,
0.3356134593,
-0.1667376459,
0.2637682557,
-0.0025578041,
-0.364014864,
0.6652086973,
0.7175415754,
0.968080163,
-0.3247069716,
0.1461455226,
0.2219361812,
0.2039554268,
-0.1346236765,
0.2995194197,
-0.1067945734,
-0.2920622826,
-0.7375568151,
-0.4995317459,
-0.1781828851,
0.0595232397,
-0.6793723702,
0.2792648077,
-0.0221716072,
-0.0718947724,
0.0147675602,
-0.5120053887,
-0.2175921798,
0.3098782897,
0.2128436118,
0.9583702087,
-0.9313001633,
0.4390775561,
0.3724432886,
-0.4162850082,
-0.5044391751,
-0.0072090696,
-0.2391189784,
-0.5346342325,
0.4030148089,
0.2125848383,
-0.0381736346,
0.2183965445,
-0.0405437164,
-0.8329493403,
1.0683301687,
0.1608867496,
-0.6573699117,
-0.4922953844,
0.250564754,
0.4116311967,
-0.3824007213,
0.6053802371,
0.4937036335,
0.1067160368,
0.2440052927,
-0.9455820918,
-0.1755788475,
-0.2834300101,
0.0471747257,
0.1703900397,
-0.9095098376,
0.7327342629,
-0.4179027081,
-0.1543028653,
-0.1752757132,
1.0296430588,
-0.1834354997,
0.6241207719,
0.0626891404,
0.5008991361,
0.1800658554,
-0.0283390507,
1.0240069628,
-0.5422293544,
0.3887141049,
1.389931798,
-0.103075251,
1.0914764404,
0.3173918426,
-0.2022454292,
0.3038654029,
0.7759924531,
0.4537255466,
0.7319396138,
-0.0010238804,
-0.3871511221,
0.2072076499,
-0.1012767777,
-0.6141253114,
0.2812041342,
0.5241981745,
-0.4883359969,
-0.5458187461,
0.162816599,
-0.1513183713,
0.1817849427,
-0.4349097013,
1.1146429777,
0.4260981679,
-0.5595548153,
0.4521104991,
0.1592229307,
0.4259920418,
-0.4835568368,
0.2310187668,
-0.307426244,
-0.0947619379,
-0.3628723323,
-0.616783917,
0.6845764518,
-0.0153458249,
-0.2128202021,
-0.2083734423,
0.6261587739,
-0.6471783519,
-0.4983274937,
0.3548832238,
0.6657993793,
0.302208513,
-0.1973261833,
-0.2537978888,
-0.2702269554,
0.0071535325,
-0.5772838593,
0.3228711486,
0.3231419027,
-0.1610017717,
0.4153708518,
0.6433299184,
0.2230681926,
0.0209846869,
0.2662588954,
0.797712326,
-0.5127342343,
-1.1263554096,
-0.9140597582,
0.4574839473,
-0.0518841483,
-0.0679545552,
0.5174141526,
1.0464971066,
0.512455225,
-0.0866330564,
1.291993022,
0.1040445492,
0.6820437908,
-0.4394036531,
0.5257261395,
-0.445494771,
0.2360511273,
0.0826365575,
-0.9577790499,
0.0606751926,
0.2766399384,
-0.1665381491,
-0.0007087716,
0.6580747366,
0.6235951185,
0.0017812976,
0.3755619824,
0.3612575233,
0.248911947,
0.4060783684,
0.560501039,
0.7298586965,
-0.6525771022,
0.623914361,
0.0222212933,
-0.5615561008,
-0.2332744151,
-0.7232475877,
-0.8640127182,
-0.6866284609,
-0.281726867,
-0.2464431971,
0.4004241526,
0.7840628624,
0.6090627313,
-0.7083770633,
-0.277797699,
-0.2335834652,
-0.3336599469,
-0.333833307,
-0.1638534665,
0.6381226778,
-0.2400268167,
-0.6820775867,
0.2265603542,
0.4267640412,
0.1708857417,
0.134982124,
0.0874723718,
0.124677375,
0.3507514,
1.0290286541,
0.1163766533,
-0.5101938844,
0.0107866405,
-0.3167981207,
0.1052469611,
-0.1336032301,
0.7554836273,
-0.6822369695,
0.0388955809,
0.5020671487,
0.6257915497,
0.8528994322,
0.1024330184,
0.6154734492,
-0.8401771784,
-0.0241202675,
0.039410226,
0.1616144627,
0.1889231354,
-0.30408898,
0.3734575808,
0.1815902591,
-0.553003788,
-0.6655759215,
0.3288373947,
-0.9744079113,
-0.3093517423,
1.3933944702,
0.0839056373,
-0.1027814001,
-0.2033629864,
-0.2730681598,
0.5693346858,
-0.5627037883,
0.7385255098,
0.4833785892,
-0.1555786431,
-0.1766272634,
-0.8332104087,
0.5014305115,
0.1973946244,
-0.8389288187,
0.1343691349,
0.0814830735,
0.3940605223,
-0.1909148395,
0.7777685523,
-0.105668433,
0.3065632582,
-0.016408138,
-0.3434159756,
-0.1809119582,
-0.2940498888,
-0.12988244,
0.2848168612,
-0.4053436518,
-0.1433650553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03736v1 | FinRED: A Dataset for Relation Extraction in Financial Domain | 2023-06-06T14:52:47 | 2023-06-06T14:52:47 | Soumya Sharma, Tapas Nayak, Arusarka Bose, Ajay Kumar Meena, Koustuv Dasgupta, Niloy Ganguly, Pawan Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation extraction models trained on a source domain cannot be applied on a
different target domain due to the mismatch between relation sets. In the
current literature, there is no extensive open-source relation extraction
dataset specific to the finance domain. In this paper, we release FinRED, a
relation extraction dataset curated from financial news and earning call
transcripts containing relations from the finance domain. FinRED has been
created by mapping Wikidata triplets using distance supervision method. We
manually annotate the test data to ensure proper evaluation. We also experiment
with various state-of-the-art relation extraction models on this dataset to
create the benchmark. We see a significant drop in their performance on FinRED
compared to the general relation extraction datasets which tells that we need
better models for financial relation extraction. | [
-0.3576007187,
-0.6121360064,
-0.0003867795,
0.0646308064,
-0.2028834522,
-0.0264424272,
-0.1740925461,
-0.8706796765,
-0.0500815585,
0.7532138824,
-0.7360268235,
-0.4436822534,
-0.509088397,
0.0607191473,
-0.2800197601,
1.4674203396,
-0.0714614168,
0.0682249144,
-0.3667425513,
-0.1145161763,
-0.4372208416,
-0.4490356743,
-0.6730797887,
-0.1386980563,
0.3555803597,
0.5109498501,
0.4122558534,
0.6337439418,
1.3040270805,
0.1634220481,
0.269202739,
0.1822075546,
-0.5472542048,
-0.2327735722,
-0.2553503513,
-0.074014239,
-0.5503801107,
0.3607364893,
0.2706446648,
0.7552170157,
0.0951870531,
0.599781096,
-0.3844926953,
0.9400105476,
-0.7593432069,
0.6751074791,
-0.320194006,
-0.0814846084,
-0.5411319733,
-0.0151771521,
-0.1481176615,
-0.5912978053,
0.4895666242,
-0.6808524728,
0.5071949959,
0.4059002697,
1.2125095129,
-0.068629995,
-0.3572923541,
-0.3982209265,
-0.9782853127,
0.3249040842,
-0.4973142743,
0.6986187696,
0.513751626,
0.7033002377,
0.2395891994,
-0.7506583333,
-0.2106264681,
0.2316898704,
-0.1359965056,
-0.1168711632,
-0.174215138,
-0.1267690808,
0.0213369932,
0.7078720927,
0.0579546317,
-0.3175306916,
-0.8760066032,
0.0126353065,
0.7777382731,
-0.0013938423,
-0.0158123467,
-0.2775643766,
-0.6725467443,
-0.3844955266,
-0.8705283999,
-0.022073213,
0.5728956461,
0.6995994449,
-0.147973597,
0.5073618889,
0.0460334681,
0.7570005655,
0.1724185646,
-0.368483454,
0.2660390735,
-0.2673017383,
-0.295722127,
0.1960239261,
0.8022851348,
0.6236135364,
0.5149300098,
-0.2299696952,
-0.2464140803,
-0.4044704437,
0.0752995536,
-0.4441465437,
-0.4781933427,
0.1240832284,
-0.5199697018,
-0.378559649,
0.5694457293,
-0.8210368156,
0.0571713932,
-0.1836348921,
0.1333224028,
-0.333940208,
-0.6059622765,
0.1517411768,
-0.3845450878,
0.3141814768,
-0.2147238106,
-1.2145335674,
0.6979039311,
0.9601474404,
0.5451194644,
-0.254395932,
-0.0524559282,
-0.4955035746,
0.3109238744,
-0.2447125316,
0.742869854,
-0.3117876053,
-0.2163337171,
-0.0679925829,
-0.1559169888,
-0.2369676828,
-0.6909053922,
0.408308506,
-0.8442946076,
0.2364163697,
-0.2616527081,
-0.8775169253,
-0.30843696,
-0.3087011278,
-1.0334786177,
0.780174613,
0.7212878466,
-1.045363903,
0.5435849428,
-0.8455303907,
-0.2935079634,
0.2366482168,
-0.1806788146,
-0.4247914851,
-0.2336052805,
0.1249002665,
0.5569579601,
-0.6151406169,
0.5199517608,
-0.5131380558,
-0.2919564247,
0.1436723918,
-0.0115575753,
0.694458425,
0.017663382,
-0.1828527451,
-0.2074368447,
-0.918554008,
-0.3626940846,
0.1289101243,
0.1011716276,
-0.8879756927,
-0.1674564183,
0.3688971698,
0.2625885904,
0.1817871779,
-0.7086097598,
0.1192516088,
-0.5225852132,
0.1709896177,
0.6627227664,
0.4274508357,
0.3697776198,
-0.3058539927,
0.4560176432,
-0.1270950437,
0.1167747304,
0.3899927735,
-0.0559735633,
-0.5263435245,
-0.3023362458,
0.5374749303,
0.4599817991,
-0.430593878,
0.254566431,
-0.55230546,
-0.4550261497,
-0.5165658593,
0.1578330547,
0.5575990677,
0.7536327839,
0.1246840656,
0.2073648721,
-0.5650454164,
-1.2581129074,
-0.2704363763,
-0.0251623485,
0.0997405574,
0.1850603223,
0.3958332241,
0.1170666516,
1.2082881927,
-0.9572069645,
-0.4312973022,
0.0401096418,
-0.1470081955,
0.3118223548,
0.3527097404,
0.8316833973,
-1.2747116089,
-0.2541663945,
0.1443220377,
-0.7840899825,
0.2522456944,
0.0396823585,
-0.3973002434,
-0.2433438599,
0.4424827397,
-0.4159181714,
0.4191598594,
0.3647271991,
-0.4818084836,
0.6237475276,
0.3494035304,
0.0599534772,
-1.0090489388,
0.4756740332,
0.1582630575,
-0.3533014059,
-0.5660649538,
-0.0611707903,
0.1308749765,
0.1490483135,
-0.3091900349,
0.6966346502,
-0.3074688613,
-0.5570381284,
0.0553944781,
0.2494874448,
0.1175958589,
0.5554745793,
0.0704862252,
0.7013732791,
0.2499767691,
-0.6149060726,
0.7690181136,
0.7681289315,
-0.4050188363,
0.6477422714,
-0.3571310341,
-0.1303343028,
0.3626534343,
-0.2295815051,
-0.7776888609,
-0.2867136002,
0.5640007854,
-0.0923037976,
0.1888767928,
-0.195145607,
-0.2862808108,
-0.3439680636,
-0.1353577524,
0.3156722188,
-0.0173758119,
-0.8034454584,
0.1571268588,
0.2769454122,
-0.6280333996,
-0.6077241898,
-0.5015448928,
-0.4309916496,
-0.4087777436,
-0.5588997006,
0.3162848651,
0.1095717028,
-0.7213559747,
0.3382649422,
-0.5357273817,
-0.3531031013,
-0.022108471,
0.5020213127,
0.8661981225,
-0.4786795974,
0.2706377208,
-0.1449460387,
-0.1723473221,
0.3024266362,
0.0946073905,
-0.1102717072,
0.0703216642,
-0.0879999027,
-0.1311992258,
0.364851594,
0.4460703433,
-0.2228372693,
0.6697900891,
0.203381449,
-0.5670275688,
0.1423897147,
-0.6427120566,
0.1269988567,
-0.4815406501,
0.0621352382,
-0.5901198983,
-0.8229511976,
0.5777183175,
-0.1066302732,
0.3362105191,
1.0624747276,
-0.0821073875,
0.1511385739,
0.0327933207,
0.9554404616,
-0.2102432102,
0.2657700479,
-0.3334758282,
0.1926730275,
-0.6472153068,
-0.5511140823,
-0.507553041,
0.3068476617,
-0.2602151334,
0.3742360175,
-0.1184192225,
0.2617831826,
-0.1606008559,
0.6527293921,
-0.2225348502,
0.455869019,
0.3072987795,
-0.0198614094,
0.5052115321,
0.1888329983,
-0.0232681576,
-0.1839598119,
-0.4488070011,
-0.1710315347,
0.9627539515,
0.1173239052,
0.3168098032,
-0.0851536393,
0.5364524722,
0.5233328342,
0.4696095884,
-0.575843513,
-0.0748785883,
-0.1311834306,
-0.642303586,
-0.3511912227,
-0.9738155007,
-0.6511319876,
-0.246271804,
-0.0923413634,
-0.5854073763,
0.5984745026,
-0.4596306682,
-0.4336049557,
0.418235302,
-0.445561558,
0.9177836776,
-0.0291107669,
-0.1481633335,
0.3794908524,
-0.5992261171,
0.8531109095,
-0.6267113686,
0.6364550591,
-0.3300005794,
0.4069868028,
1.1885690689,
-0.8520326614,
0.3846825063,
-0.1121002138,
-0.4200997949,
0.1931613088,
0.0035228978,
0.1085453033,
0.0095832851,
-0.2429161221,
0.2918427885,
0.2793205976,
-0.1796068698,
-0.3391946852,
0.5753000975,
-0.577293396,
-0.1374581754,
-0.2954873443,
-0.3840060532,
-0.4933759868,
0.3056571484,
0.1388969868,
0.5929288268,
-0.4602112174,
-0.1264362484,
0.0669802427,
0.3536115587,
0.595842123,
0.366769135,
-0.3661788106,
-0.8333474398,
0.8674991727,
-0.1973244101,
0.0945293382,
0.171676144,
-0.1999457628,
-0.4672838449,
-0.0221976228,
-0.1274837106,
0.4040335119,
-0.7311222553,
-0.6414598823,
-0.2310933471,
-0.441537559,
-0.5423939824,
-0.049525544,
-0.4689381123,
-0.5674672127,
-0.171972543,
-0.3381876349,
0.973968029,
1.0021548271,
-0.3252925575,
0.2038838863,
-1.0530868769,
0.5524535775,
0.1395460069,
0.5747068524,
-0.1806302518,
-0.047594998,
-0.5440127254,
-0.1109696701,
0.2151942849,
-0.4103139937,
0.3592766225,
0.2949281633,
0.2536382377,
0.76013726,
0.2018160969,
0.9025706649,
-0.0778366178,
0.2083448172,
0.2964025736,
-0.6542925835,
0.4154027104,
-0.4297318459,
-0.2084991038,
0.8524751663,
0.5666338205,
-0.2769307792,
-0.1445937008,
-0.9093314409,
-0.6334120631,
0.7699350715,
0.1885255575,
-0.30974406,
0.1133752242,
0.7774623036,
0.6244621873,
0.334376514,
-0.0872997269,
-0.53180933,
0.2861344218,
0.0025721353,
-0.1255990714,
-0.3332565129,
-0.0325771309,
-0.1742369533,
0.6657840014,
0.4241745174,
0.1785885245,
0.1980505437,
0.2673003376,
-0.4153411984,
-0.3631643951,
0.087746866,
0.9779976606,
-0.6985156536,
-0.1997048557,
-0.4510851204,
-0.6334314346,
-0.0000915527,
0.6208135486,
0.1261679679,
0.2015405744,
0.6061949134,
0.4778265059,
0.6766178608,
-0.48849231,
0.8123897314,
-0.2445940226,
-0.5074459314,
-0.4700241387,
-0.0692205131,
0.0108785275,
0.3050097525,
0.7819750309,
0.3447193205,
0.0380931571,
-0.1351249665,
0.6779208183,
-0.0820666477,
-0.4018418193,
-0.001646518,
0.8025529385,
0.1184289604,
-0.2500039935,
1.0882470608,
0.2323725373,
-0.2034679651,
0.4258136153,
0.2663077712,
0.6486752033,
0.0534832776,
0.0972939804,
0.3217536509,
-0.2336714119,
-0.2614632547,
0.0899259895,
-0.1421203166,
-0.5981964469,
-0.5516476035,
-0.6261613369,
-0.4674794674,
0.166051209,
-1.3246850967,
0.2749694586,
-0.4298689663,
-0.2916070223,
0.3218682706,
0.4079894722,
-0.6523761749,
0.0760618746,
-0.318582058,
0.9562931061,
-0.7088838816,
0.5516578555,
0.0970778093,
-0.4425433576,
-0.6563378572,
-0.3937638402,
-0.1291673928,
-0.2383884788,
0.9375032187,
-0.071405232,
-0.1406602561,
-0.0157420933,
-0.5012426972,
-0.6949373484,
0.9455732703,
0.4036926031,
-0.5645151138,
-0.0812994167,
-0.0028024397,
-0.0135691678,
-0.6802184582,
-0.3223608434,
0.7101165652,
0.3583747447,
0.1216907054,
-0.8662993908,
-0.0625534579,
-0.3767392635,
-0.4548221827,
0.4456400573,
-0.6140007973,
0.8460240364,
0.0092329532,
-0.2656063139,
-0.106896624,
0.6891520619,
0.0833659545,
0.3818089068,
0.2200930268,
0.1245149449,
0.790818274,
-0.0817653313,
0.9302929044,
-0.1877438724,
0.5489729643,
1.4053792953,
-0.3948035538,
0.9019682407,
0.2789940536,
-0.007645024,
0.4866161942,
0.7376147509,
-0.3818069696,
0.6190254092,
-0.1431159079,
-0.1223833263,
-0.21710217,
0.1492717117,
-0.3410345614,
0.5360178351,
0.2766028941,
-0.4653931558,
-0.1532871127,
-0.1324991733,
0.0634922385,
0.0204593781,
-0.1771392226,
0.7179276347,
0.2270939648,
-0.1635702401,
0.28494367,
0.0346127972,
0.3965648413,
-0.6743300557,
-0.242796585,
-0.1641887575,
-0.0066823973,
-0.1733709127,
-0.1708797365,
0.3089452386,
0.0389512889,
-0.3014174402,
0.0073205386,
0.9749971628,
-0.3181072772,
-0.5100685358,
0.3971834481,
0.7949227095,
0.1468471885,
-0.038770359,
-0.3611076772,
-0.2291697264,
-0.1513770521,
-0.2211365253,
0.1232605502,
0.4699683487,
0.1589102745,
0.5716413856,
0.9601795077,
0.1474288106,
-0.4228816032,
-0.2343083769,
0.7320236564,
-0.860024631,
-0.3016315997,
-0.813862443,
-0.1167612672,
-0.363355577,
-0.4444054961,
0.7620051503,
0.8859142661,
0.6806622148,
-0.2256011516,
0.7238516808,
0.1407773495,
0.5651915073,
-0.4456858039,
0.6926057339,
-0.0274158996,
0.1555980295,
-0.5530840755,
-0.9973238707,
-0.4098534286,
0.4839316905,
-0.3677763641,
-0.0388938263,
0.6637654901,
0.3064240813,
-0.4226782918,
0.5516937375,
0.0850366428,
-0.2133360803,
-0.1636433899,
0.426605314,
0.4121824801,
-0.7601283193,
0.6228434443,
-0.4825850129,
0.1356283724,
-0.2807464302,
-0.6751707196,
-1.0226686001,
-0.7217879295,
-0.4052150249,
-0.0295229536,
0.1516094506,
0.710488081,
0.5333895087,
-0.5089389682,
-0.3369167149,
0.1972280294,
0.0531522892,
-0.3993728459,
-0.3020280302,
0.812240243,
0.2266148925,
-0.3806788921,
0.3510623872,
0.1419451982,
0.3171027303,
-0.2146019489,
0.145887807,
-0.2644019723,
-0.3192786574,
0.2457488626,
0.3437975049,
-0.0298664924,
-0.4389973283,
-0.2199943513,
-0.1213128418,
0.0572982617,
0.7645162344,
-0.3301489949,
-0.0464062653,
0.121533528,
0.3918807805,
0.6275500655,
0.2572520673,
0.9364703298,
-0.6769168377,
-0.0253453944,
-0.2538608015,
0.0249960013,
0.3256169558,
-0.706564784,
0.9423411489,
0.1839185655,
-0.2496822178,
-0.3879000843,
-0.2496021986,
-0.8791257143,
-0.1116187498,
0.9861053824,
-0.2035745829,
-0.4816299081,
-0.3535223603,
0.1302117556,
0.1243269145,
-0.4097671211,
0.3663988113,
0.6922514439,
-0.0752900615,
0.1101074964,
-0.6643427014,
0.8218564987,
-0.4566192627,
-0.5644747615,
0.5705344677,
0.4395334721,
0.6278714538,
0.1307604462,
0.6806622744,
-0.2901721895,
0.3766672015,
0.2823077738,
0.0965060219,
-0.4190607369,
-0.2330862582,
0.01216566,
0.277299881,
-0.2887297571,
-0.2522786558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03734v2 | A Cross-Linguistic Pressure for Uniform Information Density in Word Order | 2023-06-06T14:52:15 | 2023-07-09T17:17:39 | Thomas Hikaru Clark, Clara Meister, Tiago Pimentel, Michael Hahn, Ryan Cotterell, Richard Futrell, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL | While natural languages differ widely in both canonical word order and word
order flexibility, their word orders still follow shared cross-linguistic
statistical patterns, often attributed to functional pressures. In the effort
to identify these pressures, prior work has compared real and counterfactual
word orders. Yet one functional pressure has been overlooked in such
investigations: the uniform information density (UID) hypothesis, which holds
that information should be spread evenly throughout an utterance. Here, we ask
whether a pressure for UID may have influenced word order patterns
cross-linguistically. To this end, we use computational models to test whether
real orders lead to greater information uniformity than counterfactual orders.
In our empirical study of 10 typologically diverse languages, we find that: (i)
among SVO languages, real word orders consistently have greater uniformity than
reverse word orders, and (ii) only linguistically implausible counterfactual
orders consistently exceed the uniformity of real orders. These findings are
compatible with a pressure for information uniformity in the development and
usage of natural languages. | [
-0.3409764469,
-0.7239513993,
0.4168376327,
0.6764034033,
-0.3485169709,
-0.0634451807,
-0.0067788484,
-0.9616370201,
0.4722678959,
0.5231160522,
-0.1496439129,
-0.3829250932,
-0.7940590978,
0.0918357149,
-0.1819100529,
0.7124792337,
-0.093940869,
0.2510991395,
-0.0298854653,
-0.6722362041,
-0.3727648556,
-0.9733726382,
0.030609753,
-0.2310554832,
0.6719724536,
0.1498380899,
1.1348598003,
0.7475321293,
0.4352376461,
0.3109820783,
0.2651159167,
-0.0496727116,
-0.3786970377,
0.2476188391,
-0.2149089724,
-0.4953465164,
0.1137738898,
0.1193091944,
0.5439625382,
0.965602994,
-0.4301726222,
-0.0357386507,
0.1572617888,
0.6687687039,
-0.6684436798,
0.0473187827,
-0.3341519535,
0.004962028,
-0.2043801397,
-0.3488905728,
-0.4715136886,
-0.4877046347,
0.2936942577,
-0.6497229338,
-0.1397966295,
0.1000158191,
0.9759812355,
0.1238987222,
-0.0928100049,
-0.2489861399,
-0.9701012969,
0.7273161411,
-0.1897800416,
0.6783072352,
0.2319209725,
-0.1470496058,
-0.2159265876,
-0.4173049033,
-0.7079069018,
-0.058315672,
0.055876933,
0.1674510539,
-0.1438442469,
0.0752250552,
0.1499921381,
-0.019221684,
-0.6301664114,
0.2207498252,
-0.0429070853,
0.3644245267,
0.6105898023,
0.0742375404,
0.6108393073,
0.1125160232,
-0.2639606297,
-0.3051824868,
-0.7142207026,
0.1743162572,
0.2798262239,
0.2573464215,
-0.2809855938,
0.655551374,
-0.3550584912,
0.6906875372,
-0.133551538,
0.1334605515,
0.3513583541,
-0.4363510609,
-0.3753122985,
0.1054120734,
0.8389350176,
0.2640332878,
0.558408916,
-0.093649298,
-0.0120142577,
0.0192403905,
0.3969430029,
-0.508002162,
0.0914989412,
-0.0789201036,
-0.2591377497,
-0.3156927228,
0.7056491375,
-0.409565419,
-0.2892897427,
-0.2831825018,
0.3160953522,
-0.50016433,
-0.3073880672,
0.0584177263,
-0.3252596259,
0.1936846673,
0.2007454485,
-0.9925249219,
0.1899968535,
0.7618818879,
0.7234318256,
-0.286300391,
-0.4045476019,
0.0534753017,
-0.0103611741,
-0.7052085996,
0.8676270843,
-1.0316545963,
-0.428380698,
-0.0429258347,
-0.1692483574,
-0.2280651927,
-0.6661518812,
0.4637793303,
-0.2352202833,
0.0233654417,
-0.532515645,
-0.4893244803,
-0.1836147308,
0.0271010213,
-0.3277942836,
1.1394524574,
0.2837564647,
-0.7343510389,
0.7160024047,
0.0952117667,
-0.3891125023,
0.2904503345,
-0.8433653712,
-0.020730136,
0.4260741472,
-0.552442193,
0.2550991774,
-0.260748148,
0.0634927452,
-0.6368403435,
-0.3772374392,
0.566375196,
-0.2757160664,
0.6418381333,
-0.0068668881,
-0.5974405408,
-0.4400751293,
-0.5537514687,
0.3182014227,
0.1253186315,
-0.3492713869,
-0.9616831541,
0.1273291409,
-0.2648638785,
0.1882005185,
-0.092842266,
-0.6286907792,
0.4121609926,
-0.1647001803,
-0.2163505703,
0.7651386857,
0.0672648475,
0.4641909003,
-0.5209397674,
0.3675566018,
-0.0296132807,
0.2816104293,
0.7959973812,
-0.9313155413,
-0.3339746296,
-0.2734493613,
0.2763359249,
0.9837315679,
-0.5561898351,
0.3718938828,
-0.3233687282,
-0.5088766217,
-0.5399923921,
-0.0335673429,
0.5335504413,
0.3117378056,
0.1338648647,
-0.3037494123,
-0.2973617911,
-0.9390593171,
-0.4494370818,
-0.3409425914,
0.1410792768,
0.5212789774,
0.0002494033,
-0.3581380546,
0.763689816,
-0.4681154788,
0.0286766831,
-0.2445414811,
0.6772521734,
0.2854145169,
0.3320890665,
0.7432565093,
-1.0743224621,
-0.6215891242,
0.1823682189,
-0.5845119953,
-0.4378817379,
0.0223995838,
-0.2370610237,
0.5517971516,
0.3018967211,
-0.6307822466,
0.4579963684,
0.5704886317,
-0.3057718873,
0.5554493666,
-0.537884295,
0.1443702132,
-0.6964014769,
-0.3489266634,
-0.2834557593,
0.3308740258,
-0.9788297415,
-0.0205571447,
-0.0367317311,
0.3956724703,
-0.195334658,
0.4825458229,
-0.2953468263,
0.0272467397,
-0.0686948597,
-0.1816314757,
-0.1753165126,
0.1948725283,
0.2588600814,
0.396646589,
0.2947143018,
-0.8072865009,
0.029517889,
-0.119801946,
-0.5582046509,
0.5043949485,
-0.6081435084,
-0.3254463673,
-0.2169829458,
0.0008277405,
-1.3016394377,
-0.04435011,
-0.0777839571,
-0.2592875957,
0.2194818258,
-0.0451528057,
-0.666228354,
0.0995677114,
-0.1570295393,
0.5108969212,
0.4645238519,
-0.4064727724,
0.1837087721,
0.5527598858,
-0.2623409927,
-0.5097362995,
-0.9445492029,
-0.3260322511,
0.1653259844,
-0.7432512045,
0.3095801771,
-0.4395442307,
-0.7338966727,
-0.0509717613,
-0.157833457,
-0.2749217749,
-0.1015832201,
0.3918735683,
0.3613501489,
-0.1718850732,
0.2422623485,
-0.0824263841,
0.3758650422,
-0.01344587,
-0.3858899772,
0.5786876082,
0.2612690032,
-0.1066447124,
-0.0323913991,
0.4328956902,
0.4575468898,
0.4180594087,
0.9316009283,
0.1851773709,
-0.1442295015,
-0.1905840784,
-0.6712540984,
0.2200525701,
-0.5076838136,
-0.0386055335,
-0.5188239813,
-0.4246180952,
0.3794701695,
0.3690742552,
0.2518789768,
0.3511920869,
0.2593146265,
-0.347428143,
1.2227329016,
0.6052321196,
0.0666425452,
0.7104705572,
-0.0294650141,
-0.1452409476,
-0.2379086614,
-0.0651340634,
-0.6248208284,
-0.304528743,
-1.0366379023,
-0.3995850384,
0.0071912697,
0.2177899331,
0.1537835747,
0.0325030982,
-0.4868872166,
0.3603979647,
0.3593683541,
-0.3587646186,
0.151556313,
0.0908329636,
-0.3673829138,
-0.1067320034,
-0.6564600468,
-0.075584814,
0.660398066,
-0.2192109525,
0.8409346938,
0.1289864033,
0.8936107159,
0.3162899911,
0.2892000079,
-0.4985358119,
0.3427962065,
-0.6160469055,
-0.2766346335,
-0.3117879331,
-0.4671939313,
-1.3593176603,
0.3600257933,
-0.28267169,
-0.7458876371,
0.8409575224,
-0.1828516275,
-0.1158028767,
-0.0558764525,
-1.0293307304,
0.4924919605,
-0.1261693835,
0.0078016603,
0.0092246607,
-0.3905462325,
0.1889114082,
0.0986246318,
0.5844317675,
-0.0875392258,
-0.153327629,
0.8130297065,
-0.6788509488,
0.658190906,
-0.0067102755,
-0.2232794613,
0.3875154257,
0.2613226175,
0.5662559867,
0.0048178323,
-0.048512049,
0.2290014774,
0.0571219511,
-0.52456671,
-0.5624328256,
0.7163851261,
-0.9429674745,
-0.381426096,
-0.4473609328,
-0.6072599888,
0.0104899397,
0.0630767271,
0.8725084662,
0.5614231825,
-0.1603924632,
0.0903882459,
0.7617849112,
0.0980696157,
0.3855947256,
0.5159229636,
0.1446769983,
-0.2180622816,
1.0581235886,
1.0058438778,
0.5643042922,
0.6240356565,
0.365188688,
-0.0302144364,
-0.3716029227,
-0.26266554,
0.2291824073,
-0.4127902687,
0.2620025277,
-0.5909413099,
-0.1967625767,
-0.6481176615,
-0.4886713922,
-0.3346672058,
-0.5929852724,
-0.0076554767,
0.0285602845,
0.251755923,
1.12555933,
0.1740512848,
-0.062973544,
-0.7322386503,
0.6961589456,
0.2321256399,
0.4900920093,
-0.4773943424,
-0.4473642707,
0.2969563007,
0.1534477919,
0.1179955229,
-0.8540923595,
0.3311112225,
-0.066069901,
0.7536845207,
0.379696846,
0.3657847345,
0.6204962134,
-0.4145219624,
0.4409456253,
0.1621068716,
-0.4731479883,
-0.0985412449,
-0.2835589647,
0.6131923199,
0.3843084276,
0.5684313178,
-0.829413712,
-0.8531313539,
-0.9591148496,
-0.7725848556,
0.444701761,
-0.0410974286,
0.0267361682,
-0.1582698226,
0.1549050361,
0.4532235563,
0.010253014,
-0.6990205646,
-0.1799001992,
-0.1295465231,
-0.2123963088,
0.0546988137,
-0.179162994,
0.0202452857,
-0.0139511582,
0.1487958878,
0.2185774148,
0.4241832793,
0.5582925677,
-0.1646293551,
0.025072841,
0.4568189979,
0.9326624274,
0.6909056306,
-0.1342869103,
0.2489160001,
-0.1930228472,
-0.8900409937,
0.1105836704,
0.0932221711,
-0.4669727981,
0.3013337255,
0.3259310424,
0.6654189825,
0.1920392215,
-0.4711793959,
0.2268029302,
-0.2466995567,
-0.4433538616,
-0.1693295985,
0.1817329377,
-0.2439084202,
0.1414659768,
0.4361253381,
-0.1079566553,
-0.0872877762,
-0.9701930881,
0.0603822172,
0.5504783392,
-0.3519606888,
-0.2066308409,
-0.0653894246,
-0.1958684325,
-0.3534008861,
0.4229900241,
-0.2600626945,
-0.4183746278,
0.5514365435,
0.3931963742,
0.6012663841,
-0.3241539299,
0.2388510555,
-0.0795686692,
0.3939435184,
-0.386170119,
1.0540282726,
0.0240444317,
-0.8400918245,
-0.0722239017,
-0.3415831327,
-0.4440072179,
-0.1052883267,
-0.5454627275,
0.1713570952,
-0.7732141614,
-0.0461259559,
0.141519174,
-0.1547934711,
-0.3430042267,
0.2830213308,
0.0280077774,
0.6546226144,
-0.5711259246,
0.8805966973,
0.3460882902,
-0.1944635808,
-0.7239621282,
0.1388991773,
-0.2748531103,
-0.7848141193,
0.7178962231,
0.0611321442,
-0.1359963268,
-0.1627601236,
-0.6224389076,
-0.9854616523,
0.6165097356,
0.084769547,
-0.3890333474,
0.2767762244,
0.4572097659,
0.8093848228,
-0.5402896404,
0.1185515597,
0.080417268,
0.5322992802,
-0.0559002273,
-0.6120858788,
0.1735145748,
-0.2101024091,
-0.0328550972,
0.6729772687,
-0.5079592466,
0.7579123974,
-0.1976049542,
-0.549564302,
-0.0080827568,
0.4260440469,
0.1641597748,
0.0729143098,
0.6145261526,
0.435120374,
0.689278543,
-0.1781232506,
1.4092310667,
-0.1760891676,
-0.1809730232,
0.833501935,
-0.3109233379,
0.916477561,
0.5748307705,
-0.1076569781,
0.7322850823,
0.424534291,
0.1146097705,
0.496827662,
0.3171983361,
0.0957690105,
0.0290194713,
-0.3998404145,
-0.4098110795,
0.2299674749,
0.3781967461,
-0.0647350252,
0.1742652506,
-0.1642412692,
-0.3283151984,
-0.160428673,
0.0497479104,
0.7128981352,
0.0541881435,
-0.7651354074,
1.0776845217,
-0.2652179599,
0.5697062016,
-0.7238556147,
0.0277232081,
-0.1988613904,
-0.0736591071,
-0.0744068697,
-1.0565451384,
0.1311085373,
-0.2633116841,
-0.2523436546,
-0.4899740517,
0.1665734202,
-0.428732276,
-0.3176889718,
0.6524036527,
0.2369248122,
0.0153731741,
0.1836996228,
-0.4003130198,
-0.1478648633,
-0.3609427214,
-0.3960721791,
0.4984163642,
0.6282606721,
-0.3896227777,
0.4459044039,
0.6905053258,
0.2848967314,
0.6137190461,
0.1779402643,
0.2725266218,
-0.4459994733,
-0.8278133869,
-0.6177319288,
0.0383819714,
-0.2253884673,
-0.5149529576,
0.5194339156,
0.1815001518,
0.9501265883,
0.0709596798,
0.6891224384,
-0.1668362916,
0.2969091535,
-0.24547185,
0.4769069552,
-0.4343834519,
-0.1011117771,
-0.4664836824,
-0.8749116063,
-0.3210066855,
0.2239216715,
-0.2059878111,
-0.2176357806,
0.8761262298,
0.4187867641,
-0.0408575796,
0.1277861893,
0.4452318847,
0.4110281169,
-0.1026380807,
0.1182897091,
0.7339071631,
-0.1104430109,
0.7105147243,
-0.5335339308,
-0.1952902824,
-0.2100788057,
-0.4351454079,
-0.4907601476,
-0.6104849577,
-0.0666065067,
-0.367910713,
0.0250859931,
0.8699717522,
0.5903733969,
-0.5193229318,
-0.4756356478,
-0.4577178657,
0.233390972,
-0.412117213,
-0.3086424768,
-0.1200385392,
-0.1431992799,
-0.5935451984,
0.2000640035,
0.4679281414,
0.5102461576,
0.4245366156,
-0.1401269734,
-0.4076922834,
0.6807674766,
0.4359129667,
0.6316580772,
-0.6628710628,
-0.4359919429,
0.0654149204,
-0.7984947562,
0.0416715518,
0.8895791173,
-0.3781929612,
0.2842494845,
1.1540560722,
0.5879187584,
-0.0220574308,
-0.0681976005,
0.832449317,
-0.8938878775,
0.33879143,
-0.0725558251,
0.3286094666,
-0.1763287634,
-0.6194210649,
0.3769384623,
0.590810895,
-0.272526145,
-0.7589592934,
0.5007603168,
-1.0186314583,
-0.6593894362,
1.3284112215,
0.0832721442,
-0.0672716498,
-0.3201147318,
-0.0335350819,
0.0686718896,
-0.319139868,
1.026804924,
1.0242732763,
-0.2792224288,
0.1635699719,
-0.4814814627,
0.4333940148,
0.7779653072,
-0.6324183345,
0.10331586,
0.084048681,
0.0267279409,
0.3965631425,
0.7040664554,
0.1590451151,
0.2844946086,
-0.1574765891,
-0.3612681627,
0.5044767261,
-0.3473408222,
-0.2801588774,
0.2188768089,
-0.2401150614,
0.0236378293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03733v1 | A Novel Approach To User Agent String Parsing For Vulnerability Analysis Using Mutli-Headed Attention | 2023-06-06T14:49:25 | 2023-06-06T14:49:25 | Dhruv Nandakumar, Sathvik Murli, Ankur Khosla, Kevin Choi, Abdul Rahman, Drew Walsh, Scott Riede, Eric Dull, Edward Bowen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | The increasing reliance on the internet has led to the proliferation of a
diverse set of web-browsers and operating systems (OSs) capable of browsing the
web. User agent strings (UASs) are a component of web browsing that are
transmitted with every Hypertext Transfer Protocol (HTTP) request. They contain
information about the client device and software, which is used by web servers
for various purposes such as content negotiation and security. However, due to
the proliferation of various browsers and devices, parsing UASs is a
non-trivial task due to a lack of standardization of UAS formats. Current
rules-based approaches are often brittle and can fail when encountering such
non-standard formats. In this work, a novel methodology for parsing UASs using
Multi-Headed Attention Based transformers is proposed. The proposed methodology
exhibits strong performance in parsing a variety of UASs with differing
formats. Furthermore, a framework to utilize parsed UASs to estimate the
vulnerability scores for large sections of publicly visible IT networks or
regions is also discussed. The methodology present here can also be easily
extended or deployed for real-time parsing of logs in enterprise settings. | [
-0.5201281309,
-0.8244700432,
0.3166566491,
0.3753123283,
-0.1327778697,
0.1086307466,
-0.0862449408,
-0.5140684843,
0.1545514315,
0.3361412287,
-0.5265908837,
-0.472854495,
-0.1333456337,
0.2091488987,
-0.1140165925,
1.0495042801,
0.4623022676,
-0.570859313,
0.268427372,
-0.1836173981,
-0.4813031554,
-0.4500958025,
-0.5432463884,
0.4163672626,
0.6478270888,
0.4651940167,
0.431817174,
0.6792759895,
0.9242824316,
0.3615448773,
0.1608559936,
-0.2574512959,
0.0553196818,
0.1804167032,
-0.4075832069,
-0.1363548785,
-0.7446553707,
-0.1197505668,
0.661595881,
0.4095689058,
-0.0456003509,
0.4570117891,
0.1322962642,
0.4288703203,
-0.734135747,
-0.2618736625,
-0.8071904182,
0.0896024927,
-0.5415156484,
-0.598277986,
-0.5914586782,
0.1057802141,
0.2102190852,
-0.2704077363,
0.2502528727,
-0.0387557112,
0.5895820856,
0.0645741373,
-0.6837769747,
0.3001974523,
-0.3268924952,
1.0446668863,
-0.6603346467,
0.5424380898,
-0.0066397488,
0.5326780081,
-0.3732514977,
-0.4673394859,
-0.3317812681,
0.1751453876,
-0.0673850626,
-0.1220694855,
-0.316875577,
0.0232937522,
0.2813705504,
0.2477493286,
-0.723064065,
-0.0674726516,
0.2431993186,
-0.3781217933,
0.3840025663,
0.1239760369,
0.1954324841,
-0.2167100906,
-0.7661739588,
-0.2222377658,
-0.3684906363,
0.2805500031,
0.190848738,
0.6187655926,
-0.1398050785,
0.4031515718,
-0.041030053,
0.8115166426,
0.2974705994,
-0.5143669248,
0.2371184826,
-0.1725745797,
-0.3377630115,
-0.2478890121,
0.6974160671,
0.3239916563,
0.1359275877,
-0.1813811362,
0.0499996915,
0.0838410407,
0.6805322766,
-0.4787778258,
0.2161696255,
0.335490942,
-0.498790592,
-0.1651757658,
-0.0026833145,
-1.623383522,
-0.44878003,
0.0445543155,
-0.0496109612,
-0.1630202979,
-0.2567242682,
-0.0752965212,
-0.2436357141,
0.4389365017,
0.0497902781,
-0.7077442408,
0.0979790315,
0.4237549305,
0.6971297264,
-0.0416693762,
-0.4515808225,
-0.743391633,
0.4203248024,
0.4921996593,
0.9979826212,
-0.5545713902,
-0.0590495318,
-0.1836279333,
-0.1769882739,
-0.2130352557,
-0.1466015428,
0.6715566516,
-0.550819397,
-0.3978697658,
-0.0501905344,
0.0883915722,
-0.1280209869,
0.4922149181,
-0.6399794817,
0.8063080311,
0.1180613488,
-1.0591422319,
0.0514019951,
-0.5965629816,
-0.7352084517,
0.0973886997,
-0.1384244859,
-0.5515505075,
-0.0106006451,
0.3736940026,
0.4449782372,
-0.3725746274,
-0.1613761485,
-0.5046056509,
-0.0330489464,
0.23797521,
-0.3118141294,
0.8818747997,
0.2599723935,
-0.6830590963,
0.1670548916,
-0.6985037327,
0.2790042162,
0.0641924143,
-0.173553288,
-0.3739936948,
-0.1684849411,
0.3473218083,
0.228759408,
0.1797193885,
-0.6763371825,
0.2972884774,
-0.3876939416,
0.2535732687,
0.8733501434,
0.0681259558,
0.0202646907,
0.1080641747,
0.5709681511,
0.141017586,
0.4640854597,
-0.4388432205,
-0.4751553535,
-0.4746481478,
-0.3629775643,
-0.1292596459,
0.5573807359,
-0.1971152276,
0.6514482498,
-0.0471825227,
-0.413702935,
-0.3622284234,
-0.0901319534,
0.545366466,
0.5887441039,
0.448867172,
-0.1651364267,
-0.596973002,
-0.7953068018,
-0.7635138035,
-0.2788277268,
-0.0480090491,
0.2444982529,
0.1285075694,
-0.3717193007,
1.0373458862,
-0.6525383592,
-0.7007001638,
-0.1619082689,
0.0900280625,
-0.1331393123,
0.4416438639,
0.688554585,
-0.7000712752,
-0.5302941799,
0.5216822624,
-0.5298957229,
0.1120669842,
-0.1852932274,
-0.0942838117,
-0.0255381577,
0.196886003,
-0.5717583895,
0.4838055074,
0.4336285591,
-0.756942153,
0.6241272688,
0.1534206569,
0.1971001029,
-0.892350316,
0.3635122478,
0.5514930487,
-0.4275160432,
-0.7119814157,
0.5088826418,
0.3012654483,
-0.1837314218,
-0.5523253083,
0.2757817507,
-0.6189008355,
-0.3518207371,
0.0491645671,
-0.1395794153,
0.0656887293,
0.7632232904,
-0.4850081205,
1.0297801495,
0.6295746565,
-0.5335736871,
0.3554070294,
-0.0516016223,
0.3497553766,
0.7422227859,
-0.6281574965,
0.3359663785,
0.1343555152,
-0.1353721619,
-0.9732303023,
-0.2153220326,
0.2262937725,
-0.3844141364,
0.3135524988,
-0.2371140569,
-0.1268097907,
-0.4427032471,
-0.6891196966,
0.6802272797,
-0.0671872571,
-0.2894809842,
0.8131817579,
0.8914763927,
-0.1265377402,
-0.6662909985,
-0.4043390751,
0.4208632708,
-0.7628380656,
-0.8761230707,
0.1883073747,
-0.0584630668,
-0.2074115127,
-0.2901023626,
-0.1155223474,
-0.2897895277,
0.3760981858,
-0.1635944247,
-0.0281165633,
-0.3613384962,
-0.4751793742,
0.0612334535,
-0.1669740975,
0.0262749474,
-0.1625750959,
0.1240440384,
-0.6269571185,
-0.4126875401,
-0.7766946554,
0.9016467333,
0.8675718307,
-0.8030558825,
0.3194483221,
0.3084800839,
-0.3088395596,
-0.0457549095,
-0.5496515036,
-0.2878094614,
-0.506526351,
0.0731715262,
-0.4665977955,
-0.5349937677,
0.7958433032,
-0.0552512854,
-0.1379387975,
0.3695718348,
0.3837890625,
0.0234100521,
1.1000695229,
0.7981505394,
-0.1923507154,
0.3181603551,
0.1804155409,
0.2312901616,
-0.7705011964,
-0.0437257029,
-0.7108749151,
-0.0298565608,
-0.3880466223,
0.1245502308,
0.6644393206,
-0.3772230744,
0.0885654241,
0.673640132,
-0.4281181097,
0.592897892,
0.3032173514,
-0.1060052067,
0.0930195004,
0.1475337893,
-0.1419439465,
0.1264204979,
-0.0080212839,
-0.46349594,
1.0055685043,
0.5798698664,
0.6841775775,
0.5104518533,
0.2687836885,
0.7187253237,
-0.1272324175,
-0.7224088311,
0.5120152831,
0.1673626602,
-0.4029871225,
-0.5966348648,
-0.2494098842,
-1.1873171329,
0.6168375015,
0.3952334523,
-1.2046741247,
0.1595294476,
0.1112770587,
-0.5920805931,
0.2283837199,
-0.9583081007,
1.2664257288,
0.0805484354,
-0.3281208277,
0.0133004859,
-1.0178107023,
0.2392770052,
0.0712691694,
0.1342261434,
0.0391613506,
0.0861786529,
0.8181544542,
-0.104655847,
0.8030580282,
-0.2546996772,
-0.3238447905,
0.2793881297,
-0.1944090873,
0.6235079765,
0.2303418219,
0.1322721243,
0.2375866324,
-0.3197711408,
-0.5896546841,
-0.4084643126,
0.6236234903,
-0.3453418612,
-0.7257360816,
-0.6240538359,
-0.3929355741,
-0.4139906764,
0.4284872115,
-0.0993988663,
0.2910793424,
0.0161421709,
-0.0833268911,
0.6026539803,
0.264539063,
0.724414587,
0.4283764362,
0.2660580873,
-0.2327710688,
0.6538186669,
-0.0596690178,
-0.2231440544,
0.3117219806,
0.1459594667,
-0.182297349,
-0.3093382716,
-0.6784313321,
0.3043082952,
-0.4442896247,
-0.6531310678,
-0.830776155,
0.0028172238,
-0.7809202075,
0.082969442,
-0.1475912929,
0.0993785486,
-0.179671973,
0.0005897582,
0.1919643283,
0.1924590766,
0.3314550221,
0.5276360512,
-0.9671959877,
0.5001633167,
0.334977448,
0.4223283529,
0.0688461065,
-0.2086720616,
-0.3382422924,
-0.1801023036,
-0.6806540489,
-1.5477561951,
0.3858896494,
0.0488142446,
0.6638445854,
0.7480771542,
0.1765280068,
0.8138451576,
-0.4061993361,
0.4806658626,
0.060132347,
-1.0907618999,
0.5970100164,
-0.5810483098,
0.1356552094,
0.6161619425,
-0.0638836026,
-0.702470541,
-0.6001069546,
-0.2907373011,
-0.7819314599,
0.8914105296,
0.2847122252,
-0.123069413,
0.0146151399,
0.0150552858,
0.0812404975,
-0.0091154352,
-0.4923484325,
-0.4740350246,
-0.1970145404,
-0.0118642123,
0.3314702511,
-0.1433703899,
0.1394771338,
-0.1037542224,
0.4042335153,
-0.3777255714,
0.3572157621,
0.1422610432,
-0.2276239097,
-0.1867558658,
0.658375442,
0.56648314,
0.4740785062,
-0.2022446692,
0.4821486473,
-0.0313274227,
-0.8827215433,
0.3524938822,
0.0627429187,
-0.0234024394,
-0.2571420074,
0.2792213857,
0.4007959366,
-0.1662177891,
-0.742852211,
0.7241587043,
-0.1689440012,
0.5529181957,
-0.2205715626,
-0.2202733308,
-0.3517999649,
0.1591317654,
0.8001109362,
0.2007354498,
0.5405548215,
-0.3809847832,
0.5302453041,
0.354442656,
-0.3129950762,
-0.6378552318,
0.3507411778,
0.4533834457,
-0.2381740659,
0.1444293261,
-0.0247466937,
-0.3665119112,
0.8223500252,
0.6634245515,
1.2869300842,
-0.8599164486,
0.0670382828,
0.1245118827,
0.5120644569,
0.555339694,
0.2889211774,
-0.0856550783,
-0.2730046213,
-0.2642248273,
-0.4914672971,
-0.0451262072,
0.3257752061,
-0.806448102,
0.1182994395,
-0.375082761,
-0.5200906992,
0.3824025989,
-0.4259323478,
-0.5737646222,
0.2870377004,
-0.0563749969,
0.7497776151,
-0.9200609922,
0.5251650214,
0.9647937417,
-0.2808372676,
-0.5207005739,
0.6189056039,
0.1661549211,
-0.3838858604,
-0.053014569,
0.6038419008,
-0.2071597576,
0.0655807331,
0.1389240921,
-0.8494215608,
0.5732104778,
0.3785329461,
-0.3423439264,
-0.0636725128,
0.3419919014,
0.3851611316,
-0.0590090528,
0.3411629498,
0.6531103849,
0.7210095525,
-0.5491560102,
-0.8094612956,
0.2601074576,
-0.3230920732,
-0.1616962552,
0.2620305717,
-0.8306030035,
0.9263549447,
-0.1774103045,
-0.5388982296,
-0.4851977825,
0.8007887602,
-0.0098979231,
0.5322765708,
0.5976598263,
0.552275002,
0.513505578,
0.3006672859,
0.7382295132,
0.0119195692,
0.4801393747,
0.7492747307,
-0.477961123,
0.6847877502,
0.8141046762,
-0.4315183163,
0.515055418,
0.2391895652,
0.1012929529,
0.3994847238,
-0.1074386686,
-0.1727224439,
-0.1204731166,
-0.0953098685,
-0.3760893345,
0.7796189785,
0.1699991524,
-0.1035184711,
-0.7483155727,
0.2848897576,
0.0272172205,
0.0488508344,
-0.2987662852,
0.9077916145,
-0.2417713702,
-0.6451413631,
0.5312201977,
0.3938958645,
0.4011714458,
-0.4224440753,
0.0892519504,
-0.0737088174,
0.3393358886,
-0.3152052164,
-0.8351554871,
0.5991178155,
0.5405660272,
-0.2069287598,
0.0992304385,
0.5760667324,
0.0464497432,
-0.2252934575,
0.4438057542,
0.0437584594,
0.0478749797,
-0.4890788198,
-0.5212131739,
0.097983703,
-0.0035674549,
-0.5722432137,
0.5928232074,
0.4362467527,
-0.2781488299,
0.5963600278,
0.5236082077,
-0.4237015843,
0.3179798126,
-0.196890533,
1.0073239803,
-1.0280851126,
-0.9584495425,
-0.8961283565,
0.8585367799,
-0.1694911569,
-0.3743547797,
1.1562396288,
0.6057194471,
0.4561569095,
-0.0969732478,
0.8094985485,
0.1052948907,
0.3654708564,
-0.1525780708,
0.5743982792,
-0.3841190338,
0.1537529379,
-0.5074138045,
-0.782965064,
-0.488583982,
0.1238844246,
0.3157145381,
-0.0187766366,
0.776411593,
0.6680153608,
-0.2228329629,
-0.2469305992,
0.2180958837,
-0.0971965641,
0.4184935093,
0.4583803415,
0.4106251001,
-0.2865655422,
0.5703966618,
-0.0701653212,
-0.503374815,
-0.5216411352,
-0.9238274693,
-0.8529297709,
-0.3536245823,
-0.2597033083,
-0.1136617959,
-0.090230152,
0.5535229445,
0.5855567455,
-0.8461765051,
-0.0882953554,
0.0143177211,
0.0000309492,
-0.5215709209,
-0.2842653096,
0.4590770602,
-0.4763381481,
-0.3029640913,
0.4993411899,
0.5671349168,
0.0396067761,
-0.2577830553,
0.2104747593,
-0.3265530467,
0.2667527199,
0.474832952,
0.531562686,
-0.7480926514,
-0.4786790609,
0.0011830684,
-0.3310876489,
0.1911892444,
0.8650199175,
-0.6710767746,
0.100319162,
0.355854243,
0.7534790039,
-0.0106711164,
0.2013988793,
0.0781781375,
-1.2993221283,
0.1655623168,
0.2303666323,
0.3330102563,
0.277071774,
-0.7834534049,
0.0537738055,
0.3139306903,
-0.249175027,
-0.8793299198,
0.4513334334,
-1.5544016361,
-0.1624263525,
1.0826870203,
-0.4027140737,
-0.6453844309,
-0.5161922574,
-0.3431017399,
0.0954355896,
-0.6226219535,
0.7081000805,
0.1423005164,
0.0881858096,
0.0142453732,
0.1567252427,
0.3367621601,
0.2067751139,
-1.0362842083,
0.5652121305,
0.2509655356,
-0.0681348965,
0.3971863389,
0.3691483736,
-0.065397501,
0.3710047007,
-0.083942689,
0.0522602573,
0.1974106133,
-0.8743786812,
-0.5071634054,
0.6562011242,
-0.178171441,
-0.3752888441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03723v1 | Financial Numeric Extreme Labelling: A Dataset and Benchmarking for XBRL Tagging | 2023-06-06T14:41:30 | 2023-06-06T14:41:30 | Soumya Sharma, Subhendu Khatuya, Manjunath Hegde, Afreen Shaikh. Koustuv Dasgupta, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE | The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) mandates all public
companies to file periodic financial statements that should contain numerals
annotated with a particular label from a taxonomy. In this paper, we formulate
the task of automating the assignment of a label to a particular numeral span
in a sentence from an extremely large label set. Towards this task, we release
a dataset, Financial Numeric Extreme Labelling (FNXL), annotated with 2,794
labels. We benchmark the performance of the FNXL dataset by formulating the
task as (a) a sequence labelling problem and (b) a pipeline with span
extraction followed by Extreme Classification. Although the two approaches
perform comparably, the pipeline solution provides a slight edge for the least
frequent labels. | [
-0.2486483604,
-0.3771583438,
-0.2240332514,
0.4985458255,
-0.35337165,
0.4434206486,
0.2366755307,
-0.7982385755,
0.1612140536,
0.6215679646,
-0.3307673633,
-0.5720196962,
-0.3316104114,
0.085296385,
-0.5270462632,
1.301409483,
0.0043837484,
-0.3413358033,
0.301183641,
-0.0724168196,
0.0226395074,
-0.810957253,
-0.4427816868,
-0.1380171031,
0.5045805573,
0.2253901511,
1.0388647318,
1.2017719746,
0.7149643898,
0.2624852061,
-0.1480599642,
-0.0759535208,
-0.2978543043,
-0.0309054106,
0.0591235682,
-0.4071893394,
-0.4509262145,
-0.1017757803,
1.0004686117,
0.6700475216,
0.0832581222,
0.4452682436,
-0.4317911267,
0.575910151,
-0.6616911292,
0.3398585916,
-0.2892769575,
0.3237679303,
-0.3929401338,
-0.0110702896,
-0.404001385,
-0.6969813704,
0.3500412107,
-0.6271063089,
-0.1628070474,
0.7604773641,
0.9307194352,
0.3331628144,
-0.4990054071,
-0.1731122136,
-0.4043365121,
0.4568023682,
-0.5744387507,
0.4644078612,
0.2392485887,
0.1539201438,
0.402795285,
-0.8431507945,
0.0321994014,
0.1348644644,
0.020578932,
-0.1185247004,
-0.5805219412,
0.0853288844,
0.6754748821,
0.3771396279,
-0.5881423354,
0.5008405447,
-0.3593030572,
-0.2973736823,
0.8155394793,
0.2588019371,
-0.055275742,
0.1408404857,
-0.8107228875,
-0.6379134655,
-0.8768563867,
-0.0533827916,
0.3820458353,
0.3345734477,
0.0509247519,
0.4902013242,
-0.1757081449,
0.6698943377,
-0.4281747937,
0.1762619466,
0.6365822554,
-0.1497353613,
-0.6025547981,
0.7106617093,
0.499576509,
0.5236846209,
0.3070606589,
-0.1993477643,
-0.7770510316,
-0.0638616532,
-0.0379400216,
-0.5302787423,
-0.240758121,
-0.1004453972,
-0.1340881586,
-0.4419647157,
0.0613561645,
-0.6188106537,
-0.3282831311,
-0.4075757861,
0.4201284051,
-0.1348547935,
0.2334932983,
-0.2035568208,
-0.3376299441,
0.2069753408,
-0.2882715464,
-0.7442419529,
0.2858499885,
0.7467829585,
0.7837761045,
0.293566376,
0.2688117921,
-0.7597721815,
0.1705075353,
-0.5274885893,
0.6729261875,
-0.6250526905,
-0.3110291362,
-0.1087707132,
-0.1952096075,
0.1115911901,
-0.471060127,
0.3704071939,
-0.9376836419,
-0.6381876469,
-0.27374053,
-0.7805839181,
0.0716332719,
-0.079244338,
-0.7146173716,
1.0117195845,
0.3492648005,
-0.49460271,
0.4363111854,
-0.6741480827,
-0.1390117407,
0.2787418962,
-0.030885566,
-0.3474071324,
-0.1195053607,
-0.2339726835,
0.4596744776,
-0.2951995432,
0.2230925858,
-0.2280015051,
-0.255188942,
0.781247735,
-0.3113281727,
0.6272372603,
0.2000675648,
-0.5135234594,
0.0947930887,
-1.0683361292,
0.3400651217,
-0.31138587,
-0.1825404912,
-0.6338154674,
-0.4603000879,
0.3283391595,
0.3040395081,
0.0545793511,
-0.651239872,
0.2258801162,
-0.4975550771,
0.4896026552,
1.1799490452,
-0.2017255127,
0.1374693513,
-0.2925182879,
0.5039647818,
-0.2525672615,
-0.0908083618,
-0.3071206808,
-0.1361096948,
-0.527910769,
-0.2355556935,
1.0496692657,
0.7221390009,
-0.4161972106,
0.3370591104,
-0.2266703248,
-0.4290961325,
-0.3834323883,
0.0059775119,
0.8740755916,
0.4243503213,
0.2297872752,
-0.1306471378,
-0.9034474492,
-1.2015570402,
-0.0047652139,
0.1562429518,
0.0898466334,
0.1140181944,
0.4868250787,
0.1036249623,
0.9085723758,
-0.8590894938,
-0.1843885779,
0.3429774642,
0.8345115185,
0.2837941051,
0.30456689,
0.5351000428,
-0.9104413986,
-0.6168122292,
0.1119487733,
-0.4467580616,
-0.4165501595,
-0.4205105007,
-0.1795754582,
0.3979150355,
0.6500961185,
0.155956611,
0.588755846,
0.2724600136,
-0.4561930299,
0.4546318352,
-0.1212635562,
-0.4520990252,
-0.489967078,
0.284057796,
0.4344409704,
-0.2732905447,
-0.5277347565,
-0.1985785812,
0.3818432093,
0.3334478438,
-0.2412569374,
0.5900034308,
-0.5153973699,
-0.384820044,
0.0000990661,
0.0784267485,
-0.2328704745,
0.3358410597,
0.0407370962,
0.6333587766,
0.2399369329,
-0.263292253,
0.6000481248,
0.3531646729,
-0.523511827,
0.2774303257,
-0.4469736218,
-0.2470718473,
-0.0160685554,
0.498685956,
-1.2538943291,
0.1640348285,
0.0612383559,
-0.0410884917,
0.3204632401,
0.0980191305,
-0.451197058,
-0.4601441622,
-0.1757568419,
0.1719934791,
0.3395786881,
-0.3164599836,
0.0526900515,
0.3095579743,
-0.3130779266,
-0.8068833947,
-0.993516624,
0.208485797,
-0.225902617,
-0.3909023106,
0.5759769082,
0.0085813133,
-0.5135622621,
-0.0454823337,
-0.3275658786,
-0.1502280533,
0.1002502665,
0.4471016526,
0.5710408688,
-0.5385824442,
0.1083983555,
-0.0656745955,
-0.6264695525,
0.189522028,
-0.1847983599,
0.1618082225,
-0.2085776627,
0.1125868112,
-0.1505485475,
0.5114091635,
0.2613702118,
-0.0185200498,
0.41633147,
0.1724881381,
-0.2512524426,
-0.2752740979,
-0.3576516509,
0.1779097915,
-0.451466471,
0.066274114,
-0.4202702343,
-0.6964380145,
0.3722815514,
0.0556028262,
0.5366073847,
0.3890141845,
0.3212572932,
0.2108021826,
0.9322220683,
0.5874654651,
-0.1861888766,
0.2220530808,
-0.3434176147,
0.2103879005,
-0.5379154086,
-0.2656165957,
-0.6212202907,
-0.609796524,
-0.1287789047,
-0.2425108552,
0.1480288804,
-0.0469041355,
-0.392434299,
0.5031629801,
-0.5094512701,
0.6424856186,
0.6096190214,
-0.2680719197,
0.3197121322,
-0.0451838933,
-0.5100565553,
-0.1159338504,
-0.2590327263,
-0.5016582608,
0.9067860842,
0.263425529,
0.5781571865,
0.0623113178,
0.5163692236,
0.5822933316,
0.647384882,
-0.5380083323,
0.3772723079,
-0.3254071176,
-0.7365651727,
-0.3157850802,
-0.4626622796,
-0.5750137568,
-0.0775334015,
-0.024266107,
-0.8885545135,
0.334102869,
-0.0242387448,
-0.9019157887,
0.1769301146,
-0.5681224465,
0.6200723052,
-0.3238427639,
-0.0784034431,
0.4356979728,
-1.1608505249,
0.1835770011,
-0.6097868681,
0.2183508873,
-0.1598710716,
-0.3787302077,
1.0064761639,
-0.6369048953,
1.0074932575,
-0.144684881,
-0.3091985285,
0.1409050673,
-0.3570621908,
0.5211872458,
-0.0800963715,
-0.1279000938,
-0.3060002923,
0.235066548,
-0.0936122686,
-0.3797436655,
0.4093840718,
-0.7717009187,
-0.0785276592,
-0.6358298063,
-0.6836158037,
-0.2205049396,
0.088090077,
0.0788300708,
0.8132187128,
-0.042328611,
0.4467269778,
0.7068768144,
0.0611901917,
0.8327357173,
0.6305024028,
-0.2365383804,
-0.5704558492,
0.9557145834,
0.6368732452,
0.0069772894,
0.8115157485,
-0.0403181799,
-0.8659143448,
-0.1886958778,
-0.4736629128,
-0.0721822679,
-0.7548226118,
-0.6432147026,
-0.7191067934,
-0.4576042891,
-0.541598022,
-0.4567318857,
-0.158357814,
-0.7110459208,
-0.093286112,
-0.3147838712,
0.6807153821,
0.6589500904,
-0.5871590376,
0.374199748,
-1.0231009722,
0.1368837655,
0.1566746682,
0.2862416506,
-0.0250244904,
-0.3632757068,
-0.2472108305,
0.0611537211,
-0.0035111683,
-0.7160020471,
0.2676614821,
0.2589884996,
0.5200150013,
0.8118305802,
0.5721141696,
0.7581923604,
-0.0292133205,
0.20916228,
0.2616271675,
-1.1796828508,
0.0738443956,
-0.2981742024,
0.1373110563,
0.2803913057,
0.9987180829,
-0.8705114722,
-0.1564487815,
-0.7427122593,
-1.4662407637,
0.5914893746,
0.1518526822,
-0.1692426652,
-0.0269100331,
0.2236920148,
0.1315409988,
0.1717185974,
-0.4871660769,
-0.5057782531,
0.0081590209,
0.0663300678,
-0.0001368359,
-0.3052222729,
-0.2541761994,
0.0755353495,
0.8629489541,
-0.0895245373,
-0.027878996,
0.0962026045,
-0.0249579903,
0.1090939641,
0.0934266374,
0.591373086,
0.6110160351,
-0.3000823855,
0.1102127582,
0.012732775,
-0.2359249443,
0.2683891952,
0.3533814549,
0.0292320456,
-0.0001947312,
0.201172173,
0.7512557507,
0.7834076881,
-0.9339747429,
0.3041910529,
0.2542371452,
-0.4763873518,
-0.1517540812,
-0.0873555094,
0.0484596044,
0.3415593803,
0.8594129682,
-0.1971371323,
0.1033608466,
-0.2565456331,
0.7607849836,
-0.0485037342,
-0.6130335331,
-0.0890996009,
0.7103480697,
0.0290592834,
0.028672304,
0.8538438678,
-0.0806931779,
-0.4954806566,
1.0288773775,
0.7365798354,
0.6076321602,
-0.0477951504,
0.3480502069,
0.0843290463,
0.2037084252,
-0.0717642531,
0.239401117,
-0.1276034266,
-0.3893716037,
-0.6083038449,
-0.627325356,
-0.6708236933,
-0.2348646969,
-0.9422411323,
0.2372413129,
-0.8209791183,
-0.1789226234,
0.8830871582,
-0.0492928475,
-0.2161111236,
0.5818240643,
0.700421989,
1.1888272762,
-1.0473697186,
0.5600230694,
0.7387989163,
-0.1303934902,
-0.7154609561,
-0.9620891809,
0.4120433033,
-0.9560499787,
1.0030047894,
0.2194980085,
0.231325686,
0.1047919616,
-0.4284083545,
-1.1042984724,
0.8222286701,
-0.1048133075,
-0.9247807264,
-0.1605502665,
0.3656955957,
0.3243533373,
-0.4317841232,
0.0839186609,
0.6093524694,
0.7571911812,
0.5797572732,
-0.7053566575,
0.1060677245,
-0.5557886958,
-0.1931256354,
0.6601580977,
-0.847312212,
0.5778637528,
0.0240152199,
-0.0291383807,
0.1298323423,
0.6225064993,
0.1373626739,
0.4338252246,
0.5124413371,
0.6538095474,
1.0062333345,
-0.3505843282,
0.5318120122,
-0.3079262674,
0.2112295032,
1.1507356167,
-0.4397785366,
0.7948510051,
-0.0837201104,
-0.2049596608,
-0.0039568925,
0.914508462,
-0.6439325809,
0.3251486719,
0.6747864485,
-0.1704451889,
-0.1970949471,
-0.3326149285,
-0.6096175909,
0.354459852,
0.4644926488,
-0.7307379842,
-0.3451575935,
0.0316575915,
0.2558662593,
-0.4063537419,
-0.329374671,
0.6277827621,
0.2198155522,
-0.3553216457,
0.4433237612,
-0.0025630156,
0.4024425745,
-0.6339769363,
0.2050616294,
-0.0994814709,
0.1671147197,
-0.2816285491,
-0.7748027444,
0.5600774288,
0.0385532416,
-0.2190088779,
-0.7352278233,
0.3483287692,
-0.0153274713,
-0.4678920507,
-0.0332288705,
-0.0472959019,
0.3151270449,
-0.0488202125,
-0.5911200643,
-0.0413327813,
0.1308002174,
-0.2228535712,
0.4842378199,
0.4508389235,
-0.4696668088,
0.7184674144,
0.8103739619,
-0.2774467766,
0.2784136534,
-0.1758804768,
1.0757577419,
-1.1906514168,
-0.7332333922,
-0.7668035626,
0.3758490384,
-0.229457438,
-0.6874045134,
0.621817708,
1.0588940382,
0.4253857434,
0.2353867292,
0.8168309331,
0.023699766,
0.1804305017,
-0.3229119182,
0.4217363894,
-0.2617510557,
0.1447209716,
-0.501036644,
-0.9803164601,
-0.7603161335,
0.3523449898,
-0.2207613736,
-0.5020287633,
0.5939067602,
0.7156555057,
0.1798180491,
0.7238764763,
0.3589298725,
0.4290400445,
-0.0610822998,
0.5318931937,
0.7881652117,
-0.1981183887,
0.8516938686,
-0.4187175632,
-0.3012030423,
-0.2746592164,
-1.1155877113,
-0.4286000133,
-0.3499614894,
-0.8340815902,
-0.2870315015,
-0.0268346742,
0.9130397439,
0.4387923181,
-0.6233543158,
-0.1255224943,
0.3408828676,
-0.1893291324,
-0.1913384795,
-0.1928471178,
0.4286044538,
-0.101644516,
-0.5000469089,
0.2357896864,
0.5972925425,
0.3074380159,
-0.056831874,
0.4491930008,
-0.1134616137,
-0.0756729692,
0.4023419321,
0.489692837,
-0.1913821101,
-0.0308609288,
0.2024566382,
-0.0877236649,
0.0919210836,
0.8644404411,
-0.5537196398,
0.137015298,
0.4706091881,
0.70861727,
0.427808255,
0.2248653471,
0.4866438508,
-0.7727977633,
-0.1999150217,
0.2575810254,
-0.0602611378,
-0.1879167557,
-0.2103181034,
0.7491117716,
-0.0045001432,
-0.6024076939,
-1.0022678375,
-0.3761689663,
-1.1061234474,
-0.1604081094,
0.9903416634,
-0.4061375856,
-0.5418658257,
-0.5128746033,
-0.0905210301,
-0.1367160827,
-0.5951787829,
0.3344628513,
0.6542332172,
0.000605867,
0.1182250157,
-0.3443864286,
0.2863728702,
0.1602414399,
-0.3007361591,
0.3042945266,
0.4201204777,
0.0238061082,
0.3214808702,
0.4799928069,
-0.0054238797,
0.1837571114,
0.2266698629,
-0.1490134448,
0.0248361547,
-0.0430148989,
-0.0801987499,
0.4684861898,
-0.5018658638,
0.0293002576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03722v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03722v2 | Evaluating the Effectiveness of Natural Language Inference for Hate Speech Detection in Languages with Limited Labeled Data | 2023-06-06T14:40:41 | 2023-06-10T09:20:59 | Janis Goldzycher, Moritz Preisig, Chantal Amrhein, Gerold Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Most research on hate speech detection has focused on English where a
sizeable amount of labeled training data is available. However, to expand hate
speech detection into more languages, approaches that require minimal training
data are needed. In this paper, we test whether natural language inference
(NLI) models which perform well in zero- and few-shot settings can benefit hate
speech detection performance in scenarios where only a limited amount of
labeled data is available in the target language. Our evaluation on five
languages demonstrates large performance improvements of NLI fine-tuning over
direct fine-tuning in the target language. However, the effectiveness of
previous work that proposed intermediate fine-tuning on English data is hard to
match. Only in settings where the English training data does not match the test
domain, can our customised NLI-formulation outperform intermediate fine-tuning
on English. Based on our extensive experiments, we propose a set of
recommendations for hate speech detection in languages where minimal labeled
training data is available. | [
-0.596328795,
-0.9020628333,
0.1622294337,
-0.0497320741,
-0.0483752824,
-0.1975811571,
-0.3805907667,
-0.8040679693,
0.0438860022,
0.4294745624,
-0.489678055,
-0.4040851891,
-0.6029976606,
0.3192182183,
-0.3608187139,
1.0363533497,
0.4132896662,
0.1201528907,
0.2671861947,
-0.4085140824,
-0.3789020181,
-0.1741900146,
-0.9722235203,
-0.3788602054,
0.6943089366,
0.4099811316,
0.7388701439,
0.713778615,
0.1985606551,
0.1494208425,
-0.220753029,
0.1842754185,
-0.5025430322,
-0.0329457782,
-0.1107945368,
-0.48853302,
-0.0299442075,
0.1068696827,
0.4012121856,
0.5773202181,
0.2036191672,
0.0256711133,
-0.0420699604,
0.3215911984,
-0.891602695,
-0.483471483,
-0.8325747848,
0.3032638431,
-0.2594491243,
0.2720192671,
-0.5964899659,
-0.3332062066,
0.1371487826,
-0.4767124653,
0.3275072873,
0.1491704881,
0.8048806787,
0.3390440643,
-0.3556788266,
-0.3178075254,
-0.769951582,
1.0566432476,
-1.1678369045,
0.2609069347,
0.6181867123,
0.1941997856,
-0.0490405858,
-0.0066173854,
-0.6118023992,
-0.3470857739,
-0.1260784417,
0.1234803125,
-0.5950464606,
0.2367865592,
0.4865627885,
0.1659962982,
-0.5822261572,
0.7215723395,
-0.2807741463,
-0.2368065715,
0.6176682711,
-0.0215149447,
0.1851161867,
-0.1662291586,
-0.10550531,
0.2078215033,
-0.3777539432,
-0.2220231742,
0.7613503933,
0.8782390952,
-0.2744426429,
0.3346828818,
-0.2619282901,
1.023748517,
-0.0443377495,
-0.3333360851,
0.1128863767,
-0.0352265127,
-0.326013118,
0.0020048525,
0.5858134627,
0.4210878313,
0.58463341,
-0.4974776804,
-0.0656736046,
0.5851487517,
0.0292821955,
-0.7632985115,
-0.1221127659,
0.0848588571,
-0.0302762128,
-0.2178266644,
-0.5186121464,
-0.8056324124,
-0.6916122437,
-0.2771746814,
0.3044204116,
-0.6213532686,
-0.1674018502,
-0.0826120675,
-0.4716901779,
0.2102994919,
0.194328621,
-0.6642177701,
0.2920440733,
0.46838516,
0.5501987338,
-0.5360168219,
0.0544550605,
-0.7842640281,
-0.0243427008,
-0.3589824438,
0.6347336769,
-0.8153803945,
0.0856701508,
0.0514364243,
-0.2435801476,
0.0509420894,
-0.8644508719,
0.9008319378,
-0.4227882028,
0.0260718931,
0.239723146,
-0.7586337328,
0.0275681745,
0.3015311062,
-0.5385782719,
0.8644061089,
-0.053199105,
-0.7532089353,
0.5693405271,
-0.3549804688,
-0.6770817637,
-0.0182951316,
0.0923991203,
-0.5983714461,
0.1171320379,
-0.0283155181,
0.1977741122,
-0.0728430226,
0.224191308,
-0.5908632874,
-0.2828595638,
-0.0958675966,
-0.6035519242,
0.7220543623,
0.3357595801,
-0.4223047793,
-0.1846907735,
-0.9248459935,
-0.1049671546,
-0.0055582733,
-0.1443031132,
-0.6291537881,
-0.0443227366,
0.0941700265,
-0.0974940285,
-0.353028059,
-0.9517247081,
-0.2731841505,
-0.6433819532,
-0.0359846316,
0.5422139168,
-0.1038533524,
0.4657445252,
-0.1733214408,
0.6319812536,
-0.1023871079,
-0.0073787989,
0.485542506,
-0.5913383365,
-0.8347197771,
-0.3100901842,
0.2217973918,
0.581520915,
-0.6696419716,
0.125671953,
0.1912867427,
-0.274826467,
-0.5191360712,
0.060748402,
0.5878296494,
0.5233840942,
0.3561071157,
0.0546248406,
-0.9613322616,
-1.220744133,
-0.6423676014,
0.1027664021,
-0.1094004288,
0.4339846075,
0.4812350869,
0.00292146,
0.9838516712,
-0.2063074261,
-0.2353608161,
-0.4169974923,
0.3224843442,
0.1631029248,
0.1416879743,
0.5913461447,
-0.6713430882,
-0.7357327938,
-0.0945783928,
-0.2954792976,
-0.1732159406,
0.012491514,
-0.0329280794,
0.096398063,
-0.0347397141,
0.2544698715,
0.6607024074,
0.5654605031,
-0.2806109488,
0.4083255827,
0.3089147508,
0.063381426,
-0.4928755462,
-0.2471229434,
0.2702569664,
-0.4027151167,
-1.1762077808,
-0.1242907196,
-0.3102640212,
-0.0111145414,
-0.6382501125,
0.5698563457,
0.00409124,
0.2772869766,
-0.4194381535,
0.2818630934,
-0.3754503131,
0.3361052871,
0.2384892255,
0.5854178071,
0.3055702746,
-0.8243659735,
-0.1573213786,
0.021409478,
-0.4541376531,
0.7058157921,
-0.3309949636,
0.1506425738,
-0.1914320737,
-0.2938100994,
-0.8461462855,
-0.299556911,
0.2010008842,
-0.3679686785,
0.0529584363,
-0.4620453417,
-0.1722767204,
-0.3451009095,
-0.144834727,
0.1651485711,
0.3520366549,
-0.4741561115,
0.3057621121,
0.5307933092,
0.3880140483,
-0.5055634975,
-0.8614333868,
-0.0622934774,
-0.4927867353,
-0.2664503455,
0.0802123249,
-0.1856036931,
-0.4207959771,
-0.2049569786,
-0.0524180569,
-0.6267246008,
0.2513400018,
0.2493477166,
-0.0900412723,
-0.2051347792,
0.0170430578,
0.0071182717,
0.2219696045,
-0.1626405716,
0.0923021287,
0.1745433211,
0.103703253,
0.0079953438,
-0.3228593469,
0.2907999158,
0.2163724154,
0.0423929729,
0.8327281475,
0.7385683656,
-0.6096923351,
-0.5343592167,
-0.5378326178,
-0.0426638052,
-0.3820649385,
0.0893018544,
-0.1831956804,
-1.0528501272,
0.1828423887,
0.3489179909,
0.0350424796,
0.2008463889,
0.3247421384,
0.1082293913,
0.9791297913,
0.5625959635,
-0.4228844047,
0.3068715334,
0.1541064233,
0.3828150332,
-0.4039976895,
0.363627106,
-0.7152161598,
-0.3042645752,
-0.5152130723,
-0.2668376863,
0.3711687028,
0.021446364,
-0.2264041603,
0.4529562294,
-0.5568768382,
0.8772678971,
0.3653840423,
0.1101246774,
0.3556784987,
0.1733193249,
0.1513109207,
-0.4249013662,
-0.6234947443,
-0.3811201155,
0.7806322575,
0.1914102286,
0.2397226393,
0.3107099235,
0.5347980857,
0.389893353,
0.3918761611,
-0.7954193354,
0.1739168167,
-0.4224545062,
-1.0756311417,
-0.4543837309,
-0.3153836429,
-0.9144363403,
0.2355213761,
-0.1852484941,
-0.7720221281,
0.0960404575,
0.2025812715,
-0.5974774361,
0.4675341845,
-0.8521606922,
0.8164440989,
0.0647922233,
-0.3690747023,
-0.1917214245,
-0.2629709542,
0.5778712034,
-0.1183289513,
0.4260948896,
-0.4919769168,
0.1518939286,
1.0983612537,
-0.1754674166,
1.1255927086,
-0.431671083,
-0.0976871923,
0.2659015059,
-0.011314068,
0.4990025163,
-0.2311294675,
-0.6452464461,
0.0393569693,
-0.2430506051,
-0.3767298162,
-0.5308324099,
0.4399132133,
-0.2493643016,
-0.3257116675,
0.0432928018,
-0.5004380345,
-0.3866332769,
0.2488565743,
0.3323822021,
0.2330361009,
-0.192631945,
0.0796422884,
0.6337151527,
-0.3184607327,
0.2851794958,
0.8646011353,
-0.0332815461,
-0.1483301222,
0.9315253496,
0.0477651581,
0.1469656378,
0.1500531584,
0.3613187969,
0.0058333855,
-0.8967196941,
-0.4969733953,
0.1194922552,
-0.230601728,
-0.2057037503,
-0.5133185387,
0.0058286246,
-0.3455128968,
-0.1260001063,
-0.3494921029,
-0.1929312795,
0.0045220698,
0.0701008886,
0.5342541933,
0.7155589461,
-0.3274019957,
0.4154842496,
-0.1686772555,
0.7065104842,
0.1859796345,
0.3765852153,
-0.0452468432,
-1.1502369642,
-0.292081058,
0.1980192959,
0.0733564049,
-0.9090301991,
0.4362813532,
0.3308047056,
0.1410503685,
0.3095192611,
0.4401323497,
0.9643011689,
-0.6982228756,
0.3647640944,
0.0033182921,
-0.539839685,
0.7077946067,
-0.3852306902,
0.1176977754,
0.8500571251,
0.5757765174,
-0.5030335784,
-0.8269795179,
-0.4424149692,
-0.5348359942,
0.7920607328,
0.3239517212,
0.1151113585,
-0.1648545861,
-0.0244622342,
0.1049268246,
0.0287647918,
-0.9058253169,
-0.7101273537,
0.3672858477,
-0.009581048,
0.0722054541,
-0.2007354349,
-0.043241635,
-0.533924818,
0.8144226074,
0.0724882334,
0.0789300874,
-0.1274816841,
-0.1513593793,
-0.0373122543,
0.5036079884,
0.4357223511,
0.3405976593,
-0.2607601285,
-0.1001256108,
0.5522357821,
-0.1854192913,
0.1048722193,
0.0043765944,
-0.4782661498,
0.2540818751,
0.3459714651,
1.1260929108,
0.1429815441,
-0.7152567506,
0.5254126191,
0.0472096168,
-0.0681038648,
-0.1857512146,
0.2262762189,
-0.1991748065,
0.0289169438,
0.0569219179,
-0.0769319534,
0.3568430245,
-0.2052485496,
0.5731405616,
0.6517318487,
-0.5771556497,
0.0041002845,
0.5659679174,
0.0055235797,
-0.50853616,
0.3293581307,
-0.5673509836,
-0.4206313491,
0.6025694609,
0.6645468473,
0.3415993154,
-0.2029970288,
0.432444036,
0.6252400875,
0.4961178005,
0.3911286891,
-0.1281122863,
-0.0424912162,
-1.0159332752,
-0.5451888442,
-0.7870739698,
-0.5275253654,
0.5965821743,
-0.7191824913,
0.1652831286,
-0.5180029273,
0.0685203001,
0.414496094,
-0.1864865273,
-0.6951836348,
0.3534379303,
0.7014100552,
0.9289738536,
-1.0824514627,
0.6604375243,
0.2445810884,
0.0407874621,
-0.70828861,
-0.3023474216,
0.342153132,
-0.77148664,
0.4810754359,
0.2437005937,
-0.3237318099,
0.0315927602,
-0.6423465014,
-0.4302015603,
0.0513023175,
0.4664053023,
-0.5399587154,
0.3953139782,
0.3731161654,
0.7628411651,
-0.1587557644,
0.2581404448,
1.1527520418,
0.4986163378,
-0.0058134627,
-0.6779823303,
-0.3220174909,
0.0834616572,
-0.4259718359,
0.3286724389,
-0.2628574669,
0.2417423278,
0.0929750726,
-0.3067635298,
0.0054784319,
0.6801075339,
-0.079322353,
0.4455541074,
0.7229534984,
0.8257330656,
0.8471283913,
0.0555309467,
1.0348854065,
0.1742117554,
0.0778159574,
1.4229493141,
-0.1937155575,
0.7625629902,
0.0584955402,
-0.3145132363,
0.2573506534,
0.2887605727,
-0.01751565,
0.3640760779,
0.2378018647,
-0.4556780159,
-0.371832639,
-0.7827069163,
0.1337585598,
0.5236540437,
0.1469621956,
-0.0154758776,
-0.4879777133,
0.4003837109,
0.3109668493,
0.2713976502,
-0.3183431625,
0.6557824016,
-0.1907880604,
-0.4506929219,
0.9068667889,
0.0500422306,
1.0819871426,
-0.3085033,
0.1141072363,
-0.3492191434,
-0.0939584747,
-0.3313670754,
-0.4837260842,
0.5774665475,
0.6208334565,
-0.2144513279,
0.045593068,
0.6293437481,
-0.4889354706,
-0.2203264385,
0.3617414832,
0.0782188997,
0.4341942072,
-0.107816942,
-0.5706202984,
-0.1030589193,
0.3730833232,
0.0173419025,
0.3918947279,
0.1682213843,
0.2486133575,
0.4720970392,
0.4243942499,
0.2261816859,
0.3015340269,
0.2318394035,
0.3142921329,
-0.5055613518,
-0.0777476951,
-0.8534338474,
0.3760444522,
-0.3292556703,
-0.4973477125,
0.9854950905,
0.7885350585,
1.0739701986,
-0.00716735,
0.7577621937,
-0.0927926376,
1.0075162649,
-0.2864843905,
0.2789515257,
-0.3868677914,
-0.1882019788,
-0.2735025585,
-0.5259464979,
-0.7406829596,
0.6740407348,
-0.6675693393,
-0.3243300915,
0.4426562488,
0.9860568643,
-0.2060125172,
0.0887282863,
0.7745512724,
0.3332850635,
0.0411998965,
0.4734365344,
0.5452187657,
-0.501829505,
0.5655860901,
-0.6070213318,
-0.0531814769,
0.1426313668,
-0.7204716802,
-1.0063371658,
0.0416304097,
-0.5042820573,
-0.2261478454,
0.1530963331,
0.6125427485,
0.7364519835,
-1.1921033859,
-0.0352495983,
0.0352656394,
0.382222116,
0.0922878906,
-0.2574191391,
-0.1105482429,
-0.213340953,
-1.0602394342,
0.8819511533,
0.1921383739,
-0.1133383363,
0.402333498,
-0.2036313117,
-0.3935881853,
0.1782090068,
0.5879589915,
0.6345623136,
-0.7044529915,
-0.3144207299,
-0.4898073077,
0.082844466,
0.0809693262,
0.5940790772,
-0.6601852775,
0.3138397336,
0.0175870396,
0.920204401,
0.3142882884,
-0.1073017642,
0.1963459253,
-0.9528069496,
0.556930542,
0.4273302853,
0.0170445647,
0.1674390733,
-0.1385798156,
0.6531902552,
0.1216896176,
-0.2595470548,
-1.0452014208,
0.4664388299,
-0.5307646394,
-0.1966349334,
1.1974221468,
0.1986087114,
-0.2137978375,
-0.5211153626,
0.0598648489,
0.2124827057,
-0.3635284603,
0.3690182865,
0.6456668973,
-0.1825669259,
-0.0067481478,
-0.7668136358,
0.6672810316,
0.688082099,
-0.6290756464,
0.1497223973,
0.5308289528,
-0.0328166224,
-0.0774562806,
0.3536022604,
0.4943289161,
0.0697592199,
-0.2285044938,
-0.1153476685,
0.2997662723,
-0.2582803965,
-0.5766307116,
0.0894749984,
0.090212889,
-0.0191352237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03678v1 | On the Difference of BERT-style and CLIP-style Text Encoders | 2023-06-06T13:41:09 | 2023-06-06T13:41:09 | Zhihong Chen, Guiming Hardy Chen, Shizhe Diao, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Masked language modeling (MLM) has been one of the most popular pretraining
recipes in natural language processing, e.g., BERT, one of the representative
models. Recently, contrastive language-image pretraining (CLIP) has also
attracted attention, especially its vision models that achieve excellent
performance on a broad range of vision tasks. However, few studies are
dedicated to studying the text encoders learned by CLIP. In this paper, we
analyze the difference between BERT-style and CLIP-style text encoders from
three experiments: (i) general text understanding, (ii) vision-centric text
understanding, and (iii) text-to-image generation. Experimental analyses show
that although CLIP-style text encoders underperform BERT-style ones for general
text understanding tasks, they are equipped with a unique ability, i.e.,
synesthesia, for the cross-modal association, which is more similar to the
senses of humans. | [
-0.5075582862,
-0.5979190469,
0.378238827,
0.2673979998,
-0.4056929946,
0.1139106378,
-0.336623013,
-0.5738162398,
0.3527593911,
0.4281241,
-0.6673636436,
-0.4209947288,
-0.6019920111,
0.4591266811,
-0.4299565852,
0.9687094688,
-0.164564997,
0.4664892852,
-0.2265262604,
0.0038697023,
-0.2962344587,
-0.9525901675,
-0.1752230972,
-0.1045308113,
0.1427059174,
-0.383816123,
0.6624980569,
0.2688305974,
0.5058238506,
0.2987466753,
0.0553611815,
-0.2398997694,
-0.2296426892,
-0.1285639554,
-0.0415289067,
-0.3292360604,
-0.0319816843,
-0.0919943899,
0.4451186955,
0.5153859258,
0.277002573,
-0.2915246487,
0.2771645784,
0.6942168474,
-0.8095686436,
-0.2071137279,
-0.7208405733,
0.2861690819,
0.06956283,
0.0202691518,
-0.3060612082,
-0.2828335166,
0.6862610579,
-0.6941599846,
0.543821454,
0.1024430916,
1.2101559639,
0.0693592727,
-0.0126861827,
-0.5702245831,
-0.5509762168,
0.7407433987,
-0.5754962564,
0.5987948179,
0.0590605512,
0.1129661277,
0.3179435134,
-0.8156962991,
-0.8150545955,
0.2248033136,
-0.2918762863,
0.0514486693,
-0.0985521227,
0.3162107468,
-0.0879252926,
0.276004225,
-0.408695668,
0.0031355794,
-0.4678886831,
-0.1200935841,
0.204758361,
-0.1230960414,
0.415163815,
-0.2772062719,
-0.85603863,
-0.2384279072,
-0.5690340996,
0.0081060193,
0.2608268261,
-0.2284548432,
-0.0346015841,
0.0838213935,
0.1326723546,
0.7271667123,
0.0274562798,
-0.171098724,
0.289414674,
-0.3135854006,
-0.6883448958,
0.0259081703,
0.8989979625,
0.425455898,
0.5859507322,
-0.506859839,
-0.2882447839,
0.0707294643,
0.3555545211,
-0.8769389391,
-0.4314751327,
-0.2841228545,
-0.8479091525,
-0.0929268524,
0.3602374792,
-0.5215091109,
-0.1003210992,
-0.3493853807,
1.116481781,
-0.5975321531,
0.1278083324,
0.3115566969,
-0.3683131635,
0.418610394,
0.3026662171,
-0.9035003781,
0.4995705783,
0.4064479768,
0.8172128201,
-0.5839125514,
-0.291369915,
0.2373310477,
-0.2770441473,
-0.3839468062,
0.5371285081,
-0.6373673677,
-0.2500678301,
-0.0227989051,
0.0708704665,
-0.3972954452,
-0.6002224088,
0.1286499798,
-0.4831229746,
0.4589361846,
-0.4200688899,
-0.3958171606,
-0.5099241734,
0.0621750802,
-0.5541535616,
0.7478333712,
-0.2025208175,
-0.7278751731,
0.6003811955,
-0.4448981583,
-0.3794124722,
-0.1387841552,
-0.469311893,
-0.4126460552,
-0.0693177134,
0.4708437324,
0.5591114759,
0.0794384629,
0.0624320321,
-0.1524727792,
-0.6372582912,
0.6701347828,
-0.1597359627,
0.5387168527,
0.0022744504,
-0.4191990495,
0.16856426,
-0.5351393819,
-0.1763249487,
0.1326968372,
-0.0149826566,
-0.4961784482,
0.0621754862,
0.1745307297,
0.2588153481,
0.0502730459,
-0.6121917963,
-0.3605955541,
-0.2439797074,
0.4657995403,
0.7055180073,
0.0912156776,
0.3397789598,
-0.317877382,
0.3133442402,
-0.0080951266,
0.1848922372,
-0.6299365163,
-0.2658744156,
-1.124650836,
-0.3585852981,
0.3179403245,
0.4992209673,
-0.627822876,
0.4462253749,
0.1206089556,
-0.0542109311,
-0.6466691494,
-0.0460750982,
0.5562155843,
0.3913360238,
0.3253602684,
-0.6322133541,
-0.5548424721,
-1.045507431,
-0.2821415961,
0.3729199171,
-0.1871236861,
0.4219080508,
0.5184630156,
-0.2919721305,
1.0546264648,
-0.3338879049,
-0.2741466761,
-0.2413502038,
-0.0914243981,
-0.0340705216,
0.520552218,
0.9335141778,
-0.6700339317,
-0.5375065804,
-0.3589297533,
-0.5987799168,
0.1671670824,
-0.3538812101,
-0.134972319,
0.2064291686,
0.4772977531,
-0.2557556331,
0.5982296467,
0.4150029719,
-0.0691608712,
0.6820851564,
-0.1925410628,
0.2180298716,
-0.7790831327,
-0.1116292551,
-0.141904071,
-0.1210756153,
-0.9614273906,
-0.1987830997,
0.0848667547,
-0.2302223146,
-0.4086371958,
0.2118938565,
-0.6637878418,
-0.4091737568,
-0.1397733539,
0.1244934052,
0.4070665836,
0.8973807096,
0.6531848311,
0.9460612535,
0.6905583143,
-0.7532933354,
-0.0625230819,
0.3614833951,
-0.6612912416,
0.0380871333,
-1.0233538151,
0.4353886843,
-0.2622213066,
0.0178878047,
-0.9304176569,
0.0328054689,
0.1886656731,
-0.2516780794,
0.4072291851,
0.3120283186,
-0.3907657266,
-0.1926561594,
-0.5408456326,
0.4315407574,
0.7907364368,
-0.7201173306,
0.2991633713,
0.0988651365,
-0.0473136455,
-0.5452792645,
-0.8164765239,
-0.1936652958,
-0.0417735726,
-0.3777855039,
0.5096219778,
0.0586951673,
-0.1906758696,
0.0891961604,
-0.1107990444,
-0.3960557282,
-0.1085319147,
0.1852870584,
0.3890542388,
-0.2417080849,
0.1804000288,
-0.053808786,
0.3099648654,
0.0853402168,
-0.0309351515,
0.5047368407,
0.0000048125,
-0.4096106887,
-0.3527430892,
0.3157273531,
0.0651139766,
-0.3923507929,
0.7947661281,
0.448466301,
-0.1437724382,
-0.2072273493,
-0.5671434402,
-0.3224668205,
-0.5124335289,
0.2923343778,
-0.3114717305,
-0.9714720249,
0.3734005094,
0.2649399936,
-0.2098874897,
0.172805652,
0.5965108275,
-0.2629606426,
0.4170345664,
0.8540985584,
0.0614276342,
0.8722928166,
-0.0078105028,
0.0502061322,
-0.7964631319,
-0.2678953707,
-0.3003398776,
-0.400834769,
-0.2925599217,
-0.568218112,
0.2949977219,
0.1426738352,
-0.1717101336,
0.2619233727,
-0.6787508726,
0.5532928705,
0.5555526018,
0.2429395616,
-0.0085442169,
0.1474299729,
-0.1605171263,
-0.4359841645,
-0.6290320754,
-0.3984085321,
0.9772757292,
0.3145207763,
0.9897782803,
-0.365390569,
0.6968994141,
0.1212883964,
-0.1985466927,
-0.7131211758,
0.3851090968,
-0.4190809727,
-0.4865985215,
0.0264229272,
0.1165608242,
-0.7268102169,
0.4857065976,
-0.4024940729,
-0.6818752885,
0.6563281417,
0.2268655151,
-0.0592792481,
0.3719537854,
-0.6926193833,
0.8618919849,
-0.2229652554,
0.0675154775,
0.1108120307,
-0.8749260902,
0.2180303633,
-0.0640456006,
-0.1061765179,
0.1503679156,
-0.0066896449,
0.9051537514,
-0.3558318913,
0.8959587812,
0.0782247633,
0.1993296891,
0.3931591809,
0.0022357227,
0.1060523465,
-0.5170029402,
0.3192070723,
0.2763577104,
-0.2136635631,
-0.0510223359,
-0.6848620772,
0.0771263987,
-0.7614299655,
-0.3194164634,
-0.1763873249,
-0.3645546436,
-0.0685017854,
0.0500518829,
0.7388935685,
0.8655275702,
-0.3833700418,
0.191571027,
1.0132004023,
-0.5446861386,
0.6663185358,
0.2631492317,
-0.2361859977,
-0.4242599607,
0.7456467152,
-0.0505703352,
0.5676931143,
0.7397915721,
-0.1194359139,
-0.1539865732,
-0.3661587238,
-0.2689833343,
0.1977619231,
-0.6190086603,
0.0573176295,
-0.7932992578,
-0.4809517264,
-0.2856300771,
-0.5870916843,
-0.2651503384,
-0.3455144465,
-0.3985809088,
0.173360005,
0.2754760981,
0.7962812781,
0.2932186425,
0.3619254529,
-0.6536564231,
0.3594049513,
0.5031208396,
0.2814899087,
0.0502335951,
-0.2095539719,
-0.2480980754,
-0.301725179,
-0.1960294545,
-1.0398375988,
0.3537935317,
0.4473044872,
0.4330786169,
0.7425972819,
-0.034653306,
0.6360675097,
-0.6628949046,
0.8800810575,
0.5275440812,
-1.1808491945,
0.3414344788,
0.1120321676,
0.1821675152,
0.3856341541,
0.418769896,
-0.4248019755,
-0.3485580683,
-0.2881172597,
-0.5374917984,
0.5670801997,
0.4153401554,
0.0984900892,
0.0929981172,
0.0608302616,
0.6216037869,
0.4401423037,
-0.8806166649,
-0.1251051128,
-0.6539834142,
-0.103134498,
-0.0576961935,
-0.4297619462,
0.0711209774,
-0.1527948081,
0.0597532429,
0.0670873821,
0.8104405999,
0.6331311464,
-0.4831164777,
0.4072840214,
0.5835623145,
0.5489376783,
0.6349654198,
-0.3476736248,
0.1658680886,
0.1710429788,
-0.7811498046,
-0.1020902693,
-0.1573992819,
-0.2929376662,
0.5348181725,
0.5737432837,
1.3228594065,
0.4081793129,
-0.6597850919,
0.6393110752,
0.1558263898,
-0.3833180964,
0.0664715692,
0.1112240702,
-0.2596480846,
-0.0493301079,
0.385594964,
-0.0100287488,
0.2297514528,
-0.5953638554,
0.0412093811,
0.4882089198,
-0.4725560844,
-0.4531860948,
0.517211616,
0.3641853333,
-0.1891164035,
0.175799951,
0.0454039127,
-1.0380293131,
0.4569785595,
0.8658415675,
1.0424791574,
0.1935345978,
-0.0695758462,
0.1357323229,
0.3574869931,
0.3337340951,
0.2184319198,
-0.5202159286,
-1.0677831173,
-0.0973238274,
-0.5863435268,
-0.4779935777,
-0.1150787771,
-0.8388018608,
-0.1759583801,
-0.4945271313,
-0.0716710314,
-0.1769791842,
-0.2982367277,
-0.8025850654,
0.3304729462,
-0.1375795603,
0.7749990821,
-0.5834564567,
0.8938065767,
0.678362906,
0.0409928299,
-0.4706409872,
0.2534755766,
-0.378385514,
-0.7852318287,
0.8726208806,
0.3777905107,
-0.2106707543,
-0.2639607489,
-0.5403428078,
-0.3477627039,
0.8309765458,
0.0783626586,
-0.7012572885,
-0.1963554025,
0.049599193,
0.4229739904,
-0.5215034485,
0.0853360295,
0.5609122515,
-0.1278831512,
-0.1019612625,
-1.0459465981,
-0.2041061223,
0.049253922,
0.358931005,
0.3324174583,
-0.5300844312,
1.1333518028,
-0.0789674148,
-0.4699912667,
-0.0335082226,
0.469640404,
0.0489586294,
0.107843034,
0.3995343745,
0.2649852931,
0.2557515204,
-0.0879853368,
0.8693827391,
-0.1951630563,
0.207779333,
0.8829631805,
-0.1037762612,
0.8339874744,
0.4789032638,
-0.2957567275,
0.8215269446,
0.398170501,
-0.0732534528,
0.7266591191,
-0.1357537508,
-0.0740532577,
-0.228082791,
0.0777143911,
-0.4430311322,
0.1917264014,
0.1580383927,
-0.7665557265,
0.0866408721,
0.2680724561,
0.1743736118,
0.05288684,
-0.4122135639,
0.8682748079,
0.2258220017,
-0.2352595478,
0.307346344,
-0.1397741586,
1.2074302435,
-0.7031669617,
0.1927308291,
0.1856639981,
0.1585606486,
0.1251835823,
-0.8898386955,
0.2050906569,
0.1184896305,
-0.2214432657,
-0.3105915785,
1.1718565226,
-0.3719608784,
-0.2380334288,
0.2814061642,
0.1317112893,
0.2439505309,
-0.0499058925,
-0.6860920787,
0.2883288562,
-0.144955188,
0.0859161019,
0.3197746873,
0.2993076146,
0.3365999162,
0.4158424735,
0.3899987638,
-0.0762884319,
0.4267849624,
-0.0124275144,
0.8798968196,
-0.6304444075,
-0.6075438857,
-0.8951872587,
0.0963764861,
0.0105141541,
-0.3337243795,
0.804361999,
0.4450723529,
0.7442017794,
-0.7363922596,
0.5705285668,
0.1544054151,
0.3953871131,
-0.8933880925,
0.7472633123,
-0.2746186256,
-0.2850101292,
-0.4877693653,
-0.9474675059,
-0.0489247106,
0.764968574,
-0.110881716,
0.0288159084,
0.7832027674,
0.5220875144,
0.049870614,
-0.0211933013,
0.2526334524,
-0.135843873,
-0.1463178396,
0.6687983871,
0.6312873363,
-0.3277777135,
0.474907279,
-0.2645083964,
0.1410301328,
-0.2415441275,
-0.7116327882,
-1.3920283318,
-0.6197879314,
0.0572180301,
0.044985313,
0.1250231266,
0.8992916942,
0.8849310875,
-0.7400339842,
-0.1576596051,
0.0451287478,
-0.0019964299,
-0.0420693457,
-0.1824218184,
0.4466421902,
-0.4551869035,
-0.6899357438,
0.0281759221,
0.4119069874,
0.3923162818,
-0.2358378023,
-0.2548834383,
0.1332061142,
0.3572221696,
0.6533862948,
0.1712672263,
-0.9115921259,
-0.1214383468,
0.1469529122,
-0.1265197843,
0.347486347,
1.0538215637,
-1.0128386021,
0.8388671875,
0.4960706532,
0.6140159965,
0.5421463847,
0.0225651227,
0.5796934962,
-0.6850331426,
0.3923330605,
-0.0509216264,
0.2258828431,
0.3124797642,
-0.0896181539,
0.1495884955,
0.3569031954,
-0.3840639889,
-0.6102538705,
0.216796428,
-1.003054738,
-0.3654987216,
0.9562146664,
-0.1761013716,
-0.3067769408,
0.0574588701,
-0.482650578,
0.0230351761,
-0.0932676345,
0.3425112069,
0.5845326781,
-0.2084545493,
-0.2067351937,
-0.1448093653,
0.7309813499,
0.3015922904,
-0.642755568,
-0.5546296239,
0.1122505367,
0.3678824902,
0.1340416372,
0.5528715849,
0.0531677566,
0.1811259538,
0.1779185086,
0.3356179893,
-0.0412375405,
-0.4379737377,
-0.2383846641,
0.1414504647,
-0.3170208335,
-0.7868083119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03652v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03652v1 | Injecting knowledge into language generation: a case study in auto-charting after-visit care instructions from medical dialogue | 2023-06-06T13:13:27 | 2023-06-06T13:13:27 | Maksim Eremeev, Ilya Valmianski, Xavier Amatriain, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factual correctness is often the limiting factor in practical applications of
natural language generation in high-stakes domains such as healthcare. An
essential requirement for maintaining factuality is the ability to deal with
rare tokens. This paper focuses on rare tokens that appear in both the source
and the reference sequences, and which, when missed during generation, decrease
the factual correctness of the output text. For high-stake domains that are
also knowledge-rich, we show how to use knowledge to (a) identify which rare
tokens that appear in both source and reference are important and (b) uplift
their conditional probability. We introduce the ``utilization rate'' that
encodes knowledge and serves as a regularizer by maximizing the marginal
probability of selected tokens. We present a study in a knowledge-rich domain
of healthcare, where we tackle the problem of generating after-visit care
instructions based on patient-doctor dialogues. We verify that, in our dataset,
specific medical concepts with high utilization rates are underestimated by
conventionally trained sequence-to-sequence models. We observe that correcting
this with our approach to knowledge injection reduces the uncertainty of the
model as well as improves factuality and coherence without negatively impacting
fluency. | [
0.036850594,
-0.5495124459,
0.7975662351,
-0.21215038,
-0.2208239138,
-0.0458841696,
0.0100698043,
-0.3853121698,
0.2048251778,
0.6818214655,
-0.0644035712,
-0.4443526566,
-0.5030145645,
-0.1059648022,
-0.2414330691,
1.0889456272,
0.0613249503,
0.0497189946,
-0.3989918232,
-0.2386654168,
-0.3404533267,
-0.9072312713,
-0.5760986209,
-0.2484143525,
0.3073297143,
0.5757303834,
0.707103014,
0.6866776943,
0.473983556,
0.2194968611,
0.0737071708,
0.4812740088,
-0.4544069469,
-0.0553812049,
-0.1360182613,
-0.5845825076,
-0.3343376517,
-0.1773579121,
0.6013608575,
1.0510092974,
-0.2018719316,
-0.1720485687,
-0.1234444007,
0.3915151358,
-0.4716146886,
0.2958294153,
-0.7759538293,
0.1480019838,
-0.2340551168,
-0.4978616834,
-0.2772524059,
-0.5524659157,
0.3353105187,
-0.7609000206,
0.4185284972,
0.1270179898,
0.9848186374,
0.2755115926,
-0.3442094624,
-0.4306571782,
-0.5540514588,
0.7127492428,
-0.807788372,
0.1895699352,
0.5215706229,
0.1874968857,
-0.3010057211,
-1.055249095,
-0.690277338,
-0.1779761612,
-0.3603671491,
0.0692834556,
-0.0648404136,
0.1921291947,
0.2544020116,
0.3524715304,
-0.2101185918,
-0.1205599159,
-0.2853826582,
-0.3108231425,
0.3106935024,
0.1323475093,
0.458571732,
-0.4507180154,
-0.2874768078,
0.3253821731,
-0.9706550837,
-0.1522933692,
0.1792134792,
0.1537289917,
0.1224268526,
0.7147519588,
-0.1246526837,
0.6495033503,
0.1704791188,
-0.3223213851,
0.3571413755,
-0.7109519243,
-0.1762353778,
-0.0039634188,
0.537437737,
0.2475519627,
0.3935684562,
-0.066165179,
-0.0601511523,
-0.1648230404,
0.4038451612,
-0.5484424233,
-0.2966808677,
0.0761545375,
-0.3196071386,
-0.202094242,
0.0094217788,
-0.261400193,
-0.2119267732,
-0.2339879423,
0.2137256414,
-0.557100594,
-0.0835145786,
0.2570880651,
-0.2618220448,
-0.0854831412,
0.1711915582,
-0.703525722,
0.2203076333,
0.3977556825,
0.4556241333,
-0.0743495524,
-0.0027950055,
-0.7184222341,
0.4592985213,
-0.3076424301,
0.7783352137,
-0.276725173,
-0.6220300794,
0.3767233491,
-0.1729168296,
0.0003800151,
-0.9083461165,
0.4026252329,
-0.3517808914,
0.3893167078,
-0.3170597851,
-0.755687654,
0.136478886,
-0.1108828261,
-0.4042593539,
0.5899051428,
0.4719918072,
-0.7753344774,
0.8910846114,
-0.8564120531,
-0.8550582528,
0.5001536608,
-0.4937192798,
-0.3813087046,
0.2193359733,
-0.0506094992,
0.4686540961,
0.0512513258,
0.4775528312,
0.2313716859,
-0.205718115,
0.3701858222,
-0.3883043826,
0.5013263822,
0.2272163928,
-0.3311393559,
-0.2699991763,
-0.8803197145,
-0.0582842156,
0.0059808986,
-0.4661946893,
-0.5556797981,
-0.0310893804,
-0.2144570351,
0.1190342233,
0.0356396325,
-0.2912050486,
0.1838637888,
-0.9302470684,
0.245740816,
0.3600785434,
0.6565199494,
0.3075945973,
-0.4737294316,
0.2908625007,
0.3903824687,
0.2541054189,
-0.268478781,
-0.8159407973,
-0.8779574633,
-0.3369825482,
0.0910873935,
0.4028674364,
-0.9801710844,
0.4813942909,
-0.277492851,
-0.0628465414,
-0.663843751,
0.0967964828,
0.5100470781,
0.8349651694,
0.5189922452,
-0.5254859924,
-0.3454931676,
-0.6754398346,
-0.3822134435,
-0.398973763,
0.155312717,
0.5746223927,
0.0335404389,
-0.3769749701,
1.0229917765,
-0.7048028708,
-0.1557038277,
-0.2152967751,
0.256908685,
0.1013682038,
0.658308804,
0.3833262622,
-0.5201699138,
-0.3765358627,
0.0009304005,
-0.7437586188,
-0.1138462797,
-0.3975886703,
-0.2455626726,
0.2652860582,
0.3162449598,
-0.5539643168,
0.6071400046,
0.2063708007,
-0.3371063769,
0.3490592539,
-0.4578663707,
0.1529707909,
-1.2913291454,
0.2085702568,
-0.2869863212,
-0.3524035811,
-0.6926376224,
-0.1585054696,
-0.1505804211,
-0.0672583506,
-0.4006328285,
0.6522752047,
-0.3519467115,
0.2773110569,
-0.2865425944,
-0.0397868231,
0.2028114945,
0.2003155947,
0.092453517,
0.7773903608,
0.2078580409,
-0.751760304,
0.2399448454,
0.3920694888,
-0.2679099441,
0.6283594966,
-0.3339248896,
-0.04943626,
0.2080567032,
-0.0031341431,
-0.5645821691,
-0.358497262,
0.29093045,
-0.3333846033,
0.4856356382,
-0.2152734548,
-0.4881254733,
-0.2891762555,
0.2670868039,
0.3134049475,
0.6183382273,
-0.3203730285,
0.1954668313,
0.5424607992,
-0.3861319125,
-0.6241366267,
-0.6279661059,
0.1019588411,
0.1224989071,
-0.3660357594,
0.1787573546,
0.0086684255,
-0.252977401,
0.1309390515,
-0.0036917301,
-0.283888191,
-0.0230158065,
0.2312904447,
0.1650710553,
-0.11524266,
0.375479579,
0.4020485878,
-0.2917104661,
0.1145590693,
-0.7451829314,
0.4440371096,
0.2957345545,
-0.7243531346,
-0.6317389011,
0.5653092861,
0.6087847948,
0.0719796345,
0.8404173851,
0.3414818048,
-0.5562811494,
0.149595812,
-0.7935951352,
-0.2609260082,
-0.4577154815,
0.2740480602,
-0.0753784552,
-0.4366908967,
0.3335424364,
-0.1951350123,
0.1490423679,
0.5882704854,
0.5304640532,
-0.1151295751,
0.7480379939,
0.5371744037,
0.1679033041,
0.2488827258,
-0.325946033,
0.3831942379,
-0.3962430954,
-0.2665456831,
-0.2524510324,
0.3156451583,
-0.4901194572,
-0.7246223688,
0.5288898945,
-0.1277139187,
0.0479947664,
0.1233894676,
-0.1980865896,
0.1106796786,
0.7452912331,
0.1012289524,
0.4697485864,
0.0554239154,
-0.4169037342,
-0.0345782153,
-1.1117590666,
-0.4256798327,
1.0434823036,
0.0870232135,
0.4673017859,
-0.3284273148,
0.897700429,
0.1823117435,
0.3289327323,
-0.7638587356,
0.220914349,
-0.1229681298,
-0.4634910524,
-0.1876427233,
-0.7032393217,
-1.059863925,
-0.4524388313,
-0.3236735463,
-0.0394612029,
0.3465451002,
0.5616435409,
-0.8210241795,
0.2130848169,
-0.9663815498,
0.6978965998,
-0.0347508006,
-0.049382031,
-0.2483265996,
-0.8117362857,
0.1488325447,
-0.2143397629,
0.2674586773,
0.3793514967,
0.2228909582,
0.4932605326,
-0.713996768,
0.8652137518,
-0.2882294953,
-0.0800200105,
0.4574669302,
-0.2138454765,
0.5405356288,
0.1957957,
0.2181573063,
0.0372944213,
-0.1607935429,
-0.5354152322,
-0.5580188036,
0.4318491817,
-0.6322932839,
-0.6218352318,
-0.327894479,
-0.4616335928,
-0.4510629177,
0.1928867102,
0.5021650791,
0.735342741,
-0.2381494343,
-0.1244403273,
0.8080170155,
-0.6006198525,
-0.1457273066,
0.3763190806,
0.1831984222,
-0.3152425587,
1.0715557337,
0.3424365819,
0.589494288,
0.2741314769,
0.1958939582,
-0.1820203066,
-0.5276870728,
-0.4674269557,
0.4420570135,
-0.82212919,
-0.3185022771,
-1.0623790026,
-0.5006292462,
-0.5883687735,
-0.2479314655,
-0.1353583485,
-0.6282360554,
-0.4519043565,
-0.3101528585,
0.3472295105,
0.7060065269,
-0.2010718882,
0.3112303913,
-0.9255759716,
0.4336622655,
0.5411013365,
0.2120982409,
-0.335074842,
-0.3973598778,
-0.57618016,
0.0025518301,
0.0379452668,
-0.6953169107,
0.2452660799,
0.1069126725,
0.8010367155,
0.7070435286,
-0.054607287,
0.6541737318,
-0.728082478,
0.8969595432,
0.4163089097,
-0.7805678248,
0.5167587996,
-0.0885082334,
0.2409314811,
0.5525456667,
0.2899050415,
-0.6770294905,
-0.8298655748,
-1.2094647884,
-0.9986539483,
0.3355055749,
0.1852985471,
0.3674460053,
-0.4559493661,
0.5541985631,
0.2113865912,
0.4631240666,
-0.2879297733,
-0.3920981586,
-0.2826476097,
-0.4716258645,
0.2285566032,
-0.5163514614,
-0.4634677172,
-0.0826831758,
0.6883503199,
-0.0431041606,
0.2737592161,
0.2599523067,
-0.2215097249,
-0.2589461207,
0.1105544865,
0.5922912359,
0.79691571,
0.1181964502,
0.0999688804,
0.1554926038,
-0.8015358448,
-0.1290443093,
0.056335941,
-0.2188735455,
0.3318335414,
0.4040381014,
0.6736834049,
0.2181003988,
-0.5932400823,
0.6772784591,
0.1725759059,
0.1453110725,
-0.1746929288,
0.1942911595,
-0.1462893486,
-0.1756730378,
0.2654596865,
0.4625033736,
0.1472828239,
-0.6179408431,
0.5876919627,
0.2637462318,
-0.1949561834,
-0.1594746411,
0.4339637458,
0.4429995716,
-0.1136922911,
0.5290184021,
-0.2680201828,
-0.415064007,
0.2845297456,
0.5029583573,
0.6471169591,
-0.0414094515,
0.1876888275,
0.3343410492,
-0.040324863,
0.1962639093,
0.2353940606,
0.1375737637,
-0.7284629345,
-0.5175859332,
-0.325399667,
-0.3171211779,
-0.0845358297,
-0.578410089,
0.0797362998,
-0.2083038092,
-0.456473887,
-0.2226019204,
-0.0921481177,
-1.0064001083,
0.3087454438,
-0.0479793474,
0.5236128569,
-0.7177762985,
0.7202357054,
0.5201156139,
-0.5281175971,
-0.9366928935,
0.3022069335,
-0.327819258,
-1.107527256,
0.7167391777,
-0.4195679426,
0.01167823,
0.0015298451,
-0.3697246015,
-0.6619163752,
0.6470721364,
0.1732210517,
-0.3472851217,
-0.1456710547,
0.1590273678,
0.4385130405,
-0.2357621938,
0.0350000113,
0.3763871789,
0.2655441463,
0.1149363965,
-0.9253174067,
0.0248167366,
0.0610366426,
-0.1965065002,
0.0311443806,
-0.2076585889,
0.417444855,
-0.5541090965,
-0.3003983498,
-0.046972584,
0.5671128631,
0.209597066,
0.2908709943,
0.4436612427,
0.4489370883,
1.0608710051,
0.1268181354,
1.1285867691,
-0.4183126092,
-0.1032356992,
0.8806005716,
-0.168585375,
0.3980995119,
0.6112220883,
0.1298549324,
0.5830265284,
0.1729852259,
0.3292895854,
0.5160748959,
0.2639205158,
-0.4490707815,
-0.0879734978,
-0.3771313131,
-0.5851885676,
0.2279714495,
0.4907577038,
-0.568512857,
0.0931695551,
0.0480149277,
0.3148639202,
0.022507539,
-0.0228818562,
1.175817132,
0.2346474528,
-0.757430017,
0.6520457268,
-0.2561562359,
0.1604389995,
-0.5778939724,
-0.2055523545,
-0.3188487589,
-0.1774108112,
-0.0732793957,
-0.4790045619,
0.2401169091,
0.0721257627,
-0.2709266245,
-0.2215692699,
0.7000662684,
-0.5954982042,
-0.326305449,
-0.2310128212,
0.7947244644,
0.1789909005,
0.2296934873,
-0.2773137391,
-0.5324183702,
-0.032257013,
0.1192578226,
0.0988732874,
0.9024559855,
0.0825419575,
0.4501812756,
0.8077848554,
0.618837297,
0.0916067287,
0.4323571324,
0.9562001228,
-0.4532070458,
-0.4535042346,
-0.4543099105,
0.5318328142,
-0.2580144405,
-0.3201803565,
0.4479396939,
0.5462818146,
0.5915814638,
-0.0621765926,
1.0609414577,
0.2193373144,
0.6176964045,
-0.5875040293,
0.9595522285,
-0.3791908622,
0.0482725501,
-0.1950655282,
-0.1993539929,
-0.4514310062,
0.5976472497,
-0.1811172217,
-0.2676713169,
0.7378593087,
0.5503146052,
0.0564861149,
-0.3231465816,
0.5025828481,
0.2764503658,
0.2765699029,
0.3566467166,
0.8386807442,
-0.2144547403,
0.432059586,
-0.0947849303,
-0.2606688142,
-0.3302251697,
-0.6918812394,
-0.6249242425,
-0.5933688283,
-0.4441482723,
-0.5898136497,
0.2834058404,
1.086171031,
0.6816288233,
-0.901710391,
0.0751841217,
-0.1575935334,
0.0932582691,
-0.2378139496,
-0.2033300251,
0.3837196529,
-0.8022672534,
-0.4569166303,
0.2575918138,
0.3495059311,
0.3614629209,
-0.068747744,
0.0512193181,
0.0574440025,
0.2815312743,
0.4895007312,
0.2337049395,
-0.4878449738,
-0.3850876689,
0.0394305587,
-0.3266910315,
0.2300479859,
1.0975555182,
-0.8472292423,
0.6570959687,
0.2664520144,
0.6818211079,
0.2072086185,
0.0291600246,
0.9400727153,
-0.9907056689,
0.09573064,
0.5321355462,
0.4765222967,
0.4995049834,
-0.6411818266,
0.1779321581,
0.7302800417,
-0.4412619174,
-0.7181726098,
0.3778961897,
-0.5937640071,
0.0244336519,
1.2403776646,
-0.3014436662,
0.1420382708,
-0.6286224723,
-0.3032445908,
0.715026319,
-0.2389448732,
1.0321470499,
0.4605716765,
-0.07494656,
0.3782148063,
-0.5178303123,
1.032130003,
0.500774622,
-0.8469833732,
-0.0790459588,
0.4497565031,
0.2840467095,
0.2623474598,
0.8956522346,
-0.0987436622,
0.2186219841,
-0.1959251165,
-0.0747896433,
0.1838057488,
-0.2833091021,
0.1837309897,
0.000175118,
0.246076867,
-0.1633651406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03650v1 | A Quantum Probability Driven Framework for Joint Multi-Modal Sarcasm, Sentiment and Emotion Analysis | 2023-06-06T13:08:22 | 2023-06-06T13:08:22 | Yaochen Liu, Yazhou Zhang, Dawei Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sarcasm, sentiment, and emotion are three typical kinds of spontaneous
affective responses of humans to external events and they are tightly
intertwined with each other. Such events may be expressed in multiple
modalities (e.g., linguistic, visual and acoustic), e.g., multi-modal
conversations. Joint analysis of humans' multi-modal sarcasm, sentiment, and
emotion is an important yet challenging topic, as it is a complex cognitive
process involving both cross-modality interaction and cross-affection
correlation. From the probability theory perspective, cross-affection
correlation also means that the judgments on sarcasm, sentiment, and emotion
are incompatible. However, this exposed phenomenon cannot be sufficiently
modelled by classical probability theory due to its assumption of
compatibility. Neither do the existing approaches take it into consideration.
In view of the recent success of quantum probability (QP) in modeling human
cognition, particularly contextual incompatible decision making, we take the
first step towards introducing QP into joint multi-modal sarcasm, sentiment,
and emotion analysis. Specifically, we propose a QUantum probabIlity driven
multi-modal sarcasm, sEntiment and emoTion analysis framework, termed QUIET.
Extensive experiments on two datasets and the results show that the
effectiveness and advantages of QUIET in comparison with a wide range of the
state-of-the-art baselines. We also show the great potential of QP in
multi-affect analysis. | [
-0.3661525548,
-0.8231160641,
0.5976914763,
0.3542933762,
-0.2682625949,
-0.0535277389,
-0.2367836982,
-0.4384921789,
0.413092941,
-0.1512843966,
-0.6189544201,
-0.2255577892,
-0.1337907463,
-0.0888789445,
0.1168624833,
0.928735137,
0.3076634109,
0.3852854669,
0.1168992445,
-0.1726478636,
-0.2922325432,
-0.5005657673,
-0.5963787436,
0.1959040761,
0.3235526085,
0.0198492166,
1.0317566395,
-0.4196751714,
0.6000652313,
0.2121605426,
0.1083902419,
-0.3523678482,
-0.1955400407,
0.2974543273,
-0.1430077106,
-0.4470067918,
-0.4556381106,
-0.0077042477,
0.5357425213,
0.3659363687,
-0.1944999099,
-0.2793876827,
-0.2043801695,
0.7600076795,
-1.0563844442,
0.1563422531,
-0.3362903893,
0.5592052341,
-0.0632522777,
-0.2673507929,
-0.2195499092,
-0.2780002058,
0.0727236122,
-0.4767977893,
-0.1282442808,
-0.1263305843,
0.3887813687,
0.2183215916,
-1.0914322138,
0.021035606,
-0.6281362772,
1.0652574301,
-0.6262538433,
0.6372496486,
0.055367548,
0.0896207318,
-0.2858880162,
-0.0979131088,
-0.828081429,
-0.2633203268,
-0.0186823346,
0.6387229562,
-0.3512783647,
0.3249110281,
0.1496293396,
0.2284460217,
-0.5803139806,
-0.5622822046,
0.0143380528,
-0.1547264904,
0.5746370554,
0.2130687237,
0.3962157965,
-0.6242265105,
-0.7337480783,
0.0423852392,
-0.0673905015,
0.4248036742,
0.3285297751,
0.0971921161,
-0.3276418746,
0.3910139799,
-0.6330892444,
0.3664589226,
0.0049018762,
-0.4806327224,
0.1818677485,
-0.4238821566,
-0.2202202529,
-0.0300786924,
1.2123416662,
0.4036323428,
0.0348928422,
0.0207140706,
-0.0976518244,
0.3312784731,
0.0919943377,
-0.5254076123,
-0.2781079412,
0.6319720745,
-0.5861265659,
-0.4303239286,
-0.1032047048,
-1.0338072777,
-0.4700584412,
-0.1535456479,
0.5579196215,
-0.6428129077,
-0.5787705779,
0.098009266,
-0.4787631929,
0.0020463101,
0.3631775975,
-0.5976742506,
0.1668547243,
0.5564158559,
0.3733072281,
0.088806361,
-0.3301263452,
-0.2632660866,
0.2784465253,
-0.314196229,
0.5428783298,
-0.5446401834,
-0.2514571249,
-0.3229469359,
-0.5008448958,
-0.1263850331,
0.1836903691,
0.7798944116,
-0.5521196723,
0.3732763231,
-0.2203452736,
-0.2645461261,
-0.4064544439,
0.3725383878,
-0.889999032,
0.6113922596,
0.2317312062,
-1.0916688442,
0.3503336608,
-0.6266723275,
-0.5389258862,
-0.0543392934,
-0.4113005698,
-0.2228134274,
0.4368492067,
-0.1080290526,
0.2726311386,
-0.427398771,
0.5381886363,
-0.8295431137,
-0.3786978126,
0.9238685966,
-0.6531986594,
0.9341182709,
0.297375977,
-0.5365285873,
0.1275334358,
-0.6220759153,
0.154152751,
-0.3598000705,
-0.0882602558,
-0.2886791229,
0.0976190194,
0.0107889408,
0.6889100671,
0.2625316978,
-0.4078119993,
-0.0993867218,
-0.0816477165,
0.3776020408,
0.6786520481,
0.1551934481,
0.4054746032,
-0.2289323658,
0.820589602,
0.4996114373,
0.7186691165,
0.1021188572,
-0.5744650364,
-0.3542267978,
-0.7684925199,
0.1461166888,
0.6908214688,
-0.5509128571,
0.3380455375,
-0.0362314358,
-0.1902397573,
-0.3741925359,
-0.2721433342,
0.4100551009,
0.22602202,
0.1374086142,
-0.6329363585,
-0.3390236497,
-0.8943600059,
-0.5087887645,
-0.4550921321,
0.4519087374,
0.1207779869,
-0.030408144,
0.0336984918,
1.0659008026,
-0.2874823809,
-0.1610936224,
0.175941661,
0.2086930126,
0.0442071147,
0.6319513321,
0.2382600456,
-1.0700449944,
-0.2847977579,
-0.0918311477,
-0.9356669188,
0.5109642148,
-0.2810562253,
-0.4494435489,
0.289981246,
0.1709572673,
-0.9829025269,
0.5819992423,
0.2366749495,
-0.3614738882,
0.5684717894,
0.4802112281,
0.719376564,
-0.9633102417,
0.0002691797,
0.1839932203,
-0.0438125394,
-0.6415016651,
0.2444071323,
-0.0358967967,
-0.1380546093,
-0.5097185373,
0.3934331834,
-0.2126337141,
0.0086361701,
0.0711683333,
-0.1168294623,
0.0239245873,
0.674752295,
-0.0113697695,
0.1978799254,
0.7475848198,
-0.3196966648,
0.3349941671,
-0.0302672051,
0.012109627,
1.1146024466,
-0.204020083,
-0.3609588444,
-0.0063415547,
0.4680371284,
-1.00243783,
-0.3163019717,
0.6412524581,
-0.6109213829,
0.0909196213,
-0.0445951521,
-0.4100014567,
-0.0913508385,
-0.7870851755,
0.554848671,
0.4974737763,
-0.0589143224,
1.0787642002,
0.2524988055,
-0.1799335778,
-0.6797774434,
-0.5712112188,
-0.1669491231,
-0.4314845204,
-0.7974795103,
0.0038497939,
-0.3613733351,
-0.423011601,
0.0762819499,
-0.0787231326,
-0.3586067259,
0.2122260332,
0.5721930861,
0.2865496278,
-0.1381005496,
0.3238895833,
0.1200767383,
-0.0375825465,
0.2356039137,
0.1341446936,
0.1758383811,
-0.3063940108,
-0.4711995721,
-1.1029145718,
0.5288360715,
0.5982785821,
0.0592857227,
0.4170747399,
0.9836524725,
-0.3964514434,
0.1475143135,
-0.4759839177,
-0.2694601417,
-0.4510860741,
0.2069570273,
-0.6003262997,
-0.9123340845,
0.4940901697,
0.0057487222,
-0.4191311002,
0.3293056786,
0.5218113065,
-0.1246448457,
1.5347715616,
0.7562832832,
-0.2155149579,
0.7061551809,
0.4725522995,
0.677631557,
-0.6745638251,
0.0745591745,
-0.2132868469,
-0.4200246036,
-0.8059262037,
-0.2901379466,
0.6830788255,
0.6526949406,
-0.2003228664,
-0.384074688,
-0.2663541734,
0.3118712604,
0.7503044009,
0.169089973,
0.3340232372,
-0.0239365045,
0.0659008473,
-0.0276638195,
-0.5683906078,
-0.0129429027,
0.9401597381,
0.0799458325,
0.560672462,
0.5595393181,
0.8148493767,
0.2198387831,
0.0281435326,
-0.7658835649,
0.6758970618,
0.2701150179,
-0.9020796418,
-0.3126602471,
-0.6151007414,
-0.6199703217,
0.2729349732,
-0.3359473348,
-0.9250456095,
0.3560830355,
0.0681117997,
-0.584908247,
-0.0087767197,
-0.7632425427,
0.9072917104,
-0.0421646871,
-0.4938017726,
-0.5301944017,
-0.9634812474,
1.1116174459,
-0.1270952374,
0.4987036586,
-0.2461924106,
0.152693212,
0.6287555099,
-0.0204043221,
0.8903537393,
-0.0521157272,
0.0533209182,
0.4917251468,
0.5494462252,
0.1556467712,
0.5599684119,
-0.2395406216,
0.0252405815,
0.3099392056,
-0.4844351411,
-0.5794228315,
0.8101165295,
-0.8966670036,
-0.2434884012,
-0.7167749405,
-0.6313198805,
-0.4891368449,
0.0279544294,
-0.1009205952,
0.2659305334,
-0.3035760224,
-0.3659932613,
0.45413661,
-0.0052328031,
0.5563518405,
0.4566426873,
-0.0446835123,
-0.7890538573,
1.0396784544,
-0.3757951856,
0.0528655462,
0.3504658341,
0.4081352949,
-0.1963358521,
0.2317861468,
-0.1362327635,
0.0320515074,
-0.8402149677,
-0.1984828562,
-0.6381444931,
0.2288673371,
-0.589325726,
-0.2953080237,
-0.1125693023,
-0.7455974221,
-0.0241665989,
0.2757756114,
0.4092463255,
0.3094080687,
-0.5049542189,
0.112580061,
-0.9444916248,
0.5065948367,
0.5682364702,
0.2708898783,
0.1627528816,
0.1520665735,
-0.0087733157,
0.0609785095,
-0.4699619412,
-1.2350664139,
0.2271420509,
0.0173342526,
0.2127019614,
0.5999397039,
0.3986943364,
0.5822256207,
0.0948814899,
0.9304801226,
0.7636252642,
-1.4103391171,
0.5921622515,
-0.4935486913,
-0.1183688194,
0.5074509978,
0.3915151358,
-0.5621141195,
-0.3595015109,
-1.0356781483,
-0.6204236746,
0.8209529519,
0.094139874,
-0.1668813378,
-0.0536209829,
-0.0140483137,
-0.0871710256,
0.544578135,
-0.9613609314,
-0.0590374507,
-0.011181199,
-0.461758852,
0.106408678,
-0.0579338521,
-0.6450331211,
-0.0575349443,
0.6872622967,
-0.1724075824,
0.4439022541,
0.1202068776,
-0.1310293078,
-0.5141817331,
0.4503142238,
0.3246229291,
0.2682036459,
-0.3471356332,
0.3592765331,
-0.0908222422,
-0.041730918,
0.0954577625,
0.1902118772,
0.0790565759,
-0.2094374597,
0.2124734968,
0.4268627465,
0.3825903237,
-0.8213791847,
0.8575466871,
-0.1398015767,
0.1844848096,
-0.1916676015,
-0.0233621374,
-0.0308200791,
0.6645666957,
0.1247623414,
0.3429253101,
0.6899657845,
-0.8694748282,
0.2324266285,
0.6941230297,
-0.7346457839,
-0.5599048734,
0.405590862,
0.0389036126,
0.1503824443,
0.3810967803,
-0.6601244807,
-0.7576398849,
0.4338618517,
0.1888040602,
1.0744073391,
0.0400169194,
0.3948562741,
0.1795547605,
0.0899316147,
0.0894641131,
0.9964849353,
-0.1069322377,
-0.5457375646,
-0.3287766874,
-0.5951974392,
-0.4151889682,
-0.4531517923,
-0.7554591894,
0.1899614483,
-0.4320271313,
-0.4793008268,
-0.0199071337,
0.0639965981,
-0.603622973,
0.3865676522,
0.27235955,
0.1584041566,
-0.9320207238,
0.5337986946,
0.5937517285,
-0.4666656256,
-0.7034992576,
0.199000448,
0.3019955456,
-0.496145606,
0.5840639472,
0.0172473881,
-0.2675636113,
-0.0800572485,
-0.543658793,
-0.8842691779,
0.7518417239,
0.1840784997,
-0.311910212,
0.5083441734,
-0.1216934025,
0.4743143618,
0.1085635647,
0.6158075929,
0.3258273602,
0.4795999527,
-0.2015846819,
-0.7900975347,
0.2403213382,
-0.2564596236,
-0.1464315504,
0.4945784509,
-1.0754529238,
1.1080768108,
-0.1720776707,
-0.1142615676,
-0.1918611377,
0.6414484978,
0.5073956847,
0.6065311432,
0.5470214486,
0.890448153,
0.5334205627,
0.0861312896,
0.7681626678,
-0.6137932539,
0.4464600384,
0.8097117543,
-0.5685944557,
0.9743982553,
0.6099178195,
-0.5105323792,
0.594483614,
0.4541980624,
0.4343813658,
0.3505272269,
0.0970642343,
-0.7204994559,
-0.4623098969,
-0.203665033,
-0.2967736125,
0.3911278248,
0.3139341176,
0.1716549844,
-0.034992218,
-0.0337671004,
-0.1662430316,
-0.4537235796,
-0.0114740487,
0.6048799753,
0.1117085889,
-0.3935314119,
0.0533304252,
0.1276239604,
0.7224392295,
-0.4328024983,
0.1857975572,
-0.0793319941,
-0.1200659126,
-0.3224208355,
-0.6059234142,
-0.0810660198,
-0.476184994,
-0.3350038528,
0.2232898623,
0.7136982083,
-0.2037595809,
-0.2638687193,
0.1440802664,
0.6753662229,
0.088944234,
-0.1714892536,
-0.9504497051,
0.1597991735,
-0.0926985592,
-0.3963676393,
0.5001027584,
0.9210857749,
-0.1481613666,
0.3931293488,
0.7473526597,
-0.347320646,
0.1934653968,
0.0684044585,
0.6409096122,
-1.1206263304,
-0.9013962746,
-0.8021408319,
0.6103218198,
0.1047123224,
-0.4551983774,
0.532920599,
0.2693667412,
0.3469577134,
0.1204933971,
0.7991582751,
-0.2157345712,
0.0790327787,
-0.4060132504,
0.2473071814,
-0.6529508233,
-0.1200232655,
-0.6301844716,
-0.6248934269,
-0.2201810479,
0.5310502052,
-0.04751876,
0.1765158176,
1.0058428049,
0.6405491233,
0.1121153384,
0.5335327983,
0.1944596469,
-0.015151348,
0.0732401386,
1.031619072,
1.2425156832,
-0.4435181022,
0.2158315182,
-0.6586701274,
-0.3918499351,
-0.3909714222,
-0.8861637712,
-0.4882487655,
-0.4928379357,
-0.7517540455,
-0.4984520674,
-0.0995660275,
0.7952368259,
0.6584865451,
-0.5670771599,
-0.0967755839,
-0.1443827152,
0.380736649,
-0.4100495875,
-0.3759297431,
0.249518618,
-0.2814018726,
-0.5143775344,
0.2505787313,
0.5784131289,
-0.0376214124,
-0.2130814791,
0.0206693448,
-0.0025857156,
0.2317956537,
0.6008785367,
0.2029713243,
-0.7476942539,
-0.1171517223,
-0.3343129456,
-0.3166325092,
-0.1091319174,
0.7137870789,
-0.8799730539,
0.4764134288,
0.6571595073,
0.1496859789,
-0.0550684668,
-0.1619159281,
0.4326919615,
-0.5721877813,
0.3079354167,
0.4373244345,
0.2316519171,
0.0375616997,
-0.5117762685,
0.317915976,
0.4483804107,
-0.4654516876,
-0.9614669681,
0.4480717778,
-1.6103982925,
-0.4455345869,
0.8776643872,
0.2279800624,
-0.1516268551,
0.1699338853,
-0.0635417551,
0.4611167312,
-0.6924048662,
0.8305230737,
0.5954229832,
-0.5863317847,
-0.0168855917,
-0.4482742548,
0.4040737152,
1.0131275654,
-0.6877871752,
-0.212280497,
0.7618991137,
-0.0689962432,
0.3630978465,
0.9306429029,
0.090977788,
0.6244198084,
0.1408130974,
0.3397599161,
0.7022856474,
-0.277960062,
-0.7043760419,
0.5830407739,
0.0101671582,
0.0470088497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05370v1 | Detecting Human Rights Violations on Social Media during Russia-Ukraine War | 2023-06-06T12:59:03 | 2023-06-06T12:59:03 | Poli Nemkova, Solomon Ubani, Suleyman Olcay Polat, Nayeon Kim, Rodney D. Nielsen | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | The present-day Russia-Ukraine military conflict has exposed the pivotal role
of social media in enabling the transparent and unbridled sharing of
information directly from the frontlines. In conflict zones where freedom of
expression is constrained and information warfare is pervasive, social media
has emerged as an indispensable lifeline. Anonymous social media platforms, as
publicly available sources for disseminating war-related information, have the
potential to serve as effective instruments for monitoring and documenting
Human Rights Violations (HRV). Our research focuses on the analysis of data
from Telegram, the leading social media platform for reading independent news
in post-Soviet regions. We gathered a dataset of posts sampled from 95 public
Telegram channels that cover politics and war news, which we have utilized to
identify potential occurrences of HRV. Employing a mBERT-based text classifier,
we have conducted an analysis to detect any mentions of HRV in the Telegram
data. Our final approach yielded an $F_2$ score of 0.71 for HRV detection,
representing an improvement of 0.38 over the multilingual BERT base model. We
release two datasets that contains Telegram posts: (1) large corpus with over
2.3 millions posts and (2) annotated at the sentence-level dataset to indicate
HRVs. The Telegram posts are in the context of the Russia-Ukraine war. We posit
that our findings hold significant implications for NGOs, governments, and
researchers by providing a means to detect and document possible human rights
violations. | [
-0.1615395993,
-0.5169141293,
0.5276292562,
0.3288276494,
-0.5788906813,
0.4590961337,
-0.0057281973,
-0.4470284283,
-0.0515166,
0.624346137,
-0.3361724317,
-0.9138306379,
-0.8009425998,
-0.0253407024,
-0.5488972664,
0.7922622561,
-0.0830396637,
0.211036846,
0.356684953,
-0.3841364682,
0.0797851756,
-0.5610179305,
-0.1239151284,
0.0383159369,
0.7631113529,
0.3859968781,
0.2361592203,
0.4827845991,
0.7267801166,
0.291959554,
-0.0794229507,
-0.1615945399,
-0.5188524723,
0.1080585495,
0.0677089766,
-0.3609377742,
-0.1961879432,
0.0836497471,
0.6540840268,
-0.1988631636,
-0.2372522205,
0.6583588123,
0.214718774,
0.6848751903,
-0.4368605912,
-0.3237216771,
-0.4077340662,
0.0925218239,
-0.5864750147,
-0.1478772163,
-0.014146545,
-0.5798313618,
0.0848497525,
-0.3803373277,
0.4033634961,
-0.1724751145,
1.0060079098,
-0.1288854331,
-0.479735285,
-0.27108863,
-0.6340501904,
0.8307836056,
-0.2830131352,
0.6523754001,
0.5189548135,
0.3384063244,
0.002933728,
-0.7245465517,
-0.4865014553,
0.1175009459,
0.2291642725,
0.1980562806,
-0.8508750796,
-0.385286212,
0.1957082152,
-0.3486337066,
-0.4348284304,
-0.2165780813,
-0.6866123676,
-0.6010735631,
0.5974094868,
-0.1436952055,
0.4279143512,
-0.8907589912,
-0.4453112781,
0.2834807336,
-0.6115422249,
0.4079859257,
0.9489908814,
0.2067441195,
-0.6268224716,
0.6106791496,
-0.2725659609,
0.3385910988,
-0.0397864319,
0.1426076144,
-0.0367951989,
-0.28449893,
0.1091037467,
0.3576188087,
0.9424304366,
0.7211187482,
0.3234643638,
0.0770836696,
-0.1529415548,
0.4670430422,
0.5662229657,
-0.7016808391,
0.1615916342,
-0.0008555197,
-0.8315322995,
-0.6184766889,
0.2848600447,
-0.725961566,
-0.8305070996,
-0.0107476804,
0.2083551288,
-0.283937782,
-0.157179445,
-0.2389618307,
-0.3648851216,
0.3071535528,
0.1771145314,
-0.2724102437,
-0.0496054366,
0.6227295399,
1.0274648666,
0.4008997381,
0.0978012159,
-0.8675042987,
-0.3887180686,
-0.2189429253,
0.6304098368,
-0.2559099197,
-0.3631753027,
0.3988091052,
0.2368164957,
0.7057876587,
-0.2971206903,
0.8013322949,
-0.65775913,
-0.2088014334,
-0.3490624428,
-0.1271169037,
0.2011117637,
0.0075764833,
-0.5154682994,
0.744217515,
-0.0216130745,
-0.8314762712,
0.4033204019,
-0.0837885737,
-0.3450708687,
0.116933912,
-0.0878934488,
-0.659773767,
-0.1795732528,
-0.2325062305,
0.7001264095,
-0.0339578725,
-0.1345308125,
-0.5130106211,
-0.3418951035,
0.3232519329,
0.1078801379,
0.6787384152,
0.1161751524,
-0.3770788312,
0.1899954528,
-0.7405025959,
-0.2865801752,
0.0462917313,
-0.7022050023,
-0.238221705,
0.1556677222,
0.0739338621,
0.3711211979,
-0.0471906103,
-0.9921048284,
-0.2856757045,
0.1944141388,
0.599355042,
0.8616149426,
0.2716028094,
0.4807144105,
-0.442070365,
0.4331055582,
0.3322515488,
0.6511505842,
0.4632974267,
-0.4935495853,
-0.454367429,
0.2506162226,
0.2266187668,
0.3789506257,
-0.5820905566,
0.4014931917,
-0.015979806,
-0.7130561471,
-1.0174478292,
-0.0066939448,
0.0160920881,
0.3836753964,
0.1449571699,
0.1384447664,
-1.0268604755,
-0.9940339327,
-0.4437627196,
-0.4363199174,
0.0998754129,
0.1235105097,
0.2519780695,
-0.3870645165,
0.7948063016,
0.2659736574,
-0.3021789491,
0.1777361035,
0.283008635,
-0.4300781786,
0.1685914546,
0.1525917202,
-1.1492862701,
-0.6086060405,
-0.0692957565,
-0.7896239758,
0.0780545175,
0.118095845,
-0.2411739975,
0.297161907,
0.3512679636,
-0.0485264324,
0.6018390656,
0.5410414934,
-0.3400225043,
0.5509476066,
0.0556347854,
0.6524323225,
-0.8747077584,
0.1195067614,
0.2165999264,
-0.4754628241,
-0.7645123601,
-0.5323486924,
0.4155330062,
-0.1611656845,
-0.9158939123,
0.1020798609,
-0.1817421764,
-0.0663747489,
-0.0788116604,
0.2044258267,
-0.3466210663,
-0.1553313136,
-0.2859078646,
0.369697541,
0.6085708737,
-0.2106405944,
0.4446888864,
0.2183242142,
-0.7678704858,
0.4803774953,
-0.5487950444,
0.1099606454,
-0.2517744601,
0.0047766264,
-0.5896409154,
-0.1393238604,
0.5417779684,
-1.0206693411,
-0.6889843345,
-0.4052875042,
-0.2138917595,
-0.1012287065,
-0.6256358624,
-0.2168446332,
0.6082947254,
-0.0150053306,
0.4125781357,
0.8593434691,
0.1409449875,
-1.0345410109,
-0.4183308482,
0.2093117982,
-0.25310269,
-0.3634720147,
-0.0049202116,
0.3213168085,
-0.2765623927,
0.1837408543,
-0.2095050216,
0.0227822866,
-0.0458819903,
0.7954263091,
-0.0195371639,
0.0012725831,
0.1291679889,
-0.5373697877,
0.120879665,
0.145596385,
0.0878232792,
0.6383232474,
-0.2568034828,
0.0404447131,
-0.8797798157,
0.4943080544,
0.8133788705,
-0.1888422966,
0.4650679529,
0.9798971415,
-0.5392414331,
0.0630430356,
-0.6410925984,
-0.1096065268,
-0.3989998102,
-0.0259040911,
0.5267675519,
-0.6352835894,
0.8006121516,
0.2454401553,
-0.2257685214,
0.2058046162,
0.2558246851,
-0.5082309842,
0.8966283798,
0.7200959921,
-0.2741196156,
0.7195696235,
-0.1372401118,
-0.0358546041,
-0.5451470613,
-0.4201684594,
-0.5867898464,
-0.4107033908,
-0.8616312146,
-0.1039114073,
0.2109487206,
-0.0918842331,
-0.0322780088,
0.2696562111,
-0.3208419383,
0.1986922771,
0.4177204669,
0.4012335837,
-0.0302407742,
0.1593598574,
0.1646108776,
-0.0162390638,
-0.5889431238,
-0.7783091664,
0.7516469955,
0.2450869977,
0.7556776404,
-0.0672603026,
0.6873332858,
0.7971398234,
0.3411905766,
-0.6719825268,
0.5800381303,
0.0334931053,
-0.4542518258,
-0.3475718796,
-0.4842317104,
-1.246399641,
-0.1995264292,
-0.3735889196,
-0.6312360764,
0.416819185,
0.0652541965,
-0.4992164671,
0.2274868637,
-0.336489737,
0.6663792133,
-0.1301162392,
-0.4827002585,
-0.34430632,
-0.748904407,
0.1653950512,
-0.0121982712,
0.1899384111,
-0.2680843771,
-0.1297160983,
0.8649318218,
-0.3550849259,
0.8531435728,
-0.1986637712,
0.3327261806,
0.2848695815,
-0.3951814175,
0.3248643577,
-0.0994891673,
0.2090826184,
0.1960273534,
-0.1494294107,
-0.5006015301,
0.0917289779,
0.6902189851,
-1.0698542595,
-0.3114339709,
-0.5142014623,
0.0252105985,
0.1734714359,
0.1943291724,
0.5293473005,
0.3461114168,
-0.4492160082,
0.5488022566,
0.439260155,
-0.1062338874,
0.1761205345,
0.6530863047,
-0.059974961,
-0.3251617849,
0.7970722914,
0.6366491318,
-0.1689377874,
-0.0182467904,
0.1710955948,
-0.4140596986,
-0.2742210329,
-0.5114313364,
0.3511275649,
-0.6280509233,
-0.3310563266,
-0.5215993524,
0.1150600091,
-0.4608750939,
-0.0288013313,
-0.0657574534,
0.1006701812,
-0.1388164312,
0.2657988071,
0.3983835578,
0.7524034977,
-0.3196686208,
0.5201699138,
-1.041778326,
0.5956699252,
0.2325507998,
0.4637511671,
-0.4055656195,
-0.3416337967,
-0.4359825253,
0.281147778,
-0.4722582102,
-1.2885584831,
0.1786676943,
-0.3036448359,
0.1634011716,
0.2116887718,
0.2168293595,
0.616599977,
-0.4913313985,
0.5194382071,
0.1027425155,
-0.9295336604,
0.5888788104,
-0.7285990715,
0.063841708,
0.1894924343,
0.6308158636,
-0.9961738586,
-0.471660316,
-1.121029973,
-0.6127387285,
0.7446340322,
0.2668555379,
-0.0158964191,
0.3555019498,
0.2111585885,
-0.4676567912,
0.2902798653,
-0.4970865548,
0.0695646182,
-0.2642944753,
0.0507551022,
0.3654441833,
-0.3111958802,
-0.0998412892,
0.036722865,
0.7342348695,
0.4067066312,
0.0779465511,
0.5279303789,
-0.2442819625,
-0.7569547296,
0.1387716681,
0.465346396,
0.6456324458,
-0.0750571638,
0.104892306,
-0.0582637414,
-0.6312312484,
0.31015113,
-0.1078488529,
-0.1869332045,
0.2729418576,
0.1832879484,
0.3282093704,
0.1699454039,
-0.7550236583,
0.9046609998,
-0.231347993,
-0.3492920399,
-0.45518592,
-0.1668022722,
0.1712438613,
0.6480212212,
0.4885354936,
0.1014601439,
-0.0426650196,
-0.666924715,
0.7430835366,
0.303614378,
-0.5606293678,
-0.6114003062,
0.1087068468,
0.289753139,
-1.0098674297,
0.2743794918,
0.0750070587,
-0.6397955418,
0.5105803609,
-0.1157299429,
0.4150430858,
-0.6219220757,
0.7287106514,
0.083973594,
0.440367192,
0.0524873883,
0.5129953623,
0.0019917085,
-0.699614346,
-0.0753489658,
-0.2698582411,
-0.293775022,
0.474697113,
-0.9289738536,
0.5226407051,
-0.5167699456,
-0.3839780688,
0.5161132216,
0.0259697363,
-0.6767453551,
-0.146157667,
0.3977716267,
0.3855938911,
-0.6761724353,
0.5200793147,
0.6220601797,
0.0405426212,
-0.3259525001,
-0.1869233251,
0.331748873,
-0.7008285522,
0.5745605826,
0.2242302001,
-0.2582599521,
0.0528791845,
-0.450378567,
-0.1910492331,
0.6066965461,
0.5403999686,
-0.6077631712,
0.2550992668,
0.499928087,
0.5178422928,
0.1847116798,
-0.4479367733,
0.5491910577,
0.5149433017,
-0.7606884241,
-0.468313694,
-0.1210291237,
-0.2313316464,
-0.3832224905,
0.6168655753,
-0.9744913578,
0.3757413626,
0.1432664692,
-0.8723551631,
-0.2428717762,
0.2401620448,
-0.1432765871,
0.4093203843,
0.5967128277,
0.197316125,
0.4720182121,
-0.1391351521,
0.6123264432,
-0.0740516633,
0.3733642995,
0.1042527929,
-0.0100151291,
0.7648925781,
0.3628568053,
0.106637083,
0.3103993535,
0.3994249403,
-0.0919246823,
0.3497241139,
0.267860204,
-0.522690177,
-0.1533836871,
-0.5186858177,
-0.0238974374,
0.569907248,
0.1060621291,
-0.4022904038,
-0.6402702332,
0.2616354525,
-0.0815245062,
0.1077090427,
-0.2739616036,
0.824125886,
0.0047651017,
-0.2633655369,
0.518045783,
0.1684184968,
0.4399188161,
-0.7286764979,
-0.0173038114,
0.298252821,
0.2251693159,
-0.3023713529,
-0.7854652405,
0.3339609802,
0.5952534676,
-0.0254954528,
-0.2387904078,
1.0519465208,
-0.4002665579,
-0.2707713246,
0.3804745078,
0.7397875786,
0.1105046123,
-0.3266315162,
-0.7816354036,
0.494423449,
-0.0416076593,
-0.1394166946,
0.2386126965,
0.4843603671,
-0.0201997049,
0.5632411838,
0.7628257871,
0.5469127893,
0.0386753976,
-0.0406595096,
0.8008551598,
-0.6873386502,
-0.515065372,
-1.1032844782,
0.3930838704,
-0.4238429666,
-0.317848444,
0.8805770874,
0.6294770241,
0.48349756,
0.2459339797,
1.0848283768,
0.0076523814,
0.7447992563,
-0.2560417354,
0.9461151958,
-0.3529925048,
-0.2682541311,
-0.00451762,
-0.2139437646,
-0.2741298378,
0.4888132811,
-0.1486842185,
-0.8189650178,
0.2274052501,
0.8970611095,
-0.0223315861,
-0.0542644225,
0.2161462307,
0.0402006954,
0.3524359763,
-0.1153548732,
1.4378859997,
-0.3929632902,
0.8772800565,
-0.5197256804,
0.0122484351,
-0.4828837812,
-0.732010603,
-0.9357088208,
-0.6913108826,
0.0863158554,
-0.5521185994,
0.4137818813,
0.9397180676,
0.7266767025,
-0.4012076557,
-0.276494354,
0.3472869098,
0.228730306,
0.0668258294,
-0.1671109945,
0.2397382557,
0.1297778487,
-0.299788475,
-0.136473611,
0.1126060635,
0.2881896198,
-0.1460516453,
0.0824210718,
-0.2631039321,
-0.1352549046,
0.5808613896,
0.2941951752,
-0.7923548818,
-0.6271337867,
0.4384680688,
-0.1601258367,
0.1012646854,
1.1573554277,
-0.5616277456,
0.2579854131,
0.4728102088,
0.6885988712,
0.241766721,
0.2480039299,
0.2117664069,
-1.0150536299,
0.194773227,
0.5073670149,
0.4423617423,
0.5517773032,
-0.400413394,
0.1645600796,
0.3415199518,
-0.6786674857,
-1.0446128845,
-0.1363142431,
-0.8270255923,
0.0536493883,
1.1756774187,
0.0872501582,
-0.3244500756,
-0.4596219957,
-0.2534434795,
0.8114537001,
-0.8769361973,
1.3545356989,
1.1648616791,
0.2786253393,
-0.0370592922,
-0.8751077056,
0.5572966337,
0.1034987122,
-0.7997834086,
0.2875044644,
0.3426114917,
0.1324068159,
0.0381665193,
0.3319134712,
0.1122950017,
0.624356389,
-0.416521579,
-0.0988863334,
0.2486340851,
-0.2354925722,
-0.3757173121,
-0.0698817149,
-0.5973889828,
-0.3619389236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03628v1 | Convergence and Diversity in the Control Hierarchy | 2023-06-06T12:30:29 | 2023-06-06T12:30:29 | Alexandra Butoi, Ryan Cotterell, David Chiang | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.CL | Weir has defined a hierarchy of language classes whose second member
($\mathcal{L}_2$) is generated by tree-adjoining grammars (TAG), linear indexed
grammars (LIG), combinatory categorial grammars, and head grammars. The
hierarchy is obtained using the mechanism of control, and $\mathcal{L}_2$ is
obtained using a context-free grammar (CFG) whose derivations are controlled by
another CFG. We adapt Weir's definition of a controllable CFG to give a
definition of controllable pushdown automata (PDAs). This yields three new
characterizations of $\mathcal{L}_2$ as the class of languages generated by
PDAs controlling PDAs, PDAs controlling CFGs, and CFGs controlling PDAs. We
show that these four formalisms are not only weakly equivalent but equivalent
in a stricter sense that we call d-weak equivalence. Furthermore, using an even
stricter notion of equivalence called d-strong equivalence, we make precise the
intuition that a CFG controlling a CFG is a TAG, a PDA controlling a PDA is an
embedded PDA, and a PDA controlling a CFG is a LIG. The fourth member of this
family, a CFG controlling a PDA, does not correspond to any formalism we know
of, so we invent one and call it a Pushdown Adjoining Automaton. | [
-0.2096852064,
-0.5717832446,
0.1651159972,
0.2819386423,
0.0592508949,
0.3251844347,
-0.134572491,
-0.3109517097,
0.0123823062,
0.1578979194,
-0.3901098967,
-0.0536665767,
-0.7444626093,
0.073844716,
-0.6294235587,
0.960185647,
-0.4839486778,
-0.2544818521,
0.2759219706,
-0.2177676708,
-0.2616915107,
-0.0871737078,
-0.4237638116,
-0.3322613835,
0.523335278,
0.0291603655,
1.2489763498,
0.9829272032,
0.5487605929,
0.3733733296,
-0.2381961197,
-0.3500775397,
-0.3714616895,
-0.0220311806,
-0.4431734383,
-0.6038925052,
-0.3353502452,
-0.0006516413,
0.9655596614,
0.808745563,
0.0938059762,
-0.224652797,
0.1023910865,
0.8723608851,
-0.646222055,
0.0520481728,
-0.5877664685,
0.0881774724,
-0.3031372726,
-0.0799593851,
-0.1491300762,
-0.4111553729,
-0.0772751793,
-0.2440295964,
0.0308864135,
-0.3088324666,
1.0381011963,
0.4047590494,
-0.7018856406,
-0.452716589,
-0.8674850464,
0.7579136491,
-0.4773060679,
0.4351578355,
0.0323333181,
0.3120431304,
-0.5711612105,
-0.6331831813,
-0.7374666333,
-0.1535122693,
-0.0365266278,
0.3942320943,
-0.3342464566,
0.2864662111,
0.1391805112,
0.7244899273,
-0.4131765068,
0.3336301446,
-0.4875583351,
0.0372403674,
0.5670055151,
0.033375375,
0.4339837134,
0.1103186905,
-0.7267454863,
0.0733005777,
-0.8308736682,
0.1500449181,
0.3127985001,
0.2273724973,
-0.1539335549,
0.2994585335,
0.0517498292,
0.6260345578,
0.4018743634,
-0.4124850929,
0.096664533,
-0.3578605056,
-0.3608009815,
-0.4924563766,
0.4838062525,
0.3984208703,
0.0171188731,
-0.3238810301,
-0.1578785032,
0.0538875312,
0.3051425815,
-0.3785289228,
-0.091348581,
0.2010202706,
-0.5183423162,
-0.35816589,
0.310061574,
-0.6114403605,
-0.1405784339,
-0.352098465,
0.3263026178,
0.0474995673,
-0.4392989278,
-0.2965494692,
-0.1979287118,
1.1003780365,
0.292236805,
-1.2703568935,
0.8645098209,
0.7936451435,
0.6968653798,
-0.6139857173,
-0.5328435898,
-0.1745486856,
0.2136706561,
-0.6252151132,
0.2766544521,
-0.2620033324,
-0.3198878467,
0.0898827314,
0.2305366993,
-0.1273858249,
-0.6868550181,
0.2996742129,
-0.7819498181,
0.1148139089,
-0.2383873761,
-0.4239830673,
-0.3901162446,
-0.2268402725,
-0.5627720356,
0.8322598934,
0.6238548756,
-0.5440062284,
0.5480668545,
-0.0611649789,
-0.8359090686,
0.1740487665,
-0.4792828858,
-0.2078822404,
-0.078820318,
-0.8057697415,
0.1127324477,
-0.4002531171,
0.3899330199,
-0.4361435473,
-0.1247212812,
-0.276161015,
0.0920355096,
1.1880598068,
0.2495180517,
-0.9312039614,
0.252771318,
-0.4399977326,
0.068230696,
-0.2020616829,
-0.41242975,
-0.1047017872,
0.1824423075,
-0.1917570084,
0.5159105659,
-0.0126081724,
-0.1502690762,
0.3037997782,
-0.1573717892,
0.5004210472,
0.8243218064,
-0.3535430133,
0.7164868712,
-0.5885288119,
0.563806355,
0.0464852192,
0.021902103,
0.1681621373,
-0.2501351833,
-0.8569487929,
-0.2505801916,
0.1065536961,
0.7967102528,
-0.5135771036,
0.9853049517,
0.1298248619,
-0.5777717233,
-0.2006951272,
0.4040349424,
0.4295366406,
0.2118946314,
0.0047085318,
-0.5998992324,
-0.3054635525,
-0.9007226825,
-0.0656706914,
-0.3437926471,
0.0734407008,
0.2751187682,
0.3628421724,
-0.202355504,
0.7375324368,
0.0574719235,
-0.1802461594,
-0.2586854994,
-0.1194378659,
0.1206365526,
0.7132949829,
0.9372751713,
-0.7251011133,
-0.4125600159,
-0.0079733217,
-0.6549777389,
-0.320433259,
-0.1618683934,
-0.3409845829,
0.3518140912,
0.4575420618,
-0.4924766421,
0.3104746938,
0.2901045978,
-0.1620536447,
0.295112431,
0.0732848942,
-0.135591656,
-1.0319312811,
0.0580133013,
-0.4554561973,
-0.0229818393,
-0.727609098,
0.5485896468,
0.132093206,
0.2421252877,
-0.3182151914,
0.5627359152,
-0.4030579925,
-0.5483518839,
-0.4493385553,
0.1740926951,
-0.2789180577,
0.4137566388,
-0.0917612314,
0.4094935358,
0.9082505107,
-0.9695118666,
0.6178615093,
-0.0947023705,
0.1483661234,
0.3954677582,
-0.6143511534,
-0.2763080299,
-0.1788594723,
0.4736747146,
-0.9543347359,
-0.2890052795,
0.1717310995,
-0.2162776589,
0.4193823338,
0.0004417808,
-0.3526909947,
-0.5723279119,
-0.4380516708,
0.3105326295,
0.7931194305,
-0.6682358384,
0.3660082519,
0.5266467929,
-0.1249726713,
-0.473108381,
-0.7209901214,
-0.210684672,
-0.3060601652,
-0.3529350162,
0.3127608597,
-0.1366136372,
-0.7375375628,
-0.1993289441,
-0.0507077165,
-0.1381703913,
0.4712227583,
0.2892797589,
0.1226697341,
-0.1062357128,
0.2945151925,
0.4961790144,
0.1268416345,
-0.0407388695,
-0.4109682143,
0.3839900196,
-0.2260930091,
-0.1018977985,
-0.5646393895,
0.2098554224,
0.6134007573,
0.0469079278,
0.2736866772,
0.2856611609,
-0.4934227765,
-0.1175973564,
-0.031449873,
-0.0597254038,
-0.4958105981,
-0.2002937347,
-0.5946820974,
-1.0038036108,
0.7731318474,
-0.0821251199,
0.411711067,
0.9452785254,
1.0872676373,
0.178858906,
0.501193881,
0.701854527,
-0.1870799959,
0.4783140719,
0.0053124712,
-0.2292001396,
-0.5678324103,
0.0041648936,
-0.8070649505,
-0.5039597154,
-1.2306822538,
-0.1415174454,
-0.1105702147,
0.7427358031,
-0.3761052489,
0.6495322585,
-0.1306448132,
0.4412529171,
0.5192480683,
-0.462941885,
0.0837445632,
-0.3850990236,
-0.1925391555,
0.147152707,
-0.7988526225,
-0.411606282,
0.6684922576,
0.4195516407,
0.9434969425,
0.7415364385,
0.8533437252,
0.4340948462,
0.3700826168,
-0.963173449,
0.3031568527,
-0.1292495281,
-0.7417848706,
-0.0980581865,
-0.3013221622,
-1.0005795956,
0.2517363727,
0.1582251191,
-0.746520102,
0.5253147483,
0.0794131309,
-0.3347709775,
0.3645227551,
-0.6562829018,
0.6465091109,
-0.1758601964,
-0.6112591624,
-0.042553667,
-0.9916971326,
0.7346997857,
-0.0719199106,
0.2174884975,
-0.0793193281,
-0.2361012548,
0.5619711876,
-0.4658565223,
0.8456085324,
0.0720049366,
-0.5758820772,
0.5340256095,
0.5228557587,
0.2088326663,
-0.2041321844,
0.1742533743,
-0.2460017502,
0.1255731434,
-0.765605092,
-0.5519092083,
0.8770328164,
-0.9741929173,
-0.4578947723,
-0.4310832024,
-0.2133899927,
-0.0183176138,
0.461014539,
0.0710605159,
0.3532737494,
0.0658713579,
0.1076173112,
0.3002084196,
0.0831306502,
0.6689552665,
0.6117466092,
-0.3110688031,
-0.3301284611,
0.6491963267,
0.1403590441,
0.7100253105,
0.5287702084,
0.0453630239,
-0.3163129389,
-0.2233687043,
-0.5875688195,
-0.0615162551,
-0.5527495146,
-0.1091274992,
-0.4214042723,
-0.3030168414,
-0.5335775614,
-0.4944267273,
0.0148330452,
-0.6832509637,
-0.2188058347,
0.0027536196,
0.0352837741,
1.023321867,
-0.3747363389,
0.3638021946,
-0.6689663529,
0.2989068329,
0.5344261527,
0.6436470151,
0.012998133,
-0.6875364184,
0.2717467844,
-0.5632733107,
-0.5860719085,
-1.0269753933,
-0.0894539058,
0.2414368689,
0.718541503,
0.7641408443,
0.0748814121,
0.2543102503,
-0.4715560079,
0.7490103841,
0.1927907765,
-1.2072700262,
0.3507238626,
-0.4670414925,
0.0517732017,
0.5108076334,
0.5449454188,
-0.4068187475,
-0.6683414578,
-1.0033922195,
-0.7073529363,
0.5101537108,
0.1483326703,
0.2872907221,
-0.1758218706,
0.483915478,
0.3329056501,
0.2778120041,
-0.6295351982,
-0.0886677653,
-0.2136131376,
-0.0801706091,
0.1397000551,
-0.0603393614,
-0.3354924023,
-0.0230683368,
0.4275076091,
-0.0301621556,
-0.003363671,
0.0806991756,
0.0285670199,
-0.5198854804,
0.4832797945,
0.9645007849,
0.7589020729,
0.0492767952,
0.735678494,
-0.1510442942,
-0.2223738432,
0.3166003823,
-0.0100081507,
-0.5859077573,
-0.1886699647,
0.5112326145,
0.6695830226,
0.2480785251,
-0.3588458598,
0.1969923824,
0.3693909049,
-0.2091335803,
-0.0609274246,
0.3771348596,
-0.4150537848,
0.2744393647,
0.1703073978,
-0.1625445634,
0.1686827838,
-0.9385914803,
0.5931472778,
0.5077642202,
-0.3786719143,
-0.3812291324,
0.7921808958,
0.3732447624,
-0.3654044271,
-0.0664375946,
-0.2483532578,
-0.6299104095,
0.7975910306,
0.7176384926,
1.002045393,
-0.2469571978,
0.0364205614,
0.4681789577,
0.6362783909,
0.0610973388,
0.3958672583,
-0.3185197115,
-0.8027473092,
-0.0839855522,
-0.4884856343,
-0.534271419,
0.0100542977,
-0.7992344499,
0.1023453772,
-0.973533392,
-0.0351246297,
0.059633784,
0.0314478055,
-0.0783202946,
0.0090567013,
-0.1025666818,
1.0696309805,
-0.8377064466,
0.7069705129,
0.4680325389,
-0.2733175159,
-0.7845802307,
0.3883627653,
0.1606760621,
-0.4872483611,
0.6929531693,
-0.0732255802,
-0.1818829477,
0.0929557607,
-0.4763252735,
-0.7787522078,
1.24837327,
-0.1878361553,
-0.3963528872,
0.2509294748,
-0.3597643673,
0.5841590166,
-0.2227976024,
-0.0225035883,
0.8583704829,
0.4594273567,
0.2437112182,
-1.3373574018,
0.1357425153,
-0.243603304,
0.1364545226,
0.4662737548,
-1.1796051264,
0.9766921997,
-0.3269594908,
-0.4031148851,
0.3061895967,
0.7805039287,
0.1722462922,
-0.0416539758,
0.4445563257,
0.4961627424,
0.5879316926,
-0.3386645913,
1.0170806646,
-0.3378838897,
0.3677166998,
0.9756510854,
-0.5523300171,
0.5751762986,
0.1933823675,
-0.6762230396,
0.4945275486,
0.6602053046,
0.03377847,
0.188932091,
0.5346685052,
-0.2351004034,
0.1198251992,
0.1869816482,
-0.3382182121,
0.5519267321,
0.1853598058,
-0.4810503125,
-0.5582336187,
-0.3319220841,
0.2567208111,
0.0302640479,
-0.5356714725,
1.0068746805,
-0.0768918321,
-0.8222652078,
1.0270833969,
0.3182353079,
0.4244386256,
-0.5295990705,
0.3377617002,
-0.3795889616,
0.2056453675,
-0.1570072174,
-0.8856832981,
0.379734695,
-0.1789363027,
0.0106502082,
-0.0866784081,
0.7745398283,
-0.6411494017,
0.1204682291,
0.3990975022,
0.4838752449,
0.3541018665,
0.8286727667,
-0.5765159726,
-0.142216906,
-0.2691841125,
0.0622616261,
0.1605112553,
0.1341436654,
-0.382650882,
0.5317685008,
0.1519122124,
-0.0342435502,
0.6115692258,
-0.092791602,
0.9081799388,
-0.7365894914,
-0.5376643538,
-0.6452667117,
-0.0660038441,
0.35401088,
-0.212422654,
0.5742305517,
0.3685658574,
0.8942890763,
0.0203212202,
0.9512066245,
-0.5879744291,
0.3077854812,
-0.457664907,
0.5147188902,
-0.6014580727,
-0.3825774789,
-0.2785720825,
-0.7221378684,
-0.3188283443,
0.30078125,
-0.0319563225,
0.2245128006,
0.4647137821,
0.451256156,
0.1218092963,
-0.2944937944,
0.2639918625,
0.3147372007,
0.3219557405,
0.5379998684,
0.6521648169,
-0.2141710818,
0.1155738831,
-0.0666076168,
-0.8170229793,
-0.1895120293,
-0.6928128004,
-0.6769331098,
-0.5416827798,
-0.1479343772,
-0.6353811026,
-0.2472822368,
0.7567678094,
0.4428951442,
-1.0910186768,
-0.4539714456,
-0.4736942351,
0.6719889641,
-0.3853698969,
-0.2914846539,
0.3039879203,
-0.5446017385,
-0.7758533955,
0.2385977358,
0.6056556702,
0.5716147423,
-0.4822629988,
-0.2537952065,
-0.0951006636,
0.2435566187,
0.6422231197,
0.9814457297,
-0.8809388876,
-0.1076821685,
-0.3033192754,
-0.4136266112,
-0.1803401411,
1.078999877,
-0.4375375211,
0.3428968191,
0.7868546247,
0.7434030771,
-0.2040379196,
0.0409245454,
0.4355831742,
-0.4731770456,
0.2102635652,
0.0246637743,
0.0836577788,
-0.0981470421,
0.0683073774,
0.3815115392,
0.5476617813,
-0.4246279001,
-0.5292328596,
0.9605665803,
-1.2297074795,
-0.0234130695,
1.2131427526,
-0.2111872286,
-0.1860152781,
-0.0669064075,
-0.0022921169,
0.211554125,
0.0204789098,
0.8904935122,
0.6823290586,
-0.1983323097,
-0.255836755,
-0.2190369666,
0.9522560835,
0.2993693352,
-1.0836558342,
0.1586148888,
0.2856719494,
0.2003494203,
0.3571668863,
0.8527264595,
-0.4136519432,
0.370193094,
-0.2822245955,
-0.0350546092,
0.5921135545,
-0.4696580172,
-0.5300425291,
0.0245393366,
0.2000939399,
0.0398831218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03608v1 | A Survey of Quantum-Cognitively Inspired Sentiment Analysis Models | 2023-06-06T11:54:48 | 2023-06-06T11:54:48 | Yaochen Liu, Qiuchi Li, Benyou Wang, Yazhou Zhang, Dawei Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Quantum theory, originally proposed as a physical theory to describe the
motions of microscopic particles, has been applied to various non-physics
domains involving human cognition and decision-making that are inherently
uncertain and exhibit certain non-classical, quantum-like characteristics.
Sentiment analysis is a typical example of such domains. In the last few years,
by leveraging the modeling power of quantum probability (a non-classical
probability stemming from quantum mechanics methodology) and deep neural
networks, a range of novel quantum-cognitively inspired models for sentiment
analysis have emerged and performed well. This survey presents a timely
overview of the latest developments in this fascinating cross-disciplinary
area. We first provide a background of quantum probability and quantum
cognition at a theoretical level, analyzing their advantages over classical
theories in modeling the cognitive aspects of sentiment analysis. Then, recent
quantum-cognitively inspired models are introduced and discussed in detail,
focusing on how they approach the key challenges of the sentiment analysis
task. Finally, we discuss the limitations of the current research and highlight
future research directions. | [
-0.3055481315,
-0.9282792807,
0.8620613813,
0.0424062386,
-0.3239886165,
0.4498235285,
-0.1612384021,
-0.4010413885,
0.3893792629,
0.0951589197,
-0.7423049212,
-0.2903072834,
-0.4004102051,
-0.1806274354,
-0.2640812695,
0.7579516172,
0.4532025754,
0.4067279696,
-0.1590036899,
0.0365783237,
-0.0958696008,
-0.5675119758,
-0.5294039845,
-0.065496996,
0.4351103604,
-0.1745260209,
0.8590818644,
-0.6313042641,
0.5304787159,
0.1269398928,
-0.2207976878,
-0.1869917959,
-0.1588807851,
-0.0916930735,
-0.25953269,
-0.4947849214,
-0.3878395259,
0.1961244047,
0.6257939935,
0.8434563279,
-0.3927749693,
-0.0611770414,
0.0161595475,
0.8937465549,
-0.7287151814,
0.0107256165,
-0.561406076,
0.5122837424,
-0.0434204973,
-0.0243120044,
-0.2182954252,
-0.4947001636,
0.3435440361,
-0.489888519,
0.0984875783,
-0.0265769456,
0.2410089672,
-0.2542838752,
-0.7955285907,
-0.2384960502,
-0.7636359334,
1.2231092453,
-0.6426380873,
0.7100760937,
-0.0024117536,
0.1837452948,
-0.0029668165,
-0.4314210713,
-0.5515457392,
-0.4318408966,
0.2683738768,
0.6131558418,
-0.5436343551,
-0.2379083186,
-0.1205977499,
0.4170897305,
-0.4962168634,
-0.3653340936,
-0.1946467012,
0.1052329093,
0.6192293763,
0.234287709,
0.1286429018,
-0.5362787843,
-0.3565065563,
-0.0451376401,
-0.1545193791,
0.3034400642,
0.0273800623,
-0.0346321389,
-0.0606975034,
0.4387515783,
-0.6690800786,
0.5359978676,
0.0074190134,
0.2851810157,
-0.2309906781,
-0.1017276868,
-0.1182327718,
0.0633266494,
1.1549789906,
0.3442943096,
0.1285850257,
-0.0872267187,
-0.0894707814,
0.3583959937,
0.4703578055,
-0.3298277259,
-0.5063444376,
0.1469558477,
-0.6392868161,
-0.7378194332,
0.0166712385,
-0.9307686687,
-0.7542444468,
-0.1628643125,
0.1333874762,
-0.4929784238,
-0.7742916942,
0.3425318301,
-0.3412974477,
0.1773709804,
0.3162764907,
-0.5513664484,
0.2334289253,
0.8174954057,
0.5263447762,
0.0619558357,
0.1665418148,
0.3702467084,
-0.2198419571,
-0.7168431282,
0.7803208828,
-0.6987065673,
-0.6505922079,
-0.0815972313,
-0.4789195955,
0.1749174148,
-0.0807380006,
0.4497199953,
-0.8862656951,
0.1797184348,
-0.3861974478,
-0.556979239,
-0.5758730173,
0.5729750991,
-0.5200206041,
0.579602778,
0.1053402722,
-0.6397511363,
0.1726614237,
-0.5628757477,
-0.2895788848,
-0.1072371006,
-0.274173975,
-0.2512865663,
0.9764795899,
0.0320402905,
0.2858248353,
-0.8944446445,
0.4311653078,
-0.750818193,
0.1151760891,
1.1465438604,
-0.4001743495,
0.9910057187,
0.3783885241,
-0.0374750458,
0.0375408232,
-0.6626846194,
0.2371196002,
0.0892887563,
0.3449803293,
-0.3720991611,
0.1454401016,
-0.1939157695,
0.4772274196,
0.502281487,
-0.6198328733,
-0.1370968521,
-0.1189760566,
0.98845613,
0.585768342,
0.5623170137,
0.6278370023,
-0.17144759,
0.6253772378,
0.1129349992,
0.6718390584,
0.6101050973,
-0.5389502645,
-0.4177126884,
-0.0448348634,
0.1799715459,
0.432002008,
-0.5465137959,
0.3125022352,
-0.3214663267,
-0.8082211018,
-0.151415199,
-0.199579969,
0.068206057,
0.3192375302,
0.062961787,
-0.4520677626,
-0.2743590772,
-0.8859504461,
-0.7939744592,
-0.4494417906,
0.4374386072,
0.0938229635,
0.18225272,
0.0538780876,
0.9800303578,
-0.4513787329,
0.2033358365,
0.2857185006,
0.0656487644,
0.1868099719,
0.3978858292,
0.1452554315,
-0.8464667797,
-0.0378509201,
-0.1431187391,
-1.1487252712,
0.7622267008,
-0.047725521,
-0.3384845555,
-0.067098245,
0.2909468412,
-0.9921343327,
0.1898696721,
0.2851810455,
-0.0422701202,
0.3904954493,
0.4282916486,
0.2585125268,
-0.7777782679,
-0.312413007,
0.4471640289,
0.0869562849,
-0.4792067409,
0.3009488285,
0.0746696591,
-0.2389074117,
-0.440890789,
0.1187715083,
-0.1344525963,
0.0759809762,
-0.3023373783,
0.051714249,
-0.0491804928,
0.3455296755,
0.3472177088,
-0.0285912324,
0.8046002388,
-0.4910700619,
0.3704899549,
-0.0233760551,
-0.3354120851,
0.7100835443,
-0.4203720093,
0.066523172,
-0.0061734151,
0.186037764,
-0.9975693226,
0.2252409458,
0.4190143049,
-0.6400912404,
-0.1002742648,
-0.0131747331,
-0.4715822339,
-0.4515757859,
-0.5436258316,
0.3526527286,
0.8333230615,
-0.1844027489,
0.8753042817,
0.1924549937,
0.0123049766,
-0.0187830254,
-0.7363902926,
0.006163944,
-0.311727792,
-0.4138949215,
-0.0242355224,
0.032920029,
-0.5572418571,
0.0201354008,
-0.0994889736,
0.0840035602,
0.2683502734,
0.1555315107,
0.3290255368,
-0.1224842891,
0.1466074437,
0.1629369408,
0.1917566806,
0.6460818648,
-0.5818150043,
0.1252757907,
-0.4141439497,
-0.0334360301,
-0.6656073928,
0.1943671703,
0.4797526896,
-0.3096986413,
0.3806317151,
0.317592442,
-0.2946739793,
0.0043921662,
-0.3506409228,
-0.4361297786,
-0.4240101874,
0.2058847994,
-0.3402375579,
-0.9156669974,
0.0853396207,
-0.1969814748,
-0.2426086962,
0.4297804832,
0.5567730665,
-0.6080039144,
1.0636233091,
0.4299130142,
0.0742458031,
0.7732400298,
-0.0532392524,
0.5004525781,
-0.918320775,
0.1307638139,
-0.0705205649,
-0.1362783909,
-0.8958063126,
-0.2828474641,
0.5789754987,
0.4095581472,
-0.0681666508,
-0.3629234135,
-0.5590144992,
-0.1605937779,
0.532169342,
0.3193711936,
0.070125252,
0.1886389703,
0.0467997007,
0.218025282,
-0.6932668686,
-0.3892150223,
1.2218708992,
0.1982640475,
0.4051658511,
0.280954808,
0.7143757939,
0.4531915486,
-0.0326409005,
-0.7682167888,
0.7836773396,
0.0793581828,
-0.8727323413,
-0.1625810415,
-0.424965322,
-0.7938920856,
0.2410858721,
-0.5378699303,
-0.4583306015,
0.405212611,
0.0091292188,
-0.5420501232,
0.2439359426,
-0.216966033,
0.5584585667,
-0.130666405,
-0.3002467453,
-0.8448883295,
-0.5385201573,
0.777580142,
-0.2342098206,
0.4730329812,
-0.2055472136,
0.2087792158,
0.8087320328,
-0.1272302717,
0.8863054514,
-0.3584485054,
-0.2979385257,
0.9552963376,
0.4358730614,
0.3253179491,
0.4025259018,
-0.213196516,
0.363137126,
0.1903006881,
-0.5025467277,
-0.7274080515,
0.674043715,
-0.7464868426,
-0.4678736925,
-0.5023228526,
-0.228459537,
-0.6294716001,
-0.0528275818,
0.1676616967,
0.1193304732,
-0.2986878753,
-0.1557307094,
0.5761278272,
0.060942322,
0.5167068243,
0.4396312833,
-0.2394707501,
-0.7080192566,
1.05443573,
0.1106894761,
-0.126758337,
0.5251446366,
0.3861059546,
-0.2597571909,
-0.2748762965,
-0.1229313165,
0.0100500993,
-0.6521790624,
0.1149646789,
-0.4376516044,
0.1831920445,
-0.4818961024,
-0.0194410644,
-0.4236070514,
-0.9405116439,
-0.059689641,
-0.0220772866,
0.5632246733,
0.6727620959,
0.0359045044,
0.2105977684,
-0.7321941853,
0.2183086127,
0.6705207229,
0.1393700689,
0.4472518563,
-0.0555433407,
-0.2390052378,
0.1173204035,
-0.6122234464,
-0.8892909884,
0.0564318001,
-0.2828926444,
0.1086061001,
0.1893198341,
0.2796436846,
0.2674891055,
-0.1935370862,
1.1848735809,
0.5838940144,
-0.9947592616,
0.5334549546,
-0.5663458705,
0.0394466408,
0.1928122491,
0.3391839862,
-0.3930428624,
-0.3477826416,
-0.861725986,
-0.3496355414,
0.0492874049,
0.0934885442,
0.1801882237,
-0.2695081532,
0.4716856778,
-0.060026221,
0.3683987558,
-0.5126360655,
0.1301896721,
-0.3982647359,
-0.4610778987,
-0.1568977684,
-0.1093897074,
0.0077742366,
-0.2607986629,
0.7272925377,
0.0136969341,
0.4652711451,
0.2486624122,
-0.1507072449,
-0.2636446059,
0.3270902634,
0.2970837355,
0.5666845441,
-0.0054716999,
0.105937764,
0.1239728034,
0.033905562,
0.1532322317,
-0.1705440134,
-0.0640847832,
-0.4218919873,
0.1630705595,
0.5005978346,
0.2617222071,
-0.3686088622,
0.2933733463,
-0.1205794811,
-0.0852631703,
-0.7361832261,
-0.0282676965,
0.0740916207,
0.69559443,
0.3059208095,
0.2038006485,
0.6318767071,
-0.7045180202,
-0.2320622206,
0.8780943751,
-0.8677629232,
-0.6685258746,
0.3893678486,
-0.2899464369,
0.0255346727,
0.6724634171,
-0.2955989838,
-0.4041765332,
0.3244098425,
0.0314117037,
0.9546198249,
0.2941989899,
0.2494430244,
0.0178675503,
0.088547647,
0.0644166246,
0.7002913356,
-0.2375375032,
-0.7134916186,
-0.0474401489,
-0.69632864,
-0.3998012543,
-0.624253273,
-0.9605233073,
-0.0944483653,
-0.8079649806,
-0.9369743466,
0.1846441627,
0.0836945772,
-0.5243252516,
0.5857495666,
0.5036318898,
0.4659003615,
-0.6072375774,
0.6838193536,
1.0204463005,
-0.2987037301,
-0.3293153346,
-0.2232610732,
0.0003124688,
-0.533904314,
0.4600693285,
-0.3224965334,
-0.3505772054,
0.1450506896,
-0.7110624909,
-0.7837746739,
0.8314681649,
-0.1901412457,
-0.53223598,
-0.0101660639,
-0.0329846106,
0.456616044,
-0.0389701389,
0.0750084817,
0.4774377644,
0.1304400563,
-0.4685297608,
-0.2901218832,
0.0606634505,
-0.3070301712,
0.4577551782,
0.2602918148,
-1.1895092726,
1.1022130251,
0.2697266638,
0.2348650992,
0.005464517,
1.1410268545,
0.4714458585,
0.4467118382,
0.5101764202,
0.7049601674,
0.7011792064,
0.2638669014,
1.0381839275,
-0.686280787,
0.5703058243,
0.4844719172,
-0.378878057,
0.8361343741,
0.468323946,
-0.5364640355,
1.0035487413,
0.5980678201,
0.0442766026,
0.5457991958,
0.1506550461,
-0.3429913819,
-0.6701774001,
0.0092227086,
-0.1060122848,
0.3585581183,
0.4957934618,
-0.2243952155,
0.048299659,
0.1537357867,
-0.4344316721,
-0.0900564119,
-0.6154444218,
0.7638808489,
0.5117490292,
-0.3756512403,
0.0712555423,
0.1124849096,
0.6282690167,
-0.3433649838,
0.3220911622,
0.1908644587,
-0.0188101027,
0.048210118,
-0.6393188834,
-0.0874876082,
-0.3107607067,
-0.4044060409,
0.0561150163,
0.7067509294,
0.3088451326,
-0.7312259078,
0.0671097487,
0.6541640759,
0.0130183799,
-0.3743580282,
-0.9713246822,
-0.0109990612,
-0.0550726838,
-0.4587436914,
0.2481945753,
0.6995696425,
-0.3847429156,
0.3780508637,
0.6153311133,
-0.2581472993,
0.4398261011,
-0.3042455614,
0.4229512215,
-1.4084962606,
-0.6973337531,
-0.8868636489,
0.2129991055,
-0.0070090597,
-0.1785680056,
0.8600642085,
0.2198743969,
0.4065536559,
-0.2834037244,
0.9691750407,
0.250492245,
0.262165308,
-0.4032611251,
0.6915869713,
-0.6302878857,
-0.1891710162,
-0.4745323062,
-0.7827730775,
-0.0855994821,
0.526643157,
-0.5856736898,
0.1492034048,
0.6307833195,
0.3567790091,
0.2992158532,
1.0084095001,
0.0907611027,
-0.0836940855,
0.1646652818,
0.7811732292,
1.5794883966,
-0.3446514606,
-0.0803048611,
-0.7516798377,
-0.0408956632,
-0.3597700596,
-0.6943324804,
-0.641817987,
-0.3485836089,
-0.8559604287,
-0.1113861203,
-0.190449506,
0.7664625049,
0.7399131656,
-0.5658729076,
-0.1693149656,
-0.5528585911,
-0.0101471888,
-0.3782024682,
-0.2485864162,
0.1753523201,
-0.3838336468,
-0.2883249521,
0.3785504997,
0.0616724901,
-0.0131169083,
-0.2753579915,
0.2911868691,
0.0619307272,
0.5707761645,
0.9381083846,
0.0965625793,
-0.7494012117,
0.0748076737,
-0.0507047921,
-0.1156598106,
-0.1487719864,
0.7173201442,
-0.9002686739,
0.3218547106,
0.2442627102,
0.2420738935,
0.2339836061,
-0.3581140935,
0.2102655768,
-0.3449494243,
-0.138960883,
0.4970804453,
0.2482495904,
0.1617698818,
-0.4025507569,
0.3404899836,
0.3408672512,
-0.1715725362,
-0.6877153516,
0.4222667217,
-1.1310626268,
-0.6480920315,
0.5174950957,
0.4465378821,
-0.4943662286,
0.5814595819,
0.234230876,
0.2991527021,
-0.379093498,
0.7672532797,
0.704559207,
-0.4985836446,
-0.3345687985,
-0.3677671254,
0.1076925173,
1.001288414,
-0.2840365469,
-0.1330956817,
0.4334419966,
0.1436662823,
0.3538399339,
0.3941833675,
-0.2961236238,
0.3905834854,
-0.044258479,
0.1415633857,
0.4888786077,
-0.0984427407,
-0.7093605995,
0.5577782989,
0.4602838457,
0.062197499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03598v1 | CUE: An Uncertainty Interpretation Framework for Text Classifiers Built on Pre-Trained Language Models | 2023-06-06T11:37:46 | 2023-06-06T11:37:46 | Jiazheng Li, Zhaoyue Sun, Bin Liang, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text classifiers built on Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) have achieved
remarkable progress in various tasks including sentiment analysis, natural
language inference, and question-answering. However, the occurrence of
uncertain predictions by these classifiers poses a challenge to their
reliability when deployed in practical applications. Much effort has been
devoted to designing various probes in order to understand what PLMs capture.
But few studies have delved into factors influencing PLM-based classifiers'
predictive uncertainty. In this paper, we propose a novel framework, called
CUE, which aims to interpret uncertainties inherent in the predictions of
PLM-based models. In particular, we first map PLM-encoded representations to a
latent space via a variational auto-encoder. We then generate text
representations by perturbing the latent space which causes fluctuation in
predictive uncertainty. By comparing the difference in predictive uncertainty
between the perturbed and the original text representations, we are able to
identify the latent dimensions responsible for uncertainty and subsequently
trace back to the input features that contribute to such uncertainty. Our
extensive experiments on four benchmark datasets encompassing linguistic
acceptability classification, emotion classification, and natural language
inference show the feasibility of our proposed framework. Our source code is
available at: https://github.com/lijiazheng99/CUE. | [
-0.1805605292,
-0.5295276046,
0.6570958495,
0.0774337128,
-0.3166818917,
-0.0163030699,
-0.033655867,
-0.268399328,
-0.2435892075,
0.3859509826,
-0.4605389237,
-0.4829158187,
-0.8095874786,
-0.1006721631,
-0.2380111068,
0.8932310939,
-0.223792389,
-0.1389467567,
-0.1081607938,
0.0994250476,
-0.3140517771,
-0.3903214037,
-0.2343363464,
-0.2086051404,
0.3338190019,
0.2320482135,
0.9623657465,
0.450362891,
0.5135823488,
0.1806124449,
0.1544598341,
-0.2892785072,
-0.125187546,
0.1374099106,
-0.021532774,
-0.8193457723,
-0.2229550332,
0.177106306,
0.641292572,
0.5871493816,
0.0078115719,
-0.1131107584,
0.1443986893,
0.1343128681,
-0.6355585456,
0.2159049362,
-0.8111739159,
0.0656549633,
-0.2361226231,
-0.2735513747,
-0.471367538,
-0.1820065826,
0.3584072888,
-0.7002828121,
0.1660731137,
0.1150003672,
0.7718029022,
0.680218339,
-0.322142601,
-0.2895512581,
-0.6307144165,
0.8458003402,
-0.6812945604,
0.2202761918,
0.5818595886,
0.3915842474,
-0.2388697118,
-0.6455204487,
-0.6900315285,
0.1359521449,
-0.0257446729,
0.2355760187,
0.3182901442,
0.1512256563,
-0.2192792594,
0.4825382829,
-0.5335671902,
0.151110813,
0.0362626463,
-0.2973973453,
0.400409162,
0.0210411586,
0.2845913768,
-0.0280670393,
-0.5458785295,
-0.1463715583,
-0.4034472406,
0.1576824635,
0.4195744097,
0.3670629859,
-0.2781648338,
0.2970170677,
0.3066525459,
0.8139552474,
0.0038928527,
0.0221297555,
0.2596612871,
0.0035605535,
-0.3454571962,
0.0642351359,
0.9133988023,
0.1218291521,
0.0836239308,
0.2286070734,
-0.1650559902,
-0.0083682463,
0.1243328005,
-0.4320666492,
-0.2787276804,
0.4297195375,
-0.4169718325,
-0.5733615756,
0.3932168484,
-0.860857904,
-0.6759009361,
0.0411412604,
0.3130242229,
-0.5260979533,
-0.3762330711,
0.394489646,
0.2022717148,
0.3356617093,
0.4221107066,
-0.7301464081,
0.0541356914,
0.4379093647,
0.6758739352,
-0.3158269227,
-0.4828546047,
-0.3520297706,
-0.0913318768,
-0.2203836739,
0.6859257817,
-0.8172433972,
-0.4163677096,
0.1700006723,
-0.2787579894,
-0.295360744,
-0.2046823204,
0.6453368068,
-0.5716244578,
0.4207460582,
0.174062714,
-0.8966322541,
0.0288384557,
0.262478441,
-0.8857471347,
0.9974403381,
0.1757655591,
-1.0855476856,
0.4420165122,
-0.3292238116,
-0.2738113403,
0.0670295283,
-0.3125520945,
-0.4266166687,
0.2162614763,
0.056888286,
0.4015906155,
-0.2714221776,
0.4704118669,
-0.4034095109,
-0.391667515,
0.7729594111,
-0.8355675936,
0.6303541064,
0.3919077814,
-0.2182973027,
0.0879353285,
-0.9189568162,
-0.1189098433,
-0.1738726497,
-0.4099541903,
-0.1157709137,
0.1926641166,
0.0669801906,
0.4592267573,
0.3803266585,
-0.3284702003,
-0.2396475077,
-0.4089212716,
0.1204808801,
0.6900669932,
-0.0826659873,
0.6177034974,
-0.1355556399,
0.8180808425,
0.2723506093,
-0.0273196734,
-0.4505767822,
-0.4016126096,
-0.5701175928,
-0.0536675751,
0.3122005165,
0.6166309118,
-0.6505663991,
0.6764974594,
-0.0024195483,
-0.2179581821,
-0.6662051082,
-0.0639353395,
0.1679707021,
0.2863800526,
0.2712741196,
0.0346514657,
-0.5258725286,
-0.2586269975,
-0.283228308,
-0.3460282683,
-0.1968445927,
0.2503645122,
0.2684539258,
-0.2117444128,
1.180572629,
-0.236690402,
-0.1527378261,
-0.1695348471,
0.5583658814,
0.0781017616,
0.5632412434,
0.4164674282,
-0.9771356583,
-0.4393097758,
-0.3342532218,
-0.489813596,
-0.1611019373,
-0.5248214006,
-0.0467784405,
0.1203015149,
0.4540006518,
-0.36985147,
0.4973785579,
0.6331273317,
-0.4719654918,
0.7646653652,
-0.1196256727,
-0.1716267616,
-0.9441453218,
-0.0779755041,
-0.0590893067,
-0.0931090117,
-0.4224925041,
-0.3769299984,
0.0182497725,
0.0616291836,
-0.4117900133,
0.4807297289,
-0.3229839802,
-0.0589362755,
-0.2472532094,
0.0325274169,
0.1643493921,
0.1123364642,
0.3521903753,
0.5880206227,
0.6313895583,
-0.5514342189,
0.07213559,
-0.0158741698,
-0.4471663535,
0.5075107217,
-0.3633788228,
-0.0789170712,
-0.0428584032,
0.1183656901,
-1.0357698202,
-0.2748629749,
0.2513263226,
-0.6408128738,
0.5930187702,
0.160727039,
-0.2602955997,
-0.264752686,
-0.0152131962,
0.3216610253,
0.2199022472,
-0.3926148117,
0.6241741776,
0.1987615824,
-0.0804705098,
-0.7583327293,
-0.777492404,
-0.257787317,
-0.1678135842,
-0.2196549475,
0.1786420643,
-0.2006780654,
-0.2350087762,
-0.0096183512,
-0.3345578015,
-0.3154369295,
0.5117971301,
0.2893701792,
0.2883197665,
-0.2687242925,
0.229076758,
0.1733903438,
-0.1880320758,
0.216516152,
-0.6210859418,
0.3864624202,
-0.2783340812,
-0.3743824959,
-0.430033654,
-0.0694086328,
0.5423842669,
-0.1130165309,
0.7048151493,
0.6258360147,
-0.3091351688,
-0.2198742628,
-0.2240201682,
0.046896819,
-0.456291467,
0.227202028,
-0.5233368874,
-0.6822093129,
0.5220167637,
0.0343726687,
-0.2769127488,
0.4735695124,
0.3708549142,
-0.3892232478,
0.6822960973,
0.6129145026,
-0.0847073048,
0.593606174,
0.1173714697,
-0.0191341545,
-0.3676298559,
-0.0297808759,
-0.5023541451,
0.0830316693,
-0.4367946982,
-0.7178749442,
-0.2482483536,
-0.0661913827,
-0.1329984367,
-0.0258011948,
-0.1651316136,
0.2435471565,
0.4898976684,
-0.2411549687,
0.0131586837,
-0.2977263927,
-0.3308847845,
-0.1444756091,
-0.4739317298,
-0.7176850438,
0.9351621866,
0.5100459456,
0.8435464501,
-0.1318508238,
0.604467988,
0.229815647,
0.1550386846,
-0.5659302473,
0.0966054723,
-0.033087559,
-0.7362933755,
-0.3721994162,
-0.3387312591,
-0.7358716726,
0.2717772126,
-0.3638991416,
-0.6655271649,
0.3448656499,
0.2087016404,
-0.5354229808,
0.3232448101,
-0.5214402676,
1.0766648054,
-0.4691553116,
-0.256657213,
0.4118002355,
-1.047940731,
0.0995544121,
-0.324570179,
0.3718601763,
-0.1609791666,
0.0104443794,
0.4185318947,
-0.2777249813,
1.0705897808,
-0.3525051475,
-0.2300976515,
0.5113947392,
0.2732999325,
0.3830747604,
0.0623607039,
-0.3794426024,
-0.0049480768,
0.1155525967,
-0.2804318964,
-0.5985075831,
0.1862087846,
-0.8037823439,
-0.1707175225,
-0.5916911364,
-0.6551540494,
-0.3184843361,
0.2629192173,
0.7899367213,
0.128312692,
-0.2152252942,
0.0396796726,
0.7205414772,
-0.5295898914,
0.2990710437,
0.3567739725,
-0.1252540052,
-0.0927803069,
0.90035218,
-0.0620137304,
0.1354284585,
0.7364346981,
0.1846725196,
-0.3339239359,
-0.844288528,
-0.0937364474,
-0.1731852293,
-0.5028755665,
-0.0536307953,
-0.223487258,
-0.1197198555,
-0.3596913218,
-0.2481965274,
-0.3631009758,
-0.1177077368,
-0.8851873279,
-0.2822571099,
-0.0330618955,
0.5246950984,
0.0630906224,
0.7591969967,
-0.7119401097,
-0.0593292303,
-0.0333503261,
0.6727808714,
-0.5336370468,
-0.720600605,
-0.1191950291,
-0.0695155114,
0.2074005157,
-0.9135059714,
0.6182155013,
0.3328908086,
0.6548265815,
0.6686611772,
0.4051654935,
0.1333316565,
-0.1517459601,
0.7447807193,
0.2669202089,
-1.0695582628,
0.77748698,
-0.37937361,
0.1389556378,
0.800336957,
0.3383546472,
-0.1932795644,
-0.5969743729,
-0.733217597,
-0.7408120632,
0.7446519136,
0.0769481584,
-0.0980860442,
0.1319066286,
0.4636309445,
0.5140420198,
0.4186821282,
-0.6560127735,
-0.1836585402,
-0.5349749923,
-0.8178622723,
-0.1588446051,
-0.7385933995,
0.4174682796,
0.3165469766,
0.3993668556,
-0.1669245064,
0.183369562,
0.0128685702,
-0.4902194738,
0.0906091183,
0.2714737058,
0.3565154374,
0.252635926,
-0.4961789846,
0.4961850345,
-0.1509627998,
-0.5741785765,
0.0514912494,
0.2582948208,
-0.1133712605,
0.0219505895,
0.3304065168,
0.8290421963,
0.3177531958,
-0.7290085554,
0.6399100423,
-0.2212428302,
0.1853402704,
-0.408739239,
-0.0868083015,
-0.3209616542,
-0.0096735461,
0.266433239,
-0.0180421751,
0.1612073034,
-0.1521079242,
0.4181303382,
-0.0740616545,
-0.6660096645,
-0.5041922927,
0.6666812897,
0.1736433804,
-0.1080623567,
0.3345759809,
-0.2987805605,
-0.4705697,
0.5556323528,
0.5104792118,
0.6389712691,
-0.4667422175,
0.3133571744,
0.0134134348,
0.3649432063,
0.0448233485,
0.2880534828,
0.0224357545,
-1.1805874109,
-0.2734588385,
-0.8011704087,
-0.5082224607,
0.1070712581,
-0.8906105161,
0.0514876619,
-0.4246998429,
-0.189994067,
-0.4723861217,
0.0099645117,
-0.6112102866,
0.4878285229,
0.4218750298,
0.8204868436,
-1.0611217022,
1.0355702639,
0.7823746204,
-0.3653560281,
-0.6684987545,
0.3045421243,
0.0508065969,
-0.5312618613,
0.3848181665,
0.3085353374,
-0.0721369013,
-0.1419039965,
-0.5039501786,
-0.8645165563,
0.7420719862,
0.4909548163,
-0.419048667,
0.0766873732,
0.3215331137,
0.4772756994,
-0.4364205301,
0.1339673847,
0.7860219479,
0.4049736857,
0.1382161975,
-0.5756241083,
-0.0796448067,
-0.2115151286,
-0.0220250469,
-0.2491468489,
-0.0594896264,
1.0087628365,
-0.080377318,
-0.1727736443,
0.0233511496,
0.8166080713,
0.1589701772,
0.3796575665,
0.4633183777,
0.1764367968,
1.1784892082,
-0.1469272524,
1.0059711933,
-0.428602159,
0.393333286,
1.659471035,
-0.3717912436,
0.8578618765,
0.4477175176,
-0.2767778337,
0.6547047496,
0.9820384979,
0.101189144,
0.5259531736,
0.1276085526,
-0.2068765312,
-0.2960236073,
0.1967182159,
-0.1243796572,
0.5166173577,
0.9227764606,
-0.5073085427,
-0.0250032265,
0.1380083412,
-0.1692599207,
0.0503498986,
-0.028514564,
0.3960074186,
0.0657328144,
-0.5192313194,
-0.0169071537,
-0.1979677677,
0.8084806204,
-0.3290350735,
0.280518204,
0.0181489382,
0.2062005252,
-0.0786980689,
-0.8807669878,
0.2366027385,
-0.3052266538,
-0.0143061904,
-0.1591479629,
0.9013184905,
-0.4087967873,
-0.3995931149,
0.3444646597,
0.4792674184,
0.3268364668,
-0.2372979522,
-0.7678685784,
0.267917335,
-0.0684065223,
-0.3919709027,
0.116194956,
0.7177942991,
0.3719103634,
0.4249535501,
0.0837040618,
0.0420438349,
0.2491131723,
-0.0598886013,
0.3876865506,
-0.4904009402,
-0.5733448267,
-0.6529241204,
0.6101363897,
0.296852231,
-0.3514527977,
0.4425561428,
0.2399534732,
0.6223503947,
0.0071875681,
1.1558064222,
0.0789053887,
0.3198662996,
-0.5193960071,
0.6820085049,
-0.2774895728,
0.4318907261,
-0.1636928916,
-0.5325731635,
-0.6340966225,
1.0820292234,
-0.5648705959,
-0.0276336279,
0.6429334283,
0.3494619131,
0.2179574966,
0.1354479343,
0.3837834597,
0.3166447878,
0.2580583394,
0.4390803277,
0.8962290287,
-0.2291514128,
0.7258117199,
-0.1197224632,
-0.1113115847,
-0.3718295693,
-0.9601895809,
-0.6339649558,
-0.6690422893,
-0.3944397867,
-0.3103234768,
-0.2017061561,
0.7001072168,
0.4237417281,
-0.9490353465,
0.053323172,
-0.4869144261,
0.2762457132,
-0.055982139,
-0.2809043527,
0.4383781254,
-0.701397419,
-0.7646098137,
0.1826488227,
0.0078925043,
0.461261481,
-0.1421173513,
-0.0461292379,
-0.0950088874,
0.0604756661,
0.2013571858,
0.1656847298,
-0.5785475969,
-0.3633381128,
-0.0884625241,
-0.2689627111,
0.1323186755,
0.6469914317,
-0.7080988288,
0.6508355737,
0.3812977076,
0.6656094193,
0.355584085,
-0.1843579412,
0.84983325,
-0.8593466282,
0.2019437551,
0.379992336,
0.5859757066,
0.3271102607,
-0.3947493434,
0.2066615969,
0.1764619052,
-0.2296030074,
-0.7710529566,
0.2654311657,
-0.8558214903,
-0.3993864357,
1.1411278248,
-0.6361477971,
-0.2267025262,
-0.394423753,
-0.1080902293,
0.4154295325,
-0.1997812241,
0.6023256779,
0.7907719016,
0.2054377794,
-0.1083865017,
-0.3947572708,
0.4467412829,
0.2928936183,
-0.671641469,
0.0767727867,
0.5085172057,
0.1197232753,
0.1467467844,
0.4529073834,
-0.1733506769,
0.1003738716,
0.2217279524,
0.1443526149,
0.150813818,
-0.4478828609,
-0.6953441501,
0.2621036172,
0.3165540993,
-0.3228022456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03586v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03586v1 | Language acquisition: do children and language models follow similar learning stages? | 2023-06-06T11:08:20 | 2023-06-06T11:08:20 | Linnea Evanson, Yair Lakretz, Jean-Rémi King | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | During language acquisition, children follow a typical sequence of learning
stages, whereby they first learn to categorize phonemes before they develop
their lexicon and eventually master increasingly complex syntactic structures.
However, the computational principles that lead to this learning trajectory
remain largely unknown. To investigate this, we here compare the learning
trajectories of deep language models to those of children. Specifically, we
test whether, during its training, GPT-2 exhibits stages of language
acquisition comparable to those observed in children aged between 18 months and
6 years. For this, we train 48 GPT-2 models from scratch and evaluate their
syntactic and semantic abilities at each training step, using 96 probes curated
from the BLiMP, Zorro and BIG-Bench benchmarks. We then compare these
evaluations with the behavior of 54 children during language production. Our
analyses reveal three main findings. First, similarly to children, the language
models tend to learn linguistic skills in a systematic order. Second, this
learning scheme is parallel: the language tasks that are learned last improve
from the very first training steps. Third, some - but not all - learning stages
are shared between children and these language models. Overall, these results
shed new light on the principles of language acquisition, and highlight
important divergences in how humans and modern algorithms learn to process
natural language. | [
-0.0896148682,
-0.638201654,
0.5832386017,
-0.2269770056,
-0.1746997684,
0.3247829378,
-0.1311807036,
-0.7453840971,
-0.6772217751,
0.1226047128,
-0.6897906065,
-0.1063868254,
-0.8459870815,
-0.2888968289,
-0.378330946,
1.0102114677,
0.0203322805,
-0.0532757081,
0.1188433468,
0.2797527909,
-0.2036799043,
-0.3395639956,
-0.9666794538,
-0.5467884541,
0.5200217366,
0.3545026779,
0.6511141658,
0.7662567496,
0.1473460495,
0.2625614405,
-0.0792168081,
-0.2448232472,
-0.3549591303,
0.1836229712,
-0.3598748744,
-0.4043915868,
0.0336432531,
0.0753158107,
0.4317713678,
1.1881706715,
-0.1769730449,
-0.123254098,
0.26721403,
0.7672852874,
-0.2837886214,
0.3050421178,
-0.4477475882,
0.1287241876,
0.0188410208,
0.3195023537,
-0.379463315,
-0.3108816743,
0.5119944811,
-0.4051561356,
0.4420083761,
-0.3624946773,
0.881842196,
-0.1556475759,
-0.4900744259,
-0.6236419678,
-0.7884722948,
0.784774363,
-0.4846849442,
0.6325163245,
0.4978301227,
0.2610669136,
-0.0912860632,
-0.8280627728,
-0.5634385347,
-0.42866382,
-0.1055910736,
-0.2374254912,
-0.0097054169,
-0.0409982018,
0.3957999945,
0.0258464739,
-1.2039365768,
0.3558344245,
-0.6383756995,
-0.0792172626,
0.2926114798,
0.0270306803,
0.3908400834,
-0.0718257427,
-0.4256302714,
-0.3200686872,
-0.7983403206,
0.243381843,
0.178443104,
0.4465461373,
-0.4193831086,
0.2076041698,
-0.2184481621,
0.5156485438,
-0.0131237349,
-0.20399414,
0.2270459086,
-0.3354314268,
-0.058550179,
-0.247167483,
0.6659994125,
-0.1836754382,
0.8237578869,
-0.4277484417,
-0.2857054174,
0.3354923427,
0.2576617002,
-0.6466635466,
-0.2836199999,
-0.1187911183,
-0.2184656411,
-0.1993618757,
-0.053298451,
-0.3629131019,
-0.1860455424,
-0.2838199735,
0.3755369782,
-0.4073855579,
-0.4280057847,
0.2366028428,
0.1020616442,
0.5331064463,
0.1542204916,
-1.1366219521,
0.6562584043,
1.0304042101,
0.4822708666,
-0.1763894409,
-0.6305649281,
-0.1880133599,
-0.2704227865,
-0.5890079141,
0.7011006474,
-0.8313257694,
-0.2060628831,
0.1753905118,
-0.0788981393,
-0.364248693,
-0.625998795,
0.2747383714,
-0.7133019567,
0.4470716715,
-0.15765962,
-0.4405873716,
-0.450371325,
-0.0826646909,
-0.2120111436,
0.6890156865,
0.1370429248,
-0.4712343216,
0.9476928711,
-0.3434412777,
-0.661200285,
-0.0708810911,
-0.1721311361,
-0.0753086805,
0.2996211946,
0.0231609382,
0.5083873272,
-0.1745449901,
0.0991462767,
-0.1094788238,
-0.2697225809,
-0.0719947815,
-0.2641225457,
0.7514227629,
0.1933694929,
-0.5390923023,
-0.3815691769,
-0.591680944,
0.0485760979,
0.2502009273,
-0.2495065778,
-0.0557578132,
0.108580485,
-0.2995535135,
0.670769155,
0.0862362757,
-0.2168125361,
0.4446646273,
-0.461469233,
0.5711991191,
0.2902777791,
0.1086877286,
0.5795150399,
-0.1225749403,
0.5289626122,
0.2175313532,
0.2746744156,
-0.2371293753,
-0.326446265,
-0.8752733469,
0.4695916772,
0.0390732214,
0.3758783937,
-0.6522890329,
0.1453627497,
-0.2249908149,
-0.3882928491,
0.0386577323,
0.1661058217,
0.6671630144,
0.208541736,
0.1380526721,
-0.6563119292,
-0.2246761322,
-0.6689479947,
-0.0464662835,
-0.4965795279,
0.1240720227,
0.0510081574,
0.3764676154,
0.0024580492,
0.3158144951,
-0.1827986687,
0.3811266124,
-0.4032191336,
0.4732888043,
0.1733482182,
0.4848241806,
0.5202634335,
-0.5579898357,
-0.3930537403,
0.0447281115,
-0.6148323417,
0.1486496329,
0.0011771289,
0.1474423707,
0.2840933204,
0.378205061,
-0.7242775559,
0.1645412445,
0.3649223447,
-0.4381469488,
0.213468805,
-0.0462441295,
-0.1203904152,
-0.6618994474,
-0.2085340619,
-0.2622464597,
-0.285497874,
-0.9761443734,
-0.004317211,
-0.0501738824,
0.1891951561,
-0.4215197563,
0.2808734179,
-0.5264065266,
-0.4408542216,
-0.360126555,
0.1496664435,
-0.1087945253,
0.5661393404,
0.1840747595,
0.7182155252,
0.6231520176,
-0.6859054565,
-0.1030602306,
-0.4091857076,
-0.4294252694,
0.0565254092,
-0.7550361156,
0.8550669551,
0.0081904419,
-0.1667319685,
-1.1072112322,
0.0633173212,
0.3410345912,
-0.6067686081,
0.6163578033,
-0.1516212374,
-0.6704010367,
-0.3806141913,
0.1862589419,
0.1963101476,
0.8607119918,
-0.2006904483,
0.0628695488,
0.2939773798,
-0.4866910577,
-0.4963940978,
-0.4985452294,
-0.0844271109,
0.0427081771,
-0.4374871254,
-0.0604046732,
0.2016462982,
-0.1716044545,
-0.0049298215,
-0.2060044408,
-0.4204699695,
0.1043380052,
0.1544897854,
-0.0059016147,
-0.4083613157,
0.1287034154,
0.072578989,
-0.05238932,
-0.0149500985,
-0.5990278721,
0.7540364265,
0.1290805936,
0.017405536,
-0.0492015816,
-0.0489953831,
0.6205277443,
-0.1872366518,
0.579895854,
0.3372977078,
-0.4219275713,
-0.2762043178,
-0.3027602732,
-0.2370563149,
-0.3991719782,
0.5120407343,
-0.5567036867,
-0.6800427437,
0.3825035095,
0.1501846164,
0.0738833249,
0.4641702473,
0.4173420668,
-0.0922742188,
0.7885976434,
0.8638560176,
-0.0751386657,
0.3855269253,
-0.4468078613,
-0.139300555,
-0.4898435771,
-0.2456852347,
-0.5439904332,
-0.1576598138,
-0.4559212923,
-0.4102537334,
-0.1562969089,
0.3549952805,
-0.4911342263,
0.4920888543,
-0.0930218995,
0.5020497441,
0.2636032104,
-0.117465362,
0.3390312195,
0.1258984655,
-0.2350615114,
-0.0863854885,
-0.7692545652,
-0.4019600749,
0.9572805762,
0.2619270682,
0.4993564188,
-0.0591712259,
0.7407230735,
0.0171550475,
0.2153791338,
-0.6055427194,
0.4066509008,
-0.3907335997,
-0.5526847839,
-0.2729572058,
-0.1858002543,
-1.097248435,
0.213057071,
-0.0260543302,
-0.9349110723,
0.5154850483,
-0.2408416867,
-0.1792331785,
-0.0502581857,
-0.7376706004,
0.7616728544,
-0.259619385,
-0.5690717101,
-0.5460188985,
-0.8672308326,
0.2225676924,
-0.1449342519,
0.0737508535,
0.089086622,
-0.1243966669,
0.6269518733,
-0.0931936726,
0.7432275414,
-0.3599926829,
-0.2003640085,
0.4293893874,
0.4092471898,
0.3809176683,
-0.2706112564,
0.2690378428,
-0.127375856,
-0.2430827022,
-0.3406637013,
-0.8060998917,
0.5068272948,
-0.7889255285,
-0.3529073298,
-0.5824235082,
-0.3847171068,
-0.2433745116,
0.3088758886,
0.0711500123,
0.3316372931,
0.0697520301,
-0.0339108892,
0.4890311658,
-0.000797732,
0.6588392258,
0.6346668005,
-0.3412948251,
-0.1099836975,
0.7032646537,
0.1921950728,
0.7266731262,
0.250157088,
0.2232932448,
-0.355263561,
-0.853977859,
-0.3388389051,
0.4559542239,
-0.5848417878,
0.2893825769,
-0.4477820992,
-0.1741073281,
-0.349468559,
0.1380393803,
-0.3366511166,
-0.4891642928,
0.199728325,
-0.2553157806,
-0.1304468513,
1.3126710653,
0.0409382097,
0.199901402,
-0.713518858,
0.2419854254,
0.5037453175,
0.0698548183,
0.1584663689,
-0.6773717403,
-0.3580404818,
0.1971158981,
-0.3189050257,
-0.6244998574,
0.0540284999,
0.3764764667,
0.4521083832,
0.3997080624,
-0.6242539287,
0.5106707811,
-0.5363381505,
0.8789169788,
-0.0207392275,
-0.7475919724,
0.4110407531,
-0.5199045539,
0.3051281869,
0.4922831953,
0.430544585,
-0.6559807062,
-0.0813519657,
-0.8383092284,
-0.432010293,
0.8873601556,
0.111415863,
0.2110980898,
0.191214487,
0.342034936,
0.3004720509,
0.3704793155,
-0.5843132138,
0.0664993003,
0.005846607,
0.113436155,
-0.2929831147,
-0.2094740272,
0.1808499396,
-0.1942058802,
0.1501826793,
0.0105986446,
0.0894310474,
-0.1751763225,
-0.3809889555,
-0.0522727035,
0.165828079,
0.5746921301,
0.818859458,
0.1075292155,
0.070378609,
-0.1310134083,
-0.5253098607,
0.2593193948,
-0.0647566989,
-0.0170018002,
-0.2386191636,
0.772803545,
0.9144160151,
0.4399357736,
-0.3666400313,
0.4393684566,
0.1190042496,
-0.2298604101,
0.06042891,
0.3809068501,
0.1680030376,
0.3899783492,
0.2515231371,
-0.2862710357,
0.2135081887,
-0.9830394387,
0.4423644841,
0.0168000124,
-0.2152794451,
-0.7156800032,
0.3682785928,
-0.1787092388,
-0.3695098162,
0.8084618449,
-0.4053495228,
-0.5814489126,
0.7130399346,
0.545224905,
1.2329636812,
-0.308909148,
0.5005899072,
0.2203462869,
0.541305542,
-0.2650302052,
0.252315104,
-0.2673943341,
-0.7735312581,
-0.4541279376,
-0.6119911671,
-0.1628818214,
0.1494180411,
-0.4901196063,
0.1239636764,
-0.4716742933,
0.1123500913,
0.0087999059,
0.1815162897,
-0.965492785,
0.4694473445,
0.4143795967,
0.4535340071,
-0.9172180891,
1.0439937115,
0.5358448029,
-0.4611204863,
-1.0165536404,
0.2545506358,
-0.1478860974,
-0.9657940269,
1.066054821,
0.1890135258,
-0.076122418,
0.095839873,
-0.4391990304,
-0.7239908576,
0.7749673128,
-0.0126290582,
-0.7222197652,
-0.4075926542,
0.3025118411,
0.8142961264,
-0.3928107917,
0.2012631148,
0.7589039207,
0.1324101388,
0.1835134774,
-0.8576837778,
-0.2643361092,
-0.0746863708,
-0.0001780623,
0.1855703741,
-0.3196868598,
0.9268553257,
-0.438249439,
-0.5617164969,
-0.0380215272,
0.3701445162,
-0.0899901018,
0.286247611,
0.6050746441,
0.4651525915,
0.4146021307,
-0.103735812,
0.8493042588,
-0.3196321726,
0.4431722462,
0.9844458103,
-0.0722776949,
0.8226981759,
0.2071775794,
-0.5675081015,
0.5547776818,
0.6743203402,
0.299608022,
0.6784260869,
0.1118751094,
0.1444913745,
-0.0046498347,
0.268422395,
-0.1634675413,
0.3735233545,
0.6075693965,
-0.3631562591,
-0.3123426437,
0.0470864549,
0.2549433112,
-0.0066314298,
-0.0540883392,
0.9132527113,
0.338185221,
-0.7553521991,
0.7918667793,
-0.3541539311,
0.3492133319,
-0.5344316363,
-0.0010048745,
-0.3313722908,
0.0489689894,
0.0686250627,
-0.8754376173,
0.0110648274,
0.0485790335,
-0.1648824811,
-0.0941680372,
0.6046087742,
-0.5621475577,
-0.3436236382,
0.4172838926,
0.640781641,
0.2925464511,
0.2460990548,
-0.8355519772,
-0.0463447943,
-0.188583076,
-0.4291361272,
0.2107454389,
0.2715672255,
-0.0643129721,
0.5204101801,
0.5047681332,
0.4253301322,
0.5287801623,
0.2972112,
0.5511299372,
-0.5281329751,
-0.1497506499,
-0.6734976172,
0.4409597814,
0.3185855448,
-0.4035722017,
0.2899120152,
0.3471165895,
1.2190812826,
-0.0047072256,
0.6215628386,
-0.0215364713,
0.5392127633,
-0.5709244609,
0.3592384756,
-0.385312289,
-0.0163476337,
-0.1901549697,
-1.0702749491,
-0.2022264302,
0.7662031651,
-0.4785378873,
0.4446076155,
0.9712641239,
0.6795001626,
-0.0592322089,
-0.0567630976,
0.2351722717,
0.1499361247,
0.5001608133,
0.8562507629,
0.8972708583,
-0.3996939659,
0.1072517037,
-0.5492630005,
-0.0241095293,
0.1075104848,
-0.2646976411,
-0.7586164474,
-0.4661340117,
-0.1239781231,
-0.074379988,
0.6181958318,
0.7816187739,
0.560985148,
-0.6171750426,
-0.4070365131,
-0.4820061922,
-0.110778302,
-0.2997338474,
-0.1354966164,
0.2632735968,
-0.700841248,
-0.9245497584,
0.4376000166,
0.172912389,
0.1053091064,
-0.1878437251,
-0.0189257637,
-0.1163070872,
-0.1539993733,
0.4155818522,
0.483025074,
-0.5943040848,
-0.4097285569,
0.058975406,
-0.4905961454,
0.1426160783,
0.8775356412,
-0.8789626956,
0.4622752368,
0.6893203259,
0.3340958953,
0.5396031141,
-0.3084155321,
0.4383192956,
-0.2586182058,
0.3734181821,
0.1164946184,
0.0121258879,
0.2436110377,
0.0337938853,
0.5034953356,
0.3653041124,
-0.4479892552,
-0.7629999518,
0.387063086,
-0.4701990485,
-0.085937649,
0.9057284594,
-0.0693451464,
0.1184632778,
-0.1448077559,
0.1516048163,
0.3826071322,
-0.1420191973,
0.6278191209,
0.7422370911,
-0.1172173023,
-0.1834494472,
-0.6789560914,
0.5872760415,
0.3333135545,
-0.3976736665,
-0.0088952379,
0.1675546318,
0.3972532153,
0.0940767303,
0.3327355683,
-0.3094137311,
0.3331634402,
0.2397255898,
-0.1523665041,
0.2060783654,
-0.8065907955,
-0.5071004033,
-0.1080001667,
0.3606768847,
-0.2016766071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03557v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03557v2 | Take the Hint: Improving Arabic Diacritization with Partially-Diacritized Text | 2023-06-06T10:18:17 | 2023-07-31T12:29:10 | Parnia Bahar, Mattia Di Gangi, Nick Rossenbach, Mohammad Zeineldeen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic Arabic diacritization is useful in many applications, ranging from
reading support for language learners to accurate pronunciation predictor for
downstream tasks like speech synthesis. While most of the previous works
focused on models that operate on raw non-diacritized text, production systems
can gain accuracy by first letting humans partly annotate ambiguous words. In
this paper, we propose 2SDiac, a multi-source model that can effectively
support optional diacritics in input to inform all predictions. We also
introduce Guided Learning, a training scheme to leverage given diacritics in
input with different levels of random masking. We show that the provided hints
during test affect more output positions than those annotated. Moreover,
experiments on two common benchmarks show that our approach i) greatly
outperforms the baseline also when evaluated on non-diacritized text; and ii)
achieves state-of-the-art results while reducing the parameter count by over
60%. | [
-0.2617768645,
-0.5332977176,
0.5130529404,
0.0234104954,
-0.7678610086,
0.3568793535,
-0.2776429951,
-0.5980701447,
-0.0528940931,
0.2350311577,
-0.4823572934,
-0.8981573582,
-0.9935730696,
0.606470108,
-0.4064186513,
1.2257783413,
-0.2378594577,
0.1928756982,
0.3444687724,
-0.0928284749,
-0.2744155526,
-0.5328716636,
-0.4675216377,
0.128768608,
0.4874011278,
0.7066354752,
0.9898415208,
0.9161951542,
0.3311599791,
0.1831484288,
0.0922414735,
0.4795171022,
0.0401695818,
0.3678070903,
0.1963244975,
-0.3699523509,
-0.1228039041,
0.0919827074,
0.4989667237,
0.8185640574,
-0.1664512902,
-0.0138647817,
-0.0533294417,
0.6459134817,
-0.7563343048,
0.1155578569,
-0.3213109672,
-0.0404386222,
-0.3912806511,
0.3743713498,
-0.3174153864,
-0.4345799387,
-0.1796788573,
-0.5507127643,
0.2697391212,
-0.183040306,
0.7122801542,
0.7865509987,
-0.3764710426,
-0.5365242958,
-0.8105589151,
0.6745231748,
-0.6224840879,
0.5715970397,
0.7884389162,
0.2186186314,
0.2230769098,
-0.7495953441,
-0.5301405191,
-0.1090641469,
0.0162808262,
0.3238789439,
-0.0048493952,
0.4113358855,
0.0787868053,
-0.1211854145,
-0.3141793311,
0.1650967151,
-0.4281998873,
-0.5320239663,
0.5649973154,
-0.2495715767,
0.3201168478,
0.0801080912,
-0.1377382278,
-0.1854657233,
-0.6235624552,
-0.0672877952,
0.5317322612,
0.3064764738,
-0.2183432728,
0.6438743472,
-0.189084664,
0.8520948291,
0.0263921712,
0.0557176955,
0.273994416,
-0.5851601958,
0.0288480241,
0.2464351207,
0.4526872337,
-0.0415045656,
0.1821686178,
-0.1593655348,
-0.1432103962,
0.3854173422,
0.2026232332,
-0.8893696666,
-0.6755902171,
0.3886897266,
-0.2019792795,
0.0318151228,
0.0841647014,
-0.6652005911,
-0.5152850747,
-0.3354787827,
0.0159537718,
-0.4276536703,
0.0121453386,
-0.05226757,
-0.2939778566,
-0.4975470901,
0.4050258398,
-0.8741221428,
-0.0173903424,
0.2718435228,
0.9061639309,
0.0109270457,
-0.163754642,
-0.6437713504,
0.2077569813,
-0.7850015759,
0.7825219631,
-0.9509902596,
-0.3054626882,
0.1376305521,
-0.6449773312,
0.0553884208,
-0.4070976079,
0.7364100814,
-0.4912354648,
0.0400203168,
-0.1276301146,
-0.2448253185,
-0.1329737902,
-0.3091191649,
-0.737778604,
1.0390276909,
0.1885400712,
-0.7228808403,
0.655755043,
-0.5043484569,
-0.6456335187,
0.1599631459,
-0.3661438525,
-0.5706169605,
0.0202092957,
0.4792232811,
0.086713016,
0.2651067078,
0.1117070839,
-0.0527638979,
-0.6410750151,
0.0454734229,
-0.3609697521,
0.3314856291,
0.2135904729,
-0.4594142437,
0.0474766754,
-0.9536732435,
0.1335950047,
-0.3431794941,
-0.6160141826,
-0.4401633143,
-0.0345758907,
0.0713227391,
0.1088953316,
0.2847811878,
-0.4794418216,
0.056191761,
-0.5680040121,
0.3322820663,
0.5974041224,
0.0577256382,
0.459865123,
0.0108970674,
0.6758909822,
0.2508361936,
0.1898585409,
0.2186381966,
-0.6698024273,
-0.9780854583,
-0.8875832558,
0.605645299,
0.4022885561,
-1.0814269781,
0.1878168136,
0.1650009155,
-0.4478046,
-0.958127141,
0.3184864521,
0.5858792663,
0.0084200082,
0.6001672149,
-0.5195764899,
-0.9110298753,
-0.8833431602,
-0.1586813927,
-0.3492059708,
-0.024831254,
0.0834440961,
0.1181161627,
-0.2128880322,
0.8138263226,
-0.3086002171,
-0.4212809205,
-0.115118891,
0.4898794293,
0.0524536297,
0.0827490687,
0.2647984028,
-0.8839145899,
-0.7717817426,
-0.1443892419,
-0.2700767815,
-0.2738818824,
0.0359702073,
0.0073255002,
0.3279571235,
0.3529903889,
-0.4095171094,
0.6723155379,
0.5700517893,
0.0038225243,
0.5877967477,
-0.3857672811,
-0.014541016,
-0.7711577415,
-0.1763448119,
-0.0846862942,
0.0126298908,
-0.8672640324,
-0.1818969697,
0.3208053708,
0.1969505101,
-0.3762793243,
0.1440553665,
-0.6510164738,
0.1604534984,
-0.5013111234,
0.1111593843,
-0.0943668783,
0.3827457428,
0.407192409,
1.1432005167,
0.4692583084,
-0.71947366,
-0.0403787568,
0.392475605,
-0.4533695579,
0.2275160998,
-0.4203105867,
0.4292604029,
-0.3476962447,
0.3407241404,
-1.1797727346,
-0.1895666271,
0.4677033722,
-0.4249521792,
0.4344407618,
-0.4199413061,
-0.4537398517,
-0.2308876365,
-0.2613947392,
0.4984442592,
0.3662536144,
-0.4401835203,
0.2004850358,
0.3272109032,
-0.1684230119,
-0.6241666675,
-0.5571702719,
0.3265000582,
-0.0893589556,
-0.1397139877,
0.4487906694,
-0.2380354553,
-0.0853421912,
-0.3253278732,
-0.1880001277,
-0.2881856859,
0.1401979476,
0.5100903511,
0.1905259788,
0.1457464993,
0.0819431171,
0.5218824148,
-0.1032610089,
-0.218004033,
-0.2909444571,
0.3629735708,
0.5819501281,
-0.1993745118,
-0.7789040208,
0.4790786803,
0.4003989398,
-0.5277464986,
0.5812165141,
0.8136566877,
-0.4044966996,
-0.3505034447,
-0.082790114,
-0.2793653011,
-0.463892132,
0.7071400881,
-0.5646050572,
-0.4684289098,
0.038625367,
0.0585680231,
0.1400555968,
0.1244978607,
0.5736474991,
-0.1264272332,
1.5244572163,
0.7168372273,
0.0671866536,
0.3845701814,
0.0517774783,
0.5508441329,
-0.7091390491,
-0.2354018986,
-0.7322220206,
-0.190476194,
-0.6616404653,
-0.4913182259,
0.5261155367,
0.2177587301,
-0.0125677465,
0.5500285029,
-0.6069325209,
0.3391750157,
0.7227671742,
0.2115468085,
0.0643657073,
0.2229829878,
-0.3979702592,
-0.1342251599,
-0.5892366767,
-0.6917921305,
1.0551854372,
0.1754000187,
0.4837425649,
0.4115664363,
0.8581168056,
0.6320801973,
0.311766386,
-0.6065122485,
0.0338643454,
-0.1905879378,
-0.5408297181,
-0.2422356158,
-0.1153156534,
-0.5931107998,
0.1618342698,
0.0026448176,
-0.4989053309,
0.2133568525,
0.0690982938,
-0.7925174832,
-0.1238627881,
-0.7510883808,
0.1900693923,
0.1398233771,
-0.2079962045,
0.0609105863,
-0.8054152131,
-0.0260259733,
-0.2098351717,
0.5909600854,
0.1375987232,
-0.24536708,
1.1259129047,
-0.2653475106,
1.0376257896,
-0.2121884227,
-0.2085080743,
0.5092543364,
0.189749375,
0.5039981008,
0.1399492472,
-0.1634408236,
0.5761846304,
0.0440808833,
-0.3015744686,
-0.369980067,
0.3800449073,
-1.0960422754,
-0.5786429644,
-0.6792929173,
-0.502314806,
-0.1694089621,
0.1210549548,
0.2847434282,
0.2200048417,
0.1916668713,
-0.5463425517,
0.3091737926,
0.2973675728,
0.5688401461,
0.3620918989,
0.2675885558,
-0.7361453176,
0.6514941454,
0.0121507579,
0.053248886,
0.3312245607,
-0.0811213106,
-0.5307776928,
-1.0004882812,
-1.1021096706,
0.2839516699,
-0.891176939,
-0.2128614485,
-0.6172973514,
-0.2073368281,
-0.4758681059,
0.0443160273,
-0.2992060483,
-0.5904634595,
-0.7079547644,
-0.3908654153,
0.0254271347,
0.9155204892,
-0.3547545969,
0.2988609374,
-0.6465296745,
0.1816777289,
0.0577823706,
-0.0579804629,
-0.3219054043,
-0.7159696817,
-0.4476931095,
0.4015350938,
-0.2642425001,
-1.1915483475,
0.1828397959,
0.4292878509,
0.1664170325,
0.7715261579,
0.3708454967,
0.7076612711,
-0.6904730201,
0.8668622375,
0.1719859391,
-0.9498225451,
0.35698089,
0.247327432,
0.1309787631,
0.70206815,
0.3615649045,
-0.4953834713,
-0.5953654051,
-0.0638045892,
-0.7418156266,
0.7797224522,
0.4605289996,
0.1078379676,
-0.2540795207,
0.3734695315,
0.5385841131,
0.2619226873,
-0.2774964571,
-0.4884032011,
-0.2946410179,
-0.6146107912,
-0.0870518237,
-0.6745162606,
-0.1510494649,
-0.1527657062,
0.8853549361,
-0.0369681232,
0.0400897115,
0.3339165151,
-0.2112129182,
-0.1370438337,
0.2405413985,
0.6878586411,
0.6782333851,
-0.0999881178,
0.4444429278,
-0.1264827549,
-0.8682566881,
0.3577082455,
0.2873210609,
-0.5654984713,
0.1992767602,
0.2737778723,
0.6127104759,
-0.2132592946,
-0.5597847104,
0.2699246109,
-0.0439393297,
0.0240120273,
-0.2578669488,
0.0763090849,
-0.3004356325,
0.0491395928,
0.432751447,
0.2523036003,
0.1835434437,
-0.2550287843,
0.2477823049,
0.3141207993,
-0.5344057083,
-0.4491465688,
0.7649899125,
0.3586921394,
-0.4706911445,
0.6026437283,
-0.3121782541,
-0.8744242787,
0.4812752306,
0.4459141791,
0.3984519541,
-0.41231668,
0.545206964,
0.416292876,
0.3887060881,
0.2453882545,
0.3452565372,
-0.6318125129,
-0.5163800716,
-0.212400496,
-0.6085582972,
-0.4232041836,
-0.2310437709,
-0.5397950411,
0.396725595,
-0.5950619578,
-0.3424431682,
0.1809253395,
0.101285696,
-0.5892890096,
0.5186735988,
0.4675998092,
0.5205826163,
-0.9457509518,
0.9308891892,
0.9479113221,
-0.5548571348,
-0.5113303065,
0.0368416049,
-0.2208318859,
-0.8031276464,
0.3543304801,
0.4332175553,
-0.1435442716,
0.0493266135,
-0.3121472299,
-1.0607008934,
0.7114917636,
0.1934522539,
-0.7736369967,
0.0543995984,
0.4571553767,
0.4568578899,
0.0283830017,
0.7938604355,
0.6255526543,
0.5919866562,
-0.0510891862,
-0.8481490016,
0.0141748721,
-0.0224683452,
-0.0002867381,
0.235377863,
-0.4883669019,
0.6354719996,
-0.6473478079,
-0.7462175488,
0.4379443228,
0.7214880586,
0.0483400188,
0.5603528023,
0.3486530781,
0.3238936365,
0.8587930799,
0.116106607,
0.7204872966,
-0.2534275055,
0.0275320075,
1.2208969593,
-0.356734246,
0.6168774366,
0.6700783372,
-0.3139857054,
0.7945357561,
1.1090321541,
0.3642224669,
0.9879357815,
0.1715156734,
-0.3840389252,
-0.2930336297,
-0.365434438,
-0.2663422823,
0.5492468476,
0.1884721667,
-0.4865493178,
-0.1183593497,
-0.0665059164,
0.3303940892,
0.3032075465,
0.1360236257,
0.7579550147,
-0.0634470209,
-0.7597564459,
0.7454575896,
0.5320740938,
0.373386085,
-0.6023800373,
-0.3321945071,
-0.4366714656,
0.0604802556,
-0.2113493085,
-0.2807060778,
0.138441965,
0.1181982234,
-0.1776467711,
-0.0293836966,
0.204048261,
-0.603919208,
-0.6663724184,
0.0772600621,
0.2278164923,
0.322326988,
-0.2523143888,
-0.3342607021,
0.2104246616,
0.1081413552,
0.2638384402,
0.0877249241,
0.1246312484,
-0.1951947808,
0.2607367933,
0.7272518873,
0.2518551648,
0.102049686,
0.2998631299,
0.6640599966,
-0.2661793232,
-0.5774950981,
-0.8856903315,
0.1944148839,
0.0386930145,
-0.2370658368,
0.7694801092,
0.5365282893,
0.9398268461,
0.1939671636,
1.1939036846,
0.0853044838,
0.2849363089,
-0.463950485,
0.7459557652,
-0.1731471717,
0.127596736,
-0.0433234237,
-0.813551724,
-0.5422292352,
0.5457912683,
-0.0345878415,
0.125050649,
0.9001600146,
0.7453424931,
0.099162586,
0.1764411777,
0.4046869874,
0.106702134,
0.2068988979,
0.5497334599,
0.6820931435,
-0.3871805966,
0.4962967038,
-0.7650753856,
-0.5434331298,
0.0627330467,
-0.5289447904,
-1.061626792,
-0.7597484589,
-0.6985495687,
-0.3312832117,
0.4902919233,
0.8089699745,
0.9104236364,
-0.8712637424,
0.1139016077,
-0.058098767,
0.1085352302,
-0.4960335493,
-0.0384557061,
0.7496724725,
-0.0618737526,
-0.9775645733,
0.5754581094,
0.1005643979,
0.096356675,
-0.0526959784,
-0.1350730807,
-0.0666975752,
0.2559419572,
0.2552922368,
-0.07971178,
-0.6633668542,
-0.3619715869,
-0.3506436646,
0.0113772443,
-0.0259850249,
0.6090848446,
-0.7764931321,
0.6079604626,
-0.080823645,
0.3093954325,
0.2456721514,
0.4126847386,
0.0551454611,
-0.8222677708,
0.2830549479,
0.2969068885,
0.043149516,
0.6735163927,
-0.6002538204,
0.2592940331,
0.1650121659,
-0.1519696265,
-0.6010791063,
0.4179312885,
-0.374748975,
-0.1690134704,
1.3227745295,
-0.2218611538,
-0.1323790848,
-0.3427813053,
-0.3476555645,
0.7789871693,
-0.6078760028,
1.2229014635,
0.5775601864,
0.0803544372,
0.0981329679,
-0.1560019255,
0.6727660298,
0.5128240585,
-0.4686591327,
0.0177776255,
0.6301439404,
0.2602462471,
0.0346298516,
0.5109599829,
0.1551379859,
0.4118718803,
-0.0956968814,
0.1525227278,
-0.2998497188,
-0.7907897234,
-0.3015500307,
-0.0995975733,
0.2768512964,
-0.7667871118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03535v2 | SciLit: A Platform for Joint Scientific Literature Discovery, Summarization and Citation Generation | 2023-06-06T09:34:45 | 2023-11-06T15:53:23 | Nianlong Gu, Richard H. R. Hahnloser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific writing involves retrieving, summarizing, and citing relevant
papers, which can be time-consuming processes in large and rapidly evolving
fields. By making these processes inter-operable, natural language processing
(NLP) provides opportunities for creating end-to-end assistive writing tools.
We propose SciLit, a pipeline that automatically recommends relevant papers,
extracts highlights, and suggests a reference sentence as a citation of a
paper, taking into consideration the user-provided context and keywords. SciLit
efficiently recommends papers from large databases of hundreds of millions of
papers using a two-stage pre-fetching and re-ranking literature search system
that flexibly deals with addition and removal of a paper database. We provide a
convenient user interface that displays the recommended papers as extractive
summaries and that offers abstractively-generated citing sentences which are
aligned with the provided context and which mention the chosen keyword(s). Our
assistive tool for literature discovery and scientific writing is available at
https://scilit.vercel.app | [
0.0699921995,
-0.162639156,
0.5196216702,
0.6077862382,
-0.1534648389,
0.3656766415,
-0.0124362586,
-0.5871599317,
0.7441756129,
0.2689101994,
-0.3967316151,
-0.4036214948,
-0.1341439039,
0.6098612547,
-0.3140087128,
1.1995785236,
0.1182042807,
0.1457419544,
-0.5495553613,
0.0896222144,
-0.0007085708,
-0.0202842336,
-0.3172986209,
-0.250880003,
0.9143168926,
0.2663227916,
0.4065021873,
0.2979082465,
0.7314465046,
0.2011472136,
-0.0338696092,
0.4096588194,
-0.2978942692,
0.7549803257,
-0.4543266296,
-0.2491697967,
-0.6023508906,
-0.1287866533,
0.6266151667,
0.6727956533,
0.2858790457,
0.2860079706,
-0.053845007,
0.7166895866,
-0.5125854611,
0.0073641129,
-0.5110508204,
0.1164423972,
-0.2197974026,
-0.6422120929,
-0.5825061202,
-0.7625633478,
0.1507641971,
-0.7718672752,
0.5267546773,
0.4180932641,
0.5044850111,
0.1986690462,
0.0223098397,
-0.5267109871,
-0.417201221,
0.6233932376,
-0.3757584691,
-0.193571955,
0.2579784989,
0.1020879596,
-0.2667957246,
-1.2347071171,
-0.2211034447,
-0.4193926752,
-0.4299066663,
0.2306834459,
0.0309299827,
-0.0820872113,
0.3377277255,
0.1131946743,
-0.8434086442,
-0.3730460405,
-0.7906447053,
-0.3342574537,
0.7148195505,
0.0094473548,
0.4046657085,
-0.422047168,
-0.0274149217,
0.2876191437,
-0.8161818385,
-0.1840943992,
0.1204491258,
0.3126432598,
0.4609749317,
0.6465168595,
-0.1047914997,
0.3902243376,
-0.3893682659,
0.1897477061,
0.2873566151,
-0.5939008594,
-0.1426679045,
0.5566763878,
0.8850487471,
0.3118464947,
-0.1453721672,
-0.3026857674,
0.2581614256,
-0.1159027144,
0.1936337054,
-0.7867890596,
-0.5974490643,
0.1995921135,
-0.2504113615,
-0.4312161505,
0.0376169756,
-0.6608259678,
-0.5992618203,
0.1154785678,
0.0760515407,
-0.3963061273,
0.0265456717,
-0.3646918535,
-0.4713318944,
-0.2640711963,
0.3248148561,
-0.7735512853,
-0.0707583725,
0.1771277338,
1.2851331234,
-0.1608181,
-0.3350462615,
-0.6635500193,
0.4701533616,
-0.0606316663,
0.9657868743,
-0.4345655143,
-0.5889468789,
-0.3366749585,
0.013024061,
-0.0692621768,
0.0423150212,
0.7912678123,
-0.2967105508,
0.4811415076,
-0.4102668762,
-0.2397626638,
0.1091578677,
-0.3002348244,
-0.7408480644,
1.087836504,
0.13252379,
-1.1833637953,
0.4966568053,
-0.9757431149,
-0.5482897758,
0.5526026487,
-0.0669619888,
-0.3343548477,
0.1609374881,
0.1113703474,
0.3617735207,
-0.3809441328,
0.611361146,
-0.1116912961,
-0.4091960192,
-0.0255281106,
0.1447978169,
0.7312076688,
0.4322072864,
-0.0278066155,
0.4356700778,
-0.8002255559,
0.1317913234,
-0.0274604373,
-0.0940946415,
-0.5118441582,
0.213490814,
0.5392180681,
0.1020906121,
0.2893738449,
-0.9006215334,
0.2962062955,
-0.5420580506,
0.6582425237,
0.2670736611,
-0.1714444011,
0.3675548732,
-0.2537122369,
0.3823664188,
-0.5544632673,
-0.2398914099,
-0.8269585967,
-0.3396054506,
-0.4610589743,
-0.2546097934,
0.2126379311,
0.4024322033,
-0.6372085214,
0.3447936773,
-0.1231835485,
-0.5205435157,
-0.6715454459,
0.0784249529,
0.2230254859,
0.6113380194,
0.536342144,
0.1362882406,
-0.8792893887,
-0.8039554954,
-0.1817140132,
-0.0992035717,
-0.1126634106,
-0.0013449818,
0.4908386767,
-0.0196856502,
1.4643260241,
-0.5427448153,
-0.2431200892,
-0.2942290604,
0.293007344,
0.1680694818,
0.4810058475,
0.4133507311,
-0.9533995986,
-0.6550343037,
0.1842042953,
-0.9809314609,
-0.634033978,
-0.0540553369,
-0.0025068684,
0.2577738166,
0.821621716,
-0.3400833905,
0.3496724069,
0.1684291512,
-0.4969989955,
0.6228023171,
-0.4223207831,
0.0209161397,
-1.2049484253,
0.8888734579,
-0.2134664357,
-0.1701204479,
-0.405964762,
-0.1499441713,
0.0677525923,
-0.1784564704,
-0.0539823063,
0.3498207033,
-0.4668481648,
-0.1665463895,
-0.2977144718,
0.2785256505,
0.4430580735,
-0.0828252137,
0.2001384348,
0.8345944881,
0.4941168129,
-0.0808333829,
0.1351331621,
0.1100935116,
-0.0401606299,
0.2358349711,
-0.9724214077,
-0.1979719549,
-0.1825212985,
0.3262204826,
-0.9447376728,
-0.4172754884,
0.038951125,
-0.2140586823,
-0.0956605896,
0.2340557128,
-0.4312004745,
-0.1373362243,
-0.538200736,
0.1570578963,
0.0673597306,
-0.2697225213,
0.6046487093,
0.0622554086,
-0.8384021521,
-0.5756425261,
-0.3440338671,
0.2410061508,
0.0496813878,
-0.5761116147,
0.6252862811,
-0.1785870939,
-0.1603849083,
0.2273767292,
0.0757451206,
0.2168661952,
0.0837510899,
0.5368341804,
0.5214579105,
0.0757775381,
0.3536653221,
0.454005152,
-0.2521193027,
0.0863675401,
-0.1952941865,
0.3288166821,
-0.3424163163,
-0.0832619518,
0.2748604119,
0.566018641,
0.5883592367,
-0.0383830629,
0.2062428743,
0.7672146559,
-0.0739313066,
-0.0437959805,
-0.1050250605,
0.0078743985,
-0.398519069,
0.2312210053,
-0.0102880225,
-0.8828300238,
0.255744487,
-0.0386687219,
0.3805908263,
0.5862832069,
0.2570934594,
-0.2711918652,
0.776930213,
0.760530293,
0.1491684616,
0.1427851319,
0.1033735946,
0.5552488565,
-0.8020151854,
-0.4094908535,
-0.7357094884,
-0.296684593,
-0.4434254467,
-0.2140725553,
0.3637870848,
0.1653235555,
0.1741794199,
0.3850021958,
-1.0108326674,
0.6411268711,
0.7208209634,
-0.518670857,
0.5917111039,
0.0166712645,
-0.4116452038,
-0.2730171978,
-0.625077486,
-0.6872945428,
0.7723810077,
-0.0349068381,
0.5842246413,
-0.1229682118,
0.7849468589,
0.285918802,
0.5036906004,
-0.4310457408,
0.6345086098,
0.1818341613,
-0.4569812715,
-0.19391267,
-0.0583215244,
-0.8109593987,
0.333507359,
-0.3840501606,
-0.7242715359,
0.0175989866,
0.1054612249,
-0.388681978,
-0.0659920573,
-0.6681342125,
0.5245983005,
-0.3107407391,
-0.8716512322,
-0.1696903408,
-0.8543578982,
0.2146291882,
-0.0517630577,
0.0641482174,
-0.0685483143,
0.1298058629,
0.7603024244,
-0.1348533183,
0.5101843476,
-0.0150907878,
0.4713935852,
-0.0456409901,
0.2090350389,
0.0069096391,
0.4441351295,
-0.2114806175,
-0.23873806,
0.212808013,
-0.2808628678,
-0.2364440411,
0.974979341,
-0.252697736,
-0.237273097,
-1.0474094152,
-0.920432508,
0.0688318536,
0.4916881621,
0.5051945448,
0.1653934121,
-0.251604259,
0.2399151474,
0.3181091249,
-0.2632690966,
0.8450168967,
0.3961541951,
-0.6432640553,
-0.3113457263,
0.9643508196,
-0.1308017969,
-0.2041723877,
0.2380423099,
0.1805100739,
-0.1036344245,
-0.6292234063,
-0.2324814796,
0.2155642956,
-0.3948820829,
-0.25446558,
-0.8672229052,
-0.2332563698,
-0.5261369348,
-0.6541061997,
0.0199245382,
-0.664911449,
-0.3196115494,
-0.1815572977,
0.4824169278,
0.696364224,
-0.0867812634,
-0.1085759923,
-0.5211237669,
-0.0061078584,
-0.1130644009,
0.0944518447,
-0.4349085391,
-0.0511490889,
-0.3554291427,
-0.5791733861,
-0.2506899536,
-0.6115092635,
0.8040313125,
0.5097849369,
0.2649016082,
0.0833101422,
0.0193473641,
0.2719297111,
-0.6096384525,
0.8580887914,
0.340649426,
-0.562803328,
0.9921872616,
-0.325589627,
0.3595850766,
0.8356456161,
0.6836460233,
-0.3469564319,
-0.4430016875,
-0.5765675306,
-1.299567461,
0.4538067579,
0.1394631714,
-0.372582376,
0.105410412,
0.0631019846,
0.3439332843,
0.3025919795,
-0.8867750764,
0.0279488638,
-0.2639410496,
-0.1547124237,
-0.0191551335,
-0.1694641709,
-0.2766524255,
-0.1729656756,
0.7238941789,
-0.4335509539,
-0.0237427168,
0.6823454499,
-0.2823781371,
-0.1316892803,
0.2177213132,
0.7664381862,
0.9224830866,
-0.4698271453,
0.0797908157,
-0.351921767,
-0.7472043633,
-0.4357787371,
0.4985032678,
-0.5821448565,
0.3179905415,
0.4777779877,
0.4794909358,
0.3144485354,
-0.8794938922,
0.1337440908,
-0.1108912453,
-0.3319026828,
-0.384175539,
0.1533601582,
0.2113334686,
0.0355636999,
0.9439298511,
0.3604400754,
0.5001689792,
-0.2866019607,
0.2104000449,
0.2918813825,
-0.3004228771,
-0.2886064351,
0.7541697025,
0.2999252379,
-0.3664235473,
0.1704131812,
-0.2624336481,
-0.3539560139,
0.3692060113,
0.6663346291,
0.8741192222,
0.0194579028,
0.5933414102,
0.4186116457,
0.217640385,
0.1275363564,
0.1901413202,
-0.1211485937,
-0.200979352,
-0.5224248767,
-0.8390933871,
-0.4186508656,
-0.2582623959,
-0.4306404293,
0.3673578203,
-0.4542195201,
0.0554235689,
0.4913606346,
0.1923877448,
-0.0900038183,
-0.2781018317,
-0.1722593307,
0.8776471615,
-0.9410418868,
0.8618181944,
0.6554176211,
-0.5058529377,
-0.4093019664,
-0.40119344,
-0.0932480544,
-0.1913268268,
0.9078265429,
0.2504248321,
-0.3162657619,
-0.008436298,
-0.5586220026,
-0.9170466661,
1.4599936008,
0.2445199937,
-0.507373631,
-0.1556032747,
-0.5221380591,
0.8284451962,
-0.60072577,
0.7062554359,
0.3377467394,
0.3467542827,
0.3637314439,
-0.8750286102,
0.0387590416,
-0.836805284,
-0.2350505888,
0.0856171921,
-0.3404328227,
0.6879107952,
-0.2933200896,
-0.1103401482,
-0.0085904142,
0.5684434175,
0.5454045534,
0.8862117529,
-0.0275439471,
0.071884349,
1.03162992,
-0.0132910619,
0.796843648,
-0.2416561991,
0.0168881975,
1.133961916,
-0.7022429109,
0.622726202,
0.7731413245,
0.0291677676,
0.7143388987,
0.3314683735,
-0.1164242476,
0.4920727313,
0.0218551159,
-0.2745524645,
0.2632853687,
-0.4135553539,
-0.3912087679,
-0.0373374633,
0.4045355022,
-0.6701833606,
-0.3693038821,
0.1363792568,
-0.0374698564,
0.2841072977,
-0.1337209344,
0.35006091,
-0.0666933358,
-0.841635406,
0.0089919465,
-0.2267722934,
0.5705971122,
-0.807506144,
-0.2283652276,
-0.1417196095,
-0.2756980658,
-0.65076828,
-0.6639748812,
0.4180996418,
0.0677617714,
-0.4063766003,
-0.3694062829,
1.0206685066,
-0.4129903615,
-0.5251038074,
0.0084226122,
0.2752812207,
0.2120710462,
0.5100613236,
-0.5008857846,
0.0237935968,
0.0587506704,
-0.2810754478,
0.3056849837,
0.015535282,
-0.1326911151,
0.7124015689,
0.8731991053,
0.3952584863,
-0.1682839245,
-0.0488129593,
0.8656151891,
-0.5317100883,
-0.7033997178,
-0.5489956141,
0.5044425726,
-0.765950799,
-0.4615966976,
0.9367884994,
0.7305042744,
0.1579992026,
0.0104302745,
1.0259094238,
-0.5902392268,
0.6621348262,
-0.2298581153,
0.7461396456,
-0.055048313,
0.3153811395,
-0.4070937634,
-0.9406398535,
-0.7518737912,
0.9301295877,
-0.2822282016,
-0.2985733151,
1.0927629471,
0.7183611393,
0.1608348042,
0.4297123551,
-0.0348058455,
0.0164546538,
0.4286352396,
0.1917801499,
0.4091038406,
-0.0872542784,
0.3193390667,
0.0945380032,
-0.1278624237,
-0.4043554664,
-1.3945739269,
-0.8173620105,
-0.8167273998,
-0.3002763987,
-0.1779469401,
-0.0329669043,
1.0322262049,
0.3709917963,
-0.7960578203,
0.001572611,
-0.3334235549,
0.0379361287,
0.0560529642,
-0.2659606636,
0.7029958367,
-0.480422765,
-0.6021946669,
0.671996057,
0.8725818992,
-0.4050061107,
-0.6041368842,
0.0437371023,
-0.5273867846,
-0.257471025,
0.5912204385,
0.5671543479,
-0.310346067,
0.0697984695,
0.2951702476,
-0.1302812248,
-0.2892352045,
1.1467686892,
-1.0554994345,
0.6190148592,
0.8002361059,
0.3615537882,
0.57203722,
-0.2590976059,
0.7182613611,
-0.6897311211,
0.0963331908,
0.5855696201,
0.3044210374,
0.4763807356,
-0.4960159659,
0.8696950078,
0.2847550213,
-0.9134597778,
-1.2016913891,
-0.0004172654,
-0.9728553295,
-0.3617064953,
0.6537467837,
-0.0630323291,
-0.1977172792,
-0.2896077633,
-0.5282116532,
-0.1752400398,
-0.4149766862,
0.7449612021,
0.5142825246,
-0.4566900432,
0.0229017325,
-0.4110835493,
0.8301742673,
0.4235087037,
-0.7064986229,
0.0131416703,
0.6708829999,
0.0049315696,
0.8332381248,
0.6941998005,
0.1277976185,
0.5002137423,
-0.1880499721,
0.0735002384,
-0.3648405373,
-0.5041700602,
-0.0349759534,
0.5983447433,
0.03518207,
0.5174882412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03507v1 | "A Little is Enough": Few-Shot Quality Estimation based Corpus Filtering improves Machine Translation | 2023-06-06T08:53:01 | 2023-06-06T08:53:01 | Akshay Batheja, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Quality Estimation (QE) is the task of evaluating the quality of a
translation when reference translation is not available. The goal of QE aligns
with the task of corpus filtering, where we assign the quality score to the
sentence pairs present in the pseudo-parallel corpus. We propose a Quality
Estimation based Filtering approach to extract high-quality parallel data from
the pseudo-parallel corpus. To the best of our knowledge, this is a novel
adaptation of the QE framework to extract quality parallel corpus from the
pseudo-parallel corpus. By training with this filtered corpus, we observe an
improvement in the Machine Translation (MT) system's performance by up to 1.8
BLEU points, for English-Marathi, Chinese-English, and Hindi-Bengali language
pairs, over the baseline model. The baseline model is the one that is trained
on the whole pseudo-parallel corpus. Our Few-shot QE model transfer learned
from the English-Marathi QE model and fine-tuned on only 500 Hindi-Bengali
training instances, shows an improvement of up to 0.6 BLEU points for
Hindi-Bengali language pair, compared to the baseline model. This demonstrates
the promise of transfer learning in the setting under discussion. QE systems
typically require in the order of (7K-25K) of training data. Our Hindi-Bengali
QE is trained on only 500 instances of training that is 1/40th of the normal
requirement and achieves comparable performance. All the scripts and datasets
utilized in this study will be publicly available. | [
-0.4174297154,
-0.3303794265,
0.6446830034,
0.0016232018,
-0.5598514676,
-0.167281732,
0.1169743016,
-0.3394892216,
0.3375192583,
0.4770059288,
-0.3891593218,
-0.5331097245,
-0.8548697233,
0.1993737072,
-0.5908368826,
0.9189370275,
0.2759881318,
0.2083305418,
0.2014583945,
-0.3028011918,
-0.6345183849,
-0.0195605904,
-0.4012905657,
0.0806990787,
0.2692791522,
0.5652763844,
0.8325682282,
0.7131437659,
0.5693621039,
0.2315759808,
0.0962037817,
0.2340072095,
-0.6784574389,
-0.2936790287,
-0.3469526768,
-0.7813426852,
-0.3036292791,
-0.0800607651,
0.9329056144,
0.5504781008,
0.0367504507,
0.3478046656,
0.312097609,
0.9614919424,
-0.8347049356,
-0.1501395851,
-0.5396382213,
-0.181293264,
-0.3521256447,
0.1543429047,
-0.2632943988,
-0.3844056129,
-0.2038845867,
-0.6595619917,
0.0511683598,
0.3391160667,
1.1611098051,
0.457611233,
-0.1460948437,
0.0720401704,
-0.5520325899,
1.0940551758,
-0.6785923839,
0.3806783557,
0.7509971261,
0.5911695361,
-0.1187339425,
-0.5586506128,
-0.6816148162,
0.1251635998,
-0.2239127606,
0.3352123201,
-0.2287837118,
-0.1017366871,
0.1534997225,
0.1668016613,
-0.8080251217,
-0.042496819,
-0.4394464195,
-0.1690167487,
0.3350624144,
0.1706680804,
0.3102990687,
-0.3073167503,
-0.2421295941,
0.012276724,
-0.5031897426,
0.0929001123,
0.0724265799,
0.1003838032,
-0.2367822826,
0.4351889789,
-0.3113829494,
0.8814252615,
0.0826626644,
-0.1985955089,
-0.1638389528,
-0.6399732232,
-0.3591506779,
-0.2963423729,
0.7893093228,
0.1950684339,
0.1472874433,
0.1426115334,
-0.2722747624,
0.061275024,
0.1349838972,
-0.7391605377,
-0.3919283748,
0.1245610714,
-0.560616076,
0.0350940041,
0.1022284403,
-0.8869522214,
-0.2098647654,
-0.2564686835,
0.422080934,
-0.5876460075,
-0.0681606531,
-0.2824893594,
-0.0803434104,
0.0841999128,
0.0388813429,
-0.7892796397,
0.2742564976,
0.393481046,
1.0396573544,
-0.3002642989,
-0.3507441878,
-0.7960234284,
-0.0042902101,
-0.5267917514,
1.114505887,
-0.3752048016,
-0.371794492,
-0.1423394084,
-0.0869723856,
-0.2614780962,
-0.6437516212,
0.7242353559,
-0.5315739512,
0.0039656712,
-0.2014347911,
-0.5977911949,
-0.1116088033,
0.1205421463,
-0.515532434,
0.9039084315,
0.2895273268,
-0.6043278575,
0.3574243486,
-0.2764223814,
-0.0755094066,
0.1268423349,
0.0464980714,
-0.3345618546,
0.1944624037,
0.553440392,
0.0726804063,
-0.3746017218,
-0.1498713195,
-0.4645993412,
-0.637116015,
0.0970160738,
-0.3335109353,
0.7855398059,
0.4018410742,
0.359143436,
0.1924335212,
-0.6946415901,
0.2536801696,
-0.3366540968,
-0.1108672917,
-0.1831195503,
-0.3588917553,
0.123746112,
0.2695596516,
0.1046674773,
-0.7503003478,
-0.1867903471,
-0.9015160203,
0.1333019733,
0.2550367415,
0.1736115813,
0.8224341869,
-0.462149322,
0.598724246,
0.0760176927,
0.2510222495,
0.0242290217,
-0.4298895299,
-0.5046833754,
-0.6864851117,
0.7094399333,
0.6293524504,
-0.8625951409,
0.1778452247,
-0.3975005448,
-0.333663702,
-1.0808719397,
0.5648207068,
0.3717432916,
0.3460652828,
0.545150578,
-0.2500354946,
-0.493881911,
-0.8161068559,
-0.2946127951,
-0.2330449522,
-0.1429450065,
-0.3398216963,
0.3014651537,
0.1793478131,
1.2497073412,
-0.3892548382,
-0.6603793502,
-0.3812721074,
0.0558237471,
0.4508928061,
0.5427457094,
0.6544106007,
-0.6686241627,
-0.8500030041,
-0.1523881108,
-0.8392471075,
-0.186877057,
0.0095324032,
-0.5485805273,
0.0179036986,
0.2379283607,
-0.3726403713,
0.235174939,
0.790396452,
0.0927574635,
0.3875928223,
-0.2697924078,
0.1152620092,
-1.0688042641,
-0.0552742966,
0.0891605988,
-0.5481247902,
-0.375277698,
-0.0623190105,
0.2524688542,
-0.1570292264,
-0.7262413502,
0.8045145869,
-0.2382433265,
-0.0305510033,
-0.9469268918,
0.3619290888,
0.1224990413,
0.343377769,
-0.1621734947,
0.8721609712,
0.5089512467,
-0.4215367436,
-0.0054369806,
0.3286931217,
-0.4215771258,
0.8780590296,
-0.3383080363,
0.0327372253,
-0.0100529371,
0.1787172854,
-0.9240656495,
-0.0511439741,
0.1570020765,
-0.6257972717,
0.291139245,
-0.5650619864,
-0.3190741241,
-0.225969702,
-0.1049715057,
0.2319501787,
0.5655168295,
-0.4779330194,
0.2355252057,
0.4221651554,
-0.1909772754,
-0.4019910395,
-0.6230285764,
0.0911877975,
-0.0209968407,
-0.3941805661,
0.0604282171,
0.087465927,
0.1481358111,
0.3588269353,
-0.2199295759,
-0.7492206693,
-0.176086694,
0.0445375219,
0.3800756037,
-0.3117672205,
-0.0537907295,
0.503837049,
-0.3602226377,
-0.2418904155,
-0.5215403438,
0.0587116368,
0.0772112757,
-0.099722974,
-0.7773388028,
0.4128674567,
0.2690583169,
-0.0869797245,
0.8533124924,
0.9202082753,
-0.4571819007,
-0.0856246352,
-0.3393316269,
-0.2120102644,
-0.3796958327,
0.3584104776,
-0.5998606086,
-0.5859722495,
0.254935503,
0.0837436318,
-0.2375496328,
0.6328795552,
0.2504110336,
-0.6401277781,
0.9956694245,
0.7992532849,
-0.3219150901,
0.5051168203,
-0.2902517617,
0.1657968313,
-0.659788847,
0.4350179732,
-0.4896146953,
-0.1966715455,
-0.7799853683,
-0.2217700481,
0.6326494217,
0.6181898117,
0.0507855602,
0.3886530399,
-0.2240005881,
0.6429821849,
0.7011855245,
0.2723165751,
0.2391702533,
-0.0433909893,
0.0638622642,
-0.0785896257,
-0.861300528,
-0.639533937,
1.0805485249,
0.0916116759,
0.3631222844,
0.1146576405,
0.8454729319,
0.3043332994,
0.2150057107,
-0.6979185343,
0.3592158854,
-0.4413611293,
-0.7073399425,
-0.5442453623,
-0.4356309772,
-0.7803993821,
0.4252733886,
-0.4543375075,
-0.4704950154,
0.4327023029,
0.3125153184,
-0.6073424816,
0.0499046855,
-0.7264301181,
0.803337574,
0.1441596448,
-0.5468407273,
-0.5478496552,
-0.5273817182,
0.4623340368,
-0.4056367874,
0.2464018911,
-0.3690415025,
0.1928897053,
0.8123522997,
-0.5141429305,
0.5704458952,
-0.3419550359,
0.6130723357,
0.6540468335,
0.0632810816,
0.5651898384,
0.1101580113,
-0.349411428,
0.4347797036,
0.6997139454,
-1.2478901148,
-0.6554014087,
0.6822974086,
-0.7323434949,
-0.5148422718,
-0.440094173,
-0.4100898802,
-0.3058093786,
0.3636176288,
0.3407593966,
-0.1147760823,
-0.0619615801,
-0.0958422497,
0.0767178163,
-0.132883653,
0.5396355987,
0.4680641294,
0.1005073115,
-0.5628520846,
1.0997546911,
0.1503577232,
0.0769789591,
0.4471745193,
0.3744331002,
-0.3557884693,
-0.8634400964,
-0.8457571864,
0.4597925246,
-0.4938977659,
-0.3569798768,
-0.3640113175,
-0.0989947692,
-0.4242726564,
0.0939786062,
-0.5998411775,
-0.3517867029,
0.0378072895,
0.2853430808,
0.1251617819,
0.4429883957,
-0.1066835001,
0.7941516042,
-1.3528072834,
0.4453337193,
0.1548453867,
0.0995796174,
-0.3709276319,
-1.1324540377,
-0.7640652657,
0.1167931408,
-0.3828794956,
-0.8359910846,
0.7500730753,
0.1861205548,
0.4133823812,
0.0453713126,
0.2627559006,
0.8286415935,
-0.4906111658,
0.6404526234,
0.2712226808,
-0.8540463448,
0.4705890417,
-0.0499498174,
0.4470816851,
0.930963695,
0.3000736237,
-0.1294603944,
-0.2459500134,
-0.1364605427,
-0.4541681111,
0.8779782057,
0.4858775735,
-0.1006265208,
0.1051900387,
0.2033744305,
0.0092396811,
0.1116241291,
-0.4489881694,
-0.0485129058,
-0.2844320238,
-0.4345063269,
0.0685682073,
-0.3274866641,
0.210140273,
-0.1037192047,
0.7854921222,
-0.0223122369,
0.1702770442,
0.068591617,
-0.4466320276,
-0.2196871042,
0.351596415,
0.4107509851,
0.5112912059,
-0.4087491333,
-0.1687399894,
0.3245706856,
-0.3678649664,
0.0698134974,
-0.1359586418,
-0.1800211966,
0.1191473156,
0.1846317649,
0.8394607306,
-0.1164021119,
-0.3324587643,
0.5462642908,
0.4135119021,
0.2015888095,
0.0042461688,
-0.158412084,
-0.3086648881,
0.1165881306,
0.1379019469,
0.1863866299,
0.3154020607,
-0.3008514643,
0.3000712395,
0.093282558,
-0.4378663003,
-0.4064115882,
0.479331404,
0.1299427003,
-0.0748919696,
0.5302755237,
-0.4443701208,
-0.1591291726,
0.2191951722,
0.417845428,
0.6480132937,
-0.3121901453,
0.1973748952,
0.7347371578,
0.3558534384,
-0.3316194117,
0.0786784217,
0.1233509555,
-0.6686262488,
-0.8033202887,
-1.0228611231,
-0.4364849329,
-0.1919149905,
-0.4659309983,
0.4267913997,
-0.0760512576,
-0.1662742496,
-0.1786409169,
0.0490346923,
-0.6955254078,
0.3439710438,
-0.0680247396,
0.6109680533,
-1.0482746363,
1.3762944937,
0.6157653928,
-0.6658237576,
-0.5563365817,
-0.0121943979,
-0.0231185816,
-0.8101859689,
0.6284323931,
-0.2756395042,
-0.1583310366,
0.2673334181,
-0.019755505,
-1.0760369301,
0.580063343,
0.5514354706,
-0.7835971117,
0.0298971981,
0.1972521842,
0.6351159215,
-0.138654232,
0.3857392073,
0.7176858783,
0.4517349303,
-0.1660595834,
-0.8937624097,
-0.3130183518,
0.0701481476,
0.1100841165,
0.3662830591,
-0.4688519537,
0.1889613122,
0.0881215706,
-0.304430306,
0.2892971933,
0.7697358131,
0.1187412441,
0.5570154786,
0.4123854041,
0.2982386351,
0.5680403113,
0.1719307899,
1.2162103653,
-0.4125349224,
0.2338428199,
1.2273994684,
-0.0085873334,
1.2551828623,
0.5171141028,
-0.3519022465,
0.167617932,
0.5713329911,
0.0627614558,
0.5241220593,
-0.2399991453,
-0.0174782705,
-0.277141124,
-0.0982869864,
0.1165814921,
0.3583085835,
0.217775479,
-0.1785322428,
-0.1693395674,
0.3431220353,
-0.4808473289,
0.4492531419,
-0.2231672406,
0.8094043732,
0.4166773558,
-0.5766730905,
0.8400762081,
0.0402255766,
0.4308908284,
-0.2868812382,
0.1149467826,
-0.4854634404,
-0.0386789627,
-0.3754186332,
-0.6807793379,
0.6766735911,
0.0992702693,
-0.5006395578,
0.0391178764,
0.4017292559,
-0.4475700557,
-0.6350622177,
0.1799138039,
0.8017032146,
0.5879577398,
-0.3951619267,
-0.7158386707,
-0.1836842448,
-0.0989855453,
0.1424827278,
0.6676369309,
0.2995225489,
-0.2371042073,
0.2288135141,
0.6097915173,
0.5237959623,
0.2851217389,
-0.0854478776,
0.3348580003,
-0.6979835033,
-0.4875574708,
-0.6375466585,
0.2801457644,
-0.0536869243,
-0.111824654,
0.5396168232,
0.4813639522,
0.7709212899,
-0.0955218002,
0.5729544163,
0.3012671769,
0.7893790603,
-0.508611083,
0.6319876313,
-0.4658610225,
0.3147247732,
0.0377905294,
-1.254029274,
-0.2849711776,
0.4423343837,
-0.3129297793,
-0.3408815861,
0.9812125564,
0.9431996942,
-0.2338553965,
-0.2544769645,
1.0080667734,
0.2323720604,
-0.0526450388,
0.5056816936,
0.4947707355,
-0.8651370406,
0.9080238938,
-0.2536072433,
-0.2385406494,
0.0623071156,
-0.4859120846,
-0.4752061367,
-0.2485181093,
-0.2938196063,
-0.1846485436,
0.2734746039,
0.8736017346,
0.8599044681,
-1.1081095934,
-0.4234475195,
-0.0541587956,
0.1046775803,
-0.4438103735,
-0.1448284239,
0.554282248,
-0.5473752022,
-1.2118299007,
0.703507185,
0.3236522377,
-0.1975457519,
0.2929514349,
-0.0090200668,
-0.3277872503,
-0.0230860654,
0.5914723277,
0.3656639159,
-0.5359771252,
-0.1606199443,
-0.1933416873,
-0.2890711725,
0.250353843,
0.3387067914,
-0.6804180741,
0.5436965823,
0.6816489697,
0.8444878459,
0.7299673557,
0.0773051158,
0.3405144513,
-0.7245386839,
0.1800251901,
0.0308606829,
0.3219552934,
0.2060801089,
-0.0667102337,
0.3924460411,
0.4109993577,
-0.4609339237,
-0.6907824874,
0.0705427006,
-0.997928679,
-0.1888346672,
0.9233536124,
-0.3949461281,
-0.3305173516,
-0.1882145405,
-0.2229373157,
0.4808326662,
-0.4800201654,
0.6354240775,
0.6753758788,
-0.113867186,
-0.2846899033,
-0.7129815221,
0.2615872622,
0.8029935956,
-0.5048919916,
-0.4114313722,
0.3288758397,
0.2790331542,
-0.0500509776,
0.4618281722,
-0.0342746936,
0.3866086304,
-0.0923369676,
-0.0857743323,
0.1087717712,
-0.2046185732,
-0.4575091302,
0.4141254723,
0.3111302555,
-0.6938105822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03503v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03503v2 | Applying Standards to Advance Upstream & Downstream Ethics in Large Language Models | 2023-06-06T08:47:42 | 2023-06-11T10:45:57 | Jose Berengueres, Marybeth Sandell | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.4.1; I.2.0 | This paper explores how AI-owners can develop safeguards for AI-generated
content by drawing from established codes of conduct and ethical standards in
other content-creation industries. It delves into the current state of ethical
awareness on Large Language Models (LLMs). By dissecting the mechanism of
content generation by LLMs, four key areas (upstream/downstream and at user
prompt/answer), where safeguards could be effectively applied, are identified.
A comparative analysis of these four areas follows and includes an evaluation
of the existing ethical safeguards in terms of cost, effectiveness, and
alignment with established industry practices. The paper's key argument is that
existing IT-related ethical codes, while adequate for traditional IT
engineering, are inadequate for the challenges posed by LLM-based content
generation. Drawing from established practices within journalism, we propose
potential standards for businesses involved in distributing and selling
LLM-generated content. Finally, potential conflicts of interest between dataset
curation at upstream and ethical benchmarking downstream are highlighted to
underscore the need for a broader evaluation beyond mere output. This study
prompts a nuanced conversation around ethical implications in this rapidly
evolving field of content generation. | [
-0.2472930551,
-0.2652087808,
0.6269509792,
0.0724833682,
-0.2328992039,
0.0306825619,
-0.2671130598,
-0.7071512938,
-0.3052332699,
0.9086784124,
-0.5310997963,
-0.3339604437,
-0.6203411222,
0.3007263541,
-0.4045339227,
1.2958357334,
-0.0226930976,
0.0216065012,
-0.1564335972,
-0.2367791533,
-0.3526308835,
-0.4642603695,
-0.9024893641,
0.2045258284,
0.5380841494,
0.1223287359,
0.6193107367,
1.142291069,
0.4209921658,
0.2628261149,
-0.1655914038,
0.1299928278,
-0.8310323358,
0.2372056246,
-0.2748759687,
-0.0760815367,
-0.253477335,
0.2639948428,
0.6075413227,
0.212288931,
0.0392189287,
0.4854836464,
0.076979056,
0.762067318,
-0.820304215,
-0.0064430763,
-0.5102040768,
-0.1096860394,
-0.0433470272,
-0.4589415491,
-0.4759888351,
-0.5210683942,
-0.1023933366,
-0.405932039,
-0.4365004301,
0.1922280788,
0.8042069077,
0.2368077189,
-0.5069677234,
-0.6936223507,
-0.6659520864,
1.0845073462,
-0.8522239923,
0.2833894789,
0.2807676196,
0.0007751223,
0.0935934484,
-0.7354000807,
-0.5874038935,
-0.0605277978,
0.2965638041,
0.0186799448,
-0.3528039157,
-0.1224647909,
0.1474707276,
0.552872777,
-0.0613396354,
0.51042521,
-0.6478912234,
0.1061027423,
1.1053123474,
0.0798065588,
0.3133814633,
-0.115143165,
-0.2731043994,
0.0120860953,
-1.3509347439,
0.1193463355,
1.0567983389,
0.0371732786,
-0.0029067693,
0.6243979931,
-0.0503851436,
0.123860985,
-0.0833076239,
0.0262472089,
0.100621812,
-0.5598026514,
-0.1280224174,
0.2720434368,
0.6195264459,
0.7998627424,
0.5506602526,
0.2507571578,
-0.3331392109,
-0.3832848668,
0.8145631552,
-0.587595284,
0.2847220302,
0.427077204,
-0.6884468794,
-0.4441252053,
0.0945618823,
-0.4246399403,
-0.6012497544,
-0.5924788713,
0.3204005063,
0.0446882881,
-0.4271073639,
-0.1263863295,
-0.2776539028,
0.6996306181,
0.0052688187,
-0.7127382755,
0.0157492924,
0.9946149588,
0.5201610327,
0.0421813689,
-0.1060652509,
-0.6745207906,
0.5974789262,
-0.642218709,
0.3407390416,
-0.3944822252,
-0.4398674071,
0.389601469,
-0.0558538362,
0.5828927755,
-0.4224960506,
0.7186414599,
-0.776791811,
-0.0302274339,
-0.3573805988,
-0.6526142955,
-0.1946168989,
0.076991871,
-0.5839768052,
0.5661782026,
-0.0433406755,
-0.5553242564,
0.5926212072,
-0.552650094,
-0.5803974271,
0.2378856242,
-0.3400894105,
-0.3747217357,
0.0099011166,
0.0938984156,
0.4801576138,
-0.217079699,
0.4398682415,
-0.015636703,
-0.1441547871,
0.0994373038,
-0.6256349683,
0.9799697995,
0.3922275901,
-0.4230622947,
0.0660160109,
-0.4208620191,
-0.0832276419,
-0.1371864825,
-0.4767506123,
-0.3419463933,
0.2956341803,
-0.1577282995,
0.1226507351,
0.1629643738,
-0.4198745191,
-0.3201240003,
0.1918256879,
0.7847576737,
1.1706545353,
0.3253782392,
0.5660489202,
-0.6449900866,
0.4236032665,
-0.2419010401,
0.4181278944,
-0.3224872351,
-0.2727528512,
-0.6983234286,
-0.1486621499,
-0.0687888265,
0.1697701812,
-0.2298625112,
0.6181232929,
-0.3944712579,
-0.459094137,
-0.7959208488,
0.2479872853,
0.135074228,
0.3861229122,
0.1375751197,
-0.2034460306,
-0.3482619226,
-0.9926725626,
-0.3156487644,
-0.0599163212,
-0.0862205997,
0.5076293349,
0.1700356305,
-0.1981280595,
0.7746392488,
0.0348842815,
-0.1204908192,
-0.2892660797,
0.1875353307,
0.0368502475,
0.6982960105,
0.3152140081,
-0.8285875916,
-0.335899353,
-0.2047037184,
-1.0189232826,
-0.158893615,
-0.2842736542,
-0.2350904197,
0.4340160787,
0.6495800018,
-0.5313425064,
0.4212836325,
0.5435598493,
0.0119749038,
0.3472548425,
-0.0547084734,
0.422111094,
-1.1009024382,
-0.0324938931,
0.0183917377,
-0.2183678746,
-0.408890456,
0.3374223411,
-0.2539936602,
0.0010504422,
-0.5733410716,
0.4381008446,
-0.5377026796,
-0.3213181496,
-0.3429918587,
0.0742307082,
0.2815285623,
-0.1334261298,
0.2081671059,
0.752189219,
0.5434404612,
-0.8066067696,
0.2410607934,
0.3600285053,
-0.4740977883,
0.7940795422,
-0.6367178559,
0.0687470958,
-0.2230278999,
0.2521555722,
-0.4194537699,
0.013523466,
0.0491834804,
-0.4581840932,
0.2615820169,
-0.1966498643,
-0.6770095825,
-0.0555395298,
-0.5638421178,
0.3571194112,
0.9789481163,
-0.3358156979,
0.3704103529,
0.7052512765,
-0.7328304648,
-0.6257089376,
-0.9277995229,
0.37603122,
-0.4260169268,
-0.9495864511,
0.1013412252,
0.0601519421,
-0.567278266,
0.117520161,
-0.0749479756,
0.0136242863,
0.1537816375,
-0.0130636273,
-0.0280562118,
-0.345451355,
-0.242999509,
0.2767423689,
0.0770692527,
0.3969226182,
-0.1692142487,
0.2902049124,
0.140532732,
-0.2075831443,
-0.5577731729,
0.8008853197,
0.3698244989,
-0.3759506047,
0.5016148686,
0.328946352,
-0.2518073022,
-0.267113328,
-0.635002315,
-0.270924896,
-0.592695415,
0.1350691468,
0.3645218611,
-0.9955272675,
0.3559592962,
0.1020556241,
0.5313709974,
0.6874918342,
0.7521594167,
-0.2927106023,
0.8905138969,
0.9646175504,
-0.0094576869,
0.2217691094,
-0.1086858138,
0.5945580006,
-0.8485592008,
-0.1028651148,
-0.5843650103,
-0.2281733304,
-0.954923749,
-0.1018474773,
0.4321151376,
-0.0829086602,
-0.5876895189,
0.1101936996,
-0.3817205131,
0.7865378261,
0.7924285531,
-0.2275449783,
0.6719178557,
-0.1963031143,
0.5297165513,
0.1178807095,
-0.559350729,
-1.1168903112,
0.8644999266,
0.6207998991,
0.8002001047,
0.2472541779,
0.612464726,
0.8226677179,
0.4716269374,
-0.6838032603,
0.3598560095,
-0.2400675863,
-0.799479425,
-0.1779860705,
-0.3347549736,
-0.6437650919,
-0.4159352481,
0.1740737706,
-0.7190278769,
0.2184745073,
-0.1799772084,
-0.303286761,
0.2933593392,
-0.6072874665,
0.4766865075,
-0.1587893516,
-0.6007245779,
-0.4755494297,
-0.6807307601,
0.4037084579,
-0.0846674591,
0.2646226287,
-0.0628339797,
-0.1230687276,
0.6675407887,
-0.280234158,
0.7761035562,
0.1512597799,
-0.3863385618,
0.7985965014,
0.0362365693,
0.2671428323,
0.2605355382,
-0.138741523,
0.3785721958,
-0.1049846858,
-0.0790725648,
0.1509425044,
0.739341259,
-0.7019388676,
-0.8282055259,
-0.3407864869,
-0.6346940994,
-0.0861490369,
0.3722335696,
0.3873947859,
0.3729585111,
0.1287147552,
0.5280358791,
0.7882183194,
-0.4588021636,
0.6033887267,
0.4455907643,
0.5125384331,
-0.2442543507,
0.7982578278,
-0.0886531323,
0.2447087169,
0.0483051874,
0.2461149544,
-0.49506253,
-0.6428949237,
-0.5666728616,
0.0215434022,
-0.9409821033,
-0.3692613244,
-0.4782290757,
-0.6866126657,
-0.3807036877,
-0.6327686906,
-0.3093452752,
0.0911480635,
-0.5177577734,
-0.1713397056,
0.3595522344,
0.9244760871,
-0.089627102,
0.0769192949,
-1.1494376659,
0.0421778969,
0.0259896908,
0.2645988762,
-0.1334943175,
-0.4763965011,
-0.0569951832,
0.1728851199,
-0.3690359592,
-0.2842753232,
0.1618793458,
-0.0602892637,
0.7776347399,
0.4527121186,
0.2522108555,
0.1589442641,
-0.6521440148,
1.085057497,
-0.0483248942,
-1.1799547672,
0.2511781752,
-0.7188178897,
-0.2803958058,
0.5947209001,
0.8363106847,
-0.5144520998,
-0.6468242407,
-0.6035329103,
-1.0395474434,
0.4037539959,
0.358433038,
0.8349861503,
0.0146497097,
0.1970169395,
0.2715800703,
0.6277467012,
-0.9138492346,
0.1275169849,
0.0427238569,
-0.362426728,
0.2443876565,
-0.2550053596,
-0.3109748662,
0.2215541899,
0.6768315434,
0.0435826965,
0.1643947661,
0.110570997,
-0.0450432561,
-0.1353493929,
0.2534514368,
0.4116295874,
0.9033219218,
0.2212203145,
-0.2265566587,
-0.5683597326,
-0.3011747897,
0.0404883176,
-0.1452652067,
-0.3326467574,
-0.5493291616,
0.2991326153,
0.2483682334,
-0.3162283599,
-0.8975761533,
0.7480354905,
0.10311497,
-0.276008904,
-0.4342925251,
-0.0188202038,
0.0710867941,
0.3722959757,
0.3407757282,
-0.244892478,
0.1925254166,
-0.6226677299,
0.3120650351,
0.3344324827,
-0.0279340018,
0.0686322376,
0.6567160487,
0.5763754249,
0.0237708706,
0.850399971,
-0.1605932266,
-0.1700579673,
0.787912488,
0.1204642355,
0.8912298083,
0.1804729551,
0.1032496765,
0.0063481592,
0.5955224037,
-0.0591219515,
0.3497582376,
0.028247783,
-0.8122034073,
-0.5238950253,
-0.5080683827,
-0.5246195197,
0.2850275636,
-0.5533168316,
0.2834874094,
-0.684880197,
-0.0069506131,
-0.0748435482,
-0.1413487643,
-0.354349941,
-0.0072513451,
0.382501632,
0.8906601071,
-0.4328151941,
0.2482502013,
0.2277850956,
-0.5834601521,
-0.7396783829,
0.1635892987,
-0.0099632218,
-0.7622365952,
0.4686365128,
0.2582086325,
-0.0418019406,
0.080144763,
-0.8075876236,
-0.6778214574,
1.2027618885,
0.0828364789,
-0.3386443853,
0.1024798006,
0.1831212044,
0.3556900322,
-0.5272119045,
-0.2692108154,
0.4236256182,
0.4055877626,
-0.0838052258,
-0.4702727497,
0.0154495863,
-0.1952224523,
-0.0675386563,
0.072764039,
-0.8785989285,
0.6443661451,
-0.1481886655,
-0.2431605458,
0.1396945566,
0.3153044879,
0.3241479099,
0.4127497673,
0.2012121081,
0.1778626591,
0.4383465648,
0.1758810729,
1.2197669744,
-0.4123093486,
-0.1530904621,
0.7384759188,
-0.4496787488,
0.7392184734,
0.4267434478,
0.2835142016,
0.3409436047,
0.6496456265,
-0.4319817126,
0.3865767419,
0.2884887457,
-0.2118726373,
0.0752516463,
-0.7334002852,
-0.201898545,
0.6243129969,
0.3162223697,
-0.7197897434,
0.1018737108,
-0.4416876435,
0.2968506515,
0.160329178,
-0.6800769567,
0.9452978373,
0.2184359282,
-0.7323194146,
0.0143569252,
0.2064844519,
0.5319219232,
-0.5216449499,
0.1236602291,
-0.1112559214,
-0.1241656318,
-0.1340858936,
-1.1638222933,
0.6218121052,
0.4977013767,
-0.0322875977,
-0.5764434338,
0.5584171414,
-0.1996459663,
-0.2198061049,
-0.0350015201,
0.4505269825,
-0.074033089,
0.0188900139,
-0.3370108306,
0.293135494,
-0.2170973122,
-0.2567380071,
0.1507853419,
0.2855315804,
-0.08792945,
0.5240917206,
0.7252574563,
0.0317429416,
0.1142589375,
0.1046746522,
0.8377469182,
-0.4045064151,
-0.6023170352,
-0.7360094786,
0.6465923786,
-0.1806173176,
-0.3687756658,
0.5806726813,
0.3226523101,
1.0900434256,
0.1179825217,
1.100343585,
-0.1666555256,
-0.0180433039,
-0.8613389134,
1.068448782,
-0.5238960981,
0.2680427134,
-0.0439574458,
-1.0311272144,
0.1411031783,
0.3481123447,
-0.1700956523,
0.4591898322,
0.4425885081,
0.5122615099,
0.1949837208,
0.3169929385,
0.1447208673,
0.1715541482,
0.4670660198,
0.164454788,
1.0820066929,
-0.1841129065,
0.4044761062,
-0.1671916693,
-0.1032087207,
0.1704601794,
-1.4434194565,
-0.499178201,
-0.4013172984,
-0.3060050011,
-0.1864426285,
0.0305489451,
0.7773765922,
0.6889837384,
-0.4493837059,
-0.2840586901,
-0.1610578746,
-0.1020741388,
-0.2029414773,
-0.2371988446,
-0.0554420166,
-0.1992292553,
-0.8677016497,
0.0705649182,
0.4085839391,
-0.1191992238,
-0.6002610326,
-0.0321156681,
-0.116776064,
0.4742617011,
0.6689346433,
0.2018076926,
-0.4226721227,
-0.3449878097,
-0.1359862089,
-0.2364562005,
0.0286304038,
1.0112472773,
-0.0832957923,
-0.0529621765,
0.4374517202,
1.1409916878,
-0.0348141454,
0.158635661,
0.9487676024,
-0.8493737578,
-0.1913205087,
0.7162556052,
0.2177420855,
0.5247272253,
-0.7957407832,
0.2848517001,
-0.1620847732,
-0.980276525,
-0.6395413876,
0.4032834172,
-0.7891172767,
-0.08075317,
1.4716910124,
-0.1335000247,
-0.0972929522,
-0.0189791545,
0.1433766186,
0.1179097965,
-0.5709280372,
0.7162291408,
0.4834749103,
0.0630003735,
-0.1977998763,
-0.7333475947,
0.5800555348,
-0.0784299225,
-0.9551581144,
0.2831775546,
0.7270668745,
0.2674871385,
-0.1515986174,
0.4876649678,
-0.4752422273,
0.2864004374,
-0.0609850474,
-0.1460537463,
-0.0599442944,
-0.3552052379,
-0.1746823192,
-0.2150076032,
0.0696172193,
0.2148793489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03500v1 | Towards Adaptable and Interactive Image Captioning with Data Augmentation and Episodic Memory | 2023-06-06T08:38:10 | 2023-06-06T08:38:10 | Aliki Anagnostopoulou, Mareike Hartmann, Daniel Sonntag | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Interactive machine learning (IML) is a beneficial learning paradigm in cases
of limited data availability, as human feedback is incrementally integrated
into the training process. In this paper, we present an IML pipeline for image
captioning which allows us to incrementally adapt a pre-trained image
captioning model to a new data distribution based on user input. In order to
incorporate user input into the model, we explore the use of a combination of
simple data augmentation methods to obtain larger data batches for each newly
annotated data instance and implement continual learning methods to prevent
catastrophic forgetting from repeated updates. For our experiments, we split a
domain-specific image captioning dataset, namely VizWiz, into non-overlapping
parts to simulate an incremental input flow for continually adapting the model
to new data. We find that, while data augmentation worsens results, even when
relatively small amounts of data are available, episodic memory is an effective
strategy to retain knowledge from previously seen clusters. | [
-0.4251770079,
-0.6173039079,
0.3361965716,
0.0631414801,
-0.4619902372,
0.2288958132,
-0.0786168128,
-0.1865883172,
-0.0677100867,
0.5718072057,
-0.5493171215,
-0.2923144996,
-0.4041952789,
0.1186552197,
-0.1638820767,
0.8054300547,
-0.3787949681,
0.1008961797,
-0.6905287504,
-0.470357269,
-0.7258871198,
-0.5578207374,
-0.577896297,
-0.081105344,
0.4164282978,
0.725944519,
0.7610823512,
0.7117672563,
0.3983452022,
0.1839387715,
0.5332707167,
0.5727614164,
-0.4017442465,
0.3151941597,
-0.051239647,
-0.7369297743,
0.3166220784,
-0.2462155521,
0.5983965397,
0.509886682,
-0.2777004242,
-0.150906533,
-0.138431713,
0.6418907046,
-0.408033371,
0.3905632496,
-0.7722135186,
0.5021875501,
0.185078308,
-0.6819531918,
-0.5493092537,
-0.0334450938,
0.2372545898,
-0.9517302513,
-0.1459334791,
0.4205162823,
0.7580933571,
0.7000924349,
0.2425281554,
-0.3042848408,
-0.7075979114,
0.6384198666,
-0.5418968201,
0.1550762206,
0.2470185608,
0.585519731,
0.1844166368,
-0.9301990867,
-0.5915011764,
-0.4404940903,
0.017871106,
0.359097749,
-0.0428005606,
-0.1130795926,
0.2917519808,
0.0740943104,
-0.0993838012,
0.2211086005,
-0.2551457584,
-0.0099866865,
0.3989412487,
0.3753564656,
0.5360687375,
0.2559207678,
-0.5426504016,
-0.1567068696,
-0.7658477426,
0.06562154,
0.1266609579,
0.0682972595,
-0.1965995878,
0.5497475863,
-0.022441227,
0.7616685033,
0.1204952672,
0.3002991974,
0.2021053135,
-0.0058272644,
-0.0615718439,
0.0522855893,
0.4167860746,
0.2514250875,
0.3614724576,
-0.1800607741,
0.0180354472,
-0.3661526442,
0.6510862708,
-0.7773273587,
-0.6383985281,
0.1107572094,
-0.2090423256,
-0.1551152915,
0.365033716,
-0.4864446819,
-0.4485621154,
-0.5175483823,
0.5995202661,
-0.5350725055,
0.4695368111,
-0.3063143492,
-0.0376940258,
0.0953275412,
0.8591067195,
-0.7203705907,
0.2230092287,
0.0567858182,
0.947535038,
-0.4137812555,
-0.4417907596,
-0.7971075773,
0.3436284661,
-0.1709382981,
0.8339653015,
-0.7292096615,
0.0546643697,
-0.0595786311,
0.1738745868,
-0.2806026638,
-0.7642295957,
-0.0204252675,
-0.6678159237,
0.2416701466,
0.3144128025,
-0.6862378716,
-0.4275149107,
0.2144523859,
-0.7345274091,
0.4954223633,
0.3036870658,
-0.7162409425,
0.5086042881,
-1.0194476843,
-0.3291157782,
0.3208992183,
-0.2493311614,
-0.9210447669,
-0.0458806232,
0.6078571677,
0.5064619184,
0.1449762732,
-0.1278079003,
-0.5516836643,
-0.3971404433,
0.6131255031,
-0.4221759737,
0.2946999371,
0.0934389606,
0.0826070309,
0.2767120898,
-0.3669493496,
-0.1135556847,
0.0474319868,
-0.4129216671,
-0.1192481592,
0.0949630737,
-0.0761220306,
0.1724007279,
0.0175868105,
-0.4221485257,
0.3986397982,
0.1539909393,
0.5591391325,
0.7005957365,
0.3984259367,
0.2346415967,
-0.5691173077,
0.6068451405,
0.6168036461,
0.1726857573,
-1.1170091629,
-0.2304015011,
-0.8953245282,
-0.4432318509,
0.394231528,
0.7046307325,
-1.2328193188,
0.1228643134,
-0.3454431891,
-0.1297302395,
-0.6673698425,
0.2362852544,
-0.1314937472,
0.4463308454,
0.3365992308,
-0.6580631137,
-0.4139479995,
-0.6816927195,
0.2351808548,
0.0448764004,
-0.1761908084,
0.5917993784,
0.1225639209,
-0.1301881522,
0.7762428522,
-0.3030166328,
-0.239961952,
0.0052405098,
0.1353575438,
-0.0910435766,
0.5135976672,
0.2829159796,
-0.8174600005,
-0.6286990047,
0.2235139906,
-1.0727534294,
0.2081121951,
-0.6722849011,
0.0642789379,
0.1416029781,
0.6318995953,
-0.3708518147,
0.431763947,
0.0935289189,
0.0038460186,
0.3055183887,
-0.5532081723,
0.2800913453,
-0.6506403685,
-0.3170310855,
-0.0978518352,
-0.4277884066,
-0.2518535256,
0.1146009862,
0.2149829566,
-0.1871252358,
-0.5426433682,
0.2021474987,
-0.5499430895,
0.0658593774,
-0.218506217,
-0.2830307782,
-0.1910753697,
0.6446351409,
0.2115970254,
0.606621325,
0.9267624021,
-0.5073724389,
0.460795939,
0.3879565001,
-0.4519223869,
0.6401481628,
-0.3216884136,
0.2532586157,
-0.4811737239,
0.0694118589,
-1.1366630793,
-0.462241441,
0.247835815,
-0.2724962831,
0.5758538842,
-0.2791834772,
-0.5729943514,
-0.218083024,
-0.2479254454,
-0.0900558606,
0.6315299869,
-0.8600211143,
0.5410341024,
0.2630912662,
-0.4408493638,
-0.0600397326,
-0.5742397904,
0.3417496979,
-0.5229197145,
-0.4504045546,
0.3051363826,
-0.1458912194,
0.0706761181,
0.1738128066,
0.4385113418,
-0.2030045092,
-0.0707049221,
0.4970422387,
0.4890423715,
-0.0458978862,
0.2233915478,
0.2683624327,
0.0279743709,
-0.2857572734,
-0.378207773,
0.3102457523,
-0.0298230257,
-0.4974111319,
-0.6431859136,
0.2332935333,
0.6371286511,
0.0831950009,
0.7155118585,
0.5621647239,
-0.3182584047,
-0.134120211,
-0.1581881344,
-0.2568113208,
-0.4250783622,
0.2702853382,
-0.2600826919,
-0.8809725642,
0.4068158269,
-0.306086123,
0.2559680641,
0.0224218648,
0.5479007363,
-0.8245720863,
0.7752013206,
0.5492716432,
0.167554006,
0.6517252326,
-0.1350950599,
-0.0402059294,
-0.759493351,
0.0356290713,
0.2950369418,
-0.4234478474,
-0.2046497017,
-0.4402501881,
0.5068171024,
-0.0208116099,
-0.1872229129,
0.0261217188,
-0.3320131302,
0.4064594209,
0.5279889703,
0.5295959711,
0.2274168581,
0.5167821646,
0.1586333364,
-0.3640729189,
-0.8437547088,
-0.3150250018,
1.1182137728,
0.3569888771,
0.838522315,
-0.2443659604,
0.3168426454,
0.8197075129,
0.6333084106,
-0.6290037036,
0.1750321984,
0.0637180507,
-0.1206323206,
-0.3493541479,
-0.0844353884,
-0.8416989446,
0.0977424607,
-0.1913061589,
-0.4734687805,
-0.0839910433,
0.3749168217,
-0.3881494701,
0.4202327132,
-0.6501848102,
0.6325371265,
-0.2971716523,
-0.496286422,
-0.107893616,
-0.7854711413,
0.0142331533,
-0.2292819917,
0.0436069071,
0.292554915,
-0.2450685799,
0.3307883739,
-0.6320961118,
0.8269358277,
-0.4052053094,
0.6422428489,
0.5846622586,
-0.1674170792,
0.4843786359,
-0.1550077498,
0.1887716204,
-0.0133527722,
-0.2132383883,
-0.3579280376,
-0.7076992393,
0.5805164576,
-0.7318887115,
-0.2709972262,
-0.0886108726,
-0.8291757703,
-0.1915127933,
-0.2045914829,
0.0357607305,
0.3433300853,
0.2715967596,
0.3239873052,
0.6565970182,
-0.4846574962,
0.4875722528,
0.2934674919,
-0.146502167,
-0.6745343804,
0.9708196521,
0.3570018709,
0.2470297962,
0.3829143047,
-0.0204922985,
-0.1610477418,
-0.6978898048,
-0.985226512,
-0.1204365641,
-0.8106707931,
-0.119937174,
-0.7735345364,
-0.251927793,
0.2603596747,
-0.392902106,
-0.006314842,
-0.5493597388,
-0.3649025857,
-0.104838632,
0.6355769634,
0.3214668334,
0.0438609868,
0.495116204,
-0.754484117,
0.159713462,
0.3013829887,
0.1599007547,
0.0955511928,
-0.8679183722,
-0.4249479175,
-0.1668278426,
-0.3978144526,
-0.5714679956,
0.4553162158,
0.5351983905,
0.5415011644,
0.4566647112,
0.0112515287,
0.6061762571,
-0.5089348555,
0.6375877261,
0.2142980248,
-0.3530544937,
0.3344492614,
-0.2748379111,
0.546978116,
0.5551653504,
0.5055341125,
-0.3701710105,
-0.1975714564,
-0.4594272971,
-0.8396716714,
0.5268676281,
-0.073006399,
0.3994180858,
0.436378032,
0.4460023642,
0.5104514956,
0.4117750823,
-0.6962205172,
-0.1556203812,
-0.1794178039,
-0.4071861506,
0.3489876986,
0.1990538538,
0.031336356,
-0.5775789022,
0.5662516952,
-0.2146061361,
0.2634374201,
0.0181924757,
-0.4323505461,
-0.0776828751,
-0.0844690055,
0.1008442342,
0.5885171294,
-0.0148516996,
0.0762562081,
0.200053215,
-0.4943701029,
0.1769625545,
0.149807319,
-0.4274629354,
-0.1125866026,
0.2793004811,
1.1153893471,
0.1773017794,
-0.8438244462,
0.2047541738,
0.080991745,
-0.0832118839,
-0.6259095669,
0.099358134,
-0.0061826017,
-0.0109495129,
0.5346630812,
0.3441006839,
-0.1370570362,
-0.6256966591,
0.6438186169,
0.0755908191,
-0.8812490702,
-0.0001692895,
0.74523139,
-0.0842488557,
-0.1776987612,
0.9592508674,
-0.0923702642,
-0.3350477517,
0.5608695745,
0.3671570122,
0.5695608258,
-0.0273269042,
0.2149893045,
0.3910390139,
0.3224467635,
0.3747937083,
0.130690977,
-0.1513554752,
-0.5549399257,
-0.3417296708,
-0.2379764318,
-0.5741667151,
-0.0918155462,
-0.4369667172,
0.2847577333,
-0.7028154731,
0.2659400403,
-0.0740935728,
-0.4871451259,
-0.835847795,
0.2189817429,
0.2367473543,
0.6644755602,
-0.6640357375,
0.8881561756,
0.69270432,
-0.7075964808,
-0.3701635003,
-0.1843441278,
-0.2727459371,
-0.8341853619,
0.2559787631,
0.4855588675,
0.4894706607,
0.2759301662,
-1.0350236893,
-0.5774086118,
1.2137718201,
0.0371875688,
-0.3837008774,
0.5229641199,
0.1600274742,
0.385273397,
-0.8479686379,
0.2409666926,
0.1957998127,
0.5150567889,
0.3083461225,
-0.3381717205,
-0.1435249001,
-0.3602097034,
-0.1242856309,
-0.1026745513,
-0.3554771543,
0.6141696572,
-0.6864395142,
-0.2417595685,
0.0437340587,
0.7779482603,
0.1225430369,
0.4548816085,
0.6804698706,
0.6459599137,
0.653771162,
-0.1187843978,
1.0972496271,
0.0704668313,
-0.0823148564,
1.2939710617,
-0.2588355243,
0.7497442365,
0.6069947481,
-0.3463436365,
0.7175788879,
0.9042804837,
-0.4627766013,
0.8343254328,
0.2070242316,
-0.2231293768,
-0.3289909959,
-0.1735226363,
0.1254943758,
0.0746938139,
0.4948743582,
-0.4284721017,
-0.0454553887,
0.5715879798,
-0.2148931921,
0.0259604063,
-0.3852867186,
0.9076527357,
-0.0816059411,
-0.593842864,
0.4222714603,
-0.3123794496,
0.3645344973,
-0.5478111506,
-0.4605429173,
0.0169392843,
-0.049070701,
-0.353867203,
-0.965795517,
0.2672474086,
-0.1762998849,
-0.193500787,
0.1751959026,
0.5283949971,
-0.5656781197,
-0.4791603684,
-0.2237257063,
0.3602897525,
0.281549722,
0.0055685304,
-0.6889401078,
0.1040034145,
0.1022763103,
-0.0650185719,
0.3465003967,
0.173529014,
-0.1991378367,
0.9096934795,
0.7112865448,
-0.2293866873,
0.3950380683,
0.0064350124,
0.798686564,
-0.3651726842,
-0.5751029849,
-0.642914176,
0.8875316978,
-0.2059821784,
0.2920028567,
0.578584671,
0.389031291,
0.7474264503,
-0.4634011686,
1.3293120861,
-0.1165075451,
0.1942848116,
-0.6170075536,
0.5311475396,
-0.251054585,
0.1458374113,
-0.0102718808,
-0.7955707312,
-0.4180731475,
0.4142525196,
-0.294917196,
-0.1882538944,
0.4902333915,
0.4523163438,
-0.3539449871,
0.0776544884,
0.299580127,
0.1479147077,
0.1051100194,
0.493065089,
1.0102703571,
-0.2064539641,
0.2375550568,
-0.3522292972,
-0.1733312756,
-0.1657175571,
-0.8274445534,
-0.6524250507,
-0.6807528734,
-0.668143034,
0.0520419218,
-0.018908089,
0.9050552249,
0.7714037895,
-0.8208975792,
0.080868341,
-0.0695073158,
-0.1160502434,
-0.314106971,
-0.2594022155,
0.3695703149,
-0.3345332444,
-0.6637110114,
0.0258815084,
0.639293015,
0.195530802,
-0.3001549244,
-0.049892433,
0.0391272418,
0.0754869878,
0.6403169036,
0.4527528882,
-0.3397538364,
-0.2958133221,
-0.2562829256,
0.3615091145,
0.5650182962,
0.5172768831,
-0.8024940491,
1.1177368164,
0.0562612973,
0.9791172147,
0.6676330566,
0.2349395305,
0.4438178837,
-0.4872223437,
0.2122327536,
0.0180791579,
0.3110717833,
0.7505685091,
-0.4173505604,
0.4865860045,
-0.0098304357,
-0.334936738,
-0.4685260653,
-0.0361345559,
-1.0773396492,
-0.1799682379,
0.5346544385,
-0.5433434844,
-0.0573606566,
-0.1668354571,
-0.3827744722,
-0.1138104349,
-0.1579863578,
0.8565476537,
0.6226648688,
-0.4250972271,
-0.7154730558,
-0.5510959029,
0.0207704939,
0.0208413061,
-1.1410229206,
-0.2027159035,
0.699177444,
0.1931963265,
-0.1048815474,
0.262485832,
-0.2632746994,
0.3572954535,
-0.0772876889,
0.0397091322,
-0.4513958097,
-0.5198218822,
-0.3812220395,
0.2063661069,
0.1311284006,
-0.4505142868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03491v1 | SciCap+: A Knowledge Augmented Dataset to Study the Challenges of Scientific Figure Captioning | 2023-06-06T08:16:16 | 2023-06-06T08:16:16 | Zhishen Yang, Raj Dabre, Hideki Tanaka, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In scholarly documents, figures provide a straightforward way of
communicating scientific findings to readers. Automating figure caption
generation helps move model understandings of scientific documents beyond text
and will help authors write informative captions that facilitate communicating
scientific findings. Unlike previous studies, we reframe scientific figure
captioning as a knowledge-augmented image captioning task that models need to
utilize knowledge embedded across modalities for caption generation. To this
end, we extended the large-scale SciCap
dataset~\cite{hsu-etal-2021-scicap-generating} to SciCap+ which includes
mention-paragraphs (paragraphs mentioning figures) and OCR tokens. Then, we
conduct experiments with the M4C-Captioner (a multimodal transformer-based
model with a pointer network) as a baseline for our study. Our results indicate
that mention-paragraphs serves as additional context knowledge, which
significantly boosts the automatic standard image caption evaluation scores
compared to the figure-only baselines. Human evaluations further reveal the
challenges of generating figure captions that are informative to readers. The
code and SciCap+ dataset will be publicly available at
https://github.com/ZhishenYang/scientific_figure_captioning_dataset | [
-0.1811049283,
-0.0183787793,
0.3570473492,
0.1093372479,
-0.444065541,
0.3035733998,
0.2317680418,
-0.872630477,
0.2874296904,
0.2115326673,
-0.4603605568,
-0.2090157121,
-0.6336756349,
0.6004980206,
-0.2020371854,
0.7388029099,
-0.1169872284,
0.3327434361,
-0.9259479642,
-0.0342047215,
-0.3276766539,
-0.191756025,
-0.4035592675,
0.195478797,
0.5946655869,
0.3264912069,
0.5291511416,
0.8267415166,
0.859664619,
0.1962385625,
0.3890441656,
0.5906409025,
-0.2790516913,
0.1437593102,
0.036085669,
-0.6073483229,
-0.1178893372,
0.2470405847,
0.6910962462,
0.5551227331,
0.5177732706,
-0.0446876101,
-0.5138880014,
0.4412916303,
-0.4167048633,
0.8165488839,
-0.6048589349,
0.3039490283,
-0.1851745099,
-0.5113652945,
-0.4469060302,
-0.0606468581,
0.1765414327,
-1.0478694439,
0.5454829335,
0.7812165022,
0.9507485032,
0.1900892407,
-0.1376479119,
-0.3459760249,
-0.1299729496,
0.6771789789,
-0.3572492003,
0.1336175054,
0.1425219029,
0.3101873696,
0.1049127877,
-0.7572285533,
-0.6579012871,
-0.3367126882,
-0.3749486506,
0.171218127,
-0.1579227597,
-0.3044080138,
0.524929285,
0.1392012089,
-0.2370300293,
-0.1016592383,
-1.09621346,
-0.3345115483,
0.6005449891,
0.0517216884,
0.4868873358,
-0.4330067933,
-0.474386692,
-0.3271816969,
-1.0284830332,
-0.0814023912,
0.0005231976,
0.1219139919,
0.0849002674,
0.8630313873,
0.1102370322,
0.5145205259,
0.00162994,
0.2403761744,
0.3876936734,
-0.4386349022,
0.2075951993,
0.2289031744,
0.8481335044,
0.557949543,
0.0190952867,
0.01689687,
0.2117861956,
-0.0470011979,
0.1640876532,
-0.9053647518,
-0.3906885087,
-0.0346810892,
-0.0590626821,
-0.4287071526,
0.1802812815,
-0.4642243385,
-0.7116258144,
-0.3775875866,
0.2404456884,
-0.3045445979,
0.2901419997,
-0.1138597429,
-0.4675287604,
-0.0691898614,
0.6394585371,
-0.4727544188,
0.0433653072,
0.2853707075,
1.0267173052,
-0.4473245442,
-0.4958474934,
-0.4355691373,
0.4153008759,
-0.2395591438,
1.1064807177,
-0.518335402,
-0.0932976529,
-0.3054312766,
0.2001583874,
-0.2146027833,
-0.0745097995,
0.3528113663,
-0.5788911581,
0.3807436526,
-0.6068648696,
-0.4920015037,
-0.1801836938,
0.0238656029,
-1.0302163363,
0.3385355473,
0.0650225505,
-0.9606978893,
0.7906191349,
-1.1801834106,
-0.4714052379,
0.4963454008,
-0.523819983,
-0.4351183474,
-0.1199025661,
0.5272428989,
0.6222984791,
-0.2794438899,
0.2009400129,
-0.1156570166,
-0.2108079642,
0.4162097573,
-0.0587313958,
0.2355890721,
0.1363015026,
-0.2257625759,
0.3686269224,
-0.2775574625,
-0.4829708636,
0.3623767793,
0.2543419302,
-0.2081706524,
0.0422804058,
-0.0472880602,
0.2001868486,
0.1776188016,
-0.8347530961,
0.3162739277,
0.1612721086,
0.895421505,
0.3438636065,
0.1852779984,
0.3459506035,
-0.4099148214,
0.3573030829,
0.0866870657,
0.128951028,
-0.7101371884,
-0.5682352781,
-0.3490456343,
-0.5961813927,
0.2619301379,
0.1877739429,
-0.903785646,
0.2170172632,
-0.4160860479,
-0.391246736,
-0.463054955,
-0.1925286651,
0.2541229129,
0.884008348,
0.3413154483,
-0.2817171812,
-0.478451848,
-0.9208474159,
0.3812399209,
-0.1413917691,
-0.0462685339,
0.5174129605,
0.7118879557,
0.1012965515,
0.7832834125,
-0.7371316552,
-0.2518476248,
-0.0319338851,
0.2150689811,
-0.1142774895,
0.4944566488,
0.4817607403,
-0.9627843499,
-0.2900100648,
-0.2277517915,
-0.8510516286,
0.1214453876,
-0.4099149406,
-0.0629558414,
0.1468849927,
0.6817780137,
-0.9719476104,
0.1980740279,
0.1235017031,
-0.258710742,
0.9760427475,
-0.1970479041,
0.6148869991,
-0.6893368363,
0.2885277867,
-0.0510567985,
0.0219817497,
-0.2195694298,
0.1892357618,
0.0979912058,
-0.3791367412,
-0.5026589036,
0.3022657633,
-0.6178273559,
-0.1362850219,
0.0101689259,
0.1405538321,
0.5261263251,
0.1634914428,
0.5677841902,
1.0128031969,
0.6305324435,
-0.224420324,
0.3067883849,
0.6084507108,
-0.5274728537,
0.5075746179,
-0.9260377288,
-0.1470772028,
-0.3934334517,
0.2623963356,
-0.9798941612,
-0.6478631496,
0.3828785419,
-0.2824324369,
0.5341418982,
0.3516710401,
-0.5486221313,
-0.46991992,
-0.4434145093,
0.3787419796,
-0.0349499024,
-0.4184125662,
0.2514151335,
0.2059212476,
-0.3730060458,
-0.4506038725,
-0.56121701,
0.2667832971,
-0.0925746486,
-0.6425346732,
0.368948251,
-0.2985364497,
0.1184619144,
-0.1388815045,
-0.0903230757,
0.1514749527,
-0.2792247534,
0.3693362176,
0.4434589148,
0.1426228434,
0.2406186014,
0.2262857854,
0.0765354559,
0.1260419339,
0.0958854556,
0.2702314258,
-0.3189422488,
-0.5535749793,
-0.3256940544,
0.276801616,
0.7516949773,
-0.1715137362,
0.3796080351,
0.4410611093,
-0.2748783231,
0.4932181537,
-0.3085548282,
-0.3755334318,
-0.385832727,
0.3894619942,
-0.2350030094,
-0.8550424576,
0.450222522,
0.0583754554,
0.2673840821,
0.6530492306,
-0.0206839759,
-0.5001182556,
0.5858838558,
0.2024878561,
0.1073491424,
0.0726633891,
-0.2106784582,
0.1099100932,
-0.7881731987,
-0.5780879855,
-0.4241850376,
-0.2111288607,
-0.060490787,
-0.7256554961,
0.3460178375,
0.0175318271,
-0.0925041884,
0.626809597,
-0.7986844778,
0.3799791932,
0.4453161359,
0.1991046518,
0.3650633991,
0.3789829016,
0.1643393189,
-0.3110248446,
-0.7780765891,
-0.3894112408,
0.8536223769,
0.1778999865,
0.4718666971,
-0.4451163411,
0.2465164214,
0.6454319358,
0.3778986037,
-0.7109938264,
0.3585203588,
0.175409466,
-0.4401295483,
-0.4512759447,
-0.312174052,
-0.8955700994,
0.0242492184,
-0.3922314346,
-0.1467042118,
0.3308793604,
0.1323328912,
-0.2975732088,
0.0875381976,
-0.6406401396,
0.6933488846,
-0.246589765,
-0.1727685928,
-0.0124846427,
-0.8785039783,
0.2349794805,
-0.2235653102,
0.3456536531,
0.0418770164,
-0.1182850823,
0.79773736,
-0.0907613561,
0.8157439232,
-0.0657981187,
0.2590544522,
0.425603658,
0.0300466437,
0.4046642184,
0.0799723417,
0.1244778186,
0.3330680132,
0.174597621,
-0.4534212947,
-0.4351507127,
0.5881935358,
-0.6436294913,
-0.358345598,
-0.5730000734,
-1.094894886,
0.059677951,
0.2341347486,
0.3050408363,
0.400715977,
0.2068925053,
0.2933729887,
0.6175162196,
-0.1507121623,
0.2304701656,
0.4790475667,
0.1219053864,
-0.5619545579,
0.8758141398,
0.0958584026,
0.1131268218,
0.4695308208,
0.1231607646,
-0.2968914807,
-0.4657634795,
-0.6441749334,
0.407233566,
-0.6493467093,
-0.6063854098,
-0.5558159947,
-0.0326131545,
-0.3535396457,
-0.2977586687,
0.0040771938,
-0.6609909534,
-0.5602739453,
-0.2094544023,
0.5187023282,
0.55291152,
0.1132945865,
0.1221033037,
-0.6219896078,
0.1854320318,
0.1097980365,
0.0176923815,
-0.2476775646,
-0.2508606613,
0.0214317329,
-0.0490095913,
-0.0903107226,
-0.5918272138,
0.2964795828,
0.4360463619,
0.3112075329,
0.4765483439,
0.0013958125,
0.6243459582,
-0.7681921721,
0.9492824078,
0.5334154963,
-0.6124014854,
0.2629467547,
-0.3345776796,
0.2050889432,
0.5038846135,
0.7104562521,
-0.1687679738,
-0.3009009659,
-0.6192534566,
-0.6595081091,
0.3750106692,
0.1721265316,
0.0381130688,
-0.0580989569,
0.3026748002,
0.3507592678,
0.651042521,
-0.6784072518,
0.166389972,
-0.3848431706,
0.0210381914,
-0.0918424577,
-0.0634911656,
-0.3560637534,
-0.4628927708,
0.3031525314,
-0.3175419271,
0.5244841576,
0.4088840485,
-0.1620801538,
-0.2610759735,
-0.1463243216,
0.9920584559,
0.8372793198,
-0.0929582492,
0.1604659557,
-0.3724231124,
-0.5163424611,
-0.4142297804,
0.3235851824,
-0.270242095,
-0.0668978691,
0.6150067449,
0.8206880689,
0.2184935212,
-0.7872312069,
0.3696646392,
0.1850911528,
-0.5820795894,
-0.1452316046,
-0.1313895434,
0.0086025186,
-0.023620218,
0.7595991492,
0.4670880437,
0.1599310488,
-0.2328226268,
0.396240294,
0.3400388956,
-0.4039031863,
-0.3139919937,
0.751326859,
0.0747425482,
0.4304664731,
0.3413979411,
-0.1782668829,
-0.4214692116,
0.5982681513,
0.5347718,
0.1175513566,
0.1899217218,
0.4423291981,
0.4424964786,
0.3745988011,
0.1010708287,
0.1630630344,
-0.1203661785,
-0.3258176148,
-0.7267349958,
-0.3283603489,
-0.6058460474,
-0.164870739,
-0.3980833292,
0.1502734721,
-0.2779420614,
0.1249191016,
0.3716618419,
0.0530630983,
-0.5292391777,
0.0218710676,
-0.1371071488,
0.9135097265,
-1.0378987789,
0.3675272167,
0.7220973372,
-0.7064446807,
-0.539947927,
-0.7092782855,
-0.4185498357,
-0.7108209133,
0.6906058192,
0.2517352998,
0.1359677017,
-0.2319111824,
-1.2259315252,
-0.9074485898,
1.3729538918,
0.2986166477,
-0.6029574871,
0.1487927139,
0.150582701,
0.5031632781,
-0.8031125665,
0.2446540594,
0.0644850135,
0.666271925,
0.6792701483,
-0.4735608399,
0.374864161,
-0.5143597722,
-0.4162910283,
-0.1742043644,
-0.476626277,
0.6427156925,
-0.5294414759,
-0.1159152091,
0.0269631445,
0.8134638667,
0.5845216513,
0.4651466608,
0.396217674,
0.0454245135,
0.7797763348,
-0.1679241359,
0.9625877738,
-0.1448360682,
-0.1736224294,
1.0640586615,
-0.3643873036,
0.4860144258,
0.7916541696,
-0.0249556508,
0.537948668,
0.5262029171,
-0.7620027065,
0.5128499269,
0.2096886188,
-0.0321825817,
-0.0663232133,
-0.4978108406,
-0.4228614271,
0.0442954376,
0.5168543458,
-0.5214886665,
-0.0099675376,
0.2276884913,
-0.0330388173,
-0.0051017771,
-0.2599853575,
0.3957411051,
-0.0278469678,
-0.2976320088,
0.2917818725,
-0.4635832608,
0.4467110336,
-0.5248357058,
-0.4047398567,
0.1988054663,
-0.533362329,
-0.3475708961,
-0.9052767754,
0.263045907,
-0.1505828798,
-0.4121929705,
-0.076492317,
0.7911405563,
-0.4630604684,
-0.4775393903,
-0.5424185991,
0.1050599366,
0.5845749378,
-0.0951502547,
-0.5637334585,
0.0846556574,
-0.0315968804,
0.10498368,
0.2590566576,
0.0761144385,
-0.339604497,
0.6899020076,
0.7809678316,
-0.005210015,
-0.143506676,
0.1864705384,
0.8819587231,
-0.1632938236,
-0.0894846842,
-0.1285518706,
0.6053902507,
-0.4560133219,
0.1343459338,
0.8259871006,
0.6570301056,
0.3480658233,
-0.7594450712,
0.7994773984,
-0.3488280475,
0.1386603266,
-0.1007083729,
0.9960569143,
-0.2405514419,
-0.092647247,
-0.3230397105,
-0.6248724461,
-0.7388066053,
0.4777863026,
-0.3874146938,
-0.4090240896,
0.7700064778,
0.4770094752,
0.0554016046,
0.1857937574,
0.0038276755,
-0.1531732976,
0.323358655,
0.1489548683,
0.5006411672,
-0.5010637045,
0.4636882842,
-0.275876224,
-0.1064101681,
0.1531365663,
-1.2472850084,
-0.9642984271,
-0.6477852464,
-0.7736288309,
0.0313428901,
-0.1933165789,
0.6474786997,
0.5830875635,
-1.0161783695,
0.1705952734,
-0.1147051603,
-0.1623911262,
-0.2132821381,
-0.2468098104,
0.9177947044,
-0.3328585029,
-0.5140442848,
0.4062212706,
0.1720125675,
0.1293257475,
-0.2264578491,
0.0174439102,
-0.0555044562,
-0.1024837643,
0.6121740937,
0.3984957933,
-0.3007770777,
-0.2148184925,
0.2741419971,
0.0947685912,
0.1060074568,
0.8394209146,
-0.4889897704,
0.7027839422,
0.3982385695,
0.2586866617,
0.5662891269,
0.0327120386,
0.5002687573,
-0.7331400514,
0.0504736938,
0.2197701186,
0.4764374793,
0.5733810663,
-0.5326928496,
0.3706173599,
0.3409851491,
-0.4776682854,
-0.8135693669,
0.0178102944,
-1.3309772015,
-0.069524467,
0.6026389003,
-0.3719858229,
-0.2477482706,
0.0805237889,
-0.4972892404,
0.0289853681,
-0.5191877484,
0.8347784877,
0.4131596684,
-0.1776383519,
-0.4239771366,
-0.270716399,
0.535398066,
-0.0606435984,
-1.0150752068,
0.0135106919,
0.8775919676,
0.2097386271,
0.8032884002,
0.0149336746,
-0.4607065022,
0.5005490184,
-0.0386606157,
0.3684619963,
-0.8849070668,
-0.5676928163,
0.1837783605,
0.3977315426,
-0.1788837612,
0.0728274435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03476v1 | Putting Humans in the Image Captioning Loop | 2023-06-06T07:50:46 | 2023-06-06T07:50:46 | Aliki Anagnostopoulou, Mareike Hartmann, Daniel Sonntag | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Image Captioning (IC) models can highly benefit from human feedback in the
training process, especially in cases where data is limited. We present
work-in-progress on adapting an IC system to integrate human feedback, with the
goal to make it easily adaptable to user-specific data. Our approach builds on
a base IC model pre-trained on the MS COCO dataset, which generates captions
for unseen images. The user will then be able to offer feedback on the image
and the generated/predicted caption, which will be augmented to create
additional training instances for the adaptation of the model. The additional
instances are integrated into the model using step-wise updates, and a sparse
memory replay component is used to avoid catastrophic forgetting. We hope that
this approach, while leading to improved results, will also result in
customizable IC models. | [
-0.3549232483,
0.2319833934,
0.198841989,
0.2887073457,
-0.6395387053,
0.3228957057,
-0.0516190045,
-0.6364424825,
-0.0772421733,
0.6372315884,
-0.2613211572,
-0.3280980885,
-0.2551116943,
0.3125489652,
-0.3452045023,
0.9523837566,
-0.3311046064,
0.347722739,
-0.5092107654,
-0.1727697104,
-0.9311692715,
-0.6401639581,
-0.5316329598,
-0.1830306649,
0.562066555,
0.9759431481,
0.4763990045,
0.5810989141,
0.6369448304,
0.1240004003,
0.5353894234,
0.3330654204,
-0.3333140016,
-0.3954157233,
-0.3131072819,
-0.6481109262,
-0.2240908742,
0.0907524005,
0.2539665997,
0.5878447294,
-0.1609535813,
-0.0974433571,
0.0653825626,
0.6814011931,
-0.4835007191,
0.2695110738,
-0.563498795,
0.2568697929,
0.3313013613,
-0.4050780535,
-0.6000468731,
-0.1169890538,
0.3746455312,
-0.5950175524,
0.313010782,
0.5819693208,
0.6424766779,
0.1610327512,
0.2629555166,
-0.3103050292,
-0.7557047606,
0.6795319319,
-0.4649815857,
-0.0168322828,
0.2837693393,
0.4294594526,
0.1362258792,
-0.581615746,
-0.3120455444,
-0.6171421409,
0.0150581142,
0.2284563482,
-0.1301769912,
0.0255052708,
-0.0486539491,
0.2624427974,
0.1176188961,
0.1635756046,
-0.6555413604,
-0.0493745841,
0.7566124797,
0.2349289507,
0.4799475074,
0.1475446075,
-0.3935494423,
-0.0096231978,
-0.5486500263,
0.0748968348,
0.1013739854,
0.1865542084,
-0.3905088902,
0.597083509,
-0.2016208917,
0.5767521858,
0.2346586734,
0.3254582882,
-0.0728859082,
0.1492948085,
-0.0372006223,
0.1118430868,
0.5915206075,
0.6004122496,
0.4044414163,
-0.4927894771,
-0.3955253065,
0.0926342234,
0.5715125203,
-0.6312981844,
-0.6007086039,
-0.2557581067,
-0.3142484426,
-0.4651692212,
0.5560692549,
-0.680133462,
-0.6653891802,
-0.5581899285,
0.1838944852,
-0.2040513605,
0.2515175343,
-0.0238814298,
-0.1230178252,
0.0564123392,
0.745223403,
-0.7389121652,
0.750279367,
0.0346958935,
1.0103077888,
-0.5351272225,
-0.4490244091,
-0.6778752804,
0.2280736268,
-0.4043749571,
1.1336970329,
-0.6022740006,
-0.1870208085,
-0.1349857002,
0.1654218733,
0.005021899,
-0.7679792047,
0.0442438014,
-0.6748121381,
-0.1541004032,
-0.3024556637,
-0.2999164164,
0.034895815,
0.1513340324,
-0.6910809278,
0.4427063465,
0.2756031454,
-0.8608375788,
0.2001073658,
-1.3078529835,
-0.3832300305,
0.1649578661,
-0.0078923861,
-0.431773603,
0.3761247396,
0.6090155244,
0.2968858778,
-0.2874187827,
-0.0783486217,
-0.3284954429,
-0.7373633981,
0.578320384,
-0.0266963542,
0.2511034012,
0.2633676231,
-0.2649987042,
0.2035020441,
-0.608173728,
-0.3342322409,
0.0386376381,
-0.4840278327,
0.1491725147,
0.1032099351,
0.0463534333,
-0.0977473184,
-0.2733716071,
-0.3672258258,
0.4656258523,
0.1721107215,
0.7545563579,
0.7574521303,
0.1394075602,
0.4722727537,
-0.4335111976,
0.891358912,
0.4060623944,
0.1853990704,
-0.5815922022,
-0.2698613703,
-0.9173477292,
-0.1079145148,
0.5228812099,
0.5658544898,
-0.8686104417,
0.0320309028,
-0.2768536508,
-0.2002376169,
-0.5755575895,
0.2919569612,
0.2438182831,
0.1962289065,
0.2052933872,
-1.2027772665,
-0.4510222077,
-0.7362396121,
0.2046676278,
-0.2116870731,
-0.233384937,
0.553090632,
0.5223411918,
-0.1143579036,
0.9169428349,
-0.5157769918,
-0.3890918195,
-0.1276214272,
0.2293200195,
-0.2657711506,
0.6067738533,
0.4815379679,
-0.6261031628,
-0.4073928297,
0.0754319057,
-0.6995643377,
0.0631304458,
-0.3822345138,
-0.1792556792,
-0.0750804022,
0.5620982051,
-0.2557501197,
0.7191981077,
0.3798391223,
0.0344669595,
0.7709929943,
-0.448569566,
0.3612913191,
-0.6811649799,
0.0403910205,
-0.219974637,
-0.3268988431,
-0.12650913,
-0.066618219,
-0.1008664221,
-0.4409248531,
-0.4402059913,
0.1567620188,
-0.8398967385,
-0.4523490369,
-0.4581865072,
-0.1815960854,
-0.0943109468,
0.7111115456,
0.2345880568,
0.7417702079,
0.7746149302,
-0.5572070479,
0.5669013858,
0.1125890389,
-0.5934062004,
0.8250911832,
-0.6297873855,
0.6303775311,
-0.2404145598,
0.2438809276,
-0.9993622899,
-0.702464819,
0.4813808501,
-0.4505051076,
0.2692633867,
-0.1942209899,
-0.4846929312,
-0.7313609123,
-0.2377228141,
0.3253397346,
0.3769604266,
-0.7780198455,
0.4167649746,
0.1925464272,
0.0443384685,
-0.2085528076,
-0.5933334827,
0.6718052626,
-0.1163278744,
-0.2015310079,
0.2086545229,
-0.3255552649,
0.0432579406,
0.0701301768,
0.2682811618,
-0.2795251608,
-0.0374060571,
0.5104102492,
0.3724232912,
-0.1289799511,
0.1520330012,
-0.0131406439,
0.0355883762,
-0.1864673346,
-0.4864486158,
0.2399099022,
-0.2433630079,
-0.3376588225,
-1.0772508383,
0.4614059031,
0.8998353481,
-0.2429077178,
0.3554888368,
0.3513382673,
-0.5837063789,
0.0437922142,
-0.3395552039,
-0.2938347161,
-0.3895594478,
0.3035435379,
-0.1362113357,
-0.5347616076,
0.5119239092,
-0.038833499,
-0.0477864332,
-0.0987616703,
0.4350015819,
-0.5898377895,
1.2479048967,
0.8318714499,
-0.3879148364,
0.5946873426,
-0.3167701066,
-0.0151474215,
-1.0592691898,
-0.0435145907,
-0.3181310594,
-0.4429115355,
0.0415339395,
-0.3241256773,
0.0257105716,
0.2424905002,
-0.1190864667,
0.2989293337,
-0.6857409477,
0.5366358757,
0.6594811082,
0.6170248389,
0.1400232017,
0.242128998,
0.077676177,
-0.0821514204,
-0.843339026,
-0.4237270951,
0.8000494242,
0.1838617921,
1.1511902809,
-0.327313453,
0.3870171905,
0.9028097391,
1.0648738146,
-0.5185262561,
0.2984298468,
-0.0360019393,
-0.3769170046,
0.0310130324,
0.0087691536,
-0.6955223083,
-0.1580058634,
-0.1221920922,
-0.8314478993,
0.0904389024,
0.6317827106,
-0.4922506213,
0.3997348249,
-0.7588275671,
0.5637132525,
-0.3325227201,
-0.2081736475,
0.0375447236,
-0.6699880958,
0.1290264577,
0.1267482042,
0.1568461061,
0.1337624192,
0.1644860804,
0.7218434811,
-0.5660116076,
1.4002958536,
-0.3798112571,
0.353333205,
0.7729366422,
-0.1256438941,
0.3282180429,
0.0154280858,
0.3715736568,
-0.0616652742,
-0.2222472429,
-0.4904710054,
-0.5140776038,
0.5345478058,
-0.9567462802,
-0.4432792962,
-0.23068057,
-0.7953000665,
-0.1032306328,
-0.0657273158,
0.2965214849,
0.3250584304,
0.2025551796,
0.122817263,
0.241849944,
-0.4105840027,
0.2011847794,
0.2115516216,
-0.0435896888,
-0.8064429164,
0.7092349529,
-0.0872898549,
0.1191869155,
0.2640584707,
0.1924011707,
0.0402170345,
-0.6646986604,
-0.8272826076,
0.186010927,
-0.8636211157,
-0.4686746001,
-0.3958924115,
0.0591262877,
-0.2023298591,
-0.6110081077,
-0.2431577593,
-0.0782893226,
-0.8064556718,
-0.0289180018,
0.259024322,
0.8209936023,
0.1066006869,
0.7749544978,
-0.8233117461,
0.1527048647,
0.5552276969,
0.7227871418,
0.3451060653,
-0.6292637587,
-0.4892044067,
-0.036792893,
-0.4333412945,
-0.922857821,
0.2153299302,
0.2697686255,
0.1540419608,
0.3725374639,
0.0591207109,
0.9421460629,
-0.4338568449,
0.8674281836,
0.5746690631,
-0.9951623678,
0.4955583513,
-0.1114800498,
0.5339576006,
0.5627064705,
0.0559797138,
-0.4965756536,
-0.2269741297,
-0.1299723983,
-0.4422470033,
0.860593617,
-0.0866701603,
0.5857136846,
0.3166509271,
0.9316700697,
0.0200861488,
0.1082867309,
-0.8273140788,
0.3138375878,
-0.2869838476,
-0.1377883106,
0.2463942766,
-0.0801144317,
-0.0510592721,
-0.6077456474,
0.4343669713,
-0.5289375186,
0.4943710268,
0.2763215601,
-0.4647566378,
-0.5455380082,
-0.0492377132,
0.6485230923,
0.8935118318,
-0.101482749,
0.0722039714,
0.3858806193,
-0.3811127245,
0.0322253518,
-0.3135775924,
0.0197207332,
-0.1619712561,
0.4028268754,
0.9871616364,
0.4319958091,
-0.7712859511,
0.4361599982,
-0.217110768,
-0.2295887321,
-0.365393579,
0.1633182466,
-0.0175475366,
0.1540894359,
0.4591718316,
0.5351638198,
-0.0217379685,
-0.5476334691,
0.2839947939,
-0.1163985282,
-1.0755681992,
-0.6103822589,
0.9760608077,
0.150313735,
-0.432316035,
0.8789654374,
0.0692958012,
-0.7113265395,
0.7652789354,
0.5365990996,
0.6953917742,
-0.0878803879,
0.2086577713,
0.4155443311,
0.2642963827,
-0.0451264344,
0.0567002967,
-0.2464270145,
-0.5145538449,
-0.1847541332,
-0.1869757921,
-0.4846470654,
-0.1502386183,
-0.9717047811,
0.5789566636,
-0.5645140409,
0.0184001345,
0.0140849156,
-0.3740785718,
-0.8760783672,
0.3952827752,
0.311545372,
1.0858824253,
-0.7483991981,
0.7195457816,
1.0416537523,
-0.5675311685,
-0.5232555866,
-0.2628123164,
-0.3486825824,
-0.7803944349,
0.3347126544,
0.4035537243,
0.0234000087,
-0.0332711227,
-1.3419908285,
-0.5733480453,
1.2900485992,
0.3962925375,
-0.6325082183,
0.1547528803,
-0.0221685525,
0.6433939934,
-1.1311336756,
0.015692737,
0.4426613152,
0.1755083352,
0.2776706815,
-0.5856220722,
-0.1850381345,
-0.119963415,
0.3433127701,
-0.4833529592,
-0.4726376832,
0.4006238282,
-0.9891440272,
-0.1452781707,
0.4631099403,
0.9308778644,
0.0763418376,
0.3333443105,
0.8248923421,
0.2599350512,
0.511503756,
0.1076106802,
1.309247613,
-0.0305063277,
0.1861649156,
1.3790745735,
-0.1470495611,
0.694004178,
0.5305380225,
-0.1533528417,
0.6422760487,
0.8087874055,
-0.2656162381,
0.7256366014,
0.6050604582,
-0.0924339816,
-0.3000949919,
-0.3150182366,
0.0697232112,
0.3229276538,
0.1503836513,
-0.5955756307,
0.221392408,
0.2791641951,
-0.1918447763,
-0.1267442852,
-0.455956012,
0.7715739012,
0.0646607429,
-0.9413602352,
0.4561422169,
-0.0301831029,
0.324200809,
-0.0840983242,
-0.3143604398,
-0.2107350677,
0.1137716696,
-0.3629080951,
-0.4456231594,
0.017055098,
0.3023435473,
-0.3121091425,
0.3742787838,
0.4939728677,
-0.4336526096,
-0.5338005424,
-0.0100849215,
-0.1318455935,
0.2888068855,
-0.0769885778,
-0.5635947585,
0.2189767212,
0.1252070069,
0.2209444642,
0.0451452136,
-0.133164987,
-0.3757209778,
0.697037816,
0.6120488644,
-0.128832832,
0.1703008264,
0.3979717195,
1.0265343189,
-0.6044187546,
-0.631103158,
-0.3982500434,
0.6930341125,
-0.0901620016,
-0.0412843116,
0.0437383875,
0.3455357254,
0.6603640318,
-0.5421304703,
1.2079888582,
0.017121274,
0.0114167407,
-0.2190807462,
0.5427304506,
-0.3554008305,
0.2563625276,
-0.4007339478,
-0.9238976836,
-0.6240119338,
0.3930684626,
-0.0545974784,
-0.0957920998,
0.4541017711,
0.567317307,
-0.2672065198,
0.0220427699,
0.1759386212,
-0.0133461952,
0.3243533969,
0.5989832878,
1.1034189463,
-0.4142441452,
0.6430435777,
-0.5960957408,
-0.4451401234,
-0.366994679,
-0.9844776392,
-0.868950665,
-0.5132864714,
-0.7123549581,
-0.1172883585,
0.0725848675,
0.7861579657,
1.1991846561,
-1.1171668768,
-0.3259806037,
0.0288838129,
-0.1798263192,
-0.3013198078,
-0.236984551,
0.4387700856,
-0.1785178185,
-0.5884204507,
-0.1983979791,
0.514046967,
0.2050854415,
-0.1681531072,
-0.4686774909,
0.157898441,
0.0858042315,
0.4605389237,
0.3817053139,
-0.673656404,
-0.6982213259,
-0.0836512819,
0.2068333477,
0.4529571533,
1.1763315201,
-0.4481101036,
0.9263148308,
-0.1266793907,
0.5862554908,
0.4436695874,
0.2062292397,
0.6284220815,
-0.601583302,
-0.0441746488,
0.1086013466,
0.4549927711,
0.7126617432,
-0.3609775007,
0.3748170733,
0.3121743202,
-0.343984127,
-0.9123046398,
-0.1322947443,
-1.1100229025,
0.0089609874,
0.578794837,
-0.5228620172,
-0.2590711117,
-0.0158367883,
-0.592254281,
-0.0196011383,
-0.3416199684,
1.2143301964,
0.7872911096,
-0.2777458131,
-0.6633802652,
-0.0715348721,
-0.105849497,
0.0469758734,
-1.0649991035,
-0.0721452907,
0.4977485836,
0.493861407,
0.1123095527,
0.5874230266,
-0.3428545594,
0.7849962115,
-0.2748109698,
0.5220347047,
-0.1200549975,
-0.6252182126,
-0.4782680571,
-0.0176544785,
0.4099088013,
-0.534909904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03469v1 | Joint Event Extraction via Structural Semantic Matching | 2023-06-06T07:42:39 | 2023-06-06T07:42:39 | Haochen Li, Tianhao Gao, Jingkun Wang, Weiping Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event Extraction (EE) is one of the essential tasks in information
extraction, which aims to detect event mentions from text and find the
corresponding argument roles. The EE task can be abstracted as a process of
matching the semantic definitions and argument structures of event types with
the target text. This paper encodes the semantic features of event types and
makes structural matching with target text. Specifically, Semantic Type
Embedding (STE) and Dynamic Structure Encoder (DSE) modules are proposed. Also,
the Joint Structural Semantic Matching (JSSM) model is built to jointly perform
event detection and argument extraction tasks through a bidirectional attention
layer. The experimental results on the ACE2005 dataset indicate that our model
achieves a significant performance improvement | [
-0.0683143958,
-0.9499254823,
0.6931814551,
-0.0590718091,
-0.5642988682,
0.1253349185,
0.1116728783,
-0.6186394095,
0.3225438893,
0.3238319755,
-0.3703383207,
-0.6179640889,
-0.4926342368,
0.0450067297,
-0.3047536612,
0.7570431828,
-0.5167202353,
-0.0608183295,
-0.3593099415,
-0.0961828232,
-0.37212044,
-0.457622081,
-0.7831573486,
0.1037317589,
0.4250293076,
0.1589040309,
0.1830001324,
0.876837492,
0.5968562365,
0.3462839425,
-0.2603416741,
0.0801740959,
-0.0267443452,
0.5568125844,
-0.4002092183,
-0.4937939346,
-0.6545071602,
-0.1100749373,
0.9738537073,
0.3600063324,
0.2158047706,
0.1995026916,
0.0481325574,
0.3527742028,
-0.5258116126,
0.4530521035,
-0.8098941445,
0.1603129804,
-0.5096767545,
-0.4698176384,
-0.3176404536,
-0.1470571309,
-0.0586155429,
-0.3283280432,
0.1921951175,
0.1067571491,
1.086956501,
0.0274220463,
-0.5581349134,
-0.2540278137,
-0.3326512575,
0.3582741916,
-0.5404316187,
0.3409278393,
-0.0538552105,
-0.0292421989,
-0.3593783677,
-0.6166751981,
-0.6200069189,
-0.0979621634,
0.0426376164,
0.1429245919,
0.0209226292,
0.419965148,
0.2016385049,
0.3272227943,
-0.5257232189,
-0.0303482469,
-0.1219365969,
0.002648799,
0.5786180496,
0.1478675455,
0.7631360888,
-0.642234683,
-0.5476706028,
0.0050949398,
-0.3462932706,
-0.2139437199,
0.5122246742,
0.2671461701,
-0.2576687634,
0.6180596948,
-0.1315571368,
0.3651338518,
0.1527858973,
-0.1011824757,
0.018744098,
-0.5220407248,
-0.3190884888,
0.4028026462,
0.5365817547,
0.0679734647,
0.0590588115,
-0.3296656311,
0.2405629903,
0.3361432552,
0.1056987941,
-0.5647515655,
-0.0776759163,
0.2307995558,
-0.82034868,
-0.3650446832,
0.116518788,
-0.9492151737,
0.0630530268,
-0.3081180155,
0.4243669808,
-0.1485716105,
-0.3676170111,
0.2700829506,
-0.5521033406,
0.3091596663,
0.2222328484,
-0.368257612,
0.1560366303,
0.6125406027,
0.5658644438,
-0.4509263039,
0.2337825596,
-0.8738030791,
0.741445303,
0.0063422602,
1.0026745796,
-0.781269908,
0.0567992963,
-0.1066503376,
0.1054431126,
-0.1954192519,
-0.2080829889,
0.6599718928,
-0.7947996855,
0.2051114589,
-0.0785141811,
-0.6148719192,
-0.241231367,
0.2666809857,
-0.6695370674,
1.0235649347,
-0.339451462,
-0.7854550481,
0.4865155518,
-0.8659656644,
-0.5768869519,
0.5121858716,
-0.5181530118,
-0.5073989034,
0.0876678675,
0.0822339356,
0.4704202116,
-0.0146155981,
0.3115279973,
-0.6223198771,
0.0952465609,
-0.1475902647,
-0.1461320519,
0.4217934608,
-0.0443551913,
-0.5205452442,
0.1540162861,
-1.0781779289,
-0.2961148322,
0.243773222,
-0.4757876992,
-0.6469925046,
0.5271235108,
0.0672821254,
0.2573915422,
0.3282896876,
-0.6904224157,
0.1110948622,
-0.5717070103,
0.0354339369,
0.5791110396,
0.3348169029,
0.3423681557,
0.3415722847,
0.5209102631,
0.3727045059,
-0.2325176448,
-0.0961448476,
-0.1811586171,
-0.3793591261,
-0.3595192134,
0.282705009,
0.5879375339,
-0.7050417066,
0.6289764047,
-0.0275224932,
-0.0070587154,
-0.2363413274,
-0.1832794398,
0.3885667324,
0.3784458935,
0.1811756045,
-0.0970631763,
-0.8540238142,
-0.8051516414,
-0.546687007,
-0.3992369771,
0.1058124527,
-0.0051979437,
0.2378382534,
0.2127361149,
0.5722131133,
-0.3186286986,
-0.1583848894,
-0.528665781,
0.3660444319,
-0.1835593879,
0.1986020207,
0.4850641191,
-0.9037581682,
-0.5648425817,
0.2685751021,
-0.96903795,
-0.1195728555,
-0.0834547505,
-0.221478641,
0.3253126442,
0.622350812,
-0.3115453422,
0.539560318,
0.1450854242,
-0.6677570939,
0.2027371824,
0.3434604704,
0.3407050073,
-1.5962257385,
-0.1264738292,
-0.0587754324,
-0.4165858924,
-0.331192404,
0.0918437168,
0.0355852768,
-0.208268851,
-0.3369382024,
0.3099066615,
-0.8020178676,
-0.2413095534,
-0.2112485319,
0.6960580349,
0.2449909896,
0.3561253548,
0.2987200916,
0.2398482561,
0.5938508511,
-0.4082417786,
0.5044924021,
0.4297933578,
-0.2724770606,
0.6414310336,
-0.4801335335,
-0.0388696454,
-0.4034100771,
0.1180365533,
-1.1205683947,
-0.1579622775,
0.1171832234,
-0.1829664409,
0.4679058492,
-0.3691373467,
-0.4649341702,
-0.3526439667,
-0.3525370359,
0.2308723927,
-0.0929145217,
-0.3705831766,
0.8972479105,
0.6334735155,
-0.5114107132,
-0.3335323036,
-0.5400058031,
0.2679309845,
-0.219233349,
-0.7374110818,
0.6759849191,
0.264051348,
-0.0680399463,
0.4303106368,
-0.2929783463,
0.0676837116,
-0.0028154701,
0.2190186679,
0.4510192871,
-0.6227404475,
-0.029925039,
0.3081016839,
-0.0440917797,
-0.0376797356,
0.0476942696,
0.3557136059,
0.1277388185,
-0.550373733,
-0.8885651827,
1.0350580215,
0.6099715829,
-0.2933880389,
0.7048761845,
0.5163542032,
-0.549279511,
0.131652981,
-0.5539789796,
-0.0799773708,
-0.4143841565,
0.8195670843,
-0.633946836,
-0.7192652225,
0.5660672784,
-0.0655657575,
-0.0041312682,
0.6386146545,
0.3416497707,
-0.2317665964,
1.2396618128,
0.1821980178,
0.0826944038,
0.6530505419,
0.2928517163,
0.1998524368,
-0.8825347424,
-0.295345366,
-0.6423828006,
-0.4057067037,
-0.160491392,
-0.1361991167,
0.2561110854,
0.3253620863,
0.1159379482,
0.5730566382,
-0.3465677202,
0.3633829951,
0.0965865627,
-0.1716722697,
0.2615014911,
0.0037392327,
-0.104974851,
-0.125433594,
-0.6032297611,
-0.6737673879,
0.4954094887,
0.4307385087,
0.4175063968,
0.0145984879,
0.8257966638,
0.1845643818,
-0.1595406085,
-0.5580397844,
0.8572998047,
-0.2231659442,
-0.5131241679,
-0.1048376784,
-0.2694739699,
-0.8647546172,
0.0669519678,
-0.1066541225,
-0.805866003,
0.3531499207,
-0.1472533792,
-0.0458406694,
0.5905035138,
-0.5346935391,
0.9908480644,
0.023465775,
-0.1022846848,
-0.3188452125,
-0.4110016525,
0.0916796997,
0.3040042818,
-0.0463168174,
-0.2566179037,
0.1913960576,
1.1858314276,
0.1810656786,
0.6359497905,
-0.2591049373,
0.1094892025,
0.4484138787,
0.128026545,
0.9796572924,
0.0657235384,
-0.1264684647,
-0.1696116179,
0.3474710286,
-0.2070890218,
-0.4034720063,
0.4573332965,
-0.3350130022,
-0.6102640629,
-0.1991623342,
-0.3275237083,
-0.025387954,
-0.1294948608,
-0.2506239116,
0.8036310673,
-0.2515974343,
0.2795282304,
0.550475359,
0.0521645807,
0.7630951405,
0.5643824935,
0.2653566301,
-0.3106514513,
0.4675992429,
-0.064086251,
-0.0455509014,
0.7114396095,
-0.0968324915,
-0.3068039119,
-0.6326491237,
-0.4843669832,
0.1119657233,
-0.6520479321,
-0.5127163529,
-1.2008368969,
-0.2241892815,
-0.355155319,
-0.17793791,
-0.3445522785,
-0.3264357746,
-0.4293152094,
-0.2450651079,
0.1331604719,
0.4430049062,
0.2040498406,
-0.0031126027,
-0.917244494,
0.5128006339,
0.0292229801,
0.1739224494,
-0.1197463647,
-0.1440891773,
-0.0703370646,
-0.4225977659,
-0.429160744,
-1.2270847559,
0.1729356498,
0.1078694388,
0.900008142,
0.4715246856,
0.0195435286,
0.7973772287,
-0.4274407625,
0.7920732498,
0.0455957875,
-0.8770840168,
1.0420787334,
-0.1251932383,
-0.1391978711,
0.4990818202,
0.4636943042,
-0.1845138669,
-0.4051230848,
-0.6216012836,
-0.687526226,
0.9028379321,
0.0047648628,
-0.3643077612,
-0.4386483431,
0.5820724964,
-0.1432167888,
-0.1499865353,
-0.8896610141,
0.0723802447,
0.5164198875,
-0.5583412051,
0.7061166167,
-0.5379604697,
-0.0081289625,
0.0682320297,
0.4420340061,
0.0397595279,
0.3997332156,
0.2801626027,
-0.1586607397,
-0.3847019076,
0.3283307552,
0.2499271482,
0.1739214212,
-0.1036297604,
0.2819941342,
0.2300450653,
-0.3535507619,
-0.0639091432,
0.323574841,
0.1868074536,
0.1180451885,
0.5385712981,
0.7904362082,
0.4244604111,
-0.405241549,
0.5050320625,
0.0046111769,
-0.1843336523,
-0.017026471,
0.0727497041,
0.0236601662,
0.550262332,
0.2251994908,
-0.2788309753,
0.3620581329,
-0.8384026289,
0.4815016985,
0.6753159165,
-0.3366450965,
-0.522262454,
0.7937581539,
0.3393922746,
-0.2718356252,
0.0225903615,
-0.1183746979,
-0.6453318,
0.7506655455,
0.760121882,
0.9707317352,
-0.1964051276,
0.1567418426,
0.2078244537,
-0.0482610166,
0.3146525919,
0.5852552056,
-0.2472182065,
-0.5775945783,
-0.6479912996,
-0.997600317,
-0.0995902419,
0.1008591056,
-0.8226178288,
0.5130119324,
0.216716975,
0.2502382398,
0.2717696428,
0.1720553637,
-0.4541921616,
-0.0582457893,
0.3117557168,
0.7546635866,
-0.9561207294,
0.7202823162,
0.8843283057,
-0.3829703331,
-0.5466531515,
-0.0349012502,
-0.2051804364,
-0.2678766549,
0.7716010213,
-0.111625284,
0.0989733264,
-0.0996914282,
0.0948820636,
-0.9679798484,
0.8849462867,
0.1612373292,
-0.6550781727,
-0.3388549685,
0.0856911466,
0.3081813455,
-0.4777025878,
-0.0569505095,
0.1587779373,
0.54598248,
0.1670362353,
-0.599245429,
0.2926685512,
0.032996051,
-0.0621334054,
0.5106554031,
-0.2964019179,
0.3600284159,
0.4382307529,
-0.5938017368,
-0.2767148316,
0.8776317239,
0.222317189,
0.5434586406,
0.4969468713,
0.4838916361,
0.393619895,
0.1059688777,
0.6552172303,
-0.2187318951,
0.0649285316,
0.9563126564,
-0.6139431,
0.939661622,
0.287645936,
-0.179890871,
0.7323658466,
0.5265074968,
0.3003967106,
0.5221083164,
-0.3018957675,
-0.4415579438,
-0.3938503861,
0.255643785,
-0.2546864748,
0.5918920636,
0.5248767138,
-0.4472652078,
-0.510569036,
0.1988890767,
-0.1222831532,
0.0840761438,
-0.3114044368,
1.1500282288,
-0.1321566105,
-0.4607477486,
-0.0925599411,
0.1663250476,
0.3024406135,
-0.5568743348,
0.0410456695,
0.1491359472,
0.0172126908,
0.0262875408,
-0.685038209,
0.9053447247,
-0.0953259766,
-0.4204272032,
0.0413572937,
1.1707849503,
-0.6512101293,
-0.1602964252,
0.5252856016,
0.1447963864,
0.0894918963,
-0.0901528224,
-0.5559712052,
0.3072946072,
-0.1964390129,
-0.4410273433,
0.448562324,
0.6593102217,
-0.139747709,
-0.0682017431,
0.5340054631,
0.1594670862,
0.0338816792,
-0.0193960182,
0.8070964813,
-0.729842782,
-0.6151767373,
-1.0197526217,
0.5114122033,
-0.5798573494,
-0.1098632216,
0.4785531461,
0.6806443334,
0.2283051461,
-0.053500697,
0.5142237544,
-0.0034045195,
0.2864353061,
-0.4507701695,
0.3110038042,
-0.493868798,
-0.1258555651,
-0.4155223668,
-0.8065496683,
-0.3065152466,
0.3384331763,
-0.148805514,
-0.4628052413,
0.8092569113,
0.5536709428,
-0.2139455229,
0.1915324181,
0.3149044514,
0.1392650753,
0.3341957331,
0.4736618996,
0.5238798261,
-0.6636036038,
0.5337246656,
0.4950823486,
-0.364481777,
-0.3663396835,
-1.0462017059,
-1.0207699537,
-0.9089035392,
-0.9514986873,
-0.2804258466,
0.3445591331,
0.7305828333,
0.5812054873,
-0.918063879,
0.257907033,
-0.2477765083,
0.1927225739,
-0.053831771,
-0.3439731598,
0.7141675949,
-0.5153526068,
-0.697644949,
0.7861073017,
0.9670770168,
-0.0328657478,
0.2036402971,
0.541272521,
-0.6477349401,
0.427805841,
0.7724041939,
0.1434859931,
-0.6052193642,
-0.692833066,
-0.4619544446,
-0.0987797529,
-0.0597717613,
0.5039539933,
-0.4798766077,
0.1705725044,
0.8248093128,
0.8321081996,
0.7805942297,
-0.1211069971,
0.4357008934,
-0.8373705149,
0.2777667642,
-0.0190715827,
0.4785088003,
-0.1328251809,
-0.6257101893,
0.2519263625,
0.5106425881,
-0.3457359672,
-0.9868870974,
0.2862355411,
-1.5543999672,
-0.1536837667,
1.1597485542,
-0.0877198651,
-0.486423552,
-0.506704092,
-0.1856986284,
0.6228944659,
0.0779836699,
0.6202017069,
0.6593353748,
-0.163688615,
-0.2124677449,
-0.1303735375,
0.4193781912,
0.1767624468,
-0.9118639231,
-0.0765552297,
0.1252397299,
0.0875871554,
0.2283786684,
0.2445199639,
-0.4747838676,
0.1650033295,
0.1179097444,
0.2913711369,
-0.0133363623,
-0.3749411702,
0.0200949404,
0.7344669104,
-0.5270495415,
-0.7404292822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03460v1 | Natural Language Commanding via Program Synthesis | 2023-06-06T07:28:49 | 2023-06-06T07:28:49 | Apurva Gandhi, Thong Q. Nguyen, Huitian Jiao, Robert Steen, Ameya Bhatawdekar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.HC | We present Semantic Interpreter, a natural language-friendly AI system for
productivity software such as Microsoft Office that leverages large language
models (LLMs) to execute user intent across application features. While LLMs
are excellent at understanding user intent expressed as natural language, they
are not sufficient for fulfilling application-specific user intent that
requires more than text-to-text transformations. We therefore introduce the
Office Domain Specific Language (ODSL), a concise, high-level language
specialized for performing actions in and interacting with entities in Office
applications. Semantic Interpreter leverages an Analysis-Retrieval prompt
construction method with LLMs for program synthesis, translating natural
language user utterances to ODSL programs that can be transpiled to application
APIs and then executed. We focus our discussion primarily on a research
exploration for Microsoft PowerPoint. | [
-0.0565018915,
-0.8314299583,
0.735217154,
0.1259286404,
-0.0473148264,
0.2151097208,
-0.1223452538,
-0.4347745478,
-0.0313004144,
0.8136076927,
-0.5729156137,
-0.8732061386,
-0.3650653958,
0.2845466137,
-0.3764923811,
0.7219545245,
-0.2150799334,
-0.2466017157,
-0.1858411729,
-0.0999490395,
-0.7117508054,
-0.4252309203,
-0.305128485,
-0.4341974258,
-0.0249486677,
0.484490484,
0.8381299376,
0.3381367028,
0.3146235943,
0.4137094319,
0.2911987007,
0.0321353488,
-0.3041703403,
0.1956172884,
-0.3964153528,
-0.3572712243,
-0.5773805976,
-0.0584610514,
0.4111230373,
0.969220221,
0.0227104332,
-0.0230795704,
-0.2446683049,
0.6779960394,
-0.5326938629,
0.4577798843,
-0.6392844319,
0.1730591953,
-0.0098993555,
-0.3167628348,
-0.6314356327,
-0.1865056753,
0.4609838426,
-0.7277325988,
-0.2420384437,
0.1870842576,
0.6308594346,
0.178366214,
-0.5074179769,
-0.510381043,
-0.7286856771,
1.1050413847,
-0.8006785512,
0.2588762939,
0.1858070642,
0.4515351057,
-0.3702013791,
-1.0653146505,
-0.5594972372,
-0.5988581181,
-0.052043926,
-0.0230316482,
-0.3430975676,
0.4630349278,
0.1947067976,
0.2245147526,
-0.4200735092,
-0.1614845246,
-0.41008389,
-0.0609631762,
0.5121115446,
0.4376919568,
0.7553915977,
-0.1627047509,
-0.3340881169,
0.1731329113,
-0.6466503143,
-0.1083824337,
0.2184485346,
0.5002855062,
0.2308959067,
0.9397930503,
-0.2999558747,
1.0901260376,
-0.4558336139,
0.1145141646,
-0.062102478,
-0.4039787352,
-0.4719647467,
0.5113885999,
0.7373397946,
0.467543602,
0.2785029113,
-0.3862128854,
-0.2367720157,
0.4062121212,
0.4016268551,
-0.7092506289,
0.0603087805,
0.3504856229,
-0.334947139,
-0.2378707379,
0.1081575379,
-0.1313498765,
-0.2728483677,
-0.9518848062,
0.2424009889,
-0.8537874818,
0.0334619246,
0.3447191119,
-0.2167636454,
0.2374886423,
0.3898825943,
-0.6715965867,
0.6802600026,
0.9360960126,
0.5039445758,
-0.2732450068,
-0.312319845,
-1.0755035877,
0.2934730649,
-0.5564793348,
0.4263160229,
-0.6902669072,
-0.389821291,
0.0891286358,
-0.2644662559,
-0.0979500934,
-0.4480650127,
0.458337009,
-0.5331101418,
0.4079816937,
0.4241257608,
-0.6220934391,
-0.1137011051,
0.113274999,
-0.2633008063,
0.8052980304,
0.383197248,
-0.5572600365,
0.2650260925,
-1.0250946283,
-0.586322546,
0.0900350213,
-0.4999600053,
0.2575875223,
0.0452819206,
-0.2605406046,
0.1128803343,
-0.0340254158,
0.1630179137,
0.2392301857,
-0.1428027153,
0.0312128887,
0.062605828,
0.5758281946,
0.4347113669,
-0.2565335631,
0.544647038,
-0.9758155346,
0.1383152455,
0.0456050299,
-0.2810569108,
-0.3622294068,
0.2804580629,
-0.0313889459,
0.2050807774,
0.4400795996,
-0.5050842166,
0.2766699791,
-0.8067193627,
0.475710988,
0.3508369625,
-0.2081661671,
0.6648464203,
0.1913914233,
0.6623438001,
-0.4423131049,
-0.0890793279,
0.0161126498,
-0.5807617307,
-0.2667728364,
-0.068921268,
-0.2822392881,
0.8094015718,
-0.933953464,
0.5181525946,
-0.4052485228,
-0.1208422184,
-0.3145852089,
0.3713645935,
0.1434369981,
0.6215078235,
0.1176337525,
-0.3023503423,
-0.4897171855,
-0.7219952345,
-0.357845515,
-0.3777171671,
-0.3432973921,
0.136445269,
-0.08408425,
-0.1299434602,
1.4041806459,
-0.631423533,
-0.5812640786,
-0.7950214744,
0.30343467,
0.448725462,
0.0371108092,
0.4955077767,
-0.7823383808,
-0.8259989619,
0.1823444068,
-0.6930439472,
-0.4251737595,
0.013649255,
-0.2824299634,
0.427139014,
0.8687086701,
-0.5842559934,
0.4976728261,
0.4120934904,
-0.4594351351,
0.3655637205,
-0.4033679664,
-0.1532013714,
-0.9389337897,
0.2674885392,
-0.6050230265,
-0.0965786651,
-0.9050195813,
-0.0273340903,
-0.1493076384,
-0.540780127,
-0.6866518855,
0.2853711843,
-0.3865920305,
-0.2966973186,
-0.4338882267,
0.5608825088,
0.0587898903,
0.1103432849,
0.3740100265,
0.5585680604,
0.7756838799,
-0.5442844033,
0.5322623253,
0.5389348269,
-0.3309222162,
0.6372615695,
-0.5952137709,
0.12146198,
-0.0804928243,
-0.144508779,
-0.8367990851,
-0.2087294012,
0.0752022415,
-0.3333588839,
0.2650203109,
-0.1134092957,
-0.3717989028,
-0.2143258303,
-0.2612097859,
-0.2018059045,
0.5687374473,
-0.2171146721,
0.8321884274,
0.014537137,
-0.3174778819,
-0.1714639664,
-0.8428422809,
0.5488281846,
0.052458033,
-0.9987770319,
0.478112489,
0.2155596018,
-0.5671236515,
0.2197061926,
0.1869373471,
-0.0191324614,
0.0738686994,
0.2366456836,
0.5186588168,
-0.3346394598,
-0.2122810781,
-0.2703980207,
-0.2603644133,
0.0413537994,
-0.3838482499,
0.3584006727,
-0.1974525005,
-0.5818436742,
-0.5053972006,
0.4920091629,
0.7364791632,
-0.2802443802,
0.4433071613,
0.4717969,
0.0162100084,
0.0394788012,
0.0908479169,
0.024325069,
-0.5259745121,
0.4904741347,
-0.3490713835,
-0.3920428455,
0.0396778844,
0.0040125526,
0.3691115081,
0.2037684321,
0.4598170221,
0.6080112457,
1.3560541868,
0.6826209426,
0.0340893231,
0.8635238409,
-0.1435472667,
0.4916862547,
-0.5458247066,
0.1315829903,
-0.4299497008,
-0.1135531664,
-0.3942006528,
-0.0648782775,
0.2627826929,
-0.2667731345,
0.0727236569,
0.706420958,
-0.5767982602,
0.192206949,
0.5671564937,
-0.5461606383,
0.2650659382,
0.0721430779,
0.0413754582,
-0.0671243146,
-0.4949884415,
-0.9744899273,
0.716706574,
0.1723781675,
0.8768566847,
0.1231195331,
1.0217337608,
0.2894017994,
0.2467262,
-1.0209060907,
0.79334867,
-0.2851812541,
-0.1942352653,
-0.5008601546,
-0.3125333786,
-1.1641145945,
0.013504697,
0.1602721661,
-1.1244525909,
-0.4912060201,
-0.0456350185,
-0.2333443761,
0.0609239712,
-1.1832287312,
1.2693192959,
-0.3655172884,
-0.3175294399,
-0.3942376375,
-0.6626466513,
-0.0812555924,
0.4745701849,
0.1728360206,
-0.2635517716,
-0.1487090588,
0.2966617346,
-0.7741818428,
0.6467127204,
-0.1143026277,
-0.3325513303,
0.5725114942,
0.3887908459,
0.5370705128,
-0.4369938672,
-0.4722013772,
-0.4083542228,
0.1336548477,
-0.1530806571,
-0.5614877343,
0.7708492875,
-0.3154204786,
-0.7517056465,
-0.2904706597,
-0.6912913918,
-0.2965546548,
0.4938252866,
-0.0315390602,
0.6153045893,
-0.4915975928,
0.0177279208,
-0.1702911705,
-0.3526466191,
0.2320986539,
0.6307703853,
-0.403287679,
-0.0837225169,
0.9516710043,
-0.0237618946,
0.7115414739,
0.6091077328,
0.1749067008,
-0.2967150807,
-0.5964631438,
-0.5487996936,
-0.1838990301,
-0.790063858,
0.2555065155,
-0.42178002,
0.0633018836,
-0.6303022504,
-0.5040981174,
-0.1234452724,
-0.503888607,
-0.3465077877,
0.0887610316,
0.2544770837,
0.8365693092,
0.4327270985,
-0.203496933,
-0.9794693589,
0.5299810171,
0.3543439806,
0.2655994892,
-0.4439663887,
-0.1603251547,
0.1261620969,
-0.1617052108,
-0.6100703478,
-0.7940776348,
0.7433276772,
0.4631502032,
0.6228182912,
0.3444673717,
0.4100253582,
0.1766888499,
-0.6668465137,
1.1094783545,
0.262576133,
-0.8556969166,
0.8034096956,
0.0452269875,
0.4117736518,
0.3523158729,
0.1315169483,
-0.5503948927,
-0.9064022303,
-0.4845851958,
-0.8802209496,
1.1526366472,
0.2909649014,
0.316047132,
-0.349524498,
-0.2561950386,
-0.0500867926,
0.2414675355,
0.0167804118,
-0.0432815403,
-0.2502372861,
-0.4334917068,
0.2136746049,
0.0697504506,
-0.0784886256,
0.1289691478,
0.3986454308,
-0.4244791567,
0.0198740624,
0.292080462,
-0.0861228853,
0.0974948257,
0.5525534153,
0.4359324276,
0.8651347756,
-0.3425958455,
0.3187874258,
0.0281199478,
-0.3344747722,
-0.3127855659,
0.1353833824,
-0.0025406994,
0.2236111015,
0.1886028349,
0.741286695,
0.1559112221,
-1.0443938971,
0.4251301587,
0.0242809374,
-0.0195602551,
-0.2370063514,
0.1751400977,
0.0908981487,
-0.1470746249,
0.1986582577,
-0.225905031,
0.2313175648,
-1.0428869724,
0.0409799851,
0.3857930601,
-0.4598552585,
-0.3361089528,
0.7270743251,
0.3147977293,
-0.5404093862,
0.6933320165,
-0.2627128661,
-0.5011491776,
0.4851412773,
0.4910024107,
1.0308504105,
0.114277795,
0.0420660675,
-0.1054697335,
-0.1368048638,
0.4991915524,
0.6595352292,
-0.1418567449,
-0.3694427311,
-0.5705291629,
-0.3260400295,
-0.6201030612,
-0.2725693583,
-0.3338901103,
0.516225338,
-0.3684246838,
-0.2143528014,
0.2554290295,
-0.2452987731,
-0.4309474826,
-0.2244821936,
0.1925976127,
1.1050821543,
-0.4593740106,
0.820753932,
1.0188732147,
-0.4460290372,
-0.4981265366,
-0.3056936264,
0.0502665304,
-0.6252555251,
1.1455438137,
0.0770562068,
-0.2134093791,
-0.0124928048,
-0.4790687859,
-0.2554100752,
0.9796332121,
0.5196867585,
0.0888044685,
0.0824050978,
0.6083785295,
0.6437121034,
-0.4247162938,
-0.0548935905,
0.6653558016,
0.3735165596,
0.1981659383,
-1.0142043829,
0.079365477,
-0.0262480695,
0.1593876332,
0.2686074078,
0.0697470829,
0.4683227539,
-0.3108854294,
-0.4337727726,
0.314321965,
0.781401813,
-0.0689989477,
0.4567389786,
0.3030440807,
0.0745097324,
0.3864771426,
0.1331726164,
1.404314518,
-0.772490561,
-0.1337817162,
1.0307900906,
-0.7748416662,
0.8380188346,
0.8644351959,
-0.2766028047,
0.5492111444,
-0.1580405682,
0.4291944504,
0.3949913681,
0.1503489763,
-0.4860928059,
-0.1444440186,
-0.4697115719,
-0.0231467802,
0.2796676755,
0.5178810358,
-0.3740020096,
-0.5579339862,
-0.1852903664,
-0.1977293044,
0.3907223344,
0.0382027365,
0.8845456839,
0.2787092924,
-0.8804551959,
0.5590743423,
0.2001386136,
0.2619389594,
-0.950352788,
-0.1869029105,
0.2900955081,
0.2485181391,
-0.2696729302,
-1.1210130453,
0.7097686529,
-0.052059304,
0.2162148505,
-0.6618105769,
0.8516051173,
-0.3476867378,
0.0112473872,
0.0911126137,
0.0877452716,
0.3145502508,
-0.1649964601,
-0.6322857141,
-0.0042951861,
-0.1623216122,
-0.1229087263,
0.1823316067,
0.6989405155,
-0.1262669563,
0.7661828995,
0.606582582,
0.1497343928,
0.1040455177,
0.2354719043,
0.6657602191,
-0.4156961441,
-0.6997765899,
-0.5412938595,
0.2415987402,
-0.1793756932,
0.0083195511,
0.897347033,
0.5750172138,
0.5315872431,
-0.4089170396,
0.8612786531,
-0.4637493193,
0.2066233456,
-0.6613175869,
0.3083012104,
-0.2922973335,
0.1575379819,
-0.222592473,
-0.6372209787,
-0.1840704829,
0.4301000535,
-0.7990841269,
-0.4109857082,
0.5155768394,
0.756316781,
-0.1323440969,
-0.0590970367,
0.6807291508,
-0.0388446823,
0.5100892782,
0.6165599823,
0.8117951155,
-0.0335766301,
0.7399373651,
0.0086674951,
-0.1909931451,
-0.3726911843,
-1.1979148388,
-0.6061427593,
-0.1807122529,
-0.5265384912,
-0.3244903982,
-0.3271443844,
1.2796604633,
0.5907510519,
-0.8924409747,
-0.359143585,
-0.5313386321,
0.1708829254,
-0.2368492931,
-0.3273157477,
0.3140513003,
-0.6788203716,
-0.9529537559,
0.6558145285,
0.4792174399,
-0.0364722274,
-0.254348129,
-0.4627372921,
-0.0637171865,
0.1423606724,
0.9001829624,
0.6188746095,
-0.6940522194,
-0.292740047,
0.0646496192,
-0.360812515,
-0.0589376315,
0.8036720157,
-0.5595001578,
0.8086233735,
0.9826790094,
0.509996295,
0.0139058372,
-0.0811410472,
1.0561865568,
-0.8733316064,
0.1997682899,
0.1902804822,
0.3079281449,
0.3773905337,
-0.0430163182,
0.4370497763,
0.0494805537,
-0.166433081,
-0.3861984313,
0.4879014492,
-1.0411843061,
-0.2757125795,
1.1451966763,
0.0371847935,
-0.4521324039,
-0.3743101656,
-0.9521028996,
0.0553386398,
-0.4217791557,
0.5951764584,
0.5247389078,
-0.5640397072,
0.4931122363,
-0.7435593605,
0.4890095592,
0.2668934166,
-0.6960910559,
0.1560127288,
0.711073637,
0.0927172452,
0.5287972689,
0.6225975156,
-0.2443431616,
0.139760226,
-0.0091000497,
0.0302970596,
-0.1636878401,
0.2130153924,
0.1111840233,
0.0361326188,
0.3478016555,
-0.4024809897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03457v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03457v2 | TwistList: Resources and Baselines for Tongue Twister Generation | 2023-06-06T07:20:51 | 2023-06-07T05:24:25 | Tyler Loakman, Chen Tang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous work in phonetically-grounded language generation has mainly focused
on domains such as lyrics and poetry. In this paper, we present work on the
generation of tongue twisters - a form of language that is required to be
phonetically conditioned to maximise sound overlap, whilst maintaining semantic
consistency with an input topic, and still being grammatically correct. We
present \textbf{TwistList}, a large annotated dataset of tongue twisters,
consisting of 2.1K+ human-authored examples. We additionally present several
benchmark systems (referred to as TwisterMisters) for the proposed task of
tongue twister generation, including models that both do and do not require
training on in-domain data. We present the results of automatic and human
evaluation to demonstrate the performance of existing mainstream pre-trained
models in this task with limited (or no) task specific training and data, and
no explicit phonetic knowledge. We find that the task of tongue twister
generation is challenging for models under these conditions, yet some models
are still capable of generating acceptable examples of this language type. | [
-0.4287035167,
-0.3878110051,
0.200374797,
-0.0892802849,
-0.1633597463,
0.1410430372,
-0.0941315442,
-0.2916690707,
0.2546108663,
0.8167135119,
-0.4658395052,
-0.0993042812,
-0.5348049402,
0.099852927,
-0.628909111,
1.1998567581,
0.2258054316,
-0.1962255538,
-0.0105644166,
0.0643555075,
-0.4791605771,
-0.2555750906,
-0.3150512278,
-0.4816704094,
0.2966397703,
0.4696168303,
0.691455543,
0.4677898586,
-0.1195972934,
0.2995463014,
-0.2967843711,
0.0006396475,
-0.5809084773,
0.4799236655,
-0.4048026204,
-0.2903967202,
-0.0304324646,
0.1586283147,
0.2014740855,
0.8500786424,
-0.007859055,
0.1821847856,
-0.2783460617,
0.4154625535,
-0.4631305933,
-0.3975912333,
-0.8557782769,
0.128274411,
-0.2869140804,
-0.1272046268,
-0.1694013774,
-0.6693192124,
0.4481379092,
-0.5269625783,
0.4201101959,
0.1046066955,
0.7459191084,
0.100572072,
-0.5970822573,
-0.5597848892,
-0.7307674289,
0.3910552561,
-0.4177242219,
0.7178376317,
0.1821103245,
0.2573567629,
-0.5524045229,
-0.7946116328,
-0.7741979361,
-0.3638559878,
0.3626292348,
-0.0688817427,
-0.0514439791,
-0.1966413856,
0.066854611,
0.3910170794,
-0.6332600713,
0.008089371,
-0.2820270658,
-0.0569611192,
0.4933929443,
-0.0741638392,
0.5394963622,
-0.3406017721,
-0.2214886397,
-0.2914069593,
-0.6982999444,
0.1188136041,
0.7172902226,
0.2845557332,
0.1281177104,
0.9315427542,
-0.0478865504,
0.313551873,
0.5239301324,
-0.3404448926,
0.1546825171,
-0.1719899476,
0.0004886297,
-0.1515052021,
0.5867729783,
0.1688174903,
0.5245869756,
-0.4154581428,
-0.4432087541,
-0.0557679795,
0.4829479754,
-0.5858179331,
-0.5976583362,
0.2358894944,
-0.0271271523,
-0.4625758529,
-0.0374593176,
-0.6550232172,
-0.4789963365,
-0.21573174,
0.2899123728,
-0.7292291522,
-0.7317412496,
-0.0734126121,
-0.7196164131,
0.0862209722,
-0.2351224571,
-0.7052677274,
0.499191165,
0.5053995252,
0.2577472329,
-0.0801313668,
-0.5136408806,
-0.3996150494,
-0.0893419534,
-0.2340183109,
0.7073194981,
-0.5152205229,
-0.5307745934,
0.259578824,
-0.1838796288,
0.0560957901,
-0.7845385671,
0.6929187775,
-0.355156064,
0.2730776072,
0.0030509534,
-0.7921636105,
-0.0250591021,
0.0357239619,
-0.6893143058,
0.9989907742,
0.2518347502,
-0.6602125764,
0.9176069498,
-0.2929563522,
-0.6184262037,
0.3805681467,
-0.3069181442,
-0.178200841,
0.268271327,
0.1956080198,
0.1457844526,
-0.3895725608,
0.66480726,
0.1513004303,
-0.0541905388,
0.4870019257,
-0.1876804978,
0.4938069284,
0.1256248057,
-0.7553587556,
0.0454796255,
-0.8412690759,
0.0379980318,
0.3156249821,
-0.3661643863,
-0.2572939992,
-0.1935654283,
0.6233126521,
0.3232056797,
-0.0840808898,
-0.4599969387,
0.2133588493,
-0.4157050252,
0.4731134176,
0.4231445193,
0.1411380023,
0.2943448424,
-0.2433249354,
0.5237139463,
0.4462102354,
0.018713126,
-0.0637402833,
-0.4510139525,
-0.8328765035,
0.1349846423,
0.6342252493,
0.2585615218,
-1.0123710632,
0.6901457906,
-0.6067383885,
-0.5692051649,
-0.4537928104,
0.2284176797,
0.5011641383,
0.2013662905,
0.1423879415,
-0.3736620545,
-0.5295530558,
-0.6878917217,
-0.4248747528,
-0.2084909379,
0.0308020618,
0.1406793892,
0.3812366724,
-0.0378474407,
1.1103166342,
-0.1744059026,
0.3419941068,
-0.4747536182,
0.3804326653,
0.0936485976,
0.5166316628,
0.3978050947,
-0.992687881,
-0.0339290425,
-0.1480177343,
-0.2686209381,
-0.0915955305,
0.0119985277,
0.0210243575,
0.049799189,
0.1729967594,
-0.8041561842,
0.0795841068,
0.2883852422,
-0.4226969481,
0.6016281843,
0.0927468762,
-0.2563098669,
-0.7816467881,
-0.0592017882,
0.2424256057,
-0.2203033268,
-1.0471510887,
-0.0321704037,
-0.1511281282,
-0.3519214094,
-0.5096806884,
0.8241278529,
-0.2635188401,
0.2546241283,
-0.4453769624,
0.2459437102,
-0.1957190633,
0.247438401,
0.3326643407,
0.6683200002,
0.4621345401,
-0.6712543964,
-0.0195862558,
0.1862549037,
0.0386190675,
0.7294493914,
-0.468624711,
0.2729048729,
0.0308549572,
0.1527887285,
-0.5998139977,
-0.4087300897,
0.1523056626,
-0.3573607504,
0.429735899,
-0.4410434365,
-0.2602420449,
-0.6226295233,
-0.2531262636,
0.4009971917,
0.8451114893,
-0.7887441516,
0.3494230211,
0.6295914054,
-0.0980512649,
-0.4594652355,
-0.1192602813,
0.0428144261,
-0.5590239167,
-0.5280191302,
0.0957203582,
0.1888482571,
-0.0027965226,
-0.0695496649,
-0.3679362237,
-0.0074187433,
-0.1955638081,
0.3057737648,
-0.2437860668,
-0.1297527552,
0.0412691906,
0.0392179415,
0.074644886,
0.0592654981,
-0.9479951262,
0.543507576,
0.1668727547,
-0.0910574049,
0.0479404777,
-0.1280099005,
0.4129612446,
0.0568509884,
0.1989485919,
0.6299988627,
-0.4308797121,
-0.3728360832,
-0.8643501401,
-0.0456236787,
-0.4555964768,
-0.0177715514,
-0.6292355657,
-0.7199746966,
0.2494481802,
-0.3299984932,
-0.2961355448,
0.3310422301,
0.3957740963,
-0.0220457464,
0.3995443583,
0.5596672297,
-0.094970867,
0.0988322124,
-0.0359919146,
0.1440409571,
-0.6519218683,
-0.0579341203,
-0.4129607677,
-0.0594760329,
-0.8928329349,
-0.0806299075,
0.1437837183,
0.3458271921,
-0.241262272,
0.578686893,
-0.5494199395,
0.4962052703,
0.7940711379,
-0.1606253982,
-0.075701952,
-0.3449876606,
-0.3828210533,
0.1434749812,
-0.7244694233,
-0.5865010023,
1.1459900141,
0.2209875584,
0.4829574227,
0.0503069758,
0.7211488485,
0.1488840431,
-0.3083394468,
-0.5195491314,
0.4543467462,
-0.1113389954,
-0.4330752194,
-0.4030216634,
-0.308844775,
-1.126105547,
-0.0742426515,
-0.1249656454,
-0.7006006241,
0.0370950699,
0.0294372942,
0.0842253342,
0.1162722185,
-0.44072631,
0.6750693321,
-0.3513993621,
-0.090621151,
0.4058043063,
-0.5744963884,
0.43565467,
-0.0545531549,
-0.029805081,
-0.0382725485,
0.3078932166,
0.8197636008,
-0.5138756037,
0.7982134819,
-0.4349458218,
-0.0196582824,
0.3413417935,
0.229093194,
0.4508062005,
0.1136684716,
0.3538720906,
-0.2774092853,
-0.1544337869,
-0.2037971765,
-0.4061141014,
0.5102302432,
-0.7215753794,
-0.5376945138,
-0.2765361369,
-0.4321714938,
-0.4274900258,
0.407510221,
0.3769370914,
0.2972769737,
-0.3148646951,
-0.1398232579,
0.5206135511,
-0.0004503411,
0.1243553758,
0.1940843612,
-0.3128505051,
-0.5948221087,
1.1580593586,
0.1118544042,
-0.2659062445,
0.1518783569,
0.3388353586,
-0.5853214264,
-0.8769569993,
-0.4853574038,
0.27184093,
-0.7437862754,
0.0007702652,
-0.4034367204,
-0.3110165,
-0.5270510316,
0.0362417772,
-0.2442250401,
-0.713018775,
0.1486818343,
-0.1583181471,
0.4973361492,
1.2347052097,
0.1282871813,
0.1231086031,
-0.4425279796,
0.4384708703,
0.3156264722,
0.3870826662,
-0.2527674735,
-0.3713382483,
-0.002445793,
-0.28134498,
-0.3766492009,
-0.7437036037,
0.1774338782,
0.1783580035,
0.6004155874,
0.0978922024,
0.1326111406,
0.4966026843,
-0.6302320957,
1.0130525827,
0.1286577731,
-1.2170807123,
0.8237615824,
-0.3663743734,
0.2642001212,
0.5600420237,
0.4660548568,
-0.6075133681,
-0.8202096224,
-0.885155201,
-1.0061093569,
0.3100850582,
0.6009657383,
-0.0183761138,
-0.1636905819,
0.5019577742,
0.5419347286,
0.4076155126,
-0.6641182303,
-0.0381742083,
-0.5673584342,
-0.2617640793,
-0.0670358166,
-0.1116690189,
-0.0843951255,
-0.0601287819,
0.6035531759,
-0.057525754,
-0.2170609236,
-0.041366566,
-0.5247944593,
-0.0243298989,
0.291849792,
0.7145413756,
0.4998296201,
0.0907565206,
0.2983987331,
-0.0008150237,
-0.8582450747,
0.3437581658,
-0.0634422079,
-0.3035229445,
-0.0187664255,
0.1632984877,
0.7522198558,
0.3419204652,
-0.7677192092,
0.4086868465,
0.118969366,
-0.0498094484,
-0.4918555915,
0.141991362,
0.0574537292,
0.1901836544,
0.2686998248,
-0.1320728511,
0.2981686592,
-0.174069792,
0.4900183082,
0.1949856281,
-0.2548189163,
-0.5389668345,
0.6081113219,
0.3342565298,
-0.4258438945,
0.6211189032,
-0.406716764,
-0.5570239425,
0.3044600785,
0.6710882783,
1.065574646,
-0.1558774263,
0.1386496425,
0.1432798654,
0.2894718051,
0.0131843295,
0.3653915226,
-0.0321059749,
-0.7098820806,
0.1206256002,
-0.5172505379,
-0.4940181375,
0.3168888688,
-0.4578127861,
0.4218121767,
-0.2883283794,
-0.2908002436,
0.1021758243,
-0.2435034364,
-0.9187189341,
0.3839690685,
0.293709904,
1.0866277218,
-0.8110197783,
0.7978408933,
0.7686844468,
-0.5363410711,
-0.6540009379,
0.2897111475,
0.0425437875,
-0.4195334315,
0.679705441,
0.0532526039,
-0.1541295201,
-0.1895109862,
-0.1510363668,
-0.654337883,
0.771625936,
0.069660984,
-0.0500372797,
-0.1693145484,
0.5934399962,
0.595000267,
-0.4571440816,
0.4724423885,
1.0500768423,
0.3689544499,
0.1006827876,
-1.0522699356,
0.1586950868,
-0.5919390917,
0.4295051098,
0.2118824571,
-0.1482836008,
0.7072227001,
0.3156598806,
-0.1277494729,
0.0783625841,
0.507946372,
0.444175005,
0.0397199653,
0.6896336079,
0.6376392245,
0.7948741317,
-0.2065911293,
0.6886785626,
-0.3795059025,
-0.030303631,
1.0800626278,
-0.5354585052,
0.8377624154,
0.5611302853,
0.0405876487,
0.1633878499,
0.4934215844,
0.1315821856,
0.2236794978,
0.609454453,
0.0962859765,
-0.003508413,
-0.1481920183,
-0.1346073449,
0.6587421894,
0.2002940923,
0.0902763531,
0.1508637071,
0.2361158431,
-0.1555322558,
0.0537064634,
-0.0741429776,
0.8600149751,
-0.2306236178,
-0.7265003324,
0.5670546889,
-0.4194698632,
0.83396703,
-0.1122176126,
0.145099014,
-0.1792622358,
-0.2093383372,
-0.0046458305,
-1.0455557108,
-0.1130242422,
0.1245513037,
-0.0709056854,
0.1076948345,
0.9479096532,
-0.4842032492,
-0.3732509911,
0.1542642564,
0.5930624604,
0.3370134532,
0.2359219342,
-0.2718725801,
-0.1392485797,
-0.3767027259,
-0.3521978259,
0.0445857346,
0.7115733624,
-0.0709660128,
0.6795764565,
0.4515865445,
0.150014922,
0.5182946324,
0.4437714517,
0.8930663466,
-0.9219064713,
-0.4566733539,
-0.1661231518,
0.7710405588,
-0.058209002,
-0.6715397239,
0.5576786995,
0.6353699565,
0.9906602502,
-0.2299631238,
0.9875537753,
0.0019125154,
0.6335564852,
-0.5860922933,
0.6141386032,
-0.3036867678,
-0.0856554434,
-0.088964805,
-0.9562319517,
0.1670368016,
-0.002805555,
-0.0259683803,
0.2982407212,
0.5268912315,
0.338681072,
-0.3195748627,
0.2902832627,
0.3153358102,
0.063088581,
0.2941715717,
0.2534735501,
1.0342134237,
-0.5991106629,
0.3626979291,
-0.4848034978,
0.1155126467,
-0.2211199999,
-0.6570584178,
-0.9535521269,
-0.9355648756,
-0.3491384387,
-0.2487426549,
0.0947937742,
1.1908568144,
0.6660072207,
-0.7508106828,
-0.5013982058,
-0.24664478,
0.0182069484,
-0.0388285108,
-0.1828998625,
-0.2170083523,
-0.484806627,
-0.7059989572,
0.6492766142,
-0.0463461988,
0.2163420171,
-0.3346539438,
-0.142724812,
0.1006139144,
0.1266319305,
0.4080483615,
0.5539810061,
-1.0769892931,
-0.505233109,
0.0168981273,
0.2572502792,
-0.1019522846,
1.0115953684,
-0.9215191007,
0.293200165,
0.2020552158,
0.3881523311,
0.5016652346,
-0.1708503664,
0.6082761288,
-1.019798398,
0.0740680695,
0.3870134354,
0.3323201835,
0.3287424445,
-0.1024644971,
0.4311406016,
0.0449072272,
-0.4665988684,
-0.9818119407,
0.3334461749,
-0.9234603643,
-0.0482899994,
1.0400297642,
0.1511421502,
-0.1043103561,
-0.4443538487,
0.1029243767,
0.3930751979,
-0.3036162555,
0.4672982693,
0.4943341017,
-0.0846947879,
-0.2435506135,
-0.0866349787,
0.6140290499,
0.1261227876,
-0.6071739793,
-0.0928912982,
0.1200594306,
0.4660104513,
0.4165225923,
0.3126112521,
0.2177603245,
0.3440961838,
0.3461027443,
0.4097180367,
0.2463864982,
-0.6288391352,
-0.3973816335,
0.2356289625,
0.495692879,
0.1852131635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03444v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03444v1 | Automatic Assessment of Oral Reading Accuracy for Reading Diagnostics | 2023-06-06T06:49:58 | 2023-06-06T06:49:58 | Bo Molenaar, Cristian Tejedor-Garcia, Helmer Strik, Catia Cucchiarini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic assessment of reading fluency using automatic speech recognition
(ASR) holds great potential for early detection of reading difficulties and
subsequent timely intervention. Precise assessment tools are required,
especially for languages other than English. In this study, we evaluate six
state-of-the-art ASR-based systems for automatically assessing Dutch oral
reading accuracy using Kaldi and Whisper. Results show our most successful
system reached substantial agreement with human evaluations (MCC = .63). The
same system reached the highest correlation between forced decoding confidence
scores and word correctness (r = .45). This system's language model (LM)
consisted of manual orthographic transcriptions and reading prompts of the test
data, which shows that including reading errors in the LM improves assessment
performance. We discuss the implications for developing automatic assessment
systems and identify possible avenues of future research. | [
-0.1223508641,
-0.6363704801,
0.2190807909,
0.3655621707,
-0.024480328,
0.2157822102,
-0.1751083136,
-0.9310081601,
0.0151842106,
0.1524881274,
-0.1338553727,
-0.2978631258,
-0.8828883767,
0.6510997415,
-0.7524507642,
0.0800664127,
-0.2560872436,
0.2772933245,
0.0462579764,
-0.1941370815,
-0.7780135274,
-0.1294498742,
-0.7214150429,
-0.4884430468,
0.3980730772,
0.4657531381,
0.5774877071,
0.6021562815,
0.6512264609,
0.4257512987,
-0.0170487445,
0.1309730411,
0.2214819342,
0.4194661975,
0.1384389699,
-0.1732636243,
-0.4640783966,
-0.2375085801,
0.7405033708,
0.8140630126,
-0.0718245357,
-0.0147709036,
0.2251080573,
0.7417898774,
-0.6582151651,
0.3451038003,
0.030235583,
-0.08226493,
-0.1075219214,
-0.0903228894,
-0.563182056,
-0.673119545,
0.7754967213,
-0.5558784008,
-0.0941427201,
0.006545723,
0.8884210587,
0.2407739609,
-0.5855259299,
-1.0659939051,
-0.6786859632,
0.5563032627,
-0.5117701888,
0.5259073973,
0.6306935549,
0.5238808393,
0.1954871863,
-0.4115414917,
-0.5932705998,
-0.2910913229,
-0.0721895546,
0.3064655662,
-0.4293525219,
-0.0337962918,
-0.1048468947,
0.324919343,
-0.6105864048,
0.1662956476,
-0.3021820188,
-0.3719556332,
0.8977320194,
0.0620975532,
0.4827956855,
-0.2236697525,
0.1132544354,
-0.5267270803,
-0.1262659431,
0.2528215647,
0.3985114396,
0.5123689175,
0.2904786766,
0.6333050728,
-0.1258944124,
0.8417485952,
-0.0624672733,
-0.2000086606,
0.3116031289,
-0.2306891382,
-0.1143295839,
0.3925962448,
0.849145472,
0.3908644617,
0.4586054087,
0.0272090994,
-0.4821662605,
0.39453578,
0.0895839036,
-0.2715685666,
-0.2705006003,
0.2481521666,
-0.3036204278,
-0.2062680274,
0.1419901401,
-0.5461077094,
-0.3734948039,
-0.2810367048,
0.8907439113,
-0.6356869936,
-0.2117053568,
0.5366616845,
-0.2656589746,
0.4043585658,
0.3872089684,
-0.7360377312,
0.6156511903,
0.2248048782,
0.7638136148,
-0.4641141593,
-0.0264887083,
-0.385821104,
-0.007548505,
-0.3525736034,
1.1585334539,
-0.3504680395,
-0.6179855466,
0.1810558736,
-0.0314258151,
-0.4511160851,
-0.4879232049,
0.476649195,
-0.503713727,
0.0945969447,
-0.1792690754,
-0.8527364731,
-0.3305098414,
0.1104955301,
-0.599168241,
1.1014586687,
-0.1290016323,
-0.4487754405,
0.4581939876,
-0.7410427928,
-0.6151545048,
0.1134438217,
0.2237838805,
-0.2320863158,
-0.1771824807,
0.3489302695,
0.2654178441,
0.0269258898,
0.0083162393,
0.2762227952,
-0.4506781399,
0.2160335332,
-0.6597704887,
0.9152984023,
0.0040549454,
-0.3893653154,
0.0675372183,
-0.7753612399,
0.4148386717,
-0.092989102,
-0.4103352427,
-0.1682786345,
-0.0535561405,
0.1305669099,
-0.4340728223,
0.1111798137,
-0.6077930331,
0.0335647762,
-0.7376275659,
0.1164783165,
0.3831506968,
-0.0116374269,
0.0777321383,
-0.3442397714,
0.6012113094,
-0.2437758893,
-0.0239773709,
-0.2024034709,
-0.6272947788,
-0.8356077671,
0.0038809795,
0.8571665883,
1.2220430374,
-0.6087209582,
0.8716889024,
-0.2048807293,
-0.624473393,
-0.5407904387,
-0.0247657597,
0.7105929852,
0.3846049607,
0.137353763,
-0.5442785025,
-0.1266905963,
-0.4781422317,
-0.3225866556,
-0.2422806323,
-0.0653207228,
0.2870027125,
0.2649760246,
-0.2834814489,
0.6671199203,
-0.2704605162,
-0.5871224999,
-0.1786497682,
0.1701074392,
-0.0941967666,
0.4534059167,
0.1503206939,
-0.6355429888,
-0.993838191,
0.2024187297,
-0.591155529,
-0.2298642248,
0.4415723979,
0.4137152135,
0.3972417712,
0.4523890615,
-0.1259993464,
0.5247938633,
0.4742112756,
-0.4943023324,
0.6554232836,
-0.5744198561,
0.4084957838,
-0.3747523129,
0.1591675133,
-0.0423088558,
-0.3856121302,
-0.624661684,
-0.1636626422,
0.1947646141,
0.0678950325,
-0.0461267643,
0.6313374639,
-0.6085715294,
-0.1869472116,
-0.2250066698,
0.238003239,
0.0247022584,
-0.2703911662,
-0.0555258691,
0.7806018591,
0.6169968843,
-0.5728809834,
0.3870723546,
0.4625152051,
-0.5703459382,
0.4723515213,
-0.7453669906,
0.2149446607,
0.1141032875,
0.017367376,
-1.2361290455,
-0.2860347629,
0.1244731247,
-0.6783786416,
0.6476422548,
0.3740128279,
-0.4577620625,
-0.4204352498,
0.141580686,
0.010772937,
0.4469092488,
-0.2791323364,
0.873332262,
0.4988922179,
-0.4996300638,
-0.6807874441,
-0.6089789271,
0.0704102144,
0.2382358313,
-0.6283535361,
-0.1031731218,
0.125297159,
-0.4147356749,
-0.2276244015,
-0.2268817425,
-0.349280864,
-0.0244749673,
0.0418126881,
0.1681452692,
-0.2689065039,
0.082866773,
0.2222639024,
-0.4565222263,
-0.0871547908,
-0.0024684882,
0.2075211704,
-0.3799236119,
-0.3294130862,
-0.8649476171,
0.2818389535,
0.3538329005,
-0.1426686943,
0.0159346163,
0.4149869084,
-0.3455451131,
0.0695470795,
-0.671995759,
-0.0475251116,
-0.5505501032,
-0.068175368,
-0.5750105977,
-0.6000084281,
0.5068002343,
0.2278543264,
-0.0455481298,
0.5020146966,
0.3213703334,
-0.4262561202,
1.17271626,
0.609813571,
0.1576141119,
0.3377892375,
-0.0219632313,
-0.1041386798,
-0.3127146959,
-0.0195212699,
-0.6666916013,
-0.0403189994,
-0.2504816949,
0.0235153157,
0.3517838717,
-0.085591808,
0.2542966008,
0.1718417406,
-0.811367929,
0.6200492978,
0.4662198722,
-0.0428623222,
0.6753468513,
-0.1659259498,
-0.4265320003,
-0.0905483216,
-0.3656192422,
-0.9369195104,
0.9820467234,
0.2637813091,
0.5096755028,
0.0654158592,
0.3315000534,
0.666338861,
0.2775154412,
-1.1163622141,
0.2117415667,
-0.2552787364,
-0.4911704957,
-0.723447144,
0.0240252111,
-1.1617320776,
0.1593760997,
0.0905669704,
-0.4646857083,
0.5903926492,
0.1089650691,
-0.7443863153,
-0.2095162123,
-1.2594797611,
0.7005624175,
0.0801620409,
0.6220422387,
0.070307754,
-0.8592996597,
-0.0687340945,
-0.0262073949,
-0.0888193846,
-0.0371893384,
-0.2319945544,
0.814598918,
-0.1940545142,
0.8036029339,
-0.32514745,
-0.1813522428,
0.4375210702,
0.1624982953,
0.2516057789,
-0.3533792794,
-0.3791426122,
0.0728819892,
0.6520578861,
-0.276442945,
-0.6064568758,
0.1139858663,
-0.8545976281,
-0.2399993539,
-0.9275619388,
-0.3320391178,
-0.5135294795,
0.4405585527,
0.0946295187,
0.7810329795,
-0.3622633219,
-0.1867949069,
0.6524339914,
0.0254662149,
0.3381616771,
0.8785091043,
-0.0801225454,
-0.3305461407,
0.9603857398,
0.4050007463,
0.3275170326,
0.0737703219,
0.3297426403,
-0.5972930789,
-0.792602241,
-0.6169389486,
0.0323406607,
-0.8079604506,
-0.1411164701,
-0.780846417,
-0.2643204033,
-0.4977547824,
-0.1707527488,
-0.1289268136,
-0.2736217976,
-0.2926626205,
-0.0566322021,
0.5389226079,
0.9984276295,
-0.2256441712,
0.4080504477,
-0.6866853833,
0.0765948147,
0.2614533603,
0.2479842901,
-0.0689525753,
-0.6255248785,
0.067034401,
-0.2597334087,
-0.2565996349,
-0.7977405787,
0.6242464185,
0.4769545794,
0.0941797495,
0.3883135319,
0.1508728117,
0.6354944706,
-0.6276516318,
0.4580028057,
-0.0866465867,
-1.2594680786,
0.5676071048,
-0.24671413,
0.3820620477,
0.7871816158,
0.3608342707,
-0.6661792994,
-0.6661766768,
-0.278542161,
-0.4742148221,
0.5126488209,
-0.0876383707,
-0.1831397861,
0.0118613923,
0.2869911194,
0.264219135,
-0.307753861,
-0.2123189867,
-0.2271661907,
-0.0422515497,
-0.5909801722,
-0.279921025,
-0.1679907739,
0.0847630575,
-0.4458374381,
0.6743502021,
-0.2582483888,
0.3916331828,
0.6513419747,
-0.3528340757,
-0.2665641308,
0.1782078892,
0.4757634699,
0.7612490654,
-0.2216405869,
-0.1191459969,
0.2162031084,
-1.0166131258,
0.4030115008,
0.3337611556,
-0.1352452487,
0.208493799,
0.3807502687,
0.2418298721,
0.0574558191,
-0.9689083099,
0.7982079983,
-0.3365878463,
-0.197567448,
-0.5347850919,
0.146130845,
-0.0369510315,
0.1605789214,
0.3925966918,
0.1622825861,
0.2872256637,
-0.1318731606,
0.2685934901,
0.0546549,
-0.7604219913,
-0.1556860954,
0.0985639244,
0.2544797957,
-0.5353790522,
0.4964076579,
-0.3022588789,
-0.4574969709,
0.3916549981,
0.4272323549,
0.5997006297,
-0.6341007948,
0.0083398493,
0.1811888814,
0.3988681436,
-0.1598492265,
0.7201200724,
0.0009922402,
-0.9096834064,
-0.4105610847,
-0.5038681626,
-0.6813403964,
-0.4237754345,
-1.0377115011,
0.2700896859,
-0.256781131,
-0.0650508106,
0.3050026596,
0.4676371217,
-0.4769171774,
0.4590160549,
-0.0693934783,
0.9707714319,
-0.8716474771,
0.8256700039,
0.4826526046,
-0.2725369036,
-0.7298777699,
-0.1276696622,
0.1282271594,
-0.9266815782,
0.5732109547,
0.250261873,
-0.3642250299,
0.3691719174,
-0.0208030082,
-0.9245277643,
0.9328055978,
0.0784430578,
-0.659653008,
-0.0633494854,
-0.1488367915,
0.7060929537,
-0.0029577762,
0.5384863019,
0.8686754107,
0.6574048996,
-0.0040453882,
-1.6445153952,
-0.2326741964,
-0.2098650634,
-0.142172426,
0.0896584168,
-0.277887851,
0.1859155446,
0.0501200669,
-0.5831159949,
0.3027231395,
0.740015924,
-0.0519198067,
0.3754198551,
0.6894876957,
0.2391208112,
1.0897283554,
-0.0719981641,
1.2052400112,
-0.0322872177,
-0.0225924291,
0.627169311,
-0.4242168665,
1.2041914463,
-0.0044977688,
-0.2572623491,
0.5123388767,
0.5910408497,
0.1280806065,
0.2672673464,
-0.015627658,
-0.3333880007,
-0.0362763181,
-0.0120786307,
-0.168486625,
0.5734066367,
0.633844614,
-0.0896659195,
-0.0063264426,
0.4450193644,
-0.3067085743,
0.2119125873,
-0.0814557374,
0.9474070072,
0.0176707022,
-0.4899747074,
0.6187122464,
-0.1467721909,
0.7999618649,
-0.4939098358,
0.2393095642,
0.2579306662,
0.2642758787,
0.0063970708,
-0.7616642714,
0.6022081971,
0.0262385421,
-0.1083938554,
-0.375202328,
0.932245791,
-0.2690827847,
-0.6208167672,
0.3243584633,
0.7580721378,
0.5110730529,
0.1390815675,
-0.826587975,
0.1381555051,
-0.2537895739,
-0.1715940386,
-0.1739752889,
0.2474410236,
0.216645658,
0.809314847,
0.4680802822,
0.2868785858,
0.1716078073,
0.2420211434,
0.204226464,
-0.6409551501,
-0.5212556124,
-0.4513973594,
0.2084123939,
0.1532349288,
-0.425986886,
0.8581108451,
0.2464161217,
0.5092693567,
0.2053523809,
0.5969229341,
0.1415597647,
1.0618382692,
-0.1996413171,
0.9844478369,
-0.3496477902,
-0.3153828681,
-0.4712649584,
-0.5915232897,
-0.7527353764,
0.9313522577,
-0.381722331,
-0.1275677532,
0.8990808129,
0.6875302196,
0.200048998,
0.4205721617,
0.3463749886,
0.2041817904,
0.0904846415,
0.0389776528,
0.8143809438,
-0.7196017504,
0.5417517424,
0.016549971,
-0.4483101666,
-0.154947564,
-0.5803434849,
-0.6451001167,
-0.5601069331,
-0.5328590274,
-0.4102649987,
0.4203462899,
0.800896883,
0.3512572348,
-1.0424067974,
-0.4489436746,
0.1309335679,
-0.1677506417,
-0.5738943815,
-0.2171162665,
0.6699587107,
-0.3028455973,
-0.7148457766,
0.5927976966,
0.305949688,
0.1849583685,
-0.395293057,
0.0683180466,
-0.0106197363,
0.1006294563,
0.575594008,
0.4268139303,
-0.7919572592,
-0.327819556,
0.2075977623,
-0.2794042826,
0.178930372,
0.3222702742,
-0.6862403154,
0.9750761986,
0.3557476103,
0.6966643333,
0.1969231516,
-0.0011856486,
0.7759110332,
-0.1282986403,
-0.2841358781,
0.657130003,
0.0762275979,
0.3713714778,
-0.3147261143,
0.2250686735,
0.0519717932,
-0.6591780186,
-1.0443475246,
-0.2777669132,
-0.7805353403,
0.1692526788,
0.8408403993,
-0.2076361179,
-0.3983721733,
-0.8305287957,
-0.2371177077,
0.0492848195,
-0.4318832457,
0.6297159195,
1.0733338594,
-0.2790048122,
0.0464801341,
-0.586276114,
0.4757168591,
0.5607636571,
-0.5062910318,
-0.0667059794,
0.2602083981,
0.2702430785,
0.4194260836,
0.7176198959,
-0.1385900527,
0.5027930737,
0.2382962704,
0.0644757822,
0.2112054229,
-0.1914655119,
-0.8071666956,
-0.1326458156,
0.0385981388,
-0.0172860362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03443v1 | Alzheimer Disease Classification through ASR-based Transcriptions: Exploring the Impact of Punctuation and Pauses | 2023-06-06T06:49:41 | 2023-06-06T06:49:41 | Lucía Gómez-Zaragozá, Simone Wills, Cristian Tejedor-Garcia, Javier Marín-Morales, Mariano Alcañiz, Helmer Strik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is the world's leading neurodegenerative disease,
which often results in communication difficulties. Analysing speech can serve
as a diagnostic tool for identifying the condition. The recent ADReSS challenge
provided a dataset for AD classification and highlighted the utility of manual
transcriptions. In this study, we used the new state-of-the-art Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) model Whisper to obtain the transcriptions, which also
include automatic punctuation. The classification models achieved test accuracy
scores of 0.854 and 0.833 combining the pretrained FastText word embeddings and
recurrent neural networks on manual and ASR transcripts respectively.
Additionally, we explored the influence of including pause information and
punctuation in the transcriptions. We found that punctuation only yielded minor
improvements in some cases, whereas pause encoding aided AD classification for
both manual and ASR transcriptions across all approaches investigated. | [
-0.0601052195,
-1.0543653965,
0.5788021684,
0.1056919694,
-0.1629364491,
-0.0389218666,
-0.1083116382,
-0.797966063,
0.2753617167,
0.3240417838,
-0.2500873506,
-0.5177922249,
-0.8911750317,
0.3155307174,
-0.337644428,
0.791221261,
-0.0270168465,
0.4443773925,
-0.1939981431,
-0.2234636545,
-0.6088535786,
-0.6449691653,
-1.1893497705,
0.0369944647,
0.1884156615,
0.1446687877,
0.558077693,
0.7992703915,
0.2678980231,
0.3152315915,
-0.6775656343,
0.1838802546,
0.3200347424,
0.076144442,
0.7076689005,
-0.065840371,
-0.5969891548,
0.3936031461,
0.4539830089,
0.7591792345,
-0.2343276143,
0.1250864416,
0.2909130752,
0.3225050271,
-0.2758129537,
0.3155783117,
0.0307647754,
0.2135759145,
-0.3463068902,
-0.0997978002,
-0.321721822,
-0.64026618,
0.4002256989,
-0.6469817162,
-0.1034568921,
0.1589816362,
0.7712880373,
0.5409502983,
-0.52119416,
-0.9072803259,
-0.5863093138,
0.5171380043,
-0.6984057426,
0.4412142932,
0.5064503551,
0.2454880774,
-0.0098278159,
-0.7109048367,
-0.3738039732,
-0.2686977684,
-0.0067553553,
-0.0520010181,
-0.5287801027,
0.1710373759,
0.2408377826,
0.4631287754,
-0.3816915452,
0.2499115169,
-0.7235475183,
-0.6986123919,
0.3135302067,
0.2164672464,
0.6236643195,
0.0490540937,
-0.2447991967,
0.147782743,
-0.3214743733,
0.2755732536,
0.1465400308,
0.2311501056,
0.1879861206,
0.3749191165,
-0.0543425195,
0.7058496475,
-0.0702686757,
-0.1207523942,
0.3227058649,
0.0090318331,
-0.1428724974,
0.4635811746,
0.7450605631,
0.2821624875,
0.0812783092,
-0.1648799181,
0.2562893033,
0.4680799842,
-0.187830016,
-0.582162261,
-0.3683064878,
0.2194802463,
-0.5144841671,
0.1105221808,
-0.0723823011,
-0.4669445157,
-0.1226987466,
-0.1655477881,
0.5013199449,
-0.6763624549,
0.2812294662,
0.4829332829,
-0.3645347059,
-0.0391377918,
0.5557118058,
-0.2515086234,
0.6354888082,
0.2462028116,
0.8707804084,
-0.3281454742,
-0.1639293283,
-0.8278657198,
0.1606363803,
-0.0070256586,
0.891505599,
-0.353179723,
-0.5670216084,
-0.0113729555,
-0.1502766013,
-0.5157219768,
-0.6713545322,
0.586938858,
-0.3418009579,
0.4875138104,
-0.1166621,
-0.6806846857,
-0.4114559889,
-0.0987943038,
-1.0457428694,
0.6491954327,
-0.3759386539,
-0.3863680661,
0.3879300356,
-0.6682931781,
-0.9633278251,
0.1093190312,
-0.0449106209,
-0.5457936525,
-0.0160937775,
0.2552170455,
0.147059083,
-0.2578230202,
-0.0608759336,
0.2415930331,
-0.1791725457,
0.5495097041,
-0.3788286448,
0.5759527683,
0.2000562698,
-0.1518356651,
0.0137052648,
-0.6154120564,
0.0126652699,
-0.2522002161,
-0.5339922905,
-0.2536168993,
0.0193747878,
-0.1728954762,
0.2333665192,
0.2593133748,
-0.5460688472,
0.0817087069,
0.0083068721,
0.5247415304,
0.4125252366,
0.3264722228,
0.0004035752,
-0.6371199489,
0.5679257512,
0.0118550872,
0.5032328963,
-0.3107956946,
-0.8724212646,
-0.5359003544,
-0.4887388051,
0.5641009212,
0.7753712535,
-0.1829451919,
0.3860034645,
-0.0172756482,
0.0260378886,
-1.0499322414,
-0.2441544533,
0.5854494572,
0.6055342555,
0.7081229091,
-0.5884287953,
-0.2587316632,
-0.4757728279,
-0.0687611625,
-0.1181526035,
0.140422076,
0.6334869266,
-0.0757127553,
-0.1571386606,
0.5305860639,
-0.7398248911,
-0.7537713051,
0.0865895227,
0.4362674952,
-0.2833933234,
0.347307831,
-0.2338362038,
-0.5324552655,
-0.2022914439,
-0.3507763147,
-0.559488833,
-0.4204392135,
0.3283456266,
0.4883082807,
0.1783277541,
0.8414521217,
-0.5681735277,
0.6791056991,
0.3442394733,
-0.5560756922,
0.6683720946,
-0.138653487,
0.2255109698,
-0.4065537453,
0.1895393878,
-0.419986546,
-0.1755283624,
-0.4390714169,
-0.717987299,
-0.3269510269,
-0.3022935987,
-0.1941109598,
0.2600374222,
-0.6119826436,
0.0875709206,
-0.1649859697,
-0.12432722,
0.2615256906,
-0.1161326841,
0.0693998411,
0.6843867898,
0.5998921394,
-0.7358677387,
-0.1662436873,
0.7491396666,
-0.3098840714,
0.066217877,
-0.7664409876,
0.2272309214,
0.2114279419,
0.2069509625,
-0.8141607046,
0.2949668169,
0.151377365,
-0.7656670809,
0.3261654675,
-0.086410515,
-0.4696981907,
-0.0730322599,
-0.1362824291,
0.4329635501,
0.515765667,
-0.020984998,
0.3949341774,
0.7109019756,
-0.3600755334,
-0.0894368514,
-0.6460418701,
0.0186846666,
-0.2258632928,
-0.5331842899,
0.1845662892,
-0.2799459696,
-0.0204983968,
-0.0096143847,
-0.1477631181,
-0.0511885509,
0.1386212707,
0.3204650879,
0.1264694035,
-0.2220602036,
-0.023892466,
-0.1222119331,
-0.2548149228,
-0.1276235133,
0.1389832646,
0.5999521017,
0.2154639214,
-0.1445369124,
-0.9669526815,
0.5462761521,
0.7034400105,
-0.4491590261,
0.27298069,
0.1236695945,
-0.2237410694,
-0.0514509901,
-0.5136207938,
-0.2487172186,
-0.4161354005,
-0.157548219,
-0.1499953568,
-0.8781944513,
0.5977320671,
-0.3219875097,
-0.4674078226,
0.2482436299,
0.0534588993,
-0.0823125467,
0.9400369525,
0.6287502646,
-0.137175262,
0.4076021314,
-0.0287682936,
-0.2777625322,
-1.0252152681,
-0.3241740763,
-0.518902421,
0.057248693,
-0.0893712416,
-0.4213201702,
0.4754231274,
-0.0391705297,
0.1074127331,
0.0120558022,
-0.7105596662,
0.0869411975,
0.2337000668,
0.1360312998,
0.415713042,
-0.2695867717,
-0.0637867376,
-0.147951901,
-0.5668970942,
-0.5885550976,
0.7295653224,
0.1887674034,
0.5129756331,
-0.0672145113,
0.3535853028,
0.6858193278,
0.0712861642,
-0.9374200702,
0.3100718558,
-0.4279772043,
-0.2097153664,
-0.2800060511,
-0.2682594061,
-1.1468640566,
-0.2823309004,
0.1785032004,
-0.643091917,
0.27846995,
0.2144481242,
-0.9568180442,
-0.1510411799,
-0.5076812506,
0.9105503559,
-0.3423623443,
0.3657614291,
0.1164548546,
-0.7155678272,
-0.0975167453,
0.2723035514,
0.3101744056,
-0.1481734812,
-0.1238078624,
1.3283830881,
-0.3715274632,
0.7679111958,
-0.0029899916,
0.0551666655,
0.311529994,
0.0471804701,
0.3175477982,
-0.2907267809,
0.020741744,
0.2942910492,
-0.2583470047,
0.024110755,
-0.3444847167,
0.3173353374,
-0.6605811119,
-0.3725539148,
-0.7798218131,
-0.2782755792,
-0.1000574157,
0.1166827381,
0.4232496917,
0.7391956449,
-0.3748032749,
-0.3711475432,
0.8230499029,
-0.1616763771,
0.3452416062,
0.8377491236,
0.0264247041,
-0.7877247334,
0.7085785866,
0.4537770748,
0.0986078307,
-0.05478286,
0.2570226789,
-0.0735848993,
-0.7027876377,
-0.3491176069,
0.1647119224,
-0.6014001369,
-0.2530275881,
-0.5761128664,
-0.2403692007,
-0.4996256828,
0.0718774647,
0.0082097622,
-0.4888319373,
-0.6114954948,
-0.035051316,
0.6186000705,
0.899574995,
-0.0681902021,
0.4429626465,
-0.7257623672,
0.0930124149,
0.2989307344,
0.0925672054,
-0.0140491575,
-0.7158505917,
-0.1406859159,
-0.3570221364,
-0.2699065208,
-1.0750968456,
0.2598737776,
0.645804882,
0.4125319421,
0.4756300151,
0.0143319611,
0.839453578,
-0.8747429252,
0.6530939937,
-0.0048845303,
-1.0941654444,
0.5702229738,
0.1468750387,
0.289844662,
0.5600081086,
0.4904919565,
-0.8500564098,
-0.3199477196,
-0.6606791019,
-1.1530021429,
0.6347494721,
0.2143967003,
-0.406491518,
-0.2928889096,
0.1903670281,
0.1922531128,
0.0503190756,
0.0649302751,
-0.3845809996,
0.0892274827,
-0.0450775512,
-0.0998244956,
-0.3363772035,
-0.0766055509,
-0.249545753,
0.4294988215,
0.2534920573,
0.4133548141,
0.5521657467,
-0.4170919955,
-0.0569606312,
-0.0117656821,
0.5489975214,
0.2103035599,
-0.0811381266,
0.1692754626,
0.1193307415,
-0.7645597458,
-0.0670116767,
0.667722106,
-0.3402809203,
0.3088804185,
0.4247244298,
0.7976754904,
0.2183466852,
-0.674476862,
0.5600875616,
-0.1654258668,
0.2502726614,
-0.5933166146,
-0.1327127069,
-0.0497273728,
0.2139953524,
0.3942994773,
0.1649398655,
0.5896949768,
-0.3404450119,
0.5501378179,
0.2906549573,
-0.5877149105,
-0.4991472065,
0.784335494,
0.0264628287,
-0.4805413485,
0.6515144706,
-0.0017148871,
-0.5600019097,
0.5190787315,
0.4818740785,
0.693551898,
-0.6426710486,
-0.0468716659,
-0.0774674937,
0.1295141131,
-0.1157202125,
0.4751848876,
-0.0937396213,
-0.4480747581,
-0.418467015,
-0.5279318094,
-0.4218677282,
0.1373799592,
-1.0873703957,
0.3221526742,
-0.4373107553,
-0.5290310383,
0.5556269884,
-0.062878117,
-0.4096215665,
0.321698457,
0.4176888168,
0.8870411515,
-1.0564004183,
0.73556602,
0.8701934218,
-0.4917706251,
-0.465660125,
0.2260251343,
0.0815847665,
-0.5635800362,
0.4319922626,
0.5573486686,
-0.188234061,
0.1251268834,
-0.5079987645,
-1.0181683302,
1.0771393776,
0.1692980379,
-0.162054047,
0.1001610085,
-0.1999958307,
0.4040258527,
-0.3089356422,
-0.0834585726,
0.4431323111,
0.3781910241,
0.0460547879,
-1.3307077885,
0.1923231333,
-0.2376077771,
-0.3264271021,
0.2582906485,
-0.6444196105,
0.7737565637,
-0.1177532524,
-0.5323559642,
0.1136558205,
0.5978422761,
0.2528676689,
0.5869916081,
0.3009991646,
0.7913219929,
0.922844708,
0.0238903034,
0.8445109725,
-0.1396427602,
-0.1909622848,
0.7363826632,
-0.284431994,
0.8520297408,
0.1790890992,
-0.1140083149,
0.5220026374,
0.4077909887,
0.2092841864,
0.4273216128,
0.3010606766,
-0.3686500192,
-0.0277923271,
-0.3048536777,
-0.1538471878,
0.3629298806,
0.7053161263,
-0.2912658453,
0.0573735908,
0.2576614916,
0.4694644511,
0.064918682,
-0.0736930519,
1.0914306641,
0.1728450805,
-0.2141586393,
0.352668196,
-0.1276390851,
0.6155781746,
-0.625874579,
-0.1838380247,
0.097871542,
0.0247351043,
0.1443828791,
-0.2754355669,
0.3526285887,
-0.1452507079,
-0.3568228185,
-0.0038690295,
0.4142837822,
-0.5684605837,
-0.258941263,
0.2791191041,
0.3143572509,
0.6479266286,
-0.0713421777,
-0.4462902546,
0.5779952407,
-0.3260701597,
-0.0256755687,
0.0123712113,
0.504170239,
-0.2262314856,
0.5802808404,
0.6112345457,
0.3398792744,
0.1186594889,
-0.3547753096,
0.6947751641,
-0.7534542084,
-0.5374276638,
-0.8999096155,
0.2306416184,
-0.0565915965,
-0.5951592922,
0.8048858047,
0.6694302559,
0.0544700027,
0.0813587308,
0.6557841301,
0.0124287205,
0.5966664553,
-0.6506137848,
0.7696253657,
-0.1971142143,
-0.0091106957,
-0.0561130159,
-0.0654062107,
-0.5071696043,
0.4717193246,
-0.4065149426,
-0.1505268514,
0.8168879747,
0.2873803675,
0.1118965819,
-0.0759583563,
0.0428755395,
0.3787940145,
0.0246910919,
0.4716337025,
0.6322606802,
-0.4910875559,
0.6410939097,
0.1220375821,
-0.2997203767,
-0.2661229968,
-0.693035543,
-0.4324804544,
-0.6676207781,
-0.7530010343,
-0.4183665216,
0.4163845479,
0.6079374552,
0.4952091873,
-0.8175693154,
-0.1096417829,
0.4271723926,
-0.0959945917,
-0.4678060412,
-0.1600385755,
1.1329145432,
-0.0094510969,
-0.4826608896,
0.7401755452,
0.1640030444,
0.4531404078,
0.3250898123,
0.052600801,
-0.2508403957,
0.0138368616,
0.5084850788,
0.6447637081,
-0.5456774831,
-0.0524589121,
0.04230069,
-0.0286321267,
0.1569200307,
0.8154164553,
-0.9100174308,
0.3386425078,
0.0767528862,
0.3880541623,
0.2462232113,
0.2213339508,
0.5969957113,
-0.3996495306,
-0.0547896624,
0.5664708614,
0.2654080987,
0.5826058388,
-0.5476055741,
-0.089795433,
0.2203015238,
-0.6543785334,
-0.7311214805,
0.1403487921,
-0.9869197607,
-0.1865818948,
1.151556015,
-0.1166433766,
-0.3402014375,
-0.7014668584,
-0.4280897081,
0.568785131,
-0.6430978179,
0.8552119136,
0.4536726475,
-0.5734008551,
-0.0900837034,
-0.6015648842,
1.0709108114,
0.368755877,
-0.4689683616,
0.0037187391,
0.66085428,
0.2862231433,
0.1042252928,
0.8410502672,
-0.417658031,
0.4997630417,
-0.2711054981,
0.2491127253,
-0.3297744691,
-0.2259265035,
-0.801399827,
-0.0098678153,
0.1886280775,
-0.6016526818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03438v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03438v2 | Large Language Models of Code Fail at Completing Code with Potential Bugs | 2023-06-06T06:35:27 | 2023-12-01T01:27:37 | Tuan Dinh, Jinman Zhao, Samson Tan, Renato Negrinho, Leonard Lausen, Sheng Zha, George Karypis | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Large language models of code (Code-LLMs) have recently brought tremendous
advances to code completion, a fundamental feature of programming assistance
and code intelligence. However, most existing works ignore the possible
presence of bugs in the code context for generation, which are inevitable in
software development. Therefore, we introduce and study the buggy-code
completion problem, inspired by the realistic scenario of real-time code
suggestion where the code context contains potential bugs -- anti-patterns that
can become bugs in the completed program. To systematically study the task, we
introduce two datasets: one with synthetic bugs derived from semantics-altering
operator changes (buggy-HumanEval) and one with realistic bugs derived from
user submissions to coding problems (buggy-FixEval). We find that the presence
of potential bugs significantly degrades the generation performance of the
high-performing Code-LLMs. For instance, the passing rates of CODEGEN-2B-MONO
on test cases of buggy-HumanEval drop more than 50% given a single potential
bug in the context. Finally, we investigate several post-hoc methods for
mitigating the adverse effect of potential bugs and find that there remains a
significant gap in post-mitigation performance. | [
-0.5301523209,
-0.7231795192,
0.6171965599,
0.0321839117,
-0.1417289078,
0.4217624366,
-0.4749800563,
-0.7148054242,
0.3948861063,
0.4087699056,
-0.6537741423,
-0.4530911446,
-0.3345837593,
0.0435533263,
-0.4716234803,
0.964356184,
-0.0426510274,
-0.2585538328,
-0.4895020723,
0.3326143622,
-0.6313504577,
-0.6996458173,
-0.3578965664,
0.0795226544,
0.5321843028,
0.597633183,
0.5191804171,
0.4890409708,
0.4814355075,
0.1784586161,
-0.0481619835,
0.13102144,
-0.5656032562,
0.3024143577,
0.2960783839,
-0.7423030138,
-0.6241189837,
0.036933288,
0.3819314539,
0.5303538442,
-0.0142459879,
0.1132102385,
0.1273419559,
0.3700173497,
-0.5394768715,
0.2377312779,
-0.5717552304,
0.1822702587,
-0.3482011259,
-0.169324249,
-0.3047786355,
-0.2826140821,
-0.3729456067,
-0.3226574361,
0.1258276552,
-0.1448541284,
0.7465367913,
0.4967966974,
-0.1554564685,
-0.4400906265,
-0.623958528,
0.5051656365,
-0.8668350577,
0.0613145344,
0.6633934379,
-0.0734373555,
-0.5667414665,
-0.2053093016,
-0.464301765,
-0.6857553124,
0.0687347129,
-0.0584657788,
0.0417826027,
0.1465921998,
0.75551337,
0.2164981812,
-0.6959063411,
0.0254134517,
-0.3709011972,
-0.1905260235,
0.5418303013,
0.1113763079,
0.1993375272,
-0.2378171384,
0.0276245009,
0.2800466418,
-1.0428786278,
0.1785693467,
0.4671702385,
-0.0851881057,
0.0918554366,
0.4560118914,
-0.0467081144,
1.103978157,
-0.420966059,
0.0838385522,
0.3305966258,
-0.3579165041,
0.0714189336,
-0.259973824,
0.1946991533,
0.2482343614,
0.4336513281,
-0.2880529761,
-0.3508711457,
0.3738173544,
0.3369080722,
-0.4587903917,
-0.3382818401,
0.3168958127,
-0.2470682412,
-0.4037068784,
0.1088975742,
-0.5027640462,
-0.2329591662,
-0.1836988926,
0.1015288308,
-0.1805404425,
-0.4054663479,
-0.0404120199,
0.1447950304,
0.2024772763,
0.0840900317,
-0.1914773434,
-0.3006949127,
0.6588075161,
0.6548004746,
0.1875445694,
-0.3125016391,
-0.8257421851,
0.0075384355,
-0.6357424259,
0.9128391743,
-0.6598904729,
-0.6173460484,
-0.228261441,
-0.2350679487,
0.200387463,
-0.7647242546,
0.1615404189,
-0.3741877675,
-0.0889128372,
-0.4042701125,
-0.4055193365,
0.0701157749,
0.3092018068,
-0.4714102447,
0.8621345758,
0.1448680013,
-0.5031895041,
0.3884029388,
-0.4442222118,
-0.4654705524,
0.0382461697,
-0.3064535558,
-0.4553368688,
0.3499210477,
-0.4504532814,
0.1856874824,
-0.2246315777,
0.3862405419,
-0.2858197391,
-0.8318736553,
0.366897583,
-0.0554034673,
0.3993483186,
0.2800597548,
-0.3823154569,
0.1467428952,
-0.7550559044,
0.0691023543,
0.0386692919,
-0.4045710266,
-0.3108788729,
0.3297711611,
-0.0575010329,
0.5501978397,
0.1424286515,
-0.4307279885,
0.7186864018,
-0.235440433,
0.4095590413,
0.7693722844,
-0.1356052309,
0.0849577785,
-0.5351252556,
0.8813760281,
-0.0434917659,
0.2347270846,
-0.4678886533,
-0.4774680734,
-0.7977722883,
-0.255192548,
0.505376339,
0.6717198491,
-0.8861142993,
0.3934191465,
-0.0560842343,
-0.3216092587,
-0.1641844213,
0.1019680128,
0.748873353,
0.1196866482,
0.1577731371,
-0.2981860042,
-0.7527025342,
-0.7047773004,
-0.3584722281,
-0.2020480335,
-0.1761807948,
0.2008696049,
0.2073618174,
-0.6719604731,
1.1484392881,
-0.5111003518,
-0.0439048447,
-0.0316961445,
-0.0544560999,
0.1247923672,
0.5442566872,
0.5791785121,
-0.5886558294,
-0.1179335415,
-0.5454667211,
-0.5865867734,
-0.500944674,
0.0400645398,
0.175089702,
0.6008268595,
0.6655547619,
-0.4873225391,
0.5360155106,
0.6529054046,
-0.4058270752,
0.7369864583,
-0.2367779911,
0.2338651866,
-0.8801055551,
-0.0594987348,
-0.1688404083,
-0.3100996315,
-0.3257873356,
0.2910700142,
0.1364972144,
-0.2245801836,
-0.1383401901,
0.1902717501,
-0.566554606,
-0.1207841262,
-0.2894934714,
-0.1424171925,
-0.3824302256,
0.4393232167,
-0.3494992852,
0.7616304159,
0.5490120649,
-0.5844463706,
0.3295970857,
-0.2976476848,
-0.1928054541,
-0.0049530822,
-0.4578157663,
0.1606375873,
-0.1665176302,
0.2535188794,
-0.9176868796,
-0.3289660513,
0.2258722931,
-0.5259702206,
0.3802675605,
-0.264497757,
-0.8139389157,
-0.5002275705,
-0.3489383757,
0.4786128998,
0.8494887948,
-0.2164133638,
-0.0983897373,
0.1362817436,
-0.1548756957,
-0.3000051379,
-0.6928600669,
0.4492608905,
-0.0393268317,
-0.4644985497,
0.1077026352,
-0.2434745878,
-0.1856381446,
0.3056486845,
-0.2884194553,
0.1697884649,
0.3237435222,
0.3168551922,
0.4097167253,
0.0517687649,
-0.0246355701,
-0.2499741167,
-0.3700895309,
0.2343082428,
-0.1353401244,
0.5273552537,
-0.066712819,
-0.5890083909,
0.1088585481,
0.320581466,
0.5940403342,
-0.3855071962,
0.4134136736,
0.1125047132,
-0.4716386199,
-0.349188298,
-0.6126570702,
-0.1419804394,
-0.369076848,
0.5089934468,
-0.3253388703,
-0.7372330427,
0.6926468611,
0.0485958531,
0.1184334904,
0.0830059499,
0.0585756898,
0.0052230703,
0.9374501109,
0.5760974884,
0.1855944842,
0.5678604841,
-0.4432309568,
0.3953208625,
-0.4740822315,
-0.1407647878,
-0.4902947843,
-0.0794110447,
-0.6184193492,
-0.6330824494,
0.370003134,
0.4495470822,
0.2828748524,
0.6119182706,
-0.3388932943,
0.4538996816,
0.6251577735,
-0.0330480188,
0.2759573162,
-0.0597038791,
-0.0492217354,
0.0067806402,
-0.8381758928,
-0.2512387335,
0.8488903046,
0.0196629893,
0.6509841681,
0.1059636846,
0.8881332874,
0.4580768049,
0.2879752219,
-0.5616531372,
0.6179406643,
0.0614473224,
-0.319234103,
-0.0046154787,
-0.7083340883,
-0.7702888846,
-0.1524403095,
-0.0715537593,
-0.4044202268,
-0.1307094395,
0.5237204432,
-0.4102692008,
0.1122303978,
-0.6617750525,
0.9660517573,
-0.0698850453,
-0.4086111486,
-0.4777956307,
-0.4950317442,
0.4254699647,
-0.3507931828,
0.5608354807,
-0.0267713219,
0.0528203733,
0.4234135449,
-0.5778473616,
0.557574749,
-0.2955833673,
-0.3626886308,
0.2897360921,
0.3687529862,
0.5906364918,
0.1686715931,
-0.0102350758,
0.0867331102,
-0.1571074873,
-0.6195627451,
-0.3982067108,
0.7076127529,
-0.2443591356,
-0.6194125414,
-0.4937550724,
-0.3784545362,
-0.1720257699,
-0.0615452155,
0.5330791473,
0.7964169979,
0.2424806356,
-0.2442305684,
0.7569023371,
-0.5144718885,
0.6198490262,
0.4561917186,
-0.5195544958,
0.002781786,
1.069593668,
0.4511987567,
0.2100077868,
-0.256205231,
-0.3136489689,
0.1277622133,
-0.6525642872,
-0.4704588354,
0.1050776318,
-0.4058467448,
-0.4278718233,
-0.3307679296,
-0.3445028067,
-0.1277657598,
-0.2958483994,
-0.2722985148,
-0.0707073957,
-0.2210644186,
0.1059632823,
0.4751058221,
0.8513532281,
-0.0116338711,
-0.1604208946,
-1.2490190268,
0.2764288783,
-0.0626393035,
0.6281598806,
-0.0209100116,
-0.2745384276,
-0.5428008437,
0.1820890456,
0.0579396486,
-0.8911620975,
0.2197642177,
-0.1925469786,
0.5322012901,
-0.0989984944,
0.1499339044,
0.6623923182,
-0.4265927076,
0.8182919025,
0.0136336768,
-0.9958052635,
0.6144842505,
-0.5034137964,
0.4395519793,
0.2828738689,
-0.0894652531,
-0.649579227,
-0.8669803739,
-0.5905483961,
-1.0970824957,
0.6125670671,
0.2605476379,
-0.0646264106,
-0.3879880607,
0.465267241,
-0.146957323,
0.2946012914,
-0.6226412058,
-0.159624517,
0.1720925719,
0.1385897994,
-0.1211356074,
-0.4946381152,
0.400546968,
-0.0279654413,
0.6155292988,
0.102704145,
0.1947747618,
0.095134221,
-0.4872592092,
-0.4031134248,
0.2736686766,
0.9978957772,
0.8399874568,
-0.1448304653,
-0.0318925679,
-0.2085200995,
-0.0876646638,
0.0661493912,
0.0088435421,
-0.2746024132,
0.0061949701,
0.4234586656,
0.4264035821,
0.2749417722,
-1.1453689337,
0.5168095827,
0.1084060073,
0.0664502531,
-0.6026985049,
0.3581960499,
-0.0786408037,
0.0592041276,
0.5620467067,
0.3775515556,
0.0877417028,
-0.6628975272,
0.2961475849,
0.3798220754,
-0.2332723439,
-0.304356873,
0.5721593499,
0.2946638465,
-0.5063325167,
0.632286191,
-0.7769014239,
-0.7872297764,
1.1533223391,
0.3144925535,
0.7678385377,
-0.0389201604,
-0.0826395303,
0.2134247869,
0.3695014417,
-0.0973345786,
0.4947615266,
0.0970507637,
-0.1746043712,
-0.9234070182,
-0.580334723,
-0.1335321814,
0.0011157386,
-0.351190716,
0.3223978877,
-0.1749541312,
-0.164151445,
-0.602770865,
-0.0413744822,
-0.2539720833,
-0.2273892164,
0.2937439978,
0.8309534788,
-0.5628483891,
0.9064363241,
0.8305262327,
-0.4562762976,
-0.631111145,
0.4535747468,
-0.1002288088,
-0.1661991924,
0.4363274872,
0.2510306537,
0.0298071094,
0.0234911945,
-0.2369648367,
-0.8399597406,
0.5046292543,
0.4850118458,
-0.8260974288,
-0.1935593188,
-0.1088734642,
0.4237672091,
0.0685028732,
0.0380815826,
0.3055532873,
0.5143170357,
-0.1523380429,
-1.2308726311,
-0.0057216282,
-0.3401534259,
0.2761179507,
0.6460164785,
-0.5242945552,
0.8715962172,
-0.4482375681,
0.1078014001,
0.1383578777,
0.1429850459,
0.4164280891,
0.2710778713,
0.6040619016,
0.6826615334,
0.4373272657,
-0.0770300329,
0.9660980701,
-0.5326766968,
0.4688557982,
0.7972944379,
-0.2656893134,
0.5400616527,
0.2018876821,
-0.1856110245,
0.3855296075,
0.8535764217,
0.0850051567,
0.3068601787,
0.774335146,
-0.2674970031,
-0.2934662402,
0.1935978532,
-0.7067090273,
0.3212115169,
0.2358219624,
0.0705280304,
-0.106555745,
0.3451095819,
0.0031894764,
0.0537196547,
-0.4065293074,
0.5918694139,
0.0113515714,
-0.8952900171,
0.8457706571,
-0.0351228192,
0.9422149062,
-0.5254769921,
-0.2207326889,
-0.4027257264,
0.1036662236,
-0.4428798854,
-0.340757817,
0.6016972065,
0.2249417305,
-0.4335859418,
-0.128977567,
0.3550769091,
-0.6661888361,
-0.3336110711,
0.4966290891,
0.3115559816,
0.0696134642,
-0.169639945,
-0.2745153904,
0.3291982114,
0.0346131623,
-0.186060667,
0.3549355268,
0.1544569582,
-0.066444926,
0.4761585593,
0.5497686267,
0.2263302505,
0.0920564085,
-0.2381844372,
0.953369081,
-0.7523325682,
-0.4468021095,
-0.8309364319,
0.3131105006,
0.1667849123,
0.0968515798,
0.6790971756,
0.6908780336,
1.0418989658,
-0.156272769,
0.7870609164,
-0.341358453,
0.3243729472,
-0.5828021169,
0.6109030247,
-0.5442534089,
0.7747776508,
-0.5275568366,
-1.0823981762,
-0.2942784131,
0.5205243826,
-0.1327261627,
0.1180155054,
0.6099419594,
0.9996698499,
0.1176445931,
-0.4484315217,
0.4157227576,
0.3159637749,
0.2958144248,
0.835352242,
1.086227417,
-0.1572703421,
0.6108490229,
0.0177637469,
-0.3981682956,
-0.508503437,
-0.8024402261,
-0.4448886514,
-0.4204482138,
-0.4264665842,
-0.729095459,
0.245580256,
1.154761076,
0.5909507871,
-0.634983182,
-0.1395273358,
-0.2893392742,
0.2799553573,
-0.0341931731,
-0.2154827118,
-0.148840189,
-0.6720398068,
-0.3845014274,
0.3551006913,
0.2272163779,
-0.1254432797,
-0.1670373827,
-0.0844838023,
0.1301087588,
-0.0663161501,
0.5449001193,
0.3738630116,
-0.7520548701,
-0.3459473252,
0.1082059443,
-0.2052522004,
-0.065964438,
1.1105540991,
-1.0336279869,
0.2599644065,
0.3667159081,
0.4801665545,
0.1211876646,
-0.2516741157,
0.4307728112,
-0.7604106069,
0.3414191008,
0.2226384282,
0.3289928436,
-0.0953812301,
-0.4370583296,
0.4903521836,
0.4605182409,
-0.5056831241,
-1.1225324869,
0.4993426502,
-0.6104462147,
-0.5719233751,
1.2045835257,
-0.0968648642,
0.0490297563,
-0.1573852152,
-0.1762079149,
0.225610733,
-0.2658897042,
0.9015607834,
0.8260443807,
-0.1362900138,
-0.0892457962,
-0.6768195629,
0.6533558965,
0.3610338867,
-0.7002200484,
0.2184862792,
0.948153615,
0.2072328329,
0.0589837842,
0.665905714,
0.0721626431,
0.6166079044,
-0.0741941109,
0.2595843673,
-0.2875206769,
-0.5403621793,
-0.4755154252,
-0.0308914464,
0.5207673907,
0.0834269673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03435v1 | On the Role of Attention in Prompt-tuning | 2023-06-06T06:23:38 | 2023-06-06T06:23:38 | Samet Oymak, Ankit Singh Rawat, Mahdi Soltanolkotabi, Christos Thrampoulidis | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Prompt-tuning is an emerging strategy to adapt large language models (LLM) to
downstream tasks by learning a (soft-)prompt parameter from data. Despite its
success in LLMs, there is limited theoretical understanding of the power of
prompt-tuning and the role of the attention mechanism in prompting. In this
work, we explore prompt-tuning for one-layer attention architectures and study
contextual mixture-models where each input token belongs to a context-relevant
or -irrelevant set. We isolate the role of prompt-tuning through a
self-contained prompt-attention model. Our contributions are as follows: (1) We
show that softmax-prompt-attention is provably more expressive than
softmax-self-attention and linear-prompt-attention under our contextual data
model. (2) We analyze the initial trajectory of gradient descent and show that
it learns the prompt and prediction head with near-optimal sample complexity
and demonstrate how prompt can provably attend to sparse context-relevant
tokens. (3) Assuming a known prompt but an unknown prediction head, we
characterize the exact finite sample performance of prompt-attention which
reveals the fundamental performance limits and the precise benefit of the
context information. We also provide experiments that verify our theoretical
insights on real datasets and demonstrate how prompt-tuning enables the model
to attend to context-relevant information. | [
-0.5894325376,
-0.8110384345,
0.6356193423,
0.3438995183,
-0.102734521,
-0.4730741382,
-0.3372269571,
0.0586903207,
-0.2227835059,
0.3949057162,
-1.1587218046,
-0.0762852803,
-0.1643101424,
0.2841445208,
-0.1026034951,
1.0726730824,
0.3941597641,
-0.0812651441,
-0.2184187919,
-0.0258474424,
-1.1666533947,
-0.1404477954,
-0.9664200544,
0.0344728492,
1.0875582695,
0.4891886413,
0.2838024199,
1.0197591782,
0.1041717902,
0.274780333,
-0.0910811499,
-0.0741510019,
-0.6143219471,
0.4251600802,
-0.416639477,
-0.65945822,
-0.1591389626,
0.2504663765,
0.6133523583,
0.7201817632,
0.2291055918,
0.2446849197,
0.45918715,
0.4909792244,
-0.5497286916,
0.0302734766,
-0.7117376924,
-0.0513954051,
-0.1673493683,
-0.5411507487,
-0.4919269979,
0.120484367,
0.1305168718,
-0.7274284959,
0.4773483574,
0.4547426999,
0.2731909156,
0.7565226555,
-0.3197815716,
-0.051757127,
-0.2272943854,
0.7644088864,
-0.3049152195,
0.0399287492,
0.2923575044,
0.2197293043,
-0.1816579849,
-0.4118267298,
-0.2217136919,
-0.0118433032,
-0.0693867579,
0.13918975,
0.19082129,
0.197635904,
0.5526477695,
0.2807857096,
-0.4431684613,
0.1935340762,
-0.0678836554,
-0.2098984718,
0.0326617919,
0.3824273646,
0.1508550942,
-0.0562193878,
-0.4590745568,
0.1526152343,
-0.6626326442,
0.4450493753,
-0.0369369276,
0.7655538917,
-0.2193734497,
0.2570317388,
-0.1519556046,
1.142680645,
0.7025462389,
0.0137028983,
-0.2160181254,
-0.4533868432,
-0.2786163986,
0.3149722815,
0.4024268091,
0.3126687109,
0.2904034555,
-0.1431761682,
-0.3095188141,
-0.160633862,
0.23857297,
-0.617433548,
0.0973076075,
0.1821148694,
-0.3018570244,
-0.1228340492,
-0.191128552,
-0.5047200918,
-0.4678390324,
-0.6332995296,
0.5386551619,
-0.1422205865,
-0.0558472686,
-0.1193253249,
-0.2104386985,
0.3781054914,
0.2189114392,
-0.9920913577,
-0.0979807302,
0.8352769613,
0.8751943707,
-0.2737459242,
-0.4443872571,
-1.1840145588,
-0.0705131069,
-0.4112361372,
0.7475649714,
-0.6706708074,
-0.2083920687,
-0.0299889501,
0.1146038473,
-0.5043445826,
-0.3762025237,
0.7995041609,
-0.5196186304,
0.3111937344,
-0.680472374,
-0.4521220624,
0.0485599488,
0.0444596,
-0.6123993993,
0.8020331264,
0.3457126915,
-0.7417636514,
0.5512664914,
-0.5446940064,
-0.5293179154,
0.2693047523,
-0.0248230919,
0.0731603131,
0.3368909657,
0.3842693567,
0.5739314556,
-0.4033218622,
0.2107368559,
-0.3508568704,
-0.5049964786,
0.2837251127,
-0.3247484863,
0.633086741,
0.0990699977,
-0.2848636806,
0.3381038904,
-0.7052506208,
-0.2187400311,
-0.1519193947,
-0.1915258169,
-0.2723347247,
-0.2168614864,
-0.0114857648,
0.3829216361,
0.1389379203,
-0.2314511091,
0.0850727856,
-0.5506604314,
0.4659624696,
0.9881655574,
0.1769006997,
0.6554346085,
-0.2971729338,
0.794988811,
0.1328394115,
0.1015877575,
-1.0983165503,
-0.2423363179,
-0.676261425,
-0.292037636,
0.5437401533,
0.4470078349,
-0.4894540906,
0.4612973332,
0.0380461328,
0.0656961799,
-0.6866801977,
-0.0129452385,
0.2112958133,
1.2885015011,
0.0630484,
0.1876556426,
-0.237157464,
-0.7827127576,
-0.3758587539,
0.2062940747,
-0.0444354974,
0.6169511676,
-0.1101804003,
0.1735558957,
1.1483447552,
-0.1905194372,
-0.2483433038,
-0.2838277519,
-0.1878101975,
0.4602417648,
0.5408108234,
0.6553506851,
-0.5440764427,
-0.449854821,
-0.1390515417,
-0.4669086933,
-0.4679718614,
-0.332393527,
-0.207410723,
-0.1719962507,
0.5491983891,
-0.517811358,
0.1177909374,
0.1074795127,
-0.5894209743,
0.3609148562,
0.007630873,
0.0361592397,
-0.8366143703,
0.1508095711,
0.0889160857,
-0.256865859,
-0.6284091473,
-0.0097749159,
0.1743732095,
-0.2398867756,
-0.2503791153,
0.8915911317,
-0.4013944864,
-0.0075370977,
-0.4493789971,
0.1419766843,
0.0989016742,
0.7214102149,
-0.1611339599,
1.1496633291,
1.115709424,
-0.9279766083,
0.0367987677,
0.0580176376,
-0.2268906981,
0.6841446757,
-0.8575841784,
0.049617283,
-0.3624638617,
0.0618961751,
-1.3286167383,
-0.237088412,
0.276007086,
-0.3611286581,
0.4622886777,
-0.2046045512,
-0.2127939612,
-0.1834166497,
-0.1933624744,
0.4591938555,
0.3270919621,
-0.620022893,
0.5762513876,
0.0236528907,
-0.5402544737,
-0.4268139899,
-0.3846808374,
-0.1660116911,
-0.4404026568,
-0.3779657781,
0.2234057933,
-0.1888921857,
0.0405773856,
-0.2780144513,
-0.1700665355,
0.3162203729,
0.359502852,
0.2218391448,
0.0450800806,
-0.4170187116,
0.3107823431,
0.1281119883,
-0.2097354233,
0.1729552299,
-0.4964070022,
0.4694162905,
0.288362354,
0.029225884,
-0.4236567914,
0.4219410419,
0.5520182848,
-0.2285883576,
0.4103697538,
0.5657922626,
-0.0108467061,
-0.3892509639,
-0.4186974764,
-0.5094848275,
-0.5299649835,
0.1300157756,
-0.4663864374,
-0.9010941386,
0.7260728478,
0.0508270413,
-0.0927030444,
0.389549762,
0.5717294812,
-0.0283843651,
1.1483718157,
0.681196034,
-0.219985038,
0.8779619932,
0.2663919926,
-0.1124434546,
-1.0251909494,
0.039796222,
-0.7122641206,
-0.4503862858,
-0.4373409152,
0.0270605013,
0.5257891417,
-0.1236692145,
-0.297650665,
-0.1246830076,
-0.4312086701,
0.6268928051,
0.6345131993,
0.0547694676,
-0.1932908595,
-0.1495641321,
-0.1532877535,
0.0262619518,
-1.0971173048,
-0.0949836224,
0.7056350708,
0.2795483768,
0.6605655551,
-0.4774987698,
0.1415833384,
0.2311462015,
-0.1303875595,
-0.7148412466,
0.3576457798,
0.338473171,
-0.4873149097,
-0.2943336666,
-0.2745105922,
-1.0507069826,
0.218047753,
0.2714865804,
-0.4636026919,
0.3754398227,
0.3719650805,
-0.8042865396,
-0.463001579,
-0.8669776917,
1.0876851082,
-0.0303005558,
-0.6892055869,
0.0164345168,
-0.8958837986,
0.1612385958,
0.1103225201,
0.1628064662,
-0.0646965429,
-0.1909428686,
0.6364164352,
0.133213535,
0.9697899222,
-0.405859977,
-0.2867414057,
0.1087230444,
0.0901876763,
0.4597886801,
0.3625999689,
0.0232045669,
-0.3925950229,
-0.3491229415,
-0.4963034987,
-0.6358869076,
0.7951096296,
-0.5330532789,
-0.885378778,
-0.1326303184,
-0.5815675259,
-0.4275213778,
0.1488758773,
0.4207622111,
0.7993992567,
0.1768241525,
0.0574816465,
0.9575336576,
0.0332569443,
0.6062855124,
0.4396295249,
0.0005751902,
-0.0836184695,
0.732691884,
-0.1151082665,
0.1023034155,
0.2740854919,
0.2474674731,
-0.3745142817,
-0.2058593631,
-0.7173447013,
0.1083214581,
-0.7577322125,
-0.2259727716,
-0.6370295882,
0.1393290162,
-0.3992131948,
-0.1007114202,
0.0794216916,
-0.2187085897,
-0.811920166,
0.0214377753,
0.3502043188,
0.396692425,
0.2316509336,
0.4140661061,
-0.5422927737,
0.1166247353,
0.4302795827,
0.3140077889,
0.1865798682,
-0.8753063083,
-0.2579070926,
-0.2779476047,
0.0945038646,
-0.7372617722,
0.1723500341,
0.3767903149,
0.7672297359,
0.6309344172,
-0.0517899953,
0.4928886592,
-0.5536156297,
0.8208994865,
-0.2395557016,
-0.7137571573,
0.713452518,
-0.6943977475,
0.8646771312,
0.7889323235,
0.0634192079,
-0.5229932666,
-0.2140944153,
-0.1566215008,
-0.5899707079,
1.1688483953,
-0.2907099128,
0.1934371293,
-0.0308196228,
0.6796149015,
0.3944927156,
0.3504104316,
-0.5070704222,
-0.3432916403,
-0.1152163222,
-0.2109410614,
-0.2746829391,
-0.2221197933,
-0.0430105776,
-0.1881190985,
0.3562637568,
-0.4178168774,
0.1581971198,
0.1901721954,
-0.0117160967,
-0.2387353927,
0.1360222101,
0.6708160639,
0.4842632413,
0.0879168063,
0.051753778,
-0.0377398357,
-0.1314006299,
0.0170938764,
-0.0229523033,
-0.3630744517,
-0.3358380198,
0.3150040507,
1.2641721964,
0.4521508813,
-0.4755767882,
0.4412498474,
-0.1354170442,
0.2329394817,
0.2787537277,
0.4987398386,
-0.2226638943,
0.1278879791,
0.5758884549,
0.1897021085,
0.3603514433,
-0.4274177253,
0.0580667183,
0.4738433957,
-0.5798179507,
-0.4128810167,
0.6557117701,
0.3352024853,
-0.289870888,
0.3416905701,
0.0392233394,
-0.4870577753,
0.7945611477,
0.6708009839,
0.92358464,
-0.28707394,
-0.06843739,
0.4103271365,
0.0212773383,
0.252391696,
0.144937411,
-0.6490299106,
-0.3831599355,
-0.4411868155,
-0.4555068612,
-0.0014005754,
0.0178438276,
-0.6815046072,
0.2103781849,
-0.3403683305,
-0.0782595128,
-0.0760302991,
-0.2585097849,
-0.6876769066,
0.2688971162,
0.0023979319,
0.9032299519,
-0.6473799348,
0.3019600213,
0.5769655704,
0.1329804808,
-0.6322296262,
0.278639853,
-0.2680854797,
-0.8020001054,
0.4489482343,
0.536647141,
-0.0346496291,
0.4625086784,
-0.6547089219,
-0.9166030288,
0.751218915,
0.4952346981,
-0.7034908533,
0.0073172292,
-0.3935443759,
0.3156577051,
-0.5407978892,
0.1920562088,
0.5678961873,
0.4434867501,
-0.023329759,
-0.7001627684,
0.1668190211,
-0.0867609158,
0.0095561203,
-0.0314279124,
-0.8558246493,
0.8842868209,
-0.1593672931,
-0.4686829448,
-0.1855911613,
0.5453802943,
0.1326666474,
0.3000784814,
0.5225778222,
0.0945688859,
0.5587382317,
-0.0407303087,
1.1729469299,
-0.6665146351,
0.0143432021,
0.9212338924,
-0.2875077724,
0.1732837558,
0.5277400017,
0.1711987257,
0.159193188,
0.9074540138,
0.2826548815,
0.8825293183,
-0.1066917777,
-0.0917877853,
-0.4241259694,
-0.4373877645,
-0.3702302873,
0.1574076414,
0.3407896459,
-0.3773140311,
-0.1210439578,
0.2904641926,
-0.492891103,
-0.102901645,
-0.8872742653,
1.0648752451,
0.0125393718,
-1.2831784487,
0.5577886105,
-0.1889581382,
0.4150604904,
-0.4454578161,
0.2068446428,
-0.3380964696,
-0.0885445625,
0.1451810151,
-0.4686324596,
-0.2303131074,
-0.3025875986,
-0.5403242707,
-0.1935051531,
0.7203884721,
-0.368822515,
-0.1919060796,
-0.0312989727,
0.5028108358,
-0.3883791864,
-0.2781353593,
-0.609708786,
-0.066284284,
-0.1438907385,
-0.4913616776,
0.3990656137,
0.8136308789,
0.2002483755,
0.6282355785,
0.4232448637,
-0.0961590707,
0.0998261645,
0.1559859812,
0.8434600234,
-0.707416594,
-1.0030885935,
-0.9790538549,
0.4291370809,
0.2359271944,
-0.6309430003,
0.7194682956,
0.2599951327,
0.3935970664,
-0.2414761782,
0.7618362308,
0.3343166411,
0.5381311178,
-0.668867588,
0.3094423413,
-0.5516591072,
-0.0170963109,
0.0752078816,
-0.8335837126,
0.0141469175,
0.3474166691,
-0.1913663447,
0.3113710284,
0.5099772215,
0.7975991368,
-0.0470916592,
-0.0629343465,
0.3935142756,
0.0668223649,
-0.2855012119,
0.4396248758,
0.8543937206,
0.0707113668,
0.053128764,
0.1894053221,
-0.1925842911,
-0.3880362213,
-0.7381647229,
-1.0942574739,
-0.6042361259,
-0.0790195242,
-0.070628576,
-0.1927362978,
0.9818814993,
0.8025116324,
-0.7606572509,
0.2160222977,
-0.2743748128,
0.196893543,
-0.279973805,
-0.2864810228,
0.1947257221,
-0.9634807706,
-0.7093340755,
0.5415279865,
0.5983239412,
-0.0234659407,
-0.3758519292,
0.227728948,
0.2809827924,
0.1724740714,
0.434774667,
0.08762981,
-0.7304593921,
0.0166434236,
0.3048822284,
-0.1967059374,
0.2014100403,
1.1657408476,
-1.0189849138,
0.382689625,
0.3485043347,
0.6910584569,
0.1677509695,
0.3736467957,
0.7055994272,
-1.060957551,
0.1780574471,
0.1514041275,
0.2126598358,
0.2868361175,
-0.7919363379,
0.1033894345,
0.1352293491,
-0.7078082561,
-0.7866566777,
0.3001115024,
-1.001740098,
-0.2171407491,
1.0974503756,
0.0690583587,
-0.5235724449,
-0.1502732337,
-0.5967988968,
0.0816512182,
-0.6738997102,
0.6400382519,
0.7152426243,
0.1054765806,
-0.5120771527,
-0.3872594535,
0.7168500423,
0.6908673644,
-0.4167515039,
0.425444603,
0.4855376482,
0.1187182814,
-0.1559808701,
0.4964097738,
0.4672147036,
0.5766605735,
-0.2343062013,
-0.5685412884,
-0.0556490421,
-0.4872939885,
-0.9103522301,
0.4462350309,
0.0386176743,
-0.0821935534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03415v1 | Efficient and Interpretable Compressive Text Summarisation with Unsupervised Dual-Agent Reinforcement Learning | 2023-06-06T05:30:49 | 2023-06-06T05:30:49 | Peggy Tang, Junbin Gao, Lei Zhang, Zhiyong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, compressive text summarisation offers a balance between the
conciseness issue of extractive summarisation and the factual hallucination
issue of abstractive summarisation. However, most existing compressive
summarisation methods are supervised, relying on the expensive effort of
creating a new training dataset with corresponding compressive summaries. In
this paper, we propose an efficient and interpretable compressive summarisation
method that utilises unsupervised dual-agent reinforcement learning to optimise
a summary's semantic coverage and fluency by simulating human judgment on
summarisation quality. Our model consists of an extractor agent and a
compressor agent, and both agents have a multi-head attentional pointer-based
structure. The extractor agent first chooses salient sentences from a document,
and then the compressor agent compresses these extracted sentences by selecting
salient words to form a summary without using reference summaries to compute
the summary reward. To our best knowledge, this is the first work on
unsupervised compressive summarisation. Experimental results on three widely
used datasets (e.g., Newsroom, CNN/DM, and XSum) show that our model achieves
promising performance and a significant improvement on Newsroom in terms of the
ROUGE metric, as well as interpretability of semantic coverage of summarisation
results. | [
-0.2419427931,
-0.2969398499,
0.373016268,
0.1724891514,
-0.7038972974,
0.2925668955,
-0.3759186566,
-0.1502979547,
0.4448387325,
0.4011756182,
-0.4764245152,
-0.3197146356,
-0.7636336088,
0.1498401165,
-0.3488002121,
1.1246554852,
-0.0097717633,
-0.2519270182,
-0.2902730107,
-0.0390129201,
-0.409920454,
-0.5473868251,
-0.4298479855,
-0.4062746167,
0.168872118,
0.4915721714,
0.8137683272,
0.1805877984,
0.1290116012,
0.3994836807,
-0.1438342035,
0.4692778885,
-0.6346218586,
0.1024927571,
0.0886311084,
-0.2034123391,
-0.1408159137,
-0.0657155067,
0.773894906,
0.5524573326,
-0.1983384192,
-0.2030464709,
0.3906297684,
0.7026646137,
-0.5682063699,
0.6323581338,
-0.3275950551,
0.0783865079,
0.4599221051,
-0.4836221039,
-0.3478106856,
0.0520565324,
-0.1699988395,
-0.6024118066,
0.3410661817,
-0.2404489368,
0.7148336768,
0.6769267321,
-0.6383945346,
-0.2431501448,
-0.5112208128,
0.6982784867,
-0.2214202434,
0.2894208431,
-0.0325826444,
0.3357802033,
-0.1473763138,
-0.7781546116,
-0.5558835268,
0.0594998337,
-0.4865756929,
0.5117723942,
-0.2256808132,
0.0456471518,
-0.1495896131,
0.5009586811,
-0.6553955078,
-0.2883206904,
-0.1740399599,
-0.1063156277,
0.6817256808,
0.0733146295,
0.1856401861,
-0.2953523099,
-0.5530376434,
-0.4354897141,
-0.0360283516,
0.1189843118,
0.0857090726,
0.2102404684,
-0.1200672016,
0.2835845053,
-0.3892716467,
0.3779895008,
-0.1884552985,
-0.1576698869,
0.1803389341,
-0.4137490392,
-0.296226114,
0.1675084978,
0.7168943882,
0.389315933,
0.2340061069,
-0.5186927915,
-0.414162159,
0.3442709744,
0.5513262153,
-0.6526042223,
-0.2024325579,
0.2112155557,
-0.4373946786,
-0.5166504979,
0.1826193035,
-0.6356310248,
-0.2077161521,
-0.3355082572,
0.3406185806,
-0.2092894465,
-0.2644685209,
0.2790659666,
-0.6075549722,
-0.0049508531,
0.4341165125,
-0.786536932,
0.5087182522,
0.5254588127,
0.9503625035,
-0.1852752417,
-0.4086695611,
-0.5930660963,
0.0795159638,
-0.0776373744,
1.025526166,
-0.0048800963,
-0.2306989729,
-0.2531449795,
-0.1359748691,
-0.0346704088,
-0.3940714598,
0.3891572654,
-0.4132098258,
0.1198674217,
0.2320542485,
-0.3110682964,
-0.3987134099,
0.1763399094,
-0.6642962098,
0.7980323434,
0.3190720677,
-0.6592522264,
0.2730088532,
-0.1251748055,
-0.5738354325,
-0.2248616219,
-0.1500280648,
-0.5409095883,
0.322766602,
0.4137561321,
0.5707092285,
0.0376773179,
0.2670699358,
0.0724713951,
-0.6617581248,
0.396794945,
-0.6072314382,
0.3325530589,
0.0069146985,
-0.1685284078,
0.1869357228,
-0.7490234375,
-0.1587666124,
0.0659093931,
-0.2170566022,
-0.2351272106,
-0.1579491049,
0.1964563727,
0.38470155,
0.0555362254,
0.0302700084,
0.089827545,
-0.4269321263,
0.0923005268,
0.5450069308,
0.2203753889,
0.3892424107,
-0.5641522408,
0.5082501769,
-0.0075447848,
-0.1154893786,
-0.2118126899,
0.0619131625,
-0.4737725854,
-0.6408573389,
0.3695882559,
0.3858936429,
-0.9619086981,
0.4553555548,
-0.4148570597,
-0.172575146,
-0.291288197,
0.0320091732,
0.4802100062,
0.1839046329,
0.321244359,
-0.4553628862,
-0.4024254084,
-0.533016026,
-0.2529641092,
-0.0780753344,
-0.0667372867,
-0.0573500916,
0.3929570019,
0.1061704308,
0.4558082521,
-0.6141210198,
-0.4854659736,
-0.7599288225,
0.4926708043,
0.0765555948,
0.1166536137,
0.1495191753,
-1.0830091238,
-0.4130818248,
-0.4673178494,
-0.7913131118,
0.0216820221,
-0.6281280518,
-0.0915660784,
0.2176787555,
0.2800974548,
-0.7976480126,
0.6162230372,
0.2999118567,
-0.4990403354,
0.5644536018,
-0.4972796142,
0.1431986839,
-1.167159915,
-0.0064268704,
-0.1792703122,
-0.8768934608,
-0.374119997,
0.1722019762,
-0.0127392542,
-0.0649245083,
-0.2521278858,
0.4010038972,
-0.7140099406,
-0.2993274033,
-0.6800042987,
0.5084407926,
0.1236049905,
0.9369225502,
0.2935906351,
0.6583332419,
0.1641212255,
-0.6822886467,
0.3177316785,
0.5203106403,
-0.3248366714,
0.3448251784,
-0.5436518192,
-0.271881938,
-0.4315807223,
0.4234421253,
-0.9666255116,
-0.2473592609,
0.2742421031,
-0.6998178363,
0.4056743383,
0.1325364113,
-0.4716269672,
-0.0448745303,
-0.4999940395,
0.1613695174,
0.5803158283,
-0.7198833227,
0.5451491475,
0.4944548011,
-0.1352380812,
-0.7584918737,
-0.5479292274,
0.1510928273,
-0.1187385544,
-0.2816982567,
0.3841508627,
0.1807558537,
-0.1561519802,
0.1304323077,
-0.3795326352,
-0.0304710753,
0.40512532,
0.3733495176,
0.1931940317,
0.3098299801,
0.2311434597,
0.129456237,
-0.4007054567,
0.1002893448,
-0.2128269076,
0.3801244199,
0.1389058828,
0.2776149213,
-0.4050724506,
0.6137984991,
0.4922260344,
0.0765558407,
0.7488774061,
0.3114192486,
-0.2778472304,
-0.4809451401,
0.1009452045,
-0.1362851858,
-0.362478137,
0.4895816743,
-0.2222394645,
-0.4065873325,
0.2173097134,
-0.0171768386,
-0.0773200095,
0.4486083984,
0.5671877861,
0.031066779,
0.9032604694,
0.6922127604,
-0.0658354089,
0.3933312595,
-0.4513002932,
-0.2262628675,
-0.3884239793,
-0.2512042224,
-0.2207789719,
-0.1968799233,
-0.2646932602,
-0.368435353,
0.591891706,
0.001526525,
0.2863201499,
0.0864148885,
-0.4436897039,
0.5453819633,
0.4927522838,
0.2788743079,
0.6639908552,
0.0968608335,
0.1526079029,
0.4855944216,
-0.5423272848,
-0.4978779852,
0.7223502994,
0.033685293,
0.5591650605,
0.329837352,
0.6553013921,
0.5922316909,
0.0036828571,
-0.82408005,
0.3027485013,
-0.0360517316,
0.0351219885,
-0.4269010425,
-0.7365829945,
-0.9033641219,
0.8507330418,
-0.3269910514,
-0.3990839422,
0.0698048845,
0.0860830098,
-0.360507071,
0.0589637868,
-0.6533646584,
0.8475518823,
-0.0046239807,
0.0436993241,
-0.5941514969,
-0.7889748216,
0.3735948503,
0.0243389234,
0.0167832766,
0.1351373047,
-0.1502087563,
0.5089032054,
-0.5355727673,
0.6602289081,
-0.0498789959,
0.1471658796,
0.1399433762,
-0.377592355,
0.5551441908,
0.250731945,
0.2376142889,
-0.1066407785,
0.0591605119,
-0.5876263976,
-1.0082728863,
0.2553555965,
-0.8930914402,
-0.1625548601,
-0.8190823793,
-0.9151412249,
-0.095487386,
0.1528369486,
0.2422301471,
0.6760520339,
-0.4285674095,
-0.1344599724,
0.5027952194,
-0.0833205581,
0.4229947925,
0.5636318326,
0.0471685342,
-0.5252463818,
0.8685379028,
-0.0672293454,
0.2269231379,
0.6764333844,
-0.0457847491,
-0.4545190632,
-0.3559715748,
-0.4726214707,
0.1440243125,
-0.6158047318,
-0.246309042,
-0.8205640912,
-0.1912248582,
-0.5262952447,
-0.0993590429,
-0.1628890932,
-0.7789991498,
-0.2251521796,
0.0310029611,
-0.1407472491,
0.6520231366,
-0.2067420632,
0.3045295477,
-0.622084558,
0.7149381638,
0.2294536233,
-0.0497454368,
-0.0229206719,
-0.5340643525,
-0.4531466663,
0.0024802631,
-0.3376949131,
-0.9547586441,
0.720903337,
0.0175983217,
0.2960348129,
0.3063620031,
0.5653268099,
0.3500549793,
0.1038488671,
0.3762662113,
0.2135676295,
-0.7006406784,
0.0956869721,
0.0787478387,
0.435110271,
0.6815045476,
0.2749218643,
-0.4299589694,
-0.6288004518,
-0.7296597958,
-0.8301437497,
0.8271209002,
0.3297296166,
-0.0543011203,
0.165634945,
0.1828966439,
0.1422829777,
0.431843996,
-0.4171583056,
-0.2237270921,
-0.333112061,
-0.2873561084,
-0.6237860322,
-0.4210629463,
0.134721294,
0.1311079562,
0.9781543612,
-0.1818473339,
0.2889941037,
0.1526977867,
-0.4316768944,
0.1227084994,
0.4810305834,
0.4564314485,
0.1439567059,
-0.4734834135,
0.3934071958,
-0.0357913598,
-0.4767004251,
0.2387685925,
0.4726399481,
-0.128202185,
0.2294193506,
0.3638449013,
0.8266964555,
0.3851269782,
-0.87709409,
0.8386047482,
-0.7031962872,
-0.1430160999,
-0.4524608552,
-0.0385231301,
-0.4127111137,
0.3458090127,
0.2158990204,
0.2408904582,
0.4438719153,
-0.6340534091,
0.3243183494,
0.3239397705,
-0.4151230752,
-0.0629555434,
0.4260854721,
0.0146964099,
0.2163161039,
0.5660617948,
-0.5670771003,
-0.61527282,
0.496786803,
0.4363385439,
0.859781146,
0.2664892972,
0.5692402124,
0.1698367447,
0.2510482967,
-0.2807400525,
0.3020613492,
-0.636054039,
-0.4964763522,
-0.4273612201,
-0.330889076,
-0.5487818122,
-0.2685486674,
-0.8646663427,
0.125101313,
0.0880867019,
0.3904629052,
0.0070337909,
0.302210927,
-0.219051525,
0.2474415153,
0.0151771847,
0.9055326581,
-0.9256860018,
0.6040863395,
0.6139828563,
-0.5519683361,
-0.8270456195,
0.2834425569,
-0.0797257721,
-0.5226013064,
0.0567765012,
0.3363435864,
-0.1477809548,
0.0388418175,
-0.0506424345,
-0.559905529,
1.1178827286,
0.4147624075,
-0.0843015015,
-0.2463626862,
-0.1397236437,
0.5046620965,
0.0254377928,
0.4604781866,
0.4708125591,
0.1441511661,
0.2888859212,
-0.5305091739,
0.1911785156,
-0.308825016,
-0.2530033588,
0.3849593103,
-0.9083411098,
0.4372758269,
-0.2113639265,
-0.4450760782,
0.1122272015,
0.8897114396,
-0.0964921117,
0.4452184737,
0.4646942019,
0.5775767565,
0.8961914182,
0.1029981449,
1.3706241846,
-0.2012137622,
0.4939121008,
1.1738619804,
0.2040029913,
0.6255997419,
0.1855118126,
0.1367168576,
0.4176436961,
0.3583076894,
0.2316121608,
0.856133461,
0.0931928083,
-0.3892318904,
-0.2432757467,
-0.2354344875,
-0.0027084893,
0.6314671636,
0.0057396716,
-0.2491558939,
-0.4427011013,
-0.0450904816,
-0.0918184593,
0.241193369,
-0.3572674394,
1.0952035189,
0.1554998606,
-0.8493186831,
0.6856732965,
0.1282373518,
0.3933344483,
-0.4627799392,
-0.1511075199,
-0.309564501,
0.3898845017,
-0.0134562142,
-0.6005775928,
0.4495199621,
-0.1126645133,
-0.2858914435,
-0.4421887696,
0.7375690341,
-0.6444764733,
-0.3156180382,
0.0714235902,
0.3797406554,
0.3955325782,
-0.4706073403,
-0.3993430436,
-0.2349626869,
-0.171454519,
-0.0846301615,
0.4164904952,
0.5185300112,
0.1890588999,
0.4805173576,
0.2368899882,
0.2078534365,
-0.5977522135,
-0.075467594,
0.9872618318,
-0.6386472583,
-1.0599176884,
-0.7068408132,
0.5055635571,
-0.2092440724,
0.0160361975,
0.5997959971,
0.6841697097,
0.5799784064,
0.0485513508,
0.8922504783,
0.2127393335,
0.3489024937,
-0.7102252841,
0.6066349745,
-0.6627053022,
0.0702978894,
-0.2093317956,
-0.4618656933,
-0.2413716018,
0.5402854681,
0.1823805124,
-0.1895196289,
0.7297860384,
0.695109427,
0.0062835589,
0.0594964735,
0.5236455202,
0.1046181694,
-0.1705509126,
0.8679692149,
0.8979182243,
-0.3916148841,
0.7623100877,
-0.3075166345,
-0.4318280518,
-0.1925511658,
-0.608287394,
-1.1455583572,
-0.6323886514,
-0.2975309491,
-0.5161792636,
0.1017366201,
0.9370467067,
0.4994689226,
-0.5207056403,
0.0322448984,
-0.0688101202,
0.4405393898,
-0.7410291433,
-0.2248517275,
0.5933385491,
-0.5038170218,
-0.744600594,
0.2319662422,
0.2220101655,
-0.0386148468,
-0.1371049881,
-0.1703378707,
0.1107352674,
0.0983906612,
0.425869137,
0.2001061738,
-0.2639244795,
0.0747038424,
-0.5031263232,
-0.1459088773,
0.0484394059,
0.7505802512,
-1.0527340174,
0.2444334179,
0.4542635977,
0.4822219312,
0.595144093,
0.4081167877,
0.4801658094,
-0.9892122149,
0.2460847795,
-0.039478071,
0.3504416943,
0.2568707168,
-0.5391688347,
0.4635344744,
0.2747429013,
-0.5232131481,
-0.6753500104,
-0.0386177674,
-1.0868449211,
-0.528455615,
1.044754982,
-0.1539978385,
-0.2213216573,
-0.18822667,
-0.2697623968,
0.6798320413,
-0.6135926247,
1.050625205,
0.0900470689,
0.029952487,
-0.2744702399,
-0.2340108454,
0.5475508571,
0.2551679015,
-0.8543046117,
0.1644836366,
0.7032673359,
-0.0339183174,
-0.08337605,
0.7300700545,
0.1077116951,
0.6042580605,
0.1777843237,
0.1473875791,
-0.3949029148,
-0.6199324727,
-0.6391518116,
0.2965563536,
-0.1671731174,
-0.3632311523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03411v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03411v1 | Generate-then-Retrieve: Intent-Aware FAQ Retrieval in Product Search | 2023-06-06T05:18:21 | 2023-06-06T05:18:21 | Zhiyu Chen, Jason Choi, Besnik Fetahu, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Customers interacting with product search engines are increasingly
formulating information-seeking queries. Frequently Asked Question (FAQ)
retrieval aims to retrieve common question-answer pairs for a user query with
question intent. Integrating FAQ retrieval in product search can not only
empower users to make more informed purchase decisions, but also enhance user
retention through efficient post-purchase support. Determining when an FAQ
entry can satisfy a user's information need within product search, without
disrupting their shopping experience, represents an important challenge. We
propose an intent-aware FAQ retrieval system consisting of (1) an intent
classifier that predicts when a user's information need can be answered by an
FAQ; (2) a reformulation model that rewrites a query into a natural question.
Offline evaluation demonstrates that our approach improves Hit@1 by 13% on
retrieving ground-truth FAQs, while reducing latency by 95% compared to
baseline systems. These improvements are further validated by real user
feedback, where 71% of displayed FAQs on top of product search results received
explicit positive user feedback. Overall, our findings show promising
directions for integrating FAQ retrieval into product search at scale. | [
-0.4616003036,
-0.7643958926,
0.6286432743,
0.1084865928,
-0.0878876373,
-0.162282154,
0.1173587963,
-0.4699265063,
0.4328699708,
0.7952446342,
-0.7246182561,
-0.2108629793,
-0.0813427642,
-0.0270191543,
-0.472456336,
0.7760340571,
0.0801943019,
-0.2637084126,
-0.3554152548,
-0.0800423324,
-0.4190226197,
-0.284065932,
-0.585047543,
0.0274339467,
0.4972108006,
0.4299533069,
0.6989265084,
0.034028329,
0.4415531158,
0.2575711608,
0.058502011,
0.5348850489,
-0.3702490926,
0.6465200186,
0.0805062354,
-0.5731224418,
-0.2904269695,
0.0255091358,
0.1729792207,
0.4943050742,
-0.2714042664,
0.0592445582,
0.0592342764,
0.7311042547,
-0.7644852996,
-0.1391581744,
-0.6581507325,
-0.0205228664,
-0.0604199395,
-0.2727819085,
-0.5603396893,
-0.5408843756,
0.3914408982,
-0.9317824841,
0.3628934026,
0.3633445799,
0.5452756286,
0.1677424908,
-0.3535335064,
-0.577198863,
-0.5984808207,
0.3541274965,
-0.2696816027,
0.8637607694,
0.3419019878,
0.3621696532,
-0.4130889773,
-0.8052246571,
-0.509111166,
-0.1853278428,
-0.064203985,
0.0586515404,
-0.2912627757,
-0.1719314307,
0.1384559125,
0.541667819,
-0.4901957512,
-0.8152623773,
-0.3356823325,
-0.0880879536,
0.7912258506,
0.0226676911,
0.0909117162,
-0.028991174,
-0.4262447953,
0.1900155842,
-0.7030431628,
0.2626162171,
0.0739891976,
0.0260365587,
0.6349105835,
0.6009731889,
-0.5546905398,
0.6749567986,
0.6421817541,
0.2171223164,
0.1141895056,
-0.4721571207,
-0.0074021039,
0.0804942027,
0.3785422146,
0.1473477185,
-0.1260405183,
-0.1776928455,
-0.5628132224,
-0.7465646267,
0.504273653,
-0.540569067,
-0.171807915,
0.3326795995,
-0.3532864153,
-0.1385156661,
0.2442711443,
-0.375710398,
-0.444229722,
-0.1443909109,
0.8276058435,
-0.2085781842,
-0.1054121554,
0.21080634,
-0.0609569252,
0.303979218,
0.5073962212,
-0.6235814691,
0.2441020459,
0.7735560536,
0.6306173205,
-0.0227478649,
0.2166983932,
-0.7696457505,
0.1308735162,
-0.1486199796,
0.9879313111,
-0.3595992327,
-0.4876939058,
-0.0113877924,
0.0582971759,
0.1649208218,
-0.5964105129,
0.3489489853,
-1.2713694572,
0.2451213151,
-0.5932514071,
-0.5073018074,
-0.106119059,
0.4885868132,
-1.0081682205,
0.8230696917,
-0.0452214666,
-0.5572291017,
0.3538620174,
-0.7256962061,
-0.5681061745,
0.3711974025,
-0.2391247153,
-0.3304305971,
0.0734409466,
0.0031433306,
0.2267474234,
-0.2552286088,
-0.0046648607,
-0.1300907135,
-0.2419726253,
0.3442826271,
-0.2398676425,
0.50488621,
0.2465763539,
-0.2810584903,
-0.2133454084,
-0.1098422334,
0.2352740467,
0.2608384788,
-0.418271929,
-0.1979799271,
-0.0846926048,
-0.2268126756,
0.1126806736,
0.6053200364,
-0.6449640989,
0.2709912062,
-0.3159928322,
-0.1435740143,
0.4949177802,
0.3689010739,
0.427770257,
-0.3722498715,
0.3714472651,
-0.3534217477,
0.6080997586,
0.0066240937,
-0.9516170025,
-0.6106360555,
0.3130034804,
-0.0210704859,
0.2679955661,
-0.6664370298,
0.1585729271,
-0.0020994039,
-0.5636649132,
-0.3345116377,
0.3236089349,
0.2462096214,
0.4987787008,
0.4781354964,
-0.3253803849,
-0.2850333154,
-0.4803214371,
-0.5530215502,
-0.2657404542,
0.0126513792,
0.9006127715,
0.0130050816,
-0.0386543982,
1.1112834215,
-1.1057778597,
-0.4227236509,
-0.4096778631,
0.3104349673,
0.1914046556,
0.0642850921,
0.2643532753,
-1.4057116508,
-0.5890643597,
-0.135900557,
-0.2370686978,
-0.2425997555,
0.2083533555,
-0.3536038995,
0.1255744994,
0.2151581645,
-0.8709911704,
0.6150596738,
-0.0921730697,
-0.3467943668,
0.5406776667,
-0.1397217065,
0.4407829344,
-0.6732189655,
0.345590651,
-0.3123697937,
0.0950334817,
-0.5609795451,
-0.4260451794,
0.1639337391,
0.0144685181,
-0.6061819792,
0.5771387219,
-0.32107234,
-0.246338129,
-0.2933093309,
-0.0822482184,
0.4553262591,
0.1208393648,
0.0074364082,
1.0961911678,
-0.1115430519,
-1.0882736444,
0.1185138375,
0.4259584844,
-0.2603185177,
0.2172318548,
-0.6345257163,
0.2262485027,
-0.2553625703,
0.2135358453,
-1.1062046289,
-0.493155539,
0.2806755304,
-0.5544747114,
0.0081136916,
-0.1013222337,
-0.4520967603,
-0.2918586135,
-0.1862313002,
0.3415060937,
0.378102392,
-0.6517361999,
0.7669838667,
0.4405285418,
-0.0688402057,
-0.6441829801,
-0.1955002844,
-0.5094749928,
0.2535894513,
-0.7031865716,
0.3328170478,
-0.3271768391,
-0.0323715881,
-0.0452983119,
-0.4862738252,
-0.1799356788,
0.2463155538,
-0.0012807908,
0.1450078934,
-0.1309484988,
0.3781742752,
0.0757725537,
-0.0037611197,
0.0714384764,
-0.2269851267,
0.6620529294,
-0.1078488752,
-0.2538352311,
-0.162240997,
0.566568315,
0.3728122115,
-0.3653836846,
0.2426707447,
0.3844043911,
-0.2719885707,
-0.0163654014,
-0.7573096156,
-0.4128979743,
-0.5507468581,
-0.0357555225,
-0.3239963055,
-0.7336555719,
0.2094238997,
-0.0286748763,
0.2093060017,
0.3761022091,
0.322283268,
-0.3823184073,
1.2966350317,
0.3783655763,
0.5692757368,
0.6272665858,
-0.0762521923,
0.3294092417,
-0.6896418929,
-0.8353515863,
-0.2644425631,
-0.2809696198,
0.0664022565,
-0.3995221555,
0.3548961878,
0.0509284735,
-0.0684707537,
0.3604812026,
-0.2733310759,
0.3645202816,
0.4961156845,
0.4842931628,
0.4046297669,
0.1707927585,
-0.0057230834,
0.1861585677,
-0.2955513299,
-0.1454475522,
1.1895788908,
-0.1369804591,
0.7022503018,
0.2734825611,
0.6081924438,
0.4251681268,
0.5195632577,
-0.8705913424,
0.5250895619,
-0.0961951688,
-0.9974221587,
-0.1809336692,
-0.2831725478,
-0.8973079324,
-0.0197286103,
0.0528303124,
-0.4273098409,
0.3894489706,
0.2993419766,
-0.7935739756,
-0.1537268907,
-0.6346043944,
0.519322753,
-0.7318813801,
-0.5451215506,
0.0382879712,
-0.4955348969,
0.0818207413,
-0.1620257497,
0.0101969196,
-0.0087842979,
-0.1864575148,
0.8669906259,
-0.279543072,
0.1758148968,
-0.3932047188,
-0.0547859743,
0.4358944297,
0.0806346387,
0.3726866245,
0.1019199714,
-0.0250712018,
-0.5367783308,
-0.3252553046,
-0.0811365619,
-1.0210535526,
0.5062809587,
-0.3675618768,
-1.0278060436,
-0.188243553,
-0.1776252836,
-0.3748839498,
0.5169142485,
0.298420608,
0.1587968618,
-0.3051104248,
0.4525072575,
1.2503722906,
0.1764740348,
0.0015726652,
0.7099779844,
-0.5760917664,
-0.2108117193,
0.5031575561,
0.2326141447,
0.0767375454,
0.3413261473,
0.1774391383,
-0.7376843691,
-0.2103896439,
-0.2677934468,
0.1327573657,
-0.6312134266,
-0.4215969443,
-0.9861726165,
-0.0462078527,
-0.4570809901,
0.0209444668,
-0.388471216,
-0.2849349082,
-0.3798263967,
0.155923456,
0.517821908,
0.6263766885,
0.1131805778,
0.398352474,
-0.7987989783,
0.443071723,
0.5726373196,
0.4886768162,
-0.1476970911,
-0.4398577809,
-0.044624202,
0.0892496929,
-0.4879706502,
-0.9563327432,
0.180547595,
0.3617981076,
0.676306963,
0.6310046911,
0.420665592,
0.4647268653,
-0.1623847634,
0.565828383,
0.1518253833,
-0.4996601045,
0.8219103813,
-0.0348085202,
0.0842352584,
0.9222012162,
0.8666857481,
-0.4294494987,
0.1727305949,
-0.4823539555,
-0.9920315146,
0.7148385048,
0.2092939019,
0.0855232477,
-0.1405909508,
0.4662546813,
0.3058972061,
0.3297281861,
-0.2019437701,
-0.324154079,
-0.1643265784,
0.0304022562,
0.3439920247,
-0.1786201894,
0.1313780844,
-0.1466865391,
0.6141555309,
0.0751659349,
0.4505785704,
0.4574471414,
-0.1035584733,
-0.0483509339,
0.1925587505,
-0.1505129337,
0.0790151656,
-0.5444558859,
-0.1399047077,
-0.2977015078,
-0.7762460113,
0.0711230189,
0.0191976987,
-0.3069545031,
0.0146432715,
-0.6538829803,
0.2887569666,
0.3131940961,
-0.7559437156,
0.7554098964,
-0.4395941496,
-0.1324486136,
-0.3782396019,
0.435862571,
-0.1344851851,
0.2065360546,
0.8528724313,
0.1467558295,
0.8375742435,
-0.3370386958,
0.8535150886,
0.3869318664,
-0.3010142148,
-0.0770563111,
0.5985689163,
0.238032341,
-0.4813152254,
0.690333128,
-0.2728321254,
-0.5677855015,
0.4065369964,
0.6324014068,
0.8841948509,
-0.5072287917,
0.2362402827,
0.3487821221,
-0.084508568,
-0.2250708193,
0.8947751522,
-0.4151828885,
-0.5739175081,
0.0471101664,
-0.2573795915,
-0.4532641768,
0.113558732,
-0.5738568902,
0.3894596994,
-0.4784026146,
-0.4047454,
0.0325728953,
0.1747345924,
-0.6489419341,
0.3701512814,
-0.0707562268,
0.8369234204,
-0.360709697,
0.2956240773,
0.6330801249,
-0.5321150422,
-0.7141203284,
0.4169628918,
-0.1054126993,
-0.4867175221,
0.480905056,
0.5219470263,
-0.443985641,
0.0739888847,
-0.6373878121,
-1.0586611032,
1.4793571234,
-0.0985507295,
-0.2991173863,
0.173963502,
0.0369285271,
0.2487124801,
-0.4460419416,
0.2918745577,
0.4319051206,
0.2790460587,
0.408370018,
-0.3659517169,
0.1552352756,
-0.4816080034,
-0.4159009159,
0.2106201649,
-0.4462706447,
0.6372926235,
-0.2386817187,
-0.4531325102,
0.0611665584,
0.615429163,
0.3894724846,
0.773876667,
0.6491897702,
0.204873994,
0.8524154425,
0.080150269,
0.7943816781,
-0.287493825,
0.1494621634,
0.9924012423,
-0.2389256209,
1.2219684124,
0.4098317027,
0.0327416919,
0.227514714,
0.34718436,
0.4476415515,
0.8586256504,
-0.2688475549,
-0.6003656983,
-0.532797873,
-0.3052823246,
-0.5660339594,
0.3556798697,
0.5918907523,
-0.3894940913,
-0.0494980365,
-0.2068562657,
-0.1832115501,
-0.4758455753,
-0.2429356426,
0.8274515271,
-0.1029231623,
-0.9240916967,
0.3994163573,
-0.3741345108,
0.3348200321,
-0.4038510919,
0.027188655,
-0.5099050999,
0.037501391,
-0.4820961058,
-1.0938729048,
0.2741433978,
-0.1086175814,
-0.3932983875,
0.0587503724,
0.8950836062,
-0.3728434145,
-0.0972968265,
0.0397133492,
0.510599792,
0.0202299803,
-0.4215414822,
-0.7328240871,
-0.0799821094,
0.2967920899,
-0.459969312,
-0.0102567831,
0.1622907817,
0.0966216102,
0.717310667,
0.7720655203,
-0.6212432981,
0.2957752645,
-0.2028977871,
1.0355803967,
-0.4058327973,
-0.4059143662,
-0.1010440588,
0.4554160535,
-0.1333500594,
-0.1120327935,
0.6324317455,
0.7135618329,
0.5063656569,
-0.0706116408,
0.8474746346,
-0.1446574628,
0.3947689831,
-0.2260572165,
0.7827649713,
-1.0595910549,
0.404437393,
0.1155037209,
-0.7484464645,
-0.2047299147,
0.4424233139,
-0.4512503445,
0.051752001,
0.386664778,
0.8054945469,
-0.1715074182,
0.4221450686,
0.102745831,
-0.1518054307,
0.2096688598,
0.2233955115,
0.870136857,
-0.6248227954,
0.8456508517,
-0.1666392535,
-0.1811233014,
-0.6798291802,
-0.4070926905,
-0.1556987315,
-0.4882883132,
-0.1674899757,
-0.2721828222,
-0.0481824428,
0.7987511754,
0.3411217928,
-0.6705396175,
0.1106534302,
-0.1422413737,
0.151688382,
0.0246291868,
-0.2384432554,
0.0912662297,
-0.5182209611,
-0.2711096406,
0.3645096719,
0.2321164906,
0.0062131425,
0.062795803,
-0.2001879215,
-0.2966859937,
0.3052724302,
0.410369128,
0.4323301017,
-0.6258208752,
0.0253529865,
0.9433764815,
-0.0338016823,
0.169958666,
0.9525604844,
-0.8398177028,
0.6021894813,
0.7136819959,
0.6258584261,
0.4193379879,
0.1752822548,
0.5989770293,
-0.6822742224,
-0.5082918406,
0.4165195525,
0.077943325,
0.1452188492,
-0.7797923088,
0.2359050512,
-0.0493346974,
-0.4707253873,
-0.3370526135,
0.2845506072,
-0.9356198907,
-0.0282089636,
1.1201913357,
-0.2354179025,
-0.2634331584,
-0.6675879955,
-0.2949253023,
0.2271360755,
-0.6758708358,
0.7355754972,
0.2411874384,
-0.4300014377,
-0.0708104372,
-0.1870775521,
0.5660375953,
0.3999347687,
-0.4930815101,
0.0743744522,
0.4432762563,
0.2847352624,
0.3411851823,
0.8515651822,
-0.1716638952,
0.7462900281,
-0.2798200548,
-0.3047727346,
0.0097954599,
-0.3416101933,
0.083523199,
0.3933298886,
0.1290179044,
-0.1584669352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03377v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03377v2 | TextFormer: A Query-based End-to-End Text Spotter with Mixed Supervision | 2023-06-06T03:37:41 | 2024-04-01T11:55:46 | Yukun Zhai, Xiaoqiang Zhang, Xiameng Qin, Sanyuan Zhao, Xingping Dong, Jianbing Shen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | End-to-end text spotting is a vital computer vision task that aims to
integrate scene text detection and recognition into a unified framework.
Typical methods heavily rely on Region-of-Interest (RoI) operations to extract
local features and complex post-processing steps to produce final predictions.
To address these limitations, we propose TextFormer, a query-based end-to-end
text spotter with Transformer architecture. Specifically, using query embedding
per text instance, TextFormer builds upon an image encoder and a text decoder
to learn a joint semantic understanding for multi-task modeling. It allows for
mutual training and optimization of classification, segmentation, and
recognition branches, resulting in deeper feature sharing without sacrificing
flexibility or simplicity. Additionally, we design an Adaptive Global
aGgregation (AGG) module to transfer global features into sequential features
for reading arbitrarily-shaped texts, which overcomes the sub-optimization
problem of RoI operations. Furthermore, potential corpus information is
utilized from weak annotations to full labels through mixed supervision,
further improving text detection and end-to-end text spotting results.
Extensive experiments on various bilingual (i.e., English and Chinese)
benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of our method. Especially on TDA-ReCTS
dataset, TextFormer surpasses the state-of-the-art method in terms of 1-NED by
13.2%. | [
-0.3151728511,
-0.6897599697,
0.7199446559,
0.4701937437,
-0.605964005,
0.0348253213,
0.020907633,
-0.4931809902,
0.3117189109,
0.4938373268,
-0.3120656908,
-0.6295663714,
-0.9427733421,
0.2713078558,
-0.6546964049,
0.8684350848,
-0.2518801391,
-0.2336969227,
-0.2889207006,
-0.0779956654,
-0.4347492456,
-0.6453959346,
-0.7160480618,
0.28911376,
0.535073638,
0.1974478215,
0.3046681285,
0.2365234792,
0.350415796,
0.3561374247,
-0.3357363343,
0.5203581452,
-0.2686901093,
0.3459536731,
-0.0802199468,
-0.5018386841,
-0.0265907831,
-0.2975016832,
0.4570595622,
0.0734317675,
-0.1241234168,
-0.2333526611,
-0.1903451532,
0.3029093146,
-0.9657424092,
-0.1049629748,
-0.5096135139,
-0.0810493529,
-0.3281499445,
-0.2720077038,
-0.5046577454,
-0.0217472762,
0.1111081839,
-0.6532282233,
0.6012266874,
0.1458884031,
0.8069445491,
0.408677578,
-0.6243864298,
-0.3162809014,
-0.4852797687,
0.6568559408,
-0.2022339255,
0.3375414014,
0.5792767406,
0.56835711,
0.0252012331,
-0.8169912696,
-0.7109379768,
0.1964299828,
-0.3678162396,
0.7407497168,
-0.3552004099,
-0.2110623866,
-0.1848472208,
0.3865857422,
-0.5128192902,
-0.1260349303,
-0.2615584731,
-0.2208863795,
0.3093079329,
-0.21502617,
0.4794656038,
0.0470308885,
-0.360912174,
0.0238694549,
-0.1732494384,
0.2977015078,
-0.0483369753,
-0.0850359574,
-0.0430390798,
0.2696827948,
-0.1634817123,
0.9499822855,
0.0735162944,
0.2562927604,
0.0383618586,
-0.0728516877,
-0.3829546869,
0.0333454013,
0.9285223484,
0.2207867354,
0.0405584238,
-0.3157204092,
-0.3494766057,
-0.0519412123,
0.2886779904,
-0.777767837,
0.0438145101,
0.0389459021,
-0.1554213017,
-0.1795826256,
0.2303084582,
-0.639229238,
-0.3932774067,
-0.1783849895,
0.3652701378,
-0.2483593076,
0.1244601682,
0.2024172395,
-0.5898848772,
0.4249319136,
0.5673890114,
-1.0135406256,
0.1127812192,
0.3022084832,
1.0535755157,
-0.2471646667,
-0.017243661,
-0.5277615786,
0.273467809,
-0.3279039562,
1.309078455,
-0.3692226708,
-0.5433328152,
-0.06852258,
0.4876948297,
-0.5472277403,
-0.4401650429,
0.721239388,
-0.5318552852,
0.8550272584,
0.1696445346,
-0.2618500292,
-0.1926303208,
0.5056064129,
-0.7934409976,
1.4344810247,
0.1981171221,
-0.6483341455,
0.6188313961,
-0.1303522587,
-0.5767769217,
0.2395751625,
-0.3219170868,
-0.5752692223,
0.1375997961,
0.8191952109,
0.3659327328,
-0.2046023309,
0.5050237179,
0.1752370149,
-0.6574786305,
0.1679617763,
-0.6619102955,
0.4075117111,
-0.391051054,
-0.2588819861,
0.3280799985,
-0.8734639287,
-0.3560002446,
-0.058490295,
-0.2776297033,
-0.5930889249,
0.1099138409,
0.5372249484,
0.1586452574,
0.1952120811,
-0.8041650057,
-0.0016869096,
-0.3875858188,
0.2492692024,
0.3692587614,
0.105168052,
0.544903636,
-0.1271717846,
0.5653830767,
-0.025232736,
0.1716065854,
-0.6433183551,
-0.5735558867,
-0.8343593478,
-0.4536747634,
-0.1407126039,
0.8807873726,
-0.8064570427,
0.5252932906,
-0.0823244303,
-0.4776952863,
-0.2219982594,
-0.2636193335,
0.5203353167,
0.1923177689,
0.4622691274,
0.1201729029,
-0.38201648,
-0.7606442571,
-0.406596005,
0.2216428965,
-0.3096366227,
0.0790051371,
0.3508388102,
-0.08160007,
1.0616252422,
-0.5171085596,
-0.9411203265,
-0.3539346755,
-0.1365180463,
0.1201703846,
0.3159821928,
0.8369739056,
-1.2193959951,
-0.7308730483,
0.2725341916,
-0.7423320413,
0.0327752195,
-0.0179104488,
-0.3220130503,
0.405638665,
0.6490508914,
-0.3669658303,
0.6568669081,
0.462010175,
-0.4907528162,
0.2328088433,
-0.3738482893,
0.3462940156,
-1.2619737387,
-0.173714906,
0.2701948881,
-0.446719557,
-0.7049822807,
-0.1763350815,
0.3182395399,
0.0503430404,
-0.1431123316,
0.4891281426,
-0.4460644126,
0.1790540516,
-0.4092888534,
0.1184959039,
0.3329974711,
0.4969053566,
0.1731593907,
1.0282511711,
0.4825136662,
-0.3535936475,
0.09251073,
0.3156994283,
-0.0878327042,
0.443092078,
-0.6981527805,
0.1698068976,
-0.3676429689,
0.3579183817,
-1.3654347658,
-0.3268856406,
0.085305512,
-0.586425066,
0.1866631508,
-0.2128046155,
-0.4244900942,
-0.1203996241,
-0.2421463877,
0.2363195866,
0.1564860344,
-0.7627370358,
0.7389020324,
0.3273091316,
-0.2626184225,
-0.4680930972,
-0.7143109441,
0.2913896739,
0.1658779234,
-0.5593760014,
0.7956322432,
0.478558898,
0.3993760347,
-0.2776359618,
-0.2776482403,
-0.596201241,
-0.3511294723,
0.1085736528,
0.3000342548,
0.0199919492,
-0.009636594,
0.4594764709,
-0.4374771416,
-0.1482403427,
-0.4053745568,
0.1716468483,
0.3464140594,
-0.1727312505,
-0.1953996122,
0.3789259791,
0.6488305926,
-0.4208497703,
0.6099454165,
0.6218601465,
-0.4736934602,
-0.2846598029,
-0.3286787271,
0.25875175,
-0.4685601294,
0.4941838086,
-0.317697078,
-1.0293533802,
0.3441631496,
0.1414634734,
0.1241206601,
0.324908644,
0.1692475975,
-0.2249275595,
0.7920163274,
1.0428425074,
0.0477317385,
0.5858875513,
0.0433422849,
0.3003911376,
-0.4496853352,
-0.5091513395,
-0.4443728328,
-0.1404261142,
-0.0936833099,
-0.7247771621,
0.3106837571,
0.2139414996,
0.1624772102,
0.4117829204,
-0.8711587787,
0.5933443308,
0.5047907233,
0.3926313221,
0.3076870143,
-0.0788013339,
0.1770252585,
-0.1726957411,
-0.2443832159,
-0.3111284375,
0.6364762187,
-0.1730892509,
0.4308612943,
-0.0039000234,
0.4023908377,
0.1152594686,
0.2823156714,
-0.8260521889,
0.3019372821,
-0.6064730883,
-0.3610052764,
-0.2689595222,
-0.0288836583,
-0.5137786269,
0.6023055911,
0.1005252302,
-0.5560975075,
0.3858789206,
0.1225886196,
0.2013733387,
0.3346490264,
-0.6973935962,
0.9299697876,
-0.1130484194,
-0.157575354,
0.3789673448,
-0.4211927354,
0.2213259935,
-0.1417045891,
0.2042735815,
0.0946897045,
-0.2103085965,
0.6158367991,
-0.2389425784,
0.981839776,
-0.2656089067,
-0.271466583,
0.3451092839,
-0.1696903855,
0.4159247577,
-0.0213891845,
0.2600892484,
-0.1721929908,
-0.0728065595,
-0.2435729653,
-0.7002599239,
0.1324398667,
-0.4504567087,
-0.1994166821,
-0.3381996751,
-0.3985392451,
0.0051110853,
0.2828221917,
0.6748748422,
0.7398130894,
-0.1607567817,
0.2594190836,
0.5576062202,
-0.4089157879,
0.7455105782,
0.3287154734,
-0.3217554092,
-0.5748636127,
0.9201660156,
-0.2659870684,
-0.0154602965,
1.0772016048,
-0.1646286398,
-0.423755914,
-0.4913173914,
-0.7815465927,
-0.2106236219,
-0.4363233149,
-0.2017253786,
-0.9333602786,
-0.1747425795,
-0.0648484007,
-0.5885003805,
-0.2560704052,
-0.1783296466,
-0.3214760125,
-0.0454862863,
0.6005890965,
0.3485433757,
0.6950170398,
1.0085257292,
-0.6201069355,
0.4853732586,
0.0348487608,
0.3950234056,
-0.4002046585,
-0.6455578804,
-0.2546779811,
-0.5559634566,
-0.1565539688,
-0.8007972836,
0.7128252983,
0.2132722437,
0.290866524,
0.1992154866,
-0.0316056199,
0.4011360109,
-0.3945887089,
0.4874134958,
0.1984986365,
-0.7657303214,
0.5468540192,
-0.4325196147,
0.5388425589,
0.4420123398,
0.1089394614,
-0.7045963407,
-0.6753219962,
0.1504330039,
-0.9359236956,
0.8486481905,
0.2238698155,
0.0149502307,
0.0658418983,
0.1620632261,
0.0440229066,
-0.0300402809,
-0.6657389402,
-0.1023909748,
-0.3940329254,
-0.6209399104,
0.0097710565,
-0.2745331824,
0.3246386647,
-0.0826860741,
0.291927129,
-0.3144439459,
0.2192424536,
0.5741783977,
-0.4509697855,
0.2561960518,
0.5366686583,
0.379820168,
0.38542822,
-0.1197608113,
-0.0355775356,
-0.0228350703,
-0.9434217811,
0.1185034588,
0.612493217,
-0.4188022017,
0.4325166941,
0.3364871442,
0.7047820687,
0.5331236124,
-0.584035933,
0.7065446377,
-0.16893363,
-0.5624873638,
-0.240273118,
-0.1999801844,
-0.1382851601,
-0.0520592704,
0.7521612644,
0.1591994315,
0.1851058453,
0.0689935908,
0.3695217371,
0.1278530508,
-0.908052206,
-0.1660230756,
0.8669376969,
0.058773458,
-0.1839908212,
0.0678340569,
-0.1410770267,
-0.9144322276,
0.8890371323,
0.7237492204,
0.8963081241,
-0.0806188211,
0.2412169725,
0.0947341695,
0.3408919573,
0.0646954551,
0.2643675506,
-0.3335413039,
-0.7255821228,
-0.5115768313,
-0.6124323606,
-0.5859129429,
-0.3347835243,
-0.5234975815,
0.3349924386,
-0.2787468731,
0.2574927211,
0.0411660671,
-0.4386716485,
-0.1228422821,
0.3831520677,
-0.1284169406,
0.7766608596,
-0.3996254504,
0.4803925157,
1.0926574469,
-0.2407363951,
-0.3530246913,
-0.0531332381,
-0.0887176096,
-0.6525010467,
0.1181360856,
0.7382668257,
-0.1380772144,
0.1105122939,
-0.3567141891,
-0.649507165,
1.14138484,
-0.1003616452,
-0.6581280828,
-0.1965086162,
-0.0255777203,
0.4329188168,
-0.0414946079,
0.6831608415,
0.3384916186,
0.1545262039,
0.3080380261,
-0.7039154172,
-0.0438359566,
-0.2213075608,
-0.2272640318,
0.6258288026,
-0.6241186261,
0.5828114748,
0.1197070926,
-0.2035008818,
-0.0406337641,
0.488278985,
0.5039674044,
0.7045705318,
0.452145189,
0.2594668865,
0.2378659248,
-0.1804797798,
0.8906394243,
-0.1617197096,
0.2494681925,
0.898698926,
-0.0288807116,
0.7200807929,
0.2580429912,
-0.1150409877,
0.3551600277,
0.5039513111,
-0.0320533849,
0.6752195954,
-0.24982813,
-0.4047112167,
-0.0615967512,
0.1603568196,
0.0836989507,
0.3583078086,
0.3901849985,
-0.4242651463,
-0.4809150398,
0.2326087803,
-0.0921686441,
0.4081044495,
-0.1616318971,
0.793094635,
-0.0293645244,
-0.6152614355,
0.0214069951,
0.1846460253,
1.2430108786,
-0.5738128424,
0.051903028,
-0.3129995167,
0.3511634171,
-0.148412779,
-0.8301846981,
0.2607802153,
0.1757719219,
-0.6162669063,
-0.480951041,
1.0307016373,
-0.6078112125,
-0.6358935237,
0.4778495431,
0.4377014637,
-0.0860869959,
-0.7194878459,
-0.0557109118,
-0.3502798676,
0.1589569002,
-0.1149370968,
0.142125532,
0.807564497,
-0.3097443879,
0.2173543423,
0.6841799617,
-0.2766654491,
0.2329280674,
0.5269218087,
0.7950577736,
-0.8584259152,
-0.9504001737,
-0.6761995554,
0.4673547745,
-0.1180112064,
-0.5004671812,
0.4819115102,
0.8872910142,
0.5613826513,
0.0193219185,
0.8116024137,
0.0191350803,
0.5550346971,
-0.2327322811,
0.9440802932,
-0.526848197,
-0.1142294779,
-0.1467226297,
-0.9074540138,
-0.5259075165,
0.247933045,
-0.085652031,
-0.2195072025,
0.587628901,
0.472787112,
-0.2784544826,
0.1646410525,
0.3456110656,
-0.4058481455,
0.6680588722,
0.3808464408,
0.7954241633,
-0.6098155975,
0.9447642565,
0.0016050691,
-0.3590756059,
0.1766736507,
-0.4583689272,
-1.0029785633,
-0.4172606766,
0.1609793007,
0.4482261837,
-0.0501642935,
0.0255522728,
0.5606305003,
-0.6405168772,
0.1614530981,
-0.4983483851,
-0.0742111802,
0.2005413026,
-0.296318233,
0.5398199558,
-0.3894646466,
-0.8431757689,
0.3120493889,
0.6841905713,
0.1277554482,
0.2348195612,
0.4232439697,
-0.1458993405,
-0.3176716864,
0.8155741096,
0.0550249852,
-0.5157054663,
0.2407222688,
0.3567242026,
-0.2390992939,
-0.0036327448,
0.6793771982,
-0.9629390836,
0.5087325573,
0.3482497633,
0.8351009488,
0.7979196906,
0.1742487401,
0.5411634445,
-1.0199462175,
0.4236991405,
-0.0642412528,
0.3108816743,
0.3197810352,
-0.4629936218,
0.3019221723,
0.2585006356,
-0.4915418327,
-0.4279790521,
-0.2317829132,
-0.9917950034,
-0.2279961407,
0.6049578786,
-0.0270531345,
-0.2727592587,
-0.3271518648,
-0.5987440348,
0.2647929192,
-0.588513732,
0.3902603686,
0.319755435,
-0.0006718141,
-0.5893347859,
-0.5597566366,
0.2788593173,
0.2752294242,
-1.0647836924,
-0.1584323943,
0.4483519495,
-0.0565420426,
0.0284106601,
0.8776959777,
0.0726445317,
0.2699564397,
-0.0028602798,
-0.0317955613,
-0.0512946919,
-0.3280477226,
-0.3041920662,
0.0108875548,
-0.813841939,
-0.6495766044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03361v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03361v3 | WHAT, WHEN, and HOW to Ground: Designing User Persona-Aware Conversational Agents for Engaging Dialogue | 2023-06-06T02:28:38 | 2023-07-03T22:44:12 | Deuksin Kwon, Sunwoo Lee, Ki Hyun Kim, Seojin Lee, Taeyoon Kim, Eric Davis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.1, I.2.7 | This paper presents a method for building a personalized open-domain dialogue
system to address the WWH (WHAT, WHEN, and HOW) problem for natural response
generation in a commercial setting, where personalized dialogue responses are
heavily interleaved with casual response turns. The proposed approach involves
weighted dataset blending, negative persona information augmentation methods,
and the design of personalized conversation datasets to address the challenges
of WWH in personalized, open-domain dialogue systems. Our work effectively
balances dialogue fluency and tendency to ground, while also introducing a
response-type label to improve the controllability and explainability of the
grounded responses. The combination of these methods leads to more fluent
conversations, as evidenced by subjective human evaluations as well as
objective evaluations. | [
-0.8976991177,
-0.7324266434,
0.4733761251,
0.2531245947,
-0.0030264701,
0.3894407749,
-0.1548788399,
-0.1793483347,
0.1444890946,
0.5399982333,
-0.6602814198,
-0.4370484352,
-0.0570983626,
-0.1358159333,
0.2173305899,
0.8763648868,
0.3342006505,
-0.1149862334,
-0.3712352812,
-0.4676376283,
-0.9888076186,
-0.8176516891,
-0.339620024,
-0.439563632,
0.3300916255,
0.6594256163,
0.9013571143,
0.0604252331,
0.206757769,
0.3903632462,
-0.0080585293,
0.1795961708,
-0.6149990559,
0.3516369164,
-0.3533889353,
-0.1543410271,
-0.3578972816,
0.003147603,
-0.0574864484,
0.966121614,
-0.2977207005,
0.0170663316,
0.0648147911,
0.3246155679,
-0.4921392798,
0.251298219,
-0.3514945209,
0.1752846539,
0.0440342873,
-0.7593484521,
-0.5117740035,
-0.2560748756,
0.4180109203,
-0.7914559245,
0.1863699853,
0.2337088138,
0.500174582,
0.0675302371,
-0.495734483,
-0.0045836004,
-0.9867303967,
0.5888343453,
-0.7481945157,
0.1019693613,
0.2842658758,
0.620687604,
-0.2715213001,
-0.3705070913,
-0.431122154,
-0.2398177832,
-0.1488898695,
0.3101586103,
-0.0870641991,
0.2780508399,
0.389859885,
0.2920694649,
-0.4428853393,
-0.2040227354,
0.1795936376,
0.0184958763,
0.4813292921,
0.3127138019,
0.1582595557,
0.1273454279,
-0.0769677237,
0.0355472714,
-0.381347239,
0.3196503818,
0.5723585486,
0.3968852162,
-0.0302794836,
0.9076187611,
-0.64590168,
0.7475025058,
0.6923830509,
-0.1818503439,
0.0605304949,
0.003527737,
-0.2940428555,
0.1288646907,
0.453153342,
0.7451394796,
0.4839895964,
-0.2769788802,
-0.0785097629,
0.0668146834,
0.4207790792,
-0.8429017067,
0.0277968794,
0.3814970553,
-0.4483980536,
-0.5842096806,
0.1380161345,
-0.6655541062,
-0.4970490932,
-0.7203552127,
0.1839719117,
-0.1350512058,
-0.2248571813,
0.0572238751,
-0.2194184959,
0.2173770517,
0.2804793715,
-0.7372797728,
0.6560035348,
0.2882747948,
0.321413964,
0.2461278141,
0.2178403139,
-0.861499846,
0.1783118546,
-0.2489952743,
0.504581511,
-0.4284332097,
-0.4663220644,
0.3740972281,
-0.2240311801,
0.167406559,
-0.5754291415,
0.4246761203,
-0.5857890844,
0.6398772597,
-0.5716453791,
-0.1244178489,
-0.0286178347,
0.5079955459,
-0.1017909423,
0.5743681192,
0.325771749,
-1.097211957,
0.0286470149,
-0.7359978557,
-0.5209317207,
0.3357896805,
-0.2555757761,
0.1621864587,
0.2897280455,
0.0991229936,
0.2810157835,
-0.384285152,
0.5376170874,
-0.1485317796,
-0.2300622165,
0.3843705654,
-0.0694675744,
0.4657290876,
0.2770921588,
-0.5757246614,
0.2979044616,
-0.8828580976,
0.3098264933,
0.295825392,
-0.0305876154,
-0.4705682397,
0.1286778301,
0.0663337782,
0.3880913556,
0.1793384105,
-0.4444696903,
-0.1170112938,
-0.5289869905,
0.2686167955,
0.7914127707,
0.2843305469,
0.3496960402,
-0.505681932,
0.3554410934,
0.2113070786,
-0.169863686,
-0.5093607903,
-0.5636159182,
-0.7624325752,
0.2225490957,
-0.1242445856,
0.5600301027,
-0.7315670252,
0.7407596111,
-0.231516391,
-0.3308698237,
-0.210405916,
-0.2713495195,
0.6008584499,
1.2551339865,
0.2807691991,
-0.4752347767,
-0.4116274714,
-0.8393585086,
-0.3002489805,
-0.3428635299,
-0.126121074,
0.7062867284,
-0.1310198903,
-0.2653597295,
1.5347608328,
-0.9058434367,
-0.0214717854,
-0.1915660948,
0.3830055892,
-0.1648813486,
0.3013893664,
0.4155179262,
-0.8619084358,
-0.5892754197,
0.2519561946,
-0.8529108167,
-0.4026808143,
-0.051639799,
-0.1933402866,
-0.1998543739,
0.0612651631,
-0.8079180121,
0.5089671612,
0.00998432,
-0.5508158207,
0.4732422531,
-0.06382709,
0.4850457907,
-1.0249406099,
0.0922578797,
0.2153292447,
-0.3234435618,
-0.8549823165,
-0.1153371632,
-0.5724245906,
-0.5882021785,
-0.4208365679,
0.3447569013,
-0.1469167769,
-0.0910205618,
-0.2610936761,
0.1108724251,
0.0822703615,
0.8686337471,
0.0819491521,
0.8378096223,
0.2401866317,
-0.8656948209,
0.2210306227,
0.9395543337,
-0.140251264,
1.1379717588,
-0.8524147868,
0.41057989,
-0.4740341902,
0.3739673495,
-1.0394051075,
-0.5284351707,
0.3806303144,
-0.4763559103,
-0.1088743508,
-0.1243940741,
-0.2006134689,
-0.2830761373,
-0.0714661032,
0.2297771126,
0.6421515346,
-0.5624504089,
0.5358017087,
0.4013166428,
-0.2093507499,
-0.1262303591,
-0.3041404188,
0.1686333716,
-0.4856000543,
-1.0513114929,
0.4972681701,
-0.5185320377,
-0.7584477663,
-0.4277486205,
-0.1256692261,
0.0074212374,
0.072863631,
0.354675889,
-0.2661097348,
-0.2332756519,
-0.1783178002,
-0.0427558832,
-0.2407363206,
0.1820747852,
-0.1845766455,
0.7918131351,
-0.0674152747,
-0.2874183357,
-0.612724483,
0.5399616957,
0.6374952793,
-0.1991827637,
0.5419126749,
0.167578429,
-0.3685408235,
0.2460470498,
-0.5753603578,
-0.150251165,
-0.5480908155,
-0.2401141524,
-0.5202977657,
-0.624766171,
0.5020875931,
-0.3548142016,
0.2340414375,
-0.0266422797,
0.7444330454,
-0.3643200994,
1.2311472893,
0.3963050544,
0.0532307997,
0.2662078142,
-0.0154341497,
0.5347468257,
-0.6723070145,
-0.4600939155,
-0.4572846889,
-0.3218759596,
-0.2430941761,
-0.1496993005,
0.1435452402,
-0.3581911922,
-0.4647512436,
0.3387207985,
-0.3144641221,
0.0495962612,
0.5080720186,
-0.112142615,
0.2343057096,
-0.1423860639,
-0.2181412429,
-0.5206782818,
-0.2559562027,
-0.6007442474,
0.5366008282,
0.350518465,
0.787830472,
0.1914435774,
0.4136022329,
0.4802142084,
0.1338951439,
-0.8271381855,
0.5906329751,
0.5331164598,
-0.3003638685,
-0.2296263874,
-0.2029883862,
-0.7269228697,
0.4940094054,
0.0998736024,
-0.6911008358,
0.0323360376,
0.208435744,
-0.4016313553,
-0.2110670358,
-0.7644619942,
0.5841168165,
-0.0888341144,
-0.2773851156,
0.0440245681,
-0.8786229491,
0.3705017567,
0.1335811615,
0.2568871081,
-0.2082566023,
0.3433987498,
0.4650333226,
-0.7015148401,
0.8936178088,
-0.6537881494,
-0.1311628371,
0.4798116982,
0.0706988797,
0.6788113713,
0.1328575164,
0.1561800689,
-0.3479475975,
-0.5045840144,
-0.2380245924,
-0.8238006234,
0.4602770209,
-0.6526851654,
-0.7822299004,
-0.2066913843,
-0.2207407951,
-0.8587655425,
0.0970605165,
0.3741665483,
0.5681946874,
-0.7403646708,
0.2313471437,
0.8847025037,
-0.206842944,
0.2646778226,
0.6296449304,
0.1542570442,
-0.5633711219,
0.8092421889,
-0.1956399828,
0.1283848137,
0.3615974188,
0.3631765246,
-0.1811402738,
-0.1810364425,
-0.2177987099,
-0.2630251348,
-0.5214923024,
-0.3613943458,
-0.7565307617,
-0.1518197656,
-0.6109774113,
-0.3722859621,
-0.0266441721,
-0.2487774491,
-0.2594594359,
-0.2638246417,
0.0045181932,
0.4248026609,
0.4742730558,
0.9183889627,
-0.4573654234,
0.5824572444,
0.3901046216,
0.0821502358,
-0.2350874096,
-0.5495482087,
-0.0374523215,
0.265160054,
-0.6812326908,
-0.8310735226,
0.5936551094,
-0.0200004019,
0.6589283943,
0.6905793548,
0.4014387131,
0.6948096156,
-0.6396629214,
0.7672915459,
0.3186487556,
-0.863280654,
0.7573426366,
-0.7585297227,
0.2498983592,
0.5862148404,
0.2115347683,
-0.7718563676,
-0.270547688,
-0.885946393,
-0.7482503653,
0.6245955825,
0.4261104167,
0.432670176,
0.0118516209,
-0.0049494556,
0.0634055063,
0.6591578722,
-0.3831357956,
-0.2684055269,
-0.2809361517,
-0.0749516636,
-0.0940483883,
-0.1858079731,
-0.6943635345,
-0.0105790012,
0.347142756,
-0.6102107763,
0.2618291676,
-0.0086677829,
-0.1310391724,
-0.363398701,
0.3579862714,
0.5480515957,
0.6098217368,
-0.311717391,
-0.0099539878,
-0.0888448358,
0.0746195167,
0.3083532751,
-0.1042285115,
-0.0746355876,
-0.1981305927,
-0.0363361649,
0.7492283583,
0.4226509333,
-0.801807344,
0.5067411065,
-0.2436657995,
-0.2194528282,
-0.268220365,
0.0284842402,
-0.0876030102,
0.0415829085,
0.356805563,
0.139008075,
0.3147831559,
-0.4518054426,
0.1594896764,
0.4077470303,
-0.2889267504,
-0.4217655361,
0.6362017393,
0.657499969,
-0.6602241397,
0.4582287371,
0.1396940202,
-0.4123438001,
0.3395414948,
0.66309762,
0.9953641891,
-0.2736618221,
0.5320091844,
0.1030161306,
-0.1377442181,
0.3763095737,
0.1980231106,
-0.2819115818,
-0.730676353,
-0.0294256788,
-0.0333568715,
-0.6212488413,
0.2070068568,
-0.8310697675,
0.2953357399,
-0.638866365,
-0.3462946117,
-0.1429627836,
0.0006325284,
-0.796992898,
0.4918091297,
0.0858753473,
0.7222498059,
-0.8510391116,
0.2242626101,
0.6258234978,
-0.2575973272,
-0.325163871,
0.2846830189,
-0.0629574582,
-0.4161981344,
0.3749524951,
0.3557335138,
-0.2404688746,
0.0878112465,
-0.6077728868,
-0.5277017355,
1.0730860233,
0.1786279827,
-0.2318523973,
0.0314700119,
0.1368126422,
0.6162060499,
-0.5542426705,
0.1903412342,
0.5549821258,
0.3907170594,
0.3670283854,
-0.6568143964,
-0.0957173258,
-0.3915224075,
0.2128292918,
-0.1497741789,
-1.0066950321,
0.3104176223,
0.0170324184,
-0.0952301472,
0.0810286328,
0.6767851114,
0.3095662892,
0.4948473871,
0.5694310069,
0.544459641,
0.7899044752,
-0.0634304583,
0.7241153121,
-0.2797857821,
-0.1973335147,
1.2286776304,
-0.708273828,
0.3157812059,
0.3593596518,
0.191952765,
0.5255462527,
0.6497014761,
0.3963211775,
0.771545887,
0.4719770253,
-0.6120649576,
-0.2010853738,
-0.3428604603,
-0.3947604299,
0.2728978693,
0.2982445061,
0.1186977401,
-0.1715890914,
0.3111273348,
-0.2003481984,
0.2997680604,
0.1606357247,
0.9953868985,
-0.1783079207,
-0.9950745702,
0.4107675254,
0.3527300358,
0.4152909219,
-0.4459959567,
0.0939016044,
-0.4868219495,
-0.0979390815,
-0.2048243582,
-0.4931328595,
0.1248557568,
0.0148541713,
-0.1746527106,
-0.513453722,
0.6835892797,
-0.2799264193,
0.2906107306,
0.1161719933,
0.5118940473,
-0.0343839861,
-0.2052680999,
-0.5296893716,
-0.0255378969,
-0.0892847255,
-0.3847386241,
0.3866045177,
0.5873808265,
-0.1453234553,
0.7940376997,
0.6602076292,
-0.595110476,
-0.2217476368,
0.331546098,
1.1461086273,
-0.6741831303,
-0.7647967339,
-0.1926783323,
1.0617880821,
-0.2719832957,
-0.3598897755,
0.6419582367,
0.5539239049,
0.3741418123,
-0.3242166638,
1.0427321196,
-0.1247392893,
0.4688077271,
-0.1448480189,
0.2296969593,
-0.0279843993,
0.085592933,
-0.3568163812,
-1.0879793167,
0.1912590712,
0.7076011896,
0.0282384716,
0.1605214924,
0.3959347308,
0.5179898739,
-0.046819143,
0.0418132283,
0.5340086818,
-0.0809298083,
0.843043983,
0.2273441553,
1.0663472414,
-0.0807020962,
0.2205354869,
-0.1466312706,
-0.4781296253,
-0.4438571334,
-0.715046227,
-1.0054392815,
-0.5304784179,
-0.5255511999,
-0.6350397468,
-0.0810665116,
1.0879116058,
0.7054550648,
-0.7229214907,
-0.2879679501,
-0.2757097781,
-0.2342366576,
0.0209072027,
-0.3001820445,
-0.3383249938,
-0.5494245291,
-0.7582778335,
0.6921563745,
0.2634189725,
0.3232263327,
-0.2620508075,
-0.2877420187,
0.2652545571,
0.48353827,
0.7015628815,
0.5622447133,
-0.5258380175,
-0.2346096635,
-0.0520566888,
-0.2085328102,
0.3490514159,
1.2719931602,
-0.9950646162,
0.5092046261,
0.3702192307,
0.6306059957,
0.3117950261,
0.6204675436,
1.0105116367,
-1.0185775757,
0.3981091082,
0.4920759797,
0.0967242196,
0.483525902,
-0.6842408776,
0.4894034564,
0.361569792,
-0.3678073585,
-0.7207635045,
0.2821857333,
-1.2336524725,
0.150794059,
1.0113838911,
-0.1749937832,
0.3068678677,
-0.4189762473,
-0.7433076501,
-0.141496256,
-0.389202565,
0.5255330801,
0.7759751678,
-0.2551267147,
0.1722602695,
-0.4168240428,
0.4830296338,
0.1937631518,
-0.9821835756,
0.144657746,
0.6627455354,
0.1766311526,
0.2515738904,
1.0717746019,
0.2765537798,
-0.05825096,
-0.1951771379,
-0.2024853826,
-0.0202032886,
-0.5126620531,
0.0288612954,
0.3722055554,
0.0618136488,
-0.2446525842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03355v1 | BatchSampler: Sampling Mini-Batches for Contrastive Learning in Vision, Language, and Graphs | 2023-06-06T02:13:27 | 2023-06-06T02:13:27 | Zhen Yang, Tinglin Huang, Ming Ding, Yuxiao Dong, Rex Ying, Yukuo Cen, Yangliao Geng, Jie Tang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | In-Batch contrastive learning is a state-of-the-art self-supervised method
that brings semantically-similar instances close while pushing dissimilar
instances apart within a mini-batch. Its key to success is the negative sharing
strategy, in which every instance serves as a negative for the others within
the mini-batch. Recent studies aim to improve performance by sampling hard
negatives \textit{within the current mini-batch}, whose quality is bounded by
the mini-batch itself. In this work, we propose to improve contrastive learning
by sampling mini-batches from the input data. We present
BatchSampler\footnote{The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/THUDM/BatchSampler}} to sample mini-batches of
hard-to-distinguish (i.e., hard and true negatives to each other) instances. To
make each mini-batch have fewer false negatives, we design the proximity graph
of randomly-selected instances. To form the mini-batch, we leverage random walk
with restart on the proximity graph to help sample hard-to-distinguish
instances. BatchSampler is a simple and general technique that can be directly
plugged into existing contrastive learning models in vision, language, and
graphs. Extensive experiments on datasets of three modalities show that
BatchSampler can consistently improve the performance of powerful contrastive
models, as shown by significant improvements of SimCLR on ImageNet-100, SimCSE
on STS (language), and GraphCL and MVGRL on graph datasets. | [
-0.8000066876,
-0.4557720721,
0.3155469,
-0.2784017324,
-0.4370199442,
-0.0305203907,
0.0019757005,
-0.5241368413,
0.412047863,
0.3335942924,
-0.4504368603,
-0.3295085132,
-0.5487759113,
-0.0011867447,
-0.3899708986,
0.9578784704,
0.0368757397,
0.21038571,
-0.1140985265,
-0.4669529796,
-0.6734513044,
-0.2191256881,
-1.1231204271,
-0.4179487526,
0.5438834429,
0.6510587931,
0.266177237,
0.6580553651,
0.5131305456,
0.3423488438,
0.2315208465,
-0.0986523181,
-0.721660018,
0.1139729694,
-0.2654196918,
-0.5892013311,
0.076478444,
0.0357045904,
0.4170883894,
0.6895156503,
-0.0597208142,
0.1862175018,
0.4820381999,
0.6584094763,
-0.5811577439,
-0.0262365919,
-0.3350202739,
0.1432977468,
-0.4122918546,
-0.0061621363,
-0.0732076764,
-0.2800963223,
-0.2085022777,
-0.5880895257,
0.9473461509,
0.2938050926,
0.821677804,
0.3881473839,
-0.1192959026,
-0.1317347586,
-0.3767518699,
0.9520651698,
-0.3245540261,
0.2237569243,
0.2753482461,
0.8013665676,
0.2149856538,
-0.9220162034,
-0.6143818498,
-0.068476513,
-0.1590957046,
0.1544748247,
0.0833989009,
0.17294164,
0.2166532874,
0.8327002525,
-0.4185119569,
0.2628490925,
-0.642468214,
-0.211128369,
0.1545209885,
0.3329210579,
0.1187809631,
-0.0344373658,
-0.3098567426,
-0.5624393821,
-0.4425774515,
-0.1680117249,
0.1219092086,
0.4863874316,
-0.1009650528,
0.4505536854,
-0.2488156706,
0.75858742,
0.2960281372,
0.1020696014,
0.5112478733,
-0.4535663724,
-0.4502842426,
-0.2129836679,
0.6353386045,
0.3882696033,
0.0044625681,
0.2040816844,
-0.4291430116,
0.0561831631,
0.0339735076,
-1.2021665573,
-0.8553293943,
0.2746600807,
-0.5263608694,
-0.3748455346,
-0.146578148,
-0.9540544152,
-0.7658304572,
-0.5420536399,
0.6041995287,
-0.4830000997,
0.1787578166,
-0.3264351785,
-0.4963384271,
-0.0851182938,
0.5418214798,
-0.6823580265,
0.8041114211,
0.1792658418,
0.8548355103,
-0.2737585008,
-0.4954130352,
-0.9045864344,
-0.1863596141,
-0.2375575602,
0.753534615,
-0.3242442906,
-0.4220358431,
-0.4551882148,
-0.1571804732,
0.0357663408,
-1.2001254559,
-0.0278754365,
-0.2893868685,
0.226463154,
-0.3915024698,
-0.5458096266,
-0.1365167201,
0.3558480442,
-0.9449304938,
1.0939440727,
0.2379658371,
-0.735837996,
0.6818109155,
-0.5836207867,
-0.3082415462,
0.2096930593,
-0.5771970749,
-0.6387204528,
-0.0309730321,
0.3409345746,
0.5487946272,
-0.1057847738,
-0.1672002226,
-0.3749229014,
-0.678578496,
-0.2052515,
-0.1697748899,
0.8031733036,
0.346288383,
-0.2408955842,
0.2692146003,
-0.6280136704,
-0.3217605054,
0.1564563811,
-0.0686853006,
-0.4118115008,
-0.394901067,
0.2497640848,
0.4229162037,
-0.1283024251,
-0.4100020826,
-0.1177050695,
0.0436925851,
-0.1171735376,
0.8491030335,
0.3505580425,
0.4232287109,
-0.6168786287,
0.5965958238,
0.3219892383,
0.0741188154,
-0.2259284109,
-0.1252596527,
-0.9766449928,
-0.795460701,
0.257791996,
0.4010481834,
-1.0381309986,
0.0922396034,
-0.0724397525,
-0.2836628556,
-0.6415253282,
0.5440167785,
0.4465494454,
0.8072722554,
0.7429577112,
-0.5593467951,
-0.5426136851,
-0.8059780598,
0.0735271648,
0.3646039367,
-0.1715172231,
0.5097255111,
0.4771476686,
-0.1188872904,
0.8708325028,
-0.6934344172,
-0.7061942816,
-0.3194554448,
0.1200850829,
0.0987159908,
0.5766998529,
0.4360911846,
-0.8530871272,
-0.6850858331,
-0.4102766812,
-0.639904201,
0.0909279287,
0.016981503,
0.0256273951,
-0.0334126428,
0.94594419,
0.0422094278,
0.1222799271,
0.4968934059,
0.2023962885,
0.319024384,
-0.14999336,
0.2364536673,
-1.3661957979,
0.1066936776,
0.2218160033,
-0.3913383186,
-0.3628575504,
0.0850901604,
-0.1035716161,
-0.1308764517,
-0.6761135459,
0.7161086798,
-0.4585655928,
0.101606369,
-0.161668092,
0.0344748162,
-0.1791049093,
0.4116746187,
-0.1259312183,
0.893823266,
0.5042176843,
-0.8331302404,
0.3159172833,
-0.0796898603,
-0.4044567645,
0.7996627688,
-0.556433022,
0.0390008166,
-0.2633220851,
0.2470521778,
-1.2788447142,
-0.3231179416,
0.311034292,
-0.0551620387,
0.5296162367,
-0.2631103992,
-0.3846746981,
-0.4041103423,
-0.3970781863,
0.5560365319,
0.6712992191,
-0.8760920167,
0.235352248,
0.3474960625,
0.0060612257,
-0.4606118202,
-0.8200107813,
-0.1794912815,
-0.33105129,
0.0294890925,
0.066070132,
-0.0366611369,
-0.4131731689,
0.0956117809,
-0.0372093134,
-0.0225078817,
-0.2085523009,
0.3020540774,
0.127480194,
0.1140173078,
0.1559782326,
-0.0767639205,
-0.2034985423,
-0.4959813058,
-0.3457190394,
0.7493907213,
-0.2406530231,
-0.4167530537,
-0.4210622907,
0.0269727334,
0.0953769013,
0.2138769627,
0.5541623831,
0.6141466498,
-0.2632184327,
-0.343334794,
-0.5082458854,
-0.5897250772,
-0.5190098882,
0.2579539716,
-0.4922344685,
-0.8006346226,
0.3591779172,
-0.0373756215,
-0.286167115,
0.3165977597,
0.3296705782,
-0.4389698505,
0.3605562747,
0.6398749352,
-0.2842694521,
0.8857999444,
-0.6288328171,
-0.2003870159,
-0.6452122927,
-0.013832951,
-0.2277196646,
-0.5683937669,
-0.6592265368,
-0.6223995686,
0.2373006195,
-0.0756353363,
-0.1249771789,
0.2537895143,
-0.3054673374,
0.9056606889,
0.8052896857,
0.3381584287,
0.1080193222,
0.2120038569,
-0.3079274893,
-0.1465867609,
-0.5861260891,
-0.0461603478,
0.7852678299,
-0.1441094577,
0.7801011205,
-0.3025273681,
1.2864392996,
0.4345483482,
0.3503980339,
-0.8231520057,
0.6280550361,
-0.3527032137,
-0.4162710309,
-0.2967323661,
-0.525126338,
-0.901317656,
0.3534707725,
0.1128575429,
-0.5937303901,
0.466987431,
0.723906219,
-0.1434229314,
0.4673072696,
-0.7864894271,
0.8662140965,
0.3383983076,
-0.4353019595,
-0.2019127905,
-0.9321457744,
0.3497814834,
-0.0534030013,
0.0938372314,
0.1914788336,
0.1877499074,
0.6060835719,
-0.5923938155,
1.1060256958,
-0.4646426737,
0.2306917757,
0.3618355989,
0.2313289493,
0.430563271,
-0.5583702326,
0.0924488306,
0.1316191256,
-0.3271869719,
-0.6473379135,
-0.4271747172,
0.5589057207,
-0.4971087575,
-0.3271286488,
-0.2457493097,
-0.2964177728,
-0.0104491897,
0.3953342736,
0.5229309797,
0.4910024107,
-0.1933740377,
0.060485553,
0.4553764462,
0.0236497503,
0.3609320819,
0.0107481349,
-0.2071636468,
-0.4269439578,
1.4310110807,
0.2122670561,
0.4224903584,
0.6370772719,
0.1546412408,
-0.273042351,
-0.5085868239,
-0.2424693704,
0.1464753598,
-0.8631852865,
-0.0587306507,
-0.438865155,
0.0128388591,
-0.0208258945,
-0.3846022785,
-0.2606880963,
-0.5092072487,
-0.2173618674,
-0.1142971069,
0.0543478876,
0.4486280084,
-0.4127369225,
0.2350268066,
-0.4056074321,
0.714099288,
0.5266267657,
0.1957356185,
-0.0404205546,
-0.381385982,
-0.2244694829,
-0.1581461579,
-0.1659155339,
-0.3362714052,
0.4511367679,
0.0378321186,
0.3389566243,
0.4284384847,
-0.0042332131,
0.8787567019,
-0.4076425433,
0.6664085388,
0.2610863149,
-0.6829735041,
0.4006455839,
-0.1418887824,
0.0921987519,
1.2267202139,
0.2555240095,
-0.5401201248,
-0.4523219168,
-0.5915865302,
-0.8499251604,
0.6748259664,
0.0529408045,
-0.257720679,
-0.0130672241,
-0.0108508915,
0.1374184936,
0.289616406,
-0.4623488486,
-0.4080721438,
-0.3300914466,
-0.4658242464,
-0.5489094257,
0.0502068661,
-0.2117989361,
-0.1330568939,
0.6229605675,
-0.1558679938,
0.0545347519,
-0.0336938538,
-0.2057956755,
0.2795613706,
0.1429465264,
0.1266701967,
0.1894749999,
-0.3998940289,
0.5821463466,
0.3973043561,
-0.6749237776,
0.2095469087,
0.2119750082,
-0.142421782,
-0.323125869,
-0.0974616259,
0.4553429484,
-0.2356923819,
-0.5414767861,
0.5562286973,
-0.0670617074,
0.0995920002,
-0.0078694867,
0.129536882,
-0.3192504942,
0.1612174064,
0.1311453879,
0.3811981976,
0.5480040908,
-0.2859753966,
0.3271833658,
0.2368675619,
-0.6802336574,
0.0966171548,
0.4544890523,
0.0922408104,
-0.0628785044,
0.8631834984,
-0.5350886583,
-0.2479766905,
0.8603108525,
0.5046710372,
0.7171938419,
-0.0912011787,
-0.0126668522,
0.3998558819,
0.171979636,
-0.0473048165,
0.1141361967,
-0.3958852887,
-0.746481657,
-0.0703713596,
-0.2462254912,
-0.6407563686,
0.1748766154,
-0.7673102617,
0.3018962443,
-0.4460452497,
0.1085050777,
-0.2708462179,
0.2030027658,
-0.794590652,
0.594486177,
-0.1114543527,
0.7044880986,
-1.0297983885,
0.9058919549,
0.498023808,
-0.670846045,
-0.548420608,
0.1753118485,
0.2404892743,
-0.8468324542,
0.5342483521,
0.4014723003,
-0.4198260009,
0.0108171161,
-0.4164171517,
-0.3608950377,
1.1601244211,
0.1984413564,
-0.6058630347,
0.3161441386,
-0.1155562103,
0.421631366,
-0.0343930237,
-0.0359649621,
0.3916544914,
0.0100629013,
0.328068465,
-0.3826384246,
0.3872174621,
-0.42244789,
0.1872641891,
0.3332774937,
-0.7269334793,
0.9229310751,
-0.4295448363,
-0.2543798685,
0.0262698922,
0.528734684,
0.6391966343,
0.5724797845,
0.5774199367,
0.6367782354,
0.9862701297,
0.2102337331,
1.3841475248,
-0.2014587373,
0.2953772247,
1.6443175077,
-0.0418921039,
0.6136196852,
0.8144436479,
-0.0323374048,
0.3084288239,
0.6344686151,
-0.31167081,
0.7059178352,
0.3319366276,
-0.3114360869,
-0.0424012505,
-0.0777690113,
-0.2422620356,
-0.1528812349,
0.2754895091,
-0.2792474926,
-0.2017642111,
0.1128524989,
-0.1346743703,
-0.156025514,
-0.3698652089,
0.6167774796,
0.1290312409,
-0.3417569399,
0.4544554353,
-0.1509836763,
0.8142142296,
-0.2580302656,
-0.2415832877,
-0.4411182702,
0.4597067833,
-0.1613526791,
-0.6904205084,
0.0937999189,
-0.3178576529,
-0.0095921401,
-0.0070957546,
0.5829403996,
-0.4034832716,
-0.321521461,
0.2148086131,
0.3831708133,
0.3010798991,
0.0852507874,
-0.437522918,
-0.1654633433,
-0.1788682491,
0.1324136108,
0.4367249012,
0.183414802,
0.1106460541,
0.4996403158,
0.4718683958,
0.0219276194,
0.0092087602,
0.3707829416,
0.8512585759,
-0.5391510725,
-0.4729159474,
-0.8300208449,
0.2936913967,
-0.3299541175,
-0.0456215441,
0.933852911,
0.9615402222,
1.2049837112,
-0.1926315576,
0.8021794558,
0.0613892451,
0.5246548653,
-0.4457654357,
0.5146991014,
-0.6548820734,
0.168059662,
-0.3143518567,
-0.7170546055,
-0.3650410175,
0.5559599996,
-0.3031887412,
0.3171156049,
0.7519360185,
1.0105081797,
-0.5503913164,
-0.4452722371,
0.3637482524,
0.1613817662,
0.1843864024,
0.3468928039,
0.7794234157,
-0.4961865842,
0.6225582361,
-0.5440116525,
-0.0881711394,
-0.3009243906,
-0.6183210015,
-0.8583295941,
-0.5223773718,
-0.2863789797,
-0.3702045381,
-0.0236309599,
0.9986873269,
0.9432586432,
-0.988990128,
-0.3364154398,
-0.5612304807,
0.0607337318,
-0.4374040365,
-0.287362963,
0.4179129601,
-0.5385501385,
-0.9455153346,
0.1779976785,
-0.0286820754,
0.4666207731,
0.1732293665,
-0.0764397532,
0.2348379344,
-0.057369899,
0.384770155,
0.5056112409,
-0.1421449482,
0.0556956455,
-0.4961509705,
-0.2257002145,
0.2826940417,
0.8692805171,
-1.0217162371,
0.580786407,
0.4034592509,
0.461250633,
1.1202538013,
0.1612614989,
-0.005542371,
-1.0679993629,
0.2034824342,
0.1337486506,
0.6122330427,
0.6077281237,
-0.0409277864,
0.5308163166,
0.4454186261,
-0.2195831239,
-0.5117673874,
0.261336416,
-0.9124721289,
-0.3230054677,
0.9622987509,
0.2523114979,
0.0210651737,
-0.1482898444,
-0.4061888754,
0.2116152942,
-0.4579944909,
0.8078659773,
0.2707519531,
-0.3342894614,
-0.1913322508,
-0.29139328,
0.5276382565,
0.1039724052,
-0.8262408972,
-0.2868233025,
0.670840621,
0.5998262167,
0.0399522968,
1.1256921291,
-0.1036905721,
0.0734925643,
0.3688418567,
0.0654518679,
-0.2269016653,
-0.5269238949,
-0.6996827722,
0.3506106734,
-0.0803040788,
-0.7376019955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03350v1 | Click: Controllable Text Generation with Sequence Likelihood Contrastive Learning | 2023-06-06T01:56:44 | 2023-06-06T01:56:44 | Chujie Zheng, Pei Ke, Zheng Zhang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It has always been an important yet challenging problem to control language
models to avoid generating texts with undesirable attributes, such as toxic
language and unnatural repetition. We introduce Click for controllable text
generation, which needs no modification to the model architecture and
facilitates out-of-the-box use of trained models. It employs a contrastive loss
on sequence likelihood, which fundamentally decreases the generation
probability of negative samples (i.e., generations with undesirable
attributes). It also adopts a novel likelihood ranking-based strategy to
construct contrastive samples from model generations. On the tasks of language
detoxification, sentiment steering, and repetition reduction, we show that
Click outperforms strong baselines of controllable text generation and
demonstrate the superiority of Click's sample construction strategy. | [
-0.3339803815,
-0.7226615548,
0.2385332584,
0.2040329427,
0.031134868,
0.0716697052,
-0.0042403531,
-0.2541464567,
0.0110711036,
0.5394139886,
-0.5063717365,
-0.4792631269,
-0.4151600301,
-0.0308292881,
-0.5647505522,
1.0996963978,
0.1694475412,
-0.3004770279,
-0.1950530559,
-0.1155483723,
0.0115444381,
-0.4996422827,
-1.0814861059,
-0.3350643814,
0.9168738127,
0.2220406681,
0.9261394143,
0.4539976716,
0.3035545051,
0.1885296255,
-0.0713015646,
0.0262891687,
-0.5567994118,
0.0873312131,
-0.380446434,
-0.3430713117,
-0.0901956633,
0.2587067485,
0.4224327207,
0.8557683825,
0.1500406563,
-0.2932510674,
0.2526305616,
0.9280157089,
-0.7134340405,
-0.4338296652,
-0.7057850361,
0.0740594566,
-0.153829053,
-0.5646734834,
-0.8038437963,
-0.7412292957,
-0.0009556861,
-0.2014612705,
0.2779872715,
0.0817563087,
0.7189782858,
0.1843362302,
-0.8397737741,
-0.1267676651,
-0.8401473761,
0.9914171696,
-0.5927891731,
0.2694002986,
0.3432069719,
-0.1237004176,
-0.3535326123,
-0.5233809948,
-0.4954733253,
-0.4531977773,
-0.0809649155,
0.1730441004,
-0.0814113319,
0.1488857269,
0.2003916204,
0.2099417299,
-0.5515204668,
0.1585784405,
-0.2736450732,
-0.2605832517,
0.6618530154,
0.1328845322,
0.5463170409,
-0.1629762799,
-0.4032109678,
-0.0425938629,
-0.8535999656,
-0.019769324,
0.742334187,
0.441316247,
-0.0487969592,
0.5369107127,
-0.0960766003,
0.5712152719,
0.2129711658,
-0.0030941442,
0.2839956582,
0.0474200509,
-0.1119135842,
-0.1770773679,
0.9616987109,
0.3568680882,
0.0415770411,
-0.0828667581,
0.0622985177,
-0.0665837526,
0.4158501923,
-0.8723077774,
-0.5283870697,
0.4672398865,
-0.5583617091,
-1.0965559483,
-0.1617920548,
-0.6200689077,
-0.2441488951,
-0.155599162,
0.4912286103,
-0.6196175218,
-0.0939888284,
-0.1801201403,
-0.013587228,
-0.0047309771,
0.2904413044,
-0.8067856431,
0.1668868512,
0.0504780412,
0.3750288785,
-0.7100154757,
-0.1106885821,
-0.7040669918,
0.1282315254,
-0.6340207458,
0.4221812785,
-0.6870068312,
-0.5511176586,
0.2608570755,
-0.1275008321,
-0.0405385159,
-0.8114497066,
0.1424320787,
-0.6965095997,
0.6742526889,
0.1759363711,
-0.5032921433,
-0.2355555445,
0.1776401699,
-0.7986347079,
0.9895021319,
-0.0064230715,
-0.8878950477,
0.4595736861,
-0.3268824816,
-0.6794002652,
-0.0837593302,
-0.0424683727,
-0.5994685888,
0.0954154134,
-0.3268305659,
0.3161839545,
0.0532380044,
0.1282083541,
-0.0482421294,
-0.020790061,
0.3984848261,
-0.4564835727,
0.7673348188,
0.3215243518,
-0.7177349329,
0.1083009988,
-0.9917336702,
-0.0675585791,
0.0618030243,
-0.9883336425,
-0.4372340441,
0.1171851233,
0.3935095966,
0.4250581264,
0.0350310765,
-0.1780914217,
0.019726567,
-0.3219054043,
-0.1082413569,
0.417004019,
0.200351432,
0.3839105368,
-0.4745738804,
0.5251876712,
0.2152479291,
0.0455329008,
-0.2415798455,
-0.2428101301,
-1.0151399374,
-0.068422474,
0.1789794713,
0.6908867955,
-1.0558925867,
0.4662388563,
0.1244301423,
-0.4483707845,
-0.2362951189,
0.2861132622,
0.5964154601,
0.5749157667,
0.406701237,
-0.1432123333,
-0.1157937646,
-0.8489869237,
-0.1993172616,
-0.0241341591,
-0.267385602,
0.3109363914,
0.3230989873,
-0.0745038912,
0.5745239854,
-0.3958919048,
0.0993577689,
-0.4347339272,
0.5794864893,
-0.0842334554,
0.6944705844,
0.3096145093,
-1.1545352936,
-0.4370758533,
-0.2790567279,
-0.50736624,
-0.3127350807,
-0.4116990566,
-0.0909875482,
0.5083841681,
0.8283302784,
-0.1712321341,
0.3871843517,
0.5905992985,
-0.2419527471,
0.4609308243,
-0.1749562621,
0.2889666259,
-1.2874858379,
0.5973123908,
0.0394399427,
-0.2518375814,
-0.7702283263,
-0.0365841985,
0.0374047421,
-0.3000411391,
-0.8272569776,
0.4367538691,
-0.1387633234,
0.5097103119,
-0.3644316494,
-0.0979798585,
-0.0215661563,
0.5635408759,
0.219365254,
0.6052471399,
0.0873460546,
-0.986728549,
-0.1469986886,
0.2397665381,
-0.1203043461,
0.468718797,
-0.4262691438,
-0.1189644635,
-0.3106866777,
-0.0412820056,
-1.1247903109,
-0.0542885922,
0.3021351397,
-0.4502203465,
0.5044724345,
0.2892410755,
-0.2038680464,
-0.1375089586,
-0.3611657619,
0.3478317261,
0.6348755956,
-0.5059518814,
0.2232077271,
0.0655271634,
-0.3986656964,
-0.3685903549,
-0.5998905301,
-0.0647920668,
-0.3625772595,
0.1342716068,
0.3589332998,
-0.3246742189,
-0.0116494801,
-0.1402048618,
0.2658219039,
0.2550027072,
0.1232978106,
0.1569056064,
0.1919005513,
0.2795725763,
0.5034407377,
0.2539389431,
-0.386454463,
-0.0405526161,
-0.0136704575,
0.5977960825,
0.6298345327,
-0.2714700103,
-0.4566480517,
0.430444479,
0.4317748249,
-0.1900022477,
0.7112385035,
0.3298221529,
-0.069656536,
-0.4479453266,
-0.2965789437,
-0.1772328764,
-0.5056703687,
0.2605108917,
-0.0781789124,
-0.8449114561,
-0.0597076416,
-0.415063113,
0.0305563286,
0.4180389643,
0.4361857772,
-0.2049548179,
1.0901777744,
0.70692873,
-0.2559480071,
0.4089381993,
0.0774586424,
0.1773326546,
-0.2971001267,
-0.0792897046,
-0.4746799767,
-0.4500867724,
-0.9642893672,
-0.3193156123,
0.2487954199,
0.1900699437,
-0.5504838824,
0.2183076292,
-0.5301477909,
0.2995742559,
0.7999638915,
0.248879984,
0.3441132009,
0.0588626266,
-0.470962435,
-0.2426778823,
-0.5972718,
-0.523319602,
0.8056012988,
0.121732831,
0.8983081579,
0.0475807674,
0.9836961627,
0.2924906611,
0.3884511292,
-0.5373846889,
0.5560144186,
-0.3850134015,
-0.6640313864,
-0.2543000877,
-0.3987554014,
-0.8831299543,
-0.067599453,
-0.4751629233,
-0.7251935005,
0.0497065447,
0.4066212773,
-0.1600257307,
0.475409776,
-0.291300416,
0.7568359375,
-0.0097889928,
-0.5938244462,
-0.1532851607,
-0.6432446837,
0.3651928902,
-0.19011949,
0.1864254773,
0.0616735183,
-0.1729059815,
0.5460385084,
-0.4021613598,
1.0290389061,
0.0992239192,
-0.2652714252,
0.2545171678,
0.5720102787,
0.5153508782,
-0.446862638,
-0.0771421045,
-0.3114857674,
-0.6199434996,
-0.3914341331,
-0.3006127179,
0.6845331788,
-0.3632496595,
-0.3783856928,
-0.0453659408,
-0.4347666204,
-0.2430876791,
0.2740770876,
0.6209292412,
0.5869690776,
-0.3141624331,
0.1609454155,
0.8812212944,
-0.8717229366,
0.5925342441,
0.1721917987,
-0.2978307009,
-0.507923007,
1.2954801321,
-0.285944134,
0.7100636363,
0.8427557945,
0.2098666877,
-0.314432919,
-0.5396351814,
0.0846732408,
0.1135131866,
-0.4617494643,
0.0252937395,
-0.7600600123,
-0.3091722727,
-0.1182931289,
-0.5128105879,
-0.1785446405,
-0.3365622163,
-0.3964482844,
-0.210452497,
0.2156289369,
0.6233258843,
-0.2261840254,
0.3910353184,
-0.9049665332,
0.3759144545,
0.5466349721,
0.2216644734,
-0.0531436354,
-0.1688096374,
-0.0131738884,
-0.427108407,
-0.6398998499,
-0.9974136353,
0.5583242774,
0.1301502883,
0.3823479712,
0.6281375289,
0.4195951819,
-0.0732235238,
-0.4776750207,
0.8795344234,
0.3535001576,
-0.8515310287,
0.8836709261,
-0.6024551392,
0.4786862135,
0.5948199034,
0.9156413674,
-0.3305179179,
-0.8716933131,
-0.8161495924,
-1.0610601902,
0.4877146482,
0.3211613297,
0.3569001555,
-0.3524277806,
0.0058724545,
0.1426479816,
0.5503588915,
-0.8523379564,
-0.407359004,
0.118683137,
-0.3776057363,
-0.1231816188,
-0.5284613371,
-0.0784498751,
0.2407406867,
0.909260869,
0.0492015779,
-0.1345245242,
-0.0869487599,
0.0039344444,
-0.1345438659,
0.346264869,
0.2723874152,
0.1246484891,
-0.1154672205,
0.2500304878,
-0.1028392017,
-0.3106405735,
0.2288770974,
-0.0586188026,
-0.6947542429,
0.0053419289,
0.0361890085,
0.6767376065,
0.4663233757,
-0.481202215,
0.4886968434,
0.4294323921,
-0.3344492018,
0.0841594934,
0.1114576086,
0.1667177081,
-0.0257351827,
0.1570350677,
-0.0297860019,
0.2839877009,
-0.2404780835,
0.4498502016,
0.1993098557,
-0.6256662607,
0.0238567367,
1.1522883177,
0.6617128849,
-0.1164985001,
0.5681328773,
-0.2120317221,
-0.3304616511,
0.4934076965,
0.6126261353,
0.8768283129,
-0.5822086334,
0.5604326129,
0.741255939,
0.2424301356,
0.2801358402,
0.2984180152,
-0.0657987371,
-0.7907892466,
-0.1905034781,
-0.5372754335,
-0.6258391142,
0.5924950242,
-0.728564322,
0.1563911438,
-0.4232124686,
-0.0114114871,
-0.0133333178,
-0.188373372,
-0.3300397992,
0.687114954,
0.1404685378,
0.9193668962,
-1.0279942751,
0.6664690971,
0.4753707647,
-0.5056595802,
-0.488933146,
0.1239413321,
0.3425076604,
-0.3624052405,
0.7054492235,
0.3708970249,
-0.0980004519,
0.2164396644,
-0.7803913951,
-0.4374319911,
0.6258112788,
-0.1061164737,
-0.3557553291,
0.2619190812,
0.1108679175,
0.3276741505,
-0.0787920654,
-0.053743694,
0.4063646495,
0.3153967559,
0.403865844,
-0.3789922595,
0.1698693335,
-0.3434206843,
0.1677542329,
0.3615227938,
-0.4924191236,
0.5016185641,
-0.3151606917,
-0.2843866646,
0.1549548358,
0.5792837143,
0.3329465687,
0.1338313669,
0.5762804747,
0.5227938294,
0.5741165876,
0.1309528947,
0.8419960737,
-0.39395383,
-0.0996892899,
1.2611886263,
-0.1648817509,
1.0621327162,
0.4304426312,
-0.151668027,
0.4788503647,
0.4911409914,
0.1037129462,
0.658704102,
0.352042973,
-0.7315450907,
-0.4431397617,
-0.2066366225,
-0.0223267823,
0.2404278517,
0.2965092063,
-0.5991652608,
-0.2101445943,
0.1198490411,
0.2569523454,
0.4575280249,
-0.1103008389,
0.7922205329,
-0.0606179573,
-0.4687291384,
0.4005508423,
-0.2824626565,
0.9121251702,
-0.7116373777,
-0.0567028373,
-0.3040594757,
0.0960674211,
-0.1863333881,
-0.4583831131,
0.1916776448,
-0.0978947133,
-0.2432606071,
-0.3291299343,
0.6898168325,
-0.8880794644,
-0.3625583947,
0.1474421471,
0.3837862313,
0.2416688502,
0.133233875,
-0.5452376604,
-0.171424374,
0.234876141,
-0.4655654132,
0.4333039522,
0.0809974894,
0.0156177059,
0.7344523072,
0.6239794493,
0.1018164232,
-0.1002803668,
0.0767306983,
0.7486484647,
-0.9174264669,
-0.3906324506,
-0.4927257597,
0.787720561,
-0.0843172967,
-0.2210776657,
0.5021330714,
0.6519451141,
0.867890954,
-0.2484088838,
1.1760845184,
-0.0779817998,
0.7347401977,
-0.4795808196,
0.9496924877,
-0.7750400305,
-0.2418720126,
-0.351136595,
-0.7538633943,
-0.516500473,
0.167781502,
-0.160420686,
0.1550023407,
0.8148242831,
0.958797574,
0.1948300898,
-0.4127957523,
0.6166135669,
0.0311989654,
0.3508173823,
0.5672552586,
0.6413652301,
-0.3566240966,
0.6844092011,
-0.321926266,
-0.3448926508,
-0.1689834446,
-1.3327076435,
-0.9689307213,
-0.5904853344,
-0.7024716735,
-0.4938423932,
-0.1616877913,
0.7759625912,
0.4714336693,
-1.1225835085,
-0.0552363023,
-0.2316484302,
0.1412552595,
-0.0923264399,
-0.3029159009,
0.3926453292,
-0.7463946342,
-1.1066040993,
0.3843736947,
0.2473490387,
0.4615119398,
-0.0547170304,
0.0633286759,
-0.185369432,
0.1867880225,
0.5346055627,
0.6268082857,
-0.3473311067,
-0.1125418171,
-0.2793986201,
-0.4390369654,
-0.2103190422,
0.8376901746,
-0.7853143811,
0.5646369457,
0.6937170625,
0.5804855227,
0.0365858302,
0.0398634002,
0.8310844898,
-0.800532639,
0.1266632527,
0.0362465791,
-0.1013112143,
0.4242824614,
-0.2989169657,
0.2713941634,
0.1345472932,
-0.4350941777,
-0.255004257,
0.3755869567,
-0.8870996833,
-0.3916162252,
1.1170920134,
0.1521598995,
0.0831583515,
-0.0882279724,
-0.4534703791,
0.2327937931,
-0.2194063365,
0.9148060679,
0.2258406281,
-0.1095522344,
-0.186241433,
-0.3229584694,
0.9523765445,
0.4790518582,
-1.0023361444,
-0.0998023525,
0.6999355555,
0.1309215575,
0.1288678646,
0.6834343672,
-0.2543551326,
0.1267020255,
0.0012766873,
0.3816595078,
0.0781212077,
-0.4417156577,
-0.3792085648,
0.3993694782,
0.1047216728,
-0.3275566995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03341v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03341v6 | Inference-Time Intervention: Eliciting Truthful Answers from a Language Model | 2023-06-06T01:26:53 | 2024-06-26T14:11:53 | Kenneth Li, Oam Patel, Fernanda Viégas, Hanspeter Pfister, Martin Wattenberg | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce Inference-Time Intervention (ITI), a technique designed to
enhance the "truthfulness" of large language models (LLMs). ITI operates by
shifting model activations during inference, following a set of directions
across a limited number of attention heads. This intervention significantly
improves the performance of LLaMA models on the TruthfulQA benchmark. On an
instruction-finetuned LLaMA called Alpaca, ITI improves its truthfulness from
32.5% to 65.1%. We identify a tradeoff between truthfulness and helpfulness and
demonstrate how to balance it by tuning the intervention strength. ITI is
minimally invasive and computationally inexpensive. Moreover, the technique is
data efficient: while approaches like RLHF require extensive annotations, ITI
locates truthful directions using only few hundred examples. Our findings
suggest that LLMs may have an internal representation of the likelihood of
something being true, even as they produce falsehoods on the surface. | [
0.0013673028,
-0.8638142347,
0.8122341037,
0.4647133946,
-0.22757864,
0.141451627,
-0.2594055235,
-0.4231625497,
0.0187611375,
0.1603129804,
-0.4310305417,
-0.4120430648,
-0.6615019441,
-0.1948360801,
-0.4051780105,
0.7747274637,
0.0990225971,
-0.0374004021,
0.1692382246,
-0.2611374855,
-0.1990642399,
-0.2964558303,
-0.8122252226,
-0.4549036622,
0.6680367589,
0.3291085064,
0.7539755702,
1.139375329,
0.3493635058,
0.2438727319,
-0.1096124575,
-0.0159886386,
-0.4428458512,
-0.3778517842,
-0.2872271538,
-0.7695003748,
-0.2026583403,
0.3504177332,
0.7505050302,
1.0390334129,
-0.4190405607,
0.255179137,
-0.0639814213,
0.6050655842,
-0.9645456672,
0.1207150444,
-0.532092154,
0.0323652737,
-0.2064774632,
-0.2292976528,
-0.5081180334,
-0.6284627914,
0.0946511775,
-0.6004975438,
0.0889135003,
0.0588168837,
0.787825644,
0.688339889,
-0.540589869,
-0.2158581167,
-0.8502152562,
1.2476198673,
-1.1370354891,
0.2956630886,
0.3522870541,
0.2796092033,
-0.2201570868,
-0.5372932553,
-0.8577415347,
-0.2563672066,
-0.0237292442,
0.1789038777,
-0.3649177849,
0.0281725153,
0.526743114,
0.1411696523,
-0.1545688957,
0.1999327391,
-0.1621729583,
0.0054432568,
0.5943644643,
0.1235761344,
-0.0229112282,
0.2215569019,
-0.0648274869,
0.0029946668,
-0.7599178553,
0.1597145051,
0.5085120201,
0.050301984,
-0.0365493149,
0.6958481669,
-0.2892895341,
0.8710455298,
0.1615518034,
-0.5825787783,
0.0880136862,
-0.3885250688,
0.0158677325,
0.2552527785,
0.578772366,
0.5633661747,
0.0543945692,
-0.0903589427,
-0.1135577261,
0.3766411245,
0.0224698596,
-0.9757493734,
0.1015470847,
0.4203662276,
-0.4218690097,
-0.4309238791,
-0.1778424829,
-0.5627566576,
-0.3106288016,
-0.2642253935,
0.3206637204,
-0.4079475701,
-0.4026486874,
0.2366999388,
-0.2385967225,
0.6261209249,
0.1134640574,
-0.5751462579,
0.1743179411,
0.6717129946,
0.7339853644,
-0.1200666726,
-0.0115701361,
-0.7167642713,
0.4279639423,
-0.6775099635,
0.7557843924,
-0.9474005103,
-0.3927760124,
-0.1390110552,
-0.1859226525,
-0.2150841355,
-0.4395805597,
0.7737811208,
-0.5149700046,
0.2450891286,
-0.4083329439,
-0.6974837184,
-0.320653379,
0.258097738,
-0.7353547812,
0.933613658,
-0.0826399401,
-0.8314904571,
0.2137123942,
-0.8530133963,
-0.5382775664,
-0.5419566035,
0.0421120711,
-0.4040229023,
0.2132324278,
0.4003353715,
0.1380589157,
-0.2479368597,
0.4098966718,
-0.4781951904,
-0.2726770341,
0.6334986687,
-0.7795448899,
0.7667175531,
0.2501218617,
-0.4438148141,
-0.1017491445,
-0.9197557569,
0.1019974127,
0.3075353503,
-0.3277227879,
-0.3015409112,
0.0052882307,
-0.2562138736,
-0.1516670287,
0.1841283888,
-0.8851370215,
0.1547129005,
-0.4424391091,
0.3502708972,
0.7476360798,
0.1947231144,
0.3597027957,
-0.4325730205,
0.2223839611,
-0.0739393085,
0.3909726739,
0.0970352143,
-0.4788100719,
-0.9785258174,
-0.4259190559,
0.4485628605,
0.5294520855,
-0.8466535807,
0.2424919456,
-0.2627802491,
-0.2795405686,
-0.9036221504,
0.0471109264,
0.417758286,
0.9032545686,
0.2666371167,
-0.004261951,
-0.2575187981,
-1.0128124952,
-0.3103641868,
-0.3956760168,
0.0301406626,
-0.0359763615,
0.3518587649,
-0.037655104,
0.9151986241,
-0.3616844416,
0.0391119607,
-0.0986928493,
0.4975225031,
0.3859366477,
0.3245503604,
0.7400035858,
-0.7332773209,
-0.2073991001,
-0.2441500872,
-0.7399607897,
-0.368883729,
-0.2247467637,
0.0115071349,
0.1012566686,
0.1022804454,
-0.3299074471,
0.6243753433,
0.577743113,
-0.1737972349,
0.1512591243,
-0.0222865604,
0.3659022152,
-0.8438865542,
0.1323805004,
-0.1916314214,
-0.1251026392,
-0.7421236634,
-0.0790584683,
0.0597661063,
0.396009475,
-0.334821403,
0.6655409336,
-0.3101590574,
-0.1322600245,
-0.412712872,
0.1186112016,
-0.0760208219,
0.6730023623,
0.2401720285,
1.0644792318,
0.1218691096,
-0.7142345309,
-0.0639840737,
0.0244658813,
-0.3640581965,
0.6296799183,
-0.7544901967,
0.3846418858,
-0.1832768023,
0.0793537423,
-0.9347620606,
-0.2201709896,
0.2537016571,
-0.286046952,
0.1128943041,
0.1019045413,
-0.312047869,
-0.1896237433,
-0.460218966,
0.4545293748,
0.269669205,
-0.8872659802,
0.9592334628,
0.2801573575,
-0.0817188993,
-0.9156684875,
-0.7421777248,
0.1530226618,
-0.1459791809,
-0.3800444007,
0.0470984131,
-0.4313211739,
-0.7342275977,
0.1804496795,
-0.077433303,
-0.0994802862,
0.2982028723,
0.1086821333,
0.2749294937,
-0.0939297974,
0.1004006043,
0.3105853498,
-0.1924994439,
-0.0940868631,
-0.1342635453,
0.2020982951,
-0.1923852265,
-0.7141782641,
-0.7163131237,
0.5278791189,
0.2204778343,
-0.415477097,
0.794513762,
0.4818298221,
-0.2888747752,
0.2083224058,
-0.8992316723,
-0.0836142451,
-0.4446043372,
0.0390532278,
-0.3733926713,
-0.7341942191,
0.2261407524,
-0.2455210537,
0.3784388602,
0.0960260779,
0.4023093283,
-0.0168003198,
1.364921093,
0.7617164254,
-0.3606215417,
0.6683558822,
-0.3464299738,
0.2857021689,
-0.701666832,
0.0185902081,
-0.5116302371,
-0.2727378905,
-0.3178312182,
-0.5783212781,
0.4113616347,
-0.0390182361,
-0.1799757779,
-0.1419867873,
-0.2438732088,
0.5646021366,
0.5702729821,
0.307363987,
0.605466783,
-0.1976443082,
0.2318252772,
-0.0952853337,
-0.784347415,
-0.5548467636,
1.1388828754,
0.3003456295,
0.8251960278,
0.2851327956,
0.426047653,
0.212857753,
0.7970766425,
-0.9770319462,
0.4643003345,
0.2524787188,
-0.4846687615,
-0.1754732877,
-0.338165164,
-0.644367218,
-0.0883330256,
-0.1945109814,
-0.5821589231,
0.3099645972,
0.3032252491,
-0.4570357502,
0.2700590789,
-0.8542590737,
0.4003743827,
-0.3661514223,
-0.4697205722,
-0.6129197478,
-0.6227093935,
0.2738205492,
-0.1172448248,
0.2379777282,
-0.2206289321,
-0.4399504662,
0.6261329651,
-0.3015542924,
0.9666377902,
-0.1429430693,
-0.2394416034,
0.2901785076,
0.0033419128,
0.7253674865,
-0.0494561531,
-0.4573768675,
0.3180991709,
-0.2864751816,
-0.6275478005,
-0.9298332334,
0.4770343006,
-0.5869109035,
-0.9142786264,
-0.2191246301,
-0.6907840371,
-0.3868219256,
0.015462297,
0.029552795,
0.3818204105,
-0.2480021566,
0.121605739,
1.0263478756,
-0.0616146624,
0.6383606195,
0.8513191938,
0.0482391566,
-0.2438883483,
0.7146648169,
-0.0063036717,
0.5002923608,
0.5452701449,
0.4785113335,
-0.4008899629,
-0.4800517559,
-0.2797915637,
0.5567474961,
-0.7511255741,
0.0491202623,
-0.6353753209,
0.0324322209,
-0.2262547463,
0.1299216002,
-0.4633052647,
-0.7193599343,
-0.0211779345,
-0.335357666,
0.3696152568,
0.6309431195,
-0.2589514852,
0.4628209174,
-0.5237222314,
0.2184558213,
0.4668291211,
0.0918408558,
-0.160371691,
-0.6590011716,
-0.0041852682,
0.0908959433,
0.0720156431,
-0.8087615967,
0.1947851628,
0.4011272192,
0.6202632189,
0.5505833626,
0.2093660533,
0.7813482285,
-0.4570348859,
0.6165614128,
0.1023520976,
-0.9888435006,
0.5334255695,
-0.105239816,
0.361058563,
0.2429899871,
0.4036824703,
-0.3792460859,
-0.6116727591,
-0.3803437054,
-0.4133424163,
0.3310298622,
0.1105325446,
-0.0527568869,
0.0872811601,
0.3793209493,
0.0862617344,
0.4206621945,
-0.4001765847,
-0.2562359273,
-0.2318696678,
-0.5445128679,
0.1088322699,
-0.4708203673,
-0.6540681124,
-0.1030196473,
0.8427845836,
-0.6014108658,
0.3516153395,
0.2654235065,
0.0502594672,
-0.1724494547,
0.3535534441,
0.4729311466,
0.7953110933,
0.1607680172,
0.0990037993,
0.3784676194,
-0.1787020564,
0.0241855811,
0.1279127151,
-0.2925412655,
-0.1143056378,
0.7224149704,
0.9328220487,
-0.0916932747,
-0.5885137916,
0.6134572625,
-0.2451135367,
0.091332458,
-0.1697449535,
0.1570128053,
0.0477914661,
0.6018742323,
0.2556824088,
-0.2346977741,
0.3236816227,
-0.5066302419,
-0.1736149043,
0.498049736,
-0.2012883872,
-0.2688570023,
0.6203871369,
0.0036942377,
-0.2458209544,
0.416238606,
0.0872897059,
-0.4146881104,
0.4839826524,
0.5785012245,
0.6343708634,
-0.4517508745,
0.2805292904,
0.3833684623,
0.3512865305,
-0.0041408096,
0.2409152687,
-0.1896404773,
-0.863894403,
-0.7239938378,
-0.2572672069,
-0.5439308286,
0.137967065,
-0.6743136644,
-0.2318223268,
-0.5053121448,
-0.1749938428,
-0.1019425392,
-0.1554549783,
-0.4860708714,
0.1579023153,
-0.0237642527,
0.9949018955,
-0.8192856312,
0.8455538154,
0.3560049534,
-0.3400219679,
-1.01328969,
0.3153978586,
-0.0425619632,
-0.9295343757,
0.4523857534,
0.0517695174,
-0.5239707232,
0.0185768176,
-1.2229058743,
-0.8442256451,
1.0010988712,
0.6746117473,
-0.6350189447,
0.1536248475,
0.2147567272,
0.4835298359,
-0.2573325038,
0.3368226588,
0.9565429688,
0.5668106079,
0.1743045598,
-0.7390610576,
0.0002480685,
-0.2549670041,
0.1604020447,
-0.107188344,
-0.8190877438,
0.431679219,
-0.6086793542,
-0.3097728491,
0.3189907372,
0.9416697621,
0.2645557225,
0.2469845712,
0.8097285032,
0.5114555359,
1.1255301237,
-0.1469171643,
1.2971715927,
-0.4986439049,
-0.0308332313,
1.1928337812,
-0.2640941441,
0.7662015557,
0.8830249906,
0.1516468972,
0.4625063539,
0.5654626489,
0.4433598518,
0.6379563212,
-0.1962577403,
-0.6328012943,
-0.4728361964,
-0.6928425431,
-0.1631605923,
0.1473650336,
0.4625520706,
0.0682186112,
-0.1576060504,
0.2293679565,
0.2555455863,
0.209132418,
-0.1037423834,
0.6950374842,
0.0624842867,
-0.6942622066,
0.414001435,
-0.2114045471,
0.343046844,
-0.6608366966,
-0.5557986498,
-0.3245942593,
0.2943018079,
-0.0503995456,
-0.833698988,
0.044148501,
0.0983214602,
-0.1115854979,
0.0500818267,
0.5949146748,
-0.4954885542,
-0.419285804,
0.313172996,
0.334027499,
-0.0709948093,
0.1350016743,
-0.7014787197,
0.1950673461,
0.0305796098,
-0.4997734725,
-0.1860314757,
0.4066040814,
-0.2046096027,
1.1139365435,
0.6186854839,
0.121858485,
0.04470459,
0.2191878408,
0.8743023872,
-0.5118457675,
-0.260173738,
-0.6170853972,
0.2937853336,
-0.2884019017,
0.017485043,
0.6621008515,
0.2517796457,
0.66590482,
0.1405013949,
0.8399927616,
0.1036589444,
0.7154146433,
-0.7498465776,
0.2006908059,
-0.559781611,
0.3418708742,
0.104902409,
-0.58395648,
-0.1468589008,
0.5317738056,
-0.5384745598,
-0.2183615416,
0.7391722798,
1.0095683336,
0.2530327439,
0.199115321,
0.2470816225,
0.3468421996,
0.4063406587,
0.4315180779,
1.0976662636,
-0.2179972082,
0.4597370028,
-0.4253432751,
-0.5077985525,
0.180498898,
-1.0526888371,
-0.8874451518,
-0.1081304774,
-0.3794254661,
-0.2036093771,
0.3394605517,
0.9433110356,
0.5543600917,
-0.7703168988,
-0.1308724284,
0.1058445945,
0.1747307628,
-0.4859761,
-0.1821400076,
0.3039317131,
-0.1921154708,
-1.0285053253,
0.6365292072,
0.1313967258,
-0.1050510257,
-0.1211741865,
0.0262076613,
-0.2166184485,
0.3683056533,
0.3811080456,
0.2654780149,
-0.5045392513,
-0.6619488597,
0.0360912532,
-0.1305954605,
0.1458923966,
0.7653886676,
-0.5806804895,
0.4522094131,
0.1050914079,
1.0102185011,
0.5188695192,
0.0256615579,
0.6940299273,
-0.7117290497,
0.2993558347,
0.132257551,
0.3150250912,
0.4816651344,
-0.4394119382,
0.9488466978,
0.2822289765,
-0.2627288699,
-0.6796785593,
0.336363703,
-0.8072793484,
-0.1492507458,
1.2555912733,
-0.1543725282,
-0.6684033275,
-0.048383154,
-0.2906448245,
0.4264097214,
-0.4326639771,
0.9095064402,
0.6466646791,
-0.0985080451,
0.0037328599,
-0.6455227137,
0.292639941,
0.6106036305,
-0.9005836844,
-0.1385322809,
0.3692836463,
0.3446693718,
0.3770035803,
0.7102947235,
-0.0104846936,
0.181991443,
-0.1046916991,
0.0351360254,
0.1144874766,
-0.3047320247,
-0.3989575207,
-0.1354555637,
0.2420241535,
-0.2556179464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03316v1 | CoSiNES: Contrastive Siamese Network for Entity Standardization | 2023-06-05T23:58:40 | 2023-06-05T23:58:40 | Jiaqing Yuan, Michele Merler, Mihir Choudhury, Raju Pavuluri, Munindar P. Singh, Maja Vukovic | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entity standardization maps noisy mentions from free-form text to standard
entities in a knowledge base. The unique challenge of this task relative to
other entity-related tasks is the lack of surrounding context and numerous
variations in the surface form of the mentions, especially when it comes to
generalization across domains where labeled data is scarce. Previous research
mostly focuses on developing models either heavily relying on context, or
dedicated solely to a specific domain. In contrast, we propose CoSiNES, a
generic and adaptable framework with Contrastive Siamese Network for Entity
Standardization that effectively adapts a pretrained language model to capture
the syntax and semantics of the entities in a new domain.
We construct a new dataset in the technology domain, which contains 640
technical stack entities and 6,412 mentions collected from industrial content
management systems. We demonstrate that CoSiNES yields higher accuracy and
faster runtime than baselines derived from leading methods in this domain.
CoSiNES also achieves competitive performance in four standard datasets from
the chemistry, medicine, and biomedical domains, demonstrating its cross-domain
applicability. | [
-0.7772833109,
-0.2164220363,
0.158571884,
0.1708167642,
-0.3374539912,
-0.1703167409,
-0.3222577572,
-0.4628041685,
0.7770046592,
0.5453795195,
-0.3633841872,
-0.881960392,
-0.3734339178,
0.2283328623,
-0.4225181341,
0.8116313219,
-0.3189439476,
-0.3148297369,
-0.0929895639,
-0.3429253697,
-0.2229073793,
-0.3186882436,
-0.6931130886,
-0.2099906057,
0.6054610014,
0.5251510739,
0.4393245578,
0.3557131588,
0.9380185604,
0.2626296282,
0.3681012988,
0.0138738593,
-0.3433356583,
0.2304582447,
-0.5889249444,
-0.3540013433,
-0.7072660327,
-0.0896323398,
0.1844047904,
0.9241671562,
-0.0220525656,
0.2079917789,
0.1073483974,
0.5165845156,
-0.7250093818,
0.3390387893,
-0.7757510543,
-0.0149923321,
-0.041671019,
-0.4021980464,
-0.143750459,
-0.1199986711,
0.579367578,
-1.3026227951,
0.4283717871,
0.3288783729,
1.1242755651,
0.2272938788,
-0.3349012136,
-0.4991566539,
-0.5360711217,
0.7658778429,
-0.1617805958,
0.8065101504,
-0.0763795227,
0.5779362917,
-0.1361380219,
-1.0496569872,
-0.3327414095,
-0.1419741958,
0.0186723806,
-0.111481294,
-0.1275638789,
0.1002091169,
0.0920652822,
0.2268600911,
-0.4711708426,
-0.0679853559,
-0.2320906222,
-0.1420522928,
0.4497734308,
-0.1382823288,
0.349909991,
0.1026952267,
-0.5811543465,
-0.0818211138,
-0.8646610379,
-0.3052257895,
-0.22412844,
0.2016032636,
-0.2524157166,
0.487080425,
-0.5997170806,
0.3243454099,
0.1526205391,
0.2030328512,
0.1521474272,
-0.3042119741,
-0.5569266677,
0.0980049148,
0.5399179459,
0.6989553571,
0.266079247,
-0.5797125697,
-0.0109484196,
0.0839702785,
0.1891856045,
-0.909709096,
-0.6858339906,
-0.0263657961,
0.0308303386,
0.2216805071,
-0.0966090411,
-0.6412262917,
-0.2203942537,
-0.6231247783,
0.3367399275,
-0.3503160477,
-0.3794466555,
0.1485916823,
-0.4404040873,
-0.1838914007,
0.4724262655,
-0.5268149376,
0.5836825967,
0.7279887199,
0.9237712622,
-0.3108178079,
0.1590698361,
-0.1035445035,
0.2927686274,
-0.5318180919,
0.7055684924,
-0.3953306079,
-0.2040345669,
-0.2971778512,
0.0061881002,
-0.0920014754,
-1.0078902245,
0.2532339394,
-0.8663752079,
-0.2885356247,
-0.241581738,
-0.3669220805,
-0.421289593,
0.4724800289,
-0.9850357771,
0.7447760105,
0.1410677284,
-0.801756382,
0.732845068,
-0.6239426732,
0.1871890426,
0.0677561685,
-0.5419233441,
-0.4682973325,
-0.1539537162,
-0.1521225125,
0.47932145,
-0.3085279465,
0.5696344376,
-0.616601944,
-0.2230795175,
-0.0554247722,
0.2216345668,
0.8299685717,
0.2517539561,
-0.4408586621,
-0.0911210477,
-0.9530000687,
-0.1843103468,
-0.1530378163,
0.1338417828,
-0.9517542124,
-0.2526443303,
-0.2460541278,
0.1780345142,
-0.08131551,
-0.3468183279,
-0.2176654637,
-0.0562830158,
0.0886816978,
-0.1356631219,
0.4418142736,
0.6864576936,
-0.3013314307,
0.2386536896,
0.6572749019,
-0.2039778084,
0.2177731693,
-0.2085284293,
-1.0261017084,
-0.5435811877,
0.2933816016,
0.2566345036,
-1.2048939466,
0.6618200541,
-0.8828673959,
-0.5849130154,
-0.2641360164,
0.046947632,
0.0450093821,
0.7830376625,
0.6873905063,
-0.8006531596,
-0.9085008502,
-1.1360491514,
-0.2853645384,
0.0649388134,
-0.2610507607,
0.2785120308,
0.4935674965,
-0.1264327615,
1.097376585,
-0.2158482373,
-0.3321461082,
0.2259505093,
0.0185038522,
-0.074553594,
0.5099189281,
0.3581686914,
-0.7862169147,
-0.5285540223,
0.0035754438,
-0.7895870805,
0.0992629007,
0.0065000891,
-0.410502553,
-0.2350551635,
0.7354530096,
-0.1615752578,
0.0382259786,
0.4400871098,
0.0258540567,
0.2505767345,
0.19204624,
0.0757475048,
-1.2831124067,
0.3127106726,
0.3718141913,
-0.201472044,
-0.5849568844,
-0.0738163367,
-0.0460371897,
-0.0797703266,
-0.4915540218,
0.5391851664,
-0.5170823932,
-0.0679092184,
0.29733634,
0.5048794746,
0.3987277448,
0.4028754234,
0.4029049277,
0.7216770649,
0.4431195557,
-1.0723456144,
0.3762798309,
0.1029838845,
-0.3676281571,
1.0559622049,
-0.5430464745,
-0.1123208255,
0.1996827722,
0.2977927625,
-0.4101888835,
-0.0708083212,
0.3134199083,
-0.1428079307,
0.2775450349,
0.0479912311,
-0.1336179078,
0.0210891459,
-0.2617794871,
0.4236217737,
0.0877499878,
-0.4595696032,
0.237719357,
0.5047550201,
-0.2541384101,
-0.3007142544,
-0.7149585485,
0.4219357967,
-0.2851679325,
-0.7790013552,
0.5122518539,
0.1689219028,
-0.3826617599,
0.1893663108,
-0.2408529818,
-0.6240050197,
0.3524090052,
-0.0892341286,
0.0221823081,
-0.8509153724,
0.2498357296,
0.1614132673,
-0.0652248338,
-0.0373889022,
-0.5270606875,
0.2412057966,
0.1183698773,
-0.2228820175,
-0.6603871584,
0.272814244,
0.0607885532,
-0.0215466879,
0.5114395022,
0.0924662873,
-0.6581416726,
-0.2113072127,
-0.2560584843,
-0.151574105,
-0.464825213,
0.6567991972,
-0.6318867803,
-0.8457186818,
0.3070839047,
-0.3613587916,
0.0497976914,
0.7246261239,
0.1106457934,
0.1471135169,
0.3199300766,
0.7922567725,
0.3549815118,
0.1586636007,
-0.2965405881,
0.4287133515,
-0.8899226189,
-0.2852572203,
-0.9141337276,
-0.278380394,
-0.8090630174,
-0.4733021557,
0.3893661499,
0.2597060502,
-0.3660473526,
0.6921326518,
-0.5487755537,
0.2328693271,
0.3064561784,
-0.0826625004,
0.5732965469,
0.2847395539,
-0.093593739,
-0.2196613401,
-0.7301040292,
-0.7366335988,
0.6933736801,
0.3010729253,
0.6199344993,
0.0219233949,
0.9607428312,
-0.1152969971,
0.6603218317,
-0.6125018001,
0.4925992787,
-0.314848423,
-0.6482841372,
-0.2901196778,
-0.3549726903,
-0.7160277963,
0.0463776328,
0.0540907942,
-0.4791559577,
0.7154585123,
0.0668607503,
-0.3419527709,
0.3176285625,
-0.868994236,
0.6027206182,
0.3609556258,
-0.036371313,
-0.0407292694,
-0.28796345,
0.2119978219,
0.018723283,
0.0655257478,
-0.2554092109,
-0.5071222782,
0.9300490022,
-0.2103396356,
0.8293887377,
0.0090309931,
-0.0367025882,
0.4203898907,
0.1770478934,
0.046992328,
0.1510462016,
-0.2585022151,
0.4262192249,
0.1262617707,
-0.3250184059,
-0.5601302981,
0.7333306074,
-0.5931687951,
-0.3872440457,
-0.1587514877,
-0.2840213478,
-0.3110796213,
0.3766731024,
0.3244939446,
0.3984069228,
-0.5008587241,
0.31100595,
0.8316735029,
0.0487175733,
0.1185080856,
0.3078106046,
0.1499418616,
-0.3234378695,
0.9564645886,
0.4194581807,
0.0610107854,
0.5097802877,
-0.488707453,
-0.3008435071,
-0.3445621729,
-0.4558776021,
0.0842381716,
-0.7555234432,
-0.3108510077,
-0.8399866223,
-0.2869110703,
-0.3762272894,
-0.4131070673,
-0.3796596825,
-0.6529436111,
-0.3936730325,
0.2241897583,
0.1487125903,
0.6896187067,
0.2342470735,
0.0624313094,
-0.6530085206,
0.1905432791,
0.1659370363,
0.8592540622,
-0.1460976601,
-0.2404270321,
-0.3726794422,
0.0166674964,
-0.3096871972,
-0.6763293743,
0.0148704015,
0.4221223891,
0.374189347,
0.1296711415,
0.2624624074,
0.5891819,
-0.345038563,
0.717399478,
0.4400330782,
-0.8067467213,
0.081522271,
0.0082769906,
-0.2405296117,
0.713835597,
0.7341378927,
-0.9803427458,
-0.3020135462,
-0.8532838225,
-0.6960320473,
0.3043393493,
-0.0155944424,
-0.0022183345,
-0.0812902972,
0.5028355122,
0.1490055174,
0.2346027344,
-0.255723387,
-0.076150991,
-0.0666542202,
-0.604084909,
0.0042927996,
-0.0614207201,
-0.143220827,
0.2206350565,
0.8852593899,
-0.1474562883,
0.2322468013,
0.5617983937,
-0.4731761515,
0.2553117275,
0.2825934887,
0.4361965656,
0.5337510705,
0.0900058523,
0.6707578301,
0.1631085575,
-0.5155459642,
-0.0427425504,
0.0277509391,
-0.29488343,
0.4524422586,
0.1107580438,
0.6446227431,
0.4676533043,
0.0118861403,
0.231863752,
0.0000836246,
-0.1865797192,
-0.1243081987,
0.3211213052,
0.2886322141,
0.121594131,
-0.02431513,
0.1347505301,
0.3350414932,
-0.1513713598,
0.5960581899,
0.11906486,
-0.8420367837,
-0.5151669383,
0.3860650361,
0.5381120443,
-0.2355598658,
0.1714452505,
-0.3627335429,
-0.1271771491,
0.7297170758,
0.0882324725,
0.9616246223,
-0.1500747353,
0.0226170979,
0.4910874963,
0.1888492107,
0.0458774641,
0.0381261148,
0.0039817924,
-0.4569905698,
-0.0169575885,
-0.3010340631,
-0.5227186084,
0.0137322331,
-0.5901625752,
0.7845668793,
-0.5398486853,
-0.2178621739,
0.1194550544,
0.2072118968,
-0.9560412169,
0.587978363,
-0.3108324707,
1.4506011009,
-0.6254823804,
0.6669412255,
0.6819950938,
-0.5628244281,
-0.5694108009,
-0.1453238726,
-0.3113443255,
-0.4852364361,
0.6175610423,
0.0117179248,
-0.0348245502,
0.1657401472,
-0.3406937122,
-0.9657015204,
1.2689735889,
0.1939337254,
-0.8324851394,
-0.1986964792,
0.3038004041,
0.6111152172,
-0.7695233822,
0.157608062,
0.5136716962,
0.0824225619,
0.0361828282,
-0.857725203,
0.163984701,
-0.0285634007,
0.15454036,
0.0402633809,
-0.5280508995,
0.4709904194,
0.2614826858,
-0.382037282,
-0.1458007693,
0.8265846372,
0.0852143466,
0.7156206369,
0.5644007921,
0.4164253473,
0.7656311393,
-0.15033333,
0.4808296561,
-0.4488574862,
0.3113862276,
1.236487627,
-0.4105867147,
0.8003252745,
0.4235222936,
0.1595850587,
0.7332921028,
0.5776051283,
0.2129142284,
0.1932446361,
0.2568347156,
-0.2948443294,
-0.1045233458,
-0.3470045626,
-0.4710153639,
0.109956719,
0.6141578555,
-0.1679493487,
-0.7375522256,
-0.3806268275,
0.1326247007,
-0.0678238645,
-0.0665823296,
0.7525826097,
0.4532223046,
-0.6170573235,
0.4950757921,
0.0604002438,
0.5174427032,
-0.259583503,
-0.0819186792,
-0.1093670726,
0.1404678077,
-0.184998408,
-0.5038917065,
0.7550899386,
-0.1784556955,
-0.0530038327,
0.1485292166,
0.6525248885,
-0.6510617733,
-0.0755046457,
0.236571461,
0.2263502777,
0.0334006362,
-0.1147421673,
-0.4942023754,
-0.2571855187,
-0.3948839009,
0.0719428807,
0.0983035937,
0.7893612385,
-0.573944211,
0.2482160926,
0.1547045857,
-0.1452498883,
0.2105024457,
-0.1337331384,
0.777054131,
-0.588845253,
-0.5590274334,
-0.1589573175,
0.3192150593,
-0.320671767,
-0.1716514528,
0.4482823014,
0.8444266915,
1.1212593317,
0.2176891416,
0.7689720392,
0.2065330446,
0.6348431706,
-0.3115331233,
0.716136992,
-0.5504314303,
0.3374162018,
0.1975727379,
-0.8574510813,
-0.6006844044,
0.1977230906,
-0.4237817526,
0.0080763735,
0.9151485562,
0.9011237025,
-0.4916520715,
0.0778339878,
0.3032627106,
0.1048266888,
0.472288847,
0.4539115727,
0.2737035751,
-0.5820977092,
0.4214728773,
-0.3410163224,
-0.1983850449,
-0.3550535142,
-0.8258243799,
-0.6841455698,
-0.6577786803,
-0.6463262439,
-0.3869544566,
0.1603878438,
0.9863122106,
0.8030831814,
-1.0842846632,
-0.1278209835,
-0.0531480722,
0.1147332937,
0.1298073977,
-0.1467690915,
0.3406699896,
-0.5897974968,
-0.7028315067,
-0.0925456807,
0.5632032752,
0.0177205987,
-0.0753842592,
0.0672227144,
0.0281688254,
0.1789950728,
0.2202277631,
0.1052970663,
-0.2504297793,
-0.3795037568,
0.3259799182,
-0.5221173167,
0.3328202069,
1.0059486628,
-0.4820126593,
0.437399894,
0.4705072939,
0.6613696218,
0.1168916076,
-0.5229793787,
0.2937068641,
-0.886950016,
0.1727393866,
0.2898461223,
0.2066598684,
0.6013418436,
-0.1623122394,
0.4006197155,
0.5901258588,
-0.0953521058,
-0.2613158524,
0.2347764075,
-0.9202160239,
0.1071993783,
0.9542387724,
-0.2277256697,
-0.4430513084,
-0.6480488777,
0.1681029052,
0.5139769912,
-0.2824112475,
0.7884472609,
0.5287451744,
0.3082463443,
0.2034250349,
-0.2406867296,
0.6803352237,
0.2223181725,
-0.802680552,
-0.2933987379,
0.2537429035,
0.5646129251,
0.448448956,
0.8087718487,
-0.1270837188,
0.3526299,
0.1129271537,
0.3238137066,
0.1976382583,
-0.4591282606,
-0.1070041582,
0.2106709629,
0.1298188418,
-0.2105662078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03315v1 | Few Shot Rationale Generation using Self-Training with Dual Teachers | 2023-06-05T23:57:52 | 2023-06-05T23:57:52 | Aditya Srikanth Veerubhotla, Lahari Poddar, Jun Yin, György Szarvas, Sharanya Eswaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-rationalizing models that also generate a free-text explanation for
their predicted labels are an important tool to build trustworthy AI
applications. Since generating explanations for annotated labels is a laborious
and costly pro cess, recent models rely on large pretrained language models
(PLMs) as their backbone and few-shot learning. In this work we explore a
self-training approach leveraging both labeled and unlabeled data to further
improve few-shot models, under the assumption that neither human written
rationales nor annotated task labels are available at scale. We introduce a
novel dual-teacher learning framework, which learns two specialized teacher
models for task prediction and rationalization using self-training and distills
their knowledge into a multi-tasking student model that can jointly generate
the task label and rationale. Furthermore, we formulate a new loss function,
Masked Label Regularization (MLR) which promotes explanations to be strongly
conditioned on predicted labels. Evaluation on three public datasets
demonstrate that the proposed methods are effective in modeling task labels and
generating faithful rationales. | [
-0.2727819681,
-0.5282065272,
0.480160147,
-0.2194188684,
-0.1500251889,
-0.3074687421,
-0.261423707,
0.0616105609,
-0.228660211,
0.5910825133,
-0.7988001704,
-0.3384273648,
-0.4597790241,
0.1127371788,
0.0387385897,
1.2479573488,
0.0021795225,
0.3598958254,
-0.2261727005,
-0.0970540568,
-0.5053287148,
-0.4236165583,
-0.5488699675,
-0.5705628395,
0.737082541,
0.6924925447,
0.2559329569,
0.5927751064,
0.1419765502,
0.1541110575,
0.6709103584,
0.3506858349,
-0.4624188244,
0.0643155798,
-0.0408138596,
-0.4816179872,
-0.0470045768,
0.4317231774,
0.6039853096,
0.4959490001,
0.3546518087,
0.3813162744,
0.1842968762,
0.4972412884,
-0.8116816878,
0.1141789854,
-0.6663456559,
0.1611186713,
-0.0557803288,
-0.1569303125,
-0.5751133561,
0.1483176649,
0.1143218353,
-0.7621909976,
0.2889761329,
-0.2944847941,
0.567463696,
0.5569693446,
-0.555257082,
-0.0349552743,
-0.6982406378,
0.961422205,
-0.4805477858,
0.1105892286,
0.528408587,
0.5294870734,
-0.0766031444,
-0.6622126102,
-0.4737589061,
-0.0063624079,
-0.2282420993,
0.2923305333,
0.028641168,
0.1234955415,
0.303201437,
-0.1604762226,
-0.4181861877,
0.0865335986,
-0.3224765658,
-0.2366037816,
0.7327522635,
0.0554847419,
0.0330193155,
-0.1753072888,
-0.7261041999,
-0.053039819,
-0.5767046809,
0.1679676771,
0.3879007101,
0.4420035183,
-0.1182549447,
0.4819920659,
0.0712762848,
0.8689965606,
0.0918394476,
-0.6875911355,
-0.2643905282,
-0.2913852632,
-0.2745343149,
-0.0077038608,
0.9419186115,
0.2343320101,
0.2920909822,
-0.2624743581,
-0.0830175281,
0.3043179214,
0.1208733544,
-0.8964358568,
-0.4450074136,
0.0524796546,
-0.1659190655,
-0.3130158186,
-0.272154063,
-0.6020578742,
-0.3598789871,
-0.5487546921,
0.5533662438,
-0.3142921031,
-0.0582881235,
-0.1991187483,
-0.0916416422,
-0.0428260639,
0.2874191999,
-0.8975433707,
0.049977608,
0.4634304345,
0.5332407355,
-0.1269900203,
-0.5093479753,
-0.5736336112,
0.3921824992,
-0.3603178263,
0.7886911035,
-0.4785680473,
-0.1400574446,
-0.2692753971,
-0.4374409616,
-0.1290616542,
-0.2277362645,
0.2210050076,
-0.2120375484,
0.3315446377,
-0.0718265325,
-0.6008619666,
-0.2989715636,
0.3833703399,
-0.3018467426,
1.0096254349,
-0.16580984,
-0.8749674559,
0.6229977608,
-0.637661159,
-0.2396869361,
0.103562437,
-0.3639229238,
-0.564036727,
-0.1644549966,
0.3140774071,
0.6347138286,
-0.2291522324,
0.4806799293,
-0.3816537261,
-0.0822903737,
0.2224963605,
-0.5831640363,
0.6249650717,
0.1235896423,
-0.2715304792,
0.1485517174,
-0.7883158326,
0.0784613714,
0.140931204,
-0.2482226193,
-0.0851675719,
-0.2325331569,
-0.3005965054,
0.325527519,
0.0844359547,
-0.5062292218,
0.1790053844,
-0.3472743332,
0.304353416,
0.6061165929,
0.0059877634,
0.7559622526,
-0.2484226823,
0.701787293,
0.1091314107,
-0.0858623087,
-0.5898519158,
-0.2781811059,
-0.6030874252,
-0.5714617372,
0.1889972687,
0.448374033,
-0.680034399,
-0.0620264746,
-0.0026659218,
-0.3366440535,
-0.6307433844,
0.4632666111,
0.4908877909,
0.9133093953,
0.4688106477,
0.0489886068,
-0.614141047,
-0.9202469587,
-0.5030377507,
0.180055216,
0.0335235633,
0.2310344875,
0.614220202,
-0.0860058963,
1.4211102724,
-0.413426131,
-0.5174483061,
-0.3894855678,
0.5268937349,
-0.0939312503,
0.6496171951,
0.4992209673,
-0.5392130613,
-0.5786553621,
-0.5007067919,
-0.6099360585,
0.03683649,
-0.5191243887,
-0.2539683282,
0.1932159662,
0.1103490964,
-0.5360981822,
0.5618058443,
0.2350866348,
-0.0554521866,
0.4408294857,
-0.1010158956,
-0.2244229615,
-0.8536903858,
-0.0099159703,
0.21374318,
-0.4470440149,
-0.5936539173,
-0.2478901744,
-0.1057735234,
-0.3667205572,
-0.2994387448,
0.7836709023,
-0.4932943583,
-0.0416539572,
-0.5871697068,
0.1093579531,
0.1774554849,
0.767123282,
0.1798087209,
0.5735140443,
0.7655835152,
-0.450846523,
0.2704297304,
0.0087652933,
-0.0349965245,
0.3112698495,
-0.4756611884,
0.2558065653,
-0.4221559763,
0.5017332435,
-1.0427225828,
-0.3280557394,
0.5446961522,
-0.3900752366,
0.3980616033,
-0.6796544194,
-0.4282876253,
-0.5779286027,
-0.2232200503,
0.5001890063,
0.476770997,
-0.6630939841,
0.4653297663,
0.2501192987,
0.2383095026,
-0.6307423115,
-0.8585211039,
-0.2914457023,
-0.2200953662,
-0.546459198,
0.0903448015,
-0.1042505652,
0.0919407234,
-0.1138504818,
-0.2807075977,
-0.3062689304,
0.1517237574,
0.3299730718,
0.2345755249,
-0.2577332258,
0.4123099446,
0.1627950519,
-0.4936603606,
0.0875865594,
-0.551292181,
0.0828281268,
0.0562244095,
-0.1752577573,
-0.638019681,
0.3608547449,
0.069674179,
-0.2891311646,
0.823820591,
0.7973525524,
-0.4124048948,
-0.5809599161,
-0.5099611878,
-0.5739195347,
-0.3854082823,
-0.0081603983,
-0.5451889038,
-0.6862972975,
0.0945849642,
-0.0474936552,
0.1244862825,
0.3941336572,
0.6942384839,
-0.0404719338,
1.1212128401,
0.4214859605,
0.2662864327,
0.1571723074,
-0.4330183864,
0.253331989,
-0.3507546186,
-0.2477671057,
-0.1051595062,
-0.2822334468,
-0.289041549,
-0.4796432853,
0.5399256349,
0.2880675793,
-0.2258119881,
0.001134092,
-0.7443369627,
0.8296740055,
0.9477238059,
0.0349127613,
0.0545413643,
0.0033990226,
-0.0031740009,
-0.0444894508,
-0.9594030976,
-0.7312620282,
1.3405169249,
0.3656218946,
0.6717309356,
-0.3736034632,
1.0906529427,
-0.1106898263,
0.5282528996,
-0.8213724494,
0.337076515,
-0.1053792015,
-0.9817939401,
-0.4508443177,
-0.3655060232,
-0.7990781069,
0.5622537732,
-0.3653753102,
-0.4882279336,
-0.2152753025,
0.6468455195,
-0.6947066188,
0.0955014005,
-1.0443781614,
1.2983670235,
-0.3723062277,
-0.5064824224,
-0.1054327115,
-0.7854027748,
0.6744509935,
-0.0623758212,
0.1505450606,
-0.3816100657,
0.0980541557,
0.9413613677,
-0.552567482,
1.3215246201,
-0.422532171,
0.2114219517,
0.6509097219,
0.0613274723,
0.2337317765,
0.3279754817,
-0.0053672134,
-0.1907627434,
0.002915334,
-0.6371235847,
-0.6280129552,
0.5863274932,
-0.804181695,
-0.6425783038,
-0.3951399624,
-0.7201879621,
-0.287298888,
0.2324065864,
0.4444043338,
0.3928045034,
0.2134321034,
-0.2479422688,
0.3638943136,
0.1875388324,
0.4220105708,
0.4879285395,
0.215490073,
-0.5092943907,
0.8551406264,
0.2696417272,
0.0370522588,
0.2373523712,
0.5469434857,
-0.3216895163,
-0.2310620397,
-0.4645867944,
0.2842066586,
-0.800757587,
-0.5709890127,
-0.4161123633,
0.0272771269,
-0.6559109092,
-0.2307877243,
-0.4146333039,
-0.4996806085,
-0.6335042119,
-0.1741200984,
0.2439229339,
0.6174677014,
-0.2753798962,
0.4903737009,
-0.6591543555,
0.4784464538,
0.609010458,
0.013364898,
-0.0587280579,
-0.543822825,
-0.1204591617,
0.4111930728,
-0.6456544399,
-1.0357651711,
0.4061768651,
0.268704921,
0.5068967938,
0.4106485546,
0.3387155235,
0.6894997954,
-0.4478918314,
0.6110795736,
0.545512557,
-0.897116363,
0.788416028,
-0.1453596801,
0.2972743809,
0.48829934,
0.5990142822,
-0.095803149,
-0.0819366053,
-0.5695359707,
-0.4830648005,
1.1979951859,
0.097033821,
0.1729249507,
0.181259051,
0.4251942039,
0.4676560462,
0.0978637487,
-1.1449079514,
-0.473092556,
-0.6767252088,
-0.2946521342,
-0.1516246498,
-0.410977304,
-0.4077270925,
-0.2759997547,
0.8686490655,
-0.4605446458,
-0.0375074521,
0.1340722591,
-0.1103163809,
-0.1544995159,
0.3113120496,
0.5395286083,
0.3857208788,
0.1153357774,
0.4148882329,
0.1447691172,
0.1684093475,
0.239023149,
0.1847380847,
-0.1438920796,
-0.1048551351,
0.352791667,
1.0578523874,
0.2275022417,
-0.4388846159,
0.682313621,
0.344557941,
-0.2560030818,
-0.3418433666,
0.0077918423,
-0.066344738,
0.2296437025,
0.2720770836,
0.0519094616,
-0.0361864902,
-0.279394418,
0.2038158625,
0.5559737086,
-0.066598013,
-0.4371688366,
0.7591544986,
0.2001291215,
0.0325735323,
0.3111045361,
-0.4618572891,
-0.515042007,
0.4701925516,
0.7599306107,
0.8298286796,
-0.0340763107,
0.5951759219,
0.6430684924,
0.1095068827,
-0.0417420194,
-0.1910712719,
-0.5274037123,
-0.6925965548,
-0.3494469821,
-0.4104717076,
-0.2565537393,
0.1391197443,
-0.345307827,
0.3822114468,
-0.4660625756,
-0.2524531186,
0.2683987617,
0.0333923735,
-0.6170859933,
0.3309764564,
0.4956293404,
0.3771924078,
-0.9164052606,
0.8898186088,
0.757820785,
-0.607899487,
-1.0063868761,
-0.1989813149,
-0.0731656179,
-0.884642005,
0.9202288389,
0.4065860808,
-0.1331810802,
0.0495480932,
-0.727578938,
-0.7670850158,
0.9923981428,
0.699277401,
-0.3824961185,
-0.1509750485,
0.2427404225,
0.4274888635,
-0.5446898937,
0.3427992463,
0.3342923224,
0.4139131308,
0.2699412107,
-0.4495217204,
-0.1417450011,
0.3268329501,
-0.0805584863,
0.0794340521,
-0.4985140264,
0.6029875278,
-0.4859977961,
-0.310752213,
-0.2745769024,
0.698659718,
0.1326130927,
0.6951642036,
0.3191188872,
0.5808081031,
0.543579638,
0.150368005,
0.8931641579,
-0.2574388683,
0.4290928543,
1.4201415777,
-0.0543682948,
0.4906460345,
0.4234986603,
0.0358389392,
0.3761090934,
0.4550082386,
-0.1751468331,
0.4916506708,
0.1124673262,
-0.2248757035,
-0.9320315123,
-0.0802283883,
0.0473742075,
0.529774487,
0.0964828581,
-0.3271865547,
-0.5811662674,
0.4105414748,
-0.0067446344,
0.0775426254,
-0.3282009661,
0.7950778008,
0.1849530488,
-0.9584850669,
0.7030043602,
0.0702776983,
0.46291098,
-0.4742768109,
0.1202446371,
-0.0399079807,
0.1389585435,
-0.2737469673,
-0.4897978604,
0.1554244459,
0.0797806457,
-0.2576491535,
-0.6475763917,
0.8692025542,
-0.8242148757,
-0.4571309388,
-0.1034292132,
0.3337376118,
0.1233667433,
0.021701837,
-0.8630799055,
-0.3521258533,
-0.0666287839,
-0.2677871287,
0.2707529962,
0.2837790847,
0.1699430197,
0.6212313771,
0.5180655122,
-0.3335841,
0.2904643714,
-0.0648009926,
0.6872976422,
-0.3533233106,
-0.3755584955,
-0.8779771328,
0.6480850577,
0.2372833341,
-0.3480710387,
0.6423820257,
0.5784689784,
0.7278853655,
-0.3476486802,
0.825836122,
0.428622812,
0.6816699505,
-0.4550611079,
0.3604901135,
-0.5753546357,
0.0614116155,
0.1382715553,
-0.5089583993,
-0.2693518102,
0.5930045247,
-0.5381920934,
0.0198588762,
0.5522283316,
0.7009333968,
-0.1026321426,
-0.191031903,
0.4202890694,
-0.0478951298,
0.0556617528,
0.6699046493,
0.7197137475,
-0.3717793226,
0.6830960512,
-0.741132915,
-0.1112940684,
-0.0177765656,
-0.740144968,
-1.4215204716,
-0.529953599,
-0.6854575276,
-0.0428501442,
-0.1000937745,
0.8576503396,
1.0873060226,
-0.7015792131,
0.0079998756,
-0.2984124422,
0.2284497917,
0.1138119921,
-0.2571564913,
0.1518396288,
-0.7287182212,
-0.6718373895,
0.4847081006,
0.0503292978,
0.3539415002,
-0.2853227854,
-0.1563518643,
-0.030377388,
0.0711112022,
0.4942255914,
0.4182379842,
-0.9621748924,
-0.0708940178,
-0.2956297398,
-0.1701019257,
0.0054442771,
1.0540709496,
-1.1808284521,
0.5705634952,
0.3426965475,
0.5642976761,
0.6344798207,
0.0823925808,
0.434214294,
-1.0615445375,
0.2104163468,
0.3954824209,
0.0235285517,
0.3025687933,
-0.2478608787,
0.3982180059,
0.4071517587,
-0.4195820689,
-1.008138895,
0.3897330165,
-0.7753996849,
-0.4074914753,
1.141189456,
-0.4554031789,
-0.0861357003,
0.1277908087,
-0.1473349035,
0.4866082072,
-0.287180841,
0.5169546008,
0.5020812154,
-0.2883422971,
-0.35883829,
-0.1673557609,
0.6047602296,
0.6554200649,
-0.7755582929,
-0.0877953619,
0.6454590559,
0.317974776,
0.0172867738,
0.6515714526,
0.4867572486,
0.3214092851,
0.1418217421,
0.0052502281,
-0.3993295431,
-0.5361384749,
-0.215677619,
0.23981224,
-0.0044488856,
-0.4425655305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03313v1 | A Scalable and Adaptive System to Infer the Industry Sectors of Companies: Prompt + Model Tuning of Generative Language Models | 2023-06-05T23:55:09 | 2023-06-05T23:55:09 | Lele Cao, Vilhelm von Ehrenheim, Astrid Berghult, Cecilia Henje, Richard Anselmo Stahl, Joar Wandborg, Sebastian Stan, Armin Catovic, Erik Ferm, Hannes Ingelhag | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, 68T05, I.2.7; I.2.1 | The Private Equity (PE) firms operate investment funds by acquiring and
managing companies to achieve a high return upon selling. Many PE funds are
thematic, meaning investment professionals aim to identify trends by covering
as many industry sectors as possible, and picking promising companies within
these sectors. So, inferring sectors for companies is critical to the success
of thematic PE funds. In this work, we standardize the sector framework and
discuss the typical challenges; we then introduce our sector inference system
addressing these challenges. Specifically, our system is built on a
medium-sized generative language model, finetuned with a prompt + model tuning
procedure. The deployed model demonstrates a superior performance than the
common baselines. The system has been serving many PE professionals for over a
year, showing great scalability to data volume and adaptability to any change
in sector framework and/or annotation. | [
-0.071693942,
-0.6169122458,
0.7016184926,
0.8157739043,
0.0518427268,
0.2508862615,
0.0644166023,
-0.1372995824,
-0.1190157086,
0.5655038953,
-0.7738662362,
-0.4496153891,
-0.3714408278,
0.1088602319,
-0.1948193908,
0.8844884038,
0.2207769901,
0.0857778043,
-0.048854325,
-0.3429040015,
-0.676448524,
-0.3703805804,
-1.0732530355,
-0.2091332823,
0.1249255687,
0.2964075208,
0.4436468184,
0.6426478028,
0.3546825945,
0.3367341161,
-0.1462416351,
0.0964857638,
-0.3168458045,
0.1833620667,
-0.3408292234,
-0.3369292021,
-0.404995352,
-0.0384833142,
0.6534836888,
1.0449001789,
-0.4192081988,
-0.0141536724,
0.0834064111,
0.4787662327,
-0.7798171639,
0.1407663375,
-0.8446173072,
0.0073673441,
-0.074509792,
0.0086323051,
-0.5274080634,
-0.3262765706,
0.1006045341,
-0.7086904049,
0.4127811491,
0.4167633355,
0.8530229926,
0.0454858802,
-0.2234474272,
-0.1478701085,
-0.6642447114,
0.766756475,
-0.3008914888,
0.2170736194,
0.5567002296,
0.4008679092,
-0.235598132,
-0.8613841534,
0.0388033465,
-0.0791248456,
0.2127090693,
-0.0106933014,
-0.1134864539,
0.0274772123,
0.2499695271,
0.5665282011,
-0.2900623679,
0.3861073256,
-0.0853204131,
-0.1569555849,
0.3225548267,
0.2231699973,
0.0561638884,
0.3207418621,
-0.2338289469,
0.0087278159,
-1.0034592152,
0.0560342595,
0.4724676907,
0.2464781106,
-0.0146791246,
0.382278055,
-0.3640022576,
0.7195137143,
0.486926645,
-0.0174938347,
-0.037747778,
-0.4127910137,
-0.6858160496,
0.1833536178,
0.4053553045,
-0.0039057697,
-0.1238064766,
-0.1423696131,
-0.2778146565,
-0.0650162473,
0.0993384346,
-0.6155768633,
-0.4198708534,
0.0976659358,
-0.3066798449,
-0.046119757,
-0.0200667828,
-0.5928928256,
-0.5983875394,
-0.1046654806,
0.2232261002,
-0.3045408726,
-0.0822798759,
0.2839487195,
-0.3950801492,
0.2722087204,
0.3867113888,
-0.8733910918,
-0.2451333553,
0.7516766191,
0.8010885715,
0.4232350886,
-0.0740231499,
-0.8462530971,
0.3380262852,
-0.4678734243,
1.0899842978,
-0.874250412,
-0.7956793308,
-0.0815386921,
0.3170700073,
-0.2927714586,
-0.6423640251,
0.5479413271,
-0.5213981271,
0.3715467453,
-0.2685551345,
-0.5624534488,
0.0210075788,
-0.0566863716,
-0.3525522053,
0.7262346745,
0.3253113031,
-0.6055908203,
0.8902744055,
-0.7855337858,
0.0110721299,
0.3431347013,
-0.2436229289,
-0.6624706984,
0.087055929,
0.5473950505,
0.3270271719,
-0.4496818185,
0.4302120805,
-0.7336986065,
-0.0199172832,
0.3674817383,
-0.4667468369,
0.696252346,
0.2390805781,
0.0680745617,
0.4239646196,
-1.1581645012,
-0.3096118569,
-0.3444481194,
0.1131965518,
-0.4613559544,
0.3786078393,
-0.0587917157,
-0.1894567162,
0.2586956024,
-0.3544380963,
0.1223976091,
-0.3630910218,
0.9594647884,
0.8008117676,
0.4543945491,
0.6654490232,
0.0162447561,
0.6919538379,
0.1843085587,
0.0624769852,
-0.6216722131,
-0.2842666209,
-0.6111997366,
-0.9709035158,
0.2043222487,
0.2948843241,
-0.684034884,
0.4560727477,
0.0953484699,
-0.4453102648,
-0.5366231203,
-0.1097903475,
0.0673927441,
0.5977938771,
0.0469079763,
-0.2342755944,
-0.4059947729,
-0.9606758356,
-0.2248736173,
-0.2145802081,
-0.3685195744,
0.2926133275,
-0.0288598649,
0.0558764003,
0.9765946865,
-0.5899241567,
0.274104476,
-0.0523171499,
0.4826643467,
0.7364160419,
0.4086411595,
0.5222441554,
-0.6441012621,
-0.348614037,
0.3151961863,
-0.5953508615,
-0.1076902822,
-0.3525048196,
-0.2145082206,
-0.5435324907,
0.6395210028,
-0.2130806893,
0.0010827027,
0.3478697836,
-0.9837440252,
0.2780373096,
-0.3343604505,
-0.1502860934,
-0.9942815304,
0.1494012326,
0.6492482424,
-0.5330784917,
-0.1082575619,
-0.106722258,
0.1654221863,
-0.4755765498,
-0.1142731681,
0.2920351326,
-0.3275633156,
-0.0496416762,
-0.1725628078,
-0.4240654409,
0.3308364749,
0.1643070579,
-0.0337374061,
1.3332643509,
0.8703985214,
-0.7951338887,
0.2084191144,
0.0217442699,
-0.775627315,
0.8689704537,
-0.7461713552,
-0.0062180418,
-0.1059446782,
-0.0679588392,
-0.6134428978,
-0.2901695669,
0.0977606103,
0.2495809495,
0.2968279421,
-0.3149841428,
-0.1457382739,
-0.2788539529,
0.1478123963,
0.0538123325,
0.3134163022,
-0.5394717455,
0.3435291648,
0.2500024736,
-0.6342029572,
-0.2184993327,
-0.2219185531,
0.0436334275,
-0.6794522405,
-0.4739821851,
0.2190655768,
0.0201677904,
-0.205428049,
-0.116179198,
-0.0996032804,
-0.6150426269,
0.3390219808,
0.3216642439,
0.2676427364,
-0.4743948877,
-0.1566072553,
0.2783438861,
-0.2491173744,
-0.0675441325,
-0.5231157541,
0.0489313267,
0.0077883899,
-0.3690645695,
-0.3018136024,
0.120382756,
0.9564528465,
-0.3413925469,
0.8080102801,
0.1783272326,
-0.0859920532,
-0.4992935061,
-0.3212376237,
0.0555501468,
-0.5687680244,
0.5373046994,
-0.5276739001,
-0.8751835823,
0.5691115856,
-0.5277441144,
-0.2450039983,
0.5940100551,
0.7158578634,
0.0980095714,
1.0710178614,
1.1934775114,
-0.223674193,
0.6243781447,
-0.2395325452,
0.3540344238,
-0.5893670917,
-0.2476479858,
-0.7937046885,
-0.0048096813,
-0.4662639499,
-0.2018678933,
0.6601102352,
0.4465798438,
-0.5982083082,
0.3639737368,
-0.4009705484,
0.4070945978,
0.503967464,
-0.056407813,
0.2194871306,
0.0780889094,
-0.006444254,
-0.1394503266,
-0.658226788,
-0.4399269819,
0.6233372688,
0.7672225237,
0.8729434609,
-0.1409658343,
-0.0035373215,
0.145468846,
0.5651807785,
-0.5015443563,
0.0604837574,
-0.1745846868,
-0.4767016172,
-0.2207894772,
-0.0668677688,
-0.5421867371,
0.1074254587,
0.10892912,
-0.7466869354,
1.169786334,
0.0409009643,
-0.7566982508,
0.0950203314,
-0.8240537047,
0.7361700535,
0.1827871054,
-0.5630329847,
-0.1366842091,
0.0771409795,
0.2148715556,
-0.365149498,
-0.1430937499,
-0.5073192716,
0.0166412331,
0.3460174203,
-0.5448778272,
0.886248529,
-0.1609825045,
0.0787016302,
0.3625793755,
-0.1869890243,
0.4263063967,
0.409101814,
-0.6266457438,
0.0081964796,
-0.0417850316,
-0.587518096,
-0.4762614965,
0.5376968384,
-0.6834326386,
-0.4498873949,
-0.3488459885,
-0.5419703126,
-0.3827567399,
0.0372537822,
0.3397792876,
0.3545712233,
-0.4359886348,
0.5116321445,
0.5824574828,
-0.1021503806,
0.8583568931,
0.7177363634,
0.1167480797,
-0.3848123848,
0.759139657,
-0.0285393205,
-0.3005988598,
0.3941490948,
-0.1103426814,
-0.5577591658,
-0.4726518393,
-0.7060777545,
-0.0640396103,
-0.2804693282,
-0.40209499,
-0.5369650126,
-0.0372968428,
-0.1718827039,
-0.3527965546,
-0.4463295341,
0.0051055807,
-0.3978115916,
-0.1543468684,
0.5201823115,
0.5895411372,
0.3789105117,
0.3531420529,
-0.6387046576,
-0.1011293679,
0.4483017921,
0.6126490235,
-0.3855766952,
-0.5023621321,
-0.5565748215,
-0.045917131,
-0.5588973165,
-0.7751223445,
0.3543430567,
0.4298932254,
0.4426330328,
0.7586323619,
-0.2467905283,
0.6666331291,
-0.3971952796,
0.7792619467,
0.1976531893,
-1.0193276405,
0.5821313858,
-0.6427742243,
0.1605789959,
0.6292729378,
0.2968975604,
-0.3187472522,
-0.2035196424,
-0.5681719184,
-0.7985736728,
0.5299142599,
0.0648068339,
0.0230338704,
-0.1477114111,
0.591750145,
0.2567783594,
0.4575102627,
-0.4364662468,
0.0335675962,
-0.0650090724,
-0.0804629549,
-0.0876334459,
-0.3974533379,
0.0915424079,
-0.0413035676,
0.7007576823,
-0.1783962697,
0.0526315682,
-0.0318747163,
0.187286526,
-0.0995826647,
0.1611582935,
0.1898017228,
1.208660841,
-0.1298883408,
-0.3166912794,
-0.1319963783,
-0.1668861657,
0.3031585217,
0.0530960225,
-0.2291713208,
-0.071895659,
0.234885186,
1.3226377964,
0.2576684654,
-0.5488223433,
0.1740119308,
0.0580614917,
-0.0130389128,
-0.0085628293,
0.2125800252,
-0.1359091103,
0.4741025567,
0.2946726382,
0.0115539813,
0.2609569728,
-0.5524715781,
0.0441707969,
0.2675962746,
-0.5815986395,
-0.4461807609,
0.8194490671,
0.367809087,
-0.1879114956,
0.7665380836,
-0.2458503097,
0.0099945553,
0.9394298792,
0.7422841191,
1.3021738529,
-0.1765810102,
0.2976186275,
0.1729599535,
0.0257067885,
-0.1377514899,
0.1250371486,
0.098180905,
-0.7520698905,
-0.8305365443,
-0.8654952645,
-0.6099545956,
0.2886036038,
-0.726369381,
0.2139880061,
-0.7083072066,
-0.221974656,
0.3010138571,
-0.2702810466,
-0.7461736202,
0.24921076,
-0.0971029699,
1.101462841,
-1.0811411142,
0.9431976676,
1.1607475281,
-0.3040447533,
-0.5525605679,
-0.0792385489,
-0.4097668529,
-0.8608237505,
0.6561933756,
-0.1817136854,
0.0560390502,
0.0916720331,
-0.3778780997,
-0.7756587267,
0.9733939171,
0.4188455939,
-0.8846155405,
0.1167132705,
-0.2928377092,
0.4539778233,
-0.7226251364,
0.0493567735,
0.6091527343,
0.2891971171,
0.0533236228,
-0.5528683662,
-0.479262203,
-0.1472664475,
0.5038754344,
0.1964483559,
-0.5656667948,
0.6117048264,
0.273488611,
-0.0071963021,
0.0861965641,
0.9755909443,
0.5447130203,
0.7964621782,
0.3952778578,
0.4345428646,
0.8155124187,
-0.0421504565,
1.1336327791,
-0.7198214531,
0.4377375245,
1.0342129469,
-0.388253957,
0.5280619264,
0.3272253275,
-0.5799652934,
0.6336350441,
0.9455521703,
-0.192182526,
0.7063155174,
-0.1003149897,
-0.4903883934,
-0.4130134284,
-0.3580855131,
-0.3576439917,
0.4020396769,
0.6524019241,
-0.3268273175,
-0.1520624161,
-0.0173216891,
-0.2904435694,
0.1449949592,
-0.5555397272,
0.7079012394,
0.0763366073,
-0.7492246628,
-0.2258823067,
0.4169148207,
0.3124870956,
-0.654620409,
-0.0302095301,
-0.5639833212,
0.2609303892,
0.2398500144,
-0.3594029844,
0.3229002953,
0.0087778736,
-0.6763325334,
-0.4337776005,
0.6312788129,
-0.4771349728,
-0.9698672891,
-0.0510315932,
0.2365813553,
-0.2220024168,
-0.1780707091,
-0.6650832295,
-0.24933514,
-0.0329623781,
-0.0111051509,
0.2184188664,
0.9269977212,
-0.2684213519,
0.6747317314,
0.3001977205,
0.0558166355,
-0.0791027099,
0.0939371288,
0.6235275865,
-0.5486060977,
-0.9250992537,
-0.7218269706,
0.4838666022,
-0.0754398927,
-0.4262902439,
0.7233393192,
0.5358006358,
0.4639039934,
-0.1642314643,
0.6248499751,
0.2978600562,
0.3172625899,
-0.5399646163,
0.6366830468,
-0.141722098,
0.4096880853,
0.1881572604,
-0.9399411082,
0.0288439263,
0.5951263309,
-0.5974735618,
-0.0144163771,
0.5073889494,
0.987277329,
-0.2966872156,
0.1730945259,
0.2297015637,
0.3444827497,
0.1528003365,
0.1033590063,
0.515940249,
-0.1397662163,
-0.1561502367,
-0.1637599617,
-0.1779443175,
-0.1720800847,
-1.1635036469,
-0.4433112741,
-0.3941865861,
-0.8630656004,
-0.3025296032,
0.1688240767,
0.6051433086,
0.9147701859,
-1.0989296436,
-0.2634909153,
-0.4616834223,
0.1542786658,
-0.34722808,
-0.249044463,
0.2083667964,
-0.4864422977,
-0.8754780293,
0.7923028469,
1.0456997156,
-0.3307409286,
-0.2500576079,
0.2107130587,
0.0890783146,
0.079947941,
0.614798069,
0.4112845659,
-0.2849570215,
-0.1791662872,
-0.1387189776,
0.131183669,
-0.0396761484,
1.2736879587,
-0.6418858767,
0.5461437702,
0.293477267,
0.7501150966,
0.3908453286,
-0.1439935863,
0.955296278,
-0.8829110265,
0.6276391149,
0.0060679498,
0.4656668007,
0.2837810218,
-0.593318522,
0.240936622,
0.5523328185,
-0.4891607165,
-0.6298415065,
0.0855160058,
-0.4284687638,
-0.307828337,
0.5659143925,
-0.203106001,
-0.1567066014,
-0.2801556885,
0.0035205102,
-0.0937255546,
-0.3518308699,
0.5519531965,
0.6644805074,
0.1375609338,
-0.1700575352,
-0.1548268497,
0.2595131993,
0.4367508888,
-0.3735404313,
-0.1386499405,
0.4639404714,
0.2831845284,
-0.2623398304,
0.817776382,
0.1062411591,
0.1141581535,
0.1579233259,
-0.0345845185,
0.1319998056,
-0.4960703254,
-0.652164042,
0.5519656539,
0.5038815141,
-0.339872241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03268v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03268v2 | "Medium" LMs of Code in the Era of LLMs: Lessons From StackOverflow | 2023-06-05T21:38:30 | 2024-01-24T07:53:30 | Manisha Mukherjee, Vincent J. Hellendoorn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Large pre-trained neural language models have brought immense progress to
both NLP and software engineering. Models in OpenAI's GPT series now dwarf
Google's BERT and Meta's RoBERTa, which previously set new benchmarks on a wide
range of NLP applications. These models are trained on massive corpora of
heterogeneous data from web crawls, which enables them to learn general
language patterns and semantic relationships. However, the largest models are
both expensive to train and deploy and are often closed-source, so we lack
access to their data and design decisions. We argue that this trend towards
large, general-purpose models should be complemented with single-purpose, more
modestly sized pre-trained models. In this work, we take StackOverflow (SO) as
a domain example in which large volumes of rich aligned code and text data is
available. We adopt standard practices for pre-training large language models,
including using a very large context size (2,048 tokens), batch size (0.5M
tokens) and training set (27B tokens), coupled with a powerful toolkit
(Megatron-LM), to train two models: SOBertBase, with 109M parameters, and
SOBertLarge with 762M parameters, at a budget of just $\$187$ and $\$800$ each.
We compare the performance of our models with both the previous SOTA model
trained on SO data exclusively as well general-purpose BERT models and OpenAI's
ChatGPT on four SO-specific downstream tasks - question quality prediction,
closed question prediction, named entity recognition and obsoletion prediction
(a new task we introduce). Not only do our models consistently outperform all
baselines, the smaller model is often sufficient for strong results. Both
models are released to the public. These results demonstrate that pre-training
both extensively and properly on in-domain data can yield a powerful and
affordable alternative to leveraging closed-source general-purpose models. | [
-0.3681723475,
-0.493122071,
0.5809571743,
0.0523068272,
-0.1508722454,
-0.3040709496,
-0.5639851093,
-0.3319078386,
0.1007528007,
0.8200291395,
-0.472548306,
-0.3160664141,
-0.3794383705,
-0.0850327387,
-0.5106753111,
1.2570903301,
-0.0056474553,
0.2250183076,
-0.0957822427,
-0.0457439162,
-0.1155162975,
-0.779189229,
-0.3974804282,
-0.135744378,
0.738142252,
0.110087052,
0.7657628655,
0.4543320239,
0.5885021687,
0.1873350143,
0.0976611376,
0.1184139103,
-0.6685702801,
-0.2084489614,
-0.1434752345,
-0.4952568412,
-0.4146447778,
0.1120869219,
0.6349382997,
0.7817602158,
-0.1104622409,
0.2807732224,
0.1493137777,
0.5656321645,
-0.4965493679,
0.0245353691,
-0.7169537544,
-0.0166523196,
-0.0901664793,
-0.2032145113,
-0.5964264274,
-0.2850322127,
0.180997014,
-0.4577806592,
-0.1933717877,
0.1651099473,
1.0076901913,
0.3441068232,
-0.1585351676,
-0.579551518,
-0.907045424,
1.0025701523,
-0.7966740727,
0.3982487917,
0.1862786412,
0.3139011562,
-0.1518001109,
-0.9555810094,
-0.4061388969,
-0.4739232957,
0.161866188,
0.1565250754,
-0.2529783547,
-0.0763540864,
0.2660770118,
0.2363103777,
-0.6655520201,
0.4813940525,
-0.5818222761,
0.0811569467,
0.4809219837,
0.0535451286,
0.2870055735,
0.0805975348,
-0.5647121668,
0.309048295,
-1.1130071878,
-0.4377156198,
0.2356483489,
0.3342231214,
0.0373389423,
0.5340220928,
0.2132088095,
0.6824166775,
-0.375646472,
-0.0127942888,
-0.0314098373,
-0.2492252588,
-0.38681373,
-0.206742093,
0.7554059029,
0.0542982854,
0.5905597806,
-0.2330890596,
-0.4310989678,
0.101955004,
0.3161353171,
-0.8364050388,
-0.2346948534,
0.2412258834,
-0.5138133764,
0.1289106309,
-0.147802189,
-0.3217277527,
-0.284195751,
-0.6913844943,
0.4192096591,
-0.1637051404,
-0.2920337617,
0.2739594579,
0.3784885108,
0.1729221791,
0.339209199,
-0.7153199911,
0.146287173,
0.6629972458,
0.8771682382,
-0.1023368165,
-0.2522232234,
-0.2287177742,
-0.0864211842,
-0.5712958574,
0.5208681226,
-0.3319255114,
-0.0757371411,
0.1198473498,
-0.1245051101,
0.0942264795,
-0.6448718309,
0.4007513225,
-0.8966913223,
0.202921018,
-0.0902872905,
-0.5973155499,
0.1786872149,
0.1262996048,
-0.5319823623,
0.701487124,
-0.0364830457,
-0.7012721896,
0.2417941391,
-0.7525215745,
-0.0606800206,
0.0331040807,
-0.301071018,
-0.2443466932,
-0.0205470212,
-0.005162444,
0.8704827428,
-0.5563293695,
0.4104521275,
-0.3137468994,
-0.5187342167,
0.1881483793,
-0.3175072074,
0.7959587574,
0.5389449,
-0.1620951742,
0.1124295816,
-0.6381506324,
0.1351308376,
0.0866168216,
-0.5668690205,
-0.3186576664,
0.0182977114,
0.1242466867,
0.285204649,
0.1976722926,
-0.2967798412,
0.1919566393,
-0.3193295598,
0.7300910354,
0.8268207908,
-0.3936824501,
0.5079590082,
-0.1624106467,
0.4452567995,
-0.0943469852,
0.1188462302,
0.0012067312,
-0.2941069603,
-0.5219390988,
-0.5006670356,
0.4561054409,
0.2997006178,
-0.7329141498,
0.5091227293,
-0.5416038036,
-0.4379090369,
-0.3951059878,
0.2121581137,
0.1559740752,
0.1948420852,
0.2681851685,
-0.1176992804,
-0.4854880571,
-0.7857205868,
-0.0584990233,
0.1547284871,
-0.4823751152,
0.36483711,
0.5235602856,
-0.5287314057,
0.9416037798,
-0.4391611516,
-0.2751675546,
-0.2665100694,
-0.0669153929,
0.4561920762,
0.3552531004,
0.5564575791,
-0.807921648,
-0.3552418351,
-0.0800790638,
-0.7859013081,
-0.0230715126,
-0.0475418344,
0.0328371376,
0.2099939436,
0.6733311415,
-0.558852613,
0.0069849542,
0.8193069696,
-0.0253965184,
0.6436677575,
-0.2788306177,
-0.3165852129,
-1.2429145575,
0.1606513709,
-0.0103873303,
-0.2168281674,
-0.5890633464,
0.1688749492,
0.1639719456,
-0.3054086566,
-0.5119944811,
0.3958835602,
-0.7032433748,
-0.3170689642,
-0.3017588556,
0.2080723941,
-0.3487148881,
0.6374736428,
-0.0101732463,
0.9474502802,
0.4361530244,
-0.7175661922,
0.2777269185,
-0.10764011,
-0.6606352925,
0.2105700672,
-0.8775472045,
0.2549246848,
-0.1378071606,
0.4153138995,
-0.8132109642,
-0.1222195476,
-0.1392923445,
-0.3189835548,
0.253188163,
-0.1415052861,
-0.7363004684,
-0.2743530273,
-0.1663447618,
0.1313984841,
0.7794681787,
-0.7084767222,
0.4887881279,
0.3853929937,
-0.1626424789,
-0.622713089,
-0.8148849607,
0.0251670554,
-0.0991124287,
-0.6058567166,
0.0475553125,
-0.0094163027,
-0.1296242177,
0.1319371015,
0.0069885501,
-0.3274439871,
0.0154769383,
0.1409227252,
0.4989297092,
-0.6196046472,
0.3802029192,
-0.4513163865,
-0.0876343995,
-0.0060703354,
-0.7355371118,
0.8368700147,
-0.3421799242,
-0.3253465593,
-0.0121284248,
0.0475799516,
0.5388488173,
-0.3341937959,
0.9965699911,
0.4656569958,
-0.3501474261,
-0.3677081466,
-0.5533599257,
-0.1389221102,
-0.4394304752,
0.5197035074,
-0.1667278111,
-1.0644159317,
0.3860161304,
-0.1566676646,
0.2949617207,
0.3806683421,
0.6876291037,
-0.2076569945,
0.8087585568,
0.6108683348,
-0.3720665276,
0.5691680312,
-0.3244843483,
0.3668865263,
-0.6587235332,
0.1777412444,
-0.560953021,
-0.2345808297,
-0.4675529301,
-0.4695703387,
0.3853183091,
0.1049319208,
-0.411868453,
0.3057926297,
-0.4669301808,
0.5274989605,
0.558000803,
0.0986215025,
0.237790823,
0.0388290845,
0.2270040959,
0.0071154423,
-0.8773328066,
-0.7267687321,
1.4871252775,
0.5397729278,
1.0123131275,
0.0692592636,
0.6057540178,
0.1112896875,
0.5524835587,
-0.6708872318,
0.536755085,
-0.3041969836,
-0.6622430682,
-0.3225115836,
-0.7202422023,
-1.1052951813,
0.0682430714,
-0.1262567937,
-0.4650532007,
-0.0614795275,
0.1406355053,
-0.3879941106,
0.4454801679,
-0.8619557619,
0.7622166872,
-0.2731324732,
-0.2842880487,
-0.1721604615,
-0.6102557182,
0.4556733966,
-0.2217068672,
0.214250356,
0.0649904013,
-0.1328429729,
0.7474685907,
-0.4291577637,
0.7374486327,
-0.0618395656,
-0.2809672058,
0.3499006331,
-0.218855232,
0.5290172696,
-0.1407586336,
0.2205642313,
0.211325109,
-0.0634414628,
-0.5074170232,
-0.487586081,
0.810136795,
-0.9599260092,
-0.3638471365,
-0.1364294142,
-0.4379590154,
-0.2593262196,
0.2460587621,
0.3106956184,
0.5737311244,
0.1424595863,
0.6486305594,
1.0262367725,
-0.2671418786,
0.214639917,
0.3298180997,
-0.2669304907,
-0.0339078456,
0.8009996414,
0.303933531,
0.5089746714,
0.2347659022,
0.087254256,
-0.2413097322,
-0.572309494,
-0.2443750501,
0.2977827489,
-0.7475771308,
-0.0996417329,
-0.7376962304,
-0.414460361,
-0.2301910073,
-0.1656401008,
-0.4826923311,
-0.1816295534,
-0.2431567311,
0.1522965729,
0.0588017069,
0.6933296919,
0.2221180946,
0.2133606374,
-0.7811682224,
0.260338515,
0.3008689582,
0.3696706593,
-0.1253478527,
-0.5646225214,
-0.3062619865,
0.0754604489,
-0.0034832987,
-0.4989603758,
0.187682271,
0.0385119431,
0.4187106788,
0.3046964109,
-0.0666131154,
0.3399322629,
-0.6245874166,
0.8075923324,
0.343988955,
-0.6220596433,
0.3249425888,
-0.4426348507,
0.159537062,
0.317415297,
0.7859521508,
-0.3567028642,
-0.1045644581,
-0.5492600203,
-0.6874175072,
0.5296649337,
-0.1110763922,
0.4585658312,
0.1607891023,
0.2984448969,
-0.0063432623,
0.3377190828,
-0.9661405683,
0.0609210618,
-0.0142836301,
-0.3300670981,
-0.2211726457,
-0.2581355274,
-0.049106691,
-0.0090468312,
0.5064072609,
-0.2173042446,
0.3632017076,
-0.0367595665,
-0.1798664033,
0.2829517722,
0.367559731,
0.5147570968,
0.9569563866,
-0.1478410512,
0.0948230401,
0.0378875174,
-0.4396457672,
0.0037416571,
-0.0650229082,
-0.0193181578,
-0.1088121384,
0.3459893465,
0.624643743,
0.3256429136,
-0.8849251866,
0.6022943854,
0.3389976025,
-0.2966113091,
-0.3314157128,
0.0286278185,
0.2915043533,
0.3248780668,
0.1596763134,
-0.0638255924,
-0.0291215088,
-0.8388255835,
0.1161556169,
0.3641968966,
-0.2819146216,
-0.2211171836,
0.5761460066,
0.0478744507,
0.0103536276,
0.6353085041,
0.0577739552,
-0.3616620004,
0.4632134438,
0.4494845569,
0.6200916767,
0.0365506224,
-0.0806011558,
0.122814782,
0.3731888831,
-0.4158933759,
0.2571355104,
0.1073862165,
-0.7622275949,
-0.4751953781,
-0.543874681,
-0.3014312088,
0.3153246045,
-0.3810263872,
0.2370135933,
-0.7738272548,
-0.0936436281,
-0.1958253533,
0.0101031829,
-0.7698146105,
0.3127889037,
0.0728870779,
0.8950968385,
-0.6496127248,
0.9509478211,
0.6027407646,
-0.5828030109,
-0.9641401768,
-0.0821105465,
-0.3333060443,
-0.8716098666,
0.7970423698,
-0.0324814841,
-0.00842945,
0.0586697049,
-0.8573623896,
-0.7775732279,
0.904338479,
0.3912562132,
-0.7232519388,
-0.375613749,
-0.1020214185,
0.6087925434,
-0.380510062,
0.2202457786,
0.3425195217,
0.0938344523,
-0.0347445905,
-0.8386250138,
-0.0720365047,
-0.049715627,
0.0901217908,
0.2433399111,
-0.5692765713,
1.205406785,
-0.0321903974,
-0.1998075694,
0.0057600881,
0.5510630012,
0.2972141206,
0.0400739387,
0.4298464954,
0.2847899199,
0.5982526541,
-0.1011333838,
1.0572949648,
-0.2621041834,
0.4350458682,
1.0565587282,
-0.3371072114,
1.1462191343,
0.414745599,
-0.3000664115,
0.2456390858,
0.5225126147,
0.0157327447,
0.4796339571,
0.5803712606,
0.1194936261,
-0.0788994655,
0.022350736,
-0.5631511807,
0.1616439968,
0.323433578,
-0.4102579057,
-0.0676719174,
0.0060354918,
0.1238424703,
0.0587884299,
-0.4716820121,
0.6246452928,
0.3174698651,
-0.4632163644,
0.7877134085,
-0.0892206356,
0.9538431764,
-0.8990081549,
0.3120549023,
-0.1550678015,
0.3648770452,
-0.1538811922,
-0.6354691982,
0.1844844073,
0.1405769587,
0.0348070897,
-0.406688273,
0.6978225708,
-0.3076241612,
-0.2456766814,
0.2852371633,
0.4042068422,
0.3178409934,
-0.2585019469,
-0.5192558765,
0.0015890582,
-0.2955189347,
-0.3675064147,
0.3254543245,
0.4388136566,
0.0781179816,
0.6611527205,
0.6683303118,
0.2297672331,
0.1851525605,
0.1433043778,
0.9907659888,
-0.4493614435,
-0.486140728,
-0.6982786655,
0.3071798384,
0.0517540015,
-0.2934708893,
0.720269382,
0.436150074,
0.9051157236,
-0.1972982138,
0.7109248638,
0.1835706681,
0.5306076407,
-0.904940784,
0.7309880257,
-0.7216304541,
0.3379560411,
-0.1033473387,
-1.2353227139,
-0.1954045743,
0.3617331088,
-0.6008526087,
0.2755179703,
0.5245108008,
0.696588397,
-0.2598311603,
0.0042630136,
0.4022072852,
0.2497370392,
0.2894992828,
0.7774138451,
1.1310734749,
-0.1020251065,
0.4814122319,
0.3523285389,
-0.3719701171,
-0.4772004783,
-0.5894433856,
-0.9815506339,
-0.4060460031,
0.0159929562,
-0.224909991,
0.0171776917,
1.0778838396,
0.8508527875,
-0.6773769855,
-0.2050606906,
-0.0792954117,
-0.2331139892,
0.0634298921,
-0.1661195755,
0.243292585,
-0.6464737058,
-0.4874106944,
0.1593013704,
0.23992531,
-0.0750377625,
-0.5982054472,
-0.0746290907,
-0.1709279716,
0.2612465024,
0.6104099154,
0.2201255113,
-0.6749948263,
-0.1693349183,
0.1796393842,
-0.4973223209,
-0.0000603036,
0.8259637356,
-0.4368183017,
0.0487403348,
0.2377132028,
1.0695245266,
0.4656453133,
-0.3131013811,
0.5933606625,
-0.6237533689,
0.1640308648,
0.413053602,
0.4380890131,
0.0956106633,
-0.1270365864,
0.6066477895,
-0.0691286623,
-0.7452746034,
-0.9437080622,
0.2642791271,
-0.5427662134,
-0.4859194756,
1.1532348394,
-0.3029917777,
-0.2163133323,
0.0850216895,
-0.1266454607,
-0.1471910328,
0.0346403643,
0.5919715762,
0.7332680821,
0.2181397229,
-0.0384453386,
-0.9620727301,
0.4111140072,
0.5703982711,
-0.9038853645,
-0.0800244063,
0.493938446,
0.1900758296,
0.2466994077,
0.7106423974,
-0.0948981345,
0.1736792177,
-0.0369923748,
0.047052931,
-0.0071835639,
-0.6355218887,
-0.2484575957,
0.1324812919,
0.1456892341,
-0.1512904018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03264v1 | shs-nlp at RadSum23: Domain-Adaptive Pre-training of Instruction-tuned LLMs for Radiology Report Impression Generation | 2023-06-05T21:33:04 | 2023-06-05T21:33:04 | Sanjeev Kumar Karn, Rikhiya Ghosh, Kusuma P, Oladimeji Farri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuned generative Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and
Bloomz possess excellent generalization abilities, but they face limitations in
understanding radiology reports, particularly in the task of generating the
IMPRESSIONS section from the FINDINGS section. They tend to generate either
verbose or incomplete IMPRESSIONS, mainly due to insufficient exposure to
medical text data during training. We present a system which leverages
large-scale medical text data for domain-adaptive pre-training of
instruction-tuned LLMs to enhance its medical knowledge and performance on
specific medical tasks. We show that this system performs better in a zero-shot
setting than a number of pretrain-and-finetune adaptation methods on the
IMPRESSIONS generation task, and ranks 1st among participating systems in Task
1B: Radiology Report Summarization at the BioNLP 2023 workshop. | [
-0.1449526846,
-0.482263118,
0.5893998742,
0.1883400381,
-0.4048599601,
0.0748607367,
-0.207963109,
-0.5605815649,
0.4839450419,
0.5050269365,
-0.6391880512,
-0.7102113366,
-0.7091162205,
0.1856607497,
-0.0240176395,
1.2232868671,
0.1814591587,
0.4435290396,
-0.4109418094,
0.0451171584,
-0.3968529105,
-0.3123261929,
-0.5385555029,
-0.365252316,
0.4108439684,
0.3997807205,
0.6686028838,
0.4105687439,
0.7888947129,
0.1885398328,
0.3630292416,
0.3259401023,
-0.4025941789,
0.1566968262,
-0.2738779485,
-0.0873177797,
-0.7479884624,
-0.5449847579,
0.4934984446,
0.6809495687,
-0.0738766864,
0.0295640472,
-0.1375944763,
0.6876831055,
-0.6623692513,
0.1565149426,
-0.5977016687,
0.2468418926,
-0.0601561628,
-0.8873173594,
-0.6352000833,
-0.2121733129,
0.4059753418,
-0.6308187842,
0.2378167361,
-0.1740621179,
0.8925121427,
0.1269705743,
-0.1142089367,
-0.37274611,
-0.8055217862,
0.5449029803,
-0.6224378347,
0.1769673973,
0.3837118447,
0.0789554715,
-0.0661607683,
-0.9168061018,
0.0448532104,
-0.0298743621,
-0.0121315923,
0.5475413799,
-0.1655804217,
0.3179647923,
0.1191694811,
0.4362353384,
-0.7105900645,
0.1982331127,
-0.2908043265,
-0.0635177866,
0.4838300049,
0.2933124304,
0.3985584974,
-0.0712235048,
-0.3680020273,
-0.2087014765,
-0.723662138,
-0.5992975831,
-0.3505490124,
0.1147645414,
-0.1017971113,
0.3555316627,
-0.3076375127,
0.8695770502,
0.0515808836,
-0.1097923294,
0.4151161313,
-0.1160502434,
-0.4668979645,
0.0073068053,
0.6691903472,
0.2844396532,
0.0924170911,
0.0583637133,
-0.1166235134,
-0.1484948397,
0.4522717297,
-0.8613806963,
-0.2402294725,
-0.0005835879,
-0.4573211968,
-0.3911242783,
0.041933395,
-0.6168163419,
-0.381855607,
-0.2102878243,
0.704353869,
-0.6466069221,
-0.0184240732,
0.5736738443,
0.144089058,
0.3212016821,
0.5230451226,
-0.9304918647,
0.3503071666,
0.1844268441,
0.6902525425,
-0.1491687745,
-0.1278342605,
-0.4359723628,
0.2617741823,
-0.3459344208,
1.1183263063,
-0.4387244284,
-0.5357298255,
0.0392457992,
-0.053565301,
-0.2471707463,
-0.7639706135,
0.2744957805,
-0.5884527564,
0.3014149964,
0.0938144326,
-0.592992723,
0.0558805093,
0.052989427,
-0.113070257,
0.6282065511,
0.4063948393,
-0.6428477764,
0.2755232751,
-0.5644435287,
-0.6579758525,
0.396810621,
-0.3359757364,
-0.3857794702,
0.2575832605,
0.4121739864,
0.5798726082,
0.1001803577,
-0.1515880376,
0.0236437842,
-0.1821524054,
0.0960315764,
-0.135500297,
0.3224706352,
0.111464113,
-0.0273577347,
0.294206351,
-0.6172226667,
0.2929723263,
0.2231985927,
-0.4425905347,
-0.0308336299,
0.0040842905,
-0.1118445769,
0.0050715711,
0.1040439829,
-0.2974961102,
0.2856292427,
-0.627594471,
0.1309505999,
0.5882633328,
0.3226571679,
0.1099537835,
-0.566618681,
0.7186285257,
-0.0962932035,
0.0292924456,
-0.4536963701,
-0.1766181141,
-0.8006173968,
-0.2229122967,
0.2597762346,
0.5823917985,
-0.9036041498,
0.3024653792,
-0.5997551084,
-0.4395902753,
-0.2661511898,
-0.138622418,
0.5499203205,
0.4007433653,
0.4384699166,
-0.5821769238,
-0.672516942,
-0.7248216867,
-0.0264141131,
0.146849975,
-0.302160114,
0.3961437643,
0.1767919213,
-0.2076024264,
0.4716462791,
-0.8703448772,
-0.6345582008,
-0.2186044306,
0.0585234463,
0.0898737013,
0.2218116373,
0.4577332437,
-0.2801164687,
-0.5982240438,
-0.0571517125,
-0.6688525677,
-0.0463895835,
-0.1140324995,
0.0566199124,
0.2038949728,
0.6353990436,
-0.4362221956,
0.1868719906,
0.668412149,
-0.2616607249,
0.4913358986,
-0.65390414,
0.1953349113,
-1.0923484564,
-0.2316731662,
-0.1294941902,
-0.575936377,
-0.5213752985,
-0.1372834444,
-0.1619150043,
-0.1935072541,
-0.3458338976,
0.2573262155,
-0.4592370689,
-0.2627211511,
-0.5294466615,
-0.1243664175,
0.1096755564,
0.2995360494,
0.4359802008,
0.5918495059,
0.6976350546,
-0.6379764676,
0.0466313809,
0.502393961,
-0.5981677771,
0.3437483907,
-0.3655999899,
0.4907215834,
-0.0323142372,
0.4495945871,
-0.6688093543,
-0.5238285661,
-0.1031825617,
-0.530441761,
0.5920836926,
-0.0052297604,
-0.0940419883,
-0.2714321017,
-0.1878102422,
0.1599764079,
0.6368313432,
-0.4032279253,
0.4852820635,
0.3281004727,
-0.3596027493,
-0.5866187215,
-0.5675784349,
0.2096414566,
0.1559682339,
-0.4154397547,
0.6913602948,
0.1487718374,
0.0442903861,
-0.1512703001,
-0.0714952052,
-0.122166425,
-0.1791517287,
0.2615778744,
0.3989596963,
-0.5293288231,
0.1104527861,
-0.0761860833,
0.0405637212,
0.0443400182,
-0.2547512949,
0.748293519,
-0.0313572846,
-0.4686650038,
-0.4804285765,
0.0196964927,
0.5244709849,
0.1362560391,
0.4189296663,
0.3058405817,
-0.3143988848,
-0.2671250403,
-0.3467351496,
-0.2332524061,
-0.4387255907,
0.8444386125,
-0.1018387973,
-0.860407114,
-0.0183787998,
-0.1679077148,
0.0722854286,
0.5797294378,
0.7988516092,
-0.4244118035,
0.8238467574,
0.5362481475,
0.0996714532,
0.4297268391,
0.0728556514,
-0.2341102213,
-0.6455938816,
-0.0730612278,
-0.3353904784,
0.0330373868,
-0.2330504954,
-0.5660974383,
0.4789510965,
-0.3453727663,
0.0569471307,
-0.1706136167,
-0.6168981194,
0.5729381442,
0.2119682133,
0.5616329312,
0.2135430127,
0.1227814481,
0.2699418664,
-0.202525869,
-0.806261301,
-0.2960526943,
1.2665711641,
0.1539552063,
0.7311139703,
-0.2102768719,
0.5230097175,
0.4382044971,
0.3849998415,
-0.7555879354,
0.4639096856,
-0.6466950774,
-0.2945135236,
-0.1886584461,
-0.1599069983,
-0.8325796723,
-0.0063216733,
-0.5134371519,
-0.2203558385,
-0.1947727799,
0.3450498283,
-0.6059813499,
0.1231442466,
-0.4161628783,
0.3159854114,
-0.1750210226,
0.0273900554,
-0.534060955,
-0.4741577804,
0.1858836561,
-0.1167967394,
0.1525863409,
-0.1126109883,
0.1212288961,
0.7403537035,
-0.3360906541,
0.8995282054,
-0.3907078207,
0.022397818,
-0.0389960781,
0.1043437198,
0.2991232276,
-0.0660038739,
0.1950575262,
-0.0100762304,
0.0236311574,
-0.1946437508,
-0.3795275092,
0.533900857,
-0.8504035473,
-0.5298110843,
-0.3149051964,
-0.5373213291,
-0.6963838339,
0.2007643878,
0.5943621993,
0.5427197814,
-0.5439505577,
0.1964740157,
0.9040712118,
-0.7393605113,
-0.0011726595,
0.4387303293,
-0.2856657207,
-0.5181770921,
0.8486074209,
-0.1354515851,
0.4388919473,
0.5819007754,
0.1504579782,
0.0457529984,
-0.8159321547,
-0.3527085781,
0.2733092606,
-0.7777971625,
-0.5069587231,
-0.5827991962,
-0.6224862933,
-0.4381170571,
-0.2726779282,
-0.3185203969,
-0.4424856305,
-0.1860585362,
0.0173087548,
0.47730878,
0.8310278058,
0.0498099886,
0.5270215273,
-0.8001951575,
0.3745599687,
0.1434855908,
0.4063417017,
-0.3801983595,
-0.9759019613,
-0.4924042523,
-0.2826338112,
-0.36357674,
-0.4408577681,
0.3356752694,
0.5275509953,
0.1739377528,
0.420045197,
-0.1613584757,
0.5251961946,
-0.6740869284,
0.4702610075,
0.2270741612,
-0.5163628459,
0.695975244,
-0.5563704967,
0.571829021,
0.5082406402,
0.270603478,
-0.2385539412,
-0.4096575081,
-0.5527909994,
-0.671584487,
0.8175374866,
-0.1720237136,
0.4085085392,
-0.0312027819,
0.4900957346,
0.0695621371,
-0.2669507563,
-0.5046305656,
-0.0208848137,
-0.1464932561,
-0.3418151438,
0.0487732366,
-0.5428729653,
-0.2432430983,
-0.2089882344,
0.8121480346,
-0.2658952475,
0.4947713912,
0.3418569565,
-0.2895295918,
-0.0930010155,
0.247079283,
0.9732028246,
0.9775106311,
-0.3369802237,
0.0464860648,
0.3073015511,
-0.937312305,
-0.0476449281,
-0.2618053555,
0.0274885241,
0.1666312367,
0.5478928089,
0.9345988631,
0.2741636634,
-0.5728690624,
0.627925694,
-0.0562230572,
-0.6548883319,
-0.267452538,
0.2385017276,
0.1086135283,
-0.1879482418,
0.2789366245,
0.1242738143,
-0.1318328977,
-0.1326246709,
0.3580812812,
0.3063417673,
-0.6545661688,
-0.3409880698,
0.4266835749,
0.1379309297,
-0.0536911301,
0.5705845356,
0.3383474648,
-0.0786284655,
0.3728484213,
0.6342204809,
0.7158169746,
-0.3700606823,
0.251201272,
0.3988951743,
0.0648158193,
-0.0568976849,
0.2234658003,
0.2904835343,
-0.8090013266,
-0.74695158,
-0.4972653687,
-0.4517219663,
0.4363434315,
-0.8681672812,
0.5025921464,
-0.7916970849,
-0.1345138252,
0.1930323839,
-0.4311193824,
-0.495480895,
0.5962612629,
0.2692015171,
0.7245684266,
-0.7230711579,
0.8556571007,
0.6947290897,
-0.0658413172,
-0.5287128091,
0.0549042523,
-0.1343940347,
-1.1857104301,
0.5866445899,
-0.0522495061,
-0.2891385555,
0.1610306501,
-0.4130401313,
-0.6398017406,
0.8988502622,
0.28446877,
-0.4697254598,
-0.0751856714,
0.1628062427,
0.637288034,
-0.4121637046,
-0.0011450815,
0.2838464379,
-0.0380969606,
0.088971816,
-0.8412835002,
-0.0644530281,
0.0573767312,
-0.2326464802,
-0.0808512121,
-0.3936121464,
0.3888314366,
-0.3673528433,
-0.1102326289,
-0.1130452827,
0.6898391843,
0.2067332119,
0.1176305115,
0.4449030757,
0.4646348953,
0.4506385922,
-0.0229774471,
1.1189684868,
-0.2593203783,
0.1435348094,
1.3608192205,
-0.2588267028,
0.6459565759,
0.2399838865,
-0.2238308489,
0.6189340353,
0.5462408662,
-0.1035305411,
0.5650395155,
0.1168850362,
-0.3452059925,
-0.2952073812,
-0.0295358412,
-0.456728667,
0.6030694246,
0.6449522376,
-0.5414786339,
-0.1427718401,
0.2085098475,
-0.1454128325,
-0.0249516629,
-0.3094085455,
1.1181716919,
0.2631992996,
-0.489544332,
0.5661976337,
-0.0522674695,
0.6230869889,
-0.8967012167,
0.0291759111,
-0.1737968475,
0.3042072952,
-0.4919160604,
-0.6063209772,
0.4205146134,
-0.0981406793,
-0.4130446315,
-0.1809355319,
0.803129971,
0.0124382833,
-0.4375061095,
0.0437494814,
0.3945284784,
0.1479990035,
0.1733009368,
-0.5588074327,
-0.0971170515,
0.2190843523,
-0.35498932,
0.6107607484,
0.24257572,
0.0156039437,
0.4217381775,
0.3526033163,
0.4658927917,
-0.2539287806,
0.4374718368,
0.6900414824,
-0.4245944619,
-0.2262298167,
-0.6455159783,
0.0078890808,
0.1356230974,
-0.1538122147,
0.3928726315,
0.5919645429,
0.6715728641,
-0.3212879598,
0.8603230119,
0.1480960697,
0.7285428047,
-0.8489666581,
0.7093275189,
-0.3427577913,
0.148224622,
-0.2158430517,
-0.6744434834,
-0.5144731998,
0.5314888954,
-0.2524649799,
0.0749308765,
0.8255372643,
0.6459655166,
0.0092779668,
-0.1736086011,
0.4040715396,
0.1714117676,
0.0259199329,
0.5746182203,
0.7045919895,
-0.2019366771,
0.4883693457,
0.0674992502,
-0.1662769765,
-0.2597285211,
-0.6267530918,
-0.6506851315,
-0.3351029158,
-0.4854345322,
-0.4897876084,
-0.0218958706,
0.6936433315,
0.7864416242,
-0.7139971852,
-0.052167166,
0.1380439699,
-0.5604736209,
0.0682485774,
-0.225829795,
0.7973499894,
-0.5689321756,
-0.3598069251,
0.4730378985,
0.6791157722,
0.1395150721,
0.0152119687,
0.0266337618,
0.1148636714,
0.0859551653,
0.582638979,
0.2420031428,
-0.296833396,
-0.3396734893,
0.1408313513,
-0.2741347551,
0.5096978545,
0.9105715752,
-0.6128098369,
0.487085104,
0.166078791,
0.7084770203,
0.6254782677,
-0.0248850938,
0.5976604223,
-0.8293479681,
0.1327749044,
0.4496919513,
0.0938021764,
0.3255416453,
-0.4088558257,
0.2937421501,
0.0854586065,
-0.565184772,
-0.588883996,
0.1386845559,
-1.0726649761,
-0.5416017771,
1.1122597456,
-0.07851284,
0.0270740502,
-0.1029413044,
-0.0638840422,
0.0220215041,
0.0997593775,
0.8763804436,
0.4624485075,
-0.5243678093,
-0.0874850452,
-0.608399868,
0.8459755778,
0.6661753654,
-1.0902557373,
-0.1301127374,
0.5603026748,
0.5343821049,
-0.0644755065,
1.1945223808,
-0.4296671152,
0.4676432312,
-0.2937704027,
0.270126611,
0.0467474274,
-0.1520764381,
-0.307449311,
-0.0459961146,
0.3772710562,
-0.2312172651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03241v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03241v2 | Early Weight Averaging meets High Learning Rates for LLM Pre-training | 2023-06-05T20:51:44 | 2023-12-11T22:31:12 | Sunny Sanyal, Atula Neerkaje, Jean Kaddour, Abhishek Kumar, Sujay Sanghavi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Training Large Language Models (LLMs) incurs significant cost; hence, any
strategy that accelerates model convergence is helpful. In this paper, we
investigate the ability of a simple idea checkpoint averaging along the
trajectory of a training run to improve both convergence and generalization
quite early on during training. Here we show that models trained with high
learning rates observe higher gains due to checkpoint averaging. Furthermore,
these gains are amplified when checkpoints are sampled with considerable
spacing in training steps. Our training recipe outperforms conventional
training and popular checkpoint averaging baselines such as exponential moving
average (EMA) and stochastic moving average (SWA). We evaluate our training
recipe by pre-training LLMs, where high learning rates are inherently preferred
due to extremely large batch sizes. Specifically, we pre-trained nanoGPT-2
models of varying sizes, small (125M), medium (335M), and large (770M)on the
OpenWebText dataset, comprised of 9B tokens. Additionally, we present results
for publicly available Pythia LLMs, ranging from 1B to 12B, which were trained
on the PILE-deduped dataset containing 207B tokens. | [
-0.3207041919,
-0.4305268228,
0.6995865703,
0.2238771319,
-0.5072203875,
0.0171978213,
-0.3160811067,
-0.2612691522,
0.2077764869,
0.0919041634,
-0.203689754,
-0.468180716,
-0.98573035,
-0.2317789942,
-0.1556013674,
0.7880702019,
0.0098527865,
0.1858659089,
0.2507971823,
-0.2763723135,
-0.2834359705,
-0.1683789641,
-0.9426881075,
-0.088925004,
0.7688371539,
0.2473348081,
0.2978945971,
0.6870575547,
0.4006413519,
0.2388552725,
-0.1920392662,
0.1533414871,
-0.4684589207,
-0.2906558216,
-0.0486101694,
-0.2935048342,
-0.6919585466,
0.2999235988,
0.92546767,
0.8637495041,
-0.5194545984,
0.0776480511,
0.3368228674,
0.6491256952,
-0.6054794788,
-0.0107855797,
-0.8154888749,
-0.0573392808,
-0.2127241194,
-0.0957288742,
-0.3195212781,
-0.381003648,
0.0674940795,
-0.7900067568,
-0.0013156338,
0.1099930257,
0.7215028405,
-0.1677986979,
-0.1285438389,
-0.4177484214,
-0.4677412808,
0.9481233358,
-0.7850707769,
0.2309576124,
-0.0981087834,
0.07815703,
-0.3127832115,
-0.7009581327,
-0.558136344,
-0.0051830499,
0.2430830151,
-0.1095856726,
-0.652667582,
0.1719925255,
0.4432806373,
0.2496756017,
-0.3737735748,
0.5459645391,
-0.1020434871,
-0.2076815814,
0.06027022,
0.0590442456,
0.0842831135,
0.1924245805,
-0.2954851687,
-0.2820519507,
-0.7113659978,
-0.032414604,
0.2335766405,
0.4550982416,
-0.1919208318,
0.2903751731,
-0.4952245951,
0.7200177908,
0.0466305763,
0.1045497581,
0.2684620917,
-0.7089065313,
-0.1357393116,
-0.145420298,
0.8035795093,
0.1882038862,
0.4468881786,
-0.0706235319,
-0.2814851105,
-0.4167967439,
-0.0536694229,
-1.3305165768,
-0.2792490125,
-0.0965050235,
-0.4270882905,
0.1887207925,
0.0580745302,
-0.6311534643,
-0.2329928875,
-0.3330086172,
0.4128175974,
-0.1748713106,
-0.1463903487,
-0.0442547537,
0.008123613,
0.5150796771,
0.5588552356,
-0.8297988176,
0.4168298244,
0.376812309,
1.1265981197,
0.0246764291,
-0.4262626767,
-0.8772792816,
-0.1194443107,
-0.6857922673,
0.9482138753,
-0.0801028162,
-0.1082788557,
-0.2508815825,
-0.0739513412,
-0.1717015505,
-0.7058012486,
0.1460110396,
-0.5894139409,
-0.2389378697,
-0.4016904831,
-0.1810189933,
0.0772752389,
0.1238174587,
-0.4445928335,
0.9447034597,
-0.0286329575,
-0.6328598261,
1.0414494276,
-0.4304681718,
-0.3732590973,
-0.1750446111,
0.0050166496,
-0.5186816454,
0.3419566154,
0.4796601236,
0.6591467857,
-0.3425453305,
-0.0447298884,
-0.375315547,
-0.5080956817,
-0.0947351977,
-0.0932066068,
0.393012464,
0.2787068486,
-0.4902638495,
0.1262971759,
-0.628927052,
0.1714636534,
0.2566154003,
-0.6050599217,
-0.3212842345,
-0.1211731657,
-0.3809156418,
0.0020080719,
0.1188081726,
-0.2898480296,
0.2683883607,
-0.4120216072,
0.2395578027,
0.8919893503,
0.0338676572,
0.3791546524,
-0.3111095726,
0.2302762121,
0.2743159533,
-0.3912485242,
-0.3047968149,
-0.3030815125,
-0.6779925823,
-0.6287403703,
0.4087219238,
0.4089517295,
-0.3536040187,
0.3385266066,
-0.563252449,
-0.4102930129,
-0.2153024971,
0.6318264008,
0.393009156,
0.0542983226,
0.3389275968,
-0.6530613899,
-0.4676383138,
-0.6225821376,
-0.5690424442,
-0.0706216395,
-0.3728581369,
0.172045663,
0.4921688735,
-0.0207192991,
0.8616264462,
-0.3127285242,
-0.0664134547,
-0.3736290932,
0.4945068955,
0.4880944788,
0.535282433,
0.1845733672,
-0.1726268977,
-0.437864989,
-0.0879244059,
-0.384629637,
-0.0542561486,
-0.0166275408,
-0.0918283537,
-0.1235058904,
0.4425873756,
-0.5510289073,
0.1506774127,
0.1566635072,
-0.0206467472,
0.4475148022,
-0.4336621165,
0.1716164201,
-1.2188444138,
-0.0925519988,
0.0869530067,
-0.2058127671,
-0.4086481631,
-0.1909027696,
0.0338329971,
-0.0364482738,
-0.5816791058,
0.5780054927,
-0.6911225319,
-0.4566488564,
-0.5987126231,
0.1700720638,
-0.426397115,
0.4599917531,
0.0577328168,
0.9339693189,
0.4610255063,
-0.8913069367,
-0.1948464066,
-0.069064483,
-0.5841269493,
0.2970782816,
-0.6911520958,
0.3189157248,
0.0726555139,
0.4009460509,
-0.8356254697,
-0.1099107787,
-0.1661806554,
-0.4115129709,
0.26665622,
-0.1076870933,
-0.6828284264,
-0.3087541461,
-0.357218504,
0.6452330351,
0.6335170269,
-0.7113322616,
0.5971686244,
0.044110138,
-0.2225982696,
-0.3473722637,
-0.5002533197,
-0.0939781666,
-0.3351067007,
-0.2408826351,
0.0085257189,
0.1649496108,
-0.071679309,
-0.3186193109,
0.1197251901,
0.041091226,
0.1902543604,
-0.0285053812,
-0.1759537011,
-0.2807497084,
-0.1657282412,
-0.1010427028,
-0.1812976152,
-0.2159450054,
-0.9146273732,
0.7999411821,
-0.2566543519,
-0.1120568886,
-0.6263529062,
-0.1728866845,
0.5009860396,
0.0755055696,
0.9805256128,
0.6153728366,
-0.564627707,
-0.0071871383,
-0.5921089053,
-0.02514988,
-0.3912640214,
0.6919274926,
-0.1859863997,
-0.5628939271,
0.6704558134,
-0.1337938309,
0.0358477868,
0.2925057411,
0.8931902647,
-0.151521787,
0.8669802547,
0.6244084239,
-0.2127669752,
0.7811453938,
-0.162390992,
0.0623016208,
-1.0171384811,
-0.0551634356,
-0.4993706644,
-0.1898010224,
-0.4931245744,
-0.7513386011,
0.1746010035,
0.6613574028,
-0.4044079781,
0.353407532,
0.0426569618,
0.6449648738,
0.6544225812,
0.2435032278,
0.1951799989,
0.1960643381,
-0.2655968666,
0.0839873329,
-0.9182911515,
-0.2388894111,
1.4086362123,
0.4229435325,
0.7472444773,
-0.1515421867,
0.7737941742,
0.1322115213,
0.3761379421,
-0.823616147,
0.5697517395,
0.0028921298,
-0.1859458238,
-0.3274670541,
-0.713552773,
-0.986585319,
0.3720422387,
-0.0140830046,
-0.6566249728,
0.0926600695,
0.3655384481,
-0.5358011127,
0.4574349225,
-0.4905820787,
0.6885511875,
-0.1632433236,
-0.3252598047,
-0.3908486366,
-0.3357823789,
0.2670521438,
-0.1695937663,
0.3345533609,
-0.2215430737,
-0.0559487455,
1.3441038132,
-0.4779809415,
0.7575070262,
-0.5362505913,
0.2045057565,
0.4831849039,
-0.1557022631,
0.8187425137,
-0.2659041882,
0.3202860057,
0.1361445338,
-0.3388703763,
-1.0246813297,
-0.299543649,
0.3985054791,
-0.7052138448,
-0.4779336751,
-0.4270186126,
-0.4283308089,
-0.2266470939,
0.4471201301,
0.0941309482,
0.2701919377,
0.0104161147,
0.2799164653,
0.8400982618,
-0.1288151294,
0.5259346366,
0.609580338,
-0.0736257881,
-0.6966902614,
0.810187757,
0.1248194128,
0.6447542906,
0.0908166319,
0.3501265645,
0.0012584302,
-1.2971208096,
-0.4444719851,
0.1679224223,
-0.6847509742,
-0.0455821976,
-0.7365860939,
0.2064691186,
-0.4546996951,
-0.1523616314,
-0.3094588518,
-0.2883130312,
-0.1167612448,
-0.0761386231,
-0.0117252711,
0.4855490029,
-0.0992333069,
0.8775311112,
-0.7576205134,
0.0138977664,
0.3279377818,
-0.0619566813,
0.2163378894,
-0.6993653774,
-0.5075499415,
-0.1088341847,
-0.2214908153,
-0.3692802489,
0.0447213352,
0.3149107397,
0.6073086858,
0.5113525391,
-0.598560214,
0.8111535907,
-0.429872483,
0.6019836664,
0.5523332357,
-0.688560307,
0.489030093,
-0.4660739899,
0.5836085677,
0.8568500876,
0.3500041366,
-0.2690894306,
-0.1410338134,
-0.3234547675,
-0.6986439824,
0.5960769057,
-0.0827707723,
0.1710956246,
-0.0610162467,
0.3561937511,
-0.1796860248,
0.2180259079,
-1.0992904902,
0.3715848327,
0.1650884449,
-0.2351290584,
-0.0295741558,
-0.0843666419,
-0.0064857644,
-0.2473613918,
0.6360917091,
-0.4645315707,
0.3062482178,
-0.1242699921,
-0.3145031631,
-0.0656985939,
0.1362956315,
0.4447834194,
0.7147529125,
-0.0591145381,
-0.0605765171,
0.6340596676,
-0.5547370911,
0.248130098,
0.1238299236,
0.0892066658,
-0.5364490747,
0.6274798512,
0.7863711119,
0.4872462153,
-0.5720860362,
0.6983454823,
-0.067897886,
-0.1679935604,
0.2388655543,
-0.0537795797,
0.0843119398,
0.3310049176,
0.5728936791,
-0.1051833406,
-0.3277599216,
-0.7565529943,
0.3630342782,
0.6962854862,
-0.1883190572,
-0.3219303489,
0.5219473243,
0.1001823545,
0.1962498426,
0.7954673767,
-0.3065449893,
-0.5801738501,
0.4948296547,
0.4762179852,
0.8763467669,
-0.0625959337,
-0.2374557853,
0.5086337328,
0.5279550552,
-0.2625446916,
-0.0030542002,
-0.2823147774,
-0.7473376393,
-0.3700811267,
-1.0877914429,
-0.0684296265,
-0.2996974885,
-0.5510261655,
0.3966811597,
-0.8529291153,
0.0263068359,
-0.5058492422,
0.2186571956,
-0.8381294608,
0.3395334482,
0.1131512299,
0.9742041826,
-0.8550565839,
0.9980678558,
0.2000709474,
-0.2163076103,
-0.920753479,
0.1989273578,
-0.2701843381,
-0.9986006021,
0.55157727,
0.2989969552,
-0.1195906028,
0.2371586859,
-0.1970703304,
-0.8592160344,
1.3385962248,
0.1281817555,
-0.9844199419,
-0.4434536994,
-0.0608489215,
0.2359799147,
-0.5958260298,
0.4372714162,
0.8742331266,
0.1644926816,
0.3907268047,
-0.7706865072,
0.0797652155,
0.1509803683,
-0.0390389711,
0.4484801292,
-0.5736325383,
0.7672370076,
-0.590123415,
-0.2326151431,
0.3111064136,
0.8955802321,
0.604219377,
0.3269443214,
0.6861529946,
1.0130819082,
0.8464874029,
-0.2020098567,
0.9691374898,
-0.1980523318,
0.3049329519,
1.0737421513,
-0.0544918366,
0.7514212728,
0.4628158212,
-0.4472551942,
0.3975791633,
1.0042399168,
0.1778897792,
0.6728614569,
0.3987685144,
0.0079684593,
-0.1716124862,
0.2452127039,
-0.4338455796,
-0.1503958702,
0.1997454762,
-0.3199853897,
-0.30668661,
0.2443819046,
0.2806264758,
-0.3658119142,
-0.7464449406,
0.9137724042,
0.2144022137,
-0.3401952386,
0.5211876035,
-0.0851800814,
0.7624140382,
-0.7777560353,
0.330562681,
-0.2680779696,
0.1554463208,
-0.0618752763,
-0.1381947994,
-0.1823527515,
0.0005767941,
-0.0778263882,
0.0138079245,
0.3111715019,
-0.2063193917,
-0.503158927,
0.2808510065,
0.4214612842,
0.1070521399,
-0.0896360129,
-0.6365782619,
-0.0752979591,
-0.3886502385,
-0.4296629429,
0.5731729865,
0.2985758781,
-0.0985568464,
0.3550030589,
0.7947071195,
0.3985785544,
0.5097311735,
-0.1277844161,
0.9429678917,
-0.6945339441,
-0.6392891407,
-0.742067337,
0.3070783019,
0.2262462527,
-0.316265434,
0.707369566,
0.6472964883,
0.8626019359,
0.3092752099,
0.3822275102,
-0.0213348027,
0.4258569479,
-1.0194567442,
0.4172869921,
-0.4733194709,
0.2818496227,
-0.190321818,
-1.3740165234,
-0.0353025384,
0.3259317875,
-0.6258915663,
0.4251098037,
0.8665720224,
0.60663867,
-0.1360645592,
-0.3568866551,
0.1856550276,
0.2159726322,
0.5106623173,
0.7471383214,
0.8134579062,
-0.208182469,
0.2820627689,
0.1753887832,
-0.5224884152,
-0.0886661187,
-0.9833257794,
-0.8133438826,
0.0369602069,
-0.0689378679,
-0.5238582492,
0.0350037143,
1.0522502661,
0.9044390917,
-0.8821161985,
-0.1745482385,
-0.41561836,
-0.2289087176,
-0.2139976025,
-0.0798493326,
0.3937996626,
-0.6183878183,
-0.7691479325,
0.4610222876,
0.0845411643,
0.3043306172,
-0.0542870238,
-0.2962350547,
-0.1735786945,
0.3664260209,
0.2343420088,
0.33267048,
-0.3703784049,
-0.0815683156,
-0.5045591593,
-0.0589683428,
0.1582881063,
1.3365534544,
-0.7695288658,
0.3174329996,
0.2607715726,
0.766292572,
0.8137897849,
0.0978485644,
0.4917108715,
-0.4909761846,
0.4847489297,
0.0535415411,
0.4247651398,
0.1924761683,
-0.0079801278,
0.148001954,
0.4343274534,
-0.3374934196,
-0.9442160726,
-0.0284830164,
-0.6990231872,
-0.1326267719,
0.7203141451,
-0.4098808467,
-0.2864011228,
0.3900893033,
0.3243145645,
0.1444027722,
-0.1378230602,
0.5211385489,
0.8490893841,
-0.0923051387,
0.1843947917,
-0.4743880033,
0.3401208818,
0.7446026206,
-1.0136269331,
0.1377970874,
0.1854685992,
0.5214236975,
-0.032680694,
0.8670620322,
-0.1987922341,
0.4515319765,
0.0641574413,
-0.1796662211,
0.0581261255,
-0.7122452855,
-0.4990277588,
0.023449786,
0.3803229034,
-0.2001473755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03208v1 | NLU on Data Diets: Dynamic Data Subset Selection for NLP Classification Tasks | 2023-06-05T19:30:41 | 2023-06-05T19:30:41 | Jean-Michel Attendu, Jean-Philippe Corbeil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Finetuning large language models inflates the costs of NLU applications and
remains the bottleneck of development cycles. Recent works in computer vision
use data pruning to reduce training time. Pruned data selection with static
methods is based on a score calculated for each training example prior to
finetuning, which involves important computational overhead. Moreover, the
score may not necessarily be representative of sample importance throughout the
entire training duration. We propose to address these issues with a refined
version of dynamic data pruning, a curriculum which periodically scores and
discards unimportant examples during finetuning. Our method leverages an EL2N
metric that we extend to the joint intent and slot classification task, and an
initial finetuning phase on the full train set. Our results on the GLUE
benchmark and four joint NLU datasets show a better time-accuracy trade-off
compared to static methods. Our method preserves full accuracy while training
on 50% of the data points and reduces computational times by up to 41%. If we
tolerate instead a minor drop of accuracy of 1%, we can prune 80% of the
training examples for a reduction in finetuning time reaching 66%. | [
-0.3942840397,
-0.898378551,
0.1076407656,
0.0384760648,
-0.3871887028,
-0.0623030216,
-0.5120862126,
-0.4196667373,
0.1856171936,
0.3337142467,
-0.6908156872,
-0.3025667667,
-0.2837560177,
0.1867814511,
-0.5514034629,
0.9337260127,
0.0992259458,
-0.357898891,
-0.3464363813,
-0.2419973761,
-0.6402382255,
-0.2271914035,
-0.904994607,
-0.1790292859,
0.6471560001,
0.4858269095,
0.7451184392,
0.993596077,
0.6873959303,
0.217231825,
-0.2524084449,
0.4105574489,
-0.6799451113,
0.1233585477,
0.0877300128,
-0.8686283827,
-0.1624593288,
0.1750959307,
0.5557152629,
0.8868837357,
-0.3559187949,
0.3297431767,
0.2282496691,
0.8816202283,
-0.5475286245,
0.2429323941,
-0.7337353826,
0.4467436969,
-0.4412286878,
-0.1660519093,
-0.3972541094,
-0.4041757286,
0.280533433,
-0.8131123781,
0.4086880982,
-0.1351935416,
1.0522036552,
0.8004435897,
-0.2174625397,
0.1031851619,
-0.7849363685,
1.088138938,
-0.3847598433,
0.3538027406,
0.3977723718,
0.2724460065,
0.0168626849,
-0.7401354313,
-0.3492363095,
-0.2593026459,
0.1009214967,
0.2382310927,
0.1164545193,
0.0854155645,
0.49544245,
0.4734498262,
-0.554870069,
0.200622797,
-0.574898839,
0.0730226636,
0.7907267809,
0.1625571251,
-0.0089885397,
0.0629034638,
-0.1777293831,
-0.4061032236,
-0.697357893,
-0.1614788175,
0.3457603455,
0.2032047063,
0.1734184027,
0.5259367824,
-0.0294489227,
0.9405131936,
0.0880108774,
-0.2365072072,
0.2453144789,
-0.1384894103,
-0.2665500939,
-0.0003490688,
0.482961446,
0.6803875566,
0.3228023648,
-0.0452498123,
0.0406093076,
0.3494154215,
0.4920180142,
-0.5117094517,
-0.6137590408,
0.1892177761,
-0.3645217419,
-0.4067766368,
-0.0474383049,
-0.6465367079,
-0.1498622298,
-0.8699225783,
-0.1429724693,
-0.3767383397,
-0.078781046,
0.1171908528,
-0.0976078883,
0.097407423,
0.6534671187,
-0.5687490702,
0.3859171867,
0.7040584087,
0.7459207177,
-0.5293929577,
-0.150809139,
-0.5737926364,
-0.0677667707,
-0.4044218063,
0.4346421361,
-0.4354420602,
-0.1169904545,
-0.2383219153,
-0.007848355,
-0.1000735089,
-0.827809155,
0.5565053821,
-0.2135978043,
0.0112180747,
-0.0162940249,
-0.5578059554,
-0.3613980412,
0.1741410196,
-0.7772282958,
1.126111865,
0.1757030338,
-0.57994771,
0.6298894882,
-0.2516101599,
-0.5843123198,
0.2069972754,
-0.1514325142,
-0.5545445681,
0.1940478534,
0.000167635,
0.5885382295,
-0.0895367339,
0.6383475661,
-0.2552343011,
-0.4848572016,
-0.0544144362,
-0.581882894,
0.5406112671,
0.3175316155,
-0.2806929052,
-0.0505866781,
-0.8953053951,
-0.051337529,
0.1741806269,
-0.6573260427,
-0.4840577543,
0.2759144902,
0.1512492895,
-0.0256021786,
-0.1892769039,
-0.3331717849,
0.4173056483,
-0.6280704737,
0.4407902062,
0.6787502766,
-0.2348564118,
0.3928572536,
-0.4759896994,
0.3160321712,
-0.3704082072,
0.1142522618,
0.339697659,
-0.4792760015,
-1.0534238815,
-0.00965966,
0.527718544,
0.7876372933,
-0.8194012046,
0.7165436149,
-0.2566733062,
-0.4681012928,
-0.4865148067,
0.1614157557,
0.1382695287,
0.3109103739,
0.4798694253,
-0.490100354,
-0.4090757668,
-0.7600357533,
0.0071757068,
0.1344394386,
-0.3318064213,
0.2839463055,
0.1133905053,
0.1155375093,
0.9542794228,
-0.6442475319,
-0.581929028,
-0.3219008148,
0.1772774756,
0.2515934408,
0.6355196238,
0.7349927425,
-0.9635544419,
-0.4125793278,
-0.2018507421,
-0.6741333008,
0.1231425181,
-0.5775545835,
0.2060563266,
-0.0227218643,
0.412109524,
-0.4940770268,
0.6633500457,
0.4633895159,
0.044849664,
0.4321689606,
-0.0368249714,
-0.334759444,
-0.6367928386,
0.009237906,
0.2285422534,
-0.2898698151,
-0.5009713173,
0.0920133293,
-0.1913647205,
-0.1874589473,
-0.6308717728,
0.3576832414,
-0.396597445,
0.1705497801,
-0.0680260286,
0.0073478366,
0.1062341258,
0.4742213786,
0.1471868455,
0.412327826,
0.3517065942,
-0.9514769316,
0.4346742332,
0.37725088,
-0.7075923681,
0.109454073,
-0.5031782389,
0.0817237571,
-0.0205751415,
0.23130624,
-0.4122718871,
-0.071635589,
0.0488395095,
-0.0980637893,
0.6127450466,
-0.1013097316,
-0.4296183884,
-0.4941399395,
-0.2736215889,
0.240756914,
0.3760841191,
-0.3849085867,
0.4042820334,
0.4920477867,
-0.0045814975,
-0.4200455248,
-0.9120332599,
-0.1522496194,
-0.4360298216,
-0.3497743309,
0.5589116812,
-0.03094602,
-0.1075029597,
-0.0440305471,
-0.4111222923,
-0.0759598762,
0.4350346327,
0.0576891378,
0.2140105218,
-0.0208239388,
0.0018907599,
-0.0092812693,
-0.1761773229,
-0.1243093386,
-0.1372388601,
0.4531357288,
0.2287393361,
-0.1689507365,
-0.8096534014,
0.0769447908,
0.3796950579,
-0.2462584376,
0.6521689892,
0.8186720014,
-0.2701899409,
-0.3716464341,
-0.4943767488,
-0.3362522423,
-0.4875582159,
0.370295465,
-0.1713946164,
-0.6536872387,
0.1802871525,
-0.1873354912,
0.5819554925,
0.3212771714,
0.1697161496,
-0.3172608614,
0.6838902831,
0.5094974041,
0.0271368101,
0.8340461254,
-0.6270526648,
0.162936911,
-0.8073697686,
-0.0030142078,
-0.1971837729,
-0.8406937718,
-0.4161157608,
-0.4299440682,
0.2008899748,
0.0926422998,
0.2111171186,
0.2749475539,
-0.8568993807,
0.6153458953,
0.5838533044,
0.3339267671,
-0.1275041997,
0.1007282063,
0.1427491009,
-0.1774608195,
-0.9151378274,
-0.1460613459,
1.10163486,
0.336479634,
0.6169101596,
-0.2123856395,
0.427474767,
0.0389125235,
0.1579829007,
-1.1425454617,
0.7170467973,
-0.691293776,
-0.3399873972,
-0.3237864971,
-0.6661880612,
-0.9945449233,
-0.0044045849,
-0.4499005675,
-0.5575965047,
0.2600387931,
0.4248889983,
-0.5735737681,
0.3962628543,
-0.733158648,
0.6314447522,
-0.1664199829,
-0.4177979529,
-0.2823202908,
-0.7259500027,
0.2805877924,
-0.1503952891,
-0.1072619483,
-0.5276484489,
0.323510766,
1.1306279898,
-0.4538123012,
0.85004884,
-0.2778787017,
0.2581153214,
0.3506795764,
0.1895339936,
0.4966442287,
0.044262141,
-0.1781256795,
0.1362543702,
-0.1387312412,
-0.103696987,
-0.4817343354,
0.6081579924,
-0.4500593543,
-0.3516585827,
-0.2843982577,
-0.5784620047,
-0.0744297206,
-0.0975156501,
0.0393565297,
0.607901454,
0.1499025226,
0.724321723,
0.6211825609,
-0.2897720933,
0.3027123809,
0.0994262993,
0.2311175317,
-0.1532784253,
1.0348314047,
0.3659333289,
0.1944250911,
0.4129537642,
0.3399621248,
-0.0953664929,
-0.8511878848,
-0.1322622895,
0.0861254483,
-0.4402275085,
-0.4445176423,
-0.3509425819,
-0.1457818747,
0.0952305049,
-0.3461679816,
-0.6246598959,
-0.5859470963,
-0.4453772008,
-0.0175284054,
0.3836885095,
0.2267266214,
0.1698401719,
0.368088305,
-0.7589234114,
0.4369615614,
0.1447675228,
0.2525446117,
-0.0755575299,
-0.2275740206,
-0.064732179,
-0.0511749759,
-0.3169822991,
-0.3462559283,
0.4506544769,
0.6163020134,
0.5182108879,
0.4241794944,
0.3526849747,
0.8804495931,
-0.5664768815,
0.6783898473,
0.2712825239,
-0.497664243,
0.7422050238,
-0.0754681751,
0.4052976966,
1.0070431232,
0.3881715238,
-0.409555614,
-0.5388580561,
-0.6190790534,
-1.1948276758,
0.7264971733,
0.2330578864,
-0.0779746622,
0.0870316625,
0.6043395996,
0.1084874272,
0.0978215337,
-0.4478624463,
-0.4315437973,
0.045397263,
-0.4485809505,
-0.0027383007,
0.0152325248,
-0.1246734336,
-0.7364035249,
0.3915517032,
-0.1825492233,
0.2344176918,
0.0480797403,
-0.1046143472,
0.1227392927,
-0.2353719771,
0.3150396347,
0.7064507604,
-0.3157431185,
-0.1899442524,
0.319321543,
-0.8938394785,
-0.1366959512,
-0.0171109252,
-0.4116509557,
0.1609826684,
0.2465394437,
0.9304684997,
0.1848287135,
-0.5059407949,
0.3006056249,
-0.288623482,
-0.4407505393,
-0.2882165909,
0.3481857479,
-0.4073988199,
-0.1363116056,
0.1795525104,
0.394133538,
0.1039313525,
-0.2675659955,
0.4445440471,
0.0722495019,
-0.264824003,
-0.1733508557,
0.4984100759,
0.2765834928,
-0.0563063957,
0.9450750351,
-0.2284063995,
-0.2265571505,
0.8121929765,
0.2462281138,
0.539214313,
-0.2419224083,
0.0364390016,
0.5216442943,
0.1087557971,
-0.3381251395,
0.0876748115,
0.0465707928,
-0.6777080297,
-0.6452696919,
-0.9378657341,
-0.4151045978,
0.4773698151,
-0.8716821671,
0.5767006874,
-0.5416083336,
-0.2148811966,
0.1313276142,
0.1874496639,
-0.7794687152,
0.3827720284,
0.2202805877,
0.9268763661,
-0.7641384602,
0.9673057199,
0.6631402373,
0.0074040564,
-0.8870062232,
-0.2160245031,
0.2992791533,
-0.4158217013,
0.439090699,
0.3506090343,
0.2622876465,
0.1409787238,
-0.3587675393,
-0.7155951858,
0.9467118979,
0.344476819,
-1.0642457008,
-0.27715379,
-0.1056193635,
0.2024457157,
0.0630588531,
-0.1143166944,
0.757727325,
0.417778343,
0.2135470808,
-0.912524879,
-0.2098837644,
-0.1591913849,
-0.2077250481,
0.4186279774,
-0.5701332092,
0.5506073236,
0.0744174048,
-0.3959282041,
-0.1941435486,
0.5776777864,
0.0906886086,
0.2396989018,
0.8210678697,
0.6841165423,
0.9514944553,
-0.53411901,
0.8251146674,
-0.0588559434,
0.4627533555,
1.076335907,
-0.1369137019,
0.7829959989,
0.3791126311,
-0.4624302685,
0.0375511646,
0.7418572307,
-0.4746871293,
0.6930311322,
0.4577585161,
0.1132482439,
-0.08893691,
-0.0807761252,
-0.0980058834,
0.6160583496,
0.6123514771,
0.12988469,
-0.067583099,
0.3092172146,
-0.0127434842,
-0.1272518635,
-0.27858603,
0.795855701,
0.2205853164,
-0.5279497504,
0.8636491895,
-0.3231183887,
0.8334124088,
-0.5126349926,
0.0669600517,
-0.1475612819,
0.3981151581,
-0.3033003509,
-0.8591602445,
0.7993552685,
-0.2139924318,
0.1053040773,
-0.5104446411,
0.5394521356,
-0.4621988833,
-0.4276821911,
-0.0480278954,
0.1399496645,
0.2730398476,
0.0274686273,
-0.8279662132,
0.1174485981,
0.1449136138,
-0.2841098309,
0.282541126,
0.2428265959,
-0.0216655172,
0.7344387174,
0.8001722693,
0.2388479263,
-0.0076999222,
0.1114034802,
0.9744374156,
-0.4073701799,
-0.3853686452,
-0.5920783877,
0.3724358976,
-0.1471580863,
-0.353081435,
0.4422634244,
0.6383875608,
1.0902489424,
0.0065394826,
0.3988893926,
-0.0964234024,
0.447876215,
-0.7169167399,
0.6649843454,
-0.7252703309,
0.1856216043,
-0.0280464441,
-1.1013000011,
-0.6918059587,
0.9131680131,
-0.3389210701,
-0.4288710952,
0.8157500029,
0.3459610343,
-0.2033510953,
-0.0348931737,
0.1275994778,
-0.1491902173,
0.1579190344,
0.5279706717,
0.6041583419,
-0.294647783,
0.3861392736,
-0.6648725271,
-0.092682831,
-0.2723571658,
-0.7486714721,
-0.7321127653,
-0.3786977828,
-0.7956962585,
-0.0313936882,
-0.0379486643,
0.7240872979,
0.9199880362,
-0.7528658509,
-0.1266013384,
-0.2188254744,
-0.0716353804,
-0.5964761376,
-0.2985417545,
0.44470945,
-0.2303386182,
-0.6681618094,
0.5323565006,
0.0608619712,
0.0357682109,
0.0873893052,
0.2330499291,
-0.282120049,
-0.3271094263,
0.4929423034,
0.2548713684,
-0.566165626,
-0.1559242606,
-0.1893107146,
0.3194065988,
0.1743880659,
0.5423785448,
-0.8594587445,
0.2189429849,
0.3404124677,
0.802054882,
0.6621259451,
0.071253486,
0.4361953139,
-1.0594899654,
0.5284740329,
0.5916609764,
0.2424841672,
0.2030668706,
-0.3772471249,
0.7075026035,
0.3436499834,
-0.5382328629,
-0.9370830655,
0.0896319076,
-1.2655816078,
-0.190156132,
1.0493881702,
-0.1147614717,
-0.4780296385,
-0.1387165636,
-0.0983778536,
0.2860527337,
-0.1966355592,
0.6100283861,
0.3894509077,
-0.0183212142,
-0.197787568,
-0.971816659,
0.7785722017,
0.4911428094,
-0.6843374372,
0.1662270129,
0.3586012125,
0.1104359031,
0.2869149446,
0.157986328,
0.2806310654,
0.1392135322,
-0.1532033086,
-0.1033431068,
-0.0464960262,
-0.7462444901,
-0.0307300873,
0.1439137161,
-0.1442909688,
-0.2939343452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03203v1 | A Static Evaluation of Code Completion by Large Language Models | 2023-06-05T19:23:34 | 2023-06-05T19:23:34 | Hantian Ding, Varun Kumar, Yuchen Tian, Zijian Wang, Rob Kwiatkowski, Xiaopeng Li, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Baishakhi Ray, Parminder Bhatia, Sudipta Sengupta, Dan Roth, Bing Xiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Large language models trained on code have shown great potential to increase
productivity of software developers. Several execution-based benchmarks have
been proposed to evaluate functional correctness of model-generated code on
simple programming problems. Nevertheless, it is expensive to perform the same
evaluation on complex real-world projects considering the execution cost. On
the contrary, static analysis tools such as linters, which can detect errors
without running the program, haven't been well explored for evaluating code
generation models. In this work, we propose a static evaluation framework to
quantify static errors in Python code completions, by leveraging Abstract
Syntax Trees. Compared with execution-based evaluation, our method is not only
more efficient, but also applicable to code in the wild. For experiments, we
collect code context from open source repos to generate one million function
bodies using public models. Our static analysis reveals that Undefined Name and
Unused Variable are the most common errors among others made by language
models. Through extensive studies, we also show the impact of sampling
temperature, model size, and context on static errors in code completions. | [
-0.046088241,
-0.2591943443,
0.5027881265,
0.2553735077,
-0.1870694458,
-0.029289918,
-0.6190642715,
-0.3866818249,
-0.1808288544,
0.2284617871,
-0.1703630537,
-0.3969678581,
-0.2650384009,
0.2869693339,
-0.5640177131,
0.9820008278,
-0.1515271664,
-0.2302041054,
-0.5787627101,
-0.2128070742,
-0.2903442681,
-0.2176692486,
0.192933172,
-0.0496703126,
0.123442851,
0.0030180428,
0.517408371,
0.4164031148,
0.3010931909,
0.3586416841,
-0.1904440522,
0.1480512619,
-0.5510309935,
-0.1171379387,
0.0460214838,
-0.1166599914,
-0.3267336786,
-0.3811066449,
0.44854635,
0.6586292982,
-0.142732814,
0.6156467199,
-0.0117951985,
0.5645611286,
-0.8412236571,
0.3402735293,
-0.6111642122,
0.0018565417,
0.0518240035,
-0.1125407219,
-0.2080003619,
-0.7516389489,
0.1573782563,
-0.166279912,
0.0433142819,
-0.5435392857,
0.7552838922,
0.4448620677,
-0.1927926838,
-0.1255836934,
-0.5379209518,
0.6830852628,
-0.9744433165,
-0.0145421522,
0.1194393635,
0.0622350834,
-0.1204140261,
-0.5418242812,
-0.2925154865,
-0.4796095788,
-0.261118412,
-0.2920226455,
-0.1658886969,
0.271088928,
0.5123325586,
0.3660892546,
-0.2625720203,
-0.5169094205,
-0.6105894446,
0.0219708979,
0.5201143622,
0.0779713318,
0.6754319668,
-0.1912811548,
0.2252027243,
0.207355544,
-0.4211612642,
0.1484739631,
0.2540214956,
0.0673765987,
-0.2910096943,
0.6120678186,
-0.3814887404,
1.1447199583,
-0.5810669065,
0.0643190593,
0.2940657437,
-0.389686048,
-0.2804094553,
-0.4010665417,
0.4467535615,
0.4155637324,
0.7401334643,
-0.3534777462,
-0.3777827024,
0.0638249442,
0.3564331532,
-0.9224053621,
-0.3169546127,
0.5374594927,
-0.3362497389,
-0.5096083879,
0.157448411,
-0.5453287959,
-0.4074852467,
-0.2639110982,
-0.1173008308,
-0.3927102387,
-0.3784545958,
0.1009721309,
-0.1687941104,
-0.0939638391,
0.3329144716,
-0.4955350459,
0.1034854576,
0.7677097321,
0.9184744954,
0.3220955431,
-0.371091336,
-0.514436841,
-0.2369193584,
-0.6781302691,
0.5121586919,
-0.4426484406,
0.004942643,
-0.0671784207,
-0.2404019535,
0.0233943127,
-0.3588604927,
0.0863538831,
-0.2623038888,
-0.4460877776,
-0.0306166578,
-0.3030230403,
-0.3844744563,
0.0806176588,
-0.405056119,
0.8846805692,
0.4512897432,
-0.8074285388,
0.2386403978,
-0.496696651,
-0.2482548505,
0.3260941207,
-0.1828312129,
-0.3062012792,
0.5865547061,
-0.2416104525,
0.337623626,
-0.3385134935,
0.5590313673,
-0.273975879,
-0.6233701706,
0.3994410932,
-0.0981250927,
0.5996336341,
0.2025310397,
-0.5782014132,
0.2391295731,
-0.9319161177,
0.5199153423,
-0.1214691177,
-0.5744282603,
-0.4571784139,
0.2665204406,
0.2048452199,
-0.0641007125,
0.2282170951,
-0.3644902706,
0.1445127279,
-0.1864681095,
0.4230307639,
0.5415093899,
-0.134905979,
-0.0441718251,
-0.1578214616,
0.5097403526,
-0.575350821,
-0.2934800088,
-0.4218045175,
-0.3537394106,
-0.6241552234,
-0.2716614306,
0.5390182137,
0.2125838697,
-0.135219872,
0.6197251678,
-0.3915188015,
-0.4812212586,
0.0656946898,
0.1353604347,
0.6886107922,
0.0698086098,
-0.0414158143,
-0.0440380797,
-0.6091694236,
-0.4761559665,
-0.1540368497,
-0.101398319,
-0.1282758564,
0.4524582922,
0.5741890073,
-0.4446164668,
1.1021230221,
-0.4640083909,
0.4130617082,
0.0255266,
0.2975698113,
0.2275085747,
0.4993689656,
0.5222635865,
-0.3359789848,
-0.383251071,
0.2491809577,
-0.8243149519,
-0.4187052548,
-0.0005739533,
0.4035613835,
0.3012661338,
0.3420588374,
-0.3378923237,
0.293217808,
0.769017458,
-0.1610782892,
0.6952174902,
-0.4038355649,
0.0100918589,
-0.3062648177,
0.6155225039,
-0.1269065738,
-0.2727209628,
-0.4261604548,
0.5016538501,
0.2737172544,
-0.4434032738,
-0.3565996289,
0.2868203819,
-0.56460917,
-0.2971316278,
0.0042303596,
-0.2430320531,
-0.34029603,
0.3823516965,
0.0554671213,
0.919308722,
0.4810782671,
-0.4334770739,
0.1076616868,
-0.4521374702,
-0.665002346,
-0.1725206077,
-0.8517426252,
0.2152988017,
-0.1628219485,
0.1865115911,
-0.9493170381,
-0.5293269753,
-0.1654077619,
-0.197318539,
-0.0161300451,
-0.4726193249,
-0.3342605233,
-0.4500226974,
-0.2891343534,
0.4411623776,
0.5995357633,
-0.454497695,
0.2246887088,
0.0504931323,
0.1015004441,
-0.7851086855,
-0.4652990103,
-0.1488309652,
0.0478078164,
-0.5757355094,
-0.2936929762,
0.1136796102,
-0.3074300289,
0.1432441324,
-0.3964164257,
-0.0942060426,
0.4758306742,
0.2203385383,
0.0232575741,
-0.3022412658,
0.043799825,
-0.3222055137,
0.0195215773,
0.0450201742,
-0.2868480384,
0.5748028159,
-0.6142597198,
-0.2410367429,
-0.2489104718,
-0.1674464792,
1.0146563053,
-0.3496453166,
0.4213321507,
-0.1458806843,
-0.5477559566,
-0.355009377,
-0.4030939043,
0.3044222295,
-0.355630517,
0.6325188279,
-0.1576611549,
-0.1999932528,
0.4243925214,
-0.0374225341,
0.1500894129,
0.1707179844,
0.2194123566,
0.3208470345,
0.6909002662,
0.4147168696,
0.0386108793,
0.2552348077,
-0.4354371428,
0.1195387915,
-0.3674820662,
0.1655261517,
-0.5636941195,
0.0751943067,
-0.3553948998,
-0.6357269287,
0.145871982,
0.4081950784,
-0.2451202422,
0.4734120369,
-0.7042979002,
0.946300447,
0.2432721406,
-0.1530606449,
0.2259931266,
0.0123013994,
-0.0622323975,
0.3215684295,
-0.3166234791,
-0.6660247445,
1.1765525341,
0.3631249666,
0.546053648,
-0.0885892808,
0.7244543433,
0.1552976519,
0.5447397232,
-0.6950153708,
0.2645186782,
-0.0888360068,
-0.3399432302,
-0.2498232424,
-0.6935101151,
-0.4407060742,
0.3100884259,
0.1399958879,
-1.0130199194,
-0.0464675575,
0.1756985784,
-0.7070994973,
0.2214626074,
-0.770108819,
1.0349909067,
-0.1218515784,
-0.278146714,
-0.1302706301,
-0.1531886905,
0.6768900156,
-0.2119131237,
0.1649392843,
-0.1711947024,
0.0074707759,
0.5015077591,
-0.7832912803,
0.6317577958,
-0.1864796281,
-0.2045293599,
0.4308814406,
0.2454044074,
0.4459081292,
0.0516338795,
-0.1549203098,
0.2607570887,
0.2533812225,
-0.0990435109,
-0.4830168486,
0.5295950174,
-0.7215488553,
-0.1673897803,
-0.4159770608,
-0.5400657058,
0.1697473526,
0.1807582527,
0.1089783013,
0.8007090092,
-0.1398260444,
0.2728095353,
0.1760398895,
-0.4758346677,
0.4352754653,
0.504755795,
-0.3772856593,
-0.1499000341,
1.014554143,
0.0976370052,
0.1845495403,
-0.1398875564,
0.1997346729,
0.1143977419,
-0.5467711091,
-0.5550007224,
0.0689093769,
-0.6077873111,
-0.4294581115,
-0.8386582136,
-0.0979799926,
0.041249264,
-0.2556843162,
-0.4397275746,
-0.3042944372,
0.0912882835,
0.1274605989,
0.3338914216,
0.8125200868,
0.1326008439,
0.0849902481,
-0.8315686584,
0.1632351875,
0.12658225,
0.5817784071,
0.3109384477,
0.2106514424,
-0.1447514147,
0.1405429691,
-0.1243286431,
-0.5864432454,
0.2466057837,
-0.003532296,
0.1680084914,
0.214448303,
0.1604503244,
0.5810379386,
-0.4174234569,
0.6910739541,
0.1328838617,
-1.2901669741,
0.3894605041,
-0.4934524894,
0.2896992862,
0.614172101,
-0.1983743608,
-0.6195450425,
-0.5129274726,
-0.5612719655,
-0.8470293283,
0.9424328208,
0.2595559955,
0.2049859315,
-0.0176809672,
0.1851618439,
-0.3024916351,
0.2432053834,
-0.9531701803,
-0.073096104,
0.0177439637,
-0.0650782213,
0.0145489601,
-0.1014079824,
-0.1771994531,
-0.2337251753,
0.3697009385,
-0.2464960217,
0.137055397,
-0.1656217426,
-0.3233718574,
-0.4223911166,
0.2503513694,
0.7742791772,
1.0854079723,
-0.7057713866,
0.0050209146,
0.1398157626,
-0.0813771561,
0.0061340765,
-0.124979198,
-0.1917213351,
0.2184279859,
0.3471406996,
0.3394457102,
0.1428416222,
-1.1164016724,
0.8027017713,
-0.0244379099,
0.3010472953,
-0.3991118073,
0.0388602763,
0.0878887326,
-0.1122272015,
0.2806700468,
0.5079407096,
0.1414627731,
-0.5199754834,
0.368264854,
0.3951095939,
-0.2211222798,
-0.3072814047,
0.3220286965,
0.3965760469,
-0.1087014005,
0.4316169918,
-0.2295964211,
-0.67226547,
1.1928758621,
0.4336690605,
1.0650712252,
0.2464515716,
0.1792080998,
0.4616383612,
0.1887364239,
-0.2101023346,
0.2459944338,
-0.234047547,
-0.2202356905,
-0.6315391064,
-0.8118656278,
-0.3157030642,
0.1446957737,
-0.1998577714,
0.4954659641,
-0.5821253657,
0.2064512521,
-0.2199747115,
-0.260892272,
-0.2119854391,
0.0604493693,
0.3167618513,
0.7807021141,
-0.815384388,
0.7938606143,
0.7366042137,
-0.3254711628,
-0.8471053243,
0.2706772983,
-0.1548960954,
-0.2361384183,
0.8083825707,
0.5540147424,
-0.1792155355,
-0.2513931096,
-0.2573471367,
-0.9491084218,
0.596100688,
0.4214295745,
-0.4127950072,
-0.034803234,
-0.1471861601,
0.7429656982,
-0.1300567836,
0.792221725,
0.4954069853,
0.3456026316,
-0.1131195277,
-0.9169341922,
0.1603031009,
-0.3935184181,
0.3245180249,
0.3392628133,
-0.2496482432,
1.0968344212,
-0.3205999434,
-0.3337118924,
0.4765883982,
0.2878008485,
0.387060225,
-0.0290286969,
0.4076821506,
0.2038982809,
0.8567284346,
0.0532158017,
1.3587034941,
-0.7025948167,
0.8673115969,
0.895862937,
-0.0875224918,
0.7306856513,
0.0630557463,
-0.3721445501,
0.2794721127,
0.3060029447,
-0.0509292074,
0.3604679108,
0.9013394713,
-0.0905211419,
0.0134266401,
0.1346617937,
-0.6684626341,
0.1619522572,
0.253623426,
-0.1394626796,
-0.5190476179,
-0.3883050382,
0.0315981358,
0.0764141679,
-0.0593465865,
0.3772839308,
-0.1302930713,
-0.9124035835,
1.2902240753,
0.1335024238,
0.7925761938,
-0.5217493773,
-0.0242252406,
-0.3092251122,
0.5165090561,
-0.5363914967,
-0.385296315,
0.540953517,
0.4077282548,
-0.0310896225,
0.1380192488,
0.2767781913,
-0.263951838,
-0.5199338794,
0.3215278387,
0.0341779292,
0.2439400107,
-0.175922811,
-0.2826437354,
0.0836718827,
0.0948335007,
-0.0567392297,
0.0026919201,
0.3012978733,
-0.0315718465,
0.4686349928,
0.4208512008,
-0.0070750578,
-0.0007226508,
-0.2860586345,
0.7612661123,
-0.4065946341,
-0.342821002,
-0.8509336114,
0.6839435697,
0.0168677885,
-0.2863574326,
0.4817201793,
0.6535426974,
0.7341014743,
-0.4442211688,
0.8828427792,
-0.5177811384,
0.1983360946,
-0.3503612876,
0.8845729828,
-0.5650070906,
0.4505810738,
-0.6491350532,
-1.1044434309,
-0.2406103909,
0.6942561865,
-0.1921780556,
-0.1888334602,
0.708303988,
0.8164870739,
-0.3164639175,
0.0081342543,
0.3205374777,
0.0204498023,
0.1021623164,
0.4535034001,
1.0917019844,
-0.3744589388,
0.3263936639,
-0.3992660344,
-0.5124608874,
-0.1652130187,
-1.0593841076,
-0.8135656714,
-0.3357764184,
-0.4736407995,
-0.5397758484,
0.0879939869,
1.2421329021,
0.5465204716,
-1.0546101332,
-0.6441029906,
-0.4960451424,
0.2210592628,
-0.3241975904,
-0.1753686368,
0.3102471232,
-0.8706831932,
-0.7349618077,
0.1736742258,
-0.0282598436,
-0.2566939592,
-0.0366927721,
-0.0451654792,
-0.0223603602,
-0.0654578134,
0.3475180566,
0.4410134852,
-0.8407543302,
-0.2552933991,
-0.3103937209,
-0.2056930661,
-0.089833118,
1.1222536564,
-0.6369122863,
0.4187678993,
0.7936370969,
0.6112176776,
0.1148298308,
0.1259183288,
0.8379792571,
-0.7706436515,
0.2383203506,
-0.0759025067,
0.5703231096,
0.1611619741,
-0.3459936082,
0.8100555539,
0.2249743044,
-0.3142677546,
-1.142344594,
-0.224753961,
-0.4658408761,
-0.4107485712,
1.3878246546,
-0.5336361527,
-0.2134146392,
-0.0413995683,
-0.1546014696,
0.0048309434,
-0.3061393201,
0.5585718155,
0.5991597176,
0.2150838226,
0.195479393,
-0.6116325259,
0.6253578663,
0.2410309017,
-0.6386136413,
0.6720783114,
0.716935277,
0.5718866587,
0.4873192608,
0.4891854227,
-0.0072271,
0.5798669457,
-0.1061163768,
0.3680976331,
-0.1355540901,
-0.2583528459,
-0.5978252292,
0.1574359983,
0.1562453806,
-0.0158489253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03197v1 | AutoScrum: Automating Project Planning Using Large Language Models | 2023-06-05T19:16:37 | 2023-06-05T19:16:37 | Martin Schroder | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in the field of large language models have made it
possible to use language models for advanced reasoning. In this paper we
leverage this ability for designing complex project plans based only on knowing
the current state and the desired state. Two approaches are demonstrated - a
scrum based approach and a shortcut plan approach. The scrum based approach
executes an automated process of requirements gathering, user story mapping,
feature identification, task decomposition and finally generates questions and
search terms for seeking out domain specific information to assist with task
completion. The shortcut approach looks at most recent snapshot of the current
and desired state and generates the next most reasonable task to do in order to
get to the desired state as quickly as possible. In this paper we automate
everything using a novel concept of "Language Programs". These are programs
written in natural language designed to process input data through the language
model. Guidance language is used for all LLM programs. All demo source code for
this paper is available at https://github.com/autoscrum/autoscrum | [
-0.1081289575,
-0.7129337192,
0.651280582,
0.3710995317,
-0.0581849888,
0.3808110654,
0.0047782101,
-0.3504336178,
0.4184060097,
0.5912070274,
-0.611553967,
-0.3452144265,
-0.3001850247,
-0.1689334065,
-0.6835185289,
0.4702042937,
-0.74510324,
-0.253893882,
0.2329900712,
0.0465649888,
-0.4541820884,
-0.2947691679,
-0.4540089369,
-0.4495433569,
0.3909924626,
0.8059003949,
0.76540941,
0.7807903886,
0.3920427263,
0.3402946889,
0.1219541654,
0.0271423943,
-0.0798628181,
0.458451122,
-0.2386261374,
-0.1385141015,
-0.5496376753,
0.0237747096,
0.1007647738,
0.526778698,
-0.5075802207,
0.527833581,
-0.23525244,
0.5513890982,
-0.5204849839,
0.5324018002,
-0.6110839248,
0.1262189299,
0.2174626589,
-0.0763667226,
-0.0037786555,
-0.3806158006,
0.0136779668,
-0.6253140569,
-0.1170541123,
0.2164599001,
0.5144680738,
0.1440735161,
-0.0195557084,
-0.7857009768,
-1.0022519827,
0.5960398912,
-0.603641808,
-0.0520558022,
0.4109426737,
0.5862739682,
-0.1233428642,
-0.5164361596,
-0.3989043534,
-0.4613547325,
0.155685544,
0.0546182059,
0.0374266803,
0.267496556,
0.3469804525,
0.3407664299,
-0.7667197585,
0.2525408864,
-0.4459751546,
-0.0603372827,
0.811663568,
0.5221012831,
0.278685987,
-0.2180720717,
-0.1845351458,
0.1651495993,
-0.5858179927,
0.0411947444,
0.1733735949,
0.1188445985,
-0.1183480769,
0.9693396688,
-0.6387134194,
0.5947369337,
-0.1334421188,
-0.1526147723,
-0.2206059992,
-0.3605295718,
-0.5707201362,
0.0182427578,
0.360045284,
0.0637654662,
0.2879860699,
-0.0371824317,
-0.2641619444,
0.0886848047,
0.0495667011,
-0.2941911221,
-0.3421516716,
0.2738084495,
-0.4277769029,
-0.1943592578,
-0.4223173261,
-0.3058897853,
-0.2361284047,
-0.8018231392,
0.2813167274,
-0.3084263802,
-0.1855012774,
0.125548929,
0.1169915721,
0.318946749,
0.4716511071,
-0.6488445997,
0.3659951687,
0.4669426382,
0.5980682373,
-0.2179965675,
-0.5466521382,
-0.2499620169,
0.7669424415,
-0.2824037671,
0.8073696494,
-0.2242783904,
-0.4073172808,
-0.067854926,
-0.3673478365,
0.0216049012,
-0.4263561666,
0.0193469841,
-0.2483372688,
0.1356559098,
0.137533769,
-0.3386763632,
-0.0696516708,
0.3198626041,
-0.530570507,
1.0363172293,
0.1755627841,
-0.2203041315,
0.2781249583,
-0.8743706942,
-0.7541611195,
0.0896150842,
-0.1179391444,
0.1049498543,
-0.0893315822,
0.1805243641,
0.4977552891,
-0.6930389404,
0.6912968755,
-0.1121032164,
-0.2144681215,
-0.1327522546,
0.1215929091,
0.5978807807,
0.51303792,
-0.5094310045,
0.3599098623,
-0.5183734298,
0.2889450192,
0.0957826898,
-0.375538826,
0.0899870098,
0.1878895015,
-0.158139199,
0.4821010828,
0.3774372935,
-0.1096770763,
0.6076814532,
-0.5648801327,
0.649882853,
0.4010154307,
-0.1480658501,
0.8693782091,
-0.123867549,
0.7761631608,
-0.5142967105,
0.5614174008,
-0.4123722911,
-0.1623603851,
-0.839754343,
-0.0634160414,
-0.1341386288,
0.8878073096,
-0.5528835654,
0.106644921,
0.2309161276,
-0.6303418279,
-0.1174910516,
0.0876320973,
0.1778739989,
0.0853704065,
0.3960293233,
-0.2200327069,
-0.5628270507,
-0.8849387765,
-0.3856269419,
-0.6118660569,
0.0433744602,
0.0751902759,
0.4765334427,
0.0680934936,
0.9065162539,
-0.8436690569,
-0.3551611602,
-0.9172129631,
0.5694531798,
0.2832658291,
0.2971708775,
0.2444052249,
-0.7522791028,
-0.4745498002,
-0.4135947227,
-0.5287723541,
-0.1435732991,
-0.4770689607,
-0.0280276109,
0.1939535737,
0.6241388917,
-0.8836301565,
0.693048656,
0.3214901984,
-0.2232239097,
0.5402444601,
-0.1348755062,
0.0013864019,
-0.932543993,
0.3852484524,
-0.2848230898,
-0.0217541326,
-0.2776940465,
0.1541554332,
-0.0917039961,
-0.3722257912,
-0.4600473046,
0.5094922185,
-0.8935882449,
-0.3088677526,
-0.4662563205,
-0.1462636888,
-0.1940248609,
0.4248167276,
-0.0347339921,
0.4614000618,
0.4879921079,
-0.5368492007,
0.7254312038,
0.228975907,
-0.3791247308,
0.2870889306,
-0.5588351488,
-0.174800247,
0.1284908503,
0.3331590593,
-0.6760917902,
-0.3901643157,
0.1304710209,
-0.3437426984,
0.202497974,
-0.1437824816,
-0.7822294831,
-0.8256183267,
0.0842741281,
0.1090259552,
0.3095051944,
0.0256185867,
0.8351210952,
0.6311637759,
-0.4849819541,
-0.144720912,
-0.5751591325,
0.3832105994,
-0.0134686222,
-0.2972231805,
0.4262554646,
-0.2240993381,
-0.3790802658,
-0.1374394149,
-0.0906601995,
-0.4681598246,
0.0862893984,
0.5816053748,
0.3124234378,
0.222064063,
-0.3385311961,
0.1238107458,
-0.351449877,
0.0014984934,
0.0018027192,
0.5310541391,
0.2770463228,
-0.436804086,
-0.3814480007,
0.8029484153,
0.8819585443,
-0.3236064315,
0.1579542011,
-0.1916973889,
-0.3250429928,
-0.2741754353,
-0.5507596135,
0.0790005997,
-0.4995366633,
0.2168045491,
-0.264765352,
-0.5293314457,
0.4071799219,
-0.3826353252,
0.4271493554,
0.0714749843,
0.585672915,
-0.1806038767,
1.1432691813,
0.8623714447,
-0.3980785608,
0.2793570161,
-0.2856413126,
0.2919966578,
-0.2721148133,
-0.1280153394,
-0.4379419088,
-0.2546207905,
0.2060442418,
-0.5344732404,
0.0328214951,
0.0704972148,
-0.3422794938,
0.7422873974,
-0.4282158017,
0.4440554976,
0.4526495934,
-0.6285254955,
0.181162402,
-0.3679106534,
-0.280087471,
0.2239360809,
-0.8314547539,
-0.4131612778,
0.5547397733,
0.1174063459,
0.6994473934,
-0.5088965297,
0.6329211593,
0.1704140306,
0.2127202898,
-0.7463344336,
0.869674623,
0.4484499395,
-0.7631946802,
-0.5815213919,
0.0860523731,
-0.5580380559,
-0.1090272963,
-0.1027326137,
-0.304669559,
-0.0277129505,
0.3028001785,
-0.3863088191,
0.0773620456,
-0.4056198895,
0.5457068682,
-0.5204578638,
0.1117550954,
-0.5470565557,
-0.7319466472,
0.0865294114,
-0.0926550329,
0.4617029727,
-0.5081986189,
0.1967425793,
0.3496769667,
-0.2800141275,
0.6534747481,
-0.1311945766,
0.2260788828,
0.5049446821,
0.4368130565,
0.7293983102,
-0.2283160836,
-0.2173800915,
-0.3040404618,
-0.1927644461,
-0.2324549854,
-0.2860690951,
0.5216539502,
-0.0786017329,
-0.4305385053,
-0.4583055973,
-0.9772931933,
-0.0299257115,
0.16363056,
0.0304363575,
0.1908869892,
-0.4062345326,
-0.5551421642,
0.0808870122,
-0.5083174706,
0.8699138761,
0.8252521157,
-0.3973608315,
-0.3492493033,
0.3583920598,
0.3811468482,
0.2864276767,
0.1439649761,
-0.3090288341,
0.1894214749,
-0.7872074246,
-0.5372457504,
0.2956688702,
-0.4764022529,
-0.3270394802,
-0.3518404365,
-0.1618026793,
-0.4118027687,
-0.6853405237,
-0.4472615719,
-0.6371669173,
0.1294376105,
-0.0246047061,
-0.0461710654,
0.7862204909,
0.0176379457,
0.2553266883,
-0.5490727425,
0.5386544466,
0.0789955482,
0.0782453269,
-0.2315177917,
0.0184645616,
-0.4327019453,
-0.2767852545,
-0.2563584447,
-1.0255842209,
0.7606965303,
-0.0123682087,
0.7332960963,
-0.0940121785,
0.073506996,
0.8114535213,
-0.5149424076,
0.6298636198,
0.1396654993,
-0.927854836,
1.0607925653,
-0.3364049196,
0.6870068312,
0.8309342861,
0.4191432893,
-0.4665855169,
-0.813024044,
-0.548492074,
-1.2702461481,
0.5590164065,
0.0805558711,
-0.2954550087,
0.1611108184,
0.4027407169,
-0.0603788085,
0.3600603044,
-0.5656334758,
-0.0517326258,
0.1483302265,
-0.1836755872,
0.0269110352,
-0.2127716094,
-0.0560659394,
-0.3984448612,
0.5290683508,
-0.1965490282,
0.0678176358,
-0.0188206844,
-0.3550760448,
-0.1394634247,
0.1497103125,
0.3385410607,
1.1463508606,
0.2359538823,
-0.1237578243,
0.2373235077,
-0.3529721498,
0.089028649,
0.0742727593,
-0.3181087971,
-0.1485079527,
0.1631870121,
0.2567072809,
0.3693229258,
-0.778966248,
0.2796110213,
0.1788842231,
-0.2656808197,
-0.6142519116,
0.1302943826,
0.3025867939,
0.4975176752,
0.4468327463,
-0.1532651931,
0.1938278228,
-0.5896615982,
-0.0137247406,
0.1049970016,
-0.2391241342,
-0.2528319955,
0.5840630531,
0.0882755294,
-0.3455409706,
0.52171731,
0.0381671041,
-0.4605973065,
0.7915479541,
0.5887110829,
0.787276268,
-0.5688309669,
0.4323568642,
0.3109034002,
0.5519267321,
-0.3156283498,
0.7711889744,
-0.0777112991,
-0.1321072131,
-1.0206563473,
-0.5597106218,
-0.5205529332,
-0.0763759762,
-0.2790582478,
0.4075046182,
-0.4303155541,
0.3235096931,
-0.1908483207,
-0.0826061442,
-0.3680542707,
0.4007920027,
0.0790235773,
1.2378509045,
-0.8813741803,
1.0816712379,
0.7897331119,
-0.2822004259,
-1.1896373034,
-0.1618121713,
0.2188496292,
-0.7972854376,
0.9525539279,
-0.0812299326,
-0.1050101146,
-0.0785818398,
-0.4661769569,
-1.1981986761,
1.1998131275,
0.2349614948,
-0.4824588597,
-0.5173111558,
0.3183119297,
0.1111575589,
-0.3137069643,
-0.0994586274,
0.5004559159,
0.646945715,
0.425932914,
-1.2165466547,
0.0304892827,
-0.0257706232,
-0.3046291173,
0.4883514941,
-0.1145875826,
0.6850734353,
-0.3191880584,
-0.1262790859,
0.1963524222,
0.6219964027,
0.356734246,
0.5449068546,
0.5850747824,
0.3182748556,
0.383831352,
0.1195281222,
0.5371658206,
-0.6021119356,
0.1029954851,
1.1469715834,
-0.5637013316,
0.606631279,
0.3413203955,
0.0688310415,
0.2557389438,
0.5649437904,
0.0213356335,
0.5235528946,
0.3145547509,
0.0904188976,
-0.2312596142,
0.2604606152,
0.0186382663,
0.6003002524,
0.3592443764,
-0.2441263646,
-0.3498911262,
0.2114341706,
0.1738908142,
-0.0110583873,
-0.4915665984,
0.5262893438,
0.1469793022,
-0.9307231307,
0.1413948089,
-0.0250271671,
0.2499070615,
-0.7342923284,
-0.0393554382,
-0.0479287021,
0.0353453048,
-0.1253407151,
-0.7858177423,
0.8181781769,
-0.0643521845,
-0.1565849036,
-0.6954516768,
0.8292343616,
-0.2623987496,
-0.2870604098,
0.2010531276,
0.4359658062,
0.0436050929,
-0.2853624523,
-1.0857044458,
-0.2024538815,
-0.1801712066,
-0.2078727037,
0.0291876066,
0.1981351376,
-0.2214747071,
0.9162299633,
0.4240869284,
0.3651968837,
-0.0927187055,
-0.2471589446,
0.7933523059,
-0.9494319558,
-0.7010276914,
-0.6821659207,
0.3377039433,
-0.1525403559,
-0.2525637448,
0.6838449836,
0.9246599078,
0.4663870335,
0.2063939869,
0.6184645891,
-0.2342378795,
0.8591956496,
-0.3460426927,
0.5250333548,
-0.2252520621,
0.2683028579,
-0.328649044,
-0.9284317493,
-0.4377611279,
0.4908649623,
-0.4581615031,
-0.5844056606,
0.6715967655,
0.5812731981,
-0.0116088819,
-0.0351131596,
0.0755808279,
0.0544038564,
0.3399343789,
0.5434653163,
0.7852525711,
0.3107805252,
0.6262868643,
-0.0457031019,
-0.4121290743,
-0.2264954746,
-0.8864857554,
-0.4910057783,
-0.6211053133,
-0.3126292229,
0.0098176086,
0.069897458,
0.9375158548,
0.6897316575,
-0.4151414335,
-0.8025403619,
-0.2679691911,
-0.0907654613,
-0.0347315557,
-0.1190090254,
0.1771312505,
-0.2706922591,
-0.2748785019,
0.6612064242,
0.6598367691,
-0.051150132,
-0.428925097,
-0.0161320232,
-0.2782059312,
0.2631666958,
0.5605112314,
0.6914111972,
-0.5619577169,
0.091826275,
0.1508213282,
-0.156957075,
-0.2109345794,
1.2476129532,
-0.8320746422,
-0.0023256135,
0.4727600813,
0.0009736606,
0.8007704616,
-0.3155329227,
1.0361021757,
-0.0016127037,
0.2103705853,
0.4794460237,
0.1827422529,
0.0007376795,
-0.2096059322,
0.6568789482,
-0.2243730277,
-0.800355196,
-0.5912163854,
0.7344546318,
-0.8586320877,
-0.6932756305,
1.0595775843,
0.1901181042,
-0.1195100844,
-0.4731928408,
-0.544233799,
0.3183317482,
-0.0121252229,
0.8457413316,
0.3852177262,
-0.4616452456,
0.2800971866,
-0.7789978981,
0.5428639054,
0.2511197031,
-0.8636569977,
0.3126040995,
0.6249880791,
-0.0274629761,
-0.0229147412,
0.9324958324,
-0.0328967646,
0.1961525977,
-0.4190168381,
0.2890627384,
-0.0633994862,
-0.5002231598,
0.1854112893,
0.434792161,
0.1093411669,
0.1584034264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03189v1 | Easy-to-Read in Germany: A Survey on its Current State and Available Resources | 2023-06-05T19:00:25 | 2023-06-05T19:00:25 | Margot Madina, Itziar Gonzalez-Dios, Melanie Siegel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Easy-to-Read Language (E2R) is a controlled language variant that makes any
written text more accessible through the use of clear, direct and simple
language. It is mainly aimed at people with cognitive or intellectual
disabilities, among other target users. Plain Language (PL), on the other hand,
is a variant of a given language, which aims to promote the use of simple
language to communicate information. German counts with Leichte Sprache (LS),
its version of E2R, and Einfache Sprache (ES), its version of PL. In recent
years, important developments have been conducted in the field of LS. This
paper offers an updated overview of the existing Natural Language Processing
(NLP) tools and resources for LS. Besides, it also aims to set out the
situation with regard to LS and ES in Germany. | [
-0.4678201973,
-0.8127202392,
0.517817378,
0.1234882474,
-0.299554497,
-0.0968891159,
-0.2967618704,
-0.9088203907,
-0.0172812194,
0.3724168539,
-0.3310757875,
-0.1842165291,
-0.7652419209,
0.4478289485,
-0.3286306858,
1.1025387049,
-0.2417680621,
0.0896370634,
0.1698228419,
-0.4297798276,
-0.0512760282,
-0.5108853579,
-0.8666548729,
-0.485763967,
0.793174684,
0.5642932057,
0.5526872277,
0.4683509767,
0.8078878522,
0.3074933887,
-0.5503110886,
-0.2000702173,
-0.2035022974,
0.3875809014,
-0.2815691233,
-0.4387283027,
-0.2798495591,
-0.5070046186,
0.57875067,
0.7173209786,
-0.3005745113,
-0.0324196219,
0.1419082284,
1.17818892,
-0.3871985972,
0.2240324616,
0.1205089092,
0.1207215413,
-0.4719860852,
0.0649178028,
-0.5716306567,
-0.2210098356,
0.3137697279,
-0.2996390462,
0.4395738244,
0.1411331445,
0.7811096907,
0.2531928718,
-0.7741439939,
-1.1666190624,
-0.8098598719,
0.5923244953,
-0.2679543793,
0.9022807479,
0.2223609984,
0.4935118258,
-0.3048817217,
-1.0031359196,
-0.4479755163,
-0.1437029243,
-0.4719540477,
0.0575986132,
-0.5865626335,
-0.0189315379,
0.2218102813,
0.2373393327,
-0.2159577161,
0.1944657564,
-0.4202724099,
-0.1247262582,
0.4181782305,
-0.3650233448,
0.3529111743,
-0.2056253105,
-0.1745924503,
-0.0064066104,
-0.4368955493,
0.2594138384,
0.287296921,
0.2866356671,
-0.2028731406,
0.5928063393,
-0.1447008848,
0.8450105786,
-0.1180844977,
-0.1595526338,
0.338087678,
-0.2434899807,
0.0366369374,
-0.0993980542,
0.033083111,
0.2501670122,
0.1446028054,
-0.1294252276,
-0.3606421351,
-0.4065943956,
-0.2327020913,
-0.5484542847,
-0.0103320209,
0.2582173049,
-0.3768807352,
0.3730506301,
0.2402480841,
-0.7210552096,
-0.4257011116,
-0.2964837849,
-0.1787449121,
-0.3451773524,
-0.1245032549,
0.3994053304,
-0.3801612556,
0.4460422397,
0.7538448572,
-0.697738111,
0.5205866098,
0.4617007971,
0.7166312337,
-0.3513675928,
-0.0428557172,
-0.382217586,
0.2638212144,
0.2064614445,
1.322273016,
0.081035234,
-0.2349561602,
0.325199753,
0.3089791834,
0.3711623847,
-0.1797180176,
0.8299480081,
-0.6524444222,
0.3620139658,
-0.0919925943,
-0.3755019605,
-0.2429171801,
-0.0612844527,
-1.1608986855,
1.1786165237,
0.0108217737,
-1.0781966448,
0.1812624186,
-0.7851958275,
-0.8374331594,
-0.0330577418,
-0.0508603044,
-0.3643326759,
0.05658672,
-0.0264996905,
0.1275206357,
-0.2088897526,
-0.0300467703,
0.2432481349,
-0.1819853485,
-0.0199553873,
-0.4626980126,
0.7633051872,
0.4814688265,
-0.4671067297,
0.0726390556,
-0.6939668059,
0.0957555845,
0.1083725467,
-0.6616409421,
-0.1372361332,
0.3624463379,
0.6202366352,
0.2758144736,
0.4449461401,
-0.31262815,
-0.263625592,
-0.3891423643,
0.2937354445,
0.3977319896,
-0.1815609038,
0.8481485844,
-0.0350285731,
0.2633133829,
-0.0288694855,
-0.0112255029,
-0.2044684887,
-0.5515075326,
-1.1822240353,
-0.3186725974,
0.3098725677,
0.9873143435,
-0.7405298352,
0.5082677603,
-0.0143224327,
-0.6826624274,
-0.4826824963,
0.1792994738,
0.4006968737,
0.1129197031,
0.1590444893,
-0.0584115684,
-0.1814956218,
-1.0166614056,
-0.4613747895,
0.107818611,
-0.0854420885,
0.264179945,
0.420537591,
-0.0237330906,
0.8110410571,
-0.4457188845,
-0.4328772128,
-0.8126354218,
-0.0967410579,
0.1254198849,
0.2357281595,
0.4050371647,
-0.9276971221,
-0.8029381633,
0.1605574787,
-0.6846061945,
-0.1686706096,
0.4626872838,
0.1536906064,
0.7181039453,
0.623319447,
-0.1524840444,
0.2781870961,
0.3974658549,
-0.5493925214,
-0.2186212987,
-0.6279975176,
-0.2022205889,
-0.6185262203,
0.2315451205,
0.2410363406,
-0.495372355,
-0.9245511293,
0.5702791214,
0.0986182243,
-0.0226123016,
-0.7732642293,
0.7269883156,
-0.7571499944,
-0.1979610324,
-0.146301195,
0.3128858209,
-0.1408968717,
-0.0941675454,
0.3059707284,
0.5276045203,
0.3597514033,
-0.4223300815,
0.1040748358,
0.1600122899,
-0.3827455938,
0.6071615815,
-0.4964510798,
0.3302899003,
-0.786051631,
0.5140792727,
-0.4626823962,
-0.2906687856,
0.3820742369,
0.0135260262,
0.5260816216,
0.336368084,
-0.5639808178,
-0.1231293902,
0.0176361464,
-0.2108696997,
0.2557010651,
-0.2122995555,
0.7195314765,
0.4904936254,
-0.7388734818,
-0.4303540289,
-0.9139375687,
0.0070886984,
0.1118542627,
-0.7015889883,
0.0362555869,
-0.1212542728,
-0.3196898699,
0.0071911346,
0.0183350239,
-0.3603534102,
-0.098038964,
-0.2132003605,
-0.0814635605,
-0.100884445,
-0.0937292427,
0.1476441324,
-0.530546844,
-0.6823667884,
0.5336012244,
0.5129805803,
-0.6503482461,
-0.3692870736,
-0.4808649421,
0.9913873672,
0.0583121516,
-0.017645929,
0.3379184902,
0.3777323663,
-0.2911837399,
-0.3066996336,
-0.3705705106,
-0.3534059823,
-0.5467238426,
0.4509223402,
-0.4404552281,
-1.1214101315,
0.3661014736,
-0.2368657142,
0.1238495335,
0.4994487166,
0.3520684838,
-0.3677850068,
0.7863135338,
1.087900281,
0.4473475814,
0.4095070362,
0.292627424,
0.4354127347,
-0.0341462605,
-0.3548692763,
-0.8737970591,
-0.1508216262,
-0.6971001625,
-0.3635470867,
0.0103496006,
0.4878330827,
-0.1893063337,
0.2688578665,
-0.6172949076,
0.4301770329,
0.5525376201,
-0.1125686318,
0.6786858439,
0.2728846967,
0.1706662178,
-0.3813941181,
-0.8248358369,
-0.8703288436,
0.3854902387,
0.5295718908,
0.5147141218,
0.3900517523,
0.7713306546,
0.4415144324,
0.2644908726,
-1.0994919538,
0.5085608959,
-0.3466895819,
-0.763412118,
-0.3875465691,
-0.0473967083,
-0.8505284786,
0.1431829035,
0.1336857229,
-0.4340851605,
0.1917879134,
0.0417779423,
0.0875891745,
0.2301818281,
-0.9605482817,
0.560770452,
-0.2917495668,
-0.0573052354,
-0.1065364629,
-0.7740607858,
-0.3402877152,
-0.1135325059,
0.6895134449,
-0.0300922543,
-0.2464390248,
0.5929279327,
-0.0377118737,
0.6894648075,
-0.1737789214,
-0.1484858692,
0.4211931229,
-0.1358689964,
0.8403619528,
-0.2744950652,
-0.3842743635,
0.120582357,
0.045806013,
-0.4448683858,
-0.291584909,
0.2232719809,
-0.5611820221,
-0.5309943557,
-1.1139065027,
-0.2450832129,
0.184762314,
0.5060591102,
0.2568709552,
0.085821718,
-0.2968966067,
0.152629897,
0.4729839563,
-0.332693696,
0.5672562122,
1.2498140335,
-0.1799874604,
-0.0450904779,
0.7054094672,
0.3626735806,
0.0566204302,
0.038625095,
-0.1001042873,
-0.3836481571,
-0.4464669526,
-0.5347549319,
0.1578081995,
-1.0671340227,
0.1647566259,
-0.5297091603,
-0.4368849993,
0.0482729413,
-0.6074760556,
-0.0873428807,
-0.3572289944,
-0.1499519795,
-0.2149536312,
0.5415260792,
1.0788811445,
-0.4148489833,
0.5022432804,
-0.4921914935,
0.2654323876,
-0.0454125218,
0.5898973346,
-0.3647135496,
-0.3403509557,
-0.0767135248,
-0.4161985815,
-0.1475406438,
-0.9470669031,
0.0087393913,
0.3588574231,
0.4165564775,
0.2907963395,
0.0393711776,
0.081718415,
-0.8324445486,
0.6560304761,
0.3548784256,
-0.7597998977,
0.4889625907,
-0.1083536744,
0.0720915124,
0.6809021235,
0.2180849165,
-1.028750658,
-0.4026406407,
-0.4724516869,
-1.168554306,
0.9293576479,
-0.0075320201,
0.1940318197,
0.0388661288,
-0.0313418433,
0.2460686713,
0.13810803,
-0.8230788112,
-0.7772170305,
0.042308338,
-0.1285520494,
-0.0431626439,
-0.247630313,
-0.0279729143,
-0.340664655,
0.5196498632,
0.2395022362,
0.3194636405,
0.2238966227,
-0.1215433851,
-0.1458448768,
0.8566567898,
0.3450188637,
0.4174745679,
-0.274312228,
0.3043716848,
0.1395139992,
-0.5026957393,
0.3744164407,
0.3013297915,
-0.7855346799,
0.3756122589,
-0.0778068528,
0.7824629545,
0.3867770731,
-0.7651765347,
0.53283149,
0.1817491204,
-0.0740089715,
-0.6325424314,
-0.090422377,
0.2646128833,
0.1932309419,
0.3729245663,
0.0693826824,
0.0530752912,
-0.4950229526,
0.3125142157,
-0.0631132275,
-0.5435321927,
-0.0913616419,
0.2540078461,
0.6303830743,
-0.6215009093,
0.3384971321,
-0.6029605865,
-0.3001363575,
0.4044828415,
0.9345268607,
0.4517889023,
0.057913743,
0.3508885205,
0.2073935866,
0.4431464672,
-0.3361814022,
0.847476542,
0.2069847286,
-0.682729423,
-0.1516171694,
-0.501719892,
-0.5711123943,
-0.1521353722,
-0.7633754611,
0.4700084925,
-0.3688840568,
-0.1776667982,
-0.0116539896,
-0.0203846358,
-0.945830524,
0.1943519264,
0.0385331474,
1.1601976156,
-0.6932217479,
0.9173232317,
0.8401684761,
-0.3815227747,
-0.438632369,
-0.083365418,
0.0452181436,
-0.4471690357,
0.5525084734,
0.1726823747,
-0.2952966094,
0.3852690458,
-0.2795978189,
-0.9645215273,
0.92360425,
0.1576786786,
-0.636063993,
-0.1412990391,
0.32985726,
0.6149358153,
0.1600339264,
0.0184757262,
0.814479351,
1.006685853,
-0.3215017617,
-0.7187662721,
-0.301268965,
-0.327970922,
-0.4417970777,
0.4610168934,
-0.6585795283,
0.3810295165,
-0.1103024781,
-0.620734036,
-0.1821919978,
0.7373139858,
0.2262634188,
0.6781693101,
0.4711793661,
0.5247032642,
0.8878023028,
-0.2859705389,
1.1299054623,
-0.5042982101,
0.1804386377,
0.96834445,
-0.4631905854,
1.3493851423,
0.8195329905,
-0.3640603721,
0.5568886399,
0.3152945936,
-0.0151758976,
0.5104418397,
0.0354706235,
-0.4768862724,
0.1188606545,
-0.1323969662,
-0.2297779024,
0.343875438,
0.3153621256,
-0.1202923954,
-0.7459288836,
0.0136474986,
0.271111846,
0.117168732,
-0.1746312082,
0.7570546865,
0.3515228331,
-0.4319138527,
-0.2005141377,
0.5117436647,
0.8976435661,
-0.8997652531,
0.2736449242,
0.0810000226,
-0.0049137548,
-0.3168194592,
-1.1907488108,
0.5745484829,
0.5343264341,
-0.3884100318,
-0.4007263184,
1.037191987,
-0.1514271349,
-0.5700968504,
0.5745463967,
1.2341880798,
0.424053818,
0.3763183057,
-0.7181834579,
-0.3084397018,
0.1113121957,
-0.5108008385,
0.2097542882,
0.2171711177,
-0.0429422148,
0.6362130642,
0.4501293302,
0.0498080477,
0.1567681879,
0.0615420863,
0.418712467,
-0.8421133161,
-0.657595098,
-0.1811198741,
0.6251787543,
-0.1827137172,
-0.3646739721,
0.7190117836,
0.5890761614,
0.6708625555,
-0.018816974,
1.0616627932,
-0.5706810951,
0.8991138935,
-0.0944185778,
0.9865612388,
-0.5172569752,
-0.2300584316,
0.145064801,
-0.8234661818,
-0.3213270903,
0.7521039248,
-0.1439334899,
-0.2629158497,
0.8224838376,
0.614300549,
-0.0292729475,
-0.0623895377,
0.035966672,
0.0260416232,
-0.0731175318,
-0.0606517978,
0.5077791214,
-0.3126290739,
0.5280303359,
-0.2523917556,
-0.3024223745,
-0.2573597431,
-1.0860739946,
-0.2581934035,
-0.534794271,
-0.1137053147,
-0.5004197955,
0.1320599169,
0.8341263533,
-0.1346092969,
-1.019190073,
-0.2169301063,
-0.2232411504,
-0.0100519378,
-0.0718792975,
-0.1472435892,
0.6883050203,
-0.1196125224,
-0.9124558568,
0.2608753443,
0.4553182125,
0.1707963198,
-0.0514230244,
-0.255138427,
-0.0356335565,
0.1520647258,
0.737834096,
0.7224995494,
-0.5999375582,
-0.1817194074,
0.0642334968,
-0.5764173269,
0.2236841917,
0.6064827442,
-0.1681347042,
0.5509986877,
0.7479357719,
0.3397917747,
0.4343622923,
-0.4458763003,
0.389353931,
-0.3268534243,
0.6454669237,
0.2955498099,
0.4003662765,
0.4598511755,
0.0664048195,
0.5531383753,
-0.160872817,
-0.5058498979,
-0.6237970591,
0.553876102,
-1.0820524693,
-0.2332586944,
1.2954279184,
-0.119115606,
-0.1456110179,
-0.7803608775,
-0.5637956262,
0.4972919226,
-0.5837348104,
0.4275006652,
0.913028121,
-0.1720318049,
-0.2352717072,
-1.0875647068,
0.7105704546,
0.3959827423,
-0.8123757839,
-0.2401231527,
0.4981949329,
0.3417173326,
-0.0525491498,
0.9697495103,
0.0449444577,
0.2334033996,
-0.1396594048,
0.1086342186,
0.2191261798,
-0.2681873143,
-0.4817339778,
0.1774448752,
0.2792988718,
0.6329464316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03168v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03168v1 | Composition and Deformance: Measuring Imageability with a Text-to-Image Model | 2023-06-05T18:22:23 | 2023-06-05T18:22:23 | Si Wu, David A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Although psycholinguists and psychologists have long studied the tendency of
linguistic strings to evoke mental images in hearers or readers, most
computational studies have applied this concept of imageability only to
isolated words. Using recent developments in text-to-image generation models,
such as DALLE mini, we propose computational methods that use generated images
to measure the imageability of both single English words and connected text. We
sample text prompts for image generation from three corpora: human-generated
image captions, news article sentences, and poem lines. We subject these
prompts to different deformances to examine the model's ability to detect
changes in imageability caused by compositional change. We find high
correlation between the proposed computational measures of imageability and
human judgments of individual words. We also find the proposed measures more
consistently respond to changes in compositionality than baseline approaches.
We discuss possible effects of model training and implications for the study of
compositionality in text-to-image models. | [
-0.5137608051,
-0.8881925941,
0.6341757774,
0.2213027626,
-0.448728323,
-0.2702316344,
-0.3144351244,
-0.7433076501,
0.2384888232,
0.2085846514,
-0.4388982654,
-0.153956458,
-0.732088387,
0.3975914717,
-0.7085085511,
0.6284189224,
-0.0091133052,
-0.2075023353,
-0.8927116394,
-0.2527093589,
-0.6541540027,
-0.0704744458,
-0.6623879075,
-0.2118991911,
0.3795987964,
0.0486232229,
0.9752681255,
0.6882680655,
0.6534296274,
0.4122511446,
0.0660925135,
-0.1638021618,
-0.2262223959,
0.148928538,
-0.1452994198,
-0.6691163778,
-0.0595957376,
0.1542284638,
0.8264092207,
0.7437467575,
0.0454354808,
-0.1075433716,
0.0820062086,
0.6780301929,
-0.4177978635,
0.0597074814,
-0.7786464095,
0.1263943166,
-0.0292934794,
-0.0529236086,
-0.4263308346,
-0.0735313967,
0.0771800652,
-0.5404703021,
0.2954789102,
0.1318590492,
0.5783909559,
0.359423697,
-0.3978407383,
-0.6022754908,
-0.5223629475,
0.6769077182,
-0.4090096951,
0.5634989738,
0.5528167486,
0.1379317939,
0.0448355675,
-0.8398330808,
-0.6744652987,
-0.4208814502,
-0.3605678082,
0.151997894,
-0.3392621875,
-0.1725968122,
0.1438787282,
0.4648933411,
-0.634345293,
-0.1914877146,
-0.2489117086,
-0.0679899901,
0.8014739752,
0.1712162346,
0.9650826454,
-0.1453360021,
-0.1920402199,
-0.2105096281,
-0.2808944881,
-0.1902579069,
0.4628029466,
-0.0718526766,
-0.3838084936,
0.8578028083,
0.5465020537,
0.6797679067,
0.3025953174,
-0.1960743666,
-0.3352614641,
-0.3128991425,
-0.1464625895,
0.0652277544,
0.6800327897,
0.3347106278,
0.1747705936,
-0.1870667189,
-0.2587145269,
0.4459881485,
0.3776899278,
-0.6895914078,
-0.6397131085,
0.1543273926,
-0.4731663764,
-0.4032122493,
0.1264137626,
-0.4182094336,
-0.622913003,
-0.3734132946,
0.3484911919,
-0.8553031087,
-0.3569682837,
-0.0162844881,
-0.1066684648,
0.0812127739,
0.0927509815,
-0.9789229035,
0.1935467124,
0.3648081422,
0.8496927619,
-0.4257765412,
-0.5135731697,
-0.0112941479,
-0.0217468198,
-0.6074893475,
1.182937026,
-0.2054881603,
-0.4170178473,
-0.0664125234,
-0.0373054631,
-0.3879377842,
-0.6136844754,
0.4847883284,
-0.3599696159,
0.4716389775,
-0.0002235022,
-0.7365026474,
-0.1633026451,
0.3561612666,
-0.9937116504,
0.6941034198,
0.1902482063,
-0.9705546498,
0.2959179282,
-0.4850873351,
-0.4643527567,
0.0666203871,
-0.4018560946,
-0.4940352142,
0.6140061617,
-0.1956632137,
0.1787067056,
-0.1284213513,
-0.1320271343,
-0.0715849027,
-0.4848708212,
0.8978433609,
-0.3976967931,
0.4837161005,
0.034917891,
0.153234899,
-0.1961640567,
-0.6652756929,
0.0019790591,
0.4162875116,
-0.3871213496,
-0.579169035,
0.3393324018,
0.2663008571,
-0.0935219303,
0.1909252554,
-0.4763244689,
-0.0670351684,
-0.5559254885,
0.2768675983,
0.541965127,
-0.0538233668,
0.4416944385,
-0.6183260679,
0.3699116409,
0.217672348,
-0.1964221895,
-0.4086058736,
-0.2416553199,
-0.5969370008,
-0.7734197378,
0.3985913694,
0.3272317052,
-0.6318350434,
0.2907271087,
-0.2859890759,
-0.360352844,
-0.3133993745,
-0.1390032023,
0.2160254717,
0.1876137406,
-0.0048560579,
-0.6471269131,
-0.2593184114,
-0.9288426042,
-0.3510167301,
-0.1975047141,
-0.0556383319,
0.1919102371,
0.414129436,
-0.3489565849,
0.6411718726,
-0.5488818884,
-0.0709521398,
0.21578224,
0.4297530055,
-0.2866504192,
0.3095531166,
0.8487801552,
-0.8727424145,
-0.3761366904,
-0.1061090305,
-0.709115386,
0.0200314224,
-0.2232663631,
0.0602549389,
0.5042633414,
0.2063971907,
-0.5585415959,
0.4318934381,
0.6907120347,
-0.460334152,
0.6483222842,
-0.269135654,
0.3535407186,
-1.0803779364,
0.01381349,
0.194692716,
-0.2563422322,
-0.5062587261,
0.2585421205,
-0.0974916965,
-0.1860294193,
-0.4044704437,
0.4324690998,
-0.5304204226,
-0.270699352,
-0.5373746157,
0.1716297567,
-0.0549780317,
0.1351454109,
0.0013811762,
0.7722183466,
0.7272499204,
-0.5185083151,
0.3464769423,
0.3188701868,
-0.5574181676,
1.2652798891,
-0.8282036781,
0.2395969182,
-0.5467243791,
-0.1532780528,
-1.5331482887,
-0.5842536092,
0.0680229068,
-0.3442047238,
0.4798488915,
0.3682921529,
-0.3316228092,
-0.2849523425,
-0.302983731,
0.7431107163,
0.3434039056,
-0.3773438334,
0.5695329309,
0.109111771,
-0.086048007,
0.0296323299,
-0.9394721389,
0.1848617196,
-0.3055266738,
-0.7948450446,
0.4980783761,
-0.244727686,
-0.3236278296,
0.1400958002,
0.0855361223,
-0.394043386,
0.0008610102,
0.4541202188,
0.1481444091,
-0.0092487149,
0.1506541669,
0.0901756808,
0.2444472611,
0.2639443874,
0.0713141561,
0.2970515788,
0.0262564998,
-0.3775719404,
-0.4825432897,
0.5985203385,
0.6677873731,
-0.0890074223,
0.5211597681,
0.4871436357,
-0.4610468149,
0.0765738338,
-0.1570271105,
-0.224025771,
-0.4319220483,
0.2257449776,
-0.4520127773,
-0.4427129626,
0.4558768272,
-0.1431731582,
-0.1850321144,
0.2702105641,
0.4719459414,
-0.4650145173,
0.9731557965,
0.732011199,
0.4882850051,
0.5947497487,
-0.2170074284,
0.0440633819,
-0.4794058502,
0.0192876756,
-0.3359364569,
-0.491746664,
-0.7170658708,
-0.2392402142,
0.442751497,
-0.2210004926,
-0.0221433602,
0.2572211623,
-0.4793145657,
0.5614446402,
0.3159577847,
0.3823253214,
0.3532038331,
0.2604656518,
-0.2581955492,
-0.2517803311,
-0.3010028899,
-0.3992423415,
0.5410397053,
0.080299288,
0.7379786372,
0.1221120283,
0.5503149629,
0.3233709633,
0.2669543922,
-1.0691761971,
0.5966801047,
-0.3390777111,
-0.4560876787,
0.0447946638,
-0.1833309531,
-0.9376475811,
-0.0261825882,
-0.4661771953,
-0.6031338573,
0.1586086899,
0.2888750136,
0.1698080301,
0.1215745434,
-0.5509301424,
0.7033931613,
-0.3193649948,
-0.1830863059,
-0.1487948,
-0.470487535,
0.5095010996,
-0.4386718869,
0.0395307094,
0.2076352835,
-0.230358541,
0.4555998743,
-0.0621776506,
0.8460348248,
0.2642768025,
-0.4079072475,
0.3230648339,
0.5314816833,
0.0976116955,
-0.2855865359,
0.1077829972,
0.1076080203,
0.4888108671,
-0.3902486563,
-0.7028689981,
0.5278860331,
-0.6280809045,
-0.1707411259,
-0.2825416028,
-0.8353643417,
-0.0547333583,
-0.1465744227,
0.7009553313,
0.4251437783,
-0.4447064698,
0.0337909348,
0.3415544331,
-0.1985952407,
0.5481236577,
0.0595009215,
-0.2600334287,
-0.5064327121,
0.7866770625,
0.063131094,
0.2437424958,
0.1679974049,
0.1307501942,
-0.3774760067,
-0.2916674912,
-0.2300708145,
0.34169963,
-0.4420030117,
-0.0758195072,
-0.0504752584,
-0.0172095466,
0.0437797084,
-0.1828825474,
-0.3480454981,
-0.3897685111,
-0.335932374,
0.1922017485,
0.208162263,
0.6997643709,
-0.0780698285,
0.3363866508,
-0.5095823407,
0.3060711324,
0.3909642398,
0.3372399807,
-0.2040180266,
-0.6403093338,
-0.2365790308,
0.2118841559,
-0.5182610154,
-1.0588034391,
0.1379121244,
0.5188025236,
0.1246816143,
0.5712906122,
-0.1564270258,
0.3934075236,
-0.2943322361,
0.869687736,
0.5813984275,
-0.9506442547,
0.6972460747,
-0.3770025074,
0.2071118504,
0.2916825116,
0.4205241203,
-0.5007493496,
-0.5020942688,
-0.4056673348,
-0.1890705526,
0.1135116741,
0.1175172478,
0.5745081902,
-0.0861216038,
0.4267186821,
0.2164334208,
-0.0107074324,
-0.7541396618,
-0.0336522087,
-0.2635844052,
-0.6432932019,
0.1389253885,
-0.2362250984,
-0.1342129111,
-0.2159385979,
0.1863659918,
-0.2731851339,
0.5872793794,
0.2422264069,
-0.164724946,
-0.171655342,
0.1201869473,
0.7550825477,
0.5350387692,
0.0725140497,
0.4448153377,
-0.2241954505,
-0.7413313389,
0.3426209986,
-0.0358178243,
-0.4024447799,
-0.0189996902,
0.5119310617,
0.7539825439,
-0.0013664028,
-0.7259984016,
0.5219899416,
-0.1540526003,
-0.5373445153,
-0.2407576889,
0.0175792612,
0.0028889226,
0.1341932118,
-0.0028613047,
0.1745053232,
-0.0058950745,
-0.8308777809,
0.0168677084,
0.4809075296,
-0.5056963563,
-0.6329787374,
0.5763919353,
-0.3090651035,
-0.293861568,
0.5698981881,
-0.1635385007,
-0.150547415,
0.5318898559,
1.0053132772,
0.7519450784,
-0.2266786546,
0.3082048893,
0.1854660958,
0.2487166077,
-0.0409669764,
0.3534393311,
0.2032901794,
-1.0066527128,
-0.2343471944,
-0.251480341,
-0.2269564569,
0.0147654228,
-0.4616973996,
0.115848653,
0.0325969532,
-0.4288264513,
0.0760150924,
-0.2606162429,
-0.4196428359,
0.3387840688,
0.2080344111,
0.5476683378,
-1.1170611382,
0.4073721468,
1.3901716471,
-0.5087545514,
-0.5696107745,
0.1763584167,
-0.2748315036,
-0.4312587678,
0.3513807952,
0.1877672821,
0.0725496709,
0.0423223153,
-0.833543539,
-0.3965429962,
1.1200668812,
0.7549175024,
-0.0716621205,
0.0625174716,
0.3266845644,
0.5395359993,
-0.2353094965,
0.1220342442,
0.4947278798,
0.52339077,
0.2260719985,
-0.5200793743,
-0.0360165276,
-0.0892688408,
0.3622335196,
0.1329336464,
-0.3568595648,
0.7319212556,
-0.2006109357,
-0.6675723195,
0.3983275294,
0.7467172742,
0.1807709783,
0.4983692169,
0.6236894727,
0.8083139658,
0.7557276487,
-0.0918325111,
1.0765066147,
-0.3002288938,
0.3468930423,
0.8908292651,
-0.0582149141,
0.5994250178,
0.6453623176,
-0.2078033686,
0.5115429759,
0.5078184009,
-0.1308135539,
0.6226606965,
0.3119723201,
-0.5418352485,
0.0646227747,
-0.3108220398,
0.0592726357,
0.8334849477,
0.1407652646,
-0.5168430805,
0.0867429301,
0.4576146007,
-0.4230119586,
0.5542784333,
-0.156131357,
0.8073795438,
0.2352455556,
-0.6076894403,
0.560246408,
-0.0126662226,
0.6623357534,
-0.2324393541,
0.1781782359,
-0.3837169707,
-0.1023725197,
-0.2224748433,
-0.8850945234,
0.7395336628,
-0.2220905274,
-0.2886585891,
0.2096472681,
1.0398035049,
-0.5977877975,
-0.8092778325,
-0.006758498,
0.6586484313,
0.3755998015,
-0.0979757458,
-0.4998660088,
0.2296286076,
-0.3588421345,
0.0627765879,
0.143047303,
0.351544112,
0.2228695601,
0.3686364889,
0.0821338296,
0.1929235607,
0.0460248515,
-0.2291636169,
0.4794716537,
-0.4767837822,
-0.0425804742,
-0.8076677322,
0.3329351246,
0.1121611521,
-0.0701362342,
0.3421552181,
0.4764250219,
0.5943123698,
-0.504193306,
0.592105329,
-0.2082560509,
-0.104747951,
-0.496979177,
0.7542254329,
-0.701195538,
-0.3553437293,
-0.2688573897,
-0.9423431158,
-0.2698194981,
0.7131038308,
-0.078992717,
-0.1238952354,
0.9661936164,
0.9585780501,
-0.4563525319,
0.1757921726,
0.5247183442,
-0.0417390205,
-0.1957488209,
0.3261773586,
0.941676259,
-0.5818117261,
0.3210473359,
-0.0816031769,
-0.040928442,
0.236792013,
-1.033274889,
-0.7181897163,
-1.0182836056,
-0.8685472012,
-0.1632154286,
-0.222689271,
0.5002143383,
0.5920324326,
-0.2778700292,
-0.0697915331,
-0.237616837,
-0.141641289,
-0.3203547001,
-0.2352411449,
0.3439220786,
-0.125270918,
-0.6997660398,
0.10044422,
0.1088485867,
0.687713325,
-0.2608135939,
0.2008936852,
0.1740398854,
0.4938072264,
0.7597324252,
0.1476265937,
-0.5072875023,
-0.3542845547,
-0.0958775952,
-0.162715897,
0.2169731557,
0.7341080308,
-0.3425249159,
0.3826113939,
0.6016240716,
0.5059087873,
0.2318031341,
0.0520550571,
0.3128030896,
-1.0092282295,
0.1907307059,
-0.1556890905,
0.3927574158,
0.6347500682,
-0.1996300817,
0.4751930535,
0.4077667296,
-0.4474255443,
-0.6360481977,
0.4659745693,
-1.1896448135,
-0.3416953981,
0.8686475158,
-0.0609991737,
-0.4715680778,
0.4615449607,
-0.3939283788,
0.1722409278,
0.2822902203,
0.8287688494,
0.8946529627,
-0.0571334101,
-0.4610078335,
-0.2856107056,
0.1763525456,
0.2245768309,
-0.9460228682,
-0.1886919141,
0.8971984982,
0.2440648228,
0.4026812911,
0.5676566362,
-0.0773116201,
0.2561634779,
0.0548654236,
0.0377597623,
0.1274979711,
-0.2263984233,
-0.3106606901,
0.0829632431,
0.1225577444,
-0.2179811448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03166v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03166v1 | Unsupervised Dense Retrieval with Relevance-Aware Contrastive Pre-Training | 2023-06-05T18:20:27 | 2023-06-05T18:20:27 | Yibin Lei, Liang Ding, Yu Cao, Changtong Zan, Andrew Yates, Dacheng Tao | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Dense retrievers have achieved impressive performance, but their demand for
abundant training data limits their application scenarios. Contrastive
pre-training, which constructs pseudo-positive examples from unlabeled data,
has shown great potential to solve this problem. However, the pseudo-positive
examples crafted by data augmentations can be irrelevant. To this end, we
propose relevance-aware contrastive learning. It takes the intermediate-trained
model itself as an imperfect oracle to estimate the relevance of positive pairs
and adaptively weighs the contrastive loss of different pairs according to the
estimated relevance. Our method consistently improves the SOTA unsupervised
Contriever model on the BEIR and open-domain QA retrieval benchmarks. Further
exploration shows that our method can not only beat BM25 after further
pre-training on the target corpus but also serves as a good few-shot learner.
Our code is publicly available at https://github.com/Yibin-Lei/ReContriever. | [
-0.3473756611,
-0.5590362549,
0.575973928,
-0.1482867897,
-0.4973167777,
-0.262414217,
-0.0943836719,
-0.3616808355,
0.3097470701,
0.5700951815,
-0.2125339359,
-0.3369710147,
-0.3720890582,
-0.2289834321,
-0.4473371506,
0.991452992,
0.427388519,
0.2447831631,
-0.1353592575,
-0.4761585295,
-0.3471440375,
-0.5002855062,
-0.5171474218,
-0.2120380104,
0.5108517408,
0.543225348,
0.6036202312,
0.2060478479,
0.5636228919,
0.2379945666,
-0.0026618668,
-0.0329963565,
-0.9574856758,
0.0242328774,
-0.4790780246,
-0.6767359972,
-0.0121705309,
-0.0699024126,
0.6614119411,
0.63270998,
-0.3320310414,
0.0151614528,
0.0458645336,
0.8575003743,
-0.901755929,
-0.3178304732,
-0.8705391884,
-0.1946145445,
-0.4101844728,
-0.2989762127,
-0.3442611098,
-0.3246972859,
0.3698169291,
-0.8194506764,
0.2635119855,
-0.0846021995,
0.8235341907,
0.3502016068,
-0.366787672,
-0.0203552842,
-0.6515727639,
0.7764641643,
-0.3811489642,
0.482008785,
0.3656141758,
0.5801280141,
0.0282097794,
-1.0617254972,
-0.5816340446,
0.0727211684,
-0.0244218875,
0.5552911162,
-0.067543596,
-0.0299136005,
0.1389368027,
0.6289909482,
-0.5591183305,
-0.0201916005,
-0.1992409527,
-0.0685263053,
0.2236504257,
-0.0667178258,
0.0126466686,
0.2201730907,
-0.2806921303,
-0.1041209549,
-0.7750914693,
-0.1456808001,
0.0990465507,
0.3028512001,
0.072590217,
0.5106458664,
-0.2782672346,
0.5373677611,
0.3492461145,
0.4359036088,
0.4948960245,
-0.413715601,
-0.0958854184,
0.0169525724,
0.3494212925,
0.0849388167,
-0.0722669885,
-0.1275024563,
-0.2880496085,
-0.0124482615,
0.4053316116,
-1.0505506992,
-0.5139465928,
0.1511313617,
-0.383982867,
0.2358941883,
0.0507257991,
-0.5668975711,
-0.3649352491,
-0.2288370132,
0.9702926278,
-0.5056310296,
-0.066787526,
0.3305814266,
0.0292106103,
0.3466738164,
0.3099392056,
-0.5652548075,
0.0495665334,
0.2942080498,
0.2821377218,
0.075115405,
-0.0010554109,
-0.9352016449,
-0.058442831,
-0.3787930608,
0.7915803194,
-0.6800908446,
-0.2193843275,
0.0985820293,
-0.139720276,
0.2536921203,
-0.8640521169,
0.829000175,
-1.0517673492,
0.2466194481,
-0.3798540533,
-0.6315454245,
-0.1920792758,
0.191776678,
-0.6011978984,
0.9369848371,
0.1763843745,
-0.7677479982,
0.4562697411,
-0.2248260975,
-0.2682420313,
0.1906607896,
-0.1919761747,
-0.7242194414,
0.1608755141,
0.0404988118,
0.3330420852,
-0.1940760314,
0.1787306964,
-0.4121907055,
-0.6846501231,
0.0235712472,
-0.0000151034,
0.5255568624,
0.2928554714,
-0.1416618377,
0.2103337497,
-0.671069324,
-0.1166083887,
0.082724914,
-0.2366017848,
-0.6069016457,
-0.2927713394,
-0.0073492867,
0.1025394797,
0.320595324,
-0.4556707442,
-0.234723404,
-0.3974705338,
-0.1962883621,
0.4587748051,
-0.0278042685,
0.5965183377,
-0.2041289061,
0.2258458883,
0.33986637,
0.09215004,
-0.1810644865,
-0.0250971038,
-0.792154789,
-0.3828568459,
0.5152649283,
0.3966561854,
-1.1067841053,
0.4290316403,
-0.1122739166,
-0.6436090469,
-0.5571228862,
0.2291578948,
0.6096032262,
0.691388607,
0.8059694171,
-0.3629297614,
-0.6929402947,
-0.6786486506,
-0.1051040217,
0.2537107766,
-0.1291495413,
0.5192266703,
0.2486156225,
-0.4859161079,
0.7452887893,
-0.6123200655,
-0.5969444513,
-0.1842133701,
0.0998118594,
0.4263624549,
0.5728540421,
0.5842109323,
-1.1522763968,
-0.5698340535,
-0.0970850363,
-0.7550470233,
0.1482448876,
0.090327844,
-0.3378683627,
-0.3554393947,
0.6140871048,
-0.4601257741,
0.3812058866,
0.1035442501,
-0.0079389689,
0.3868010938,
-0.4409345686,
0.1634240448,
-1.163334012,
0.2888458371,
-0.0714647248,
-0.2922406793,
-0.4934033751,
0.073400028,
0.1701041907,
-0.1354782134,
-0.5714927316,
0.5456916094,
-0.3982620835,
-0.2962031364,
-0.3661912382,
0.1658711135,
0.0019789157,
0.1994131356,
0.1463957727,
0.8619071841,
0.6320284605,
-0.8067995906,
-0.0920988768,
0.2572513223,
-0.4023540914,
0.5800102949,
-0.6344782114,
0.0457108207,
-0.3280164301,
0.1924017221,
-0.7954548597,
-0.015851954,
-0.0165003426,
-0.3102098107,
0.3537041545,
-0.0756599158,
-0.4179322422,
-0.075634405,
-0.3333788216,
0.7307651639,
0.474321574,
-0.8817580342,
0.4850266278,
0.3749929368,
0.0300787427,
-0.6629521251,
-0.4135039747,
-0.2512383461,
-0.2290501595,
-0.0269940607,
0.7589526772,
-0.3750448525,
0.1696078479,
-0.0671020001,
-0.243474409,
-0.2658787072,
0.1281019896,
-0.0543636158,
0.1102566198,
-0.2282923758,
0.1946869195,
-0.1254953146,
-0.217612341,
-0.1994830519,
-0.2165133059,
0.4250407219,
-0.1906336099,
-0.2563167512,
-0.2216626555,
0.0466480963,
-0.1180291176,
-0.3957826197,
0.6331940889,
0.975083828,
-0.5474502444,
0.1364590675,
-0.739012599,
-0.4673095047,
-0.471912235,
0.3490199447,
-0.3613227308,
-0.9693630934,
0.5911983848,
-0.0159640294,
-0.2682505846,
0.2915765941,
0.2783755958,
-0.2590559423,
0.697232306,
0.638857305,
0.1230559498,
0.8542401195,
-0.3427526653,
-0.0361512899,
-0.7700289488,
-0.1886558086,
-0.5039825439,
-0.0346580371,
-0.5883833766,
-0.2517420948,
0.2105554193,
0.3373574615,
-0.2228440195,
0.1524949819,
-0.3992872834,
0.6899776459,
0.576045692,
0.5455362201,
0.0579650141,
-0.26616171,
0.0660044551,
-0.1531367451,
-0.6268291473,
0.0303607862,
1.2234505415,
-0.181303829,
0.7249711156,
0.2392845303,
0.751568675,
0.2975054681,
0.4189583659,
-0.3760097325,
0.3518461585,
-0.4485613406,
-0.6333987117,
-0.1749224663,
-0.5109779835,
-1.2837355137,
0.2353453636,
-0.3455629051,
-0.2901346385,
0.6144741774,
0.2106064111,
-0.5848916173,
-0.1921293885,
-0.7235889435,
0.9723779559,
-0.181159094,
-0.6721622348,
-0.3783886731,
-0.9780778885,
0.1455406696,
-0.2348320782,
-0.2234934419,
0.1728335768,
-0.0501665995,
0.6530066729,
-0.1926113814,
0.4925392568,
-0.3486700654,
0.3803710341,
0.3413831294,
-0.0164193455,
0.2404057682,
0.23759453,
-0.3058006465,
-0.084955059,
-0.207028836,
-0.8817362189,
-0.6615141034,
0.6413992047,
-0.6202092767,
-0.520095706,
-0.354380995,
-0.1448087245,
-0.1287562847,
0.5816380382,
0.3465987742,
0.3687255681,
-0.268204987,
0.5558313131,
1.0686722994,
-0.0578859039,
0.1334522218,
0.7090395093,
-0.1340404004,
-0.3746949732,
1.0544121265,
0.0995402336,
-0.1187886819,
0.7793869376,
0.1272883713,
-0.5313340425,
-0.8233069777,
-0.1000069231,
0.1708548963,
-0.7688530684,
-0.3619813919,
-0.5465034842,
-0.0602646545,
-0.107033506,
-0.2135672271,
-0.4312885702,
0.0909681171,
-0.6554592252,
-0.0508417301,
0.0165413413,
0.3056727052,
-0.1003273204,
0.3643366992,
-0.7079892755,
0.4618041515,
0.4989252388,
0.2580184937,
-0.2430811673,
-0.9529227018,
-0.4305784106,
-0.0094296532,
-0.1618740857,
-0.4682599008,
0.3418604434,
0.2656678855,
0.7251660228,
0.4619653225,
0.3387030661,
0.697075665,
-0.1369791031,
0.3388906121,
0.1436289996,
-0.6152620912,
0.5844074488,
-0.1521286964,
0.2523349822,
1.1627312899,
0.635620594,
0.1859597713,
0.2393223494,
-0.6036755443,
-0.785136342,
0.5739402175,
0.0431708321,
0.0758058205,
-0.1321578026,
0.6681643724,
0.2543656528,
0.2285890579,
-0.7179476619,
-0.2578807771,
-0.4937734902,
-0.123302117,
-0.3066723645,
-0.4809227288,
0.1912868023,
-0.1022945046,
0.7575930357,
-0.215241462,
0.0656214505,
0.3398430049,
-0.4669387043,
0.2437849939,
0.1917536706,
0.2115453929,
0.5527043939,
-0.6354604363,
0.2881340981,
0.1247601733,
-0.3266796768,
-0.0111526921,
0.4771799445,
-0.1064359471,
-0.1875870526,
-0.1575482786,
0.4473199248,
0.4287172854,
-0.7163167596,
0.7351230979,
-0.2336358577,
0.2477070242,
-0.2418474406,
-0.1425286978,
-0.092552498,
0.3742431104,
0.498708576,
-0.0001936113,
0.6635674238,
-0.5595749617,
0.544968009,
0.4164292514,
-0.785783112,
-0.3769038022,
0.6045555472,
0.2637539804,
0.1549468189,
0.6824063063,
-0.4477093518,
-0.3347361982,
0.2644957304,
0.5694077611,
0.5224529505,
-0.3857056797,
-0.0778062716,
0.4464074671,
-0.0527820848,
-0.0613105036,
0.395432055,
-0.1578431129,
-0.8602944613,
-0.207091108,
-0.4209435284,
-0.2646780908,
0.1314718872,
-0.7706125975,
0.3672144115,
-0.2683864236,
-0.0836529732,
0.0160284583,
0.1782930195,
-0.7311791778,
0.5298417211,
-0.2929786742,
0.653960824,
-0.5751382113,
0.90035218,
0.7904618382,
-0.7781988978,
-0.2775137126,
0.1520734131,
-0.559622407,
-0.60956496,
0.4081521928,
0.3003414273,
-0.0702443942,
0.2560119927,
-0.2532495558,
-0.6475182772,
1.045442462,
0.7403637767,
-0.4045217633,
0.3494937122,
-0.4091758728,
0.7147274017,
-0.1857277006,
0.6731093526,
0.1910290867,
0.0869674534,
0.0829674378,
-0.255204767,
-0.0549546145,
-0.2481418103,
-0.1118013859,
0.0630451664,
-0.6914862394,
0.6635102034,
-0.2581436932,
-0.2805085182,
0.0845662504,
0.9417790174,
0.1936358213,
0.628236115,
0.3876136839,
0.6897879839,
0.6218351126,
0.1292466372,
0.9608264565,
-0.1850852072,
0.1982340068,
1.3076188564,
-0.4065465629,
0.9919409156,
0.3034478724,
-0.0464005657,
0.3446176946,
0.7905886769,
0.3286933303,
0.8002312779,
-0.074350968,
-0.2838240862,
-0.6208790541,
-0.3938097358,
-0.613876462,
0.2520723641,
0.3424676359,
-0.0917271301,
-0.174481526,
-0.051644247,
-0.3247689605,
0.3157915473,
-0.2865465283,
0.8983362913,
0.1584568769,
-0.5378060937,
0.6071915627,
-0.4310225844,
0.7045791745,
-0.5594536066,
-0.1229322776,
-0.4274150431,
0.2702245414,
-0.2944635451,
-0.6996833682,
0.140086323,
-0.5114198327,
-0.2616370022,
0.2240646929,
0.7797774076,
-0.5740713477,
-0.0885766894,
0.4100391567,
0.538222909,
0.083999455,
-0.3669593036,
-0.7417417765,
-0.2665843666,
-0.0575075485,
0.0331663862,
0.7295106053,
0.5703943372,
0.0734317452,
0.6353205442,
0.7247217894,
-0.3858878613,
-0.1564960033,
0.22977148,
1.0387843847,
-0.5997834802,
-0.454012841,
-0.4564693868,
0.281986177,
-0.0488304459,
-0.0669979081,
0.5880417824,
0.9919241667,
0.966566503,
-0.0491233654,
0.30794698,
0.3377398849,
0.6016190648,
-0.4623208642,
0.5103163123,
-0.8197478056,
0.3865654767,
-0.0806834102,
-1.1679093838,
-0.4132819474,
0.5051092505,
-0.2380356789,
0.2655356228,
0.501740098,
0.8775199056,
-0.3799030781,
-0.1890218258,
0.6035804749,
0.2318112999,
-0.038445387,
0.424258858,
0.6718071699,
-0.6286016703,
0.6570734382,
-0.2764830589,
-0.2374612987,
-0.5819865465,
-0.6752613187,
-0.732129395,
-0.6061194539,
-0.2211696357,
-0.2221844941,
0.3072465062,
0.5554180145,
0.802252233,
-0.7212299109,
0.1056424007,
-0.1211403236,
0.0605499223,
0.0012280798,
-0.1681007296,
0.5161348581,
-0.3284719288,
-0.4632182717,
0.3301531971,
0.1716921031,
0.0223529506,
0.0852321014,
-0.1247258335,
-0.4648768306,
-0.0219192319,
0.5086313486,
0.4170282185,
-0.274253428,
-0.1741191447,
-0.1830497086,
-0.1656676978,
0.2975132465,
0.6333176494,
-1.1188927889,
0.6536809802,
0.5075437427,
1.0952216387,
0.9519839883,
0.1799628735,
0.16885373,
-0.7335730791,
0.1153995544,
0.4556079507,
0.4861268699,
0.4787274897,
-0.3769095838,
0.5988755822,
0.2001425922,
-0.6273149848,
-0.6803503036,
0.1421840936,
-1.0228204727,
-0.1041607037,
0.6793087721,
-0.272074908,
-0.0372486785,
-0.2134706229,
-0.1709006578,
0.3348929882,
-0.5138500929,
0.8957653046,
0.0125123411,
-0.0025405032,
-0.1603013575,
-0.0103694927,
0.4116906822,
0.9702336192,
-0.898178041,
-0.2017303854,
0.3341985345,
0.0796205178,
0.171439752,
0.8441784978,
-0.0692737028,
0.6611360312,
-0.0744678974,
0.1342735738,
0.207160607,
-0.3440825641,
-0.3438095152,
-0.0237494148,
0.2439073622,
-0.0882215649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03091v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03091v2 | RepoBench: Benchmarking Repository-Level Code Auto-Completion Systems | 2023-06-05T17:59:41 | 2023-10-04T01:13:49 | Tianyang Liu, Canwen Xu, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Large Language Models (LLMs) have greatly advanced code auto-completion
systems, with a potential for substantial productivity enhancements for
developers. However, current benchmarks mainly focus on single-file tasks,
leaving an assessment gap for more complex, real-world, multi-file programming
scenarios. To fill this gap, we introduce RepoBench, a new benchmark
specifically designed for evaluating repository-level code auto-completion
systems. RepoBench supports both Python and Java and consists of three
interconnected evaluation tasks: RepoBench-R (Retrieval), RepoBench-C (Code
Completion), and RepoBench-P (Pipeline). Each task respectively measures the
system's ability to retrieve the most relevant code snippets from other files
as cross-file context, predict the next line of code with cross-file and
in-file context, and handle complex tasks that require a combination of both
retrieval and next-line prediction. RepoBench aims to facilitate a more
complete comparison of performance and encouraging continuous improvement in
auto-completion systems. RepoBench is publicly available at
https://github.com/Leolty/repobench. | [
-0.4108550549,
-0.0362219028,
0.0724208578,
0.5116471648,
-0.0812247768,
0.4998165369,
-0.1629515439,
-0.4835138619,
0.1292019486,
0.5043615699,
-0.3640165925,
-0.4612238407,
-0.2729547918,
0.4716041088,
-0.7520580888,
0.5618256927,
-0.1274344027,
-0.0742594898,
-0.2219495028,
-0.3155315816,
-0.5789039731,
-0.3362288177,
-0.1364991516,
-0.4160438478,
0.5569208264,
0.3749224842,
0.4148593247,
0.7081573606,
0.6704024673,
0.302533865,
0.4777985215,
-0.2161106169,
-0.4431724548,
0.7234749794,
-0.0960352793,
-0.3112849295,
-0.0075587248,
-0.0021648509,
0.5900604129,
0.3688755035,
-0.2547645569,
0.4577478468,
0.0454823375,
0.8195459843,
-1.0994353294,
-0.0906327367,
-0.2495212257,
0.204236418,
-0.0749681666,
-0.2796516418,
-0.1682132632,
-0.8478272557,
0.2610108554,
-0.3949318528,
-0.0312922075,
0.0803879648,
0.6993095875,
0.5935424566,
-0.0854926929,
-0.1020800844,
-0.2300014496,
0.4583698213,
-0.6168317795,
0.5009219646,
0.2156678736,
0.3393351734,
-0.1132721007,
-0.84275949,
-0.1467268318,
-0.4272217453,
-0.2119892985,
0.0033052003,
-0.0630654022,
-0.1601308584,
0.4392210245,
0.6155927181,
-0.747527957,
-0.0739455298,
-0.0257393736,
-0.150771752,
0.2566628158,
0.0220026094,
0.0802102461,
-0.353643328,
-0.3538659513,
-0.2875137627,
-0.712557137,
0.0031457341,
0.3815168738,
0.0234919786,
0.1533058286,
0.5662602782,
-0.5742024779,
0.6793779731,
-0.224215582,
0.2545755208,
0.4701629579,
-0.2562367618,
-0.3553151488,
-0.2355753779,
0.759629786,
0.3198662698,
0.0309070181,
-0.4208550453,
-0.3149597943,
-0.1640767753,
0.5411963463,
-0.9118717909,
-0.5732660294,
0.2904195189,
-0.4628282189,
-0.19745107,
0.0186815523,
-0.878908515,
-0.7376494408,
-0.2044584006,
0.3417386413,
-0.4381610155,
-0.35726282,
-0.2781425416,
-0.184517771,
0.1494144201,
0.2681375146,
-0.4254346192,
0.1154554933,
1.0458276272,
0.8069446087,
-0.1227623299,
-0.5887019038,
-0.8679478168,
0.000034702,
-0.3440965712,
0.8141474724,
-0.4845094681,
-0.1681948304,
0.0769963861,
-0.0529754274,
0.2265800834,
-0.7258065939,
0.0939745679,
-0.4218255877,
-0.1069448888,
-0.177015543,
-0.6589382887,
-0.0336357318,
0.2679593563,
-0.6647148728,
1.584707737,
0.5207085609,
-0.7537087798,
0.4899635613,
-0.0233472306,
-0.3413842916,
0.1562918276,
-0.3252629936,
-0.2272796035,
0.0526014976,
-0.2362331003,
0.2719453275,
-0.5470297933,
0.0705527291,
-0.585714817,
-0.6496148109,
0.1703086346,
0.0851356089,
0.5296564102,
0.2655532658,
-0.46994856,
0.0157098547,
-0.5251081586,
0.3524903655,
-0.3183866441,
-0.606951952,
-0.4170536399,
-0.3304549754,
-0.0204560906,
0.0914147198,
0.6093016267,
-0.4917595088,
0.6085981727,
0.020517813,
0.3567554057,
0.5781878233,
-0.4611735046,
0.3736597896,
-0.2794882357,
0.640321672,
-0.686529696,
0.2158066034,
-0.4265219867,
0.0160593335,
-0.6451839805,
-0.415722549,
0.480261147,
0.6303466558,
-0.3875110447,
0.4141440094,
-0.0682914555,
-0.7631790638,
-0.4374961555,
0.3853868246,
0.8587142825,
0.1566472054,
0.2098108679,
-0.5170784593,
-0.7855033278,
-0.9359551668,
-0.4418850839,
-0.3802417815,
-0.0903811455,
0.3342620432,
0.5330039859,
-0.363242358,
0.8091349006,
-0.2234422863,
-0.1236927509,
0.0247370116,
0.3528165221,
0.2984472811,
0.5050724149,
0.3362050354,
-0.3736982644,
-0.4476883709,
-0.0368232951,
-0.7255870104,
-0.5669534802,
0.004539297,
-0.0005916297,
0.2030664086,
0.7577438354,
-0.1600162834,
0.3709149063,
0.8770176172,
-0.0001145068,
0.6677966714,
-0.31276384,
0.4602743685,
-0.6378756762,
0.452172488,
-0.3076685369,
-0.2078430653,
0.088249743,
0.3255319893,
0.6343485117,
-0.0031810224,
-0.1008028537,
0.242398724,
-0.5169897676,
-0.7878793478,
-0.0927211866,
-0.080615133,
0.1645618528,
0.2467455715,
-0.1189660877,
1.0085828304,
0.3481016159,
-0.310108155,
0.7010576725,
-0.3244341016,
-0.676318109,
0.3373283148,
-0.6383593678,
-0.03796345,
0.4801083505,
0.388370961,
-1.2730666399,
-0.1000204533,
-0.1069807112,
-0.410711199,
0.1227261499,
-0.5408437252,
-0.7522128224,
-0.5969904661,
-0.2573689818,
0.4214745462,
0.3020190895,
-0.5249660611,
0.4767047167,
0.3457871974,
-0.1425268501,
-0.9910382628,
-0.6203416586,
0.2655130029,
0.0384692848,
-0.1115118638,
0.1663462967,
0.161506325,
0.13298361,
0.0147409765,
-0.3237682879,
-0.1552740633,
0.2254155725,
0.5940896273,
0.0681328848,
0.0279130023,
0.1153440475,
-0.1372713298,
-0.3303593099,
-0.1182661057,
-0.3045276701,
0.648807168,
-0.3135282695,
-0.4400652647,
-0.2163735181,
0.1091687977,
0.6072657108,
-0.1567911059,
0.1429049075,
0.3783641756,
-0.2043685466,
-0.0278298389,
-0.9258601069,
0.0390171073,
-0.4169358909,
0.2444899231,
-0.4886158109,
-0.8741598725,
0.442974925,
-0.3248248696,
0.3195670545,
-0.0935277641,
0.2874493003,
-0.0427462645,
0.4628269672,
0.4763135016,
-0.3532710075,
0.6315137744,
-0.3499157429,
-0.0010276542,
-0.8943949938,
-0.0856993496,
-0.9026386142,
-0.2440892011,
-0.5130200982,
-0.3847731948,
-0.1054070219,
0.5053071976,
-0.4229816794,
1.2996946573,
-0.767401576,
0.4825436473,
0.7692840099,
-0.3045131266,
0.4036441445,
-0.2182563692,
-0.3963624835,
0.0144685125,
-0.5067003965,
-0.2366054505,
1.1649296284,
0.2269127071,
0.9124327302,
-0.0822743699,
1.1771987677,
0.4198849797,
0.7032567263,
-0.2533197999,
0.3991364241,
-0.0480620675,
-0.647462666,
-0.3209711313,
-0.506965816,
-0.899307847,
0.4379267693,
0.0319412537,
-0.6164549589,
0.2373536676,
0.0546773523,
-0.4585784674,
0.0151076885,
-0.7803142667,
1.0256773233,
-0.2600975335,
-0.4702767432,
-0.400404036,
-0.3077785969,
0.1465804726,
-0.0164193232,
0.0236376897,
-0.2901614308,
-0.3857750297,
0.4865096509,
-0.3484062552,
0.3161716461,
-0.0902343765,
-0.1684233695,
0.0049439403,
0.5032578707,
0.3732104301,
0.339369446,
-0.352127552,
0.2016427964,
0.2980239689,
-0.1912815869,
-0.3567679822,
0.9575349689,
-0.6935126185,
-0.3732659519,
-0.5474284291,
-0.2987567782,
0.0710400343,
0.3932441771,
0.2003070265,
0.5022788048,
-0.0670140535,
0.4379564524,
0.3703408837,
-0.4607860446,
0.4588744044,
0.7453659773,
-0.5870748162,
-0.6613515615,
0.6958326101,
-0.079980202,
-0.003973959,
0.5619053841,
-0.2096511573,
-0.3985474408,
-0.2949104607,
-0.401167959,
0.077471979,
-0.6543542147,
-0.5861057043,
-0.6998860836,
0.0610948391,
-0.5196247101,
-0.1736946404,
-0.7277063131,
-0.225986734,
0.2223220468,
0.2619030476,
0.4446521401,
0.6715036631,
-0.2646026611,
-0.1606027931,
-0.7722651362,
0.4109942317,
0.2276052386,
0.7677822709,
-0.0803300589,
-0.332549125,
-0.3747830391,
-0.502512455,
-0.2080353945,
-0.6136193871,
0.379060179,
-0.2142201513,
0.5441316366,
0.0578860343,
0.1634614021,
0.7547482252,
-0.3073559999,
0.2554608583,
0.2131544501,
-0.8401430249,
0.5156354904,
-0.1963527203,
0.3404715061,
0.9991149902,
-0.0379291512,
-0.69045192,
-0.6511918306,
-0.178280279,
-0.9823530316,
0.4542259872,
0.1910030544,
-0.4832390547,
0.2059089392,
0.2004117221,
0.3188008368,
0.4283237159,
-0.653916955,
-0.2082008123,
-0.2844207883,
0.250807941,
0.0766219944,
0.0368439741,
-0.014512768,
-0.0528950021,
0.3018414676,
0.0066276859,
0.2881405652,
0.3014931381,
-0.3359997869,
-0.1983986199,
0.0728688315,
0.0857126564,
0.713152349,
-0.59348768,
-0.0006872652,
-0.018351648,
-0.2869119048,
0.099968642,
0.3929813802,
-0.0228478201,
0.0406210311,
0.4487389624,
0.1975711584,
0.5080123544,
-0.8423594832,
0.359616816,
-0.2875216007,
0.033662241,
-0.528652072,
0.194890365,
-0.00136744,
0.4466320574,
0.7974663377,
0.0716303214,
0.2966791093,
-0.4672084749,
0.4676217139,
0.1668558568,
-0.2351390123,
0.2708378732,
0.3223486245,
0.3668150902,
-0.2214732766,
0.5628402233,
0.0195094831,
-0.4256420732,
0.8180636168,
0.0082355319,
1.1994152069,
-0.0989048555,
-0.0531108044,
0.6579092145,
0.3353955448,
-0.2038575262,
0.1005349085,
-0.3268913329,
-0.1731266379,
-0.5561613441,
-0.5924062133,
-0.5964133739,
-0.0729971975,
-0.7783959508,
0.0699451044,
-0.4206912518,
-0.1501460075,
-0.3566808999,
0.3547929227,
-0.5395739675,
-0.1187171042,
0.0225164816,
1.3138566017,
-0.509303987,
1.0513515472,
0.5846343637,
-0.2660108805,
-0.5151729584,
-0.0728420466,
-0.1692632139,
-0.5502539277,
0.6674845219,
0.5185462236,
-0.1401752383,
-0.2037841827,
-0.0003573162,
-1.1255909204,
1.0702265501,
0.22499457,
-0.7716591954,
0.0092326785,
-0.177363798,
0.4419848919,
-0.418963939,
0.7081719041,
0.6252983809,
0.5439424515,
-0.3728215694,
-1.0569326878,
0.0073940726,
-0.5018191934,
0.3019274473,
0.337369144,
-0.5542425513,
0.9090666771,
0.0050560157,
-0.0905928835,
0.5621558428,
0.4128508866,
0.4616118968,
0.1308571845,
0.6173216701,
0.6702709198,
0.5304672122,
-0.2248807698,
1.189145565,
-0.6996794939,
0.4405018985,
1.3758968115,
-0.5038428307,
1.0298217535,
0.3519709706,
-0.2720794082,
0.730730474,
0.7612714767,
-0.1086776331,
0.5399757624,
0.4639552832,
0.1473742574,
-0.1901209354,
0.0835391432,
-0.9294842482,
-0.0373543538,
0.1189382374,
-0.0699608028,
-0.1011436284,
-0.2767379582,
-0.5833736062,
-0.0577671416,
0.1060392559,
0.6254153848,
-0.0993307903,
-0.9972417951,
0.7283278108,
-0.3989382684,
0.6898421049,
-0.4677934349,
0.0282505695,
-0.5020512342,
0.3647850454,
-0.2013980746,
-0.8077389002,
0.0519388095,
0.0158794802,
-0.0436612442,
-0.3201900721,
0.4327807128,
-0.1793421954,
-0.0029922524,
0.864178896,
0.1985929608,
-0.0672224015,
-0.1581348181,
-0.9626738429,
0.3661816716,
-0.1513688266,
-0.373588115,
0.4184630811,
0.5334455967,
0.2998459041,
1.133713007,
0.4879336357,
-0.0508615896,
0.1278089583,
0.0298783071,
0.804441452,
-0.756003201,
-0.3655780554,
-0.5034554005,
0.0377741866,
-0.1598603725,
-0.3999790549,
0.8563377261,
1.0642291307,
1.0293016434,
-0.0478633568,
0.77845186,
-0.4084445834,
0.8972500563,
-0.0289701112,
0.4546557367,
-0.7424537539,
0.3227801621,
-0.5297656655,
-1.1175830364,
-0.1541487724,
0.7748549581,
-0.1755077392,
-0.1479779631,
0.8376007676,
0.9315989017,
0.1981369406,
-0.1521336287,
0.190632686,
-0.0328739397,
0.0333498344,
0.6797032952,
1.2467067242,
-0.531301558,
0.9805501103,
-0.4417962134,
-0.2452680618,
-0.6753982902,
-0.8488015532,
-0.5312725902,
-0.4070347846,
-0.356878072,
-0.4948278666,
0.12819767,
0.7681378722,
0.8038600087,
-0.8648596406,
-0.6265015602,
-0.2814685702,
0.1826568842,
-0.3391362727,
-0.1657645404,
0.035578344,
-0.4976326823,
-0.5290687084,
0.2172240317,
0.6781746745,
-0.3660905361,
-0.4389779568,
-0.146200031,
-0.1178687885,
-0.6590083241,
0.2355752438,
0.6443988681,
-0.7106178403,
0.0120935682,
0.0364782959,
-0.7267031074,
-0.1255862117,
1.2178890705,
-1.0925633907,
0.276111871,
0.7701398134,
0.7000314593,
0.2712080479,
-0.1020980552,
0.7609115243,
-0.4268024862,
0.0457883365,
0.1311589628,
0.4491319358,
0.132237196,
-0.0852612332,
0.9708079696,
-0.0104646236,
-0.6555883288,
-1.0072823763,
0.0080189398,
-0.5156587362,
-0.3714020848,
0.859308064,
-0.5453867912,
0.0627409741,
-0.2549362481,
-0.1371430755,
0.2632116675,
-0.6306393147,
0.7954697609,
0.483882457,
0.1405727863,
-0.2657475471,
-0.5766956806,
0.4046657681,
0.5457544923,
-0.6439375281,
0.5264015198,
0.6414749622,
0.1989579499,
0.1163883433,
0.5357363224,
-0.0456327386,
0.6031609178,
-0.1870776862,
0.3738683462,
0.1092901006,
-0.423437655,
-0.1580433547,
0.2322455645,
-0.0753733367,
-0.0048529571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03090v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03090v1 | Is ChatGPT a Good Teacher Coach? Measuring Zero-Shot Performance For Scoring and Providing Actionable Insights on Classroom Instruction | 2023-06-05T17:59:21 | 2023-06-05T17:59:21 | Rose E. Wang, Dorottya Demszky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Coaching, which involves classroom observation and expert feedback, is a
widespread and fundamental part of teacher training. However, the majority of
teachers do not have access to consistent, high quality coaching due to limited
resources and access to expertise. We explore whether generative AI could
become a cost-effective complement to expert feedback by serving as an
automated teacher coach. In doing so, we propose three teacher coaching tasks
for generative AI: (A) scoring transcript segments based on classroom
observation instruments, (B) identifying highlights and missed opportunities
for good instructional strategies, and (C) providing actionable suggestions for
eliciting more student reasoning. We recruit expert math teachers to evaluate
the zero-shot performance of ChatGPT on each of these tasks for elementary math
classroom transcripts. Our results reveal that ChatGPT generates responses that
are relevant to improving instruction, but they are often not novel or
insightful. For example, 82% of the model's suggestions point to places in the
transcript where the teacher is already implementing that suggestion. Our work
highlights the challenges of producing insightful, novel and truthful feedback
for teachers while paving the way for future research to address these
obstacles and improve the capacity of generative AI to coach teachers. | [
-0.3350405395,
-0.735717237,
0.3391768634,
-0.0329375118,
-0.2276144177,
0.1612650901,
-0.1729270667,
-0.0508826636,
0.0845925137,
-0.0455895737,
-0.3416641355,
-0.4119648635,
-0.7956421375,
-0.2352984399,
-0.7985069156,
1.2680231333,
0.1149415001,
0.4838185608,
-0.4108999968,
0.2408053428,
-1.0267980099,
-0.2632946074,
-0.9054304957,
-0.3496910632,
0.1446882635,
0.9161071777,
0.6575413346,
0.4282057285,
0.5063752532,
0.2347387671,
0.3304803371,
0.1607906669,
-0.4339296818,
0.2761175632,
-0.0589292534,
-0.6982371211,
-0.4159513116,
0.4203743935,
0.5530577302,
0.8055059314,
-0.5539206862,
0.0403028503,
0.2293151468,
0.3904750943,
-0.4865849316,
0.4451040924,
-0.6058138609,
0.4473998547,
0.109916389,
-0.2668276727,
-0.418700844,
-0.619930923,
0.2472174019,
-0.5554518104,
0.6732836366,
-0.2746017277,
0.4272961617,
0.5576554537,
-0.0955516398,
-0.4278891981,
-0.9510672092,
0.6757901311,
-0.4054784775,
-0.0793431252,
0.5470172167,
0.647179842,
-0.0577989742,
-0.2121036351,
-0.5110146999,
-0.1440900564,
0.2411687523,
0.8549922705,
-0.0344340801,
-0.06474749,
0.1601409763,
0.3754371405,
-0.2913135588,
-0.0031384537,
-0.2720807493,
0.0574847683,
0.5965598822,
0.2988716662,
0.3784901202,
0.1486970484,
-0.1283603907,
0.0548345633,
-0.4645123482,
0.0263904762,
0.3828005195,
0.235860154,
-0.1138470918,
0.4242528379,
-0.1868099421,
0.6953747869,
-0.0915197507,
0.1339735091,
-0.4697719514,
0.0591650642,
0.2833503783,
0.2989012897,
0.5111699104,
0.4660809338,
0.4036616385,
-0.5903075933,
-0.1186899319,
0.3878618479,
0.3870843351,
-0.7975930572,
-0.8078677058,
-0.1285273731,
0.0596817397,
-0.4441996217,
0.1042646766,
-0.869717598,
-0.3091771603,
-0.4905342162,
0.4701706171,
-0.7016731501,
-0.1237517372,
-0.1979960054,
-0.347414881,
0.4399873912,
0.8768327236,
-1.0966956615,
0.144362092,
0.6564065218,
0.9806270599,
-0.1512872428,
-0.4547667801,
-0.7098684907,
-0.1263939589,
-0.5716984868,
1.1619603634,
-0.7361412644,
-0.8456360102,
0.0202404503,
-0.4451182187,
-0.2425938249,
-0.4176607728,
0.2429793328,
-0.2006026208,
0.5455434322,
-0.073636353,
-0.8932622075,
0.2066484392,
0.4195026457,
-0.3332083821,
0.933426857,
0.3340499997,
-0.2320464849,
0.5394307375,
-0.6919264793,
-0.2711293399,
0.4758168459,
-0.3194816709,
-0.353556931,
-0.0119220493,
0.4479387403,
0.1188789532,
-0.1633676291,
0.0954861939,
-0.0267833602,
-0.6508418918,
0.2414804846,
-0.6520941257,
0.3264522552,
-0.0001357443,
-0.545179069,
-0.0235683043,
-0.5339406133,
0.2799651623,
-0.124384895,
-0.2223597467,
0.2348626852,
-0.0536741167,
-0.3544493616,
-0.3166358173,
-0.396037817,
-0.4051103592,
0.5183807611,
-0.2334342897,
0.2326532602,
0.8273293972,
0.1398290247,
0.5020493865,
-0.3933729529,
0.9733083248,
-0.2922296226,
0.0450653546,
-0.3532574773,
-0.6633116603,
-0.9866186976,
-0.3477358818,
0.5113216639,
0.4221830964,
-0.866663754,
0.0396190546,
-0.2527212203,
-0.5826652646,
-0.7805463076,
-0.0003629173,
0.3905365467,
0.7691637874,
0.261040926,
-0.5550504327,
-0.1053823829,
-0.3123549521,
-0.3779234588,
0.133283928,
-0.0433628894,
0.3157390058,
0.4406916201,
0.4923331439,
1.1540291309,
-0.7200777531,
-0.5115092993,
-0.0710735768,
0.3498751223,
0.114143759,
0.5441455841,
0.6329087019,
-0.3489066362,
-0.9157047272,
-0.2710443139,
-0.7665889859,
0.1843232214,
0.0642613173,
-0.2816030979,
-0.1345068812,
0.1523938477,
-0.76531744,
0.5611753464,
0.1228045151,
-0.2083350569,
0.4840425551,
-0.1727982759,
0.183779344,
-0.6580481529,
-0.0182487462,
-0.4109810591,
-0.1524250358,
-0.4753981233,
-0.1889836341,
-0.3016949892,
-0.7128545642,
-0.1552954912,
0.1668479741,
-0.1463740915,
0.0147585198,
-0.4478461146,
0.0860648155,
-0.3673688769,
0.5849075317,
-0.0586672388,
1.0797777176,
0.5990604162,
-0.3831966221,
0.6346728206,
0.3121487796,
-0.4989349246,
0.8796923757,
-0.6572619081,
0.3166687489,
-0.2700911164,
0.3908397555,
-0.8750758767,
-0.2268140763,
0.3977334201,
-0.8977532387,
0.3402307928,
-0.4313500226,
-0.2693183124,
-0.20099172,
-0.2150916457,
0.0372408144,
0.709484458,
-0.3669212461,
0.3047254086,
0.0292095039,
-0.1046643555,
-0.4214614332,
-0.3115391731,
0.0732216015,
0.2925238907,
-0.0604923889,
0.2285662889,
-0.0271294452,
0.1694283783,
0.5903199315,
-0.1648095697,
-0.1575344801,
0.2118784636,
0.1544127464,
0.3465383053,
-0.2129631341,
0.1147360578,
-0.2954067588,
-0.5627462864,
0.1139627695,
-0.3988094628,
0.3859725296,
-0.0160891768,
-0.5821380019,
-0.4698666334,
0.3718643188,
0.3598285019,
-0.2001778632,
0.6245669127,
0.7649140954,
-0.0613378361,
-0.5130640864,
-0.1533832252,
-0.4101955891,
-0.3513270915,
0.0777094662,
-0.0063245716,
-0.5595964193,
0.0669893622,
0.0878253132,
0.0855079964,
0.2381019592,
0.4610502124,
-0.2425730675,
1.3216676712,
0.329365015,
-0.1427451223,
0.5938120484,
-0.8700489402,
0.3370141089,
-0.3932261467,
-0.348720938,
-0.4596770406,
-0.2539132535,
-0.3036072254,
-0.1627430618,
0.4068772495,
0.081156455,
-0.1442213356,
-0.0480987467,
-0.9605717659,
0.7439288497,
1.1559202671,
0.1490688175,
-0.0053375354,
-0.2592312396,
0.2414594293,
0.0348205306,
-0.9349847436,
-0.2478548437,
0.8027968407,
-0.1230520904,
0.6741130948,
0.3168633878,
0.6966364384,
0.2381656319,
0.6543186903,
-1.0182499886,
0.4218987226,
0.0420229286,
-0.6875396371,
-0.5324851871,
-0.2168889195,
-0.6348087788,
0.2073011994,
-0.1705416888,
-0.2982368767,
-0.3562290072,
0.3395704329,
-0.5286878347,
0.2707493901,
-1.0243186951,
0.9001398683,
-0.0176951736,
-0.2216205597,
-0.1592712253,
-0.276991725,
0.0690120235,
0.2341861427,
-0.2439632416,
-0.1910767704,
0.2952953875,
0.5527866483,
-0.8573744297,
0.9208707809,
-0.6344456673,
0.1006530896,
0.7229613066,
0.1718790233,
0.1176723316,
-0.0496303625,
0.0703024268,
-0.2503254414,
-0.0112493262,
-0.6956553459,
-1.2061353922,
0.4056966007,
-1.0064412355,
-0.911270678,
-0.5308783054,
-0.4637460709,
-0.4329030514,
-0.0280962624,
0.3602338731,
0.3555442393,
0.1973242462,
0.1930168718,
0.4836175144,
0.2890103459,
0.5460819006,
0.3801825345,
0.2719134688,
-0.3503316343,
1.3772017956,
0.4073448479,
-0.0910408497,
0.2701955736,
0.2206128687,
-0.0178481527,
-0.3494355977,
-0.7297277451,
-0.2737802863,
-0.6014143825,
-0.5038861036,
-0.0938796327,
-0.3438779116,
-0.4690684974,
-0.2482962906,
-0.3483165503,
-0.5307871103,
-0.3435869813,
-0.2155320197,
0.2625236511,
0.5786334276,
-0.02402623,
0.4773836732,
-0.62047261,
-0.263545543,
0.748100996,
0.5147711635,
0.4479720294,
-0.5002800226,
-0.2404409051,
0.0428868644,
-0.6504983306,
-0.5597082973,
0.3496473432,
0.4820935726,
0.3762061298,
0.4874845445,
0.0216108281,
0.6681162715,
-0.5406076908,
1.032153368,
0.2339933366,
-0.7292454839,
0.6748310924,
-0.2242762893,
0.4437244534,
0.1595436484,
0.3247232437,
-0.4199655056,
-0.5214422941,
-0.4614776969,
-0.4148436785,
1.1864247322,
0.2345846444,
0.6858733892,
-0.0480847657,
0.3228906095,
0.1219054684,
0.3326168954,
-0.2957684398,
-0.181378752,
-0.7563707829,
-0.2253936082,
0.0624533556,
-0.1847956032,
-0.2584016919,
-0.2955101728,
0.5943691134,
-0.1722693443,
0.6470608711,
-0.0085131284,
0.267427206,
-0.0168874413,
0.2176223397,
0.5137700438,
0.3928384781,
-0.0798606724,
0.1902051568,
0.3498518765,
-0.5237038136,
0.0192050226,
-0.0171985608,
-0.1726831496,
0.0554639101,
0.7508541346,
0.7315459251,
0.4053223133,
-0.2919651568,
0.7432528138,
-0.0114585105,
-0.4520705044,
-0.5488721132,
0.6283891201,
-0.3120343685,
0.0429797359,
0.2923009098,
0.1123543084,
-0.0800170451,
-0.5170333385,
0.0136988061,
0.3701200187,
-0.7002242208,
-0.4245862067,
0.7461571097,
0.4107783735,
-0.6455219984,
1.0973653793,
-0.0435348041,
-0.723036468,
0.6634722948,
0.5168007016,
0.8442106843,
-0.3573116064,
0.6852202415,
0.3141894042,
-0.1310127974,
0.271879673,
0.1222770214,
-0.6628555059,
-0.6985611916,
-0.1854327917,
0.0239137691,
-0.914711535,
-0.4517627656,
-0.7057417631,
0.2733584344,
-0.4279848635,
-0.0019123117,
0.2171155661,
-0.0738314986,
-0.5169346929,
0.2293256074,
-0.1360676736,
0.3053832054,
-0.4584984481,
0.6355927587,
0.611531496,
-0.8814134598,
-0.9915556908,
-0.1571852714,
-0.0660891756,
-1.1470217705,
0.6007932425,
0.0195275694,
-0.1473816484,
0.2428687811,
-0.6763663292,
-0.4033997655,
0.9790418148,
0.4131276608,
-0.086261265,
-0.2742216885,
0.1674928963,
0.6893813014,
-0.1738884449,
0.8710224628,
0.0975336432,
0.1074045673,
0.5728936791,
-0.4053403139,
-0.471845448,
-0.1077311188,
-0.168174684,
0.2461265922,
-0.7583859563,
0.5598146915,
-0.3529026806,
-0.1704995632,
-0.0108963046,
0.4862053692,
-0.3787838519,
0.5130665898,
0.2581638992,
0.7035040259,
0.5900105834,
-0.1038682312,
1.1147507429,
-0.5356183648,
0.5238034725,
0.9808158875,
-0.0318390541,
0.6504292488,
0.1787542552,
-0.4058313966,
0.3412511349,
0.4201846421,
-0.3992196321,
0.5719692111,
0.0665381774,
-0.7005351782,
-0.4516717494,
-0.3007160127,
-0.2596252561,
0.5303388834,
0.1570487916,
-0.047520142,
-0.40066275,
0.035974253,
0.045521941,
0.0433284044,
-0.2031000108,
0.7833209634,
0.0248969179,
-1.1285904646,
0.1958466768,
-0.2668646276,
0.0143801356,
-0.1732066572,
-0.5950398445,
-0.5639719963,
0.2392045259,
-0.3563168049,
-0.8123553991,
0.0826257467,
0.1464843899,
0.012936268,
-0.3635043502,
0.218884781,
-0.5664502382,
-0.1572863311,
-0.3752618134,
0.4754287601,
0.1295416802,
0.1374171078,
-0.4146177769,
-0.547077477,
-0.0503074378,
0.2718087435,
0.1504633129,
0.3903357685,
0.3452413082,
0.52286762,
0.6718423963,
0.0120708542,
-0.1108672619,
0.37417835,
0.5751852393,
-0.5416266322,
-0.2838972807,
-0.7346027493,
0.4214451611,
-0.1748760939,
-0.5911000967,
0.865753293,
0.4672444761,
0.7915689945,
-0.1477272958,
0.7218297124,
0.1500734091,
0.6760000587,
-0.3605527282,
0.5380898714,
-0.0790649801,
-0.0133431694,
-0.1676784754,
-1.000297308,
-0.4254834652,
0.6446959376,
-0.4821842909,
0.0522727668,
0.543163538,
0.4945746064,
0.1124153435,
0.4658802748,
0.3985753059,
-0.291610539,
0.6530638933,
0.4636886716,
1.1872063875,
-0.1785070449,
0.8505635858,
-0.2512373626,
-0.3950447738,
-0.217462495,
-0.3752863705,
-0.8312385082,
-0.3946953416,
-0.605104506,
-0.1018014625,
0.1344388723,
0.7287039757,
0.7154152393,
-0.7022289038,
-0.037457414,
-0.502314508,
0.0738712177,
-0.0883143544,
-0.3288884759,
0.4818436801,
-0.7681763768,
-0.9375066161,
0.0774591416,
-0.070077382,
0.0924689174,
-0.1077874824,
0.0881502181,
0.4515792131,
-0.0833948255,
0.7019901276,
0.1834007204,
-0.469611913,
-0.5629022121,
0.1389288157,
0.0316492282,
-0.0882536024,
0.8309755921,
-0.6255541444,
0.7813856602,
0.0627117753,
0.9529754519,
0.5820863247,
0.1187715232,
0.5884267092,
-0.4959789813,
-0.0691090003,
0.664413929,
-0.0426281318,
0.1534947753,
-0.1418204606,
0.7963321805,
0.5238072872,
-0.6361503601,
-0.7473933697,
-0.1607866585,
-0.5142788887,
0.1234361008,
0.7031334639,
-0.3615208864,
0.1224491596,
0.2795169055,
-0.4456450641,
0.1220907569,
-0.4038627148,
1.1889206171,
1.1006548405,
-0.5254706144,
-0.2493344992,
-0.5824355483,
0.4267960787,
0.6788468361,
-0.5311116576,
-0.4428178966,
0.3763306439,
-0.1101488695,
-0.1568888575,
0.5689367652,
0.1563973427,
0.6199143529,
0.5035662651,
-0.0445501022,
-0.0268731844,
-0.2684660554,
-0.0000332243,
0.0378096402,
0.2895427048,
-0.6865730882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03081v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03081v2 | Sequential Monte Carlo Steering of Large Language Models using Probabilistic Programs | 2023-06-05T17:55:05 | 2023-11-26T21:40:00 | Alexander K. Lew, Tan Zhi-Xuan, Gabriel Grand, Vikash K. Mansinghka | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL, stat.CO | Even after fine-tuning and reinforcement learning, large language models
(LLMs) can be difficult, if not impossible, to control reliably with prompts
alone. We propose a new inference-time approach to enforcing syntactic and
semantic constraints on the outputs of LLMs, called sequential Monte Carlo
(SMC) steering. The key idea is to specify language generation tasks as
posterior inference problems in a class of discrete probabilistic sequence
models, and replace standard decoding with sequential Monte Carlo inference.
For a computational cost similar to that of beam search, SMC can steer LLMs to
solve diverse tasks, including infilling, generation under syntactic
constraints, and prompt intersection. To facilitate experimentation with SMC
steering, we present a probabilistic programming library, LLaMPPL
(https://github.com/probcomp/hfppl), for concisely specifying new generation
tasks as language model probabilistic programs, and automating steering of
LLaMA-family Transformers. | [
-0.1581888944,
-0.7172561884,
0.8985345364,
0.4911704659,
-0.1267574281,
0.1877260059,
-0.3094593585,
0.0339817517,
-0.0234360229,
0.6165941954,
-0.8187794089,
-0.4293434918,
-0.6127484441,
-0.0816062912,
-0.404797554,
0.8553278446,
-0.0737498552,
-0.1714775413,
0.0227833297,
0.4398060143,
-0.0110081555,
-0.1506236047,
-0.6299717426,
-0.3173950315,
0.6337500811,
0.547098577,
0.835010767,
0.439788729,
0.2394280434,
0.2874896824,
0.0548152328,
0.2559461594,
-0.2867735922,
0.1590073109,
-0.4792858064,
-0.3729950488,
-0.0686665177,
-0.2802745998,
0.9080805182,
0.8414980769,
-0.3918403089,
-0.2964758873,
-0.1228352189,
0.5332944989,
-0.7387104034,
0.3199189603,
-0.6642797589,
-0.0898555741,
-0.4320224822,
-0.4938777089,
-0.636693418,
-0.212390855,
-0.0969536528,
-0.5974656343,
0.0663117319,
0.1532631516,
0.47244367,
0.3200212419,
-0.4736503661,
-0.2110851854,
-0.8714799285,
0.8666374087,
-0.8956045508,
0.2034005225,
0.2414941639,
0.3666936159,
-0.8888321519,
-0.5611177087,
-0.767349422,
-0.3079728484,
0.2081304938,
0.0125676701,
0.1163882986,
0.226713717,
0.3398392498,
-0.0569569468,
-0.6487349868,
0.3667349219,
-0.2429930866,
0.0884515941,
0.8280158639,
0.0625248849,
-0.1200193912,
-0.1313522607,
-0.2056758851,
-0.1008303463,
-0.958769083,
-0.2988541722,
0.4964938462,
0.2088486105,
0.0230393186,
0.7480528951,
-0.589058876,
0.6474068761,
-0.0504455604,
-0.1523807645,
0.1939369291,
-0.1679615527,
-0.0367887877,
0.0843734443,
0.8511665463,
0.0547909141,
0.5205150843,
0.0190618057,
-0.2016229481,
0.0817841217,
0.1230954379,
-0.2274645716,
-0.3406438828,
0.2752905786,
-0.0991311073,
-0.2930609584,
-0.1697975099,
-0.6228060126,
-0.2924614549,
-0.1455200762,
0.2226661891,
-0.3521877825,
-0.0455300361,
0.0573580377,
0.1202080548,
0.3021793962,
0.1760546714,
-1.0856393576,
0.2797317803,
0.8469207883,
0.7222927809,
-0.2569536567,
-0.3506962061,
-0.7344545722,
0.5223835707,
-0.3434684575,
0.9233976007,
-0.7126486301,
-0.4910599589,
-0.1127922013,
0.1243562177,
-0.0804715231,
-0.3677529991,
0.385075599,
-0.4442167282,
0.1211896017,
0.1508655697,
-0.5732315183,
0.1069211736,
-0.2669999003,
-0.3738854825,
0.7870284915,
0.1389074475,
-0.885679841,
0.1084185466,
-0.1390982121,
-0.7862801552,
-0.0096497424,
-0.3834840953,
-0.345446527,
0.2391937077,
0.4487675726,
0.4973477125,
-0.249042064,
0.5710875392,
-0.3741863966,
-0.2555148602,
0.0716034845,
-0.2378657907,
0.6531223059,
0.4548995197,
-0.281308502,
0.3694249392,
-0.6204556823,
-0.1743767411,
0.1932473034,
-0.1020935327,
0.0048559033,
0.6528235078,
-0.3652002513,
0.3445372581,
0.1103322878,
-0.270817101,
0.4866359532,
-0.5167136788,
0.4564061761,
0.7252862453,
0.1984422654,
0.7423568368,
-0.2666192055,
0.517637074,
0.0409754068,
-0.0748540387,
-0.1724511683,
-0.7633136511,
-0.5322962403,
-0.1252393723,
0.1593667269,
0.6490980983,
-1.2534270287,
0.3220433295,
-0.1243411228,
-0.1892033219,
-0.2854689658,
-0.1018678322,
0.113793388,
0.2748385966,
0.1964262277,
-0.3018171191,
-0.4227526188,
-0.9063380957,
-0.0345637202,
-0.177723214,
-0.1767581105,
-0.0508599132,
0.3769509792,
0.0259388797,
0.7816566825,
-0.3566975892,
0.0299118645,
-0.5567947626,
0.3965788186,
0.2225690186,
0.7865817547,
0.1909335703,
-0.5156362057,
-0.1972027868,
-0.1444761604,
-0.3209601343,
-0.5312295556,
-0.5482199192,
-0.2977334261,
0.2454878986,
0.5796286464,
-0.706258595,
0.2834280431,
0.6380321383,
0.0314452425,
0.7957215905,
-0.3301078975,
-0.0545850396,
-0.6773569584,
-0.1702602357,
-0.1527304202,
-0.2330731452,
-0.4693844914,
0.0440543294,
-0.1529667825,
0.219271034,
-0.3825376332,
0.5928441286,
-0.3141344786,
-0.439337343,
-0.3885991573,
0.3840240836,
-0.3256387115,
0.4967521429,
0.6314278841,
0.4621412754,
0.4207953811,
-0.6371076107,
0.2393974364,
0.0497567132,
-0.6074773073,
0.3181787431,
-0.4880723059,
-0.2605040371,
-0.2232552469,
0.540361464,
-0.7408334017,
-0.1751815826,
0.3680297732,
-0.3545748889,
0.3487667143,
-0.0941416845,
-0.6174220443,
-0.3553806543,
0.1945107132,
0.0168557223,
0.6667664647,
-0.3687619567,
0.3156458437,
0.1786023229,
-0.4649993777,
-0.4705488086,
-0.4981246293,
-0.1053622216,
0.0335235521,
-0.4454589188,
0.5211052299,
0.0598140955,
-0.1772531867,
-0.1823822707,
0.0256658476,
0.131572336,
0.1748852134,
0.1503780782,
0.033458963,
0.0701128021,
-0.0629016906,
0.6102926731,
-0.3262013197,
-0.0816548765,
-0.5489524007,
0.5790817142,
0.3029319942,
-0.5570104718,
-0.2995902598,
0.3340180516,
0.145874247,
-0.3253931999,
0.7825987935,
0.3809209466,
-0.1034238636,
-0.4921247065,
-0.3465658426,
-0.2443551421,
-0.4469856322,
0.4078387916,
-0.463712126,
-0.8739515543,
0.2186040878,
-0.2314306647,
0.2578831315,
0.3415035009,
0.9976533651,
-0.2018877715,
1.3752406836,
0.4422175884,
0.1352483034,
0.5294708014,
0.0280308668,
0.1868701875,
-0.4857570827,
-0.0382302888,
-0.4497664273,
-0.3477078378,
-0.7343457937,
-0.7673351765,
0.2177398056,
0.090726614,
-0.1820366234,
0.2538696229,
-0.1139881611,
0.4208675325,
0.8455038071,
-0.2327115685,
0.4562735856,
0.0050111138,
-0.4899547994,
0.1192212552,
-0.9955567122,
-0.4489379823,
0.7580437064,
0.2209480107,
0.8362330794,
-0.137336731,
0.9014009237,
-0.1865481585,
0.2913322747,
-0.3641475439,
0.6913325787,
-0.1358760893,
-0.5219513774,
-0.3003686368,
-0.7152687311,
-0.8303031921,
0.2459532619,
-0.2821950912,
-1.0057317019,
0.1246396303,
0.2490682453,
-0.3785437644,
0.3154329062,
-0.2676440179,
0.8726145029,
-0.2550619841,
-0.5287456512,
-0.4778567255,
-0.8118081689,
0.6243755221,
-0.0347113088,
0.4433912933,
-0.4392844737,
0.0444561243,
0.3612833619,
-0.4073960185,
0.5836090446,
-0.1614325643,
-0.14090994,
0.4134710133,
0.3309050202,
0.853505969,
-0.0254449714,
0.0689188093,
-0.3123799264,
0.0651025027,
-0.37215662,
-0.6007406712,
0.786456883,
-0.3258831501,
-0.4978072047,
-0.4368620217,
-0.7963200212,
-0.3807758093,
-0.0248052105,
0.2188542485,
0.0691007003,
-0.0048286268,
-0.1733652949,
0.4738709033,
-0.6087598801,
0.3445590436,
0.4302212596,
-0.3430458903,
-0.0353108756,
1.0384995937,
-0.1964307874,
0.4559236765,
0.6027680635,
0.2000806779,
-0.2446452975,
-0.8518604636,
-0.3329834342,
0.4188878536,
-0.215959847,
0.1877379417,
-0.4839714766,
-0.2339853048,
-0.4719394743,
-0.3872525394,
-0.3534676135,
-0.8198754191,
-0.1224713251,
0.1371358335,
0.031382788,
0.4669875503,
-0.1804592013,
0.9450888634,
-0.7583116889,
0.2353007346,
0.0880026892,
0.1141250134,
-0.2311428338,
-0.514015913,
-0.0417618454,
-0.1553206742,
-0.3045147657,
-0.7829500437,
0.6459252238,
0.1716064066,
0.4413002431,
0.3493042588,
0.0574005321,
0.3473508656,
-0.873149693,
0.5400555134,
0.0419842079,
-0.698599577,
0.4566310048,
-0.4733114243,
0.5502987504,
0.2474278957,
0.5363663435,
-0.521017909,
-0.7632764578,
-0.6932647824,
-0.7110535502,
0.5340199471,
0.2309141904,
-0.4184021354,
-0.3718703389,
0.0841078758,
-0.1497271359,
0.5223327279,
-0.3699044585,
0.124204874,
0.3037953675,
-0.434964031,
-0.3752860129,
-0.3132881224,
0.2074485719,
0.1703855842,
0.7950485945,
-0.1341987699,
0.0177830197,
-0.0495558903,
-0.2228406817,
0.0886602625,
0.3219886422,
0.7150056958,
0.4017429352,
-0.0152403656,
0.2129049897,
-0.0458799079,
0.0469241366,
0.1326586157,
0.1870912462,
-0.3553162813,
-0.2256674767,
0.3254108131,
0.700684309,
0.6624214649,
-0.8439228535,
0.2281321585,
0.3611473441,
-0.3167324364,
-0.2344713807,
0.1844397336,
0.2098623514,
0.4462577999,
0.0904548317,
-0.2363745272,
0.0772892833,
-0.2800924778,
0.2605493963,
0.3663640618,
0.0675090328,
-0.1366732121,
0.8514316082,
0.0306303483,
-0.0158614013,
0.7981330752,
-0.4989949167,
-0.4037947655,
0.3984163404,
0.4040080607,
0.5594428182,
-0.2641434669,
0.3943729997,
0.2919237316,
0.3829408288,
-0.5489657521,
0.3000150323,
-0.1394040585,
-0.6876730919,
-0.9475103021,
-0.6549680233,
-0.4945047796,
-0.5215814114,
-0.1805884391,
0.0985077173,
-0.5852394104,
-0.1052048877,
-0.2106895,
-0.1673720181,
-0.2886092663,
-0.0865423381,
0.5807144642,
0.7980636358,
-0.6701365709,
1.2090913057,
0.2698323131,
-0.1130234227,
-0.4562989473,
-0.4158806503,
0.2440186739,
-0.6302122474,
0.6535351276,
-0.2153815776,
-0.0762819126,
0.1200878024,
-0.7033547759,
-0.8841658235,
0.6571938992,
0.2417689562,
-1.0941934586,
-0.3714985549,
-0.0065874043,
0.1574523151,
-0.3622474372,
0.0692464188,
1.0103058815,
0.4024950862,
0.3858895302,
-0.9441692233,
-0.2417963743,
0.1828382462,
0.0889368579,
0.2326852381,
-0.3282122016,
0.7287678719,
-0.5693367124,
-0.340670079,
0.3547394872,
1.148373127,
0.8471848369,
0.1426487267,
0.5038695931,
0.4326351881,
0.7312358022,
-0.2445314825,
1.0514694452,
-0.159218967,
0.2010442764,
1.625392437,
-0.5424304008,
1.0474584103,
0.6517775059,
-0.2769759297,
0.6657994986,
0.562687397,
0.1327922493,
0.5669370294,
0.6594179869,
-0.3445480764,
-0.3696860373,
0.1122947112,
-0.0342742689,
0.163004443,
0.6513949037,
-0.169733882,
-0.1737368554,
-0.1202035844,
-0.1218640581,
0.0664745346,
-0.1952963024,
0.339333415,
0.2451938987,
-0.7607573271,
0.1007829607,
0.2486397475,
0.5250763893,
-0.7885235548,
0.1437549144,
-0.1372961104,
0.2204573154,
-0.1651557684,
-0.7825862169,
0.2874899805,
-0.197447598,
0.1166447252,
-0.2350452542,
0.4160657525,
-0.7043450475,
-0.5611837506,
-0.0176895689,
0.3380730748,
0.2892987728,
0.0057087778,
-0.5677970052,
0.1655295789,
-0.1312242299,
-0.3967661858,
0.2551982403,
0.3215687871,
-0.3120491803,
0.999987185,
0.564841032,
0.3989300132,
0.422072202,
0.2563331425,
0.4467845261,
-0.5581959486,
-0.5754511952,
-0.5671156645,
0.4146713912,
0.1296634972,
0.0637573078,
0.647942543,
0.1325217634,
0.9430218935,
-0.0446579605,
0.5700562596,
-0.0334085785,
0.5500076413,
-0.822471261,
0.2398227155,
-0.4094279706,
0.3131431639,
-0.2561529279,
-1.0324445963,
-0.3228014708,
0.9202984571,
-0.6057850718,
0.0782546103,
0.689494431,
0.824857235,
0.192787081,
-0.09430857,
0.2469188422,
0.2999093235,
0.3475869,
0.9812569022,
0.9587191939,
0.1653504521,
0.2030767202,
-0.464885354,
-0.2289423048,
-0.1399322897,
-1.0900859833,
-0.5700868964,
-0.3957570195,
-0.4519861937,
-0.1474923193,
0.0827218592,
1.0962672234,
0.5662798882,
-0.9335082769,
-0.4970500171,
-0.2239454538,
0.3014986217,
-0.3552231789,
-0.2095788717,
0.0479709916,
-0.5958713293,
-0.9188469648,
0.7554278374,
0.3947739899,
-0.0491715558,
-0.336455524,
-0.0953540355,
-0.4354852438,
-0.0353242829,
0.5147323012,
0.4877410531,
-0.7062747478,
-0.0779352635,
-0.2630960047,
-0.0091698803,
-0.2707879841,
1.0935512781,
-0.9263051152,
0.3774521649,
0.6616587639,
0.4668826163,
0.6802951694,
-0.0871635601,
1.0428580046,
-0.7509894371,
0.4145417213,
0.2355086207,
0.4125263393,
0.0842290148,
0.1573761851,
0.4455664456,
0.3079193532,
-0.693823278,
-0.6899460554,
0.4436653256,
-0.8184579015,
-0.3569390178,
1.0379258394,
0.0857499838,
-0.2220245749,
0.0379776582,
-0.0739748999,
0.1670547575,
-0.2745817006,
0.2731510401,
0.5214121342,
-0.0807418078,
-0.4620886743,
-0.8750084043,
0.4010766149,
0.430333674,
-0.5863442421,
0.0520420037,
0.5473340154,
-0.0066513275,
-0.2700666189,
0.6824505925,
-0.0742387474,
0.1105704382,
-0.0056774458,
0.0745473579,
0.2032015622,
-0.6937134862,
-0.2911581993,
0.0012205224,
0.0725741982,
0.3020883203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03079v1 | Machine Learning and Statistical Approaches to Measuring Similarity of Political Parties | 2023-06-05T17:53:41 | 2023-06-05T17:53:41 | Daria Boratyn, Damian Brzyski, Beata Kosowska-Gąstoł, Jan Rybicki, Wojciech Słomczyński, Dariusz Stolicki | cs.CL | cs.CL, 91F10 (Primary) 68T50 (Secondary), J.4; I.2.7 | Mapping political party systems to metric policy spaces is one of the major
methodological problems in political science. At present, in most political
science project this task is performed by domain experts relying on purely
qualitative assessments, with all the attendant problems of subjectivity and
labor intensiveness. We consider how advances in natural language processing,
including large transformer-based language models, can be applied to solve that
issue. We apply a number of texts similarity measures to party political
programs, analyze how they correlate with each other, and -- in the absence of
a satisfactory benchmark -- evaluate them against other measures, including
those based on expert surveys, voting records, electoral patterns, and
candidate networks. Finally, we consider the prospects of relying on those
methods to correct, supplement, and eventually replace expert judgments. | [
-0.2965730429,
-0.3437543213,
0.7396269441,
-0.0772432685,
-0.0298785679,
0.4198550582,
-0.4360201061,
0.0767682269,
0.3049920797,
0.7649486065,
-0.3707660735,
-0.566486001,
-0.7134250998,
-0.0942023769,
-0.3671053052,
0.8560227156,
0.3381831348,
0.0295049194,
-0.3339393437,
-0.2495085001,
-0.2181733549,
-0.6336138248,
-0.318075031,
-0.6350829601,
0.2539062798,
0.4788045883,
0.9704759717,
0.7807477713,
0.9109296203,
0.3338774443,
0.1530955881,
-0.1482168138,
-0.4939889014,
-0.0164734498,
-0.3820824921,
-0.8388364911,
-0.1436521858,
0.3215361536,
0.6045663357,
1.0022079945,
-0.029107729,
0.1216461882,
0.2396091521,
0.9752410054,
-0.6968343854,
0.4669713974,
-0.9278262854,
0.0999231264,
-0.1332575977,
-0.3820807338,
-0.2332363278,
-0.53083992,
0.0278781597,
-0.3265258074,
0.4876923263,
0.2695470452,
0.38225016,
0.1834439784,
-0.5806238055,
-0.4641751349,
-0.9531883001,
1.0343669653,
-0.5885092616,
0.0685854778,
0.4923821688,
0.3922008872,
-0.6239058971,
-0.4142835736,
-0.6675161719,
-0.3948558569,
-0.0217073448,
-0.1356023848,
-0.0880613029,
-0.0471057184,
0.0129611408,
0.1675755829,
-0.6720961332,
0.1960330904,
-0.4142035246,
-0.0445209816,
0.8807102442,
0.469642669,
-0.0791108981,
-0.2269936055,
-0.2173336297,
-0.3637475371,
-0.6341793537,
-0.1254467517,
0.7880256176,
0.474829495,
0.1918290854,
0.5184919238,
-0.3456278741,
0.6078780293,
-0.1801446676,
0.3157542944,
0.1338612735,
-0.3880827725,
-0.1705108881,
-0.2070707828,
1.1779538393,
0.3723702729,
0.3932590783,
-0.0174029935,
0.002939492,
0.3303251565,
0.0657282844,
-0.3805263638,
-0.7374715209,
0.1154648066,
-0.7174307704,
-0.2841898501,
0.1289495975,
-0.8194906116,
-0.6777382493,
-0.7684364319,
0.054603938,
-0.3597937822,
-0.2840791047,
-0.3805943727,
-0.3064819574,
0.1296717674,
-0.0865014717,
-0.556417942,
0.4435591698,
1.3631745577,
0.7500165701,
-0.4094100296,
-0.1721181422,
-0.2470846921,
-0.2441980392,
-0.5629857183,
0.9426941872,
-1.0907930136,
-0.1240325645,
0.2249022424,
-0.1472344846,
0.02002999,
-0.8976740241,
0.3134671152,
-0.3126005232,
0.4416384995,
-0.3566199541,
-0.9072111249,
-0.0421473607,
0.1913342178,
-0.7375600338,
0.8618681431,
-0.2575144768,
-0.6820679307,
0.761022687,
-0.5960147977,
-0.131232664,
-0.2945555747,
-0.1615413129,
-0.4209848046,
0.2238071859,
-0.2189014703,
0.7729243636,
-0.2444018275,
0.3608234525,
-0.4078627825,
-0.4422154725,
0.3869824708,
-0.0763201565,
0.911032021,
0.1061244383,
-0.1585044861,
0.4968631566,
-1.0731436014,
-0.0850815773,
-0.1029501557,
0.1327168196,
-0.6995833516,
0.5465660691,
-0.0041318992,
0.0327002332,
0.2056602389,
-0.3349574208,
0.2062164098,
-0.3672011495,
0.5579547882,
0.5371109843,
-0.0869657099,
0.7830310464,
-0.1973666847,
0.0792109892,
0.0316003822,
-0.0835222602,
0.0468977802,
-0.5840058327,
-0.6430882812,
0.1314497888,
0.6413062215,
0.7101872563,
-0.6437979937,
0.5488129258,
-0.4487586617,
-0.8745913506,
-0.3720134199,
-0.3142000735,
0.0266034622,
0.0101108206,
0.1780945361,
-0.4193395376,
-0.4240318239,
-0.9652846456,
-0.8544117808,
-0.5317970514,
-0.2370257229,
-0.0717726126,
0.7779909372,
0.2933853567,
0.9402881265,
-0.3775061071,
-0.2239170372,
0.3308511078,
0.3565876484,
0.2510797381,
0.3249895275,
0.1963424087,
-0.6352869868,
-0.4377484024,
0.2276043445,
-0.4849587977,
-0.0558758415,
0.0371831581,
0.4765420258,
0.1521372795,
0.4149009585,
-0.1272933483,
0.3769008815,
0.4148578942,
-0.4569843113,
0.3495459259,
-0.3058009744,
0.5205798149,
-0.9570823908,
0.0280054659,
0.1636856049,
-0.2506807446,
-0.8098877072,
-0.0257803872,
-0.1739786863,
-0.0907123983,
-0.2264915556,
0.2804085314,
-0.2440647632,
-0.1730355769,
-0.480240047,
0.0900328457,
-0.5012782812,
0.3106341064,
-0.2612091005,
0.521781683,
0.3180844486,
-0.3682148457,
0.571613729,
-0.2062673569,
-0.4033737183,
0.9082231522,
-0.3090929389,
0.3511488438,
-0.1837374121,
0.0792145506,
-1.0306681395,
-0.0109343808,
0.3302506208,
-0.4914369881,
-0.0094339717,
0.0017208717,
-0.3790057302,
-0.1891927123,
-0.1844210923,
-0.1802751124,
0.6920855641,
-0.0101972502,
0.2781968117,
0.5851379037,
-0.1027830318,
-0.52784729,
-0.309206754,
0.3293207586,
-0.6304838061,
0.0162685085,
0.2545147836,
0.5222585797,
-0.5762539506,
0.4271573424,
0.2489580512,
-0.4179483652,
-0.2292241007,
0.1920326352,
-0.0900877044,
-0.2014950067,
0.1535170674,
-0.3184168041,
-0.3141615391,
0.2449327707,
-0.2504584193,
0.223720029,
0.1808605492,
-0.2845433354,
-0.5989677906,
0.6298694611,
0.3781870306,
-0.1124024689,
0.7328622341,
0.4488736689,
-0.3207421601,
0.0139024686,
-0.5793619752,
-0.2375728637,
-0.3402056396,
0.4648394883,
-0.3458203375,
-0.8700096011,
0.6356752515,
-0.3780157566,
-0.0162532162,
0.5922486782,
0.7295004725,
-0.1314667165,
0.6919145584,
0.8084485531,
-0.353875488,
0.2008506805,
0.0328657739,
0.4180197716,
-0.092410624,
-0.2261035442,
-1.3071465492,
-0.4814135134,
-1.0112614632,
-0.6618121266,
-0.1097461656,
-0.5828710198,
-0.5986334085,
0.4663704336,
-0.642300725,
0.5446858406,
0.6249228716,
-0.3907294869,
0.2735134363,
0.1475302726,
0.3730790317,
-0.368906498,
-0.6371531487,
-0.653088212,
1.0057159662,
0.1428475082,
0.6450383067,
-0.5671533942,
0.73878479,
0.3601102233,
0.2368460149,
-0.5439817905,
0.6662874222,
-0.3734796345,
-0.2954163551,
-0.4203210473,
-0.8218472004,
-0.9301396608,
0.2711747885,
-0.4480993748,
-0.4998493493,
0.3940891027,
-0.0513327979,
0.3273748457,
0.6499256492,
-0.1873572469,
0.6103361249,
0.2403150201,
0.1438627988,
-0.5739508271,
-0.7300109267,
0.0173128359,
0.1253455281,
0.3279724419,
-0.3748440444,
-0.312343061,
1.1324981451,
-0.2410910875,
0.6250090599,
-0.3014522791,
0.1953731328,
0.1224676892,
0.0584967621,
0.2105160356,
-0.6804986596,
-0.3382204175,
0.2632327378,
0.4821149707,
-0.4200519919,
-0.7802984118,
0.8061406016,
-0.7380384803,
-0.4160038233,
-0.3429706097,
-0.5079174042,
-0.0033466627,
-0.1335921884,
0.0669577867,
-0.0004201528,
-0.6299189329,
0.4976357818,
0.328753233,
0.1463876665,
0.3652913868,
0.127442807,
0.1112865508,
-0.3202934861,
1.0776141882,
0.2949824035,
-0.1540540755,
0.365988642,
0.3049452901,
-0.2798336446,
-0.3248588741,
0.1338161975,
-0.0750385448,
-0.4251056314,
-0.2098625898,
-0.4276750684,
0.2210708857,
-0.0236951448,
0.1431973577,
-0.4170314968,
-0.6169490218,
-0.380359143,
0.4286220074,
0.1249669939,
0.9604262114,
0.1071774885,
0.3383965492,
-0.2686980963,
0.0044064247,
-0.0257074088,
0.3541892171,
-0.2247990817,
-0.2573286593,
0.1022074819,
-0.1350223124,
-0.364718765,
-1.2642475367,
0.1723818332,
0.3652478158,
0.2590748072,
0.227043584,
0.2686385214,
0.3492251635,
-0.7948142886,
0.9152299166,
0.1942608953,
-0.6919927597,
0.5303949714,
-0.1072069556,
-0.2264211476,
0.6505423784,
0.6534721851,
-0.3387362361,
-0.6437938809,
-0.6234535575,
-0.2713445127,
0.1532037556,
0.21995911,
0.3098878264,
0.1180690527,
0.3815570176,
0.1971191317,
0.0842711478,
-0.1722561717,
-0.2212251425,
0.031833224,
-0.3518452942,
-0.3829547465,
0.180654496,
-0.0526147634,
0.0470465422,
0.5116896033,
-0.3315185905,
0.013944922,
0.0562129952,
0.4959140122,
-0.1355649829,
0.554276526,
0.3599505723,
1.0508742332,
0.1600599438,
0.1633775234,
0.143438518,
0.049679596,
0.3599737883,
-0.1635804772,
0.1139663532,
0.2103253603,
0.4444017112,
0.531172514,
-0.0609922037,
-0.1190343872,
0.3951191902,
0.1074343324,
-0.3760609031,
-0.1872006208,
0.0765463188,
0.1724655479,
0.1864768863,
0.4965473413,
0.2630883753,
0.419622004,
-0.964705646,
0.2613302767,
0.7848265767,
-0.8386287093,
-0.2736520767,
0.4640103877,
0.1389702559,
-1.0847213268,
0.3736533523,
-0.005411882,
-0.7357950807,
0.8681323528,
0.2153591663,
0.5571460128,
-0.4202777445,
0.1775887311,
0.282607913,
0.5202499032,
-0.0272126794,
0.1531413645,
0.2752890885,
-0.2901883125,
-0.5409322381,
-0.0987538621,
-0.720611155,
0.0672064349,
-0.5893101096,
0.2916026711,
-0.3437348604,
-0.4539402723,
0.1198969707,
0.6195926666,
-0.8671026826,
0.0323324539,
-0.1466324776,
0.7096788883,
-1.4536271095,
0.5189453959,
0.7056527734,
0.2330886722,
-0.3385912776,
-0.0319739804,
-0.0003443094,
-0.4147163033,
0.3141749799,
-0.261654079,
0.2835820019,
-0.6408522129,
-0.4093180597,
-0.3237834871,
0.5056359172,
0.1428217292,
-0.7647439837,
-0.0560892411,
0.3830227554,
0.6306011081,
-0.4665871263,
0.2193954438,
0.8045569658,
0.470592469,
-0.439140588,
-0.9123535752,
0.0437106416,
0.0927571207,
0.0718981549,
0.5488400459,
-0.4013396502,
0.5518934131,
0.1159731522,
0.0295170993,
-0.0880627632,
1.027387023,
0.0681791678,
0.5938420892,
0.6318409443,
0.3455901146,
0.8396172523,
-0.1221879423,
0.7665314078,
-0.1954421103,
0.4962178171,
1.0214599371,
-0.4243436456,
0.9417205453,
0.6614915133,
-0.6554628611,
0.5680528879,
0.3772695959,
-0.1094261184,
0.2137846202,
0.5645509362,
0.181475237,
-0.2033609152,
0.0567398034,
-0.245015502,
0.6138799787,
0.3180310428,
-0.2447779626,
-0.0631268099,
-0.0552740358,
-0.3390332162,
0.8212442398,
-0.0590521432,
0.8804781437,
0.2147967219,
-0.687525928,
-0.0100835003,
-0.2564890087,
0.3907628953,
-0.2017014027,
-0.365051955,
0.0087344879,
-0.0019528603,
-0.1144769937,
-1.2677174807,
0.6515484452,
-0.1753882617,
-0.1848588139,
0.1054467261,
0.7526389956,
-0.4013595581,
-0.5275682211,
0.2262346745,
0.6648694277,
0.4551778138,
0.0752389655,
-0.7566885352,
0.0417175665,
-0.1713620573,
-0.1118556559,
0.2414494753,
0.638481617,
-0.0508091338,
0.6549063921,
0.4216372371,
0.5119176507,
-0.2036208063,
-0.1062302589,
0.5256371498,
-0.6219775677,
-0.5290346146,
-0.9751728177,
0.0185274966,
-0.3298506737,
-0.1455930471,
0.4311378896,
0.5656688213,
0.7570555806,
0.0111161917,
0.548448503,
0.0190872382,
0.6889206767,
-0.214949742,
0.8665046692,
-0.3213065565,
-0.0535971746,
-0.1160632521,
-1.3902598619,
-0.5161868334,
0.6153253913,
-0.4524756372,
-0.0774580389,
0.6971237063,
0.9392241836,
-0.303704083,
0.0482238941,
0.3505709469,
-0.1171258315,
0.2392556518,
0.5780100226,
1.0124688148,
-0.3182642758,
0.5221360326,
-0.165970251,
-0.4375306368,
-0.0627034307,
-0.9146483541,
-0.9624806046,
-1.2981829643,
-0.6124730706,
-0.1097725481,
0.2597629726,
0.730830729,
0.6546717882,
-0.9346280098,
-0.5123372674,
0.3387219012,
0.2534202933,
-0.1169501245,
-0.280017972,
0.6774778962,
-0.2308611721,
-0.6657443047,
-0.0671170652,
0.2537650764,
-0.6460925341,
-0.4713018239,
0.2694117725,
0.0348028541,
0.1417227983,
0.2848388255,
0.1560848206,
-0.8676508069,
-0.669626832,
-0.2940224111,
-0.0422463268,
0.2103748471,
1.2685875893,
-0.8701702952,
0.2711515725,
0.9405662417,
0.4800178409,
0.0145285139,
-0.1679047197,
0.4741995037,
-0.4266177118,
0.0421644971,
0.3645867705,
0.0109587321,
0.4632071257,
0.0664773285,
0.5961745381,
0.0410992578,
-0.9366646409,
-0.7826169729,
0.1442518532,
-0.7528317571,
-0.234479785,
0.7815870643,
-0.0000851094,
-0.3458580971,
-0.3191507757,
-0.0641990453,
0.2950946689,
-0.055967588,
0.5923706889,
0.6076353192,
-0.0743895248,
-0.0279930774,
-0.5858430266,
0.4776118994,
0.2383900285,
-0.4993166625,
0.0341324396,
0.0653320923,
0.3267415762,
0.3531401455,
0.682082355,
0.0786689147,
-0.0592691451,
-0.0747818202,
-0.1871851683,
0.4547276795,
-0.379394412,
-0.4268131554,
0.5023031831,
-0.3494590819,
-0.0739772469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03078v1 | SpQR: A Sparse-Quantized Representation for Near-Lossless LLM Weight Compression | 2023-06-05T17:53:28 | 2023-06-05T17:53:28 | Tim Dettmers, Ruslan Svirschevski, Vage Egiazarian, Denis Kuznedelev, Elias Frantar, Saleh Ashkboos, Alexander Borzunov, Torsten Hoefler, Dan Alistarh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in large language model (LLM) pretraining have led to
high-quality LLMs with impressive abilities. By compressing such LLMs via
quantization to 3-4 bits per parameter, they can fit into memory-limited
devices such as laptops and mobile phones, enabling personalized use. However,
quantization down to 3-4 bits per parameter usually leads to moderate-to-high
accuracy losses, especially for smaller models in the 1-10B parameter range,
which are well-suited for edge deployments. To address this accuracy issue, we
introduce the Sparse-Quantized Representation (SpQR), a new compressed format
and quantization technique which enables for the first time near-lossless
compression of LLMs across model scales, while reaching similar compression
levels to previous methods. SpQR works by identifying and isolating outlier
weights, which cause particularly-large quantization errors, and storing them
in higher precision, while compressing all other weights to 3-4 bits, and
achieves relative accuracy losses of less than 1% in perplexity for
highly-accurate LLaMA and Falcon LLMs. This makes it possible to run 33B
parameter LLM on a single 24 GB consumer GPU without any performance
degradation at 15% speedup thus making powerful LLMs available to consumer
without any downsides. SpQR comes with efficient algorithms for both encoding
weights into its format, as well as decoding them efficiently at runtime.
Specifically, we provide an efficient GPU inference algorithm for SpQR which
yields faster inference than 16-bit baselines at similar accuracy, while
enabling memory compression gains of more than 4x. | [
-0.2624255419,
-0.6762799025,
0.5223708749,
0.1468262076,
-0.4005313516,
0.1497200131,
-0.2905306518,
0.187169522,
0.2099654377,
0.2321160734,
-0.4389201105,
-0.3238387108,
-0.6923127174,
-0.0082213897,
-0.3314039707,
0.9671806693,
0.1626145095,
0.1116526797,
-0.3145950735,
-0.174070403,
-0.249458164,
-0.8922875524,
-0.5575723052,
0.0058200569,
0.4506311417,
0.0797865614,
0.8454740047,
0.7791477442,
0.1729411334,
0.2790634632,
-0.2032735497,
0.0891501233,
-0.6652176976,
-0.2312754691,
0.5135648251,
-0.3351947069,
-0.5618795753,
-0.232909292,
1.0846422911,
0.5454969406,
-0.632979393,
0.1750723571,
0.1001991406,
0.6705117226,
-0.6031351089,
-0.0308131129,
-0.3629012406,
0.2276462466,
-0.3153278232,
-0.3157906532,
-0.3061765432,
-0.4503962398,
-0.4965703487,
-0.8674003482,
0.1823786795,
0.0714081675,
0.9626390934,
0.6529358029,
-0.5466096401,
0.19046323,
-0.7057132721,
0.8277379274,
-0.5229798555,
0.7206678391,
0.1133873686,
0.2740881741,
-0.1083883196,
-0.9247143865,
-0.5433412194,
0.1211769283,
0.2767055631,
-0.0227765664,
-0.31619519,
0.263443023,
0.4172454774,
0.684513092,
-0.6194652319,
-0.3419754505,
-0.1726848334,
-0.3606225252,
0.5540775657,
0.0619619489,
0.034491647,
0.1908037215,
-0.462371856,
-0.0786847174,
-0.9168812037,
-0.1224158183,
0.2532982826,
0.1745253056,
0.1240834221,
0.4089051187,
-0.1538084447,
0.8750174046,
0.242151767,
-0.356636703,
-0.0756294355,
-0.1132267118,
-0.3226912022,
0.0823372602,
0.8111572266,
0.2969244421,
-0.127873987,
-0.1129156053,
-0.4459806085,
-0.0572132505,
0.0412751399,
-1.0416084528,
-0.2240357548,
-0.017416805,
-0.6312258244,
0.1871557385,
-0.1958623976,
-0.3014824092,
-0.4067183137,
-0.0607552342,
0.8268703222,
-0.3675165176,
-0.1012987569,
0.369088918,
0.0270290691,
0.0879990309,
0.3623254597,
-0.6211127639,
0.8081224561,
0.5656398535,
0.7866429687,
0.0942343324,
0.0058487677,
-0.8159275651,
0.1264983714,
-0.1890720129,
0.7068325281,
-0.1682678312,
-0.2735332549,
-0.2724917531,
-0.2125970721,
0.2458973974,
-0.5250617266,
0.5231995583,
-0.5269343257,
-0.300951153,
-0.134865582,
-0.7076987624,
-0.1268840134,
0.0758066922,
-0.7097014785,
1.2251354456,
0.2173416466,
-0.6196661592,
0.2713822722,
0.1002329662,
-0.1399080306,
0.4279412031,
-0.3553726971,
-0.5899399519,
0.3579258025,
0.16681391,
0.5497664213,
-0.4382167757,
0.1254322231,
-0.121061489,
-0.9276889563,
0.3298262358,
-0.4666185975,
0.4130160809,
0.2602313161,
0.1221009344,
0.0632812679,
-0.6127692461,
0.2694475949,
0.2128341943,
-0.3740166426,
-0.1753012538,
0.0760054141,
-0.1601532549,
-0.0445223935,
0.5237609744,
-0.5267956257,
0.0674730837,
-0.1873415262,
0.5501297712,
0.6981445551,
-0.1983596385,
0.5744256973,
-0.2777893245,
0.5441448689,
-0.3420336843,
0.2328972518,
-0.0172111131,
-0.2045239508,
-0.690118134,
-0.5294833183,
0.3852077425,
0.3089618385,
-0.6096160412,
0.3421472907,
-0.6952159405,
-0.3812085986,
-0.4958127141,
-0.0702917352,
0.0599628277,
0.1338403821,
0.2205352336,
-0.0333778858,
-0.3526423872,
-0.574470818,
-0.3170141876,
0.1427220255,
-0.1310273111,
0.1243013293,
0.0610164627,
0.00077271,
0.8116196394,
-0.549680829,
-0.2030286938,
-0.3677373528,
0.0599265024,
0.2406021804,
0.571041286,
0.1332099438,
-0.7145385742,
-0.3945017755,
-0.1673263311,
-0.1900381744,
-0.0013947763,
-0.09768641,
0.1821215898,
-0.057390701,
0.4589121044,
-0.6826184392,
0.4146114886,
0.752869308,
-0.1186355725,
0.2260726839,
-0.460190624,
-0.0887698159,
-0.8926412463,
-0.1987341046,
0.0460678115,
-0.4683971703,
-0.5183302164,
-0.0715016648,
0.431804955,
-0.443543911,
-0.1537758857,
0.3735608459,
-0.4745116532,
-0.3075554073,
-0.0350088365,
-0.1959921271,
0.1540480852,
0.5394819379,
0.1802043021,
1.1573367119,
0.3753150403,
-0.5966504812,
0.3589771092,
-0.0814575925,
-0.1365189999,
0.6025771499,
-0.8097090125,
0.1981612295,
-0.4230198264,
0.4353065491,
-0.6284160614,
0.0486776792,
0.1447312683,
-0.4421216547,
0.3585754335,
-0.2885895073,
-0.7291779518,
-0.0133870337,
-0.3490832448,
0.5518336296,
0.5281488299,
-0.2751393914,
0.7965864539,
0.3872929513,
-0.1901545227,
-0.4833752811,
-0.9328795075,
-0.0433895253,
-0.3150496483,
-0.412208885,
0.4919196367,
-0.3530092239,
0.2682630122,
-0.1179380268,
-0.4204174578,
-0.1456314474,
-0.064878881,
0.3973001838,
0.0742855892,
-0.2412947118,
0.0460654348,
0.0511295013,
-0.2560092807,
-0.1526941657,
-0.2321379036,
0.4221443534,
-0.2233024836,
-0.1736538708,
-0.5368045568,
0.3352852464,
0.1555192322,
-0.2772959471,
0.6305685043,
0.5106483102,
-0.5105825663,
-0.3301110864,
-0.5093233585,
0.0356283598,
-0.506200552,
0.3760269284,
-0.5198147893,
-1.0848811865,
0.3074550629,
-0.3316539526,
-0.4400129616,
0.1930040121,
0.1394281089,
0.0303699616,
1.1931092739,
0.6571061611,
0.0945660099,
0.4086360931,
-0.2422838062,
0.3343146741,
-0.5855026245,
-0.2384466529,
-0.378895998,
-0.1153641343,
-0.4001841843,
-0.8349935412,
0.563991189,
0.2774115801,
-0.5861973763,
0.1270571202,
-0.6439874768,
0.4711528122,
0.2861654758,
0.2338935286,
0.0343959704,
0.1447975636,
0.2558860183,
-0.1590542495,
-0.9596418738,
-0.3335906267,
0.7432796359,
0.4905320704,
0.9832853079,
-0.008498867,
0.7216610312,
0.3256637156,
0.1640249342,
-1.0083941221,
0.6587359309,
-0.2781801224,
-0.1759288758,
-0.2169411778,
-0.8112340569,
-0.5512140393,
0.0658085719,
-0.2144714445,
-0.3907808661,
0.0594772473,
-0.0254344679,
-0.8993272781,
0.3795304,
-0.5038735271,
0.7621984482,
-0.1515154243,
-0.1503322124,
0.0069974633,
-0.5295048952,
0.1676561087,
0.0084986649,
0.118066743,
-0.1454412341,
-0.4385506213,
0.6473476887,
-0.81909132,
0.5102985501,
-0.2880249023,
-0.0949132219,
0.154232204,
0.1044895723,
0.8541612029,
0.0689521506,
-0.0438267104,
0.2190002501,
0.2841088772,
-0.6124837399,
-0.797472477,
0.5621681809,
-0.8101668954,
-0.2313419878,
-0.6978285313,
-0.5708400607,
-0.0449923351,
0.0259870179,
0.2656325102,
0.5785925984,
0.0565052405,
0.0311322566,
0.9994373918,
-0.4497661293,
0.0343147144,
0.3463849723,
0.077816315,
-0.842438519,
1.2239054441,
0.2546178401,
0.0300175585,
0.5366903543,
0.0094223637,
-0.3726812601,
-0.8503223062,
-0.4597334862,
0.3347938657,
-0.6657076478,
-0.787153244,
-0.3390906453,
-0.4034282863,
-0.1792109013,
-0.0881850198,
-0.6040020585,
-0.474013567,
-0.3812849522,
0.1284600943,
0.4002286494,
0.7095232606,
-0.1325745136,
0.8080403209,
-0.8821800947,
0.2038288862,
0.3198696971,
0.2823850214,
-0.2281993926,
-0.5625633597,
-0.4639162719,
-0.1189300492,
-0.058292821,
-0.6154321432,
0.5554175377,
0.6060457826,
0.2193475366,
0.5017022491,
0.1546937227,
1.2082829475,
-0.4141303301,
0.8077309132,
0.1610038429,
-1.0947936773,
0.1454047412,
0.0438857377,
0.1151871905,
0.3943145871,
0.4924193621,
-0.5119224787,
0.0298504364,
-0.3894557357,
-0.6690276265,
0.6210420728,
-0.1425931752,
0.3251664042,
-0.0127091603,
0.5511299968,
0.0406176336,
0.0995795503,
-0.7590254545,
-0.4344030917,
-0.3633619249,
-0.2915415764,
-0.1115342379,
-0.5586380363,
0.0639333725,
-0.1298517138,
0.5061847568,
-0.2027015537,
0.5800706148,
0.1756354421,
-0.2322607189,
-0.0812088177,
0.0923510492,
0.4134618044,
0.2076215893,
-0.3745017946,
0.448677659,
0.4069490433,
-0.4360888898,
0.2348327041,
0.5995044708,
0.0754286572,
-0.0781469643,
0.0019452251,
0.7763069868,
0.2545204759,
-0.7176044583,
0.9346385598,
-0.4791247249,
-0.024257293,
-0.4119616747,
-0.2205818743,
-0.0941806287,
0.1679856479,
0.6879779696,
-0.0430212095,
0.1769821495,
-0.1198106855,
0.1162177697,
0.4592063129,
-0.2453109324,
-0.2319882363,
0.7817261815,
-0.0619575344,
0.1777748168,
0.4911453724,
-0.4963192344,
-0.3198298216,
0.1936141551,
0.5033276677,
0.4930401742,
-0.214356184,
0.0385761112,
0.5152692199,
0.0448634662,
-0.3270144463,
0.3639083207,
-0.4167795181,
-0.6179174185,
-0.9292804599,
-0.8285774589,
-0.1253548265,
-0.0769896507,
-0.6978998184,
0.1076624915,
-0.7250033021,
-0.2237783372,
-0.5101953745,
0.2613496482,
-0.1896888167,
0.328661114,
0.3834953308,
0.9616154432,
-0.485367924,
1.0120942593,
0.5118730068,
-0.2669124901,
-0.9807695746,
-0.1699409932,
-0.2224935591,
-0.6750721335,
0.5899755955,
-0.0457985103,
-0.1120592877,
0.403827101,
-0.539622426,
-1.0580676794,
1.2549495697,
0.7073714733,
-0.6701562405,
0.049886886,
0.2940061092,
0.0393257774,
0.0752163082,
0.2614862621,
0.2666361928,
0.1103642881,
0.2616854906,
-0.6016834378,
0.4084804654,
-0.0647400692,
0.3181219995,
0.4869382977,
-0.7944036722,
1.0169351101,
0.0481752902,
-0.5678805709,
0.4254858196,
0.9864546657,
0.4821996689,
0.1983598918,
0.3118515313,
0.6707536578,
0.8893008828,
-0.1762192845,
1.0552703142,
-0.5505868793,
0.4330847561,
0.7099390626,
-0.0792450532,
0.8175759912,
0.4846998453,
-0.3979772031,
0.1400652379,
0.7467942238,
0.3076548874,
0.4687022567,
0.5767316222,
-0.6978847384,
-0.2923079133,
-0.1715355814,
-0.3646565974,
-0.0126622152,
0.4609921873,
0.1181599647,
-0.0574588478,
-0.1166873053,
0.0967238173,
0.0320496932,
-0.6758111715,
0.4777764082,
0.0907523856,
-0.023116136,
1.0111727715,
0.1545733958,
1.0278434753,
-0.8081231117,
-0.0135932667,
-0.3622232378,
-0.1155793369,
-0.3046657741,
-0.5314098001,
0.2679995596,
-0.1193660796,
0.0453393497,
-0.5676788092,
0.8887658715,
-0.4739688337,
-0.3621733785,
-0.137175858,
0.2333401144,
0.3673917353,
-0.5311105251,
-0.5829159021,
0.6825967431,
-0.191824317,
-0.0411795974,
0.4470713735,
0.7526702285,
0.1809632331,
0.7084407806,
0.4548479319,
0.4464065135,
0.3317722976,
-0.1459561586,
1.038549304,
-0.7975993752,
-0.2738167346,
-0.45218274,
0.2641645372,
0.243336916,
0.0708622336,
0.6508470178,
0.78641361,
0.6729260087,
0.1556646526,
0.5116559267,
0.0643748567,
0.2793733776,
-0.4218203425,
0.653722465,
-0.7441748977,
0.1611733288,
0.0937570482,
-0.7755548954,
-0.5414080024,
0.7091647983,
-0.0408972539,
0.022950232,
0.4323289096,
0.9366253018,
0.0005826431,
-0.3511345983,
0.6376985908,
0.0046525775,
-0.2092738301,
0.6978203058,
1.0361909866,
-0.7432804704,
0.872615099,
-0.1855102479,
-0.0469822958,
-0.0399330705,
-0.8550288081,
-0.3583586812,
-0.4592221975,
-0.4673252702,
-0.3551915586,
0.177547127,
0.8870820403,
0.9200555682,
-0.3633345366,
-0.2379008681,
-0.2650554776,
-0.057524167,
-0.2372660935,
-0.1926733404,
0.3693965077,
-0.0620003901,
-0.6719079614,
0.4153069556,
0.2300923318,
0.2008800507,
-0.1539454162,
-0.6390934587,
0.3186820149,
0.0552179851,
0.5650186539,
0.2600369155,
-0.4504266679,
-0.0520033315,
-0.2386047542,
-0.0824626237,
0.1948342025,
0.7322469354,
-1.0203348398,
0.0754887909,
0.4233565629,
0.663154006,
0.7518516779,
0.0199856423,
0.4687098861,
-0.9047851562,
0.2499304563,
0.3680589199,
0.1540237367,
0.448959887,
-0.3633904159,
0.2124259025,
0.1602081209,
-0.6968076229,
-0.9825071096,
-0.0182283502,
-1.1178373098,
-0.181446299,
1.0075893402,
-0.2687850296,
-0.3706504405,
0.2680515349,
-0.2023927271,
0.472697109,
-0.6174541712,
0.2375884056,
0.2988959551,
-0.0566374511,
-0.7567443252,
-0.5904210806,
0.680876255,
0.3200107217,
-0.3698816299,
-0.0347681977,
0.4344333708,
0.2767596841,
-0.3201087415,
0.7996370792,
-0.0226076115,
0.1751145273,
0.1231074035,
0.3422289193,
-0.0105674313,
-0.0085629039,
-0.7215855122,
0.1570779085,
0.3405280113,
-0.0894695222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03067v1 | Interactive Editing for Text Summarization | 2023-06-05T17:43:53 | 2023-06-05T17:43:53 | Yujia Xie, Xun Wang, Si-Qing Chen, Wayne Xiong, Pengcheng He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Summarizing lengthy documents is a common and essential task in our daily
lives. Although recent advancements in neural summarization models can assist
in crafting general-purpose summaries, human writers often have specific
requirements that call for a more customized approach. To address this need, we
introduce REVISE (Refinement and Editing via Iterative Summarization
Enhancement), an innovative framework designed to facilitate iterative editing
and refinement of draft summaries by human writers. Within our framework,
writers can effortlessly modify unsatisfactory segments at any location or
length and provide optional starting phrases -- our system will generate
coherent alternatives that seamlessly integrate with the existing summary. At
its core, REVISE incorporates a modified fill-in-the-middle model with the
encoder-decoder architecture while developing novel evaluation metrics tailored
for the summarization task. In essence, our framework empowers users to create
high-quality, personalized summaries by effectively harnessing both human
expertise and AI capabilities, ultimately transforming the summarization
process into a truly collaborative and adaptive experience. | [
-0.4354426861,
-0.5368513465,
0.412339747,
0.2719670236,
-0.1110047475,
0.3968177438,
-0.3099447787,
-0.4942005873,
0.6771274209,
0.5213293433,
-0.6333312988,
-0.3984053135,
-0.2104680538,
0.3492335677,
-0.3505873084,
1.1507036686,
-0.0938462317,
-0.225669235,
-0.3438531458,
-0.2188279331,
-0.3957838118,
-0.3528474271,
-0.7030658126,
-0.3874459565,
0.6790038943,
0.5626312494,
0.7677924037,
0.3909765482,
0.5353364944,
0.4324477017,
-0.433342427,
0.2557798624,
-0.6638855338,
0.3730633259,
-0.2968298793,
-0.4658727646,
-0.9568722248,
-0.176911816,
0.6346212029,
0.948261857,
-0.0457183607,
0.0967098027,
0.0871210024,
1.1227120161,
-0.4380767643,
-0.1317870915,
-0.3088291287,
0.015416461,
-0.0320975408,
-0.2337620556,
-0.2318044752,
-0.5294708014,
0.0680873021,
-0.9730898738,
0.5314536691,
-0.114898026,
0.5983123779,
0.2171065807,
-0.0041137403,
-0.0691577792,
-0.6675846577,
0.188094601,
-0.8849394917,
0.1993704587,
0.1758180857,
0.3152572215,
-0.1086840481,
-1.2380410433,
-0.4682238996,
-0.0232085604,
-0.1766707003,
0.4155968428,
-0.0194671657,
0.4543366134,
0.169397682,
0.6172164679,
-0.3837397695,
0.0553458035,
-0.5055986643,
-0.0658498108,
0.8025001287,
0.5296911001,
0.3997530341,
0.2709289491,
0.3242007494,
-0.0032228476,
-0.3274822533,
0.1344100982,
0.4118588865,
-0.0865271986,
0.0420969687,
0.7204370499,
-0.6706501245,
0.5864883065,
0.1821145564,
0.1058263183,
0.069335714,
-0.4285236597,
-0.4603443742,
0.0557343699,
0.4798267782,
0.9249337316,
0.0565193184,
-0.1405238807,
-0.2713303566,
-0.3544204831,
0.3130409718,
-0.6980133653,
-0.3161872327,
0.431381017,
-0.5187696218,
-0.4377649426,
0.0270845909,
-0.7729159594,
-0.5956691504,
-0.430600673,
0.2422878593,
-0.1454733312,
0.1400074363,
0.4591976702,
-0.842407763,
-0.3681327105,
0.9279816747,
-0.8541365266,
0.1757137626,
0.4336195588,
0.6873105168,
0.0655004531,
-0.6389893293,
-0.2732035816,
0.1617821008,
-0.1803930551,
1.0984765291,
-0.3460704088,
-0.6791499257,
-0.1826010048,
-0.1720056832,
0.2803574502,
-0.3672479391,
0.2564074397,
-0.6415163875,
0.4468027651,
-0.2604504526,
-0.4201255441,
-0.2511046827,
0.3651382625,
-0.708722353,
0.6594598293,
0.1897583008,
-0.7861810923,
0.3554611206,
-0.8159459829,
-0.4962168038,
-0.2594198585,
0.3975275159,
-0.4947643578,
0.2156652659,
0.4012607336,
0.0800094754,
0.1562377363,
-0.0421302803,
-0.0307326596,
-0.442094475,
0.2403919548,
-0.2083072662,
0.5141996741,
-0.0545839481,
0.283302784,
0.9563658237,
-0.7525701523,
-0.1045059115,
-0.2058406025,
-0.4745996594,
-0.1734793633,
-0.1386668235,
0.1202147901,
-0.3053401709,
0.3882733881,
-0.309971869,
0.7109009624,
-0.5787045956,
0.4009978473,
0.6313442588,
0.5580939054,
0.6514334679,
-0.7014804482,
0.6373918056,
-0.3637881279,
0.205163762,
-0.8363288641,
-0.3163397312,
-0.7015262246,
-0.2503167689,
0.5590177178,
0.4365274012,
-0.6592600346,
0.2239259928,
-0.3442281783,
-0.3896369636,
-0.7385970354,
0.3049942553,
0.0864474624,
0.4785022438,
0.4158348143,
-0.3322121203,
-0.6485064626,
-0.8433891535,
-0.712148428,
0.0922109038,
-0.2462389171,
-0.4509760439,
0.2962456644,
-0.2373717725,
1.0212655067,
-0.6284489632,
-0.5300246477,
-0.5856397748,
0.3615826666,
0.0549792573,
0.3365596235,
0.4551922083,
-0.4910161495,
-0.5176140666,
-0.1112173349,
-0.804115355,
-0.4166625142,
-0.7693966627,
-0.059444949,
-0.2544619143,
0.8235399127,
-0.3206906319,
0.705147922,
0.0405776277,
-0.3310221434,
0.4230818748,
-0.7410213351,
0.5178633332,
-1.0556021929,
0.1527935266,
-0.52624017,
-0.3438627124,
-0.5316107869,
0.1763492376,
0.047574006,
-0.0919422433,
-0.0044067292,
0.303242296,
-0.6028176546,
-0.0202428997,
-0.371021837,
0.4743144512,
0.3814810812,
0.4950359464,
-0.0968355387,
0.58676368,
-0.2041639835,
-0.3334495723,
0.2227187753,
0.5465880632,
-0.1236053556,
0.4341990352,
-0.8888216019,
0.2134778649,
-0.5958737135,
0.4165538549,
-1.1191483736,
-0.5768788457,
-0.0794354305,
-0.5641269088,
0.2137927562,
0.0910771713,
-0.2479337901,
0.026842365,
-0.9607163072,
0.1858572364,
0.1138648316,
-0.4801605046,
0.7747980356,
0.2229889184,
-0.5828510523,
-0.3266263902,
-0.7402070165,
0.7408891916,
0.1093562394,
-0.654936254,
0.7893325686,
-0.1620157957,
-0.4456925988,
0.0758426711,
0.246639058,
-0.0191066563,
-0.0212852936,
0.226162374,
0.2161551863,
0.1510044932,
-0.0578895435,
0.6372708082,
-0.3266977668,
-0.3280118108,
0.2313943207,
0.0186735187,
0.1632158011,
-0.1848131418,
-0.6187407374,
0.664783597,
0.9367281795,
-0.5637482405,
0.2176946998,
0.2967458367,
-0.3660458624,
0.1716704071,
-0.5183277726,
-0.0875794515,
-0.4559608102,
0.4734208584,
-0.213404268,
-0.8674003482,
0.7571730018,
-0.0483850241,
0.7334999442,
0.251434654,
0.3197352886,
-0.2874812782,
0.8033232093,
0.7679957747,
0.0540750585,
0.599984467,
-0.1727808863,
-0.0580082424,
-1.1024588346,
-0.1563436687,
-0.4228061438,
-0.6278831959,
-0.1021557599,
0.0234746784,
0.3809586763,
0.2761563063,
0.1027797535,
0.1587527096,
-0.6148170233,
0.7814606428,
0.2844578624,
0.0922035798,
0.7058332562,
-0.4031260014,
0.194686994,
-0.3053355515,
-0.4607947469,
-0.3215733171,
0.731939733,
0.1991071403,
0.6004672647,
0.204259485,
0.6546450853,
0.6769747138,
0.6261235476,
-0.6783502698,
0.5102389455,
0.102411665,
-0.2570068538,
-0.4448792636,
0.0810392275,
-0.7563266158,
0.2382656038,
-0.3988363147,
-0.4710284472,
0.2723064721,
0.3393936157,
-0.5973423719,
0.2529488802,
-0.9385253787,
0.6244900823,
0.0903220624,
-0.2712234855,
-0.5032551885,
-0.5288919806,
0.3377777636,
0.1698093563,
0.1493201405,
0.3193241954,
-0.337970376,
0.5663381815,
-0.5292996764,
0.9400013685,
-0.0654656142,
0.2848142982,
0.1738995463,
0.3139044344,
0.289844811,
0.2295810729,
-0.1933784485,
-0.1439285576,
-0.3226214647,
-0.1871371418,
-0.8559470177,
0.5077636838,
-0.3598019183,
-0.5471678972,
-0.2620237768,
-0.4591904283,
-0.06940981,
0.4226203263,
0.3962870538,
0.4588947892,
-0.5531153083,
0.0369146839,
0.3260737956,
-0.2571629584,
0.6992904544,
0.3498767018,
-0.5796846747,
-0.9616678357,
0.503621459,
0.1676529199,
0.0883643478,
0.4217557311,
-0.0306932684,
-0.0901673809,
-0.7639241219,
-0.5014343262,
0.0638443008,
-0.7082082629,
-0.1206319928,
-0.7463606,
-0.0414358154,
-0.3239280581,
-1.0193321705,
-0.3145516515,
-0.7911638618,
-0.1893383265,
-0.2527363896,
0.3256060183,
1.0380084515,
-0.161939621,
0.4585889578,
-0.9583213925,
0.7428762913,
0.3247598708,
0.3390167654,
0.0071493266,
-0.6150581837,
-0.3019481003,
-0.1588909179,
-0.2318385094,
-0.8260092735,
0.3594510555,
0.2287155241,
0.2777652442,
0.1333847493,
-0.0428453013,
0.9552862644,
-0.2407684475,
1.0244326591,
0.1204675362,
-0.9340536594,
0.5494326353,
-0.3627860248,
0.800837934,
1.0185146332,
-0.0540170968,
-0.7819005251,
-0.3766080737,
-0.4607149065,
-0.9508527517,
0.3818291128,
0.0597445592,
-0.1054714918,
0.3302149177,
0.6443460584,
0.1981362849,
0.3615377843,
-0.1351827532,
0.1332124472,
-0.4807250202,
-0.1338148415,
0.0065965429,
-0.3647960424,
0.0780548379,
-0.3933070302,
0.5480602384,
-0.0076663261,
-0.0393811278,
0.6303223968,
-0.1771636903,
-0.0203995984,
0.3897576034,
1.0390278101,
0.7422165275,
-0.3755087256,
-0.3152084351,
0.3291743696,
-0.6326403618,
-0.1485432684,
-0.0727494955,
-0.286482513,
0.1407937855,
0.6216398478,
0.4457660913,
0.4922488928,
-0.5751689076,
0.168625623,
-0.4972277582,
-0.2572131157,
-0.3698982894,
0.0943037346,
0.2014419287,
0.1216982678,
0.1814226955,
0.5217619538,
0.4279080033,
-0.357725054,
0.0853949338,
-0.1939000785,
-0.339397788,
-0.4759769142,
0.8893328309,
0.4935412407,
-0.6378289461,
0.7153723836,
-0.0802180693,
-0.3465257883,
0.377438277,
0.085379608,
1.3736507893,
-0.0993608013,
-0.0400953591,
0.4340717494,
0.3034521937,
0.1045851782,
0.1494559646,
-0.1624778807,
-0.5189525485,
-0.5363903642,
-0.1431094706,
-0.6777192354,
-0.0995791033,
-0.7284548283,
0.1961351037,
-0.6594218612,
-0.1818419546,
0.2217823714,
-0.479554683,
-0.0264065508,
0.0957838371,
-0.4531260431,
1.0619767904,
-0.2313817739,
0.3631261587,
0.9471017122,
-0.5104750991,
-0.0285519008,
-0.0601293147,
0.1219903082,
-0.2248725593,
0.0097030941,
0.1099471226,
-0.2528820336,
0.017164547,
-0.3665037751,
-0.1386835873,
1.1682546139,
0.1019243747,
-0.4865425527,
-0.3256828487,
-0.1473663002,
0.8464935422,
-0.1459657252,
0.4241027534,
0.5942335725,
0.4659724534,
-0.1163993552,
-0.7597128153,
-0.3564677536,
-0.5226858258,
-0.0360443033,
0.0892742053,
-0.6556277871,
0.4766230881,
-0.6814008951,
-0.0031845621,
0.1096354648,
0.8555142879,
-0.2095763385,
0.2765716016,
0.2425164133,
0.4061919451,
0.6344767809,
-0.0139579261,
0.9307716489,
-0.2545725107,
-0.1354517341,
1.678047657,
-0.0745319277,
0.7592324018,
0.3679456115,
0.0338442735,
0.2902877629,
0.4362481236,
0.3559092581,
0.3286514282,
-0.071943894,
-0.2855080962,
-0.031655658,
0.1266908944,
-0.2077545375,
0.4033161402,
0.2766294777,
-0.2488707304,
-0.3688766658,
-0.0748749748,
0.0828456059,
0.4926061928,
-0.3565943837,
1.0238034725,
-0.125906378,
-0.6925820708,
0.0808568299,
0.2509190738,
0.5832179189,
-0.6319417953,
-0.3605871797,
-0.379224658,
0.1558032036,
-0.5290973186,
-1.017423749,
0.6125716567,
0.0975554883,
-0.2959845066,
-0.3937067389,
0.63307482,
-0.4621096253,
-0.1467759013,
-0.0564242676,
0.0633074343,
-0.3226676881,
-0.3798831105,
-0.4406489134,
0.1366195232,
0.327223897,
-0.4247617424,
0.3026272953,
0.3363250196,
0.0796027854,
0.6271522045,
0.784647882,
0.0849004909,
-0.2944686711,
0.3972169459,
1.0172549486,
-0.8788849711,
-0.8094035387,
-0.6485664845,
1.1985971928,
-0.4192658663,
-0.5887901187,
0.4698057771,
0.736142695,
0.6283210516,
-0.2695064843,
0.9246484637,
0.2630032003,
0.5425053835,
-0.3902775049,
1.055152297,
-0.3690699339,
0.4251865447,
-0.1435889155,
-0.8150148392,
-0.4962753356,
0.3115082383,
-0.0405624881,
-0.2307476103,
0.4228386581,
0.5836456418,
0.2227012217,
0.1512462944,
0.2311081737,
0.1989163756,
0.4980536103,
0.101931259,
0.5318046808,
-0.4269387722,
0.2023170292,
-0.4157559872,
-0.4173698425,
-0.2816597521,
-0.8702602386,
-1.0035768747,
-0.5625760555,
-0.3514245749,
-0.1781443357,
0.1322327107,
0.9283877611,
0.016617991,
-0.55012393,
-0.2556346655,
0.0936034098,
0.0370385274,
-0.3802293837,
-0.2728151977,
0.1481483728,
-0.2447438985,
-0.6443303823,
0.5367850065,
0.6746756434,
0.2015238106,
-0.1249438822,
0.1796763539,
0.1203106791,
0.0722203851,
0.6665703058,
0.4876272678,
-0.2481496036,
-0.1043802425,
0.0212975759,
0.0479408614,
0.0556594804,
0.9875577092,
-0.7168800235,
0.9923664331,
0.9182196856,
0.6537746787,
0.5769340396,
0.2307199687,
0.8154694438,
-0.5092182755,
0.1333217025,
0.0942246765,
0.2169942111,
0.4320144057,
-0.5775402188,
0.4388926029,
-0.0304384064,
-0.4808968008,
-0.678088963,
-0.2071239799,
-1.1621758938,
-0.1150648147,
0.5455963016,
-0.0306496006,
0.0386152007,
-0.3613326252,
-0.7958458662,
0.1791276336,
-0.3172491491,
1.1073762178,
0.5649067163,
-0.3724716306,
-0.0419752114,
-0.1687536687,
0.5624331236,
0.0762657374,
-0.9520761371,
0.3305386007,
0.6225309968,
0.1451611966,
0.0343807228,
0.8191369772,
-0.1469594091,
0.6149996519,
0.064903006,
0.4442281127,
-0.6329799294,
-0.210803315,
-0.4977191985,
0.1922964156,
0.0299111549,
0.0804446116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03061v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03061v3 | Structured Voronoi Sampling | 2023-06-05T17:32:35 | 2024-06-06T09:30:19 | Afra Amini, Li Du, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Gradient-based sampling algorithms have demonstrated their effectiveness in
text generation, especially in the context of controlled text generation.
However, there exists a lack of theoretically grounded and principled
approaches for this task. In this paper, we take an important step toward
building a principled approach for sampling from language models with
gradient-based methods. We use discrete distributions given by language models
to define densities and develop an algorithm based on Hamiltonian Monte Carlo
to sample from them. We name our gradient-based technique Structured Voronoi
Sampling (SVS). In an experimental setup where the reference distribution is
known, we show that the empirical distribution of SVS samples is closer to the
reference distribution compared to alternative sampling schemes. Furthermore,
in a controlled generation task, SVS is able to generate fluent and diverse
samples while following the control targets significantly better than other
methods. | [
-0.2184238136,
-0.5184284449,
0.3217102885,
0.3792324066,
-0.4180077016,
0.0972641259,
-0.1008910835,
0.0520180501,
0.2523631752,
0.7175041437,
-0.426145196,
-0.6185052991,
0.0047895205,
-0.0962576419,
-0.4414687455,
1.1807237864,
0.1418862641,
0.0930903107,
-0.0482233055,
0.1102847084,
-0.1211419106,
-0.5284456015,
-0.6657942533,
-0.3975913525,
0.5127936006,
-0.0133754741,
0.1578262746,
0.7155301571,
0.1228218153,
0.2235842645,
-0.3333365619,
0.1314410269,
-0.5352688432,
0.1501409709,
-0.0029066501,
-0.5897369981,
-0.2045215666,
-0.0035445991,
0.7370353341,
0.8294041157,
-0.7478669882,
-0.1956380755,
0.00718799,
0.5113340616,
-0.8099424243,
-0.1906424016,
-0.6821535826,
0.400868237,
-0.3333202004,
-0.466833353,
-0.4396565259,
-0.6351321936,
0.0215718094,
-0.6144787073,
0.6428848505,
-0.2374047637,
0.3594912589,
-0.0730767697,
-0.3902970552,
-0.4305506051,
-0.9892126918,
1.1901839972,
-0.5033609867,
0.2080588341,
0.3528171182,
0.3502624035,
-0.2163398564,
-0.7568846941,
-0.7632343769,
-0.470565021,
0.2153446525,
0.1441302747,
0.3832855225,
-0.0473012589,
0.2979272604,
0.2999911904,
-0.2638227046,
-0.1805716604,
-0.4766023457,
-0.0933646336,
0.6560799479,
0.032165911,
0.2186307907,
-0.5719683766,
-0.5191216469,
-0.5343219042,
-0.6644822955,
0.2269902974,
0.6932547688,
0.40997383,
-0.1265285909,
0.6997250915,
-0.2270033062,
0.7391734123,
-0.1423832327,
-0.3507887423,
0.1850952506,
-0.4852156937,
-0.4038455188,
-0.2141656727,
0.7398495078,
0.3246456683,
0.5919556618,
0.1968944222,
-0.4437539577,
-0.1232951507,
0.3963481486,
-0.4444372952,
-0.4388709068,
0.2861541808,
-0.2135335356,
-0.8116451502,
0.0174901746,
-1.1332032681,
-0.0438001975,
-0.2847705483,
-0.3856134713,
-0.3346875608,
-0.1284796596,
-0.1346619874,
-0.5458012223,
-0.1103806272,
0.2487038523,
-1.0891753435,
0.5321831703,
0.2255927324,
0.4865167737,
-0.1858216226,
0.1452870518,
-0.7052750587,
0.3693058789,
-0.6285071969,
0.7079045773,
-0.5528180599,
-0.8296970129,
0.6012629271,
-0.6981879473,
0.1294291764,
-0.6274786592,
0.5588976741,
-0.3950948119,
0.1666285843,
-0.2614648342,
-0.2059480399,
0.2451625019,
0.2088169903,
-0.6768347621,
1.3895386457,
0.3553946614,
-0.7625248432,
0.3223690391,
-0.0196497925,
-0.4542099833,
0.1911222935,
-0.7200479507,
-0.1623649299,
0.1071010903,
0.1032838896,
0.367300421,
-0.1120928451,
0.2635493875,
-0.0334747881,
-0.02139901,
0.1907038987,
-0.3037796617,
0.9073334336,
0.3786945343,
-0.1332430542,
-0.091803208,
-1.0052102804,
0.2241037935,
-0.2806378603,
-0.6719299555,
-0.6337580085,
0.2749731541,
0.3937530518,
0.1548498422,
-0.1879812479,
-0.3943528235,
0.3134273887,
-0.391182363,
0.4064476788,
0.7065578103,
0.144108355,
0.8104262352,
-0.2167756706,
0.6271945238,
-0.0619691722,
-0.1334474832,
0.1650837064,
-0.0975456908,
-0.488948077,
-0.6216111779,
0.6054540277,
0.7027636766,
-1.4087635279,
0.4429796636,
-0.2201801538,
-0.5088822246,
-0.0222613961,
-0.0112503618,
0.4928441346,
0.6432746053,
0.2187341452,
-0.1083116606,
-0.1984256059,
-0.9812951088,
0.0905883163,
-0.088538982,
-0.516744554,
0.4104620516,
0.377355665,
0.0755104497,
0.8913812637,
-0.6621860862,
0.1619471312,
-0.1588045061,
0.3449302018,
-0.2041983753,
0.5436442494,
0.7851148248,
-0.8376964331,
-0.3622921705,
-0.0258988328,
-0.5075932741,
-0.1270322651,
-0.0921954364,
-0.4014422894,
-0.138999939,
0.6634393334,
-0.3728299737,
0.2457573116,
0.5022773147,
0.1056758016,
0.416837424,
-0.0859576389,
-0.0446297042,
-1.2606899738,
0.0322625339,
0.3610363901,
-0.3769508302,
-0.6539745927,
0.0088676717,
-0.1529154032,
-0.0156598296,
-0.5094306469,
0.4947343469,
-0.2116268277,
0.0636234358,
-0.1751465797,
0.2245239019,
-0.082314238,
0.6227452755,
-0.0208246838,
0.7316424251,
0.2942811251,
-1.0425429344,
0.0966694579,
0.0559819043,
-0.4577540457,
0.6451025009,
-0.8547492623,
-0.2149136364,
-0.2858925164,
0.4421256185,
-0.8790095448,
-0.0822593942,
0.3042938411,
-0.1797105521,
0.1106552705,
0.0681309327,
-0.1696808934,
-0.1597760767,
-0.3289541602,
0.3686413765,
0.8248748779,
-0.2983130813,
0.5106134415,
0.5570982099,
-0.448353678,
-0.7154256105,
-0.6395212412,
-0.557466507,
-0.0851783082,
-0.1415909082,
0.5291642547,
-0.1449802816,
-0.5014701486,
-0.1004484817,
0.0129394103,
-0.1042469293,
-0.1195011958,
-0.170452863,
-0.0411141738,
0.2278635204,
-0.0278603062,
0.4401696622,
0.1413567364,
-0.1023662686,
-0.3715164661,
0.8177737594,
0.8131428361,
-0.1958417594,
-0.3153732121,
0.5824446678,
0.3765158653,
-0.111874871,
0.3272087574,
0.1885826737,
-0.3114128709,
-0.8227789402,
-0.0732460991,
-0.1604441702,
-0.4584333599,
0.1833060682,
-0.3553729057,
-0.6488428712,
0.5619724989,
-0.1665149927,
0.2509331703,
0.4127988219,
0.7162649632,
-0.3478704095,
0.8580463529,
0.779828608,
0.0956912413,
0.8462916613,
-0.2730843127,
-0.0636142939,
-0.7369751334,
-0.1745085418,
-0.9338121414,
-0.0900891051,
-0.6995447278,
-0.6327320933,
0.4368309081,
0.4283463061,
0.2069749832,
-0.0356430784,
-0.3806022406,
0.1068193018,
1.0126478672,
0.0538534671,
0.0442029759,
0.5543172956,
-0.6518369913,
0.0717543811,
-0.6696025729,
-0.5628079772,
0.8629889488,
-0.0952407345,
0.3802312613,
-0.0756327212,
0.704387188,
0.3297085166,
0.570638299,
-0.3963395953,
0.5574700832,
0.0522831641,
-0.4456595182,
-0.4367037714,
-0.5068824291,
-0.7232511044,
0.1685133725,
-0.1650048941,
-0.5383274555,
0.3904891312,
0.3929252028,
-0.1231402159,
-0.0250139236,
-0.2168032229,
0.1381800026,
0.4438526928,
-0.0559489168,
-0.0023204251,
-0.2875977755,
0.4541511238,
-0.1478244662,
0.3131961823,
0.0872879773,
0.3249608576,
0.5097306967,
-0.7846326828,
0.7833153009,
-0.2168616205,
-0.3009416163,
0.7385855913,
-0.0115584619,
0.7879226208,
0.202184245,
-0.2761868834,
-0.1233259439,
-0.1948062927,
-0.6706572175,
-0.7363855243,
0.462009877,
-0.5575861335,
-0.1117537171,
-0.2687467039,
-0.3151372969,
-0.0198853202,
0.0501487888,
0.7309967279,
0.6601412296,
-0.3313599527,
0.1606374234,
0.5595735908,
-0.1794776469,
0.4111864269,
0.1040033847,
-0.0806673169,
-0.7670484185,
0.86389184,
0.1597052068,
0.2423243672,
0.6768701077,
0.0813395754,
-0.1630577743,
-0.6466983557,
-0.6515225768,
-0.0567293428,
-0.3959413171,
0.161942333,
-0.5899338126,
-0.1830418557,
-0.33833009,
-0.4067716002,
-0.3336763084,
-0.3733024001,
0.0204792283,
-0.1866790503,
0.1626790762,
0.3664621413,
0.0286845174,
0.5200226903,
-0.6090936065,
0.3419867158,
0.5680048466,
-0.0753092989,
-0.0896496177,
-0.0402220376,
0.0571966916,
0.2576242685,
-0.116937615,
-0.8537989855,
0.6337609291,
-0.1303550154,
0.8254278302,
0.1959964633,
0.053106349,
0.3685339689,
-0.9303925633,
1.0514477491,
0.2479296029,
-0.7805675268,
0.6598909497,
-0.8123164773,
-0.2403434813,
0.6146916151,
0.2436701953,
-0.5136262774,
-0.4774263799,
-0.637684226,
-0.7539960742,
0.2160483003,
0.807974875,
0.3749118447,
-0.4082033932,
0.6342189312,
-0.2323455364,
0.673206389,
-0.7212542892,
-0.2953055501,
-0.2409608364,
-0.6539205909,
-0.2220909894,
-0.1812503785,
-0.5325063467,
-0.041918505,
0.4082339108,
-0.1257475913,
0.2414639443,
0.3646953404,
0.3176316917,
-0.0703613907,
-0.0122202625,
1.0388740301,
0.4855336845,
-0.0309957042,
0.025363192,
-0.0973305106,
-0.7955029607,
0.0524049588,
-0.0562604219,
-0.8702824116,
0.2101847678,
0.1561535746,
0.6946622729,
-0.0929462612,
-0.8445973396,
0.3181081116,
-0.0365687497,
-0.4991738796,
-0.4645510316,
0.3404611647,
-0.1876823753,
0.0822035,
0.3323609233,
-0.0675261915,
0.0749479383,
-0.3138850927,
0.2381873727,
0.4427810609,
-0.4657132328,
-0.2602113187,
0.5368489623,
0.4502869546,
-0.679212451,
0.6326836348,
-0.287027806,
-0.1307517588,
0.798171401,
0.4678372741,
0.6080310941,
-0.2299375534,
0.4851732254,
0.3922929764,
0.1388138682,
-0.2871626019,
0.6649711132,
-0.2029129118,
-1.0196644068,
-0.3608081639,
-0.7475625277,
-0.4579177499,
0.1802250743,
-0.8408118486,
0.0976998881,
-0.6147134304,
-0.0217385199,
-0.0643296465,
-0.2219840139,
-0.3634041846,
0.4545191824,
-0.1949975789,
0.7995787859,
-0.9070698619,
0.8385984898,
0.3857490122,
-0.1245037913,
-0.775244832,
0.1934697479,
-0.1648885459,
-0.4936184585,
0.5739123821,
-0.5603084564,
-0.1389542669,
0.2303375006,
-0.7998667359,
-0.6502958536,
0.908239603,
-0.1064143404,
-0.5735881925,
0.1893064231,
-0.2321767956,
0.6582581997,
-0.2163807601,
-0.1472317129,
0.2536258698,
0.1176490039,
0.2903475165,
-0.2709960938,
-0.3521344066,
-0.5655382276,
0.3557745814,
0.3317371905,
-0.3396987617,
1.1518182755,
0.2933766544,
-0.1889107972,
0.1200606823,
0.9109178185,
1.0218057632,
0.0102206804,
0.6623598933,
0.4170947373,
1.1408754587,
0.2919817567,
1.5119731426,
-0.3689719141,
0.2285377681,
0.7592279315,
-0.3506061733,
0.9451832771,
0.6298711896,
-0.067736432,
0.7363427877,
0.5210971236,
0.1154041365,
0.8683441281,
0.6292587519,
-0.6289958358,
0.108209677,
-0.2311313152,
-0.1406026632,
0.0817600414,
0.3653883338,
-0.3974404335,
-0.1080130115,
-0.1073284447,
-0.1825193018,
0.3568117917,
-0.181071505,
0.3944483995,
0.0483617634,
-0.8659284115,
0.3831759095,
0.3699938357,
0.4984876812,
-0.378413707,
-0.1519955844,
-0.2806791663,
-0.2034382373,
0.3045952022,
-0.3756594956,
0.0557258017,
0.114571318,
-0.3668659627,
-0.4096007943,
0.494342953,
-0.5509579182,
-0.6700146794,
-0.3061308265,
0.5369135737,
0.0667118728,
0.2786196768,
-0.219819501,
-0.3433890343,
0.1659834832,
-0.4132832885,
0.1200116873,
0.5293872952,
-0.3183147907,
0.3594048917,
0.8196809292,
0.2999747992,
0.1086427048,
0.3269430101,
0.7889271379,
-0.6679108739,
-0.8427334428,
-0.6209626198,
0.683999002,
-0.3309519291,
-0.6643622518,
0.5155273676,
0.3078678548,
0.8612185121,
-0.2098358423,
1.0814751387,
0.1676478535,
0.6395477057,
-0.9010565281,
0.2510608733,
-0.3684235513,
0.0597447343,
-0.2483926415,
-1.0194805861,
-0.123510316,
0.9947545528,
-0.0163390916,
0.1969219148,
0.6140215993,
0.6701229811,
0.1179985926,
-0.2527226508,
0.0398734659,
-0.1194855571,
0.5358541608,
0.0992225856,
0.7338918447,
-0.2034580559,
0.1850876212,
-0.297100693,
-0.154652819,
-0.1870898008,
-0.8493768573,
-1.0012563467,
-0.4366894066,
-0.0538882576,
-0.3866945505,
-0.2006216645,
0.6689084768,
0.8450735211,
-0.596251905,
-0.0934368744,
-0.7719081044,
0.0828288421,
-0.2552233636,
-0.2263854444,
0.1243346035,
-0.1215763837,
-1.4417625666,
0.304158777,
0.0801539421,
0.3970484436,
-0.412843585,
0.2414832115,
0.1532685906,
0.4335379899,
0.6214691401,
0.2708655298,
-0.3905905485,
-0.2091238797,
-0.0026756665,
-0.7744125128,
-0.0877234414,
1.1240588427,
-0.7690953016,
0.0824716911,
0.8987987638,
0.3105520606,
0.6404472589,
0.3100290895,
0.983728826,
-1.3970352411,
0.6318033934,
0.3957458138,
-0.0410889685,
0.0434377007,
-0.1859640628,
0.2973534465,
0.4402015805,
-0.1813582927,
-0.9647145271,
0.4748256803,
-1.2253241539,
-0.3851111531,
1.363162756,
0.3772810698,
-0.3619142175,
-0.1313209683,
-0.1723026037,
0.2774727046,
-0.2393423468,
0.6309201121,
0.5319542289,
0.2443030328,
0.1452494115,
-0.8339288831,
0.8322005272,
0.3014015555,
-0.7647420168,
-0.2788475752,
0.4302874506,
0.0251144059,
0.2888609767,
1.2347668409,
0.1245556101,
-0.1361145973,
0.1419923902,
0.4178169668,
0.4646425843,
-0.4764303565,
-0.12390659,
0.5355634689,
-0.4593063295,
-0.0262491126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03055v1 | Analyzing Syntactic Generalization Capacity of Pre-trained Language Models on Japanese Honorific Conversion | 2023-06-05T17:27:48 | 2023-06-05T17:27:48 | Ryo Sekizawa, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Using Japanese honorifics is challenging because it requires not only
knowledge of the grammatical rules but also contextual information, such as
social relationships. It remains unclear whether pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) can flexibly handle Japanese honorifics like humans. To analyze
this, we introduce an honorific conversion task that considers social
relationships among people mentioned in a conversation. We construct a Japanese
honorifics dataset from problem templates of various sentence structures to
investigate the syntactic generalization capacity of GPT-3, one of the leading
LLMs, on this task under two settings: fine-tuning and prompt learning. Our
results showed that the fine-tuned GPT-3 performed better in a context-aware
honorific conversion task than the prompt-based one. The fine-tuned model
demonstrated overall syntactic generalizability towards compound honorific
sentences, except when tested with the data involving direct speech. | [
-0.1895046234,
-0.8100638986,
0.9487210512,
0.0929293558,
-0.5393273234,
-0.2348090708,
-0.7554177046,
-0.511721015,
-0.0777928382,
0.5206295848,
-0.5040496588,
-0.4859767556,
-0.8131842017,
0.4532695115,
0.2101879418,
1.433249712,
-0.3292961121,
0.1217220947,
-0.1867067218,
-0.0019284973,
-0.4178023338,
-0.6547318697,
-0.6781410575,
-0.248913303,
0.6552231312,
0.3848112226,
0.6140266061,
0.429236412,
0.6658705473,
0.2595163584,
0.2535963655,
0.0942558497,
-0.5855157375,
0.1985451132,
-0.0119515862,
-0.6173884273,
-0.6577163339,
0.2730078399,
0.789953649,
0.8668223619,
0.1312000901,
0.2555041313,
0.0201442037,
0.3789482117,
-0.2853606939,
0.6596469283,
-0.8098795414,
-0.1277463436,
-0.4502760768,
-0.080005005,
-0.3153196871,
-0.3609311879,
0.1335784048,
-0.8709281087,
0.2361178547,
0.0674407557,
0.7950127125,
0.2506830394,
-0.1597768366,
0.2570914328,
-0.8243851066,
0.680262804,
-0.3277394176,
0.2074125856,
0.6361561418,
0.3667018116,
-0.2032430768,
-0.5535340905,
-0.4126966596,
-0.3844693303,
-0.0954732522,
0.003569586,
-0.1337104142,
0.3865630031,
0.4043312073,
0.4441194534,
-0.5514191985,
0.0067109945,
-0.2903154194,
-0.0044484092,
0.4989321828,
-0.142571792,
0.4905672669,
-0.3124168217,
0.080369167,
-0.0828965083,
-0.5249437094,
-0.0291378405,
0.2794828415,
0.4343696833,
-0.0493574739,
0.4264065623,
-0.2276071459,
0.5438525081,
-0.2037289143,
-0.0227453206,
0.1163031161,
-0.6671552062,
0.0057944078,
-0.1841340363,
0.8116915822,
0.3418937922,
0.7706357241,
-0.5124208331,
-0.019427726,
0.2614214718,
0.1439869702,
-0.8146512508,
0.0229743347,
-0.407240659,
-0.0945270807,
0.0199386012,
-0.0217150822,
-0.0146664167,
0.1987902373,
-0.0897955522,
0.2299656272,
-0.3560815454,
-0.0751199201,
0.0337080099,
-0.1746800989,
0.1697350889,
0.4930950701,
-1.0239946842,
0.3652235866,
0.5605055094,
0.8186897635,
-0.2010760605,
-0.4954120219,
-0.417709291,
0.6488488913,
-0.2694892585,
0.519292295,
-0.7556405663,
-0.3941916823,
-0.3914769292,
0.1917664409,
-0.4131042361,
-0.2566482127,
0.4987981617,
-0.4152792692,
0.1933277994,
-0.1771147847,
-0.4307492375,
-0.0260979161,
0.2084085792,
-0.4354410172,
0.3918444514,
0.4942988753,
-0.4726378322,
0.5607165694,
-0.6306254864,
-0.4541217387,
0.3432099223,
-0.3378486633,
-0.4836874306,
0.1368001699,
0.198131457,
0.7322940826,
-0.3324775994,
0.577993989,
-0.6101167202,
-0.3294431567,
0.0263113119,
-0.0714441687,
0.1644544452,
-0.0176125951,
-0.1370426267,
-0.0052458229,
-0.4049059153,
-0.1769975573,
0.2376213074,
-0.206802845,
-0.5442639589,
-0.2366675436,
-0.2691363692,
-0.2123266011,
0.1911656708,
-0.5168101788,
0.6037190557,
-0.3123438656,
0.5642948747,
0.4738027453,
0.1810429245,
0.5200663805,
-0.2020455152,
0.6342525482,
-0.1877872348,
-0.0338536724,
0.0472391285,
-0.7211601734,
-0.3301353753,
0.1361378878,
0.1634317189,
0.2896584868,
-0.7102355957,
0.29333359,
-0.6460002065,
-0.2583909333,
-0.3276126683,
0.0808015987,
0.3451729417,
0.3748377264,
0.3006100357,
-0.3276637197,
-0.3123860657,
-0.918807447,
-0.53167665,
-0.4996209145,
-0.0273176897,
0.5799713731,
0.4710760713,
-0.3229416013,
0.5972588658,
-0.3495534062,
-0.2419825345,
-0.3769953847,
0.1361742914,
0.296467036,
0.5728630424,
0.5295635462,
-0.5439779162,
-0.2978269458,
0.3445903361,
-0.4824391603,
-0.0421925783,
0.0244292002,
0.0071909381,
-0.0532567948,
0.3722887039,
-0.5008898377,
0.2313327491,
0.4346329272,
-0.1680858433,
0.4574356675,
-0.0180583745,
0.3130161464,
-1.1722147465,
0.086192131,
0.0675939396,
-0.1649333537,
-0.7360540628,
-0.0842647031,
-0.1230046749,
-0.297814846,
0.0996622741,
0.5276834965,
-0.4639114738,
-0.2100601494,
0.0957070887,
-0.0797929019,
-0.3698287308,
0.548160255,
0.2552101016,
0.878990829,
0.2604625821,
-0.7621856332,
0.2072866112,
0.1554313451,
0.0018607025,
0.3705808818,
-0.5845819712,
0.3504814804,
-0.0482572988,
0.4729396999,
-0.9714698792,
-0.6619039774,
0.3245995641,
-0.5075933933,
0.0165231451,
-0.4550895095,
-0.5237361193,
-0.1235210374,
0.0584282279,
0.6482915878,
0.437210232,
-0.0805740878,
0.2552369535,
0.1396310031,
-0.4931880534,
0.0978019759,
-0.5768649578,
-0.0039071022,
-0.3100400567,
-0.6260783076,
0.5963477492,
0.0365504175,
0.0200774446,
-0.1431214809,
0.0080121178,
0.1222040355,
0.227521494,
-0.0013042671,
0.3463211358,
-0.2499055266,
0.0397397839,
0.1395088136,
-0.0254085362,
0.1174679175,
-0.1631615162,
0.4878586233,
-0.3324621022,
-0.1211691424,
-0.4753789306,
0.0969235376,
0.4306951761,
0.0984517857,
0.6433080435,
0.6095516682,
-0.28722471,
-0.0687263384,
-0.4625237882,
-0.1839319021,
-0.3377155066,
0.5392953157,
-0.6879438162,
-1.1074237823,
0.5579009056,
0.0146302171,
-0.0979026183,
0.2732464671,
0.1052495912,
0.2660231888,
1.107791543,
0.5131062269,
-0.1161398739,
0.5489857197,
-0.0800480768,
-0.0536586456,
-1.0490190983,
-0.0622921549,
-0.5399228334,
-0.0793008655,
-0.6518297195,
-0.2779892087,
0.4397982955,
0.216387853,
-0.199652344,
0.3501005769,
-0.2743677795,
0.3798272908,
0.1478213072,
0.0852217153,
0.474726975,
0.09561418,
0.4218908548,
-0.1544474959,
-0.3766480088,
-0.5056303144,
1.0031263828,
0.4269735217,
0.4671671987,
0.3431085944,
0.7637371421,
0.0090484787,
0.3755915761,
-0.8093041182,
0.6204608679,
-0.4708917439,
-0.1986543834,
-0.565151453,
-0.7638777494,
-1.0856608152,
0.0250122026,
0.1337226927,
-0.5939048529,
-0.2707893252,
-0.0284820888,
-0.2029858679,
0.0160770696,
-0.7672733068,
0.885186851,
-0.1445354372,
-0.176926136,
-0.0806393102,
-0.5186258554,
0.310134083,
-0.0707211196,
0.004248389,
-0.1806296706,
-0.2560256422,
0.9584133625,
-0.076270707,
0.704023242,
-0.2999542654,
-0.0547039956,
-0.2992978394,
-0.0511231013,
0.4363822341,
0.325879395,
-0.0195301808,
0.1125345975,
-0.2389785647,
-0.2572562397,
-0.8718503714,
0.487641871,
-1.1088832617,
-0.9647600651,
-0.2078100145,
-0.4313033521,
-0.641172111,
0.2748621106,
0.2289650738,
0.0205910206,
-0.4796586633,
0.1891204268,
0.4093069732,
0.2306392491,
0.0637844726,
0.42935583,
-0.1494518667,
-0.2561205924,
0.6405652761,
0.2601724267,
0.4305685461,
0.2451016158,
0.204622969,
-0.3509854078,
-0.7482203841,
-0.6569394469,
0.5754902363,
-0.3766114116,
0.0934526175,
-0.4782887697,
-0.1852787286,
-0.7788655162,
-0.1032642797,
0.0445192643,
-0.3616374433,
-0.4701992869,
0.0398826525,
0.3034053445,
0.7772800922,
0.3766936958,
0.3349172771,
-0.646448195,
0.2319780737,
0.4559973478,
0.4083093405,
-0.4355827868,
-0.7802855372,
0.1592160314,
-0.1620480865,
0.0762563199,
-0.92935884,
0.1270539016,
0.4293174744,
0.5147804022,
0.2532669306,
-0.1864647567,
0.8644186258,
-0.432975322,
0.6091378331,
0.0222904887,
-0.6999167204,
0.7770434022,
-0.9170241952,
0.3657977283,
0.8238662481,
0.3994962871,
-0.6950164437,
-0.4869885147,
-0.8596238494,
-0.5279700756,
0.8464415073,
0.1386207491,
0.2403220087,
-0.0704230145,
0.7703318,
0.0918873474,
0.3364235759,
-0.9215589166,
0.1169117019,
0.0867331922,
0.1696413159,
-0.5851920843,
0.1916109473,
0.0785102844,
-0.3880099654,
0.5881929994,
-0.2282856107,
0.0922231749,
0.1560809463,
-0.0760175809,
-0.035737142,
0.5624943972,
0.3411302269,
0.375769496,
-0.1399712563,
0.0288978536,
0.2202950567,
-0.3972556889,
0.1629771441,
0.2427961528,
-0.1446532458,
-0.1435668319,
0.3170277178,
1.0124495029,
0.4742614329,
-0.0103521487,
0.5271520615,
-0.2005031854,
-0.1803875715,
-0.137753889,
0.291129142,
-0.0216684937,
-0.3026698828,
0.1189572066,
-0.0994974822,
0.1666637808,
-0.8721568584,
-0.0944157913,
0.3897691965,
-0.1237647086,
-0.5743294358,
0.5856653452,
0.3882310987,
-0.1250810027,
0.3991302252,
-0.2757278979,
-0.5237156153,
0.2887616754,
0.7897519469,
0.9453606009,
-0.3208189607,
0.2920848727,
0.4694257975,
0.14784199,
-0.1465179026,
-0.2004756331,
-0.5925453901,
-0.9047130346,
-0.3516798019,
-0.6496961117,
-0.5553388,
0.2941503823,
-0.884029448,
0.0071622315,
-0.4878145456,
-0.4369460642,
0.0974270776,
0.0556673557,
-0.6654037833,
-0.101999335,
0.0722735226,
0.1753303856,
-0.974511683,
0.7576545477,
1.1471897364,
-0.4525905848,
-0.9727014303,
0.0190918725,
-0.5728831887,
-0.8556029797,
0.6547787189,
0.2691525817,
-0.2141680717,
0.2397702634,
-0.57255584,
-0.6204605699,
0.9422731996,
0.5567717552,
-0.5807253718,
-0.2904533148,
0.2798993289,
0.622556448,
-0.5151846409,
0.1262500435,
0.8609967828,
0.6044558883,
-0.3264872134,
-1.2567585707,
0.2120968997,
-0.4294397533,
0.4822588563,
0.1983785927,
-0.852410078,
0.7762275338,
-0.0902417749,
-0.3999503255,
0.0504165143,
0.6409401298,
0.4714463651,
0.0952141136,
0.4940783381,
0.3824556172,
0.7129632235,
-0.2348775119,
0.9425974488,
0.0356290601,
-0.0787428916,
0.736545682,
-0.3403153121,
0.6140786409,
0.5473584533,
-0.2440795153,
0.6241588593,
0.3532630503,
0.0004812898,
0.1084716171,
0.147680521,
-0.2655263543,
-0.4031842947,
-0.1345138401,
-0.5456982851,
0.5289566517,
0.4972214401,
-0.3609933853,
0.0391632915,
0.0661575794,
0.2637315989,
0.033123441,
-0.3860621154,
1.1787378788,
0.0083984453,
-1.171300292,
0.61162287,
-0.0519066863,
0.6384791732,
-0.7361487746,
-0.0037887045,
-0.0026618179,
0.0280873962,
-0.0815732032,
-0.6629726887,
-0.0415033028,
-0.0045222882,
-0.2303301692,
-0.0952000245,
0.6721144319,
-0.4913111329,
-0.2082739919,
0.1037492752,
0.6068038344,
0.4361158609,
0.0248132125,
-0.3481601477,
-0.1265779585,
0.0782078132,
-0.1167095229,
0.4651228786,
0.5096954107,
-0.2727166116,
0.4808835387,
0.5889678597,
0.4386604428,
-0.2722246349,
0.4029422998,
0.7985203266,
-0.6028434038,
-0.6544875503,
-0.7106084824,
-0.0292265601,
-0.015975792,
-0.5485646725,
0.8301096559,
0.3056562245,
1.0015178919,
-0.0676244572,
0.9950595498,
0.2683985829,
0.281337589,
-0.6707797647,
0.5323018432,
-0.408156693,
0.1517709196,
-0.4002461731,
-0.8729870319,
-0.3582556844,
0.6595397592,
-0.7978996634,
0.3510373831,
0.6064380407,
0.4263297915,
0.0284376275,
0.154936865,
0.3917196691,
-0.0693309978,
0.2148896009,
0.751413703,
0.6603659391,
-0.2087135464,
0.4199185073,
-0.0351099521,
-0.2983436286,
0.0365962796,
-0.571446836,
-0.9202061892,
-0.6414597034,
-0.2114676386,
-0.0555529222,
0.4002109766,
0.7071748972,
0.6005391479,
-0.450220108,
-0.2687080204,
-0.3087789416,
-0.2649829686,
0.181640923,
-0.2529598773,
0.0826839954,
-0.4841836095,
-0.6566743255,
0.3616654277,
0.1509067714,
0.1609952152,
-0.1670622081,
-0.0114245554,
0.3021728694,
-0.3579174876,
0.3903774023,
0.2605754137,
-0.7870588303,
-0.5289793611,
-0.1570577919,
-0.0181682631,
-0.0471984781,
0.7950381637,
-0.5918514729,
0.2721941173,
0.2934186757,
0.5714253783,
0.5443710089,
0.2907964885,
0.8143107891,
-0.8403322697,
-0.0579376146,
0.3689712286,
0.371943146,
0.2555474043,
-0.4711560905,
0.4438854754,
0.4098885953,
-0.8149419427,
-0.77318573,
0.3281925023,
-0.9375893474,
-0.0369704254,
1.3291893005,
-0.1193076447,
-0.2884083092,
-0.243833676,
-0.0892274827,
0.3416308165,
-0.6131998301,
0.4024493992,
0.783125639,
-0.3391520381,
-0.1449685395,
-0.3971066475,
0.8477893472,
0.5740160346,
-0.9746554494,
0.1914431155,
0.4375151992,
0.3083393276,
0.2018614113,
0.9618521333,
-0.067387566,
0.6365638375,
-0.3357045352,
-0.1817581356,
-0.1120707318,
-0.2246424556,
-0.3778836131,
-0.0618081652,
0.3487893343,
0.1313197017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06077v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06077v3 | Semantically-Prompted Language Models Improve Visual Descriptions | 2023-06-05T17:22:54 | 2024-04-02T16:19:22 | Michael Ogezi, Bradley Hauer, Grzegorz Kondrak | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Language-vision models like CLIP have made significant strides in vision
tasks, such as zero-shot image classification (ZSIC). However, generating
specific and expressive visual descriptions remains challenging; descriptions
produced by current methods are often ambiguous and lacking in granularity. To
tackle these issues, we propose V-GLOSS: Visual Glosses, a novel method built
upon two key ideas. The first is Semantic Prompting, which conditions a
language model on structured semantic knowledge. The second is a new
contrastive algorithm that elicits fine-grained distinctions between similar
concepts. With both ideas, we demonstrate that V-GLOSS improves visual
descriptions and achieves strong results in the zero-shot setting on general
and fine-grained image-classification datasets, including ImageNet, STL-10,
FGVC Aircraft, and Flowers 102. Moreover, these descriptive capabilities
contribute to enhancing image-generation performance. Finally, we introduce a
quality-tested silver dataset with descriptions generated with V-GLOSS for all
ImageNet classes. | [
-0.525180757,
-0.6259801984,
0.6984986067,
0.1760557443,
-0.4176957011,
-0.2789878249,
-0.1687541157,
-0.6715787649,
0.345602721,
0.6326012611,
-0.4121650159,
-0.5663319826,
-0.4688423872,
0.0101185963,
-0.7279908657,
0.8398776054,
0.028416533,
-0.0701939389,
-0.2032633275,
0.0552827679,
-0.501042366,
-0.0641301796,
-0.3364624977,
0.0189949572,
0.6977928281,
0.4295887947,
0.8685054183,
0.6474451423,
0.5160346031,
0.3319651783,
-0.0417743661,
0.1677795053,
-0.3633821905,
0.1313935667,
-0.0528108887,
-0.4204219878,
-0.1261767,
-0.4155995846,
0.3434549272,
0.7001136541,
0.0458831824,
-0.0707150102,
-0.0961595401,
0.5325530767,
-1.0409400463,
0.1806082875,
-0.7959519029,
0.0290382281,
-0.1677051187,
-0.3905753791,
-0.1925064474,
0.1814398468,
0.4389368892,
-0.9585806727,
0.4215621948,
-0.1442780644,
1.4683394432,
0.1556662172,
-0.0809121877,
-0.0363690406,
-0.7161061168,
0.7101700306,
-0.498601079,
0.1971221715,
0.0991168916,
0.6367982626,
0.0675147623,
-1.0353027582,
-0.7092285752,
-0.2093915492,
0.0385839604,
0.2781599462,
-0.1895490587,
0.2044270337,
0.2036377639,
0.4276576042,
-0.167001456,
0.0226764828,
-0.6607677341,
-0.0878299549,
0.2728485465,
0.2832145989,
0.3110978603,
-0.2325314581,
-0.5846088529,
-0.1661821902,
-0.6799039841,
0.0820062459,
-0.2116776854,
0.3040581942,
0.0063109924,
0.6043800712,
-0.9185516834,
0.9187291861,
-0.1247738153,
0.0577664152,
0.2570680976,
-0.3289729953,
-0.3247382045,
-0.1600046009,
0.5798202157,
1.1056681871,
0.3747172356,
0.0032829451,
-0.2273170948,
0.2710747719,
0.2253323346,
-1.007630825,
-0.2673427463,
0.0606193617,
-0.2452516258,
-0.5344544649,
0.1676634103,
-0.6801060438,
-0.2677129507,
-0.557017982,
0.6244014502,
-0.3108988404,
0.0870887339,
0.3806143105,
-0.4933256805,
0.4727935493,
0.7442058325,
-0.7685928941,
0.2439912558,
0.4425338209,
0.6995970011,
0.1318168789,
-0.2503968775,
-0.7234323621,
0.1946598589,
-0.5456398726,
0.9171702266,
-0.4081730545,
-0.1919691116,
0.2597463727,
-0.1258268505,
0.5019531846,
-0.4951521456,
0.1666202247,
-0.2267528027,
0.2334087044,
-0.3902228177,
-0.2100311965,
-0.1495443583,
0.1511417776,
-0.3361502588,
0.8017231822,
0.1482727975,
-0.6285545826,
0.8023078442,
-0.1852100194,
-0.0789754167,
0.6169560552,
-0.7036082149,
-0.3933421969,
0.5229827166,
0.3415720463,
0.3944387734,
-0.281593889,
0.1214375868,
-0.1578340083,
-0.2813320756,
0.0081875129,
-0.1540640444,
0.1990067065,
0.104719229,
-0.3415789008,
0.4157966971,
-0.6813486218,
0.3091568351,
0.2562436759,
0.1341997385,
-0.4256440699,
-0.1443670094,
-0.0793943331,
0.1789560467,
0.2796804011,
-0.3226302862,
0.0807190537,
-0.5164010525,
0.1244295835,
0.5341382027,
-0.0602834672,
0.2657294869,
-0.1243415102,
0.3654138744,
0.1634153277,
0.4588082731,
-0.6750420928,
-0.4438657761,
-1.0730005503,
-0.1543600112,
0.1312464625,
0.6291670203,
-1.3625744581,
-0.0686167106,
-0.2991805375,
-0.1817314029,
-0.1838903576,
0.0997103974,
0.6794502139,
0.8179982305,
0.4691188037,
-0.5626573563,
-0.3060694635,
-1.0817540884,
0.3260198534,
-0.1854712814,
-0.2040370554,
0.6188869476,
0.2384414822,
-0.0596209094,
0.7609623671,
-0.6970381141,
-0.121385105,
0.0551178008,
0.2777054012,
-0.0441577993,
-0.0714865401,
0.7107448578,
-0.9022980332,
-0.5572993159,
-0.0125504434,
-0.6155336499,
-0.3869889379,
0.0538377166,
-0.1551568657,
0.004994412,
0.6255084276,
-0.3122934699,
0.6867138147,
0.063379243,
-0.2830322981,
0.8530880213,
-0.1794211119,
0.1937607825,
-0.8128509521,
-0.2280353159,
-0.0147606442,
-0.0352898017,
-0.636967361,
0.0672105253,
-0.1441577524,
-0.0852928609,
-0.9355583787,
0.673989892,
-0.4027155042,
-0.0104016438,
-0.4738057554,
0.2719444335,
0.1975563169,
0.2533651292,
0.5429416299,
0.6268590689,
1.3817200661,
-0.7469475269,
0.2254856378,
0.4342422485,
-0.257548064,
0.7612764835,
-0.7290607691,
-0.38899225,
-0.3781014681,
-0.1471496373,
-1.0103459358,
-0.5937678218,
0.0538570359,
-0.1846277118,
0.1007404998,
-0.1413877159,
-0.1478311419,
-0.4278056324,
-0.4032350481,
0.284896493,
0.5261275768,
-0.5833683014,
0.2165122479,
-0.1703719795,
-0.0919082686,
-0.5758338571,
-0.6813889146,
0.4368692935,
-0.1167304367,
-0.5635219216,
0.480551064,
0.1360008866,
-0.1572599858,
0.1385447085,
0.0244225413,
-0.0609264895,
0.0327339619,
0.2951054573,
0.5261060596,
-0.2196964324,
0.1982857585,
-0.2197641134,
-0.0045330282,
-0.2933591604,
-0.3590016365,
0.3218826056,
-0.3943329453,
-0.0142510738,
-0.3077512681,
0.4016861618,
0.2818041444,
-0.2270189971,
0.4811748564,
0.6163306832,
0.0315471292,
-0.2426045686,
-0.2588546574,
-0.2153833658,
-0.5173899531,
0.3016289771,
-0.4846205413,
-0.9155201912,
0.2252256423,
-0.1361629367,
-0.1089418754,
0.3376369774,
0.2643185854,
-0.1218652278,
0.9038035274,
0.8840463758,
0.4102676213,
0.8009266853,
-0.1870611757,
-0.0796448216,
-0.5500540137,
-0.0812137648,
-0.1844653487,
0.0545017272,
-0.6367151141,
-0.3564579189,
0.5066870451,
0.5139799118,
0.0671998709,
0.242660597,
-0.674020052,
0.6724807024,
0.4463353157,
-0.0240909569,
-0.1408507228,
0.4040581286,
-0.1429577619,
0.0843044966,
-0.5456327796,
-0.3925200999,
0.8326879144,
-0.0965137333,
0.6069794297,
-0.0691127703,
0.9353944063,
0.1018126234,
0.0697821453,
-0.9857490063,
0.7733434439,
-0.5112200379,
-0.0665068179,
-0.0960974842,
-0.3179843426,
-0.9422779083,
0.0833653435,
-0.4435721934,
-0.8506312966,
0.214171201,
0.2885029018,
-0.4748247266,
-0.1905247718,
-0.4863740504,
0.7234793901,
-0.3125457168,
-0.405857116,
0.0511555523,
-0.642049253,
0.3981128931,
0.3141677678,
-0.0807818994,
-0.1249041259,
-0.2811229527,
0.1662023067,
-0.7564753294,
0.7922441959,
-0.1210379452,
-0.0676347315,
0.4454170763,
0.1092072725,
0.1417952329,
-0.3620015979,
0.3446508646,
0.0364133492,
-0.1716299951,
-0.4307795465,
-0.7271368504,
0.4769581854,
-0.2760156691,
-0.5610988736,
0.0816401765,
-0.2435445935,
-0.1661401391,
0.3046041429,
0.4003826678,
0.784947753,
-0.0422740914,
0.0066772634,
0.5146202445,
-0.3833756745,
0.3080683947,
0.4363809228,
-0.7463006377,
-0.5863722563,
1.0843729973,
-0.0047634798,
0.5442100763,
0.3293988407,
0.178332299,
-0.0131804626,
-0.5836073756,
-0.4733968973,
0.0281182453,
-0.8983561397,
-0.2789130509,
-0.2729769051,
-0.2302831262,
-0.1879956722,
-0.6108514667,
-0.1267016381,
-0.6098963022,
-0.0923693404,
0.0695255473,
0.4614946544,
0.7148464322,
0.0833743885,
0.566640377,
-0.5358371735,
0.5979133844,
0.5237523317,
0.3487393558,
-0.2407021523,
-0.2659020126,
-0.1638271809,
-0.2887553275,
-0.2190067023,
-0.641715467,
0.4637171924,
0.4397470355,
0.4575420916,
0.3981503844,
-0.1368180662,
0.7661313415,
-0.6126106977,
1.0843002796,
0.6297983527,
-0.7868546247,
0.8041880131,
-0.4163247645,
0.4507325888,
0.4457574189,
0.0984829515,
-0.3264601827,
-0.7257633209,
-0.7006114721,
-1.2878324986,
0.3773576915,
0.2837019265,
0.2235810757,
-0.3788383603,
0.3244777322,
-0.0494857095,
0.3612501025,
-0.4977740645,
-0.2197166979,
-0.4388825297,
-0.1711679101,
0.1418712437,
-0.3467161655,
-0.0472096913,
0.0509292707,
0.4109610319,
-0.3903106153,
0.1893963963,
0.4519767761,
0.0561263748,
0.0663882792,
0.3176646233,
0.7207676768,
0.5029201508,
0.0355706252,
0.4461267591,
-0.053095676,
-0.1024794206,
-0.2297729105,
-0.1247778758,
-0.6700617075,
0.195491761,
0.270152241,
1.0249884129,
0.0926688984,
-0.6355084181,
0.694673121,
-0.05546261,
-0.2991332412,
0.022279026,
0.3038336933,
-0.3202955723,
-0.0505771227,
0.1050994918,
-0.0115463883,
0.4790365994,
-0.4495463371,
0.3818712234,
0.43622154,
-0.4802746773,
-0.0590483993,
0.5409436226,
0.1797093749,
0.0953857601,
0.3038988411,
-0.224131003,
-0.5213194489,
0.4542617798,
0.2540578246,
0.8233908415,
0.1620738208,
0.4977860153,
0.4556503296,
-0.0807030201,
-0.0359213576,
0.5283718705,
-0.4701465368,
-0.6038486362,
-0.3598232567,
-0.714753747,
-0.3846918643,
-0.0393327586,
-0.621058166,
0.474381268,
-0.4099526405,
-0.3578236401,
0.3997645974,
-0.4601527154,
-0.6270803809,
0.317232877,
0.7575712204,
0.783146739,
-0.887991786,
0.4082823694,
0.4399025738,
-0.6763308644,
-0.6485420465,
-0.0061255856,
-0.090023011,
-0.5591338873,
0.8975114822,
0.3226427138,
-0.4404180944,
-0.2371263057,
-0.9031543136,
-0.5791530013,
0.8786976933,
0.1950488985,
-0.4087005854,
0.282561034,
0.1546916366,
0.5851944685,
-0.4084641337,
0.11881648,
0.0621588193,
0.4542938769,
0.5156885982,
-1.0058760643,
-0.2583390474,
-0.2704246938,
0.4274933934,
0.1933729202,
-0.3403503597,
0.7431554794,
-0.3347512484,
-0.3157369494,
0.3904522657,
0.8365567923,
0.024192702,
0.354770124,
0.4140111804,
0.4627074897,
0.5635784864,
-0.1668379605,
1.2047542334,
-0.0997633114,
-0.0118908836,
1.3242535591,
-0.2404346764,
0.799023509,
0.5559749007,
0.2335325778,
0.5901193619,
0.1854089499,
-0.1817341745,
0.636274159,
0.0816395059,
-0.3286065757,
-0.4896977246,
-0.6248444915,
-0.0557517931,
0.4711809456,
0.3913534284,
-0.4694487453,
-0.6418206692,
0.1548010558,
-0.4254128635,
0.1377383173,
-0.6703748107,
0.9049729109,
0.050107006,
-0.5792037249,
0.8671068549,
-0.2764516473,
0.5343087316,
-0.4898316264,
-0.2495333403,
0.1111114025,
-0.0918160155,
-0.2125140131,
-1.1617106199,
0.1788383275,
0.0033665218,
-0.2428674251,
-0.0907792747,
0.7767808437,
-0.6113551259,
-0.3840644062,
0.1795559525,
0.3690808117,
0.2789278328,
0.1057477668,
-0.5795758963,
-0.0660350099,
-0.1476154923,
0.1139458641,
0.0495504402,
0.5780103207,
-0.4107252359,
0.5447747111,
0.3363522291,
0.1436508447,
0.253338635,
0.412027061,
0.7460222244,
-0.6088963151,
-0.3841669261,
-0.5207675695,
0.573577106,
-0.2246669829,
-0.1579550803,
0.7061083317,
0.4034323692,
0.8099675179,
-0.347207725,
0.6829261184,
-0.1791023314,
0.0502786227,
-0.7536634803,
0.0554547012,
-0.703456521,
0.0014098757,
-0.1692171991,
-0.5985219479,
-0.4972005785,
0.3700397611,
-0.3876716793,
-0.1125054508,
0.4055349231,
0.8718281388,
-0.0333012007,
-0.4744697809,
0.7144296765,
0.0817257091,
0.1394140273,
0.483461231,
1.0487511158,
-0.3947436213,
0.5783205628,
-0.374609977,
-0.0769703016,
-0.3159324229,
-0.9203776717,
-0.6837803125,
-0.5675449371,
-0.6752094626,
-0.235513851,
-0.0076206527,
0.3358490169,
0.8368392587,
-0.5093550086,
0.050722003,
-0.3252093196,
-0.2013658285,
-0.0995929986,
-0.2433146387,
0.0675129294,
-0.6757291555,
-0.501807332,
0.2891848087,
0.6080860496,
0.4149544537,
-0.0917924643,
-0.0604682453,
0.4521548748,
0.3350490034,
0.7161663771,
0.3793204427,
-0.8808628917,
-0.2980245948,
-0.2316732258,
-0.197319001,
0.1272497922,
0.5803370476,
-0.9146731496,
0.6883977652,
0.5045787692,
0.0712334141,
0.3765280843,
0.088280417,
0.4113554657,
-0.7517239451,
0.2607442141,
-0.1375371218,
0.3854174018,
0.4440315962,
-0.2241903991,
0.3592118025,
0.0865804777,
-0.120702371,
-0.5525436401,
0.6007343531,
-1.3560479879,
-0.3010171354,
1.0634715557,
0.0195604004,
-0.6381545663,
0.2404461503,
-0.5278636217,
-0.2079988122,
-0.1669332832,
0.6305735707,
0.3471256793,
0.0265169106,
-0.1470634788,
-0.5826469064,
0.6217672229,
0.3911105394,
-0.766196847,
0.1701222211,
0.9167383909,
0.194845885,
0.3041546345,
0.4016187489,
-0.084180668,
0.6694792509,
0.0687969998,
0.2190383971,
-0.2793021798,
-0.7064685225,
-0.2519024909,
0.112903662,
0.2222847342,
-0.2009203732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03030v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03030v3 | Benchmarking Large Language Models on CMExam -- A Comprehensive Chinese Medical Exam Dataset | 2023-06-05T16:48:41 | 2023-10-23T02:55:08 | Junling Liu, Peilin Zhou, Yining Hua, Dading Chong, Zhongyu Tian, Andrew Liu, Helin Wang, Chenyu You, Zhenhua Guo, Lei Zhu, Michael Lingzhi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have transformed the
field of question answering (QA). However, evaluating LLMs in the medical field
is challenging due to the lack of standardized and comprehensive datasets. To
address this gap, we introduce CMExam, sourced from the Chinese National
Medical Licensing Examination. CMExam consists of 60K+ multiple-choice
questions for standardized and objective evaluations, as well as solution
explanations for model reasoning evaluation in an open-ended manner. For
in-depth analyses of LLMs, we invited medical professionals to label five
additional question-wise annotations, including disease groups, clinical
departments, medical disciplines, areas of competency, and question difficulty
levels. Alongside the dataset, we further conducted thorough experiments with
representative LLMs and QA algorithms on CMExam. The results show that GPT-4
had the best accuracy of 61.6% and a weighted F1 score of 0.617. These results
highlight a great disparity when compared to human accuracy, which stood at
71.6%. For explanation tasks, while LLMs could generate relevant reasoning and
demonstrate improved performance after finetuning, they fall short of a desired
standard, indicating ample room for improvement. To the best of our knowledge,
CMExam is the first Chinese medical exam dataset to provide comprehensive
medical annotations. The experiments and findings of LLM evaluation also
provide valuable insights into the challenges and potential solutions in
developing Chinese medical QA systems and LLM evaluation pipelines. The dataset
and relevant code are available at https://github.com/williamliujl/CMExam. | [
-0.1265416145,
-0.5471595526,
0.913354218,
0.0867616832,
-0.2811632156,
-0.1245118231,
-0.4369107485,
-0.4157812297,
-0.1645949334,
0.5173311234,
-0.3680174053,
-0.7204832435,
-0.4943072796,
0.1189180762,
-0.168224588,
0.7867001295,
-0.097776562,
0.6015315652,
-0.3748103678,
-0.4818004966,
-0.2731154859,
-0.7021827698,
-0.8828853965,
-0.290854305,
0.547942996,
0.0078837937,
0.7271545529,
0.7554030418,
0.6095629334,
0.2174639404,
-0.1472551227,
0.2063490152,
-0.2427897155,
-0.1896667629,
-0.0590901598,
-0.4473344088,
-0.4915005863,
0.0134235704,
0.6659445763,
0.9053866863,
-0.1938141435,
0.2645233572,
-0.118727766,
0.3775726855,
-0.3595956564,
-0.0275497437,
-0.4621171653,
0.0956534892,
-0.1105059832,
-0.2855949402,
-0.2435346395,
-0.4931325614,
0.1527121365,
-0.5144760013,
-0.1744098067,
-0.0238983948,
0.7544433475,
0.1898183972,
-0.5919986963,
-0.1368386,
-0.3988838494,
0.7166776657,
-1.0032513142,
0.1156698763,
-0.0051779607,
0.6039350033,
-0.0212840978,
-0.726190865,
-0.3761102557,
-0.3817660809,
0.1673480719,
0.3010824919,
0.2606697381,
0.1349973828,
0.3501639366,
0.5965342522,
-0.7615029216,
0.2429042161,
-0.2367867827,
-0.1616332531,
0.6686714292,
0.565561235,
0.6131997705,
0.204782784,
-0.4767548144,
-0.0908022746,
-0.9055601358,
-0.1151964217,
-0.0796416998,
0.1336139888,
-0.0280907732,
0.3876533806,
-0.0766415372,
0.6041187048,
-0.4952375591,
-0.069434762,
0.3785453439,
-0.4008227885,
-0.351521045,
-0.1805900633,
0.9225136042,
0.5067674518,
0.0936398283,
0.0127652567,
-0.3358849287,
-0.0692574531,
-0.0340353698,
-0.8867229819,
-0.1556057781,
0.5872863531,
-0.5761811733,
0.020256618,
0.106504634,
-0.6518508792,
-0.5820780993,
-0.4147386849,
0.4379467368,
-0.0863818303,
-0.2796286643,
0.2750978768,
0.0592517518,
0.6225270033,
0.3122027516,
-0.4720569253,
0.4149214029,
0.8849475384,
0.6439979672,
-0.4408766031,
-0.1591841131,
-0.4834658206,
-0.2888109088,
-0.5932475328,
0.6578708291,
-0.5440218449,
-0.1793760061,
-0.0563950427,
0.09022291,
-0.1799322367,
-1.0196452141,
0.6689763665,
-0.3551784158,
0.3226663768,
-0.3706616163,
-0.6611924171,
-0.0546202324,
0.596042037,
-0.5121201277,
0.7807139754,
0.0666840971,
-0.3921088278,
0.1470981538,
-0.5718345046,
-0.1918109059,
0.0325187482,
-0.422182411,
-0.2327936143,
-0.0082181143,
0.2770782113,
0.4143431783,
-0.7151038051,
0.3428275287,
-0.20887582,
-0.5660454035,
0.4403382242,
-0.4142919779,
0.965498805,
0.1689226329,
-0.2248774618,
0.1915157735,
-0.7620514035,
0.3417699635,
0.2213920802,
-0.2873470187,
-0.1648731083,
-0.135848105,
0.0193660129,
0.5607469082,
0.125083372,
-0.5255166292,
-0.0095191263,
-0.3801044524,
0.2944034636,
0.6372680068,
-0.0065090377,
-0.2502612174,
-0.340421617,
0.6840884089,
0.150104031,
0.3391904235,
-0.3503625095,
-0.5116367936,
-0.5112626553,
-0.0112344567,
0.3597867787,
0.539414227,
-0.5432291627,
0.1554319561,
-0.1149930134,
-0.5697790384,
-0.684809804,
0.0055154487,
0.6066547632,
0.4312665164,
0.3876907229,
-0.0993787795,
-0.1936956197,
-0.8607603312,
-0.2646541595,
-0.0757972822,
-0.2780180573,
0.4293994904,
0.421397239,
-0.1417624354,
0.2597565949,
-0.5482957363,
-0.1344571412,
-0.1147914007,
-0.0982303396,
0.3846502602,
0.3341382444,
0.4136086404,
-0.6363185048,
-0.3737466633,
0.1719176471,
-0.6555236578,
-0.3707187176,
-0.3591922224,
-0.2124713063,
0.1003059074,
0.3348076642,
-0.2864341438,
-0.1074840203,
0.7615183592,
-0.3281170428,
0.8367424011,
-0.1948324442,
0.3409355581,
-1.0444654226,
0.3175388277,
-0.0449121632,
-0.1496628225,
-0.4819157124,
0.3451339006,
0.2422115356,
-0.0334402211,
-0.4662492871,
0.6789444685,
-0.487808913,
-0.0109878769,
-0.3680981398,
0.5018451214,
0.0200257152,
0.484259367,
-0.0769424886,
0.6097276211,
0.5410334468,
-0.3583055139,
0.3783595562,
0.0775128454,
-0.3526844382,
0.4258528352,
-0.8017781377,
0.207075417,
0.2057677656,
0.0135186976,
-0.9925236106,
0.0367625095,
0.1097401083,
-0.4137994051,
0.1373219639,
0.1277016252,
-0.6526437998,
-0.2772674263,
-0.2957338691,
0.3516140282,
0.5540799499,
-0.5776554346,
0.2398416102,
0.369117707,
-0.0243331995,
-0.4631731212,
-0.3846984804,
0.1720714122,
0.0104526961,
-0.4276700318,
0.1305029392,
-0.2936968803,
-0.239889279,
-0.2787954807,
-0.1882212758,
-0.2761109173,
0.1633248031,
0.0278023612,
0.5791748762,
-0.4841624796,
0.1409129649,
-0.0338015407,
-0.1562296301,
0.5498445034,
-0.072539784,
0.3440272808,
0.0331987701,
-0.5049982071,
-0.3075743914,
0.0741916969,
0.5523152947,
-0.3044811189,
0.4622873068,
0.2401165366,
-0.5628511906,
-0.0007535192,
-0.4562431276,
-0.136139065,
-0.4000273943,
0.5079008937,
-0.2928293049,
-0.7805398107,
0.4647293389,
0.0399559736,
0.3954645693,
0.5289564729,
0.6136587858,
0.2786319852,
1.2269062996,
0.128129065,
-0.1082289666,
-0.190705657,
0.1955886036,
-0.1582927257,
-0.7502014041,
-0.0482180007,
-0.4288197756,
-0.0971363485,
-0.4826574624,
-0.6042369604,
0.4164590538,
-0.3335848451,
-0.104432635,
-0.0591271259,
-0.4266855121,
0.4995129108,
0.2128098011,
0.148959592,
0.4422899485,
-0.5257306099,
-0.2741049826,
0.0860409066,
-0.5950444937,
-0.5538066626,
1.3380194902,
0.4313509762,
0.4931087792,
-0.2609216869,
0.2583104968,
-0.2177447379,
0.560685575,
-0.5875033736,
0.6479457617,
-0.2877623141,
-0.683077395,
-0.1717242897,
-0.6569458842,
-0.7453501225,
0.4930676818,
-0.1477521211,
-0.3072634339,
-0.3529456258,
-0.0195032377,
-0.4649062157,
0.3207930624,
-0.4883104563,
1.0095410347,
-0.5041542649,
-0.2333510071,
0.011880585,
-0.6969234943,
0.6323595047,
-0.3230648339,
0.0349107198,
-0.2348907888,
-0.2228313684,
0.7549478412,
-0.3590508401,
0.4480383098,
-0.1849956512,
-0.216750741,
0.1790913492,
-0.2308716625,
0.1827791482,
0.0655669123,
-0.230346173,
0.2520608604,
0.5795949697,
-0.4613452554,
-0.6191603541,
0.6537641883,
-0.5907214284,
-0.5997495651,
-0.4091497958,
-0.4875173867,
-0.3596146405,
0.2448973805,
-0.0439990051,
0.5879588723,
-0.208540827,
-0.0110878283,
0.7061011195,
-0.8597414494,
0.0415214933,
0.6034051776,
-0.3514339924,
-0.3824254274,
0.8015676737,
0.1983270496,
0.3265760541,
0.4258690774,
0.295570612,
-0.2769318521,
-0.7968683243,
-0.566249907,
0.4638727903,
-0.7188782692,
0.0422409847,
-0.5920086503,
-0.4193551838,
-0.1757963449,
0.2674019635,
-0.3696023226,
-0.1206419021,
0.081159614,
0.0375848562,
-0.1856328994,
0.5875869989,
0.4212454855,
-0.0202518683,
-0.9252662063,
0.2879044712,
0.1188813299,
0.5243726373,
-0.0584651046,
-0.4934375882,
-0.322727114,
-0.0705735087,
-0.2030808181,
-0.7406923771,
0.1111503839,
-0.0693501905,
0.7382368445,
0.6568766832,
-0.00424066,
0.6588879228,
-0.3769343793,
0.8713621497,
-0.0847955346,
-0.7480657101,
0.2642008364,
-0.2898161709,
0.532592535,
0.5289869308,
0.2699099183,
-0.8562006354,
-0.3972916901,
-0.2629554868,
-0.7617986202,
0.4227515459,
-0.002224151,
0.1011732072,
-0.0557821169,
0.4790097475,
0.2629894912,
0.0436239392,
-0.5882883072,
-0.3976822793,
0.4016739726,
-0.2571294308,
-0.0681292787,
-0.2394216359,
-0.1340155602,
-0.1688399017,
0.57010144,
-0.1898762584,
0.2174835652,
0.163611725,
-0.0133516155,
0.077290304,
0.2798389792,
0.7305625081,
1.0965982676,
-0.1056720912,
0.0595784523,
0.4196366072,
-0.5502509475,
0.0334276706,
0.2538211346,
0.1523292512,
0.0450351462,
0.3903774321,
0.2840732336,
-0.0005598426,
-1.3357412815,
0.683216691,
-0.1608529836,
-0.3634803891,
-0.3748921752,
0.0377900004,
0.1938655227,
0.0822532475,
0.2922038436,
-0.4358190894,
0.2325962931,
-0.3573187888,
0.19726035,
0.3588733673,
-0.4993710816,
-0.3059461415,
0.8533313274,
0.0500777438,
0.1940914094,
0.5609841347,
0.1208305135,
-0.4370794594,
0.8682658076,
0.3353506327,
0.7030079961,
-0.2979588509,
-0.0071567092,
0.497856319,
0.3998607993,
-0.1501511186,
0.5192404985,
0.251493305,
-0.4975841045,
-0.5396206975,
-0.2947431803,
-0.9003093243,
0.3713031709,
-0.5871545076,
0.3069590628,
-0.5670440197,
0.237374112,
-0.1515316218,
0.2399935871,
-0.3582996726,
0.5465172529,
0.4768408537,
1.2284508944,
-0.6309438348,
0.7685388327,
0.8012753725,
-0.0493374467,
-0.7922798991,
-0.070944719,
0.0257336926,
-0.913092792,
0.0973655507,
0.5254276395,
0.3041887581,
-0.3301771581,
-0.3846553266,
-0.556150794,
1.1879050732,
0.2819170058,
-0.7445566654,
0.356747359,
0.3520614505,
0.7978270054,
-0.4645496905,
0.5952044725,
0.7053352594,
0.4274609089,
-0.130469501,
-0.8342317343,
0.3846912682,
-0.4728198946,
-0.1313390285,
0.1039801911,
-0.770786345,
0.6720327735,
-0.2936417162,
-0.2112809569,
0.2580857575,
0.2937326729,
0.6671883464,
0.5918180943,
0.4508578479,
0.3521903753,
0.8215384483,
-0.1899264008,
0.9938322306,
-0.3884944022,
0.1028902978,
1.1481184959,
-0.5377566218,
0.7919174433,
0.3501614034,
-0.3223635852,
0.086725004,
0.9395623207,
-0.1258219928,
-0.0109486263,
0.5406913757,
-0.1588875949,
-0.3501439691,
0.0118884873,
-0.5685213804,
0.224554196,
0.1698350906,
-0.5673137903,
-0.0280697979,
-0.0696887895,
0.1376287937,
0.0128623303,
-0.3854856789,
0.5816031098,
0.151795283,
-0.6366727352,
0.4897070229,
-0.1059327945,
0.4171369672,
-0.627684772,
-0.0762126818,
-0.4082450867,
0.1364803165,
-0.1100702733,
-0.755998075,
0.1209822148,
-0.1054357141,
0.2469650209,
0.0424742959,
0.427711457,
-0.5524359941,
-0.4245528281,
0.2580467761,
0.5211239457,
0.5264414549,
-0.3479857743,
-0.7914606929,
-0.0432127491,
-0.1595805436,
-0.3483981788,
0.3314335644,
0.4185193777,
0.0013813681,
0.6212746501,
0.4754023254,
0.2479030788,
-0.0165290199,
0.2442176342,
0.8702002764,
-0.8289923668,
-0.2774986327,
-0.9753385782,
0.3026657104,
-0.053133361,
-0.5166735053,
0.5882149339,
0.8186255693,
0.7819641232,
0.0724552944,
0.7111056447,
0.3790842593,
0.6066595316,
-0.5295299888,
0.8774687052,
-0.7759729028,
0.3903392255,
-0.1559928507,
-0.790818274,
-0.6022108197,
-0.0407365113,
-0.2447256297,
0.2337713838,
0.7934166193,
0.7798141241,
0.2094015777,
-0.073372297,
0.7417894006,
0.2970456183,
0.2923327982,
1.0534216166,
0.8832148314,
-0.5445610881,
0.7610421181,
-0.1590656191,
-0.2830029428,
-0.0402943864,
-0.566069901,
-0.9908505082,
-0.3148153126,
-0.4596505463,
-0.216761604,
0.0410125405,
1.1073994637,
0.4778728187,
-0.9661493897,
-0.2264111191,
0.4654129446,
0.0000621279,
-0.5756878853,
-0.1903720647,
0.5841254592,
-0.2494285405,
-0.7812737226,
0.1697120219,
0.3517891467,
-0.1396157742,
-0.2815522552,
-0.0716840178,
0.1291389763,
0.1298740208,
0.5990732908,
0.0826518312,
-0.6163015366,
-0.0987014472,
0.2283447683,
-0.400893569,
0.3187076449,
0.7459142208,
-0.4413994551,
0.5006594062,
0.3665317893,
0.9083704352,
-0.0606337562,
-0.0646366775,
0.592451334,
-0.1742204279,
-0.4571773112,
0.1332991272,
0.4187703729,
0.2228617817,
-0.2743884325,
0.5688044429,
0.0725096613,
-0.7020907402,
-0.8841267824,
-0.3457953632,
-1.1039772034,
-0.4150549173,
1.136808157,
-0.358201474,
-0.1992453188,
-0.0960186645,
-0.4154576063,
0.189408198,
0.0981907919,
0.7896043658,
0.7595002055,
-0.0683411583,
-0.3926952779,
-0.9091793299,
0.2418002188,
0.7634723186,
-1.2963066101,
0.1879340559,
0.3919757009,
0.3480943739,
-0.3530377746,
0.7161483765,
-0.5648254156,
0.6666606665,
-0.2045715749,
0.0256024357,
-0.0979323313,
0.004449592,
-0.5958741903,
0.1279121339,
0.1856889278,
-0.3051447272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03024v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03024v1 | PokemonChat: Auditing ChatGPT for Pokémon Universe Knowledge | 2023-06-05T16:44:27 | 2023-06-05T16:44:27 | Laura Cabello, Jiaang Li, Ilias Chalkidis | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recently released ChatGPT model demonstrates unprecedented capabilities
in zero-shot question-answering. In this work, we probe ChatGPT for its
conversational understanding and introduce a conversational framework
(protocol) that can be adopted in future studies. The Pok\'emon universe serves
as an ideal testing ground for auditing ChatGPT's reasoning capabilities due to
its closed world assumption. After bringing ChatGPT's background knowledge (on
the Pok\'emon universe) to light, we test its reasoning process when using
these concepts in battle scenarios. We then evaluate its ability to acquire new
knowledge and include it in its reasoning process. Our ultimate goal is to
assess ChatGPT's ability to generalize, combine features, and to acquire and
reason over newly introduced knowledge from human feedback. We find that
ChatGPT has prior knowledge of the Pokemon universe, which can reason upon in
battle scenarios to a great extent, even when new information is introduced.
The model performs better with collaborative feedback and if there is an
initial phase of information retrieval, but also hallucinates occasionally and
is susceptible to adversarial attacks. | [
-0.3931024075,
-0.9897643328,
0.5845053196,
-0.1282068789,
-0.1344832629,
-0.1340382844,
0.0677184239,
-0.3914577961,
0.2833026052,
0.5728443265,
-0.6199839115,
-0.104591772,
-0.336414963,
-0.1046530679,
-0.3708838522,
1.2356784344,
0.0257571731,
-0.065904513,
-0.1403726488,
0.152423799,
-0.641675055,
-0.8183118105,
-0.8700351119,
-0.3554356098,
0.4406422377,
0.6708281636,
0.6779136658,
0.1781787872,
0.696176827,
0.1831528395,
-0.129479304,
-0.2380867004,
-0.7033036947,
0.153290838,
-0.3734913468,
-0.7223431468,
-0.7276694775,
0.0651783198,
0.0684788302,
0.553848207,
-0.2708995044,
-0.05159159,
-0.0128679713,
0.2311409563,
-0.5045228004,
0.1690623015,
-0.6975262165,
0.4204805195,
0.1134398729,
-0.4648452699,
-0.229323566,
-0.0248165224,
0.7257874012,
-0.7446910143,
0.3865521252,
0.1362836957,
0.8892483711,
-0.1741107851,
-0.222357139,
-0.4319053888,
-0.8471484184,
0.3786446452,
-0.3803429902,
0.4419692457,
0.4635680318,
0.6639643312,
-0.115456827,
-0.6954932213,
-0.6529006958,
-0.4898079932,
0.215519771,
0.696872592,
-0.0792476237,
0.0289334096,
0.1414824128,
0.5719021559,
-0.5846328139,
-0.3875179887,
-0.3683215678,
-0.0259177126,
0.4056331813,
0.0473423712,
0.4420880675,
-0.0966022238,
-0.2672020495,
-0.1468829662,
-0.5507814884,
-0.1469539255,
0.2998299301,
-0.3240577281,
0.0859022141,
0.7963242531,
-0.3726942539,
0.1736797839,
0.0915009007,
0.2869578898,
-0.2818851471,
-0.4496796429,
-0.2577779591,
0.2635174394,
0.4224388599,
0.6755198836,
-0.0453874841,
-0.5593893528,
0.202437833,
0.1432343423,
0.2543628216,
-0.8460398316,
-0.6543740034,
0.337659955,
-0.2631226182,
-0.2587541044,
-0.1467437446,
-0.9341790676,
-0.6547953486,
0.1075690314,
0.646781981,
-0.9208018184,
-0.536780715,
0.3713754117,
-0.5657994747,
0.434920758,
0.6944054961,
-1.1310083866,
0.0222291201,
0.9627977014,
0.7866523266,
0.4737036228,
-0.4957734644,
-0.2400790751,
-0.1062063426,
-0.2996278405,
1.0208024979,
-0.3574766219,
-0.4206106663,
-0.4202342629,
-0.241328299,
-0.2389207035,
-0.2078676373,
0.6316087246,
-0.3491230309,
0.569914937,
-0.227920413,
-0.9723467827,
-0.2618718445,
0.6226657629,
-0.1171362624,
0.2742693424,
-0.1321409792,
-0.9484917521,
0.5141479969,
-1.0769417286,
0.2376001328,
0.5166273713,
0.0356423296,
-0.0745586678,
-0.1973515898,
0.1974836886,
0.3826487064,
0.0641932636,
-0.0463874154,
-0.4978776276,
-0.2497652918,
0.3471210897,
-0.3067923486,
0.7013821602,
0.4589021802,
-0.236489594,
-0.3794859052,
-0.333116442,
0.0301342662,
0.2950334251,
-0.0432273038,
-0.132847473,
0.244964242,
-0.7836708426,
-0.1893187165,
0.1627661139,
-0.7261318564,
0.3758091331,
-0.251078546,
0.5111159682,
0.2502480149,
0.5015645027,
0.3221738935,
-0.4227481186,
0.3561904132,
-0.2855418622,
0.4710302055,
-0.4980429411,
-0.9182435274,
-0.8318475485,
0.0452281758,
0.2511523366,
0.8847700357,
-0.5153965354,
0.5497406125,
-0.2912830114,
-0.7429582477,
-0.1421869993,
-0.3359624445,
0.0814191625,
0.5579688549,
-0.0054753493,
-0.4826210439,
-0.525474906,
-0.4547522068,
-0.1589876115,
-0.6108781099,
-0.289388299,
0.5554015636,
0.5820800066,
-0.1837868243,
0.8483000994,
-0.1939395517,
0.1298710257,
-0.3515729606,
0.1733396798,
0.1617018729,
0.3553403914,
0.2899552286,
-0.7037193775,
-0.207609579,
0.1977157444,
-1.0681186914,
0.152342245,
-0.0669766814,
-0.4852400422,
-0.6945957541,
0.2118519247,
-0.676543951,
0.4309351444,
0.4216632545,
-0.7241095304,
0.4263242483,
-0.1403753161,
0.5990771651,
-0.8360495567,
0.1564629823,
-0.3830205798,
0.0753159374,
-0.8476464152,
0.1263486892,
0.0210070293,
-0.5733504891,
-0.2674954236,
0.368254751,
-0.0189546309,
0.0480856448,
0.097757861,
0.6067487597,
0.0432670899,
0.3139187694,
0.1894565225,
0.4896719456,
0.4360969365,
-0.5691538453,
0.8133499026,
0.612349093,
-0.2231301069,
0.9310280681,
-0.588273406,
0.2892063558,
-0.0538991392,
0.2134641409,
-0.9324144125,
-0.3504145145,
0.2557958066,
-0.9609510303,
-0.0606722683,
-0.6538015008,
-0.4123959839,
-0.169694975,
0.0487834066,
-0.0604227297,
0.6236163974,
-0.5719723701,
0.2216121256,
0.2851930559,
-0.0216099247,
-0.2284036577,
-0.3599351346,
0.2902534306,
-0.364313513,
-0.9771525264,
-0.3308010995,
-0.1033923402,
-0.2615314126,
-0.1192717999,
-0.0467393547,
-0.2714454532,
0.3194079697,
0.1447067857,
0.248373881,
-0.4243070185,
-0.1045101956,
-0.5314733386,
0.0454234555,
-0.0059363437,
-0.3509064317,
0.6959763169,
-0.2520745099,
-0.6083147526,
-0.2115045935,
0.0355096869,
0.3973004818,
-0.0712906942,
0.5720522404,
0.2023480982,
-0.2209412754,
0.2491869479,
-0.5719045997,
-0.2904633284,
-0.396211952,
0.4883956611,
-0.327064544,
-0.765098393,
0.7601290345,
-0.1172624528,
0.269928962,
0.3579138219,
0.4387712181,
-0.1830441356,
1.0704088211,
0.2823941112,
0.1402852088,
0.404068023,
-0.1836715341,
0.6193912625,
-0.7652936578,
-0.4415760636,
-0.4042591453,
0.1507181674,
-0.323066473,
-0.1115802974,
0.1790827513,
0.7048152685,
-0.2859157324,
0.4216021001,
-0.2488704771,
0.7718473673,
0.4388958514,
0.1457886845,
0.3381774127,
-0.3203931153,
-0.0281148441,
0.1267558038,
-0.7705962658,
-0.3586247265,
1.1156680584,
0.5365082622,
0.6075718999,
0.2365564704,
0.8536049724,
-0.0926790014,
0.1793950349,
-0.5771676302,
0.4159710705,
0.2554843724,
-0.7908243537,
-0.3172311485,
-0.4696648121,
-0.9830979109,
0.313295424,
-0.057575196,
-1.1735322475,
-0.2348114401,
0.2793721855,
-0.4505969584,
0.6035614014,
-1.3209427595,
1.1024633646,
-0.1921623945,
-0.1381406039,
-0.0064535681,
-0.2313410789,
0.6199836135,
0.1615454704,
-0.209441334,
-0.0846216306,
0.2321740836,
0.6532994509,
-0.3795788586,
0.6235897541,
-0.0551839955,
0.0530541092,
0.4719541669,
0.4175626934,
0.3167959452,
0.379968822,
0.3851307631,
0.1278071553,
0.2830881178,
-0.4039972723,
-0.6966462135,
0.3978218436,
-0.7364342809,
-0.3794393837,
-0.2021472007,
-0.1386045963,
-0.4491247535,
0.0796395838,
0.4849039614,
0.2644650936,
-0.4295856059,
0.3313514888,
0.8888915181,
-0.3218626082,
-0.1021289006,
0.628731966,
-0.4065211117,
-0.1493940353,
0.8539005518,
-0.285644114,
0.2590340674,
0.4702436924,
0.356665343,
-0.3216019869,
-0.3845737875,
-0.4367159903,
-0.0700445175,
-0.5636751652,
0.1118143722,
-0.5607870817,
-0.3653326631,
-0.4050973356,
-0.0474644117,
-0.4119570851,
-0.5061790347,
0.3910622001,
0.1052892879,
0.2403136194,
0.6868015528,
0.012912821,
0.3304044604,
-0.8155233264,
0.0135340169,
0.7286864519,
0.4505745769,
-0.235013783,
-0.5833527446,
0.0265055168,
0.2607871592,
-0.3895466626,
-1.0633523464,
0.1615360528,
-0.0078807808,
0.6458779573,
0.5139745474,
-0.2557447255,
0.6047285795,
-0.4790692627,
1.0890579224,
0.2492132038,
-0.7668673396,
0.7635720372,
-0.7037183642,
0.1506887078,
0.2274035811,
0.1333921105,
-1.1902375221,
-0.5261603594,
-1.1848599911,
-0.2726596594,
0.528657496,
0.5324378014,
0.0624196045,
0.0430105403,
0.4439115226,
-0.1572336257,
0.1300087422,
-0.3295094669,
0.0878426954,
-0.5933841467,
0.2855061591,
0.0702670515,
-0.2085690051,
-0.0698763356,
-0.0314629748,
0.4892711341,
0.1723988205,
0.6122488976,
0.3537827432,
-0.0469342358,
0.0365666114,
0.3691280782,
0.3848726451,
0.7942542434,
-0.5095151067,
0.0575348474,
0.3868636191,
-0.6872504354,
-0.2315977514,
-0.0938370377,
-0.0663598254,
-0.1804401278,
0.4873937666,
0.6834743619,
0.3024565876,
-0.6493382454,
0.6801329851,
-0.5343068838,
-0.528611362,
-0.1776749045,
0.3773089349,
0.061849378,
0.3858656585,
0.057253994,
0.048240032,
0.0886038095,
-0.6095039845,
0.3944965601,
0.2795841396,
-0.1175503656,
-0.4205334485,
0.6726472378,
0.2114715725,
-0.1948668063,
0.6178328395,
-0.3877804279,
-0.7908799052,
0.5903732181,
0.280444324,
0.8037917614,
-0.2145504504,
0.1784752905,
0.4288242757,
0.1984687895,
0.0010024636,
-0.040197216,
-0.1924589276,
-1.0093873739,
-0.2328472137,
-0.1628121585,
-1.0254167318,
0.475726068,
-0.378172338,
0.1675830036,
-0.5996840596,
0.2399803698,
0.1397582889,
0.2508721054,
-0.6233822107,
-0.0488489047,
0.1824130416,
0.8622593284,
-0.6096850634,
0.3659098744,
0.4932969511,
-0.558611691,
-0.677351892,
-0.0945269838,
0.0018692003,
-1.0858951807,
0.5920863152,
-0.0521572903,
0.3977893293,
-0.1980280131,
-0.7707051635,
-0.6318411231,
1.0638349056,
0.1459814757,
-0.3712447882,
0.1694966555,
-0.0572064184,
0.6083106399,
0.0037654503,
0.6707370877,
0.5805897713,
0.1761193126,
0.3761223257,
-1.1184335947,
-0.5989814401,
-0.3585437536,
-0.42659536,
0.1463316977,
-0.5550015569,
0.7234259844,
-0.1471147239,
-0.2970046401,
0.0400610343,
0.3830983639,
0.1551709026,
0.3533250391,
0.4161382616,
0.6574315429,
0.782269001,
-0.0834613889,
0.9943115711,
-0.155448854,
0.5791376233,
0.9302297831,
-0.331820339,
0.7276548743,
0.1441961378,
-0.2482269406,
0.0838229507,
0.6437774301,
-0.0823635533,
0.4126509428,
-0.0015802208,
-0.3281216919,
-0.1594029218,
0.0560040995,
-0.3449225128,
0.4562261105,
0.2224004865,
0.1545054168,
-0.5863320231,
-0.2834008038,
0.2753690779,
-0.5569262505,
-0.2496920675,
0.9399048686,
-0.3202184737,
-0.8381035328,
0.218552798,
-0.2994354963,
0.4982863367,
-0.6620520353,
-0.14493604,
-0.6565377712,
0.2819111645,
-0.0750153363,
-0.8471009135,
0.0056278245,
0.0959347412,
0.2636289895,
-0.0407030955,
0.7367919087,
-0.4068975449,
0.1299404949,
-0.2133356184,
0.5264608264,
0.6144775748,
-0.241987288,
-0.6552280188,
-0.4214473665,
0.0423479863,
-0.0024482061,
0.4145370126,
0.9357290864,
0.3262666762,
0.7399363518,
0.5129058361,
0.1510698944,
0.2493196577,
-0.1119915321,
0.4916585088,
-0.3075243533,
-0.814353466,
-0.6822391748,
0.1805950254,
-0.4352244735,
-0.3990724683,
1.0642805099,
0.6133670211,
0.8068939447,
0.1719843,
0.8738175035,
-0.2048724443,
0.682993114,
-0.3601949215,
0.7855349779,
-0.1255907118,
0.0709721297,
-0.1971320212,
-0.6572131515,
0.0380949825,
0.9007211328,
-0.4488383234,
-0.2547253072,
0.7538862824,
0.5657550693,
-0.2711473703,
0.797639966,
0.5338542461,
-0.0683953539,
0.5968745351,
0.8594202995,
1.4054191113,
-0.5154184699,
0.7935161591,
-0.4581106603,
-0.443084985,
-0.2013611048,
-0.8634525537,
-1.1738500595,
-0.5575022101,
-0.3258874714,
-0.4233083725,
0.0613275655,
0.4089727104,
0.7245925069,
-0.7096504569,
0.0015409839,
-0.3434135616,
-0.1296701133,
0.1408930421,
-0.2761674225,
0.0806311294,
-0.4664579332,
-0.3610764742,
0.2473745346,
0.2970744073,
0.1375389397,
0.0671361908,
-0.2321160436,
0.0881914347,
-0.0411849879,
0.4145455062,
0.5500156283,
-0.2454472929,
-0.5514984727,
0.1206738725,
0.246724993,
0.0055303611,
1.0724269152,
-0.1918045133,
0.627446115,
0.5360044837,
0.7212024927,
0.5961647034,
-0.2290257215,
0.5895079374,
-0.5209728479,
0.0516233668,
0.4182149172,
0.5504515171,
0.0518968627,
-0.3250141144,
0.6674815416,
0.4391410053,
-0.8566696048,
-0.6068478227,
0.010216061,
-0.6618794799,
-0.0759965032,
0.8378998041,
-0.3642603457,
-0.1597182453,
-0.3134300113,
-0.4691543579,
0.0756286159,
-0.2712284029,
0.886331141,
1.0089546442,
-0.3960361779,
-0.3613729477,
-0.8732062578,
0.4002177715,
0.3344130218,
-1.0218441486,
0.1854976118,
0.2740366459,
0.3578154147,
0.3903565705,
0.830540061,
-0.1158896759,
0.4652118981,
0.5790599585,
-0.0822995082,
0.1828548759,
0.0335871503,
-0.1058133096,
-0.1563407183,
-0.0502261296,
-0.2851118445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02982v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02982v2 | PolyVoice: Language Models for Speech to Speech Translation | 2023-06-05T15:53:15 | 2023-06-13T15:15:17 | Qianqian Dong, Zhiying Huang, Qiao Tian, Chen Xu, Tom Ko, Yunlong Zhao, Siyuan Feng, Tang Li, Kexin Wang, Xuxin Cheng, Fengpeng Yue, Ye Bai, Xi Chen, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma, Yuping Wang, Mingxuan Wang, Yuxuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | We propose PolyVoice, a language model-based framework for speech-to-speech
translation (S2ST) system. Our framework consists of two language models: a
translation language model and a speech synthesis language model. We use
discretized speech units, which are generated in a fully unsupervised way, and
thus our framework can be used for unwritten languages. For the speech
synthesis part, we adopt the existing VALL-E X approach and build a unit-based
audio language model. This grants our framework the ability to preserve the
voice characteristics and the speaking style of the original speech. We examine
our system on Chinese $\rightarrow$ English and English $\rightarrow$ Spanish
pairs. Experimental results show that our system can generate speech with high
translation quality and audio quality. Speech samples are available at
https://speechtranslation.github.io/polyvoice. | [
0.1198452935,
-0.4030511677,
0.2859354019,
0.4669667482,
-0.5540117025,
0.0350056626,
-0.2120690346,
-0.21065256,
0.1615770012,
0.8498164415,
-0.2172599584,
-0.334294498,
-0.2398013771,
-0.1280347407,
-0.7719776034,
0.9866253138,
0.1659508198,
0.4987868965,
-0.4429621994,
0.1484432518,
-0.2150193453,
-0.611338377,
-0.648940146,
-0.7170397639,
0.0139309457,
0.3313384652,
0.5235724449,
0.5063122511,
0.0848169774,
0.2107110173,
-0.2539332211,
-0.2670333087,
-0.2263626307,
0.3253256977,
-0.3140725493,
-0.5097914934,
-0.5741747618,
-0.2439622581,
0.8219924569,
0.6283512115,
-0.4436064363,
0.1257713884,
-0.0410459973,
0.629966259,
-0.1494516134,
0.2908434868,
-0.5381899476,
0.0013616226,
-0.2782120407,
0.086904496,
-0.504204154,
-0.5070362091,
-0.0725585744,
-0.3147230148,
-0.0412462503,
-0.3726398051,
0.6150732636,
0.2676578462,
-0.5316970348,
-0.0980188325,
-1.0678107738,
0.5420601964,
-0.764883101,
0.3741912842,
0.2676257491,
0.6155603528,
-0.1287024021,
-1.2594980001,
-0.3837914765,
-0.2161782235,
0.2134885341,
0.4612821043,
-0.3911570907,
0.0627060831,
0.0583857372,
0.3554192185,
-0.6565738916,
0.0906493291,
-0.403663069,
-0.1093431562,
0.8387313485,
-0.2183892429,
0.3939667642,
-0.2015775144,
-0.3614433408,
0.0476536714,
-0.6478161812,
0.218283698,
0.3349205256,
0.467512548,
-0.1131357923,
0.7614332438,
-0.0302562732,
0.5514027476,
-0.1727513671,
-0.1788000315,
0.1495814621,
-0.3886311054,
-0.4303955734,
0.4745056033,
0.7753999233,
0.0970666036,
0.1645706445,
-0.1646987349,
-0.3664645851,
0.0390577354,
0.1932941526,
-0.7124690413,
0.0738026351,
0.2768653631,
-0.5027301311,
-0.6115179062,
-0.0398003981,
-0.6022692323,
-0.2057106942,
-0.3553382754,
0.4095185399,
-0.3016579151,
-0.827511251,
0.3692679703,
0.030964423,
0.0364687555,
0.1319108605,
-0.7186175585,
0.5819468498,
0.6595048308,
0.8092033267,
-0.288954705,
-0.2167245448,
-0.5911742449,
0.1394513547,
-0.4672642946,
0.9227932096,
-0.1081119776,
-0.6194040179,
0.1444308609,
-0.1394187063,
0.1704085767,
-0.5637044907,
0.6204661727,
-0.0449648611,
0.1912114173,
0.0005358005,
-0.5632238388,
0.0173716098,
-0.3901780546,
-0.5819803476,
1.0793688297,
0.0580898896,
-0.4340396225,
-0.1837196946,
-0.5877156854,
-0.6888154745,
0.239140898,
-0.1665483713,
-0.4348827899,
0.3386785984,
-0.030141715,
0.1803974062,
-0.7492098212,
0.2764965594,
0.2561782002,
-0.1764201522,
0.2092521191,
-0.4279435277,
0.9616318941,
0.4420829117,
-0.3234321773,
0.1898651123,
-0.7173248529,
-0.0388377905,
0.3962082267,
-0.2509398162,
-0.0629400089,
0.299567461,
0.5049799085,
0.2041492909,
0.3576273322,
-0.6518594027,
0.2313302308,
-0.7174283266,
0.5946846008,
0.4350911081,
-0.2355906665,
0.4089981318,
-0.1374723911,
0.7098882794,
-0.0623666458,
0.0438176319,
-0.0092385327,
-0.597810328,
-0.600451529,
-0.0867882892,
0.2680153251,
0.7275898457,
-0.948426187,
0.1625594646,
-0.2685214877,
-0.5939342976,
-0.4960201681,
-0.262060225,
0.3967579007,
0.3745903373,
0.2026361972,
-0.0713246688,
-0.5715044141,
-0.9681384563,
-0.0012065718,
-0.4937302768,
-0.2479229867,
-0.0485768914,
0.1401290148,
-0.0901095793,
0.8200240135,
-0.1470320374,
-0.2182059586,
-0.5656648278,
0.1898358017,
0.2432477623,
0.3977842927,
0.7105492949,
-0.8540303111,
-0.5037001371,
0.3103245199,
-0.5485486984,
-0.5642581582,
-0.0642325431,
0.121904701,
0.3512662351,
0.6911889911,
-0.3331553638,
0.3669160604,
0.8106169105,
-0.1298821568,
0.7621151805,
-0.2221447229,
-0.0387805402,
-1.7235338688,
0.1051257849,
-0.3724165261,
-0.5544145703,
-0.8606271148,
-0.2803364694,
-0.0341158733,
-0.5586714745,
-0.7924740314,
0.2174987942,
-0.2746885419,
-0.636290133,
-0.5305584073,
0.0856753364,
-0.0162641425,
0.0571265109,
0.2654520273,
1.2610440254,
0.7360342145,
-0.2771966159,
0.9691252112,
0.1320057511,
-0.3773651421,
0.679987967,
-0.9236211777,
0.2998664379,
0.0906001478,
0.1586361527,
-0.96417588,
0.0154640824,
-0.1468254179,
-0.6186701655,
0.1084035486,
-0.4930416048,
-0.5120592713,
-0.2296103835,
0.1088298336,
0.3757730126,
0.4933552146,
-0.5213922262,
0.4568191171,
0.5512931347,
-0.7047290802,
-0.0623194426,
-0.7698894739,
0.3258958161,
0.1592965275,
-0.7576985359,
0.5414413214,
0.0100540221,
-0.0754379183,
0.015982233,
0.0962778106,
-0.2231365591,
-0.3712682128,
0.0199279264,
-0.0136440303,
-0.3453520238,
0.1529280543,
0.3148355782,
-0.1952985823,
-0.0140878763,
-0.5803734064,
0.6610078216,
-0.2138630152,
-0.2313215137,
-0.5566105843,
0.831908226,
0.8865368366,
-0.4459235966,
0.1592447013,
0.3040177226,
-0.5171942115,
-0.0267976895,
-0.2974775732,
0.0666615069,
-0.4324509203,
0.5214381218,
-0.7095848918,
-0.5119122863,
0.4086067975,
-0.196137771,
-0.0439593829,
0.2356850058,
0.9257678986,
-0.0106187752,
1.2803417444,
0.4545528591,
0.0905701518,
0.6425304413,
-0.1078482196,
0.0265984684,
-0.5663058162,
-0.2042737007,
-0.5980354548,
0.2920355797,
-0.4158330858,
-0.4356957674,
0.3562912941,
0.0794120654,
0.1253012717,
0.6542813182,
-0.5326579213,
0.2619974911,
0.6643674374,
-0.3074348569,
0.1229394451,
0.301047802,
-0.3010663688,
-0.1706359684,
-0.5916067958,
-0.5245919228,
0.8228666782,
0.2553903162,
0.5670846701,
0.277161181,
0.7102105021,
0.2976042032,
-0.381285131,
-0.9977977872,
0.4537369311,
-0.5281537175,
-0.3596823215,
-0.3556343317,
-0.4062950313,
-1.0084322691,
0.283008039,
-0.1507913917,
-0.7858967781,
0.107736297,
-0.0308925509,
-0.0073613357,
0.3325084746,
-0.6023776531,
0.6517668962,
-0.4236874878,
-0.1457326263,
-0.1804905236,
-0.3397246003,
-0.0108409105,
0.1034408808,
0.0120904576,
0.1208783984,
0.3254458308,
0.7449510694,
-0.4326680005,
0.4315319061,
-0.0405530222,
-0.1824769676,
0.2110477388,
0.3705771267,
0.5455016494,
0.0586382784,
-0.3885787427,
0.2349279672,
0.3618510067,
-0.3539794683,
-0.5934534073,
0.570331037,
-0.7904438972,
-0.3545984626,
-0.4890387058,
-0.472917825,
-0.0163109954,
0.3880888522,
0.4783186913,
0.3891100883,
-0.3545086086,
0.168908149,
0.3268342912,
-0.1729010195,
0.3198831081,
0.5806202888,
-0.5225536823,
-0.7690669298,
0.9620084763,
0.2478176355,
0.4817952812,
0.2907479107,
0.3205012679,
-0.5183407664,
-0.4940233529,
-0.6285865307,
0.3798302412,
-0.3686611354,
0.0567901134,
-0.1788790226,
-0.4832219481,
-1.1056138277,
0.0422539301,
-1.0755083561,
-0.5659641027,
-0.2210491151,
0.040489845,
0.1353344768,
0.9407425523,
-0.2124697119,
0.2719051838,
-0.4405027032,
0.4524795413,
0.4581329525,
0.1600489169,
-0.5809591413,
-0.6566378474,
-0.2844448686,
0.2755028605,
-0.0322165452,
-0.9688925743,
0.474998951,
0.0141222849,
0.4398589432,
0.1981590837,
0.1472055465,
0.3664582074,
-0.6994081736,
1.0294504166,
0.4622654915,
-1.1795502901,
0.9544720054,
-0.1619981229,
0.1951892525,
0.1263321787,
-0.1325017214,
-0.9187428355,
-0.2365932018,
-0.5273259878,
-0.9168272614,
0.9052382708,
0.5726574659,
-0.0822007507,
0.3664264083,
0.2562713325,
-0.0542634875,
0.1988635957,
-0.5921301842,
-0.2754811347,
-0.6378272772,
-0.168959111,
-0.0394508392,
-0.4399393797,
-0.0948136821,
-0.1492726207,
0.7015696764,
0.0964584127,
0.4616544247,
0.0875012651,
0.1019571424,
-0.0692989901,
0.3227705657,
0.9320133924,
0.4148892462,
-0.2139879614,
0.077494204,
-0.115303807,
-0.4777659178,
0.3535138667,
0.2549315691,
-0.3333509564,
0.3202858865,
0.0053587495,
0.9851465225,
-0.0902841911,
-0.314388901,
0.805960238,
-0.1467155516,
-0.2825398445,
-0.7324390411,
-0.3338455558,
0.2568242848,
0.2275525928,
0.1658413857,
-0.2890424728,
0.1404664069,
-0.4258415997,
0.2545624077,
0.0452716723,
-0.5509104729,
-0.3284056485,
0.8733146191,
0.4260072112,
-0.7663468719,
0.2115454078,
-0.0075698029,
-0.2977876961,
0.4704495072,
0.9809809923,
1.0743749142,
-0.4987441301,
0.4617061615,
0.0323966257,
0.1901956499,
-0.2684535384,
0.3365148902,
-0.1026878133,
-0.5232467055,
-0.4227412641,
-0.5745338202,
-0.5784885883,
0.2516331673,
-0.9719391465,
0.4071859717,
-0.0662662536,
-0.118750155,
0.0404114313,
-0.3454138935,
-0.0521027409,
0.0075072879,
0.3734535575,
0.7142642736,
-1.0341844559,
1.3501288891,
1.0159443617,
-0.5220549703,
-0.6732778549,
-0.2036934495,
-0.0265580658,
-0.5052347183,
0.4846509397,
-0.3703497648,
-0.5658049583,
0.3219887018,
-0.1386662722,
-0.8200421929,
0.9633641839,
0.9273338914,
-0.5444236994,
0.1420198977,
0.6015315056,
0.5305390358,
-0.3538675308,
-0.0394343622,
0.5229306817,
0.1556272656,
0.2022360116,
-1.256485939,
-0.3043124378,
-0.3985601664,
0.4197266698,
-0.1537628919,
-0.4220173657,
0.7475334406,
0.1391116381,
-0.2490397841,
0.209501639,
0.6982209682,
0.0789194927,
0.1785439998,
0.4786018133,
0.2688420415,
0.4552748799,
-0.0321031362,
0.890605092,
-0.1651332676,
0.3666039705,
1.1298574209,
-0.3740212619,
0.913954854,
0.5509903431,
-0.3254795074,
0.2224842757,
0.3794798553,
0.3323020637,
0.4468331933,
0.0911528096,
-0.4017780125,
-0.3233033717,
-0.308526516,
-0.5415462255,
0.6482652426,
0.1838313937,
-0.1789513081,
-0.1050963104,
0.2934754789,
0.0287516452,
0.2896231413,
-0.0222303886,
0.9393655062,
0.1411040574,
-0.5048172474,
0.765196085,
0.0922263563,
0.274089694,
-0.6696383357,
0.0509019122,
-0.3461332917,
-0.0223906953,
-0.0936843604,
-0.7666090727,
0.2985514104,
0.0997330621,
-0.2383685559,
-0.4663064778,
0.4718941748,
-0.757927835,
-0.7976626754,
0.4724542797,
0.2960937619,
0.5171661973,
-0.1548511535,
-0.7816912532,
-0.0557650588,
0.2230461985,
-0.1411395222,
0.0974331126,
0.376947552,
-0.0445621014,
0.4868485034,
0.6984491348,
0.7987288833,
-0.0499157272,
0.6045185328,
0.499422133,
-0.2758428156,
-0.7281837463,
-0.4478609562,
0.5551393032,
-0.1618752331,
-0.0941701978,
0.2775589824,
0.8531824946,
0.6887316704,
-0.0975244641,
1.042386055,
0.1845911741,
0.6490424275,
-0.4946585298,
0.7737686634,
-0.762411952,
0.0576889403,
-0.4061656296,
-0.875569284,
-0.2277449369,
0.6154792905,
0.019016156,
-0.4692402482,
0.7075825334,
0.9372751117,
-0.0807273462,
-0.1598577499,
0.8124885559,
0.1047528014,
0.5802938938,
0.3632471263,
0.5355238318,
-0.6238615513,
0.9738402963,
-0.3170716465,
-0.336488843,
-0.3378949761,
-0.6513289809,
-0.3632374406,
-0.9056529999,
-0.3413268328,
-0.4751079679,
0.222070992,
0.8764756918,
0.7362769246,
-0.7378556728,
-0.9301432371,
-0.2403450459,
-0.0153196901,
-0.4443506002,
-0.1742841601,
0.2840449214,
-0.0467473119,
-1.0230127573,
0.7690380812,
0.5025547743,
0.321978271,
-0.2831438482,
-0.1019781679,
-0.0094290897,
0.235583514,
0.7089550495,
0.3266670108,
-0.8099066615,
-0.1938007325,
-0.0882465765,
-0.1754770726,
-0.0195667129,
1.0469509363,
-0.389975965,
0.8110138178,
0.6871039271,
0.3766764402,
0.8592067957,
-0.1804864258,
1.0033710003,
-0.7054127455,
0.6465663314,
0.3326043189,
0.4803599417,
0.3495653272,
-0.0989527181,
0.3547728658,
0.3671844602,
-0.5339229703,
-0.9290819764,
0.6985464692,
-1.1274085045,
-0.179340288,
1.3582727909,
-0.1297791898,
-0.1117477641,
-0.006030723,
-0.4739112258,
0.6157580614,
-0.355912149,
0.4701693058,
0.3988954127,
-0.1567168683,
-0.2183184475,
-0.4869036973,
0.4248387814,
0.4322651029,
-0.6180577278,
0.1732500345,
0.2809921503,
0.1941576004,
0.0613656528,
0.6974791884,
-0.3830213845,
0.5066568255,
0.0953898877,
0.5888150334,
-0.1357902735,
-0.1878591031,
-0.4358240962,
-0.1554027945,
0.1413409263,
-0.4081413448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02980v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02980v1 | KNOW How to Make Up Your Mind! Adversarially Detecting and Alleviating Inconsistencies in Natural Language Explanations | 2023-06-05T15:51:58 | 2023-06-05T15:51:58 | Myeongjun Jang, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Julian McAuley, Thomas Lukasiewicz, Oana-Maria Camburu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While recent works have been considerably improving the quality of the
natural language explanations (NLEs) generated by a model to justify its
predictions, there is very limited research in detecting and alleviating
inconsistencies among generated NLEs. In this work, we leverage external
knowledge bases to significantly improve on an existing adversarial attack for
detecting inconsistent NLEs. We apply our attack to high-performing NLE models
and show that models with higher NLE quality do not necessarily generate fewer
inconsistencies. Moreover, we propose an off-the-shelf mitigation method to
alleviate inconsistencies by grounding the model into external background
knowledge. Our method decreases the inconsistencies of previous high-performing
NLE models as detected by our attack. | [
-0.604736805,
-1.0430355072,
0.6553018689,
-0.1215718985,
0.2640777528,
-0.1848081201,
-0.1985674649,
-0.3524470031,
0.2198637873,
0.7127395272,
-0.7787416577,
-0.101099126,
-0.8379953504,
-0.0684299693,
-0.2727864981,
0.9571899176,
0.1216685995,
-0.1058634371,
-0.03676375,
-0.095371291,
-0.5713028908,
-0.3447835445,
-1.0447171926,
-0.3496097624,
0.3629434705,
0.1414578706,
1.1234111786,
0.5039169192,
0.2698409557,
0.3513422012,
-0.1709903926,
0.4296972454,
-0.3941627741,
0.0892459899,
-0.3452963531,
-0.4514456093,
-0.1579324156,
-0.1604808271,
0.2349317819,
0.553683877,
-0.2461030036,
-0.100189209,
-0.0677151829,
0.8894442916,
-0.7174530625,
-0.186493665,
-0.9491081834,
0.0899177268,
-0.0466605239,
-0.0833019763,
-0.5012556314,
-0.1929381043,
0.22639893,
-0.6985827088,
0.59309268,
-0.0576616824,
0.8924615383,
0.5998126268,
-0.1032200381,
-0.234444499,
-0.6575273275,
0.4226928055,
-0.9233383536,
0.2769574821,
0.2817841172,
0.4290308654,
-0.4196769893,
-0.5534572601,
-0.7489232421,
-0.0662077963,
-0.1521884799,
0.0030915705,
-0.4179522395,
-0.0125212222,
0.4525376558,
0.1229371876,
-0.6727807522,
-0.240051806,
-0.138700217,
-0.4056248069,
0.4549648166,
-0.2622948885,
0.5111226439,
0.0879940987,
-0.3020182252,
-0.1707997173,
-0.9608384967,
0.1502626538,
0.4923568368,
-0.0729133785,
0.1490946859,
0.5274726748,
-0.1530338079,
0.7118020058,
0.2669427097,
0.0806358457,
-0.3690263033,
-0.0798963979,
-0.7462300062,
0.1050063968,
0.4989808798,
0.2470107824,
0.129005447,
-0.5539386272,
0.0057230322,
0.2987088859,
0.4400247931,
-0.2630519867,
-0.5466393232,
0.3253355026,
-0.1688157767,
-0.3317706287,
-0.1466493905,
-0.6659122705,
-0.9350834489,
-0.458129853,
0.6366974115,
-0.3863123953,
-0.2164630145,
0.0722108036,
-0.3569481075,
-0.2635934949,
0.3190231025,
-0.7762898803,
0.325892508,
0.3875549734,
0.4814869761,
0.3197299838,
-0.117403686,
-0.5481479168,
0.1976546794,
-0.5648561716,
0.8796714544,
-0.0158266556,
0.020642899,
-0.2081321478,
-0.0996570364,
0.0402941406,
-0.6190919876,
0.4477375746,
-0.4882462323,
0.5478608012,
-0.4378629625,
-0.4886381924,
-0.605810523,
0.3048410118,
-0.7011595368,
0.8796383142,
-0.0540555157,
-0.9651769996,
0.2284853607,
-0.7112745047,
-0.1775174588,
-0.2019481212,
-0.0518184528,
-0.2607895136,
0.1768160611,
0.7268033028,
0.1761392653,
-0.0377498008,
0.4681605697,
-0.3098624945,
-0.1950731575,
0.3691701293,
-0.558009088,
1.2647997141,
0.0768112689,
-0.4772874117,
0.2909700871,
-0.7722619176,
-0.1079276055,
0.2939861417,
0.1028287932,
-0.353230536,
0.0124624791,
-0.742188096,
0.1295282394,
0.2015878856,
-0.3707500994,
0.0219358932,
-0.7341181636,
0.2932585478,
0.7668448687,
0.2396878451,
0.4806570113,
-0.5731645823,
0.2726950347,
0.0291349273,
0.0596101359,
-0.0885171741,
-0.5046457052,
-0.9428022504,
-0.0004585089,
-0.0938669667,
0.506704092,
-1.0641838312,
0.2505239248,
0.047946509,
-0.2869982123,
-0.4982081056,
0.359259516,
0.3974469602,
0.5945536494,
0.585359931,
0.2730562389,
-0.9290811419,
-0.8951969743,
-0.5800330639,
0.0015667443,
-0.2494940013,
-0.1908769011,
0.3414745033,
-0.0908129513,
0.8212320209,
-0.3200049102,
0.0425411649,
0.0327986628,
0.0275026653,
0.063959986,
0.3265796006,
0.5744627118,
-0.6107161045,
-0.2611054778,
-0.2767310739,
-0.8886258602,
0.183512792,
-0.2289460599,
-0.232098937,
0.1031606272,
0.5810701251,
-0.7652376294,
0.3596178889,
0.4233830273,
-0.2997835875,
0.4030393958,
-0.3484987915,
-0.0032407644,
-0.9782739878,
-0.2806087136,
0.0778890923,
-0.1129572317,
-0.7567813993,
0.1850163043,
0.0695222914,
-0.1029504314,
-0.3374578059,
0.2885354459,
-0.3062627912,
0.3405033052,
-0.1828560978,
0.234440431,
0.4662999511,
0.4841437042,
-0.1830975413,
0.6976932883,
0.7332361937,
-0.7422012687,
0.4464564919,
0.2332154512,
-0.0385523997,
0.52884835,
-0.5540682673,
0.0017656336,
-0.3708192706,
0.2435300499,
-0.9115017653,
-0.3104498982,
0.5059744716,
-0.66389364,
0.4351410568,
-0.1386127174,
-0.2240337133,
-0.2579244375,
-0.2272911519,
-0.2820667922,
0.210555464,
-1.0626145601,
0.8348588943,
0.2611557543,
0.0446703546,
-0.8686383367,
-0.7649157643,
0.1833993495,
-0.3085559309,
-0.8705607057,
0.4300884306,
-0.1749606133,
-0.6752561331,
0.0903668255,
-0.2901661098,
-0.193726331,
0.2760934234,
-0.0391945802,
-0.0349520855,
-0.4103415608,
0.1592810005,
-0.2261553109,
0.1232778803,
0.4951197207,
-0.358017385,
0.1355784684,
0.1970665157,
-0.3090935647,
-0.2762542069,
0.3240270019,
0.5327650905,
0.0377782919,
0.8724940419,
0.4789583683,
-0.6130905747,
-0.5195891261,
-0.7355700135,
-0.3031196296,
-0.5393634439,
0.2022987157,
-0.1397181898,
-0.2787080705,
0.4922590852,
0.3101732135,
0.0787192136,
0.4560508132,
0.1296216249,
-0.0117891738,
1.2279546261,
0.480086416,
0.000457064,
0.1963805705,
-0.0615371391,
0.4018318653,
-0.7483240962,
0.0551645234,
-0.2518769503,
0.0382590257,
-0.5183101296,
-0.2524372339,
0.192794919,
0.2166050524,
-0.3810252249,
0.2765838504,
-0.6789988279,
0.6435518265,
0.6626163721,
0.2855707705,
0.1753695607,
-0.0212386567,
-0.0545964278,
-0.0267224777,
-0.8114364147,
-0.4349599481,
1.030744791,
0.3100172281,
0.5241968632,
0.3726086915,
0.4358351231,
0.3358329535,
0.3919735253,
-0.3758003712,
0.3473696709,
-0.1131824628,
-0.6487082839,
-0.2287807018,
-0.5448342562,
-0.5483363867,
0.4528448284,
-0.4062879086,
-0.7288488746,
-0.1324424297,
0.2901849449,
-0.4483448863,
0.6943839788,
-0.8919299245,
0.8224562407,
-0.0681330338,
-0.1987101287,
-0.0579815954,
-0.2704032958,
0.7870386839,
0.1031981707,
0.3038824797,
0.017771557,
0.4256291091,
0.6185959578,
-0.4463907182,
0.8984750509,
-0.4182606637,
-0.3844599426,
0.3020150959,
0.2021135986,
0.8081052899,
0.2175398469,
0.0010469774,
-0.0311572701,
-0.5146032572,
-0.407931,
-1.0037018061,
0.6282964945,
-0.4979779124,
-0.8738158345,
-0.0835024342,
-0.5675132871,
-0.3281603456,
-0.0333838947,
0.6223886013,
0.5768682361,
-0.0775507316,
0.0352067389,
1.0470688343,
-0.3692768812,
0.3900781572,
0.6381158233,
0.1102673039,
-0.4533595443,
0.7168887854,
0.1572450101,
0.2122575939,
0.3097204864,
0.3550345004,
-0.5464997292,
-0.5676078796,
-0.6210569739,
0.1057757735,
-1.0062212944,
-0.2084081024,
-0.4238141179,
-0.0520870127,
-0.6350243688,
-0.1757196337,
-0.2110252529,
-0.39579615,
-0.0409331284,
-0.154198274,
0.5156665444,
0.9519506693,
-0.089063257,
0.4785733223,
-0.6836615801,
0.5851812363,
0.4318726361,
0.1066972464,
0.2207385451,
-0.5710494518,
-0.1413926333,
0.4866196215,
-0.5017790198,
-1.0394676924,
0.3835982382,
-0.0390947498,
0.6342734694,
0.4574235976,
0.2156583816,
0.8288061619,
-0.3420929313,
0.7010246515,
0.2787787914,
-1.0662255287,
0.6379604936,
-0.3101992309,
0.1738936156,
0.1982456446,
0.165915966,
-0.3410954773,
-0.9289147854,
-1.1043772697,
-0.6800839901,
0.3891058266,
0.3312998712,
-0.3258962929,
0.0505577363,
0.2456235141,
-0.1953290999,
0.0353076607,
-0.8903323412,
-0.4643102884,
-0.2339363992,
-0.1954547465,
0.2624054253,
0.0602453835,
-0.442101568,
0.1059734672,
1.0939773321,
-0.1044935808,
0.2069797963,
0.3358672857,
-0.2241602838,
-0.275808394,
0.1095390543,
0.6960806251,
0.7321360707,
0.0646447986,
0.3348802328,
0.4303790629,
-0.0471680164,
0.0695896596,
0.0314124227,
-0.3449490964,
0.2387187332,
0.4987231791,
0.7406119108,
0.0307843257,
-0.4413048625,
0.4264209569,
-0.1684438288,
-0.1039784327,
-0.4580334127,
0.2474546731,
0.2666884363,
0.0851771533,
0.2499055713,
0.8213191628,
0.0180801973,
-0.2964024842,
0.2065666914,
0.6519225836,
-0.2486056834,
-0.1943649948,
0.6015157104,
-0.0235581659,
-0.197151348,
0.0077443337,
-0.1645067185,
-0.611327529,
0.8177651763,
0.4441851079,
0.481126368,
-0.2126624286,
0.1420464367,
0.2138208747,
0.6197259426,
-0.1775071621,
0.0486141071,
0.1479475945,
-1.0330276489,
-0.5649341941,
-0.0475692004,
-0.6087599993,
0.6193256378,
-0.6072851419,
-0.0637688637,
-0.6501306891,
0.1389306933,
0.2535734773,
-0.1989256889,
-0.7776570916,
0.4550295174,
0.1205272898,
0.6389400363,
-0.8229069114,
0.6274917722,
0.4688575566,
-0.5833166838,
-0.8443914652,
0.1471648961,
0.1898607761,
-0.7317985892,
0.5940472484,
0.1758183539,
-0.3067372143,
-0.1565579027,
-0.5320023298,
-0.9830664396,
0.4064848423,
0.5344779491,
-0.2633341253,
0.0380173102,
-0.2592486143,
0.2974444032,
-0.0807022974,
0.2850273848,
0.5009658337,
0.7178119421,
-0.3466123939,
-0.5023222566,
0.2393090874,
-0.0313456394,
-0.196184963,
0.2686007023,
-0.1704745442,
0.6291563511,
-0.3491304815,
-0.5501565337,
-0.2347608656,
0.7008148432,
-0.0227468647,
0.2885179222,
0.4792642295,
0.792809248,
1.1771409512,
-0.134165436,
0.9030345678,
-0.1641670018,
0.0522559136,
1.4405063391,
-0.1948458105,
0.6183506846,
0.4243240356,
-0.2060259283,
0.5646423101,
0.4955314696,
-0.0012361293,
0.3610248566,
0.0308077503,
-0.3328262866,
-0.107233718,
0.1363735348,
-0.4230741858,
0.204794839,
0.4661914706,
-0.3178771734,
-0.4019322097,
0.0957760662,
0.1511577517,
0.4221948981,
-0.2108082175,
0.974734962,
-0.2676838636,
-1.0022963285,
1.02534163,
-0.1528567076,
0.6070643067,
-0.6481444836,
0.0042916555,
-0.1898712963,
0.4136164784,
-0.1977905929,
-0.4743957222,
0.6332395673,
-0.1082832664,
-0.4799200892,
-0.0734415427,
0.5927550793,
-0.4991061985,
-0.2538475394,
0.4505566955,
0.3801769018,
-0.1609647423,
-0.431075722,
-0.618150115,
-0.2792290151,
0.2203976363,
-0.1427737325,
0.2356859148,
0.7918400168,
0.2423803657,
0.6971279979,
0.9414701462,
0.139327541,
0.0506874137,
-0.0394744501,
0.6706348062,
-0.50451684,
-0.3746302724,
-1.0801465511,
0.3916553855,
-0.4374326169,
-0.2792487741,
0.8747372627,
0.1979573518,
0.8215030432,
-0.1820895523,
0.9787903428,
0.0641568676,
0.7413259149,
-0.6988542676,
0.6526161432,
-0.3853916526,
0.4607151151,
0.1106147468,
-0.5566938519,
-0.3443156183,
0.647524178,
-0.0064448034,
-0.4528236091,
0.9327189326,
0.979698956,
-0.0252909269,
0.2651606798,
0.357514441,
0.480186671,
0.3335934579,
0.4141732156,
0.741505444,
-0.5394744277,
0.6623207331,
-0.4839504659,
-0.1289200634,
0.0422412679,
-1.0948978662,
-0.9195813537,
-0.092977725,
-0.5008906722,
-0.55578053,
0.1370016187,
0.7120068073,
0.7885537148,
-1.1505384445,
0.2415066063,
-0.5400336981,
0.4867903888,
-0.5616567731,
-0.290055871,
0.2865632176,
-0.5283088684,
-0.3913849294,
0.9438346624,
-0.0778421462,
0.0905210078,
-0.3388672769,
0.0303078722,
-0.0780294538,
0.3742927909,
0.3036060333,
0.2764817476,
-1.0634490252,
-0.4116275907,
-0.1673261672,
0.1019351035,
0.1891022623,
0.7739590406,
-0.5951657891,
0.5317786336,
0.5480698347,
0.7440932393,
-0.0330652036,
-0.0709511042,
0.8399502039,
-1.0628796816,
-0.0080951108,
-0.0291916784,
0.6600615978,
0.721026659,
-0.7879230976,
0.384034127,
0.1401360333,
-0.323738724,
-0.5492588282,
0.3231279552,
-0.5172438622,
-0.650668025,
0.7322406173,
-0.3705982864,
-0.2956126034,
-0.3653429747,
-0.323063612,
0.393173933,
-0.224251613,
0.9599422812,
0.8801487088,
-0.0024078023,
0.0891421363,
-0.5952962637,
0.8067421913,
0.5001229644,
-0.9874040484,
0.284663856,
0.3289551735,
0.3755939603,
0.3356603086,
0.3142850399,
0.1983053684,
0.3543636501,
0.1559744626,
0.0638971552,
-0.0664852336,
-0.3915969431,
-0.2021686733,
0.2042544782,
-0.1511764377,
-0.0965419188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02978v1 | Which Argumentative Aspects of Hate Speech in Social Media can be reliably identified? | 2023-06-05T15:50:57 | 2023-06-05T15:50:57 | Damián Furman, Pablo Torres, José A. Rodríguez, Diego Letzen, Vanina Martínez, Laura Alonso Alemany | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the increasing diversity of use cases of large language models, a more
informative treatment of texts seems necessary. An argumentative analysis could
foster a more reasoned usage of chatbots, text completion mechanisms or other
applications. However, it is unclear which aspects of argumentation can be
reliably identified and integrated in language models. In this paper, we
present an empirical assessment of the reliability with which different
argumentative aspects can be automatically identified in hate speech in social
media. We have enriched the Hateval corpus (Basile et al. 2019) with a manual
annotation of some argumentative components, adapted from Wagemans (2016)'s
Periodic Table of Arguments. We show that some components can be identified
with reasonable reliability. For those that present a high error ratio, we
analyze the patterns of disagreement between expert annotators and errors in
automatic procedures, and we propose adaptations of those categories that can
be more reliably reproduced. | [
-0.4079088569,
-0.9919589758,
0.5391746163,
0.0879091769,
-0.2039889097,
0.1801946759,
-0.1717652977,
-0.469045639,
0.2868767679,
0.1167728081,
-0.3858046234,
-0.2516180575,
-0.8111560345,
0.2559736371,
-0.7135977745,
1.084684968,
-0.0417882651,
0.0573395081,
-0.2515651882,
-0.4062409103,
-0.2808671892,
-0.729870379,
-0.8537581563,
-0.1433353573,
0.9456337094,
0.1727877855,
0.8186919093,
0.6701294184,
0.3287450373,
0.4596174061,
0.032604523,
0.0909119546,
-0.423132509,
0.3486827612,
-0.4387866557,
-0.0481586829,
-0.1676846594,
-0.0533635542,
0.2756918073,
0.0564187579,
0.2056541592,
0.1118901297,
0.0009753499,
0.1764126122,
-0.4119472206,
-0.1754086167,
-1.0568423271,
-0.1299539208,
-0.3286514878,
-0.103851065,
-0.2537820935,
-0.6654238701,
-0.0239525437,
-0.3317660689,
-0.0013662594,
-0.2248353362,
0.804163456,
0.3021537662,
-0.2180875987,
-0.5730430484,
-0.9003913403,
0.7296969295,
-0.6779651046,
0.2445578724,
0.3354290426,
0.3129124343,
-0.1377846599,
-0.2427072525,
-0.6549493074,
-0.1789895147,
-0.1382214278,
-0.0019396459,
-0.5641469359,
-0.0163192879,
0.0878498703,
0.2636988163,
-0.3293162882,
0.1745775938,
-0.4328107238,
-0.5721867681,
0.6835030913,
-0.0397477187,
0.4307078719,
-0.4368858635,
-0.0505495295,
0.2313925624,
-0.0471854471,
-0.3289554417,
0.8524980545,
0.0098929182,
-0.1146791801,
0.5162439346,
0.1141581386,
0.4662050009,
0.1504077017,
0.1355086565,
0.0758008435,
-0.0247134268,
-0.0309210047,
-0.091591537,
0.9581471086,
0.359862417,
0.5522757173,
-0.2818725705,
-0.0044577802,
0.3538881838,
0.7473082542,
-0.4341102839,
-0.3649251759,
0.485910356,
-0.2395829856,
-0.5537503362,
-0.2089281976,
-0.8514075875,
-0.8829170465,
0.1165257022,
0.2709514201,
-0.4490919411,
-0.2249300778,
-0.6574847102,
-0.4056224227,
-0.0815300569,
0.2805786729,
-0.5028373599,
0.0899781436,
0.8666698933,
0.7127524018,
-0.3384534419,
-0.210756585,
-0.5609981418,
-0.2820929587,
-0.5298464894,
1.243508935,
-0.7868980765,
0.127929002,
0.2634046376,
0.0429027863,
0.118833214,
-0.5110607743,
1.0021687746,
-0.6662364006,
-0.1111127213,
-0.3459649384,
-0.6642685533,
-0.2962548435,
0.2559280396,
-0.7321189642,
0.875020504,
0.1828646511,
-0.8315120339,
0.4855920672,
-0.395254761,
-0.338799119,
0.3137749434,
-0.174307853,
-0.6314055324,
0.1245406121,
-0.3334975541,
0.4423808157,
-0.180466786,
0.0838844627,
-0.8709427714,
0.1045536771,
0.6074799299,
-0.2102003396,
0.5512109995,
0.1895133704,
-0.3661888242,
0.412953794,
-1.0764839649,
-0.3231361508,
0.2613049448,
-0.0482892655,
-0.5260095596,
0.3945971727,
-0.0440087877,
0.1824602336,
0.0260307323,
-0.772839129,
-0.500087738,
-0.1988404244,
0.5297726989,
1.0030062199,
0.2317484766,
0.0081427461,
-0.411999464,
0.5486439466,
-0.0258104783,
-0.0388047583,
0.2386977226,
-0.4950966835,
-0.6922181249,
-0.0201724824,
0.0831557289,
0.4868756831,
-0.3420482576,
0.1630760878,
-0.0624922067,
-0.8624895215,
-0.2085284293,
0.1560012996,
0.402040422,
0.3454327881,
0.2317028493,
0.0163414795,
-0.9417981505,
-1.014624238,
-0.4846813381,
-0.4285158217,
0.4065991342,
0.4721598327,
0.3432782292,
-0.1001970544,
0.7899546027,
0.186507374,
0.4479562938,
-0.0991416797,
0.505918026,
-0.1483509094,
0.0539833307,
0.4939425588,
-0.6242172718,
-0.6251623631,
-0.056449037,
-0.7217143774,
-0.5695608854,
-0.1225486472,
-0.3626925051,
0.109993495,
0.3257788718,
-0.0417251512,
0.4106070697,
0.5498671532,
-0.3135485947,
0.6082913876,
0.3722136915,
0.3353675902,
-0.701149404,
-0.3521591127,
0.3558596671,
-0.2425189763,
-0.6328088641,
-0.2832838893,
-0.3005976975,
0.1936689615,
-0.4734146595,
0.3361501396,
0.1442067623,
0.3244531751,
-0.3179303408,
0.2172695398,
-0.417561084,
0.1011798233,
-0.1325122863,
0.380944252,
0.1182160601,
-0.4682418108,
0.6611502171,
-0.1408506483,
-0.2023677528,
0.9529331326,
-0.7650571465,
0.2365933657,
-0.0322290175,
0.0150952796,
-1.2043447495,
-0.4248874784,
0.5108249784,
-0.3996859491,
-0.4051825404,
-0.4940868318,
-0.2708404064,
-0.1755119562,
-0.2882030308,
0.3187942207,
0.0179128814,
-0.2560877502,
0.7282071114,
0.5717360377,
-0.2156683207,
-0.6562541723,
-0.2848629951,
0.0806063265,
-0.5542166233,
-0.4694617987,
0.1457410157,
-0.0896196514,
-0.7325335741,
0.0387687087,
0.2694929838,
-0.1835537255,
0.1375563741,
0.7734485865,
-0.0369294174,
-0.1015409231,
0.1884798855,
-0.0698217079,
0.1637682766,
0.23945795,
0.3540252149,
0.5096226931,
0.1514242887,
-0.1770458668,
-0.2368945777,
0.4578177631,
0.6932842731,
0.3615547419,
0.550331831,
0.4506852627,
-0.4425061941,
-0.2590437233,
-0.8864873052,
0.2705365717,
-0.3789119422,
0.2557758987,
-0.0498465598,
-0.7806454897,
0.8300939798,
0.5222415328,
0.3665903509,
0.7973245382,
0.5490201712,
0.0231116805,
0.7130756378,
0.2391088456,
-0.085190475,
0.3482729495,
0.5681074262,
0.0339636654,
-0.178916797,
0.1453423202,
-0.7660456896,
-0.0629418492,
-0.5456335545,
-0.2225441039,
0.014849917,
-0.3277642429,
-0.4323171079,
0.3731742799,
-0.4479641616,
0.3756123185,
0.1622656435,
-0.2100086659,
0.1001473814,
0.2272618711,
0.2136591524,
-0.2299608141,
-0.3432773054,
-0.7088317871,
0.7495974302,
0.6426508427,
0.3248450458,
0.0765244141,
0.5093071461,
0.8055986762,
0.7052913308,
-0.8141545057,
0.4961853623,
-0.2456245273,
-0.8914899826,
-0.1111928225,
-0.3237658143,
-0.5490171313,
0.0444323532,
-0.3190331757,
-0.8892449737,
0.1787210107,
0.210799709,
-0.4985287786,
0.2821474969,
-0.4705395997,
0.9216835499,
-0.0800160319,
-0.3553510606,
-0.1999042332,
0.0618865415,
0.2922534049,
-0.3949683607,
0.3621772826,
-0.1315425485,
0.3215310872,
1.3629385233,
-0.5605325103,
0.7284169197,
-0.0556685738,
-0.2543536127,
0.5265546441,
0.0136695253,
0.263130784,
-0.3531794846,
-0.2763137221,
0.224938184,
0.0092020687,
-0.1065138802,
-0.4611947238,
0.5113757253,
-0.5709505677,
-0.4057754576,
-0.3582347929,
-0.1304761022,
-0.0119273225,
0.0327831917,
0.0903034061,
0.2568098307,
-0.3604635298,
0.2477778047,
0.3375522196,
-0.3379422426,
0.3879846931,
0.2306944728,
-0.126818046,
-0.6459524632,
1.1321102381,
0.3516937792,
-0.0464054942,
-0.1713010222,
0.4754295945,
-0.0626523271,
-0.6494060159,
-0.6941123605,
0.0994243175,
-0.9837585092,
-0.1577758789,
-0.9388538003,
-0.174334079,
-0.1695487797,
-0.3437648118,
-0.5080414414,
-0.3307670951,
0.0890605971,
-0.2329740524,
0.5694875121,
1.0500472784,
-0.107445702,
0.2650131285,
-0.4518198967,
0.1721094251,
0.3095990419,
0.2497012913,
0.1957562417,
-0.7027873993,
-0.1418322474,
-0.0191003922,
-0.0745479241,
-1.457772851,
-0.026454838,
-0.2506830096,
0.3900162876,
0.4415276647,
-0.0068818894,
0.6927893162,
-0.4165737629,
0.8950380683,
-0.0202787761,
-0.7107692957,
0.2584103048,
-0.4115160406,
-0.4984542727,
0.4925534129,
0.6844910383,
-0.4604649842,
-0.6615279913,
-0.679197073,
-0.6989876032,
0.2965903282,
-0.0482845865,
0.0882152691,
-0.4150655866,
0.2582109571,
0.0986747816,
-0.1788096279,
-0.9413155913,
-0.1646737605,
-0.3664255738,
-0.0976718888,
0.2696363628,
-0.7840710282,
-0.4296271801,
-0.0311678965,
0.7669479847,
0.2722012401,
0.0213821381,
-0.2015672475,
-0.209320724,
-0.1870276779,
0.3888605237,
0.6481475234,
0.8756802678,
-0.1140036806,
0.2495769858,
0.086994037,
-0.2540034354,
0.2323510498,
0.0546536967,
-0.0719595701,
0.4053533077,
0.3644821942,
0.5360785127,
0.0574242435,
-0.5083748102,
0.4709569812,
0.0484389365,
-0.1300494969,
-0.8193615079,
-0.0356286392,
0.0097422237,
0.3107235432,
0.2208180577,
-0.2502698004,
0.0436422825,
-0.4846403003,
0.2695627213,
0.4959690273,
-0.5957653522,
-0.356282711,
0.5254192948,
0.1692910194,
-0.4956922829,
0.0105883358,
-0.3026280403,
-0.6775121093,
0.3668756783,
0.1858795881,
0.927682519,
-0.2948110104,
0.3614311516,
0.4460259378,
0.2919336855,
0.4796665311,
0.0999227539,
0.17578879,
-0.9113847017,
-0.3257761002,
-0.7421520352,
-0.3923693895,
0.3122313321,
-0.281737566,
0.0110274637,
-0.7437189817,
-0.151145488,
0.6956144571,
-0.3130148947,
-0.2993190289,
0.18076846,
0.3364664614,
0.3551633954,
-1.1727764606,
0.2766205966,
0.7402259111,
-0.4850861132,
-0.5783971548,
-0.1535730064,
0.3331768513,
-0.5376307368,
0.7431569695,
-0.2452004403,
-0.5493565202,
-0.5778372884,
-0.5597669482,
-0.4569678307,
0.2511590123,
0.013046341,
-0.2892464101,
0.4962278008,
0.1508253068,
0.7428774238,
-0.3504410088,
0.560564518,
0.321449548,
0.386018157,
0.0616179146,
-0.7750868797,
0.3077638745,
-0.2199316025,
-0.1123843938,
-0.2213167548,
-0.4036150873,
0.3998592198,
0.3128662109,
-0.3104592562,
-0.2107253671,
0.874073863,
-0.1552379429,
0.3614315093,
0.8997785449,
0.4349626005,
0.6158188581,
0.1084988639,
0.651378572,
-0.2679850161,
0.0251601189,
1.0357308388,
-0.0080324542,
0.8003201485,
0.0709080175,
-0.1990212202,
0.6927396655,
0.4739001691,
-0.1595508754,
-0.0690249205,
0.2693608403,
-0.3021964133,
-0.3235369325,
-0.3367711008,
-0.0202642679,
0.4387800992,
0.3381263018,
-0.4920870662,
-0.0609292649,
-0.1787728667,
0.5900472999,
0.2378732413,
-0.1196712181,
0.8087114692,
-0.2499016523,
-0.7484540939,
0.4779991508,
0.0482304953,
0.7079882026,
-0.2322390974,
-0.0945956558,
0.0671493933,
-0.1981992722,
-0.6161652207,
-0.622256577,
0.6560448408,
0.4628924727,
-0.2536033392,
0.2803019285,
0.8443739414,
-0.1381376237,
-0.2817049026,
0.2633036077,
0.2747496367,
0.3278584778,
-0.0458489656,
-0.6424150467,
0.5424615741,
-0.092310898,
-0.1156537458,
0.1138297841,
0.4327550232,
0.0206619091,
0.3296567798,
0.4930096865,
0.0754610524,
0.3313610554,
0.0748049989,
0.6140341759,
-0.5417757034,
0.0207309015,
-1.1725839376,
0.5776357651,
-0.6141422987,
-0.3568644226,
0.8975028396,
0.3708021939,
0.6169242263,
0.2801367342,
0.9974534512,
-0.1408234984,
1.0273058414,
0.041352421,
0.5704170465,
-0.2484498024,
-0.0820428431,
-0.7214958668,
-0.643281877,
-0.1500615329,
0.8756082058,
-0.5883707404,
-0.0215652958,
0.6389757395,
0.7710918784,
-0.0308346823,
0.1988623291,
0.2629949152,
0.4877302647,
0.4839759469,
-0.0100051388,
1.0217247009,
-0.1688274741,
0.6641463637,
-0.3987492323,
-0.3367583752,
-0.3393602073,
-0.9800278544,
-0.7648653388,
-0.6145616174,
-0.7822718024,
-0.9766374826,
0.2070934922,
0.8770806193,
0.3625353277,
-0.7985111475,
-0.104408063,
0.20272322,
0.3909997046,
-0.0991231129,
-0.2036781311,
0.0951899812,
-0.361086458,
-0.5797485113,
0.2014372647,
0.3376558423,
-0.5651350021,
-0.1915063262,
0.1405700296,
-0.0782069489,
0.6371230483,
0.5980552435,
0.6894472837,
-0.8765556812,
-0.6739493012,
-0.5515589118,
0.0305694938,
-0.0592088215,
0.7672933936,
-0.0407005884,
0.4431012869,
0.3364881277,
0.8331307769,
-0.2255561203,
0.277559042,
0.308098495,
-0.1636488289,
-0.2802354991,
0.2343357205,
0.3617482185,
0.3968491852,
-0.0662494078,
0.3015429974,
0.4329138994,
-0.6961713433,
-0.7419164777,
0.1583808661,
-1.0416115522,
-0.020797899,
1.6209340096,
-0.2357227504,
-0.2718161941,
-0.6618253589,
0.0094139138,
0.2370948195,
-0.4656553864,
0.860827744,
1.287145257,
0.0135593936,
-0.2598628104,
-0.5153331757,
0.6852717996,
0.3413149714,
-0.5533527732,
0.2738098204,
0.9025565982,
0.23371692,
0.4338493645,
0.6425495148,
-0.2663187981,
0.2446634173,
0.0320957974,
-0.1790535301,
0.337869525,
-0.1161216199,
-0.1813690364,
0.5237206817,
0.1129691899,
0.1028201431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02955v1 | A Simple and Flexible Modeling for Mental Disorder Detection by Learning from Clinical Questionnaires | 2023-06-05T15:23:55 | 2023-06-05T15:23:55 | Hoyun Song, Jisu Shin, Huije Lee, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Social media is one of the most highly sought resources for analyzing
characteristics of the language by its users. In particular, many researchers
utilized various linguistic features of mental health problems from social
media. However, existing approaches to detecting mental disorders face critical
challenges, such as the scarcity of high-quality data or the trade-off between
addressing the complexity of models and presenting interpretable results
grounded in expert domain knowledge. To address these challenges, we design a
simple but flexible model that preserves domain-based interpretability. We
propose a novel approach that captures the semantic meanings directly from the
text and compares them to symptom-related descriptions. Experimental results
demonstrate that our model outperforms relevant baselines on various mental
disorder detection tasks. Our detailed analysis shows that the proposed model
is effective at leveraging domain knowledge, transferable to other mental
disorders, and providing interpretable detection results. | [
-0.2271487713,
-0.936050415,
1.082028985,
0.0826275051,
-0.339910984,
-0.1879237592,
-0.4200206101,
-0.5001884699,
0.4016630948,
0.3554018438,
-0.8356189728,
-0.732057333,
-1.0788353682,
-0.1073372811,
-0.5569337606,
1.1754801273,
-0.1775348336,
-0.0988198221,
-0.1238709688,
-0.0895209834,
-0.2476978898,
-0.2443043292,
-0.9306941032,
-0.1438093483,
0.4061746597,
0.3464160264,
0.7671489716,
0.3004273176,
0.757830441,
0.1781450659,
-0.0327345431,
0.4235114753,
-0.4972807169,
-0.0002124076,
-0.3423471451,
-0.2529177964,
-0.6789705157,
0.0144181643,
0.0947395712,
0.8257254958,
-0.2847565413,
0.2120144218,
0.0490095578,
0.2499500811,
-0.2785604894,
0.2571402192,
-0.5145831704,
-0.1037368998,
-0.1403951198,
-0.1955307573,
-0.219266668,
-0.1543136388,
-0.0110845594,
-0.7336573601,
0.520180881,
-0.504489243,
0.8184378743,
0.2314871103,
-0.5013384223,
-0.3557936549,
-0.8970448375,
0.3536489308,
-0.5243754983,
0.3222843111,
1.0068901777,
0.6813469529,
0.1854118854,
-0.6721019745,
-0.7222946286,
0.1543234885,
-0.0646986812,
-0.2081861198,
-0.3959101737,
-0.4147738814,
-0.0058577969,
0.1036035717,
-0.8039491177,
-0.1943047941,
-0.3585223854,
-0.1619475633,
0.7371333838,
0.3751725554,
0.6458940506,
-0.3062110841,
-0.0735409483,
0.417540282,
-0.0233087391,
-0.0592029504,
-0.3296558559,
0.3063995242,
-0.3551165462,
0.3539192677,
-0.0507806689,
0.3706283569,
0.0404978991,
-0.2782973945,
-0.0114160348,
0.0878399834,
-0.1131278723,
-0.3365646899,
0.4198248982,
0.5632055998,
0.1091536134,
-0.2514086366,
-0.2875224948,
0.3785286248,
0.5306515694,
-0.6236374974,
-0.6190665364,
0.2834944129,
-0.8021451235,
-0.0744233057,
-0.2875909209,
-0.5637695193,
-0.8333773017,
-0.4048285782,
0.3550319374,
-0.8268811107,
-0.700058639,
0.2927500606,
-0.1213611737,
-0.2179120034,
0.4852049649,
-0.7826980352,
0.3341778517,
0.6327360868,
0.9242275357,
-0.416018784,
0.1429087222,
-0.3533598483,
0.179635942,
-0.0547189899,
0.9826007485,
-0.3559698164,
-0.2127232701,
0.00205237,
0.2878950536,
-0.1148652062,
-0.51793468,
0.4589008391,
-0.3505736589,
-0.1031718999,
-0.2202129513,
-0.5360476971,
-0.103725493,
0.1018512547,
-0.6995218992,
0.6761287451,
0.5789474845,
-0.9352394342,
0.3980092406,
-0.2339261472,
-0.3659287393,
0.5422874093,
-0.0839501247,
-0.2400860339,
0.2189259082,
0.0542765707,
0.7047191262,
-0.1649548858,
0.4696148038,
-0.7221676707,
-0.3843457699,
0.3564749658,
-0.1395260096,
0.6147877574,
0.3841429353,
-0.0164132193,
-0.033297766,
-0.847003758,
-0.0030189347,
0.4774718881,
-0.2065154761,
-0.763040781,
0.2423779219,
0.3402634561,
0.0161886886,
-0.0664456785,
-0.3295402825,
-0.2729364634,
-0.1407742798,
0.3262757659,
0.3659244776,
0.1609872133,
0.1041355208,
-0.5048520565,
0.6175955534,
0.1942926943,
0.1952438951,
0.3289380372,
-0.7053520679,
-0.3458651006,
-0.8721697927,
-0.0977767184,
0.5227478147,
-0.7046311498,
0.5212828517,
-0.2867329419,
-0.4768510759,
-0.7425299287,
0.1516249478,
0.0464976653,
0.3233558536,
0.478316009,
-0.1560170352,
-0.3764775395,
-0.639523685,
-0.4712947607,
0.1012159213,
-0.0797684714,
0.0826286077,
0.4025405347,
-0.6198328137,
0.6668999195,
-0.6900863051,
-0.307258606,
-0.5388048887,
0.2178753316,
0.0359827131,
0.0019675812,
0.3459994793,
-0.8684335351,
-0.3817538321,
0.1606057882,
-0.9364647865,
-0.155801937,
0.2211973667,
-0.0631711408,
-0.3370984197,
0.202650547,
-0.8123650551,
0.6557673216,
0.1875394434,
-0.5860202312,
0.2960951626,
0.0619524643,
-0.0729268864,
-0.9427113533,
-0.1081241518,
0.1812191606,
-0.4151658118,
-0.7703248858,
0.0472105555,
0.0668833852,
-0.3348135948,
-0.2181896716,
0.3568252623,
0.0767154843,
0.4336248934,
-0.3784056306,
0.2812749445,
0.0923580453,
0.1695342064,
-0.0226996019,
0.1221331954,
0.4495155215,
-0.5762655735,
0.2080380172,
0.1206012145,
-0.3460816443,
0.9505896568,
-0.3419181108,
-0.0398859084,
-0.6223604679,
-0.1004812792,
-1.1912699938,
-0.436696589,
0.3209029138,
-0.6724336743,
0.0994046107,
0.1480552107,
-0.2358005941,
-0.3027776778,
-0.045713719,
0.4071682096,
0.1328905672,
-0.2744650841,
0.4589270651,
0.6288958788,
-0.1858204156,
0.0833882764,
-0.5179257989,
-0.2585333884,
-0.4851187468,
-0.5937729478,
0.4555840492,
0.0918700844,
-0.2478868514,
0.3230905533,
-0.151314348,
-0.5597937107,
0.2758220434,
0.1000881866,
0.2075904757,
-0.2379498482,
0.618542254,
0.1791814417,
-0.0157195572,
0.1253556758,
-0.0309460238,
0.3000681698,
0.0831340402,
-0.2751845419,
-0.5869430304,
0.7255536318,
0.6153323054,
-0.0820160508,
0.6234771609,
0.6228173375,
-1.1105251312,
-0.6810804009,
-0.1589768231,
-0.2146573365,
-0.4362939298,
0.2470129281,
-0.4665179551,
-0.583602488,
0.5352606773,
-0.2017083317,
-0.6144505143,
0.2311482728,
0.4989386201,
-0.1800687462,
1.4295362234,
0.778151989,
0.1553361267,
0.0494314656,
-0.1252810806,
0.5874168277,
-0.3444547057,
-0.0566354617,
-0.2626250684,
0.1397529989,
-0.3756949306,
-0.3818025887,
0.3331751525,
-0.0698618963,
-0.0483642444,
0.1294332743,
-0.540671289,
0.0815036967,
-0.0672432482,
0.5466138124,
0.424652487,
-0.0097415922,
0.02945338,
-0.4926505387,
-0.4693652391,
-0.815664649,
0.8803712726,
0.4052324891,
0.6429477334,
0.3133514524,
0.4753341377,
0.6574422121,
0.6905043125,
-0.8030669093,
0.3834297359,
-0.3072421551,
-0.5984672308,
-0.1499579549,
-0.313768059,
-0.7701227069,
0.1851918101,
-0.2385728955,
-0.9054247737,
0.1818882078,
-0.0888442025,
-0.5143036246,
0.2789485455,
-0.66130656,
1.0187039375,
-0.1949800253,
0.2422578484,
-0.1585200727,
-0.4098253846,
0.5332852602,
-0.3116460443,
0.6078869104,
-0.547680974,
0.1190070882,
0.8012990355,
-0.3474230766,
0.8421070576,
-0.1795133352,
0.1109133661,
0.0926933512,
0.1187399551,
-0.0971424133,
0.143622756,
0.1202648729,
-0.2678495944,
0.4914248288,
-0.4933817089,
-0.8969866633,
0.5005394816,
-0.7795015574,
-0.3732520938,
-0.1391621232,
-0.5981608629,
-0.4784086645,
0.2842324972,
0.0823433846,
0.2104971707,
-0.294932723,
-0.2630475163,
0.6655529141,
-0.2190850377,
-0.1810124218,
0.8119105101,
-0.4750607014,
0.0678775385,
1.0308227539,
-0.0135668218,
-0.0088840071,
-0.0442377776,
0.2448143661,
-0.1699745357,
-0.3618413508,
-0.0075311931,
0.5037780404,
-0.8706750274,
0.0377399512,
-0.6506440639,
-0.1291086674,
-0.5034265518,
0.1059965715,
-0.2197229117,
-0.258220762,
-0.3994715512,
-0.2827239335,
0.5068532228,
0.710878849,
-0.0296682175,
0.2617107332,
-0.5980480909,
0.7801644802,
0.3000236452,
0.4243583381,
0.1742944866,
-0.3452274799,
-0.0194502026,
0.0486080684,
-0.3182884753,
-1.2298225164,
0.5934780836,
0.2523090541,
0.407897085,
0.8752072453,
0.352984786,
0.5895275474,
-0.1221144572,
0.211822927,
0.0669962093,
-0.8582167625,
0.9199029803,
-0.3491895497,
-0.0215512086,
0.6318454742,
1.1778488159,
-0.7565726042,
-0.6056439877,
-0.5980237722,
-0.538427949,
0.4667016268,
-0.0446748734,
0.1330329031,
-0.3677412868,
0.4885493815,
0.1111573055,
-0.2521208525,
-0.425978899,
-0.048879113,
-0.2191691846,
-0.5683478713,
-0.0803250149,
-0.1635067016,
-0.2487004697,
-0.5464167595,
0.2623819709,
-0.0939636156,
0.6016882658,
0.3076213598,
-0.2376502454,
-0.1411090791,
0.009164595,
0.1857306659,
0.7542875409,
-0.4935156703,
0.4988400936,
-0.1483645737,
-0.5254980922,
-0.0236371458,
0.235768646,
-0.1022222042,
0.2882653177,
0.376784265,
0.6748042107,
0.0268002152,
-0.9214811325,
0.7798877954,
-0.0740904063,
-0.1997321546,
-0.1836166829,
-0.0748271942,
0.4407134652,
0.3629575074,
0.237699762,
-0.1829062998,
0.3824086189,
-0.5778656602,
0.5142310262,
0.364353776,
-0.6729906201,
-0.5088090897,
0.7385250926,
-0.1495457441,
-0.7202947736,
0.5282543898,
-0.4635878503,
-0.4199343026,
0.5307756662,
0.6244685054,
0.4317774773,
-0.3006944656,
0.5912608504,
-0.2091499865,
0.2177002877,
0.0286135525,
0.6743888259,
0.1037201434,
-0.9932179451,
0.012031774,
-0.4147334993,
-0.1614837497,
0.4949552417,
-1.0252896547,
0.2390095443,
-0.554853797,
-0.6918987036,
0.7211350799,
-0.2405555546,
-0.6397971511,
0.4207895696,
0.4285857975,
0.8296781182,
-1.1063425541,
0.8622486591,
0.8701178432,
-0.2627198398,
-0.7026674151,
0.1052850336,
0.3372184634,
-0.7005289793,
0.2685295045,
0.3289345801,
0.0685321242,
-0.27557832,
-0.4915478528,
-0.6038885117,
0.8461015821,
0.1950725913,
0.105740428,
0.004265483,
0.09489806,
0.8232574463,
-0.4611828923,
-0.0918538198,
0.7677317858,
0.3378730416,
-0.0157667845,
-0.7184512615,
0.3074967563,
-0.576072216,
0.0048404168,
0.0540424623,
0.089647159,
0.5963606834,
-0.1720626354,
-0.6847599745,
-0.2068812549,
0.4272848666,
0.2629432976,
0.7482798696,
0.3234655261,
0.5195701718,
1.2243810892,
0.3021725714,
1.0088740587,
-0.1938896924,
0.5405610204,
0.7826934457,
-0.335252434,
0.9251378775,
0.1417969465,
-0.1811723262,
0.3649749756,
0.6973794103,
0.318618685,
0.6275733709,
0.0986729264,
-0.5180553198,
-0.5096083879,
-0.3187694848,
-0.1166564301,
0.3043160141,
0.7418401837,
-0.3478674293,
-0.4708670378,
0.2602435052,
0.1601340175,
0.2963115573,
-0.1988794804,
0.3859529793,
0.3041815758,
-0.2915682793,
0.739168942,
0.2101788074,
0.5022296309,
-0.351470232,
0.0140536446,
-0.0482802726,
0.3888746798,
-0.154541105,
-0.6024056673,
0.9480825067,
-0.0025962137,
-0.4126247168,
0.0162768923,
1.1016892195,
-0.4353083074,
-0.7406719327,
0.5472748876,
0.8521684408,
0.3985248506,
-0.2845264375,
-0.5290237069,
-0.2399613261,
-0.4277044535,
0.1862935126,
0.2768343389,
0.723968327,
-0.4482793212,
0.8101030588,
0.4968435168,
0.2227161378,
-0.1704612672,
-0.0384168364,
0.6569907665,
-0.4729950428,
-0.3487747908,
-0.5373020172,
0.2315964103,
-0.0823736861,
-0.2475145012,
0.3648083806,
-0.0992886871,
0.5316790342,
-0.0481207445,
0.8195195794,
-0.0037644266,
0.9791416526,
0.0235737264,
1.0906736851,
-0.8348376751,
0.0782777667,
-0.0463000685,
-0.0490274727,
-0.4164230824,
0.7692886591,
-0.381349653,
-0.2331036776,
0.8293612599,
0.6269336939,
-0.2880968451,
0.2053404897,
0.222178489,
0.2051012814,
0.109045364,
0.670769453,
0.8077035546,
-0.0154765705,
0.1664424539,
-0.1477797031,
-0.496113956,
-0.0720344856,
-0.4516447783,
-0.9624651074,
-0.6856373549,
-0.4060178101,
-0.2641520202,
0.1551830471,
0.6807181835,
0.787848413,
-0.7764636874,
0.1756165326,
0.3820790052,
0.4085810184,
-0.5196191669,
-0.2789271772,
0.3297038972,
0.0493763685,
-0.1255532354,
0.1234160066,
0.0132149644,
-0.1892726868,
0.0461247005,
0.2125923336,
-0.0823742151,
0.2115770727,
0.826305747,
0.0187226944,
-0.6377490163,
-0.2659479082,
0.030647302,
-0.3829645813,
-0.271615535,
0.6403521299,
-0.4409519434,
0.2356517017,
0.3514470458,
0.7447605729,
0.3844987452,
0.0589052774,
0.3153209984,
-0.2118312865,
-0.2576094568,
0.1925092489,
0.1407438219,
0.3882721663,
-0.6984204054,
0.2132592946,
0.5730581284,
-0.0414136015,
-0.7233438492,
0.1653840244,
-1.1272993088,
-0.6153315902,
1.1062369347,
-0.3714264929,
-0.1201160848,
-0.6765744686,
-0.0118638752,
0.3020449579,
-0.0025419716,
1.0281410217,
0.5521371961,
-0.1955000907,
-0.0985760167,
-0.8560767174,
0.5471880436,
0.1536626071,
-0.5481958985,
-0.247348547,
0.1202651933,
0.6721025705,
-0.2217836678,
1.1384884119,
-0.0851826593,
0.5228582025,
-0.3323585987,
-0.1374863088,
0.2557603419,
-0.1006926671,
-0.3025815785,
0.1664904952,
-0.0731455386,
0.0640515611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02923v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02923v2 | MidMed: Towards Mixed-Type Dialogues for Medical Consultation | 2023-06-05T14:36:31 | 2023-06-14T02:56:06 | Xiaoming Shi, Zeming Liu, Chuan Wang, Haitao Leng, Kui Xue, Xiaofan Zhang, Shaoting Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most medical dialogue systems assume that patients have clear goals (medicine
querying, surgical operation querying, etc.) before medical consultation.
However, in many real scenarios, due to the lack of medical knowledge, it is
usually difficult for patients to determine clear goals with all necessary
slots. In this paper, we identify this challenge as how to construct medical
consultation dialogue systems to help patients clarify their goals. To mitigate
this challenge, we propose a novel task and create a human-to-human mixed-type
medical consultation dialogue corpus, termed MidMed, covering five dialogue
types: task-oriented dialogue for diagnosis, recommendation, knowledge-grounded
dialogue, QA, and chitchat. MidMed covers four departments
(otorhinolaryngology, ophthalmology, skin, and digestive system), with 8,175
dialogues. Furthermore, we build baselines on MidMed and propose an
instruction-guiding medical dialogue generation framework, termed InsMed, to
address this task. Experimental results show the effectiveness of InsMed. | [
-0.4507656097,
-0.3824340999,
0.9529376626,
0.2628567815,
-0.3469453752,
0.4294669628,
-0.2129558325,
-0.4517293274,
0.4715160131,
0.5308080316,
-0.6817501783,
-0.5627838373,
-0.2670068741,
0.2441514134,
0.039860405,
0.9622327089,
0.087850742,
0.6561714411,
-0.3630744815,
-0.1391948462,
-0.7127666473,
-0.3719159663,
-0.6143045425,
-0.3716739714,
0.404045254,
0.9733423591,
0.7180000544,
-0.0177780837,
0.2478836775,
0.2316482216,
0.0791526958,
0.6604099274,
-0.0194766466,
0.328935802,
-0.2150957584,
-0.6306160092,
-0.1455983222,
-0.1257489622,
0.3233265579,
0.9865339398,
-0.2935633659,
-0.1174562126,
0.0428280085,
0.5393474102,
-0.2962303758,
-0.2822141349,
-0.2145981342,
0.3391101658,
-0.2316452116,
-0.4190913439,
-0.1193145812,
-0.0951594338,
0.5595098138,
-0.4860791266,
0.1452174783,
0.2959570885,
0.6624160409,
0.3668008447,
-0.4121282399,
-0.5021716952,
-0.7864145041,
0.4563677311,
-0.7826975584,
0.1177755296,
0.2670051455,
0.5978909731,
-0.3860206902,
-0.6707313657,
-0.4905900061,
0.0473961979,
-0.3081445992,
0.3080539405,
-0.0948250368,
0.5557382107,
0.1919897348,
0.2832848132,
-0.3134033382,
-0.0203485955,
-0.2925463319,
-0.2155635804,
0.3399045169,
0.3956474066,
0.4461884499,
-0.0513020083,
-0.3040941656,
0.5403424501,
-0.7551857829,
-0.0732528046,
0.0981108695,
-0.0013071336,
-0.3142067194,
0.4729951918,
-0.3470271826,
0.7462366223,
0.3931357563,
-0.3910613358,
-0.2089526653,
-0.4272074997,
-0.2201870531,
0.1309795678,
0.5890028477,
0.5724235773,
-0.05684416,
-0.1808910668,
-0.1216163784,
-0.0324915946,
0.3281520009,
-0.6946143508,
-0.2443812042,
0.4528717697,
-0.7258355618,
-0.0942957476,
-0.4316306412,
-0.6211968064,
-0.3307572901,
-0.4658708572,
0.1930676848,
-0.4221096933,
0.0553626195,
0.4549858272,
0.0538656637,
-0.062780939,
0.5697966218,
-0.6388229728,
0.6337592006,
0.134241268,
0.3091344237,
0.2639073133,
0.3961179554,
-0.2581222951,
0.2605972588,
-0.1432430148,
0.7949398756,
-0.5473608971,
-0.6185141206,
-0.0108823562,
-0.3205353022,
-0.0112280417,
-0.8906475902,
0.5230892301,
0.2176679671,
0.9588727951,
-0.2632343769,
-0.5135404468,
-0.1385126263,
0.5155758262,
0.0582007691,
0.4904293716,
0.2675739229,
-0.6512672305,
0.2100181729,
-0.7204905748,
-0.3977530301,
0.4724442065,
-0.8740360141,
-0.1022365019,
-0.1226586625,
0.2589306533,
0.3229053915,
-0.9238765836,
0.5019865632,
0.0190577265,
-0.2144161314,
0.2315438092,
-0.109913893,
0.4510157406,
0.3061142266,
-0.1959371865,
0.1970915794,
-0.6950936913,
-0.0340337269,
-0.2678201199,
-0.1885749698,
-0.3614576161,
0.1404528171,
-0.2812537253,
0.3618046641,
0.1789815873,
-0.8610417247,
0.2399991006,
-0.6094232798,
0.281354785,
0.1970335841,
0.4161962867,
0.1922447085,
-0.5815438032,
0.590367198,
0.4889214039,
0.4768029153,
-0.1209491715,
-0.9351246357,
-0.9009280801,
-0.2648686767,
0.196197778,
0.6020994782,
-1.1241153479,
0.2264883667,
0.1865709126,
-0.3316803277,
-0.9220533371,
-0.1747814268,
0.7365348935,
0.9418327212,
0.3607116044,
-0.286345154,
-0.5332884789,
-1.0693343878,
-0.0542814955,
-0.2112890035,
-0.0065953466,
0.7614570856,
-0.0969358832,
-0.529004395,
1.0887174606,
-0.4920954108,
-0.2224843353,
-0.203074649,
-0.1207129136,
0.244964093,
0.4352813065,
0.5654078126,
-0.7275040746,
-0.6741564274,
-0.0571496561,
-0.5646184087,
-0.310936898,
-0.1743338257,
-0.1992494911,
-0.2586907744,
0.2963650823,
-0.5328822732,
0.4678331316,
0.3903550208,
-0.2841554284,
0.4894433022,
-0.304351747,
0.2704821527,
-1.5736064911,
0.0735205561,
-0.1183112711,
-0.339299351,
-0.6448844671,
-0.6113086343,
-0.2218671739,
-0.3140287995,
-0.2380208075,
0.4267229736,
-0.3044811189,
0.2191363424,
0.0087619191,
-0.2128429264,
-0.0944899842,
0.4717693329,
-0.1866248101,
0.5215592384,
0.4272371531,
-0.4765059054,
0.2105489075,
0.4866392314,
-0.1109925881,
1.0370359421,
-0.6416004896,
0.1125689298,
-0.0225638859,
0.3104822338,
-0.9956051707,
-0.2813713849,
0.5712105632,
-0.3298439384,
0.4869049489,
-0.3717890084,
-0.4058035612,
-0.396674186,
0.2597903013,
0.7246546745,
0.2297037989,
-0.0434268713,
0.3405537903,
0.4368487298,
-0.5343958139,
-0.4376681745,
-0.2768379152,
0.339445591,
-0.0344073698,
-0.6757211685,
0.4335718453,
-0.2258609384,
-0.2764126062,
-0.1395107955,
-0.0304251965,
-0.0450185835,
-0.320354104,
0.3993542194,
0.321154356,
0.0196925364,
0.0235322546,
0.5360921025,
-0.09713649,
-0.0272922516,
-0.3560448289,
0.5154601336,
0.1297086179,
-0.7257687449,
-0.3589970469,
0.7561436296,
0.5982097983,
-0.0750159547,
0.1930200905,
0.1636153758,
-0.567661047,
-0.0176062472,
-0.8263174295,
-0.2191829085,
-0.4057307839,
-0.1093277708,
-0.2991228104,
-1.0082126856,
0.5286672711,
-0.4691641629,
0.2746375501,
0.2042172998,
0.8372887373,
-0.480583787,
0.9227212667,
0.3488965929,
0.5563897491,
0.020640241,
0.1363589019,
0.1164694354,
-0.6753994226,
-0.52433002,
-0.3953708112,
-0.4713557065,
-0.3810369968,
-0.391380161,
0.941775322,
-0.1897957772,
0.1083833948,
-0.0331771709,
-0.9105888605,
0.0186605416,
0.6667268276,
0.397111237,
0.1212512478,
-0.1737222672,
-0.7789777517,
-0.2316090763,
-0.8575627208,
-0.3184851408,
0.9195973873,
0.2709878385,
0.5823614597,
-0.1467631459,
0.9260166287,
-0.0100468909,
0.1670107245,
-0.7346231341,
0.5276840329,
-0.1694792211,
-0.5915217996,
0.1831650287,
-0.3862455785,
-0.8554725647,
0.0837118477,
-0.3609261513,
-0.3736842871,
0.4155187607,
0.0639507845,
-1.0319629908,
0.0301219802,
-0.633767426,
0.5685196519,
-0.0350988433,
-0.0573148169,
-0.193784222,
-1.360304594,
0.1873986125,
0.1362883002,
0.1431893259,
-0.1180958152,
0.0531937331,
0.6509024501,
-0.6882370114,
1.0002151728,
-0.370762229,
0.2599286735,
0.2407515645,
-0.1962814629,
-0.0433211997,
0.3275901675,
0.380768925,
-0.2329899371,
0.3654560149,
-0.2116158605,
-0.4494162202,
0.1166093275,
-0.6869791746,
-0.3687372804,
-0.1866480857,
-0.7048708797,
-0.7802959085,
0.2033489197,
0.4483648837,
0.6902533174,
-0.2934977412,
-0.145845741,
0.7139665484,
-0.417740196,
-0.0130813178,
0.6705132127,
-0.1192720532,
-0.4512903988,
0.385742873,
0.0511558056,
0.0965672657,
0.4129911661,
0.1762095541,
-0.1561012715,
-0.5693020821,
-0.744261682,
0.3555310071,
-0.4137198925,
-0.3757911026,
-0.59108603,
-0.3635702729,
-0.2229773998,
-0.0305277612,
-0.0529085249,
-0.1584992409,
-0.3622868359,
0.5325854421,
0.1242110431,
0.7677613497,
0.2339537442,
0.3570124805,
-1.1112313271,
0.3100044131,
0.1494743377,
0.2937801778,
-0.3515622318,
-0.1689968407,
-0.3141137958,
0.2910358012,
-0.3503380716,
-0.7940012217,
0.2971782684,
-0.1974145323,
0.5265546441,
0.6111358404,
0.0652264282,
0.889328599,
-0.7137839198,
0.5780658126,
0.7314023376,
-0.5328053832,
0.4921514988,
-0.1772052944,
0.1639881283,
0.7057648897,
0.2759959996,
-0.9888390303,
-0.4647031426,
-0.5121212006,
-0.3442510664,
0.513466239,
-0.0508183502,
-0.1229161471,
-0.0671425983,
0.3053797483,
0.2278191894,
0.3585106432,
0.074361451,
-0.0694488809,
0.1418780237,
-0.5403606296,
0.1764158607,
-0.29352808,
-0.8016867042,
-0.2507520318,
0.2181348652,
-0.2040971965,
0.2796141505,
0.7274518609,
0.2920597196,
-0.2743747532,
0.6870283484,
0.6539492011,
0.4184122682,
-0.0454679318,
-0.0457677953,
-0.1127890199,
-0.611328721,
0.0833317563,
0.2022816092,
-0.02866593,
0.2867833674,
-0.1424322426,
0.5609969497,
0.3956430852,
-0.7239304781,
0.4663349986,
-0.290587008,
-0.2650305033,
0.0258970391,
-0.2023075074,
0.0193798468,
0.2082104832,
0.1921482235,
0.4320248365,
0.3019991517,
-0.4591389,
0.2377268225,
0.3440886438,
-0.5468159318,
-0.1226326674,
0.4021301866,
0.6540747285,
-0.3151322901,
0.5038387775,
-0.0188330822,
-0.3854520619,
0.0938491672,
0.5334370136,
0.6318390965,
-0.0263765175,
0.0389726497,
-0.1777814478,
0.0614298284,
0.1856514663,
0.6798246503,
-0.0703526512,
-0.6289181113,
-0.3702646792,
-0.3988360167,
-0.9767025113,
-0.3037008643,
-0.4484586716,
0.2061576694,
-0.3856996596,
-0.3737371862,
0.1268476844,
0.0951568708,
-0.5402116776,
0.3582091033,
0.0290591493,
0.8200713992,
-0.2751668692,
0.6779183149,
0.9937410951,
-0.2311761677,
-0.8770756721,
-0.0380091406,
-0.045126833,
-0.7661239505,
-0.0229017399,
-0.0102696866,
0.0261757039,
-0.2235092372,
-0.5993341804,
-0.2531678379,
0.7684950233,
0.2531318069,
-0.627356708,
-0.5732169151,
0.1817274839,
0.5025312304,
-0.5914713144,
0.1272678226,
0.2256593257,
0.1703254133,
0.2575213611,
-1.276943922,
-0.0077256793,
-0.2940933108,
-0.3383678198,
0.3567019701,
-0.4935550988,
0.6653789878,
-0.2137197256,
-0.1851121038,
0.1632629186,
0.1721418947,
0.0959621817,
0.4283927381,
0.6382629871,
0.6198903322,
0.6499283314,
-0.1330878139,
0.8523097038,
-0.5355040431,
-0.3185437024,
0.893491447,
-0.3657027483,
0.2170215845,
0.6600269079,
-0.0239361357,
0.5246771574,
0.7260504961,
0.2111711651,
0.2721160054,
0.0251184627,
-0.6314928532,
-0.2505018413,
-0.2497295439,
-0.3862733841,
0.3522613943,
0.8230860233,
-0.1342275292,
-0.2025115341,
-0.045549605,
-0.108274214,
-0.0356581695,
-0.1095384359,
1.0686161518,
0.1898371726,
-0.8427368999,
0.5511707664,
-0.030737849,
0.601485014,
-0.5928960443,
-0.2571060956,
-0.0903834552,
-0.0240053385,
-0.5024493933,
-0.8270602226,
0.1049493104,
-0.2501735985,
-0.1986086369,
-0.0981211811,
0.6999689341,
-0.9199020267,
-0.1560585946,
-0.1869549602,
0.6663922071,
0.310626924,
0.1783489585,
-0.720261395,
-0.458977282,
0.2100328505,
0.4524643421,
0.2740005255,
0.5908910632,
-0.1701505482,
0.604473412,
0.5817144513,
0.3344107568,
-0.1640277058,
0.1742169559,
1.034932375,
-0.3150061369,
-0.4619734287,
-0.3802758753,
0.4447797537,
-0.1425381005,
-0.3834305704,
0.3186337948,
0.5936953425,
0.5232387781,
0.1007309109,
0.8157559633,
0.1375432312,
1.052893877,
-0.2445862144,
0.629909277,
-0.5012850761,
-0.0459953062,
-0.1181619093,
-0.5618284345,
-0.3272955418,
0.2329036891,
0.0461934768,
-0.142401278,
0.5083122849,
0.5926267505,
-0.1156317964,
0.1278039515,
0.4426726699,
0.0480220281,
0.2594191134,
0.7767009139,
0.9969911575,
0.0213353969,
0.3376066685,
-0.2400137186,
-0.3889812231,
-0.4221778512,
-0.1879594922,
-0.7033093572,
-0.3648277819,
-0.1162144244,
-0.3299472928,
-0.0057925354,
1.1781246662,
0.9289344549,
-0.4538355172,
-0.2196868658,
0.1592761278,
-0.1677061617,
0.2191028744,
-0.1561034918,
-0.0828178152,
-0.3469193876,
-0.5297443271,
0.5556240082,
0.7936891317,
0.3088515699,
-0.2516604662,
-0.0369885229,
-0.1171268597,
0.123144567,
0.2433585972,
0.2622485459,
-0.5993313789,
-0.0476800464,
0.1006303951,
-0.4245081544,
0.3201723397,
1.0949606895,
-0.6860897541,
0.76534307,
0.1039352342,
0.6007367373,
0.4319407344,
-0.1236375794,
0.8259039521,
-0.7841288447,
0.2216983289,
0.8130562305,
0.5744116902,
0.265235126,
-0.3917856216,
0.3035586774,
0.2925240695,
-0.6219967008,
-0.6405400038,
0.4247480631,
-1.1526180506,
-0.1552003026,
0.7304558158,
-0.1723452806,
0.2848500609,
-0.6556008458,
-0.8639202118,
0.3958642483,
-0.3539259434,
0.4972328842,
0.5119508505,
-0.5902678967,
0.0861006901,
-0.3639709055,
0.8393833637,
0.651078999,
-0.8326362371,
-0.4954695106,
0.4490844905,
0.3644987941,
0.0769078583,
1.0448143482,
-0.3746853769,
0.4272508621,
-0.3361013234,
0.2377702147,
0.3617403507,
-0.2528729737,
0.3576034009,
-0.0693544671,
-0.0841936469,
-0.38783741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02920v1 | Second Language Acquisition of Neural Language Models | 2023-06-05T14:32:41 | 2023-06-05T14:32:41 | Miyu Oba, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Hiroki Ouchi, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the success of neural language models (LMs), their language acquisition
has gained much attention. This work sheds light on the second language (L2)
acquisition of LMs, while previous work has typically explored their first
language (L1) acquisition. Specifically, we trained bilingual LMs with a
scenario similar to human L2 acquisition and analyzed their cross-lingual
transfer from linguistic perspectives. Our exploratory experiments demonstrated
that the L1 pretraining accelerated their linguistic generalization in L2, and
language transfer configurations (e.g., the L1 choice, and presence of parallel
texts) substantially affected their generalizations. These clarify their
(non-)human-like L2 acquisition in particular aspects. | [
-0.2042314112,
-0.5844942927,
0.5235679746,
0.1139186099,
0.0422528461,
0.0668821782,
-0.2678533792,
-0.8838455081,
0.1144811511,
0.3607601523,
-0.3017648458,
-0.0854731724,
-0.815772295,
-0.0582587719,
-0.3345745802,
0.8479946852,
-0.020056393,
0.4084686935,
0.0196332503,
-0.1528346688,
-0.3815433979,
-0.5479254127,
-0.8972527385,
-0.9119182825,
0.9119366407,
0.1699209511,
0.6759957671,
0.3040807247,
0.1833495051,
0.2865681648,
-0.0590997003,
-0.2300814986,
-0.4174650013,
-0.2183919549,
-0.4461191893,
-1.0187020302,
-0.5392767787,
-0.1525553167,
0.7166644931,
0.975279808,
0.1318061054,
0.0880281329,
0.1381250173,
0.7416105866,
-0.3026509881,
-0.0012710405,
-0.5154672861,
0.2196742296,
-0.043357078,
-0.1677660495,
-0.5774260163,
-0.2231062204,
0.4770607948,
-0.6834104061,
0.138360545,
-0.0899480432,
0.4790138602,
-0.2363879234,
-0.5821179152,
-0.207312271,
-0.5994719863,
0.6283018589,
-0.3596983552,
0.5238497853,
0.6448274851,
0.2217484266,
0.0695325062,
-0.8869264722,
-0.5194484591,
-0.1076435521,
-0.4303238094,
-0.1603137553,
-0.0852070302,
0.0203208141,
0.210225001,
-0.0970833749,
-0.7751961946,
0.6553713083,
-0.7641624212,
-0.110752739,
0.532217443,
0.0779291838,
0.4155166447,
0.0791104883,
-0.5541954041,
0.193062976,
-0.815010488,
0.2768712342,
0.2958143651,
0.3228312135,
-0.2955977917,
0.3001703024,
-0.0088627562,
0.7440915704,
-0.2616732717,
0.1691762805,
0.3056658506,
-0.5958037972,
-0.0753848776,
-0.1567274034,
0.3543920815,
0.3271556795,
0.8147194386,
-0.3629065156,
-0.0946596935,
-0.3145548701,
0.096645236,
-0.7506940365,
-0.0340021141,
-0.0787823275,
-0.6073362231,
-0.1790617257,
-0.1779445261,
-0.6486538649,
-0.4030072689,
-0.5100826025,
0.5093890429,
-0.1893413216,
-0.6694008112,
0.1374976337,
-0.0829557031,
0.3509500921,
0.0845902711,
-1.3512589931,
0.4186341166,
0.7551219463,
0.652156055,
-0.3867083788,
-0.6107345819,
-0.140875563,
-0.0958171412,
-0.3413287401,
0.5385138392,
-0.2047430128,
-0.3176567554,
0.3001816273,
0.0634192899,
-0.1970974803,
-0.6176747084,
-0.0364452638,
-0.9797809124,
0.2800736129,
-0.4364644289,
-0.2860835791,
-0.2788335681,
0.1410381794,
-0.4121561646,
0.6831353903,
0.2037183493,
-0.469668895,
0.2396138608,
-0.5679919124,
-0.5898942351,
-0.1721647531,
-0.1851942986,
0.2499950379,
0.3830340505,
-0.0979574546,
0.1702960283,
-0.3073395193,
-0.1004791111,
-0.0241189785,
-0.2731907964,
0.3147726357,
-0.0180966314,
0.9147644043,
-0.0392288417,
-0.2924205661,
-0.1280727983,
-0.4346385002,
0.2090147436,
0.2450755388,
-0.4628497064,
-0.3911201358,
-0.1134163067,
0.1086651236,
0.4127138853,
0.3850114644,
-0.2519582212,
0.2714570165,
-0.4470312893,
0.2086196691,
0.4871099293,
-0.2689020932,
0.9291460514,
-0.062643595,
0.4883546233,
0.3188152909,
-0.0942723453,
-0.1843844056,
-0.4193630815,
-0.989479959,
0.3892799318,
0.5096529722,
0.7440927029,
-0.8484461308,
0.096221216,
-0.2061858475,
-0.0299316756,
-0.2501325607,
0.5332124829,
0.5995019078,
0.3659369051,
0.3424553871,
-0.2517269552,
-0.4416735172,
-1.1903312206,
-0.3807767034,
-0.2201956958,
0.0532372817,
0.1007418782,
0.1168145314,
-0.3497816026,
0.695843339,
-0.0663094819,
0.0251703281,
-0.6386351585,
0.3274883628,
0.1331544667,
0.6372840405,
0.8087428212,
-0.6777161956,
-0.6080028415,
0.0581761748,
-0.668982029,
0.0681253225,
-0.0931571722,
-0.2144526541,
0.3480440378,
0.5983569622,
-0.5384935737,
0.3163184822,
0.5982294679,
-0.2187348455,
0.1745365709,
-0.3984053433,
-0.3091526031,
-0.9603011012,
0.0071263057,
-0.2347807139,
-0.3339817524,
-1.0496511459,
-0.3005582988,
0.1612827778,
0.4207856357,
-0.507697165,
0.6543816328,
-0.6758102179,
-0.6163426042,
-0.4718553126,
0.1869141161,
-0.2270874232,
0.5966084599,
0.3378172815,
0.5539813042,
0.640219748,
-0.62147367,
0.0116170533,
-0.0857996717,
-0.3118770421,
0.2785299122,
-0.6692355871,
0.638748467,
-0.2906196117,
0.1275340468,
-0.943896234,
0.1630565077,
0.2848593295,
-0.5356045365,
0.5745369792,
-0.0218907353,
-0.3798229098,
0.083367005,
0.1101267859,
0.7017831802,
0.528527379,
-0.5007265806,
0.3076793253,
0.3044806123,
-0.2877114713,
-0.4806084037,
-1.0022675991,
0.095368214,
0.0522933044,
-0.4104481936,
0.1511525214,
0.1503700018,
-0.3535867631,
-0.1752250046,
0.2452961355,
-0.1963112205,
0.0539148599,
-0.0747423023,
0.2061675936,
-0.4529204667,
0.1662900746,
0.0397335105,
-0.1679474115,
0.2369430661,
-0.3618909717,
0.6024087667,
0.1397561431,
-0.0436750278,
-0.5709132552,
0.2595002949,
0.3903416395,
-0.1229446679,
0.8141394258,
0.490283072,
-0.4537160099,
-0.2280310839,
-0.3235953152,
-0.3269892037,
-0.4190043211,
0.8358177543,
-0.525975585,
-0.6193624139,
0.4147003591,
-0.0058269491,
-0.023818966,
0.3531096876,
0.5412848592,
-0.140684098,
0.9705687165,
0.6763470173,
-0.1716142446,
0.6856743097,
-0.3559727371,
-0.1088063642,
-0.8186067343,
-0.4183520079,
-0.3641162515,
-0.7744501233,
-0.4094840884,
-0.5463958383,
-0.1816934347,
0.3228902519,
-0.075435847,
0.3960353434,
0.1737124622,
0.6905174255,
0.313249588,
0.1827698052,
0.1452720612,
0.3224205673,
-0.1123996675,
-0.3458843529,
-0.6869417429,
-0.1638245285,
1.2434271574,
0.7359702587,
0.3626648188,
0.3657214344,
0.5245136619,
0.1578218192,
0.4834687412,
-0.6896002293,
0.4008744359,
-0.233500585,
-0.5135443807,
-0.1901601106,
-0.1709012836,
-0.9962364435,
0.2826505601,
-0.0135259693,
-0.859431088,
0.4525566697,
0.0475933887,
-0.4057345986,
-0.0182530992,
-0.543107748,
0.6592068076,
-0.8080177307,
-0.5629751086,
-0.6107477546,
-0.8037828803,
0.3564006686,
-0.3303795457,
0.1124921814,
0.1956987828,
-0.4413942993,
0.5407605767,
0.1742051542,
0.6474608183,
-0.421325922,
-0.1513506621,
0.0350163914,
0.3288472295,
0.4214615524,
-0.058985237,
-0.0795752108,
0.3416315615,
-0.3355429471,
-0.5057089329,
-0.7495741844,
0.4834097624,
-0.9650939107,
-0.49557212,
-0.2823722064,
-0.7281242609,
-0.4420264065,
0.1631019562,
0.1839750558,
0.0295742005,
-0.1872338653,
0.0034338622,
0.6107183695,
-0.2184823453,
0.4870134592,
0.786080718,
-0.7843684554,
-0.2764769495,
0.5623669624,
0.0495889187,
0.7541918159,
0.2291738838,
0.0321204662,
-0.5796360373,
-0.78964746,
-0.3864285946,
0.3251264393,
-0.6774421334,
0.2709305882,
-0.4489165246,
-0.2664614618,
-0.4989362061,
0.2273153812,
-0.2875420451,
-0.6181470156,
-0.4384581447,
-0.2260447741,
-0.2269120663,
1.0849833488,
-0.1659618467,
0.5050479174,
-0.786280334,
0.3171729445,
0.3891419172,
0.0507950038,
-0.1501591206,
-0.9802498817,
-0.4046050012,
0.3043648601,
0.1341088116,
-0.7900976539,
0.2168527097,
0.2295612097,
0.7513580322,
0.3986079395,
-0.7086184621,
0.3697376549,
-0.3995679617,
0.6042818427,
0.5088911653,
-0.6226211786,
0.1839954555,
-0.2764831185,
0.1665392667,
0.5360702276,
0.5093593001,
-0.5239322186,
0.3352820873,
-0.3639422357,
-0.4931525886,
0.9797098637,
-0.0690146312,
0.291311264,
0.2652669251,
0.4610588849,
0.0918199122,
0.0543402545,
-0.7869122624,
-0.260270685,
0.1226245984,
0.1826267987,
-0.6675081253,
-0.5542596579,
0.0081871096,
-0.4751987755,
0.3403244019,
-0.0774850026,
0.1662368774,
0.1147214323,
-0.5282120705,
0.0669267774,
0.0845011547,
0.9128462672,
0.6933732033,
0.0078359498,
0.3225272,
0.3973302543,
-0.1918879896,
0.198981747,
-0.1752848327,
0.0105627179,
0.0183565393,
0.2872421145,
0.8806142807,
0.3467191458,
-0.2744743824,
0.350271523,
0.0029348924,
-0.1815221608,
-0.2080244869,
-0.0368867815,
0.5411974788,
0.4820895493,
0.0924491361,
-0.0043574609,
-0.0302733164,
-0.7121381164,
0.2020014077,
0.2945151925,
-0.2769765258,
-0.6924080849,
0.3710938096,
0.2553379536,
-0.5968244076,
0.6998170614,
-0.0197948106,
-0.8165103197,
0.8105149865,
0.9632533193,
0.9948090911,
-0.2810586095,
-0.0906703621,
0.4974965751,
0.5090278387,
-0.083742395,
0.2793343961,
-0.2912063897,
-0.9955832958,
-0.0839809403,
-0.5006384254,
-0.1035574526,
0.0452158377,
-0.7233564854,
0.330018878,
-0.4750654995,
-0.2993086278,
-0.1763468981,
-0.1707216501,
-0.727540493,
0.0176729113,
0.730163753,
0.9397878647,
-0.8019572496,
1.3896237612,
0.6894830465,
-0.2259559929,
-0.6233206391,
-0.1900427192,
-0.1413387954,
-1.0934069157,
1.2691468,
0.0119072627,
0.033804331,
0.2185200006,
-0.0337742418,
-0.6959674358,
1.0354890823,
0.3475959301,
-0.6965022683,
-0.3109002113,
0.7978667021,
0.8256860375,
-0.5473412871,
0.3228090405,
0.9260184765,
0.4330091476,
-0.1907458305,
-0.950771153,
-0.1546399742,
-0.2371612042,
0.220499143,
-0.10449972,
-0.5531625152,
1.020862937,
-0.3594226837,
0.0503747426,
0.2418979257,
0.651669085,
-0.0487831123,
0.3716753721,
0.4930114746,
0.3700731397,
0.4835427105,
0.2782721519,
0.893020153,
-0.4017668664,
0.2134067267,
1.2431793213,
-0.2006172836,
0.9689216614,
0.7276572585,
-0.2974076569,
0.4729545116,
0.4564777017,
0.4112312794,
0.3984177411,
0.4108971357,
-0.1340693831,
-0.1759134233,
-0.0691249594,
-0.6390958428,
0.5144059062,
0.4990321994,
-0.7612205744,
-0.0847541392,
-0.124427259,
0.0147050442,
-0.1176059023,
-0.2556888461,
0.7704738975,
0.3323973417,
-0.8670749664,
0.4619587064,
-0.0385761708,
0.5626121759,
-0.614561379,
0.2061768323,
-0.4419767559,
0.4193093777,
-0.2869254947,
-0.5644041896,
0.3160645366,
-0.1734013855,
-0.3102131784,
-0.5977298021,
0.7556926012,
-0.8105075359,
-0.2716580927,
0.9094409347,
0.879733026,
0.3391169012,
0.0482335836,
-0.6050363183,
-0.2250397354,
0.078274712,
-0.3286060393,
0.6659744978,
-0.0436530337,
-0.0079284729,
0.1025403291,
0.6640408039,
0.3355415761,
0.5747724175,
0.1628979295,
0.3305618763,
-0.4898078144,
-0.3170428276,
-0.7284281254,
0.359796077,
0.3012405336,
-0.2406454831,
0.5833073258,
0.5922771692,
0.8321698308,
-0.1166292652,
0.5664119124,
0.0306587089,
0.4502878487,
-0.5529226661,
0.8747640252,
-0.689088881,
0.1627615839,
0.3206329346,
-0.8823941946,
-0.1145732179,
0.4080444276,
-0.2920691669,
0.0641703755,
0.7466126084,
0.9281651974,
-0.0532176271,
0.0142318001,
0.3965315819,
0.2171826214,
-0.0492799953,
0.8431299329,
1.0926939249,
-0.4512895644,
0.2091813833,
-0.3961054385,
-0.0823432058,
0.0265033711,
-0.549102962,
-0.8484178185,
-0.2338344008,
-0.0667503402,
-0.3023875952,
0.2042707205,
0.8665566444,
0.5036120415,
-0.7762056589,
-0.7255321145,
-0.2386549413,
0.0447208621,
0.225967899,
-0.0962144732,
-0.0054184743,
-0.6063865423,
-0.843424201,
0.5367487073,
0.0015771822,
0.1439922899,
-0.2586339414,
-0.5232172608,
-0.3929544389,
-0.1698633134,
0.593221724,
0.5162239075,
-0.4939546585,
-0.1234173104,
0.1303132921,
-0.4805650115,
0.0880178139,
1.1403015852,
-0.6623116732,
0.3783920705,
0.8607991934,
0.7864093184,
0.3908118606,
-0.25734061,
0.6800284982,
-0.4525413811,
0.6319710016,
-0.0251803119,
0.2545507252,
0.0271967351,
-0.0321065485,
0.3222236037,
0.4875804186,
-0.3266241848,
-0.7591935396,
0.1458023787,
-0.6240530014,
-0.0890269279,
1.2318276167,
-0.0875725895,
0.0834189802,
-0.0768829435,
-0.0505895056,
0.3528093398,
0.2571334839,
0.4051453471,
0.6829769611,
-0.1040697917,
-0.1267725229,
-0.7873838544,
0.3849580586,
1.0465931892,
-0.8097646236,
-0.3984568119,
0.2159693241,
0.4851195812,
0.1196356639,
0.594134748,
-0.0884332806,
0.4550170898,
-0.0211733859,
0.0279067848,
0.0735567212,
-0.5415455699,
-0.9082481265,
-0.136126563,
0.185294345,
-0.2851943374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.02907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.02907v1 | SelfEvolve: A Code Evolution Framework via Large Language Models | 2023-06-05T14:12:46 | 2023-06-05T14:12:46 | Shuyang Jiang, Yuhao Wang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Large language models (LLMs) have already revolutionized code generation,
after being pretrained on publicly available code data. However, while various
methods have been proposed to augment LLMs with retrieved knowledge and enhance
the quality of code generation, the performance of these retrieval-based
methods is limited by the strength of the retrievers used. In addition, while
LLMs show great emergent ability, they still struggle to produce the correct
code in one turn. To address these challenges, we propose a novel two-step
pipeline, called \autoknow, that leverages LLMs as both knowledge providers and
self-reflective programmers. Unlike retrieval-based methods, \autoknow~obtains
the knowledge from input prompts and generates intermediate code based on the
generated knowledge. After that, \autoknow~asks LLM to act as an expert
programmer to perform debugging for the generated code. This is achieved by
receiving the error message from the interpreter, without requiring special
test cases for correctness verification. We evaluate \autoknow~on three code
generation datasets, including DS-1000 for data science code, HumanEval for
software engineering code, and TransCoder for C++-to-Python translation. Our
empirical experiments show that \autoknow~outperforms strong baselines by a
significant margin on all datasets. We also conduct exhaustive analytical
experiments to validate the effectiveness of the two stages of \autoknow, and
find that both are superior to other prompting-based methods. Further
scalability analysis demonstrates that \autoknow~can be adapted to other more
advanced models, such as GPT-4, and bring consistent efficacy improvement. | [
-0.0407061726,
-0.3608185649,
0.5166114569,
0.3354170918,
-0.0541530922,
0.3367137611,
-0.2265398055,
-0.2935184836,
-0.0726817995,
0.4990941286,
-0.3598535657,
-0.2702487409,
-0.5660306215,
0.2284217179,
-0.4821792543,
0.7834485173,
-0.041139856,
-0.1348594576,
-0.1909724325,
0.0729553029,
-0.4019774199,
-0.1081569046,
-0.2582938373,
-0.1537017822,
0.1715402156,
0.6371967793,
0.4634464383,
1.030454874,
0.239508763,
0.3333977163,
0.3623242676,
-0.0221712161,
-0.3999948204,
0.5704603195,
-0.1583652347,
-0.300470382,
-0.2717835009,
-0.3158914447,
0.372456789,
0.2363086492,
-0.4136994183,
0.348947227,
0.121067591,
0.6486679912,
-0.4622942507,
0.2108043283,
-0.8586786985,
0.0243658405,
-0.0355762839,
-0.2083524764,
-0.0988508463,
-0.2056479156,
-0.0345450304,
-0.3551252484,
0.0214625075,
-0.0731013641,
0.1407950222,
0.75656569,
-0.1470789164,
-0.6071584225,
-0.718911767,
0.478962481,
-0.9217281938,
0.2314566076,
0.0693267956,
0.3472037315,
-0.2477408051,
-0.8623155355,
-0.5156334639,
-0.2235937715,
0.1430426389,
0.1158659384,
-0.1150775477,
-0.1538528949,
0.2492501736,
0.4826539755,
-0.6449805498,
0.3137976825,
-0.4682668149,
-0.0582335591,
0.7670450807,
0.0553414859,
0.3054140806,
-0.4141818583,
-0.204799816,
0.1162213013,
-0.7910234332,
-0.2162278742,
0.1409849524,
0.0383365713,
0.1252742857,
0.4131207764,
-0.2451924682,
0.5999356508,
0.2710655332,
0.1656010449,
0.1980478913,
-0.1312590837,
-0.3194978833,
-0.0814193636,
0.8149461746,
-0.1299430728,
0.201676771,
-0.2064494193,
-0.3340467513,
-0.2627238035,
0.3356900811,
-0.6786422729,
-0.6758875251,
0.3065563738,
-0.4839808643,
-0.4030298889,
-0.304517746,
-0.817415297,
-0.4740978181,
-0.4411654472,
0.5113675594,
-0.1580827683,
-0.5064998269,
0.0238188244,
0.1821508557,
0.3739373088,
0.2556791902,
-0.8946533203,
-0.0876289457,
0.5200346708,
0.6923145056,
-0.1298414618,
-0.281650275,
-0.6277388334,
-0.0635355562,
-0.4934177697,
0.697935462,
-0.4112071693,
-0.3718941212,
-0.0865320414,
-0.2958346605,
0.2232179791,
-0.6019967794,
0.0681933835,
-0.5992944241,
0.2225761265,
-0.1110163778,
-0.6608301997,
0.2713710666,
-0.1487951875,
-0.291864723,
1.1142598391,
0.2859537601,
-0.4752797484,
0.3966372907,
-0.7680416703,
-0.3018912077,
0.4093870521,
-0.4716734886,
-0.2428095043,
0.2553949654,
0.1433684826,
0.5495761037,
-0.1099375188,
0.2582458854,
-0.2414814383,
0.0152173322,
-0.128744632,
-0.0901045054,
0.7467052937,
0.5061953068,
-0.6578917503,
-0.1089895889,
-0.8809351325,
0.1059173569,
0.166272372,
-0.3339718878,
-0.2747422457,
-0.0282266624,
-0.649917841,
0.6071514487,
0.1531585902,
-0.413215667,
0.6050980687,
-0.4424825311,
0.4982204437,
0.8589915633,
0.0859972611,
0.5337616205,
0.1172452271,
0.7735416889,
-0.1273081899,
0.2254904062,
-0.520698905,
-0.2058183849,
-0.8672622442,
-0.0906195566,
0.0473333262,
0.4599595368,
-0.9646867514,
0.3572177887,
-0.0295126513,
-0.4623104632,
-0.5971211195,
0.7025505304,
0.3728252053,
0.5322169662,
0.5428545475,
-0.0636201426,
-0.5287340879,
-0.6948804855,
-0.3169503212,
-0.2417447567,
0.0527028292,
0.1174091771,
0.4364845753,
-0.4910392761,
0.9213774204,
-0.5034438372,
0.0292268414,
-0.0614730455,
0.2842928469,
0.152265951,
0.650781095,
0.3369360566,
-0.3353341818,
-0.5565969944,
-0.151730895,
-0.8080056906,
-0.4495649934,
-0.1477954835,
-0.1936534494,
0.290658772,
0.71116364,
-0.1227895617,
0.1564093977,
0.6164928675,
-0.3340099454,
0.685210526,
-0.5478915572,
-0.0699217543,
-1.0883487463,
0.0780413225,
-0.4256454408,
-0.2328286469,
-0.4213970304,
0.0587864816,
0.2728095353,
-0.0483343638,
0.0100879064,
0.4956561625,
-0.7837629318,
-0.386084199,
-0.4462100863,
-0.0647080839,
-0.1890857667,
0.1550187171,
-0.0249443687,
0.7701390386,
0.7845953107,
-0.6999399662,
0.6392718554,
0.0784772038,
-0.2990155816,
0.2293183655,
-0.6446429491,
0.3792961538,
-0.1292825937,
0.0008745286,
-0.9905579686,
-0.1835730225,
-0.0461995341,
-0.4927971661,
0.4914789796,
-0.2993766665,
-0.5470253825,
-0.6946614385,
0.0833483785,
0.2345660329,
0.7474808693,
-0.9059994221,
0.4319878519,
0.0907350406,
-0.366963923,
-0.5914625525,
-0.4387535453,
0.3710698783,
-0.1107415855,
-0.4602352977,
-0.2150989473,
-0.3769967854,
-0.183971107,
-0.2343527526,
-0.1297743618,
-0.0075601591,
0.1194994599,
0.1008588597,
0.2275726497,
-0.086439684,
0.3935059011,
0.239869386,
-0.3269756436,
0.3108089864,
-0.7960767746,
0.2648357451,
0.0611321256,
-0.4094560742,
-0.0206665173,
0.103290379,
0.6161159277,
-0.5177266598,
0.2463775277,
0.4551827013,
-0.0300984308,
-0.7117605209,
-0.8171637654,
-0.0751641989,
-0.5388752818,
0.2906561196,
-0.3328236938,
-0.7762725949,
0.4915593565,
-0.214015916,
0.3145105541,
0.518658638,
0.680380404,
-0.0046136845,
0.9546892643,
0.66775769,
-0.0077308882,
0.2671890557,
-0.4168228507,
0.1428513676,
-0.6889680624,
-0.2280710489,
-0.4071684182,
0.0132478904,
-0.3919092417,
-0.5409947038,
0.2223148495,
0.2066293955,
-0.2485255748,
0.5625218749,
-0.7107220292,
0.5389947891,
0.3817570508,
-0.314938724,
0.5032980442,
-0.1512382776,
-0.2037335485,
0.0568243489,
-0.9261664748,
-0.2039449662,
1.199103713,
0.4941561818,
0.9624140263,
0.0328925774,
1.1221271753,
0.3999089599,
0.4722563922,
-0.4980718493,
0.196011439,
0.0519274063,
-0.4540255368,
-0.3366085887,
-0.5867512822,
-0.6722112894,
0.0332281329,
0.1492601633,
-0.3523775339,
0.4360947609,
0.4268535078,
-0.5406915545,
0.0071442127,
-0.7478049994,
0.8060885668,
-0.5310909152,
-0.3842905164,
-0.1628681719,
-0.5749845505,
0.3507012129,
-0.3821786642,
0.4207434654,
0.1845232248,
-0.0489749573,
0.5671682358,
-0.3695470989,
0.5213773251,
-0.3899519145,
-0.5972605348,
0.2969977856,
0.5631027818,
0.6803102493,
0.1716465056,
0.0190973207,
-0.2473451048,
-0.0806592181,
-0.3715003133,
-0.8123292923,
0.8308216333,
-0.611446023,
-0.5128750205,
-0.2014173716,
-0.287261039,
-0.0899368897,
0.31273368,
0.240663588,
0.6057521105,
0.2922919393,
0.0485092849,
0.6876432896,
-0.3553183973,
0.6783514619,
0.8662512898,
-0.4356795549,
-0.4019583762,
0.8291650414,
0.2058462799,
0.3844565451,
-0.081122987,
0.2486815602,
-0.3860023618,
-0.5882199407,
-0.5721054673,
0.1637599468,
-0.7665391564,
-0.5289466381,
-0.674041748,
-0.1760327071,
-0.4792310596,
-0.1661680937,
-0.6097368598,
-0.344512552,
-0.127230078,
-0.0778059736,
0.1745613366,
1.0726903677,
-0.5229151249,
-0.158536762,
-0.7538926005,
0.2033647746,
0.6837106347,
0.480155319,
0.1462946981,
-0.674869597,
-0.4699009359,
-0.0946463719,
-0.1012795344,
-0.655217886,
0.4793269634,
0.1574193984,
0.5889173746,
0.2668544948,
0.2091210634,
0.6843354702,
-0.484483093,
0.6488726139,
0.1570421755,
-1.0021936893,
0.7398773432,
-0.3300635815,
0.4215273559,
0.4542080462,
0.1208378226,
-0.3198182285,
-0.5805645585,
-0.6137350202,
-0.752076745,
0.4695602357,
0.2467010468,
0.1283233017,
-0.0747137144,
0.7667894363,
0.221633777,
0.1346488744,
-0.7086979747,
-0.1710124165,
-0.5332850814,
-0.1899733245,
-0.0099007329,
-0.2453410625,
0.1802813262,
-0.3493056297,
0.5856217146,
-0.3686139882,
0.3487389684,
0.3782821298,
-0.4146839678,
-0.3087616265,
0.0725720301,
0.3098170757,
0.9431737065,
0.2170838267,
0.0601812005,
0.1033103094,
-0.2636417747,
0.1262063682,
0.0300188232,
0.0919146016,
-0.2849296331,
0.4758723676,
0.3667857647,
0.0293703396,
-0.5639747381,
0.4711863995,
0.0746358335,
-0.2157316357,
-0.3720955253,
0.3303457499,
-0.0448667482,
0.5933192968,
0.7002456188,
-0.2162810713,
0.2545988858,
-0.4056820869,
0.4513358176,
0.1802942753,
-0.0273193326,
-0.2849887013,
0.6935184002,
0.3288333118,
-0.2703843117,
0.605348289,
-0.4757936299,
-0.6113932133,
0.5441402197,
0.6044458747,
1.0348280668,
-0.432212323,
0.1659195423,
0.4885724485,
0.0135603519,
-0.0328825749,
0.088509433,
-0.3909834921,
-0.4875073731,
-0.7651103735,
-0.7130106688,
0.0423786268,
-0.0664460808,
-0.4455016255,
0.0816720277,
-0.2407815307,
0.283224076,
-0.2760002613,
0.0135382665,
-0.6158863306,
0.0189055316,
0.2661007643,
0.9576700926,
-0.5619430542,
0.9566802979,
0.4923792481,
-0.2499841899,
-0.7488341331,
0.0077503999,
-0.0797248036,
-1.0606976748,
0.9815899134,
-0.1413672119,
-0.0153213078,
0.43917346,
-0.749017477,
-1.0788104534,
1.2939255238,
0.0948373899,
-0.7290201783,
-0.1702360958,
-0.2313496321,
0.6106616855,
-0.5040453076,
0.2455748618,
0.4693714082,
0.2834471464,
0.2017026097,
-0.9694843888,
-0.0202334486,
-0.1012357324,
0.0870649144,
0.0838372037,
-0.5191094875,
0.5246309638,
-0.4889265597,
-0.0513842218,
-0.0349532664,
0.7227638364,
-0.0113248322,
0.0195421185,
0.4173616767,
0.439933598,
0.6192654371,
0.3017604053,
0.7000071406,
-0.5765790939,
0.6884498,
1.2127782106,
-0.1206426397,
0.6305581331,
0.1091868505,
-0.2271101624,
0.7053979039,
0.2764981687,
-0.1309358031,
0.4271816611,
0.3735907972,
0.0509294942,
-0.2848776579,
0.5310050249,
-0.3502788544,
0.6338350773,
0.2075016201,
-0.5310043097,
-0.3519208133,
0.1371161789,
-0.0452711582,
0.0263165999,
-0.2134263963,
0.9604239464,
0.0559701398,
-0.860589087,
0.6124943495,
-0.2587984502,
0.4735646248,
-0.3968042135,
-0.0805617794,
-0.4466772676,
0.2380548269,
-0.2737653553,
-0.7627203465,
0.3876449466,
0.0669038147,
0.0023801506,
-0.3906182051,
0.8188976645,
-0.4666493237,
-0.3095901608,
0.3927339911,
0.6854380369,
0.0372638926,
0.0426998734,
-0.7717734575,
-0.0944217294,
0.1309393793,
-0.2129855752,
0.1933347881,
0.544875443,
0.4869994223,
0.9961571693,
0.5307179689,
0.0576884337,
0.354088366,
-0.0652794018,
0.9444451928,
-0.4450910687,
-0.402551949,
-0.8087310195,
0.5608049035,
-0.0807448477,
-0.1590376496,
0.9901487827,
0.5000032783,
0.4535276592,
0.0071516461,
0.8418414593,
-0.2549983859,
0.5606907606,
-0.4429757893,
0.6137311459,
-0.3786894083,
0.419493705,
-0.3627261817,
-0.9776945114,
-0.1969588995,
0.6423301697,
-0.3596609235,
0.1259036213,
0.4436328411,
0.689635396,
0.0334895961,
-0.3256181777,
0.2664231062,
0.6595781446,
0.538284719,
0.4498638511,
0.8336613774,
-0.2366090715,
0.5169394016,
-0.1170550063,
-0.4118532836,
-0.0880936831,
-0.8805630803,
-0.753203094,
-0.5966562629,
-0.4632276893,
-0.4635826945,
0.0104610613,
0.9824461937,
0.7896431684,
-0.5070803165,
-0.1722265035,
-0.5560985804,
-0.1164594442,
0.1234469861,
-0.2364989817,
0.1407570392,
-0.9609529376,
-0.2696124613,
0.4568404257,
0.3552634716,
-0.0141283218,
-0.8194162846,
-0.4454396069,
0.1369196326,
-0.0063470323,
0.6182842851,
0.5962438583,
-0.4165887535,
-0.1409015805,
0.1167395562,
-0.0222262349,
-0.0600790977,
0.8509027958,
-1.0445768833,
0.9047129154,
0.4858136773,
0.6057717204,
0.3752132058,
-0.064478904,
0.8139654994,
-0.4742756188,
-0.4129907489,
0.3375581503,
0.2166564167,
0.2025146484,
-0.4960757494,
0.3765499592,
0.0674489886,
-1.115033865,
-0.6833155155,
0.2939982116,
-0.2226193249,
-0.3217063248,
1.2958141565,
-0.0960225612,
0.0200722199,
-0.2240274996,
-0.0228912123,
0.0914769098,
-0.2544581592,
1.019449234,
0.4642105401,
-0.2866533399,
-0.3736220598,
-0.4994122684,
0.8459045291,
0.1517389119,
-0.770158112,
0.3760260642,
0.5269818902,
0.5965743661,
0.0954533815,
0.6596417427,
-0.149018243,
0.1980198175,
-0.1803103983,
0.0254839491,
-0.2863637805,
-0.5005940199,
-0.6183404922,
-0.2805824578,
0.3787333965,
0.2213816345
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.