id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05240v1 | Dealing with Semantic Underspecification in Multimodal NLP | 2023-06-08T14:39:24 | 2023-06-08T14:39:24 | Sandro Pezzelle | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Intelligent systems that aim at mastering language as humans do must deal
with its semantic underspecification, namely, the possibility for a linguistic
signal to convey only part of the information needed for communication to
succeed. Consider the usages of the pronoun they, which can leave the gender
and number of its referent(s) underspecified. Semantic underspecification is
not a bug but a crucial language feature that boosts its storage and processing
efficiency. Indeed, human speakers can quickly and effortlessly integrate
semantically-underspecified linguistic signals with a wide range of
non-linguistic information, e.g., the multimodal context, social or cultural
conventions, and shared knowledge. Standard NLP models have, in principle, no
or limited access to such extra information, while multimodal systems grounding
language into other modalities, such as vision, are naturally equipped to
account for this phenomenon. However, we show that they struggle with it, which
could negatively affect their performance and lead to harmful consequences when
used for applications. In this position paper, we argue that our community
should be aware of semantic underspecification if it aims to develop language
technology that can successfully interact with human users. We discuss some
applications where mastering it is crucial and outline a few directions toward
achieving this goal. | [
-0.6273514032,
-0.3265497684,
0.638594389,
0.2918340862,
-0.332156986,
0.1458127797,
-0.2376609892,
-0.6737125516,
0.1927668303,
0.5006132722,
-0.550431788,
-0.2506620288,
-0.7656378746,
-0.0597110242,
-0.480181545,
0.6176449656,
0.0591971204,
-0.2016694248,
-0.5780822039,
-0.2131425738,
-0.5702463984,
-0.6355364919,
-0.2307961583,
-0.5806318521,
0.3936074376,
0.3803092539,
0.795784235,
0.3814016879,
0.4975499511,
0.3760472536,
-0.1368778646,
0.3658862412,
-0.1821360439,
0.071316503,
-0.329626292,
-0.3760786355,
-0.4035922289,
-0.0157046244,
0.6990187764,
0.959363997,
0.0964381173,
0.06592419,
0.0807225108,
0.4431555867,
-0.7989058495,
0.246900782,
-0.6674495935,
0.1923139244,
-0.2347272784,
-0.3919079304,
-0.082999967,
-0.0541241467,
0.0303001646,
-0.6844748259,
-0.0701933578,
-0.0629124939,
0.4820237458,
0.3498069346,
-0.5441866517,
-0.0042684348,
-0.8165929317,
0.9206166267,
-0.4369770586,
0.5378423333,
0.6611192822,
0.044287134,
-0.2917470336,
-0.2948492467,
-0.6012537479,
-0.1998547018,
-0.1214406565,
0.0287006553,
-0.3020426333,
0.1838228852,
0.2404000014,
-0.0848006234,
-0.1567740142,
0.0953505412,
-0.6533503532,
-0.3463065922,
0.5140913129,
0.0878045112,
0.4035781026,
-0.159642294,
-0.6205681562,
0.2997275889,
-0.6401716471,
-0.3925324082,
0.240438804,
0.3777854443,
0.3766351342,
0.6631218791,
-0.335474968,
0.3348827362,
-0.1705462337,
0.1704318672,
0.4189090729,
-0.4816358984,
0.1024276838,
-0.0032111816,
0.7054949999,
0.4111996293,
0.4759808183,
-0.2864594758,
-0.1936449707,
0.5837526917,
0.5989104509,
-0.2352090329,
-0.0355492793,
0.218236208,
-0.1339931339,
0.0649086833,
-0.1775728315,
-0.64249897,
-0.3962849677,
-0.3385001719,
0.4986467361,
-0.4915542006,
-0.5869759917,
0.191338554,
-0.267955631,
-0.0594517589,
0.3483820558,
-1.2829114199,
0.447412461,
0.746068418,
0.4943580925,
0.1153801456,
-0.4123318493,
-0.109591186,
0.3780150712,
-0.212205261,
0.8121977448,
-0.6197481155,
-0.3914038837,
-0.2353929579,
-0.2913986444,
-0.2797537148,
-0.4527730346,
0.5449180007,
-0.3104550242,
0.1410630941,
-0.261477232,
-0.5927038789,
0.0358060002,
-0.0974171758,
-0.2320495993,
0.6534690857,
-0.3659147918,
-0.6889688969,
0.4338085353,
-0.734837532,
-0.2893269062,
0.3005137742,
-0.1549217552,
0.0072096847,
0.385548234,
0.1044004187,
0.4311414063,
0.1489375681,
0.118950218,
-0.0899586678,
-0.3594422638,
0.3770870566,
-0.3461665213,
0.4457733333,
0.1875673383,
-0.1906429678,
0.0417540446,
-0.5790414214,
0.193533659,
-0.17584683,
-0.1573809832,
-0.6572755575,
0.2098008692,
0.0392209142,
0.3679278493,
0.2033370137,
-0.6008844972,
-0.0171451736,
-0.3955823481,
0.3791905344,
0.5716520548,
-0.3119076788,
0.6990910769,
-0.0569047779,
0.2475391179,
0.1783217043,
0.3804253638,
0.0506599732,
-0.6481303573,
-0.9079133272,
-0.1959956586,
0.2338768393,
0.6486410499,
-0.783175528,
0.3073931336,
-0.1377198398,
-0.2766478658,
-0.5367416739,
0.4693943262,
0.4105405211,
0.2133395672,
0.5218051076,
-0.4563085735,
-0.5655723214,
-1.0090317726,
-0.1432811916,
-0.3203326166,
-0.1388048977,
0.0737070516,
0.5655712485,
-0.4598676562,
1.0766266584,
-0.2609625161,
-0.7128455043,
-0.3410766423,
0.1961029768,
-0.1775084585,
0.6811520457,
0.3094983697,
-1.1008112431,
0.2057915777,
-0.2363540232,
-0.8041056991,
-0.2374488562,
-0.039349135,
0.0567312576,
0.0136919534,
0.5101043582,
-0.7453633547,
0.3271945417,
0.465757966,
-0.3075166047,
0.1638998687,
-0.4185554087,
0.0250244159,
-0.6961424351,
-0.0856322348,
0.0591343567,
-0.1655045152,
-0.5774868131,
0.1316706836,
-0.1222208962,
0.0002732831,
-0.6135571003,
0.4750835299,
-0.4671890438,
-0.1553377956,
-0.4304631054,
0.3929133713,
-0.1420981735,
0.3896787465,
0.1809112579,
0.4297657013,
0.3589054942,
-0.539734304,
0.5227869153,
0.1692850441,
-0.2454023361,
0.5554833412,
-0.4981881082,
-0.1678679287,
-0.3066835105,
0.1674256772,
-0.6496537328,
0.0083021512,
0.4634080231,
-0.5513202548,
0.0722123235,
0.1362900734,
-0.598826766,
-0.3051528335,
-0.1763373911,
0.3509601653,
0.1981709301,
0.0854923874,
0.4875596464,
0.6047094464,
0.2400984466,
-0.7666239738,
-0.8588799238,
0.2364579886,
-0.2917852104,
-0.5555779338,
0.2650766671,
0.1846126318,
-0.3081968725,
0.1352622658,
-0.0986354649,
-0.2044294029,
0.2954413295,
0.4960053265,
-0.0148584694,
-0.0087099625,
0.5077680349,
-0.0155974803,
-0.6965822577,
-0.1794756651,
-0.3012684286,
0.3302977383,
-0.1215538383,
-0.5535463095,
-0.6311155558,
0.7784626484,
0.4964855015,
-0.2685610354,
0.7053206563,
0.6793463826,
-0.3886886537,
0.0343982875,
-0.5083931088,
-0.3131082356,
-0.4129601419,
0.3037233949,
-0.3265815675,
-0.6901276708,
0.53722471,
-0.268171221,
-0.2355528474,
0.3956258893,
0.2305036485,
-0.5325883627,
1.016372323,
1.1075373888,
0.0888605863,
0.5916675329,
-0.1364678442,
-0.0367584378,
-0.7954044938,
-0.2555306256,
-0.4557270706,
-0.2769014537,
-0.5585902929,
-0.3784778714,
0.2668898702,
0.066335462,
0.2009199411,
0.6059129834,
-0.1183234528,
0.5318325162,
0.8248720765,
0.1381125301,
0.4203767776,
-0.2357904166,
-0.1300289035,
-0.2727481723,
-0.7502900362,
-0.5477215648,
0.7287613153,
0.3881902993,
0.7286126018,
0.0078379791,
0.6757569313,
0.3875873089,
-0.2207665443,
-0.5706412196,
0.7469667196,
-0.3493431509,
-0.6569183469,
-0.0968448147,
-0.3156047463,
-0.8252705336,
0.4942651987,
-0.5284301639,
-0.8871649504,
0.4983921945,
0.3670867383,
-0.2508531809,
0.0909132361,
-0.7878736258,
0.9864087701,
-0.0856191367,
-0.1637732387,
-0.6812797785,
-0.7820695043,
0.1422920823,
-0.1011700928,
0.3454705775,
-0.3764084578,
-0.1802132279,
0.5243445635,
-0.3379073739,
1.3050947189,
-0.1469881386,
0.1076946855,
0.0549194477,
-0.3068736196,
-0.0651096106,
-0.3281458616,
0.4079824686,
0.2781953216,
0.0550968908,
-0.4054764807,
-0.4983049631,
0.5052413344,
-0.790928185,
-0.4924661517,
-0.3909588456,
-0.2733644545,
-0.3156664073,
0.0751570687,
0.1742211133,
0.6124035716,
0.0703629926,
0.1383931339,
0.7316513658,
-0.1189507842,
0.21156618,
0.1774333864,
-0.1598612517,
-0.0184698068,
1.0340834856,
0.2962596118,
0.4278794527,
0.2691042423,
0.1821691096,
-0.3330751657,
-0.5856932402,
-0.5051239133,
0.1988198161,
-0.9499771595,
-0.0138751343,
-0.7631493807,
-0.0030025451,
-0.3160617948,
-0.0382966548,
-0.4369425774,
-0.6396054626,
-0.4047536254,
0.0689121783,
0.0965178385,
0.4445499778,
-0.1759486198,
0.4592766762,
-0.8907603621,
0.6040241718,
0.3824025989,
0.2944092155,
-0.1602155119,
-0.1644686162,
-0.0973696187,
0.144047156,
-0.0942886025,
-0.6378290057,
0.1174360663,
0.4212357402,
0.9671720862,
0.2093672901,
0.151301831,
0.5755422115,
-0.414321363,
0.5260817409,
0.0809823051,
-1.0935070515,
0.5279811621,
-0.2243638933,
0.6229891777,
0.5098680854,
0.518692255,
-0.9701715708,
-0.84783113,
-0.516402483,
-1.1404787302,
0.6344726682,
0.0812003016,
0.4932675064,
-0.0684841201,
0.0174154863,
-0.1431407034,
0.4622362256,
-0.7482562661,
0.1070684195,
-0.3381504714,
-0.0601458661,
0.090165548,
-0.4864135087,
-0.1727405787,
-0.0554262884,
0.5256436467,
-0.1125910804,
0.2982284427,
-0.1314191371,
-0.3344911635,
-0.0546486974,
0.401586771,
0.6290518045,
0.8280590773,
-0.0452839956,
0.3220995665,
0.0087054502,
-0.447812587,
-0.111060746,
-0.297498405,
-0.1770328581,
-0.2862761617,
0.5260956883,
0.6369658113,
0.419665724,
-0.5883501172,
0.6994187236,
0.097355701,
0.0666871369,
-0.2929286659,
0.1229501963,
-0.0970850736,
0.4301711321,
0.5567969084,
0.491561234,
0.1057222337,
-0.6854418516,
0.1899942309,
0.3811124563,
-0.4244364798,
-0.2500244677,
0.5693517327,
0.4279493988,
0.1013250798,
0.5660203099,
0.0732364431,
-0.7150995731,
0.3132272959,
0.346178472,
0.8214244246,
-0.027719235,
0.20058918,
-0.1661958396,
0.5834879875,
-0.0928090215,
0.2048323601,
-0.4621878564,
-1.1827157736,
-0.5765195489,
-0.5860160589,
-0.3109873533,
-0.5556086302,
-0.3021887243,
0.1588629484,
-0.322581321,
-0.4087306261,
0.1676101685,
-0.3209542036,
-0.2958583832,
0.2194760442,
0.4892619848,
0.6701610088,
-1.1516419649,
0.8927221894,
0.6099769473,
-0.4482138455,
-0.0963069573,
-0.1480632573,
0.2135346532,
-0.5530128479,
1.0209774971,
0.0987732261,
-0.5642300844,
-0.1568365544,
-0.2787793875,
-0.600976944,
0.5907990932,
0.3378103077,
-0.1111964211,
0.0638331249,
0.3065895438,
0.7097739577,
-0.1542295516,
0.1977631599,
0.2319354266,
0.5807191133,
0.2727348506,
-1.2355111837,
-0.1797527224,
-0.0424380004,
0.1377443075,
0.2835884094,
-0.4230310321,
0.5097630024,
-0.262539655,
-0.4512931705,
-0.0773582533,
0.6453163624,
-0.3292927742,
0.154299885,
0.5710298419,
0.3421141207,
0.3985516727,
-0.1237650365,
0.7034590244,
0.2195532173,
0.0995022953,
0.8049894571,
-0.0837649629,
0.9750742912,
0.6559527516,
-0.0429032594,
0.0815399513,
0.228286773,
0.3304797709,
0.4754101932,
0.0475288704,
-0.4207980335,
-0.6289677024,
-0.3368949592,
-0.2214015424,
0.8446842432,
0.7096555233,
-0.1699136794,
-0.2273507416,
0.3434411883,
-0.2148142308,
0.4772405922,
-0.367805779,
0.8861820698,
0.0988423228,
-0.1303402632,
0.3917975426,
-0.1159706935,
0.9457007647,
-0.6370940804,
0.1331781,
0.0480765663,
0.2765014768,
-0.4243467152,
-0.8296557069,
0.7820923328,
-0.3878265321,
-0.2307447642,
-0.6072095037,
0.9037839174,
-0.5918237567,
-0.3855029345,
0.55624336,
0.6048334241,
0.3030703068,
-0.1029900908,
-0.5330386162,
0.0803637505,
-0.3074996769,
0.1831659973,
0.2508316338,
0.2860584259,
-0.4662228823,
1.0812613964,
0.3285125196,
0.2356510311,
0.3113189638,
0.073705785,
0.8906806111,
-0.533859551,
-0.1800800562,
-0.8391885161,
0.406006366,
0.0572937429,
-0.2629354894,
0.7459641099,
0.0431607701,
0.9998469949,
0.1415516883,
0.3702303171,
0.0529808216,
0.3494613469,
-0.3962538242,
0.5776520967,
-0.5771372914,
0.1014120653,
-0.6269682646,
-0.7983275056,
-0.6666027308,
0.5530250669,
-0.3895993233,
-0.1389245689,
0.4162634015,
0.3971888423,
-0.14250049,
0.1202048436,
0.4957515597,
-0.0573783554,
-0.1037213281,
0.4419742823,
1.0523591042,
-0.1916422695,
0.4945608377,
-0.3405892551,
-0.0841691867,
-0.1886774898,
-0.8337986469,
-0.5295456648,
-0.7640542388,
-0.3797933161,
0.2844021916,
0.1637812108,
1.0000970364,
0.7507358789,
-0.6781391501,
-0.1469525546,
0.2514225245,
0.246927768,
-0.2112070173,
-0.1412805915,
-0.1553327292,
-0.3029184937,
-0.6737367511,
0.5052574873,
0.4113758206,
0.0952051282,
-0.4753249586,
0.3774739206,
-0.3504498601,
-0.1627679318,
0.6666986942,
0.325409919,
-0.7640684247,
-0.4434779882,
-0.3126971126,
0.041778069,
-0.1273266524,
0.8017742038,
-0.9923180342,
0.525432229,
0.4497244954,
0.5428830385,
0.0983039513,
-0.1304462999,
0.7049475312,
-0.9923141003,
0.3972348571,
0.2541231215,
0.3250829279,
0.3987547457,
-0.1812823713,
0.103497833,
0.5122414231,
-0.3428052664,
-0.5378509164,
0.3977030218,
-0.7121086717,
-0.4120402336,
0.8101854324,
0.1167674512,
-0.1779023856,
-0.4834273458,
-0.125511542,
-0.0477865115,
-0.4544667006,
0.5120106339,
0.6182568073,
-0.1237756163,
-0.2354107648,
-0.6533135772,
0.3971011341,
0.4434217513,
-0.4492664039,
0.1882360131,
0.6207710505,
-0.0205939077,
0.5929384232,
0.7078328133,
-0.0863631368,
0.2533722222,
0.10180825,
0.1839050353,
0.0687934086,
-0.5295723081,
-0.2496257275,
0.1747417897,
0.0251726769,
-0.3941883445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05443v1 | PIXIU: A Large Language Model, Instruction Data and Evaluation Benchmark for Finance | 2023-06-08T14:20:29 | 2023-06-08T14:20:29 | Qianqian Xie, Weiguang Han, Xiao Zhang, Yanzhao Lai, Min Peng, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Jimin Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although large language models (LLMs) has shown great performance on natural
language processing (NLP) in the financial domain, there are no publicly
available financial tailtored LLMs, instruction tuning datasets, and evaluation
benchmarks, which is critical for continually pushing forward the open-source
development of financial artificial intelligence (AI). This paper introduces
PIXIU, a comprehensive framework including the first financial LLM based on
fine-tuning LLaMA with instruction data, the first instruction data with 136K
data samples to support the fine-tuning, and an evaluation benchmark with 5
tasks and 9 datasets. We first construct the large-scale multi-task instruction
data considering a variety of financial tasks, financial document types, and
financial data modalities. We then propose a financial LLM called FinMA by
fine-tuning LLaMA with the constructed dataset to be able to follow
instructions for various financial tasks. To support the evaluation of
financial LLMs, we propose a standardized benchmark that covers a set of
critical financial tasks, including five financial NLP tasks and one financial
prediction task. With this benchmark, we conduct a detailed analysis of FinMA
and several existing LLMs, uncovering their strengths and weaknesses in
handling critical financial tasks. The model, datasets, benchmark, and
experimental results are open-sourced to facilitate future research in
financial AI. | [
-0.0351410992,
-0.94742167,
0.1657152176,
0.5177844167,
0.0532120802,
0.132255733,
-0.5705204606,
-0.2370498031,
-0.2774420381,
0.63565135,
-0.3428781629,
-0.7751608491,
-0.6062812805,
-0.2023890615,
-0.3781599402,
1.0077213049,
0.0911905169,
0.0846016705,
-0.1424388736,
0.0981034935,
-0.3737172782,
-0.2705909312,
-1.1749132872,
-0.2777982354,
0.2508948445,
0.5932357907,
0.6782602072,
0.6514462233,
0.7344084978,
0.2929483354,
0.2593666911,
0.0065264152,
-0.4590071738,
-0.3075428903,
-0.1146825179,
-0.5782105923,
-0.8207454681,
0.171793133,
0.7397921681,
0.715303719,
-0.2784335613,
0.2912151515,
-0.0405217484,
0.9243072271,
-0.8146025538,
0.7815141678,
-0.3629020154,
-0.0710957795,
-0.1890023053,
0.1041307449,
-0.5252241492,
-0.3982892036,
0.2300565094,
-0.6839888692,
-0.2392652333,
0.293007642,
0.6472978592,
0.4938423932,
-0.2458496839,
-0.3856434524,
-0.5979256034,
0.7999262214,
-0.6380091906,
0.3169967234,
0.4380678833,
0.1803942472,
-0.1625183225,
-0.607732892,
-0.3710811734,
-0.2821348011,
0.092890881,
-0.0539404526,
-0.5239281058,
-0.1108945757,
0.0856869966,
0.3219440579,
-0.2917268574,
0.262049973,
-0.3457325697,
0.208689943,
0.851700604,
0.080296807,
0.0032725811,
0.4693162739,
-0.3710837364,
-0.4904502332,
-0.726723671,
-0.0819925517,
0.374291718,
0.3315965831,
-0.198215127,
0.5130114555,
-0.1910202801,
0.6165927649,
-0.1666987687,
-0.3598624766,
0.2689398229,
0.0313676931,
-0.5203070641,
0.2573570311,
0.8691465259,
0.3213274777,
0.3058553934,
-0.2431125194,
-0.3675183058,
-0.2536045611,
0.2150598466,
-0.5110357404,
-0.1465383917,
0.2189686,
-0.3431951404,
-0.014134828,
0.0467956141,
-0.7475504279,
-0.2844540477,
-0.5533878207,
0.2893019021,
-0.5605581999,
-0.0768602118,
0.1662644148,
0.2634934783,
0.4869451225,
0.1595850587,
-0.869649291,
0.7255635858,
1.4836847782,
0.7288475037,
-0.2893504798,
-0.3506483138,
-0.9621569514,
0.0783182606,
-0.4128700197,
0.8059535027,
-0.755646646,
-0.2035478801,
-0.153580144,
-0.038672898,
-0.3707684577,
-0.5950777531,
0.4244082272,
-0.1908597648,
-0.0489043109,
0.181109935,
-0.7852357626,
-0.3926830888,
0.0687560216,
-0.6039663553,
0.8560405374,
0.1362190545,
-0.5083841681,
0.2154113352,
-1.1260210276,
-0.4914917052,
0.1137862951,
0.0327294953,
-0.6799320579,
-0.1243074089,
-0.0176721569,
0.5586567521,
-0.8104584813,
0.4589509368,
-0.3151059449,
-0.7416327596,
0.315656662,
-0.5390034318,
0.3657881916,
0.1297826618,
-0.4525070488,
0.1878588051,
-0.8701613545,
-0.3162878156,
0.2174367309,
0.0925441906,
-0.39230147,
0.3265124857,
0.1025405675,
-0.5278337002,
0.5949658751,
-0.3870804906,
0.2622863948,
-0.3841126263,
0.6240337491,
0.8219328523,
-0.4772850871,
0.3828429282,
-0.3974402249,
0.2903288901,
-0.3901204467,
0.1485928893,
-0.2863702774,
-0.3647497296,
-0.6459762454,
-0.310462743,
0.2738481164,
0.712012291,
0.0492575355,
0.3358193636,
0.0234616809,
-0.5397694111,
-0.3796022832,
0.2679515779,
0.1533012986,
0.3899239004,
0.1416711956,
0.3069373667,
-0.1080931202,
-1.0437173843,
-0.0216147359,
0.0800550804,
-0.088922739,
0.2425595075,
0.4049828053,
-0.3125469983,
0.5968716145,
-0.6589173675,
-0.3721324205,
-0.0767249912,
0.3746638,
0.4937771559,
0.5698955655,
0.6561174393,
-0.749322772,
-0.2327172458,
0.284129262,
-0.3911603391,
0.0549415797,
-0.3395718634,
-0.1932439357,
0.0502343588,
0.4080248177,
-0.1395260543,
0.3730258048,
0.5000430346,
-0.3781726956,
0.2000713646,
-0.3867623806,
-0.0562100038,
-0.9232649207,
0.2980113626,
0.1749043316,
-0.0998779163,
-0.2776876986,
0.1256574839,
0.146906957,
-0.1380110979,
-0.1347759664,
0.6926537752,
-0.1472254544,
-0.3908031583,
-0.4980161488,
0.2180579901,
-0.2676103413,
0.5942691565,
0.0020458251,
1.0161782503,
0.6899749041,
-0.5343221426,
0.6274929047,
-0.0585734695,
-0.4263726771,
0.4899535477,
-0.9302808046,
0.149425149,
0.117745772,
-0.2095250487,
-0.7603062391,
-0.073660247,
0.392011553,
0.0761983767,
0.1898632944,
0.1677535921,
-0.5917921662,
-0.1360129863,
0.0089676203,
0.3106324971,
0.162708059,
-0.3903823495,
0.6042299867,
0.366009295,
-0.6154700518,
-0.5938441157,
-0.2522185445,
0.0008773999,
-0.3425764143,
-0.4325946867,
0.3555421531,
-0.135457024,
-0.5014193654,
-0.052583579,
0.0993118882,
-0.0633996278,
0.4810504317,
0.3246845007,
0.7933188677,
-0.4638520777,
0.275867939,
0.0527043566,
-0.3433399498,
0.060384132,
-0.3417865932,
0.5286540389,
-0.6481947899,
-0.2531652153,
-0.4564402401,
-0.0013895538,
0.3665942848,
-0.3807596564,
0.8016052246,
0.3002492189,
-0.4261370897,
-0.0461641774,
-0.5693570375,
0.5209419727,
-0.4495708644,
0.1596574634,
-0.2038362622,
-0.9266732931,
0.2874444723,
-0.3816395998,
0.547147274,
0.689017117,
0.6212941408,
0.1242530569,
0.4118917584,
0.8457784653,
-0.4133326411,
0.5439916253,
-0.2958739698,
0.0708737299,
-0.4404217303,
-0.1461809278,
-0.4797687829,
-0.5056591034,
-0.2457244247,
-0.4136303961,
0.1961933225,
0.1616971344,
-0.4863319993,
0.4591327906,
-0.2636891305,
0.6870352626,
0.7172918916,
-0.2021502554,
0.2718483806,
-0.1928639263,
0.1137383878,
0.2317620218,
-0.3563384116,
-0.6058885455,
1.5016872883,
0.512509346,
0.7669367194,
-0.3231375813,
0.3213258684,
0.5623198748,
0.489967227,
-0.677033484,
0.1082968935,
-0.4282754362,
-0.0697024167,
-0.4229912162,
-0.5253490806,
-0.7720700502,
-0.2245763838,
-0.2215048969,
-0.7404034734,
-0.0943256021,
-0.1414651275,
-0.7169979215,
0.1134558842,
-0.800919354,
1.1202178001,
-0.5902019739,
-0.3749555051,
-0.3656385541,
-0.0767632946,
0.4080298245,
-0.4946000278,
0.3766503632,
-0.3964235485,
-0.2436634898,
0.7638104558,
-0.4709706903,
0.7492804527,
0.1920876205,
-0.3569432795,
0.2465198487,
-0.2470798492,
0.4396008253,
0.2949730754,
-0.2689577639,
0.3464744985,
0.1045552045,
-0.4805852175,
-0.4731969833,
0.8814805746,
-0.8014124036,
-0.3332599103,
-0.3081687987,
-0.5837419033,
-0.1668124348,
0.1254072934,
-0.2309438139,
-0.1084808186,
-0.235521093,
0.3799576759,
0.3609340489,
-0.3048304319,
0.4584781229,
0.5034089088,
-0.0471635535,
-0.4553313553,
1.1512818336,
-0.2915839851,
-0.2133352757,
0.6159332991,
0.3580087125,
-0.1260798424,
-0.2380098552,
-0.2704513073,
0.2986820936,
-0.2195633352,
-0.2734907269,
-0.1006381586,
-0.1804318577,
-0.484927386,
-0.2379983217,
-0.8734614849,
-0.080210641,
-0.1889132559,
-0.0386043862,
0.5236288905,
0.8288421035,
-0.0128988195,
0.4937146604,
-0.7695310712,
0.3257962167,
0.202251479,
0.7968418002,
0.1008430496,
-0.0709793717,
-0.420889169,
0.116211094,
-0.0582952201,
-0.2312249541,
0.2485372722,
0.2103471607,
0.5102242231,
0.8175081611,
0.1407503933,
0.5576146841,
-0.1853146404,
0.1710776687,
0.0799487755,
-1.048178196,
0.6271506548,
-0.0337826163,
0.0708623752,
0.4201934338,
0.3639385998,
-0.5798922777,
-0.157587707,
-0.291233331,
-0.802259624,
0.8051438332,
0.1552766412,
-0.0889079273,
0.048165828,
0.5393111706,
0.5668062568,
0.3564705551,
-0.4019464254,
-0.2375630736,
-0.1302074045,
-0.09225104,
-0.2907091677,
-0.028823616,
-0.0589563996,
-0.113896668,
0.6318410635,
-0.2714327574,
-0.0376725644,
-0.2341151386,
0.2346949428,
0.1331282407,
0.0109026134,
0.5824404359,
0.7566680312,
-0.2108405679,
-0.3777005374,
-0.0135501893,
-0.3487885296,
-0.1637445986,
0.4084324837,
-0.0941519663,
-0.3466284275,
0.3333991766,
0.8648759127,
0.6827079654,
-1.2691730261,
0.4997614622,
-0.2484186739,
-0.1121510044,
-0.7469177246,
0.3690298796,
0.1187054664,
0.4823629856,
0.534779489,
-0.1491533369,
-0.0105557777,
-0.5696083903,
0.3014577627,
0.1990085542,
-0.1938990951,
-0.0556434207,
0.8609682322,
0.0866895914,
-0.2836684287,
0.8928816915,
0.0113500357,
-0.0258347765,
0.7724773288,
0.3543381691,
0.9728830457,
0.0604292192,
0.1640315205,
0.3051794171,
0.1947116852,
-0.2564799488,
0.1772574484,
-0.1833045781,
-0.4612626433,
-0.5190812349,
-0.9080461264,
-0.8125475645,
0.1364800036,
-0.700784862,
0.3370025158,
-0.8917634487,
-0.0402915291,
0.0396366231,
0.1433951408,
-0.5538960099,
0.1182084382,
0.3569323719,
0.9780778885,
-0.3165976703,
0.7957687974,
0.5348683596,
-0.1673602313,
-0.334846735,
-0.2610056102,
-0.2184200436,
-0.980194509,
0.6326316595,
0.1134513021,
-0.0416562967,
-0.2555808425,
-0.5539264083,
-0.7805235982,
1.0522508621,
0.6437644362,
-1.1322654486,
-0.2394554615,
0.4257163703,
0.2243326306,
-0.6504395008,
0.0555209666,
0.8267974257,
0.6732068062,
0.2618187368,
-0.6860045195,
-0.4488637745,
-0.3914586306,
-0.3017944098,
0.1470939964,
-1.005576849,
0.9219747186,
-0.1354727894,
0.0135071017,
0.1824669838,
0.8132961392,
0.1386443228,
0.7670516968,
0.3957862556,
0.4120775163,
0.9290056825,
-0.4382600784,
0.9573433399,
-0.8371768594,
0.3441958427,
1.2834070921,
-0.2846714258,
1.2288208008,
-0.0064608422,
-0.3014510572,
0.2192298621,
0.5565178394,
-0.3986058831,
-0.0534660108,
0.358258605,
-0.120155178,
-0.318168968,
0.038874805,
-0.1836370081,
0.7134201527,
0.41169855,
-0.1920256615,
0.0959779844,
0.0413649455,
0.1106508672,
0.1505098492,
-0.5115966201,
0.6486867666,
0.1602788121,
-0.431979239,
0.1016311869,
0.3833566904,
0.5979668498,
-0.7568601966,
-0.0114581864,
-0.419579953,
0.3346657753,
0.140288204,
-0.5950856209,
0.4839294851,
0.3095515966,
0.0887956545,
-0.1624018997,
0.3435056806,
-0.1110975593,
-0.937989831,
0.323795706,
-0.0240570791,
0.1797318161,
-0.3806396425,
-0.5169661641,
-0.0305463579,
-0.3281316459,
-0.0954217091,
0.2776654661,
0.4692684412,
0.1290168315,
0.8298122287,
0.7881913781,
-0.0948183164,
-0.1371393651,
-0.0507286303,
0.6323593259,
-0.977029562,
-0.4171744883,
-0.8572055697,
-0.0861252844,
0.0690757334,
-0.5560770035,
0.4162600338,
1.0226008892,
1.0368150473,
0.1509546638,
0.5374311805,
0.4811125398,
0.259903878,
-0.5339416862,
0.8485812545,
-0.5383611917,
0.3363189697,
-0.2797403634,
-1.0234982967,
-0.1865057349,
0.6090399623,
-0.4982872009,
-0.5045739412,
0.2662390172,
0.3676546514,
0.0226140115,
0.3998453319,
0.375172317,
0.1276873499,
-0.0804883912,
0.720173955,
0.3345424831,
-0.5269634724,
0.5026142001,
-0.4605722725,
-0.1369276196,
-0.3143740892,
-0.7644591928,
-0.7694939971,
-0.3551536202,
-0.5741353631,
0.3665470481,
-0.0457288064,
0.9958076477,
0.3405317366,
-0.8686070442,
-0.7644982934,
0.1343533546,
0.2265512198,
-0.5587161183,
-0.1942541599,
0.4829845726,
-0.3625160754,
-1.1726794243,
0.5804985166,
0.7361810207,
-0.1009705588,
-0.1362063587,
-0.2050027996,
0.1221332252,
-0.0715720505,
0.5104077458,
0.2496977299,
-0.3767510355,
0.012854795,
0.0659018531,
0.1121030971,
0.0638713762,
0.7469645739,
-0.2922834456,
0.0896487832,
0.0897116736,
0.9920191169,
0.2987418771,
-0.1831332445,
0.8170804977,
-0.0371387042,
0.1169483885,
-0.0987405032,
0.4730483294,
-0.2022338361,
-0.3524165452,
0.7539251447,
0.0214881804,
-0.4010115266,
-0.366971314,
-0.5729979277,
-0.9742977619,
-0.3708184659,
0.7895957828,
-0.3886415958,
-0.6182408333,
0.3277798295,
-0.1696882844,
0.0932043344,
-0.6523863673,
0.6561015844,
0.6625068188,
0.0507555567,
-0.1107538044,
-0.5889387131,
0.0547373854,
0.1877401024,
-0.7961736917,
0.2712647021,
0.3106241524,
0.1008750945,
0.0332664996,
0.3392561972,
0.1807357818,
0.4412490726,
0.2158516496,
-0.0889186412,
-0.2658581138,
-0.3580148518,
0.0556257814,
0.3750548661,
-0.2150185853,
-0.159595862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05183v1 | Improving Long Context Document-Level Machine Translation | 2023-06-08T13:28:48 | 2023-06-08T13:28:48 | Christian Herold, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Document-level context for neural machine translation (NMT) is crucial to
improve the translation consistency and cohesion, the translation of ambiguous
inputs, as well as several other linguistic phenomena. Many works have been
published on the topic of document-level NMT, but most restrict the system to
only local context, typically including just the one or two preceding sentences
as additional information. This might be enough to resolve some ambiguous
inputs, but it is probably not sufficient to capture some document-level
information like the topic or style of a conversation. When increasing the
context size beyond just the local context, there are two challenges: (i)
the~memory usage increases exponentially (ii) the translation performance
starts to degrade. We argue that the widely-used attention mechanism is
responsible for both issues. Therefore, we propose a constrained attention
variant that focuses the attention on the most relevant parts of the sequence,
while simultaneously reducing the memory consumption. For evaluation, we
utilize targeted test sets in combination with novel evaluation techniques to
analyze the translations in regards to specific discourse-related phenomena. We
find that our approach is a good compromise between sentence-level NMT vs
attending to the full context, especially in low resource scenarios. | [
-0.3557580411,
-0.7132166624,
0.6619996428,
0.3003843427,
-0.4923740923,
-0.1907440275,
-0.5133488178,
-0.3165514171,
0.0973259434,
0.4966152012,
-0.4234469533,
-0.247797668,
-0.7059692144,
0.1570204347,
-0.3805026412,
1.0191472769,
-0.3149522543,
-0.2391339988,
-0.2906699181,
-0.2538402081,
-0.7523269057,
-0.4115088284,
-0.959377408,
-0.2694655657,
0.5945389271,
0.2558380365,
0.5745348334,
0.7366991639,
0.5923936963,
0.2538098693,
-0.3353890777,
0.1846557558,
-0.5260999203,
0.3824794888,
-0.2574473917,
-0.1191145629,
-0.5149886012,
-0.3570735455,
0.788559556,
0.7536461949,
0.2083960623,
0.0225755703,
0.3224247694,
0.6320675611,
-0.4165580869,
0.0846651047,
-0.3912724555,
0.1628914773,
-0.1358521432,
-0.3064991236,
-0.3638209701,
0.1724743843,
0.3139640093,
-0.6512129307,
0.0678287223,
-0.1559755355,
0.6676137447,
0.7504255772,
-0.7138049006,
0.0787370503,
-0.6658787727,
0.6711489558,
-0.574596405,
0.3324674666,
0.3722342849,
0.1212446615,
-0.1721729189,
-0.5137357116,
-0.2429066002,
-0.1590411812,
-0.1152613238,
0.2535414994,
0.0148024643,
0.1544954181,
0.4268257916,
0.2434341311,
-0.6327919364,
-0.169316873,
-0.3067615032,
-0.2138870656,
0.1550834626,
0.0633177236,
0.1721100509,
-0.2452218533,
-0.4706859589,
0.0944989994,
-0.4935989678,
-0.2522106171,
-0.0497767255,
0.1498149633,
0.1134894043,
0.4276655316,
-0.2544320524,
0.765324533,
0.1042896062,
-0.0531484932,
0.1252451539,
-0.430175662,
-0.1760549992,
-0.0319807827,
0.5844208598,
0.45296821,
-0.0849153548,
-0.3097435832,
-0.2591720521,
-0.2952071428,
0.4499159753,
-0.9290726185,
0.3350465894,
0.1501210928,
-0.231099844,
-0.0243557375,
-0.1894365102,
-0.5825964808,
-0.2046086192,
-0.2829829752,
0.1160667911,
-0.5919076204,
0.0230973177,
0.021349825,
-0.0767346993,
0.1430955082,
0.3641439974,
-0.7843718529,
0.1445247233,
0.5893980265,
0.9422860146,
-0.4402970672,
-0.2904802561,
-0.5685908794,
0.3114081025,
-0.2843076289,
0.4426595271,
-0.3136344552,
-0.061289642,
-0.3216024935,
-0.0995757431,
-0.2253548056,
-0.4636721313,
0.7122989893,
-0.3897022903,
0.2881807089,
-0.2984055579,
-0.4072473049,
-0.021771742,
0.4899611175,
-0.5517944098,
1.0632903576,
0.4350156486,
-0.5982022882,
0.1094784886,
-0.9265677333,
-0.8465583324,
-0.1291498393,
-0.1153178364,
-0.2464095056,
0.2968150675,
0.2466708124,
0.4478300214,
-0.31580019,
0.5016174316,
0.2555791736,
-0.4410832524,
0.1225327253,
-0.4315786958,
0.4172254205,
0.2655088305,
-0.5314546824,
0.1530562192,
-0.6343808174,
-0.1997281164,
0.1087966412,
-0.4557490349,
-0.4261188209,
-0.2190690786,
0.0631345659,
0.4084032178,
0.3248912692,
-0.4285056293,
0.0539616235,
-0.5304900408,
0.7496406436,
0.4545693696,
0.0703998953,
0.7589475513,
-0.1188774556,
0.5794488788,
0.1317394227,
0.0436309427,
-0.3939555287,
-0.3186966479,
-0.9089919925,
0.0019853634,
0.3839733601,
0.4598012269,
-0.9430961013,
0.3583153188,
-0.409294337,
0.1065272093,
-0.4461528957,
-0.0094408896,
0.5086987019,
0.9086483717,
0.5456769466,
-0.2812019289,
-0.5084587932,
-1.0777193308,
-0.1568645239,
0.3132443726,
-0.0408319682,
0.2462863773,
0.3366982639,
-0.1880542934,
0.8562030792,
-0.2484778166,
-0.2447137386,
-0.0902621299,
0.0466988385,
0.0469487309,
0.5918499231,
0.4127060771,
-0.8398908377,
-0.4524224997,
0.2536443472,
-0.4607649744,
0.0166406035,
-0.4975637197,
-0.0842662305,
0.2697393894,
0.6324146986,
-0.7104375362,
0.3705722988,
0.4463614821,
-0.2614403665,
0.0458360836,
-0.2893299162,
0.0802550465,
-1.2315270901,
0.1898916364,
-0.131167382,
-0.4105342329,
-0.5294280052,
0.3058899343,
0.393137604,
-0.2912299335,
-0.5212612152,
0.5487428904,
-0.5323775411,
-0.01475453,
-0.3334610164,
0.3199033439,
0.1784672737,
0.6794356108,
-0.2267474383,
0.9442015886,
0.0226538293,
-0.3894036412,
0.1015382558,
0.1384197474,
-0.149364993,
0.6247290969,
-0.5157475471,
0.3841059804,
-0.0227424279,
0.2828481197,
-0.9007944465,
-0.2826097608,
0.3391979933,
-0.4552310705,
0.6757768989,
0.095216766,
-0.398445636,
-0.0532340184,
-0.0970010236,
0.4119090438,
0.3079891503,
-0.2198844254,
0.3993656933,
0.1420593709,
-0.1158801541,
-0.6813097,
-0.9081160426,
0.5320803523,
-0.1599283963,
-0.7304086685,
0.5600029826,
0.1667450666,
0.1066674069,
-0.0280022416,
-0.5240606666,
-0.0613756068,
0.2375017852,
-0.0364640206,
-0.289842695,
-0.4208959043,
0.2702589929,
0.3491695821,
-0.2407454848,
-0.055434078,
-0.5768510103,
0.5507037044,
-0.1723694354,
0.0573072284,
-0.4116940796,
0.7366085649,
0.6889496446,
-0.3501157463,
0.6979905963,
0.6551220417,
-0.396415323,
-0.0946291462,
-0.3407561183,
-0.1058536991,
-0.4152950943,
0.6737436652,
-0.5291914344,
-1.0261824131,
0.4617673159,
-0.0904157013,
-0.3183739781,
0.5013139248,
0.2832373381,
-0.0424311981,
0.8020610213,
0.4909962118,
-0.0801588148,
0.5444071889,
-0.1714057475,
0.1543781161,
-1.3293001652,
0.1377711743,
-0.2814205587,
-0.4831318557,
-0.2961774468,
-0.6265565753,
0.1622888893,
-0.0526475087,
0.0118313963,
0.6898976564,
-0.6259005666,
0.5772326589,
0.2666486502,
0.0592625216,
0.1233329624,
-0.2234551311,
-0.2136417478,
-0.2355521917,
-0.7530760169,
-0.4159829021,
0.7951497436,
0.3100693226,
0.156826809,
0.0488189794,
0.7457785606,
-0.0610776208,
0.1915846467,
-0.8413522243,
0.5804517865,
-0.1517122537,
-0.5354146361,
-0.4473003149,
-0.5583585501,
-1.1163123846,
0.30422014,
0.2399774492,
-0.5092768669,
-0.0288264528,
-0.0081522828,
-0.3444122672,
-0.0812968537,
-0.692242384,
1.1779237986,
-0.212070629,
-0.3992008865,
-0.0302324761,
-0.8723176122,
0.0574874096,
-0.2377599329,
-0.1053756177,
0.0894989818,
-0.5294195414,
0.4584865272,
-0.239290148,
0.7482839227,
-0.0086217718,
-0.1735748351,
-0.0027961449,
-0.0557805374,
0.5513426065,
-0.018276833,
-0.1023461223,
-0.0586619191,
-0.2626740932,
-0.4618989229,
-0.8259215355,
0.7104518414,
-0.5170807242,
-0.7451796532,
-0.2544053793,
-0.9196044803,
-0.1353058368,
0.4752224982,
0.3087945879,
0.1006885916,
-0.3518393338,
0.4808599353,
0.8982658386,
-0.0979155898,
0.2784868181,
0.0655394867,
0.000723296,
-0.2774899006,
0.8032818437,
0.2386626601,
0.3607207537,
0.6467735171,
0.2544046938,
-0.0544755273,
-0.7847046256,
-0.6398611069,
-0.0927764773,
-0.6248528957,
-0.1345504671,
-0.749512434,
-0.0745871142,
-0.4216937423,
-0.1210053265,
-0.383656919,
-0.7740953565,
-0.2532380223,
0.0428194031,
0.0118151354,
0.1873702705,
0.2736773789,
0.4492159188,
-0.5749639273,
0.3538857102,
-0.0389821753,
0.1447912753,
-0.1860317737,
-0.646345675,
-0.3611857295,
-0.1427986026,
-0.3831385374,
-0.9178344011,
0.2918116748,
0.1604775488,
0.3823955059,
0.1709988713,
0.0697341859,
0.656439364,
-0.5895982981,
0.5210998654,
0.0089845126,
-0.9209301472,
0.6565545797,
-0.7035979629,
0.8531567454,
0.6428118348,
0.1628963053,
-0.8502500057,
-0.5997024775,
-0.4588420689,
-1.1716812849,
0.65774405,
0.4143240154,
0.2563943267,
-0.1572634727,
0.6911148429,
-0.1014933661,
0.0785259008,
-0.5372649431,
0.0170519929,
0.0677880421,
-0.2355251759,
-0.0810118616,
-0.1099598855,
-0.0542541891,
-0.2863945663,
0.4490986168,
-0.1767500192,
0.2632427514,
0.4054584801,
-0.3244121075,
-0.0118964724,
0.4105846286,
1.1050115824,
0.6410399675,
-0.2160990685,
0.1320076436,
0.4636399448,
-0.4542806745,
0.0161978044,
0.0541906878,
-0.5739994645,
0.0938145667,
0.0240392964,
0.8262175322,
0.4722767174,
-0.4029940069,
0.3906779587,
-0.0288151726,
-0.1097301915,
-0.208350718,
-0.0399066918,
0.3977558017,
0.1565464437,
0.1084886342,
0.3149137795,
0.2496563196,
-0.4407955408,
0.2944856882,
0.0891983956,
-0.6500865221,
0.0789748952,
0.5938977599,
0.4030998647,
-0.4377186894,
0.5088571906,
-0.2927688658,
-0.634855628,
0.7819164991,
0.5999597907,
0.9699087143,
-0.2529684603,
-0.0919245034,
0.387448132,
0.585251987,
-0.1697098464,
-0.0765789002,
-0.3091020584,
-0.3049108982,
-0.6748277545,
-0.2895066142,
-0.265688628,
0.2177787274,
-0.6619104743,
0.0653240085,
-0.3707729578,
-0.2899898589,
-0.215627715,
-0.1145445779,
-0.3909938037,
0.0775678754,
0.0431794189,
0.744163096,
-0.2552267015,
1.1016167402,
0.5680100322,
-0.2397749573,
-0.2292805314,
0.1405981034,
-0.2505627275,
-0.4223138392,
0.3708225489,
0.4043265581,
-0.1288851649,
-0.0408191308,
-0.0887825117,
-0.9520739317,
1.0365384817,
0.6063097715,
-0.6339455247,
-0.1397182792,
0.1588559598,
0.6395409107,
-0.4073699713,
-0.1788090318,
0.5521481633,
0.6443571448,
-0.0927799419,
-0.8579812646,
0.3645926714,
-0.1260650605,
0.2694728076,
0.5774453878,
-0.6926329136,
0.6033881307,
-0.0441159345,
-0.2970919609,
0.0427677557,
0.6516294479,
-0.2975184023,
0.3416014612,
0.3624099195,
0.6452453732,
0.6761104465,
-0.071669884,
1.1141215563,
-0.1575701833,
0.2601896226,
1.6052671671,
-0.1599666476,
0.7805953622,
0.8180789351,
0.3562511206,
-0.1102994606,
0.6471047401,
0.1570084393,
0.4441511333,
0.3498293161,
-0.1055990085,
-0.0626559779,
-0.1033786088,
-0.3774515688,
0.3856646717,
0.3603644371,
-0.5423792601,
-0.2570593655,
0.1618978828,
0.10122253,
0.0908509567,
-0.0036033283,
0.6063302755,
0.2223492712,
-0.9431887865,
0.7256644368,
0.1903889775,
0.483684957,
-0.2941043675,
0.1521602422,
-0.3275130391,
0.3039149046,
0.0380445272,
-0.4351700544,
0.7772746086,
-0.0270582493,
-0.3040184975,
-0.6383606791,
0.7284229994,
-0.4917714298,
-0.1110250652,
0.4046808779,
0.4651724994,
0.1843397468,
-0.3946862519,
-0.6524344683,
-0.0534038544,
-0.0456293374,
-0.5480589271,
0.5138154626,
0.7379706502,
-0.0798192471,
0.2546483278,
0.3840540648,
-0.2987083197,
0.0187224001,
-0.1106419638,
0.8202914596,
-0.790555954,
-0.3638130128,
-0.8223162889,
0.3632299006,
-0.3723579645,
-0.6727572083,
0.6412671804,
0.6587856412,
0.9126034975,
0.0938114449,
0.575514257,
0.0802846849,
0.10370408,
-0.432439208,
0.8752903342,
-0.5945033431,
0.0693946406,
0.0219494384,
-1.0081299543,
-0.4324478805,
0.7142341733,
-0.3338601291,
-0.1579169929,
1.1325502396,
0.4703624249,
-0.1624745876,
-0.1512036622,
0.6548166275,
0.133437559,
0.0366826802,
0.9302995205,
0.8145143986,
-0.6698371768,
0.7716010809,
-0.1533020288,
-0.0707577318,
-0.313849777,
-0.9591860175,
-0.8442757726,
-0.5947360992,
-0.3464529216,
-0.3135386109,
0.1069078371,
0.7154816985,
0.6600733995,
-0.5187229514,
0.0350960754,
-0.069589749,
0.1342399567,
-0.3221578598,
-0.1396972984,
0.341340065,
-0.5502735972,
-0.6897445321,
0.6359407306,
0.6586557627,
-0.0830217451,
-0.0122459829,
-0.1166947633,
-0.2343754321,
-0.0021227885,
0.7982201576,
0.1382567883,
-0.647408843,
-0.3107220232,
0.2272773385,
-0.4107480049,
0.3819674253,
0.8606081605,
-0.3863725662,
0.3832835257,
0.5498043299,
1.0727741718,
0.7974013686,
-0.29299739,
0.6881293058,
-0.9562727213,
0.2932630777,
0.4807844162,
0.3388047516,
0.3324844837,
-0.5313723087,
0.6687695384,
0.061402522,
-0.4044933319,
-0.6673560143,
0.3249060214,
-1.2472320795,
-0.2669124007,
1.0844455957,
-0.2912279069,
-0.490508914,
-0.217851758,
-0.3530801535,
0.4880948365,
-0.3943019211,
0.583763063,
0.9612205029,
0.0698071569,
-0.2218814045,
-0.9718798995,
0.2206667513,
0.8104830384,
-0.7429269552,
0.0034386623,
0.3301463425,
0.0800538361,
0.3449412584,
0.5575889349,
-0.0931056812,
0.3364834189,
-0.1595270187,
-0.215336144,
-0.0858164132,
-0.3516601622,
-0.5315086842,
0.154518798,
-0.1997421831,
-0.1294619441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05179v2 | M3Exam: A Multilingual, Multimodal, Multilevel Benchmark for Examining Large Language Models | 2023-06-08T13:21:29 | 2023-11-10T04:11:01 | Wenxuan Zhang, Sharifah Mahani Aljunied, Chang Gao, Yew Ken Chia, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Despite the existence of various benchmarks for evaluating natural language
processing models, we argue that human exams are a more suitable means of
evaluating general intelligence for large language models (LLMs), as they
inherently demand a much wider range of abilities such as language
understanding, domain knowledge, and problem-solving skills. To this end, we
introduce M3Exam, a novel benchmark sourced from real and official human exam
questions for evaluating LLMs in a multilingual, multimodal, and multilevel
context. M3Exam exhibits three unique characteristics: (1) multilingualism,
encompassing questions from multiple countries that require strong multilingual
proficiency and cultural knowledge; (2) multimodality, accounting for the
multimodal nature of many exam questions to test the model's multimodal
understanding capability; and (3) multilevel structure, featuring exams from
three critical educational periods to comprehensively assess a model's
proficiency at different levels. In total, M3Exam contains 12,317 questions in
9 diverse languages with three educational levels, where about 23\% of the
questions require processing images for successful solving. We assess the
performance of top-performing LLMs on M3Exam and find that current models,
including GPT-4, still struggle with multilingual text, particularly in
low-resource and non-Latin script languages. Multimodal LLMs also perform
poorly with complex multimodal questions. We believe that M3Exam can be a
valuable resource for comprehensively evaluating LLMs by examining their
multilingual and multimodal abilities and tracking their development. Data and
evaluation code is available at \url{https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/M3Exam}. | [
-0.6279489398,
-0.7398753166,
0.49436149,
0.1811350733,
-0.0281558167,
0.0922058821,
-0.2483369112,
-0.5114755034,
-0.2737981081,
0.3239773512,
-0.5481989384,
-0.6018778682,
-0.5771471858,
0.1938743144,
-0.3295064867,
0.7216615677,
-0.1342167854,
0.1881891638,
-0.4896795452,
-0.4659562409,
-0.2482334226,
-0.6499688625,
-0.8650710583,
-0.1422630399,
0.586820662,
0.1415116638,
0.644859314,
0.3837286532,
0.7013338208,
0.3421607018,
0.0095927147,
0.2513114512,
-0.268070966,
-0.1410341263,
-0.2173328847,
-0.4507516325,
-0.4549474716,
0.2146817893,
0.9417836666,
0.8299905658,
-0.0328184403,
0.4574747086,
-0.0180727299,
0.5133593678,
-0.5265679955,
0.0872889385,
-0.5003030896,
0.0018596555,
-0.0463265181,
-0.1669500321,
-0.3003466427,
-0.1474732757,
-0.0289801061,
-0.3224219084,
-0.0658340976,
0.1647812873,
0.582521379,
0.0339663923,
-0.8802909255,
-0.1845210791,
-0.5375525355,
0.9040980935,
-0.5799933076,
0.4077403545,
0.1653876305,
0.450251013,
-0.0846325383,
-0.4869630337,
-0.5789821744,
-0.4676751196,
0.178462103,
0.2034275085,
-0.1509362459,
-0.1215680838,
0.2175409049,
0.4512102902,
-0.9668512344,
0.1110865399,
-0.315297693,
-0.0973986983,
0.532137692,
0.329415679,
0.6993332505,
-0.0362674147,
-0.5992780328,
-0.1266681403,
-0.636803925,
0.024236178,
0.4610567987,
0.1367913187,
-0.0434022881,
0.3472700417,
0.0068700961,
0.6171801686,
-0.7327848077,
-0.2898262739,
0.2319129109,
-0.3527672291,
-0.0191680063,
-0.2883734107,
0.6958642602,
0.5195685029,
0.1670044065,
-0.0245235544,
-0.2745812237,
0.1612259895,
0.0358180553,
-0.9228822589,
0.1359239668,
0.2943206131,
-0.3569241464,
0.2576083839,
-0.2569474876,
-0.8807006478,
-0.1390934139,
-0.3570636213,
0.6290248036,
-0.2689338923,
-0.4347550869,
0.2032026201,
-0.0141050629,
0.3097945154,
0.1966971606,
-0.7946205139,
0.4627957344,
0.8839181066,
0.7429599762,
-0.293782115,
-0.6548551917,
-0.4214729965,
0.0498616584,
-0.2666532993,
0.770837605,
-0.777174294,
-0.3310765624,
-0.2463521808,
-0.0358579345,
-0.341250211,
-0.6892092824,
0.6524119973,
-0.5469260812,
0.3654577732,
-0.040247038,
-0.5292725563,
-0.449880749,
0.6974714398,
-0.6291971207,
0.8871788979,
-0.0139427809,
-0.4424093664,
0.172888279,
-0.6542161107,
-0.2023479193,
-0.0780508816,
-0.2884844542,
-0.0501388051,
0.0023273851,
0.1669187099,
0.3216731846,
-0.5542792678,
0.2299769521,
-0.3339171112,
-0.5345703959,
0.2012255341,
-0.7383722663,
0.8510814309,
0.0336193256,
-0.3159373701,
0.0344052576,
-0.9688217044,
0.3036052287,
0.2559545338,
-0.4391919374,
-0.2059524506,
-0.017909497,
0.0729333833,
0.5466774106,
0.2285317183,
-0.3818794191,
0.0323624052,
-0.0270395353,
0.1606428474,
0.6431777477,
-0.1525076777,
0.0721669868,
-0.3648374379,
0.5623210669,
0.0646698475,
0.1176762357,
-0.1928405762,
-0.7428354621,
-0.6871778965,
-0.2771517634,
0.1047912762,
0.6499549747,
-0.2938159704,
0.0147210965,
-0.2695655227,
-0.6297821403,
-0.6467235684,
0.4104867876,
0.53578794,
0.2861090004,
0.399133414,
-0.2921160758,
-0.3811019659,
-1.0815014839,
-0.3623015881,
-0.050648015,
-0.0742968395,
0.1579038054,
0.7995384336,
-0.5354842544,
0.4380075037,
-0.2114291638,
-0.1610607505,
-0.3496705592,
0.4999049008,
0.1006691679,
0.398509115,
0.4583071172,
-0.7566840649,
-0.2719065249,
0.0661216453,
-0.6908171177,
0.023121791,
0.0196337178,
-0.0337855667,
0.206735611,
0.2734377682,
-0.5810762048,
-0.102348268,
0.8924095035,
-0.2855417728,
0.5619652867,
-0.4339858592,
0.2556415498,
-0.9907713532,
0.2872592509,
-0.0113350181,
-0.1488739699,
-0.5087535977,
0.3909145892,
0.2257044315,
-0.1916238517,
-0.4427389205,
0.8886463046,
-0.6340448856,
-0.2922448516,
-0.1405434161,
0.4195742905,
0.1121022776,
0.6167823672,
-0.1910529584,
0.8305057883,
0.3592704833,
-0.4987570345,
0.28777951,
-0.0394414254,
-0.6435213685,
0.7008009553,
-0.4969163239,
0.2253832817,
-0.1881189942,
-0.0373499244,
-1.0716018677,
0.0033590451,
-0.1742490083,
-0.3654294312,
0.2750974298,
0.0119783608,
-0.6487215757,
-0.2788176835,
-0.2397739738,
0.4542227685,
0.486158967,
-0.3802202642,
0.5935582519,
0.4234741032,
-0.1633193344,
-0.528581202,
-0.3806892931,
0.2264591008,
-0.1567385644,
-0.7355203032,
0.1174149141,
-0.3948436677,
-0.4083434045,
-0.1333369762,
0.0444832332,
-0.125094384,
0.3302859664,
0.009740226,
0.3660321534,
-0.3705519736,
-0.1510479003,
-0.0732865706,
-0.2745964527,
0.332056731,
0.0334850065,
0.423895359,
-0.4665699899,
-0.542278707,
-0.326056242,
0.5927328467,
0.7536149621,
-0.3310303986,
0.4991483986,
0.9201615453,
-0.3733862936,
-0.0044899774,
-0.616204977,
-0.01387027,
-0.4107736349,
0.6320059896,
-0.5620160699,
-0.8404998779,
0.4851742685,
0.0313865654,
0.2134800404,
0.4179216921,
0.6719365716,
0.1255030781,
1.6080827713,
0.3422471285,
-0.0967085958,
-0.053029269,
-0.1007602289,
0.003533992,
-0.891620338,
-0.0447780751,
-0.3886658251,
-0.3517699242,
-0.5675515532,
-0.5872957706,
0.2498728037,
-0.1466851383,
-0.1659408212,
-0.0249391794,
0.0395642519,
0.4761190116,
0.4902846813,
-0.3691948354,
0.6099893451,
-0.1438580304,
-0.2615937293,
-0.1297930032,
-0.4004779756,
-0.8227884173,
1.159104228,
0.37424016,
0.4499517381,
0.3540627956,
0.1733803302,
0.1097773686,
0.6375260353,
-0.6142522693,
0.7617921233,
-0.080644913,
-0.9927796721,
-0.0418959521,
-0.6603991389,
-0.847497046,
0.7480400205,
0.0029345534,
-0.5534160733,
-0.2754147351,
-0.1375882626,
-0.2118711472,
0.4178713858,
-0.8526620865,
1.0050436258,
-0.4833647907,
-0.397408098,
-0.3833659589,
-0.5038208365,
0.6035339236,
-0.1133940592,
0.4063363969,
-0.6139162183,
-0.3631182015,
0.8271093965,
-0.0292395204,
0.596729219,
-0.1034586206,
-0.1126916185,
0.1207781509,
0.0523485653,
0.1878726482,
0.0931140557,
-0.1720777005,
0.2280246466,
0.275069207,
-0.5653815269,
-0.681707859,
0.6617818475,
-0.9349290729,
-0.7569850087,
-0.4797832966,
-0.679207027,
-0.5373923779,
0.2413237095,
-0.1985592246,
0.7228069901,
-0.363198787,
0.0397199728,
0.4008366764,
-0.2341611385,
0.2977825701,
0.726085484,
-0.4373481572,
-0.3145964444,
1.0942715406,
0.0265404731,
0.4022835195,
0.5233637691,
0.1822367162,
-0.4150999784,
-0.690199554,
-0.6098002791,
0.29690364,
-0.8450205922,
0.1930251867,
-0.8209280968,
-0.0917159244,
-0.1629208177,
0.2446257323,
-0.3329572976,
-0.1535426825,
0.0309019294,
0.080704838,
-0.2028389722,
0.6454707384,
0.060191378,
-0.0670671239,
-0.926903069,
0.3660912514,
0.5593728423,
0.2708884776,
-0.1061675027,
-0.5220191479,
-0.0202870276,
0.0163531024,
-0.2568230331,
-0.4687870741,
0.2555966675,
0.280204922,
0.7599377036,
0.4947515428,
-0.340954572,
0.5781750083,
-0.5530928969,
0.6246606708,
-0.0402239226,
-0.8746580482,
0.2079814225,
-0.300329417,
0.4674586356,
0.6930043697,
0.7200867534,
-0.7807909846,
-0.3198903799,
-0.2117511779,
-0.6606774926,
0.5045089126,
-0.043186646,
0.3471826315,
-0.0697061792,
-0.001236386,
0.1672312617,
0.158179298,
-0.7878060341,
-0.1829337627,
0.244721815,
-0.1462348253,
-0.2567209005,
-0.4744288027,
-0.17652376,
-0.2512325943,
0.5070524812,
-0.1741672009,
0.1972128004,
-0.0979645848,
-0.3343619406,
0.2443419695,
0.5066866875,
0.9280481339,
0.9914357066,
-0.5401760936,
0.327621609,
0.2244935483,
-0.5322752595,
0.2601312399,
0.1062895358,
0.190034911,
-0.1420992315,
0.3915096819,
0.5476676822,
0.3540140688,
-1.0529224873,
0.5312061906,
-0.3227385283,
-0.2674456537,
-0.1882650107,
0.0622994788,
0.3334816396,
0.0369162336,
0.3851273954,
-0.0724722967,
0.1251468211,
-0.77614218,
0.0881313682,
0.3864726722,
-0.3860996664,
-0.4543999135,
0.5052317977,
0.2129421234,
-0.1077478752,
0.62118572,
-0.5340591073,
-0.449822098,
0.550322175,
0.6420494318,
0.6113244891,
-0.3671967983,
0.081170857,
0.4561525583,
0.6428051591,
0.0179962907,
0.4996685088,
0.0566167124,
-0.7253437042,
-0.3726012409,
-0.5248693824,
-0.7128551006,
0.1929257363,
-0.4631049931,
0.1229303852,
-0.4695688486,
0.0112633919,
-0.2289943844,
0.2880143821,
-0.5662329197,
0.3709214628,
0.492938906,
1.0557597876,
-0.5635003448,
0.6797763705,
0.6495391726,
-0.2130114883,
-0.368956238,
-0.3096205294,
0.1982739568,
-0.8783710599,
0.5688477159,
0.6449911594,
-0.2251641154,
0.0200598482,
0.0237306412,
-0.8424873352,
1.0173574686,
0.4805473387,
-0.3235870004,
0.0474499427,
0.3723328114,
0.5584905744,
-0.4190036356,
0.7311252952,
0.6154150367,
0.5956043601,
-0.1890936494,
-0.6443855166,
-0.0647099987,
-0.7015592456,
-0.0058240215,
0.183223784,
-0.6516394615,
0.9441164136,
-0.2145892233,
-0.4165126383,
0.019233359,
0.5214629173,
0.3487771749,
0.3216020763,
0.5284352899,
0.5978323817,
0.8238921165,
-0.0959919393,
1.1669777632,
-0.4585222304,
0.1990391016,
1.0473588705,
-0.5725473762,
1.1066890955,
0.4153215587,
-0.2462747693,
0.4477855265,
0.6059352756,
0.0330469906,
0.0883013979,
0.2648568749,
-0.2673278153,
-0.2934785187,
-0.0093505168,
-0.5308732986,
0.5912809372,
0.3669610918,
0.0368018188,
-0.3309437931,
0.0204010736,
0.2087484449,
-0.0902231559,
-0.3749469817,
0.4077751338,
0.0898299292,
-0.6816812158,
0.482550472,
0.1350560635,
0.6431689262,
-0.7156742215,
0.1651822478,
-0.3666249812,
0.2943771482,
0.0433443338,
-0.7207095027,
0.4018850327,
-0.0532820225,
0.0933356658,
-0.1343059987,
0.2597133517,
-0.4509232938,
-0.7252199054,
0.624242723,
0.7541053891,
0.2558210194,
-0.27665326,
-0.881413281,
0.0047621392,
-0.2875231504,
-0.3987395763,
0.4447227418,
0.1793462038,
0.0445842855,
0.8403277397,
0.6102035642,
-0.0879207626,
0.069744952,
0.2885970771,
0.4318993092,
-0.7097494006,
-0.2052386999,
-0.9060676098,
0.3066247404,
-0.0519509576,
-0.5463123322,
0.8630509377,
0.7587130666,
0.9397449493,
0.1449200362,
0.6358947158,
0.4125182927,
0.5302898288,
-0.4696800709,
0.690544188,
-0.987644136,
0.1143822595,
-0.1222632304,
-1.0326862335,
-0.3323833644,
0.2763207257,
-0.3996906281,
0.2878103554,
0.8883705735,
0.8542258143,
-0.085937731,
0.135388121,
0.6591356397,
-0.0443373322,
0.2604629993,
0.778760016,
1.1677442789,
-0.4629148245,
0.730489254,
-0.1387774944,
-0.2305250317,
-0.1402239501,
-0.6433552504,
-1.0491765738,
-0.5289731622,
-0.2837144136,
0.1345180571,
-0.2156884521,
0.9828154445,
0.5473973155,
-0.6596346498,
-0.535450995,
0.4190278053,
0.1536618322,
-0.2837589979,
-0.1948767155,
0.138362214,
-0.284126848,
-0.972235024,
0.4270415306,
0.6352770329,
0.0223579798,
-0.6138706803,
0.0700563863,
-0.3036291003,
0.1684427261,
0.798609972,
-0.0162883066,
-0.5312978625,
-0.0786796734,
0.0118234912,
-0.4407584667,
0.1919476539,
0.7996463776,
-0.300355643,
0.3832844496,
0.5021274686,
0.7712903023,
0.2385449409,
-0.3533198535,
0.4988632202,
-0.3246963322,
0.0523720533,
0.1508103609,
0.5823411345,
0.4294808805,
0.0087226219,
0.4571894109,
0.2369081229,
-0.4856737852,
-0.7902922034,
0.0693422481,
-0.8519744873,
-0.2506662905,
1.0854506493,
-0.1572618634,
-0.3280504346,
-0.2058494091,
-0.0978190526,
-0.1137728319,
-0.018007718,
0.6716544628,
0.7975332737,
0.1486463547,
-0.3266669214,
-0.9835448265,
0.0901311114,
0.6785971522,
-1.140904665,
-0.1496207714,
0.2586582005,
0.2068310827,
0.153214708,
0.6217167377,
-0.2713207006,
0.3723138869,
-0.0493703894,
0.1180165708,
0.0256837383,
-0.2663749158,
-0.3938694,
0.3660120964,
0.107835941,
0.0771720707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05176v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05176v2 | RRWKV: Capturing Long-range Dependencies in RWKV | 2023-06-08T13:17:06 | 2023-06-09T02:56:20 | Leilei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Owing to the impressive dot-product attention, the Transformers have been the
dominant architectures in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
Recently, the Receptance Weighted Key Value (RWKV) architecture follows a
non-transformer architecture to eliminate the drawbacks of dot-product
attention, where memory and computational complexity exhibits quadratic scaling
with sequence length. Although RWKV has exploited a linearly tensor-product
attention mechanism and achieved parallelized computations by deploying the
time-sequential mode, it fails to capture long-range dependencies because of
its limitation on looking back at previous information, compared with full
information obtained by direct interactions in the standard transformer.
Therefore, the paper devises the Retrospected Receptance Weighted Key Value
(RRWKV) architecture via incorporating the retrospecting ability into the RWKV
to effectively absorb information, which maintains memory and computational
efficiency as well. | [
-0.5281835794,
-0.5053977966,
0.2666071057,
0.3199876249,
-0.0055718645,
-0.1613581479,
0.061949838,
-0.4571781456,
0.1797759086,
0.3532914221,
-0.5097203851,
-0.1397020072,
-0.6993294358,
0.0560017861,
-0.4721100628,
0.9356454015,
0.3276569843,
-0.5531162024,
-0.1306860149,
-0.4395903647,
-0.4147934914,
-0.27536273,
-0.4256097376,
-0.3321578801,
0.7082588077,
0.2234408259,
0.6974998713,
0.4160055518,
0.431881249,
0.2617904842,
-0.0174190979,
-0.2510322928,
-0.7686949372,
0.4587036669,
-0.3538811505,
-0.4509985745,
-0.4010549188,
-0.1090784296,
0.9179621935,
0.2906835675,
-0.2255771607,
0.3333530128,
0.0966660082,
0.9716268778,
-0.8965321779,
0.3414403796,
-0.4841013551,
0.3785212338,
-0.1516436189,
-0.3242346048,
-0.6933535933,
0.0067394152,
0.3658296168,
-0.6101484299,
0.2518039942,
0.0347275399,
0.6381764412,
0.2836521268,
-0.3246225119,
0.0583653077,
-0.866166234,
1.2626453638,
-0.4603186846,
0.8096132278,
0.2399069816,
0.11458195,
-0.4074746668,
-0.9018828273,
-0.5548362732,
0.0327275619,
-0.1117204055,
0.2117003947,
-0.4971286654,
-0.1055819169,
0.3689244688,
0.3772807419,
-0.4985543191,
-0.1243592799,
-0.4471631646,
-0.1030202731,
0.1696050465,
0.3425769508,
-0.1148298755,
-0.5225846767,
-0.4810569882,
-0.1502567828,
-0.4559564888,
0.2399162054,
-0.2377547026,
0.114793703,
0.1078479365,
0.5874632001,
-0.4986384213,
0.8254503608,
0.2974472642,
-0.2733331919,
0.3475296199,
-0.2911242247,
-0.5293733478,
-0.2314904481,
0.7636244297,
0.0670026094,
0.294260174,
-0.1978787631,
0.0497159027,
-0.4359010756,
0.7504415512,
-0.6745404005,
-0.0548898093,
0.3628925383,
-0.8060287237,
-0.3680718839,
-0.04467519,
-0.9451501369,
0.1703198552,
0.0271928385,
0.2789152265,
-0.492159009,
-0.0905365497,
0.0474882275,
-0.4196133316,
1.0033006668,
0.062718749,
-1.0979756117,
0.1243380085,
0.9563813806,
0.8335864544,
-0.2279958129,
-0.2203512043,
-0.5882675648,
0.2725541294,
0.1055185124,
0.8792386651,
-0.4608484209,
-0.5016525984,
-0.279779464,
0.0049866536,
0.2002133131,
-0.2314759195,
0.5424997807,
-0.7497006059,
0.495783329,
-0.0882726535,
-0.2347043008,
-0.4113382101,
0.3815549314,
-0.6254146695,
1.1910731792,
0.1940650493,
-1.0866357088,
0.3050585687,
-0.1767888516,
-0.6710806489,
0.2179347724,
-0.2227749974,
-0.744235754,
0.1612394601,
0.2825217545,
0.5273098946,
-0.1304592192,
-0.041106768,
-0.2589940727,
-0.4947991073,
-0.0019665628,
-0.5765943527,
0.7130610347,
0.0067786626,
-0.216410175,
0.0909522474,
-1.1665612459,
-0.0321933106,
0.1941217184,
-0.5898633599,
-0.4136313498,
0.170454666,
-0.0929857492,
0.0195656475,
0.0530173257,
-0.5850057602,
0.2256607711,
-0.5298886299,
0.4961713552,
0.6837879419,
0.0591970906,
0.5551301837,
-0.1333600283,
0.5600331426,
-0.1796045303,
0.2110839486,
-0.0622200668,
-0.5779473782,
-0.6833330989,
-0.1752223521,
-0.0577508435,
0.6354367137,
-0.5989896059,
0.2963600457,
-0.4243014753,
-0.3283652365,
-0.1360957474,
-0.3132252693,
0.260766536,
0.7669953704,
0.4992451668,
-0.2037049085,
-0.5469302535,
-1.0733952522,
-0.1516827941,
-0.1088210195,
-0.4079789519,
0.1680901498,
0.2717298269,
-0.0583254918,
1.0168794394,
-0.6504926682,
-0.4972434938,
-0.3201918602,
0.2757032216,
0.3896834552,
0.0971685126,
0.1764834523,
-0.6730087399,
-0.2271371484,
-0.12283241,
-0.5352506042,
0.1172067448,
-0.2561817765,
-0.0396837443,
0.1267463863,
0.4245588183,
-0.9304075241,
0.5002138019,
0.4690180421,
-0.0524406247,
0.5333623886,
-0.0437044017,
0.1238029972,
-0.964397192,
0.4054627419,
-0.1213742271,
-0.3464633822,
-0.5038303137,
-0.1321609467,
0.1671867967,
0.0406136215,
-0.5006050467,
0.2162576616,
-0.5018162727,
-0.2928679287,
-0.2682733834,
0.0575017259,
0.1959778666,
0.7054296732,
0.1682783067,
0.7465118766,
-0.0498656556,
-0.5891643167,
0.5957605243,
0.3864304125,
-0.038708955,
0.7952746153,
-0.7910445929,
0.0646512434,
-0.3363751769,
0.4855189323,
-0.8807920814,
0.1557212323,
0.4404664934,
-0.7861238122,
0.2857906818,
-0.0416035652,
-0.0237195063,
-0.1084345281,
-0.5272300839,
0.5549523234,
0.539511919,
-0.4080883861,
1.2712119818,
0.1279345304,
-0.0029312605,
-1.0700626373,
-0.8764895201,
-0.1226197854,
-0.1441576183,
-0.4804712236,
0.1685012728,
0.7175197005,
0.0060601435,
0.0838505253,
-0.014612616,
0.2146547735,
-0.2139694244,
0.4190314114,
0.2732768059,
-0.2601362765,
0.3348306417,
-0.4366913736,
-0.4781400561,
0.2658418119,
-0.3617218733,
0.3062983453,
0.2650754154,
0.0193164945,
-0.4679709673,
0.7386164665,
0.6442649961,
-0.3091315627,
0.6901168823,
0.5113998652,
-0.1372347623,
-0.5166418552,
-0.4365442395,
0.0275287163,
-0.4721200168,
0.798772037,
-0.4107499123,
-0.8087328672,
0.2601763904,
0.2861784101,
0.1681402177,
0.641348362,
0.4814456105,
-0.2117442936,
0.4865083992,
0.6024773717,
-0.3797115386,
0.6000822186,
0.0684863105,
0.2913982868,
-0.9420288801,
-0.203343153,
-0.5007911325,
-0.3938588798,
-0.3548902571,
-0.3332832158,
0.1660918444,
-0.3298910558,
-0.2757038474,
0.3259727657,
-0.6995562315,
0.14476946,
0.7077876925,
-0.0442407355,
0.2675501406,
-0.1290088892,
0.2026273757,
-0.1131139472,
-0.6085445881,
0.1638096422,
1.1020315886,
0.6617407203,
0.8583887815,
-0.03222505,
0.4531966448,
0.1331518888,
-0.0605205223,
-1.1491384506,
0.5329529643,
-0.0713849291,
-0.1402546316,
-0.3526107073,
-0.42746225,
-0.9896986485,
0.2210912853,
-0.219131887,
-0.3447386324,
0.2758965492,
0.1725220084,
-0.4315001965,
0.0260978639,
-0.4544766843,
0.5995289087,
0.2576659024,
-0.2314390242,
-0.4862140119,
-0.7254679203,
0.2642280459,
0.2487748116,
-0.1811661571,
0.428440094,
0.0594767965,
0.7841731906,
-0.247248888,
0.7939310074,
-0.0570513867,
-0.112201184,
0.0296063237,
-0.1715448201,
0.8468490243,
0.0929667875,
0.3970615864,
0.0380798206,
-0.2726694942,
-0.33888188,
-0.7320860028,
0.4715413451,
-0.5407764912,
-0.6131355762,
-0.6366741657,
-0.4888339937,
-0.2133713216,
0.3033697605,
0.1498731226,
0.2538392246,
-0.3435584903,
0.4434910715,
1.008430481,
-0.3961537182,
0.5267351866,
0.244452849,
-0.1772927493,
-0.4987550974,
0.5516988635,
0.0080151325,
0.5522665381,
0.7983739972,
-0.002622114,
-0.1297990084,
-0.4113462567,
0.0224247444,
0.2127263099,
-0.7117632627,
-0.368917346,
-0.8612859249,
-0.4283783734,
-0.3622223735,
-0.1138718277,
-0.5731208324,
-0.5319606662,
-0.1650377661,
-0.030506663,
0.588688612,
0.7110422254,
0.1188990474,
-0.0477223732,
-0.9043461084,
0.7517886162,
0.5777598023,
0.4072748721,
0.3658680618,
-0.4095206857,
-0.3146478534,
-0.3321384788,
-0.2060310096,
-0.5154802799,
0.2707617581,
0.1628652066,
0.4831896424,
0.0790705308,
-0.1054581255,
0.4978648126,
-0.5272425413,
0.6326290965,
0.0858484283,
-0.7635762095,
0.343223691,
-0.1524097174,
0.9885568023,
0.3420001268,
0.0945821479,
-0.8439888954,
-0.5174965858,
-0.1052778065,
-0.9604767561,
0.4737364054,
0.0626532361,
-0.0628184825,
-0.0636971295,
0.3910370767,
-0.1252908856,
-0.2453598529,
-0.6780237556,
-0.2814227343,
-0.3759346902,
-0.0915647224,
0.2460826933,
-0.4764271975,
0.1207510605,
-0.0193903912,
0.5382397771,
0.1557096988,
0.5235769153,
0.4814556241,
0.0529297553,
0.2587230802,
0.4221796095,
0.5012362003,
0.2262883335,
-0.3804170191,
0.1513254642,
0.2492333204,
-1.1157273054,
-0.0726530403,
-0.1667203754,
-0.0653994605,
-0.1183697954,
0.4716038704,
0.4407434762,
0.2809592783,
-0.2083807588,
0.3650223613,
-0.2387094647,
-0.2098526657,
-0.436937511,
-0.1913206875,
0.4201288521,
0.4889014065,
0.5667108893,
0.0194637198,
0.1978649944,
-0.2628198266,
0.5712572932,
0.6202233434,
-0.3260048628,
0.0442209765,
0.4599659145,
0.2520961761,
-0.2576629817,
1.0385007858,
0.0816113055,
-0.3882057965,
0.4452337325,
0.3520665765,
1.0011107922,
-0.1754172146,
-0.1747099161,
0.4090114534,
0.0363010317,
0.04185009,
0.2390227616,
-0.4371930957,
-0.596811235,
-0.7631309628,
-0.4423824847,
-0.2226945609,
-0.1745830029,
-0.9250490069,
0.3317019641,
-0.4849992394,
-0.1093820855,
-0.1312856823,
-0.4197154939,
-0.5256285667,
0.2486936599,
-0.0424162447,
0.7075973153,
-0.3747291267,
1.1289207935,
-0.0729450658,
-0.1036621481,
-0.6411537528,
0.1549360454,
-0.1506976485,
-0.9550162554,
0.9719269872,
0.1494632214,
-0.5944074988,
-0.0707279444,
0.0598968156,
-1.0325723886,
1.1799914837,
-0.3182672262,
-0.5956350565,
-0.1619484276,
0.2855276763,
0.5038315058,
0.0033815445,
0.02370473,
0.4500228763,
0.3269257247,
0.1636166871,
-0.7191778421,
0.168811366,
-0.1043726802,
0.1002615392,
0.6710954309,
-0.5821064711,
0.5295751691,
-0.121044457,
-0.4947932661,
-0.3820400536,
1.1100816727,
0.1673347503,
-0.1808506697,
0.312769413,
0.8808528185,
-0.0050015948,
0.1075537652,
0.8669204712,
0.0782812163,
0.6087493896,
1.1985864639,
0.2306047529,
1.3493589163,
0.8470394611,
-0.4943191707,
0.2951598465,
-0.0299890563,
-0.2241532207,
0.6723872423,
0.0283691231,
-0.1447936296,
0.2724419534,
0.2728333175,
-0.4820303023,
0.5834987164,
0.2892860472,
-0.589525938,
-0.2449461669,
0.0206632167,
-0.1235090643,
-0.2530309558,
-0.2198358774,
0.7220607996,
0.2342547625,
-0.5882281065,
0.5619718432,
-0.1292295307,
0.9541066289,
-0.7076682448,
-0.2202053666,
-0.020152241,
0.3595414162,
-0.3916482627,
-0.8823292851,
0.7321120501,
-0.41146788,
-0.5982471704,
-0.3452363014,
0.7034439445,
-0.1037444323,
-0.3953270316,
0.3900405169,
-0.0765487254,
-0.3815747499,
0.1131092161,
-0.3860573173,
0.0653283149,
0.0198128801,
-0.7648814321,
0.3805159032,
0.2115887403,
0.2875862122,
0.7332344651,
0.3375170529,
-0.0345471613,
0.0546131432,
-0.1612838656,
0.6493165493,
-1.0879822969,
-0.4978504479,
-0.8003267646,
0.4729593992,
0.0745131522,
-0.3594759405,
0.7967895865,
0.3133053184,
0.5759415627,
0.0190509763,
0.741850853,
-0.0776155367,
0.6190627813,
-0.2179299593,
0.5934993625,
-0.1171846762,
0.0406495072,
0.0430149473,
-0.8061103821,
-0.4490717053,
0.6109445095,
-0.3100124002,
-0.2138460577,
0.6987310052,
0.4400767386,
-0.0350821428,
0.1589584798,
0.0924384147,
0.1528524309,
0.4101601839,
0.9946891069,
0.5318740606,
-0.5163565874,
0.7306761146,
-0.1145492792,
-0.2886224687,
0.0943579599,
-0.9450736046,
-0.6456509829,
-0.3987523019,
-0.0261771865,
-0.4648112059,
-0.0472006127,
0.4499179125,
0.3558957279,
-0.737718761,
0.0769715235,
-0.1488828808,
0.0183280725,
-0.3434458077,
-0.3701556623,
0.3596999943,
-0.3119875491,
-0.412968576,
0.155538097,
0.8340477347,
-0.2861258686,
-0.5087169409,
0.2688640654,
-0.2373210639,
0.0416641049,
0.7866700292,
0.6673266888,
-0.6807975173,
-0.6185845137,
0.071548745,
-0.1935765147,
0.4669664502,
0.8570967913,
-1.1927573681,
0.3670580387,
0.8726465702,
0.7633373141,
0.5945050716,
0.074206911,
0.9890351892,
-0.4700097144,
0.3335931003,
0.2573641539,
0.1672837138,
0.0509162061,
-0.6006472111,
0.0013596164,
0.0866885632,
-0.8697568178,
-0.3244663179,
0.4795233309,
-1.1611206532,
-0.3286243379,
1.0522216558,
-0.133137539,
-0.3386202455,
-0.4717063606,
-0.047083009,
0.1389179975,
-0.386831373,
0.7257202268,
0.6582708359,
-0.3130874336,
-0.5054141879,
-0.4901109636,
0.3533648551,
0.4723625183,
-0.3657082915,
0.1439055055,
0.2874645591,
0.4161640108,
0.1643151343,
0.5506922007,
-0.3126836717,
0.2354177386,
0.2154385,
-0.0549463481,
-0.0168590005,
0.0326821618,
-0.5442871451,
0.6149474382,
-0.2021817565,
-0.4897594154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05126v1 | Mapping Brains with Language Models: A Survey | 2023-06-08T11:50:58 | 2023-06-08T11:50:58 | Antonia Karamolegkou, Mostafa Abdou, Anders Søgaard | cs.CL | cs.CL | Over the years, many researchers have seemingly made the same observation:
Brain and language model activations exhibit some structural similarities,
enabling linear partial mappings between features extracted from neural
recordings and computational language models. In an attempt to evaluate how
much evidence has been accumulated for this observation, we survey over 30
studies spanning 10 datasets and 8 metrics. How much evidence has been
accumulated, and what, if anything, is missing before we can draw conclusions?
Our analysis of the evaluation methods used in the literature reveals that some
of the metrics are less conservative. We also find that the accumulated
evidence, for now, remains ambiguous, but correlations with model size and
quality provide grounds for cautious optimism. | [
-0.3403344452,
-0.678183496,
0.8107972145,
0.2272791564,
0.1961038411,
-0.1228192076,
-0.4998103678,
-0.6872506738,
0.1942704767,
0.2115739584,
-0.2154778987,
-0.230975017,
-0.738807857,
-0.1235705018,
-0.5804672241,
0.6813114882,
0.3385820985,
0.4002647698,
-0.277371645,
-0.2373177707,
-0.4253556132,
-0.5536855459,
-0.7570824027,
-0.6039059162,
0.6539658904,
-0.1679534018,
0.7172009945,
0.6001960635,
0.4927648604,
0.2314610779,
-0.2098639458,
-0.1836916208,
-0.3152985871,
-0.1784841418,
-0.0663962439,
-0.5704569817,
-0.7211383581,
0.1038932651,
0.7119253874,
1.3939136267,
-0.0978290811,
0.1887861639,
0.0779106766,
0.5997709632,
-0.6085541844,
0.0636996552,
-0.5660774708,
-0.0606070645,
-0.0685244054,
-0.0504071079,
-0.5975459814,
-0.1413518637,
0.5002371073,
-0.2884139419,
0.0625091046,
0.0301681347,
0.737901926,
-0.0831120014,
-0.6002341509,
-0.4422951043,
-0.8039484024,
0.945736289,
-0.8846359849,
0.5786914229,
0.4817833304,
0.0857869834,
-0.1990305781,
-0.7682669759,
-0.5833242536,
-0.4801262915,
-0.1389855444,
-0.0024885477,
-0.3557795882,
0.0040553664,
0.5835690498,
0.1520446837,
-0.5828362703,
0.2869348526,
-0.480047375,
-0.3543018997,
0.6778678894,
0.1573681086,
0.5860213041,
0.1593744904,
-0.3106998205,
-0.1811376363,
-0.8953348398,
-0.0106774233,
0.469779402,
0.2257335484,
-0.2699620128,
0.685993135,
0.0779508799,
0.9836242795,
-0.3522878587,
0.0639740378,
0.1924574524,
-0.4508412778,
-0.1079363674,
0.0215322915,
1.1974482536,
0.5350485444,
0.3533998728,
-0.4359326363,
-0.1388948709,
0.408211261,
0.237608552,
-0.4835619032,
-0.2550318241,
0.1624794453,
-0.5706948638,
0.1590605974,
-0.0990309268,
-0.6662364006,
-0.4405144155,
-0.2773060203,
0.1848233789,
-0.3986319304,
-0.7039968967,
0.2652005553,
-0.3078959882,
0.3918812871,
0.1349324882,
-0.9123731256,
0.5700980425,
0.7165124416,
0.6635791659,
-0.510931015,
-0.3031489253,
0.1645756066,
-0.3576672375,
-0.6248474121,
1.1309353113,
-0.6390832067,
-0.2994039059,
0.1302036941,
-0.0921037644,
-0.0322552249,
-0.5436612368,
0.3570603728,
-0.4668266773,
0.5262718797,
-0.7039114833,
-0.4985089898,
-0.3509069681,
0.2347233295,
-0.7044696212,
0.9845176935,
0.054844927,
-0.6979715228,
0.3933106959,
-0.4624296725,
-0.2759471834,
-0.2340722531,
-0.4867989123,
-0.1414261907,
0.448967427,
-0.1393711865,
0.1285800338,
-0.6584044695,
0.3779604137,
-0.4028062224,
-0.4793249071,
0.6266658902,
-0.2103409618,
1.0546774864,
0.1206289381,
-0.1939772069,
-0.1077221408,
-0.6102520823,
-0.0678803176,
-0.01764277,
-0.191116333,
-0.4088442922,
0.252073884,
0.2300881445,
0.3164351881,
0.1688722968,
-0.7907032371,
0.2506415248,
-0.4049616456,
0.4568580389,
0.1545324177,
-0.1522018015,
0.5060364604,
-0.4501852095,
0.5543132424,
0.2046177387,
-0.3622918129,
-0.006668956,
-0.7443006039,
-0.6982918382,
-0.0596256517,
0.5805466771,
0.0235333908,
-0.0850880891,
0.4634939134,
-0.6182451844,
-0.4135837555,
-0.6375896335,
-0.3688482344,
0.2269262373,
0.3478602767,
0.2608520687,
-0.7684749961,
-0.4872798324,
-1.2408052683,
-0.4044215083,
-0.3213475049,
-0.2169603258,
0.2174457014,
0.4289116263,
0.0133147677,
1.0589659214,
-0.3029308617,
-0.0505899787,
-0.0254370105,
0.3168039024,
0.0409687422,
0.3273928463,
0.940980196,
-0.3023962677,
-0.2704097331,
0.075912416,
-0.7915401459,
0.0580022894,
-0.0814934298,
0.2147096545,
-0.0652757436,
0.4520723522,
-0.50688833,
0.3470153809,
0.5756636858,
-0.1776622236,
0.3599572778,
-0.021413004,
0.4218226075,
-0.6966773272,
0.3088297248,
-0.0323691405,
0.088308312,
-0.8397896886,
-0.2085945606,
0.1820816249,
0.0540538803,
-0.1694017351,
0.5880382657,
-0.7704269886,
-0.3598009348,
-0.5632064342,
0.3849213421,
-0.4075603187,
0.571265161,
0.0535872802,
0.5194431543,
0.8020842075,
-0.2611628771,
0.0570476353,
-0.0500999503,
-0.6211458445,
0.166968435,
-0.6967464685,
0.3435545266,
-0.2181679457,
0.1118727922,
-1.2727452517,
-0.0191088505,
0.0781053305,
-0.5748827457,
0.2124831825,
0.0474972911,
-0.274775207,
-0.2717704475,
-0.0793223232,
0.3335718215,
0.7109014392,
0.0038279458,
0.7039574385,
0.6229032278,
-0.2394790947,
-0.4232020378,
-0.8678967953,
0.1959797442,
-0.241560325,
-0.3992361724,
0.2716561258,
0.0554357879,
-0.5588929653,
0.1136501282,
-0.143207863,
-0.2547667027,
0.1258002669,
0.2644077539,
0.0036732554,
-0.533064425,
-0.2520269752,
-0.1113844216,
0.1685532331,
0.4935165942,
0.133088991,
0.5585175753,
0.1571211666,
-0.390784055,
-0.2882672846,
0.3331966698,
0.6220086217,
-0.0747312605,
0.6467629075,
0.075539127,
-0.6694379449,
0.0879387259,
-0.5099071264,
-0.2994834185,
-0.3741910756,
0.532135129,
-0.3292784393,
-0.7770019174,
0.7553290129,
-0.293105185,
0.0520827137,
0.4334777296,
0.6463105679,
0.0035644323,
1.1350822449,
0.6752695441,
0.0340938196,
0.4965857267,
-0.1182085499,
0.3570330143,
-0.8524280787,
-0.2244552225,
-0.6992872357,
-0.4787361324,
-0.5946368575,
-0.1397074014,
-0.0612783432,
-0.1633676142,
0.1781345904,
0.3363696933,
-0.4226023555,
0.2015985847,
0.2418694198,
0.0514090993,
0.0868956745,
-0.0507289954,
-0.064169012,
-0.2923358679,
-0.7430840135,
-0.3936421573,
1.3230021,
0.1184710562,
0.4150801003,
-0.0361685753,
0.1566977054,
0.0641869158,
0.6374493837,
-0.7131386399,
0.5859645605,
0.2381323725,
-0.9449357986,
-0.0354842059,
-0.2147815526,
-1.2071079016,
0.1892341971,
-0.2843444645,
-0.8660361171,
0.4789133668,
-0.0432972871,
-0.2585470676,
-0.1910498589,
-0.7655416131,
0.6900023222,
-0.2179629058,
-0.1695110947,
-0.3805649579,
-0.5671982765,
0.4933665693,
-0.2332950085,
0.1912889034,
-0.0611292608,
0.0777538493,
1.009521246,
0.1097915843,
0.5648380518,
-0.0717028677,
-0.2599892616,
0.2939369082,
-0.1143661365,
-0.0146837393,
-0.4346957207,
-0.1818410307,
0.3796580434,
0.0981966555,
-0.5142627358,
-0.7506158352,
0.9273217916,
-0.5581653714,
-0.4710320532,
-0.6997023821,
-0.7005450726,
-0.2913908064,
0.1614063531,
0.031278491,
0.3159101903,
-0.3915640116,
0.3158800602,
0.2662517726,
-0.0648982823,
0.5975840092,
0.5011259913,
-0.3490709364,
-0.2630012333,
0.539233923,
0.296960324,
0.2006537616,
0.0657006726,
-0.0409008935,
-0.0770071596,
-0.876514256,
-0.1331391931,
0.3925116062,
-0.3874721527,
0.2135936618,
-0.5239945054,
-0.1199860126,
-0.3829377294,
0.2201208919,
-0.5331531167,
-0.4052511156,
0.2381952107,
0.0963715911,
0.0676958039,
0.7737463117,
0.2342626601,
0.4667498767,
-0.3961830437,
0.1903983057,
0.0093081789,
0.1517579108,
0.2488748431,
-0.4560337663,
-0.5553616881,
0.5181396008,
-0.1800552607,
-1.2855407,
0.237930581,
0.0997733623,
0.7000823617,
0.4738839269,
-0.4212380052,
0.8105477095,
-0.6835662723,
1.1038137674,
0.2255528867,
-0.5976862907,
0.1971028,
-0.3071509302,
0.2401156574,
0.4162166715,
0.6761859655,
-0.3827742934,
-0.4689160883,
-0.6941831708,
-0.5087598562,
0.3896288872,
-0.0224580094,
0.0990117639,
0.0213620812,
0.3819310069,
0.0164435618,
0.0351396725,
-0.4862790704,
-0.4034377337,
0.1730173975,
-0.2366597503,
0.091462858,
-0.1609125584,
-0.2770797014,
-0.3347460628,
0.0337560549,
-0.0513902046,
0.6076562405,
-0.0511691943,
-0.0493675061,
0.0468947887,
0.1462921649,
0.6780462861,
1.137290597,
-0.0162136909,
0.2458004206,
0.1663160026,
-0.5913925171,
0.0149124209,
-0.081933707,
-0.1019557789,
-0.0167730525,
0.6373850107,
0.7540493608,
0.2269780487,
-0.6748170257,
0.4036296904,
-0.0761512369,
-0.1421219707,
-0.3244927526,
0.0791337937,
0.3611115217,
0.1192192286,
0.2756742239,
0.2325005382,
0.1896382421,
-0.7237659097,
-0.0570472814,
0.6686678529,
-0.5320415497,
-0.7690530419,
0.4927253425,
-0.2225992084,
-0.5251303315,
0.7014397383,
0.1981007606,
-0.3090687394,
0.5473672152,
0.5674479604,
0.8000125289,
-0.0389666855,
-0.3861210942,
0.4618339241,
0.4430014491,
-0.3411716819,
0.4884162545,
0.0826206654,
-0.8509212136,
-0.6039737463,
-0.4828954041,
-0.258875221,
0.3414886594,
-0.8517603874,
0.2137695253,
-0.0414961837,
-0.6069997549,
0.2247018814,
-0.0340236388,
-0.7273111343,
0.1860452592,
0.1470318884,
0.8292838335,
-1.2375319004,
1.1243698597,
0.9100317359,
-0.3591069579,
-0.5190876126,
-0.1032876894,
-0.1742001921,
-0.5551291108,
0.5780394077,
-0.0936177894,
-0.0557149164,
0.0087423865,
-0.547350347,
-0.8478197455,
0.8239874244,
0.5050808787,
-0.3931743801,
-0.2952354848,
0.0980954915,
0.8670398593,
-0.5612095594,
0.4415085614,
0.7188814878,
0.3984932303,
-0.3283074796,
-0.8187752366,
-0.0293854028,
-0.4060369432,
-0.0281324983,
0.0729586333,
-0.3526773453,
0.4697521329,
0.0091030411,
-0.4761298895,
0.0700151697,
0.8546288013,
0.2000001669,
0.179619804,
0.4263451099,
0.5224593878,
0.5177462697,
-0.159307763,
0.9594904184,
-0.6442903876,
0.3242303133,
1.0350607634,
-0.3398444951,
0.8950508833,
0.7363004684,
-0.4662110806,
0.4964341819,
0.640583694,
0.0572981983,
0.5608519912,
0.254170537,
-0.0984925926,
-0.1318914592,
-0.1526508629,
-0.2876624465,
0.4557453692,
0.5176884532,
-0.5435085893,
-0.0568368994,
-0.1755431145,
-0.0244446397,
0.0964869186,
0.2681137919,
0.6490082741,
0.1761020124,
-0.9785095453,
0.5232055187,
-0.2376134694,
0.5762152076,
-0.5870429277,
-0.0489022546,
-0.3802866638,
-0.1827898026,
0.1133332923,
-0.6176553369,
0.3496355712,
-0.050360363,
-0.0949735194,
-0.4551201761,
0.6303294897,
-0.5387634635,
-0.0601700582,
0.4124803841,
0.7282847762,
0.4855358899,
0.1848656088,
-0.3082292378,
0.2919086218,
-0.1511226892,
-0.3224377036,
0.4562612474,
0.4168336391,
0.0471464768,
0.4418679476,
0.5971569419,
0.5746120214,
0.3057951629,
-0.1729035527,
0.6912107468,
-0.871194005,
0.0529911518,
-0.9237741828,
0.4750072658,
-0.2146150768,
-0.5568386912,
0.9066240788,
0.7845056653,
0.7678754926,
-0.0740141571,
0.58034271,
-0.0787340403,
0.2245396525,
-0.2914414704,
0.9407588243,
-0.5224713087,
-0.0066415812,
-0.1059237197,
-1.051731348,
-0.261713624,
0.6467814445,
-0.3116882443,
0.1850972772,
1.0559450388,
0.784745276,
-0.1661849171,
0.0579163879,
0.3785003126,
0.3323920369,
0.0559907258,
0.4352733195,
0.9160789847,
-0.5262607932,
-0.0861961022,
0.0237407219,
-0.2515803874,
0.0910690799,
-0.871714592,
-0.6372313499,
-0.8560125828,
-0.5962579846,
-0.1617473066,
-0.087042585,
0.5486710668,
0.6352307796,
-0.707746923,
-0.5735787153,
0.0671441928,
-0.1588093191,
-0.4341712594,
-0.104921557,
0.3798973262,
-0.0575281121,
-0.8482795358,
0.4972321987,
0.203904137,
-0.1374081522,
-0.4391440451,
0.1080933139,
-0.3628306985,
0.2533213496,
0.3783327341,
0.3097048402,
-0.8617333174,
-0.4498734176,
0.4069154263,
-0.434704721,
0.1403302997,
0.9445849061,
-0.7576277852,
0.3831150234,
0.9251098633,
0.6091747284,
0.5632246137,
-0.3871535659,
0.7576186657,
-0.4141608775,
0.1225058958,
0.069770582,
0.5469824076,
0.4544637203,
0.2291253507,
0.5051971078,
0.0632892847,
-0.6095709205,
-1.1736588478,
0.1766005754,
-1.3116794825,
-0.0319329426,
1.0475068092,
-0.1509878635,
-0.4568238556,
0.0197149031,
0.0409089178,
0.2036425918,
0.1384537816,
1.0112267733,
1.1198015213,
-0.3571711481,
-0.0019833464,
-0.8067724705,
0.395487994,
0.4959113598,
-0.5930396914,
-0.0373844691,
0.5761886239,
0.2656708658,
0.5259088278,
0.5623948574,
-0.1663839072,
0.2947152257,
0.2243809551,
0.2039348483,
0.4071026146,
-0.2500741482,
-0.5134702921,
0.1798040867,
0.2768225372,
0.1168633401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05119v1 | Reference Matters: Benchmarking Factual Error Correction for Dialogue Summarization with Fine-grained Evaluation Framework | 2023-06-08T11:41:39 | 2023-06-08T11:41:39 | Mingqi Gao, Xiaojun Wan, Jia Su, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factuality is important to dialogue summarization. Factual error correction
(FEC) of model-generated summaries is one way to improve factuality. Current
FEC evaluation that relies on factuality metrics is not reliable and detailed
enough. To address this problem, we are the first to manually annotate a FEC
dataset for dialogue summarization containing 4000 items and propose FERRANTI,
a fine-grained evaluation framework based on reference correction that
automatically evaluates the performance of FEC models on different error
categories. Using this evaluation framework, we conduct sufficient experiments
with FEC approaches under a variety of settings and find the best training
modes and significant differences in the performance of the existing approaches
on different factual error categories. | [
-0.2576322556,
-0.3760130703,
0.3888818026,
0.2951385081,
0.042499654,
-0.0594407655,
0.0393683985,
-0.2015188187,
-0.0019167454,
0.3201867342,
-0.5618396401,
-0.2712943852,
-0.3300539255,
0.3963610232,
-0.3333090246,
1.5995730162,
0.1423835158,
0.3715718985,
-0.4713139534,
-0.6700732112,
-0.2742778659,
-0.3988064826,
-0.3793255687,
-0.1461644769,
0.2375908941,
0.5130088925,
0.7951882482,
0.4146630466,
0.6544628143,
0.3564924896,
-0.3354344368,
0.5266618133,
-0.6702678204,
-0.2476304322,
-0.692617774,
-0.5117304921,
-0.7005704045,
-0.0011611343,
0.5969613791,
0.8148987293,
-0.1677173823,
0.2283000797,
-0.1007302701,
0.6137441397,
-0.6923082471,
0.3599977493,
-0.4457415044,
0.1452505887,
0.2389113605,
-0.4047692716,
-0.493598491,
-0.7401001453,
0.3148664236,
-0.5144501328,
0.970802784,
0.2679672539,
0.7258040309,
0.2670856118,
-0.3100714386,
-0.3293401003,
-0.944594264,
0.6989746094,
-1.0065047741,
0.222913444,
0.3835749924,
0.1602284312,
-0.0734300092,
-0.6644952297,
-0.4280355275,
-0.0355573371,
-0.3310447335,
0.1388234645,
0.0334526449,
0.3758715093,
0.4525479972,
0.6906673908,
-0.0860212371,
-0.5882850289,
-0.6100346446,
-0.4676219225,
0.7478091121,
0.4951996505,
0.011389249,
-0.2308759987,
-0.1190246269,
-0.0852697864,
-0.4496323168,
-0.0661033764,
0.1279583275,
0.351451993,
-0.197815299,
0.3319488168,
-0.675051868,
0.281853497,
0.4192348719,
-0.2762981355,
0.2184746414,
-0.8884792328,
-0.1531148851,
0.3316714764,
0.5782312155,
0.8012089133,
-0.0000171586,
-0.2674071789,
-0.0133954389,
-0.2509113252,
0.3539429009,
-1.0441977978,
-0.2423515916,
0.1681407392,
-0.1917859167,
-0.4376491606,
0.0096136825,
-0.6894378662,
-0.4695065916,
-0.3621378541,
0.2433781922,
-0.0453577079,
0.1917716712,
-0.0690925792,
0.1264848709,
-0.1459649354,
0.663600266,
-1.0725179911,
0.4088382721,
0.3380157053,
0.7731370926,
0.03446595,
-0.0747510642,
-0.6577051878,
-0.1123470664,
-0.506447494,
1.0870747566,
-0.199130863,
-0.4743509591,
0.2131472528,
0.2769104242,
-0.028001396,
-0.4637244642,
0.9444361329,
-0.0792605355,
0.1006910279,
-0.6584289074,
-0.419609189,
-0.2685678899,
0.1267932355,
-0.6909685135,
0.9574838877,
0.2060593218,
-0.899386704,
0.3168246448,
-0.5044576526,
-0.3328097165,
-0.3201636374,
-0.0136292465,
-0.4105239213,
0.1056786701,
0.1090984344,
0.4465880692,
-0.4721745849,
0.5852368474,
-0.0726603121,
-0.319758147,
0.3257240653,
-0.5720359683,
0.3442593217,
0.185850203,
-0.3933021724,
0.0396330468,
-0.9091842771,
-0.0518602841,
-0.3416605592,
-0.2514743805,
-0.0747326314,
0.1705839336,
-0.2364320457,
0.042938605,
-0.0969536155,
-0.3924877942,
-0.1334419399,
-0.5329684019,
0.0478835255,
0.5319038033,
0.1066025943,
0.3721687496,
-0.653421998,
0.18869102,
0.0190305486,
-0.0772587806,
-0.4465444982,
-0.122813873,
-1.1521852016,
0.0522563793,
0.605178535,
0.5987786651,
-0.6358633637,
0.1730972826,
-0.3029657602,
-0.406647861,
-0.4087075591,
-0.1003422365,
0.669344306,
0.5665743351,
0.2354196161,
-0.4278033376,
-0.5248521566,
-0.8304556012,
-0.0799540058,
-0.466786921,
0.2024399936,
0.3990483284,
0.5246505141,
-0.1336451024,
1.1798125505,
-0.5029187799,
-0.3019083738,
-0.0358539969,
0.6784208417,
0.0583411083,
0.4869848788,
0.6141640544,
-0.4007712901,
-0.079458639,
0.1574437171,
-0.6169925332,
-0.5406852961,
-0.2472499311,
-0.1016403139,
0.2798187733,
0.4699229002,
-0.279247731,
0.6263538003,
0.3457484543,
-0.2889255583,
0.7341016531,
-0.201068148,
0.7882041335,
-0.9504507184,
0.0229206607,
-0.1125802845,
-0.4070282876,
-0.483364135,
-0.32754004,
-0.1644146442,
0.1155514941,
-0.3128367364,
0.3029851615,
0.0291070361,
-0.0446980186,
-0.1619197428,
0.272587657,
0.3251634836,
0.7593281269,
-0.1557224393,
0.9952011704,
-0.289922595,
-0.4829702675,
0.4417698085,
0.4838798344,
-0.2256003767,
0.8574517965,
-0.6272681355,
0.0238754023,
-0.1812657416,
0.4345313311,
-1.1791599989,
-0.3823848963,
0.1110550538,
-0.2702654302,
0.0823317319,
0.0113885067,
-0.2911501825,
0.1744229048,
-0.3591506481,
0.4328896403,
-0.1256361902,
-0.4163170457,
0.5876525044,
0.1367671043,
-0.4236675203,
-0.5196082592,
-0.5550108552,
-0.3452759087,
0.214522779,
-0.4946473539,
0.1173418164,
-0.2094041854,
-0.2810442746,
-0.1528649926,
-0.451282829,
-0.0750183314,
-0.1042926088,
0.2599900067,
0.0914667025,
-0.2850683928,
0.1281129271,
0.0566152446,
-0.1726497412,
0.2069717646,
0.2896751761,
0.1693197787,
-0.3385172486,
-0.3611197174,
-0.406382829,
0.2112734616,
0.5247392058,
0.0162813962,
0.4992296398,
0.3349002004,
-0.2587584257,
0.1158961952,
-0.7009411454,
0.0125087081,
-0.3831151724,
0.4395267665,
-0.0412501059,
-0.5270400047,
0.7425966859,
-0.3196475208,
0.3121332526,
0.6563339829,
0.4959295094,
-0.0593362041,
0.7157782316,
0.5352345705,
-0.0069227875,
0.1817738414,
-0.2809253931,
0.22419402,
-0.680151701,
-0.1459825784,
-0.8458960056,
0.105285123,
-0.3691517711,
-0.6147438288,
0.2098351866,
-0.073380813,
-0.0811309144,
0.1799758226,
-0.042187348,
0.6106755137,
0.2017842531,
-0.0208410174,
0.7831826806,
-0.2684442103,
-0.2931171954,
-0.1896762103,
-0.6298131347,
-0.6080169082,
0.9037510753,
0.322884053,
0.7525721192,
0.1254309714,
0.1253263503,
0.6774476767,
0.4641214609,
-0.8145792484,
0.2724592686,
0.0113713704,
-0.8893997073,
-0.1359955966,
-0.4246520996,
-0.1499155462,
0.3185329437,
-0.4176755548,
-0.6121050715,
0.5317254066,
0.3117997348,
-0.765335083,
0.235943675,
-0.8014842272,
0.8514282703,
0.0977120921,
-0.4277127683,
-0.1709851325,
-0.5678829551,
0.3043022454,
-0.0231695995,
0.2215570062,
-0.3066991568,
0.4321175218,
0.6381500959,
-0.6404323578,
0.8837394714,
0.1579361409,
0.0113206971,
0.2709420025,
0.0770220459,
0.6435854435,
0.3034653962,
-0.0739226192,
0.0096567646,
0.287861824,
-0.2863918543,
-0.7065909505,
0.1800590754,
-0.5933308005,
-0.3725630343,
-0.7172987461,
-0.4606716931,
-0.542134881,
-0.1762044728,
0.3009307384,
1.0000298023,
-0.763394475,
0.2791851163,
0.8481511474,
0.0670890361,
0.2473613471,
0.6476672292,
-0.0206206832,
-0.6594067812,
0.8096429706,
-0.0390875489,
0.427090764,
0.1895265579,
0.0220549125,
0.0011634758,
-0.5352467299,
-0.6277036071,
0.0984039232,
-0.8206564188,
-0.4651432037,
-0.6389734149,
-0.3049156666,
-0.2371699214,
-0.2735202014,
-0.6589937806,
-0.3184440136,
-0.1423697472,
-0.2413638085,
0.3889435232,
0.5442891121,
-0.0036915629,
0.7021526098,
-0.7611094713,
0.3529907465,
0.3598648012,
0.322963208,
-0.2709518969,
-0.7778230309,
-0.6454545259,
0.2185564935,
-0.557302773,
-0.4599836171,
-0.0559703186,
0.4047121406,
0.2779842317,
0.4631263018,
0.3122722805,
0.9501484632,
-0.4770804048,
0.7235476375,
0.0567246601,
-1.1316622496,
0.3605378568,
-0.4044357836,
0.3065659702,
1.0758682489,
0.027432302,
-0.6350978613,
-0.3405067027,
-0.8480064273,
-0.5605994463,
1.1973167658,
0.557433486,
-0.0115915323,
0.2410937995,
0.2020587176,
-0.0912063122,
0.3044030964,
-0.2848691642,
-0.3034297228,
-0.2430173606,
-0.2929241657,
0.0852033049,
-0.5229530931,
-0.5779790878,
-0.253998071,
1.0747380257,
-0.459880054,
0.1577367783,
0.5946241021,
-0.1085362062,
-0.2365992963,
0.2293395549,
0.8522105813,
0.8156698346,
-0.4474180043,
-0.3149635196,
0.7713364363,
-0.4896772206,
0.0652164668,
0.088384226,
-0.0752751753,
0.4437815845,
0.5451238751,
0.9541121721,
0.68664217,
-0.6111518145,
0.6552878618,
-0.2712557912,
-0.1062979475,
-0.2125921547,
0.0871421248,
-0.2491437048,
0.2427606732,
0.252523005,
0.5527600646,
0.6177232862,
-0.6035276055,
0.3153054416,
-0.1032642052,
-0.3641544282,
-0.2501829863,
0.5161297917,
0.6730358601,
0.1602551937,
0.1068339124,
-0.2024679929,
-0.4040177763,
0.5264743567,
0.2722222507,
0.9075779319,
-0.3793313801,
0.4759401679,
0.5834656358,
0.2595753968,
-0.2810746133,
-0.2076344192,
-0.2005310059,
-0.8367028832,
-0.5315272808,
-0.3828376234,
-0.9413753748,
-0.1722206622,
-0.7136645913,
0.1876781732,
-0.6630361676,
-0.1431098729,
0.1664236486,
0.1547035873,
-0.2678890526,
0.5466755033,
-0.1347095817,
0.6975563169,
-0.9693730474,
0.319542706,
0.3408218622,
-0.2132463008,
-0.8481164575,
-0.1201126203,
0.2280619442,
-0.1053316221,
0.3195281923,
-0.1540900469,
-0.4793157279,
-0.4818439782,
-0.3605511487,
-0.7339096665,
0.9810987115,
0.3082100749,
-0.4777824879,
0.1195743978,
0.1038171723,
0.5696325302,
-0.5424460769,
0.6569635272,
0.9341179132,
0.249948293,
0.3059649467,
-1.1187316179,
-0.2412666827,
-0.3431223631,
0.1233671084,
-0.0353098363,
-0.8339021802,
0.5480801463,
-0.1838814169,
-0.2461465001,
0.2874028683,
0.7318341732,
-0.0799224973,
0.4781403244,
0.2334735394,
0.400955379,
0.79809165,
-0.5375853777,
0.768276751,
-0.0793276355,
0.7397178411,
1.5338171721,
-0.2724292576,
0.3094240427,
0.0480600148,
-0.4343353808,
0.3077252209,
0.3298847675,
0.0497112311,
0.4238705635,
-0.1292928755,
-0.43150267,
0.0151342368,
-0.3532721996,
-0.1792102158,
0.2681512833,
0.2790069878,
-0.4190070629,
-0.3403263092,
-0.3168276846,
0.2571192086,
0.1854403317,
-0.1952652633,
0.9916881323,
-0.1470813453,
-0.480225414,
0.5903221369,
0.0396952778,
0.2904211879,
-0.5267030001,
-0.1417107731,
-0.6650109887,
0.2117327601,
-0.5825175643,
-0.2539099455,
0.4907978177,
0.2807294726,
-0.6062984467,
0.2202830613,
0.3758030236,
-0.484598428,
-0.4386077523,
-0.2450338751,
-0.0612537302,
0.0834057182,
0.2287598997,
-0.3109894097,
0.1010214537,
0.2669912875,
0.175107494,
-0.1779339463,
0.6434401274,
-0.1384194046,
0.4676795006,
0.5240660906,
-0.1034342721,
-0.2126710117,
0.154002741,
0.7253844142,
-0.7285670638,
-0.2864470184,
-0.5477232933,
0.7066976428,
-0.3352554739,
-0.6958051324,
0.488668412,
0.584182322,
0.778691113,
-0.2058587223,
0.7062237859,
-0.0581802651,
0.5404856205,
-0.674226284,
0.4917961955,
-0.1267781854,
0.2408142686,
-0.5683686733,
-0.8747928143,
-0.1106475666,
0.783172965,
-0.1752241552,
-0.1299875677,
1.0106418133,
1.0215792656,
0.0769307539,
0.6084745526,
0.2429298013,
0.3690567315,
0.0804774687,
0.154554978,
0.648527801,
-0.9408091307,
0.3945505619,
-0.4144937098,
-0.111408785,
-0.5471148491,
-0.9110662937,
-0.9641155601,
-0.5586556196,
-0.6347025037,
-0.4406625032,
0.0909101814,
1.183998704,
0.6489004493,
-1.3141957521,
-0.0773431286,
0.1963602453,
0.1156346947,
-0.1002469584,
-0.2028211504,
0.1771045029,
-0.431034863,
-0.9204013348,
-0.021173723,
0.2583221793,
0.060779009,
-0.0688638836,
0.0064649526,
-0.070203729,
0.4141479731,
0.5133104324,
0.2615378201,
-0.5203670263,
-0.4776030183,
-0.4940686524,
-0.2191857547,
0.1909535974,
1.1225516796,
-0.4694102705,
0.6784895062,
0.4726853669,
0.7417459488,
0.3236062825,
0.410611093,
0.8132392764,
-0.7587789893,
0.3726142347,
0.0470163748,
0.4138074219,
0.4359219968,
-0.3854324222,
0.7861686945,
0.352722764,
-0.6453921795,
-0.6795222759,
-0.1230460703,
-1.2277837992,
0.2788177431,
0.9549003243,
-0.4466474354,
-0.2182037979,
-0.2563287914,
-0.7089583278,
0.1127957031,
-0.4678007364,
0.7770757675,
1.1418390274,
0.0953173116,
0.3136542141,
-0.6331662536,
0.8352649808,
0.4761749804,
-0.8181536198,
0.3437105715,
0.7414287925,
0.1922160238,
0.461276114,
0.6133739948,
-0.192695573,
0.5392088294,
0.0422278009,
0.0072249561,
0.2951662838,
-0.319070816,
-0.2285607457,
-0.249948442,
-0.0630504563,
0.0863020048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05116v1 | On Search Strategies for Document-Level Neural Machine Translation | 2023-06-08T11:30:43 | 2023-06-08T11:30:43 | Christian Herold, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Compared to sentence-level systems, document-level neural machine translation
(NMT) models produce a more consistent output across a document and are able to
better resolve ambiguities within the input. There are many works on
document-level NMT, mostly focusing on modifying the model architecture or
training strategy to better accommodate the additional context-input. On the
other hand, in most works, the question on how to perform search with the
trained model is scarcely discussed, sometimes not mentioned at all. In this
work, we aim to answer the question how to best utilize a context-aware
translation model in decoding. We start with the most popular document-level
NMT approach and compare different decoding schemes, some from the literature
and others proposed by us. In the comparison, we are using both, standard
automatic metrics, as well as specific linguistic phenomena on three standard
document-level translation benchmarks. We find that most commonly used decoding
strategies perform similar to each other and that higher quality context
information has the potential to further improve the translation. | [
-0.2899021208,
-0.4953815937,
0.6401401162,
0.060579434,
-0.4655440152,
-0.0822520703,
-0.1223058477,
-0.2979829907,
-0.0890177712,
0.1762098074,
-0.4280867577,
-0.5844134092,
-0.7188399434,
0.3462686241,
-0.6505137682,
0.6339635849,
-0.2968151271,
0.3403057754,
0.0560271703,
0.1038076282,
-0.6810666323,
-0.8027850986,
-0.8645193577,
-0.4668495059,
0.4477134049,
-0.0816733018,
0.5444377065,
0.8323318362,
0.5777022243,
0.2339617312,
-0.4541027844,
0.2192324847,
-0.229743138,
0.3834770918,
-0.0522815622,
-0.4583504796,
-0.2844932675,
-0.0178744383,
0.362536788,
0.535584867,
-0.0433414541,
-0.301948607,
-0.0362099186,
0.3780421913,
-0.5131307244,
0.1249440461,
-0.5866144896,
0.3573337197,
-0.1120266542,
-0.6719356179,
-0.6418600082,
-0.0740483925,
0.1402709931,
-0.6535079479,
0.3345292807,
-0.0533951968,
0.7027701735,
0.1006299034,
-0.8238993287,
-0.5346375108,
-0.6092432141,
0.6290807724,
-0.8242236376,
0.5466787815,
0.5727242231,
0.1812818497,
-0.1007988751,
-0.5452714562,
-0.0807230622,
-0.1386146992,
-0.1859600097,
0.1602324992,
-0.1075189486,
0.0997588113,
0.2456303537,
0.545350194,
-0.566752851,
-0.1311627328,
-0.034364067,
-0.2200586945,
0.1667020172,
0.1781924367,
0.4334135056,
-0.4859539568,
-0.4077382386,
-0.365357399,
-0.5571404099,
-0.1090065539,
0.1264095306,
0.1714116484,
0.3791456521,
0.4982148111,
-0.4430688918,
0.7737825513,
-0.2032004148,
0.1852266043,
-0.0220539123,
-0.7062149644,
0.0511006974,
-0.0077389292,
0.4143746197,
0.4268158078,
0.0374723785,
-0.5269386172,
-0.8969790339,
-0.180128336,
0.5824050307,
-0.666372776,
0.2441878319,
-0.0863157511,
-0.6033263206,
-0.1629218161,
-0.1796357632,
-0.2059184462,
-0.2675228417,
-0.418307811,
0.5710784197,
-0.8700478673,
-0.0983350277,
0.2397736907,
-0.4016465843,
0.4185784459,
0.47829777,
-1.0073390007,
0.1640038341,
0.6716715693,
0.9695548415,
-0.03713765,
-0.1831854284,
-0.4655221105,
-0.1494340003,
-0.7398582697,
0.5743400455,
-0.199350521,
-0.2763520181,
0.1346238852,
-0.2758108079,
-0.4453865588,
-0.3616542518,
0.7356772423,
-0.8470389843,
0.2007367015,
-0.700119853,
-0.5942630172,
-0.3502074182,
0.5750405788,
-0.5646772981,
0.7924661636,
0.191222325,
-0.7748671174,
0.1604844481,
-0.8070266247,
-0.5524153113,
-0.1666876078,
0.0608421825,
0.1593629569,
0.5370402932,
0.5013257861,
0.5322732925,
-0.3003796935,
0.0736102462,
0.3216178119,
-0.6720827222,
0.1901193857,
-0.7348977327,
0.6532716155,
0.4397278428,
-0.3817278445,
-0.2484018952,
-0.475848943,
-0.0520382188,
0.318718195,
-0.7025758028,
-0.528262794,
0.0113059152,
0.0470781624,
0.0436162986,
0.2137689441,
-0.377158612,
0.1181646809,
-0.567489326,
0.8081389666,
0.2599133551,
0.0253140088,
0.7133861184,
-0.1698265523,
0.4003517032,
0.0705799088,
-0.1160213277,
-0.5118163824,
-0.1597382426,
-0.6578980684,
0.2723034918,
0.4912029207,
0.4430226088,
-0.8396656513,
0.1062178016,
-0.1552787572,
-0.0588899218,
-0.6820222735,
-0.1542418599,
0.5115954876,
0.7950125337,
0.5701860189,
-0.2223008275,
-0.3207214773,
-0.6447304487,
-0.2889739275,
0.2050688267,
0.0821759701,
0.2439972907,
0.3077139258,
-0.0500012115,
0.5997574329,
-0.1325611174,
-0.0828661844,
-0.1717679203,
0.2756045461,
0.1273854375,
0.4076834321,
0.5332839489,
-1.0619543791,
-0.4925762117,
0.3857595921,
-0.9767382145,
0.2155729234,
-0.0352530964,
0.0719612464,
0.3094187975,
0.7484736443,
-0.5232720375,
0.5984072685,
0.3115183413,
-0.1714946777,
-0.0030362983,
-0.4316668808,
0.498980701,
-1.2692439556,
0.0739955232,
-0.1885592639,
-0.2687074542,
-0.9090742469,
0.5801365972,
0.5110160112,
-0.0299911704,
-0.3566928506,
0.2445995808,
-0.6867201924,
-0.1994127333,
-0.346855104,
0.0895681158,
0.2189282179,
0.4173969626,
0.090886943,
0.9605712891,
0.134405911,
-0.4369232953,
0.1554673314,
0.2293384969,
-0.3157482147,
0.451107204,
-0.571100533,
0.3823490739,
-0.043876715,
0.2772699594,
-0.936835885,
0.0137195708,
-0.0451490022,
-0.6800817251,
0.4467678368,
-0.3008615673,
-0.6592966318,
-0.1288399547,
-0.0586660095,
0.4467829168,
0.415017426,
-0.6012302041,
0.3855201602,
-0.0321655981,
0.173586607,
-0.8079968691,
-0.8563897014,
0.4543589354,
-0.0892726332,
-0.7891392708,
0.6242836714,
0.0581380241,
0.2002495527,
-0.1479409784,
-0.4836912155,
-0.0619625524,
0.3815397918,
-0.1694730669,
-0.2274437845,
-0.5672661066,
-0.2366357446,
-0.0061266464,
-0.399668932,
-0.0399418809,
-0.5443374515,
0.7975238562,
-0.2198061794,
-0.2299900651,
-0.1989395767,
0.7605056167,
0.5547482371,
-0.4982610941,
0.7810109258,
0.7815227509,
-0.5356363654,
-0.0521898568,
-0.3459961712,
-0.2435602695,
-0.4351021945,
0.192923218,
-0.7411239743,
-0.6271710992,
0.7306879759,
0.1170689464,
-0.1564841419,
0.3053918481,
0.4641335011,
-0.2410006076,
1.2182633877,
0.6358991265,
0.2219275236,
0.5423732996,
-0.5269236565,
0.3243644238,
-1.1610716581,
-0.1865449548,
-0.5396673679,
-0.2587794363,
-0.2899599671,
-0.2790219784,
0.233115539,
0.2254793346,
0.2105410695,
0.9610856175,
-0.5125014186,
0.3980855644,
0.8624275923,
0.1205435768,
0.29986009,
-0.0626367852,
-0.4802132249,
-0.0022704755,
-0.9106384516,
-0.3007590175,
0.7955714464,
0.3395350277,
0.52463305,
0.0991771072,
0.9330406189,
0.0711834729,
-0.0539824069,
-0.9040865898,
0.2997156084,
-0.2934164107,
-0.6824362278,
-0.2770055532,
-0.633733511,
-1.0918520689,
0.5123887062,
-0.0718756467,
-0.3226764202,
0.3174257278,
-0.0947997272,
0.0079735415,
0.1388606429,
-0.6891328096,
0.9889250398,
-0.1208650693,
0.2810262144,
0.0991408303,
-0.614510119,
-0.1373106539,
0.0514396615,
-0.125371635,
0.2749877274,
-0.2389225364,
0.3032263815,
-0.4203106761,
0.3078200221,
-0.04276485,
-0.1153089255,
-0.1251260489,
0.2464673221,
0.4571313262,
-0.1882927269,
-0.3219124973,
0.0580617003,
0.1748681962,
-0.2796028554,
-0.7008321881,
0.4867627919,
-0.7466342449,
-0.4867874384,
-0.3008821011,
-0.8801428676,
0.0243612509,
0.6412658691,
0.8514374495,
0.7322830558,
-0.2979701161,
0.521512866,
1.0191317797,
-0.0066741859,
0.5831602216,
0.5212107897,
0.2784796655,
-0.1401640624,
0.7293927073,
0.2408910096,
0.1315005869,
1.006238699,
0.122705996,
-0.2989406884,
-0.9376621246,
-0.5459305644,
-0.2556307316,
-1.1576546431,
-0.46042642,
-0.8133280277,
-0.4049348831,
-0.5637726188,
-0.3146830201,
-0.3538188934,
-0.1702222675,
-0.2183249593,
0.0220668484,
0.1090886593,
0.5470907688,
0.1429425031,
0.4574098587,
-0.5533222556,
0.3578277528,
-0.0478490219,
0.1402196586,
0.0100878058,
-0.4798741341,
-0.3699203134,
0.0006335205,
0.0536482073,
-1.2045527697,
0.4322996736,
-0.2927573025,
0.6972967982,
-0.151744619,
0.1370908916,
0.2550240755,
-0.4551751912,
0.4005210996,
-0.1708332896,
-0.9403907657,
0.437835902,
-0.6232191324,
0.4805981517,
0.5236589313,
0.3432486653,
-0.919123292,
-0.1827549934,
-0.24575378,
-0.9161032438,
0.8732357621,
0.3865819573,
0.2937850058,
-0.0995084494,
0.411419481,
-0.2616845667,
0.1112924144,
-0.6447994113,
0.0739105642,
-0.3222929537,
-0.180137679,
-0.0862768739,
0.0571844354,
-0.0824022964,
0.0728702471,
0.2109542191,
-0.0588153116,
0.3795836866,
0.3570893109,
-0.4916446209,
0.0290846545,
0.2731351852,
0.5613888502,
0.2720995843,
-0.4151622653,
0.3100792766,
0.1806570143,
-0.3511640429,
0.1294921637,
-0.0793562457,
-0.4200615883,
0.226967752,
0.210157305,
0.8728865385,
0.3578469455,
-0.0890895277,
0.6589974761,
-0.4055326879,
-0.517660737,
0.07855618,
0.0163023435,
0.3610399067,
0.1385473907,
0.2050781995,
0.2235805243,
0.4333456755,
-0.4255438149,
0.0653202161,
0.349058032,
-0.2398770005,
0.1662190109,
0.5020820498,
0.1949102134,
-0.58250314,
0.7114747167,
-0.0719995275,
-0.5876295567,
0.6695596576,
0.6951455474,
0.8950349092,
-0.0440405607,
0.1132064313,
0.1191219091,
0.6462337971,
-0.4785899818,
-0.0489331186,
-0.3238648772,
-0.5431696773,
-0.2793299258,
-0.4240758717,
-0.3047219515,
0.080410175,
-0.7452999353,
0.0447500795,
-0.3184938431,
-0.1304947734,
-0.1138271466,
0.0911690071,
-0.674061954,
0.0660709962,
0.0359133109,
1.2559520006,
-0.3522566855,
0.8568680882,
0.640629828,
-0.5235171914,
-0.6603210568,
0.045100268,
-0.0752394274,
-0.6905017495,
0.2603752315,
0.1996257305,
-0.2454639077,
0.1964642406,
-0.055549942,
-0.9562323689,
1.2941094637,
0.326723367,
-0.1138092875,
-0.4887907803,
-0.0155637106,
0.5426448584,
-0.510242641,
0.1898446977,
0.4184067845,
0.4214451015,
-0.0459546186,
-0.6642996073,
0.061787948,
-0.3099791706,
0.5369675756,
0.1383538544,
-0.191356644,
0.7898977399,
0.2646890879,
-0.3832527697,
0.3171114028,
0.345310986,
-0.2811374962,
0.4996298552,
0.1994126439,
0.3471035659,
0.5030102134,
-0.0840172917,
1.3176949024,
-0.3613298237,
0.2740747631,
0.7977445722,
0.3054804206,
0.9379495978,
0.2127191871,
0.5715488195,
-0.0511166118,
0.8538706899,
0.1215411276,
0.6863455772,
0.0454637185,
0.0588171296,
-0.2107269019,
0.232171312,
-0.4643390477,
0.3856806159,
0.2953831255,
-0.606426239,
-0.4044372439,
0.0249366481,
-0.0320687816,
0.1962098032,
-0.0677976757,
0.9190511107,
0.1135138795,
-0.8248100281,
0.8875199556,
0.6416572332,
0.6762287021,
-0.4727432728,
0.1899162233,
-0.662773788,
0.0158348903,
-0.0749887303,
-0.5129539371,
0.2925141454,
-0.0336051323,
-0.5281442404,
-0.5960868597,
0.7789583206,
-0.3599287271,
0.0550925024,
0.4222983718,
0.6139109731,
0.1363484263,
-0.3653527796,
-0.787121594,
0.0863074213,
-0.1392947882,
-0.3008804619,
0.3992630541,
0.6030981541,
0.0525384694,
0.3813463449,
0.4576746225,
-0.2799804509,
0.2166916579,
-0.0166782308,
0.615167737,
-0.8022418618,
-0.4137042463,
-0.4317919016,
0.2505548596,
0.086192593,
-0.3151877224,
0.6583930254,
0.2778131068,
0.9549377561,
-0.0218894612,
0.4876463115,
0.1692045778,
0.1588382423,
-0.7828826904,
0.8048449755,
-0.5650178194,
0.2153312862,
0.0030490367,
-1.1180860996,
-0.1781286895,
0.9500436783,
-0.180966422,
0.1516798586,
0.8735540509,
0.793636024,
-0.3262557685,
0.06617973,
0.5906985402,
-0.0723541975,
0.2548325658,
0.6803836823,
0.9347910285,
-0.861256659,
0.6147304177,
0.0236903019,
-0.0039621945,
-0.542707324,
-0.7861735225,
-0.7053937316,
-0.6486516595,
0.0880677402,
-0.2916170955,
0.2456680685,
0.5266443491,
0.9135192633,
-0.3739998043,
-0.1281416863,
-0.1653872281,
0.2228328139,
-0.2879109383,
-0.0885399953,
0.0517361499,
-0.6851315498,
-0.7055655122,
0.8848822713,
0.1686610878,
-0.0071359011,
-0.100673601,
-0.2148025185,
-0.2007353306,
0.2215728462,
0.5560875535,
0.1331648231,
-0.5212279558,
-0.0092116799,
0.5497958064,
-0.6775414944,
0.2451170832,
1.0731019974,
-0.2807145119,
0.4656747878,
0.8636674285,
0.9751648903,
0.6592469811,
-0.2184021175,
0.8356915116,
-0.7188586593,
-0.329873383,
0.259298861,
0.311142385,
0.4098118842,
-0.5325505137,
0.6632685065,
0.087633878,
-0.3490333259,
-0.6603096724,
0.1105618998,
-0.9617874026,
-0.5129179358,
1.0289510489,
-0.2088481486,
-0.2458472848,
0.0473145805,
-0.1590872258,
0.3594923317,
-0.2691162527,
0.3992176652,
0.8900336623,
0.1050036699,
-0.0740562975,
-0.7574228048,
0.3994550705,
0.5300699472,
-0.2637224793,
-0.0503911562,
0.1981301308,
0.2635762095,
0.2789582908,
0.696423769,
-0.3734124005,
0.4190565944,
0.1868033111,
-0.4207417071,
-0.2846661508,
-0.501234889,
-0.6118664742,
0.2084620893,
0.0178002715,
-0.101772055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05115v1 | Closing the Loop: Testing ChatGPT to Generate Model Explanations to Improve Human Labelling of Sponsored Content on Social Media | 2023-06-08T11:29:58 | 2023-06-08T11:29:58 | Thales Bertaglia, Stefan Huber, Catalina Goanta, Gerasimos Spanakis, Adriana Iamnitchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Regulatory bodies worldwide are intensifying their efforts to ensure
transparency in influencer marketing on social media through instruments like
the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (UCPD) in the European Union, or
Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act. Yet enforcing these obligations
has proven to be highly problematic due to the sheer scale of the influencer
market. The task of automatically detecting sponsored content aims to enable
the monitoring and enforcement of such regulations at scale. Current research
in this field primarily frames this problem as a machine learning task,
focusing on developing models that achieve high classification performance in
detecting ads. These machine learning tasks rely on human data annotation to
provide ground truth information. However, agreement between annotators is
often low, leading to inconsistent labels that hinder the reliability of
models. To improve annotation accuracy and, thus, the detection of sponsored
content, we propose using chatGPT to augment the annotation process with
phrases identified as relevant features and brief explanations. Our experiments
show that this approach consistently improves inter-annotator agreement and
annotation accuracy. Additionally, our survey of user experience in the
annotation task indicates that the explanations improve the annotators'
confidence and streamline the process. Our proposed methods can ultimately lead
to more transparency and alignment with regulatory requirements in sponsored
content detection. | [
-0.5412415862,
-0.8695040345,
0.2076588869,
0.2523215413,
-0.5596829057,
0.1070530191,
-0.3866561949,
-0.5772286057,
0.081268698,
0.622487247,
-0.518003583,
-0.5311837196,
-0.856061697,
-0.0107175549,
-0.2745847106,
1.2842888832,
-0.1226676553,
-0.0178305767,
-0.2068849802,
-0.0807643905,
-0.5127539039,
-0.3828484416,
-0.788695991,
-0.3764385283,
0.4993683994,
0.4074678719,
0.5372126102,
0.4358815849,
0.4972174168,
0.2078562826,
-0.2167672068,
0.3214257658,
-0.7046781182,
-0.1350485533,
-0.0328415558,
-0.071632728,
-0.3850662112,
0.2333407104,
0.185132727,
0.6306223869,
-0.1109225675,
0.1653229445,
0.4097390771,
0.3651780784,
-0.3932397366,
0.5202918649,
-0.5327528119,
-0.2733100653,
0.2184667438,
-0.2966002226,
-0.5034418702,
-0.489887625,
0.2177297622,
-0.779150784,
0.5135558844,
0.1729536653,
1.2406728268,
0.348004967,
-0.459038049,
-0.5825951099,
-0.8737660646,
0.4321421981,
-0.5138034225,
0.1924968213,
0.3976621926,
0.3621820807,
-0.1461667269,
-0.7136041522,
-0.4760269821,
-0.1750869751,
-0.1950277984,
0.0753537714,
-0.5114721656,
0.0669288859,
0.2907807827,
0.1239755601,
-0.4006473124,
0.0020977892,
-0.6302883625,
-0.3282234073,
0.7486333251,
-0.3230864108,
0.3887136281,
-0.0676394105,
-0.4191316068,
0.1559577286,
-0.5792328119,
0.0655621886,
0.5031498075,
0.2883810699,
-0.0469257832,
0.5056163073,
-0.3148062229,
0.450605303,
0.0611527227,
0.4723438621,
0.0892265886,
-0.0258468539,
-0.1047041789,
0.4517769516,
0.8671446443,
0.6452629566,
0.4516901374,
0.0194832049,
-0.109678112,
0.2108816952,
0.1749599576,
-0.7863134146,
-0.3759944141,
0.088796258,
-0.361923486,
-0.3013050854,
0.3415591121,
-0.5255814195,
-0.4252493382,
-0.4246453047,
0.4065434039,
-0.3389156461,
-0.3175169826,
0.2648275495,
-0.2645751834,
0.2650307119,
0.3510483205,
-0.6487677097,
0.0334719643,
0.8453394175,
0.6644531488,
0.1475193948,
0.1664839983,
-0.5746226311,
0.0969075784,
-0.3259989321,
1.0392100811,
-0.6148961186,
-0.1895199716,
0.1441456228,
0.1536715478,
0.0254699457,
-0.3642941713,
0.515384078,
-0.7480041385,
0.2418889999,
-0.4083427787,
-0.836184144,
-0.405959636,
0.2126758248,
-0.591119051,
0.7838718295,
-0.1132534295,
-0.5301870108,
0.7578750849,
-0.8984655738,
-0.3239862323,
0.1417106539,
-0.0048880484,
-0.6791937351,
-0.0182124022,
0.5255521536,
0.3744073212,
0.0859942436,
0.3620575368,
-0.5406695604,
-0.4692160785,
0.3717824817,
-0.551363647,
0.7344123721,
0.3086879551,
-0.3558761477,
0.2712654769,
-0.2146876156,
-0.4637544751,
0.1029088944,
-0.1565315127,
-0.2448302656,
-0.0586292073,
0.1048226878,
0.0388537794,
-0.1650157869,
-0.435029,
0.1846167445,
0.1445001215,
0.42313236,
0.9103474617,
0.1956573427,
0.2616998553,
-0.2334404737,
0.6800410748,
-0.2935137451,
0.2464641631,
-0.3393980265,
-0.9360398054,
-0.4961576164,
-0.2083154023,
0.4777315855,
0.1832658499,
-0.4760287702,
0.4082034528,
-0.2808101177,
-0.2720865309,
-0.631721735,
0.1311236173,
0.2473654449,
0.3707492352,
0.1823018044,
-0.3749264479,
-0.4315112531,
-0.6378297806,
-0.4606826305,
-0.0755958036,
-0.20016554,
0.2757368982,
0.5095737576,
-0.0362650305,
1.1317195892,
-0.4884451926,
-0.4672079682,
-0.2730883062,
0.4722826779,
0.1087007299,
0.2264745831,
0.2624762952,
-1.1033744812,
-0.6418098211,
0.0345166549,
-0.5115484595,
-0.3843781948,
-0.1057132035,
0.0383766517,
-0.0094568087,
0.4053053856,
-0.4321157932,
0.6830102801,
0.3480225801,
-0.4986533225,
0.5745314956,
-0.203597948,
0.3646150231,
-0.6316826344,
-0.1464889199,
0.3556043804,
-0.4475647509,
-0.4909259677,
-0.4774569869,
-0.0971567109,
-0.2000533789,
-0.2702691555,
0.3821535408,
-0.32099244,
0.1098855138,
-0.5462883115,
0.2528966665,
0.1803800911,
0.267152518,
-0.1700429767,
0.690939486,
0.4162740409,
-0.6209546328,
0.4274260104,
0.210983783,
-0.3047595322,
0.5962093472,
-0.7398290038,
-0.0029100431,
-0.3445796669,
0.6435648799,
-1.2965681553,
-0.5754058957,
0.5685087442,
-0.8519854546,
0.0695619211,
-0.6131125689,
-0.5468130112,
-0.2375824451,
-0.0873694569,
0.0923125148,
0.7205130458,
-0.6815802455,
0.3519245088,
0.5216474533,
0.1409917027,
-0.2849442363,
-0.298815012,
0.1022698209,
-0.474761337,
-0.7259075046,
0.2479426116,
0.1906059086,
-0.0869307443,
0.2425363809,
-0.2311154306,
-0.0631483123,
-0.0907827467,
0.2551469207,
0.0433251001,
-0.2106208056,
0.1629107893,
-0.1239355132,
-0.2416371256,
0.1532788128,
-0.3177994788,
0.5201284289,
-0.1493439972,
-0.3572612107,
-0.891649127,
0.0447435006,
0.2165733576,
-0.3093721569,
0.4790315926,
1.0769021511,
-0.2102605104,
-0.2902421355,
-0.4893580973,
-0.1614632607,
-0.4679747522,
-0.1291616559,
-0.0167102143,
-0.800465703,
0.5690709352,
-0.1125195846,
-0.1553178132,
0.3250035644,
0.4742854536,
-0.2500269413,
1.2480870485,
0.6730864048,
0.0357200876,
0.5896148086,
-0.2688338757,
0.3787541389,
-0.4852915704,
-0.147615999,
-0.2967633605,
-0.1826312095,
-0.6452126503,
-0.4319542348,
0.1950838864,
0.1725468636,
0.2096057385,
0.4228913784,
-0.7071698308,
0.693239212,
0.6822838187,
0.296924293,
0.3556470275,
-0.021723371,
0.2251748741,
0.2021913528,
-0.5318477154,
-0.7930034995,
0.7108224034,
0.3446172774,
0.7588149905,
-0.1540574729,
0.407156229,
0.8017359376,
0.722473681,
-0.7076553106,
0.2762162685,
0.0193440374,
-0.8237743378,
-0.0824636742,
-0.085759066,
-0.8741858602,
0.1944155395,
-0.0143595198,
-0.7356094718,
0.0753059611,
0.5722575784,
-0.2734178305,
0.291144371,
-0.8422028422,
0.9152284861,
0.0295372084,
-0.318975538,
-0.0934785828,
-0.4351109564,
0.33171767,
0.0128783602,
0.3507866263,
-0.438790679,
0.3337152004,
0.8108063936,
-0.4235152602,
1.1802433729,
-0.244999826,
-0.0895432979,
0.4020439386,
-0.2243102491,
0.5983355045,
0.1009944752,
0.2519215643,
0.1372691393,
-0.3084329665,
-0.4179962277,
-0.4040163159,
0.268339783,
-0.2218055427,
-0.4605442584,
-0.0864197984,
-0.4464409053,
0.0462501124,
0.0795840397,
0.2016271353,
0.1518563628,
-0.1654844582,
0.3951851726,
0.7523369193,
-0.1413674653,
0.1067078784,
0.1400074363,
-0.1752397567,
-0.2601204216,
0.9029455781,
-0.2220773697,
0.0490793549,
0.0171352513,
0.316535145,
-0.5106707215,
-0.4620882273,
-0.254955858,
0.1337671727,
-0.6789060831,
0.0852785185,
-0.5671267509,
0.0161075965,
-0.6353769302,
-0.3368036151,
-0.1678030789,
-0.2524464428,
-0.0903229788,
-0.1383822709,
0.3807214797,
0.7030143738,
-0.2907165885,
0.7333943844,
-0.5892672539,
0.3100911081,
0.141720295,
0.341924578,
-0.4269848466,
-0.4578117728,
-0.2939828634,
0.2434887588,
-0.3350408673,
-0.775190711,
0.1333084702,
-0.1071378514,
0.4712313414,
0.7626872063,
0.1413023323,
0.6069046259,
-0.211779505,
0.5221447945,
0.1310898364,
-0.8354793191,
0.5453392267,
-0.6649311185,
-0.251624018,
0.177055642,
0.4724057913,
-0.7929313183,
-0.5140516162,
-0.6643357873,
-0.7917072177,
0.5759782195,
0.5601695776,
0.2652382255,
0.0543672293,
0.2045755386,
0.0698662773,
0.0868538991,
-0.6005205512,
-0.022015335,
0.054481104,
-0.0268444214,
0.0487313084,
-0.3049891889,
-0.1344055831,
0.0373164341,
0.9159724712,
-0.0325154588,
-0.0194255263,
0.1830709726,
-0.2504149377,
-0.0378277153,
0.0834930837,
0.4284139574,
0.889980793,
-0.251190871,
-0.185705021,
-0.199699536,
-0.286421299,
-0.1603918374,
0.385717988,
-0.3253859282,
0.3468783796,
0.3828245997,
0.7891277671,
-0.0263433699,
-0.5518805385,
0.5292770267,
-0.1902541518,
-0.2258261889,
-0.3345294893,
0.0403409488,
-0.0407325663,
0.236209482,
0.2406280786,
-0.2925756872,
0.1208162531,
-0.2159014195,
0.7101901174,
0.4130215049,
-0.9028128982,
-0.2365729809,
1.0791040659,
0.2608829141,
-0.3538960516,
0.3855366409,
-0.1757188439,
-0.6390348673,
0.8241397738,
0.2923365235,
0.8262897134,
-0.1387175918,
0.4658709764,
0.1402347684,
0.4362485111,
-0.0499129146,
-0.1197363064,
-0.2044588774,
-0.7788510919,
-0.5342799425,
-0.3271579146,
-0.6915348768,
-0.0746219754,
-0.8197323084,
0.5828872323,
-0.0790682957,
-0.2611703277,
0.5799543858,
-0.3110477924,
-0.6024118066,
0.1287569851,
0.3375793993,
0.6639855504,
-1.0637078285,
0.6092137098,
0.6204701066,
-0.6021211147,
-0.6616390944,
0.0390704572,
0.3047652245,
-0.7367758155,
0.5855337977,
0.5292666554,
-0.0767347962,
-0.0533911251,
-0.8842929006,
-0.341470331,
0.8769395947,
0.0337620117,
-0.421656549,
0.090435341,
0.3517420292,
0.5098107457,
-0.4874485433,
0.0390377231,
0.54912287,
0.4396099448,
0.3499648869,
-0.7596482038,
0.0263527948,
-0.0116377166,
-0.234598726,
0.1285583526,
-0.3279764056,
0.2227696925,
-0.2373747975,
-0.112033084,
-0.3380345702,
0.4639664292,
0.3025031686,
0.7252015471,
0.7483842373,
0.4116909802,
0.5717377067,
-0.1885170788,
0.9976036549,
-0.1746311784,
0.8498288989,
1.0364954472,
-0.0490326434,
0.2933500409,
0.3424092531,
0.0377868228,
0.3887462914,
1.0428824425,
-0.3951639533,
0.3460674882,
0.3428455889,
-0.3183037043,
-0.3848206103,
-0.5239129663,
-0.0942781493,
0.4702453017,
0.4679739475,
-0.4564484656,
-0.387488991,
0.114807561,
0.3457071185,
-0.1293296218,
-0.1049285978,
0.747160852,
0.0461542979,
-0.5157673955,
0.2856532335,
-0.1715724617,
0.4184316397,
-0.463349849,
-0.1941754073,
-0.179352805,
0.24664554,
-0.1012064368,
-0.7390310764,
0.443284452,
0.1277181655,
0.2425890118,
-0.38445279,
0.918769896,
-0.4942809939,
-0.447272718,
0.2580894232,
0.066595614,
0.2867079675,
-0.4474360645,
-0.8144273162,
0.1648892313,
0.027756514,
-0.3286091387,
-0.314466238,
0.4721836448,
-0.0605817251,
0.6374118924,
0.9933108687,
-0.0796808302,
0.0803633109,
0.1505190879,
0.9022434354,
-0.4635562301,
-0.6381062269,
-0.8774042726,
0.6642938256,
-0.4819007218,
-0.0460576788,
0.6645249724,
0.6265870929,
1.0399549007,
0.1292183101,
0.9762529135,
-0.1585131437,
0.2256113291,
-0.3782141209,
0.8127955198,
-0.4992763102,
0.4448418021,
-0.1421905011,
-0.7315645218,
-0.4465120435,
0.2459768951,
-0.4302122593,
-0.1201537848,
0.5254988074,
0.7667118311,
-0.3443119526,
0.1043160111,
0.1790591329,
0.0890679732,
0.7827043533,
0.0767745823,
0.8539360166,
-0.3071863651,
1.0397597551,
-0.5417177081,
-0.2100210339,
-0.3905089796,
-0.8385072947,
-1.0717059374,
-0.3584501743,
-0.6726951003,
-0.7258204818,
0.1520442069,
0.761341989,
0.9213421941,
-0.8206330538,
-0.0773313344,
0.0124151632,
0.264341116,
-0.3293065429,
-0.3000130057,
0.4605675042,
-0.4424562156,
-0.8702321649,
-0.0567052513,
0.33460024,
-0.1834521741,
0.0783957541,
0.0765641406,
0.089395538,
0.0356038623,
0.4784572721,
0.2698243856,
-0.7187875509,
-0.2495573312,
-0.2242216468,
0.2019332945,
0.1835810691,
0.9982768893,
-0.3143754601,
0.6366996169,
0.4287340343,
0.5337038636,
0.6452547312,
0.4161698222,
0.6201316118,
-0.632564187,
-0.0173439961,
0.1247162148,
0.2250958681,
0.3094867468,
-0.3639904559,
0.5368071198,
0.3122026324,
-0.5741448998,
-0.7182021737,
0.1209566593,
-1.0584088564,
-0.3667883575,
1.2159597874,
-0.1790063232,
-0.3060346842,
-0.370773524,
-0.2625347376,
0.4723413289,
-0.5060411692,
1.1367605925,
0.6626648307,
-0.1701026857,
-0.0797675103,
-0.8340522647,
0.5953710675,
-0.0565109923,
-0.7070307136,
0.1681390107,
0.4399587214,
0.4556451738,
-0.0484497808,
0.7457802892,
0.0617339686,
0.226984486,
-0.2637455761,
0.2163800746,
-0.08408501,
-0.0531834736,
-0.1882141829,
-0.1310549974,
-0.2815884352,
-0.6130463481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05088v1 | The ART of Conversation: Measuring Phonetic Convergence and Deliberate Imitation in L2-Speech with a Siamese RNN | 2023-06-08T10:42:44 | 2023-06-08T10:42:44 | Zheng Yuan, Aldo Pastore, Dorina de Jong, Hao Xu, Luciano Fadiga, Alessandro D'Ausilio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Phonetic convergence describes the automatic and unconscious speech
adaptation of two interlocutors in a conversation. This paper proposes a
Siamese recurrent neural network (RNN) architecture to measure the convergence
of the holistic spectral characteristics of speech sounds in an L2-L2
interaction. We extend an alternating reading task (the ART) dataset by adding
20 native Slovak L2 English speakers. We train and test the Siamese RNN model
to measure phonetic convergence of L2 English speech from three different
native language groups: Italian (9 dyads), French (10 dyads) and Slovak (10
dyads). Our results indicate that the Siamese RNN model effectively captures
the dynamics of phonetic convergence and the speaker's imitation ability.
Moreover, this text-independent model is scalable and capable of handling
L1-induced speaker variability. | [
-0.1411257535,
-0.7306631804,
0.1085057482,
0.1451805383,
-0.251947552,
0.2267538309,
-0.2428079545,
-0.5785782933,
0.6598115563,
0.6085492969,
-0.4718833566,
-0.4135899246,
-0.3416907787,
0.1915259063,
-0.382224232,
0.6257220507,
0.1539550424,
0.3588773608,
0.3391186893,
-0.4831602871,
-0.5827741623,
0.0119791571,
-0.9226620793,
-0.2059433907,
0.6264241338,
0.5135102868,
0.3917860389,
0.5224662423,
0.3867202699,
0.4043295383,
0.2278799564,
0.0827093869,
-0.5690155625,
0.3863680363,
-0.1655150801,
-0.817702651,
-0.3598742187,
-0.0989964083,
0.8502678871,
0.4963395,
-0.2913484573,
-0.2414247841,
0.1948113441,
0.7523418665,
0.061058525,
0.070128195,
-0.7786701918,
0.0778346807,
-0.0906068832,
-0.1569285244,
-0.4924082458,
-0.2557315826,
0.4259741008,
-0.5001751184,
0.0248515978,
-0.1670240909,
0.4969560504,
0.1844753921,
0.0128302937,
-0.4092520177,
-0.8290845156,
0.5868205428,
-0.8304750919,
0.3596287668,
0.0404351391,
0.1542313248,
-0.1172472388,
-0.7846370935,
-0.7723658681,
-0.322149992,
0.1064912006,
0.3423210382,
-0.2392979115,
-0.0056899562,
-0.2381183505,
0.0953687578,
-0.6220481992,
0.2885577381,
-0.4654229283,
0.1016085222,
0.5855225325,
0.0368621498,
0.5367974043,
0.0304541159,
-0.2469554245,
-0.0503734313,
-0.0566621795,
-0.0768405721,
0.5930414796,
0.2641377151,
-0.1381593198,
0.5752442479,
0.0220539533,
0.5369429588,
-0.0375845097,
-0.1825710535,
0.0698568001,
-0.7039007545,
0.2795236111,
0.3536977768,
0.7911634445,
0.4754567444,
0.613160789,
-0.274579823,
-0.0535425171,
-0.1367867291,
0.1632921249,
-0.4727394879,
-0.4363351166,
-0.1135363728,
-0.1887091994,
-0.0389955528,
-0.1928128898,
-0.641951561,
-0.172169745,
-0.5067229271,
0.3952165842,
-0.4422582388,
-0.6941517591,
0.0961127579,
-0.1705643088,
0.3073968291,
0.0133247422,
-0.7170270681,
0.5404794812,
0.6563729644,
1.0946520567,
-0.5405548811,
-0.4376061857,
-0.158649683,
-0.2477294654,
-0.3870247602,
0.6763284206,
-0.2387734056,
-0.4997638464,
-0.2707743943,
0.1133537889,
-0.3269039989,
-0.4996322095,
0.2278332412,
-0.2935011089,
-0.0164804906,
0.1783961207,
-0.4906193018,
-0.2485285848,
-0.1028770581,
-0.6809638739,
0.9171771407,
0.0151012409,
-0.7153192163,
0.1703582406,
-0.608972013,
-0.3064328432,
0.119202137,
-0.3049349487,
-0.5103729963,
0.1151153371,
-0.2439614832,
0.2277602553,
0.188995108,
-0.0919871405,
-0.4148876369,
-0.3468331099,
0.5462555885,
-0.5085734129,
0.717651844,
0.1111246496,
-0.3578142226,
-0.1080407053,
-0.9947530627,
0.0627562702,
0.076725021,
-0.1457688063,
-0.3673475385,
-0.1551697403,
0.0028055408,
-0.1300627589,
0.0816098899,
-0.6860504746,
0.1819104403,
-0.7437614799,
0.6709444523,
0.5001654029,
0.2951431572,
0.346409142,
-0.6714459062,
0.283763051,
0.2194291651,
-0.3661009073,
-0.0046743699,
-0.6813008189,
-0.9267023802,
-0.1766676009,
0.3906682432,
0.9440358281,
-0.8177828193,
0.4163187742,
-0.7342433333,
-0.3771921396,
-0.6624215841,
0.0992490426,
0.3761024177,
0.1594789922,
-0.1216378361,
-0.9062627554,
-0.7819132805,
-0.9397044778,
-0.4627245367,
-0.4455728829,
0.0320391618,
0.4456318617,
0.3115289509,
0.1536364555,
1.0723102093,
0.4388249815,
-0.2399493307,
-0.2635272145,
0.3586170375,
0.2754436135,
0.603753686,
0.3349541426,
-0.5180095434,
-0.5659794807,
0.0717768297,
-0.4988384247,
0.0823261514,
-0.0883168429,
-0.0202572085,
0.4122972488,
0.328286916,
-0.0640037879,
0.4066942036,
0.3136666119,
0.0313885361,
0.4427992404,
-0.1826298386,
0.1620509923,
-1.3558926582,
-0.0560141243,
-0.0332490504,
-0.0115802372,
-1.0589416027,
-0.339894712,
-0.577621758,
-0.0662835017,
-0.4486422241,
0.4616841078,
-0.3375870585,
-0.4319183528,
-0.2536173165,
0.2829591632,
-0.1599238366,
0.626675725,
0.4014582932,
0.9111079574,
0.2647481263,
-0.3846502304,
0.2962447405,
0.0787670314,
-0.805480957,
0.7610701919,
-0.7980351448,
0.4050196409,
-0.0307498202,
0.128136605,
-1.6022213697,
-0.0770243183,
0.2507643104,
-0.6405055523,
0.2865332663,
-0.049794998,
-0.2562991381,
-0.2697085142,
0.2014122903,
0.6076337099,
0.4366635382,
-0.319352448,
0.7065734863,
0.1219223887,
-0.6548852921,
-0.2230546325,
-0.9407110214,
0.3426190913,
-0.2600170374,
-0.7333946228,
-0.1751488149,
0.084626779,
-0.4187666476,
-0.2375015765,
0.4283813834,
-0.1224455908,
-0.1280947328,
0.0480960682,
0.1008998156,
-0.6181373596,
-0.1705750078,
-0.3262834549,
0.0828657001,
-0.0687065721,
-0.5044401288,
0.4399389029,
-0.0495780371,
-0.3254417181,
-1.0789766312,
0.2516088486,
0.826413095,
0.1326373369,
0.2759783566,
0.4364230335,
-0.0685120896,
0.1445856243,
-0.6079149246,
-0.1609969139,
-0.4021867514,
0.7017199397,
-0.6811493039,
-0.246339187,
0.6546991467,
0.1807642728,
0.2674438357,
0.0391112044,
0.5273557901,
-0.1709298342,
0.6910901666,
0.2682153881,
-0.173468858,
0.5865889788,
-0.328963697,
0.177644968,
-0.923078537,
0.0937731937,
-0.358282268,
-0.7581973672,
-0.6404538751,
-0.3813357055,
0.4723281562,
-0.0639650151,
0.0045403498,
0.4544243813,
-0.4115093052,
0.3454573452,
0.6431052089,
0.5569065213,
0.362416327,
0.3239092529,
-0.0758976936,
-0.3407532871,
-0.8159835935,
-0.1804043204,
0.89865309,
0.4610865712,
0.664078474,
0.2633333802,
0.6486290693,
0.1564530134,
-0.117376104,
-0.8950182796,
0.5059185624,
-0.2072723806,
-0.2981882691,
-0.6740071177,
-0.2091944367,
-1.0025850534,
0.1471835822,
0.3118589818,
-0.786195457,
0.4546333253,
-0.175821051,
-0.293815285,
0.3149423599,
-0.3949610889,
0.4208775759,
-0.2254914343,
-0.3466653228,
-0.3349243701,
-0.6594279408,
0.4430249333,
0.2071765959,
0.0451913252,
0.0245859567,
0.0271623507,
0.9672825336,
0.00481534,
1.0693434477,
0.0625244528,
-0.2585558295,
0.4348088801,
0.2732103467,
0.5318933129,
-0.2619736195,
-0.2862484455,
0.1923973262,
-0.0650907159,
-0.3223986924,
-0.7468560934,
0.6089158058,
-0.7629150748,
-0.3493674695,
-0.0993032902,
-0.4566326737,
-0.2277089655,
0.0410103537,
0.355781734,
0.5723081231,
-0.3993780911,
0.2239612937,
0.602350533,
0.1117040366,
0.4113073647,
0.7828949094,
-0.0673890561,
-0.8028922677,
0.9783229828,
0.351593107,
0.7423990369,
0.1279482543,
0.1017071679,
-0.4230785966,
-0.2993516028,
-0.6752693653,
0.1306833774,
-0.5922259092,
0.3665635884,
-0.6657210588,
-0.5148074031,
-0.2376667261,
0.2041190863,
-0.3493622541,
-0.5205726027,
-0.3778843582,
0.1395145059,
0.4097066522,
0.8997197151,
-0.2239216119,
0.0436409786,
-0.3226282001,
-0.0186555814,
0.4123263061,
0.3172590137,
0.2515741885,
-1.0237170458,
-0.0405093618,
0.3278714716,
-0.0584893003,
-0.6059828997,
0.0996766016,
0.6175228953,
0.3763459623,
0.4160155356,
-0.1303556263,
0.4967018664,
-0.6719663143,
0.781330049,
0.3938869238,
-0.4568368495,
0.3264865577,
-0.249938488,
0.3870908022,
0.6594632268,
0.1419405937,
-0.616871655,
-0.554382503,
-0.5308377147,
-0.3515288532,
0.4900919497,
0.2347926646,
0.1447451264,
0.0544943735,
0.4174845219,
0.0150958076,
-0.1234823167,
-0.6699748635,
-0.1734758317,
-0.1209133118,
-0.1640848517,
-0.0849998295,
-0.1714272797,
-0.2394291908,
-0.2751234472,
0.5067355633,
0.0804394782,
0.3722899854,
0.3639304042,
0.1153192967,
-0.1133846492,
0.2237415463,
1.0552347898,
0.2404277921,
0.1831318438,
0.140248239,
0.3863863051,
-0.6805768013,
0.363486439,
-0.2658240199,
0.0169341527,
0.457372725,
0.4890062809,
1.0752676725,
0.6253300309,
-0.3410065174,
0.2777921259,
-0.0826776177,
-0.3673880398,
-0.3542993069,
0.1749578565,
-0.0392085128,
0.2161281407,
-0.0166323464,
0.224147439,
0.1035127416,
-0.7941201329,
0.7047877312,
0.1680914015,
-0.5690669417,
-0.2854174376,
0.4800961614,
0.2484895289,
-0.8511722684,
0.4849829376,
-0.0009831531,
-0.6520529389,
0.6319687366,
0.5677170157,
0.9806736112,
-0.3132145405,
-0.1274545342,
0.6118140221,
0.1449245811,
0.0581048839,
0.4415410161,
-0.2393019795,
-0.7302619219,
-0.0434689559,
-0.4114494026,
-0.2861948907,
-0.1358274966,
-0.9235738516,
0.1142850518,
0.0482917763,
-0.0430966206,
-0.0054442971,
-0.0042764624,
-0.3630230725,
-0.4164988101,
-0.1562284827,
0.8117983937,
-0.4726221263,
0.8969292641,
0.1031029895,
-0.1652177721,
-0.5369720459,
-0.1695796102,
-0.1402453929,
-1.096257925,
0.7856244445,
-0.0957782269,
-0.3311358094,
0.3541687727,
-0.164603442,
-0.62662673,
1.0120307207,
0.019720491,
-1.1549969912,
0.107077308,
0.4347105622,
0.601986289,
-0.467184633,
0.3072698414,
0.8397698402,
0.3781158626,
0.3506164551,
-1.382707119,
-0.5229905844,
-0.3016985059,
0.2676407695,
-0.079384394,
-0.6120303273,
0.3102274239,
-0.3560088575,
-0.3966867328,
0.9547900558,
0.7760201693,
0.1981351078,
0.2366563827,
0.7672410607,
0.6436792016,
0.598405242,
-0.029625373,
0.5068995953,
-0.553075254,
-0.168365255,
1.3318448067,
-0.453063935,
1.1107028723,
0.2590467632,
-0.2570574284,
0.6113498211,
0.4424006641,
0.125791207,
0.3999021053,
0.5570932031,
-0.475620687,
0.1376760602,
-0.1042415649,
-0.3996026516,
0.4969099164,
0.4574176967,
-0.2985063195,
0.1363118291,
0.4832422733,
-0.2957113385,
0.0967231244,
-0.1175467968,
1.3413085938,
0.0676829815,
-0.8430583477,
0.8349023461,
-0.5392500758,
0.4794639051,
-0.3113493323,
0.013324962,
-0.1955039203,
0.1742315888,
0.153177157,
-0.96335572,
0.1822519749,
-0.4412510097,
-0.1308201402,
0.2319551408,
0.2632795274,
-1.0280884504,
-0.4394828081,
0.146019578,
0.0559566282,
0.6287152171,
0.6461839676,
-0.7921889424,
0.1570561528,
-0.1235775277,
0.1409279555,
-0.0029355821,
0.658162415,
0.3054097891,
0.5496369004,
0.3250776827,
0.2528965473,
0.3492729962,
0.3547608554,
0.1336971223,
-0.1247286797,
-0.6257545948,
-0.6496967673,
0.3518107831,
0.0165210515,
-0.4392584264,
0.4253079891,
0.6149093509,
0.5104877949,
0.0070729712,
0.6012614369,
0.338876456,
0.6640657187,
-0.6357386708,
0.7241526842,
-0.4422592819,
0.0824544355,
-0.0530063026,
-0.5810284019,
0.160262391,
0.7668642402,
-0.033935491,
-0.0143844066,
0.3573780954,
1.1237851381,
-0.1647983342,
0.4345847368,
0.5098565817,
0.4945009947,
-0.0665775985,
0.4682679176,
0.7215525508,
-0.5463383198,
0.3023800254,
-0.1314172298,
-0.2834266722,
-0.1492897123,
-0.4738117754,
-0.7751098275,
-0.8976438642,
-0.2955225408,
-0.7443916798,
0.2621052861,
0.7750442624,
0.7269479036,
-0.8845449686,
-0.6436106563,
-0.4467971027,
-0.1211507022,
-0.28034091,
-0.2901582718,
0.1640623808,
-0.2594020367,
-0.8732189536,
0.4921162426,
0.4992296994,
0.3553887308,
-0.6352205276,
-0.2093791813,
-0.1242169887,
0.2525700331,
0.2719418705,
0.6292812228,
-0.9549175501,
-0.0886519179,
0.0285509154,
-0.103857547,
0.1478155404,
0.8438501954,
-0.2923928797,
0.9322479367,
0.2281672359,
0.6877435446,
0.0981873646,
-0.2341358066,
0.7421633601,
-0.4717398882,
0.2630696595,
0.3302904367,
0.2299035192,
0.0238814913,
-0.123509258,
0.4676997066,
0.3985776007,
-0.6393619776,
-0.8908876777,
0.2808852196,
-0.915388763,
0.1566073596,
1.001835227,
-0.1087366641,
-0.153610006,
-0.4921485782,
-0.3420586586,
0.1824398339,
-0.2005452663,
0.7066738009,
0.8782214522,
-0.2228096575,
-0.4200348854,
-0.6301323771,
0.2937591076,
0.5932514071,
-0.2827140689,
-0.1822101474,
-0.1967577487,
0.3314917386,
0.2432100922,
0.5930520892,
0.1277410984,
0.6221885681,
0.083117269,
-0.0610774681,
0.4719100893,
-0.4184839427,
-0.3537584543,
-0.3826308548,
-0.0245515686,
-0.4409179389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05087v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05087v2 | PandaLM: An Automatic Evaluation Benchmark for LLM Instruction Tuning Optimization | 2023-06-08T10:41:56 | 2024-05-24T06:37:31 | Yidong Wang, Zhuohao Yu, Zhengran Zeng, Linyi Yang, Cunxiang Wang, Hao Chen, Chaoya Jiang, Rui Xie, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie, Wei Ye, Shikun Zhang, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction tuning large language models (LLMs) remains a challenging task,
owing to the complexity of hyperparameter selection and the difficulty involved
in evaluating the tuned models. To determine the optimal hyperparameters, an
automatic, robust, and reliable evaluation benchmark is essential. However,
establishing such a benchmark is not a trivial task due to the challenges
associated with evaluation accuracy and privacy protection. In response to
these challenges, we introduce a judge large language model, named PandaLM,
which is trained to distinguish the superior model given several LLMs.
PandaLM's focus extends beyond just the objective correctness of responses,
which is the main focus of traditional evaluation datasets. It addresses vital
subjective factors such as relative conciseness, clarity, adherence to
instructions, comprehensiveness, and formality. To ensure the reliability of
PandaLM, we collect a diverse human-annotated test dataset, where all contexts
are generated by humans and labels are aligned with human preferences. Our
results indicate that PandaLM-7B achieves 93.75% of GPT-3.5's evaluation
ability and 88.28% of GPT-4's in terms of F1-score on our test dataset. PandaLM
enables the evaluation of LLM to be fairer but with less cost, evidenced by
significant improvements achieved by models tuned through PandaLM compared to
their counterparts trained with default Alpaca's hyperparameters. In addition,
PandaLM does not depend on API-based evaluations, thus avoiding potential data
leakage. All resources of PandaLM are released at
https://github.com/WeOpenML/PandaLM. | [
-0.3603426218,
-0.9192685485,
0.3478429019,
0.4610475302,
-0.465957433,
0.0432676487,
-0.4010166526,
-0.1663610339,
-0.4700434506,
0.5314640403,
-0.3884373009,
-0.800642848,
-0.547055006,
0.1349134147,
-0.5581521988,
1.1308333874,
0.0384070463,
0.1054576039,
-0.2616195679,
-0.2367469966,
-0.134321481,
-0.4687875211,
-0.575206399,
-0.2125715613,
0.3000884652,
-0.0357350484,
0.6167935133,
1.0406917334,
0.5283712149,
0.2826440632,
-0.2961665094,
0.268350929,
-0.533932209,
-0.0704496652,
0.0841724351,
-0.4767109454,
-0.4916113913,
0.0487542562,
0.7370964289,
0.6837712526,
-0.5969002247,
0.5169868469,
0.1333618909,
0.812512219,
-0.6484458447,
0.3205265105,
-0.753715694,
0.0032303527,
-0.1783280373,
-0.0256731696,
-0.3389348388,
-0.8173010945,
-0.1270954907,
-0.5924784541,
0.3790203631,
0.3588294089,
0.6400180459,
0.7078527212,
-0.2895770371,
-0.1071918532,
-0.2081153989,
0.7837965488,
-0.6842582822,
0.5167531371,
0.5361046791,
0.3659082353,
-0.2797575593,
-0.4740604758,
-0.4543716013,
-0.4997895062,
0.057699956,
-0.122359179,
0.0331001841,
-0.0019346672,
0.5621501803,
0.3498374522,
-0.6832270026,
0.2717925906,
-0.3431044817,
-0.2811460495,
0.5477480292,
0.4601896107,
-0.1000341848,
0.0810007975,
-0.2862903774,
0.0107796751,
-0.7643096447,
0.0628040358,
0.6432040334,
0.0954774246,
-0.0407476202,
0.5350533128,
-0.3100495636,
1.1231033802,
0.037909843,
-0.1085244715,
0.2232315391,
0.0501091331,
-0.3852568567,
0.0283454973,
0.7536007166,
0.4780179262,
0.0486788861,
-0.133983627,
-0.5314424038,
0.0048205224,
0.2545925677,
-1.0014688969,
-0.3024502397,
0.0484860092,
-0.4976938367,
-0.2720353007,
-0.0185842849,
-0.7100534439,
-0.4863359034,
-0.5567438006,
0.1344397664,
-0.3186179698,
-0.0778543055,
-0.0500609018,
0.092197746,
0.3687880635,
0.3895279765,
-0.9865661263,
0.4505910277,
1.235075593,
0.7209047079,
-0.4580439329,
-0.2969208062,
-1.0300116539,
-0.0271880683,
-0.6686115861,
0.7799552679,
-0.6903133392,
-0.4622000158,
-0.1178677529,
0.0278707445,
-0.102291137,
-0.8148006797,
0.6544300318,
-0.5644491911,
0.0311718192,
-0.1380929053,
-0.7625017166,
-0.0952229351,
0.1702867746,
-0.6676986217,
1.0952723026,
0.2259310335,
-0.4608396292,
0.3634190857,
-0.7316718698,
-0.5059291124,
0.003948126,
0.0755498633,
-0.6953402162,
0.0806392804,
0.2112822533,
0.2270001322,
-0.6164073944,
0.1906992197,
-0.4883915186,
-0.6503480673,
0.2773281038,
-0.5987061858,
0.8845103979,
0.0979268476,
-0.2940737009,
0.3337928057,
-0.9430242777,
0.2423689961,
0.0523358211,
-0.5790910125,
-0.146308288,
-0.053502325,
-0.1417924017,
-0.1782471687,
0.3746626973,
-0.4764431119,
0.1374509335,
-0.3179045618,
0.390815109,
1.0414112806,
-0.2725663185,
0.1501758546,
-0.1776176542,
0.4898345768,
-0.1510147601,
0.6232284307,
-0.0268593524,
-0.4967924953,
-0.7749801278,
-0.3604670167,
0.4531392753,
0.446205616,
-0.2735714912,
0.7187187076,
-0.0996835828,
-0.4387862682,
-0.8613588214,
0.7394790649,
0.504793644,
0.7239099741,
0.2730713189,
-0.1932888776,
-0.177743569,
-0.8473425508,
-0.0655857623,
-0.1400193125,
0.0803461298,
0.2591610849,
0.166059643,
-0.1636401266,
0.7002692819,
-0.5737724304,
-0.0822727904,
0.0156218493,
0.1503536999,
0.3391374648,
0.3491328359,
0.450090766,
-0.5356675982,
-0.643343091,
-0.0424750075,
-0.5269705057,
-0.3713430166,
0.3074381351,
-0.3061444461,
0.5362272859,
0.1590246707,
-0.5649236441,
0.3236777782,
0.6030887961,
-0.0037137,
0.6988195181,
-0.5039471984,
-0.099956587,
-0.366096139,
-0.0274650808,
-0.0224634279,
-0.1935011446,
-0.1643083543,
0.0264602676,
0.5352036357,
-0.0210675597,
-0.3258687854,
0.5711581707,
-0.3883290887,
-0.2435338199,
-0.2657008469,
-0.0253608879,
0.0382187851,
0.5087410808,
-0.1886887699,
0.9354885817,
0.6394578815,
-0.5476680398,
0.6121708155,
-0.0011568116,
-0.7904395461,
0.6475855112,
-0.7339030504,
0.3869490027,
0.2013857365,
0.2544265091,
-0.6114451289,
-0.0726201758,
0.3221260011,
0.0674471632,
0.4172188044,
-0.140253678,
-0.7313909531,
-0.3757696152,
-0.2407474667,
0.019420512,
0.6460428238,
-0.8976761103,
0.3372333944,
0.235556677,
-0.0227154586,
-0.6436777115,
-0.1547147334,
-0.0807506442,
-0.308342427,
-0.3129757643,
-0.0576172881,
-0.419154793,
-0.1274100244,
-0.104390204,
-0.2154825181,
-0.0082771387,
0.2244429439,
0.2585670352,
0.4627437592,
-0.3150635362,
0.018622471,
0.1543411762,
-0.1536204666,
0.1106894687,
-0.0368664861,
0.5333076119,
-0.3740098476,
-0.5152046084,
-0.4584874511,
0.0685845613,
0.4022039473,
-0.5672985911,
0.5980266333,
0.8329154849,
-0.0494999699,
-0.4040435851,
-0.5903034806,
0.1652725786,
-0.4747797847,
0.3802855313,
-0.2403470874,
-0.5100319386,
0.2489961535,
0.0699041709,
0.2118600756,
0.2344057262,
0.7014796734,
0.1327016056,
1.2063118219,
0.3976449072,
-0.1928785294,
0.3188650608,
-0.1752861738,
-0.0861440897,
-1.2196388245,
-0.0505564511,
-0.4478546083,
0.039141424,
-0.3711450696,
-0.3966575265,
0.2375051081,
0.1036267132,
-0.4888229668,
0.1576390415,
-0.69562006,
0.6025244594,
0.6166686416,
0.0811895728,
0.2518688738,
-0.3044957519,
-0.1371451616,
0.2362777144,
-0.3277183771,
-0.5982370377,
1.3760360479,
0.1762880236,
0.9553194642,
-0.0228913967,
0.6193407178,
0.2906381488,
0.8123245835,
-0.6586263776,
0.6212646365,
-0.2037114948,
-0.4849862158,
-0.4203082025,
-0.5741583705,
-0.8826701045,
0.4213844836,
0.124795258,
-0.5989148021,
-0.240699172,
0.1209287047,
-0.3846152723,
-0.0628323257,
-0.8850231767,
0.8794477582,
-0.7033919692,
-0.4422594607,
-0.2450449169,
-0.5395007133,
0.445186764,
-0.4424542785,
-0.0562441424,
-0.4939509332,
-0.2636372447,
0.5877668858,
-0.4349884987,
0.6669470668,
-0.2016440183,
-0.2491526008,
-0.0087616974,
-0.1129413545,
0.4092273116,
0.0141278412,
-0.4794818759,
0.3289709985,
0.0231386125,
-0.2990921438,
-0.7210933566,
0.8450614214,
-0.8372097611,
-0.9423402548,
-0.1710437685,
-0.5533879995,
-0.201648578,
0.2027066499,
-0.1346377432,
0.4189675748,
-0.1860393882,
0.2517212629,
0.6110376716,
-0.3567339778,
0.176153332,
0.8069221973,
-0.4035784006,
-0.3322061002,
1.0605494976,
-0.0370805636,
0.1773963273,
0.3063792884,
0.278744489,
-0.5439988971,
-0.4928131998,
-0.7122169137,
0.1577685326,
-0.8431565762,
-0.3599390984,
-0.3912427425,
-0.1963602901,
-0.2371128201,
0.1215137541,
-0.1953305304,
-0.3054136932,
-0.3667333126,
-0.0135490885,
0.1854058057,
0.5140311718,
0.1685158461,
0.2342634797,
-0.5775038004,
0.5047087073,
0.451949805,
0.6089778543,
-0.0841670409,
-0.4883149266,
-0.1807583123,
-0.0186518952,
-0.4899978042,
-0.3967340589,
0.2712391615,
0.4968755245,
0.881459713,
0.4397796392,
0.1059916541,
0.751994431,
-0.6622621417,
0.4947126806,
-0.0910914242,
-0.9500305653,
0.4635351598,
-0.0464847311,
0.1140632331,
0.2617535889,
0.0192565359,
-0.0741434321,
-0.4152513146,
-0.3738856316,
-0.5502955317,
0.7368439436,
-0.0849469602,
0.0343824849,
0.0591615401,
0.2410819232,
0.4473776221,
0.3364148736,
-0.2779579759,
-0.2456645519,
-0.3263148367,
-0.2006037086,
-0.2026837915,
-0.0847040787,
-0.4179511368,
-0.3503124118,
0.5829107761,
-0.1924113184,
-0.0765985176,
-0.404126972,
-0.2019189596,
-0.2708067894,
0.0673693195,
0.5260697007,
0.9230515957,
-0.2947497666,
-0.1646863222,
0.2191136926,
-0.3354514837,
0.0559882224,
0.4732602835,
-0.1369115859,
-0.2104856968,
0.276910603,
1.0257929564,
0.1235960871,
-0.731074512,
0.5331897736,
-0.288192302,
0.1278643608,
-0.0377411433,
0.6000185013,
0.0181068778,
0.1892476231,
0.2384674698,
-0.2050011307,
0.1778120548,
-0.1457709074,
-0.0842258409,
0.505812645,
-0.060272336,
-0.1292099357,
0.7454762459,
0.1283111721,
-0.3879903257,
0.7159668207,
-0.1061428934,
-0.509360671,
0.7787822485,
0.6054099202,
0.8488152623,
-0.2915838957,
0.2253510654,
0.2274281979,
0.364068687,
-0.026565738,
-0.0465571024,
-0.3007518947,
-0.2801011205,
-0.1729618162,
-1.1601094007,
-0.6798126698,
0.0213618316,
-0.7964062691,
0.2749196291,
-0.6407617927,
-0.0790254623,
-0.0379297324,
0.1783541441,
-0.7674176097,
0.1479237378,
0.0543987378,
0.903167963,
-0.5136963129,
1.0624103546,
0.537094295,
-0.0545264706,
-0.4705342948,
-0.0732054189,
-0.080958724,
-1.1046037674,
0.7030551434,
0.3762947619,
0.0989358723,
-0.0893094763,
-0.5567656755,
-0.659529984,
0.9390451312,
0.6277990937,
-0.7142591476,
0.3636631072,
0.1077234,
0.7091686726,
-0.3160684109,
0.2063430846,
0.8424038291,
0.5667100549,
-0.1236751154,
-0.8865630031,
0.0660868064,
-0.2146551907,
0.2294250131,
0.200347513,
-0.8881924748,
0.6808763742,
-0.2305332273,
0.0758978575,
0.2266930342,
0.5552133322,
0.4144076705,
0.1738938689,
0.7249692678,
0.5058114529,
0.9642570615,
-0.0857447386,
1.2358430624,
-0.4687337577,
0.3005008996,
1.0650736094,
-0.5100127459,
0.7920207381,
0.080359742,
-0.3684849739,
0.2018255442,
0.8253327012,
-0.2129438818,
0.5808487535,
0.4367343783,
-0.1203842163,
-0.3606393039,
0.1578770876,
-0.4059898853,
0.3700333834,
0.4546206295,
-0.2167417854,
-0.0818164796,
-0.2137193829,
-0.2488519847,
-0.1824978888,
-0.2837440968,
0.7654215693,
0.0502599031,
-0.6895247102,
1.0105177164,
-0.0364634916,
0.3841619492,
-0.6136941314,
0.0152527066,
-0.4050913453,
0.2986884415,
-0.077903986,
-0.6312981844,
0.0147905136,
0.1842002124,
-0.0305107292,
0.1188030839,
0.3491017222,
-0.4194825888,
-0.6554258466,
0.124256894,
0.0206220523,
0.1258130074,
0.0202900656,
-0.9006865621,
0.422903806,
-0.1565051973,
-0.3420502245,
0.4667803645,
0.4863404632,
-0.0635980144,
0.8708721995,
0.8896246552,
0.1996573657,
0.2320775092,
0.279874742,
0.86143893,
-0.4737027287,
-0.3275998235,
-0.7858703732,
0.0748567954,
-0.2073398232,
-0.3598183692,
0.6260036826,
0.8148806095,
0.6269852519,
0.105577305,
0.6891760826,
0.3942082822,
0.5712772012,
-0.5274656415,
0.7777423859,
-0.4989185035,
0.4396296144,
-0.0089396266,
-1.1782207489,
-0.1797545552,
0.618647635,
-0.4308023751,
-0.1177171543,
0.5070349574,
0.8635082245,
-0.0062349718,
0.1078794897,
0.4157972038,
0.115874432,
0.4226427376,
0.3452654481,
0.9011709094,
-0.0830296353,
0.7121540308,
-0.4459062815,
-0.3980047703,
-0.3057151139,
-0.8849721551,
-0.9989634156,
-0.3487437665,
-0.2983615696,
0.0961735696,
0.2298430055,
0.8784908056,
0.6355776191,
-0.7726612091,
-0.3044399917,
0.304407835,
0.3169689775,
-0.4366804361,
-0.2041539699,
0.7054592371,
-0.5719299912,
-0.852893889,
0.2322508246,
0.4244022667,
-0.3116674721,
-0.483990103,
-0.2269080281,
0.3202759624,
-0.0737628043,
0.5550763607,
0.094839707,
-0.8349457979,
-0.0910645574,
-0.2336490154,
-0.27048406,
0.0532712638,
0.499466598,
-0.4304944277,
0.5105644464,
0.0860452056,
0.8223733306,
0.3937440217,
0.145625338,
0.4552529752,
-0.3651626408,
-0.0052645844,
0.0316384695,
0.4637945294,
0.5908831358,
-0.257045567,
0.5815693736,
0.0045945519,
-0.7622226477,
-0.9935042858,
-0.2269577086,
-0.8209856749,
0.0977839008,
1.279086113,
-0.3633416891,
-0.549967587,
0.0269255936,
-0.3936353922,
0.2374526113,
-0.5122006536,
1.1491411924,
0.6709626913,
-0.1203414723,
-0.1902451217,
-0.5520219803,
0.3947906196,
0.3492612541,
-0.8521233797,
0.332598865,
0.5404731631,
0.3428893387,
-0.2985044122,
0.3006970882,
0.0170495212,
0.3613704443,
-0.2641558051,
-0.2140916735,
-0.2929567099,
-0.102178365,
-0.1753967702,
0.0573214516,
0.1099427417,
-0.19649598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05083v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05083v2 | Revealing the Blind Spot of Sentence Encoder Evaluation by HEROS | 2023-06-08T10:24:02 | 2023-06-13T04:56:06 | Cheng-Han Chiang, Yung-Sung Chuang, James Glass, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing sentence textual similarity benchmark datasets only use a single
number to summarize how similar the sentence encoder's decision is to humans'.
However, it is unclear what kind of sentence pairs a sentence encoder (SE)
would consider similar. Moreover, existing SE benchmarks mainly consider
sentence pairs with low lexical overlap, so it is unclear how the SEs behave
when two sentences have high lexical overlap. We introduce a high-quality SE
diagnostic dataset, HEROS. HEROS is constructed by transforming an original
sentence into a new sentence based on certain rules to form a \textit{minimal
pair}, and the minimal pair has high lexical overlaps. The rules include
replacing a word with a synonym, an antonym, a typo, a random word, and
converting the original sentence into its negation. Different rules yield
different subsets of HEROS. By systematically comparing the performance of over
60 supervised and unsupervised SEs on HEROS, we reveal that most unsupervised
sentence encoders are insensitive to negation. We find the datasets used to
train the SE are the main determinants of what kind of sentence pairs an SE
considers similar. We also show that even if two SEs have similar performance
on STS benchmarks, they can have very different behavior on HEROS. Our result
reveals the blind spot of traditional STS benchmarks when evaluating SEs. | [
-0.4822434485,
-0.7757048607,
0.693263948,
-0.0928948969,
-0.2471758872,
-0.0895576328,
-0.1247363836,
-0.2439591289,
0.2159240991,
0.5642666817,
-0.3982101679,
-0.2796525061,
-0.7698323131,
0.5264542699,
-0.3722762465,
0.8112308383,
0.1040473655,
0.0665601194,
-0.6066889167,
-0.5477666855,
-0.653521359,
-0.4901477396,
-0.1808054447,
-0.0282340515,
0.134291321,
0.4263643026,
0.8895298839,
0.4033031762,
0.7694557905,
0.2970051765,
-0.2734547853,
0.1200342178,
-0.4485894442,
0.0762744173,
-0.1436861157,
-0.2896043956,
-0.1724977493,
-0.1581134945,
0.4336343706,
0.7128733397,
0.3052574992,
0.1487570256,
0.4008304477,
0.7617024183,
-0.9104856253,
-0.2659668028,
-0.366879046,
0.1672334969,
-0.4321936369,
-0.0683020577,
-0.3522386849,
-0.4644269943,
-0.0353323184,
-0.3767437935,
0.5295485258,
0.0006888027,
0.749695003,
0.4123935997,
-0.4272997677,
0.0844374597,
-0.3454550505,
0.3794983029,
-0.4214991927,
0.3263118267,
0.2579662204,
0.2760913968,
-0.0466232821,
-0.3022512197,
-0.7429203987,
-0.0496857613,
-0.2571769059,
0.1276978105,
-0.434686929,
-0.0292184763,
0.4439280927,
0.2398055196,
-0.743503511,
0.1307785213,
-0.3002387583,
-0.0015401451,
0.4515843093,
0.2818582356,
0.0471201092,
-0.5786039829,
-0.6120681763,
-0.0844898745,
-0.6282698512,
0.0377416834,
0.0937267989,
0.0624577776,
0.0249139518,
0.7362064719,
-0.1870058924,
0.7756060958,
0.0487371311,
0.3782541454,
0.7240046859,
-0.2012995332,
-0.3582601845,
0.0345362648,
0.8302699924,
0.707808435,
0.600917995,
-0.1328018606,
-0.3429886997,
0.4151006937,
0.4173310101,
-0.4332636595,
0.1567110121,
-0.3152069449,
-0.5450586081,
-0.1242230833,
0.090215601,
-0.7863993049,
-0.7379250526,
-0.0238452069,
0.7497349381,
-0.4292540252,
0.2070142329,
0.1505022794,
-0.4448976219,
0.1966320872,
-0.1501122862,
-0.4168488681,
0.478836149,
0.6121270657,
0.7466461062,
-0.0259527136,
-0.6037030816,
-0.8593059778,
-0.1315928251,
-0.4434860349,
0.8793193698,
-0.667957902,
-0.1576763839,
-0.0651466474,
0.0278920364,
-0.342110157,
-0.6885066032,
0.6209918857,
-0.2027450949,
0.135419786,
-0.4189059138,
-0.7029978633,
-0.2130048424,
0.2198801786,
-0.5467460752,
0.7477809191,
0.2196222544,
-0.8233909607,
0.3705002069,
-0.4526479244,
-0.4698470235,
0.1367633939,
-0.3618690372,
-0.3822052479,
0.4512394369,
0.5285640359,
0.4559904337,
-0.5161767602,
0.0818932652,
-0.2766473889,
-0.7272440791,
0.5792738199,
-0.420884639,
0.5531631112,
-0.0579652824,
-0.199577108,
-0.0301456507,
-0.3178101778,
-0.1359822154,
0.0468976758,
0.2356380671,
-0.7058879733,
-0.1957007945,
0.0841298178,
0.1507576704,
-0.0538764745,
-0.6387153864,
-0.3018487394,
-0.3074311018,
0.5374189615,
0.5999340415,
0.2219140232,
0.1579720676,
-0.3432109654,
0.5332691073,
-0.0265245531,
0.3618563712,
-0.1074600741,
-0.5386027694,
-0.8242064714,
-0.1149049699,
0.1772847325,
0.423484832,
-0.5081300735,
0.5642416477,
-0.3956731558,
-0.2679010332,
-0.8903820515,
-0.1556506604,
0.6848223209,
0.5880616307,
0.5601348281,
-0.4389863908,
-0.36911726,
-1.2860629559,
-0.7892092466,
0.0814866275,
0.0287368633,
0.0769633129,
0.5339538455,
-0.059301015,
0.9361504912,
-0.4503148496,
-0.3995103836,
-0.2932097018,
-0.1315358579,
0.0257455166,
0.4797386825,
0.4837997556,
-0.7689818144,
-0.4315049648,
-0.3157131076,
-0.940056622,
0.0712286606,
-0.0754886195,
0.1608942896,
0.0197710954,
0.9339188933,
-0.4618438482,
0.640881896,
0.2211294025,
-0.7195628881,
0.1913270503,
-0.2397600859,
0.3332098424,
-0.8052175045,
-0.11616759,
-0.0778132975,
-0.1963737756,
-0.4053238034,
0.1547859311,
0.1181005985,
-0.135549739,
-0.3094201982,
0.1913812011,
-0.4432806969,
-0.3554551601,
0.1096980646,
0.3361960351,
0.0444487855,
0.3820177317,
-0.4139537811,
0.7680116892,
0.5959685445,
-0.4246812463,
0.1783954799,
0.6250439882,
-0.5208088756,
0.9680953026,
-0.8201400042,
0.0840869844,
-0.3905222714,
-0.0692503601,
-0.7022815943,
0.1505297273,
0.1197576821,
-0.4322004318,
-0.0901757255,
0.0216660872,
-0.5921567678,
-0.4583220482,
-0.1842777431,
0.361515224,
0.6619931459,
-0.4548008442,
0.1097984165,
0.4010946155,
-0.1118609607,
-0.4576401412,
-0.9973607659,
0.3015162945,
-0.3296119273,
-0.3279264569,
0.2655072808,
-0.1184449345,
-0.2493103147,
0.3130962849,
-0.0805346444,
0.0024392731,
0.0343651548,
0.4139935076,
-0.0435944013,
-0.1991193444,
0.3659178019,
-0.0567516834,
-0.3291570544,
-0.0281112362,
-0.0305305831,
0.3154982328,
-0.2919629514,
-0.5874880552,
-0.3276432455,
0.5167820454,
0.712936759,
-0.3116025031,
0.5569880009,
0.3099731207,
-0.4165814221,
0.0770858526,
-0.6540269256,
0.0078063766,
-0.419642061,
0.4338731766,
-0.5995213985,
-0.7556160688,
0.2468568832,
0.2124001533,
-0.4237309098,
0.640501976,
-0.0768965483,
-0.017447371,
0.8139490485,
0.6231485605,
-0.0173248481,
0.1139127985,
-0.065990448,
0.1480589062,
-0.8514873981,
-0.2420704514,
-0.5390899777,
-0.5124637485,
-0.5196891427,
-0.4155474901,
0.3673760593,
0.2650068998,
-0.4221974313,
0.4704471529,
-0.5271883607,
0.8906386495,
0.4460394084,
0.1377581209,
0.0742289647,
-0.0231853165,
-0.1041914225,
-0.4457548559,
-0.8038995266,
-0.3740182817,
1.0987852812,
-0.1077987105,
0.2675896883,
0.0412293933,
0.5633267164,
0.6097266078,
-0.2627440095,
-0.308303237,
0.7445790172,
-0.6488502026,
-0.0209387094,
-0.1593407542,
-0.2880263031,
-0.9677808285,
0.223325327,
-0.3846606314,
-0.4204293489,
0.4446991384,
-0.3434196711,
-0.3170150816,
0.0648297742,
-0.8378197551,
1.170353651,
-0.0013955332,
-0.1951437891,
-0.3093019724,
-0.6119180918,
-0.0365089327,
0.0803158879,
0.1095954627,
0.153802976,
0.1216452345,
0.8558437228,
-0.4598511457,
0.5516846776,
-0.0723846704,
0.6010032296,
0.1084395349,
0.1082733721,
0.4103944898,
-0.1061367095,
-0.1235644892,
0.0870434791,
-0.5346866846,
-0.5131590962,
-0.5460904241,
0.718331933,
-0.5402575731,
-0.5019296408,
-0.4163438976,
-0.1227850616,
-0.2968702614,
0.167825833,
0.5506247282,
0.4940805733,
-0.475662291,
0.117353119,
0.5166541934,
-0.156125024,
0.498136729,
0.5218120813,
0.4239217341,
-0.4671913981,
0.6172074676,
0.0548468046,
0.0944552198,
0.5304679275,
-0.0721121728,
-0.1923863292,
-0.4907944202,
-0.4505780935,
0.1873337328,
-0.6336475611,
-0.3149887323,
-0.6264468431,
-0.3903995752,
-0.3664192855,
-0.5568629503,
-0.2596739233,
-0.2942209542,
-0.1388789713,
-0.2485904396,
0.5837268829,
0.8323890567,
0.0506252982,
0.0699810833,
-0.6819480062,
0.380327791,
0.322540313,
0.3442231119,
-0.2812218368,
-0.6178860664,
-0.1870784312,
-0.2266116887,
0.0506032556,
-1.0165122747,
0.3349276781,
0.0613712221,
0.6955551505,
0.4575231373,
0.2884931862,
0.8170223832,
-0.4745165408,
0.6546664834,
0.2398455143,
-1.0854183435,
0.6543242931,
0.053861063,
0.2954556346,
0.8103494644,
0.0492515974,
-0.6241488457,
-0.4857248366,
-0.6833549738,
-0.5774422288,
0.4940180182,
0.3417954147,
-0.1404078156,
-0.2951171398,
0.1810628027,
0.3194663823,
0.1018282399,
-0.4069744647,
-0.2041723877,
-0.1245690137,
-0.1758205444,
-0.6671810746,
-0.2971985638,
-0.065518178,
-0.0204375573,
0.0236449726,
0.0212144237,
0.290391773,
0.4682046771,
-0.5604713559,
0.0985505283,
0.4874708354,
0.2570307851,
0.2968229055,
-0.0902389809,
0.2914091051,
0.2712223828,
-0.2789595723,
-0.1167905852,
0.2245241404,
-0.3527497351,
0.2053609937,
0.6222824454,
1.023804307,
0.3461281657,
-0.6995109916,
0.9928608537,
0.0881182402,
-0.0150277894,
-0.247136876,
-0.0390407518,
-0.2607533336,
0.4317022562,
0.1821429878,
0.7112018466,
0.2042424828,
-0.2608350515,
0.2337892652,
0.1677444726,
-0.7879089117,
-0.2123890817,
0.542966783,
0.278126955,
-0.5778239369,
0.7143998146,
-0.2795571387,
-0.6071943045,
0.7339555621,
0.3942390978,
1.2067118883,
0.0405315496,
0.2727535963,
0.3659445345,
0.6514620781,
-0.04691796,
0.3237205744,
0.0635390356,
-0.4921868742,
0.0366237611,
-0.2772779763,
-0.0274835471,
-0.0187616833,
-0.9256892204,
0.2853300869,
-0.1253680587,
0.0656339452,
-0.0412384123,
-0.3707957864,
-1.0484086275,
0.1036311537,
-0.1526572108,
0.7721600533,
-1.1376425028,
0.3216111958,
0.6551879048,
-0.4856275022,
-0.2029632926,
0.306943059,
-0.1092952341,
-0.594285965,
0.2818096876,
0.4608632922,
0.1234162524,
-0.2381205708,
-0.0945595279,
-0.4920242429,
0.8699145913,
0.3999996483,
-0.6834478378,
0.3024529815,
0.2739348114,
0.6967762709,
-0.5115070343,
0.2853299379,
0.4998713434,
0.3604914844,
-0.5396062732,
-0.8462731242,
0.3728442788,
-0.429050386,
-0.0720376372,
0.1689282656,
-0.5425299406,
0.9710017443,
-0.4589583874,
-0.2024371475,
-0.1374331117,
0.219787553,
0.0225321501,
0.4814485908,
0.5766872764,
0.6956654787,
0.6625694633,
0.0995903388,
0.9347811341,
0.1101672649,
0.0311584771,
0.9840413332,
-0.3325815201,
0.9459971189,
0.4132704437,
0.0489273146,
0.5966112018,
0.3119259179,
-0.254027307,
0.5227648616,
-0.0211448371,
0.0912262425,
-0.4293508232,
-0.0610684156,
-0.6229435205,
0.4516222179,
0.2111055851,
-0.4788020849,
-0.1403003186,
0.2619594634,
-0.2476553619,
0.6382858753,
-0.303992331,
0.7320469022,
-0.1983111203,
-0.617347002,
0.6726387143,
-0.1513166279,
0.5790269971,
-0.2978702784,
0.2407707423,
-0.3964603543,
0.333055377,
-0.0383638255,
-0.981549859,
0.3134487867,
0.1927173138,
-0.2858439088,
-0.2450567931,
0.5549791455,
-0.0508962534,
-0.3469251096,
0.4045981169,
0.678992331,
0.280059278,
-0.1724240184,
-0.4003534913,
-0.2132161856,
-0.0596600436,
0.0600909442,
0.3846585155,
0.6210024357,
-0.1491825879,
0.5344660282,
0.208977133,
-0.1295669675,
-0.1010011733,
0.3086474836,
0.7290764451,
-1.0983917713,
-0.7919789553,
-0.7056494355,
0.23097682,
-0.2350752503,
-0.8207460046,
0.9896863103,
0.8071700931,
0.7428857684,
-0.130448088,
0.725389123,
0.1811484247,
0.5223318338,
-0.3954006433,
0.710688293,
-0.5220110416,
0.2397166938,
-0.3364610076,
-0.7342187166,
-0.2371775657,
0.3872300982,
-0.1632444412,
-0.1769928336,
1.0777922869,
0.8503676057,
-0.0792256817,
0.1854592413,
0.3133222163,
0.415649116,
-0.2508476079,
0.793281436,
0.8104904294,
-0.7025465965,
0.6571172476,
0.1623898298,
-0.1910794526,
-0.247434184,
-0.463924408,
-0.9149727821,
-0.5963841081,
-0.3937630951,
-0.2853547037,
0.6452689171,
0.4614584446,
0.3752919137,
-0.6614989042,
0.1482032239,
-0.5057786703,
0.2353369445,
-0.728741169,
-0.1747258604,
0.4650941193,
-0.0983194113,
-0.5102888942,
0.5875234604,
0.3193795383,
-0.0529566817,
0.0777649283,
-0.1957577318,
0.0230860412,
0.031408973,
0.3599582016,
0.0498290509,
-0.7107057571,
-0.3474723995,
0.0095175672,
-0.2580173016,
-0.0157423224,
0.825540185,
-1.3860161304,
0.4343384206,
0.5885035992,
0.5791097283,
0.3737760186,
-0.2869252563,
0.352519989,
-0.6644430161,
0.0148368618,
0.1817212254,
0.27412498,
0.5360686779,
-0.1106906533,
0.5225545168,
0.517162323,
-0.3984293938,
-0.9024576545,
0.124885194,
-0.8141033649,
-0.4352460802,
1.0368933678,
0.1166135669,
0.0738697052,
-0.2084628046,
0.1655362695,
0.0645720959,
-0.2289168835,
0.6159746051,
0.3605138659,
-0.0535624325,
0.0077236169,
-0.3415423632,
0.2748893797,
0.6443061829,
-0.4388605058,
0.1292182207,
0.4677130878,
0.2218425572,
-0.0681009963,
0.5203020573,
0.0203240961,
0.3767403364,
0.4561831355,
0.014139466,
-0.2726415694,
-0.1689794064,
-0.653973639,
0.2866255641,
-0.3829324245,
-0.5518607497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05079v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05079v2 | Enhancing Robustness of AI Offensive Code Generators via Data Augmentation | 2023-06-08T10:02:04 | 2023-10-01T13:01:07 | Cristina Improta, Pietro Liguori, Roberto Natella, Bojan Cukic, Domenico Cotroneo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | In this work, we present a method to add perturbations to the code
descriptions to create new inputs in natural language (NL) from
well-intentioned developers that diverge from the original ones due to the use
of new words or because they miss part of them. The goal is to analyze how and
to what extent perturbations affect the performance of AI code generators in
the context of security-oriented code. First, we show that perturbed
descriptions preserve the semantics of the original, non-perturbed ones. Then,
we use the method to assess the robustness of three state-of-the-art code
generators against the newly perturbed inputs, showing that the performance of
these AI-based solutions is highly affected by perturbations in the NL
descriptions. To enhance their robustness, we use the method to perform data
augmentation, i.e., to increase the variability and diversity of the NL
descriptions in the training data, proving its effectiveness against both
perturbed and non-perturbed code descriptions. | [
-0.3834615648,
-0.9967207909,
-0.1160863191,
0.124472551,
-0.2966197729,
0.433652848,
-0.1401869804,
-0.5997978449,
0.0179303121,
0.4921413958,
-0.2744801641,
-0.5653178692,
-0.5997442007,
0.4818564355,
-0.3689470589,
1.1500533819,
0.0913664401,
-0.2958350778,
-0.1500404626,
-0.0336647257,
-0.5532184243,
-0.8007095456,
-0.2219607532,
0.056728363,
-0.0745118186,
0.315910399,
1.1966055632,
0.8665984869,
0.7817068696,
0.3545389473,
-0.1962040514,
0.0977109969,
-0.4786648452,
0.4402024448,
0.0455249324,
-0.6440334916,
-0.417196393,
-0.3599167466,
0.4933580756,
0.1933906227,
0.1499081105,
-0.011106858,
0.0854389071,
0.3219995499,
-0.7959158421,
0.1167498752,
-0.7829808593,
0.0969325453,
-0.1703638583,
-0.5004559755,
-0.2591011524,
-0.1792567372,
0.0275899787,
-0.3546975851,
0.0396591723,
-0.3857383132,
0.6845746636,
0.613373816,
0.0883654281,
-0.1929024309,
-0.9205716848,
0.6781980395,
-0.9995155334,
0.1321210116,
0.4088351429,
0.1175588742,
-0.358076632,
-0.4913015962,
-0.6338394284,
-0.5978838801,
-0.0029950398,
-0.044656273,
-0.3008069992,
0.1534881145,
0.5619302988,
0.4331690669,
-0.2580963373,
0.1943006963,
-0.1005731747,
-0.3880566657,
1.0705264807,
0.2747763395,
0.4166266918,
0.1324117482,
-0.3517036438,
-0.2795579135,
-0.6857954264,
0.1525149047,
1.0688977242,
0.2788660824,
-0.2508916557,
0.4339779913,
-0.0984937102,
0.617162168,
0.1157490462,
-0.1229498833,
0.4506072402,
-0.6283364892,
-0.0873138309,
-0.1192293465,
0.5912383795,
0.1988280714,
0.0891132057,
-0.1708429754,
-0.4315693378,
0.0722817257,
0.5982174277,
-0.5897568464,
-0.385464251,
0.1100092605,
-0.4661452174,
-0.8115153909,
0.1775751114,
-1.0208070278,
-0.5910352468,
-0.0823585093,
0.0104022026,
-0.4720370471,
-0.1215186566,
-0.0763502866,
-0.2168925703,
0.3443434536,
-0.0264670011,
-0.7299589515,
0.1081864089,
0.5255236626,
0.2269716859,
-0.0417151712,
-0.2535377145,
-0.4929145873,
-0.0724131465,
-0.2481209785,
0.4416123033,
-0.8116635084,
-0.5665878057,
0.1661729664,
-0.5526649356,
0.4523066282,
-0.5747662783,
0.5870443583,
-0.5474674702,
0.0481445454,
0.2365355343,
-0.357678175,
0.052096203,
0.3974530995,
-0.7318721414,
0.7186463475,
0.2627990246,
-0.8837943077,
0.2911396325,
-0.8103231788,
-0.8379403949,
0.1661453247,
-0.4003177285,
-0.651119709,
0.315271467,
0.4654563367,
0.0446032248,
0.1051106006,
-0.2595241666,
-0.1550767273,
-0.4688688517,
0.6647719145,
-0.7542712688,
0.8902448416,
0.2555406094,
-0.4047439098,
0.1506521255,
-0.8172088861,
0.0401728414,
0.0225253273,
-0.5266430974,
-0.151077792,
0.2432981431,
-0.2081981748,
-0.2021860927,
0.313416481,
-0.407776922,
0.2844373584,
-0.7653041482,
0.0999300778,
0.8773604035,
0.1894260943,
0.1953689605,
-0.1493864954,
0.889231801,
-0.0608787872,
0.4485238492,
-0.4992968738,
-0.4653737247,
-0.3281923234,
-0.210756436,
0.2303752303,
0.7354678512,
-1.0400841236,
0.6559371352,
-0.0820476487,
-0.2314041406,
-0.3540076613,
0.35529688,
0.4086216092,
0.3681063056,
0.3910204768,
-0.3085097075,
-0.8736586571,
-0.7006667852,
-0.3599459827,
-0.3968795836,
-0.0023608885,
-0.0126360757,
0.2989761233,
-0.534094274,
0.90675807,
-0.2771732211,
0.2093344778,
-0.1560619473,
-0.0459133349,
0.0380705968,
0.6853082776,
0.6550173163,
-0.7945786119,
-0.2903814614,
-0.0603822954,
-0.6050459146,
-0.1133268178,
-0.3771955669,
0.2419818044,
0.0302597303,
0.3877963126,
-0.2145060897,
0.9495530128,
0.4265242517,
-0.1825091243,
0.8524154425,
0.0093031116,
0.0592285804,
-0.9801208377,
-0.1086162701,
-0.234124288,
0.0062943636,
-0.826610446,
0.810287416,
-0.2600456178,
-0.0913027152,
-0.409224689,
0.0173153616,
-0.2389942855,
0.2603682876,
-0.3321473002,
-0.1094713286,
-0.2298062295,
0.1605781615,
-0.5075876713,
0.9266976118,
0.9920571446,
-0.7404692173,
0.6651411653,
0.3572714627,
0.0408293046,
0.3267863691,
-0.5708368421,
0.4383033514,
-0.2100429684,
0.084705703,
-0.8265926838,
-0.3621911705,
0.1763975173,
-0.8585935831,
0.396525681,
-0.2446234971,
-0.4200054407,
-0.3474538028,
-0.6363149285,
0.4679897428,
0.5319721103,
-0.4778319299,
0.5159689784,
0.1296776384,
0.1497597247,
-0.8530259132,
-1.0292547941,
0.47825104,
-0.457000792,
-0.5688162446,
0.2554267049,
-0.0214047432,
-0.4292556643,
-0.2136859,
-0.1730017662,
-0.02185091,
0.5541133285,
0.2030238211,
0.4675314724,
-0.1409411132,
-0.1174424291,
-0.0061170687,
-0.0500128642,
0.3021581471,
-0.2701041102,
0.5121281147,
0.0051572621,
-0.4604752064,
-0.545593679,
0.2249498963,
0.3403480053,
-0.4792200923,
0.5816168785,
0.7199475765,
-0.3555614352,
-0.0216660555,
-0.2355839908,
-0.1431211233,
-0.6083654761,
0.4493372738,
-0.35753268,
-0.7841878533,
0.7184732556,
0.2712839246,
0.2706714272,
0.4205741882,
0.3434376419,
0.0387326553,
0.9788639545,
0.5187978745,
-0.3420692086,
0.6760488749,
-0.1593244225,
0.3211579919,
-0.5998097062,
0.0155835683,
-0.5965470672,
-0.3354256451,
-0.848788619,
-0.1154726446,
0.1972571313,
0.1435370296,
-0.065954417,
0.4174033999,
-0.7326847315,
0.4640571475,
0.2782337964,
0.0394842364,
-0.0164318383,
0.2836402059,
0.1706473529,
0.1527028531,
-0.47514382,
-0.5208309293,
1.4164223671,
0.4287715256,
0.9514588714,
0.3441211581,
0.9338697195,
0.5496775508,
0.0234462228,
-0.3820489049,
0.4339821935,
-0.1866286099,
-0.3515268266,
-0.1621311456,
-0.5647241473,
-0.9744436145,
-0.3326704204,
-0.4210037887,
-0.9733620882,
0.2344694734,
0.2762191594,
-0.5846555233,
0.2508257926,
-0.5602395535,
0.3328947723,
-0.3588358164,
-0.2944608629,
-0.1444628388,
-0.5375832915,
0.231250152,
0.0307697095,
-0.1272328645,
0.4345663786,
-0.1718927771,
0.4110176265,
-0.486746788,
0.7661042213,
-0.3796980679,
-0.3370770216,
0.5743827224,
-0.04080927,
0.684435308,
0.4426691234,
-0.3092124164,
0.1534083039,
-0.481803894,
-0.5349690914,
-0.6681198478,
0.5136325359,
-0.6020838618,
-0.7405979633,
-0.0551298335,
-0.6584481597,
-0.2583413422,
0.1628637314,
0.4117198884,
0.5425392985,
0.0739681274,
0.3016785979,
0.6381040215,
-0.628293097,
0.4686566591,
-0.0131161157,
-0.01711227,
-0.4962762594,
0.6159076095,
-0.3168646395,
0.3170721233,
0.3309729099,
-0.037687581,
-0.2496454269,
-1.0646864176,
-0.3960295618,
-0.6158884168,
-0.4423211217,
-0.518234849,
-0.1888640523,
-0.2283915281,
-0.5474112034,
-0.1713505387,
0.0070144492,
-0.3400542438,
-0.1735457778,
-0.2250944376,
0.5804278851,
0.5907066464,
0.0444680974,
0.5053112507,
-0.8233801723,
0.2617827654,
0.0587278716,
0.5502203703,
-0.3096211851,
-0.4804044664,
-0.3054910302,
0.389211297,
-0.214358896,
-1.1336077452,
0.0890184268,
-0.0281430073,
0.7116746306,
0.5509272218,
0.1727321297,
0.6631083488,
0.1255617142,
1.0789055824,
0.0579679422,
-0.9371655583,
0.662954092,
-0.3021953702,
0.4262937605,
0.6728305221,
-0.263887316,
0.195649758,
-0.7916016579,
-0.5936139226,
-0.9452430606,
0.4982236028,
0.5157580972,
0.8228484988,
0.0832265243,
0.5700438023,
-0.0748467967,
0.1051605791,
-0.4293470681,
-0.5310739875,
-0.4664938748,
-0.0887031853,
0.4157320559,
-0.1800963283,
-0.0605326183,
0.0138452873,
0.4302035272,
-0.0195386689,
0.487662971,
0.0051339539,
-0.0445332788,
-0.0180159137,
0.2826690674,
0.5293129086,
0.5042234659,
0.1116563305,
0.117226921,
0.3522743285,
-0.8398641348,
0.008156389,
0.4882333577,
-0.4333186448,
-0.0953479931,
0.6086609364,
0.8629162908,
-0.4675654769,
-0.7529481053,
0.32557863,
-0.0916509479,
0.0290035941,
-0.1221889555,
0.5434312224,
-0.6857469678,
0.0701879561,
0.4934524,
0.5975245833,
0.1808482558,
-0.5612977147,
0.4680448472,
0.5086733699,
-0.1031543761,
-0.2473550141,
0.6206075549,
0.1585327387,
-0.6643893719,
0.6856738925,
-0.4209293425,
-0.8827475905,
0.7317718267,
0.7342641354,
0.9418476224,
-0.411349535,
-0.1235353127,
0.1440440267,
0.6068439484,
0.4885611832,
0.29035905,
-0.1256795079,
-0.6675691009,
-0.5864131451,
-0.2988374531,
-0.0958163142,
0.2146642953,
-0.6292900443,
0.115372166,
-0.9274222255,
-0.38792184,
-0.3376638591,
-0.1253881305,
-0.6081163883,
0.1762662381,
0.3132422268,
0.8803292513,
-0.4775747061,
0.5286007524,
0.8879379034,
-0.5625502467,
-0.7876631021,
0.5389556885,
-0.1212170571,
-0.5345619321,
0.0041848798,
-0.1134819239,
-0.0054321392,
-0.4178889096,
-0.7446736097,
-0.8748694658,
0.5962003469,
0.4509337544,
-0.1722044051,
0.1851602495,
0.4209348559,
0.8743256927,
-0.0779892057,
0.1545510739,
0.5997914672,
0.5370170474,
-0.2492605746,
-0.6471488476,
0.0401795991,
-0.5560708642,
-0.0238674544,
0.0772212967,
-0.1302625686,
0.6160724759,
-0.1978792101,
-0.2786315978,
0.2007329762,
0.6584834456,
-0.0209616292,
0.0833239257,
0.4167794287,
0.3600700498,
0.6137515903,
-0.1043179855,
1.2193983793,
-0.5164331794,
0.0390840024,
1.1833373308,
-0.051459834,
0.5097522736,
0.2893167734,
-0.289452672,
0.5766271353,
0.0242670365,
-0.4103288352,
0.1064434871,
0.2255859971,
-0.2115985304,
0.2548211515,
0.203010425,
-0.4700146914,
0.7159563899,
0.380951941,
-0.3674249649,
-0.0182646755,
0.0746204033,
-0.0140163023,
0.2626682222,
-0.0914505571,
0.946937561,
-0.4144529998,
-0.5367264152,
0.8153018355,
0.2874931395,
0.8127100468,
-0.4354244471,
-0.0513169691,
-0.2114672214,
0.1297186315,
-0.6158279777,
-0.796595633,
0.7365201712,
0.4101734757,
0.0925880447,
-0.0341863595,
0.7869375348,
-0.0976210237,
-0.3486410975,
-0.0191126037,
-0.0803326219,
-0.1074466482,
0.1657205522,
-0.5710527301,
0.302567035,
0.398198545,
0.2280970216,
0.0867334232,
0.1210811138,
0.0201064963,
0.4323863089,
0.6956798434,
0.0940405428,
0.3154521286,
-0.1117970198,
1.1054129601,
-0.1792174429,
-0.5268654823,
-1.1754263639,
0.6416235566,
-0.2790498137,
-0.4556932151,
0.9813506603,
0.5229201317,
0.814971149,
-0.0435403138,
1.0467303991,
-0.3291614652,
-0.0398627371,
-0.3451418281,
0.429604888,
0.0133606829,
0.8805419803,
-0.5213425756,
-0.9145832658,
-0.4617693424,
0.4945490658,
-0.2156994194,
0.038341444,
0.0961516425,
0.849412024,
0.2189632654,
0.1043637767,
0.0931631625,
0.1868702769,
0.5479072332,
0.3398424387,
0.8869402409,
-0.5391788483,
0.5176289082,
-0.3018189669,
-0.2658786774,
0.0474968031,
-0.6533049345,
-0.644641459,
-0.0929268077,
-0.4231727719,
-0.5443704724,
0.2803986669,
0.8423726559,
0.5055969357,
-0.9321087599,
0.1008278206,
-0.2925157845,
0.2945871055,
-0.2771859765,
-0.2722837627,
0.1315338016,
-0.5788171291,
-0.4764512181,
0.5293844342,
0.0716022626,
0.1168972403,
-0.440362066,
-0.2456444651,
0.1230039299,
0.2873239815,
0.3517856598,
0.213044256,
-0.4352782667,
-0.2584484816,
-0.1564265192,
0.2298031896,
0.1144307107,
0.6784971952,
-0.842535615,
0.7189592719,
0.5116174221,
0.9936295152,
-0.1442085356,
0.3125629723,
0.674184978,
-1.1377949715,
0.243221879,
0.4292422533,
0.1024714857,
0.3462982774,
-0.726266861,
0.2929299474,
-0.0507836677,
-0.2409183681,
-0.8896642923,
0.5135247707,
-0.4076666534,
0.0322640389,
1.0266584158,
-0.3265322745,
0.1259753257,
-0.2362535149,
-0.1463323534,
0.2392516583,
-0.3999733627,
0.9005222321,
0.3464790881,
-0.059288267,
0.1611128002,
0.0158373732,
0.7190157175,
0.3495438695,
-0.9782633185,
0.0143581415,
0.5340098143,
-0.1302684098,
0.4674962163,
0.0655755252,
-0.3581744432,
0.4456341863,
0.2700580657,
-0.3061119616,
-0.2914953828,
-0.1053483933,
-0.5799622536,
0.1353648901,
0.2251996696,
-0.363463968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05077v1 | Improving Language Model Integration for Neural Machine Translation | 2023-06-08T10:00:19 | 2023-06-08T10:00:19 | Christian Herold, Yingbo Gao, Mohammad Zeineldeen, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The integration of language models for neural machine translation has been
extensively studied in the past. It has been shown that an external language
model, trained on additional target-side monolingual data, can help improve
translation quality. However, there has always been the assumption that the
translation model also learns an implicit target-side language model during
training, which interferes with the external language model at decoding time.
Recently, some works on automatic speech recognition have demonstrated that, if
the implicit language model is neutralized in decoding, further improvements
can be gained when integrating an external language model. In this work, we
transfer this concept to the task of machine translation and compare with the
most prominent way of including additional monolingual data - namely
back-translation. We find that accounting for the implicit language model
significantly boosts the performance of language model fusion, although this
approach is still outperformed by back-translation. | [
-0.3144201636,
-0.135858506,
0.5207439065,
0.1282803565,
-0.2698523402,
-0.1359373331,
-0.3927808404,
-0.7503421307,
-0.1402537525,
0.3467761576,
-0.0486442856,
-0.5955885053,
-0.8325232863,
0.0814460367,
-0.5835092068,
0.9193184376,
-0.1831420809,
0.4588933587,
-0.2564966083,
-0.4126263559,
-0.8170181513,
-0.7716374993,
-0.8578183055,
-0.6777986884,
0.3658367693,
-0.0873676538,
0.7751322985,
0.704669416,
0.344042629,
0.3552109599,
-0.161369279,
0.0731873289,
-0.1616030484,
0.2285850346,
-0.2444165796,
-0.380582422,
-0.4980341196,
-0.0639276728,
0.9566754103,
0.8975527883,
0.0704488307,
-0.0501958132,
0.2545831501,
0.4767334163,
-0.5332538486,
0.3688766658,
-0.3177634478,
0.1362700462,
0.3022675514,
0.1092063859,
-0.5077950358,
-0.2884417772,
0.1908414215,
-0.2323437333,
0.2013490051,
-0.378152132,
0.5748773217,
0.4557831883,
-0.4303683937,
-0.1461651027,
-0.9718298912,
0.647572577,
-0.9210876822,
0.8853389025,
0.2302661836,
0.1721378565,
0.0296423584,
-0.321677953,
-0.4628211856,
-0.3629049659,
-0.4180568457,
0.1174935997,
-0.336484462,
0.1263952106,
0.2387320548,
0.1640079916,
-0.3616485894,
0.1660901904,
-0.3567429483,
-0.1797410846,
0.7008981705,
-0.001829194,
0.3195242882,
0.0605577007,
-0.1610731035,
-0.1738223284,
-0.6920090318,
0.148601532,
0.1715644747,
0.6429071426,
-0.1253549606,
0.6885753274,
-0.1828334779,
0.4560269117,
-0.048991967,
0.2364637107,
0.3416379988,
-0.5016533732,
-0.1692751646,
0.4459399283,
0.525182724,
0.0480505861,
0.2136559486,
-0.3496758342,
-0.3697874844,
0.0230682604,
-0.0277084243,
-0.6162942648,
0.0632941052,
0.3069313169,
-0.4316001534,
0.2422348112,
-0.2364412695,
-0.1247374713,
-0.1603818536,
-0.521484673,
0.4435905516,
-0.4554178417,
-0.288346082,
-0.0221077856,
-0.2001134008,
0.183190614,
0.3589877188,
-0.81183815,
0.4959367514,
0.7881340981,
0.8985787034,
0.0600410476,
-0.4463751018,
-0.9210577607,
0.1680697203,
-0.5211275816,
0.6698539853,
-0.3155462444,
-0.3805357218,
-0.0058525275,
-0.177909255,
-0.2040131092,
-0.4372287989,
0.2306343913,
-0.5000461936,
0.4100432694,
-0.2957210541,
-0.4910713136,
-0.5679828525,
0.0492008328,
-0.4855844676,
0.8731622696,
-0.1133845747,
-0.3518632054,
0.333669126,
-0.4150190949,
-0.7191593647,
-0.1487775296,
-0.1156605333,
-0.3326325417,
0.4630044699,
0.2922637761,
0.3701873422,
-0.3137716055,
0.172023043,
-0.2124473155,
-0.4470048845,
0.2284610718,
-0.2816301286,
0.7103617787,
0.0560930818,
-0.3198264241,
0.083342053,
-0.4432103932,
-0.0704084039,
-0.1449452639,
-0.4233196676,
-0.5958628654,
-0.0485562868,
-0.2599467635,
0.4070722461,
0.1766568422,
-0.3681394458,
0.0806517825,
-0.7296839356,
0.0596182607,
0.6097796559,
-0.4281477332,
0.7720366716,
-0.0200864691,
0.2985652983,
0.0707795247,
-0.2340794057,
-0.2535626888,
-0.6400609016,
-1.0206788778,
-0.1761219501,
0.5832198858,
0.6514513493,
-0.4824024439,
0.2650560141,
-0.3475972712,
-0.228346169,
-0.9653285742,
0.3980153203,
0.7416673899,
0.6373839378,
0.7709444761,
-0.2167208493,
-0.4961360991,
-0.9468356967,
-0.2863372266,
-0.1672567725,
0.0892962068,
0.1638855487,
0.3006649315,
-0.2228442132,
0.558447361,
-0.1544777602,
-0.1612268239,
-0.3254887462,
0.2712006867,
0.2624599338,
0.9187208414,
0.2030429691,
-0.613124311,
-0.5763758421,
0.2754349411,
-0.9048786163,
-0.050987307,
0.1753760725,
-0.1010056138,
0.4593012631,
0.4511245191,
-0.6184802055,
0.3548309803,
0.7671851516,
-0.2015459836,
-0.0155968079,
-0.52737391,
0.3411519825,
-1.048982501,
0.2050082982,
-0.0783434883,
-0.2730698586,
-0.9411758184,
-0.0192856137,
0.3122377992,
-0.2162202895,
-0.5521444082,
0.5387574434,
-0.5950644016,
-0.4583750367,
-0.4602822661,
-0.0186824277,
-0.1730550528,
0.4287345409,
0.2993743718,
0.6837556362,
0.4973266721,
-0.5571502447,
0.3113955259,
0.1553860903,
0.0555318706,
0.1974747628,
-0.737727344,
0.3782321811,
-0.2915445566,
0.2265131474,
-0.9924585223,
0.1488859504,
0.1965955794,
-0.4463732243,
0.8159278035,
-0.4824000895,
-0.4053779542,
-0.0278858207,
-0.0333567597,
0.491730243,
0.7519616485,
-0.6453168392,
0.7715153098,
0.2428236455,
-0.1399202943,
-0.6152499318,
-0.9406551719,
0.1999496818,
0.0006194314,
-0.6960825324,
0.5305988193,
0.1711520553,
-0.1262026727,
0.0877309367,
-0.0887961462,
0.0333954319,
-0.0667431802,
0.0562094077,
0.0950024202,
-0.5442661047,
0.1524572521,
0.2324819714,
-0.6617606878,
-0.1579103321,
-0.4987338483,
0.540152967,
-0.0940095335,
-0.3328132927,
-0.5715582967,
0.6378561854,
0.4069757462,
-0.3458201885,
0.9996930957,
0.4781424105,
-0.5339323878,
-0.0823215023,
-0.6260415912,
-0.2202304155,
-0.4181756973,
0.2285272628,
-0.537397027,
-0.4171870947,
0.4820085168,
0.319296211,
-0.074483417,
0.468465656,
0.1837140918,
-0.1399500221,
1.7289319038,
0.9376789927,
-0.2461835742,
0.4506192505,
-0.2372238487,
-0.029723078,
-0.9053137898,
-0.1756300032,
-0.6630086303,
-0.2546736002,
-0.675042212,
-0.2638469934,
0.2464375794,
0.1209306419,
-0.0169564188,
0.5181868076,
-0.2207535207,
0.1514120251,
0.5727031231,
0.1148867756,
0.5257932544,
0.0161860436,
-0.086680837,
-0.0424808078,
-0.9580461979,
-0.1825788468,
0.7951062322,
0.4933174253,
0.6457173228,
0.0770108253,
0.7911279202,
-0.146131888,
0.5692987442,
-0.6429213881,
0.3502225578,
-0.5896911621,
-0.2383178174,
0.0231014919,
-0.6518273354,
-0.5838808417,
0.4684827328,
-0.0478277802,
-0.3994530737,
0.3135440052,
0.4773591757,
-0.1739629209,
-0.0882577002,
-0.8402406573,
0.84555161,
-0.3166397512,
-0.2372097075,
-0.2842957377,
-0.3052169085,
0.1804950684,
0.0730024278,
0.1395034492,
0.06668704,
-0.0908877179,
0.5166743398,
-0.2825526893,
0.6510551572,
-0.183601737,
-0.4101353288,
-0.1348134577,
-0.0079122987,
0.7741467357,
-0.1014579087,
-0.1093431637,
0.4905172884,
-0.4352900684,
-0.3044056594,
-0.8114972711,
0.7832595706,
-0.6861851215,
-0.6915302277,
-0.3571011126,
-0.7742770314,
-0.1526275873,
0.1051921844,
0.2374447286,
0.415169239,
0.1834681779,
0.1220972538,
0.7033296824,
-0.2669867873,
0.3406754434,
0.631431818,
-0.1776841283,
-0.5052165389,
0.8657984138,
0.2888590395,
0.4497222006,
0.4356147647,
0.2371127754,
-0.3886397481,
-0.759175241,
-0.606697619,
0.2299693823,
-0.9256446958,
-0.1201638952,
-0.9689727426,
-0.3473636508,
-0.8006743789,
-0.0029722748,
-0.6815721989,
-0.4494939446,
-0.0217248686,
0.1695138067,
0.1828470528,
0.5758699775,
-0.1444636434,
0.1913569272,
-0.964727819,
0.2768158317,
0.1173907593,
0.1694913656,
-0.2623513341,
-0.7589093447,
-0.4326204956,
0.2203889489,
0.3853648901,
-0.9055326581,
0.4034378231,
0.0514720008,
0.8463060856,
-0.0933924988,
-0.5016593337,
0.7008814812,
-0.6220126748,
0.4013206363,
0.1162480414,
-1.1255787611,
0.5045880079,
-0.159954533,
0.7690402865,
0.4055271447,
0.3952941895,
-0.7120175958,
-0.6059229374,
-0.267485112,
-0.7144290805,
0.7318618894,
0.2065390795,
0.3672169149,
0.399087429,
0.1209077165,
0.0344722681,
0.2507631481,
-0.8492620587,
-0.1511330903,
-0.1386290193,
-0.4173272848,
-0.5223946571,
0.024245115,
0.1275449842,
-0.3996740878,
0.7123894691,
-0.0960722044,
0.0874481723,
-0.079873696,
-0.318726182,
-0.1390394866,
0.1182132214,
0.5628706217,
0.1753575802,
-0.0944856629,
0.3190175891,
0.6369282603,
-0.1633304358,
0.0541400947,
0.5302600861,
-0.43233639,
0.2035518289,
0.4066553712,
0.7147138119,
0.3347381651,
-0.3749486506,
0.2338323444,
0.0449504182,
0.0607519746,
0.0411401354,
0.1455554217,
-0.006264518,
0.405615896,
0.1386147738,
0.307703048,
0.1517945081,
-0.5224285126,
0.0253379941,
0.5411115289,
-0.4988618493,
-0.2378936857,
0.4662529826,
0.1708706766,
-0.2494981885,
0.6260336637,
0.1350393444,
-0.9214706421,
0.5154371858,
0.7942361832,
1.038500309,
-0.5917708278,
-0.1878571212,
0.4197348058,
0.5543448329,
-0.1626718491,
0.1998541951,
-0.2634401619,
-0.6780996323,
-0.6706240773,
-0.3924075961,
-0.226064384,
-0.0759869441,
-0.2916089296,
0.4619743824,
-0.0907968357,
0.0263476502,
-0.2407588363,
-0.2722199559,
-0.6774530411,
0.2811845243,
0.4474188089,
0.7616838217,
-0.6978796124,
1.1269530058,
0.5722813606,
-0.6757578254,
-0.5531213284,
-0.159808144,
-0.2295064181,
-0.4829989672,
1.034537673,
0.2296032012,
-0.5273495317,
0.0604303405,
-0.044849854,
-1.1851146221,
0.6752322316,
0.6095974445,
-0.3346232772,
0.0057312385,
0.1319587529,
0.6568954587,
-0.5003663301,
0.0381952934,
0.3360958695,
0.3182283342,
-0.0440673977,
-0.8698179722,
0.162714228,
-0.3180831373,
0.1598398685,
0.364377141,
-0.1727122217,
0.8436657786,
0.0111749712,
-0.4528953433,
-0.0592063442,
0.8679116368,
-0.1867563277,
0.2767715156,
0.4338874519,
0.3705206513,
0.368711561,
0.0342872888,
1.107470274,
-0.1985590309,
0.1472440511,
1.4596450329,
-0.1578483135,
1.0219459534,
0.3655258715,
0.2056524605,
0.1302537769,
0.2900532186,
0.1296862364,
0.5527681708,
-0.1527976543,
-0.2602909803,
-0.1269313544,
-0.0662177801,
-0.7800042033,
0.4664802253,
0.2389068753,
-0.7139685154,
-0.1972985864,
0.2164341658,
-0.0723843127,
0.1241534501,
-0.1460540593,
1.0115032196,
0.1527703553,
-0.9327586293,
0.7427223325,
0.1329586357,
0.5167748928,
-0.3859258294,
-0.1978780776,
-0.4693900347,
0.4180807173,
-0.1524193585,
-0.4470815063,
0.4847951531,
0.0596497543,
-0.2132636756,
-0.5260763764,
0.714410305,
-0.9438936114,
-0.4495961964,
0.7627137899,
0.4688636661,
0.0513234772,
-0.0441531241,
-0.6118786335,
0.0572945327,
-0.2926921546,
0.0913337991,
0.2182338387,
-0.0757867023,
0.3410453796,
0.429890424,
0.7603245378,
0.1363252997,
0.0917124376,
0.1157225966,
0.759673357,
-0.5507519245,
-0.535581708,
-0.8946917653,
0.700226903,
-0.1058977768,
-0.1226890981,
0.933003366,
0.588232398,
1.0189810991,
0.2325017899,
0.6537949443,
0.3531689346,
0.2585658133,
-0.7733874917,
0.7849761844,
-0.5535020232,
0.2446599007,
-0.2121304423,
-0.9420152903,
-0.3453064859,
0.461990267,
-0.4017140865,
0.1688222736,
0.5901296735,
0.7688423991,
-0.3286437094,
-0.0918435231,
0.3452017903,
0.1826681197,
0.265001446,
0.4230831265,
0.9802256227,
-0.7835872173,
0.5660313964,
-0.4601349831,
-0.1184109375,
-0.1283065379,
-0.8719508648,
-0.7289893031,
-0.5295010805,
-0.3389192224,
-0.5829622149,
0.2631594539,
0.9455712438,
0.8836293817,
-1.0571548939,
-0.445138365,
-0.1072494462,
0.3259429336,
-0.414290905,
-0.0456876867,
0.0089446194,
-0.6333016753,
-0.9115773439,
0.8120494485,
0.2720472515,
0.2328690588,
-0.1597505808,
-0.2980207801,
-0.2386699617,
-0.001145868,
0.6171219945,
0.267698437,
-0.4947037697,
-0.153486073,
0.045216009,
-0.3529686034,
0.0995365381,
0.9748055339,
-0.6378014684,
0.567160368,
0.6513763666,
0.9171428084,
0.7032911777,
-0.1672437638,
1.1469122171,
-0.6576591134,
0.3015381396,
0.1473430097,
0.462552011,
0.5362430215,
-0.533413291,
0.313447535,
0.0488978475,
-0.1094082147,
-0.8289216161,
0.0548988804,
-0.4349744618,
-0.285432905,
0.9688689113,
-0.1120558307,
-0.2048111409,
0.0082828933,
-0.0794083625,
0.6307569146,
-0.4121693075,
0.5152000189,
0.5534872413,
-0.0397771858,
-0.0898203403,
-0.5457395315,
0.4340081215,
0.7761939764,
-0.7508500814,
-0.1241286844,
0.4951801896,
0.0003656579,
0.2606220543,
0.3515807092,
0.0429566428,
0.4893857539,
0.0126442518,
-0.0705741793,
-0.1058378145,
-0.4575538635,
-0.970225215,
0.028094139,
-0.0658811405,
-0.1945761889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05076v1 | DLAMA: A Framework for Curating Culturally Diverse Facts for Probing the Knowledge of Pretrained Language Models | 2023-06-08T09:59:48 | 2023-06-08T09:59:48 | Amr Keleg, Walid Magdy | cs.CL | cs.CL | A few benchmarking datasets have been released to evaluate the factual
knowledge of pretrained language models. These benchmarks (e.g., LAMA, and
ParaRel) are mainly developed in English and later are translated to form new
multilingual versions (e.g., mLAMA, and mParaRel). Results on these
multilingual benchmarks suggest that using English prompts to recall the facts
from multilingual models usually yields significantly better and more
consistent performance than using non-English prompts. Our analysis shows that
mLAMA is biased toward facts from Western countries, which might affect the
fairness of probing models. We propose a new framework for curating factual
triples from Wikidata that are culturally diverse. A new benchmark DLAMA-v1 is
built of factual triples from three pairs of contrasting cultures having a
total of 78,259 triples from 20 relation predicates. The three pairs comprise
facts representing the (Arab and Western), (Asian and Western), and (South
American and Western) countries respectively. Having a more balanced benchmark
(DLAMA-v1) supports that mBERT performs better on Western facts than
non-Western ones, while monolingual Arabic, English, and Korean models tend to
perform better on their culturally proximate facts. Moreover, both monolingual
and multilingual models tend to make a prediction that is culturally or
geographically relevant to the correct label, even if the prediction is wrong. | [
-0.4547095895,
-0.5646591187,
0.528695941,
0.2758139372,
-0.2058564872,
0.1370912194,
-0.3807393014,
-0.5377870798,
-0.0318636745,
0.3755488992,
-0.3418192565,
-0.7249800563,
-0.6359910965,
0.2444245666,
-0.1082950234,
1.1272668839,
-0.3546555936,
0.1895153522,
-0.2017356604,
-0.7464445829,
-0.398866564,
-0.6245160103,
-0.1757475287,
-0.2138966769,
0.6419841051,
0.6037333608,
0.5903019309,
0.5258191824,
0.4544143975,
0.2272170931,
-0.0504643135,
0.5724399686,
-0.57849437,
0.0957817435,
-0.2027402371,
-0.6441322565,
-0.3020859659,
0.4479661286,
0.4747877121,
0.903296113,
-0.1217333823,
0.6815099716,
-0.1558512449,
0.6116814017,
-0.8636844158,
0.1839611381,
-0.5498703718,
0.0746438354,
-0.2822425961,
-0.1045727059,
-0.3842535317,
-0.9070457816,
0.1022947356,
-0.5128260851,
0.1346339285,
-0.1061925963,
0.8661573529,
0.2365819067,
-1.0374667645,
-0.2424787432,
-0.7235102057,
0.8840274215,
-0.4305220246,
0.3407542109,
0.694668293,
0.4030347764,
0.2071461976,
-0.6393452883,
-0.5799423456,
-0.221738711,
-0.2447849065,
0.0410218313,
-0.0438458286,
-0.5176711679,
0.245197162,
0.3598680496,
-0.3543443084,
0.2018762976,
-0.5143232942,
-0.2989189327,
0.6061096787,
0.1440290064,
0.333904922,
0.0163564533,
-0.4098628461,
-0.067066066,
-1.102684617,
-0.0094922679,
0.6039113998,
0.4162599444,
-0.3965120912,
0.3583919704,
-0.2327644974,
0.5982306004,
-0.1632812023,
-0.6421863437,
0.5597656965,
-0.574118495,
0.2549553216,
0.1027200669,
0.6186133623,
0.428281039,
0.4549180269,
-0.0736609623,
0.1431778669,
0.2110656351,
-0.1292401254,
-0.8767340183,
-0.112588197,
0.0081420084,
-0.4579665661,
0.0665318519,
-0.0295966603,
-0.7857393622,
-0.1783039868,
-0.3991782665,
0.2617712021,
-0.2020834833,
-0.4624964297,
0.1067125052,
0.1216557026,
0.1364401579,
0.1786628217,
-0.7509840727,
0.0161323845,
0.4075199664,
0.5846346021,
-0.2366854697,
-0.5179621577,
-0.3642515242,
0.2257183492,
-0.2764248252,
0.677631557,
-0.574324429,
-0.2859206498,
0.1030856743,
-0.2730321884,
0.2099772692,
-0.4754250944,
0.8317974806,
-0.7412366271,
0.3768976033,
-0.8785520792,
-0.1567811668,
-0.4462732971,
0.6054089665,
-0.9452756643,
1.1856986284,
-0.242316097,
-0.887635231,
0.791977644,
-0.4911527932,
-0.5843038559,
-0.3423760533,
-0.1501116753,
-0.119792603,
-0.2957985401,
0.5225507021,
0.2157050073,
-0.412831068,
0.5828714967,
-0.2733851373,
-0.4058328271,
0.0274442732,
-0.626544714,
0.9644216299,
0.3431656361,
-0.3402077258,
-0.1797408313,
-1.0720847845,
-0.1503239423,
0.1688129902,
-0.5863152146,
-0.4629152119,
-0.0430207178,
-0.3251473308,
0.3664304018,
0.2493406236,
-0.493173033,
0.0300534274,
-0.0396896563,
-0.3471422493,
0.7696849704,
-0.2821300328,
0.1582462937,
-0.3702209592,
0.4993891716,
0.4730398059,
-0.0155698005,
-0.2029398233,
-0.2596888244,
-0.9712690711,
-0.4820761979,
0.0848980919,
0.5174068809,
-0.6255168319,
0.0987138897,
-0.2826398909,
-0.6272868514,
-0.8583760262,
0.2018832564,
0.2893576324,
0.6239224672,
0.4112940729,
-0.0451820157,
-0.8173483014,
-0.8947509527,
-0.2327974141,
-0.370829463,
0.319118917,
0.1015710831,
0.3724362552,
-0.1675457954,
0.8138724566,
-0.3529883921,
-0.1414687783,
0.0316407494,
0.3029453754,
0.4243551791,
0.1784608066,
0.8569408655,
-0.7718884945,
-0.6124085188,
0.0255240165,
-0.95076406,
-0.2425090373,
0.4643772542,
-0.1543642581,
0.3366420269,
0.182301119,
-0.559011817,
0.367138654,
0.7215245962,
-0.1686606407,
0.5620988011,
0.061653588,
0.5412886739,
-1.0938655138,
0.3492253721,
-0.4443612695,
-0.040456567,
-0.3948049843,
0.1641436666,
0.0422621928,
0.2197120935,
-0.4023725092,
0.640034318,
-0.5048212409,
0.0959462523,
-0.1755867153,
0.1802991182,
0.1339662373,
0.4266346693,
0.0409644842,
0.7489159107,
0.4276008308,
-0.7775393724,
0.3127507567,
0.1318433434,
-0.7017022371,
0.6628459096,
-0.4341177344,
0.1922603548,
-0.2771965265,
0.2446145862,
-0.8432098031,
0.1902055144,
-0.0728249624,
-0.1992500871,
0.0295965914,
-0.1035216451,
-0.54737854,
-0.2694680095,
-0.2474684417,
0.7600208521,
0.3251161575,
-0.9212228656,
0.401732564,
0.5180020332,
-0.1823448837,
-1.142305851,
-0.4598057866,
-0.0723626688,
-0.4369561374,
-0.5417846441,
0.0698826835,
-0.2210153937,
-0.4255966544,
-0.1708888113,
-0.0952502862,
0.0641274974,
0.2209529579,
0.1065499112,
0.3249199688,
-0.4501860738,
0.0039477865,
-0.2477185726,
0.0958628207,
0.2256533951,
-0.0863986313,
0.4965092242,
-0.1398925036,
-0.4567998946,
-0.0489200838,
0.4527935088,
0.4126810431,
-0.6593196392,
0.9012925029,
0.9950027466,
-0.1933290511,
0.0442954898,
-0.8573102355,
0.0160680134,
-0.4174200892,
0.2390954494,
-0.5227862,
-0.8444900513,
0.7513939142,
0.0837383941,
0.1047146171,
0.3401590288,
0.7685337067,
0.1851542592,
1.0240623951,
0.6626641154,
-0.2437388748,
0.009797032,
-0.0878006443,
0.1859653294,
-0.2365906984,
-0.3751111627,
-0.8482608199,
-0.2626274228,
-0.7344326973,
-0.42557621,
0.4363404214,
-0.0247256868,
-0.311527133,
0.0049750316,
0.2983706295,
0.5693115592,
0.591771841,
-0.1628717482,
0.6022674441,
0.0741319656,
-0.5196916461,
-0.1293942481,
-0.5765914321,
-0.8041898608,
1.3220539093,
0.0797396526,
0.7821542621,
0.6058595777,
0.5680198669,
0.1543266624,
0.6288102865,
-0.4565603733,
0.3372351825,
0.0301810913,
-0.9440241456,
0.2474980652,
-0.5144183636,
-0.8324972987,
0.2669080496,
0.00625944,
-0.493239671,
0.1606762558,
0.0107487887,
-0.121730417,
0.3470898569,
-0.6482371688,
0.4815298617,
-0.2366442382,
-0.387060076,
-0.2768267095,
-0.5606957078,
0.6293688416,
-0.243940115,
0.4260692596,
-0.4355297089,
0.0568570122,
0.7019827366,
-0.1036235541,
0.8517355323,
-0.238898769,
-0.4303919673,
0.2051284909,
0.1264705509,
0.2197531611,
0.0784390122,
-0.4576851428,
0.2454859018,
0.11034026,
-0.5666899681,
-0.3927048147,
0.648647964,
-1.0726741552,
-0.8243736625,
-0.5006890297,
-0.6870526075,
-0.4814646244,
0.15512456,
-0.1312703639,
0.2449822128,
-0.3740216792,
0.1531020999,
0.3210830986,
-0.1095139012,
0.2406296581,
1.1275632381,
-0.2593825161,
-0.0495005623,
0.5878679156,
0.0931948423,
0.1223600805,
0.3915765584,
0.1026532352,
-0.247363314,
-0.4204739034,
-0.2811144292,
0.1971476823,
-1.1230846643,
-0.3239571452,
-0.6889958978,
0.0612025075,
-0.2542601526,
0.2484015077,
-0.2632552385,
-0.2546610236,
0.0308535695,
-0.5299260616,
0.3086465299,
0.7529972196,
-0.39481318,
-0.0446218289,
-0.7133814692,
0.3934293389,
0.3089297116,
0.2625166476,
-0.0097717419,
-0.5172166824,
-0.4473579228,
0.2539912164,
-0.1112958565,
-0.7403252721,
0.0703935549,
0.086343348,
0.9436981678,
0.4646275043,
0.1664914638,
0.8271906972,
-0.4919557571,
0.6798315644,
-0.1280807406,
-0.706068337,
0.5463091731,
-0.1122188941,
0.1759642661,
0.7700155377,
0.9636139274,
-0.4775220752,
-0.3005561531,
-0.1073854342,
-0.6267821193,
0.7931289673,
-0.2106921524,
0.2415507883,
-0.2828851342,
-0.0994501933,
0.6622829437,
0.0792552605,
-0.7888825536,
-0.43642506,
-0.1500956714,
-0.2414803207,
-0.1850395352,
-0.4135313928,
-0.4509896934,
-0.301697433,
0.6980224848,
-0.1791396141,
-0.3116343021,
-0.0141559038,
-0.5360766053,
0.0844564959,
0.1650022119,
0.4941757023,
0.9993360043,
-0.3639966249,
0.3710688353,
0.2681400478,
-0.5916629434,
0.484082371,
0.1772018671,
-0.2400958836,
-0.0267194752,
0.4312276542,
0.8281708956,
0.0524282902,
-0.6115816832,
0.3116999567,
-0.2190390378,
0.2300171852,
-0.03953363,
-0.1662729234,
0.0250705164,
-0.0160283465,
0.3693906367,
-0.0764210448,
-0.0083986195,
-0.6869698167,
0.1346449703,
0.1164714918,
-0.0014642036,
-0.424859792,
0.4176058173,
0.5019141436,
0.366723001,
0.5307170153,
-0.1601519138,
-0.5750940442,
0.434689492,
0.6606325507,
0.2897458673,
-0.3377119899,
0.2348430753,
0.6679654121,
0.4603485167,
0.1532088816,
0.5142415166,
-0.1718968451,
-0.9996768832,
-0.4356637597,
-0.6108401418,
-0.2048161179,
-0.0935665295,
-0.8171637058,
0.3060105741,
-0.2738515735,
-0.1771576554,
-0.1488717943,
0.3262108266,
-1.2187837362,
0.3199335635,
0.3378250301,
0.8439713717,
-0.9672538042,
0.9695269465,
0.6362411976,
-0.5296402574,
-0.7036882043,
-0.1008402482,
0.189985171,
-1.0689097643,
1.1448985338,
0.2554483712,
-0.3209308684,
-0.3333826661,
-0.2646904588,
-1.0586751699,
0.9810518622,
0.7129825354,
-0.1354611814,
0.211216405,
0.2235404253,
0.4724527895,
-0.3098678589,
0.4450348914,
0.6995962262,
0.6568906903,
-0.1082823724,
-0.9601037502,
-0.0221671425,
-0.4096811712,
-0.3482390642,
-0.1212548986,
-0.6815231442,
0.9725804925,
-0.4509147108,
-0.3128396273,
0.0702054724,
0.8522849083,
0.5799314976,
0.1396344453,
0.3748385906,
0.491119802,
1.1036387682,
-0.1528651118,
0.9097107053,
-0.2792632878,
0.0756707117,
1.1904653311,
-0.7265883088,
0.633877635,
0.5573509336,
-0.3880256414,
0.8059314489,
0.5149412751,
0.1874186844,
0.479616344,
0.0414367877,
-0.2989372611,
-0.0535819083,
-0.5943098664,
-0.6539468765,
0.9570607543,
0.227682367,
-0.1144051179,
-0.3305597901,
-0.1948091239,
0.6027585864,
0.3130475581,
-0.2169572562,
0.5031443238,
-0.161605224,
-0.9663612247,
0.6096592546,
0.1500743628,
0.7433089614,
-0.7620139122,
0.0668760762,
-0.7375965714,
0.0060005952,
-0.0585358776,
-0.6550697684,
0.1596564054,
0.2353993952,
-0.4737503529,
-0.0346161202,
0.360632211,
-0.6909219623,
-0.5749167204,
0.4566075504,
0.6923016906,
0.0810437799,
0.4329430759,
-0.2553160489,
0.3012741208,
-0.039231088,
-0.1257178634,
0.065059945,
0.457834959,
-0.2008602619,
0.5406944752,
0.6514247656,
0.0285994504,
0.1112190261,
0.3978327811,
0.5948414803,
-0.553396821,
-0.4547422826,
-0.9051119685,
0.3166181743,
-0.065063931,
-0.2471947223,
1.0157585144,
0.4796618521,
0.9600688219,
0.0488237701,
0.6629732251,
0.1637376845,
0.4705216885,
-0.7077741027,
0.8876699209,
-0.5178028345,
0.1204834431,
-0.1349177212,
-0.8375051022,
-0.0071725785,
0.3461795449,
-0.1943679005,
0.3949788809,
0.6621429324,
0.7442255616,
-0.1244959906,
0.1511163861,
0.1471371949,
0.2614828944,
0.2933190763,
0.4680089951,
0.964107573,
-0.2734721303,
0.6396818161,
-0.2401936799,
-0.0486567356,
-0.0088578798,
-1.1502424479,
-0.9815480709,
-0.6564676166,
-0.1914178431,
-0.1141780764,
-0.1526605636,
0.8386949301,
0.889608562,
-0.868946135,
-0.2836744785,
0.9040006399,
0.2612524629,
-0.0981307402,
-0.1708624214,
0.457008481,
-0.224627316,
-0.7062259316,
0.4245767891,
0.0689440072,
-0.0776818916,
-0.3421963453,
-0.1806985438,
-0.5487292409,
0.1116620302,
0.7629603148,
0.0587150156,
-0.6442853808,
-0.3894874454,
-0.1925063431,
-0.255826354,
-0.0359329544,
0.6513896585,
-0.8984401226,
0.3838009238,
0.3393802345,
0.6088956594,
0.4253124297,
-0.2967566848,
0.8051326871,
-0.9634845257,
0.5837471485,
0.0151238879,
0.5008947849,
0.6761730909,
0.0313041098,
0.5485106707,
0.1940043569,
-0.2175537497,
-0.8984171748,
0.3122092485,
-0.6226916909,
-0.0277842768,
0.9458404183,
-0.4807356298,
-0.0009225887,
-0.1551100761,
-0.167105183,
0.3646500409,
0.0774020925,
0.8083077073,
1.0139786005,
0.5811877847,
0.1321286708,
-0.4519348145,
0.3983585536,
0.5414534807,
-0.8803943396,
-0.097068496,
0.4650987983,
0.3747904897,
0.1372003108,
0.6003357172,
-0.2123377919,
0.4211721718,
-0.1318041533,
0.0473181382,
-0.1006706282,
-0.3604618013,
0.0737771988,
0.0839741006,
0.1415836662,
0.0310236122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05075v1 | LCT-1 at SemEval-2023 Task 10: Pre-training and Multi-task Learning for Sexism Detection and Classification | 2023-06-08T09:56:57 | 2023-06-08T09:56:57 | Konstantin Chernyshev, Ekaterina Garanina, Duygu Bayram, Qiankun Zheng, Lukas Edman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Misogyny and sexism are growing problems in social media. Advances have been
made in online sexism detection but the systems are often uninterpretable.
SemEval-2023 Task 10 on Explainable Detection of Online Sexism aims at
increasing explainability of the sexism detection, and our team participated in
all the proposed subtasks. Our system is based on further domain-adaptive
pre-training (Gururangan et al., 2020). Building on the Transformer-based
models with the domain adaptation, we compare fine-tuning with multi-task
learning and show that each subtask requires a different system configuration.
In our experiments, multi-task learning performs on par with standard
fine-tuning for sexism detection and noticeably better for coarse-grained
sexism classification, while fine-tuning is preferable for fine-grained
classification. | [
-0.4436274767,
-0.7191995978,
0.402600944,
0.3158558607,
-0.2917249203,
-0.0926323086,
-0.1611455977,
-0.3440542817,
-0.2432152331,
0.386716485,
-0.9024733305,
-0.1191613674,
-0.854981184,
0.3982393146,
-0.4194090962,
1.0812795162,
0.0758703798,
0.1171532124,
-0.1600798815,
-0.037585184,
-0.5181614161,
-0.5471386313,
-0.6414954662,
0.0127703631,
0.3645602465,
0.3061082959,
0.2207754552,
0.1461509913,
0.4790031016,
0.3469451666,
0.1155046225,
0.3907290995,
-0.7346969247,
0.0811636895,
-0.4546233714,
-0.4280037582,
-0.6389819384,
0.0307365488,
0.1688149571,
0.4560952485,
0.0329662934,
0.4037221074,
0.2648896575,
0.6053428054,
-0.7110521793,
-0.0675390884,
-0.7358446717,
0.1002265066,
-0.3050639033,
-0.3807200789,
-0.4176096618,
0.0841031596,
0.0811051652,
-0.5513348579,
0.6236793995,
0.1238328516,
0.5115482807,
0.2485356331,
-0.7833863497,
-0.3496373594,
-0.7753084898,
0.8813247681,
-0.2974070907,
0.6943327188,
0.4811497331,
0.132812798,
0.117530182,
-0.4995956421,
-0.3931517601,
0.116858393,
-0.1863229424,
0.0422436856,
-0.2598336041,
-0.18550843,
0.3413874507,
-0.0592358373,
-0.670579493,
-0.0171840973,
-0.2617232502,
-0.1564212143,
0.4564488828,
0.0350966416,
0.1234414577,
-0.1302269846,
-0.3377508521,
0.208296001,
-0.3620745242,
-0.0059427735,
0.4797516465,
0.4881266952,
-0.1108107492,
-0.0598444268,
-0.0458309017,
0.0513066053,
0.3405159712,
-0.0216176789,
0.3645707667,
-0.4365105331,
-0.2259615362,
-0.0748923346,
0.4108987451,
0.1700965613,
0.2076588422,
0.1853387505,
-0.0060457522,
0.2670044601,
0.6819072962,
-0.6342626214,
-0.2158651054,
0.0526626669,
-0.5351276994,
-0.434050113,
-0.1376662552,
-0.6310404539,
-0.540908277,
-0.5226210952,
0.4496091306,
-0.2428314984,
-0.5736397505,
-0.0947414711,
-0.0394774526,
0.1227676198,
0.7599627972,
-0.7819974422,
0.2635060549,
0.4594845176,
0.4763451219,
-0.4164789021,
-0.2220893651,
-0.3066954315,
-0.1551656425,
-0.1389178932,
0.7994760275,
-0.4015798569,
0.0336816572,
0.0210546274,
0.7336066365,
-0.2656998336,
-0.2641839683,
0.5887505412,
-0.4133381844,
0.234461233,
-0.6049452424,
-0.1831652522,
-0.1317369789,
0.3168255687,
-0.3851059377,
0.9162374735,
0.0331287012,
-0.8679059744,
0.6026358008,
-0.867112875,
-0.5270036459,
-0.038801644,
0.2316574752,
-0.7499784231,
-0.05779735,
0.3052301109,
0.6948934793,
-0.0680546314,
0.1344156861,
-0.500848949,
-0.3348501921,
-0.0745640695,
-0.3243700266,
0.7049160004,
0.4130802751,
-0.6127577424,
0.3912579417,
-0.5085572004,
-0.29483217,
0.2210651934,
0.1000752524,
-0.2902262807,
0.037369661,
0.0604502335,
0.0800460279,
0.1361224055,
-0.3839364648,
-0.2367318273,
-0.1478130966,
0.3154644966,
0.9288132191,
-0.2250163406,
0.4632337391,
-0.1933505684,
0.4627152979,
0.3329338431,
0.242784977,
0.0206096303,
-0.1207256839,
-0.7963453531,
0.1552075595,
-0.0595459752,
0.5400015116,
-0.9252592325,
0.1915827543,
-0.0592711493,
-0.4159610569,
0.1115755141,
0.1349627078,
0.4499333501,
-0.0099833841,
0.6079097986,
-0.1469313055,
-0.7781124115,
-0.7172219157,
-0.499548763,
0.1769223809,
0.245717749,
0.0787744522,
0.9538097978,
-0.0405531451,
0.3411126137,
-0.2106834799,
-0.4413809478,
-0.2280514836,
0.2974825203,
-0.1236175671,
0.538597703,
0.7011470199,
-1.147793889,
-0.3908945322,
-0.0409982577,
-0.7324396372,
-0.0938609764,
0.1414179802,
-0.0118827112,
0.1116616726,
0.6132274866,
-0.02354265,
0.412476182,
0.2451998591,
-0.3477780223,
0.567812562,
-0.0781272948,
0.5767357349,
-1.04649055,
-0.3101734817,
0.0834107473,
-0.517234385,
-0.9257039428,
-0.0646170527,
0.1376114041,
0.0238270555,
-0.6220724583,
0.0646302253,
-0.3763248026,
-0.1702741235,
-0.5112636089,
-0.1285010427,
-0.3955872655,
0.5898409486,
-0.0558886714,
0.6889992952,
0.4168912172,
-0.8127381802,
0.1634867936,
0.0452735983,
0.0838762224,
0.7891677022,
-0.3386693001,
0.5349695683,
-0.3016785979,
0.3669773936,
-0.9933799505,
-0.2272659391,
0.1914329529,
-0.4561120272,
-0.048451636,
-0.156741038,
-0.2972388268,
-0.4740892649,
-0.3833065629,
0.4626658261,
0.040046826,
-0.5774498582,
0.6461184621,
0.5413541198,
0.1254426986,
-0.6158065796,
-0.2130908966,
-0.4061248004,
-0.2552013993,
-0.225057736,
0.327826947,
0.1260585487,
0.173992604,
-0.2481749654,
-0.2182775885,
-0.1293293685,
0.2915826142,
0.2643642724,
0.0248572044,
-0.1031314656,
0.3588998616,
0.1708996892,
0.0989050716,
0.0458339714,
-0.09436436,
0.6797788143,
-0.315448612,
-0.4071154296,
-0.362927705,
0.3676345944,
0.4340176284,
-0.0668867975,
0.5768398046,
1.2420847416,
-0.618919909,
-0.4147277176,
-0.3801387548,
-0.3299624324,
-0.4892359376,
0.5625724196,
-0.4068476558,
-1.1435376406,
0.2425488681,
-0.2263690084,
-0.0212507322,
0.4787731767,
0.5515024662,
-0.4066924453,
1.1799705029,
0.8892092109,
0.3252801597,
0.4797465205,
-0.0066020289,
0.048457589,
-0.460108012,
0.0678727999,
-0.6083046198,
-0.3049840629,
-0.7717908621,
-0.2375991493,
0.2544745803,
-0.1244838759,
-0.5588790178,
0.7853850126,
-0.641163528,
0.3480372429,
0.2091942132,
0.3989289403,
0.0767697915,
-0.1284658611,
0.3165320158,
-0.2572825849,
-0.3130090535,
-0.3180609941,
0.9230718017,
0.2836015522,
0.6264669895,
0.2959046662,
0.1802600175,
0.7029440999,
0.261416316,
-0.2598170042,
0.5060884953,
-0.7254660726,
-0.7405437827,
-0.1062047854,
-0.1500159353,
-0.9397697449,
0.4742662311,
-0.3951716125,
-0.6620975733,
0.259359479,
0.3273379505,
-0.0684365034,
0.339466989,
-0.6452887654,
0.95547539,
-0.0982922316,
-0.2748989761,
-0.2710272968,
-0.5307821631,
0.3502963185,
-0.2463193685,
0.6234638691,
-0.2823381424,
0.3041889071,
0.8556060195,
0.0114467582,
1.1960080862,
-0.4820742905,
-0.0565321483,
-0.1953511536,
-0.1493322104,
0.3601880372,
-0.0730805546,
0.2771163583,
-0.1209222972,
0.3184701502,
-0.4546981454,
-0.2092015445,
0.3499043584,
-0.8216173649,
-0.5192350149,
-0.3499342501,
-0.3822372854,
-0.2910482585,
0.1059341282,
0.2304234207,
0.305749923,
-0.1949133724,
0.4454528391,
0.7302458286,
-0.2937152088,
0.172645092,
0.2915758491,
-0.2436851561,
-0.057482738,
0.8242781162,
-0.1194025576,
0.0597033314,
0.2647902369,
0.0236402079,
-0.2379403859,
-0.360953927,
-0.2378524095,
-0.1651600152,
-0.8094375134,
-0.0749684498,
-0.914642036,
-0.1404821277,
-0.8169339299,
-0.1301475763,
-0.4947554171,
0.078328222,
-0.3747466207,
0.145775333,
0.1133750975,
0.7563210726,
0.1534236819,
0.5468308926,
-0.6632527709,
0.428021431,
0.475676477,
-0.1450384408,
-0.29940781,
-0.8860572577,
0.0050480743,
-0.0106194913,
-0.6982587576,
-0.9072329998,
0.2975168824,
0.2454339415,
0.4290697277,
0.4745664597,
0.053929504,
0.8080664277,
-0.2344445139,
0.6633123755,
0.2336760312,
-1.1551049948,
0.9589291811,
-0.3616196215,
0.1661356986,
0.4625279307,
0.7438114882,
-0.3868993521,
-0.1520870328,
-0.4835603535,
-0.4225727618,
0.9192807078,
0.3319478333,
0.3300282359,
0.1089109927,
0.3554568887,
0.4155340493,
0.2278691232,
-1.1141248941,
-0.3732691109,
-0.320309937,
-0.0678973123,
0.2157600522,
-0.1364946663,
-0.0280462969,
-0.5183123946,
0.7300462127,
-0.4668545425,
0.6121743321,
-0.1235696003,
-0.5304623246,
-0.1595387161,
0.4373545349,
0.809579432,
0.8091976643,
-0.0461511984,
0.3598093688,
0.757981658,
-0.616322577,
0.2246654332,
-0.0921070501,
0.2512841523,
-0.2054017484,
0.5117267966,
1.1218870878,
0.2161003947,
-0.2390076965,
0.8870839477,
-0.1127059087,
-0.6023045778,
-0.4292318225,
0.0688463524,
-0.0368890949,
0.3900373876,
0.3613573909,
0.4329801798,
0.1286617219,
-0.6387911439,
0.2242565453,
0.3418254852,
-0.6756700873,
-0.5686140656,
0.7247744799,
0.1187835783,
-0.0772129744,
-0.1169420555,
-0.506685555,
-0.9357247949,
0.5958667994,
0.5874457955,
0.6289166808,
-0.3892713785,
0.3357509375,
0.4346998632,
0.3780407608,
0.0308449734,
0.42044577,
-0.0754955038,
-1.1446658373,
-0.2865703404,
-0.5555547476,
-0.2157393247,
0.3158823848,
-0.5657660961,
0.5521553755,
-0.2941471934,
-0.0681703612,
0.4058288038,
-0.211397633,
-0.9049290419,
0.1978801191,
0.1728608608,
0.3188025355,
-1.0795878172,
0.7535582185,
0.9069098234,
-0.0748705342,
-0.4913513362,
-0.1643363088,
0.3673175573,
-0.7385094762,
0.8314634562,
0.4007289708,
-0.2285145968,
-0.0089878151,
-0.59675318,
-0.6552234292,
0.9964157939,
0.3421295583,
-0.5509654284,
-0.0562378429,
0.0058516306,
0.4343686402,
-0.5488897562,
0.3933400512,
0.437835753,
0.3557670414,
-0.0994572639,
-1.2967400551,
0.0843146294,
-0.1155041903,
-0.0448472947,
0.2264278233,
-0.377984494,
0.8921819925,
0.0419692621,
-0.336892873,
-0.39420259,
0.4981884658,
0.0119556477,
0.5105403066,
1.0856993198,
0.3142201006,
0.4853606224,
-0.3346586525,
0.5406431556,
0.2505682111,
0.6468648911,
1.2220793962,
-0.123069711,
0.5409322381,
0.1384961754,
-0.6509267092,
0.4007245302,
0.6591656208,
-0.0022574444,
0.3403134942,
0.0199798644,
-0.0400460996,
-0.5726369619,
-0.1461734474,
-0.4414429665,
0.6251217723,
0.4135919213,
-0.3293390274,
-0.3418763876,
0.7029147744,
-0.128876105,
-0.0192505978,
-0.3867019415,
0.7277646661,
-0.0419506952,
-0.4072294533,
0.36646384,
-0.1164481491,
0.9939575195,
-0.3429012299,
0.0762522891,
0.2653896511,
0.3676574528,
-0.3451324105,
-0.379630059,
0.2273493856,
-0.1116254628,
-0.1636179835,
-0.4519481063,
1.3585728407,
-0.4012849033,
-0.227663517,
0.4341722727,
0.7387393713,
0.0780859068,
-0.3567832112,
-0.8406487107,
-0.1132194921,
0.0977351218,
-0.0893175229,
0.4120452702,
0.3855166435,
-0.2243077457,
0.5378777981,
0.9698336124,
-0.3884413838,
0.0031156945,
0.3124033511,
0.7651215792,
-0.5036884546,
-0.5408357978,
-0.7444368601,
0.0663804263,
-0.1356556118,
-0.3487927318,
0.5935155749,
0.1261395812,
0.990539968,
-0.2926147282,
0.505307138,
-0.206656456,
0.684019208,
-0.1686844826,
0.5269903541,
-0.7772336602,
0.081814833,
-0.4765184522,
-0.8425135016,
-0.1224031895,
0.5235785842,
-0.3290182948,
0.2283961922,
0.995002389,
0.6255018711,
-0.3056177497,
0.6173933744,
0.4108186066,
-0.0024698409,
0.2524210811,
0.239374429,
0.8024256825,
-0.5362029076,
0.4785783887,
-0.4012351036,
-0.1228994057,
-0.2092401832,
-0.799814105,
-1.0135550499,
-0.8747463226,
-0.3335382044,
-0.1289309114,
0.1535397619,
1.0650601387,
1.0299916267,
-1.0832813978,
0.0853054896,
-0.113043502,
-0.0321570262,
-0.4436814189,
-0.2759272456,
0.1927226186,
-0.5996243954,
-0.6621376872,
0.1595923305,
0.1904883385,
-0.2224211395,
-0.0121745626,
0.1778842807,
-0.5057405233,
-0.3171090782,
0.9139493704,
-0.126380682,
-0.594244957,
-0.5564807057,
0.0425715446,
0.1688582748,
-0.1092345193,
0.895873487,
-0.3345386386,
0.1855543554,
0.3617776632,
0.6465107203,
0.5864748955,
-0.0450225435,
0.274841845,
-0.7439025044,
-0.058266528,
0.1081604436,
0.3586413264,
0.0087041222,
-0.5400895476,
0.5340049267,
0.7108203173,
-0.6985360384,
-0.8325567245,
0.1620191783,
-0.9620789886,
-0.4657141566,
0.7944071889,
-0.1805323809,
-0.1900671273,
-0.7682590485,
-0.2303539366,
0.4166504443,
-0.2644840181,
0.4335808456,
0.6221764088,
-0.2128067017,
-0.3911431432,
-0.8159023523,
0.679562211,
0.5697388053,
-1.1341997385,
0.0385256,
0.0735758319,
0.4464422762,
0.2229261249,
0.6322841048,
0.123291336,
0.5804757476,
-0.3701568246,
-0.0158874951,
0.1716257185,
-0.3593311906,
0.0191436652,
0.3735228777,
-0.585652113,
-0.1873956472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05064v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05064v2 | K2: A Foundation Language Model for Geoscience Knowledge Understanding and Utilization | 2023-06-08T09:29:05 | 2023-09-13T19:33:18 | Cheng Deng, Tianhang Zhang, Zhongmou He, Yi Xu, Qiyuan Chen, Yuanyuan Shi, Luoyi Fu, Weinan Zhang, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou, Zhouhan Lin, Junxian He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; F.4.1 | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved great success in general domains
of natural language processing. In this paper, we bring LLMs to the realm of
geoscience with the objective of advancing research and applications in this
field. To this end, we present the first-ever LLM in geoscience, K2, alongside
a suite of resources developed to further promote LLM research within
geoscience. For instance, we have curated the first geoscience instruction
tuning dataset, GeoSignal, which aims to align LLM responses to
geoscience-related user queries. Additionally, we have established the first
geoscience benchmark, GeoBench, to evaluate LLMs in the context of geoscience.
In this work, we experiment with a complete recipe to adapt a pre-trained
general-domain LLM to the geoscience domain. Specifically, we further train the
LLaMA-7B model on 5.5B tokens of geoscience text corpus, including over 1
million pieces of geoscience literature, and utilize GeoSignal's supervised
data to fine-tune the model. Moreover, we share a protocol that can efficiently
gather domain-specific data and construct domain-supervised data, even in
situations where manpower is scarce. Meanwhile, we equip K2 with the abilities
of using tools to be a naive geoscience aide. Experiments conducted on the
GeoBench demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and datasets on
geoscience knowledge understanding and utilization.We open-source all the
training data and K2 model checkpoints at https://github.com/davendw49/k2. | [
0.0667408779,
-0.6684311032,
1.0792173147,
-0.0020446791,
-0.2822957933,
0.049946636,
-0.506544292,
-0.4426727295,
-0.1339561045,
0.5476565957,
-0.2274556309,
-0.8163680434,
-0.8550495505,
-0.2186586857,
-0.4476853907,
0.865031004,
-0.0915893614,
0.0423077047,
-0.5322076082,
-0.0238482729,
-0.3790840209,
-0.3947299421,
-0.2369515151,
-0.8447881341,
0.3039312959,
0.5948092937,
0.7528715134,
0.52633816,
0.2506939173,
0.1093450561,
-0.4167073965,
-0.1086063758,
-0.7375779748,
-0.0023147564,
-0.3865624368,
-0.6972770095,
-0.1983643025,
-0.0359103791,
0.6106806397,
1.0066945553,
0.0105331438,
0.2783671021,
0.0287968479,
0.4478359818,
-0.4698258936,
0.4379627407,
-0.5411117077,
-0.2158315182,
0.0548053756,
-0.0242282618,
-0.2908580899,
-0.1904566288,
0.4889263511,
-0.8115044236,
0.1594772041,
0.0560276322,
0.4441171587,
0.3665795028,
-0.4006078839,
-0.5102903247,
-0.5622842908,
0.6623341441,
-0.2884707749,
0.64629668,
0.5446264148,
0.4611614347,
-0.3343135715,
-0.8087520003,
-0.5169431567,
-0.1925412267,
-0.0629717857,
-0.1133819968,
0.2770726085,
-0.3318758011,
-0.0410019197,
0.3247095644,
-0.6721372604,
0.3272137344,
-0.4103773832,
-0.1286734194,
0.3311867714,
0.2114905566,
-0.0247639269,
-0.2321822196,
-0.3493219018,
-0.1051801294,
-1.0192524195,
0.1159963086,
0.2155465037,
0.3687465191,
-0.3085012734,
0.7466719747,
-0.3675698638,
0.3133912086,
-0.3154869676,
-0.2570567727,
0.0297387149,
-0.1211545393,
-0.3381405771,
0.1111238673,
0.4415704608,
0.2426216751,
0.2259624004,
-0.4635908008,
0.1660152823,
0.3352420926,
-0.0317187235,
-0.8779727817,
-0.5568112135,
0.0247132573,
-0.1702690572,
-0.2693040073,
-0.3466864526,
-0.7318580151,
-0.845954597,
-0.4793554544,
0.1826940328,
-0.2083036304,
-0.3854175806,
0.4166544676,
0.0710412636,
0.1699585468,
0.1668747663,
-0.7441203594,
0.3650217354,
0.8336868286,
0.7033370137,
0.1276507229,
-0.3840858638,
0.0085231485,
0.2527467608,
-0.1972535402,
0.7656213045,
-0.5570269227,
-0.733619988,
-0.1667792797,
0.0703965575,
0.4563060701,
-0.5469637513,
0.5872339606,
-0.7205911279,
0.0664485469,
-0.3825832903,
-0.4910984337,
-0.3697103262,
0.0939549878,
-0.4508084655,
1.2935180664,
0.3440753222,
-0.4288079143,
0.3135005832,
-0.38072294,
-0.1453800946,
0.1984335333,
-0.0730126947,
-0.1474406868,
-0.0252618138,
0.0575082451,
0.132465601,
-0.7364509702,
0.3401621282,
-0.3160459101,
-0.1702736914,
0.0692369044,
0.1031414568,
0.3496749699,
-0.0738616809,
-0.0676724464,
-0.3603666127,
-0.4863830805,
0.3322679996,
0.2700125277,
-0.3642503619,
-0.3605535924,
0.1387738883,
0.0229485761,
0.0558236651,
0.2595209777,
-0.3445082009,
0.1743458062,
-0.4664705992,
0.4012200236,
0.5582564473,
-0.2777264118,
0.726647377,
0.1905137151,
0.2164012045,
-0.458370477,
-0.2522721589,
-0.3081336915,
-0.1897774041,
-0.486879468,
-0.0998399928,
0.3359399438,
0.5203883052,
-0.1136637628,
0.233841598,
-0.7699244022,
-0.7500329614,
-0.2813102007,
0.3818524182,
0.4471585155,
0.6845546961,
0.5210311413,
0.1585544944,
-0.6210151911,
-0.6110773087,
-0.1540769935,
-0.1259503216,
-0.1286475509,
0.6688544154,
0.3906772137,
-0.3468121588,
1.1927747726,
-0.7567059398,
0.0230822321,
-0.068582654,
0.0100097656,
0.2566976845,
0.2628998756,
0.4247272611,
-0.5979669094,
-0.4748977423,
0.1022534147,
-0.9358344674,
-0.2683015764,
0.6318193674,
-0.3667677641,
0.0070000957,
0.4012182355,
-0.7056086063,
0.1724998057,
0.6227650046,
-0.5289379954,
0.4708350003,
0.145019874,
-0.1222392991,
-0.8238975406,
0.2794704437,
-0.0746865422,
-0.3187395334,
-0.50691998,
0.1481585652,
0.1188697815,
-0.2905379832,
-0.2826570272,
0.8119676113,
-0.409711957,
-0.2667499185,
-0.5886071324,
0.0471678562,
-0.0814042166,
-0.0032200464,
0.1113495305,
0.7560275793,
0.6358733177,
-0.6264619827,
0.3715775907,
0.3377802968,
-0.5572937727,
0.3177964985,
-0.7732752562,
0.3768324852,
-0.2025452554,
0.4792281687,
-0.7971965075,
-0.4829171002,
0.2256643027,
-0.3728762269,
0.1685778052,
-0.4619535506,
-0.6153097153,
-0.4056147039,
0.035164386,
0.198826015,
0.7556655407,
-0.731549859,
0.5747600198,
0.4591576755,
-0.5502602458,
-0.2427102327,
-0.5679417849,
0.1066441834,
-0.2412443757,
-0.6582705379,
0.4374896884,
-0.1153251007,
0.0286540855,
0.2976610661,
-0.4619745612,
-0.0968680531,
0.2755968571,
0.4527527988,
0.2330164164,
-0.1015013456,
0.0640730113,
-0.0994577557,
-0.4156025946,
0.4126227498,
-0.5477820039,
0.6987596154,
0.0168653652,
-0.1228631362,
-0.2403470427,
0.0228851568,
0.355270505,
0.2702991664,
0.5916532278,
0.1912909001,
-0.5004622936,
-0.0927252695,
-0.3928326666,
-0.1295609474,
-0.4175459146,
0.5231001377,
-0.2659745812,
-1.2208948135,
0.1909860224,
-0.7800704837,
-0.2770496607,
0.294837743,
0.4972224832,
-0.1393017471,
0.5819219351,
0.9382508397,
-0.4491990209,
-0.0455874801,
-0.190801397,
0.4110150933,
-0.8140108585,
-0.4931136072,
-0.5125829577,
-0.2162264735,
-0.086776346,
-0.4138096869,
0.3966201842,
0.5164612532,
-0.3702150881,
0.180002436,
-0.2006933391,
0.8906394839,
0.2323132008,
0.0754256397,
0.0395013392,
0.3085607886,
0.0098401736,
-0.0216695722,
-0.3871679902,
-0.7971634269,
1.2626355886,
0.3226224184,
0.7987763882,
0.1793701053,
0.2142772973,
0.1918771416,
0.2711459994,
-0.6583189964,
0.4458536208,
0.0470114611,
-0.436581254,
-0.1526233107,
-0.2097057253,
-0.7277140617,
0.0661568642,
-0.0116577707,
-0.7565605044,
-0.2839207649,
0.3358824551,
-0.3282491565,
-0.0414160192,
-0.8006775975,
0.5392917395,
-0.2764024734,
-0.3326544464,
-0.4122356176,
-0.6973124146,
0.2563013434,
-0.0173747484,
0.2943098843,
-0.3482353091,
0.0704657361,
0.1716152877,
0.0006951863,
0.8505930305,
-0.3492073119,
-0.1949296296,
0.4204137027,
0.1640011966,
0.5752937794,
0.4355804324,
-0.1392850131,
0.3513871431,
-0.3254902959,
-0.3072885871,
-0.5490803719,
1.0499745607,
-0.9374837875,
-0.522310555,
-0.1286121756,
-0.5030061603,
-0.052041363,
0.2080180794,
-0.1501372308,
-0.0885980278,
-0.2233097404,
0.1650134325,
0.7957797647,
-0.1333231032,
-0.1228391975,
0.7295523882,
-0.2785025835,
-0.4694942534,
0.7632314563,
-0.0822849572,
0.1329351068,
0.0716789663,
0.2214680016,
-0.6363341212,
-0.3563050628,
-0.1049754396,
0.2589036524,
-0.8667092919,
-0.4563761055,
-0.8483473063,
-0.1644690931,
-0.5508381724,
-0.270042032,
-0.0685035363,
-0.1979887933,
-0.1585476249,
-0.240959838,
0.5067367554,
0.6421761513,
0.1545547396,
0.6995210648,
-0.566519618,
0.2683271468,
0.1308674514,
0.3573511541,
-0.2786433101,
-0.4356103539,
-0.3605262637,
0.0239102636,
-0.0045432854,
-0.4704349637,
0.1256979257,
0.1600818932,
0.5732042193,
-0.098485522,
-0.5220407248,
0.3430303335,
-0.5112649202,
0.7955285907,
-0.0145778963,
-0.7574188113,
0.7269545794,
-0.31792292,
0.1580138206,
0.3338792026,
0.4543822706,
-0.5837419629,
0.2155792713,
-0.4081664085,
-0.9386239648,
0.64494133,
-0.0345149636,
0.0344497785,
0.2563629448,
0.767580688,
0.3896703422,
0.1905347258,
-0.615026176,
-0.0803388953,
-0.1377941966,
-0.1199730933,
-0.1750687957,
-0.5992811918,
-0.3513819277,
0.0711531267,
0.7189689279,
-0.2694637775,
0.1223467439,
0.0557506494,
-0.5935698748,
0.0299600773,
0.2207285911,
0.2665032148,
0.7519096732,
-0.082271494,
0.3796155155,
0.340262413,
-0.5843070745,
0.0977696776,
0.2891449332,
-0.1353855282,
-0.3039430678,
0.054467272,
0.5039125681,
0.3588895202,
-0.731408596,
0.1229733154,
0.3032508492,
-0.2036975175,
-0.2537408173,
0.1803741455,
0.5024539232,
0.3700643182,
0.2483433038,
-0.3740542233,
0.0360463597,
-0.1068972349,
-0.0957831517,
0.1204531789,
0.1525143087,
-0.4061337113,
0.6055666208,
0.1376385391,
0.0752702728,
0.6634823084,
-0.1968481839,
-0.455989778,
0.5912091136,
0.6433162093,
0.3397568762,
-0.120177947,
0.01419577,
0.49965927,
0.2963971794,
-0.1425443143,
0.3502188027,
0.1132292822,
-0.5406368375,
-0.4294897616,
-0.6737599969,
-0.4188323617,
0.3252302706,
-0.2190626562,
0.4725716412,
-0.6289000511,
0.1461139619,
-0.0249256883,
-0.0293693338,
-0.8411361575,
0.2205179483,
0.277517885,
0.9791045189,
-0.837665081,
0.5273569226,
0.8805955648,
0.1366506815,
-0.5781367421,
-0.3819687366,
0.197016418,
-0.9413003325,
0.7616067529,
0.2526687384,
-0.1132994965,
0.2001109868,
-0.8709029555,
-1.1864570379,
1.5166705847,
0.3462374508,
-0.3424367011,
0.2148724645,
0.3874095678,
0.4153926671,
-0.2062927783,
-0.0211459622,
0.7438944578,
0.415872097,
0.0781225413,
-0.6776781082,
0.0368303657,
-0.0551069677,
-0.0524015762,
0.2581918538,
-0.5506711006,
0.587167263,
-0.243339479,
-0.2892538309,
0.3426182568,
0.7157641649,
0.4752297103,
0.3272719979,
0.5474668145,
0.9580283761,
0.9920209646,
-0.1912470907,
0.8910083771,
-0.4978783131,
0.4826004207,
1.1159422398,
-0.6923356652,
0.5704392791,
0.2803398371,
-0.2914806604,
0.4966822863,
0.5832912922,
0.0774850473,
0.8046507239,
0.2652622461,
-0.5594950914,
-0.2042781562,
-0.4688493311,
-0.5899271965,
0.3874625862,
0.6448492408,
-0.2162447274,
-0.4726386964,
-0.312721014,
0.2367291003,
0.0593545139,
-0.214786768,
0.3948011696,
0.1130528972,
-0.3454369903,
0.2292223126,
0.2577879131,
0.3226286769,
-0.8001538515,
0.0318212025,
-0.1494600326,
-0.0386621766,
-0.201272577,
-0.9460050464,
0.0670920238,
0.2122031599,
-0.5681233406,
-0.0053982199,
0.9115057588,
-0.336671412,
-0.4024987817,
0.3474526107,
0.360773623,
0.211507827,
0.013899358,
-0.1344365329,
-0.1107315943,
-0.2811170816,
-0.1338614374,
0.313308835,
0.4152536094,
0.0526584387,
0.6503974795,
0.938782692,
-0.1279963851,
0.0116558047,
0.1228391677,
1.2581022978,
-0.6591817141,
-0.4370155931,
-0.5545504689,
0.3787664175,
0.050682418,
-0.1723002344,
0.3815277517,
0.7329903841,
0.7494968176,
0.0860784352,
1.0877326727,
-0.2225030661,
0.5153485537,
-0.5971729159,
0.4177464545,
-0.0528730974,
0.0595856979,
0.3138088584,
-0.8838686943,
-0.0819775015,
0.4272933006,
-0.3006913364,
-0.0713957399,
0.5591121912,
0.8991137147,
-0.1928173751,
0.0094298674,
-0.1951520443,
0.2317045182,
0.2872592807,
0.5991927981,
0.7550871372,
-0.2004114091,
0.4252656102,
-0.0577979684,
-0.2557603121,
-0.0688102916,
-1.0046436787,
-0.7499364018,
0.0826170668,
0.1241048425,
-0.4305822253,
0.1622241586,
0.7409938574,
0.5448481441,
-0.4476256669,
-0.067892395,
-0.2729157209,
-0.0845905766,
0.3509650528,
-0.2044734806,
0.2442589551,
-0.2147425115,
-0.4952596724,
0.8300395608,
0.1511995196,
0.0200850647,
-0.1817063093,
-0.4283656776,
0.1710626781,
-0.407600373,
0.642326653,
0.3329047859,
-0.6116523743,
-0.262991339,
0.193452239,
-0.147383973,
-0.110670507,
0.8084486127,
-0.8614326715,
0.2352396548,
0.1782379597,
0.9967130423,
0.3566945791,
-0.1700344235,
0.207827419,
-0.6944919229,
0.2372755855,
0.0019753033,
0.2026696652,
0.4703498185,
-0.672896862,
0.8301395178,
0.3384938538,
-0.7724150419,
-0.6240677834,
0.1804774553,
-0.7781530023,
-0.0587654635,
1.46048069,
-0.0536105186,
0.0187343527,
0.2089020312,
-0.1372692883,
0.0650505349,
-0.1511787325,
0.7324602604,
1.0256204605,
0.1275426745,
-0.031152213,
-0.742275238,
0.1290805638,
0.3916108608,
-0.8039036989,
0.1080222279,
0.646478653,
0.718582809,
-0.0312954523,
0.509018898,
0.0023436579,
0.0885763019,
-0.2168605328,
0.1784200966,
-0.1266110688,
-0.54379493,
-0.234694168,
-0.0230170991,
0.1333846599,
0.3272727132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05052v1 | Interpretable Medical Diagnostics with Structured Data Extraction by Large Language Models | 2023-06-08T09:12:28 | 2023-06-08T09:12:28 | Aleksa Bisercic, Mladen Nikolic, Mihaela van der Schaar, Boris Delibasic, Pietro Lio, Andrija Petrovic | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Tabular data is often hidden in text, particularly in medical diagnostic
reports. Traditional machine learning (ML) models designed to work with tabular
data, cannot effectively process information in such form. On the other hand,
large language models (LLMs) which excel at textual tasks, are probably not the
best tool for modeling tabular data. Therefore, we propose a novel, simple, and
effective methodology for extracting structured tabular data from textual
medical reports, called TEMED-LLM. Drawing upon the reasoning capabilities of
LLMs, TEMED-LLM goes beyond traditional extraction techniques, accurately
inferring tabular features, even when their names are not explicitly mentioned
in the text. This is achieved by combining domain-specific reasoning guidelines
with a proposed data validation and reasoning correction feedback loop. By
applying interpretable ML models such as decision trees and logistic regression
over the extracted and validated data, we obtain end-to-end interpretable
predictions. We demonstrate that our approach significantly outperforms
state-of-the-art text classification models in medical diagnostics. Given its
predictive performance, simplicity, and interpretability, TEMED-LLM underscores
the potential of leveraging LLMs to improve the performance and trustworthiness
of ML models in medical applications. | [
0.3557927907,
-0.943375349,
1.0258845091,
-0.0279278848,
-0.417845279,
0.1409305632,
-0.2376211882,
-0.682393074,
0.1290800869,
0.5881896019,
-0.2755126953,
-0.9072920084,
-0.6441949606,
0.232300505,
-0.557066083,
1.2025171518,
-0.164231047,
0.2624139488,
-0.234096542,
0.1059234515,
-0.5101564527,
-0.4007014632,
-0.4328825772,
-0.5007576346,
0.4637421668,
0.3125938773,
0.5875889659,
1.0570015907,
0.6567015648,
0.1727156341,
-0.0590725839,
0.4759431183,
-0.1076993868,
0.215857774,
0.0590061247,
-0.4685541987,
-0.7368559241,
-0.068520315,
0.5512270331,
0.7377122045,
-0.3546727896,
0.004111269,
-0.0119915586,
0.5902870893,
0.1129822508,
0.4892478287,
-0.5798338652,
0.1464098096,
-0.2752343118,
-0.5312612057,
-0.8639690876,
-0.510232389,
0.1675916314,
-0.6164472699,
0.1520331651,
0.0634019226,
0.8581587076,
0.2867507935,
-0.4344201088,
-0.2824906707,
-0.8272536397,
0.4977944791,
-0.5580843687,
0.4163835645,
0.3577689826,
0.5175520182,
-0.1941028088,
-1.0363764763,
-0.2084063441,
-0.4197643399,
-0.3533102274,
0.1422286928,
-0.0573426411,
-0.0644720718,
0.2495961189,
0.2085516006,
-0.8110007644,
0.2064733058,
-0.4598449469,
0.0957436115,
0.4652488828,
0.3872034848,
0.5694262981,
0.0355004035,
-0.4533149302,
0.5056501627,
-0.7618583441,
-0.1605885476,
-0.5495200157,
0.3866718411,
-0.2005210221,
0.648434639,
-0.0573986694,
0.6118010879,
-0.1618308276,
-0.5044121146,
0.3481994271,
-0.0976081118,
-0.4070374072,
0.2141371071,
0.5343912244,
0.2365919054,
0.238740176,
-0.5002355576,
-0.2338723242,
0.1758871526,
0.316391021,
-0.635606885,
-0.2623816431,
0.4876548052,
-0.7246080041,
-0.5963571668,
-0.0967834815,
-0.8099813461,
-0.5957812667,
-0.0547628403,
0.1154269278,
-0.4207410812,
-0.0757343397,
0.1903698444,
0.041287452,
-0.0481097996,
0.3873078227,
-0.6641151309,
0.4294644296,
0.6273331046,
0.7088222504,
-0.3957588673,
0.213822633,
-0.6698518395,
0.3542407155,
-0.4914098978,
0.9893040061,
-0.7289533019,
-0.3442271948,
-0.2221417725,
0.1801316738,
-0.0860968232,
-0.7222488523,
0.5306518674,
-0.3185700476,
0.1349082142,
0.0638693273,
-0.6138638854,
-0.1912186891,
0.2577745616,
-0.7670584321,
0.8356215358,
0.2661625147,
-0.5807500482,
0.5070450306,
-0.628269732,
-0.4927798808,
0.4278429151,
-0.4279815257,
-0.7324297428,
0.0151922032,
0.2468788773,
0.5688427687,
-0.6927129626,
0.7671965361,
-0.3013577759,
-0.165896669,
0.299025327,
-0.2538914979,
0.5368025303,
0.1676944047,
-0.1642642617,
0.0587331951,
-0.737656951,
0.1259398609,
0.428670764,
-0.404548496,
-0.054287456,
0.2188796401,
-0.1131678596,
-0.0073242602,
-0.0696552396,
-0.5377519727,
0.2651562393,
-0.5236190557,
0.3270521164,
0.35545367,
-0.1333671361,
0.2606477439,
-0.5801495314,
0.679700613,
0.1391128302,
-0.0638553277,
-0.0139409257,
-0.5840728879,
-0.1510454714,
-0.6580045819,
0.5024838448,
0.7478519082,
-0.7411735654,
0.3098590076,
-0.4159204066,
-0.5662035346,
-0.4876640737,
-0.1186941266,
0.2836077213,
1.1660513878,
0.4297282696,
0.1319504827,
-0.4540414214,
-0.7974329591,
-0.4056635499,
-0.1344822794,
-0.1896955371,
0.2153096646,
0.1787777543,
-0.4030861855,
0.4825507104,
-0.6621406078,
-0.1984657198,
-0.6023724675,
-0.1321471184,
0.5568110943,
0.3088720739,
0.3265425861,
-0.6513277292,
-0.5461580157,
0.520529747,
-1.003618598,
-0.3700731397,
-0.1169751287,
0.12012472,
0.1594338566,
0.4125523269,
-0.6304565668,
0.6943362355,
0.202702567,
-0.6358375549,
0.5905954838,
-0.2712991536,
-0.0969060361,
-0.9094759226,
0.168676883,
0.3405186236,
-0.7280950546,
-0.6749014854,
-0.0965635404,
0.2560139596,
0.0550681204,
-0.1056859791,
0.6074998975,
-0.2546606064,
0.0022487731,
-0.0064808703,
-0.145592168,
0.4488551617,
-0.0130062541,
0.1549130976,
0.3800922334,
0.4085068107,
-0.4130988121,
0.2427260578,
0.2838535309,
-0.4356250465,
0.2715553641,
-0.8003969789,
-0.1862824559,
-0.2172407806,
0.3070553243,
-0.7580074668,
-0.1648612171,
0.2297722101,
-0.4185729921,
0.6190558672,
-0.0373907126,
-0.5617835522,
-0.3238579929,
0.0356788412,
0.1133391485,
0.53100425,
-0.47037521,
0.6258944273,
0.557107687,
-0.3974406421,
-0.3334011137,
-0.7017372251,
-0.0923557505,
-0.3787246943,
-0.3199451566,
0.5545048118,
0.1027817354,
-0.2363317013,
0.036658287,
-0.1630239338,
-0.4187525213,
0.3376311064,
0.1857020259,
0.8064836264,
-0.272026211,
0.4161702096,
0.1700639874,
-0.244340688,
0.1367631257,
-0.0788013265,
0.3831668198,
-0.1577222645,
-0.085109055,
-0.4998384118,
0.2492728531,
0.5344128609,
-0.0736784637,
0.7478159666,
0.3287209272,
-0.7882771492,
-0.2094357163,
-0.2704005539,
-0.1184866875,
-0.3451860249,
0.5353876948,
-0.1577742845,
-0.3745343089,
0.4220409691,
-0.239015922,
0.0459025726,
0.5788736343,
0.6902819872,
-0.6267866492,
1.2138531208,
0.3771369159,
0.4631101191,
0.0423085727,
0.0999039188,
0.0974550769,
-0.4366253912,
-0.8194801807,
-0.6641725898,
0.0432546251,
-0.4026553631,
-0.0829403028,
0.6162201166,
-0.3774751127,
0.0749154165,
-0.1992857158,
-0.6002957225,
0.3567892313,
0.0723194778,
0.6632599831,
0.4964881539,
0.1046506017,
-0.2237358838,
-0.0155969271,
-0.6000103354,
-0.7461436987,
1.1368752718,
0.5570091605,
0.5405244231,
-0.1376706511,
0.4066872299,
0.4136241972,
0.6224045157,
-0.9160446525,
0.2401961982,
-0.5122467279,
-0.4884485006,
-0.0736724511,
-0.5262622237,
-1.1231245995,
-0.0561417788,
-0.4390931427,
-0.741337359,
-0.21708709,
-0.0780322701,
-0.436052829,
0.3844971955,
-0.7642874718,
0.8661230206,
-0.2546240985,
0.0124404002,
0.0876082405,
-0.573323071,
0.2709699571,
-0.4162317514,
0.4000685215,
-0.0087569449,
-0.0906012207,
0.7900732756,
-0.5199320912,
0.6963373423,
-0.0500879437,
-0.0567456596,
-0.1249109134,
0.1848361492,
0.3563543856,
0.0564477071,
-0.0838044286,
0.1405787766,
0.3159439266,
-0.3367626369,
-0.618332088,
0.3513425589,
-0.350823462,
-0.3656792045,
-0.2848162949,
-0.5570318103,
-0.3888804615,
0.1557390243,
0.0905424953,
0.7590301037,
0.0322106443,
0.1431906968,
0.5273856521,
-0.4054583311,
0.0779410154,
0.5122497678,
-0.2665652335,
-0.1193586588,
0.7474637032,
0.0587228686,
-0.0723979548,
0.4791781306,
0.5176239014,
-0.3718549907,
-0.7045212984,
-0.5350079536,
0.3146205842,
-0.420463711,
-0.3144926131,
-0.6016305685,
-0.2853031754,
-0.0345980711,
0.0638231486,
-0.1466477066,
-0.4288815558,
-0.4008430541,
-0.2632549703,
0.3294623196,
0.8656842709,
0.3379944265,
0.1937696487,
-1.136474371,
0.5126395822,
-0.2467950732,
0.4550453722,
-0.2255386859,
-0.4815873504,
-0.2252115607,
-0.3358779252,
-0.022675341,
-1.1184443235,
0.7829522491,
0.0915523767,
0.6121365428,
0.3771078289,
-0.0649563298,
0.573979497,
-0.4907492995,
0.3593927026,
0.1856462508,
-0.6592100263,
0.6611658335,
-0.2050329447,
-0.0339553729,
0.2214306742,
0.3098019361,
-0.1574432999,
-0.2716830075,
-0.4623403251,
-0.4658735693,
0.5303299427,
-0.268989712,
-0.5774927735,
0.0429520532,
0.6091657281,
0.5239912271,
-0.0531689301,
-0.6806057096,
-0.1838164479,
0.2737256289,
-0.7393864393,
-0.0538932085,
-0.3061602116,
-0.1199707836,
-0.5086174607,
0.3420678973,
-0.056833107,
0.2867724001,
0.3834559321,
-0.194040224,
-0.1419274062,
0.2621894479,
0.3854520619,
0.7891353369,
-0.1311313808,
0.191840902,
0.0648816079,
-0.5611601472,
-0.0724060684,
0.24005799,
-0.0363312103,
0.2012228817,
0.3696166575,
0.3886986673,
-0.0429816768,
-0.8240945935,
0.3570319116,
-0.2064353824,
-0.2159418017,
-0.2081812173,
-0.1880059838,
-0.0272993799,
0.4579109848,
0.254540205,
-0.0479159988,
0.1907489151,
-0.3302393258,
0.3460546434,
0.3462371826,
-0.4374596179,
-0.3592832386,
0.6503157616,
-0.081809774,
-0.2326739728,
0.5972465277,
0.3094741404,
-0.2633570731,
0.8325281739,
0.7883612514,
0.5264570117,
-0.120217979,
0.3657585979,
0.0014672539,
0.3007377982,
0.0346215554,
0.5151965022,
0.4620189369,
-0.4867175221,
-0.5143079162,
-0.4170984924,
-0.1858962476,
0.3375544846,
-0.7359641194,
0.3472643793,
-0.438554883,
-0.131977424,
0.405438751,
0.0103910118,
-0.5362474918,
0.4617433846,
0.1847036779,
0.8311927915,
-0.6999161243,
1.0067839622,
0.5999208689,
0.020685548,
-0.8400489688,
-0.2303450108,
-0.1190380305,
-0.9719127417,
0.3751623631,
0.2835939825,
0.4073643386,
-0.1685048938,
-0.5249441862,
-0.3746287227,
0.9017913342,
0.4076867104,
-0.5657957792,
-0.3196752667,
0.0708876103,
0.6412898302,
-0.443207711,
0.2239120901,
0.8171761632,
0.4232254326,
-0.0320815109,
-1.0252743959,
0.3600001335,
-0.2714300156,
-0.5575935245,
0.2655449808,
0.111039333,
0.5902887583,
-0.446355015,
-0.2385994047,
-0.0626791418,
0.2187971473,
0.3956153393,
0.7194061279,
0.2654545307,
0.3468308449,
1.1831811666,
-0.1888223737,
1.2280093431,
-0.1358403862,
0.2074335814,
0.7945335507,
-0.3505993187,
0.6974770427,
0.2044244707,
-0.1397144347,
0.5835584402,
0.717951417,
-0.0499845594,
0.4219175875,
-0.0908415765,
-0.0787238777,
-0.3306112289,
-0.1835557967,
-0.3909964263,
0.582402885,
0.8360453844,
-0.7502212524,
-0.1967393309,
-0.2105223686,
0.0014836484,
0.0291614123,
-0.4099467695,
0.8795010448,
0.0677676275,
-0.3150492907,
0.6189550757,
0.0220496189,
0.0925478712,
-0.3759634793,
-0.3228848279,
0.0730291903,
0.0778239146,
-0.4824711978,
-0.7096097469,
0.4520986676,
0.1934437305,
-0.1541274637,
-0.1105340123,
0.8010490537,
-0.4625906646,
-0.6896755099,
0.0431549326,
0.8624025583,
0.2183094919,
0.0742322057,
-0.488748461,
-0.1206810102,
0.049472075,
-0.0064281691,
0.1322761923,
0.4775765836,
-0.1486456245,
0.8073791862,
0.5304545164,
0.4809719026,
-0.4321802258,
-0.1296308786,
0.9326936603,
-0.8321232796,
-0.4161762595,
-1.1130037308,
0.4071756601,
0.0816935897,
0.2440382838,
0.1859393865,
0.4950074255,
0.1003083959,
-0.0409966484,
0.755356133,
0.4297518432,
0.9318734407,
-0.6813336015,
0.9020019174,
-0.6560897827,
0.4208615422,
-0.0575492457,
-0.3025040925,
-0.6484389901,
0.3453599811,
-0.2019735873,
-0.0981464908,
1.002699852,
0.3661820292,
0.1181199774,
0.1158514842,
0.3458672464,
0.6346439719,
0.2690929472,
0.5408427119,
0.7391289473,
-0.0203468055,
0.4958083928,
0.0654216707,
-0.4452115595,
-0.1831222475,
-0.7819684744,
-0.8383600712,
-0.2603523433,
-0.2453405261,
-0.5504803658,
0.0083397953,
0.8464396596,
0.6085306406,
-0.6836622953,
0.3433085382,
0.0905510262,
0.3447667956,
-0.115206562,
-0.2174873054,
0.508427918,
-0.050890442,
-0.53120327,
0.5679813623,
0.362793088,
0.0984200537,
0.198265478,
0.2328639328,
0.2831142247,
-0.1993962824,
0.6110107899,
0.12569879,
-0.6744801402,
0.0642516389,
0.0852642283,
-0.3101395965,
0.4212883413,
0.5885156393,
-1.07967484,
0.403218329,
0.117597267,
0.6827760935,
0.3699692488,
0.0037490551,
0.6176515222,
-0.3275999725,
-0.1132115722,
0.4128730595,
0.4706265628,
0.0646208525,
-0.5678361654,
0.4341796339,
0.2271897197,
-0.3352757096,
-1.1220110655,
-0.1059805825,
-1.0542926788,
-0.398199141,
1.1730949879,
-0.2170252055,
-0.3814599812,
-0.4266807139,
-0.0467810631,
0.3337607086,
-0.2174151242,
0.898730576,
0.1879792958,
-0.2306568772,
-0.0877503306,
-0.6530327797,
0.4307169318,
0.2177585065,
-1.2439807653,
-0.1923745126,
0.3170897663,
0.4637762606,
-0.2675211728,
0.5565243959,
-0.484479934,
0.4061341882,
-0.3478934467,
-0.2818071246,
-0.2543258071,
-0.5237786174,
-0.302454114,
0.2519788146,
-0.0091363443,
-0.0560194813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04996v1 | T3L: Translate-and-Test Transfer Learning for Cross-Lingual Text Classification | 2023-06-08T07:33:22 | 2023-06-08T07:33:22 | Inigo Jauregi Unanue, Gholamreza Haffari, Massimo Piccardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual text classification leverages text classifiers trained in a
high-resource language to perform text classification in other languages with
no or minimal fine-tuning (zero/few-shots cross-lingual transfer). Nowadays,
cross-lingual text classifiers are typically built on large-scale, multilingual
language models (LMs) pretrained on a variety of languages of interest.
However, the performance of these models vary significantly across languages
and classification tasks, suggesting that the superposition of the language
modelling and classification tasks is not always effective. For this reason, in
this paper we propose revisiting the classic "translate-and-test" pipeline to
neatly separate the translation and classification stages. The proposed
approach couples 1) a neural machine translator translating from the targeted
language to a high-resource language, with 2) a text classifier trained in the
high-resource language, but the neural machine translator generates "soft"
translations to permit end-to-end backpropagation during fine-tuning of the
pipeline. Extensive experiments have been carried out over three cross-lingual
text classification datasets (XNLI, MLDoc and MultiEURLEX), with the results
showing that the proposed approach has significantly improved performance over
a competitive baseline. | [
-0.1423530877,
-0.3543992341,
0.1630370617,
0.2259603143,
-0.166730836,
0.1271199584,
-0.3737739325,
-0.6268563271,
-0.2967243195,
0.4261596799,
-0.3228157461,
-0.3341718316,
-0.5531279445,
0.2648597658,
-0.515857935,
1.2806127071,
-0.5738036633,
0.1749492139,
0.3527993858,
-0.1715871692,
-0.3588587046,
-0.4319625199,
-0.7703516483,
-0.4205598235,
0.7719551325,
0.3899614811,
0.5158882141,
0.3392674029,
0.2080690712,
0.209277615,
0.0299138855,
0.1166665182,
-0.4633940458,
-0.0979716107,
-0.3143855631,
-0.6361874342,
-0.180114314,
0.0557481572,
0.6472221017,
0.7407541275,
0.3580754101,
0.0065487339,
0.3672822714,
0.2446517199,
-0.8047530651,
0.1852550656,
-0.5138712525,
0.4388775527,
-0.1650328785,
-0.3020820618,
-0.7965164185,
-0.2652635574,
0.0626365691,
-0.477532059,
0.2727901042,
0.1788787246,
0.7637248635,
-0.1379303634,
-0.7016083002,
-0.0094983298,
-0.7861585617,
0.9953326583,
-0.3737920821,
0.6775352955,
0.2246306092,
0.2646876574,
0.4363665879,
-0.6364930868,
-0.5711880326,
0.0400739275,
-0.1554468572,
0.0618726462,
0.1353701353,
-0.339578867,
-0.1808569431,
0.2658550441,
-0.7383738756,
0.4005935788,
-0.4656568766,
-0.3033032119,
0.561150074,
-0.1028415635,
0.4692594707,
0.1012189686,
-0.5417690873,
-0.3451502919,
-0.6637557745,
-0.1882259697,
-0.1937161535,
0.6373582482,
-0.0749915913,
0.2826353312,
0.1910542101,
0.5368505716,
-0.1167911366,
-0.1230857298,
0.5088431239,
-0.6187759042,
-0.2079306841,
0.3239257336,
0.8441323042,
0.1389489174,
0.5427043438,
-0.3903654814,
-0.3059026003,
-0.1718603224,
0.0911064073,
-0.898894906,
0.2028001398,
-0.1830059439,
-0.4359090328,
-0.3780103326,
-0.3295820653,
-0.5644328594,
-0.2340814918,
-0.0605101734,
0.5763473511,
-0.2317910194,
-0.2966226637,
0.254812479,
0.2359726727,
0.3248869181,
0.1632555127,
-0.9120487571,
0.2999370694,
0.4746814966,
0.9594514966,
-0.5522517562,
-0.6465102434,
-0.8327946067,
0.3095523417,
-0.5118132234,
0.4937328696,
-0.1072400659,
-0.2551569939,
0.4423033595,
0.2517929077,
-0.3486580849,
-0.3592703044,
0.4119038284,
-0.6415736079,
0.6920614839,
0.2288475782,
-0.2424597144,
-0.2633707523,
0.5160193443,
-0.5282521248,
0.934804976,
0.2371932566,
-0.4887660444,
0.2793081999,
-0.4872311652,
-0.8975710869,
-0.0137777068,
0.1484891623,
-0.4157728851,
-0.3361771405,
0.07763239,
0.7317739725,
-0.4994350374,
-0.0380783007,
-0.2560724318,
-0.4205218554,
0.1401358545,
-0.2351418436,
0.8476398587,
0.2339854389,
-0.5765301585,
0.0238475762,
-0.5687304139,
0.1826942116,
-0.1357115954,
-0.325330317,
-0.2478200048,
-0.4474023283,
0.6764364839,
0.536914885,
0.0338360518,
-0.6254043579,
0.0197556429,
-0.4291399121,
0.3038979471,
0.3671278059,
-0.4756424129,
0.8400610685,
-0.3363497555,
0.5391030908,
0.0402905382,
0.0846919492,
0.1345656663,
-0.4081276655,
-0.8293430805,
0.069064416,
0.6224836707,
0.9193214178,
-1.038621068,
0.2038517594,
-0.541105032,
-0.3997646272,
-0.4254505932,
0.376110971,
0.5061609745,
0.3986913562,
0.6140192151,
-0.1528645158,
-0.2240019292,
-0.6550735235,
-0.1886036694,
-0.2998906076,
-0.0302560478,
0.1095618308,
0.3257871568,
-0.1403035969,
0.1497217566,
-0.1993328929,
-0.6712107658,
-0.6742428541,
0.1840174347,
-0.1595571637,
0.4767973125,
0.5556771755,
-0.9365696907,
-0.7563621998,
0.7011094093,
-0.5474486947,
-0.2538419664,
-0.1971022636,
-0.1531195641,
0.5501084328,
0.7006363273,
-0.2767422199,
0.193787694,
0.6742178202,
-0.3254323602,
0.2724651992,
-0.0243904609,
0.1457128823,
-1.2082936764,
0.0436516516,
-0.0785736293,
-0.297747165,
-0.585421443,
0.0939069614,
0.407376945,
-0.0354750566,
-0.8951684237,
0.9253783226,
-0.2731998563,
-0.0250772536,
-0.233060196,
0.125019908,
0.1518862844,
0.5434099436,
0.1112377942,
0.685623467,
0.3515668213,
-0.5906482935,
0.1848499924,
0.2164431065,
-0.1293223351,
0.5088691115,
-0.1984337419,
0.0099765733,
0.2657826245,
0.1964286715,
-0.9186370969,
0.2374918163,
0.4253956378,
-0.2747659981,
0.4960519373,
-0.1761004627,
-0.5765326619,
0.1012848243,
-0.0340218432,
0.7817681432,
0.634005785,
-0.6895126104,
0.7876117826,
-0.0968841463,
-0.1220758781,
-0.342687279,
-1.1526783705,
0.0161143206,
-0.179910332,
-0.4362765551,
0.4942300022,
0.1858140975,
0.1624794155,
0.1287803799,
0.1307522804,
-0.514441967,
0.0446852855,
-0.1242196858,
0.3214119077,
-0.3449781835,
0.1673903316,
0.0118674245,
-0.0231418535,
-0.1418315321,
-0.5824373364,
0.2173667103,
-0.0098471614,
-0.1710988581,
-0.1558671594,
0.4184625745,
0.5058764815,
-0.3025076985,
0.5196691751,
0.9746584892,
-0.2559379637,
-0.4159252346,
-0.2978699207,
0.0283963531,
-0.3926915526,
0.4116716087,
-0.5637480617,
-0.8692913055,
0.2625746429,
0.0629684478,
0.1845739484,
0.4544052482,
0.5256275535,
0.0960822999,
1.1124747992,
0.6416211724,
-0.0539277829,
0.5132814646,
-0.2384408116,
0.1638637483,
-0.4679113626,
-0.2130987197,
-0.5665932894,
-0.4646972418,
-0.6880416274,
-0.3870603144,
0.115712218,
-0.1981597841,
-0.1776085496,
0.4451152086,
-0.0137365581,
0.4058212936,
0.2069336474,
0.1066196635,
0.2491969317,
0.0576147437,
-0.1681972742,
0.0207114369,
-0.7637916207,
-0.1370887458,
1.0015871525,
0.1564675421,
0.4988366365,
0.2169117481,
0.5415871143,
-0.0434867218,
0.620503068,
-0.9389706254,
0.4893368781,
-0.6239816546,
-0.3625202179,
-0.0554199703,
-0.6020923853,
-1.0336728096,
0.3946462572,
-0.1835867465,
-0.3082852662,
0.0834789872,
-0.1600006223,
-0.099669002,
0.6268745065,
-0.8074999452,
1.1020709276,
-0.590773046,
-0.4594630003,
-0.1447211951,
-0.5130463243,
0.3093774617,
-0.3983546793,
0.2668377161,
0.2352828383,
-0.2548317015,
0.596987009,
-0.0084200269,
0.8068311214,
0.1485003233,
-0.3137927055,
-0.1643978357,
0.4282069504,
0.3366410136,
-0.1608618051,
0.063072294,
0.029203048,
-0.0330539383,
-0.4676448405,
-0.7362481952,
0.6529260874,
-0.7350572944,
-0.2559713423,
-0.4345525503,
-0.634079814,
-0.3323059678,
0.4916858673,
0.1253775656,
0.2773858607,
0.0043401471,
0.1492397189,
0.6113659739,
-0.2892889977,
0.4132548571,
0.6147685051,
-0.4696342945,
-0.181840077,
1.0929484367,
-0.0317062475,
0.4622050524,
0.6696195006,
0.1401637644,
-0.329536587,
-0.6442722678,
-0.6794221997,
0.0814455003,
-0.5480008721,
-0.1537943631,
-0.4736219049,
-0.3821716905,
-0.342849493,
-0.2299945354,
-0.4096624851,
-0.3271305859,
-0.4433858097,
0.1896499693,
0.0278409906,
0.4230928719,
0.041875463,
0.076911293,
-1.0397149324,
0.1987584233,
0.178649798,
0.3812929094,
-0.1830865741,
-0.6913319826,
-0.4382173121,
-0.2806251943,
-0.1938445717,
-0.6897520423,
0.5192620158,
0.3451715708,
0.2876663506,
0.005146679,
0.0103261871,
0.3687582612,
-0.5249447227,
0.5726017356,
0.289683342,
-0.8435342908,
0.2212988138,
0.099587597,
0.3184170723,
0.4223664105,
0.5686218143,
-0.7748036385,
-0.2029838711,
-0.2988084555,
-0.6207621694,
0.7602083087,
0.0404733308,
0.0017391719,
0.3364626467,
0.1353270859,
0.2802342176,
-0.2380093038,
-0.7134156227,
0.0402585939,
-0.1487416178,
-0.2530239522,
-0.3554668427,
0.0938009769,
0.0911773071,
-0.0790344849,
0.5752367377,
-0.3875776529,
-0.2027625591,
0.0235922839,
-0.4030489028,
0.0733262599,
0.4605886638,
0.3839841187,
0.3502194583,
-0.1186848134,
0.2412464768,
0.4447111487,
-0.3487794399,
0.4246754348,
0.2659715414,
-0.2928780913,
-0.099435553,
0.4578264356,
0.7906112671,
0.5482214689,
-0.4427506626,
0.557302475,
-0.034742564,
-0.4252833426,
0.1155678257,
-0.1336177438,
-0.2168530524,
0.2223486304,
0.0764132068,
0.1192748025,
0.1457051039,
-0.5681614876,
0.1875576526,
-0.0451146439,
-0.6121072173,
-0.2982226908,
0.4977156222,
0.4503388405,
-0.3336314261,
0.5217208862,
-0.1884625256,
-0.9464126825,
0.2056818753,
0.6766055226,
1.115344882,
-0.1023782641,
0.3250394762,
0.1720256656,
0.258726269,
-0.2374745905,
0.1581295282,
-0.0335753225,
-0.7725219727,
-0.816647768,
-0.3202233315,
-0.3324909806,
0.1262747198,
-0.5098708868,
0.3142372072,
-0.1706315726,
0.3491550982,
-0.2231074721,
0.0342465192,
-0.8189621568,
0.2619920969,
0.4537576437,
1.0087176561,
-1.0281264782,
0.9987806082,
0.6957369447,
-0.1630531847,
-0.6193414927,
0.0888823941,
-0.2714694142,
-0.6605077982,
1.0352663994,
0.1833592802,
-0.0670493543,
0.0710652173,
-0.066079475,
-0.6151605844,
0.719422996,
0.3491324782,
-0.2905897796,
-0.02008266,
0.3073692322,
0.58488065,
-0.2956901789,
0.2480020225,
0.4875001609,
0.3726025224,
0.0339940451,
-1.3467400074,
0.1804100275,
-0.3219059408,
0.0584567823,
0.2402760834,
-0.5381848812,
0.7149838209,
-0.0523456074,
-0.2304086983,
-0.0925586894,
0.6055031419,
0.0516287424,
0.3014899194,
0.7738021612,
0.2521976233,
0.3487764895,
-0.0111699244,
1.1429499388,
-0.1070475057,
0.2283800542,
0.9129521251,
-0.5066030622,
1.1146380901,
0.5216949582,
0.094181776,
0.3559396863,
0.7201905847,
0.1158389449,
0.5570536852,
0.0775144026,
-0.1954088658,
-0.3223091662,
-0.2801306844,
-0.3525871336,
0.3503578305,
0.1458275914,
-0.3046253622,
-0.3877000809,
0.2335671037,
-0.1284651756,
-0.0596016981,
-0.289508611,
0.4510235786,
0.0647325963,
-0.7899386883,
0.8319226503,
0.090875797,
0.7712802291,
-0.4565338492,
0.0493058115,
-0.3670038879,
0.6097048521,
-0.0324288644,
-0.9462636709,
0.2247632444,
-0.1187388748,
0.1089623719,
-0.832613647,
0.7153061032,
-0.7767032385,
-0.4356111586,
0.6695113182,
0.6305415034,
0.0858028084,
0.1189931035,
-0.758708775,
-0.1095099375,
-0.0954870954,
-0.1389746815,
0.4537010193,
0.6331774592,
-0.2670643628,
0.5500625968,
0.5101467371,
0.2508858442,
0.0499947555,
0.2079547942,
0.5194541216,
-0.5269640684,
-0.5325247049,
-0.612314105,
0.052852951,
0.2783361077,
-0.5536840558,
0.5119866133,
0.6401407123,
1.3308244944,
-0.1233984232,
0.8382969499,
0.0668377057,
0.2898099422,
-0.6889858842,
0.6467990875,
-0.9822317362,
-0.0354686752,
0.0382318906,
-0.7788937092,
-0.5984970331,
0.3100472093,
-0.1143730953,
0.0550238453,
0.9725973606,
0.5562772155,
-0.2743587196,
-0.093679525,
0.3515998423,
0.0969442353,
0.3092747927,
1.0983450413,
0.7566491365,
-0.7981555462,
1.181827426,
-0.3440929651,
-0.0321534798,
-0.337009728,
-0.7203007936,
-1.0458014011,
-0.5602460504,
-0.3816945851,
-0.5582845807,
0.0817876533,
0.5843935609,
0.6632936001,
-0.9251983762,
-0.399011761,
0.0899432972,
0.1907966733,
-0.3869109154,
-0.1813325137,
0.358264029,
-0.6294513345,
-0.8965694904,
0.2633284032,
0.0169916097,
0.2989970446,
-0.4148846865,
-0.1648530662,
-0.2078448087,
-0.4369725585,
0.5969139338,
0.325761795,
-0.4174649715,
-0.2780980468,
0.1904401183,
-0.4395617545,
-0.0687052086,
0.7906659842,
-0.6911988258,
0.221881479,
0.7513453364,
1.1580071449,
0.7625806332,
-0.6178506017,
0.8008877039,
-0.7633302212,
0.0773648545,
0.2449128479,
0.206449002,
0.3420799375,
-0.1352306306,
0.6583093405,
0.2537433505,
-0.2434313595,
-0.8163763285,
0.0503525026,
-0.9019262791,
-0.3342967629,
1.3411909342,
-0.1740245074,
-0.2761462331,
-0.0932562873,
-0.1889795661,
0.5200235248,
0.1106284484,
0.6069279909,
0.54442662,
0.213124305,
-0.3091123402,
-0.5394822955,
0.3094233274,
0.805847764,
-0.8786292672,
-0.1893380135,
-0.0331157818,
0.2254768908,
0.3276362717,
0.247969687,
-0.1011401489,
0.3624333739,
-0.3994218409,
0.0677306131,
0.1110768989,
-0.4202269316,
-0.267600894,
0.2430802733,
-0.2331113964,
-0.3842584491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04980v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04980v1 | Assessing Phrase Break of ESL Speech with Pre-trained Language Models and Large Language Models | 2023-06-08T07:10:39 | 2023-06-08T07:10:39 | Zhiyi Wang, Shaoguang Mao, Wenshan Wu, Yan Xia, Yan Deng, Jonathan Tien | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This work introduces approaches to assessing phrase breaks in ESL learners'
speech using pre-trained language models (PLMs) and large language models
(LLMs). There are two tasks: overall assessment of phrase break for a speech
clip and fine-grained assessment of every possible phrase break position. To
leverage NLP models, speech input is first force-aligned with texts, and then
pre-processed into a token sequence, including words and phrase break
information. To utilize PLMs, we propose a pre-training and fine-tuning
pipeline with the processed tokens. This process includes pre-training with a
replaced break token detection module and fine-tuning with text classification
and sequence labeling. To employ LLMs, we design prompts for ChatGPT. The
experiments show that with the PLMs, the dependence on labeled training data
has been greatly reduced, and the performance has improved. Meanwhile, we
verify that ChatGPT, a renowned LLM, has potential for further advancement in
this area. | [
-0.3773007095,
-1.1026972532,
0.3246916234,
0.3392840326,
-0.4358151853,
0.3859406114,
-0.1648099869,
-0.2515762746,
0.1741113365,
0.6265899539,
-0.5803754926,
-0.4257877171,
-0.5490223169,
0.1568919867,
-0.4271632731,
0.8959257007,
0.10299813,
0.2769269943,
-0.2380604744,
0.2260177881,
-0.6178333163,
-0.6121393442,
-0.9445960522,
-0.1887705177,
0.345115453,
0.3291887939,
0.4596851468,
0.3751186728,
0.4500597119,
0.3230455518,
-0.4605101943,
0.265883714,
-0.3281605244,
0.0688935518,
-0.0521691367,
-0.284250319,
-0.4532474875,
-0.0680471286,
0.6191924214,
0.6318108439,
-0.028070379,
0.1274070889,
0.2146872729,
0.2943018377,
-0.1958127916,
0.1891414225,
-0.5553655624,
0.2230210453,
-0.4344421029,
-0.3627867103,
-0.5393543243,
-0.4109688699,
0.1881403476,
-0.0409861282,
0.1016276404,
-0.0794400424,
0.7423893213,
0.3502157032,
-0.2146247029,
-0.3130525351,
-0.4219979048,
0.5750608444,
-0.7578811049,
0.4805431962,
0.3561311364,
-0.0795457661,
-0.0865843669,
-1.0004248619,
-0.3805640936,
-0.4283050299,
0.2628946006,
0.1208977476,
0.10672573,
0.30197528,
0.2589852214,
0.1720309258,
-0.6386035681,
0.5067973733,
-0.3921442926,
-0.0199994296,
0.4226672053,
0.2206463218,
0.487606436,
-0.1150895879,
-0.6475712657,
0.0730233267,
-0.8158137798,
-0.0279111825,
0.3359729946,
0.4512924552,
0.1755927205,
0.7228870392,
0.0821010023,
0.8270362616,
-0.2491954714,
0.0582226105,
0.3536018729,
-0.2965781391,
-0.2611809671,
0.0941396579,
0.7380746603,
0.3518158197,
0.3289562464,
-0.1602413058,
-0.1440499127,
-0.1870839745,
-0.0856262147,
-0.8747627139,
0.01577002,
0.2785199881,
-0.1709678769,
-0.1685198843,
-0.027229378,
-0.7420643568,
-0.3513987362,
-0.6821237803,
0.3872050941,
-0.4094181657,
-0.1054475978,
0.4035902917,
0.0528405793,
0.3703641593,
0.0321245231,
-0.6989391446,
0.219919011,
0.8958348632,
1.1501854658,
-0.2372154742,
-0.4872453809,
-0.8974986076,
-0.3933396637,
-0.0752185583,
0.8499709964,
-0.4001273811,
-0.634170711,
0.2426647097,
0.0168832876,
-0.2258280814,
-0.5260260701,
0.6367254853,
-0.3428944647,
0.2229625583,
0.1301807314,
-1.1708437204,
0.2168325484,
0.3828961551,
-0.4838337004,
0.8708096147,
-0.3803158402,
-0.6004517078,
0.1225863472,
-1.0026580095,
-0.5805435777,
0.1453523338,
-0.0589296296,
-0.2911323905,
0.1572581828,
0.220416531,
0.3707229197,
0.0467382297,
0.2271086276,
-0.15075697,
-0.1487753093,
0.6292101741,
-0.6555885673,
0.6779669523,
0.3144896328,
-0.0547455437,
0.288833797,
-0.6737409234,
0.3677308261,
-0.0886421725,
-0.2925690114,
0.0943612605,
0.2924117446,
0.3940889835,
0.2732491791,
0.3503714204,
-0.3990044892,
0.133861959,
-0.5941137075,
0.4426729083,
0.6557644606,
-0.0005263345,
-0.0426482558,
0.0429300144,
0.6916760802,
-0.1907191575,
0.1973871142,
-0.3991659284,
-0.3011072278,
-0.7476339936,
-0.121910952,
0.5629658699,
0.6351314783,
-0.7089682221,
0.6569466591,
-0.1130790189,
-0.4581398368,
-0.4402580559,
-0.0144413095,
0.3815202713,
0.4049193263,
0.5173819661,
-0.2759896219,
-0.5422770977,
-0.310931325,
-0.438752979,
-0.0123879267,
-0.2123264223,
-0.0664326325,
0.4790400565,
0.0758078471,
1.1259096861,
-0.6449302435,
-0.2200537622,
-0.6300894022,
0.3586196005,
0.1156295091,
0.3755360246,
0.1723266095,
-0.6179167032,
-0.4492174387,
-0.4794645309,
-0.2322234213,
-0.4415959418,
0.0386279151,
0.3969779611,
-0.0852050781,
0.867790401,
-0.4650015831,
0.2982034683,
0.6347727776,
-0.7281980515,
0.7927906513,
-0.1908270419,
-0.2034822404,
-0.9858987927,
-0.2237979472,
-0.1705695838,
-0.2714017332,
-0.7717494369,
-0.2278612107,
-0.384996146,
-0.4596288502,
-0.9528636932,
0.4962219298,
-0.4102458656,
-0.3865098059,
-0.5314528942,
0.5160019994,
0.0753150284,
0.1416510195,
0.2693969309,
0.778773129,
0.4770832956,
-0.3189832568,
0.2504730821,
0.1916135848,
-0.5792276263,
0.4254139066,
-1.0697817802,
0.4137375355,
0.1448562592,
0.0947066993,
-1.0544720888,
0.113896139,
-0.0506971963,
-0.3636878133,
0.2449167073,
-0.2000081837,
-0.718064189,
-0.0939869434,
-0.1726255715,
0.1612421572,
0.3789151311,
-0.6473463178,
0.4068670869,
0.4874381125,
-0.4727060795,
-0.2498453259,
-0.5313813686,
0.1390642077,
-0.290407002,
-0.6927161813,
0.2898069024,
-0.1636941582,
-0.1507671773,
-0.2803520262,
0.031824179,
-0.2163051814,
0.2910940945,
0.053668838,
0.2331333309,
-0.2208120376,
0.2088445127,
-0.1719426066,
-0.0651877299,
0.0218413156,
-0.2151646316,
1.063615799,
-0.4195762277,
-0.293997854,
-0.6020111442,
0.0195677597,
0.4588392079,
-0.5539215207,
0.7015371323,
0.6654561758,
-0.1576581895,
-0.0151644917,
-0.317818284,
-0.0699453875,
-0.4658708274,
0.4595442116,
-0.2846373916,
-0.9199992418,
0.3342458606,
-0.297057122,
-0.0405866727,
0.0769786984,
0.4080889225,
-0.0929545686,
0.9587573409,
0.4459602535,
0.0388418138,
0.6458112597,
-0.0670053288,
0.0837317705,
-0.6267405748,
0.0645477995,
-0.5973483324,
-0.1180243343,
-0.2692823112,
-0.7480545044,
-0.0145736597,
0.3341647685,
-0.024129441,
0.0278058518,
-0.116199404,
0.8461742401,
0.2376057506,
-0.1312353164,
0.1773958802,
-0.2252506912,
-0.0551378615,
-0.0319809243,
-0.3676624894,
-0.5842494369,
0.7591584325,
0.4712001681,
0.6136206388,
-0.1278769225,
0.5814596415,
0.321926415,
0.0736387968,
-0.9235364199,
0.6437293291,
-0.4797455966,
-0.2910466194,
-0.458674401,
-0.2187099457,
-0.974807024,
0.3878052533,
0.0135952951,
-0.8444343209,
-0.4000688791,
-0.0693464354,
-0.3991445601,
0.0345178209,
-0.7355046272,
1.0170798302,
-0.573333025,
-0.0797837898,
0.1064643338,
-0.5821909308,
0.0230565071,
0.1270252913,
0.1907555461,
-0.0745793879,
0.0866020098,
0.9582466483,
-0.7718040943,
1.0606176853,
-0.3146360219,
-0.019178139,
0.4839778543,
-0.2975497544,
0.3639073968,
-0.2060993612,
0.2597450316,
0.0490348153,
0.0730899498,
-0.2947326601,
-0.3643796146,
0.2370352298,
-0.5402637124,
-0.2953457832,
-0.2277146727,
-0.205421254,
-0.6005648375,
0.0130363842,
0.3613035977,
0.5793649554,
-0.4115698934,
0.4404040873,
0.6007089615,
-0.320520103,
0.3083231151,
0.5571043491,
-0.6683930159,
-0.3489842117,
0.8316900134,
0.1535071284,
0.3232325315,
0.2654869258,
0.3480535746,
-0.7423872352,
-0.7537370324,
-0.0516788363,
0.0974526554,
-0.5140951872,
0.0299092587,
-0.2186917961,
-0.4003003836,
-0.3836900294,
-0.0207155347,
-0.6500197649,
-0.2110958844,
-0.3961809874,
-0.376042217,
0.140440017,
0.4611309469,
0.1297718883,
0.7609628439,
-1.007542491,
0.0251805335,
0.178980872,
0.1421794295,
-0.5169030428,
-0.7635572553,
-0.0732590333,
-0.2277006656,
-0.2883013785,
-0.896481216,
0.4310930371,
0.3741401434,
0.309945792,
0.4354201555,
-0.2557676136,
0.6744356751,
-0.792078495,
1.0997697115,
0.4119253755,
-1.256334424,
0.7910981774,
-0.2442111075,
0.2657874227,
0.3356979191,
-0.0179562531,
-0.6923999786,
-0.402466476,
-0.6548173428,
-0.9518517256,
0.5044403076,
-0.0964805186,
0.1982950121,
-0.3216722906,
-0.0664998591,
-0.1606235355,
0.0368016101,
-0.5680183768,
-0.1794494092,
0.0321224183,
-0.314101994,
-0.1528926939,
-0.3885920048,
-0.0700262189,
0.1168984175,
0.3431673944,
-0.1890543699,
-0.0445770212,
-0.1123735011,
-0.3378748596,
0.4314592481,
0.489110589,
0.838696301,
0.8089472055,
-0.1018018126,
0.0502841286,
0.2440441698,
-0.4856874645,
-0.0008683591,
0.3433608413,
-0.133905679,
0.3140228689,
0.3653503954,
1.0313036442,
0.3742363155,
-0.8927015662,
0.5560655594,
-0.1964590698,
-0.0203737635,
-0.2538887262,
-0.1070380583,
0.1215861812,
0.2870873213,
-0.0333198681,
-0.3455199599,
-0.1395160258,
-0.3549308479,
0.4608598351,
0.1200487986,
-0.4181183875,
-0.3504108191,
0.4460841119,
0.3884910643,
-0.6462165713,
0.5371745825,
-0.0780111253,
-0.6932193041,
0.6064053178,
0.6504666209,
0.8993785977,
-0.4624095261,
0.4158993959,
-0.0497254394,
0.2747983634,
-0.1938582808,
0.3799470067,
0.1988293082,
-0.7769117355,
-0.7465114594,
-0.6088306308,
-0.4775183797,
0.3947668672,
-0.6972081065,
0.4556563199,
-0.3433252871,
-0.309609592,
-0.3544502556,
0.0048851278,
-0.628937304,
0.2577909529,
0.3911013603,
1.0187323093,
-0.7751865983,
0.8505566716,
0.5152261257,
-0.4900729954,
-0.7145376205,
-0.042717468,
-0.0078638867,
-0.7633666396,
1.0118279457,
0.3519182503,
-0.0966515914,
0.1560419649,
-0.285526067,
-0.6193175316,
0.732377708,
0.3125795722,
-0.705909431,
0.0016699707,
0.4455820918,
0.5442949533,
-0.2402407825,
0.0937333331,
0.704490304,
0.1101100966,
0.0761012435,
-0.9819658995,
-0.5179009438,
0.2168426216,
-0.1441497058,
0.1065211147,
-0.3879871666,
0.6535945535,
-0.0136704175,
-0.1396379769,
0.1639824063,
0.7487512827,
0.3435111642,
0.382825911,
0.7257911563,
0.6210792661,
0.9294221401,
-0.2285918891,
0.6956307888,
-0.2877860963,
0.6435175538,
1.6240063906,
-0.2607237995,
1.2390766144,
0.477107197,
-0.3910290003,
0.0154749574,
0.6404078007,
-0.0140779838,
0.4383585751,
0.5039848089,
-0.2999844849,
-0.1224202216,
-0.2179428488,
-0.3576559424,
0.8008951545,
0.5389869809,
-0.402399689,
-0.2156587243,
0.3491614461,
0.1655982435,
-0.1285341829,
-0.4457144141,
0.5742313266,
0.1190445125,
-0.6458625197,
0.266854316,
-0.1040709019,
0.4691346586,
-0.591888845,
0.2665987611,
-0.2099240273,
0.1330015957,
-0.0547249243,
-0.8861091733,
0.2635369897,
0.5223209858,
0.4407313168,
-0.4853097498,
0.8866163492,
-0.6280154586,
-0.4667267203,
0.1599737704,
0.6302226186,
0.4574723244,
0.0576734208,
-0.8583846688,
0.3269653618,
-0.068146579,
-0.4717019796,
0.3828084767,
0.3402272165,
0.651499033,
0.413933605,
0.5880835056,
0.1664496064,
0.2815128267,
0.4770245552,
0.552808702,
-0.541518271,
-0.4900095463,
-0.96209234,
0.6925065517,
-0.0534812324,
-0.4383715987,
0.5936514139,
0.4837457538,
0.580763936,
-0.0460833311,
0.5996075869,
0.1714639813,
0.5219133496,
-1.0708067417,
0.3954543173,
-0.2836576402,
0.3667684197,
-0.1451176703,
-0.7616604567,
-0.2877825201,
0.5802690387,
-0.5053589344,
-0.2734267116,
0.6987223625,
0.5147624612,
0.3097778261,
0.1293430179,
0.4369346797,
0.1239774376,
0.5948180556,
0.1343198121,
1.228928566,
-0.1805942953,
0.5714755654,
0.048811838,
-0.0496513695,
-0.1511125714,
-0.8666093946,
-0.8863132,
-0.3337821662,
-0.5084676147,
-0.3070729673,
-0.0821840689,
1.0356042385,
0.4667378068,
-0.4693656564,
-0.2510935366,
-0.1260451674,
-0.008351435,
0.0125030372,
-0.2588726878,
0.5122509003,
-0.9424849749,
-0.8718191385,
0.7943618894,
0.2740002573,
0.0327669345,
-0.158807829,
0.1009433866,
-0.0582034662,
0.0988116413,
0.9438413382,
0.3429302871,
-0.6667288542,
-0.4046477973,
0.0305305049,
0.1733349115,
-0.0119742174,
0.8198283911,
-0.4185219407,
0.4048325121,
0.4324760139,
0.9265207052,
0.3037028909,
0.1888140887,
0.3925417066,
-1.0113930702,
0.0604698136,
0.352453649,
0.5768213868,
0.3058862388,
0.2429546863,
0.5132818222,
0.2158364952,
-0.6548883915,
-0.9706757069,
0.2445753664,
-0.9821305871,
-0.2048595399,
1.0920928717,
-0.4847179055,
0.0508899763,
-0.0191253368,
-0.3410434425,
0.2236196846,
0.0629314706,
0.5143048167,
0.9466071129,
-0.2921936214,
-0.1015702486,
-0.4491389394,
0.3913038671,
0.4843698144,
-0.9960005879,
-0.0502283461,
0.4691153765,
0.1824018508,
0.192015335,
0.5125406384,
-0.2550058365,
-0.1604175568,
-0.0997904167,
-0.1941095591,
0.0894485489,
-0.3277422786,
-0.4572176635,
0.2618820369,
0.3058967292,
-0.5323036909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04968v1 | Actively Supervised Clustering for Open Relation Extraction | 2023-06-08T06:55:02 | 2023-06-08T06:55:02 | Jun Zhao, Yongxin Zhang, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Zhongyu Wei, Minlong Peng, Mingming Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current clustering-based Open Relation Extraction (OpenRE) methods usually
adopt a two-stage pipeline. The first stage simultaneously learns relation
representations and assignments. The second stage manually labels several
instances and thus names the relation for each cluster. However, unsupervised
objectives struggle to optimize the model to derive accurate clustering
assignments, and the number of clusters has to be supplied in advance. In this
paper, we present a novel setting, named actively supervised clustering for
OpenRE. Our insight lies in that clustering learning and relation labeling can
be alternately performed, providing the necessary guidance for clustering
without a significant increase in human effort. The key to the setting is
selecting which instances to label. Instead of using classical active labeling
strategies designed for fixed known classes, we propose a new strategy, which
is applicable to dynamically discover clusters of unknown relations.
Experimental results show that our method is able to discover almost all
relational clusters in the data and improve the SOTA methods by 10.3\% and
5.2\%, on two datasets respectively. | [
-0.1428875774,
-0.9049729705,
0.606969595,
0.0507829115,
-0.0770202279,
-0.2728510201,
-0.3974072635,
-0.5098527074,
0.0883205831,
0.2020494789,
-0.6209494472,
-0.5065612793,
-0.303077817,
-0.0357239917,
-0.1400171667,
0.8736091852,
-0.2117875814,
-0.0833955109,
-0.3110707402,
-0.4582155347,
0.0207373854,
-0.262886852,
-0.6425165534,
0.0217944998,
0.7942388654,
0.6801221371,
0.3594064415,
0.6148938537,
0.4727844,
0.2052188963,
-0.3134714961,
0.3254356086,
-0.500084579,
0.4852468371,
-0.193994686,
-0.4414281547,
-0.1778437942,
-0.1249643341,
0.6793792248,
0.8143452406,
-0.2412240207,
0.3670243621,
-0.273804754,
0.8008080125,
-1.010892272,
0.4785085917,
-0.6758304834,
0.1140116155,
-0.3904047608,
0.2806781232,
-0.3831464648,
-0.2613619864,
-0.0806877986,
-0.7093723416,
0.2882109284,
0.0202519428,
0.8389540315,
0.1471297592,
-0.4163049757,
-0.1215710863,
-1.0928891897,
0.4610399604,
-0.1137813181,
0.2319037467,
0.3114659488,
0.5725319982,
0.0037464772,
-0.8258530498,
-0.1625899971,
0.1467357874,
-0.3352869153,
0.2464750558,
-0.2408530563,
-0.1981391311,
0.1552860886,
0.5919269919,
-0.0935427025,
0.1778349429,
-0.3707605898,
0.2221871763,
0.3128218055,
-0.2194505036,
0.1076457873,
0.2434072942,
-0.5709334016,
0.0267060306,
-0.6191681027,
0.2087951452,
0.2274404168,
0.5519378185,
0.3610764444,
0.752669394,
-0.2349647284,
0.5639032722,
0.1126385182,
0.1854939908,
0.0384850763,
-0.0338086002,
0.0622081757,
0.3596618176,
0.8800761104,
-0.0555722378,
0.1867966503,
-0.3625684679,
0.0668431148,
0.3558716774,
0.2466724366,
-0.5847831368,
-0.3930817246,
0.1677957773,
-0.4843301475,
-0.3818030059,
0.620220542,
-0.6364457011,
-0.0261558779,
0.1328296512,
0.3792918026,
-0.0703345835,
-0.63772434,
-0.4476749003,
0.1412852108,
-0.2886044085,
0.1384354085,
-0.7517232895,
0.5374222994,
0.4205788076,
0.7733954191,
-0.5101149082,
0.0682191774,
-0.9228136539,
0.6473036408,
-0.2664274573,
0.769076705,
-0.7776940465,
-0.1325045079,
-0.0610762797,
0.3375771642,
0.0074999323,
-0.5872743726,
0.2682595551,
-0.7101035714,
0.049402982,
0.0595154464,
-0.1061455309,
-0.2769212127,
-0.0660877377,
-0.9327104688,
1.3991972208,
0.1652095467,
-0.7282499075,
0.4774475694,
-0.6506767869,
-0.4168125689,
-0.0960344002,
-0.2057715356,
-0.7849825621,
-0.0301011354,
0.2925865054,
0.4257958531,
0.0860024169,
0.3528801203,
-0.4292809963,
-0.0315460376,
0.2476966828,
0.447789371,
0.4879473746,
0.1364483535,
-0.2713160813,
0.5229377747,
-0.7226210237,
-0.1042861119,
-0.0674939379,
-0.0118797142,
-0.8473719358,
0.1150909588,
-0.5437930822,
0.1679383963,
0.1669190377,
-0.7277613878,
0.2739600539,
-0.2268972844,
0.174788028,
0.5307505727,
0.4965743423,
0.7559499145,
0.3174115121,
0.5134657621,
0.2938245833,
0.2626358569,
-0.1883236915,
-0.4620476365,
-0.7467955947,
-0.2135240436,
0.4215654135,
0.2549990416,
-0.2773464322,
0.509591639,
0.1070624292,
-0.5555312634,
-0.4781996608,
-0.0805246532,
0.4252249002,
0.3592529595,
0.4979991615,
-0.1614585966,
-0.4698118269,
-0.9808043242,
-0.1888178736,
-0.0421952866,
0.1918427646,
0.3080930114,
0.2100001425,
-0.1055705249,
1.0083189011,
-0.9880549312,
-0.8291153312,
0.1513286382,
0.1646736413,
0.3540633917,
0.2776652873,
0.2683588266,
-0.8449245095,
-0.8190774918,
0.3810525537,
-0.8567166924,
0.1307019889,
0.2480818331,
-0.4327026606,
0.0332725532,
0.7222324014,
-0.3281759322,
0.6350437403,
0.2281833291,
0.1407944858,
0.071491465,
-0.0509706922,
-0.2646516562,
-0.572252512,
0.3077894449,
0.068024233,
-0.1314947903,
-0.4953926504,
0.1589196473,
0.1950204074,
-0.1305139065,
-0.3935775757,
0.3579538167,
-1.1605266333,
-0.0600472875,
-0.0701894462,
-0.0217269734,
-0.4747139812,
0.7594326138,
0.406649828,
0.353961587,
0.7647435665,
-0.6233148575,
0.2005580366,
0.3666541576,
-0.4264419675,
0.0481559746,
-0.2983660698,
0.1069187224,
-0.1847632676,
0.2571689785,
-1.0515432358,
-0.1038338095,
0.4117731452,
-0.2554218471,
0.2809531689,
-0.5027954578,
-0.3673904538,
-0.212442562,
0.0570179299,
0.4924837947,
0.3289679587,
-0.6882362962,
0.4007608593,
0.7340189815,
-0.0853422731,
-0.4617635012,
-0.2249357551,
-0.5066167712,
-0.1570882648,
-0.362296015,
0.331448406,
0.4913858771,
-0.3781745732,
0.5378914475,
-0.5159239769,
-0.5103930831,
-0.2853865921,
0.6886059046,
-0.0658604801,
0.0118522542,
0.3308577836,
0.0796826333,
-0.4089996517,
-0.1088835075,
-0.0498533472,
0.1324813217,
-0.0466758385,
-0.295157522,
-0.1472052336,
0.5240995288,
0.2305504382,
-0.6120565534,
0.9688430429,
0.5904896855,
-0.5815786123,
-0.146542713,
-0.3110777736,
-0.3122799993,
-0.4456031621,
0.091756098,
-0.3125782907,
-1.0863939524,
0.4532260001,
-0.4447555542,
0.3321949542,
0.5880250335,
0.3386858106,
0.1312354356,
1.0447710752,
0.7751165032,
0.2162299305,
0.3940782845,
-0.2247651517,
0.4959068596,
-0.6410520077,
-0.7430484295,
-0.5210627317,
-0.5185341835,
-0.2239167392,
-0.3632002175,
0.7935032845,
0.3527524173,
0.1399777681,
0.1978146434,
-0.6689916253,
0.2240594029,
0.5732061267,
0.2921839356,
0.648442626,
0.2478260696,
0.0835552216,
-0.1149628088,
-0.8232518435,
-0.1262073666,
0.6977339387,
0.025726866,
0.6727069616,
0.2538490295,
0.6183695197,
-0.0490906239,
0.6361560225,
-0.800570488,
0.4710748494,
-0.1407408863,
-0.7640382051,
-0.5771129727,
-0.5610365868,
-1.5397801399,
0.085862726,
-0.2945935428,
-0.7696260214,
0.3557620943,
0.0948446766,
-0.1759755313,
0.3635040224,
-0.4080008566,
0.7901691794,
-0.0909133852,
-0.5601965785,
-0.133029148,
-0.8377799392,
0.6284728646,
-0.1072278023,
0.3462648094,
-0.1466965973,
-0.1343427598,
0.8627188206,
-0.6051986217,
0.7390931845,
-0.3080145717,
0.0894998088,
0.5744835138,
0.0014585748,
0.3644360602,
0.0779918507,
-0.0492823422,
-0.2624871135,
-0.1670947522,
-0.1291978508,
-0.7204399705,
0.8527953625,
-0.4719501436,
-0.1626922041,
-0.5789914131,
-0.0714092329,
-0.1666546315,
0.4823344946,
-0.0860884637,
0.3547760248,
-0.5240296721,
0.2530116141,
0.6896742582,
0.0634931624,
0.3572542071,
0.6767190099,
-0.4838515818,
-0.2696389258,
0.7731975317,
0.0542382859,
-0.0442271344,
0.4591993988,
0.265615195,
-0.3477036357,
-0.0708238855,
-0.1817090511,
0.4787832499,
-0.1607277989,
-0.3465902805,
-0.9275212884,
-0.0842122138,
-0.2750588655,
0.2703532279,
-0.4688843191,
-0.5466868877,
-0.361990273,
-0.1691312194,
0.63815099,
0.5832820535,
-0.0117256204,
0.3563641012,
-0.9265643954,
0.6264428496,
0.4340171218,
0.5466461182,
0.2078384608,
0.1352808475,
-0.1835508943,
-0.1173648685,
-0.1068346053,
-1.1472423077,
0.0400515422,
0.5042604804,
0.7557644844,
0.8063650727,
0.4727977514,
0.5898040533,
-0.2644358873,
0.0947966352,
0.2160061598,
-0.2201814801,
0.8518415689,
-0.5101186037,
0.0266141146,
0.8516495228,
0.8135342598,
-0.098901704,
-0.0821279883,
-0.9949607253,
-1.174511075,
0.974293232,
0.2743164003,
-0.454010129,
-0.1452989727,
0.3834308684,
0.2307373881,
0.2763493955,
-0.781909883,
-0.3143604994,
0.5216902494,
0.150947839,
0.2510386109,
-0.2997513115,
-0.2865398526,
-0.2548541725,
0.8283283114,
0.1816786826,
0.1950921565,
0.0453914329,
0.0052845804,
-0.6753628254,
0.0783286542,
-0.3625525832,
0.7533175945,
-0.3384294212,
0.2269596905,
-0.2828654945,
-0.0127463965,
0.1127364337,
-0.0317933634,
-0.1119640842,
0.152084887,
0.0276576821,
0.6517514586,
0.3375793695,
-0.537319541,
0.649473846,
0.1403601468,
-0.2588166893,
-0.4344183505,
0.1923643649,
0.0637274608,
0.1509048045,
0.3130667806,
0.0436373875,
-0.11625503,
-0.8989174366,
0.2694040537,
0.2518441379,
-0.9111889005,
-0.2516652346,
0.6752609611,
0.1293479055,
-0.2185590267,
0.7257296443,
-0.0463709235,
-0.2642448246,
0.3331817389,
0.3786330223,
0.6380531192,
-0.5088049769,
0.0652955398,
0.7536213994,
0.0090446239,
-0.3702023625,
0.0821869522,
-0.1980649382,
-0.513333559,
-0.4534572661,
-0.574529171,
-0.4102746844,
-0.0077827969,
-1.328224659,
0.315725565,
-0.1501354724,
0.0114338724,
-0.1532828063,
-0.3577352762,
-0.163125366,
0.0481189676,
-0.5208618045,
0.5738825202,
-1.0089957714,
0.7396207452,
1.2359663248,
-0.0605732575,
-0.6746490002,
-0.2782322168,
-0.3134122491,
-0.5051985383,
0.2656481862,
0.3739043176,
0.0034220333,
0.1518420577,
-0.4627297819,
-0.6737887859,
0.7415625453,
-0.2050452828,
-0.5669613481,
0.033353433,
-0.4440765381,
0.4653565884,
-0.2230562568,
-0.0867003053,
0.235445261,
0.6753971577,
0.1744010895,
-0.4597021341,
-0.0260646269,
-0.483220607,
-0.5365511179,
0.9872952104,
-0.7634212971,
0.3657898605,
-0.1631863713,
-0.4529680312,
-0.1561598629,
1.0861839056,
0.2352358848,
0.5956037045,
0.8943307996,
0.542347014,
0.4507320821,
-0.1048282757,
0.3138488531,
0.1862740815,
0.1789495051,
1.073767066,
-0.3569327891,
0.8666593432,
0.41618222,
-0.4593333304,
0.4673421085,
0.5980757475,
-0.0807936788,
0.6845145822,
-0.0191646367,
-0.4190543592,
-0.375272274,
-0.083486855,
-0.3100974858,
0.2498657107,
0.5222212076,
-0.2360733747,
-0.3578858674,
-0.1956128031,
0.0595107898,
0.4098766446,
-0.2002409101,
1.0324150324,
0.0904056281,
-1.0230443478,
0.1220102236,
-0.0234986376,
0.2946209013,
-0.7339770794,
-0.1645387709,
0.2356902957,
0.2446473837,
-0.5042617917,
-0.5538216233,
0.2310650647,
-0.0608131252,
-0.3684953153,
-0.1811630279,
0.8370372653,
-0.6743465662,
-0.5775747299,
0.3513683081,
0.6358016133,
0.2965470552,
-0.3003356755,
-0.0355477966,
-0.1780112088,
0.1033970192,
-0.1653363854,
0.5159850717,
0.6685103178,
-0.6159923673,
0.3234728873,
0.6592049003,
-0.0782041699,
0.0855208635,
-0.2142201811,
1.1985205412,
-0.3975721002,
-0.4726802409,
-0.4471806884,
0.4525622427,
-0.1629998386,
-0.1621115357,
0.6462801695,
0.9169144034,
0.48468104,
-0.0329583064,
0.6627748609,
-0.2627373934,
0.9727501869,
-0.3097158968,
0.2701523006,
-0.5893771052,
0.0502227396,
-0.3503780067,
-1.3578041792,
-0.4994524717,
0.7264376283,
-0.1170712486,
-0.1705726534,
0.8825623393,
0.781073451,
-0.5042984486,
0.0330961943,
-0.3218597472,
0.2209993154,
0.0020391336,
0.2404634506,
0.9091742039,
-0.0025618954,
0.9255322814,
-0.5201419592,
-0.714204073,
-0.126365304,
-0.7560953498,
-0.91545856,
-0.6695536375,
-0.5249843597,
0.0238455757,
0.1739090532,
0.2219137102,
0.5789722204,
-0.5625342727,
-0.2037310451,
-0.0841839686,
-0.1260721982,
-0.7050600052,
-0.2719151676,
0.6253638268,
-0.1354321092,
-0.4234388173,
0.66696316,
0.1881171763,
-0.4116382897,
-0.031048229,
0.292560786,
-0.6944035292,
-0.8298264146,
0.3643299639,
0.4959931672,
-0.3351890743,
0.1064483225,
-0.0970871821,
0.283012718,
0.1476240009,
0.9816739559,
-0.7587566972,
0.455093056,
0.452691853,
0.1113675758,
1.2236001492,
0.546949625,
0.4461748898,
-0.9873758554,
0.2354756743,
0.267994225,
-0.1248366386,
-0.0686254203,
-0.3567131162,
0.9366840124,
0.0338276215,
-0.4291796088,
-0.9402276278,
0.1965257674,
-1.3429306746,
-0.3963069916,
1.220569849,
-0.220012337,
-0.3080225587,
-0.224945575,
-0.1700312644,
0.5145007372,
-0.5854594111,
0.5700988173,
0.0304363333,
-0.5040668845,
-0.181146577,
-0.3242537081,
0.2426994741,
0.0942868665,
-0.6742357612,
0.0914886892,
0.5478865504,
0.0106788334,
-0.0053418488,
0.6840747595,
-0.3589915335,
0.0099390633,
-0.4402481318,
-0.0250848979,
-0.2615365386,
-0.6702387333,
0.2799916565,
0.4944564998,
-0.0083754351,
-0.3290302753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04964v1 | Leveraging Language Identification to Enhance Code-Mixed Text Classification | 2023-06-08T06:43:10 | 2023-06-08T06:43:10 | Gauri Takawane, Abhishek Phaltankar, Varad Patwardhan, Aryan Patil, Raviraj Joshi, Mukta S. Takalikar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The usage of more than one language in the same text is referred to as Code
Mixed. It is evident that there is a growing degree of adaption of the use of
code-mixed data, especially English with a regional language, on social media
platforms. Existing deep-learning models do not take advantage of the implicit
language information in the code-mixed text. Our study aims to improve
BERT-based models performance on low-resource Code-Mixed Hindi-English Datasets
by experimenting with language augmentation approaches. We propose a pipeline
to improve code-mixed systems that comprise data preprocessing, word-level
language identification, language augmentation, and model training on
downstream tasks like sentiment analysis. For language augmentation in BERT
models, we explore word-level interleaving and post-sentence placement of
language information. We have examined the performance of vanilla BERT-based
models and their code-mixed HingBERT counterparts on respective benchmark
datasets, comparing their results with and without using word-level language
information. The models were evaluated using metrics such as accuracy,
precision, recall, and F1 score. Our findings show that the proposed language
augmentation approaches work well across different BERT models. We demonstrate
the importance of augmenting code-mixed text with language information on five
different code-mixed Hindi-English downstream datasets based on sentiment
analysis, hate speech detection, and emotion detection. | [
-0.3552692533,
-0.6456663609,
-0.020578783,
0.3583935797,
-0.3677967787,
0.800288558,
-0.6327880025,
-0.8842973709,
0.1222028956,
0.216979444,
-0.2806170583,
-0.3995386362,
-0.4824232757,
0.0871726945,
-0.319417119,
1.1930429935,
0.118463695,
0.2439181656,
0.04807318,
-0.2231393754,
-0.4919586778,
-0.8563731909,
-0.2721109092,
-0.3234715164,
0.5885585546,
0.2477682233,
0.9066851139,
0.3218400478,
0.4647098482,
0.2267868668,
-0.080515109,
0.4932724535,
-0.4283357263,
-0.1363468617,
0.1211863533,
-0.3202051222,
-0.1669746041,
-0.2439055294,
0.3774473965,
0.5736191869,
0.261270225,
-0.0244362131,
0.1727411747,
0.2515844405,
-0.7562630773,
0.1894804835,
-0.6269810796,
0.0343300179,
-0.0789761469,
-0.238424927,
-0.3136779964,
-0.5523117781,
0.0285508838,
-0.1850368381,
0.1274455935,
-0.223552987,
0.9482500553,
0.0517253093,
-0.0250356141,
-0.5256441236,
-0.7844537497,
0.8832173347,
-0.9907006025,
0.3201089203,
0.2778518796,
-0.013825532,
0.3706701994,
-0.4108069539,
-0.7203065753,
-0.1455017775,
-0.3976952136,
0.0802146196,
0.1199273765,
0.0864672512,
0.1177951992,
0.5276083946,
-0.5441268682,
0.4196823239,
-0.4805597365,
-0.4251811504,
0.7081224322,
-0.2019938678,
0.5322729349,
-0.2269748598,
-0.2674283683,
-0.1326616704,
-0.4913755357,
0.0085859988,
0.6244043112,
0.6450813413,
-0.2168599814,
0.4756709337,
-0.0158650018,
0.5469969511,
-0.1017781124,
0.0494685434,
0.6055503488,
-0.284352839,
-0.2469304353,
0.1533777714,
0.634737432,
0.1710476726,
0.4357773662,
-0.1053795069,
-0.4397309124,
0.3000134826,
0.1672908515,
-0.7605063319,
-0.2225425094,
0.144988358,
-0.4926555157,
-0.4249317646,
0.0870885104,
-0.6427096128,
-0.5094082952,
-0.2201379389,
0.3813839257,
-0.6125395298,
-0.4751348495,
-0.0697834268,
0.0149463313,
0.4476584494,
0.2120525241,
-0.753906846,
-0.0346275307,
0.6892647147,
0.6496141553,
-0.1898329705,
-0.1990591884,
-0.2151129544,
-0.2026274204,
-0.4598948956,
0.4709724784,
-0.93817693,
-0.2105704695,
0.5421760082,
-0.1641035676,
0.1058646068,
-0.5798565745,
0.3879483044,
-0.7282717824,
0.3009588718,
0.0264070369,
-0.5727529526,
-0.0130380727,
0.1451901048,
-0.5448278189,
1.3250877857,
0.0126830824,
-0.8651117086,
0.4864962697,
-0.4296111465,
-0.8466815352,
0.4423554242,
-0.2240884006,
-0.2881152332,
0.2249183953,
0.288534224,
0.6547129154,
0.2688932717,
0.2614740729,
-0.2546359301,
-0.7390446067,
0.3045426309,
-0.401322633,
0.5927172303,
0.6005978584,
0.1232069433,
0.0131897693,
-0.8519089222,
0.2240089327,
-0.1089757234,
-0.6110718846,
-0.4867881536,
0.0989296958,
0.4765054584,
0.0865520611,
0.4592835009,
-0.4708685577,
0.1399989724,
-0.4597245157,
0.1120841652,
0.6241316795,
-0.1687422246,
0.5149630308,
-0.2009618133,
0.4391287565,
0.09169209,
-0.0769452602,
-0.2117180973,
-0.4348535538,
-0.8876492381,
-0.3415287733,
0.5578585267,
0.6956976056,
-1.1408227682,
0.5935192704,
-0.3921580911,
-0.3544579446,
-0.8943082094,
0.209432587,
0.3893862963,
-0.0238082036,
0.4283798039,
-0.3520731628,
-0.7432112694,
-0.7219916582,
-0.3308225274,
-0.193511039,
-0.0155759631,
0.2512302101,
0.0525221415,
-0.489834398,
0.8345700502,
-0.3288590014,
0.1263346821,
-0.5527098179,
0.3746348619,
0.1258468479,
0.450748831,
0.4617927969,
-0.8000603318,
-0.6133121252,
0.2281256914,
-0.4994822145,
-0.265455395,
-0.174108699,
0.2465785742,
0.2904011011,
0.4201722145,
0.0862452313,
0.3782551289,
0.7119563222,
0.0211611893,
0.2869555652,
-0.1861666292,
0.2567475438,
-1.0106266737,
-0.2695659995,
0.1658277959,
-0.0198790636,
-0.8505484462,
0.2734176517,
0.3176265061,
-0.2272977978,
-0.3357899785,
0.3236561418,
-0.4124355614,
-0.0312217083,
-0.5015245676,
-0.2348691672,
-0.2323741764,
0.6789484024,
0.1979386806,
0.9911477566,
0.466756165,
-0.5593283176,
0.1132733151,
-0.0540836081,
-0.596286118,
0.0788987428,
-0.3956796527,
0.2449522018,
-0.2915743887,
-0.0906658769,
-1.080471158,
-0.2001215369,
0.0222920328,
-0.7420068979,
0.4431777894,
-0.2204481661,
-0.761352241,
-0.0951900259,
-0.2115211189,
0.3499021828,
0.7679549456,
-0.7129256725,
0.4330737293,
0.2904992104,
-0.1826069057,
-0.6038342714,
-0.9942107797,
0.0806307271,
-0.1028319001,
-0.3515138328,
0.2981556654,
-0.1470047981,
-0.0580809638,
-0.1352601647,
0.0842757747,
-0.6027954221,
0.0107825659,
0.081477493,
0.3989908993,
-0.1129189655,
0.4629302323,
0.2890534401,
0.2557645738,
-0.1980063617,
-0.0613160916,
0.7974257469,
-0.0708415285,
-0.1173886955,
-0.1228807718,
0.4571228027,
0.3177167773,
-0.4593327045,
0.8048961759,
1.1190598011,
-0.5008716583,
-0.2172112167,
-0.5435282588,
-0.0338721499,
-0.4551374018,
0.3540843725,
-0.2697553635,
-1.0640543699,
0.4961873293,
0.1637858152,
-0.1139667332,
0.1188511103,
0.6175891757,
-0.1439004242,
0.9692823291,
0.8762811422,
-0.5899170637,
0.8520585895,
-0.0066933883,
0.6503501534,
-0.4065085649,
0.2094139457,
-0.5405331254,
-0.1587515622,
-0.8929041028,
-0.461956054,
0.0065695141,
0.0927709714,
0.0460628457,
0.4901716709,
-0.5225453973,
0.4138406515,
0.277987361,
0.3689554632,
0.1904284656,
0.2636983097,
0.071042642,
-0.1249745637,
-0.7157850266,
-0.3737885952,
0.907523632,
0.4482096434,
0.9600858092,
-0.0673959628,
0.7877151966,
0.5130820274,
0.4435308576,
-0.6167653799,
0.34973526,
-0.2272797674,
-0.4848656952,
0.2084702551,
-0.4796800315,
-0.4916296899,
0.2051236331,
-0.3291048408,
-0.4991250932,
0.2713779509,
-0.0803551897,
-0.2679350972,
-0.049965471,
-1.15505898,
0.3959262073,
-0.3856942356,
-0.2648428679,
-0.2987901866,
-0.415212214,
0.2720752358,
-0.3044435084,
0.5692810416,
0.2018132359,
0.0433664955,
0.4922203422,
-0.3132749498,
0.9558438659,
-0.0592166819,
-0.3432115912,
0.2271798998,
-0.3259149492,
0.4222803712,
-0.0448036306,
-0.0278649926,
0.3887576163,
-0.2655159235,
-0.4162122309,
-0.4856318831,
0.8308231831,
-0.8375870585,
-0.1119894311,
-0.1594574302,
-0.5087588429,
-0.2964104116,
-0.0050047557,
0.1848874539,
0.3942581713,
0.2647845447,
0.2078480572,
0.6599593163,
-0.6124725342,
0.6391436458,
0.4421654642,
-0.1829879135,
-0.4416932762,
1.0035873652,
-0.0616606101,
0.2872921526,
0.4149920344,
-0.0384969823,
-0.094963178,
-0.5976260304,
-0.3563555181,
-0.0982234925,
-0.7233420014,
-0.1860755235,
-0.6508379579,
-0.4982715249,
-0.3827611506,
-0.2134810388,
-0.1205061227,
-0.1090600863,
-0.2398264259,
-0.0984872207,
0.4051677883,
0.3692043126,
0.1163503602,
0.4102254808,
-0.9074836373,
0.2638935447,
0.0211183596,
0.6374874711,
0.0645833239,
-0.50568223,
-0.6434824467,
0.169172883,
0.2859714925,
-0.9392380118,
0.3719593585,
0.1816089451,
0.4293046296,
0.1816329062,
-0.1139843315,
0.7992770076,
-0.3201336861,
0.6918897033,
0.1444582194,
-0.9584867954,
0.4469521046,
-0.222608,
0.2504355907,
0.5134866238,
0.3221184015,
-0.4013963044,
-0.6003633738,
-0.2408672124,
-0.9188114405,
0.5443906188,
0.2380232662,
0.5918930769,
-0.1164531559,
0.1476301104,
0.0255352017,
0.2987692952,
-1.2752196789,
-0.1494765431,
-0.0780496672,
-0.5591465235,
0.1658236533,
-0.1770425439,
0.2909060419,
-0.3983438015,
0.4608469009,
-0.214993313,
0.1782633066,
0.0103220642,
-0.4800611436,
-0.009974503,
0.4367015958,
0.1844535917,
0.4091008306,
-0.1884873211,
-0.1379688531,
0.1097778678,
-0.4324243665,
-0.1596693844,
0.2196994275,
-0.0496766977,
0.1159261614,
0.5396994352,
0.678422749,
0.0620865226,
-0.8478581309,
0.369645685,
-0.0145619661,
0.1207219809,
0.0377828293,
0.1609734744,
-0.2494532615,
0.1828721166,
0.4131664336,
0.0889813825,
0.0843732059,
-0.7360216975,
0.1154010817,
0.4331835806,
-0.536393702,
0.0298064817,
0.1039963141,
0.299649626,
-0.3308639526,
0.2901785672,
-0.2266238332,
-0.7819197774,
0.5205159187,
0.357423991,
0.847003758,
-0.1121837422,
0.117486313,
0.1721796244,
0.485347867,
0.2994911373,
0.440328598,
-0.3165716231,
-1.0499966145,
-0.8024750948,
-0.6812525988,
-0.1359958202,
0.235477984,
-0.7013724446,
0.3329941332,
-0.4330824316,
0.08093144,
-0.1351193041,
0.0819193199,
-0.7813979387,
0.2967077494,
0.4751034677,
0.690859139,
-1.0353845358,
1.1537737846,
0.7591279745,
-0.528866291,
-0.7893704772,
0.2909830809,
-0.5239163041,
-0.8448839188,
0.5625089407,
0.3373574317,
0.1183988303,
-0.0319212154,
-0.6277544498,
-0.5060785413,
0.5326276422,
-0.1449213922,
-0.4537107944,
0.2592270076,
0.1518737376,
1.0136954784,
-0.4532234669,
0.309967339,
0.3888106048,
0.2380469888,
-0.101750657,
-0.8416911364,
-0.2764803767,
-0.4587910771,
0.1916712075,
0.2731916904,
-0.3001801074,
0.6310369372,
-0.1086047813,
-0.3220552504,
-0.0662718415,
0.5983842611,
-0.0348789282,
0.1097228229,
0.4859875441,
0.4439142346,
0.5356198549,
-0.0994919389,
0.89867872,
-0.3778077662,
0.448479712,
0.9441964626,
-0.4422703385,
0.8803166151,
0.2688786387,
-0.1332091391,
0.6522436142,
0.5960252285,
-0.0828772485,
0.6524697542,
0.1387675703,
-0.2157657892,
-0.0394510031,
-0.19732517,
-0.3704954386,
0.3535211384,
0.5042752624,
-0.4606268704,
-0.0857785195,
0.1791625321,
-0.0229720082,
0.1579583436,
-0.1832699925,
1.0687842369,
-0.2876553535,
-0.4944045842,
0.6481949687,
0.0852559358,
1.1725825071,
-0.4888308048,
-0.0154429395,
-0.3634946942,
0.1902877539,
-0.3417825401,
-0.6916845441,
0.233868733,
0.3537495136,
-0.2080641538,
-0.2606464028,
0.9540738463,
-0.8302939534,
-0.6508350372,
0.506753087,
0.3598582745,
-0.1666856259,
0.1693281233,
-0.6239270568,
0.3728121817,
0.0967973843,
0.3257150352,
0.3443648815,
0.3253272474,
0.1479707211,
0.3442861438,
0.6689059734,
0.164782688,
0.1292610019,
0.39130494,
1.004326582,
-0.4392880201,
-0.5327501893,
-0.7678978443,
0.3884663284,
-0.2607304156,
-0.1163459569,
0.7656357884,
0.6184568405,
1.1880881786,
-0.1898006648,
1.1579831839,
-0.159763515,
0.6105038524,
-0.5104081035,
0.5804663897,
-0.5335258842,
0.5345679522,
-0.507029295,
-0.719656229,
-0.1703026444,
0.5493165851,
-0.2440486699,
0.1833444685,
0.4467503726,
0.9170321822,
-0.1061377227,
-0.0878861025,
0.2110132128,
-0.0480975285,
0.2287155539,
0.4026775658,
0.9933120012,
-0.4448817074,
0.5362837315,
-0.3417227566,
-0.2203725278,
-0.2816128135,
-0.6954540014,
-0.9778789878,
-0.3465313911,
-0.3365679085,
-0.3819406927,
0.1249535158,
0.9078330994,
0.7395094037,
-0.9517551661,
-0.2143930346,
-0.001393302,
0.0914823487,
-0.0691286251,
-0.3552778065,
-0.0114377448,
-0.6438129544,
-0.7842993736,
0.2694261074,
0.3325855732,
-0.1218866259,
-0.22554335,
-0.0280595142,
-0.2808527648,
0.1738873869,
0.7112526298,
0.0851896927,
-0.5604361296,
-0.2902126908,
-0.0171817206,
-0.2740886807,
0.0994369686,
0.982614696,
-0.7920944691,
0.5999675989,
0.540045321,
0.9579318166,
0.0898128152,
0.0909873247,
0.5644002557,
-1.2318367958,
0.4088201523,
0.3821288347,
0.3899821341,
0.5339637995,
-0.4532826841,
0.3819870651,
0.0405898802,
-0.2712363303,
-0.8271526098,
0.0990946591,
-0.680511415,
-0.4357570708,
1.1831703186,
-0.0175611731,
0.1261613667,
-0.0978665277,
-0.2528063655,
0.2451115847,
-0.3907960355,
0.6425384879,
0.8777233362,
0.2174269855,
-0.3805179298,
-0.308131367,
0.4231372476,
0.3004545867,
-0.864564836,
-0.0762088448,
0.5046067238,
-0.0853555799,
0.2642769217,
0.4224256277,
-0.0158380345,
0.0343987308,
-0.4777010977,
0.2624216676,
0.2695254385,
-0.2020387948,
-0.5399508476,
-0.0374067053,
0.0207843799,
-0.2494861037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04954v1 | RE-Matching: A Fine-Grained Semantic Matching Method for Zero-Shot Relation Extraction | 2023-06-08T06:02:34 | 2023-06-08T06:02:34 | Jun Zhao, Wenyu Zhan, Xin Zhao, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Zhongyu Wei, Junzhe Wang, Minlong Peng, Mingming Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic matching is a mainstream paradigm of zero-shot relation extraction,
which matches a given input with a corresponding label description. The
entities in the input should exactly match their hypernyms in the description,
while the irrelevant contexts should be ignored when matching. However, general
matching methods lack explicit modeling of the above matching pattern. In this
work, we propose a fine-grained semantic matching method tailored for zero-shot
relation extraction. Following the above matching pattern, we decompose the
sentence-level similarity score into entity and context matching scores. Due to
the lack of explicit annotations of the redundant components, we design a
feature distillation module to adaptively identify the relation-irrelevant
features and reduce their negative impact on context matching. Experimental
results show that our method achieves higher matching $F_1$ score and has an
inference speed 10 times faster, when compared with the state-of-the-art
methods. | [
-0.4344502985,
-0.9560106993,
0.743183732,
-0.1081633568,
-0.4409440756,
-0.4166140556,
0.073455818,
-0.5469651818,
0.2002940178,
0.7704343796,
-0.6644519567,
-0.54638201,
-0.3205878437,
0.0653322935,
-0.486712873,
1.0858447552,
-0.0837135687,
-0.5928182006,
-0.2642116249,
-0.2845894694,
-0.6292104125,
-0.1040280238,
-0.2900643647,
-0.3357649446,
0.646895349,
0.4820715785,
0.5342427492,
1.0317933559,
0.3792112172,
0.3134191334,
-0.1167465746,
-0.151327014,
-0.5801621079,
0.5290511847,
-0.5372065306,
-0.1049648449,
-0.559219718,
0.140031293,
0.2633644938,
0.6961526275,
0.2757223547,
0.5587383509,
0.0225399099,
0.3830921352,
-1.1462903023,
0.3217992485,
-1.1108952761,
0.1301151812,
-0.0946151093,
-0.48069489,
-0.2163650393,
0.122419104,
0.1941669881,
-0.7394349575,
0.5506094694,
-0.0292709004,
1.2837485075,
0.302500397,
-0.0851839706,
0.0478490666,
-0.8179994822,
0.6244987845,
-0.6265020967,
0.0022798043,
0.2723458111,
0.2972534299,
-0.3273806572,
-0.4234790504,
-0.6768891215,
-0.0430920497,
-0.3166429102,
0.0673165023,
-0.0891391784,
0.004369026,
0.1631988138,
0.5012028217,
-0.3157722354,
-0.099460572,
-0.028355781,
-0.1059391871,
0.4341622591,
0.2415212095,
0.081045799,
-0.140951246,
-0.6436955929,
0.1017860174,
-0.2651762366,
-0.387506932,
-0.2056204677,
0.5788714886,
0.2567814589,
0.4869895577,
-0.6945720315,
0.9734982848,
0.1329472661,
-0.2856217027,
0.3055565357,
-0.4999354482,
-0.4716465175,
0.4095475078,
0.6066122651,
0.7163844705,
0.5447650552,
-0.3078132868,
0.0316917449,
0.2794334292,
0.097621806,
-0.8657360077,
-0.0226744711,
-0.0692166239,
-0.2565099299,
-0.3498384058,
-0.1095382124,
-0.8197687864,
0.2061233222,
-0.2466077954,
0.6324483156,
-0.2851898372,
-0.1354334056,
-0.0152035588,
-0.4583171606,
0.7479442954,
0.2919222713,
-0.8310105801,
0.1687554717,
1.0329922438,
0.8985331655,
0.1908886433,
-0.4095625877,
-0.5442276597,
0.3409966826,
-0.2327510715,
0.8707898259,
-0.6344438791,
-0.1169313118,
-0.1099113524,
0.1910897642,
0.2556960285,
-0.5206489563,
0.5888165832,
-0.4238911867,
0.0846963078,
-0.0728275105,
-0.6195129752,
-0.2352011055,
0.5635089278,
-0.4317153692,
0.855923593,
0.452055186,
-0.5538096428,
0.650609374,
-0.2494137883,
-0.3646010756,
0.134456411,
-0.0293426104,
-0.4252359569,
0.2086452693,
0.0968167633,
0.5427152514,
-0.3557024002,
0.0319970176,
-1.01293993,
-0.5153905153,
-0.1616865546,
-0.2152986825,
0.4721830189,
0.2220284194,
-0.1554046422,
-0.1743426174,
-1.0694975853,
0.0744822472,
0.03364335,
-0.0966095403,
-0.8068690896,
-0.1601920277,
0.0222608522,
0.4570989013,
0.0527740717,
-0.8467435241,
0.052010674,
-0.5200347304,
0.328547895,
0.36806494,
0.1739146113,
0.6989177465,
-0.2256155312,
0.0259581245,
0.2155764699,
-0.0593005791,
-0.4906544387,
-0.3594862819,
-0.4447903931,
-0.3286219239,
0.3587791026,
0.6932731271,
-0.5787305236,
0.7041079998,
-0.4109442532,
-0.5268453956,
-0.6328319907,
0.0978841856,
0.5546745062,
1.0320038795,
0.6029148102,
-0.392031014,
-0.2562680542,
-0.8468891978,
-0.2961183786,
0.0603903458,
-0.2371106148,
0.2765822113,
0.3161358833,
-0.0091426959,
1.2332575321,
-0.8663133979,
-0.8302205801,
0.0981489718,
-0.1112124547,
0.0886733532,
0.4704143107,
0.8781739473,
-0.4799606502,
-0.4078245759,
0.2172079235,
-0.8133658171,
-0.242388472,
0.0768995881,
-0.3251981437,
-0.0119898263,
0.4376741946,
-0.5100784302,
0.5517013073,
0.0998477563,
-0.5903089046,
0.0390780419,
-0.0241039824,
0.2798851728,
-1.2843285799,
0.0139292758,
0.1468437165,
-0.3824577332,
-0.630862236,
0.1647164971,
-0.1115921289,
-0.1962379068,
-0.7044487,
0.6278955936,
-0.3908744454,
-0.1632408202,
-0.5620629191,
0.7639981508,
0.3741790056,
0.4273972213,
-0.0303992406,
0.1918475777,
0.7365084291,
-0.5499222279,
0.5329367518,
0.2049037665,
0.0271686055,
0.976508081,
-0.397326529,
-0.1809469908,
-0.1909706444,
0.1627300382,
-0.9876173735,
0.0027795406,
0.3761616945,
-0.3397879899,
0.3092303574,
-0.3946205378,
0.0788550377,
0.0951675177,
-0.508256495,
0.4244863689,
0.1441413462,
-0.1621482968,
0.558445394,
-0.0172462538,
0.0252938494,
-0.6000157595,
-0.7849845886,
0.0895803273,
-0.2774033248,
-0.3956396282,
0.7285087109,
0.4453315735,
0.052052673,
0.5416824818,
-0.4596769214,
-0.4538310766,
0.3150092661,
0.1034270078,
0.2730182111,
-0.5231550932,
-0.0668974966,
-0.0904579163,
-0.5245886445,
-0.4309614599,
-0.0995186418,
0.1768292785,
0.3542864025,
0.1219004467,
-0.5786400437,
0.5517777801,
0.6611505151,
0.0739915371,
0.6261377931,
0.6260812283,
-0.5666618347,
0.0653441697,
-0.4665820003,
-0.0296302997,
-0.3917804956,
0.4985284209,
-0.7079101205,
-0.9266672134,
0.4796037674,
-0.0112598669,
-0.0285161044,
0.5273723602,
0.2330756038,
0.0450765528,
0.2368090004,
0.6964368224,
-0.388756156,
0.449252069,
0.0716298968,
0.1316827983,
-0.8831056356,
-0.0823951811,
-0.683187604,
-0.3658384681,
-0.7112475634,
-0.078018792,
-0.3655707538,
0.3016246557,
-0.1063218117,
0.8114750385,
-0.6116726398,
0.5797737241,
0.3766027093,
-0.1549200267,
0.3792364895,
-0.2142974436,
0.3395499587,
0.0187947508,
-0.3006635904,
-0.2306564599,
0.5424445868,
-0.0547484942,
0.628277123,
0.0770668238,
0.9645701051,
-0.0029253983,
0.1414477676,
-1.1553788185,
0.4704662561,
-0.3734366298,
-0.5216004848,
-0.4101063609,
-0.6324811578,
-1.0099219084,
0.2814815342,
-0.4625402689,
-0.9087827206,
0.2622149587,
0.118048586,
-0.5652971864,
-0.0380442664,
-0.7447813749,
1.1348156929,
0.1811642349,
-0.222344175,
0.1633303761,
-0.5340836048,
0.3667401075,
-0.190697059,
-0.1032865867,
-0.6761637926,
0.0098707024,
0.4138009846,
-0.4517444372,
0.2627690732,
-0.3265452683,
0.0548271462,
0.1588277221,
0.3146163523,
0.0737936199,
-0.0162304118,
-0.0318362042,
0.176386252,
0.3937019706,
-0.4445319176,
-0.874977529,
1.0163420439,
-0.3089710474,
-0.5422368646,
-0.386798054,
-0.3047531247,
0.0698729903,
0.2998973429,
-0.0009537133,
0.2049170882,
-0.2790671885,
0.1066514105,
0.3318861425,
0.0826011747,
0.5973548293,
0.5796453953,
0.0197576471,
-0.1996624172,
0.7634382844,
0.1330775768,
0.1938551068,
0.6852217913,
0.0656195506,
-0.2153023183,
-0.1318097264,
-0.4430149794,
-0.0471733734,
-0.3416119218,
-0.5608257055,
-0.4564206302,
-0.0644317716,
-0.3985314071,
-0.1591415554,
-0.3844909668,
-0.2222548872,
-0.336789757,
0.3268097639,
0.6043033004,
0.1771442741,
0.2760913074,
0.1855701804,
-0.9419486523,
0.6772030592,
0.3819874227,
0.4446972311,
-0.1486769319,
-0.638933599,
0.2106533796,
-0.1908801496,
-0.239220947,
-0.8494650126,
0.0389353111,
0.6684169173,
0.3204381764,
0.2360617518,
0.2562678754,
1.1537693739,
-0.6853783131,
0.5056054592,
0.051934883,
-0.9011555314,
0.6933078766,
0.0966560319,
0.3440680802,
0.8933658004,
0.2582438588,
-0.3581600785,
-0.182310611,
-0.4938774109,
-1.0595152378,
0.7558520436,
0.1707275063,
0.276363641,
-0.0899368227,
1.0217186213,
-0.1962912083,
-0.1521141231,
-0.4181992412,
-0.3019109964,
-0.0372012705,
-0.3403250575,
-0.0582804084,
-0.2009050995,
0.2061976343,
-0.0731142387,
0.5838410854,
-0.0599557348,
0.1255036443,
0.4289698005,
-0.0958059281,
0.0196270868,
0.2696345448,
0.3658737838,
0.3002587557,
-0.4533122182,
0.1419909447,
0.2175814956,
-0.2989142537,
0.4088797271,
0.2044115961,
-0.3377687037,
0.2950998247,
0.3638027608,
0.5598877668,
0.5189988613,
-0.0874166861,
0.6301114559,
-0.0116933631,
-0.2391044945,
0.0855911151,
0.272737354,
-0.0228102468,
0.2843251228,
0.0832634643,
-0.0481383018,
0.2518078387,
-1.0604588985,
0.6797061563,
0.4527620971,
-0.7264627814,
-0.0487482548,
0.4896983802,
0.0750357434,
-0.5426424742,
0.3996759951,
-0.2972209156,
0.0035635096,
0.3091697097,
0.4667831659,
1.0676000118,
-0.1715382785,
-0.0359546281,
0.374912858,
-0.1613446176,
0.0130532319,
-0.2297855318,
-0.3742693365,
-0.7826420665,
-0.6900384426,
-0.9248797894,
0.0689856708,
0.0873726681,
-0.9016348124,
0.5024904609,
-0.2656185925,
-0.0118100056,
0.6051443219,
-0.1149522364,
-0.5184288025,
0.1357607543,
0.0096860183,
0.8095350862,
-0.8907305002,
0.8795077205,
0.3672981858,
-0.4981443584,
-0.6486314535,
0.0896364897,
0.0105519583,
-0.4064316154,
0.2970642745,
0.1869002283,
-0.115125455,
-0.0207628924,
0.0263031907,
-0.8079403639,
1.1702666283,
0.5106239915,
-0.67178303,
0.1537538171,
-0.0750000179,
0.5320360065,
-0.5303004384,
0.1168163568,
0.928481698,
0.0916988701,
0.4298166037,
-0.8684030771,
0.3664064407,
0.1477282792,
0.1947403699,
0.5640773773,
-0.3377737701,
0.5298592448,
0.2755208611,
-0.314796567,
0.2942052484,
0.4636807144,
0.0172351282,
0.5632978678,
0.3273302615,
0.8790256977,
0.1525002122,
-0.1075984314,
0.322470367,
-0.2339769006,
0.9331227541,
1.5697613955,
-0.6773840189,
0.9532450438,
0.4611795545,
0.0287462696,
0.3321703374,
0.2979421914,
-0.0920056179,
0.702744782,
0.1819082052,
-0.1977721751,
-0.2668043375,
-0.0083698528,
-0.1922966689,
0.8273401856,
0.0691149905,
-0.4817019105,
-0.961186707,
-0.3205572963,
-0.0085111838,
0.2394501865,
-0.3189842105,
1.2505404949,
-0.0192304626,
-0.5274050236,
0.622143507,
-0.0822696686,
0.6868457794,
-0.3293679059,
-0.2987868488,
-0.2167526037,
0.222795859,
-0.1472476423,
-0.8270847797,
0.6820653677,
-0.0782389119,
-0.4727045894,
0.2468212545,
0.8930873871,
-0.5435153246,
-0.2854768932,
0.5394004583,
0.403932631,
0.1304013431,
-0.2443068326,
-0.7058163881,
-0.2295831591,
-0.313896805,
-0.0329561681,
0.402200222,
1.0055837631,
-0.0705453455,
0.2984119952,
0.4372890294,
-0.1240067482,
-0.294765681,
-0.0478322245,
0.6679216027,
-0.9924517274,
-0.0022842421,
-1.3081029654,
0.0901051462,
-0.1353779882,
-0.4913478494,
0.4057326615,
0.4760047495,
0.8992089629,
-0.0091689704,
0.273142457,
-0.0943982303,
0.243395254,
-0.2153191864,
0.4675976038,
-0.407615304,
-0.0685602427,
-0.6738024354,
-1.4837610722,
-0.5640403032,
0.5390837789,
0.0785945132,
-0.1688116938,
0.4202337265,
0.897533834,
-0.3370493352,
-0.4217695892,
0.6445146203,
0.0843626112,
0.109562628,
0.6683323383,
0.414059788,
-0.8150573373,
0.5696596503,
-0.2054909617,
-0.4172290564,
-0.2789144218,
-1.0971797705,
-0.4731286466,
-0.4806040525,
-0.6529213786,
-0.223936528,
-0.0489296094,
0.6207241416,
0.5268138647,
-0.6112912893,
0.3230165243,
-0.04499387,
0.1005286425,
-0.2995633781,
-0.3248454332,
0.1524897814,
-0.2830379307,
-0.5553896427,
0.0274048168,
0.7512655258,
-0.0847435668,
0.0333814062,
0.3471373916,
-0.5243399143,
0.0021791963,
0.7936881781,
0.2219723165,
-0.8107023835,
-0.7418223023,
-0.2623401582,
0.1095904931,
0.0394580886,
0.6511056423,
-0.8378395438,
0.369055748,
0.4420466721,
0.6232872009,
0.5494276285,
0.0837475732,
0.2429264188,
-0.8237863779,
0.4243478775,
-0.0797391981,
0.3035752475,
0.2292096764,
-0.3888810873,
0.3627097905,
0.4308659434,
-0.4079706967,
-0.5764139891,
0.338057369,
-1.3554412127,
-0.3065480292,
0.9149633646,
-0.4909308553,
-0.6003193259,
-0.4219913483,
-0.184230864,
0.4740577042,
-0.162088722,
0.8306496143,
0.4389731288,
0.0487111807,
-0.0777365118,
-0.1393243521,
0.3534833193,
0.0793347061,
-0.4485322833,
0.2137913704,
0.298155725,
0.627176404,
0.4015318155,
0.4619918168,
-0.0532343313,
0.2530447245,
0.0673066229,
-0.0647208914,
-0.1501243711,
-0.0209685061,
-0.2446915507,
0.1767151207,
0.0278460365,
-0.600825429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04950v1 | Open Set Relation Extraction via Unknown-Aware Training | 2023-06-08T05:45:25 | 2023-06-08T05:45:25 | Jun Zhao, Xin Zhao, Wenyu Zhan, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Zhongyu Wei, Yunwen Chen, Xiang Gao, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The existing supervised relation extraction methods have achieved impressive
performance in a closed-set setting, where the relations during both training
and testing remain the same. In a more realistic open-set setting, unknown
relations may appear in the test set. Due to the lack of supervision signals
from unknown relations, a well-performing closed-set relation extractor can
still confidently misclassify them into known relations. In this paper, we
propose an unknown-aware training method, regularizing the model by dynamically
synthesizing negative instances. To facilitate a compact decision boundary,
``difficult'' negative instances are necessary. Inspired by text adversarial
attacks, we adaptively apply small but critical perturbations to original
training instances and thus synthesizing negative instances that are more
likely to be mistaken by the model as known relations. Experimental results
show that this method achieves SOTA unknown relation detection without
compromising the classification of known relations. | [
-0.5713946819,
-0.9810935259,
0.3285599947,
-0.1148212329,
-0.1113366485,
-0.4145155549,
-0.2731567025,
-0.5741629004,
0.2080897689,
0.2921048403,
-1.019898653,
-0.1540110558,
-0.4484315515,
0.0527993478,
-0.0960989073,
1.2056707144,
-0.1099899635,
-0.0798325315,
0.167346999,
-0.3647643924,
-0.4011882544,
-0.4734977484,
-0.4228260219,
-0.211958617,
0.3083731532,
0.3810698986,
0.6653199196,
0.5821942687,
0.2527332008,
0.2220838815,
-0.0099734534,
0.2878421843,
-0.7384281158,
0.2393842041,
-0.3425344825,
-0.5065954328,
-0.4010565877,
0.33949247,
0.5253332853,
0.482411325,
0.1943656057,
0.306884855,
-0.3517086208,
0.3922649324,
-1.0040482283,
0.280687809,
-0.9552477002,
0.3381493092,
-0.179681316,
-0.3160699904,
-0.525329113,
-0.1414720565,
0.1069917083,
-0.9813069701,
0.3176468909,
-0.2279014736,
1.2456345558,
0.261597693,
-0.2185646892,
-0.3449852467,
-1.1546083689,
0.569924891,
-0.4905869067,
0.443661809,
0.3618446589,
0.7004833221,
-0.2675989568,
-0.4611829221,
-0.5705881119,
-0.0750200003,
-0.1110423133,
0.262965709,
0.133670032,
-0.1867395043,
0.4791851938,
0.3816737831,
0.0468183905,
-0.0048672026,
-0.2474885434,
0.0620785318,
0.4969968796,
-0.1248019561,
0.3582691848,
-0.0253950525,
-0.3302260041,
0.1974746734,
-0.7408049703,
-0.1764480323,
0.2632407248,
0.5339543223,
-0.0127969431,
0.5538134575,
0.0957700834,
0.7761189342,
0.0839236602,
0.0023767129,
0.1087827161,
-0.1013305038,
-0.4020983875,
0.0406591445,
0.7405440807,
-0.1316966116,
0.5269919634,
-0.2804416418,
-0.2226653248,
0.2462330461,
0.0967328176,
-0.6366369128,
-0.3785013258,
0.0859180838,
-0.2336300313,
-0.3958778083,
0.0095832041,
-0.6812393665,
-0.508695662,
-0.141023621,
0.623205483,
-0.4223431349,
-0.5079681277,
-0.1113864258,
-0.2043685168,
0.06667348,
0.4054957926,
-0.7283554673,
0.3347195387,
0.151208967,
0.365349412,
0.4337354898,
-0.1144837439,
-0.9247570038,
0.2662054896,
-0.3346043229,
0.500657618,
-0.3992060125,
0.1033653691,
-0.1752884686,
-0.0034134139,
-0.0471774824,
-0.5488186479,
0.1333918571,
-0.866134882,
0.2930934131,
-0.0571023114,
-0.3551301062,
-0.037104588,
0.4859777689,
-0.7239519358,
0.7676397562,
0.2311247289,
-0.9463173151,
0.1987993866,
-0.6273736954,
-0.1939418614,
-0.0714661852,
-0.3836319447,
-0.7543315887,
-0.2591622472,
0.4757423103,
0.5713013411,
0.0560184419,
0.0180545487,
-0.6714168787,
-0.3414448202,
0.2656744719,
-0.0570899136,
1.0578010082,
0.0451183207,
-0.2874301076,
-0.0384873301,
-1.1418478489,
-0.1185766608,
0.3062350452,
-0.1903961748,
-0.9441320896,
-0.102399677,
-0.5178689361,
0.1982997358,
0.138854906,
-0.6543017626,
0.4105421901,
-0.5789897442,
0.0801178664,
0.842787683,
0.716752708,
0.5453877449,
0.202684626,
0.5328595638,
-0.0131476223,
-0.0320755728,
-0.0037333176,
-0.0999790952,
-1.0862993002,
-0.127540499,
0.5619579554,
0.4671810269,
-0.9959298372,
0.2692835331,
-0.0596501902,
-0.5477550626,
-0.3213683963,
-0.1067282334,
0.6252446771,
0.4243221879,
0.3797900975,
0.1179380491,
-0.8238118291,
-0.6169982553,
-0.4877073765,
0.1268654466,
0.1445832103,
0.4346012771,
0.4546340406,
-0.0895018727,
0.8217884302,
-1.0182896852,
-0.6430621743,
0.1528192014,
-0.03655532,
0.1806593984,
0.460038662,
0.6213405728,
-0.9011626244,
-0.5970398784,
0.1147241518,
-1.2269064188,
0.3665509522,
-0.3022089601,
-0.1657472849,
-0.2849236429,
0.7229311466,
-0.4177495837,
0.4985869229,
0.2058130205,
-0.072261706,
0.5470208526,
0.0178903285,
-0.3685402572,
-1.1394350529,
0.019661326,
0.0638038069,
-0.2955037653,
-0.6961872578,
0.3187286258,
0.1508544087,
-0.1638285816,
-0.4731241167,
0.3973902464,
-1.0146789551,
-0.0887172073,
0.1901280731,
0.2403704524,
-0.3630852699,
0.7130707502,
0.1077096313,
0.5835596919,
0.5460423827,
-0.891063273,
0.1789678633,
0.5345871449,
-0.0296528824,
0.3295168877,
0.0416561253,
0.1802764833,
-0.1981814355,
-0.0438669249,
-0.5281982422,
-0.2348978221,
0.6430119872,
-0.6096976995,
0.540029943,
-0.5485684276,
-0.1001257524,
-0.1318401098,
-0.1560870856,
0.4189059138,
0.2562820315,
-0.6006611586,
0.5063227415,
0.4099109769,
0.220026046,
-0.9337530732,
-0.56508708,
-0.2797206342,
-0.11340224,
-0.116687566,
0.1523887068,
-0.029305201,
-0.2869746983,
0.1710377336,
-0.5001422763,
-0.6341558099,
0.3125570416,
0.3681522906,
0.1311260164,
-0.2340313047,
0.2844150662,
-0.0493074022,
-0.0758176222,
-0.0166466963,
0.0896424353,
0.2480125278,
-0.078938216,
0.0785488337,
-0.4481523037,
-0.0005012893,
0.5081329942,
-0.4813800156,
0.8486471772,
0.3998700082,
-1.0422831774,
-0.3717595935,
-0.1284865737,
-0.2399655879,
-0.4675399959,
0.3905642331,
-0.704767108,
-0.5388665199,
0.6230735779,
-0.1184442118,
-0.073775053,
0.4726350605,
0.2064989358,
0.1831736267,
0.620193541,
0.813208282,
0.1350746006,
0.5529533029,
-0.5098249912,
0.3113264143,
-0.844610095,
-0.19051449,
-0.3202841878,
-0.00661834,
-0.5702798367,
0.2619048059,
0.3903790712,
0.2627461851,
-0.2910855114,
0.6766909957,
-0.4321314991,
0.3893929124,
0.4639854729,
0.5586984158,
0.3494606316,
-0.1505503058,
0.0336648636,
-0.1497736275,
-0.5953319073,
-0.0918245465,
0.9949689507,
0.2388190478,
0.6505768895,
0.1665969789,
0.8983914852,
0.0716277063,
0.7530494332,
-0.8795182705,
0.4072924554,
0.0530234538,
-0.6934964657,
-0.5253351927,
-0.7088656425,
-1.03338027,
0.0339312442,
-0.5256717205,
-0.8023508787,
0.3815170825,
0.1429951042,
-0.563904345,
0.3757543266,
-0.7984198332,
0.7087547183,
0.2117734998,
-0.2046002299,
0.3464701772,
-0.6805366874,
0.6387557387,
-0.2648984194,
0.2974452376,
0.0691547021,
0.2596089244,
0.8762532473,
-0.4587780535,
0.5985788703,
-0.4875132143,
-0.0423868857,
0.3750858307,
0.4863790274,
0.5578195453,
0.2163334936,
-0.0075810952,
-0.2573789656,
-0.3283294141,
-0.1478337944,
-0.8274703026,
0.5848769546,
-0.8701918721,
-0.3206384778,
-0.3670318127,
-0.5569625497,
-0.4599108994,
0.7854491472,
0.303221792,
0.3698999286,
-0.2594417334,
-0.1683171242,
0.6616340876,
-0.1090560257,
0.3467180133,
0.6608173847,
0.0094876783,
-0.2414861023,
0.9608383775,
0.4610973299,
0.1134573966,
0.4940654039,
0.1108118892,
0.0275474228,
-0.3365159035,
-0.3304429948,
0.2318913788,
-0.4865114689,
-0.4237103164,
-0.5941477418,
-0.5546529293,
-0.1415815949,
0.1698966324,
-0.5558296442,
-0.464258492,
-0.6552090049,
-0.1476138383,
0.1487102211,
0.4755235314,
0.0597925894,
0.2694200277,
-0.7416093349,
0.7196221948,
0.4122539163,
0.3257997036,
0.0537086651,
-0.3285979331,
-0.1034531742,
0.1292324513,
-0.2480320781,
-1.1394643784,
0.2830633223,
0.2385380715,
0.3539820313,
0.6605370641,
0.5744076371,
0.6808471084,
-0.4181462824,
0.3192008734,
0.1978509277,
-0.6067738533,
0.6531310081,
-0.4787305892,
-0.0820152164,
0.4682999849,
0.5723052621,
0.0691610351,
-0.3157601058,
-1.0224070549,
-0.4552316368,
0.9827356935,
0.4590979517,
-0.1249939278,
0.1705666482,
0.5848445296,
-0.0322077014,
0.1330593377,
-1.098993063,
-0.5190548301,
0.1077199727,
0.0353025682,
0.1438205242,
-0.3115255535,
-0.2274519503,
-0.016880868,
0.8529407978,
0.1976113021,
0.4382629693,
0.2111937553,
-0.081314005,
-0.3866272867,
0.2601176798,
0.1779729426,
0.6100161672,
-0.6743693948,
0.1880368292,
-0.0410870127,
-0.2818866074,
0.3758924901,
0.3799833953,
-0.3529510498,
-0.1512254775,
0.1854322255,
0.4477412999,
-0.074587591,
-0.3938239515,
0.8355657458,
-0.2892275453,
-0.0433376767,
-0.4994100034,
0.1344937682,
-0.0829904154,
0.2335233539,
0.1213422269,
0.6782826185,
-0.0088872425,
-0.540435791,
0.3322408497,
0.3641057909,
-0.8377485275,
-0.2812255621,
0.5678791404,
-0.0262731109,
-0.4555333555,
0.6593686342,
-0.4367181957,
-0.5760848522,
0.4961879551,
0.5848559737,
0.6100998521,
-0.3501040041,
-0.0773999542,
0.4149292111,
0.4204525948,
0.206548363,
0.203115344,
-0.1003121734,
-1.0671238899,
-0.2045112699,
-0.2232410759,
-0.2722845674,
0.6564846635,
-1.0962461233,
0.4656302333,
-0.7152033448,
0.0663180277,
0.0672185272,
-0.1058512479,
-0.6047070026,
0.6166242957,
-0.279538393,
0.663234055,
-0.9104943871,
0.6431404352,
0.7601367235,
-0.5204447508,
-1.0912289619,
0.1840874553,
-0.4112935662,
-0.6467707157,
0.3327768743,
0.264869988,
0.0407796353,
0.0329955481,
-0.4789896309,
-0.5494938493,
0.6249862313,
0.6610895991,
-0.2671968937,
-0.0436956957,
-0.5056433082,
0.4464325309,
-0.1221655682,
0.0523099042,
0.2646713555,
0.1600029469,
-0.3195556402,
-0.534619987,
0.3683654666,
-0.4410559833,
-0.5570209026,
0.5626657605,
-0.6929460764,
0.8133268356,
-0.2968023717,
-0.6226218343,
-0.0077169547,
0.7030317783,
-0.0889860094,
0.347376436,
0.4616578221,
0.4029692113,
0.6888258457,
0.1933247149,
0.6475713253,
0.1966709644,
0.5091394186,
1.7220513821,
-0.0022907103,
0.6749345064,
0.4709421098,
-0.0426427349,
0.4604675174,
0.7569505572,
0.0493348837,
0.7676691413,
0.0552996919,
-0.2013943791,
-0.339104116,
0.0902340263,
-0.5922960639,
0.4675364196,
0.4286704659,
-0.5158715248,
-0.4316173494,
-0.1692081243,
0.0949741453,
0.2656222582,
-0.3852949739,
0.7736869454,
0.0372054502,
-0.6153091788,
0.8494626284,
0.0490977839,
0.2124501914,
-0.5768620968,
-0.2820982933,
0.1419432759,
0.2895112634,
-0.333738327,
-0.3025348783,
0.1264259368,
-0.2128183097,
-0.2891856432,
0.2242478579,
0.9248373508,
-0.4154751599,
-0.1861166954,
0.2348050773,
0.6125405431,
0.015032826,
-0.2399426401,
-0.1725214869,
-0.3715521097,
0.202667743,
-0.3029532731,
0.3392938375,
0.7035386562,
-0.0874422938,
0.4979376793,
0.5559378266,
0.1131511107,
-0.0320695527,
-0.3178631663,
1.0923302174,
-0.347778827,
-0.5168217421,
-0.7627402544,
0.2263658494,
-0.1737013161,
-0.3574801087,
0.7786396146,
0.3710909784,
0.8600050211,
-0.220102042,
0.9434217811,
0.0283444338,
0.5751519203,
-0.3904358149,
0.7281816006,
-0.3365892768,
0.3310180306,
-0.4236079752,
-0.9172378182,
-0.4834489524,
0.6233909726,
-0.3694955111,
-0.1990508288,
0.5733332038,
0.5552704334,
-0.4789419472,
-0.0245080255,
0.0626125783,
0.6355583072,
0.2826500833,
0.5392287374,
0.729519546,
-0.8379288912,
0.7471402287,
-0.271366179,
-0.6118945479,
0.1685306281,
-0.919085741,
-1.1265609264,
-0.3223760426,
-0.2775807381,
-0.5495347977,
0.1414200068,
0.5882197618,
0.557864964,
-0.6666398048,
0.1730815768,
-0.3390495777,
0.2073168755,
-0.4172582626,
-0.3274114728,
0.5862534046,
0.0591256246,
-0.3634474277,
0.4307898581,
-0.1342421621,
0.2925940454,
-0.1365867853,
0.048506178,
-0.564574182,
-0.1043839231,
0.2234898061,
0.6102259755,
-0.1244734228,
-0.3417336345,
-0.4123094976,
0.2496862859,
0.0902890041,
0.581187427,
-0.6635470986,
0.8590207696,
0.0908248127,
0.6028337479,
0.780970335,
0.017290853,
0.5979945064,
-1.2318825722,
0.2539609373,
0.3840286136,
0.1547475755,
0.2210048139,
-0.8295541406,
0.6194409132,
0.3722444177,
-0.1219816431,
-1.0733355284,
0.4459857047,
-0.7303312421,
-0.2271234691,
1.0035222769,
-0.543417275,
-0.1790172756,
-0.0948079526,
-0.0682849139,
0.5848267674,
-0.280965358,
0.8790189028,
0.2865268886,
-0.2525245249,
0.1313363463,
-0.2582831979,
0.5791043639,
-0.0108918278,
-0.7110610008,
0.0642712638,
0.1946582347,
0.4130465388,
0.3698987067,
0.7179090977,
-0.082146652,
0.322437346,
0.1081905663,
-0.1315448582,
-0.3907578886,
-0.4866298139,
0.1309897602,
0.3142135441,
-0.0515640713,
-0.4313705862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04941v1 | A modified model for topic detection from a corpus and a new metric evaluating the understandability of topics | 2023-06-08T05:17:03 | 2023-06-08T05:17:03 | Tomoya Kitano, Yuto Miyatake, Daisuke Furihata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a modified neural model for topic detection from a corpus
and proposes a new metric to evaluate the detected topics. The new model builds
upon the embedded topic model incorporating some modifications such as document
clustering. Numerical experiments suggest that the new model performs
favourably regardless of the document's length. The new metric, which can be
computed more efficiently than widely-used metrics such as topic coherence,
provides variable information regarding the understandability of the detected
topics. | [
-0.6578043103,
-0.9213035703,
0.84893924,
-0.0423652604,
-0.4902603924,
0.0202933513,
-0.3995102644,
-0.2722032964,
0.7168033719,
0.1845320016,
-0.1494238824,
-0.499797225,
-0.9343046546,
-0.2161883265,
-0.8166966438,
0.8603981733,
0.1374119371,
-0.0623357929,
-0.6158491373,
0.0798998997,
-0.458893925,
-0.175560981,
-0.7148888111,
-0.290117979,
0.544552207,
0.400715977,
0.5172393918,
0.5353692174,
0.6421690583,
0.2380934805,
-0.8371995687,
-0.1392579228,
-0.0706791058,
0.0372298248,
-0.3846361339,
-0.7190805674,
-0.5122990012,
-0.0007575353,
0.8551563621,
0.8577566147,
0.1700531691,
-0.0045694215,
-0.0698188469,
0.2509056628,
-0.427519381,
-0.1529628783,
-0.7463876605,
0.0131097576,
0.0698592514,
-0.262347132,
-0.3002379239,
0.0891901553,
0.3577982187,
-0.5696681142,
0.7138076425,
-0.3021088839,
0.7865179181,
0.207425952,
-0.2380076051,
-0.4550051093,
-0.3382421732,
0.6765995622,
-0.720222652,
0.5301526189,
0.5228201151,
0.3240549266,
0.1591371447,
-0.9022961259,
-0.6917387843,
-0.3892388046,
-0.0759613514,
-0.0602181666,
-0.457814306,
-0.4698869884,
-0.014891834,
0.4574686885,
-0.4904262125,
0.1712108254,
-0.2621340156,
-0.327457726,
0.3725472093,
0.0953122526,
0.5079820156,
-0.5539611578,
0.1497159451,
0.2931761146,
-0.2328055352,
-0.2087223828,
0.5052569509,
-0.0371138342,
-0.113447018,
0.2377342582,
-0.300671041,
0.6157878637,
0.1333767474,
-0.0424615629,
0.0820953324,
-0.3557891548,
0.1060610041,
0.1125718132,
-0.0052047186,
0.363414079,
-0.1852297336,
-0.2658587098,
-0.2238143235,
0.2740339041,
0.4816755652,
-0.6427648664,
-0.326848805,
0.2175171226,
-0.9528947473,
-0.2115594596,
-0.1507319957,
-0.4260152876,
-0.2976504564,
-0.4450958371,
0.1172774881,
-0.715175271,
-0.5661221743,
0.1440694481,
-0.5972406268,
0.1075448915,
0.6828680634,
-0.9801801443,
0.2782263458,
1.2471715212,
1.2433260679,
-0.4915496409,
-0.2705489993,
-0.1699918061,
-0.4058798552,
-0.3893787861,
1.2092119455,
-0.5476270914,
-0.3607496023,
-0.4044247568,
0.0809442326,
-0.0976226851,
-0.5129291415,
0.4395229816,
-0.7521523833,
0.1246553212,
-0.058453247,
-0.968475461,
-0.2976050079,
0.6234511733,
-0.6190950871,
0.594158709,
0.1284259409,
-0.84810853,
0.6241449714,
-0.8772662282,
-0.0355585217,
-0.0746470168,
0.112885572,
-0.3264251053,
0.3321138024,
0.0467769131,
0.1833603084,
-0.0029825522,
0.6488173008,
-0.2659380436,
-0.6409830451,
0.468660146,
-0.5367321372,
0.4153486192,
0.4431630969,
0.0872544348,
0.5022065639,
-0.7427793145,
-0.283722043,
-0.2331963778,
-0.2609894574,
-0.5904735327,
0.1669560969,
0.0647223443,
-0.3018009067,
0.5024350286,
-0.4875943363,
-0.2187114954,
-0.4993106723,
0.4319395125,
0.4378362596,
0.3094587028,
0.7645302415,
-0.386411041,
0.2577204406,
0.1134427562,
-0.0887048915,
-0.367831111,
-0.629326582,
-0.8719650507,
-0.3219990432,
0.7738822699,
0.1550723314,
-0.1606509387,
0.8242644668,
-0.0162763614,
-0.6723127961,
-0.1767399162,
-0.241495207,
0.0021524613,
0.4087830186,
0.3143945634,
-0.373096168,
-0.4330467284,
-0.8460528851,
-0.3034907877,
-0.1307325959,
-0.0799791813,
0.2613427639,
0.7748444676,
-0.189694345,
0.8956946731,
-0.6988781691,
0.3313853741,
-0.0505880825,
0.6399804354,
0.4402264059,
0.7107747793,
0.6069064736,
-0.9333287477,
-0.5078029037,
-0.0781815648,
-0.6615347862,
-0.1028660387,
-0.066516161,
0.0649805367,
-0.2607299685,
0.7652691603,
-0.3392767012,
0.6806542277,
0.0467036255,
-0.6856638789,
0.5360584259,
-0.4151049852,
0.0731863305,
-1.2059594393,
-0.208875373,
-0.0029134995,
-0.1226634383,
-0.4283028543,
0.1987636238,
0.3205019832,
-0.279125452,
-0.434905231,
0.5718668103,
-0.3744812906,
-0.2706513703,
-0.9537268877,
0.3355688751,
0.1589110345,
0.0219500996,
0.1207469627,
0.7228575349,
0.5612543821,
-0.7034944892,
0.2248503566,
0.4013640285,
-0.5160425305,
0.7632077336,
-0.7855769992,
0.1129393801,
-0.4671279788,
0.1137798429,
-1.0150358677,
-0.059726201,
-0.1817425042,
-0.8138850331,
0.1507445425,
-0.1922741979,
-0.240300104,
-0.0359088033,
-0.1525079012,
0.1576084495,
0.3156159818,
-0.393948555,
0.3770774901,
0.2556189299,
-0.189309597,
-0.2575190365,
-0.5236609578,
0.2771020234,
-0.4471571743,
-0.7978844643,
0.9288879037,
-0.1762931645,
-0.3995269835,
0.385174185,
0.0402495191,
-0.4307703376,
0.574904561,
0.2295317054,
-0.0387699455,
-0.5511101484,
0.4612134099,
0.3092554212,
-0.3728747368,
0.0062665837,
-0.2259899676,
0.7813575268,
0.0056762788,
-0.2684331834,
-0.5884100795,
0.4370079935,
0.37686342,
-0.3884450495,
0.7794630527,
1.0129878521,
-0.6374211907,
0.0731430948,
-0.2584105134,
-0.3462463021,
-0.4226594865,
0.4155584872,
-0.2600013912,
-0.8433895111,
0.7219576836,
-0.1283974648,
-0.4379547834,
0.7392457128,
0.5546252728,
-0.0332048498,
0.5585092306,
0.8901796341,
0.0654073507,
0.8106485605,
-0.3306939304,
0.2431296259,
-0.976396203,
-0.1470217258,
-0.7207314372,
-0.4530442655,
-0.4851019084,
-0.4359059334,
0.1237224713,
0.303455323,
0.1747718751,
0.264301002,
-0.4565292001,
0.3167397678,
0.5739574432,
0.3489304483,
0.1977726817,
-0.2251021862,
0.0471333973,
0.0102083338,
-0.2220769078,
-0.5943436623,
0.8813285232,
0.5603064895,
0.3510440588,
0.2949046493,
0.6212598085,
0.6742251515,
0.2474201173,
-0.9370797873,
0.3715046942,
-0.4166135192,
-0.6073781848,
-0.3009748459,
-0.0480029844,
-0.8555241227,
0.3190917969,
-0.3054170012,
-0.9294688106,
0.4328771234,
-0.1833845228,
-0.2452484965,
0.2748198211,
-0.7343497276,
0.8171297908,
0.0920287073,
-0.0344065167,
-0.4836226106,
0.0567924306,
0.0318083949,
-0.3194450736,
-0.3217405975,
-0.3182117939,
-0.2108024806,
1.2320684195,
-0.2535758615,
0.7064402103,
-0.2215806246,
0.1043230966,
0.3504219651,
-0.2798195779,
0.0444955118,
0.4265086651,
-0.4536347389,
0.0737048239,
-0.0698034987,
-0.533005178,
-0.6968771219,
0.6626952887,
-0.5821679235,
-0.7862092257,
-0.243292585,
-0.8497843742,
0.1895688176,
0.3320349753,
0.1720981747,
0.2639771998,
-0.5059202909,
0.5210530162,
0.5957663059,
-0.6200626493,
0.5398469567,
0.7906742096,
-0.1800646931,
-0.0431444794,
0.674916923,
-0.1035284474,
-0.280893743,
0.4581897259,
0.4295885861,
-0.261831075,
-1.0474658012,
-0.108878158,
-0.134681046,
-0.7209724784,
0.0954913571,
-1.0024049282,
-0.2562322915,
-0.5020412207,
-0.2246558964,
-0.2524372935,
-0.4974276423,
-0.7378048301,
-0.2435403466,
0.5752416253,
0.510749042,
-0.3713784218,
0.7897362709,
-0.7021308541,
0.2229435593,
0.0664057657,
0.170940116,
-0.056191314,
-1.1053190231,
-0.0833649486,
-0.1875201315,
-0.2461331785,
-0.8988996148,
0.5164467096,
-0.0562523566,
0.6391054988,
0.3729759753,
-0.3009054363,
0.1986640841,
-0.274328053,
0.7139760852,
0.1368067265,
-1.2340284586,
0.8300581574,
-0.4280111194,
0.2325795889,
0.4038096964,
0.4021065235,
-0.6056039333,
-0.1370882839,
-0.6123130322,
-0.4427369833,
0.258128047,
0.0189993531,
0.5391008854,
-0.0404165462,
0.6792864799,
0.2570340335,
0.0840575397,
-0.2146072835,
0.1170677841,
-0.1059558541,
-0.0362619422,
-0.093802318,
-0.4648105502,
0.2593274117,
-0.4982739389,
0.1787498295,
-0.0239951555,
0.6592394114,
-0.0024519267,
-0.1792945862,
0.2129692733,
0.2525898814,
0.5916538835,
0.9595168829,
-0.5655310154,
0.2510562241,
0.1420231313,
-0.603584826,
-0.0398419574,
0.1783049852,
-0.2049447149,
0.2873004377,
0.4928199649,
0.7063784599,
0.0829276815,
-0.2210621089,
0.4343847036,
-0.1919094473,
-0.2214510739,
-0.3438857496,
0.313582778,
0.3060447574,
0.251134038,
0.0492276847,
0.3530714214,
0.3013351262,
-0.6189914346,
0.8514563441,
0.1727165878,
-0.6063347459,
-0.1719452292,
0.3526139259,
-0.0643213317,
-0.7717915177,
0.4502243996,
-0.4141440988,
-0.744278729,
1.2748078108,
0.7358072996,
0.6176500916,
-0.1199310794,
0.4972062111,
0.3549335897,
0.1154713929,
0.1892236024,
0.3379180133,
-0.0018506432,
-1.0962799788,
-0.2307230979,
-0.525590539,
-0.5570611358,
0.1284284145,
-0.7711755633,
0.2063510418,
-0.3470746577,
-0.2350771427,
0.7064180374,
0.0592415817,
-0.295067668,
0.4432387054,
-0.208436951,
1.1635296345,
-0.8192704916,
0.9195371866,
0.6761981845,
-0.2664031982,
-0.2214358151,
0.3218192756,
-0.3206879199,
-0.5458863378,
0.552644074,
0.0233224146,
0.3546648026,
-0.274815619,
-0.2568159103,
-0.9467657208,
0.9779756069,
0.0186513141,
-0.1556377411,
0.1915804744,
-0.3258123696,
0.7310686707,
-0.3424980044,
0.3338218033,
0.4359632432,
0.4319255948,
-0.2024060041,
-0.5936855674,
-0.2452517748,
-0.409043014,
-0.2323840261,
0.3194612563,
-0.3354257643,
1.2886691093,
0.1348952949,
0.2475651503,
0.1315358877,
0.8979008794,
0.0982668847,
0.9168920517,
0.5647505522,
0.500611186,
1.1851027012,
-0.0126768705,
0.9369885325,
-0.382842809,
0.391390115,
0.9965899587,
0.0318695791,
0.8068398237,
0.2682053745,
0.0179983713,
0.4323966205,
0.8932178617,
-0.1410944015,
0.657587707,
0.3371957242,
-0.2799463868,
-0.0372814685,
-0.3416063488,
-0.5455584526,
0.8935924172,
0.7337586284,
-0.6616948843,
-0.2860580981,
0.010807815,
-0.1878077984,
0.3716461062,
-0.3113716245,
0.5023382306,
0.1291158646,
-0.7456607819,
0.3630271852,
0.6248069406,
0.9646184444,
-0.2635885775,
0.0823935792,
-0.259837687,
0.1078886464,
-0.1640479118,
-0.7252531648,
0.9873011112,
0.1746292114,
-0.6757021546,
0.1085356176,
1.3668692112,
-0.1179078221,
-0.4204490781,
0.380236119,
0.6335527301,
0.254173249,
-0.3702916801,
-0.5722228289,
-0.0234879386,
-0.0776300207,
0.2048383355,
0.3182787001,
0.417368114,
0.0196526963,
0.260228157,
0.6049372554,
-0.1722031981,
-0.1863383055,
-0.0522373542,
0.6290041804,
-0.7217918038,
-1.0487599373,
-0.6791557074,
0.0519963652,
-0.370364666,
-0.378220737,
0.5517337322,
0.4365956485,
0.4245944023,
0.0209597442,
0.5403030515,
0.1916411966,
0.6396669745,
-0.5012509823,
0.9559593797,
-0.8220517635,
0.4143221974,
-0.0515936576,
-0.7975167632,
-0.0601085052,
0.7435928583,
-0.7127982974,
-0.1296501756,
0.8472234011,
0.6029137969,
-0.4535418749,
0.4534138739,
0.5432943106,
-0.075819619,
0.1346140206,
0.2158010006,
1.1110323668,
-0.1046477258,
-0.0034348089,
-0.2809921801,
-0.2173656821,
-0.2156454623,
-0.931279242,
-0.8356134295,
-0.61040622,
-0.4175990224,
-0.160285309,
0.0135622537,
0.2070063353,
0.9187495708,
-0.8983128071,
0.1883680224,
-0.2507354617,
0.4253064096,
0.0754192024,
-0.2703996301,
0.5682329535,
-0.2118998766,
-0.6308578253,
0.4585967958,
0.2702994049,
-0.0742777437,
-0.1485429108,
0.1922356635,
-0.3969302773,
0.205259338,
0.4853644073,
-0.1049912944,
-0.536706686,
-0.4729224443,
0.0006146655,
0.0598154888,
0.1178163886,
0.9367022514,
-0.4159764647,
0.1388460249,
0.8051891923,
0.8938180208,
0.8325244784,
-0.2298747301,
0.4285496771,
-0.6761509776,
0.471737802,
0.1132365987,
0.6180906296,
0.2682500482,
-0.7079717517,
0.4683493972,
0.4147116542,
-0.2934565842,
-0.6157554984,
0.1680431366,
-0.8992497325,
-0.8200481534,
0.7727665305,
-0.2943809032,
-0.3389743865,
-0.3219503462,
-0.0625495389,
0.4749176502,
-0.3633691967,
0.623439908,
0.7140806317,
-0.0581399873,
-0.090460889,
-0.3288076222,
-0.0460648425,
0.6327309608,
-0.8925589919,
-0.6086449027,
0.2325016558,
0.4940803349,
0.5892790556,
0.7093790174,
0.0217196345,
0.4280956984,
0.3599576056,
-0.3194538951,
0.1846810877,
-0.4870932102,
-0.2994160056,
0.1734262109,
0.0619555116,
-0.2393904477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04933v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04933v1 | InfoPrompt: Information-Theoretic Soft Prompt Tuning for Natural Language Understanding | 2023-06-08T04:31:48 | 2023-06-08T04:31:48 | Junda Wu, Tong Yu, Rui Wang, Zhao Song, Ruiyi Zhang, Handong Zhao, Chaochao Lu, Shuai Li, Ricardo Henao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Soft prompt tuning achieves superior performances across a wide range of
few-shot tasks. However, the performances of prompt tuning can be highly
sensitive to the initialization of the prompts. We also empirically observe
that conventional prompt tuning methods cannot encode and learn sufficient
task-relevant information from prompt tokens. In this work, we develop an
information-theoretic framework that formulates soft prompt tuning as
maximizing mutual information between prompts and other model parameters (or
encoded representations). This novel view helps us to develop a more efficient,
accurate and robust soft prompt tuning method InfoPrompt. With this framework,
we develop two novel mutual information based loss functions, to (i) discover
proper prompt initialization for the downstream tasks and learn sufficient
task-relevant information from prompt tokens and (ii) encourage the output
representation from the pretrained language model to be more aware of the
task-relevant information captured in the learnt prompt. Extensive experiments
validate that InfoPrompt can significantly accelerate the convergence of the
prompt tuning and outperform traditional prompt tuning methods. Finally, we
provide a formal theoretical result for showing to show that gradient descent
type algorithm can be used to train our mutual information loss. | [
-0.4151164293,
-0.8305112123,
0.4208499789,
0.3107561171,
-0.274699688,
-0.4155090749,
-0.5524511933,
-0.0058259168,
-0.1016962528,
0.1187171936,
-1.0765087605,
-0.4483195543,
-0.581225574,
0.0668843389,
0.0311821215,
1.247181654,
0.2598414719,
0.1470501125,
-0.0411813185,
-0.1827075332,
-0.5950393081,
-0.3012104928,
-0.8524785042,
0.0369866528,
0.7267611027,
0.5530064106,
0.5043638945,
0.475779593,
0.3901565671,
0.1833532602,
0.1257739216,
0.1045420691,
-0.5830265284,
0.053755004,
-0.0705371872,
-0.6481205821,
0.1696692109,
0.1141640991,
0.5574606657,
0.7911669612,
-0.3081194162,
0.2184828818,
0.3493514955,
0.6119983196,
-0.6345396638,
0.5782850385,
-0.5666700006,
0.1634941697,
-0.2760326266,
-0.5776620507,
-0.3727144301,
-0.3423591256,
-0.0323779956,
-0.9405968785,
0.3769145012,
0.0783625469,
0.8348178864,
0.345164597,
-0.3135206401,
-0.2520895302,
-0.53982687,
0.5611696839,
-0.5301600099,
0.3347227573,
0.3552663624,
0.2272736281,
-0.2809669673,
-0.3785744011,
-0.5993096232,
-0.2920068204,
-0.013232003,
0.0585962124,
-0.1630758047,
0.3903096318,
0.3152319193,
0.1329700351,
-0.6060757041,
-0.0466695204,
0.1011283845,
-0.5383089185,
0.0447582155,
0.1349563003,
0.2094131261,
0.127703324,
-0.4359295964,
-0.1552403569,
-0.5783308744,
0.3102841675,
0.3707156181,
0.5091449618,
-0.1265216023,
0.2143278867,
-0.0734445378,
1.1260325909,
0.2574801147,
-0.1418753415,
-0.0260507241,
-0.6949716806,
-0.0616774373,
0.1343247443,
0.592756331,
0.4098368585,
0.3592355549,
-0.1901609898,
-0.0111274319,
-0.0825072303,
-0.125905633,
-0.7135166526,
0.163450554,
-0.3015858233,
-0.5261821151,
-0.1312712729,
0.1744948924,
-0.3571852446,
-0.5791810155,
-0.6393070221,
0.5837376118,
-0.4872163236,
-0.5258731842,
0.2722164989,
-0.2154039145,
0.1660130769,
0.0485623926,
-0.8114916682,
0.2878817618,
0.6740430593,
0.8120515943,
0.205500558,
-0.2446012497,
-1.0092086792,
-0.0439216234,
-0.0675615892,
0.5769372582,
-0.4348433912,
0.1102940217,
0.1474513859,
-0.148465246,
-0.3819269538,
-0.2988682687,
0.6068130732,
-0.2835019231,
0.3835642338,
-0.4455922842,
-0.5419685245,
-0.3112897277,
-0.0085903341,
-0.7037121654,
0.722497344,
0.3294509649,
-1.097461462,
0.4894790649,
-0.5941624641,
-0.4881559908,
-0.065141201,
-0.0924385563,
0.0479588471,
0.1799233109,
-0.1301590949,
0.5118115544,
-0.3878147006,
0.5791327953,
-0.2152881473,
-0.4666589797,
-0.0762680173,
-0.4623268247,
0.5604203939,
0.2201672941,
-0.2921293974,
0.136053279,
-0.5941455364,
-0.2294239253,
-0.0107773365,
-0.1455539614,
-0.4633577764,
-0.2366450727,
-0.127766639,
-0.2330508381,
0.2682433724,
-0.4227015376,
0.1777926236,
-0.4097570181,
0.2813471854,
0.741815567,
0.077598393,
0.5202188492,
-0.3368862271,
0.5566167831,
0.1708844602,
0.3932294846,
-0.4149479568,
-0.3997679949,
-0.4572508633,
-0.099028945,
0.3426160812,
0.6206916571,
-0.8156151175,
0.438426137,
0.0474391319,
-0.139755711,
-0.5888791084,
0.1039350927,
0.3636729419,
1.2126960754,
0.1355165392,
-0.0428463668,
-0.4387249053,
-0.8325101137,
-0.7625278831,
-0.2233000547,
0.0320259556,
0.0771815628,
-0.281793654,
0.0340535566,
0.9311083555,
-0.31998384,
-0.3960214257,
-0.4015883207,
0.5336321592,
0.872764647,
0.3079108596,
0.5781579614,
-0.6523903608,
-0.1762838662,
-0.3766773045,
-0.360124588,
-0.2763002515,
-0.2806195617,
-0.1132077351,
-0.2100446969,
0.332462281,
-0.6999046803,
0.2706749141,
0.3254704475,
-0.651987195,
0.601637423,
-0.2747243643,
0.1937410533,
-0.7668664455,
0.0207037628,
0.20177944,
-0.3329125643,
-0.4973785281,
-0.298666209,
0.1318489164,
-0.0319797061,
-0.1125023887,
0.6371068358,
-0.3176217973,
0.3741489351,
-0.288711518,
0.1212875843,
0.1224559471,
0.6516624093,
-0.1938509792,
0.7887456417,
0.7593365312,
-1.1390812397,
0.1969580054,
0.0329893157,
-0.3222075701,
0.7275921702,
-0.3499019742,
-0.0801932514,
-0.7004550099,
0.0615320504,
-0.8105436563,
-0.0761934519,
0.4244573712,
-0.5451387763,
0.5871569514,
-0.2514209151,
-0.4772614241,
0.0329220891,
-0.3904908895,
0.2935510874,
0.33807078,
-0.5534449816,
0.4446096122,
0.1945335716,
-0.4110927284,
-0.6902452111,
-0.4594439864,
-0.2397170663,
-0.1592794508,
-0.6841779947,
0.3289135993,
-0.1920261234,
-0.1070205122,
0.0939649194,
-0.1140210405,
-0.169639498,
0.205267638,
0.1318453252,
-0.0611747131,
-0.3715605438,
0.6769505739,
0.1865304261,
-0.4066079855,
-0.0712029338,
-0.4390372038,
0.4734262824,
-0.1417906731,
-0.2549602091,
-0.5580698252,
0.3555418551,
0.0811284333,
0.0460893475,
0.8860555887,
1.0161557198,
-0.2013698667,
-0.2381534427,
-0.4313677847,
-0.5350452662,
-0.4989846647,
0.3253194094,
-0.2882838845,
-0.7482087612,
0.3845351934,
-0.2367845923,
0.0794577003,
0.4486397207,
0.1312905103,
-0.141339913,
0.9688068628,
1.0425972939,
-0.1140961647,
0.7874109149,
0.0190953873,
0.0659787953,
-0.3671515286,
-0.3828648627,
-0.6248278618,
-0.3001789451,
-0.0078158034,
-0.02180654,
0.5339064002,
0.3058976531,
-0.2926645577,
0.2279882878,
-0.2780798376,
0.3699329495,
0.8823856711,
0.1003781036,
0.1161645353,
-0.060554862,
-0.2543821931,
-0.1690683961,
-0.9431216121,
-0.123039186,
0.5426453948,
0.0877036601,
0.7605226636,
-0.2391689271,
0.2073612362,
0.5366882086,
-0.1228795201,
-0.7454794645,
0.3876586258,
0.120922029,
-0.1641117781,
-0.1703227013,
-0.7737145424,
-0.9188210964,
-0.2914854586,
-0.0046790717,
-0.3451382518,
0.090209648,
0.5268256664,
-0.3480219245,
0.0773231164,
-0.9416778088,
0.8598799109,
-0.0450828746,
-0.2543634474,
-0.1620950699,
-0.7418712378,
0.1648914218,
0.2428437471,
0.4276934564,
-0.1534357369,
-0.0913626105,
1.0376689434,
-0.3735506833,
0.7778550982,
-0.7360470891,
-0.1035473645,
0.1939100772,
0.180895716,
0.5937381983,
0.2669805288,
-0.2834169269,
-0.0373292789,
-0.1252603084,
-0.4002964497,
-0.8495473266,
0.5108831525,
-0.2790195942,
-0.4234672785,
-0.2596771121,
-0.2796775997,
-0.3275617063,
0.1605920643,
0.630461216,
0.8664357662,
0.0694622993,
-0.1755584031,
0.8114189506,
-0.1379959285,
0.5478836894,
0.7827033997,
0.2525173426,
-0.1132578254,
0.8816879988,
-0.1829348505,
-0.057336662,
0.4941113889,
0.3203237653,
-0.4413259625,
-0.366263479,
-0.3290846646,
0.3302233815,
-0.7512478232,
-0.5741705298,
-0.3022252321,
0.068763718,
-0.2573952675,
0.1943267584,
-0.1476985067,
-0.3533152044,
-0.5666262507,
-0.1279687732,
0.6341195107,
0.6089519858,
-0.2613302767,
0.4570405781,
-0.8257603645,
0.2033987939,
-0.0945621505,
0.6560552716,
-0.3339972794,
-0.6136565208,
-0.2997722924,
0.1357986629,
0.161514625,
-1.0353735685,
0.0500106215,
0.6951231956,
0.639318049,
0.7760649323,
0.4316245914,
0.4766814709,
-0.252726078,
0.5142540932,
0.3654670417,
-1.0165432692,
0.5806303024,
-0.0538313836,
0.5372223258,
1.0988242626,
0.3237437308,
-0.7138230205,
-0.0856247544,
-0.3523693383,
-0.4906055927,
0.9177276492,
-0.0591403358,
0.1032494679,
0.1001535356,
0.5571925044,
0.6305141449,
0.2684279084,
-0.5112892985,
-0.3598745465,
-0.016243998,
-0.827316165,
0.013775955,
-0.1424576342,
0.0355757028,
-0.1939662546,
0.4805941284,
-0.2316128463,
0.4932428598,
0.2219470888,
-0.286565125,
-0.1795695573,
0.1151445433,
0.5275053978,
0.4553855658,
-0.0361765213,
0.3367672265,
-0.1229717135,
-0.4956824481,
0.1179720014,
0.1197788492,
-0.2241254151,
0.1722275913,
0.5289203525,
1.2439905405,
0.3673306108,
-0.5956764221,
0.9315522313,
-0.4282853901,
0.0280385669,
0.0875477046,
0.3098475337,
-0.2340207398,
-0.0090539018,
0.3593427837,
0.4169719517,
0.3054799139,
-0.4109370708,
0.2966899276,
0.527636826,
-0.7749891281,
-0.6155230403,
0.3674831688,
0.1679413766,
-0.3268559575,
0.4214423895,
-0.4573622048,
-0.4136254489,
0.4829301834,
0.4615860283,
0.769570291,
-0.2141236514,
0.5164550543,
0.398314774,
0.1923924834,
0.0976358354,
0.5266071558,
-0.4700840712,
-0.3256700337,
-0.4804610908,
-0.5299118757,
-0.1147052273,
0.0641279146,
-0.6178187132,
0.3866316378,
-0.3651224375,
-0.2755074799,
-0.3770017624,
-0.1721047163,
-0.8875212073,
-0.0445583053,
-0.1572252959,
1.0409855843,
-0.6768903136,
0.3855353892,
0.5287579298,
-0.1829210222,
-0.8006036282,
0.1606704146,
-0.218717292,
-0.7466824651,
0.5240755081,
0.4293893576,
-0.2615230978,
0.2748906612,
-0.6977860332,
-0.7757360935,
0.7551333904,
0.9105800986,
-0.6400473714,
-0.0625752285,
-0.1778917909,
0.0500509441,
-0.168648228,
0.5642553568,
0.3652662933,
0.7947866917,
-0.0508613959,
-0.8964985013,
0.1110173836,
-0.3234136403,
-0.4921716452,
0.2120306045,
-0.4275847077,
0.6504041553,
-0.4147012234,
-0.6503394842,
-0.2749530673,
0.4539702237,
-0.2010542899,
0.5292752981,
0.695551157,
0.1396760195,
0.9255268574,
-0.1632331461,
0.9880643487,
-0.4733030498,
0.1300331354,
0.9624171257,
0.1648560464,
0.1508016586,
0.2587745488,
0.0296039712,
0.2847578228,
0.6543496251,
0.478295356,
0.8340599537,
0.2512931526,
-0.4354173541,
-0.073801145,
-0.4796590805,
-0.4552543461,
0.0242383573,
0.334215939,
-0.1350653619,
-0.3185813129,
0.4588871896,
0.0346820913,
-0.0973259881,
-0.3195697963,
0.9861186743,
0.0301493518,
-0.7592352629,
0.6205304265,
0.1347264647,
0.7055429816,
-0.9614009261,
-0.1087285578,
-0.3238842785,
-0.0639266148,
0.0017157228,
-0.4770016968,
0.0713804439,
-0.2028913498,
-0.0621494986,
-0.2275010794,
0.8468006849,
-0.5080606937,
-0.0260720551,
0.1924470514,
0.1453163475,
-0.1599559039,
-0.488302201,
-0.5688157678,
0.014013119,
-0.0929201171,
-0.2378400564,
0.0609370954,
0.6187095642,
0.4662147164,
0.5651675463,
0.3248099387,
0.2189318538,
0.0972089544,
0.1218800917,
0.7372347116,
-0.8201611638,
-0.6389504075,
-0.8320196867,
0.2316715419,
-0.0247096252,
-0.4178717732,
0.4769064486,
0.2282542884,
0.4271015525,
-0.1605564207,
0.8097096086,
0.169009313,
0.5013426542,
-0.8143879175,
0.4870778918,
-0.3502163589,
0.1496554911,
-0.009794415,
-0.9220380783,
-0.1211418286,
0.2700837851,
0.1378282905,
-0.1011139676,
0.6616092324,
0.7200630307,
-0.115960598,
0.2056034654,
0.0541165248,
0.075872466,
-0.047361955,
0.6531274319,
0.6935916543,
-0.1538870931,
0.5595447421,
-0.1610194445,
-0.5012999177,
-0.3093988895,
-0.9895191789,
-0.6681757569,
-0.7987927198,
-0.2908203602,
-0.1283785701,
0.0456626341,
0.994053483,
0.7870603204,
-0.6192067862,
0.1609271318,
-0.5127541423,
0.2367257476,
-0.1489541382,
-0.2574222684,
0.1934397817,
-0.7960809469,
-0.2956593037,
0.5641050935,
0.3278136253,
-0.0589142069,
-0.0852229297,
-0.3353898823,
0.0720541924,
0.1834060848,
0.2697809935,
0.3644381464,
-0.1574103087,
-0.0050249705,
-0.0950173065,
0.0211601406,
-0.0260249898,
1.1409175396,
-0.9004325867,
0.4325546026,
0.6159958243,
0.564388454,
0.2221917212,
0.083970882,
0.7922028899,
-1.0374320745,
0.3531992137,
0.2819604576,
0.1961629689,
0.316529572,
-0.5888235569,
0.2304118425,
0.3532959521,
-0.1600290537,
-0.715257585,
0.4513426423,
-0.8727184534,
-0.1743451208,
0.9261911511,
-0.1298669726,
-0.2678079009,
-0.2414384782,
-0.4550402761,
0.5444607139,
-0.5660734773,
0.4978507161,
0.5697984695,
-0.0353104807,
-0.1520260125,
-0.1665446162,
0.9179202318,
0.5539153814,
-0.6882719994,
0.0059886212,
0.2431680262,
0.0703802928,
-0.0866063535,
0.7157956362,
0.295284003,
0.2130889893,
-0.1714658737,
-0.1953519285,
-0.3533789515,
-0.4681268334,
-0.3797665834,
0.1428155452,
0.0682786703,
-0.2279607803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04926v1 | covLLM: Large Language Models for COVID-19 Biomedical Literature | 2023-06-08T04:08:32 | 2023-06-08T04:08:32 | Yousuf A. Khan, Clarisse Hokia, Jennifer Xu, Ben Ehlert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The COVID-19 pandemic led to 1.1 million deaths in the United States, despite
the explosion of coronavirus research. These new findings are slow to translate
to clinical interventions, leading to poorer patient outcomes and unnecessary
deaths. One reason is that clinicians, overwhelmed by patients, struggle to
keep pace with the rate of new coronavirus literature. A potential solution is
developing a tool for evaluating coronavirus literature using large language
models (LLMs) -- neural networks that are deployed for natural language
processing. LLMs can be used to summarize and extract user-specified
information. The greater availability and advancement of LLMs and pre-processed
coronavirus literature databases provide the opportunity to assist clinicians
in evaluating coronavirus literature through a coronavirus literature specific
LLM (covLLM), a tool that directly takes an inputted research article and a
user query to return an answer. Using the COVID-19 Open Research Dataset
(CORD-19), we produced two datasets: (1) synCovid, which uses a combination of
handwritten prompts and synthetic prompts generated using OpenAI, and (2) real
abstracts, which contains abstract and title pairs. covLLM was trained with
LLaMA 7B as a baseline model to produce three models trained on (1) the Alpaca
and synCovid datasets, (2) the synCovid dataset, and (3) the synCovid and real
abstract datasets. These models were evaluated by two human evaluators and
ChatGPT. Results demonstrate that training covLLM on the synCovid and abstract
pairs datasets performs competitively with ChatGPT and outperforms covLLM
trained primarily using the Alpaca dataset. | [
-0.1480550766,
-0.8347580433,
0.4282529056,
0.4064475298,
-0.2498954684,
0.122391969,
-0.3157384098,
-0.5672927499,
0.1574086249,
0.4576531947,
-0.4243817627,
-0.5524014235,
-0.1569059044,
0.0696744174,
-0.5412609577,
0.9742000103,
0.0929999426,
0.3738235533,
-0.9496924281,
0.0253263786,
-0.1630354375,
-0.5954661369,
-0.6680647731,
-0.7947723269,
0.5133048892,
0.2439369261,
0.6252715588,
0.1917608529,
0.7681479454,
0.1128359959,
-0.167771861,
0.0888417214,
-0.5938506722,
0.1703312099,
0.1200924441,
-0.3678857982,
-0.4522201717,
0.1747419387,
0.1577343941,
0.5275392532,
-0.1728556305,
0.2318960875,
-0.1397603154,
0.3221059144,
-0.3801169395,
-0.1907320619,
-0.2880510986,
0.3575980365,
-0.0306123216,
-0.3078580797,
-0.5297135711,
-0.3296631873,
0.5332211256,
-0.4907618761,
0.1835969836,
0.1506850719,
0.7342815399,
0.0865053907,
-0.118715018,
-0.301769793,
-0.7089040279,
0.7852668166,
-0.6888625026,
0.1303619146,
0.3506736457,
0.1645600498,
-0.3629842103,
-0.6053124666,
-0.106677413,
-0.619828403,
0.1219992489,
0.2971765101,
-0.2447760254,
0.0227181204,
-0.0340846255,
0.4781584442,
-0.8324622512,
0.4766490459,
-0.542609632,
-0.272618264,
0.8958084583,
0.4731998444,
0.4976742864,
-0.0522928052,
-0.5280042887,
0.0808590725,
-0.6846877337,
0.1150023192,
-0.0075736209,
-0.0295306519,
-0.2118409872,
0.4772990346,
0.0764581338,
0.6813666224,
-0.0448854715,
-0.2333853692,
0.0387036167,
-0.4963722825,
-0.5519785285,
0.1839986444,
1.0588726997,
0.3104603291,
-0.1864652336,
-0.3675875962,
0.1204741746,
-0.0849877074,
0.3088141978,
-0.9404635429,
-0.3208324611,
0.4140135944,
-0.5478181243,
-0.5241024494,
-0.417876333,
-0.7918764353,
-0.6847751737,
-0.3744619489,
0.2407696694,
-0.474183172,
0.0476864278,
0.146220997,
-0.1820855439,
0.5112081766,
0.5239419341,
-0.4315971732,
0.6262429953,
0.5702657104,
0.7952744961,
-0.3932287395,
-0.0232201945,
-0.5547274351,
-0.4831830859,
-0.2890665531,
0.5622564554,
-0.4471688271,
-0.2344282418,
-0.0747997239,
-0.3577657938,
-0.0747713074,
-0.5767042637,
0.4811041951,
-0.4612334073,
0.2120535523,
-0.2211770266,
-0.4976683557,
0.0088795675,
0.3416489959,
-0.6555799246,
0.8403387666,
-0.2591497302,
-0.7562920451,
-0.0191702843,
-0.3919769526,
-0.3660973608,
0.0901771486,
-0.1930273026,
-0.7581714988,
0.0305577479,
0.3665504754,
0.6579334736,
-0.8242363334,
0.5363384485,
-0.3524403274,
-0.1827258319,
0.3727481663,
-0.1663269997,
0.9175447226,
0.28038764,
0.1830637455,
0.1347558796,
-0.6676799655,
-0.4566322565,
0.0424541719,
-0.1702242494,
-0.5406040549,
-0.0543784946,
0.3115020394,
0.1116582975,
0.3441462517,
-0.6720029712,
0.0390832201,
-0.3504538834,
0.270639807,
0.2547910213,
0.0537622571,
0.4718562365,
-0.3848780394,
0.8515305519,
-0.001399175,
0.28891626,
-0.0943471268,
-0.5090979934,
-0.5105580688,
-0.3654174805,
-0.0653248951,
0.6620978117,
-0.5007999539,
0.3247078359,
0.0868216082,
-0.8583602309,
-0.3684924841,
-0.0128267007,
0.1986748725,
0.6565089822,
0.4149663746,
-0.2489096373,
-0.7652778625,
-0.6470168233,
-0.0595064647,
0.0399443842,
0.3864223659,
0.2099988312,
0.5518451929,
-0.2811040878,
0.9453826547,
-0.4144220054,
-0.2821578085,
-0.2792361379,
0.2982958555,
0.1902229488,
0.2362412065,
0.3528388441,
-0.4765212238,
-0.1199505627,
0.1589283198,
-0.9351376891,
-0.1586365104,
-0.2388510555,
0.0994674712,
-0.241015017,
0.7167692184,
-0.2964330614,
0.3998538852,
0.549963057,
-0.1451897323,
0.6804916859,
-0.4596655071,
-0.1285957396,
-1.1933298111,
0.3228963614,
0.189964667,
-0.3156353235,
-0.7984182835,
0.0442755334,
-0.1415411085,
-0.3635092974,
-0.388644278,
0.4653613865,
-0.3160517514,
0.071050033,
-0.2578930855,
-0.0032083243,
0.2050405443,
-0.0838936418,
-0.025811879,
0.6715864539,
0.2795494497,
-0.3485614061,
0.6647052765,
0.3328142762,
-0.4177855551,
0.210911572,
-0.8369054198,
0.0032523277,
-0.3316320181,
0.3825277686,
-0.762947619,
-0.1608583629,
0.0902731717,
-0.172627002,
-0.016237447,
0.3327483833,
-0.1195277646,
-0.467164278,
-0.4201934934,
0.4019431174,
0.3870490193,
-0.4203167558,
0.3246488869,
0.4974069595,
-0.2027321458,
-0.590998292,
-0.7191743851,
0.3048343658,
-0.1568159908,
-0.7314450145,
0.4026590288,
-0.2177442163,
-0.3948001564,
-0.0685930252,
0.2294426709,
-0.2938121259,
0.3439995348,
0.392791599,
0.4771108031,
-0.1909565777,
0.2616405189,
-0.0254332162,
0.2929704189,
0.0855886415,
0.06651292,
0.63558954,
-0.2349362373,
-0.085490182,
-0.4769963622,
0.1360063851,
0.5811765194,
-0.4663287997,
0.671133697,
0.7840298414,
-0.3554470539,
0.0935432091,
-0.4336959422,
0.0259834658,
-0.2783121169,
0.3491580486,
0.0399406888,
-0.8492203355,
0.55863446,
0.0490699522,
-0.1817611009,
0.3374013007,
0.8658217192,
0.0763119906,
0.3898522258,
0.3829839528,
-0.2824198008,
0.3426224887,
-0.3074910939,
0.1070455983,
-0.846370995,
-0.6064690948,
-0.5983678102,
-0.0047329897,
-0.1462753564,
-0.6802677512,
0.5655399561,
-0.0347238034,
0.160443306,
0.2324126065,
-0.4067359567,
0.2985074222,
0.3472355604,
0.400411725,
0.2544864416,
0.0782065913,
-0.2386923581,
0.2514178157,
-0.7893425822,
-0.2425132096,
1.0929336548,
0.5013022423,
1.2000635862,
-0.1919383854,
0.7997168303,
0.4184084237,
0.3366521895,
-0.8820056915,
0.4129831195,
-0.2198097259,
-0.3253765106,
-0.2286546975,
-0.1707210839,
-1.2847453356,
-0.0593452863,
-0.3819579184,
-0.5141922832,
0.347311914,
0.0074148122,
-0.7010061741,
-0.1262144893,
-0.3676005602,
0.7034592628,
-0.2211028039,
-0.3907290101,
-0.4265373647,
-0.5018190145,
0.564458549,
-0.21521689,
0.1266012788,
-0.2092468888,
0.0396221802,
0.8379684091,
-0.6098697782,
0.8462904096,
0.1785425544,
-0.0443433709,
0.3907875717,
-0.3118954897,
0.3306845725,
0.2101395726,
-0.3227596581,
0.096293062,
0.0503065698,
-0.3520919681,
-0.1732758582,
0.765385747,
-1.1088149548,
-0.2737539113,
-0.6922941208,
-0.6239771843,
0.1171298176,
-0.1939564794,
0.3201279044,
0.5921700597,
-0.7923910022,
0.139778316,
0.7046017647,
-0.7088182569,
0.3722757101,
0.3650795519,
-0.4374264479,
-0.4539615512,
0.5790271163,
-0.0555966273,
-0.015662048,
0.5399799347,
0.5075455308,
-0.0940992534,
-0.6541362405,
-0.1036793739,
0.1941067427,
-0.4943793416,
-0.2632785738,
-0.5672483444,
-0.5631390214,
-0.3470906317,
0.0657943115,
-0.1189976409,
-0.0651139617,
-0.6067493558,
0.0878062397,
0.6406232119,
0.7577527165,
0.2359084338,
0.1371667236,
-0.7167667747,
0.2598635256,
0.3282672167,
-0.0674259588,
-0.0356593318,
-0.4764404595,
-0.5316438675,
-0.0552716888,
-0.1736805737,
-0.7444267273,
0.7269082069,
0.3549199998,
0.341961354,
0.1030590013,
-0.0398517698,
0.7460707426,
-0.4330815077,
0.739948988,
0.4710622728,
-0.6684555411,
0.5087782145,
-0.2968704104,
0.3596574068,
0.452542156,
0.4032488167,
-0.6707751751,
-0.2456795126,
-0.355347544,
-0.7036040425,
0.5011332035,
0.1017612815,
-0.1676002592,
0.0682691261,
0.3488340974,
0.2256309986,
-0.0235759728,
-0.3426768184,
-0.0733616203,
0.0248583201,
-0.371804148,
-0.0603719428,
-0.1176185906,
-0.123118557,
-0.3594091535,
0.5251432061,
-0.0691282675,
0.4117055237,
0.5818516016,
-0.2709631324,
-0.1374385059,
0.2726562321,
0.7106605172,
0.465934664,
-0.3969638646,
0.0590614416,
0.0757542551,
-0.6987957954,
0.2003837377,
0.3156771958,
-0.1802058369,
-0.141410172,
0.3378205597,
0.8648136258,
-0.1483764797,
-0.9148753881,
0.6811068058,
-0.3697411418,
0.0322858393,
-0.5547425151,
-0.0577612668,
0.0983950794,
0.3111658096,
0.2599408925,
0.3311008513,
0.2025738657,
-0.3430923522,
0.1048442349,
0.5707439184,
-0.3425047696,
-0.4423771799,
0.5698391795,
0.2518558204,
-0.2517789304,
0.4435278475,
0.1072608978,
-0.2031852156,
0.8019886017,
0.5541839004,
0.8078453541,
-0.2297559977,
0.3753165901,
0.2447760254,
0.1952441484,
-0.2942200899,
0.2650544345,
0.3476212621,
-0.5204631686,
-0.661185503,
-0.7656088471,
-0.4441078603,
0.604242444,
-0.8050172925,
0.4286710322,
-0.4072724879,
-0.0760186166,
0.1027634069,
-0.0558572635,
-0.8013207912,
0.3060685694,
0.4667845666,
1.0619158745,
-0.9794616103,
0.8884115219,
0.7699415684,
-0.3558040559,
-0.3903111219,
-0.1479438394,
-0.2293080091,
-0.7620156407,
0.481179446,
0.0274173543,
0.2405380458,
-0.3254679441,
-0.6600549221,
-0.8477168083,
1.3100819588,
0.2985545397,
-0.6825028062,
0.053019952,
0.1083996221,
0.9180356264,
-0.4678698778,
0.3081068397,
0.4308698475,
-0.0406534895,
-0.0415325016,
-0.9529231787,
-0.0141666224,
-0.2354903668,
-0.1119209528,
-0.1151214242,
-0.7193777561,
0.6692615747,
-0.1570735723,
0.3594934642,
0.4552811086,
0.686412096,
0.2623011768,
0.7138719559,
-0.0103111072,
0.6966078877,
1.1481229067,
0.1936992854,
1.1513004303,
-0.0418622084,
0.4003713727,
1.0250577927,
-0.2419266999,
0.9186722636,
0.4976595044,
-0.1489830017,
0.3451133072,
0.6733940244,
-0.0999153182,
0.3072853386,
0.3880322874,
-0.468744874,
-0.3286178708,
-0.4093827307,
-0.3443414867,
0.4658668041,
0.4676915407,
-0.5817266107,
-0.1547175944,
0.4390197396,
0.0620237216,
-0.0356730334,
-0.4463677406,
0.5493810177,
0.3949382007,
-0.6982961893,
0.6866614819,
0.0938320532,
0.3696505427,
-0.3969107568,
0.3214296699,
-0.1782597452,
0.0925289467,
-0.2444495112,
-0.3103193939,
0.3244324625,
0.0843189806,
-0.3005454838,
0.1195129976,
0.9989050627,
-0.6273636222,
-0.6818620563,
0.2238833457,
0.4366075695,
0.1690652668,
0.0717535391,
-0.7187319994,
0.2083875835,
-0.2322013378,
-0.0207859017,
0.3919149935,
-0.2170760483,
-0.1939614415,
0.6439436674,
0.5321923494,
0.1604426503,
0.0191149637,
0.0898082107,
0.7200987935,
-0.5881069899,
-0.1901492327,
-0.9631673694,
0.0753858909,
-0.1816206276,
-0.1158508658,
0.6148008704,
0.7283707261,
0.1255059242,
-0.1377542466,
0.901298821,
0.1915096045,
0.2568096817,
-0.4116153419,
0.777474761,
-0.3313260972,
0.2315683365,
0.0740415454,
-0.354971081,
-0.5479148626,
0.3562640548,
-0.5197140574,
-0.464135766,
0.6462658644,
0.7046783566,
0.16050376,
-0.0124646258,
0.2679152489,
0.3842734993,
0.3585007787,
0.5289735794,
0.8369720578,
-0.5759590268,
0.3835235834,
-0.1223210245,
-0.2129585743,
-0.5598927736,
-0.8378516436,
-1.2509967089,
-0.2485987842,
-0.4851162434,
-0.55562222,
0.2291420549,
1.3531053066,
0.5287112594,
-0.6447594166,
-0.4006239772,
-0.1545036435,
-0.0893359035,
-0.1420770288,
-0.151624307,
0.5076731443,
-0.3802511692,
-0.3399080634,
0.5849459171,
0.4088245928,
-0.0728371292,
-0.4761253595,
-0.2457588613,
-0.3318427801,
0.1835922152,
0.713534236,
0.2186281234,
-0.6820880175,
0.300532192,
0.2627117038,
-0.4433407485,
0.1294645369,
0.711001575,
-0.9875586033,
0.5914170146,
0.758777082,
0.8146102428,
0.7036973834,
-0.1708504111,
0.7551999688,
-0.6133722663,
0.0232439395,
0.2951396108,
0.3882371187,
0.4913005233,
-0.3770247102,
0.1985070407,
0.2454174906,
-0.7473762631,
-0.6942301393,
-0.1784045994,
-1.1897088289,
-0.1438565552,
1.2208726406,
-0.1874185503,
-0.5369567871,
-0.2844605744,
-0.3544696569,
0.2302565426,
-0.3716224134,
0.6718526483,
0.5133411884,
-0.1429615468,
-0.141735062,
-0.3280903697,
0.5569441915,
0.3592126966,
-1.1121295691,
-0.2763113976,
0.2271659374,
0.112368308,
0.0353577435,
0.6385323405,
0.0613623373,
0.4988154769,
-0.3632259667,
0.1872232109,
-0.0289827771,
-0.1313540488,
-0.7473484278,
0.2357207537,
0.1106853858,
0.1370499432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04925v1 | Prefer to Classify: Improving Text Classifiers via Auxiliary Preference Learning | 2023-06-08T04:04:47 | 2023-06-08T04:04:47 | Jaehyung Kim, Jinwoo Shin, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The development of largely human-annotated benchmarks has driven the success
of deep neural networks in various NLP tasks. To enhance the effectiveness of
existing benchmarks, collecting new additional input-output pairs is often too
costly and challenging, particularly considering their marginal impact on
improving the current model accuracy. Instead, additional or complementary
annotations on the existing input texts in the benchmarks can be preferable as
an efficient way to pay the additional human cost. In this paper, we
investigate task-specific preferences between pairs of input texts as a new
alternative way for such auxiliary data annotation. From 'pair-wise'
comparisons with respect to the task, the auxiliary preference learning enables
the model to learn an additional informative training signal that cannot be
captured with 'instance-wise' task labels. To this end, we propose a novel
multi-task learning framework, called prefer-to-classify (P2C), which can enjoy
the cooperative effect of learning both the given classification task and the
auxiliary preferences. Here, we provide three different ways to collect
preference signals in practice: (a) implicitly extracting from annotation
records (for free, but often unavailable), (b) collecting explicitly from crowd
workers (high paid), or (c) pre-trained large language models such as GPT-3
(low paid). Given existing classification NLP benchmarks, we demonstrate that
the proposed auxiliary preference learning via P2C on them is effective in
improving text classifiers. Our codes are publicly available. | [
-0.3960149586,
-0.2277678996,
0.3763301075,
0.0642604604,
-0.2220336497,
-0.2972874045,
-0.6079608202,
-0.6431481242,
0.1284191012,
0.3793315589,
-0.2402626872,
-0.3755037785,
-0.8846719861,
0.2504789233,
-0.0884303525,
1.1948721409,
-0.0082187653,
-0.0410706587,
-0.4540360272,
-0.3615060747,
-0.3439556658,
-1.0597586632,
-0.8368823528,
-0.3268682361,
0.8791695237,
0.6217687726,
0.5633292198,
0.3364879489,
0.2907538712,
0.3335538805,
0.3145246208,
0.4600406587,
-0.0779493749,
0.2148612142,
0.0514158383,
-0.682741344,
-0.0933440775,
0.3775095642,
0.2043109834,
0.4649373293,
0.2504370213,
0.0932027325,
0.0794964284,
0.6398439407,
-0.5971753597,
0.4841028154,
-0.5848186612,
-0.0637732223,
-0.3946294785,
-0.2778115273,
-0.6659374237,
-0.0443119854,
0.3502381444,
-0.5215833187,
0.3001369536,
0.0577498674,
0.7360523939,
0.2631523013,
-0.5175565481,
-0.1052468792,
-0.2025565207,
0.7556307316,
-0.1123094261,
0.5480026603,
0.8578864932,
0.0891735256,
0.4227522016,
-0.593354404,
-0.3561136425,
-0.2529162467,
-0.2963444293,
0.2668759525,
0.1268858612,
0.0894358456,
0.0643792599,
0.3275783062,
-0.1623805612,
0.3214099705,
-0.1677197218,
-0.2143164575,
0.7035470605,
-0.3051570356,
0.2661883831,
-0.175180003,
-0.3509203494,
-0.3380795717,
-0.3291207552,
0.3508804142,
0.3653403223,
0.4504956901,
-0.0364897884,
0.5729759336,
-0.3585985899,
0.5300073028,
0.1073798314,
0.2136067152,
0.6355519891,
0.0776238516,
-0.110935621,
-0.0320136324,
0.7115460634,
0.5184041858,
-0.0078471797,
-0.4194172621,
-0.1567099541,
0.3256774843,
0.2446893752,
-0.5465081334,
-0.4677027166,
0.2070170641,
-0.5944408178,
-0.4128625393,
-0.2434155047,
-0.3988412619,
-0.4008076489,
-0.7611072063,
0.3119405806,
-0.1112824157,
-0.1178867519,
0.0782609805,
-0.2079990357,
-0.0981554165,
0.4830329716,
-1.2142230272,
0.2009139955,
0.7062659264,
0.934928,
-0.5361862779,
-0.205683738,
-0.8007711172,
-0.1716929376,
-0.0763727427,
1.1746710539,
-0.4752909839,
-0.4137984514,
0.0022609213,
-0.0450489409,
-0.0215338059,
-0.4161164761,
0.8831313848,
-0.4636894763,
0.3727869689,
-0.2976734936,
-0.4369254708,
-0.2216792107,
0.1785490215,
-0.6382449865,
1.0723073483,
0.016046023,
-0.8672851324,
0.6510256529,
-0.716225028,
-0.4941332042,
0.053724166,
-0.2337168604,
-0.3912746608,
-0.0695468262,
0.1875211596,
0.8266753554,
-0.1360221207,
0.3566238284,
-0.5348724127,
-0.0672124103,
0.2043793648,
-0.3639915884,
0.6505521536,
0.0492731072,
-0.2242073417,
0.3912932277,
-0.4677935243,
-0.2400569469,
-0.1831432879,
-0.4334205389,
-0.5959828496,
0.1695227921,
0.1263715327,
0.2483370751,
0.2563772798,
-0.4413738549,
0.1285691708,
-0.4408800304,
0.2212855369,
0.9442365766,
-0.3477268517,
0.7842833996,
-0.6560738683,
-0.0164073072,
-0.3013153672,
-0.0243611708,
0.2764190137,
-0.5584044456,
-0.9739133716,
-0.3977786899,
0.151293993,
0.3445141912,
-0.7249163389,
0.330349654,
-0.2090672851,
-0.3078857064,
-0.4046778381,
0.084747605,
0.2610144913,
0.4553538561,
0.6427870989,
-0.2840885222,
-0.7383963466,
-0.9611676335,
-0.1670547426,
-0.2657868862,
-0.1196853966,
0.7019142509,
0.1614073366,
-0.2192411274,
0.8899800777,
-0.4784300923,
-0.388355583,
-0.1434976012,
0.1545639932,
-0.0033423291,
0.3644760847,
0.5847988129,
-1.1094994545,
-0.5567884445,
0.0006879792,
-0.2885260582,
0.0185685121,
0.0933742225,
-0.3967010081,
0.1996482462,
0.1379340291,
-0.3299465179,
0.1630041003,
0.3903715014,
-0.0542722568,
0.3320624828,
-0.1245015338,
0.2136223167,
-1.0225806236,
0.0118071632,
0.2807245851,
-0.3323048353,
-0.6217026711,
-0.1614239961,
0.117278263,
0.2692910433,
-0.2929979563,
0.560154438,
-0.1320647299,
0.0227199774,
-0.3804135025,
-0.01476066,
-0.1510432959,
0.6011430025,
0.8811326027,
0.5820521712,
0.4984615743,
-0.7216571569,
0.2218279392,
0.5260007977,
0.0155962845,
0.2089833021,
-0.2422906011,
0.472894758,
-0.1949542761,
0.4152371883,
-0.846108377,
-0.28020522,
0.2974643707,
-0.6386481524,
0.3110280037,
-0.2647390366,
-0.2971937358,
0.010077917,
-0.387891382,
0.1948118955,
0.5355562568,
-1.0436036587,
0.4787270427,
0.5056365728,
-0.001807185,
-0.6417217255,
-0.6967311502,
-0.211079672,
-0.1955933273,
-0.2234944701,
0.4761609733,
0.1237695515,
-0.0814408287,
-0.1781623065,
-0.2210177332,
-0.3054284751,
0.0856812671,
0.6444714069,
0.3991235793,
0.075206548,
0.4046657979,
0.1283748001,
-0.435958147,
-0.0804642141,
-0.4168819487,
0.3353684545,
0.0584368184,
0.0585539602,
-0.2031890601,
0.4226694107,
0.0976237506,
-0.4748034179,
0.490326196,
0.6785891056,
-0.1953623444,
-0.2350165248,
-0.6269004941,
-0.1624262184,
-0.4757222831,
0.2149626762,
-0.3994947374,
-1.0647314787,
-0.2688525915,
0.0004939284,
0.3984994888,
0.5671863556,
0.4001494944,
-0.1352686733,
0.8053290248,
0.5408486724,
-0.3273237646,
0.4888873696,
-0.1826210767,
-0.1632526219,
-0.6544141769,
-0.3099750876,
-0.8736333847,
-0.1910262406,
-0.398552984,
-0.512157619,
0.1826849878,
-0.1554567367,
-0.0828255489,
0.427113682,
-0.6562998891,
0.3464912176,
0.8333699107,
0.5147990584,
0.1044205204,
0.0904751793,
0.1754920185,
0.0148208262,
-0.4309701324,
-0.366948843,
1.2537246943,
0.1893659681,
-0.0202126019,
-0.026348304,
0.9467520714,
0.2075056881,
0.6674202085,
-0.9296181798,
0.2962685823,
-0.6044928432,
-0.5145611167,
-0.1877334118,
-0.3667248189,
-0.607406497,
0.2604152262,
-0.445281148,
-0.6791064739,
0.3176409304,
0.3891260922,
-0.4232913852,
0.1815267503,
-0.8822767138,
0.7938320041,
-0.3981972933,
-0.5147379041,
-0.3517135978,
-0.6887833476,
0.1655919254,
0.1302922219,
0.1981050968,
-0.2287975401,
-0.3212339878,
0.8745853305,
-0.1079333946,
0.8307333589,
-0.2141408771,
0.2047501355,
-0.0112716807,
-0.1834710389,
0.4741843343,
0.248829484,
-0.2304767817,
0.2181772143,
-0.4415729642,
-0.2393496931,
-0.3953377604,
0.6713047624,
-0.897079885,
-0.4028974473,
-0.4928274751,
-0.3234179616,
-0.5731823444,
-0.0035578338,
0.3800436258,
0.5044027567,
0.339307338,
0.2400580794,
0.498444587,
-0.0073827687,
0.5527564287,
0.2264792621,
0.1382434368,
-0.405438751,
0.9100922346,
-0.1427391469,
0.0242334045,
0.8000705838,
0.2851324677,
-0.6696128249,
-0.6025502086,
-0.2525267005,
-0.1627309471,
-0.5082198381,
-0.1151006818,
-1.0479168892,
0.1828799397,
-0.2795696855,
-0.2687741816,
-0.0934401155,
-0.4310767055,
-0.4642390311,
-0.2308480144,
0.5966277719,
0.21437186,
-0.1537433267,
0.1020124704,
-0.6120200753,
0.4591596723,
0.6617061496,
0.4364479482,
-0.1655932814,
-0.3682164252,
-0.049244225,
-0.0473923013,
-0.0284870155,
-0.7043733001,
0.2235269696,
0.1635465622,
0.4432478249,
0.2137598991,
0.3389554918,
0.4675837457,
-0.3634324372,
0.542485714,
0.4836500883,
-0.8980996609,
0.297639221,
-0.2379075438,
-0.2040511817,
0.9126950502,
0.6707835793,
-0.5700649023,
0.1117710769,
-0.3940281272,
-0.8629644513,
1.030831337,
0.1565985531,
0.0587540604,
-0.0802657306,
0.2206078172,
0.5363466144,
0.1368606836,
-0.9168099165,
-0.4653195441,
-0.3758037388,
-0.3501039445,
-0.5437331796,
-0.2531667054,
0.136400938,
-0.1852015555,
0.8094546199,
-0.1374476999,
0.2253318727,
0.2429550588,
-0.0892049447,
0.3928192556,
0.2204127908,
0.0561172739,
-0.1332910508,
-0.1590880007,
0.3458314538,
0.2028526366,
-0.2635212839,
0.1624465734,
0.2637872398,
-0.1281290352,
0.0033760497,
0.0747786909,
0.9403250813,
0.1892678887,
-0.4241594076,
0.7005788684,
-0.1309482455,
-0.4123118818,
-0.1483481824,
0.059800297,
-0.0289934799,
0.0424053781,
0.1644123495,
0.6677590013,
0.5778592825,
-0.271735996,
0.2787638307,
0.3589662313,
-0.6200059056,
-0.0642012209,
0.4175431132,
0.6076802015,
-0.3100509346,
0.1959095597,
-0.3191631436,
-0.6068330407,
0.3721460402,
0.2869276702,
0.9488794208,
-0.0454081371,
0.4820753038,
0.3699215055,
-0.0292679649,
-0.3889644742,
-0.1788781285,
-0.6797946692,
-0.7901498675,
-0.3437243998,
-0.4564558864,
-0.4641786516,
-0.017310733,
-0.5610954165,
0.4236547053,
-0.2614617348,
-0.1255343854,
0.2498874366,
-0.0235472247,
-0.6977787018,
0.3419993222,
0.2691243887,
0.4766175151,
-0.7077556252,
0.9130561948,
0.8451280594,
-0.3018831611,
-0.6719408035,
-0.0269593634,
-0.1566823423,
-0.5465770364,
0.568446517,
0.6932439208,
0.0541606136,
-0.1378269941,
-0.2609835863,
-0.5303426385,
0.6062780023,
0.1203454733,
-0.5362855196,
-0.0894527584,
-0.2065421492,
0.2590309083,
-0.2359201759,
0.4622928202,
0.3325816095,
0.3870997131,
-0.3264277577,
-0.8934636116,
-0.115373902,
-0.3910831809,
-0.1668730974,
0.2923435867,
-0.8038166761,
0.6136180758,
-0.0361672081,
-0.0935808122,
-0.1920033544,
0.4264239967,
-0.1356185377,
0.6273214221,
0.9197590351,
0.1328639537,
0.6058820486,
-0.1629078388,
0.9172720909,
0.0190903414,
0.25707376,
1.3039240837,
-0.1794902086,
1.0717109442,
0.2524451315,
-0.2515418231,
0.2150210291,
0.7602930665,
0.080576174,
0.5077583194,
0.0042069391,
-0.4031928778,
-0.5455950499,
-0.1988186836,
-0.2935735583,
0.4394665062,
0.0360835046,
-0.2797119617,
0.1839132458,
0.0846745446,
-0.1092175394,
0.1651919335,
-0.2876829207,
0.8929896951,
-0.0432200022,
-0.7766023278,
0.1558547318,
0.0907102749,
1.1867953539,
-0.522161603,
0.158155635,
0.065267995,
0.0020311193,
-0.4418015182,
-0.4115414619,
0.1012243629,
-0.0320057012,
-0.3023467958,
-0.3265577257,
0.7317756414,
-0.528273344,
-0.1658218056,
0.312078774,
0.0550606437,
-0.103008166,
-0.2329993546,
-0.5447588563,
-0.3199950159,
0.0981187895,
0.0901619643,
0.405567497,
-0.1115398705,
0.0823849514,
0.3188416362,
0.9152135253,
-0.0698102191,
-0.1925205439,
0.017602982,
0.662412107,
-0.2193295062,
-0.6397421956,
-0.6453645229,
0.4255229831,
-0.4199203849,
-0.4272443056,
0.7175700665,
0.7119053006,
1.0512883663,
-0.1140791923,
1.0822408199,
-0.0184887387,
0.663030982,
-0.4234858155,
0.4733047783,
-0.4612226784,
-0.0683001205,
-0.2739027143,
-0.6915888786,
-0.3173421323,
0.6127105355,
-0.4881507754,
-0.1325920522,
0.7491502762,
0.3493691683,
0.0189137701,
0.339733988,
0.0368840508,
-0.4584888518,
0.1483241618,
0.7348572016,
0.7254980206,
-0.1127227321,
0.390475601,
-0.7212204337,
-0.4383199513,
-0.1556754261,
-0.6090422273,
-1.0761457682,
-0.85498631,
-0.5078154802,
-0.2011242509,
0.1430841237,
1.4173462391,
0.8761825562,
-0.7704652548,
-0.0370468795,
-0.0809596777,
-0.083095707,
-0.1939353198,
-0.1505773813,
0.4888755083,
-0.5734875202,
-0.8493438363,
0.2712279856,
0.0740766004,
0.0030020948,
0.3430514336,
-0.1308865994,
-0.026982246,
-0.2959929705,
0.6917291284,
0.2243705392,
-0.4997070432,
-0.2784388065,
-0.1400466561,
-0.0041392795,
0.0712802112,
0.9014481306,
-0.7061162591,
0.3922269046,
0.3873748779,
0.9863408208,
0.5863257051,
-0.0773528367,
0.3642559648,
-0.6449881792,
0.2701429129,
0.185476169,
0.3174170852,
0.3173447251,
-0.4996612072,
0.4553025365,
0.2127189338,
-0.4959108233,
-0.665686667,
0.0557210483,
-1.0600860119,
-0.2461628169,
1.3399451971,
-0.1690758765,
0.0542332456,
-0.3012318611,
-0.5791829824,
0.3045896292,
-0.7315012813,
0.6590204239,
0.4382750392,
-0.1250573099,
0.1082454994,
-0.217296347,
0.854422152,
0.5631200671,
-0.8243094683,
0.0203090291,
0.621655941,
0.0544785708,
0.1135689691,
0.7704412937,
0.1335939169,
0.3429886401,
-0.144782722,
0.0072405036,
-0.3037359715,
-0.3842104077,
-0.2254425585,
0.3764617443,
0.1457214653,
-0.5217359066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04903v1 | NOWJ at COLIEE 2023 -- Multi-Task and Ensemble Approaches in Legal Information Processing | 2023-06-08T03:10:49 | 2023-06-08T03:10:49 | Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong, Hai-Long Nguyen, Tan-Minh Nguyen, Hoang-Trung Nguyen, Thai-Binh Nguyen, Ha-Thanh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the NOWJ team's approach to the COLIEE 2023 Competition,
which focuses on advancing legal information processing techniques and applying
them to real-world legal scenarios. Our team tackles the four tasks in the
competition, which involve legal case retrieval, legal case entailment, statute
law retrieval, and legal textual entailment. We employ state-of-the-art machine
learning models and innovative approaches, such as BERT, Longformer,
BM25-ranking algorithm, and multi-task learning models. Although our team did
not achieve state-of-the-art results, our findings provide valuable insights
and pave the way for future improvements in legal information processing. | [
-0.4706036747,
-0.5058830976,
0.7811666131,
0.0490684919,
-0.145312652,
0.2812898755,
0.0250202101,
-1.0963567495,
0.1377461106,
0.6064096093,
-0.3381412625,
-0.3201441467,
-0.4778507352,
0.0495682694,
-0.2333457917,
0.8781480193,
0.045222573,
0.2284154594,
-0.1011463553,
-0.1568189561,
-0.6086124182,
-0.2992281616,
-0.641970396,
-0.0216697268,
0.3611126244,
0.4199230969,
0.2523503602,
0.5860084295,
0.7806738615,
0.3248682022,
0.1010678634,
-0.1576085389,
-0.1900089383,
0.4323518872,
-0.1993414313,
-0.6862456203,
-0.7356038094,
0.0666216835,
0.4591032863,
0.3748854995,
-0.2075633705,
0.0356339179,
-0.2360194176,
0.6483370066,
-1.1286519766,
0.3454772234,
-0.4803391397,
0.2078808397,
-0.4427264035,
-0.4076164067,
-0.7295367718,
-0.3872345686,
0.0242384188,
-0.8941194415,
0.2003223002,
0.5404010415,
0.5857524872,
0.2903095186,
-0.525059104,
-0.5125922561,
-0.583589673,
0.7688052058,
-0.4581032395,
0.5578482151,
-0.0680718943,
0.540338397,
-0.3929107487,
-0.82765764,
-0.5304853916,
-0.0751354545,
0.5315095186,
0.660487771,
-0.3594013751,
0.1519317478,
0.0022772779,
-0.0494124331,
-0.6057928801,
0.1893355846,
-0.3677853346,
-0.0669275522,
0.8548129797,
-0.2252542973,
-0.1613260508,
0.2027972639,
-0.3427242339,
-0.2429398149,
-0.3641929626,
0.1158813909,
0.2936610579,
0.0566320531,
0.3566438556,
0.452426672,
-0.298275739,
0.763064146,
0.2500699461,
-0.1425106674,
0.3064688444,
-0.2328813076,
-0.3398721516,
0.2505655587,
0.8356298804,
0.2214287668,
-0.361366868,
-0.2549123764,
-0.2016441375,
-0.4152384102,
0.4461180568,
-0.4174686074,
-0.1604821831,
0.4820369184,
-0.9154537916,
-0.2568509877,
0.2998743653,
-1.5951560736,
-0.756495595,
-0.4033878446,
0.5020842552,
-0.2956565917,
-0.2813832462,
0.0198434833,
-0.5880312324,
0.2756171823,
0.4747311771,
-0.5154252648,
0.3448152244,
0.7490139008,
0.3746400476,
-0.0374177098,
-0.0225389246,
-0.932692945,
0.4075346589,
-0.0897952393,
0.9978194237,
-0.8581721187,
-0.1508352011,
-0.0896312445,
0.0036860972,
-0.2542453706,
-0.6513436437,
1.026193738,
-0.9067074656,
-0.0819224864,
-0.0981603563,
-0.7083521485,
-0.2818873227,
-0.0098190885,
-0.9276793003,
0.4625442028,
-0.2625074089,
-0.6716089845,
0.9285062551,
-1.2755452394,
-0.5018607974,
0.4780500829,
-0.1638590991,
-0.8661776185,
0.0806746781,
-0.0002309481,
0.5683633685,
-0.214707315,
0.4320565164,
-0.5046713352,
-0.2898573875,
-0.2711593509,
0.1256359667,
1.0132728815,
0.7374826074,
-0.4625965655,
0.4604578912,
-0.6924030781,
-0.0415259004,
0.0889138803,
-0.3525266349,
0.1472369581,
0.1600527465,
-0.0742883459,
0.125416249,
0.1932269037,
-0.7820852995,
0.2661808729,
0.0438637957,
0.6512005925,
0.3089440763,
-0.0039738594,
0.6535348892,
-0.5057196617,
0.5661001205,
-0.2323667258,
0.3295563757,
0.0711282939,
-0.7423077822,
-0.638692379,
-0.3654222488,
0.5341117978,
0.9433184862,
-0.7755933404,
0.1791801602,
-0.4781632721,
-0.6294000149,
-0.4563161135,
-0.2927307189,
-0.0009743623,
-0.1580536216,
0.3594849408,
-0.0587075539,
-1.0349302292,
-0.7849652171,
-0.3056740761,
-0.3340092003,
0.0850408375,
0.0133234067,
0.7589510679,
-0.0939638019,
0.670435667,
0.0297672842,
-0.3803679943,
-0.358419925,
0.7520466447,
0.3286161721,
0.3795496821,
0.2499235719,
-1.2915458679,
0.0852412805,
0.1360910982,
-0.9350225925,
0.2871796787,
-0.1551690698,
-0.0751355514,
0.2131156176,
0.83441782,
-0.4949110448,
0.3843292892,
-0.0501791537,
-0.2659296095,
0.3750967383,
-0.1783732176,
0.608133316,
-0.9077880383,
-0.2271438837,
-0.006927717,
-0.2470358461,
-0.4661925435,
0.6249382496,
0.3219968081,
-0.1126370355,
-0.6037601233,
0.0735102445,
-0.730907619,
-0.3856960237,
-0.286994338,
0.0642952546,
-0.0264370758,
0.3401923776,
0.1072928458,
0.6065495014,
0.467269659,
-0.8327111006,
0.6037990451,
-0.2163919061,
-0.4013662934,
0.9638118148,
0.0308237132,
-0.1746072322,
-0.1376613379,
0.3902478516,
-0.5366535187,
-0.6616840363,
0.1112077013,
-0.2804028094,
0.5997286439,
-0.1434942931,
-0.6731009483,
-0.8872690201,
-0.4687379301,
0.3369554877,
0.2614735663,
-0.2218229026,
1.0663098097,
0.9448831677,
0.0250992868,
-0.5051897764,
-0.5612153411,
0.3502471447,
-0.7265668511,
-0.5338051319,
0.7269467711,
0.0587940626,
-0.3283365369,
0.0656249523,
0.3434213102,
-0.4613303542,
0.317591697,
0.0797308907,
-0.0360121652,
-0.1064559296,
-0.0376861989,
-0.2195783556,
0.2315355688,
0.0181156993,
-0.6189675927,
0.3184331059,
-0.2275080234,
-0.2450425476,
-0.6822224855,
0.4511719644,
0.3544992507,
-0.2706401646,
0.4533885419,
0.5164071918,
-0.4944124222,
0.2393974513,
-0.7212480307,
0.156103,
-0.3957030177,
0.2947586477,
-0.6020331979,
-1.0235873461,
0.3460925519,
-0.4190502465,
0.4530201554,
0.5086472631,
0.6070407033,
-0.4452818036,
0.7289103866,
0.7096457481,
0.0351495966,
0.4853966832,
0.0196512938,
0.5692418814,
-0.5876531601,
-0.468301177,
-0.5784875154,
-0.0464201048,
-0.9132707119,
-0.2195374817,
0.5184352398,
0.0706135184,
-0.0502803959,
0.7678551674,
-0.278527081,
0.5058643818,
1.0836786032,
-0.1329105347,
0.2050039917,
-0.4040387571,
-0.0084778825,
0.5699282289,
-0.8020998836,
-0.3190202713,
1.2412223816,
0.0281943306,
0.3165098727,
0.3811579645,
1.0209639072,
0.7229416966,
-0.0220156312,
-0.8249154091,
0.6360346675,
0.1811009347,
-0.765832901,
-0.4523833394,
-0.1238838732,
-1.4838066101,
0.2558975816,
-0.4386569262,
-0.9774455428,
0.2580007315,
-0.1120602638,
-0.680097878,
0.298630476,
-0.4909720719,
0.7280594707,
0.0491261594,
-0.7289326787,
-0.1346786916,
-0.7872499228,
0.5719214678,
-0.3578038216,
0.8929421902,
0.0850902498,
0.161465615,
0.8944811225,
-0.1589524001,
0.3160847425,
-0.1478766352,
-0.0025025313,
0.71176368,
-0.0757354498,
0.5679050684,
0.0293408148,
-0.422791332,
-0.3392854333,
0.2774336636,
-0.391197145,
-0.3884312809,
0.3173370957,
-0.2604500055,
-0.6039751172,
-0.7591713071,
-0.5069260597,
0.0023163438,
0.3888916075,
0.2286524624,
0.0701602548,
-0.0134892436,
0.2361828387,
0.4481758177,
0.2119162977,
0.8069950342,
0.5458139777,
0.2809725106,
-0.3236791492,
1.1362347603,
0.1389748007,
-0.4557808638,
0.6857152581,
-0.1477040946,
-0.5045719743,
-0.8759933114,
-0.4916901886,
-0.144515872,
-0.6735261083,
-0.3521843553,
-0.6591860652,
0.1218992844,
-0.8572186232,
0.0479561239,
-0.379306227,
-0.2901516557,
0.0274431612,
0.315297395,
-0.1118293777,
0.8782020807,
-0.1273015738,
0.0236668698,
-0.8997955322,
-0.0024373413,
0.172155261,
0.0897407532,
-0.5641169548,
-0.1739748567,
-0.2427692115,
-0.1954135597,
-0.7433646917,
-0.7280427217,
0.0818819925,
0.1676348597,
0.9046056271,
0.2994945049,
0.1918147951,
0.5519992113,
-0.5862705708,
0.6421859264,
0.0084571047,
-0.8900728822,
0.8247320652,
-0.375892967,
-0.1373871118,
0.643042326,
0.0882707015,
0.0439686291,
-0.4829491377,
-0.6497437358,
-0.6445097327,
0.5825129151,
0.5338451266,
-0.4339739978,
0.3044660687,
0.2727822065,
0.1274711043,
0.2733333111,
-0.718365252,
0.2956344187,
0.0418207161,
-0.2166618705,
0.564042449,
-0.0278542079,
0.1843409687,
-0.0072660828,
0.8214640021,
-0.1061419621,
0.8237646818,
-0.1946372688,
-0.1012671813,
0.0962496474,
0.5265184641,
0.4627377987,
0.6686308384,
-0.317669183,
-0.0255960003,
0.0703065619,
-0.1160204858,
0.2104043365,
0.3267452717,
0.0015117989,
-0.4157416224,
0.7112842798,
0.6684712172,
0.1926203668,
-0.785954535,
0.6032131314,
-0.1583252549,
-0.7892540693,
-0.6563153863,
0.2593094707,
-0.1951785833,
0.7465543747,
0.496361047,
0.4180996716,
1.0524932146,
-0.8955230713,
0.464925319,
0.2313175648,
-0.245046407,
0.071303986,
1.0562660694,
0.0345822014,
0.0698337108,
0.1532260329,
-0.6558238864,
-0.267442733,
0.7078275084,
0.3583875299,
0.4444343746,
-0.0944847539,
-0.0135517064,
0.3710072935,
-0.1038039848,
-0.5096898079,
0.4686736166,
-0.2617912889,
-0.4219568968,
-0.5159707069,
-0.3807284832,
-0.4387841523,
0.1366219223,
-0.9184581637,
0.478380084,
-0.144155249,
-0.3637805581,
0.1855494827,
-0.1145114675,
-0.6472691894,
0.2859213352,
0.114958398,
0.5867442489,
-0.302344203,
0.84521842,
0.7662870288,
-0.3693883419,
-0.2063423395,
0.08521837,
0.2639351487,
-0.4944098592,
0.5075766444,
0.2478285432,
-0.148204267,
0.1399627328,
-0.422753036,
-0.8783870935,
1.1541513205,
0.1120555773,
-0.6958906651,
0.0199133437,
-0.2652845979,
0.2467115372,
-0.1641623676,
0.2442443222,
0.8567225933,
0.5489819646,
0.3576890528,
-0.8156670332,
-0.308814615,
-0.6192370653,
-0.3442547321,
0.244151473,
-0.7186532617,
0.7922244668,
-0.3765544593,
-0.4298042059,
0.1059288904,
1.0496903658,
0.4296991825,
0.6229587793,
0.6889692545,
0.5444435477,
1.1338000298,
-0.1757439226,
1.1481593847,
-0.1420087814,
0.2057557702,
1.243191123,
-0.5783492923,
0.9353405237,
0.3790858984,
-0.2435879111,
0.3483009338,
0.9093984962,
-0.3064723015,
0.5070332885,
0.3087499142,
-0.3961362541,
-0.404469341,
-0.3210473955,
0.0828732029,
0.7982177734,
0.1396921873,
-0.0278858468,
0.0549041145,
0.4254632592,
-0.0654029995,
0.0111117903,
-0.3358290195,
1.0170066357,
-0.4242432714,
-0.8898788095,
0.0061143707,
0.2123339325,
0.485462606,
0.0900973305,
-0.1213343143,
0.365677923,
0.274176389,
-0.0873518139,
-1.1043288708,
0.2512022555,
-0.0092662238,
0.1254314631,
-0.1449261457,
0.6595493555,
0.1038392633,
-0.5793908238,
0.5514093041,
0.3365197182,
0.4448999465,
-0.2044298202,
-0.6691359282,
0.0315874517,
-0.2632167339,
-0.0723298192,
0.0921297967,
0.6372784376,
-0.4430113435,
0.7383838892,
0.2116161436,
-0.244914636,
0.4011339843,
0.2616179883,
0.6500585675,
-0.6224478483,
-0.5336717963,
-0.7102224827,
0.1998382211,
-0.2802421749,
0.1923015416,
0.4505722523,
0.9132688642,
1.071231246,
0.0426026322,
0.9228223562,
-0.433562845,
0.4411031008,
-0.9245128632,
0.1497313827,
-0.6859127879,
-0.0941806138,
-0.2388777137,
-0.8618083,
-0.4548475444,
0.5281224847,
-0.0485710539,
0.0747841746,
0.725886941,
0.3127192855,
0.0752156079,
0.7440297604,
0.2404183298,
-0.2268580198,
0.4478453696,
0.9731109142,
0.7582586408,
-0.5149422884,
0.6497578621,
-0.0305711422,
-0.2330204099,
-0.3992451727,
-0.7732008696,
-0.5449599028,
-0.6443908811,
-0.1356590539,
0.0389112644,
0.0631146953,
0.901871264,
0.9017111659,
-1.1746091843,
-0.2127043605,
-0.5041730404,
-0.1966460496,
-0.1926794797,
-0.1720919609,
0.0301058497,
-0.7180486321,
-0.9580003023,
0.6832770109,
0.2833271325,
-0.0528566204,
0.4508999884,
0.1002087519,
-0.608420372,
-0.4628047645,
0.6337772012,
0.1188410148,
-0.7032980919,
-0.1183912009,
-0.3170134127,
0.249764666,
0.2996282578,
0.9691585898,
-0.5399364233,
0.5148794651,
0.3714408278,
0.7142930031,
0.5785422325,
-0.1530098319,
0.7006351948,
-0.0753085613,
0.1619971544,
0.2908822894,
0.5854479074,
-0.1595352292,
-0.3260552883,
0.8176723719,
0.2483031601,
-0.6307533979,
-0.3305419087,
-0.0531406477,
-0.8725290298,
-0.5495868325,
0.498172611,
-0.2503461838,
-0.4298804104,
-0.6978379488,
-0.0001524849,
0.8399450183,
-0.5428954363,
0.6270218492,
0.7984980941,
-0.5908041,
-0.3081710041,
-1.0315304995,
0.3201247752,
0.1152026355,
-1.1774206161,
-0.298220396,
0.439237237,
-0.1266154945,
0.4252499342,
0.4543889761,
-0.2113434523,
0.4504647851,
-0.0235530809,
0.3031518757,
0.1491401047,
-0.6390436292,
0.1482236832,
0.6931019425,
-0.272166878,
-0.1908292472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04891v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04891v2 | In-Context Learning through the Bayesian Prism | 2023-06-08T02:38:23 | 2024-04-14T05:12:52 | Madhur Panwar, Kabir Ahuja, Navin Goyal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) is one of the surprising and useful features of
large language models and subject of intense research. Recently, stylized
meta-learning-like ICL setups have been devised that train transformers on
sequences of input-output pairs $(x, f(x))$. The function $f$ comes from a
function class and generalization is checked by evaluating on sequences
generated from unseen functions from the same class. One of the main
discoveries in this line of research has been that for several function
classes, such as linear regression, transformers successfully generalize to new
functions in the class. However, the inductive biases of these models resulting
in this behavior are not clearly understood. A model with unlimited training
data and compute is a Bayesian predictor: it learns the pretraining
distribution. In this paper we empirically examine how far this Bayesian
perspective can help us understand ICL. To this end, we generalize the previous
meta-ICL setup to hierarchical meta-ICL setup which involve unions of multiple
task families. We instantiate this setup on a diverse range of linear and
nonlinear function families and find that transformers can do ICL in this
setting as well. Where Bayesian inference is tractable, we find evidence that
high-capacity transformers mimic the Bayesian predictor. The Bayesian
perspective provides insights into the inductive bias of ICL and how
transformers perform a particular task when they are trained on multiple tasks.
We also find that transformers can learn to generalize to new function classes
that were not seen during pretraining. This involves deviation from the
Bayesian predictor. We examine these deviations in more depth offering new
insights and hypotheses. | [
-0.576556921,
-0.4626351595,
0.5979445577,
-0.1380111426,
0.0706244856,
-0.0930233747,
0.0122897904,
-0.1237273216,
-0.4807206988,
0.4801420569,
-0.8027279973,
-0.2863387167,
-0.6122390032,
-0.1786101907,
-0.3763237,
1.3940637112,
0.3215511739,
0.0822497904,
0.0193186831,
-0.0201568082,
-0.3433718383,
-0.4104504585,
-0.2624855936,
-0.5727258325,
0.4196351767,
0.4070141315,
0.6088777184,
0.1978806853,
0.4685179293,
0.180349946,
0.3951820433,
-0.2780717611,
-0.4825018048,
-0.1184014603,
-0.4272681475,
-0.608310163,
0.0054671345,
-0.0941351131,
0.8167002201,
1.2824513912,
-0.0866879374,
0.2139899433,
0.6812106371,
0.5206050277,
-0.98909235,
0.4760231972,
-0.9405826926,
0.1237279773,
-0.0333960094,
-0.1034095585,
-0.6676586866,
-0.0554827377,
0.5281544328,
-0.401709497,
0.441752702,
-0.2114389986,
0.5116739273,
0.4645104408,
-0.69394207,
-0.1469436884,
-1.0349959135,
0.7461029291,
-0.450011611,
0.3253442645,
0.3236066699,
0.534948647,
-0.0773422569,
-0.7101646662,
-0.4875023663,
-0.1208237335,
-0.406630367,
0.2076379508,
-0.0644491836,
0.3249480426,
0.5940555334,
0.0884472355,
-0.3523925841,
-0.0259356014,
-0.3073534966,
0.4480489194,
0.4539800882,
0.0631843805,
0.0316665433,
0.163417697,
-0.4249977171,
-0.3137071729,
-0.7699045539,
0.1875794977,
-0.0258720051,
0.2379922271,
-0.0898296162,
0.1184414998,
-0.0116975466,
0.6489677429,
0.242347002,
-0.2989755571,
0.1203966215,
0.193941474,
-0.333791703,
0.0612817407,
0.5634679794,
-0.156998232,
0.4470416307,
-0.3073616326,
-0.1789525747,
-0.1521121413,
0.3983522058,
-0.5533822775,
-0.263725251,
-0.1499403566,
-0.44123739,
-0.0728152916,
0.4085660279,
-0.6315883398,
-0.042329412,
-0.5237443447,
0.8784723878,
-0.3785030842,
-0.0947942063,
-0.0505290926,
0.0701483861,
0.2375475764,
0.0998558551,
-1.1290280819,
0.3775116503,
0.5226842165,
0.4509643614,
0.0512779169,
-0.4804191589,
-0.4786044955,
0.4737364054,
-0.392241627,
0.6169130206,
-0.5225080252,
-0.235303238,
0.2765269279,
0.0502276942,
-0.4177942574,
-0.7138838172,
-0.0898836702,
-0.3722663522,
-0.0319974385,
-0.0525553599,
-0.3247401118,
-0.2604280114,
-0.1154878214,
-0.3957019448,
0.737408638,
0.4952674806,
-0.8555622697,
0.977184236,
-0.6221507788,
-0.4007478058,
0.1114592254,
-0.2484607548,
-0.3712497652,
0.3500203788,
0.0428549349,
0.684853673,
-0.2367135137,
0.5892757177,
-0.5487506986,
-0.4471210837,
0.4797087014,
-0.5854539275,
0.7721216679,
0.129188776,
-0.8202518225,
-0.0539644025,
-0.7331169844,
-0.2735157311,
-0.4492956698,
-0.0814317688,
-0.3340767622,
0.2909890413,
-0.2157448381,
0.3807968199,
-0.2864060402,
-0.4379730225,
0.1714770794,
-0.3703229129,
0.2263142318,
0.7126680017,
-0.1136229187,
0.6724084616,
-0.2090856284,
0.4135039747,
0.1650106013,
0.2679404914,
-0.2355343699,
-0.1174141169,
-0.665877223,
-0.2015656531,
0.0728201568,
0.5454359055,
-0.715410471,
0.3551532328,
-0.1572234631,
-0.3295247853,
-0.4312222004,
-0.1877521873,
0.338537693,
0.6861813068,
0.5614155531,
-0.0347031578,
0.0970570892,
-1.1107920408,
-0.0847076923,
-0.0862564072,
-0.2923442721,
0.1681746691,
0.6001395583,
-0.4660295248,
1.0200023651,
-0.3568129539,
-0.1477762908,
-0.3367692232,
0.2899404764,
0.3814311922,
0.6110937595,
0.5151289701,
-0.6797602177,
-0.724409163,
0.0859053656,
-0.6918610334,
-0.1759548485,
-0.3962717652,
-0.0587558523,
0.0168668553,
0.5454866886,
-0.4236533344,
0.8260554075,
0.2412200123,
-0.0870767459,
0.5048853755,
-0.1901585907,
-0.3133573234,
-0.8559620976,
0.1195886582,
0.0646619499,
0.0755832195,
-0.7418290973,
-0.0986845195,
0.2114834189,
0.0773545504,
-0.1331991255,
0.3506017029,
-0.1895782202,
-0.333076179,
-0.3175034821,
-0.264113158,
-0.5217118859,
0.5825549364,
0.1213286966,
0.4504650533,
0.7465171218,
-0.7849295139,
-0.2789334059,
0.0888455361,
-0.4504756033,
0.4868908823,
-0.4572698474,
-0.3880695701,
-0.5056965947,
0.3296644986,
-1.1724826097,
-0.1225740835,
0.3590888679,
-0.1878180206,
0.4485904276,
-0.2474180609,
-0.5583263636,
-0.0943919942,
0.3015562296,
0.3934174776,
0.4808904827,
-0.8446104527,
0.4532173872,
0.2702901363,
0.1164651886,
-0.8541930318,
-0.72217834,
-0.4173142612,
-0.3872554302,
-0.1774318665,
0.5959885716,
-0.2250465751,
-0.3669237792,
-0.1728633493,
-0.0462502688,
-0.2123121917,
0.2257862985,
0.4388418496,
0.1872433275,
-0.1181784347,
0.3351507783,
0.3082420528,
-0.2962034941,
0.3163074851,
-0.2870451212,
0.4628586173,
-0.037984319,
-0.5039798021,
-0.4088223279,
0.3153254986,
0.4453318417,
0.0215729661,
0.709590137,
0.676537931,
-0.2827172577,
-0.5028294325,
-0.4684875011,
-0.4692096412,
-0.4410955608,
0.3071961105,
-0.3471514881,
-0.6461746097,
0.2188647538,
-0.030430438,
0.1931083202,
0.3496492803,
0.3463744521,
-0.0758326426,
1.2188805342,
0.8896970153,
-0.1039323509,
0.477884829,
-0.5199241638,
0.3265063763,
-0.7838773727,
-0.1515203416,
-0.2494736165,
-0.4846678376,
-0.7656085491,
0.0120578902,
0.6791928411,
0.03808349,
-0.5829461217,
0.1461016089,
-0.2122062743,
0.2877371907,
0.7439646125,
0.1148877665,
0.0063971123,
-0.0593004227,
-0.1837719828,
0.1091108993,
-0.8041604161,
-0.2262702137,
1.0683866739,
0.1662029475,
0.8966389298,
-0.1379741579,
0.5141332746,
-0.0989933312,
0.764288187,
-0.5738703609,
0.2740356326,
-0.0536359362,
-0.7117197514,
-0.1217954606,
-0.2162715495,
-0.9158416986,
0.5390307307,
-0.2429578602,
-0.8036199212,
0.3527222574,
0.2421575487,
-0.3622881174,
0.3827691078,
-0.4150161743,
0.8948277831,
-0.2063947916,
-0.5022131801,
-0.2437809855,
-1.1011428833,
0.4017875791,
-0.144255504,
0.1133365929,
0.1309736818,
0.1462829411,
0.2193829268,
-0.1083621979,
0.9876133204,
-0.2086590677,
0.1511134505,
-0.0166635215,
0.0786687657,
0.0062749241,
0.4024620354,
0.1338240802,
-0.0726140365,
0.1363739371,
-0.2618781626,
-0.6747744083,
0.2234679908,
-0.7701781392,
-0.4798395932,
-0.5508513451,
-0.7879422307,
-0.4371085167,
0.0154400161,
0.6697155833,
0.6547667384,
0.0220277589,
0.363494873,
0.828373909,
-0.3124914467,
0.6837175488,
0.555380702,
-0.1625514776,
-0.036438439,
0.4741909504,
0.2359212488,
0.4004600942,
0.7901672125,
0.1183316559,
0.0026075873,
-0.3136347532,
-0.2748274207,
0.1765994579,
-0.5220873952,
-0.0313126408,
-0.6017962694,
-0.3709743917,
-0.1368725598,
-0.3702957928,
0.0125950566,
-0.0480340496,
-0.2531147599,
-0.0161091592,
-0.5508869886,
0.8196591735,
-0.1199319437,
0.8156288266,
-0.5558568239,
-0.0223090313,
0.4101681113,
-0.0447083376,
0.2161426395,
-0.4951274097,
-0.3740691245,
0.1080521047,
-0.5944277048,
-0.750739634,
0.5505521894,
0.3432820141,
0.7983939052,
0.8860989213,
-0.0375214741,
0.6867669225,
-0.5991254449,
0.5048163533,
-0.0037106387,
-0.8898680806,
0.4481355548,
-0.2770790756,
0.4109245241,
0.5050282478,
0.8890768886,
-0.2302818745,
-0.2590628862,
-0.8891896605,
-0.4593850076,
0.7051969171,
-0.1959885508,
0.1095066741,
-0.0626978874,
0.5517085791,
0.4943246245,
0.4580281079,
-1.0438964367,
-0.1147510707,
-0.0387378596,
-0.248678267,
-0.3958323598,
-0.112536706,
0.0623344108,
-0.4851133227,
0.4198713601,
-0.4132534564,
0.3062688112,
-0.0829111934,
-0.3540528715,
-0.0163559057,
0.0764099509,
0.2133063823,
1.1776720285,
-0.1969056278,
0.144595176,
0.2771959007,
-0.0440707617,
-0.0775492564,
0.1184443235,
-0.1635989696,
-0.0422494188,
0.5617876053,
0.7441273928,
0.483278811,
-0.6505793929,
0.6508732438,
0.1298335642,
-0.1818335056,
-0.5517070293,
0.1418000609,
-0.311793685,
0.4000146091,
0.5692042708,
0.2134710252,
0.3909401298,
-0.9703148603,
0.3404339254,
0.7235146165,
-0.6871104836,
-0.6401465535,
0.5340238214,
-0.3380877972,
0.1003716365,
0.7717388868,
-0.0072952071,
-0.5191889405,
0.4192882478,
0.8892062902,
0.8841437697,
-0.4215092063,
0.3267623782,
0.4298596382,
0.2579083443,
0.0604556613,
-0.194839716,
-0.4532675147,
-0.7251936197,
-0.2945413888,
-0.7281460166,
-0.2173348069,
0.210912317,
-0.7543013096,
0.1743283421,
-0.3469529748,
0.0253623035,
-0.2155173123,
-0.3864620626,
-0.8680590391,
0.2354360819,
0.0877929181,
0.553201735,
-0.9097639918,
1.0877938271,
0.3179759681,
-0.282301724,
-0.6119482517,
0.4984537363,
-0.2723918855,
-0.6686165929,
1.1272699833,
0.4238634706,
0.1173927113,
-0.0399902686,
-0.5364229083,
-0.9602152705,
1.0239801407,
0.3355640173,
-0.4698429406,
-0.2641588748,
0.3553337753,
0.4837145209,
-0.7029198408,
0.4226654768,
0.6593923569,
0.1698025167,
-0.1748988479,
-0.6960453391,
-0.364942044,
0.0400128216,
0.0189492218,
0.305285126,
-0.3162602186,
1.0811070204,
-0.2158669531,
-0.0943723246,
-0.1436068267,
0.4366360903,
0.1449674666,
0.4075536132,
0.5257815719,
0.3410509825,
0.3401456475,
-0.004924017,
1.0349681377,
-0.3546391129,
0.260412246,
1.0296314955,
-0.0976311341,
0.8046421409,
0.3144743145,
-0.2165980488,
0.8034766316,
0.5487518907,
0.1031742096,
0.7635092735,
0.1972758174,
-0.4085512757,
-0.1971925348,
0.189969629,
-0.1314804256,
0.3311647177,
0.6498982906,
-0.6343307495,
-0.2392631918,
0.401899606,
-0.1327348053,
-0.2366975099,
-0.3532395363,
0.8195437193,
0.128998816,
-0.928901732,
0.1194642782,
-0.4760760069,
0.5048138499,
-0.7401996255,
-0.089710407,
0.0341461934,
0.5630999804,
-0.0706343204,
-0.643794179,
0.3416110873,
-0.5464599729,
-0.1654498279,
-0.2137705088,
0.5916228294,
-0.5143739581,
-0.446143508,
0.3842155933,
0.3870364428,
-0.0867920592,
-0.1506853104,
-0.5087153912,
-0.4498948753,
-0.1379854977,
0.0385058075,
0.6738787293,
0.3927702904,
0.1664552093,
0.7831035256,
0.2912069559,
-0.1357153356,
0.1304621398,
-0.148568511,
0.5399549007,
-0.3473715782,
-0.4844816327,
-0.8972218633,
0.6674362421,
0.2103939652,
-0.4108051658,
0.5021831989,
0.3305953145,
1.3793091774,
-0.323114574,
0.9153237939,
0.0135439988,
0.4320493937,
-0.3798843324,
0.4560925663,
-0.5415921807,
0.0557153635,
-0.5057427287,
-1.06118536,
-0.3927371204,
0.8511914015,
-0.5775713325,
0.0892443955,
0.8243609071,
0.670137465,
-0.3768852353,
-0.1294898838,
0.3761328757,
-0.0510345772,
0.282210201,
0.6515563726,
0.9653034806,
-0.1903461069,
0.2730005682,
-0.6060477495,
-0.495161742,
-0.2044512928,
-0.5503552556,
-0.9653996825,
-0.975251615,
-0.0364567153,
-0.0566509739,
0.0178436488,
0.9280263186,
0.8630489707,
-0.6529352665,
-0.7684147358,
-0.1984896064,
-0.0589603521,
-0.4315673411,
-0.2773270905,
0.2428435385,
-0.8287280798,
-0.647279799,
0.0997577459,
0.446562022,
-0.2333495021,
-0.2349521369,
0.1563410908,
-0.0851264298,
-0.1855846047,
0.8847988844,
-0.0015360912,
-0.5802979469,
-0.3313359022,
-0.373462081,
0.1626605392,
0.0532793254,
0.8564803004,
-1.0551918745,
0.2990734875,
0.4090436399,
0.5923622847,
0.6830447912,
-0.1568891704,
0.6562458277,
-0.3504807055,
-0.0205940939,
0.1802935302,
0.38436535,
0.0020959747,
-0.1496180147,
0.6376808286,
0.1806662232,
-0.8889059424,
-0.6661190391,
0.4451714754,
-0.6520838141,
-0.479403615,
0.8692057133,
-0.042092938,
0.0533714406,
-0.1220848709,
-0.0028801104,
0.1975416541,
0.0081714494,
0.9861520529,
0.4204018414,
-0.4461811781,
-0.1574350148,
-0.8723604679,
0.5882069468,
0.469335258,
-0.5919135809,
-0.0916925967,
0.2255981714,
0.3774722517,
0.0011914319,
0.2449170202,
0.1489955485,
0.263559401,
-0.2289586365,
-0.2489030361,
0.6422488689,
-0.7141361833,
-0.2631377876,
0.2506944537,
-0.1087977812,
0.0595233552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04874v1 | Expanding Scope: Adapting English Adversarial Attacks to Chinese | 2023-06-08T02:07:49 | 2023-06-08T02:07:49 | Hanyu Liu, Chengyuan Cai, Yanjun Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Recent studies have revealed that NLP predictive models are vulnerable to
adversarial attacks. Most existing studies focused on designing attacks to
evaluate the robustness of NLP models in the English language alone. Literature
has seen an increasing need for NLP solutions for other languages. We,
therefore, ask one natural question: whether state-of-the-art (SOTA) attack
methods generalize to other languages. This paper investigates how to adapt
SOTA adversarial attack algorithms in English to the Chinese language. Our
experiments show that attack methods previously applied to English NLP can
generate high-quality adversarial examples in Chinese when combined with proper
text segmentation and linguistic constraints. In addition, we demonstrate that
the generated adversarial examples can achieve high fluency and semantic
consistency by focusing on the Chinese language's morphology and phonology,
which in turn can be used to improve the adversarial robustness of Chinese NLP
models. | [
-0.0423680246,
-1.0007532835,
0.2317643762,
0.2423205227,
-0.0106149958,
-0.2533688247,
-0.2725728452,
-0.5892390013,
0.1820959151,
0.5940277576,
-0.3394778967,
-0.1312612444,
-0.4471335113,
0.0678924173,
-0.3125611842,
1.0727818012,
0.1044097543,
0.284494549,
0.5070403814,
-0.2126450241,
-0.4093254805,
-0.7421994209,
-1.0081802607,
-0.008371762,
0.324375391,
-0.1905575842,
1.2093946934,
0.4485437572,
0.6551875472,
0.2975981236,
-0.1284762025,
0.1092301533,
-0.3709492385,
-0.0307112038,
-0.2216441482,
-0.7328734398,
-0.3765055537,
-0.2570436299,
0.6571439505,
0.4534240365,
-0.023855919,
-0.4277499616,
0.0212883335,
0.4938817322,
-0.5528389215,
-0.3177797496,
-1.1690727472,
0.1872264296,
-0.3350757658,
-0.197372213,
-0.6152268648,
-0.0802302957,
0.2970646024,
-0.815058291,
-0.0374501497,
-0.094429858,
1.0759038925,
0.1416627765,
-0.1547911018,
-0.4919711649,
-0.6353067756,
0.5591056347,
-0.9597700238,
0.0042530186,
0.0784392506,
0.4840404987,
-0.545320034,
-0.7828997374,
-0.3392864168,
-0.4132553637,
-0.10974361,
0.1884924769,
-0.3843533993,
0.0375201888,
0.0970369503,
0.1616673023,
-0.8240355253,
0.226863116,
-0.1397785097,
-0.1540592015,
0.9429029226,
-0.0365898423,
0.9197506309,
0.0413175374,
-0.5976099968,
-0.2546341121,
-0.7036508322,
0.0687296838,
0.3339545727,
0.515158534,
0.0859075487,
0.0769225955,
0.4119404852,
0.6754951477,
-0.087275438,
0.0403127111,
-0.3080765307,
-0.3464237452,
-0.3248460293,
0.0924840271,
0.9250683784,
0.2225573212,
0.1437475383,
-0.124447979,
-0.2713052332,
-0.0210260563,
0.4585007727,
-0.3935339451,
-0.425775528,
0.1987873167,
-0.1797938794,
-0.2412750423,
0.1330802739,
-0.5874219537,
-0.6270340681,
0.4318336248,
0.6146308184,
-0.696628511,
-0.3177240491,
0.234060958,
-0.1660980284,
0.2771236002,
0.0512692071,
-1.1240278482,
0.2327268869,
0.7434187531,
0.6999365687,
-0.0895823836,
-0.6017757654,
-0.3292631209,
-0.0060127652,
-0.7057617903,
0.5667544603,
-0.1225474775,
-0.188791573,
0.2186024785,
0.1248172,
-0.2665661871,
-0.4377561212,
0.4743930697,
-0.8034439683,
0.2478497773,
-0.0113036362,
-0.2324294895,
-0.3772029877,
0.5130265355,
-0.8348354101,
0.4931554496,
-0.1734019518,
-0.9205184579,
0.028470939,
-0.7418801785,
-0.8261665106,
-0.1468011737,
0.1690157503,
-0.4949133992,
0.0564543754,
0.3601206541,
0.4299132824,
-0.1488351971,
0.1156027764,
-0.0054708659,
-0.0990722552,
0.22788091,
-0.5507801175,
1.2750816345,
0.3284201622,
-0.3757287264,
0.2168292701,
-0.5962574482,
-0.0457760841,
0.6681243181,
-0.073662065,
-0.6135690808,
0.0791921914,
0.0177335348,
-0.0764470771,
0.2592468262,
-0.2431872636,
0.0984326825,
-1.0910106897,
0.6056747437,
0.5169658065,
0.0633718818,
0.3934051394,
-0.1540721208,
0.4311823547,
-0.3299531341,
0.2340085059,
-0.1990082115,
-0.3069538176,
-0.5774602294,
0.132769689,
0.4049984515,
0.6146038175,
-1.0672017336,
0.1446024925,
-0.1124410257,
-0.6843698621,
-0.3697873056,
-0.2180211246,
0.3331373334,
0.0974051282,
0.2691346705,
-0.0719107091,
-0.6905990243,
-0.5822539926,
-0.5168765187,
-0.3078598678,
-0.159316957,
0.0539060198,
0.3460555971,
-0.0217875522,
0.4184162319,
-0.3124956191,
-0.2102338076,
-0.3624921441,
-0.2671743333,
-0.0406721942,
0.4548518956,
0.8551374674,
-1.1005535126,
-0.8431735039,
0.3236123025,
-0.6489900947,
0.3655661047,
-0.6538069844,
-0.1237072423,
0.0527112111,
0.4505455494,
-0.1573024243,
0.2553722262,
0.7896051407,
-0.1318783313,
0.3838840127,
-0.1872438043,
-0.0244783107,
-1.3268458843,
-0.3219899535,
-0.1899597049,
-0.1151046678,
-1.271720171,
0.7345065475,
-0.0110805817,
-0.150078088,
-0.7530645132,
0.367041409,
-0.1703715026,
0.0182905849,
-0.4594753981,
0.1396921128,
0.101128906,
0.3210327327,
0.1276919693,
0.5548198223,
0.7179436684,
-0.7724515796,
0.3273841143,
-0.0129926801,
0.0138937151,
0.2333680838,
-0.674515903,
0.0297484156,
0.1583121121,
0.1277097762,
-0.7709786892,
-0.0092633869,
0.1898534,
-0.5845304728,
0.477899462,
0.1349837333,
-0.0760645196,
0.0840612277,
-0.4809340239,
0.0007817324,
0.3235543668,
-0.8388767242,
0.7054412961,
0.335722506,
0.119240351,
-0.7673613429,
-0.8855706453,
0.3737567961,
-0.220497027,
-0.7364464998,
0.4621238112,
0.0817976668,
-0.2434928119,
-0.2140816748,
0.2483300269,
-0.2215487212,
0.7190780044,
-0.2093102634,
0.0956652239,
-0.566862762,
-0.4131284654,
-0.3892139494,
0.0827732086,
0.122273393,
-0.4544147551,
0.6693976521,
0.1306506544,
-0.3517213166,
-0.3577251434,
0.263050288,
0.3522586524,
-0.2020188123,
0.7465139031,
0.4752059579,
-0.6838282943,
-0.423514694,
0.0529293492,
-0.262091428,
-0.4929195642,
0.9472946525,
-0.5290499926,
-0.4726094007,
0.3535878062,
0.2957761288,
0.5768555999,
0.5975282788,
0.4955841303,
0.1069943011,
1.1603872776,
0.7327130437,
-0.4005283117,
0.4839991331,
-0.1199524179,
0.2339828312,
-0.433738023,
0.29084903,
-0.471612215,
-0.0170371421,
-0.7461092472,
0.0655453652,
0.0357624143,
-0.1158423424,
0.1303427517,
0.8261659741,
-0.4243613183,
0.3373077214,
0.3875574172,
-0.0015298958,
-0.0722981319,
-0.0076434636,
0.1202827916,
-0.0104768071,
-0.8931095004,
-0.300157696,
0.8935305476,
0.4532198012,
0.5691062808,
0.2482999861,
0.3462590873,
0.1310186088,
0.0921583474,
-0.6313180327,
0.3818742037,
-0.6855317354,
-0.5562101007,
-0.4541735053,
-0.0269103162,
-1.1828432083,
0.3322557807,
-0.2548969388,
-0.5046406388,
-0.1357260197,
-0.0742447749,
-0.4734322727,
0.5535581112,
-0.5232442617,
0.8474055529,
-0.39335832,
0.1959392279,
0.1010702699,
-0.3791210651,
0.3566688299,
-0.2329895645,
0.2807989419,
0.3638551533,
0.2062314898,
0.8008771539,
-0.3132406175,
0.7497354746,
-0.1209869012,
-0.4111126959,
0.3491871953,
-0.0241886694,
0.5825091004,
-0.1281220615,
-0.1124383435,
0.2113316208,
-0.0090716854,
-0.5584097505,
-0.9471136928,
0.3610794246,
-0.7805280685,
-0.8764612079,
-0.2872278392,
-0.4660783112,
0.0181100629,
0.1624485999,
0.4892112315,
0.0931749046,
-0.4240525663,
-0.016162755,
0.5626141429,
-0.3440381885,
0.4673062265,
0.6377090812,
-0.0601598881,
-0.3072952032,
0.9822876453,
0.1829680353,
0.5145233274,
0.6388496757,
0.4158947468,
0.0340657942,
-0.8654335141,
-0.6573303342,
-0.1969415694,
-0.6281579137,
0.0440975577,
-0.4012034535,
-0.5069417953,
-0.6127315164,
-0.356356591,
-0.463888675,
-0.2209140211,
0.0028076062,
0.0006178307,
0.1709170341,
0.4993524849,
0.0740332827,
0.4107115567,
-0.628152132,
0.3413996994,
0.3390797973,
-0.4012996554,
-0.0257740654,
-0.7735511661,
-0.4932173193,
0.2365498841,
-0.2520793676,
-0.9193763733,
0.4425378144,
0.3047193587,
0.4350640774,
0.3077058196,
0.2245439142,
0.4673640132,
-0.6279371977,
0.9828462005,
0.0413274914,
-0.6609148979,
0.6718180776,
-0.0622633547,
0.1304652542,
0.2563996613,
0.3968245089,
-0.4605707824,
-0.5104413629,
-0.6592799425,
-0.5427582264,
0.6418201923,
0.1063298583,
0.2616009712,
0.2869744897,
0.4035141468,
-0.1196112186,
-0.3999949098,
-0.9786441326,
-0.4707257152,
-0.44358024,
-0.1613100618,
-0.0001558828,
-0.0992459878,
-0.1100337133,
0.4941398203,
0.7168524265,
-0.1190009937,
-0.1632852405,
0.2458627671,
-0.069337979,
0.2365333736,
0.2649201453,
0.4826509058,
0.255730629,
0.2139625847,
0.0331842378,
0.4771101475,
-0.7593550682,
0.1314897537,
0.1837179959,
-0.7835742831,
0.0269155186,
0.5602692962,
0.6701853275,
-0.0386810228,
-0.519256413,
0.5235041976,
-0.3234096766,
-0.1770768762,
-0.301538825,
0.0588923581,
-0.1278799027,
0.1869993657,
0.2510341704,
0.075886108,
0.1496690661,
-0.646528244,
0.2177654058,
0.7553815246,
-0.5226423144,
-0.4559906423,
0.5941442847,
-0.0334893204,
-0.4742874205,
-0.0827363059,
-0.0576709062,
-0.9577980042,
0.7195379734,
0.9263791442,
0.8652656078,
-0.5888301134,
-0.1554369926,
0.099597767,
0.7041927576,
-0.0309022777,
0.1266005486,
0.4605302811,
-0.9363759756,
-0.1793388575,
-0.1250572801,
-0.4342512488,
0.2557906508,
-0.6348412037,
0.2532771826,
-1.0124950409,
0.0018267501,
0.0266444497,
-0.0231267791,
-0.0704197288,
0.5811181664,
0.2462152839,
0.7360920906,
-0.8098442554,
0.7667850256,
0.9679713249,
-0.2916168571,
-0.9070801735,
0.233052671,
-0.0782971829,
-0.9833040833,
0.2272606641,
-0.0767366886,
0.0297544356,
-0.2707017064,
-0.3726673722,
-0.7467594743,
0.6924576163,
0.4171144664,
-0.2234909981,
0.0013056332,
0.1845568568,
0.5957962871,
-0.1629693508,
-0.0513736755,
0.6464640498,
0.2849237621,
-0.4161865711,
-0.7324590683,
0.1117688417,
-0.1382028162,
-0.0665462539,
-0.1112224683,
-0.8985421658,
0.9265546203,
0.0225612577,
-0.485532701,
0.1168904155,
1.0459858179,
0.1045124531,
0.2842872143,
0.5713222027,
0.199370414,
0.5906103849,
0.0015652326,
0.9397314191,
-0.2825249135,
-0.1135668978,
0.8579306006,
-0.1259068996,
0.9120506644,
-0.0020734447,
-0.2291029841,
0.3338141441,
0.5263084769,
-0.2378846109,
0.5410907865,
0.1824794263,
0.1367071569,
0.3429597318,
-0.1555616856,
-0.4144874811,
0.5056272149,
0.3700868785,
-0.1119439006,
0.0685983971,
0.1681330204,
0.4511702061,
0.5972467065,
-0.4203406572,
0.8748351336,
-0.1197218969,
-0.5479777455,
0.9516473413,
0.3125246167,
1.0260378122,
-0.8797902465,
0.3031092584,
-0.0237820484,
0.1559468806,
-0.3099414408,
-0.3395054936,
0.2672078907,
-0.0198659357,
0.0376202799,
0.2216978818,
0.6752753258,
-0.212772429,
-0.4275012314,
0.4127634168,
-0.0623998158,
0.1129262224,
-0.1287954003,
-0.8881313205,
-0.1789270937,
0.36842978,
-0.1783356816,
0.5461063981,
0.3946808875,
-0.0156907197,
0.5067340732,
0.5109540224,
0.4836587906,
0.1217981875,
0.0073668323,
0.642382741,
-0.5696800351,
-0.574154675,
-1.115695715,
0.1984143704,
0.0330907889,
-0.1890902519,
1.1044329405,
0.2134254128,
1.0907635689,
0.1609957665,
1.0771297216,
0.2284903675,
0.2650264502,
-0.8549978137,
0.9156101942,
-0.6740038991,
0.1714394391,
-0.311260581,
-0.5468617082,
-0.480949074,
0.5005431175,
0.0231769867,
-0.2290352881,
0.7422882318,
0.7495689392,
0.3486621678,
0.1098117009,
0.5690647364,
0.3642211556,
0.5576657653,
0.8654723763,
0.7588552237,
-0.9420586824,
0.8396518826,
-0.3388062119,
-0.1836950332,
-0.1009081379,
-0.7015991211,
-0.9842197895,
-0.3430341482,
-0.169906199,
-0.4047156572,
0.3345471323,
0.4392187893,
0.5453339219,
-1.1261678934,
-0.0088812876,
0.0668121874,
0.0766633227,
-0.4148034453,
-0.1935738623,
0.7996045351,
-0.4091873765,
-0.8721506,
0.6903868318,
0.1932342798,
0.1934244037,
-0.4185744822,
0.0032885326,
-0.1558236778,
0.1994993538,
0.2638248503,
0.5327415466,
-0.757683754,
-0.2030322701,
0.1587221473,
-0.2299764156,
-0.0502991714,
0.6387432218,
-0.1898787022,
0.3545906246,
0.3247461617,
1.1907849312,
-0.1887274981,
-0.1151613444,
0.9032934308,
-0.6366932392,
0.2565912902,
0.2807872891,
0.5359850526,
0.4324390292,
-0.4993744493,
0.3932971656,
-0.0479026102,
-0.2416884452,
-0.7937541008,
0.3594523072,
-0.3648681641,
-0.6438896656,
0.9939467311,
-0.665988028,
-0.4783294797,
-0.1908105463,
-0.3001073897,
0.0824218318,
0.1739099473,
0.6492878199,
0.5501981378,
0.375069499,
0.2553416789,
-0.4048007727,
0.7463532686,
0.761395514,
-0.6098492742,
0.0966041908,
-0.2791003287,
-0.1596846431,
0.4044507742,
0.3463971615,
-0.0507029779,
0.5038471222,
0.357457459,
-0.231642127,
0.2133038044,
-0.2223599404,
-0.4812378585,
0.2153095752,
0.2485425174,
-0.0737360939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04845v1 | Mixture-of-Supernets: Improving Weight-Sharing Supernet Training with Architecture-Routed Mixture-of-Experts | 2023-06-08T00:35:36 | 2023-06-08T00:35:36 | Ganesh Jawahar, Haichuan Yang, Yunyang Xiong, Zechun Liu, Dilin Wang, Fei Sun, Meng Li, Aasish Pappu, Barlas Oguz, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan, Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi, Vikas Chandra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Weight-sharing supernet has become a vital component for performance
estimation in the state-of-the-art (SOTA) neural architecture search (NAS)
frameworks. Although supernet can directly generate different subnetworks
without retraining, there is no guarantee for the quality of these subnetworks
because of weight sharing. In NLP tasks such as machine translation and
pre-trained language modeling, we observe that given the same model
architecture, there is a large performance gap between supernet and training
from scratch. Hence, supernet cannot be directly used and retraining is
necessary after finding the optimal architectures.
In this work, we propose mixture-of-supernets, a generalized supernet
formulation where mixture-of-experts (MoE) is adopted to enhance the expressive
power of the supernet model, with negligible training overhead. In this way,
different subnetworks do not share the model weights directly, but through an
architecture-based routing mechanism. As a result, model weights of different
subnetworks are customized towards their specific architectures and the weight
generation is learned by gradient descent. Compared to existing weight-sharing
supernet for NLP, our method can minimize the retraining time, greatly
improving training efficiency. In addition, the proposed method achieves the
SOTA performance in NAS for building fast machine translation models, yielding
better latency-BLEU tradeoff compared to HAT, state-of-the-art NAS for MT. We
also achieve the SOTA performance in NAS for building memory-efficient
task-agnostic BERT models, outperforming NAS-BERT and AutoDistil in various
model sizes. | [
-0.4752893448,
-0.2243163437,
0.0984115303,
0.2843244076,
-0.2734155953,
0.1406367123,
0.0358085558,
-0.3269726932,
0.939217031,
0.2770244777,
-0.4338901937,
0.0546459071,
-0.881318152,
-0.0781334564,
-0.5775244832,
0.8209771514,
0.1881849617,
0.3913462758,
-0.0835285038,
-0.2448481619,
-0.2839215398,
-0.6374102831,
-0.636376977,
-0.4654729366,
0.4106657207,
0.0477816798,
0.693374157,
0.5276976824,
0.2370971143,
0.3194711208,
-0.273073554,
0.5235711336,
-0.3503278494,
0.0866206884,
-0.2833130062,
-0.527120769,
-0.6830604076,
-0.330208987,
0.5703165531,
0.5485975742,
-0.5413112044,
-0.0760937855,
-0.0806000233,
0.7865195274,
-0.6871671677,
-0.1799506396,
-0.6573342681,
0.249257803,
-0.2877053618,
-0.3433817625,
-0.0697250813,
0.1363554597,
0.3539758325,
-0.6366724968,
0.1259899437,
0.4651743472,
0.7660340667,
0.3223602176,
0.0412159227,
0.0429207608,
-0.4084120691,
0.8350192904,
-0.7606503963,
0.4069615006,
0.2175980657,
0.374869436,
-0.2100558132,
-0.5178880095,
-0.6392341256,
-0.1719774455,
0.1765207797,
0.3290541172,
-0.1473528296,
-0.0784682259,
-0.3027078509,
0.5063630342,
-0.5517430305,
0.1365066022,
-0.2462682128,
-0.0130478814,
0.689362824,
0.1083275005,
0.489969641,
0.2183186412,
-0.4545823932,
0.1719439626,
-0.6583092809,
-0.5429397225,
0.4511749148,
0.0734868348,
0.0473912135,
0.2193372548,
-0.3575461209,
0.6095814705,
0.2243659943,
0.1624076515,
0.3356497586,
-0.2935035229,
-0.272816807,
0.0187557675,
0.6886893511,
0.2643375695,
0.1448382288,
-0.4799932539,
-0.4400808513,
-0.3548902571,
0.3266770542,
-0.4946055412,
-0.2492256016,
-0.0097873779,
-0.6242675781,
-0.1473697275,
-0.2312825918,
-0.3953135312,
-0.3027012944,
-0.334600836,
0.5557736754,
-0.3405926824,
-0.6764523387,
0.4305954576,
-0.1796539575,
-0.051652573,
0.1030893549,
-1.1751445532,
0.6306958795,
0.6351184249,
0.9036732316,
-0.1159898117,
-0.4548331499,
-0.3956589401,
-0.0655576214,
-0.3992898762,
0.4140301347,
-0.3826285601,
-0.1935817599,
-0.3926494122,
-0.6149794459,
-0.2652175128,
-0.9374483228,
0.0157225821,
-0.8687592745,
0.040142145,
-0.0625349507,
-0.5990354419,
-0.1119015291,
0.3322208822,
-0.5650003552,
1.2290010452,
0.037227653,
-0.8164094687,
0.1003540084,
-0.4540550411,
-0.3376088738,
0.1818203032,
-0.4389286935,
-0.0601837263,
0.3075039089,
0.1908738315,
0.7236585617,
-0.4392053783,
0.6893345118,
0.1763074547,
-0.4152695835,
-0.0096996306,
-0.0767530724,
0.7224351168,
0.1971107274,
-0.4927904606,
0.0341980308,
-0.7076740265,
-0.3240830302,
-0.0012087519,
-0.4427663982,
-0.4525574446,
0.0732129589,
0.0330506414,
0.2719411552,
0.3416090012,
-0.4658166468,
0.1514951289,
-0.4360074997,
0.3371120095,
0.7822519541,
-0.3520044088,
0.4898321927,
-0.3544574976,
0.5506449938,
0.1599702537,
0.0925581753,
0.3340014815,
-0.5963085294,
-0.8278059363,
-0.023881061,
0.654959023,
0.4885362387,
-1.1862589121,
0.6608886719,
-0.4295947254,
-0.6282628775,
-0.6200141907,
0.0690050572,
0.6073715091,
0.479270041,
0.6685271263,
-0.5357760787,
-0.7474547029,
-0.9529220462,
0.0429489277,
0.1829939038,
0.002690949,
0.4522939622,
0.4581928849,
-0.0072640888,
0.7206763625,
-0.3028477132,
-0.0177010763,
-0.637146771,
0.1235508323,
0.0200915765,
0.7740724087,
0.6176507473,
-1.0735212564,
-0.536934495,
0.1454221904,
-0.6629513502,
0.0290297698,
0.1060200334,
-0.1889458001,
-0.2614381611,
0.6143918037,
-0.2581525743,
0.0602833517,
0.7521719337,
0.195128575,
0.830121994,
-0.2805589736,
-0.1870939881,
-1.1584277153,
0.0046325065,
0.0867873132,
-0.0361461975,
-0.5407643318,
0.6266701221,
-0.3128677607,
0.1006888896,
-0.600741148,
0.3595370054,
-0.3009464145,
-0.2306193262,
-0.109761402,
-0.1015238166,
-0.001155848,
0.6110966802,
-0.0502952449,
0.981333673,
1.0895751715,
-0.6761115789,
0.2052379996,
-0.1771030426,
-0.2680751085,
0.5270512104,
-0.7654351592,
-0.0366324224,
-0.1341203451,
0.5777126551,
-0.6565918326,
0.0272035468,
0.3504715562,
-0.3581202626,
0.237144053,
-0.0567321144,
-0.3842226863,
0.1157904565,
0.0168644041,
0.5517524481,
0.2078571767,
-0.2779746354,
0.910564661,
0.3732881546,
-0.0329415314,
-0.8972703218,
-1.0647021532,
0.3550920188,
0.090751119,
-0.7334256768,
0.7640956044,
-0.0653449148,
0.3326154053,
0.0167283397,
-0.3458276093,
-0.2531244755,
0.1752023995,
-0.0231399219,
0.0275966059,
-0.3522689044,
-0.0068009542,
0.2033001781,
-0.3248146772,
-0.2308326513,
-0.8476593494,
0.892180562,
-0.0678169504,
-0.1950232536,
-0.5510460138,
0.7198203802,
0.3278489411,
-0.3939412832,
1.1488274336,
0.6789704561,
-0.2644393444,
-0.2072703093,
-0.5487390161,
0.0155552123,
-0.4233454764,
0.4655242562,
-0.2909449935,
-1.0323168039,
0.4912770689,
-0.0174069051,
0.0119235301,
0.3873980343,
0.481842041,
-0.0540152639,
0.7708716989,
0.480238229,
-0.3403742909,
0.5538444519,
-0.6356152296,
0.0812030211,
-1.0619374514,
-0.2616345286,
-0.4059084654,
-0.8609102964,
-0.4002135694,
-0.4043332636,
0.4478785694,
-0.1013236567,
-0.0175039954,
0.4400997162,
-0.2408812493,
0.4762842357,
0.8249081373,
0.2650936842,
-0.0274596941,
0.0449324101,
-0.4975675941,
0.311227262,
-1.1922631264,
-0.0803349093,
1.0348771811,
0.069886066,
0.3394165039,
0.0281463657,
0.9569765329,
0.2624023557,
0.1008917019,
-0.4113956988,
0.7434104085,
-0.5297712684,
-0.6999094486,
-0.0761751607,
-0.791011095,
-0.6875262856,
0.4465304613,
-0.2208982259,
-0.6297993064,
0.3342834413,
0.2162130028,
-0.6977764964,
0.4673393369,
-0.4036545753,
0.3991809487,
-0.1024089456,
0.0473052822,
-0.3378947079,
-0.9049021602,
0.0627258867,
0.2050059885,
-0.0826412663,
0.3759585619,
0.0149626834,
0.8135734797,
-0.575525105,
0.5411671996,
-0.0556551032,
0.2074988484,
0.1454293579,
0.0072447257,
0.2586546242,
-0.3084471524,
-0.303907752,
0.503852725,
-0.6353788972,
-0.5183379054,
-0.7618002892,
0.4301340878,
-1.0755931139,
-0.3313105702,
0.2087915987,
-0.4570518434,
-0.0013679091,
0.0749541,
0.4377110898,
0.8705759048,
0.3020665646,
0.5095642209,
0.8224133253,
-0.007414287,
0.2200593501,
0.1989726275,
-0.0351445861,
-0.3241308928,
1.1960502863,
0.4987872541,
0.1339667737,
0.7582042813,
0.3935856223,
-0.0819090083,
-1.0830749273,
-0.5746062994,
-0.3832041025,
-0.2068314552,
-0.1584371775,
-0.828795433,
-0.3439411819,
-0.2800272703,
-0.1129723936,
-0.7245951891,
-0.4180321097,
-0.2240568399,
-0.0770675614,
-0.1575325429,
0.433357507,
-0.1797857732,
0.8455685377,
-0.6526474357,
0.2452903688,
0.3555338979,
0.2263780534,
0.5862865448,
-0.5426822901,
-0.7256629467,
-0.0916525647,
-0.1497617215,
-0.5949761868,
0.2788816094,
0.1765752137,
0.7049534321,
0.1893494725,
-0.279071182,
0.5495393872,
-0.373386085,
0.783818543,
0.3897211552,
-0.8045752048,
0.062980704,
-0.2513157129,
-0.2249214798,
0.6386315823,
0.5326696038,
-0.3545503318,
-0.1643763334,
-0.7268968225,
-1.1164591312,
0.5806996822,
0.2382555902,
0.137349233,
0.1248069108,
0.2427006513,
0.0521152392,
0.5187570453,
-0.3324015737,
-0.4729936719,
-0.1825235784,
-0.1500790119,
0.2902983427,
0.0883911252,
-0.0477933027,
-0.2243054956,
0.790818572,
0.1004906446,
0.0000085253,
0.1903782189,
-0.0794550627,
0.1438066959,
-0.0066490476,
0.5345879793,
0.6859745979,
-0.2561943829,
0.1499213278,
0.1202589497,
-0.4332340062,
0.1725028455,
-0.151439324,
-0.3316178322,
-0.0729596913,
0.1138877124,
0.8037344813,
0.3124626875,
-0.4036730826,
0.492025584,
-0.0015917238,
-0.4355354309,
0.4372923076,
0.3969091475,
0.2679541707,
0.3200572431,
0.5398659706,
0.6113972068,
0.331795305,
-0.1661489606,
0.3033948839,
0.043649219,
-0.0582501031,
-0.2291970551,
0.4002511501,
0.288826108,
-0.5228420496,
0.331037879,
-0.3864373565,
-0.7031732202,
0.5716984272,
0.3626699746,
0.9089103341,
-0.2118158638,
0.1461221576,
-0.2609465718,
0.1777014881,
-0.3607711196,
0.2095157206,
-0.1076978594,
-0.9440104365,
-0.6402571797,
-0.6466193795,
-0.3287272453,
-0.0317081288,
-0.628793776,
-0.3934084177,
-0.5482738614,
-0.099720709,
-0.2974081039,
-0.052207239,
-0.487020731,
0.5433812141,
0.0709965006,
0.9672757387,
-0.8236388564,
0.5798230767,
0.9384166002,
-0.2215459347,
-1.0283448696,
-0.0414969772,
-0.2227568477,
-0.7638340592,
0.5821276307,
-0.0995382518,
-0.2852517366,
0.1394410431,
-0.458607614,
-0.7320882678,
0.9698877335,
0.3917464614,
-0.5643633604,
-0.0966387242,
-0.1345733553,
0.5145166516,
-0.4950799346,
0.5453208089,
0.2487675697,
0.1343766302,
0.0489145741,
-0.8164442778,
-0.2224479914,
-0.4261055887,
0.1997646689,
-0.2103063613,
-0.9098553658,
1.092492342,
0.5268577933,
0.154951781,
-0.12963292,
0.9270651937,
0.4197715521,
0.1776762456,
0.6694677472,
0.8591223955,
0.6005197763,
0.3905222714,
0.9207210541,
-0.3932604492,
0.1527519822,
1.1375505924,
-0.0691377595,
0.9055575728,
0.3356588483,
-0.0253118072,
0.5955272913,
0.4015907645,
0.4435707629,
0.5917176604,
0.4598526061,
-0.0670025349,
-0.3872503638,
-0.2454829365,
-0.7253465652,
0.4219674766,
0.1756950319,
-0.3479297757,
-0.2747463882,
-0.3523139954,
-0.0603383072,
-0.0773904026,
-0.3329798877,
0.4022942185,
0.0310396198,
-0.432915628,
0.4498823285,
0.1848367751,
1.1676893234,
-0.6268204451,
0.2635660172,
-0.508248508,
-0.2110419124,
-0.2088181823,
-0.3534075618,
0.306641221,
-0.2328435779,
-0.2584545314,
-0.2941739857,
0.5758095384,
-0.2114494443,
-0.3482902646,
0.3263898194,
0.7241584063,
0.2880160213,
-0.2554624379,
-0.9099701047,
-0.0667711869,
-0.2489727587,
-0.3007408082,
0.7334209085,
0.4245803058,
0.219007954,
0.7426425815,
0.6481550932,
0.3572027981,
0.4189254344,
0.167785123,
1.081610918,
-0.1243862957,
-0.8294522762,
-0.7870618105,
0.4364013672,
-0.0152055882,
-0.5505570769,
0.3029195964,
0.369056344,
0.8722593188,
0.0440422446,
0.5983245969,
-0.0899606794,
0.0106995348,
-0.5456705093,
0.8340173364,
-0.986754179,
0.0293120183,
-0.1155415773,
-0.8506979942,
-0.13760221,
0.472496599,
-0.0438757092,
0.1592316478,
0.2477930933,
0.9156811833,
-0.3745350838,
0.0410718732,
0.357640028,
0.0204173718,
0.1719478369,
0.4081924558,
0.6006788611,
-0.4968052804,
0.3673280776,
-0.0775121599,
-0.3015966415,
-0.5795028806,
-0.8506754041,
-0.3304291368,
-0.3766707182,
-0.2481964827,
0.1446184069,
0.190346837,
0.9704887271,
1.269780755,
-0.6283858418,
-0.2069488466,
-0.3096788824,
0.0355646573,
-0.521728754,
-0.1552194506,
0.2898488045,
-0.0675030053,
-0.4440096915,
0.7393410206,
0.5608963966,
-0.3218409121,
-0.6453792453,
-0.1956887096,
-0.4580424428,
0.1386037469,
0.2539342344,
0.0348457694,
-0.4111755192,
0.120214045,
-0.0616806224,
-0.0339290798,
-0.022240933,
0.6501284242,
-0.5356416702,
0.3327772021,
0.731597662,
1.2411203384,
0.1874579191,
-0.0168597493,
0.586558938,
-1.1093038321,
-0.041894488,
0.2794199884,
0.4896747172,
0.2146234065,
-0.2709043324,
0.3892505467,
0.3722939491,
-0.4973698556,
-0.4158098102,
0.0990091562,
-0.8414521217,
-0.0052195871,
0.7609061003,
-0.4370462,
-0.2009948641,
-0.2377236933,
-0.0846225247,
0.2183869481,
-0.4435374439,
0.6707951427,
0.4953095317,
0.0122806691,
0.1154393405,
-0.4943911433,
-0.0853919759,
1.0178561211,
-0.4240891337,
-0.3781709373,
-0.0757248104,
0.0802032351,
0.3683938384,
0.8141425848,
0.3162959218,
-0.0037252305,
0.0658429563,
0.0650211647,
-0.3598564863,
-0.9005706906,
0.0805946589,
0.242563799,
-0.4740888178,
-0.485714674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04841v1 | Improving Vietnamese Legal Question--Answering System based on Automatic Data Enrichment | 2023-06-08T00:24:29 | 2023-06-08T00:24:29 | Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong, Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Quang-Huy Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen, Xuan-Hieu Phan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering (QA) in law is a challenging problem because legal
documents are much more complicated than normal texts in terms of terminology,
structure, and temporal and logical relationships. It is even more difficult to
perform legal QA for low-resource languages like Vietnamese where labeled data
are rare and pre-trained language models are still limited. In this paper, we
try to overcome these limitations by implementing a Vietnamese article-level
retrieval-based legal QA system and introduce a novel method to improve the
performance of language models by improving data quality through weak labeling.
Our hypothesis is that in contexts where labeled data are limited, efficient
data enrichment can help increase overall performance. Our experiments are
designed to test multiple aspects, which demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed technique. | [
-0.2069527656,
-1.0061349869,
0.7088320851,
-0.2565224469,
-0.776758194,
0.0293280873,
0.0597607493,
-0.4489453733,
0.1623885632,
0.782743454,
0.0311396476,
-0.5251853466,
-0.5241485834,
0.2728073895,
-0.405788362,
0.9183967113,
0.0631765947,
0.103736639,
-0.2755280137,
-0.6236381531,
-0.6661427617,
-0.4707832932,
-0.3588759303,
0.1196233481,
0.1743837148,
0.5200446248,
1.0072063208,
1.0137745142,
0.6544962525,
0.2943066657,
-0.3121984601,
0.2374861836,
-0.616750896,
0.0796215683,
-0.1719581634,
-0.6257364154,
-0.4725077152,
-0.2719591558,
0.5503706336,
0.4064041376,
-0.077556923,
0.1829568595,
-0.3326646984,
0.5150206089,
-0.7317029834,
0.0514287427,
-0.5952333808,
-0.2045315653,
0.0007472957,
-0.1899928749,
-0.0517882109,
-0.5676925182,
0.1482582837,
-0.687096715,
0.0225606449,
-0.3159612417,
1.13729918,
0.5553781986,
-0.6062242985,
-0.1422452331,
-0.7900734544,
0.4773286581,
-0.9014216065,
0.3128522038,
0.5046033859,
0.193458274,
0.2531039119,
-0.5240691304,
-0.5752859712,
-0.2751484215,
-0.1622555554,
0.1253188252,
-0.1691647321,
0.1428394616,
0.2785452604,
0.2076029927,
-0.6747919917,
0.0216835458,
-0.6088331342,
-0.119636029,
0.8099692464,
0.0821390301,
0.4020217657,
-0.2206406593,
0.1074540913,
0.1078590751,
-0.5780407786,
0.2140869051,
0.3321377039,
0.369359076,
0.3934898973,
0.9570682645,
-0.4845513105,
0.7832349539,
-0.0965981334,
-0.0513911657,
0.4863955081,
-0.4701804519,
-0.1835687757,
-0.0310756583,
0.504833281,
0.1134345308,
-0.0200493224,
0.0546636134,
-0.5357196927,
-0.3203582168,
0.1791578382,
-0.5907818079,
0.1240279526,
0.6878429055,
-0.5890762806,
-0.1434380114,
0.4890832603,
-0.6796301603,
-0.319904685,
-0.4189321995,
0.6430287361,
-0.2982925177,
-0.1786683351,
0.2343125194,
-0.1679830551,
0.2977031469,
0.267541647,
-0.2732566595,
0.1486883312,
0.6144115925,
0.3418051004,
0.1085401773,
0.2064898908,
-1.365429759,
0.1770884246,
-0.2488666028,
0.7288510203,
-0.8338828087,
-0.3197469711,
0.2214400917,
0.0565022044,
0.2926852703,
-1.0987946987,
0.6655261517,
-0.8539831042,
0.1157139912,
0.0354176015,
-0.7665973306,
0.0708978996,
0.1163163483,
-0.8057860136,
1.082542181,
0.3895582557,
-0.6287499666,
0.3045861721,
-0.5604888797,
-0.4440999925,
0.4260886312,
-0.0757276937,
-0.6307881474,
-0.0175730493,
0.4304839969,
0.0965356678,
-0.0936255306,
0.4493059814,
-0.0053607873,
-0.5866776109,
0.2242741138,
-0.0113795223,
1.0203510523,
0.5336680412,
-0.2028919607,
0.038299039,
-0.9701193571,
0.1791395098,
-0.0471721776,
-0.7989105582,
-0.5765575171,
-0.3234728277,
-0.329993844,
0.1436337531,
0.3773040771,
-0.5761059523,
0.2770889401,
-0.4030435979,
0.0484691001,
0.2409665734,
0.2626051009,
0.3985292315,
-0.1873676181,
0.7608811855,
0.2569073737,
0.0730695128,
0.0617102087,
-0.5657140017,
-0.9153517485,
-0.175380379,
0.6424751878,
1.0820636749,
-1.1643971205,
0.5768103004,
-0.3754686415,
-0.2700916529,
-1.3082011938,
0.470649153,
0.2699159682,
0.460316956,
0.7541427612,
-0.1610395014,
-0.6091141105,
-0.9066747427,
-0.4012998044,
-0.4761527181,
-0.1744865328,
0.4219872355,
0.3548021317,
-0.2943531573,
0.9484891891,
-0.5416716933,
-0.0385526977,
-0.3374575973,
0.2403544188,
0.3101160228,
0.3220798969,
0.255037576,
-0.9233313799,
-0.4051588178,
-0.063003853,
-0.7600845098,
-0.5173996091,
0.0188088771,
-0.0597121455,
-0.2149354666,
0.4584424198,
-0.4666284621,
0.5569392443,
-0.158016324,
-0.5373902321,
0.4567928016,
-0.369356513,
0.2542504668,
-0.7647022009,
-0.2044743896,
-0.1499429047,
-0.2479027212,
-0.8401972651,
0.1359849423,
0.2172977477,
-0.2787955403,
-0.80061692,
0.3689012229,
-0.2621363997,
0.1381367296,
-0.5441729426,
0.1359863728,
0.0657385364,
0.0978886336,
0.0051212497,
0.7164842486,
0.4404219091,
-0.63951689,
0.4710690081,
0.3347567022,
-0.0134463655,
0.8483000398,
-0.6125668883,
0.0221692454,
-0.5441313386,
-0.1491654813,
-0.4528870285,
-0.0211762264,
0.1617026925,
-0.0385801494,
0.2046734691,
-0.4150933921,
-0.4614833593,
-0.3186382651,
-0.0993319601,
0.5214750171,
0.5227555633,
-0.3082329631,
0.3598106205,
0.5301439762,
-0.2991410792,
-0.5669471025,
-0.4560562372,
0.2022535652,
-0.5078083277,
-0.4090817869,
-0.0232349075,
0.2166751921,
-0.5278573036,
0.3395394087,
0.2402748615,
-0.618766427,
-0.0725688785,
-0.2878955305,
0.0870943666,
-0.5757763982,
0.632922411,
0.3292093873,
0.0661992431,
-0.0313808806,
-0.3225895464,
0.0614528656,
-0.063400507,
-0.0330429003,
-0.7632926702,
0.4965191483,
0.2192805856,
-0.7242328525,
0.5680617094,
0.2678945363,
-0.2532723248,
0.0873622075,
-0.6508846879,
-0.0137153147,
-0.451546073,
0.3369810581,
-0.3479243219,
-0.9088785648,
0.2281697243,
0.2090872526,
-0.2578058243,
0.533385098,
0.3025657833,
-0.1300847828,
0.6866239905,
0.5480275154,
-0.1372959614,
0.4247596562,
-0.063717857,
-0.0549393259,
-0.2989433408,
0.0195814911,
-0.7694216967,
0.0874548927,
-0.8568776846,
-0.5999273062,
0.339902848,
0.017061362,
-0.1089894623,
0.4628136754,
-0.4241119623,
0.5530260205,
0.7046750784,
0.2209924608,
0.6827235818,
-0.3155848086,
0.1772326082,
0.223936677,
-0.6796300411,
-0.7425640225,
1.2490501404,
0.2003458291,
0.6539209485,
-0.0441894978,
1.0029404163,
0.2303566933,
0.0040549082,
-0.5382241011,
0.4442271888,
-0.2252177,
-0.505636394,
-0.5740199685,
-0.7846425772,
-1.0520911217,
0.1401398033,
-0.2563842833,
-0.4449535012,
0.5170170665,
-0.1032935902,
-0.5162528753,
-0.0051413556,
-0.6448638439,
0.6959840059,
-0.335496068,
-0.416003257,
0.1280361563,
-0.664583385,
0.1850390583,
-0.0732465684,
0.1096388772,
0.0277456194,
-0.1611671299,
0.9290258288,
-0.9168868661,
0.2842062414,
-0.480543524,
-0.3930238783,
0.9346838593,
-0.2970830202,
0.688201189,
0.4622889459,
-0.0950727537,
-0.4956347346,
0.2040310353,
-0.627764523,
-0.8154653311,
0.1803518534,
-0.612744689,
-0.6385913491,
-0.0687095597,
-0.6856530309,
-0.2712991536,
0.3568966985,
-0.1099033132,
-0.141051814,
0.0694428459,
0.2312831581,
0.8359841704,
-0.4039542377,
-0.1604016721,
0.7975348234,
0.1126923189,
-0.3030226827,
1.1946414709,
0.5063511729,
-0.1878931969,
0.5056988597,
0.1551941633,
-0.54811728,
-0.6044852734,
-0.0964749083,
0.3184867203,
-0.6587741971,
-0.2970250845,
-0.8696718216,
-0.2716407776,
-0.4389857948,
0.3280971646,
-0.1598822474,
-0.8035173416,
-0.4041618407,
-0.2631638646,
0.2489669025,
0.6687466502,
0.1358847171,
0.1280719638,
-0.9993078113,
0.8012244701,
0.7199158072,
0.3765798509,
-0.5276987553,
-0.6415042281,
-0.1474802196,
0.1013154611,
-0.0650968179,
-0.9603366852,
0.0463242605,
0.072943069,
0.4175084233,
0.405597955,
0.3222648203,
0.6830021739,
-0.2199415714,
0.4681760371,
-0.4825682938,
-0.8133824468,
0.988160193,
-0.3576364517,
0.3716148138,
0.7976562977,
0.081319198,
-0.1205588058,
-1.0684150457,
-0.7658953667,
-0.8520384431,
0.4659537375,
0.4989849329,
0.1550578028,
0.2676057816,
0.7213404179,
0.1462761909,
0.2473282218,
-0.5545564294,
0.0446577929,
-0.2958379984,
-0.184514448,
0.1033584625,
-0.3712956905,
0.0031536501,
-0.4093551636,
0.6893491745,
0.0255312398,
-0.0054163961,
0.1088371947,
-0.2968132794,
0.0276815463,
0.7042536736,
0.383100003,
0.6646030545,
-0.2532178164,
0.209337458,
0.2441686541,
-0.3725147545,
0.7000374794,
0.3409246504,
-0.5448172688,
0.1010913402,
0.2040133178,
0.4422216415,
-0.5176016688,
-0.9704782963,
0.3467925489,
-0.1136414409,
-0.091261223,
0.2698797882,
0.232185483,
-0.0450687259,
0.3376648426,
0.5817289948,
-0.7117350698,
0.2589357793,
-0.4330878556,
0.6785972118,
0.1123169139,
-0.3567961752,
0.3027693033,
0.6766170859,
0.0930257887,
-0.1672632247,
0.6864307523,
-0.277209729,
-0.2718716264,
0.8539178967,
0.2979247868,
0.4609899819,
-0.0277494807,
0.5174033642,
0.3226085901,
0.4868934453,
-0.0511482768,
0.8960511684,
0.1774407774,
-0.3413345218,
-0.3755976856,
-0.326946944,
-0.2239398658,
0.2658952773,
-0.7354056835,
0.1307931244,
0.0621433817,
-0.1545700878,
-0.4890426397,
0.1675890982,
-0.6345884204,
0.5389066339,
-0.3283054829,
0.6783503294,
-0.6615825891,
0.7881342769,
0.7464353442,
-0.6672954559,
-0.5440769196,
-0.1381042749,
-0.3427307308,
-0.395734489,
0.6508587003,
-0.0607624613,
0.2745352685,
-0.0992193893,
-0.6659476757,
-0.6415768266,
0.7721052766,
0.4914509356,
-0.272166878,
0.2343448102,
0.7172519565,
1.0405060053,
-0.2517566979,
-0.0169089604,
0.8670959473,
0.5463914275,
-0.2054670155,
-0.611382544,
0.1298382133,
-0.4805788696,
0.0024779474,
-0.0914911479,
-0.3423773646,
0.4414924383,
-0.1086999103,
-0.1555346251,
0.1344742626,
0.9845172167,
0.0935331136,
0.3409027755,
0.375893116,
0.6806938648,
0.9863080978,
-0.1662666351,
0.7584007978,
-0.1854534,
0.2903154194,
1.2362003326,
-0.2847079039,
0.7565995455,
0.5606291294,
0.0103865825,
0.2106441557,
0.5109724402,
-0.2844677567,
0.1870845854,
0.338149637,
-0.1020526662,
-0.3291902244,
-0.5457258821,
-0.3481531441,
0.5344929695,
0.0788042843,
-0.2952415049,
-0.1252998114,
0.1082209423,
-0.3114500344,
0.1076151952,
-0.1593742669,
1.1041609049,
-0.3050397933,
-0.6117277741,
0.6203475595,
0.0299192816,
0.1980915517,
-0.1808866858,
-0.1503826231,
-0.606028378,
-0.3621840477,
-0.2249855846,
-0.8106684089,
0.2018790245,
0.3681250215,
0.1906855702,
0.0525247119,
0.6200988889,
-0.6863204837,
-0.5698210001,
0.1819095165,
0.9282978177,
0.2066743225,
-0.0242690779,
-0.6994642019,
-0.2164248526,
-0.4305954874,
-0.0097257374,
-0.063944526,
0.7372473478,
0.0432902165,
0.6595150828,
0.3906049132,
0.2928273678,
0.2794751823,
-0.0530886427,
1.0193027258,
-0.7087837458,
-0.6741350293,
-0.3969771564,
0.5833967328,
-0.153370738,
-0.1020501405,
0.4144849181,
0.904661417,
0.765158236,
0.1032677367,
0.823207736,
0.0058038263,
0.5372856259,
-0.7069343925,
0.6140885353,
-0.6860403419,
0.5644369721,
-0.2705660462,
-0.9997631907,
-0.3193063438,
0.2349639833,
-0.1952842325,
-0.1200309098,
0.5040316582,
0.8812400103,
-0.13910532,
-0.4111025631,
0.4564554691,
0.2583443224,
0.3396691978,
0.4474272132,
0.837582767,
-0.5038133264,
0.9928939342,
-0.3988382816,
-0.0494658351,
-0.1632135808,
-0.1898455024,
-0.6276665926,
-0.3573020995,
-0.4076392055,
-0.5058410168,
0.3099757135,
0.6414666176,
0.3357473612,
-0.9874598384,
-0.2782204747,
0.15510194,
0.2404350638,
-0.2506605387,
-0.3251347542,
0.6389420033,
-0.5686146617,
-0.7159921527,
0.4335033894,
0.1790132374,
0.2576765418,
0.138286978,
-0.0743729547,
-0.5582818389,
0.105106771,
0.444069773,
0.4173181355,
-0.2715755701,
-0.1466681212,
-0.1766385436,
-0.2931948602,
0.463104099,
0.8994710445,
-0.6694205999,
0.790412426,
0.7568791509,
1.0543860197,
0.2062597573,
0.5763782263,
0.6279912591,
-0.5934044123,
0.0644243285,
0.5251010656,
0.2982011735,
0.0204111524,
-0.4728128314,
0.649964273,
0.1088242158,
-0.3950697184,
-0.7598662972,
0.1260286123,
-0.6144234538,
-0.3994067907,
1.0700826645,
-0.1544330865,
-0.2015365213,
-0.6901878715,
-0.3514931798,
0.4695617557,
-0.4857497215,
1.038212657,
0.6170974374,
-0.0965672806,
-0.1639987677,
-0.6750824451,
0.4797125161,
0.5342580676,
-1.2512238026,
-0.1244435385,
0.5848106742,
0.07462468,
0.0659248009,
0.6990665793,
-0.1618091911,
0.6149693131,
-0.3369949162,
-0.4338591099,
0.028340932,
-0.1444429308,
-0.5485087037,
0.3613053262,
-0.0384321027,
0.036293149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04823v1 | Data Augmentation for Improving Tail-traffic Robustness in Skill-routing for Dialogue Systems | 2023-06-07T23:07:23 | 2023-06-07T23:07:23 | Ting-Wei Wu, Fatemeh Sheikholeslami, Mohammad Kachuee, Jaeyoung Do, Sungjin Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale conversational systems typically rely on a skill-routing
component to route a user request to an appropriate skill and interpretation to
serve the request. In such system, the agent is responsible for serving
thousands of skills and interpretations which create a long-tail distribution
due to the natural frequency of requests. For example, the samples related to
play music might be a thousand times more frequent than those asking for
theatre show times. Moreover, inputs used for ML-based skill routing are often
a heterogeneous mix of strings, embedding vectors, categorical and scalar
features which makes employing augmentation-based long-tail learning approaches
challenging. To improve the skill-routing robustness, we propose an
augmentation of heterogeneous skill-routing data and training targeted for
robust operation in long-tail data regimes. We explore a variety of conditional
encoder-decoder generative frameworks to perturb original data fields and
create synthetic training data. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed method, we conduct extensive experiments using real-world data from a
commercial conversational system. Based on the experiment results, the proposed
approach improves more than 80% (51 out of 63) of intents with less than 10K of
traffic instances in the skill-routing replication task. | [
-0.3239222765,
-1.0260857344,
0.2607717216,
0.2953052819,
-0.2780815065,
0.26023525,
-0.2992075682,
-0.5270161033,
0.3550370336,
0.686468184,
-0.7511504889,
-0.3036321104,
-0.1613068581,
0.0163187645,
-0.3669788241,
0.8068404198,
0.5547832847,
-0.0479255244,
-0.2039365619,
-0.2123863101,
-0.7360266447,
-0.6873816848,
-1.046921134,
-0.1307689995,
0.3706595302,
0.2601151764,
1.0094311237,
0.5928977728,
0.1990707368,
0.3673655093,
0.0110795107,
0.3772107959,
-0.5665568113,
0.4517029524,
-0.2366582751,
-0.4325066805,
-0.6060412526,
-0.6033354402,
0.9615035057,
1.169254899,
-0.2319834828,
-0.4396202564,
0.0488877259,
0.6583066583,
-0.5556418896,
0.1293033063,
-0.693148911,
-0.0213239416,
-0.1990253776,
-0.5126923919,
-0.26234743,
-0.2294397503,
0.2052749246,
-0.7927288413,
0.2597124279,
0.211199373,
0.7428053021,
0.3416162729,
-0.2669152617,
0.0005011753,
-0.7244797349,
0.7338101268,
-0.5522957444,
0.7012187243,
0.5016060472,
0.4193508625,
-0.241013661,
-0.4017574787,
-0.5118665695,
-0.0571201555,
-0.0694526434,
0.2667913735,
0.0246118866,
0.3209430873,
0.521959126,
0.2283622324,
-0.5166043639,
0.3740528822,
-0.1956225485,
-0.301963985,
0.8418281674,
0.3827064037,
0.0307035614,
0.2973144948,
-0.1781934202,
-0.4079871178,
-0.8240534067,
0.1877878308,
0.9365385771,
0.4506700635,
-0.0906170905,
0.454333514,
-0.7245998383,
1.0300806761,
0.3823698759,
-0.112101227,
0.5911388397,
-0.4184209108,
0.0090573914,
0.1368895024,
0.5733363628,
0.3234004676,
0.0606879257,
-0.4267864525,
-0.2891023457,
-0.1593894958,
0.3804636598,
-0.666593194,
-0.2004989535,
0.186594978,
-0.165520221,
-0.3425176144,
0.0797605291,
-1.0164425373,
-0.2027354091,
-0.2764936984,
0.3913631439,
-0.5923813581,
-0.3359537721,
0.3221246004,
-0.079196386,
0.4104529023,
0.3422560394,
-1.0547673702,
0.3713359833,
0.7506291866,
0.8344815969,
-0.2857147157,
-0.223407492,
-1.0548549891,
0.0532884002,
-0.3797819316,
0.476113677,
-0.7695060372,
-0.4100674689,
0.2470143884,
0.2328778505,
-0.0841077566,
-0.5754878521,
0.6402583122,
-0.668815434,
-0.0028175546,
-0.0487300307,
-0.3401710689,
-0.0671087652,
0.1339234859,
-0.6778103709,
0.7737711668,
0.232519269,
-0.4693486691,
0.333027631,
-0.599481523,
-0.9969133139,
-0.0160365365,
0.1130921692,
-0.6267262697,
-0.1902656555,
0.3873354197,
0.2918097079,
0.1362690181,
-0.0541938469,
-0.3872968853,
-0.5254402161,
0.2324977368,
-0.8325458765,
0.753066361,
0.1642977744,
-0.1193847358,
-0.0898632407,
-0.8645172119,
0.0221655089,
-0.171722278,
-0.203460291,
-0.3698368371,
0.1925838888,
-0.0515085272,
-0.0277260803,
-0.1186111495,
-0.5094865561,
0.1706348509,
-0.856358707,
0.1295356005,
0.7425243855,
0.0786917135,
0.5706013441,
-0.5538600087,
0.5373752713,
0.269510299,
0.1197540089,
-0.3645026088,
-0.4470897317,
-0.9423584342,
-0.0993822739,
0.1508997381,
0.4684815109,
-1.1063008308,
0.5834600329,
-0.5751087666,
-0.212065056,
-0.5081982017,
-0.0048338324,
-0.0058601121,
0.6230720878,
0.4280245602,
-0.5445141792,
-0.5550252199,
-0.5959046483,
0.0891857296,
0.0704945028,
0.0153490007,
0.2050823122,
-0.06355194,
-0.2041705847,
1.0608065128,
-0.5396031141,
-0.1274556667,
0.0495056584,
0.0554901101,
0.1200008392,
0.8011173606,
0.4063009024,
-0.8533478975,
-0.4149412811,
0.0094897458,
-0.3886731863,
-0.0612384863,
-0.4256126881,
-0.3077390492,
0.1638489515,
0.2810811698,
-0.4675915241,
0.4246259034,
0.4438881874,
-0.1114997119,
0.6084222794,
-0.114616096,
0.1238169298,
-0.749075532,
-0.1588794142,
-0.0409156792,
-0.3435132802,
-0.8727456927,
-0.2444353104,
-0.323038578,
-0.21990107,
-0.1158118993,
0.0600176863,
-0.2023442537,
-0.0971040055,
-0.1744265556,
-0.2469800115,
0.0114864307,
0.5738996267,
0.3584681749,
0.9330210686,
1.0766333342,
-0.7377995849,
0.466321677,
0.1807058007,
-0.1501070857,
1.0397884846,
-0.5399286747,
0.2609680891,
-0.1400123984,
0.1864251792,
-0.797403872,
-0.3123814762,
0.2629688978,
-0.3268873096,
0.2419512123,
-0.6039842367,
-0.4374158382,
-0.0114164725,
-0.0700303018,
0.2860551775,
0.8287178278,
-0.599296391,
0.6429466009,
0.0793635771,
-0.1925983727,
-0.415735513,
-0.5628724098,
0.1165086478,
-0.4671916664,
-0.8872314692,
0.4046643376,
-0.0049015526,
0.2114758641,
-0.3170512915,
0.0400391296,
-0.2312485725,
0.1777335107,
0.3192980289,
0.20737876,
-0.0318516195,
0.180160895,
0.2678597271,
-0.1400895566,
0.2500697374,
-0.4206487834,
0.6676748395,
0.152559489,
-0.8243032694,
-0.2998225987,
0.5496236682,
0.5211184025,
-0.3269117177,
0.7884175181,
0.8524693847,
0.0316076092,
-0.2928062677,
-0.5709710121,
-0.5048578978,
-0.626054883,
0.3277452886,
-0.341335088,
-0.7925799489,
0.3438006043,
-0.1231533885,
-0.0599868037,
0.108306624,
0.1441170424,
-0.3703607917,
1.2504614592,
0.3965218067,
-0.2008368373,
0.5757340193,
-0.2997502685,
0.2480998486,
-0.5357949138,
-0.1417825818,
-0.248968631,
0.1127194241,
-0.8072796464,
-0.3686404824,
0.688953042,
-0.3323110342,
-0.2427642792,
-0.0176566895,
-0.1865777969,
0.0265839379,
0.5264186263,
0.3783466816,
0.3980256617,
0.4917281568,
0.3628213704,
0.2719019055,
-1.0374269485,
-0.0610244088,
0.9477300048,
0.311756134,
0.9735203981,
0.100252226,
0.4764746726,
0.3863370717,
-0.1394089758,
-0.7546287775,
0.5217240453,
-0.0333185196,
-0.0766728446,
-0.4721652567,
-0.6246587038,
-0.9394657016,
0.0428893901,
-0.5240972042,
-0.4793331027,
0.4344305396,
0.4305630922,
-0.3601562381,
0.2816798389,
-0.6024128795,
0.4267284274,
-0.274386853,
-0.6371638179,
-0.2391190231,
-0.7630864382,
0.0760026649,
-0.119207181,
-0.0716851503,
0.3333584368,
0.254136622,
0.3810116351,
-0.6738004088,
0.9233759046,
-0.256377846,
-0.1741339266,
0.2429762483,
-0.2180309594,
1.0211740732,
-0.1369118094,
-0.1728138179,
0.0941719562,
-0.2214635015,
-0.3289055228,
-0.8708809018,
0.4451894462,
-0.5292922258,
-0.4501059651,
-0.1551683098,
-0.3324215114,
-0.6818208098,
-0.1913060397,
0.1032607406,
0.6891806722,
0.0608029403,
0.4260228574,
0.8216949701,
-0.0895211101,
0.197727859,
0.3440173566,
0.1585550308,
-0.2199926376,
1.292619586,
-0.0648064539,
0.6434993148,
0.1851109415,
-0.0782363042,
-0.4580014944,
-0.7289095521,
-0.4962336719,
-0.2242029011,
-0.3352297544,
-0.0973574594,
-0.5373623967,
-0.4882874787,
-0.2701610923,
-0.0361574925,
-0.4720684588,
-0.251393497,
-0.2662224174,
-0.0164831802,
0.6471199393,
0.0559968166,
-0.3068360686,
0.6929551363,
-0.5687898993,
0.0980421826,
0.4919558167,
0.5624787807,
0.1498620808,
-0.4792060554,
-0.6237365603,
0.5039847493,
-0.1310077161,
-0.5493998528,
0.2988852262,
0.3905765712,
0.4314411879,
0.6910116076,
0.0557447933,
0.844642818,
-0.4067544937,
0.6167162657,
0.248375535,
-0.6035585999,
0.4910822511,
-0.5160196424,
0.0757008344,
0.4398874938,
0.2043462098,
-0.4360063076,
-0.3490521908,
-0.5416703224,
-0.8442625999,
0.5661142468,
0.4628276825,
0.397365272,
0.1873311549,
0.1388370097,
0.07974834,
0.221523717,
-0.2745132446,
-0.1859325916,
-0.6667366028,
-0.1082538292,
0.0419364013,
0.0125333453,
-0.0724834576,
-0.2426733971,
0.4929852784,
-0.3435972035,
0.1817077994,
-0.0313472562,
0.041332256,
0.0053582531,
0.2398842573,
0.2984203696,
0.4776208699,
-0.2629844248,
-0.0399258733,
0.3023462892,
-0.5901437998,
0.2576555312,
0.3063996732,
-0.3330778778,
-0.0714428425,
0.1997306049,
0.9560642242,
-0.2750203907,
-0.7142509222,
0.3934819698,
0.3926064372,
-0.0979656577,
-0.4063721299,
0.4656432569,
-0.4687010944,
0.1014020815,
0.4021601677,
-0.0515422486,
0.384568423,
-0.4463165998,
0.1757865995,
0.5226331949,
-0.3895075321,
-0.3015400469,
0.2291706502,
0.3996576071,
-0.2346808314,
0.6270245314,
-0.2867576778,
-0.4146438539,
0.3497927189,
0.5073850155,
0.7844907045,
-0.1476970464,
0.1050996035,
0.2879165113,
0.0964947268,
-0.0977969542,
0.106771633,
-0.165142715,
-0.7666670084,
-0.683917582,
-0.4498276711,
-0.368270129,
0.0714401528,
-0.6354143023,
0.0600816309,
-0.2314775288,
-0.2654938698,
-0.4547792375,
-0.3431815207,
-0.8412042856,
0.2897374928,
-0.0743462443,
0.4790271819,
-0.8548278809,
0.6931766272,
0.5928711295,
-0.3318587542,
-0.5333344936,
-0.0570686683,
-0.4391293824,
-0.4703115821,
0.4743834734,
-0.1458538622,
-0.3244234025,
0.0617159568,
-0.5571926832,
-0.6779993773,
0.8488858938,
0.013368818,
-0.7563937902,
0.0059519331,
0.6209952831,
0.5157747865,
-0.3328673244,
0.1516027004,
0.4024500847,
0.3958543241,
0.1925183684,
-0.7480698228,
-0.0595307872,
0.0032604188,
0.0339653492,
0.0207123831,
-0.6406572461,
0.3728054464,
0.1424594969,
-0.2110759765,
0.1105054766,
0.6819519401,
0.0877850726,
0.2999121547,
1.069422245,
0.5811411738,
0.6641459465,
-0.1655874401,
0.6409823298,
-0.1227735952,
-0.0219621696,
1.047606349,
-0.1864356399,
0.5445654392,
0.4684710205,
-0.138954103,
0.5791916847,
0.4144580364,
0.1030726284,
0.8427445292,
0.1916517615,
-0.4983017743,
-0.5253646374,
-0.0925442278,
-0.2939141989,
0.6159852147,
0.5044795275,
-0.1449847966,
-0.0686134622,
0.3601408601,
-0.1215652004,
-0.1677521169,
-0.2031269521,
0.8464099169,
-0.2082357854,
-0.8190128207,
0.6417334676,
-0.19233419,
0.7590972185,
-0.7552345395,
-0.454274863,
-0.3084397018,
-0.2124427408,
-0.2571054697,
-0.8726935387,
0.3611295521,
-0.1033023745,
0.0786754563,
-0.1829676926,
0.741037488,
-0.5500926375,
-0.3197295368,
-0.1515992284,
0.4389485121,
-0.0247216504,
-0.0539831594,
-0.3780508637,
0.1449198425,
-0.1192311496,
0.1775839776,
0.302701354,
0.4228104651,
0.0733470246,
0.854190886,
1.0437322855,
0.1599954367,
0.0593208745,
0.2966447771,
1.129154563,
-0.4745609462,
-0.7316876054,
-0.4283044934,
0.6566553712,
-0.5548209548,
-0.0254465267,
0.6639893055,
0.5272834897,
0.7797722816,
0.0556713752,
0.8025153279,
0.1060983613,
0.382684797,
-0.8802933097,
0.5517587066,
-0.3806140125,
0.5603898168,
-0.1875115186,
-0.7812520862,
0.2337286621,
0.6028476954,
-0.2466806173,
0.0947500467,
0.0913310274,
1.1602318287,
-0.399310708,
0.0587181076,
0.3011342585,
-0.0750628784,
0.2950435579,
0.4839124084,
1.0388063192,
-0.2071464509,
0.3666622639,
-0.421225518,
0.0383673161,
-0.4328457117,
-0.7413143516,
-0.7679007649,
-0.6065920591,
-0.3539911509,
-0.5099624395,
0.5252690911,
0.7104878426,
1.0286688805,
-0.5238941908,
-0.1903330833,
-0.1831361502,
0.1651228815,
-0.5835732818,
-0.320831418,
0.3185253143,
-0.4953252971,
-0.5889664292,
0.5767899156,
0.1245585531,
0.1409130991,
-0.4740297496,
-0.1330896467,
0.2926374972,
-0.0132524734,
0.7086382508,
0.3984158039,
-0.1825156808,
-0.5489282012,
-0.0942367762,
0.3294905126,
0.3126573563,
0.5311920047,
-0.9483496547,
0.7956547737,
0.2454437315,
0.679166317,
0.589150548,
0.3830738366,
0.7706511021,
-0.789911449,
0.2457621396,
0.3677324057,
0.1247779801,
0.4689531326,
-0.4108074307,
0.4032981694,
0.2904911339,
-0.2906247973,
-0.707867384,
0.2311806977,
-1.2627152205,
0.3018055558,
1.1681572199,
0.0345780775,
-0.0525137335,
-0.4836788177,
-0.162675038,
0.0325837582,
-0.4958508611,
0.5627823472,
0.1839945167,
-0.0909682736,
-0.2450597733,
-0.5508161187,
0.5864932537,
0.4259245396,
-0.8549901247,
-0.2201572061,
0.7026929855,
0.2538788915,
-0.0718609393,
0.4649892449,
0.2299168855,
0.3105071485,
0.0211525913,
-0.4122575819,
-0.2169515491,
-0.2671220303,
-0.1632377952,
0.1243748069,
-0.0602203868,
-0.313506484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04820v1 | Good Data, Large Data, or No Data? Comparing Three Approaches in Developing Research Aspect Classifiers for Biomedical Papers | 2023-06-07T22:56:53 | 2023-06-07T22:56:53 | Shreya Chandrasekhar, Chieh-Yang Huang, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid growth of scientific publications, particularly during the COVID-19
pandemic, emphasizes the need for tools to help researchers efficiently
comprehend the latest advancements. One essential part of understanding
scientific literature is research aspect classification, which categorizes
sentences in abstracts to Background, Purpose, Method, and Finding. In this
study, we investigate the impact of different datasets on model performance for
the crowd-annotated CODA-19 research aspect classification task. Specifically,
we explore the potential benefits of using the large, automatically curated
PubMed 200K RCT dataset and evaluate the effectiveness of large language models
(LLMs), such as LLaMA, GPT-3, ChatGPT, and GPT-4. Our results indicate that
using the PubMed 200K RCT dataset does not improve performance for the CODA-19
task. We also observe that while GPT-4 performs well, it does not outperform
the SciBERT model fine-tuned on the CODA-19 dataset, emphasizing the importance
of a dedicated and task-aligned datasets dataset for the target task. Our code
is available at https://github.com/Crowd-AI-Lab/CODA-19-exp. | [
-0.2476175129,
-0.5519695282,
0.6617546678,
0.2086743414,
-0.299093008,
0.001425244,
-0.1288836598,
-0.7777240276,
0.2086167783,
0.4103783369,
0.0956824124,
-0.4468309283,
-0.6523417234,
0.2976926267,
-0.6352699995,
1.5084394217,
0.0747810304,
0.2787602246,
-0.5915699005,
-0.0226531159,
0.010216374,
-0.8690145612,
-0.543736577,
-0.4501307905,
0.7931959033,
0.2707620561,
0.602763176,
0.6506075859,
0.8501814604,
0.2219645828,
-0.115869306,
0.212443307,
-0.349844873,
0.0939327627,
-0.2531964481,
-0.273170799,
-0.4771400094,
0.1728854924,
0.2228504121,
0.4814279974,
0.1240989789,
0.2074186504,
-0.0309018753,
0.4713686109,
-0.2648734152,
0.4138852656,
-0.1261014193,
-0.0983209163,
-0.4276346564,
-0.126819402,
-0.1980409026,
-0.1130423769,
0.4137046039,
-0.6428350806,
0.5571082234,
0.1484576166,
0.9905797243,
0.0358532183,
-0.2860927284,
-0.2160803825,
-0.6222878695,
0.5174071789,
-0.7028929591,
0.0596614368,
0.588355124,
-0.0436341427,
-0.2467822284,
-0.5400602221,
-0.3772405684,
-0.0572449975,
0.0802173316,
0.0199289378,
-0.1888249218,
0.2639457881,
0.1903701276,
0.485011369,
-0.6150206923,
0.2069594711,
-0.8972290754,
-0.1724451631,
0.8680718541,
0.0659769177,
-0.0433572941,
-0.5112364888,
-0.0698780119,
-0.1612932086,
-0.5483525991,
0.0015830037,
0.128925398,
0.4107097983,
-0.1505271047,
0.558155179,
-0.3280444145,
0.6801003218,
0.0756861046,
-0.0400340408,
0.4973952174,
-0.4529469311,
0.0201217867,
-0.1872880906,
0.7749437094,
0.0538857318,
-0.1957437694,
-0.1670036316,
-0.0910961106,
-0.3643934131,
0.3687932193,
-0.830978632,
-0.5143616199,
0.3700832427,
-0.5229640603,
-0.2725006342,
0.1620263904,
-0.6519162655,
-0.582659781,
-0.4491536319,
0.403855443,
-0.482400924,
-0.1241279691,
0.0000428918,
-0.1458262056,
0.1010755971,
0.6923976541,
-0.4179980457,
0.1516109556,
1.0473716259,
1.1846542358,
-0.4915738106,
-0.101239793,
-0.50126791,
-0.1508000046,
-0.2863746285,
0.9216861129,
-0.7258470654,
-0.3446414471,
-0.3484041691,
0.0026160274,
-0.1156981438,
-0.405333668,
0.6274346113,
-0.3311172128,
0.333349973,
-0.5333595872,
-0.6386990547,
-0.4995695353,
0.0746145621,
-0.6565676928,
0.6256314516,
-0.0070415847,
-0.9764381647,
0.3702590764,
-0.8443686366,
-0.5629538894,
0.1628422886,
-0.39378196,
-0.7131615877,
0.311450541,
0.1791020185,
0.7875499725,
0.0004375241,
0.3978279531,
-0.5860009789,
-0.246924147,
0.4531834126,
-0.1464891136,
0.2388868481,
0.1983734071,
-0.0244557746,
0.1242046058,
-0.5532399416,
-0.3160266578,
-0.1272468567,
-0.4034454823,
-0.4381489158,
0.1113892049,
0.3416863084,
0.2142367363,
0.1625711173,
-0.7531517744,
0.3632024229,
-0.1102433428,
0.6516222954,
0.4644027948,
0.0333620943,
0.2692303956,
-0.4941105247,
0.4850762188,
0.1171049699,
0.1069467738,
0.0814806148,
-0.8605485559,
-0.3918646574,
-0.5077727437,
0.5619874001,
0.2858694494,
-0.6901127696,
0.299292028,
-0.1965085864,
-0.7210400701,
-0.5790667534,
-0.1397954226,
0.2511204481,
0.2998773754,
0.4122312069,
-0.3359636664,
-0.577824533,
-1.0253751278,
0.144236818,
-0.26277408,
0.0685413703,
0.3171460629,
0.6159986854,
0.0464987271,
0.8716462255,
-0.4367277622,
-0.1353911608,
-0.2630173564,
0.4605421722,
0.0475162715,
0.4024027288,
0.4369174242,
-0.7867830992,
0.1508244723,
0.0746980458,
-0.6761312485,
-0.1024284214,
0.2318322659,
0.0756271631,
-0.0013385956,
0.2140756845,
-0.5773895383,
0.6193162799,
0.6565653086,
-0.2648645937,
0.3179931641,
-0.2392272353,
0.3314227164,
-0.9887912273,
0.1460690796,
0.323087126,
-0.223345384,
-0.902638495,
-0.253166616,
0.1326479465,
-0.2285372466,
-0.2035206854,
0.3300329149,
-0.1226519495,
-0.109110862,
-0.6142760515,
-0.381845057,
0.3497127295,
0.1434228867,
0.4595119953,
0.7611423731,
0.2787434459,
-0.4596753716,
-0.1165130213,
0.2781873345,
-0.3326901793,
0.0308858752,
-0.6906279922,
0.2662992775,
-0.310407728,
0.6753953099,
-0.7489684224,
-0.6501903534,
0.1429470927,
-0.4242865443,
0.3020538092,
0.0101297628,
-0.479121685,
-0.3432719409,
-0.3143596947,
0.5450036526,
0.240774557,
-0.3233960569,
0.2373178452,
0.3399438858,
-0.3415999115,
-0.2522978187,
-0.6126254201,
-0.0304960161,
-0.3618160784,
-0.4013463557,
0.340555042,
0.363366574,
-0.2035868466,
-0.1224897429,
0.0546566248,
-0.1839454472,
-0.0554354563,
0.6647888422,
0.341486603,
-0.0591502264,
0.4631888568,
-0.0952309296,
0.2540116012,
-0.1019881517,
0.2382854372,
0.392411083,
-0.2252145112,
-0.3788358271,
-0.421833694,
0.1093778014,
0.4863206148,
-0.1185581163,
0.6033876538,
0.6324602365,
-0.1301054955,
0.2178291231,
-0.4844672978,
-0.0972397849,
-0.3174982667,
0.5176168084,
0.028889969,
-1.0053342581,
0.4965768158,
0.3486166298,
0.0082392292,
0.4589614868,
0.2860581279,
-0.0502846204,
0.4872136712,
0.3759149313,
-0.3767442107,
0.4721919298,
-0.1032147184,
0.1982966959,
-0.8679022193,
-0.2048228234,
-0.7861575484,
-0.2077625394,
-0.4322908819,
-0.7660414577,
0.5034223795,
-0.0613786057,
0.0113263922,
0.2430458367,
-0.6977867484,
0.0610498525,
0.4184091985,
0.4452109933,
0.4298590422,
-0.0272446536,
0.7274081707,
0.2232192457,
-0.6835771203,
-0.580855608,
1.3973749876,
0.5507270098,
0.7432893515,
-0.2529302537,
0.7030228376,
0.3242900074,
0.3902828991,
-0.7007650733,
0.3181668222,
-0.245093897,
-0.7134902477,
-0.1758122146,
-0.4285056889,
-1.0125225782,
0.0698914453,
-0.1600019038,
-0.42180866,
0.708940208,
0.0265210494,
-0.6353577375,
0.1526961476,
-0.7179383636,
0.4645181596,
-0.2151877135,
-0.2465400994,
-0.2473468482,
-0.2312924564,
0.2993037701,
-0.4182642102,
0.3069945276,
-0.3026180565,
-0.1124453917,
1.1713581085,
-0.5092430115,
0.7438361049,
-0.1679604501,
0.1174154803,
0.2309977859,
-0.3762458861,
0.4822283387,
0.1262844801,
-0.3073606193,
0.6712812781,
0.178405121,
-0.4954309464,
-0.3297810256,
0.4580498934,
-0.9094732404,
-0.5844424963,
-0.6224545836,
-0.6220035553,
-0.1039979458,
-0.2271705121,
0.325630635,
0.5145549178,
0.0441082716,
0.333391428,
0.519920826,
-0.3965300024,
0.1902003288,
0.6850027442,
-0.3347787559,
-0.2715397775,
1.0131268501,
0.4290646911,
0.0099379551,
0.3066541553,
0.1705283374,
0.1204512715,
-1.0929102898,
-0.243136555,
0.1921030283,
-0.2209735662,
-0.4120023549,
-0.8284764886,
-0.335216403,
-0.5711302161,
0.1701132804,
-0.1955963671,
-0.4176419675,
-0.3448776901,
-0.2284523398,
1.010650754,
1.0844156742,
-0.1605398953,
0.0439348705,
-0.5493372679,
0.07704667,
-0.1008155942,
0.0980790332,
-0.1119390801,
-0.581740737,
-0.4876079261,
-0.1052998453,
-0.2330381125,
-0.603064537,
0.3055666983,
0.2304356545,
0.2794540524,
0.4631692469,
-0.0226242337,
0.4758758545,
-0.2096979171,
0.7189176083,
-0.1070889086,
-0.5980681181,
0.4219816327,
-0.5486015081,
0.1800543368,
0.7834220529,
0.4586357474,
-0.2759339511,
-0.342364192,
-0.4763320088,
-0.8138982654,
0.764746964,
0.3324570358,
-0.2960477471,
-0.1345137358,
0.3955725133,
0.5601594448,
0.2165940255,
-0.2960557938,
0.2316057384,
-0.2443868816,
-0.1487322748,
-0.1486871988,
0.1186625138,
0.0159370918,
-0.4436134696,
0.6254219413,
-0.0254946183,
0.2457536459,
0.5029121041,
0.2179179639,
0.069015488,
0.282746017,
0.482919395,
0.7450817227,
-0.3501639962,
0.0804811344,
-0.1732152998,
-0.8733101487,
-0.0789542347,
0.3832587004,
-0.2617164254,
-0.0308685843,
0.6457931399,
0.6747511625,
-0.0484854132,
-0.640895009,
0.5304339528,
0.0583107509,
-0.3175117671,
0.0304441825,
0.06556575,
-0.101221703,
0.2195904106,
0.5622858405,
0.0942811295,
0.4659140706,
-0.2033149749,
0.0639131591,
0.256744355,
-0.1997889429,
-0.5579036474,
0.2098464668,
0.1545023471,
-0.0267999321,
0.4219306111,
-0.1360138953,
-0.2544282079,
0.6969851851,
0.0782021061,
0.6372433305,
-0.2208609581,
0.4056697488,
0.1141445935,
-0.0080248462,
-0.4116203785,
0.2428669482,
0.1921479553,
-0.4350235164,
-0.7962927222,
-0.6245744824,
-0.5919861197,
0.6402440071,
-0.8007209301,
0.1848268658,
-0.3776613772,
-0.2163639665,
0.4170610309,
-0.0381414331,
-0.7264103293,
-0.0354240723,
0.0516005456,
0.6840105653,
-1.0234826803,
0.9506434202,
0.9747491479,
-0.4675334394,
-0.7668381929,
-0.0117550176,
-0.0605405681,
-0.4986419678,
0.4981091917,
0.2110040188,
0.4510160089,
-0.5364745259,
-0.7446274757,
-1.1299535036,
0.8508434892,
-0.1427669227,
-0.6518388987,
0.0074885297,
0.0531743094,
0.8824817538,
-0.2794267237,
0.0355372354,
0.2534636855,
0.3777797222,
0.0302911345,
-1.134326458,
-0.1044948101,
-0.2056553215,
-0.1788603812,
0.0318459347,
-0.7180685401,
0.8407872319,
0.0293065738,
0.2275028974,
-0.0696758777,
0.791490972,
0.3320738673,
0.7569422126,
0.2767423093,
0.4507333934,
0.8212404847,
-0.1330854297,
0.9223110676,
0.0182896741,
0.3120655417,
1.0042790174,
-0.369366169,
0.923392415,
0.2728145719,
-0.4694855809,
0.226997003,
0.9794880748,
-0.0935239419,
0.3842800856,
0.1983828396,
-0.0523833297,
-0.2558538914,
-0.1657993495,
-0.6285054088,
0.52054739,
0.5058085322,
-0.5001710653,
-0.1668445766,
0.5759807229,
0.1554792523,
-0.2357408702,
-0.3391981423,
0.7680699825,
0.116100125,
-0.4453276098,
0.1947882175,
-0.0317577943,
0.7432770133,
-0.2380870283,
0.0745141655,
-0.2514071465,
-0.0201292466,
-0.5804448724,
-0.8046291471,
0.2991737127,
0.0997645333,
-0.4031144381,
0.1975672543,
0.6814274192,
-0.2974645495,
-0.6867998242,
-0.0937852338,
0.3328428268,
0.6049774885,
-0.194608897,
-0.5620468855,
0.2523169816,
-0.2033207268,
-0.4213560224,
0.6126259565,
0.3666094244,
-0.2900214791,
0.4863661528,
0.3010321558,
0.1102582961,
-0.4671261311,
-0.1679590046,
0.9051098824,
-0.6281192303,
-0.0510633104,
-0.608885169,
-0.1552353054,
-0.1315748394,
-0.286671102,
0.88347435,
0.9740294218,
0.4754319489,
0.1317827851,
1.0624864101,
-0.2537711561,
0.8025557995,
-0.2323412299,
0.4420645535,
-0.1923567057,
0.1494050771,
-0.2462409586,
-0.424308151,
-0.1314039081,
0.3757748604,
-0.9633851647,
0.105386585,
0.5116192698,
0.6498690844,
-0.0150265824,
0.4114351273,
0.0003227432,
0.1199989617,
0.5008006692,
0.2916083038,
0.662972033,
-0.190060541,
0.2680646479,
-0.1978129894,
-0.3775044382,
-0.3202262223,
-0.634403944,
-0.9334765077,
-0.781136632,
-0.5261605382,
-0.525921464,
0.3425169587,
1.0690042973,
0.95167768,
-0.9295163155,
0.0527878441,
0.1086089015,
-0.2976202965,
-0.1025138274,
-0.2166199535,
0.6264790297,
-0.1932329535,
-0.4088521004,
0.389139086,
0.3697889745,
-0.0022245781,
-0.2925296426,
0.1879623532,
-0.2811112106,
-0.0963509232,
0.5684717298,
0.3657226562,
-0.5614391565,
-0.1971255243,
-0.1183021143,
-0.0778051466,
0.0763370097,
0.8383304477,
-0.6655100584,
0.2243711203,
0.6430605054,
0.6042571664,
0.658444643,
0.5407165885,
0.585675478,
-0.2587091327,
-0.0873022303,
0.308255434,
0.175743714,
0.5158885121,
-0.5203550458,
0.7215248346,
0.1119174361,
-1.0207401514,
-0.663670063,
-0.3509339094,
-1.0915110111,
-0.4339562953,
1.4036353827,
-0.1403812021,
-0.3740952611,
-0.6402053833,
-0.1756005138,
0.0163871199,
-0.8895123005,
1.0071417093,
0.7979980707,
-0.5881152153,
0.2578169703,
-0.7068543434,
0.6608119607,
0.1930901706,
-0.9955313206,
0.0144602144,
0.4490465224,
0.1504336447,
0.2234314382,
0.473690629,
-0.1673149914,
0.1142193452,
-0.467378974,
0.2807008028,
-0.2851088345,
-0.0499279611,
-0.4239625037,
0.4298634231,
0.0285587907,
-0.0399001166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04803v1 | Privately generating tabular data using language models | 2023-06-07T21:53:14 | 2023-06-07T21:53:14 | Alexandre Sablayrolles, Yue Wang, Brian Karrer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Privately generating synthetic data from a table is an important brick of a
privacy-first world. We propose and investigate a simple approach of treating
each row in a table as a sentence and training a language model with
differential privacy. We show this approach obtains competitive results in
modelling tabular data across multiple datasets, even at small scales that
favor alternative methods based on marginal distributions. | [
0.1111675352,
-0.8989316821,
0.620660603,
0.2005218565,
0.1503496021,
0.0898690522,
-0.0718227178,
-0.3687498569,
0.0403292142,
0.6322860718,
-0.4834578931,
-0.7626335621,
-0.1185943559,
-0.186570242,
-0.7970454693,
1.0528889894,
0.1406037956,
0.1538933218,
-0.0720926821,
0.109583579,
0.148128286,
-0.8301185369,
-0.0536075458,
0.0572736561,
0.6795424819,
0.5732188821,
0.8499537706,
1.2902104855,
0.3803491294,
0.3082213104,
0.3381232023,
-0.0313981883,
-0.5335527658,
0.1655099243,
0.1207153052,
-0.4694950581,
-0.3407201171,
0.1334310472,
0.9388688803,
1.0069690943,
-0.1011777893,
0.2450477332,
0.0143536236,
0.817048192,
-0.2779157162,
0.5134561658,
-0.7118877769,
0.5503139496,
-0.6642366052,
0.1915275753,
-0.6010063291,
-1.0415713787,
0.1042738259,
-0.2587011158,
0.503903091,
0.2459861934,
0.5558309555,
-0.2865613401,
-0.333181262,
0.0635251924,
-1.0786730051,
0.2918387353,
-0.4620484114,
0.6156501174,
0.3806190491,
0.4636603296,
-0.1015380993,
-0.9464729428,
-0.5556368232,
-0.8220136762,
-0.4046873748,
-0.3744379282,
0.0949372351,
-0.0945708603,
0.2698101699,
0.5049392581,
-0.652428627,
-0.0531145334,
-0.4771372378,
0.0760634765,
0.8685548306,
0.384018898,
0.3582710326,
-0.0809600279,
-0.2014326155,
-0.1133809388,
-0.879336834,
-0.020235572,
0.9013819098,
0.6095260978,
-0.2342951596,
0.8388586044,
-0.4310764372,
0.5736653209,
-0.3338299096,
0.032247059,
-0.055253379,
-0.2199804336,
-0.0822472274,
0.1087200567,
0.8606657982,
-0.1006600857,
0.1558367014,
-0.5552707911,
-0.1158657745,
0.4120033085,
0.2192397267,
-0.2878246307,
-0.5879942775,
-0.0082569616,
-0.1316992193,
-0.5491964221,
0.0440653861,
-1.1169998646,
-0.5986122489,
-0.3535847068,
0.3562982082,
0.1083075181,
0.0148571227,
-0.2774792016,
0.0077848323,
-0.2582930624,
-0.1290014684,
-1.1889388561,
0.9421402216,
0.5428023934,
0.7365862727,
-0.1542182863,
-0.2103184462,
-0.6639947295,
0.5182975531,
-0.5669880509,
0.5486931205,
-0.4675208926,
-0.5941637158,
0.1684426963,
0.0262134094,
0.3935416341,
-0.4389164448,
-0.0052671828,
-0.2370405495,
0.2462495416,
-0.2473212481,
-0.4105770886,
0.3055936992,
-0.0233147386,
-0.939417541,
0.5452178717,
0.1308361143,
-0.7152786851,
0.5805567503,
-0.8582426906,
-0.5076981187,
0.2356926501,
-0.4657267034,
-0.6210003495,
0.0050905216,
-0.0991605148,
0.4524697959,
0.0568022169,
0.4542410076,
-0.4024439454,
0.2444928288,
0.7097399235,
-0.2449424565,
0.4732218683,
0.183062166,
-0.3654254079,
0.0241502132,
-0.921019733,
0.011648817,
0.0041311365,
-0.3136125207,
-0.1077651083,
0.2131160647,
0.1135395765,
-0.1853144467,
0.0802490115,
-0.5599537492,
0.2590504885,
-0.4026184082,
0.1299335957,
0.7323064208,
-0.0389856361,
0.924962163,
-0.509025991,
0.412676841,
-0.0669477955,
0.2076575607,
0.552993834,
-0.3289094269,
-0.3229783773,
-0.0553416833,
0.6314262748,
0.3747683167,
-0.4293929935,
0.0085576251,
-0.2006839067,
-0.3966517448,
-0.2129264474,
0.0914782658,
0.3724124432,
0.327480644,
-0.0070601334,
-0.0256294813,
-0.5354135633,
-1.2912503481,
-0.4907839596,
0.1398264617,
0.1398393661,
0.4229823947,
0.2026554346,
0.2002505213,
1.0122387409,
-0.5641066432,
-0.4965005517,
-0.5632218719,
0.140896216,
-0.1108601913,
0.8371201158,
0.3221149743,
-0.789537251,
-0.9370706677,
0.2365838885,
-0.8341192603,
0.0230975226,
-0.0447150059,
-0.3665252626,
0.3654502332,
0.0530855581,
-0.2821711302,
0.7244643569,
0.5583226085,
-0.1326141953,
0.1208004355,
-0.2210119814,
-0.1984262317,
-0.9542134404,
-0.1285363883,
0.0382931754,
-0.5853825212,
-1.0691891909,
0.1712894589,
-0.1522270143,
-0.5449920893,
-0.5882998109,
0.5275761485,
-0.7568281293,
-0.2993207872,
0.0998469964,
-0.0801660493,
-0.2319832891,
0.3573865891,
0.2665660381,
0.6551963687,
0.4527670443,
-0.5557295084,
0.2272716016,
0.3966743946,
-0.5075173974,
0.0269675963,
-0.5006449223,
0.283277452,
-0.1559527963,
-0.1091756895,
-0.8270516396,
-0.7291842699,
0.2597506642,
-0.1626132876,
0.3912563026,
-0.1080230102,
-0.3489156365,
-0.3032215238,
-0.2499894053,
0.0358060263,
0.6972196698,
-0.4904331863,
0.2546757162,
1.0929642916,
-0.2817156017,
-0.5173678994,
-1.1423051357,
-0.0524988063,
-0.3033460081,
-0.5951761007,
0.3992341161,
0.1960635781,
-0.5385577083,
0.1121010184,
-0.0076405597,
-0.5073878765,
-0.1145124957,
0.312181592,
-0.0280913729,
0.1345827281,
-0.055547148,
0.1259766221,
0.0392753296,
0.1262912899,
-0.0358315334,
0.6839855909,
-0.0032461258,
0.1762959659,
-0.6324808598,
0.725410223,
-0.010063896,
0.0815010369,
1.0067366362,
0.0513926744,
-0.4940792322,
-0.7081363797,
-0.347361356,
-0.1851310134,
-0.5205796361,
0.0622790717,
-0.2237504125,
-0.412135601,
0.6126409769,
0.2577792108,
0.0556847863,
-0.2024654299,
0.619764328,
0.0966953859,
0.9521520138,
0.9177553058,
0.0598690026,
0.4152148962,
-0.302577585,
0.2294670641,
-0.1340839118,
-0.4069383144,
-0.7623067498,
-0.403349638,
-1.0721755028,
-0.0720082521,
0.6518719792,
-0.4491723478,
-0.1302351207,
0.193101868,
-0.5126612186,
0.7915599346,
0.8860535026,
0.5485603809,
0.3283787668,
0.3378424942,
0.0003003608,
-0.0709515437,
-0.5516409278,
-0.7203781605,
1.0649373531,
0.0574705191,
1.1131203175,
0.0280992128,
1.2113384008,
0.3810906112,
0.4670653045,
-0.1270238012,
0.5701777339,
-0.3291729987,
-0.9148696661,
-0.5354351401,
-0.745572865,
-0.9723187089,
-0.0410982594,
-0.2031662166,
-0.9659523964,
0.2051254362,
0.334277153,
-0.1776605844,
0.2418865263,
-0.9693230987,
1.0506241322,
0.0634590313,
-0.83867383,
0.2933606207,
-0.579351604,
0.6252545714,
0.0705772266,
0.3331425786,
0.010281926,
0.3952097893,
0.7504712939,
-0.7088689804,
0.8418121338,
-0.4574986696,
0.1525830925,
0.2336994112,
0.6146255732,
0.5226693749,
0.5011301637,
0.0496624596,
0.0026142893,
0.0698567554,
-0.2053094655,
-0.3608395457,
0.8414468765,
-0.8065499663,
-0.8034781218,
-0.3875038028,
-0.7534531355,
-0.2487422228,
0.0374090746,
0.1186337546,
0.4495125115,
-0.2887940109,
0.3755140305,
0.2230926454,
-0.3178902566,
0.3947601318,
0.3871074617,
-0.2588417232,
-0.1226405427,
0.6909769177,
0.5564572811,
0.076365687,
0.3896390498,
0.4355707169,
-0.7435412407,
-0.3613406122,
-0.3610355258,
0.0474084392,
-0.4187102914,
-0.0210859906,
-0.9018253088,
-0.2621749938,
-0.4215981364,
-0.0422405936,
-0.2665209174,
-0.7391092777,
0.1357570142,
-0.4906620979,
0.5054734349,
0.9698901772,
-0.6554931402,
0.2706826925,
-0.7672642469,
0.6363177896,
0.470941782,
0.3891659379,
-0.1846576929,
0.0328758359,
0.1604875177,
0.2173872739,
-0.1114665195,
-1.2385079861,
0.83006078,
0.1256369203,
0.5534369349,
-0.19517304,
0.1951510608,
0.3333981335,
-0.949691236,
0.8237313628,
-0.2667542398,
-1.1202251911,
0.4444525838,
-0.5417188406,
-0.3161769509,
0.471761018,
0.5387789011,
-0.2548473179,
-0.4999734163,
-0.6271731853,
-0.6365624666,
0.8821067214,
0.3459527791,
0.3974298537,
0.2302279025,
0.1770793945,
0.5764811039,
0.4970661402,
-1.5010319948,
-0.1659933329,
0.1251020133,
-0.3476294279,
0.1089797392,
-0.0759664401,
-0.3975638151,
-0.258477211,
0.3461137116,
0.2818439305,
0.4936969876,
-0.0376307257,
0.0690185055,
-0.0962310582,
0.3280835152,
0.276707232,
0.7999562025,
-0.0177091304,
0.1549474746,
-0.1102765203,
-0.2650674284,
0.456401825,
0.1131503657,
-0.3691630661,
0.1190880165,
-0.3923063576,
0.4698944986,
-0.2770247757,
0.0576466843,
0.3729873598,
-0.1438198239,
-0.3946039975,
-0.3493042588,
0.0220410544,
0.0969129354,
0.1508314162,
-0.0873607695,
-0.4480418861,
0.2551177442,
-0.8379974365,
0.4292732179,
0.2742399573,
0.1057207584,
-0.3776797652,
1.1240321398,
-0.2425572425,
-0.5713108182,
0.4646704197,
-0.1460430771,
-0.0004891185,
0.4168566167,
0.5369981527,
0.6187301874,
-0.3794333041,
0.8253685832,
-0.117015928,
0.1570615321,
-0.1753746718,
0.6778245568,
-0.1961112171,
-0.4061289728,
0.1090889275,
-0.5754825473,
-0.6300444007,
0.2748445868,
-0.6502940655,
-0.123686865,
-0.6284018159,
-0.0255663693,
0.2683075666,
-0.0734430924,
-0.8015579581,
0.0369481519,
0.2327078432,
0.3436703384,
-0.7217589617,
0.9172928929,
0.1871377826,
-0.4483753145,
-0.9729294181,
-0.3082138896,
-0.3210976124,
-0.503554225,
0.7184866071,
-0.0346090533,
0.2961330116,
-0.1838845015,
-0.7200471759,
-0.7526296973,
0.5694327354,
0.6406547427,
-0.8531265259,
-0.173652634,
0.9407940507,
0.7101656199,
-0.1462053955,
-0.6059367061,
0.4769324064,
0.4468838871,
-0.6227763295,
-0.5723877549,
0.041636534,
-0.0672075376,
0.039473068,
0.1483748853,
-0.3897128403,
1.100838542,
0.2131972462,
-0.4188028872,
-0.1040028855,
0.5302995443,
0.0326907262,
0.4832542539,
0.1890722066,
0.054554075,
0.885371089,
-0.2008706033,
1.1506146193,
-0.3351501822,
0.1764818132,
1.1645458937,
-0.840816617,
0.5593575835,
0.0975757688,
-0.2147352993,
0.4677990079,
0.2408297807,
0.1023131609,
0.8551563621,
0.5620781779,
-0.3157280087,
0.314450264,
0.0083288103,
-0.4360934794,
0.3497455418,
0.1605646163,
-0.5502509475,
-0.2223049253,
-0.0181701481,
-0.1321081668,
0.526368618,
-0.0808209106,
0.9270669222,
0.0320237577,
-0.2091991007,
0.1219202653,
-0.0313400663,
-0.1478318572,
-0.4275352359,
0.0392655656,
-0.4621035755,
0.2088427097,
-0.2363262028,
-0.4838907421,
0.4796310365,
0.3501539528,
-0.0259840786,
-0.4087708592,
0.316778332,
-0.6521168947,
-0.6741111279,
-0.2577205896,
0.7728783488,
0.2437574863,
0.2911177576,
-0.289156884,
-0.2035420984,
-0.1876677871,
-0.3495676816,
0.4064020216,
0.5198300481,
-0.1410389543,
0.3354527354,
0.6924644709,
0.2040431947,
0.5091741085,
0.1436425596,
0.9986464381,
-0.8200315237,
-1.1384228468,
-0.9355418682,
0.478253901,
-0.2271990776,
0.0757009983,
0.7431333661,
0.6242547035,
0.8791065216,
-0.4090802372,
0.926466167,
0.0091510918,
0.6775192618,
-0.6135547757,
1.0592045784,
-0.2495286912,
-0.1108305156,
-0.2391835302,
-0.9619032741,
-0.4884606302,
0.6410828233,
-0.4158340991,
-0.2412256747,
0.6936497092,
1.0383067131,
-0.041270379,
0.1558400691,
0.341268003,
0.3388744295,
0.3751906455,
0.2408103049,
1.1119549274,
-0.0796335936,
0.1812734306,
-0.8090085387,
0.0311866403,
0.4365042448,
-0.8241428733,
-0.910994947,
-0.639683485,
-0.0595566034,
-0.297193408,
0.128099665,
0.8244016171,
0.9752411246,
-0.7293414474,
-0.5085197091,
-0.5749515891,
-0.0350987129,
0.1220728755,
-0.2590262592,
0.3096400499,
-0.1239954606,
-0.7966650724,
0.4921748638,
0.0197574645,
0.2703350484,
-0.5265769362,
0.4407218099,
0.0081206467,
0.0300227124,
0.2538335621,
0.1464163512,
-0.2080384642,
-0.224893555,
-0.2405790985,
-0.0452902578,
0.2328176349,
0.8976898789,
-0.5826300383,
0.2738797069,
0.4471185505,
0.5264112353,
0.805863142,
0.2012499869,
0.7393875718,
-1.1849265099,
0.4886945486,
0.3359938562,
0.088728793,
0.3132959902,
-0.882375598,
0.487070471,
-0.1133979931,
-0.7472872734,
-1.2918192148,
0.3247437179,
-0.7826945186,
0.0511622466,
0.9619310498,
-0.1248454377,
-0.7586547136,
0.0091311503,
-0.0568908602,
0.2434346378,
-0.6217038035,
1.2291015387,
0.3206856251,
-0.0067567187,
0.0582263879,
-0.4197412729,
0.9205513597,
-0.1699608713,
-1.1189739704,
0.4067220688,
0.6222234964,
0.1621178836,
-0.0445056334,
0.7804137468,
-0.3992859423,
-0.0741785914,
0.3804963231,
-0.2156074941,
-0.0871855393,
-0.8077118993,
-0.2192456722,
0.6068437099,
-0.2022509128,
-0.229579702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04802v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04802v3 | A Review on Knowledge Graphs for Healthcare: Resources, Applications, and Promises | 2023-06-07T21:51:56 | 2024-02-19T23:40:58 | Hejie Cui, Jiaying Lu, Shiyu Wang, Ran Xu, Wenjing Ma, Shaojun Yu, Yue Yu, Xuan Kan, Chen Ling, Tianfan Fu, Liang Zhao, Joyce Ho, Fei Wang, Carl Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Healthcare knowledge graphs (HKGs) are valuable tools for organizing
biomedical concepts and their relationships with interpretable structures. The
recent advent of large language models (LLMs) has paved the way for building
more comprehensive and accurate HKGs. This, in turn, can improve the
reliability of generated content and enable better evaluation of LLMs. However,
the challenges of HKGs such as regarding data heterogeneity and limited
coverage are not fully understood, highlighting the need for detailed reviews.
This work provides the first comprehensive review of HKGs. It summarizes the
pipeline and key techniques for HKG construction, as well as the common
utilization approaches, i.e., model-free and model-based. The existing HKG
resources are also organized based on the data types they capture and
application domains they cover, along with relevant statistical information
(Resource available at
https://github.com/lujiaying/Awesome-HealthCare-KnowledgeBase). At the
application level, we delve into the successful integration of HKGs across
various health domains, ranging from fine-grained basic science research to
high-level clinical decision support and public health. Lastly, the paper
highlights the opportunities for HKGs in the era of LLMs. This work aims to
serve as a valuable resource for understanding the potential and opportunities
of HKG in health research. | [
0.0498488881,
-0.5902959108,
0.7469705343,
-0.1706551313,
-0.2235815376,
0.1547692567,
0.2884276211,
-0.5531377196,
0.1708771288,
0.7664635777,
-0.1866369098,
-0.9708363414,
-0.8876873255,
-0.0123564862,
0.0289227013,
0.764395833,
-0.2667823136,
0.1765245795,
-0.2794540524,
-0.459746629,
-0.2272084057,
-0.4228412807,
-0.4418544769,
-0.6376627684,
0.7282809019,
0.2062286884,
0.8176637888,
0.7605780363,
0.5102902055,
0.1417745948,
-0.1936814934,
0.3623978198,
-0.3763569295,
0.1218680143,
0.236711219,
-0.1125834584,
-0.6489087939,
-0.0829053894,
0.4516084492,
1.289090395,
-0.1514076144,
0.0148326112,
0.155433163,
0.8374418616,
-0.4559685886,
0.6658767462,
-0.026933521,
0.5111543536,
-0.3425733447,
-0.1933958977,
-0.0808830857,
-0.4368221164,
0.4266698956,
-0.6406988502,
-0.2999716699,
0.0937766656,
0.6337218285,
0.1356898099,
-0.9277740121,
-0.3061476946,
-0.3694622815,
0.5581664443,
-0.7969811559,
0.6586790085,
0.3166472018,
0.5760498047,
-0.422288686,
-1.282610178,
-0.108690396,
-0.2067845762,
-0.2817212343,
0.4047356844,
-0.2922423482,
0.4605329037,
-0.0835202634,
0.6825383902,
-0.6022109389,
0.1976450682,
-0.4353795648,
-0.4517674446,
0.4321946502,
0.5267034769,
0.4597198963,
-0.360552609,
-0.4269458652,
0.2567238808,
-0.7933707833,
0.0609728284,
-0.1195441931,
0.2270907909,
-0.3384118378,
0.6926437616,
-0.3789172471,
0.8575965166,
-0.3188936114,
-0.5627997518,
0.4027478099,
-0.4578152597,
-0.1674056053,
0.20913212,
0.6536217928,
0.3431578577,
-0.1688223183,
-0.3533164859,
0.2329633981,
-0.3065549433,
0.3290659189,
-0.6482963562,
-0.1842259616,
0.3782415092,
-1.0423418283,
-0.2125621289,
-0.232586056,
-0.2110491842,
-0.5985330939,
-0.1822056323,
-0.2319821566,
-0.4242865741,
-0.0263342578,
0.322721839,
-0.0334117003,
-0.34931463,
0.3501379788,
-0.3152542412,
0.2002544105,
0.4305327535,
0.8401599526,
-0.1540421695,
-0.0157147497,
-0.0289681628,
0.5214414001,
-0.3579899669,
0.5018622279,
-0.0660153851,
-0.4701291621,
0.3104513884,
0.0416053087,
0.184912473,
-0.5517501235,
0.5023744702,
-0.5466583967,
-0.2014423907,
-0.5903496742,
-0.8088380694,
-0.0982694179,
0.4829414487,
-0.9899906516,
0.1972554326,
0.5604459643,
-1.0095885992,
0.4353268147,
-0.5902613997,
-0.5339215994,
0.3468030095,
-0.2949737906,
-0.2932036519,
-0.1756062955,
0.1493783593,
0.5081007481,
-0.403845489,
-0.0950463936,
-0.6511486173,
-0.0275146943,
-0.1280403584,
0.2991043925,
0.9723066092,
0.5590344071,
0.2110799998,
0.2384121865,
-0.4704215527,
0.1400554925,
0.1024194062,
-0.3239602447,
-0.2909101844,
0.0755392611,
-0.282938689,
-0.2677526176,
0.2584030926,
-0.1366415918,
0.2572799027,
-0.1945376098,
0.5691511035,
0.4485543966,
0.091615878,
0.2471078634,
-0.3428937197,
0.7156723142,
0.0378282294,
0.6158806682,
0.0356743075,
-0.6405668259,
0.1268338114,
-0.0619352795,
0.2556574941,
0.2179548144,
-0.7217569351,
0.280072242,
0.0667469427,
-0.6819518209,
-0.4696695507,
-0.098612614,
-0.0087931696,
0.7882727385,
0.3744212091,
-0.4187789857,
-0.3711745441,
-0.7768309116,
-0.0938380808,
-0.6318298578,
0.1484990269,
0.7965112925,
-0.0505586267,
-0.690813005,
0.6261581779,
-0.6289880276,
-0.236100316,
-0.2458949685,
-0.19310233,
0.0616819374,
-0.0799235776,
0.5899001956,
-0.7450136542,
-0.4357047975,
0.3660596609,
-0.9845947027,
-0.1518405229,
0.6666417718,
-0.0409577303,
-0.3008174598,
0.3122755587,
-0.3057848215,
0.2077450305,
0.7118262649,
-0.1685433239,
0.7496228814,
0.1095485389,
0.2165801227,
-0.7901241779,
0.1785847098,
-0.0235348772,
-0.1426394284,
-0.5884904861,
-0.0025609171,
-0.1777851135,
-0.1279797405,
-0.1481101662,
0.8511526585,
-0.1829782575,
0.1147371009,
-0.1349847019,
-0.38459149,
-0.0066211103,
-0.10537678,
-0.2708404362,
0.349632889,
0.3944119513,
-0.3983753324,
0.4942468703,
0.4879527986,
-0.5789901614,
0.1298394948,
-0.6235790849,
-0.1340208054,
0.2056866139,
0.4402938187,
-0.5496714115,
-0.3312757909,
0.4021267593,
-0.1567736119,
0.1551746726,
-0.1419281811,
-0.533711493,
-0.7751063108,
0.0211209953,
0.3434050381,
0.4491781592,
-0.2370281368,
0.0306117237,
1.1670353413,
-0.2562265396,
-0.6981446147,
-0.5637433529,
0.0275245029,
-0.1434616745,
-0.363086462,
0.3631447554,
0.1958783269,
-0.3455501795,
0.2836250663,
-0.3058298528,
-0.3303450644,
-0.1832550466,
0.2964175642,
0.1047376469,
-0.2517009079,
0.3848373592,
-0.059933167,
-0.0532784835,
0.0854991078,
-0.6481948495,
0.1203417704,
-0.0496621691,
-0.5432014465,
-0.0734720677,
0.2038692981,
0.4522020221,
0.1273561865,
0.5007955432,
0.6337032914,
-0.5043620467,
0.1718487293,
-0.2985968888,
-0.1808546931,
-0.3569049239,
0.4763453603,
0.24100025,
-1.3839952946,
0.4674093127,
-0.2692628503,
0.1089187264,
0.3445506096,
0.5263256431,
-0.1619177759,
0.9116997719,
0.6831682324,
-0.0820673704,
-0.0589221008,
0.0414977446,
0.4377528429,
-0.4998087287,
-0.5280346274,
-0.3289809525,
-0.053896796,
-0.8736626506,
-0.3240312934,
0.9250634909,
0.3527994454,
-0.133372277,
-0.1089339033,
-0.5318393707,
-0.1103858799,
0.0970259458,
0.2903652787,
0.3768692911,
-0.2093159854,
-0.1450892687,
0.0182727445,
-1.1746002436,
-0.4181403816,
1.1074819565,
0.4583346546,
0.8105641603,
-0.2680116594,
0.5467976928,
0.3356896937,
0.2262180448,
-0.7427685261,
0.1583621204,
-0.512147367,
-0.4605925679,
-0.4163377285,
-0.6419463754,
-1.1321781874,
-0.2376789749,
-0.013663847,
-0.5094225407,
-0.0637062937,
0.327092737,
-0.4474527538,
0.5645570755,
-0.414280951,
0.8162742257,
-0.2481052876,
-0.042699039,
-0.0832262933,
-0.6598997116,
0.4361717999,
0.229808405,
0.0594730899,
-0.104657717,
0.2920661271,
0.6338039637,
-0.555819571,
0.5524865389,
-0.0204687342,
-0.1021511555,
0.6273923516,
-0.2728686631,
0.1134486794,
-0.0777701437,
-0.0971446931,
0.5297147632,
0.2672471404,
-0.5203534961,
-0.4077386558,
0.4303581417,
-0.7017661929,
-0.4082561135,
-0.144998163,
-0.7309685946,
-0.4652232826,
0.3895118833,
-0.0479157828,
0.386143595,
-0.1073862463,
0.1341756731,
0.4133372605,
-0.656540513,
-0.4980171025,
0.1153913438,
-0.3017292917,
-0.2911978662,
0.4900604486,
0.399297893,
0.1115408316,
0.1605765671,
0.51169312,
-0.3032118082,
-0.8526943922,
-0.0537753031,
0.0429033376,
-0.6700749993,
-0.1627299041,
-0.639347434,
-0.5776779056,
-0.7175738215,
-0.0352957807,
0.0948976576,
-0.2233336866,
-0.0121247461,
-0.0326347537,
0.5415029526,
1.1213798523,
-0.2118936926,
0.0630252734,
-1.0194900036,
0.2881441712,
0.3221933544,
0.5525528193,
0.2096381783,
0.2696420848,
-0.677365303,
-0.1321074814,
-0.2255679518,
-0.9317455888,
0.1675016731,
-0.5162908435,
0.7553139329,
0.672504127,
0.0499545634,
0.5897094607,
-0.5396981239,
0.726351738,
0.4470919669,
-0.2704032958,
0.2187448293,
-0.527782023,
0.165724352,
0.3835089505,
0.5265139937,
-0.6611462235,
-0.0736833289,
-0.5516157746,
-0.9419704676,
0.3808249235,
-0.1758343875,
-0.3666606843,
0.1626576483,
0.6147602797,
0.1626591086,
0.3518057168,
-0.2211337984,
-0.5172966719,
-0.0723289773,
0.0473236851,
0.1499461234,
-0.358584106,
-0.5285993814,
-0.0722549558,
0.3998113573,
-0.2819845676,
0.1871022582,
0.101158537,
0.33414343,
-0.1405513287,
0.4337619841,
-0.0938775241,
0.55038625,
-0.1793260276,
0.2676011324,
0.0224758554,
-0.3706830144,
-0.0906522274,
0.1263951808,
0.0900709927,
-0.051341977,
0.55424577,
0.6217936873,
0.08830937,
-0.5498659015,
0.122445412,
0.2859233022,
0.0610606186,
0.1331027448,
0.0353466459,
0.2339730263,
0.2016857117,
-0.0417662822,
-0.4370926321,
0.2368959486,
-0.4865217209,
0.3051483035,
0.2498373687,
-0.7173743248,
-0.062546514,
0.5590571165,
0.0400586873,
0.1773523986,
0.5264900923,
-0.0351093672,
-0.2634625137,
0.5344170928,
0.5092326403,
0.2997810543,
-0.0221689213,
0.2408099025,
0.3490758538,
-0.0410368368,
0.0577685572,
0.0742604509,
0.1133392155,
-0.7045853138,
-0.5401051044,
-0.3767882288,
-0.6642255783,
0.4161251485,
-0.4669263959,
0.0822918192,
-0.2510386705,
-0.4629078805,
-0.03727917,
0.2096681744,
-0.5774979591,
0.1189531535,
0.1101048812,
0.8639948964,
-0.3438550234,
0.5184297562,
0.7726100087,
-0.1942979693,
-0.8789384961,
-0.0879030749,
0.1735862195,
-1.0554585457,
0.4347364604,
-0.2423392981,
0.2367092818,
-0.2724998593,
-0.451561898,
-0.512272656,
1.1702524424,
0.4020754099,
-0.3320967555,
-0.4765342772,
0.3936384618,
0.4406844676,
-0.1662580967,
-0.076044865,
0.4324851334,
0.6883014441,
0.0000402051,
-0.854123354,
0.0458773412,
0.0392951183,
-0.3101423979,
-0.2200706154,
-0.632055819,
0.8392630219,
-0.2710652947,
-0.0652538836,
0.0401173308,
0.3586761653,
0.5840522051,
0.5122042298,
0.3535540104,
0.7989768982,
0.8349068165,
-0.1350590289,
1.2930570841,
-0.4184904397,
0.2447010875,
0.5918185711,
-0.6090434194,
-0.1934304088,
0.2336155176,
-0.6835600734,
0.4722446203,
0.7755151391,
0.1550825685,
0.3972833753,
0.1751899272,
-0.2164476067,
-0.155354917,
-0.6720247865,
-0.6402295828,
0.0567888618,
0.4142484665,
-0.364941746,
-0.5123277307,
-0.1387922615,
-0.1123480648,
-0.2070234865,
-0.4540905058,
0.6044105887,
0.425424099,
-0.0828587785,
0.0755755678,
-0.0878777206,
-0.0920903161,
-0.970282495,
-0.3229318857,
0.209076032,
-0.1879197061,
-0.4124045968,
-0.8164557219,
0.1564171165,
-0.3332108557,
-0.0942158774,
-0.2558919191,
1.1129261255,
-0.1616355479,
-0.0463066176,
0.344956547,
0.7224677205,
-0.0317374952,
0.4571176767,
-0.6212059855,
-0.2060545236,
-0.0659471899,
-0.1696274281,
0.2344550192,
0.5962017775,
-0.0379725769,
0.4318892956,
0.6173128486,
0.5193980336,
-0.2642742097,
0.1442912966,
0.5228977799,
-0.427582413,
-0.6633982062,
-0.4921170771,
0.231181398,
0.1175913066,
-0.0061969841,
0.8276416659,
0.3659240007,
0.5589696169,
0.2891246676,
1.1734344959,
0.0805181637,
0.508954227,
-0.5400871038,
1.0959483385,
-0.5977101326,
-0.1427792162,
-0.0767914876,
-0.1582734138,
-0.510656774,
0.3030159175,
-0.2031578273,
-0.0382814407,
0.5292696953,
0.2063738108,
0.2146632671,
0.035056483,
0.4258036017,
0.3586344123,
0.3792445064,
0.3441748321,
0.6939795017,
-0.2412853986,
0.2175200433,
-0.1556941569,
-0.0629012436,
-0.3217408955,
-0.6728307009,
-0.463619113,
-0.5440436006,
-0.2421535701,
-0.7712343335,
0.2068944722,
0.6004183888,
0.9970042706,
-0.7147244811,
-0.0862353742,
0.0909367874,
0.4830098748,
-0.1546228528,
-0.1154339314,
0.7214154005,
-0.1220656559,
-0.1471736878,
0.372225821,
0.4899056554,
0.1031068265,
-0.1335453987,
-0.2687762082,
0.2583669126,
-0.3047802746,
0.52451545,
0.4487650096,
-0.4419068098,
-0.0470408276,
-0.0616616197,
-0.3330530226,
0.0929125473,
1.0206246376,
-0.6679095626,
0.4783419073,
0.3858169019,
0.764298737,
0.2141917795,
-0.3067177534,
0.3296917379,
-0.3026009798,
-0.0274195895,
0.4462786913,
0.6800091267,
0.1972868294,
-0.3258369863,
0.5357115269,
0.2105087787,
-0.4932315946,
-0.8829465508,
0.3996846974,
-0.8943064213,
-0.3564377129,
1.1032863855,
-0.1921563894,
0.0142951095,
-0.3519396484,
0.1032030657,
0.6501177549,
0.0577443577,
0.9184592366,
0.641593039,
-0.557286799,
0.327494055,
-0.6983287334,
0.6335599422,
0.0781587064,
-1.1149857044,
0.0843277276,
0.4176970422,
-0.016109705,
0.0660101473,
1.0292693377,
-0.5371106267,
0.1771313846,
-0.2659330964,
0.0012011881,
-0.0897018984,
-0.1618767232,
-0.0566006042,
0.3113128841,
0.1482217312,
0.1744010895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04787v1 | Absformer: Transformer-based Model for Unsupervised Multi-Document Abstractive Summarization | 2023-06-07T21:18:23 | 2023-06-07T21:18:23 | Mohamed Trabelsi, Huseyin Uzunalioglu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multi-document summarization (MDS) refers to the task of summarizing the text
in multiple documents into a concise summary. The generated summary can save
the time of reading many documents by providing the important content in the
form of a few sentences. Abstractive MDS aims to generate a coherent and fluent
summary for multiple documents using natural language generation techniques. In
this paper, we consider the unsupervised abstractive MDS setting where there
are only documents with no groundtruh summaries provided, and we propose
Absformer, a new Transformer-based method for unsupervised abstractive summary
generation. Our method consists of a first step where we pretrain a
Transformer-based encoder using the masked language modeling (MLM) objective as
the pretraining task in order to cluster the documents into semantically
similar groups; and a second step where we train a Transformer-based decoder to
generate abstractive summaries for the clusters of documents. To our knowledge,
we are the first to successfully incorporate a Transformer-based model to solve
the unsupervised abstractive MDS task. We evaluate our approach using three
real-world datasets from different domains, and we demonstrate both substantial
improvements in terms of evaluation metrics over state-of-the-art
abstractive-based methods, and generalization to datasets from different
domains. | [
-0.6018584967,
-0.4763634205,
0.1733542234,
-0.0195449293,
-0.424987793,
0.2465065122,
-0.0193132404,
-0.1318184733,
0.4613996148,
0.5279420614,
-0.4900472462,
-0.5339310765,
-0.8659490943,
0.4246869683,
-0.5827912092,
1.1704190969,
-0.2240846008,
-0.0242670905,
-0.3882185817,
-0.0634651035,
-0.1445654184,
-0.4851403534,
-0.2300415039,
-0.5443196893,
-0.0862328038,
0.1407730579,
0.2020137459,
0.4483011365,
0.4793881476,
0.35697034,
0.0272842888,
0.1967904419,
-0.2476973981,
0.305993855,
0.0577780344,
-0.4115495086,
-0.469191581,
-0.2066090703,
0.4962041378,
0.86427176,
-0.1500070989,
0.014360019,
0.11336115,
0.7597436309,
-0.6758673787,
0.2672178745,
-0.5325052738,
-0.0045732497,
0.1384299845,
0.0471123941,
-0.2664921582,
-0.3352738023,
-0.0209782943,
-0.4229593873,
0.7796606421,
-0.1772292405,
0.5684148669,
0.1427464038,
-0.63007617,
-0.2865124047,
-0.8296942711,
0.5429064631,
-0.7867575288,
0.0830399171,
0.0272579193,
0.5296522975,
0.1066583991,
-0.8663440347,
-0.6561486721,
0.2321924567,
-0.3513047099,
0.3786419332,
-0.519874692,
0.1388866305,
-0.1553125083,
0.6463903785,
-0.3429862559,
-0.0059010945,
-0.5811130404,
-0.1607433707,
0.5385377407,
0.1490872353,
-0.0309960023,
-0.1765349358,
-0.045897264,
-0.0575214438,
-0.6309162378,
-0.017181769,
0.1553720683,
0.1555961519,
-0.2947041094,
0.8066220284,
-0.2607703209,
0.4611798525,
0.3298411965,
-0.3245209455,
0.2415395826,
-0.3691365421,
-0.1842561811,
0.3335846364,
0.7625108361,
0.5644932389,
0.1594638824,
-0.207778573,
-0.4344988763,
0.4769726992,
0.3783526421,
-1.0966604948,
-0.1641728729,
0.326990515,
-0.7215088606,
-0.4395598769,
0.2547316849,
-0.7423787713,
-0.2041768432,
-0.4405784607,
0.1508854926,
-0.3853386641,
-0.2080743909,
-0.1200915128,
-0.2212162018,
-0.0360603034,
0.1478758901,
-0.9003827572,
0.5653207302,
0.3724036217,
0.8774852753,
-0.3744181097,
-0.0570804216,
-0.1872055829,
0.2094968706,
-0.2976444066,
1.09278512,
-0.3624723256,
-0.6275637746,
-0.0311037041,
-0.0037560782,
-0.3791013062,
-0.4508740604,
0.4743519723,
-0.3320400715,
0.4403053522,
0.3234240413,
-0.5562360883,
-0.3431749642,
0.2441170365,
-0.6751520038,
0.8212102056,
0.111809507,
-0.8300956488,
0.1551907957,
-1.0576562881,
-0.7417615056,
-0.1211049259,
-0.2238093019,
-0.6096642017,
0.3483717442,
0.6415308118,
0.5118446946,
-0.0595311001,
0.4207448661,
0.4753286839,
-0.2480073422,
-0.0139338039,
-0.4716672003,
0.2099404931,
0.0565375388,
-0.3959315121,
0.3803198934,
-0.8507357836,
-0.2484305948,
0.0295053218,
-0.2425855547,
-0.144157216,
-0.1567245126,
0.1387993395,
0.3375381827,
0.0890609771,
-0.6032209396,
-0.0112015456,
-0.6086047888,
0.2471089214,
0.3815504014,
0.2657218874,
0.5438316464,
-0.4923250377,
0.7110050917,
0.0654837564,
-0.0304922499,
-1.044410944,
-0.3904781938,
-0.6872893572,
-0.4704551995,
0.3490017354,
0.3865756392,
-0.6230533123,
0.7184152603,
-0.3966935277,
-0.5602181554,
-0.5747363567,
-0.3083834052,
0.4513265491,
0.4066737592,
0.5438533425,
-0.3723849952,
-0.7563061118,
-0.9994699359,
0.0950419083,
0.4395484924,
-0.4440620542,
-0.2018374801,
0.6472830772,
-0.4813365042,
1.125983119,
-0.5915963054,
-0.6488522887,
-0.6949495673,
0.4607409239,
0.1951211244,
0.3599556088,
0.4380888343,
-0.7235090137,
-0.3163501322,
-0.2214631587,
-0.7938148379,
0.0439906009,
0.0044965511,
0.3398359716,
0.4304211438,
0.4614740908,
-0.7045864463,
0.5513669252,
0.7111193538,
-0.0068485062,
0.6204358339,
-0.5030806065,
0.171763733,
-1.4017328024,
0.2443902344,
-0.2115350664,
-0.130198285,
-0.6641506553,
-0.1568107307,
-0.0120696295,
-0.3089863658,
-0.2693043947,
0.2212044895,
-0.6575140953,
0.0114684701,
-0.6728647351,
-0.0269105546,
0.23306638,
0.6152631044,
0.1166902781,
0.5431165695,
0.6956483722,
-0.7250595093,
0.1354708523,
0.5055956841,
-0.1584307998,
0.4957554042,
-0.8125444651,
-0.1401704848,
-0.6970599294,
0.6277787685,
-0.8574255705,
-0.0784891248,
0.0045791119,
-0.4133263826,
0.3530420661,
-0.1151314974,
-0.1788473427,
-0.2919110954,
-0.3623226285,
0.2554332614,
0.2758233547,
-0.3654393256,
1.1522806883,
0.3737052381,
-0.3877605796,
-0.3509591818,
-0.4677776992,
0.1858425587,
0.0785489008,
-0.4294814467,
0.6621632576,
0.0568476245,
-0.1776279062,
-0.0284262821,
-0.4055330753,
0.0699007958,
-0.307123661,
0.5580360889,
0.3075466454,
-0.2104372531,
-0.3712638021,
0.5556441545,
-0.4820730984,
0.1705738604,
-0.2787879109,
0.5397389531,
-0.035241928,
-0.4870197475,
-0.2488042861,
0.829610765,
0.6635417342,
-0.607406199,
0.7939549088,
0.194265604,
-0.3934696913,
-0.0121234208,
-0.296220243,
-0.2884857357,
-0.399990797,
0.3060889244,
-0.4033498168,
-0.6329311728,
0.5083559752,
-0.2791169286,
0.3665571809,
0.6984872222,
0.475823015,
0.1089486629,
1.0268919468,
0.8270751238,
0.0020512808,
0.0480154566,
-0.5846478343,
0.4094142318,
-0.6265151501,
-0.5769797564,
-0.4643710256,
-0.1736897826,
-0.2822192907,
-0.218602106,
0.6218118668,
0.0175292138,
0.1006594151,
0.1857786626,
-0.6357572675,
0.5289670825,
0.4096765816,
-0.2870145142,
0.6360672116,
0.0128696589,
-0.2474342436,
0.0707017183,
-0.6437426209,
-0.6373752952,
1.187317729,
0.0657597631,
0.6580968499,
0.0805928037,
0.6276373863,
0.1995186359,
0.4749455154,
-0.5632967353,
0.1342773139,
-0.1800836921,
-0.2470090389,
-0.1950259954,
-0.2122226954,
-0.9400281906,
0.5983254313,
-0.3932582438,
-0.3376323879,
0.1404374391,
-0.0093536684,
-0.1071944982,
0.3533649743,
-0.3859707415,
0.6106643677,
-0.1510049701,
0.419062525,
-0.0356495157,
-0.7993334532,
0.5284999013,
-0.2925728858,
0.315354526,
0.3162625432,
0.2950744033,
0.8208099008,
-0.4245670438,
0.7541055679,
-0.1098298803,
-0.0008592723,
0.0498384386,
0.0639903322,
0.4669742286,
-0.1157659963,
0.0971978754,
0.3481315672,
-0.1432650834,
-0.1257006973,
-0.6620066166,
0.4233263433,
-0.4337306321,
-0.1537158787,
-0.4638492763,
-0.4789106548,
0.1052849814,
0.6138443947,
0.7763721347,
0.6917552948,
-0.3529347479,
0.0084492816,
0.7238866091,
0.1686758399,
0.6534298658,
0.6261486411,
-0.1285784394,
-0.4309837818,
0.5446102023,
-0.1786952168,
-0.0298637152,
0.7626769543,
-0.0974578112,
-0.498522222,
-0.7779115438,
-0.4789420962,
0.2496981621,
-0.6259385347,
-0.459515959,
-1.1032370329,
-0.3060762584,
-0.6278081536,
-0.4457275271,
-0.5246022344,
-0.5296216011,
0.0239628088,
-0.2895807922,
0.0990175307,
1.0143927336,
0.054533422,
0.4394196868,
-0.8083254695,
0.7941924334,
-0.1281418651,
0.3333095014,
-0.0534491576,
-0.4213197827,
-0.2410651594,
0.1040863395,
-0.3849935234,
-0.7687236071,
0.4960524738,
0.1468771845,
0.7679342628,
0.6102644205,
0.3685305119,
0.1615013778,
-0.5077974796,
0.4959229529,
0.3658467233,
-0.8523237705,
0.452263087,
-0.1703921109,
0.4196472168,
0.6366135478,
0.3505669534,
-0.3852792084,
-0.6233032346,
-0.4454948306,
-1.1167522669,
0.4963595867,
0.4761924148,
0.084164232,
0.1312704384,
-0.0578274913,
0.2665967047,
0.3856555223,
-0.5754400492,
-0.6667352319,
-0.8101329803,
-0.3286350667,
-0.2360896468,
-0.1141673848,
-0.1051935926,
-0.1042297333,
0.7252505422,
-0.223100841,
0.1914957613,
0.1353210658,
-0.273301661,
0.0534020513,
0.5062878728,
0.6934893131,
0.6100679636,
-0.3255777359,
0.2275771797,
-0.0658479184,
-0.5833594203,
0.1248212308,
0.4411087334,
-0.3448553085,
0.4383749962,
0.3757116497,
0.7597186565,
0.2294389009,
-0.6406683922,
0.6608673334,
-0.2918308377,
-0.4070830941,
-0.4214036167,
-0.3280906081,
-0.1055895612,
-0.2798860669,
0.6306626201,
0.5519689322,
0.1112982854,
-0.1986080557,
0.3560022712,
0.2387005538,
-0.3118245006,
-0.1526711285,
0.8159046173,
0.2621517181,
-0.0435196385,
0.3407301605,
-0.1328803897,
-0.5502929688,
0.3478436172,
0.8397756219,
0.8418534398,
-0.3574595749,
0.1857377887,
0.2114072293,
0.3286261857,
0.0077359895,
-0.2452671528,
-0.0813359767,
-0.6200284362,
-0.4903696179,
-0.6917047501,
-0.3879311681,
0.0526916496,
-0.6788691878,
-0.0090904068,
0.0404633284,
0.3014223278,
0.1183641478,
-0.2271151096,
-0.1879921257,
0.2073741406,
-0.2445927411,
0.7507101297,
-0.9172367454,
0.4863106906,
0.7310888767,
-0.3339354992,
-0.4566988051,
-0.1737906486,
-0.0755669847,
-0.3432624042,
0.0949106514,
0.2816341817,
-0.3338558674,
0.0445253998,
0.1469130963,
-0.6967314482,
1.108094573,
0.1320666373,
-0.3582620025,
-0.1031923592,
0.2859432399,
0.4873563349,
-0.6661200523,
0.3825881779,
0.5221915841,
0.332365185,
0.2373301685,
-0.61887604,
0.0673087388,
-0.6097767353,
-0.1417012364,
0.3716607988,
0.0435017683,
0.9044935703,
-0.2422643453,
-0.262472868,
-0.0591731854,
0.5968647599,
0.2420885563,
0.3937996924,
0.1985626519,
0.4082500637,
0.5557317138,
0.1287893653,
1.1958755255,
-0.549813807,
0.1128807217,
0.9884045124,
-0.1221493185,
0.3768257201,
0.1485879123,
0.0755832642,
0.584656179,
0.1017021686,
-0.0958399028,
0.5469359159,
0.0744967833,
-0.4026712179,
0.1878759265,
0.0729361251,
-0.4730260074,
0.5948592424,
0.1473177969,
-0.4732356071,
-0.7000103593,
0.212280497,
0.1190306023,
0.4366244972,
-0.3159891367,
0.907807827,
-0.0481203794,
-0.6540532112,
0.4356426895,
0.6391019225,
1.101154685,
-0.8635178208,
-0.028748503,
-0.385091424,
0.2794619501,
-0.3464171588,
-0.3403398991,
0.5692490935,
0.1937460899,
-0.6600294709,
-0.275700897,
0.7731769681,
-0.4785980582,
-0.8168788552,
-0.018435061,
0.5666667223,
0.0778466463,
-0.4639173746,
-0.2719147205,
-0.4265631735,
-0.1898864359,
0.0035108181,
0.3397513926,
0.1579271555,
-0.2454277575,
0.5117329955,
0.755182445,
-0.0666115731,
-0.0895847455,
0.2619341016,
0.9002363086,
-0.3920744956,
-0.8748946786,
-0.6244176626,
0.4035125077,
-0.0082515869,
-0.0612540096,
0.8647307754,
1.1706569195,
0.4563345313,
-0.2216042727,
1.202362299,
0.0345640592,
0.6145669222,
-0.4764787853,
1.0200808048,
-0.0830811188,
0.2115237266,
-0.2040679902,
-0.9293067455,
-0.346513927,
0.4786893427,
0.0681079701,
-0.0813110322,
0.7626144886,
0.7792013884,
-0.1479525119,
0.1403046697,
0.15408957,
-0.0713254139,
0.2865873873,
0.2392092198,
0.4496084154,
-0.6082208753,
0.5809646249,
-0.2224426568,
-0.3364391625,
0.123186484,
-0.7776702642,
-0.9977697134,
-0.6501791477,
-0.1584635228,
-0.0893694162,
-0.1547690034,
0.7135273814,
0.5625923276,
-1.1000204086,
-0.1372120976,
-0.1619707793,
0.1028938144,
-0.3607187867,
-0.2516100109,
0.6248793006,
0.0383617505,
-0.6863198876,
0.5296269059,
0.1927841455,
0.3242916465,
-0.1819399595,
0.0219989549,
0.112804912,
0.0388718806,
0.688598454,
0.0874447525,
-0.3736321032,
0.4097733796,
-0.1459212601,
0.2133450955,
0.2260327041,
1.1825720072,
-0.9078787565,
0.2310026139,
0.085453406,
0.3977578878,
0.7784476876,
0.2645474374,
0.6756160855,
-0.9958272576,
0.0886856616,
0.0835357681,
0.4009804726,
0.4130642414,
-0.2417814434,
0.0956697017,
0.0687469617,
-0.1262595505,
-0.5186600685,
0.154230848,
-0.8716709614,
-0.4105547369,
0.7444152832,
0.0579064265,
0.1286611408,
-0.4635058343,
-0.1638514102,
0.360157609,
-0.4108134806,
0.9254035354,
-0.0443950444,
-0.2266695052,
-0.2620303333,
0.0584821776,
0.3377491832,
-0.1347183287,
-1.0359044075,
-0.0271049496,
0.5327374339,
0.1648624241,
0.433208853,
0.7225067616,
-0.3146454394,
-0.0300446283,
0.1304075122,
0.3959331214,
-0.7035684586,
-0.3879849911,
-0.4962053597,
0.4789657295,
-0.6227542162,
-0.2249926925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04765v1 | The HCI Aspects of Public Deployment of Research Chatbots: A User Study, Design Recommendations, and Open Challenges | 2023-06-07T20:24:43 | 2023-06-07T20:24:43 | Morteza Behrooz, William Ngan, Joshua Lane, Giuliano Morse, Benjamin Babcock, Kurt Shuster, Mojtaba Komeili, Moya Chen, Melanie Kambadur, Y-Lan Boureau, Jason Weston | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Publicly deploying research chatbots is a nuanced topic involving necessary
risk-benefit analyses. While there have recently been frequent discussions on
whether it is responsible to deploy such models, there has been far less focus
on the interaction paradigms and design approaches that the resulting
interfaces should adopt, in order to achieve their goals more effectively. We
aim to pose, ground, and attempt to answer HCI questions involved in this
scope, by reporting on a mixed-methods user study conducted on a recent
research chatbot. We find that abstract anthropomorphic representation for the
agent has a significant effect on user's perception, that offering AI
explainability may have an impact on feedback rates, and that two (diegetic and
extradiegetic) levels of the chat experience should be intentionally designed.
We offer design recommendations and areas of further focus for the research
community. | [
-0.5148737431,
-0.5848554969,
0.3917473257,
0.4685417116,
-0.0971410722,
0.1827477366,
-0.1440104991,
-0.7868595719,
0.307559371,
0.3712449968,
-0.3755791485,
-0.1984034777,
-0.074387975,
0.1009076834,
-0.194322899,
0.8760777712,
0.0736975744,
-0.3155577481,
-0.4735237062,
0.0710332468,
-0.6642653942,
-0.8153942823,
-0.4000423849,
-0.0900985003,
0.997606039,
0.5862613916,
1.2154297829,
0.2825804651,
0.6321920753,
0.295614928,
-0.170348838,
-0.0462651514,
-0.6108107567,
-0.0871976316,
0.1827173233,
-0.7418103814,
-0.2840774357,
0.1067441329,
0.3785214126,
0.7250636816,
-0.2984795868,
-0.0068541351,
0.0237836558,
0.2872108817,
-0.8883214593,
-0.1544238776,
0.0540968254,
0.1304420084,
-0.2756202817,
-0.1767052114,
-0.5424884558,
-0.4134343565,
0.297518909,
-0.720228672,
-0.1045464277,
0.3425202072,
0.4973350465,
-0.1978403181,
-0.6796186566,
-0.0795088559,
-1.4442027807,
0.9231505394,
-0.6570817828,
0.1017590985,
0.2389475703,
0.626627326,
-0.4371341467,
-0.3312254846,
-0.4642880559,
-0.3740788698,
-0.5035623908,
-0.0187980272,
-0.3043355644,
0.208041206,
-0.0052381516,
0.4225006402,
-0.4748677015,
0.186468333,
-0.6134336591,
-0.15696235,
0.83281672,
0.181636557,
0.3608207405,
0.1870341897,
-0.3714125752,
-0.203870073,
-0.4694576859,
-0.0576729737,
0.7475016713,
0.3189087808,
-0.5551008582,
0.7254689336,
-0.0634479746,
0.2817799449,
-0.3002443314,
0.4038570225,
0.3148486018,
-0.2833223641,
0.0811527371,
-0.3485779166,
0.5507546663,
0.4026660919,
0.3738362789,
-0.0008863081,
-0.0778176114,
-0.0262684897,
0.958114028,
-0.3998920023,
-0.1084940359,
0.3483582735,
-0.6963043213,
-0.5045074224,
-0.0934408531,
-0.7675000429,
-0.8144400716,
-0.2284026742,
0.2770943046,
-0.1636413187,
-0.7860500216,
-0.1846511662,
-0.4391643703,
0.2647423446,
0.6173632741,
-0.582891345,
0.3870657086,
0.4398390949,
0.7968886495,
-0.1312586367,
-0.1725515574,
0.2568603456,
-0.1946199238,
-0.2143358588,
0.7797757983,
-0.5407811403,
-0.8745031357,
0.4697546363,
-0.1602806896,
-0.1873800009,
-0.335336417,
0.3350765705,
-0.2794216573,
0.5821675062,
-0.1416441053,
-0.2267962843,
-0.1414250582,
0.1157225668,
-0.1767268926,
0.5742505789,
0.1072236821,
-1.0314722061,
0.0265876446,
-1.188524127,
-0.4149270356,
0.2925789356,
-0.2407640666,
-0.1335361898,
0.1799151599,
-0.2658273578,
0.0670525357,
0.0771813467,
-0.2465539128,
-0.4230413437,
-0.4146725833,
0.4987856746,
-0.3360058963,
0.7133866549,
0.5062114596,
-0.1059270799,
0.6205240488,
-0.4673121572,
-0.1705002189,
0.1439759582,
-0.047654748,
-0.328286469,
0.249110505,
0.4178988338,
-0.1800464392,
-0.033974696,
-0.582763195,
-0.1121737584,
-0.1684207469,
0.4304694831,
0.5597028136,
0.1181167737,
0.6200197339,
-0.5680017471,
0.7170006633,
-0.048560895,
0.7020807266,
0.1949660778,
-0.7762179971,
-0.3757238984,
-0.3599646389,
0.1024883986,
0.3001227379,
-0.4107454121,
0.1487288177,
0.2705475986,
-0.6740977764,
-0.629997313,
-0.2452126741,
0.2451424301,
0.1737733334,
0.0128847221,
-0.3841153383,
-0.261300385,
-1.2568192482,
0.0627441481,
-0.5636623502,
-0.4051841199,
0.8227989674,
0.449619323,
-0.5084264874,
1.0359102488,
-0.4489423931,
0.0856253058,
-0.0430293307,
0.3899142742,
-0.3269509077,
0.368011862,
0.7189232707,
-1.0210849047,
0.0549825057,
-0.0642772019,
-0.6447160244,
0.197229743,
0.1479802877,
-0.2607211471,
-0.023320647,
-0.0581870973,
-0.7891106009,
0.7663612366,
0.4227026403,
-0.144214958,
0.4631930292,
-0.3636163175,
0.5195305347,
-0.7234832048,
0.2952409983,
0.0820080563,
0.1855013818,
-0.9333133698,
0.1456636786,
-0.2855708301,
-0.6659830213,
-0.6768670082,
0.5225353837,
-0.1400128603,
-0.0048799957,
-0.5820143819,
0.0700743198,
-0.2600497603,
0.3496707678,
0.0188486185,
0.808709681,
0.1867746264,
-0.4994581938,
0.1290198714,
0.4199379086,
-0.144194901,
0.3985656202,
-1.1285164356,
0.5116580725,
-0.1047091559,
0.3668994606,
-1.1803232431,
-0.4515649378,
0.6347621679,
-0.6503170133,
-0.1338371336,
0.1995401084,
-0.1923583597,
-0.4769252539,
-0.3358007967,
0.6055190563,
0.5398193598,
-0.0896934271,
0.6338018179,
0.7995141745,
0.0585430153,
-0.2981691658,
-0.5099819899,
0.0542133041,
-0.3927723467,
-0.7373649478,
0.1051261202,
-0.0237961896,
-0.6843321323,
-0.2172436863,
0.26478374,
-0.1969377697,
0.3174262941,
0.5634067059,
0.0315060429,
-0.1499814391,
-0.1490470767,
-0.5024127364,
-0.0317444243,
0.0387258157,
0.5611409545,
0.2188075632,
-0.1369412243,
-0.4345605075,
-0.6205253005,
0.673194766,
0.4780473113,
-0.090338558,
0.579218924,
0.45111081,
-0.2057234049,
0.3022914231,
-0.4363362789,
-0.2486602813,
-0.4606798887,
-0.0592106134,
-0.050794974,
-0.8901819587,
0.5011167526,
-0.0241278652,
0.7537321448,
0.1301123351,
0.6145820618,
-0.6497045159,
1.0067209005,
0.9292564392,
0.0498266704,
0.5793403387,
0.164379701,
0.3761413395,
-0.453276366,
-0.323091656,
-0.8893545866,
-0.2383930385,
-0.6902205348,
-0.3524234295,
0.1867610067,
-0.3414545357,
0.0078526037,
0.3573045731,
-0.3559366465,
-0.1234232038,
0.8581024408,
0.3458491266,
0.0900659189,
-0.3943729997,
0.4818187654,
0.2712714374,
-0.4909831583,
-0.5736100674,
0.7056319714,
0.6699287891,
0.9457300305,
0.2467805296,
0.5423286557,
0.6064567566,
0.1493994594,
-0.5276750922,
0.3516189754,
0.6854821444,
-0.9858101606,
-0.5136810541,
-0.3180713356,
-1.1447250843,
0.2315280437,
-0.3865423203,
-0.8259812593,
0.3035530448,
0.339607805,
-0.3104795516,
-0.3228821158,
-1.0092531443,
0.7419789433,
-0.1215317696,
-0.0095479824,
-0.7280945182,
-0.9203209877,
0.2402848303,
0.3882390261,
0.4416981339,
-0.1095706746,
0.3231091201,
0.7237510681,
-0.3138787746,
1.0747269392,
-0.3229069114,
0.1139072031,
0.5451601744,
-0.1691500843,
0.2029783577,
-0.0923558027,
0.1778458953,
0.191861406,
0.1595591605,
-0.6828446984,
-0.7618228793,
0.3673296571,
-1.043787241,
-0.8602243662,
-0.2544757724,
-0.4530664086,
-0.2548768222,
-0.1542705595,
-0.2760137022,
0.1820570529,
-0.4760378003,
0.2328489274,
0.4445161223,
-0.5263687968,
-0.1194862872,
0.2070753574,
-0.2742838562,
-0.1751128882,
0.4880178571,
-0.3539601564,
0.2448954731,
0.148185119,
0.3227022886,
-0.1914332062,
-0.5557301044,
-0.4895915091,
0.0999593884,
-0.3166205585,
0.4666410685,
-0.2434992939,
-0.3663363755,
-0.3708909452,
-0.1459876448,
-0.4405838847,
-0.213875562,
-0.3219762743,
0.1429516524,
0.4565279484,
0.9536952972,
0.1851181388,
0.5554349422,
-0.3291119635,
0.4345439076,
0.3088603318,
0.3440701663,
0.0098438002,
-0.3862362206,
-0.2990652621,
0.318138361,
-0.2140213847,
-0.5563538671,
-0.1378890127,
-0.348959446,
0.7268002033,
0.3202575743,
0.4730353355,
0.4842279851,
-0.281234026,
0.815007329,
0.0365555175,
-0.0577034093,
0.4551989734,
-0.6166290045,
0.0635375604,
0.7199097276,
0.6944836378,
-0.6723014712,
-0.4238585532,
-0.5735885501,
-0.529905498,
0.5014778972,
0.7796400785,
0.5974069834,
0.1737672389,
0.0337881483,
-0.0191874746,
0.2535898685,
-0.3504263759,
-0.3860021234,
-0.1361330301,
0.1846215725,
-0.1701918989,
-0.4120376706,
-0.4837810695,
0.0824466944,
0.2076440901,
0.1939844936,
0.4805308878,
-0.0546259098,
0.1823939532,
-0.1286990345,
0.4419675171,
0.6914697289,
0.8321950436,
-0.460197866,
-0.0669739097,
-0.3796619475,
-0.1556218565,
-0.1978834569,
-0.0031832019,
-0.0265910141,
-0.2112607956,
0.1921482533,
0.6118286252,
0.2955796421,
-0.4975462556,
0.663461566,
-0.2913740277,
-0.4537837207,
-0.2596832812,
0.0986172259,
-0.045866318,
0.3165499568,
0.2725481093,
0.0234378763,
0.2430256605,
-0.857567668,
-0.162833482,
0.3065580428,
-0.5045566559,
-0.4630307555,
0.6265079975,
0.86451298,
-1.0180319548,
0.7261000872,
0.4153557718,
-0.1098231375,
0.4026460946,
0.3324304223,
0.771220386,
-0.1505855322,
0.4267241657,
-0.1935487688,
-0.0123593882,
0.2510290444,
0.250741303,
-0.362641722,
-0.6670513749,
-0.0174999442,
-0.228290081,
-1.0750696659,
-0.1599756628,
-0.5744864941,
0.3196968138,
-0.1004051715,
-0.3515875638,
0.437517792,
-0.3238923252,
-0.5041405559,
-0.2146634758,
0.2938521504,
0.6580207944,
-0.8601183295,
0.2069938332,
0.7728844285,
-0.3687543273,
-0.2210564911,
-0.2653149366,
0.2821398079,
-0.5756126642,
-0.1103330478,
-0.0002097676,
-0.1303189397,
-0.3716977239,
-0.5577727556,
-0.5656314492,
0.6650559902,
0.13053976,
-0.2502281964,
-0.1792183071,
0.1866220683,
0.8849289417,
-0.209795773,
0.7757767439,
0.1277421415,
0.4106377363,
0.2003732771,
-1.190002799,
-0.2215659022,
-0.4449770451,
0.2051642686,
-0.0444222838,
-0.8686602712,
0.2530813515,
-0.0375106782,
-0.3725687265,
-0.0525884964,
0.6529873013,
0.2102380097,
0.6295211911,
0.6192154884,
-0.1104995608,
0.4526177347,
0.4883004129,
1.0443432331,
-0.0610762201,
-0.1504202634,
0.8332570791,
-0.2099277228,
0.5874843597,
0.6114335656,
-0.343272388,
0.4927201867,
0.6199176908,
0.2614927292,
0.3601859808,
0.3389959335,
-0.188452214,
0.1084500253,
-0.4857959747,
-0.3359969258,
0.492405802,
0.0468068235,
-0.0235969331,
-0.0660284311,
0.3179065585,
-0.1806400567,
0.076469034,
0.1567776948,
0.7930110693,
0.0880249664,
-0.4446420074,
0.1673003733,
-0.1850921065,
0.3947669566,
-0.3583657444,
-0.2717937231,
-0.0919945985,
0.0580479428,
-0.3108513653,
-0.8026166558,
0.3289049864,
-0.1754812896,
-0.0612908751,
-0.2286769897,
0.7210819125,
0.1500284523,
-0.0142398635,
0.1941485703,
0.5775505304,
0.5583925247,
-0.0821395889,
-0.4125280678,
0.1624781191,
-0.2736525536,
-0.3284167051,
0.4079906046,
0.1481602788,
-0.2419413626,
0.8755933046,
0.3895202279,
-0.2927126884,
-0.1565991938,
0.3652157784,
0.9325094819,
-0.6395744681,
-0.2588740289,
-0.3769696057,
0.648891747,
-0.0182877518,
-0.6184719801,
0.7225604057,
0.4691261053,
0.4508174658,
-0.0091142822,
0.7771011591,
-0.2501195073,
0.4911911488,
0.2504369318,
0.5331608057,
-0.4041637778,
-0.0905169994,
-0.1973062605,
-0.4976055324,
-0.1243027747,
0.283719629,
-0.1546718776,
0.0292668026,
0.3274171948,
0.8004888296,
0.1826329082,
0.4141470492,
0.2962203324,
-0.2434638739,
0.3700374961,
0.0710990205,
1.5323705673,
-0.0500004888,
0.4873921275,
-0.4594064057,
-0.519313097,
-0.5466637015,
-0.3726497889,
-1.013035655,
-0.5739448071,
-0.2872439921,
-0.1213617772,
0.1613515019,
0.6465156078,
0.9972600937,
-0.6811620593,
-0.5315074921,
0.1327449232,
0.2037388086,
0.0499749482,
-0.291131109,
-0.2090230137,
-0.1180753633,
-0.4020686448,
0.4439144433,
0.0707041025,
0.0296272822,
-0.4539827108,
0.1001735032,
-0.2630465627,
0.0672078282,
0.3450489044,
0.6354973316,
-0.507109046,
-0.7348450422,
0.1125913635,
-0.1765271276,
0.3102779388,
1.0143351555,
-0.3281004131,
0.4035058022,
0.3668350875,
0.5878368616,
0.5730386376,
0.3047459722,
1.0488405228,
-0.3389303386,
0.3087736666,
0.5565735102,
-0.1285887808,
0.1182127744,
-0.3541239202,
0.5443639755,
0.0876520351,
-0.7928370833,
-0.9286864996,
0.0845430046,
-0.9605736136,
-0.2095000744,
1.097599864,
-0.0337515846,
-0.2762462199,
-0.4377416074,
-0.4621382952,
0.0776953772,
-0.5431210399,
1.0390486717,
0.5434602499,
-0.4858286977,
-0.1942907423,
-0.507995069,
0.2273184806,
0.0215148013,
-0.6412864923,
0.2340202481,
0.4705463946,
-0.0948961452,
0.2938693762,
0.784604013,
-0.0059934976,
0.2881213725,
0.2060068846,
0.3950144351,
0.1495684683,
-0.466311276,
-0.2844395041,
0.0772566944,
0.4037233293,
-0.4755245447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04757v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04757v3 | INSTRUCTEVAL: Towards Holistic Evaluation of Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models | 2023-06-07T20:12:29 | 2023-06-15T05:08:56 | Yew Ken Chia, Pengfei Hong, Lidong Bing, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-tuned large language models have revolutionized natural language
processing and have shown great potential in applications such as
conversational agents. These models, such as GPT-4, can not only master
language but also solve complex tasks in areas like mathematics, coding,
medicine, and law. Despite their impressive capabilities, there is still a lack
of comprehensive understanding regarding their full potential, primarily due to
the black-box nature of many models and the absence of holistic evaluation
studies. To address these challenges, we present INSTRUCTEVAL, a more
comprehensive evaluation suite designed specifically for instruction-tuned
large language models. Unlike previous works, our evaluation involves a
rigorous assessment of models based on problem-solving, writing ability, and
alignment to human values. We take a holistic approach to analyze various
factors affecting model performance, including the pretraining foundation,
instruction-tuning data, and training methods. Our findings reveal that the
quality of instruction data is the most crucial factor in scaling model
performance. While open-source models demonstrate impressive writing abilities,
there is substantial room for improvement in problem-solving and alignment. We
are encouraged by the rapid development of models by the open-source community,
but we also highlight the need for rigorous evaluation to support claims made
about these models. Through INSTRUCTEVAL, we aim to foster a deeper
understanding of instruction-tuned models and advancements in their
capabilities. INSTRUCTEVAL is publicly available at
https://github.com/declare-lab/instruct-eval. | [
-0.1280093044,
-0.8725727201,
0.3569749892,
0.0381743535,
0.2132969946,
0.4170161486,
-0.549420476,
-0.2167582661,
-0.5061299205,
0.4798169136,
-0.3056985438,
-0.5270628929,
-0.5938160419,
-0.2575887144,
-0.3710950017,
1.1817941666,
-0.0405705385,
0.244016245,
-0.5233476758,
0.1085542813,
-0.4924629033,
-0.4446910918,
-0.3034574389,
-0.4499305785,
-0.3064693511,
0.4191402495,
0.6735212803,
0.5835425258,
0.7495881915,
0.2952917814,
0.0909320638,
-0.0071140477,
-0.5104669929,
0.0059792609,
-0.2765474916,
-0.0848606527,
-0.6950440407,
0.0119165117,
0.8163174987,
0.8750001788,
-0.4063262939,
0.4349375665,
0.4123046398,
0.5524578691,
-0.6592892408,
0.2891508639,
-0.4944312871,
-0.2896244526,
-0.055979874,
0.0982629135,
-0.6003589034,
-0.735476613,
0.3340982795,
-0.4383445084,
0.1868708581,
-0.0785543174,
0.5736488104,
0.208133176,
-0.2416770607,
-0.3473449051,
-0.7388187051,
0.6275473833,
-0.9862562418,
0.3155199885,
0.3319651484,
0.3122784793,
-0.2239425778,
-0.731234014,
-0.2797623277,
-0.6167370677,
0.2256019861,
0.095491156,
-0.2116978168,
0.297444433,
0.2205942124,
0.6146866679,
-0.7237153053,
0.2550556362,
-0.148055166,
-0.0720390826,
0.4534955621,
0.1298182458,
0.3622469902,
0.2995412648,
-0.1347194463,
-0.1321267486,
-0.6804461479,
-0.0644180775,
0.3725512922,
0.3295156956,
-0.0169741567,
0.4843502045,
-0.1181385741,
0.7643532753,
0.2543781996,
0.0991838574,
0.045286689,
-0.1794064045,
-0.2723987103,
0.0665331185,
0.6138693094,
0.0511752479,
0.17506513,
-0.2612680197,
-0.3227522075,
0.0575877689,
0.5576844811,
-1.0672299862,
-0.3120481074,
-0.0090293614,
-0.1561979949,
-0.2523091435,
-0.0642104894,
-0.7547326684,
-0.3631272912,
-0.5734627247,
0.7478479743,
-0.5547683239,
-0.3077370524,
0.2703459561,
0.2898643315,
0.300498724,
0.3353603482,
-1.0871527195,
0.5161859989,
0.9393814206,
0.7094630003,
0.0503044724,
-0.3205108941,
-0.6068508625,
-0.0925442427,
-0.4260669053,
0.5290889144,
-0.9208961725,
-0.2535458505,
0.1709339619,
-0.1394117475,
-0.1126595736,
-0.4860039949,
0.4606027901,
-0.464340955,
0.2132029384,
-0.0632189438,
-1.1074931622,
-0.0274128299,
0.3103313744,
-0.4474082887,
1.0057376623,
0.4727618992,
-0.537555933,
0.0732765272,
-0.9325965047,
-0.4658434391,
0.4717027247,
0.1792670935,
-0.3882185817,
0.1681751162,
0.1494592726,
0.394223541,
-0.5518761277,
0.3748499751,
-0.1592121571,
-0.3877135813,
-0.0523591004,
-0.4356794655,
0.6347968578,
-0.0941150263,
-0.6047431827,
0.3431285322,
-0.6977626681,
0.3172502518,
-0.1031642854,
-0.1715931892,
-0.2787441909,
-0.1282693297,
-0.1552986801,
-0.0553643554,
0.3235279322,
-0.4072578847,
0.3256867826,
-0.5788251162,
0.471536845,
0.7252427936,
-0.1409045756,
0.5104026794,
0.0810265839,
0.7957746983,
-0.3877670169,
0.3604862094,
-0.1519945413,
-0.1942442507,
-0.6192700863,
-0.0471292436,
0.2558894753,
0.3443403244,
-0.4912011921,
0.2452125847,
-0.2203116864,
-0.7804041505,
-0.8627265096,
0.1097090319,
0.7710363269,
0.5928676724,
0.3938821852,
-0.0699212924,
-0.1129835173,
-0.8331779838,
-0.283451438,
0.0337927639,
0.0122842025,
-0.1940388381,
0.7662292123,
-0.2195238918,
0.587413013,
-0.4446357787,
0.0824071616,
-0.2067084759,
0.1658600122,
0.0261725411,
0.4599983692,
0.3147849441,
-0.3403580189,
-0.6099880338,
0.3356839418,
-0.5200566649,
0.0322111994,
0.2887779772,
-0.1886547059,
-0.0058162375,
0.3864803314,
-0.3746117055,
0.2922899723,
0.5178053379,
-0.2859236002,
0.7545611858,
-0.4493820071,
0.0931999832,
-0.8955334425,
-0.0452029333,
0.0730110183,
-0.0442074686,
-0.6030200124,
0.1896186471,
0.3094592988,
-0.2507207096,
-0.0815629512,
0.3054458499,
-0.4495815039,
0.0166473556,
-0.1494390815,
-0.0312590525,
0.0688321516,
0.374658525,
-0.1343611926,
0.9172738791,
0.4943793416,
-0.3043071926,
0.3030890226,
0.1915742904,
-0.6949465871,
0.5363368988,
-0.8784350157,
0.4487396479,
0.1066398844,
-0.0635190681,
-0.5966974497,
-0.4563337564,
-0.0447584987,
-0.0260549728,
0.5909130573,
-0.2461771369,
-0.4240161777,
-0.2571125925,
-0.1653195769,
0.2431534678,
0.4414455593,
-0.5584591627,
0.2331387997,
0.4223850369,
-0.1797145605,
-0.5257411003,
-0.1303923577,
-0.0911964849,
-0.0557430759,
-0.3484153152,
0.4624148905,
-0.2278594971,
-0.235497877,
-0.020822417,
0.0101946797,
-0.1168798804,
0.0083183516,
0.0918123648,
0.4501516521,
-0.4300385416,
0.2475062162,
0.1355246007,
0.0372358784,
0.1870445311,
-0.5253919363,
0.4370228648,
-0.8372300863,
-0.5208144188,
-0.3707900345,
0.071664989,
0.7052233219,
-0.7459449768,
0.6352790594,
0.4809559882,
-0.3702401519,
-0.3565822244,
-0.4240432084,
-0.1142285317,
-0.4411459565,
0.6208069921,
0.0845538974,
-0.8352848291,
0.0532753021,
-0.0589686073,
0.2740448415,
0.327647388,
0.7923668027,
0.1438181549,
0.9927271605,
0.6583685279,
0.1353321373,
0.4388277531,
-0.3346672654,
0.1460175812,
-0.9107093215,
-0.2150324434,
-0.4041635096,
0.1605533212,
-0.3455826342,
-0.2737845778,
0.4283505678,
-0.1675005555,
-0.5751315355,
0.2325535417,
-0.7683503032,
0.726364255,
0.3703835607,
-0.0365055986,
0.1829475909,
-0.2944983542,
0.1133459806,
0.0398998074,
-0.5259501934,
-0.8080523014,
1.2470456362,
0.3468384445,
0.7869036198,
-0.0459378734,
0.4271964431,
0.1352934837,
0.6666638255,
-0.8294140697,
0.323610574,
-0.2012935281,
-0.52563411,
-0.354929775,
-0.2369105816,
-0.8010155559,
0.217041418,
-0.0692733601,
-0.6371046305,
-0.3381548822,
0.3331661522,
-0.3992941976,
0.2160705775,
-1.033195734,
1.288659215,
-0.5162533522,
-0.4437083602,
-0.3671087623,
-0.5781735182,
0.3594381809,
-0.0675468221,
0.0754261836,
0.1087625921,
0.2859920561,
0.6312625408,
-0.444126904,
0.805824697,
-0.0647993758,
-0.1841578037,
0.1964672506,
0.1243921295,
0.3650393784,
-0.1446230561,
-0.1451214701,
0.0281568393,
0.3413879871,
-0.2206599265,
-0.8053013086,
0.7163837552,
-0.7841701508,
-0.5319988132,
-0.1766191274,
-0.5220503807,
-0.4456483424,
0.1774497479,
0.2816825211,
0.8680495024,
-0.5081915259,
0.3422008455,
0.7167857885,
-0.0732093155,
0.301120162,
0.3463258743,
-0.1644677073,
-0.3238857687,
0.956349194,
0.1996623278,
0.5677976012,
0.3863456249,
0.3667246699,
-0.2610345781,
-0.6187736392,
-0.470592469,
0.0407302789,
-0.6450740695,
-0.1831573248,
-0.1698866338,
-0.2866323888,
-0.2700938582,
-0.1476831436,
-0.6402381063,
-0.1034614965,
-0.2601982355,
-0.0419660248,
0.100986436,
1.0166084766,
0.3719432056,
0.3382625878,
-0.656881392,
-0.0667574555,
0.2122996002,
0.5123733878,
0.1691699326,
-0.6918460131,
-0.6620449424,
0.2498527467,
-0.5492332578,
-0.6682311296,
0.2332232594,
0.3582748175,
0.4208547175,
0.2964225113,
0.0629120618,
0.6812703609,
-0.6098490357,
0.4610978663,
-0.1004177183,
-1.2821125984,
0.6708948612,
-0.158853516,
0.3586176932,
0.6082713008,
0.2533909678,
-0.1794287264,
-0.3149097562,
-0.5697768331,
-0.6405164599,
0.6897726059,
0.0940622091,
0.1076756939,
0.1465633661,
0.3869639337,
0.2598692179,
0.2827547789,
-0.4832978845,
0.3125315607,
-0.4308938682,
-0.3252426684,
-0.0178374127,
-0.1319833994,
0.0382405482,
-0.4524003565,
0.7242547274,
-0.1209101155,
-0.0768486783,
-0.1856044531,
-0.2527854741,
-0.0427994356,
0.4805681705,
0.3909173012,
0.9749504924,
-0.2243314385,
-0.0923348889,
0.0558575839,
-0.5903622508,
0.1151827574,
0.0881225392,
0.0365619808,
-0.4277890921,
0.6798138022,
0.8100962043,
0.5665081739,
-0.648771584,
0.6040408015,
0.030003313,
0.0554640554,
-0.1797007322,
0.1686882377,
-0.047684595,
0.1684236825,
-0.0329041518,
-0.1018327847,
0.1312820613,
-0.4931603968,
-0.1366268396,
0.5076250434,
-0.4912694991,
-0.636099875,
0.4881111681,
0.1330896318,
-0.5227570534,
0.9606198668,
-0.2569850683,
-0.4912218451,
0.5678095222,
0.8207690716,
0.9956880212,
-0.5500861406,
0.4437350929,
0.3341839612,
0.4876018167,
-0.0881187394,
-0.0934102163,
-0.0225595813,
-0.4989651144,
-0.5769259334,
-0.6649680138,
-0.6807858348,
0.2088963985,
-0.9029508233,
0.1131955683,
-0.3959980011,
-0.0339004733,
0.0900085866,
0.0781795308,
-0.6149459481,
0.0389949866,
-0.2122651041,
0.6120787859,
-0.6493071318,
0.8830538392,
0.874651134,
-0.3258812726,
-0.8025864959,
0.1178594977,
-0.1878786385,
-0.5282353163,
0.4405416846,
0.1996630579,
-0.295468837,
0.2327035517,
-0.6544784904,
-0.5589392781,
0.817922771,
0.8035945892,
-0.5792640448,
-0.1254722327,
-0.0917179585,
0.8095108867,
-0.4375571012,
0.3867897689,
0.6490464211,
0.290039897,
0.0551902205,
-0.9137135148,
-0.2070845664,
-0.203997016,
-0.0493061282,
0.3213790059,
-0.3640386462,
0.6737511754,
-0.327750355,
-0.078399621,
-0.1660649329,
0.4585955143,
-0.1629133672,
0.1297779828,
0.0343934633,
0.4147094488,
0.9399683475,
-0.0282294378,
1.1638462543,
-0.3212727308,
0.5039553642,
1.1777038574,
-0.3917377293,
0.9806648493,
0.0047528702,
-0.2808487415,
0.4831460714,
0.4549247026,
0.0864668638,
0.2826959193,
0.0306687802,
-0.2045674473,
-0.2747722566,
0.0183708891,
-0.3484916091,
0.6405950189,
0.4681139886,
-0.0015224412,
-0.2146471888,
-0.0206172969,
0.0459440723,
0.224751249,
-0.3557956517,
0.6375806332,
-0.2079388201,
-0.6954815388,
0.6575159431,
-0.2015509754,
0.195103392,
-0.6801784039,
-0.2152392417,
-0.0128065469,
0.3598784804,
-0.113424018,
-0.8273025155,
0.2367499471,
0.0508671328,
0.0050017643,
-0.1872503608,
0.4609185755,
-0.5882539749,
-0.4830988348,
0.0621032938,
0.2877667546,
-0.0398694016,
-0.0607391782,
-0.5222201347,
-0.1552066356,
-0.1590524316,
-0.1755660325,
0.4011872709,
0.3162410855,
-0.1318584532,
0.6373203993,
0.4869558513,
-0.0278694052,
-0.1602434963,
0.1895282567,
0.7125803828,
-0.2731825113,
-0.2539637387,
-0.9996880889,
0.4837054908,
0.0155673558,
-0.4687426984,
0.8117188811,
0.5822559595,
0.7782812119,
-0.1648466885,
0.6646758318,
0.2314299345,
0.2483116984,
-0.4655780494,
0.7806665897,
-0.3259164393,
0.2349926084,
-0.4845875502,
-0.9260278344,
-0.1607652158,
0.5193964243,
-0.602838695,
0.0885231942,
0.5729779005,
0.7402393222,
-0.0532559864,
0.1481413394,
0.3137594163,
0.2142472714,
0.4023870528,
0.4742621779,
1.0445468426,
-0.1494898647,
0.3029085994,
-0.2509567142,
-0.5995168686,
-0.1327647269,
-0.8552932143,
-0.9864243865,
-0.6890819073,
-0.5291104913,
-0.1487670392,
0.1229188368,
1.0515943766,
0.6814107299,
-0.730427742,
-0.3462425768,
-0.2112161815,
0.0308370646,
-0.2350419164,
-0.1884163171,
0.6016776562,
-0.5308936834,
-0.7120235562,
0.4893027544,
0.5644373298,
-0.0941072032,
-0.4019620121,
0.0046966649,
0.1114998683,
0.10678868,
0.8181756139,
0.1682190001,
-0.6159768105,
-0.226210922,
-0.0382878967,
-0.0435705557,
-0.0310227778,
0.7918393016,
-0.5000484586,
0.8274805546,
0.1851101667,
0.843259871,
0.3515937626,
-0.0358236656,
0.6048307419,
-0.4993066192,
-0.1938842535,
0.4460282624,
0.1913701147,
0.504506588,
-0.2827171087,
0.404323101,
-0.2754360139,
-0.93264395,
-0.9133476019,
0.0733822286,
-0.5395116806,
-0.0517982468,
0.8397889137,
-0.1925149411,
0.0350078456,
0.1342336237,
-0.2196234465,
0.2198049128,
-0.1115942523,
0.7436750531,
0.9413298368,
-0.1160634011,
0.0002851307,
-0.7614504695,
0.4228072762,
0.1746964902,
-1.0517597198,
0.2753056586,
0.5616668463,
0.205518499,
-0.146858573,
0.1696749479,
-0.115397729,
0.1556505263,
-0.0948116183,
0.2326444387,
-0.0603592955,
-0.2905664742,
-0.5039177537,
0.1492514312,
0.2984464169,
-0.0641200095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04751v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04751v2 | How Far Can Camels Go? Exploring the State of Instruction Tuning on Open Resources | 2023-06-07T19:59:23 | 2023-10-30T20:36:20 | Yizhong Wang, Hamish Ivison, Pradeep Dasigi, Jack Hessel, Tushar Khot, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, David Wadden, Kelsey MacMillan, Noah A. Smith, Iz Beltagy, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work we explore recent advances in instruction-tuning language models
on a range of open instruction-following datasets. Despite recent claims that
open models can be on par with state-of-the-art proprietary models, these
claims are often accompanied by limited evaluation, making it difficult to
compare models across the board and determine the utility of various resources.
We provide a large set of instruction-tuned models from 6.7B to 65B parameters
in size, trained on 12 instruction datasets ranging from manually curated
(e.g., OpenAssistant) to synthetic and distilled (e.g., Alpaca) and
systematically evaluate them on their factual knowledge, reasoning,
multilinguality, coding, and open-ended instruction following abilities through
a collection of automatic, model-based, and human-based metrics. We further
introduce T\"ulu, our best performing instruction-tuned model suite finetuned
on a combination of high-quality open resources. Our experiments show that
different instruction-tuning datasets can uncover or enhance specific skills,
while no single dataset (or combination) provides the best performance across
all evaluations. Interestingly, we find that model and human preference-based
evaluations fail to reflect differences in model capabilities exposed by
benchmark-based evaluations, suggesting the need for the type of systemic
evaluation performed in this work. Our evaluations show that the best model in
any given evaluation reaches on average 87% of ChatGPT performance, and 73% of
GPT-4 performance, suggesting that further investment in building better base
models and instruction-tuning data is required to close the gap. We release our
instruction-tuned models, including a fully finetuned 65B T\"ulu, along with
our code, data, and evaluation framework at
https://github.com/allenai/open-instruct to facilitate future research. | [
-0.1906106472,
-0.5783738494,
0.0319109485,
-0.1376675665,
-0.0380607843,
-0.1230929866,
-0.6138116121,
-0.408518672,
-0.5278683305,
0.6235235929,
-0.5440926552,
-0.6397467256,
-0.5238460898,
-0.2864986956,
-0.2379497588,
1.3563715219,
-0.0659151897,
0.0392555445,
-0.0143131828,
-0.3331562579,
-0.6669141054,
-0.1370908916,
-0.1834240109,
-0.077337794,
0.4365143776,
0.7787105441,
0.7886411548,
0.9313822389,
0.4268009365,
0.1637598127,
0.0412750766,
0.3320842087,
-0.7521322966,
-0.2178960294,
-0.1393524408,
-0.3350250125,
-0.3412255645,
0.3048407137,
0.687132597,
0.854241848,
-0.374042809,
0.5682166815,
0.1448212713,
0.716732502,
-0.9140592217,
0.1256807446,
-0.5754570365,
-0.0618915744,
-0.3133027554,
-0.1199267283,
-0.6339148283,
-0.6869674325,
0.2934458554,
-0.522082448,
0.3571639657,
0.1870590001,
0.7912410498,
0.4354663193,
-0.282196492,
-0.3595803678,
-0.8498958945,
1.0314112902,
-0.421300143,
0.5810164213,
0.4360742569,
0.5064938664,
-0.1946156323,
-0.531244874,
-0.1408905238,
-0.3614255786,
0.3019118011,
0.1100407392,
-0.3268873692,
0.0754055753,
0.1365372688,
0.6954264045,
-0.3879838884,
0.3006950021,
-0.523008287,
0.0262588896,
0.1295258403,
0.1166896075,
0.1950955391,
0.3014927804,
-0.3020836115,
-0.3074582517,
-0.8570620418,
0.3204506338,
0.5370542407,
0.3746690452,
-0.0914906785,
0.6742187142,
-0.1873807758,
0.9828363657,
-0.2217302024,
0.3407712877,
-0.3240017295,
-0.1796631366,
-0.3078706563,
-0.0155970249,
0.4463067055,
0.2667657733,
0.3509529531,
-0.4043341279,
-0.3118975461,
-0.1273121685,
0.2412418425,
-0.9124034643,
-0.4391703904,
-0.1898853034,
-0.4761349559,
-0.0899448246,
0.0351062603,
-0.6545728445,
-0.2268118262,
-0.2236657739,
0.3944612443,
-0.5647662282,
-0.0799432024,
0.3120335937,
0.0228525363,
0.3922235072,
0.0413113385,
-1.1742515564,
0.4638164341,
0.679294765,
0.8545496464,
0.0563903376,
-0.1891753525,
-0.5906176567,
0.0516596101,
-0.6046420932,
0.7470641136,
-0.9597557783,
-0.427618444,
0.0322595239,
0.1212159842,
-0.1742407382,
-0.5144625306,
0.5067147017,
-0.6436976194,
0.2142075449,
-0.4070833027,
-0.5977479815,
-0.1453383416,
-0.2517787516,
-0.7487915158,
0.8406356573,
0.2516697943,
-0.591422379,
0.2931878269,
-0.7714032531,
-0.2819794118,
-0.2558255494,
0.1109315082,
-0.2405598909,
0.2608372569,
0.1816759259,
0.093454957,
-0.5685335398,
-0.1731862575,
-0.0914702192,
-0.6493487358,
0.1831153631,
-0.6560079455,
0.8440895677,
0.0212892611,
-0.2849515975,
0.1561189145,
-0.6483654976,
0.2836026549,
-0.1536208093,
-0.4267372191,
-0.1465587765,
0.0653726235,
-0.4351112545,
-0.1529786587,
0.2045658082,
-0.5721295476,
0.3008112013,
-0.3559488356,
0.459920913,
1.0761373043,
-0.1818313599,
0.4975827336,
-0.317617923,
0.7212864161,
-0.3084771931,
0.3227339685,
-0.2499730587,
-0.5024523139,
-0.9779055715,
0.013105806,
0.5275483727,
0.4055552185,
-0.2799705267,
0.1499650478,
-0.1088121384,
-0.568543613,
-1.0993416309,
-0.0446827896,
0.6461201906,
0.5971132517,
0.5968024731,
-0.3116777241,
-0.1341066211,
-0.6699524522,
-0.385103941,
0.0129193384,
0.0064001628,
0.4208946228,
0.3417536318,
0.256115675,
0.5828826427,
-0.5892215371,
0.1046757475,
0.1805029213,
-0.0033079584,
0.047395844,
0.4295208752,
0.3222533166,
-0.2141436636,
-0.2518861294,
0.2660691738,
-0.4757397771,
0.1339862347,
0.3750628829,
-0.4989317358,
0.1881417036,
0.2212397009,
-0.2886143029,
0.4385106266,
0.5588895082,
-0.1601697654,
0.6270021796,
-0.3989982009,
0.1955525875,
-0.5266370773,
-0.0386139676,
-0.135608837,
0.2939793468,
-0.2902151048,
0.1116471365,
0.1205732301,
-0.1501928121,
-0.1463612169,
0.4423879087,
-0.6307983398,
-0.3109060526,
-0.1349855661,
-0.0837066025,
-0.1122370437,
0.5160655975,
-0.2296577245,
1.1045314074,
0.511987865,
-0.4896789193,
0.2373201996,
0.1724683195,
-0.8606717587,
-0.0165462252,
-0.7752315402,
0.2696218491,
0.1855921745,
0.1194370687,
-0.6423744559,
-0.2304867059,
0.2126806527,
-0.112855114,
0.4711360037,
-0.2841512859,
-0.3096635342,
-0.2922347784,
-0.0283406731,
0.2739563286,
0.7600334883,
-0.7752686739,
0.2189620435,
0.0032116023,
0.116090253,
-0.9518134594,
-0.4009198546,
-0.3315483332,
0.0915797353,
-0.5652112961,
0.230302453,
-0.0697530657,
-0.027509328,
0.165641427,
-0.4495265484,
-0.1310067624,
0.0331194252,
0.1397003233,
0.372780323,
-0.5506507754,
0.2628170252,
0.1549515575,
-0.0461636856,
-0.1134399101,
-0.6002756357,
0.1645224094,
-0.4485088587,
-0.575294733,
-0.3313854039,
0.0748540908,
0.2937889099,
-0.7125818133,
0.8851450086,
0.5253369212,
-0.0740610361,
-0.3839665353,
-0.2727815211,
-0.1324822456,
-0.4679333568,
0.3526192009,
-0.1227025166,
-0.7793709636,
0.2416723818,
0.0118137589,
0.4558665156,
0.1429336518,
0.3623414636,
0.0358073488,
1.0171974897,
0.8786658645,
0.0471080355,
0.5755652785,
-0.384244591,
0.1392714828,
-0.7905209661,
-0.3068730235,
-0.6447390318,
-0.1631821692,
-0.9431884289,
-0.5558333993,
0.3308886886,
0.2061489671,
-0.4336415529,
0.0671351105,
-0.7301691771,
0.843549788,
0.7798862457,
0.3222222924,
0.0755083412,
-0.0658162609,
-0.1009082645,
0.2900643945,
-0.9421640038,
-0.6557592154,
1.1851187944,
0.1520655751,
0.838006556,
0.0070601054,
0.2797699869,
0.1989948452,
0.3182455003,
-0.6920934319,
0.4472506344,
-0.476464361,
-0.4157977402,
-0.4858307242,
-0.2526132464,
-0.9334317446,
-0.1361826509,
0.021556085,
-0.5251403451,
-0.2452993244,
0.1543932557,
-0.3089025915,
0.538089633,
-0.944152236,
1.0902915001,
-0.192169562,
-0.4587820172,
-0.391695112,
-0.6608392,
0.2889262438,
0.3538202047,
-0.1363576204,
-0.2057827562,
-0.0306691341,
0.6155068278,
-0.4867633581,
0.6682735085,
-0.0945096314,
-0.2081144154,
0.5041850805,
-0.0518799089,
0.0952760205,
-0.5627799034,
-0.3245716989,
0.2112604231,
-0.1169771105,
-0.7660241127,
-0.6955124736,
0.7952097654,
-1.0526657104,
-0.5720729828,
-0.0655525923,
-0.5939288735,
-0.162495032,
0.1094158962,
0.1887752563,
0.8229489326,
-0.3747867346,
0.1073843613,
0.8447070718,
-0.3681528866,
0.353274405,
0.5525428057,
0.3022780716,
-0.0313329734,
1.273738265,
0.246790871,
0.3764338195,
0.3651034236,
0.3272719979,
-0.1208227575,
-0.4151109755,
-0.8655477762,
0.1312327832,
-0.7466912866,
-0.1509726793,
-0.1148285791,
-0.1556664258,
-0.1612033546,
0.0032128743,
-0.3386559486,
-0.3599613607,
-0.4384872019,
0.0788501725,
0.3472053409,
1.0824116468,
0.1374857873,
0.2974755764,
-0.8386713266,
-0.1269436479,
0.3311446905,
0.7844622731,
0.1761340797,
-0.6234859824,
-0.6695165634,
0.2878091633,
-0.4417926967,
-0.7454990745,
-0.0601598583,
0.3332019448,
0.4678167403,
0.4194634557,
0.070279032,
0.7468996048,
-0.7320528626,
0.6755805016,
-0.2070879489,
-0.8588213921,
0.607323885,
-0.3329445422,
0.309332937,
0.2168379426,
0.4139302671,
-0.1885183007,
-0.2500818372,
-0.3151768148,
-0.3936880231,
1.0685936213,
-0.0039483556,
0.038531933,
0.003879786,
0.2578155994,
0.4667170346,
0.0867183208,
-0.1127502546,
-0.05558604,
-0.389318496,
-0.0672850534,
0.1026304141,
0.0665631816,
-0.1196739897,
-0.1329347193,
0.7984504104,
-0.1066036299,
0.1999765486,
-0.4182343483,
0.0929684117,
-0.2855146229,
0.3908824325,
0.3969264328,
0.7233792543,
-0.2375570834,
-0.3953775167,
-0.0427751169,
-0.3110409379,
-0.0907348692,
0.2093399316,
0.0128878346,
-0.3961423934,
0.3412673771,
1.0620416403,
0.3361874819,
-0.6394751072,
0.3685612381,
-0.0720898136,
0.3517757654,
0.0749103278,
0.5445760489,
-0.1671973616,
0.2760460377,
-0.0909389406,
0.1428982466,
-0.0669303834,
-0.4600041807,
-0.2146791071,
0.4154437184,
-0.4902634621,
-0.4423155189,
0.5467652082,
0.2059242725,
-0.2865408063,
0.9979524612,
0.1117746979,
-0.0515588187,
0.718249917,
0.4812308848,
0.6952411532,
-0.3644324839,
0.1676894128,
0.2139964849,
0.363747716,
-0.1039296836,
0.0405305214,
-0.3327940702,
-0.4468845129,
-0.3494126499,
-0.5962558985,
-0.699049294,
-0.0655910149,
-1.0216038227,
0.3224366307,
-0.3040379286,
0.0532455444,
-0.05290851,
0.0634208545,
-0.8212250471,
0.1287790388,
-0.1605903804,
1.0298906565,
-0.6787539124,
0.8134205937,
0.6940831542,
-0.5048615336,
-0.7247652411,
0.0717939809,
-0.3575989306,
-0.9206183553,
0.3048643768,
0.2741660774,
-0.2689084411,
-0.0008695751,
-0.6622861028,
-0.6921802163,
1.043165803,
0.5004373789,
-0.5629642606,
-0.3959901929,
-0.2170762867,
0.4771585464,
-0.2523292005,
0.5867050886,
0.8089447021,
0.1299174577,
0.0414641052,
-0.8408275843,
-0.1749663055,
0.0241882969,
-0.1515481621,
0.4113486707,
-1.0006949902,
0.8343193531,
-0.6497015357,
-0.2208759189,
0.4484176636,
0.745711863,
-0.1265881062,
0.2437763363,
0.2033634037,
0.4417964518,
0.9852364659,
-0.0798500478,
1.1444621086,
-0.4435519576,
0.0649549738,
1.1468807459,
0.0296910107,
0.8471190929,
-0.0480039269,
-0.0410566963,
0.8421329856,
0.7928803563,
0.0095356749,
0.6120088696,
0.2896133661,
-0.3615266383,
-0.1872944534,
-0.3828834295,
-0.3618918955,
0.6335056424,
0.4113620222,
-0.2447117567,
-0.1680645198,
-0.0859619454,
-0.3079586327,
0.0490224808,
-0.3798362911,
0.5252094865,
-0.1996400654,
-0.8684538603,
0.8611866236,
-0.0069279261,
0.1818308383,
-0.6431092024,
-0.390860796,
-0.0828090757,
0.0755005404,
0.0429899283,
-0.7485064268,
-0.1219055057,
0.2148649693,
-0.199557066,
-0.1857747883,
0.5421383381,
-0.4165561497,
-0.1409429163,
0.0991152599,
0.4109797478,
0.3354949951,
0.4008849859,
-0.4327071905,
0.0248548388,
0.0220271312,
-0.1551251858,
0.3145725429,
0.5553563833,
-0.1137310639,
0.6394062042,
0.4954018593,
0.0653618872,
0.1987566203,
0.0907503888,
0.9995006323,
-0.6251039505,
-0.2586368024,
-0.4833209217,
0.2844716311,
0.1643805802,
-0.5667673349,
0.5638458729,
0.4133663774,
1.211791873,
0.1352446973,
0.7046057582,
0.2781614363,
0.4468773007,
-0.6025840044,
0.5241286755,
-0.3406520188,
0.2490352839,
0.1483282447,
-0.830343008,
0.3735136688,
0.3951761425,
-0.4744396806,
0.235387966,
0.4900121689,
0.7600775957,
-0.1171504483,
0.5083042383,
0.1566578895,
0.1320419461,
0.0543959439,
0.6484392881,
0.859839201,
-0.2450198382,
0.6909374595,
-0.2421919852,
-0.5470002294,
-0.0924982578,
-0.6770325899,
-0.9151721001,
-0.3747057021,
-0.0841503665,
-0.1973144412,
0.4345723391,
0.7394082546,
0.7000443339,
-0.6580868363,
-0.3814761043,
-0.0576136895,
0.1942151636,
-0.3729936182,
-0.1661628783,
0.4357334375,
-0.3704614639,
-0.7179036736,
0.5660979152,
0.0285023842,
0.0377610624,
-0.3522370756,
0.020292161,
0.1457427442,
0.2577216029,
0.3838212192,
0.5367637873,
-0.6823789477,
-0.368615061,
0.278649807,
0.0033033895,
-0.0778014809,
0.87435323,
-0.7071475983,
0.7511557937,
0.1110619605,
0.6689611673,
0.3924375474,
-0.0778989866,
0.5470901132,
-0.6543881297,
-0.0819473118,
0.229455933,
0.0535880141,
0.2880552709,
-0.0156584643,
0.5605531931,
-0.2042396665,
-0.9352083802,
-0.728661716,
0.0775118545,
-0.5534235835,
-0.1655661315,
0.8548797369,
-0.3405510485,
-0.2584494948,
0.2951660156,
0.0253976341,
0.6260961294,
-0.4251398742,
0.8555874228,
0.7741075754,
-0.3294552565,
0.18143031,
-0.8479578495,
0.3261921406,
0.4478520453,
-0.5546061397,
0.2580747902,
0.632334888,
0.1672274023,
-0.3452346921,
0.2445739061,
0.0082022315,
0.5127185583,
0.0980913863,
-0.066091381,
-0.2412109077,
-0.6716111302,
-0.2562618852,
-0.0560352169,
0.1245031655,
-0.7006317377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04746v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04746v3 | Using Imperfect Surrogates for Downstream Inference: Design-based Supervised Learning for Social Science Applications of Large Language Models | 2023-06-07T19:49:41 | 2024-01-14T23:02:59 | Naoki Egami, Musashi Hinck, Brandon M. Stewart, Hanying Wei | stat.ME | stat.ME, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | In computational social science (CSS), researchers analyze documents to
explain social and political phenomena. In most scenarios, CSS researchers
first obtain labels for documents and then explain labels using interpretable
regression analyses in the second step. One increasingly common way to annotate
documents cheaply at scale is through large language models (LLMs). However,
like other scalable ways of producing annotations, such surrogate labels are
often imperfect and biased. We present a new algorithm for using imperfect
annotation surrogates for downstream statistical analyses while guaranteeing
statistical properties -- like asymptotic unbiasedness and proper uncertainty
quantification -- which are fundamental to CSS research. We show that direct
use of surrogate labels in downstream statistical analyses leads to substantial
bias and invalid confidence intervals, even with high surrogate accuracy of
80-90%. To address this, we build on debiased machine learning to propose the
design-based supervised learning (DSL) estimator. DSL employs a doubly-robust
procedure to combine surrogate labels with a smaller number of high-quality,
gold-standard labels. Our approach guarantees valid inference for downstream
statistical analyses, even when surrogates are arbitrarily biased and without
requiring stringent assumptions, by controlling the probability of sampling
documents for gold-standard labeling. Both our theoretical analysis and
experimental results show that DSL provides valid statistical inference while
achieving root mean squared errors comparable to existing alternatives that
focus only on prediction without inferential guarantees. | [
-0.3380042315,
-0.974638164,
0.8120775819,
0.1106415242,
-0.2941263616,
0.3847760856,
-0.2444978058,
-0.2796665132,
0.2818232477,
0.5358956456,
-0.7111831307,
-0.4705537856,
-0.6229086518,
-0.0942690969,
-0.2674621344,
0.9496818185,
0.1097766533,
0.0981549621,
-0.2324968725,
-0.0342143811,
-0.0675946325,
-0.3427114785,
-0.4513442814,
-0.1547810286,
0.6217992902,
0.3249000311,
0.9724987149,
0.6518130898,
0.2617894709,
0.2608632147,
-0.247777909,
0.4916374087,
-0.5297949314,
0.0171692222,
-0.2103740871,
-0.2941743433,
-0.2579528093,
0.2271781266,
0.6271334887,
1.200119853,
0.3011885583,
0.2510262132,
0.2817101479,
0.8632692695,
-1.0020747185,
0.347530812,
-0.4752528071,
-0.0538082905,
-0.1152411848,
0.0134324487,
-0.8620058894,
-0.6852995157,
-0.1091926396,
-0.6077572703,
0.2934404612,
-0.1155545339,
0.7059099674,
0.5628200769,
-0.159595415,
-0.1679272503,
-0.6643899083,
1.0607824326,
-0.6593460441,
0.3859798908,
0.6313577294,
0.1932426989,
-0.5463380218,
-0.6621636748,
-0.2016905397,
-0.2814620435,
-0.1434099823,
0.2207021266,
-0.1103686467,
0.1617520005,
0.2976516187,
-0.0184099264,
-0.2899588943,
0.210939005,
-0.5354049802,
0.0309391543,
1.0065181255,
-0.1483070999,
-0.0231735911,
0.0054000723,
0.018496722,
0.1215022653,
-0.6450279355,
-0.1713157296,
0.4980706871,
0.8235208392,
-0.0566023402,
0.4590456486,
-0.2673379183,
0.7088113427,
0.083209455,
0.3192843497,
0.3140887916,
0.0128968246,
-0.2046342492,
0.0493176691,
0.5710112453,
0.0241398644,
0.4916733205,
-0.2137890458,
0.0756276399,
0.4402561784,
0.4566442966,
-0.3229498863,
-0.3756826818,
0.367828697,
-0.2684908211,
-0.514330864,
-0.041951336,
-0.9547427893,
-0.5499328375,
-0.6482134461,
0.1529173553,
-0.0577806532,
-0.0690950155,
-0.1390825212,
-0.2603541911,
-0.2100442648,
0.2672360837,
-0.6105658412,
0.2272555828,
0.5478810668,
0.7036217451,
-0.0789834782,
-0.2188587338,
-0.5985691547,
0.1052829847,
-0.8571574688,
0.7939919233,
-0.659211874,
-0.3654187024,
0.0658910945,
0.0323267393,
0.0549103171,
-0.1062073037,
0.9202759266,
-0.6622414589,
-0.3138741851,
-0.3600992858,
-0.6919099092,
0.0012738905,
-0.2594282031,
-0.6237867475,
0.7700836658,
-0.0724703372,
-0.9079816341,
0.6859115958,
-0.3911757767,
-0.4060039818,
0.0771494508,
-0.2270240784,
-0.6944695711,
0.3929514289,
0.2766118348,
0.3654732704,
0.0922882855,
0.6113281846,
-1.0018543005,
-0.5211513042,
0.2672931552,
-0.6752055883,
0.8996413946,
0.2901364863,
-0.1995627582,
0.0663884878,
-0.723531723,
0.0943847448,
0.0173788816,
-0.1788642406,
-0.5102446079,
0.4027261436,
0.0400055908,
-0.2284869552,
-0.1939568371,
-0.6260077953,
0.0689587742,
-0.081193842,
0.3884680271,
0.8695850372,
-0.1136015505,
0.4875359535,
-0.1755680293,
0.1339146346,
-0.461525023,
0.3285556436,
0.1861433685,
-0.2337991893,
-0.6919633746,
-0.599283576,
0.6579275727,
0.286373347,
-0.7084389925,
0.3145786226,
-0.2259932458,
-0.7204287648,
-0.3010546863,
-0.1476869136,
0.2675517797,
0.3700845242,
0.4543236792,
0.1707508266,
-0.6775785685,
-0.9279789925,
-0.5925059915,
-0.2411802858,
-0.0870273411,
0.0910245329,
0.4553059042,
-0.3820753396,
1.087446928,
-0.7091735005,
-0.0092733866,
-0.1406026483,
0.5610462427,
0.075688988,
0.4522098005,
0.4112382531,
-0.8135900497,
-0.179059729,
-0.3644061089,
-0.7132263184,
-0.5861626267,
-0.2003433108,
-0.1186904088,
0.3866747022,
0.4300820231,
-0.3739373088,
0.7197155952,
0.3351597786,
0.0050271712,
0.5975384712,
-0.2199652195,
-0.0146047994,
-0.7854459882,
-0.1831972897,
0.4617917538,
-0.0431209095,
-0.5341617465,
-0.1437089145,
0.3499178886,
0.1593881547,
-0.3402633965,
0.4757401645,
-0.450432837,
-0.0568871759,
-0.3899003565,
-0.0147480275,
0.0024234657,
0.3084071577,
0.2574386001,
0.382275641,
0.1872639209,
-0.3965803087,
-0.0870368257,
0.0412614234,
-0.1505810618,
0.5045274496,
-0.5544303656,
-0.1101349443,
-0.5113313198,
0.5148707628,
-1.197068572,
-0.514311254,
0.0999832526,
-0.4903082848,
0.4112056196,
-0.4954767227,
-0.3996706307,
-0.5226787925,
-0.2836550474,
0.0223085694,
0.4038633704,
-0.5870894194,
0.3598543406,
0.6805061698,
-0.1089768931,
-0.4730321467,
-0.9398661256,
0.0619138777,
-0.2517805398,
-0.3351534009,
0.2407638431,
0.1701706052,
-0.3068392575,
0.1328503937,
-0.1274991781,
-0.3194457591,
0.0033803387,
0.3782646954,
0.5348709822,
0.0080139376,
0.1297483295,
0.4203949869,
-0.2623274326,
0.0726877451,
-0.1909307092,
-0.117884405,
0.0759801939,
-0.6121225953,
-0.4447862208,
0.2592461407,
0.7414782643,
0.1436410844,
0.5465250611,
0.0955354646,
-0.5459759235,
-0.3487251103,
-0.7167580724,
0.0078003565,
-0.4612149596,
0.2983489931,
-0.1681065857,
-0.5131654739,
0.3680467308,
-0.1924192756,
0.317171216,
0.4151279628,
0.0515379533,
-0.2316383272,
1.0507490635,
0.5407051444,
0.0243678465,
0.3120338917,
-0.1036438942,
0.1259273887,
-0.6090328693,
0.2035166621,
-0.6571885943,
-0.0009459222,
-0.8040989637,
-0.3143675625,
0.1012784615,
0.0350304134,
-0.5618594885,
0.0612463988,
-0.4062744975,
0.4114674926,
0.7295260429,
0.1977332085,
0.1372614354,
0.1700444818,
0.1248145401,
-0.149769485,
-0.4720557332,
-0.6983215809,
1.0198009014,
0.3283387721,
1.1418454647,
-0.2008800358,
0.6510159373,
0.6075055599,
0.6892163157,
-0.647796154,
0.1456644237,
-0.371986568,
-0.5738822222,
-0.2643528879,
-0.3537130356,
-0.6281219125,
0.3443744183,
-0.0555656552,
-0.9057975411,
0.4485760927,
0.339320004,
-0.2817908227,
0.1270980537,
-0.7448379397,
0.6615253687,
-0.2624581754,
-0.8419374228,
0.150785327,
-0.5820281506,
0.2593155801,
-0.4126713872,
0.4821833968,
0.1123844162,
0.2286493927,
0.5687885284,
-0.3785440028,
1.2636458874,
-0.3368158042,
0.0895557553,
0.5059618354,
-0.094439365,
0.7238899469,
-0.0281333178,
-0.3877396584,
0.3337046504,
0.0401930176,
-0.6357144117,
-0.5436378717,
0.4030243754,
-0.5647439361,
-0.6523085833,
-0.5462034345,
-0.4112991095,
-0.4141140282,
0.0340458229,
0.1119547635,
0.2385390103,
0.2128878087,
0.243691057,
0.3713773489,
-0.1472460032,
0.2499663234,
0.4571819305,
0.2086452991,
-0.3816613853,
0.7146854997,
0.7139256001,
0.26506868,
-0.0813187435,
0.4091434181,
-0.6043370366,
-0.4612321556,
-0.7206670046,
0.082921572,
-0.574243784,
-0.0643270239,
-0.5560266972,
-0.3289079964,
-0.200751543,
-0.5752100945,
-0.6101646423,
-0.220168978,
-0.3031326532,
-0.3322667181,
0.2072322667,
0.6919149756,
-0.4371742606,
0.0412273817,
-0.532022059,
0.1902246028,
-0.059535604,
0.2554646432,
-0.0727222934,
-0.4959500134,
0.034957096,
0.5689235926,
-0.2621598542,
-0.983079493,
0.1470867991,
-0.1233953387,
0.7745315433,
0.3089239299,
0.5900070667,
0.9250543118,
-0.4268197119,
0.5353149176,
-0.2070160359,
-0.8681541681,
0.6718124747,
-0.4482414126,
-0.1425105184,
0.7344449759,
0.4139170051,
-0.1744206846,
-0.5950189233,
-0.547739923,
-1.0002723932,
0.5528614521,
0.2306031734,
0.1933620274,
-0.1438859999,
0.5026603937,
0.1302970201,
-0.0176895298,
-0.6067554355,
-0.1533149779,
0.0266923103,
-0.2628772855,
-0.0446083173,
-0.4074084759,
0.1031852216,
-0.0187394898,
0.9608817697,
-0.336905092,
-0.35265553,
0.1852878928,
0.1121193543,
-0.1710822284,
0.0552992746,
0.391382426,
0.8155688643,
-0.2403881997,
0.2584851086,
0.28033337,
-0.3948888779,
0.1737982035,
0.3168160021,
-0.5821481347,
-0.0004256803,
0.3878883719,
0.406103611,
-0.0048163622,
-0.5935255885,
0.2312923521,
-0.030361075,
-0.152240932,
-0.5136253834,
-0.1986790299,
-0.0114904689,
0.2490034252,
0.6599374413,
0.0504187457,
0.1149019152,
-0.2280293554,
0.404550612,
0.5807763338,
-0.835811615,
-0.1048224568,
0.8465892076,
0.0810428187,
-0.0118159922,
0.3359539807,
-0.239690125,
-0.3351028264,
0.7219297886,
0.3876576722,
0.8370589614,
-0.0072299778,
0.4386073649,
0.2120404094,
0.3636046648,
-0.3999870121,
0.1057294309,
0.0187103413,
-0.3649044633,
-0.6990116239,
-0.9160022736,
-0.6160616279,
0.2099627405,
-0.5659560561,
0.3105253577,
-0.0874150991,
-0.1876766831,
0.2694920599,
0.0041750534,
-0.2404817194,
0.4506782889,
0.1570257843,
0.656878829,
-1.3833218813,
0.4695646465,
0.5385626554,
-0.4067912698,
-0.5471949577,
0.0752106607,
0.2340533137,
-0.4589002132,
0.6746901274,
0.0818886235,
-0.1975897104,
-0.2813031673,
-0.6425489783,
-1.0476160049,
0.4394640923,
0.4940067828,
-0.4892558455,
0.4191896915,
0.3001544774,
0.5508295894,
-0.0409106687,
0.1046134159,
0.331777662,
0.4698380232,
0.3640161455,
-0.3842262626,
0.1901652217,
-0.0251580961,
-0.0476995073,
0.0793103501,
-0.5038228035,
0.5575900674,
-0.3165393174,
-0.1461937577,
0.0267132912,
0.6567854285,
0.6316064,
0.5942932367,
0.3058558106,
0.42122522,
0.7638286948,
-0.1030705944,
0.8013799191,
0.0532019027,
0.5508463979,
1.3205026388,
-0.2663004398,
0.6380052567,
0.5244969726,
-0.3634065986,
0.0901214778,
1.2038593292,
0.063897647,
0.5718004704,
0.6315745115,
-0.04668504,
-0.1781087369,
-0.2371504158,
-0.0791648254,
0.2126706094,
0.5090155602,
-0.5640631914,
-0.1380866468,
-0.3459589481,
0.1616266817,
0.1710062623,
-0.2208016664,
0.4374397099,
0.0782295167,
-0.6882607341,
0.439016819,
-0.2565929294,
0.4213094115,
-0.3004098237,
-0.0855383128,
-0.3821795881,
0.2599925101,
-0.286585182,
-0.7008352876,
0.6193600893,
0.0453646444,
-0.0247535184,
-0.1032661721,
0.7328829169,
0.0228166915,
-1.134546876,
0.2440245003,
0.321798116,
0.1601876318,
-0.0654568896,
-0.3011413813,
0.1610860527,
-0.0986186638,
-0.4310473204,
-0.0527580678,
0.3465485573,
-0.3473281264,
0.5941067338,
0.7437170744,
0.1806811392,
-0.1177746877,
0.2165865898,
0.9091053009,
-0.330639869,
-0.3710917234,
-1.1824837923,
0.5739927888,
-0.3860173821,
0.0671569854,
0.6641988158,
0.5987440944,
0.7744583488,
0.0747854188,
1.2632011175,
0.1264899373,
0.4026997387,
-0.2566216886,
0.6674149632,
-0.6001164913,
0.086196214,
-0.7495034337,
-0.7741131783,
-0.5104555488,
0.5535078049,
-0.6528404355,
0.0468107909,
0.1879881173,
0.5794341564,
-0.2126514614,
0.4007968605,
0.2053414136,
0.0060649253,
0.2844586074,
0.1276975721,
0.8634063601,
-0.1522019356,
0.3536781073,
-0.4147872329,
-0.5499957204,
-0.0358056463,
-1.0038708448,
-0.924241662,
-0.3063276708,
-0.5129462481,
-0.3658350408,
0.4253824651,
0.6260190606,
0.752808094,
-0.7429462075,
0.2126974463,
-0.4019284248,
0.195339635,
-0.2208628803,
-0.2638636529,
0.7272062898,
-0.5434036255,
-0.8488422036,
0.086243704,
0.1348176897,
0.0311797187,
-0.3557172418,
0.2798866332,
-0.055030331,
0.3075623214,
0.5114228725,
0.2652493715,
-0.8145406842,
-0.5318810344,
-0.2133582532,
0.091381453,
-0.2795439959,
0.2825542986,
-0.6989833713,
0.4182080626,
0.4562333226,
0.9832184315,
0.3884554505,
0.3136919141,
0.3716552556,
-0.6754988432,
0.0445581451,
0.0112158321,
0.3257125616,
0.4380700588,
-0.3985934556,
0.7504507303,
0.2497569621,
-0.5387780666,
-0.9754920006,
0.2308042645,
-0.542963922,
-0.6845971942,
1.2506481409,
-0.2159396857,
-0.3930366337,
-0.3408926129,
-0.1597260088,
0.4841020703,
-0.3376035094,
1.011284709,
0.4806444645,
-0.2052806765,
0.089794226,
-0.8584073186,
0.312283814,
0.1944221854,
-0.6059985161,
0.4528324902,
0.6809349656,
0.1049206182,
0.2389506102,
0.4551213384,
0.1647990197,
0.1013630033,
0.2615038157,
-0.2895613611,
0.1944839954,
-0.1818708777,
0.1579724252,
0.1400289983,
-0.2134684473,
-0.3769297302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04743v2 | ScienceBenchmark: A Complex Real-World Benchmark for Evaluating Natural Language to SQL Systems | 2023-06-07T19:37:55 | 2023-12-05T15:05:58 | Yi Zhang, Jan Deriu, George Katsogiannis-Meimarakis, Catherine Kosten, Georgia Koutrika, Kurt Stockinger | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.2.4; I.2.7 | Natural Language to SQL systems (NL-to-SQL) have recently shown a significant
increase in accuracy for natural language to SQL query translation. This
improvement is due to the emergence of transformer-based language models, and
the popularity of the Spider benchmark - the de-facto standard for evaluating
NL-to-SQL systems. The top NL-to-SQL systems reach accuracies of up to 85\%.
However, Spider mainly contains simple databases with few tables, columns, and
entries, which does not reflect a realistic setting. Moreover, complex
real-world databases with domain-specific content have little to no training
data available in the form of NL/SQL-pairs leading to poor performance of
existing NL-to-SQL systems.
In this paper, we introduce ScienceBenchmark, a new complex NL-to-SQL
benchmark for three real-world, highly domain-specific databases. For this new
benchmark, SQL experts and domain experts created high-quality NL/SQL-pairs for
each domain. To garner more data, we extended the small amount of
human-generated data with synthetic data generated using GPT-3. We show that
our benchmark is highly challenging, as the top performing systems on Spider
achieve a very low performance on our benchmark. Thus, the challenge is
many-fold: creating NL-to-SQL systems for highly complex domains with a small
amount of hand-made training data augmented with synthetic data. To our
knowledge, ScienceBenchmark is the first NL-to-SQL benchmark designed with
complex real-world scientific databases, containing challenging training and
test data carefully validated by domain experts. | [
-0.5059586167,
-0.7674239874,
0.3709747791,
0.292016685,
-0.2954307199,
0.4155049622,
-0.1031012833,
-0.629786551,
0.2692655921,
0.4110499322,
-0.4802027941,
-0.4691988528,
-0.3292551935,
0.3742536902,
-0.4718820751,
0.8362085819,
0.1112086549,
0.3198923469,
-0.1730626523,
-0.1870314777,
-0.1784778833,
-0.7457373142,
-0.2836370468,
-0.1053169742,
0.3069540858,
-0.0299227741,
0.5637267828,
0.4895584583,
0.7001868486,
0.1808754802,
-0.1489585042,
0.3445225954,
-0.3731291294,
0.2085590214,
-0.4545680285,
-0.6262949109,
-0.5283537507,
-0.1717533171,
0.6193735003,
1.0139703751,
-0.098983936,
0.2897742391,
-0.2354485989,
0.839869976,
-0.7422329187,
0.2927206457,
-0.5928376317,
0.3493023217,
-0.3860834539,
-0.110741131,
-0.3493819833,
-0.618884027,
0.0444157459,
-0.5966947675,
0.5462476015,
0.5958619714,
0.7707092762,
0.2269246876,
-0.6297008395,
0.1266961992,
-0.794315815,
0.4899777472,
-0.6250928044,
0.3843587935,
-0.0129506923,
0.8259732723,
-0.724848032,
-0.5280770063,
-0.8154343367,
-0.0810090527,
-0.1546323448,
0.0322400592,
-0.1092385501,
-0.3736002743,
0.3247281611,
0.1338759959,
-0.8280604482,
-0.2350449115,
-0.2899150252,
-0.1829850227,
0.5510979295,
0.2838108242,
-0.002888862,
-0.1146151498,
-0.3291987777,
-0.3901358545,
-0.7277058959,
-0.391094923,
0.1908601522,
0.6441595554,
0.1863093376,
0.7895689607,
-0.3630319536,
0.7644194961,
-0.124895677,
0.3257483244,
0.1991849095,
-0.4060741663,
-0.0774848685,
0.2604408264,
0.7119058967,
0.3955998719,
0.2136977613,
-0.5419260263,
-0.0105611077,
0.2661096156,
0.3245761693,
-0.6604186296,
-0.1605198532,
0.1391476989,
0.0000058801,
-0.0534176566,
-0.1695862263,
-0.9037290215,
-0.5538700223,
-0.1850631535,
0.3720236719,
-0.2788633406,
-0.4341437817,
0.0071292417,
-0.0488788188,
0.2778915763,
0.1544557363,
-0.4974959195,
0.7880731821,
0.8222922087,
0.8872590065,
-0.7241719961,
-0.1542756855,
-0.5145448446,
0.293987453,
-0.5613250136,
1.0653866529,
-0.1575127393,
-0.1134327203,
-0.3467885852,
0.1161440536,
0.0134125939,
-0.7824243307,
0.4251899421,
-0.7226687074,
0.229208678,
-0.0254063867,
-0.631426394,
-0.0224013384,
0.3629112244,
-0.7807742357,
1.2463097572,
0.1784948856,
-0.5048466325,
0.6753618121,
-0.7632187605,
-0.5305087566,
0.2222266942,
0.0542260185,
-0.3622610569,
0.0070882258,
-0.126617685,
0.2009866238,
-0.792941153,
0.5035552382,
-0.3866120279,
-0.3938988745,
0.0178208239,
-0.0886327103,
0.3754588366,
0.0908529982,
-0.5323220491,
-0.1243856847,
-1.1907271147,
0.3886334598,
0.2490724027,
-0.1731379926,
-0.2298185825,
0.1904707849,
0.1346458495,
0.1392825693,
-0.0007372867,
-0.7080405951,
0.213031292,
-0.5646816492,
0.3233937025,
0.3687394261,
-0.0806596801,
0.1112337634,
0.1102990583,
0.3116348684,
-0.0223665573,
-0.0367450751,
0.4959159493,
-0.1830648929,
-0.6891645789,
0.0106253009,
0.3678682745,
0.4995672107,
-0.5419902802,
0.535362184,
-0.6005914807,
-0.7856333256,
-0.4262380302,
-0.085235551,
0.3385715783,
0.4196960032,
0.8725718856,
-0.54697752,
-0.4936979413,
-1.1033248901,
-0.7289732099,
0.1059523374,
-0.1891100854,
0.1568380147,
0.6523644924,
0.2658492625,
1.086012125,
-0.5118365288,
-0.2907377481,
0.0675494447,
-0.0835839137,
0.3953574896,
0.5102054477,
0.333922416,
-0.5824171901,
-0.5143800974,
0.0576759614,
-0.765622437,
0.1941260397,
0.2505246401,
-0.1992651671,
0.4673330188,
0.2559622228,
-0.7076115608,
0.2304457724,
0.5112904906,
-0.4974413812,
0.921841383,
-0.0073321615,
0.1222824901,
-0.8553676009,
0.5345386267,
-0.1632874757,
-0.2612099051,
-0.5207303762,
0.09002202,
0.0715907365,
-0.2518814206,
-0.4669569135,
0.5323475599,
-0.4371287823,
-0.304622829,
0.0400158241,
0.1986622363,
0.105765909,
0.4636512995,
0.0117868865,
0.8060593605,
0.389854908,
-0.6164392829,
0.5345422029,
0.3091307878,
-0.4307990372,
1.0358308554,
-0.7880511284,
0.165546611,
0.2173160762,
0.4307322204,
-0.6554471254,
-0.3132579625,
-0.0185613967,
-0.2446603179,
0.1188487336,
-0.13900204,
-0.8857406378,
-0.3268796504,
0.0828698799,
0.0046795541,
0.2375182211,
-0.4973879158,
0.646951139,
0.1370633245,
0.1324853152,
-0.4166194499,
-0.7968708873,
0.573431313,
-0.1248748899,
-0.4492430091,
0.460388869,
0.1512873918,
0.0858291239,
0.1996297687,
-0.5557084084,
-0.2422950864,
-0.0953020453,
0.0854720622,
0.1719625443,
-0.3111465573,
-0.0200565588,
0.0210811216,
-0.3182016313,
0.2455151528,
-0.1655169427,
0.508915484,
-0.2699124217,
-0.4469660223,
-0.1364043355,
0.491666466,
0.3945377767,
-0.1047643274,
0.9359591007,
0.4005766511,
-0.1976658404,
-0.2340897769,
-0.6505966783,
-0.3553936481,
-0.4228646755,
0.4342587888,
-0.4956232607,
-0.6606075764,
0.1315812469,
-0.5518687963,
-0.0655447319,
0.5299267769,
0.1247777194,
-0.1351109892,
1.1749532223,
0.3652204871,
0.2753425241,
-0.1182411462,
-0.0917695686,
0.4282948375,
-0.6538088918,
-0.3266601264,
-0.8172479868,
-0.1186996624,
-0.4517452717,
-0.4484296739,
0.3935238123,
0.1695919931,
-0.695666492,
0.8985478282,
-0.8483353257,
0.5599772334,
0.457148701,
-0.0473018587,
0.525559783,
0.0805990696,
-0.2477946132,
-0.2218373269,
-0.6172704101,
-0.4331938028,
0.8980996609,
-0.317858994,
0.4184024334,
0.3694900274,
0.3225751221,
0.4069773555,
0.0913575217,
-0.2841679752,
0.7883986831,
-0.092595607,
-0.8671593666,
-0.0620486774,
-0.5380836129,
-0.8812645674,
0.3373146951,
-0.4632140994,
-0.3767641187,
0.2360902876,
0.0440228544,
0.1994826943,
0.2884634137,
-0.7878862023,
0.8452696204,
-0.3338923156,
-0.799724102,
-0.2511327565,
-0.8764460087,
0.0334921405,
-0.1805698574,
0.1727164537,
-0.3060368299,
-0.0736092851,
0.6468484402,
-0.4559336007,
0.6320259571,
-0.376685828,
0.2484418452,
-0.0991127118,
0.4996928573,
0.6740694642,
-0.2385141999,
-0.512329638,
0.1929478347,
0.2279368639,
-0.5694579482,
-0.5302131176,
0.5594741702,
-0.5577857494,
-0.4511517286,
-0.7759635448,
-0.1788823903,
-0.6015629768,
0.482247591,
-0.1655273438,
0.065616563,
-0.3069333732,
0.3650754094,
0.3825770915,
0.0330346189,
0.1008268818,
0.9017854929,
0.1411652565,
-0.2298544794,
0.7975788116,
-0.0823165998,
0.3056395948,
0.2901339531,
-0.1363493502,
-0.4628188014,
-0.4747896492,
-0.5965271592,
0.1681771874,
-0.5883255601,
-0.38719365,
-0.5854613781,
0.0147214942,
-0.1505325586,
-0.0590183027,
-0.5823255181,
-0.5832256079,
0.1951979995,
0.1457801312,
0.4663008749,
0.4815100431,
0.2624155879,
-0.0207113717,
-0.6041062474,
0.2097651809,
-0.1107320264,
0.8072144389,
-0.1856705099,
-0.0580031052,
-0.0531017445,
-0.1660391539,
-0.1263065487,
-0.7041965723,
0.2590390444,
0.4332202077,
0.5985391736,
-0.3735773861,
0.1733562648,
0.7395741343,
-0.5422774553,
0.8200870752,
0.1430636048,
-0.9919570088,
0.6313615441,
-0.088817209,
0.07600867,
0.779088378,
0.5097271204,
-0.2947109938,
-0.1460329592,
-0.4160449505,
-1.0266817808,
0.6006752253,
0.0889667496,
-0.2637152076,
0.1746921837,
0.2541654408,
0.1298995316,
0.3798413277,
-0.625869751,
-0.2343628705,
-0.3356097341,
0.0677211061,
-0.065917924,
0.3139604628,
-0.2662371397,
-0.1831368804,
0.6420869827,
-0.4839521646,
0.0929182768,
0.1754623353,
-0.184428826,
0.0251599904,
0.4456935525,
0.2714064121,
0.4348422587,
-0.4118198156,
0.1589927226,
0.4089682102,
-0.3863969445,
0.2140884846,
0.0941017792,
-0.0387391187,
-0.112326175,
0.2749872208,
0.7043817043,
0.1182309836,
-0.7604573369,
0.2708741426,
0.0936847329,
-0.1126023829,
-0.0335600451,
0.2521035969,
0.2878444791,
-0.1377902478,
0.5491138101,
0.4345092475,
0.2566348314,
-0.4322484136,
0.0066653048,
0.4021528065,
-0.4370222688,
-0.250644654,
0.7227309346,
0.0749474466,
-0.3104070723,
0.3370434642,
-0.286444962,
-0.394182831,
0.530372262,
0.7234799862,
0.6295224428,
0.0234088525,
-0.0618572868,
0.6623375416,
0.2151492089,
-0.0915117562,
0.2867686749,
-0.074167721,
-0.2960303128,
-0.4712133408,
-0.8240562081,
-0.7553814054,
-0.4100050032,
-0.6889616847,
0.2136828005,
-0.411552906,
-0.1766675413,
0.1188473105,
0.1816153526,
-0.5933610201,
0.1657595634,
-0.5498595238,
0.9924089313,
-0.6741460562,
0.783175528,
0.6258786917,
-0.1218377426,
-0.539560914,
-0.50369519,
-0.0539559498,
-0.4887749255,
0.6026886702,
-0.1020082012,
-0.2819835246,
0.0403595492,
-0.449562043,
-0.8155404329,
0.9389526844,
0.4906724691,
-0.5758743286,
0.0902932659,
0.5699257255,
1.0175001621,
-0.1762600988,
0.1720041782,
0.7346326113,
0.7534818053,
-0.0199102331,
-0.8021428585,
0.4186987579,
-0.4657063782,
-0.0403345227,
0.4977747798,
-0.4805777371,
0.6094031334,
-0.005918595,
-0.4064846337,
-0.2671303749,
0.4072040915,
0.3918610513,
0.1896612197,
0.612362206,
0.2295957804,
0.415253371,
-0.4991790652,
0.9794777036,
-0.3440946639,
0.3226255476,
1.1927164793,
-0.807631731,
1.1328642368,
0.599950552,
-0.6384136081,
0.6158337593,
0.3415902555,
-0.5058240294,
0.3506419659,
0.5932270288,
-0.1797794551,
-0.2444751561,
-0.2775760889,
-0.6706472635,
0.1243520826,
0.3647816777,
0.3017207086,
-0.4046214819,
-0.3501963913,
-0.301969111,
0.2992503345,
0.3689352274,
0.9084402323,
-0.1634533107,
-0.6517670751,
0.7715871334,
-0.2962202728,
0.6012403369,
-0.8587502241,
-0.1279020458,
-0.1360629499,
0.2227797061,
-0.4286929071,
-0.7367523909,
0.4876142442,
0.0135201486,
0.0326412022,
0.2254443169,
0.4163252711,
-0.2473914176,
-0.2481088489,
0.4560217559,
0.3932249844,
0.2748788893,
-0.120713599,
-0.6272172928,
-0.0205347519,
-0.4063204527,
-0.3312865794,
0.40236637,
0.1925218105,
-0.2324395776,
0.7045001984,
0.99612391,
0.3518899083,
-0.0126895476,
0.0119659984,
0.7228510976,
-0.7668859363,
-0.3906808197,
-0.4798589051,
0.0466180854,
-0.4633951187,
-0.225705862,
0.8131952882,
0.966347158,
0.4837706387,
-0.160765782,
0.4785730541,
-0.3778329492,
0.8020570874,
-0.1063209698,
0.6972498894,
-0.6236638427,
0.1124267131,
-0.2041620761,
-1.2221570015,
-0.5518161654,
0.1010149866,
0.0660566688,
-0.0371608846,
0.9333235621,
0.9106659889,
0.0468239561,
0.2316610813,
0.0099733975,
0.1671898961,
0.5715013146,
0.4079005122,
0.4983842075,
-0.5161769986,
0.6544604301,
-0.2250676155,
0.0483938605,
-0.3184047341,
-1.0372931957,
-0.5540284514,
-0.4701676667,
-0.1983552575,
-0.4992701411,
0.3409400582,
0.8453377485,
0.8411492109,
-1.1475524902,
-0.263282299,
-0.3273969591,
-0.2460069805,
-0.5937181711,
-0.2690828145,
0.7512195706,
-0.1050598845,
-0.509857595,
0.6594310403,
0.2643110156,
-0.0462179817,
-0.3914810717,
0.2183892131,
-0.3463182747,
-0.1704687029,
0.6039418578,
0.3757771552,
-0.4529181421,
-0.2229923755,
0.1862632632,
-0.2103904933,
0.042967204,
0.6446419954,
-0.9779459238,
0.3827232718,
0.3557030559,
0.625161767,
0.9927843809,
-0.1831889451,
0.6155921221,
-0.804109633,
-0.0554201044,
0.4806262255,
-0.0320129469,
0.499783963,
-0.1176896021,
1.1601264477,
0.3424108326,
-0.3199999034,
-1.1807293892,
-0.1004225686,
-1.1691703796,
-0.1141891703,
0.6061788797,
0.1402335614,
-0.3371422887,
-0.525144577,
0.0559921153,
0.1206426173,
-0.1705290228,
0.6920116544,
0.4739864767,
-0.1426671743,
0.4057141542,
-0.5146243572,
0.5651654601,
0.6882164478,
-1.117120862,
0.1591512859,
0.2898007631,
0.4066159129,
0.3225569129,
0.0742843151,
-0.1921006292,
0.2933151126,
0.2342550457,
0.3262305558,
-0.0058134031,
-0.09329734,
0.1640317291,
0.4487541318,
-0.2623114288,
0.3430005312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04735v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04735v2 | Soft-prompt Tuning for Large Language Models to Evaluate Bias | 2023-06-07T19:11:25 | 2024-03-05T17:29:06 | Jacob-Junqi Tian, David Emerson, Sevil Zanjani Miyandoab, Deval Pandya, Laleh Seyyed-Kalantari, Faiza Khan Khattak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Prompting large language models has gained immense popularity in recent years
due to the advantage of producing good results even without the need for
labelled data. However, this requires prompt tuning to get optimal prompts that
lead to better model performances. In this paper, we explore the use of
soft-prompt tuning on sentiment classification task to quantify the biases of
large language models (LLMs) such as Open Pre-trained Transformers (OPT) and
Galactica language model. Since these models are trained on real-world data
that could be prone to bias toward certain groups of populations, it is
important to identify these underlying issues. Using soft-prompts to evaluate
bias gives us the extra advantage of avoiding the human-bias injection that can
be caused by manually designed prompts. We check the model biases on different
sensitive attributes using the group fairness (bias) and find interesting bias
patterns. Since LLMs have been used in the industry in various applications, it
is crucial to identify the biases before deploying these models in practice. We
open-source our pipeline and encourage industry researchers to adapt our work
to their use cases. | [
-0.5585981607,
-0.5404729247,
0.5565097928,
0.1979474276,
-0.1606313884,
-0.3144935071,
-0.6345717311,
0.1057737097,
-0.2349428087,
0.5879048705,
-1.1111218929,
-0.64802742,
-0.353017658,
0.2606451213,
0.1262220889,
1.3941221237,
0.3172189295,
0.3416632116,
-0.0912381262,
-0.1939488053,
-0.6427510381,
-0.3640531003,
-0.6369975805,
-0.0769716948,
0.6205433607,
0.4504124522,
0.7109163404,
0.2505123913,
0.2481594533,
0.2947318554,
-0.3529669046,
0.1069697216,
-0.3212405741,
0.2598795891,
-0.2802538872,
-0.6151447892,
-0.5778012276,
0.1880384535,
0.4536242485,
0.6544952989,
0.158912465,
0.461261332,
0.2522496879,
0.5559331179,
-0.5868710876,
0.2243412286,
-0.7804412842,
0.1009956151,
-0.2626770735,
-0.0511352457,
-0.5517982841,
-0.6048756838,
-0.0089476146,
-0.3166112602,
0.4621722996,
0.0366754048,
0.5781155825,
0.4681545198,
-0.3551126122,
-0.1561629623,
-0.3266187906,
1.0271880627,
-0.7897055745,
0.1696835458,
-0.0669190288,
0.1614682823,
-0.2084857374,
-0.1511791795,
-0.539699018,
-0.2214148492,
0.0468039326,
0.0473688766,
0.0461630151,
0.1925723702,
0.547863245,
0.2988830507,
-0.4351671934,
0.502206862,
0.1317410618,
-0.3704003692,
0.4909672439,
0.1658990085,
0.1290266067,
-0.3172113895,
-0.1408965439,
-0.108974047,
-0.6144856215,
0.0328689031,
0.7069812417,
0.8375667334,
-0.0340355076,
0.4920286238,
-0.1319700032,
0.6742755771,
0.1846899688,
0.0723615289,
0.4463202655,
-0.1945572495,
-0.0790697485,
-0.0092741521,
0.7402207851,
0.5170658231,
0.8114017248,
0.1725133955,
-0.4089069068,
0.2308677435,
0.1081351265,
-0.6572674513,
0.3058168292,
0.0327532366,
-0.5811772943,
-0.3983265162,
-0.2248097211,
-1.1191241741,
-0.7370994091,
-0.4044767618,
0.1356217563,
0.1356559545,
-0.5280650854,
0.0849924013,
-0.0486876853,
0.275496155,
0.1826845407,
-0.8191521764,
-0.2412543446,
0.8373574018,
0.740994513,
-0.0932702273,
0.0031540394,
-0.8398777843,
-0.5981377363,
-0.210149616,
0.8386957645,
-0.5086371303,
-0.3619377613,
0.4658717215,
-0.0882959813,
-0.0121613694,
-0.6049030423,
1.1891334057,
-0.42871508,
0.4410670996,
-0.4197683334,
-0.3108668625,
0.1080849171,
0.1871151328,
-0.6017479897,
0.7195945978,
0.2016705275,
-0.7314078212,
0.7284581661,
-0.6307887435,
-0.3174183965,
-0.022101365,
-0.1001493931,
-0.4940147102,
0.3168440163,
0.5663999915,
0.624366045,
-0.3789083064,
0.4686520696,
-0.5485100746,
-0.1895559281,
0.3912720978,
-0.5556226373,
0.7149533629,
0.3345732987,
-0.392246604,
0.4801487327,
-0.4408163726,
-0.006956046,
-0.1617847681,
-0.0108504212,
-0.4225949645,
-0.0999732614,
0.0791997686,
0.3845095634,
0.067306906,
-0.330290854,
0.4228705466,
-0.5045679808,
0.2967732549,
1.3034156561,
-0.3100300729,
0.5482342243,
0.0942610875,
0.7572786212,
0.2069387138,
0.4862204194,
-0.1626460999,
-0.3817673028,
-0.7203074098,
-0.2976725996,
0.4339062274,
0.4334271848,
-0.5983836055,
0.6225860119,
-0.1995407194,
-0.1885897368,
-0.8307673931,
0.2418542951,
0.1530039161,
0.5624608397,
0.0787619725,
-0.0676718131,
-0.2957283556,
-1.0181889534,
-0.5716937184,
-0.0262554735,
-0.2250603735,
0.6636143923,
0.1627442539,
-0.2302351892,
1.0951827765,
-0.4955466092,
-0.355761379,
-0.3552192748,
0.1662862301,
0.7200645208,
0.091574885,
0.515293479,
-0.5857791305,
-0.2856255472,
-0.2914764285,
-0.4677494168,
-0.8345178962,
-0.0254528187,
-0.230527088,
0.3539890647,
0.4603930116,
-0.7046279311,
0.018683672,
0.5005447865,
-0.610525012,
0.6433078647,
0.4247326255,
0.1895411164,
-0.8538868427,
0.0647637621,
0.4106325507,
-0.1715929359,
-0.2595334649,
-0.1971379519,
0.1005986184,
0.0243308712,
-0.5645480752,
0.5296115279,
-0.2997702062,
0.0857767388,
-0.2580009699,
0.0510487854,
-0.0504476652,
0.4066669941,
-0.0364721194,
0.9481177926,
0.6510074139,
-0.5670550466,
0.1109824404,
0.0178873558,
-0.476111412,
0.7178973556,
-0.5057512522,
0.2860868573,
-0.2883569598,
0.3112776577,
-0.7845756412,
0.1235840172,
0.2523767948,
-0.2713498473,
0.1270852238,
-0.4337564111,
-0.4240894914,
-0.4151883125,
-0.4350672364,
0.3494371474,
0.5826390386,
-0.665483892,
0.5464872718,
0.2308557779,
-0.3070467412,
-0.6742094159,
-0.1716754884,
-0.2491494417,
-0.5681781769,
-0.6274210215,
-0.0360677615,
-0.1131751165,
-0.2810370922,
-0.2849416733,
-0.0135689424,
0.3854649067,
0.043494191,
0.2416153848,
0.4946107566,
-0.3194501996,
0.1332237124,
0.1115152389,
-0.2154491395,
0.1834620833,
-0.2300696373,
0.6755142808,
-0.1835150868,
-0.1572211087,
-0.2039552778,
-0.0257432032,
0.6870908141,
-0.1612492055,
0.6688904762,
0.7425833344,
0.0535432138,
-0.5564373732,
-0.7544571757,
-0.2750402391,
-0.5847038627,
0.3397009969,
-0.0628701672,
-1.0511159897,
0.5292137861,
-0.3106422424,
0.034755066,
0.4602776468,
0.6821947098,
0.3104286492,
1.5658105612,
0.5294727683,
-0.4819973111,
0.5949997902,
0.0161708035,
0.1106011942,
-0.7671125531,
-0.0542534217,
-0.8310418725,
-0.2381516844,
-0.5923577547,
-0.1917316467,
0.619674325,
-0.2762733698,
-0.2182706594,
-0.3313704431,
-0.493349582,
0.5672439337,
0.3905739486,
-0.0380813479,
-0.059049543,
-0.0866098478,
-0.07528276,
-0.0310220644,
-0.5224871039,
-0.5353073478,
0.8441922069,
0.4569200277,
0.924141407,
-0.2787135839,
0.1606412828,
0.4308381975,
0.4224518538,
-1.0763550997,
0.6397589445,
-0.2409307063,
-0.4418306053,
-0.0105820801,
-0.6977688074,
-0.9117316008,
0.1735385954,
-0.1363913268,
-0.3214288354,
0.1149086803,
0.2910245359,
-0.4432028234,
0.0394452214,
-0.8989036083,
0.9100722075,
-0.1799049377,
-0.3513446748,
-0.0344963409,
-0.3708121777,
0.3703599274,
0.0392175727,
0.3564603925,
-0.3202645481,
0.0227875933,
0.7581629157,
-0.2220881879,
0.946026206,
-0.5488072038,
-0.4708175659,
0.1359268278,
-0.1430903822,
0.4613173604,
0.114690654,
-0.4196479321,
0.3316411972,
-0.538417995,
-0.1727172583,
-0.5725172758,
0.7345532179,
-0.6922273636,
-0.5072981715,
-0.4396533668,
-0.3384384811,
-0.5230713487,
0.0894782469,
0.318218708,
0.3683999777,
0.0452108048,
-0.0867954567,
0.7069817185,
-0.514713645,
0.3581364751,
0.6135455966,
-0.216193676,
-0.2068025917,
0.6182115078,
-0.1147828177,
0.162207976,
-0.1342823356,
0.4079822004,
-0.4848850071,
-0.4359184206,
-0.7344216704,
0.2413508594,
-0.5949636698,
-0.5000339746,
-0.2623800635,
-0.0193602461,
-0.59793365,
0.0085099051,
-0.2285629213,
-0.0695895329,
-0.4682593346,
-0.0510711707,
0.508156538,
0.5587449074,
0.2515288293,
0.3055681586,
-0.7674241066,
0.183529377,
0.2106558233,
0.6614928842,
-0.1595270485,
-0.632266283,
-0.1087592542,
-0.0012788692,
-0.0850163177,
-0.8441975117,
0.3908578455,
0.188757956,
0.525906682,
0.4381447732,
0.0487955399,
0.222397849,
-0.4324632287,
0.9457871914,
-0.0654179826,
-1.0689322948,
0.7091904283,
-0.5365701318,
0.5150986314,
0.7620794177,
0.2764697373,
-0.5267996788,
-0.1498978585,
-0.239482969,
-0.9930280447,
0.8606005311,
-0.3353916109,
0.295729816,
-0.0120127248,
0.4151221514,
0.4194734693,
0.3428529501,
-0.6317301393,
-0.1710380763,
-0.0602943264,
-0.5665989518,
-0.1448287964,
-0.2133004963,
0.2249522507,
-0.0684253946,
0.6769566536,
-0.5175227523,
-0.0359100215,
-0.1575956643,
-0.25273031,
-0.3004208803,
0.5936865211,
0.2991438508,
0.2651865482,
0.0277552903,
-0.0261343997,
0.2537490726,
-0.3584151566,
-0.0124817174,
-0.1315344721,
-0.4188757241,
-0.1424412727,
0.1055243537,
1.081040144,
-0.0706224293,
-0.7789005041,
0.7420309186,
-0.2249682844,
0.0998321027,
-0.0595459901,
0.3391839564,
-0.4087924361,
0.2067965716,
0.2299658805,
0.1626187265,
0.272285223,
-0.4401522577,
-0.2198556066,
0.774674356,
-0.3996763527,
-0.3386412561,
0.2684752643,
0.4930947125,
-0.2731163502,
0.7684562206,
-0.1908894479,
-0.936655581,
0.4360029697,
0.2794978619,
1.1508443356,
-0.3400008082,
0.2538769543,
0.2749354839,
0.2687921226,
-0.0567499064,
0.2393802553,
0.1434970051,
-0.7381675839,
-0.6974099278,
-0.8755598068,
-0.3551210165,
0.380194217,
-0.6891918778,
0.6640729904,
-0.2250404358,
-0.4878823459,
-0.2300366312,
-0.2733125389,
-0.8456776142,
0.0421245433,
0.4739327133,
0.8593293428,
-1.2586072683,
0.3284263313,
0.6294202805,
0.0099728908,
-0.7251798511,
0.1407992989,
-0.0079138391,
-0.7629740834,
0.5248597264,
0.4881868064,
-0.0775502548,
-0.0195640549,
-0.80661273,
-0.4798547328,
0.3615013659,
0.480091393,
-0.6814108491,
0.2633002996,
0.0508177616,
0.5382742286,
-0.2111318707,
0.5876924992,
0.7098178267,
0.6130669117,
-0.2379093915,
-0.9694877863,
0.1139625832,
-0.3593481481,
-0.2773447037,
0.2445447445,
-0.6814789176,
0.7008152008,
-0.0351927243,
-0.0419137143,
-0.2847510576,
0.6839599013,
0.2759355605,
0.3972489238,
1.1505814791,
0.2730979025,
0.7307827473,
-0.1637855023,
0.8165489435,
-0.0374662653,
0.263500154,
0.661206305,
-0.538440764,
0.3721656501,
0.2996075749,
-0.1228907332,
0.4467386901,
0.5363944173,
-0.0195015538,
0.4038141668,
0.3339630961,
-0.3187727332,
-0.3448897302,
-0.4803146422,
-0.3940539956,
0.3219579458,
0.4665195048,
-0.3801890016,
0.0547969006,
0.2128753066,
0.1443543136,
-0.1059400588,
-0.7274939418,
0.8792739511,
0.1085498258,
-1.1161131859,
0.3120262027,
-0.1422337294,
1.3261039257,
-0.5412684083,
0.2484521717,
-0.2585038841,
0.3098142743,
-0.2312877178,
-0.8020373583,
-0.069358021,
0.3191942871,
-0.1622244269,
-0.4457945228,
0.8493510485,
-0.3003079891,
-0.4812148809,
0.1055192873,
0.3509622216,
-0.2094779909,
-0.3528661728,
-0.7856459618,
0.1885960102,
-0.0049521471,
-0.5418301225,
0.2703821659,
0.4997888803,
-0.0464464985,
0.5055863261,
0.6079025865,
0.1679501683,
-0.0792785585,
0.7151184082,
0.8703112006,
-0.6279825568,
-0.4901457429,
-1.1047552824,
0.4598849714,
0.0093512312,
-0.4851541817,
0.7898393273,
0.3047524989,
0.4766141772,
-0.2683084607,
0.8240564466,
0.275890857,
0.5485003591,
-0.654556036,
0.6568146944,
-0.3988524377,
0.2080375999,
-0.3909654319,
-0.9933533072,
-0.180982247,
0.5933022499,
-0.4577587247,
0.4782804847,
0.4003166258,
1.0056914091,
-0.0270374473,
0.2138148397,
-0.1543782353,
0.3191788495,
0.2620634139,
0.3081699908,
1.1053556204,
0.1611413062,
0.3765974939,
0.1353283674,
-0.3996138275,
-0.2847315669,
-1.1888399124,
-0.9773782492,
-0.2766566575,
-0.337713927,
-0.5417191982,
-0.215352878,
1.2865175009,
0.6197544336,
-0.9059800506,
0.1024907455,
0.064572908,
0.2348359674,
0.0089690443,
-0.3378265798,
0.2499381304,
-0.6336268783,
-0.7843929529,
0.2362660319,
-0.0179271139,
-0.2564131021,
-0.4951155186,
0.1126126051,
0.3864084184,
0.1240909323,
0.5430270433,
-0.1439552456,
-0.4133700728,
-0.1777644753,
0.130604893,
0.0160883181,
-0.1628301889,
1.1324614286,
-0.9839328527,
0.0562800057,
0.5623582006,
0.2755748332,
-0.0256879665,
0.0041636899,
0.6410176158,
-0.9178047776,
0.0470368527,
0.4061999917,
0.3698766232,
0.5136576295,
-0.5253708959,
0.21546188,
0.0585143939,
-0.8118851781,
-1.0214078426,
0.1253402382,
-0.9877797961,
-0.1481818557,
1.5316761732,
0.1826713979,
-0.2488835454,
0.0130041149,
-0.5229305625,
0.2648586929,
-0.6415748,
0.8171544671,
0.6096709967,
0.2336554676,
0.0068462254,
-0.3804738522,
0.6018277407,
0.7544803619,
-0.684281528,
0.2462403178,
0.6476294398,
0.0906083062,
-0.1355486959,
0.3984149396,
0.0396926105,
0.043513529,
-0.5730587244,
0.0443726294,
0.07873182,
-0.2300846726,
-0.7386452556,
0.1295784563,
0.1690158695,
0.1641837358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04724v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04724v1 | Prompter: Zero-shot Adaptive Prefixes for Dialogue State Tracking Domain Adaptation | 2023-06-07T18:39:57 | 2023-06-07T18:39:57 | Taha Aksu, Min-Yen Kan, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | A challenge in the Dialogue State Tracking (DST) field is adapting models to
new domains without using any supervised data, zero-shot domain adaptation.
Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning (PETL) has the potential to address this
problem due to its robustness. However, it has yet to be applied to the
zero-shot scenarios, as it is not clear how to apply it unsupervisedly.
Our method, Prompter, uses descriptions of target domain slots to generate
dynamic prefixes that are concatenated to the key and values at each layer's
self-attention mechanism. This allows for the use of prefix-tuning in
zero-shot. Prompter outperforms previous methods on both the MultiWOZ and SGD
benchmarks. In generating prefixes, our analyses find that Prompter not only
utilizes the semantics of slot descriptions but also how often the slots appear
together in conversation. Moreover, Prompter's gains are due to its improved
ability to distinguish "none"-valued dialogue slots, compared against
baselines. | [
-0.3822518289,
-0.6589651108,
0.6593831182,
0.0386595577,
-0.4015851617,
0.2299124599,
-0.0003007661,
-0.0756296962,
-0.0140760504,
0.3008239865,
-0.8247947097,
-0.1914648414,
-0.5506475568,
0.0649387762,
0.1019650921,
1.1566485167,
0.0157934446,
-0.245861724,
-0.002167596,
-0.1784064621,
-0.800596118,
-0.5494368672,
-0.8963131905,
0.0352830179,
0.5314844251,
0.2644067705,
0.4489434659,
0.4248184264,
0.2143302113,
0.2271120846,
0.0936216041,
-0.0894142166,
-0.4963263273,
0.4662985802,
-0.3822105527,
-0.0540012904,
-0.5602794886,
-0.1967818141,
0.5831606388,
0.5322586298,
0.0900074691,
-0.0409402773,
-0.1357999891,
0.286500901,
-0.740246594,
0.1349956691,
-0.7858858109,
0.0694300756,
0.0630030856,
-0.5608479977,
-0.3700084984,
-0.1231951267,
0.4369158745,
-0.8624055982,
0.4192763269,
-0.1445848942,
0.6160282493,
0.3482730985,
-0.5806509256,
-0.0503958575,
-0.8051081896,
0.7644124627,
-0.5064450502,
0.3120934963,
0.0071566962,
0.5580734015,
-0.2075111717,
-0.5032164454,
-0.5523035526,
-0.1579761058,
0.1498824656,
0.2293636054,
-0.246979773,
0.1602205932,
0.3223550916,
0.0501593761,
-0.4115208983,
-0.0669536889,
-0.2007113397,
-0.3748532534,
0.4657693207,
0.2429271787,
0.1068333238,
0.1684704423,
-0.6128196716,
-0.1637821048,
-0.3510929048,
0.23049137,
-0.1958380193,
0.4221617281,
0.1315959841,
-0.0458555855,
-0.2346188575,
0.9225667119,
0.6692981124,
-0.0496531352,
0.0099896379,
-0.3665319979,
-0.2430322319,
0.3259498775,
0.6346274018,
0.4972337782,
-0.1330566853,
-0.2473242879,
0.1135478914,
-0.1491279304,
0.3846462071,
-1.1177047491,
-0.2019592077,
0.0316611044,
-0.0252331309,
-0.2071454972,
-0.234989807,
-0.4504045248,
-0.369823724,
-0.1136580631,
0.6657610536,
-0.462364465,
-0.0634116381,
0.2316064388,
-0.2021400034,
0.6343829632,
0.790538311,
-0.7983617783,
0.3222395182,
0.4055710733,
0.8816611767,
-0.4347290695,
-0.2971243262,
-0.8998386264,
0.0747741386,
-0.477057755,
0.9066026807,
-0.4562708139,
-0.6010997891,
-0.2749380171,
0.2904183865,
-0.4725610614,
-0.163782388,
0.4911231399,
-0.4115143418,
0.3031519651,
-0.2136906534,
-0.5982237458,
-0.2311180383,
0.1818455458,
-0.2667007744,
0.7788338661,
0.3508967459,
-0.0485707819,
0.3762296736,
-0.8088724017,
-0.2679391205,
0.3353298306,
-0.0040333346,
-0.3211318552,
0.32133919,
0.0402356349,
0.3375681043,
-0.0056572589,
0.2003100812,
-0.1804835349,
-0.2366963774,
0.3898520172,
-0.6013438106,
0.3347492516,
0.0693209097,
-0.0784671679,
0.16363509,
-0.8278905153,
0.0475573801,
0.0235025249,
0.2148388028,
-0.2446610928,
-0.1399933696,
-0.1557791531,
0.3092646003,
-0.1328561455,
-0.5873363614,
0.3660706878,
-0.2126989216,
0.1981234103,
0.640268743,
0.4935483336,
0.6065734029,
-0.2558773756,
0.6187129617,
0.1709989309,
0.1872008741,
-0.770957768,
-0.2327578962,
-0.8771911263,
-0.2207464874,
0.4425341189,
0.5255905986,
-0.8769772053,
0.414585501,
-0.0139044942,
-0.5020685792,
-0.3997085392,
-0.344788909,
0.3199365139,
0.7804499865,
0.3872754872,
-0.7422333956,
-0.0429469645,
-0.4875569642,
-0.1873011291,
-0.0326789655,
0.0767984539,
0.4265874326,
0.1153112948,
0.4208374023,
0.9452876449,
-0.6301906705,
-0.2444076538,
0.0248478763,
0.246762082,
0.0948867649,
0.4012495577,
0.7063750029,
-0.48089993,
-0.9183486104,
-0.1540133506,
-0.4425270259,
-0.1412590444,
-0.6541895866,
-0.20501329,
-0.1053092256,
0.2128615528,
-0.6325029135,
0.5001386404,
0.138949126,
-0.4703275859,
0.4300161302,
-0.1366045326,
0.1300199628,
-1.1539309025,
-0.1384171098,
-0.0198081359,
-0.5007154942,
-1.1867702007,
-0.5469473004,
-0.061339017,
-0.3569522798,
-0.6932723522,
0.7400634289,
-0.4636390507,
0.0350883976,
-0.6426014304,
0.176873222,
0.0071860007,
0.7177984715,
0.3294652402,
1.0783581734,
1.0567297935,
-0.6219984293,
0.319257021,
0.4666468501,
0.0449483804,
0.978602469,
-0.5321147442,
0.3932165802,
0.0685266554,
0.4608820975,
-0.9054437876,
0.1261514425,
0.5283762813,
-0.4601011574,
0.3472657502,
-0.4604905248,
0.3463856578,
-0.0322514214,
-0.3955198526,
0.466493845,
0.451742053,
-0.3229295015,
0.4461111128,
-0.0177160688,
-0.3199081123,
-0.361923039,
-0.0497963354,
0.2252596617,
-0.1730059981,
-0.0785635561,
0.4976184964,
-0.3656536639,
0.4815565348,
0.0386398807,
-0.5742091537,
-0.1589893252,
0.2836868763,
0.0825723857,
0.2829254568,
-0.4644477963,
-0.1114048138,
-0.0887003466,
-0.4352474213,
-0.0984081775,
-0.4277029335,
0.2643027008,
0.1755405217,
-0.3443335593,
-0.6138908267,
0.2260038704,
0.6396511197,
-0.0992463604,
0.7012311816,
0.3990511298,
0.0475920998,
-0.4876396656,
-0.1520419717,
-0.2760148942,
-0.4941957593,
0.2129414678,
-0.6265344024,
-0.9980511665,
0.3479225338,
-0.4939972162,
-0.0761851966,
0.27005288,
0.3208064437,
0.0579212941,
0.7753036022,
0.8804551363,
0.0298870951,
0.6947315931,
0.1483020633,
0.4238664806,
-0.9941880107,
0.052937191,
-0.2118881345,
-0.0993260518,
-0.3884431124,
-0.5443835855,
0.4432038963,
0.2357371598,
-0.1989119053,
0.5850325227,
-0.5315374136,
0.5504795313,
0.3850885928,
-0.3308855593,
0.0104175974,
-0.0659500957,
0.2739387453,
-0.065157935,
-0.5219519734,
-0.0654468611,
0.692307055,
0.0450928323,
0.5974384546,
0.0456635356,
0.370239228,
0.5747354627,
-0.2593349814,
-1.108227253,
0.5493754745,
-0.0091287503,
-0.2282141596,
-0.3226920962,
-0.1017530188,
-0.9030559659,
0.4726593196,
-0.0602867492,
-0.9704475403,
0.4724960327,
0.0632074252,
-0.8270539641,
0.1120597273,
-0.2670908868,
0.8984860778,
-0.2463317662,
-0.35381037,
0.1094788834,
-0.6586145759,
-0.0117508741,
-0.4210926592,
-0.5374672413,
-0.5458093286,
-0.0503484197,
0.5125057101,
-0.2801008224,
0.8704392314,
-0.4589336514,
-0.0532657877,
0.2202431858,
0.3529186249,
0.3635441959,
-0.1946505457,
-0.043662481,
-0.0333476998,
0.0436271541,
-0.4475417435,
-0.8753881454,
0.3985819817,
-0.6616704464,
-0.7344208956,
-0.6986163855,
-0.5028998256,
-0.4724469781,
0.2342871279,
-0.1346993148,
0.6119137406,
-0.4192780554,
0.0399375223,
0.6014185548,
-0.2757307887,
0.5854676962,
1.1804603338,
0.2155962884,
-0.3421189189,
1.0429871082,
-0.1390054226,
0.3377927542,
0.2661323547,
-0.0349451862,
-0.3191284835,
-0.4233961999,
-0.9165539145,
0.1000626385,
-0.4062921405,
-0.5110410452,
-0.51850003,
-0.6634680629,
-0.1516512781,
-0.4462969005,
-0.300703615,
-0.6255147457,
-0.2526186109,
-0.0065985285,
0.5942026973,
0.3361974061,
0.1383684576,
0.7535013556,
-0.6991177201,
0.2437191606,
0.2589871883,
0.2794053555,
-0.3009198606,
-0.8074701428,
-0.0728900507,
-0.2695170939,
-0.5032814145,
-0.8484894037,
0.3038874865,
0.6999627352,
0.5510800481,
0.2291371971,
0.4675119221,
0.8454054594,
-0.6892777681,
1.1275281906,
0.2852414548,
-1.1535197496,
0.6859433651,
-0.3255749047,
0.3896895945,
0.5376386642,
0.3807556331,
-0.7805129886,
-0.0994003713,
-0.4945752919,
-0.5746727586,
1.3158333302,
0.011136245,
0.5029794574,
0.1102538779,
0.4163431525,
0.2599323392,
0.0428671017,
-0.3790346086,
-0.278300792,
-0.2660266757,
0.1128607094,
0.0233730581,
-0.212475121,
0.0723831505,
-0.1936331987,
0.765863657,
-0.587310791,
0.3807407618,
0.3199165761,
-0.1502577811,
-0.2600794435,
0.4883354306,
0.7291511297,
0.498893857,
-0.2529262602,
-0.011655909,
0.3540620506,
-0.1409317106,
0.5156903863,
0.1209225729,
-0.3390492201,
0.120147787,
-0.0371024981,
1.4928988218,
0.1428093463,
-0.2504463196,
0.8186442256,
-0.1651670039,
-0.414075911,
0.0529922619,
0.2214591056,
-0.4915751815,
0.1263649464,
0.2406147271,
0.3247178793,
0.2499001473,
-0.2875201702,
0.3881270289,
0.3060613871,
-0.7669660449,
-0.7300007939,
0.5905067325,
0.3502321839,
-0.3032373786,
0.3254077435,
-0.2467325926,
-0.5212243199,
0.3033727407,
0.9478956461,
1.2553964853,
-0.549513638,
0.5061462522,
0.2950207889,
-0.2288275957,
0.2382449508,
-0.0170721523,
-0.503973484,
-0.7638548613,
-0.5819406509,
-0.5080778003,
-0.7013078928,
0.1756027341,
-0.6579767466,
0.2258041054,
-0.3795882761,
-0.2342561036,
0.2150790244,
-0.145132497,
-0.4295189977,
-0.0363011807,
0.3808608353,
0.8566590548,
-0.8695396781,
0.9758784175,
0.6791359186,
-0.1484489739,
-0.4774950147,
0.1999305934,
0.0218528882,
-0.7741248012,
0.2620839179,
-0.0501278937,
-0.3906296492,
0.286440134,
-0.1092691123,
-0.9046553373,
0.959490478,
0.2442350686,
-0.4512291551,
0.2594241798,
0.1381983906,
0.4848880172,
-0.33864519,
0.4760203362,
0.4061159194,
0.1938137114,
0.4643593431,
-0.9865078926,
0.1490743309,
-0.0811834857,
0.1529769301,
0.2692677975,
-0.9019313455,
0.5006709695,
0.091701664,
-0.2985155284,
0.0321015045,
0.5693972111,
-0.1632232368,
0.3653823137,
0.5614029169,
0.2658317089,
0.5858694315,
0.0553624667,
0.6094162464,
-0.5917105675,
0.2866620421,
1.1774500608,
-0.7431573868,
0.4711360633,
0.1782088727,
-0.0609745532,
0.5413483977,
0.4567224681,
-0.2147388607,
0.8621739745,
0.0203934014,
-0.6060031652,
-0.2828881741,
-0.454516232,
-0.1298579723,
0.4621084034,
0.320812434,
0.0240512416,
-0.5905629396,
0.1668685377,
-0.0110858902,
-0.3179742992,
-0.150459528,
1.337477088,
0.0414659716,
-0.7925900817,
0.7187052369,
-0.1522772163,
0.3045367897,
-0.7942065597,
-0.1033952609,
-0.3610774875,
0.1688370109,
0.2760148942,
-0.6177936792,
0.1379193664,
0.0597699769,
-0.1119090617,
-0.3620821536,
1.0428894758,
-0.5289036036,
-0.1751313061,
0.1359064728,
0.8101876974,
0.2567910552,
-0.0213815831,
-0.8502182364,
-0.1152434647,
0.0606211685,
-0.1570493132,
0.4927185476,
0.5532425642,
-0.2206726074,
0.4044530392,
0.599283278,
-0.0567308553,
0.0300079007,
0.0270902608,
0.9223148227,
-0.8895708323,
-0.3118779957,
-0.8130500913,
0.4172744751,
-0.0520745777,
-0.3382325172,
0.8816238046,
0.4422803819,
0.5481707454,
-0.1489038616,
0.9258373976,
-0.0732737929,
0.2726462185,
-0.1476615369,
0.2506765723,
-0.2280013114,
0.0391073301,
0.0518308356,
-1.0513520241,
-0.1930210441,
0.3881802559,
-0.1615594178,
-0.1764587164,
0.585242033,
0.7527310848,
-0.334405005,
-0.0420777574,
0.6774579883,
0.0099035585,
0.2597157955,
0.7301434875,
1.0595823526,
-0.5727027655,
0.3365240395,
-0.1480176598,
-0.1846342087,
-0.1097085252,
-1.0709522963,
-0.798161149,
-0.4415085912,
-0.6948703527,
0.0017523766,
0.2621789277,
0.8056467772,
1.0601119995,
-1.0633846521,
-0.1064352095,
0.1561546326,
-0.1474790424,
-0.3691463172,
-0.2003522366,
0.4175104201,
-0.6659474969,
-0.6193966269,
0.8531047106,
0.4784068167,
0.0428397693,
0.1943524331,
-0.0621687919,
0.280433774,
0.4113645852,
0.6224322915,
0.5300869942,
-0.6240552068,
-0.4655888975,
-0.000922156,
0.1459507495,
0.2670879066,
0.8787108064,
-0.9867972732,
0.6466498971,
0.2193615884,
0.7072490454,
0.5746669173,
0.4122469127,
0.6352395415,
-0.8843327165,
-0.0360184349,
0.0057748263,
-0.0708349273,
0.2581965923,
-0.3325767517,
0.3798079789,
0.368326664,
-0.6401388645,
-0.6693260074,
0.1738786548,
-1.4035823345,
-0.246617198,
0.8176646829,
-0.1980963945,
-0.2143835425,
-0.2026753575,
-0.3892492652,
0.1717925221,
-0.6630600095,
0.4874079823,
0.3537278175,
-0.5551807284,
-0.4138294756,
-0.3989835382,
0.8091458082,
0.3655150533,
-0.6026187539,
0.0818986148,
0.3459121287,
0.5120459199,
0.1009721458,
0.9314031005,
0.2849197686,
0.3520608842,
-0.1456974298,
-0.0834576786,
-0.1367052346,
-0.2260579467,
-0.7156755328,
-0.0981993601,
0.0786019266,
-0.5182298422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04723v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04723v2 | Intrinsic Dimension Estimation for Robust Detection of AI-Generated Texts | 2023-06-07T18:38:04 | 2023-10-31T19:25:36 | Eduard Tulchinskii, Kristian Kuznetsov, Laida Kushnareva, Daniil Cherniavskii, Serguei Barannikov, Irina Piontkovskaya, Sergey Nikolenko, Evgeny Burnaev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, math.AT, 68T50 | Rapidly increasing quality of AI-generated content makes it difficult to
distinguish between human and AI-generated texts, which may lead to undesirable
consequences for society. Therefore, it becomes increasingly important to study
the properties of human texts that are invariant over different text domains
and varying proficiency of human writers, can be easily calculated for any
language, and can robustly separate natural and AI-generated texts regardless
of the generation model and sampling method. In this work, we propose such an
invariant for human-written texts, namely the intrinsic dimensionality of the
manifold underlying the set of embeddings for a given text sample. We show that
the average intrinsic dimensionality of fluent texts in a natural language is
hovering around the value $9$ for several alphabet-based languages and around
$7$ for Chinese, while the average intrinsic dimensionality of AI-generated
texts for each language is $\approx 1.5$ lower, with a clear statistical
separation between human-generated and AI-generated distributions. This
property allows us to build a score-based artificial text detector. The
proposed detector's accuracy is stable over text domains, generator models, and
human writer proficiency levels, outperforming SOTA detectors in model-agnostic
and cross-domain scenarios by a significant margin. | [
-0.2877858281,
-0.8299058676,
0.70024997,
-0.1955405176,
-0.2461510301,
0.1638032943,
-0.1998516321,
-0.7529459596,
0.1910625547,
0.1022298485,
-0.1271697283,
-0.6386088133,
-0.7088353634,
0.1682932228,
-0.3339379132,
0.8100717068,
0.0085265813,
-0.3057437241,
-0.472936064,
-0.256521225,
-0.1086498201,
-0.4895776212,
-0.24521029,
0.2272903621,
0.2594490051,
0.1863698661,
0.2720490396,
0.7913518548,
0.6945168376,
0.3506819606,
0.02879286,
0.4822843075,
-0.0011046201,
0.0971038565,
0.0105395755,
-0.4477351606,
-0.556509912,
0.170124948,
1.2194808722,
0.2204617113,
0.3665580451,
0.1448422968,
0.1659765542,
0.6185052395,
-0.6191494465,
0.1561757326,
-0.4982406497,
-0.0192988347,
-0.3225985169,
-0.2294791192,
-0.3310573697,
-0.4091041982,
0.1212035641,
-0.4454481602,
0.1933961809,
0.0905392468,
0.9522064328,
0.4443136752,
-0.3637381196,
-0.484532088,
-0.7616137862,
1.0422887802,
-0.5386655927,
0.3286497593,
0.6871584654,
0.0808906034,
0.2680476606,
-0.4437260032,
-0.932787478,
-0.273910135,
-0.0677442849,
0.1967583299,
-0.2362203598,
-0.2806892693,
0.111932531,
0.3627431393,
-0.7126622796,
0.2694430053,
0.0402148329,
-0.4734124541,
0.8015046716,
0.1665314436,
0.6780872941,
-0.2543968856,
-0.1990760118,
0.0139142014,
-0.5176629424,
0.2554384172,
0.6002885103,
0.1053680629,
-0.2144595981,
0.2873634398,
0.1928806305,
0.4067238867,
0.0770780668,
-0.3197208941,
0.1398000866,
-0.4851975143,
0.2275947332,
-0.0875806361,
1.0449510813,
-0.0395449735,
0.2170602679,
0.0525121354,
-0.2254985571,
0.202238664,
0.321383208,
-0.8764659762,
-0.3177812696,
0.1762825996,
-0.6023998857,
-0.3429955244,
0.308152318,
-0.4447185397,
-0.3786425591,
-0.1782130301,
0.3279311359,
-0.7684584856,
-0.1691991538,
-0.2436775863,
-0.0235387366,
0.0990236849,
0.0985213071,
-0.8044276834,
-0.0735332519,
0.4470096231,
0.9887521267,
-0.2946203351,
-0.3858870566,
-0.5830190182,
-0.0218725484,
-0.2620583475,
1.265280962,
-0.5897071958,
-0.2457511872,
-0.165979892,
-0.3880601525,
0.1302746534,
-0.425929755,
0.8784580827,
-0.2848971486,
0.1912458539,
-0.1447255462,
-0.6950334907,
0.0015919909,
0.4306613207,
-0.4466357827,
0.844278574,
0.0633243099,
-0.9473198056,
0.6737875342,
-0.4262278974,
-0.4879578948,
0.1758741885,
-0.1733634025,
-0.8736994267,
0.1079614162,
0.5566995144,
0.3785717785,
-0.1279635578,
-0.0192474481,
-0.0838973075,
-0.541657865,
0.5167657137,
-0.8222680688,
0.7651491165,
0.0013058943,
-0.2384021431,
0.2076776773,
-0.8707491755,
-0.0301165543,
-0.118078135,
-0.6401178837,
-0.5552649498,
0.3828885257,
0.0166894794,
-0.276668787,
0.4278562963,
-0.7783434987,
0.1173619032,
-0.3516794741,
0.2557967007,
0.9609078765,
-0.0092604943,
0.5620658994,
-0.2342583835,
0.4042631686,
0.241228044,
-0.1667302102,
-0.2356458306,
-0.5296105742,
-0.338332653,
-0.9025331736,
0.4385232925,
0.4844703078,
-0.7042078376,
1.1245180368,
-0.4493243694,
-0.4545870721,
-0.3223538101,
0.0055876998,
0.4103417397,
0.2489565611,
0.1607534885,
-0.2012702227,
-0.0354043096,
-0.6663330197,
-0.4871749878,
-0.6807261109,
-0.421566844,
0.2828958631,
0.5698165894,
-0.1554162353,
1.0456380844,
-0.6038921475,
-0.4536522627,
-0.1432536989,
0.3624989688,
-0.1203856915,
0.5870251656,
0.8340644836,
-0.7186023593,
-0.9995718598,
0.2544580102,
-0.8899914026,
-0.1393991709,
-0.3690750003,
-0.1484394372,
0.4381171167,
0.1094584018,
-0.499946028,
0.6177242994,
0.3025099635,
-0.4540696442,
0.6875582933,
-0.4515711963,
-0.0160132498,
-0.9871653318,
0.1825667769,
0.3472385406,
-0.3202275634,
-0.6705337763,
0.2291884273,
0.3609106541,
0.2315599173,
-0.074543491,
0.6674188375,
-0.4330145419,
0.0603603609,
-0.258987695,
0.2155374587,
0.0511375442,
0.5632896423,
0.0457705073,
0.8879688978,
0.3934867382,
-0.5832499862,
-0.0181355942,
0.4275697172,
-0.4990242124,
1.1643742323,
-0.6623994708,
0.2062157243,
-0.0930346921,
0.2318581492,
-0.6665794849,
-0.0857681558,
0.1659230292,
-0.9593634009,
0.4834313095,
0.0386484712,
-0.5557919741,
-0.0836125687,
-0.5369119048,
0.3775040805,
0.3783331513,
-0.551926434,
0.7378270626,
0.7386520505,
-0.1548268497,
-0.3655032516,
-0.6018323302,
0.0851852298,
-0.2532092631,
-0.6198564172,
0.1471350044,
-0.1709884405,
-0.0095395129,
0.033070676,
0.0625149235,
-0.2201566398,
0.0612520687,
0.315923661,
0.2074997574,
-0.2970117331,
0.0688387007,
0.5608345866,
-0.303666532,
0.1638005525,
-0.6059089899,
0.3265797198,
-0.1305160522,
-0.3704534769,
-0.7784119248,
0.3465365171,
0.7152885795,
-0.44846645,
0.8366424441,
1.031981349,
-0.629083097,
-0.214907527,
-0.1604209542,
0.0408643261,
-0.4880936146,
0.2954341769,
-0.3088372052,
-0.7311841249,
0.7146459222,
0.5042433143,
-0.0176829863,
0.6766058803,
0.6915916204,
-0.2155743241,
1.3593058586,
0.5282487273,
-0.2004656196,
0.3937857151,
-0.2600511014,
0.4450538158,
-0.8904309273,
-0.0591449663,
-0.7149255872,
-0.5123261809,
-0.6460955143,
-0.1160596386,
0.6373074651,
-0.2082397342,
-0.4058309495,
-0.0010644657,
-0.5897525549,
0.4962906539,
0.9832943082,
0.144847393,
0.1966438442,
0.1399136782,
-0.0819323659,
-0.2680265009,
-0.1334946305,
-0.5915060043,
0.9342342615,
0.4038175642,
0.3212186098,
0.2819885015,
0.5958983302,
0.4834493101,
0.1882259995,
-0.8475643992,
0.2503457367,
-0.361273855,
-0.4117791653,
-0.4566076398,
-0.7171400785,
-0.6184955835,
-0.0840012878,
-0.0906280726,
-0.9601006508,
0.2826943696,
0.0086840019,
-0.2474558502,
0.546620965,
-0.5168371797,
0.5451351404,
-0.0850817561,
-0.2744920254,
0.0106695099,
-0.394546777,
0.0533576012,
-0.2404093146,
-0.2320025712,
-0.0820882618,
0.0226712078,
0.6277396083,
-0.2642892897,
0.8571486473,
-0.2155299485,
-0.2689085007,
0.6105675697,
0.3069625199,
0.5502524376,
0.3411152661,
-0.1688325554,
0.4217083752,
-0.1026029438,
-0.6110985279,
-0.4534342587,
0.6524637938,
-1.031021595,
-0.3370089531,
-0.551183939,
-0.6875991821,
0.0972949043,
0.3715574741,
0.5895971656,
0.5615721941,
-0.1589087248,
0.0770004988,
0.3673529327,
-0.5370469093,
0.5092006326,
0.4113663137,
0.2445762306,
-0.2270666808,
1.578609705,
0.0183455311,
-0.0560409017,
0.6734814644,
0.4452497065,
-0.5282126069,
-0.7573176026,
-0.6117291451,
-0.0220525656,
-0.3135894835,
-0.2923797071,
-0.7980617285,
-0.4613786638,
-0.1743685454,
-0.2319003195,
-0.1291318238,
-0.3103981316,
-0.6196366549,
-0.0209221281,
0.139548108,
0.5698364377,
-0.2640891969,
0.0947707295,
-1.1850930452,
0.2349030972,
0.2210402489,
0.2601895034,
0.0266780257,
-0.7536029816,
-0.4231242537,
0.0602834076,
-0.4463753402,
-0.4133472145,
0.7067818642,
0.4357264042,
0.4573531449,
0.8594288826,
0.335618645,
0.0926538631,
-0.2674883604,
0.8860731721,
-0.128902033,
-1.1999659538,
0.516413331,
-0.4977802932,
0.3421866894,
0.3769100308,
0.2029273212,
-0.2380822152,
-0.6510725021,
-0.2890920639,
-0.3791470528,
0.6056326628,
0.4223821163,
0.2780150771,
-0.0097079864,
0.3342812061,
0.1109010726,
-0.0420664549,
-0.6364243627,
-0.1078065038,
-0.2298222929,
-0.5492932796,
0.1866256744,
-0.2852683067,
0.2914232016,
-0.2017767578,
0.3173607588,
-0.4186921716,
0.6581058502,
0.0119390162,
-0.2050504684,
-0.0897638649,
-0.2659881115,
0.6764135361,
0.4461213946,
-0.2726436555,
0.3500638604,
-0.1134205684,
-1.0584892035,
0.2123538256,
-0.1196075901,
-0.3916813433,
-0.3470391035,
0.7547467351,
0.59746629,
-0.4340156317,
-0.6265455484,
0.4964974821,
-0.2510098517,
-0.1045573428,
-0.3350805044,
0.0335427746,
-0.3420104384,
0.179911837,
0.2594950199,
0.3562760651,
0.1480548531,
-0.3294582069,
0.2422471941,
0.4714496732,
-0.7362473607,
-0.8665634394,
0.6362819076,
0.2194391638,
-0.4302024841,
0.7649471164,
-0.5600536466,
-0.8520770669,
0.6105538607,
0.4601921737,
1.0832351446,
-0.1049687788,
0.4581765234,
0.3987358212,
0.2948358655,
0.36917153,
0.1305995286,
-0.1377168298,
-1.1359277964,
-0.0713386089,
-0.8164925575,
-0.2033932358,
-0.2707718015,
-0.4329799116,
-0.0816663429,
-0.5617293119,
0.0078377435,
-0.0300523639,
0.285836339,
-0.2970476747,
0.0421247557,
0.092538327,
0.3831547797,
-0.7582088709,
0.7722127438,
0.6894240379,
-0.4211699069,
-0.3556966782,
0.4904901981,
0.2234772742,
-0.6382675171,
0.5030249953,
0.2949486971,
0.0081601599,
-0.0356977135,
-0.5137689114,
-0.7589334846,
0.9061792493,
0.1603591591,
0.0484043546,
0.2095559835,
0.1852067262,
0.8652674556,
-0.215258345,
0.1698931456,
0.6106754541,
0.4691375792,
-0.2661779821,
-0.3779394031,
-0.1132267416,
-0.4673138261,
-0.2184709311,
0.4322472215,
-0.5639094114,
0.8288419247,
0.0599378422,
-0.4798513949,
0.2705132961,
0.8582240939,
0.3483931124,
0.3847642243,
0.435837239,
0.446800977,
0.9047241211,
-0.0231776685,
1.2428565025,
-0.4216234684,
0.3032243252,
0.5963157415,
-0.1160536855,
0.766607523,
-0.0967363194,
-0.2530762255,
0.483656317,
0.3472254574,
0.0366936587,
0.2218488753,
-0.0710822791,
-0.3991141021,
-0.1713290364,
-0.2678111494,
0.000293311,
0.6781193018,
0.5016952753,
-0.1127906293,
0.3795372546,
-0.2145075798,
-0.2446797341,
0.3916882873,
0.1095426977,
0.6341744661,
-0.0016947323,
-0.4038141668,
0.2440688163,
0.1824812889,
0.772929132,
-0.2013371587,
0.0891225934,
-0.3343043029,
0.4653397501,
-0.0843795091,
-0.8894645572,
0.3154321909,
0.1976425946,
-0.3005123734,
-0.0326952301,
0.7367717624,
-0.2264356762,
-0.8503699303,
-0.0941193104,
0.3961869776,
0.0538830534,
-0.2398299277,
-0.3751531541,
-0.1636952013,
-0.086779654,
-0.0873965546,
0.3815106153,
0.6366671324,
0.0044491817,
0.4836477339,
0.8463752866,
0.1673176736,
-0.0116183879,
-0.3473314345,
0.5356903076,
-0.4517373443,
-0.7259812355,
-0.83683604,
0.6071016788,
-0.1955911368,
-0.5741886497,
0.7050043941,
0.3400504291,
0.4870376587,
0.0037100236,
0.8122345209,
-0.0247936696,
0.5095746517,
-0.4673036039,
1.2542076111,
-0.6024774313,
0.4792556167,
-0.2733255029,
-1.1687837839,
-0.4670834243,
0.7303347588,
-0.1409938335,
-0.1045834124,
0.5984637141,
0.5637988448,
-0.1061189547,
-0.1513604075,
0.3775832355,
0.1097867042,
0.9714525938,
0.2900927961,
0.8728711009,
-0.3440059125,
0.1942756325,
-0.102402769,
-0.3114521503,
-0.0158608835,
-0.7807103992,
-1.1222552061,
-0.6767473817,
-0.3010890484,
-0.0332332924,
-0.5794631839,
0.4630336165,
0.4965755939,
-0.9866964817,
0.1797701567,
-0.0387757607,
0.3781917989,
-0.1589772552,
-0.2639796436,
0.8408699036,
-0.0266765598,
-1.0825275183,
0.1270571053,
0.6604966521,
0.1121652126,
-0.5565015078,
-0.119025372,
-0.1764769256,
0.3778446615,
0.5541802049,
0.3356652558,
-0.517254591,
-0.8208321929,
0.0604286604,
-0.2965397239,
0.0506257117,
0.6576554775,
-0.5718775988,
0.3828081489,
0.9098222256,
0.7029180527,
0.0420165174,
0.105842784,
0.4639983475,
-1.1944732666,
0.1444995552,
0.2475143075,
0.2135703862,
0.2917024493,
-0.6060787439,
0.264366895,
0.3840377033,
-0.7592574358,
-0.9604849219,
0.1076575443,
-0.8409793973,
-0.1283957064,
0.7518885732,
-0.4676838815,
-0.1841255426,
-0.0107122837,
0.0262654424,
0.1096249074,
-0.3906912208,
1.0165442228,
0.365170598,
0.0477129743,
0.0502096452,
-0.0040653707,
0.2583213747,
0.0659236237,
-0.9447026253,
-0.293451041,
0.4250928164,
-0.2021943778,
0.559442997,
0.5259489417,
0.0904937387,
0.1436912417,
0.2802796066,
-0.0675125495,
-0.0182772875,
-0.7323704362,
-0.0526354797,
-0.0281919204,
-0.0768482387,
-0.2439514101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04707v1 | Improving Open Language Models by Learning from Organic Interactions | 2023-06-07T18:19:46 | 2023-06-07T18:19:46 | Jing Xu, Da Ju, Joshua Lane, Mojtaba Komeili, Eric Michael Smith, Megan Ung, Morteza Behrooz, William Ngan, Rashel Moritz, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Y-Lan Boureau, Jason Weston, Kurt Shuster | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present BlenderBot 3x, an update on the conversational model BlenderBot 3,
which is now trained using organic conversation and feedback data from
participating users of the system in order to improve both its skills and
safety. We are publicly releasing the participating de-identified interaction
data for use by the research community, in order to spur further progress.
Training models with organic data is challenging because interactions with
people "in the wild" include both high quality conversations and feedback, as
well as adversarial and toxic behavior. We study techniques that enable
learning from helpful teachers while avoiding learning from people who are
trying to trick the model into unhelpful or toxic responses. BlenderBot 3x is
both preferred in conversation to BlenderBot 3, and is shown to produce safer
responses in challenging situations. While our current models are still far
from perfect, we believe further improvement can be achieved by continued use
of the techniques explored in this work. | [
0.0054424852,
-0.9412542582,
0.6220245957,
-0.2800726295,
0.0713354796,
0.246609807,
-0.2420227975,
-0.8952051401,
-0.3748981953,
0.7781415582,
-0.263653338,
-0.4189509153,
-0.404309392,
0.0344338566,
-0.3396283984,
1.0334724188,
-0.0401338115,
0.4308510721,
-0.1502737105,
-0.060696099,
-0.3952111304,
-0.8092930317,
-1.084405899,
-0.4508246183,
0.5518718362,
0.5299566388,
0.8519257307,
0.4166472554,
0.4031683207,
0.3033094406,
-0.2251049429,
-0.0175862461,
-0.9400076866,
0.0818487331,
-0.2678567171,
-0.7523469925,
-0.3576578498,
0.2279883474,
0.3432626128,
0.8099367619,
-0.3319536746,
-0.1997491568,
0.3199727535,
0.4188804924,
-0.4252855182,
0.5745546818,
-0.6195687652,
0.1664128006,
0.0008711522,
0.0482685193,
-0.719805181,
-0.4824511111,
0.0394750759,
-0.70317173,
0.202140972,
0.0255908873,
0.7745907903,
-0.1591955423,
-0.3718063533,
-0.1317060441,
-1.0636239052,
0.7646873593,
-0.767134428,
0.3031803071,
0.68485111,
0.3511969745,
-0.4129314721,
-0.4514631927,
-0.8328773975,
-0.2368177623,
0.0146919014,
0.0299198776,
-0.1316584647,
0.2772619426,
-0.082811892,
0.3652568758,
-0.0604193136,
0.2527736127,
-0.7134212852,
0.0168969724,
0.5691496134,
0.2709267139,
0.1875727624,
0.2392870933,
-0.2068721652,
-0.4562988281,
-0.7961091399,
-0.0310137235,
0.6915766597,
0.4828366041,
-0.1231726259,
0.7185196877,
-0.0507296547,
0.6462919712,
-0.2223866135,
0.0623171963,
0.5089089274,
-0.3060121834,
-0.1093232557,
-0.3310129642,
0.7716234326,
0.6297860146,
0.3512947261,
0.047436852,
-0.2157732397,
-0.0112807825,
0.3675398827,
-0.6021726727,
-0.4744943082,
0.194375664,
-0.3797708452,
-0.5531587601,
0.1562798172,
-0.7916089892,
-0.5232477188,
-0.3070474267,
0.2539262772,
-0.5000018477,
-0.5498793125,
0.2395436019,
-0.0523546822,
-0.0454191528,
0.6492981315,
-1.0070171356,
0.8413318992,
0.6640262604,
0.6723607779,
-0.0937563926,
-0.0018535964,
-0.4331623614,
0.2825883627,
-0.3848022819,
0.5894576907,
-0.7217355967,
-0.556093812,
-0.1172994599,
-0.0513934605,
0.0586495511,
-0.9070433974,
0.0179553311,
-0.2906936109,
0.5503120422,
0.2165392041,
-0.3112692237,
-0.5881200433,
0.1852277219,
-0.628407836,
1.0298253298,
0.5095590949,
-0.4157713652,
0.1751613319,
-1.1311868429,
-0.156244278,
0.0244243722,
-0.042519059,
-0.2625254095,
-0.0251430552,
0.022349406,
0.2956516743,
-0.0533350632,
0.1696108133,
-0.6142131686,
0.0171966273,
0.3054824173,
-0.2700523138,
0.7193988562,
0.2373099476,
-0.0245857723,
0.4576911032,
-0.7680032849,
-0.107587032,
0.2320720851,
-0.4499824345,
-0.1089092419,
-0.002764777,
0.1842713058,
0.0291114245,
-0.2673162818,
-0.7702925205,
0.1149079055,
-0.6862699986,
0.2929226458,
1.1286486387,
0.1704761535,
0.2986184061,
-0.3989949226,
0.4682066739,
0.187273398,
0.3622677922,
-0.1730272472,
-0.6609432697,
-0.7637984753,
-0.0619398728,
0.0709583908,
0.3596501052,
-0.9333695173,
0.112659052,
-0.0165694952,
-0.5284666419,
-0.3375838101,
0.3499458134,
0.4119942486,
0.5106779337,
0.4580565691,
-0.6495585442,
-0.308755666,
-0.5151566267,
-0.2534350753,
-0.4044978321,
-0.2756227255,
0.5970965028,
0.4548463821,
-0.113937892,
0.9252181053,
-0.7288026214,
-0.0324259736,
-0.4210484326,
0.1605096757,
-0.0094534233,
0.6453541517,
0.6339300871,
-0.626468122,
-0.6581406593,
0.2730104923,
-0.5545413494,
0.3294102848,
0.5144963264,
0.0191972088,
0.3342430294,
0.4355949163,
-0.497444123,
0.2582880259,
0.563259244,
-0.2038063705,
0.1828916967,
0.1795575172,
0.0686745569,
-0.9782731533,
-0.1371583343,
-0.0621936396,
-0.4183312654,
-0.8712766767,
0.0755787194,
-0.3769409359,
-0.4548517168,
-1.017547965,
0.795614779,
-0.3066167831,
0.5827391148,
-0.114592649,
-0.1855998337,
-0.3814689815,
0.6637126803,
0.3397212029,
0.6024873257,
0.6468904018,
-0.5311369896,
0.3034419119,
0.3366405964,
-0.1111339331,
0.3541874886,
-0.5459758043,
0.4666473269,
-0.0606793799,
0.3168653548,
-0.665338695,
-0.5756899714,
0.8542308807,
-0.4532840252,
0.2131869346,
-0.1093759239,
-0.6547849774,
-0.3426262736,
-0.2057323605,
0.2352083772,
0.3951289356,
-0.4744884372,
0.6081948876,
0.563339889,
-0.2219301611,
-0.0643802211,
-0.2923562825,
-0.1677967161,
-0.1298565418,
-0.3849900663,
-0.4919996858,
-0.217741698,
-0.2293096036,
-0.0747370049,
-0.2306399047,
-0.4121242464,
0.2679884136,
0.1307415217,
0.2136272937,
-0.0992358178,
0.0035739909,
-0.4928034246,
-0.0933489799,
0.2945549786,
-0.0128024491,
0.5098763108,
-0.1223876178,
-0.1263776273,
-0.4430127144,
0.2774125934,
0.3177632689,
-0.0288131312,
0.915378511,
0.1753408909,
-0.4654405713,
0.013729088,
-0.1055322364,
-0.5648143291,
-0.5467607379,
0.2352146059,
0.0107598091,
-1.0169719458,
0.0748613998,
0.0625112653,
0.0451438762,
-0.0680272505,
0.3626684248,
-0.1401705295,
1.3736940622,
0.7906903028,
0.3789585233,
0.5923686028,
-0.2127926499,
0.3659560382,
-0.5773353577,
-0.5013507605,
-0.4575299919,
0.1692388058,
-0.2942497134,
-0.5771923065,
0.2984393239,
-0.2397639155,
-0.2853162587,
0.3032609522,
-0.112752378,
0.588393867,
0.6684767008,
0.6181189418,
0.208387509,
-0.0668928176,
0.1103477702,
0.1934702247,
-0.6355813146,
-0.5300582647,
1.2165546417,
0.6172870994,
1.0102910995,
0.3283179402,
0.5541405082,
-0.1247095093,
0.6895334721,
-0.6950882077,
0.7179953456,
0.4607695341,
-0.8116746545,
-0.153584376,
-0.7188398838,
-1.1029558182,
0.1153624952,
-0.3688953221,
-1.1249630451,
-0.2368838936,
0.4509704411,
-0.237512216,
0.3885417581,
-0.8361102939,
0.823736012,
-0.159975037,
-0.4424564242,
-0.1705164462,
-0.8555064797,
0.2666069269,
0.0486661084,
0.2497943938,
-0.1138274074,
0.277862817,
0.5192825198,
-0.4705659747,
1.3594630957,
-0.1731216013,
-0.4055044651,
0.4152635336,
0.2616006732,
0.2613867521,
-0.1155128852,
0.0782861337,
0.2912986875,
-0.3231980205,
-0.3360265791,
-0.6234070063,
0.4465650022,
-0.9115926623,
-0.7977532744,
-0.539079845,
-0.5933783054,
-0.4825592935,
0.3765334785,
-0.2616040707,
0.0538716093,
-0.1216951385,
0.5951510072,
0.6781013608,
-0.1760751307,
0.1640921086,
0.6449161172,
-0.4309039116,
-0.3674417436,
0.8824462891,
-0.2622818351,
0.716383934,
0.2463737875,
0.4037407041,
-0.0911688879,
-0.4779326618,
0.1707132608,
-0.0036003431,
-0.8542304635,
-0.2938469648,
-0.8492301702,
-0.1537405252,
-0.4411959648,
-0.0140399793,
-0.36357674,
-0.4620253444,
-0.5540282726,
-0.501994133,
0.3911004364,
1.1357537508,
-0.0983935595,
0.5421628952,
-0.9245458245,
0.2984240353,
0.1165127084,
0.6778222919,
-0.0432876758,
0.0200849939,
-0.2879858911,
0.3292962015,
-0.8200750947,
-1.0775427818,
0.2332348526,
0.1577926576,
0.5845063925,
0.3687205911,
-0.1207560897,
0.117416054,
-0.2219836265,
1.0634896755,
0.2974050641,
-0.8737059832,
0.7230440974,
-0.7016774416,
0.0460576415,
0.427396059,
0.5973325372,
-0.3164538443,
-0.7071171403,
-0.7648355961,
-0.9765694141,
1.0307378769,
0.4210410416,
0.2815662324,
-0.1940259486,
-0.0915118232,
0.3587331176,
0.36537233,
-1.1862411499,
-0.0772417784,
-0.270594418,
-0.3228150308,
-0.0476077236,
0.0773780867,
-0.4614973664,
-0.2285243273,
0.8639678359,
-0.2764384449,
-0.0859379098,
-0.2862211466,
0.2137116641,
-0.3117354214,
0.1231713668,
0.1515224278,
0.5074465275,
-0.2050590664,
0.0366075821,
0.0238728244,
-0.5344860554,
0.1524135917,
-0.1199649721,
0.0746025667,
-0.4040675461,
0.0573091544,
0.7258391976,
0.2862940431,
-0.9075781703,
0.4841981232,
-0.1079322472,
-0.1352722347,
0.0212023109,
0.6328523159,
-0.1114524677,
-0.1044852734,
-0.0666191205,
0.3558245897,
0.1128665134,
-0.7433214784,
0.0224045683,
0.125698626,
-0.7306814194,
-0.3033000827,
0.7580910921,
0.7160923481,
-0.4088798463,
0.8128111959,
0.2040857524,
-0.4255870879,
0.3026581109,
0.6308028698,
0.712990582,
-0.3526366353,
0.2523107231,
0.4239721,
0.2116586417,
0.0132905841,
0.3777095377,
-0.0898562819,
-0.7904118896,
0.0892688036,
-0.1795545518,
-0.7884201407,
0.3407061994,
-0.6592534781,
0.3250931501,
-0.5607875586,
-0.015662726,
-0.1986662149,
-0.2982649505,
-0.5756237507,
0.1088057458,
-0.0841953829,
0.7825214863,
-1.0112444162,
0.6171553135,
0.691861093,
-0.4724186361,
-0.8336302042,
-0.0749883354,
0.2870254815,
-0.606636703,
0.3356687725,
0.3799755573,
-0.0935633928,
0.0945235416,
-1.0401022434,
-0.8642312288,
0.6951438785,
0.3763129413,
-0.2158777416,
0.3005869091,
0.1716707796,
0.6639968157,
-0.1944488883,
0.2262218148,
0.3565196395,
0.3809741139,
-0.0254335701,
-0.8744612932,
-0.0665857047,
-0.5120933652,
-0.0474849492,
0.135305658,
-0.5489274263,
0.6786548495,
-0.2681383491,
-0.4753261209,
0.304390341,
0.7115781307,
0.1333857626,
0.1242292076,
0.626403749,
0.4448800683,
0.6285343766,
-0.1916988343,
1.2178502083,
-0.040112257,
0.2599036396,
1.481842041,
-0.6425732374,
0.8235848546,
0.5340422988,
0.0288118348,
0.4546672702,
0.6324620843,
0.0594776012,
0.4605926275,
0.4192264974,
-0.4683814943,
-0.0270501878,
-0.1089391485,
-0.240086481,
0.394359082,
0.4193204045,
-0.1115474403,
-0.1203728095,
0.2408589125,
0.3259695172,
0.3241487741,
0.0068196524,
1.0968903303,
-0.2025675625,
-0.7511417866,
0.2743946612,
-0.2099551558,
0.0883843154,
-0.5482313633,
-0.6622747183,
0.0044160909,
0.3189455569,
-0.0918371007,
-1.1045260429,
0.1718814969,
-0.1696678102,
0.08305417,
-0.2485696524,
0.3341006637,
-0.5736325979,
-0.2791938782,
0.3532088697,
0.3105096221,
0.0638626516,
0.2018018961,
-0.4926940203,
0.1621826291,
-0.1934738904,
-0.2059627175,
0.1060574353,
0.1536909938,
-0.0532146879,
0.7779389024,
0.9776477814,
-0.0977022499,
-0.0123379687,
-0.0298278574,
1.177482605,
-0.4318947196,
-0.4271235764,
-0.3219473064,
0.5864408016,
-0.0657925978,
-0.1612520963,
0.7314600348,
0.5709584951,
1.4186530113,
-0.2466614246,
0.9579057097,
-0.0248475894,
0.6456210613,
-0.7191185951,
0.4996706843,
-0.2251075655,
0.2342990041,
-0.1414848268,
-0.9307873249,
-0.3459219337,
0.6469026208,
0.0227488484,
0.2773261368,
0.8693290949,
0.8460153937,
-0.2207784802,
0.2647508085,
0.0949815586,
0.6535794139,
0.6773407459,
0.3857338428,
0.9749928117,
-0.2494311184,
0.4552706182,
-0.4069910049,
-0.4437161088,
-0.0089711342,
-0.831981957,
-0.983866632,
-0.3419627547,
-0.2585192025,
-0.4939398468,
0.2704719305,
1.0044300556,
0.8498075604,
-0.7977792621,
-0.4581588209,
-0.3479249179,
0.0867925212,
-0.2960812747,
-0.3301625252,
-0.3847470284,
-0.1286691874,
-0.8537505865,
0.595371604,
0.0379700698,
0.3728270829,
-0.141539067,
-0.1795312166,
-0.1881738901,
0.1615017802,
0.523168385,
0.4717126191,
-0.5507031083,
-0.6311243176,
-0.1665928662,
0.2009414583,
0.348218143,
0.7599136829,
-0.5221450329,
0.7096273303,
0.2715462446,
0.2482156605,
0.2790718973,
-0.050654918,
1.1614588499,
-0.6611201763,
0.0474384278,
0.5073454976,
0.1882669181,
0.6052962542,
-0.4604568183,
0.7915799618,
0.1549649388,
-0.4012353122,
-0.9248049855,
0.3217452168,
-0.8066003323,
-0.2752201557,
1.2969546318,
-0.2586375475,
-0.2926934659,
-0.2809042633,
-0.575532794,
0.0598414764,
-0.4892186522,
0.6792925596,
0.616957128,
-0.3236328363,
-0.1876849681,
-0.5727081299,
0.4076775908,
-0.0985022262,
-1.1553527117,
0.1717809737,
0.6461919546,
0.3648192585,
0.1104217693,
0.757914722,
-0.3587561548,
0.2657101452,
-0.0825132206,
0.1924981922,
0.1060318425,
-0.7218642831,
-0.2659936249,
-0.0300830416,
0.0482627191,
-0.0248960853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04695v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04695v2 | ConceptBed: Evaluating Concept Learning Abilities of Text-to-Image Diffusion Models | 2023-06-07T18:00:38 | 2024-02-22T19:11:46 | Maitreya Patel, Tejas Gokhale, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The ability to understand visual concepts and replicate and compose these
concepts from images is a central goal for computer vision. Recent advances in
text-to-image (T2I) models have lead to high definition and realistic image
quality generation by learning from large databases of images and their
descriptions. However, the evaluation of T2I models has focused on photorealism
and limited qualitative measures of visual understanding. To quantify the
ability of T2I models in learning and synthesizing novel visual concepts
(a.k.a. personalized T2I), we introduce ConceptBed, a large-scale dataset that
consists of 284 unique visual concepts, and 33K composite text prompts. Along
with the dataset, we propose an evaluation metric, Concept Confidence Deviation
(CCD), that uses the confidence of oracle concept classifiers to measure the
alignment between concepts generated by T2I generators and concepts contained
in target images. We evaluate visual concepts that are either objects,
attributes, or styles, and also evaluate four dimensions of compositionality:
counting, attributes, relations, and actions. Our human study shows that CCD is
highly correlated with human understanding of concepts. Our results point to a
trade-off between learning the concepts and preserving the compositionality
which existing approaches struggle to overcome. The data, code, and interactive
demo is available at: https://conceptbed.github.io/ | [
-0.3691268265,
-0.7762318254,
0.6781769991,
0.2460120469,
-0.4953535199,
0.3763698637,
-0.0746541098,
-0.1646255106,
0.0801007897,
0.067219466,
-0.2035278082,
-1.0562968254,
-0.5632538795,
-0.3394212425,
-0.505371809,
0.5536422729,
-0.2885704041,
-0.0944791585,
-0.7734009624,
0.0862892941,
-0.9006431699,
0.2131781876,
-0.615819037,
0.0741853938,
0.2056484818,
0.3507764339,
0.2972633541,
0.5572182536,
0.8335716724,
0.1743709147,
-0.0187803693,
0.1705956608,
-0.3880560696,
-0.0565666705,
-0.3013966084,
-0.4949475527,
-0.2528398931,
0.1162818819,
0.5842743516,
0.452989608,
-0.0913913921,
0.0432467461,
0.062708579,
0.5570158362,
-0.7126095891,
0.1751387119,
-0.3165878057,
0.2689065933,
0.1366019249,
-0.0272621214,
-0.4058688283,
-0.340931952,
0.4335368574,
-0.8453242779,
0.4802947044,
-0.0762453526,
0.8890017867,
0.4943836033,
-0.1317694932,
-0.4892217815,
-0.4205109179,
0.5937740207,
-0.1116698831,
0.255223155,
0.2895186245,
0.4450164735,
0.3180247843,
-0.6783999205,
-0.685131669,
-0.0058510136,
0.242098406,
0.419413954,
-0.064751856,
-0.3193659186,
-0.1284687221,
0.1873246431,
-0.5198462605,
0.0257285759,
-0.3077302277,
-0.1154184565,
0.7164068222,
0.1227611229,
0.4145974219,
-0.1414936036,
-0.5070385337,
-0.3771466315,
-0.1093797311,
0.0180499852,
0.0064173215,
-0.142889902,
-0.4355299175,
0.6477473974,
0.1820461154,
0.5913847089,
0.1100546271,
-0.2251999676,
0.2346855849,
-0.5233062506,
-0.1647578478,
-0.0625403374,
0.5897482038,
0.8249543905,
0.2178811729,
-0.1744700968,
0.0177425221,
0.5518652797,
0.5298717022,
-0.7086718678,
-0.2931914628,
0.1855050325,
-0.3311123252,
-0.5997092128,
0.2270555645,
-0.6157535911,
-0.5090543032,
-0.0813179985,
0.5226540565,
-0.6508123875,
-0.3389104009,
0.1736520678,
-0.7803311944,
0.346252799,
0.5418402553,
-0.4160351753,
0.1723097712,
0.4945447445,
1.2224150896,
-0.9254726768,
-0.06940189,
0.1429783553,
0.0652302951,
-0.9163022637,
1.0165470839,
-0.4643363655,
-0.7466022372,
-0.1493225098,
-0.3922501802,
-0.1066856235,
-0.4718438685,
0.1881240606,
-0.3969037235,
0.0827491507,
-0.2357190251,
-0.8426609635,
-0.0406797752,
0.3162574172,
-0.4657875896,
0.6747905016,
0.2443265766,
-0.8127982616,
0.5613960028,
-0.620147109,
-0.2541706264,
0.1908290535,
-0.3217729926,
-0.5091614127,
0.2243361622,
-0.314319402,
0.5948413014,
-0.0371747874,
0.0674403831,
-0.4140056074,
-0.3820609748,
0.3581830859,
0.0637088642,
0.2315706164,
0.2015047073,
-0.0468638986,
0.0137565238,
-0.6142020822,
-0.0958418027,
0.288449347,
0.0955470651,
-0.6944079995,
0.0475196727,
0.2158869803,
0.147640422,
0.2116212696,
-0.5297697783,
0.0547971502,
0.0821161643,
0.4020295143,
0.6336627603,
0.5227080584,
0.4651962519,
-0.1823017299,
0.4226810634,
0.4477860332,
-0.1514699906,
-0.3326079845,
-0.5518642664,
-0.5634557009,
-0.4327826798,
0.274276942,
0.4159899652,
-0.8606727719,
0.5629609823,
-0.3559986651,
-0.5647554398,
-0.3720770776,
0.1405690461,
0.4427956045,
0.4667460024,
0.3087260723,
-0.8407208323,
0.0719130114,
-0.7973144054,
0.138938725,
0.0203653257,
-0.0459802933,
0.2996982336,
0.6347975731,
-0.2462867349,
1.1405005455,
-0.8172416091,
-0.5664540529,
-0.0524229631,
0.1823431253,
-0.4231169522,
0.5547891259,
0.5498606563,
-0.9094615579,
-0.4054690897,
0.0357851014,
-0.8628099561,
0.3575260937,
-0.3047748506,
-0.2781426609,
-0.0015586114,
0.5003048182,
-0.4839807153,
0.6907228827,
0.3012368977,
-0.5731303096,
0.1165755987,
-0.2160125971,
-0.0061745965,
-1.5441561937,
-0.0819573104,
0.6895104647,
0.0355926603,
-0.3062187433,
0.1837477833,
0.1790280789,
0.1005252227,
-0.3230580688,
0.4957440495,
-0.2134145796,
-0.3195026815,
-0.0937052816,
0.4820280969,
0.1383766681,
0.1343370974,
0.4732531011,
0.8021228313,
0.5335755348,
-0.7211533785,
0.1788246334,
0.6886380315,
-0.6932515502,
1.0060975552,
-0.9008181691,
0.238600716,
-0.0803941861,
0.1546428502,
-1.4659143686,
-0.3118361831,
-0.0434144959,
-0.5394362807,
0.2849246562,
0.1839194,
-0.3977357745,
-0.1873294264,
-0.3825463355,
0.3135610819,
0.4993166924,
-0.3433850706,
0.392103076,
0.3060260713,
0.1304694265,
-0.3665029705,
-0.8839381337,
0.1717113853,
-0.1391680837,
-0.5919504762,
0.5467711091,
-0.211862579,
-0.2343178689,
0.2963800728,
-0.0115222055,
-0.1347900331,
0.131064266,
0.3082461357,
0.3378553689,
-0.0342178345,
0.341750294,
0.1832974553,
0.1048795432,
0.0735880136,
-0.3961417675,
0.2479807436,
0.1311525255,
-0.3734658062,
-0.6506928205,
-0.0103084175,
0.2284106165,
-0.2571928501,
0.5698224306,
0.7476522923,
-0.315033704,
-0.2487507313,
-0.3370480239,
0.2345151305,
-0.3426636755,
0.4747915864,
-0.444278717,
-0.60542804,
0.260258615,
-0.040461611,
0.0080414973,
0.4250195026,
0.4345387816,
-0.6394930482,
0.5194821954,
0.8538778424,
0.4040796757,
0.48135221,
-0.8179035187,
-0.0988869667,
-0.841562748,
-0.5811162591,
-0.0607344583,
-0.4621749222,
-0.4928673804,
-0.9658125043,
0.2433571219,
-0.1972365528,
-0.0571268685,
0.0560655259,
-0.4538706243,
0.509070158,
0.3928996623,
0.5975506306,
0.2630807161,
0.2009404302,
-0.2488759011,
-0.0527401641,
-0.2215445042,
-0.4200946689,
1.2172294855,
0.3328767419,
0.6693809628,
0.0250458717,
0.6823230386,
0.7377310991,
0.0187597927,
-1.0856533051,
0.4488863647,
-0.2478094846,
-0.2195717245,
-0.0987597108,
-0.2110127956,
-0.4550507963,
0.0199958738,
-0.425779134,
-0.2680610418,
0.399923116,
0.127664417,
-0.1562188417,
0.0982334912,
-0.9584538937,
0.8895907998,
0.0549437851,
-0.5464363694,
-0.5296266675,
-0.4273372591,
0.3787506819,
-0.3324132562,
-0.148802489,
0.1660555154,
-0.406311959,
0.5981598496,
0.0365891084,
0.943892777,
-0.1458200663,
-0.1541902423,
0.3300221562,
0.1577780843,
-0.1663311273,
-0.139776051,
0.246299848,
0.0665026456,
-0.1078088731,
-0.4838241339,
-0.6083606482,
0.5498845577,
-0.9206311703,
-0.2299125344,
-0.190773204,
-0.2039100975,
-0.0865262672,
-0.0760668591,
0.4432882965,
0.2151847035,
-0.7276918292,
0.2400437146,
0.9946650267,
-0.2943711579,
0.4532801807,
-0.059892986,
0.0142644774,
-0.3171446621,
1.0710052252,
-0.1206233278,
0.4125422239,
0.4682270885,
0.0302518252,
-0.3200845718,
-0.5909927487,
-0.3192721307,
0.0747768357,
-0.7614290714,
-0.1714156121,
-0.4718561471,
-0.1173561439,
0.056049671,
-0.32522735,
-0.2776679993,
-0.479451865,
-0.5218389034,
-0.1760574281,
0.1187175289,
0.7949020863,
0.3421414196,
0.3336498439,
-0.3497956395,
0.3769673705,
0.4238583446,
0.3892048895,
-0.0652129129,
-0.6054934859,
-0.1507781148,
-0.0960010141,
-0.5441901684,
-0.735710144,
0.1693147868,
0.2623970509,
0.2756176293,
0.5883421898,
-0.1996083409,
0.5699549913,
-0.1613224,
0.8213359714,
0.5492708087,
-1.0648537874,
0.7996995449,
0.0350346565,
0.1653309166,
0.3764669001,
0.4996604919,
-0.4579250216,
-0.1003722548,
-0.6463755965,
-0.3417019248,
0.1670214236,
0.1153963208,
0.1688652486,
0.1147764772,
0.5087553263,
-0.0070727644,
0.0970467553,
-0.1909170896,
0.0753521621,
-0.4825461507,
-0.6369344592,
-0.3232018054,
-0.0546033122,
0.0576336458,
-0.0122742103,
0.1241032556,
-0.3341345787,
0.3189029396,
0.1881822795,
-0.2149814367,
0.213148877,
-0.0755559802,
0.5796954036,
0.5664842129,
-0.0485042892,
0.0284846444,
-0.1151894331,
-0.7155096531,
0.2026448995,
-0.3467333913,
-0.2552682459,
-0.0580192953,
0.4710415602,
0.8080948591,
-0.1343654394,
-0.5226286054,
0.822391808,
-0.3711650074,
-0.5456779599,
-0.2632233799,
0.346429348,
0.1483474672,
0.0874215215,
0.1215878353,
0.5331299305,
0.1191665903,
-0.3499139249,
0.1817323118,
0.3798307478,
-0.5126134753,
-0.4360515177,
0.497964263,
0.1617168933,
-0.1044360921,
0.6093441844,
-0.2183115929,
-0.0378592126,
0.8015807271,
0.3567335606,
0.8707681894,
-0.0171484221,
0.6509410143,
0.3734010756,
0.1357022822,
0.0265191067,
0.2330878526,
-0.1165433303,
-1.0932476521,
-0.1837638617,
-0.4199786186,
-0.3999363184,
-0.4033998549,
-0.7196398377,
0.3452168107,
-0.7736985683,
-0.3144057989,
0.1661774665,
-0.0358984321,
-0.7430849075,
0.4238349199,
0.1529006511,
1.0920671225,
-0.9506821036,
0.7328787446,
0.9014920592,
-0.5877489448,
-0.4968234301,
0.1649805307,
-0.1845355779,
-0.6668325067,
0.5793716908,
0.0818042308,
-0.0812544003,
0.0930995718,
-0.8703491092,
-0.3511976302,
1.4138168097,
-0.0431187823,
-0.3925586045,
-0.0207446981,
-0.1214159876,
0.6853176355,
-0.7515105605,
0.1531097889,
0.5637114048,
0.171644792,
0.6441682577,
-0.2082508355,
-0.2098464221,
-0.1946640611,
0.5442808867,
-0.2839162648,
-0.6265335083,
0.2499783337,
-0.685765326,
-0.3157973289,
0.0201332774,
0.5914504528,
0.242141217,
0.5529710054,
0.4501819909,
0.8217422962,
0.6761747003,
-0.2043538541,
0.9676424861,
-0.0288866013,
0.2154337615,
0.8785523176,
-0.1383050084,
1.0387625694,
0.2820356488,
0.0618064627,
0.6676881909,
0.8047270179,
-0.2205448598,
0.8299957514,
0.0538437888,
0.0092403051,
-0.2862586975,
-0.2400971949,
-0.1613479406,
0.4817271829,
0.692447722,
-0.3795250356,
0.1834704131,
0.0354610048,
-0.5131114125,
0.2469629794,
-0.0532716215,
1.0741815567,
0.060799934,
-0.3372015655,
0.2940633893,
-0.0565044917,
0.5043983459,
-0.3424898684,
-0.1231461838,
-0.4259857535,
0.1449609995,
-0.2008638829,
-1.1291332245,
0.1273664981,
-0.0225702468,
-0.1150165647,
0.0439406298,
0.3881869316,
-0.3755106926,
-0.4534822106,
0.0185150169,
0.3668904603,
-0.0094274562,
0.1482889652,
-0.5999633074,
0.1472181231,
-0.0467258096,
0.21838139,
0.0801232085,
0.4108297825,
-0.1330986917,
0.6415569782,
0.3299098909,
0.0506320149,
-0.2525455058,
-0.0118045248,
0.6279326081,
-0.542548418,
-0.5224751234,
-0.6479036212,
0.3615934253,
-0.268255651,
-0.4652386308,
0.4817416966,
0.5384697318,
0.8280465603,
-0.3623394966,
0.8643018603,
0.0958127603,
0.1310260296,
-0.502818644,
0.5319671035,
-0.5642680526,
0.0172238965,
-0.5101478696,
-0.9125579596,
-0.171194464,
0.7391555309,
-0.1911258847,
-0.1147497743,
0.6991285086,
0.5123678446,
-0.1006989256,
-0.0046122205,
0.3527188599,
-0.0848679915,
0.2114735544,
0.3739906847,
0.8500618339,
-0.3323842883,
0.0925217643,
-0.1332948506,
-0.3884036541,
0.014234921,
-0.7508988976,
-0.9682785273,
-0.7675670981,
-0.853448689,
-0.1108147576,
-0.052109085,
0.6917527318,
0.883771956,
-0.5641111135,
-0.0857421905,
-0.3363176286,
0.0177696515,
-0.2014654577,
-0.2019571811,
0.6206822395,
-0.2055313289,
-0.5866905451,
-0.1282976419,
0.3256807029,
0.4841681719,
-0.2640050352,
0.0453699194,
0.1080569923,
0.0816202685,
0.5876939297,
-0.1977108121,
-0.5155273676,
-0.0109591968,
0.0256236997,
-0.2419086695,
0.1184013635,
0.6114737988,
-0.5726231337,
0.6458073854,
0.3604702353,
0.8796252608,
0.6614866853,
0.2634407282,
0.3190348148,
-0.8505652547,
0.0475036986,
-0.1382537335,
0.1634302735,
0.5940961242,
-0.2850418389,
0.5052230358,
0.5850540996,
0.0965535119,
-0.3620631993,
0.0689072758,
-1.2316418886,
-0.3699181378,
0.8348838687,
-0.3155207336,
-0.2104727626,
0.2272184789,
-0.2508513331,
-0.0083769318,
-0.3340601921,
0.8077097535,
0.7876818776,
0.2261797786,
-0.2719191611,
-0.4089009166,
0.3540642262,
0.063628599,
-0.9671244621,
-0.4437087774,
0.4918841124,
0.4625752568,
0.3847954273,
0.2961315215,
0.0275479611,
0.312567085,
0.0813814104,
0.2644421756,
0.1735633761,
-0.2962077558,
-0.1738506705,
0.1007046029,
-0.0407616161,
-0.5970201492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04640v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04640v2 | ModuleFormer: Modularity Emerges from Mixture-of-Experts | 2023-06-07T17:59:57 | 2023-09-11T19:31:26 | Yikang Shen, Zheyu Zhang, Tianyou Cao, Shawn Tan, Zhenfang Chen, Chuang Gan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable results. However,
existing models are expensive to train and deploy, and it is also difficult to
expand their knowledge beyond pre-training data without forgetting previous
knowledge. This paper proposes a new neural network architecture, ModuleFormer,
that leverages modularity to improve the efficiency and flexibility of large
language models. ModuleFormer is based on the Sparse Mixture of Experts (SMoE).
Unlike the previous SMoE-based modular language model, which requires
domain-labeled data to learn domain-specific experts, ModuleFormer can induce
modularity from uncurated data with its new load balancing and concentration
losses. ModuleFormer is a modular architecture that includes two different
types of modules: new stick-breaking attention heads and feedforward experts.
Different modules are sparsely activated conditions on the input token during
training and inference. In our experiment, we found that the modular
architecture enables three important abilities for large pre-trained language
models: 1) Efficiency, since ModuleFormer only activates a subset of its
modules for each input token, thus it could achieve the same performance as
dense LLMs with more than two times throughput; 2) Extendability, ModuleFormer
is more immune to catastrophic forgetting than dense LLMs and can be easily
extended with new modules to learn new knowledge that is not included in the
training data; 3) Specialisation, finetuning ModuleFormer could specialize a
subset of modules to the finetuning task and the task-unrelated modules could
be easily pruned for a lightweight deployment. | [
-0.2784867883,
-0.4497836828,
0.4564994574,
0.1215916276,
-0.1671163738,
0.0145501569,
-0.4723494053,
0.0243266579,
0.3063242435,
0.4881410301,
-0.2917037308,
-0.2103989124,
-0.8007940054,
-0.1081553772,
-0.1404596269,
0.7667094469,
0.3309117258,
0.0911672637,
-0.3571673334,
0.0048989085,
-0.4246985316,
-0.3312341273,
-0.6013563275,
-0.3935374916,
0.7216976285,
0.28346017,
0.4877139628,
0.5273327231,
-0.0230864529,
0.5795906782,
-0.1708900928,
0.1411257386,
-0.3893841207,
-0.0933127254,
-0.1034524739,
-0.7307268381,
-0.8334826827,
-0.3742640018,
0.6254588962,
0.6458687782,
-0.2479769737,
0.120020099,
-0.1701387912,
0.6281055212,
-0.3859384358,
0.3807498813,
-0.9126232862,
-0.0195280612,
-0.0626443923,
0.3220355809,
-0.383318007,
-0.0373012647,
0.1481479853,
-0.3919141889,
0.0361212082,
-0.143640697,
0.1254033297,
0.2638181746,
-0.3037060797,
0.289287746,
-0.3360163569,
0.6627573967,
-0.9571066499,
0.1285169721,
0.0662074909,
0.4090909958,
-0.1146380156,
-0.5364838839,
-0.6331217885,
-0.1008516327,
-0.205596894,
0.1196452454,
-0.0529689081,
0.1887062788,
-0.1024114341,
0.404532522,
-0.5176206827,
0.3086077869,
-0.653734386,
-0.2078491598,
0.4518633783,
-0.1070144624,
0.3809634149,
-0.3177279234,
-0.0227748808,
0.3453011215,
-0.4599144161,
-0.0523390584,
0.4417889118,
0.1979535818,
0.2518470287,
0.404445976,
-0.2954972982,
0.7128347158,
0.3192933202,
-0.1393859982,
0.2568640709,
0.2111641467,
-0.342269063,
-0.0569013469,
0.5987514853,
-0.2890713215,
0.0095764557,
-0.3823259473,
-0.5705763102,
-0.3715718687,
0.4553874433,
-0.5568307042,
-0.4136358202,
0.2051202655,
-0.6104010344,
-0.228402704,
0.0747916698,
-0.1841505766,
-0.0144969169,
-0.5294985175,
0.9490190148,
-0.4614614546,
-0.5934907198,
0.173095718,
-0.101239413,
-0.1342786551,
0.3961932659,
-1.0883307457,
0.5515022874,
0.8914452791,
0.6808066964,
-0.4416153729,
-0.3070813417,
-0.4024090171,
0.0371034741,
0.0132735036,
0.866884172,
-0.3957807124,
0.1473380923,
-0.2535401881,
0.1172300354,
-0.4688055515,
-0.7522220016,
-0.1416848749,
-0.6074255705,
0.2995988429,
0.4658354819,
-0.4270306826,
-0.4714734256,
0.0937237665,
-0.8373141289,
0.8428558707,
0.2836797535,
-0.2482091784,
0.2629841864,
-0.2845635414,
-0.4300069809,
0.3849388361,
-0.3435865343,
-0.3829086125,
0.5355914831,
-0.1077304259,
0.7732805014,
0.0389011167,
0.6567268968,
-0.0395723172,
-0.2675198019,
0.1668585986,
-0.1638981849,
0.3367338479,
-0.1110894904,
-0.4685932696,
0.3650457561,
-0.9924367666,
-0.054167293,
-0.3678885102,
-0.7215965986,
-0.1138860062,
0.0687079132,
0.0970566049,
0.3263397515,
0.194133386,
-0.3571711481,
0.0567480214,
-0.3314157426,
0.5804479122,
0.8586117029,
-0.4750059247,
0.750541389,
-0.4298556149,
0.3291376531,
0.3694135547,
0.1963995099,
-0.1182637587,
-0.5654987097,
-0.8323959708,
-0.4236517251,
0.1212109029,
0.3745874465,
-0.7007607818,
0.8452408314,
-0.2298714221,
-0.4766036272,
-0.4271511436,
0.4129210413,
0.4209659398,
0.2099125683,
0.3458929956,
-0.517793715,
-0.4321400225,
-1.0457482338,
0.2157275677,
-0.0061361906,
0.041633416,
0.1978814006,
0.3284224868,
-0.1283273995,
0.5966525078,
-0.2519433498,
0.0122502809,
-0.6836416125,
-0.0856064036,
0.4747303426,
0.824676156,
0.3175754845,
-0.6933274865,
-0.1440392733,
0.1731777638,
-0.1986261606,
0.1321045011,
0.0408748426,
-0.1008921489,
0.1720401496,
0.2284856886,
-0.9444303513,
0.028169224,
0.4713925421,
0.019703744,
0.613052249,
-0.1937304288,
-0.3195043802,
-1.2635025978,
-0.0036278632,
-0.4122093916,
-0.1100564972,
-0.729051888,
-0.1728705913,
0.1755727232,
-0.0848965123,
-0.4041568339,
0.2291415632,
-0.386051774,
-0.0070231124,
-0.2051304579,
0.0041070641,
-0.034884546,
0.6228080392,
-0.0301460158,
0.5567430258,
0.5420417786,
-0.5009891987,
0.2898673713,
0.1570595354,
-0.4848320186,
0.0787571371,
-0.6032139659,
-0.044899784,
-0.3703844547,
0.1585302651,
-1.0301748514,
-0.2669024765,
-0.246938929,
-0.313901782,
0.5043726563,
-0.2377725095,
-0.2712913454,
-0.2509873211,
-0.1078081727,
0.6129238009,
0.5788423419,
-0.2352340221,
0.9895094633,
0.2546665967,
-0.2194222659,
-0.5550999641,
-0.8057864904,
0.0475320593,
0.0840116292,
-0.7580732703,
0.1554237306,
-0.2170694172,
0.0337164551,
-0.0144619336,
-0.2664878666,
-0.292583704,
0.0281201154,
0.1338015199,
0.2062959075,
-0.804420948,
0.3518995345,
0.1913795769,
-0.2561230063,
-0.0401679724,
-0.8903742433,
0.6484285593,
0.2012268454,
-0.1550154239,
-0.5094822049,
0.2787984312,
0.69108814,
-0.2046595663,
0.8646489978,
0.4850236475,
-0.1952610761,
-0.4910691977,
-1.0483494997,
0.0463126265,
-0.4857801795,
0.7311847806,
-0.2026578635,
-1.1654723883,
0.320122689,
0.0339766219,
-0.178665489,
0.5011939406,
0.5790212154,
0.4182270467,
0.6741711497,
0.596808672,
-0.2615065873,
0.469224304,
-0.193230316,
0.1701454669,
-0.6168987155,
-0.4699722528,
-0.1207687631,
-0.4704498053,
-0.1789827198,
-0.6414786577,
-0.0182805471,
-0.1690145433,
-0.0860760882,
0.4597685933,
-0.332028091,
0.5110404491,
0.3147753179,
0.2775561213,
0.104880996,
-0.1121605113,
-0.0409649238,
0.3895219862,
-1.038703084,
-0.3946452439,
0.9026801586,
0.1270533353,
0.4994417727,
0.2346482575,
0.5176585913,
-0.0693750232,
0.1639259458,
-0.9914072752,
0.6055489779,
-0.4127066731,
-0.4194983542,
-0.1653650999,
-0.4914983809,
-0.4419274032,
0.3317864537,
-0.2824573219,
-0.5592785478,
0.2445030212,
0.1048431247,
-0.5748738647,
0.5270555615,
-0.7311043143,
0.6988346577,
-0.0150885852,
-0.0994507894,
-0.3767941594,
-0.3994885981,
0.5543113351,
-0.2829894423,
0.0390180685,
-0.0243499596,
-0.2362644672,
0.5566816926,
-0.4000530839,
1.0011034012,
-0.0125262756,
0.0405589975,
0.0146771995,
-0.0851214379,
0.1926276237,
0.0927658975,
-0.3257983625,
-0.226639092,
-0.4722522497,
-0.6713243127,
-0.7639619708,
0.6665440798,
-1.0063189268,
-0.7386599779,
0.327074945,
-0.5540885329,
-0.0022105905,
0.3108073473,
-0.0018755079,
0.9214302897,
-0.0924582109,
0.2862894237,
1.0338830948,
-0.1889334023,
0.4452168047,
0.3458387554,
0.0756532624,
-0.7255593538,
0.7848916054,
0.3391978443,
0.5754051805,
0.6539241672,
0.1304916292,
0.2947265208,
-0.8557947874,
-0.3876567185,
0.0118064582,
-0.4767897129,
-0.4249713421,
-0.9301906824,
-0.4508258402,
-0.3772107661,
0.0316715986,
-0.3674513698,
-0.9378991127,
-0.1327444166,
-0.3024878502,
0.2275620252,
1.0123083591,
0.1247694641,
0.6175469756,
-0.6044400334,
-0.039517127,
0.7486643791,
0.3561308682,
0.4108915627,
-0.4659432173,
-0.51751858,
-0.47069484,
0.0358625315,
-0.3622477055,
0.0839496627,
0.2960034013,
0.8629476428,
0.5774269104,
-0.5820863843,
0.4927092791,
-0.742331624,
0.599524796,
0.1235407367,
-0.8153147697,
0.1658193469,
-0.4369193017,
0.4578755498,
0.4540295005,
0.1731248051,
-0.1473249346,
-0.3053883612,
-0.4536469579,
-0.8029075265,
0.8208634853,
0.0123185795,
0.3958792984,
0.0234303102,
0.6018996835,
0.6058955193,
0.3817228377,
-0.6710729003,
-0.0882806256,
-0.1937250793,
-0.3124592006,
-0.2401652038,
-0.3357339501,
0.129949227,
-0.4893392622,
0.5225646496,
-0.0901697725,
0.2060201764,
-0.1011526287,
-0.4726907313,
0.0792664438,
0.3100522161,
0.6379767656,
0.6707857847,
0.1485140175,
0.4555417597,
0.3644255102,
-0.5566283464,
0.1091105193,
-0.0704374686,
-0.0727245957,
-0.1312234402,
0.3652476072,
0.8678149581,
0.6556762457,
-0.4194947183,
0.5380200148,
0.0325615555,
-0.3563660383,
-0.2427244484,
0.4915705323,
0.3253508508,
0.3372424841,
0.4400751889,
0.7356059551,
-0.0133834872,
-0.4100524783,
0.3584658504,
0.1414717585,
-0.2867601216,
-0.7236903906,
0.3581020832,
0.0771721378,
-0.4191093445,
0.1426149756,
0.01919844,
-0.6471921802,
0.6062946916,
0.7230458856,
0.7475661039,
-0.4288010299,
0.3107772171,
0.109502703,
0.2434327453,
-0.343478173,
0.1196208522,
-0.2603114247,
-0.6233121157,
-0.7194257379,
-0.5661602616,
0.0731442571,
0.1102624014,
-0.4043839276,
0.072261773,
-0.7107214928,
0.12121775,
-0.2184628397,
-0.2536922097,
-0.4351683557,
0.192578733,
0.2202505618,
1.0436884165,
-0.6941028237,
0.8628065586,
0.8580590487,
-0.1669612378,
-0.8298160434,
-0.2843938768,
-0.0933996886,
-0.765022099,
0.6235163808,
0.4731035233,
0.0697487891,
0.0692453235,
-0.2754131556,
-0.8951612711,
1.2520298958,
0.2501191497,
-0.4328463376,
-0.0282107033,
0.0047662607,
0.2744037807,
-0.6604534984,
0.4411632121,
0.4203658402,
0.2795165479,
0.0127343833,
-0.7212284207,
0.1664439291,
-0.5220490694,
0.0208228119,
0.2341291606,
-0.8279986978,
1.1285511255,
0.2399628907,
0.2939114869,
0.2627308369,
0.6477438807,
-0.0587920398,
-0.1616750509,
0.5549978018,
0.6047298312,
0.6158155799,
0.1622812599,
0.5216651559,
-0.068321906,
-0.0529847331,
0.7646405101,
0.1821440905,
1.011126399,
0.2179224342,
-0.000374427,
0.7708080411,
0.0865684748,
0.1499095857,
0.3189051747,
0.3030822873,
-0.5032929778,
-0.563233614,
0.3931199014,
-0.0953127369,
0.3877616823,
0.1403303444,
-0.1426585317,
-0.038347844,
0.0423991121,
0.0486574695,
-0.0317177586,
-0.5058193803,
0.9684962034,
0.1107607111,
-0.6359502673,
0.2055352032,
-0.1067909822,
0.8422989249,
-0.6941063404,
0.3870241046,
-0.2181176394,
0.3391884863,
-0.5130494833,
-0.1790849864,
0.1988106966,
-0.5418579578,
-0.4118775129,
-0.0786119029,
0.7946741581,
-0.5809679031,
-0.5491987467,
0.1759864688,
0.6507247686,
-0.092121549,
-0.0835034698,
-0.3847266138,
-0.2751998305,
-0.238674134,
-0.316824019,
0.5012833476,
0.7451000214,
0.1725248247,
0.3894727826,
0.4443199337,
0.2668923438,
0.2535170913,
0.1155547649,
1.3106410503,
-0.5024453402,
-0.2638174891,
-0.7481789589,
0.7647172213,
-0.1940632612,
-0.2471658587,
0.4229779541,
0.5876583457,
0.5086885691,
-0.329233408,
0.5885635018,
0.072853975,
-0.0195130892,
-0.541511178,
0.9863268137,
-0.4260811508,
0.1269947141,
0.0374329872,
-0.9581490755,
-0.4172159135,
0.3861012161,
-0.3826218545,
0.0606526397,
0.5782086849,
0.8069266677,
-0.4989880025,
-0.1373462081,
0.6612986922,
0.4197718203,
0.033495184,
0.4613628089,
0.7703602314,
-0.2082485706,
0.388656795,
0.0006719655,
-0.3633377254,
0.0001217206,
-0.4830859005,
-1.2600325346,
-0.4402157068,
-0.1137436554,
0.2440437675,
-0.0412902981,
1.0408644676,
1.0056185722,
-0.8700823784,
-0.3696635664,
0.0038394532,
0.1364684254,
0.0321795233,
-0.1562480927,
0.0857328996,
-0.7496874928,
-0.3613013327,
0.541719377,
0.6530066133,
-0.1655452102,
-0.4134490192,
0.0832950026,
-0.0919234529,
0.1107646748,
0.7833991647,
-0.2176905721,
-0.5923457742,
-0.1280113757,
-0.1233850271,
0.11994192,
0.1029254496,
0.9727037549,
-0.9053690434,
0.1907888949,
0.5711971521,
0.8508509398,
0.1540673226,
-0.2212732136,
0.8433889151,
-0.5649425387,
0.3494410813,
0.001597011,
0.5738021731,
0.2617626786,
-0.4273826778,
-0.1214646026,
0.2053123415,
-0.5982376933,
-0.2667627931,
0.1325716078,
-0.9185797572,
-0.278049022,
0.85863024,
-0.1062240601,
-0.6101686358,
-0.3171637058,
-0.2929943502,
-0.0328822248,
-0.3836411536,
0.7751340866,
0.4740059972,
0.147630617,
-0.2278841585,
-0.4695212543,
0.3387594521,
0.5323448777,
-0.6474682689,
-0.2939248085,
0.247900784,
0.5394262075,
0.1246097833,
0.5567213297,
0.0012829333,
0.2747638524,
-0.2326869071,
0.0292554684,
-0.3390594125,
-0.2998245656,
-0.3933607042,
0.2236463428,
-0.0499454252,
0.2018843442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04637v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04637v2 | Transformers as Statisticians: Provable In-Context Learning with In-Context Algorithm Selection | 2023-06-07T17:59:31 | 2023-07-06T16:55:36 | Yu Bai, Fan Chen, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong, Song Mei | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.ST, stat.ML, stat.TH | Neural sequence models based on the transformer architecture have
demonstrated remarkable \emph{in-context learning} (ICL) abilities, where they
can perform new tasks when prompted with training and test examples, without
any parameter update to the model. This work first provides a comprehensive
statistical theory for transformers to perform ICL. Concretely, we show that
transformers can implement a broad class of standard machine learning
algorithms in context, such as least squares, ridge regression, Lasso, learning
generalized linear models, and gradient descent on two-layer neural networks,
with near-optimal predictive power on various in-context data distributions.
Using an efficient implementation of in-context gradient descent as the
underlying mechanism, our transformer constructions admit mild size bounds, and
can be learned with polynomially many pretraining sequences.
Building on these ``base'' ICL algorithms, intriguingly, we show that
transformers can implement more complex ICL procedures involving
\emph{in-context algorithm selection}, akin to what a statistician can do in
real life -- A \emph{single} transformer can adaptively select different base
ICL algorithms -- or even perform qualitatively different tasks -- on different
input sequences, without any explicit prompting of the right algorithm or task.
We both establish this in theory by explicit constructions, and also observe
this phenomenon experimentally. In theory, we construct two general mechanisms
for algorithm selection with concrete examples: pre-ICL testing, and post-ICL
validation. As an example, we use the post-ICL validation mechanism to
construct a transformer that can perform nearly Bayes-optimal ICL on a
challenging task -- noisy linear models with mixed noise levels.
Experimentally, we demonstrate the strong in-context algorithm selection
capabilities of standard transformer architectures. | [
-0.522634089,
-0.341896385,
0.4739105105,
0.1105031297,
-0.0771970078,
0.0980845317,
-0.2784715295,
-0.3249692619,
-0.1719627231,
0.2247763574,
-0.6182621717,
-0.019809369,
-0.4498855174,
0.0100194346,
-0.6815023422,
1.2803133726,
0.0576727688,
0.3911487162,
-0.0826019123,
-0.0176671837,
-0.5362184048,
-0.3996120989,
-0.5201012492,
-0.3700622022,
0.3357660472,
0.4671870768,
0.4576708674,
0.1806602031,
0.7561177611,
0.2642971873,
0.1368171424,
-0.135079667,
-0.3957219124,
0.1691970974,
0.0563735813,
-0.9185085893,
0.0158964563,
-0.1109187976,
0.6204086542,
0.6571877599,
0.0700576305,
0.2634807229,
0.2718394399,
0.5613048673,
-0.6640902162,
0.1689118594,
-0.7085266113,
0.3257286847,
-0.0132867359,
-0.3380033374,
-0.8823872805,
-0.4348795116,
0.2679977119,
-0.2154988945,
0.4174622893,
0.0006185605,
0.3950482607,
0.5808494091,
-0.4505716562,
-0.3506386876,
-1.1193853617,
0.9903924465,
-0.265544802,
0.6104782224,
0.1787937582,
0.7075458169,
0.0477280393,
-0.8720417023,
-0.2038150132,
-0.3925060928,
-0.383993566,
0.2002153099,
-0.1069219559,
0.0186233707,
0.5256477594,
0.1452160478,
-0.2561352551,
0.1718600988,
-0.2958860993,
0.0644010231,
0.3437750936,
0.1007439271,
0.010187502,
0.2074569762,
-0.148771137,
-0.2444742769,
-0.839859426,
0.3146679699,
0.1701665819,
0.1119284704,
-0.2225235701,
0.2050709277,
0.1256446838,
0.3431687057,
0.3199537098,
0.0012461356,
0.0719554946,
0.0729338005,
-0.0924974903,
0.2347087562,
0.4596507549,
-0.3029889762,
0.2783807516,
-0.4340138435,
-0.4747632444,
0.0720241666,
0.5532065034,
-0.7316576242,
-0.227160424,
0.1956188828,
-0.6489421129,
-0.3672867119,
0.2240948677,
-0.7693701386,
-0.0475559719,
-0.5540013909,
0.5315493941,
-0.3252083659,
0.0801078528,
-0.3332240283,
-0.1997633278,
0.1966840327,
-0.0146272546,
-0.8908693194,
0.5880854726,
0.6394351125,
0.6559396386,
-0.1848941743,
-0.3360075653,
-0.45037058,
-0.1894052029,
-0.5087083578,
0.5816342235,
-0.3539877534,
-0.0895234421,
0.0593686439,
-0.2635799348,
-0.1370396018,
-0.5464999676,
0.5151565075,
-0.8636761904,
-0.0361645371,
0.0077303802,
-0.4783190191,
-0.0189471226,
-0.2023621351,
-0.619058013,
0.7989476919,
0.1791617721,
-0.6088035107,
0.713010788,
-0.8973545432,
-0.6367538571,
-0.1381622255,
-0.0555890799,
-0.5764950514,
0.3699049354,
-0.1712316722,
0.5613445044,
-0.499114573,
0.3215377033,
-0.1021573097,
-0.7271933556,
0.5148213506,
-0.7921675444,
0.9680076241,
0.3603659868,
-0.743622303,
0.1089345291,
-0.6940953732,
-0.2418381572,
-0.0852529258,
-0.1245919093,
0.0297415275,
0.509781599,
-0.0065931557,
0.0135745928,
-0.2111034244,
-0.4234259129,
-0.0487011001,
-0.3441516161,
0.4452906549,
0.698569715,
-0.2902339697,
0.7388218045,
-0.2899810672,
0.4213852584,
-0.1858278662,
0.401874572,
0.0452403128,
-0.2533257902,
-0.6583792567,
-0.3094968498,
0.3590165079,
0.7415888906,
-0.6425728798,
0.4615989625,
-0.2959675789,
-0.5197282434,
-0.0850797594,
-0.1857707351,
0.1557709277,
0.667561233,
0.5502997041,
-0.0557224602,
-0.6025448442,
-0.7500495315,
-0.1311527789,
-0.0458176099,
-0.3209141195,
0.1508674026,
0.3791977465,
0.0446826443,
1.1428478956,
-0.4798313379,
-0.0816878155,
-0.3335402012,
-0.0233568046,
0.3991647959,
0.342728883,
0.6182919145,
-1.1617722511,
-0.4477587044,
-0.0368073545,
-0.9277813435,
0.0752469599,
-0.0221842956,
0.1813431233,
-0.0773591474,
0.5738248825,
-0.6058379412,
0.6344931722,
0.1284850091,
0.0300104097,
0.6582981348,
-0.4039420187,
-0.1616882086,
-0.7844291329,
-0.2317053527,
0.3081062436,
-0.0085208286,
-0.9742588401,
0.0574710295,
0.2558235228,
0.1697193235,
-0.3541348279,
0.398960799,
-0.0993596092,
-0.1954438388,
-0.2053818703,
-0.7042171955,
-0.6578846574,
0.5418204069,
-0.041803658,
0.7194555998,
0.8125602603,
-0.9109362364,
-0.1233432293,
0.0999480411,
-0.5257706046,
0.4672267139,
-0.5065988898,
-0.2164531946,
-0.4758076966,
0.4165945649,
-0.9789070487,
-0.2746101618,
0.1981292963,
-0.064617902,
0.349219799,
-0.1278894097,
-0.3198592663,
-0.3877064586,
0.1408440471,
0.5553899407,
1.0831071138,
-0.8398145437,
0.6664361358,
0.2970551848,
0.3548199236,
-0.6631745696,
-0.6275984645,
-0.10433162,
-0.6083388925,
-0.0581948459,
0.4545840025,
-0.2756386399,
-0.3668235838,
-0.2603953183,
0.1254166812,
-0.2566188276,
0.2916693091,
0.1196869686,
0.4195519984,
-0.185387522,
0.1958048046,
0.0249393024,
-0.2909793854,
0.1793245822,
-0.4017656446,
0.4327305853,
-0.0432797372,
-0.4806018174,
-0.2811358273,
0.0343895555,
0.3211025894,
-0.1242053881,
0.4018360376,
0.6615635753,
-0.1643951833,
-0.5279838443,
-0.3861055374,
-0.6509353518,
-0.4657964408,
0.4049343467,
-0.4182118475,
-0.7551872134,
0.3574073315,
-0.1333925873,
0.1698024273,
0.4114949405,
0.5578085184,
-0.2975082099,
1.2357060909,
0.5019387007,
-0.1079326943,
0.7179498076,
-0.3732960224,
0.5792564154,
-0.5311624408,
0.2267566919,
-0.4887421429,
-0.7007604241,
-0.8443788886,
0.0309290495,
0.7789058685,
-0.1353934854,
-0.585565865,
0.3668694198,
-0.5983662009,
0.5881146789,
0.6990191936,
0.3266402781,
-0.1829567552,
0.0230546463,
0.1504792571,
0.1158128977,
-0.7769983411,
-0.1970897913,
1.1285225153,
0.1597149819,
0.6944112182,
-0.0787769184,
0.4958368242,
0.3917370439,
0.785048902,
-0.7615221739,
0.4935055375,
-0.3390617967,
-0.2888650298,
-0.1899735332,
-0.4395927191,
-0.8290981054,
0.1085273623,
-0.1877451837,
-0.7858113647,
0.3685136735,
0.306687057,
-0.2312248498,
0.3908953667,
-0.6178086996,
0.5930551291,
-0.1281244159,
-0.0399120227,
-0.3260238469,
-0.8456931114,
0.2463790476,
-0.1971798986,
0.0167956147,
0.3128319681,
0.1077262685,
0.3974682093,
-0.2225311995,
0.8808293939,
-0.3667218983,
0.3545106649,
0.3015193343,
0.1145054176,
0.4281435311,
0.0538141094,
-0.1698181182,
0.1753775179,
-0.0908220261,
-0.1552381516,
-0.7885344625,
0.2815056145,
-0.7726157904,
-0.3723778725,
-0.2019763589,
-0.6090179682,
-0.2539179027,
-0.0411231592,
0.5864982605,
0.7190971971,
-0.1508724093,
0.408390075,
0.7221144438,
0.203805849,
0.7067509294,
0.047914926,
0.3688372374,
-0.0730387196,
0.9512839317,
0.238653779,
0.0671157315,
0.7620425224,
0.3765234649,
-0.2973364294,
-0.6078881621,
-0.2732897699,
-0.269956857,
-0.8288353682,
-0.1943064928,
-0.5185410976,
-0.4331896603,
0.1905855238,
-0.3243323565,
-0.0094294753,
-0.1332410127,
-0.1577454358,
-0.0918624774,
-0.0221421104,
0.7671901584,
0.0174587071,
0.5148223042,
-0.3677377701,
0.2420054972,
0.3425976336,
0.168441698,
0.2944075763,
-0.4359995425,
-0.2995687723,
0.0829134881,
-0.3472498953,
-0.6710335016,
0.1911752522,
0.105166018,
0.6142051816,
0.3385466635,
-0.0542843826,
0.4443691969,
-0.7738919854,
0.5234698057,
0.0059713339,
-0.8432794809,
0.2417390496,
0.0115545848,
-0.072568208,
0.4404528439,
0.5568378568,
-0.1910085827,
-0.2042779028,
-0.5086941719,
-0.3788346052,
0.7015426159,
0.1643873602,
0.199834466,
0.0040832069,
0.5269339681,
0.1820269823,
0.2163548768,
-0.514765501,
-0.3405595422,
-0.311460048,
-0.5949739218,
-0.1988579035,
0.0014383772,
-0.0972537398,
-0.3704883754,
0.4630591273,
-0.552084744,
0.4607442319,
0.188421607,
-0.3284460306,
0.0139722908,
0.2367102653,
0.4549378753,
0.8916915655,
-0.2003980726,
0.0993151814,
0.4386105537,
-0.2875466347,
0.4482662082,
0.1153406799,
-0.5725465417,
-0.2428385466,
0.2915486395,
0.889251709,
0.571156919,
-0.5928617716,
0.5002059937,
-0.2457002848,
-0.2041763067,
-0.6255781054,
0.2554281652,
-0.4248063564,
0.3640725911,
0.7150118947,
0.7694478631,
0.327398479,
-0.4120279849,
0.436537981,
0.6532751918,
-0.8375071287,
-0.6190670133,
0.8313671947,
-0.3810672462,
-0.5544516444,
0.5702163577,
-0.1631495804,
-0.3647182882,
0.8290608525,
0.7412995696,
1.0701944828,
-0.0883657336,
0.2244449705,
0.2185791284,
0.0310297608,
-0.3582606018,
-0.0236497633,
-0.1583609432,
-0.8754579425,
-0.3796866536,
-0.495523572,
-0.3587545455,
-0.2297899425,
-0.5670055747,
0.2708562315,
-0.3736717105,
0.0377910696,
-0.0468754247,
-0.3630118668,
-1.1347930431,
0.2406285554,
-0.0667447448,
0.8032138348,
-0.644382894,
0.6775435805,
0.4058108628,
-0.0757074952,
-0.6719807982,
0.2149289995,
-0.0827412754,
-0.6291280985,
0.8977646828,
0.2251068056,
0.1967225522,
0.0298075043,
-0.542237401,
-0.7250931263,
1.0439510345,
0.4827204645,
-0.2316755652,
0.0176687706,
0.107790567,
0.6155318618,
-0.5435042381,
0.8875703216,
0.6256588697,
0.3250072896,
0.0605509654,
-0.6278662086,
-0.0730664879,
0.1160942987,
-0.1762852967,
0.3705654144,
-0.5498247743,
0.9886942506,
-0.0774698034,
0.0258895736,
0.0420219228,
0.7855817676,
0.1277151108,
0.2550506294,
0.8826856613,
0.1196818203,
0.546864748,
-0.0842261463,
1.3129763603,
-0.5535778403,
0.2350741327,
0.7745453715,
-0.1817536503,
0.6681796908,
0.353240937,
-0.3277200758,
0.514046073,
0.4734143317,
-0.0035330663,
0.6387766004,
0.0285407752,
-0.2663906515,
-0.0801760331,
0.0817532763,
0.1934399009,
0.6613238454,
0.1577478945,
-0.4084415436,
-0.1263234913,
0.0814860538,
-0.453260839,
-0.2821487784,
-0.2779273093,
0.7629439831,
0.0589287207,
-0.7996647954,
0.1745145768,
-0.3305893242,
0.7158681154,
-0.8444728851,
-0.1915738583,
0.1141953692,
0.2624259889,
-0.1003240123,
-0.6139990091,
0.3852793276,
-0.3027742505,
-0.2499272227,
-0.2416361272,
0.8435091376,
-0.0311430711,
-0.6251491904,
0.0946556851,
0.3500552177,
-0.0107238032,
-0.0493107177,
-0.3289200366,
-0.3739689887,
-0.1650880426,
-0.1978598535,
0.4857483804,
-0.0020166775,
-0.3178293407,
0.6565901041,
0.5881710052,
0.0932838246,
-0.0331694782,
0.1300901473,
0.5421929955,
-0.4118663669,
-0.6371667981,
-1.0017899275,
0.463377893,
0.0378702879,
-0.2504808009,
0.491173178,
0.4148230851,
1.0252767801,
-0.2051436156,
0.7851915956,
-0.1848388016,
0.2187690884,
-0.4537324905,
0.4373463094,
-0.3915944397,
-0.0212868061,
-0.0914190263,
-0.9733933806,
-0.4711043537,
0.5731606483,
-0.4795161188,
-0.0000323546,
0.5996893644,
0.7969299555,
-0.4426417351,
0.3535193801,
0.2198707312,
-0.0533486381,
0.3909724355,
0.3032149076,
0.7864779234,
-0.3898597956,
0.3732900321,
-0.4471823573,
-0.3824466765,
-0.1021793932,
-0.6129184365,
-0.8100989461,
-0.8127149343,
0.1305197924,
-0.09674301,
-0.2200178355,
1.1195802689,
0.9693153501,
-0.9164235592,
-0.5437687635,
-0.2475877851,
0.2640039027,
-0.749017179,
-0.2661296427,
0.3319886923,
-0.6125788093,
-0.7214903831,
0.5199995637,
0.1919858754,
-0.2460779399,
-0.2188492268,
-0.1921832711,
0.3516387939,
-0.0882516727,
0.7574667931,
0.1917495728,
-0.4794585705,
-0.3811891079,
-0.0616907068,
0.2280602902,
0.3390981853,
1.1696161032,
-0.8942691088,
0.1253927648,
0.648236692,
0.8049468398,
0.3243615627,
-0.265824765,
0.4220468104,
-0.5669804215,
0.2129044682,
0.3466828167,
0.5229982734,
-0.0847499743,
-0.4094472229,
0.5298454762,
0.0986984521,
-0.8408230543,
-0.8063670397,
0.364760071,
-0.5190867186,
-0.2852821946,
0.6054449677,
0.3858502805,
-0.2499887943,
-0.0859303176,
-0.0577976964,
0.1939942986,
-0.1250921339,
0.9049229026,
0.3573939502,
-0.4618445337,
-0.104386434,
-0.6917945147,
0.834671855,
0.473580122,
-0.5856060386,
-0.3271894455,
-0.0371731296,
0.1410907805,
0.076231882,
0.4087495804,
0.2726517022,
0.318764776,
-0.2535593808,
-0.2274478376,
0.3360738754,
-0.6076772809,
-0.2677398026,
0.3463849127,
-0.1757742912,
0.0898253024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04634v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04634v4 | On the Reliability of Watermarks for Large Language Models | 2023-06-07T17:58:48 | 2024-05-01T21:20:36 | John Kirchenbauer, Jonas Geiping, Yuxin Wen, Manli Shu, Khalid Saifullah, Kezhi Kong, Kasun Fernando, Aniruddha Saha, Micah Goldblum, Tom Goldstein | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | As LLMs become commonplace, machine-generated text has the potential to flood
the internet with spam, social media bots, and valueless content. Watermarking
is a simple and effective strategy for mitigating such harms by enabling the
detection and documentation of LLM-generated text. Yet a crucial question
remains: How reliable is watermarking in realistic settings in the wild? There,
watermarked text may be modified to suit a user's needs, or entirely rewritten
to avoid detection. We study the robustness of watermarked text after it is
re-written by humans, paraphrased by a non-watermarked LLM, or mixed into a
longer hand-written document. We find that watermarks remain detectable even
after human and machine paraphrasing. While these attacks dilute the strength
of the watermark, paraphrases are statistically likely to leak n-grams or even
longer fragments of the original text, resulting in high-confidence detections
when enough tokens are observed. For example, after strong human paraphrasing
the watermark is detectable after observing 800 tokens on average, when setting
a 1e-5 false positive rate. We also consider a range of new detection schemes
that are sensitive to short spans of watermarked text embedded inside a large
document, and we compare the robustness of watermarking to other kinds of
detectors. | [
-0.0651994497,
-0.9596230388,
0.7868044972,
0.2377875596,
-0.5599485636,
0.1536592841,
-0.072266832,
-0.5170538425,
0.0666264296,
0.7601985931,
-0.0650696456,
-0.4689490795,
-0.8966838121,
0.232243225,
-0.9427114725,
0.8685461879,
-0.0952021182,
-0.3546411395,
-0.4000264108,
-0.3508192003,
0.0338038057,
-0.78283149,
-0.5488931537,
-0.2321976721,
0.6058151126,
0.0044901306,
0.8283516765,
1.017255187,
0.5048467517,
0.2318770885,
-0.4314306676,
0.1782060564,
-0.5066584945,
0.6116390228,
-0.1455655247,
-0.4965904355,
-0.0575920083,
0.0462510064,
0.6832766533,
0.3358551264,
0.1927955598,
-0.1334750205,
0.4324183762,
0.6393296719,
-0.6867369413,
0.1414563209,
-1.0160729885,
-0.1721894741,
-0.5536668301,
-0.2465365529,
-0.4483274817,
-0.1407525539,
-0.0171042196,
-0.5586233735,
0.1650493294,
0.3116576076,
0.9569752216,
0.1900670081,
-0.09771543,
-0.3339786232,
-0.7161163092,
0.8888300061,
-0.7032113075,
0.1202575415,
0.7642586827,
0.1598112881,
-0.3112416267,
-0.9286571741,
-0.6021189094,
-0.3057984114,
0.2293187529,
-0.0669555441,
-0.3425593674,
-0.2178663462,
0.4161040187,
0.3269926906,
-0.3123231828,
-0.215800494,
0.1884742528,
-0.4784005582,
0.5107257962,
0.1082455963,
0.4116286635,
0.1007977575,
-0.4964598715,
-0.0636757091,
-0.88444978,
-0.3769659698,
0.5433709025,
0.1157704219,
0.207503587,
0.5505200624,
0.0139778582,
0.4867788255,
-0.3207101226,
-0.383241266,
-0.3401207924,
-0.3248928189,
-0.0187822338,
-0.2841107249,
0.8761255145,
0.4046887755,
0.7553597689,
-0.3427595496,
-0.4508500695,
-0.0834629461,
0.1795137078,
-0.6031888127,
-0.1852165014,
-0.08536686,
-0.3015751541,
-0.3271263838,
0.0557802208,
-0.5668442845,
-0.8203035593,
-0.1117734537,
0.6919269562,
-0.4691884816,
-0.0135740051,
0.1795024276,
-0.3251313269,
-0.0483017974,
0.198816821,
-0.6175097227,
0.2703009248,
0.7579135895,
0.9090148211,
-0.3357529342,
-0.4105673432,
-0.4801253378,
0.3751372993,
-0.268955946,
0.9469991326,
-0.4223687053,
-0.3174413443,
0.0646022782,
0.0472519137,
0.0549047478,
-0.7644752264,
0.6421157122,
-0.5748257041,
-0.0100662354,
-0.2571510971,
-0.9449445009,
0.1728836447,
0.3140295446,
-0.9453246593,
0.7624863982,
-0.1425603032,
-1.1036421061,
0.2474560589,
-0.1119449511,
-0.5464701056,
-0.0829175264,
0.2304177433,
-0.7769843936,
-0.0631858036,
0.0150033599,
0.4901487529,
-0.2642740309,
0.2554475963,
-0.5943043232,
-0.6059256792,
0.7114801407,
-0.9065240622,
0.4582968652,
-0.1474912316,
-0.4513518512,
-0.2994596362,
-0.6688894033,
-0.0574516132,
0.2372518629,
-0.561573863,
-0.349940598,
0.1138397828,
0.2087102085,
0.0028859384,
0.4408836365,
-0.4368392825,
-0.2396023124,
0.0571740791,
0.741728425,
0.7613115311,
0.3271308541,
0.1189645231,
-0.5863678455,
0.5730007887,
-0.1761179715,
0.1138923913,
-0.3620173931,
-0.7102529407,
-0.5427143574,
-0.3168261945,
0.4501849413,
0.3649561405,
-0.8218116164,
0.353656739,
-0.3561762571,
-0.4838751256,
-0.1158948988,
0.5032386184,
0.574626565,
0.3668196797,
0.5581304431,
0.0443250909,
-0.2341527194,
-0.982760489,
-0.8591174483,
-0.2470057011,
-0.0325529911,
0.1153776124,
0.6242318153,
-0.1992655993,
0.933319509,
-0.3574105799,
-0.0569263101,
-0.413670212,
0.1779695451,
-0.2253964394,
0.2652238011,
0.3927991688,
-0.6908871531,
-0.6618022323,
-0.379774034,
-0.6245313287,
-0.4102727175,
-0.1147835702,
0.0159479026,
0.278281033,
0.481847018,
-0.6978027225,
0.5701098442,
0.6474198699,
-0.1953232735,
0.5079968572,
-0.3486737013,
-0.0360433273,
-1.0358157158,
0.2505944371,
0.0368416235,
-0.3123240471,
-0.3199034929,
-0.1716231853,
0.1120961383,
0.0506350324,
-0.290422827,
0.7340099216,
-0.3668741286,
0.1575718522,
-0.7515530586,
0.0606894903,
0.2905395329,
0.0404078215,
-0.2677742243,
0.7120454311,
0.4363750219,
-0.3404353559,
0.1047809049,
-0.1210143864,
-0.4043070972,
0.7057912946,
-0.8570029736,
0.2683414519,
-0.0100548854,
0.46831882,
-0.9918470979,
-0.0187128745,
0.0698501542,
-0.2092954516,
0.170140788,
-0.2433737069,
-0.9370759726,
0.1293526888,
-0.4556884766,
0.0312752724,
0.3849931955,
-0.3824141026,
0.4941092432,
0.2291333526,
-0.0244657602,
-0.3450823426,
-0.7417032123,
0.6619747281,
-0.3017106354,
-0.5946942568,
0.3865087628,
-0.0271091815,
-0.3157014251,
-0.0475218892,
-0.2541581094,
-0.3864097595,
0.3818125129,
0.5018473268,
-0.025576612,
0.1149126962,
-0.2240594029,
-0.0630649477,
-0.2177505046,
-0.0556075834,
-0.1110514179,
0.4198647738,
0.1379912347,
-0.5422825813,
-0.5655350089,
0.4132567048,
0.9085724354,
-0.0198305212,
0.8387056589,
0.4594471753,
-0.6679523587,
-0.1638866663,
-0.5641124845,
-0.1784739196,
-0.4372492731,
-0.0788377374,
-0.0247102343,
-0.8255269527,
0.5330996513,
0.1841153353,
0.1647044718,
0.4452648461,
0.0596220642,
-0.3924650848,
0.6091538668,
0.6085247397,
-0.2643078566,
0.4543478191,
0.1112856865,
0.1496036202,
-0.5581975579,
0.0338522233,
-0.5523376465,
-0.2871241868,
-0.3206338286,
-0.3740776181,
0.0168798622,
0.3188094497,
0.0888387114,
0.5182584524,
-0.088540405,
0.7168831229,
0.5283361077,
0.1431992501,
0.4461624026,
0.2228430361,
0.0888454467,
-0.2453871667,
-0.29264763,
-1.0172735453,
1.1050946712,
0.224179253,
0.7199733853,
-0.1907839477,
0.7654602528,
0.5594617724,
0.4898257554,
-0.3117133379,
0.5762809515,
-0.0425122082,
-0.7090480328,
-0.3058730662,
-0.2408727258,
-1.0452814102,
0.0394897461,
-0.2628194094,
-0.4903268814,
-0.2751808167,
0.1519768685,
-0.1180818379,
0.5094850063,
-0.3652031124,
0.6646535397,
-0.2487099469,
-0.5672197938,
-0.0007679471,
-0.6180061698,
-0.1185825244,
-0.5317587852,
0.2295112163,
-0.2473013103,
-0.3556292355,
0.971056819,
-0.3205193877,
0.8364821672,
-0.0852589533,
-0.2882404029,
0.3947481513,
0.2656494677,
0.6648441553,
0.0008451762,
-0.1479535997,
0.2283084691,
-0.1107094735,
-0.548874259,
-0.4802365899,
0.5100519657,
-0.3221692741,
-0.6073163748,
-0.3059906065,
-0.3887729347,
-0.1189231873,
0.2072184235,
0.3192274272,
0.3499212861,
0.0758581161,
0.5118519664,
0.7536972761,
-0.1926805377,
0.5247468948,
0.3024809062,
0.1583651006,
-0.5986723304,
0.9350517392,
0.2237132937,
0.3633722365,
0.5008540154,
0.3827526271,
-0.2968914807,
-0.8354731798,
-0.3605763018,
0.2658224106,
-0.9102833271,
-0.1673716158,
-0.6461410522,
-0.2821352482,
0.080562003,
-0.2583679259,
-0.3291531205,
-0.2273607105,
-0.3527056873,
0.0526417904,
0.4082283676,
0.6685795784,
0.1618107557,
0.126446262,
-0.8154498339,
0.3559537232,
0.3686482012,
0.0291542672,
-0.2475865483,
-0.8712812066,
-0.1050265655,
0.133372739,
-0.2077533156,
-0.5398642421,
0.1466590911,
0.2268854827,
0.477448225,
0.4143336415,
0.1677087694,
0.4529802799,
-0.5191645026,
0.8383692503,
-0.0695617944,
-1.0297900438,
0.2305170745,
-0.4060159624,
0.1588450819,
0.5680559874,
0.2701820433,
-0.4598276317,
-0.8521306515,
-0.6711745858,
-0.9906061292,
0.0422367044,
0.2917146385,
0.5294007063,
-0.1430796534,
0.5168406963,
0.202748701,
0.1617437601,
-0.8757038116,
-0.0763257816,
-0.0997049809,
-0.2378056794,
-0.0471059345,
-0.5673094988,
-0.1523153782,
0.0489754267,
0.4155732095,
-0.1400798857,
-0.041317828,
-0.0039226306,
-0.2606345713,
0.1385471821,
0.1813146323,
0.7055972815,
0.6914370656,
0.0636032894,
0.6443824768,
0.0565628968,
-0.5170206428,
0.1696219742,
-0.1129283458,
-0.1810141802,
0.2393123955,
0.9523849487,
0.4838015735,
0.3280769587,
-0.8104909658,
0.6063672304,
0.0687780976,
-0.3012909293,
-0.1107250005,
-0.0310064256,
0.4217465818,
0.0558138937,
0.3995757699,
-0.2158809453,
-0.2856532037,
-0.4750719368,
0.3015429676,
0.4736481309,
-0.1191758737,
-0.3849060833,
0.8211606741,
-0.0507245846,
-0.2564240396,
0.3025378287,
0.1945298463,
-0.7297112346,
0.4289377928,
0.5393225551,
0.9447078705,
0.1073872,
-0.1417216808,
-0.058627177,
0.4761303067,
-0.5109149814,
0.1167543381,
0.0082803089,
-0.6362268329,
-0.1557566822,
-0.7991605401,
-0.6896829605,
0.2216169387,
-0.389225781,
-0.0458220169,
-0.6261370182,
-0.3007423282,
0.0459309705,
-0.2833314836,
-0.1272689998,
0.1634411067,
0.2234839797,
0.774361372,
-0.9534652233,
0.8332198262,
0.5015948415,
0.0158782564,
-0.3260695338,
0.4775773287,
-0.2160446644,
-0.8314607739,
0.3431144357,
0.3701089621,
-0.301453203,
-0.1534089744,
-0.8381245136,
-0.8847543597,
1.1112186909,
0.7444573045,
-0.4162320495,
0.3738081455,
0.3703049421,
0.7889185548,
0.1906674653,
-0.2581302226,
0.3495841324,
0.5251141191,
-0.1811810881,
-0.7256343365,
0.3114671111,
-0.0080189677,
0.0911566988,
0.015431135,
-0.4940733016,
0.7717816234,
0.2108591646,
-0.2722567916,
0.3083476424,
0.3231220245,
0.323877275,
0.2396104783,
0.5330148339,
0.6514620781,
0.6175308228,
-0.162727952,
1.1368118525,
-0.517611146,
0.2316524386,
0.7861533761,
-0.5053579211,
0.9854632616,
0.6277867556,
-0.0989973843,
0.2359866351,
0.3235727847,
-0.0526448116,
0.4032625258,
0.3424039483,
-0.4904204011,
-0.4809666872,
-0.1327636093,
-0.0951250121,
0.0833828896,
0.1157613322,
-0.622441113,
-0.0526426472,
-0.1954754293,
0.3317051828,
0.2538839877,
0.0184617098,
0.5925148129,
0.4642003775,
-0.4809032381,
0.6411185265,
0.1395021379,
0.7494899631,
-0.4190406799,
0.1482195109,
-0.3713785708,
0.2758329511,
-0.1114665642,
-0.9305542707,
0.353701055,
0.1432605535,
-0.1881131679,
-0.5315532684,
0.8880265951,
-0.3710603118,
-0.2325817645,
0.3460875452,
0.5102412105,
0.2461923063,
-0.413428694,
-0.64927876,
0.266854763,
-0.1627849489,
-0.4302335978,
0.522551775,
0.4312498271,
-0.1258546114,
1.0776978731,
0.7987701297,
-0.0310119428,
0.1555713564,
-0.0243589934,
0.5600784421,
-0.6247296929,
-0.2164876759,
-1.4189542532,
0.14012748,
-0.2438162565,
-0.1276751161,
1.008241415,
0.4556033611,
0.44982481,
0.0631203726,
0.9132041931,
0.3302462101,
0.1288830489,
-0.4415882528,
0.9475401044,
-0.4163346887,
0.176766783,
-0.3620903194,
-1.0894076824,
-0.6002303958,
0.3624707758,
-0.0176558848,
-0.1091409028,
0.7617518306,
0.6216018796,
0.1296678483,
-0.0791916922,
0.5177511573,
-0.310488075,
0.4318549633,
0.2869030535,
0.9748075604,
-0.3134549856,
0.9912023544,
-0.256116271,
0.1459052116,
-0.1672807634,
-1.1308733225,
-0.8745259047,
-0.3908902705,
-0.6014534235,
-0.4630860686,
0.1091017798,
0.2749556601,
0.3919948637,
-0.6890809536,
0.1189725995,
-0.1275558174,
0.1856504381,
-0.0619594194,
-0.1749580353,
0.3009371161,
0.0730440691,
-0.6480318308,
0.2084635645,
0.603436172,
0.5468749404,
-0.29106161,
0.1001458392,
0.1416496336,
0.3908294439,
0.3254290223,
0.3026720881,
-0.5347156525,
-0.4129204452,
-0.1507846415,
-0.5138491392,
-0.1801037788,
0.5804012418,
-0.2452072501,
0.1506289691,
0.4153758585,
0.8440060019,
0.2501505613,
0.0794444978,
0.3523393273,
-0.579832077,
-0.1653521508,
0.2289044708,
0.6019960642,
0.803317368,
0.0671886876,
0.2906932831,
0.7401342988,
-0.4827329814,
-0.9574297667,
-0.1046551988,
-0.7238017917,
-0.162994206,
1.5153040886,
-0.7005292177,
-0.2767049968,
-0.4743210077,
-0.1166919917,
-0.0183805097,
-0.0759594068,
0.8604437113,
1.087785244,
0.3516179323,
0.1446598172,
-0.3925229013,
0.3145075142,
0.331687659,
-0.7192929983,
0.3952718973,
0.1591841131,
0.7762118578,
0.1767641455,
0.454380542,
-0.0712928027,
0.0236796718,
0.0215404946,
-0.214680329,
-0.0005245602,
-0.1463166475,
-0.1206881851,
0.2571926415,
0.2377865165,
-0.1640330851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04618v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04618v2 | Revisiting Out-of-distribution Robustness in NLP: Benchmark, Analysis, and LLMs Evaluations | 2023-06-07T17:47:03 | 2023-10-26T06:59:50 | Lifan Yuan, Yangyi Chen, Ganqu Cui, Hongcheng Gao, Fangyuan Zou, Xingyi Cheng, Heng Ji, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | This paper reexamines the research on out-of-distribution (OOD) robustness in
the field of NLP. We find that the distribution shift settings in previous
studies commonly lack adequate challenges, hindering the accurate evaluation of
OOD robustness. To address these issues, we propose a benchmark construction
protocol that ensures clear differentiation and challenging distribution
shifts. Then we introduce BOSS, a Benchmark suite for Out-of-distribution
robustneSS evaluation covering 5 tasks and 20 datasets. Based on BOSS, we
conduct a series of experiments on pre-trained language models for analysis and
evaluation of OOD robustness. First, for vanilla fine-tuning, we examine the
relationship between in-distribution (ID) and OOD performance. We identify
three typical types that unveil the inner learning mechanism, which could
potentially facilitate the forecasting of OOD robustness, correlating with the
advancements on ID datasets. Then, we evaluate 5 classic methods on BOSS and
find that, despite exhibiting some effectiveness in specific cases, they do not
offer significant improvement compared to vanilla fine-tuning. Further, we
evaluate 5 LLMs with various adaptation paradigms and find that when sufficient
ID data is available, fine-tuning domain-specific models outperform LLMs on ID
examples significantly. However, in the case of OOD instances, prioritizing
LLMs with in-context learning yields better results. We identify that both
fine-tuned small models and LLMs face challenges in effectively addressing
downstream tasks. The code is public at
\url{https://github.com/lifan-yuan/OOD_NLP}. | [
-0.3894836307,
-0.5545041561,
0.2302395552,
0.01998966,
-0.2948237956,
-0.1238677204,
-0.542799592,
-0.5676224828,
-0.1960938722,
0.3483867645,
-0.4629677534,
-0.411753267,
-0.6670540571,
0.2098507136,
-0.3916163146,
0.9093202949,
0.1212036014,
-0.1200889125,
-0.1736382693,
-0.4294070899,
-0.4016737938,
-0.3320703208,
-0.4831700623,
-0.2965157926,
0.0089531988,
0.2196003795,
0.8212192059,
0.821849823,
0.9101259112,
0.1660238951,
-0.3623171151,
0.0968119279,
-0.7208852172,
0.2637239397,
-0.4046743512,
-0.5635982752,
-0.5894173384,
-0.5102303028,
0.793605268,
0.8208835721,
-0.4200929701,
0.2623014152,
0.3196316361,
0.6650631428,
-0.9029772878,
0.1347845942,
-1.0860353708,
-0.0714864954,
-0.517541945,
-0.0843366534,
-0.4092190564,
-0.2741530538,
-0.0034625034,
-0.3182799518,
0.121105507,
0.2629552484,
0.6718920469,
0.579916656,
-0.1341532767,
-0.4846900105,
-0.5847494006,
0.8875855207,
-0.8890337348,
0.3969145715,
0.3826731741,
0.5826891065,
-0.3675360382,
-0.6928346157,
-0.3469654918,
-0.1565858573,
0.3935343027,
0.1123365834,
-0.1629331559,
-0.221026659,
0.2046673,
0.6555247307,
-0.1367505938,
0.5164270997,
0.0180544145,
0.4529117048,
0.5929456353,
0.1834161878,
-0.0364568271,
0.0993397683,
-0.4848664999,
-0.3533757925,
-0.7932279706,
0.0487488247,
0.6525356174,
0.4623098671,
-0.049832724,
0.595955193,
0.0443692803,
0.5707855821,
-0.0000940294,
-0.3681933284,
0.2191960067,
-0.3177135885,
-0.233236596,
-0.2868761122,
0.6286182404,
0.3790285289,
0.0655116588,
-0.2168225199,
-0.4950097203,
0.005092199,
0.5138785243,
-0.5720780492,
-0.1765786707,
0.2653619647,
-0.78886199,
-0.4089240432,
-0.1910920739,
-1.0713412762,
-0.5950644016,
0.1027190909,
0.1686619669,
-0.3534246981,
-0.4414716959,
0.2646284401,
-0.0396508016,
-0.093101792,
-0.0042491634,
-1.0476897955,
0.5108080506,
0.7855570912,
0.8181190491,
-0.6725844741,
-0.3036394417,
-0.4064228535,
-0.0588754639,
-0.3712980747,
0.6606687307,
-0.1365777105,
-0.1612646133,
0.196102336,
-0.2127331793,
-0.229857862,
-1.1400191784,
0.6799716949,
-0.2846203446,
-0.3966144919,
-0.0860869884,
-0.5218873024,
0.2207310349,
0.2319182903,
-0.4733659923,
1.3216043711,
0.2798472643,
-0.966947794,
0.5829655528,
-0.7182825804,
-0.0410213619,
-0.0940232947,
-0.0802096426,
-0.4655648768,
0.2485329956,
0.0724186972,
0.3928616345,
-0.3379528821,
0.1160388514,
-0.7280417085,
-0.2089316398,
0.2177541703,
-0.2756335735,
1.0891923904,
0.1922994256,
-0.3146276176,
-0.0885443166,
-1.1208142042,
0.0449396782,
0.1480110735,
-0.1698966473,
-0.2732463479,
0.2973979712,
-0.2646040022,
0.0267811604,
-0.2007244676,
-0.2594258189,
0.0653521046,
-0.6450421214,
0.5831452608,
0.6192421913,
-0.1215625852,
0.6120799184,
-0.3650033176,
0.7022742033,
-0.2074859291,
0.3254140913,
0.1126904711,
-0.4172559977,
-0.3288884461,
-0.3642328382,
0.0901419744,
0.511754334,
-0.74745363,
0.7401424646,
-0.2729280889,
-0.4691691101,
-0.3231566846,
0.3079601526,
0.2912024558,
0.5932865143,
0.317301929,
-0.6457057595,
-0.2758013606,
-0.3219707012,
-0.2354793102,
-0.3279073834,
0.0167450123,
-0.0776595771,
0.5928438306,
-0.4104380012,
1.0128866434,
-0.3057424724,
-0.4455146194,
-0.5130497813,
-0.167181462,
0.2794018686,
0.3077068329,
0.7669263482,
-0.4128096104,
-0.2264275402,
-0.0598562174,
-0.6557281017,
-0.1710963845,
0.2783834934,
-0.2050769925,
0.1687674224,
0.696093142,
-0.3701561391,
0.4817508161,
0.6520562768,
0.0528715178,
0.6784433722,
-0.2788169384,
-0.7060658336,
-0.9737448692,
0.0037564554,
-0.2350685894,
-0.0677898526,
-0.4723469913,
0.3831067383,
0.0705784261,
0.0411881506,
-0.4293302,
0.3354629874,
-0.4201941192,
-0.3460297585,
-0.2149948925,
0.2606733143,
-0.2192014754,
0.1521670073,
-0.2414514124,
0.4614701867,
0.6133016944,
-0.6857333779,
0.3807425499,
0.2615922987,
-0.7506530285,
0.8528423905,
-0.5908364058,
0.0478697196,
-0.1825022399,
0.1301556975,
-0.9863960743,
0.0993081182,
0.2983833849,
-0.0945326462,
0.3370731771,
-0.1863517314,
-0.7042281628,
-0.0954992995,
-0.4502772689,
0.30983302,
0.6077631712,
-0.7047042251,
0.1506446898,
0.3321319818,
0.1291661263,
-0.5080775023,
-0.7735859752,
-0.2485557497,
-0.6001185775,
-0.5335313678,
0.3228696883,
-0.2334522158,
-0.6840232611,
-0.0771624073,
-0.2065688521,
-0.089922376,
0.2760614753,
0.0850009248,
-0.2829497755,
-0.098807998,
0.0696678832,
-0.1640744656,
0.0305385068,
0.181119144,
-0.1781970412,
0.2392507046,
0.0225926377,
-0.3560709357,
0.0774802864,
0.1052392423,
0.1216246635,
0.0043740612,
0.6445224285,
0.5688869953,
-0.2800959051,
-0.7986803055,
0.0324270278,
-0.1888710409,
-0.4757798314,
0.386236459,
-0.2074600011,
-0.1280504465,
0.5234051347,
-0.2908555865,
0.2645379305,
0.256893158,
0.5245588422,
-0.0938121006,
0.6061159968,
1.0063012838,
0.2142516375,
0.5912773013,
-0.3691738546,
0.2202406526,
-0.8019356728,
0.1465817839,
-0.6798041463,
-0.0827588513,
-0.542817831,
-0.2238187343,
0.2247638851,
0.5015823841,
0.1146523729,
0.3542369604,
-0.2413869351,
0.1674797237,
0.3389561772,
-0.2211165726,
0.2991586328,
-0.0862166062,
-0.1184504554,
0.0415866114,
-0.7872468829,
-0.4937720001,
1.1002597809,
0.5271266699,
0.8553079367,
0.3250468671,
0.5869022012,
0.1431357563,
0.2370131016,
-0.5323085189,
0.4373883605,
-0.1484706849,
-0.4818062782,
-0.3525479734,
-0.298089087,
-1.0532439947,
0.3869647384,
-0.2607714236,
-0.9471080303,
0.4642637968,
0.1761905104,
-0.2902927995,
0.3589896262,
-0.7162224054,
0.8304778337,
-0.0290681832,
0.0099684531,
0.293391794,
-0.8199596405,
0.2739897668,
-0.1546959132,
0.3716586232,
-0.2599778175,
-0.1181567386,
0.3195928037,
-0.5703518391,
0.8391004801,
0.1991911083,
-0.4358437061,
0.0082436977,
-0.1619100571,
0.6384189129,
0.2783304155,
-0.3573467433,
0.3188322186,
0.1001153737,
-0.1988074332,
-0.6327682137,
0.4790206552,
-0.5757012367,
-0.111038439,
-0.2452950776,
-0.5150322318,
-0.3967595696,
0.208883062,
0.8376815915,
0.6205145717,
-0.0003066854,
0.3350487649,
0.6731696129,
-0.1579659283,
0.7470012903,
0.1227852032,
-0.2648247182,
-0.5175406337,
0.5583127737,
0.2780825198,
0.6804513335,
0.4406630397,
0.3377139866,
-0.5852245688,
-0.9895922542,
-0.5293169618,
-0.0416988172,
-1.0324870348,
-0.1637531519,
-0.3220900297,
0.0733402371,
-0.3648428023,
-0.0943573192,
-0.5886023045,
-0.0332899839,
-0.2307270616,
0.0308375079,
0.1815198511,
0.731308341,
0.0678068772,
0.2463365495,
-0.1473272741,
0.402980864,
-0.0403281935,
0.5408887267,
-0.0257587545,
-0.6914414763,
-0.2387466282,
-0.0729874671,
-0.4136190712,
-0.7715392113,
0.3148216605,
0.4951323569,
0.6203837991,
0.6099085808,
0.6375400424,
0.6302686334,
-0.3162095249,
0.6197209954,
-0.0035253582,
-0.7985343933,
0.2800011635,
-0.2463383526,
0.1925388575,
0.7006517649,
0.2071788758,
0.1104486808,
-0.6006806493,
-0.5697973967,
-1.1811342239,
0.6289550066,
0.2849341035,
-0.0373847708,
-0.0767149404,
0.2756680846,
0.6067749262,
0.4401744604,
-0.7135443091,
-0.5463967919,
-0.0731126964,
-0.0107915932,
-0.3728136122,
-0.31887272,
-0.1492024809,
-0.0746202618,
0.3554210663,
-0.2569726408,
0.1293630302,
-0.1223771125,
-0.1285960227,
-0.0279626269,
0.155739367,
0.4045915306,
1.1406066418,
-0.5938170552,
0.2693285048,
0.2222757339,
-0.6123526096,
-0.1175468937,
-0.0021933857,
-0.2158966213,
0.1540118307,
0.4295268953,
0.7076717615,
0.1653548032,
-0.7124288678,
0.5579080582,
-0.0313368104,
0.0704234466,
-0.335421294,
-0.0250347462,
-0.22017169,
0.2203078419,
0.2271251976,
0.3243212104,
0.1236617267,
-0.741165936,
-0.1705886722,
0.4322030246,
-0.2229654342,
-0.3897583485,
0.68754673,
-0.1080706418,
-0.310628593,
0.2685033679,
-0.4280673563,
0.1841595322,
0.4160656035,
0.6813114285,
0.8666229248,
0.194152087,
-0.0269394238,
-0.1174451262,
0.5401586294,
-0.4541050792,
0.3253729343,
0.0338793583,
-0.7247322202,
-0.2166036218,
-0.3914563954,
-0.6029687524,
0.0101171127,
-1.0105361938,
0.3750066757,
-0.4285399616,
-0.3336179256,
-0.1180467233,
-0.0635333359,
-0.5076603293,
0.0889563859,
-0.399045676,
0.9779381156,
-0.5733697414,
0.8996912241,
0.7652820349,
-0.0356451757,
-0.3019130826,
0.2903554738,
-0.1652002931,
-0.5658548474,
0.2278790325,
-0.0143852765,
-0.0483942814,
-0.1281033456,
-0.3516487181,
-0.8780709505,
1.0455570221,
0.9086045027,
-0.4035522044,
0.3517250121,
0.081871897,
0.7634509206,
-0.1983811408,
0.3004119694,
0.5008567572,
-0.0175394695,
-0.2467214167,
-0.9677082896,
-0.121802099,
-0.0187651571,
0.4281360507,
0.2233460844,
-0.4779670238,
0.8533880711,
-0.1807551086,
-0.3419212699,
0.1325891316,
0.518748343,
0.2344810665,
0.4393949807,
0.5893350244,
0.582007885,
0.7785861492,
0.0022041332,
1.2164486647,
-0.0550662242,
0.3787079751,
1.0810947418,
-0.4238699079,
1.2152656317,
0.5381166339,
-0.2914904952,
0.2475237399,
0.3742932081,
0.2641298175,
0.7930782437,
0.3704901636,
0.1324014962,
0.2488811016,
0.0091249123,
-0.7592790127,
0.2598480582,
0.0433625318,
-0.1597634256,
-0.3269713223,
-0.1015173048,
-0.1671026498,
0.257576704,
-0.3161769211,
0.6599905491,
0.2068867683,
-0.3827908635,
0.8608296514,
-0.0512449332,
0.8717470169,
-0.5609456301,
0.2709047198,
-0.3564409316,
0.6764110327,
-0.1734773964,
-0.5972637534,
0.6188424826,
-0.2318191528,
-0.1405144036,
-0.4493919313,
0.5987263918,
-0.1628267467,
-0.1489091963,
0.5090120435,
0.3632872403,
0.1583940834,
0.0287910365,
-0.536216855,
0.3434710205,
-0.460223496,
-0.110487707,
0.6842706203,
0.7579738498,
-0.0688489005,
0.807274878,
0.4304476976,
0.2536458075,
0.3527867794,
0.0458942577,
0.5629358292,
-0.3821564913,
-0.5693208575,
-0.8503144383,
0.1693269908,
0.0739074275,
-0.8361409307,
1.0171688795,
0.1018979624,
1.19348979,
-0.2232028097,
0.4692063332,
-0.0115141701,
0.5658054948,
-0.5429362655,
0.4702755511,
-0.5861538053,
0.4328186512,
-0.5440876484,
-1.0427877903,
-0.267010957,
0.3016608953,
-0.0952256098,
-0.0193662867,
0.7904930115,
0.6264360547,
-0.0446964651,
-0.1582564414,
0.4201885164,
-0.015884744,
0.0784214139,
0.2099868208,
0.9752572775,
-0.3934588134,
0.6928370595,
-0.5471999645,
-0.0830861405,
-0.380687803,
-1.3893573284,
-0.9389502406,
-0.4140121341,
-0.412799865,
-0.2439272553,
0.1640840322,
0.7634205818,
0.7879120708,
-0.6926826239,
-0.3927354515,
-0.3950532675,
0.2434508502,
-1.0016931295,
-0.1867180914,
0.1786870956,
-0.4683993757,
-0.5823343992,
0.5163977742,
0.2905939519,
-0.1549004167,
-0.2638740242,
0.050603427,
0.3214843571,
-0.1080664024,
0.5650463104,
0.2419406027,
-0.4437489212,
0.0195996184,
-0.2469932288,
0.0756108984,
0.0982792228,
0.6017823219,
-0.1934593916,
0.4471563995,
0.4988746047,
0.6386137009,
-0.0191777106,
0.0579939373,
0.453754276,
-0.987488389,
0.2529189289,
0.2089778781,
0.4076679349,
0.2839207351,
-0.1273631603,
0.6697728038,
0.0744106621,
-0.6209104657,
-1.5258668661,
0.35383147,
-0.8515962958,
-0.0804787502,
1.3376402855,
-0.2803015411,
-0.1302050501,
-0.4277989268,
-0.022628922,
-0.2135772109,
-0.2331942618,
0.8602389097,
0.5899240375,
-0.0414726436,
-0.1129007116,
-0.7447134256,
0.6760874987,
0.3047262728,
-0.8065778613,
0.0963014066,
-0.0857842937,
0.1465816945,
-0.0006961484,
0.579914391,
-0.1282248348,
-0.0420597382,
0.0946601108,
-0.0828061327,
0.0278698243,
-0.285733819,
-0.6000086069,
0.2818491459,
0.4769531488,
-0.3556295037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04610v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04610v1 | The Two Word Test: A Semantic Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2023-06-07T17:22:03 | 2023-06-07T17:22:03 | Nicholas Riccardi, Rutvik H. Desai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities recently,
including passing advanced professional exams and demanding benchmark tests.
This performance has led many to suggest that they are close to achieving
humanlike or 'true' understanding of language, and even Artificial General
Intelligence (AGI). Here, we provide a new open-source benchmark that can
assess semantic abilities of LLMs using two-word phrases using a task that can
be performed relatively easily by humans without advanced training. Combining
multiple words into a single concept is a fundamental aspect of human language
and intelligence. The test requires meaningfulness judgments of 1768 noun-noun
combinations that have been rated as meaningful (e.g., baby boy) or not
meaningful (e.g., goat sky). by 150 human raters. We provide versions of the
task that probe meaningfulness ratings on a 0-4 scale as well as binary
judgments. We conducted a series of experiments using the TWT on GPT-4,
GPT-3.5, and Bard, with both versions. Results demonstrated that, compared to
humans, all models perform poorly at rating meaningfulness of these phrases.
GPT-3.5 and Bard are also unable to make binary discriminations between
sensible and nonsense phrases as making sense. GPT-4 makes a substantial
improvement in binary discrimination of combinatorial phrases but is still
significantly worse than human performance. The TWT can be used to understand
the limitations and weaknesses of current LLMs, and potentially improve them.
The test also reminds us that caution is warranted in attributing 'true
understanding' or AGI to LLMs. TWT is available at:
https://github.com/NickRiccardi/two-word-test | [
-0.3125763237,
-1.0082274675,
0.4727873504,
0.0894837976,
-0.42588678,
0.1292676777,
-0.3601685464,
-0.6529894471,
-0.0785187334,
0.3433399498,
-0.2114743292,
-0.3878439069,
-0.7173852324,
0.0530303679,
-0.4403163195,
0.7251711488,
-0.1523975283,
0.223037973,
-0.1138297692,
-0.400781244,
-0.6740169525,
-0.2267238647,
-0.495028168,
-0.4445187151,
0.6398842335,
0.0635196567,
0.7843617797,
0.4245651364,
0.6414626837,
0.1953425258,
-0.0984536037,
0.0595574006,
-0.5028520823,
0.0493003875,
-0.4816791117,
-0.3257547319,
-0.5157520175,
0.5879938006,
0.5926234126,
0.8576077819,
0.1698986441,
0.3061219156,
-0.1188918725,
0.4477982521,
-0.4894607365,
0.1446699053,
-0.8899766803,
-0.1095840707,
-0.3292458951,
0.1334730238,
-0.0292941313,
-0.426156193,
0.0202761348,
-0.3593539894,
0.1724812239,
0.2814043462,
0.9970812201,
0.3609958887,
-0.6017168164,
-0.2367322743,
-0.3355089426,
0.8887729645,
-0.6030615568,
0.618968606,
0.3132756054,
0.277030766,
-0.2607196569,
-0.7537215948,
-1.013582468,
-0.6859605312,
0.1086192355,
0.2241682708,
-0.0490021966,
0.0256007314,
0.2036007643,
0.2227385789,
-0.6800206304,
0.137015,
-0.2953465879,
-0.0719801858,
0.4650831819,
0.0339099988,
0.4067062736,
-0.1087945849,
-0.4578215778,
-0.2666686475,
-0.597135663,
-0.132655248,
0.2796901464,
0.2352955788,
0.2294850051,
0.8685370088,
-0.0539486744,
0.6157571673,
-0.5823126435,
-0.1512455344,
0.3320488632,
-0.4773752391,
0.0634525344,
-0.2300622314,
0.6608749628,
0.7049640417,
0.3896827698,
-0.5702200532,
-0.2881110013,
0.735794425,
0.2248646915,
-0.7153635621,
0.0094030369,
0.0827623308,
-0.2866808474,
-0.1052408516,
0.0574097782,
-0.5284609795,
-0.1794899702,
-0.299457252,
0.6285617948,
-0.4172565043,
-0.4120537639,
0.081359677,
-0.5225400329,
0.528226316,
-0.036129497,
-0.6025942564,
0.4234423339,
1.1545051336,
0.7245494723,
-0.3933846951,
-0.6643954515,
-0.5396975279,
-0.0706880093,
-0.6701331139,
0.883523345,
-0.4224347472,
-0.3236750066,
-0.3024151325,
-0.3155018091,
-0.0595494844,
-0.5484153032,
0.5447542667,
-0.5921189785,
0.1692397296,
-0.3558494747,
-0.9399294853,
-0.1635338217,
0.5083646774,
-0.3710546196,
1.1578543186,
0.353952229,
-0.5453876853,
0.5603721142,
-0.6076514721,
-0.3336266577,
0.2333762497,
-0.3547022939,
-0.0316324383,
0.2280834913,
-0.4758362174,
0.2547743618,
-0.5939141512,
0.1940354854,
-0.6402768493,
-0.4887572527,
0.3821350336,
-0.2445882708,
0.4080215693,
-0.0770737007,
-0.4006423652,
-0.1035318673,
-0.6558213234,
0.5498659015,
0.1757109314,
-0.3730996251,
-0.2206636667,
0.0265082028,
0.0616568811,
0.3402813673,
0.1315599084,
-0.7119731307,
0.1163136885,
-0.6303880811,
0.4752533734,
0.5532390475,
-0.2905229926,
0.0476268604,
-0.2804935277,
0.2333365232,
-0.3349365294,
-0.1408699751,
0.4901717901,
-0.6385648251,
-0.6896016002,
-0.0961435586,
0.4483607411,
0.7289417982,
-0.4872798622,
0.6275152564,
-0.4914757609,
-0.529210031,
-0.6037514806,
0.3725686073,
0.6583184004,
0.3348560929,
0.3712783456,
-0.5059735775,
-0.1523233503,
-0.8308696151,
-0.6917642355,
-0.3201136589,
-0.3878621757,
0.2265058905,
0.8273058534,
-0.199855268,
0.9673051834,
-0.3628931344,
-0.3064685464,
-0.1338458955,
0.3187050819,
-0.0133587942,
-0.0423510782,
0.2918561995,
-0.6733822823,
-0.0674309582,
-0.1211891174,
-0.5969661474,
-0.0877311453,
0.4406096339,
0.0092944428,
0.0247287191,
0.3097624481,
-0.5730665326,
0.3473578095,
0.5961430669,
-0.7297167778,
0.4387971163,
-0.3445878327,
-0.1015848145,
-0.8248334527,
0.1350965202,
-0.2733146846,
-0.0128605915,
-0.4769367576,
0.2858585119,
0.2466986328,
0.1706138104,
-0.3730348051,
0.9307652712,
-0.2106218189,
-0.3072539568,
-0.4191353023,
0.588226378,
0.0296394899,
0.2691963911,
-0.3826709092,
0.872574985,
0.1882267594,
-0.5461685658,
0.5558056235,
0.1977947056,
-0.5108198524,
0.5937889814,
-0.9167158604,
0.4205030203,
-0.1290803254,
0.0506722629,
-1.1040729284,
-0.1654679328,
-0.021838773,
-0.4751360416,
0.0153600629,
0.5086856484,
-0.826559484,
-0.4406104684,
-0.3849980831,
0.3778391182,
0.5768432021,
-0.4967650473,
0.6132752895,
0.378808558,
0.0648207888,
-0.1425417364,
-0.8439658284,
0.3575477898,
-0.1015933901,
-0.7480019331,
0.36482355,
-0.0977541432,
-0.4207178056,
0.1580415815,
-0.0662271455,
-0.0856329873,
0.2424574196,
0.0346807167,
0.2833276391,
-0.0567290597,
0.3652833402,
-0.3570598066,
-0.1746610403,
0.070448868,
-0.2636833191,
0.4170389175,
-0.3809092641,
-0.2932359576,
-0.1742381006,
0.1839449704,
0.5039911866,
-0.3759729564,
0.4423777759,
0.8054482937,
-0.2370248586,
-0.0090365186,
-0.8126502633,
0.0291963555,
-0.3585233092,
0.5274050832,
-0.4767822325,
-0.9108381271,
0.2012657076,
-0.0458015017,
0.1696421504,
0.4959529638,
0.5520605445,
0.1915996969,
0.9369158745,
0.2529566884,
-0.0168707836,
0.0562475659,
-0.0162683539,
0.4529151618,
-0.8239505887,
-0.1696622521,
-0.5661931038,
-0.2489169985,
-0.6247760653,
-0.6090744734,
0.2722221315,
0.223729223,
-0.1508901715,
0.1219278425,
-0.2652335167,
0.5174787045,
0.5361195207,
0.0250457227,
0.2590151429,
-0.3801431954,
-0.2059325278,
0.0424181707,
0.0040792827,
-0.7013983727,
0.9910506606,
0.2332689464,
0.450974524,
0.4911991954,
0.2586685121,
0.1914559305,
0.2668789327,
-1.0629410744,
0.7591477036,
-0.4181410372,
-0.7087923288,
-0.3141713738,
-0.4507127106,
-0.8729993105,
0.4757229388,
-0.1729114354,
-0.7267659307,
-0.4522294104,
-0.0732694119,
-0.1337000877,
0.1598949283,
-0.7831488252,
0.8433637619,
-0.4532766044,
-0.1845501661,
-0.4363308549,
-0.54630512,
0.3668014407,
-0.2772251964,
0.2035318762,
-0.7764832973,
-0.5934525132,
0.8846983314,
-0.1837194264,
0.4887898862,
-0.0233645216,
0.1057735085,
0.046091307,
-0.0415985473,
0.2973330617,
-0.2552028,
-0.2242350876,
0.2404289693,
0.1242304742,
-0.5542714,
-0.5932868123,
0.5567689538,
-0.7288617492,
-0.4561595321,
-0.3504711688,
-0.4127109051,
-0.4060554802,
0.3909415007,
-0.0058570676,
0.3324239254,
-0.4466685951,
0.0733748749,
0.3808052838,
-0.0338614546,
0.0918637589,
0.599347651,
-0.2293382436,
-0.3886136413,
0.8056337237,
0.028421592,
0.3348417282,
0.2420266271,
0.5410633683,
-0.5926420689,
-0.6905297637,
-0.278629005,
0.2604202032,
-0.5718571544,
0.078192398,
-0.5772874355,
0.1051612794,
-0.4782251418,
0.2604795694,
-0.1769062132,
-0.3206947148,
0.0531455204,
0.0007948398,
0.1565636545,
1.0012481213,
0.1300829351,
-0.0841180161,
-0.6254474521,
0.600504458,
0.6499561071,
0.4152427912,
-0.1923800707,
-0.5528949499,
0.338419944,
-0.1348385513,
-0.1972981989,
-0.6538110375,
-0.0656635612,
0.4228593707,
0.5631605983,
0.3747676611,
-0.1180015877,
0.5418053269,
-0.6517426968,
0.9698665142,
0.3206142783,
-1.026063323,
0.3711720109,
-0.1522094011,
0.2325375527,
0.7580596209,
-0.0573420152,
-0.6399288177,
-0.4941219687,
-0.3951761425,
-0.6428896785,
0.4300762713,
0.102348201,
0.2281353921,
-0.2955637872,
0.3870275021,
-0.0164535362,
0.109410584,
-0.3435517251,
-0.0898684189,
0.0412848517,
-0.1466496438,
-0.3130043149,
-0.3763056993,
-0.0141470395,
-0.2126965225,
0.5698987246,
-0.0607729666,
0.1246102005,
-0.0569864288,
0.0300753955,
0.0579665042,
0.4014323354,
0.3437082171,
0.7947558165,
-0.2145360708,
0.2330688983,
0.4632493854,
-0.4249822199,
0.0604024865,
0.1420931369,
0.0166096911,
-0.1504026502,
0.5890446901,
0.5839216709,
0.3472822309,
-0.8256611228,
0.7839972377,
-0.3362855017,
-0.3570931852,
-0.1673248559,
0.1983192265,
0.2766780555,
0.0921399295,
0.0553806946,
-0.2126401514,
0.0003988914,
-0.7961269617,
0.1814577878,
0.5603808165,
-0.2445550263,
-0.2363604456,
0.5990632176,
0.1242244691,
-0.4158919156,
0.6807897687,
-0.7094464898,
-0.6659282446,
0.3299534619,
0.3304606974,
0.6783207655,
-0.0215476304,
-0.1261874586,
0.2389157563,
0.2283824384,
-0.2721995413,
0.5399892926,
0.0512268841,
-0.924032867,
-0.3894009292,
-0.7056413889,
-0.494001478,
0.0106469803,
-0.577991426,
0.1557014287,
-0.255502969,
-0.234879896,
0.2396662086,
0.3785155118,
-0.8421826363,
0.0870523378,
0.0569225065,
1.0340331793,
-0.6231706142,
0.8245758414,
0.7810710073,
-0.2047801912,
-0.8662509918,
0.0313053131,
-0.0018822243,
-0.9971246123,
0.7044332623,
0.4269879758,
-0.1120487154,
-0.1108845398,
-0.2484232634,
-0.6415864229,
1.000793457,
0.2578207254,
-0.3705453277,
-0.0726461932,
0.2389252633,
0.6497511864,
-0.0014867549,
0.4167192578,
1.0259251595,
0.6699563861,
0.1604825556,
-1.0994910002,
0.0488172807,
-0.1188621446,
0.2816536129,
0.2975685,
-0.6244468093,
0.8017802835,
-0.1763924807,
-0.2523270547,
0.3246736825,
0.5458149314,
0.2900170684,
0.3064441085,
0.8557783365,
0.7578499913,
1.0189207792,
-0.2038030922,
1.1315312386,
-0.30302459,
0.4347355366,
1.0074021816,
-0.4651899934,
1.1367655993,
0.4278623462,
-0.4277003407,
0.1837266237,
0.4205010533,
-0.0084254192,
0.4232954681,
0.6137324572,
-0.3136689067,
-0.3346960545,
-0.3808555901,
-0.2547888458,
0.8067117333,
0.2937755883,
0.0373408757,
-0.3909366429,
-0.0237699933,
0.0607969314,
0.0466382317,
-0.1180090308,
0.7183157802,
0.1954507381,
-0.7591605186,
0.4349676073,
0.0278469063,
0.7125380039,
-0.6169602871,
0.0378841385,
-0.0053916164,
0.294776082,
0.1257867366,
-0.8350043893,
0.1994727403,
0.1565367132,
0.1277353913,
0.0133318417,
0.5845713019,
-0.4069181085,
-0.5306734443,
0.736513555,
0.6436548829,
0.5063160658,
-0.1135918573,
-0.6734519005,
0.0527680516,
-0.3608888686,
-0.1937954873,
0.1886238605,
0.3054201007,
0.1185868979,
0.4599531293,
0.5408151746,
0.2933045328,
-0.0500363894,
0.343411237,
0.7090822458,
-0.8850082755,
-0.3562640846,
-0.8536471128,
-0.1974200308,
-0.0529400259,
-0.574695766,
0.6449923515,
0.468500942,
0.8672421575,
0.4514508843,
0.7118756771,
-0.0779847205,
0.7885882258,
-0.467289418,
0.4638488889,
-0.7078709602,
-0.0466660373,
0.0112220226,
-0.8775105476,
-0.3477995694,
0.3772841692,
-0.2880443335,
0.0839749128,
0.9400802255,
0.828410387,
0.1088965461,
0.0932237953,
0.6075145006,
0.2041490227,
0.2742337584,
0.6331869364,
1.0464084148,
-0.3645544946,
0.6343747377,
-0.0456425212,
-0.3222915828,
0.0373531431,
-0.8019687533,
-1.2012642622,
-0.2400608957,
-0.1203840524,
-0.4643245935,
0.1427465826,
0.9511165619,
0.4922685027,
-0.6280409694,
0.0492340066,
-0.039056439,
-0.0677001625,
-0.1504638791,
-0.1573905349,
0.4454489648,
-0.2950856984,
-0.5819752216,
0.4463712275,
0.2018942088,
-0.0671284273,
-0.3207094669,
-0.0816526189,
0.0733621642,
-0.0089409063,
0.7170211673,
-0.1136675477,
-1.0170779228,
-0.6316139698,
-0.1437710971,
-0.186615929,
-0.3154647052,
0.6514160037,
-0.5652952194,
0.3697185814,
0.5281559825,
0.645172596,
0.1275191009,
-0.0384174027,
0.2059261352,
-0.398103863,
-0.1023129523,
0.2797769904,
0.2962822318,
0.2726686299,
0.0536746867,
0.6648536921,
0.3416567147,
-0.520177722,
-0.6077210903,
0.2169578671,
-0.9603834152,
-0.2999304235,
1.311175704,
-0.1106548533,
-0.31225425,
-0.203307569,
0.0692080408,
0.2484896332,
-0.1752119213,
0.7718948126,
0.7570704222,
0.0259771217,
0.4036230147,
-0.7617793679,
0.0659372881,
0.5261620879,
-0.7919414043,
-0.0786758438,
0.1724797338,
0.5264821053,
0.1159854159,
0.5934278965,
-0.005811003,
0.179390654,
0.0397121608,
0.0748994052,
-0.0728798732,
0.0153134456,
-0.3158883452,
0.0230978616,
0.3120597899,
-0.3138758242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04597v1 | Language Models Get a Gender Makeover: Mitigating Gender Bias with Few-Shot Data Interventions | 2023-06-07T16:50:03 | 2023-06-07T16:50:03 | Himanshu Thakur, Atishay Jain, Praneetha Vaddamanu, Paul Pu Liang, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Societal biases present in pre-trained large language models are a critical
issue as these models have been shown to propagate biases in countless
downstream applications, rendering them unfair towards specific groups of
people. Since large-scale retraining of these models from scratch is both time
and compute-expensive, a variety of approaches have been previously proposed
that de-bias a pre-trained model. While the majority of current
state-of-the-art debiasing methods focus on changes to the training regime, in
this paper, we propose data intervention strategies as a powerful yet simple
technique to reduce gender bias in pre-trained models. Specifically, we
empirically show that by fine-tuning a pre-trained model on only 10 de-biased
(intervened) training examples, the tendency to favor any gender is
significantly reduced. Since our proposed method only needs a few training
examples, our few-shot debiasing approach is highly feasible and practical.
Through extensive experimentation, we show that our debiasing technique
performs better than competitive state-of-the-art baselines with minimal loss
in language modeling ability. | [
-0.3189371228,
-0.8571864963,
0.3427989781,
-0.0843451098,
0.1096862406,
-0.0294256881,
-0.1269350201,
0.0048536016,
-0.1541850418,
0.6361423731,
-0.8050726652,
-0.3301009536,
-0.714238584,
0.0377933681,
-0.4499933422,
0.7456002831,
0.218077302,
0.6245259047,
0.1758627295,
0.3610588014,
-0.6059957147,
-0.3725606203,
-0.4104194343,
-0.4796079099,
0.3848523498,
0.5573444366,
0.6012935638,
0.5076596141,
0.4001623094,
0.2420745492,
-0.193561852,
0.0674712434,
-0.9180629253,
-0.2001598626,
0.0000067416,
-0.5439513922,
-0.4745839238,
0.5128754973,
0.5384334922,
1.0297384262,
-0.0296452846,
0.2587763071,
0.3566588163,
0.9179766774,
-0.9362403154,
0.1051247269,
-0.7672572732,
0.0493414514,
-0.2057403475,
0.0786299482,
-0.269873023,
-0.5013592243,
0.0916091278,
-0.3657632172,
0.2339661121,
-0.1159681454,
0.3288064301,
0.2117203772,
-0.427924484,
0.2900446057,
-1.0860182047,
1.2185949087,
-0.7420522571,
0.3809861541,
0.6961086988,
0.1846691817,
-0.3493433893,
0.0017187373,
-0.3185996115,
0.0147891175,
0.0661330819,
-0.2487028241,
-0.5179820657,
-0.0903787091,
0.4943849444,
-0.3320609927,
-0.1272962987,
0.0931814089,
-0.415436089,
0.0309291184,
0.524205327,
-0.0340076089,
0.3353576958,
0.1036628336,
0.232810542,
0.0377847776,
-1.1328122616,
-0.3044312596,
0.826616466,
0.7142817974,
-0.0415184908,
0.4113560319,
-0.3237864077,
0.405867219,
0.2450603098,
-0.1684361547,
0.2909795344,
-0.0854264498,
-0.191453591,
0.252184391,
0.373768121,
0.2045021653,
0.5692594051,
0.0720590577,
-0.065850921,
0.2442981154,
0.2522740662,
-0.7583348751,
0.1082484871,
0.0083482359,
-0.4329382479,
-0.5506458282,
-0.4048828185,
-0.7703585625,
-0.6869097352,
-0.5878357291,
0.273347795,
-0.0445792861,
-0.476844579,
0.2158533186,
-0.1345367432,
0.3330503106,
0.4898623228,
-1.0942640305,
0.1541001946,
0.744903326,
0.493418932,
0.518568933,
-0.0842475146,
-0.3984903395,
0.0619751811,
-0.7001545429,
0.6346048713,
-0.8312129974,
-0.4389798641,
-0.0039071594,
-0.1757597476,
0.1628088951,
-0.4017669857,
0.0157482196,
-0.0287275985,
0.3202627003,
-0.6241292357,
-0.1768891364,
0.1683013439,
0.3815454841,
-0.59383744,
0.7653554082,
-0.1248412356,
-0.9789857864,
0.7256060243,
-0.5962784886,
-0.2119880021,
-0.4751571417,
-0.199570775,
-0.4626119733,
0.1077240184,
0.5282167792,
0.0658096448,
-0.4594645202,
0.335529536,
-0.640055418,
-0.4800179899,
-0.1427244991,
-0.6144313812,
0.6639581919,
-0.0392287932,
-0.4612331986,
0.1290723383,
-0.5145683289,
-0.2282087058,
-0.0121289715,
0.2562661767,
-0.5228678584,
-0.0889393091,
0.0189007912,
0.1249860302,
-0.1508370042,
-0.6260381937,
0.271610707,
-0.6727979183,
0.3411798775,
0.8292537928,
-0.3810231388,
0.9064315557,
-0.2508684695,
0.6064098477,
0.018529648,
0.3749094307,
0.1665500551,
-0.1674635708,
-0.535597086,
-0.4815425575,
0.4348853827,
0.4176071882,
-0.8251379132,
0.1468348652,
-0.3254286647,
-0.4299773276,
-0.7271197438,
0.3924664855,
0.4064416885,
0.4138965905,
0.1615049094,
-0.0270227697,
-0.8162633181,
-1.1872544289,
-0.6617140174,
-0.1535326689,
-0.0501641519,
-0.0533135459,
0.6964210868,
-0.2631817758,
1.1737705469,
-0.4482216537,
-0.4115307927,
-0.5494832397,
0.1861668527,
0.133240819,
0.6886104941,
0.6417495608,
-0.4853454232,
-0.06407924,
-0.4061568975,
-0.4189607203,
-0.3511764705,
0.1039762795,
-0.2321474701,
0.0149919894,
0.5446442962,
-0.261564523,
0.6632582545,
0.3338649273,
-0.069181256,
0.3209421337,
-0.0332050547,
0.1950971335,
-0.6872666478,
0.0293872636,
-0.0843902901,
-0.2932930291,
-0.8221216202,
-0.3830842972,
-0.1863325536,
-0.1948674768,
-0.6203500628,
0.7323088646,
-0.3683437705,
0.1394851506,
-0.4903608561,
-0.0978758633,
-0.2336319983,
0.1920546293,
0.041088786,
0.418319732,
0.3845256269,
-0.3258733451,
-0.2354748547,
0.3953681886,
-0.2554914355,
0.5250005126,
-0.6120682359,
0.4050255716,
-0.9085819125,
0.3385897875,
-0.9429910779,
-0.0867823809,
0.3379605412,
-0.1414596885,
0.1912906766,
-0.4774846435,
-0.2289282382,
-0.2126244605,
-0.5772879124,
0.3158053458,
0.4548782706,
-0.4875885844,
0.4839677513,
0.5054470897,
-0.0692428797,
-0.7766734958,
-0.9557105303,
0.0626377016,
-0.2123072296,
-0.2245695591,
0.0573481955,
0.0240042936,
-0.2844026387,
-0.3191815615,
-0.0229641087,
-0.1203265935,
0.3674586117,
0.0778983906,
0.1374568492,
0.2344446331,
0.2955128849,
0.2850389481,
-0.4571797252,
-0.3484479189,
-0.1196553484,
0.724771142,
0.012923304,
-0.4961384535,
-0.2875331342,
0.3481488824,
0.4064331949,
-0.0300557818,
0.6800034642,
0.359467119,
-0.5926792026,
-0.2178269327,
-0.5717351437,
-0.6005222797,
-0.4537411928,
0.3970045447,
-0.1979898214,
-0.714877367,
0.0551703162,
-0.2148684561,
0.2202897072,
-0.0515722707,
0.431866616,
0.0056375135,
1.3183021545,
0.6887906194,
-0.5576937199,
0.7334322333,
-0.208650887,
0.3003138602,
-0.4212308526,
0.2349442989,
-0.7477263212,
-0.5042119622,
-0.637662828,
-0.2678373456,
0.1486588567,
0.0125155384,
-0.6706838608,
0.0727920234,
-0.2120606303,
0.5611954927,
0.6624507308,
0.3019421399,
0.0492870584,
-0.0254758,
0.3656885922,
-0.3101934493,
-0.7798013091,
-0.6837348342,
1.3266066313,
0.4005770087,
1.1955761909,
-0.0809439719,
0.806838572,
0.3086021245,
0.4920109212,
-0.4555493593,
0.4719935656,
-0.3523076475,
-0.9563549161,
-0.3472474813,
-0.4939619899,
-0.8967649341,
0.1687926054,
-0.4578139782,
-0.5740565062,
0.43459934,
0.5139926076,
-0.065682523,
0.2158509195,
-0.6457019448,
0.7822825909,
0.0432349965,
-0.3617555201,
-0.2687497735,
-0.2273704559,
0.4243240058,
-0.198637858,
0.5070939064,
-0.3304776549,
0.4407866597,
0.570284903,
-0.3705053926,
1.2991980314,
-0.576869905,
-0.2283100635,
-0.1725156456,
0.0036694838,
0.3946046233,
-0.2503808439,
-0.0241155345,
0.318023175,
-0.1204440594,
-0.6203112006,
-0.4470908046,
0.2838216126,
-0.5624265075,
-0.6856982112,
-0.1455857754,
-0.4296614528,
-0.3057599664,
0.1773520708,
-0.072433345,
0.5525826812,
-0.581145227,
0.2378453761,
0.4552923739,
-0.4034127891,
0.3359334171,
0.4450153112,
-0.3088982105,
-0.1527359337,
0.2617173791,
0.0745972246,
0.2991634011,
0.0359576307,
0.4440236092,
-0.1578560919,
-0.1594646722,
-0.2032385021,
0.0146661261,
-0.4372047186,
0.016225867,
-0.4931158721,
0.2169021368,
-0.7556946278,
-0.0322103724,
-0.7559149265,
-0.1661396474,
0.0703885406,
-0.0988609642,
0.1978887469,
0.4225868285,
-0.1084632128,
0.8182237148,
-0.5102065206,
0.4611096382,
0.4185858071,
0.1954240501,
-0.093716003,
-0.5031785369,
0.0377705358,
0.4552449882,
-0.0645937324,
-0.7751164436,
0.5700986981,
0.1458040625,
0.3894269466,
0.237224102,
-0.0418495387,
0.7276775241,
-0.7768347263,
0.4314841926,
0.2181216329,
-1.2837164402,
0.7629337907,
-0.3527900279,
0.5119106174,
0.711553812,
0.067894876,
-0.5982268453,
-0.3340754211,
-0.3854623735,
-0.5915657878,
0.7832798362,
0.1752102822,
0.5579510927,
0.1362029016,
0.2892970741,
0.0926411301,
0.6543055773,
-0.4686865509,
-0.2561802864,
-0.0936835781,
-0.3554402292,
0.1162661463,
-0.3169267476,
-0.1282711774,
-0.3493838906,
0.8136203885,
-0.2488448471,
0.0528015681,
-0.125674516,
-0.3706767559,
-0.0449027754,
0.6973008513,
0.4567771852,
0.5974472165,
-0.2339555472,
0.0265928674,
0.1922672689,
-0.3663743734,
0.4148632586,
-0.0910026804,
-0.6133919358,
-0.1364274025,
0.3658510745,
0.9389799833,
0.4605222642,
-0.2823073268,
0.3818126321,
-0.0355380736,
-0.1366202235,
-0.0425382517,
-0.0395594537,
-0.0477630869,
0.2491862327,
0.2408256233,
-0.0084352996,
0.0922429711,
-0.6116862893,
-0.0377963223,
0.6626794934,
-0.4819969535,
-0.20364362,
0.6485722661,
0.3190225065,
-0.1079899296,
0.3889164627,
-0.0014256849,
-0.6084153056,
0.4944891334,
0.4439077973,
1.071814537,
-0.5255280733,
0.4152777195,
0.3063486218,
0.7739832401,
-0.5148808956,
0.3638374209,
0.4267242849,
-1.0507500172,
-0.3952924013,
-0.2147503793,
-0.2486462593,
0.1884560287,
-0.4005993605,
0.492682308,
-0.5274623632,
-0.3157360554,
0.0491232276,
-0.1004156619,
-0.9855204821,
0.1367244422,
0.360769242,
0.6019711494,
-1.2226372957,
0.7801186442,
0.421800524,
-0.2503840923,
-0.4036242664,
-0.041222807,
0.3766166866,
-0.587336123,
1.0200209618,
0.2153237164,
-0.2639141977,
0.0549572967,
-0.8695803881,
-0.7575163245,
0.385027796,
0.9718122482,
-0.9363541603,
0.1523389369,
0.3607813716,
0.2817090154,
-0.3299538791,
0.6495275497,
0.8653540611,
0.7467393279,
-0.4236376286,
-0.9507819414,
-0.2000425011,
-0.0310663525,
0.0815825313,
0.1583959162,
-0.1122059971,
0.57751894,
-0.0828498453,
-0.0769942105,
-0.3369477391,
0.3154509962,
0.1245457232,
0.0491135046,
0.9230493307,
0.1002910733,
0.6813086271,
-0.1722071469,
0.9967275262,
-0.0739361569,
0.2424132228,
1.158796072,
-0.5534445047,
0.4575224519,
0.4877180457,
-0.2466331124,
0.0416426361,
0.2010013312,
0.2816347778,
0.4943971038,
0.2912104428,
0.0218853336,
-0.521846056,
-0.2424519807,
-0.2832162082,
0.6922908425,
0.0577102266,
-0.1908457875,
-0.5156212449,
0.4321323931,
0.3432456553,
0.0701740235,
-0.1607774198,
0.6376219392,
0.144975692,
-0.1628891826,
0.4459349513,
-0.1394774318,
0.7418884635,
-0.6744161248,
-0.1613716036,
-0.3535214365,
0.2656797171,
-0.0818071812,
-0.0865864009,
0.1186963692,
0.215896517,
-0.4262332618,
-0.5167357922,
0.9406699538,
-0.936915338,
-0.7151179314,
0.196919322,
0.732452035,
-0.1490363181,
-0.2541559339,
-0.657494545,
-0.0247157216,
0.0292870589,
-0.2025519907,
0.2183879167,
-0.153158173,
-0.2513147593,
0.7905949354,
0.6413702965,
0.180552125,
-0.3054892123,
0.5440077782,
0.6583681703,
-0.7102806568,
-0.3575256467,
-1.0451124907,
0.2191943079,
-0.0219828282,
-0.0527597107,
0.6472129226,
0.2310367674,
0.5589122772,
-0.2557317317,
0.8731412888,
0.3458826244,
0.5209956169,
-0.3099737465,
0.8624715209,
-0.4343490303,
0.3833721876,
-0.7336764336,
-0.8675462604,
-0.3792506158,
0.594386518,
-0.6946065426,
0.2463037372,
0.1019921228,
1.0310034752,
0.0491532199,
-0.0700020716,
0.3340483904,
0.1371649057,
0.5665821433,
0.2784318328,
0.8639528751,
-0.3717316985,
0.1121429726,
-0.1302947104,
-0.3729668558,
-0.0049632294,
-1.0981947184,
-0.9794814587,
-0.0334005989,
-0.4074403346,
0.0548471138,
0.3833577335,
1.2676285505,
0.9132163525,
-0.694224298,
-0.0392277092,
-0.0056944489,
0.3059546649,
-0.0343029238,
-0.0840617418,
0.2486881167,
-0.3688933253,
-1.1222666502,
0.3595124781,
-0.0228249114,
-0.1864116937,
-0.3054368496,
0.1913698018,
-0.1424393952,
0.1567161381,
0.565843761,
-0.1284354627,
-0.3793160319,
-0.3079265952,
-0.2099703699,
-0.0069132526,
-0.0719773248,
0.9765934348,
-0.9032592773,
0.5615407825,
0.6426095963,
0.5899348855,
0.3556190729,
-0.0020069694,
0.9787818193,
-0.9178736806,
0.4739443064,
-0.079248786,
0.2694770992,
0.4582408071,
-0.123673737,
0.533514142,
0.0943593606,
-0.0295783933,
-1.0558570623,
0.2228081226,
-0.2669360042,
-0.5166141391,
1.131131053,
0.2371300161,
-0.2363609076,
-0.1790446788,
-0.473503083,
0.2906476855,
-0.3843935728,
0.9191248417,
0.5233620405,
0.4906055927,
-0.1213362813,
-0.6584347486,
0.5982632637,
0.6092931032,
-1.0560357571,
0.3702441454,
0.4701113701,
0.3539023697,
-0.1789194196,
0.6024463177,
-0.1468178034,
0.0246134624,
-0.20836097,
0.3890072107,
0.0466778688,
-0.3398245275,
-0.5549170375,
-0.3601543903,
-0.0792322606,
-0.2057167143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04573v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04573v1 | Gender, names and other mysteries: Towards the ambiguous for gender-inclusive translation | 2023-06-07T16:21:59 | 2023-06-07T16:21:59 | Danielle Saunders, Katrina Olsen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The vast majority of work on gender in MT focuses on 'unambiguous' inputs,
where gender markers in the source language are expected to be resolved in the
output. Conversely, this paper explores the widespread case where the source
sentence lacks explicit gender markers, but the target sentence contains them
due to richer grammatical gender. We particularly focus on inputs containing
person names.
Investigating such sentence pairs casts a new light on research into MT
gender bias and its mitigation. We find that many name-gender co-occurrences in
MT data are not resolvable with 'unambiguous gender' in the source language,
and that gender-ambiguous examples can make up a large proportion of training
examples. From this, we discuss potential steps toward gender-inclusive
translation which accepts the ambiguity in both gender and translation. | [
-0.2807956636,
-0.4364013672,
0.6643739343,
0.0191774108,
-0.0009375529,
0.4103951752,
0.0058840541,
-0.5586001873,
-0.0063680569,
0.316013515,
-1.1133602858,
-0.1172237918,
-1.0911253691,
0.6068550348,
-0.6187533736,
0.6528157592,
-0.1954450458,
0.2613269687,
0.1346373707,
-0.4395591617,
-0.7805320024,
-0.666161716,
-0.5363966823,
-0.0396852978,
0.6827138066,
0.3550100029,
0.7276265621,
0.6191478968,
0.412004292,
0.2810799778,
-0.1995745301,
0.5641675591,
-0.3682607412,
0.2295115143,
-0.1576927006,
-0.6271916032,
-0.2778562605,
0.1510792375,
0.7224767208,
1.025595665,
0.1020911932,
0.2987002134,
-0.1025145873,
0.8426728249,
-0.4782434106,
0.0160256401,
-0.4382348359,
0.2683961987,
-0.4784302711,
-0.0394077115,
-0.2704454064,
-0.010677536,
0.0445631705,
-0.4486995339,
0.4506852031,
0.5161408186,
0.4669126272,
0.0629434884,
-0.5374674201,
-0.3976564109,
-0.7936224937,
0.8614507318,
-0.1710908413,
0.3533540964,
0.446084857,
0.3810517192,
-0.5665824413,
-0.2530474067,
-0.5032640696,
0.1675384045,
-0.2044978291,
0.0063893953,
-0.2711409032,
-0.222156316,
0.4059693217,
0.2461695075,
-0.2488871962,
-0.0240557566,
-0.561416626,
0.0534906164,
0.5882347226,
0.1214982346,
0.564371109,
-0.0041920664,
-0.1409999579,
0.1929568201,
-0.8891330957,
0.0457892753,
0.9820325971,
0.7289687991,
0.0065300115,
0.8708567023,
-0.1307818294,
0.6261277795,
-0.0853588432,
0.324015975,
0.2147285938,
0.0117828436,
-0.0242064204,
0.260004878,
0.7299543619,
0.0199224241,
0.3186013699,
-0.4874801636,
0.1969019622,
-0.3109985888,
0.240402326,
-0.3936055601,
-0.1590366811,
0.2275346071,
-0.181981653,
-0.0690618902,
0.2715768218,
-0.5057067871,
-0.5349658728,
-0.1352112293,
0.2792394161,
-0.0442090444,
-0.2742685676,
-0.038715478,
-0.5531070828,
0.0275208559,
0.5807052851,
-1.0965679884,
-0.0413518064,
0.5430995226,
0.1913170666,
0.0316357948,
-0.3431729376,
-0.847935915,
0.2492279112,
-0.1432185471,
0.3480497301,
-0.7523518801,
-0.3340328932,
-0.1903146952,
0.3453364968,
0.0285651367,
-0.1504907459,
0.2444300801,
-0.0222747065,
0.801041007,
-0.8303861022,
-0.1538054198,
-0.1980451792,
-0.0935547426,
-0.3492167592,
1.0369337797,
0.4219649434,
-0.7937838435,
0.2794173062,
-0.6597726345,
-0.2852630019,
0.165276736,
-0.4215832949,
-0.3614166975,
0.3839049935,
0.0586762577,
0.1641270071,
-0.2340391576,
0.4544270039,
-0.0953445435,
-0.4338316321,
0.6165036559,
-0.2591360211,
0.9873990417,
-0.0401795954,
-0.3144555688,
-0.050749097,
-0.5530644655,
-0.3380644023,
0.2302949429,
-0.0970214605,
-0.3090547919,
-0.121019192,
0.0591917373,
-0.115440771,
-0.1244951561,
-0.564566493,
0.3361976147,
0.1373970211,
0.5855135322,
0.5635421276,
-0.5020652413,
0.5945463777,
-0.1446162462,
0.6799892187,
-0.1052146032,
0.1587888449,
-0.0587743856,
-1.0187798738,
-0.6384288669,
-0.0858794004,
0.9169966578,
0.4567858279,
-0.8634396195,
0.146333009,
-0.1402757615,
-0.1013436019,
-0.9122717381,
0.0544470735,
0.3767665923,
0.3444830179,
0.3412516415,
-0.1950366497,
-0.8633136153,
-1.1239477396,
-1.0041970015,
-0.2609446347,
-0.0790610164,
0.0494768471,
0.642054081,
-0.0715745538,
0.8742258549,
-0.3359346092,
-0.2817086279,
-0.3381401598,
0.3809941709,
-0.0297960863,
0.5825372338,
0.4749638736,
-0.9760716558,
-0.1467750818,
-0.0626984686,
-0.5305395126,
-0.1004239172,
0.1119141877,
-0.2134365141,
-0.3179831207,
0.251909107,
-0.3669760823,
0.5656964779,
0.6253458858,
-0.54311198,
0.1117993221,
-0.1422594637,
0.2912333906,
-0.9673323035,
-0.0890764892,
-0.3663029969,
-0.582192421,
-0.7582597733,
0.2118848562,
0.2042911798,
0.2050411254,
-0.5897399187,
0.4881195128,
-0.9795598388,
-0.0092051188,
-0.0325208716,
0.0832950994,
-0.0816240609,
0.2249652445,
-0.0784671232,
0.6789797544,
0.285338819,
-0.3709132373,
0.0475949012,
0.5966421962,
0.1028215438,
0.6939502954,
-0.1098316386,
0.1552135795,
-0.3372749686,
-0.0643885732,
-1.0149320364,
-0.4139856994,
0.8883376122,
-0.6577655077,
0.5735276341,
-0.3659817576,
-0.6042935848,
-0.4391775429,
-0.1122551411,
0.729287982,
0.5811442733,
-0.3290355206,
0.5510691404,
0.2757624984,
0.0026766376,
-0.9806272984,
-1.0845270157,
0.345238626,
-0.2918105721,
-0.2379759103,
-0.0231882893,
-0.121966958,
-0.0876915976,
-0.167519331,
-0.1344188005,
-0.3547004759,
0.3331101239,
0.3990963101,
0.0953870565,
-0.0965023115,
0.0357143804,
0.2128850371,
0.0567882173,
-0.0091475993,
0.0660004914,
0.1119040474,
0.1537908316,
-0.3136307895,
-0.31815359,
0.9230651259,
0.3664060235,
0.0009679304,
0.9080756903,
0.6479008198,
-0.3536166847,
0.0427455567,
-0.3752180338,
0.0515525937,
-0.4340875447,
0.1955749989,
-0.4481273293,
-1.0691291094,
0.6736187935,
-0.0702719316,
-0.1808888167,
0.6781918406,
0.1097818911,
-0.4476182759,
1.0553748608,
0.7690705061,
0.6295681596,
0.2012281418,
0.243397221,
0.3144461513,
-1.1104531288,
-0.1496615559,
-0.6902109981,
-0.658003211,
-0.6788900495,
-0.3289520741,
-0.0111318352,
0.0030716672,
0.0199228413,
0.6281532645,
-0.5862337947,
0.5276033878,
0.5971076488,
-0.163250193,
0.4457533658,
-0.1521758139,
0.1771423966,
-0.3457816839,
-0.723726213,
-0.2683396041,
1.0220738649,
0.2052676678,
0.1590311825,
0.5331305861,
0.3323806524,
0.3445096314,
0.4065003991,
-0.2175056636,
0.194033727,
-0.2750791907,
-1.153326273,
-0.1109723374,
-0.6183543205,
-1.2548288107,
0.2821367681,
-0.3077115417,
-0.790520072,
0.5066198707,
-0.1755948663,
-0.1218272224,
0.3276728392,
-0.6106433272,
0.6130124331,
-0.2622397542,
-0.0310476404,
0.6035981774,
-0.9152599573,
0.6853419542,
-0.1594189256,
0.4759531617,
-0.3111295998,
0.0331300348,
0.6329901218,
-0.2732560635,
0.7095524073,
0.0351078287,
-0.220899716,
-0.0830368698,
0.1524515301,
0.29225564,
-0.1351299286,
0.0962422788,
0.5259881616,
-0.2264094949,
-0.4403339922,
-0.5394553542,
0.2080535442,
-0.5938887596,
-0.6471192241,
-0.5256441832,
-0.9018358588,
-0.1615379155,
0.3161121011,
0.4071511626,
0.2447319925,
0.1412851512,
-0.1099038348,
0.6233400106,
-0.2693278491,
0.1810279042,
0.5641917586,
-0.4151619077,
-0.2402935624,
0.4465569854,
0.1586480439,
0.1485831738,
0.4776829183,
-0.0077634207,
-0.2702521384,
-0.5732034445,
-0.9494789839,
0.3946585059,
-0.6043562889,
-0.0643771663,
-0.7808964849,
-0.1826260835,
-0.1406659931,
0.0378379673,
-0.3854047954,
-0.775397718,
-0.3129388094,
0.0584920347,
0.3813596964,
0.9349125624,
0.3552915454,
0.6986643076,
-0.6539061069,
0.6232309341,
0.1613893211,
0.0770599395,
-0.4275483489,
-0.5733091831,
0.1455248296,
0.1180121526,
0.0398728438,
-1.2395826578,
0.2137016654,
-0.2070418745,
0.520639956,
0.0775389224,
0.1339624673,
0.7278654575,
-0.622405231,
0.7089756727,
0.3416870236,
-1.0345287323,
0.5321466327,
-0.3277957439,
0.1769524068,
0.6064113975,
0.1467694044,
-0.6297032833,
-0.8897869587,
-0.5567923784,
-0.6691073179,
0.9860205054,
0.8175901771,
0.2368970662,
0.1366051137,
0.5728926659,
0.6676874161,
0.6249161363,
-0.7588326335,
-0.8149889708,
0.2862139344,
-0.1964562982,
0.1061759293,
-0.2567990124,
-0.2189651132,
-0.4113867581,
0.2988345623,
0.1114053801,
0.3684063256,
0.1695079952,
-0.1911414713,
-0.1517540663,
0.3568436205,
0.7182586789,
0.6480557919,
-0.0710023642,
0.3470322192,
0.1479562372,
-0.5392162204,
0.2309549749,
-0.0521747917,
-0.3020699024,
0.390388906,
0.1731828302,
0.6466554999,
0.0864974111,
-0.2655285299,
0.4530362487,
-0.4718106687,
-0.4323978722,
-0.3507687151,
0.0255950373,
0.0017295639,
0.359364748,
0.500039041,
0.5523408055,
0.1434174925,
-0.7018083334,
-0.4444131553,
0.4172395468,
-0.6628223658,
-0.3145060241,
1.0437966585,
0.1927624196,
-0.6102318764,
0.5872694254,
-0.4172338843,
-0.7706278563,
0.4793215394,
0.2709721029,
0.9715818763,
-0.4882330298,
0.1536290348,
0.0111358976,
0.7831912637,
-0.2377577424,
0.4909885526,
-0.0079394272,
-0.3914134502,
-0.1464172155,
-0.1172605827,
-0.4896811545,
-0.3169718087,
-0.6992588043,
0.4101851285,
-0.0177443605,
-0.1561934948,
-0.1544404775,
-0.421127528,
-0.830884099,
-0.1678939611,
0.4285776019,
0.5042968988,
-0.8782562017,
0.7341107726,
0.6986595392,
-0.2304501384,
-0.3808706403,
-0.2805788219,
-0.0205283351,
-0.6946721673,
0.6787000895,
0.2012795359,
-0.0003592783,
-0.0799084976,
-0.3562160134,
-0.5611308813,
0.8723634481,
0.9036801457,
-0.4305281043,
-0.1566135585,
0.6135969162,
0.1895200461,
-0.3186963201,
0.3077236712,
0.3368350267,
1.0731915236,
0.047689978,
-0.7719615698,
0.086955294,
-0.2449580729,
-0.055082757,
0.5355567932,
-0.5560755134,
1.0538076162,
-0.1088936925,
-0.3566888571,
0.2296683788,
0.5351528525,
0.0161123071,
0.4653179646,
0.1860027909,
0.1988192201,
0.9790013433,
-0.5519358516,
1.0223429203,
0.5407466292,
0.1243726537,
1.1007043123,
-0.0039629173,
0.4968438148,
0.5563411713,
-0.6349484324,
0.4484471977,
0.6686294675,
-0.1441252381,
0.2261585891,
0.2281905711,
-0.0725655109,
-0.2038443238,
-0.0561120249,
-0.5412822962,
0.4974125326,
0.2571758926,
-0.4701599479,
-0.1014536247,
-0.0922099128,
0.1388598084,
-0.1290897429,
-0.0687231198,
0.2378663421,
0.1979543716,
-0.4797022641,
0.0528062806,
0.1649588048,
0.3993275166,
-0.5524240732,
-0.0940095931,
-0.1735311449,
-0.2201553136,
-0.251254648,
-0.6299803257,
0.2628899813,
-0.0635514781,
-0.428668648,
-0.5283761024,
0.3874545991,
-0.7552110553,
-0.6759525537,
-0.0092179365,
0.8211079836,
0.4648867249,
-0.3849856555,
-0.3089261949,
-0.2943409383,
0.1940560937,
0.3330760896,
0.2831620872,
0.7618231773,
-0.033147119,
0.413882941,
0.449311316,
0.0382405706,
0.3935388923,
-0.144974649,
0.2644325197,
-0.7660378218,
-0.2777973711,
-0.943385005,
0.7390785813,
0.01329921,
-0.5673530102,
1.0784418583,
0.3162665367,
0.5186600089,
-0.1444019079,
0.4760538638,
0.138475731,
0.2270459533,
-0.2190902084,
0.8546990156,
-0.5220558047,
0.2554553449,
-0.2693620622,
-1.1503479481,
-0.6440554261,
0.0858587623,
0.079625532,
0.0715771317,
0.8825015426,
0.0900601819,
-0.1728821695,
0.3266316652,
0.3439766765,
0.0057376982,
-0.0523697436,
0.4611729085,
1.3096010685,
-1.0131374598,
0.427763164,
-0.0375883132,
0.1206249222,
-0.243437618,
-1.0765590668,
-1.0354275703,
-0.5263333917,
-0.6933714747,
0.0593048409,
0.2177843451,
0.5344413519,
0.6667147875,
-0.6979480982,
0.1209308207,
-0.1298500001,
0.4804424345,
-0.2927543521,
-0.1156880781,
0.0697907433,
0.147366941,
-1.024055481,
0.3471036553,
0.1053708717,
0.2441313267,
-0.1920344085,
-0.0150530692,
0.0512001999,
-0.0984483957,
0.2501157224,
0.1844604313,
-0.8799207807,
-0.3897963762,
-0.1343105882,
0.2499752045,
0.1594505161,
0.7870324254,
-0.5624573231,
0.5423257351,
0.3181438148,
0.6201046705,
0.2311768234,
0.005333453,
0.7889786363,
-1.1789528131,
-0.0434246063,
-0.1426819116,
0.3687535524,
0.5233163834,
-0.6922237873,
0.6878206134,
0.4432506561,
-0.2252652496,
-1.164146781,
0.2982342243,
-1.1128110886,
-0.3540335,
0.9994065166,
-0.0045874384,
-0.0066043199,
-0.4315784872,
-0.2016827911,
0.4334058464,
-0.3120651543,
0.5757065415,
1.003313303,
-0.018689096,
-0.2086654603,
-1.1025835276,
0.1011418104,
0.4786441028,
-0.4004000425,
0.1016139239,
0.0980747566,
0.0915100947,
0.0942333117,
0.3194867074,
-0.0681473091,
0.2137653083,
-0.0138430148,
0.1601204127,
-0.2674073875,
-0.1834880859,
-0.2511073947,
0.0122443223,
0.0145475026,
-0.1543740034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04563v1 | ChatGPT is fun, but it is not funny! Humor is still challenging Large Language Models | 2023-06-07T16:10:21 | 2023-06-07T16:10:21 | Sophie Jentzsch, Kristian Kersting | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Humor is a central aspect of human communication that has not been solved for
artificial agents so far. Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly able to
capture implicit and contextual information. Especially, OpenAI's ChatGPT
recently gained immense public attention. The GPT3-based model almost seems to
communicate on a human level and can even tell jokes. Humor is an essential
component of human communication. But is ChatGPT really funny? We put ChatGPT's
sense of humor to the test. In a series of exploratory experiments around
jokes, i.e., generation, explanation, and detection, we seek to understand
ChatGPT's capability to grasp and reproduce human humor. Since the model itself
is not accessible, we applied prompt-based experiments. Our empirical evidence
indicates that jokes are not hard-coded but mostly also not newly generated by
the model. Over 90% of 1008 generated jokes were the same 25 Jokes. The system
accurately explains valid jokes but also comes up with fictional explanations
for invalid jokes. Joke-typical characteristics can mislead ChatGPT in the
classification of jokes. ChatGPT has not solved computational humor yet but it
can be a big leap toward "funny" machines. | [
-0.2631824911,
-1.059879303,
0.8177255988,
0.6192893982,
-0.6926605701,
-0.316622436,
-0.3493361473,
-0.3907155097,
0.0072103674,
0.1066899374,
-0.3388895392,
-0.1228357926,
-0.4077018201,
-0.0186338276,
-0.346719861,
1.1299722195,
0.5731371045,
0.0273825545,
-0.0202462263,
0.1361955702,
-0.1125363186,
-0.6033744812,
-1.0439392328,
-0.4404457808,
0.8260362744,
0.4365570247,
0.8776116967,
0.1553522199,
0.6471297145,
0.2616952062,
-0.2875534892,
-0.3123960197,
-0.5068866611,
-0.1411616802,
-0.0522436462,
-0.6029204726,
-0.2616162896,
-0.3574509025,
0.3685784042,
0.7606469393,
-0.3477586508,
-0.3291112185,
-0.1238260344,
0.5573770404,
-0.0382270403,
0.2090830207,
-0.4144786298,
0.1245634481,
-0.2458197623,
-0.2622384131,
-0.3829497993,
-0.5001314282,
0.0872865096,
-0.1971003264,
0.0743354112,
0.1237648502,
0.5931894779,
0.3128635883,
-0.4374912381,
-0.493560791,
-0.7869146466,
0.4393577874,
-0.8791526556,
0.0139383217,
-0.0205878168,
0.6376060843,
-0.3312239945,
-0.547909379,
-0.9288074374,
-0.6376700401,
0.2420220524,
0.1117840111,
-0.3316782415,
-0.1256780922,
0.2903699279,
0.2234942168,
-0.7881552577,
-0.0825087726,
-0.2998865247,
0.2541218996,
0.4053026736,
-0.0622544326,
0.6380196214,
-0.1133845001,
-0.4495681226,
0.0071943472,
-0.8091637492,
-0.1546722203,
0.5854417086,
0.0996758863,
-0.1373920441,
0.6259299517,
0.0903895274,
0.0181330163,
-0.4793401659,
-0.0095039317,
0.0931368321,
0.3067680895,
-0.2743087709,
0.0923313648,
0.9539553523,
0.2771086097,
0.9067240357,
-0.3087686598,
-0.157696858,
-0.1118231118,
0.1273604631,
-0.3961929083,
-0.5432128906,
-0.0172275193,
-0.2328122407,
-0.5430241227,
0.0238294173,
-0.4441596568,
-0.4764110446,
0.3832434416,
0.4247358143,
-0.5152224302,
-0.2970509529,
0.4369090497,
-0.3460333943,
0.3727645576,
0.6299286485,
-0.5444950461,
0.1150329784,
0.886775434,
0.7751787901,
0.1753134578,
-0.264769882,
-0.3354690075,
-0.1835549772,
-0.2715759277,
0.9348169565,
-0.4792592227,
-0.3274972737,
-0.3624252081,
0.1000007242,
0.0998962075,
-0.4172002077,
0.586574018,
-0.5246862769,
0.3908417523,
-0.2780064642,
-0.2951823473,
-0.0786087513,
0.236720264,
-0.3287656903,
0.5766012669,
0.1271527857,
-0.971390605,
0.1009888873,
-0.8860572577,
-0.5660924911,
0.3046419621,
0.1065183952,
-0.1114758104,
0.0288163591,
-0.0691442043,
-0.0484049022,
-0.2838348746,
0.3262989223,
-0.4204733074,
-0.6854073405,
0.750831604,
-0.6593126655,
0.7978200316,
0.5141718388,
-0.5330417156,
-0.32398507,
-0.1602102071,
-0.1210416332,
0.5764806271,
-0.3510107696,
0.1432579458,
0.0377078503,
-0.2190884799,
0.4232153893,
-0.0301267318,
-0.7094108462,
0.2731812298,
-0.4093647599,
0.7989327908,
0.5848477483,
-0.1424319893,
-0.138813585,
-0.4465367794,
0.4931678772,
-0.0039469199,
0.2170874029,
-0.0760189071,
-1.1576726437,
-0.7907177806,
-0.1188681722,
-0.0942654163,
0.8929181695,
-0.8387663364,
0.1795680225,
-0.2714734077,
-0.5680503249,
-0.0372002237,
-0.3495322168,
0.21486561,
0.3154995143,
0.1419902742,
-0.4292847812,
-0.0203627516,
-0.7556382418,
-0.5789771676,
-0.4539875388,
-0.2877531946,
0.4526897073,
0.4690069258,
0.040349707,
0.6378397346,
-0.2880326211,
0.1797750294,
-0.4782453179,
0.2062703669,
0.4014300704,
0.2239307165,
0.6708426476,
-0.8228211999,
-0.2940374911,
0.0684788078,
-0.762819767,
-0.1167547852,
0.236104995,
0.3936663866,
0.1145134568,
0.1235488206,
-1.0330357552,
0.3216411173,
0.3008954227,
-0.2295869142,
0.7065161467,
-0.359416306,
0.0858904272,
-0.4527641535,
0.103797771,
-0.3528465927,
-0.4010646343,
-0.5220323205,
0.0182269979,
-0.3243685365,
-0.6732781529,
-0.6194865108,
0.8191446662,
-0.0860357732,
-0.2588484287,
-0.3869156539,
0.1213306263,
-0.2629427016,
0.5806951523,
-0.2790581882,
0.5026473999,
0.5311704278,
-0.5155692101,
0.6932743788,
-0.1103857234,
-0.2543011308,
0.3770096302,
-0.7635661364,
0.4973848164,
-0.1297639012,
0.4108703136,
-1.0321427584,
-0.5080848336,
0.4885351062,
-0.6449729204,
0.0135001643,
-0.2964609265,
-0.6989658475,
-0.4422981441,
-0.1435585171,
0.2424934059,
0.9521522522,
-0.5981974006,
0.1175591722,
0.1692098528,
-0.5056419373,
-0.3504164517,
-0.7690600753,
0.4335639179,
-0.4460458159,
-1.0585856438,
-0.2495288551,
-0.1463405341,
-0.3133064806,
-0.0032241668,
0.0255794358,
-0.0168465097,
0.1360668391,
0.0250916816,
-0.2415566891,
-0.3796094954,
0.1356789768,
-0.4884479344,
0.0708880499,
0.0145648774,
-0.0798228607,
0.7447243929,
-0.5052235126,
-0.7713486552,
-0.2698399425,
0.250302434,
0.2845392823,
0.1979230493,
0.562510252,
0.4921458066,
-0.1836718619,
0.0242183916,
-0.4767808318,
-0.2040931135,
-0.4488816559,
0.2845204771,
-0.2295064926,
-0.9802936912,
0.406142354,
0.0496225432,
-0.2693193555,
0.1761596799,
0.2575359046,
-0.1557630002,
1.1059296131,
0.5395854115,
0.2947815955,
0.2132721841,
0.3444440961,
0.812158823,
-0.3591677547,
-0.0433023125,
-0.4737672806,
-0.286572665,
-0.7775957584,
-0.3628873825,
0.3812886477,
0.0508736782,
-0.3242261708,
-0.0241274722,
0.0129455961,
0.4895008206,
0.4333644509,
0.001062955,
0.360732764,
-0.0507697202,
0.1007770896,
0.1926448047,
-0.6803106666,
-0.4733379185,
0.527056694,
0.5826553702,
1.023447156,
0.4993781447,
0.6095446944,
0.1950597167,
0.3055120707,
-0.7792969942,
0.7600293756,
-0.3690805137,
-0.2562533915,
-0.3016972244,
-0.8448239565,
-0.7205951214,
-0.1124194637,
0.2897571325,
-1.0557779074,
-0.1644466519,
0.3034901023,
-0.1038245559,
0.4917138517,
-1.004660368,
0.6713526845,
-0.0973028839,
-0.168468982,
0.0728937909,
-0.7884796262,
0.5953595042,
0.1954165399,
0.5024785399,
-0.0699519515,
0.3959135413,
0.392563343,
-0.3660613596,
0.6665608883,
-0.1093881205,
-0.0548976995,
0.3641492724,
0.3997508883,
0.4426507056,
0.0131290853,
0.0207702164,
-0.0721497014,
-0.3570027947,
-0.6016662121,
-0.8941242099,
0.6527354717,
-0.5512933731,
-0.7726507783,
-0.2169004679,
-0.4128100872,
0.0005910416,
-0.1313332766,
0.0965827405,
0.1092639118,
-0.1079549715,
0.3338354826,
0.3576668501,
-0.6219140887,
0.2917985022,
0.09433759,
-0.2502864897,
0.0704456642,
1.2277966738,
-0.2794414759,
0.2953140736,
0.0595292598,
0.4491273761,
-0.1239356846,
0.0051526693,
-0.2770653367,
0.4675411284,
-1.0050991774,
0.372238934,
-0.906121552,
-0.4508201182,
-0.3818260729,
-0.0224715471,
-0.3434365094,
-0.5851948261,
0.1857081056,
0.2841112614,
0.226612255,
1.0407899618,
-0.100984104,
0.48635903,
-0.680455029,
0.0546226911,
0.6341020465,
0.2848151624,
-0.0670947284,
-0.4141817391,
0.3052506745,
0.0400527008,
-0.2462353259,
-0.8822997212,
0.376947999,
0.3085867763,
0.2858109772,
0.3118264377,
-0.1386702806,
0.0008860446,
-0.373074919,
0.9457069635,
-0.048543863,
-0.5152978301,
0.164850682,
-0.5006338954,
0.1746245623,
-0.3391761184,
0.1868939102,
-0.7902956009,
-0.4936882854,
-0.9033393264,
-0.6602268815,
0.5840409398,
0.4316343069,
0.5195642114,
-0.3479138613,
0.3088457882,
-0.1057392433,
0.347404331,
-0.8928614855,
0.0285549592,
-0.4161368608,
-0.0404545218,
0.1025043279,
-0.2981304228,
-0.1392993033,
0.2251095325,
0.4726764858,
-0.0408211723,
0.6167284846,
0.1547718346,
-0.0970760435,
-0.0968903229,
0.5990207195,
0.9434495568,
0.5964144468,
-0.4201103449,
0.3462008536,
-0.0540238768,
-0.5237609148,
-0.2168730646,
0.0108303847,
0.2040980458,
-0.0598021969,
0.3828319609,
1.0482693911,
0.2979156673,
-0.7904855609,
0.8273518085,
-0.2493585944,
-0.2254437804,
-0.3294677138,
0.3806200922,
0.2432881445,
0.4909443259,
0.2566613257,
-0.0059723835,
0.1181918308,
-0.9254028201,
0.0182459764,
0.4361179471,
-0.3613686562,
-0.5169921517,
0.7046517134,
0.143124938,
-0.4712139964,
0.7067855,
-0.3835514784,
-0.9138017893,
0.8235430121,
0.719321847,
0.8311575055,
0.0007833806,
0.3872861266,
0.0296876933,
0.4867862165,
-0.0588881373,
0.4050324857,
0.2514230609,
-0.6149061918,
-0.2647445202,
-0.4205137193,
-0.7340263724,
0.1264438331,
0.1296298951,
0.5544640422,
-0.1522883475,
0.1412527412,
-0.2514772415,
-0.2710660994,
-0.5466634631,
0.1725778282,
0.2342249006,
1.0062373877,
-0.6436520219,
0.7433055639,
0.4812467694,
-0.2193972021,
-0.6462292671,
0.3126021028,
-0.1408295929,
-0.9177423716,
0.6465931535,
0.3543355465,
0.0223708693,
0.1854500473,
-0.9307299852,
-0.253270179,
0.7267009616,
0.6934395432,
-0.2925725579,
-0.1362872571,
0.2510192692,
0.5426213145,
-0.2336833775,
0.6030266881,
0.1660134196,
0.5910594463,
0.5278682709,
-1.0788724422,
-0.1626871079,
-0.2116071135,
-0.2639137805,
0.0102627743,
-0.5967238545,
1.1794397831,
-0.6498689055,
-0.2817691863,
-0.0522181392,
0.2811957896,
0.439337194,
0.5437302589,
0.7460754514,
0.6246191263,
0.38315624,
-0.1768968254,
1.4398094416,
0.0902658701,
0.5693708062,
0.9004389048,
-0.5652862191,
0.4279382825,
0.3329418004,
-0.0883978978,
0.258815825,
0.4626335204,
0.20292826,
0.269180268,
0.3795073628,
-0.2259085476,
-0.3037475348,
0.1200489849,
-0.446978569,
0.3501527607,
0.1118655652,
-0.0142796487,
-0.5692258477,
0.1257935762,
0.426962465,
-0.4192435443,
0.2141161114,
0.6407120228,
0.3734568059,
-0.5277528763,
0.1993170232,
-0.1049226969,
0.504242301,
-0.4475553632,
-0.1414775103,
-0.4316616952,
-0.0549836978,
0.0786268786,
-0.9970090389,
0.104567863,
0.183562845,
0.4388935864,
0.3952734768,
0.7772520781,
-0.273699373,
0.0042008976,
0.1064703241,
0.4664556384,
0.9008693099,
-0.483112365,
-0.3891437352,
-0.2363345176,
-0.2179565281,
-0.4501295388,
0.2605881989,
0.980255127,
-0.1391480118,
0.9476723075,
0.7435716391,
-0.0243202019,
0.0330692977,
0.2134766579,
1.032168746,
-0.914298594,
-0.433932811,
-1.0830699205,
0.5239029527,
-0.0714741275,
-0.2256679237,
0.3183298409,
0.2982222438,
0.1549756676,
-0.2903016806,
0.7379021645,
-0.1221219301,
0.2707676291,
-0.5273718238,
0.8106838465,
-0.720724225,
0.2885990739,
-0.2493844181,
-1.0574944019,
-0.2129436284,
0.4257329702,
-0.3787243664,
0.3956213892,
0.8684219718,
0.6158230901,
-0.3364732563,
0.3455483615,
0.6130429506,
0.3249625862,
0.7049809694,
0.7277091742,
1.1767790318,
-0.0361252949,
0.82336092,
-0.3386056721,
-0.4028026462,
-0.4091616869,
-1.2924001217,
-0.8106105924,
-0.183380574,
-0.2396762818,
-0.1770320237,
0.1328790337,
0.5521560907,
0.2598226964,
-0.1906545162,
0.0638302937,
-0.098260358,
0.1620459706,
0.1625513285,
-0.322229743,
0.1429797113,
-0.3652317822,
-0.5359435081,
0.3756992817,
0.4557125568,
0.0320865028,
-0.1270063668,
-0.0572098531,
0.0174507331,
0.2396626174,
0.4576167762,
0.5363352895,
-0.5814790726,
-0.7565276623,
0.0937895551,
-0.0444459803,
0.0290767215,
0.5888111591,
-0.349919796,
0.1731726825,
0.6213728786,
0.4084656537,
0.2903882265,
-0.1421082318,
0.3934804201,
-0.656750381,
0.3759952188,
0.3071765602,
0.371386975,
0.5934446454,
-0.4616240263,
0.6266165376,
0.5199139118,
-0.9822536111,
-1.0403456688,
0.3153731227,
-1.1115550995,
-0.0348907188,
1.149818182,
-0.3584832251,
-0.6640579104,
-0.042832166,
-0.4463220835,
0.2437801957,
-0.2775494158,
0.855483532,
0.9262573719,
-0.277715385,
-0.5106416345,
-1.0499347448,
0.3135489523,
0.3534928262,
-0.8170422912,
-0.1341422945,
-0.0999176577,
0.3746215105,
0.1788942665,
0.8674151897,
-0.048203662,
0.6624699831,
-0.1274937838,
0.2187483162,
0.2085786909,
-0.1447353214,
-0.0866688564,
-0.0350779518,
0.3650897145,
0.2415846884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04551v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04551v2 | Multi-Task Training with In-Domain Language Models for Diagnostic Reasoning | 2023-06-07T15:55:34 | 2023-06-13T17:28:34 | Brihat Sharma, Yanjun Gao, Timothy Miller, Matthew M. Churpek, Majid Afshar, Dmitriy Dligach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is a promising direction for
augmenting clinical diagnostic decision support and reducing diagnostic errors,
a leading contributor to medical errors. To further the development of clinical
AI systems, the Diagnostic Reasoning Benchmark (DR.BENCH) was introduced as a
comprehensive generative AI framework, comprised of six tasks representing key
components in clinical reasoning. We present a comparative analysis of
in-domain versus out-of-domain language models as well as multi-task versus
single task training with a focus on the problem summarization task in DR.BENCH
(Gao et al., 2023). We demonstrate that a multi-task, clinically trained
language model outperforms its general domain counterpart by a large margin,
establishing a new state-of-the-art performance, with a ROUGE-L score of 28.55.
This research underscores the value of domain-specific training for optimizing
clinical diagnostic reasoning tasks. | [
-0.1553629637,
-0.5737943649,
0.7791417241,
0.0212195292,
-0.1900567263,
0.0455066748,
-0.1862512231,
-0.2504537404,
-0.2714124322,
0.2398557365,
-0.4874896109,
-0.4641169906,
-0.7895990014,
0.2724513412,
-0.457667172,
0.913174808,
-0.1126918048,
0.547113657,
-0.7132056952,
-0.3277290165,
-0.5601932406,
-0.80292207,
-0.8284571767,
-0.4805172682,
0.0550373606,
0.0999485329,
0.515253365,
0.5219473243,
0.7371669412,
0.2468427718,
0.3956831098,
0.3012850583,
-0.19082582,
0.271758765,
0.0261645708,
-0.5290664434,
-0.597586453,
-0.186907813,
0.3256230056,
0.9326505661,
-0.1918261647,
-0.1560890824,
-0.3459089696,
0.5775860548,
-0.5059403777,
0.3848207593,
-0.1029685587,
-0.1139978394,
-0.2180420011,
-0.0813029557,
-0.5076929927,
-0.0440857336,
0.0387210473,
-0.7585745454,
0.6081880927,
-0.3435210586,
0.5217054486,
0.6435511708,
-0.4163493216,
0.0807514638,
-0.62403965,
0.7792553902,
-0.7035596371,
0.3830100596,
0.5173683763,
0.4979152083,
0.0949525684,
-0.8851569891,
-0.4698511362,
-0.2135718465,
-0.1116725728,
0.3452763259,
-0.2304868251,
0.0594868734,
0.253118813,
0.1564298272,
-0.8446550369,
0.0308795366,
-0.109829098,
0.1165435836,
0.8651064038,
0.4971584678,
0.2161233574,
0.3759566545,
-0.248750478,
-0.0589756705,
-0.6748056412,
-0.1748303771,
-0.5020939708,
0.1635216624,
-0.1408848614,
0.2072155029,
-0.1536485404,
0.7822945118,
0.0243521929,
-0.5694978237,
0.2868721783,
-0.3975477219,
-0.2808432579,
-0.1289219558,
0.7678683996,
0.3071400821,
0.2861492634,
-0.2684590518,
-0.1401393861,
0.635238409,
0.6317697167,
-0.4426907897,
-0.1829167753,
0.3890357316,
-0.6253312826,
-0.0409647711,
-0.2327977568,
-0.4126868248,
-0.4887329042,
-0.4810431898,
0.0298057199,
-0.6644908786,
-0.216840446,
0.2618881464,
-0.2655011714,
-0.213626653,
0.6593837142,
-0.681771338,
0.5516948104,
0.5243452787,
0.4738234878,
-0.2860753238,
-0.403870225,
-0.493676126,
0.2021348774,
-0.3511447608,
1.0123924017,
-0.6574246883,
-0.6642712355,
0.0002501069,
-0.0796747655,
-0.5883490443,
-0.9010611176,
0.3932563961,
-0.0790366232,
-0.0722389147,
-0.0071484135,
-0.5741286874,
-0.0697590113,
0.189735204,
-0.4113891125,
1.0087288618,
0.6022752523,
-0.2383245528,
0.4624687731,
-0.5931168795,
-0.8444418907,
0.3574721217,
-0.3986088932,
-0.3205010593,
0.016445104,
0.4302961826,
0.5067661405,
-0.7485632896,
0.4065493643,
-0.1347650141,
-0.2339040488,
0.0940380916,
-0.0701891407,
0.6389917731,
0.085357368,
-0.4452878833,
0.1476766318,
-0.8123349547,
0.0875912979,
0.2444462031,
-0.1205406338,
-0.3121652603,
-0.0042690434,
-0.183752194,
0.1927635521,
-0.168542251,
-0.3533128798,
0.1081780717,
-0.2854058444,
0.3656066656,
0.2516548038,
-0.0350207761,
0.1130420119,
-0.6909653544,
0.8225374818,
0.1684902906,
0.1318165511,
-0.1439277083,
-0.7948366404,
-0.6256197691,
-0.4958944321,
0.0240470506,
0.7038198113,
-0.5338494182,
0.1086312085,
-0.0109407455,
-0.5115824938,
-0.7141219974,
-0.1443921924,
0.7172185183,
0.5876323581,
0.6423698068,
-0.4204290211,
-0.1695296019,
-0.7670275569,
-0.0052738157,
-0.0144268787,
0.2376673073,
0.2872612774,
0.6334012747,
-0.3198670149,
0.5384426117,
-0.4755837321,
-0.5849933624,
-0.5429267287,
0.1771906763,
0.057234291,
0.4728755355,
0.6956917048,
-0.683873713,
-0.7512326241,
0.151503846,
-1.049058795,
0.1145067066,
-0.2222464532,
0.2574851811,
0.0811801478,
0.5573913455,
-0.9278290272,
0.7988862395,
0.1603796035,
-0.0750524849,
0.7699146271,
-0.4936567545,
0.3128806651,
-0.8175452948,
0.1015224606,
0.1774160564,
-0.2704317868,
-0.9062032104,
0.204811886,
0.1640766114,
-0.1754936576,
-0.1085193008,
0.607775569,
-0.3116886914,
0.1089474559,
-0.3008074462,
0.0561529994,
0.1032629162,
0.3217754662,
0.1482748389,
0.9668604732,
0.8153861761,
-0.7348800898,
0.4932153821,
0.5243076682,
-0.2318733633,
0.8544716239,
-0.6697978973,
0.0558060743,
-0.2121617347,
0.2111855894,
-0.7885097265,
-0.1032803729,
-0.1354891211,
-0.3200544417,
0.4784389734,
0.1496606171,
-0.5094386935,
-0.5788156986,
0.1836354136,
0.5876185298,
0.4539674819,
-0.3089098334,
0.4451274872,
0.3717244864,
-0.2356813252,
-0.4892513156,
-0.6008150578,
-0.1839949042,
-0.1132624447,
-0.3997060359,
0.6901711822,
-0.1768816262,
-0.4399276078,
-0.123999007,
0.0707676709,
-0.3245559931,
0.1553685665,
0.1918583512,
0.0719280317,
-0.2877337933,
0.3327916861,
0.1568875313,
-0.3868763447,
0.1240807697,
-0.0256683715,
0.4611329138,
-0.1197615936,
-0.7013536096,
-0.6992706656,
0.7198057175,
0.7177627683,
-0.4890758097,
0.6200701594,
0.2431290895,
-0.5120111704,
-0.3457034826,
-0.3169874847,
-0.169105202,
-0.2925208211,
0.4482650757,
-0.5247390866,
-0.4333220422,
0.3029810488,
-0.1977536082,
-0.2044828087,
0.6981443167,
0.8360866904,
-0.1360788345,
1.4431574345,
0.5726840496,
0.1183478162,
-0.2554802597,
-0.2779033184,
0.3657511175,
-0.6297044754,
-0.2495215237,
-0.6050838232,
0.1574275047,
-0.0026510102,
-0.3863997757,
0.6361626387,
0.013184147,
-0.3810531795,
0.0870748162,
-0.6601835489,
0.1481029689,
0.7322428823,
0.233415097,
0.2973078787,
-0.4191577435,
-0.1521711648,
0.2071253508,
-0.8717318177,
-0.2908507884,
1.3156827688,
0.0441706479,
0.5139722824,
0.0719807819,
0.5170848966,
0.3493683338,
0.3849927783,
-0.5971085429,
0.3672553897,
-0.5542469621,
-0.4987235665,
-0.1715240479,
-0.073997736,
-0.8276693225,
0.2407857031,
0.007356571,
-0.4337482452,
0.096619226,
0.0067981384,
-0.5650879741,
0.066017732,
-0.661598146,
1.2348831892,
-0.3293401599,
0.1935104281,
-0.5544518232,
-0.8054769635,
0.1588326842,
-0.1427160501,
0.2684293985,
-0.1431019306,
0.2271054834,
0.4737879038,
-0.5639137626,
0.9716606736,
-0.181126684,
0.2425871193,
-0.0463529304,
-0.187724188,
0.2662152052,
0.1068479493,
0.0873747393,
0.0107720913,
0.2216768116,
-0.4078470767,
-0.4749414921,
0.2861640155,
-0.8750335574,
-0.6088316441,
-0.655612886,
-0.715231657,
-0.7556209564,
0.1489373893,
0.253217876,
0.7698491216,
-0.3294752836,
-0.318602562,
0.6636586189,
-0.113950938,
0.0723103955,
0.3991185129,
0.3814489245,
-0.0481797829,
0.6011632085,
-0.4860866368,
0.3434774876,
0.5402377844,
-0.0117825828,
-0.224173829,
-0.8634845018,
-0.6814041734,
0.3869821727,
-0.9406834245,
-0.3081241846,
-0.644724369,
-0.2723590136,
-0.5799371004,
-0.2213773429,
-0.2974612117,
-0.2128958255,
-0.3324200511,
0.2368742675,
0.2090204507,
0.7196263075,
0.2716863751,
0.1536170542,
-0.9384880066,
0.4420521259,
0.1533969045,
0.1970722228,
-0.0562546588,
-0.479005456,
-0.3474954069,
-0.0621070303,
-0.1810001582,
-0.6486006975,
0.4297346771,
0.4339042306,
0.939117074,
0.5278116465,
-0.0117495507,
0.7339508533,
-0.5966703892,
0.7477292418,
0.427144289,
-0.7240096331,
0.6334007978,
-0.1373181194,
0.4379286468,
0.4701246619,
0.586619854,
-0.5189569592,
-0.5614417791,
-0.5524433255,
-0.3228153884,
0.6314805746,
-0.2262965441,
-0.1253365278,
-0.2580060661,
0.2638361156,
0.4366040826,
0.244933635,
-0.138453871,
-0.5711664557,
-0.2510443926,
-0.3538632095,
-0.3199906349,
0.0142165124,
-0.6569862366,
-0.6084413528,
0.5570992827,
-0.4707298577,
0.6096046567,
0.1434065253,
-0.1916029006,
-0.0747792572,
0.1037941873,
0.7849178314,
0.9801469445,
0.06319049,
-0.1141422093,
-0.0026406609,
-0.50125283,
0.0789236724,
0.5783821344,
0.2110631317,
-0.0172805469,
0.6218845248,
0.8824301362,
-0.0481905788,
-1.0595520735,
0.6417758465,
-0.1110713258,
-0.5559391379,
-0.2333945632,
-0.0061241947,
-0.1246790662,
0.2894954681,
0.1928159595,
0.4016532004,
0.0667513311,
-0.3360809386,
0.2036212832,
0.4423391819,
-0.2513411045,
-0.2544565201,
0.9492379427,
0.095743522,
-0.0042590559,
0.8429895639,
-0.207684055,
-0.4434847236,
0.7656056881,
0.7962266803,
0.6762821078,
-0.2431589961,
0.434781611,
0.2686993182,
-0.0220008157,
-0.0725106075,
0.331974864,
0.1444940269,
-0.7544449568,
-0.4044314623,
-0.3062716722,
-0.4379040301,
0.0603907034,
-0.6637202501,
-0.1368706077,
-0.3306478858,
-0.2495913059,
0.2701817453,
-0.3602859676,
-0.6574726105,
0.6638316512,
0.0228261035,
0.7252517939,
-0.5082550645,
1.0590786934,
0.9919137359,
-0.602907002,
-0.5359513164,
-0.2493208796,
0.133896485,
-1.051473856,
0.6426359415,
-0.0293465089,
0.2307056636,
-0.1646397412,
-0.0618471615,
-0.7061322927,
0.8442403674,
0.1989375055,
-0.220561251,
-0.0108678192,
0.163592875,
0.7785531282,
-0.6408632994,
0.1540572196,
0.7761634588,
0.1494969577,
-0.2261229306,
-1.3174402714,
0.1186342016,
-0.5498151779,
-0.1789483279,
0.2865227163,
-0.3342648447,
1.1371403933,
-0.5129759908,
-0.154926613,
0.2490685731,
0.0066888211,
0.1691415012,
0.4275608957,
0.2558116615,
0.8256422877,
0.837957561,
-0.3305634856,
1.5570462942,
-0.4974695444,
0.0607066602,
0.8324311972,
-0.6217821836,
0.5516939163,
0.0671593845,
-0.5554945469,
0.5577975512,
0.4964958727,
0.0003971699,
0.7048099637,
-0.0436198302,
-0.5405712128,
-0.4822110236,
-0.0829935297,
-0.7417746186,
0.2477580309,
0.4700857401,
-0.2174219191,
-0.0914317667,
0.3065718114,
-0.2121876925,
0.2158563584,
-0.3166080415,
0.8250748515,
0.2226686925,
-0.8237316608,
0.9117208123,
-0.1009267718,
0.0124273021,
-0.5820679665,
-0.0167964753,
-0.2415308505,
0.6729769707,
0.020547783,
-0.4842206836,
0.2102614492,
-0.2547340393,
-0.3540872335,
-0.3439659774,
0.508795917,
-0.2613892853,
-0.2476166934,
0.2130343616,
0.8960053325,
0.0696848631,
-0.2275224775,
-0.8735233545,
-0.3759052157,
-0.312042743,
0.2676538527,
0.5205965042,
0.2233541906,
-0.2439790666,
0.8924880624,
0.4745236933,
-0.0176976342,
-0.1829296649,
0.7346686721,
0.8731922507,
-0.5763776302,
-0.4914597869,
-0.4140993059,
0.4226275682,
0.0120926714,
-0.5134890676,
0.3863200545,
0.3270354569,
0.7325293422,
-0.2295618504,
1.182749629,
0.0852501392,
0.805627048,
-0.1857866645,
0.5478659868,
-0.9222800136,
-0.1178127676,
-0.0589805581,
-0.2669629753,
-0.5967713594,
0.4965847135,
-0.108560957,
0.3127439916,
1.2994196415,
0.4532685578,
0.1950467229,
0.1731084734,
0.3292189837,
-0.0470167138,
0.2118092775,
0.7767392993,
0.695233047,
-0.2102572322,
0.1214520186,
-0.4811831713,
-0.4251042306,
-0.0893054381,
-0.331123203,
-1.0099321604,
-0.6399294138,
-0.4307839274,
-0.1942400336,
0.3219523132,
0.5998977423,
0.97486341,
-1.1324750185,
-0.2630037367,
-0.1605318189,
-0.3073483109,
-1.0661743879,
-0.1085228175,
0.5775521398,
-0.7123901844,
-0.521725595,
0.7820680737,
0.4382165074,
-0.0807589963,
-0.0259866118,
-0.1345633864,
-0.0734334737,
-0.3610418141,
0.6761327386,
0.2534534931,
-0.7933598757,
0.1314336509,
-0.0352151878,
-0.29371351,
0.2482844591,
0.9115475416,
-0.8924208283,
0.495960474,
0.0050070575,
0.7991242409,
0.5817270279,
0.0424307361,
0.7671744823,
-0.4473308623,
0.1541796476,
0.5748417377,
0.484285742,
0.1399483383,
-0.2351419181,
0.5895290375,
0.6103910208,
-0.483040452,
-0.7282090783,
0.1628316492,
-0.8917908669,
-0.5342724323,
0.8717960119,
-0.1808535606,
0.2336452901,
-0.589198947,
0.0248685572,
0.0402392782,
-0.1650129855,
0.6938854456,
0.3336472213,
-0.6921540499,
-0.2441310734,
-0.6079599261,
0.8930966258,
0.6231187582,
-1.2888531685,
-0.1028930098,
0.3871542513,
-0.0321620852,
0.0990007892,
1.0285402536,
0.0279925428,
0.9482271671,
0.2041387111,
-0.0287839845,
-0.0042704083,
-0.3605222404,
-0.0457589813,
0.1385649294,
0.0301918425,
-0.0756324902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04544v1 | Contrastive Bootstrapping for Label Refinement | 2023-06-07T15:49:04 | 2023-06-07T15:49:04 | Shudi Hou, Yu Xia, Muhao Chen, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional text classification typically categorizes texts into pre-defined
coarse-grained classes, from which the produced models cannot handle the
real-world scenario where finer categories emerge periodically for accurate
services. In this work, we investigate the setting where fine-grained
classification is done only using the annotation of coarse-grained categories
and the coarse-to-fine mapping. We propose a lightweight contrastive
clustering-based bootstrapping method to iteratively refine the labels of
passages. During clustering, it pulls away negative passage-prototype pairs
under the guidance of the mapping from both global and local perspectives.
Experiments on NYT and 20News show that our method outperforms the
state-of-the-art methods by a large margin. | [
-0.3319898546,
-0.6803139448,
0.4680314958,
-0.0955879837,
-0.4969357848,
0.234909758,
-0.3890628815,
-0.9123689532,
0.2221637666,
0.2021046877,
-0.466136694,
-0.7535768151,
-0.4434777498,
0.0741162598,
-0.5288820267,
1.4352238178,
-0.0283004045,
-0.0490517989,
-0.2199446559,
-0.2720331848,
-0.0298654065,
-0.1393895298,
-0.6482240558,
-0.5439087749,
0.7354885936,
0.6007535458,
0.5495998263,
0.5297297239,
0.4949068129,
0.2962942719,
-0.4612614512,
-0.2642610669,
-0.4520024359,
0.1549992561,
-0.2658427656,
-0.4842226803,
-0.0336032361,
0.2293445617,
0.4797823429,
0.8142740726,
-0.0083675273,
0.3835907876,
0.2892945409,
0.6682004333,
-0.7852594256,
-0.1330329776,
-0.6508414149,
0.0617536753,
-0.3582059443,
-0.3057796657,
-0.4375583231,
-0.4462430477,
0.2836806178,
-0.7745041847,
0.7061582208,
0.2113053203,
1.0065618753,
0.1191319451,
-0.165019691,
-0.273594141,
-0.6450624466,
0.82986027,
-0.6083241105,
0.1231704429,
0.3999513686,
0.419567138,
0.2975538671,
-0.9383111596,
-0.2064097971,
-0.2626897395,
-0.476243794,
-0.1007904783,
0.0561999828,
-0.1416473687,
-0.1805087775,
0.7216502428,
-0.3437745273,
0.4079346955,
-0.624492228,
-0.1075494662,
0.4150962234,
-0.0245809518,
-0.1406196803,
0.0970616341,
-0.7774318457,
0.0252599381,
-0.5239052773,
0.0798667967,
-0.0322166979,
0.6384908557,
-0.1255668253,
0.1125981286,
-0.5230620503,
0.7187843919,
0.2914479375,
-0.3063229322,
0.4364928305,
-0.1960226893,
-0.2741435468,
0.173470825,
0.6538516879,
0.7174420357,
-0.0988932922,
-0.4484396577,
-0.2860864401,
-0.0708118156,
0.32128492,
-0.9926883578,
-0.1411938965,
0.0770241693,
-0.5517732501,
-0.7722792625,
-0.0939484462,
-1.0329426527,
-0.5686209798,
-0.4968516231,
0.6453751922,
-0.0726306513,
0.3443408906,
-0.1571393609,
-0.1044228896,
0.1914352328,
0.4920178056,
-0.8447726965,
0.5702476501,
0.4313007891,
0.8999421,
-0.2146103084,
0.0491820611,
-0.5832325816,
-0.0237684511,
-0.2742782831,
1.0366210938,
-0.8170101047,
0.0226078406,
-0.1006096601,
0.1067592204,
0.3569153845,
-0.6969999075,
0.5062696934,
-0.4293814301,
0.0165890232,
-0.2160713673,
-0.2334422767,
-0.2366161495,
0.6918045282,
-0.4607844651,
1.138953805,
0.2326711416,
-0.8527383208,
0.4701829851,
-0.0970207155,
-0.4264521897,
0.0000685178,
-0.3166714311,
-0.5592112541,
0.0151028298,
0.1581846774,
0.6684134007,
-0.61231637,
0.311131686,
-0.2067660689,
-0.7055881023,
0.0282347407,
-0.168225348,
0.3810559213,
0.2668251097,
-0.4553641975,
0.2742951512,
-1.2452831268,
-0.1741588265,
-0.079872638,
-0.2870633304,
-0.74360919,
-0.1134999543,
0.3345855772,
0.2236680537,
0.0351811349,
-0.5723165274,
0.2068840414,
-0.2960587442,
0.3605296016,
0.5906105042,
-0.1025708541,
0.6715530157,
-0.365496695,
0.3418076336,
0.1800510585,
-0.1389092952,
-0.2681347132,
-0.3038038313,
-0.9588996768,
-0.0896591023,
0.7734106779,
0.387937963,
-0.7637541294,
0.2628905773,
-0.0810633972,
-0.901981771,
-0.6997438669,
-0.1203861386,
0.4225875437,
0.7145373225,
0.7819248438,
-0.2727136016,
-0.0796948522,
-1.0005450249,
-0.1903347075,
0.2626942694,
-0.1462042481,
-0.0458803698,
0.3670189083,
-0.334110111,
0.6616359949,
-0.7257879376,
-0.3536929488,
0.1622050256,
0.6073961258,
-0.3984693289,
0.8304057121,
0.3247929513,
-0.8425126076,
-0.4501960278,
0.2066742778,
-0.2851538956,
-0.3839131296,
-0.3195455968,
-0.079798013,
0.0061876238,
1.0593680143,
0.1597074717,
0.5551003814,
0.3118641078,
-0.3293862641,
0.5028302073,
0.0309514329,
0.2184567451,
-0.9577899575,
0.200712353,
0.4068827331,
-0.3152652383,
-0.5031589866,
0.3981885612,
-0.0217395201,
0.0233680569,
-0.1801742166,
0.5819106102,
-0.3401238024,
0.1486946642,
-0.2706991732,
0.4167928398,
0.110117346,
0.2132962495,
0.2072334588,
0.5113790631,
0.4381369948,
-0.7146567702,
0.0307100844,
-0.1670810729,
-0.2923919857,
0.7468006015,
-0.2918548584,
-0.2133356631,
-0.3205038905,
0.4288241565,
-1.2707864046,
0.0625516102,
0.3365294039,
-0.0197824407,
0.5292792916,
-0.0208583847,
-0.3898145556,
0.0421152301,
-0.554599762,
0.5664851665,
0.3862799406,
-0.626024127,
0.2644253671,
-0.0723085552,
-0.3298455775,
-0.2869615853,
-0.8068887591,
-0.1309839934,
-0.3295549154,
-0.0914011821,
0.789272666,
0.0142659321,
-0.2720445096,
-0.2319300324,
-0.3764972389,
-0.3213867247,
0.0302054267,
0.1117839441,
0.0253702309,
-0.114569813,
0.3941094577,
0.1477034688,
-0.3773747087,
-0.2883530259,
-0.1126582101,
0.2415871769,
-0.1438537389,
0.0811221674,
-0.3643217683,
0.2999123931,
0.3235278726,
-0.137051627,
0.5680890083,
1.0438216925,
-0.2453380376,
-0.2063938826,
-0.7050446272,
-0.2981499434,
-0.5031433702,
0.0196309108,
-0.1403405964,
-0.9863551855,
0.4223466814,
-0.4078920782,
-0.0736781061,
0.6128566265,
0.0819340944,
-0.084804371,
0.1538021564,
0.8167893291,
0.1366769969,
0.3079803586,
-0.0308973547,
-0.0052281464,
-0.6342388988,
-0.4564803839,
-1.0494865179,
-0.8131910563,
-0.9287121296,
-0.5090517402,
0.0222435426,
0.070233576,
-0.0318473093,
0.2257207632,
-0.9185336828,
0.6798329353,
0.6327649355,
0.141147092,
0.4284098744,
0.1264361143,
-0.172911644,
-0.2515824139,
-0.3544502854,
-0.5577970147,
0.661192596,
0.1757163256,
0.8933087587,
-0.4424354434,
0.9223815203,
-0.0641301945,
0.7972208858,
-0.85456568,
0.4935231805,
-0.1561184973,
-0.5180255175,
0.0277303383,
-0.4605359733,
-0.8606270552,
0.3303842843,
-0.3922223747,
-1.0073899031,
0.4193169475,
-0.0045195501,
-0.3360542953,
0.299315542,
-0.7540498972,
0.7601596713,
0.3783944547,
-0.3421328068,
0.0623667724,
-1.0321176052,
0.1829906404,
-0.2861029804,
0.4505693018,
0.0496159829,
-0.147288397,
0.909503758,
-0.3544659913,
1.1499444246,
0.0995503962,
-0.3149216771,
0.3638495505,
0.0127862822,
0.2530969381,
-0.2676959038,
0.0601945221,
-0.0902762786,
0.0701791868,
-0.5210790038,
-0.3944379389,
0.6859978437,
-0.2482482195,
-0.1311423182,
-0.4633481205,
-0.1131002009,
-0.2590256631,
0.1742246747,
0.6019703746,
0.5598279834,
-0.1766415834,
0.2107047588,
0.3916737139,
-0.0549770668,
0.5205312371,
0.5542097688,
-0.1039123982,
-0.3010154963,
1.1116329432,
0.2416606396,
0.2784187198,
0.7784090042,
0.4277462959,
-0.0197171792,
-0.6943913102,
0.0163216554,
-0.0022923083,
-0.8426706791,
-0.452506423,
-0.0925460607,
-0.074154444,
-0.0268969219,
-0.7261801362,
-0.2721381485,
-0.4943308532,
-0.2996293008,
-0.0082118781,
0.0956268758,
0.8177694082,
0.145878166,
0.6763719916,
-0.7778423429,
0.3845101893,
0.3254775703,
0.5332446098,
0.0753015354,
-0.3826491535,
-0.3820008039,
-0.4623799622,
-0.6048973799,
-0.8101807833,
0.0473463237,
-0.0623344146,
0.1071940064,
0.5515757799,
0.3470821083,
0.7376756072,
-0.6671918631,
0.7948144078,
0.3010930717,
-0.7842755914,
0.4881769121,
-0.1698231101,
0.3591931462,
1.1218193769,
0.5379203558,
-0.4740528762,
-0.5225095749,
-0.6461573243,
-1.1919226646,
0.4416210055,
0.2067326158,
-0.2091460079,
-0.0627084896,
0.5072212219,
0.6027474403,
0.3455016017,
-0.9791408777,
-0.3707068264,
0.2505082488,
-0.1401502639,
-0.2750888765,
-0.1615776271,
0.0201882068,
-0.4535046518,
0.7819002867,
-0.0553002544,
-0.1432665139,
0.2679333687,
0.1402916163,
0.0466001183,
0.8008699417,
0.5315669775,
0.5058482885,
-0.291600436,
0.6485708356,
-0.0156758092,
-0.4982501268,
0.3811528981,
0.4369590878,
-0.5406928658,
0.1339012235,
0.1670412272,
0.2788567543,
0.6400350332,
-0.4521599114,
0.3557151258,
0.2343704402,
-0.1558968872,
0.3474268615,
-0.1799796075,
-0.1040918455,
0.194665134,
0.2865487933,
0.4685969651,
0.5628748536,
-0.4705207944,
0.1058710068,
0.1447548866,
-0.5595188737,
-0.1797928214,
0.3576133251,
0.4424298406,
-0.2055865824,
0.1216233298,
-0.5426796675,
-0.2242678404,
0.3193125427,
0.7132374644,
0.9059434533,
-0.1549373269,
0.3117890656,
0.4541156888,
0.3867089152,
-0.2268198282,
-0.2476040721,
-0.3667213321,
-0.1950506121,
-0.3463086188,
-0.6868024468,
-0.3855484724,
0.3089609146,
-0.9832786918,
0.1130684391,
-0.3766443729,
-0.0260131061,
0.2265193611,
-0.0038606375,
-0.4473358691,
0.7440257072,
0.2366522402,
0.8579046726,
-0.9326453805,
0.3986352384,
0.7570760846,
-0.159344852,
-0.3341109455,
0.4983126819,
-0.0348017439,
-0.3500401974,
0.4453883767,
0.7418463826,
-0.3821009696,
-0.142915234,
-0.7639164925,
-0.5207006335,
1.0791851282,
0.0351145528,
-0.8578209281,
-0.1129516885,
-0.2592256367,
0.5237116814,
-0.1752801985,
-0.1350072771,
0.5590862036,
0.3524278104,
0.2129975706,
-0.7968984842,
0.2042300403,
-0.251871556,
0.06704925,
0.2367194742,
-0.7097678185,
0.5555294156,
-0.0052158562,
-0.1030798331,
0.1594014913,
0.4759374857,
0.0205305181,
0.7859296799,
0.3734523654,
0.6707673669,
0.8986078501,
-0.2105907947,
0.7337493896,
0.0585121848,
0.3970247507,
1.2536127567,
0.0998636484,
1.073355794,
0.7309362292,
-0.1470602155,
0.8348811269,
0.6619175076,
-0.0140460823,
0.5898768902,
0.4790103137,
-0.266985327,
-0.1489488035,
-0.0609830953,
-0.4022517502,
0.1470631212,
0.2488199025,
-0.4549303353,
-0.6300075054,
-0.0581349134,
0.0331730135,
0.3306105733,
-0.5927148461,
0.7201189399,
0.0815249309,
-0.5678501725,
0.5996828675,
0.3059369922,
1.0289683342,
-0.2892481685,
-0.0114890784,
0.063370645,
0.1844329536,
-0.3468452692,
-0.4574148953,
0.1965443492,
-0.0340538397,
-0.0500953309,
-0.1291506588,
0.7685636878,
-0.5537241101,
-0.4631934464,
0.1025553271,
0.1223759875,
0.0704689696,
0.0107129039,
-0.4016161561,
0.0262009092,
-0.1444384903,
-0.2046328038,
0.481136024,
0.4485461414,
0.0321831442,
0.4528267682,
0.1799978465,
-0.2656407952,
-0.2187984884,
-0.0392777249,
0.8764025569,
-0.8111321926,
-0.7137285471,
-0.8090571165,
0.6767201424,
-0.1431788355,
-0.4208293259,
0.5480075479,
0.6606562734,
0.9222317338,
-0.0664702505,
0.4194163382,
0.2254321724,
0.4791618288,
-0.6672875881,
0.6017109156,
-0.6682760715,
0.316046685,
-0.5050644875,
-0.8556272984,
-0.4932050109,
0.7919206619,
-0.3559065461,
0.1008863747,
0.9580965638,
0.4251871109,
-0.1631601155,
-0.0221226774,
-0.0122392485,
0.0782424361,
-0.0112308767,
0.1709280759,
0.6029379964,
-0.5083643198,
0.5677981377,
-0.4043523073,
-0.2816236615,
-0.3000487685,
-1.0082924366,
-0.9492617249,
-0.6630571485,
-0.7777304649,
-0.3934803009,
-0.1575238109,
0.6921453476,
0.747789979,
-0.7006369829,
0.0677358881,
-0.2378458381,
-0.0446760692,
-0.2435837537,
-0.332954973,
0.2858501971,
-0.7835047841,
-0.4467526972,
0.1116314083,
0.1610792428,
0.3756605387,
-0.1616125554,
0.3354153633,
0.0082833124,
0.0157495569,
0.4921512902,
0.0975298434,
-0.5449842811,
-0.0678731799,
-0.5878629088,
-0.2431407869,
0.3876167238,
0.8289067149,
-1.0672688484,
0.3576845527,
0.195839107,
0.5565224886,
0.7909177542,
0.1503454149,
0.0719688907,
-1.2288070917,
0.2794885039,
0.1863432378,
-0.0300313849,
0.5338003635,
-0.0770127475,
0.4545463324,
0.2066780925,
-0.5093662143,
-0.6636045575,
0.0960524976,
-1.1344770193,
-0.5078316927,
1.1175152063,
0.0627132505,
-0.1696337163,
-0.045877777,
-0.4220723808,
-0.0375083312,
-0.386351496,
0.8535509109,
0.6579188108,
0.3588380814,
-0.0012619791,
-0.3367205262,
0.6477031112,
0.0425674058,
-1.0436848402,
0.0367831886,
0.3752222955,
0.3513397574,
0.6604347825,
0.8151008487,
-0.0489896685,
0.0350588709,
0.1685300618,
-0.1395982355,
0.2799717486,
-0.4640974104,
-0.3903213143,
0.3835111558,
0.0378695652,
-0.1546789259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04539v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04539v2 | Multimodal Learning Without Labeled Multimodal Data: Guarantees and Applications | 2023-06-07T15:44:53 | 2024-06-13T17:05:54 | Paul Pu Liang, Chun Kai Ling, Yun Cheng, Alex Obolenskiy, Yudong Liu, Rohan Pandey, Alex Wilf, Louis-Philippe Morency, Ruslan Salakhutdinov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IT, math.IT, stat.ML | In many machine learning systems that jointly learn from multiple modalities,
a core research question is to understand the nature of multimodal
interactions: how modalities combine to provide new task-relevant information
that was not present in either alone. We study this challenge of interaction
quantification in a semi-supervised setting with only labeled unimodal data and
naturally co-occurring multimodal data (e.g., unlabeled images and captions,
video and corresponding audio) but when labeling them is time-consuming. Using
a precise information-theoretic definition of interactions, our key
contribution is the derivation of lower and upper bounds to quantify the amount
of multimodal interactions in this semi-supervised setting. We propose two
lower bounds: one based on the shared information between modalities and the
other based on disagreement between separately trained unimodal classifiers,
and derive an upper bound through connections to approximate algorithms for
min-entropy couplings. We validate these estimated bounds and show how they
accurately track true interactions. Finally, we show how these theoretical
results can be used to estimate multimodal model performance, guide data
collection, and select appropriate multimodal models for various tasks. | [
-0.4261115789,
-0.5924427509,
0.5856653452,
0.144066751,
-0.1371099204,
0.0945638046,
-0.4084038436,
-0.7680494189,
0.1698270142,
-0.0123075712,
-0.552295208,
-0.1598350257,
-0.3998227417,
-0.098619245,
0.0837623477,
0.720359087,
0.0507283732,
0.1038207039,
-0.7736875415,
-0.3642229438,
-0.2119863927,
-0.518014431,
-0.1072600037,
-0.3464467525,
0.7318114638,
0.172591269,
0.5258066058,
0.2646382153,
0.4624889195,
0.4033298194,
0.1089157909,
0.4543790221,
-0.0628864914,
0.0461634919,
0.0678765476,
-0.2761413753,
-0.3196417987,
0.1725821197,
0.4296556413,
0.8062195778,
0.2589345276,
0.2745928764,
0.0398285985,
0.2967877984,
-0.7831650972,
0.4106520116,
0.0152163273,
0.4883308113,
-0.2724624574,
-0.3993194401,
-0.6629464626,
0.321388334,
0.0105299652,
-0.6533791423,
-0.0540027171,
-0.1271601617,
0.6777749658,
0.4094550312,
-0.9974436164,
0.0287200585,
-0.6788409948,
0.99936831,
-0.2909447849,
0.5837826133,
0.597186327,
0.1306952983,
-0.0058074519,
-0.4513964355,
-0.5599856973,
-0.1766201556,
-0.254935503,
0.1743644774,
-0.2865312099,
0.5385644436,
0.2479575574,
0.192851603,
-0.2603290677,
0.084641926,
-0.5019735694,
-0.5657185316,
0.4932992458,
0.1697262675,
0.3157850206,
-0.2720850706,
-0.6546908021,
-0.1268244684,
-0.1563435644,
0.3591582775,
0.1923980564,
-0.0482770279,
-0.4278675318,
0.8623622656,
0.1305690259,
0.6660381556,
0.0133285746,
-0.0532993488,
0.2862369418,
-0.8185559511,
-0.164527595,
-0.1878314614,
0.9547129273,
0.4713948071,
-0.034329541,
-0.4903526306,
0.0140362801,
0.143584013,
-0.0425803699,
-0.4432204068,
-0.2787144184,
0.0209097266,
-0.3063349724,
-0.2439578325,
0.0484004095,
-0.7736142278,
-0.3559730351,
-0.6256787181,
0.8286427855,
-0.1462946832,
-0.2293816358,
-0.3290915191,
-0.3154773712,
-0.2749307752,
0.2723273933,
-0.7019972205,
0.0274303351,
0.1084852889,
0.7697710991,
-0.0047880644,
-0.5303238034,
-0.6647212505,
0.4947020113,
-0.1945731491,
0.3706170619,
-0.669708848,
-0.0581962541,
-0.3231671751,
-0.0284730587,
-0.2223079354,
-0.1379680037,
0.0866660625,
-0.5912715793,
0.2106061727,
0.0147141693,
-0.7072607279,
-0.0948260799,
-0.0097558452,
-0.8149245977,
0.7130888104,
-0.1413347274,
-0.8458259106,
0.2668510079,
-0.5755426288,
-0.6527662873,
-0.3103972971,
-0.0638899282,
-0.270404458,
0.2836298943,
-0.2217001319,
0.448771745,
-0.0595598556,
0.4040577114,
-0.7721844316,
-0.0374859013,
0.5182766914,
-0.6233417392,
0.5802643895,
0.250670284,
0.0112724919,
0.1376466602,
-0.7666368484,
0.1406119466,
-0.2949564159,
-0.6069122553,
-0.4117062688,
-0.296535939,
0.0575719997,
0.2286376059,
0.4317933321,
-0.5726144314,
0.014136781,
0.4601532221,
0.4627550542,
0.7514594197,
-0.0972381458,
0.5602220893,
-0.2026879191,
0.2641118169,
0.2700549364,
0.1493295729,
-0.1866452396,
-0.2368418127,
-0.4878997207,
-0.5420308113,
0.6562382579,
0.053813003,
-0.9224480987,
0.1216741949,
-0.0808297694,
-0.3451848626,
-0.4541317821,
0.2622310221,
0.5016621351,
0.2367403954,
0.4548290074,
-0.2307240367,
-0.8824710846,
-0.8087315559,
0.046053905,
-0.0116044823,
-0.048863031,
0.3243023455,
0.3098883331,
-0.1933880895,
1.0663547516,
-0.242719695,
-0.2841361165,
0.0499048308,
0.709327817,
-0.2691579461,
0.4439581931,
0.3772197366,
-1.0453003645,
-0.3319664896,
0.0255580805,
-1.1209161282,
0.0725140199,
-0.1213666648,
0.1887625903,
0.0951585099,
0.3364352286,
-0.5508750081,
0.5281445384,
0.7015379071,
0.1108355373,
0.0463869236,
-0.5443692803,
0.2372954488,
-0.7706993818,
-0.0379992351,
0.3861870766,
-0.152921766,
-0.8271710873,
-0.3626976907,
0.1310085058,
0.0051553627,
-0.5426015854,
0.6757843494,
-0.6131619811,
-0.0771192834,
-0.0290361512,
-0.2074618489,
0.0850739703,
0.9498955607,
0.330096066,
0.427713722,
0.6114187241,
-0.7000932693,
0.4084499776,
0.0855534077,
-0.1672478467,
0.4006576836,
-0.4051553607,
-0.0406665988,
0.0104292994,
0.2759412825,
-0.9468619227,
-0.5137227178,
0.1129344329,
-0.4013470709,
0.2001438588,
-0.5586189032,
-0.4487810731,
-0.0113169067,
-0.3748991787,
0.8207712173,
0.0794659108,
-0.5354007483,
0.6325668693,
0.5969353914,
0.2746138573,
-0.5737255812,
-0.727239728,
-0.1206475645,
-0.1615661234,
-0.5062202215,
0.1616968662,
-0.1257474124,
0.0355498977,
-0.0123167085,
-0.1843479872,
-0.3365398943,
-0.0551949851,
0.4985227287,
0.2966651618,
0.1818300784,
0.3071860671,
0.2244611084,
-0.1192885414,
-0.1131627783,
0.2819044888,
0.281868875,
-0.0286382623,
-0.5943762064,
-0.6415738463,
0.1319072247,
0.655682683,
-0.3280528188,
0.6269443631,
0.9403788447,
-0.505713284,
0.4508195519,
-0.2892527878,
-0.0787716135,
-0.4939484,
0.1303778291,
-0.422015816,
-0.619060576,
0.3631648123,
0.0811019912,
-0.2804602683,
0.0202935338,
0.3044337928,
-0.4267204702,
1.2100448608,
0.5733022094,
0.1678562462,
0.585819006,
-0.0612564534,
0.0623714887,
-0.8467532396,
-0.6440666318,
0.0455809832,
-0.6033533812,
-0.7033808827,
-0.3716904819,
0.6837177873,
0.1262214482,
0.1337149143,
0.2550611198,
-0.0427879915,
0.4113724232,
0.7782204151,
0.355594039,
0.3281146288,
-0.0162717644,
-0.0904450789,
-0.1181462929,
-0.6862801909,
0.0429017544,
0.8613434434,
0.2184191942,
0.9775102735,
0.2740845084,
0.3796183169,
0.7065942287,
-0.0137003744,
-0.583625257,
0.4858834743,
0.1997949332,
-0.5975417495,
-0.2884574533,
-0.8537741899,
-1.080316186,
0.3157461584,
-0.3791491985,
-0.7561629415,
0.2752307951,
0.3402612507,
-0.1502272785,
0.2539053559,
-0.9860772491,
0.7909614444,
-0.4014958739,
-0.6980067492,
-0.2878247797,
-0.8875645399,
0.2721042037,
0.0637174323,
0.3015179038,
0.005696584,
0.1106605083,
0.8283260465,
-0.1571278721,
1.1223608255,
-0.1764731556,
0.0634507313,
0.2061269283,
0.0934159905,
0.0523676425,
0.0171943158,
0.5721625686,
0.2164372653,
0.4922145307,
-0.4860376716,
-0.3545353711,
0.471046418,
-0.7186703086,
-0.0570016541,
-0.4093030393,
-0.7748563886,
-0.3119003475,
0.2831501067,
0.2053928673,
0.8013569117,
0.1455915719,
0.2376931608,
0.6582164168,
0.0327816717,
0.6507054567,
0.2828154564,
-0.053608641,
-0.4641687572,
1.1502835751,
0.046301309,
0.2108003795,
0.6093457937,
0.0448659696,
-0.4597167373,
-0.0478969105,
-0.2991906703,
0.1807497591,
-0.465787977,
-0.1087460965,
-0.5244377255,
-0.0209629983,
-0.1263177693,
0.1381499767,
-0.2034834921,
-0.4875946641,
-0.3265996575,
0.1014380679,
0.0917778313,
0.4829034209,
-0.7657368779,
0.0415197909,
-0.9849239588,
0.2178685665,
0.5190900564,
0.2469801009,
0.0821895227,
-0.1113118231,
-0.5265368223,
0.4946689308,
-0.2692694366,
-0.776797235,
-0.0519239381,
0.2362294048,
0.4168566763,
0.5215438604,
0.2712688446,
0.7006725669,
-0.0986897424,
0.5483807921,
0.5549759269,
-0.8627341986,
0.2659086287,
-0.2497165501,
0.1260239929,
0.2588729858,
0.4911648631,
-0.4247627556,
-0.1461457908,
-0.5072131753,
-0.4807375968,
0.7797899246,
0.2642356157,
0.0008628083,
0.2180391252,
-0.1921236217,
-0.1924090683,
0.4909860492,
-0.6882064342,
-0.1610081941,
-0.0269181505,
-0.3225189149,
-0.1063626781,
-0.0618427247,
-0.5399858952,
-0.2451408654,
0.3255191743,
-0.1042395458,
0.3140587211,
-0.3093195558,
-0.6782777309,
-0.2286129743,
0.1430317611,
0.6994642615,
0.5882866383,
-0.2509167492,
0.6853970885,
-0.0314351432,
-0.1093104184,
0.2669788003,
0.1530138105,
0.2932696044,
-0.0257168468,
0.5447739363,
0.7566269636,
0.3257966936,
-0.8295719624,
0.6065128446,
-0.2211425304,
0.0443493798,
-0.1066022664,
0.0373239256,
-0.0950716585,
0.6557023525,
0.1993968487,
0.4219456017,
-0.0065380395,
-0.3770037889,
0.3833703399,
0.6136851907,
-0.525062561,
-0.7195342779,
0.6424925327,
0.154009968,
0.0732396618,
0.4663118422,
0.0201365501,
-0.2551245093,
0.4604207277,
0.0390358381,
0.169244051,
0.0884019285,
0.4140844941,
0.0616329089,
-0.117108129,
0.2999263108,
-0.1362127662,
-0.6994903088,
-0.7060713768,
-0.4560357034,
-0.2327198684,
-0.4686756134,
0.0910843164,
-0.9542751312,
0.0793425441,
-0.0092908619,
-0.4572597146,
0.3334073126,
-0.0460589938,
-0.6330538392,
0.0557055771,
0.2848875225,
0.3278428912,
-0.9491773248,
0.5707994103,
0.8526017666,
-0.6226910949,
-0.3078811765,
-0.4014991224,
0.082581751,
-0.5644512773,
0.5292782187,
0.1389137059,
-0.1575519443,
-0.2157318145,
-0.4246697426,
-0.5059671998,
0.8878111243,
0.4906200767,
-0.0913767144,
0.0005445961,
0.2480879575,
0.3782686889,
0.1557731479,
0.3673822582,
-0.0700118691,
0.6752537489,
0.2419620156,
-0.8927862048,
-0.2607120275,
-0.4485299587,
-0.2541386783,
0.2608648539,
-0.6918622255,
0.4592167437,
-0.2720876634,
-0.0951658338,
-0.0318013094,
0.7163869739,
-0.1612252891,
0.780865252,
0.4775361121,
0.5298138261,
0.662884593,
-0.1117752269,
0.7225697041,
-0.0444411002,
0.6749426126,
1.1580526829,
0.0005339248,
0.2425608486,
0.6632793546,
-0.1999677718,
-0.1993762404,
0.9368667006,
-0.007683076,
0.6617949009,
-0.203899309,
-0.419821322,
-0.6202480197,
-0.5590375662,
-0.2460924089,
0.3924482763,
-0.0286830924,
-0.0651623234,
-0.1316687614,
0.4860115051,
-0.0710966885,
-0.3002248704,
-0.061854288,
0.8136318922,
-0.1832834184,
-0.4749957621,
0.3315608501,
-0.1745825112,
0.5974589586,
-0.4265810549,
0.0383568741,
-0.1571252644,
0.0590085611,
-0.3755390346,
-0.836610198,
-0.1384215951,
-0.2086326033,
-0.4680810571,
-0.0445219912,
0.5112521052,
-0.934751749,
-0.2796908319,
0.2642556727,
0.3845901787,
-0.0474901795,
0.3688641191,
-0.0855855867,
0.1431699693,
-0.0674552023,
-0.0932765231,
0.8301277161,
0.4481407404,
0.0825970471,
0.6394532323,
0.4372101128,
-0.3133116663,
0.4110103846,
-0.2461961806,
0.7321617007,
-0.2278074771,
0.069198519,
-0.6904717684,
0.560616374,
0.058273606,
-0.061107222,
0.5828069448,
0.5360095501,
0.9078530669,
-0.0704507753,
0.7070976496,
-0.2676867247,
-0.0874108672,
-0.740819931,
0.1119200289,
-0.9165015221,
0.00065594,
-0.1277736723,
-0.5040569305,
-0.198773846,
0.3821659386,
-0.1237538531,
0.1701556295,
0.4062883556,
0.524736762,
-0.5396189094,
0.0643334016,
0.4721931517,
-0.1266951114,
0.0733443275,
0.4995696843,
1.0252783298,
-0.131357193,
0.510984242,
-0.7485429049,
-0.2438227385,
-0.1334210634,
-0.7708038688,
-0.9779359102,
-0.9802331924,
-0.3879933953,
-0.1959844679,
-0.3149561584,
1.0083471537,
0.912769258,
-0.4055395424,
-0.1570358276,
0.3790248632,
0.2914242446,
-0.2968021929,
-0.1696076989,
0.2544363141,
-0.0513835661,
-0.7966132164,
0.3459430337,
0.1239480302,
0.3157909214,
-0.0896366313,
-0.3972817063,
-0.3352601826,
-0.0282507874,
0.6368999481,
0.5289549232,
-0.3008873165,
-0.2216660529,
-0.2767632902,
0.0946644247,
0.0777436718,
0.8314641714,
-0.4749108553,
0.7164969444,
0.4464132488,
0.5963848233,
0.739472568,
-0.1499746442,
0.2668010294,
-1.1424385309,
0.1630194038,
-0.0808357596,
0.3569617271,
0.1038097739,
-0.1094827428,
0.4508805573,
0.2932965159,
-0.2588216364,
-1.0415731668,
0.3125736117,
-1.1003204584,
-0.0352751948,
0.8431738019,
-0.2075021565,
-0.0938697904,
0.2566053271,
0.1856820881,
0.5881937742,
-0.2403209656,
0.6274528503,
0.6601713896,
-0.5814457536,
-0.4351637065,
-0.2957167327,
0.2694387138,
0.2543896437,
-0.6818847656,
-0.1601176411,
0.6746006012,
-0.0277137812,
0.3922879398,
0.1633483022,
0.2007318437,
0.1943002045,
-0.2587016225,
0.0764364228,
-0.4576577246,
-0.664098978,
0.027824169,
0.05492099,
-0.2826245725,
-0.5140182972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04537v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04537v1 | Long-form analogies generated by chatGPT lack human-like psycholinguistic properties | 2023-06-07T15:42:31 | 2023-06-07T15:42:31 | S. M. Seals, Valerie L. Shalin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Psycholinguistic analyses provide a means of evaluating large language model
(LLM) output and making systematic comparisons to human-generated text. These
methods can be used to characterize the psycholinguistic properties of LLM
output and illustrate areas where LLMs fall short in comparison to
human-generated text. In this work, we apply psycholinguistic methods to
evaluate individual sentences from long-form analogies about biochemical
concepts. We compare analogies generated by human subjects enrolled in
introductory biochemistry courses to analogies generated by chatGPT. We perform
a supervised classification analysis using 78 features extracted from
Coh-metrix that analyze text cohesion, language, and readability (Graesser et.
al., 2004). Results illustrate high performance for classifying
student-generated and chatGPT-generated analogies. To evaluate which features
contribute most to model performance, we use a hierarchical clustering
approach. Results from this analysis illustrate several linguistic differences
between the two sources. | [
-0.1776139289,
-0.828961134,
0.6312464476,
0.15911071,
-0.1452093273,
0.4869146645,
-0.3898221552,
-0.5633931756,
0.4873353839,
0.1353458762,
-0.4234091938,
-0.3915252686,
-0.1647880822,
0.3995805979,
-0.1927613467,
1.1002578735,
0.2042147964,
0.2091509104,
-0.2897539437,
0.0293953363,
-0.2141548991,
-0.8357266188,
-0.6401104927,
-0.7301026583,
0.5888540745,
-0.1546446532,
0.6412700415,
0.3108267784,
0.5183653235,
0.2880994081,
-0.270011276,
-0.5552046299,
-0.4572539628,
-0.1709786952,
-0.1222437844,
-0.3282367885,
-0.6029387116,
0.2076633871,
0.6210668087,
1.0275335312,
-0.0625179708,
0.0427724496,
0.0964555666,
0.6137458086,
-0.234887898,
0.5392110944,
-0.2713222206,
0.1695232093,
-0.0388469696,
-0.1556420922,
-0.3963709772,
-0.3892283738,
0.3309151232,
-0.4698286653,
0.3853576779,
-0.0121809691,
0.863761425,
-0.0640126467,
-0.1097590923,
-0.5009399056,
-0.4269829988,
0.526687026,
-0.7852753997,
0.4145275056,
0.1992999762,
0.176357165,
-0.3731557727,
-0.4807269871,
-0.7476844192,
-0.7374593616,
-0.344104141,
0.353125155,
0.0062633273,
0.5207090974,
0.1358283907,
0.3256923854,
-0.7955445051,
0.2550566196,
-0.6248539686,
-0.2892438769,
0.5558086634,
0.1035624743,
0.4483779371,
-0.5592045188,
-0.4425643981,
-0.3286432326,
-0.4093676805,
0.051449988,
0.464525491,
0.2626445591,
-0.1144526675,
0.5901237726,
0.0912818983,
0.1670209467,
-0.233124122,
-0.2321478575,
0.2200444639,
-0.1373326629,
-0.2158374041,
0.333414495,
1.0159282684,
0.2326902002,
0.5196674466,
-0.3496013582,
0.0868947655,
0.3213579059,
-0.0485499054,
-0.8507534266,
-0.4489340484,
0.1883838326,
-0.4578718245,
-0.1573956013,
-0.1009267718,
-1.0234718323,
-0.140479818,
-0.20151034,
0.4656490088,
-0.4592023492,
0.0301629249,
0.1133556217,
-0.3547444046,
0.2412588596,
0.0136848921,
-0.9041386247,
0.9194432497,
0.4789949358,
0.8787617683,
-0.6704206467,
-0.3428805172,
0.0148028554,
0.0374316536,
-0.0592325479,
0.7145116329,
-0.5375988483,
-0.3960533738,
-0.3189272583,
-0.0305730253,
-0.0741268247,
-0.9655339122,
0.3974785209,
-0.237548545,
0.2108944207,
0.0250074379,
-0.6998807192,
-0.134842664,
-0.3009732068,
-0.3675744832,
0.8903944492,
0.2118254751,
-0.4895463586,
0.2799347639,
-0.7223470807,
-0.2481931448,
0.192903161,
-0.4980280399,
-0.1815167665,
-0.0320584252,
-0.4283483028,
0.4499343932,
-0.1186723933,
0.3582898378,
-0.3508034945,
-0.3839611411,
0.6454833746,
-0.3189856708,
0.7703947425,
0.0859216005,
-0.096837759,
-0.0107804714,
-0.8102597594,
0.1836774647,
-0.0654724985,
-0.5239443779,
-0.1577840447,
0.0737743303,
0.217764318,
0.1102558598,
0.0252222866,
-0.6878346801,
0.0491895489,
-0.4221423864,
0.5828378201,
0.5024782419,
0.1300281733,
0.0567580611,
-0.2531319857,
0.5207633376,
-0.0127214435,
-0.5638663769,
0.0187019259,
-0.3783524334,
-0.6971105337,
-0.4887855351,
-0.0200155713,
0.6036747098,
-0.0892100334,
0.560908258,
-0.4905922413,
-0.6753191948,
-0.3203478456,
-0.0175088085,
0.3790689409,
0.2679974735,
0.3597316146,
-0.6054697633,
-0.354682833,
-1.2492781878,
-0.4097220898,
-0.2885809243,
-0.3884118795,
-0.1292336285,
0.6520704031,
-0.2326943874,
0.8308722973,
-0.572345674,
-0.0418048948,
0.0786409304,
0.1369213462,
0.1760693341,
0.236354053,
0.5443587899,
-0.2308233976,
-0.3789973855,
0.1691843569,
-0.8296913505,
-0.1211534739,
0.0798748955,
0.0136341657,
-0.1542416811,
0.4483884871,
-0.7517524958,
0.4053300917,
0.3091290295,
-0.2263676971,
0.804412961,
-0.2172591835,
0.1218097135,
-0.8345846534,
0.0612209812,
0.1227935925,
-0.1202841401,
-0.5796994567,
0.1228740364,
-0.3272798359,
-0.7314396501,
-0.2819553614,
0.6551636457,
-0.4857168198,
-0.0797981322,
-0.1074083149,
0.1058062464,
-0.0934985727,
0.663021028,
0.2075236887,
0.8215219975,
0.2909232676,
-0.426002264,
0.4825615287,
0.1899633408,
-0.1727990955,
0.2981516719,
-0.6938585639,
0.0254008174,
-0.021248363,
0.4163378477,
-1.2096267939,
-0.6781446338,
0.1754260212,
-0.3288494349,
0.2749668658,
0.1849450618,
-0.4998979867,
-0.1788226515,
-0.2943100035,
0.3728746772,
0.944337666,
-0.075179331,
0.1965679973,
0.0156064639,
-0.4627964497,
0.127709046,
-0.7008469105,
0.0096718976,
-0.5557046533,
-0.3872307241,
0.1399180442,
0.0966044292,
-0.2537869513,
-0.2174685001,
-0.0589899607,
-0.2583951652,
-0.0890286788,
0.1289416701,
0.0644632205,
-0.3970943093,
0.3438901901,
0.1047578454,
0.1097583994,
0.5249553323,
0.2591536641,
0.4302208126,
-0.2834510207,
-0.2318491191,
-0.5774256587,
0.4372209311,
0.824014008,
0.2898038626,
0.6816465855,
0.3677079976,
-0.1789280623,
0.2740952373,
-0.1499893963,
-0.4824523926,
-0.4245631695,
0.7037766576,
-0.2292234451,
-0.5460143089,
0.7254570127,
0.0121485656,
-0.4919700027,
0.3171706498,
0.5567974448,
-0.4592527151,
0.327670753,
0.2807931602,
0.2343234271,
0.1730068475,
0.132770136,
0.5005636811,
-0.6233480573,
-0.1108084917,
-0.3887039125,
-0.2370521873,
-0.8931003809,
-0.2753407061,
0.5829586387,
-0.0497059375,
-0.2771002352,
0.3699666858,
-0.0438030958,
0.3492124081,
0.0290658586,
0.4025273323,
0.2347380668,
0.5118534565,
-0.062520422,
-0.3109530509,
-0.700429678,
-0.7566176057,
0.8098623753,
0.5015608668,
0.7396457791,
0.3008996546,
0.546017468,
0.2493478358,
0.3976913095,
-1.0593221188,
0.7406215668,
-0.136457637,
-0.470962733,
-0.2314246744,
-0.4234303832,
-1.1835075617,
0.2167697698,
-0.3462560177,
-1.1364350319,
-0.0537540279,
-0.1802509427,
-0.108480081,
0.0799517483,
-1.0502618551,
0.6245096326,
-0.0588333644,
-0.2396068722,
-0.1887936443,
-0.6585083008,
0.275826335,
-0.4947425425,
0.0664532334,
-0.1585985422,
0.1686442792,
0.9622235894,
-0.3454598188,
1.0564386845,
0.3489419222,
-0.136021629,
0.3496873379,
0.2735378444,
-0.1971597821,
-0.3939343393,
-0.1973373741,
0.1909428537,
0.4012911618,
-0.752708137,
-0.8283706307,
0.3920774758,
-0.7447460294,
-0.6330363154,
-0.5083340406,
-0.4206464291,
-0.170400992,
0.1022347063,
0.2560626864,
0.3301511407,
-0.5971800089,
0.0498002768,
0.2152422667,
-0.4255445004,
0.4004466236,
0.1349621117,
-0.3014349043,
-0.1916255504,
0.8745295405,
-0.0776513219,
0.7498278022,
0.2554026842,
0.4993864298,
-0.1955459267,
-0.2087924331,
-0.2433560044,
0.4433500469,
-0.594617486,
0.1849438101,
-0.5694957376,
-0.4638238549,
-0.4699772,
-0.0476251617,
-0.0810833946,
-0.2808404565,
0.0239855535,
0.0594211929,
0.4832825065,
0.617967546,
0.1172716543,
0.4875326455,
-0.7763729692,
0.3305137157,
0.1225617006,
0.1865712553,
0.153059423,
-0.4106111825,
-0.0489979312,
0.0607130118,
-0.6849579215,
-1.2266777754,
0.3793335855,
0.5650995374,
0.4695127606,
0.2839516699,
-0.3908725381,
0.4610272646,
-0.4217007458,
0.7947595716,
0.3610814512,
-0.8763666153,
0.3437945247,
-0.6233314872,
0.0947662666,
0.4193409383,
0.5465208292,
-0.4853543341,
-0.4207235277,
-0.514307797,
-0.69551754,
0.0512782261,
0.6487566233,
0.1544363052,
-0.3857854009,
0.5406175852,
0.3134322464,
0.1362809986,
-0.8146986365,
-0.1850928217,
0.1455758512,
-0.398219645,
-0.2372006774,
0.011760721,
0.1346874982,
-0.3707687855,
0.3097246289,
0.043503318,
0.373159349,
0.2579670548,
0.0005547148,
0.0389472358,
0.6791881323,
0.4958153069,
0.5605934858,
-0.5421659946,
0.1527123898,
0.2381662726,
-0.8122040629,
0.4919843674,
-0.0662483275,
0.0751990005,
0.0495816953,
0.5630918741,
0.4114690125,
0.1917383671,
-0.9260434508,
0.2134299576,
0.2999758422,
0.0123259043,
-0.16552113,
0.2734402418,
0.3162998259,
0.0327270254,
0.1706048995,
0.0668916926,
0.3312709928,
-1.1052517891,
-0.0121023878,
0.2087838203,
-0.3623962998,
-0.5498450994,
0.4177004397,
0.0819463655,
-0.5317335129,
0.612193346,
-0.0972870216,
-0.4598950744,
0.7567178607,
0.6169739962,
0.9391543865,
-0.0847626105,
-0.0136545775,
0.3198435605,
-0.0914788023,
0.2201241702,
-0.0936892554,
0.1195576862,
-0.5341891646,
-0.3754204214,
-0.8628491759,
-0.2803372443,
0.2932212353,
-0.8061082363,
0.3543520272,
-0.3209706247,
-0.1367111951,
0.3920164704,
-0.2793391049,
-0.5750246048,
0.1168903857,
-0.1559973508,
0.4606529772,
-1.150859952,
0.5412712097,
0.8416674137,
-0.3958825767,
-0.6072043777,
0.0308302641,
-0.1041906402,
-0.4389055371,
0.9477342963,
0.1329440922,
-0.1228175238,
-0.1519721895,
-0.2536159456,
-0.4111980498,
0.7780137658,
0.4060555995,
-0.3418118656,
-0.1641115546,
0.4393844604,
1.1692515612,
-0.2003931552,
0.3189526498,
0.6210455298,
0.2056944817,
-0.1756029129,
-1.2427663803,
0.0470433161,
-0.2574734986,
-0.3186424077,
0.0873646364,
-0.579787612,
0.7314962149,
-0.1725948155,
-0.5141663551,
0.1851105839,
0.5519669056,
0.4080418944,
0.3956374824,
-0.0374733135,
0.3219905496,
0.6896573305,
0.3495082259,
1.0124237537,
0.1320302933,
0.6199683547,
1.0884921551,
-0.2348927259,
0.9451161623,
0.6507341862,
-0.8227629066,
0.5110009909,
0.7869077921,
0.03057901,
0.2814351022,
0.8991369009,
-0.3809692264,
0.1180401891,
0.1836626977,
-0.3340644538,
0.5479088426,
0.4868865311,
-0.4393728375,
-0.3602046371,
-0.1095500961,
-0.0231118575,
0.2137421668,
-0.0290533714,
0.650149703,
0.4118884206,
-0.3872824907,
0.7214807272,
-0.2731864154,
0.3957155049,
-0.4124407768,
-0.2791051865,
-0.064857766,
-0.0591150485,
-0.1660513431,
-0.7992473841,
0.2601983249,
-0.0720642582,
-0.1115712523,
0.165393576,
0.5262317061,
-0.4932784438,
-0.4768447578,
0.3811603785,
0.6540426612,
0.9266110659,
0.2506714761,
-0.2109493613,
-0.4769670665,
-0.2201841474,
0.1421246529,
0.387448281,
0.3113324642,
-0.1253857315,
0.7363055944,
0.4361661971,
0.2195198387,
0.0090107312,
-0.164231807,
0.5669329166,
-0.8213804364,
-0.2364674509,
-0.9975414872,
-0.1396944523,
0.2793672085,
-0.2516675591,
0.3947796822,
0.6971826553,
0.6571026444,
-0.5664382577,
0.67689991,
0.1861199141,
0.198651731,
-0.6605155468,
0.9295935035,
-0.2419876307,
0.0381242223,
-0.3875212371,
-1.287432313,
-0.0459337682,
0.5651779175,
-0.1830285043,
0.1961775571,
1.1562819481,
0.6907634735,
-0.4468298256,
-0.1602669507,
0.4844513237,
0.4309365749,
0.2417359501,
0.5553662777,
0.8530980349,
-0.4093916416,
-0.0833744556,
0.1315023005,
-0.0427168086,
-0.0140388329,
-0.9196015596,
-1.1847034693,
-0.4435931146,
-0.33209759,
-0.5516245365,
0.016054811,
1.0271192789,
0.4922306538,
-0.6381638646,
-0.6137522459,
-0.0126949539,
-0.4208253622,
0.0540747195,
-0.2840616405,
0.6128745675,
0.0119536649,
-0.329615593,
0.1562618762,
0.2686160207,
0.4191576242,
-0.365530014,
0.1302628219,
0.0209597629,
0.285292536,
0.6833199263,
0.1880113035,
-1.043263793,
-0.526830554,
-0.0292511489,
-0.2932822108,
0.4332012534,
0.6061515808,
-0.6234461665,
0.2565095127,
0.4915516675,
0.3857175708,
0.3287662268,
-0.0176818892,
0.6031783223,
-0.5283230543,
0.1872174144,
0.1693533659,
0.0047779367,
0.3046633303,
-0.2725620568,
0.3705133498,
0.3577588797,
-0.4104237258,
-0.3718853891,
0.2573637366,
-1.4900476933,
-0.1794565618,
1.0550431013,
-0.2075906843,
-0.3929357827,
0.02397177,
-0.3342829347,
0.3154024184,
-0.4531928301,
0.9354195595,
1.1172332764,
-0.4898623526,
0.1614503413,
-0.6867907047,
0.4062118232,
0.4941310287,
-1.0453615189,
-0.0874728188,
0.2557625175,
0.5213235021,
0.3007509112,
0.3583949804,
-0.0852535442,
0.079229705,
-0.0524141826,
0.2812696695,
0.5241849422,
0.2575933337,
-0.1135546565,
-0.070629172,
0.0074707102,
0.1594942063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04535v1 | PromptAttack: Probing Dialogue State Trackers with Adversarial Prompts | 2023-06-07T15:41:40 | 2023-06-07T15:41:40 | Xiangjue Dong, Yun He, Ziwei Zhu, James Caverlee | cs.CL | cs.CL | A key component of modern conversational systems is the Dialogue State
Tracker (or DST), which models a user's goals and needs. Toward building more
robust and reliable DSTs, we introduce a prompt-based learning approach to
automatically generate effective adversarial examples to probe DST models. Two
key characteristics of this approach are: (i) it only needs the output of the
DST with no need for model parameters, and (ii) it can learn to generate
natural language utterances that can target any DST. Through experiments over
state-of-the-art DSTs, the proposed framework leads to the greatest reduction
in accuracy and the best attack success rate while maintaining good fluency and
a low perturbation ratio. We also show how much the generated adversarial
examples can bolster a DST through adversarial training. These results indicate
the strength of prompt-based attacks on DSTs and leave open avenues for
continued refinement. | [
-0.3371126652,
-1.1035224199,
0.6201754808,
-0.3438578248,
0.0052802279,
0.2687337697,
0.1818094254,
0.0981819779,
0.2200716138,
0.4240548909,
-1.0198700428,
-0.2357980013,
-0.4716258347,
0.0824451149,
-0.3218826056,
1.3760032654,
0.3866762817,
0.1110829264,
0.1597124487,
0.0794989765,
-0.726937294,
-0.5141154528,
-0.9962820411,
0.1617801487,
0.4621892571,
-0.0062847557,
0.6793817878,
0.1100486666,
0.163751781,
0.3713281751,
-0.2293585837,
0.0109941214,
-0.5666657686,
0.6084058285,
0.0159995407,
-0.6036854982,
-0.3018591404,
0.2238889188,
0.3479477465,
0.1982185543,
0.0089499597,
-0.1255304515,
0.0706186891,
0.3092756867,
-0.4786427021,
0.0480667539,
-0.7387848496,
-0.2015806139,
-0.0052803266,
-0.3393988609,
-0.6363616586,
-0.5352045298,
0.4944408834,
-0.5314854383,
0.3287495077,
-0.0641084388,
0.5727428198,
0.3049515486,
-0.6147863269,
-0.4869756401,
-0.4175332189,
0.5327240229,
-0.7021440864,
-0.0478388742,
0.2000971138,
0.6311507821,
-0.6929264069,
-0.6551271081,
-0.3155679405,
-0.5660302639,
-0.1846394688,
0.1161250621,
-0.3984837234,
0.3476594985,
0.5739369392,
0.2378341705,
-0.7517668009,
-0.3620048463,
-0.1447604001,
-0.4634032249,
0.3966427147,
0.4279026389,
0.5485613942,
-0.2271393389,
-0.4756479561,
-0.0654023886,
-0.5860664248,
0.2657197416,
0.5785240531,
0.5233912468,
0.1687978208,
0.3304169178,
-0.1370085478,
0.7765992284,
0.3567087948,
-0.0115667665,
-0.321088016,
-0.3776033521,
-0.0376154631,
0.0941484421,
0.9204834104,
0.0714454204,
-0.1585769951,
-0.099185124,
-0.398824662,
0.1493187845,
0.5229167938,
-0.7294455171,
-0.5620226264,
0.1641188115,
-0.0793728307,
-0.8228064775,
-0.2177710831,
-0.7283152342,
-0.6912324429,
-0.1006845906,
0.6210510731,
-0.6903994679,
-0.0974616483,
-0.1816393286,
-0.2473017424,
0.0571666323,
0.3777651787,
-0.677893281,
0.2570089996,
0.6628637314,
1.0125082731,
0.0174941998,
-0.2163278908,
-0.9668394923,
-0.343115449,
-0.3750713766,
0.7471255064,
-0.2093574405,
-0.5904685855,
-0.0092214514,
-0.016011361,
-0.1054103896,
-0.0542025231,
0.3850898147,
-0.6428496242,
0.5710346103,
-0.4724663496,
-0.5231142044,
-0.245524615,
0.7177092433,
-0.6541016698,
0.7411352992,
0.0665298775,
-0.7039707899,
0.1625138074,
-0.8417173028,
-0.4231345952,
0.1334606707,
-0.1619794518,
-0.2634285688,
0.0847123042,
0.3400326073,
0.3027334511,
-0.0928168967,
0.341077894,
-0.2795746028,
-0.3087803721,
0.5451335907,
-0.8276885152,
1.2032493353,
0.185389787,
-0.4071750343,
0.0657808334,
-0.6512627602,
-0.0639050677,
0.2765137851,
0.004183956,
-0.3192586601,
-0.0450121351,
-0.4398088157,
-0.0501059853,
0.1733888835,
-0.5741567016,
0.2665556073,
-0.5696165562,
0.3704484403,
0.8597916961,
0.3951878846,
0.2744247615,
-0.2845160663,
0.9509961009,
-0.2402442843,
0.1521091759,
-0.7349695563,
-0.342871815,
-0.5383703113,
-0.4438869059,
-0.0802579075,
0.6552682519,
-1.0822685957,
0.1996252239,
0.1124541983,
-0.689021647,
-0.3315253854,
-0.4222493768,
0.6246478558,
0.8528670073,
0.2444854826,
-0.0461855866,
-0.3509074152,
-0.5685063601,
-0.4712090492,
-0.3455309868,
0.0343850963,
0.2261487693,
0.2731528282,
0.220935896,
1.0854830742,
-0.7404004931,
-0.0442973338,
-0.3177341223,
0.3695985377,
-0.0237482879,
0.2888585925,
0.637411654,
-0.6569764018,
-0.39879632,
-0.5718461275,
-0.6348071694,
0.0433521457,
-0.2975986898,
0.2816874683,
-0.0743246824,
0.3411028385,
-0.5870178938,
0.4535307884,
0.2788515091,
-0.5232365131,
0.6570403576,
0.1155786291,
0.4352645278,
-1.346296072,
-0.0679273531,
-0.0230593365,
-0.3654608727,
-1.0393251181,
-0.0114944167,
-0.1794404387,
-0.8765634298,
-0.6338845491,
0.3501124084,
-0.1254080087,
0.0575616844,
-0.2551091909,
0.0692573488,
-0.0398233086,
0.5210482478,
-0.2966605127,
1.3124505281,
0.5491448641,
-0.5915564895,
0.6665569544,
0.3736910522,
-0.072277911,
0.9159239531,
-0.8338876367,
0.3276920617,
-0.071931161,
0.6656602621,
-1.2965070009,
-0.1322025657,
0.281961143,
-0.8427996039,
0.2552863359,
-0.4796001613,
-0.1494435072,
-0.1250847727,
-0.2777421772,
0.033610452,
0.4378350675,
-0.6587163806,
0.4893969595,
0.2263857275,
-0.2120027691,
-0.4406746626,
-0.3014368415,
0.3000206649,
-0.4159450531,
-0.5390446186,
-0.1579350084,
-0.0946275815,
0.0305946749,
-0.4306121767,
-0.0153684579,
0.157161504,
0.6768000126,
0.1680551171,
0.3560633063,
-0.250203371,
-0.0905603468,
-0.3971641362,
-0.2929551899,
0.3024395406,
-0.3219222724,
0.6208898425,
-0.3269842267,
-0.3761535287,
-0.9282023907,
0.5363652706,
0.6874547005,
-0.1474702507,
0.2936734557,
0.3862136602,
-0.2448087484,
-0.1826548725,
-0.1687313765,
-0.6081154943,
-0.591401577,
0.3051895499,
-0.5034379959,
-0.5160863996,
0.3080861568,
-0.2224427313,
0.2538869381,
0.1662153751,
0.1660224944,
-0.0814261362,
1.4683260918,
0.3495085537,
-0.2526053488,
0.6845487952,
-0.2053832412,
0.1970284879,
-0.5759838223,
-0.005996835,
-0.5995463729,
-0.0714991689,
-0.5543929338,
0.1538264602,
0.4183500707,
-0.2569528818,
-0.2851381302,
0.6770057082,
-0.3940523267,
0.3770480156,
0.7554047704,
0.158483386,
-0.0872877613,
-0.3202890158,
0.0139793213,
-0.1923618168,
-0.5996320248,
-0.499209255,
0.9927376509,
0.135115996,
0.8441088796,
0.0727526546,
0.6684375405,
0.4587222338,
-0.2421012521,
-0.8610575199,
0.7909777164,
0.1114801243,
-0.5383213758,
-0.2614454031,
-0.3661128581,
-0.8623401523,
-0.0349221006,
0.0992395803,
-0.8176152706,
-0.1895683706,
0.5102217197,
-0.4656779766,
0.2224134505,
-0.7460194826,
0.9167016149,
-0.1970648766,
-0.0744365975,
-0.0109304339,
-0.561851263,
0.3755656183,
0.3424236476,
-0.3094705343,
-0.0157446768,
0.257268548,
0.6162427068,
-0.3485327065,
1.1074736118,
-0.5309396982,
-0.0537394509,
0.4315553904,
0.5486063361,
0.9659956694,
0.2207176387,
0.202174291,
-0.3875448406,
0.0298604481,
-0.4531574249,
-0.9115259051,
0.5085080266,
-0.4480690956,
-0.9181622863,
-0.6862695813,
-0.3865678012,
-0.3533127606,
0.0158995446,
0.3413614929,
1.0394430161,
-0.6134474277,
-0.1532752067,
0.919095099,
-0.1595502049,
0.2450193018,
0.5770158768,
0.2511029243,
-0.5667713881,
1.0866242647,
-0.1823126823,
0.4467970431,
0.184506014,
0.223407194,
-0.2781663835,
-0.3534863591,
-0.5928024054,
-0.2781068385,
-0.5021422505,
-0.3586065769,
-0.5540442467,
-0.1978914887,
-0.5645594597,
-0.3627922535,
-0.3893405795,
-0.3744038641,
-0.2905453146,
-0.0380969495,
0.4833761454,
0.6219306588,
0.183949694,
0.5575492382,
-0.6119426489,
0.236181736,
0.6846764088,
-0.2085844427,
-0.3252942562,
-0.3584415317,
0.0242423024,
0.3344806731,
-0.6671690941,
-1.1239305735,
0.2847095728,
-0.0034047733,
0.4964372516,
0.4137359858,
0.4284906983,
0.5918068886,
-0.3403047919,
1.3411233425,
0.2131480873,
-0.9420949221,
1.0566138029,
-0.5844649673,
0.4576982856,
0.6318358779,
0.2440556288,
-0.5814818144,
-0.6806507707,
-0.8492867351,
-0.4734424055,
0.8401589394,
-0.0796036422,
0.1437795311,
-0.1026118547,
0.0964390486,
-0.0786084831,
0.1294127852,
-0.3173494041,
-0.1847307086,
-0.3234162629,
-0.2536337078,
-0.1246935576,
-0.076493226,
-0.3530476391,
0.4653630853,
0.7660099268,
-0.3725865781,
0.2815743685,
0.1346639842,
-0.2037653029,
0.3907530904,
0.2799335718,
0.6259780526,
0.0783298686,
-0.1424626708,
0.0445833355,
0.1597077399,
-0.5542016029,
0.4574332535,
0.2481421232,
-0.6115292311,
-0.0089138225,
0.1609995663,
0.9448300004,
0.1050538421,
-0.5000930429,
0.814017415,
-0.4853496552,
-0.0254830793,
-0.2726890743,
0.2155279666,
-0.4793064892,
0.4116648734,
0.2430257797,
0.2281971872,
0.4323019683,
-0.4713478684,
0.4047700167,
0.7489418983,
-0.7886303067,
-0.6062481403,
0.6373162866,
0.3629067838,
-0.5426973104,
0.4021289945,
-0.2526146173,
-1.0322400331,
0.5697811842,
0.6609243751,
1.1579585075,
-0.4900289774,
0.4962438047,
0.3078843653,
0.2839459777,
-0.0315625407,
0.0806712285,
-0.2729018629,
-0.2604490221,
-0.0785392746,
0.0155756008,
-0.5964805484,
0.3003286123,
-0.8349202275,
0.3395624161,
-0.5701800585,
-0.2136533111,
-0.1568850726,
0.2210629433,
-0.4249095023,
0.1634455919,
-0.095243074,
0.7208083272,
-0.8426157832,
0.3815962672,
0.5159159899,
-0.369147718,
-0.5105778575,
0.2135407031,
0.6947990656,
-0.7669892311,
0.3556423187,
0.2633640766,
-0.2648437023,
-0.0477908179,
-0.5718688965,
-0.8118109703,
1.0110837221,
0.3645997345,
-0.2059967965,
-0.0655738711,
-0.3165262938,
0.2282427549,
-0.0552838221,
0.3470976651,
0.6320768595,
0.0589996539,
-0.0093705431,
-0.5034273267,
0.2754070759,
-0.0445575789,
-0.2502094209,
0.3497029543,
-0.6705787778,
0.5465008616,
-0.2021544874,
-0.5092828274,
0.2000754178,
0.6107057929,
0.0953122824,
0.4093411267,
0.6819851995,
0.509226799,
0.7899272442,
-0.1040664166,
0.8215312958,
-0.2404784113,
0.0076962924,
1.1974383593,
-0.1337005347,
0.2939000428,
0.274721235,
-0.0072593195,
0.1485281736,
0.6504058838,
-0.0224584546,
0.767431438,
0.1328146458,
-0.43800506,
0.0148445787,
-0.108719185,
-0.2595703602,
0.3195261359,
0.430074662,
-0.0380557217,
-0.3235954046,
0.3110592663,
0.4054886103,
0.0619441234,
0.0041735559,
1.2182844877,
-0.2095318586,
-0.8503943086,
0.6088971496,
-0.4745774567,
0.4755434692,
-0.8445186615,
0.1606966406,
-0.2873803675,
-0.0774137974,
0.2847865224,
-0.4030526578,
0.0689098835,
0.2911928892,
0.1280581802,
-0.2021452039,
0.6499341726,
-0.1816598922,
-0.09716288,
-0.0838440657,
0.1292345375,
0.0528209172,
0.0189083554,
-0.7280516624,
-0.3300066888,
0.2811681926,
-0.495098561,
0.3693793416,
0.3616243601,
0.3506901562,
0.6686242223,
0.7498512268,
0.1728938073,
-0.181578964,
-0.3278391957,
0.9339909554,
-0.5834148526,
-0.7348595262,
-0.7895005941,
0.4773401022,
-0.3689066172,
-0.4975139499,
0.7951401472,
0.4475408494,
0.5062027574,
0.2521523535,
1.0491883755,
0.054721605,
0.6790235639,
-0.5478773713,
0.5677825212,
-0.2805205584,
0.3467113376,
-0.1774279624,
-0.4135664105,
0.1412763,
0.2003493458,
-0.2853637934,
-0.3619555533,
0.5142166018,
0.9516428709,
0.0526944101,
0.4401265979,
0.3520459235,
0.0859290063,
0.8528517485,
0.5329729915,
1.0550758839,
-0.5368427634,
0.8322181702,
-0.1403581649,
-0.3864076436,
-0.1116475239,
-0.6500701308,
-1.1086473465,
-0.6691504121,
-0.2622261941,
-0.5632471442,
0.3617198467,
0.8167337775,
0.5576282144,
-0.7311483026,
0.2143107653,
-0.28453511,
-0.0611139014,
-0.1831157058,
-0.2435316741,
0.3266129494,
-0.6862519979,
-0.6959390044,
1.0038179159,
0.0202266276,
0.5145070553,
-0.354437381,
0.197197035,
0.1238036826,
0.3230671585,
0.2618419826,
0.5003884435,
-0.592931509,
-0.2906053364,
0.0730409846,
-0.152990222,
-0.2868644297,
1.0469374657,
-1.0259122849,
0.647844851,
0.5479852557,
0.8822990656,
0.1485930532,
0.1190378889,
1.0321671963,
-0.7821010947,
0.2322840542,
0.4509252608,
0.2296369225,
0.3178933859,
-0.5260019898,
0.1382727921,
0.1949094832,
-0.5760386586,
-1.0174828768,
0.6678136587,
-0.6236366034,
-0.2245535105,
0.916302681,
-0.514441371,
-0.1016391292,
-0.1590782553,
-0.4589524567,
0.1952477396,
-0.7980226874,
0.8629407287,
0.402447015,
0.1008480564,
0.150922507,
-0.4374287128,
0.9624696374,
0.3676949739,
-0.7177735567,
0.1448698491,
0.5262003541,
0.1814471781,
0.1170163676,
0.4748657048,
0.2653258145,
0.5021817684,
0.3027592301,
-0.6281946301,
-0.1468358338,
-0.309214443,
-0.5668757558,
0.1379934847,
-0.2587006688,
-0.6219542027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04530v1 | Lenient Evaluation of Japanese Speech Recognition: Modeling Naturally Occurring Spelling Inconsistency | 2023-06-07T15:39:02 | 2023-06-07T15:39:02 | Shigeki Karita, Richard Sproat, Haruko Ishikawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Word error rate (WER) and character error rate (CER) are standard metrics in
Speech Recognition (ASR), but one problem has always been alternative
spellings: If one's system transcribes adviser whereas the ground truth has
advisor, this will count as an error even though the two spellings really
represent the same word.
Japanese is notorious for ``lacking orthography'': most words can be spelled
in multiple ways, presenting a problem for accurate ASR evaluation. In this
paper we propose a new lenient evaluation metric as a more defensible CER
measure for Japanese ASR. We create a lattice of plausible respellings of the
reference transcription, using a combination of lexical resources, a Japanese
text-processing system, and a neural machine translation model for
reconstructing kanji from hiragana or katakana. In a manual evaluation, raters
rated 95.4% of the proposed spelling variants as plausible. ASR results show
that our method, which does not penalize the system for choosing a valid
alternate spelling of a word, affords a 2.4%-3.1% absolute reduction in CER
depending on the task. | [
0.036882855,
-0.591955781,
0.4019082487,
-0.0825114623,
-0.2287556976,
0.0872133002,
-0.4663755894,
-0.3984489739,
0.1650574207,
0.3798404336,
-0.4234395027,
-0.3680118322,
-0.5175170898,
0.3271372318,
-0.0749854743,
0.5295521617,
-0.1892328262,
0.3400672078,
0.0903505981,
-0.3943639696,
-0.5935709476,
-0.6099228859,
-0.79734689,
-0.432682544,
0.487151593,
0.4516556561,
1.01390028,
0.4502638578,
0.5193600655,
0.3419380784,
-0.0077854288,
0.0394160226,
-0.1512747407,
0.0566104762,
0.1280944645,
-0.7299075127,
-0.306612879,
-0.0452046543,
0.9477227926,
0.8030102849,
-0.3608991504,
-0.0083434181,
-0.0703579709,
0.8019555807,
-0.5050011277,
-0.2102263123,
-0.5474261642,
0.3696105182,
-0.4300870597,
0.0034957374,
-0.1286732405,
-0.4609003961,
0.1419598311,
-0.61930269,
0.4255417883,
-0.0429453142,
0.6366013288,
0.2744429111,
0.0375714675,
-0.4475560188,
-0.7752982378,
0.5095929503,
-0.8385019898,
0.7654672265,
0.3901780546,
0.3774784207,
-0.0806207135,
-0.5275240541,
-0.7156908512,
-0.5552030802,
0.0950256288,
0.1757764816,
0.0133735463,
0.1545477808,
0.5919828415,
0.411070168,
-0.5840005875,
0.1952332556,
-0.4471091032,
-0.4125345349,
0.6739017963,
0.137643069,
0.6457425356,
-0.2524861395,
-0.004575043,
-0.1233079061,
-0.4281477034,
0.0814973116,
0.7031843066,
0.4183804393,
0.0346051864,
0.6204510331,
-0.1305701733,
0.4492886662,
-0.1275956631,
-0.343945682,
0.3933756053,
-0.1684888899,
0.0367867909,
0.3834931254,
0.9982111454,
0.2914531529,
0.2151482999,
-0.101233609,
-0.2381238639,
0.4927203953,
0.3125375211,
-0.4188118577,
-0.3371893167,
-0.1503534764,
-0.2930164933,
0.2665831149,
0.1230259538,
-0.5961329341,
-0.3342086375,
-0.0025034528,
0.6125490665,
-0.7367130518,
-0.0520516299,
0.1559552997,
-0.3777138293,
-0.0234891344,
-0.0313571803,
-0.5147167444,
0.2521981299,
0.4329707026,
0.7189732194,
-0.0379546545,
-0.4342792928,
-0.2518099248,
-0.3328299224,
-0.4683871865,
0.6616944075,
-0.5881619453,
-1.1080091,
-0.2329741418,
0.0151456697,
-0.195763588,
-0.5078927279,
0.81738168,
-0.3085454404,
0.0341628641,
-0.3664575815,
-0.6138572693,
-0.2412029058,
-0.0617370084,
-0.7117811441,
0.6268537641,
-0.1496217847,
-0.4491529167,
0.5270417929,
-0.6778157949,
-0.6216457486,
0.2189869583,
0.0295355991,
-0.6240202188,
0.2495150417,
0.0537030399,
0.0141357668,
0.0017189239,
0.0771559626,
-0.3073925078,
-0.4838173091,
0.6071375608,
-0.9536617398,
0.5453965068,
0.1452154666,
-0.1702680588,
-0.3414517343,
-1.0008356571,
0.1782725304,
-0.085286729,
-0.4469581842,
-0.4574538767,
-0.1039066538,
-0.1438786536,
-0.1282414198,
0.2915718257,
-0.7976419926,
-0.029562341,
-0.5811102986,
0.4003694654,
0.4372770786,
0.0280212015,
0.2149303555,
-0.5108903646,
0.5948984623,
-0.4938533604,
0.2858335078,
0.0753795505,
-0.5676735044,
-0.9863055944,
-0.1270335168,
0.3121209443,
0.3838726878,
-0.6979042888,
0.215411216,
-0.5423005819,
-0.6037744284,
-0.8635038733,
-0.1123724282,
0.8443538547,
0.5463405848,
0.0876941681,
-0.6943054795,
-0.8021622896,
-0.6661754251,
-0.6586359739,
-0.3157249391,
0.0859124511,
0.0423806347,
0.2465352714,
-0.102559641,
0.6551043391,
-0.2014805228,
-0.2822846472,
0.131475389,
0.1698008925,
0.352270484,
0.347258091,
-0.2174399644,
-0.8326581717,
-0.5499756932,
-0.0927855596,
-0.5068710446,
0.0225963444,
0.1670656204,
0.2787738442,
0.3494597077,
0.297883749,
-0.1918232888,
0.6791093946,
0.192481935,
-0.0143185155,
0.7987750769,
-0.5243359804,
0.3151954114,
-0.6431696415,
0.2331936061,
-0.2166763246,
-0.1513108909,
-0.7449564934,
0.2450273335,
0.0253110733,
-0.0746784955,
-0.315002501,
0.3067111373,
-0.5313825607,
-0.1924078465,
-0.2189983577,
0.1885454506,
0.0482650436,
0.3370155096,
0.1651894748,
0.8181102872,
0.1037403643,
-0.6793354154,
0.4078390002,
0.2257544249,
-0.4864003062,
0.8445881009,
-0.5419473648,
0.4418392777,
0.0522682481,
0.0415680818,
-0.9788416028,
-0.2486586124,
0.2119596899,
-0.6339477897,
0.4496027529,
0.0589576438,
-0.3553597331,
-0.7193641663,
-0.198947072,
0.2278433293,
0.5594223142,
-0.5063713789,
0.2479371727,
0.462313056,
-0.1503189802,
-0.3809466958,
-0.8837302327,
0.0261132028,
-0.1479835808,
-0.246084556,
0.2531078756,
-0.1988567561,
0.0555712171,
-0.046527572,
-0.3025616109,
-0.16588521,
0.0018408702,
0.3425199091,
0.4122231603,
-0.1217820719,
-0.0499534607,
-0.3452233076,
-0.2190713584,
-0.0583144464,
0.0733325332,
0.3793659806,
-0.0871544629,
-0.7174400091,
-0.6575055122,
0.1138810292,
0.4795834422,
0.2042757273,
0.1257174015,
0.5124060512,
-0.5881708264,
0.3022849858,
-0.7885658145,
0.0671156794,
-0.4236381948,
0.4909971952,
-0.6953672767,
-0.6362606287,
0.6105517745,
0.3189136386,
-0.1145939082,
0.4974998236,
-0.0406587832,
0.0601819158,
1.2013930082,
0.4272227585,
-0.1264487803,
0.2746728957,
-0.0199754685,
0.2742538154,
-1.0856407881,
-0.1693609059,
-0.5997270346,
-0.2683044672,
-0.8810819983,
-0.1481211334,
0.6139373779,
-0.0796684027,
-0.0606394261,
0.3429947495,
-0.5075420737,
0.4369897544,
0.6239940524,
0.1677473336,
0.5619903207,
-0.0275116228,
-0.1905889213,
-0.3106775582,
-0.7516291142,
-0.4226874113,
0.9903170466,
0.1312576681,
0.6104380488,
0.0069273286,
0.6266925335,
0.0587298013,
0.201744169,
-0.8583117127,
0.4125007391,
-0.6167253256,
-0.6102162004,
-0.6195108891,
-0.5270322561,
-0.7072188258,
-0.075280793,
-0.0894265622,
-0.7547736764,
0.2035353035,
0.0983526632,
-0.6487836838,
0.245947063,
-0.4565652311,
0.5897776484,
-0.1005998403,
0.1318377852,
-0.1966781914,
-0.5654660463,
0.3004574776,
-0.0954129025,
0.3635882139,
0.0127483141,
0.0707259923,
0.9022156596,
-0.7345304489,
0.6213650703,
-0.2105671018,
0.1621951163,
0.1555103362,
-0.0486473069,
0.3831375539,
-0.1051038802,
-0.4520813525,
0.3846161962,
0.0546519198,
0.1538337916,
-0.6434626579,
0.4520932436,
-0.7803608775,
-0.3959318697,
-0.3626990914,
-0.0970670655,
-0.1955038458,
0.0662467852,
0.8603397608,
0.5733267069,
-0.4849832654,
-0.0571834818,
0.2768959403,
-0.1187572628,
0.061911907,
0.7248430848,
-0.038217403,
-0.7607634664,
1.1706351042,
0.633035481,
0.1387500167,
0.2436696887,
0.4358246624,
-0.5039467216,
-0.2812354267,
-0.4232058525,
0.208212018,
-0.6324691772,
0.0410820954,
-0.3708062172,
-0.6104417443,
-0.2992858589,
-0.1700637341,
-0.4722775221,
-0.3996738791,
-0.220230937,
0.0720122978,
0.4075883329,
0.5064225793,
-0.2793046236,
0.2110071182,
-0.7796030045,
0.4223574102,
0.257745564,
0.4626416266,
-0.1400733441,
-1.0316101313,
0.053513851,
0.2905115783,
-0.1118258312,
-0.6480341554,
0.3682608604,
0.518047452,
0.553217411,
0.3283386827,
0.0499159656,
1.1752669811,
-0.7765276432,
0.7433515787,
0.4841890633,
-1.0875908136,
0.4723989367,
0.2043713927,
0.4549723268,
0.821367383,
0.2962431014,
-0.9857529402,
-0.3475047052,
-0.7540389895,
-0.6960123181,
0.609167397,
-0.197276637,
0.110886693,
-0.0235240795,
0.4805623889,
0.3958151937,
0.0011428285,
-0.4808347225,
-0.2245525867,
-0.1340514719,
-0.126257807,
-0.2744812965,
-0.3741089106,
0.37975353,
-0.0299976226,
0.9766328931,
0.1822297275,
0.0287175197,
0.5052946806,
-0.2403522581,
-0.1154462174,
0.4214361608,
0.3816534281,
0.3682434857,
-0.0235047415,
0.1297050118,
0.470051229,
-0.8166895509,
0.1700421572,
0.1084370613,
-0.4153383374,
0.3856099844,
0.1773825586,
0.9779430628,
0.3799482882,
-0.6118966341,
0.3734767139,
-0.0458968766,
-0.1380513757,
-0.457472831,
0.0287264735,
-0.2319673449,
-0.1203303635,
-0.026214337,
0.1494109184,
0.4918175936,
-0.6248376966,
0.025455147,
0.4433219135,
-0.6856761575,
-0.4404085577,
0.440567255,
0.0644322336,
-0.7884164453,
0.5597792864,
-0.3464701772,
-0.8671584129,
0.4038977623,
0.4602728486,
0.9626887441,
-0.7843800187,
0.0555939674,
0.5707479715,
0.3062212467,
-0.4093275368,
0.4291725755,
-0.0059336214,
-0.840194881,
-0.0498466529,
-0.5916463733,
-0.7797467709,
0.0045325602,
-0.944218576,
0.2480413914,
-0.3839861453,
-0.4241970778,
0.0132835833,
0.0908506364,
-0.6161928773,
0.2324702293,
0.1054380834,
0.4267016351,
-0.6480286121,
0.5457137227,
0.5876425505,
-0.2918271124,
-0.9133928418,
-0.063992776,
-0.1085201278,
-0.8986276984,
0.2552219033,
0.3401241302,
-0.2329021841,
-0.1876950413,
0.0682568699,
-0.8288246393,
0.7156037092,
0.2146288007,
-1.0568180084,
0.0750968978,
0.2070699781,
0.5716778636,
0.1155980155,
0.2356202304,
0.7356775403,
0.4668520689,
-0.0551168174,
-1.1208623648,
0.0119811539,
-0.2983427942,
0.4670453072,
0.086908251,
-0.6153714061,
0.3581458926,
-0.2990617454,
-0.6537320018,
0.3379217684,
0.4570342004,
0.2524029613,
0.5057999492,
0.6103904247,
0.5049008131,
1.072624445,
0.0888937488,
0.8763560057,
-0.1470737159,
-0.074976027,
1.142403245,
-0.3764832914,
1.0624339581,
0.3720210195,
-0.6131049991,
0.4407099187,
0.3122222424,
0.0484694429,
0.3850315511,
0.2350095659,
-0.2418496162,
0.0418839231,
-0.028855117,
-0.188249439,
0.5754831433,
0.4624682963,
-0.0635816231,
0.2930365801,
0.2878571749,
-0.0193550084,
0.4101462364,
-0.2356373817,
0.6962863207,
0.4025464952,
-0.722730875,
0.6116922498,
-0.0444673635,
0.9088815451,
-0.5759695768,
0.2121678889,
-0.0320276134,
-0.0021393939,
-0.0750879496,
-0.4618906975,
0.5340249538,
0.286105603,
-0.225386858,
0.1669643074,
0.6055262685,
-0.3490147293,
-0.5653227568,
-0.0881181806,
-0.0007645646,
0.5331648588,
0.0597865358,
-0.5261321068,
0.1587596685,
-0.0286669154,
-0.048195187,
-0.1490530521,
0.2197059691,
0.0286153741,
0.4559194148,
0.6614577174,
0.3284518421,
0.0271173175,
0.4446310103,
0.2233970612,
-0.4649520516,
-0.5561880469,
-0.8755432963,
0.1657244563,
0.010729433,
-0.4086120129,
0.8524127007,
0.407660991,
0.6516913176,
0.130644083,
0.8254722953,
0.2537696362,
0.6089796424,
-0.6810359359,
0.8264424205,
-0.4470433295,
0.2442136258,
-0.3623147607,
-0.8248788118,
-0.3503692448,
0.7961606383,
-0.317356348,
-0.0060076606,
0.733710587,
0.7852007151,
0.1716795415,
0.3872858882,
0.6725664735,
0.3017516136,
-0.1151622236,
0.5613596439,
0.8616682291,
-0.6811898947,
0.456535846,
-0.3008641899,
-0.2090837657,
-0.2991012335,
-0.6782007813,
-0.2971574664,
-0.5840241909,
-0.5374355912,
-0.2602837086,
0.4379585087,
0.804166615,
0.376085192,
-0.5717110038,
-0.0379503779,
-0.2455540001,
0.0631020516,
-0.2167982459,
-0.1670749485,
0.2547106445,
-0.1144546047,
-0.6189687252,
0.4807324409,
0.2252639532,
-0.058218088,
-0.1292134523,
-0.1187908277,
0.3919436932,
-0.0384639129,
0.0564419366,
0.5905895829,
-0.8425418735,
-0.5701223016,
-0.1083916426,
0.0141684562,
0.1219535619,
0.2979904115,
-0.4592707157,
0.9192292094,
0.4146181345,
0.2922381759,
0.3096013963,
-0.314365685,
0.5191065073,
-0.6495132446,
-0.2142593861,
0.1873416901,
0.4847397804,
0.8155231476,
-0.38786906,
0.2864989638,
0.4219029248,
-0.4629058242,
-0.8840867281,
0.1223074049,
-0.5613452196,
0.1312699467,
0.9524413943,
-0.2385882884,
-0.3976580501,
-0.0248725116,
-0.1646647155,
0.4862094522,
-0.2491492927,
0.7504382133,
0.7762525678,
0.1458489448,
0.2690658867,
-0.4371860921,
0.3069643974,
0.3545279503,
-0.2634794712,
-0.0951136649,
0.4166245162,
0.589762032,
0.4981484711,
0.8967769742,
-0.2182470262,
0.5977936983,
0.309641391,
0.3641349971,
0.1057984307,
-0.1593527794,
-0.6931652427,
-0.1180158406,
0.3887553215,
-0.2886989713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04528v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04528v4 | PromptBench: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Large Language Models on Adversarial Prompts | 2023-06-07T15:37:00 | 2023-10-18T14:16:01 | Kaijie Zhu, Jindong Wang, Jiaheng Zhou, Zichen Wang, Hao Chen, Yidong Wang, Linyi Yang, Wei Ye, Yue Zhang, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | The increasing reliance on Large Language Models (LLMs) across academia and
industry necessitates a comprehensive understanding of their robustness to
prompts. In response to this vital need, we introduce PromptBench, a robustness
benchmark designed to measure LLMs' resilience to adversarial prompts. This
study uses a plethora of adversarial textual attacks targeting prompts across
multiple levels: character, word, sentence, and semantic. The adversarial
prompts, crafted to mimic plausible user errors like typos or synonyms, aim to
evaluate how slight deviations can affect LLM outcomes while maintaining
semantic integrity. These prompts are then employed in diverse tasks, such as
sentiment analysis, natural language inference, reading comprehension, machine
translation, and math problem-solving. Our study generates 4788 adversarial
prompts, meticulously evaluated over 8 tasks and 13 datasets. Our findings
demonstrate that contemporary LLMs are not robust to adversarial prompts.
Furthermore, we present comprehensive analysis to understand the mystery behind
prompt robustness and its transferability. We then offer insightful robustness
analysis and pragmatic recommendations for prompt composition, beneficial to
both researchers and everyday users. Code is available at:
https://github.com/microsoft/promptbench. | [
-0.3905040324,
-1.0655590296,
0.521912396,
0.3286476135,
0.1456486583,
0.1416308135,
-0.2518790364,
0.0431847163,
-0.2864407599,
0.3012757897,
-0.7713541985,
-0.4534622431,
-0.5135636926,
0.4485710859,
-0.4194913805,
0.8798297644,
0.200852558,
0.0579286627,
-0.3523944616,
-0.2839853168,
-0.8418599367,
-0.4655213058,
-0.7120319605,
0.2160872668,
0.7236799002,
0.0769875422,
0.8926936388,
0.2838511467,
0.4623875916,
0.4096034765,
-0.2317828536,
-0.009119072,
-0.5590462685,
0.6337023973,
-0.3627915382,
-0.5503439307,
-0.2527750731,
-0.0800294206,
0.6441646218,
0.6397823095,
0.1824854016,
-0.064282231,
0.3145506978,
0.3511556387,
-0.541896522,
-0.0479184575,
-0.726275146,
-0.1108464971,
-0.4147497118,
0.0124358758,
-0.5676169991,
-0.398814559,
-0.0376617461,
-0.3736662567,
0.0927003324,
0.2130550593,
0.5015511513,
0.391667515,
-0.2131702453,
-0.3667053878,
-0.0688028038,
0.6513141394,
-0.5810686946,
0.0074542845,
0.1886006296,
0.6326744556,
-0.7000126243,
-0.6491538286,
-0.4072192013,
-0.7044060826,
0.0906394124,
-0.0214298368,
-0.5914996862,
-0.0804928318,
0.5835101604,
0.1543590724,
-0.9911009669,
0.1002197936,
0.3692655265,
-0.3594739139,
0.1248451024,
0.5029578805,
0.8187246323,
-0.1083942279,
-0.3684743643,
-0.3836502433,
-0.6154595017,
0.2458797693,
0.5319172144,
0.5449972749,
0.0588852987,
0.4212760031,
0.1889721006,
0.7523934841,
-0.0350211896,
-0.0136754168,
-0.1772479713,
-0.3691291809,
0.236767903,
-0.1619804353,
0.9662374854,
0.3170547485,
0.1577433646,
-0.3399361372,
-0.1993720382,
0.1360639781,
0.4866347909,
-0.725163877,
-0.1913666129,
0.1921358109,
-0.1471282691,
-0.4095338285,
-0.115040265,
-0.8324558735,
-1.0724265575,
0.125293225,
0.1528327316,
-0.4663282335,
0.1033296138,
-0.3110571802,
-0.1389006823,
-0.1579942256,
0.3074723482,
-0.558639884,
0.0859087557,
0.8224545121,
0.8659054637,
-0.2386303991,
-0.580057919,
-1.0125414133,
-0.4548688829,
-0.3426758945,
0.7890002131,
-0.3003527522,
-0.5801074505,
0.1025105044,
0.2212142497,
-0.1884059608,
-0.3690060973,
0.9878155589,
-0.6337808967,
0.2750554085,
-0.5355141163,
-0.4028810263,
0.0555499606,
0.5695881844,
-0.8773750067,
0.8407640457,
0.1668788493,
-0.9775910378,
0.0757110417,
-0.1566772163,
-0.4290597737,
-0.0803565755,
-0.0178917274,
-0.0866414234,
0.1577109247,
0.1996433437,
0.1569889784,
-0.5307697058,
0.3369160593,
-0.7251871824,
-0.1560562849,
0.8105936646,
-0.8101202846,
1.1109567881,
0.1313415766,
-0.1790394336,
0.491150409,
-0.76491642,
-0.121717371,
0.1409877241,
-0.1544877142,
-0.0588906407,
-0.2475260198,
0.0251932628,
0.2204146534,
0.2850609422,
-0.2642736733,
0.1659987271,
-0.4313738644,
0.3500392437,
0.8710625172,
-0.0755129755,
0.2594930232,
-0.3315929174,
0.86465168,
-0.3351072967,
-0.0258025248,
-0.3547301292,
-0.1909291446,
-0.2891801,
-0.2716527283,
0.215868786,
0.7036753297,
-0.9596249461,
0.5397279263,
-0.1789527386,
-0.5744857192,
-0.224546209,
0.1898965389,
0.3363375068,
0.7388190031,
0.133788079,
0.0316683762,
-0.3541496694,
-0.6627622843,
-0.6414037347,
-0.2466017157,
-0.2027359605,
0.0206806771,
0.2379185259,
-0.065044187,
0.8182451725,
-0.1774827391,
0.2439445406,
-0.3763474226,
0.1100623682,
0.2948026955,
0.2371928394,
0.786542356,
-0.347369045,
-0.3638049364,
-0.5393289924,
-0.6912122965,
-0.4678974152,
-0.2581059337,
-0.2257452607,
0.0792421624,
0.5077736378,
-0.6621217132,
0.0877336711,
0.512152195,
-0.6432846785,
0.7195982933,
0.0008343952,
0.0454768836,
-1.127201438,
0.357236445,
-0.186215952,
-0.2304119021,
-0.5929424763,
0.184866786,
0.0591529422,
-0.4398601353,
-0.3320976198,
0.6729801297,
-0.2009377331,
0.0715207979,
-0.4742637277,
0.2498916984,
0.032254912,
0.1366181821,
-0.6112111211,
1.1681451797,
0.6320852637,
-0.260578841,
0.6892490387,
0.2956681252,
-0.2404246181,
0.9833112955,
-0.8793614507,
0.079429999,
0.0418134853,
0.297808677,
-1.2378287315,
-0.2106453776,
0.3383263946,
-0.5693691373,
0.4542860985,
0.039022509,
-0.6267751455,
-0.2155031711,
-0.5124065876,
-0.0002179547,
0.2722103894,
-0.5560450554,
0.604747653,
0.0269760173,
-0.5672225952,
-0.5108762383,
-0.438383162,
0.5527707934,
-0.2645857036,
-0.8791085482,
-0.1046618968,
-0.3024876714,
-0.3341029882,
-0.1506336629,
0.0251364335,
0.2797390521,
0.6692889929,
0.2741727829,
0.2111565769,
-0.1806600243,
-0.1412476599,
-0.463085711,
-0.2225389034,
0.428532213,
0.1271072626,
0.6372943521,
-0.288385123,
-0.4803572595,
-0.2338070869,
0.3673550785,
0.7470009327,
-0.0903902948,
0.740981698,
0.5703305006,
-0.2351026684,
-0.3655768037,
-0.293725878,
-0.1441212595,
-0.5073559284,
0.329893738,
-0.3401957154,
-0.6126933694,
0.7711104751,
0.0654987469,
0.0561590865,
0.4110920131,
0.3866645098,
0.1674518436,
0.9666519761,
0.2688566148,
-0.2032384723,
0.515540719,
0.3634147644,
-0.1250451505,
-0.5069473982,
0.0992758274,
-0.8059860468,
-0.081041418,
-0.3189672828,
-0.0826910511,
0.2634379566,
-0.0559901223,
-0.3152226806,
0.2753487527,
-0.0145157594,
0.3117929399,
0.7182816267,
-0.2312041223,
-0.0960378498,
-0.1178684458,
-0.1079272628,
-0.1013652757,
-0.561380744,
-0.7069352269,
0.7423303127,
0.2462620139,
0.7660566568,
0.2105330676,
0.0682297945,
0.3451652527,
-0.0110182203,
-0.5116452575,
0.7008067966,
-0.1205224097,
-0.4677810371,
-0.0578854606,
-0.5977190137,
-0.9804242849,
0.0848886445,
-0.1432490647,
-0.6906114221,
-0.0607353486,
-0.0799936354,
-0.4465180039,
0.2098908871,
-0.423222512,
1.1235430241,
-0.38954404,
-0.4980228245,
0.3168973625,
-0.8185043335,
0.110723488,
-0.1181684583,
0.0947710276,
-0.1029767096,
-0.0875993595,
0.511788547,
-0.3905642033,
0.9796687365,
-0.0693725199,
-0.1849880368,
0.1765429378,
0.4933066964,
0.7589952946,
0.0372549742,
-0.3063793778,
-0.1133130789,
-0.1506070942,
-0.462028116,
-0.6817086339,
0.9673561454,
-0.5809839964,
-0.6265524626,
-0.5577527285,
-0.6418609023,
-0.4927843809,
0.2504419386,
0.3629578352,
0.5800130963,
-0.5721420646,
0.2225352526,
0.5392769575,
-0.3827150762,
0.5228617787,
0.434281528,
0.1623633057,
-0.6950882673,
0.8584862351,
-0.0822124258,
0.2129008472,
0.0466706268,
0.104129225,
-0.4773981869,
-0.5077472329,
-0.6957630515,
-0.2622115612,
-0.9714063406,
-0.2002268583,
-0.4912187457,
0.0434549712,
-0.3508791924,
-0.3212368786,
-0.1264411658,
-0.1768373847,
-0.4319599867,
0.0684461594,
0.2756904662,
0.4205706418,
0.2637732029,
0.1941828728,
-0.802065134,
0.0726129264,
0.2094222307,
-0.012874498,
-0.1113210618,
-0.6150468588,
0.2586211264,
-0.2304536998,
-0.1755872369,
-0.9160544872,
0.2026119083,
0.0228962898,
0.7127248049,
0.2991091907,
0.47521469,
0.2201708853,
-0.3411823511,
1.0643795729,
0.1366593391,
-0.8965277076,
0.5478014946,
-0.4163744152,
0.5435936451,
0.9132704735,
0.1044296101,
-0.4757990837,
-0.5281862617,
-0.5207874775,
-0.8552751541,
0.5257064104,
0.0539372005,
0.1147979349,
-0.0533374697,
-0.0015488192,
0.2033783942,
0.1097992286,
-0.2733659446,
-0.1705221683,
-0.1669356525,
-0.4517275691,
-0.2923929095,
-0.4191834331,
-0.3180564046,
0.5644621849,
0.4246267676,
-0.2140106559,
-0.3262290657,
-0.1505549252,
-0.1842936575,
0.1880223006,
0.6029297709,
0.4688695967,
0.5010209084,
0.1199152917,
0.4560044408,
0.3067331016,
-0.4104952216,
0.1485434324,
0.4654276371,
-0.2432753444,
-0.1242676824,
0.7905024886,
0.689596951,
0.3137064278,
-0.9071682096,
0.647677958,
-0.4198678136,
0.3622259498,
-0.0482779071,
0.0710911378,
-0.1177285686,
0.1611174643,
0.0496759117,
0.1945028901,
0.1633218527,
-0.4891402721,
0.029426543,
0.4811860621,
-0.38401559,
-0.3781602085,
0.6121202707,
0.1817228794,
-0.172058776,
0.5489148498,
-0.1600873321,
-0.5478569865,
0.6049944162,
0.5344407558,
1.0731328726,
-0.0340957269,
-0.0261404924,
0.2078039795,
0.3948723376,
0.0204642378,
0.1521769315,
0.2699678838,
-0.2282939404,
-0.0627184808,
-0.3583025634,
-0.536200881,
-0.1298395246,
-0.4884275794,
0.052669961,
-0.6174323559,
-0.3377591074,
-0.1350459903,
-0.0674340203,
-0.4782134891,
-0.2079843581,
-0.0324136689,
1.0380244255,
-0.6771974564,
0.2584595978,
0.8936181068,
-0.2854737639,
-0.4984859228,
0.084017396,
0.4050529897,
-0.7681732178,
0.2339380383,
0.2807106972,
-0.140443638,
-0.3391903937,
-0.4345315695,
-0.5379094481,
0.7597058415,
0.7040094733,
-0.4719809592,
0.2765266597,
-0.0570240989,
0.5219259262,
0.0689361393,
0.3152185678,
0.4704951048,
0.4479985535,
0.1012894064,
-0.630374372,
0.4999894202,
-0.3943169713,
0.0233900733,
-0.1140841842,
-0.4519076943,
0.7489654422,
-0.0521265268,
-0.4321412742,
0.5134916306,
0.5162528157,
0.3046992421,
0.258251518,
0.539285481,
0.5070136189,
1.0191602707,
-0.3345697224,
1.2039563656,
-0.5806440115,
-0.0250072405,
1.1395106316,
-0.3923271,
0.6279066801,
0.2440367937,
-0.1683295369,
0.2013612241,
0.5750462413,
-0.1011271924,
0.3118903041,
0.3616475463,
-0.3651784956,
-0.2519310713,
-0.3699356914,
-0.443883419,
-0.0773901343,
0.1892765909,
-0.0493761115,
-0.4478769004,
0.1904064268,
0.1252099425,
0.2149908394,
-0.1353479773,
0.8349468708,
0.0131666642,
-0.7570236325,
0.5793427825,
-0.2468442023,
0.4617645144,
-0.7702289224,
0.3185941577,
-0.3081728816,
0.3328005373,
0.069108516,
-0.9270660877,
0.0559525155,
0.3518749177,
-0.0819400772,
0.015531241,
0.8071784973,
-0.0625975579,
-0.3246354163,
0.08120244,
0.4406831861,
-0.0962277129,
-0.2364555448,
-0.7700870633,
0.4561671019,
-0.2382931709,
-0.3361119628,
0.389563024,
0.743198514,
0.0941462517,
0.7195825577,
0.6123625636,
-0.0829089358,
-0.1474844366,
0.2006463408,
1.0554586649,
-0.5857567787,
-0.3811451197,
-1.0531151295,
0.4228546023,
-0.1559320986,
-0.5543455482,
1.210195303,
0.3048741817,
0.3570124209,
0.0757534429,
0.8246819377,
0.0700189099,
0.3424532413,
-0.437759757,
0.6371663809,
-0.2387387753,
0.3822638094,
-0.1905882806,
-0.7623388767,
-0.360070765,
0.1571360677,
-0.3176300824,
-0.0664337575,
0.4785165489,
0.823746264,
0.2616150081,
0.0582903549,
0.2715554237,
0.2385173291,
0.4493860304,
0.4960875213,
1.2045063972,
0.0175577216,
0.7615049481,
0.0269884076,
-0.3153895736,
-0.2997059524,
-0.9532649517,
-1.2057420015,
-0.2206012458,
-0.1895745844,
-0.6821633577,
0.276784569,
0.786175549,
0.1688454002,
-0.9189052582,
0.1958136708,
-0.2726845741,
0.1295096725,
0.0535360388,
-0.2335940301,
0.4468427002,
-0.6979983449,
-0.4509431422,
0.7761609554,
-0.0104656927,
0.1686754674,
-0.3982079625,
0.2115556151,
0.3451474607,
0.0521612577,
0.3016489446,
0.3589676619,
-0.618214488,
-0.1696471721,
0.1630628556,
-0.4525815547,
-0.3856111169,
0.6199129224,
-0.443900466,
0.5705987811,
0.7959233522,
0.9523940086,
-0.5834218264,
0.0658108369,
0.6930268407,
-0.7178205252,
-0.040367119,
0.241525799,
0.6216456294,
0.6484631896,
-0.2269655168,
0.3114713132,
0.1056995764,
-0.5684828162,
-0.9707591534,
0.2444614768,
-1.0113848448,
-0.4688315988,
1.0964875221,
-0.4920887649,
-0.3334512413,
-0.0059864125,
-0.5576967597,
-0.0265839417,
-0.4742877483,
0.600312829,
0.9761901498,
0.4038303792,
0.0509935617,
-0.4937614799,
0.3532229364,
0.3676903248,
-0.7086868286,
0.3860604167,
0.6923926473,
0.2134660631,
0.1701123863,
0.0630934536,
0.1243524253,
0.3970398009,
0.3822900057,
-0.3128675222,
-0.2935143113,
-0.2301784456,
-0.7605383396,
0.5549115539,
0.275378406,
0.0817834213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04523v1 | Can current NLI systems handle German word order? Investigating language model performance on a new German challenge set of minimal pairs | 2023-06-07T15:33:07 | 2023-06-07T15:33:07 | Ines Reinig, Katja Markert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compared to English, German word order is freer and therefore poses
additional challenges for natural language inference (NLI). We create WOGLI
(Word Order in German Language Inference), the first adversarial NLI dataset
for German word order that has the following properties: (i) each premise has
an entailed and a non-entailed hypothesis; (ii) premise and hypotheses differ
only in word order and necessary morphological changes to mark case and number.
In particular, each premise andits two hypotheses contain exactly the same
lemmata. Our adversarial examples require the model to use morphological
markers in order to recognise or reject entailment. We show that current German
autoencoding models fine-tuned on translated NLI data can struggle on this
challenge set, reflecting the fact that translated NLI datasets will not mirror
all necessary language phenomena in the target language. We also examine
performance after data augmentation as well as on related word order phenomena
derived from WOGLI. Our datasets are publically available at
https://github.com/ireinig/wogli. | [
-0.3651902974,
-0.8553985953,
0.2429584116,
0.1216803864,
-0.2122811824,
-0.2484332025,
0.0975952893,
-0.7530183792,
0.0690749511,
0.3466639519,
-0.4974855483,
-0.3968149126,
-0.8702780604,
0.3483343124,
-0.3306363523,
0.8385694027,
0.1005348861,
0.2769196928,
-0.0807125494,
-0.7443132997,
-0.0137873236,
-0.6924153566,
-0.4789121151,
-0.6625820398,
0.587195158,
0.1073565781,
1.1879028082,
0.6867520213,
0.5891593099,
0.4038023055,
-0.3184775412,
0.2391473353,
-0.3765645921,
-0.0822082013,
0.1155939996,
-0.4586652219,
-0.3452235162,
0.0535745695,
0.2471125126,
1.1289871931,
-0.2424158901,
-0.0759886429,
-0.0838820562,
0.4744218886,
-0.8092435002,
-0.0152339954,
-0.4650680125,
0.1333327144,
-0.2756281793,
0.0654722974,
-0.5835290551,
-0.0835673958,
0.3812938929,
-0.4908531606,
0.2951646745,
0.1882289201,
1.2058285475,
0.3113005757,
-0.2699963152,
-0.3089928925,
-0.5281658769,
0.2502250671,
-0.9687752128,
0.4863330424,
0.1561434418,
0.0796148553,
-0.4967217445,
-0.5345728397,
-0.5002533793,
0.0622514822,
-0.2701340318,
0.2149449736,
-0.6733872294,
0.078331694,
0.2874410152,
0.3045470119,
-0.791790843,
0.6641328931,
-0.1307491064,
-0.1336601079,
0.6426795721,
0.1023650616,
0.2001909763,
-0.0764767751,
0.0104887532,
-0.5282077193,
-0.6032595634,
-0.1234947518,
0.5814923644,
0.2680027783,
-0.2021530569,
0.7049584985,
-0.2899489105,
0.7433127165,
0.0913990736,
0.0961980224,
0.5350667834,
0.0932877809,
-0.4377795756,
0.2331160009,
0.8956075907,
0.1734315753,
0.1649319977,
-0.5354721546,
-0.3036882877,
0.2953630984,
-0.0542171225,
-0.5596966147,
-0.2919788063,
0.0128396684,
-0.1490042657,
-0.3003164828,
0.3855293691,
-0.5082227588,
-0.4933418632,
-0.0433264412,
0.5869945884,
-0.5717858076,
-0.080808349,
0.4546473324,
-0.2975125313,
0.4893039465,
-0.0604849719,
-0.7461721897,
0.2120209932,
0.7306468487,
0.4935501516,
-0.1634983569,
-0.5202566981,
-0.5199965239,
0.0779796764,
-0.6003805995,
0.7303145528,
-0.5458557606,
-0.5526309013,
0.2059590667,
0.2550230622,
0.0076407464,
-0.4476825297,
0.6677732468,
-0.7030014992,
0.6571565866,
-0.105201982,
-0.8809005618,
-0.0169670973,
-0.2577437758,
-0.5378167033,
0.9762822986,
-0.2456443161,
-1.0903344154,
0.267380923,
-0.4409594834,
-0.935170114,
-0.030928161,
0.069457911,
-0.2319614887,
0.5666334629,
0.0894506723,
0.2125305384,
-0.0675273761,
0.3533433974,
-0.4162465632,
-0.4129928052,
-0.028923234,
-0.6796447039,
0.8034845591,
0.023861764,
-0.4737940133,
-0.1028274149,
-0.9606536031,
0.1750724912,
0.4462559223,
-0.0880820602,
-0.6039974689,
-0.0130120078,
0.0205600373,
0.1826395243,
0.1946586967,
-0.5868857503,
-0.0076763495,
-0.7319526672,
0.2636211216,
0.6042129993,
-0.0633489564,
0.5667893291,
0.1326343268,
0.2488921732,
-0.027994059,
0.3120577931,
0.3647496104,
-0.7006961107,
-1.1537685394,
0.1248651817,
0.5646912456,
0.8154028058,
-0.8639634848,
0.5540801287,
-0.4896918833,
-0.5000224113,
-0.5949941874,
-0.2065293342,
0.6375696659,
0.1273525357,
0.1003849208,
-0.0562369786,
-0.3492383957,
-1.3185584545,
-0.1208499297,
-0.2849218249,
-0.0362994671,
-0.0984026119,
0.5733785629,
-0.146009475,
0.5670167208,
-0.6683408618,
0.0810829625,
-0.2412774414,
0.6037651896,
0.3033587933,
0.1878343672,
0.4594721794,
-1.0210802555,
-0.0160739273,
-0.1097778603,
-0.9212235212,
-0.257727772,
0.242339164,
-0.4859199524,
0.4185352325,
0.4991941154,
-0.4184600413,
0.3998882473,
0.676368475,
-0.4633698761,
-0.0010772009,
-0.6866360307,
-0.3257859945,
-1.0740572214,
-0.0628014728,
0.0229529999,
-0.0577749424,
-0.8500103354,
0.1859644353,
-0.0317136459,
0.1164072379,
-0.3831763864,
0.4565639794,
-0.2600107789,
-0.0077775591,
-0.4015802145,
-0.0770918429,
0.111955449,
0.5135082006,
-0.1276877373,
0.5857908726,
0.4076509774,
-0.6889544725,
-0.0415801704,
0.4206547439,
-0.4396302104,
0.4852084517,
-0.6552143097,
0.1466455609,
-0.2899601758,
-0.1620086581,
-0.7361531258,
-0.3032963574,
0.0855671391,
-0.3368535936,
0.451666683,
0.0722203851,
-0.9775235653,
-0.3476341665,
0.3006733954,
-0.1726221591,
0.5319310427,
-0.472974658,
0.3968212008,
0.4226023853,
0.1856474429,
-0.3684068024,
-0.5834513903,
0.2467034608,
-0.1690630466,
-0.3011495769,
0.4892176986,
0.0465958305,
-0.4430534542,
-0.0173112229,
-0.0841484815,
-0.287758857,
0.3081365824,
0.0531204231,
0.3752717078,
-0.0862613916,
-0.1106397063,
-0.0437415838,
-0.1170370653,
-0.1045820415,
-0.2595984042,
0.3118252158,
-0.0545106754,
-0.4370920658,
-0.1341731846,
0.4759747684,
0.6581817269,
-0.2054391056,
0.7953875065,
0.6983513236,
-0.5849459171,
0.0685974211,
-0.5332323909,
0.0370195061,
-0.4947693646,
0.2817804813,
-0.6576126814,
-0.6786608696,
0.2339694798,
0.3745366931,
0.4144869745,
0.4500753582,
0.1444362253,
-0.2653510869,
1.2307581902,
0.8395776153,
-0.4790748656,
0.1841173023,
-0.2130537033,
0.2207743973,
-0.1912352443,
0.0934388712,
-0.3550097644,
-0.2384089381,
-0.9508230686,
-0.0744434595,
0.3579472005,
0.2592539787,
-0.0108431373,
0.4050776958,
-0.2655066848,
0.4212937355,
0.5356203914,
0.0327600092,
0.3037402332,
0.244379282,
-0.1681675166,
-0.0270501673,
-0.8692932129,
-0.2550573647,
0.4733748436,
-0.0100390529,
0.5410600305,
0.2752749622,
0.6834332347,
0.3587756157,
0.1507880986,
-0.5886653662,
0.5488299727,
-0.4485976696,
-0.4045082033,
-0.2686635852,
-0.3684654832,
-1.0855257511,
0.5785170197,
-0.1174746081,
-0.4688734412,
0.2708102763,
-0.1898127943,
0.0040019914,
0.1754098982,
-0.7780824304,
0.6513111591,
-0.2707865834,
-0.31130898,
0.0109479576,
-0.5462864041,
0.0207498875,
0.1846783161,
0.2565213144,
-0.1777769625,
0.2061294764,
0.7815752625,
-0.5871911645,
0.7502430677,
-0.282243669,
-0.6070010662,
0.1756719202,
0.0997447073,
0.7713112831,
-0.351932168,
-0.2430805117,
0.1512684673,
-0.0650833473,
-0.5678866506,
-0.6901795268,
0.6075662971,
-0.5107089281,
-0.8412874341,
-0.4740791917,
-0.3953462243,
-0.3993427455,
0.2931983471,
0.7959211469,
0.6799359918,
-0.2449348867,
-0.204523176,
0.4248169363,
0.0072818375,
0.6792846322,
0.7763773203,
0.0915678591,
-0.236502707,
1.0659053326,
0.2127602398,
0.1752185524,
0.2367610335,
0.1334985793,
-0.4069812,
-0.6269235611,
-0.7064208388,
0.3004761934,
-0.8659769297,
0.1549419463,
-0.6124969125,
-0.139702484,
-0.1921693832,
-0.0314413942,
-0.240230605,
-0.2920107245,
0.0126639437,
-0.1046986431,
0.3943780959,
0.957465589,
0.0977517739,
-0.0593344457,
-0.5329535007,
0.2416255027,
-0.0000853918,
0.3690081239,
-0.3380669653,
-0.6743082404,
-0.0607967228,
0.0755241215,
-0.0163823478,
-0.7821787,
0.3457407951,
0.1965752244,
0.4331855178,
0.3189080954,
0.2593362629,
0.8760900497,
-0.862654686,
0.2560153008,
-0.0440023504,
-0.7067161202,
0.3288318217,
-0.2741210163,
0.4313111603,
0.5388985276,
0.143389523,
-0.5929734111,
-0.59980762,
-0.8028107882,
-0.7050001025,
0.4774884284,
0.3312902153,
0.142637834,
-0.1309237331,
0.3575215638,
0.171603635,
0.0685046911,
-0.6204826236,
-0.5841635466,
0.0418175757,
-0.252038151,
-0.2930110693,
-0.0203464665,
0.0563382767,
-0.2376125604,
0.6836085916,
-0.2667604387,
0.2023279369,
0.2233596742,
-0.2548295259,
0.2640070617,
0.3356998563,
0.3318698108,
0.4223478734,
0.0821749195,
-0.0196921397,
0.3990693688,
-0.0338717811,
0.3305317163,
0.2437085211,
-0.5012824535,
0.4039862752,
0.5330762267,
1.097917676,
0.4377105534,
-0.5167562366,
0.5419872403,
-0.0141944289,
-0.3654254973,
-0.1525432169,
-0.0212401617,
-0.0612895265,
0.1238774508,
0.1049526855,
-0.1254203469,
0.2163854539,
-0.200425148,
0.1030302197,
0.4880844355,
-0.3601998389,
-0.3916187286,
0.4814468026,
-0.2337508053,
-0.181367442,
0.3556404412,
-0.4779650569,
-0.4608637094,
0.3709537089,
0.4572685659,
0.597849369,
-0.0345719792,
0.3125534952,
0.0842122138,
0.253880173,
-0.2272125334,
0.4161158502,
0.2509725094,
-0.7435290217,
-0.1561030746,
-0.6299120784,
-0.3600761592,
0.2544429004,
-0.9338111877,
0.1276346445,
-0.2322648913,
-0.0824176446,
0.1716854274,
-0.5166369677,
-0.5549279451,
0.1270849705,
0.3563269973,
0.7544582486,
-0.8608742952,
0.8670515418,
0.6906241775,
-0.0310052205,
-0.2121587694,
0.1875675023,
-0.0477564111,
-0.588704288,
0.4605052173,
0.1760269254,
-0.4215440154,
0.147037968,
-0.2772566974,
-0.9796387553,
0.6264717579,
0.2236923128,
-0.148588419,
-0.2944161296,
0.2410974056,
0.8331730962,
0.0313025899,
-0.082463637,
0.4367668927,
0.3890769482,
-0.1758556664,
-0.6068435907,
-0.2293319106,
-0.4672056735,
0.1266822368,
0.3653927147,
-0.4833171964,
0.3433425128,
-0.1208616868,
-0.6957522035,
0.1373435855,
0.8535848856,
-0.2700599134,
-0.0136734303,
0.7209128141,
0.8812551498,
0.7756468654,
-0.2894149125,
1.2943515778,
-0.1984201521,
-0.0000219751,
1.1305480003,
-0.5785732865,
1.0668551922,
0.3887999058,
-0.2282870859,
0.3914816976,
0.7218976021,
-0.2053071409,
0.733710885,
0.1327403933,
0.0210592505,
-0.1796808243,
-0.251549989,
-0.1146675423,
0.7893119454,
0.1521178186,
0.1985107213,
-0.2843419015,
0.3096079528,
0.0791579336,
0.0095139872,
0.2434816957,
1.0589388609,
-0.1756916791,
-0.8843684196,
1.0179884434,
0.2692829072,
0.8108820915,
-0.5232226849,
0.3186352849,
-0.3666933775,
0.2372244,
0.1658285707,
-0.432346344,
0.183588922,
0.1061751768,
-0.1992311478,
0.0317637771,
0.1856441498,
-0.2899518013,
-0.9014987946,
0.6399049759,
0.6869184375,
0.0374336727,
0.4422954023,
-0.6191767454,
-0.3483366966,
-0.2116136104,
-0.2672922611,
0.3470771313,
0.5116913319,
-0.0339693576,
0.5130633712,
0.4339908361,
-0.0747002959,
0.3091412187,
0.3960877657,
0.4660512209,
-0.2687812448,
-0.5141454339,
-0.8981081843,
-0.0210866537,
-0.1681756377,
-0.3226736188,
0.710598588,
0.5461708307,
0.9458302855,
0.0856194347,
0.6625834107,
-0.0864043683,
0.1077294946,
-0.4825102389,
0.5609481931,
-0.7910951972,
-0.2826176882,
-0.2602051198,
-0.5840669274,
-0.2706673443,
0.2066440284,
-0.1565935761,
-0.3029094636,
0.7339068055,
0.7516542077,
-0.0888152272,
0.4394637644,
0.4430240989,
0.2020977437,
0.0484699644,
0.4483176172,
0.5377441049,
-0.7530463338,
0.55955863,
-0.6123603582,
-0.0588620454,
0.1679746658,
-0.488209933,
-0.8641495109,
-0.5184265971,
-0.3299699128,
-0.389662683,
0.2779861689,
0.7231607437,
0.3941951394,
-0.9205760956,
-0.079864718,
-0.3996709585,
-0.2941885889,
-0.1277036667,
-0.1716956198,
0.5259665251,
-0.2707891166,
-1.0573887825,
0.7767724991,
0.122546874,
0.4631329477,
0.1051656827,
-0.0487707183,
-0.3043971658,
0.0238480121,
0.5030143261,
0.1567037255,
-0.9451072812,
-0.2770159841,
0.1337458938,
-0.35771209,
0.1662413031,
0.6344234943,
-0.3272128105,
0.2204512358,
0.3560581803,
0.8134613037,
0.0627562255,
-0.4207150936,
0.7242073417,
-0.6931508183,
0.5441474915,
-0.2728729844,
0.751247406,
0.3776955605,
-0.2760994434,
0.5924776196,
0.2938757241,
0.1470054686,
-0.771109283,
0.3172342181,
-0.275375247,
-0.3985082209,
1.0204451084,
-0.1554528773,
-0.2048375607,
-0.1343848258,
0.1797182858,
0.3383127153,
-0.0093407203,
0.594678998,
1.0492070913,
0.0428470969,
0.0052055949,
-0.5558220744,
0.349028796,
0.8842931986,
-0.6646313667,
0.0222895183,
0.4028373957,
-0.0990681052,
0.1646337509,
0.1430511028,
-0.156415686,
0.0342851877,
-0.0966369584,
-0.1995580792,
0.0591330603,
-0.1671396792,
-0.5073426366,
0.1816067547,
-0.1351000816,
-0.2552273273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04508v1 | Enhancing In-Context Learning with Answer Feedback for Multi-Span Question Answering | 2023-06-07T15:20:24 | 2023-06-07T15:20:24 | Zixian Huang, Jiaying Zhou, Gengyang Xiao, Gong Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Whereas the recent emergence of large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT has
exhibited impressive general performance, it still has a large gap with
fully-supervised models on specific tasks such as multi-span question
answering. Previous researches found that in-context learning is an effective
approach to exploiting LLM, by using a few task-related labeled data as
demonstration examples to construct a few-shot prompt for answering new
questions. A popular implementation is to concatenate a few questions and their
correct answers through simple templates, informing LLM of the desired output.
In this paper, we propose a novel way of employing labeled data such that it
also informs LLM of some undesired output, by extending demonstration examples
with feedback about answers predicted by an off-the-shelf model, e.g., correct,
incorrect, or incomplete. Experiments on three multi-span question answering
datasets as well as a keyphrase extraction dataset show that our new prompting
strategy consistently improves LLM's in-context learning performance. | [
-0.3601683974,
-0.9623531103,
0.3410928249,
0.2084870487,
-0.2197521925,
0.0967276096,
-0.3441461921,
-0.2963024974,
-0.0539037809,
0.2114133835,
-0.7883825302,
-0.4176872969,
-0.3298615515,
0.0990453362,
-0.2299526632,
1.264092207,
0.0377064459,
0.1066257656,
-0.4629054666,
-0.0209640581,
-0.8438701034,
-0.6320351958,
-0.6990743876,
-0.2007755935,
0.6803871989,
0.8477897644,
0.1262849718,
0.2939659357,
0.0305967536,
0.1905661523,
-0.1078875363,
0.5782708526,
-0.3982062936,
0.3096397519,
0.1529583484,
-0.4544043243,
-0.3006039262,
-0.0421393067,
0.7049328685,
0.7600293756,
-0.0252070539,
0.0519539826,
0.5860478878,
0.3660358191,
-0.4530762732,
0.2735725045,
-0.5394387841,
-0.0713065863,
-0.0544299483,
-0.4138575792,
-0.8256739378,
-0.5610005856,
0.2862248421,
-0.4933334887,
-0.054905206,
-0.0768926591,
0.428861171,
0.3186732829,
-0.4227071702,
-0.4711464345,
-0.4773996472,
0.5792792439,
-0.7203391194,
0.0970804393,
0.2841550708,
0.4261100292,
-0.0421516411,
-0.5748843551,
-0.3993704319,
-0.2052995414,
-0.2159305513,
0.4967504144,
0.1341445893,
-0.1510399431,
0.1238378137,
-0.0154532837,
-0.214812398,
0.039726343,
-0.384365797,
-0.0811453983,
0.2941457927,
0.0491894372,
-0.0108742397,
-0.117423743,
-0.6027953029,
-0.065464288,
-1.0326814651,
0.414222002,
0.0576900207,
0.5810852051,
-0.0090958402,
0.671770215,
-0.2145038545,
0.9699193239,
0.2669340074,
0.0682010427,
0.1419291198,
-0.2824461758,
0.0211557709,
-0.0023956252,
0.4457269609,
0.4376814663,
0.0379342921,
-0.278405726,
-0.005890565,
-0.2373775542,
-0.0739206374,
-0.8304315209,
-0.1917956024,
0.1614045501,
-0.1634275913,
-0.0260179993,
0.0488509685,
-0.9588114619,
-0.384162724,
-0.0314566791,
0.6934495568,
-0.3391037881,
0.015202499,
0.1581946164,
-0.1734005362,
0.2816678286,
0.5984264612,
-0.7553937435,
0.2011834681,
0.4023038149,
0.7024456263,
-0.0945580155,
-0.2497125268,
-1.2293279171,
0.1567681879,
-0.2288883924,
0.8568313122,
-0.5895922184,
-0.2036002427,
0.102158986,
-0.0056594554,
-0.1800213158,
-0.4897740185,
0.1395933479,
-0.62833184,
0.5610084534,
-0.3457639813,
-0.9053507447,
-0.0449229255,
0.576874733,
-0.3650835454,
1.1549597979,
-0.0385613181,
-0.7628263235,
0.2992079258,
-0.8053621054,
-0.217644915,
0.1477694809,
-0.0822292194,
-0.2754154503,
-0.1569569856,
0.629643321,
0.5515912175,
0.1799607873,
0.149931252,
-0.3535336256,
-0.4551541805,
0.5339138508,
-0.5677716732,
0.3575412631,
-0.0624849573,
-0.2017797232,
0.1969271898,
-0.5442094803,
0.1365101039,
-0.2527425885,
-0.7649394274,
-0.0817289129,
-0.1727848649,
-0.181186378,
0.2739294171,
0.1163325608,
-0.6749774218,
0.3965435326,
-0.3650041521,
0.2295999378,
0.5264077187,
0.2901409864,
0.3345247507,
-0.4612603486,
0.7342798114,
-0.1391815394,
-0.232372269,
-0.6405463815,
-0.5164493322,
-0.6088560224,
-0.2969267666,
0.2452200055,
0.3544216156,
-0.839302659,
0.015889585,
-0.1724609137,
-0.3060356081,
-0.3826476336,
0.2544437647,
0.4896144867,
0.9139814973,
0.5329353809,
-0.0230439603,
-0.5108107328,
-0.3406917453,
-0.1896141469,
-0.0974720418,
-0.110737808,
0.5144971013,
0.3606075346,
0.135163635,
1.2999168634,
-0.5101382136,
-0.0285910554,
-0.5600309372,
0.0421168357,
0.1060786992,
0.2494424134,
0.1567304879,
-0.5539005995,
-0.5892890692,
-0.2347142547,
-0.4210975766,
-0.1432442665,
-0.041808825,
0.0168966465,
-0.0949327052,
0.719327569,
-0.2932663262,
0.0953413472,
0.4448799789,
-0.0746746659,
0.5759191513,
-0.189685002,
-0.0251251645,
-1.252645731,
-0.1666832417,
-0.1240287572,
-0.2760914862,
-0.5796493888,
-0.1120827049,
0.2999769151,
0.0529430658,
-0.7115589976,
0.6100842357,
-0.215694651,
0.2190501541,
-0.281853348,
0.2454543263,
0.0619628504,
0.5494186878,
0.135636732,
0.8413303494,
0.3886024058,
-0.6898872256,
0.3306601346,
0.5125043392,
-0.3148398697,
0.4317357838,
-0.6731472015,
0.2086581886,
-0.458576113,
0.8556825519,
-1.4621764421,
-0.557624042,
0.075842239,
-0.5158573985,
0.2738201916,
-0.3698307872,
-0.4665109813,
-0.2225219756,
-0.3950988948,
0.3311714828,
0.3141669035,
-0.9923141599,
0.1557579041,
0.0678032711,
-0.1500207186,
-0.6003661156,
-0.6258866191,
-0.196757108,
-0.5401481986,
-0.3425454199,
0.2489024699,
-0.314362675,
0.2508101463,
-0.2665323019,
-0.0587042011,
-0.0884349644,
0.0797169507,
0.073227711,
0.2791729569,
-0.0728053823,
0.5486653447,
-0.0420212671,
0.0628657714,
-0.0340874717,
-0.0558350869,
0.5057795048,
-0.2735604048,
-0.3726753592,
-0.2230787575,
0.3321605027,
0.224129647,
-0.2795483172,
0.5220655203,
0.4292522669,
-0.3129270971,
-0.3511090577,
-0.1554363817,
-0.5320627093,
-0.4454088211,
0.3715577424,
-0.2069320232,
-1.1730103493,
0.3164639175,
-0.4130841494,
0.1733107716,
-0.0086355619,
0.5399317145,
-0.4309659302,
0.992187798,
0.4833720922,
0.0347014703,
0.3970820904,
-0.1339505017,
0.1518515646,
-0.9987688065,
-0.4816131592,
-0.4560284019,
-0.1248897836,
-0.2170110494,
-0.2915724814,
0.5971515775,
0.3199315667,
-0.1767313927,
0.149570629,
-0.3158598244,
0.5648745894,
0.4930539131,
0.4185164571,
0.2420717776,
-0.2068480104,
-0.2649454176,
0.0111409249,
-0.9562997818,
-0.2973833084,
0.9600394368,
0.2080150843,
0.9240236282,
0.0816474631,
0.6731259227,
-0.1276656091,
0.5658265352,
-0.7300978303,
0.1529653966,
0.164088279,
-0.5508496761,
-0.3217146695,
-0.1982013881,
-0.8994787335,
0.3891622424,
-0.040548902,
-0.9563583732,
-0.0967493802,
0.4532899261,
-0.687307477,
-0.0037126106,
-0.730514586,
0.8098970056,
-0.0034170393,
-0.3503194153,
0.2589516938,
-0.7566539645,
0.3269771636,
0.0959845036,
0.143606782,
0.2065122128,
0.1040095091,
0.6490308046,
-0.383082062,
1.3742413521,
-0.2859348655,
-0.1582314819,
0.4140821397,
-0.2662400603,
0.6292148829,
0.221448794,
-0.0133472206,
-0.7840279937,
-0.1011895314,
-0.1966804117,
-0.8354377747,
0.5559177399,
-0.3964654207,
-0.5152667165,
-0.0467568859,
-0.7175120711,
-0.7810642719,
-0.1521622688,
0.3931747675,
0.7273480296,
0.0726065189,
0.5339749455,
0.7607515454,
-0.2635319829,
0.5205544233,
0.3640714884,
-0.2311103344,
-0.3562511802,
0.6457436085,
-0.0656818151,
0.3776229322,
0.4357343614,
0.3771588802,
-0.7844218016,
-0.0578981601,
-0.6841303706,
0.0702160671,
-0.9965108633,
-0.3506116271,
-0.6000609398,
-0.1213087514,
-0.1728022695,
-0.1562520266,
-0.1063432544,
-0.2750543058,
0.0438392237,
-0.1835960001,
0.3957664669,
0.6546282768,
0.1925802082,
0.5303638577,
-0.757199347,
-0.1374150813,
0.6410319209,
0.2144289017,
0.1744426042,
-0.5114156604,
-0.2577979565,
0.1568483263,
-0.4586344361,
-1.221050024,
0.0654368177,
0.3360350132,
0.4172304869,
0.2032415867,
0.1629353017,
0.8486013412,
-0.4539040029,
0.8704112172,
0.0270749182,
-0.8755142689,
0.6799905896,
-0.2798081934,
0.6277137995,
0.437571466,
0.2838128805,
-0.8590476513,
-0.5241761804,
-0.4191089272,
-0.8173351288,
0.5779871941,
-0.2231335342,
0.4325050712,
-0.2339662611,
0.2761504948,
0.2180203646,
0.2837401927,
-0.8013781309,
-0.1914044023,
-0.0993634835,
-0.1410647482,
0.0739586428,
-0.147346288,
-0.1382429004,
-0.350948751,
0.6059570312,
-0.5381968021,
0.1342612356,
0.1492144167,
-0.1971122622,
0.3139413297,
0.5693717003,
0.4673864543,
0.5801734924,
-0.1967836618,
0.2800822556,
0.5099084377,
0.0834393725,
0.1391183883,
-0.0546640493,
-0.0356198996,
0.0232751109,
0.2871347964,
0.5943343639,
0.3123763204,
-0.5912424922,
0.6725744605,
0.0598027483,
-0.1519575268,
0.0254155863,
-0.0990011394,
0.2927927673,
0.156878531,
0.4753549099,
-0.13978374,
0.0362482183,
-0.3732073903,
0.4171629846,
0.4099275768,
-0.6877388954,
-0.11995776,
0.6513019204,
0.0977146477,
0.0116936592,
0.5853943825,
0.0544213466,
-0.6717873216,
0.5810153484,
0.9537200332,
0.3290444911,
-0.0759078711,
0.4615059197,
0.4710142612,
0.0515295304,
-0.0152176302,
0.234984681,
-0.4826759696,
-0.6274671555,
-0.6676772833,
-0.178421393,
-0.6884589791,
0.1874120831,
-0.754633069,
0.1312661916,
-0.1464346945,
0.1319146156,
-0.0817346349,
-0.1626647115,
-0.4408236742,
0.2602057755,
0.028816605,
0.8908681273,
-0.8733174801,
0.8719580173,
0.6892216206,
-0.4571815729,
-0.954693377,
0.1888433993,
-0.0434001684,
-0.529278636,
0.5336886048,
0.5729600191,
-0.1422685087,
0.0519899689,
-0.7641780972,
-0.7602217793,
0.902331531,
0.356677711,
-0.1138640717,
0.2231031209,
-0.0638319328,
0.4484010339,
-0.4612177312,
0.4160900712,
0.2221420258,
0.3731979728,
0.2331006825,
-0.7029781342,
0.0312953778,
-0.2367490232,
-0.1673892885,
-0.0625144765,
-0.5777339935,
0.5255575776,
-0.3320486546,
-0.0694613978,
0.0292203352,
0.668368578,
0.5459766388,
0.159480378,
0.5295938253,
0.1408525407,
1.0065300465,
-0.0792605057,
1.0720119476,
0.0211228654,
0.3465196788,
1.5157986879,
-0.141897738,
1.0611689091,
0.6177217364,
0.0740623474,
0.4959286153,
0.9009083509,
0.1394372731,
0.7458792925,
0.3045853376,
-0.3689830005,
-0.2363918871,
-0.1383136511,
-0.3082141876,
0.349140197,
0.3628503084,
-0.03801772,
-0.5390924811,
0.1721391678,
0.2496345043,
-0.0522679836,
-0.1009880155,
0.7906153798,
-0.1814518124,
-0.9632577896,
0.5505362749,
-0.2219462097,
0.8048790693,
-0.5549676418,
-0.2135922462,
-0.4445234835,
0.1358787417,
-0.2438400388,
-0.8110309839,
0.2040933967,
0.094534494,
-0.1749593318,
-0.2975350916,
0.2334620059,
-0.8857468963,
-0.136542663,
0.0692416653,
0.5486306548,
0.1099626645,
0.0479070619,
-0.3447884321,
-0.3558834791,
-0.0221320707,
-0.0783316717,
0.2580475807,
0.3110002577,
-0.0727276057,
0.6956825256,
0.5280399919,
-0.2416789234,
0.2695425153,
0.0573782362,
0.8879398704,
-0.1609378159,
-0.5755695105,
-0.7774386406,
0.6865323782,
-0.1924090236,
-0.4223408401,
1.0508753061,
0.5613793731,
0.9930689335,
-0.0609537289,
0.9074550271,
0.1013354808,
0.6509547234,
-0.4046886265,
0.3885641992,
-0.6069338918,
0.3623252511,
-0.2622386217,
-0.5989947319,
-0.3417246938,
0.3698495328,
-0.173544094,
0.0284519363,
0.798419416,
0.8088551164,
0.0188598596,
-0.093765296,
0.1511881053,
-0.0573754795,
0.3126446009,
0.6695770621,
0.9961984158,
-0.2571821213,
0.799702704,
-0.1979724169,
-0.2416922599,
-0.1592320353,
-0.816778481,
-0.8576212525,
-0.6605728865,
-0.3502993286,
-0.5275253654,
-0.1076666936,
0.8938489556,
0.8361716866,
-0.6983565688,
-0.1439834684,
0.2176527083,
0.0882024541,
-0.4124259651,
-0.1959839016,
0.5747126341,
-0.6961629987,
-0.7864547372,
0.6944747567,
0.1110437512,
-0.0423981771,
0.0815757364,
-0.1647817791,
-0.072392039,
-0.0257394463,
0.5782508254,
0.2484412193,
-0.5937955976,
-0.3442124426,
0.1446445882,
0.050445307,
0.2230368406,
0.6586940885,
-0.842620194,
0.5381339192,
0.3803470731,
1.0207692385,
0.6207096577,
0.2987344563,
0.6181417704,
-1.3908927441,
-0.0882889181,
0.0896161422,
0.2207236588,
0.438681066,
-0.3802776039,
0.2932117879,
-0.2065963894,
-0.3965469599,
-0.5060569048,
0.2303467989,
-0.6579210162,
-0.2945141792,
1.14047575,
-0.3665671647,
-0.0522831492,
-0.1084915847,
-0.4119146168,
0.1820098758,
-0.3093711436,
0.7824151516,
0.8016913533,
-0.2707153261,
-0.3464349806,
-0.4838356078,
0.6054654121,
0.6082672477,
-1.0912593603,
0.1780596823,
0.5677755475,
0.3279043138,
-0.2121185809,
0.6466318369,
-0.0552409813,
0.4375426769,
-0.4649814367,
-0.2962422967,
0.00959267,
-0.4157879651,
-0.472132802,
0.3428311348,
0.0914188251,
-0.5776372552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04504v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04504v3 | Evaluation of ChatGPT on Biomedical Tasks: A Zero-Shot Comparison with Fine-Tuned Generative Transformers | 2023-06-07T15:11:26 | 2023-08-24T13:39:17 | Israt Jahan, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Chun Peng, Jimmy Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT is a large language model developed by OpenAI. Despite its impressive
performance across various tasks, no prior work has investigated its capability
in the biomedical domain yet. To this end, this paper aims to evaluate the
performance of ChatGPT on various benchmark biomedical tasks, such as relation
extraction, document classification, question answering, and summarization. To
the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that conducts an extensive
evaluation of ChatGPT in the biomedical domain. Interestingly, we find based on
our evaluation that in biomedical datasets that have smaller training sets,
zero-shot ChatGPT even outperforms the state-of-the-art fine-tuned generative
transformer models, such as BioGPT and BioBART. This suggests that ChatGPT's
pre-training on large text corpora makes it quite specialized even in the
biomedical domain. Our findings demonstrate that ChatGPT has the potential to
be a valuable tool for various tasks in the biomedical domain that lack large
annotated data. | [
-0.2319986075,
-0.9097533226,
0.6011097431,
0.0334889144,
-0.2616673112,
0.0006986331,
-0.301277101,
-0.578959465,
0.0778900236,
0.0949011371,
-0.3376520872,
-0.485573411,
-0.7267125249,
0.1771735698,
-0.3930665553,
1.4105750322,
0.1566804498,
0.1304073036,
-0.2125936598,
-0.0929611847,
-0.3056901693,
-0.388207376,
-0.7233566046,
-0.4974478483,
0.6371841431,
0.1409727633,
0.7616218925,
0.356749475,
0.9443010092,
0.1792268604,
-0.2516839504,
-0.1385694146,
-0.7545462847,
0.1024520025,
-0.1154831722,
-0.3166359961,
-0.5001203418,
-0.1725785881,
0.5913348198,
0.7657570243,
0.0858497322,
0.0946015194,
0.0386174358,
0.6158823371,
-0.4594197869,
0.3827133775,
-0.4601582885,
0.2585474849,
-0.2765282393,
-0.2896920741,
-0.3629190922,
-0.2054260373,
0.2721548676,
-0.5326361656,
0.5592086315,
-0.0328712426,
0.9423052073,
0.3508768976,
-0.2874289751,
0.0025077271,
-0.821072042,
0.4978273809,
-0.5453310609,
0.441539973,
0.1313173473,
0.4115838408,
-0.2043542713,
-0.8395913243,
-0.4673958719,
-0.3982699215,
-0.0019184977,
0.6811670661,
-0.448925525,
0.2462465316,
0.3230178356,
0.527539134,
-0.9545228481,
0.1205237135,
-0.6336248517,
-0.0071811383,
0.1630067378,
0.0349036492,
0.4384514093,
-0.188658461,
-0.1854775995,
-0.1225921065,
-0.7527564168,
-0.3959823251,
-0.0886960998,
0.0931261033,
-0.0716001242,
0.8744206429,
-0.4524405003,
0.6640965343,
-0.1960764676,
0.2553149164,
0.2672764063,
-0.308116585,
-0.391120255,
-0.0486736037,
1.2198599577,
0.1714753509,
0.2972605228,
-0.5585303903,
0.2287324518,
0.2072539628,
0.4696888328,
-1.1591730118,
-0.3326811194,
0.3310853243,
-0.5018289685,
-0.3281769156,
-0.3765792847,
-0.7493084669,
-0.237482965,
0.1109652817,
0.3968705833,
-0.9515386224,
-0.0214837696,
0.3430654705,
-0.1767746806,
0.3796671331,
0.3097276986,
-0.8843950033,
0.0081611965,
0.794619441,
1.2506525517,
-0.282890439,
-0.1035505012,
-0.4640837312,
-0.0651443675,
-0.1555573046,
1.1686435938,
-0.5409802198,
-0.5187502503,
-0.2669719756,
-0.1106921583,
-0.3743144572,
-0.4089913964,
0.7280973792,
-0.3112694025,
0.1241687387,
0.1038138196,
-0.6355963945,
0.1801464558,
0.313036412,
-0.3217227757,
0.5774357915,
0.226361379,
-0.8791487217,
0.3506266475,
-1.0482130051,
-0.5020493865,
0.537368536,
-0.289837867,
-0.5616351366,
-0.0921771079,
0.1309640706,
0.6204202771,
-0.327113837,
-0.0109572746,
-0.4626722634,
-0.4760392904,
0.4240826666,
-0.5867407918,
0.6458730698,
0.1120444164,
-0.2486967146,
0.1110368669,
-0.6638987064,
-0.0230964124,
0.0351736173,
-0.1193121746,
-0.0899254084,
-0.0660088584,
0.1147308424,
0.0413812995,
-0.0434063002,
-1.0612645149,
0.3512975276,
-0.6806815267,
0.6082373261,
0.218784079,
0.0674245954,
0.1274918169,
-0.2669501901,
0.497464478,
-0.3087849319,
0.1798779368,
-0.1624913067,
-0.7915792465,
-0.5341206789,
-0.5575663447,
0.5694531798,
0.708448112,
-0.7663530111,
0.32211411,
-0.5209043622,
-0.8649445772,
-0.7318200469,
-0.3112825751,
0.411308527,
0.5573000908,
0.5893511772,
-0.4234908223,
-0.142118454,
-0.9794288278,
0.1370902508,
-0.2057709843,
-0.5033989549,
0.3363430202,
0.4615782201,
-0.4710949957,
0.7846061587,
-0.6423417926,
-0.3224079907,
-0.0602658167,
0.459243238,
0.1610955149,
0.4671177566,
0.4892746508,
-0.5092297792,
-0.366394639,
0.4867003262,
-0.9294813275,
-0.0794859529,
-0.0008859778,
-0.1958804727,
-0.232404083,
0.3212204576,
-0.9570939541,
0.4536856413,
0.6016800404,
-0.2373373657,
0.6580340266,
-0.3320715427,
0.2470382154,
-1.0386675596,
0.5750228167,
-0.0970997885,
-0.3610693216,
-0.7123259902,
-0.1084666178,
0.0348424166,
-0.4408843517,
-0.2899942696,
0.4934740365,
-0.072194308,
0.0343725495,
-0.3216265142,
0.0842431933,
-0.3230285347,
0.4143959582,
0.2155676037,
0.8120906353,
0.5500696301,
-0.349783659,
0.159427762,
0.7405352592,
-0.3036889732,
0.4997589588,
-1.1362929344,
0.1519136727,
-0.1833172292,
0.1347708851,
-0.9030156136,
-0.1596242487,
0.3127590716,
-0.6868958473,
0.3579333127,
-0.2156493366,
-0.4837801158,
-0.267942965,
-0.074851729,
0.1928879619,
0.7895035148,
-0.083041124,
-0.0051251245,
0.1494440585,
-0.2790962756,
-0.3563549221,
-0.4844535589,
0.0367599614,
0.0752023757,
-0.4330722094,
0.3672860265,
-0.0727492124,
0.1980274469,
-0.0549905002,
-0.0337760597,
-0.0903638452,
-0.0823500901,
0.4665555656,
0.4225590527,
-0.3842971325,
0.2196709365,
0.053929273,
-0.3292938173,
-0.309889555,
-0.0673049837,
0.6099272966,
-0.219072327,
-0.6220448613,
-0.1455993652,
0.1211255416,
0.4632714391,
-0.2788060606,
0.7530350685,
0.8834759593,
-0.000786458,
0.3449636698,
-0.2864642441,
0.0067359582,
-0.3989534676,
0.6317022443,
-0.0843418539,
-1.0723083019,
0.2596443295,
-0.1159827411,
0.0922367647,
0.6740532517,
0.699301362,
-0.0453932434,
0.7769262195,
0.5310946703,
0.0161684081,
0.3585930169,
-0.1117811725,
0.2999203503,
-0.812463522,
0.0177533217,
-0.6255207658,
-0.0474582203,
-0.8318656683,
-0.4802038372,
0.6777533889,
-0.0076762498,
-0.260363847,
0.4315267801,
-0.5519406199,
0.2387785167,
0.4110296965,
0.395037055,
0.306091994,
-0.0779131949,
0.1622205973,
0.2400518209,
-0.7913448811,
-0.5539906621,
1.0877642632,
0.3567164838,
0.60515064,
-0.1407075375,
0.4741406441,
0.0959822014,
0.5945596099,
-1.059728384,
0.3588240147,
-0.3870514035,
-0.4747250676,
-0.4561348557,
-0.450160712,
-1.4604350328,
0.1931700855,
-0.3000926673,
-0.8121298552,
0.0290138647,
0.0105475225,
-0.5361012816,
0.1191702858,
-0.7273957133,
1.1059859991,
0.1631861925,
-0.1894157827,
-0.0220506042,
-0.6129679084,
0.1005468369,
-0.1931574941,
-0.3508184254,
-0.1925943792,
0.1041150838,
0.6494138241,
-0.1818848997,
0.8028216958,
0.0902377293,
0.1549019217,
0.0529999658,
-0.0296294149,
-0.0939567611,
0.0530800894,
0.0206871834,
0.6284783483,
0.4823794961,
-0.462972194,
-0.4716635346,
0.4550468028,
-0.6804149151,
-0.1599773765,
-0.3403376043,
-0.4138802886,
-0.5172663927,
0.3918215334,
0.532530129,
0.4618995786,
-0.6614668965,
0.5528532267,
0.6816671491,
-0.5792534947,
0.2305182964,
0.4934749007,
-0.0462953746,
-0.1144453958,
0.8553730845,
-0.2097951919,
0.3719501197,
0.5604627132,
0.057413213,
0.0394017808,
-0.6450699568,
-0.7194812298,
0.2275400907,
-0.2303821892,
-0.369143635,
-0.8544952273,
-0.5787817836,
-0.4571700096,
0.0583779402,
-0.4733231962,
-0.2618804276,
0.1075103134,
0.2252226025,
0.2850257158,
0.5849901438,
0.1643195003,
0.4824986756,
-0.9849232435,
0.4522845745,
0.1392034143,
0.505335927,
-0.3673640192,
-0.3130788505,
-0.1021337509,
0.0901225954,
-0.3718183041,
-0.8207711577,
0.2601036429,
0.2715832889,
0.4750449359,
0.383343786,
-0.3001358509,
0.5153441429,
-0.797927618,
0.6898314953,
0.1253619194,
-0.4823864996,
0.4595105946,
-0.6221911907,
0.5178948045,
0.5273371935,
0.4469324648,
-0.7098916173,
-0.4211083651,
-0.6729164124,
-0.6963877082,
0.4630896747,
0.7845801711,
0.0075130868,
-0.0913496688,
0.2260332406,
0.1795257032,
0.1556773037,
-0.4481993318,
-0.1137536988,
-0.0711130053,
-0.1984176636,
-0.1356700659,
-0.1206911132,
0.0224512164,
-0.0805436745,
0.5185357928,
-0.2513209581,
0.8896948099,
0.4460140765,
0.0199482199,
0.1555762589,
0.504073143,
0.3938251138,
0.2345098704,
-0.3395886123,
-0.2107228637,
0.078184545,
-0.7778346539,
-0.3460973203,
0.4641165733,
-0.2407820523,
0.1050591245,
0.5985950828,
0.8728868961,
0.2060651034,
-0.760109961,
0.6648064256,
-0.2003017664,
-0.2071351856,
0.0919281244,
0.0561119504,
-0.0834806338,
0.1087976396,
-0.0047301184,
0.2650983334,
0.3716097474,
-0.3464608788,
0.2243068963,
0.4939388335,
-0.6774607301,
-0.2840480804,
0.7273831367,
-0.0177939739,
-0.0614003018,
0.6786947846,
-0.1111778542,
-0.1928299516,
0.3963311613,
0.5756231546,
0.8926469088,
-0.1765762269,
0.3574474752,
0.3803367317,
0.1737910807,
0.107293196,
-0.0293555912,
-0.1890205443,
-0.666723907,
-0.7691429257,
-0.8997412324,
-0.6481254101,
0.1411819309,
-0.5533208847,
0.2222744226,
-0.0595967434,
-0.0393011943,
0.5706899166,
-0.3797047436,
-0.7285972238,
0.0902063549,
-0.0101251323,
0.6561778188,
-0.5924767852,
0.8756676912,
0.6075245738,
-0.5251383781,
-0.3165729344,
0.0569462143,
-0.3585703969,
-0.8830407262,
0.5981569886,
0.1325575262,
0.0647011399,
-0.1206005514,
-0.424226284,
-0.5523976088,
0.8174631,
0.473888129,
-0.5482614636,
-0.0270799436,
0.3919346929,
1.0821763277,
0.2434099764,
0.6273483038,
0.4530390799,
0.1304293126,
0.2045155168,
-1.36203897,
-0.1880315244,
-0.4213197529,
-0.2166534364,
0.2112881243,
-0.6094236374,
0.5736233592,
0.0752907991,
-0.2025217861,
0.1981456727,
0.3829024434,
-0.0408653766,
0.197223708,
0.1319921464,
0.2934295833,
0.5527120233,
-0.179234758,
1.314183116,
-0.3334203064,
0.534017086,
0.8328996301,
-0.3191971779,
0.8839483857,
0.0916249231,
-0.3851103783,
0.1221102998,
0.3535880148,
-0.0717557371,
0.3063223362,
0.0309592579,
-0.399361372,
-0.0003505955,
-0.0447049066,
-0.5258475542,
0.5985221267,
0.3111129105,
-0.2345619798,
-0.347867161,
0.1838299632,
-0.0598004721,
-0.3883556426,
-0.1618582308,
0.9512176514,
0.0971766636,
-0.5194596648,
0.4665202796,
-0.1984932572,
0.6042732596,
-0.7443419695,
-0.1018281057,
-0.1077356488,
0.1985720247,
-0.0499847978,
-0.927259028,
0.5294435024,
0.0939095914,
0.1317778975,
-0.1247640178,
1.1156134605,
-0.2345800847,
-0.3351117671,
0.0994726866,
0.5541961193,
0.4650362432,
-0.3335085809,
-0.5527288318,
-0.306812197,
-0.123904027,
-0.2226502001,
0.4172470868,
0.4055373669,
0.2104157805,
0.590796411,
0.6113238931,
0.2799990177,
-0.28362149,
0.0040675402,
0.7465240955,
-0.6089209914,
-0.1518959552,
-0.9289945364,
0.0071326708,
-0.2561857998,
-0.3615938723,
0.5917875171,
0.7698212862,
0.6271437407,
-0.2900998294,
0.8514568806,
-0.2339931577,
0.6092056036,
-0.3365471959,
0.9527039528,
-0.1932801455,
-0.2674918771,
-0.3107821047,
-0.7038831711,
-0.5323036909,
0.6796559691,
-0.4837946892,
-0.0013630218,
0.8607426286,
0.762432158,
-0.2208109647,
0.2003457248,
0.6718354225,
0.2015663385,
0.3257113993,
0.5342193246,
0.5851747394,
-0.462126404,
0.6337687373,
-0.1502520442,
-0.3915762901,
-0.0311256088,
-0.7390167713,
-1.0084733963,
-0.5022776127,
-0.3483926356,
-0.3095802665,
0.1675170958,
0.6005644798,
0.7775766253,
-0.8201266527,
0.1926518232,
-0.0769860521,
-0.5245842934,
-0.1596507579,
-0.1879741997,
0.4877934158,
-0.439452529,
-0.7232753038,
0.3905084431,
0.7015911937,
0.0290257055,
-0.0434079096,
0.2396291494,
0.1044074222,
-0.209962815,
0.881819427,
0.4924305975,
-0.2636531293,
-0.2734246254,
0.1070566252,
-0.2186868638,
0.2986521423,
0.7832792997,
-0.7941699028,
0.3696281314,
0.4890697896,
0.8419032693,
0.7713091373,
-0.0150113003,
0.5206057429,
-0.5657697916,
0.1032899767,
0.3177848756,
0.2588493228,
0.2843366861,
-0.311689049,
0.8161848783,
0.0944345742,
-0.9861988425,
-0.5127402544,
-0.1088092923,
-1.4511418343,
-0.0952037424,
1.2458956242,
-0.0995436981,
-0.2180417627,
-0.1130825281,
-0.597681582,
0.5683857799,
-0.1751136929,
0.9694930911,
0.3562144935,
-0.3311307132,
0.1937794089,
-1.0856745243,
0.4523708522,
0.6044701934,
-1.0619139671,
-0.0183156654,
0.2757621408,
0.2220941037,
0.1970652491,
0.8514379859,
-0.3322229683,
0.2679504156,
0.0422319472,
0.1799247116,
0.1428218484,
0.1829265952,
-0.1752830148,
0.129187718,
-0.0185962934,
-0.3553714454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04441v1 | STEPS: A Benchmark for Order Reasoning in Sequential Tasks | 2023-06-07T13:58:55 | 2023-06-07T13:58:55 | Weizhi Wang, Hong Wang, Xifeng Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Various human activities can be abstracted into a sequence of actions in
natural text, i.e. cooking, repairing, manufacturing, etc. Such action
sequences heavily depend on the executing order, while disorder in action
sequences leads to failure of further task execution by robots or AI agents.
Therefore, to verify the order reasoning capability of current neural models in
sequential tasks, we propose a challenging benchmark , named STEPS. STEPS
involves two subtask settings, focusing on determining the rationality of given
next step in recipes and selecting the reasonable step from the multi-choice
question, respectively. We describe the data construction and task
formulations, and benchmark most of significant Large Language Models (LLMs).
The experimental results demonstrate 1) The commonsense reasoning of action
orders in sequential tasks are challenging to resolve via zero-shot prompting
or few-shot in-context learning for LLMs; 2) Prompting method still
significantly lags behind tuning-based method on STEPS. | [
0.0588680916,
-0.6857200861,
0.704241097,
0.1724156588,
0.1406777352,
-0.2516489029,
0.2110432386,
-0.2615039051,
-0.2043415755,
0.4669691026,
-0.8076250553,
-0.4308652282,
-0.5669651031,
0.4184607863,
-0.4631698132,
0.4392418861,
-0.0725286081,
0.2248954624,
-0.1367316395,
-0.3293844163,
-0.6636177301,
-0.4193938673,
-1.027035594,
-0.4607218206,
0.7618065476,
0.3782076538,
0.6018157601,
0.5105810165,
0.471267879,
0.4437307417,
-0.1533771604,
0.4481333792,
-0.0241860468,
0.4629400074,
-0.362472713,
-0.4622152448,
-0.3589307368,
0.1586539596,
0.2894850969,
0.7761503458,
-0.0193839278,
0.2566865981,
-0.3397636116,
0.6618176699,
-0.5839831233,
0.0744144022,
-0.2669535577,
0.0321892016,
0.1162496954,
0.0362470932,
-0.5334308743,
-0.1547599435,
-0.0631497204,
-0.3726609945,
-0.0188749991,
0.2306156307,
0.6088368893,
0.5344998837,
-0.2514491677,
-0.2222885042,
-0.4636175632,
0.6567789912,
-0.7094717622,
0.3985921741,
0.6521501541,
0.2378356159,
-0.4361074269,
-0.9065514803,
-0.5801237226,
-0.3063520491,
-0.0582700856,
-0.0192970298,
0.2544347942,
-0.0920659676,
0.6576250792,
-0.0139822569,
-0.6616002321,
0.248788476,
-0.0457322858,
0.1977562308,
0.6888841987,
0.5316220522,
0.1932269782,
-0.2585292459,
-0.3452908397,
-0.3061386943,
-0.5057805777,
0.2746853232,
0.1589570194,
0.2845494747,
0.0782831237,
0.5979302526,
-0.567837894,
0.7674894929,
0.0231303181,
0.0361996181,
0.0763183534,
-0.4493879974,
-0.4988306165,
-0.2227887809,
0.6420559287,
0.3236173689,
0.126271382,
0.0573178157,
-0.2592006326,
-0.1384772062,
0.3545854986,
-0.5749458075,
-0.0838819519,
0.4929414392,
-0.2300190032,
0.1291552484,
-0.3714212179,
-0.3011113703,
-0.6299903393,
-0.3693828583,
0.4426010847,
-0.4560001493,
0.1113864481,
0.1128718629,
0.206896469,
0.2851470113,
0.5244574547,
-0.9107196331,
0.4310614169,
1.0041923523,
0.8050403595,
-0.1570592672,
-0.6832963824,
-0.5828844309,
-0.3416025639,
-0.7233914137,
0.9140238166,
-0.4043250978,
-0.1704487801,
-0.2136046737,
0.0222242046,
-0.3762325048,
-0.5917136669,
0.6385193467,
-0.5932306051,
-0.1519771367,
-0.6078938842,
-0.5889657736,
-0.3326997161,
0.4990299344,
-0.4697013497,
1.140950799,
-0.0608356968,
-0.3823215663,
0.5062025189,
-0.4884549081,
-0.7251867652,
0.1078898013,
-0.2701185048,
0.0102213155,
-0.0744837448,
0.0637284517,
0.8155284524,
-0.3116506636,
0.1134084985,
-0.1717477739,
-0.2735942602,
0.2532014251,
-0.2453363389,
0.8193455338,
0.0459112898,
-0.3376159668,
0.3632875383,
-0.5606514215,
0.0357687101,
0.1675136387,
-0.2353373468,
-0.2940434217,
0.3932748437,
-0.5067145824,
0.504840076,
0.0725259632,
-0.164733395,
0.238271907,
-0.1999920607,
0.4804094732,
0.7551608682,
0.0236322228,
0.3281956315,
-0.4353178442,
0.168678537,
0.0892200619,
0.1845421046,
-0.3266176283,
-0.7923277617,
-0.6816026568,
-0.0126417698,
0.356099695,
0.9030617476,
-0.6265459061,
0.3428406715,
-0.189920947,
-0.3952050209,
-0.019157866,
-0.1034822688,
0.5019518137,
0.5185489655,
0.3813107312,
-0.4064477086,
-0.250531286,
-0.6800439954,
-0.3559537828,
-0.306812942,
-0.1056978628,
0.1381552666,
0.7265666127,
0.0670879185,
0.2855312824,
-0.27887398,
0.3282172084,
-0.1011457369,
0.8004736304,
0.360483259,
0.529422164,
-0.1641186029,
-0.7189041376,
-0.2137654573,
-0.1187455356,
-0.6464990377,
0.1641710103,
-0.414662987,
-0.1945344508,
0.2316492051,
0.7493271232,
-0.7242307067,
0.4522899389,
0.1219852269,
-0.299174279,
0.4196700752,
-0.3064615428,
0.4443871975,
-0.7296002507,
0.0518169217,
-0.0438139066,
-0.0479334965,
-0.7320531011,
0.0199435484,
0.178192988,
0.1215702295,
-0.4029068947,
0.5409628749,
-0.2308518738,
-0.3133405745,
0.0081999479,
-0.3013520837,
-0.3273321986,
0.7660467029,
0.3530810773,
0.4993343651,
0.2739773393,
-0.6246368289,
0.1819564849,
0.1212155968,
-0.6171358228,
0.5021247268,
-0.6978343725,
0.2220735848,
-0.03718156,
0.1310801357,
-1.3253822327,
-0.2707068622,
0.1805504113,
-0.3535785377,
-0.0006100072,
-0.1785834283,
-1.0224233866,
-0.427600503,
0.2593042552,
0.3946692348,
0.5164586306,
-0.2414741367,
0.4456325769,
-0.2581811249,
-0.1642362922,
-0.5948116183,
-0.4841583669,
-0.0574515797,
-0.026123004,
-0.4952109456,
0.1816266328,
-0.2471250445,
-0.4418771267,
-0.4169632792,
-0.4341922402,
-0.1556778997,
0.0888523832,
0.2677794993,
0.0828527957,
-0.0295016449,
-0.2211747468,
-0.0654571056,
-0.0298571326,
0.237791121,
-0.0352791585,
0.3196649253,
0.1463355422,
-0.5179062486,
-0.2153570503,
0.3706896603,
0.9050967693,
-0.0557012707,
0.3949304819,
0.0643878728,
-0.543101728,
-0.3807317615,
-0.4736323655,
-0.1435545832,
-0.4734219611,
0.1714501381,
-0.2576922774,
-0.3029187024,
0.4274721742,
-0.128712371,
0.4273355007,
0.0313715674,
0.5366909504,
-0.1214596629,
1.1467175484,
-0.1277355999,
0.1433823854,
0.1620901525,
-0.0878714398,
0.1437437981,
-0.4345560074,
-0.225415349,
-0.4792264998,
-0.5683321953,
-0.3500142992,
-0.7859256268,
0.3224649429,
0.0653982684,
-0.5973916054,
0.4985187054,
-0.1518720239,
0.6168634295,
0.7306317091,
0.183843419,
0.2290442884,
-0.2770791054,
-0.4529894292,
0.2652358711,
-0.5159127712,
-0.3636860847,
0.6786595583,
0.0031765273,
0.3436263204,
-0.047349833,
0.745459199,
0.2920087278,
0.0438615046,
-0.9227131009,
0.9074779153,
-0.1536659598,
-0.6634730697,
-0.5928031206,
-0.1877173781,
-0.8958482146,
0.3547534049,
0.0577276424,
-0.7391921282,
0.0471641123,
-0.089654766,
-0.7813356519,
0.0471677259,
-0.6872704625,
1.0423517227,
-0.3948376477,
-0.6510546207,
-0.109164454,
-0.9145663977,
0.2433327138,
0.5141441822,
0.1904345453,
-0.1809007823,
-0.0825023726,
0.5659157634,
-0.5479543209,
0.8696601391,
-0.0365703925,
0.0473333634,
0.1153991818,
0.3544922471,
0.8099185228,
-0.1587207615,
-0.0965074524,
-0.0982578918,
-0.3005340397,
-0.4259962142,
-0.6367560625,
0.5740517378,
-0.2879528701,
-0.5196543336,
-0.5289333463,
-0.6581202745,
-0.5865736604,
0.3328663409,
0.1733765155,
0.4218841493,
0.1791196615,
-0.2893389761,
0.6710059643,
0.0164276138,
0.7295457125,
0.6246104836,
0.2938783765,
-0.2817481458,
0.6224617362,
0.2599781156,
0.1121807471,
0.5448185205,
0.032181602,
-0.2409708947,
-1.0066521168,
-0.5266122818,
-0.0617838614,
-0.7577898502,
-0.1480246782,
-0.4818943739,
-0.0153779853,
-0.2557925582,
-0.2210886478,
-0.4761866927,
-0.2810755968,
-0.0346709006,
0.0239728838,
0.1145028174,
0.8473975062,
0.1176226735,
-0.3146368265,
-0.6924970746,
0.6155678034,
0.5848599076,
0.3497261405,
0.2175093591,
-0.3202967346,
0.0692401454,
-0.243054837,
-0.188303262,
-0.7242119312,
0.297657609,
-0.4021756351,
0.567466855,
0.2265345305,
0.0700714663,
0.7568608522,
-0.9366192818,
0.8963462114,
0.0897205174,
-0.6655210853,
0.5792537332,
-0.3799359202,
0.5033135414,
0.5690377355,
0.7450903654,
-0.5550067425,
0.0157340784,
-0.6397694945,
-1.0410871506,
0.7999481559,
0.3379874825,
-0.3055527806,
-0.2922558486,
0.2592464387,
0.0119714672,
-0.0083600935,
-0.3885939717,
-0.2765980363,
0.0912926495,
0.0396612883,
-0.0629451498,
0.1328767836,
0.0506397709,
-0.3299514055,
0.4873583019,
-0.0592471696,
0.118059054,
0.3362013996,
-0.0080993585,
0.0289478078,
0.2398639321,
0.8800435066,
0.4636851847,
-0.019570509,
0.0739163309,
0.2068130225,
-0.1524081677,
0.1828108728,
0.1101473048,
-0.1041658297,
-0.3134352565,
0.4826413989,
0.5278895497,
0.4731810093,
-0.7097449303,
0.3818484247,
-0.0459927917,
-0.2388762683,
0.0273504741,
0.1770378202,
0.0199774541,
0.5762028098,
0.1334358901,
0.2856785059,
0.3010179996,
-0.4738333225,
0.1143341213,
0.0736195445,
-0.1746334285,
-0.1627205312,
0.3862224221,
0.0798580945,
-0.6236941814,
0.746712625,
-0.4849064052,
-0.2309783697,
0.7430286407,
0.2319621146,
0.9135408998,
-0.094027333,
0.2046892792,
0.7873364091,
0.2362588346,
-0.7977833152,
0.6256657243,
-0.241448462,
-0.5459298491,
-0.4814647138,
-0.3950229287,
-0.6483223438,
0.2857924998,
-0.5349211693,
0.0199245121,
-0.7257749438,
-0.050713174,
0.1677137017,
-0.1547158062,
-0.4405471087,
0.3025990129,
0.1395348608,
0.8366913199,
-0.7126682997,
0.6500561237,
0.7756967545,
-0.3470289409,
-0.7323474288,
0.0967333689,
0.2088170201,
-0.8150938749,
0.8203616142,
0.1575436592,
0.0173504185,
-0.3676843941,
-0.5838707685,
-0.6704257131,
0.9050471187,
-0.1458860636,
-0.4799456,
-0.1464378387,
-0.0009432193,
0.5804704428,
-0.1526513249,
0.1955613047,
0.5114066005,
0.5090267062,
0.4006109238,
-0.6714618802,
0.2825133204,
-0.3390714526,
-0.072782293,
0.2126562148,
-0.4272209704,
0.9797951579,
-0.2684843242,
-0.1437204629,
0.463070333,
0.6254054308,
0.3758885562,
0.4649731219,
0.6272864342,
0.6142408848,
0.7033706307,
-0.0427367464,
1.050219059,
0.0846131891,
-0.1913843155,
1.383538723,
-0.5909718275,
1.0732856989,
0.3722527325,
-0.3458717167,
0.6306456327,
0.8230205774,
0.1076961532,
0.4824304581,
0.405844599,
-0.0262827203,
-0.5002809167,
0.1905851066,
0.0771845505,
0.3263911009,
0.4477685392,
-0.2707579136,
-0.0538085215,
-0.4274972379,
-0.1350922287,
-0.0243603177,
-0.3985598683,
0.7313443422,
-0.0116380667,
-1.408290863,
0.7158873677,
-0.1378265917,
0.2455122769,
-0.4128157794,
-0.2162716836,
-0.3235578239,
0.0511016659,
0.0034041498,
-0.6930835247,
0.0856297463,
-0.0552176014,
-0.1371842474,
-0.4246383905,
0.2633707225,
-0.078941077,
-0.3077288866,
0.1306110322,
0.3043405116,
0.0291654989,
0.0759400204,
-0.9282954931,
-0.2706696689,
-0.4924824238,
-0.3368926942,
0.1781916171,
0.4685465395,
-0.2356855273,
0.493201524,
0.4472799301,
-0.2460800707,
0.0958200544,
0.0948173031,
0.201739043,
-0.7583854198,
-0.3984948397,
-0.6752302647,
0.6388510466,
-0.1309689432,
-0.4690913558,
0.5818184614,
0.1564648747,
0.9555388093,
-0.0975867957,
0.4524247646,
-0.246642217,
0.323695451,
-0.67092067,
0.1751156449,
-0.4972247183,
0.2828247845,
-0.1998316795,
-0.2113047093,
-0.3554366231,
0.5412902236,
-0.4605609179,
0.0903271511,
1.1744391918,
0.897038877,
-0.0063829827,
0.3147229254,
0.4161634147,
0.144359678,
-0.3142837286,
0.6520918608,
0.9701429009,
-0.5188897252,
0.1656047106,
-0.3530065417,
-0.0868842453,
0.0208485406,
-0.9132590294,
-1.0860812664,
-0.6490285397,
-0.4224069118,
-0.3035720587,
0.0643525273,
1.1243031025,
0.7338181138,
-0.94257617,
-0.3015440702,
-0.5690099597,
0.3847368062,
-0.9850438833,
-0.0999119505,
0.0736454949,
-0.4440869689,
-0.6406727433,
0.6410906315,
0.2081307173,
-0.0504714884,
0.2180861682,
-0.0592154711,
-0.6680044532,
0.2402596474,
0.7084445953,
0.4999077916,
-0.9043117166,
-0.1656745672,
0.2068017274,
-0.0601493903,
0.075885959,
1.1775516272,
-0.4484483004,
0.1836915314,
0.9177030325,
0.5799773335,
0.3223909438,
-0.2054244727,
0.3986175954,
-0.6361609697,
-0.3328751624,
0.3127247393,
0.488709271,
0.1048799008,
-0.2202498913,
0.6321647763,
0.1321436316,
-0.6515936255,
-0.6180633307,
0.3447048962,
-1.057292819,
-0.5101795197,
1.1760219336,
-0.231870383,
-0.2423313111,
-0.3053673208,
0.0773326457,
0.0674821958,
-0.3006659746,
0.6590716243,
0.7168348432,
-0.6457550526,
-0.0644672588,
-0.5617991686,
0.4975582361,
0.7157232165,
-0.7535294294,
0.3752709031,
0.588144958,
0.0296906736,
0.2344965786,
0.6518774629,
-0.0416841172,
0.4963929951,
0.1358942538,
-0.5772483945,
0.1460949928,
-0.6107253432,
-0.1645034254,
0.2591665387,
-0.1251042634,
-0.1221691519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04428v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04428v2 | Zambezi Voice: A Multilingual Speech Corpus for Zambian Languages | 2023-06-07T13:36:37 | 2023-06-13T20:48:02 | Claytone Sikasote, Kalinda Siaminwe, Stanly Mwape, Bangiwe Zulu, Mofya Phiri, Martin Phiri, David Zulu, Mayumbo Nyirenda, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This work introduces Zambezi Voice, an open-source multilingual speech
resource for Zambian languages. It contains two collections of datasets:
unlabelled audio recordings of radio news and talk shows programs (160 hours)
and labelled data (over 80 hours) consisting of read speech recorded from text
sourced from publicly available literature books. The dataset is created for
speech recognition but can be extended to multilingual speech processing
research for both supervised and unsupervised learning approaches. To our
knowledge, this is the first multilingual speech dataset created for Zambian
languages. We exploit pretraining and cross-lingual transfer learning by
finetuning the Wav2Vec2.0 large-scale multilingual pre-trained model to build
end-to-end (E2E) speech recognition models for our baseline models. The dataset
is released publicly under a Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license and can be
accessed via https://github.com/unza-speech-lab/zambezi-voice . | [
-0.3074603081,
-0.2371984124,
-0.1224654913,
0.7094681263,
-0.2398288399,
0.0833705068,
-0.6035061479,
-0.488008976,
0.2670096755,
0.2273338586,
-0.6788256168,
-0.1418074816,
-0.4960218966,
-0.0280809496,
-0.5112769008,
0.7523522377,
0.444259733,
0.4300398231,
0.2582124472,
-0.0905682817,
-0.0561779104,
-0.4460539818,
-0.361222297,
-0.3491899669,
0.8589815497,
0.4508114755,
0.7134113312,
-0.0183757842,
-0.4813446999,
0.1003931612,
-0.0072371801,
0.0108021758,
-0.3449649513,
-0.2207205892,
-0.0800617486,
-0.2389715165,
0.1074866429,
0.1320957243,
0.3456511497,
0.7846051455,
-0.5093945265,
0.2048614323,
0.1598929912,
0.2963522375,
-0.4996981919,
0.2460321188,
-0.4447361827,
0.0190074407,
-0.6014145613,
0.1348737478,
-0.4915551841,
-0.4954157174,
0.0868713185,
-0.295131743,
-0.0404919796,
-0.7564525008,
0.7026207447,
-0.1500166208,
-0.1811217964,
-0.4775840044,
-0.6325746775,
0.6731169224,
-0.5615125299,
0.3411877155,
0.697763145,
0.5413520932,
0.1379009038,
-0.8912554979,
-0.5570136309,
0.1175316125,
0.0939239934,
0.2076505125,
-0.3063948452,
-0.2966833413,
-0.1467411965,
0.0441647805,
-0.3677268624,
0.2713193893,
-0.6823137999,
-0.3255313635,
0.6831086874,
-0.4944728911,
0.3456872404,
-0.2873705328,
-0.3749796748,
-0.0613331236,
-0.5273832083,
0.3715450466,
0.6043749452,
0.7797651291,
-0.2748056352,
0.2051101923,
0.0116513455,
0.8026025295,
-0.4527776837,
-0.3238024116,
0.523875773,
-0.1060199812,
-0.0306528341,
0.690331161,
0.7809770107,
0.0868841633,
0.5400523543,
-0.2683886886,
0.0945053026,
-0.4671733379,
0.0167528577,
-0.728268981,
-0.364205569,
0.1694098562,
-0.4576657116,
0.1478521228,
-0.0227626581,
-0.730602622,
-0.391558826,
-0.2821998298,
0.48713696,
-0.6518759131,
-0.4999903142,
-0.154526934,
0.0120968558,
0.2299107909,
0.1299685538,
-1.0545605421,
-0.1045762375,
0.2179812938,
1.0331815481,
0.3845743537,
-0.6111415625,
-0.4063867033,
0.231066674,
-0.1953808963,
0.6174354553,
-0.241806075,
-0.4309266806,
0.0776633322,
0.1269270182,
-0.2107391953,
-0.4378300905,
0.6007273197,
-0.140221566,
-0.0272988193,
-0.2080824375,
-0.1651326716,
-0.289108783,
-0.6327725053,
-0.7438489199,
0.8516092896,
0.581786871,
-0.2800242901,
0.083568871,
-0.6327262521,
-0.7570998073,
0.0558564439,
-0.1207571253,
-0.1399616748,
-0.1553249061,
0.2395932823,
0.3409669995,
-0.2876340449,
0.2148707509,
-0.0389283784,
0.0303672496,
0.3289882243,
-0.2914173007,
1.5143481493,
0.5188660622,
-0.3255369365,
-0.0020118838,
-1.0131803751,
0.5048044324,
-0.1007678732,
-0.274258554,
0.1052408814,
0.1093990356,
0.6060698032,
0.5757191777,
0.1831464916,
-0.8791168332,
-0.1472632736,
-0.0787477195,
0.7380076647,
0.3996211886,
-0.7219746113,
-0.0315243043,
-0.0208445862,
0.1681427956,
0.0752140358,
0.0836747512,
-0.1298537552,
-0.5142068267,
-0.4236664772,
-0.2300044745,
0.8412784338,
0.7542820573,
-0.4573013783,
0.3036148548,
-0.1378218234,
-0.7692250609,
-0.9993814826,
0.3986718059,
0.0157109685,
0.3280110955,
0.4241642058,
0.0677307397,
-0.8108378649,
-1.2875833511,
0.209979102,
-0.1558701098,
-0.2335393876,
0.2103232294,
0.0088047367,
-0.2682202458,
0.9597401619,
-0.1158863083,
-0.4322088659,
-0.5231723785,
0.3757380843,
0.2534712255,
0.4707427025,
0.9592638612,
-0.9113041162,
-0.4988916218,
-0.1268272251,
-0.453094691,
-0.4212917387,
0.0217234194,
0.0960249826,
0.0422757044,
0.2221956998,
-0.2222809047,
0.0733987391,
0.7352416515,
0.059954524,
0.2162471116,
-0.0873988271,
-0.0536644161,
-1.05884552,
0.0958853215,
-0.3126872778,
0.0111001125,
-0.7618411779,
-0.4058688283,
0.317284435,
-0.4244930446,
-0.6732109189,
-0.0499069914,
-0.508760035,
-0.308547467,
-0.3371775448,
0.1858958602,
-0.3541602194,
0.2371457666,
0.0888189003,
1.1804525852,
0.738948822,
-0.4543938935,
0.7435597777,
0.426571995,
-0.8246247172,
0.4134998322,
-0.475586772,
0.1794450432,
0.0641109943,
-0.0294659175,
-0.8201234341,
-0.3274708986,
0.0045280368,
-0.5891117454,
0.2120350897,
-0.0282697119,
-0.5425195694,
-0.1751030684,
-0.0720565468,
-0.0751406774,
0.3171948195,
-0.9608569741,
0.3770651221,
0.6636410356,
-0.7107703686,
-0.5904801488,
-0.9960619807,
0.4462097883,
0.2000077665,
-0.6559924483,
0.3347992599,
0.146311909,
0.0301487036,
-0.247971043,
0.2918031514,
-0.6833757758,
-0.0442581736,
0.2880152464,
-0.0574555956,
-0.3409636021,
0.1777502,
0.0207434651,
0.1523304135,
0.0226430781,
0.0281979516,
0.7466819882,
0.1688240021,
0.2171539515,
-0.2571359575,
0.7504132986,
0.4548417628,
-0.2819729745,
0.8583133817,
0.7478762865,
-0.4269687235,
-0.065171212,
-0.2522611618,
0.5236566663,
-0.3422983885,
0.2833949029,
-0.378654778,
-0.4938239157,
0.5855445266,
0.045050852,
-0.1477066278,
0.291857183,
0.5377298594,
-0.0086393505,
0.5361663699,
0.450131923,
-0.5017267466,
0.4086523652,
-0.0735604689,
0.1995292008,
-0.6822935939,
-0.6586020589,
-0.8514662385,
-0.2474437058,
-0.108919993,
-0.3536276817,
-0.0869932622,
0.4437600076,
0.3110895157,
0.6821343303,
-0.0608350635,
0.3222868443,
0.5893070698,
0.12856628,
-0.3162882328,
0.0131060136,
-0.1969384253,
-0.0025417365,
-0.7002216578,
-0.4549883902,
0.8651857972,
-0.1067510322,
0.6883862019,
0.4596996605,
0.3092972934,
0.1534709483,
0.0967000052,
-0.6364632249,
0.0790953711,
-0.111328721,
-0.4045372903,
-0.4685686529,
-0.2274411619,
-1.0136547089,
0.4142768681,
0.0052694976,
-0.8819535375,
0.3238662183,
-0.301807791,
-0.5947955847,
0.4034941792,
-0.7342568636,
0.6392809749,
-0.3128518462,
-0.1977262348,
-0.2833908498,
-0.8825542927,
0.1976970136,
-0.2682808936,
0.2341751754,
-0.1593557894,
0.2020053715,
0.7467448711,
-0.3248473108,
0.6408125162,
-0.2597419322,
-0.4156388938,
0.3488886058,
-0.4316075742,
-0.0741541535,
0.0189857055,
-0.3872999847,
0.5526862741,
0.0189086944,
-0.4373703897,
-0.2669712007,
0.7811906338,
-0.9729678035,
-0.0758712217,
-0.3120288551,
-0.4357797503,
-0.3220770061,
0.26102072,
0.4006596208,
0.5275768638,
-0.3703458607,
0.5089622736,
0.3676838577,
-0.4726006091,
0.7225207686,
0.8081564903,
-0.1089669541,
-0.5838819146,
0.6479632854,
0.5417063832,
0.1770886183,
0.2066755444,
0.0228483249,
-0.5466428995,
-0.3680237532,
-0.7300571799,
-0.0341179781,
-0.6970863342,
-0.0320306383,
-0.5842733979,
-0.5733480453,
-0.8605933189,
0.2888590693,
-0.194745928,
-0.69989115,
-0.3982668817,
-0.13007842,
0.2387151271,
0.5160134435,
-0.8138644099,
0.5237939358,
-0.7667750716,
0.5656596422,
0.4757594168,
0.261287123,
-0.0688116029,
-0.3772558272,
-0.4812117219,
0.3210799694,
-0.1447214782,
-1.0266053677,
0.4523828924,
0.6926253438,
0.6604036689,
0.2993451953,
0.1258895993,
0.6157297492,
-0.5268332362,
0.9338632226,
0.4053963423,
-1.0046100616,
0.8437966108,
0.0641742945,
0.1915436089,
0.4867070317,
0.5386078954,
-0.642929256,
-0.0195551962,
-0.2744826376,
-0.7659320831,
0.9799227118,
0.3083570302,
0.1195223406,
-0.0029428087,
-0.0740232021,
0.3636575341,
0.2228153348,
-0.4976930618,
-0.3785017431,
-0.6993173957,
0.1464105695,
-0.4716568291,
-0.3948985338,
-0.022743905,
-0.5017040372,
0.6449168324,
0.0207574293,
0.2261163592,
0.2229427248,
-0.5234621763,
-0.0948971286,
0.6320537925,
0.9304081202,
0.9194273353,
-0.2688713372,
-0.0387651883,
-0.142845422,
-0.5474851131,
0.1975089759,
0.5046784878,
-0.0657608956,
0.49503088,
0.1228744984,
0.9665670991,
0.4881921113,
-0.7330709696,
0.4351215959,
0.0809919089,
-0.0941467807,
-0.6766616106,
-0.1158389002,
0.3639984727,
0.0726369619,
0.7415952682,
-0.0287763625,
-0.0180223007,
-0.6717097759,
0.1976491064,
-0.037626598,
-0.3851650059,
-0.1954268664,
0.7360513806,
0.4535395801,
-0.267609477,
0.6257020235,
0.476691395,
-0.4173949957,
0.4588600397,
0.6080950499,
0.643938601,
-0.7878032923,
0.4679574072,
0.519470036,
0.3599522412,
0.1048843712,
0.3748754561,
-0.3148501813,
-0.5738564134,
-0.1984047443,
-0.4515116811,
-0.3020340204,
0.5419901609,
-0.9308552146,
0.0634667948,
-0.1524780989,
-0.0800122172,
0.4597409964,
-0.1882351786,
-0.0829519778,
0.1890099645,
0.4711715579,
0.9356360435,
-0.6224495769,
1.4060519934,
0.1494701654,
-0.310574472,
-0.7178872228,
-0.3080570698,
-0.1620557606,
-0.5981553197,
0.7369509339,
0.3617932796,
-0.2996420264,
0.0406986289,
-0.3530507088,
-0.6315035224,
0.9153484106,
0.826931715,
-0.6566222906,
0.2346643955,
0.277260989,
0.0697211251,
-0.2340117246,
0.0709168166,
0.4794792831,
0.4793556035,
-0.2168020606,
-1.2115007639,
-0.6638877988,
-0.2805236578,
-0.1138513982,
0.0413955525,
-0.7565470338,
1.1338261366,
-0.3093654811,
-0.3422124386,
0.3715384007,
0.7780935764,
-0.3226928711,
-0.0399887823,
0.466198355,
0.2876680195,
1.0002696514,
-0.183342576,
0.8055459261,
-0.3358072042,
0.183537215,
1.2598651648,
-0.5671705604,
0.8016552925,
0.3742882907,
-0.2321638018,
0.4853625596,
0.6273484826,
0.0629327074,
0.8186916113,
0.1657129973,
-0.6736559868,
-0.2500242889,
-0.2294916064,
-0.7389621139,
0.6757286191,
0.2523668706,
-0.3980731368,
-0.534404099,
0.3831200898,
-0.1732125133,
0.1084835157,
-0.3536697924,
0.3850810826,
-0.0451868065,
-0.2683984637,
0.502319634,
0.0391515642,
0.5544015169,
-1.0556969643,
0.1198065355,
0.1895639002,
0.1175072864,
-0.4083821774,
-0.8743075728,
0.2162486613,
0.0670212284,
-0.2560821176,
-0.2659973204,
0.5159016252,
-0.7558178306,
-0.2938853204,
0.6679012775,
0.3372440636,
0.2193859369,
0.0915456563,
-0.5321974158,
-0.105097048,
0.0677488074,
0.0909640864,
0.4581326246,
0.2031691968,
0.2957921624,
0.668895483,
0.6144918203,
0.4394693971,
0.1858979166,
0.6053550243,
0.5485287905,
-0.5396718383,
-0.7715991735,
-0.5664946437,
0.0197060611,
-0.1289945096,
-0.5083032846,
0.6933431625,
0.9655447006,
0.9931770563,
-0.3283519149,
1.0814254284,
-0.2286542803,
0.7933604121,
-0.6225420833,
1.0891577005,
-0.1139056087,
-0.3765620291,
-0.0992243662,
-0.5089751482,
0.0770143196,
0.9039571285,
0.3113790751,
-0.2523603141,
0.2151154578,
0.6485705972,
-0.0257564876,
0.4551131427,
0.5057718158,
-0.0887087137,
0.0568791069,
0.7299866676,
0.9153791666,
-0.3849928081,
0.580502212,
-0.5255855918,
-0.0992919132,
0.0763916001,
-0.6301280856,
-0.5905352831,
-0.8499330282,
-0.1302959174,
-0.2829448581,
-0.0715193227,
1.0279318094,
0.7933148146,
-0.9925721884,
-0.7550519109,
0.6680571437,
-0.2715564072,
-0.3668486476,
-0.1649210155,
0.1888679713,
-0.099397473,
-0.6854177117,
0.7983093262,
0.1483370513,
0.1304904372,
-0.1222480237,
-0.1728855968,
-0.7118195891,
-0.1237842664,
0.7917346358,
0.6005690694,
-0.6705018282,
-0.0747193396,
-0.3831739128,
-0.1323147416,
0.274526,
0.9659278393,
-0.706188798,
0.4010288715,
-0.000420602,
0.425157547,
0.3285182714,
-0.3696629405,
0.5729053617,
-0.8394217491,
0.5579618812,
0.0251683593,
0.526627183,
0.5232271552,
-0.074352406,
0.5310111046,
-0.0419574268,
-0.0169639643,
-0.8114873767,
0.0160123073,
-1.0438587666,
-0.3366967738,
0.7954822183,
-0.340426147,
-0.0808097944,
-0.2427073121,
-0.3707256317,
0.6459258199,
-0.2914785147,
0.5484490991,
0.8765617013,
-0.1393887252,
-0.4509223402,
-0.6144072413,
0.3183196783,
-0.0150763504,
-0.7121848464,
0.1910939664,
0.4634842575,
0.2796122432,
0.2727046907,
0.518370986,
-0.2231571823,
0.5618383884,
-0.049775172,
0.235808894,
-0.2635337114,
-0.3783315718,
-0.590754807,
0.3178561628,
-0.3513575494,
-0.2869034708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04424v1 | Examining Bias in Opinion Summarisation Through the Perspective of Opinion Diversity | 2023-06-07T13:31:02 | 2023-06-07T13:31:02 | Nannan Huang, Lin Tian, Haytham Fayek, Xiuzhen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Opinion summarisation is a task that aims to condense the information
presented in the source documents while retaining the core message and
opinions. A summary that only represents the majority opinions will leave the
minority opinions unrepresented in the summary. In this paper, we use the
stance towards a certain target as an opinion. We study bias in opinion
summarisation from the perspective of opinion diversity, which measures whether
the model generated summary can cover a diverse set of opinions. In addition,
we examine opinion similarity, a measure of how closely related two opinions
are in terms of their stance on a given topic, and its relationship with
opinion diversity. Through the lens of stances towards a topic, we examine
opinion diversity and similarity using three debatable topics under COVID-19.
Experimental results on these topics revealed that a higher degree of
similarity of opinions did not indicate good diversity or fairly cover the
various opinions originally presented in the source documents. We found that
BART and ChatGPT can better capture diverse opinions presented in the source
documents. | [
-0.8344573379,
-0.2930478156,
-0.0243693441,
0.0798411369,
-0.407433331,
0.2464782,
0.008834227,
-0.3919936717,
0.6670664549,
0.1922592074,
-0.398558408,
-0.2944912016,
-0.774812758,
0.1486389488,
-0.373814255,
1.6115192175,
0.0726562366,
0.031129919,
-0.2213723958,
-0.5571005344,
-0.3271567225,
-0.6548964977,
-0.2358142585,
-0.4868497849,
0.2865714133,
0.2253281772,
0.6935420632,
-0.0251171123,
0.4945495725,
0.1296695173,
-0.5572782159,
-0.0745382234,
-0.89771384,
0.1466082036,
-0.365306735,
-0.6059814095,
-0.3170995414,
0.3315177858,
0.4829945266,
0.676038146,
0.2176053524,
0.3192180991,
0.5054353476,
0.8219994903,
-0.5444738865,
-0.4067289531,
-0.4386518896,
0.3289610147,
-0.0202756487,
0.1890362501,
-0.0396072567,
-0.332373172,
0.3141046464,
-0.1940055639,
0.7573287487,
-0.0916257203,
0.668066442,
-0.0681421459,
-0.6413815022,
-0.1386245042,
-0.7454149127,
1.0102287531,
-0.8891227841,
-0.0336021744,
0.0060276077,
0.0987151936,
0.2333133966,
-0.1127427965,
-0.5496816635,
0.1203795299,
-0.045136679,
0.5639343858,
-0.3133917749,
-0.1275730878,
0.3107647002,
0.7180247903,
-0.4221299887,
-0.2471506596,
-0.5748522282,
-0.2043685168,
0.7411248088,
0.1698070168,
0.1600411236,
-0.4498298466,
-0.4115455151,
-0.0235367399,
-0.6230472326,
0.2080329359,
0.7375559211,
-0.0322153307,
-0.3064424694,
0.4552071393,
-0.291985929,
0.2706139088,
0.5137914419,
-0.0360047519,
0.3382395506,
-0.522030592,
-0.2645023167,
0.0706127957,
0.6506098509,
0.8283377886,
0.0669102743,
0.0934881344,
0.1622145027,
-0.0871186703,
0.3046215475,
-0.6771380901,
0.0720677227,
0.2049767822,
-0.9798696041,
-0.4455988705,
0.3225061595,
-1.0708242655,
-0.4914995432,
-0.1187126711,
-0.174881056,
-0.0394466035,
-0.4295929968,
-0.2926042378,
-0.8833320737,
0.506714046,
0.6491563916,
-0.8202610612,
0.2521513402,
0.8379542828,
0.7026244998,
-0.5820738673,
-0.1116056368,
0.0365588665,
-0.0784784853,
-0.2712482512,
0.7644007802,
-0.504029572,
-0.8115571141,
-0.5999848843,
-0.4012765586,
0.2583667338,
-0.5514145494,
0.3517215848,
-0.1325547546,
0.4835141897,
-0.6890759468,
-0.3511282206,
-0.4072018564,
0.6690962315,
-0.4812110364,
0.8031962514,
0.0415312424,
-1.3038688898,
0.8385528922,
-0.1283177882,
-0.3870514333,
-0.3738534153,
-0.5077120066,
-0.471057564,
0.2549848258,
0.3999477327,
0.0467784591,
-0.091107294,
0.085200578,
-0.6941079497,
-0.1680182964,
0.2408488691,
-0.1450680345,
0.9125829935,
0.3353353143,
-0.3403002918,
-0.025502475,
-0.2077295929,
-0.4703360498,
-0.2499870956,
-0.0779345632,
-0.8060493469,
-0.102479361,
0.1328445375,
0.3149066567,
0.0596170016,
-0.4443868399,
0.3306868672,
-0.414601326,
0.0482786559,
0.6249318719,
0.4869404733,
0.7309203744,
-0.5976759791,
0.7487262487,
0.2428698391,
0.1727487743,
0.0591791011,
-0.5693295598,
-0.2716702223,
-0.2126165777,
0.1482126266,
0.3240418732,
0.0805101171,
0.0050031315,
-0.0654520541,
-0.5033231974,
-0.4810327291,
0.2371453196,
0.2653033137,
0.4307985902,
0.0224978421,
-0.6652595401,
-0.6704717875,
-1.1580570936,
-0.6370068789,
-0.3992357552,
0.2673373818,
0.161190182,
0.7187758684,
-0.0194020122,
0.9940037727,
-0.3611034751,
-0.1990249306,
-0.6230911613,
0.3629974127,
0.2087293267,
0.3428842723,
0.9131991863,
-0.870710969,
-0.3595134914,
-0.1234204322,
-0.7523829937,
-0.021620566,
-0.0977698192,
-0.0269342586,
-0.0758569762,
0.3164196014,
-0.2968104184,
0.4443896115,
0.2713705599,
-0.2942266762,
0.2598226666,
0.2134481966,
0.4143979847,
-1.3687272072,
-0.0051945024,
-0.0085300151,
-0.2053636014,
-0.4619343281,
0.1177894846,
-0.4603927135,
-0.1443481743,
-0.3295600116,
0.3593450189,
-0.2325602174,
-0.1149484888,
-0.5248715878,
-0.2177646458,
0.3957433701,
0.1097653732,
-0.0004058798,
0.3215428293,
0.3407423496,
-0.1349707097,
0.1180680245,
0.2845878005,
-0.1501599997,
0.6223494411,
-0.4324775338,
-0.0699050054,
-0.3992648721,
0.4576570392,
-1.0254483223,
0.0058756717,
0.1968787163,
-0.5055423379,
-0.1235452145,
0.0517245494,
0.3139379323,
-0.2612192929,
-0.8469720483,
0.5181918144,
0.5330032706,
-0.0480816849,
0.5417987704,
0.507792294,
-0.4458276331,
-0.9837860465,
-0.9541288614,
-0.1476516426,
-0.6400340796,
-0.216946736,
0.17883192,
0.0567266271,
-1.0210226774,
0.0977129713,
-0.3999322057,
0.1765022427,
-0.0803686082,
0.4924588799,
-0.0665561855,
-0.0670614913,
-0.2165016383,
0.2704268098,
0.375893563,
0.0912599191,
0.0691795498,
0.2547349334,
-0.023567982,
-0.5019410849,
0.0135829328,
0.87158674,
0.7248630524,
0.0262334514,
0.3347902298,
0.3480367064,
-0.1100693792,
-0.2422323525,
-0.3983471096,
-0.0234777126,
-0.2996273041,
0.3635118306,
-0.0941414535,
-0.7339103818,
0.792324841,
0.4267787635,
0.1390937716,
0.7998111844,
0.8027561903,
-0.3305930197,
0.5190107226,
0.5737715364,
-0.6699095368,
0.464523524,
-0.2991267741,
0.2315826118,
-0.5469079614,
-0.3308565021,
-0.6031488776,
-0.6504729986,
-0.4462328553,
-0.1260590553,
0.2499066442,
-0.0467113629,
0.1110622585,
-0.1484361589,
-0.3480596244,
0.2872965932,
0.573978126,
0.2034464628,
0.2666819394,
-0.0421042666,
0.0992300585,
-0.07730975,
-0.5269907713,
-0.3478020728,
1.0864318609,
0.1545490623,
0.7032376528,
0.0597318374,
0.9318226576,
0.8301913142,
0.1249861121,
-0.6698169112,
0.4269193411,
-0.0124628264,
-0.714070797,
-0.1511357725,
-0.1211981326,
-0.6725977063,
0.4872666299,
-0.3010665774,
-0.2317196578,
0.6956610084,
0.0539014824,
-0.1387768835,
0.3457197547,
-0.2596912086,
0.5453421474,
0.1000840515,
-0.1562084705,
-0.7751751542,
-0.4730193615,
0.5742871761,
0.1278846711,
0.1419994831,
-0.0774539411,
0.3488901258,
1.0049086809,
-0.4817585349,
0.8082999587,
-0.0625952855,
-0.0524614789,
0.5524980426,
-0.209064573,
-0.049538359,
0.1276946664,
-0.272301048,
0.254620254,
-0.20037359,
-0.6471378207,
-0.4663718939,
0.5819365382,
-1.0806941986,
-0.8008165359,
-0.7404783964,
-0.5309026241,
0.1390713304,
0.1053364128,
0.4404997826,
0.4608657956,
-0.7688843012,
-0.0201641098,
0.4535321891,
-0.1599357873,
0.44500494,
0.0544542857,
-0.2795111835,
-0.3335059583,
0.3680778146,
0.1940288395,
0.2225110829,
0.471852392,
0.2659225762,
0.0683733746,
-0.5007990599,
-0.2286176533,
-0.1702886373,
-0.8262657523,
0.0594334751,
-0.7114323378,
0.0199801102,
-0.5674164295,
-0.3441011012,
-0.0958163515,
-0.5619475842,
-0.0124533009,
-0.3278504014,
0.3326668739,
0.8199492097,
0.0186115447,
0.0045916941,
-0.3361970782,
0.5310403705,
0.6068616509,
-0.1232727841,
0.0710852891,
-0.4862654209,
-0.1702407598,
-0.0163659528,
-0.5934678316,
-0.9947040081,
0.4168208539,
-0.0627205148,
0.6197136641,
0.6666753888,
0.140563637,
0.2989744246,
0.2206367254,
1.1588945389,
0.1731235981,
-0.929046452,
0.6398455501,
-0.4474849701,
0.4369354248,
0.7345478535,
0.2591125667,
-0.3231579363,
-0.9702012539,
-0.8238116503,
-0.695274055,
0.365224421,
0.1535619497,
-0.0238313135,
0.0980866104,
-0.0690617636,
0.6297214031,
0.412756741,
-0.528961122,
-0.3514298201,
-0.6198502183,
0.0738693401,
0.0226495732,
-0.215984121,
-0.2452483177,
-0.1266846806,
0.3933947086,
0.24364461,
0.1452709287,
0.2177944332,
-0.0412815027,
0.0293764472,
0.6976317763,
0.5401338339,
0.7698087692,
-0.3974938989,
0.2839134932,
0.3986305296,
-0.7744632363,
0.0840633512,
-0.2584781349,
-0.5168747306,
0.2834367156,
0.5251682997,
0.6574481726,
-0.3114280999,
-0.3649647832,
0.6850985289,
-0.0290042683,
-0.1671835482,
0.0210385229,
-0.0251106806,
-0.2464612573,
0.1128642485,
0.3226693869,
0.6092687845,
0.4968397617,
-1.0028830767,
0.1037216336,
0.7114855647,
-0.1711910963,
-0.3032958806,
0.6415522099,
0.2507528365,
0.2235942334,
0.1967162788,
0.0997401327,
-0.4338506162,
1.047483325,
0.2415049672,
0.9274443984,
-0.038459789,
0.2340965718,
0.2889870405,
0.3691426218,
0.066743046,
0.2386362851,
-0.0992801636,
-0.4491825104,
-0.254291147,
-0.2201368362,
-0.7192325592,
-0.051794216,
-1.0941388607,
0.2659499645,
-0.3502469659,
-0.1991866529,
-0.0835565329,
-0.2013178617,
-0.4347116649,
0.5383877754,
0.2129186392,
0.7472982407,
-1.1979266405,
0.3633191884,
0.6754963398,
-0.5132371187,
-0.5114001036,
0.5150052309,
0.0282744598,
-0.378641367,
0.4780389369,
-0.0393438414,
-0.0570966788,
-0.927957058,
-0.2560768425,
-0.5190282464,
0.8094373345,
0.3116807938,
-0.389936775,
0.1102007478,
0.1393800378,
0.6005755663,
-0.4581439793,
0.3468618393,
0.2084907889,
0.0791539699,
-0.235326454,
-0.8772576451,
-0.0898427442,
-0.4353302419,
-0.238298744,
-0.0764651597,
-0.9795259833,
0.89234972,
-0.1549634039,
0.2881537378,
-0.6305103898,
0.6280286312,
0.0436620079,
0.6779688001,
0.3741993308,
0.384768784,
0.7501044273,
0.2820863128,
1.1031577587,
-0.0463492572,
0.4052589536,
0.9812853336,
-0.2458197623,
0.5168784261,
0.586152494,
-0.0882442966,
0.4523253441,
0.4738768041,
-0.0801784545,
0.7134953737,
0.1048818678,
-0.0419567786,
0.053969264,
0.0414192975,
-0.7523692846,
0.456268847,
0.1244399324,
-0.6151270866,
-0.4290236831,
0.0343109779,
-0.1195583865,
0.1414806843,
-0.8094206452,
0.845615387,
0.2496062815,
-0.7564657331,
0.2110952139,
-0.2148850858,
0.6014181376,
-0.2979943752,
0.1410719454,
-0.632156074,
-0.0555067584,
-0.4287652075,
-0.8202674985,
0.7225100994,
0.1855125874,
-0.7584466338,
-0.2973584831,
0.7182939053,
-0.102796711,
-0.3513688445,
0.0276042279,
0.6007328033,
0.1826967001,
0.0337896682,
-0.5231722593,
-0.0047922437,
0.2712219357,
-0.1814772487,
0.5122284889,
0.1978797764,
-0.2472257763,
0.3614539504,
-0.0718337074,
0.2203793377,
-0.1251173615,
-0.0246528089,
0.7784644961,
-0.633638382,
-0.9606483579,
-1.1825594902,
0.1572538018,
-0.2953875065,
-0.4689540565,
1.1262800694,
0.8077236414,
0.7908760309,
-0.2471636087,
1.3845875263,
-0.0784515068,
0.4956834614,
-0.1199894026,
0.7521597147,
-0.4013290703,
0.146089077,
-0.6121383905,
-0.8968566656,
0.0549050309,
0.4485388994,
-0.5442818999,
-0.0374090187,
0.4665020406,
0.5840411782,
-0.1446268559,
0.1300170571,
-0.0539327376,
0.0589846969,
-0.0247587673,
0.3684469759,
0.8187798858,
-0.0448485389,
0.4249991179,
0.1355175376,
-0.1670846641,
-0.2890507281,
-0.8041866422,
-1.1060693264,
-0.2806305885,
-0.4253442585,
-0.5627269745,
-0.1055895835,
1.0043469667,
0.5326978564,
-1.096611619,
-0.1289655268,
0.0441749468,
0.3387338817,
-0.5164110661,
-0.2000689656,
0.4122219384,
0.2978134751,
-0.7168741822,
-0.1712620258,
0.2323892713,
-0.1453756839,
-0.2728467286,
0.2113044709,
0.2902913392,
0.2039697319,
0.3236926198,
0.3153496385,
-0.7066152096,
-0.0429563038,
-0.3278737366,
-0.1510799378,
0.3101869524,
1.0448467731,
-0.6624991298,
0.4907467961,
0.8466547728,
0.37835899,
0.7194104195,
0.4291905165,
0.8246483803,
-0.5652703047,
0.2651242018,
0.1518748403,
0.412696749,
0.343182832,
-0.316719979,
0.1012451127,
0.2257679105,
-0.2507104576,
-0.6224454045,
0.4509353936,
-1.3210386038,
-0.2355418503,
1.1287808418,
-0.0617987886,
0.231503427,
-0.1768416017,
-0.556452632,
0.1727364361,
-0.6005818844,
0.9860529304,
0.6631789804,
-0.318050921,
0.0403298363,
-0.1222573146,
0.3870445192,
0.3631314635,
-0.7094395161,
-0.0911738798,
0.3112828434,
0.3494640887,
0.0637670085,
0.6877512336,
-0.0915942863,
0.2028493881,
0.0897352546,
-0.0484237932,
0.1447282732,
0.1490796357,
-0.5607599616,
0.7164503932,
-0.101195313,
-0.084761627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04399v1 | Transfer Learning of Transformer-based Speech Recognition Models from Czech to Slovak | 2023-06-07T12:58:46 | 2023-06-07T12:58:46 | Jan Lehečka, Josef V. Psutka, Josef Psutka | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we are comparing several methods of training the Slovak speech
recognition models based on the Transformers architecture. Specifically, we are
exploring the approach of transfer learning from the existing Czech pre-trained
Wav2Vec 2.0 model into Slovak. We are demonstrating the benefits of the
proposed approach on three Slovak datasets. Our Slovak models scored the best
results when initializing the weights from the Czech model at the beginning of
the pre-training phase. Our results show that the knowledge stored in the Cezch
pre-trained model can be successfully reused to solve tasks in Slovak while
outperforming even much larger public multilingual models. | [
-0.1145669594,
-0.1640175879,
0.445401907,
0.0223540515,
-0.2087102234,
-0.0681497529,
-0.4054614604,
-0.6421655416,
-0.1123182029,
0.6365300417,
-0.6851722002,
-0.400096029,
-0.8136273623,
-0.1024741456,
-0.5356879234,
0.8579388857,
-0.1344673336,
0.5544075966,
0.1178843826,
-0.0026913842,
-0.8018884063,
-0.5717852712,
-0.3734582961,
-0.4106929004,
0.2572093606,
0.5756472349,
0.1788093448,
-0.0443610623,
0.3887149394,
0.295225054,
0.0307607688,
-0.3170588613,
-0.3728638589,
0.151877135,
-0.2213278115,
-0.8834056258,
0.0191579703,
-0.0927554518,
0.5540021658,
0.4367871284,
-0.2577075958,
0.3494833708,
-0.1388058811,
0.3583543897,
-0.2859023809,
0.4362023771,
-0.9492712021,
0.12710087,
-0.0774052739,
0.1553677619,
-0.8664820194,
-0.2818930149,
0.6318790317,
-0.4930488169,
0.260748595,
-0.3713126183,
0.5848753452,
0.1745257527,
-0.6070054173,
-0.31347996,
-1.3633500338,
0.7160612941,
-0.3733596802,
0.6556722522,
0.1363932192,
0.77501899,
0.233204484,
-1.0129882097,
-0.4123103023,
-0.0996767357,
0.1080035493,
0.2126322389,
-0.5281553268,
-0.2821363807,
0.1551117897,
-0.0595163554,
-0.5090442896,
0.0012179941,
-0.9602560997,
-0.495369941,
0.2069183141,
-0.1146297306,
0.1063995212,
-0.0000920992,
-0.467420429,
-0.3616370261,
-0.4746696055,
0.2775354981,
0.2845811248,
0.6587086916,
-0.1185695827,
0.4229660928,
0.1316545159,
0.3899280131,
0.2415052354,
0.0957111567,
0.505782187,
-0.359719485,
0.043566525,
0.3900770247,
0.3198292255,
-0.1569134444,
0.5253696442,
-0.3032746315,
-0.0077312007,
0.1134779528,
0.526843071,
-0.5396711826,
-0.5636166334,
-0.2808718979,
-0.4742301106,
-0.056929294,
0.3945300579,
-0.3111180365,
0.2452707291,
-0.5862995386,
0.8635215163,
-0.299697876,
-0.7389489412,
0.1169811711,
-0.202556476,
0.4893904328,
0.2912565768,
-1.0307543278,
0.5207785964,
0.425047636,
0.7285529971,
-0.2842830122,
-0.064621985,
-0.5378859639,
0.0658093691,
-0.2484771907,
0.9723889828,
-0.081575498,
-0.5465131402,
-0.04508017,
0.2240532935,
-0.183826074,
-0.7042007446,
0.4366435707,
-0.4619590342,
0.3213484585,
-0.1305394322,
-0.2211998105,
-0.2101399153,
-0.3925846815,
-0.7289395928,
1.1952852011,
0.6570647359,
-0.5843530297,
0.375653863,
-0.5148175359,
-0.589569211,
-0.0899595022,
0.2356332392,
-0.4456065595,
0.1140839756,
-0.0259233247,
0.3846800327,
0.0476802252,
0.0269955881,
0.017214356,
-0.0522117764,
0.029987175,
-0.3868976533,
1.0169743299,
0.251524806,
-0.3541217148,
0.2454479188,
-0.7251207829,
0.0458170287,
-0.1805011332,
-0.2884244919,
-0.2311439216,
-0.2258655578,
0.4923469424,
0.6205206513,
-0.026354406,
-0.6653983593,
-0.118746765,
-0.5697759986,
0.5213244557,
0.6466665268,
-0.3758701682,
0.6609572768,
0.1160850674,
0.4695431888,
0.2710778713,
0.2127849609,
0.2255417705,
-0.5023816228,
-0.727900207,
-0.027207857,
0.6442280412,
0.8156600595,
-0.8149510622,
0.5076061487,
-0.4300931394,
-0.7490748167,
-0.5293514729,
-0.138678655,
0.3301470876,
0.7150387764,
0.5584692955,
-0.103863351,
-0.8474845886,
-0.9523915648,
-0.0602182224,
-0.3549070358,
-0.1667402685,
0.2641794384,
0.4502335191,
-0.0142387403,
0.871378541,
-0.139627561,
-0.3001987636,
-0.6496413946,
0.1646389216,
0.1267140806,
0.4933356941,
0.6709976792,
-0.9865369201,
-0.6184354424,
0.0830645561,
-0.3142015636,
0.0649253055,
0.1870786995,
-0.0872755125,
0.2685423195,
0.2998074889,
-0.5518173575,
0.4755787551,
0.7108934522,
-0.4567748606,
0.6597772241,
-0.0998523086,
0.1144941226,
-1.5242496729,
-0.1225726753,
-0.2299257815,
-0.485502243,
-1.0004733801,
-0.7090673447,
0.1871380806,
-0.1673483551,
-1.1363347769,
0.5269521475,
-0.2620177865,
-0.3526230454,
-0.1906581372,
-0.2801806033,
-0.3243753314,
0.4675154686,
0.2586741745,
1.0697849989,
0.7746335268,
-0.5434517264,
0.5970057845,
0.6586587429,
-0.6660806537,
0.4235253632,
-0.5168527365,
0.1783564836,
0.1035829037,
0.2784947455,
-1.0799716711,
0.1318369657,
0.1148985699,
-0.7358627319,
0.3501526117,
-0.3262345493,
-0.0427721925,
-0.6449537277,
0.2049602717,
0.3549001217,
0.828722775,
-0.8657701612,
1.0082479715,
0.3561002612,
-0.2908656299,
-0.2456953824,
-1.0290539265,
-0.0643215328,
-0.3532587588,
-0.5521356463,
0.6060006022,
0.243749395,
0.0161771607,
-0.0519428775,
-0.2727439106,
-0.3830817044,
-0.1746167392,
0.1410785764,
0.4161711037,
-0.4043317437,
0.0741588026,
-0.0668036789,
-0.4175584614,
0.106491521,
-0.6636429429,
0.6241312623,
0.0844573528,
-0.0887193009,
-0.9189110994,
0.2301187217,
0.3506231904,
-0.2177876234,
0.5632576346,
0.673879981,
-0.3963361979,
-0.1137600839,
-0.6031514406,
-0.1394770145,
-0.4341782928,
0.5836479664,
-0.6147767901,
-0.6162731051,
0.6351348162,
-0.2243303061,
-0.2190660536,
0.7308834791,
0.8979181051,
-0.1449347436,
0.905190587,
0.9356900454,
-0.1426616311,
0.9137222767,
-0.3895254433,
0.1046301723,
-0.6810277104,
-0.5221146941,
-0.9532591701,
-0.0478060283,
-0.3761143386,
-0.2392996997,
0.2263758928,
-0.1740715951,
-0.0870672241,
1.1571062803,
-0.3250300884,
0.238131687,
0.6328501701,
0.3458920419,
0.0340888202,
0.0704060271,
0.0734183937,
0.0230895914,
-0.7045787573,
-0.3093501329,
1.3105384111,
0.0625923872,
0.6769556403,
0.0375602767,
0.4465601444,
0.3167457879,
0.0838894695,
-0.8708450794,
0.1743838638,
-0.2887810767,
-0.5957077146,
-0.4742612839,
-0.3806656897,
-0.8021717072,
-0.0698017403,
-0.2029022872,
-0.8940888643,
0.3526731133,
0.083551161,
-0.1584980935,
0.4798665345,
-0.8707760572,
0.6941644549,
-0.1749774218,
0.2708369792,
-0.4100522399,
-0.7923909426,
0.1673124433,
-0.0314484984,
-0.1582792699,
0.1305964142,
0.4977342188,
1.0458395481,
-0.1099266186,
0.4753340781,
-0.51957798,
-0.1234037653,
0.3459483981,
-0.1514697075,
0.4703217447,
-0.3008526266,
-0.0860099569,
0.4042983651,
0.1918217689,
-0.1557711214,
-0.7029054165,
0.2666081786,
-0.9790711999,
-0.2942525446,
-0.0961048082,
-0.0845325887,
-0.3407213986,
0.0163261686,
0.5420210958,
0.6115059257,
-0.1869451702,
0.2594161034,
0.8111271858,
0.0827629119,
0.3069550395,
0.4460708201,
0.1722181737,
-0.5715491772,
0.5975859761,
0.2092794329,
0.3842626512,
0.2863373756,
-0.0059077861,
-0.4777189493,
-0.4460603297,
-0.392645359,
-0.1268521249,
-0.7062339187,
-0.3607462049,
-0.5594953299,
-0.5920980573,
-0.6796727777,
0.2199460268,
-0.7137952447,
-0.5364329219,
-0.4214388728,
-0.1889223754,
0.388551861,
0.7819958329,
-0.0785463154,
0.5306058526,
-0.6982883811,
0.3595111072,
0.4646635056,
0.2664091885,
-0.1314243525,
-0.9942561388,
-0.514708519,
0.0325197615,
-0.1878990829,
-0.8872215748,
0.2370763719,
0.0351565368,
0.6837099791,
0.1809173524,
-0.1272001565,
0.505197227,
-0.7224481702,
0.897379756,
0.5532798767,
-1.0925283432,
0.7069980502,
0.0748922974,
-0.0931308568,
0.5581713915,
0.1815377623,
-0.3805381954,
0.0633377209,
-0.6014693379,
-0.5743649006,
1.0721495152,
0.2967512012,
0.2815690637,
0.4348767698,
0.4984459579,
0.4498227537,
-0.2103236616,
-0.5028858185,
-0.1487989873,
-0.446934849,
-0.5260432959,
-0.1106718704,
-0.076709196,
0.2075626701,
-0.5816249847,
0.6702616811,
0.1309680492,
0.5591315031,
0.1210661232,
-0.4736811519,
0.0108455559,
0.1910794973,
0.6422181726,
0.399387002,
0.1145403534,
-0.0213454422,
0.6070965528,
-0.7963919044,
0.4039235413,
-0.1593502462,
0.2107623219,
0.1100668684,
0.2055757046,
1.1116199493,
0.3711340129,
-0.3138178587,
0.7114658356,
-0.1806233674,
-0.7825030088,
-0.6329661012,
0.2491442561,
-0.0491783805,
0.5018613338,
0.4395058155,
0.2961182594,
0.1441490948,
-0.5256026983,
0.3200731277,
0.3775375783,
-0.6143966913,
-0.6994705796,
0.6178477407,
0.1792990565,
-0.7489356995,
0.7481393218,
0.7087714672,
-0.8500475883,
0.6604374647,
0.7857436538,
0.9965614676,
-0.5953170657,
0.1105717123,
0.3733222187,
0.028685797,
-0.4715319276,
0.1707827896,
-0.4343162477,
-0.5992517471,
-0.3691835105,
-0.2504085004,
-0.3928174376,
-0.1468540877,
-1.0766003132,
0.7604584098,
0.0785872489,
-0.3633085191,
-0.124814555,
-0.0188193489,
-0.9259420037,
0.1478346288,
0.3382447958,
1.0361738205,
-1.0421423912,
1.1083830595,
0.3561450839,
-0.2229712754,
-0.9958027005,
-0.208182022,
-0.4300225675,
-0.8502802253,
0.9622700214,
0.066933699,
-0.314483285,
0.2597673535,
-0.3359051049,
-1.145164609,
1.2200545073,
0.471809119,
-0.5827682018,
-0.3239766657,
0.057206545,
0.4561122358,
-0.2872943878,
0.2884201705,
0.6535505652,
0.515994668,
0.2046312988,
-1.3139674664,
-0.4949804842,
-0.0812243372,
0.0661460161,
-0.0046376912,
-0.3914605379,
0.7062558532,
-0.2008246779,
-0.4130858183,
0.3691376448,
0.8739756346,
-0.3230239451,
-0.007857929,
0.6541246772,
0.3050357401,
0.5628486872,
-0.1485806853,
0.4608591497,
-0.1303718686,
0.3558829427,
1.0133466721,
-0.1830072999,
1.0635802746,
0.4725090861,
-0.4759275317,
0.736727953,
0.4359229803,
-0.1871295869,
0.8630188704,
0.0484206751,
-0.1438459307,
-0.2637624145,
0.3691481948,
-0.4226927757,
0.7409430742,
0.0007212834,
-0.0972375944,
-0.2167592943,
0.7140226364,
-0.5377951264,
-0.039970722,
-0.2627735138,
1.2571983337,
-0.1845440418,
-0.3607686162,
0.2640900612,
-0.272157371,
0.5949402452,
-0.6872153878,
-0.0071814605,
0.263250947,
0.176985085,
-0.140691027,
-0.7242513299,
0.5299725533,
0.0411654487,
-0.5069063902,
-0.290812254,
0.7734980583,
-0.4893060327,
-0.5519934297,
0.3824115694,
0.4402869344,
0.3148562014,
0.0223270785,
-0.3691937625,
-0.3104790151,
-0.0307264458,
-0.1160944253,
0.1953562349,
0.3014398813,
-0.0071305572,
0.4519762993,
0.6233401895,
0.4050042033,
0.2460881621,
0.3485901356,
0.7463544011,
-0.6019254327,
-0.636739254,
-0.4901801944,
0.541179359,
0.293363899,
-0.1533643305,
0.4597108066,
0.5624809265,
0.9678145051,
-0.4343708754,
0.7805082798,
0.2069126815,
0.7726611495,
-0.6329427361,
0.6357282996,
-0.1419906169,
-0.1833917946,
-0.1373326033,
-0.9704253078,
-0.1151509136,
0.6875747442,
-0.2352059186,
-0.048175443,
0.4614143074,
0.6327669621,
-0.173214674,
0.0820293278,
0.3976816535,
0.1242636219,
0.2155133486,
0.7497315407,
0.9413310885,
-0.6979241967,
0.8449537158,
-0.1696273983,
-0.1264442205,
-0.0386920199,
-0.3723712862,
-0.8107572198,
-0.9959616661,
-0.0448011272,
-0.3768556714,
0.0544596873,
0.8939247131,
1.0523239374,
-1.0422611237,
-0.1114835665,
-0.0660249069,
-0.203951329,
-0.2134040594,
-0.1854450703,
0.3423730135,
-0.2573012114,
-0.6062090397,
0.2945922613,
-0.0584462173,
0.3513015807,
-0.2606348097,
-0.0748511255,
0.2420793027,
-0.1895705312,
0.5274828672,
0.2243088037,
-0.671777308,
-0.4572851062,
0.126881212,
0.1526458859,
0.4592896998,
1.0738129616,
-1.2419196367,
0.2136124969,
0.436881572,
0.3448474109,
0.8490132689,
-0.030985361,
0.599140048,
-0.3121525347,
0.2828268409,
0.1735533178,
0.282222867,
0.3333840966,
-0.2966687381,
0.1443742812,
0.1617097855,
-0.2958429754,
-0.7253782153,
0.0913708806,
-1.1473958492,
0.0046828552,
1.0347880125,
-0.0823100656,
-0.1394779533,
-0.1405777484,
-0.4177290499,
0.7527831197,
-0.0913894475,
0.6402569413,
0.6655653715,
-0.0290794559,
-0.0699071661,
-0.3497105837,
0.536108017,
-0.013257321,
-0.6969131231,
0.3081739545,
-0.0283446256,
0.837248981,
0.0984945297,
0.251912266,
-0.3971639276,
0.4191168249,
-0.0074723046,
0.2996929288,
0.0623220466,
-0.8643285036,
-0.5861090422,
-0.2027811706,
-0.2540033758,
-0.2892252505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04387v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04387v2 | M$^3$IT: A Large-Scale Dataset towards Multi-Modal Multilingual Instruction Tuning | 2023-06-07T12:35:37 | 2023-06-08T13:44:24 | Lei Li, Yuwei Yin, Shicheng Li, Liang Chen, Peiyi Wang, Shuhuai Ren, Mukai Li, Yazheng Yang, Jingjing Xu, Xu Sun, Lingpeng Kong, Qi Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Instruction tuning has significantly advanced large language models (LLMs)
such as ChatGPT, enabling them to align with human instructions across diverse
tasks. However, progress in open vision-language models (VLMs) has been limited
due to the scarcity of high-quality instruction datasets. To tackle this
challenge and promote research in the vision-language field, we introduce the
Multi-Modal, Multilingual Instruction Tuning (M$^3$IT) dataset, designed to
optimize VLM alignment with human instructions. Our M$^3$IT dataset comprises
40 carefully curated datasets, including 2.4 million instances and 400 manually
written task instructions, reformatted into a vision-to-text structure. Key
tasks are translated into 80 languages with an advanced translation system,
ensuring broader accessibility. M$^3$IT surpasses previous datasets regarding
task coverage, instruction number and instance scale. Moreover, we develop
Ying-VLM, a VLM model trained on our M$^3$IT dataset, showcasing its potential
to answer complex questions requiring world knowledge, generalize to unseen
video tasks, and comprehend unseen instructions in Chinese. We have
open-sourced the dataset to encourage further research. | [
-0.0727561563,
-0.6714068651,
0.3750445247,
0.2181873322,
-0.2085317969,
-0.0942039564,
-0.3759794831,
-0.1878785938,
-0.0968498662,
0.4872168303,
-0.7728113532,
-0.575982511,
-0.3573255837,
-0.1482039541,
-0.0066452157,
0.7446613908,
0.019070169,
0.4570541084,
0.1081954464,
-0.0672433153,
-0.5573378801,
-0.3684875369,
-0.3383847177,
0.1550616473,
0.6517602205,
0.7714671493,
0.6644474864,
1.0107183456,
0.6025701165,
0.2497138083,
0.4594565928,
0.6564074755,
-0.492289573,
-0.3166204691,
0.1284001917,
-0.4632954299,
-0.5890928507,
-0.0966422856,
0.8213487864,
0.6407271028,
-0.1303518564,
0.2577314675,
0.1043492854,
0.8159306645,
-0.7001898289,
0.4124138355,
-0.5189567804,
-0.0760337412,
-0.5465680957,
-0.2337840945,
-0.5962610245,
-0.2405033261,
-0.1636303365,
-0.7659825087,
0.1910920888,
0.3458912373,
0.7536327839,
0.2653661668,
-0.4763029814,
0.2222822756,
-0.5175662041,
0.9472834468,
-0.6621061563,
0.6095544696,
0.4599190056,
0.3015442491,
0.172299251,
-0.1592078507,
-0.4716603458,
-0.0579741932,
0.1175014973,
0.073944822,
0.0462011658,
0.0766027421,
0.1320450008,
0.292830348,
-0.6726108193,
0.2348398268,
-0.6034753323,
-0.1519075036,
0.4301685691,
0.5035194159,
0.1847417504,
0.0601977222,
-0.3671479821,
-0.1565436572,
-0.7780734301,
0.0800021514,
0.3382457793,
0.3545703888,
-0.15904814,
0.9445823431,
-0.220833689,
1.3095190525,
-0.2707515061,
-0.3000416756,
0.2780519128,
-0.5737566948,
-0.2143999487,
-0.0855860338,
0.6829778552,
0.7082615495,
0.3290760517,
0.0856839344,
-0.0371670984,
-0.2686218321,
0.4739223421,
-0.7213096619,
-0.0858043581,
-0.1406313926,
-0.2547092438,
0.1205925196,
0.2427117079,
-0.6195652485,
-0.2500856817,
-0.7724796534,
0.482668072,
-0.5714361072,
-0.161409542,
0.2879382372,
0.287943393,
0.4290257394,
0.3938964903,
-1.0856354237,
-0.203773737,
0.7612382174,
0.7097133994,
-0.0738337487,
-0.7450248599,
-0.4614503384,
0.2978104055,
-0.5737485886,
0.5563220382,
-0.7377052307,
0.0133134071,
0.0428490974,
0.2571952641,
-0.5757949352,
-0.2961571515,
0.3073901534,
-0.3724955022,
0.3850595355,
-0.1773305535,
-0.4384193718,
-0.3580106795,
0.3036052585,
-0.6756728888,
0.9012696743,
0.1707662046,
-0.5485919118,
0.3496262729,
-0.6670743823,
-0.4270051122,
-0.1347387135,
-0.2134557962,
-0.372392714,
0.1605091095,
0.4170938432,
0.4061249197,
-0.607326746,
0.1156428456,
-0.1911608428,
-0.5159041286,
-0.0242221784,
-0.6743366718,
0.6964722872,
0.1467613131,
-0.4122517109,
0.2535716295,
-0.786781013,
0.1988891959,
-0.1746537089,
-0.4390956759,
-0.1981569827,
0.000209768,
0.0348160937,
0.0582264252,
0.368191123,
-0.6383713484,
0.4389216602,
-0.1345014423,
0.2816396058,
0.8781023026,
-0.4212887585,
0.1978267729,
-0.222687155,
0.3673660457,
0.1941608638,
0.5527231097,
-0.4260395765,
-0.6398903728,
-0.8656852245,
-0.4177831411,
-0.0552091487,
0.6625500917,
-0.9860662818,
0.040319398,
-0.4855901599,
-0.1837178469,
-1.0249254704,
0.2208111584,
0.555924356,
0.5405591726,
0.4372598529,
0.2985496223,
-0.296315968,
-1.0730826855,
0.0140860621,
0.1431718916,
-0.20294258,
0.4161306918,
0.1395195723,
-0.1586482227,
0.3974188566,
-0.5250828266,
-0.5048385262,
0.1515026689,
-0.060470406,
0.1429861188,
0.4621083438,
0.2372799814,
-0.758984983,
-0.3903850615,
0.3098652363,
-0.7911558151,
0.1541253775,
0.0846918225,
-0.2952948809,
0.2359153181,
0.4525143802,
-0.0671656057,
-0.029386377,
0.8185120821,
-0.459551245,
0.2923346162,
-0.4003196359,
0.653111577,
-1.2728289366,
-0.1188804209,
-0.0388284884,
-0.0204908941,
-0.4942072928,
0.1327330321,
0.5687448978,
-0.1369909495,
-0.4941147268,
0.2513471544,
-0.5325018764,
0.013492913,
-0.1226055548,
0.0397901498,
0.0423233807,
0.7329067588,
-0.0022361914,
1.0001920462,
0.6517212987,
-0.5449737906,
0.3481535912,
0.0757117346,
-0.5143627524,
0.7282298803,
-0.3249453306,
0.0691567585,
0.0386894904,
-0.3440470994,
-0.6206584573,
-0.3583021462,
0.22252886,
-0.0446981862,
0.3176285923,
0.0654288605,
-0.4698863328,
-0.3285514712,
-0.3493975997,
0.4754563868,
0.0529566221,
-0.5634216666,
0.6259406209,
0.2330637276,
0.1652422398,
-0.8173900843,
-0.4166251719,
0.1467946917,
0.0049257805,
-0.8281265497,
0.2481444031,
-0.2984488606,
-0.0708465949,
-0.1220525801,
0.0164684858,
-0.2045807093,
-0.1301752925,
0.1022864655,
0.5396197438,
-0.6040947437,
0.0932186544,
-0.1262383014,
-0.1164168492,
-0.2885168195,
-0.3976687491,
0.3138623238,
-0.2426988631,
-0.6136659384,
-0.3546951711,
0.4316474199,
0.7100222111,
-0.3612717092,
0.6621174216,
0.8794468045,
-0.1731797308,
-0.0167658515,
-0.5081424117,
0.115285933,
-0.4394433498,
0.5355221629,
-0.4747687578,
-0.9780384302,
-0.1081988662,
0.150403738,
0.3582977951,
0.2158821821,
0.588111937,
-0.1325945407,
1.4093381166,
0.9431486726,
-0.2297286242,
0.621761322,
-0.0563136488,
0.0904075503,
-0.9354326129,
-0.3793763816,
-0.2575577796,
-0.2539868951,
-0.3262613416,
-0.747657299,
0.5929162502,
-0.0575066283,
-0.1766654402,
0.2708602548,
-0.3473555148,
0.5923126936,
0.7175568938,
0.3754117489,
0.1400143951,
-0.1350987256,
0.1420098245,
-0.1945996583,
-0.60741359,
-0.4180085063,
1.1418209076,
0.0045981971,
0.793520093,
0.304546535,
0.1412234008,
0.0700991899,
0.0775469467,
-0.6688305736,
0.3586546779,
-0.4646595716,
-0.4097010791,
-0.2806869745,
-0.3440246582,
-0.7938609123,
0.3133024573,
-0.0343571529,
-0.6460230947,
-0.2173834443,
0.2759756148,
-0.1411571205,
0.3366406262,
-0.9489192367,
0.9897193909,
-0.3954674602,
-0.5506993532,
-0.1729117632,
-0.5886861682,
0.5469221473,
-0.1288234442,
0.3695585728,
-0.1554317772,
-0.1362333298,
0.4513298869,
-0.1904171407,
0.8242842555,
-0.1735131592,
-0.4543902278,
-0.071479775,
-0.0684661791,
0.2804123461,
-0.0292358734,
-0.0965913907,
0.0757025555,
-0.11554607,
-0.6090423465,
-0.4420005381,
0.7785933018,
-0.760827601,
-0.6751013398,
0.1537860334,
-0.9935716391,
-0.2629202902,
0.2079841942,
0.1421187818,
0.6440381408,
0.0047869971,
0.3960200548,
0.7739099264,
-0.1003124267,
0.3024162352,
0.8112663627,
-0.1066867113,
-0.360545367,
1.3956893682,
-0.0016302366,
0.288456589,
0.6940788627,
0.0813880041,
0.0049426309,
-0.2621310949,
-1.0399544239,
0.0354500972,
-0.570197165,
-0.204875201,
-0.3978334963,
0.0426716059,
-0.2002964318,
-0.1122018173,
-0.4256168604,
-0.1048169136,
-0.3600191474,
0.0816293731,
0.3118873537,
0.6940439939,
-0.0032170785,
0.2773078978,
-0.802321136,
0.5836061239,
0.2896777391,
0.5292302966,
-0.4082963467,
-0.4617426991,
-0.6162996292,
0.3929171264,
-0.058316838,
-0.6214547753,
0.2131749541,
0.4953657687,
0.5059042573,
0.5192841291,
-0.3449779749,
0.8739122748,
-0.8067876101,
0.9018959403,
0.0218863655,
-0.8454584479,
0.3488066494,
-0.3905796707,
0.4735248685,
0.3513741195,
0.267724514,
-0.3785320818,
-0.2511011958,
-0.0368143395,
-0.6635469794,
1.0347515345,
-0.1113866195,
0.0974524245,
0.2406043261,
0.0516223721,
0.2062892169,
0.2830301225,
-0.5859639049,
-0.3100856543,
-0.3416139781,
-0.4657876194,
-0.3124342859,
-0.087322101,
-0.2678432763,
-0.3565283418,
0.6514348388,
-0.5450353622,
0.1938556731,
-0.2730903029,
-0.2131097019,
-0.0919311792,
0.1211934462,
0.9550915956,
0.722514689,
-0.0496464521,
0.1613001674,
-0.0756485015,
-0.5590236187,
0.0737210885,
0.0263772551,
-0.0823316574,
-0.2896758914,
0.2915466428,
1.1037665606,
0.3835023046,
-0.68672508,
0.5514692664,
-0.0746465921,
-0.3155820668,
0.0793642327,
0.1225673631,
0.0536908619,
0.3612922728,
0.1428153366,
0.1724861711,
-0.0689164102,
-0.2844611704,
0.098668009,
0.3720825315,
-0.5927343369,
-0.2634068727,
0.7218388319,
0.0262139048,
-0.3223772645,
0.6239675879,
0.1682708263,
-0.264755249,
0.4114778042,
0.5443443656,
0.5727601051,
-0.1791322082,
0.2658063471,
0.4638953209,
0.6236587763,
-0.0583258234,
0.5146142244,
-0.140748024,
-0.4972669482,
-0.4877545238,
-0.5258877277,
-0.3572818339,
0.1528032571,
-0.668859601,
0.3217294514,
-0.1111687273,
0.377548188,
-0.1399525255,
-0.3626490831,
-0.6890847683,
0.1331924498,
0.1444366574,
0.6681033969,
-0.6214530468,
1.1538425684,
0.5649970174,
-0.284249723,
-0.7309930921,
-0.0860164016,
0.1998251379,
-1.2944449186,
0.5154438615,
0.3105073571,
-0.3251890242,
0.1805781871,
-0.6395450234,
-0.8645143509,
1.1400383711,
0.6151123047,
-0.6964061856,
-0.004998432,
0.1956231296,
0.1794523746,
-0.3489477038,
-0.0441080965,
0.4651965499,
0.6193028092,
-0.1418277323,
-0.8165708184,
-0.2679781914,
-0.4643352032,
-0.0638966188,
0.4068882167,
-0.8216766715,
1.0235799551,
-0.4969828725,
-0.0299706925,
-0.1040499434,
0.3910958469,
0.0261003394,
-0.0134619661,
0.3750175834,
0.3572850227,
0.6540254354,
-0.1907961667,
0.9571485519,
-0.4802766442,
-0.0476487055,
1.0685286522,
-0.0688319206,
0.7285467386,
0.4783183932,
0.1432266235,
0.1729258001,
0.6118508577,
-0.2036393434,
0.4469728768,
-0.0376412608,
-0.2400160879,
-0.4118286669,
-0.091986306,
-0.3036566675,
0.6350355148,
0.437194258,
-0.2428686917,
-0.0761562139,
0.3781724572,
-0.0485824086,
-0.0924595594,
-0.3473881185,
0.8313583136,
-0.3158786595,
-0.6256005764,
0.7147607803,
-0.0474546812,
0.5710998774,
-0.6985117197,
-0.216773659,
-0.1167380139,
0.329415828,
-0.0014861479,
-0.7234523892,
-0.1160867736,
0.0345764719,
-0.2905825675,
-0.1969504952,
0.1435982436,
-0.7268924713,
-0.6345937252,
0.0541361012,
0.5051121712,
-0.0282484982,
0.0130748153,
-0.6134622097,
0.1039596796,
0.2214165479,
-0.3229785264,
0.3243160546,
0.6427977085,
-0.1000344455,
0.6607090831,
0.4683393836,
-0.0658689365,
0.3028213382,
0.2410380393,
0.8948782086,
-0.720631659,
-0.17941387,
-0.7899110913,
0.6682956815,
0.1035735607,
-0.4309262931,
0.8495444655,
0.6251705289,
0.9172174335,
-0.1916880161,
0.5724145174,
0.056981992,
0.2422874123,
-0.8487610221,
0.2702067196,
-0.834064424,
0.1419311911,
-0.0635235459,
-0.8134512305,
-0.3390907049,
0.3591733873,
0.0016184991,
-0.1685943156,
0.6314418912,
0.9887397885,
-0.2428169101,
0.0964063033,
0.6128780246,
-0.1210940182,
0.1971625537,
0.6306119561,
0.6052981615,
-0.4078221619,
0.5818756819,
-0.2503525913,
-0.2975302637,
-0.2735380828,
-0.735779047,
-0.7716728449,
-0.8606706262,
0.0052424348,
0.1517343968,
0.0040080277,
0.8240740895,
0.7344164252,
-0.6840218306,
-0.3787904382,
0.1514389366,
-0.0418896675,
-0.6801794171,
-0.2040567845,
0.3317601681,
-0.5743988752,
-0.9008125067,
0.7357457876,
0.4435733855,
-0.1572158635,
-0.2510318458,
-0.023285538,
-0.2425766289,
-0.1903652549,
0.8105096221,
0.0267091058,
-0.7823696733,
-0.3197080195,
0.4620728493,
-0.2087257355,
0.2276248932,
0.8870681524,
-0.2435656488,
0.8850892186,
0.0747063905,
0.6226217151,
0.2879623771,
-0.1560103297,
0.9017222524,
-0.8900055289,
0.0599426255,
-0.1107996181,
0.4242568314,
0.4011947215,
-0.2450832278,
0.5538682938,
-0.1080297679,
-0.5344600081,
-0.5492495894,
0.1229148135,
-0.9084919691,
-0.3285789192,
1.0573180914,
-0.0040902616,
-0.3058887124,
-0.0272777528,
-0.758218348,
0.1641931534,
-0.2805445492,
0.7354631424,
0.5677870512,
-0.1099245623,
-0.3524376154,
-0.9004991055,
0.4611214101,
0.3543864787,
-0.8841775656,
0.4203102887,
0.7273622751,
-0.189981699,
0.0154907657,
0.3706273735,
0.0172214173,
0.4343339205,
-0.0770395175,
0.1110065281,
-0.3867960572,
-0.5931226015,
-0.1789977252,
0.2231635451,
-0.0150990337,
-0.4952938855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05524v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05524v2 | On the Detectability of ChatGPT Content: Benchmarking, Methodology, and Evaluation through the Lens of Academic Writing | 2023-06-07T12:33:24 | 2024-03-18T03:14:54 | Zeyan Liu, Zijun Yao, Fengjun Li, Bo Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | With ChatGPT under the spotlight, utilizing large language models (LLMs) to
assist academic writing has drawn a significant amount of debate in the
community. In this paper, we aim to present a comprehensive study of the
detectability of ChatGPT-generated content within the academic literature,
particularly focusing on the abstracts of scientific papers, to offer holistic
support for the future development of LLM applications and policies in
academia. Specifically, we first present GPABench2, a benchmarking dataset of
over 2.8 million comparative samples of human-written, GPT-written,
GPT-completed, and GPT-polished abstracts of scientific writing in computer
science, physics, and humanities and social sciences. Second, we explore the
methodology for detecting ChatGPT content. We start by examining the
unsatisfactory performance of existing ChatGPT detecting tools and the
challenges faced by human evaluators (including more than 240 researchers or
students). We then test the hand-crafted linguistic features models as a
baseline and develop a deep neural framework named CheckGPT to better capture
the subtle and deep semantic and linguistic patterns in ChatGPT written
literature. Last, we conduct comprehensive experiments to validate the proposed
CheckGPT framework in each benchmarking task over different disciplines. To
evaluate the detectability of ChatGPT content, we conduct extensive experiments
on the transferability, prompt engineering, and robustness of CheckGPT. | [
-0.1753376871,
-0.6967263818,
0.6560510993,
0.0978244692,
-0.0847304612,
0.4339822233,
-0.4223876595,
-0.7685191035,
0.0115410956,
0.3261528909,
-0.2751343548,
-0.627771616,
-0.7675747275,
0.2032898515,
-0.7570587993,
1.3220586777,
-0.2373186201,
-0.0465157293,
-0.3286001086,
0.2809207737,
0.0094798692,
-0.4280695319,
-0.7414479852,
-0.3650069237,
0.3857148886,
0.1773201674,
0.2602970898,
0.2329247445,
0.7641614676,
0.2457010299,
-0.3290539682,
0.1134829372,
-0.6809933186,
-0.0399765037,
0.045188807,
-0.4580824673,
-0.2999639809,
-0.0870635286,
0.8397498727,
0.4121779799,
-0.1407700777,
-0.0002300338,
0.4366891384,
0.5087073445,
-0.2437484264,
0.4485635459,
-0.7584825158,
0.0154080829,
-0.5045499802,
-0.0230023637,
-0.449801743,
-0.4230990708,
0.1502416432,
-0.3549414575,
0.4484780729,
0.0715442747,
0.7839782238,
-0.084831737,
-0.1964038908,
-0.4895744026,
-0.5016989112,
0.4992420375,
-0.9148076177,
0.2419647127,
0.3079976737,
0.1580832005,
-0.3411268592,
-0.9276046157,
-0.7084280849,
-0.5356659293,
-0.2004706413,
0.2093077302,
-0.2004727274,
0.0334913917,
0.2032963037,
0.508508563,
-0.9595650434,
0.048874598,
-0.2320979089,
-0.3441520929,
0.4151679873,
0.0775689185,
0.5288693309,
-0.0422415957,
-0.1940434277,
0.1643595845,
-0.7060853243,
-0.0671407133,
0.547913909,
0.0338720791,
-0.0721095428,
0.6095170379,
-0.1792484671,
0.210068658,
-0.4234685302,
0.2923244834,
-0.0665418878,
-0.6120358109,
0.1532131881,
-0.0155880582,
1.0816200972,
0.3226605952,
0.4491554201,
-0.3061056435,
-0.21701397,
0.1882751584,
0.1979610324,
-0.9459261298,
-0.6502138972,
-0.0087824324,
-0.2890481651,
-0.3363274038,
-0.3702618778,
-0.673605442,
-0.7032698393,
-0.0890108421,
-0.0160260163,
-0.6544683576,
-0.3857067823,
0.0628485382,
-0.0360200256,
0.3299336731,
0.2414862663,
-0.9276198745,
0.4382562339,
1.0643572807,
1.1870100498,
-0.4382785261,
-0.3307750821,
0.0480302759,
-0.2112629265,
-0.2198729366,
1.1538255215,
-0.4338234365,
-0.2396159917,
0.1274307966,
-0.1354342997,
-0.171555981,
-0.3250767291,
0.920475781,
-0.4594063461,
0.0394407026,
-0.1578063369,
-0.8773866892,
0.0091373548,
0.3933221996,
-0.4007426202,
1.0001606941,
0.0637815073,
-0.8554589748,
0.3020684719,
-0.6388615966,
-0.3741461933,
0.093300961,
-0.0429413766,
-0.5560157895,
-0.0683221668,
-0.1043652445,
0.3973177969,
-0.2756060362,
0.4736277163,
-0.0679438934,
-0.5348114967,
0.5967431068,
-0.6352752447,
0.3586756289,
0.0410410613,
-0.3615162075,
-0.1143187135,
-0.7005322576,
-0.0919754133,
0.0062129707,
-0.3076872826,
-0.0236275923,
0.3139739633,
0.3458003998,
-0.192786321,
0.0958301052,
-0.7437540889,
0.1038902178,
-0.1118271649,
0.7054898143,
0.4833691716,
-0.1435065418,
0.0215795916,
-0.357383132,
0.3870817423,
-0.2020449787,
-0.2023867667,
-0.3046871126,
-0.6499775052,
-0.5493761301,
-0.338069737,
0.3982292414,
0.4985376596,
-0.4569523633,
0.2326272428,
-0.1736210585,
-0.6591092348,
-0.4790079892,
0.0049988795,
0.5559708476,
0.5621965528,
0.3082585931,
-0.2852342129,
-0.5287843347,
-0.8155232668,
-0.5473341346,
-0.2374075949,
-0.2284911722,
0.0731733739,
0.6708368063,
-0.1851952821,
0.6850945354,
-0.286670655,
-0.0466553792,
-0.1467879266,
0.5362927914,
0.1659545451,
0.3743970096,
0.3005892634,
-0.3935890198,
-0.6233932376,
0.1228223145,
-0.7876445055,
-0.4409147203,
-0.0403703414,
0.0690251365,
-0.0758250952,
0.5953134894,
-0.6114505529,
0.3450244963,
0.4032267332,
-0.3792189062,
0.7991866469,
0.0179097895,
0.2561294734,
-0.6717479229,
0.2800752521,
0.2363847941,
-0.1753838062,
-0.56823349,
-0.1472391635,
0.0372836515,
-0.0105253002,
-0.0113322875,
0.4925080836,
-0.3124136627,
0.0856611282,
-0.503841877,
0.2857893705,
-0.1018354818,
0.1852496117,
0.1221034452,
0.9071466923,
0.3790150881,
-0.2260086238,
0.001498388,
0.3511195779,
-0.8962526917,
0.5937636495,
-0.9650480747,
-0.0361701809,
-0.03204735,
0.3622191846,
-1.2948309183,
-0.2035782784,
0.1897587925,
-0.4652649462,
0.2904003859,
-0.3371094167,
-0.5982336998,
0.0077083469,
-0.1101051196,
0.2135565877,
0.5617249608,
-0.2364914864,
0.3428998291,
0.380181402,
-0.6458126903,
-0.3534603715,
-0.4758420289,
0.4681148827,
0.041152034,
-0.665563643,
0.3456250429,
0.0005932154,
-0.1801009327,
-0.1022076532,
0.0149818035,
0.046412345,
0.0865690336,
0.2577074766,
0.2472448349,
-0.3051446974,
0.0181815811,
-0.1092560217,
-0.1371524185,
0.2213781178,
-0.2638874054,
0.6017057896,
-0.3876168728,
-0.4839623272,
-0.2175799608,
0.1770587116,
0.3866433799,
-0.0787591636,
0.4023528695,
1.023486495,
-0.0972511247,
-0.1621831805,
-0.6125149727,
-0.2838978767,
-0.4358816445,
0.5578477979,
0.0985505357,
-0.9813869596,
0.6642096043,
-0.0033943339,
0.1374863386,
0.3221080303,
0.5195593238,
0.0118463365,
0.7039368749,
0.3990218341,
-0.0499254391,
0.4136403501,
-0.0420505218,
0.46506688,
-1.0228234529,
-0.1940711439,
-0.8078331351,
-0.1810557693,
-0.6695861816,
-0.3157501221,
0.2521469593,
-0.2323012203,
-0.050093919,
0.2588860691,
-0.6165533066,
0.7222821116,
0.4238419533,
0.0474531315,
0.532348752,
-0.083711274,
-0.0871386677,
-0.1315758973,
-0.5444797277,
-0.8480436802,
0.9655693769,
0.4211986363,
0.6792097688,
-0.0924414024,
0.3688386977,
0.3831328452,
0.6821311116,
-0.7373886704,
0.7016270161,
-0.0652933046,
-0.4145432115,
-0.2059740275,
-0.3204785585,
-0.8320636749,
0.2120480984,
-0.2101629227,
-0.9918969274,
-0.0910808817,
-0.0726404488,
0.0689901188,
0.3877712786,
-0.6152828336,
0.8324559927,
-0.0699843764,
-0.5305207372,
-0.0004599949,
-0.3910189867,
0.3575071394,
-0.0275869872,
0.1056543961,
-0.2613447607,
0.0761219263,
0.9229443669,
-0.0239101686,
0.985219717,
0.1879938543,
-0.209519878,
0.4194507599,
0.1266401708,
0.598960042,
0.2267660946,
-0.0553962402,
0.4864538014,
0.0936531872,
-0.2381179333,
-0.1951894164,
0.667996943,
-0.6015618443,
-0.2759789526,
-0.6145517826,
-0.5151925087,
-0.1877283156,
0.2850957811,
0.3865399063,
0.2722941339,
-0.5147426128,
0.1809131652,
0.6089522839,
-0.0121770967,
0.4494356215,
0.6853055954,
-0.192403093,
-0.0369002074,
0.9539803267,
-0.1090654358,
-0.0418875366,
0.3479712605,
0.1402838826,
-0.3183134794,
-1.1953924894,
-0.2666207552,
0.1838006824,
-0.5984057784,
0.1139227897,
-0.7454613447,
-0.4814244509,
-0.2661246955,
-0.0879787207,
-0.3215420842,
-0.103244707,
-0.0108758155,
-0.011440983,
0.2931441367,
0.6952305436,
0.1088230535,
0.3289797306,
-0.6515297294,
0.0716474727,
0.0061969324,
0.564506948,
0.0188348554,
-0.5155758262,
-0.1541595757,
0.0239020977,
-0.2758883238,
-0.3514792919,
0.2648788691,
0.2006644756,
0.4515913129,
0.2745840549,
-0.2795138657,
0.1845847368,
-0.6317417026,
0.8436779976,
-0.0467665195,
-0.8214429021,
0.1897350103,
-0.6406131983,
0.1463472843,
0.6450340152,
0.4808184505,
-0.8230898976,
-0.5988103747,
-0.4930078387,
-0.846637249,
0.1660801768,
0.3706813455,
0.1798596382,
-0.0770312697,
0.2317993045,
0.1857583225,
0.2507352531,
-0.6270763278,
0.3106556833,
0.0044463058,
-0.2017330378,
-0.1379035711,
-0.365337342,
-0.1513121724,
0.2451094389,
0.5696151257,
-0.1326907724,
0.2758345604,
0.1847925484,
-0.0203082822,
0.2876943946,
0.36589697,
0.6143648028,
0.6741483808,
-0.2471019328,
0.14154917,
-0.2488634586,
-0.9649435282,
-0.1684987992,
0.2844450474,
-0.4823886752,
0.2002720535,
0.6217288375,
0.5198358297,
0.3963567019,
-0.8238396645,
0.4780445695,
-0.1655596197,
-0.3463508189,
-0.3587319851,
0.2212858349,
0.0915164202,
0.1922917664,
0.2255526334,
-0.0850025564,
0.4099303484,
-0.4256060123,
0.1918208301,
0.6194981933,
-0.5318917036,
-0.330715239,
0.6053426266,
-0.011635365,
-0.1055302992,
0.5668763518,
-0.0771880969,
-0.568156302,
0.6666115522,
0.4172714651,
0.8247701526,
0.1452725232,
0.3949165046,
0.2106161118,
0.3889284432,
-0.203747496,
0.0890857205,
0.0805286393,
-0.7378882766,
-0.4874594808,
-0.6349648833,
-0.8181042671,
0.1150743142,
-0.4030178189,
0.1839020401,
-0.2141427994,
-0.1083090082,
0.4371055663,
-0.0987254456,
-0.4453446865,
-0.252649188,
0.0238157474,
0.6062548161,
-0.8306990266,
0.4184289575,
0.5095749497,
-0.0936997607,
-0.4806574285,
-0.120039247,
0.2733878791,
-0.8094016314,
0.2871533632,
0.1105660945,
-0.0055235578,
-0.0997148156,
-0.6561552882,
-0.5251128674,
0.8958884478,
0.0753208101,
-0.5942326188,
0.1437033862,
0.2222388834,
0.8637810349,
-0.034520492,
0.7656029463,
0.6290338039,
0.5511018038,
0.190306291,
-0.9627718329,
-0.0053127264,
-0.4851046503,
-0.2343151867,
0.1934034675,
-0.5757361054,
0.7532798052,
0.0874648616,
-0.2241349071,
0.0860969946,
0.3655740619,
0.1961590946,
0.5163338184,
-0.1047694609,
0.3178800046,
0.8955187798,
-0.3184784949,
0.9685659409,
-0.3068152368,
0.2966310382,
0.952650547,
-0.5193592906,
0.7451541424,
0.3507529795,
-0.3859784007,
0.5211812854,
0.5052759051,
-0.4002226293,
0.3570730686,
0.523835361,
-0.6003584266,
0.0834494829,
-0.2962981462,
-0.4210309684,
0.4617370963,
0.3467860818,
-0.3249877393,
-0.1939063221,
-0.2220054716,
0.2309538126,
0.0686583221,
-0.1679094732,
0.8731616735,
0.2187583447,
-0.7859500051,
0.4204895198,
-0.1939143091,
0.6754336953,
-0.6075920463,
-0.0915302038,
-0.3032476008,
0.1720187813,
-0.2294785827,
-1.0793327093,
0.2702846527,
0.2130881548,
0.0275518782,
-0.0893600807,
1.0998528004,
-0.4361929595,
-0.4635638297,
-0.1063494384,
0.5386381745,
0.3078202605,
-0.1518583,
-0.2402541935,
0.0009181807,
-0.1954007149,
-0.3208900094,
0.6626586318,
0.4915975928,
0.2328830957,
0.7751591802,
0.7672675252,
0.345308423,
-0.2044710368,
-0.0057231043,
0.7704325914,
-0.3087755144,
-0.3687418699,
-0.9507316947,
0.4372946918,
-0.3009416759,
-0.3135590553,
0.7889459133,
0.6259875298,
0.6966502666,
-0.1084870845,
1.1532189846,
-0.040181715,
0.4680284262,
-0.6259232759,
1.0450848341,
0.0431683995,
0.3773941398,
-0.378228575,
-0.7117622495,
-0.2120418251,
0.4827554524,
-0.4366782904,
-0.0806743726,
0.7739503384,
0.8375028372,
-0.0713991225,
0.3924540281,
0.1013956964,
0.061314594,
0.4827900529,
0.4292098284,
0.9710873961,
-0.2757362425,
0.6209930778,
0.0967537388,
-0.2522206306,
-0.2058633119,
-1.2175625563,
-1.0937014818,
-0.4850431383,
-0.4914506674,
-0.4412079751,
0.2337943912,
0.3129684627,
0.3631876707,
-1.020534277,
-0.0441364087,
-0.3103922009,
0.1150077954,
-0.0938639045,
-0.2236561328,
0.4381955564,
-0.2870699763,
-0.4838253558,
0.2172201127,
0.2222371548,
-0.0408430286,
-0.1898927242,
0.1802905649,
0.0296106283,
0.0009991317,
0.5734545588,
0.443510294,
-0.3427540064,
-0.2415480912,
0.0594753064,
-0.2616184652,
0.0173657611,
0.9292270541,
-0.3490051031,
0.1323431432,
0.5476546288,
0.7955136895,
0.4955727458,
-0.227466777,
0.4344601035,
-0.5245830417,
-0.263320297,
0.4581883848,
0.4602430761,
0.3781505525,
-0.106311135,
0.8337122202,
0.265784651,
-1.1152242422,
-0.7672351599,
-0.1022634655,
-1.089989543,
0.0208430998,
1.1308546066,
-0.4550879002,
0.061839968,
-0.3499522507,
-0.4059209228,
0.0992718339,
-0.3587595224,
1.270232439,
0.9536057711,
-0.0990973935,
-0.3476128876,
-0.9289820194,
0.6251862049,
0.2655490637,
-0.961828649,
0.1739230156,
0.3865574896,
0.26363796,
0.1389879137,
0.6259664297,
-0.2109801024,
0.1833089143,
0.1856894642,
0.060469579,
-0.1008544266,
0.07540638,
0.0187694076,
0.1148697808,
0.0961836353,
0.3701962531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07936v1 | FOOCTTS: Generating Arabic Speech with Acoustic Environment for Football Commentator | 2023-06-07T12:33:02 | 2023-06-07T12:33:02 | Massa Baali, Ahmed Ali | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | This paper presents FOOCTTS, an automatic pipeline for a football commentator
that generates speech with background crowd noise. The application gets the
text from the user, applies text pre-processing such as vowelization, followed
by the commentator's speech synthesizer. Our pipeline included Arabic automatic
speech recognition for data labeling, CTC segmentation, transcription
vowelization to match speech, and fine-tuning the TTS. Our system is capable of
generating speech with its acoustic environment within limited 15 minutes of
football commentator recording. Our prototype is generalizable and can be
easily applied to different domains and languages. | [
-0.7739083767,
-0.6994787455,
-0.0489692017,
0.2633146048,
-0.4626434147,
0.3492539525,
-0.0573164262,
-0.6072508693,
0.6237950325,
0.449265331,
-0.8913620114,
-0.370428592,
-0.3060218394,
0.4096319377,
-0.7271212935,
1.2820302248,
0.4285478294,
-0.1288542598,
0.6478952765,
-0.102448009,
-0.4259498119,
-0.4587672651,
-1.0609498024,
0.1471120268,
-0.0528888628,
0.3442411721,
0.836153388,
0.465526849,
0.028119361,
0.5122474432,
-0.0881997123,
0.1049662605,
-0.3766033649,
0.5438777804,
0.0337800346,
0.3850771189,
0.0057809693,
-0.2902750373,
0.7996740937,
0.0495934859,
-0.1285231262,
-0.1078153923,
-0.1877706349,
0.4752115905,
-0.2530588806,
0.1073266938,
-0.658542335,
0.0372359939,
-0.1757737696,
-0.2075021118,
-0.1419590265,
-0.5662170053,
0.1176793948,
-0.3864169717,
0.2059798986,
-0.3289591074,
0.8304561973,
0.6075783372,
-0.303982228,
-0.3241139054,
-0.7514718175,
0.3746157885,
-0.4391491413,
0.7325955033,
0.2817933857,
0.4938110113,
0.0289778877,
-0.481534481,
-0.1970842034,
-0.2022859305,
0.0243408382,
0.4570667744,
0.0868204311,
0.2553783655,
-0.0909784809,
0.243871212,
-0.1253305525,
-0.3659000099,
-0.4973416626,
-0.3738448918,
0.8804320097,
-0.0686479658,
0.1941457987,
0.0998281762,
-0.2068767548,
0.3117908537,
-0.5956405997,
-0.036001388,
0.5217546821,
0.2823750973,
-0.1728131324,
0.108769536,
-0.4971460402,
0.6941477656,
0.2250705361,
-0.2750553787,
0.0008923438,
-0.0430710204,
0.0305225737,
0.5435209274,
0.6203136444,
-0.121729441,
0.3441347182,
-0.283909142,
-0.3496597409,
-0.3237966597,
0.2362022847,
-1.1260248423,
-0.5663672686,
0.3793244958,
-0.2973277569,
-0.3720353544,
0.2453969121,
-0.6843981743,
-0.0003665935,
-0.3015106022,
0.1510628611,
-0.6688144803,
-0.3545120656,
-0.2011658102,
-0.3986586332,
0.0804002956,
0.3244428039,
-0.7529454827,
0.4784486592,
0.1550810486,
0.8192935586,
0.1005096287,
-0.1030964628,
-1.1595609188,
0.4592375159,
-0.426399231,
1.0751324892,
-0.1767961234,
-0.697510004,
0.3217765391,
-0.2994518578,
0.3900483251,
-0.3398324251,
0.4886473417,
-0.4620311856,
-0.1767692268,
-0.2567062378,
-0.5174260139,
0.1587890983,
-0.4303156435,
-0.5707420707,
1.0844801664,
0.1846756488,
-0.6684305072,
0.6264122725,
-0.872195363,
-0.8106433153,
0.650781095,
-0.2261179984,
-0.5219979286,
-0.0657305568,
0.2451207787,
0.1542415917,
0.3532173932,
-0.0194986966,
0.3741321564,
-0.5527684093,
0.4383286238,
-0.1518067122,
1.0018479824,
0.5977618098,
-0.5837891698,
-0.0121741164,
-0.7165368199,
0.1309105009,
-0.4241914749,
-0.7369202375,
0.1804019064,
0.4346430302,
0.5421346426,
0.0721651018,
-0.1982387155,
-0.7188311815,
-0.0297715906,
-0.5489907265,
0.6247132421,
0.6961888075,
0.0074783671,
-0.1293313503,
-0.3269351125,
0.4818754494,
-0.2923964858,
-0.2863683105,
0.0445832796,
-0.3580159247,
-0.4907984436,
-0.931435883,
0.1546288878,
0.5182716846,
-0.7523241639,
0.2849728465,
0.0290418342,
-0.5759452581,
-0.3986392915,
0.1880010068,
0.2702840865,
0.398756355,
0.2280256748,
0.0610218905,
-1.0831352472,
-0.7446928024,
-0.1588487476,
-0.5324978232,
0.014023439,
0.2376344502,
0.3589134812,
-0.084582597,
1.123281002,
-0.2487540245,
-0.5273076296,
-0.0585750081,
0.1362516433,
0.0726415515,
0.52728194,
1.0198911428,
-0.8757305145,
-0.8413478732,
-0.0511572696,
-0.2176279128,
-0.747568965,
0.1521596014,
0.0311217029,
0.4768690467,
0.7718507648,
-0.4155143201,
0.3132665753,
0.7068577409,
-0.5521325469,
0.9513685107,
0.4300829172,
0.5479816198,
-0.9435329437,
-0.0992909893,
-0.1827887893,
-0.6105557084,
-0.5528296828,
-0.2034706622,
-0.7786892056,
-0.2296200693,
-0.6414341927,
0.5008854866,
-0.4503350854,
0.0835713595,
-0.3832191229,
-0.0641646609,
-0.3292118609,
0.0258917268,
0.6060260534,
1.4513878822,
0.4478914142,
-0.7075305581,
0.5609565973,
0.6215356588,
-0.5256076455,
0.6024151444,
-0.5214524865,
0.2254127264,
0.2815535665,
0.4299877286,
-1.481806159,
-0.3383909166,
0.2293991297,
-0.622657299,
-0.0828833356,
-0.1942686737,
-0.2116914392,
-0.4033071399,
-0.0916823894,
0.3683435321,
0.5798476338,
-0.4439999461,
0.2513878047,
0.7862254977,
-0.6403250098,
-0.2016839832,
-0.4573622346,
0.1811765432,
-0.214392066,
-0.7197428346,
0.3799157739,
-0.116632387,
-0.2623134851,
-0.0520092919,
-0.0440740883,
-0.6322922111,
-0.0344182253,
0.3212839365,
-0.1136470288,
-0.5134330988,
0.1062890515,
0.2615618408,
0.2886574566,
0.2141223401,
-0.4662172794,
0.2791009545,
-0.2339589596,
0.2723276615,
-0.8169168234,
0.7631087899,
-0.031271223,
-0.0731637701,
0.5331314802,
0.7609272599,
-0.140523091,
-0.2270102203,
-0.7296032906,
-0.4144273996,
-0.6039764881,
0.5606842041,
-0.7420240045,
-0.8409584165,
0.4165284038,
0.2054062784,
0.3256109357,
0.5380422473,
0.6794810295,
-0.3650166392,
1.1784603596,
0.2194076627,
-0.2020264417,
0.508687973,
-0.0430963822,
-0.2704599798,
-0.2069874704,
0.0287510604,
-0.9761587381,
0.0018507777,
-0.4659783244,
0.1859966367,
0.2593194544,
-0.2380048782,
-0.3751522303,
0.0566819422,
-0.6419081092,
0.7500880361,
0.481228888,
-0.1418961436,
0.1112158895,
-0.0020293477,
0.0642230585,
-0.0893161148,
-0.594607234,
-0.3587054908,
0.4197713435,
0.1942352951,
0.4265938401,
0.3701536059,
1.0441402197,
0.7470998764,
0.7053243518,
-0.7970409989,
0.3579569161,
-0.0446085222,
-1.018728137,
-0.6429664493,
-0.1298228353,
-0.5894230008,
-0.0171338134,
-0.1519321799,
-0.9203509092,
-0.180612281,
0.4039869606,
-0.3647445142,
0.2957409322,
-0.4562774301,
0.2452782542,
0.2533634901,
-0.3737426996,
0.1390353888,
-0.5245332718,
0.1654760987,
0.1605672091,
0.3214302063,
0.1862712801,
0.0557880551,
1.1985883713,
-0.8873355985,
0.688225925,
-0.4732019901,
-0.3116547763,
0.8872122765,
0.3961233199,
0.267950654,
0.3942773938,
0.0435557775,
0.2005281895,
0.2283726782,
-0.2548012137,
0.1476797312,
0.3798404932,
-0.8891910911,
-0.7882261276,
-0.3272095621,
-0.3901893198,
-0.3650908172,
0.0413145609,
0.5897550583,
0.4416286051,
-0.686009407,
0.1457533836,
0.375074029,
0.0904652849,
0.5616515875,
0.5005265474,
-0.1990771294,
-0.8430073261,
0.7907534838,
-0.0114843864,
-0.3181317747,
0.1076756641,
0.0502542369,
-0.6363748312,
-0.6870258451,
-0.7122990489,
0.0710386783,
-0.4958674908,
-0.4750585556,
-0.3625926673,
-0.6688341498,
-0.5524144173,
-0.3916150331,
-0.4213078022,
-0.2797232568,
-0.0230801776,
-0.2628893554,
0.5770562887,
1.0957379341,
-0.5246477723,
0.9408041835,
-0.9810369611,
0.4090170264,
0.4281565249,
0.261249572,
-0.6286638379,
-0.6688870192,
-0.720636487,
0.1700033993,
-0.3268951178,
-1.1991199255,
0.6446498632,
0.6105055809,
0.2594239116,
0.6848844886,
-0.1845793873,
0.5725371838,
-0.6397817731,
0.8339526057,
-0.0339815393,
-1.3684834242,
0.5879835486,
-0.7321711183,
0.0939858034,
0.6065613627,
0.0064892485,
-0.5269681811,
-0.8066606522,
-0.3604449034,
-0.4658058286,
1.0081980228,
0.5427739024,
-0.054756429,
-0.3190258443,
0.057418026,
0.2338875979,
0.2468880862,
-0.3381206393,
-0.1392537653,
-0.7361155152,
0.0258697104,
-0.1427566111,
-0.1848146468,
-0.1780509949,
-0.4201630652,
0.9453859925,
-0.1056240126,
0.2803886831,
0.3695763052,
0.0659021959,
-0.1531615406,
0.0663608015,
0.678532064,
0.5147469044,
-0.5322427154,
-0.2305412143,
0.2278020084,
-0.57212466,
0.3528144062,
0.2181652337,
-0.0916566849,
0.7187963128,
0.2335273474,
0.4424578547,
0.0655553192,
-0.6213408709,
0.1641865671,
0.1206681803,
-0.7643799782,
-0.7609168887,
-0.0027120728,
0.1803751886,
-0.1291717142,
0.6054413915,
-0.1626303047,
0.331630379,
-0.2032126188,
0.6571442485,
0.3656568527,
-0.716242671,
-0.2194291204,
1.1224132776,
0.8961099386,
-0.4915713966,
0.5724250674,
0.2230060399,
-0.6093987823,
0.6826512218,
0.5432954431,
0.9481505752,
-0.893416822,
0.5753340125,
0.0776143745,
-0.0201049503,
0.4823660254,
0.5466238856,
-0.318400383,
-0.6596518159,
-0.5994640589,
-0.6299281716,
-0.3569466174,
0.1890322566,
-0.4369513094,
0.1659663618,
-0.3681128323,
-0.1616244912,
0.1570848972,
-0.0244756471,
-0.5119683743,
0.535836041,
0.1834139973,
0.9467980862,
-0.9556891322,
0.8947252631,
0.9792575836,
-0.2287224084,
-0.7309496403,
-0.1198237091,
0.0737746507,
-0.6016353965,
1.0727021694,
-0.0542096794,
-0.5390482545,
0.3117718697,
-0.562235713,
-0.6054934859,
0.4110376835,
0.3819578588,
-0.2992766201,
0.3028677404,
0.295877248,
0.4200549424,
-0.4023966193,
0.161002636,
0.5178520083,
0.6500627995,
0.0661712289,
-0.8085671067,
-0.2394318581,
-0.0755034313,
-0.2808272839,
0.1699908972,
-0.9694533944,
0.7332522273,
0.2386905849,
-0.202593565,
0.2812303007,
0.7707206607,
0.0716017857,
-0.2625538409,
0.6372817159,
0.2598857582,
0.3964328766,
-0.2406049669,
0.6429646015,
-0.4083939195,
0.0266467519,
0.7666566968,
0.0419492573,
0.5863050818,
0.4363021255,
-0.2864447534,
0.371101737,
0.6520544887,
0.3075518906,
0.558678925,
0.2463744432,
-0.474799186,
-0.2938086689,
-0.1260540038,
-0.5525922179,
0.7441102862,
0.3128194213,
-0.1104909256,
-0.0814936981,
-0.332373172,
-0.0141399335,
0.1035045087,
-0.1521724313,
1.1058472395,
-0.0713077337,
-0.6262848973,
0.8281645775,
-0.1032954454,
0.5995228291,
-0.7675401568,
-0.1968867928,
-0.2876485884,
-0.1745845526,
-0.2767339051,
-0.6176040173,
0.6401039958,
-0.0694598183,
0.2076414376,
-0.1396937817,
0.5647704005,
-0.3583821356,
-0.1926969141,
0.0584952161,
0.4433024824,
0.4653281569,
-0.3078587949,
-0.4839467406,
0.1376409978,
0.2717058659,
-0.3368805945,
-0.1149164364,
0.4528521001,
0.3953449726,
0.4546771944,
0.4877859056,
0.5444866419,
0.1242192686,
-0.0822175443,
0.7352569699,
-0.7985540628,
-0.8581596613,
-0.7969840765,
0.2870211899,
-0.1109455302,
-0.5492502451,
0.4210587144,
0.9725685716,
0.5624281168,
-0.5167363882,
1.1302479506,
-0.0484556407,
0.5617013574,
-0.5760026574,
1.0587244034,
-0.1915200353,
-0.2118453085,
-0.5457869172,
-0.9036616087,
0.1105227694,
0.7703194618,
0.2930722833,
-0.084716484,
0.5041790605,
0.5583350062,
-0.0302743018,
0.2619466782,
0.3586653471,
0.2337988168,
0.2862516642,
0.2207889408,
0.9346846342,
-0.2288993299,
0.7372762561,
-0.1657922417,
-0.0120686069,
-0.3047810197,
-0.4956375659,
-0.9970164299,
-0.8553122878,
-0.4364939034,
-0.3794101179,
0.7047774196,
0.7297019958,
1.1157902479,
-1.012216568,
-0.7690489888,
0.1065101922,
-0.1410139501,
-0.2839074135,
-0.3647201061,
0.4076481164,
-0.297416985,
-1.0481910706,
0.5434088707,
-0.0023073731,
0.0670251101,
-0.0450186543,
-0.2532654703,
-0.1969798803,
0.2911690176,
0.5024935603,
0.6457586884,
-0.5100283623,
-0.6533473134,
-0.6093264818,
0.1507075578,
0.2850059867,
0.6079257727,
-1.0462486744,
-0.1314807683,
0.2984707057,
0.5991098285,
0.3947018385,
0.3738252223,
0.602344811,
-0.8370580077,
0.6030257344,
0.5659020543,
0.0929581672,
0.1308423281,
-0.2519668043,
0.5191380382,
0.1744029522,
-0.5800228715,
-0.7662841082,
0.1100304052,
-0.7230713964,
-0.1890106797,
1.0967812538,
0.1834068,
0.0714710727,
-0.5419852138,
-0.82268399,
0.389827311,
-0.9224616885,
0.8751062155,
0.6267284751,
-0.1778259724,
0.1662045419,
-0.3968690336,
1.2344961166,
0.3201148212,
-0.6188647151,
-0.2626413703,
0.8316269517,
0.459092319,
-0.1919922829,
1.0781754255,
0.2678981423,
0.4132246971,
0.2434770316,
-0.1362584382,
0.0022425242,
-0.2320626527,
0.4290450811,
0.1977807283,
-0.0547456034,
-0.4635582566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04384v1 | Multilingual Clinical NER: Translation or Cross-lingual Transfer? | 2023-06-07T12:31:07 | 2023-06-07T12:31:07 | Xavier Fontaine, Félix Gaschi, Parisa Rastin, Yannick Toussaint | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Natural language tasks like Named Entity Recognition (NER) in the clinical
domain on non-English texts can be very time-consuming and expensive due to the
lack of annotated data. Cross-lingual transfer (CLT) is a way to circumvent
this issue thanks to the ability of multilingual large language models to be
fine-tuned on a specific task in one language and to provide high accuracy for
the same task in another language. However, other methods leveraging
translation models can be used to perform NER without annotated data in the
target language, by either translating the training set or test set. This paper
compares cross-lingual transfer with these two alternative methods, to perform
clinical NER in French and in German without any training data in those
languages. To this end, we release MedNERF a medical NER test set extracted
from French drug prescriptions and annotated with the same guidelines as an
English dataset. Through extensive experiments on this dataset and on a German
medical dataset (Frei and Kramer, 2021), we show that translation-based methods
can achieve similar performance to CLT but require more care in their design.
And while they can take advantage of monolingual clinical language models,
those do not guarantee better results than large general-purpose multilingual
models, whether with cross-lingual transfer or translation. | [
-0.2343351692,
-0.5082588792,
0.4739708602,
0.3013281822,
-0.1484016627,
-0.130812183,
-0.2969601154,
-0.8693070412,
0.4002149403,
0.6122043133,
-0.3606861234,
-0.1524811834,
-0.9146466255,
0.3874100447,
-0.3442254663,
1.0517885685,
-0.3334238827,
0.7499132156,
-0.1063661352,
-0.3814081848,
-0.4359363317,
-0.718977809,
-1.0181837082,
-0.7247068882,
0.7833889127,
0.2065472454,
0.4482838809,
0.2341817766,
0.8560212255,
0.2355705649,
0.274548918,
-0.0867006406,
-0.0837107822,
-0.393725872,
-0.3337896466,
-0.2006850243,
-0.4727922976,
-0.3974990845,
0.3728714287,
0.8890612125,
0.1440196484,
-0.1857917309,
-0.281396687,
0.6421467066,
-0.4649940729,
0.0926762,
0.0524828508,
0.1962442547,
0.0373469293,
-0.193091169,
-0.4245646894,
-0.2405854613,
0.6022276282,
-0.6332876682,
0.2662754953,
-0.1176923439,
0.8917624354,
0.0094157076,
-0.7918514013,
-0.6012369394,
-0.830275178,
0.5034169555,
-0.642026484,
0.792011261,
0.2705270648,
0.3630656004,
0.1125652939,
-0.8003914356,
-0.3983039558,
-0.3595545888,
-0.4654975235,
-0.0155549115,
-0.2053896636,
-0.0207108613,
0.2587845623,
0.1328391284,
-0.6620414853,
0.0375858061,
-0.7624043226,
-0.3226549327,
0.5306153893,
-0.1936071217,
0.686276257,
-0.0764544085,
-0.6410397291,
-0.1843013316,
-0.715697825,
-0.2366425693,
-0.2874229848,
0.4724594653,
-0.3577538133,
0.5290009379,
0.0960324183,
0.5702319145,
-0.08209344,
-0.2557203174,
0.5132439733,
-0.4664597511,
-0.0671884418,
0.5194519758,
0.8399627209,
0.5150966644,
0.766985774,
-0.5889236331,
-0.2580687702,
0.0301180854,
-0.0892759115,
-0.8153847456,
-0.3619140089,
-0.086965248,
-0.316930443,
0.1075449213,
-0.2112248242,
-0.7998788357,
-0.1668623537,
-0.3972862661,
0.3348184228,
-0.3842189908,
-0.1281771958,
0.2252611518,
-0.0279156081,
0.2139168382,
0.2101645172,
-0.5923396349,
0.5266525149,
0.1149778143,
0.7048239112,
-0.4511814415,
-0.2114269137,
-0.7484208941,
0.0198450591,
-0.4205804467,
0.7948769927,
-0.2336637527,
-0.324849546,
0.03546739,
0.4597913921,
-0.514464736,
-0.3793419302,
0.2759509981,
-0.3619484007,
0.3703353107,
-0.3780080676,
-0.3510941565,
-0.2306241095,
-0.0648770779,
-0.7130014896,
0.6348552108,
0.1056493744,
-0.6523821354,
0.5057972074,
-0.6815120578,
-1.0119731426,
0.0523814298,
0.0400246233,
0.09719567,
0.0097995326,
0.5047058463,
0.2408757508,
-0.3312313557,
0.2828609645,
-0.092980288,
-0.0876351595,
0.2628085911,
-0.324783951,
0.5217813253,
0.0346002504,
-0.4145823121,
-0.3501929045,
-0.7637812495,
0.048625838,
0.0006440364,
-0.1411094218,
-0.5580780506,
-0.332536757,
0.5669760108,
0.622954905,
0.0519960262,
-0.6263223886,
-0.2693281174,
-0.4361769259,
0.3128459156,
0.1266131252,
0.0845927447,
0.5584943891,
-0.4507839978,
0.5303913951,
-0.1732580364,
-0.08903905,
0.35434708,
-0.3352069855,
-0.8033336401,
-0.2055249214,
0.7032954097,
1.0153975487,
-0.932608664,
-0.3519854546,
-0.4492459297,
-0.3827698827,
-0.6749836206,
-0.0764588863,
0.5986604095,
0.7251859307,
0.6649697423,
-0.3775019944,
-0.3443017304,
-1.0402156115,
-0.1048249602,
0.0868693888,
0.3564296365,
0.4981767237,
0.6555313468,
-0.2293594182,
0.1187509894,
-0.1319846362,
-0.6441217065,
-0.4636017382,
0.0688556507,
-0.0457976758,
0.6122413874,
0.6761726141,
-0.8885028958,
-0.8433789015,
0.6470720172,
-0.8579560518,
-0.2781456411,
-0.375670135,
0.1175744981,
0.3720102608,
0.7681772709,
-0.2835700214,
0.5669285059,
0.7007687092,
-0.0230387133,
0.0900892243,
-0.4353458881,
0.362875402,
-1.0122067928,
0.4262012541,
-0.1736570597,
-0.4627804458,
-1.0157343149,
-0.1531843394,
0.2315357625,
0.0288972408,
-0.86543262,
1.1393858194,
-0.7242631316,
0.2809475362,
-0.2767148912,
0.1259790808,
0.0962934047,
0.1562584937,
0.3912931681,
0.6209335923,
0.5756312609,
-0.636872232,
0.2932880819,
0.3874452412,
-0.135201782,
0.8611351848,
-0.7853900194,
-0.0046597016,
-0.0672237575,
-0.0215272382,
-0.4186500609,
-0.1786724776,
0.4321711063,
-0.2524057329,
0.647190094,
-0.2563966215,
-0.2750057876,
-0.1052743345,
0.4682903886,
0.5630284548,
0.3883430958,
-0.413433522,
0.2946849465,
0.2026041448,
-0.399140805,
-0.4824307859,
-1.2188829184,
0.1159138009,
-0.2124047279,
-0.4081589282,
0.4423654974,
0.1939513683,
-0.1099273339,
0.1325000077,
0.0273985006,
-0.3356012106,
-0.3527357876,
-0.0253649931,
0.2062106878,
-0.4639941752,
0.3670672178,
0.0536805205,
-0.3055776358,
-0.0802209452,
-0.0146665704,
0.2514278889,
-0.0136174327,
-0.4945420027,
-0.2763644755,
0.8064441681,
0.5646841526,
-0.3053223491,
0.5656340718,
0.6385040879,
-0.5324087143,
0.0358887315,
-0.6664630771,
-0.3345553577,
-0.3102277815,
0.2621256113,
-0.3711589277,
-0.6456766725,
0.399631232,
0.1222112104,
-0.1946881264,
0.3346732259,
0.4064393938,
0.1160219461,
0.8430284262,
0.7143620253,
0.1946151406,
0.1765311062,
0.2257808894,
0.5354692936,
-0.5788742304,
-0.1760994345,
-0.3484048545,
-0.2151907384,
-0.7148759961,
-0.2830836773,
0.4217295349,
-0.061231479,
0.1184281856,
0.5742937922,
-0.4184599519,
0.215052098,
0.2855678201,
0.0817593336,
0.4747839272,
0.2305065393,
-0.1057881266,
-0.3039282858,
-0.8119453192,
-0.1635422111,
1.0111845732,
-0.100652419,
0.5155153275,
-0.014432149,
0.5767324567,
-0.027736539,
0.5358406305,
-0.715305686,
0.3273839653,
-0.5269957781,
-0.4515207708,
-0.0557949543,
-0.4332855046,
-1.1724970341,
0.4033958912,
-0.3261354566,
-0.5173067451,
0.4937516153,
-0.1700652391,
-0.0651237667,
0.3022427261,
-0.7163652182,
0.9582021832,
-0.6494053006,
-0.0050244574,
0.1647661775,
-0.6670535207,
0.0168784745,
-0.3948916793,
0.4231764078,
0.0325954482,
0.029956622,
0.6394967437,
-0.3411896527,
0.5355472565,
0.0048026247,
0.1627726257,
-0.2013003975,
0.1142590195,
0.4548974633,
0.0618903711,
0.1673277467,
0.2077762783,
0.4267505705,
-0.309127897,
-0.6786034107,
0.7328680754,
-0.447758764,
-0.2986767292,
-0.7785856724,
-0.6246140599,
-0.1456103474,
0.560747087,
0.6437724829,
0.6317917705,
-0.3492087424,
-0.2256479412,
0.3929220438,
-0.3510602415,
0.1508969367,
0.7497215271,
-0.2460723519,
-0.357486099,
0.8064209819,
0.1486187726,
0.5211440921,
0.5808362365,
-0.0180681311,
-0.3972735703,
-0.5674700737,
-0.6453567147,
0.693575561,
-0.7193316817,
0.171058625,
-0.7945263386,
-0.3891548216,
-0.5614523888,
-0.4019931555,
-0.3956707418,
-0.3993080258,
-0.0145378541,
0.0165139902,
0.4568545818,
0.5074166059,
-0.2566948831,
-0.0152274044,
-0.934487462,
0.289622277,
-0.1441843361,
0.0533601455,
-0.4217970073,
-0.328699708,
-0.0555785261,
0.15079014,
0.4055323899,
-1.0051447153,
0.6632593274,
0.22668688,
0.4133628607,
0.0067501492,
0.0456272848,
0.9581878185,
-0.7601180673,
0.2059687227,
0.3440109491,
-0.6368936896,
0.2867559791,
0.0905848369,
0.222366482,
0.8014543653,
0.6935161948,
-1.0673683882,
-0.0185245834,
-0.4203341305,
-0.9115322828,
0.4957233369,
-0.1486369073,
0.0728109628,
-0.0954019278,
0.0168363675,
0.0647518337,
0.047651168,
-0.6217173338,
-0.0313897245,
0.186323151,
0.0959293544,
-0.4998394251,
0.2788387835,
-0.2848979235,
-0.148268193,
0.5880895257,
-0.1946139783,
0.2041093409,
0.8266367316,
-0.3587960303,
-0.0037929933,
0.4382892549,
0.4323143661,
0.495978117,
0.0115144057,
0.0707316622,
0.4564714432,
-0.4039100111,
0.2348666638,
0.4306493104,
-0.2365112752,
0.3911828995,
0.4422939718,
0.7955893874,
0.4364909828,
-0.7571207881,
0.6968480349,
0.032704547,
-0.3821744025,
-0.3549962938,
-0.4337231517,
0.0222098362,
0.1747136712,
-0.3890199065,
0.0331450291,
0.2380060554,
-0.2043543458,
0.4266824722,
0.196389854,
-0.8424497247,
-0.2605649829,
0.5431876779,
-0.0717903897,
-0.2277501822,
0.834967196,
0.0716698319,
-0.2279501259,
0.4803142548,
0.7035761476,
0.6914166212,
-0.049923826,
0.3052113652,
0.4449967742,
0.3401315212,
-0.3072519898,
0.2012856454,
0.3002512753,
-0.6232452393,
-0.5783113837,
-0.286193043,
-0.3199565411,
0.010520597,
-0.8383777738,
0.3264645636,
-0.0719765797,
-0.1287609786,
0.1183972061,
-0.5531301498,
-0.8526740074,
0.1810650975,
0.0522209071,
0.8867152929,
-0.8243387938,
0.7227011919,
1.0155858994,
-0.2956304848,
-0.6173058748,
-0.3978804052,
-0.028263662,
-0.5897498131,
0.6250430942,
0.0016233261,
0.1413832605,
-0.2487276345,
0.2322125733,
-0.9668394923,
0.7124040127,
0.1661331952,
-0.4782818258,
-0.2790923119,
0.4191875458,
0.7393673062,
-0.3282836676,
0.0601597019,
0.4141643345,
0.5398509502,
0.1100959554,
-1.3786169291,
0.1182511002,
-0.3103990555,
-0.2610237002,
0.4503353536,
-0.245393157,
0.6923978925,
-0.4959810078,
-0.3372121155,
-0.0814699233,
0.1314372569,
-0.1366368681,
0.4265099466,
0.2514889538,
0.3955133557,
0.5973079205,
-0.058173582,
1.310770154,
-0.4391392469,
0.1171168908,
1.0362448692,
-0.6789479852,
0.7865363359,
0.7290782332,
0.1376484931,
0.1430546492,
0.3825444579,
-0.0848735347,
0.6163716316,
-0.0545960478,
-0.2122806609,
-0.1842101216,
-0.2519459128,
-0.5731628537,
0.3339696825,
0.1806910485,
-0.3581277132,
-0.4203824401,
0.4123548865,
0.2371638715,
-0.058362063,
-0.0203840453,
0.8950834274,
0.5428853631,
-0.9522231817,
0.7203842998,
-0.1186415404,
0.2877593935,
-0.7316821218,
0.0100638485,
-0.1123495176,
0.4066352844,
-0.2556329966,
-0.3139034808,
0.503537178,
-0.1478061825,
-0.0559394136,
-0.3097029924,
0.7465125918,
-0.5640383959,
-0.7720030546,
0.7953708768,
0.9218014479,
0.3777496219,
0.1997575909,
-0.6904007792,
-0.6386474371,
-0.0831408128,
0.0517343283,
0.5166425705,
0.4110627472,
-0.5201354623,
0.6110822558,
0.876557827,
0.7083670497,
0.0776697695,
0.1509951651,
0.4392802715,
-0.3664300144,
-0.1681033224,
-0.6425626874,
0.1241593584,
0.2066881657,
-0.4658232331,
0.5387462378,
0.4415474832,
0.9756766558,
-0.1488441825,
0.7494900823,
-0.1528528929,
0.4231584668,
-0.4904978573,
0.6059257984,
-0.8064095974,
-0.2350542247,
-0.1847863048,
-0.6136581898,
-0.6496483684,
0.5359989405,
-0.4256568849,
-0.0576720648,
1.1327815056,
0.8637065291,
-0.2722651362,
-0.0305873975,
0.3533282578,
-0.0069487742,
-0.0260437056,
0.9554595947,
0.4811367095,
-0.5776124597,
0.3945362568,
-0.4720155895,
-0.0517872274,
-0.0399435423,
-0.7141330838,
-0.9791372418,
-0.2542701662,
-0.4497903883,
-0.4631286263,
0.3048745096,
0.8709046245,
0.7153016925,
-1.0486783981,
-0.1355081648,
0.0729665831,
-0.0797172487,
-0.5193973184,
-0.1284736991,
0.4815683067,
-0.1683586389,
-0.7231544852,
0.4813271463,
0.0956920236,
0.2342096567,
0.1742721647,
-0.0946978405,
-0.2368106395,
-0.2355569899,
0.4392201006,
0.524685204,
-0.5228580832,
-0.0766632259,
0.4052759707,
-0.3669550717,
0.2378036231,
0.8167091608,
-0.5264440775,
0.6067928672,
0.6354594827,
0.7250373363,
0.6998484731,
-0.4332491457,
0.7090212703,
-0.1160927862,
0.1190913916,
0.3131830096,
0.3697853386,
0.4497386217,
-0.2649328113,
0.588029325,
0.2729614973,
-0.3512898684,
-0.7985469103,
0.0722642913,
-0.8324566483,
-0.1010881811,
1.1174740791,
-0.1615703106,
-0.1077740714,
-0.3597867787,
-0.0524163842,
0.1608926654,
-0.0655573234,
0.198212564,
0.7669794559,
-0.2597184777,
-0.2532818317,
-1.2414678335,
0.4880609214,
0.538397193,
-0.6340311766,
-0.4689410925,
0.1668612361,
0.4445492625,
0.1920517981,
0.8544267416,
-0.553463459,
0.5273715258,
-0.1959857494,
0.2966557741,
0.1903324127,
-0.3564093113,
-0.3013446629,
0.0302321799,
-0.2463177443,
0.1025383547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04374v1 | Label Aware Speech Representation Learning For Language Identification | 2023-06-07T12:14:16 | 2023-06-07T12:14:16 | Shikhar Vashishth, Shikhar Bharadwaj, Sriram Ganapathy, Ankur Bapna, Min Ma, Wei Han, Vera Axelrod, Partha Talukdar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech representation learning approaches for non-semantic tasks such as
language recognition have either explored supervised embedding extraction
methods using a classifier model or self-supervised representation learning
approaches using raw data. In this paper, we propose a novel framework of
combining self-supervised representation learning with the language label
information for the pre-training task. This framework, termed as Label Aware
Speech Representation (LASR) learning, uses a triplet based objective function
to incorporate language labels along with the self-supervised loss function.
The speech representations are further fine-tuned for the downstream task. The
language recognition experiments are performed on two public datasets - FLEURS
and Dhwani. In these experiments, we illustrate that the proposed LASR
framework improves over the state-of-the-art systems on language
identification. We also report an analysis of the robustness of LASR approach
to noisy/missing labels as well as its application to multi-lingual speech
recognition tasks. | [
-0.3315214813,
-0.3930772543,
0.107915096,
0.2583882511,
0.0125327185,
0.1668061167,
-0.0516341999,
-0.5240551233,
0.2851907611,
0.5271795988,
-0.1201656535,
-0.2911660373,
-0.5309252739,
0.0703090355,
-0.2299926132,
0.9598678946,
0.0246887151,
0.1101687774,
0.04837358,
-0.2282444984,
-0.4698356688,
-0.8439408541,
-0.6336684227,
-0.3830633163,
0.6801982522,
0.0741645545,
0.2008407265,
0.7722786665,
0.2106846422,
0.2551484406,
0.3543232977,
-0.0724786296,
-0.2930498123,
-0.0434149019,
0.0837981999,
0.0013864798,
-0.1003594771,
-0.0928794444,
0.9779602289,
0.7542993426,
-0.1715260446,
0.1514752507,
0.1591795683,
0.4456461668,
-0.7597549558,
0.4525414109,
-0.4397311509,
0.2378016859,
-0.4059574604,
-0.1585166752,
-0.4075087309,
-0.1677601635,
0.0176579133,
-0.485112071,
0.1112633422,
-0.0925973579,
0.5454063416,
0.3795132637,
-0.38435179,
-0.4125418961,
-0.8910925388,
0.713611722,
-0.4782189429,
1.0237845182,
0.5183852911,
0.3550779223,
0.2556344271,
-0.3724551499,
-0.3049023747,
-0.0009582248,
-0.2515420318,
0.1281533092,
-0.03201003,
-0.0720079094,
0.0684209615,
0.2680238485,
-0.5806812048,
0.210941121,
-0.4131142497,
-0.6570250392,
0.4703751802,
-0.4066870809,
0.1971559972,
-0.0104794949,
-0.5931940079,
-0.1376912594,
-0.4194943607,
0.0753179714,
0.2671989501,
0.8303669095,
-0.1317162663,
0.2134205252,
-0.0151836751,
1.0207227468,
-0.0102981348,
-0.3766587079,
0.5537465811,
0.0401033498,
-0.2238857895,
0.6900857091,
0.8448909521,
-0.2430230081,
0.1333362162,
-0.1722563207,
-0.3872335553,
-0.28774634,
-0.1323182583,
-0.4992402792,
-0.2838965654,
-0.123442091,
-0.1146724299,
-0.0012799343,
0.1521876454,
-0.4259610474,
-0.294444561,
-0.2751365006,
0.6031844616,
-0.2453771532,
-0.5151987076,
0.0080607682,
0.3314645588,
0.348870039,
-0.0722990185,
-1.1014853716,
0.3358125687,
0.334271878,
0.5021029115,
-0.18172656,
-0.136496678,
-0.8181589842,
0.6332541108,
-0.340528667,
0.4982024729,
-0.4019733965,
-0.2444533408,
-0.1653341651,
-0.1567811072,
-0.2266434878,
-0.4774708748,
0.2513259947,
-0.7013497353,
0.0649660677,
0.0024027049,
-0.5667390823,
-0.2018199563,
-0.1112776399,
-0.9363498092,
0.9786630869,
-0.0233964678,
-0.7566505075,
0.2995999157,
-0.5424776673,
-0.4019826055,
0.2544768155,
-0.3029277325,
-0.6126382351,
-0.2802038193,
0.2873111367,
0.6880682707,
0.1820432544,
0.259049207,
-0.1504570544,
-0.1493645012,
0.2093296945,
-0.4372183084,
0.601076901,
0.3031146526,
-0.0833282843,
0.1103627533,
-0.9537909627,
0.0354933888,
-0.051505506,
-0.2966522872,
-0.3861896098,
-0.204139784,
0.0659238398,
0.0639384389,
0.3728513718,
-0.6252023578,
-0.1769322008,
-0.4242187738,
0.1569359004,
0.5944465399,
-0.1051836088,
0.3369012177,
0.1181039885,
0.3946265876,
-0.0446385629,
-0.26248914,
0.0344003662,
-0.1945991367,
-0.7703837752,
-0.6051430106,
0.732268095,
0.6888489127,
-0.5641988516,
0.2394763976,
-0.2213143408,
-0.2491944432,
-0.6094092131,
0.3886603117,
0.6629037261,
0.4589349926,
0.4922942221,
0.0670065656,
-0.8875015378,
-0.8817362189,
-0.1352561265,
-0.0740102679,
0.0643209815,
0.0315059833,
0.2570051253,
-0.3274004757,
1.2151407003,
-0.2179955095,
-0.7246459723,
-0.1817808896,
0.2913014889,
0.0398830622,
0.4532527328,
0.195153594,
-1.0355433226,
-0.5054618716,
0.1832085848,
-0.5997676849,
-0.1742192507,
0.0234596785,
0.5491161346,
0.3124670088,
0.7460277677,
0.1793925166,
0.1675983667,
0.5740656257,
0.2141872644,
0.2020047158,
-0.2445534319,
-0.2401707023,
-0.7912061214,
-0.0544406436,
0.00852466,
-0.33438012,
-0.877200067,
-0.5146579742,
0.1382141262,
-0.2898465395,
-0.5374703407,
0.6048641205,
-0.4847919345,
-0.2449528128,
-0.2145421952,
-0.072790727,
-0.1879893094,
0.5112842917,
0.346060276,
0.8282220364,
0.7783885002,
-0.652459681,
0.1837326884,
-0.1231026128,
-0.0495371036,
0.1590481997,
-0.5151625276,
0.2844239473,
-0.3012714088,
-0.0045334874,
-0.8820474744,
-0.3311252594,
0.3928221762,
-0.2929466367,
0.5157404542,
-0.0938249379,
-0.2306426615,
-0.2009896785,
0.2501696646,
0.4219071567,
0.1699177027,
-0.635672152,
0.6715168953,
0.6556842327,
-0.0155528896,
-0.6292372346,
-0.6598289609,
-0.2843599021,
-0.3339260519,
0.0266094226,
0.3569487631,
0.2601909041,
0.1343827695,
-0.1290005147,
-0.2783020735,
-0.3328044116,
-0.1317687631,
0.1599084884,
-0.1880767494,
-0.1111690849,
0.4633171856,
-0.2813722491,
-0.4786773026,
-0.0774946809,
-0.2465232909,
0.3739351928,
-0.5200567842,
-0.5052970648,
-0.5918332338,
0.4740456641,
0.1314330101,
-0.6808336973,
0.4207360148,
1.0014812946,
-0.4955908954,
0.0969108045,
-0.6351116896,
0.0410149805,
-0.4516531229,
0.317009598,
-0.7150931358,
-1.0133558512,
0.2658140957,
0.0858005434,
-0.3190639913,
0.3407752216,
0.3605433106,
-0.1711302698,
0.8323913217,
0.6534872055,
-0.3772448003,
0.4434306324,
-0.0649482682,
0.4013951123,
-0.6750329733,
-0.3119730949,
-0.4665324688,
0.2923745513,
-0.4166973233,
-0.3958750367,
0.2054658681,
0.360209018,
-0.0797621906,
0.329877764,
-0.4943675399,
0.4042598307,
0.5429390073,
-0.0894303247,
0.1150476113,
0.0617840178,
-0.1669309437,
-0.1235985383,
-0.6471082568,
-0.4252745509,
0.648047328,
0.3188198209,
0.6119298935,
0.0541157648,
1.2096576691,
0.3735667765,
0.309032321,
-0.6616734862,
0.3674623072,
-0.0759928897,
-0.5181851387,
-0.4453697801,
-0.5700598359,
-0.9717009068,
0.2884556949,
-0.1530448049,
-0.7338437438,
0.1705221385,
0.2079001814,
-0.3485114276,
0.2404239029,
-0.7879639268,
0.7198715806,
-0.4097971916,
-0.0183035359,
0.2707237601,
-0.6340166926,
0.0010563341,
-0.4784330428,
0.6058167219,
-0.1376334131,
0.2196463197,
1.234870553,
0.060893748,
1.0600273609,
-0.4372825027,
-0.2702124715,
0.2961216867,
-0.2492695451,
0.1636284888,
-0.1665097624,
-0.1664092392,
0.1899216771,
0.1120017022,
-0.2825062275,
-0.649961412,
0.5357934237,
-0.6825681925,
-0.4923717976,
-0.5071315169,
-0.406858325,
-0.3443378508,
0.3713639677,
-0.0979812071,
0.6594722867,
-0.0975939184,
0.1756644249,
0.6806384325,
0.0018557704,
0.530595839,
0.3769165874,
-0.4373447001,
-0.6289160252,
1.4421862364,
0.1485928744,
0.199349016,
0.698314786,
0.4064455926,
-0.6140321493,
-0.3920170367,
-0.2593516409,
0.224207595,
-0.754912138,
-0.0329392701,
-0.5486503839,
-0.3192421198,
-0.5577066541,
0.188412264,
-0.3437322676,
-0.2288054228,
-0.518996954,
-0.0632766932,
0.1735059023,
0.8418790102,
-0.5274226069,
0.3692211211,
-0.5540264249,
0.481382519,
0.6313356161,
0.4167475998,
-0.244749397,
-0.1869437993,
-0.3387438059,
0.0860630646,
0.004878853,
-0.9098729491,
0.2445643991,
0.4693165421,
0.8638373017,
0.4807070196,
0.0180932637,
0.678899169,
-0.4234001935,
0.2660655975,
0.3316304386,
-1.0085222721,
0.6056832075,
-0.1692501009,
0.1260318458,
0.3454096019,
0.5882371664,
-0.2699787617,
-0.0668927729,
-0.2325289249,
-0.5764273405,
0.6018725634,
-0.0077435137,
-0.0000240497,
0.0965108424,
0.147001043,
0.0998706147,
-0.0375104994,
-1.2168624401,
-0.4165987372,
-0.4883172214,
-0.2690534592,
-0.2599605322,
-0.1844381392,
0.1305545866,
-0.1894224584,
0.5915139318,
-0.2084294707,
0.0974010974,
0.209958002,
-0.25518471,
0.3217206597,
0.5419320464,
0.3055659235,
0.2432677597,
-0.2960735857,
0.2873625457,
0.1125203222,
-0.1322046518,
0.360984683,
0.3404187858,
0.0526077859,
-0.0022429039,
0.4415513873,
0.970859766,
0.3674247563,
-0.3966497779,
0.4086805582,
0.127618745,
-0.213928178,
-0.2272675931,
-0.0785465986,
0.0629066005,
0.015175662,
0.504878819,
-0.0591643862,
0.2852393091,
-0.2627393901,
0.4595706761,
0.4354197681,
-0.9918869734,
-0.0236960817,
0.555456996,
0.0045173969,
-0.4507679045,
0.1512269378,
-0.3297818303,
-0.6237438917,
0.1934719384,
0.8116863966,
0.587860465,
-0.7666211128,
0.3184021115,
0.2778232992,
0.0957292244,
0.2075465769,
0.0494087301,
-0.5105189681,
-0.7844585776,
-0.3926981986,
-0.7399475574,
-0.3334560394,
0.0091354037,
-0.8146116734,
0.1061143726,
-0.1834742427,
0.0154511761,
-0.0103409262,
-0.2650520504,
-0.4356047213,
0.3409603536,
0.6088289618,
0.1204903126,
-0.9397694468,
1.2180322409,
0.5040786266,
-0.1997947097,
-0.9206658006,
-0.1989904642,
-0.1416046023,
-0.6073368788,
1.0646213293,
0.4546381831,
-0.7210437059,
0.3510378301,
0.0333014727,
-1.1788489819,
0.6593663096,
0.4281658232,
-0.4790076017,
0.3699824214,
0.3684669435,
0.3507677019,
-0.4403565526,
-0.1193069965,
0.3463307619,
0.3366329372,
0.2243352383,
-0.9177315235,
-0.2105279565,
-0.0481233224,
0.0858731419,
0.1730024666,
-0.2246516943,
0.4825769365,
-0.1672353148,
-0.3825840056,
-0.3038344383,
1.0052565336,
0.3187050521,
0.2285007089,
0.7510733008,
0.2510793209,
0.9825777411,
-0.1244245321,
0.6942380667,
-0.0292244442,
0.3699307442,
1.2897747755,
-0.3417932689,
0.8680282235,
0.4648247063,
-0.1344812512,
0.3368993402,
0.4114201069,
0.1233866438,
0.8611804247,
0.3694807291,
-0.3011196554,
-0.1939566284,
-0.1944064498,
-0.4924614131,
0.6116977334,
0.5518095493,
-0.0463058762,
-0.2887690961,
0.5973889828,
-0.2318220139,
-0.104065001,
-0.2774934471,
0.8964296579,
0.0092723342,
-0.0788505599,
0.8698384762,
-0.2481416762,
0.564106822,
-0.6659293175,
-0.0776490942,
0.421746403,
0.0959338695,
-0.3066261411,
-0.4654967189,
0.3445160687,
-0.4795855582,
-0.1138051301,
-0.6038477421,
0.8273746371,
-0.7701928616,
-0.6149015427,
0.5358821154,
0.3140400946,
0.1872957796,
0.1117047146,
-0.6105524302,
0.2661597431,
0.1045168489,
0.140813455,
0.0371695757,
0.148348242,
0.0238530673,
0.7421725392,
0.4398171604,
-0.035303887,
0.2327261269,
0.327832073,
0.4112782478,
-0.5567891002,
-0.4723326862,
-0.702286005,
0.0738228559,
0.1190192476,
0.0770167112,
0.7375767827,
0.6123530865,
0.8605479002,
-0.0934514776,
0.7278530598,
0.1098622158,
0.8307834864,
-0.6092091203,
0.5609766245,
-0.5014513135,
0.1624568701,
-0.3499030173,
-0.7366313934,
-0.7539131641,
0.7794165611,
-0.4334925115,
0.0898358598,
0.3125473857,
0.8953222036,
-0.0848842338,
0.0641329214,
0.4394437373,
-0.05015672,
0.2762466967,
0.2809920907,
0.7464374304,
-0.351665318,
0.4640758932,
-0.3990326822,
-0.1256024837,
-0.1353622526,
-0.7919147015,
-0.8033361435,
-0.9830140471,
-0.4659480155,
0.1461703479,
0.0146834217,
0.7916044593,
1.0119729042,
-0.96466434,
-0.358425796,
0.1114200875,
0.0896840245,
-0.2147736698,
-0.2226423025,
0.6696957946,
-0.3744800389,
-0.5034301877,
0.7074018717,
0.210293591,
0.2888638675,
-0.257886827,
-0.2070151716,
-0.2583658695,
-0.4798568487,
0.4557884037,
0.6095619202,
-0.7488942742,
-0.2405606955,
-0.3784926236,
0.1441695839,
0.1670753658,
0.6368406415,
-1.0193554163,
0.6540178657,
0.1190126762,
0.7745183706,
0.654683888,
-0.2469123453,
0.4538193047,
-0.8721442223,
0.1467356682,
0.2279334366,
0.2533879876,
0.7124890685,
-0.1229039729,
0.1976959407,
-0.1187935993,
-0.2531174421,
-0.7166220546,
0.27398628,
-1.0510133505,
0.1466619372,
0.7918341756,
-0.0241381805,
-0.0280592497,
-0.4084180892,
-0.1220728084,
0.4007060528,
-0.3072085381,
0.2563305795,
0.4861513674,
-0.3167766631,
-0.4199991822,
-0.4502923489,
0.3606617749,
0.231652841,
-0.515553236,
-0.0004235817,
0.1398910731,
0.2143481374,
0.4076500535,
0.7976868153,
-0.0584579855,
-0.2053237557,
-0.4421186447,
0.1535474211,
-0.0950543433,
-0.440431267,
-0.3889236152,
0.2595932782,
-0.0322695337,
-0.3887480199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04368v1 | Arabic Dysarthric Speech Recognition Using Adversarial and Signal-Based Augmentation | 2023-06-07T12:01:46 | 2023-06-07T12:01:46 | Massa Baali, Ibrahim Almakky, Shady Shehata, Fakhri Karray | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Despite major advancements in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), the
state-of-the-art ASR systems struggle to deal with impaired speech even with
high-resource languages. In Arabic, this challenge gets amplified, with added
complexities in collecting data from dysarthric speakers. In this paper, we aim
to improve the performance of Arabic dysarthric automatic speech recognition
through a multi-stage augmentation approach. To this effect, we first propose a
signal-based approach to generate dysarthric Arabic speech from healthy Arabic
speech by modifying its speed and tempo. We also propose a second stage
Parallel Wave Generative (PWG) adversarial model that is trained on an English
dysarthric dataset to capture language-independant dysarthric speech patterns
and further augment the signal-adjusted speech samples. Furthermore, we propose
a fine-tuning and text-correction strategies for Arabic Conformer at different
dysarthric speech severity levels. Our fine-tuned Conformer achieved 18% Word
Error Rate (WER) and 17.2% Character Error Rate (CER) on synthetically
generated dysarthric speech from the Arabic commonvoice speech dataset. This
shows significant WER improvement of 81.8% compared to the baseline model
trained solely on healthy data. We perform further validation on real English
dysarthric speech showing a WER improvement of 124% compared to the baseline
trained only on healthy English LJSpeech dataset. | [
-0.3635836542,
-0.7287852764,
0.0614571981,
-0.0647163019,
-0.2047360539,
0.5534551144,
-0.0120832594,
-0.5779058933,
0.1604750454,
0.0967913419,
-0.451041609,
-0.5542715788,
-1.0012742281,
0.1990240663,
-0.2010056973,
0.7179464102,
-0.0632997453,
0.3573031723,
0.4623771012,
-0.474526763,
-0.5065163374,
-0.2841741145,
-0.6681245565,
-0.492818445,
0.3004755974,
0.2805244029,
1.193960309,
0.6510514617,
0.1035607979,
0.3750250936,
-0.3939988613,
0.3215267062,
-0.1926468611,
0.3641269207,
0.2521829605,
0.0563058481,
-0.4869549274,
-0.3343057334,
0.6402406096,
0.7626215816,
-0.2226729393,
-0.0621217899,
0.0099632069,
0.7793045044,
-0.3092032969,
0.1541712284,
-0.4369158149,
-0.1329002082,
-0.3527257144,
0.0334413163,
0.1608364284,
-0.3434631526,
-0.3332039118,
-0.4446499646,
0.0791568905,
-0.1679597944,
0.2494905293,
0.4781211317,
-0.2676214576,
-0.4545714259,
-0.7470425963,
0.2853780389,
-0.6427045465,
0.6767955422,
0.5799114108,
0.4642955363,
-0.4576176703,
-0.748075068,
-0.6999275088,
-0.5229855776,
0.1551150382,
-0.0486296937,
-0.3515098691,
0.168495357,
0.3751790226,
0.5111413002,
-0.6943891644,
0.090963766,
-0.5057016015,
-0.6067879796,
0.8140633702,
-0.0394798853,
0.5983723402,
0.2886277735,
0.1837156564,
-0.3242669106,
-0.6933746338,
0.1403072774,
0.5342949629,
0.4857045114,
0.0306355115,
0.478756994,
-0.2380856276,
0.7906070948,
0.4516828358,
-0.5417890549,
0.5215235949,
0.104630284,
0.3223544359,
0.7759654522,
0.3704348803,
-0.1673453599,
-0.0000873525,
-0.3127936125,
-0.2963782251,
0.2933343053,
0.1636115909,
-0.7823829651,
-0.4784403145,
0.4109718204,
-0.2088132352,
0.0367823504,
-0.1997842789,
-0.3091930449,
-0.6106527448,
-0.4505339861,
0.5195867419,
-0.6978721619,
-0.3490078449,
0.1670313925,
-0.0576561689,
-0.2081685215,
0.1390785277,
-0.5845549703,
0.1539527476,
0.2772181034,
0.6693312526,
0.1781302392,
-0.1934799254,
-0.8189778924,
0.2841887772,
-0.1901781857,
0.4979002178,
-0.4637642801,
-0.4843277037,
-0.1149330735,
-0.228738755,
-0.1173213124,
-0.6583618522,
0.9024222493,
-0.5951479673,
-0.2853108644,
0.0532661527,
-0.2725272477,
-0.3598556221,
-0.1593421251,
-0.9032562971,
0.7908295393,
-0.1475734264,
-0.725371778,
0.3884302974,
-0.6180068254,
-0.8623856902,
0.1659350842,
-0.1418304443,
-0.5668029785,
0.0023626436,
0.7359092832,
-0.1057403907,
0.053376846,
0.0649226308,
-0.0921200067,
-0.5709560513,
0.2724929452,
-0.8402016163,
0.611610949,
0.4234112203,
-0.4632753432,
0.1256163865,
-1.1975888014,
0.1061480939,
-0.1664000452,
-0.3810149729,
-0.0718350708,
0.0214291159,
0.2981308699,
0.352493763,
0.0119604627,
-0.757861495,
-0.0229788292,
-0.8950853944,
0.3275518119,
0.2659758925,
-0.1482474208,
-0.0558052287,
-0.5806482434,
0.3480463326,
0.2938498855,
-0.1620770991,
0.1949587613,
-0.3548476398,
-0.4563535452,
-0.7623824477,
0.299569428,
0.4249509573,
-0.919439733,
0.5385238528,
-0.3480373621,
-0.483076483,
-0.9534214735,
-0.0881401822,
0.3430433273,
0.4673165977,
0.5956193209,
-0.2489651442,
-0.6450107694,
-0.4677927196,
-0.3719415069,
-0.1536991298,
-0.0426339172,
0.0557049997,
0.0729327202,
-0.1934163123,
0.5087794065,
-0.1483923346,
-0.4550692141,
-0.2395847887,
0.3320982158,
0.3880938888,
0.3650118113,
0.0932366177,
-0.7289890647,
-0.4710642695,
0.1307177544,
-0.2692910135,
-0.1278048307,
0.223267436,
0.5881616473,
0.2130840272,
0.3411203325,
-0.3874378502,
0.7422813177,
0.4958849549,
-0.1509580016,
0.2431566417,
-0.4089512229,
0.3315188587,
-0.9379764199,
-0.002733689,
-0.3768353164,
-0.1478369534,
-0.8225985169,
-0.1387845874,
-0.1304366887,
-0.4378945827,
-0.2294164002,
0.2137454003,
-0.5004485846,
0.1395777613,
-0.7450580001,
-0.018864641,
-0.148518458,
0.0902673453,
-0.2737673819,
1.083183527,
0.9474018812,
-0.4732204676,
0.4607060552,
0.4670099914,
-0.0885716602,
0.3591496944,
-0.7021714449,
0.394505471,
-0.3780988753,
0.36951226,
-1.201830864,
-0.05353662,
0.3030285239,
-0.6020736694,
0.7484418154,
0.1171523482,
-0.3516477942,
-0.6701824069,
-0.278614223,
0.4856505692,
0.372238934,
-0.7864644527,
0.6461926699,
0.4458537102,
-0.4955020845,
-0.5116922855,
-0.389590323,
0.1707520634,
-0.0985771343,
-0.8356813788,
0.6378980875,
0.1212427095,
-0.0384909175,
-0.2511746883,
-0.4564643204,
0.0011505674,
-0.1634189188,
0.5052291155,
-0.2214066684,
-0.0286298245,
0.0609418936,
0.2300317585,
-0.1755843759,
-0.20634076,
-0.3524771333,
0.5487997532,
0.1429008543,
-0.695945859,
-0.929551065,
0.369499743,
0.8647099137,
-0.3335764706,
0.4161367714,
0.8575869799,
-0.5328790545,
0.2700839639,
-0.636300385,
-0.22206074,
-0.457339853,
0.435177058,
-0.8257836103,
-0.550119698,
0.3696004748,
-0.1073890999,
-0.3699871898,
0.3243252039,
0.5053014755,
0.2480977774,
1.4425157309,
0.1195410416,
-0.6162747145,
0.1037657261,
0.0182573423,
0.2707304358,
-0.7533854842,
-0.0103530968,
-0.5680016875,
-0.2481816262,
-0.6128445268,
-0.2105855048,
0.6648494601,
0.0616157316,
-0.1754656136,
0.0360035226,
-0.3794208765,
0.0087187467,
0.4167060256,
0.597897768,
0.2853797376,
0.386153847,
-0.2486344576,
-0.0178039335,
-0.6618917584,
-0.3503610492,
0.8893663883,
0.3290270865,
0.7658065557,
0.2955538332,
0.5013215542,
0.5205014348,
0.0912981033,
-0.6278235912,
0.0966677442,
-0.3456080556,
-0.2882553041,
-0.3660894334,
-0.2054214031,
-0.786000073,
0.066207394,
-0.0539903603,
-0.4565400481,
0.21994178,
0.2058696747,
-0.4396151304,
0.0829200447,
-0.2831396759,
0.2515232563,
-0.0616836995,
-0.3678684235,
-0.515088737,
-0.6883828044,
0.0020604262,
-0.014405448,
0.1955230683,
0.0279848631,
0.3560378253,
0.6318324208,
-0.5991793275,
0.6094583869,
-0.5687406659,
-0.0848241225,
0.2592468858,
-0.2044178247,
0.731964469,
-0.0902896076,
-0.3170435131,
0.3199915886,
-0.0661141425,
-0.1792250127,
-0.3566105068,
0.5879598856,
-0.9321652651,
-0.6727172732,
-0.6439245343,
-0.8364599347,
-0.5443018675,
-0.2218322009,
-0.102021955,
0.8263733387,
-0.2075102031,
-0.1060532182,
0.1231257692,
-0.1226990968,
0.309679836,
0.6733008027,
0.1432651281,
-0.8634493947,
0.9848909974,
0.1511646509,
-0.065652445,
0.0283784289,
0.0579108857,
-0.7859760523,
-0.9718334675,
-0.8406698704,
0.1000053063,
-0.4878145754,
-0.260974586,
-0.494345665,
-0.4032906294,
-0.6373529434,
0.3732870817,
0.1390279233,
-0.4444180429,
-0.0841225758,
-0.0129262656,
0.6583982706,
0.5801295042,
-0.3923395574,
0.2979986668,
-0.8259398937,
0.8053756952,
0.1669441462,
0.0380113535,
-0.0996506661,
-0.8945647478,
-0.1302980036,
0.4761949778,
-0.4788821042,
-0.8806974292,
0.5470676422,
0.5370897651,
0.4648025632,
0.1485726684,
0.1346908808,
1.0328953266,
-0.6504526138,
0.3732186258,
0.1870085895,
-0.8117827773,
0.482693553,
-0.018816106,
0.4574248195,
0.4852282405,
0.2695962191,
-0.4549413621,
-0.6212730408,
-0.228273645,
-0.8906838298,
0.7825895548,
0.204537943,
-0.1002720445,
0.1913918108,
0.3856498599,
0.0130021144,
-0.0251061786,
-0.067850247,
-0.453525126,
-0.4371752441,
-0.5328341126,
-0.0218218509,
-0.1239213571,
-0.3189269602,
-0.4346910715,
0.8470646143,
-0.0835726559,
-0.3259598613,
0.2654065192,
-0.3539964259,
-0.2943803966,
0.2793886065,
0.4803524315,
0.6353150606,
0.0072336029,
-0.0335510112,
0.246266678,
-1.0561144352,
0.524757266,
1.146607995,
-0.1810446829,
0.0522494465,
0.0806412771,
0.9467027783,
-0.4026308358,
-0.5339918733,
0.3988812566,
-0.0149972998,
-0.0255770963,
-0.219916597,
-0.1748709828,
-0.0990111381,
0.4623580575,
0.6411474347,
0.1834688783,
0.3777861893,
-0.2259572446,
0.51930058,
0.5336077213,
-0.3742920756,
-0.1838034838,
0.7800004482,
0.1216963902,
-0.4150549173,
0.4375908673,
-0.1562189907,
-0.5576001406,
0.3400822878,
0.7662596703,
0.5993717313,
-0.8420391679,
-0.0346776731,
0.1771797985,
0.0325216167,
0.2753403187,
0.4937277436,
-0.1498979032,
-0.5398282409,
-0.4431309104,
-0.6907032132,
-0.1511990875,
0.1397174895,
-0.46618855,
0.059757892,
-0.0637097582,
-0.0968145207,
0.0608692579,
0.1637684852,
-0.1967708915,
0.5181680918,
0.17611292,
0.5626093745,
-0.567168355,
1.0556827784,
0.7024157643,
-0.4529685676,
-0.8234131336,
0.4509449899,
0.1252052486,
-1.0326920748,
0.731516242,
0.2502740622,
-0.6203432679,
0.2539020479,
0.273232758,
-0.8038625121,
1.037805438,
0.2619669735,
-0.822407186,
0.5796203017,
0.4451625049,
0.4878884554,
0.0738403499,
0.0865180492,
0.5171689391,
0.461265415,
0.4630901515,
-1.0118547678,
0.0916898102,
-0.1486513317,
0.0476196446,
0.1448094994,
-0.1424186379,
0.4209154546,
-0.2758889794,
-0.3435350358,
0.208360061,
0.8073129654,
0.4323512018,
0.3640975654,
0.6694738269,
0.6587260962,
0.9165068865,
0.123028554,
0.6545028687,
-0.8982085586,
-0.2815516293,
0.7225143909,
-0.398175776,
0.4990667701,
0.2962972224,
-0.2865618765,
0.2320120931,
0.2749599814,
0.5204200745,
0.6036544442,
0.4576488733,
-0.9766597152,
0.1655519456,
-0.1742990315,
-0.7476328015,
0.7648302913,
0.4234636724,
-0.010807558,
-0.1854717582,
0.3137537837,
0.0237182174,
0.3343970478,
-0.466495961,
0.8851222992,
-0.1666803956,
-0.2831025124,
0.9463502765,
0.0904173777,
0.4935998917,
-0.5991650224,
-0.1340428889,
0.0461904183,
0.5199715495,
-0.1834230572,
-0.27104491,
0.5636180043,
-0.1433131993,
-0.1564405859,
-0.0220635366,
0.8679308891,
-0.5963457823,
-0.7162743807,
0.1199658439,
0.3555786312,
0.0497840382,
-0.3945638537,
-0.4582360983,
0.3943979144,
-0.1833809912,
0.2277721614,
0.1715090871,
0.1987825036,
0.0681226179,
0.3705170751,
0.7647104263,
0.4159690142,
-0.1367587447,
0.4477028549,
1.0811140537,
-0.3650657833,
-0.3410719335,
-0.6143422127,
0.3388900161,
0.0653826594,
0.0044905655,
0.5425275564,
0.4540014863,
0.4002368748,
0.1451454908,
0.7733299136,
-0.0044585732,
0.8794694543,
-0.333863169,
1.0428899527,
-0.3010109663,
0.121860005,
0.0189388823,
-0.4489860237,
-0.40657112,
0.7009330988,
-0.2298490256,
0.1273676157,
0.4019595385,
1.2509332895,
0.061753165,
0.2570101321,
0.4630717933,
0.4363315105,
0.236125499,
0.387260139,
0.7828167677,
-0.5431776643,
0.5915929079,
-0.1449123621,
-0.3462190032,
-0.0168308858,
-0.2863232791,
-0.4740687907,
-0.4588670433,
-0.3082117736,
-0.4755019844,
0.7837008834,
0.958330214,
0.5563143492,
-1.0232714415,
-0.1051620767,
-0.1799803227,
-0.146073252,
-0.5517684817,
-0.1002773494,
0.5955953598,
-0.3024921715,
-0.6035867929,
0.9115331769,
0.2641572952,
0.0014121797,
0.0368595198,
-0.1838661879,
0.0386676341,
-0.2539367676,
0.3808220029,
0.3230350912,
-0.7265213728,
-0.4799205065,
-0.2961525619,
0.0690596923,
0.1012958735,
0.6283680797,
-1.009221673,
0.4958856404,
0.1541743129,
0.7062984705,
0.4556291997,
0.0641937852,
0.404604733,
-0.5839222074,
0.3608880639,
0.3490540981,
0.2585955262,
0.5855249763,
-0.2369440943,
-0.1519643664,
0.1599407047,
-0.406773448,
-0.5301212668,
0.4249913692,
-0.6622474194,
0.0208421573,
0.7921181321,
-0.0295085274,
0.2034042031,
-0.6879307032,
-0.700155139,
0.6451780796,
-0.4040169716,
1.0506652594,
0.4311439991,
-0.283521086,
0.1504282206,
-0.0351074934,
0.5622865558,
0.1937377304,
-0.3866011798,
-0.0259158649,
0.7035289407,
0.1626114547,
0.1041120514,
0.4552703202,
-0.1971797496,
0.3867860138,
0.1744267493,
-0.1427698284,
-0.4653805494,
-0.260043323,
-0.6707875729,
0.2846964598,
0.406334877,
-0.570846498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04362v1 | Youku-mPLUG: A 10 Million Large-scale Chinese Video-Language Dataset for Pre-training and Benchmarks | 2023-06-07T11:52:36 | 2023-06-07T11:52:36 | Haiyang Xu, Qinghao Ye, Xuan Wu, Ming Yan, Yuan Miao, Jiabo Ye, Guohai Xu, Anwen Hu, Yaya Shi, Guangwei Xu, Chenliang Li, Qi Qian, Maofei Que, Ji Zhang, Xiao Zeng, Fei Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | To promote the development of Vision-Language Pre-training (VLP) and
multimodal Large Language Model (LLM) in the Chinese community, we firstly
release the largest public Chinese high-quality video-language dataset named
Youku-mPLUG, which is collected from Youku, a well-known Chinese video-sharing
website, with strict criteria of safety, diversity, and quality. Youku-mPLUG
contains 10 million Chinese video-text pairs filtered from 400 million raw
videos across a wide range of 45 diverse categories for large-scale
pre-training. In addition, to facilitate a comprehensive evaluation of
video-language models, we carefully build the largest human-annotated Chinese
benchmarks covering three popular video-language tasks of cross-modal
retrieval, video captioning, and video category classification. Youku-mPLUG can
enable researchers to conduct more in-depth multimodal research and develop
better applications in the future. Furthermore, we release popular
video-language pre-training models, ALPRO and mPLUG-2, and our proposed
modularized decoder-only model mPLUG-video pre-trained on Youku-mPLUG.
Experiments show that models pre-trained on Youku-mPLUG gain up to 23.1%
improvement in video category classification. Besides, mPLUG-video achieves a
new state-of-the-art result on these benchmarks with 80.5% top-1 accuracy in
video category classification and 68.9 CIDEr score in video captioning,
respectively. Finally, we scale up mPLUG-video based on the frozen Bloomz with
only 1.7% trainable parameters as Chinese multimodal LLM, and demonstrate
impressive instruction and video understanding ability. The zero-shot
instruction understanding experiment indicates that pretraining with
Youku-mPLUG can enhance the ability to comprehend overall and detailed visual
semantics, recognize scene text, and leverage open-domain knowledge. | [
-0.4556208849,
-0.5482644439,
-0.103578344,
0.244465977,
-0.510825932,
-0.0996896476,
-0.5089620352,
-0.0752052367,
-0.096195668,
0.2151753157,
-0.4395520091,
-0.4235302806,
-0.7435243726,
-0.1885459423,
-0.3177014589,
0.8294696808,
0.2559989393,
0.4688432217,
0.0599623509,
0.0162607245,
-0.0769429877,
-0.6925166845,
-0.2644811869,
-0.3361268044,
0.5342404246,
0.2375643849,
0.5117890239,
0.7521203756,
0.4792004824,
0.2837786674,
0.1700367779,
-0.1464392692,
-0.4287829995,
-0.4235094786,
0.1742340475,
-0.3656668067,
-0.579067409,
0.1003389433,
0.7811193466,
0.4729402959,
-0.1379034668,
0.3554754853,
0.0749316141,
0.4510091841,
-0.9315874577,
0.1572057605,
-0.4658113718,
0.4358390272,
-0.537309587,
-0.1828044206,
-0.3988120854,
-0.0449376032,
-0.0268994942,
-0.5608676672,
0.1482785642,
-0.3161816597,
0.9745332003,
0.3428529799,
-0.3434574604,
0.4785929918,
-0.561173737,
0.7133892179,
-0.856215775,
0.574860096,
0.4037128091,
0.5489651561,
-0.0624535307,
-0.962554574,
-0.6963554025,
-0.1938888878,
-0.0403132215,
0.2517841458,
0.2546654642,
0.2316512913,
0.4790031314,
0.512250185,
-0.7772929072,
0.2418847084,
-0.4053218365,
-0.1946112812,
0.7585148215,
0.0873843506,
0.3356141448,
-0.2429112941,
-0.5785919428,
-0.3523899913,
-0.7483765483,
0.2584539056,
0.2350519001,
-0.0549330711,
-0.018374227,
0.5337250233,
-0.4877092242,
0.7431894541,
-0.2835575044,
-0.5337405801,
0.4097576737,
-0.4082146287,
-0.5507181883,
0.0180615988,
1.1659237146,
0.6429252028,
0.3195290864,
0.2483078241,
0.1193426922,
0.034265466,
0.0281738136,
-0.8682793975,
-0.4819623232,
-0.1162776574,
-0.5422848463,
0.0356123224,
0.0935528278,
-0.6562826633,
-0.2739309072,
-0.1111806929,
0.5820711255,
-0.2307462841,
-0.43193385,
0.1485085636,
0.0869045705,
0.4820511639,
0.5644082427,
-1.0438393354,
-0.0080130687,
0.4863982797,
0.4355075061,
-0.0344520323,
-0.8361549973,
-0.590793848,
0.1442127228,
-0.2577585876,
0.7032650113,
-0.2417856604,
0.1705031693,
0.0214595962,
0.183558166,
-0.1114844382,
-0.3437127769,
0.4686728418,
-0.2307070643,
0.1407218874,
-0.3781809211,
-0.3164248765,
-0.3689676821,
0.3958669007,
-0.5164453387,
0.9381462932,
-0.1953774989,
-0.5423440933,
0.6405821443,
-0.3768715262,
-0.2829534411,
0.4067723453,
-0.5276812315,
-0.2852025032,
-0.0822927877,
0.3170149922,
0.7694550753,
-0.4273320436,
0.3529299796,
-0.2315502167,
-0.2729171515,
0.1202114597,
-0.6896232963,
0.5644130111,
0.4236685932,
-0.183846131,
0.1503976882,
-0.7299181819,
0.1314774454,
0.1018800065,
-0.622435987,
0.1578725576,
0.0234985016,
0.2601289451,
0.3805873692,
0.307407856,
-0.3936226368,
0.1088962927,
0.1064818352,
0.4771069288,
0.7980442047,
-0.5472534895,
0.2500188351,
0.1077399924,
0.5621388555,
0.0850842521,
0.4023189843,
-0.7930781245,
-0.3607544005,
-0.5417964458,
0.0233147983,
0.1159621999,
0.3025979996,
-0.6129837632,
0.3696560562,
-0.12282186,
-0.4534075856,
-0.4655987322,
0.289239943,
0.4527601302,
0.4842366576,
0.185061872,
-0.3742889762,
-0.3442235589,
-0.777936995,
0.1460430026,
-0.1963052005,
-0.2138678879,
0.2225286365,
0.2073488235,
0.0261041299,
0.3884683251,
-0.5780487657,
-0.415659517,
-0.3875598311,
0.0971902236,
0.0972720981,
0.2975665927,
0.563683331,
-0.935816288,
-0.7852036953,
0.1487631947,
-0.8583709598,
0.325897634,
-0.0057778,
0.196121648,
0.0196287129,
0.5005577803,
-0.4103403986,
0.0610373132,
0.6871657968,
-0.1096108109,
0.6922820807,
-0.4602540731,
0.3380589187,
-1.0031391382,
-0.0341584906,
0.0040002582,
-0.2187282145,
-0.5812866688,
0.1542720646,
0.1270928383,
-0.3156868815,
-0.8635030389,
0.19327344,
-0.2908537984,
-0.259295553,
-0.140145883,
0.1794485152,
-0.2312611789,
0.9049981236,
0.1949032545,
0.6939430833,
0.9721108675,
-0.6553027034,
0.8085660338,
0.1578940004,
-0.6485316753,
0.2302679271,
-0.4392923415,
-0.0974840745,
-0.0588903651,
0.0674059689,
-1.0141119957,
-0.5664153099,
0.1795709878,
-0.4774262905,
0.1933384687,
-0.0771921873,
-0.5995439887,
-0.3777122796,
-0.3533915877,
0.3407702148,
0.5401471853,
-0.6463912725,
0.4795917273,
0.3296342194,
-0.012221287,
-0.9250320792,
-0.5063400269,
0.0944381654,
-0.1540483534,
-0.4548669457,
0.0496735424,
-0.259175837,
0.2845331728,
-0.0723759383,
0.0064955545,
-0.2572451234,
0.0478792563,
0.0543612614,
0.0411501154,
-0.3831206262,
0.1302014887,
-0.3416223526,
-0.168362841,
-0.0223054346,
0.0253363624,
0.7855266929,
-0.2181553692,
-0.2023974955,
-0.4076481164,
0.006910888,
0.4205168486,
-0.4919182062,
0.5600981116,
1.091580987,
-0.2560475171,
-0.0239841286,
-0.4987102151,
-0.0705818385,
-0.5125362873,
0.8446115255,
-0.360583812,
-0.7422694564,
0.1085208654,
-0.1403671354,
0.0558466129,
0.19647865,
0.6415957808,
-0.3323888779,
0.9954661131,
0.6077052951,
-0.3543891311,
0.613931179,
-0.168737635,
-0.1123830304,
-0.5539841056,
-0.349313885,
-0.1101495177,
-0.3263473213,
-0.3665006459,
-0.2676924467,
0.2873880565,
0.395956248,
-0.2165656537,
0.4722693563,
-0.3297849596,
0.6306976676,
0.4988894165,
0.0255870167,
0.2331049293,
0.1048938259,
0.2943806946,
-0.1847362518,
-0.8675069809,
-0.140826568,
1.1452333927,
0.3127543032,
0.9985694885,
0.0581896603,
0.2560171783,
0.3112132847,
-0.0773610994,
-0.669329524,
0.7193700075,
-0.5137062073,
-0.5230798125,
-0.3446313739,
-0.2359380275,
-0.7159090042,
0.2630706131,
-0.280071944,
-0.7112394571,
-0.4613633156,
0.3280512094,
-0.3987267613,
0.3809814453,
-0.6239622831,
1.1355178356,
-0.6170852184,
-0.2112573534,
-0.3391290009,
-0.6819156408,
0.5106995106,
0.0000195481,
-0.1276347786,
-0.0855861604,
0.190244168,
0.687995851,
-0.3505355716,
0.5302203298,
-0.1441742331,
-0.0915787742,
0.3442130983,
-0.4260599911,
0.1570005864,
-0.0586664975,
0.4615383148,
0.2383999527,
-0.0202138256,
-0.3825221062,
-0.5962865353,
0.4533337951,
-1.0020467043,
-0.6891910434,
-0.4181096256,
-0.3113262057,
0.2517889142,
0.2639763355,
0.491034627,
0.3807550967,
-0.023158906,
0.5822718143,
0.7541752458,
-0.6198890209,
0.579785645,
0.4872957766,
-0.4078405201,
-0.4274717867,
0.999486208,
0.0715290457,
0.3307930529,
0.4655221403,
0.1650880873,
-0.155978635,
-0.4172180295,
-0.4997441173,
0.079624325,
-0.782597661,
-0.0754313767,
-0.5892939568,
-0.5193029046,
-0.4569310546,
0.1874998361,
-0.6792716384,
-0.0574324243,
-0.0318435654,
-0.169527024,
0.1371967643,
0.3629122972,
-0.0980976149,
0.6287582517,
-0.8156812191,
0.4916288555,
0.4108703136,
0.4396607876,
-0.1409677416,
-0.5563712716,
-0.4633546472,
-0.1861684918,
-0.2173023075,
-0.5841183662,
0.3427096009,
0.3051520288,
0.6707375646,
0.9498780966,
-0.332256794,
0.7158994675,
-0.568765521,
1.1069060564,
0.5854111314,
-0.6939626932,
0.3470865786,
-0.4316501319,
0.3576475978,
0.2217236757,
0.500254333,
-0.615791142,
0.2957816422,
-0.2330355346,
-0.545255959,
1.0479596853,
0.0252809506,
0.1582083702,
0.3085321188,
0.2505230606,
-0.010470042,
0.2396266907,
-1.1353344917,
-0.4893139303,
-0.611413002,
0.2614280581,
-0.4680333138,
-0.2882693112,
0.0348739326,
-0.3661729693,
0.5485964417,
-0.385722816,
0.1833483577,
-0.2149336487,
-0.2129541188,
-0.1512141824,
0.26603508,
0.7208628654,
0.4238069952,
-0.3469610214,
0.1566565186,
0.1718671471,
-0.7519694567,
0.2301068902,
0.0312981009,
-0.11738085,
-0.1595091373,
0.3687913418,
0.8432405591,
-0.0078651868,
-0.9462755322,
0.6709167361,
-0.0191828441,
-0.1700184494,
-0.495527029,
0.1382097751,
-0.0630117953,
0.1637600809,
0.4352997243,
-0.2182868272,
-0.0460943468,
-0.671854794,
0.2539506853,
0.3318688869,
-0.1598724425,
-0.5054123998,
0.7763811946,
0.0112851458,
-0.1296188682,
0.4558971226,
-0.1746740043,
-0.6043815613,
0.4964873195,
0.2832144499,
0.7274559736,
-0.3908780217,
0.5060281157,
0.7910627723,
0.2558361292,
-0.479629159,
0.1854301691,
-0.3415769935,
-0.8525666595,
-0.6519838572,
-0.6557200551,
-0.1633889079,
0.7925886512,
-0.5915369987,
0.4819229245,
-0.5386652946,
0.0269642696,
-0.1986431479,
0.0295707136,
-0.5418004394,
0.5412634611,
0.5877889991,
0.6896566749,
-0.7748702168,
1.2816560268,
0.7543706894,
-0.4334774613,
-0.900578618,
-0.3227394521,
-0.1054929718,
-0.5381615162,
0.8058037162,
0.1904513985,
0.1775225103,
-0.0955573767,
-0.6458398104,
-0.7605118752,
1.3097516298,
0.3006358743,
-0.7703140378,
-0.1234296411,
0.4274920225,
0.4522292614,
-0.1910312027,
0.3409054875,
0.3855375051,
0.2599433064,
0.1852479428,
-0.8863381147,
-0.4078088403,
-0.3339015245,
-0.1899973899,
0.1001085714,
-1.0363336802,
1.2287527323,
-0.0178385507,
-0.1206546947,
-0.022147987,
0.6276181936,
0.0631722584,
0.2438477129,
0.4476857185,
0.546298027,
0.2703082263,
-0.1332628131,
0.8426790833,
-0.0704391822,
0.1766884178,
1.2032318115,
-0.0092682531,
0.8088498116,
0.2602520585,
-0.2635134459,
0.1764033586,
0.6611546278,
-0.3263298571,
0.5655633807,
-0.12970981,
-0.3361614943,
-0.6244669557,
-0.1949852556,
-0.4624134898,
0.6296105981,
0.2072367519,
-0.3025863171,
-0.3932344913,
0.2015627176,
-0.1889825612,
0.0509736426,
-0.4680308998,
0.6046419144,
0.0954619274,
-0.4682871997,
0.6155468225,
-0.1000994816,
0.6989324689,
-0.9847816229,
-0.0071631619,
-0.1627663374,
0.3134951293,
-0.241447717,
-0.6682969332,
-0.2408981323,
0.0534860194,
0.2164898962,
-0.0384854749,
0.5488659143,
-0.5501884818,
-0.2577314973,
0.3464738429,
0.2490989268,
0.396450907,
-0.1598905921,
-0.7028918862,
0.0509965643,
-0.0217940975,
-0.3471095264,
0.6625712514,
0.1998903602,
0.0911342427,
0.6890880466,
0.4609824717,
0.1369728148,
0.2426559329,
0.327627629,
0.8893327117,
-0.7073588967,
-0.323602587,
-0.9214724302,
0.5393613577,
0.2059684992,
-0.2011094689,
0.8778440952,
0.4875139594,
1.2404506207,
-0.2906371355,
0.812680006,
-0.1377965659,
-0.1091902629,
-0.5325284004,
0.7789395452,
-0.7388595939,
-0.0364757627,
-0.4586602151,
-1.0585645437,
-0.2632318139,
0.5394906998,
0.0676994175,
-0.139728412,
0.4299199879,
0.6106225252,
-0.0928511098,
-0.2989257872,
0.9233540297,
0.2915426195,
0.3997758627,
0.8773008585,
0.9081227779,
-0.6937132478,
0.7852534056,
-0.4615511596,
-0.1832476705,
-0.095572181,
-0.7760338187,
-1.337620616,
-0.6720909476,
-0.2760111094,
0.1266494989,
-0.1940557212,
1.0352380276,
0.7976366282,
-0.6544610858,
-0.3684104979,
0.1847007275,
-0.3744851351,
-0.2741136551,
-0.1616049558,
0.3026962876,
-0.0843140781,
-0.7714132667,
0.3516304195,
0.2529754639,
-0.0690170079,
-0.6041019559,
-0.2671068609,
-0.3412348032,
-0.359000653,
0.841422379,
0.4504599273,
-0.7514805794,
-0.0641143769,
0.0753029585,
0.0258127768,
0.3022540808,
0.7834624052,
-0.6230406761,
0.6202340722,
0.5973379612,
0.5164866447,
0.7565637827,
0.0918087512,
0.6163313985,
-0.563944757,
0.3919917941,
-0.3157454431,
0.5041195154,
0.3131582737,
-0.2077551782,
0.4864384532,
0.1742900312,
-0.4005889595,
-0.6732682586,
0.265855819,
-0.9719278216,
-0.2752952278,
1.0131953955,
-0.5234047174,
-0.0495430417,
0.4031468332,
-0.2428245097,
0.3462586999,
-0.2306764871,
0.8400227427,
0.7519704103,
0.2158120275,
-0.880538702,
-0.5119146705,
0.6843442917,
0.4443108141,
-0.8424708843,
0.0171143841,
0.3095130622,
0.2260008007,
0.203646794,
0.5888825059,
-0.0835163519,
0.6400814652,
-0.0380377285,
0.0902526081,
-0.2817055583,
-0.5254909396,
-0.5226306319,
0.1696113497,
0.0322297253,
-0.2121425569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04357v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04357v5 | Dial-MAE: ConTextual Masked Auto-Encoder for Retrieval-based Dialogue Systems | 2023-06-07T11:40:07 | 2024-03-27T03:06:13 | Zhenpeng Su, Xing Wu, Wei Zhou, Guangyuan Ma, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Dialogue response selection aims to select an appropriate response from
several candidates based on a given user and system utterance history. Most
existing works primarily focus on post-training and fine-tuning tailored for
cross-encoders. However, there are no post-training methods tailored for dense
encoders in dialogue response selection. We argue that when the current
language model, based on dense dialogue systems (such as BERT), is employed as
a dense encoder, it separately encodes dialogue context and response, leading
to a struggle to achieve the alignment of both representations. Thus, we
propose Dial-MAE (Dialogue Contextual Masking Auto-Encoder), a straightforward
yet effective post-training technique tailored for dense encoders in dialogue
response selection. Dial-MAE uses an asymmetric encoder-decoder architecture to
compress the dialogue semantics into dense vectors, which achieves better
alignment between the features of the dialogue context and response. Our
experiments have demonstrated that Dial-MAE is highly effective, achieving
state-of-the-art performance on two commonly evaluated benchmarks. | [
-0.6390343904,
-0.5083347559,
0.2691206634,
0.2022646815,
-0.2121916562,
0.2565717399,
0.1678963006,
-0.2864379883,
0.4937930405,
0.5951161385,
-0.6499244571,
0.035134986,
-0.5352039933,
0.2438089401,
-0.2789091766,
0.7313391566,
0.1927784085,
0.3276194334,
-0.0892316326,
-0.2697265446,
-0.6196251512,
-0.5807332993,
-0.6509104371,
-0.1471085697,
0.1267770678,
0.0590567105,
0.5159810781,
0.2243656069,
0.3371042907,
0.2401292622,
0.2308855504,
0.1176328734,
-0.4813331068,
0.5203945637,
0.3684909046,
-0.1993633956,
-0.3710981607,
-0.0528406426,
0.4343663454,
0.5661531091,
-0.0591633469,
0.0073788227,
0.1460940987,
0.4474327266,
-0.8041672707,
-0.0532723553,
-0.7591053843,
0.0695078373,
0.3772099316,
-0.4514661431,
-0.4421822727,
-0.3707756996,
0.6308507919,
-0.6084477305,
0.0445403755,
0.3363502324,
0.6592290998,
0.4489660263,
-0.3826196194,
-0.4849691987,
-0.4407151639,
0.6697499752,
-0.614123404,
0.5749542713,
0.5013533235,
0.4036452174,
0.0785321817,
-0.3325818181,
-0.3408004642,
-0.0416830219,
-0.2405635864,
0.3069933951,
0.2396529764,
0.3084442616,
0.3821401,
0.3463606536,
-0.6683229804,
-0.1673735976,
-0.1998623013,
-0.5367363691,
0.3104519248,
0.2248612642,
0.1191664115,
-0.0934252664,
-0.4671898484,
-0.0527251214,
-0.6795224547,
-0.0133374054,
0.1666364968,
0.0214516055,
0.1358597726,
0.4697259367,
-0.2750819325,
0.6190859079,
0.3911995292,
-0.0961322486,
0.1731257439,
-0.1315677613,
-0.5267729759,
0.3174692988,
0.83284688,
0.3269200921,
-0.022280382,
-0.1012202352,
-0.4938020408,
0.024751218,
0.2758685052,
-1.0983921289,
-0.0505822226,
-0.0638331696,
-0.5772107244,
-0.1650066525,
0.0523450635,
-0.778906703,
-0.0178781785,
-0.2430222929,
0.7195999622,
-0.0581442229,
0.0408283323,
0.2650372088,
-0.0272648409,
0.4586445689,
0.4697689414,
-0.7898213863,
0.3607143164,
0.1496181339,
0.6299711466,
0.0493272506,
0.3648453355,
-0.9204667807,
-0.0044363905,
-0.1980105042,
0.3790857792,
-0.9755269289,
-0.7985262275,
0.3054717183,
0.0748048574,
-0.1381293088,
-0.6864477992,
0.2885005772,
-0.7691277266,
0.5211016536,
-0.2050061822,
-0.3602857888,
0.0243751239,
0.09916538,
-0.4377607107,
0.9927027822,
0.1245393679,
-0.4998908639,
0.3472997546,
-0.3900082111,
-0.2824473381,
-0.1096245274,
-0.1592762619,
-0.2413764,
0.0497094542,
0.5428017974,
0.2174787372,
-0.306543082,
0.3578203022,
-0.2791888118,
-0.5438465476,
0.1949604154,
-0.5026877522,
0.8221590519,
0.5422047973,
-0.3440177143,
-0.085020043,
-0.601326704,
0.0567737445,
-0.1218388677,
-0.2854093611,
-0.2768066525,
-0.3424736857,
-0.103341125,
0.2690468132,
0.2564379275,
-0.7544118166,
-0.0031073252,
-0.4304799139,
0.4323321581,
0.4616128504,
-0.3067995906,
0.6945117116,
-0.3172006309,
0.4403634071,
-0.1418844759,
0.1303259879,
-0.4384640157,
-0.3366442025,
-1.0018430948,
-0.4245500565,
0.2707151175,
0.7515294552,
-1.0268480778,
0.7449481487,
-0.025644362,
-0.0525090247,
-0.9558774829,
-0.0652862564,
0.4975778759,
0.7445834279,
0.3030724823,
-0.8972550035,
-0.7555750012,
-0.91157794,
0.0617625527,
-0.2964581847,
-0.2736898363,
0.6976991296,
0.2224223018,
-0.5848442912,
1.2749119997,
-0.6722474098,
-0.2051520199,
0.1651564687,
0.2408878356,
-0.2626968026,
0.3317011893,
0.3555929363,
-0.5751843452,
-0.5098972321,
-0.1126026735,
-0.6645227671,
-0.5199009776,
0.0651021451,
-0.1232448891,
0.107802853,
0.5043466687,
-0.4695935249,
0.424669385,
0.2663488984,
-0.039977286,
0.4943574965,
-0.109025985,
0.4038710296,
-1.0044811964,
0.1953323931,
-0.440683037,
-0.6376644373,
-0.5952692032,
-0.4237574935,
0.1154430658,
-0.3650809526,
-0.2202869505,
0.5543196201,
-0.2745972276,
-0.2349197119,
-0.1534727812,
-0.1521816999,
0.1033101007,
0.6952919364,
0.3098184764,
0.9849786758,
0.341848135,
-0.3769274354,
0.3138988912,
0.4879753888,
-0.3062991798,
0.625436604,
-0.7388367653,
0.3971850872,
-0.2996566892,
0.6157143116,
-1.1667114496,
-0.1316208988,
0.1686394662,
-0.4510447681,
0.2259314358,
-0.2542611361,
-0.1521841586,
-0.3966840506,
-0.3297873735,
0.6348699331,
0.6436565518,
-0.5573394895,
0.6275145411,
0.473086834,
-0.3852374554,
-0.4858320951,
-0.2279262394,
-0.0787714347,
-0.2842636108,
-0.3805330098,
-0.0421018451,
-0.4471697211,
0.1261713505,
-0.502237916,
-0.2532004714,
-0.2973086834,
-0.0338241085,
0.1522467285,
0.3232811689,
-0.2830640674,
-0.0592123047,
0.0191262607,
-0.2523638606,
0.0350923613,
-0.2278722078,
0.5405473709,
0.1525621116,
-0.3196756244,
-0.3447906375,
0.6435162425,
0.7344231606,
-0.2233981341,
0.3593859076,
0.5882037282,
-0.1841814667,
0.1833125353,
-0.9263442755,
-0.5593618751,
-0.5131328106,
0.0902914703,
-0.3653979599,
-1.2257750034,
0.5009553432,
-0.1190049052,
0.0868854746,
0.0430099852,
0.4650584757,
-0.2850891948,
1.3886506557,
0.3606233299,
-0.2778153121,
0.6480970979,
-0.0557526276,
0.3809500933,
-1.0818750858,
-0.2413056791,
-0.5882476568,
-0.1541497707,
-0.16929847,
-0.3632813394,
0.4793782532,
-0.2068429142,
-0.4713395834,
0.4522765875,
-0.5519158244,
0.0852446407,
0.4468284249,
-0.0771315098,
0.2196290046,
0.0568601377,
-0.0241452027,
-0.154028371,
-0.6076127887,
-0.3949038684,
0.853179872,
0.3846236467,
1.142318964,
-0.12857382,
0.5393371582,
0.1325631887,
0.0512545705,
-0.6776866317,
0.5250809789,
0.1945122331,
-0.3664510548,
-0.2329789698,
-0.4127680361,
-0.8932754397,
0.4974231422,
-0.0808456913,
-0.5997225046,
0.4826492369,
-0.0772545859,
-0.7226919532,
-0.2666176856,
-0.8209026456,
0.4814293087,
-0.0446458459,
0.1663382053,
0.1584365815,
-0.9692922831,
-0.011503377,
-0.1077729836,
-0.0691300705,
-0.0584724396,
0.1236239672,
0.723107636,
-0.5658828616,
0.8207150102,
-0.1888082623,
-0.1011390835,
0.1876182258,
0.2360906005,
0.4200291336,
0.2779345214,
0.2053879797,
-0.1369664371,
0.0483862832,
-0.1755626202,
-0.8587329388,
0.553879559,
-0.8005660772,
-0.6932397485,
-0.1506996751,
-0.5758860707,
-0.4561373889,
-0.0752096549,
0.4030392766,
1.0163235664,
-0.1866884083,
0.3152059615,
1.1186009645,
-0.222985357,
0.3204554021,
0.6701806188,
-0.1379324198,
-0.6303249598,
0.7719830871,
0.0013450995,
0.4977100492,
0.3562874198,
-0.1963096559,
-0.2670978308,
0.0347302556,
-0.5628557205,
0.0240002256,
-0.3530906439,
-0.4013364315,
-1.0367254019,
-0.5857905746,
-0.3681715727,
-0.6272977591,
-0.3252538741,
-0.3611599803,
-0.1853864193,
0.2539244592,
-0.1253131032,
0.4411571622,
0.2609777153,
0.3189949989,
-0.6634336114,
0.4905023873,
0.78555125,
0.2328435034,
-0.2335836887,
-0.6520263553,
-0.1602254212,
0.279489398,
-0.2413130552,
-0.6715956926,
0.4838471413,
0.2024228424,
0.4113044441,
0.4971934259,
0.2463395745,
0.7720769644,
-0.551894486,
0.6649745107,
0.3100425601,
-0.7153147459,
0.8018829226,
-0.2216607034,
0.6659699678,
0.6045843959,
0.1331274509,
-0.4221549034,
-0.4546534121,
-0.3503398299,
-0.7340906262,
0.7340192795,
0.2964806557,
0.3082721829,
-0.0294352304,
-0.0898931623,
0.3634282947,
0.4617068768,
-0.3451183438,
-0.1008219272,
-0.2983438373,
-0.1567264199,
0.1171300188,
-0.5013882518,
-0.222596705,
-0.1748753637,
0.5021375418,
-0.407201916,
0.7450991273,
0.4906177223,
-0.4917423427,
-0.1768091619,
0.1293298751,
0.4419924915,
0.1860029995,
-0.5205765963,
-0.1366249025,
0.1919960082,
-0.4388256371,
0.1796019971,
0.1177038699,
-0.1535779089,
0.1298490316,
0.0969047919,
0.9647154808,
0.5321978331,
-0.7040025592,
0.524890244,
-0.3625799716,
-0.1034854352,
-0.096056208,
-0.0021540355,
-0.5274142623,
0.0707940683,
0.5481888056,
0.0273459367,
0.6408658624,
-0.4930149913,
0.1482762694,
0.7082859874,
-0.6015232205,
-0.0671401247,
0.5643354058,
0.6003242731,
-0.4104455411,
0.5339388847,
0.0613492317,
-0.7505746484,
0.377138257,
0.6001663804,
1.1154894829,
-0.4166176915,
0.2135933936,
0.361779809,
0.0122211473,
0.1365224719,
0.0400990732,
-0.5877488256,
-0.7182232141,
-0.0475165546,
-0.6652080417,
-0.2871698439,
-0.0171566121,
-0.9126039743,
-0.057749968,
-0.3079179823,
-0.224992767,
-0.545183599,
-0.037570361,
-0.8153817654,
0.26332286,
0.0543593653,
0.8323959708,
-0.5871700644,
0.6473650932,
0.4149528146,
0.0056992751,
-0.445392698,
-0.0017096376,
0.0778523684,
-0.8866932392,
0.6553115249,
0.4865637124,
-0.3560446799,
-0.014725131,
-0.2721290886,
-0.9133672118,
1.004743576,
0.3168249428,
-0.53053689,
-0.1113034561,
-0.0747566372,
0.2777517736,
-0.8045675159,
0.7083820105,
0.6211995482,
-0.0530305021,
0.4288947284,
-1.4038395882,
-0.1716187745,
-0.2358720005,
0.3776412308,
0.1411254704,
-0.6530716419,
0.1769108325,
0.2935269475,
-0.1482868791,
0.4050115645,
0.430878222,
-0.0669854134,
0.108174853,
0.4961788654,
0.4878282249,
0.5070962906,
-0.1915859729,
0.7045635581,
-0.2589813769,
0.2300957292,
0.9075772762,
-0.3747113049,
0.7292175293,
0.4066711366,
0.1065624356,
0.4125338793,
0.5321630239,
0.5649445653,
1.0150063038,
-0.2308882177,
-0.4691612422,
-0.3383520544,
-0.2193555534,
-0.4680211842,
0.3708470762,
0.5219341516,
-0.2595744729,
-0.1385193169,
0.3153188527,
-0.2988351583,
-0.4269921184,
-0.1363252103,
1.1720817089,
0.2159752399,
-0.750189662,
0.7159010172,
-0.4693685472,
0.738696754,
-0.6735147238,
0.0600125752,
-0.2043512464,
-0.2301281691,
0.0312221274,
-0.5306122899,
0.1800208539,
-0.2296921313,
-0.1583064049,
-0.4662420452,
0.970659852,
-0.8019202352,
0.0024252587,
0.2644609809,
0.3904723525,
-0.0284157898,
0.2335499078,
-0.6035165787,
0.2426627129,
0.0182166565,
-0.0662560388,
0.2809052169,
0.3016521931,
0.2068303525,
0.6881412864,
0.6183735132,
-0.4149642289,
-0.0148050506,
0.1559134871,
1.040299058,
-0.3687571883,
-0.5444599986,
-0.3782677054,
0.5295763016,
-0.2875035107,
-0.1673546284,
0.440557301,
0.485704273,
0.5716621876,
-0.0297680721,
0.7114847302,
0.0874494314,
0.2305580378,
-0.435667634,
0.4511462748,
-0.3441577554,
0.2498853952,
-0.184568733,
-1.1549589634,
-0.1232319325,
0.9687953591,
-0.2963271439,
0.1124291718,
0.4545580149,
1.1013554335,
0.027239209,
0.0351503864,
0.5791963935,
0.1737534851,
0.2505306005,
0.5881898999,
0.7814300656,
-0.5273028016,
0.3661564291,
0.3331439495,
-0.2881556153,
-0.7174341083,
-0.3202177882,
-1.096552372,
-0.7587954998,
-0.0421979949,
-0.2162740529,
0.0503940582,
0.9187919497,
1.0694189072,
-0.8512634039,
-0.1820563227,
0.4327104688,
-0.3330177665,
0.3219662011,
-0.2264469266,
-0.0638811812,
-0.6397953629,
-0.5882347822,
0.4290209115,
0.7143336535,
-0.0073540406,
-0.292858839,
-0.3890001774,
0.1602825522,
0.3882995546,
0.6995413899,
0.1591307074,
-0.7898128033,
-0.3550929129,
0.0839585513,
-0.5170973539,
0.0854958743,
0.987686038,
-1.1246516705,
1.1158089638,
0.3320733607,
0.9366137981,
0.4487244785,
-0.0745102912,
1.0967936516,
-0.6100999713,
0.1844245493,
0.3243384063,
0.4733288884,
0.3416595459,
-0.3157597184,
0.331217438,
0.0785507187,
-0.7016861439,
-0.6821671128,
0.3255397677,
-0.8621317744,
0.1269615144,
1.0624735355,
-0.0179404691,
0.0432585292,
-0.5267423391,
-0.8304419518,
-0.0978958979,
-0.7031310797,
0.7214356661,
0.7371008992,
0.1406266093,
-0.1660204828,
-0.5120030642,
0.6359179616,
0.7022701502,
-0.407592833,
-0.2518537641,
0.5406255722,
0.0697276443,
0.0863264278,
1.1003187895,
-0.0009317191,
0.4198661447,
-0.2592975199,
-0.4232010245,
0.2566236854,
-0.318887502,
-0.2223300785,
-0.035489101,
-0.1725687087,
-0.192885533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04349v2 | GPT Self-Supervision for a Better Data Annotator | 2023-06-07T11:33:14 | 2023-06-08T05:45:45 | Xiaohuan Pei, Yanxi Li, Chang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB | The task of annotating data into concise summaries poses a significant
challenge across various domains, frequently requiring the allocation of
significant time and specialized knowledge by human experts. Despite existing
efforts to use large language models for annotation tasks, significant problems
such as limited applicability to unlabeled data, the absence of self-supervised
methods, and the lack of focus on complex structured data still persist. In
this work, we propose a GPT self-supervision annotation method, which embodies
a generating-recovering paradigm that leverages the one-shot learning
capabilities of the Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT). The proposed
approach comprises a one-shot tuning phase followed by a generation phase. In
the one-shot tuning phase, we sample a data from the support set as part of the
prompt for GPT to generate a textual summary, which is then used to recover the
original data. The alignment score between the recovered and original data
serves as a self-supervision navigator to refine the process. In the generation
stage, the optimally selected one-shot sample serves as a template in the
prompt and is applied to generating summaries from challenging datasets. The
annotation performance is evaluated by tuning several human feedback reward
networks and by calculating alignment scores between original and recovered
data at both sentence and structure levels. Our self-supervised annotation
method consistently achieves competitive scores, convincingly demonstrating its
robust strength in various data-to-summary annotation tasks. | [
-0.4858862758,
-0.5196909904,
0.3184015155,
0.3466365635,
-0.4868268073,
-0.2891513109,
-0.2546257377,
-0.0214706045,
0.5504220128,
0.6168337464,
-0.5480467081,
-0.5564931035,
-0.554995954,
0.3193050921,
-0.3581371009,
1.7121956348,
0.0237504616,
-0.5247737169,
0.0438708961,
0.1147346273,
-0.5402511954,
-0.5396082997,
-0.6372910142,
-0.3908694685,
0.510880053,
0.1337160319,
0.403952688,
0.7598509192,
0.4294787943,
0.2270983011,
0.3846843839,
0.0581598319,
-0.4738039076,
0.147093609,
-0.1258850396,
-0.1720415056,
-0.5665078759,
0.2570115328,
0.5131332278,
0.4060072303,
-0.1258762926,
0.2879983187,
0.2452433854,
0.5103237033,
-0.4960718155,
0.5218262672,
-0.4276750386,
0.2988158464,
-0.2558716238,
-0.5276074409,
-0.3848989308,
-0.3136376441,
0.0045216931,
-0.9583546519,
0.6323004365,
-0.1848473847,
0.7161663771,
0.6402733326,
-0.1910457313,
0.0009954592,
-0.6346901655,
0.3750875294,
-0.5039879084,
-0.1960882843,
0.6330192089,
0.5074871778,
0.2095465362,
-0.8311555982,
-0.4247379303,
0.0185563825,
-0.6256461143,
0.5433229208,
0.1292979717,
-0.0499076918,
0.2391204089,
0.413307488,
-0.4323770106,
-0.0369870551,
-0.357398361,
-0.2723107636,
0.8946347833,
0.1484789699,
-0.0841857269,
-0.4855751395,
-0.5568550825,
-0.1450638622,
-0.6774094701,
-0.4562449753,
0.2773835659,
0.5742380023,
-0.0571519732,
0.2679716051,
-0.3584065139,
0.3734243214,
0.2462505251,
-0.048458986,
0.3633120656,
-0.3902938962,
-0.2069933116,
0.2877364159,
1.1619799137,
0.3607808053,
0.4997347891,
-0.4270451665,
-0.152975589,
-0.1634163111,
0.5587234497,
-0.7635784745,
-0.6552441716,
-0.1682793051,
-0.2371194363,
-0.2752705514,
0.1982489675,
-0.7289181352,
-0.1680710316,
-0.3790857196,
0.6678565145,
-0.3455153406,
-0.4923041761,
-0.1503771842,
0.0417036116,
0.1852056384,
0.3078531623,
-1.2123593092,
-0.1643586457,
0.4962211549,
0.875659287,
-0.0333530642,
-0.4899014831,
-0.2928079367,
0.2775685787,
-0.2037720978,
0.7493520379,
-0.0003483635,
-0.5157565475,
-0.1332466602,
0.0118417423,
-0.087950483,
-0.3071812391,
0.4194672406,
-0.1301890761,
0.3211873174,
-0.244336158,
-0.5864500999,
0.0894993395,
0.335436523,
-0.5678408742,
0.955753088,
0.3897679448,
-0.9615994096,
0.7420105934,
-0.6662840843,
-0.563203752,
0.3853130937,
-0.41786623,
-0.8515789509,
-0.095236823,
0.5133553147,
0.7269618511,
0.1584632993,
0.320720911,
0.0463704579,
-0.1406609267,
-0.3566243649,
-0.353617698,
0.3848048151,
0.0394720174,
-0.3831877708,
0.1423857808,
-0.6970806122,
-0.1537525207,
0.2027888596,
-0.1519027054,
-0.057868626,
-0.1265548021,
-0.1118500903,
0.1651702076,
-0.0830055699,
-0.4733148813,
0.6022700667,
-0.1387910694,
0.1976398379,
0.7215685844,
0.4400048554,
0.1519925445,
-0.1126787141,
0.6859163046,
-0.1345019788,
0.0589152165,
-0.7604728937,
0.0355250314,
-0.6392102242,
-0.3809565008,
0.3369573653,
0.3736522794,
-0.973533988,
0.7056896687,
-0.5177502632,
-0.3289996088,
-0.8355156183,
0.1076636314,
0.4055238664,
0.924821496,
0.8431504369,
-0.1164456308,
-0.467787087,
-0.9106798768,
-0.2269534618,
-0.0510369986,
-0.3479006886,
-0.2013038397,
0.4649092257,
0.0077956808,
1.2161852121,
-0.5876631141,
-0.914928019,
-0.3266353309,
0.5794093609,
0.0135801481,
0.7686633468,
0.4814205468,
-0.45291996,
-0.395457983,
-0.1012170613,
-1.1105716228,
-0.1296745688,
-0.5139914751,
-0.0959279835,
-0.1399089694,
0.5382947326,
-0.3806062043,
0.481033653,
-0.0122092562,
-0.2664520144,
0.644703567,
-0.2067808509,
0.0820050612,
-1.1865125895,
0.1360647678,
-0.0180686023,
-0.4538156092,
-0.3899669051,
-0.3732765019,
0.0700256526,
0.1640148163,
0.0575153604,
0.1078370288,
-0.3820718527,
0.3915240169,
-0.4015616179,
0.253077358,
-0.1264937073,
0.4915611744,
0.1035570204,
0.751013577,
0.6341894865,
-0.3968439698,
0.2905385792,
0.6559357643,
-0.1766712964,
0.3677678108,
-0.6299610734,
0.1425549835,
-0.4500274658,
0.2550329566,
-0.8265416026,
-0.3352209926,
0.265190661,
-0.3469680548,
0.6067378521,
-0.3864089847,
-0.5363746881,
-0.1405780911,
-0.1870372146,
0.1519779414,
0.3644723892,
-0.6977345347,
0.6091599464,
0.1602255106,
-0.3057727516,
-0.3428740501,
-0.671931088,
0.1052379534,
-0.3143674433,
-0.1634097099,
0.1461435556,
0.4689452052,
0.3862535357,
-0.1191930175,
-0.1835767478,
0.3882744014,
0.0778860077,
0.328641355,
0.2022090405,
0.0043344512,
0.3867521584,
0.141975686,
-0.6830848455,
0.213058874,
-0.2308256477,
0.1839892268,
0.0907317996,
-0.1672890931,
-0.3443686068,
0.2448402643,
-0.1201483905,
-0.3884874582,
0.4115331173,
0.7333940864,
-0.0937342718,
-0.2718094885,
-0.4132634699,
-0.1221687496,
-0.4360192716,
0.2442133725,
-0.4852162302,
-0.6984811425,
0.3134760857,
-0.0591200702,
0.0458070263,
0.8817087412,
0.3644203544,
-0.1817547381,
0.7747965455,
0.5772778988,
-0.5172997117,
0.6072922349,
-0.4944144189,
-0.0270321667,
-0.7423322201,
-0.1461088508,
-0.147041887,
-0.1052303985,
-0.4614999592,
0.1755833626,
0.563686192,
0.2216645181,
-0.1076656356,
0.4485806227,
-0.7930990458,
0.4849392474,
0.5309370756,
0.0379135087,
0.2825450003,
-0.1374048591,
0.2614577711,
0.0539721549,
-0.5753874779,
-0.5766607523,
1.1304709911,
0.1704479456,
0.8794878721,
-0.3111047447,
1.0569747686,
0.2405362725,
0.7195165753,
-0.3492003083,
0.2116627842,
0.0614421703,
-0.4946087003,
-0.4571025372,
-0.6202312112,
-0.8579300046,
0.365013808,
-0.2208542675,
-0.6595754623,
-0.2948993146,
0.6476925611,
-0.4453451335,
0.094950065,
-0.8219608068,
1.1981363297,
-0.0723652318,
-0.18286255,
0.2173053771,
-0.9342058897,
0.1868489236,
-0.063884154,
-0.1593251228,
-0.1350059807,
0.5220612288,
0.5695341229,
-0.3657430708,
0.8930468559,
-0.464495033,
-0.0661260188,
0.3104571104,
-0.0249407627,
0.3984273076,
0.275280565,
0.1825523674,
-0.0039606234,
-0.0911207497,
-0.2809119821,
-0.6523690224,
0.2362100631,
-0.4977130592,
-0.644867301,
-0.2192675024,
-0.3948900998,
-0.0939250663,
0.0851827636,
0.63564533,
0.3254761994,
0.0360514969,
-0.0109179458,
0.1929502487,
0.2282317579,
0.5829357505,
0.1836955547,
-0.2974835932,
-0.4703228474,
0.9156773686,
0.0997843817,
0.1627729684,
0.2804772854,
0.0614987835,
-0.3576219976,
-0.3226862252,
-0.5721442103,
0.0415432751,
-0.5924079418,
-0.5942212939,
-0.603001833,
-0.0925343633,
-0.3861557245,
-0.1112936363,
-0.3716198504,
-0.4950137436,
-0.2507695556,
-0.4648216069,
0.3588495255,
0.5921577811,
-0.1249967888,
0.6212297678,
-0.583941102,
0.4058349431,
0.288415134,
0.3716096878,
-0.269820869,
-0.45744735,
-0.2888557911,
-0.2374676019,
-0.3789403141,
-0.63085711,
0.3031052053,
0.3656578362,
0.3896855712,
0.4171920121,
0.0113306632,
0.7452899814,
-0.3973778486,
0.6507664919,
0.153180033,
-0.7907388806,
0.9710646272,
-0.3017263114,
0.3776111901,
0.815382719,
0.2388262451,
-0.3659565449,
-0.4179241955,
-0.4244692922,
-1.038233757,
0.6625065804,
0.3241937757,
0.0146201141,
-0.2168916911,
0.6325809956,
0.4035913944,
0.1725029051,
-0.7660681009,
-0.3221579492,
-0.9205397964,
-0.4166209102,
-0.2766621411,
0.1558948606,
0.0225473084,
-0.15788427,
0.75436759,
-0.4959795177,
0.0044727731,
0.4792045951,
-0.2310485542,
0.0919260159,
0.2197550088,
0.0450230725,
0.4648208916,
-0.0749220625,
0.2328342944,
0.2030133456,
-0.4853551388,
-0.0180666037,
0.4359378517,
-0.4108905196,
-0.102392897,
0.6826695204,
0.8758425713,
0.0032880388,
-0.1351542324,
0.5721085072,
0.012378213,
-0.202940613,
-0.3482080698,
0.0966991782,
-0.2431175262,
0.1118654683,
0.5316514373,
-0.4140041173,
0.0646367297,
-0.1781553328,
0.3272064626,
0.2843471467,
-0.1390337497,
-0.490108192,
0.900046885,
0.071300745,
-0.0187069681,
0.7316078544,
-0.4308254421,
-0.5162966847,
0.2540765703,
0.6960753202,
1.0809116364,
-0.2172421217,
0.2705410123,
0.5926820636,
0.2877619267,
-0.104838118,
0.0123881241,
-0.397601068,
-0.4579020739,
-0.6246723533,
-0.6735777259,
-0.0708225071,
-0.1621842384,
-0.8776749372,
0.0408420935,
-0.1527694762,
-0.0860701427,
0.1759337336,
-0.2364828438,
-0.6262133718,
0.4155042768,
-0.1102966666,
0.5047566295,
-0.8498648405,
0.8115788698,
0.3713001907,
-0.9743486047,
-0.8559057117,
-0.0504926071,
-0.2695226073,
-0.5355191231,
0.4774509966,
0.2820720673,
0.0139003405,
0.2842160165,
-0.3676904738,
-0.4826701581,
1.2685239315,
0.4667656422,
-0.5220109224,
-0.0464591198,
0.1912547648,
0.6484236121,
-0.3001419306,
0.1536383331,
0.7110317945,
0.3736810684,
-0.1497699767,
-0.8416428566,
0.1362366974,
-0.1521878839,
-0.246827051,
0.5079883337,
-0.5612308383,
0.4872580171,
-0.0807401463,
-0.420873642,
-0.28202492,
0.7193523049,
-0.1714482009,
0.0706670359,
0.4522508681,
0.6771135926,
0.3317013085,
-0.3258309662,
1.1365588903,
-0.1709351689,
0.8979498148,
1.4924273491,
0.1589867622,
0.3520045877,
0.3322355151,
-0.165811494,
0.1458630711,
0.2427671403,
-0.3225371242,
0.6089585423,
0.1717125326,
-0.1136577353,
-0.3447886407,
0.2025459856,
-0.384452939,
0.4429922998,
-0.009037964,
-0.5088686347,
-0.4781906009,
-0.0197006483,
0.0736586601,
0.0107479841,
-0.3397054374,
1.1474342346,
-0.0391865261,
-0.5438525081,
0.2885651886,
-0.5586254001,
0.4590795636,
-0.686691165,
-0.0898728371,
-0.3018174171,
0.026034506,
-0.3209396601,
-0.7012696266,
0.3784856796,
-0.0256243311,
-0.0571782254,
-0.5158599019,
0.5623695254,
-0.7174861431,
-0.4556115568,
0.0309492294,
0.3446750343,
0.0623544268,
-0.3629275858,
-0.1296654791,
-0.3105022311,
-0.1800100654,
-0.4690898359,
0.1519568712,
0.3785161376,
0.1688843668,
0.4063686132,
0.2507100403,
-0.0368371978,
0.0876698643,
0.3655079603,
0.8658692241,
-0.8276263475,
-0.6300188899,
-0.9390869141,
0.600890398,
-0.1625503451,
-0.6523793936,
0.8149052262,
0.6783289909,
0.9791621566,
-0.062384557,
1.1214601994,
-0.1668348014,
0.5520775318,
-0.5078573823,
0.8166146874,
-0.1847899258,
-0.0833019763,
-0.3449362516,
-0.654605031,
-0.4044484794,
0.7130186558,
-0.2385464609,
0.1629548371,
0.3895706832,
0.451226294,
-0.1040425003,
0.1431724429,
0.0740489885,
0.0362548977,
0.4288553894,
0.3178505003,
0.6337818503,
-0.436285615,
0.5650640726,
-0.3781526089,
-0.0395875871,
0.1933149695,
-0.9705173969,
-0.9188917279,
-0.5184393525,
-0.4812816679,
0.034046758,
-0.1785939336,
0.9675553441,
0.7852501869,
-0.8069552779,
0.3393958807,
-0.1620465517,
-0.3515185416,
-0.2198337466,
-0.2710826993,
0.6650227308,
-0.852981925,
-0.4210689366,
0.3539918065,
0.4280805886,
0.0814815462,
-0.2316094786,
0.1822654158,
0.1252951622,
-0.5235496759,
0.5723664165,
0.1742288321,
-0.4613630474,
-0.500228405,
-0.5468133688,
0.1145566702,
0.1899631917,
0.8959645629,
-0.8930339217,
0.7190288901,
-0.1275444925,
0.7328438759,
1.0509300232,
0.5508359671,
0.4446786642,
-1.2944157124,
-0.1154048517,
0.2002512664,
0.3584127426,
0.388099134,
-0.4084614813,
0.7645070553,
-0.0210081246,
-0.6102318764,
-0.4177896082,
0.0671398565,
-0.8339845538,
0.1725427061,
0.7937757969,
-0.4890885353,
0.2365006953,
0.0835666507,
-0.3200440705,
0.5560144186,
-0.1504410654,
1.2398884296,
0.3496026993,
-0.220188722,
-0.1827566922,
-0.3639636338,
0.6287223101,
0.3017828166,
-1.1467434168,
0.3201586008,
0.375955075,
0.3152079284,
0.2126642466,
0.770815134,
-0.0109003456,
-0.0277059861,
-0.0283258278,
0.3643223643,
-0.3738566339,
-0.2730301619,
-0.3758997619,
0.3046277761,
-0.2401966304,
-0.4424197674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04347v1 | World Models for Math Story Problems | 2023-06-07T11:25:20 | 2023-06-07T11:25:20 | Andreas Opedal, Niklas Stoehr, Abulhair Saparov, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Solving math story problems is a complex task for students and NLP models
alike, requiring them to understand the world as described in the story and
reason over it to compute an answer. Recent years have seen impressive
performance on automatically solving these problems with large pre-trained
language models and innovative techniques to prompt them. However, it remains
unclear if these models possess accurate representations of mathematical
concepts. This leads to lack of interpretability and trustworthiness which
impedes their usefulness in various applications. In this paper, we consolidate
previous work on categorizing and representing math story problems and develop
MathWorld, which is a graph-based semantic formalism specific for the domain of
math story problems. With MathWorld, we can assign world models to math story
problems which represent the situations and actions introduced in the text and
their mathematical relationships. We combine math story problems from several
existing datasets and annotate a corpus of 1,019 problems and 3,204 logical
forms with MathWorld. Using this data, we demonstrate the following use cases
of MathWorld: (1) prompting language models with synthetically generated
question-answer pairs to probe their reasoning and world modeling abilities,
and (2) generating new problems by using the world models as a design space. | [
-0.2571048737,
-0.995493412,
0.6507148147,
0.3278632164,
0.0450807512,
0.2086109072,
0.2338775992,
-0.6109076142,
0.1121311039,
0.506190598,
-0.8059467673,
-0.381257385,
-0.4324818552,
0.0708038509,
-0.2581810355,
0.8318443894,
-0.3864203691,
-0.0265739672,
-0.7187891006,
-0.1062643453,
-0.4572390318,
-0.7334234118,
-0.320068419,
-0.4840221405,
0.3791236281,
0.1713555008,
1.0869024992,
0.3480691016,
0.6498149633,
0.282151252,
-0.0442456752,
0.3663906753,
-0.1480065286,
0.1651818007,
0.0611467436,
-0.4317665994,
-0.2237010598,
0.3330820501,
0.2354156077,
1.2465993166,
-0.0324295238,
0.277233392,
-0.3093756139,
0.3651995361,
-0.0951400846,
0.732122004,
-0.1416118145,
0.3806077242,
0.3229270577,
-0.0585622452,
-0.2063149363,
-0.4616250992,
0.5228453875,
-1.0935788155,
0.1798373759,
0.3376889527,
0.6547945738,
-0.1015540734,
-0.4338246584,
-0.6822549701,
-0.7372987866,
0.4933800101,
-0.479857713,
0.1907256544,
0.2870504558,
0.4152553678,
-0.3132331073,
-0.3927968442,
-0.6018059254,
-0.0357083194,
-0.1478585452,
0.0672543496,
-0.4044274092,
-0.3809394538,
0.6047804952,
0.0861623138,
-0.5256986022,
-0.0581398346,
-0.3180673122,
-0.4018441439,
0.6473701,
0.5429763198,
0.7569617629,
-0.3492998183,
-0.2228030264,
-0.072168231,
-0.579087019,
0.1647992879,
0.5355783701,
0.1216216162,
-0.248488009,
0.7289402485,
0.0398967974,
1.0011028051,
-0.7318395972,
-0.3540952504,
0.0230260808,
0.1147005558,
0.2301565558,
-0.0687845945,
0.3688217402,
0.4875574112,
0.61265558,
-0.1728096604,
-0.0889488459,
0.5202769041,
-0.0811837912,
-0.6427804232,
-0.0987893939,
-0.05159951,
-0.1674766093,
-0.600237906,
-0.1408417672,
-0.4917639792,
-0.3725986183,
-0.6597149372,
0.4226751924,
-0.332362473,
-0.1717430949,
0.3937178254,
-0.4249936044,
-0.118914187,
0.3985049427,
-0.7818281054,
0.5211316943,
0.823823154,
0.7254844904,
0.0162683763,
-0.1524992138,
-0.4246355593,
0.0703707039,
-0.5075005889,
0.8367580175,
-0.5138087273,
-0.2148539126,
0.0906193182,
-0.3066987097,
0.0703619421,
-0.4233291447,
0.5404199362,
-0.4549844265,
0.4905309379,
-0.0402396135,
-0.7222450376,
-0.2945260704,
0.504812479,
-0.6909531355,
0.7294985056,
0.1287041008,
-0.742911756,
-0.1627319902,
-0.655626297,
-0.1531605273,
0.0431655198,
0.0130105643,
-0.2110434026,
0.417234987,
0.4949944317,
0.1626690626,
-0.1655632555,
0.6477897763,
-0.200638786,
-0.1974613219,
0.3807466924,
-0.3930436671,
0.9038482904,
0.1322419792,
0.2384441644,
-0.2559102774,
-0.8428985476,
0.2552801371,
0.6901573539,
0.2811387479,
-0.5599742532,
-0.0810235739,
0.0323922671,
0.4053436816,
0.1287580878,
-0.6686013937,
0.3045893312,
-0.4727019072,
0.5354875326,
0.4215006232,
0.0333018973,
0.0923269168,
-0.5554374456,
0.657781601,
-0.0943782628,
-0.0018049969,
-0.3606343567,
-0.8569868803,
-0.6022500992,
0.3714066148,
0.2910301983,
0.6200566292,
-0.7027478218,
-0.0469987579,
-0.2647454739,
-0.5344543457,
0.0069197374,
-0.354690969,
0.1938108504,
0.790538311,
0.1101054996,
0.0530480184,
-0.5452851653,
-0.8250279427,
-0.4162478447,
-0.2305293232,
-0.1054966897,
0.5296100974,
0.5767003894,
0.125996232,
1.4103221893,
-0.9605233073,
-0.2035881728,
-0.2341379076,
0.0992348343,
0.2048374712,
0.2380793244,
0.2932828963,
-1.0065275431,
-0.3798849881,
-0.1815022081,
-1.1027992964,
-0.2919006944,
-0.0353267938,
-0.2818443477,
-0.070751816,
0.1049636826,
-0.5881838202,
0.6256048679,
0.4861388206,
-0.4481163025,
0.6843652129,
-0.1739511639,
-0.2668232322,
-0.9172708988,
-0.1488064229,
0.0481871665,
-0.2117836624,
-0.4598556459,
0.183833003,
-0.2137918472,
-0.9451792836,
-0.3363175392,
0.9174851179,
-0.161222443,
-0.3097066581,
0.0978424996,
0.5164417624,
0.3494305909,
0.6916657686,
0.1161114201,
0.3653695285,
0.4130959809,
-0.5149794817,
0.592345953,
0.642531693,
-0.333514154,
0.557575047,
-0.6749863029,
0.0749454275,
-0.2339801639,
0.4867851436,
-0.5512319207,
-0.2050027847,
0.0577492006,
-0.5960528255,
-0.4271380603,
-0.1777536422,
-0.8714237213,
-0.4964120984,
0.1793658286,
0.2226243615,
0.3757571876,
-0.5967552662,
0.6335188746,
0.4657613039,
-0.2173162848,
-0.2012826204,
-0.3849360645,
0.1305190474,
-0.1574829072,
-0.9543800354,
0.4617162049,
-0.2382091731,
-0.5484853387,
0.2616312206,
-0.3696922064,
-0.2728946507,
0.0535854027,
0.2078163177,
0.5626308918,
-0.0170283206,
0.2018415481,
0.0213534925,
-0.5976896882,
0.4488259852,
-0.4658875763,
0.3770885468,
-0.155998975,
-0.2148270905,
-0.0828267857,
0.6495171189,
0.4052924812,
-0.3175557256,
0.5430243611,
0.0969732627,
-0.831154108,
-0.3637004495,
-0.1248346269,
0.1037659422,
-0.4142612219,
0.1858627796,
-0.4182700217,
-0.8059307933,
0.7542364001,
-0.2914772034,
0.4139269888,
0.3700743914,
0.3200027943,
-0.1870674789,
1.2174875736,
0.7138410807,
0.4643577039,
0.1367755234,
-0.4017652571,
0.5145674944,
-0.512884438,
-0.4488654435,
-0.3425372243,
-0.2404870242,
-0.0785704181,
-0.2633020282,
0.5785475969,
0.2076400518,
-0.1658829302,
0.3691424429,
-0.3456252217,
0.8060571551,
0.1321879625,
-0.2728671432,
0.7953048348,
0.3339956403,
-0.4855580926,
-0.5492364168,
-0.739313364,
-0.5067865252,
0.7743046284,
0.0388535708,
0.7407926321,
0.2448041737,
0.4917907119,
0.0497528762,
0.3261744082,
-0.6949240565,
0.4494047761,
0.0290097855,
-0.7591993809,
-0.184979707,
-0.532874465,
-1.0291624069,
0.4601607621,
-0.2181553692,
-0.5857744813,
-0.2754209638,
-0.1372307986,
-0.2370057106,
0.2172232121,
-0.6823333502,
0.9862824678,
-0.1963979602,
0.1120885685,
-0.0178782567,
-0.3889465332,
0.3714264631,
0.0142973978,
0.5743930936,
-0.2772898376,
0.1870978773,
0.5247167349,
-0.7516705394,
0.8571557403,
0.0810842365,
-0.2761817276,
0.5606511831,
0.5823674202,
0.4521481395,
0.4098807871,
0.1994773,
0.0812644511,
0.2123074532,
-0.1033146679,
-1.1509152651,
0.6347230077,
-0.7273515463,
-0.5628224015,
-0.5378371477,
-0.9665278196,
-0.5718829036,
0.179501161,
-0.0197385121,
1.0874013901,
-0.0800108165,
-0.3000069857,
0.4862221181,
-0.2277182341,
0.4144523442,
0.5859366655,
-0.7898525596,
-0.1571710855,
1.0393954515,
0.1619367003,
0.2670073807,
0.1659751832,
0.4900538325,
-0.2613927424,
0.0936699733,
-0.610337913,
0.1543081999,
-0.8698630333,
-0.2308751196,
-0.7003595233,
-0.5072457194,
0.0967115909,
-0.2745917439,
0.0174985211,
-0.9230202436,
0.1155093163,
-0.1134890988,
0.4295639098,
0.5904045105,
0.0695984811,
-0.042924393,
-0.7969465256,
0.3477261961,
0.3222572505,
0.3392176032,
0.0396920443,
-0.2294086218,
-0.1047213599,
-0.0021538821,
-0.3509143889,
-0.6511213779,
0.624329865,
0.066491358,
0.38649562,
-0.3480783105,
0.145761162,
0.7278161049,
-0.7807589173,
0.3251503408,
0.1645823866,
-1.0277926922,
0.6260659099,
-0.3181560636,
0.1689916849,
-0.0983340442,
0.4366835356,
-1.0183047056,
-0.3269819319,
-0.9485301375,
-0.3477309644,
0.5183737874,
0.4418665469,
0.496668458,
0.189383626,
0.517280817,
0.1954580098,
0.0254777893,
-0.7391103506,
-0.2342545092,
-0.141192928,
-0.4022804201,
0.1854114085,
0.1087785661,
-0.2098993957,
-0.2175200135,
0.3508381546,
-0.2303902954,
0.197445035,
0.0548362508,
-0.3010051847,
-0.2331033796,
-0.0175319016,
0.2604642808,
0.9020847082,
0.2395186126,
0.0969630554,
-0.0317783505,
-0.2441503257,
0.1907873303,
0.2557991445,
-0.2542862296,
0.1007533446,
0.6326563358,
0.6039051414,
0.4110693932,
-0.983782351,
0.4413862824,
-0.2076897919,
-0.3383682072,
-0.3892363906,
0.0190450363,
0.272582382,
-0.01434677,
0.1999204755,
0.2010033876,
0.0015925467,
-0.4979206026,
0.0462549143,
0.1916439533,
-0.2104534358,
-0.2695404589,
0.5157800317,
0.0964226872,
-0.7571668029,
0.8701699972,
-0.1257846206,
-0.7929253578,
0.9541708231,
1.032791853,
0.2520070076,
0.3684776127,
0.5656253695,
0.3789125979,
-0.0128220711,
0.2887614071,
0.118648909,
0.3117200434,
-0.8866399527,
-0.487259835,
-0.5577440858,
-0.6203278303,
-0.0942574739,
-0.4701538682,
0.2769326866,
-0.4297053218,
0.2427403927,
0.213371098,
0.0987681821,
-0.5379081964,
0.0873598084,
0.3510450423,
0.6922838688,
-0.8557748795,
0.2527416348,
0.6682555079,
-0.2064762264,
-0.8588209152,
-0.3449828029,
0.0613467544,
-0.753565073,
0.7446935773,
0.3344481289,
0.2121991813,
0.1782841831,
-0.601824224,
-0.9924527407,
0.7648999095,
0.3327305913,
-0.3703945875,
-0.1965157092,
0.2130369693,
0.6628426909,
-0.6200054884,
-0.2476254553,
-0.0461187735,
0.191835016,
0.344174087,
-0.6794022322,
-0.2690842748,
-0.4518531859,
0.0931443796,
0.2803570032,
-0.2825638354,
0.686473906,
-0.5555372834,
-0.092191726,
-0.0221551824,
0.5393913388,
0.6259222627,
0.4466494024,
0.5203799009,
0.6507006884,
0.7496321797,
-0.105411455,
1.108248353,
-0.0673995987,
0.5644421577,
0.7727438211,
-0.1016920954,
0.4639652073,
-0.1048422903,
-0.2737995088,
0.7182563543,
0.6647292376,
0.0755162835,
0.2137803286,
0.6730006337,
0.0003472123,
-0.5632563829,
-0.1206843555,
-0.3711670041,
0.3408902287,
0.5476773381,
0.2584379315,
-0.6869939566,
0.1115204617,
0.0557883829,
0.2109732777,
-0.2438138276,
0.2884774506,
0.3172706962,
-0.5452177525,
-0.0365919359,
0.1464341134,
0.0734786019,
-0.523530364,
-0.3872388899,
-0.2368004322,
-0.0172380451,
0.0094156396,
-0.5821622014,
0.4469259679,
0.0534786917,
-0.2172165811,
-0.285928756,
0.526994586,
-0.3866663277,
-1.2160054445,
-0.1854679286,
0.8321343064,
0.0037750369,
0.1825636476,
-0.6947739124,
0.0079159373,
-0.3887626231,
0.196242556,
0.2025690079,
0.7136700749,
-0.6055875421,
0.9518691301,
0.9523072839,
-0.425278008,
-0.0651550889,
0.1710441858,
0.7048070431,
-0.5847812295,
-0.9417976141,
-0.6067581773,
0.271499455,
0.0395100564,
-0.4404326677,
0.7024787664,
0.5136479735,
0.5715955496,
0.1185535863,
0.5812895298,
0.1013836339,
0.3633200824,
-0.4718770087,
0.2500911951,
-0.3373016417,
0.2506055236,
-0.4303715229,
-1.1218469143,
-0.6944998503,
0.8653125763,
-0.1824954152,
-0.1489452571,
0.8162747622,
0.0960750133,
0.065518558,
0.5080955625,
0.1400682628,
-0.1938354522,
0.4807198942,
0.6858531237,
1.1184868813,
-0.3658510149,
0.6216567159,
-0.3020718694,
-0.136632055,
0.1267282218,
-0.8580493331,
-0.9076638222,
-0.5018069148,
-0.4797579944,
-0.3449756205,
-0.3762319684,
0.6060634851,
0.467621088,
-0.398796618,
0.0207567513,
-0.0692650303,
0.4050580561,
-0.198417604,
-0.1830228567,
0.3183685839,
-0.3116135597,
-0.579017818,
0.1651170403,
0.2390180677,
0.2430319488,
-0.509005487,
0.1189069897,
0.3842095733,
0.1438284814,
0.6382942796,
-0.0544461049,
-0.6559219956,
-0.2348222136,
0.2829114497,
0.0356339179,
-0.1416219473,
1.1913889647,
-1.0894509554,
0.3115812242,
0.058671385,
0.4642838836,
0.5499327779,
-0.2112532705,
0.5533878803,
-0.5815936327,
0.1005543992,
0.3847619891,
0.4234713614,
0.223513335,
-0.3462608457,
0.6417421103,
0.5759627819,
-0.054347761,
-0.7443166375,
0.4126971364,
-0.6920366883,
-0.3444016874,
0.6971164346,
-0.0796393752,
-0.272429496,
-0.1432950795,
-0.2096047699,
-0.3188976347,
0.132379055,
0.4646970332,
1.1971913576,
-0.3138459623,
0.0351761021,
-0.8372485042,
0.1612047404,
0.2264759243,
-0.9323770404,
0.1504250616,
0.622168839,
0.1407519132,
0.3890884221,
0.18778947,
-0.2821269035,
0.0583973415,
0.112816155,
-0.3089546561,
-0.5311041474,
-0.382440865,
0.0527892075,
0.1764371544,
-0.4387289584,
0.4533598721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04340v1 | Co-evolving Graph Reasoning Network for Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction | 2023-06-07T11:11:12 | 2023-06-07T11:11:12 | Bowen Xing, Ivor W. Tsang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction (ECPE) aims to extract all emotion clauses and
their corresponding cause clauses from a document. Existing approaches tackle
this task through multi-task learning (MTL) framework in which the two subtasks
provide indicative clues for ECPE. However, the previous MTL framework
considers only one round of multi-task reasoning and ignores the reverse
feedbacks from ECPE to the subtasks. Besides, its multi-task reasoning only
relies on semantics-level interactions, which cannot capture the explicit
dependencies, and both the encoder sharing and multi-task hidden states
concatenations can hardly capture the causalities. To solve these issues, we
first put forward a new MTL framework based on Co-evolving Reasoning. It (1)
models the bidirectional feedbacks between ECPE and its subtasks; (2) allows
the three tasks to evolve together and prompt each other recurrently; (3)
integrates prediction-level interactions to capture explicit dependencies. Then
we propose a novel multi-task relational graph (MRG) to sufficiently exploit
the causal relations. Finally, we propose a Co-evolving Graph Reasoning Network
(CGR-Net) that implements our MTL framework and conducts Co-evolving Reasoning
on MRG. Experimental results show that our model achieves new state-of-the-art
performance, and further analysis confirms the advantages of our method. | [
-0.4517472386,
-0.9232040644,
0.4102039337,
0.0511132814,
-0.2461797148,
0.0469931439,
-0.0836573914,
-0.6565070152,
0.2550397217,
0.2561524212,
-1.1241112947,
-0.4068918228,
-0.7553585172,
0.2612025738,
-0.1517352462,
0.9502321482,
-0.1428563893,
-0.3989815712,
-0.318680495,
-0.1661749929,
-0.3113482296,
-0.4275266826,
-1.0192055702,
-0.4582867622,
0.809243679,
0.6174256206,
0.014929872,
0.0127582895,
0.3371745646,
0.2779384255,
0.1442005485,
0.5869238377,
-0.4886870384,
0.3402707279,
-0.026134504,
-0.1735747755,
-0.6055014133,
-0.2613948882,
-0.0751712695,
0.3862275779,
-0.250040561,
0.1343978792,
0.248745203,
0.6976318359,
-0.5881088972,
0.4086713493,
-0.5738742948,
0.2170963585,
-0.033797577,
-0.288253814,
-0.5619680882,
0.1597921103,
0.1115242466,
-0.6206963062,
0.1562225521,
0.2911432385,
0.8039506674,
0.1516846567,
-0.4451634288,
-0.2778180242,
-0.2526875734,
0.4880131483,
-0.4777650833,
0.3388834894,
0.07655444,
0.0318677649,
-0.2359594256,
-0.7851300836,
-0.4914916754,
-0.0600963123,
-0.131776914,
0.5008656979,
-0.4896057844,
0.0691607371,
0.137389496,
0.0016606838,
-0.6649038196,
0.0881238505,
-0.0461785607,
-0.1330515295,
0.5251601934,
0.1271723658,
0.5288892984,
-0.3279213607,
-0.3624902368,
0.0940797478,
-0.6049861312,
0.2124227881,
0.2171518505,
0.3354612887,
-0.2610249519,
0.2642680109,
0.015460737,
0.3779049218,
0.3956783116,
0.3368895352,
0.3213302195,
-0.0385771208,
-0.3422543108,
-0.002706833,
1.0733584166,
0.259410888,
-0.0422716029,
-0.2465759814,
0.2102451175,
0.075627923,
0.1694664061,
-0.584933877,
-0.2709301412,
0.5147208571,
-0.5461005569,
-0.2650483549,
-0.2485931665,
-1.1456558704,
-0.4160254896,
-0.3433203995,
0.2124820799,
-0.4717850387,
-0.5926625133,
0.008829318,
-0.2370421439,
-0.2935926914,
0.4544917345,
-0.7279385328,
0.2916952074,
0.7827093005,
0.753508091,
-0.1139669642,
-0.3657414019,
-0.7733846903,
-0.0794262886,
0.0544848256,
0.8459498882,
-0.3545410931,
-0.0550604723,
-0.0273177549,
0.2538479865,
-0.3447457552,
-0.3090876341,
0.6908518672,
-0.2982709408,
0.3646931052,
-0.377690047,
-0.3087802529,
-0.3630616367,
0.4834918082,
-0.6681342125,
1.0876243114,
0.1032981351,
-0.8676530123,
0.1515727788,
-0.9529036283,
-0.3802843392,
0.1175951064,
-0.0534826331,
-0.7290912271,
-0.0663977638,
0.2760601938,
0.5981290936,
-0.4607414603,
0.3874131143,
-0.7723888755,
0.048025962,
-0.168218106,
-0.0221247841,
0.8386161923,
0.011106641,
-0.532056272,
0.2997958362,
-0.6424881816,
-0.1150628254,
0.1049490795,
-0.0588776171,
-0.2417521775,
0.247712642,
-0.1495397389,
0.7478973866,
0.0964655802,
-0.6582711339,
-0.0812312737,
-0.1080137715,
0.4944675565,
0.7397222519,
0.2234156132,
0.1401041895,
-0.1609935015,
0.4871762693,
0.3211924732,
0.2215567678,
-0.0261784364,
-0.3699789047,
-0.6211485267,
-0.1524119377,
-0.2361548841,
0.3511854708,
-0.7671971917,
0.3384348154,
-0.034600269,
-0.3474709988,
-0.1623526365,
0.015126003,
0.3797545433,
0.5915107131,
0.6325490475,
-0.1636595577,
-0.6237618923,
-0.5661053658,
-0.2904601693,
0.0312704369,
0.3472382724,
0.6572753191,
0.4936421812,
-0.0332603566,
0.4575637579,
-0.3736078143,
-0.0544746816,
-0.3435292542,
0.5047641397,
-0.0368766077,
0.4065099657,
0.560054183,
-0.6875029206,
-0.526717782,
0.1327204257,
-0.8598765731,
-0.2333349884,
-0.1842763871,
-0.3165917397,
0.0784232542,
0.3753141463,
-0.5821399093,
0.1549194157,
0.8095753193,
-0.6209622025,
0.5442145467,
-0.163798511,
0.1483962685,
-1.1457146406,
-0.0744947419,
0.3380137086,
-0.1186713278,
-0.4438580275,
-0.0410961546,
-0.0717244446,
-0.2660489082,
-0.1657017767,
0.3600462973,
-0.5666320324,
0.0033516723,
-0.1113859341,
0.3663101494,
0.1907151043,
0.8933263421,
-0.2407915294,
0.0273945034,
0.6954289079,
-0.3381681144,
0.6191337705,
0.1870442033,
0.1692707539,
0.8634607196,
-0.3826863766,
0.357434243,
-0.1900989264,
0.2772701383,
-0.7835153341,
0.0922228843,
0.6440068483,
-0.3971503675,
0.484733969,
-0.2117702365,
-0.308104068,
-0.5940636396,
0.0687563047,
0.0246569756,
0.1856167912,
-0.6070333719,
0.92800349,
0.1657023579,
-0.2717534304,
-0.633261323,
-0.4066295624,
0.1458925009,
-0.1784633994,
-0.8381781578,
0.2590700984,
-0.01515684,
0.0094667887,
0.328923285,
-0.131106019,
0.0111289453,
0.1007910371,
0.4799271822,
0.1321121454,
-0.1195701137,
0.2637787461,
0.2671525776,
-0.1596815288,
0.2355494499,
-0.3658098876,
0.6060554981,
-0.075540483,
-0.2407229096,
-0.4168111384,
0.6555476785,
0.6622689366,
-0.5474512577,
0.4929355383,
0.6179295778,
-0.4260079265,
-0.321020782,
-0.1621588469,
-0.0993720815,
-0.3797996342,
0.6044787169,
-0.4462756217,
-0.8164393902,
0.5355463028,
-0.6208164692,
-0.1090520695,
0.5343191028,
0.5565242767,
-0.2430500984,
0.9105305076,
0.4710816145,
0.1732860655,
0.6572368145,
-0.38681072,
0.0374729559,
-1.1163004637,
-0.4314911067,
-0.3491150439,
-0.4792968333,
-0.405218333,
-0.0871319249,
0.3394892812,
0.1230428591,
-0.3886632919,
0.3303673565,
-0.5301924348,
0.0466367342,
0.329677999,
0.7293031216,
-0.0980881825,
-0.1207915172,
-0.2250009477,
0.2445700169,
-0.5913567543,
0.0652261898,
0.8973463178,
0.0388576165,
0.1352384239,
0.0837305561,
0.8222740889,
0.2448489964,
0.4601248503,
-0.5122425556,
0.4030329585,
-0.3330269158,
-0.498606354,
-0.2730828822,
-0.497372359,
-1.1145563126,
0.3580851555,
-0.3741638362,
-1.082149744,
0.4143948555,
0.244948104,
-0.0151725598,
0.2298949361,
-0.609064281,
1.2397633791,
-0.282622993,
-0.6174592972,
-0.4410105348,
-0.7587639093,
0.221797809,
0.1002312824,
0.3517510295,
-0.1965142936,
0.440026015,
0.6294775009,
-0.5110509396,
0.9281918406,
-0.4882464111,
0.1920379251,
0.4928564727,
0.0480730012,
0.9089717865,
-0.2695426047,
-0.2143463045,
0.020019874,
-0.2043739855,
-0.3022720218,
-0.6757996082,
0.5568474531,
-0.6318454742,
-0.4238137603,
-0.1111586392,
-0.5075938702,
-0.1632687598,
0.2799602151,
0.1617879122,
0.4955688119,
0.0322722867,
0.0354156196,
0.0803629756,
-0.1025615856,
0.592412889,
0.1721590459,
0.0724864379,
-0.454212606,
0.704634726,
-0.0298635904,
0.1844248325,
0.2534782887,
0.5170633793,
-0.042277813,
-0.2062728107,
-0.4513461292,
0.0572996251,
-0.6301448345,
-0.2284341902,
-0.8034361601,
0.1970881671,
-0.168442443,
0.0165500548,
-0.1795674711,
-0.1178010106,
-0.1817012131,
-0.0804518759,
0.4404862523,
0.3945142925,
-0.2479929179,
-0.0316616744,
-0.9375938773,
0.3071604371,
0.2214893848,
0.1620347947,
0.2543891072,
-0.1579097807,
-0.2077457011,
0.0861006975,
-0.5354630947,
-1.2374982834,
0.5250580311,
0.1643877327,
0.4640617371,
0.2459276468,
0.194341898,
0.6200324893,
-0.4151535034,
0.545317471,
0.5874918103,
-1.0542070866,
0.3701071441,
-0.4465108514,
-0.2789005637,
0.2221823186,
0.3301687837,
-0.700731039,
-0.2011905462,
-0.8424543142,
-0.7337936163,
0.7330655456,
0.0085956203,
-0.2276922017,
-0.0337995626,
0.5201297402,
0.1123308614,
0.1178717166,
-0.7948318124,
-0.3203745484,
-0.3688960373,
-0.4809014201,
0.2089424878,
-0.0455989912,
-0.1908871084,
-0.1966392547,
0.401442647,
-0.3451370001,
0.4370563924,
0.206049636,
0.0518568158,
-0.6269729137,
0.3467372358,
0.389532119,
0.1933110356,
-0.175458774,
0.2143304944,
0.1273220032,
-0.1541630626,
0.0000924978,
0.2480694801,
0.2967605293,
-0.1583099663,
0.3589026928,
1.0471251011,
0.2131483108,
-0.265175432,
0.7332181931,
0.0687518492,
-0.376046598,
-0.1002945378,
-0.1929221004,
0.3700494468,
0.6484801769,
0.1125964075,
0.3750795722,
0.1649809033,
-0.7044437528,
0.343591243,
0.3062996566,
-0.4975448847,
-0.5762064457,
0.4757680893,
0.3278737664,
-0.4322921634,
0.5138479471,
-0.5661811829,
-0.9018439651,
0.9249924421,
0.6402390003,
1.1207908392,
-0.0229845922,
0.3599667549,
0.3889279366,
0.0825219229,
0.1595847458,
0.5641889572,
-0.1286761314,
-0.7897608876,
-0.4785344601,
-0.173152402,
-0.5392209291,
-0.1085637137,
-0.6368685365,
0.3138607144,
-0.0049447366,
0.0778447464,
-0.1449462324,
-0.1727993637,
-0.8236042857,
0.3580311835,
0.1821550727,
0.3201236427,
-0.9913947582,
0.6440292001,
0.6576576233,
-0.4231832922,
-0.8807328939,
-0.1765861213,
0.1238741204,
-0.7814050317,
1.0391610861,
0.2449021786,
-0.0414328314,
0.1516293585,
-0.4449380338,
-0.6730777025,
1.2899127007,
0.2215302289,
-0.8197690845,
-0.0230350029,
-0.3001402915,
0.5303894281,
-0.5263644457,
0.3018588722,
-0.051452361,
0.3519417942,
0.1253566444,
-0.6826501489,
0.4300374985,
-0.3926235139,
-0.6932678223,
0.4905451834,
-0.7584403157,
0.9187418818,
-0.3165081739,
-0.2275343537,
-0.5936847329,
0.2281166315,
0.1762324423,
0.7083396912,
0.7442446947,
0.8162761927,
0.9533993602,
-0.0849268287,
1.0389803648,
-0.5075697899,
0.6881033778,
1.2376263142,
-0.3259805739,
0.8101171851,
0.3875158727,
-0.0832029507,
1.0092810392,
0.7087026834,
0.0835011229,
0.3868091404,
0.1328445822,
-0.1489059925,
-0.4092737138,
0.0270265955,
0.0000063704,
0.2506849766,
0.4068397284,
-0.4485986829,
-0.2802916169,
-0.0733037889,
0.1124393567,
-0.4075983465,
-0.2419148088,
0.6708977222,
0.1953560412,
-0.6276291609,
0.1745793819,
-0.3939140439,
0.3801239729,
-0.2298235744,
-0.1180825308,
0.054656893,
0.043182563,
-0.419652909,
-0.3602490425,
0.3022513092,
-0.141446352,
-0.0716138631,
-0.0869136453,
0.7946820855,
-0.4464337826,
-0.1590402871,
0.7531453371,
0.7477812767,
-0.1472430825,
-0.105878599,
-0.9460943937,
-0.2431749851,
-0.2468433231,
-0.4493287206,
0.2268361747,
0.8713154197,
0.1291568428,
0.4944444299,
0.7499381304,
0.0637700334,
-0.0657405555,
0.1439144313,
0.8645138144,
-0.5019258261,
-0.3935618997,
-1.072850585,
0.7733279467,
-0.3895424902,
-0.2181365192,
0.2921088934,
0.1764858365,
0.3456752896,
0.1319371164,
0.8867632747,
-0.2037082016,
0.3174559772,
-0.371956706,
0.4899565876,
-0.8327882886,
-0.1517533213,
-0.5563372374,
-0.6089426279,
-0.2293097824,
0.2764862478,
-0.2999640107,
-0.1457371712,
1.2588744164,
0.4651322067,
0.0694063902,
0.165493086,
0.1375939548,
0.295522064,
0.4352438152,
1.1307948828,
0.6489236951,
-0.4088901281,
0.5252835155,
-0.0895573422,
-0.2492586374,
-0.2769963145,
-1.176435113,
-0.7533029914,
-0.5821679831,
-0.6706080437,
-0.4873311818,
0.1076819301,
1.0912435055,
0.7180459499,
-0.5523884296,
0.1351545155,
-0.5970709324,
0.18532525,
-0.5253280997,
-0.2596293092,
0.6447472572,
-0.2423031181,
-0.4664206803,
0.181362018,
0.57338202,
-0.3176573515,
0.0803271234,
-0.237743333,
-0.2722578645,
-0.1608566195,
0.6099936366,
0.3798093796,
-0.57536906,
-0.6256194711,
-0.0972992033,
0.1369284689,
0.2705996335,
0.7847184539,
-0.2968832552,
0.6390594244,
0.5395386815,
0.5370611548,
0.7153614163,
-0.321901381,
0.5076329112,
-0.6994114518,
-0.1477990448,
-0.0277475733,
0.8364514709,
0.1802572608,
-0.5093878508,
0.3950416446,
0.6653372645,
-0.6813377142,
-0.5988394618,
0.522339046,
-1.1982216835,
-0.1662739813,
0.9922597408,
-0.4846525788,
-0.1384689659,
-0.2080789804,
-0.2161235213,
0.658048749,
-0.4444549978,
0.7859773636,
0.5930888653,
-0.8131495714,
-0.7568800449,
-0.1098200977,
0.2021230608,
0.2397722304,
-1.3698965311,
0.2120183557,
0.3825916946,
0.173148796,
0.2967345119,
0.5146005154,
0.1068847701,
0.2237102836,
0.1878072768,
0.3693343699,
-0.4167041481,
-0.082854934,
0.0390616767,
0.4792179465,
-0.2434443682,
-0.1844065189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04337v2 | A study on the impact of Self-Supervised Learning on automatic dysarthric speech assessment | 2023-06-07T11:04:02 | 2024-03-22T18:41:02 | Xavier F. Cadet, Ranya Aloufi, Sara Ahmadi-Abhari, Hamed Haddadi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automating dysarthria assessments offers the opportunity to develop
practical, low-cost tools that address the current limitations of manual and
subjective assessments. Nonetheless, the small size of most dysarthria datasets
makes it challenging to develop automated assessment. Recent research showed
that speech representations from models pre-trained on large unlabelled data
can enhance Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) performance for dysarthric
speech. We are the first to evaluate the representations from pre-trained
state-of-the-art Self-Supervised models across three downstream tasks on
dysarthric speech: disease classification, word recognition and intelligibility
classification, and under three noise scenarios on the UA-Speech dataset. We
show that HuBERT is the most versatile feature extractor across dysarthria
classification, word recognition, and intelligibility classification, achieving
respectively $+24.7\%, +61\%, \text{and} +7.2\%$ accuracy compared to classical
acoustic features. | [
-0.3120943606,
-0.3925513327,
0.3010752797,
0.3558958769,
0.0877766162,
0.1317705959,
-0.1149470657,
-0.6510272622,
0.5050279498,
0.075540632,
-0.1383703947,
-0.1547843069,
-0.7187823653,
0.3533385396,
-0.4917061925,
0.608974278,
-0.0348288752,
0.0526246913,
-0.1462697387,
-0.0627133399,
-0.2385901064,
-0.3999386728,
-0.2373703718,
-0.4261547625,
0.4337258339,
0.2764193416,
0.4925776124,
0.8508871794,
0.4400235116,
0.4130982757,
0.0919328183,
-0.1687676162,
-0.1537641287,
0.3497014344,
0.0649262369,
0.4743820429,
-0.649061799,
0.5219186544,
0.5774276257,
0.9021653533,
-0.3672547042,
0.441911608,
0.3492004573,
0.5430621505,
-0.335205555,
0.3547695875,
-0.2699593306,
0.0711975843,
-0.4612033963,
-0.2043388039,
-0.1211424842,
-0.0745534897,
0.2546981275,
-0.5865142345,
-0.1651557088,
-0.070719555,
0.578663528,
0.5929903984,
-0.0571389869,
-0.4284664392,
-0.6470705271,
0.4858916998,
-0.2489350289,
0.5118248463,
0.6659795642,
0.4710707366,
-0.0400063358,
-0.9469298124,
-0.3967585266,
-0.5249333382,
-0.154729411,
0.0888350084,
-0.5575127006,
0.1862332523,
0.4626819491,
0.6988480687,
-0.414539665,
0.455575645,
-0.846405983,
-0.4346010685,
1.0535154343,
-0.0094056334,
0.1481574178,
-0.433144629,
0.085346058,
-0.1646787077,
-0.1951969117,
0.2677341104,
0.3169959486,
0.4141583443,
-0.0095858891,
0.300087899,
-0.462536484,
0.7377187014,
0.4930745065,
-0.2400421649,
0.4906440675,
0.3974560201,
-0.1145567596,
0.4709219337,
0.7715511918,
-0.2545203567,
-0.0358925946,
-0.3176886439,
-0.038573768,
-0.1520165205,
0.383004874,
-0.7949870825,
-0.9482198358,
0.2011280358,
-0.4206951857,
-0.3225426674,
0.2012651861,
-0.522162199,
-0.4026507437,
-0.7230850458,
0.5151008964,
-0.1483712494,
-0.4007605612,
0.0871580839,
0.0022892053,
-0.1668335944,
0.2526244223,
-0.8849771023,
0.4706873,
0.2559019327,
0.4562134743,
-0.3996318877,
-0.4568862915,
-0.9352090359,
-0.0826171935,
-0.4331695139,
0.6147273779,
-0.3809780777,
-0.3207547963,
-0.7042269707,
-0.0366725996,
0.0022124967,
-0.6764839292,
0.1048081219,
-0.0966536403,
-0.1202946901,
-0.049035836,
-0.3968669772,
-0.2733732164,
-0.2708978951,
-0.6838465929,
0.9879206419,
0.3526711166,
-0.7907578945,
0.697144568,
-0.5770485997,
-0.5932109356,
0.3155060709,
-0.3990322649,
-0.3769256771,
0.2810880542,
0.3605714142,
0.6626668572,
0.0805632845,
0.3604303598,
-0.5091000199,
-0.202222988,
0.2250273824,
-0.5511745214,
0.6600708365,
0.1687474996,
-0.4342618585,
0.0098446785,
-0.9051203728,
0.1013013422,
-0.1715161502,
-0.3426584601,
-0.2315628678,
-0.2772760689,
-0.2486308217,
0.1300210357,
0.1004699543,
-0.706428647,
-0.1060778573,
-0.4703741968,
0.123634927,
0.5838941336,
-0.3573595285,
0.2162036598,
-0.2840117216,
0.5251706839,
-0.1116424426,
0.0986114293,
0.2662761807,
-0.4436669648,
-0.117615059,
-0.7996784449,
0.7630199194,
0.4260287285,
-0.3666183949,
0.7854818106,
-0.2284575552,
-0.5075480938,
-1.029628396,
0.2779361904,
0.2890741527,
0.6688114405,
0.5473106503,
-0.2849178016,
-0.4482505918,
-0.6285632849,
0.0901696533,
-0.2366096377,
0.0835958794,
0.2687979639,
0.1881828159,
-0.2820935249,
1.0384702682,
-0.1405022889,
-0.4838500321,
-0.2725664079,
0.3695210218,
0.0409395061,
0.4252551198,
0.3449314833,
-0.4296113253,
-0.6776102185,
0.1569969058,
-0.8620288372,
-0.34370929,
0.3708073497,
0.702762723,
0.0383912064,
0.4904131591,
-0.3925730288,
0.7594571114,
0.6499859095,
0.0937876478,
0.5005181432,
-0.5417591333,
0.1625459194,
-0.5623171329,
0.1231489629,
-0.4181962311,
-0.2497806251,
-0.4824617505,
-0.3518367708,
0.0050051818,
-0.2209792733,
-0.0118084876,
0.4544894099,
-0.6268183589,
-0.4374987483,
-0.1842269897,
0.0977786854,
-0.0746101439,
-0.111565277,
-0.1259445101,
0.7497364283,
1.1622678041,
-0.4960482717,
0.5173692107,
0.2235755622,
-0.3341403008,
0.228879571,
-0.6876853704,
0.1058929041,
-0.1090328544,
0.0661371052,
-0.7390911579,
-0.398173213,
0.0456041172,
-0.5624560118,
0.9682520032,
0.1045407578,
-0.2080013603,
-0.8249951601,
-0.2752487957,
0.0581411831,
0.3566687703,
-0.8521416783,
0.6209098697,
0.8685452938,
-0.2655671239,
-0.5301123261,
-0.4891693294,
0.1164834052,
-0.4259179831,
-0.3570028543,
0.3434264958,
0.0184682589,
-0.3876618445,
-0.0667021498,
-0.2610899806,
0.0733655617,
0.2039279342,
0.5659610033,
-0.0269240122,
-0.0633143857,
0.3499211073,
0.1633180976,
-0.3905712664,
-0.0470303558,
-0.0162214506,
0.1585802436,
-0.1490501612,
-0.4041861296,
-0.9437698126,
0.1211990044,
0.5209900141,
-0.0995374545,
-0.2856215835,
0.5761123896,
-0.2523620725,
-0.0686008558,
-0.6200447679,
-0.3377489746,
-0.5257498026,
0.3471333683,
-0.6369119883,
-0.6808977723,
0.2207756042,
0.015612972,
-0.4401301742,
0.5243986845,
0.181559965,
-0.6182268262,
0.9382522106,
0.2816902995,
-0.4082994163,
0.0161687955,
-0.1529586911,
0.0454312377,
-0.8149724603,
0.0805459023,
-0.2689279616,
-0.3162021935,
-0.6903857589,
-0.1843297184,
0.2872840762,
-0.0259202272,
0.1310085356,
0.2254432887,
-0.7687327266,
0.116178982,
0.382951647,
0.1674000919,
0.0994299725,
0.2135832608,
0.1569058597,
-0.2229380012,
-0.599642694,
-0.1962521374,
1.1391525269,
0.4335765541,
0.9419842362,
-0.2508528233,
1.1120506525,
0.6118295193,
0.418181479,
-0.8799464703,
0.1675417721,
-0.4167149961,
-0.3654725552,
-0.7216824293,
-0.5103517771,
-1.0277591944,
-0.1024448723,
-0.0777295679,
-0.6803407073,
0.3006586134,
0.3212152421,
-0.7757110596,
0.031437207,
-0.3357442915,
0.6720097661,
-0.3829904795,
-0.034222234,
-0.3071559668,
-0.5236240029,
0.0396008231,
-0.2726987898,
0.0879619867,
-0.271545738,
0.3552617729,
0.9417102337,
-0.148521319,
0.6791681647,
-0.4379340112,
0.1415830404,
0.2665028572,
0.0636024028,
0.0632047132,
0.0181182623,
-0.0732188001,
0.4327291548,
0.2007448226,
0.1158523262,
-0.5001230836,
0.6759007573,
-0.7184938192,
-0.6911286712,
-0.6673215628,
-0.5127627254,
-0.3906272054,
-0.2438122332,
0.0075502675,
0.8142160773,
-0.2618097365,
0.2592249513,
0.4548712075,
0.0201464668,
0.3382202983,
0.5765146613,
-0.3726991117,
-0.4658246636,
1.1438940763,
0.5484783649,
-0.1844124049,
-0.0812630579,
0.6309030652,
-0.422159493,
-0.7244607806,
-0.5699239373,
0.2021011114,
-0.5612728596,
-0.3045033216,
-0.8028951883,
-0.3406423032,
-0.607299149,
0.2787978053,
-0.1714260727,
-0.6625729203,
-0.6401908994,
-0.4360168874,
0.4687529504,
1.111879468,
-0.8263371587,
0.2537267208,
-0.5591524839,
0.5259724259,
0.9296687841,
0.1862189621,
-0.209340319,
-0.8019874692,
-0.0460065715,
-0.2279342562,
-0.2284548134,
-0.6289284825,
0.4118237495,
0.5102055669,
0.8289017081,
0.3266846538,
0.1302321553,
0.9728266001,
-0.3213620484,
0.3846794963,
0.08911255,
-0.7994708419,
0.573214829,
0.0157184564,
0.0543176904,
0.8435177207,
0.571967423,
0.0967195481,
-0.23852624,
-0.6479943395,
-0.3899607956,
0.911280334,
-0.2277987301,
-0.0657498613,
0.0579622835,
0.2928648293,
0.2533360124,
-0.0746318921,
-0.3165214956,
-0.0136570726,
-0.2220351547,
-0.2838813365,
-0.1127644405,
-0.2544891834,
0.0274268277,
-0.9091959,
0.5117987394,
-0.0982322022,
-0.0684583262,
0.2427403331,
-0.2180278748,
-0.047518529,
-0.1513171345,
0.0269727204,
0.6203618646,
-0.1685023457,
0.0400645956,
0.389536202,
-0.7162519693,
-0.039540045,
0.7677047849,
0.1229769215,
0.0473775417,
0.3314799368,
0.6201348305,
0.0899353027,
-0.2869858444,
0.6675260663,
-0.0762268901,
-0.2658910453,
-0.1942723095,
-0.1088328436,
-0.1897462606,
0.2540737092,
0.3495469391,
-0.0818860382,
0.4927752912,
-0.2202998698,
0.6286238432,
0.2514870465,
-0.7745395899,
-0.464831233,
0.4216906428,
0.027032705,
0.011888722,
0.6053572297,
-0.3364265859,
-0.3540739715,
0.2245574892,
0.3158307374,
0.8287222385,
-0.8671817183,
0.1076305136,
0.2851549685,
0.0062200786,
-0.0068007247,
0.2905598879,
-0.5928621888,
-0.2459204197,
-0.2806520462,
-0.9466418028,
-0.1952934265,
-0.0920338556,
-0.8530823588,
0.2008360177,
-0.1976979077,
-0.3161349595,
0.2834240794,
0.052772209,
-0.3026615083,
0.3059488833,
0.1213129982,
0.5751671791,
-0.5967897773,
1.0561103821,
0.338401854,
-0.1772790104,
-0.9398511648,
0.1134725213,
-0.0615810007,
-0.7942614555,
1.1544234753,
0.353161186,
-0.3279438913,
0.1145416051,
-0.0363530479,
-0.9775080085,
1.0455225706,
0.4314618111,
-0.3540537655,
0.2212657928,
-0.0130079845,
0.4901654124,
-0.2460494339,
-0.0530250184,
0.6706048846,
0.3805008233,
-0.0178598147,
-1.4932357073,
-0.2289215773,
-0.0338492654,
-0.342284888,
-0.2098326087,
0.1379247755,
0.6121546626,
-0.3652819395,
-0.2999538481,
-0.1948753297,
0.8501169086,
0.1197186187,
0.3993833661,
0.4867601097,
0.5775691271,
1.1048411131,
0.0361892059,
0.8918489814,
-0.4399930239,
0.0269626193,
1.1443228722,
-0.2428133786,
0.8226697445,
0.1641837656,
-0.30196473,
0.2517068982,
0.5056069493,
0.2262985855,
0.4974400103,
0.581135869,
-0.1265594363,
-0.2337868959,
0.0028088978,
-0.4677122235,
1.001960516,
0.4620971084,
-0.1224016845,
0.0077723474,
0.3972060084,
-0.2796328962,
0.1624689251,
-0.3380954862,
0.9825478196,
0.1044377759,
-0.2957466245,
0.5694084167,
-0.468619287,
0.5764514804,
-0.5659918785,
0.047441598,
0.101121448,
0.1696831882,
-0.3534644842,
-0.6149735451,
0.5924547315,
-0.2270124555,
0.0073079122,
-0.4228740633,
0.7299525142,
-0.3201114833,
-0.5895652175,
0.5149989724,
0.3303147554,
0.4050811827,
-0.2539785802,
-0.4581141472,
0.0960604697,
-0.361214608,
-0.0753756166,
0.3394622803,
0.3818726242,
0.0651445091,
0.5900518894,
0.3430421948,
0.4267060161,
-0.0353094973,
-0.0095007978,
0.9609755278,
-0.3213870525,
-0.4237298369,
-0.5067605972,
0.2516753972,
-0.2414084375,
-0.1274844557,
0.7330019474,
0.4096079767,
0.5474898815,
0.2136745304,
0.5998286009,
-0.1369607002,
0.9639080167,
-0.1989738345,
1.0063874722,
-0.5311335921,
-0.1315290183,
-0.2090943605,
-0.2548903823,
-0.2037189901,
0.8668950796,
-0.5112352371,
0.0380254053,
0.436953485,
0.5996924043,
-0.1666850448,
0.1618810445,
0.6272392869,
0.2323204577,
0.0240057763,
-0.1429407597,
0.9747402668,
-0.1952712387,
0.283146441,
-0.4852167666,
-0.6099940538,
0.1087638885,
-0.5765522122,
-0.8273882866,
-0.6793366671,
-0.4937604964,
-0.1222476661,
0.036149025,
1.0071357489,
0.8767709732,
-0.8635549545,
-0.3473750353,
0.4607483745,
-0.2575712204,
-0.3340391815,
-0.1335152537,
0.6691212058,
-0.3338862956,
-0.330337286,
0.8959041834,
0.5313185453,
0.1147299781,
-0.3241146207,
-0.2004925609,
0.3854122758,
-0.4462628961,
0.5367814302,
0.3416613638,
-0.646935463,
-0.1780441999,
-0.0174837504,
0.0572384782,
0.1227085963,
0.5811697841,
-1.1050329208,
0.7268037796,
0.1826015264,
0.5648472905,
0.5990279317,
0.076604791,
0.2926965058,
-0.4100777507,
-0.0159853809,
0.3899115324,
0.3285320699,
0.518414259,
-0.3353601694,
0.1534067839,
0.1574780941,
-0.4647704065,
-0.8550473452,
-0.1644415259,
-0.9381452799,
0.0263359901,
0.7435885072,
-0.1883872896,
-0.0620710626,
-0.603448689,
-0.1242807657,
-0.0172146894,
-0.2890052497,
1.0869654417,
0.2817604244,
-0.511521697,
0.1010414287,
-0.5765308738,
0.8462721109,
-0.0678150281,
-0.6142321229,
0.4212305844,
0.410105288,
0.1994282901,
0.2745763958,
0.7167298198,
-0.2298438698,
0.350887835,
-0.0493966229,
-0.2005705535,
-0.4560345709,
-0.6813153028,
-0.6861012578,
0.0103192916,
0.2008172125,
-0.2894626558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04334v1 | Echoes from Alexandria: A Large Resource for Multilingual Book Summarization | 2023-06-07T11:01:39 | 2023-06-07T11:01:39 | Alessandro Scirè, Simone Conia, Simone Ciciliano, Roberto Navigli | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, research in text summarization has mainly focused on the
news domain, where texts are typically short and have strong layout features.
The task of full-book summarization presents additional challenges which are
hard to tackle with current resources, due to their limited size and
availability in English only. To overcome these limitations, we present "Echoes
from Alexandria", or in shortened form, "Echoes", a large resource for
multilingual book summarization. Echoes features three novel datasets: i)
Echo-Wiki, for multilingual book summarization, ii) Echo-XSum, for
extremely-compressive multilingual book summarization, and iii) Echo-FairySum,
for extractive book summarization. To the best of our knowledge, Echoes, with
its thousands of books and summaries, is the largest resource, and the first to
be multilingual, featuring 5 languages and 25 language pairs. In addition to
Echoes, we also introduce a new extractive-then-abstractive baseline, and,
supported by our experimental results and manual analysis of the summaries
generated, we argue that this baseline is more suitable for book summarization
than purely-abstractive approaches. We release our resource and software at
https://github.com/Babelscape/echoes-from-alexandria in the hope of fostering
innovative research in multilingual book summarization. | [
-0.5107840896,
-0.2192931771,
0.2587665021,
0.1793279946,
-0.6394529343,
0.1856457144,
-0.2789137959,
-0.6376127601,
0.590200603,
0.4874328375,
-0.1349321008,
-0.4982085228,
-0.6330502629,
0.3189442456,
-0.6774532795,
1.3810011148,
0.1466776133,
0.0712701604,
0.2499291152,
-0.4170244634,
-0.1112378985,
-0.5341554284,
-0.622944653,
0.0323840752,
0.9007146955,
0.3122348487,
0.6499252319,
0.6565003991,
0.2938762605,
0.1964693666,
-0.0020604853,
0.2078773528,
-0.3504549563,
0.4015956819,
-0.0223823097,
-0.1318171322,
-0.6090487838,
-0.4082520604,
0.8908110261,
0.7127577066,
-0.1101610363,
0.3637517393,
0.357978344,
0.9953844547,
-0.5943697095,
-0.0432884507,
-0.1043060347,
-0.1124446765,
-0.1765999645,
-0.3403249085,
-0.1039174721,
-0.5826679468,
0.021570567,
-0.5870366693,
0.2213941514,
0.1599902511,
0.5790275335,
-0.0595090464,
-0.8697350025,
-0.397079587,
-0.8129123449,
0.8074874282,
-0.3972609639,
0.3275289237,
0.2084203362,
0.2311526239,
0.1723312736,
-0.8020727038,
-0.5220333934,
0.2041721344,
0.0765511841,
0.3599123359,
-0.3057638109,
-0.206105873,
-0.0803746879,
0.6031894088,
-0.5760164857,
-0.2990198731,
-0.3768959343,
0.0384276621,
0.7141537666,
-0.0069897184,
0.4161203504,
-0.0754706264,
-0.1065142229,
-0.312632829,
-0.7146919966,
-0.219677031,
0.4783133566,
0.3669551015,
-0.2578717768,
0.4425590336,
0.018652061,
0.243645817,
-0.4991937578,
-0.077686429,
0.0761162937,
-0.4698165655,
0.3287398219,
0.3571275771,
0.6381492019,
0.649492979,
0.0761483759,
0.0611683764,
-0.1463300735,
-0.5655260086,
-0.0863029584,
-0.8638753891,
-0.0795020461,
0.4937929809,
-1.0838708878,
0.0889035091,
-0.1177785918,
-1.0118465424,
-0.6007182598,
-0.2085399032,
0.2439082116,
-0.3519895077,
-0.5863711834,
-0.0064725266,
-0.4060378969,
-0.2063356787,
0.3509220779,
-0.9275805354,
0.5165587664,
0.6178042293,
1.1086126566,
-0.0649184361,
-0.5312010646,
-0.4718298316,
0.2801856995,
-0.4065230489,
0.8368560672,
-0.1555419117,
-0.6253753901,
0.2322297692,
-0.1345848888,
0.3927640021,
-0.337040931,
0.6429300904,
-0.3233463764,
0.2725935876,
-0.3763397634,
-0.4074158967,
-0.5112870932,
0.0642119572,
-0.9534019232,
0.9031943679,
-0.289994508,
-0.6967386603,
0.0302995555,
-0.4610773027,
-0.5954127908,
-0.2906125188,
0.0315141715,
-0.2442922443,
0.3758889437,
0.3649611771,
0.2473434061,
-0.260714829,
-0.1858537644,
0.0760095119,
-0.3689998388,
-0.111781843,
-0.6039217114,
0.8476499915,
0.2821432948,
-0.2458252758,
-0.0538524576,
-0.7956069112,
0.0137445647,
0.0010356514,
-0.2427801341,
-0.7026484013,
0.366238147,
0.462863028,
-0.2064343989,
0.5258899331,
-0.1391000003,
0.364688307,
-0.218975246,
-0.1740447283,
0.3638321459,
0.1663386822,
0.2310798317,
-0.6548480392,
0.5999312401,
-0.3168830872,
-0.1202238873,
-0.8091900349,
-0.6356022358,
-0.4909279943,
-0.5819103718,
0.3493725955,
0.4223951697,
-0.5634000301,
0.4426631331,
-0.4289264977,
-0.6282307506,
-0.3710525632,
-0.0622351952,
0.425060153,
-0.0641250238,
0.4569918513,
-0.2456083447,
-0.6175175309,
-0.728123188,
-0.364913404,
-0.1401753575,
-0.1438249797,
0.0340272076,
0.531791389,
0.1840646267,
0.2914375961,
-0.2748920619,
-0.3243860602,
-0.4262010753,
0.2651648819,
0.5213269591,
0.1909693927,
0.5812050104,
-0.8079760075,
-0.7056937218,
0.3426322937,
-0.660369575,
0.0558929257,
-0.2476217002,
-0.0762919486,
0.0722083077,
0.139738217,
-0.366463691,
0.2971854806,
0.7233492136,
-0.2222171128,
0.6270461679,
-0.437089324,
0.3824192286,
-1.6765013933,
0.3158467114,
-0.3538376093,
-0.2337695658,
-0.2943296432,
0.0815505758,
0.0782828629,
-0.0903582647,
0.0050541591,
0.7968384027,
-0.8358513117,
-0.053163711,
-0.3741333187,
0.1119639277,
0.1886390299,
0.1829898506,
0.0811311007,
0.8072404861,
0.3809440136,
-0.4818170667,
0.334371984,
0.3802154362,
-0.3267131746,
0.4711495638,
-0.3707308173,
-0.2372024804,
-0.1224517822,
0.4511549175,
-0.8160299063,
-0.1246651858,
0.0010665766,
-0.2735636532,
0.1814748049,
-0.1284382641,
-0.3490113318,
0.1630753875,
-0.7305073738,
0.5707581639,
0.5697801709,
-0.7242375612,
0.732562542,
0.378100723,
-0.8103106618,
-0.9514445066,
-0.3212476373,
0.4630011022,
-0.2284397483,
-0.1358307004,
0.3102485836,
-0.0888550878,
-0.3973093629,
0.0704005882,
-0.0614037365,
-0.1607928574,
-0.2205595523,
0.0685201809,
0.1702425033,
-0.2888890207,
0.3541512787,
0.2475690693,
-0.0027017319,
-0.1595992446,
-0.5723214149,
0.3422069252,
0.0336391032,
-0.2906915843,
-0.3339698613,
1.2070596218,
0.6728251576,
-0.3706233501,
0.5803732872,
0.3118556738,
-0.383462131,
-0.1404249817,
-0.4147582054,
-0.0500380956,
-0.3496914506,
0.5462865829,
-0.1913525611,
-0.3331646025,
0.7595432997,
0.0456952304,
0.6031974554,
0.4636413753,
0.6358884573,
-0.0678115487,
0.9697651863,
0.5797298551,
-0.3369272351,
0.4688844085,
-0.2044063509,
0.1147099957,
-0.659275949,
-0.0936954021,
-0.794029355,
-0.4324618578,
-0.3124744296,
0.0137516167,
0.4206026196,
0.0443474129,
0.1182568818,
-0.0389163941,
-0.4719723761,
0.7076140046,
0.7228132486,
-0.3099669516,
0.7448757291,
0.3749526739,
0.2866097987,
-0.0277683903,
-0.4622395039,
-0.7487553358,
1.4534461498,
-0.044216916,
0.4894785583,
0.6601599455,
0.8235775828,
0.3426400423,
0.2978478372,
-0.7079438567,
0.1488929391,
-0.0801268592,
-0.7033538222,
-0.1924227774,
-0.3814235628,
-1.4156348705,
0.5496803522,
-0.1915259808,
-0.4362009466,
0.2406679541,
0.0228435323,
-0.5139268041,
0.3888758719,
-0.6552419662,
0.555924952,
-0.3230153024,
-0.1852385253,
-0.5533748865,
-0.4175961912,
0.0508237369,
-0.1441567689,
0.5494356155,
0.1010964587,
-0.4047429264,
0.6932749152,
-0.4018799663,
0.5029014349,
0.1019712463,
-0.288131088,
0.3207585514,
0.0621625073,
0.3821992278,
0.1298893243,
-0.1112539023,
0.3378771842,
0.1999878138,
-0.6713815331,
-0.4977702796,
0.6761481166,
-0.7440056801,
-0.1896576732,
-0.807677269,
-0.495772481,
0.0104685863,
0.6529679298,
0.3119344711,
0.8726683855,
-0.3267739117,
0.1997751147,
0.3941771984,
-0.1154012084,
0.7036980391,
0.4729479253,
-0.7015851736,
-0.7551847696,
1.2212548256,
0.3200888634,
-0.1834813654,
0.4596068263,
-0.0526810922,
-0.3033397198,
-0.807667613,
-0.4213105738,
0.1916424185,
-0.4375733137,
0.0445815548,
-0.3928156197,
0.0516289063,
-0.0853135809,
-0.1351979971,
-0.281785816,
-0.8469597101,
-0.1102098078,
0.0358262211,
0.1304810494,
0.910389781,
-0.1514260471,
0.1060559228,
-1.2645989656,
0.3878867924,
0.0054848203,
0.1083693579,
0.0756329671,
-0.2840337753,
-0.8077501655,
-0.1937527061,
-0.3494155109,
-1.0848493576,
0.6163855195,
0.4394703209,
0.0616874322,
0.5381497145,
0.1930236816,
0.3990572095,
-0.6807069778,
0.8897695541,
0.4010255039,
-0.6694583893,
0.1219121292,
-0.7142127752,
0.2320029885,
0.4041108787,
0.4436280727,
-0.800863862,
-0.4553629756,
-0.6058173776,
-1.0919473171,
0.318131566,
0.3355598748,
0.2735592723,
0.0890453085,
0.0884895176,
0.4686480165,
0.4614467919,
-0.4493147731,
-0.5012478828,
-0.2120867372,
-0.5108584762,
-0.4109705687,
-0.3734868169,
-0.3556131721,
-0.0757007524,
0.7070126534,
0.0280181654,
0.0431009233,
0.2299264967,
-0.0432858765,
0.0424294472,
0.2770088017,
0.6378110647,
0.7677598,
-0.1487662196,
0.2797780037,
0.0272716787,
-0.7348693013,
-0.0767724067,
0.2920296788,
-0.0696515068,
0.4675012231,
0.8230068088,
0.2565652132,
0.001917775,
-0.7524915338,
0.4255475998,
-0.3417158127,
0.0860239342,
-0.6791812778,
-0.3275672495,
-0.0092326989,
0.399515748,
0.8402636647,
0.1347151995,
0.5298159719,
-0.4059319198,
-0.0359132364,
0.2043496519,
0.0715295821,
-0.5117151141,
0.5827860832,
0.5360231996,
-0.2310943156,
0.3549601734,
-0.2010931373,
-0.239240557,
0.4386310875,
0.3732126951,
0.9242707491,
-0.0349423587,
0.0320670716,
0.5478371382,
0.2826189399,
-0.0528404564,
0.462493211,
-0.2137002498,
-0.4388437867,
-0.4110861123,
-0.2456926852,
-0.6287248135,
-0.0899176672,
-0.7127891183,
-0.0275588911,
-0.2284144759,
-0.014199161,
-0.0498031825,
0.1913620383,
-0.108644098,
-0.1191679388,
0.1477312744,
0.8855822682,
-0.4446139038,
0.548060298,
0.6844877005,
-0.2371895462,
-0.3229464591,
0.0858104378,
0.1678616405,
-0.4076184928,
0.0038783923,
-0.0750076845,
-0.2920478284,
0.1410337687,
-0.1388184428,
-0.7303873897,
0.9138669968,
0.4436568916,
-0.4463630021,
0.0419962853,
-0.4640131593,
0.4288895726,
-0.0698556378,
0.4952757657,
0.1003695503,
0.4852970243,
-0.3754395247,
-0.7354115844,
-0.2930383682,
-0.7086641192,
-0.2975857854,
0.3560115695,
-0.7546340823,
0.7360098958,
-0.0702940226,
-0.141715765,
0.4549191892,
0.7351753116,
0.0753414333,
0.3858632445,
0.0325245298,
0.3426403105,
1.0740007162,
-0.0431441553,
1.4141064882,
-0.6884015799,
0.2627278864,
1.157823801,
-0.0417437516,
1.0183528662,
0.4867424965,
-0.116605036,
0.4924367964,
0.5944626927,
0.2901398242,
0.3303442597,
-0.2512731552,
-0.7672125101,
0.1706371307,
-0.2716953456,
-0.8774907589,
-0.0405650772,
0.2240095586,
-0.1595972776,
-0.2151654959,
-0.1646844,
0.1012363657,
0.0624210611,
-0.3091201186,
0.6735422611,
0.1703002602,
-0.5501950979,
0.5247401595,
-0.172412172,
0.2759256363,
-0.7128667831,
-0.3758581877,
-0.4873271585,
0.1828301549,
-0.2092652172,
-0.4777946472,
0.0531798229,
0.1047139913,
-0.4121999145,
-0.2489724904,
0.1511090249,
-0.4872457087,
-0.5306078196,
0.2844929993,
0.5837035775,
0.4767882228,
-0.119490847,
-0.2360086888,
-0.1173431352,
0.0475137681,
-0.3574478626,
0.2433044165,
0.5671929717,
0.1392671913,
0.3710903823,
0.6679614186,
0.5848941207,
0.0144867375,
0.0629193559,
0.4367505014,
-0.6797837019,
-0.6945599914,
-0.7524935007,
0.5634967089,
-0.2999947369,
-0.5251690149,
1.0665210485,
1.01422894,
0.4237332642,
0.0221831799,
1.1084324121,
0.0979261398,
0.6370235085,
-0.3613930941,
0.9271600842,
-0.9612966776,
0.0932628363,
-0.0221064109,
-1.4757105112,
-0.4353136122,
0.3997434378,
0.1789384633,
-0.057714913,
1.043348074,
0.493793726,
-0.0413008817,
0.2145728469,
0.1602077186,
0.1331388503,
0.0215232112,
0.2989471853,
0.8818377852,
-0.4273616374,
0.7981421947,
0.0233272463,
-0.3078674972,
-0.3827052414,
-0.7071164846,
-0.7305439115,
-0.9236120582,
-0.1324660182,
-0.2944535613,
0.0643577054,
0.9630275369,
0.4135856628,
-0.9383779764,
-0.6020001769,
0.2982613146,
0.2978468835,
-0.5139890313,
-0.0526266731,
0.7287954688,
-0.1434728503,
-1.1607763767,
0.408112824,
0.2537982762,
-0.0004369123,
-0.0366618074,
-0.2446496189,
0.0610084645,
0.0611701682,
0.3690839708,
0.50232023,
-0.236444056,
0.0119114071,
-0.3603310883,
-0.0922296271,
-0.01263321,
0.8642479777,
-0.338346988,
0.6506204605,
0.4598259032,
0.6554858088,
0.4147365093,
-0.0765089169,
0.7412896156,
-0.6674698591,
0.3019995987,
0.1763596386,
0.6549863219,
0.0677379295,
-0.0640041903,
0.3557458818,
-0.0547909476,
-0.3389219344,
-0.8487272859,
0.0104915528,
-0.6803187728,
-0.2297148108,
0.8774014115,
-0.0545097515,
-0.0907335728,
-0.25421381,
-0.5619373918,
0.2910731137,
-0.555000186,
1.0085577965,
0.8234895468,
0.2220755816,
-0.0569215119,
-0.5077075362,
0.4162832499,
0.5502266884,
-0.8298246264,
0.0522084236,
0.7239964008,
-0.142316699,
0.5297918916,
0.6551632285,
0.0444267914,
0.4602447748,
0.2647331655,
0.5240806937,
-0.0217580404,
-0.4361062348,
-0.6269512773,
0.4228360951,
0.0509591922,
-0.1248338595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04328v1 | IUTEAM1 at MEDIQA-Chat 2023: Is simple fine tuning effective for multilayer summarization of clinical conversations? | 2023-06-07T10:47:33 | 2023-06-07T10:47:33 | Dhananjay Srivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL | Clinical conversation summarization has become an important application of
Natural language Processing. In this work, we intend to analyze summarization
model ensembling approaches, that can be utilized to improve the overall
accuracy of the generated medical report called chart note. The work starts
with a single summarization model creating the baseline. Then leads to an
ensemble of summarization models trained on a separate section of the chart
note. This leads to the final approach of passing the generated results to
another summarization model in a multi-layer/stage fashion for better coherency
of the generated text. Our results indicate that although an ensemble of models
specialized in each section produces better results, the multi-layer/stage
approach does not improve accuracy. The code for the above paper is available
at https://github.com/dhananjay-srivastava/MEDIQA-Chat-2023-iuteam1.git | [
-0.2580540478,
-0.8613631129,
0.4545804858,
0.0819357634,
-0.5188958049,
0.2822912931,
0.0609924048,
-0.75130862,
0.3194085062,
0.6323509812,
-0.5304954648,
-0.7219746113,
-0.5966715217,
-0.0953677967,
-0.2931438386,
1.3768999577,
0.1366978586,
0.2971518338,
-0.0795059353,
-0.3319815993,
-0.5183534622,
-0.2071874589,
-0.8804453015,
-0.3390103877,
0.4412916005,
0.9048157334,
0.5899623632,
0.6767908931,
0.9654861689,
0.3239755034,
-0.0618488155,
0.496929884,
-0.6200507879,
0.3171259165,
0.357064873,
-0.4346733391,
-1.021985054,
0.0595206693,
0.3192466497,
0.7712740302,
-0.1705635786,
0.1044403762,
0.0699783936,
0.8862057924,
-0.2337889224,
0.2466458678,
-0.4642700553,
-0.2097421438,
-0.0734885857,
-0.3994974196,
-0.495072335,
-0.2367494404,
0.3399695754,
-0.3486424983,
0.2624061406,
0.0230166577,
0.7744961381,
0.1098346338,
-0.5777133107,
-0.5568668842,
-0.7135663629,
0.4541630745,
-1.1973638535,
-0.1805794984,
0.4222588241,
0.4797210097,
0.1056533456,
-0.979390204,
-0.1549216658,
-0.0801474229,
-0.24288854,
0.4984010458,
0.0941864997,
0.2781765461,
-0.1595505476,
0.3851423562,
-0.2253772318,
0.3637832403,
-0.739607811,
-0.0477235578,
0.7688308954,
0.5284466147,
0.2495905608,
-0.1403677464,
-0.174657166,
-0.0779004246,
-0.3578139246,
-0.0275474191,
0.0516786538,
0.3591310084,
-0.5953994393,
0.4528262615,
-0.3589500487,
0.5172512531,
0.1208662242,
-0.4569114745,
0.2391667813,
-0.5856528282,
-0.1427738667,
0.2064804882,
0.7192762494,
0.7730135322,
0.1362759471,
-0.0303328484,
0.2238542587,
-0.1244909018,
0.4435071051,
-0.8919942379,
-0.5705661178,
0.7900915742,
-0.5299569368,
-0.6023567915,
-0.1847046614,
-0.5957705975,
-0.3899551034,
-0.531750679,
0.0421615094,
-0.6743846536,
0.1632408351,
0.0604476742,
0.1093047708,
-0.285480082,
0.7753374577,
-0.6824088097,
0.4404630065,
0.7222374082,
0.830306828,
0.0376590043,
-0.1101039946,
-0.4867202342,
0.1759793758,
-0.2313221246,
1.0519875288,
-0.2422634959,
-0.1547125876,
-0.3556703627,
-0.3039799035,
-0.3496826291,
-0.5449525714,
0.6523462534,
-0.0559257306,
0.5233964324,
0.2240590006,
-0.8057600856,
-0.138144657,
0.2788182497,
-0.4573151171,
0.3238953054,
-0.0243124049,
-0.7910906076,
0.2423755229,
-0.7320508957,
-0.4703152776,
-0.1065536663,
-0.0211072024,
-0.9397960305,
-0.0210101064,
0.6029993892,
0.4655932486,
0.0938994512,
0.1409782171,
-0.0946132243,
-0.3440343142,
0.1884278357,
-0.1170384064,
0.5611196756,
0.4012232721,
-0.0219458304,
0.2245741785,
-0.9563610554,
0.2330935597,
-0.1719061285,
-0.2034418732,
-0.0950967818,
-0.0526333116,
0.1535893977,
0.1309890598,
-0.0671079829,
-0.3393977284,
0.0439171419,
-0.653875351,
0.3597614169,
0.3824231625,
0.3792901933,
0.4345526993,
-0.6997771263,
0.4751775861,
0.4161839485,
0.2379974425,
-0.580375433,
-0.6912113428,
-0.5905157328,
-0.6215322614,
0.4282478988,
0.582151413,
-0.376930505,
0.1936164051,
-0.1443990469,
-0.9213048816,
-0.6778590083,
-0.0764841139,
0.5735135078,
0.7713606954,
0.4089356959,
-0.3963845372,
-0.7630079389,
-0.958945334,
-0.2077400982,
-0.0914546028,
0.0739352405,
0.1456774175,
0.2304046303,
-0.0745217204,
0.4918665886,
-0.4460684955,
-0.4346641004,
-0.4984669387,
0.3636617959,
0.1855046153,
0.7174345851,
0.5494417548,
-0.2887974679,
-0.7397279143,
0.0063409335,
-0.6163498163,
-0.0833468437,
-0.1678816676,
-0.1922759563,
-0.0016281902,
0.4756325483,
-0.578219831,
0.5433425903,
0.4830978811,
-0.1026374623,
0.1887534559,
-0.5012510419,
0.4619304836,
-1.3928624392,
-0.0538692661,
-0.1857901067,
-0.2972326875,
-1.0546776056,
0.2252104282,
0.0713151395,
-0.0408535749,
-0.1406665742,
0.1320752352,
-0.3972645104,
0.4935168326,
-0.4604744613,
0.3745651841,
0.1402778924,
0.4858316481,
-0.3856731355,
0.4283680022,
0.2511295378,
-0.5931286812,
-0.1320940256,
0.489546746,
-0.1485492587,
0.7666465044,
-0.7453791499,
0.3360265493,
-0.2631970346,
0.3190534711,
-1.2108564377,
-0.2867860198,
0.1466849148,
-0.5239542723,
0.5578270555,
-0.023341313,
-0.2284639031,
-0.18096596,
-0.4763212204,
0.2553790212,
0.307621628,
0.0882075876,
0.334766835,
0.6594820619,
-0.4699878991,
-0.1238378882,
-0.6878277063,
0.277646482,
-0.2205318213,
-0.767988801,
0.3160720766,
-0.1405330002,
-0.2439785451,
-0.4460904896,
0.0503488667,
-0.1272431314,
0.0329741761,
0.1913189888,
0.2069763839,
-0.4295164347,
0.0859478563,
0.277420342,
-0.2401465476,
-0.1681663394,
0.2504543066,
0.5444629192,
0.0340107828,
-0.4421906471,
-0.7476071715,
0.5253512859,
0.7039097548,
-0.154562518,
0.806278348,
0.3733987808,
-0.2752928138,
0.2060801536,
-0.4130482972,
-0.1977285594,
-0.4084440768,
0.4076890647,
-0.0057476568,
-0.580105722,
0.7925773263,
0.110265471,
0.2613995969,
0.4790996909,
0.5897132754,
-0.6727015376,
1.2502048016,
0.3035637736,
0.0390707329,
0.131793201,
-0.2315044105,
0.4488549829,
-0.7546408176,
-0.1392838657,
-0.7444733977,
-0.4497861266,
-0.6071550846,
-0.1371711195,
0.8719863296,
-0.0184629001,
0.0682442412,
-0.0182019621,
-0.4511974454,
0.3702813089,
0.4028737247,
0.5537216067,
0.5388523936,
-0.0343126692,
0.1456035078,
-0.2597541511,
-0.7484706044,
-0.5344543457,
1.0669877529,
0.3516115248,
0.7054063082,
0.0275771841,
0.6445788741,
-0.0944457352,
0.2932989597,
-0.4963128269,
0.233793065,
-0.2836913764,
-0.2079657018,
-0.3407658339,
-0.3026375473,
-1.0604294538,
0.343130827,
-0.3537828028,
-0.5920805931,
-0.1987301409,
0.3433741033,
-0.4613774419,
0.0543168224,
-0.9205887318,
0.7868061066,
0.0757423565,
0.0825277865,
-0.3642241359,
-0.9004380703,
0.4988396168,
0.1165215373,
0.3876755238,
-0.1382945627,
0.2825087011,
0.5479912162,
-0.776478827,
0.9073287845,
0.0905524045,
-0.0189809836,
0.1965956688,
-0.0064278725,
0.4592730105,
0.01782717,
0.156569466,
-0.1631550789,
0.0287738144,
-0.5683636069,
-0.4256120324,
0.334825784,
-0.6114720106,
-0.2765257061,
-0.0606895946,
-0.8675751686,
-0.3965134323,
0.0266897622,
0.3444809318,
1.1018069983,
-0.0472416133,
0.1565818936,
0.3237304091,
-0.1656722128,
0.0860939547,
0.5352051258,
-0.0651712865,
-0.467885226,
0.4995435476,
0.1621035188,
0.5104054809,
0.3033599854,
0.1995591074,
0.1442207843,
-0.9227522612,
-0.3537421227,
0.3122186065,
-0.7653412819,
-0.2905387282,
-0.9728335142,
-0.4367224872,
-0.6372682452,
0.0269030035,
-0.3083575666,
-0.7782062888,
-0.1407897472,
-0.1385399401,
0.4650563896,
0.7369562387,
0.2390439808,
0.5067014694,
-1.0874952078,
0.2885091901,
-0.0600147173,
0.1258991212,
0.0577437617,
-0.5172041655,
-0.6065875888,
0.2874286175,
-0.5238419175,
-0.4883761406,
0.3604471385,
0.3296903372,
0.4041372538,
0.2087780237,
0.0289171785,
1.0299105644,
-0.3713024259,
0.5822537541,
0.1927232593,
-0.6208484173,
0.6716871858,
-0.4309037328,
0.8242653012,
0.799013555,
-0.1505929232,
-0.4188689888,
-1.3085089922,
-0.7054851055,
-0.8376839161,
0.7562584281,
0.3350585997,
-0.0133259306,
0.2465429008,
0.0936970711,
0.1815154999,
0.1782299429,
-0.022963997,
-0.3724714518,
0.1021241322,
-0.6700908542,
-0.1768470407,
-0.2803311944,
-0.2938379645,
-0.3580645025,
0.5064831972,
-0.2039828897,
-0.0529349595,
0.2376277149,
-0.0587698035,
-0.2971429527,
0.2002955526,
1.1463015079,
0.9886760712,
-0.3871770501,
0.090784438,
0.0251900479,
-0.9565429091,
-0.3577750027,
-0.0162184294,
-0.1820677817,
0.0466109253,
0.7497643828,
0.8668679595,
0.4565471113,
-0.5376039147,
0.3211731911,
-0.3251734674,
-0.234810859,
0.0288691875,
-0.02116042,
0.2370488197,
0.1552912742,
0.0733238086,
0.6270623803,
0.3936841488,
-0.5061684251,
0.2414612323,
0.0877346098,
-0.318097204,
-0.2390438467,
0.8062285185,
0.1662462652,
-0.2004359215,
0.5268253088,
0.3433241546,
-0.294727385,
0.7160756588,
0.3913456202,
0.6285355091,
-0.1230096966,
0.2616952658,
0.4470288455,
0.1778990626,
0.2702608705,
0.1122459993,
0.2236931324,
-0.500594914,
-0.5812585354,
0.0611235313,
-0.7886922359,
-0.0367609076,
-0.5640957952,
0.176449284,
-0.2574703395,
-0.0889086723,
0.2492057979,
-0.0456298217,
-0.3756662905,
0.2331150025,
-0.0721808225,
0.7207803726,
-0.3739225864,
0.4760619402,
0.437182039,
-0.3389500976,
-1.0317226648,
-0.2433494627,
0.00511993,
-0.6931342483,
-0.1068779752,
0.0965906605,
0.1648353338,
-0.3442140818,
-0.5801121593,
-0.6831653118,
1.0488417149,
0.2416193336,
-0.5109049082,
0.1260361373,
0.2117076963,
0.9635176659,
-0.4788003266,
0.5087067485,
0.4611652195,
0.085734807,
0.1807257831,
-1.2777218819,
-0.1853376776,
-0.3898574114,
-0.3624955118,
-0.0275021847,
-0.6264644861,
0.9350850582,
-0.4682637155,
-0.1677499563,
0.2243629843,
0.3517623544,
0.3820582628,
0.6869747043,
0.1727211773,
0.5004137754,
0.866907537,
0.1068134755,
1.200887084,
-0.5018358827,
0.1779535264,
1.5481888056,
-0.2057718188,
0.5557517409,
0.2562709749,
-0.0510432273,
0.4244131744,
0.3629942834,
0.4242218137,
0.4895437062,
-0.1543616056,
0.1970490664,
0.1974117011,
0.1715975404,
-0.4596480429,
0.5554760098,
0.3145402074,
-0.4931321144,
-0.2768903673,
-0.0462648347,
0.3233157098,
0.1885837764,
-0.2949054241,
1.0960688591,
0.2627129555,
-0.8459812999,
0.5913894773,
-0.1186112165,
0.2058371603,
-0.3727810979,
-0.034054704,
-0.3982548714,
0.431571871,
-0.2551397681,
-0.4354359508,
0.2647651136,
-0.1401347667,
-0.0112523269,
-0.002300431,
0.6307907701,
-0.6991969943,
-0.6364002824,
-0.2830881178,
0.6565334797,
0.1246687248,
0.1768112183,
-0.5438790321,
-0.227221787,
-0.1560616493,
-0.071189262,
0.3051196337,
0.525524199,
0.0431414209,
0.6758775115,
0.4133555889,
0.1592497379,
0.0211452413,
0.6780164838,
0.6327593327,
-0.3134616911,
-0.8196855783,
-0.7808290124,
0.6946153641,
-0.3092689216,
-0.3805611134,
0.6702722311,
0.6388947368,
0.3714656532,
-0.0967182592,
0.4752284288,
0.3482218683,
1.0660789013,
-0.6476637125,
0.9636544585,
-0.2598261535,
0.3297713995,
-0.4789005518,
-0.3638863862,
-0.552355051,
0.2606663704,
0.0878439844,
-0.1249659881,
0.8860285282,
0.7156748176,
0.0661921725,
0.4151804745,
0.1429919302,
0.3844918013,
0.4377799928,
0.3797521591,
0.5344362855,
-0.8027071357,
0.2108011842,
-0.5455511212,
-0.0596031621,
-0.1189344972,
-0.5728322864,
-0.7741827369,
-0.4786732197,
-0.516456008,
-0.2927433252,
-0.1171572059,
0.7666503191,
0.7750481963,
-1.119451046,
-0.2238927037,
0.0988746062,
-0.2300272286,
-0.3864358068,
-0.1789064556,
0.4549488127,
-0.4766999781,
-0.6532763243,
0.142257154,
0.4969768524,
0.0943195075,
0.0820163563,
0.0698432028,
-0.1763592809,
0.0075468025,
0.5064758658,
-0.3090136051,
-0.3065384328,
-0.2664692402,
-0.2609757781,
-0.3497128487,
0.5388314724,
0.9254362583,
-0.4238374829,
0.5018476844,
0.4028807878,
0.2941770852,
0.6802535057,
0.1837847233,
0.629956305,
-0.5799190402,
0.0976201221,
0.1667279005,
0.2070709765,
0.2848353982,
-0.3869333565,
0.6402726173,
-0.17538625,
-0.6600901484,
-0.8128755689,
-0.1999191046,
-1.2282452583,
-0.0351387784,
0.4444651306,
0.0867505819,
-0.0427509099,
-0.3111032546,
-0.6066052914,
0.3627995253,
-0.3044615984,
0.9517586231,
0.3787671626,
-0.3868669271,
-0.353880465,
-0.4296768606,
0.4616793394,
0.3112347424,
-1.1059898138,
-0.2503800988,
0.2731927633,
0.1484781951,
0.2345800996,
1.0054787397,
-0.241579935,
0.4376457334,
-0.14045766,
-0.4253605008,
-0.0345072821,
-0.1182452962,
-0.1317462176,
0.2967368662,
-0.0316410102,
-0.2219552994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04314v1 | Cross-Genre Argument Mining: Can Language Models Automatically Fill in Missing Discourse Markers? | 2023-06-07T10:19:50 | 2023-06-07T10:19:50 | Gil Rocha, Henrique Lopes Cardoso, Jonas Belouadi, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Available corpora for Argument Mining differ along several axes, and one of
the key differences is the presence (or absence) of discourse markers to signal
argumentative content. Exploring effective ways to use discourse markers has
received wide attention in various discourse parsing tasks, from which it is
well-known that discourse markers are strong indicators of discourse relations.
To improve the robustness of Argument Mining systems across different genres,
we propose to automatically augment a given text with discourse markers such
that all relations are explicitly signaled. Our analysis unveils that popular
language models taken out-of-the-box fail on this task; however, when
fine-tuned on a new heterogeneous dataset that we construct (including
synthetic and real examples), they perform considerably better. We demonstrate
the impact of our approach on an Argument Mining downstream task, evaluated on
different corpora, showing that language models can be trained to automatically
fill in discourse markers across different corpora, improving the performance
of a downstream model in some, but not all, cases. Our proposed approach can
further be employed as an assistive tool for better discourse understanding. | [
-0.2285529524,
-0.4661211669,
0.8070274591,
-0.0300327465,
-0.4943033457,
0.1511751413,
-0.1530195922,
-0.5613183975,
0.3111133277,
0.3898507059,
-0.5056602359,
-0.7394188046,
-0.7996792197,
0.2551741004,
-0.1841771305,
1.0644068718,
0.088677071,
0.0475357585,
-0.231548816,
-0.3507239819,
-0.6841424704,
-0.5629433393,
-0.572629571,
-0.3074098229,
0.55044806,
0.2581146657,
0.6037575603,
0.9366679192,
0.0299994852,
0.3576666713,
-0.0227905326,
0.3332178593,
-0.1600693315,
0.483528614,
-0.3074473441,
-0.3339779079,
-0.5810958147,
-0.0558268726,
0.3598120511,
0.9615302086,
0.2939828336,
0.0399814211,
-0.0535553843,
-0.1883927286,
-0.6933374405,
0.2093373239,
-1.0138188601,
0.1553701907,
-0.4038150311,
-0.4497579336,
-0.448059231,
-0.3685733974,
0.1718539596,
-0.5488348007,
0.2161075026,
0.1280462891,
1.0404570103,
0.1294797063,
-0.230858773,
-0.4348399043,
-0.7302837968,
0.5745446682,
-0.7481634617,
0.0542795323,
0.3925306499,
0.016985435,
-0.0206612293,
-0.6228576303,
-0.1074961498,
0.0230260547,
-0.365188539,
0.1091080979,
-0.3555546701,
0.0563975275,
0.3161909282,
0.3671685755,
-0.0741704553,
0.1563098282,
-0.1828751713,
-0.3234053254,
0.3751318753,
0.2023209631,
0.3026334643,
-0.3299663067,
-0.1638457328,
0.1377002597,
-0.8146162033,
0.088028647,
0.704867065,
0.5246989727,
0.0007613985,
0.4241740704,
0.1152290255,
0.9523233175,
0.3218246102,
0.0348638184,
-0.1056037694,
-0.1635596156,
-0.0607192293,
0.234815225,
0.8072304726,
0.0572325699,
0.034982603,
-0.0336800255,
0.1420854926,
-0.0288298428,
0.0455844365,
-0.4926255047,
-0.6037530303,
0.2461019605,
-0.3222499192,
-0.0469569974,
-0.1389630437,
-0.6705932617,
-0.5615423322,
-0.3172132671,
0.0789277107,
-0.5151495934,
-0.2472973317,
-0.0394924283,
-0.2953980267,
-0.0833557397,
0.2129977196,
-0.935454309,
0.1261606514,
1.0006394386,
0.9001039863,
-0.0636291951,
-0.0161210708,
-1.0809509754,
0.1908674389,
-0.4093178213,
1.4298943281,
-1.3011324406,
-0.3852061927,
0.3007979691,
0.0537122339,
-0.0536078624,
-0.6032338738,
1.0376629829,
-0.1698267013,
0.5384652615,
-0.3467102647,
-0.7726912498,
-0.1604384184,
0.1160898358,
-0.7351514697,
1.1761569977,
0.1345537156,
-0.724842608,
0.692099154,
-0.4609847665,
-0.4934025109,
0.3006359339,
-0.1463896334,
-0.3819514215,
-0.0040342347,
0.17192702,
0.5497707725,
-0.401044637,
0.4746422768,
-0.5861427188,
-0.4160004258,
-0.0126727624,
-0.081741102,
0.9667261243,
-0.1105616018,
-0.2108249962,
0.2034041882,
-0.7171241045,
-0.1170986369,
-0.3903610408,
-0.1070988104,
-0.8075991273,
0.2225278616,
-0.0316781886,
0.2154953182,
0.0060715084,
-0.4473593533,
-0.0076295612,
-0.635232091,
0.2032761425,
0.6110498905,
0.1879343092,
0.2088285983,
-0.1586609334,
0.6019424796,
0.0209923293,
-0.4622531235,
-0.436668098,
-0.7294797897,
-0.9376469851,
-0.6373409629,
0.7398402095,
0.5864942074,
-0.2915905416,
0.7720018029,
-0.260466367,
-0.426646173,
-0.9133114219,
-0.0138007533,
0.2011317909,
0.5484011769,
0.4717737436,
-0.3134612441,
-1.1013991833,
-0.8413361907,
-0.4744299948,
-0.4703555703,
-0.0372757167,
0.2399197817,
0.1810006052,
0.1973457038,
1.1480805874,
-0.4271711111,
-0.081115149,
-0.1958788335,
0.5258636475,
-0.0600476824,
0.3011825979,
0.3618099689,
-0.3924489319,
-0.5700945854,
0.206189543,
-0.6138830781,
-0.5478707552,
-0.2780170143,
-0.0798808262,
0.0553432368,
0.4646551311,
-0.1937245727,
0.1866421103,
0.2707762122,
-0.2647413015,
0.4372951388,
-0.011865858,
0.0797821283,
-1.0579594374,
-0.0042777481,
0.1262425929,
-0.3434095085,
-0.6647788882,
-0.361394316,
-0.3035602868,
0.0777760893,
-0.2591796517,
0.3810825646,
-0.4128013253,
0.2000778615,
-0.4081082642,
0.031028064,
0.0329917707,
0.3266827464,
0.4576813877,
0.4599084556,
0.606828928,
-0.2745661438,
0.1205751523,
0.0785603002,
-0.0488954671,
0.8955963254,
-0.4562734962,
0.0164632518,
-0.0044298796,
0.2388424426,
-0.9682756662,
-0.2080729157,
0.4842137694,
-0.1246573403,
0.1106062531,
-0.8419086933,
-0.089060463,
0.1865703017,
-0.2075690478,
0.1284561455,
0.2773583233,
-0.4436114132,
0.7143629789,
0.6785206795,
-0.4758871794,
-0.5260095596,
-0.2124736905,
0.3225320876,
-0.670412004,
-0.3835381567,
0.4950658381,
0.1903350651,
-0.2532474697,
0.1155356318,
0.3427279294,
-0.2063446641,
0.0068517737,
0.5302580595,
0.3802149296,
-0.2534784377,
0.3086493313,
0.2325624526,
-0.1470741183,
0.1537092924,
-0.2631075978,
0.4489472508,
0.0605522208,
-0.3326964974,
-0.1555578411,
0.8452936411,
0.2006677985,
-0.1489195228,
0.4969392419,
0.3816367984,
-0.4529908299,
-0.1443807036,
-0.4675166607,
-0.0343538001,
-0.4364752471,
0.0889924243,
-0.4490969479,
-0.8889960647,
0.5474117398,
-0.3295331895,
0.2314349264,
0.644154489,
0.7030966878,
0.070924148,
0.9419384599,
0.5034347177,
-0.0732436404,
0.1841403097,
0.2299287468,
0.4945200384,
-0.62173599,
0.0413574725,
-0.7402606606,
0.0198410526,
-0.8459861875,
-0.4519097805,
0.0650631264,
-0.3090972304,
0.061665643,
0.5325645208,
-0.3663989305,
0.4251777828,
0.2065306455,
-0.4689548612,
0.574121058,
0.0865731984,
-0.2737613022,
-0.3512189984,
-0.9401608109,
-0.7544375658,
0.751347363,
0.3292537034,
0.1676407456,
-0.3018864393,
0.613202095,
0.2097459584,
0.6562297344,
-0.7336410284,
0.4143452346,
-0.2698835731,
-0.6751173735,
0.1601794809,
-0.2373212725,
-0.9238205552,
0.3137573004,
-0.5009197593,
-0.7520790696,
0.4963208735,
0.1833585799,
-0.5366149545,
0.4548790753,
-0.6402355433,
0.9190670252,
0.1132564247,
-0.4332115352,
0.1740420014,
-0.3660119772,
0.3891132474,
-0.0197439436,
0.2375649065,
-0.2202184051,
0.1337792426,
0.6487351656,
-0.4549027979,
0.874378562,
-0.1465546191,
-0.43817541,
0.4812802374,
-0.0443495549,
0.2579515278,
-0.0465449654,
-0.2536215484,
0.1114501506,
-0.124767594,
-0.0321137905,
-0.4881215096,
0.7022078633,
-0.2874535024,
-0.7913571596,
-0.5161990523,
-0.5348123312,
-0.3130111098,
-0.1859315783,
0.3133767247,
0.3930836618,
-0.1940172166,
-0.0220341329,
0.4582137465,
0.0271799751,
0.3613536358,
0.282699883,
0.3322776556,
-0.229033336,
0.999933064,
0.0628676936,
-0.139955461,
0.0435878411,
0.1960228831,
-0.4131909311,
-0.3520733714,
-0.6289970875,
0.039451506,
-0.926179409,
-0.354193598,
-1.0956457853,
0.1200332195,
-0.257599324,
-0.0938001573,
-0.187055558,
-0.582608819,
-0.214819327,
-0.1684480608,
0.4841219485,
0.3378927708,
-0.1137880683,
0.1660557687,
-0.7178738713,
0.0493225791,
0.1069768369,
0.346198529,
-0.09468624,
-0.5150455236,
-0.130082503,
-0.1018831208,
-0.1324111223,
-1.0687296391,
0.251539737,
0.3865546584,
0.2521494031,
0.3415756822,
-0.0007281054,
0.964966774,
-0.7185832262,
0.6950892806,
0.0511863418,
-1.0119792223,
0.4373859465,
-0.5428616405,
0.127422452,
0.5958086848,
0.5446730852,
-0.5869550705,
-0.8012381196,
-0.6910815239,
-0.9332653284,
0.5427701473,
-0.0697807968,
0.0370215029,
-0.0904506445,
0.0442564823,
0.5066428185,
-0.0572837256,
-0.961281836,
-0.0222846698,
-0.1567988247,
-0.4479307234,
0.3383265138,
0.0786608905,
-0.376752466,
-0.2450799644,
0.7666791677,
-0.2121516019,
-0.0116485162,
-0.0151276393,
0.0178177916,
-0.1790951937,
0.4118065238,
0.0811227113,
0.4618653357,
-0.0151598062,
0.2519398034,
0.2713336647,
-0.1462669522,
0.1691293865,
0.4346218109,
-0.3995001614,
0.4276562035,
0.4574446082,
0.9062235951,
0.174577564,
-0.5373575091,
0.1139646471,
0.1359451115,
0.0089814411,
-0.2472433448,
0.0720558763,
0.2878714502,
0.0064721359,
0.2437265515,
0.0719665587,
0.3195081353,
-0.8898314238,
0.0978524908,
0.5876258612,
-0.5062289238,
-0.1882068068,
0.4718021154,
0.046193257,
-0.3833124638,
-0.12182042,
-0.2250560522,
-0.6927981377,
0.2100892961,
0.503962934,
0.8990520835,
-0.0489428304,
0.3326182067,
0.3486060798,
0.0754667073,
0.1426119357,
-0.0342890397,
-0.0302170087,
-0.4512364268,
-0.7659294009,
-0.396674484,
-0.5904852152,
0.0901081786,
-0.2683440149,
0.3571899235,
-0.3380820453,
-0.1465268433,
0.382168442,
-0.0486933514,
-0.3289130032,
0.2691333592,
0.1668217778,
0.2993522882,
-1.1220514774,
0.6932033896,
0.8298374414,
-0.1848382354,
-0.5651449561,
0.0444511697,
-0.1560165882,
-0.1168652922,
0.4038279653,
-0.0133273518,
-0.4995847046,
-0.3874412179,
-0.3316061795,
-0.5270950794,
0.4564964473,
0.3809979558,
-0.1569173783,
0.3521744013,
0.3343749046,
0.8169970512,
-0.8639274836,
0.4262938499,
0.6235688925,
0.5118514299,
0.0302289948,
-0.4592033625,
0.3506221175,
-0.3136819899,
-0.2179917544,
0.2854170799,
-0.1587799489,
0.8189762235,
0.2700356245,
-0.2741363347,
-0.0756998658,
0.8825867176,
0.2987480164,
0.4297612011,
0.8244130015,
0.5016055107,
0.9805628657,
-0.2404946536,
0.6720898747,
-0.2090337574,
0.0491255,
1.4043943882,
-0.6695312858,
0.7031987906,
0.2063213736,
0.1519166231,
1.0905294418,
0.7871686816,
-0.2388561368,
0.0564834103,
-0.0397721194,
-0.5270344615,
-0.7393154502,
-0.5356081128,
-0.313040942,
0.5500424504,
0.5058377981,
-0.3308493793,
-0.2584394217,
-0.3327483833,
0.39603737,
0.4228690863,
0.0335512869,
0.5994691849,
-0.0945746079,
-1.2147749662,
0.4962821007,
0.2066090405,
0.4547709525,
-0.4334932566,
-0.2906033993,
-0.1433074027,
-0.1907268167,
-0.2943613827,
-0.5387655497,
0.3650313318,
0.4948894978,
-0.0406590849,
-0.0671797395,
1.035332799,
-0.7474507093,
-0.6790393591,
0.3685027361,
0.6218385696,
0.0436820276,
0.2955000699,
-0.4286259711,
-0.0991497487,
-0.1245783344,
0.29910326,
0.1759488136,
0.5847100616,
-0.2442792952,
0.3551066518,
0.6629362106,
0.1869772673,
-0.0881082937,
-0.0345954597,
0.8638802171,
-0.4094162583,
-0.4825946093,
-0.9399399161,
0.55616045,
-0.5946485996,
-0.42138502,
0.8657053709,
0.6130591631,
0.4743407071,
0.039638482,
0.8319429159,
-0.1002668962,
0.7122542858,
-0.3475874662,
0.3970931768,
-0.3250933886,
0.2514882982,
-0.4737639427,
-0.833771646,
-0.4623033106,
0.5473053455,
-0.4490551054,
-0.2256350964,
0.7223098874,
0.6386495829,
-0.3564012945,
0.3569867015,
-0.0089648692,
-0.1183211952,
0.2523664534,
0.4785366654,
0.8082890511,
-0.3595995009,
0.5750905275,
-0.0215227474,
-0.0671973899,
0.0114648659,
-1.1839692593,
-0.85139364,
-0.6791530848,
-0.8066499829,
-0.2381533086,
0.1044603065,
1.0366585255,
0.5699757934,
-0.9509851933,
-0.3785201609,
0.1963784248,
0.2368150055,
-0.1606810242,
-0.1617243141,
0.3216279447,
-0.4063490033,
-0.8630715013,
0.6057420969,
0.3535912931,
-0.3491252065,
-0.1257697791,
0.219715938,
-0.6884775162,
0.3713736534,
0.4093906879,
0.3917193711,
-0.5527555346,
-0.4909562171,
-0.2775430083,
0.3233305514,
0.5654465556,
1.1696304083,
-0.8368761539,
0.4511501193,
0.3542028368,
0.5259885192,
0.2462159693,
0.1649148166,
0.7446827888,
-0.9768782854,
0.2583041489,
0.330308497,
0.6983154416,
0.7339096069,
-0.2114908248,
0.3910267949,
0.2085238844,
-0.1613031775,
-0.9018067718,
0.2919391692,
-0.6995941997,
-0.2466851175,
1.0143733025,
-0.5347968936,
0.0281268619,
-0.6717133522,
-0.286920011,
0.3294501901,
-0.328843236,
0.7837175727,
1.0250959396,
0.0327464491,
-0.0051019401,
-0.2461098582,
0.8476472497,
0.7519776225,
-0.9406121969,
0.3505278528,
0.8134139776,
0.1429511458,
0.3816138208,
0.5456112623,
-0.0320842825,
0.1968614906,
-0.185817793,
-0.3760354817,
0.3553913236,
-0.2898887992,
-0.2640261948,
0.7621850371,
-0.0549856238,
0.2035740912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04308v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04308v2 | Personality testing of GPT-3: Limited temporal reliability, but highlighted social desirability of GPT-3's personality instruments results | 2023-06-07T10:14:17 | 2023-12-15T06:26:05 | Bojana Bodroza, Bojana M. Dinic, Ljubisa Bojic | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | As AI-bots continue to gain popularity due to their human-like traits and the
intimacy they offer to users, their societal impact inevitably expands. This
leads to the rising necessity for comprehensive studies to fully understand
AI-bots and reveal their potential opportunities, drawbacks, and overall
societal impact. With that in mind, this research conducted an extensive
investigation into ChatGPT3, a renowned AI bot, aiming to assess the temporal
reliability of its personality profile. Psychological questionnaires were
administered to the chatbot on two separate occasions, followed by a comparison
of the responses to human normative data. The findings revealed varying levels
of agreement in chatbot's responses over time, with some scales displaying
excellent agreement while others demonstrated poor agreement. Overall,
Davinci-003 displayed a socially desirable and pro-social personality profile,
particularly in the domain of communion. However, the underlying basis of the
chatbot's responses-whether driven by conscious self reflection or
predetermined algorithms-remains uncertain. | [
-0.5119994283,
-1.0654343367,
0.9254945517,
0.472109586,
-0.1938005388,
0.047950279,
0.1018357426,
-0.5790358782,
0.0285215247,
0.0609805398,
-0.4897218049,
0.1202135608,
-0.8197647929,
0.2663722932,
-0.4047805369,
1.1115247011,
0.0823776424,
0.0695751086,
0.2898860872,
0.0089041647,
-0.361585319,
-0.5429090858,
-0.8083563447,
-0.2587032616,
0.7895746231,
0.3416487277,
1.0314253569,
0.1804080755,
0.7361750603,
0.2813642919,
0.0284207985,
-0.5106176734,
-0.3664115667,
0.099941127,
-0.0043972251,
-0.2640659511,
-0.7963997722,
0.3757879734,
0.5376906395,
0.2833601832,
0.1352817416,
0.2870856822,
0.2990756929,
0.7560236454,
-0.2638966143,
0.4242069125,
-0.3654844165,
-0.0646058246,
-0.5484918952,
0.0062326598,
-0.1990141422,
-0.5865601301,
0.453496784,
-0.2571705878,
0.2923818529,
-0.2238638401,
0.6398932934,
0.2863124311,
-0.4707680941,
-0.1319769472,
-1.0534484386,
0.6147834659,
-0.4283914268,
-0.0713407174,
0.4562675953,
0.5292387009,
0.0252862759,
-0.3455683291,
-1.0111992359,
-0.6083324552,
-0.1118626371,
0.2946541011,
0.0745326504,
-0.1277654618,
0.1692828238,
0.3659003079,
-0.6428318024,
-0.035978701,
-0.2546691,
0.0802564323,
0.6021856666,
0.1717901826,
0.4298873544,
-0.070762001,
0.0002634505,
-0.19280909,
-0.4124843776,
-0.1393017173,
0.7698432803,
-0.2036865503,
-0.1224170923,
0.5909571648,
-0.0780625343,
0.4021155238,
0.0222201739,
-0.0461272709,
0.1190007254,
-0.2098052055,
0.1995896548,
-0.1554991007,
0.8850483894,
0.480030328,
0.6662037373,
0.2055393159,
0.2590492666,
0.160534516,
0.519423902,
-0.6389049888,
-0.4237840474,
0.58846277,
-0.3683201671,
-0.1851855367,
0.1427456886,
-0.6464102268,
-0.367580235,
0.0308124889,
0.1945456862,
-0.5954867601,
-0.3628690541,
-0.1888276488,
-0.311337322,
0.3783275783,
0.6400597095,
-0.9884779453,
0.0125769274,
0.6291435957,
1.1806625128,
-0.4411302805,
-0.3337262869,
-0.2515660822,
-0.0253309906,
-0.2718188465,
0.6335994005,
-0.5473005176,
-0.5175486207,
-0.4783583283,
0.127359435,
0.1875731796,
-0.1414991766,
0.128295809,
-0.4377001226,
0.2617747784,
-0.2712777853,
-0.2719997466,
0.0876096189,
0.3245423436,
-0.6483140588,
0.6931779981,
0.4693777561,
-0.5670900345,
0.5706315041,
-0.9739643335,
-0.1765113175,
0.2992084324,
-0.370826453,
-0.3825980425,
-0.2371750474,
-0.1694163084,
0.6704853177,
0.0201876741,
0.0681573823,
-0.826996088,
-0.5883693695,
0.5196482539,
-0.6104509234,
0.7330809236,
0.1310518533,
-0.7731696963,
-0.2311621159,
-0.4717552662,
-0.2369106263,
0.3801040947,
0.1193319708,
0.0734823048,
0.2593933046,
-0.1810018271,
0.0838271901,
0.2166874111,
-0.9122574329,
0.2888403237,
-0.0671708211,
0.5412375331,
0.8793660998,
0.1550923437,
0.0692099482,
-0.5992708206,
0.4326152503,
-0.1659619659,
0.5124862194,
0.5198931098,
-1.0155975819,
-0.5032981634,
-0.2348715365,
-0.2153918147,
0.6756555438,
-0.4351759851,
0.4633566737,
-0.293133229,
-0.7724650502,
-0.1256071478,
-0.0343472175,
0.2758917511,
0.199580431,
0.1731355637,
-0.4627885222,
-0.0141266994,
-0.9302113652,
-0.3104015291,
-0.6379802227,
-0.2620458007,
0.5111524463,
0.9254665971,
-0.2277100384,
0.7586263418,
-0.4660270214,
-0.2453662157,
-0.2353424728,
0.0161882993,
0.1782598346,
0.4659405053,
0.6290354133,
-0.8736160398,
-0.6323488951,
-0.1363209486,
-0.4553513527,
0.3001544178,
0.081378147,
0.1557026356,
0.0964934155,
-0.1651989073,
-0.3076183498,
0.7448526621,
0.4429273307,
-0.3360516131,
0.6112447381,
0.0118855378,
0.6640805602,
-0.6000025868,
-0.0073525794,
-0.1581858099,
0.0624002218,
-0.4728957713,
-0.4518946111,
-0.1073669642,
0.0202660095,
-0.4080801308,
0.7943978906,
0.0028447339,
-0.1393221617,
-0.0628390163,
0.3065101802,
-0.3384635448,
0.4773106873,
0.0009610694,
0.9439223409,
0.265923202,
-0.5578736663,
0.3724917769,
0.3357456326,
-0.1643493623,
0.8257526755,
-0.9601774812,
0.4975509048,
0.1147661433,
0.218034178,
-1.1759828329,
-0.6900734305,
0.444532007,
-0.7748833895,
-0.1722684503,
-0.0596318468,
-0.5657538772,
-0.3777184784,
-0.1128719822,
0.3039044738,
0.6306201816,
-0.110953629,
0.4175746143,
0.2547678053,
-0.4144739807,
-0.1435321569,
-0.7042165995,
-0.1006018966,
-0.2735438645,
-0.6226701736,
0.2558597922,
-0.2297141254,
-0.5954232812,
-0.2249741852,
0.0658794865,
-0.0293101724,
0.4203019738,
0.2977850139,
0.2366477549,
0.2532862723,
-0.2419595271,
-0.3703089356,
-0.1141005978,
0.0038636089,
0.3210515082,
0.5858978033,
-0.7624350786,
-0.6924598217,
-0.7256680131,
0.3047798276,
0.7034364343,
0.1144560501,
0.7305648327,
0.7185666561,
-0.0321634151,
0.5268224478,
-0.563534081,
-0.1436549425,
-0.4871160686,
0.1873781085,
-0.3071644306,
-1.016240716,
0.6205937266,
0.5812138915,
-0.0900283307,
0.6240852475,
0.766313076,
-0.262786597,
1.1773767471,
0.1105514392,
0.0547088459,
0.6553320289,
0.0526592508,
0.0393259451,
-0.6900019646,
-0.040464703,
-0.3068525791,
-0.4005245268,
-1.0256426334,
0.0929668397,
0.5748957396,
-0.4873503745,
-0.6792350411,
0.1420858949,
-0.6096633077,
0.3887730241,
0.6627141237,
0.3362214863,
0.3362627923,
-0.5585058331,
0.478050977,
0.0296937153,
0.2061749399,
-0.8811571002,
1.0582603216,
0.2392567694,
0.3342318833,
0.7575771809,
0.488587141,
0.5977820158,
0.4316031933,
-0.4315132201,
0.48552531,
0.1308460087,
-1.0840998888,
-0.7027380466,
-0.2447566539,
-0.9154013991,
-0.2498318553,
0.287650615,
-1.2413233519,
-0.0302964766,
0.2142845243,
-0.5753656626,
0.1102110147,
-0.8152092695,
0.6828090549,
-0.3569437563,
-0.4357830882,
-0.0228083991,
-0.951420784,
0.3951910734,
-0.2536793649,
-0.2146163285,
-0.4547646642,
0.0448523313,
0.561249733,
-0.2905269861,
0.8353063464,
-0.2526881397,
0.0123037333,
0.2074114829,
0.3931342065,
0.3893667459,
0.6439965963,
0.0583118461,
0.2891991138,
0.430750668,
-0.7435373068,
-0.8231306076,
0.5248208046,
-1.0822989941,
-0.8507213593,
-0.7942306995,
-0.1948979497,
-0.4319355786,
0.1789389402,
-0.125093773,
0.1481546015,
-0.57510674,
0.2075404078,
0.3096759617,
-0.2840851545,
0.438192904,
0.5193340778,
-0.1235390678,
-0.386166811,
0.5461657047,
-0.0513432398,
0.5368158817,
-0.0141827557,
0.1635505259,
-0.01938775,
-0.2552059293,
-0.402069062,
0.0767935812,
-0.1816115528,
0.5169701576,
-0.6090604663,
-0.1799285561,
-0.4897070825,
-0.1473008245,
-0.5914103985,
-0.236079216,
-0.246421203,
0.1568586528,
0.5459092855,
1.0372898579,
0.1344997138,
0.6127743125,
-0.6713960767,
0.350915432,
0.4474264979,
0.4732494056,
-0.2329820693,
-0.3830449283,
0.3106136322,
0.0052217646,
-0.622905314,
-1.0027122498,
0.1261139214,
0.0311657358,
0.2213191539,
0.5098706484,
-0.2637524605,
0.5294393301,
-0.2742601037,
1.2099585533,
-0.2500601411,
-0.7789042592,
0.7425715923,
-0.8771621585,
0.2016038001,
0.6415669322,
0.4562592804,
-0.5857837796,
-0.4716318548,
-0.9595811963,
-0.395080626,
0.6797451377,
0.8039227128,
0.0955114514,
-0.2533940077,
0.6431071758,
0.2193576247,
0.0737745911,
-0.6780870557,
-0.4868415296,
-0.3677102625,
0.1710601151,
-0.2698280513,
-0.2033255398,
-0.0468804128,
-0.3245347142,
0.3781819642,
0.0105146114,
0.5912995934,
0.3854727149,
0.3544583321,
0.5214212537,
0.2756922245,
0.6157778502,
0.7221639156,
-0.730404079,
-0.1593631506,
-0.1185012683,
-0.9015822411,
0.5596229434,
-0.0121409604,
0.1608174443,
-0.2728241682,
0.3969851136,
0.2899141908,
-0.4484876394,
-0.2326696962,
0.7361765504,
-0.3173346221,
-0.1718589664,
-0.8961423039,
0.3834939599,
-0.1695290357,
0.2262676954,
0.328835547,
0.1003055498,
0.1169838458,
-0.7652565837,
0.2890565693,
0.2393453717,
-0.4694090784,
-0.4056811333,
0.7175706029,
0.1714215577,
-0.4471507668,
0.8381682634,
-0.5810780525,
-0.3249703348,
0.5584180355,
0.1313870549,
1.044768095,
-0.0610614866,
0.417054832,
0.1686768979,
0.2143903524,
-0.142701149,
0.3900672495,
-0.1513786167,
-0.7695242763,
-0.2068621814,
-0.2576582134,
-0.8731316924,
0.042911049,
-0.7061849833,
-0.0310824495,
-0.4441113472,
-0.5477359295,
-0.3147307038,
0.1475065947,
-0.806447804,
0.1051752269,
-0.1254307032,
0.2172436863,
-0.500174284,
0.5504872203,
0.194039464,
-0.438624084,
-0.4876479805,
0.2152020931,
0.4282362163,
-0.9318594337,
0.6484361887,
0.2072758079,
-0.057348527,
0.1712973416,
-0.5156089067,
-0.9096675515,
1.1651402712,
0.2561014891,
-0.466411978,
0.005692564,
0.1003152877,
0.6902137399,
0.0546812415,
0.7307143211,
0.8293793797,
0.6683263779,
0.015031362,
-1.0331032276,
-0.1117596403,
-0.4331892431,
0.0129401768,
0.0782980472,
-1.0355598927,
0.578910172,
-0.1683690995,
-0.2835296988,
0.2061664313,
0.5230052471,
0.3664682508,
0.0594778359,
0.6007031798,
0.1923734993,
0.5609946251,
-0.3569451869,
1.2402718067,
-0.3047037423,
0.1453595161,
1.0728168488,
-0.3588074446,
0.48600775,
0.2940820754,
-0.5410824418,
0.7593669891,
0.8618932962,
-0.1619224399,
0.3367360234,
0.0381019413,
-0.1641846001,
0.0612795055,
0.1652388275,
-0.409250021,
0.6730405092,
0.1977327019,
-0.1526369601,
0.2752179205,
-0.0871399716,
0.1949546486,
-0.5051079392,
0.2171200812,
0.629984796,
-0.1984419376,
-0.7305648327,
-0.0740874559,
-0.5967814922,
0.2904070318,
-0.5512539744,
-0.069056198,
-0.1955315173,
0.3662040234,
0.0485009365,
-1.0123708248,
0.2914327383,
-0.0687827393,
0.2080797255,
-0.3918759525,
0.2861058712,
0.2718205154,
-0.2614291012,
0.1815916449,
0.7727717161,
0.4963265955,
-0.4092368186,
-0.6115652323,
-0.0419398285,
-0.1992984414,
-0.5287804604,
0.2168841958,
0.3145951331,
0.3110429347,
0.8322724104,
0.4440425038,
0.0801040083,
-0.4500484467,
0.0666677505,
0.5270043612,
-0.833982408,
-0.1793006063,
-1.4463355541,
0.3877095878,
-0.1538513899,
-0.5914725065,
1.0025678873,
0.3164517581,
0.7157911062,
0.156571418,
0.7981154919,
-0.4029672742,
0.3816583753,
-0.3122193813,
0.6855499148,
-0.4447728395,
0.124071613,
-0.7299956679,
-0.8440428376,
-0.1647288501,
0.352625221,
-0.5280069113,
0.4674330652,
0.7725054622,
0.5351026654,
0.4999555349,
0.2385850251,
0.2034350783,
0.1236333996,
0.5775014758,
0.4334761202,
1.0531007051,
-0.094980076,
0.2782808244,
-0.2252110243,
-0.5974039435,
-0.0754982233,
-0.7487288713,
-1.0173466206,
-0.7357221842,
-0.2743560672,
-0.4598732293,
0.0827128217,
0.414113611,
0.3097825646,
-0.4164525867,
0.1761161685,
-0.0228705462,
-0.0658247694,
-0.2685731053,
-0.3328363299,
0.2700844407,
0.0354831517,
-0.8029974699,
-0.1285471916,
0.4322142303,
0.4829056561,
-0.5859297514,
0.2132783532,
0.2297758609,
-0.1671403497,
0.3658720851,
0.0597242229,
-0.8169574142,
-0.9189109802,
0.243131876,
-0.0299915839,
0.100237228,
0.5848848224,
-0.3510707021,
0.3023221195,
0.3177151382,
0.110426344,
0.4346678257,
0.0604231246,
0.8031825423,
-0.0932751074,
-0.2025426775,
0.3973544836,
0.295448631,
0.0993117318,
-0.566119194,
0.7447444797,
0.4354197979,
-1.1369566917,
-0.4631541669,
0.2952984869,
-1.0402220488,
0.0232574511,
1.3054718971,
-0.0291748792,
-0.1599527895,
-0.5552568436,
-0.2491057813,
0.1540650874,
-0.5869905353,
1.041226387,
1.0846524239,
-0.7068750262,
0.1615157425,
-0.8997856379,
0.5908814669,
0.2647794783,
-0.5713495612,
-0.0712660104,
0.3287740648,
0.2558058798,
0.2989792824,
0.9890351892,
-0.3403274417,
0.3923233449,
0.0343838558,
-0.1055622473,
0.3564862311,
-0.1688637733,
0.0136428261,
0.0754956827,
0.0529587194,
0.0405074172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04306v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04306v2 | Allophant: Cross-lingual Phoneme Recognition with Articulatory Attributes | 2023-06-07T10:11:09 | 2023-08-16T17:44:59 | Kevin Glocker, Aaricia Herygers, Munir Georges | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7 | This paper proposes Allophant, a multilingual phoneme recognizer. It requires
only a phoneme inventory for cross-lingual transfer to a target language,
allowing for low-resource recognition. The architecture combines a
compositional phone embedding approach with individually supervised phonetic
attribute classifiers in a multi-task architecture. We also introduce
Allophoible, an extension of the PHOIBLE database. When combined with a
distance based mapping approach for grapheme-to-phoneme outputs, it allows us
to train on PHOIBLE inventories directly. By training and evaluating on 34
languages, we found that the addition of multi-task learning improves the
model's capability of being applied to unseen phonemes and phoneme inventories.
On supervised languages we achieve phoneme error rate improvements of 11
percentage points (pp.) compared to a baseline without multi-task learning.
Evaluation of zero-shot transfer on 84 languages yielded a decrease in PER of
2.63 pp. over the baseline. | [
-0.200122267,
-0.3849547803,
0.2653772533,
0.1022230536,
-0.2319927961,
0.066310212,
-0.2763262093,
-0.7983135581,
0.661960423,
0.3611097634,
-0.2701996267,
-0.3492583632,
-0.4419157505,
0.0315160267,
0.000960597,
0.609174192,
-0.023115404,
-0.0671584085,
0.2789935768,
-0.3044957221,
-0.3590416014,
-0.4817315042,
-0.4851152897,
-0.2154838741,
0.4591979384,
0.78320086,
0.3782539964,
0.6745253205,
0.146280691,
0.2597684562,
0.3569444418,
-0.174745515,
-0.075955689,
0.0317719691,
-0.0391315892,
-0.496773839,
-0.6808074713,
0.0415892564,
0.6054298878,
0.7986436486,
-0.1516364366,
0.0347616747,
-0.1121445671,
0.3242881894,
-0.823438704,
0.256110996,
-0.7262379527,
0.3510341346,
-0.5512773395,
-0.3193849325,
-0.1223140433,
-0.0377511866,
0.3988330662,
-0.7090219259,
-0.3617788255,
0.1407844275,
0.440752089,
-0.0850567743,
-0.4640970528,
-0.4129336774,
-0.5162815452,
1.04101336,
-0.2342796326,
0.8186427951,
0.5244899988,
0.1353352219,
0.3078539073,
-0.197412014,
-0.4477554262,
-0.250492543,
0.1411693543,
0.3665108383,
-0.1952925324,
0.1273017973,
-0.1802810729,
0.5384408236,
-0.6707102656,
0.113428019,
-0.409783721,
-0.5573780537,
0.4264923036,
-0.3458975554,
0.4830141962,
-0.5014895201,
-0.4368376434,
-0.0866410807,
-0.3797727525,
0.1784723699,
0.2953686416,
0.5004667044,
-0.0341694653,
0.5012629628,
0.1620865166,
0.4983272254,
0.1371153891,
-0.3664426804,
0.4461041391,
-0.3249116242,
-0.2766665518,
0.4387349486,
0.8574951291,
-0.2126490623,
0.2803196609,
-0.1876322776,
0.0131458957,
-0.3346633613,
-0.1049272716,
-0.6283974648,
-0.494607091,
0.2282425314,
-0.4927607477,
-0.1834576577,
-0.1051942632,
-0.4062050581,
-0.2489077449,
-0.2533060908,
0.3994909227,
-0.8963491917,
-0.7445269823,
-0.0421870239,
0.167393595,
0.152837351,
0.3178041577,
-0.9105783701,
0.1334047467,
0.1972973347,
0.9101148248,
-0.376570642,
-0.717363894,
-0.7683093548,
0.1695140749,
-0.4257081151,
0.8559513092,
-0.4449544847,
-0.3230724335,
-0.2262614071,
0.3265207112,
-0.5802903771,
-0.6371640563,
0.541443646,
0.0370964892,
0.2904644907,
-0.0408871472,
-0.4435977042,
-0.3782501221,
-0.0814774781,
-0.8590567112,
1.0098452568,
0.3133875132,
-0.4503571689,
0.222899884,
-0.7974748015,
-0.7213619947,
0.2949618399,
0.0387976877,
-0.3571464121,
-0.0308443699,
-0.028611403,
0.3952927589,
-0.0828939006,
-0.3381691575,
-0.2282833159,
-0.4862319529,
0.1273685843,
-0.3160176575,
1.147644639,
0.1530912369,
-0.3251539171,
0.01797924,
-1.0649130344,
0.3324202597,
0.0154328952,
-0.6800996661,
-0.3694517016,
-0.600620091,
0.4722593129,
0.3409629166,
0.3610285819,
-0.8407344818,
0.1738619953,
-0.1385931522,
0.584204495,
0.4087175131,
-0.3926050365,
0.9866641164,
-0.254904896,
0.6178022027,
0.1884157509,
0.0607425757,
-0.2321555912,
-0.4436232746,
-0.6254754066,
-0.74360919,
0.3135638237,
1.1451791525,
-0.6206841469,
0.635668695,
-0.214612022,
-0.4833805263,
-0.5279080272,
0.4757985473,
0.158103317,
0.1061586589,
0.1437622011,
-0.7054994106,
-0.6050981283,
-0.872898519,
0.0861734226,
-0.448038578,
-0.2814465165,
0.4317952394,
0.1677323729,
0.0096237175,
0.4212801754,
0.0888260379,
-0.7170128226,
-0.2258725315,
0.1680415571,
-0.0284212735,
0.4924198389,
0.719402492,
-0.319121778,
-0.5264632702,
0.29809618,
-0.4802139401,
-0.2899938822,
0.0556587912,
-0.1910015941,
0.111560531,
0.2225092202,
-0.9924886227,
0.0162494909,
0.5586326718,
0.0824086443,
0.4399699867,
0.1372465193,
0.2206885517,
-1.0248868465,
0.159062326,
-0.3054178655,
-0.2737442255,
-0.6715461016,
-0.3957708776,
0.1709386408,
-0.4725942314,
-0.7393962145,
0.3284653127,
-0.711420536,
-0.5701243877,
-0.1885062307,
0.2670736313,
-0.1056483611,
0.8145538568,
0.1915203929,
0.7426540256,
0.9086993337,
-0.3746134043,
0.6832125783,
0.1920045465,
-0.2555152774,
1.2212537527,
-0.2600918412,
0.3429821134,
0.1660544872,
0.2176826745,
-0.9308084846,
-0.0383903235,
0.5157251358,
-0.3671953082,
0.0453125164,
-0.2329693735,
-0.1090593711,
-0.0489213504,
-0.3466511965,
0.6737377048,
0.1832406968,
-0.475741744,
1.1030315161,
0.3501050472,
-0.2538922429,
-0.4513418972,
-0.6776146889,
0.1628325582,
-0.2830792665,
-0.3729184568,
0.2857149243,
0.2623286545,
0.2114623338,
-0.0112734269,
-0.0653644577,
-0.6025462747,
-0.1821617335,
0.0489207134,
0.021781154,
-0.2716398835,
0.3012590408,
-0.6982871294,
-0.0913276225,
-0.3014180958,
-0.6380323172,
0.3777135313,
0.0468336418,
-0.3955554068,
-0.5906283855,
0.7130019665,
0.7393070459,
-0.5608339906,
-0.1237133145,
0.8468766212,
-0.3238039911,
0.0908976719,
-0.3216459751,
0.0130490409,
-0.3991991878,
0.551609695,
-0.588999033,
-0.56318748,
0.5340327024,
-0.0335096866,
0.0329987556,
-0.0430886857,
0.3328839242,
0.029960949,
0.6101566553,
0.5894573331,
-0.2674301267,
0.8643755317,
0.046093367,
0.4571681023,
-0.6912537217,
0.1458004117,
-0.2632274032,
-0.0901151374,
-0.6964882016,
-0.4151360393,
0.242616564,
0.0999094322,
0.0675254464,
0.6773325205,
-0.4521950483,
0.2369817942,
0.8594332337,
0.2037459016,
0.1983216554,
0.0409969166,
0.1049629375,
-0.0111238016,
-0.6403519511,
-0.1395411789,
0.9802626967,
0.1946049035,
0.5667386651,
0.2029239237,
0.7888271213,
-0.0186994486,
-0.2102408558,
-1.4111959934,
0.5878069401,
-0.3144610524,
-0.4480763674,
-0.5161781311,
-0.2762003839,
-0.93150419,
0.3238303065,
-0.0792387053,
-0.9431618452,
0.5055326819,
0.0071064103,
-0.4415959716,
0.4564239085,
-0.6592319012,
0.7908194065,
-0.5486462116,
-0.1949957907,
-0.2323804051,
-0.413749963,
0.3113234937,
-0.2406396419,
0.1283402443,
-0.4339054823,
0.1269063205,
0.694432497,
-0.1569277495,
0.8363409638,
-0.132128045,
-0.2952145338,
0.2722788155,
0.2574559152,
0.2842026353,
-0.5906236172,
-0.0823270306,
0.3646313548,
0.2390663922,
-0.653875649,
-0.4509265721,
0.4742848575,
-0.5747742653,
-0.2094147503,
-0.3245883882,
-0.7394304872,
-0.1260185987,
0.2846516967,
0.0576674044,
0.1349503398,
-0.1587676108,
0.0215159096,
0.3620864451,
-0.2658651769,
0.4724339247,
0.4934742451,
0.0937989652,
-0.4493710399,
1.1941490173,
0.4162840247,
0.2210697532,
0.390218854,
0.1963542849,
-0.294121623,
-0.0914995819,
-0.7409607172,
-0.0926956534,
-0.7936050296,
-0.057317283,
-0.4299051166,
-0.0859456733,
-0.3341611624,
0.1125723273,
-0.455214411,
-0.760242641,
-0.0239525922,
0.1069575846,
0.5055881143,
0.4672985971,
-0.5803420544,
0.4533981383,
-0.7960238457,
0.0800009817,
0.6687248349,
0.2971065342,
0.057947915,
-0.2485410422,
-0.3521714509,
-0.0335300528,
-0.3104829788,
-0.9212857485,
0.1043862551,
0.8558670282,
0.4855007529,
0.4672518373,
0.0287942775,
0.6639961004,
-0.4846754968,
0.5511780977,
0.3113851845,
-1.3661972284,
0.4126558006,
-0.1862117797,
0.1210839674,
0.181797877,
0.2668069601,
-0.6069531441,
-0.0663816556,
-0.4702079296,
-0.7711777091,
0.622933805,
0.0128904553,
-0.1621931344,
0.3553121686,
0.0305938143,
0.200731039,
0.2420675308,
-0.6711104512,
0.1432338059,
-0.6013362408,
-0.2652467787,
0.3647779822,
0.0856709629,
0.0357783847,
-0.2578082681,
0.3378028274,
-0.2802585065,
0.3482355475,
-0.0423740186,
-0.4028283656,
-0.1872656643,
0.6256586313,
0.2712779939,
0.5751695633,
-0.1197959185,
0.3554388285,
0.3171344399,
-0.5975794196,
0.3466767371,
0.2700038552,
0.3248821199,
0.0981140584,
0.5600119233,
0.7828698754,
0.4820237756,
-0.5032837391,
0.7117165923,
0.4005388021,
-0.2315727174,
-0.4728399515,
-0.3145298362,
-0.1410014331,
0.0477994382,
0.5768698454,
-0.0524947196,
0.2567489147,
-0.7963401079,
0.437456876,
0.3057095408,
-0.3151562512,
-0.4726849794,
0.4311249554,
0.2928749919,
-0.097770676,
0.3466992974,
-0.0830028802,
-0.6780384183,
0.3667238951,
0.2836608291,
0.8535225987,
-0.9265677929,
0.2100126445,
0.2094147503,
0.1435349584,
0.3026435673,
0.4376695752,
-0.4711910784,
-0.86459589,
-0.3490382135,
-0.3432865739,
-0.6673457623,
0.0408985317,
-0.5466262102,
0.1963408291,
-0.3192071617,
0.0795532539,
0.2799074054,
-0.1042293683,
-0.7511646748,
0.0742450356,
-0.0224111564,
0.3778263628,
-0.9949190021,
1.0667887926,
0.8868111372,
-0.5257333517,
-0.6876416206,
-0.0193880927,
0.0871765316,
-1.3309028149,
0.8141849637,
0.0425797366,
-0.1580603719,
0.0877276585,
-0.044242274,
-0.9072618484,
0.8321832418,
0.4460213482,
-0.5402185321,
0.1059076115,
0.4195931554,
0.0986098722,
-0.3708464503,
0.4842452109,
0.5142959356,
0.6172046661,
0.0636836514,
-1.6682137251,
0.0692439079,
-0.1814941466,
-0.2405171096,
0.0289843455,
-0.5128467083,
1.0708930492,
-0.153877601,
-0.4400802851,
0.0351200663,
0.1262605637,
0.2236998379,
-0.0599285476,
0.9302786589,
0.4363851547,
0.8933641315,
-0.0046380903,
0.4489970207,
-0.5223337412,
-0.1659081578,
0.646920383,
-0.5784680247,
1.0015510321,
0.5028057098,
-0.12715289,
0.1774650365,
0.7633729577,
0.0261907671,
0.5862521529,
0.1876603514,
-0.3402362466,
-0.4228047729,
-0.4815194309,
0.0735063329,
1.0414364338,
0.1276170462,
0.1184806079,
-0.192314297,
0.5040080547,
-0.1428168267,
-0.4274197817,
-0.1733292341,
0.6975979209,
0.2121393532,
-0.1800390929,
1.0188407898,
-0.362036407,
0.9429562688,
-0.4615341425,
-0.0291898772,
0.190682739,
0.2433258444,
-0.4215286672,
-0.71506989,
0.1630610973,
-0.6669495106,
0.0657424852,
-0.0919404849,
0.6919254065,
-1.002466321,
-0.2826292217,
0.5194932818,
0.9073860645,
0.5718522668,
-0.181739524,
-0.6391527057,
-0.0089579728,
-0.1490630358,
0.0853982493,
0.104128994,
0.8528236151,
-0.0960156024,
0.5083705783,
0.6930534244,
0.3603098094,
-0.0411012918,
0.2864311635,
0.3066732883,
-0.6043416858,
-0.712695837,
-0.3015070558,
0.1764681637,
0.0280235913,
-0.2799259722,
0.6172607541,
0.4327423871,
0.8478015065,
-0.010631822,
1.0014140606,
-0.0282039307,
0.4526524246,
-0.3845003545,
0.4061965346,
-0.6301528811,
-0.1258839369,
-0.2035775483,
-0.9861366153,
-0.1016836837,
1.0220196247,
-0.0124351066,
-0.0336516201,
0.7458231449,
0.4541987479,
-0.3854743838,
0.052061975,
0.4774463475,
-0.1320805848,
-0.0013156912,
1.0778403282,
0.7390407324,
-0.5448464155,
0.9154443145,
-0.391600281,
-0.3565111756,
-0.1890299767,
-0.5031626225,
-0.9007405639,
-0.7724605799,
-0.1826220751,
0.0435919538,
0.0881343409,
1.0775732994,
1.0557011366,
-0.9312446713,
-0.54641819,
0.2294311225,
-0.1545147896,
-0.5485219955,
-0.2384025753,
0.5434063673,
0.0193503648,
-0.8251475692,
0.5317844152,
0.2479753643,
0.3600195348,
-0.3857042789,
0.1370483339,
-0.0472506285,
-0.27666834,
0.8498544097,
0.4926614761,
-0.6065815091,
-0.304661423,
0.2622785568,
0.0799621716,
0.4000991583,
0.8392038345,
-0.2394397706,
0.1624760926,
0.4393583536,
0.4972559214,
0.2646306753,
-0.3445426524,
0.7232829928,
-0.8077849746,
0.6642274261,
0.1705368757,
0.5695544481,
0.6187680364,
-0.3370561302,
0.375644356,
0.2004215866,
-0.3534691036,
-0.5417571068,
0.462631017,
-1.0618095398,
-0.0602477789,
0.9072055221,
-0.2206164747,
-0.2872796059,
-0.5555132627,
-0.3731111586,
0.0598837435,
-0.6303554177,
0.6481270194,
0.7729495168,
-0.4243122637,
-0.7967328429,
-0.6779655814,
0.3472462595,
0.5004436374,
-0.745200336,
0.1830606014,
0.3475376964,
0.3888202608,
0.497469753,
0.878508687,
-0.0969054401,
0.4365372658,
-0.0357291996,
0.533030808,
0.0995946079,
-0.1183044612,
0.0215156022,
0.0052812183,
-0.0274455175,
-0.8463615775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04293v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04293v1 | Phrase Retrieval for Open-Domain Conversational Question Answering with Conversational Dependency Modeling via Contrastive Learning | 2023-06-07T09:46:38 | 2023-06-07T09:46:38 | Soyeong Jeong, Jinheon Baek, Sung Ju Hwang, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Open-Domain Conversational Question Answering (ODConvQA) aims at answering
questions through a multi-turn conversation based on a retriever-reader
pipeline, which retrieves passages and then predicts answers with them.
However, such a pipeline approach not only makes the reader vulnerable to the
errors propagated from the retriever, but also demands additional effort to
develop both the retriever and the reader, which further makes it slower since
they are not runnable in parallel. In this work, we propose a method to
directly predict answers with a phrase retrieval scheme for a sequence of
words, reducing the conventional two distinct subtasks into a single one. Also,
for the first time, we study its capability for ODConvQA tasks. However, simply
adopting it is largely problematic, due to the dependencies between previous
and current turns in a conversation. To address this problem, we further
introduce a novel contrastive learning strategy, making sure to reflect
previous turns when retrieving the phrase for the current context, by
maximizing representational similarities of consecutive turns in a conversation
while minimizing irrelevant conversational contexts. We validate our model on
two ODConvQA datasets, whose experimental results show that it substantially
outperforms the relevant baselines with the retriever-reader. Code is available
at: https://github.com/starsuzi/PRO-ConvQA. | [
-0.4429650903,
-0.7982674837,
0.4062146544,
-0.2283735275,
-0.4328714907,
0.0781427622,
0.0373082571,
-0.3606579304,
0.0663660094,
0.8191506267,
-0.8032566309,
-0.464076668,
-0.394097507,
-0.1754836738,
0.0190885216,
0.8004812598,
0.0290171672,
0.1022930294,
-0.4635180831,
-0.3682923317,
-0.5116772056,
-0.356885314,
-0.5224046111,
-0.395444423,
0.3911329806,
0.5065456033,
0.5283595324,
0.2923697829,
0.3210643828,
0.2430301309,
-0.3888705671,
0.1112175137,
-0.8184221983,
0.3368912339,
-0.0270001702,
-0.469833523,
0.048487924,
-0.0942665562,
0.1559851021,
0.8777166605,
-0.2840867043,
-0.1866007894,
0.2789356112,
0.4213172197,
-0.7710603476,
0.1248703375,
-0.8463833928,
-0.0352943242,
0.0570609383,
-0.2369730473,
-0.4193447828,
-0.3898784518,
0.6543901563,
-0.4953482151,
0.195382759,
-0.0501817614,
0.5839602947,
0.1747182012,
-0.406904757,
-0.4266941249,
-0.4878081679,
0.8583912253,
-0.5717283487,
0.3051465452,
0.2479791194,
0.3311849236,
0.0609931946,
-0.7205825448,
-0.5822713971,
-0.2711367011,
-0.1720241159,
0.4335739017,
0.0938777402,
-0.0407576673,
-0.0364017263,
0.3629839122,
-0.6442757845,
0.0594495572,
-0.3810054958,
-0.0249095242,
0.0708158165,
0.4134571254,
-0.1056504622,
-0.1166766211,
-0.6701873541,
0.1590722203,
-0.6228470206,
0.1730817109,
0.1849163771,
0.433500737,
0.1794195175,
0.6698315144,
-0.3684731424,
0.5167456865,
0.211551562,
0.2325907201,
0.135345757,
-0.3709605932,
-0.1270812452,
-0.0791459903,
0.592064023,
0.1144931763,
-0.0028111958,
-0.2274538726,
0.2471090704,
-0.0905183181,
0.3832255006,
-0.9849211574,
-0.3942112923,
0.4203420877,
-0.4800816476,
-0.0593214892,
0.1034445912,
-0.9376131892,
-0.5110309124,
-0.2357119024,
0.2560220361,
-0.6035400033,
-0.0290183462,
0.1367328167,
0.2930935919,
0.3872570693,
0.3048191369,
-0.4624717832,
0.4558449388,
0.6436629891,
0.8203315735,
-0.2529580891,
0.0400320403,
-1.143655777,
-0.4231100678,
-0.1375084221,
0.5999552608,
-0.6165103316,
-0.6342677474,
0.4022906423,
-0.1611991972,
-0.1526521742,
-0.6647791266,
0.5211823583,
-0.9425464272,
0.3250343502,
-0.1432732493,
-0.5259068012,
-0.1292939782,
0.3092559576,
-0.5778872371,
0.6803312898,
-0.1025024429,
-1.0066024065,
-0.2619307041,
-0.1806871146,
-0.1772863716,
0.0781938657,
-0.2015312612,
-0.3920987844,
-0.1006289348,
0.0678015947,
0.2948538959,
-0.2587031424,
0.016418701,
-0.222161755,
-0.2944951057,
0.3078791499,
-0.0379795656,
0.6505378485,
0.190913856,
-0.0466678888,
0.0848136544,
-0.5732955933,
0.0372084789,
0.0416082107,
-0.2956467569,
-0.5105265379,
0.1821990907,
-0.2508070767,
0.2744780183,
-0.031743817,
-0.8916101456,
-0.0546903796,
-0.518294692,
0.0996863768,
0.5038077235,
0.1909445077,
0.4268983603,
-0.2745810747,
0.598087728,
0.3303892612,
-0.1475978047,
-0.5485773087,
-0.3645665944,
-0.786049962,
-0.0362804793,
0.2179909199,
0.6925476193,
-1.3491812944,
0.0875853747,
-0.102193214,
-0.3711976111,
-0.5560839772,
-0.0946129188,
0.8757690191,
0.731497407,
0.6352437139,
-0.4413435459,
-0.3500623405,
-0.4844232202,
-0.1331056803,
0.0080090333,
-0.0352455266,
0.614671886,
0.4129554629,
0.2510888278,
0.8955959678,
-1.0902173519,
-0.4087194502,
-0.3041236997,
0.3309810758,
0.1065114066,
0.3899732232,
0.2212219536,
-1.0219016075,
-0.4567224681,
-0.1309626102,
-0.3536611497,
0.1490105391,
0.1507585049,
-0.2782883644,
-0.0136000374,
0.7750980854,
-0.5627778172,
0.4980178773,
0.4410620332,
-0.3351457119,
0.5138950944,
0.0203204099,
-0.0212784875,
-1.1330417395,
0.1106283367,
-0.1035641879,
0.0267483201,
-0.7742871642,
0.0648032427,
-0.0608032681,
-0.024396237,
-0.6941467524,
0.5592064261,
-0.2553468645,
0.3562723696,
-0.1812593341,
0.3967073262,
-0.1242081076,
0.646959722,
0.350469619,
0.6559610367,
0.2468200028,
-0.7276910543,
0.1639553457,
0.6675443649,
-0.4587016404,
0.6322472095,
-0.8580335975,
0.435192734,
-0.2370879799,
0.1677443683,
-1.2479015589,
0.3049601018,
0.3891759217,
-0.5856013298,
0.1647168845,
-0.2502771914,
-0.0870524943,
-0.0675159991,
-0.0201627128,
0.4562838078,
0.344214946,
-0.6916288137,
0.5063039064,
0.1773302555,
-0.4824852943,
-0.6869936585,
-0.4118964374,
-0.4225609601,
-0.0281404257,
-0.4635110497,
0.5879138112,
-0.2172933966,
-0.1081978381,
-0.0635906905,
-0.2295795828,
-0.170988664,
-0.1287318617,
0.008166939,
0.348886013,
-0.2411099523,
0.1203404963,
-0.2874057591,
-0.1402618289,
-0.0418556966,
-0.5068418384,
0.7209253311,
0.0823438168,
-0.0833040103,
0.067869164,
0.6132913232,
0.2345193475,
-0.6281663179,
0.9262248278,
0.4683059752,
-0.0603989586,
-0.0384005196,
-0.3168776333,
-0.1913592219,
-0.4157094657,
0.3805260658,
-0.5365893245,
-0.9955683947,
0.5802101493,
-0.0163064562,
-0.0417341404,
0.0263529345,
0.3192194402,
0.0472349934,
0.8191335797,
0.4635708034,
0.1696523577,
0.5730264187,
-0.3589838743,
0.1224407777,
-0.9123435616,
-0.5398932099,
-0.8373900056,
0.0943870693,
-0.6500096321,
-0.5308638811,
0.2244256288,
0.0951043516,
-0.1348664016,
0.1709664911,
-0.0171370711,
0.3429054022,
0.7339441776,
0.4186643958,
0.3315629661,
-0.326195389,
-0.4051233828,
-0.0966898575,
-0.4128715694,
-0.1581226587,
0.7524980307,
-0.0776545554,
0.7869858146,
0.1704215258,
0.7414708138,
-0.2273929864,
-0.0188004803,
-0.8171451092,
0.5778074861,
-0.2905736864,
-0.0876705796,
-0.189434424,
-0.652844727,
-1.142681241,
0.5011293292,
-0.095317997,
-0.7348646522,
0.3247001469,
-0.0493638553,
-0.3700967431,
-0.0106912805,
-0.3496464491,
1.0081670284,
0.1233412698,
-0.3635268211,
-0.0973648876,
-0.9474330544,
0.2115847319,
0.2680467367,
-0.1931964159,
0.1767834872,
0.027116118,
0.4542383552,
-0.4123921394,
0.7308684587,
-0.2123249471,
-0.0406078547,
0.5156877041,
0.2292608172,
0.4088081717,
-0.0855222419,
-0.0406668857,
-0.2127761394,
0.022232255,
-0.5013583899,
-0.6625082493,
0.6721479893,
-0.5268664956,
-0.5032592416,
-0.3518169224,
-0.2098923028,
-0.4049608111,
0.1702374965,
0.2501211762,
0.5791112185,
-0.6098085046,
0.2859122455,
1.0205465555,
-0.2930040658,
0.1763491035,
0.6353647113,
-0.1500837207,
-0.4083386064,
0.8423981071,
-0.07735008,
0.5434610248,
0.6861088276,
0.0953662395,
-0.476693958,
-0.6630203128,
-0.0415563397,
0.2036159784,
-0.7454075217,
-0.2378586233,
-0.7302593589,
-0.2370385379,
-0.319889605,
0.2049601674,
-0.1150545329,
-0.1390441209,
-0.5246638656,
0.0601926968,
0.134528473,
0.3300389647,
0.5030220747,
0.1020951048,
-0.7495241165,
0.5441855192,
0.4497098625,
0.3379968405,
-0.1349784434,
-0.6475532651,
-0.1569794267,
0.0236772429,
-0.6423649788,
-0.8112353086,
0.4577223957,
0.2788286805,
0.4745004475,
0.1542359143,
0.5995440483,
0.540707171,
-0.5600380898,
0.7516356707,
0.2045302242,
-0.698800385,
0.5576008558,
-0.123991169,
0.5339667201,
0.6419703364,
0.681878984,
-0.6433237791,
-0.3219035566,
-0.5433583856,
-0.9190402031,
0.6968812943,
0.255933553,
0.1721068472,
-0.1694855988,
0.1905761659,
0.3034646511,
0.2896750867,
-0.2814587355,
-0.29839167,
-0.2604139149,
-0.1863916814,
-0.1883154958,
-0.1886158735,
0.1831923574,
0.3477731049,
0.5641846061,
-0.3770605326,
0.3256305754,
0.3341593742,
-0.042054601,
0.1897470802,
0.3751778305,
0.1792388707,
0.3844531476,
-0.3588835001,
0.0026686967,
-0.1836031228,
-0.5012072325,
-0.2839814723,
0.4276455641,
-0.1412235349,
0.0415991992,
-0.1119043529,
0.7238788009,
0.0255512297,
-0.8538967967,
0.5765573978,
-0.1173937172,
-0.0987678096,
-0.1455611736,
-0.229716748,
0.0409599766,
0.5044088364,
0.2272280157,
0.0839497373,
0.2925086021,
-0.6234763861,
0.2154824138,
0.3774963915,
-0.8735014796,
-0.0286173578,
0.5571607947,
0.2712103724,
-0.2421458364,
0.7429326177,
-0.101861015,
-0.4576419294,
0.6368697882,
0.2761949301,
0.918160677,
-0.3994770646,
0.281147927,
0.3634463847,
-0.3313056231,
0.1555631906,
0.528881371,
-0.0121777207,
-0.6987019181,
-0.218295604,
-0.4125721157,
-0.5780711174,
0.0395724736,
-0.9894088507,
0.1563091874,
-0.0215557199,
0.1681098491,
-0.0500622392,
0.0280833095,
-0.6518707275,
0.274690479,
0.0662961975,
0.8164672256,
-0.3283798993,
0.7485461235,
0.5460522771,
-0.5634537339,
-0.3462622762,
0.4548343718,
-0.0261062533,
-0.4991326034,
0.4603322744,
0.2370765358,
-0.3159049153,
0.080689013,
-0.3081674278,
-0.5647490025,
1.0962719917,
0.1090133041,
-0.2341093868,
0.0975448191,
-0.0326047987,
0.5963343978,
-0.5830640793,
0.3289185762,
0.4782088697,
-0.2976564765,
0.6520606875,
-0.7047583461,
0.0367130376,
-0.2530994415,
0.1244597659,
0.198153466,
-0.5232373476,
0.8365772963,
-0.4206759036,
-0.1130165905,
0.7148932219,
0.916480422,
0.120013006,
0.2179426998,
0.432624042,
0.2380174994,
0.5486195087,
-0.0224646106,
0.9156048298,
0.0697857216,
0.3825548291,
1.4439282417,
-0.2428447008,
1.2660868168,
0.4750212729,
0.0245261099,
0.5541290641,
0.4134494662,
0.5303028822,
1.0350257158,
0.3707890511,
-0.4086437225,
-0.2401797026,
-0.3494830728,
-0.1248590276,
0.4551845491,
0.273473978,
-0.2423032671,
-0.0445536338,
0.0651118681,
-0.0292354263,
0.4579524398,
-0.2475797683,
1.0058389902,
0.1204350069,
-1.070220232,
0.6866782308,
-0.2922121882,
0.4704747796,
-0.4788282216,
-0.247571826,
-0.5063611269,
0.4220967889,
0.1541133225,
-0.7587770224,
0.204027459,
-0.2511017621,
-0.0162923522,
0.0133741358,
0.3487228453,
-0.887296617,
-0.1128807887,
0.3749449253,
0.6523615718,
-0.1760673225,
-0.1676738262,
-0.5703024268,
-0.2165475041,
-0.0698061138,
0.0052915337,
0.3895344734,
0.2866083384,
0.259144485,
0.5842490792,
0.1979179084,
-0.2669982612,
-0.068488583,
0.0724284202,
1.0527466536,
-0.4227066934,
-0.6703118086,
-0.3680799007,
0.5882472992,
0.1120997667,
-0.345130384,
0.4011738002,
0.4857607484,
0.923237741,
-0.0395015515,
0.6528268456,
0.0339952856,
0.9866681099,
-0.8178246617,
0.1988418102,
-0.4340952337,
0.3925656676,
-0.3039965332,
-0.7491710186,
-0.1247299984,
0.2561866343,
-0.4052372575,
-0.1061468348,
0.8880360126,
0.8680615425,
-0.0451644026,
0.27681458,
0.244209975,
0.3653193414,
0.2053227723,
0.6678735614,
0.8982396126,
-0.4000887275,
1.1794850826,
-0.1964334399,
-0.0833092108,
-0.1926607937,
-0.5472361445,
-0.9169843793,
-0.6938749552,
-0.5263904929,
-0.6724853516,
0.2097475082,
0.6624448895,
0.4343126714,
-0.8897995353,
-0.1154563874,
-0.117894344,
0.1142924726,
-0.3598705232,
-0.2081240118,
0.3623873889,
-0.4451345801,
-0.8289007545,
0.2982704937,
-0.0543222241,
-0.2164977193,
0.0479693487,
-0.1737066507,
-0.3746975064,
0.1153344885,
0.5248818994,
0.3590306938,
-0.6851038933,
-0.2921231091,
0.3514598012,
-0.070097886,
0.277317822,
1.1156016588,
-1.0385820866,
0.6030083895,
0.5650390387,
0.7945391536,
0.7240723968,
0.1965925545,
0.4251515269,
-0.7134821415,
-0.2017865181,
0.5438320637,
0.1081153527,
0.2752792239,
-0.1542725563,
0.2563932836,
0.1780312806,
-0.4096585214,
-0.3201783597,
0.5616846085,
-0.9925971627,
-0.3941266537,
1.0209548473,
-0.6896348596,
0.1506544948,
-0.5065102577,
-0.570096314,
0.0849924237,
-0.2959844172,
0.6876866221,
0.2491476536,
-0.0752594769,
-0.4397542775,
-0.2510675788,
0.3361773193,
0.385604471,
-0.6421231031,
0.1026205793,
0.4998610616,
0.0067451182,
0.2069982886,
0.5506985784,
-0.0934629887,
0.1926532686,
-0.0064578592,
-0.2684563398,
0.1139519662,
-0.1656698436,
-0.27822119,
0.3375124931,
-0.2139630914,
-0.5666627884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04277v1 | Analysis of the Fed's communication by using textual entailment model of Zero-Shot classification | 2023-06-07T09:23:26 | 2023-06-07T09:23:26 | Yasuhiro Nakayama, Tomochika Sawaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we analyze documents published by central banks using text
mining techniques and propose a method to evaluate the policy tone of central
banks. Since the monetary policies of major central banks have a broad impact
on financial market trends, the pricing of risky assets, and the real economy,
market participants are attempting to more accurately capture changes in the
outlook for central banks' future monetary policies. Since the published
documents are also an important tool for the central bank to communicate with
the market, they are meticulously elaborated on grammatical syntax and wording,
and investors are urged to read more accurately about the central bank's policy
stance. Sentiment analysis on central bank documents has long been carried out,
but it has been difficult to interpret the meaning of the documents accurately
and to explicitly capture even the intentional change in nuance. This study
attempts to evaluate the implication of the zero-shot text classification
method for an unknown economic environment using the same model. We compare the
tone of the statements, minutes, press conference transcripts of FOMC meetings,
and the Fed officials' (chair, vice chair, and Governors) speeches. In
addition, the minutes of the FOMC meetings were subjected to a phase analysis
of changes in each policy stance since 1971. | [
-0.3380542397,
-1.2686350346,
0.6418818235,
0.1782864779,
-0.3537049592,
-0.3806590438,
-0.485920459,
-0.402179271,
0.0745134056,
0.7908853292,
-0.6782106757,
-0.7497767806,
-0.4333120584,
0.178575322,
-0.6212931275,
1.352488637,
-0.1157590598,
-0.2292907834,
-0.0146965859,
0.2231886238,
-0.2070471346,
-0.1984947473,
-0.3108352721,
-0.1834489852,
-0.0036497556,
0.2203577161,
0.7356108427,
0.3892868459,
0.6009967327,
0.3974722028,
-0.2272703648,
-0.5296565294,
-0.2157004774,
0.1084518284,
-0.0938794464,
-0.6281769872,
-0.2995428443,
0.3710809052,
0.6653225422,
0.3103161752,
0.0680062547,
0.2497428507,
0.0207651462,
0.3881548643,
-0.6332109571,
0.5387263894,
-0.4993680418,
-0.1018002927,
-0.2480833679,
-0.518210113,
-0.6431342959,
-0.1278424263,
0.4239637554,
-0.2396907508,
0.2559528947,
0.1286518276,
0.9132983088,
-0.0407789499,
-0.4507600665,
-0.7052596211,
-0.7997237444,
0.9304434657,
-0.895614624,
0.0255841967,
0.3863843679,
0.2740004957,
0.1287894696,
-0.2886722088,
-0.8468542695,
-0.0116314534,
-0.2474330366,
0.3635169864,
-0.1640951186,
0.3235639632,
0.3449496329,
0.6971517801,
-0.2035043836,
-0.4425085485,
-0.3979870081,
0.0395635292,
0.4958736002,
0.0520692952,
-0.017696254,
-0.47174263,
-0.2257293165,
-0.428425163,
-0.1439332366,
0.1165395752,
0.5180389285,
0.6175928116,
-0.0997609273,
0.5253221393,
-0.6124033332,
0.762845993,
0.1847859174,
-0.3251155317,
0.0846699625,
-0.3250744343,
-0.6127259731,
0.4440830946,
0.5020007491,
0.5184546709,
-0.0748030618,
0.0337123945,
-0.3159501851,
-0.0180971324,
0.142241627,
-0.6571204662,
0.4085456133,
0.2806825638,
-0.6288692951,
-0.5615823269,
0.429580301,
-1.2057039738,
-0.1388391852,
-0.5503566861,
0.2311319113,
-0.1598921567,
-0.2340050191,
0.0324819311,
-0.3183334172,
0.7476270795,
0.1505168378,
-0.7891231775,
0.2131872475,
0.9621460438,
0.729706943,
0.4307863116,
0.1966176182,
0.1911745816,
-0.0853119493,
-0.0990234762,
1.121104598,
-0.5881189108,
-0.7175412774,
0.4152437747,
0.2622257769,
-0.1815883964,
-0.0243716687,
0.5855815411,
-0.1119563282,
0.5527999997,
-0.1304039955,
-0.4595669806,
-0.3099988401,
0.5598444343,
-0.5023626685,
0.3490354419,
0.3334821165,
-0.6890934706,
0.3722580075,
-0.8013530374,
-0.1700876653,
-0.2170128822,
-0.0071539613,
-0.3727724254,
-0.1281198114,
0.0094560375,
0.1503948718,
-0.2467235625,
0.2054672241,
-0.5292012691,
-0.4354515076,
0.6263738275,
-0.4572910964,
0.78333956,
0.2060659975,
-0.5457057953,
-0.046517089,
-0.7439555526,
0.0874682739,
-0.1822462529,
-0.178673774,
-0.3425461948,
-0.0641064942,
0.1978248805,
0.1885178685,
0.3066748679,
-0.6880850196,
-0.0010594636,
-0.6091996431,
0.3456192315,
0.851084888,
0.4835214019,
0.7683541179,
-0.292792201,
0.4092798531,
-0.2775508165,
0.551934123,
-0.4411741495,
-0.176189974,
-0.7308996916,
0.0415043719,
0.2373453677,
0.6274012923,
0.141234681,
0.2004708052,
0.0913229361,
-0.4260797501,
-0.2736908793,
-0.4448553622,
0.2006309628,
0.4718445241,
0.1797000617,
0.1327857822,
-0.4360504746,
-0.7122664452,
-0.5791406035,
-0.2221879214,
0.2061793506,
0.1698393375,
0.3312551677,
-0.1513066292,
1.068789959,
-0.5784317255,
-0.1166412979,
0.0787049904,
0.3540688455,
0.549266696,
0.3026060462,
0.5298660994,
-0.3211478889,
-0.55163306,
0.25255391,
-0.377836585,
0.0238325726,
-0.4056115448,
-0.2211838514,
0.5888322592,
0.4375302494,
-0.3666000068,
0.5373375416,
0.2484107167,
-0.6186148524,
0.3780212402,
0.0388600156,
0.2609639764,
-0.4499391317,
0.1024974361,
0.0167526081,
0.145971626,
-0.6608206034,
0.0484857187,
-0.0125862472,
-0.1360174716,
-0.1421560496,
0.5822467804,
-0.1378732324,
0.2487235516,
-0.1780975163,
0.1323655993,
0.0799674988,
0.4383864701,
-0.1235420257,
0.390955925,
0.5415962934,
-0.201723814,
0.269946456,
0.4210787416,
-0.1748206913,
1.0122756958,
-0.3377579153,
0.0018287809,
-0.2518250346,
0.0879201889,
-0.730054915,
0.0130749522,
0.3823729157,
-0.2601550519,
0.5164117813,
0.3589812219,
-0.2997210622,
-0.3238426149,
-0.3688047826,
-0.4284360111,
0.3273919225,
-0.1471150219,
0.3268567324,
0.0041676499,
-0.0903674513,
-0.4883545041,
-0.7928175926,
-0.1584937871,
-0.346781671,
-0.3212986887,
0.0359996483,
-0.001722825,
-0.6490064859,
0.1398988813,
-0.4908189476,
-0.1010612473,
-0.0064151157,
0.2634219825,
0.4015617073,
-0.1926157773,
0.0830536783,
0.0479196608,
-0.1178928241,
0.3521754146,
-0.229144752,
0.2246023864,
-0.3140446842,
0.0602083169,
-0.6776778102,
0.1616400778,
0.2775259018,
0.0106069241,
0.8768577576,
0.1952012777,
0.0024299521,
-0.0940099359,
-0.2841225863,
0.0138297407,
-0.4170884192,
-0.2469018996,
0.1041109934,
-0.5568611622,
0.421269089,
-0.1505690068,
0.0532815605,
0.6841893792,
0.3124055266,
0.1144540086,
0.5393106937,
0.7665634751,
0.095544368,
0.7377064824,
-0.2083495557,
0.3687535226,
-0.3484428525,
-0.3955900073,
-0.9131996632,
-0.1843089163,
-0.6352996826,
0.041848518,
-0.0704203844,
-0.1203485504,
-0.2948957384,
0.3031208515,
-0.5423272252,
0.3873853683,
0.3332687318,
0.0004038608,
0.1413583308,
-0.1144970432,
0.0007322714,
0.2267605811,
0.0638053566,
-0.731104672,
1.1583315134,
0.3093294501,
0.5708790421,
-0.0865259171,
0.6444371939,
0.2823069394,
0.5662531853,
-0.8015176058,
0.3173489869,
0.0974712521,
-0.7424631715,
-0.3771596551,
-0.2559581697,
-0.5390967131,
0.1039818898,
-0.7351770997,
-0.3431367874,
0.4997444749,
-0.1719270647,
-0.5547049642,
-0.1310832798,
-0.4697186649,
1.0039893389,
-0.0553613491,
0.1890861243,
-0.1624645293,
-0.2462989241,
0.5705429316,
-0.138317287,
0.2668156922,
-0.2548646927,
0.1161087453,
0.4530205131,
-0.3863131106,
0.6434437037,
-0.2303756624,
-0.1203526855,
0.7158054113,
-0.2167116106,
0.4067522585,
-0.0531110056,
-0.3210929632,
0.18045187,
0.29052791,
-0.439935416,
-0.3744536042,
0.7241274118,
-0.8229448795,
-0.3732776046,
-0.7070636749,
-0.3351723552,
0.0500874966,
0.2178795189,
0.0549746081,
0.5806167722,
-0.5660772324,
0.1132135242,
0.1958580464,
-0.1399050802,
0.5999194384,
0.6322132349,
-0.2128322423,
-0.2353257984,
0.4781532288,
0.0693427399,
0.1706478745,
0.3799514472,
0.1841756999,
-0.3391409516,
-0.1706717461,
0.0837097093,
0.1570694745,
-0.6803415418,
-0.2549514472,
-0.5282586813,
0.0142070139,
-0.9327448606,
-0.3216461539,
0.183975026,
-0.4236598611,
-0.3606556654,
-0.1969094723,
0.3570474088,
0.5424807072,
0.0221212357,
0.8220896125,
-0.5034226775,
-0.1466403604,
0.1712172925,
0.373845309,
-0.3724220395,
-0.2840862572,
-0.2892192602,
-0.0355048031,
-0.5712324381,
-1.2642258406,
0.5122837424,
0.1639572382,
0.4844092429,
0.9764193892,
0.3473092914,
0.6106823683,
0.0624003746,
0.5102250576,
0.0015023212,
-1.2591786385,
0.5473335385,
-0.3622136712,
0.4002389312,
0.5003283024,
-0.1064616293,
-0.7683774233,
-0.8241872191,
-1.0481637716,
-0.6573582888,
1.1566623449,
0.1119267493,
0.1007761061,
-0.3359446228,
0.3383674026,
-0.1754000038,
0.4330945909,
-0.332955569,
-0.1160832718,
-0.4917243421,
-0.3305821419,
0.1016504616,
-0.3137742579,
-0.2122794688,
0.1415004134,
0.3182582855,
0.022204712,
0.2853881419,
0.2395759374,
0.1079377607,
-0.4683184624,
0.8060388565,
0.7543206215,
0.6417690516,
-0.6324560642,
0.0035045631,
0.0654948577,
-0.1477470249,
-0.2194134593,
0.1617557406,
-0.5562364459,
0.2903516293,
0.2913032472,
0.9002090693,
0.456528753,
-0.7564946413,
0.5947490335,
0.0108249569,
-0.4909522235,
-0.6747097969,
-0.0240537636,
-0.473778367,
0.2837296128,
0.172820434,
0.4866072237,
0.3630566299,
-0.9708800316,
0.1116694734,
0.4960882366,
-0.6868910193,
-0.4148061872,
0.3964294195,
0.0890598223,
-0.0171225928,
0.5153129101,
-0.1173892692,
-0.2628909349,
0.5908226371,
0.4531761706,
0.918943882,
-0.3294339776,
0.6389389038,
0.4415377676,
0.5365365744,
-0.312793225,
0.2048823833,
-0.0874510556,
-0.4240479171,
-0.3871474266,
-0.7487091422,
-0.3268799186,
-0.0825649723,
-0.8908833861,
0.5789074302,
-0.8139523268,
-0.4961441457,
0.0792616382,
0.255430162,
-0.5665819049,
0.1978768706,
0.2958211303,
0.8375036716,
-0.9019129276,
0.4510838091,
0.45801121,
-0.3254166245,
-0.2675370276,
0.0571778864,
0.3360901177,
-0.4545747638,
0.1550327241,
0.2940921485,
0.5726996064,
-0.3752283752,
-0.7494319677,
-0.5923645496,
1.0982655287,
0.0031268324,
-0.2463533729,
0.2493138015,
0.238135621,
0.593516767,
-0.2294824123,
0.3447367549,
0.8184401393,
1.0348131657,
0.0785880089,
-0.7666804194,
-0.0856477395,
-0.1127659455,
-0.3056483269,
0.4631077349,
-0.6841314435,
1.1838536263,
0.3439979255,
-0.7299591303,
-0.2424415499,
0.5697221756,
-0.2646840215,
0.7079547644,
0.3521173894,
0.3595074117,
0.6961180568,
-0.195193693,
1.0113697052,
-0.4404079616,
0.8402731419,
0.2781154811,
-0.2905571461,
0.8696026802,
0.1994959414,
-0.2770228088,
0.7421961427,
0.3199791014,
-0.2100696564,
0.4035096765,
-0.032461293,
-0.3773206472,
0.0711980537,
-0.0700871423,
-0.1753904372,
0.5729961395,
0.4058114886,
-0.3323405087,
-0.5509496331,
-0.0964795351,
0.2304550856,
0.3594256639,
-0.596925199,
0.7412536144,
0.0952333808,
-0.4192295372,
-0.0463172719,
0.2336625457,
0.5781060457,
-0.3310542107,
0.1972975731,
-0.1961456239,
0.4558131695,
-0.1243288964,
-0.7146552801,
0.9079915285,
0.1791163534,
-0.1762062311,
-0.5579590797,
0.6180707812,
-0.3841739893,
-0.4776516855,
-0.1104829386,
0.1978206635,
0.0814934671,
-0.2990026474,
-0.6847903728,
-0.2176090479,
0.0059767473,
-0.2789923251,
0.2750543356,
0.6923412681,
0.1473723054,
-0.0487465225,
0.6090387702,
-0.2403466702,
-0.2475819588,
-0.3272098601,
0.4875468612,
-1.2138103247,
-0.6338149905,
-0.7469448447,
-0.0263470653,
-0.2246241421,
-0.3095805049,
0.7415608168,
0.2753126323,
0.6855026484,
-0.1092051864,
0.6302773356,
-0.1419790089,
0.3870024681,
-0.378051281,
0.7800267339,
0.0374373123,
-0.1816619486,
-0.178870514,
-0.9589319229,
-0.308038801,
0.7702323198,
-0.6076676846,
-0.2491937578,
0.9437932372,
0.6046168208,
0.4805625975,
0.5785774589,
0.1133713201,
0.3032966852,
-0.1283778846,
-0.0626125783,
0.4787240624,
-0.2805175781,
0.8765321374,
-0.3848148286,
-0.1217417121,
-0.2916404307,
-0.7939609885,
-0.7408574224,
-0.2427824289,
-0.3086063564,
-0.3344000876,
-0.2086071074,
0.7212454677,
0.0680578202,
-0.8583297729,
-0.4242783487,
0.0916505083,
-0.1220912412,
-0.3163296878,
-0.2966397107,
0.3586116433,
-0.389703095,
-0.9341648817,
0.0099661928,
0.5129759312,
0.1797005087,
-0.1490309685,
0.2567424178,
-0.0380627178,
0.4083636999,
0.4264698625,
0.2990111113,
-0.5740283132,
-0.2131854445,
0.2526339293,
-0.2284121066,
-0.2525858879,
0.9226392508,
-0.4126040041,
0.3865561485,
0.4807903767,
0.1172616705,
0.2840595543,
0.3320457339,
0.2133459747,
-0.4730079472,
0.4449150562,
-0.1552875936,
0.0488302782,
0.0402794443,
-0.4857423306,
0.2142404467,
0.1891384572,
-0.7217046022,
-0.5571487546,
-0.3774056435,
-1.1300250292,
-0.4651397467,
0.9733014107,
-0.1782075316,
-0.8232457042,
0.0390447043,
-0.3610187769,
0.1576995254,
-0.5675461292,
0.757895112,
0.9019785523,
0.0114082163,
-0.3858329058,
-0.6897634268,
0.2522071898,
-0.2064800709,
-0.4774637222,
-0.0398610719,
0.4388437867,
-0.2355963439,
0.1904034764,
0.7918142676,
-0.2011490464,
-0.1458592564,
0.2891388535,
0.0582819581,
0.2286009789,
0.2556327581,
-0.4281150997,
0.1087800115,
-0.3566604555,
0.0361648276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04268v1 | Multi-microphone Automatic Speech Segmentation in Meetings Based on Circular Harmonics Features | 2023-06-07T09:09:00 | 2023-06-07T09:09:00 | Théo Mariotte, Anthony Larcher, Silvio Montrésor, Jean-Hugh Thomas | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Speaker diarization is the task of answering Who spoke and when? in an audio
stream. Pipeline systems rely on speech segmentation to extract speakers'
segments and achieve robust speaker diarization. This paper proposes a common
framework to solve three segmentation tasks in the distant speech scenario:
Voice Activity Detection (VAD), Overlapped Speech Detection (OSD), and Speaker
Change Detection (SCD). In the literature, a few studies investigate the
multi-microphone distant speech scenario. In this work, we propose a new set of
spatial features based on direction-of-arrival estimations in the circular
harmonic domain (CH-DOA). These spatial features are extracted from
multi-microphone audio data and combined with standard acoustic features.
Experiments on the AMI meeting corpus show that CH-DOA can improve the
segmentation while being robust in the case of deactivated microphones. | [
-0.960878551,
-0.8208333254,
0.5597417951,
-0.0275662746,
-0.4020473063,
-0.0510285534,
-0.0219777413,
-0.777025938,
0.2635043263,
0.4752595723,
-0.8732241988,
-0.6135592461,
-0.2005676925,
0.1941717565,
-0.2379832417,
0.4302943051,
0.3225648701,
0.3790709972,
0.2380677015,
-0.5277552009,
-0.6572024226,
-0.8411451578,
-0.2721915245,
0.0324298814,
0.2768316269,
0.6443638802,
0.4297290444,
0.6011840701,
0.5193933249,
0.3799117804,
-0.1899764836,
0.3468138278,
0.2955258787,
0.3032526076,
0.2273145765,
-0.2054170817,
-0.403673023,
0.0303927399,
0.8425936699,
1.090814352,
-0.3534759283,
-0.1372952163,
-0.1249985993,
0.4736191034,
-0.3219014108,
0.2661188543,
-0.6934623122,
0.2424223572,
-0.7156733274,
-0.282176584,
0.1585047543,
-0.0515320823,
0.4300192893,
-0.3630268276,
0.3617708683,
0.1111831889,
0.5883436203,
0.0949022546,
-0.1614504606,
-0.2584741116,
-1.1228859425,
0.7652509809,
-0.4675479829,
0.8474712968,
0.3745490015,
0.5545348525,
-0.1945889741,
-0.2109643221,
-0.7083407044,
-0.0125930309,
0.4299506247,
-0.1691717356,
-0.2143047899,
0.1997915357,
0.227924332,
0.3837609589,
-0.2342368662,
0.1629456431,
-0.5395905375,
0.014514477,
0.4895657003,
-0.0093185874,
0.3064607084,
-0.1139854118,
-0.1031873822,
-0.0655225515,
-0.3299721777,
-0.202373758,
0.2141153961,
0.6045491099,
-0.2704559267,
0.5323922038,
-0.1211229339,
0.7473943233,
0.3709439635,
-0.0496091843,
0.2953070998,
-0.3385332525,
-0.090773426,
0.5670344234,
0.4868726134,
0.1435139626,
-0.0495881438,
-0.0012539601,
0.0466897376,
-0.0718708113,
-0.1042814478,
-0.1543934345,
-0.2705407739,
0.3407274485,
-0.3665308356,
-0.0030344105,
0.1025406569,
-0.7903589606,
-0.0804228708,
-0.6417973042,
-0.1930191666,
-0.454172641,
-0.2394897491,
-0.1838093251,
-0.1071625426,
0.3279889822,
0.2285905927,
-1.0898869038,
0.4778315127,
0.6051501036,
0.9205322862,
-0.2787083089,
-0.0943409055,
-0.9318318367,
0.1493490636,
-0.3077742159,
0.8996075988,
-0.5514032841,
-0.5754024386,
-0.2659925222,
-0.0157866944,
-0.0179907456,
-0.8561083674,
0.3637004793,
-0.4160933197,
0.5156279206,
-0.2701164484,
-0.2495972812,
-0.2963810563,
0.1049938425,
-0.4423322976,
0.7751445174,
0.2455299497,
-0.6380622983,
0.4672573507,
-0.577101171,
-0.0126848826,
0.1102952957,
-0.4802317023,
-0.5327252746,
-0.1300870031,
0.553021431,
0.1056463942,
0.0709679499,
-0.0169314835,
-0.7215092778,
0.0283493511,
0.0036427779,
-0.3369517326,
0.7027302384,
0.3550613821,
-0.2030103207,
0.5182481408,
-1.064170599,
-0.1283056736,
-0.4987491667,
-0.1789636761,
-0.4606208801,
0.2839163244,
0.2909206748,
0.3505924642,
-0.2781935036,
-0.5135446787,
-0.0840280876,
-0.5591699481,
0.2008576244,
0.4636428952,
0.4401047826,
0.4128110409,
-0.2670894265,
0.5831772685,
0.3484049141,
0.0582778789,
0.0661162883,
-0.6849527955,
-0.3282287717,
-0.7826840281,
-0.1374678314,
0.5965958238,
-0.4360558689,
0.7001228333,
0.1011626199,
-0.4784887731,
-0.2767293751,
-0.0867970511,
0.2202344388,
0.4078507721,
0.3818817139,
-0.4527737498,
-0.693274498,
-0.6260510087,
0.004826643,
-0.1537879109,
-0.3553984761,
0.4175938964,
-0.0261197314,
0.0878521875,
1.0698318481,
-0.3002063334,
-0.5944547653,
0.0581277534,
-0.0724656507,
0.1332124919,
0.3287524879,
0.510800004,
-0.9211648703,
-0.4025869668,
0.2647805512,
-0.4649664164,
-0.3417359293,
-0.0701951459,
0.0042270031,
0.0448397994,
0.6374427676,
-0.3459944427,
0.288441807,
0.5340808034,
-0.0608430505,
0.6761065125,
0.1158729121,
0.2719073892,
-0.7986345887,
-0.2174747884,
-0.0336708501,
-0.2889207602,
-0.8036516309,
-0.4528324306,
-0.4644448459,
-0.2962592244,
-0.5060073137,
-0.0261137895,
-0.6087499261,
-0.7072756886,
-0.2072357833,
0.8155799508,
-0.2585659325,
0.6654340029,
0.2810195684,
0.5235086679,
0.6503651738,
-0.7324041128,
0.4821166098,
0.6010207534,
-0.2955192327,
0.8823481798,
-0.247303158,
0.3227314949,
0.3003695011,
0.1273169369,
-0.958704412,
-0.066554144,
0.5566216707,
-0.3216375709,
0.004735129,
-0.1482588053,
0.0575923175,
-0.1832454652,
-0.3657079935,
0.661888659,
-0.0215105116,
-0.5023949146,
0.3599553108,
0.8501090407,
-0.523045063,
-0.0250426605,
-0.1510142833,
0.1047759652,
-0.582332015,
-0.9101547003,
0.6072859764,
0.2131669521,
-0.624478817,
-0.2527970672,
-0.0383989923,
-0.4296042025,
-0.4362097085,
0.3197280467,
0.3247075379,
-0.1273270845,
-0.189141959,
-0.0621712096,
0.013288836,
-0.0999351442,
-0.3657014668,
0.7392972708,
0.0391438752,
-0.5687031746,
-0.9579393268,
0.7159277201,
0.5452762246,
-0.2626836002,
0.3484724462,
0.5840762854,
-0.4173481464,
0.1756088138,
-0.5399434566,
-0.1707942784,
-0.4444957376,
0.3932898641,
-0.2162747532,
-0.7532994151,
0.7905359268,
-0.1082965881,
0.1705014408,
0.414098382,
0.361869216,
-0.0742332712,
0.8880731463,
0.4814469218,
0.0217259619,
0.794026196,
0.2011496127,
0.1313778609,
-1.2037661076,
-0.1932836771,
-1.0326097012,
0.0587511398,
-0.6328887343,
-0.6175020337,
0.6436815858,
0.3617189825,
0.1725936234,
0.2606345713,
-0.490567565,
0.0561307967,
0.5501869321,
-0.2719662189,
0.2358874828,
0.2356611937,
-0.0709678531,
-0.1832510531,
-0.4337798953,
-0.2887672782,
0.4103316367,
0.2659684718,
0.0061470829,
-0.2171729803,
0.6810848713,
0.0610985383,
-0.1155793816,
-0.7760564685,
0.4038021266,
0.2343907654,
-0.6543209553,
-0.7859181166,
-0.3817762733,
-0.860419035,
0.6231428385,
0.0413127542,
-0.8694965839,
0.7942060232,
-0.0906508118,
-0.3655858636,
0.32289657,
-0.3065455556,
0.2154119015,
0.0423733704,
0.3367917836,
-0.305059284,
-0.5283929706,
0.0971585512,
-0.2379292846,
0.6231979728,
-0.2824981213,
0.5170406699,
0.9632075429,
-0.5565428734,
0.4428575337,
-0.3966723382,
-0.3056529164,
0.5097447634,
-0.2141204327,
0.2672204673,
-0.1862624437,
-0.1280865967,
0.6416057944,
0.1314264238,
0.1475319117,
-0.2681850195,
0.3927839994,
-0.4931971133,
-0.5118442178,
-0.2387995273,
-0.2542869747,
-0.4519945383,
0.1024096608,
0.2307141572,
0.5536728501,
-0.3405564725,
-0.0767813995,
-0.0044317399,
-0.3143226206,
0.6913292408,
0.244566679,
-0.1555879861,
-0.7595046759,
0.6169103384,
0.1073295847,
0.2087836415,
0.0217506662,
-0.0548132434,
-0.3701824248,
-0.7351160049,
-0.3315731287,
0.1443238854,
-0.4423642755,
0.2319567949,
-0.4000584483,
-0.2054311782,
-0.3978776634,
-0.1159932092,
-0.4579526484,
-0.5852556825,
-0.3820716739,
0.1025977805,
-0.185449928,
0.5234937668,
-0.2774675786,
0.2423928082,
-1.0039335489,
0.5931850076,
0.2500615716,
-0.0761609152,
-0.2690620422,
-0.2975046337,
-0.1780536473,
0.1563653648,
-0.6961951852,
-0.8507178426,
0.7008318901,
0.18625696,
0.502799809,
0.6576766968,
0.0872675329,
0.931881547,
-0.6669824719,
0.7997090816,
0.5756118894,
-0.9780871272,
0.5223858953,
-0.607727766,
0.2665289938,
0.2665368617,
-0.0881253481,
-0.9280115366,
-0.5345304012,
-0.3907601535,
-0.8110271096,
1.2447173595,
0.4554804564,
-0.3147305548,
-0.190224275,
0.1344693005,
-0.0318182632,
0.1414816976,
-0.2870937288,
-0.4848027229,
0.1268628538,
0.1922523677,
0.3056311905,
-0.0937642455,
-0.2691404521,
-0.099153541,
0.4813869894,
0.2640090883,
0.3743131161,
0.497082144,
0.4806922972,
-0.4018391967,
0.4109397531,
0.5792692304,
0.7118703127,
-0.2918201685,
-0.0447687767,
0.3592967689,
-0.5302012563,
0.0811866224,
0.1784600466,
0.3810430169,
0.3049480915,
0.4314272702,
0.5385942459,
0.1221357137,
-0.2765524089,
0.2487277538,
0.005458985,
-0.2632920742,
-0.4547537863,
0.0255181603,
-0.1922144145,
0.4181599617,
0.5966506004,
0.3464589417,
0.3446170688,
-0.4390176535,
0.5003472567,
0.4194524288,
-0.8280441761,
-0.40296188,
0.5554013848,
0.4786174595,
-0.810762465,
0.7223083973,
-0.0961288139,
-0.40517959,
0.531011641,
0.0632853135,
1.0530539751,
-0.7355527878,
-0.2232584208,
-0.0830682442,
-0.1723831147,
0.5009306669,
0.4536959529,
-0.4295684397,
-0.7232678533,
-0.2173895985,
-0.5104986429,
-0.4049752951,
-0.0581340119,
-0.7197281718,
0.3989984989,
-0.2257438004,
-0.3351276815,
0.3581236899,
-0.1043679193,
-0.2414833903,
-0.1665402949,
0.4239270687,
0.1223510429,
-0.2537244558,
0.7930560708,
0.1246904731,
0.3884662986,
-0.6251980662,
-0.0618895814,
0.1984384954,
-0.245225668,
0.3603920341,
0.0999938622,
-0.6522545218,
-0.3229646385,
-0.1851134747,
-0.6676335335,
0.8556597829,
0.2674902976,
-1.2402591705,
0.0230732057,
0.2351151109,
0.1892603636,
-0.3764717281,
-0.1236094087,
0.2801010311,
0.3351661861,
0.254117012,
-1.384424448,
-0.495985657,
0.1984906048,
-0.1835000217,
0.1690401733,
-0.362991482,
0.5287086964,
-0.1526823491,
-0.4587755799,
-0.1688139588,
0.6692395806,
0.6673811078,
0.6195124388,
1.0856612921,
0.0823334083,
0.9532155395,
0.0445192643,
0.491307497,
-0.2716963887,
0.2250868678,
1.1333159208,
-0.4612490535,
0.7734024525,
0.4132442176,
-0.4643975794,
0.3545517921,
0.6904459,
0.0456842482,
0.6137270927,
0.1784592122,
-0.5587489009,
-0.19685103,
0.0848913789,
-0.6869415641,
1.0241897106,
0.4614728093,
-0.0026696427,
-0.3046522141,
0.2916797101,
-0.2433316112,
-0.2135122716,
-0.1564275771,
0.7609857917,
0.24810265,
-0.4923697114,
0.3966979086,
0.2264066488,
0.3154704273,
-0.3670757413,
-0.293248415,
0.167329967,
0.0400179103,
-0.1878620088,
-0.2238131166,
0.59991014,
-0.2920961678,
-0.0739560872,
0.0943743065,
0.235088408,
-0.5624788404,
-0.1957279891,
0.375410229,
0.3045359254,
0.2969045341,
-0.4052380919,
-0.449598521,
0.1274356842,
0.0340342969,
0.1201399565,
0.1238462701,
0.6194742918,
-0.2442447096,
0.4641505778,
0.7804179192,
0.1096714363,
0.104262203,
0.3893988431,
0.8478522301,
-0.5636575222,
-0.9994511604,
-0.7148867846,
-0.2189007252,
-0.0546366014,
-0.2060614675,
0.9148412943,
0.583565712,
0.4861440361,
0.2208307683,
0.3760983348,
0.1556863338,
0.694742918,
-0.3700667024,
0.3821801543,
0.0176447686,
0.5499131083,
-0.8493459225,
-1.1247380972,
-0.5827022195,
0.6242687702,
-0.2098142654,
0.1974574924,
0.5910468698,
0.5596094131,
-0.0254186019,
0.3230776191,
0.4303742349,
-0.1268881559,
0.7457488775,
0.002482194,
0.9769915342,
-0.0987146646,
0.4312624335,
-0.3955102265,
-0.2860518396,
-0.0109291859,
-0.4167318642,
-0.5115931034,
-0.9437001348,
-0.7234702706,
0.1369070858,
-0.1713421047,
0.7217987776,
1.2592439651,
-0.9057792425,
-0.3812952638,
-0.1449198723,
0.0992164239,
-0.535846293,
-0.2618364096,
0.7044517398,
-0.2313476056,
-0.8717534542,
0.8350152969,
0.743984282,
-0.0362178385,
-0.1058452204,
0.0073923506,
-0.3032718897,
-0.0310718324,
0.3713911474,
0.3353416324,
-0.5700037479,
-0.4714015722,
-0.3884141147,
0.3279098272,
0.3706153631,
0.6854891181,
-0.5073687434,
0.5261324048,
0.1573639959,
-0.3447743356,
0.5865941644,
0.3020039797,
0.5526505709,
-0.8401970267,
0.3994240165,
0.3371042013,
0.1857168227,
0.2157748491,
-0.2630234063,
0.1165875345,
0.3978266418,
-0.835766077,
-0.7914893627,
0.0138529791,
-1.3117712736,
-0.0168136079,
0.8462875485,
-0.0054583033,
-0.0629497394,
-1.0611627102,
-0.3709874153,
0.3516475856,
-0.312079668,
0.9418637156,
0.8091746569,
-0.6411678791,
-0.0294741802,
-0.3516114354,
0.7868420482,
-0.0408536494,
-0.7781806588,
0.2449567765,
0.8181611896,
0.0798113048,
0.5033866763,
0.8819056749,
-0.5257721543,
0.2318117619,
-0.0799431577,
-0.1554332674,
0.0659647733,
-0.5018338561,
-0.3102152944,
0.3901733756,
-0.1393365413,
-0.902344048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04233v1 | Transfer Learning from Pre-trained Language Models Improves End-to-End Speech Summarization | 2023-06-07T08:23:58 | 2023-06-07T08:23:58 | Kohei Matsuura, Takanori Ashihara, Takafumi Moriya, Tomohiro Tanaka, Takatomo Kano, Atsunori Ogawa, Marc Delcroix | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end speech summarization (E2E SSum) directly summarizes input speech
into easy-to-read short sentences with a single model. This approach is
promising because it, in contrast to the conventional cascade approach, can
utilize full acoustical information and mitigate to the propagation of
transcription errors. However, due to the high cost of collecting
speech-summary pairs, an E2E SSum model tends to suffer from training data
scarcity and output unnatural sentences. To overcome this drawback, we propose
for the first time to integrate a pre-trained language model (LM), which is
highly capable of generating natural sentences, into the E2E SSum decoder via
transfer learning. In addition, to reduce the gap between the independently
pre-trained encoder and decoder, we also propose to transfer the baseline E2E
SSum encoder instead of the commonly used automatic speech recognition encoder.
Experimental results show that the proposed model outperforms baseline and data
augmented models. | [
-0.3037561178,
-0.401591897,
0.2936780453,
-0.1771047711,
-0.5984976888,
0.0776090175,
-0.3284598887,
-0.6166937947,
0.3180705011,
0.4935231507,
-0.2850730121,
-0.1604244709,
-0.8112727404,
0.0185810719,
-0.563085258,
1.1410336494,
0.0359681174,
0.0288588163,
-0.1185936704,
0.1732877195,
-0.2171539515,
-0.556080997,
-0.6214421391,
-0.1815153509,
0.1880546212,
0.3688691258,
0.3069655299,
0.2973382175,
0.3505575657,
0.1851294786,
-0.0639798939,
0.2874384522,
-0.6987124085,
-0.2526943088,
-0.0687972978,
-0.4480519891,
-0.4659209251,
-0.1148453578,
0.6083995104,
0.82741189,
-0.2085636407,
0.2122553885,
0.3216242194,
0.6687712669,
-0.4863236845,
0.1061515287,
-0.431221962,
-0.0967346653,
0.0497996174,
-0.2170314193,
-0.6463337541,
-0.3530040979,
0.4413459003,
-0.5190236568,
-0.0754968375,
-0.116963543,
0.8443989158,
0.3377885818,
-0.4618940055,
-0.1709756553,
-0.991590023,
0.4615721703,
-0.7808117867,
0.3237304389,
0.3260295391,
0.3581227362,
0.0891043991,
-0.8417411447,
-0.3881962299,
-0.1486854106,
-0.1743355691,
0.2838291228,
-0.2623786628,
-0.0289822537,
-0.1220615283,
0.2402698249,
-0.688562572,
0.1122241318,
-0.7808722854,
-0.094076477,
0.4325090945,
-0.1255957931,
0.3611395359,
0.2035191804,
-0.2090746462,
0.0203296244,
-0.6108897924,
-0.0035661391,
-0.0101819932,
0.5211828947,
-0.4853467941,
0.2906848788,
-0.1006646752,
0.7724415064,
-0.0919485018,
0.3105124533,
0.2598049343,
-0.5311360359,
-0.1544367522,
0.276634872,
0.5993637443,
0.2785528004,
0.6495858431,
-0.2880047858,
-0.0092665851,
-0.079306215,
0.0724486783,
-0.9647892118,
-0.0564113073,
0.0693884939,
-0.2809621096,
-0.0560468212,
0.1954232454,
-0.4622609317,
0.2494211346,
-0.643867135,
0.4078484476,
-0.3124721348,
-0.2089107037,
0.2052949965,
-0.0300977249,
0.2489904761,
0.26903826,
-0.7375612259,
0.5523121953,
0.3975766599,
1.1436567307,
-0.1970969141,
-0.253374815,
-0.8740671277,
0.4684412479,
-0.2294251621,
0.902475059,
-0.1750499159,
-0.4345315397,
-0.0869426802,
-0.0912535414,
-0.1058200002,
-0.3576365411,
0.3334178627,
-0.2166246474,
0.3650007844,
0.1447889656,
-0.6582738161,
0.0027239353,
-0.2860423028,
-0.5515524745,
0.7387522459,
0.1668450981,
-0.5212929249,
-0.0241152328,
-0.5267065167,
-0.8057941198,
-0.1201052144,
-0.0327449627,
-0.3264552653,
0.2680929899,
0.2389004529,
0.4071982801,
-0.1211343631,
0.2541925609,
-0.0510841869,
-0.4444583356,
0.0701541305,
-0.1706886739,
0.6262541413,
0.2892000973,
0.046690125,
-0.0497714356,
-0.6835004091,
-0.2309403867,
0.082814306,
-0.1444574445,
-0.3375844061,
-0.2679673135,
0.0457186028,
0.1447591037,
0.1243829578,
-0.2576774359,
-0.0829164237,
-0.5081785917,
0.453530699,
0.5244199038,
-0.2487444878,
0.8505334258,
-0.4853271246,
0.2646591067,
-0.0284759384,
-0.1857496351,
-0.3917840123,
-0.0998280495,
-0.5854121447,
-0.1781926304,
0.4185319245,
0.7562699914,
-0.4768339694,
0.6355849504,
-0.6755455136,
-0.4315740764,
-0.6729717851,
-0.0037201515,
0.1936404109,
0.7645327449,
0.5306393504,
-0.2304320186,
-0.7128466964,
-0.7084584236,
-0.2278737128,
-0.1480645835,
-0.1672312766,
-0.0333376192,
0.2790558934,
-0.0260703675,
1.0021635294,
-0.3324187398,
-0.4316504002,
-0.7697485089,
0.2006435245,
0.1742937863,
0.5162191391,
0.3538269997,
-0.4744651616,
-0.4735721946,
0.0360690169,
-0.7221598029,
-0.1756104529,
-0.2237369418,
-0.2682387531,
-0.0341025516,
0.5778406262,
-0.571518302,
0.3849884868,
0.4401821792,
-0.1104292125,
0.3596146107,
-0.3783347011,
0.0267520677,
-1.5234922171,
0.0224121921,
-0.0999827832,
-0.5605304241,
-0.9843919277,
-0.3200575709,
0.0274505559,
-0.2097635865,
-0.6384343505,
0.3652149737,
-0.5606873035,
-0.3694922328,
-0.518845737,
0.1673595607,
-0.0671527088,
0.4892752469,
0.376878351,
0.8612284064,
0.4191778302,
-0.8338032961,
0.0118630687,
0.3132196367,
-0.275531292,
0.276367873,
-0.6941850781,
0.2332347482,
-0.414270252,
0.5375497341,
-0.8173788786,
-0.0957861766,
-0.103226237,
-0.6947835088,
0.6245489717,
-0.0584077239,
0.0393388085,
-0.0078806495,
-0.215196386,
0.2821807265,
0.8678429127,
-0.5145692825,
0.7845287323,
0.4517666698,
-0.5969814062,
-0.2505080998,
-1.0359400511,
0.1379104257,
-0.1121424213,
-0.4018381834,
0.6437357664,
0.0596618019,
0.0584112704,
-0.0463723429,
0.0993022025,
-0.030476287,
-0.0288594794,
-0.1651608199,
0.3418117464,
-0.2457986772,
-0.0313662663,
0.2409635782,
-0.2328284681,
-0.0877615362,
-0.2882413864,
0.4684023559,
0.0223178826,
-0.066614747,
-0.7594530582,
0.4532024264,
0.488948375,
-0.3172607422,
0.7221945524,
0.3001083732,
-0.6042138338,
-0.2245772332,
-0.2081258595,
-0.2514795363,
-0.3299143314,
0.7511924505,
-0.2811792791,
-0.8266808987,
0.2587297857,
-0.2293250412,
0.2614420652,
0.1275440007,
0.2517238259,
-0.2847185433,
0.7606146932,
0.644166708,
-0.2654111683,
0.6998251677,
-0.209634617,
0.1877763867,
-0.9653753042,
-0.0715157986,
-0.4748065174,
-0.0577871874,
-0.0204429124,
-0.3647900224,
0.1082037389,
0.4078809619,
-0.1520473957,
0.4647116959,
-0.1448571384,
0.6071014404,
0.2979083061,
0.3319539726,
0.2233250737,
0.279214114,
0.3864566386,
0.1759665012,
-0.5664418936,
-0.5724933147,
1.0845322609,
0.2858181,
0.6175175905,
0.2385773808,
0.964053154,
0.4736610949,
0.2118164003,
-0.6271966696,
0.334315002,
-0.4625819027,
0.1681528389,
-0.4640828371,
-0.5197271109,
-0.6127907634,
0.273119241,
0.0767087489,
-0.5084489584,
-0.0394349024,
0.2071558237,
-0.523126781,
0.131078735,
-0.6996796727,
0.3840583265,
-0.2637496293,
-0.2885700762,
-0.1239149645,
-0.7798191309,
0.3267199993,
-0.0674824566,
0.5508831143,
0.1087266281,
0.0929400846,
0.9162963629,
-0.5483646989,
0.7893939614,
-0.0975235477,
-0.0006394516,
0.286080718,
-0.0331239961,
0.6847761869,
-0.3037216365,
0.2046003789,
-0.0226051081,
-0.3280645013,
-0.3771374822,
-0.5850073695,
0.2837659419,
-0.8810860515,
-0.2906114757,
-0.215439707,
-0.2518850267,
-0.2677607536,
0.0231126025,
0.3782078326,
0.4790747762,
-0.3346196711,
-0.0250544753,
0.7207725644,
-0.0625557378,
0.4791867137,
0.5098655224,
-0.2217929065,
-0.4681910276,
0.8468797207,
0.1018276811,
0.6079103947,
0.4841309786,
0.1365635544,
-0.3624331653,
-0.5642120242,
-0.536613524,
0.2196135819,
-0.5315869451,
-0.0262455307,
-0.7280784845,
-0.5043275356,
-0.7032547593,
-0.2536287308,
-0.5083809495,
-0.4049643576,
-0.5731609464,
-0.4693567157,
0.1791110188,
0.5390838385,
-0.3518635929,
0.6104958057,
-1.032597661,
0.3937817812,
0.2033957243,
-0.0435335003,
-0.1071378663,
-1.3863825798,
-0.4003354013,
0.1372105479,
0.2868985832,
-1.063575387,
0.5071409941,
0.7155829072,
0.4362677932,
0.2807256579,
0.0323016495,
0.7263846993,
-0.5135899782,
0.6546451449,
0.5006483197,
-0.971544683,
0.6960563064,
-0.0212394297,
0.4746990204,
0.6215153337,
0.2521017492,
-0.5100052953,
-0.1746173203,
-0.0959439799,
-0.7684713006,
0.8757389188,
0.1613267809,
0.1634618938,
0.1429889351,
0.1719024032,
0.1997159868,
-0.1784065366,
-0.5326595902,
-0.023656968,
-0.225777179,
-0.4349233806,
-0.2791049778,
-0.19041574,
0.2294744849,
-0.2102784365,
0.8311454654,
-0.0231730118,
0.2166171074,
0.2541925013,
-0.8281159997,
0.0063909278,
0.3988932073,
0.7561784983,
0.4322071075,
-0.3056911528,
0.3489850163,
0.4604135156,
-0.3887772858,
0.1875903606,
0.1462937444,
-0.1213073209,
0.143800661,
0.4523019195,
0.9999829531,
0.360616833,
-0.5119288564,
0.5610202551,
-0.1053673774,
-0.3336560428,
-0.3884166181,
-0.407949537,
0.2413111925,
-0.1399683505,
0.3243854344,
0.0323571339,
0.2816006243,
-0.521543324,
0.4978401959,
-0.0192402191,
-0.2823187411,
-0.4706869423,
0.5608730316,
0.4112612307,
-0.282047838,
0.679117322,
0.1936201453,
-0.5358566642,
0.5543345809,
0.8229206204,
0.8379859924,
-0.5896624327,
0.1844001263,
0.4536578357,
0.4453048408,
-0.1489450932,
0.2409165353,
-0.1719633341,
-0.5115172267,
-0.6619647741,
-0.5822130442,
-0.2753426135,
-0.0747741759,
-0.9200841188,
0.4151333869,
-0.1582783014,
0.0889745653,
-0.3787267208,
-0.53436023,
-0.6299663186,
0.0801151618,
0.5794014931,
0.7264042497,
-1.0470095873,
0.8534587026,
0.3740325868,
-0.615576148,
-0.6038159728,
-0.3602431715,
-0.3924847841,
-0.6384583712,
0.3760426641,
0.2796408236,
-0.3428068161,
0.2173458338,
-0.3001442552,
-0.9375510812,
1.0174558163,
0.5334553123,
-1.0434017181,
-0.295170486,
0.2550650537,
0.3600470424,
-0.5479114056,
0.5340358019,
0.6436277628,
-0.0197073426,
0.2187103331,
-1.0831022263,
-0.1907046735,
-0.1959570646,
-0.0465937592,
0.1211611629,
-0.4568521082,
0.6003397107,
-0.4997649193,
-0.4531385303,
-0.1910074204,
1.2405575514,
0.1128525808,
0.2008240074,
0.335880816,
0.5188970566,
0.6856139898,
0.0727854148,
0.8130589724,
-0.2464224398,
0.0597389378,
1.7513408661,
-0.370788753,
1.1868436337,
0.3723081052,
-0.2042810917,
0.3742428422,
0.5584602952,
0.4402968585,
0.9049539566,
0.2896710634,
-0.2176616341,
-0.2402181029,
-0.1485443115,
-0.6193422079,
0.3012115955,
0.2626456916,
-0.3506546319,
-0.2452007383,
0.3617986143,
-0.1400834173,
0.1629526019,
-0.4072464406,
1.0753959417,
0.3659971356,
-0.3951733708,
0.3612135649,
-0.3363530636,
0.8095644712,
-0.7529491186,
-0.0678308383,
-0.413322866,
-0.0224972684,
-0.2666156888,
-0.3245026171,
0.5482554436,
0.147086516,
-0.0745400116,
-0.1897901446,
0.6967002749,
-0.7850846052,
-0.3943140507,
0.3371031582,
0.6797952652,
0.5227624178,
0.0641214252,
-0.247661218,
-0.2862332761,
-0.0123081626,
-0.1535600573,
0.4693108499,
0.0749717429,
0.1646490544,
0.2877075076,
0.7923051715,
0.2430079579,
0.2014711052,
0.3724443913,
0.6730878949,
-0.5218395591,
-1.0100938082,
-0.8651719689,
0.5820320845,
-0.0884342119,
0.0312014949,
0.2648124993,
0.7606610656,
0.9254854918,
-0.1011259705,
1.1904757023,
0.2165820003,
0.7182042599,
-0.6533746123,
0.6800254583,
-0.3425413072,
0.1268269718,
0.0547494367,
-0.8393862247,
-0.0265329219,
0.5354676247,
0.0022075248,
-0.0356578901,
0.6349831223,
0.6061168909,
-0.0745852888,
0.151527971,
0.4898734391,
-0.0652286708,
0.1785951108,
0.8321967721,
0.8866147399,
-0.4380032718,
0.6141331196,
-0.0728678182,
-0.4470590651,
-0.03927112,
-0.6186877489,
-0.9002094269,
-0.4910126626,
-0.3191277385,
-0.2437568754,
0.2075329721,
1.0642427206,
0.8268454671,
-0.7622246146,
-0.4067769051,
-0.2092087716,
-0.3533679247,
-0.0803659484,
-0.1055614725,
0.4516190588,
-0.2231884599,
-0.7663994431,
0.6651729345,
0.0759685859,
0.4360303283,
0.1015889496,
-0.4091771245,
-0.0589396805,
0.1065628231,
0.6301611662,
0.3266051412,
-0.425624311,
0.0584322028,
-0.1896591783,
-0.0307017025,
-0.1146739647,
0.857370019,
-0.8178856969,
0.1667598337,
0.5555632114,
1.0035544634,
0.6207048297,
-0.0590099879,
0.8783590198,
-0.5371881723,
-0.0180091783,
0.0259010643,
0.4991945922,
0.2551325262,
-0.3137915134,
0.4362918735,
0.0265316851,
-0.1939262003,
-0.8507421017,
0.1253603399,
-0.9407307506,
-0.3252267838,
0.9694567919,
-0.2443990409,
-0.2696145475,
-0.0306312405,
-0.0691620857,
0.8184871078,
-0.259255439,
0.4157960713,
0.4132412374,
-0.0679037943,
-0.3954696357,
-0.2316195965,
0.3739614189,
0.5865063667,
-1.2989993095,
0.1785071194,
0.3433725536,
0.273884654,
-0.2193430513,
0.7610364556,
-0.0089535546,
0.3309165239,
-0.1888914704,
0.1255431473,
-0.4671905041,
-0.4673264027,
-0.7202752829,
-0.0296885706,
-0.1775653958,
-0.3501147032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04217v1 | Effective Neural Topic Modeling with Embedding Clustering Regularization | 2023-06-07T07:45:38 | 2023-06-07T07:45:38 | Xiaobao Wu, Xinshuai Dong, Thong Nguyen, Anh Tuan Luu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topic models have been prevalent for decades with various applications.
However, existing topic models commonly suffer from the notorious topic
collapsing: discovered topics semantically collapse towards each other, leading
to highly repetitive topics, insufficient topic discovery, and damaged model
interpretability. In this paper, we propose a new neural topic model, Embedding
Clustering Regularization Topic Model (ECRTM). Besides the existing
reconstruction error, we propose a novel Embedding Clustering Regularization
(ECR), which forces each topic embedding to be the center of a separately
aggregated word embedding cluster in the semantic space. This enables each
produced topic to contain distinct word semantics, which alleviates topic
collapsing. Regularized by ECR, our ECRTM generates diverse and coherent topics
together with high-quality topic distributions of documents. Extensive
experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate that ECRTM effectively addresses
the topic collapsing issue and consistently surpasses state-of-the-art
baselines in terms of topic quality, topic distributions of documents, and
downstream classification tasks. | [
-0.4659430087,
-1.1415894032,
0.472014308,
0.0115343817,
-0.4581475854,
0.0373487398,
-0.6387041211,
0.1528113633,
0.665039897,
0.3903520703,
-0.1084322408,
-0.7514656186,
-0.8846389651,
-0.3305170834,
-0.753703773,
0.8247403502,
0.2662287652,
0.0791001469,
-0.3775069714,
0.0272403751,
-0.6927753091,
-0.3850721419,
-0.5835832953,
-0.2617276609,
0.6245779395,
0.3957199752,
0.1667615175,
0.6729148626,
0.5244920254,
0.3022494018,
-0.5061626434,
-0.0224420726,
-0.5436801314,
0.0924109519,
0.0469571985,
-0.4111017287,
-0.473320663,
-0.1133296937,
0.6996873021,
0.9930468202,
-0.6116549373,
-0.5105234981,
0.1620189995,
0.3154063225,
-0.2625518143,
-0.2583537102,
-0.8657414317,
0.0261039175,
0.2934608757,
-0.086847499,
-0.3989946544,
-0.2000915855,
0.4416356087,
-0.2905674875,
0.5887367725,
-0.0811765566,
0.8301514983,
0.3652701974,
-0.4624985456,
0.0396519415,
-0.7023174167,
0.5806695819,
-0.5441450477,
0.3585768938,
0.2984867692,
0.1997199357,
0.139874503,
-0.9588045478,
-0.4676376879,
0.1601926386,
0.0050408118,
0.1412682235,
-0.3215511143,
-0.0709322169,
-0.2926233709,
0.2272852361,
-0.6577096581,
0.0841269419,
-0.1760843545,
0.0523821115,
-0.030375015,
0.1841990203,
0.3403823376,
-0.0322789513,
-0.3541830182,
0.0467507765,
-0.5338323116,
-0.4009763598,
0.1108970195,
0.2464517355,
0.0864605457,
0.3131939471,
-0.0085767619,
0.5083102584,
0.087158747,
0.2883024812,
-0.181026116,
-0.1601451039,
-0.0244717598,
0.2879200876,
0.2619982064,
0.6156679392,
-0.3074389696,
-0.4448201656,
-0.0023512468,
0.3456745446,
0.5403581858,
-0.8079281449,
-0.1873262376,
0.3989823163,
-0.7806812525,
-0.1050346121,
0.1595556438,
-0.6265919805,
-0.1371468455,
-0.1772061884,
0.278626889,
-0.4571509957,
-0.5200762749,
0.2918969095,
-0.1476434916,
0.2448908091,
0.3598062396,
-0.7789652944,
0.5614001155,
0.9776673913,
1.0178191662,
-0.4110822678,
-0.355116874,
-0.1545137167,
0.0745500475,
-0.3282025456,
0.9786928296,
-0.3488565385,
-0.2697289288,
-0.15084517,
0.206065774,
0.018559739,
-0.2410014868,
0.2502888441,
-0.6032701731,
0.0853399709,
0.0396233946,
-0.8893016577,
-0.1320645064,
0.6499153972,
-0.5028034449,
0.3017490506,
-0.3449088037,
-0.855015099,
0.295722723,
-0.4130365849,
0.0151595147,
-0.1571005434,
-0.1761163473,
-0.5191031694,
0.3318671584,
-0.0306565706,
0.5837899446,
-0.1621596366,
0.6107031703,
-0.1990228593,
-0.2008621842,
0.0825508982,
-0.2757968903,
0.1699557155,
-0.0182598121,
0.0012132282,
0.3424730301,
-0.5479156971,
-0.2496529967,
0.0992947891,
-0.0575414114,
-0.6349625587,
0.0602757372,
0.1681110114,
0.0776853636,
0.3434698284,
-0.5554422736,
-0.052858673,
-0.3047789633,
0.7467482686,
0.5550869107,
0.2971606255,
0.7192547321,
-0.3585202098,
0.0331380181,
0.2064247429,
-0.2635830939,
-0.404325664,
-0.5314645767,
-0.8810651898,
-0.1222528219,
0.5737171173,
0.1791653782,
-0.0984492451,
0.9766170979,
-0.3375724554,
-0.6592139602,
0.1141894534,
-0.5034852624,
-0.0249022562,
0.4955256581,
0.2863333523,
-0.251093179,
-0.2291448563,
-0.934568882,
-0.0406379439,
0.2576524019,
-0.003158815,
0.0658398867,
0.3687598705,
-0.2487375289,
0.8935500383,
-0.4904373884,
-0.4219138026,
-0.1381445676,
0.5239004493,
0.1434666216,
0.8263530135,
0.2638385296,
-0.8969221115,
-0.3522593975,
-0.0985523909,
-0.3783899844,
0.4905683994,
-0.1172522008,
-0.1424079835,
-0.1784512699,
0.6136428118,
-0.5482321978,
0.6669068933,
0.1181750894,
-0.6663754582,
0.1057318449,
-0.5594503284,
-0.1181747243,
-1.3637821674,
-0.1284032464,
-0.1168273911,
-0.1354252994,
-0.4655359089,
-0.1487844586,
0.2048809379,
-0.4180024862,
-0.1896422356,
0.1913110018,
-0.4093559682,
0.1038366035,
-0.7420398593,
0.2968586683,
0.0512717851,
0.3645069003,
0.1451599896,
0.013537189,
0.491538614,
-0.4734327197,
0.1976707429,
0.6215708852,
0.0155245028,
0.2009063512,
-1.0968837738,
0.1885311007,
-0.2788342237,
0.4328557551,
-1.0183080435,
-0.0550752841,
-0.3539938629,
-0.5151227713,
0.6171545386,
-0.2379206121,
-0.2951416373,
0.139291808,
-0.247804895,
0.268633306,
0.5760709047,
-0.3841466606,
0.6076343656,
0.3739480078,
-0.4127156138,
-0.2997254133,
-0.8588764071,
0.2827258706,
-0.3487143517,
-0.7251244783,
1.0019489527,
0.0119116176,
0.0912368298,
0.6302289963,
0.0018054091,
-0.2128154188,
0.0351492427,
0.0729746446,
-0.1236410886,
-0.2892363966,
0.256618619,
0.2327292413,
-0.3724056184,
-0.1357690543,
-0.3625946939,
0.8320132494,
-0.1168180406,
-0.3844238222,
-0.2957450151,
0.6722051501,
0.3697806299,
-0.4010330141,
0.9507318735,
0.5778033733,
-0.9095411897,
-0.2880071104,
-0.5799463391,
-0.622605145,
-0.3725760877,
0.7227894664,
0.0852367058,
-1.1396651268,
0.6653937101,
-0.3038010001,
-0.1460382938,
0.4124511182,
0.6154366732,
0.1501656473,
0.8119605184,
1.037140131,
0.108182326,
0.507081151,
-0.5606002212,
0.2108433694,
-0.8002368212,
-0.3191357553,
-0.5301603675,
-0.4175918102,
-0.4624797404,
-0.4941000938,
0.1280885339,
0.1177321076,
-0.0442012772,
-0.0387457013,
-0.786286056,
0.4297431707,
0.505027771,
0.2843051553,
0.1842523962,
0.4146365523,
-0.1793757528,
-0.1140982583,
-0.9191939235,
-0.7019451857,
0.9202293754,
0.396771729,
0.5781962276,
-0.1391998231,
0.8066807389,
0.1096044704,
0.2011885196,
-0.7740480304,
0.2212123424,
-0.4757173657,
-0.1806154549,
-0.454022944,
-0.2155430019,
-1.0854629278,
0.2744598985,
-0.0604511909,
-0.6543715596,
0.6194333434,
-0.222308442,
-0.4318828285,
0.4869845808,
-0.396786809,
0.8420053124,
0.0311108604,
-0.2478161305,
-0.6111280322,
-0.4531497359,
0.084411025,
-0.000938542,
-0.0995046198,
-0.1045107618,
-0.3011648953,
0.8793970346,
-0.5790079236,
0.8362059593,
-0.1451004148,
0.1708790362,
0.254776597,
-0.2456078678,
0.3332549334,
0.2348657101,
0.1901334375,
0.1345988363,
-0.4035024941,
-0.495473206,
-0.6883504987,
0.9851917624,
-0.781334281,
-0.4226851165,
-0.2757245898,
-0.41113168,
-0.0206978694,
0.3658504188,
0.3340046704,
0.6310405731,
-0.5939074755,
0.5366488695,
0.7655990124,
-0.3754645884,
0.5679183006,
0.4036880136,
0.0118932901,
-0.7348784208,
1.0557186604,
0.1861118525,
-0.1151652858,
0.1801935881,
0.1866674125,
-0.0438964255,
-0.8881188631,
0.0853764564,
0.099747397,
-0.6074365377,
-0.2231750786,
-1.0178661346,
-0.2044022232,
-0.268658787,
-0.2686600387,
-0.6492131948,
-0.6105703712,
-0.2437794507,
-0.2507724464,
0.191795215,
0.7116693854,
-0.1167427227,
0.424292475,
-0.9402326345,
0.2122717202,
0.3348948658,
0.3115295768,
0.2929402292,
-0.5812999606,
-0.2883955836,
-0.2119084895,
-0.4651713073,
-0.7356346846,
0.6009740829,
0.1462793201,
0.6881247759,
0.5480570197,
-0.0492820591,
0.1729006171,
-0.7145215273,
0.6328171492,
0.3879541755,
-0.6214624643,
0.6988814473,
-0.5322570801,
0.0688042268,
0.2513377368,
0.2000960708,
-0.6130031347,
-0.2608468533,
-0.7358304262,
-1.256633997,
0.3581701517,
0.2471763939,
0.4028680325,
-0.3698995113,
0.3460316658,
0.1897824556,
0.1420728266,
-0.3427592814,
-0.2626493573,
-0.3688192666,
0.0160321463,
0.0539722331,
-0.4420473278,
-0.1337904483,
-0.2358156592,
0.4122779369,
0.0808613971,
0.5729982853,
0.2481006831,
-0.043587748,
-0.0502240509,
0.0471654646,
0.5968046784,
0.6039330959,
-0.2913893461,
0.3482243717,
-0.1233964488,
-0.2778263688,
0.1724873185,
0.2383387983,
-0.1142123789,
0.1826506853,
0.1732256711,
0.4807046652,
0.2161697447,
-0.0806855112,
0.5230107903,
-0.5212368965,
-0.2607691586,
-0.1947150677,
-0.2862987816,
0.5520178676,
-0.0487501286,
0.6456517577,
0.2067958266,
-0.0086124288,
-0.1520757228,
0.5686814785,
0.1581153572,
-0.4134522676,
-0.2155813724,
0.640668273,
0.3369958997,
-0.3228738606,
0.6888161302,
-0.0937063992,
-0.6769451499,
1.1038892269,
0.6850161552,
0.9243248701,
-0.0896702856,
0.1504628062,
0.4220636785,
0.3907452226,
-0.275626421,
0.2578352094,
0.1284403056,
-0.8509078026,
-0.4138048291,
-0.4204159677,
-0.4089535773,
-0.0696825907,
-0.772482276,
0.1559109539,
-0.4041031599,
-0.1389946491,
-0.3638879657,
-0.2084741443,
-0.2854089439,
0.2843699157,
-0.1132714972,
0.8926203847,
-0.6627345085,
0.5897581577,
0.9091824293,
-0.1737187654,
-0.3771086335,
0.1042583436,
-0.541167438,
-0.0533093363,
0.2395745963,
0.1724870205,
0.4842689931,
0.2629091144,
-0.6829434633,
-0.8529663086,
1.2744570971,
0.1322708577,
-0.5552206039,
-0.0231488589,
-0.0501889586,
0.4130168557,
-0.5384821892,
-0.1033468544,
0.017046785,
0.3445470929,
-0.2511641085,
-0.2427258641,
0.1448084265,
-0.2409788817,
0.0898919478,
0.2906736732,
-0.8569347262,
0.8448771834,
0.15179497,
0.1216774434,
0.1959562153,
0.8103244901,
0.1923550367,
0.4978773296,
0.3564665318,
0.9440920353,
0.7396748662,
-0.219467327,
0.6640970707,
-0.7209939957,
0.5376586318,
1.1028404236,
0.0468047932,
0.7876545787,
0.4811910093,
0.1769049764,
0.2324606478,
0.800062716,
-0.0936872661,
0.7948945165,
0.13357234,
-0.0059304805,
-0.3788523674,
-0.1856637895,
-0.5496988893,
0.4170970619,
0.6468933821,
-0.374889791,
-0.3430448771,
0.1132013202,
-0.3990315199,
0.1901919842,
-0.1278009564,
0.6997926235,
0.4423664212,
-0.2467024773,
0.1883457154,
0.255030334,
0.8287983537,
-0.3942392766,
-0.0867126212,
-0.4306277633,
0.0348975845,
-0.0340458639,
0.0371515267,
0.6426377296,
-0.2885193527,
-0.4250547588,
-0.2522579432,
1.1240558624,
-0.5849075913,
-0.4750423133,
0.3680382073,
0.7851988673,
0.0389234051,
-0.1695149392,
-0.4127976894,
-0.009839383,
-0.4899272621,
-0.3292134106,
0.418189913,
0.8041827679,
0.0769394115,
0.3685291409,
0.3741494119,
0.0378393903,
0.0284050908,
-0.0199742559,
0.9623061419,
-0.829251647,
-0.9044899344,
-0.6857996583,
0.4926394224,
-0.1994401664,
-0.2640964091,
0.5609052777,
0.5331465006,
0.5126899481,
0.1662422866,
0.5041834712,
0.1748869568,
0.4060040414,
-0.3256975114,
1.2120374441,
-0.7138887048,
0.2437566668,
-0.1244204789,
-0.9936246872,
-0.3115903735,
0.6446222663,
-0.1328475326,
0.1829600781,
0.8382180929,
0.6088490486,
-0.2273205966,
-0.0353922397,
0.689806819,
0.3081505299,
0.1017230675,
0.2581119239,
1.102889657,
-0.2689141035,
0.5269172788,
-0.4926716685,
-0.1406344175,
-0.3135927618,
-0.8607047796,
-0.7150035501,
-0.5462729335,
-0.595330894,
-0.1623944491,
-0.0838609189,
0.6061574817,
0.8862956166,
-0.7220876217,
0.1285398751,
-0.5406216383,
0.2752081752,
0.077760905,
-0.2448753417,
0.6600722075,
-0.4105187356,
-0.4534412622,
0.2421005517,
0.3033502996,
0.0933749154,
-0.2060151994,
0.1270752996,
-0.0827399269,
-0.166776374,
0.2714656293,
-0.2527184784,
-0.6703673601,
-0.0832569897,
0.0332153887,
-0.0955342054,
0.0375140533,
1.1305449009,
-0.376390487,
0.1766844392,
0.4283863902,
0.9338415861,
0.5212933421,
-0.1196619719,
0.6106178761,
-0.7625021338,
0.0844681635,
0.3214810491,
0.5782709718,
0.3625769615,
-0.3961746991,
0.2996726036,
0.2639383078,
-0.6109474301,
-0.7499166727,
-0.1013748944,
-0.9558977485,
-0.6235781312,
0.8159537315,
-0.1749229431,
-0.3549146652,
-0.0621627904,
0.0405257531,
0.5101653934,
-0.4261912405,
0.9213129878,
0.6130607128,
-0.0026866358,
-0.1405581832,
-0.1792134941,
0.0185079873,
0.6218867302,
-0.6062244177,
-0.2291114777,
0.3410525918,
0.3397658765,
0.2770223618,
0.297151655,
-0.0751013532,
0.3710159957,
0.2164375633,
0.1606518626,
0.0048903301,
-0.4696830213,
-0.6183684468,
0.3406083584,
-0.0196977444,
-0.1157646328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04203v1 | Leveraging Knowledge Graph Embeddings to Enhance Contextual Representations for Relation Extraction | 2023-06-07T07:15:20 | 2023-06-07T07:15:20 | Fréjus A. A. Laleye, Loïc Rakotoson, Sylvain Massip | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Relation extraction task is a crucial and challenging aspect of Natural
Language Processing. Several methods have surfaced as of late, exhibiting
notable performance in addressing the task; however, most of these approaches
rely on vast amounts of data from large-scale knowledge graphs or language
models pretrained on voluminous corpora. In this paper, we hone in on the
effective utilization of solely the knowledge supplied by a corpus to create a
high-performing model. Our objective is to showcase that by leveraging the
hierarchical structure and relational distribution of entities within a corpus
without introducing external knowledge, a relation extraction model can achieve
significantly enhanced performance. We therefore proposed a relation extraction
approach based on the incorporation of pretrained knowledge graph embeddings at
the corpus scale into the sentence-level contextual representation. We
conducted a series of experiments which revealed promising and very interesting
results for our proposed approach.The obtained results demonstrated an
outperformance of our method compared to context-based relation extraction
models. | [
-0.4750833809,
-0.7939451933,
0.6145213842,
-0.0291881561,
-0.3103587925,
-0.0748383924,
-0.1995878518,
-0.5190432072,
0.3360692859,
0.5557180047,
-0.1958453804,
-0.5587605834,
-0.7013011575,
-0.0818918571,
-0.192363292,
0.8413205743,
0.1850324869,
-0.2339119017,
-0.6641048193,
-0.0930845812,
-0.5259541273,
-0.6405516863,
-0.2407502383,
-0.2029335797,
0.5763511658,
0.1170104071,
0.6581840515,
0.7928615212,
0.2647883892,
0.2110918909,
-0.1250214726,
0.3854362369,
-0.5344309807,
0.2842707932,
-0.1054371893,
-0.2244227678,
-0.2882962823,
0.0738048702,
0.7827949524,
1.1144021749,
0.0696182847,
0.0185770858,
0.0117530208,
0.3958030939,
-0.8010906577,
0.7531791329,
-0.5900239348,
-0.0646527931,
-0.2477704287,
-0.2768716812,
-0.4129571915,
-0.3531999886,
0.3149233162,
-0.9379127026,
-0.2760294378,
0.1877069473,
0.9983868003,
-0.0334142931,
-0.6163455844,
-0.3991579711,
-0.7176257968,
0.2775112689,
-0.3361626863,
0.6901707053,
0.3856137693,
0.3189457059,
0.0513171628,
-1.0128061771,
-0.1698343903,
-0.130051896,
-0.4955375493,
-0.0858160108,
-0.2072565258,
-0.1526444107,
0.3325961828,
0.2044119984,
-0.109259665,
-0.2458447367,
-0.0968387797,
-0.0214049984,
0.0869333073,
-0.1421464235,
0.3815567493,
-0.556224525,
-0.4185339212,
-0.0198948253,
-0.7948604226,
-0.089873299,
0.1874060482,
0.3976794779,
0.2266245633,
0.5835232735,
0.0826387405,
0.6854233742,
-0.1658462286,
-0.0155805303,
0.209803775,
-0.23058182,
-0.1396582276,
-0.0876033753,
0.859813273,
0.020107422,
0.6142373681,
-0.736566186,
0.0353980996,
0.0028694896,
0.3292134106,
-0.8860042095,
-0.3561565876,
-0.1710383445,
-0.1837984324,
-0.161487475,
0.1593748927,
-0.7481634617,
-0.095190458,
-0.1769067198,
0.0514120273,
-0.8259740472,
-0.4677299857,
-0.507681191,
-0.3017989397,
-0.1550372392,
0.0387479961,
-0.984941721,
0.3927635849,
0.5674823523,
0.583609283,
0.0613117516,
0.0054298276,
-0.5975856185,
0.7109219432,
-0.2632950246,
0.560801208,
-0.7611631751,
-0.2189296484,
0.1458843052,
-0.1716150045,
-0.1635795534,
-0.6279250979,
0.3121432066,
-1.0476676226,
-0.1353470832,
-0.3442385197,
-0.8886641264,
0.1739915013,
0.240661025,
-0.8199055791,
0.9605907202,
0.3797310293,
-1.0878636837,
0.309969306,
-0.613946259,
-0.61911273,
0.1790735424,
-0.3339652419,
-0.1087239087,
-0.3300768435,
0.569357872,
0.5601488948,
-0.1590337008,
0.2094857544,
-0.310698092,
-0.0027393831,
-0.0785968006,
0.2371568978,
0.7773262262,
0.117150411,
0.0531239547,
-0.081770651,
-0.6342031956,
-0.1237939894,
0.1031349823,
-0.1007098258,
-1.0248579979,
-0.2121675611,
-0.1681328863,
0.1924524903,
0.2554506958,
-0.3953944743,
0.0380971134,
-0.7113585472,
0.3434920013,
0.3894400001,
0.3655843437,
0.9154384732,
0.2907420099,
0.4793919027,
0.1772301495,
-0.3524990678,
-0.0313569903,
-0.2552160025,
-0.229367435,
-0.2120497972,
0.5594801307,
0.2687018216,
-0.9035174251,
0.6555951238,
-0.5777052641,
-0.2921971083,
-0.1145951077,
0.4140849411,
0.2190313041,
0.9469570518,
0.385340631,
-0.1420872062,
-0.5390723348,
-0.7778618932,
-0.1793866903,
-0.1267013848,
-0.0098676495,
0.3342342377,
0.3362559974,
-0.0941352546,
1.422119379,
-0.8752834201,
-0.3875247836,
-0.3289289176,
-0.0097262217,
-0.0071444744,
0.3607229888,
0.6325203776,
-0.8573338389,
-0.2199141383,
0.0464914814,
-1.1917219162,
0.1330375969,
0.3416415453,
-0.6600452065,
-0.2987562716,
0.6299647689,
-0.7450966239,
0.2957897484,
0.2197707444,
-0.256801635,
0.3393291831,
-0.113978453,
-0.3039720953,
-1.1788294315,
0.2316679955,
-0.0668052435,
-0.6191831231,
-0.4544457793,
0.1188573465,
0.2491460443,
-0.1410489976,
-0.2246883214,
0.317193836,
-0.5088345408,
-0.1982113868,
0.1501550376,
0.5553139448,
0.1528497338,
0.5681330562,
0.1991467625,
0.3033046126,
0.3592380285,
-0.6138570309,
0.1568177491,
0.592920661,
-0.2850216031,
0.39711532,
-0.3100160658,
0.0020479436,
-0.1733566523,
0.1469462216,
-0.6522325873,
-0.1056575924,
0.2554847896,
-0.3005203605,
0.4326308072,
-0.3310528994,
-0.592538476,
-0.0565802529,
-0.0296849497,
0.2263429314,
0.2948582172,
-0.5388364196,
0.6514052153,
0.885849297,
-0.0964946598,
-0.4941546023,
-0.4136688113,
-0.1649336219,
-0.3274984658,
-0.6893966198,
0.5471053123,
0.4903874695,
-0.1125047505,
0.443852365,
-0.1098789498,
-0.3174419999,
0.0249580219,
0.303683728,
0.2740548849,
-0.2561563849,
0.5728514194,
-0.0334002115,
-0.0637439564,
0.2675129175,
-0.1926746666,
0.5792775154,
0.1321001947,
0.0810705647,
-0.1898697019,
0.2583550811,
0.4245298207,
-0.4463568032,
0.964496851,
0.5942733288,
-0.688462019,
0.017901592,
-0.3356705308,
-0.17697981,
-0.3908409476,
0.4333975315,
-0.4796325564,
-0.7623032331,
0.4586012661,
-0.6833564639,
-0.346452266,
0.3971405327,
0.0641843453,
-0.0241132751,
0.5688208938,
0.6782885194,
-0.2466946691,
0.6067586541,
-0.3870000541,
0.3758417666,
-1.1353909969,
-0.3535939753,
-0.4377835989,
0.2262844741,
-0.538759768,
-0.1382530183,
0.2819594741,
0.4625191092,
-0.2322502434,
0.6765393019,
-0.0270705298,
0.1302889436,
0.3250535429,
0.1877901703,
0.4159162343,
0.1645368934,
-0.3356187046,
-0.085275121,
-0.8507372737,
-0.5153521895,
1.013318181,
0.1862372756,
0.347743392,
0.0354984365,
0.820096612,
-0.1094202027,
0.5392472148,
-0.7353512645,
0.2785216868,
-0.0012570785,
-0.3704276681,
-0.5793555975,
-0.8557052612,
-1.2591809034,
0.2101859003,
-0.3195414841,
-0.8690652251,
0.1595658958,
-0.0343923718,
-0.1618488878,
0.1740218252,
-0.6641536951,
1.1236540079,
0.1252302974,
-0.3857597411,
0.1034908965,
-0.5637593865,
0.2254156917,
0.0864210054,
0.5221156478,
0.0985196233,
0.2893737257,
0.9505526423,
-0.585801363,
0.4449436665,
-0.3427053392,
0.0470462106,
0.357513696,
0.0039622383,
0.5252107382,
0.2791041136,
-0.0967151001,
-0.0872061104,
0.0084948624,
-0.2229731828,
-0.8882548213,
0.6198911071,
-0.7515551448,
-0.3715054989,
-0.0223612748,
-0.6257711053,
-0.677003026,
0.4677379131,
0.0056677801,
0.7155300975,
-0.3998061717,
0.2294241935,
0.2257445157,
-0.069107376,
0.2692359686,
-0.2171390653,
-0.5505478978,
-0.3891619146,
0.7911878228,
0.2614033222,
0.1888857931,
0.533605516,
0.1430591941,
-0.501170218,
-0.0794940069,
-0.2325221449,
0.2520446777,
-0.7434954047,
-0.3163442612,
-0.9654043913,
-0.118072018,
-0.8591194749,
0.1953898072,
-0.335665375,
-0.3912680447,
-0.1985297501,
-0.2021879554,
0.1906685978,
0.7569376826,
0.111363709,
0.2532078326,
-0.7670868635,
0.4207866788,
0.3962488174,
0.0192344077,
0.2408200651,
0.0403930433,
-0.2991386056,
-0.141755268,
-0.2565684319,
-1.0279786587,
0.5633717179,
0.0786218792,
0.6115500927,
0.4739051163,
0.1694136411,
0.858042419,
-0.3822027147,
0.3750699461,
0.0230980236,
-0.6822788119,
0.6984969378,
-0.3485094011,
0.1059748977,
0.5279101133,
0.6583778262,
-0.0991468802,
-0.3029439151,
-0.8074521422,
-1.0146666765,
0.5826230645,
0.4855341613,
0.0839403495,
-0.1058980972,
0.5179097652,
-0.2711723745,
0.4055530131,
-0.5793296695,
-0.2685567141,
-0.0945481732,
-0.0249353871,
0.0076108915,
-0.2531231642,
-0.0665912777,
-0.4115001559,
0.3586803377,
0.0935477838,
0.3243690133,
0.1838381439,
-0.5256491303,
0.0696252808,
-0.0095964726,
-0.1957032979,
0.9005878568,
-0.3869119585,
0.3590144515,
-0.0562646203,
-0.2506801188,
-0.3538086712,
0.2971660793,
0.0291052349,
-0.0707814395,
0.6627826095,
0.4487878382,
0.6039222479,
-0.2639413178,
0.7397798896,
0.1391901672,
0.1646403521,
-0.2018284947,
-0.2665171325,
0.672164619,
0.0902131945,
0.3586139083,
0.0077372827,
0.0071843388,
-0.7265411615,
0.4568899572,
0.3738883734,
-0.4152359664,
-0.0260265488,
0.5036000609,
0.0856518447,
-0.1300482154,
0.8437922597,
-0.2218020409,
-0.57309407,
0.4055792391,
0.774140954,
0.1776651591,
-0.0390712358,
0.2206234932,
0.4116986692,
0.0001061371,
0.245474115,
-0.4134021401,
-0.3715246022,
-1.0103670359,
-0.3008973897,
-0.6912693977,
-0.2103491873,
-0.0670705587,
-0.8112540245,
0.1320790946,
-0.354151994,
-0.1914368272,
0.0145604229,
-0.0199937969,
-0.8304806352,
0.1555897892,
-0.0341318175,
0.7425227761,
-0.6245026588,
1.0641604662,
0.569427669,
-0.5641110539,
-1.0430467129,
-0.1183915287,
-0.6192212105,
-0.5516827106,
0.9302130938,
0.211992383,
0.0941937566,
0.1269109845,
-0.1488078684,
-0.8079360723,
1.1452748775,
0.7764844298,
-0.2975940704,
-0.3127091825,
0.1563235223,
0.5240197778,
-0.8371516466,
0.2160183191,
0.5455340743,
0.3031103909,
0.2368328422,
-0.4011750519,
0.4022840261,
-0.2222167104,
0.0431968123,
0.1321387887,
-0.0932666659,
0.6109622717,
0.1790858954,
-0.3881604373,
-0.3232523203,
0.8516622186,
0.125157848,
0.065765284,
0.6068640947,
0.5378851295,
0.9828616977,
0.1440709382,
1.1598584652,
-0.4682023227,
0.2772588134,
1.2932174206,
-0.2160811126,
0.9011395574,
0.5843151212,
-0.0035194324,
0.8351297975,
0.4012197554,
0.4359315932,
0.6836073995,
-0.0699598193,
0.0004685325,
-0.380140245,
-0.2780070007,
-0.426569134,
0.4128902256,
0.4384478033,
-0.7114437222,
-0.3345164657,
-0.2103393376,
0.1006874144,
0.1818240285,
-0.1873766184,
0.7437247038,
0.2255058438,
-0.6626986265,
0.2565416992,
-0.4569195509,
0.2547694147,
-0.4758313596,
-0.2037971765,
0.2064562887,
-0.1547298431,
-0.1162252948,
-0.4005599618,
0.4046657085,
-0.2103133053,
-0.059816353,
-0.272875607,
1.0365422964,
-0.4639499187,
-0.3415061235,
0.7934295535,
0.8350827098,
-0.0804118067,
-0.2835855186,
0.0488603562,
-0.2688658535,
-0.3299004734,
-0.3193683624,
0.3109178245,
0.6722505093,
0.1416305006,
0.2536248267,
0.690189898,
0.1673215926,
-0.1815413684,
0.0906673521,
1.227652669,
-0.4978514016,
-0.5373852849,
-0.8840481639,
0.3220387995,
-0.5156903863,
-0.1894626915,
0.6226529479,
0.509409368,
0.5420437455,
0.0839288533,
0.7011780143,
-0.1314502656,
0.2511564791,
-0.2879613638,
0.7049711943,
-0.2102729231,
0.217664361,
-0.6211172938,
-0.9286913872,
-0.3912619352,
0.6897670031,
-0.5984668732,
-0.0802074298,
0.8908928037,
0.5158447623,
-0.084611997,
0.0699649975,
0.3158159852,
0.2110332251,
0.2233130187,
0.5957698226,
0.6876711249,
-0.3804413974,
0.7305024266,
-0.3486940265,
-0.2168468833,
0.056729719,
-0.8566014171,
-1.060859561,
-0.6326556802,
-0.1470606774,
-0.3027404249,
0.0104877735,
0.6805123091,
0.7481169701,
-0.2893694341,
-0.0132237002,
-0.1059337556,
0.2702900171,
-0.0032543188,
-0.2386761755,
0.6651904583,
-0.459553957,
-0.4927702546,
0.4080901444,
0.1222481877,
-0.3115428686,
-0.0894840732,
0.038490314,
-0.5220733285,
-0.424110204,
0.7894614339,
-0.0845677182,
-0.0335171595,
-0.4500313997,
-0.2103653997,
-0.0857306421,
0.1659670919,
0.7850131392,
-1.0496484041,
0.2080789804,
0.4105333388,
0.7107383013,
0.9290904999,
0.2020596266,
0.8523845673,
-1.009128809,
0.0249204133,
0.121688664,
0.422380954,
0.4428716898,
-0.5105934739,
0.6008458734,
0.1931168288,
-0.2065043598,
-0.5094854832,
0.2054563463,
-0.9398413897,
-0.1880612969,
1.1376129389,
-0.5287363529,
-0.37126863,
-0.1791099906,
-0.0112912059,
0.7253402472,
-0.4761475921,
0.4166049659,
0.5665175915,
-0.2887152135,
0.0463517867,
-0.3848377466,
0.4216860235,
0.0426692516,
-0.8857560158,
-0.0435620695,
0.2230039388,
0.347630769,
0.5053725839,
0.6199692488,
-0.3512638807,
-0.1119870618,
0.0159068778,
-0.2962001264,
-0.2385407835,
-0.1842927337,
0.2682530582,
0.8933390975,
-0.0254294295,
0.0442356281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04190v1 | An ASR-Based Tutor for Learning to Read: How to Optimize Feedback to First Graders | 2023-06-07T06:58:38 | 2023-06-07T06:58:38 | Yu Bai, Cristian Tejedor-Garcia, Ferdy Hubers, Catia Cucchiarini, Helmer Strik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | The interest in employing automatic speech recognition (ASR) in applications
for reading practice has been growing in recent years. In a previous study, we
presented an ASR-based Dutch reading tutor application that was developed to
provide instantaneous feedback to first-graders learning to read. We saw that
ASR has potential at this stage of the reading process, as the results
suggested that pupils made progress in reading accuracy and fluency by using
the software. In the current study, we used children's speech from an existing
corpus (JASMIN) to develop two new ASR systems, and compared the results to
those of the previous study. We analyze correct/incorrect classification of the
ASR systems using human transcripts at word level, by means of evaluation
measures such as Cohen's Kappa, Matthews Correlation Coefficient (MCC),
precision, recall and F-measures. We observe improvements for the newly
developed ASR systems regarding the agreement with human-based judgment and
correct rejection (CR). The accuracy of the ASR systems varies for different
reading tasks and word types. Our results suggest that, in the current
configuration, it is difficult to classify isolated words. We discuss these
results, possible ways to improve our systems and avenues for future research. | [
-0.2319734693,
-0.452308625,
-0.0616910607,
0.1899108589,
-0.3082129061,
0.1981381774,
-0.2517565489,
-0.6858401299,
0.0731883645,
0.2593942583,
-0.3569667935,
-0.2978629172,
-0.6755487323,
0.4278487563,
-0.8170399666,
0.5673240423,
0.00410733,
0.3587781191,
-0.0924912393,
-0.023058895,
-0.4241903722,
-0.511515975,
-0.9658559561,
-0.4360075295,
0.611256361,
0.9102057815,
0.3211790919,
0.7360708117,
0.5727108121,
0.3763691485,
-0.3347910345,
-0.0839135349,
0.0084480559,
0.2724870443,
-0.1558866203,
-0.3361212611,
-0.1898427159,
-0.2954903543,
0.5468451977,
0.721857965,
-0.0491064303,
0.1631515324,
0.4390874803,
0.804477334,
-0.571457088,
0.2595116496,
0.0255452525,
0.201849103,
-0.3217470348,
-0.0780465007,
-0.555146277,
-0.5567778945,
0.6870512962,
-0.5706176758,
0.3673706055,
-0.0056537832,
0.5769196153,
0.2100472599,
-0.2783028483,
-0.9806717634,
-0.7362594008,
0.8260053992,
-0.4726180136,
0.4746937752,
0.5676243305,
0.480600208,
0.2940775752,
-0.2830207646,
-0.5152184367,
-0.5109654069,
-0.0991542488,
0.1866842657,
-0.1723440289,
-0.1239650548,
0.0236439202,
0.0659110919,
-0.456174016,
0.0640977249,
-0.5460703373,
-0.3420090973,
0.6430028081,
-0.0075298026,
0.1890167445,
-0.1523795426,
-0.0424154922,
-0.4049086869,
-0.174493596,
0.495439589,
0.4090029001,
0.7370965481,
0.3340568244,
0.6523928046,
-0.1984913498,
0.702283144,
0.1067156643,
-0.3094035983,
0.1939662099,
-0.1235707179,
0.2905122042,
0.4213145971,
0.3546174765,
0.2118994296,
0.533051908,
-0.2094714195,
-0.5059261322,
0.4928766191,
0.2128020078,
-0.5324348211,
-0.3775013387,
-0.2258678377,
-0.5314432979,
-0.3208068907,
0.2354550511,
-0.482378155,
-0.2892068326,
-0.550683856,
0.5953409672,
-0.6521647573,
-0.0329781398,
0.2058237642,
-0.2439822257,
0.090041697,
0.4599122107,
-0.9383279085,
0.7868821025,
0.23181054,
0.6239939332,
-0.4507065415,
-0.1020249873,
-0.3642148972,
-0.0453030579,
-0.0829657093,
1.1128810644,
-0.219885692,
-0.6014626622,
0.0937544852,
-0.1392304301,
0.0380380787,
-0.5816309452,
0.5171940327,
-0.4202956259,
0.2248835713,
-0.2702468038,
-0.6183471084,
-0.1995886713,
0.1227018759,
-0.47095263,
0.7004481554,
-0.1200098991,
-0.6863276958,
0.4121363461,
-0.7925816774,
-0.6740113497,
0.0647830218,
0.2333763093,
-0.1291130036,
-0.0864435956,
0.2535047829,
0.0514656603,
0.0863743052,
-0.2699189186,
0.3023257852,
-0.5546992421,
0.3121318221,
-0.5615739822,
0.7330392599,
0.4425964057,
-0.2985006273,
0.0215106271,
-0.7973746061,
0.2903634608,
-0.2076996714,
-0.5031271577,
-0.3145178258,
0.2198543847,
0.2278160304,
-0.3624988794,
0.1214277372,
-0.8001479506,
-0.0568102375,
-0.5345654488,
0.246882394,
0.4297873974,
-0.1448300332,
0.3407120109,
-0.4150288999,
0.6578301191,
-0.0435109064,
0.1252960116,
-0.2763076723,
-0.2075894922,
-0.9847772121,
-0.0375051796,
0.5703938603,
0.8491367102,
-0.9032339454,
0.5026757717,
0.014143764,
-0.3238013983,
-0.3188891113,
0.0185277238,
0.7372566462,
0.4446110725,
0.3122622967,
-0.6562143564,
-0.4287199974,
-0.4308293164,
-0.3167461157,
-0.5538345575,
-0.1047912464,
0.2028969824,
0.0816295743,
-0.1438200176,
0.952054739,
-0.2338819057,
-0.4227620661,
-0.0500422604,
-0.1803223193,
-0.0107549503,
0.4237896204,
0.3923935592,
-0.3966745734,
-0.6965788007,
-0.1009388864,
-0.2759432197,
-0.2720462084,
0.4899002612,
0.2735828757,
0.2109861374,
0.5164277554,
0.1140829548,
0.5171446204,
0.22368972,
-0.5955287218,
0.4814252555,
-0.2721259296,
0.0576555803,
-0.5396210551,
0.0946137235,
0.0241341162,
-0.1993424147,
-0.661608398,
-0.3004565537,
0.0900681764,
0.0206076466,
-0.3067942858,
0.5089709163,
-0.3833445907,
0.0308954567,
-0.3632988632,
0.0940672159,
-0.189120695,
0.0042625698,
-0.1743831635,
0.8496002555,
0.4160162508,
-0.6087198257,
0.3801074922,
0.6141204834,
-0.3984338045,
0.5504150987,
-0.6246828437,
0.169847399,
-0.2075140923,
-0.0749724135,
-0.9780775309,
-0.1014846191,
0.3445786536,
-0.7838301063,
0.6476244926,
0.2381190509,
-0.574030757,
-0.6751964688,
0.0518800318,
-0.0232724119,
0.2802286744,
-0.6096746325,
0.3951048851,
0.46585536,
-0.6564075351,
-0.5971024632,
-0.6656801701,
0.0123895062,
0.1106130406,
-0.3024223745,
-0.0501835197,
0.0374698453,
-0.2405767739,
0.0623074993,
-0.2719906867,
-0.4608026445,
-0.1278229952,
0.1707827896,
0.2201061398,
-0.1759610772,
0.132875219,
0.2818837166,
-0.4334643483,
-0.2269373089,
0.0017559765,
0.15389736,
-0.2181830406,
-0.2702492476,
-0.7423629165,
0.2272188514,
0.4054254293,
-0.1020625159,
0.1280199289,
0.2478335351,
0.039447818,
-0.1641115546,
-0.5277794003,
-0.3001892865,
-0.5045719147,
0.088399455,
-0.2914591432,
-0.9426951408,
0.3525725305,
0.2381302863,
0.0816119984,
0.0881921276,
0.232205078,
-0.3391304016,
0.9190081358,
0.6382160783,
-0.1024769619,
0.9264270663,
-0.1145301536,
-0.1030025259,
-0.3967579007,
-0.1061755642,
-0.7501739264,
-0.3061453998,
-0.0393695943,
-0.0261812061,
0.1135507524,
0.0049621961,
-0.1837132424,
0.2517606914,
-0.9111130238,
0.6258201599,
0.8942298293,
0.1290325373,
0.5035845041,
0.1591587067,
-0.2930955291,
-0.1015540883,
-0.6398587227,
-0.705322504,
0.8668366075,
0.1845978349,
0.8216936588,
0.1235290915,
0.5335168839,
0.431039542,
0.5845671296,
-1.103892684,
0.564864397,
-0.5765058994,
-0.6124248505,
-0.5523194075,
-0.1092777252,
-1.1642802954,
0.2494388968,
-0.0389981456,
-0.4467939138,
0.2389660776,
0.2828777432,
-0.5498840809,
-0.1155669093,
-1.0438053608,
0.4949478209,
-0.0592256896,
-0.0204072706,
-0.0313570574,
-0.740493834,
-0.2900117338,
0.1575833112,
0.0208290648,
0.1836659461,
0.0154261533,
0.7292370796,
-0.5208678842,
0.7142444253,
-0.5065333843,
0.1016875133,
0.696416378,
-0.0528974719,
-0.076886721,
-0.3649124205,
-0.3205961585,
-0.2464264184,
0.5651313663,
-0.2926011384,
-0.4366948307,
0.1825518906,
-0.9588942528,
-0.2241829336,
-0.7900767326,
-0.3102027178,
-0.2490370125,
0.355666995,
0.2204246521,
0.7122092843,
-0.1777804345,
0.1729595065,
0.3770567775,
-0.0100248465,
0.4061539769,
1.0308451653,
-0.2806765139,
-0.5370581746,
0.987942338,
0.4345698655,
-0.0773667842,
0.0885018483,
0.3025743961,
-0.505508244,
-0.7672699094,
-0.4477825463,
0.0111373533,
-0.6472764611,
-0.0895266235,
-0.3041271269,
-0.2262603492,
-0.4936838746,
-0.2292221636,
-0.0263932049,
-0.4408478737,
-0.4671006501,
0.097712703,
0.2781645954,
0.7535281777,
-0.189504385,
0.6500714421,
-0.7670274377,
0.0380932577,
0.2438912243,
0.4321017861,
0.1266582906,
-0.6346019506,
-0.3341043293,
-0.1037236452,
-0.4408625066,
-0.6707094908,
0.5241601467,
0.3594072461,
0.273358047,
0.4751328826,
0.1583547443,
0.5833889842,
-0.6321170926,
0.5946099162,
-0.0116294287,
-0.9909650087,
0.6425268054,
-0.0868221819,
0.3848182261,
0.8371192217,
-0.1064067036,
-0.5230987668,
-0.4115602076,
-0.2201617509,
-0.5471978188,
0.9579176903,
-0.0911056548,
0.0687609911,
0.0882067159,
0.5147637725,
0.2382267267,
0.1633397192,
-0.2052525878,
-0.2172610611,
-0.1815363914,
-0.4448570013,
-0.3593159914,
-0.2321473062,
0.2369541228,
-0.5911844969,
0.6317188144,
-0.0638932958,
0.1479932666,
0.3517743647,
-0.318584621,
-0.1807973236,
0.1994286031,
0.3681980968,
0.343735069,
-0.0014188656,
-0.0128418682,
0.1022115275,
-0.9844744802,
0.3818374574,
0.1389872432,
-0.3396947682,
0.2915277183,
0.3640203774,
0.4567520022,
0.2498483062,
-0.7409306765,
0.5608225465,
-0.3186927736,
-0.2800446153,
-0.6131212711,
0.289524436,
-0.3352452517,
0.4752980769,
0.2706135809,
0.2577336431,
0.2398344874,
-0.2509481907,
0.2855328918,
0.0801547244,
-0.5034169555,
-0.2619633675,
0.3537979424,
0.304372102,
-0.7623201609,
0.517819941,
-0.1753419936,
-0.5248035192,
0.4122409225,
0.6059000492,
0.803609848,
-0.5616947412,
0.2663823366,
0.2451408803,
0.245310694,
-0.2449817657,
0.3975064754,
-0.4657654166,
-0.8431915045,
-0.2369084656,
-0.5410966873,
-0.8326836824,
-0.5908820033,
-1.0387438536,
0.2597196102,
-0.4578628838,
-0.4275022447,
0.1691860855,
0.3059538007,
-0.3964244723,
0.1704550385,
0.0501465015,
0.7808808088,
-0.6619895697,
0.7718088031,
1.0311242342,
-0.2307054847,
-0.6835102439,
-0.0023594829,
0.0163841695,
-0.4300511479,
0.6721074581,
0.2393165529,
-0.3929712176,
0.2681888342,
-0.3236427307,
-0.9384536743,
0.8026895523,
0.037802089,
-0.5569309592,
-0.1721775681,
-0.1295492202,
0.888759017,
0.0075477767,
0.2767783999,
0.4956151247,
0.3441053033,
0.4614991248,
-1.0307400227,
-0.5710614324,
-0.3583708405,
0.0946207047,
-0.074076362,
-0.5254002213,
0.3684099317,
-0.0800901279,
-0.3382517993,
0.401645869,
0.7941358089,
0.0329797529,
0.5396468043,
0.7339010239,
0.3072122931,
0.7577890158,
0.0767672062,
0.9674899578,
-0.2441234589,
0.1570400149,
0.9341355562,
-0.1302152425,
1.0258606672,
0.4098972082,
-0.3815255761,
0.4546385705,
0.3269752562,
0.1086381227,
0.6169233918,
0.2463503778,
-0.5017924309,
0.1816039383,
0.0389148295,
-0.0401763842,
0.2690505683,
0.5254400373,
-0.1813137978,
-0.0788011923,
0.4480170906,
-0.3595501482,
0.2388394028,
-0.3752196133,
0.9556002617,
0.0760391578,
-0.4913434684,
0.3558536768,
-0.1529249996,
0.7882737517,
-0.4085855484,
0.326200366,
0.057273481,
0.6359093189,
-0.1255746335,
-0.5277755857,
0.5030190349,
0.4154492021,
-0.2780413926,
-0.4172169268,
0.7449443936,
-0.4441453516,
-0.5484825969,
0.0018610068,
0.462973237,
0.2883889377,
0.2433319688,
-0.540661037,
0.1662159413,
-0.0612787604,
-0.1583286226,
-0.057671681,
0.2642530203,
0.2364026606,
0.7096505761,
0.5091984272,
0.2874547839,
0.07059066,
0.1455941349,
0.5864703059,
-0.5760296583,
-0.6196706891,
-0.3898310065,
0.2568722665,
0.229438588,
-0.373501569,
0.9396601319,
0.3768631816,
0.6226326227,
0.0224469323,
0.5969139934,
0.2213602215,
1.4768481255,
0.0051381658,
0.7635996342,
-0.3624943793,
0.0234836116,
-0.5006553531,
-0.8643453121,
-0.6209164262,
1.2276953459,
-0.2351381332,
-0.2493174374,
0.6902704835,
0.6487089992,
0.25279212,
0.5357336402,
0.0777620003,
0.0232822057,
0.2686183751,
0.1057531312,
1.0080949068,
-0.40174824,
0.4569706321,
-0.2343707085,
-0.39044559,
-0.3341077268,
-0.21108751,
-0.6185852885,
-0.4847327173,
-0.3484283686,
-0.4891642034,
0.4842983782,
0.955676198,
0.2423354536,
-1.0819878578,
-0.4894815087,
-0.0912984908,
-0.3035649359,
-0.137681514,
-0.181913659,
0.2235926241,
-0.3505115509,
-0.743827641,
0.3835046291,
0.0276347846,
0.1362247616,
-0.103527464,
-0.0835547596,
0.2570431232,
-0.0060310005,
0.8021011949,
0.5889644623,
-0.6267541647,
-0.4863709509,
0.2421540171,
-0.2123117298,
-0.0390854813,
0.5541857481,
-0.8252286911,
0.8466336131,
0.3993273675,
0.674120307,
0.4852758944,
0.1352629513,
0.3746976554,
-0.2331631631,
0.1346894503,
0.5878301263,
-0.0643998906,
0.3090814352,
0.1306676865,
0.2894833088,
0.0370622501,
-0.5805702806,
-0.8052232862,
-0.1163326055,
-0.746673584,
0.1908975393,
0.8080276847,
-0.0747271553,
-0.217073828,
-0.4167563021,
-0.6669784188,
0.285189122,
-0.5800858736,
0.785756886,
0.927933991,
-0.3347437084,
-0.1256018728,
-0.2485455573,
0.1957629919,
0.5941566825,
-0.267806679,
-0.2570221424,
0.6137690544,
0.2242493927,
0.385794878,
0.61701864,
-0.1781237125,
0.2319633961,
0.0730447695,
0.0736720338,
-0.007582509,
-0.3847903609,
-0.7008957863,
-0.0531572402,
0.1484055519,
-0.2905467749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04188v1 | A New Dataset and Empirical Study for Sentence Simplification in Chinese | 2023-06-07T06:47:34 | 2023-06-07T06:47:34 | Shiping Yang, Renliang Sun, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentence Simplification is a valuable technique that can benefit language
learners and children a lot. However, current research focuses more on English
sentence simplification. The development of Chinese sentence simplification is
relatively slow due to the lack of data. To alleviate this limitation, this
paper introduces CSS, a new dataset for assessing sentence simplification in
Chinese. We collect manual simplifications from human annotators and perform
data analysis to show the difference between English and Chinese sentence
simplifications. Furthermore, we test several unsupervised and zero/few-shot
learning methods on CSS and analyze the automatic evaluation and human
evaluation results. In the end, we explore whether Large Language Models can
serve as high-quality Chinese sentence simplification systems by evaluating
them on CSS. | [
0.141863659,
-0.6449483037,
0.2681979835,
0.6682475805,
-0.3710410297,
-0.2174978852,
-0.4532466829,
-0.2378878742,
-0.0486350432,
-0.0991261676,
-0.4738619626,
-0.3003774881,
-0.1995741129,
0.2832143903,
-0.2497162223,
0.7769405842,
0.0725356862,
0.3967089057,
-0.0791658014,
0.1862262338,
-0.340829879,
-0.2096562684,
-0.6414163113,
-0.1164647192,
0.560108006,
0.5100110769,
0.947586,
0.8367646337,
0.5579910874,
0.2475292832,
-0.2838496268,
0.019450346,
-0.4373151064,
-0.3946641684,
0.2762082517,
-0.2513185441,
-0.2209902257,
0.050829675,
0.4872698784,
1.0536390543,
0.0213460419,
0.238312453,
0.2396814972,
0.5334103107,
-0.7925994992,
0.2043502778,
-0.1634080857,
0.3976959288,
-0.0840464085,
0.0192299653,
-0.3168264627,
-0.6789610982,
-0.0882898346,
-0.8054626584,
0.051473204,
0.0273874998,
0.754406333,
0.1199954599,
-0.6545972824,
0.0642903894,
-0.5071617365,
0.9762557745,
-0.6204743981,
0.1965260804,
-0.2578490078,
0.2893609703,
-0.2260153443,
-0.7402743101,
-0.5558024049,
-0.3489966393,
-0.4013971984,
0.0932848826,
-0.0140172653,
-0.076625742,
0.3960077167,
0.4354639649,
-0.723162353,
-0.1032022089,
-0.5934933424,
-0.267677635,
0.8294370174,
0.1425447315,
0.6576402783,
-0.465157181,
-0.4582556784,
-0.1849792451,
-0.7332544923,
0.3493076563,
0.125616312,
0.448843807,
-0.1331946552,
0.3321568966,
-0.4823448062,
0.4493420124,
-0.4151108563,
-0.0240394641,
0.4697557092,
-0.3088334799,
-0.4084130228,
-0.1064043716,
0.8914572001,
0.5767427087,
0.4463442862,
-0.1588785648,
0.0283898301,
0.1453534514,
-0.3133178353,
-0.906037569,
-0.0267674942,
0.1361836791,
-0.8634095788,
-0.3458186388,
0.4512221515,
-0.3740782142,
-0.3100903332,
-0.3383528888,
-0.1248889491,
-0.3939455748,
-0.0805626735,
0.3828174174,
-0.2891359627,
0.3337218463,
0.6158114076,
-0.4170361459,
0.2685135603,
0.6548582315,
0.4566549659,
-0.2732053399,
-0.543122828,
-0.3252884448,
-0.2195849121,
-0.8046443462,
0.5510404706,
-0.2353513092,
-0.0225608982,
-0.0053175925,
0.0444575511,
0.3571329713,
-0.4353028238,
1.0345431566,
-0.0740143135,
0.0864136517,
-0.4761705995,
-0.5234504938,
0.0082643619,
-0.2060560584,
-0.637670815,
0.9015265703,
-0.1629369259,
-0.7117261291,
0.488663137,
-0.5290714502,
-0.8962765336,
0.2775090635,
-0.076227963,
-0.282060653,
0.2337228507,
0.2098327577,
0.4452844262,
-0.324342072,
0.2732301056,
-0.406573981,
-0.8760436773,
0.1591783613,
-0.5190685987,
1.1344532967,
0.5693413019,
0.0227917824,
-0.2871351242,
-0.6658035517,
0.2145251185,
0.107042335,
-0.4451501667,
-0.2111940235,
-0.0369419456,
0.5223740339,
0.3809914589,
0.4702007771,
-0.6110646725,
0.2603732347,
-0.0969464481,
0.3578291237,
0.2991593182,
0.1399351656,
0.2462526113,
-0.2128517926,
0.37235865,
-0.0199458096,
0.4199292958,
-0.5091534257,
-0.0568341799,
-0.8726037741,
-0.0350410566,
0.5838581324,
0.582597971,
-0.533456862,
0.5290907025,
-0.3499315679,
-0.3925233483,
-0.3116870522,
0.1396912187,
0.3368719518,
-0.0538703166,
0.3845978677,
-0.0919231623,
-0.4373700321,
-0.8579810262,
-0.3581486642,
-0.0478798486,
-0.4774770439,
-0.1180873737,
0.3440898359,
0.3197252154,
0.7579305172,
-0.5810130835,
-0.2073810399,
-0.4605912566,
0.3810050189,
-0.194181487,
0.3842464983,
0.4706106484,
-0.7472257614,
-0.4999429882,
-0.1269294918,
-1.0528856516,
-0.2837043405,
-0.3998789191,
0.0801339447,
-0.2251783609,
0.9046958685,
-0.3282859325,
0.7542373538,
0.2145077586,
-0.0914286077,
0.3447065353,
-0.1215041056,
0.1339672655,
-0.6312816739,
-0.019683281,
0.210304603,
-0.1388507634,
-0.5172633529,
0.1389405727,
0.3437646329,
-0.2455303371,
-0.7309932113,
0.1346556544,
-0.7481836677,
-0.2005591094,
-0.2625510693,
0.2736784816,
-0.000648437,
0.5550764799,
-0.0604988635,
0.3997657895,
0.396494031,
-0.3604065478,
0.4927518964,
-0.0332523659,
-0.4737542868,
0.0379382484,
-0.7510479689,
-0.1763734818,
-0.2246521413,
0.5018901229,
-1.0070149899,
-0.1138793379,
-0.1619040072,
-0.1909232289,
-0.3463109732,
0.2413639128,
-0.7116532922,
-0.4384487271,
-0.7113269567,
0.1489503086,
0.389941901,
-0.477327466,
0.146753177,
-0.0478296056,
-0.1857631207,
-0.4311079979,
-0.7627732158,
0.1132667437,
-0.0609311089,
-0.578440547,
0.2381657511,
-0.2382702231,
-0.314616859,
-0.1176184639,
0.0693945736,
-0.0828792453,
0.3025274575,
0.0511101075,
0.2479303926,
-0.2965079546,
0.2958449125,
0.1455233544,
0.1001490504,
-0.2066600025,
0.5085150599,
0.2401770949,
0.052023273,
-0.2982438505,
-0.7748111486,
0.1955470592,
0.2281652391,
-0.1672082543,
0.1678642333,
0.3627583086,
-0.4875814617,
-0.326299876,
-0.2435020506,
-0.0252747349,
-0.4311270118,
0.2098125815,
-0.2822267413,
-0.541783452,
0.1312082112,
-0.2736744881,
0.258002013,
0.3499224782,
0.0172146522,
-0.0937211961,
0.9482965469,
0.7674418092,
-0.3653813601,
0.3417999148,
0.134683311,
0.2406340539,
-0.2674207389,
0.1991235912,
-0.3928143084,
-0.259015739,
-0.5582462549,
-0.1692471653,
0.1999437958,
0.3807483315,
-0.1484497637,
0.2975096405,
-0.2984391749,
0.7577412724,
0.2293581665,
0.1907528788,
0.4323134422,
-0.1350383759,
0.0810302868,
-0.1486253887,
-0.3482559621,
-0.6077790856,
0.8509182334,
0.1785013378,
0.628477335,
0.014780662,
0.277349025,
0.4398741722,
0.1812074631,
-0.5511260629,
0.7285403609,
-0.492418319,
0.0077941921,
-0.5319019556,
-0.3798458874,
-0.8502140641,
0.3232573271,
-0.3579413593,
-0.3337917626,
-0.1111238673,
-0.2675249875,
-0.6015395522,
-0.2523185611,
-0.8042100668,
0.7254254818,
-0.3559141457,
-0.2774599791,
-0.0531952158,
-0.5705757141,
0.4053903222,
0.0562596992,
0.2115751505,
0.0572452061,
0.2212370932,
0.6042704582,
-0.7147554755,
0.7544170618,
0.0795758218,
0.0675790012,
0.206031695,
-0.1441424191,
0.2791031599,
-0.109479256,
-0.1117998511,
-0.0912683085,
-0.3489510715,
-0.4423857331,
-0.7971480489,
0.5585023761,
-0.4829943478,
-0.4283822775,
-0.3642902672,
-0.4081350565,
0.2182998061,
0.1931678802,
0.0546363033,
0.0286310464,
-0.5644919276,
0.3901705742,
0.2193752676,
-0.4554095864,
0.7504300475,
0.512603581,
-0.2271921337,
0.0167736076,
0.4887793958,
0.163315028,
-0.0045831073,
0.3558193147,
0.3410275877,
0.2394546717,
-0.3102359474,
-0.4083934724,
0.1462767273,
-0.6115915775,
0.0653781667,
-0.2016811222,
-0.2720974088,
-0.6460642219,
-0.2426581085,
0.1192448065,
-0.6273950934,
-0.0676155984,
-0.2693068087,
0.0399745852,
0.7151136398,
-0.0006539782,
0.2247365564,
-0.3160107434,
0.4522799253,
0.220588237,
-0.1159758791,
-0.0036713746,
-0.2837165892,
-0.2704924345,
0.0408977233,
-0.4285438955,
-0.7530378699,
0.2362316996,
-0.0515695624,
0.4005921185,
0.748619318,
0.0472436994,
0.9111257792,
-0.5842507482,
0.9900153279,
0.2126323283,
-1.1696529388,
0.4283919036,
-0.2818733752,
0.372903496,
0.3905185163,
0.0353810154,
-0.9404078126,
-0.1443428546,
-0.5388196111,
-0.6695516109,
0.6825850606,
0.2866064906,
0.1530024111,
0.2914142609,
0.4572858512,
-0.2918427289,
0.1348999441,
-0.9182873368,
-0.4567472637,
-0.044360131,
-0.2335635573,
-0.1622948945,
-0.1237285435,
0.3887747526,
-0.2850981355,
0.5208184123,
-0.0526774153,
-0.1324107051,
-0.1900107116,
-0.1711148322,
-0.2305900753,
0.4559619427,
0.2178785801,
0.4386883974,
0.0656394362,
-0.2322865427,
0.5569341183,
-0.0551208444,
-0.1522901505,
0.0093665523,
-0.4702250063,
0.2069804072,
0.6488993168,
0.550716877,
-0.1165627912,
-0.6202040911,
1.110861659,
-0.1035908833,
-0.0557980016,
-0.4482304454,
-0.0372416601,
0.0562730581,
-0.24339284,
0.4249431491,
-0.2728611827,
0.4749724865,
-0.7458697557,
0.2171378285,
0.0966235474,
-0.2168483734,
-0.1420552284,
0.3264594674,
0.159830898,
-0.032295838,
0.3718823791,
-0.2555561364,
-0.4160739481,
0.7895377278,
0.1450525075,
0.541385293,
-0.3683515191,
0.2807670534,
0.3915608227,
0.4752387106,
-0.3786115348,
0.3800881803,
-0.0466028526,
-0.4410758615,
-0.3696147501,
-0.3084978759,
-0.3797024488,
0.3349323273,
-0.6963407993,
0.9904813766,
-0.4069104195,
0.4055988789,
0.2251794636,
0.1009302139,
-0.4262731373,
0.6672661304,
0.2991333008,
0.9781399369,
-1.3518719673,
0.6930887103,
0.4765851796,
-0.6689958572,
-0.8827232122,
0.3180583417,
-0.0552993864,
-0.3535865843,
1.0952795744,
0.2995748222,
-0.1328327656,
-0.5075754523,
-0.8063181639,
-0.5753508806,
1.111271739,
0.3006675541,
-0.3955492675,
-0.0406298302,
0.6092547774,
0.9389300942,
-0.360570699,
0.576952219,
0.3645141125,
0.4686419964,
-0.1498488039,
-0.6801949143,
0.1272748262,
-0.3922016621,
0.2440996766,
-0.2427912802,
-0.8507648706,
1.3051444292,
-0.0137606198,
-0.3809087873,
0.1608348489,
0.8505425453,
-0.0850661844,
0.2553217709,
0.6650937796,
0.2568340003,
0.6657236814,
-0.1030174345,
0.7393897176,
-0.1367641985,
0.3381223083,
1.0444688797,
-0.4440695941,
0.9215855002,
0.2332527786,
-0.1233686879,
0.6539769173,
0.4686295092,
-0.0976512507,
0.2544995546,
0.8690733314,
0.026540162,
-0.4096157551,
-0.191514805,
0.0113721238,
0.3503990173,
0.0976431072,
-0.3717842996,
-0.4462737739,
0.0765814483,
0.3875478506,
0.3187811673,
-0.1543836445,
0.5552281141,
-0.0733249635,
-0.5836205482,
0.4144777954,
0.379186511,
0.6785889268,
-0.3449121714,
-0.2371925414,
-0.383646518,
0.2138752788,
-0.3902109861,
-0.4253763556,
-0.2118723691,
0.2191323638,
0.1545796692,
-0.1564231366,
0.5883355141,
-0.3863735497,
-0.7166451216,
0.2442726195,
0.4680393934,
0.3291361034,
0.0895396546,
-0.6063121557,
-0.0727443621,
0.1186811849,
-0.3387444913,
-0.0295476727,
0.8183898926,
-0.4473180473,
0.7118652463,
0.6988108158,
0.0946309641,
-0.087090686,
0.2621514201,
0.7703552246,
-0.7907406092,
-0.721742928,
-0.7138614058,
0.3318189085,
-0.4393410981,
-0.4159438312,
1.0167505741,
1.0417443514,
0.7936940789,
0.1266210526,
1.1551952362,
0.1658081263,
0.7238014936,
-0.3347676992,
0.5878430605,
-0.6704720855,
0.2942105532,
-0.3253974617,
-0.4681022763,
-0.5348368287,
0.6011946201,
-0.1942445934,
0.0498414673,
0.9911010861,
0.7320550084,
-0.2055555135,
0.3302938342,
0.4182730913,
0.0976851359,
-0.0847318545,
0.5372330546,
0.8255097866,
-0.7483800054,
0.6706761122,
-0.4471022189,
-0.223403126,
-0.2469172627,
-0.9647640586,
-0.7891720533,
-0.2095921636,
-0.3532629311,
0.1750753522,
0.071650736,
0.9020759463,
0.3494639099,
-0.7427754998,
-0.3576763868,
-0.1370037645,
-0.1948732436,
-0.6131061912,
-0.2475748211,
0.5150278807,
-0.4517884254,
-0.8030744195,
0.4177808166,
-0.0197764467,
-0.0214404203,
-0.2876286805,
0.1446320713,
0.0495920591,
0.1819226146,
0.4848428369,
0.0441951081,
-0.5430546403,
-0.200514257,
0.1091544032,
-0.4384566545,
-0.004980111,
1.0440107584,
-0.5432990789,
0.0325538032,
0.6147037745,
0.2437489778,
0.1654215306,
0.1580658853,
0.3720491529,
-0.9169809818,
0.1334765702,
-0.2660848498,
0.6592360735,
0.5195661783,
-0.3377421796,
0.5221804976,
0.0254847631,
-0.2483644485,
-0.5852251649,
-0.0007363936,
-0.8674553633,
-0.7019945979,
1.3827418089,
-0.3890090883,
-0.1959006488,
-0.0997089371,
-0.2936790884,
0.401232779,
-0.37342152,
0.590892911,
0.7080287933,
0.1076895073,
-0.1861669272,
-0.2595902979,
0.6116080284,
0.5912768245,
-1.0830819607,
0.4939772785,
0.6859334111,
0.111363329,
0.2582860589,
0.2600233257,
0.0476546437,
0.548407495,
-0.2449647635,
0.388279289,
0.0924457833,
-0.1546317637,
-0.5816857815,
0.1400906891,
-0.2396847606,
-0.0523206927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04187v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04187v2 | Knowing-how & Knowing-that: A New Task for Machine Comprehension of User Manuals | 2023-06-07T06:46:56 | 2023-08-09T01:56:01 | Hongru Liang, Jia Liu, Weihong Du, Dingnan Jin, Wenqiang Lei, Zujie Wen, Jiancheng Lv | cs.CL | cs.CL | The machine reading comprehension (MRC) of user manuals has huge potential in
customer service. However, current methods have trouble answering complex
questions. Therefore, we introduce the Knowing-how & Knowing-that task that
requires the model to answer factoid-style, procedure-style, and inconsistent
questions about user manuals. We resolve this task by jointly representing the
steps and facts in a graph TARA, which supports a unified inference of various
questions. Towards a systematical benchmarking study, we design a heuristic
method to automatically parse user manuals into TARAs and build an annotated
dataset to test the model's ability in answering real-world questions.
Empirical results demonstrate that representing user manuals as TARAs is a
desired solution for the MRC of user manuals. An in-depth investigation of TARA
further sheds light on the issues and broader impacts of future representations
of user manuals. We hope our work can move the MRC of user manuals to a more
complex and realistic stage. | [
-0.4062465727,
-0.5458069444,
0.6495194435,
-0.3316081762,
-0.3242069781,
0.0700205937,
0.3422364295,
-0.538383007,
0.0260582138,
0.6148153543,
-0.8781710267,
-0.3261691928,
-0.1676283777,
0.4259171188,
-0.2606318891,
0.9054718614,
-0.1652257591,
0.0009166776,
-0.3320536017,
-0.2558480203,
-0.5097673535,
-0.3899569511,
-0.5166125894,
-0.4524926245,
0.8102552295,
0.4684121013,
0.5599350929,
0.5290338993,
0.0734786987,
0.2802372277,
-0.2333053052,
0.3297687471,
-0.0533674322,
0.5662793517,
0.0322282091,
-0.6461352706,
-0.1275898516,
-0.0994948,
0.5576805472,
0.8843564987,
0.0065653468,
0.1562090516,
0.3418360949,
0.8310386539,
-0.4402986467,
0.1007551029,
-0.0591367073,
0.0234309118,
0.2765770555,
-0.0786101967,
-0.6032935977,
-0.1562483907,
0.2396312952,
-0.9088773727,
0.2155504078,
0.2349227816,
1.0900118351,
0.3740133047,
-0.7449195981,
-0.1893277913,
-0.5778216124,
0.3773459792,
-0.2120193839,
0.4700455964,
0.7274656892,
0.8281058669,
0.066393815,
-0.7209495902,
-0.5853721499,
-0.0467060246,
-0.2417431325,
0.0599287823,
0.0167092048,
-0.1882108897,
0.4532326162,
0.0260255802,
-0.4231547415,
-0.3080132604,
-0.4392715394,
-0.164035216,
0.4612114429,
0.2226395756,
0.3511714041,
-0.5520168543,
-0.5490814447,
-0.1120414957,
-0.5301658511,
0.0945766345,
0.2976362109,
0.0775444955,
0.0621010624,
0.4806069136,
-0.2665429413,
1.0021688938,
-0.4385743439,
-0.0326084122,
0.1095501482,
-0.4794894755,
-0.3051712513,
-0.2818590999,
0.5466800928,
0.2962541878,
0.4868451059,
-0.4484355748,
-0.3368680477,
-0.8452369571,
0.6696859002,
-0.2457982004,
-0.0593307354,
-0.0063824882,
-0.2012179792,
-0.1165911704,
0.1956409663,
-0.5575342178,
-0.3708722889,
-0.6599548459,
0.5697597265,
-0.3783798516,
-0.1147203147,
-0.2002654225,
-0.4249058068,
-0.1406272352,
0.4075253606,
-0.8341888189,
0.4137209952,
0.4556770921,
0.6521402597,
0.4910131693,
-0.2448957413,
-0.4097613096,
0.4562365115,
-0.4055263996,
1.0185412169,
-0.0206431374,
-0.1828698814,
-0.0934497267,
0.0636955872,
-0.1009913832,
-0.3056697547,
0.2051642239,
-0.8179842234,
0.1682436764,
-0.8488525748,
-0.384608686,
-0.4964303672,
0.4565366805,
-0.8520586491,
0.8990235329,
0.3773939013,
-0.9253255129,
0.2232683152,
-0.5863633156,
-0.5266734958,
-0.1744875759,
0.1651470512,
-0.3168466091,
-0.1568228006,
0.1088443026,
0.3193138838,
-0.5077525973,
0.0627726018,
-0.285568893,
-0.117603451,
0.4820091426,
-0.1795884222,
1.1019122601,
0.4560571015,
0.0113700964,
0.1268157363,
-0.6639972925,
0.0466584265,
0.0710413605,
-0.2314055413,
-0.4172776341,
-0.1010030434,
-0.1723975539,
0.0926549062,
0.3062164187,
-0.1923070252,
0.1941874325,
-0.1517113447,
0.408374846,
0.5833980441,
0.0112948781,
0.3439259529,
-0.4084154963,
0.5844442844,
-0.1003531739,
0.2554612756,
-0.3608298004,
-0.4792744815,
-0.7471423149,
-0.1250523031,
0.5555340052,
0.4201158285,
-0.8814496994,
0.3262500167,
0.0833175704,
-0.3406012654,
-0.4141227305,
0.0399433933,
0.5662934184,
1.051885128,
0.3798379004,
-0.0988715217,
-0.4940745831,
-0.9947854877,
-0.1620939225,
-0.2986174524,
-0.2283146232,
0.4526364505,
0.2722651362,
-0.1678655893,
1.0055502653,
-0.7127198577,
-0.1125581115,
-0.3407829106,
0.3379200101,
-0.1663143933,
0.0865637138,
0.147709623,
-0.8132372499,
-0.450540781,
-0.0645692796,
-0.9736770391,
-0.0437319167,
0.011591102,
-0.1111695319,
0.3650576174,
0.3128967881,
-0.2438063025,
0.3409882188,
0.0482483506,
-0.3747813702,
0.664973259,
-0.4018636346,
0.34871158,
-1.1805620193,
0.2266183496,
0.2605813742,
-0.5213499665,
-0.453076601,
0.1317483038,
0.1683066487,
-0.0188484769,
-0.1510941982,
0.3001049161,
-0.4754848182,
-0.7168944478,
0.1430806667,
-0.0308909342,
0.2573110163,
0.4672974944,
-0.2565114498,
1.1113042831,
0.337112397,
-0.5421341658,
0.2527133226,
0.3646773696,
-0.2626155615,
0.3975539505,
-0.6308091283,
0.1688381732,
-0.1503523886,
0.1815891564,
-1.3057117462,
-0.2327981293,
0.4174076617,
-0.3522777557,
0.2916072309,
-0.570057869,
-0.9723124504,
-0.3513374925,
0.4174098074,
-0.0976406634,
0.5411036015,
-0.4126535952,
0.9176470041,
0.3943077922,
0.032770399,
-0.4960062802,
-0.3869770765,
0.152249217,
0.006016863,
-0.7851703167,
-0.1068768501,
0.1427693814,
-0.3252468407,
-0.1679854244,
-0.2411632091,
-0.5760120153,
0.3653953969,
0.2932314277,
0.1860442907,
-0.1455271244,
0.2546157837,
-0.0075749792,
-0.5821137428,
0.1008325368,
-0.4898697734,
0.4608286917,
-0.0060240091,
-0.1899763942,
-0.7189416885,
0.3685931861,
0.4049722552,
-0.1012894064,
0.3617811501,
0.3228682876,
-0.2472271174,
-0.0100231115,
-0.273055464,
-0.0489272103,
-0.4727981389,
-0.096225746,
-0.7066895366,
-0.3046744466,
0.7135360241,
-0.0897506475,
-0.0227509886,
0.4422913194,
0.2240678817,
-0.8018985987,
1.0003242493,
0.6762314439,
0.1643428504,
0.2853797078,
-0.4076981843,
-0.1647229493,
-0.6765136719,
-0.4548842311,
-0.8635550141,
-0.2061679959,
-0.012026201,
-0.1149289235,
0.5368062258,
0.033755973,
-0.222779572,
0.7458973527,
-0.3896147013,
0.4054798782,
0.7497404814,
0.1748744696,
0.556258738,
-0.0856007636,
-0.3926667571,
0.2175796181,
-0.4422880411,
-0.7110731602,
0.9737403989,
0.2675129771,
0.5686344504,
0.1418456733,
0.6295910478,
0.2954643965,
0.1830738485,
-0.504129827,
0.4559111893,
0.1632420123,
-0.7484455705,
-0.5436596274,
-0.3861757815,
-0.6903341413,
0.0272064749,
0.228975758,
-0.6115777493,
-0.0081706233,
0.2176127881,
-0.4620530605,
0.1293317378,
-1.0088799,
0.9418504834,
-0.0721069053,
-0.2163213491,
-0.2356696278,
-0.9125333428,
0.1505676061,
0.0705221444,
0.1244049817,
0.0918849334,
-0.0134775722,
0.8445314765,
-0.6126545072,
0.9629797935,
-0.1761511117,
-0.2362856418,
0.4344066679,
0.103062436,
0.2971126437,
-0.0382835269,
-0.2095683515,
-0.1653325111,
0.3547887206,
-0.3979920447,
-0.9404249787,
0.192640841,
-0.786888659,
-0.579836905,
-0.3141446412,
-0.4851450324,
-0.2718798518,
0.3510698378,
0.0342477784,
0.6262352467,
-0.0189256258,
-0.2791272402,
0.8543050289,
0.3923422694,
0.2015774101,
0.5632914901,
-0.1042964235,
-0.4142905176,
0.8414195776,
0.399966538,
0.2340136468,
0.3646661937,
0.0802009329,
-0.5578613281,
-0.2343631238,
-1.0378090143,
0.1850176752,
-0.9663298726,
-0.0630833209,
-0.6835771799,
-0.0101125985,
-0.1916256547,
0.0616343804,
0.1581678241,
-0.4753395319,
-0.6990743279,
0.1332243681,
0.3252592683,
1.1763613224,
0.228534326,
0.3455900848,
-0.5804085135,
0.6361269355,
0.6527311802,
0.3972042799,
-0.0485076569,
-0.5169762373,
-0.1817370802,
0.0929801539,
-0.4258958995,
-1.1616905928,
0.0582256354,
-0.2293410748,
0.4128728509,
0.4328407943,
0.3353337348,
0.6950807571,
-0.5263435841,
0.4173660874,
0.1576965451,
-0.7433113456,
0.3582166135,
-0.294197619,
-0.0944260135,
0.8018013239,
0.7378467917,
-0.7189767361,
-0.0613579862,
-0.7008817196,
-0.3299552202,
0.715595603,
-0.0518968515,
-0.092847012,
0.2865814269,
0.5952084064,
0.1036748886,
0.0673028529,
-0.2877948284,
-0.3599891365,
-0.3244773149,
-0.2479887903,
-0.1405878961,
-0.3192769289,
-0.3231749833,
-0.2846356332,
0.4733247459,
-0.4108817875,
0.2695067823,
0.2947777212,
-0.2394449264,
-0.2012239546,
-0.0311059952,
0.4651806951,
0.7928238511,
-0.06408903,
0.2100467384,
0.0988992751,
0.007496892,
0.2026278526,
0.0531318672,
-0.2316205949,
-0.0784068555,
0.3419353962,
0.5285606384,
0.3796301484,
-0.6847392321,
0.1512043923,
-0.0683666021,
-0.2500987947,
-0.3789114952,
0.4671064019,
0.339206934,
0.0869801864,
0.4274728298,
0.1133953035,
0.333617866,
-0.5756154656,
0.399081856,
0.2410466373,
-0.620669961,
-0.2694893479,
0.4903326929,
0.1999761015,
-0.8398109674,
0.4604935944,
-0.1662688404,
-0.6454803944,
0.7661451101,
0.5254787803,
0.6186525822,
0.2289901823,
0.2946150005,
0.4159255326,
0.0156912394,
0.0947551206,
0.3774836957,
-0.6493617296,
-0.3102626204,
-0.2022402287,
-0.2091317028,
-0.5397481918,
-0.3808148801,
-0.8693728447,
0.2972379029,
-0.5334317684,
-0.0220803916,
0.3640242219,
0.2092759013,
-0.5417328477,
0.2995383143,
-0.3452294469,
1.0135577917,
-0.7809181809,
0.8410659432,
0.5337092876,
-1.0160237551,
-0.9588333368,
0.1467603594,
0.0240134746,
-0.8290441036,
0.6579384804,
0.0395019501,
-0.0040882272,
0.1496855468,
-0.5579940677,
-0.599966228,
1.0428112745,
0.0860829949,
-0.6143722534,
-0.2081994861,
-0.0232751518,
0.411981672,
-0.0788277388,
0.2464477867,
0.4791844487,
0.7069680691,
0.2315752804,
-0.7144780159,
-0.0113309184,
-0.1139751002,
-0.2812106609,
0.0917767286,
-0.3492834866,
0.5601174235,
-0.2841053903,
-0.1489113271,
0.1945349425,
0.6336429119,
-0.1302984506,
0.4366568923,
0.8115540743,
0.6079788208,
1.0281230211,
0.0033572102,
1.2573478222,
0.0078748176,
0.1402865052,
0.9230191708,
-0.2181629986,
0.5258125663,
0.3019655347,
-0.3595795929,
0.7694805861,
0.8006128073,
0.1616840661,
0.289711535,
0.0506373048,
-0.3111898899,
-0.6706792116,
0.1228381395,
-0.1015487164,
0.0317087919,
0.0420435928,
-0.2955465615,
-0.3940062225,
-0.0141061377,
-0.2919762731,
0.1538752019,
0.2425311804,
1.4105302095,
-0.0694797114,
-0.9466128945,
0.7620945573,
-0.0596442297,
-0.1744774878,
-0.5906726718,
0.0332959443,
-0.0211874079,
-0.2368430048,
0.0844982415,
-1.1258325577,
0.4087173939,
0.0241882931,
-0.5773303509,
-0.1757375449,
0.4831075072,
-0.0969107971,
-0.4009099603,
0.1610955894,
0.4273324013,
0.4034464359,
-0.0048970799,
-0.6655157208,
-0.1648744643,
0.2426205724,
0.1166482717,
0.306181252,
0.6102692485,
-0.1933713704,
1.127605319,
0.5250990987,
-0.4753489792,
-0.2159398198,
0.4236807525,
0.8201573491,
-0.5378353,
-0.5608569384,
-0.3825724423,
0.7042607069,
-0.0943807438,
-0.4255966842,
0.550342381,
0.5126001239,
0.3140092194,
0.1352542788,
0.7365769744,
0.1678263694,
0.5948916078,
-0.3788712025,
0.9137555957,
-0.84344697,
0.1567216069,
-0.0744242445,
-0.4111082256,
-0.1116987839,
0.5541554093,
-0.1042459384,
-0.1902255118,
0.5901075602,
0.5496767759,
0.0093283691,
0.3647424877,
0.193643868,
-0.0830572844,
0.1598706394,
0.0561933778,
0.8333752751,
-0.491143167,
0.7157008052,
-0.3057172,
-0.0551594533,
-0.3533762991,
-0.6307069659,
-0.8391903043,
-1.1871511936,
-0.1810391396,
-0.5067540407,
0.3643206358,
0.6431638002,
0.7349359393,
-0.4132143557,
-0.1263652444,
-0.0256294906,
0.8315598965,
-0.4422902465,
-0.0988092124,
0.1688452959,
-0.7707659602,
-0.4601728916,
0.0730566233,
-0.0778876692,
0.3114585876,
-0.4457992613,
-0.0572127625,
-0.1220423803,
-0.1821304113,
0.3287757933,
0.4235349298,
-0.6526545882,
-0.161836639,
0.0739465356,
-0.2070979178,
0.1980702579,
1.0444467068,
-0.9363750219,
0.4722720981,
0.5402245522,
0.4429704845,
0.4813475311,
0.0949987918,
0.5882966518,
-0.6859900951,
-0.3169934154,
0.0949755907,
0.4905815721,
0.2341992408,
-0.3415408134,
0.394998461,
0.2536256313,
-0.3158033192,
-0.7465139031,
0.321800828,
-1.0027362108,
-0.6395968795,
0.9171885252,
-0.193993181,
-0.6779332161,
-0.8784044385,
-0.3494573832,
0.4390867352,
-0.2139000744,
0.7521318197,
0.4887159169,
0.2358748168,
-0.2258364409,
-0.5161144733,
0.311244905,
0.1727948487,
-0.8384536505,
0.4540472329,
0.3737432361,
0.59292382,
0.2434726655,
0.4982845783,
0.304231286,
0.4368345439,
-0.0756162331,
0.0372077189,
-0.4413149059,
-0.671159029,
-0.1423603594,
0.321044445,
-0.0359867029,
-0.0981073081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04181v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04181v2 | Benchmarking Foundation Models with Language-Model-as-an-Examiner | 2023-06-07T06:29:58 | 2023-11-04T11:50:13 | Yushi Bai, Jiahao Ying, Yixin Cao, Xin Lv, Yuze He, Xiaozhi Wang, Jifan Yu, Kaisheng Zeng, Yijia Xiao, Haozhe Lyu, Jiayin Zhang, Juanzi Li, Lei Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Numerous benchmarks have been established to assess the performance of
foundation models on open-ended question answering, which serves as a
comprehensive test of a model's ability to understand and generate language in
a manner similar to humans. Most of these works focus on proposing new
datasets, however, we see two main issues within previous benchmarking
pipelines, namely testing leakage and evaluation automation. In this paper, we
propose a novel benchmarking framework, Language-Model-as-an-Examiner, where
the LM serves as a knowledgeable examiner that formulates questions based on
its knowledge and evaluates responses in a reference-free manner. Our framework
allows for effortless extensibility as various LMs can be adopted as the
examiner, and the questions can be constantly updated given more diverse
trigger topics. For a more comprehensive and equitable evaluation, we devise
three strategies: (1) We instruct the LM examiner to generate questions across
a multitude of domains to probe for a broad acquisition, and raise follow-up
questions to engage in a more in-depth assessment. (2) Upon evaluation, the
examiner combines both scoring and ranking measurements, providing a reliable
result as it aligns closely with human annotations. (3) We additionally propose
a decentralized Peer-examination method to address the biases in a single
examiner. Our data and benchmarking results are available at:
http://lmexam.xlore.cn. | [
-0.435433805,
-0.7370457053,
0.3119235039,
0.2382210791,
-0.1252210438,
-0.1372057796,
-0.3790845275,
-0.5583170652,
-0.0764259696,
0.6595990658,
-0.3585780859,
-0.3242964745,
-0.3809854686,
0.0881473497,
-0.6970688701,
0.7269108295,
-0.1812158376,
0.228072688,
-0.5184805393,
-0.4240894914,
-0.3676837683,
-0.1863945127,
-0.5469127297,
-0.3725712001,
0.103687048,
0.2864693999,
0.4373146892,
0.6487913728,
0.4041034579,
0.1966968179,
-0.0507415459,
-0.2366410047,
-0.267246902,
0.1129133031,
-0.3287111819,
-0.5063615441,
-0.3522109389,
0.0582003109,
0.7508023977,
0.9973081946,
-0.3260847032,
0.4624424875,
0.0099866325,
0.6930209994,
-0.9791773558,
0.1956136525,
-0.5913710594,
-0.0430042408,
0.0101105599,
0.1369925141,
-0.3945485651,
-0.7352602482,
0.2877621353,
-0.2340828925,
0.1469790041,
-0.1083638668,
0.8036507368,
0.3187332451,
-0.3617705703,
-0.099673681,
-0.294007659,
0.5334203839,
-0.442771256,
0.6142147779,
0.1844762117,
0.8235157728,
0.3753693998,
-0.8411684036,
-0.2620768547,
-0.2975694835,
0.097059831,
0.1388325542,
0.0543171503,
-0.2353172004,
-0.0309378207,
0.4668883383,
-0.5252792239,
-0.0056619644,
-0.1223693788,
-0.3674369454,
0.7029359341,
0.0532897934,
0.0803639516,
0.1011342406,
-0.5127964616,
-0.402053684,
-0.8157994747,
0.2262438536,
0.3145067096,
0.3365098536,
0.1395889819,
0.3185862005,
-0.6760471463,
0.7803837061,
-0.059640266,
0.2777954638,
0.2319327742,
-0.2906844616,
-0.0576599091,
-0.1255515367,
0.7926349044,
0.3409338295,
0.4518741071,
-0.3992806971,
-0.3934098482,
-0.0248670951,
0.2790509462,
-1.085387826,
-0.1856438071,
0.2246571034,
-0.3643878698,
-0.5826310515,
0.2206600904,
-1.0027918816,
-0.4014335275,
-0.0697900876,
0.6586364508,
0.0079910541,
-0.4398162067,
0.3539624512,
-0.0247384869,
0.1522791684,
0.1702549756,
-0.6815687418,
0.8738220334,
0.5326452851,
0.3961313665,
-0.2639786303,
-0.3990351856,
-0.9258726835,
-0.2160285413,
-0.3592253923,
0.8493445516,
-0.4419026673,
-0.2275350392,
0.0550195053,
-0.1876411736,
-0.1013285667,
-0.8049467802,
0.4146974981,
-0.5819535851,
0.2718023062,
-0.2846477926,
-0.4389185905,
-0.03928468,
0.4698114097,
-0.6134597659,
1.2569842339,
0.0882883668,
-0.4743299484,
0.2378321439,
-0.4729132056,
-0.2849579453,
-0.0241717622,
-0.4427098334,
-0.3313688636,
-0.1031997427,
0.2846308351,
0.3663777113,
-0.7299565077,
0.5568851233,
-0.2581205368,
-0.3742113411,
0.163703844,
-0.2314085811,
0.7439720035,
-0.0207612757,
-0.6013250947,
0.0158371348,
-0.8080785275,
0.3732892871,
0.1038030386,
-0.1927456111,
-0.0086838137,
-0.0249403231,
0.0573011935,
0.0161512513,
0.1099090949,
-0.6315829158,
-0.239398554,
-0.3469467461,
0.0603045449,
0.7612497807,
0.1100891754,
0.3398168087,
-0.4887939394,
0.5610641837,
-0.1407081634,
0.0335864238,
-0.1396271437,
-0.3755014241,
-0.7677038312,
-0.1120723188,
0.5494298935,
0.3964109719,
-0.2984431982,
0.2506795824,
-0.3524505794,
-0.6769493222,
-0.7098333836,
0.0281815566,
0.656090796,
0.7073711753,
0.3614000976,
-0.6422305107,
-0.0343893506,
-0.9161694646,
-0.5480399728,
-0.2780538201,
-0.0296768397,
0.5114430189,
0.6012021303,
0.2402946353,
1.092890501,
-0.5884842277,
-0.1496728361,
-0.0006577029,
0.1179764569,
0.0244092122,
0.4179395437,
0.492179662,
-0.8363044858,
-0.5373059511,
-0.0164780039,
-0.7638568878,
-0.5715075731,
0.2652240694,
-0.1830319017,
-0.1135900393,
0.4351944923,
-0.2710635364,
0.193083033,
0.2980444133,
-0.2384746522,
0.8772736192,
0.2997996211,
0.1252467185,
-0.8499389887,
0.4490332007,
-0.218018055,
-0.1845066249,
-0.5018900633,
0.6821507812,
0.4263329208,
-0.2142871916,
-0.5093735456,
1.0717844963,
-0.4743275344,
-0.2065015286,
-0.0338107385,
0.2711766064,
0.1341177225,
0.3880735934,
0.217697382,
0.6739866734,
0.6357201934,
-0.414465636,
0.128433913,
0.192887336,
-0.5449067354,
0.6388723254,
-0.7738623619,
0.3435949683,
0.0895612985,
0.0966408253,
-0.7326891422,
0.0544641465,
-0.0139439339,
-0.2266924828,
0.1401695162,
-0.1884125322,
-0.606526494,
-0.0637872145,
-0.382691741,
0.376370728,
0.2976703942,
-0.5149431229,
0.5418787599,
0.1831042916,
-0.206514284,
-0.8272343278,
-0.4274117351,
-0.1472220868,
-0.0302656759,
-0.8047176003,
0.2816769481,
-0.2791270912,
-0.4615335166,
0.1013328955,
-0.2345137745,
-0.3654994965,
0.4016480446,
0.0336273611,
-0.0917740613,
-0.5785871148,
-0.0100091174,
0.0727850497,
-0.1650722474,
0.2865594327,
-0.0889378637,
0.4367816448,
-0.3182861507,
-0.6388933063,
-0.1890662014,
0.2820567787,
0.5018112063,
-0.7695956826,
0.3770984411,
0.170435816,
-0.4817450345,
-0.3719880283,
-0.849616766,
-0.4964544773,
-0.4178925157,
0.2764423192,
-0.5857982635,
-0.8321440816,
0.6755003929,
-0.0866072401,
0.0104821324,
0.1997702271,
0.5601696372,
0.2970569134,
0.7092944384,
0.4719860554,
-0.2498169839,
0.1190072522,
-0.1529115438,
-0.061788138,
-0.6957231164,
-0.1061114967,
-0.8571105599,
0.0332632512,
-0.1797350198,
-0.4183026254,
0.2438650578,
0.3717010319,
-0.1873810887,
0.3618587554,
-0.2180898339,
0.6219771504,
0.2797961533,
0.0784617364,
0.4951865971,
-0.4235203564,
-0.4184787273,
0.2605542243,
-0.3005454242,
-0.5388302207,
1.3940018415,
0.3312129974,
0.4999822974,
0.1079468802,
0.7464359999,
-0.1308133304,
0.6414696574,
-0.3879730105,
0.6534997225,
0.192007184,
-0.8413948417,
-0.2759580612,
-0.3390339613,
-0.4262886941,
0.7028358579,
0.0059490227,
-0.9312443733,
0.2779175937,
-0.0162933804,
-0.1433254927,
0.0687046573,
-0.5306389928,
1.261194706,
-0.1019147784,
-0.5033242702,
-0.0024895999,
-0.5417217016,
0.2815150917,
-0.2476332933,
0.042002555,
-0.1854327768,
-0.076391831,
0.5735964775,
-0.4230140746,
0.6479170918,
-0.2601366639,
0.0949539691,
0.3708614409,
0.2634120584,
0.4152036905,
0.1782819331,
-0.5445949435,
-0.0744475871,
0.1113161892,
-0.3159874678,
-0.7086734176,
0.4619470835,
-0.6196933389,
-0.5042440295,
-0.2173836827,
-0.2994233072,
-0.4932234585,
0.3471640348,
-0.0803607032,
0.5843153,
-0.583178699,
0.2778259516,
0.5272158384,
0.0587031431,
0.1667041481,
0.9377195239,
-0.3229638338,
-0.172241047,
0.755956769,
-0.1640800834,
0.4283566773,
0.4346450567,
0.373339057,
-0.4730822444,
-0.7093366385,
-0.5824761391,
0.1687636226,
-0.7880750299,
-0.1027717367,
-0.7087565064,
-0.0527990386,
-0.2573506832,
0.0617185906,
-0.5765910149,
-0.339627862,
0.1289729774,
-0.0879782513,
-0.0789676309,
0.3864105642,
0.2385710031,
-0.050059732,
-0.4131675363,
0.1047728658,
0.4856465459,
0.5375550985,
0.2243038118,
-0.3600880206,
-0.0527678169,
-0.0314226672,
-0.3279402256,
-0.811213553,
-0.1286532581,
0.2332713157,
0.7263613939,
0.4197823703,
0.1892785579,
0.5537378788,
-0.5735518932,
0.6226099133,
-0.1739413738,
-0.9607642293,
0.4810165763,
-0.3471755981,
0.0472971126,
1.0972665548,
0.1704688072,
-0.5024645329,
-0.6239998341,
-0.2824740112,
-0.5860932469,
0.5851862431,
0.1154809445,
-0.0709644258,
-0.0010156278,
0.2370122671,
0.2898364067,
0.4558194876,
-0.7095947266,
-0.1212105229,
-0.096537821,
0.0103276484,
0.0279146973,
0.0847741887,
-0.2203977555,
-0.0615730695,
0.5668053031,
-0.4571146071,
0.007748384,
0.0983514339,
-0.4926404953,
-0.1069541723,
0.2998739481,
0.2721090317,
0.7891861796,
-0.3748544753,
0.0467342995,
0.1548472643,
-0.3040367365,
0.0953955054,
0.4265877903,
-0.2589353323,
-0.183546558,
0.426569134,
0.4263091087,
0.4137016833,
-0.9805933237,
0.796790123,
-0.0159341395,
-0.2361581326,
-0.0165412799,
0.0085875122,
0.3118210435,
0.0826211646,
0.3934457004,
-0.1852407604,
0.0779818222,
-0.504170239,
0.5069271922,
0.3019090295,
-0.6437042952,
-0.3054770231,
0.9122635126,
0.3139438629,
-0.2385850996,
0.385918498,
-0.0486227833,
-0.4939946234,
0.7394981384,
0.3458166718,
0.9507436752,
-0.3223755062,
0.1951146126,
0.1706073582,
0.200265348,
-0.2549668849,
0.4477754831,
-0.2703006268,
-0.8652362823,
-0.1973354518,
-0.5686095357,
-0.6329949498,
0.0609227009,
-1.1570286751,
0.2596699297,
-0.2998205721,
0.3586556613,
0.0025882947,
0.130024001,
-0.6588156223,
0.3786994517,
-0.2144919336,
1.376963973,
-0.9006146193,
0.5772676468,
0.7232500911,
-0.5135267973,
-0.6260253787,
0.0843901932,
-0.0045917062,
-0.832746923,
0.347496599,
0.4473961592,
-0.0237665568,
0.0247846749,
-0.0641611889,
-0.5576007962,
1.2034131289,
0.4561500847,
-0.2353505045,
0.1958497763,
0.1690904349,
0.7385612726,
-0.5390358567,
0.4851714373,
0.4984481335,
0.3697117865,
-0.3656367958,
-1.086892128,
0.2125644088,
-0.5271975398,
-0.2477083206,
0.308047384,
-0.6559045911,
0.7865317464,
-0.00351859,
-0.1027862355,
0.3072466552,
0.3432546556,
0.1779378951,
0.2147953212,
0.6374722719,
0.6074748039,
0.5504979491,
-0.0412356183,
1.0743733644,
-0.4970530868,
0.4017089605,
1.2259596586,
-0.6090234518,
1.1358071566,
0.3066942394,
-0.088123925,
0.4325430691,
0.5636045933,
0.1487383395,
0.5888066292,
0.4069771171,
-0.1517737359,
-0.2192718536,
-0.2126061171,
-0.4313946664,
0.4965679646,
-0.2356852144,
-0.2776651084,
-0.4426471591,
-0.3497326374,
-0.2396097332,
0.380672425,
-0.0550849326,
0.6511905789,
0.0235867593,
-0.8383587003,
0.3458692729,
0.0392846949,
0.1267828047,
-0.5604420304,
0.0746871009,
-0.3575611413,
0.2674980164,
0.1835756451,
-0.5819173455,
0.0492499508,
-0.0094776005,
0.0577302463,
-0.4102391005,
0.4589497149,
-0.4504529238,
-0.3643698096,
0.5775097609,
0.8945626616,
0.2064916641,
-0.4444801509,
-0.6665201783,
-0.0125706894,
-0.3413705528,
-0.4196813405,
0.4952262044,
0.1207643524,
-0.3486179411,
0.8377410173,
0.4326985478,
0.0932910293,
-0.0700468644,
0.5297247767,
0.8667089343,
-0.4330711067,
-0.6724839807,
-0.604049325,
0.5867164731,
-0.0935501531,
-0.43531093,
0.4962320924,
0.8344424963,
0.9733675122,
0.1499529034,
0.6068734527,
0.1347022355,
0.6197283268,
-0.2922546566,
0.9016094208,
-0.6020996571,
0.0871524885,
-0.5141428113,
-1.0861814022,
-0.0102631794,
0.4375288188,
-0.0837449878,
0.0951204598,
0.810764432,
0.8533281088,
-0.0973773673,
0.2327755243,
0.1803240925,
-0.008924623,
0.1802687794,
0.5641055703,
0.7789575458,
-0.5959890485,
0.5636073947,
-0.4922401607,
-0.2051207274,
-0.0933551565,
-0.8563958406,
-0.9905462861,
-0.5344671607,
-0.387188971,
-0.0819108561,
0.2202837318,
0.4897262752,
0.7338154912,
-0.8661032915,
-0.606785655,
0.0825014412,
0.0456986427,
-0.4631159008,
-0.2125673443,
0.5357509851,
-0.0424629003,
-0.6192350388,
0.4220284522,
0.1073449999,
-0.2751714587,
-0.4241645038,
0.0448456407,
-0.0355499126,
-0.1068488061,
0.2448146641,
0.128437072,
-0.5999346972,
-0.492726177,
0.2325212806,
0.0158938877,
-0.0460115634,
0.6927480698,
-0.7579833865,
0.7389116883,
0.2958803773,
0.9976373315,
0.5747967362,
0.0818320662,
0.7949821353,
-0.6901819706,
-0.0756103322,
0.4134739041,
0.1985326558,
0.2429099083,
-0.0681516752,
0.7792162895,
0.1294273138,
-0.1931937486,
-1.1864769459,
0.1259095371,
-0.6496443152,
-0.0907592028,
0.907458663,
-0.2661931515,
0.018764466,
0.0930180773,
0.2709042132,
-0.1653461903,
-0.1391071677,
0.6637685895,
0.8719140887,
0.1880648583,
-0.1610763073,
-0.5811825991,
0.2105203569,
0.6184939742,
-0.92882514,
0.1355390847,
0.1633485705,
0.6229006648,
0.0540158898,
0.9177339673,
-0.3176995814,
0.7101963162,
-0.0152912382,
0.0915437117,
-0.1102056429,
-0.3791306913,
-0.4026769102,
0.3030276,
0.0218559932,
-0.1082523242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04176v1 | When to Read Documents or QA History: On Unified and Selective Open-domain QA | 2023-06-07T06:03:39 | 2023-06-07T06:03:39 | Kyungjae Lee, Sang-eun Han, Seung-won Hwang, Moontae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | This paper studies the problem of open-domain question answering, with the
aim of answering a diverse range of questions leveraging knowledge resources.
Two types of sources, QA-pair and document corpora, have been actively
leveraged with the following complementary strength. The former is highly
precise when the paraphrase of given question $q$ was seen and answered during
training, often posed as a retrieval problem, while the latter generalizes
better for unseen questions. A natural follow-up is thus leveraging both
models, while a naive pipelining or integration approaches have failed to bring
additional gains over either model alone. Our distinction is interpreting the
problem as calibration, which estimates the confidence of predicted answers as
an indicator to decide when to use a document or QA-pair corpus. The
effectiveness of our method was validated on widely adopted benchmarks such as
Natural Questions and TriviaQA. | [
-0.3963440955,
-0.5285692215,
0.869289279,
-0.3863074481,
-0.1762223095,
0.098839283,
0.0427831113,
-0.3701965809,
-0.1006412208,
0.7161198854,
-0.4077398181,
-0.3047600985,
-0.2257023305,
0.0514949784,
-0.3214141726,
1.0060201883,
-0.3438514173,
0.1389342546,
-0.5396004915,
-0.4192061424,
-0.6561092734,
-0.538810432,
-0.4115760028,
-0.0338411555,
0.4258228838,
0.27384758,
1.0072811842,
0.3630947173,
0.3716368377,
0.2065507919,
0.0459471382,
0.3178243637,
-0.5048638582,
0.2570416033,
-0.2604628205,
-0.8515816927,
0.1561421305,
0.2049510032,
0.6556652784,
0.9128876328,
0.3668049574,
0.2829430401,
0.1286149472,
0.7011571527,
-0.8052442074,
-0.051940538,
-0.4069187343,
-0.1869775951,
-0.1619583368,
-0.6539254785,
-0.4111741781,
-0.7574244142,
0.2769764662,
-1.0776895285,
0.4262619317,
-0.0730522051,
0.8209032416,
0.0358219333,
-0.6223153472,
-0.5111446381,
-0.8953775167,
0.7994013429,
-0.1433650702,
0.4626769125,
0.7668267488,
0.2756997943,
0.0684390664,
-0.8906045556,
-0.3361000419,
0.0471734852,
-0.0856957138,
0.1135020629,
-0.2084912211,
-0.2576347589,
0.087695457,
0.3952317238,
-0.7307625413,
-0.3996680677,
-0.7767586112,
-0.2193290591,
0.2902599871,
-0.2712969482,
0.3629078567,
0.0876508653,
-0.4593568742,
-0.1576942652,
-0.5222178698,
0.2726437747,
0.4838688374,
0.1031129062,
0.4034334123,
0.5426092744,
-0.1523126066,
0.6802759171,
0.086805217,
0.1538169682,
-0.0254636332,
-0.5268612504,
-0.1144294962,
-0.2437060326,
0.3314171135,
0.3682090938,
0.6362324357,
-0.567332685,
0.0533673763,
-0.1058929712,
0.5375651121,
-0.5736230016,
-0.0109848855,
0.4222489595,
-0.3192353845,
0.0573414676,
0.3380378187,
-0.8625225425,
-0.0266687293,
-0.4739945531,
0.4388613105,
-0.4950168431,
-0.0304018855,
-0.0373983867,
-0.4494451284,
0.3053514361,
0.3659650385,
-0.7253171802,
0.2813160419,
0.5999614,
0.5650420189,
-0.0342722796,
-0.1322957724,
-0.9314461946,
-0.0108704474,
-0.5018846989,
0.9506952167,
-0.3523926139,
-0.6839597225,
0.3265556991,
0.0105740773,
-0.2960337102,
-0.4193904698,
0.9533050656,
-1.0344145298,
0.6472459435,
-0.4755945802,
-0.4667413831,
-0.2862692773,
0.0813532025,
-0.7584404349,
0.8463273644,
0.5105105042,
-0.7992869616,
0.3058833778,
-0.3169364333,
-0.0404340923,
0.094925642,
-0.1206004024,
0.2002874166,
-0.1513278782,
0.1947522014,
-0.1700404286,
-0.2356735766,
0.2109245956,
-0.2951812744,
-0.2349233329,
0.2412905842,
-0.3404566944,
0.9331188202,
0.4958449304,
-0.0116965352,
-0.1033559963,
-0.4632807076,
0.3967051208,
-0.0225741379,
-0.1990853995,
-0.8093281984,
-0.0732157379,
-0.088414371,
-0.073516801,
0.2918542922,
-0.6062616706,
-0.0727739185,
-0.2544748783,
0.1774432063,
0.5312879086,
0.1816602051,
0.5937937498,
-0.689835608,
0.7190386057,
-0.2675460875,
0.1632242501,
-0.1145462468,
-0.5740687251,
-0.1620888412,
0.1652694643,
0.4174897373,
0.4829917252,
-0.7549965978,
-0.0133471703,
0.0021319627,
-0.4398626685,
-0.7199277282,
0.3341367245,
0.4286005199,
0.6017485857,
0.4483718872,
-0.3324035406,
-0.2551344633,
-0.4328624606,
-0.4806496501,
-0.6274487972,
-0.1357038021,
0.4148044884,
0.0595305003,
0.2875734866,
1.007250905,
-0.6337774992,
-0.1425787061,
0.1442043781,
0.1254422814,
-0.165083468,
0.1760299653,
0.5314356685,
-1.3332811594,
-0.3580034077,
-0.2484160811,
-0.9172770381,
-0.0690691918,
-0.0104198018,
-0.471814096,
0.2366616875,
0.5048974156,
-0.3695198298,
0.1731133312,
0.4048421681,
-0.5525466204,
0.3785913885,
-0.2296571136,
0.5794264674,
-1.035063982,
0.3547317386,
-0.0489990972,
-0.018153064,
-0.6245903373,
0.5275799036,
0.3348756135,
-0.109753795,
-0.4833430648,
0.7733911276,
-0.5287453532,
-0.0073453207,
-0.0513886064,
0.6199784279,
0.4748362899,
0.1556198746,
-0.1105266809,
0.9014370441,
0.0616233312,
-0.5332070589,
0.0049225469,
0.5385733843,
-0.090302825,
0.8395767808,
-0.4416757524,
0.4421200752,
-0.1514015496,
0.083210133,
-1.0119667053,
0.0624662936,
0.0299362447,
-0.7622026801,
0.3456720114,
0.094248198,
-0.3451751769,
-0.4493763447,
-0.416864574,
0.4562601149,
0.2444084138,
-0.7108970881,
0.5983159542,
0.3080506325,
-0.1468809694,
-0.6982938051,
-0.2929862142,
-0.373509258,
0.0309676845,
-0.9276692271,
0.2055759728,
-0.5482328534,
-0.3976143897,
0.1929493248,
-0.4483845234,
-0.4605874121,
0.1242708266,
0.2443552315,
0.5590097904,
-0.4545741975,
0.2557855844,
-0.0655495673,
0.1763896346,
-0.054299701,
-0.1492110342,
0.3481166661,
-0.0731106848,
-0.1750153154,
-0.0275389571,
0.7390903234,
0.4933035076,
-0.5665960312,
0.5045127869,
0.223875612,
-0.1192049161,
0.0683623105,
-0.613066256,
-0.1425439715,
-0.4101069868,
-0.2527380586,
-0.4660059214,
-0.7554053068,
0.4445718527,
0.1988269538,
0.1400720626,
0.6644771695,
0.3253780305,
-0.3855015337,
0.5755354762,
0.4742356241,
-0.0379527137,
0.3514784276,
-0.190021798,
0.0465019606,
-0.7268702388,
-0.2413471639,
-1.1067664623,
0.1157270148,
-0.3813311756,
-0.2354199588,
0.3336444199,
0.4731907547,
0.0190685857,
0.2319166213,
-0.3788297176,
0.3031991124,
0.959228456,
0.0417123288,
0.6328490973,
-0.3770675361,
-0.165013209,
0.3016719222,
-0.4580075443,
-0.7648886442,
1.560182929,
0.0192407034,
0.5082220435,
0.0300051663,
0.4856009483,
0.2430803478,
0.1799188554,
-0.5882874131,
0.3307786584,
0.1078217328,
-0.9812739491,
-0.4977418184,
-0.1902927756,
-1.3450660706,
0.2973462641,
0.0570459329,
-0.4534992278,
0.4652632177,
-0.1187043861,
-0.4381600618,
0.319606185,
-0.7273558974,
0.9124033451,
0.1078423932,
-0.0036492406,
0.0724687353,
-0.7789387107,
0.1857527941,
-0.2669120431,
0.16469495,
0.2786200643,
-0.0993367657,
0.694186151,
-0.0401727557,
0.4607140124,
0.1526409686,
0.1903544962,
0.774056673,
0.0519521348,
0.1401932985,
-0.0765428245,
-0.191709429,
-0.0931691006,
0.863625288,
-0.5325056911,
-0.6121369004,
0.4387203157,
-0.8747164011,
-0.7299394608,
-0.5502884388,
-0.6822954416,
-0.4240074456,
0.3844954371,
0.2622587979,
0.5986108184,
-0.562040925,
0.2493788749,
0.72194767,
0.1662368178,
0.2093109936,
0.8005562425,
-0.0521838069,
-0.2940181494,
0.3649766445,
0.1504267454,
0.5339533687,
0.545681417,
-0.0503241643,
-0.4301970005,
-0.4318652451,
-0.5785726905,
0.4766106308,
-0.8035411239,
-0.097678341,
-0.6084085107,
-0.2323032767,
-0.7662733793,
-0.2085198909,
0.2928930521,
-0.2479870766,
-0.7008211017,
0.0299287029,
0.0771741271,
0.2186920047,
0.2070449293,
-0.2671492994,
-1.0496852398,
0.6207302809,
0.3937401474,
0.2099404782,
-0.443323195,
-0.4282663763,
0.0299152602,
-0.1002751216,
-0.6092560887,
-1.201236248,
0.1985105127,
-0.0464070626,
0.8245106339,
0.1886759549,
0.635573566,
-0.058156956,
-0.1605783403,
0.6229662299,
-0.2715046108,
-0.4606584013,
0.6347262859,
-0.4235656261,
0.3803585768,
0.938059926,
0.9788741469,
-0.5340617895,
-0.6595420241,
-0.7361783385,
-0.4251404703,
0.3400520682,
-0.0816493258,
0.1015675738,
-0.074442111,
0.3286388218,
0.2520823181,
0.1936687678,
-0.1220601276,
0.0014815248,
-0.1330120564,
-0.0387945138,
-0.2920213342,
-0.1845957786,
-0.3455981314,
0.2245326638,
0.5462589264,
-0.439121753,
0.0178433023,
0.5184026957,
-0.3111896813,
-0.521797359,
0.5457723737,
0.3460205197,
1.057541728,
-0.6839863658,
-0.1275602728,
-0.4565145671,
-0.6563587785,
-0.0154115185,
0.2472604364,
-0.6278660893,
0.1239141896,
0.018054001,
0.4756070077,
0.1434325278,
-0.745816946,
0.5110529661,
0.0078460472,
-0.4916625619,
-0.2869275212,
-0.0435969122,
-0.060650114,
0.2896349728,
0.4552896321,
-0.0585954785,
0.1802500039,
-1.0222502947,
0.1565230042,
0.4194467962,
-0.4417652488,
-0.0426704623,
0.7266390324,
0.0869085044,
-0.3644289374,
0.6219465137,
0.1640191525,
-0.2314987928,
0.5729933381,
0.3416613936,
0.7306852341,
-0.116507329,
0.4664972723,
0.2789015174,
0.1403246671,
-0.0272196084,
0.489310801,
-0.0123026967,
-0.6258121729,
-0.026311025,
-0.5389536619,
-0.7304696441,
0.0206968486,
-0.9791470766,
-0.0102718407,
-0.1058096439,
-0.1201488078,
0.1347292811,
0.2315515131,
-0.72771281,
0.3575760424,
-0.3051140904,
1.0170344114,
-0.7418689132,
0.7806352377,
0.5898553133,
-1.0056363344,
-0.6817818284,
0.2748828232,
0.0025998086,
-0.4814760685,
0.5202661753,
-0.179547742,
0.2401121408,
0.0068901991,
-0.0699932426,
-0.8860548139,
1.285330534,
0.1723494232,
-0.0539883748,
-0.4334331453,
-0.2300825417,
0.5390304327,
-0.1000846997,
0.1940622628,
0.5364258885,
0.3969967961,
0.0886786953,
-0.9399490952,
-0.0050629135,
-0.1469827294,
-0.211097151,
0.4032087922,
-0.5766656995,
0.6777368188,
-0.2525656819,
-0.4310251772,
0.4229888618,
0.737981081,
0.0300457403,
0.7289917469,
0.4310283363,
0.3695943356,
0.9701685905,
-0.1269921362,
1.3447848558,
-0.2530688643,
-0.0356639177,
0.9960080385,
-0.0759412348,
1.1342966557,
0.5438488126,
-0.2933631837,
0.3904281557,
0.7352657914,
0.1977039427,
0.6237448454,
-0.0724229068,
-0.3409762383,
0.045963686,
-0.0871481225,
-0.5372434258,
0.1153220758,
-0.0764021203,
-0.3552454114,
-0.3746618629,
-0.0422510691,
-0.0928542614,
0.5439083576,
-0.4869362712,
0.6576491594,
0.1788020134,
-1.3047994375,
0.387309432,
-0.2395513505,
0.1477744579,
-0.479767859,
0.3072140515,
-0.3980047405,
-0.1097787991,
0.1474303901,
-0.9631100297,
0.2009047717,
-0.1423081011,
-0.554636538,
-0.133235082,
0.7147300243,
-0.3177675605,
-0.0971491486,
0.3595126271,
0.8309810758,
0.1043730006,
-0.260324806,
-0.2955822945,
-0.3747002482,
-0.2370673865,
-0.0505548939,
0.529404223,
0.3512421548,
-0.1196570694,
0.3725213706,
0.7402199507,
-0.0300805103,
0.0555828586,
0.0490680486,
0.7173531651,
-0.2579599917,
-0.507958889,
-0.0648031607,
0.3056711555,
0.0598998666,
-0.4526225328,
0.6129715443,
0.5127063394,
1.0821661949,
0.118837215,
0.6051347852,
0.4499968588,
0.8589650393,
-0.5829991698,
0.5191630721,
-0.5602283478,
-0.123961404,
-0.0350911282,
-0.866094172,
0.0251772255,
0.0569690131,
-0.4015247226,
0.0569013804,
1.2364547253,
0.500678122,
0.1935157925,
0.4328821301,
0.3732409179,
-0.3227967918,
0.0199068878,
0.4035467207,
0.4717849791,
-0.5143117309,
0.8642828465,
-0.0724150985,
-0.2034062296,
-0.1907468587,
-0.4414904714,
-0.5876164436,
-0.9451468587,
-0.2377698869,
-0.7693847418,
0.2422157228,
0.3276741505,
0.2331847399,
-0.7594099045,
-0.0849102065,
0.3231484592,
0.1985729635,
-0.2393839806,
-0.1857919842,
0.3708098233,
-0.6471406817,
-0.7344717383,
0.3305998147,
-0.0253175162,
-0.1476567984,
-0.1937315315,
0.0945831239,
-0.3587171137,
0.4541951716,
0.206247732,
0.9594055414,
-0.443307817,
-0.1802980006,
0.3556110263,
-0.4737256169,
0.2352488935,
0.9133241773,
-0.6684325933,
0.7235251665,
0.7158875465,
0.8163847923,
0.5350496173,
0.2224408835,
0.718952775,
-0.2368073314,
-0.4104704857,
0.4028519094,
0.2251251787,
0.1700803787,
-0.2968164682,
0.6779102087,
0.27168715,
-0.7172679305,
-0.7442494631,
0.007978661,
-1.2015748024,
-0.5106847286,
1.0749828815,
-0.2761152983,
-0.2241123617,
-0.462677747,
-0.2508766949,
0.3347946107,
-0.2151591778,
0.5280873179,
0.9060094953,
0.1885844022,
0.0988090634,
-0.8992576003,
0.3000689447,
0.3885062635,
-0.7729336023,
-0.2558518052,
0.6002311707,
0.3286769688,
0.3279238939,
0.9930552244,
-0.3671188056,
0.6527234912,
-0.0075456551,
-0.3155385256,
0.0367759205,
-0.3313845396,
-0.2108954489,
0.6731516719,
0.2472240329,
-0.3942096829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04170v1 | From the One, Judge of the Whole: Typed Entailment Graph Construction with Predicate Generation | 2023-06-07T05:46:19 | 2023-06-07T05:46:19 | Zhibin Chen, Yansong Feng, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entailment Graphs (EGs) have been constructed based on extracted corpora as a
strong and explainable form to indicate context-independent entailment
relations in natural languages. However, EGs built by previous methods often
suffer from the severe sparsity issues, due to limited corpora available and
the long-tail phenomenon of predicate distributions. In this paper, we propose
a multi-stage method, Typed Predicate-Entailment Graph Generator (TP-EGG), to
tackle this problem. Given several seed predicates, TP-EGG builds the graphs by
generating new predicates and detecting entailment relations among them. The
generative nature of TP-EGG helps us leverage the recent advances from large
pretrained language models (PLMs), while avoiding the reliance on carefully
prepared corpora. Experiments on benchmark datasets show that TP-EGG can
generate high-quality and scale-controllable entailment graphs, achieving
significant in-domain improvement over state-of-the-art EGs and boosting the
performance of down-stream inference tasks. | [
-0.5327952504,
-1.0409061909,
0.6287924051,
0.204846397,
-0.3436861038,
0.2064149529,
-0.1057096496,
-0.2533963919,
0.419978857,
0.6089200377,
-0.5055702329,
-0.6984136105,
-0.8323071599,
0.481279254,
-0.398178786,
0.4392305613,
-0.0629912615,
-0.4687573016,
-0.1218520924,
0.3192917407,
-0.1034129411,
-0.1900196224,
-0.6524252295,
-0.2425127178,
0.1344109923,
0.3063846827,
0.5268422365,
0.4087766409,
-0.0349976607,
0.27063936,
0.3356726468,
0.642957449,
-0.5290236473,
0.2961481512,
0.2700870037,
-0.3770896792,
-0.5378334522,
0.1775240302,
0.3279074132,
0.8284054995,
0.0753372684,
0.0544196926,
0.1558102816,
0.510966599,
-0.5857389569,
0.4354130328,
-0.5213536024,
0.0798723921,
-0.6305311322,
-0.4193375111,
-0.78149122,
-0.6065296531,
-0.1009364426,
-0.963342011,
0.2872324884,
0.5239879489,
0.9918810725,
0.1620579064,
-0.4554750025,
-0.3357338309,
-0.1851658076,
0.3741439283,
-0.7246652246,
0.5754593015,
0.4482516944,
0.3258784115,
-0.6476370692,
-1.0030878782,
-0.4415076673,
-0.2724936604,
-0.2792406678,
0.2054422796,
0.0046931235,
0.1920794994,
0.0741600171,
0.3120220006,
-0.5963929892,
-0.1892305464,
0.1078742445,
-0.0251405872,
0.3480316401,
-0.2256878465,
0.2512698174,
-0.2409239411,
0.117405124,
0.2870750725,
-1.1259222031,
-0.1311457604,
0.4921247363,
0.3959719837,
0.227536276,
0.8363907933,
-0.277844727,
1.0367411375,
0.5238119364,
-0.2021509856,
0.2544336617,
-0.2092223018,
-0.2946708202,
0.0764462128,
0.747297287,
0.0049281139,
0.4877353907,
-0.4443987012,
0.1378481537,
0.2018074691,
0.1275251508,
-0.9273113012,
-0.2161278576,
0.4209562838,
-0.5199673176,
-0.2496789992,
-0.0888808817,
-0.811933279,
-0.0523409285,
-0.3282898962,
0.2525390983,
-0.8203423023,
-0.4907045662,
0.2038276196,
-0.053566806,
-0.1065198258,
0.0640741289,
-0.3814401627,
0.331145674,
0.8121067286,
0.6137595773,
0.054582838,
-0.2100871801,
-0.8669927716,
0.4492088854,
-0.4501447678,
0.7625589967,
-1.007768631,
-0.131565541,
0.2619548738,
0.0782642066,
-0.3913857341,
-0.6123988032,
0.4606245458,
-0.4989807904,
0.1070860997,
0.1718121916,
-1.2166996002,
0.0606020503,
0.3741343021,
-0.4626262486,
0.8674966097,
-0.0033674412,
-0.8172858953,
0.768660903,
-0.6562690139,
-0.9008935094,
0.3010023534,
-0.3119959831,
-0.3001260459,
-0.1533751488,
0.3783778846,
0.5382576585,
-0.0789484829,
0.2023730576,
-0.5227841735,
0.0782470331,
-0.2207473665,
0.4306252599,
0.6992569566,
0.1433971971,
-0.4425262213,
0.0935296193,
-1.0499892235,
0.0944839641,
0.0141555946,
-0.0477861911,
-0.3646024764,
0.4689050317,
-0.6647724509,
0.1147787273,
0.001101219,
-0.7051266432,
-0.1164505929,
-0.4154880941,
0.7103794217,
0.3886725307,
0.295294553,
0.2193972766,
-0.093594566,
0.5019338131,
-0.014207297,
0.084686853,
0.0501124226,
-0.6401540041,
-0.8721134663,
-0.4088447988,
0.0009115769,
0.2219692618,
-0.8510024548,
0.9677186608,
-0.0283832904,
-0.2926798761,
-0.3904081583,
-0.1655638218,
0.3895245194,
0.6843978763,
0.3452812135,
0.224042803,
-0.4793680608,
-0.7346640229,
-0.2333147675,
-0.1223424077,
0.1163223311,
-0.1119179353,
0.4540651143,
0.1447512358,
0.8572745323,
-0.9263589978,
-0.0944136977,
-0.1015131548,
0.3994735181,
0.038011305,
0.3203142881,
0.4551867247,
-0.5415836573,
-0.4271672368,
-0.345153451,
-0.4876957238,
-0.2149467319,
0.2758446038,
-0.801952064,
-0.0024676102,
0.5217261314,
-0.3790734112,
0.2830777168,
0.1692185551,
-0.4770985246,
0.6647769213,
0.0365521237,
0.2965937853,
-0.9062457085,
-0.3128180206,
0.0776056349,
-0.4470098317,
-0.5125297904,
0.3908927441,
-0.075008437,
-0.0860590413,
-0.0870581269,
0.0218325276,
-0.3751033247,
0.1426812559,
0.0861975476,
0.0875754282,
0.2711624503,
0.2023777813,
0.1110026911,
0.4904459119,
0.6023628116,
-0.8274935484,
-0.0033457906,
0.2110222131,
-0.0833495557,
0.5527995825,
-0.448587507,
0.1957703829,
-0.1068959013,
0.2491508573,
-0.9905229807,
-0.1086371094,
0.3032402992,
-0.3706829846,
0.4938097,
-0.2630825043,
-0.754453063,
-0.448122859,
-0.1694809049,
-0.1338849068,
0.3491657674,
-0.6611250639,
0.6086766124,
0.3544830382,
0.020862883,
-0.0536756478,
-0.3192303777,
0.0067114797,
-0.1032924727,
-1.1193000078,
0.3991426229,
0.0814456418,
-0.1474910527,
0.0783742145,
0.1015066877,
-0.0906067938,
-0.1091719046,
0.1750904024,
-0.0125576807,
-0.2490479946,
0.198660329,
0.2065506727,
0.1106498316,
0.0389350094,
-0.4911438823,
0.7884463668,
0.045212619,
-0.427414149,
0.0283917692,
0.3477900326,
0.1725028008,
-0.5465654135,
0.4725103378,
0.2558979094,
-0.4427402616,
-0.6284242272,
-0.4426445365,
0.0188352894,
-0.422041446,
0.1016718671,
-0.6986738443,
-0.9738827348,
0.1751313359,
-0.2950997651,
0.184331283,
0.4848404825,
0.2182428837,
0.1406957507,
0.9217453599,
0.2111719251,
0.5142142177,
0.0203779861,
-0.154665485,
0.4288252294,
-0.5464404225,
-0.3632265329,
-0.6641577482,
0.0682801083,
-0.5543266535,
-0.1994549632,
0.16909419,
0.1587075293,
-0.4117895663,
0.3632239103,
-0.6003584862,
0.0745466426,
0.3078124821,
0.1156969965,
0.4057111144,
-0.0485462919,
-0.1361417919,
-0.0263693277,
-0.2751135528,
-0.6140494943,
1.0881043673,
-0.2273570597,
0.4517052174,
0.0171534866,
1.1788579226,
0.0095929187,
0.277249366,
-0.5681036115,
0.5932542682,
-0.6659198999,
-0.3436276615,
-0.259186089,
-0.5089734197,
-0.8531534076,
0.3146623373,
-0.0890664831,
-0.5461058021,
-0.0200070497,
0.1774349511,
-0.0883764997,
0.0286769941,
-0.9015327692,
0.7074338794,
-0.082913585,
-0.1470683515,
0.0940845162,
-0.1639033705,
0.5725889802,
0.0687961876,
0.296836108,
-0.1700287461,
0.1180939302,
0.616895318,
-0.8003718853,
0.521012187,
-0.3119988441,
0.0113982093,
0.475189209,
0.3481707573,
0.561555922,
0.1882722825,
-0.1135171577,
-0.3369932473,
-0.3383840919,
-0.1845861226,
-0.4673818052,
0.4572143555,
-0.4872692823,
-0.5766987801,
-0.0639097393,
-0.1802659929,
-0.4631814063,
0.4529076517,
0.4717408419,
0.7089965343,
-0.1171550378,
-0.0788932294,
0.5169495344,
-0.1836267859,
0.2302986681,
0.2817599773,
-0.3490275145,
-0.1089669541,
0.8705781102,
0.2541141212,
0.2705764472,
0.6049382091,
0.0668732226,
-0.3388370275,
-0.5413450599,
-0.3304767013,
0.1426672637,
-0.3134797513,
-0.1546084583,
-0.7805800438,
-0.2552808821,
-0.770699501,
-0.1879462898,
-0.2577462494,
-0.3815080225,
-0.1768786907,
-0.1757843494,
0.2847042978,
0.728071332,
0.3133695722,
0.0628459603,
-0.3668895066,
0.657197535,
0.3647920489,
0.3377562463,
-0.0283332914,
-0.1925120652,
0.366743207,
-0.3771966398,
-0.2923169136,
-0.9433919787,
0.350508064,
0.7121506929,
0.4242480695,
0.7294492126,
0.1529565156,
0.7970554233,
-0.7050154805,
0.5847715735,
0.1336963326,
-0.8015048504,
0.7407343388,
-0.1698113531,
-0.1318375021,
0.3756227791,
0.3746530414,
0.0638957247,
-1.0825212002,
-0.5356988907,
-0.8354767561,
0.4048062861,
0.36027354,
-0.5130972266,
-0.5023899078,
0.2363996953,
0.4858538508,
0.2832631171,
-0.370526284,
-0.264041692,
-0.5667699575,
-0.1390943527,
0.1814064234,
-0.0087751234,
-0.1821746528,
-0.1535219252,
0.6020728946,
-0.0765068606,
0.0187261011,
-0.0622976795,
-0.275372535,
0.1338613182,
0.4225443006,
0.0336361155,
0.8536643982,
-0.5060216188,
0.5799750686,
-0.6115931273,
-0.232450217,
0.1903635412,
0.4575996995,
-0.3171001375,
-0.0758516267,
0.4063345194,
0.5128381848,
0.1430342048,
-0.1978624314,
0.3656415343,
0.1456070095,
-0.4385866225,
-0.3232253492,
-0.0756684765,
0.3929075003,
-0.1769505739,
0.3173515201,
-0.3060911894,
0.1813354194,
-0.4398089051,
0.4598629773,
0.153821215,
0.3454612792,
-0.1686462164,
0.6475582123,
0.3207058907,
-0.0974461809,
0.501064837,
-0.9387447834,
-0.4822718501,
0.6017784476,
0.9322416186,
0.7226315141,
0.2395195365,
0.5803192258,
0.4405550659,
0.3300822973,
-0.0590749271,
0.3948492408,
0.2148721516,
-0.8433755636,
-0.6727821827,
-0.7663215399,
-0.1254359484,
0.2465350032,
-0.5064788461,
0.0698016658,
-0.31053707,
-0.0291198548,
0.2751308382,
-0.0499583296,
-0.6759876609,
0.1178674176,
-0.0859530196,
0.8019948006,
-0.8101730943,
0.5223844051,
0.712408185,
-0.5689075589,
-0.925509274,
0.0453070514,
-0.2451443225,
-0.8123046756,
0.7378981113,
0.1991911083,
-0.1362404078,
0.2441079766,
-0.5374595523,
-0.6951698661,
0.7960696816,
0.4548597038,
-0.5078867674,
0.0073682657,
0.0263800528,
0.2346209735,
-0.6667021513,
0.2621177733,
0.8457802534,
0.7115566134,
0.1518963128,
-0.400357306,
0.4195868075,
-0.2060600817,
-0.2000639588,
0.5811527371,
-0.4072025716,
0.9714696407,
0.1882520616,
-0.5018222928,
-0.3600600362,
0.685780108,
0.5517573357,
0.0552997068,
0.6132905483,
0.9678974748,
0.8299958706,
-0.2321985662,
0.871032238,
-0.5093793273,
-0.0371125415,
1.2063447237,
-0.4198611975,
0.6226661801,
0.2806658149,
-0.4130644202,
0.5406624079,
0.7877873182,
0.1692577302,
0.3902115524,
0.3625560701,
-0.0550448932,
-0.558165133,
0.0982116759,
-0.5119678378,
0.0843442604,
0.472476691,
-0.1757918894,
-0.4182744026,
-0.1756921709,
0.2216721475,
0.1605866104,
-0.3362627923,
0.3246349692,
0.0591233186,
-0.8870384097,
0.4301600754,
-0.2318028659,
0.8631544709,
-0.6124072671,
-0.2295606285,
-0.014332708,
-0.0720267072,
-0.4118139446,
-0.6370257139,
0.0646121949,
0.0098695867,
0.1237098277,
-0.2018871754,
0.8068475127,
-0.5036762953,
-0.644767642,
0.5892555714,
0.5800864697,
0.1943826228,
-0.0056799753,
-0.2418397963,
-0.3924821019,
-0.3225126565,
-0.3664134145,
0.1352505088,
0.6201456189,
0.1790956855,
0.2683001757,
0.4020832181,
0.3236089945,
0.6570851803,
0.4916152954,
0.6563326716,
-0.1319531351,
-0.5368131995,
-0.5113277435,
0.1678909361,
-0.256898433,
-0.2632670403,
0.6925654411,
0.6981791854,
0.7935628295,
0.0402917601,
0.8032153845,
-0.5768513083,
0.4474196732,
-0.5593369603,
0.4949633181,
-0.521348238,
-0.3892406225,
-0.1461569816,
-0.7335996628,
-0.1818576157,
0.4088986516,
-0.2215568572,
-0.2086049914,
1.0651196241,
0.6956621408,
-0.0336722732,
0.1283453703,
0.1354641616,
0.1491425931,
0.5427924991,
0.5132763982,
0.5808403492,
-0.0052484688,
0.5779502392,
-0.2059769034,
-0.3717755079,
-0.0253839996,
-0.8694247603,
-0.914873004,
-0.519816637,
-0.4691610038,
-0.3185738623,
0.0079267928,
0.8069558144,
0.7536169887,
-0.8186693192,
-0.1111924127,
-0.4685198367,
-0.0180802923,
-0.1811491847,
-0.2956166565,
0.7056964636,
-0.8613805771,
-0.6411913037,
0.5840625763,
0.354147613,
-0.4382734895,
-0.0038155748,
-0.1106408834,
-0.5461751819,
-0.0839245319,
0.8138161898,
0.0223627537,
-0.4920991957,
-0.4805531204,
-0.2397674322,
0.1810900718,
0.0721016452,
0.8371626139,
-0.3588292599,
0.5258646011,
0.5887137651,
0.4373750985,
0.6581549048,
-0.070808202,
0.6474648714,
-0.8809880614,
0.0769633278,
0.1131519824,
0.5937595963,
0.1007949635,
-0.2363410294,
0.64691329,
0.1452814192,
-0.3072074056,
-0.5525465012,
0.533616364,
-0.6199283004,
-0.3277660906,
1.0788817406,
-0.3128218353,
-0.1590247303,
-0.3047936261,
0.3542881906,
0.6514783502,
-0.4546902478,
0.4743032157,
0.6558385491,
-0.5364000797,
0.2031977773,
-0.3179976642,
0.5299476385,
-0.0645636767,
-1.244520545,
-0.2786098719,
0.4213120043,
0.3776508272,
0.1997646093,
0.867233932,
-0.2099134475,
-0.3545388281,
0.1323542893,
-0.0180431325,
-0.4994269013,
-0.3256175816,
0.5802057385,
0.6599674821,
0.0542716011,
-0.3459821641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04140v1 | Increasing Diversity While Maintaining Accuracy: Text Data Generation with Large Language Models and Human Interventions | 2023-06-07T04:27:09 | 2023-06-07T04:27:09 | John Joon Young Chung, Ece Kamar, Saleema Amershi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can be used to generate text data for training
and evaluating other models. However, creating high-quality datasets with LLMs
can be challenging. In this work, we explore human-AI partnerships to
facilitate high diversity and accuracy in LLM-based text data generation. We
first examine two approaches to diversify text generation: 1) logit
suppression, which minimizes the generation of languages that have already been
frequently generated, and 2) temperature sampling, which flattens the token
sampling probability. We found that diversification approaches can increase
data diversity but often at the cost of data accuracy (i.e., text and labels
being appropriate for the target domain). To address this issue, we examined
two human interventions, 1) label replacement (LR), correcting misaligned
labels, and 2) out-of-scope filtering (OOSF), removing instances that are out
of the user's domain of interest or to which no considered label applies. With
oracle studies, we found that LR increases the absolute accuracy of models
trained with diversified datasets by 14.4%. Moreover, we found that some models
trained with data generated with LR interventions outperformed LLM-based
few-shot classification. In contrast, OOSF was not effective in increasing
model accuracy, implying the need for future work in human-in-the-loop text
data generation. | [
-0.2786643207,
-0.4620362222,
0.3085366488,
-0.1361331344,
-0.1566468179,
0.4105344713,
-0.443677485,
-0.7521529794,
-0.109118171,
0.6307880878,
-0.3292600214,
-0.5962341428,
-0.6047467589,
0.1882115453,
-0.2826843858,
1.154140234,
-0.0756172538,
0.0302855428,
-0.0239625163,
-0.3270849884,
-0.4857867956,
-0.6316320896,
-0.6179026961,
-0.5453058481,
0.7067593336,
0.5227973461,
0.8351701498,
0.7672802806,
0.560565114,
0.2517420053,
-0.2444762886,
0.5198879838,
-0.7313427329,
0.1226094887,
-0.1131618246,
-0.4808766544,
-0.3254359663,
-0.1798474789,
0.7626478672,
0.7827743888,
-0.1501252949,
-0.1977752298,
0.0703194737,
0.8195335865,
-0.6985653043,
-0.2353442311,
-0.7555523515,
-0.1361823529,
-0.3634845614,
0.222596243,
-0.19876571,
-0.1837696135,
0.1330440342,
-0.4148724079,
0.2848290205,
0.0067398902,
0.6531098485,
0.2496079206,
-0.4152075946,
-0.3857104778,
-1.0130887032,
1.1223568916,
-0.7712304592,
0.1687014848,
0.5811259151,
0.0010808791,
-0.3030939996,
-0.3707925677,
-0.4867507517,
0.1903951764,
0.0928995833,
0.0541652553,
-0.0666632652,
-0.042353522,
0.1236631423,
0.1822258234,
-0.3203246593,
0.5392336249,
-0.4347738922,
-0.0349432714,
1.0968099833,
0.3268027902,
0.3369967937,
0.0115536079,
-0.0247995257,
-0.3351459205,
-0.734028101,
0.0124426531,
0.6106684804,
0.4535063803,
0.1323393285,
0.6608275175,
-0.1547628343,
0.7245366573,
-0.2289931029,
-0.2813028097,
0.2146930546,
-0.6350659728,
-0.2234699428,
-0.0993796661,
0.7536386847,
0.2350547016,
0.2459533513,
-0.20949018,
-0.2745406032,
-0.1098526865,
0.1504901201,
-0.6126170754,
-0.0820334032,
0.0777697042,
-0.3422386348,
-0.4562731385,
0.3165000379,
-0.600977838,
-0.4151077271,
-0.1926445216,
0.0657954514,
-0.2795065045,
-0.0654017776,
0.1888463348,
-0.295589149,
-0.073902756,
0.2697276473,
-0.987121582,
0.2817130387,
0.6123355031,
0.4387456179,
-0.4307490289,
-0.4383823574,
-0.3393377066,
0.3971158862,
-0.2315665931,
0.5377059579,
-0.5195133686,
-0.6181071997,
-0.0936186537,
-0.4971191883,
0.2195726186,
-0.8158189058,
0.3999110758,
-0.3545428216,
0.3216809034,
-0.2748112977,
-0.6776524782,
0.1168948263,
0.0880148411,
-0.6941741705,
1.0291137695,
0.0809211507,
-0.6975418329,
0.7584348321,
-0.7230788469,
-0.5067120194,
0.1026903763,
-0.2910066545,
-0.7674164772,
-0.1259930581,
0.3978734612,
0.2230041474,
-0.3540791869,
0.4359405935,
-0.0921629518,
-0.3500476778,
0.3355035782,
-0.5055763721,
0.4555660188,
0.1401616931,
-0.3156487048,
0.097581476,
-0.6215139031,
-0.2554615736,
-0.0303491652,
-0.6544078588,
-0.3913894594,
0.0275495034,
0.3067631423,
-0.0784437582,
-0.1166253835,
-0.4989506006,
0.167536363,
-0.5144643188,
0.3417181969,
0.6076709628,
0.0043193046,
0.6061660051,
-0.7227784395,
0.4185783267,
0.0200384501,
-0.0163635053,
-0.3496875465,
-1.0463598967,
-0.3486935496,
-0.5160446763,
0.2799794078,
0.445674777,
-0.7591717839,
0.5610647798,
-0.3010876179,
-0.4597555697,
-0.3309789896,
0.5594127774,
0.2808458507,
0.4067639112,
0.3581324816,
-0.3488271534,
-0.5106837153,
-0.5670368075,
-0.53580302,
-0.2885499299,
-0.2184865177,
0.4478878975,
0.4627590477,
-0.5499495268,
1.4099683762,
-0.4761764109,
-0.1598279327,
-0.3694734573,
0.4773457646,
0.0418625474,
0.5274586082,
0.472358346,
-0.9412844777,
-0.536935389,
0.0607672222,
-0.598284483,
0.0485374443,
-0.0904854164,
-0.0492652766,
0.3888954818,
0.2012868375,
-0.4702500999,
0.6329188347,
0.3469278216,
-0.069634974,
0.1368712932,
-0.1613281518,
0.0947400331,
-1.1521474123,
-0.0222810693,
-0.0552957542,
-0.2646434605,
-0.7934495211,
-0.1235283762,
-0.2135741264,
-0.1545080096,
-0.5010766983,
0.813637495,
-0.3194792569,
0.0989337564,
-0.3431336582,
-0.102773875,
0.0655588061,
0.1040389538,
-0.0519093908,
0.6569269896,
0.2928745449,
-0.431904614,
0.3376648426,
0.2982565463,
-0.2450787425,
0.317566067,
-0.4778413773,
0.0454514511,
-0.3096673489,
0.4378114343,
-0.8021662831,
-0.6746942401,
0.3064827621,
-0.3178798556,
0.2243046463,
0.2522057593,
-0.52301687,
-0.3405207396,
-0.4219430387,
0.7416369915,
0.5809379816,
-0.676802516,
0.4288254678,
0.3943390548,
-0.1846446842,
-0.6144286394,
-1.0086834431,
0.349101156,
-0.2601570785,
-0.6609445214,
0.4343481362,
-0.1033531651,
-0.3054580688,
0.0027471366,
0.1857806593,
-0.1526533365,
0.090531677,
0.0469365641,
0.2734188735,
0.0495484322,
0.4829381108,
-0.0364522263,
0.2630553842,
-0.3185634911,
-0.451164782,
0.3933132589,
0.2535043359,
-0.5127353072,
-0.4281318486,
0.5059720874,
0.2454135567,
-0.0535352714,
0.8483848572,
0.6776844263,
-0.4804003835,
-0.0479268208,
-0.5031203628,
-0.3334729373,
-0.4379954636,
0.3391978741,
0.010175067,
-1.0243637562,
0.3072483838,
0.2348573506,
0.3452836275,
0.2406602502,
0.6959366202,
-0.2901665866,
0.8243519664,
0.5561686158,
-0.3984874487,
0.6258209348,
-0.0360316299,
0.1911902577,
-0.5813224316,
-0.092061013,
-0.4383852184,
-0.493347764,
-0.6815001369,
-0.576012373,
0.3659074903,
0.1244120672,
-0.0730452016,
0.0728202537,
-0.4099892974,
0.5785781145,
0.7698326707,
0.2824822664,
0.3678760231,
0.3580727875,
0.4689090252,
-0.0702289939,
-0.8666236997,
-0.4225545228,
1.4868650436,
0.3239763081,
0.9745969772,
0.0575555563,
1.1046317816,
0.203960374,
0.5991677642,
-0.6362482309,
0.2217518538,
-0.3302563727,
-0.6163153052,
-0.7728773355,
-0.7205525041,
-1.161439538,
-0.0573925897,
-0.4221928716,
-0.6424369812,
0.1743095666,
0.1796130836,
-0.2145074159,
0.5083791614,
-0.5329967141,
0.4612198472,
-0.2263965011,
-0.3043062091,
-0.1161326393,
-0.5220265388,
0.3215001225,
-0.4333067238,
0.2540761232,
0.1081836969,
-0.0056213965,
0.6350691319,
-0.3980730474,
0.998788774,
0.2127803117,
-0.2308413535,
0.4204906821,
-0.4088356197,
0.6755992174,
0.0349739045,
-0.2822370529,
0.1515666544,
-0.7400637865,
-0.6454620361,
-0.3654417098,
0.38715747,
-0.8807190657,
-0.4285461009,
-0.2040932626,
-0.9031579494,
-0.1449844539,
0.0239980109,
0.410099715,
0.1459637731,
-0.2343907058,
0.347897917,
0.5701190829,
-0.3693625629,
0.4442265034,
-0.031786792,
0.0078460574,
-0.4955816567,
0.9920403957,
-0.122816354,
0.3654514849,
0.2676211894,
0.2302055061,
-0.1800621748,
-0.4271093905,
-0.4301452637,
0.1976116747,
-0.6161214709,
-0.1727622449,
-0.5884376764,
-0.0974694639,
-0.5356634855,
-0.1843969822,
-0.1822643578,
-0.2428104579,
-0.5678691268,
0.0887253433,
0.4495935738,
0.7598260045,
-0.0584140792,
0.5079862475,
-1.0046428442,
0.2084939033,
0.3896329403,
0.0458879359,
-0.1635091603,
-0.3035644889,
-0.296831578,
0.3269693553,
-0.3087181449,
-0.6587567925,
0.328599304,
0.3839998543,
0.467477411,
-0.017502673,
-0.1151754335,
0.4920602739,
-0.2429334372,
0.7857285738,
0.4002935588,
-0.8705095649,
0.4316203594,
-0.4660734236,
0.5986689329,
0.5282554626,
0.1388993859,
-0.5514155626,
-0.6257168651,
-0.4734883904,
-0.9839782715,
0.7681620717,
0.5517554283,
0.1815199256,
0.3102735579,
0.4469123185,
0.1223950014,
0.3575850725,
-0.5733152628,
-0.0369804874,
-0.0313004591,
-0.5226134062,
-0.1632432044,
0.0684865788,
-0.2247945517,
0.0219779965,
0.5057786107,
-0.1839698553,
-0.2172535062,
0.104591243,
0.0747244433,
-0.3126475811,
0.2535439134,
0.573654294,
0.630150795,
0.0416283831,
-0.2243790627,
0.1925878525,
-0.4774144292,
0.113219209,
-0.0967621356,
-0.3545398712,
-0.0658351853,
0.5166709423,
0.861246407,
-0.146767363,
-0.8881650567,
0.2298682481,
-0.1364108473,
-0.1353396773,
0.2551751435,
0.3099732995,
0.0693464577,
0.1132683158,
0.3364288509,
0.2780127823,
-0.0307828039,
-0.4883458316,
0.2004767209,
0.3622058034,
-0.0182904582,
0.0070695123,
0.5956313014,
0.2612763047,
-0.4306579232,
0.6781119704,
-0.1393787563,
-0.3858632743,
0.8002983928,
0.3490706384,
0.709214747,
-0.0516876467,
0.2444363236,
0.1755641103,
0.2996843755,
-0.3114296198,
0.1922458559,
0.1000928953,
-0.9056193829,
-0.3030492365,
-0.3681553006,
-0.6835590005,
0.0933541209,
-0.4370906353,
0.3388996124,
-0.2334257513,
-0.3694434762,
-0.0724133924,
-0.2402410209,
-0.6513246894,
0.2935259044,
0.216778174,
0.5717339516,
-0.801245451,
0.8936564922,
0.7894929051,
-0.2504030168,
-0.6823474765,
0.3240548074,
-0.0872054175,
-0.3887424171,
0.6618349552,
-0.0531636402,
0.0726952106,
-0.1622282416,
-0.5720357895,
-0.6477199197,
1.0048043728,
0.1616843492,
-0.6824961901,
0.0802125558,
0.5199970603,
0.632360816,
-0.3756456077,
-0.0731993765,
0.4942726493,
0.5301184058,
0.181997329,
-0.7874968648,
-0.2696030736,
0.1260045916,
0.2471447885,
0.172152698,
-0.4113962352,
0.8280732036,
-0.3079936206,
-0.0208055563,
0.1420086473,
0.613827467,
0.529165864,
0.3676576614,
0.5185463428,
0.4628320634,
1.0333336592,
0.0530722663,
1.0005776882,
-0.0230944417,
0.2943954766,
1.1458084583,
-0.5146047473,
0.6408641934,
0.5218243003,
-0.0302355606,
0.1681799293,
0.592367053,
-0.1928700656,
0.2268943489,
0.1473412514,
-0.4332213998,
-0.0997642428,
-0.2235249728,
-0.2343868911,
0.3892628849,
0.2153930962,
-0.2092738301,
-0.0619091168,
0.151533246,
-0.1040149331,
0.2271762043,
-0.047815498,
0.7128532529,
-0.10501571,
-0.7586774826,
0.3569124639,
0.2434682995,
0.9106664062,
-0.2486322522,
0.1985304505,
-0.2491045743,
0.120542191,
-0.2346743643,
-0.7995313406,
0.3492611647,
0.2132568359,
-0.3754681349,
-0.1563640684,
0.7767782807,
-0.819423914,
-0.6517754793,
0.0555503853,
0.4846381843,
0.0499403365,
0.0564035736,
-0.4403916001,
0.1354276091,
-0.0528658032,
-0.0827200711,
0.2514408529,
0.1980680525,
-0.3101745248,
0.5541393757,
0.7826558948,
0.2666397393,
0.1409584433,
0.1759109497,
0.8962727189,
-0.533241868,
-0.3412509859,
-0.9262417555,
0.3964072168,
-0.1779273748,
-0.3636628389,
0.3145280778,
0.4597058296,
0.9015622735,
0.0209477618,
0.9772820473,
0.2177013308,
0.3887868226,
-0.3447503746,
0.6276581883,
-0.638188839,
0.3773602843,
-0.2507553399,
-0.872625351,
-0.5993498564,
0.2000650316,
-0.0731076002,
0.1898899078,
0.2256586403,
0.7731237411,
-0.0009336864,
0.0247760657,
0.3030357957,
-0.0793790743,
0.7133260965,
0.4927648604,
0.8336542845,
-0.5466372371,
0.5699182153,
0.018919671,
-0.311257571,
-0.2136043906,
-0.7135756016,
-1.0042968988,
-0.242822051,
-0.2124801427,
0.0209164433,
0.1409503371,
1.0501791239,
0.8242449164,
-0.7976846099,
-0.5365715027,
-0.3257885873,
0.1861680448,
0.062908642,
-0.1415199786,
0.0651410967,
-0.3576280773,
-1.0084431171,
0.2532417178,
0.3450186551,
0.204226777,
-0.2294097096,
-0.3440013826,
-0.176468581,
0.0058566807,
0.5211715102,
0.2489362359,
-0.625574708,
-0.0116650853,
-0.012811332,
-0.3491069078,
0.1856440902,
0.8396514654,
-0.6218825579,
0.4226269722,
0.6184372306,
1.1336821318,
0.3560957909,
0.1277408898,
0.7693120241,
-0.9654767513,
0.1475244462,
0.3515069783,
0.1163039431,
0.6206943393,
-0.4752386808,
0.4584921598,
0.3216253817,
-0.5560922623,
-0.8969911933,
0.3550004959,
-0.4898362756,
-0.3559059799,
1.1444174051,
-0.027272271,
-0.1164727733,
-0.2392690331,
-0.3823993802,
0.2905555367,
-0.5378193855,
0.906689167,
0.8360444903,
-0.2872747183,
0.0855408981,
-0.0893896967,
0.4147138,
0.6208641529,
-1.1389660835,
-0.0371721201,
0.2862922847,
0.0589991398,
0.1222122908,
0.4840798676,
0.1680252999,
0.1298108697,
-0.3745616674,
0.114965722,
0.2607809305,
-0.3091867566,
-0.2298088521,
-0.1577318907,
0.0568766668,
0.0550968796
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.